Podcast Search

The Talk Show

260: ‘A Clear Eyed Look at Dishwashers’ With John Siracusa

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00You haven't been on the show in a while. Last time I looked it up, it was episode 2 11.

0:00:03It was the last Jedi Star Wars spectacular with with guy English and a cavalcade of other

0:00:10other stars. Somehow you've gone a year and a half without being on my show. But now here

0:00:14you are. And I've had the entire cast of ATP on consecutive episodes.

0:00:18Well, there you go. Well, you're really afraid that like I haven't been on like, it's my

0:00:22fault.

0:00:23You know, I'm not the actor in that sense. I haven't been on. Is that a thing I can do?

0:00:31Can I just come on? Yeah, you can always just pop on. Yeah, just keep your Skype open. Mm-hmm.

0:00:36Invite yourself on. That's how that's how it works at Moltz. But I thought it was a special

0:00:40special relationship as they say, how's your summer going? Pretty good. It's good. Good

0:00:45summer this year. I think I saw a bunch of your pictures on Instagram. Boy, your kids are getting

0:00:50big all of our kids are getting big their monsters that my daughter is I

0:00:54didn't post most of the picture that but she's she's taller than everyone in the

0:00:58family now practically not taller than you know no Jonas is sprouting up he's

0:01:05he's has a we were I guess I forget he took jeans to Marcus Beach House but uh

0:01:12he had to take jeans somewhere and it was a pair of jeans that ain't you know

0:01:16in a way that that Amy knows but they were definitely a pair of jeans that he

0:01:22had just worn like the last week of school and they're too short it was the

0:01:27end of July yeah they do that man we've got that's a fair amount to talk about I

0:01:35want to go down history lane maybe later on just talk about Mac OS in general it

0:01:44It struck me today to look it up.

0:01:45I seemed to remember, and my memory served me correctly, that you ended your 15-year

0:01:52series of extensive Mac OS X reviews, I guess ending with OS X reviews, at 10.10, I guess

0:02:00because you thought that was a nice number.

0:02:03But now we're up to 10.15 this summer.

0:02:05So now we will have the fifth one that you have not reviewed.

0:02:09Talk about it later.

0:02:12thing I wanted to talk about every once in a while I bring it up but I like to

0:02:17sometimes wonder when's the last time you changed your mind not you in

0:02:22particular but one has changed their mind I think it's a problem with our

0:02:25species in general that we we make up our minds and and we don't we don't

0:02:31change them but if you don't change your mind what's your assumption that you're

0:02:34always right you've never been wrong if you're not changing your mind you're not

0:02:38identifying the times that you're wrong, right?

0:02:41- Well, you may have arrived at what you think

0:02:43is the correct answer after a series of wrong answers,

0:02:46because if you have your mind made up about something

0:02:49and it's because that's the right answer,

0:02:53changing it would change it to the wrong answer, so.

0:02:55- Right, so just because you changed your mind

0:02:57doesn't mean that you're now correct, but.

0:02:59- But I get your larger point, for sure.

0:03:01- I would like to revise and amend my commentary

0:03:07on the Siri recorded privacy issue.

0:03:11Well, you should, because you blew that one.

0:03:13I totally did.

0:03:15And it was bad timing, where in addition to being wrong--

0:03:20I shouldn't have been wrong.

0:03:21I should have thought this through better.

0:03:24Then after Marco and I recorded my last episode, then,

0:03:29of course, on a Friday, that's when Apple issued a statement

0:03:33and sort of acknowledged the scope of what's going on,

0:03:37which I thought looked pretty bad.

0:03:40There were some tidbits that we didn't know about before.

0:03:43I saw two articles.

0:03:44I know Matthew Panzorino had one at TechCrunch,

0:03:46and then Sam Byford had one for The Verge.

0:03:51And I thought this was a real eye opener.

0:03:53In Byford's article at The Verge,

0:03:57it's like the third paragraph,

0:03:58says Apple did not comment on whether,

0:04:00in addition to pausing the program

0:04:02where contractors listen to Siri voice recordings,

0:04:05it would also stop actually saving those recordings on its servers. That's a bit weird that they're

0:04:10not going to say whether or not they're—somebody at Apple knows whether they're still saving

0:04:16the recordings. Currently, the company says it keeps recordings for six months before

0:04:23removing identifying information from a copy that it could keep for two years or more.

0:04:29Two years, holy smokes, right? Who the hell knew that this was going on?

0:04:33Well, that's kind of the whole thing.

0:04:37It's easy to read the letter of the law surrounding this and come up with an explanation that

0:04:44makes it seem perfectly normal, but the spirit of Apple's privacy stance is in exact opposition

0:04:53to this very thing.

0:04:54The idea that you agree to something that you don't really read, some sort of amorphous

0:04:58thing that gives Apple the right to collect a bunch of information. And then, you know,

0:05:03they like the normal company, the way it works with big companies is you realize that like

0:05:10they're doing way more than you thought they were. You didn't read it. And not only did

0:05:13you not read it, but you can't even imagine the things they're doing based on the vague

0:05:17language of this in that agreement that you didn't read. Whereas the Apple one is you

0:05:21don't read it. And you what you expect is to be surprised by how good their stance on

0:05:26privacy really is. Like that's always the thing. People like Apple, you know, how many people have

0:05:29you heard just assume that Apple does something nefarious because everybody else does it. And you

0:05:35try to convince them, no, Apple doesn't do that. Apple doesn't actually make money from advertising.

0:05:39They don't actually sell your location information when you use maps to, you know, Starbucks so they

0:05:43can present you with a copy. Like all these things that everyone assumes they do. The whole Apple

0:05:47thing is in many cases, you will be surprised by the evil thing that Apple is not doing.

0:05:53But this particular case is the opposite. It's the way the rest of the world works.

0:05:56They did a thing and we're surprised by how bad it actually is.

0:06:02Tom Scott Here's a statement from a guy named Steve Jobs

0:06:06back in 2010 at the D8 conference. That's the, I guess it was the Wall Street Journal at the time,

0:06:12but that was Walt Mossberg and Kara Swisher's conference where Steve Jobs used to appear in

0:06:18in those high-backed red chairs more years than not, I think. But he was talking about

0:06:25privacy all the way back in 2010. And he said, "Privacy means people know what they're

0:06:29signing up for in plain English and repeatedly. I believe people are smart, and some people

0:06:34want to share more data than other people do. Ask them. Ask them every time. Make them

0:06:40tell you to stop asking them if they get tired of your asking them. Let them know precisely

0:06:45what you're going to do with their data. I can't think of a single thing to criticize

0:06:51in that statement and it seems like it was almost spot on a description of what's wrong

0:06:58with the Siri story. Because we still don't really know what's going on. We don't really

0:07:02know are these recordings that are getting reviewed all from the hey dingus verbal commands?

0:07:09Are some of them the ones that were manually initiated when you hold down the button? Which

0:07:14devices. You had a good rant on ATP about, you know, of course they want them for debugging

0:07:22purposes. How are they going, if Siri is mishearing certain commands or doing the wrong thing

0:07:26in response to them, there's no way that, well, I shouldn't say there's no way, but

0:07:31it's very difficult to fix it without being able to listen to the recording. But we don't

0:07:38know when they get sent, what, I still don't know. I'm still not sure now that I think

0:07:42about it and really go deep. I'm not sure how much of this gets processed on device

0:07:46period, whether they're saving their recordings on servers or not. It's unclear to me like

0:07:51how much of Siri still works when you're in airplane mode.

0:07:54>> Yeah, that was a question I had on my TV and I had just assumed that the transcription

0:07:58was done on device because the devices are so powerful. But Marco told me that's not

0:08:02actually the case and it's sending everything over the network.

0:08:04>> I don't know about everything though. I see, I don't believe that. I don't know.

0:08:08>> Well, you know, the audio anyway for the purpose of transcription. Anyway, the whole

0:08:12The whole point is this is entirely opaque to the user.

0:08:15And the Apple experience that we all want and that we were promised is that it's actually

0:08:21better than we think it is.

0:08:22And in this case, it's either worse than we think it is or it's, depending on how cynical

0:08:26you are, it's exactly the way we think it is.

0:08:28Like, "Oh, there's another big company collecting our data and not telling us how much they're

0:08:32collecting and we're surprised to see how creepy it is."

0:08:35That's how every other company works.

0:08:36So an Apple is supposed to be the exception and generally is the exception, which is why

0:08:40the PR for this is so bad because think of what a hard time you'll now have explaining

0:08:44to somebody that really Apple doesn't do it that way or no Apple can't see your messages

0:08:49except in unencrypted iCloud backups. The more you have to add qualifications and the more

0:08:55the person you're trying to convince comes back to you and say, "What about that time

0:08:58where they saved a lot of serial recordings?" And like that's the thing that happened for

0:09:02sure but in this other case Apple is actually better than the competitors. So it's this

0:09:07Perception is the real problem here.

0:09:10I mean, that's a secondary problem, I suppose.

0:09:12The real problem is recording all of our voices

0:09:14without our knowledge.

0:09:15- Our mutual friend, Manton Reese,

0:09:17pointed out that Amazon actually

0:09:22does a pretty good job with this,

0:09:23where it's pretty easy to search the web

0:09:26for how do you control your Alexa stuff.

0:09:28You get a FAQ.

0:09:29I have it in the show notes,

0:09:30so it should make it into the final show notes here

0:09:32for the public.

0:09:33But they have a FAQ about Alexa that's pretty,

0:09:36I would say it's written in plain English, font a little small maybe, but there's a link

0:09:40and they tell you how to get to a list of your recorded commands in their app and then

0:09:48there's a URL you can go to on the web and as long as you're signed into your Amazon

0:09:52account you can delete recordings from a date range. You can, there's a button to delete

0:09:58all of the saved recordings. It's really pretty clear and then there's a toggle for whether

0:10:06you want to allow your recordings to be reviewed by Amazon, and so you can opt out of it. So

0:10:12that's, that would be pretty tough. I can't really think of anything to suggest there.

0:10:17That seems like the way it should be.

0:10:20Have you ever used those web pages, whether for Amazon or for Google, they both have similar

0:10:24pages. Have you ever gone to them for your own devices?

0:10:27I did. I did it today in preparation for the show, and there was a recording of my son

0:10:34telling Alexa to shut the f up. So I've gone to these pages as well in the past and the

0:10:42strange thing about pages like this is that the experience of going to a web page and

0:10:49scrolling through like all of your past recordings and like being able to play them sort of viscerally

0:10:58makes you understand the fact that things you say in your house have been transferred

0:11:03to a server somewhere and are being stored there. You can read those words and understand

0:11:07the agreement and it's written in plain English. Like, yeah, of course that's the way it works.

0:11:10But actually seeing the web page and actually being able to scroll to three months ago and

0:11:15play a thing that somebody said when you weren't in the house, you feel creepy doing it. Because

0:11:19now you're basically eavesdropping on people in your own house hearing how they use devices,

0:11:23especially if it was an accidental activation or something. And in many ways, I feel like

0:11:28The existence of that page really hammers home exactly how invasive and creepy this

0:11:33is, despite the fact that, as you noted, this is a good thing to have if they're going to

0:11:37store them at all, give the user visibility, give the user control or whatever.

0:11:40But I think what most people would prefer is, as soon as you've done what I asked for

0:11:46you, forget it.

0:11:47Don't record my information anywhere.

0:11:48Delete it if you have it saved anywhere, or just don't save it in the first place.

0:11:52That's what everybody wants until and unless they're having a problem or whatever, which

0:11:56which gets into what I was saying in ATP,

0:11:57which is at the point where you're experiencing malfunction,

0:12:00that's the point where people would willingly opt in

0:12:02more often than not to getting their thing recorded

0:12:06just so Apple can fix it.

0:12:07But every other time,

0:12:09what would make people the most comfortable is

0:12:12I am not recorded and stored anywhere ever

0:12:14unless I explicitly ask for it.

0:12:16- Yeah, and the counterexample, which I love the feature,

0:12:20I forget how many handful of years old now at this point,

0:12:23but the voicemail transcription feature in iOS

0:12:28has a little thing where it'll say,

0:12:33was this transcription useful or not useful?

0:12:38And there are links, and then you can tap Useful,

0:12:41and then you get a dialog box instantly,

0:12:44opens up right away, which is nice.

0:12:46Help improve transcriptions.

0:12:48Would you like to submit this voicemail to Apple

0:12:50to improve transcription accuracy?

0:12:52Recordings will only be used to improve the quality of speech recognition in Apple products.

0:12:56Do not submit recordings.

0:12:58If you believe the speaker would be uncomfortable with you submitting the content to Apple,

0:13:03cancel or submit.

0:13:04Or if it's illegal in your state.

0:13:06Yes, I guess they could mention that.

0:13:09But I'm not sure though, if you leave a voicemail.

0:13:12It's like a two-party consent thing.

0:13:14I don't know.

0:13:15Do they know they're being recorded?

0:13:16I don't know how this works, legally speaking.

0:13:17But the wording is nice, but I don't understand how the legalities work there.

0:13:23Yeah, I saw you post that to the notes document and the spam voicemail that you have transcribed

0:13:30there.

0:13:31I've received that same voicemail.

0:13:32Yeah, something about my excellent credit history and I'm eligible for blah, blah, blah.

0:13:36It's like it's vaguely broken English, some kind of credit come on.

0:13:40It's like, "You're going to send this mail to literally millions of people.

0:13:42Can you spend 10 minutes getting the grammar right?"

0:13:45still going with the trick where they have the same area code as I do and the same first

0:13:53three digits as though it's, you know, as though that makes it more likely, you know,

0:13:59that it's somebody I know.

0:14:00Adam: Yeah. I have a brutal one. My caller ID, you know, we tend to get the same—what

0:14:05I think are the same spammers calling all the time and you can see from the caller ID.

0:14:09And for the longest time, caller ID of Boston College was calling. And I got to the point

0:14:14after they called three days in a row where I answered it, ready to tell them to take

0:14:18me off their list or go away or whatever, whatever things I could possibly do. And I

0:14:22answered it and there was nobody there. Just nothing. Like I don't think they hung up,

0:14:28but there was no one. It was like, hello, hello, nobody there. And so they kept calling.

0:14:31They'd call every single day and I'd pick up every single time and there was nobody

0:14:35there. Like this is the worst scam ever. Like you have to, you have to pick up, you have

0:14:38to tell me something. How can I give you all my money if you don't say anything? Eventually

0:14:42someone picked up and I told them to take me off the list or whatever. And I also started blocking

0:14:46the number, which is a thing that I can do with my phone service. Actually, this is not my landline

0:14:52phone. I actually have a landline. I started blocking the number. Then I realized that

0:14:56they were called day after day. And every time they call, the caller ID says Boston College,

0:15:01but every time they call, it's a different number. Because I bet a ton of numbers show up as Boston

0:15:06College and they're just going through all, you know, they're faking their call ID through all

0:15:09all these numbers. And so now I'm just resigned to the fact that every day someone will call

0:15:12my house with the call, I'd Boston College, and I have to just not answer it.

0:15:16What do you I can't understand the hit rate on these things. Like I don't even understand

0:15:20because sometimes I'll answer because I'm bored. And I just want to take some of their

0:15:23time and I feel like I'm doing a service for humanity, even though I'm probably doing myself

0:15:27a disservice by by marking my number is actual number. But I get so many of these calls anyway,

0:15:33it doesn't really seem plus you're lonely. Yes, exactly.

0:15:37I just want to talk to somebody.

0:15:39But I'll start talking to them, and it's like, I don't even know what they're trying to sell

0:15:43me.

0:15:44And it's like, they can't even make it clear.

0:15:45Do you get the ones in Chinese?

0:15:47I get a lot of calls in Chinese.

0:15:48Oh, I do too.

0:15:49And I'm like, you're just not getting anywhere with this.

0:15:51Yeah.

0:15:52I forget what the transcriptions look like for those.

0:15:55They're usually pretty…

0:15:56I think it just ops out.

0:15:57I think it just on the iPhone, it's like, you know, did not transcribe or could not

0:16:00transcribe.

0:16:01Right.

0:16:02Transcription not available.

0:16:03Yeah, there you go.

0:16:04Anyway, I've gone from ambivalent about this story to upset.

0:16:14I would like to know exactly how this happened.

0:16:20One of the weird things that you and I both know is that Apple has a privacy team.

0:16:28You would think most companies today should have one, but in a way that certain things

0:16:31have to go through legal.

0:16:33got to send it through the legal department. When they do new features, they have a privacy

0:16:37team that new features have to be run through and that these are people—I actually just

0:16:43met a couple of them at WWDC—who are shockingly super smart, but also have that mindset where

0:16:50they totally—it's like being a white hat hacker. They know how to think like, "Well,

0:16:57how I would abuse this and close stuff up. My only theory is that Siri has such a weird

0:17:08history where it started as this third-party company and then they slowly started integrating

0:17:14it and it's always been partially on device, partially in the servers, and that somehow

0:17:22the whole thing just sort of slipped through the cracks and that this never really got

0:17:26looked at in terms of the privacy implications because it's so far over the line.

0:17:30**Matt Stauffer:** I mean, that could be true, but my assumption has been that

0:17:34one of those things that we all don't read explicitly said that Apple's going to do this

0:17:39and we all agreed to it. To my point before, it doesn't actually make it better. I think Apple

0:17:44may be surprised to learn that, "Oh, that thing that we put in the agreement that nobody read

0:17:49that you all agreed to, they're not going to hide behind that like so many other covers." Like,

0:17:53like, well, you agreed to it or whatever, because Apple, I think, understands that it

0:17:57doesn't really matter whether we click the accept thing on the thing that we didn't read.

0:18:01What matters is how we feel about it as customers. And I think in this case, as in many cases,

0:18:07we are all surprised at how surprised Apple is that we don't like something. Like, if

0:18:12we pose this hypothetical to anybody who follows Apple or is an Apple fan, we'd say, yeah,

0:18:17people aren't going to like that. But maybe with an Apple, it was like, well, everyone

0:18:20agreed to this and we've been doing it for years and no one's complained so I guess it's a thing

0:18:23that's okay. And the privacy team would be like, look, we outlined it in plain English and if you

0:18:28had read the thing, it would say what we did and we believe in your privacy and here's what we do

0:18:31and we anonymize it and we only keep it for two years and that's better than the industry standard.

0:18:36Like there's a whole bunch of things that you can say to yourself inside Apple to convince yourself

0:18:39that this is actually okay. Lots of the evidence out in the world can be used to support the idea

0:18:44that Apple's customers are okay with this thing that's happening when in reality Apple's customers

0:18:49customers, A, weren't aware that it was happening, and B, once they became aware, are not okay

0:18:52with it.

0:18:53Tom Bilyeu: Yeah, definitely. And I saw one theory that maybe somehow inside Apple they

0:19:00chalked it up to the—like when you first set up a new device, or I guess every time

0:19:06you do a major software like OS update, you go through the onboarding process and there's

0:19:13a question like settings or diagnostic info or something like that. Will you help Apple

0:19:18out by sending diagnostic information. And I don't have it in front of me, but I'm guessing

0:19:25that there's a—well, actually, I don't know if they would have a link to the web

0:19:30page where they explain more because in that onboarding process, you can't really jump

0:19:34to Safari because you're not set up yet.

0:19:36Tim Cynova Yeah, but think of like email it to me.

0:19:38You have to say like—

0:19:39Jay Haynes Yeah, or maybe.

0:19:40Tim Cynova You used to be like printed out on your Mac,

0:19:41but now it's like email it to me.

0:19:42Jay Haynes Right. So most people just look at the high-level

0:19:45diagnostics, the two-sentence summary of it, and they either hit the button that says,

0:19:50"Okay, I'll send it," or they hit the little "not" button underneath that is a little

0:19:57diabolically designed like, "No, you don't want this one. You want to send us the diagnostics."

0:20:01But somehow they thought that that diagnostics thing—and maybe legally, maybe from a legal

0:20:05sense it does, but it certainly is.

0:20:07Steven: Yeah, and the thing is, I do wonder what sort of a non-tech enthusiast's conception

0:20:13of diagnostics is, but I think within the tech nerd world, we're all thinking crash reports,

0:20:19right? That's kind of what we're thinking. Like, yeah, if there's some problem with the program,

0:20:23or if you want to know, like, how many times I launch it or how many times a feature is used,

0:20:27that's what I'm opting into when I say diagnostics. But even tech nerds would be surprised. We say,

0:20:31oh, and also everything you say to Siri, we have the right to send and store for two years. That

0:20:36is not in our mental model of what that button means to us. Yeah. And it is funny to think about

0:20:43the fact, you know, so they apparently strip your iCloud ID from these recordings after

0:20:49six months, right? Yeah, that's what that that in that to me is a little, that's not

0:20:54what I expected. So after six months, they strip it. But it's, it's theoretically possible

0:21:03that, you know, like your example was, I think, James Earl Jones, who was your Freeman, Morgan

0:21:08Freeman. Close. Well, either—

0:21:11Steven: Someone with a voice that you would recognize, saying words that you would recognize

0:21:14as being relevant. Morgan Freeman talking to Steven Spielberg about a new movie.

0:21:19Right. You know, it's not outlandish to think that somebody could have one scooped up or it was,

0:21:27you know, easily identified.

0:21:28Yeah. I mean, especially if they have humans listening to this, and there's this big fleet

0:21:34of humans, one of the humans is going to hear the Morgan Freeman thing and is going to recognize

0:21:38Morgan Freeman's voice and this, but you know, like it's also insider trading. If you recognize

0:21:42like a CEO talking about financial things like, and I know it's like, oh, the employees

0:21:47agreed to blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Like these, this is where this stuff happens. Having

0:21:51this information at all is a liability. And then having this information pass through

0:21:56the hands of like your lowest paid, least well treated employees is not great.

0:22:01No, it's not what you want.

0:22:06Even I've been recognized by my voice.

0:22:09We were at Disney World last month and we were waiting for dinner and I was ordering

0:22:13a drink at the bar.

0:22:15My wife noticed at first that this guy next to me just suddenly shot his head over, like

0:22:21got hit by a thunderclap and he was like, "Are you John Gruber?"

0:22:25That doesn't really…that happens to me at WWDC.

0:22:27I'm sure it happens to you at WWDC.

0:22:28It does not happen to me at Disney World.

0:22:30Well, to be fair, you're Disney a lot.

0:22:32Yeah, I guess.

0:22:33It's the law of averages.

0:22:35But like he even said, he said it wasn't that I recognized you, it was that I recognized

0:22:38your voice.

0:22:39Yeah, that's the way it works in podcasting, which is as I prefer it, I suppose, because

0:22:43then you just keep your mouth shut and be anonymous.

0:22:45Right.

0:22:46Faces made for radio, as they say back on Car Talk.

0:22:50Oh, definitely.

0:22:52I guess we're done with this story, though.

0:22:56Got the Alexa thing, got the permission for the voicemail.

0:22:58Boy, pasting a screenshot into a note really takes up a lot of space.

0:23:02Yeah, you can't even see that note on my Mac Pro here because it's running Al Cap

0:23:06and I can't see shared notes.

0:23:07I can see it on my iPhone.

0:23:11All right, let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor.

0:23:17Let's see who the lucky winner is, who gets to go first.

0:23:19Why don't we talk about Away?

0:23:23I love Away.

0:23:25I just got done taking my away suitcase on a trip.

0:23:28It's still good as new.

0:23:30They make suitcases.

0:23:34They're top notch, really, really great.

0:23:36All of them are made from either a lightweight, durable,

0:23:40German polycarbonate, which is to say a very fancy,

0:23:43very nice plastic, or an aluminum alloy.

0:23:47I've got the polycarbonate one, 'cause mine is so old

0:23:49that they only had the carbonate ones when I got mine.

0:23:52And I have no reason to replace it

0:23:55because it's still as good as new.

0:23:56They've considered all types of travelers

0:23:58and they make their carry-on in two sizes

0:24:01with an optional ejectable battery,

0:24:04which I love, absolutely love.

0:24:07And when they say ejectable, it is super ejectable.

0:24:09You just click down on it, pops up.

0:24:11That's important now because now

0:24:13if you're traveling on an airplane

0:24:15and they make you check your bag

0:24:17rather than putting it in the overhead,

0:24:20you have to remove lithium ion batteries.

0:24:22Couldn't be easier.

0:24:24Super great. I love having that battery right there on my suitcase.

0:24:27Then all you have to do, keep a lightning cable handy. Although,

0:24:30I guess you need two cables now if you want to charge an iPad,

0:24:33we all need a lot of cables, but there we go. Plug it right in your suitcase.

0:24:37Every single seat at the airport is now a seat with the charging port for you.

0:24:42I love it.

0:24:44Four 360 spinner wheels guaranteed for a smooth ride.

0:24:48My wheels still absolutely fantastically smooth years old,

0:24:52Lots of trips.

0:24:54A really clever internal compression system

0:24:56that lets you pack more,

0:24:58keeps your shirts from getting all wrinkled up.

0:25:00I go everywhere.

0:25:03I can't remember the last time I went anywhere

0:25:05without my Away Carry-On.

0:25:06I really like it.

0:25:07It's a great suitcase.

0:25:09You can save 20 bucks off your suitcase

0:25:12by going to awaytravel.com.

0:25:15That's their URL, awaytravel.com/talkshow20.

0:25:20talk show because this is the talk show. Twenty because you can save twenty bucks. And just

0:25:25remember that promo code, talk show twenty during checkout. So go to awaytravel.com/talk

0:25:30show. And my thanks to Away for continuing to support the show.

0:25:35Eric Meyer I think all of our suitcases are now Away

0:25:38suitcases.

0:25:39Tom Bilyeu You know what? We had a funny thing when we

0:25:40went to see Marco and we got off the ferry. A guy took mine and you know because he had

0:25:47an Away suitcase as well.

0:25:48Well, many suitcases look alike, so check your luggage tags.

0:25:51Many suitcases look alike. I'm a big believer in that. And it's funny because I realized

0:25:55that I don't even know how many other people have an away carry-on because I can't remember

0:26:01the last time I had to gate check it. You know, because I have pretty good status on

0:26:05American Airlines and I always fly on American Airlines, so I don't get like a bad boarding

0:26:11group where they might take my suitcase away and stick it underneath the belly of the plane.

0:26:16sticking it right over my seat so it's never really out of arm's length but

0:26:21that would have been that would have been bad yeah I have all my drugs and

0:26:26stuff in my suitcase hey I know you're Martin Scorsese fans you see the trailer

0:26:34for the Irishman I am avoiding I mean Todd Bizira he's doing cool media

0:26:41blackout for it but although he was I think he's working on the movie now so I

0:26:45I don't know how that works.

0:26:46Anyway, I'm mostly avoiding all trailers now.

0:26:50And so if I'm interested in a movie,

0:26:53I avoid the trailer because I don't want to be spoiled.

0:26:55And if I'm not interested in the movie,

0:26:56I avoid the trailer because why bother?

0:26:57So the answer is no.

0:26:59- But you're aware of the basic premise.

0:27:02- I am not aware of the basic premise.

0:27:04I have almost nothing about this movie

0:27:06other than the director.

0:27:08So I just--

0:27:08- You don't even know the cast?

0:27:11- De Niro maybe?

0:27:12I don't think I know anything about the cast.

0:27:14Can I spoil the cast?

0:27:15- Sure, go for it.

0:27:16- It's the whole gang is back together.

0:27:18It's got De Niro, it's got Joe Pesci,

0:27:20and they've added Al Pacino.

0:27:24- But they're all men now, it's gonna be sad.

0:27:26- Well, this is the thing.

0:27:27Young Eyes, Robert De Niro.

0:27:32- Oh, all right then.

0:27:34- That's what I wanted to--

0:27:35- That would explain Todd Vizzier's involvement,

0:27:36not that he does that. - Right.

0:27:37There is some serious Todd Vizzier action going on.

0:27:41I will say, the trailer is excellent.

0:27:44It is not very spoilery and shocker because you'd think, you know, somebody like Martin

0:27:48Skars says he's going to keep control of his trailer.

0:27:50Do you think the directors even of that stature have control of the trailers?

0:27:54What I've heard is that no matter who you are, you get no say in your trailer.

0:27:57But I don't know how true that is.

0:27:59I don't know about that.

0:28:00If anybody does, I would think so.

0:28:02Yeah, sure.

0:28:03No, you would think.

0:28:04But I always think about Stephen King having control over his book covers.

0:28:08Right.

0:28:09And again, my vague knowledge of this is that even Stephen King has to just deal with what

0:28:14publisher wants to put on the cover.

0:28:16Right. Right. Right. The inside of his books is he has control over. They're very consistent,

0:28:22you know. It's all set, typeset in Garamond number three.

0:28:27Yeah. I mean, I suppose if you get big enough, you can insist on whatever you want to insist

0:28:30on. But I think just being conditioned by years and years of being in the industry,

0:28:34you could become accustomed to the idea that the director doesn't have control of the trailer

0:28:37and the author doesn't have control over the cover.

0:28:39Yeah, from what I saw in the trailer, the way that they've made Robert De Niro look younger

0:28:45than he really is, is pretty astounding. It is outside the uncanny valley. Now, it's a trailer,

0:28:52so maybe they're cherry picking the shots with dark lighting and cherry picking the best spots.

0:28:59But that's pretty interesting. And I don't know how I feel about it though. In some sense,

0:29:04like if we keep giving the role of a mid-forties gangster to Robert De Niro, when does our

0:29:14generation get to step into these roles?

0:29:15John: Right. Soon it'll just be his voice on a computer-animated figure. The worst thing

0:29:21about De Niro and these other actresses is we have so much footage of them at that age.

0:29:24It's not like we don't know what they look like, right? As opposed to aging Captain America,

0:29:29we don't know what Chris Evans is going to look like when he's old, but we know what

0:29:32what 30-, 40-year-old Robert De Niro looked like. We're very familiar.

0:29:36Yeah. I'd be curious to hear, after this comes out, to pick Todd Vaziri's ear about

0:29:42it and find out how much work and what source material they used to get the useful.

0:29:47And exactly how much they replaced. That's the whole thing. It's always like, "Oh,

0:29:51I'm going to just do a nip and a tuck." And it's like, "No, we're just going to

0:29:54erase your head and replace it with our computer head."

0:29:58It's a Netflix movie, which is kind of interesting. But they're doing the—I guess it's that whole

0:30:06thing Spielberg was talking about back at the Oscars in March, where, you know, for whatever

0:30:12reason Spielberg thinks that any movie up for Oscar consideration has to have been in a theater.

0:30:18I like tradition as much as the next guy. I don't really see that as a requirement.

0:30:25A movie is a movie. I like seeing a movie in a theater. I like a big screen. I like

0:30:36a good loud sound system. When you go to the movies, I don't go much anymore, I got to

0:30:40say. But I do like going to see a blockbuster in a movie theater. I like the way that I

0:30:45I don't have to worry about waking up my wife or something because I have the volume too

0:30:49loud. But if I don't put the volume up loud, then I can't hear what they're saying. But

0:30:54then when the Hulk starts throwing things against the wall, all of a sudden the volume

0:30:58you had set for dialogue is no longer appropriate.

0:31:02Yeah. Plus, the recent year's innovation that I feel like has given a big boost to my desire

0:31:09to go to movie theaters. Reserve seating everywhere. It's the best thing ever. Do you have that

0:31:14at all your local theaters?

0:31:15Dave Asprey I can't remember the last time I went to

0:31:17a movie without reserved seating.

0:31:18Jon Streeter No, I won't go to a movie without reserved

0:31:20seating.

0:31:21Dave Asprey Yeah, it's absolutely fantastic.

0:31:25Why did it take so long?

0:31:26Jon Streeter Computers, because it's like a bookkeeping

0:31:28hassle.

0:31:29And it's not like we didn't have the computers to do it, but someone needed to say, "Let's

0:31:33try this."

0:31:34Once the technology was there, it's just a matter of someone being willing to use technology.

0:31:37And once the first person was willing to use it and probably saw what it did to attendance,

0:31:40then it just spreads like wildfire.

0:31:42That's why.

0:31:43before, like, what would the logistics be of just how many

0:31:45shows a day and how many seats and picking what your seats are

0:31:48and, and sort of knowing when the seats taken for someone else

0:31:50took it like it would cost so much money to run that without

0:31:53without the web essentially.

0:31:54And like a play plays have always had reserved seatings,

0:31:57but a play typically, the theater only has one showroom.

0:32:03It is the theater. And I think most plays are typically one show

0:32:08a day, maybe two and not $7 a ticket, and not $7 a day.

0:32:13whatever current movie ticket prices are. I think they're around 11 or 12 bucks, 13.

0:32:18Right, so I guess it is the computerization. The other thing that's really nice about a modern

0:32:22theater is the reclining seats. Oh yeah. Yeah, they're sort of like stadium seating reclining

0:32:29seats. And I've even almost but not quite come around to those ones that give you the food in

0:32:34the theater because my wife really likes our local theater that gives food. I never get food in the

0:32:39theater. I don't want other people to get food in the theater, but I have to say that since it makes

0:32:44my wife and sometimes my kids happy, I like that because it makes them more willing to go to the

0:32:47movie because you can convince them, "Oh, we'll go to the one with the food and you can get, you

0:32:50know, junky french fries that you like." And the second thing is they somehow manage, maybe it's

0:32:54because there's a stupid 30 minutes of trails in front of everything, to get you the food before

0:32:59the movie starts and not deal with anything related to the food until the movie is over.

0:33:03And for the most part, people are nice about not making chewy, noisy things. The only bad thing is

0:33:08it's a little bit of extra lighting so that people can see the menus, which I wish they would turn

0:33:11off. So I would, I do not prefer it and would avoid it if possible. But I do like the idea

0:33:16that other people in my family like it because it gets them to go to the movies.

0:33:18Yeah, I totally agree. I first time I know they're the the famous chain is the Alamo

0:33:24draft house. And I know that they're, I think they're out of Texas now. I think they're

0:33:28spreading nationwide. But when for a couple of years when I lived up in Massachusetts,

0:33:33we had a place that it was called Chunky's. And it was weird. It was like when this was

0:33:37a novelty and it didn't really have theater seating. What they had were the passenger

0:33:43seats from Lincoln Continentals, like mid-80s Lincoln Continentals, and they just bought

0:33:48a whole bunch of passenger bucket seats from like 80s Lincolns, put them on wheels, and

0:33:55then you didn't really—I have to say I didn't really like that because I want to be squared

0:33:59up and I want to be in the center, but it was a way that you could kind of wheel your

0:34:02seat around. It was a comfy chair.

0:34:04**Matt Stauffer** That's weird.

0:34:05**Ezra Klein** Yeah, it was definitely weird.

0:34:06It was a little one.

0:34:07And by modern theater standards, too, the seat out of even Lincoln Continental is way

0:34:12smaller than the current gigantic recliners that they have in these theaters.

0:34:15There's enough room for like two normal-sized people to sit on each one of these things.

0:34:19Yeah, the old school movie theaters.

0:34:22I guess that was the other thing, too, is that they've raised the prices enough and

0:34:25attendance is down and they go for blockbusters.

0:34:27But I guess in the old days, throughout decades ago, they were really just trying to pack

0:34:32people in like sardines.

0:34:33Yep.

0:34:34tiny hard seats with, if you're lucky, some kind of dingy fabric on it. Rubbing elbows

0:34:41with the public, literally.

0:34:42Steven: Yeah. And if you rub the seat the wrong way, it kind of gave you like a…you

0:34:47know, like…what would you call that? You know what I mean? It's like the velvet,

0:34:52and if you rub it the right way, it feels smooth.

0:34:53Adam: Single directional velvet, yeah.

0:34:55Steven; Yeah. Anyway, I'm looking forward to that, although I don't know if I'll

0:35:01see it in the theater. I figured I'd run it by you. See what I thought.

0:35:04The Netflix thing? If it's Netflix, is it only on Netflix? Do you have the option to

0:35:07see it in that theater?

0:35:08Oh, yeah. So, they are going to do a "limited run," which I take to maybe New York and LA.

0:35:15So, I don't know that…

0:35:17New York, LA, and Philadelphia, obviously.

0:35:19Yeah. I somehow doubt it. I think I'll wait for it to come out on Netflix. But I'm looking

0:35:23forward to it. I think it's kind of interesting.

0:35:25Are they going to do "Same Day" on Netflix?

0:35:27No, I don't know. That's weird.

0:35:28So, I feel like that's a super Netflix-y thing to do. Drop the whole season at once

0:35:32and put it on Netflix the same day it opens in theaters.

0:35:34Trenton Larkin Yeah. What do you think about Netflix's distribution of, you know, like,

0:35:38here's season three of Stranger Things. Here's the whole thing. Here's eight episodes.

0:35:42Michael Scott I like it. I mean, there's a place for both kinds of distribution. So I'm not in

0:35:47favor of one completely replacing the other. But I like having it as an option because I, you know,

0:35:53I don't, I think, because there's so much now I feel a lot less of the pressure to watch a show

0:36:00that comes out immediately, otherwise I'll get spoiled by my friends because now we're

0:36:04all in the same boat where it's like no one has time to binge watch Stranger Things season

0:36:09three when it comes out just because it comes out because there's a million shows like that

0:36:13and who has that kind of time? So we all do watch it at our leisure but I watch things in a bursty

0:36:20manner sometimes it's like no episodes for several days and then I do four episodes in a day and

0:36:25and I like having that available to me. It sort of lets me go my own pace.

0:36:31Dave Asprey I thought about it a lot with Stranger Things

0:36:34this season. I didn't do super bingey. Sometimes I just get in a real rut where I'm staying

0:36:40up real late and I'll watch three or four episodes of a thing. I mostly watch one a

0:36:45night, maybe two. It used to bother me because Stranger Things in particular has cliffhanger

0:36:51episode endings. It just feels to me like this is supposed to make you wait a week.

0:36:56You're supposed to wait a week to find out what the hell just happened.

0:36:59But then I was thinking about it. You brought up Stephen King. They even call them chapters

0:37:05on Stranger Things. It's no different than a novel where lots of thriller writers will

0:37:11put a cliffhanger ending at the end of a chapter, and you make the decision. Do you find out

0:37:16what happened or do you go to bed?

0:37:18Yeah, and you know, the people making these shows are not surprised by how they're being

0:37:22distributed. They can, they should be able to tailor the show so that it works in the

0:37:27format that it's, that it's, you know, being presented, which is why, you know, Stranger

0:37:30Things is a great example. And we've talked about this before on Twitter and with our

0:37:35friend Todd, the idea of opening credits, shows that are made in an era of streaming

0:37:43services where there is a potential for you to watch episode after episode have to decide

0:37:48decide whether they're going to try to have a big, long, luxurious intro and then allow

0:37:54people to hit the skip intro button in their streaming service of choice, or whether they're

0:37:59going to try to have a really tight but entertaining intro that people will actually watch instead

0:38:04of hitting the skip intro. I think season one of Stranger Things had a fairly long intro

0:38:08sequence by sort of normal standards, but it was so artfully done that I watched that

0:38:14intro for probably more than half of the episodes of Stranger Things because it was so good.

0:38:19And so...

0:38:20I watched the intro to most shows. I watched the Game of Thrones intro every week.

0:38:24Not House of Cards, though. That was like 10 minutes long.

0:38:28I would watch it.

0:38:29Well, watch it or would you allow it to play while you, you know, pick boogers?

0:38:32Yeah, like go get a beverage and pick some boogers. Yeah. Yeah, I guess now that I think

0:38:38about it, I skipped sometimes.

0:38:40Because that one was really long.

0:38:42And things didn't grab you. The point is that it's possible to, you know, all of these television

0:38:49shows, movies, whatever, should be made with the knowledge of how they're going to be viewed

0:38:53and distributed. And so you can work within that framework to do very interesting things.

0:38:57Dave Asprey I'm not a fan. The one thing that Netflix really bothers me is I don't like the

0:39:02race at the end of the episode to quick get the remote and let the music play. You know, like one

0:39:10One of the cool things, you know, lots of shows do it, but they'll pick at the end

0:39:13of an episode.

0:39:14Instead of having a theme song like you do at the opening credits, you play a unique

0:39:19song, picked just for this episode to sort of set the mood and let yourself ease out

0:39:25of the show.

0:39:26And the filmmakers behind the shows carefully picked and licensed these songs.

0:39:31I want to hear it.

0:39:32I want to hear the music sometimes.

0:39:34And with Netflix, you're…

0:39:36And it's like, "Hey, Netflix, I'm dealing with an Apple TV remote here.

0:39:39You gotta give me some extra time.

0:39:43And the thing is, the UI of these streaming servers constitutes a form of spoilers in

0:39:47many cases because if you don't see the little prompt for the next episode, you know there's

0:39:53a post-credit sequence.

0:39:55Or you know there's an inter-credit sequence.

0:39:58That's happened to me many times where the thing doesn't pop up and I'm like, "Oh, there's

0:40:02more to it."

0:40:03And I would rather have experienced that organically or not at all.

0:40:06I feel like the best kind of post-credits or mid-credits sequence are the kind where

0:40:11you discover it on your own or you don't. If you just turned off the TV, then you don't

0:40:15get to see it. But if you did leave it running, it's a pleasant surprise. That's the best

0:40:19form of it. Unlike things like the Marvel movies where we've all been conditioned as

0:40:23a society to sit through ten years of credits because we know there will be post-credits

0:40:27sequences, possible multiple ones. TV shows, you never know. Sometimes they'll just be

0:40:30one at the end of a series or end of a season, or a show will never do one and then just

0:40:34do one randomly in the middle. I know a lot of people who watched, I mean, I don't, okay,

0:40:39some people watch a show that I really enjoy that I don't want to spoil that did have a

0:40:43sort of mid-credits post-credits sequence that lots of people just never saw. And it

0:40:48really changes the entire plot of the show because it's the kind of, you know, twist

0:40:54on a twist ending thing. And I've talked to people and they're like, I watched that whole

0:40:59show and then I heard you talk about it and I had no idea what you're talking about. And

0:41:04and then I went back and watched them. I was like, "Oh, that's perfect," because

0:41:08you can watch the show and be satisfied with it when—just turn it off when the credits

0:41:12start to roll. But if you kept watching, you got a little bonus.

0:41:15Dave: Stranger Things, I thought season three was pretty great. I thought it was probably

0:41:19my favorite season. That says a lot because I liked the first season a lot. I thought

0:41:24second season was a little, "Eh." And then usually by the third season, it's

0:41:29fading away. You usually don't think about that, but I thought it was great. I thought

0:41:33that they—to my eyes and my recollection, they nailed mid-'80s mall culture absolutely

0:41:41perfectly. I don't know how much money they spent to recreate an '80s mall, but it was

0:41:46money well spent because it was perfect.

0:41:47Eric Meyer Did you see that? What they used was one of

0:41:50those abandoned '80s malls, like an actual abandoned '80s mall, and then they dressed

0:41:54it up, which is probably the only way you could do it short of CG. So that aspect was

0:41:59For me, season one is still far and away the best season of Stranger Things by like miles and miles.

0:42:04Season two, I have fond memories of, but that's only the bits I can remember.

0:42:09And it was weird, you know, but fine.

0:42:12Season three, I felt like it was very straightforward and it felt like a little bit like they were going through the motions,

0:42:17and I think they were a little bit confused about what to do with these characters.

0:42:19This is the problem with having any show with kids as the stars.

0:42:22They start to grow up and they get awkward and the show has to decide when to start treating

0:42:28them like adults and when to keep treating them like kids.

0:42:30And I feel like Stranger Things is in that awkward phase.

0:42:33I enjoyed it.

0:42:34I just feel like season one is just so much better.

0:42:36It was just lightning in a bottle because it was the kids at the right age and it's

0:42:40a show and, you know, some sort of nostalgia and throwback and homages to things that we're

0:42:46familiar with just at the right time.

0:42:47And it was, I was riveted for season one and season two and three, and it's just a show

0:42:51that I'm watching and enjoying.

0:42:52And somehow an original take on the supernatural, you know, it was something—

0:42:57I'm not sure how original it is, but it's like Quentin Tarantino original, where you

0:43:01see all the influences, but then they are channeled through this other creative person

0:43:05and it makes them more than what they were.

0:43:06Yes, that's a good way to put it.

0:43:08Right.

0:43:09There's nothing new under the sun making supernatural movies.

0:43:11And that's what we always want, but some people are more open about it.

0:43:13Like everyone is always remixing everything they've experienced into their own creations,

0:43:16but sometimes what comes out is something that isn't immediately recognizable as a

0:43:20combination of the source materials. But then there are people, again, like Tarantino, who

0:43:24you so clearly see their influences. You clearly see what they love. And they make this new

0:43:28great thing, but you can draw direct lines back to all this other stuff. It's very clear,

0:43:33unlike other art where you would never know they were inspired by something until you

0:43:37saw an interview with a director.

0:43:39Right. Did they ever figure out, did they ever tell us what the hell happened to that

0:43:43Barb?

0:43:44Yeah, she's dead.

0:43:45Oh, she's dead.

0:43:46Well, alert.

0:43:47Sorry, Barb. Let me take a break here. Thank our good friends at Eero. E-E-R-O. Eero blankets

0:43:54your whole home with fast, reliable Wi-Fi, eliminating poor coverage, dead spots, and

0:43:59buffering. You'll have a consistently strong signal wherever you need it. Not just one

0:44:04router somewhere by your TV and you hope it gets all the way upstairs to your bedroom

0:44:09because that's where you're also streaming lots of video on your iPad or whatever. What

0:44:14They use is they use multiple little devices and they're small.

0:44:18They're very good looking.

0:44:20The ones that plug into the wall, they call them the beacons.

0:44:23They have a night light so they can shine down on the floor.

0:44:26If you don't want the night light, use the app.

0:44:28Turn it off.

0:44:29Easy as pie.

0:44:30Couldn't be easier.

0:44:31The whole thing, you set it up.

0:44:33It is so easy to set up.

0:44:35It is so uncomplicated.

0:44:37So requires no networking expertise to get a network with multiple devices that blankets

0:44:44our whole home with coverage and you do it all through their app which is a really really

0:44:48good app. I have the feature on I like it I don't know why but I like the I get Nick

0:44:55notifications when a new device joins my network sometimes my kid will bring a friend over

0:45:00and it'll say new Apple devices on the network I like knowing that really don't know why

0:45:06but it's there if you want it you don't want it you can turn it off I'm talking to you

0:45:11over an Eero network right now. It is a great product. I use it myself whole house right

0:45:16here. It's covered with Eero networking. Where do you go to find out more? Go to ero.com/the

0:45:24talk show and enter code the talk show at checkout and you get free overnight shipping

0:45:30with your order. That's ero.com/the talk show with the code for the checkout, the talk show

0:45:36and you get your Eero delivered with free overnight shipping, you got to use that URL

0:45:41though to receive the offer. Eero.com/talkshow. Their website will help you pick just how

0:45:46many devices you need based on the size of your house, how many floors you have, etc.,

0:45:52etc. Couldn't be easier. My thanks to Eero for their continuing support of the show and

0:45:57for the Wi-Fi I'm using right now. Let's get into it because who knows how long it's going

0:46:05ago. But do you do you miss writing your OS 10 reviews, Mac OS 10 reviews?

0:46:10A little bit.

0:46:15What was the average, you know, like offhand, what was the average word count?

0:46:19I think there was like, maybe it was it was lumpy, maybe 30k. Something like that.

0:46:26It's it's closer to a they were closer to short books than long articles.

0:46:32Yeah, I sold them as ebooks for the past, for the final three or four or five, I don't

0:46:39even remember how many. But yeah, when I think about it, I remember the writing process.

0:46:46I think about how long it would take. It's kind of like doing a legal copy where a contract

0:46:52is a certain length, but every sentence has to be vetted. When you're doing technical

0:46:57It's just I have sort of like school forgot my homework forgot. I was signed up for a class type of

0:47:03stress dreams about

0:47:06trying to imagine, you know, you've written something that's like

0:47:1020 30 40 thousand words and every single line of it is a

0:47:15Like that's not an opinion is a statement of fact about a product that that isn't released yet

0:47:21and that is subject to change at any time and

0:47:25And that you have to publish on the day the thing is released.

0:47:29And every single fact in it needs to be true of the version that they release.

0:47:33I still have like stress dreams and waking sort of jolts about that.

0:47:38Like it was just, it would take so long to do, to just to get through like two paragraphs of text,

0:47:47because every single sentence made assertions and, and even the opinions were based on those

0:47:52assertions. So you can't even leave the opinions because you're like, this thing is terrible,

0:47:56and it ends up they change that thing to work a different way. Now that opinion has to be removed

0:48:00or revised and you have to decide what you think about it and write a new thing about it.

0:48:03I guess I don't miss that part. >> First nickety things like file paths,

0:48:07and is there a tilde in front of the library or is that the root level library? And you got to get

0:48:12every single bit of that. >> Much more

0:48:15esoteric things than that. Like the screenshots alone because they change stuff around.

0:48:19I think that's what drove you over the edge, was where the screenshots...

0:48:23I mean, the screenshots towards the end, the screenshots were the part that I enjoyed the

0:48:26most because I really started to just insist on...

0:48:31My standards for screenshots just got higher and higher to the point where nobody reading

0:48:35the article appreciated the extra level of effort I was putting into it.

0:48:38Like the point of diminishing returns was like three reviews before I ended it.

0:48:42I just kept going.

0:48:43I wanted the screenshots to be artful.

0:48:45I wanted the content to be interesting.

0:48:48I wanted there never to be any blurred or blocked out things in them, but of course

0:48:52I didn't want to reveal any actual personal information.

0:48:55I wanted them to be composed well.

0:48:57I wanted them to show multiple things in a single screenshot.

0:48:59I needed them to be written to resolution.

0:49:02Like it was just, it went on and on and on.

0:49:06And that's, that's one of the parts that I threw myself into towards the end.

0:49:11But yeah, that was a nightmare.

0:49:12But no, just like even the technical stuff about exactly how something works under the

0:49:15the covers and what this command does

0:49:18and what technology they're using underlying this

0:49:20and what this data structure looks like.

0:49:22And they've changed that stuff.

0:49:24And every time a new build came out,

0:49:27you'd have to go through and re-vet all of your past work

0:49:30and then continue writing if you were still

0:49:32in the process of writing it.

0:49:33It's just exhausting.

0:49:36Does it bother you?

0:49:37It bothers me.

0:49:38I feel like they should have stuck with a name.

0:49:40It bothers me that they went from Mac OS X to OS X

0:49:43now to Mac OS because it makes it hard to…

0:49:47Adam: To talk about it in retrospect, yeah.

0:49:50Tom Bilyeu: Yeah. When it was all Mac OS X, you could say Mac OS X 10.4 and Mac OS X 10.5

0:49:57and you didn't have to mix it. I think I'm actually kind of inconsistent on it. What

0:50:02do I do now when I refer back to a 10-year-old version? Do I call it Mac OS X or do I use

0:50:08Mac OS for consistency with the current version?

0:50:11You gotta call it what it was named at the time.

0:50:13Like there is the, I forget which one, I think it was Lion or whatever was the in-betweeny

0:50:16one where Apple was pushing, trying to say OS X without the Mac, but they didn't really

0:50:21commit to it except for like retroactively.

0:50:23So there was one that was in the middle, but every other one is fairly definitively has

0:50:28an a product name.

0:50:29When you're referring to a specific version, it's easy to use the name that it was called

0:50:33when it was released.

0:50:34If you're referring to like the first 15 versions of the Mac operating system, I would go to

0:50:39like the Mac operating system or some other generic term that

0:50:42is descriptive but does not pin it down.

0:50:44And when I speak about it, I try to do that.

0:50:48But then if I need to refer to the whole group

0:50:50as an actual product name, I usually go Mac OS X or OS X.

0:50:54Because it still seems like in a non-marketing sense,

0:50:58at a technical sense, that's still the canonical name.

0:51:01Like there's some command line utilities like-- what is there?

0:51:05Like sysinfo or sysversion.

0:51:07There's things you can type at the command line.

0:51:09that'll tell you what version of the operating system you're running, and it still calls

0:51:13itself Mac OS X. There's still places where it still says that.

0:51:16I'll hunt down those strings eventually. The main thing that I'm disappointed about

0:51:20the naming is that I enjoy the consistency of the new naming scheme, but I hate it. I

0:51:24don't like the actual naming scheme, the lowercase then going to uppercase. I find

0:51:28that aesthetically unpleasing. It's almost as bad as what you do, which is making up

0:51:33your own naming scheme that is like the Apple naming scheme, but changed in a way that you

0:51:37find more pleasing?

0:51:38Well, it's because I don't play games with the capital side.

0:51:41But you do.

0:51:42You're playing your own game.

0:51:43You're like, "I've come up with my own naming scheme.

0:51:44Good."

0:51:45But I firmly believe that for the most part, you don't—one doesn't—spelling is letters,

0:51:52not case.

0:51:53And case is a style that you put on it.

0:51:56So in the same way that I wouldn't follow their direction if they said, "We always

0:52:00italicize the word Mac OS."

0:52:02Always.

0:52:03It's always italics.

0:52:04I wouldn't italicize it.

0:52:05Well, you've gone to a third level.

0:52:07You've got the letters, you've got capitalization, and now you're saying, like, "Font face."

0:52:12Like, that's a third level, right?

0:52:15But I take your point.

0:52:16You decided that the spelling is just the letters, which I think is ridiculous, and

0:52:19I'm sure there are examples in English where the case is so important that it changes the

0:52:23meaning of the thing.

0:52:24But I'm saying, aesthetically, I actually find capital M, lowercase a c, capital O,

0:52:29capital S, to be less aesthetically pleasing than the way Apple wants you to say it.

0:52:34it looks like, I always love Mac space OS. I love that name. It was, you know, classic

0:52:39Mac OS. It was called that later in its life. You've taken that name and squished it up

0:52:44in a way that people used to do mistakenly.

0:52:45Dave Asprey Right. No, my friend, Nat Irons, who's easily

0:52:50top two typo reporters in Daring Fireball history, along with my friend Chris Pepper,

0:52:56but dozens, dozens, probably hundreds of typos he's reported to me over the years, long-time

0:53:00reader. Like, when they first switched to this, he was like, "This is driving me nuts,"

0:53:04he's the type of anal-retentive, careful reader who not only notices typos when I make them,

0:53:10but then immediately will text me because he knows I care and I want to hear about it.

0:53:15When they first changed the name, he was like—because he's a long-time Apple user, and he was just

0:53:19like, "I spent an entire decade in the '90s correcting people when they closed up MacOS.

0:53:25I can't even with this."

0:53:27I mean, at least it's consistent. Apple naming has had problems in recent years, so

0:53:33So I applaud them for a successful attempt to attain consistency even if it is consistently

0:53:38mediocre.

0:53:39What do you think they're going to do with the iPhone name this year?

0:53:44Think they're going to go to 11?

0:53:46And it seems like they have to do something in addition to just 11.

0:53:50They could do 11 and 11 max, but then what do you call the 10R model?

0:53:55Yeah, I don't know.

0:53:57I mean, like there's with Apple being so inconsistent

0:54:01with naming, you can't really look at the past

0:54:05and try to predict what they're gonna do based on that.

0:54:08The one thing that the past tells us is that

0:54:11Apple has been willing to take the Roman numeral 10

0:54:15and use it without incrementing it for a long time.

0:54:19- Right. - Right.

0:54:19And also what they did with the iPad

0:54:21where they decided not to put a number on it,

0:54:23the new iPad, that whole business, right?

0:54:25So I feel like that option is on the table,

0:54:28that these things end up being called the iPhone 10

0:54:30and the iPhone 10s and the iPhone,

0:54:32but I don't think it's a likely.

0:54:34It's just, I just feel like that is a possibility,

0:54:37a plausible possibility.

0:54:38But honestly, at this point, almost anything is plausible.

0:54:41The number 11 is certainly plausible.

0:54:43A Roman numeral, an X and then an I is plausible.

0:54:46Would be terrible, but it's plausible.

0:54:48I mean, just think, is that beyond,

0:54:51is that beyond what Apple would do?

0:54:52No, it is not beyond what modern Apple would do.

0:54:54Apple would totally make that name.

0:54:56- Yeah, if they use Roman numerals at all,

0:54:58they could use it, you never, you can't roll it out.

0:55:00- Yeah, and in the end,

0:55:02because they've been so inconsistent,

0:55:04I think they've conditioned us not to attach,

0:55:07at least condition me,

0:55:08not to get too hung up on the names,

0:55:10'cause they're always gonna be a little bit of a mess,

0:55:12and they're not gonna really make any sense,

0:55:14and stop hoping for an inspired name.

0:55:17The inspired name is iPhone,

0:55:19and even that's not that inspired,

0:55:20'cause when we were all predicting,

0:55:23back in the job I was working at before the iPhone came out,

0:55:25we'd make our W3C predictions on a big whiteboard.

0:55:27We wrote iPhone on that whiteboard for years

0:55:29before the iPhone came out.

0:55:30It was the obvious name for the thing.

0:55:32And Apple makes, you know, it's the reverse

0:55:35where you come up with a name

0:55:36and it's not that the name is great,

0:55:37it's that the product is great

0:55:38and the greatness flows backward into the name.

0:55:41iPhone is a great name.

0:55:42The stuff they put after it and the letters and everything,

0:55:45whatever, like we'll get used to whatever they pick.

0:55:48- Yeah, I don't know.

0:55:49But I feel like they can't keep incrementing the numbers.

0:55:52Are they really going to go to 13?

0:55:54Yeah, what is Samsung?

0:55:55Is Samsung just crossing the 10 barrier this year?

0:55:57I forget.

0:55:57Yeah, because they just released this week the Samsung Galaxy

0:56:05Note 10.

0:56:08I think it's called the Note 10.

0:56:09So they're up at 10.

0:56:11And they had the respect not to use a Roman numeral.

0:56:14I think I talked about this on ADP,

0:56:16but other companies have had what

0:56:18in massively multiplayer online role-playing game parlance

0:56:23is a stat crunch, where you name your product

0:56:26and you keep incrementing the number

0:56:27and it eventually becomes so big that it's unwieldy

0:56:30and you rescale all the numbers.

0:56:32The API did it for their video cards.

0:56:34They were going up to like the Radeon 7,000 something,

0:56:378,000 something, 9,000 something,

0:56:39and they were pushing up against like 9,700.

0:56:41And they're like, are we going to go to 10,000?

0:56:43Or maybe we could call it 10K?

0:56:44And they just did a stat crunch.

0:56:45like, Nope, now it's the Radeon, like 100 200 300. They just reset everything back so

0:56:50far that it's not confusing. You don't think what is the 9700 better than the new 9400?

0:56:56It's like, if the question is, is the 9700 better than the 500? They're so far apart

0:57:00that it's clear they're not in the same family. So just reset everything. I don't think Apple

0:57:04will do that. But tech companies have done that multiple times in the past. And it's,

0:57:09it's a corner that you paint yourself into eventually, if you just keep making the number

0:57:12bigger.

0:57:13So you don't even—now that you don't write these reviews, you're not—it's

0:57:17not just that you're not spending your summer writing and screenshotting a 30,000K booklet

0:57:23on the new operating system. You're not even running it, right? Because you can't

0:57:27run it on your Mac Pro.

0:57:28I took a long time off of just like—I wanted to be completely ignorant of the new Mac operating

0:57:34system just because it was so relaxing, right? But now I'm more like the average tech nerd.

0:57:39I have the beta installed.

0:57:41I fiddle with it.

0:57:42I instinctively go through sort of my normal routine

0:57:48after a thing is installed.

0:57:49Basically a routine that lets me look at every piece of user

0:57:52interface.

0:57:52Like I go through every preference pane

0:57:54and every screen and every tab and every menu item

0:57:56and launch every single bundle app.

0:57:58It's just sort of like a thing I do to sort of go through the OS

0:58:02to find out what's new and maybe look at the versions of command

0:58:05line tools.

0:58:06I still do that.

0:58:07But then I don't take notes and I don't do it with an eye

0:58:09retaining anything. And so now I'm more just like a casual, "Oh, look at this fun thing. Oh,

0:58:13let's try this. Oh, let's do that." But that's about it.

0:58:16What's your take on dark mode? I'm personally not a fan. I think it's

0:58:22great that it exists. I think it's a lot of work for developers for a feature that

0:58:28on my list of things that Apple should prioritize in the operating system is fairly low,

0:58:34but I'm not going to ding them for it because it is a good thing to have. And if they're not

0:58:38going to allow theming, which they're not, and Apple's the only one that can do it, they

0:58:42did a really good, I feel like they did a really good job with dark mode. A very difficult

0:58:46task which is make a dark mode, whichever, it's easy to say dark mode, I just want it

0:58:51to be not so bright. Okay, but also I want everything to still be legible and like this

0:58:56is what you're not saying, and I want to be able to tell where everything is and I want

0:58:59the window layering still to work and I don't want it to be ugly and I want my applications

0:59:03to be able to support it in an intelligent way. It's a big, big, much more complicated

0:59:08feature than you think it is, and Apple I think did a really good job of implementing

0:59:12it. And I see a lot of people using it at work. But there are a lot of other features

0:59:17that I would have slotted ahead of it in terms of what Apple could have spent time on.

0:59:21Dave Asprey Wildly popular at WWDC. And I want everybody

0:59:25to be comfortable reading and true dark mode as we now have on iOS and Mac OS after a year

0:59:32is so much nicer on the eyes than using the accessibility feature to just invert,

0:59:38do just a sort of a dumb inversion where everything light goes dark. And I'm sure that that feature

0:59:46isn't as simple as I'm thinking either, but aesthetically it is so much more pleasing. And

0:59:50there's so many more subtle cues like with the accessibility feature. What was a drop shadow

0:59:56looks like a glow because it's just inverted. Whereas with dark mode, they've done some very

1:00:02clever stuff to provide hints of depth without going to a glow. But cognitively, I can't—the

1:00:11only app—you know, I run BB Edit in dark mode. So BB Edit sticks out and I like writing

1:00:16on a dark background in BB Edit. But that's just one app and it helps me identify that

1:00:23dark window over on the left. There's my BB Edit window. Especially on iOS, trying

1:00:30it on the betas over the summer, there's something cognitively that just does not work

1:00:35for me in dark mode. I'm sitting there and I'm going through emails and I realize

1:00:40that I don't remember any of the emails I just read.

1:00:43Adam: Yeah, I think I talked about this when dark mode was first announced last year. For

1:00:50me personally, culturally, I don't want my computer to work this way because of the

1:00:58historical baggage. Like when I was a kid, all my first computers were a black CRT with

1:01:04light text on it, whether it's monochrome green or amber or whatever. And that's how

1:01:09all computers were until the Mac, which was the reverse. And the Mac was like, sheets

1:01:14of paper are white and ink is black. That's the cultural context of this computer. And

1:01:20it was such a clean break from computer and thing that culturally acknowledges the written

1:01:27written word and drawings and everything in the way that you are familiar with it outside

1:01:31the computer world. And that, I've totally imprinted on that. I want black text on a

1:01:36white background whenever I see text, including in BB Edit and everywhere else. So every single

1:01:42other person at work has their text editor in dark mode with the candy colored syntax

1:01:46highlighted code all over it. All of my text windows are white and the text is black. Now

1:01:51obviously eventually if I can't look at that because of ice grain or some other reason,

1:01:55There's lots of accessibility reasons to prefer dark, but culturally, philosophically,

1:02:00and emotionally, the Mac is white background with black text on it to me.

1:02:05JEFFREY GROSSMANN Yeah, because part of the—we just don't

1:02:09use the phrase "wizzy wig" that much anymore, and it's just—for good reason.

1:02:13JIM KEOHANE Well, you don't, Mr. Markdown.

1:02:15JEFFREY GROSSMANN Right.

1:02:16Well, you can get "wizzy wig" in a preview window.

1:02:19JIM KEOHANE That's not what "wizzy wig" means.

1:02:21JEFFREY GROSSMANN I know, I know, because you're not editing.

1:02:23So, how many people listen to the podcast when we say WYSIWYG know what we even mean

1:02:29anymore?

1:02:30I wonder.

1:02:31I do wonder.

1:02:32W-I-Z-Z-Y-W-I-G is what I think we're saying.

1:02:35Right.

1:02:36Yeah, maybe.

1:02:37But part of the WYSIWYG revolution of the 1984 Mac wasn't just that when you opened

1:02:44a word processor that you didn't have to input formatting codes and that you had real

1:02:52fonts to pick from and if you put an image in you actually saw the image right where

1:02:57it was. But it was just like you said, like it was the fact that it was a white window

1:03:01with black text. So it was even more what you see is what you get because you could

1:03:05you know what you saw on screen.

1:03:08It was like the original Mac, right? The original Mac. There was one Mac, there was only one.

1:03:12There was one printer that you could hook up to it. And if you bought that Mac and you

1:03:16bought that printer and you bought Mac, right. And you wrote something in Mac, right. And

1:03:20had it in your MacWrite window and then you printed it and then you took that piece of

1:03:23paper and you held it up against the damn screen that you just typed it on. The idea

1:03:26was what you saw is what you get. And that became increasingly less true over time as

1:03:33DPI monitors changed and printers changes. But in general, that was the promise and the

1:03:38dream and it was absolutely unheard of in any other context because the printer, you

1:03:44know, character printers, they printed whatever the hell characters they wanted. They didn't

1:03:47care what was on your screen, right? And the other ones were, you know, like a sort of

1:03:51desktop publishing type system or with formatting codes or whatever. What you printed out had

1:03:56no relation to the gibberish you were seeing on your screen, right? And the Mac was, you

1:04:01know, what you see is actually what you get more or less. And it was amazing.

1:04:07It was definitely a revolution and I don't think people picked that up. And yeah, I have

1:04:11the same cultural feelings about Dark Mode 2, where it just doesn't look right to me.

1:04:18What are your thoughts on the sort of increasing—I don't know if it's all sandboxing—but

1:04:25the increasing number of warnings when you do "dangerous things" on macOS? I know

1:04:34Jason Snell has written and talked about it quite a bit recently. I haven't listened

1:04:40the most recent version of his podcast, but I know he got some feedback from Apple about it.

1:04:47I don't know. I don't know what the solution is. I get why they're doing some of these things.

1:04:53I really hope that they're not just tightening down hypotheticals, that they're really like,

1:05:02"Hey, we know some bad things, some things that apps have been doing, and so we're doing this

1:05:07this for good reason, not just because it could be. But boy, it's starting to get annoying,

1:05:14in my opinion.

1:05:15**Matt Stauffer:** Yeah. If I was still writing reviews, first

1:05:20of all, I would have experienced this more because just fiddling around as I just described

1:05:25the new beta operating system, you won't run across this until you actually start using

1:05:28it to do real work. Or if you know that they're making changes in this area and you will investigate

1:05:33deeply and do a bunch of synthetic experiments to find out what the barriers are. This, incidentally,

1:05:39would be a nightmare section to do because these are the type of policy changes that

1:05:43they can make right up to the last minute. Like, the mechanisms are all there. Like,

1:05:46here, we have a system for controlling this, but you can change the policy in the OS at

1:05:50any point and probably already have changed the policy.

1:05:53So, yeah, I see what they're going for, but I think if I had to write about this, I would

1:06:00get very philosophical and say, like, the goals of safety,

1:06:07predictability, and confinement are laudable.

1:06:12But the best way to get the thing

1:06:15that you have to the state where those goals are achieved

1:06:17may not be to take the thing that you have

1:06:19and just start putting tiny padlocks

1:06:22on every single little door.

1:06:23Like, the reason iOS has these properties

1:06:26that they want to bring to the Mac

1:06:28that iOS is fundamentally different in many ways.

1:06:31And I don't think you can get the Mac

1:06:34to that level of security by taking the Mac as it exists

1:06:37and putting tiny locks all over the place.

1:06:39Like technically, you probably can,

1:06:41but it will be a terrible experience.

1:06:42This is the reason iOS doesn't work this way.

1:06:45If this is your goal, you have to look at the Mac and say,

1:06:49are there parts of the system that we

1:06:51need to change in radical ways to get to there?

1:06:55Rather than saying, here is how the system works,

1:06:57How can we start making minor modifications to slowly ratchet our way up to that level

1:07:02of security?

1:07:03Because that is putting the security ahead of the user experience in a mild way, but

1:07:10that eventually cumulatively makes the overall experience much worse.

1:07:12Right.

1:07:13And it's like I want—I think bicycles should be made to be as safe as possible.

1:07:18But sometimes you want to ride your bicycle dangerously fast.

1:07:22And it's your bicycle, and you should be allowed to do that.

1:07:24Well, that's the second thing.

1:07:25I didn't even touch on that thing, which is, okay.

1:07:27But what if that goal of being like iOS in terms of security is incompatible with one

1:07:32of the reasons that people like Macs?

1:07:35Then you've got a dilemma there, because it's like, do we just decide that that's not the

1:07:40way our devices are going to work moving forward?

1:07:43Or can we preserve that thing that people like about the Mac and provide that functionality,

1:07:49continue to provide it in a safer way?

1:07:52And the current thing is, you know, the best example of these entitlements that all these

1:07:56this temporary stuff in the name.

1:07:58It's like temporary, like this is fundamentally

1:08:02how insert program here works.

1:08:05Either programs like this are going to be allowed to exist

1:08:07or they're not going to be allowed to exist.

1:08:09But there's no amount of temporary indulgences

1:08:14that you can give it.

1:08:15Like it's just, it's like,

1:08:17do you not understand the tension here?

1:08:18People want to use their Macs to do this thing.

1:08:20Saying you can keep doing that thing for now

1:08:24is not reassuring.

1:08:25What we want to hear is, we've come up

1:08:27with a safer, better way for your thing

1:08:30to continue doing its thing.

1:08:31And they've never said that.

1:08:32They're just like, we'll grandfather you in.

1:08:36Here's some temporary entitlements.

1:08:37They never come out and say, have you considered not

1:08:43being that kind of application?

1:08:45I don't know if they actually tell the people that.

1:08:47Have you considered not having access to the whole file system?

1:08:50It's like, I'm a disk cloning application.

1:08:52Have you considered not being a disk cloning application?

1:08:55It's like, do you want disk cloning applications

1:08:57to exist or not?

1:08:58If you do want them to exist,

1:09:00that has to be on your list of requirements.

1:09:02You can't just hope they go away

1:09:05and give them temporary entitlements

1:09:06and litter them with dialogue boxes.

1:09:09There's a disconnect between any sort of

1:09:12coherent future vision for the Mac

1:09:14and what changes they've been making

1:09:17in the operating system.

1:09:18Like they're diverging.

1:09:20- The one I ran into a couple months ago

1:09:22was I was doing something in terminal.

1:09:24And I forget where I wanted to go,

1:09:25but maybe it was in one of those containers

1:09:27in my home library folder.

1:09:29I don't know.

1:09:30I was somewhere where there are protections.

1:09:33Like, I don't know, maybe in my mail folders or something.

1:09:36And I'm in terminal and I typed LS

1:09:38and there was like nothing.

1:09:39I got no results.

1:09:40I'm like, there's gotta be, I know there's stuff here.

1:09:42And I like opened, like open dot just to open this current.

1:09:47Isn't that what you type to get it open in a finder?

1:09:52So I did that and I saw if the finder could see these files and I go back to terminal

1:09:56and type LS and there's nothing.

1:09:59I realized I had to grant terminal full disk access, but I didn't get – it didn't

1:10:03say – there was no warning.

1:10:06I just had to know it.

1:10:07For some reason, like with apps like BB Edit, which I grant full disk access to so I can

1:10:14open anything and super duper a disk cloning utility where you obviously – it's like

1:10:19I know that I've got to grant SuperDuper full disk access.

1:10:24And SuperDuper, even if it doesn't have it,

1:10:26will hopefully tell me when it launches that, hey, you need to--

1:10:31we can't do our thing without full disk access,

1:10:33because that was like an alternate name for the app,

1:10:37full disk access.

1:10:39Whereas Terminal, I spent more minutes

1:10:42scratching my head on this than I would like to admit,

1:10:45because who would ever think that Terminal wouldn't

1:10:49able to just list files wherever you are. Like, I'm in terminal.

1:10:54Yeah, that's another thing that Apple has done recently. And again, I understand the reasons for

1:10:58it, but it violates some sort of the mental model of a whole different sort of cultural domain,

1:11:05which is system integrity protection. The Unix model has always been, if you're root, you can

1:11:09do anything. System integrity protection changed that. You can be root and also not be able to do

1:11:15something, it just doesn't even make any sense from the model of Unix, which is fine to have

1:11:19different models and change things around, but that's getting back to one of the things

1:11:24that people love about Macs, was Unix with a nice GUI on top. Some people who love Unix

1:11:28love Macs, some people who love Macs love Unix, and some people who both love them.

1:11:32And both of those realms are seeing changes, and to be fair, this happens in Unix outside

1:11:36of the Mac as well, where Unix does change over time, but to make that kind of change,

1:11:43Like this is the thing you're going to do.

1:11:44It's like we want to have system integrity and protection.

1:11:46We want there to be things that root can't do.

1:11:48A Unix-y way to make that change, a more Unix-y way, would be to define a new super

1:11:56root user that's rootier than root.

1:11:58So that you would keep the model the same, but that there would be a Unix-y way to, you

1:12:02know, if you sudo from mute with some flag, you can become the super duper root and you

1:12:07can still do everything.

1:12:08Like, in other words, change Unix,

1:12:11but change it in a way that still feels like Unix.

1:12:14You just added one more layer of stuff.

1:12:17And system integrity and protection is like,

1:12:18the answer is reboot with it off or whatever.

1:12:21Like, I understand why they did it the way they did it,

1:12:22because it's a security feature,

1:12:23and if you could just bypass it that easily,

1:12:25but entering your admin password, it just becomes like,

1:12:27it all makes sense.

1:12:28I'm just saying, it feels uncomfortable

1:12:32to take a well-established, I keep saying culture,

1:12:35but that's really what it is,

1:12:36a well-established culture of a realm of computing,

1:12:40and start modifying it in ways that fly

1:12:44in the face of the history,

1:12:46like that are not well integrated with the whole.

1:12:48- Yeah, you expect pseudo-LS to always list the files

1:12:53in the current system.

1:12:54You don't really expect, it's not a very Unix-y thing

1:12:57to say, well, go find terminal app,

1:12:59or go to your system preferences and hit a plus button

1:13:02and choose it from a GUI picker to grant full disk.

1:13:06- Or if I can't delete a file,

1:13:07change it to any VRAM setting and reboot,

1:13:09and then you'll be able to delete the file.

1:13:11- Yeah, that doesn't really fit either.

1:13:15The other thing, so I'm torn on this,

1:13:18and I know Jason and I went back and forth

1:13:21on Twitter about it.

1:13:22Like I kind of, there's a part of me that says

1:13:24that I want like an expert mode.

1:13:26I want, and maybe it's not even a checkbox

1:13:29in system preferences.

1:13:30Maybe it's like a thing you have to type at the command line in terminal just to sort

1:13:35of show your command line bona fides.

1:13:38But I kind of want to turn a lot of that stuff off.

1:13:42And I kind of wish that there was an expert mode.

1:13:43I get it though.

1:13:45As soon as those words come out of my mouth, I immediately – the GUI designer in me is

1:13:50like once you start adding an expert mode, you've lost the plot a little bit.

1:13:57Right, I mean you're bargaining.

1:13:59Like you're just like, I can see how this could be implemented,

1:14:01and please give it to me because I don't want to be annoyed.

1:14:03But I think what we all really want

1:14:05is the ability to continue to do the powerful things that we

1:14:09enjoy the Mac for, but also in a safer way.

1:14:12Like we want-- it's not a middle path.

1:14:15It is a fundamental change.

1:14:18It's like, you want the Mac to be safer.

1:14:22You need to figure out a way to make the Mac safer,

1:14:25while also not only retaining all the power we had before,

1:14:28but if anything, making it more powerful.

1:14:30And that requires rethinking on a level way

1:14:33above sort of adding security.

1:14:36It is, as you said many years ago, Ronco spray-on security.

1:14:39That's not the way security works.

1:14:41You have to--

1:14:42No.

1:14:43That's the way bad security works.

1:14:45And it's a difficult problem because you see the conflict.

1:14:49Here's the way the Mac has always worked,

1:14:50and here's security.

1:14:51How do I get them together?

1:14:53What you have to think is, well, what do people actually use the Mac for?

1:14:56Like what what in what ways do they need flexibility?

1:15:01And along what axes does do their workflows change and then provide

1:15:06safe, secure mechanisms to continue to make those changes?

1:15:11And that requires rethinking at a much greater level than they're changing.

1:15:16Like it's a type of rethinking that happened between classic Mac OS and Mac OS 10.

1:15:20that level of rethinking is required

1:15:22to get us to an operating system that retains and enhances

1:15:26the power of the Mac but has the security of iOS.

1:15:28We are never going to get there by making small changes

1:15:30to the existing Mac operating system.

1:15:32Right, and this death by a thousand paper

1:15:34cuts of authorization.

1:15:35Right, right, now it's just this terrible negotiation

1:15:37of who's going to be the most annoyed,

1:15:39like how secure versus how much annoyance,

1:15:41and that is not a trade-off you want to feel like you're making.

1:15:43iOS is a good example.

1:15:44Not that we want the Mac to work like iOS,

1:15:46but those trade-offs didn't happen.

1:15:49The fundamental design of iOS is the way it is because it was designed from the beginning

1:15:53to provide that level of security.

1:15:55And now they're trying to add features to it, which I feel like they're able to do more

1:16:01easily, add features to a system that's already secure in these ways than to add security

1:16:05because there is no expectation on it.

1:16:07Everything they've given us in iOS, every new piece of functionality has been like,

1:16:10we've never been able to do this before.

1:16:12So it's a blessing.

1:16:13It's a bonus.

1:16:14We are not starting at a level of infinite power and then watching our power wane.

1:16:17We are starting at a level of total constraints and then rejoicing when we can use third-party

1:16:21keyboards.

1:16:22Right.

1:16:23And we've all—I'm not going to say—I don't want to tempt the gods, but—so for

1:16:30some definition of "can't," which isn't really "can't," it's probably "shouldn't."

1:16:36And to their credit, they typically don't.

1:16:39It's hard to take away an automation system that people really use.

1:16:44Like, at this point, so many people in the Mac OS X era are used to having scripting

1:16:52languages like Perl and Python and Ruby at their fingertips.

1:16:57They're used to being able to write a Bash script or do something like that.

1:17:01AppleScript, I mean, does anybody really think people at Apple still love AppleScript and

1:17:06it's still around?

1:17:07But it is still around because there are a lot of people who really count on it.

1:17:13And apps like Keyboard Maestro, one of my favorites, have long had superpowers to automate

1:17:20things in your on-screen buttons and stuff like that in a way that can't be scripted

1:17:28otherwise.

1:17:29It would be hard to take that away, but I kind of just want to authorize all of it.

1:17:35My other complaint is that I don't feel like these entitlements, the way that you

1:17:41as the power user who wants to change them.

1:17:44I don't think they're organized very well at all.

1:17:46Like I tend to think that there should be a way

1:17:51to do it by app.

1:17:53So that instead of fishing all over system preferences

1:17:56to find the three places where I wanna add BB Edit

1:17:59as a special app and give it entitlements,

1:18:01I'd rather just say, here's BB Edit

1:18:03and here's the permissions I want to grant to it.

1:18:06- Yeah. - Check, check, check, check.

1:18:08I wanna check them all.

1:18:09Yeah, the whole system is not designed very well.

1:18:14From a software developer's perspective,

1:18:16the nightmare of having to explain to all your users

1:18:18to do with this dance, there's a lot of steps.

1:18:20The steps are complicated, and they require a bunch of skills

1:18:23that not every Mac user has, especially

1:18:25in this day of people being raised on iPhones.

1:18:28It involves using another application

1:18:30with separate windows.

1:18:31It involves dragging something from somewhere

1:18:33into that window.

1:18:33As you said, there's no way to organize by application.

1:18:36I think iOS has a better model here where, for the most part, the iOS model is that if

1:18:43an application wants to do a thing that it requires permission for, it prompts you and

1:18:48that you can say allow or deny right from the application. It's not like this is making

1:18:54you go someplace else and drag a thing or whatever. And then the second thing is that

1:18:56they're adding now is these reminders which say, "Just so you know, the Facebook application

1:19:01has been using your location for the past three hours and here's where it..." You know,

1:19:05those dialogue boxes.

1:19:07That is a great, you know, suspenders to add to the belt

1:19:11to say, yeah, we know you tapped through that dialogue

1:19:14and it was really easy to do.

1:19:15But just a reminder, this is what this app is doing.

1:19:18Those two things combined makes people aware

1:19:21of what the app is doing, while also not requiring them

1:19:24to do more complicated stuff.

1:19:27Like there's nothing, developers of iOS applications

1:19:29don't have to have like a read me file or a support site

1:19:31explaining to people how to click allow.

1:19:34Like it's very easy to do.

1:19:37It's way too complicated to do that on the Mac.

1:19:40Even I find it annoying just because it's so tedious

1:19:43and time consuming.

1:19:44I understand the consequences.

1:19:46If it's good enough for iOS,

1:19:47explain to me the consequences here.

1:19:49Allow me to quickly say yes, but then to your point,

1:19:54have some place where this is more visible to me.

1:19:56A Mac-like way to do it would be

1:19:58some kind of like activity report.

1:20:00Maybe it can be in screen time for the Mac.

1:20:03application to show me what they're all doing. So I can look at a report if I'm interested

1:20:07and then proactively occasionally remind me that something's doing a weird thing. So I

1:20:10have, you know, it's a delicate balance, but that's the line they're trying to walk with

1:20:15the Mac now and with iOS for that matter. And on the Mac there, they have made it too

1:20:20complicated and too annoying.

1:20:21Yeah. It's occurred to me that maybe they could put some of that in the get info window

1:20:25in the finder. So if you select an app and you do

1:20:28Nobody knows what that window is.

1:20:30I do.

1:20:31Of course. I did it 10 minutes ago today, but nobody else ever looked at that window.

1:20:38There's another thing. This is the Mac OS X knowledge that I think even fewer people

1:20:41know. Do you know the difference between Command-I and Command-Option-I?

1:20:44Command-Option-I is "show info." Command-I will open a window, and then if you select

1:20:52another file, it doesn't change. But Command-Option-I will show you a floating palette, and as the

1:20:59Selection changes in the finder it changes what it's showing you the info for and we are the only two people who know that

1:21:04Entire world I thought I use it all the time and it's right there versus if oh windows

1:21:10But it's just it's such a such a relic of classic Mac OS is still hanging out there

1:21:14And then the command option is not from classic Mac OS that's a nextism. I believe that we benefited from during transition

1:21:22Yeah, because next was a little bit more

1:21:24Inspectory yeah, inspector in

1:21:28Yeah, sort of weird that they're both there, but I remember thinking it was pretty cool

1:21:31And I can't tell anybody someone Apple will find out they're both there remove one of them. I

1:21:35Will say while you mention it next is an exception to my spelling rules I do spell it the way that next

1:21:43Punctuation outside the quotes and you're spelling next with the capital X and T because it just it when you spell it without

1:21:53Their funky capitalization. It doesn't look like the same company

1:21:57It's like it doesn't read to me as the the

1:22:01Former company that Apple acquired with Steve Jobs just like back was all squished together with capital M

1:22:06Doesn't read like an Apple product us because there's no Apple product by that name

1:22:09I don't know how much longer we can roll, but I mean thank our third and final sponsor

1:22:14You're never gonna guess who it is. It's a good friends at Squarespace. I love this company

1:22:18Look Squarespace is where you go to build host

1:22:23maintain a website. You can build a store. You could host a podcast. You could host a

1:22:28blog. You could host a portfolio of your work if you're a designer. You could put menus

1:22:34up if you run in a restaurant or you know someone is running a restaurant. Anything

1:22:37you could do with a website or mix and match multiple of those things. You could do it

1:22:42with Squarespace and you do it all. Here's that word, WYSIWYG. It's all in a WYSIWYG

1:22:46fashion. You do it right in a browser window. You drag stuff. You see it. As you drag it,

1:22:52That's what you get.

1:22:55Really what you see is what you get.

1:22:57They have, in my opinion, one of the nicest analytic interfaces I've ever seen.

1:23:05So clear, such good data design, and it gives you a nice overview of where people are going

1:23:10on your site, where they're coming from.

1:23:12A lot less confusing than most analytics packages that I've ever seen, which typically seem

1:23:17like they were designed by people who shouldn't be designing anything. Just a great company. They

1:23:25have great customer service. Here's the deal. Next time you need a website or next time somebody

1:23:30comes to you and needs a website, try it at Squarespace first. Give it an hour. See how far

1:23:35you get. Start building your website today at squarespace.com and remember this. Enter this

1:23:40offer code "talk show". Know the just talk show at checkout. So you don't need it when you sign up.

1:23:45You can get started and then you get like 30-day free trial when the 30 days are up and you want to keep your website

1:23:50Just remember talk show and you save 10%

1:23:53What's the ATP code probably just ATP?

1:23:56Yep, I think so. Yeah, you don't know you don't listen to the ads. I

1:24:02Can't do it I was telling Marco when we were doing I know Marco records the ads for the ATP before you guys

1:24:10Start recording and then he can just he just slots them in

1:24:15But when you're—I don't listen to your live telecast. I always listen to the edited

1:24:19version. When you guys do sponsor breaks, how long do they last? Just a couple seconds?

1:24:24Or do you guys get up and refresh your beverages?

1:24:26Adam: In the live show?

1:24:28Tom Bilyeu: Yeah, like when you're recording. Let's say it's Wednesday. It's last night,

1:24:31right? You guys probably did a show last night. So when you're recording and you've got

1:24:37a live audience that is listening along and chatting and

1:24:41IRC

1:24:43What other what does Marco do for the sponsor breaks? There are no sparkle sponsor breaks can't stop won't stop

1:24:48Show must keep going but there you don't even mention it right now. We're not even mentioned

1:24:52We don't even know where the ads are gonna be when we're done recording and a live show. I

1:24:58Have a lot of trouble doing

1:25:02sponsor reads in post

1:25:04It takes me like, you know, I think I did a pretty I did it

1:25:09You know

1:25:09I think I did a fine job with those three sponsors reads tonight one take right there straight through off the top of my head

1:25:16I can't think of anything

1:25:17I forgot to mention but when I do them in post because like let's say that I don't have the ad when I'm you know

1:25:23It's I told you I we record tonight, but I maybe I don't have the text for one of the ads

1:25:27I'll do it tomorrow. It takes me like six takes I

1:25:31I feel like an idiot and and I'll like and there are times where I do it

1:25:35In posts like that and I look at the running time and it's like seven minutes and I'm like what the hell I mean

1:25:42I know my sponsor reads are sometimes long but seven minutes. What the hell am I doing? It's like without the pressure of

1:25:47Feeling like I'm I'm wasting you John Syracuse's or whoever my guest of the the episode is like I don't want to bore you

1:25:56I don't want to waste your time

1:25:58So it gives me like an edge and it keeps me sharp on a sponsor read

1:26:02Whereas when I'm just talking to myself in a microphone

1:26:04I do a terrible job. It's just a quiet skill just like doing the ad reads in the show

1:26:10It's I'm sure it's a thing you could get good at if you wanted to do it

1:26:12You got good at doing the ads in the show, right?

1:26:14So it's just a good question of practice

1:26:16I feel like if it's something you wanted to do a change you wanted to make you could do it

1:26:19but I've let you sound comfortable doing them live in the show and

1:26:22It's also a very different feeling psychologically like I feel like right here

1:26:27we're having a conversation and I'm not talking to myself and when I first started doing podcasts,

1:26:32I definitely was self-conscious about it. It seems weird. I never really spent much time speaking

1:26:37into a microphone. I thought it was very weird in the first years of it hearing my own voice

1:26:44in my headphones and technically I don't even know what changed in the interim, but there was also

1:26:50like in the early years doing the show with Dan Benjamin. There was also a little bit of lag

1:26:54with the audio and it would drive me nuts. I couldn't finish a sentence sometimes because

1:27:00I'm hearing my words from half a second ago. You get used to it, but I still find if I record the

1:27:07ads like that, I have this—it's incredibly self-conscious. I'm doing something very weird

1:27:13talking to myself. Well, I mean, the beauty of it is you can do six takes because who cares?

1:27:20It's time consuming, but at least you are all—it's like writing, you know, during

1:27:26Fireball Live versus being able to write ahead of time and then decide when it's ready

1:27:30to be published.

1:27:31There you go.

1:27:32I hear you bought a fridge.

1:27:34Oh, yes.

1:27:35I did.

1:27:37And you talked about it with a friend of the show, Merlin Mann, on your show.

1:27:42Honest to God, like that was—

1:27:43Reconcilable differences.

1:27:45I did buy a fridge, and that was intended to be like, oh, I bought a fridge.

1:27:50Let me just mention it for two minutes.

1:27:51But it just spooled out of me and eventually became an entire show.

1:27:57It was not the intention.

1:27:58And it's not even really like a good story with a twist ending or anything.

1:28:03It's not even a story at all.

1:28:04It is just merely a recitation of the events involving the purchase

1:28:12and installation of a refrigerator.

1:28:13but I'm glad people enjoyed it.

1:28:15Yeah, I'll put a link in Rec.

1:28:18Diff's fridge show.

1:28:20You must have had tons of this with your new house movement.

1:28:24Yeah, and you got to like new furniture, and new kitchen,

1:28:27and new-- I don't know, unless Amy just deals

1:28:29with all this stuff.

1:28:30But it's got to be that multiplied by 1,000, right?

1:28:34Yeah, I love our fridge.

1:28:36We have a really nice fridge, and I love it to death.

1:28:38It's one of my favorite things I've ever owned,

1:28:40and it's always got ice.

1:28:42and it doesn't have a stupid thing. You stick a cup in and it shoots ice. You just open the

1:28:47freezer drawer and then there's a big bucket of ice and it's always filled up and we're never out

1:28:53of ice, which was in our old house where we rented and had like a typical renter's fridge. You know,

1:28:59kept stuff cold, kept stuff frozen, but you know, didn't really have any features.

1:29:03**Matt Stauffer** Do you do any of the fancy ice stuff for your fancy drinks?

1:29:08No, I've got these—I'm not a believer in that. I think it's sort of a waste of

1:29:16time even though—like the clear ice?

1:29:19Mm-hmm. Yeah. Or weird shapes like balls or large cubes.

1:29:24I have the balls, but what I have that's easier and it's the only thing I really

1:29:28use are the large cubes, and they're in a—is it silicon or silicone?

1:29:33Silicone.

1:29:34I think it's a brand called Tuvalo.

1:29:38The Tuvalo King Size Ice.

1:29:40Let's see if that's right.

1:29:42And it's super easy.

1:29:43You just fill it up and it makes six sort of fist-size cubes of ice.

1:29:48AG: Here's the question.

1:29:51If you had a magic, cost-free, super-efficient butler who could give you perfectly clear

1:29:57ice whenever you wanted it instantly, would you use that in your drinks?

1:30:02No, I honestly don't care about clear ice. I really don't and I care about so many things and I

1:30:08Like if I am making a cocktail I would like I like to have a really nice

1:30:14Like if there's like a lemon slice or you know appeal I like to make that nice and neat

1:30:20I like to pick my own lemons and oranges and I picked them specifically as to whether the Rhine has any any

1:30:27Gross double edges. No blemishes. No blue ink

1:30:31But I I don't get it. I you know, I have all sorts of weird quirks. I have been picky about my pens

1:30:37I'm picky about all sorts of things. So I'm not putting anybody down who is picky about clear ice and

1:30:41our friends at studio neat who make all sorts of fun stuff like the space pen and notebooks and the

1:30:50Glyph which is a great product. That's a little

1:30:53Tripod mount for any phone so you can snap it on your phone and put it on a tripod

1:30:59They make all sorts of cool stuff including a clear ice kit, and I just could not care about their clear ice kit

1:31:05Well again the kit means you have to make yourself

1:31:08I was just like if you if you could get it instantly

1:31:09But you don't care about it like I don't care about drinks, and I don't really drink at all

1:31:13But I do think clear ice is really cool, and I mean I first of all I think it looks cool

1:31:17But the second thing is if you're talking about different sizes and shapes you have a drink

1:31:22Like in the summer where the ice starts to get small and you drink and some of the ice cubes come into your mouth, right?

1:31:29Mm-hmm

1:31:30When an ice cube has all the air pockets the sort of texture and also kind of taste of an ice cube with a bunch

1:31:36Of those air pockets on your tongue is very different from an ice cube that does not have

1:31:41All those air pockets in it

1:31:43Like I feel like it actually changes how the drink tastes even if it's just ice water

1:31:47You know the taste I'm talking about the aerated ice cube taste and I I find the clear ice

1:31:53More luxurious that said I do not make clear ice and I have never made it in my entire life

1:31:58Never would because it's way too much of a hassle for me to deal with and I don't even put ice in my drinks most

1:32:03Of the time so it's not a thing that is a factor in my life, but I do I do find it appealing

1:32:07So if I had that instant Butler, I would accept clear ice almost all the time

1:32:12Yeah, well, I guess if I had the Butler, I mean who am I kidding?

1:32:16What is your preference like, you know it would you rather have a clear ice cube or a non clear?

1:32:23The clear ones look cooler and I feel like they taste better.

1:32:25Dave Asprey Yeah, I guess if I didn't have to do any

1:32:28work, I wouldn't have to. Even my pal Lee, the guy who runs Hopsing Laundry, my beloved

1:32:32cocktail bar here in Philly where he fusses over everything. He does not fuss over clear

1:32:37ice. He has very good ice and he's very particular that this drink gets a cube and

1:32:42this drink gets a sphere and whatever, but he doesn't bother with the clear ice.

1:32:46Adam Back (01:

1:32:47It's still a thing. I don't see anything in the silicone thing that helps with the clearing.

1:32:52No, this doesn't clear. This is just a way to make big ice cubes.

1:32:56Yeah. If you're doing it commercially, unless I guess you could increase your price by a lot if

1:33:00you go through the hassle, but it is quite a hassle to do.

1:33:03Yeah. And it's like some of these ones, it's like they make a big thing and then it's like

1:33:07the non-clear part settles to the bottom and you got to sit there and cut it in half and all this

1:33:12stuff. And I've seen things on YouTube where there's like restaurants that have like $40,000

1:33:16ice cube makers just to get clear ice. How did we get off on the ice? Oh, the refrigerator talk.

1:33:22I'll tell you what though, as much as I like the fridge, we have a—I forget the name of the brand,

1:33:29but we have a supposedly a—Osco, I forget what it is, a dishwasher.

1:33:33**Matt Stauffer** Bosch?

1:33:34**Ezra Kleinman** Ah, no, it's something else, but I don't want to besmirch them too bad,

1:33:39but it's apparently a very nice dishwasher. It does get the dishes clean, I will say.

1:33:43It will to get the dishes clean but man. Oh man is the interface terrible and it's got even though it's it's brand new and it's nice

1:33:50It has those

1:33:51Has those type of buttons that kind of click?

1:33:55And I guess they're waterproof. You know what I mean that there's like a membrane sort of like microwave buttons often are

1:34:01But the but your touches just don't register sometimes and you'll hit like you just press harder

1:34:07Yeah, and you hit start and it makes I don't know what the symbol means it hits start and it makes it puts three little

1:34:14horizontal lines up on this ground and that means go and you close the door and then nothing happens and

1:34:20Then you open it up and you hit the same button and you get the same three lines and you close the door and it

1:34:25kicks in

1:34:26Yeah, this is I feel like is a gap and still still in this modern age

1:34:30like we're all so excited when you know back in our youth when Consumer Reports came as like finally someone is going to

1:34:36do reviews of things that people previously didn't review like a

1:34:40Clear I'd look at dishwashers and reliability in cars and in the modern era we have things like well

1:34:45There's just you know online reviews was a big revolution than things like the wire cutter

1:34:48We're like I don't have time to read a bunch of rears. Just tell me which one I should buy

1:34:51None of these I feel like address

1:34:53This major concern that is such a factor in all of our lives, which is is this the best whatever for you?

1:35:00Oh, here's how much it costs. Here's the features it has if the interface drives you insane. That is a huge factor

1:35:06I don't care how reliable it is.

1:35:08I don't care how much it costs.

1:35:09I don't care how clear it gets.

1:35:10It's just every day I have to use this interface.

1:35:12If the buttons are annoying to press, let alone if the buttons are inscrutable.

1:35:15And I feel like there's, you know, I'm mostly playing with the wire cut here.

1:35:18There's way too little emphasis in Consumer Reports, in any kind of product reviews, in

1:35:24the wire cutter of the user interface of physical products that can make or break.

1:35:30Like I understand you do want to know how does it perform and you do want to know about

1:35:33reliability and you do want to know about features, but in the end, even if you have

1:35:37all of those, if the thing that you're describing is the case, you will not love this appliance.

1:35:43This appliance will slowly drive you mad.

1:35:45Darrell Bock Yeah, totally. It's dishwasher driving me

1:35:48mad. The other thing that stinks, and I get it, I want to be a good citizen. Maybe it's

1:35:52even legal now, I don't know, but it takes forever to clean the dishes. It does get them

1:35:56very clean, but I guess as a water-saving measure, it's squirting like one tiny hot

1:36:03thing at a time. I don't know why. Mine also takes a long time. And I do wonder. I assumed

1:36:08it took forever because it's doing an extremely thorough job because I feel like it is doing

1:36:12an extremely thorough job. But I don't know what's going on inside there. I don't know what's taking

1:36:17so long. I was talking to Marco about it. Marco's convinced it's a water-saving measure. Maybe.

1:36:23But it's funny because it just shows the difference. People in all sorts of industries,

1:36:32People designing engineers who are designing dishwashers are thinking about water converse

1:36:36at conservation now. Whereas like you just know that like when dishwashers first became

1:36:41a thing like I don't know late 50s early 60s the engineers at General Electric all they

1:36:47were thinking was how do we close down these dishes as fast as we can because that's a

1:36:52selling feature.

1:36:53That's the error when they say if we can get these dishes clean by spraying with the radiation

1:36:57we'll do it. You don't care about you, your healthy environment. We just want to get dishes

1:37:02clean. And then we're going to advertise the hell out of the fact that ours is faster than

1:37:05the other guys. Yeah, our radiation really removes every trace of dirt. Totally, totally

1:37:11sanitizes them. No life remains on these dishes when we're done with them. I had a link in

1:37:16here. It looks like David Pogue is back at the New York Times. I don't know if that's

1:37:20a one off thing. I haven't looked at it yet for a while. Story fly through, but I didn't

1:37:25follow the link and didn't note that it was the New York Times. It's a story on Easter

1:37:29eggs and just totally rip off James Thompson's presentation. Do you know what? I don't know

1:37:35because I have James Thompson of, of a peak calc fame and drag thing fame. For those of

1:37:43us who are a little bit older, you still use drag thing. I'm running it right now. I'm

1:37:47looking at it right now, even though it's not retina, but you don't have a retina. This

1:37:50is my run. It is play zone. No problem. So James Thompson was at a conference recently

1:37:55and did like a 28 minute talk on the history of Easter eggs. I've got it saved up. I have seen

1:37:59rave reviews of people saying that this is they knocked it out of the park knowing James. I'm

1:38:06sure that he did. For those of you who don't know, peacocks, peacocks, Easter eggs are some of the

1:38:15most. Well, see, I feel like those are not Easter eggs. I know that's what it's on. I feel the

1:38:21The definition of Easter egg has expanded to ridiculous.

1:38:24It's kind of like lunatic fringe.

1:38:26Lunatic fringe was not an Easter egg in After Dark.

1:38:29Right.

1:38:30Lunatic fringe was a feature of After Dark.

1:38:31It wasn't a hidden cool thing that you could discover.

1:38:35It was totally there.

1:38:37It was just a feature.

1:38:38And in the same way, PCALC, which is essentially

1:38:40a calculator, has a, quote unquote,

1:38:43"Easter egg" where there's an entire crazy 3D game

1:38:46environment in the same application.

1:38:48And AR.

1:38:50Yeah, and AR.

1:38:51Like, yeah.

1:38:51But it is not a cute, hidden little feature somewhere

1:38:55that you would notice or could trigger.

1:38:56Even when you have things like the breakout game in System 7

1:38:59or whatever, that counts as an Easter egg

1:39:01because it was hidden, like an Easter egg is hidden.

1:39:03And I guess the about stuff, the PCAL stuff,

1:39:06is kind of hidden in the about screen.

1:39:08But at a certain point, I would love

1:39:10to know a number of lines of code.

1:39:14How much of PCAL is the quote unquote Easter egg,

1:39:16and how much is the calculator at this point?

1:39:19How much is the math engine?

1:39:20or as James would call it, probably the maths engine.

1:39:23With the code carried over from whatever,

1:39:25he wrote it in Pascal like 20 something years ago.

1:39:28I'm just curious if you have any fond memories of Easter eggs

1:39:31from back in the day.

1:39:32What was the-- the Finder one, was it the--

1:39:34it was the Finder, and if you held down the Option key

1:39:36and went to about this Mac--

1:39:38No, about the Finder is--

1:39:40About the Finder.

1:39:40Yeah, with the little mountain range.

1:39:43I did that-- here's the thing that I'm thinking

1:39:45about Easter eggs the other day.

1:39:46I watched James' thing as well.

1:39:49That little thing where you hold down the option key when you select the "About" and it changes to

1:39:53the "About the Finder" and you see the little "Sierra Nevada Mountains" in sort of this

1:39:57abstract black and white artwork. I must have activated that Easter egg hundreds of times

1:40:06in my life on my Mac. Why? Like, once I did it once, then I knew that it was there.

1:40:16the discovery had been made. It's not like there was any interactive elements or anything. If there

1:40:22was scrolling credits, you can watch them scroll, but once you've done that, that's it. And I wasn't

1:40:26showing people. It's not like other people were there with me. "Hey, let me show you this cool

1:40:29Easter egg that you might not know about on your Mac." Just me, by myself, I would activate that

1:40:34Easter egg. And I think the reason I was doing it was like, you know, the thing that Apple says about

1:40:40all their current products, but is actually true of Easter eggs. Surprise and delight. I just needed

1:40:45I just like the idea that it was there, and I would just activate it and get a little

1:40:51smile and have a little tiny microdose of joy.

1:40:55So yeah, there's that thing that somebody did because they thought it would be fun.

1:40:59And there's that graphic.

1:41:00So my favorite, or one of my favorites, was QuarkXPress had one.

1:41:06And I might misremember—it's been a long time since I've used QuarkXPress—but for

1:41:10a number of years, I used QuarkXPress more than I used any other app.

1:41:14I used it more than BB Edit even.

1:41:16And I got really, really good at it.

1:41:18And there was a keyboard shortcut

1:41:20to delete the current element.

1:41:24And it wasn't just the Delete key.

1:41:26It was Command-Option-K or something like that.

1:41:29And the idea was, I think, that you

1:41:33could be in text editing mode, where the Delete key would

1:41:36delete the last character.

1:41:38But what you really want to do is you

1:41:39want to delete the whole text box

1:41:41that you've placed on the pasteboard.

1:41:43you do Command-Option-K or something like that. But if you held down an extra key—I

1:41:48forget if it was Control. I think it was Control. So you do Control-Command-Option-K, a little

1:41:54alien came out from the side, marched over, and then shot the element you were deleting

1:41:59with a ray gun. It would take like 20 seconds for this. I used it all the time. Late at

1:42:07night at the student newspaper, you start going stir-crazy, I would make the little

1:42:12Quark Express alien come out and spend 20 seconds deleting a thing that I could have

1:42:16deleted completely instantaneously. But I thought that was amusing.

1:42:20Tim Cynova One of the beautiful things of the modern

1:42:22internet is that you can find a video of that happening, I believe, on YouTube or some other

1:42:26source because I remember Googling it at some time in the past and seeing the little animation.

1:42:29I never used Quark Express in real life, but yeah, it's totally one of those little Easter

1:42:34eggs that, you know, was just there to be fun. And why were you activating it? Because

1:42:39You were looking for a tiny microdose of surprise and delight?

1:42:43Yeah.

1:42:44I wouldn't be surprised if James mentioned it, but MailSmith had an Easter egg where

1:42:51on April 1st, it would add a preference to the notification set.

1:42:55MailSmith is the email client made by Barebone Software based on the text engine of BB Edit.

1:43:02And on April 1st, it would add a preference, and I think it was on by default, to deliver

1:43:06a 10 kilovolt electric shock with each new email.

1:43:09And all it did was play a little buzz sound, which was funny.

1:43:14I'm not really much for April 1st gags, but it was all right.

1:43:17But I do recall that while I was there, we did get some support mail from people who

1:43:23did not realize it was a joke.

1:43:25I remember being impressed.

1:43:32One of the other Easter eggs I was impressed by that invoked a new era of Easter eggs was

1:43:35was the first 3D Easter egg that I experienced,

1:43:39which was the iguana flag on the Power Macs.

1:43:42- I don't remember this.

1:43:43- It was a nice combination,

1:43:44I think it's in James' talk,

1:43:45it was a nice combination of,

1:43:47so the Power Mac, the whole big thing with the Power Mac

1:43:49was the Power PC, the Macintosh,

1:43:50and the whole message and sort of,

1:43:54you know, significance in the community

1:43:56was that these are much faster than your old Macs.

1:43:59They are more powerful.

1:44:00They can do all sorts of neat things

1:44:02that your old Mac could never do.

1:44:04- Oh, right, right.

1:44:04the graphing calculator. >> Yeah. And the Easter eggs followed along

1:44:09with that. I think this was in firmware or something. Maybe there was some kind of key

1:44:14combination. I forget how to activate it. But basically it would take over your entire

1:44:18screen with a comically grainy by today's standard background image of one infinite

1:44:24loop with the flags that are in front of the building. It was kind of zoomed in more. And

1:44:29was a flagpole, and hanging from the flagpole was a flag. I think it had a flag with somebody's

1:44:36pedaguan on it or something. And it was rendered in Quickdraw 3D, which you can recall was

1:44:40Apple's attempted 3D API back in the day. Or maybe it was like Quickdraw 3D Rave, or

1:44:47I don't remember the particular standard. But anyway, it was a 3D flag, again, comically

1:44:50green with a comically small number of polygons on it. And it would flap in the breeze. And

1:44:56This alone, it doesn't make any sense that this would be impressive, but this alone was

1:44:59impressive that you'd have a big color graphic which looked "photorealistic" in the background

1:45:05because it was just a photo, and then a 3D flag flapping in the breeze, which was a really

1:45:10hard thing to do.

1:45:11And it was demonstrating, as it flapped at like 12 frames per second or whatever, it

1:45:15was demonstrating the amazing power of these new computers because you couldn't hope to

1:45:19render this at all at like one frame every seven seconds on like an old Mac or worse,

1:45:24right?

1:45:25Right.

1:45:26I don't think there was a cursor on the screen, but if you move the mouse around

1:45:29You could influence the direction of the wind on the flag so you didn't actually see a cursor

1:45:34But you'd notice that it was interacted that you change the direction of the wind

1:45:37And by changing the direction of the wind

1:45:40You know sort of making go all the way to the right and all the way to the left all the way to the right like

1:45:44Back and forth whipping making the flag whip back and forth you could eventually tear the flag off of the pole

1:45:49and it would like flutter down and

1:45:51This was an amazing easter egg because it was like hidden inside your computer

1:45:55It was 3D graphics, and it was interactive, and it was weird,

1:45:58and had an iguana on it.

1:45:59And it was super Apple-focused, and it demonstrated

1:46:02the power of your Power Mac.

1:46:03That's another one that stands out in my memory.

1:46:05It's a little weird that Apple doesn't do stuff like that

1:46:07anymore.

1:46:08I mean, you get the feeling that Steve Jobs wasn't really

1:46:11a fan of that sort of thing.

1:46:12Which is weird, because if you think about Steve Jobs making

1:46:15like blue boxes with Woz, he was--

1:46:16and the pirate flag and everything like that,

1:46:18that was totally up his alley.

1:46:21But at a certain point, he turned the car on.

1:46:23Yeah, he outgrew it.

1:46:24Yeah, he outgrew it.

1:46:24Or either outgrew it or decided that if it's not him doing it, don't do it because now

1:46:28you're messing up his thing.

1:46:29It's great when he's messing up AT&T's phone system.

1:46:31It's not so great when you're messing up his thing.

1:46:33Dave Asprey Yeah.

1:46:34Because the other thing I wouldn't—I don't know if—sometimes you'd call them Easter

1:46:37eggs just because they were clever.

1:46:40But just an about box that did something interesting.

1:46:43You'd go to about this Mac or about this app and it would—people—it was a place

1:46:50for clever developers to blow off Steam.

1:46:54I mean, James obviously still has it, but--

1:46:57BBS still got it, too.

1:46:59Yeah, yeah.

1:47:01But that was thrown by the wayside.

1:47:03It was the one window the developer

1:47:05felt like was for them.

1:47:07It was a place where you could go--

1:47:08the only reason the user would go there

1:47:10is to maybe get a version number.

1:47:11So that's the only information you have to convey.

1:47:12But every other part of that window

1:47:14is it's like the place for the developer to take a bow.

1:47:17And depending on how deeply you want to bow,

1:47:19if you want to put in your breakout game or a 3D driving

1:47:22game with an AR component, that's the place to do it.

1:47:28But it's interesting that Apple sort of went away from that. I can't remember the

1:47:32last time anybody found an Easter egg in Apple software, but Google still does it famously

1:47:38all the time. They had Mario driving around Google Maps on Mario Day. Did you know this?

1:47:44Mario Day is March 10th because it looks like Mario.

1:47:47That's terrible.

1:47:48Mar 10th.

1:47:49the fourth. All these sort of pun-based holidays are not great.

1:47:54May the fourth at least—I cringe at it. I think it's a little corny. But at least

1:48:00you would say, like, when it is May fourth, you would say May the fourth. And it does

1:48:04sound like May the fourth be with you. It works at a certain level where Mar Ten equals

1:48:11Mario.

1:48:12Yeah, it's more of a stretch.

1:48:14Kind of a stretch. I'm trying to think who else does Easter eggs.

1:48:17probably still Apple ones hidden in there. Like people can sneak stuff in, but it's,

1:48:21uh, the thing is there's so much more software now that, uh, you know, so many more applications.

1:48:26The number of applications in the app store dwarfs the number of applications ever made

1:48:30for classic Mac OS by probably orders of magnitude. So if there are awesome Easter eggs out there,

1:48:35maybe we just don't even know about them. I feel like at various points in the early

1:48:39life of the Mac, I was at least aware of, if not had a copy of every application available

1:48:44things for the computer, right? Certainly all the popular ones, right? So you could,

1:48:48you could, it's like being in a small town where you know everybody, right? And then you know,

1:48:52like these three have Easter eggs and everybody eventually knows about the Easter eggs and we

1:48:56share it. And with like with millions of apps in the app store, that doesn't happen anymore.

1:48:59There's not, there's not that sort of, it's like television, you know, when we're all watching the

1:49:04same three networks in the same five shows, it's a lot easier to have a shared understanding of the

1:49:09the current state of play.

1:49:11You added this.

1:49:12Here's a story you added to the show notes about Apple locking batteries

1:49:17to iPhones.

1:49:18Michael Tsai has it on his website.

1:49:20I'll link to that in the show notes.

1:49:24This has been growing for a while.

1:49:25And I think that the gist of it now is that it's not

1:49:29that you can't use a non-authorized battery replacement,

1:49:34but if you put a non-authorized battery replacement into an iPhone

1:49:39and presumably maybe iPads too, or if not, it might be coming. You get a permanent warning

1:49:45in settings that tells you that the battery needs to be serviced, which would annoy the

1:49:51hell out of me to have something like that that I can't make go away.

1:49:54**Matt Stauffer:** Especially if it's badge settings. I don't

1:49:55think it does badge settings, but imagine if it did.

1:49:57**Beserat Debebe:** Oh, that would drive me nuts.

1:50:00**Matt Stauffer** Yeah. So this is the type of thing where now

1:50:02it's a bunch of people experimenting. So it's not a rumor. It's a real thing that's happening,

1:50:07it's unclear what the actual situation is. The situation could be that the logic in Apple's

1:50:14operating system that tries to validate the battery with the little chip that's in there,

1:50:19you know, triggers this battery needs service thing, but really it's erroneous because what

1:50:24it should just be detecting is that it's not the battery needs service, it's just that

1:50:28it's not matched up with the hardware and that should be expressed in a different way.

1:50:32Or it could be that this is totally intended behavior and Apple's trying to stop people

1:50:35from putting in other batteries. But the effect of it may end up being the same. And this

1:50:40is this ongoing battle of like—

1:50:42Jay Haynes And it's—you get it even if it is an authorized

1:50:45part. It's just that if the service is performed by someone other than an authorized Apple

1:50:51itself or an authorized Apple repair technician, there's some kind of magic incantation that

1:50:57once you put the replacement part in, you do some sort of diagnostic thing that says,

1:51:02"Okay, now it's authorized."

1:51:04it's authorized. Yeah, but involving some sort of private key

1:51:06that only Apple has or something like that. Like the thing that this is part of the larger

1:51:11right to repair issue of like, should Apple, should it be legal for Apple to stop people

1:51:16from start third parties for repairing them? And it reminds me a lot of the printer ink

1:51:19DRM debacle of years past where printer manufacturers make all their money off this ink and so they

1:51:26wanted to make it so that you couldn't use third party ink cartridges. So they put some

1:51:29sort of DRM in the ink cartridges and then tried to sue the makers.

1:51:33nothing about making your print output look better or come out faster or have higher fidelity.

1:51:40It was simply there for pure marketing spite.

1:51:46Adam: Yeah. But see, the thing is their story was similar to the Apple. They would say,

1:51:50"Well, we just want people to make sure people have guaranteed compatible highest quality

1:51:56ink that we can control." Who knows what you're getting from those third-party things

1:52:00it might not work right or it might work right with this version, but then we open our software

1:52:04and that ink doesn't work because they didn't realize they had to design it in this way

1:52:07to account for some change in our printer.

1:52:09So really it's the safest if you use our first.

1:52:12It's exactly the same story with the Apple batteries.

1:52:15Like, oh, well, third parties, we want it to be installed by an authorized dealer.

1:52:19We want it to be a genuine part and that's why we put this code in there and blah, blah,

1:52:23blah.

1:52:24And you can, again, within the company, I can imagine people convincing themselves that

1:52:28that what they're doing is in the best interest of the customer.

1:52:31But back in reality, it is not in the best interest of the customer.

1:52:36I feel like it was clearly established that it is better for people to be able to get

1:52:40cheaper printer ink.

1:52:41It's bad for a single company to have a monopoly on this because they raised the price and

1:52:45because there's no competition, right?

1:52:47And so it's bad if no one but Apple can successfully put an Apple battery back into an Apple phone.

1:52:54And there's always going to be cases where like, oh, some third party badly installed

1:52:58a battery and it blew up and it's playing on fire and killed everyone on board.

1:53:02But that's just, that's part of what Apple has to deal with as a company in the world.

1:53:06And I honestly, it wouldn't be that big a deal because what Apple would say is, yeah,

1:53:10that's because the third party did it and they did a bad job, right?

1:53:13It would be actually good for Apple to be able to explain that.

1:53:16It would help people keep people away from it.

1:53:18But the reality is that doesn't happen.

1:53:19People just get cheaper batteries from third parties and everyone is better for it except

1:53:24for apparently Apple who just can't stand the idea of that happening.

1:53:27Yeah, and the other one, and I don't think that there's an issue with it at the moment,

1:53:30but I know that in that third party repair scene for phones, the big one is repairing

1:53:36cracked displays because their displays are made of glass and people sometimes unfortunately

1:53:44drop their phone and then the glass shatters and people have different—there's different

1:53:49amounts of shattering and people have different standards for what they'll put up with once

1:53:53they've done it. I would probably go the authorized route. I've done it, in fact,

1:54:01I think twice that I've dropped an iPhone. But I totally respect that some people, if

1:54:08they could do it for half price and it still looks like a nice display, it's I guess

1:54:12an Apple part. I mean, you can't really have a third-party display. They would like

1:54:16to save money on it. I get it. I'm probably more on Apple's side on the right to repair

1:54:25stuff than a lot of people, a lot of nerds. A lot of nerds are really upset about all

1:54:30of this stuff. I get it. Your phone, you should be able to do whatever you want with it. But

1:54:36I know the iFixit guys are really down on all the glue that Apple uses to put things

1:54:41together.

1:54:42I feel like that's a separate issue.

1:54:44The issue of how repairable they are,

1:54:47you can be militant about that,

1:54:49or you can not be militant about it.

1:54:50But it's the idea that if I'm physically able

1:54:54to do a repair or replacement,

1:54:56like if I'm able to do that with the tools

1:54:57and skills that I have,

1:54:59but then some kind of essentially DRM lockout

1:55:02prevents the device from working,

1:55:05from appearing to work correctly in the future

1:55:07for no actual good reason other than just like,

1:55:10Apple doesn't want this to happen.

1:55:12That's bad.

1:55:13We can't rely on Apple's benevolence to have reasonable repair prices and wait times.

1:55:16We want there to be pressure.

1:55:18For years and years before the iPhone, there were authorized Apple dealers.

1:55:24Before there were Apple stores.

1:55:25That's where you went to get Apple stuff done.

1:55:27That is a well-established system for Apple having some modicum of control because to

1:55:31be an authorized Apple dealer, the word authorized means Apple authorized you to do it.

1:55:35I would go beyond that and say, "It should be perfectly possible to have completely unauthorized

1:55:40repair centers for these things, right? As long as, you know, the backstops against all the safety

1:55:47and the danger things should be legal backstops that exist for consumer perception, independent

1:55:51of any individual company. Like in other words, liability for doing a bad phone repair and it

1:55:55blows up a battery. We're like, that's the legal system and our laws should protect us against

1:55:59that. It's not like we're saying a laissez faire if your battery blows up, tough luck. Like,

1:56:04you know, that's, that's why we have laws. But beyond that, Apple shouldn't have any say. And

1:56:10whether you're allowed to get your phone repaired, they can void your warranty, because again,

1:56:13that's an Apple thing. That's always been the deal. Fine. You get it repaired someplace else.

1:56:16It's not an authorized Apple dealer, you void your warranty, like, these are the trade offs

1:56:20that need to be made. And it's not, you know, the slippery slope, like if you allow this,

1:56:23it will be madness. We lived in this world for years where there was authorized Apple dealers,

1:56:27no Apple stores, and also unauthorized Apple dealers, and nobody, you know, the world did

1:56:32did not end. It is a perfectly viable system.

1:56:35Dave Asprey You could take these things apart, put them

1:56:37back together, and they just worked. It reminds me of a longstanding observation. You still

1:56:43have a TiVo?

1:56:44Tim Cynova I have multiple TiVos.

1:56:46Dave Asprey So we're still a TiVo family, and that's

1:56:50why I think you and I have talked about this on the show before. It's very hard to convey

1:56:55to somebody who doesn't own a TiVo how much better TiVo fast-forwarding and skipping around

1:57:02is and how you never ever have to wait for anything. It's always super fast. They've

1:57:07even added better features where certain shows now get indexed where you can just hit that

1:57:12– do you have the green button?

1:57:13Yeah.

1:57:14D. And it skips – it perfectly skips the commercials. But we first computerized television

1:57:22or video watching, if you will, to make it better and to do amazing things like time

1:57:27shifting without having to manage a bunch of VHS tapes and a much easier—I mean, people

1:57:37forget it. Again, we're going to lose the younger crowd. But the blinking 12 on the

1:57:41VCR was a real thing. That was a real thing where VCRs were so bad to use, had such a

1:57:49terrible user interface that people didn't even bother to set the clock. And if you don't

1:57:53of the clock set, you can't program anything in advance. You can't say, "Well, I'm going

1:57:58on vacation and I want to tape my favorite show on Tuesday night." Well, if the clock

1:58:02isn't set, good luck. People didn't use it. TiVo revolutionized this. It made it—you

1:58:08had this nice little TV guide right on the screen and you'd say, "That's the show I

1:58:11want," and then you'd get it. And it was great. We used computers to make watching

1:58:17TV better. And now we use computers to make watching TV worse with unskippable Hulu ads

1:58:24and like we went from using computers to be able to skip ads if you want to, to using

1:58:30computers to make it so that you cannot skip the ads.

1:58:33Yeah, well, in some respects, we also may use computers to make TV better still, as

1:58:38in let's forego the entire concept of a continuous stream of shows that air at fixed

1:58:43times and then having a device deal with them, streaming services, the shows just exist and

1:58:47watch them when you want, so that's an improvement. But now that they have control over the venue

1:58:52again, they're using that control to extract money in various ways. Although I have to

1:58:57say that for the most part, first of all, my TiVo usage has been decreasing as more

1:59:03and more shows are on streaming services. And second, I prefer the experience of using

1:59:10a completely commercial-free streaming service that I pay for and can stream and download

1:59:15any time that I want, then the experience of TiVo in all ways except for the control

1:59:21factor because if I have to use it on tvOS I'm using the terrible Apple remote and if

1:59:28I'm using it on an iOS device I find the playback interfaces, the sort of interface that, you

1:59:34know, on the screen that you use to play the show, in all of my applications to be terrible

1:59:39I want to sit down every single one of these developers and say let me explain to you the

1:59:42things that people do when they're watching shows on their iPad and how terrible your

1:59:47interface is at doing those things.

1:59:50Like the ones that don't have like a go back 15 seconds or the –

1:59:53Yeah.

1:59:54That's just like the tip of the iceberg, right?

1:59:56I could start getting into –

1:59:57How do you not have those buttons?

1:59:58I could start getting into obscure stuff like the idea that if when I pause your video to

2:00:03like read the letter that someone is writing, if you dim the screen so much that I can't

2:00:08see the stuff anymore, why do you think I'm pausing it?

2:00:10Yes, I could be pausing it to go to the bathroom, but I could also be pausing it to pick something

2:00:14out of a frame.

2:00:15You have to give me a way to remove your HUD with a second tap, which many applications

2:00:19do, but many applications do not.

2:00:20You know another thing people do all the time?

2:00:22They turn on the captions to tell what somebody said.

2:00:25This one barrier that Apple got right, the "What did he say?"

2:00:28Siri thing, which makes you feel silly, but at least the feature exists.

2:00:32Go back a little bit and turn on captions.

2:00:33If captions are four levels deep in a menu, that's not a good experience.

2:00:39many things. And remembering playback position, I cannot express to you how important it is for

2:00:43you to remember my playback position because if you do not, it's infuriating. You just got to get

2:00:48these basics right. And because there are so many applications, they all have an opportunity

2:00:52to screw up that interface in their own unique ways. Right. Imagine a book that you couldn't

2:00:57bookmark. Or it would try to, but then it would forget. Right. And just drop you 70 pages prior

2:01:03or something like that. Or keep insisting after you finish the book that you are in the middle

2:01:07of chapter one. And every time you go back to the library, the book flies out of the

2:01:11shelf and hits you in the forehead and says, "Hey, you want to continue reading chapter

2:01:14one?" You're like, "I finished that book. How can I convince you that I finished reading

2:01:17that book? Stop telling me to resume in the middle of chapter one. Do I have to read it

2:01:21again to convince you, library, that I finished the book?" I've had that experience with

2:01:25streaming services that keep insisting that I resume watching a series that I had completely

2:01:30finished watching because some of their metadata about what I've seen and what I haven't

2:01:35is messed up and I have no way to fix it.

2:01:36Do you see this thing that came out today where Apple released a series of ASMR videos

2:01:42to YouTube?

2:01:43I did.

2:01:44At first, I thought that was like a third party, like someone just took a bunch of Apple

2:01:47videos and did some ASMR stuff.

2:01:49But then eventually, after the 75th time I saw the link, I actually followed it and saw

2:01:53that it was literally an official Apple video.

2:01:56And I was a little bit surprised by that.

2:01:57But you know, it's YouTube and they're trying different things.

2:02:01What does ASMR stand for?

2:02:03I'm Googling it right now.

2:02:04I used to know this something sensory something response.

2:02:09- Yeah, something like that.

2:02:12Autonomous sensory meridian response.

2:02:15- I got two out of the four, partial credit.

2:02:18- Basically it's satisfying noises,

2:02:23like people crunch paper.

2:02:27It's just a huge on, I guess everything's huge on YouTube.

2:02:30There's a niche for everything.

2:02:31- But this is actually a pretty big thing.

2:02:34And it's a little bit woo woo with the whole like,

2:02:36who gets what experience from watching these videos?

2:02:41But I feel like anybody,

2:02:42especially if you've never seen it before,

2:02:43will get some reaction from the experience.

2:02:47Perhaps a reaction that might surprise you,

2:02:49because if you're like,

2:02:50it's just a video of people whispering and crumpling paper,

2:02:52I'm not gonna find that.

2:02:53It might be interesting.

2:02:55You may find it incredibly interesting and satisfying,

2:02:58or you may find it mildly more interesting

2:03:00than you thought you would.

2:03:01but I doubt anyone will look at an ASMR video for the very first time and say, "I find

2:03:06this exactly as boring as I thought I would."

2:03:07Dave Asprey Right. I don't know how they're recording

2:03:10the sounds because it's—and the Apple angle is that these are shot on iPhone. They are

2:03:15gorgeous videos. Again, I found it—I'm not really into the sound that much, but it

2:03:20was interesting. The one where the woman was whispering was definitely—you really want

2:03:25headphones for that one. Every one of them opens with best heard on—with headphones

2:03:30on. But I just like it because it ups my—it makes me up my game or at least raise my goals

2:03:40for what I can shoot with my phone because I'm like, "Damn, this looks like a real

2:03:45movie." My iPhone movies still look like home videos, you know. I feel like—

2:03:50You've got to get yourself a gimbal or a tripod.

2:03:52Yeah.

2:03:53Yeah.

2:03:54That seems like a lot of work.

2:03:56Yeah.

2:03:57That's fine.

2:03:58Anything else you wanted to talk about?

2:04:00I had a whole bunch of stuff on the future of Mac OS, but we don't have time to get

2:04:06into that now.

2:04:07No, no, no.

2:04:08We don't have time on that.

2:04:09I know that you're very excited.

2:04:11The Mac Pro is coming.

2:04:15What is—and I feel like this is to me—I talk to every guest about it every week is

2:04:19is what is your take on this 16-inch MacBook Pro?

2:04:24Is it a replacement for the 15 or not?

2:04:28- I think it is at this point.

2:04:29I mean, even if the 15 hangs around,

2:04:31I think essentially this is the successor to that.

2:04:34And eventually, in the same way that models eventually

2:04:38fall off the end of Tim Cook's Apple,

2:04:40the 15-inch will be in the dustbin

2:04:43and the 16-inch will be the new 15-inch.

2:04:44That is my current expectation.

2:04:48Did you guys talk about those weird rumors about people spotting the 16-inch—I didn't

2:04:53listen last time to ATP.

2:04:54I don't know.

2:04:55We did.

2:04:56We had that in the notes, and we discussed it amongst ourselves.

2:04:57I never actually made it into a show.

2:05:00The joke I made about it, which my two co-hosts didn't get because they don't remember

2:05:03this is that—so what we're talking about is someone posted a photo of a supposed prototype

2:05:10of the 16-inch MacBook in a public place, like a public café or a Starbucks or something.

2:05:17even like Cafe Mac's on campus, like at like a Cupertino area like lunch spot. And it just

2:05:24seems so bizarre. Like who would do that? Well, so the joke I made about it was that

2:05:30I'd like that photo better if it was on the floor of an elevator. And I was joking about it.

2:05:35In the early days of MacRumors, the thing that happened a lot and became a source of parody

2:05:45was because digital photography was in its infancy, lots of the supposed spy photos of

2:05:52things were terrible quality, very grainy, low resolution, terrible lighting, because

2:05:58who had any kind of camera, let alone a digital camera, and what was the resolution and what

2:06:02was their light sensitivity.

2:06:03And that made it incredibly easy to make quote unquote "convincing" fake photos.

2:06:09And so eventually it became like a joke that every time there was a supposed photo of something,

2:06:13it was like Bigfoot.

2:06:14Why are they never in focus?

2:06:16And so one of the famous ones was someone took a picture of,

2:06:19this is the new iMac, and here it

2:06:21is, a box on the floor of an elevator in a supposed

2:06:24convention center from a weird angle, incredibly grainy.

2:06:29Like, if you actually had access to this thing and a camera,

2:06:34no one would take just one terrible grainy photo

2:06:37and post that.

2:06:38And so when I saw this picture of this Mac

2:06:40and supposedly in the Starbucks or whatever,

2:06:42I'm like, this, in the modern era,

2:06:45the resolution and color fidelity

2:06:48and focus of this photo was awful.

2:06:50Like, was it taken on an iPhone 3G?

2:06:54Like, I don't understand what took this photograph.

2:06:57And most of the mystery and authenticity of this photo

2:07:01comes from the fact that it is so low quality

2:07:03that you can't tell if that was drawn

2:07:06by someone with a Sharpie marker

2:07:07or whether it's an actual physical device.

2:07:11Yeah, I guess if you want to give the photographer the benefit of the doubt and make the argument

2:07:18that it is a legit shot, I guess maybe it was somebody who was nervous about being—realized

2:07:24what they were shooting and that this person, however crazy they are to be using a prototype

2:07:30off campus, certainly doesn't want to be photographed.

2:07:33But they're in a public place, first of all.

2:07:36Second of all, we see creep shots of celebrities all the time.

2:07:39You're much more likely to be beat down by the bodyguard of a celebrity than some Apple nerd to yell at you

2:07:45When you're in a public place, you can take a picture of them at their table

2:07:48I know you don't want to be creepy

2:07:49But the point is if you took the creepiest of creep shot under your arm with your iPhone

2:07:53It would be a hundred times better than the quality of that photo

2:07:56I don't understand why the photo is so bad and why there's only one of them, right?

2:07:59Well, the other crazy thing about it is that and I just find this so hard to believe but it would kind of be cool

2:08:06it would kind of warm my heart but the fact that

2:08:08this rumor is that the Apple logo on the back of the display is the

2:08:12Six color Apple logo. Yeah, that's that's a separate rumor and this that's why this this photo like when I look doesn't show the Apple

2:08:20Yeah, but no it does it does show it does

2:08:22Yeah

2:08:24That's the reason I I made the elevator joke is because this is exactly how in the old days you would make a convince a quote

2:08:31Unquote convincing fake you'd make it grainy you'd make it plausible and you incorporate some other rumors

2:08:36So you're like, there has been a rumor going around

2:08:38that Apple's gonna bring back the six color Apple logo,

2:08:40which I certainly hope they do,

2:08:41because I love that logo and I think it is plausible rumor.

2:08:43Incorporate that into your fake

2:08:45by getting someone to take a gray Dell,

2:08:49shove an Apple sticker on it,

2:08:50and then take an off kilter, low resolution,

2:08:53poorly lit, out of focus photo of it,

2:08:54and then post that one photo online and say, here it is.

2:08:57I caught the 16 inch MacBook Pro in real life.

2:09:00And here's the thing, if the MacBook Pro comes out

2:09:02and it is gray and has an Apple logo on the back of it,

2:09:05that doesn't mean that photo was real.

2:09:06- Right.

2:09:07- It just means that they successfully

2:09:08made a reasonable fake.

2:09:11God, like I used to be frustrated when I was younger

2:09:14that people were so bad at producing leaks,

2:09:17but eventually people got good at it.

2:09:19Like when we see the parts leaks for the iPhones now,

2:09:22they're good.

2:09:23There's like 15 photos, they're in focus,

2:09:25they're high resolution and they are legit.

2:09:27And when the real phone comes out,

2:09:28we can compare them side by side and say, yep,

2:09:30those were the parts of the phone.

2:09:32- Yeah, or the cases, right?

2:09:34like the cases sometimes leak and it's like,

2:09:36yep, that was a perfect cutout for the--

2:09:39- Down to the millimeter, 'cause they give those specs

2:09:41to the casemakers before the phones go.

2:09:43- I think they do with some select partners,

2:09:46but there's a huge racket, like the lesser casemakers

2:09:50that don't necessarily have Apple's trust

2:09:52bribe the employees at the factory to get the schematics.

2:09:56Well, the rumors I'd use to be so much worse,

2:10:04too.

2:10:05They were so bad in the old days.

2:10:06It was always—

2:10:07John

2:10:33They would just make up stuff from whole cloth and the sites would post it and we would read

2:10:37it.

2:10:38It was a fun pastime, but that seems to have fallen by the wayside.

2:10:42Now we mostly get real rumors from supposed reputable publications like Bloomberg or whatever.

2:10:49Right.

2:10:50Reading the rumor sites in the late '90s, maybe very early 2000s, was a lot like reading

2:10:54a supermarket tabloid.

2:10:56I did it and I was interested, but I pretty much went through a whole week of posts and

2:11:01be like, "That's bullshit. Bullshit. Nope." **Matt Stauffer** But like people who read

2:11:05tabloids, you'd also kind of get excited sometimes like, "But what if this one is real?"

2:11:08Like, it was like the more ridiculous they were, the more you'd like, hold that because the good

2:11:15ones would incorporate all the little kernels of truth that are out there, mix them all together,

2:11:22and then put a unicorn on it. And so it was like all our hopes and dreams with just enough

2:11:28flaws ability to make us consider it at all.

2:11:35I know you're eyeballing a Mac Pro later in the year, probably.

2:11:38What are your current thoughts on the display?

2:11:41It seems to me like with this news a week or two ago that LG's whatever it's called

2:11:47display is not in fact dead.

2:11:49It was only getting like a minor refresh.

2:11:54To me, my take on it is that this makes me feel less certain about Apple coming out with

2:12:00a lower-priced Pro display.

2:12:02Adam: I mostly agree with that.

2:12:05Apple doesn't control what LG does.

2:12:09If LG wants to make a 5G display, that's fine.

2:12:12It really all depends on exactly how much Apple starts pushing it in its venues.

2:12:16How much does it push it in its stores, in its advertising, on its website?

2:12:21I think is a stronger sign of whether Apple's going to make a reasonably priced display than the fact that LG is

2:12:26Continuing to make the display but all that said speaking of stress dreams

2:12:31I continue to have stress dreams about the monitor both waking and sleeping like

2:12:35You know, I don't it's I don't need that display

2:12:40But if I had that display, I think I would really enjoy it

2:12:42But it's really expensive and I just go back and forth and back and forth

2:12:46Then I think like could I buy this computer but then put something put a non-apple display on it like that's the whole reason

2:12:52I was flipping out when Apple stopped making displays is that I couldn't stomach that idea and it's it there's an industrial design

2:12:59Mismatch there and even if you're gonna put your Mac Pro under your desk, and so it's not right next to this display

2:13:06It you know it's not a bad-looking display. It's very plain. It's kind of bad

2:13:12have the bigger forehead. It's not even a symmetrical…

2:13:14Yeah, it's not symmetric. It's a nice panel, but I just couldn't help but think

2:13:20that when they announced the price of the Pro Display XDR and literally caused gasps

2:13:26in the room, my thought immediately went to, "Well, why not just Apple Pro Display? Why

2:13:34say XDR unless they were going to make a Pro Display that's not XDR?" And the XDR stuff

2:13:39is the stuff that non-film editors don't really need. You don't really need a thousand

2:13:46nits. You'd probably burn your eyes out if you're just coding or something like

2:13:51that. You don't need the super high dynamic range. You just need regular dynamic range,

2:13:57high dynamic range.

2:13:58Adam: Yeah, I mean, I don't know. Purchase-wise, I don't know what I'm going to do. It

2:14:03is a no-brainer to me that Apple absolutely should make an iMac without the iMac.

2:14:07But I don't understand what the whole—is this another instance where they do all the

2:14:14Mac roundtable and get the pro workflow group and talk to all these people and no one during

2:14:18that entire sequence said, "Are you going to have a regular monitor?"

2:14:23What about a display in the $1,500 range?

2:14:26Again, spending so long in corporate America, I continue to be sure that it could be about

2:14:33anything like that within Apple, they are able to convince themselves of things that

2:14:39seem preposterous to us on the outside.

2:14:41No matter how much outreaching you do an hour, how many roundtables you have, no matter how

2:14:45much talking with your customers, that somehow internally they're able to decide that this

2:14:53is not a product that we need or we don't need it this year or we don't need to say

2:14:55anything about it.

2:14:56And it's just such an obvious gap.

2:14:58Our only standalone Apple display is $6,000.

2:15:01Yeah, it's like--

2:15:02And you really want the $7,000 one.

2:15:05Yeah, and here's the thing.

2:15:07This is sort of-- the communication gap is--

2:15:09back at that roundtable thing that you went to,

2:15:12where they were like, we're going to make a Mac Pro.

2:15:14We screwed up.

2:15:15Here's what we're going to do.

2:15:16We're recommitting to the Mac.

2:15:17They so triumphantly said, and also, we're

2:15:21going to make a display.

2:15:22And there was much rejoicing, and everyone was happy.

2:15:25And I feel like the disconnect is not about the happiness,

2:15:27because Apple's like, "We think people want a display too.

2:15:30We should say that.

2:15:31We should do that."

2:15:32And they said it, and everybody liked it, and everyone's happy.

2:15:35Apple's smiling because we're smiling.

2:15:37They said they're going to do a thing.

2:15:38We say we love the thing.

2:15:40We're all one big happy family, but we're not happy about the same thing because Apple's

2:15:45like, "Let's make that $7,000 display now," and we're all expecting, "You can make a $7,000

2:15:51display.

2:15:52That's awesome.

2:15:53I think that's a great thing for you to make, but you can have a regular one too, right?"

2:15:57And now they come out like, "Yeah, here's the thing."

2:15:59And then we're all grumpy and like, "But we were all happy.

2:16:02Weren't we all happy about the display?"

2:16:03It's like, "Yes, but we weren't thinking of the same thing."

2:16:05Like we need to, there needs to be closer and can you guys just, you know, when you

2:16:09say you're going to make a display, that's the problem with all this secrecy.

2:16:11When you say you're making a display, you're not going to make a $7,000 reference monitor

2:16:16competitor are you?

2:16:17Like it wouldn't even occur to us to ask that.

2:16:19And they're not going to tell you what they're going to make either.

2:16:21They just want to roll it out and just be all smiles and wait for the plaudits to roll

2:16:25in.

2:16:26And it's like, "No.

2:16:27Like, you can have that.

2:16:30Again, I think if they had that display and also an iMac without the iMac, the story would

2:16:36be as positive as Apple wanted it to be.

2:16:38So we would be like, "I'm going to get this also new Mac Pro with this monitor, and imagine

2:16:43if I have that even cooler monitor."

2:16:46Everybody would love it, right?

2:16:47But because they didn't, and because we all didn't find out about this miscommunication

2:16:51until it's, you know, whatever the Henry thing, like, until we opened the gifts, and we're

2:16:56So, I really hope they fix this eventually.

2:17:03There's the, you know, people who don't like Apple products, nerds who don't like

2:17:08Apple products, the longstanding decades, as far back as I can remember, even before

2:17:14there was internet, the rap that we get is that we're brainwashed, right? We're, what

2:17:21cultists, you know, the cult of Mac or whatever.

2:17:28The number of people who are saying, "Just let us use an iMac as a standalone display,

2:17:36and I'll just ignore the very nice computer that's inside," is sort of right up that—I

2:17:43have to admit that—because it's crazy, but people really are—I can't tell you

2:17:47whenever I tweet about this and stuff like that, how many people say, "I just wish

2:17:50that I could plug my MacBook Pro into an iMac,

2:17:54and that would be fine with me.

2:17:55- Part of that is bargaining, because they're like,

2:17:57okay, you won't do the thing that I want,

2:17:59but how about this thing that you sorta did once,

2:18:01bring that back, right?

2:18:01But then part of it is also the actual convenience angle

2:18:04of like, look, I literally do have an iMac that I use,

2:18:07but sometimes I sit down in front of it with my laptop,

2:18:10it would be cool to have a quick little docking thing,

2:18:12right, so there's two halves of that, right?

2:18:14But like--

2:18:15- But it makes no sense, because clearly they should be able

2:18:18to make a 5K display for less than an iMac.

2:18:22But they should just sell it for the same price as the iMac.

2:18:26Like it's all profit.

2:18:27Just do not reduce the price.

2:18:29Make it cost more than the base iMac.

2:18:31People would buy that.

2:18:32That's how desperate.

2:18:33I know.

2:18:34And that's where I think the disconnect is.

2:18:35Apple thought that we were all happy.

2:18:38We were sad when they didn't make monitors and we were happy when they said they would.

2:18:41And Apple's like, "They want us to make a monitor because only Apple can make this amazing

2:18:46breakthrough monitor."

2:18:47And the real answer, I feel like, is we want Apple to make a monitor so it matches our

2:18:52computer and it's really nice.

2:18:54Like at the base level.

2:18:55We also think it's cool if they can make an awesome monitor, right?

2:18:58But at the base level, and the same reason we wanted to make Wi-Fi routers and USB hubs

2:19:04is that it's hard to find nice, high-quality stuff that you know works with your system.

2:19:09That's part of the beauty of buying Apple stuff is like, I know it will be nice, it

2:19:13It will look nice, it will be high quality, I know it will work with the Mac because it's

2:19:18made by the same company.

2:19:20It'll turn on with a button, you know, when I want it to turn on.

2:19:23It'll have nice integrations that don't, like, and yeah, it'll be more expensive, and that

2:19:27is the bargain we have struck.

2:19:29But Apple, I guess, interpreted the demand for and happiness with the announcement of

2:19:33a monitor to be, they want us to make a breakthrough.

2:19:36And I don't want to say we didn't want, we do want them to make breakthroughs, but you

2:19:39also just had to make a decent monitor.

2:19:41And the other weird thing about it is in the post switch to Intel world, we as Mac users

2:19:50gained access to a lot of peripherals and things because the Mac is effectively just

2:20:00a very specific Intel PC.

2:20:04We can literally boot Windows if we choose to.

2:20:09But the display world has bifurcated in such a weird way.

2:20:15There just are no options for a nice iMac caliber 5K display out there.

2:20:20And most PC users, especially gamers, don't want retina displays.

2:20:24They want bigger pixels because they want to drive them at a high frame rate.

2:20:29And so it's just very, very strange.

2:20:32We don't have an option to go-- there's one 5K display we can choose.

2:20:36It's from LG.

2:20:38And it's kind of flaky and it's ugly. Yeah. And the thing is, I understand where they're

2:20:45coming from and I still hold a lot of hope that the strategy is announce the Mac Pro

2:20:49and the top end display and it's one big cohesive story for super duper pros and then backfill

2:20:56later. But with Apple secrecy being the way it is and in the current sort of in-between

2:21:00stage we are where you can't actually order a Mac Pro yet, and with the LG thing coming

2:21:05coming out. They've reintroduced uncertainty, where I feel like they didn't have to. And

2:21:10maybe like they, like, I don't know what kind of financial sense any of this makes, because

2:21:17they're going to sell so few Mac Pros, and they're going to sell so few of these displays,

2:21:20and they would sell so few of the display that we were speculating about. But like,

2:21:25the argument for the Mac Pro has never been this is an awesome business for Apple to be

2:21:27in. The argument, my argument has always been it's a business that Apple has to be in, even

2:21:32if it's not particularly profitable, because to not be in it is to sort of, you know, consign

2:21:39yourself to a narrow band of the market where you miss out on all sorts of benefits.

2:21:46So anyway, that is my hope. My hope is that they call this one the XDR because there's

2:21:51also a pro display. I don't know if it would be 6K. I would be happy with 5K like the iMac

2:21:56panel, but a nice Apple branded pro display with all sorts of nice features. And it just,

2:22:03I can't help but think that it's possible that they were like, "Well, let's hold something

2:22:07back so that when we announce this for sale in October, that we'll have something new

2:22:13to announce in addition to what we already preannounced at WWDC."

2:22:17Adam: That's a terrible strategy though, because once they saw what the reaction was,

2:22:22was they should have said, "Oh, we wanted to surprise you later. Instead, we are signing

2:22:27you up for multiple months of being disappointed." And that's really when this multiple wants

2:22:31a disappointment. If they had something to stop the disappointment, I think we would

2:22:36already know about it. So I hope they're scrambling to produce something like this. But given

2:22:41their timelines, I don't expect it anytime soon.

2:22:45A thousand dollar arm.

2:22:46I'm not even getting into the stand.

2:22:50Just talking about the monitor itself.

2:22:53Oh, Jon, it was good to have you back on the show.

2:22:56Let's not make it a year and a half again.

2:22:58I'll invite you.

2:22:59You don't have to invite yourself.

2:23:00I'll invite you back.

2:23:01At the very least, we have a Star Wars movie coming up this year, right?

2:23:05We could do a Star Wars Spectacular in a couple months.

2:23:08Sure, yeah.

2:23:09No, those don't count, actually.

2:23:10So actually, you've got to have me on for the tech topics, but Star Wars I'm always

2:23:14game for, for sure.

2:23:16Well, it's always good talking to you. I enjoy your show

2:23:18one of my favorites

2:23:21My thanks to our sponsors this week with

2:23:24Squarespace where you can go to build websites ero where you can set up a mesh network Wi-Fi in your house and

2:23:31Away travel where you can get yourself an excellent suitcase my thanks to you

2:23:36For being here John. It was great