Podcast Search

The Talk Show

255: ‘Zap the PRAM’ With Jason Snell

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I'll tell you what, I don't understand how people who like,

0:00:02let's just say like, like a Stephen Colbert or Jimmy Kimmel,

0:00:07or who have you, Alan degenerate, how did how the hell

0:00:11do they do a show every day? Because I do one show. And it,

0:00:15you know, it in our world, it's kind of a big deal. It is a

0:00:18beautiful theater. It's 1100 people, I feel an immense amount

0:00:23of pressure. And then I do it. And it goes off. And then I feel

0:00:27like that's it for the month. Like, I don't understand how these people come back and

0:00:33then they're like, "Well, tomorrow I'll do the same thing."

0:00:35So, one thing is they've got a big staff and the staff helps them prepare and do some of

0:00:40the strain that maybe you and Amy have to do for this. And I don't know, does Kifasas

0:00:45do anything but just sort of smile and then read the intro?

0:00:48Ah, you know what I mean? Like, if there's anything that slips through Amy's fingers,

0:00:51he's there for it.

0:00:52Right, he's there to catch it. So, that's part of it. I think also, and I remember listening

0:00:56to Letterman talk about this. It's like being a long-distance runner, or being a runner.

0:01:02You build up some strength, but if you do it every day, you get those muscles and you're

0:01:09able to pace yourself. That said, I also got the impression, especially from Letterman,

0:01:13that after doing four days, five shows in four days, because they would require a fifth

0:01:18show, so they only work four days, that he was kind of destroyed for the weekend, that

0:01:22that was part of it was that.

0:01:24And yeah, and the other thing I think must be,

0:01:28and think back to like when you were doing

0:01:31your college newspaper, like there is something you,

0:01:34no pressure, John, but like if you say something dumb

0:01:39and Phil Schiller says something and you walk off stage

0:01:42at the end of the talk show live and you're like,

0:01:44oh, what did I do?

0:01:46You gotta live with it for a year.

0:01:48And Letterman or Colbert or Jimmy Kimmel or whoever,

0:01:51They have a bad show.

0:01:52Guess what? There's no show tomorrow.

0:01:54It's like a baseball player, right?

0:01:55There's like, there's so many games.

0:01:56You have a bad game, just there's another game tomorrow.

0:01:59Just, and I think that there's some truth in that too,

0:02:02that it's all, the whole year is magnified on that one show.

0:02:05No pressure. Forget what I said now in a year.

0:02:08- Yeah, exactly.

0:02:11- So I have that too.

0:02:12You know, I've had two podcast interviews

0:02:14with Apple employees set up by Apple PR

0:02:16in the last three months.

0:02:16And it's definitely like, on one level,

0:02:20I interview people all the time.

0:02:21and on another one it's like, "Boy, they're taking a chance, I'm taking a chance, I better

0:02:25not screw this up." It's true, it's true. And then you're kind of destroyed afterward

0:02:30where it's just like, "Oh my God." And hard to tell whether you did a good job or not,

0:02:35honestly, because I think you and I are similar in this way. You're so self-critical that

0:02:39you're always thinking like, "I could have done this differently, why did that go that

0:02:43way, I didn't expect this," and you completely lose perspective. So when people say, "It

0:02:46was a great show," you just have to say, "Thank you," because I don't know, it could be, "This

0:02:51The first time and I forget how many years I've been doing it. There was the moment cable Sasser at 111 minute

0:02:58Were you there for that one? Yeah first ever live talk show that was and then

0:03:03And then I I think I had the ATP guys on

0:03:07At

0:03:10mezzanine right and then the third year was Schiller and which is crazy to me I think right unless I'm missing something that

0:03:16Already by the third year of the live talk show was the famous

0:03:20I shit you not, Phil Schiller introduction, which was amazing. Yeah, I think that's right.

0:03:30And then next year was Schiller and Federighi. I'm going to draw a blank here. Maybe it was

0:03:38Schiller and Federighi three years ago? I don't know.

0:03:41No, didn't you have like Jaws at one point in there?

0:03:44Well, Jaws was last year. Jaws and Mike Rockwell were last year.

0:03:49But Schiller and Federighi made a comeback together the first year at San Jose at the

0:03:55California Theatre.

0:03:56Yeah, that sounds right.

0:03:57Right.

0:03:58Yeah.

0:03:59Which is funny, every time you mentioned the California Theatre, you mentioned those Apple

0:04:01events and I remember those so well.

0:04:04The last one with Scott Forstall where he was around but not on stage because he was

0:04:09being fired in the process of being fired.

0:04:11He was a week away from being fired.

0:04:12I remember that.

0:04:13I saw him.

0:04:14He was talking to Dr. Wave from Pixar out in the hallway.

0:04:18And literally the whole conversation as I walked by was, "Did you see Prometheus?

0:04:22Yes, it sucked.

0:04:23Yes."

0:04:24And then I was just like, "Okay, that was a weird…"

0:04:27And then Force Club was gone after that.

0:04:28He's out of there.

0:04:30And the iPod photo was in that theater, too.

0:04:32I remember with U2.

0:04:34So that's a great venue.

0:04:36It was good enough for Steve Jobs.

0:04:37It was good enough for the talk show.

0:04:39It's amazing.

0:04:41And then in the workup to the show, I'm like, "Why do I ever do this?

0:04:46This is the last year I'm ever doing this.

0:04:47and they were doing this again.

0:04:48I don't care how popular this is.

0:04:49I don't care.

0:04:50I'm just gonna bag. - It's not worth it.

0:04:52- Then I do the show and it comes off okay

0:04:55and I go backstage and it seemed like,

0:04:58I was like, this year I really felt like,

0:04:59hey, that might've been the best one I ever did.

0:05:01I might've been the most comfortable.

0:05:03It might've been the funniest.

0:05:04And I'm like, why don't I do this all the time?

0:05:07I should come out here once a month and do one of these.

0:05:09- Yeah, I think so.

0:05:12I mean, even though it's only once a year,

0:05:14I do think that anything you repeat, you get better, ideally,

0:05:18and you have definitely gotten better.

0:05:19Not to say you were bad before,

0:05:20but I do think you're less visibly nervous

0:05:23than you were at the beginning.

0:05:24- It feels that way.

0:05:25It absolutely feels that way.

0:05:27And I don't, anyway, again, I think what you should do is,

0:05:29you know, do it like 52 times a year or something like that,

0:05:32and then you get really good.

0:05:33Doing it once a year probably isn't the best way

0:05:36to build up muscle memory,

0:05:37but yet somehow it feels like I have.

0:05:40I do feel that way.

0:05:42- Yeah, no, I think there's some shorthand there

0:05:43where you're realizing like, oh, I already, you know,

0:05:45you process it and like, this is how I do this part of it.

0:05:47And then you just put that to the side

0:05:49and it lets you focus on the rest

0:05:50and get a little bit better.

0:05:51I had an email the other week from somebody who said,

0:05:54I love these people.

0:05:55They're the best.

0:05:56These are all like the disciples of John Siracusa.

0:05:57They're like, hey, I finally found the incomparable.

0:06:01And so I started listening from the first episode.

0:06:04I'm like, what are you doing?

0:06:06There's 460 plus episodes of this show.

0:06:09It's been on since 2010.

0:06:10What are you doing?

0:06:11- It's like a thousand hours.

0:06:12A thousand hours of audio. But what the email said was, and I've listened

0:06:17to the whole thing, okay, amazing, you've gotten a lot better as a host since 2010.

0:06:22And my response was, thank you, I can't believe you listened to all those episodes, that really

0:06:25wasn't necessary. And I would hope that after a thousand hours of hosting a podcast, I would

0:06:29at least get a little bit better. Right? Like, there's something really wrong. You should

0:06:33give up if you're not appreciably better at anything after you've been doing it every

0:06:38week for 10 years, right? Like, that's—we, as human beings, we should get better at things

0:06:43as we do them.

0:06:45We would hope so.

0:06:46It doesn't always happen, but yeah, try something else, maybe.

0:06:51We tweaked a few things at my live show this year. I don't know what was obvious. I mean,

0:06:55you've been to them, right?

0:06:57I've been to all of them. All of them.

0:06:59So we tweaked a couple of things this year, which—in the theater. And the big one was

0:07:07we moved forward on the stage. So at the California theater, it this, I don't know how much shows up on

0:07:14video. It's like when you're there, you can see it. And it's very palpable is that they have what

0:07:19they call an orchestra area, right at the front of the stage, and they can raise and lower that

0:07:25part of the stage. And in years past, we've kept it lower and done our staging on the main stage

0:07:34behind that. And then this year, it wasn't a conflict, but it was just a little bit of

0:07:42a back and forth negotiation. The day after my show, the San Francisco 49ers were holding

0:07:47something there. I don't know if that, how, if like people saw like 49ers in the area

0:07:53Wednesday or not, but, but they were holding a big event there. I don't even know what

0:07:57it was. Yeah. It's something I think involving their spring practices and I don't know whether

0:08:02was a team thing or a charity thing, but there was like they were they were around it was

0:08:06like when they fly the players in a couple months before their training camp. So yeah,

0:08:10they were around. So they there was some talk like two months before my show of hey, the

0:08:1949ers or at first they just said a client, there's another client who has an event the

0:08:24day after you. And they would like to do some setup the day before your day. You know, how

0:08:33long you know, what hours do you need the theater? What can they do? And maybe you might

0:08:38have to keep the curtains closed, etc, etc. And I was just like, at first, I was like,

0:08:43f you, you know, I mean, like, I'm, I'm paying rack rate for this theater for the day. I'm

0:08:48going to do whatever I want. But then I, you know, I, you know, I listened and I had an

0:08:52open mind. And I thought, Hey, wait a minute. Uh, if we close the curtains and moved forward,

0:08:58wouldn't that be a little bit more intimate? Wouldn't that, why haven't we done this

0:09:02ever since we've been there? And then like, I started looking at like, um, like when standup

0:09:08comedians play there and I'm not saying that my show is a standup comedy show, but it's closer,

0:09:13you know, in terms of what type of event it is, it's people with microphones trying to be

0:09:20entertaining and informative. Right. You know, with an intimacy with the crowd is like, why

0:09:25aren't we closer? And they were like, Oh, yeah, every time a stand up comedian plays

0:09:28here, they they raise the orchestra and play at the front of the stage. And I'm like, Why

0:09:31haven't I been doing that for two years? I think this actually isn't even like a concession

0:09:36to the people. You know, the 49ers having the event the day after this actually seems

0:09:40like a better way to stage this, we should be closer. And then the other change we made

0:09:44is we kept the house lights up a little bit higher this year. In years past, our perspective

0:09:50me and my guests on the stage is pretty much the audience is just black, just a complete blackout.

0:09:56And so we raised the lights sound. No, we raised the lights a little bit this year. And I don't

0:10:01know what you thought from the audience. But from the stage, it made a huge difference. But I

0:10:05specifically remember seeing you I, there was like a hand it was maybe the only thing that almost

0:10:11threw me off was that I was like, Hey, there's john circu said, taking pictures in the front row.

0:10:18I almost like every time I'd see like a friend I had and I you know had all these tickets in reserve for friends to put them in the front rows and and it was like at least three times in the opening five minutes I would be like hey there's my pal Jason that I should interrupt my

0:10:34Interrupt this opening monologue and say hi to him go shake some hands work the crowd. Yeah. Yeah, that's what a monologue is for

0:10:40Yeah, like hey, I see you over there. Yeah, I think it was fine

0:10:44line. You know, I think you don't want the lights too high out there because you feel

0:10:48almost like you're part of the show and you kind of overexposed a little bit. But, you

0:10:53know, what you did, that's a movie theater scenario, so it doesn't need to be complete

0:10:57darkness except for the stage. And it's funny, I was thinking about this because I went to

0:11:01the ATP and relay shows too, and I was briefly on stage for the relay show, which those are

0:11:06the Hammer Theater, which is on the San Jose State campus. It's a couple of blocks away.

0:11:09It's a good, great little venue.

0:11:11That was the venue that they used for the app documentary two years ago.

0:11:16Right, exactly.

0:11:17And now it's like podcasts all week long.

0:11:20Yeah, well, Marco and Casey and John went to the relay thing last year and they said,

0:11:25"Oh, this is good.

0:11:26We should do this."

0:11:27Because they were in the ballroom at Alt-Conf where everybody's on the same level and they've

0:11:31got a stage that's like six inches off the ground.

0:11:33It's a better venue.

0:11:34So standing in the wings, I'm literally waiting to go on and do my little cameo.

0:11:38I looked backstage where there's some there's some like audio equipment and stuff like that and a little video equipment that wasn't being used and

0:11:46And I had that moment where I looked and I was like, oh my god

0:11:50There's an enormous theater stage back here because of course there is

0:11:53But you know the used part was this very small front of the stage and I think it makes it yeah same reason

0:12:01It's more intimate. You don't have

0:12:04You know somebody on a horse riding by or something like that is happening. It's just it's just people talking into microphones

0:12:10So so get to the front of the stage and and I think it I think it works. I think it's great

0:12:14It is amazing. There was a did you see that article? There was an article in a German newspaper?

0:12:19That literally the whole article was basically like it was like a five-page long article on their website. It's a long article

0:12:25It was basically can you believe that people want to listen to?

0:12:32Basically dudes with microphones talking about computers. I thought I thought it was a great article. I really enjoyed it

0:12:39I really did and I wish it it it made me god. I wish I could speak and read

0:12:45Ten different languages. I'm so inept at

0:12:49Multiple languages I took four years of Spanish in high school and all I can do is order

0:12:55Amber Amber gay so's and

0:13:00- Cervezos. (laughs)

0:13:02- That's important stuff.

0:13:04- (speaks in foreign language)

0:13:06May I go to the bathroom?

0:13:07I don't even know how to ask where the bathroom is.

0:13:10(speaks in foreign language)

0:13:12I guess is where's the bathroom?

0:13:14- I took German in high school and college

0:13:15and yeah, it's a good article,

0:13:17but it is funny that the premise,

0:13:19stepping outside our bubble for a moment,

0:13:20the premise is did you know

0:13:24that there are all these podcasts about Apple?

0:13:26(laughs)

0:13:27It's like, and it is weird, right?

0:13:29think that people are going into big theaters to sit and watch a podcast, which is fundamentally

0:13:34not a visual medium live on stage all week, but we do. Yeah. And you know, and I thought,

0:13:40I thought it was a fascinating article and I really, you know, I don't know what nuance

0:13:44I missed by reading it through Google translate, although I'm blown away by how good Google

0:13:49translate has gotten. It's truly, truly one of the technical marvels of the world. It

0:13:56It really is.

0:13:57And I probably get a rep as somebody who's anti-Google

0:14:01on the whole, in the tech world.

0:14:05I have to say, I've always thought Google web search

0:14:08is truly just a marvel of the world.

0:14:11Like seriously, like if like Thomas Jefferson

0:14:14or Ben Franklin time traveled to today,

0:14:16what would you show them?

0:14:17How would you ease them into the modern world?

0:14:20Wouldn't Google search be one of the first things

0:14:22you show them?

0:14:23Just open up a computer or an iPad,

0:14:26an iPad really if you really want to wow them single window one field show them how you can

0:14:31search for stuff. Google Translate is absolutely astounding. It's truly amazing. It's it. I feel

0:14:38like in the next five or 10 years we're going to get to the point where you could literally read

0:14:41anything from anywhere in any language in your native language and it will be I mean already

0:14:46it's readable but I think there's only a matter of time you would think before it's they've used

0:14:51machine learning to scour every word, every sentence, every construction in English ever

0:14:55and in German ever. And we'll be able to just basically be it maybe never as artful as a

0:15:02human translator, but like for web articles, nobody else is going to translate them. And

0:15:06if they're completely readable, that's miraculous, right? That's amazing. The article on these

0:15:12live podcasts, and it started with the sort of a you are there, you're in the line for

0:15:17my show, but he talked about all the other live shows that happened during the week at

0:15:22WDC. But it was funny because there was like a little, if you want to call it a translato,

0:15:27you know, a translation typo. It was like the snake winds around the block. And what

0:15:35he meant was, I guess, I guess it somehow, my interpretation of how this got misinterpreted

0:15:42was that in German it said something like the Q snakes around the block.

0:15:47And somehow though the line for my show turned into a snake. And Paul Kefas is the announcer of

0:15:57the show and my wife. We were on a group chat when the article came out. We all agreed that from now

0:16:02on any sort of Q is a snake. Yeah, it's literally German uses a word for snake to mean Q. So in

0:16:12instead or line. So instead of a line winding around, they say it's a,

0:16:15a snake is a line as a snake. So it,

0:16:18and that's one of those things that's interesting where Google translate didn't

0:16:22get like dish longer Vindit.

0:16:23It should be like your it's probably not a literally a snake

0:16:29winding around. It's probably a line, but it didn't do that.

0:16:33But it was a great article. It was,

0:16:36and I think it's interesting cause I do think there's something true to that.

0:16:40And the gist of the article in the bigger term was that Apple listens to

0:16:45podcasts, popular Apple podcasts, and you know,

0:16:48they don't respond on a weekly basis, but they, they clearly do listen.

0:16:52Uh,

0:16:54and I thought it was extraordinary and so delightful how much access the,

0:16:59the Apple podcasts sphere got during WWDC.

0:17:07I mean, just off the top of my head. Federico interviewed Craig Federighi on Tuesday. You

0:17:17had an interview with Wiley Hodges and Josh, and I always forget Josh's surname.

0:17:23It's Shaffer because it's spelled like Paul Shaffer, but it's not pronounced like that.

0:17:27See, I get mixed up. But Wiley Hodges and Josh Shaffer, which I just want to just full stop,

0:17:34Interrupt my show and say that upgrade episode. I think it's 249

0:17:39Because one of the things I wanted to talk about is that you guys you guys are gonna lap me on

0:17:44Episode numbers very shortly because this is you and I are talking right now in the midst of episode

0:17:49255 good number of my shot

0:17:52Yeah, we're almost

0:18:01Absolutely the best layperson

0:18:04overview of Swift UI

0:18:07written audio otherwise of any anything I've seen since

0:18:12WWDC episode 240 the whole episode people should listen to nobody should skip around but if you were gonna skip around I would skip around

0:18:20to the part where Jason interviews

0:18:22Wiley Hodges who's a product manager in the dev tools team and

0:18:26Josh Schaffer who you know

0:18:30you know, his baby. Yeah, won't say nobody takes credit for it. They're an apple. It's

0:18:35apples thing, but effectively Swift UI is his thing. And it is absolutely phenomenal

0:18:43overview and answer so many questions. Every single question I had, even questions that

0:18:49I didn't think to ask while I was with these guys in WWDC in San Jose, I was like, Oh,

0:18:54I hope Jason asks by and every single one that popped into my head, you would ask within

0:18:5830 seconds of me thinking of it during this podcast. It's one of the best interviews I've seen.

0:19:03Not a wasted question. Such a great overview. I appreciate that because I came out of it feeling

0:19:08sort of the way that I described earlier, which is, was that good or was that a disaster? I don't

0:19:12know. And then because those guys, what's funny is like Craig Federighi, by the way, he's kind of a

0:19:18unicorn because he is a deeply technical guy, but he also like totally gets and, and, you know,

0:19:24Schiller is like this, but Schiller's not like a super technical guy. He is a marketing

0:19:28guy. But Craig is, like, you always feel it when he's walking around at WWDC. He's one

0:19:34of us. He is a computer nerd. He is a developer. He's got cred in that area, but he also has

0:19:41really blossomed as a spokesperson. And he straddles that line in a way that is, I call

0:19:47him a unicorn because it's hard to find people who can communicate. As somebody who was a

0:19:52magazine editor. So hard to find people who know the technical stuff and can communicate it well,

0:19:56and Craig does it amazingly well. And these guys are lower down in terms of the details of this

0:20:04tech stuff, but they also don't get out to communicate to the public a lot. And so that

0:20:09was the challenge. I was telling you earlier before we started, there were a couple moments

0:20:14where I'd ask a question and they'd look at each other and I'm like, "Uh-oh, what did I do?"

0:20:20because I think it wasn't a problem with my question.

0:20:23It was that they don't have the internal map,

0:20:26maybe as much at hand as Craig does about what,

0:20:30how you answer a question, what you say,

0:20:32what you're allowed to say that won't get you in trouble.

0:20:35And they were like thinking about it a little bit.

0:20:38And that's what I really noticed about it

0:20:39versus your interview with Craig,

0:20:41where Craig is just like, I mean, he's super smooth.

0:20:44And also he's got somebody next to him who's in marketing

0:20:46who can pull the chain if he says something he shouldn't.

0:20:49He was on fire on my show. He was. He was just absolutely on fire. Um,

0:20:53you're right. You're right. And, and I,

0:20:56part of it with Phil Schiller is not,

0:20:59I don't think it's so much that Phil Schiller can't speak to the technical

0:21:02details.

0:21:03He almost certainly doesn't understand the software to a deep technical level

0:21:08like Federighi does just because it's Federighi's job.

0:21:11He's the head of software. But I think, uh, I think overall though,

0:21:16Schiller, even when he's being relaxed and he's in a, "Hey, I'm going to do this podcast,"

0:21:23you know, like he was on ATP a couple months ago, he still doesn't want to break that seal.

0:21:30He's so old-school Apple that he really doesn't want to break the seal on how the magic is

0:21:35done, you know?

0:21:36Yep. Yeah, it's true. And this is something we witness when we talk to these guys. And

0:21:43I should mention, I said "guys" there, I should mention that one of the people that

0:21:46I got to talk to this year for upgrade was Colleen Novielli, who ended up on stage at

0:21:51WWDC. And I definitely got the sense like that that this was one of the that our interview

0:21:57was kind of like getting her feet wet in being doing public communication and that and then

0:22:03she's on stage and I'm like, oh, and it was funny because a lot of people are like, hey,

0:22:07we know her and it's because her voice was on a podcast. And I think that Apple that's

0:22:11That's why we had so many podcast interviews at dub dub this year is because they tried

0:22:17it out with Renee Richie and then they tried it out with with me and they've been doing

0:22:20these on stage interviews to with you and I think they finally were like this is great

0:22:25let's just go all in and so there were like a dozen different podcast interviews and that

0:22:32was great to see too. Yeah so Colleen was the woman who introduced the pro display XDR

0:22:40stage. She was the one who clicked that button to get past the 999 stand as quickly as possible.

0:22:46But she's also, you know, if you're a close attention payer, you would know that she's also

0:22:55the product manager for, is it the iMac Pro or the iMac as a whole? iMac and iMac Pro.

0:23:04and absolutely knocked it out of the park. Kind of, you know, we can get into this, I

0:23:10think, on the, like the price of the Pro Display XDR kind of had a tough, that's a tough thing

0:23:17to pitch because you've got this amazing, amazing product and it's sort of a shit sandwich

0:23:23when it comes down to how much it costs, et cetera.

0:23:25And your audience for that product is not in the room, right? Like the developers primed

0:23:30for a monitor that developers would want. If she was at NAB or something doing that

0:23:36presentation...

0:23:37People would have stormed the stage, right?

0:23:38They would have been falling down, faint in the aisles.

0:23:40Yeah, they would have run down the aisles and lifted her up on her shoulders like Vince

0:23:44Lombardi after the Super Bowl 2 and taken her off the stage, right?

0:23:48Yeah.

0:23:49Absolutely. And it would have been because the price was so low. They'd be like, "Oh

0:23:53my God, I might get one of these on my desk."

0:23:55Yeah, it's a $30,000 monitor for $6,000. This is amazing. Whereas everybody else is like,

0:23:59charging what huh so we can hold that thought but that was amazing and she was

0:24:05great and then she also did the there were a lot of behind-the-scenes

0:24:12briefings off-the-record briefings for members of the media yeah and I again

0:24:18this sounds like looking a gift horse in the mouth to say that there were too

0:24:23many but I had too many and again this I'd rather have too many than not enough

0:24:29It is an absolute privilege this when I got into this racket, you know

0:24:3320 years ago or started thinking about it, you know

0:24:37This is where I wanted to be and Mike this is where you want to be if you cover Apple as

0:24:41as a career you would like to be in the circle where when

0:24:45WWDC the Apple has

0:24:48Behind the scenes off-the-record press briefings you'd like to be invited to them

0:24:51Yep, I'm there and it's happy I was happy to be there but boy there were a lot but part of and I don't blame them

0:24:58You know, and it was not like a, it was absolutely not like a shotgun approach. Like, here's

0:25:04all this stuff and you figure it out. It was simply because they had so much to announce

0:25:09this year. I think in hindsight, now that WWDC has settled in, everybody's immediate

0:25:16impression that, "Holy crap, they did a lot this year and announced a lot this year,"

0:25:20exactly spot on and it wasn't just our excitement over the first day or two and sort of, you

0:25:30know, every year it seems like a lot, but it just seemed like this year it truly was

0:25:35more than usual. There really was a lot that they couldn't fit in the keynote.

0:25:39I feel like it was, and you know what they do of course, because they ask you, like they

0:25:43ask me, whenever you see an Apple person afterward in one of those briefings, they say, "What

0:25:46did you think of the keynote?" And you're like, "Oh man, now you're asking me to review

0:25:49your thing that you just did. And what I said this time was, I think that might be the most

0:25:54dense Apple presentation, keynote presentation I've ever seen. Just content-dense. There

0:26:00have been more earth-shattering things like the iPhone launch. I mean, there are lots

0:26:03of those. But in terms of just content density, like, we have spent the last two years-ish,

0:26:10year and a half, how long ago was Gherman's first Marzipan report, talking about the implications

0:26:16of Marzipan?

0:26:17- At least a year and a half ago, yeah.

0:26:19- The implications of Marzipan for Mac OS.

0:26:21And did they give it even five minutes on stage?

0:26:25And they're off to the next thing?

0:26:26It was like, I had that moment,

0:26:27I'm like, whoa, wait a second.

0:26:29That was Marzipan and it's gone.

0:26:32Catalyst is just like, here it is.

0:26:34And we can't wait to see what you do with it.

0:26:36Onto the next thing, we're gonna do Swift UI now.

0:26:39And that was that thing, it was just super dense.

0:26:43And that's why we all had like,

0:26:45I don't know how it worked for you.

0:26:46there's a little inside baseball,

0:26:47but I got a little email from an Apple PR person saying,

0:26:50"Well, here's what we've got you doing."

0:26:51And there were like eight things on it.

0:26:53And there was like a briefing and a demo

0:26:55and another briefing and another demo.

0:26:56Didn't even say what the briefings are,

0:26:58'cause of course they're secret.

0:26:59And I just thought, what?

0:27:00You know, like, well, they're filling my schedule.

0:27:03It's like I'm at a conference or something

0:27:06where that's not WWDC, I'm like at the Apple conference

0:27:10that they are slotting me in all these slots.

0:27:12But it's not like they didn't have stuff

0:27:14to talk about to all of us.

0:27:15There was they were really deconstructing those two hours for the rest of the week. Did you get the

0:27:20privacy

0:27:22briefing I

0:27:23Don't know if I got that one. Yeah, I don't know if I got that one

0:27:26I feel like that one might have been a shorter

0:27:28I don't know why it just seems like a lot of the people I talked to didn't get it

0:27:32But there was so much privacy and security stuff that and in theory all of it

0:27:39Everything they told me could have been in the keynote because it's it's all useful. It's all

0:27:44all very pertinent to the daily life of people using these platforms. And it's, of course,

0:27:52strongly aligned with Apple's recent public push to emphasize their privacy and security

0:28:01angle. And yet, none of it made the keynote. Yeah. It was insane. Yeah, there's a little

0:28:07in State of the Union. And then there were a bunch of sessions I went to, like, because

0:28:11the depth of like, even in Mac OS, you know, we focus on iOS so much, but like even in

0:28:15Mac OS, there are so many security and privacy things that they've done to lock down certain

0:28:21things but also allow apps to open up other things. And like it's very clear that at some

0:28:27point, and I would love to know the backstory on this, at some point, the directive came

0:28:31down from the top that said, we're going to impose some discipline on product design and

0:28:37also product communication, where everything has a security and privacy story. Like you

0:28:43can't have a feature or a product at Apple, you can't present it on stage, you can't

0:28:48formulate it without telling the story of how this is secure and how this makes sure

0:28:54that your information stays private. And the discipline has been very impressive. Like

0:28:58in the last two years, not a thing gets announced without security and privacy being mentioned.

0:29:03- Yeah, I totally agree.

0:29:05It's very impressive to me

0:29:12how much stuff they had to announce.

0:29:13It's just crazy.

0:29:15I know it's closer to the end of the month

0:29:18than the beginning of the month,

0:29:19and I still feel like I'm not done processing everything.

0:29:22- Yeah, I came out of it in like a haze for,

0:29:25I mean, I was watching videos after the week was over

0:29:27to catch up on the sessions that I missed

0:29:29because I was in briefings instead of in sessions,

0:29:32because you can only be in one place.

0:29:33And it is, even now, like somebody pops up with something,

0:29:36they're like, "Oh, did you see that this thing

0:29:38got announced in this session?"

0:29:41And it's like, "No, I had no idea."

0:29:42And it's amazing how much they held back.

0:29:47And I think the truth is, one of the reasons it's like this

0:29:51is because a lot of stuff has been on the boil

0:29:54for years in the background.

0:29:57And then this is the year where they just released

0:30:00so much of it openly.

0:30:01So this is not like the here's what we've been working on the last year.

0:30:04This is like some of this stuff we have been working on for five years and now

0:30:07you get to see it. Yeah. I,

0:30:09I sort of have that feeling too that it's not necessarily indicative that every,

0:30:14every June is going to be this much of a bonanza of news.

0:30:18I think there's a little bit of that where I do feel like institutionally

0:30:23they've gotten better at, uh,

0:30:26as we've all said for a long time,

0:30:30probably ever since the iPhone came out,

0:30:32that they're getting better at walking and chewing gum

0:30:34at the same time, doing two things.

0:30:35Ever since that first iPhone came out

0:30:37and they had to announce that the major Mac OS version

0:30:40was gonna be postponed six months

0:30:42because they had to pull engineers to finish iOS 1.0,

0:30:46there's always been a sort of,

0:30:50I don't even think it's unfair.

0:30:53I think it's a little unfair

0:30:55in so far as we don't know the backstory

0:30:57because they're so secretive,

0:30:58But from the outside, it's kind of fair to say that Apple has really only been good at

0:31:06doing one thing at a time.

0:31:07No matter how big the company's gotten, how wealthy they've gotten their profits, they've

0:31:13had trouble over the last 12 years keeping all of the platforms moving together year

0:31:18after year as opposed to just moving the iPhone OS forward.

0:31:22forward.

0:31:23I mean, who has succeeded at maintaining two separate user software platforms at all? Like,

0:31:28Microsoft didn't do it. Yeah, and I think you can use that lens to look at Catalyst

0:31:34and SwiftUI and all the stuff that they only talked about briefly last year, but like under

0:31:39the hood, they've been trying to correct for all the drift that's happened over the last

0:31:43decade between—because iOS was based on macOS, but it's drifted, and now you want

0:31:47to bring the app platform back together, you gotta kind of have all the pieces be the same

0:31:51version and react the same way. And they, you know, a lot of this is about Apple saying,

0:31:56we can't maintain these two completely separate platforms. We just can't do it. So yeah. And

0:32:01I, so it's almost like it's unfair to say they should have been doing better, but I

0:32:05do, I feel like maybe they are, I, this was the year to me where they really showed that

0:32:10they could move everything forward in an interesting way. And I think Swift UI is a big part of

0:32:16because it was conceived apparently originally

0:32:21for the watch, but then they were like,

0:32:23this would work everywhere.

0:32:25And right now, this summer with the developer betas,

0:32:30you can use Swift UI on every single shipping

0:32:33Apple platform, TV, watch, iPhone, iPad, Mac.

0:32:38That's amazing.

0:32:40And it's very different from the way stuff has rolled out

0:32:44in previous years, where usually,

0:32:46you know, whatever platform it was meant for first would ship first and then other things

0:32:50would come a year later, maybe two years later. Swift UI debuting on all the platforms right

0:32:57from the get go is, is a huge deal and, and beyond Swift UI itself, which I think is really

0:33:06interesting, really appley technology. I think the fact that it's shipping on all their platforms

0:33:12at first is one of the biggest stories of the month.

0:33:16It also prevents kind of a platform, I don't know, like a not invented here effect that

0:33:25you would get otherwise. Like if this was, if this was, and I'm not saying this is right,

0:33:30I'm just saying this is what would happen. If they came out and said, here's a great

0:33:32new way to write watch apps. And then a year later they said, it turns out you can write

0:33:36Mac apps with this too. Or iPad apps. Mac and iPad people will be like, what? You want

0:33:41us to have watch apps now? Why are you doing this to our platform?" Instead, they're like,

0:33:45"No, no, no. It's for everybody from the get-go." And it defuses a lot of arguments about, like,

0:33:51was this originally supposed to be for my platform and now you're – or for that platform,

0:33:56you're importing it into mine. It's just like, no, it's for everybody from the beginning,

0:34:00and those arguments just don't happen. And I think that's – and you can all mix and

0:34:03match, which is something that I talked about with Josh and Wiley, right? That this is not

0:34:07one of those things where it's like, "Well, if you want to build a new app, you can build

0:34:11it in this, but your old app, too bad." It's like, no, you could literally, you can build

0:34:15a Mac app for Catalina that is using Swift UI and Interface Builder that's written in

0:34:22Objective-C, that's written in Swift, that uses UIKit as well as AppKit. You could literally

0:34:31put all these different technologies, some stuff from iOS, some stuff from Mac, the new

0:34:36stuff, in a single Mac app, and it'll just work. Like, that's the kind of amazing thing

0:34:40here is they're not making you choose. You can actually mix and match this stuff if you

0:34:44want to as a developer.

0:34:45There's, you know, the more things change, the more they stay the same as the saying

0:34:53goes. It's different, but in some ways it is philosophically exactly the mentality that

0:35:01Apple has had ever since the next acquisition and or as I call it, like to call it the reunification.

0:35:08Um, it, you know, this, this, uh,

0:35:13this way and you emphasized it on upgrade.

0:35:16I think when you were talking with Wiley and Josh,

0:35:19like BB edit as an example of an app that has been in active development since I

0:35:24think like 1991, 1990, 1991,

0:35:30at least publicly 1992 was when rich released it and it's never really had a,

0:35:35it's never really had a, okay, throw everything out.

0:35:40We have to do it all over from scratch.

0:35:42It has always been, okay, let's rewrite this part.

0:35:45Let's rewrite this part.

0:35:47Let's rewrite, let's redo these dialogue boxes

0:35:52to make them use the modern UI toolkit

0:35:56so that we can keep going.

0:35:57And now all of a sudden here we are in 2019

0:36:00and the app is 64-bit.

0:36:02It's a 64-bit Cocoa app that never once got rewritten from being a 32-bit, pre-carbon

0:36:11classic Mac OS app in 1992.

0:36:15And in my Macworld piece last week where I referenced your classic, like, 2010, talk

0:36:19about 10 years ago, piece, I call it the apotheseus, where it's like literally like you replace

0:36:25every part of the ship as it's still the same ship.

0:36:28And like, BBS is like that.

0:36:29Like Rich Segal has replaced every part of that app, but he'd ever had a schism, I

0:36:34feel, where it just, "Oh, old BB Edit is gone and here's new BB Edit."

0:36:38He's just kept replacing the pieces, and that so reflects on how Apple does this, where

0:36:42they roll this stuff through.

0:36:43And as you said, it's that constant iteration.

0:36:47And you wrote about that in 2010.

0:36:48It was already clear that that's Apple's whole stock and trade is you make some leaps,

0:36:52but really the key is that you then just keep pushing and keep iterating.

0:36:57And you end up with these transitions that what my piece is about is like it's the invisible

0:37:02transition strategy is like there's no Swift UI schism. What's going to happen is we're

0:37:06going to sit around using our apps and in five years those apps are all going to be

0:37:09like written in Swift and built with Swift UI. But we're not going to notice in a lot

0:37:13of cases because it's just going to happen in the background. The developers will put

0:37:16in the work but for us it's just like I'm just using my Apple stuff and it works and

0:37:20that is how it should be. Yeah it's exactly right and you know so you can take an app

0:37:25Like you said, it's written in Objective-C, has been around on the iPhone for 10 years

0:37:30already, and you have a new feature you want to add, one new feature.

0:37:36You could do just that feature, that view in SwiftUI, and just introduce SwiftUI into

0:37:42this 10-year-old app for one view, and that'll be fine.

0:37:49And the user won't know.

0:37:50It won't be like, "Oh, all of a sudden when I go into this feature, everything looks different."

0:37:53you know, it's just a very Apple-like way of introducing something that is truly, truly

0:38:02significant. If there's one thing, and it's not a complaint, because I don't know what else Apple

0:38:06could do, is I do feel that the nature of their public keynotes and the WWDC keynote, to me,

0:38:16it's the most fun event of the year, because you never know what you're going to get, right?

0:38:21September, probably September 7th or so, I don't know what day of the week it is, but

0:38:26you and I are probably going to be standing around outside the Steve Jobs theater on some

0:38:30Tuesday within, you know, nine days of the beginning of September.

0:38:34Yeah, it'd be like the 10th of September this year is a Tuesday, so probably, let's say

0:38:38that. I'll see you there.

0:38:40Yeah, maybe I should book an air flight right now, book my plane, because that's probably

0:38:45it, because they're not going to do it on the 3rd because it's too close to Memorial

0:38:48day. And we know what we're going to get. We're going to get new iPhones, and they're

0:38:53going to tell us, you know, whatever new features of iOS are optimized just for these new phones,

0:38:58probably camera features and stuff like that. I mean, that's cool. I always have a good

0:39:02time. It's like I said, I don't want to look at gift horse in the mouth. It is. I'm honored

0:39:07to be at this position in in this field to get invited to these things. But WWDC is more

0:39:13exciting because you don't know what you're going to get. Right? Like we know that September

0:39:17event is going to be about iPhones. And if there's an October event, we'll probably have a good idea

0:39:21of what it's about just from leaks. Is it new Mac books or something like that? WWDC, you just don't

0:39:28know. And this year to me was just like the canonical example of, wow, we got everything.

0:39:36I mean, you and Mike on upgrade do like the, what do you call it? Bingo? What do you guys have?

0:39:40Yeah, the draft. Yeah, the keynote draft where we take turns picking what's going to be set on

0:39:45But like everything hit this year. The score was 9 to 9. We had 10 picks each. It was 9

0:39:53to 9. We had to go to a tiebreaker. And even then, arguably, it was almost 10 to 9. But

0:39:59in the end, we decided that one of Mike's didn't make it. So yeah, which makes it a

0:40:02lot less interesting when sort of like, yeah, we got all these things right. But that's

0:40:08the funny thing is that big picture is not the details. And there are a lot of details

0:40:13missing this time. Because it's software, right? You get the big picture. Bart Gurman

0:40:18is talking to people who have a little bit of an idea of what's going on, and Guy Rambeau

0:40:23is digging through codes somewhere. But it's just code, right? It's just like framework

0:40:29decompilation. So what I always say is it's that parable of the blind men and the elephant,

0:40:34which is like they're touching this giant animal and they can't tell what it is, and

0:40:38one of them thinks it's a snake and one of them thinks it's a rhino. And it's like that,

0:40:42like we got the details, but what's the story? And with software, there's no supply chain

0:40:47to leak, and you end up with this, you know, it's much more kind of mysterious. And something

0:40:52like SwiftUI. So you, back in like a long time ago, there was this whole question about

0:40:57like what was Marzipan and what was SwiftUI? And you went back and forth with Germin about

0:41:01it a little bit because Germin was like, oh, Marzipan, you said, well, that's not what

0:41:04I'm hearing. I'm hearing it's this other thing. And that was Amber, right? Which turns out

0:41:07to be SwiftUI. So we knew something about it, but what we knew, especially about SwiftUI,

0:41:14was almost nothing, other than that it existed and maybe we'd see it sometime. That was it.

0:41:20I knew a little bit more.

0:41:21Well, I mean, what I mean "we," it's like the rest of us were on the outside looking

0:41:26at it.

0:41:27But I was given this information over a year ago on the condition that I not share it widely,

0:41:32and I agreed to that, and I didn't share it widely, and it wasn't me trying to be a Weisenheimer

0:41:37I it was the conditions under which I was told about it

0:41:41But the long story short is that Swift UI is a much bigger project than marzipan slash

0:41:49catalyst and way more people are involved and if you just think about I mean the fact that it is the UI framework for

0:41:56all of these platforms and

0:41:58They've already I forget how many frameworks they said that already includes

0:42:03It's like 40 of the frameworks from UI kit and app kit are already in Swift UI

0:42:07UI. The genius of this system is that for the ones that aren't in Swift UI as native

0:42:14Swift UI, they just call down to the underlying platform frameworks that are already in UI

0:42:20Kit and App Kit. You don't miss anything when you're writing an app in Swift UI, but a bunch

0:42:26of the stuff is already like it's not just a wrapper that calls down to UI Kit and App

0:42:32It's really, really a huge project.

0:42:35It is truly,

0:42:36what Federighi said when he introduced it,

0:42:41that this is sort of a once every 20 years,

0:42:4425 year generational change.

0:42:46I honestly don't think he oversold it at all.

0:42:49I really think it's that big of a deal.

0:42:50It is as big a deal as when Apple first said

0:42:53the future of the Mac is these next technologies,

0:42:58the next frameworks, CoCo, for writing apps.

0:43:02It's that big a deal.

0:43:03It's like the introduction of cocoa, in my opinion.

0:43:05- It's hard not to imagine that in five or 10 years,

0:43:11like anything can happen,

0:43:14but it seems that the plan is that most of the software

0:43:18written for Apple's platforms in the 2020s,

0:43:22you know, as the 2020s go on,

0:43:24is gonna be Swift and Swift UI.

0:43:28Like not everything, but maybe, and certainly not at first,

0:43:31but like this is their, you know, what, what Wiley said was,

0:43:36what is it?

0:43:38The future is great and also secret or something like that.

0:43:42He basically, basically it's like the,

0:43:44the struggle at Apple is you never want to talk about the

0:43:46future, but you also want to pump up this thing that you just

0:43:49announced and how important it is for the future.

0:43:51And that's the balance they have to strike. But yeah, I mean,

0:43:53that's the impression I get is they didn't do this, you know,

0:43:55for a lark. This is their,

0:43:57this is the future that they think unifies all their app

0:44:00platforms in terms of what you need to know, which is not the same as building one-size-fits-all

0:44:06apps, it's just in terms of what you need to know. Like, when we talk about AppKit and

0:44:10UIKit and iOS developers and Mac developers, the thing I keep trying to emphasize with

0:44:14people is, you know, it's not about, even Catalyst is not necessarily about like creating

0:44:21a one-size-fits-all app. Apple went up there and said, "Look, you check the box, you're

0:44:25not done. Then you need to make a good iPad app. Then you need to make a good Mac app."

0:44:29The issue with Mac development for iOS developers is they don't know how to do it because AppKit

0:44:34is not UIKit. They learn the other thing. And with SwiftUI, you learn the one thing

0:44:40and you know how to build stuff on all of Apple's platforms and that's better. You still

0:44:45want to build a good watch app, a good phone app, a good Mac app, but you don't need to

0:44:51learn a whole separate set of tools for each one and that's huge for developers and I'd

0:44:55imagine for everybody inside Apple too, who has to support these platforms?

0:44:59All right, hold that thought. I want to pick that up right after this message from our

0:45:05first sponsor, Away. I love this company. Away makes suitcases, and they've got two

0:45:11types now. The original with durable German polycarbonate, and now they have aluminum

0:45:18ones. I don't have an aluminum one. I've got the plastic one. They call it polycarbonate.

0:45:24But again, they've been sponsoring the show,

0:45:26I think for like four years, maybe even more.

0:45:29They sent me one when they first sponsored the show.

0:45:31I've taken it with me every single place I've gone

0:45:35for the last four years.

0:45:37Every airplane trip, every train trip to New York,

0:45:40every time I leave my house for more than a night,

0:45:43I take this suitcase.

0:45:44It still looks brand new.

0:45:46And it's not like I'm like babying it.

0:45:48And the wheels, super smooth like butter.

0:45:50I absolutely cannot believe how durable this suitcase is.

0:45:55And the carry-ons that they have,

0:45:58they have all three sizes, or actually four sizes,

0:46:01two sizes of carry-ons, like a regular carry-on,

0:46:04a bigger carry-on, the carry-ons all come

0:46:07with a TSA compliant ejectable battery.

0:46:10And when I say it's ejectable, it is so easy.

0:46:13You just click it down, it pops right out.

0:46:15Because the reason you want that is that

0:46:18if you have to check your bag,

0:46:20if it's your carry-on, you're hoping to put it over your head in the airplane. But they

0:46:24say, "Hey, the overheads are full. We're going to have to check these things." They tell

0:46:28you you can't have a battery in there. You just pop it right out. You keep it with you,

0:46:32put it in your pocket or put it in a seat, a little folder there in front of your seat.

0:46:37Pops right out. You don't need any tools, anything like that. Couldn't be better.

0:46:41But having a 5X, like a thing that can charge your battery five times right there in your

0:46:46suitcase is amazing because every single seat you could take at the airport, no matter where

0:46:51you go, you've got a charger right there. You don't have to look for like an outlet

0:46:54or something like that. And I'm it. There is no place in the world where you more need

0:47:01extra battery power than airport because every single airport I've ever been to just it's

0:47:06like you can just watch the battery on your phone just drain right down. Terrible. Love

0:47:10this feature of their suitcases. Everything else, what else? They've got TSA approved

0:47:17combination lock. They've got a great inside the suitcases. They have this patent-pending

0:47:23compression system. All that means is that they're sort of compartments and then you

0:47:27can put your shirts on the one side and then squeeze a thing down and cinch it up on top

0:47:31of it. Keeps your shirts from getting wrinkled. You can kind of pack more stuff in the suitcase

0:47:36by sort of squeezing stuff in there.

0:47:38Once you have it, it's very obvious how it works.

0:47:40It works great, keeps your shirts from getting wrinkled.

0:47:43Really, really love My Away Suitcase.

0:47:46Here's the deal, they've got a special offer

0:47:48for listeners of the show.

0:47:50Go to awaytravel.com/talkshow20.

0:47:54Awaytravel.com/talkshow20.

0:47:59The 20 is because you save 20 bucks off any suitcase.

0:48:03Just use that code TALKSHOW20 during checkout

0:48:06and you'll save 20 bucks on any suitcase.

0:48:10I cannot recommend this product enough.

0:48:11I would recommend it to people

0:48:13even if they weren't a sponsor.

0:48:14Love their products.

0:48:16My thanks to Away Travel.

0:48:17All right, so here's the thing that I was thinking about.

0:48:22To me, one of the most telling things about SwiftUI

0:48:24is the fact that it's the first native third-party API

0:48:29for the watch.

0:48:30And in fact, it's going to be the only native API

0:48:33for the watch.

0:48:34So up until now, third party developers

0:48:37have had to use quote unquote, watch kit.

0:48:40And it's not native.

0:48:42It's a weird hybrid sort of development thing.

0:48:46I've never really heard anybody,

0:48:48any of my developer friends say good things about it.

0:48:51And it's not what Apple itself uses

0:48:54to write the first party apps on the watch.

0:48:58And I kind of touched on this on my live show.

0:49:00I don't know, time is limited.

0:49:02But I really feel, and I've heard this

0:49:07from my developer friends over the years,

0:49:09that you can always tell which APIs Apple itself uses

0:49:13and which ones they don't.

0:49:14And it's just human nature.

0:49:16You can think, you can be altruistic and think,

0:49:19hey, we're not gonna use this API,

0:49:21but we want our third-party developers

0:49:23to have a great API for this.

0:49:24We don't need it 'cause we're gonna use

0:49:26this internal non-public API.

0:49:29But we'll do as good a job as we can on this public API.

0:49:34If they're not using it, it's just human nature.

0:49:38It just isn't as good as when Apple itself is using it.

0:49:42And I think it shows.

0:49:45I think it showed, I think for all of the popularity

0:49:49of the watch and the way that the watch

0:49:50has really blossomed in the four or five years

0:49:53since it debuted, the third-party app story

0:49:56has always been a sore spot.

0:49:58It was absolutely awful.

0:50:00I honestly shouldn't have shipped the first year.

0:50:02I'm sure there was some debate in the company

0:50:06as to whether they should have even shipped

0:50:08the original watch kit,

0:50:09given how slow watch apps were to load.

0:50:13So slow as to almost be unusable.

0:50:15- Well, and keep in mind at that point,

0:50:16they were just being run,

0:50:17like the watch was basically an external display.

0:50:19They were entirely run on the iPhone,

0:50:21which is a root decision that I understand,

0:50:23but it also, I feel like this is the moment

0:50:26Apple's like, "All right, we are still dealing with that decision." And it made all of these

0:50:32apps compromised. And so now we're over it. It's done.

0:50:35Yeah. And there were good technical reasons for it. The original watch was so technically

0:50:41at low battery life, it barely got through a day for most people. And that was with all

0:50:45of the native code being Apple's own code that they sweated over every single detail

0:50:51and every subroutine to make sure this isn't going to burn excess of battery life. We got

0:50:58to be as cautious as we can. I get it, but I think it's so interesting that there is

0:51:05never going to be an Objective-C interface to writing a native watch app for third-party

0:51:11developers. It's the first platform where it's Swift all the way. And the thing that

0:51:19Really popped into my head and again, it's it gets back to like what you said like with Wiley

0:51:24you know, they're not going to talk about the future but

0:51:27Implicit at this WWDC is whatever the next platforms are going to be from Apple whether it's like AR

0:51:34Glasses or a car or something, you know, there's all sorts of stuff, you know that they're rumored to be working on

0:51:40All of the anything that's coming from Apple in the future is going to be Swift UI

0:51:47both first party and third party.

0:51:49Yes, as soon as they can. And that they're,

0:51:52you know, when I asked Josh and Wiley that question, I was like,

0:51:54are people using this inside Apple? And they're like, well, some.

0:51:57And I definitely got the impression. I think they suggested

0:52:00the idea that some people were able to

0:52:02use it. The other people were not aware it

0:52:04existed yet and now would

0:52:06learn about it and be able to do it. But it's

0:52:09clearly, um, it's clearly where

0:52:11they're going. I had a question for you about SwiftUI

0:52:13and Catalyst, which is, you've been

0:52:15a very cranky guy on Twitter and on Daring Fireball about Catalyst. You've been skeptical.

0:52:20You're sort of like, "Are these going to be toy apps? Are these going to be bad apps?"

0:52:24And I'm more positive about it as somebody who really likes my iPad and my Mac. I look

0:52:29at it as this positive that there are apps that I would like to see on the Mac that aren't

0:52:33there now because they're iOS apps. And bringing those over and having them be good Mac apps

0:52:37makes my Mac better. That said, it's also very clear it's inevitable we're going to

0:52:42get some really lousy catalyst apps on the Mac, right? That's inevitable that somebody

0:52:47who doesn't get the platform is going to do a half-assed job and there's going to be bad

0:52:51Mac apps. But my question for you is, is your concern about catalyst, was it more motivated

0:53:00by the idea that in the end the only apps that Apple would really let anybody write

0:53:05on the Mac would be these catalyst things that were built for a platform that is very

0:53:10different from the Mac and that that would be the future of the Mac is just running kind

0:53:14of iOS imports versus like is that mitigated now by the existence of something like Swift

0:53:20UI where you say, "Oh, this is a transition technology. I don't need to be concerned about

0:53:25it taking over the Mac. It's just for compatibility and transitional stuff." And the future is

0:53:31this thing where the Mac isn't like an equal partner. It's one of the platforms and you

0:53:36you know, you can write apps. Am I? I'm trying to kind of like deconstruct your attitude

0:53:40toward these two things and why? Because I feel like you were really concerned that the

0:53:44back was going to get screwed up by being kind of like just full of catalyst imports.

0:53:48And now that's not a worry anymore because catalyst isn't the future. It's a bridge and

0:53:52Swift UI is the future.

0:53:53Trenton Larkin I think it's a great question. It's absolutely

0:53:57one of the top reasons I wanted to have you on this, this first post WWDC episode.

0:54:04I'm not so worried about, I'm very still, or remain to this moment, very skeptical about the

0:54:13utility of catalyst. And I don't think it's going to be a very good thing for the Mac. But I kind of

0:54:21also think it's almost like a non event. And I do feel like the one underlying mystery

0:54:30of this year's WWDC is the relationship between Swift UI and catalyst and inside Apple and

0:54:38what what their messaging is on it. And because they're clearly two entirely different products

0:54:46that were absolutely developed independently

0:54:50and neither one needs the other.

0:54:53But they also clearly overlap in very broad

0:54:57and obvious ways, which is, hey, if you wanna share

0:55:00a code base between iOS and macOS,

0:55:03this is a way to do that.

0:55:05- Right.

0:55:08- I think that we are definitely gonna see it.

0:55:13I think most apps that are ported over with Catalyst

0:55:16are gonna be bad, but I don't think that matters.

0:55:19In one way I look back at this is that

0:55:23I kinda got the whole App Store wrong,

0:55:26just going back to the original 2008 iOS App Store.

0:55:30I thought back in 2008 that Apple,

0:55:35during their review process,

0:55:37was going to be a lot more judgmental

0:55:42about the quality of apps

0:55:44and saying this isn't good enough

0:55:46and we're just gonna reject this

0:55:47'cause it's like amateur hour.

0:55:49- That didn't happen.

0:55:52- That didn't happen.

0:55:53I thought it would be more curated

0:55:56like their retail stores, right?

0:55:58Like so when you go into an Apple retail store,

0:56:01most of the stuff they sell is actually from Apple,

0:56:03but like when you go to the sides

0:56:06and you look at like the third party iPhone cases they sell

0:56:11and stuff like external hard drives,

0:56:13You can go in there and buy SSD drives and cables.

0:56:18And there's a bunch of stuff on the sides

0:56:20that are from third party companies.

0:56:22But it's all stuff that like you look at it

0:56:26and you think, oh yeah, this belongs in an Apple store.

0:56:28It's not like going to Amazon and shopping for stuff.

0:56:32And you can find anything and everything

0:56:34from any Chinese knockoff company that you can think of.

0:56:39I thought the App Store was gonna be more

0:56:41like the physical Apple retail stores curated

0:56:45and trying to keep only high quality apps in the store.

0:56:50And it obviously wasn't like that at all.

0:56:51It's pretty much if it works and does what you say it does

0:56:55and doesn't break any rules, then you're in.

0:56:58And maybe that's the better way.

0:57:00Maybe that's actually,

0:57:01if Apple were more strict about keeping out stuff

0:57:09that just was kept out just because the UI wasn't good,

0:57:13maybe we'd be having more discussions

0:57:14about antitrust sort of control over the store.

0:57:18- Almost need to allow side loading

0:57:20if they were that strict about it,

0:57:22because you could just completely arbitrarily

0:57:24knock software out of the store.

0:57:26One thing that surprised me is that apps that use Catalyst

0:57:31don't have to be in the Mac App Store.

0:57:32That surprised me.

0:57:33So it's open.

0:57:35They could say, "Nope, this is terrible."

0:57:38they won't, but they could do that and put it out of the Mac App Store.

0:57:42They just bad apps won't get featured, I think is what's going to happen.

0:57:45Right. And so, you know, basically I expect that there will be a ton of bad apps.

0:57:49I don't think it'll matter any worse than it has mattered for all these years

0:57:54that, uh, that there are tons of bad apps in the store.

0:57:57And I think most catalyst apps are going to be bad apps and you know,

0:58:01but somebody is going to make good ones and that's cool.

0:58:04So I don't know if you saw it, the guy who does fair, right,

0:58:06which is the app that I use on iPad to edit podcasts.

0:58:10- No, I did not see this.

0:58:10- He did a thread on Twitter about what his thoughts are.

0:58:13And, you know, it's like people are asking me

0:58:15and I will admit I went and looked

0:58:17'cause I was curious if he had talked about it.

0:58:20And, and Ferrite's a really good app.

0:58:22It's, honestly, I wanted it on the Mac

0:58:25because I think I would use it instead of Logic if I could,

0:58:28plus I would be able to edit on either platform

0:58:30and there's no way to take a Logic project

0:58:33and put it on a Mac and, or put it on an iPad

0:58:35to go back and forth. So I'm really interested in this. And what he said was, first off,

0:58:40he's got a lot of improvements on iOS to do for iOS 13, and he's going to focus on those

0:58:46first. And then after that, he's going to look at the Mac and Catalyst and find a way

0:58:52to do it. But he says, "I'm going to take my time and I want to do it right." And I

0:58:55think like, that's going to be a good Mac app when it comes out. And I want to wait.

0:58:59I don't want the lousy iOS port version. I want a really good Mac app so that I can just

0:59:05switch my podcast editing over to it. I think there will be apps like that. I think there

0:59:09will be developers like that who really care about it. And I'll just say, I think one thing

0:59:14that Catalyst, because Catalyst is a bridge technology. If you're writing something brand

0:59:17new you should probably try to do as much of it in Swift and SwiftUI as possible. But

0:59:21there's so much code that was written for iOS that could be repurposed. And the one

0:59:25area where I think it makes a lot of sense is going to be, you think about Apple combining

0:59:30the message of "make a good iPad app" and "make a good Mac app," it's the addressable

0:59:34market of iPad and Mac together is a better market than either of them separately. And

0:59:42so, Ferrite is a great example. This is an app that totally could have a market on the

0:59:48Mac, but he wrote it for iOS. So if he can take that and put it on the Mac, that's great.

0:59:54And I think there are, it's going to be a class of apps that are more pro-focused, more

0:59:59power user focused that are iOS apps that will be able to run on the Mac now and will

1:00:04be welcomed by Mac users who, you know, because it makes more financial sense for the developers

1:00:10to put in the work because they've radically increased the addressable size of the market

1:00:15by writing something that goes to both iPad and Mac. So I think that's the, for me that's

1:00:20the shining part of Catalyst, that and maybe some of the media apps just because like it

1:00:25kills me that I can do picture-in-picture on my iPad for Major League Baseball or for

1:00:30Netflix or for Xfinity for my cable streaming, and I can't do it on my Mac. I've got to

1:00:36open Chrome and turn on Flash and then just stick a window in the corner, and it's terrible.

1:00:41So if those media apps, you know, if this is what it takes for them to do picture-in-picture

1:00:46on the Mac, I'll take it. But I think it's those two kinds of apps that are going to

1:00:50be the ones that I want to see out of Catalyst.

1:00:53Yeah, and the other one that I think is going to be a win but I could be totally wrong and and and it's almost

1:00:58Irrelevant to my own personal usage is games and I feel like the game story could be huge

1:01:04And I know I don't think it's a complete

1:01:06coincidence I do feel like

1:01:09You said this about half an hour ago

1:01:11I think on the show where it was just like a bunch of a couple of multi-year projects that came together this year

1:01:17Right, right and and when you've got projects that maybe you're on a hey

1:01:22this is going to take three years. This might take four years before we can even get it to the shape

1:01:27where it's ready to be unveiled. And you have a couple of projects on these multi-year development

1:01:34before you even unveil it. It's just a matter of luck whether a bunch of them come out the same

1:01:42year or not, right? It's just the way that the math works out that, wow, here's a three-year

1:01:47project. Here's a four-year project. They're all ready in 2019. Here they are. Don't expect this

1:01:52much new stuff every year. It just doesn't work like that. I don't know, though, that

1:01:58it's a complete coincidence that in the year that they're pushing Apple Arcade as a new

1:02:04major service that this technology that could really open up a bunch of iOS games to the

1:02:10Mac is at the same time. I think that that's a major factor in the whole internal politics

1:02:18of his catalyst worthwhile. Swift UI to me is a no brainer. And when you hear Craig Federighi

1:02:26talk about it, it's clear that when he was shown it and he got it, he was like 100% on

1:02:33board. He was like, I'll go down guns a blazing to make sure this happens. He's like a bigger

1:02:41Swift UI enthusiast than Josh is, right? And Josh is the guy who made it. I think Catalyst

1:02:47was was more of a political battle. I just from what they say publicly and just what

1:02:53we know about it, I think because it's, you know, trade offs.

1:02:56It's, it's a bridging technology. It's not, it's not really that exciting. It is

1:03:00the solution to a major problem, which is Apple's biggest base of developers use Macs,

1:03:06but don't know how to write Mac apps. And they've got a huge amount of code that isn't

1:03:10existing. And even if you've got a new way to do apps that you're going to roll out,

1:03:15even the same year, what do they do with all their existing code? Because then you're like,

1:03:19"Hey, SwiftUI, but only the SwiftUI parts will work on the Mac. The rest of the work

1:03:22you did won't translate." It's not like Catalyst isn't going to evolve, but Catalyst is all

1:03:30about like, "We need to get this code base to be portable." And now it is. Great. And

1:03:36that's what it's for. And because, again, the Ferrite guy, he will, like BBEdit, he

1:03:41will probably over time, if that app still exists in 10 years, it will probably have

1:03:47been rewritten to use Swift and Swift UI probably like, yeah, yeah, let's say that. But in the

1:03:54short term, he's not going to rewrite it to bring it to the Mac. That's not going to happen.

1:03:57So catalyst is there for that.

1:03:59I, I only say this half joking, I think I wrote this at some point on during firewall,

1:04:04but effectively, it was almost as though catalyst was announced at WWDC and effectively deprecated

1:04:11later in the same keynote at WWDC. And that doesn't mean it don't use it, don't touch

1:04:16it, don't you know, that it won't be an important thing for the next few years. But it's clear,

1:04:21like you said, it's a bridging technology. We thought it was the future and it turns

1:04:24out it is a transitional technology and that Swift UI is the future and Swift and that's

1:04:31yeah, it that's why I think there is a strong argument that they that they really needed

1:04:36to announce these things for developers simultaneously because what you don't want is to give the

1:04:42developers this idea that what you really need to do is just start building iOS apps

1:04:47for the Mac. That's how you get to the Mac. They're like, "No, no, no. This is for your

1:04:51– basically, this is for your existing code. The new stuff, do it over here because this

1:04:57is the future for everything."

1:04:58All right, let me take a break. Thank our next sponsor, another long-time friend of

1:05:03the show are good friends at ero, e r o, ero gives you Wi Fi at your house and they do

1:05:10it in the best way with a mesh network. Instead of having one base station somewhere, maybe

1:05:17by your TV because that's where your cable boxes or something like that and then trying

1:05:21to saturate your whole house with a network from one device.

1:05:26Euro gives you multiple devices, some of them just tiny little like nightlights literally

1:05:31that optionally have a nightlight that you can just plug in a socket and control through

1:05:36the app and just have it show a little light to walk your foot way down the hallway or

1:05:41wherever you put it in your house. Absolutely a better way to do wifi in a house that's

1:05:49more than like one room. And they have also got the new product, Euro plus, which is a

1:05:55service and it's it it defend your network against security threats blocks

1:06:02malware you can configure it to block phishing attacks you can configure it per

1:06:07device so like you could say like your kids maybe their devices aren't allowed

1:06:12to access adult content stuff like that you can configure it all it sounds like

1:06:18oh boy that would be complicated you'd have to be like a network administrator

1:06:21You do it all through the app on your phone and in my opinion as much as I love Eros hardware

1:06:28their software is better than the hardware because it

1:06:31simplifies

1:06:34Wi-Fi network management to the level you want it to be simplified to while giving you the control that you would want

1:06:41I don't know why I have mine set up. I love it

1:06:44I like to have a notification every time a new new device joins my network and

1:06:49Like maybe my son has a friend come home after school

1:06:52Gives them the password to our Wi-Fi and I get a little notification that there's a new Apple iPhone that joined the network

1:06:58I like knowing that I don't know why I love it

1:07:01It's it but if you don't want to know stuff like that, you can configure it not to do it

1:07:05Eero plus even has content blocking so that you can do stuff like block ads right at the network level

1:07:13It's it's really great. They offer VPN protection if you want from encrypt dot me

1:07:18They have integrated when you have

1:07:21Hero plus you can even get password management from one password all best-of-breed software

1:07:27It really is a great product

1:07:30You're listening to me talk to Jason right now over in the ero network that I've had for years right here at my house

1:07:36and

1:07:39Everything you want all the WPA to encryption. They've got all these other talking points anything you want. That's like secure like that

1:07:44They've got it and they even offer great customer support

1:07:48I really doubt you need it. I've only had I think I had to call them once I forget where it was for

1:07:52but I did call them once like a year or two ago. Fantastic customer support. It took me like five

1:07:58minutes to get whatever it was. I don't even remember what it was. But for the most part,

1:08:01you don't even need it. But if you do need it, you can get a hold of a Wi Fi expert within 30

1:08:06seconds typically. And they'll talk you through everything you need to do. So honestly, I think

1:08:12it's a great product really, really like it. So never think about Wi Fi again, if you need a new

1:08:18Wi-Fi system at your house, you can get $100 off the Euro base unit and two beacons package

1:08:24That's a base station little thing about the size of an Apple TV

1:08:28And then the beacons are the little nightlight things you can plug in around your house that gives you three little devices

1:08:33Saturate your whole house if you need more or you need less

1:08:36fewer devices

1:08:39They'll talk you through it on the website

1:08:41But that that Euro base unit two beacons package with one year of Euro plus service

1:08:47You can get for $100 off by going to ero.com

1:08:51The talk show and just remember that code the talk show when you check out and you'll get that hundred dollars off the the

1:08:59That package my thanks to era

1:09:02You've got the era right I do there there my whole house now. I realized I put in this smart irrigation

1:09:09Controller and as I'm you know attaching it to the wall

1:09:13I thought, "Oh no, is there Wi-Fi over here?" But there is because there's an Eero beacon

1:09:17in my bedroom and it's right behind that. So yeah, I can sit in the backyard and do

1:09:21my stuff on my Wi-Fi.

1:09:22You were just talking about that on one of your podcasts, right?

1:09:25Yeah. I just never even thought about like, "Oh no, what if there's no Wi-Fi out here?"

1:09:29Because this is not a place where anybody goes. It's the side yard with the gravel and

1:09:34like the tool shed and stuff like that. And now this irrigation controller. But yeah,

1:09:39it gets it. It's not a problem.

1:09:41service. All right. Here's my thing about the Catalyst apps, though, is I have to say

1:09:48this. The apps that Apple is shipping using Catalyst, there's four that debuted last year

1:09:55at WWDC and they shipped as part of Mojave and they're still there in Catalina. News and Stocks,

1:10:03which are very similar apps. I don't even know. I bet they share a lot of code because the Stocks

1:10:09The podcast app is mostly, it shows you stock prices,

1:10:13but for the most part shows you business news.

1:10:17It's just like the business section of Apple News.

1:10:20Yeah.

1:10:21For the most part.

1:10:22News about stocks is what it is.

1:10:23Voice memos and home.

1:10:26And then there's a new one this year, the podcast app,

1:10:31which we can get to, but of those original four.

1:10:33And Find My is also a catalyst app.

1:10:36Okay, Find My is, all right.

1:10:38I

1:10:40I'm absolutely

1:10:43boggled that the original for marzipan apps were touched so

1:10:48Barely in in the intervening year because there were so many problems with it with them

1:10:54so many ways that they are just bad Mac apps and

1:10:58At some point in recent months. I just sort of gave up and I thought well

1:11:03I'll just shut up until I see what they ship at

1:11:05WWDC and

1:11:08If anything, they're worse.

1:11:11I mean, like the Apple News app, at some point,

1:11:14one of the complaints I had, I know other people had,

1:11:17was that there was no way to copy the original URL.

1:11:20So like, let's say you're reading a story

1:11:22from the Washington Post, and it's in Apple News.

1:11:25You can copy the apple.news URL

1:11:29and then paste it to somebody,

1:11:31and then if they're on an Apple device,

1:11:33it'll open in the Apple News app.

1:11:36But what I would wanna do is send them the original story

1:11:40at washingtonpost.com.

1:11:41And certainly what I would wanna do

1:11:43if I wanna link to it at Daring Fireball

1:11:45is link to that original story.

1:11:47- Sure.

1:11:48- On iOS, it was possible,

1:11:51it's always been possible to get those URLs.

1:11:53You could just say open in Safari

1:11:55and then it opens in Safari

1:11:56and then you have the original URL.

1:11:57On the Mac, you couldn't, which seems crazy.

1:12:00It seems like if either of the platforms

1:12:01was gonna have a more powerful nerdy,

1:12:05give me a different, you know, give me the original URL, it would be the Mac. They didn't

1:12:09have it. And we complained about it. And then they added it. I think it was in the file

1:12:14menu or something. It was it was weird. It would also it was in the whole way that catalyst

1:12:19just seems weird. It was like the way they added the feature still seemed weird. It was

1:12:23like, why is it in the file?

1:12:25Yeah, it's in the file menu. It's open in Safari and there's no keyboard shortcut.

1:12:29Yeah. Why is this in the file? Shouldn't this be an edit? Shouldn't it be like an alternate

1:12:34to copy URL and copy original URL.

1:12:37- Right, and shouldn't it also be in the share button

1:12:39that's right there?

1:12:40- Right, it should be in, yeah.

1:12:42Why is it not in the share button?

1:12:45But anyway, now that that's gone.

1:12:48We're back to not even having it.

1:12:49So when you're in Catalina,

1:12:51there's no way to get the original URL anymore.

1:12:53And I realize now, all of a sudden,

1:12:55I just suddenly popped into my head

1:12:57that like a month ago, Moltz was on my show

1:13:00and I promised that I would share my script

1:13:03for turning an Apple News URL into the original URL.

1:13:06And I still haven't done that.

1:13:08So, all right, I've popped it back into my head.

1:13:10I'll get that out one of these days.

1:13:13- The one that drives me crazy is that in automation

1:13:15in the home app, when you set a time, it's the spinner,

1:13:20which is a delightful, delightful touchscreen interface.

1:13:24It's whimsical and functional and much better

1:13:28than having to type in a time on the keyboard or something.

1:13:31On the Mac, it is a disaster.

1:13:32Like it is malpractice for that to still be in there.

1:13:37And I am also, I'm like, I hope,

1:13:39I am trying to heap scorn on it this summer

1:13:42in the hopes that somebody at Apple will hear

1:13:45the rising scorn and be like,

1:13:46"Guys, can you just fix that, please?"

1:13:48- Did you see that?

1:13:49I tweeted a day or two ago,

1:13:51just like a screen recording of that interface

1:13:54in the home app.

1:13:55And also in addition to the fact

1:13:56that it is a very bad control,

1:14:00the iOS touch date picker is a very bad control

1:14:04for a mouse pointer interface.

1:14:06But in addition, when you resize the window,

1:14:09it does really bizarre things

1:14:12when you get to a certain minimum height.

1:14:15It suddenly jumps to a different size class.

1:14:18- Oh yeah, it snaps to the sides of the window

1:14:20instead of floating in the center.

1:14:21- Right, but and in addition to the fact

1:14:23that that's not, that shouldn't be what it does on the Mac,

1:14:26it's just not a good Mac interface.

1:14:28The fact that there's no animation also,

1:14:31it just seems so junky.

1:14:32- It's also a fake window inside a window, right?

1:14:35It's this fake window that looks like a window,

1:14:37but you can't click on it, you can't slide it around.

1:14:39It's not really a window.

1:14:40They've just grayed out the back

1:14:41and locked this modal thing.

1:14:42And yeah, it's bad.

1:14:43And again, I was forgiving in Mojave

1:14:46'cause it's like, well, this is bad.

1:14:48But first, during the beta, it was like,

1:14:49surely they'll fix this by the time they ship.

1:14:51That didn't happen.

1:14:52But at least we get the functionality

1:14:53and it's not for third parties yet.

1:14:54So surely next year, when they improve this technology

1:14:57and hopefully give it a name, which they did,

1:14:59it will be better.

1:15:00And those apps still don't seem to have been touched.

1:15:02And Craig Federighi has said some very weird things

1:15:05to journalists where he said,

1:15:06"Well, a lot of those things that you have ascribed

1:15:10to a catalyst is really actually just a design decision."

1:15:14And I think to myself,

1:15:16is he kind of throwing his designers under the bus there?

1:15:18Because what he's basically saying is,

1:15:20"Oh, our technology is great.

1:15:21We just made terrible choices."

1:15:23Like, really?

1:15:25They've spent the entire Mac OS X era,

1:15:30I mean, ever since Aqua was unveiled, right?

1:15:34I mean, there was this, back when it was called Rhapsody,

1:15:38there were a couple of developer betas

1:15:40that used the old platinum UI interface,

1:15:45and they were kind of fascinating builds,

1:15:48'cause they were super fast.

1:15:51It was really an exciting time to be a Mac user.

1:15:54It's like 1999 and there's like Rhapsody developer beta two.

1:15:58And it looked like Mac OS nine,

1:16:00except it was a little slightly different platinum interface,

1:16:03but it was super fast.

1:16:05It was very snappy, but it was like,

1:16:07but this isn't what we're gonna ship, wait for it.

1:16:10And then they showed us Aqua

1:16:11and Aqua was way more eye candy, right?

1:16:16Everything was anti-aliased instead of bitmap fonts

1:16:19and there were shadows and transparency and all this stuff.

1:16:23and it looked way fancier, but it was slow, right?

1:16:28I mean, that was the early era of Mac OS X

1:16:31was that even on like the fastest hardware

1:16:33you could buy from Apple, it was kind of a slow interface

1:16:36because they so emphasized the visual effects,

1:16:41you know, the shadows and the transparency

1:16:44and the animation, right?

1:16:45The animation was a huge part of it.

1:16:47Everything that could be animated was animated.

1:16:50You hit Command + S and the save sheet drops

1:16:53out of the top of the menu and comes down.

1:16:55And if you hit the cancel button,

1:16:57it doesn't just disappear,

1:16:58it slides back up into the top of the thing.

1:17:02And all these years later, effectively almost 20 years later

1:17:07and if anything, iOS took the animated aspect

1:17:13of the interface and went even further with it.

1:17:18And I think it was so important

1:17:22to the way that people could just look at the original iPhone

1:17:2510 years ago and just get it,

1:17:28was the way that almost most of the major apps in iOS,

1:17:33on the iPhone kind of work in a column view sort of way,

1:17:38where this column view metaphor

1:17:40that just take it from the finder,

1:17:41where at the top level it's on the left

1:17:43and you drill into a folder and it fills in to the right

1:17:47as you keep going down in the hierarchy.

1:17:51most iOS apps work like that.

1:17:53Like you're in mail and you see a list of accounts

1:17:56and you tap one of your accounts

1:17:57and then it slides over to the left

1:18:00and then you got your inbox for that account

1:18:03and it has a bunch of messages and you tap on a message

1:18:05and it slides over to the left and now you see the message

1:18:08and you keep, you know,

1:18:10but the actual animation gives you a mental layout

1:18:14of the app and you kind of understand

1:18:18when you're in mail or messages or even in the settings app

1:18:22that you're in this sort of left to right,

1:18:24the deeper you go, the further right you are

1:18:26and you just keep going back to the left

1:18:27to go back to the root level.

1:18:29The animation reiterates all that.

1:18:32To have this thing now in a Mac in 2019

1:18:37where the view doesn't animate at all,

1:18:39you just suddenly snap between the minimum height

1:18:42requirement of the window and it just snaps

1:18:46to be full screen with no animation at all,

1:18:50it feels like the most unhappily experience I can imagine.

1:18:54It really just, you know, I get it, I see what's going on.

1:18:59I understand that it's because I made the window too small

1:19:02and now it's at this point where the little sheet

1:19:05is gonna be full width

1:19:06instead of looking like a fake window in a window.

1:19:11But the fact that there's no animation between it,

1:19:13even though it's not a good experience overall anyway,

1:19:17but the lack of animation just feels so anti-Apple.

1:19:22It's really hard to believe that it came out of Apple.

1:19:25I'm baffled by these apps.

1:19:27- Yeah, the one that I've noticed,

1:19:29and again, it's beta, it's early,

1:19:30but the podcast app on Catalina,

1:19:34so that's a catalyst app.

1:19:39And you remember back in the early days of OS X,

1:19:44the interface convention for showing more information

1:19:47was these drawers that slid out.

1:19:49- Right.

1:19:50- And it was an animated process

1:19:52and they had a lot of Chrome on them.

1:19:53And we've gone away from that.

1:19:55You don't do that anymore.

1:19:56But I was thinking about them because in podcasts,

1:19:59if you want to see, and this is actually true,

1:20:04actually this is true in the music app too.

1:20:06So I should use the music app as an example,

1:20:08even though that's not catalyst

1:20:09because it's using this like design language

1:20:12that Apple has worked on

1:20:13that seems to be very influenced by iOS.

1:20:16In the music app, up next and lyrics when you show them,

1:20:20in iTunes, it's a popover

1:20:22that comes down from the center of the screen

1:20:25and it pops over and it's like a temporary view.

1:20:27In music, it's this drawer that slides out

1:20:32from the inside of the window over the UI

1:20:36and the UI stays active, but is covered partially

1:20:41by this thing.

1:20:42And I thought, okay, one, I see why you would need this

1:20:45on a full screen app, like you would have on an iPad.

1:20:50But two, it's a drawer and it's going the wrong way, right?

1:20:55Like it's like, why would you build an interface?

1:20:58And I know the answer is because this was built,

1:21:01we're using iPad conventions here.

1:21:04And even though this is not a Catalyst app,

1:21:06we're using those conventions

1:21:08so that it feels like the music app on the iPad.

1:21:10But on a Mac, I look at it and I just think,

1:21:13no, this is wrong.

1:21:16I've got a 27-inch monitor here.

1:21:18Why are you covering my content

1:21:20to show me what's up next with the lyrics?

1:21:23It doesn't make any sense from that perspective.

1:21:26It's a choice made for good reason on a different platform

1:21:28and then applied to this platform,

1:21:31kind of like, I don't know,

1:21:33Consistency over usability, I guess,

1:21:35is what's happening there.

1:21:36It's frustrating, it's really frustrating.

1:21:37- Yeah, because it's a perfect example.

1:21:40I know exactly which thing you're talking about.

1:21:43There's a button right above it,

1:21:45and it is animated, and it looks nice,

1:21:48but on the iPad, typically your music app is full screen.

1:21:53It is, the size of your iPad is the size of your music app,

1:21:58or the podcast app, if that's what you're listening to.

1:22:00- Yeah, and certainly, even if you did a split view

1:22:02or something like that, there's no concept on iOS

1:22:06of a window kind of like

1:22:08extruding into another space. - Growing, yes.

1:22:10- That's just not, doesn't happen.

1:22:12- Exactly, even if you're in split view,

1:22:14the app is given, okay, you've got a two-thirds

1:22:19of the size of the screen square,

1:22:21or you've got a one-third over on the right column.

1:22:25You can't grow as the app.

1:22:27You've got this space, so if you want to show more,

1:22:30It needs to overlap the content.

1:22:33But on the Mac, a roughly,

1:22:36and I'm talking to you on a 5K iMac,

1:22:40and I'm holding up my iPad right in front of it,

1:22:43and a roughly iPad-sized window is a perfect window size

1:22:48for the music app or the podcast app on the Mac

1:22:51if you have a nice big iMac display.

1:22:55Perfectly reasonable size.

1:22:56But if you need to show more,

1:22:58there's plenty of room on the screen to show more

1:23:01off to the side instead of overlapping the content.

1:23:05It seems like a very strange concession for the Mac to make

1:23:10in the grounds of consistency.

1:23:14- Right, right, 'cause it's across,

1:23:16I mean, this is the problem with cross-platform interfaces

1:23:18is every platform is different

1:23:20and has unique characteristics.

1:23:21And I wouldn't want some sort of weird drawer exclusion,

1:23:26sorry, extrusion thing on my iPad.

1:23:28That would make no sense.

1:23:30But on the Mac, I look at it and I immediately,

1:23:32like I used this app for the first time the other day.

1:23:35And I immediately was like, whoa, like why is that happening?

1:23:39And it's not like I haven't seen,

1:23:40like the music app in iOS 13 puts up

1:23:43this little slide over thing for now playing.

1:23:45And it literally grays out the rest of the interface

1:23:47and you can't interact with it,

1:23:48but it's not actually a slide over and you can't move it.

1:23:51It just sits, you can dismiss it and that's all you can do.

1:23:53And I had that same thought of sort of like,

1:23:56Is this what we want is these weird things that float on top of other things and block

1:24:00them but at least in the iPad I can understand some of the rationale on the Mac the only

1:24:04rationale is well that's how we do it on the iPad.

1:24:09And so there's a weird thing I tweeted about it I tweeted this movie I recorded with the

1:24:14home thing and absolute genius Steven trout Smith who's spent more time deconstructing

1:24:23how these apps work before they were even announced.

1:24:27Like he knows as much about how these Marzipan apps

1:24:30used to work and how they work now as anybody outside Apple.

1:24:35And he said something, I can't find the tweet right now,

1:24:37but said something to the effect that the podcast app

1:24:40seemingly is written using some catalyst features

1:24:44that aren't publicly available.

1:24:47- Yeah.

1:24:48- So like the fact that the, like the catalyst app is,

1:24:51or the podcast app is the saving grace of Catalyst so far,

1:24:54because you can look at it and say,

1:24:55"Well, this feels like a Mac app."

1:24:56There's some things that are a little off,

1:25:01but they're at the edges.

1:25:03They're truly edge cases of the interface.

1:25:06- Sure.

1:25:06- And overall, this seems like a real Mac app,

1:25:09and it doesn't feel like an iOS app running on the Mac.

1:25:12- Although some of that is that,

1:25:14what we were talking about a second ago,

1:25:16some of that is that you compare it to music,

1:25:19which is not Catalyst,

1:25:20and you compare it to TV, which is not catalyst,

1:25:23but they've got new interfaces

1:25:25that are the same interface that podcast does.

1:25:27So some of it is moving the goalposts a little bit, right?

1:25:30- Right, because they've matched the...

1:25:33The podcast app has some superpowers, seemingly,

1:25:39to be more Mac-like, and then the other side,

1:25:42it seems like they took the music and TV apps

1:25:44and made them a little less Mac-like to even it up.

1:25:47- To just get them to be a little bit closer together, yeah.

1:25:50- 'Cause they do feel of a kind, right?

1:25:51They're all from the same sort of design language.

1:25:53They're all trying to hit the same target,

1:25:55even though one of them is catalyst.

1:25:56- Yeah, they're clearly from the same team.

1:25:59They're clearly from the iTunes team.

1:26:00I have to mention this.

1:26:04If I didn't mention it, I would kill myself after the show

1:26:07for not mentioning it, but I love,

1:26:10so we know Apple effectively admitted, I think,

1:26:13it certainly is true.

1:26:15I think they more or less admitted though

1:26:17that what they did is they took the old iTunes app and,

1:26:21and took out a bunch of features, redid the interface,

1:26:25but it's not just the music app, it's also the TV app. So effectively,

1:26:30we've got two versions of iTunes now on Catalina.

1:26:33Yeah. Plus a bunch of code that runs in the finder now. So, right.

1:26:36I tunes now too, a little bit. Right. So they, yeah.

1:26:40So what we used to know is iTunes for

1:26:44geez, what, uh, 18 years, you know, right.

1:26:482001, right.

1:26:50It was before the iPod iPod actually.

1:26:54Right. Right.

1:26:54iTunes came first. So almost 20 years. Yeah.

1:26:57So 20 years of iTunes, they've taken the code and they've,

1:27:01they've forked it once to make the music app and it has all the music

1:27:06features that we used to know from iTunes.

1:27:07They forked it a second time to make the TV app,

1:27:11which is interesting to me because it seems to me like the TV app maybe could

1:27:15have gone the podcast route.

1:27:16And I'm very curious why they decided to

1:27:20do, you know, do it the way they did.

1:27:23Me too.

1:27:24My theory is that there are projects at Apple that have been in the works for

1:27:29long enough that they had already gone down the path of building a Mac version.

1:27:33And so why throw that work out when you already did it? So that that's,

1:27:37that's my theory is like the TV app, they were already working on it.

1:27:40and then Catalyst comes along and they're like,

1:27:41"Well, you're still working on Catalyst.

1:27:44"We're already down this path.

1:27:45"We'll just keep going down the path."

1:27:48- Yeah, and then they took all of the device management stuff

1:27:51and put it in the Finder, which is brilliant, right?

1:27:53Doesn't that seem like the way it should have been?

1:27:55I don't know why I never,

1:27:56I wish, as soon as I saw that in the keynote

1:27:58and they put that in the Finder,

1:28:00so if you want to manually manage

1:28:03the backup of your iPhone or your iPad

1:28:08or whatever device you connect to your Mac,

1:28:10you do it in the Finder now, and that seems so perfect.

1:28:13It's like, yeah, that's exactly the job of the Finder.

1:28:16That would be, that's great.

1:28:18- It breaks the metaphor a little bit,

1:28:19'cause the Finder windows are supposed to have,

1:28:20like, files in them, and now suddenly

1:28:22there's a device management window in the Finder.

1:28:25But on another level, I agree with you,

1:28:26'cause like, I've always been frustrated

1:28:28that you couldn't just plug in an iPhone to a Mac

1:28:30and drag files onto it.

1:28:31- Right, it just seems right.

1:28:33- You have to go to iTunes and do it, so now you can.

1:28:35- Yeah, without going into a four hour,

1:28:39we should add John Siracusa to the show.

1:28:43- Dial him in.

1:28:45- Digression on the user interface of the Finder

1:28:50in the Mac OS X era, vis-a-vis the classic Finder

1:28:53and all that.

1:28:54Again, it would easily be four hours.

1:28:59We would have to get John Siracusa.

1:29:01Given the OS X Finder,

1:29:03it just seems right that a device you plug in

1:29:06should show up in the finder sidebar.

1:29:08It's really--

1:29:10- For sure, yeah.

1:29:11Well, it certainly makes more sense than a weird button

1:29:13that grows out of the iTunes title bar, right?

1:29:16Like, what is that? - In your music playing app.

1:29:18- Yeah, it doesn't make sense.

1:29:20But you're right, the TV app is iTunes.

1:29:23Like, it's the TV parts of iTunes that they've just,

1:29:25TV and movie parts of iTunes that they've taken

1:29:27and added some other stuff to.

1:29:29- So the thing I wanna mention, and I just love it,

1:29:32and I really almost wonder whether they're trolling us

1:29:35at this point, is the fact,

1:29:37you know what I'm gonna say, right?

1:29:39The preferences window is still a modal dialogue.

1:29:44- Of course, of course.

1:29:45- So music and TV have modal dialogues for preferences.

1:29:49And I think most people listening to the show

1:29:52already know exactly what I'm talking about

1:29:54and why it's a little antiquated.

1:29:56But if you don't, just the basic idea

1:29:59is that a modal dialogue is one that when you open it up in an app,

1:30:04you can't do in anything in any other windows until you

1:30:07cancel or okay. The, the app. So when you open preferences,

1:30:12and this is all iTunes has always been this way,

1:30:14going back to what before MacOS 10,

1:30:17when it was a classic app is you'd open the preferences and you could change

1:30:21settings, but then there's an okay and cancel button at the bottom. So you could,

1:30:26you could hit cancel and then any of the changes you made

1:30:30wouldn't actually be registered

1:30:32because you canceled it instead of okaying it.

1:30:35And in the '90s, maybe even going back to the '80s,

1:30:38that was a very common,

1:30:39I mean, the further back in time you go in Mac history,

1:30:42the more stuff was modal as opposed to non-modal,

1:30:45where it would come up and you had to do it

1:30:48or cancel it right then and there

1:30:50and you couldn't do anything else until you did.

1:30:52- Yeah, everything else stopped while you were in there.

1:30:54I have a little real-time follow-up. They bought I they bought sound jam MP in 2000

1:31:00But the first version of iTunes actually did come out in 2001. It was January 2001

1:31:04But not a lot before the iPod only a little less than a year Mac World Expo

1:31:112001 yeah ten months before the iPad or iPod ship. Yep. Yep

1:31:16a lot of email so

1:31:20The fact that iTunes stuck with a modal preferences dialogue

1:31:24And I believe it's the last app Apple has with a modal

1:31:28I mean, maybe there's some kind of obscure app is somewhere in in slash applications slash utilities

1:31:35Maybe some of those still have it

1:31:37I don't know but in terms of the ones that would ever even vaguely have a chance of being demoed in a keynote

1:31:43iTunes was far and away the last app Apple made with a modal

1:31:48Preferences dialogue and they clearly did a complete UI

1:31:53Reskinning of the you know, the the the brand new Catalina music and TV apps don't look like iTunes on

1:32:01Mojave right the fact that they left the preferences as a modal dialog box. I love it. I

1:32:07acts

1:32:09You know what?

1:32:10I mean like I feel like we've circled the globe on this and we've gone away from like complaining like isn't it time for the

1:32:16iTunes preferences not to be modal and just, you know, just it's out. It's literally outlasted

1:32:22iTunes now. The preferences box has outlasted its app. I at this point, I'm actually so charmed

1:32:31that they kept it as a modal dialog box. And then of course, I checked podcasts and podcasts

1:32:36is not modal, you know, the podcast, which is catalyst app, but looks a lot like the music app

1:32:41and the TV app, not modal. It charms me now at this point. And I really, if anybody at Apple

1:32:50is on these teams, I would love to know the story behind this because technically it can't be that

1:32:56hard. It can't be that there are—with all of the work that went into splitting the music and TV

1:33:03apps from what was iTunes, surely part of that work could have been making the preferences non-modal.

1:33:10I feel like it's a deliberate choice at this point, and I kind of love it.

1:33:13When you talk about coming all the way back around the world, I will point out that automation

1:33:18box that we were talking about in the Home app. I mean, we're back there now, because that is

1:33:25literally a modal. It blocks out everything else that happens in the Home app while it's open.

1:33:30So, you know, the modal dialogues are back in style, is what I'm saying.

1:33:36- And what if you never left?

1:33:37Well, iTunes never left and now it's back.

1:33:40It's like, you know, 80s comes back in style,

1:33:4290s comes back in style, wait long enough

1:33:45and you'll be back in style.

1:33:46(laughing)

1:33:50- I absolutely love it that it's...

1:33:52(laughing)

1:33:54What are you running?

1:33:57I'm curious what betas you're running personally.

1:34:00- So I had installed...

1:34:05the Catalina beta on an external SSD. That's sort of my first step because with the Mac,

1:34:13you don't have to commit your whole device to being on it. You can use a partition or

1:34:18an SSD. Marco Arment realized that APFS will let you partition things, and I realized I've

1:34:25just been so trained from HFS to not ever, ever touch the partitions of my internal hard

1:34:31drive that I just have a Samsung SSD that is so small that I can tuck it in the back

1:34:37of my iMac's little VESA mount and it's like it's not even there. So I can reboot into

1:34:45Catalina and that's step one. Step two will be that I'll move, but step one I reboot into

1:34:49Catalina and it means I can attach that drive to my wife's MacBook Air when she's at work

1:34:54and I can boot into it on that one and use it as reference. And then for iOS, I have

1:34:59test devices that have been running it, but yesterday I put it on my iPad, mostly at the

1:35:04urging of Federico Faticci, who was talking about this on a podcast and basically said,

1:35:09"Well, if you're a regular person, you shouldn't install this beta yet, but if you're right

1:35:13about this for a living, you should probably do it." And I thought, "Oh, he's talking to

1:35:16me." So I did it. And it's, you know, once you go over the beta, I firmly believe that

1:35:21you have to use the beta on your main system to really understand anything, right? Because

1:35:26Otherwise you're just kind of noodling around in an empty shell and then you leave it. And

1:35:31you don't. I've already learned in 12 hours or 18 hours of using it on my main iPad, I've

1:35:36already learned like a dozen things I didn't notice in the last week and a half because

1:35:40it's my iPad now. So at some point you got to cut over. But like I'm going on vacation

1:35:46next week and I'm not going to put it on my phone like no way. But on the iPad I figure

1:35:52Because I do need to immerse myself in this stuff,

1:35:55I need to get there.

1:35:56And I feel like in the next few weeks,

1:35:57I will probably do a thing where,

1:35:59let me know what you think about this strategy.

1:36:02What I'm thinking of doing is I bought a,

1:36:04so this external drive is a terabyte

1:36:07and my internal iMac Pro drive is a terabyte.

1:36:09So what I'm thinking is cloning my existing Mojave

1:36:13onto that external drive and then upgrading to Catalina,

1:36:18because that'll let me live with Catalina,

1:36:20but also like have a place I can retreat to

1:36:24for things like doing podcasts

1:36:26where you don't want your apps to crash and stuff like that.

1:36:29- That sounds a lot like my strategy.

1:36:30Let's take a third break here

1:36:32and thank our third and final sponsor of the episode,

1:36:35another one of my very favorite companies, Mack Weldon.

1:36:39Mack Weldon makes, they call them men's essentials.

1:36:43Look, T-shirts, underwear, socks, that sort of thing.

1:36:46And they're just super high quality.

1:36:50They are the nicest stuff I have ever owned.

1:36:53I love it.

1:36:55I'm wearing them right now.

1:36:56I got a pair of Mack Weldon underwear on.

1:36:59Whoever thought I'd grow up and part of my life

1:37:01would be to tell everybody what kind of underwear I've got.

1:37:04Well, that's where I am.

1:37:06I love Mack Weldon products.

1:37:08They'd started from scratch.

1:37:11They've looked at this market

1:37:13and this is why I like this company.

1:37:16They engineered everything, even their own fabrics.

1:37:19They start from the ground up, they make their own fabrics,

1:37:22they make their own designs,

1:37:24they control all of the stitching and the sizing,

1:37:27and they truly believe that the difference is in the details

1:37:30and they obsess over every stitch and seam

1:37:33until they've reached their definition of perfect

1:37:36for products like underwear, t-shirts, socks.

1:37:40I almost guaranteed that whatever you're wearing right now

1:37:43as you listen to this, Mack Weldon products are better

1:37:46than what you have on right now.

1:37:47Great stuff, I love 'em.

1:37:49And they've even got, their silver line

1:37:55is made of naturally antimicrobial fabrics.

1:38:00That means they eliminate odor.

1:38:03Sounds like BS, you think like,

1:38:05how can you make a t-shirt that stays odor free

1:38:09as opposed to another thing?

1:38:10I don't know how they do it, but it works.

1:38:12It's great stuff, love them for summer.

1:38:15that silver line of products, especially the shirts,

1:38:19absolutely terrific for hot weather.

1:38:21Super comfortable, super stylish.

1:38:24Anything you could ask for in these products,

1:38:27MAC, Weld-In stuff is great.

1:38:29And the ordering process is great.

1:38:31They have a wonderful website.

1:38:32Once they know what you've got,

1:38:33so like stuff like underwear and socks,

1:38:35you kind of have to reorder every year or so.

1:38:38They remember what you've got.

1:38:40You can remember what you like,

1:38:41just reorder the stuff that you already like.

1:38:44Really just a great shopping experience. I

1:38:46Like everything they have I like their t-shirts like their underwear like their socks

1:38:50And they have a special offer for listeners of the talk show 20% off your first order 20% by going to Mac

1:38:58Weldon calm and enter the code talk show know the just talk show at checkout and you'll save 20% off your first order

1:39:06absolutely love their products and

1:39:09Glad they're still a sponsor to the show Mac Weldon calm and remember that code

1:39:13talk show what were we talking about before the break beta strategies beta

1:39:21strategy that's exactly right so I feel like everybody in our racket has these

1:39:25exact same Samsung drives right everybody up it's the Samsung t5 I'm

1:39:31looking at it right now I've got like three of them connected to my iMac right

1:39:35now so I've got one for Catalina I got my time machine is on one uh-huh I have

1:39:39a two gigabyte, two terabyte one for storage. I just bought another one for time machine

1:39:45because I realized I was backing up time machine to my server over my network and that because

1:39:49it's a raid, it's actually kind of slow. And I thought, why, why do I not just have an

1:39:53SSD tucked behind my iMac for backup? So now I've got two of those guys. They're great.

1:39:58All things considered, I don't, I just don't like Samsung as a company. I don't like their

1:40:03television sets. I certainly don't want their phones. Don't really like their computers.

1:40:08I there's a, you know, I just not a fan of the company, but you know, they make good

1:40:14SSDs. And I think that they're portable. These t five portable SSDs are one of the best products

1:40:21I've ever had in my life. And it's funny because like, I've been buying them for at least a

1:40:26year or a couple of years now. They're so much cheaper than they used to be. It is absolutely

1:40:31ludicrous. I went to Amazon, I bought a new one just to install Catalina, and it was like,

1:40:38I got a two terabyte drive for one third of the price that I bought a one terabyte for

1:40:4518 months ago. It's absolutely ridiculous how cheap they're getting. And they're just

1:40:50these tiny little things with one USB-C port in the back. They come with both cables that

1:40:57that you would possibly want, which is USB-C to USB-C

1:41:01and USB-A to USB-C.

1:41:04So you can connect it to, they have nice little cables

1:41:07that are, to me, a very smart length.

1:41:09They're not too super short, but they're not like six foot.

1:41:12One of the great products that I could recommend

1:41:18are these Samsung T5 drives.

1:41:20I did the same thing, I've got Catalina running

1:41:22on an external SSD.

1:41:23I did the same thing as you, where there was no way,

1:41:27as a, and again, I admit technically, I think we're wrong

1:41:30and Marco's probably the right way

1:41:32that we should just trust APFS

1:41:34and trust that you can repartition your internal drive

1:41:39with APFS and have a safe thing where you can put Catalina.

1:41:44But I'm so old school that I not only install it

1:41:48on an external SSD, I unmount my internal hard drive.

1:41:51I reboot, you know.

1:41:53One of the weird things about installing Catalina

1:41:55is you couldn't just install it on a blank drive.

1:41:57you had to start with Mojave.

1:41:59I think you went through the same thing.

1:42:00I think you were talking about this on a podcast.

1:42:01- Yeah, I installed Mojave and then I installed

1:42:04(laughs)

1:42:05- You had to though.

1:42:06- Although Marco says that you can download the Mojave

1:42:10or the Catalina installer and then point it

1:42:12at a blank drive and it will actually do it.

1:42:14But I decided I was not gonna risk getting my Mac

1:42:19in a position where it was gonna try to install Catalina

1:42:22on itself because that would be disaster.

1:42:24So I, yeah, we've been trained by the Mac for 20 years

1:42:27to not do that.

1:42:28- We've just got terrible, terrible battle scars

1:42:30where we're just like, whatever you say,

1:42:32you know, like if they tell you that you're supposed

1:42:33to stand on one leg and hop up and down

1:42:36as the installer runs, I would do it.

1:42:37- I think that's how you zap the PRAM.

1:42:39- Yeah, zap your PRAM and hold down six buttons

1:42:44on your keyboard as it restarts.

1:42:46- And just hope that it all works.

1:42:47So yeah, yeah, you use an external drive and it's like,

1:42:50and like you said, in the racket we're in,

1:42:54You gotta do it, right?

1:42:56But you gotta have strategies for it

1:42:58because you are going to have an unstable system,

1:43:01like even a good beta, it is an unstable system.

1:43:04I had that happen, I wanna say three summers ago,

1:43:07I finally cut over to the beta

1:43:10and realized that all of my podcasting broke when I did it.

1:43:14So I spent like two months

1:43:16where every time somebody wanted me to do a podcast,

1:43:20I said, "Okay, I will be back in five minutes

1:43:22"after I reboot."

1:43:23because I ended up with an external drive

1:43:27that was just a generic version

1:43:28of the shipping operating system

1:43:30that would actually work with podcasting.

1:43:32So that's the problem of having your test machine

1:43:35be your production machine, as it were,

1:43:37is that you're just, yeah,

1:43:39at some point you gotta use the betas though,

1:43:41because you gotta write about them.

1:43:43But if they break part of your,

1:43:44like if I couldn't write articles,

1:43:46if like BB Edit didn't open in the beta,

1:43:48that would be really bad.

1:43:49And I would have to have like another system

1:43:51to use to write my article

1:43:52because you can't, you know, you gotta use the beta stuff,

1:43:56but you've also got to work.

1:43:58- So I've got Catalina on an external drive,

1:44:02but as we podcast talking to you from Mojave,

1:44:06because I'm not gonna risk--

1:44:09- You did that, you did that.

1:44:10You're like, "I'll be back in a minute.

1:44:12"I gotta reboot into Mojave so that we can do a podcast."

1:44:14- And I've got iOS 13 or AKA iPad OS 13

1:44:19honest, on my year-old iPhone X and a Mac Mini, or iPad Mini. I mean, not a Mac Mini.

1:44:27Right. So it's not your actual iOS devices, but—

1:44:30Right. But I'm thinking—the one I'm almost certainly going to upgrade first before

1:44:35we start our family vacations is I think I'm going to put iPadOS on my main iPad. Because

1:44:41A, I don't—if it gets buggy, there's no scenario where that really adversely affects

1:44:48I mean, maybe there'd be a third-party app, I don't know, that I would wish worked but

1:44:53didn't. But it's the device that I can get by with in bugginess the most. I feel like

1:45:03I know they had this weird warning this year. They called it thrill seekers and they kind

1:45:08of made you jump through extra hoops to get the first betas of the iOS. You had to connect

1:45:15to Xcode, you couldn't just download a profile and restart and do a software update on the

1:45:22device. You kind of had to use a Mac. I find that on the iPhone, it's pretty stable. I

1:45:30haven't really seen anything. I'm probably not going to put it on my main phone before

1:45:34we start going on vacations next month, but it seems like I could. I don't know.

1:45:39- Yeah, it's, I mean, it doesn't seem disastrous, right?

1:45:43Like you always have to worry

1:45:44that the next beta will have a terrible bug

1:45:46and you'll update to that one

1:45:47and suddenly you'll be in trouble.

1:45:49- Their thrill seeker warning really turned me off.

1:45:52I was like, holy shit, this is,

1:45:54this must be really buggy, but it seems usable.

1:45:58What are you thinking about dark mode on iOS?

1:46:02- I am much more interested in dark mode on iOS

1:46:04than I am on the Mac, to be honest.

1:46:07Like I tried dark mode on Mojave

1:46:09And it's a little bit better now that Safari

1:46:12has dark mode support and websites are sort of

1:46:15starting to come around to the idea

1:46:16that you might wanna build in a dark mode.

1:46:19I wondered, maybe Daring Fireball needs like a light mode

1:46:25or something, I don't know what happens then,

1:46:27but you're already kind of doing dark mode, so it's okay.

1:46:30But on iOS devices, especially like on the iPhone,

1:46:33like I already am using the dark interface

1:46:36in a lot of my apps because they look really good

1:46:38on the OLED screen and on the iPad somewhat too.

1:46:43So I feel like I'm probably gonna use dark mode

1:46:46a lot more on iOS than on Mojave, but what about you?

1:46:49- I think it works better on iOS.

1:46:53So I think it's interesting,

1:46:55like I was just saying to you earlier in the show

1:46:57where in years past,

1:46:59and dark mode is a perfect example of this,

1:47:00where it just seems like Apple can't do it all at once.

1:47:04They can't say, okay,

1:47:05all of our platforms now have dark mode.

1:47:07It was, you know, Dark Mode's a perfect example

1:47:10where TV OS had it and then Mac got it

1:47:15and now iOS gets it.

1:47:17But it seems like iOS is the platform

1:47:19where people really wanted it.

1:47:20I know people cheered for it with the Mac,

1:47:23but the cheers that it got in the keynote,

1:47:25even though it was widely expected,

1:47:27the rumors were super rampant that, you know,

1:47:30this is the year iOS was gonna get Dark Mode.

1:47:33But man, when Craig Federighi announced it,

1:47:35the crowd went nuts.

1:47:37I mean, it was absolutely bonkers.

1:47:40I mean, if there was anything that competed with it,

1:47:43it was when they announced the PS4 controller

1:47:45for Apple TV.

1:47:47I think it works so much better on iOS than Mac

1:47:53because of the fact that iOS doesn't have

1:47:56a windowing system.

1:47:59It has this either full screen apps or tiled apps.

1:48:04And the thing on the Mac, I honestly,

1:48:07I mean, my eyes are bad and weird in a bunch of ways,

1:48:12but on the Mac, I honestly can't get

1:48:14how people run everything in dark mode.

1:48:16I've been running BB Edit in dark mode,

1:48:18effectively dark mode, for years.

1:48:20Like, I have a dark background,

1:48:23very dark gray with light-colored colors for the text.

1:48:27And in recent years, BB Edit has detected that,

1:48:33and if you have a dark theme,

1:48:35it also shows you a dark interface,

1:48:37even on older versions of macOS.

1:48:39But having one app in dark mode

1:48:44to make it jump out on my screen full of tiled windows

1:48:48from a bunch of apps is different to me than having,

1:48:52very different to me than having everything in dark mode.

1:48:54And the way that you just don't see the three dimensionality

1:48:58in dark mode as well, 'cause it's tough,

1:49:00'cause how do you show a shadow, right?

1:49:02like in light mode on Mac when you have one window in front of another, the one that's

1:49:06in front casts a shadow behind it. The fact that iOS doesn't have to worry about that

1:49:12makes it work way better. And there are some interesting touches that Apple has done that

1:49:18as you go into a view hierarchy and something pops up, it gets a little bit lighter. But

1:49:25because they don't overlap the way that Windows on the Mac by definition have to be able to

1:49:29overlap. I think it works way better. Yeah, yeah, it's, um, I think there's

1:49:37context to like I'm I mean, the fact is I use my Mac mostly during the day,

1:49:42and the brightness doesn't bother me. And I use my iPhone often in darker

1:49:47circumstances, and it's also got the OLED screen. I don't know. I mean, the

1:49:50nice thing about it. It's personal preference. Honestly, the Safari thing

1:49:53for me is huge because apps have been updated to support dark themes. But

1:49:58then you go to a web page and it just blasts you with white background and black text.

1:50:03And it's terrible, like enough for me to be like, "No, no, no, I can't look at the world

1:50:09this way and I'll just go back to the light theme on Mojave." So it's getting better.

1:50:13And I feel like once iOS is supporting dark themes, all the web developers are going to

1:50:18be like, "Look, we really need to do this," because now everybody's using their iPhone

1:50:21in dark mode. And it also, I mean, it's on Windows. I don't know if it's currently on

1:50:26But I have no doubt that they will support it as well

1:50:28It's it and there are web standards to support it and that that's the thing is I think dark mode is good when?

1:50:34Everybody's on board with dark mode the problem is that if you have as long as you have outliers

1:50:39It's like it's just like oh, this is terrible get me out of here

1:50:41And and so I haven't used it on my Mac at all. It's kind of interesting too though for me because I

1:50:48There are certain apps that have always been white background

1:50:55with

1:50:56Colors in the front like messages. I mean messages goes back to when it was called

1:51:00I chat right and has sort of had the same interface. I mean the only

1:51:04the only big difference between today's messages and I chat from

1:51:0920 years ago is

1:51:12That they don't use the aqua style the 3d bubble effect on the text bubbles

1:51:17Right. It's it's always been a light

1:51:21White background app mail has always been a white background app

1:51:25So looking at those apps when I'm running my iPhone or the iPad in dark mode it at first it is just like bizarre

1:51:34It is like I can't believe that messages has a black background, but it it doesn't take long to get used to it

1:51:39I kind of like it and then with mail

1:51:42I realized that it really kind of harkens back to even earlier like

1:51:45Go back to like the early 90s when I would connect to mail and it was always through a terminal window

1:51:50and it was a black background with white text.

1:51:53It was like, "Hmm, male seems kind of natural

1:51:56with white text on a black background."

1:51:59- Yeah, yeah.

1:52:01It's, although even there, like with male,

1:52:04there is HTML mail, so you end up with those things

1:52:06where it looks bad because it's mis-rendered and yeah.

1:52:10- Yeah, you're like going through messages like this one,

1:52:13it looks good, looks good, and then you pop one up

1:52:15that's like HTML formatted and it's white

1:52:18and it's like, ah, who invited you to this party?

1:52:21This looks terrible.

1:52:23But there's other things though

1:52:26that I think are a little bit more complicated.

1:52:30Like I get it, it's a weird feature in my opinion.

1:52:33I mean, like I said just a couple minutes ago,

1:52:36the enthusiasm that people have for it

1:52:38is almost off the charts.

1:52:41But there is something to be said

1:52:43for having a unified, look, the standard interface

1:52:48is a white background with black text,

1:52:52and then sometimes we'll go to a black background

1:52:55with white text for certain contexts, and it informs you.

1:53:00So the one that bothers me in this regard is photos,

1:53:05is the standard photos interface has always been

1:53:09a white background, and then you go into edit mode

1:53:12a photo and it turns black and then you know you're in edit mode. And now that we you can

1:53:19have a dark background at the beginning, you kind of lose that instantaneous, hey, I know

1:53:23whether I'm in browse mode or edit mode, because whether the interface is white or black. And

1:53:30I don't know what the solution to that is. Like, I kind of feel like that's a casualty

1:53:36of supporting dark mode is that you kind of lose this instantaneous, hey, you know, this

1:53:42This is a special mode where we switch to a black background.

1:53:45You're right, right, because there's that whenever you edit it, it switches like that.

1:53:50Yeah, I don't know.

1:53:51And do you invert that?

1:53:52I mean, this is—I joked about creating the light mode version of Daring Fireball, but

1:53:56I do think that is a legitimate question, which is—I was being snarky, but I'm also

1:54:02kind of serious.

1:54:03When they went to Logic Pro X from Logic Pro version 9, they remade it from this kind of

1:54:08a very gray platinum interface to an interface

1:54:11that's a dark interface.

1:54:12And they said, you know, we have a lot of people working,

1:54:14audio engineers working in windowless rooms

1:54:17and like, it was too much.

1:54:18It's like, it was sort of the argument for dark mode.

1:54:20But my question when they announced this last year was,

1:54:23okay, when can we expect a light mode for logic, right?

1:54:26Because it's, if you're letting me choose

1:54:29and your app currently is dark,

1:54:31should you not now do a light version for me

1:54:34if I prefer light interfaces?

1:54:36And not a lot of people are paying attention to that,

1:54:39but I think it's legitimate.

1:54:40Like what do you do when you edit a photo in photos

1:54:42now that you're in the dark mode?

1:54:44How can you indicate,

1:54:45and you've seen Apple's written about it

1:54:47and developers have written about it,

1:54:48the issues of like,

1:54:49how do you differentiate a floating window

1:54:52when you used to differentiate it by casting a shadow,

1:54:55but now there's nowhere to cast the shadow

1:54:57because it's dark.

1:54:59Like there are, you know,

1:55:00it's more complicated than you'd think

1:55:02to just go into dark mode.

1:55:04- Yeah, absolutely.

1:55:05The one that I was very curious to see

1:55:07was the Apple Watch app on iPhone,

1:55:11which has always had a dark interface.

1:55:15Not quite black, but that's why they don't call it

1:55:17black mode, it's dark mode.

1:55:19And I thought, well, what are they gonna do

1:55:21with the Apple Watch interface?

1:55:23Is when you go into dark mode,

1:55:24is the Apple Watch app going to go light?

1:55:27Because the point is to make it

1:55:30the inverse of what's regular?

1:55:32But instead, it just stays dark.

1:55:34It's like the Apple Watch app doesn't make any difference

1:55:38whether your system is dark mode or not.

1:55:40That's the answer that they came up with.

1:55:43But it's still, is that the right answer?

1:55:46In a way, it seems like it should be light, right?

1:55:50- Right.

1:55:51Right, I mean, it's not always gonna be

1:55:54that the right answer is the inverse,

1:55:56but it's certainly, like you have to,

1:55:58every time you do something like this,

1:55:59you have to ask yourself that question of like,

1:56:01well, what do I do here to indicate,

1:56:02Like with the drop shadow, it's like,

1:56:04you don't have to have a drop glow or something,

1:56:08but you do need to invent some way to indicate

1:56:11that thing that you can't indicate anymore

1:56:13using the darkness,

1:56:14because the darkness is now something else.

1:56:16- Yeah, I don't know.

1:56:17I like it more than I thought I would.

1:56:18I'm running it on my iPad with the setting

1:56:22to have it turn on automatically at night.

1:56:25And so at nighttime it's dark,

1:56:26and in the daytime it's day,

1:56:28which I've actually been running on my Apple TV

1:56:30for years, I believe.

1:56:33And on Apple TV in particular,

1:56:35I go months with even forgetting that I have that set

1:56:38because it seems so natural for it to be light

1:56:41in the daytime and dark at nighttime.

1:56:43On the iPhone, it's a little bit more glaring

1:56:45because you can't miss it when you're in messages

1:56:48and it's a dark background.

1:56:50But I dig it, I dig it more than I do on my Mac.

1:56:53I really can't see using it system-wide on my Mac,

1:56:56but on the iPhone, I can definitely see it.

1:56:58All right, what else is on your agenda as a high-level WWDC follow-up type thing? We

1:57:08can talk about the Mac Pro and the Pro Display XDR.

1:57:11Yeah, I mean, it is… I think they're worth talking about, although on one level, I feel

1:57:18like giving them more oxygen just kind of like repeats the problem that we've had,

1:57:23which is so much of attention is given to the Mac Pro

1:57:28and now to this display that is out of whack

1:57:31with how many people will ever use them.

1:57:34And this is not new.

1:57:35That's the thing that gets me is it's like

1:57:37the trashcan Mac Pro.

1:57:39It's been so long that people have forgotten Apple's strategy

1:57:41about the Mac Pro, but like there is a real continuum

1:57:44from the time when most power users used a power Mac

1:57:49and the time when most power users use an iMac.

1:57:53The iMac used to be a consumer Mac.

1:57:55It is now the mainstream Mac.

1:57:57And you could start that continuum wherever you want,

1:58:00when the G5 came out, when the first Mac Pro came out.

1:58:03But Apple has been gradually ratcheting up

1:58:06the power of their high-end system

1:58:09and making it further and further out of whack

1:58:13from what any normal person would want

1:58:16because they only wanna serve this little narrow group.

1:58:18And it's very profitable, but a very small niche.

1:58:20They've been doing that for years now.

1:58:22And I think the big change is that, you know, after the little digression with the trash

1:58:27can, you know, we're back to this new cheese grater and like, there are people out there

1:58:31who who really expected that this thing would start at $2,000 and that then you could build

1:58:36it up to what everybody else wants. But the truth is, to make the ultra high end computer

1:58:42that some industries need, you need to bake in a bunch of stuff that does not allow you

1:58:49to sell a $2,000 configuration. And Apple has so many Macs already that fulfill the

1:58:55people who are down here, maybe not in their desire to have slots or whatever it is that's

1:58:59motivating them. But like, you know, that that is already fulfilled that they need to

1:59:04build this thing to fulfill the dreams of the people at the at the real high end. So

1:59:08I don't think it's a change in Apple strategy at all. But it's also funny because we all

1:59:12end up talking about it becomes like a symbol of the platform, even though it is going to

1:59:18be bought and used by the tiniest fraction of Mac users, and then the display by a tiny

1:59:24fraction of those people.

1:59:26Right. There is a part of me that recognizes that this whole thing, like as we complain

1:59:33about it in the commentariat, you know, the Apple commentariat class, that within Apple,

1:59:39there must be people who are like, what can we do to please you people like you wanted

1:59:43us to make high end Mac hardware, we've given you the highest end Mac hardware we could

1:59:48even conceive of and now you're going to complain? Of course we're going to complain, that's

1:59:52what we do. But I think it's great overall and I'm so happy that this machine is so high-end

2:00:02because it matches Apple's rhetoric over the last two years ever since the sort of roundtable,

2:00:12"All right, we're going to admit we made a mistake with the trash can. Here's where

2:00:16we're going forward. What they said matches what they've shipped since then. The iMac Pro is truly

2:00:24a phenomenal computer and is almost certainly the pro computer for most people who want a pro

2:00:30desktop. The Mac Mini, which they didn't even talk about in advance, has seen a really serious

2:00:38upgrade and everybody who's interested in the Mac Mini seems very, very happy with where it went

2:00:45last year, from the base end configs to the higher end configs.

2:00:51And the new Mac Pro is truly a workstation.

2:00:55It is absolutely in that classic, like, Silicon Graphics, Sun, you know, from the '90s, those

2:01:03companies.

2:01:04Unix workstation, for true power users who really need the most computing that you can

2:01:09put underneath a desk, it truly is there.

2:01:13They've pushed the state of the art

2:01:14in hardware engineering forward

2:01:17with the expansion capabilities and the modularity.

2:01:22It's really a fascinating device

2:01:24from a hardware's perspective.

2:01:25But like you said, it is not for most people.

2:01:29It's absolutely not for me.

2:01:31I'm fascinated by the device.

2:01:33And it is the most interesting Macintosh

2:01:36that I have no interest in buying whatsoever.

2:01:38Like it takes me back to like 1990, you know,

2:01:42like 1991, when I first went to school or university and had to get a Mac. And it was

2:01:48like there were the Macs that were possible that I would get, like the LC and the SE30.

2:01:54And then of course, there was the 2FX, which is the one of course I wanted. But I think

2:01:59the Mac 2FX retailed in 1990 and 1991 for around like $15,000, $16,000 in 1990 dollars.

2:02:09Not not for regular people there was one kid at Drexel who had one he had a 2fx

2:02:14He was obviously came from a family with money and remember the game specter

2:02:17Yeah, yeah sure tank game

2:02:20Yeah, it was a 3d tank game and everybody who knew anything knew that you would put it in outline view instead of

2:02:27Fully rasterizing the the panels because it would you'd get a higher frame rate and you know have better network performance

2:02:34But the kid who had the 2fx I forget his name, but he was also a specter

2:02:38He cheated at specter. He like used res edit to you could use it to hack your specs

2:02:44you know, it was like I think you had like a limit of

2:02:46You had like points to assign to like speed shields and firepower

2:02:51And so you'd have to balance it and he like it was it was very clear that he had hacked his version

2:02:57He was a cheater

2:02:59Which I mean, why would you cheat you already have a 2fx? Why would you yeah, I always put a bad

2:03:04You're already winning. Yeah, come on

2:03:06But, you know, I wanted a 2FX. I would have loved to if I had if money were no object

2:03:12as a freshman in college, which is obviously an oxymoron, I would have had one, right?

2:03:17I wanted a 2FX. It would have run Spectre better. It would have run everything better.

2:03:22At this point in my life, I have no need for the current Mac Pro. I mean, it's just overkill

2:03:26for me. I mean, I'm still on a 2014 iMac 5K, which never gets slow for me. If I got

2:03:34new machine, I'd probably get the iMac Pro just because I love the design. I can't see why,

2:03:40how I could possibly justify anything more than an iMac Pro.

2:03:43Yeah, I have the iMac Pro and I only justify it because I have all of these podcast audio files

2:03:50that I process using these kind of like high-end plugins where it takes, you know, I'm denoising

2:03:55four hours of audio for five people and it was like, oh, that's actually enough reason for me

2:04:01to get an iMac Pro, but even then I'm pushing it. And certainly the Mac Pro, there's no reason.

2:04:06And that's okay. And I think part of the psychology of fandom is why isn't this for me?

2:04:12Like the fans of anything want everything to be... And you see it in weird ways. Like I was saying,

2:04:18I was reading about how they're doing a couple of animated Star Trek shows. And it's the first time

2:04:23since the '70s that they've done an animated Star Trek show, when I was the target audience for that

2:04:27that animated Star Trek show back in the '70s.

2:04:29And I know there's an undercurrent of fans who are like,

2:04:33why are they making a show for kids?

2:04:35I'm not a kid.

2:04:36And like, I feel that way about Apple fans

2:04:39to a certain degree too,

2:04:40where there's this feeling of like outrage

2:04:43that the Mac Pro isn't designed for them.

2:04:44And it's like, it's not, just like the MacBook.

2:04:46People were outraged about that 12 inch MacBook

2:04:49'cause it wasn't powerful enough.

2:04:50And it's like, dude, it's not for you.

2:04:52Like my daughter has one and she loves it,

2:04:54but it's not for everybody.

2:04:56and that's okay, but you know,

2:04:58I do think there's this feeling like,

2:04:59well, but I'm a power user, I'm very serious.

2:05:02The high-end Mac Pro should appeal to me.

2:05:05And the truth is it doesn't make sense for almost anybody

2:05:08and that's okay, it's not meant to.

2:05:10- Well, and then it's exacerbated by the Pro Display XDR.

2:05:15- Yeah. - Like, I'm not-

2:05:17- You went in that room, right?

2:05:18Like there's, they did a room across the street

2:05:21from the convention center where they had the,

2:05:23they had, it was a great, it was like,

2:05:25Here is the 5K monitor that people buy.

2:05:28Here is this crazy like $6,000 monitor

2:05:32that people try to scrape by with

2:05:34that's the highest quality consumer monitor,

2:05:36prosumer monitor.

2:05:37Then here's the Pro Display XDR.

2:05:39And then here are these two Sony reference monitors

2:05:42that cost between 32 and $38,000.

2:05:45- No more, they were in the forties.

2:05:47They were like-- - Was it 42 and 48?

2:05:48It was a huge sum of money, right?

2:05:49- 42 and 48, and the one of them,

2:05:51the one that was, was it the OLED one or the non?

2:05:55I think it was the OLED one. They've they've actually discontinued already, right? Because it it

2:06:00It can light goes on if it's bright for too long. It dims itself and the light goes on

2:06:05It says my hope this is no longer a reference monitor

2:06:08Yeah

2:06:08it gets it gets about 90 seconds at full brightness and then it's an actual hardware light an amber LED light on a

2:06:16Display that comes on to warn you. Hey

2:06:20We've got can't maintain reference mode any longer because I'm - I think I'm running too hot. I'm too hot

2:06:26So I've reduced the net so you can't really trust this so you you can really and I asked I was like so

2:06:32you know in in the real world of people who are like grading footage for like a

2:06:37Theatrical movie release or like a high-end HBO show or something where the color really matters

2:06:42You can really only do like one shot at a time

2:06:45Because you the light comes on and you yeah, you can no longer trust it

2:06:50it. And they're like, Yeah, that's that. Yeah, and that's $48,000. It's absolutely insane.

2:06:56It is. Sometimes Apple does these rigs, these demo rooms up, and sometimes you're like,

2:07:02Come on, guys, this is ridiculous. And other times you're like, You did a great job here.

2:07:05And this was a great job because it was all about putting this thing in context. And I

2:07:10wish other people could have seen this room because it was there's the fine four K or

2:07:165k display it was garbage right like it was so terrible and then there was the $6,000 monitor

2:07:23it was a dell it was a dell 4k display and it was truly terrible honestly it makes you wonder it

2:07:29really makes you feel like they're they're just criminals for even selling it right for any you

2:07:33know probably the imac display isn't much better but it's probably better but oh yeah like i'd see

2:07:39it i think that was the missing thing in that demo is that they should have had if they really wanted

2:07:44to be fair, they would have put an iMac 5K display in there. And that to me is ultimately what is

2:07:50missing in Apple's product line is why don't they sell the 5K iMac display as a standalone display?

2:07:59The two own goals really, two ways that Apple really kind of like did some bad PR. One is,

2:08:06one is they should not have priced the monitor without the stand. I know you need, I know it's

2:08:12It's $1,000 and you're gonna get killed by it.

2:08:14It's just price it.

2:08:16You've already proven in that room

2:08:18that the $6,000 not reference displays,

2:08:21the display with the same price as yours

2:08:24is a joke compared to yours,

2:08:26which is actually looks better in most circumstances

2:08:29to the $40,000 monitors.

2:08:31You got us, you got us.

2:08:32Just include the monitor and raise the price.

2:08:35Don't play, and say that you can order it without

2:08:38if you want and save some money

2:08:40by getting the Visa mount version instead for cheaper.

2:08:42That's all you need to do. So that was own goal number one.

2:08:45Own goal number two is they're speaking, as we said earlier in this,

2:08:49in this show,

2:08:50they're speaking to a developer audience with a product that's not for a

2:08:53developer audience and the developers, you know, and the other,

2:08:56and honestly what 90% of the people who buy a Mac pro 70% of the people who buy

2:09:00a Mac pro, they don't need a reference monitor.

2:09:02So why not come out with what everybody really wants,

2:09:07which is something like the iMac panel as a standalone for them.

2:09:10And then we'll work with a Mac mini and we work with the MacBook Pro work with a Mac Pro

2:09:13You can you can say, you know, we can argue about whether it should be a 6k

2:09:1831 inch display life sure the XDR or whether it should literally just be the 27 inch

2:09:255k panel that I'm looking at right now. Just put it in the standalone display

2:09:30I mean and I know on ATP Marco was even talking about it where they've gotten rid of the target mode for IMAX

2:09:39where you can just use an iMac as a standalone display, but you can get like the base model 5k iMac is like

2:09:4517 or $1,800 something like that

2:09:48people would buy that if you could just plug the Mac Pro into it and you just have a

2:09:53Computer you don't use on the back of it, you know

2:09:57But the fact that they don't have it is is a glaring absence that optimistically. Here's what I hope and I have no

2:10:05Inside juice on this at all. I'm not cheating. I have no sources. No little birdies

2:10:10All right

2:10:10My hope is that they called this six thousand dollar seven thousand dollar eight thousand dollar with a stand display

2:10:18the pro display

2:10:20XDR as opposed to just calling it the pro display

2:10:24Because they're gonna have a pro display and the pro display or pro display HDR or HDR

2:10:30maybe right something something else but the fact that it's not just the pro display and it is such

2:10:36a glaring hole in the lineup like there are like it's not even a hole in the lineup that's the

2:10:41amazing thing is if you look out there it's a hole in the market yes exactly there are no good retina

2:10:485k displays for max it's actually worse than it used to be because lg has discontinued the one

2:10:55that they had that they kind of made in cooperation. So the market for 5k displays is actually

2:11:00worse than it was because LG has discontinued it and the only way to get the LG one which is okay

2:11:07is to get like a fine one that's like on the gray market because it's been discontinued.

2:11:13Maybe you have to get it used or maybe somebody still has one still in stock but it's like you

2:11:17can't even get a new one. The PC side of the market is just not in the ball game at all.

2:11:24The 5K is just not a thing in Windows world.

2:11:28You're lucky if you can get 4K.

2:11:29They're kind of crappy.

2:11:31And the people who care the most about graphics are gamers,

2:11:35and they don't want retina displays

2:11:37because they have to drive four times the pixels.

2:11:39They'd rather have a non-retina display that's big

2:11:42and wraps around their desk or whatever.

2:11:44The market for displays has bifurcated

2:11:50between the Mac and PC world in a way

2:11:52that hasn't happened since the '80s when the Mac was a black and white interface and PCs had VGA

2:12:02color graphics. It's like a totally different universe. So there is no way there's nobody to

2:12:07go to other than Apple. If Apple doesn't make a 5K Pro display, nobody's going to. And it's a device

2:12:16that wouldn't just be great for people who want to buy a Mac Pro who don't need a $7,000 reference

2:12:22display, it would also be great for Mac Mini users, it would be great for, and to me the

2:12:30biggest market is the gazillion MacBook users, whether of any, whatever MacBook you have.

2:12:38Especially those MacBook Pros, right?

2:12:40Right, but if you have a MacBook Pro and you do Pro work and you want to plug it into a

2:12:45display at your desk to have a big display, they're clearly, especially the 15-inch,

2:12:50But even that the current 13-inch has such powerful graphics

2:12:54They can easily drive a 5k display and if you're doing the sort of work that it would benefit from having a big display

2:13:00What are you supposed to buy to plug your computer into I to me it is that coming out of WWDC. It is the biggest

2:13:07Hey Apple, you've done great work in the last couple of years. You've really been listening to the pro market

2:13:14But here's the one thing you've got to do because if you don't do it, nobody is going to do it

2:13:19- Yeah, and that's the key.

2:13:20It's like, I'm okay with Apple saying,

2:13:23you know, this market is served, we don't need to be in it.

2:13:25But the problem is that this market

2:13:27is now not really being served.

2:13:29And that's a little bit like Apple,

2:13:30I'm okay with Apple discontinuing the airport

2:13:33because other wifi systems are available.

2:13:35But imagine that there were no wifi powders

2:13:37other than airports, and then they discontinued it.

2:13:39You're like, wait a second, wait a second, I need my wifi.

2:13:42And that's, and again, I understand that perhaps

2:13:45that product's not ready or they think it's better timed

2:13:47with a release if they do this like rumored 16 inch revised laptop thing,

2:13:51wouldn't it be great to have an external monitor as part of that story? I get it.

2:13:55And yet at the same time,

2:13:56this pro display XDR shown off in front of developers who don't want it,

2:14:00it's like you could have avoided the controversy here if you had had another

2:14:05monitor that you pre announced, right? But they didn't.

2:14:08And one of the features that the,

2:14:10the pro display XDR has that they showed off is that you can

2:14:14rotate it to go from portrait.

2:14:17yeah, to land or landscape to portrait,

2:14:19which to me is a very developer friendly feature because developers write code

2:14:24and code scrolls up and down and it doesn't go horizontally.

2:14:31It's almost like rubbing it in your face.

2:14:34Like wouldn't this be great as a developer to have this six K display that you

2:14:38can rotate to go up and down so you can see more lines of code up and down.

2:14:44Do you remember? I'm sure you do the radius radius full page display on. I had one on

2:14:52at my desk at my college newspaper. All of our page layouts. We had one two page display

2:14:57on a like a Mac to everything else was this portrait radius display where we did all of

2:15:04our page layout. That's basically how I started using a Mac. I was one of those to having

2:15:08a back in that era in the early nineties. Having a display that went up and down was

2:15:13amazing. John, this is why I have those crazy iPad stands now is because I can actually

2:15:18write on my iPad with an external keyboard and I can put it in portrait. It's great.

2:15:25But to show that to developers, and I know you think really, really hope it all makes

2:15:32sense if in the bag in their back pocket, they've already been planning on a regular

2:15:39Pro display that costs, let's just say, costs $1,000. Maybe it's $1,500 because it comes

2:15:45with a $500 stand. The developers I talked to would be happy if they could pay the price

2:15:52of an iMac 5K and just get the screen, right? If they have that in their back pocket and

2:16:00the only reason they didn't announce it is they want to save it for when the Mac Pro

2:16:05actually ships this fall.

2:16:08Or when that new fancy new laptop comes out.

2:16:11Which might be the same event at the same time.

2:16:12It could be the same event. That would be great. And then all will be forgiven. And

2:16:17we'll be like, ah, we get it. We wanted to save some good news for when people could

2:16:22actually take out their credit cards and buy the thing and they're excited to do it. But

2:16:25you also wanted to show off with this crazy, it's worth $50,000, but we're selling it for

2:16:32for six or $7,000 Pro Display XDR.

2:16:35- Okay, great. - That's the sad truth

2:16:36of the Pro Display XDR is that everybody's making a big deal

2:16:38about that $1,000 stand and all of that.

2:16:40This is a piece of extremely high-end equipment

2:16:43almost nobody will want.

2:16:44And for the people who will want it, it's such a deal.

2:16:48It's actually a good value

2:16:50because they're gonna stop buying $40,000.

2:16:52I mean, I don't really feel bad for Sony,

2:16:55but it's like, Sony is sitting there going, "Oh no,

2:16:58"like we can't charge $40,000

2:17:00for a reference monitor anymore because Apple selling one that's basically as good for six

2:17:06grand like that's it's an amazing product it's amazing breakthrough it's actually in

2:17:10some ways it strikes me as being one of the more innovative breakthrough bits of hardware

2:17:15that Apple has done in a while it's just in such an esoteric market that like you know

2:17:21when was when was the last time we talked about reference monitors for pro video on

2:17:25your podcast never never ever I didn't even know it was a limited thing yeah I didn't

2:17:30- Yeah, so it's brilliant.

2:17:33It's just, it's a product that nobody actually,

2:17:35outside of this very small few want.

2:17:37It's brilliant for those people, but for the rest of us,

2:17:39it's like, where is my 5K or 6K display

2:17:42that I can put on my desk with my Mac Pro or MacBook Pro

2:17:45or Mac Mini or whatever.

2:17:47- And it just takes us into the heart of being

2:17:51in the Apple ecosystem as a user,

2:17:54is that you're implicitly, explicitly really,

2:17:58putting your faith in Apple because nobody else can do it. If you're all in on iOS, you

2:18:04can't buy a tablet or a phone from another company, right? You can't. You can make a

2:18:09hackintosh so that, you know, the Mac is a little different where you can unofficially

2:18:13create a hackintosh in a way that you can't even do as a hobbyist on a phone. But for

2:18:22the most part, if you're in the Mac ecosystem, you're buying Apple hardware and that gets

2:18:27to especially on laptops it gets to the whole debate we've been having over a

2:18:31couple last couple of years with the last you know modern revisions of the

2:18:36entire MacBook lineup from the you know entry level to the probe models and the

2:18:41decisions they've made on ports and thickness and of course keyboards etc

2:18:45you know we're all in on this and if their keyboards don't work right you

2:18:50know you're getting a keyboard that doesn't work right because that's your

2:18:53any choice. It's great and the bigger problem by far was the apparent, hey, they don't really have

2:19:02workstation class hardware anymore. So if you want to do workstation class work on the Mac,

2:19:09you're kind of out of luck and they've solved it. Now they've got the iMac Pro and the Mac Pro and

2:19:15They're truly, truly scaled to phenomenal distances

2:19:20of technical, I mean, 1.5 terabytes of RAM is crazy.

2:19:24I mean, that's like, as far as I can tell,

2:19:26that's gonna cost at least like $40,000 for the RAM.

2:19:29- Maybe more, you may be, you know,

2:19:31I'm sure there will be a six-figure configuration

2:19:33of this thing, right?

2:19:34- Yeah, I honestly think that you might be able

2:19:35to get like a $100,000 Mac Pro with,

2:19:38if you max out all of the cores and all the RAM

2:19:40and the SSD storage, it's insane.

2:19:42But it's great that that exists

2:19:44because there's some people who are like, yeah, sign me up. I need that. You know, I

2:19:48actually have work that, that, that would justify it. Um, but we're still, a lot of

2:19:53us want, a lot of us want it, but very few of us need it. Right. It's the truth of it.

2:19:58But we're to me, the hole that is left in the lineup is so glaring at this five K standalone

2:20:03display and nobody else is going to make it. There's just no way. I mean, LG sort of had

2:20:09it and got out of the business. So who else is wonder if if that is because Apple use

2:20:14them as a partner and then remember they had the thing where like they were blocking the

2:20:17Wi Fi and it wasn't all these bad things about it that they had to fix. I wonder if when

2:20:23Apple decided because that was at that event where I was told and and I think Neelay was

2:20:29told Apple is like out of the display business. That's why we're showing you this LG display

2:20:34because we're not going to make displays anymore. I wonder if LG's abandonment of that.

2:20:39market is a sign that they know that Apple is going to do that product and they don't

2:20:44need to work with Apple anymore. Apple doesn't need them anymore to soldier on with that

2:20:49product.

2:20:50Or they just need them as a component maker. Give us the panel, right?

2:20:52Right, right. We're going to brand it as Apple and put our secret sauce on it and improve

2:20:56the profit margin on it and that'll be great and we're just going to keep buying the panels

2:20:59from you. Maybe that's it. I actually, this is why I'm kind of hopeful that it'll happen

2:21:03is it's a product that needs to exist. Somebody's got to make it and the fact that LG is not

2:21:06making it feels a little like a timing thing where we're in transition to a new product

2:21:12and maybe that will be an actual Apple labeled product. That would make John Saracusa very

2:21:17happy. Yeah, it definitely would. And really like every developer who not just Mac Pro

2:21:24people, but anybody who's got an iMac or an iMac Pro or a MacBook Pro or I'll say it again,

2:21:31that Mac Mini actually scales pretty well. You can get a pretty powerful Mac Mini, but

2:21:35then what do you attach it to? Right? Exactly. Right. What do you, what do you, what do you

2:21:39buy? Tell me what, tell me what to buy. Phil Schiller. Tell me what monitor to this Mac

2:21:43mini out to it. Absolutely. Really. You know, just, just shut up and take my money is where

2:21:48we are with it. And I'll just say this too. I mean, I didn't sit in front of the pro display

2:21:53XDR for an extended period of time. It was all in the hands on areas and brief demos

2:21:57and stuff, but a thousand nits is super bright. I mean like, you know, like I think the IMAX

2:22:04capped at 500 nits. So about half the maximum brightness on a 5K. The maximum brightness

2:22:09on an iMac is just fine for normal use. If you're writing code or reading or whatever,

2:22:17it's not in the least bit dull or dim. It's just that a thousand is insanely bright. It

2:22:24is like, put sunscreen on your face bright.

2:22:26Tim Cynova Yeah, it is. It is hilarious just how bright

2:22:31that monitor is. And that was one of the things that came through in that sort of dim room

2:22:35with all the different monitors is this is not like I don't even run my iMac at full

2:22:40brightness.

2:22:41No, I don't either. I'm looking at it right now and it's like, yeah, I don't even have

2:22:43this on full brightness. It's bright enough. Anyway, hopefully fingers crossed Apple knows

2:22:49what they're doing and they're just saving a little bit of ammunition to have something

2:22:53nice to announce in the fall. And if not, hopefully they'll listen to the show and get

2:23:00started or at least at least turn the iMac at least let a regular iMac be a

2:23:05standalone display and just let people buy it and let the the computer part of it go to waste and just use it as a

2:23:12Display it it's almost baffling that that you that this product doesn't exist

2:23:18Yeah, how many times did you get asked I got asked, you know, like

2:23:22You know like friends and family like family people know

2:23:26"Oh, you go out to California every June

2:23:28"for this Apple thing."

2:23:29And they don't read my website.

2:23:32They just know vaguely what I do.

2:23:34And the one thing they wanted to talk about

2:23:37was the $1,000 monitor arm.

2:23:39- Yeah, yeah, I didn't get much.

2:23:43I mean, so here for me, it was my son said,

2:23:46"Oh, they made that stand that cost $1,000."

2:23:50'Cause obviously he saw a YouTuber

2:23:52who was making jokes about it.

2:23:53And I was like, "Yeah, well, it's complicated

2:23:55"and it's not for..."

2:23:56But I'm like, yeah.

2:23:56I mean, and that to me is the sign

2:23:58that you just made a major PR fumble

2:24:00is that nobody remembers anything

2:24:02but this thing that you did

2:24:04that you totally didn't need to do.

2:24:06But that's how it is.

2:24:07So yeah, for me, it was not my relatives so much

2:24:09as my son who's on this totally other,

2:24:12'cause Julian and Jonas are about the same age.

2:24:15And they obviously get all of their information

2:24:17from YouTube at this point.

2:24:18- All of it, 100%.

2:24:18100% of his information about the world comes from YouTube.

2:24:22Did you see the side-by-side of the matte finish?

2:24:25I know they're not calling it matte.

2:24:27They're calling it the nano, nano etched, whatever.

2:24:31But let's just say matte and glossy.

2:24:34Did you get to see them side by side?

2:24:36- I did.

2:24:37- The matte is so nice.

2:24:40- I just, I actually just wrote a piece

2:24:41that I turned in this morning for Tom's Guide.

2:24:45'Cause I'm writing about iPhones over there

2:24:46every other week or something like that.

2:24:48And for Phil Michaels, my old pal from Macworld,

2:24:51who's at Tom's Guide now.

2:24:52And this piece was like, what hardware,

2:24:55Now that iPhone rumors go out to 2020,

2:24:57which is ridiculous to fall of 2020,

2:25:00where should Apple steer in terms of hardware innovation?

2:25:06What are the places that it feels like

2:25:07there's room for them to push?

2:25:09And one of the things I wrote was,

2:25:11still a lot of glare on these iPhone and iPad screens.

2:25:15And I wonder like this Nano Edge stuff,

2:25:19I get that you're shooting a laser

2:25:21to make little things in class.

2:25:22And I get that it's not a touchscreen

2:25:24and it doesn't have to have the unbreakability

2:25:29that Gorilla Glass needs.

2:25:30And yet part of me is like,

2:25:32can you talk to Corning about the lasers

2:25:35for the laser-etched glass?

2:25:37'Cause I would really love it if my iPad and my iPhone

2:25:40were not glarey like they are.

2:25:42That would be really nice.

2:25:44- Wouldn't you, I would like it on my MacBook too,

2:25:46especially a MacBook. - Yeah, oh, for sure.

2:25:48- I feel like with the handheld ones,

2:25:49you can at least tilt them a little.

2:25:51Whereas the MacBook, you sort of prop it up

2:25:54whatever table you're in front of and the angle sort of defines itself. You don't really.

2:25:58I never ever since Apple put that single pane of glass in front of the display on the Mac book.

2:26:04The glare has been pretty, you know, it's way more severe than it used to be. So yeah, that's

2:26:09one of these things that I have in the back of my mind. Again, it's like, I'm not going to buy

2:26:12the $6,000 monitor, but that technology and I get that it added $1,000 to the price of the monitor,

2:26:19But that technology is really interesting because it's like, you know, who are they working with on

2:26:24the glass? What is this process? And does it have applications elsewhere in the product line? Because

2:26:29like, wouldn't it be great if you could get maybe not for $1,000, but you could get a true matte

2:26:35MacBook screen that was not just a coding and maybe it's like a $300 upgrade, you know,

2:26:43Right. Right. You know, even the size of a MacBook screen to the size of the Pro Display XDR screen,

2:26:50I would pay $300 in an instant heartbeat for that finish because it is so nice. It is truly

2:26:58remarkable. And it is, by definition, unphotographable. There is no way that you can,

2:27:05it's by definition, you can't really show the difference other than seeing it in person side

2:27:12by side. And yeah, the way I describe it is sort of like if you stand off access from

2:27:17it, you can see people's faces reflected in the in the non glare one or in the glare

2:27:23one and in the non glare one. It's like they're vampires. They're just gone. Yeah,

2:27:27oh, there's no reflection on that screen that that was what did it for me. Yeah, there

2:27:32there was some weird lighting. They held a bunch of the briefings. I'm sure you were

2:27:35at some of them in the Marriott Hotel adjacent to the convention center and those sure the

2:27:41meeting rooms that they have there have very strange lighting, sort of like an '80s futuristic

2:27:48lighting on the ceiling, but with these very long and prominent lighting fixtures in a

2:27:56square pattern on the roof and on the ceiling. That, to me, was the test. It was like on

2:28:02the glary one, on the regular one, you could easily see those white lines of the lights,

2:28:07and then you'd go right next to the next one, and you'd expect to see it continue right

2:28:11across from the one display to the other and it just disappeared. It wasn't like, "Oh,

2:28:15there's less glare." There was none. None at all. Unbelievable. So, you think of it

2:28:21as a $1,000 finish and you think, "Wow, that's pretty expensive." But when you think of it

2:28:25as going from $6,000 to $7,000 and it's only a 16% increase, you're like, "Oh, for 16%

2:28:32more, I would get that in a heartbeat." It's so much nicer that it almost makes me wonder

2:28:38why they even offer the one without it. Like why not just say here it is it everyone has

2:28:43the matte finish and it's $7,000. I had that same thought because it goes back to the stand

2:28:48to it's like look everybody's going to get the stand and you make a mounting option just

2:28:53roll in the price of the stand roll in the price of the of the match right it's just

2:28:58say it's $8,000 it's the best display anybody's ever made in the world and in small print

2:29:05"Oh, if you want to save $1,000, you can omit the stand."

2:29:08- Yeah, sure. - Yeah.

2:29:09Anything else jump out at you?

2:29:11I know we've been going on for a while.

2:29:12We're always going on when you're on.

2:29:13- I mean, for me, the iPad, just iPadOS,

2:29:18not just the name, which is like, it's interesting too,

2:29:21because it is a marketing name.

2:29:23You brought this up at the talk show with Craig and Jaws.

2:29:26A name is always marketing.

2:29:29You could argue that WatchOS is kind of iOS,

2:29:32TVOS is kind of iOS, but what they've decided to do

2:29:34brand them based on the device because the idea there is it's the device that runs the

2:29:39object. And iPadOS is really just sort of saying, you know, we have features here at

2:29:46Apple that we build for iPad users and you use them as an iPad user. And I like that.

2:29:51I also feel it gives them less place to hide next year if they try to withhold iPad features

2:29:56every other year like they've done the past few years that like now we're going to be

2:30:00like, well, what about iPad OS? And there's a question there. And like, you know, even

2:30:05like Tim Cook had to do a few slides about tvOS at the keynote, right? Like he had to,

2:30:10it was obligatory because tvOS is a product in their lineup. They have to talk about it,

2:30:14but it was telling that it was the only platform where he didn't call anybody else out. Like

2:30:18he went through it so fast that instead of calling, you know, Eddie Q or somebody to

2:30:22come up and talk about it, Tim was like, I'll do this myself. And then my feeling was like,

2:30:26Hey, you're the Apple or you're the tvOS product manager. It's like, well, I got good news

2:30:30for you. Tim Cook is going to read your slides personally. The bad news is that you're not

2:30:35important enough to have somebody else come out. You will be sitting in the audience for

2:30:39this presentation. But yeah, I just think as an iPad user, I essentially I'm a Mac user

2:30:44at my desk and I am an iPad user when I'm not at my desk. I don't really use a MacBook.

2:30:49My family has them. I have an old MacBook Air that I use occasionally, but I basically

2:30:53use an iPad when I'm traveling or even just sort of out in the house or in the backyard

2:30:58or whatever. And so for me, this is that year where we got lots of good iPad features, which

2:31:04is great. Now, I hope I hope now that the name is out there, we continue to get them

2:31:07every year. But there's a lot of good stuff in there. It's a you know, it's a work in

2:31:13progress. We'll see what they do in the in the betas. The complication of making multi

2:31:18window iPad apps is I mean, that's such a hard thing to get right. And parts of it work

2:31:25like magic and other parts of it are a little bit baffling. I mean, you know, you brought up,

2:31:31like you tap on the notes app and it shows you it's expose and it shows you all of your open

2:31:36windows for notes. That's great. But if you alt or, uh, you know, command tab into notes,

2:31:41it just kind of goes to one of them and which one is it. And that may just be a bug. They may fix

2:31:47that. But it's one of those cases where like, it's still trying to navigate, like what's a window,

2:31:52how is it like an app? How is it not like an app? But I'll tell you, there's a whole litany of

2:31:58things that computers have had for so long and that for some reason, technical or political,

2:32:02the iPad has refused that with this release, they're like, "Yeah, okay. You can plug in USB

2:32:08drives. You can mount SMB servers. You can open multiple Windows. You can open multiple documents

2:32:13in an app. So you can have two Word documents open side by side if you want. We'll let you do that."

2:32:17Well, that's really that's awful. Nice of you. Yeah, since I've had that on my Mac for

2:32:2125-30 years that we finally get that or even longer, but we finally get that on the iPad,

2:32:26but I'm glad they're there, right? Like it was it was a joke that they hadn't been there already,

2:32:31but at least they're there now. Command tab is interesting and you know, let's give credit to

2:32:36Microsoft for inventing command tab back in the day. You know, it's for sure certainly something

2:32:41that Apple took from Windows and added to the Mac.

2:32:46I was talking about it at WWDC with some people.

2:32:50We were trying to remember what the names

2:32:51of the utilities were, but before Apple

2:32:54officially supported Command Tab on the Mac,

2:32:56there were a couple of popular third-party Mac utilities

2:32:59that offered it.

2:33:01It's a great idea.

2:33:05I don't know.

2:33:07It's so innate to my muscle memory

2:33:11that I kind of can't remember not having it,

2:33:13but I do remember, I know that for years

2:33:16I used a Mac without it.

2:33:18And it works great in the Mac interface.

2:33:22It just is, you know, you command tab,

2:33:24it shows a list of all your running apps.

2:33:26When you select one, all of the windows for that app

2:33:29come forward but maintain their relative indexes

2:33:33to each other.

2:33:36It does what you expect.

2:33:38It is, it's just part of my brain.

2:33:41But on the iPad, to me, it's never sat right.

2:33:44At least since, it's like,

2:33:46I don't know when they first supported it.

2:33:48Maybe they've had it all along.

2:33:49'Cause remember, they had a keyboard with the original.

2:33:52- Yeah, I think it's been there for a long time

2:33:54and maybe forever, yeah.

2:33:56- It only, to me, on the iPad, works

2:33:59when you're using the iPad in the iPhone sense

2:34:03of each app gets the whole screen.

2:34:06And once you go split screen on iPad,

2:34:09the command tab interface to me completely breaks down.

2:34:12It's a mismatch of UI metaphors.

2:34:16And the fact that you can't command tab to some places

2:34:20is just bizarre, right?

2:34:21- Yeah, and it's been that way

2:34:23where there's also like apps that,

2:34:25I don't know if this is true in 13, but in iOS 12,

2:34:27depending on how an app gets open,

2:34:31Like if an app gets opened by another app,

2:34:33it doesn't show up at the command tab switcher,

2:34:35which like, what is that about?

2:34:37But that's, I always view that as a bug,

2:34:39but it's a really bad, weird bug.

2:34:41And now I think this is the question is,

2:34:44shouldn't, should the command tab switcher trigger

2:34:48an expose kind of thing?

2:34:49- I think it should. - If you've got

2:34:50multiple windows open.

2:34:51- I think that whether it should be the expose

2:34:53that you get as you drag up from the bottom

2:34:56of the iPad screen, or whether they redo the expose

2:34:59so that there can be one unified switching interface.

2:35:02I feel very strongly that the single thing

2:35:05that iPad OS needs the most is a unification

2:35:09of command tab switching versus swipe up switching.

2:35:13Because when you swipe up, everything makes visual sense.

2:35:16You can see, oh, I have notes paired with messages here

2:35:21in a space, and I have notes, a different note,

2:35:25but the same app, Notes, paired with Safari over here,

2:35:29that's the one I want, and I can tap it,

2:35:31and it brings, it comes forward.

2:35:33Whereas when you do the Command + Tab thing,

2:35:35and you go to Notes, and it doesn't bring up

2:35:37the one you want, and there's no other option,

2:35:39it just feels broken.

2:35:40I feel like that's a hole in the interface

2:35:42that they should fix.

2:35:43But overall, I think that the way that they've expanded

2:35:47the multi-panel interface for iPadOS

2:35:52is really, really clever,

2:35:54And I really think it's, especially, I think for people who like you,

2:35:58who that's your primary port or your only portable machine,

2:36:02being able to do two up is to me, magical. I brought that up at my talk show,

2:36:07but two is the magic number where it's like you have old and new left and right.

2:36:11And if you can look at two notes at the same time or two word documents or

2:36:16Google documents using the iPad desktop browsing or whatever,

2:36:21Two up is magical and being able to do that is a huge, huge winner.

2:36:26Slide over,

2:36:27which was really just kind of like a remnant of the original concept and it was

2:36:32always a little bit weird and kind of hard to get rid of and hard to manage.

2:36:35It's actually gone to be what they'd done with that is turn it into an iPhone

2:36:40basically, which is brilliant.

2:36:42So the now it's going to be much more useful because now the slide over thing,

2:36:47you know,

2:36:47you sort of slide it out and it's a floating window above your content,

2:36:50but you can swipe on the bottom like you can on the bottom of an iPhone 10, and it'll just go

2:36:56through all of your different apps and windows that are there. Or you can swipe up and get

2:37:01a little multitasking app switcher just for SlideOver. And so now SlideOver is no longer

2:37:05this kind of like app in a box off on the side. It's now like quick access to any app you want

2:37:15for a moment, which I feel like it's way more powerful

2:37:18a concept now than it was before.

2:37:21And I actually think I will use it

2:37:23in a way that I just never bothered with the old one,

2:37:26because now it's just so easy to just get at anything

2:37:29for a moment, do what you need to, and then flip it away.

2:37:32And that's a good concept, I like that.

2:37:35- And I do this, I wonder if you do too,

2:37:38but I'll do this where I'm working on my iPad,

2:37:40and sometimes even my Mac too,

2:37:41but I'll take out my phone and do something on my phone,

2:37:46literally my actual phone, just 'cause I know it's brief.

2:37:49And I know that some of the continuity features

2:37:53are so great that I can count on it.

2:37:55Let's say I know that I saw a tweet from Jason Snell

2:37:59and he had a link that I definitely want

2:38:01to get on my Mac somehow.

2:38:04I'll just go to my phone and there it is,

2:38:06'cause I left Tweetbot there and I can copy it

2:38:09and copy it from my phone

2:38:10and then just switch to my Mac and paste

2:38:12and continuity will make, you know,

2:38:14give me the thing I just copied on the other device.

2:38:17I feel like you can use SlideOver like that now.

2:38:19Like, it's sort of like having a, like you said,

2:38:21like having an iPhone on your iPad screen

2:38:24just for like a one-off, you know,

2:38:26get this thing and then get rid of it.

2:38:28- Yeah, yeah, and you can, if it's not the app,

2:38:30the big frustration before was like,

2:38:32if it's not the app that you want,

2:38:33then it's this whole thing where you're going through

2:38:35and like trying to find what app you wanna drop there,

2:38:37and now you just flip through 'em

2:38:39until you find the thing you want

2:38:40and then grab it and then flip it away and that's it.

2:38:43I think it's a good,

2:38:45I'm impressed with how they really rethought

2:38:48the slide over thing is like,

2:38:49what do we do with slide over to make it better?

2:38:51And the answer was, we're gonna take,

2:38:52and this may not have been an accident,

2:38:54it may have been part of the big picture even last year,

2:38:56but whoever said, oh, our method of navigating

2:39:00in iPhone 10 is the same method we should use for slide over.

2:39:05It's like, yes, good job, whoever thought of that

2:39:08it's exactly right. I feel like it's a little bit of column A and a little bit of column B,

2:39:13but I kind of feel like it's a little bit more by design. I really think that the sort of

2:39:20rethinking that they went into for the iPhone X, "Let's get rid of the home button and make

2:39:28everybody use a gestural thing," I think that was thought through to how would this grow to

2:39:35bigger devices or to something like, sure, the iPad is a bigger device. But what if you have an

2:39:42iPhone style window on that bigger device? Right? Yeah, it does feel like they, you know, you do you

2:39:49make some decisions because of expediency, and you have to get there. And then at some point, you need

2:39:53to revisit and say, Can we coordinate all this? So it makes sense, you know, a bunch of different

2:39:57places. And that's what they did. Yeah. And the other area and it's funny that you brought that

2:40:02up because I was thinking about is one of my things I thought about at WWDC when I saw this

2:40:05interface was the other thing that really makes a lot of sense on the iPad and not on the iPhone is

2:40:13that only having one home button really hurt the iPad with trying to have two apps on the

2:40:22screen at a time right because what is what is the home button controlling the left one the right one

2:40:26Who knows now both of them have a little home switcher that you can that you can trigger

2:40:32It feels way more natural if if if you're thinking hey

2:40:36I should be able to have two apps on screen two different apps or maybe the two instances of the same app on screen at a

2:40:42time

2:40:44shouldn't they both have a home button and

2:40:46Because now that now they can and it didn't really make sense before

2:40:50right

2:40:53Anything else what else are you thinking about?

2:40:55For me that was the that was the the big the biggest news was just beyond the

2:41:01Catalyst Swift UI stuff and the Mac Pro was just that the iPad got some love which I am always happy to see I can plug in

2:41:08You know what? I did this morning John for the very first time

2:41:11I plugged a USB C thumb drive into my iPad and it just showed up in the files app

2:41:16I should not be as happy about that as I am

2:41:19finally

2:41:21You know, I talked about that with the guys at my show with Craig and Jaws and I feel like

2:41:27Craig kind of joked his way out of that

2:41:30I forget exactly what he said, but it's a bigger technical underpinning and I think I'm almost convinced

2:41:36It's tied to the Mac change

2:41:38Where kernel extensions now can be run in user space instead of in the kernel memory space?

2:41:45Like I think that that's part of what they're doing on the iPad where the USB stack that that allows these drives to run is

2:41:52Not running in kernel space. It's a brand new USB stack. I feel like maybe that was too technical and they didn't want to

2:42:00Spill the beans on it. He did mention security issues and whenever I've written about it people said well

2:42:05You could have a bad USB stick and my thought has always been what I know but I need to do my work

2:42:09well, I will say this though and it's a thing to watch for on the Mac side is

2:42:14Now on iOS, you can plug in a USB drive and use it,

2:42:18and then you just unplug it when you're done.

2:42:20It's like, that needs to happen on the Mac.

2:42:22It is, how many times do I mount something on my Mac,

2:42:26and then I unmount it, and it goes away in the finder,

2:42:28and then I unplug it, and it says, no, I wasn't done.

2:42:31Like, why do I have to do that?

2:42:34Come on.

2:42:34- Right, that feels old.

2:42:37- So I'm ready.

2:42:38I'm ready for the moment where I can just unplug the device,

2:42:41and the system does the right thing.

2:42:43That would be great.

2:42:44But the iPad does that now, so that's great.

2:42:46I'm very glad that they did it.

2:42:48I get, and this is a recurring theme,

2:42:50a lot of people are like,

2:42:51"Oh, why is Apple so slow with some of these features?"

2:42:54When going back to that thing about

2:42:56everything's about privacy and security,

2:42:57like some of these things, they're like,

2:42:59"Well, if we're going to implement it,

2:43:01we need to do it right."

2:43:03Which means we need to do it securely,

2:43:05and we need to invent a whole new thing

2:43:08in order to have this thing work securely.

2:43:10And that's, I think, why some of these features

2:43:12just don't happen is because it's not that they couldn't

2:43:16mount USB in files.

2:43:19It's because they were concerned about that

2:43:21as an attack vector, probably already,

2:43:24given that you could attach USB devices

2:43:27for importing of videos and photos into the Photos app.

2:43:30And we're like, it's on our list,

2:43:32is to do that in a more secure way,

2:43:33and then we can roll it into files.

2:43:35And it would not surprise me at all

2:43:37if that's exactly what happened this year.

2:43:38- Yeah, I'm pretty sure it is.

2:43:40And I feel like they didn't wanna talk about it

2:43:42'cause they don't wanna make excuses for themselves.

2:43:44And so they didn't really wanna go into detail.

2:43:46- They didn't like to be mysterious, right?

2:43:48It's like, well, you'll get it when we're ready.

2:43:49And that's it.

2:43:51- It is true.

2:43:53It is a very funny thing to be very excited about,

2:43:55but just plugging a USB drive into yours.

2:43:57- I know, I feel bad.

2:43:58And I mounted my Mac Mini as an SMP server and files,

2:44:01and I was excited about that too.

2:44:03And I'm like, what is wrong with me?

2:44:04These are basic things.

2:44:06But when you go without water for enough days,

2:44:09you are desperate for water.

2:44:10So there we are.

2:44:13- Jason Snell, thank you very much.

2:44:15I'm gonna emphasize again,

2:44:17I think you guys even have another episode out.

2:44:19I think upgrade 250 is already out.

2:44:20- Yeah, yeah.

2:44:21- Upgrade 249 is the one where you interview

2:44:24Wiley Hodges and Josh Shaffer,

2:44:27which honestly, I don't mince words here,

2:44:31must listen interview in terms of understanding

2:44:34the scope of Swift UI.

2:44:36It's just tremendous.

2:44:38- Well, thank you.

2:44:39You've got at least 60 other podcasts you do every week.

2:44:42- That's pretty much true.

2:44:44- Incomparable, where I've been on a couple of times.

2:44:47We talked about 2001 sometime in the last year.

2:44:51- Yeah, yeah.

2:44:53And we got a couple others in there with you on them,

2:44:55which are nice.

2:44:56We're gonna have to do that again sometime.

2:44:58But that's the pop culture thing.

2:45:00And actually, one I wanted to mention is I do a podcast

2:45:04at the end of every week with, it's called TV Talk Machine.

2:45:08with Tim Goodman, who is the TV critic at The Hollywood Reporter. And we spend a lot

2:45:11of time talking about not just like new TV shows, but we do spend a lot of time talking

2:45:16about kind of the weird landscape of the television industry now, mostly disrupted by technology

2:45:21companies like Apple, and the advent of streaming services like Netflix and Prime Video. And

2:45:27that's a fun, fun podcast if you care about sort of like TV and the future of entertainment.

2:45:33We spend a lot of time

2:45:34Where do people go to get this podcast?

2:45:37Go to the incomparable.com and you can see a list of all the podcasts and

2:45:41the incomparable is there and TV Talk Machine is there.

2:45:43TV Talk Machine.

2:45:44And then Relay FM for upgrade and download. There's a lot of podcasts is what I'm saying.

2:45:51And Six Colors dot com. All the things I do, Jon, are linked to from Six Colors,

2:45:55whether it's a podcast or a column at Macworld or Tom's Guide or the stuff that I just read on

2:46:00the site. That's the place to find me. Six Colors dot com.

2:46:03So why don't we just go to six colors and you can and I as I always like to mention you can spell colors

2:46:08However you want

2:46:09Yeah within reason but I did I did register

2:46:12I did register with the you for our friends who are not in the US you can spell it

2:46:17Correctly, however you want

2:46:20Yes

2:46:22Anyway, Jason, thank you very much. This is great

2:46:24It's I'm always happy to be on and so thanks for having me on

2:46:28Alright till next time