Podcast Search

The Talk Show

248: ‘Equally Confused’ With Peter Kafka

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Peter Kafka, welcome to the talk show. I,

0:00:03thank you for having me on the talk show, John.

0:00:04I have been on your show. You've never been on mine.

0:00:07I'm happy to come to Philadelphia someday. I'm there with some frequency.

0:00:11Are you really? Yeah. Yeah. I got in-laws there. Oh, well that's a great city.

0:00:16I can get you good tickets for the Thanksgiving day parade.

0:00:18That's the kind of thing that floats your boat.

0:00:19I, we always get out of town for Thanksgiving.

0:00:24All right. You change your mind.

0:00:27So for background, you are what what's your beat at recode?

0:00:31I covered the intersection of media and technology.

0:00:35And who better to have on the show this week? Good timing, right?

0:00:40I actually missed last week's event.

0:00:46I was not present at the event because my family had a long scheduled

0:00:51vacation. It coincided with my son's spring break. So it's the first,

0:00:55It's the first event I've missed in,

0:00:58I don't know how many years.

0:00:59A long, long time ago, I had an injury or eye surgery

0:01:03that prevented me from flying.

0:01:05So I missed one a couple of years ago.

0:01:07But you were there, of course.

0:01:10- Yeah, I would not miss this one.

0:01:12I haven't met her that many,

0:01:14but I was definitely gonna make it to this one

0:01:16one way or another.

0:01:17- I would have made an exception in just about any case,

0:01:19but this was pretty exceptional.

0:01:21And you know, my son's getting older,

0:01:22so it was a big exception.

0:01:24I had a feeling like it would be different, you know?

0:01:29It was different.

0:01:30Yeah, there's, I don't want to say that something like the iPhone events in September

0:01:39are repetitive, because they're not. The stuff moves forward, but it's…

0:01:44But they kind of are repetitive, right? I mean, I think to get all meta, I mean, I do get the sense,

0:01:52I don't track it that closely because we're not really in that business, but that these

0:01:55events are drawing less attention from just ordinary sort of people who would pay attention

0:02:00to this stuff.

0:02:01If you're in the business of live blogging and stuff or writing about it, I think it

0:02:06attracts less attention than it did a few years ago because I think it's a new iPhone.

0:02:09It's not that compelling.

0:02:10Right.

0:02:11And that's sort of the meta, the annual meta response to them is, "Hmm, just another iPhone."

0:02:18And it kind of makes sense that it's just another iPhone.

0:02:22That's exactly what most people want.

0:02:23But then it makes the flow of the event sort of, you know, it's like season 11 of the

0:02:28iPhone show.

0:02:29Yeah, it's a little road.

0:02:31Whereas this was all new territory, and it was preceded, we don't have to cover it

0:02:35all.

0:02:36I did an episode before with all of the various hardware stuff that Apple released the week

0:02:39before.

0:02:41which was interesting in that they had these new things ready to go and didn't want to put them in

0:02:48the show. They wanted the show to focus entirely on quote unquote services. It's not a single

0:02:54reference to hardware that I recall. I'm sure someone will then fact check me and say there

0:02:58is one, but I mean, I don't remember any reference to any piece of hardware. Yeah, I don't think so.

0:03:02I mean, other than saying that you can see these things on your phone and your iPad and your Apple

0:03:07to be here. Yes, Oprah mentioned phones. A billion devices in your pocket, y'all.

0:03:12So let me just start and I will, let me just read a little bit of your take.

0:03:22Well, actually, let's go through these things in the order that Apple went through them.

0:03:28And let's wait for the new video service. So the first one is Apple News. And I can,

0:03:36can, oh, I kind of see why they went first with this. I mean, because obviously, they

0:03:42spent the most time on the TV plus their new their new original content stuff. And that's

0:03:47where they had a little bit of star power. So you really can't do that first. You can't

0:03:53go from Oprah and Steven Spielberg and Jennifer Aniston to

0:03:57Yeah, it'd be weird to end it with with magazines,

0:04:01magazines but also it's the only thing they announced that as of today we can

0:04:08actually use that's right so it kind of makes sense to go first I'm I'm used to

0:04:15understanding them or I guess the big thing and I will cheat I will cheat I'm

0:04:20gonna go back and I'm gonna say this was your take on the event I got to read

0:04:23this because I think it's so perfect you opened your take on the event with I

0:04:26I have some questions about Apple's new video service.

0:04:29What exactly is Apple going to have

0:04:32in its new video service?

0:04:34What, if anything, will Apple's new video service cost?

0:04:38Why would someone pay anything

0:04:40for Apple's new video service?

0:04:42And then your piece goes on from there.

0:04:43- Yeah.

0:04:44- But I thought that was a great lead

0:04:46because that was my gut feeling following this event

0:04:49remotely was, boy, I sure have a lot of questions

0:04:52coming into this event.

0:04:53And then the event came and it was two hours long and I thought boy, I think I have more questions

0:04:59Yes

0:05:00Coming out of the event and those of us who study this and those of us who know that Apple's getting into this original

0:05:06content and etc

0:05:08Have been thinking for a long time. What are they gonna do? Are they going to charge?

0:05:11Are they gonna charge anything? There was some stories from some media reporters that maybe their original content

0:05:17They would just it would just be free if you had an Apple device

0:05:20We don't even know that. I'm in that group, by the way, but we can talk about it.

0:05:23Right. I'm just saying we had these big questions where, you know,

0:05:28is it going to cost a lot? Is it going to cost a little? Will there be a bundle?

0:05:31What will be bundled? What could you get together? Will it be free? You know,

0:05:35which is what they've done with the meager offerings they've had so far,

0:05:38like Carpool Karaoke and that app show. Planet of the Apps.

0:05:42Planet of the Apps. It's strange. The thing for me that's strange,

0:05:49as somebody who's a very close Apple follower is to come out of an Apple event with more questions as

0:05:56usually I come out with very few questions or the questions that I have are esoteric. You know,

0:06:02it is something like, well, wait, wait a minute. You're saying that the 12 inch iPad pro has

0:06:07one gigabyte more RAM than the smaller iPad pro, you know, something like that. Not

0:06:14not what are you doing? Why did you do this? Those are the two main questions, I think.

0:06:21Well, and I thought maybe the best of your questions too was why would someone pay anything

0:06:26for it? You know, like, why would I buy it is sort of what Apple specializes in at these events. Like,

0:06:32here's why you want this. It they're very good at it. And they're at their best, when it starts with

0:06:40the product and that the, you know, they're not selling you on the product. They're letting the

0:06:47product sell itself by accurately describing what it is that makes it compelling.

0:06:51Scott Horner Yeah, I don't know what the point of having this event so far in advance of having this

0:06:58stuff to sell or even show is. I saw you were floating some theories. I just don't get it.

0:07:04I buy the argument that the fact that you and me and everyone else who's closely watching this

0:07:10is confused by it or maybe disappointed by it won't necessarily matter when they

0:07:14go into comes time to sell it. Apple is really good at selling things. They'll have a lot of

0:07:18ways to sell it. They'll be selling it on those billion plus phones. I don't really matter what

0:07:22John and Peter said in April. But why do an event in March if you don't have the thing ready and

0:07:29can't answer basic questions? I don't I don't get the point of that at all. Yeah. And so before we

0:07:34Before we get into the specifics, two of my theories. One is that other media companies,

0:07:43they require their partnerships for most of these things. They require, by definition,

0:07:48the partnership of magazines and newspapers and online publications like TechCrunch and

0:07:54Vox Media to get them into the Apple News Plus bundle. And they require the participation

0:08:04agreement of the TV networks that are going to be in this TV channels product and they

0:08:09you know and then to it's not quite an organization but the creative people who are

0:08:14making these TV shows and movies for original content are from an industry that is a lot more

0:08:21leaky yeah that's how I do my job right it's just and you know and there have been some good stories

0:08:29some of them by you about like the culture clash between Hollywood and Apple where it's just you

0:08:35know like like things that Hollywood is used to keeping secret are you know what happens at the

0:08:42very end of the Avengers movie right that's right that's a secret that they are culturally equipped

0:08:48to protect so if this was about what the new iPhone was going to be and was going to have

0:08:53a radical departure and was it going to have 28 different whatever the some amazing spec

0:08:58I could see you want to get out in front of that.

0:09:02In this case, I mean, there was no surprise about what the Apple News product was.

0:09:06They bought this thing called Texture a year ago.

0:09:10We all knew they were going to make it this service.

0:09:12They pretty much said that.

0:09:15There's not a lot of secrecy involved there.

0:09:18Most of the terms were sort of well-known.

0:09:20And the TV stuff, Apple has been announcing for the last couple years.

0:09:24They said, "We've hired the guys from Sony."

0:09:26And then every week or so or every couple of weeks, I get an email from someone in Apple

0:09:30Com saying, "This is on background, but we just wanted to confirm that we've ordered

0:09:33a new show."

0:09:35And that email is always timed to exactly when the Hollywood Reporter or Variety then

0:09:39writes a story about that new show being picked up by Apple.

0:09:41So they're doing it in plain sight.

0:09:44They've been announcing all this stuff.

0:09:45The only thing they haven't announced is what they're actually going to do with it,

0:09:48which they still haven't announced.

0:09:51So I don't get the secrecy deflator theory there.

0:09:55Or the leak deflator theory?

0:09:57Well, I don't either so much, which leads me to theory two, which is that this show

0:10:06was for Wall Street.

0:10:08Right.

0:10:09Which in, by which I mean, there is a narrative about Apple as a stock that is that they've

0:10:17reached peak iPhone.

0:10:19And you know, arguably, not inarguably, I would say they've reached peak iPhone in

0:10:24terms of unit sales within the last two years or so. They grew revenue from iPhone last

0:10:31year with the iPhone X because the price went much higher and an awful lot of people went

0:10:37along for it and bought it. Now with the fuller lineup of iPhone X class phones with the super

0:10:46big X Max, whatever they call it, the regular iPhone XS and the XR, the average selling

0:10:54price is probably still higher. But even there, it's leveled off very famously without going

0:11:00on a stock market-oriented episode. Their stock took a bit of a hit, and they had to

0:11:06announce that they missed earnings, and there's crazy stuff going on in China that maybe is

0:11:10affecting them. And so the basic idea is, "Hey, maybe this is peak Apple. Maybe the

0:11:17ride is over, and they're going to start declining." And Apple's answer for a while

0:11:21They have been beating the drum of quote-unquote services, you know with a caravanses services services with a capital a Steve Ballmer. Yeah

0:11:29And

0:11:32And that's what they did that's what they did of the show

0:11:36And again the the the counter to that would be if you want to impress Wall Street you would say

0:11:41Here's the things we're gonna sell and here's how much we're gonna sell them for and thus Wall Street if you're looking for new revenue

0:11:47Look at all this revenue. We're gonna make from

0:11:50Selling subscriptions to the Oprah show or whatever it is that they're gonna sell but they didn't do that either. So again, we're still confused

0:11:57And you know and and there I can't help but think that Hollywood is still a little confused too because you know

0:12:04Like I said, like Hollywood's good at keeping plots secret

0:12:07They know that yeah, you know as far as I know nobody knows what's going on on the new episode

0:12:11I knew the new final series of Game of Thrones

0:12:13Which is gonna find out tonight John going to the premiere. Are you really not to name-drop? Yeah. Are you lucky?

0:12:20Yes, I'll be I can't tell you about it though

0:12:22Look, Hollywood is very confused. I was calling some of Apple's partners the last few days

0:12:27I said, what'd you think of that? And they said ah, I don't know. I wanted to said I think it's good for me

0:12:33Meaning that person's gonna see he thinks he will sell a lot of subscriptions to his thing

0:12:38And I think it's not good for Apple because it seems kind of meth for them. Yeah

0:12:42Well, here's the here's the thing where I'm going with Game of Thrones the thing that was not secret about Game of Thrones was

0:12:48When would the new season come on?

0:12:50Right, it has been slated for April of 2019 for a very long time

0:12:58And then you know this goes back to and it's gonna be it's gonna be this many episodes. All right, and here's how you get it

0:13:06You know and blockbuster movies have long been the same way

0:13:09There's you know, these tentpole dates for here's you know, here's when the new Star Wars Episode 9 is coming out and here's

0:13:16They may not pre-announce the date that the teaser is going to drop but we can pretty well guess

0:13:21And I think the creative people who are involved know JJ Abrams probably has a pretty good idea when the teaser is going to drop

0:13:28Yes, here's a steady drumbeat of stuff and there's another version of this that everyone is referencing with with this the TV networks

0:13:37Do called an upfront where they gather everyone in New York in the spring and say here's what we're gonna show you next fall

0:13:42Which is really an antiquated way to do something, but they still do it that way

0:13:46And they will show them clips from the TV shows

0:13:48They might actually show them in a full episode of the TV show if they feel really confident about it

0:13:52They do a whole song and dance

0:13:54And they wind them and dine them

0:13:56Yeah

0:13:56And this seemed like a partial version of that and with again missing the part where they actually show you the shows which is also confusing

0:14:03Right, which really was well, well, that's

0:14:08You want to save that for the end? Yeah, that's

0:14:13Let's just take that as the preamble that the basic gist of this event was a bit of

0:14:17a head scratcher.

0:14:19All right, let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor of the show.

0:14:23It's one of my favorite products.

0:14:24I mean this sincerely, Away.

0:14:27Away makes suitcases and luggage, and I love their products.

0:14:32They build them all out of this German polycarbonate.

0:14:35It's a very fancy word for a lightweight plastic, and they're guaranteed for life.

0:14:41They also have newer models made out of anodized aluminum, very fancy, also very lightweight.

0:14:47They make their carry-on in two sizes, the bigger carry-on, the smaller carry-on, very,

0:14:53very clearly named.

0:14:54None of this grande tall vente stuff.

0:14:59And the carry-ons come with an optional ejectable battery.

0:15:03What I mean by ejectable, it's very simple because I know there's a lot of flight restrictions

0:15:06now on taking lithium-ion batteries and maybe they're going to, you know, you're late for

0:15:09a flight, maybe you got a last minute ticket, they're going to say we've got to gate check

0:15:13your thing and they can't put the thing underneath. The battery pops right out. You don't have to open

0:15:17the suitcase. You don't have to dig through your clothes to get it out. It just pops. You just lift

0:15:21it up, click it, pops right out, take it with you on the plane. But having a big, big battery and two

0:15:27USB ports right on your suitcase is like the greatest thing in the world because no matter

0:15:32where you sit down in the airport terminal, you've got to charge it right there. And my phone died

0:15:36Every single time I go to any airport, anywhere in the world, my phone is immediately somehow

0:15:41nose and just drops to like 30%. Love it. They have fantastic wheels. My family and I, like I

0:15:47said, we're just on a spring break trip, some away suitcases, some non awake suitcases that

0:15:51admittedly are a bit older. Everybody was fighting over dragging the away ones because the other ones

0:15:56don't roll very well. Mine is years old, still looks brand new. It is absolutely a fantastic

0:16:03suitcase. I love they have a bunch of colors to pick from. They have a great interior design

0:16:08with what they call a compression system. It's basically it's a nice place where you can put

0:16:13folded up shirts. Put something on top that cinches it nice and flat. And then when you

0:16:18take them out of the suitcase, the shirts don't look all wrinkled. It's great. They've got a

0:16:23special little bag for putting your dirty laundry in, keeping it in there, keeping away from your

0:16:28clean clothes as you travel. Anyway, I love my away suitcases. I recommend them thoroughly.

0:16:34I would recommend them even if they weren't a sponsor, but they are a sponsor and they

0:16:37have a special deal for you. 20 bucks off a suitcase by visiting away, travel.com away,

0:16:43travel.com/talk show and use the promo code talk show 20 talk show 20 because this is

0:16:51the talk show and you get 20 bucks off a suitcase. Use that code during checkout and you'll save

0:16:5620 bucks. Here's their slogan because this season everyone wants to get away. Get it.

0:17:03All right, Apple News Plus.

0:17:05That's a quality read, man. That was really good. I liked it.

0:17:07I'm getting good at it. I was terrible when I first started doing this.

0:17:10You're really good.

0:17:11You know what? It helps when I really like the product.

0:17:13Yeah, it does help.

0:17:16Apple News Plus, 10 bucks. Here's the one. The only price in the whole show. Which again,

0:17:23And I, you know, and, and anybody who follows Apple closely, it's like I've said, basically

0:17:29is like a, you and I talked when I was on your show about my career and how I built

0:17:33during fireball. And for the, I started this site and the podcast a couple of years later,

0:17:39but I started it in 2002 and writing about Apple starting around 2002 was really catching

0:17:47the bull by the horns, right? I mean, it's been a fantastic ride from there to here.

0:17:54And so when people over the years accused me of being biased in favor of Apple or I'm

0:17:59an Apple Homer or I'm effectively a super fan, a mouthpiece of Apple PR, whatever you

0:18:05want to say, you know, I'm, I'm, I try to listen to the criticism and I try to take

0:18:10a step back and see where I might be wrong. And there are times when, you know, maybe

0:18:15have been. Maybe I've made mistakes and I try to correct them as opposed to denying them or whatever.

0:18:20But basically my defense is, boy, if you've written about Apple from 2002 going forward

0:18:25and most of what you've written isn't very positive, then you got it wrong because they

0:18:30had a great run. They've had a great run. It might still be going, but with great products,

0:18:35you know, if, if you're treating them half your stories are bad and half are good. You're, you're,

0:18:41you're not doing justice to the actual story. It'd be like covering the Chicago bulls during

0:18:45to Michael Jordan era and saying most of the time, "Eh, they're okay."

0:18:48Yeah. Apple makes good stuff, has consistently made good stuff for a long stretch. Very good

0:18:54stuff. But, you know, one of the other things is that in addition to making good stuff,

0:18:58they present it well. I think their events are tighter than most companies, far tighter than

0:19:05most companies' events. I think they stick to things you really want to know. I think they're

0:19:10truthful. But I have to say, I've found this event very, again, I wasn't there. So I had

0:19:17to watch it remotely. But I found it very frustrating with how many questions it left.

0:19:21So it was satisfying, at least with Apple News, to have here's a thing that is shipping,

0:19:24and here's what it's going to cost. And here's what you get.

0:19:27Exactly.

0:19:28But I have to say with this, magazines?

0:19:33Yeah.

0:19:34Yeah, it's like so you want to walk through what this how we got here. Yeah, I want to walk through how we got here

0:19:42so

0:19:442009 ish we know everyone knows the iPad is coming. They're not sure that it's called the iPad or whatever. It's gonna be

0:19:49And the magazine publishers say this thing is gonna be a big deal in part because Steve Jobs has been telling him

0:19:57It's gonna be a big deal

0:19:59But we do not want to we do not want to get screwed the way the music

0:20:03Publishers the music labels got screwed where Steve Jobs said hey, you guys are in bad shape. I'm tell you what to do for you

0:20:09I'm gonna break up your $15 CD

0:20:11Into dollar songs and that's gonna be great for me and much less good for you. It's all gonna work out

0:20:16We the magazine guys say we want control of whatever this thing is going to be. We're doing a joint venture

0:20:24So Hearst Meredith timing all at the time the big publishers Conde Nast and News Corp get together

0:20:30And create what we were at the time calling like a Hulu for news because it was a joint venture

0:20:35But it was it was this idea that you still see today, which is for 15 bucks a month

0:20:40I think was the initial price you can read all the magazines you want through this service and they'll own the service and they can

0:20:47Push it on an Apple device. They can put it on an Amazon device, whatever

0:20:51They made that thing. It was called a bunch of different things

0:20:54And it was never successful. No one ever wanted to use it

0:20:58And it eventually was called texture and that is the thing that Apple bought a year ago

0:21:03And it's crucial to remember as we get into like complaints about the economics

0:21:06The magazine publishers still owned it when they when Apple bought it, so they got a check from Apple already the magazine publishers

0:21:14And that basically is the product that's out now

0:21:18The Apple folks will tell you they totally redid the product, but it's essentially the same thing

0:21:24And then what Apple has been trying to do for the last year is say our magazines are great

0:21:29But we need more stuff in here. We need news so they've been courting the the newspapers with mixed success

0:21:36They have the Wall Street Journal we could talk about why they're in the LA Times

0:21:40They have some digital publishers including my friends over at box comm are contributing some stuff

0:21:45Then notably do not have the Washington Post or the New York Times, right?

0:21:49But that's why this is a magazine product in part because it's always been a magazine

0:21:53Product and in part because Apple hasn't been able to get the news guys in it

0:21:56I

0:21:58Think the other factor that we should definitely mention

0:22:01I know you know this but I think it's worth remembering is that when Apple first went to the music companies in

0:22:082002 three ish

0:22:11I mean the iPod came out. I always remember came out

0:22:15after 9/11, so it was 2001.

0:22:17It was, the iPod was at that time a Mac only peripheral and the Mac had, you know,

0:22:26three, four, five percent, however you want to measure it, of the US market and you, you know,

0:22:31had to have a Macintosh to use an iPod and so it

0:22:35A niche product. And I think that the music industry saw it as a

0:22:40permanent niche product that they could, well, we can dip our toes in this and do this thing

0:22:43with Apple where they're selling songs for 99 cents because it's just Apple. And that's...

0:22:48And also, by the way, it's also post Napster or file sharing is a huge deal, but in retrospect,

0:22:55the music guys haven't quite realized this. Their industry is about to go into like a decade plus

0:23:00slide because of piracy. But the reason they could even get there was the jobs could even break open

0:23:05the $15 CD is because of Napster and Grokster and what it had been doing to sales.

0:23:11Yeah. And, you know, I don't think they ever foresaw that the iPod would turn into the

0:23:18digital music player of the decade, and therefore make the iTunes Music Store the digital music

0:23:26store for everybody. Right. And, you know, I think that's the caution that these other,

0:23:33whether it be books or whether it's the news industry or Hollywood or everybody's had since

0:23:38is, hey, they did it to the music guys. And I question what I question about that, though,

0:23:44analysis is that without Apple, I'm not sure the music people were going to have anything.

0:23:48Anyway, it's

0:23:50Right. And that, by the way, that that is completely parallel to what's going on here.

0:23:54We can talk about that. But a lot of it. I mean, again, you have Steve Jobs coming in,

0:23:59sort of as the music industry is in it, it's a nosedive and saying, "Things look bad

0:24:04for you.

0:24:05I've got something that's literally better than nothing."

0:24:08And that's basically the pitch here to the magazine guys.

0:24:12You guys have been trying to sell magazines for a long time.

0:24:15You've been trying to do it online.

0:24:17It's really not working.

0:24:18You guys are in a slide as well.

0:24:19You're in the magazine business, for God's sake.

0:24:23It's not going well on your own.

0:24:25I've got something that can help you.

0:24:28The economics are gonna not look that great,

0:24:30but if we supersize it, maybe it's awesome.

0:24:32- It does seem like a compelling deal

0:24:38if you want to read a bunch of magazines.

0:24:40Nine bucks a month is really an outstanding deal

0:24:44for the amount of content.

0:24:45- It's an outstanding deal if you like

0:24:48to read magazine stories and are deeply,

0:24:51deeply invested in any particular title.

0:24:54where it falls apart is if you really like The New Yorker.

0:24:58First of all, it's just not a satisfying way

0:25:00to sort of get to The New Yorker.

0:25:01And also The New Yorker is a particularly good example here.

0:25:04They are spending a lot of time and effort

0:25:06creating online-only content.

0:25:08That stuff won't be in there.

0:25:09- Right.

0:25:10- But if you are someone who just sort of likes

0:25:12the equivalent of looking through a newsstand

0:25:14and picking something up,

0:25:15or looking through your stack of unread magazines

0:25:17and picking something up, it's pretty cool.

0:25:20And if you have a little bit of motivation

0:25:22you know that there's a really good New Yorker article about dinosaurs that came out last week,

0:25:26you can go get it. And I do think it's very compelling.

0:25:29I get to why the major newspapers, and again, I'd love to hear your take on why the journal

0:25:41is in, but why the Post and New York Times aren't. Now I subscribe to the Wall Street Journal,

0:25:50I subscribe to the New York Times, all digital editions, and I do subscribe to the Washington

0:25:55Post. So I looked up what I'm paying. I'm paying $39 a month for the journal.

0:26:00Now, and the journal famously, very famously, all along, sort of as stodgy as you might think

0:26:09the journal would be as an institution, really kind of pounced on the World Wide Web, you know,

0:26:16back when we used to call it the World Wide Web. And also very, I'm not going to say all along,

0:26:22I don't know about the early years, but as long as I can remember, they've had a paywall for

0:26:27everything and you want our stuff you pay, you are more importantly, your employer pays, right. And

0:26:31they don't even do like a hey, you get five a month and then you can, you know, delete the

0:26:37cookie and maybe get five more go into private mode and then a cookie doesn't show up and you

0:26:41can do this stuff and we, you know, they don't have that, you know, it is, you're going to pay

0:26:46us and again, why it may have worked so well for them as opposed to others is exactly what you said

0:26:51that a lot of if not most of the subscribers to the Wall Street Journal can get their employer to

0:26:56pay for it. I certainly considered as myself, I mean, it's a one person company, but I consider

0:27:01it a well justified business expense because I find so much good stuff and linked to so much good

0:27:06stuff in the Wall Street Journal. But that's $39 a month. And that just all goes right to

0:27:12the journal. The Times is 20 bucks a month for a digital subscription. And funny enough, I just got

0:27:17a I just got an email from Schultzberger yesterday, telling me that that my subscription will be going

0:27:25up to $25 a month sometime between now and middle of May, which is a little weird that he doesn't

0:27:31no way when you're gonna take and you know the times has a leaky or paywall they do the

0:27:39thing where you get free some number of free articles a month and they keep a cookie and

0:27:46whatever. But for people who do subscribe that's $20 and within weeks $25 a month all

0:27:53going to the New York Times company and the Wall Street Washington Post I subscribed through

0:27:58through their app on the phone because I do love managing my subscriptions the Apple way

0:28:04where I can—if I ever wanted to unsubscribe, I can just tap a button as opposed to calling

0:28:10the New York Times call center in Iowa, talking to some nice lady there. But that's $10

0:28:17a month. I have a basic subscription to the Washington Post. I pay $10 a month for it.

0:28:23I don't even know what they have. There's a premium for $15 a month. I don't miss

0:28:27anything in the Washington Post, so 10 bucks a month is good for me. But at 10 bucks total

0:28:35for Apple News Plus and sharing it with all of these other magazines and other online

0:28:40publications that are in it, and this purported 50/50 split where Apple is taking 50% of the

0:28:46money overall, you don't have to even be good at math to sort of see why this might

0:28:53not appeal to the newspapers.

0:28:55Yeah for the news guys, it's it for the post and the time it's very clear part of it is the money

0:29:01The Times I think has three million digital only subscribers. I think maybe four million all in they're saying look, you know

0:29:08Even if we have to give Apple a cut of that because some people are subscribing through the you know iTunes, etc

0:29:14Fine, but you know, we want to keep as much of that as possible

0:29:17We certainly don't want to give away 50% and there's some more nuanced arguments about we don't want to be in someone else's bundle frankly

0:29:25And someone else's newsstand, I think Mark Thompson, who's the publisher, or I guess

0:29:31maybe the CEO's official title, at the time said something about a – he had some weird

0:29:35reference to a British blender.

0:29:37But basically he said, "You know, we don't want to be part of someone else's mix.

0:29:42We want to be the presenter at The New York Times, and we don't want to get swapped

0:29:45out for a competing news product at some point."

0:29:48There's also an issue of actually having control over who has access to the subscriber,

0:29:53all those things that are all important to the Post and The Times that are very diligently

0:29:57building up these businesses.

0:30:00The Journal could say all those same things, and the fact that they're not, you can deduce

0:30:05a couple things.

0:30:06One, Rupert Murdoch has always had an affinity/special relationship with Apple.

0:30:10I remember The Daily, among other things.

0:30:14Yeah.

0:30:15I forgot about The Daily, but that's true.

0:30:17Yeah, no, that was a big thing, right?

0:30:18It was Steve Jobs and Rupert Murdoch cooking up the newspaper of the future.

0:30:23not work.

0:30:25But they're saying, "Look, we've got all the business subscribers we're going to get.

0:30:29We think there are other people that would like to read the Wall Street Journal or a

0:30:33version of the Wall Street Journal, and maybe we can profit from that."

0:30:37So again, without saying it this way, what they've done is created a product that, in

0:30:43theory, will not satisfy you, John Gruber, who's paying $39 a month for the journal.

0:30:48You will find it to be sort of a crippled version of the journal.

0:30:52In theory, all the articles that are available in today's journal are there.

0:30:57They're online.

0:30:58They're only there for three days, and they're hard to find.

0:31:01It's not going to be the equivalent of browsing deeply through the app.

0:31:07And again, they're not going to come out and say, "We've made this thing to sort of frustrate

0:31:10our core subscribers," but that's what they want.

0:31:13So they're hoping/praying you don't dump your expensive subscription for a cheap one.

0:31:20And then their hope is we're going to bring a lot of general interest stories that maybe

0:31:25most people don't associate with the journal or people who aren't subscribing the journal

0:31:28don't know that we do and we're going to surface those.

0:31:31Weirdly they're also hiring maybe 50 journalists that are going to mostly create stuff just

0:31:36for Apple News Plus, which is confusing to me.

0:31:39And so we're really going to go deep on this and we're going to sort of make the journal,

0:31:43we would like the journal to be a general interest newspaper that attracts readers all

0:31:47over the world.

0:31:48That is our bet.

0:31:49That doesn't make any sense to me at all that there. Well, one thing you don't get and it affects

0:31:55me personally, and what I do very much is that unless I'm completely missing something.

0:32:01If you Peter subscribe to the journal only through Apple news plus you don't have a direct

0:32:08subscription and I linked to a Wall Street Journal story on during fireball. When you click through,

0:32:13you only get the preview and there's no way for you to log in using credentials from your Apple

0:32:17news plus subscription. You don't have, you know, there is that you need a real quote unquote,

0:32:23real Wall Street Journal thing to read the Wall Street Journal on the web.

0:32:26Trenton Larkin Yeah, I don't know how much of that is, is,

0:32:28is feature versus bug. Maybe they're just, they haven't figured out how to get how to figure that

0:32:33part out. I assume that's actually fairly complicated. In part, just because the number

0:32:37of times that when I do go to a publication that I am subscribing to, they don't recognize me.

0:32:44And that doesn't sort of matter what device I'm on whether it's an Apple device or it's the web or my phone

0:32:48Apparently that stuff is just hard to do. Are you talking about the journal specifically? No, I'm talking about anything. Well the

0:32:55Yorker the journal specifically and I've talked to Joanna Stern about this and she's admitted the same thing that the journals

0:33:03Remember me checkbox is the biggest lie on the entire internet

0:33:09Well, I don't know the the folks who work the New Yorkers say the same thing. Oh, there's his guys

0:33:13Yeah, theirs is awful as well

0:33:15The New Yorkers and the Wall Street journals are terrible

0:33:18The New York Times is much better in my experience at remembering me

0:33:22And I know that there's some of the funny things is the fact that when you're on your phone a whole bunch of apps

0:33:28Like your Twitter app and other apps have built in many browsers based on Safari and you know

0:33:34Whether or not they can share cookies or whatever, but I'm talking about when you're I'm just in real Safari

0:33:38on one of these devices and I I mean I have to log into the Wall Street

0:33:45Journal almost every every day it's really kind of frustrating it's probably

0:33:49there's an extra maybe there's a more expensive subscription where they

0:33:52remember you yeah I don't know they can upsell you for that that's that's that's

0:33:56that's the bet for the journal what I've heard is that this this plan was not a

0:34:04big hit internally at the journal this is very much a Rupert Murdoch and Robert

0:34:08Thompson with Apple thing that the sort of rank-and-file journalists and

0:34:12editors are not psyched about this idea either because they're similarly

0:34:15confused about it hmm and you can just see how the money just isn't there if

0:34:21if they saw it you know and I think the Times and and the post are wise to be

0:34:28cautious about this you know like you said I mean if the Times has 4 million

0:34:31digital subscribers and they're all paying 20 soon to be 25 that is you know

0:34:37going to be, that's $100 million a month in revenue.

0:34:41- Yep, and the Apple response, off the record,

0:34:45is three million digital subscribers is nothing.

0:34:48We can get you tens of millions.

0:34:50- Right.

0:34:50- We can, it's not just that we're gonna make this

0:34:53a bigger business, we can make this a huge business for you.

0:34:56Again, if you're The Times, you say,

0:34:57look, I'm doing pretty well and I have full control,

0:34:59I'm gonna go on my own for a while.

0:35:02The magazine guys are saying, you know what,

0:35:04if it's a few hundred million dollars

0:35:05split between a bunch of us, we'll take it.

0:35:08- Yeah.

0:35:09And bundles can work.

0:35:12I mean, that's how the cable industry has always worked.

0:35:15Where it's your one channel, the Discovery Channel,

0:35:18and you don't sell, there's exceptions like HBO

0:35:22and Showtime where you buy them individually,

0:35:24but for the most part, the way the cable,

0:35:27we went from having, when I was a kid,

0:35:3010 channels that came over the air and they were all local

0:35:32to having a whole bunch of cable channels to go from

0:35:35the bundle and whole bunch of channels, one monthly fee and you get everybody if everybody

0:35:41quote unquote, everybody has cable, which was effectively true at one point, there's enough

0:35:47money to go around where you know, it is real money. Right. And now that model is under great

0:35:51pressure, which is actually Apple's plan slash hope is that the bundle is going to break up and

0:35:55they'll benefit from that. My argument about this, though, with the magazines, or one of my arguments

0:36:00with it is—and I like magazines, I do—but I will admit that even when I fly, which might

0:36:06be the perfect time to read a magazine, I just don't have time. I don't have time

0:36:12to read a lot of magazines. I still subscribe to The Physical New Yorker. I get a publication

0:36:19you're probably familiar with, The Week, which is a nice weekly wrap-up magazine, and

0:36:24does a really good job of embracing what print is still great at. And it's sort of like

0:36:28a Reader's Digest for what's happened in the last week, whether it was in another magazine or whether

0:36:35it was online. But other than that, I just, you know, and I can't say, you know, famously, I mean,

0:36:42I think most people who subscribe to The New Yorker have a—

0:36:45Right. There's a stack in the bathroom or somewhere near the bathroom.

0:36:47There's a terrible guilt where all I've looked at this week was the back page cartoon contest.

0:36:54Yeah, I mean, I have the time to read lots of articles, although I'm behind on the Big

0:36:59Times/Murdoch piece today.

0:37:01But my critique there is the idea of a magazine where an editor goes and assembles a bunch

0:37:06of articles for you.

0:37:07I love that idea, but in reality, Twitter's my editor.

0:37:12And my friends or people I follow send links around.

0:37:15And you can argue that maybe I'm in a filter bubble, etc., but I get lots of people are

0:37:22picking my articles out for me on Twitter, to a lesser degree Facebook.

0:37:27And so the idea of this curated set of articles that one person picked for me seems very anachronistic.

0:37:33But frankly, you know, that's what Apple News is, right?

0:37:35Is that bundle.

0:37:36They just sort of mushed all the magazines together.

0:37:39And a lot of folks are very happy to sort of be presented with a bunch of stuff picked

0:37:42by, again, human beings in Cupertino, to Apple's credit, saying, "We think these are things

0:37:46you should read."

0:37:47The other thing, too, is that the difference between a magazine and a newspaper

0:37:53used to be a lot—when in the print world was a lot more distinct. And, you know, the type of writing

0:38:02and the type of article you would read on page one of the New York Times is very different than

0:38:06the type of stuff you would read in The New Yorker or even Time or Newsweek or something.

0:38:11But now we're mostly talking about articles. The unit is really—and, you know, it's just a post

0:38:19web thing. And in the early days of the web, I mean, in the years before I started during

0:38:23Fireball, before web blogs became a—here's how you do a web blog. You just write posts,

0:38:29and the newest one is at the top, and they scroll down. It seems very obvious, but

0:38:36In the early years of the web, I certainly struggled with it coming from, you know,

0:38:41I was much younger then, I was coming from, you know, running the student newspaper at Drexel,

0:38:47but thinking about issues and that there'd be an issue. And what do you do? Do you have an issue

0:38:50every couple days? Do you do an issue once a week? Do you have a schedule? And no, you just have

0:38:54articles. That's the nature. And that's the atomic unit of Apple News is still, even if you have the

0:39:00Apple News+, it's still the article. And the difference between an article that happens to

0:39:05come from the New York Times or the Washington Post and an article that comes from a magazine,

0:39:09it isn't really relevant. And it could come from somebody who doesn't even have

0:39:14a print edition like TechCrunch or Vox Media or, you know, you name it.

0:39:21Yeah, no, and that's all as it should be. If you're the consumer, all you care about is,

0:39:24do I like this? Is it good? Is it trustworthy? Is it come from a source that I trust and value?

0:39:30That's kind of it. And, you know, look, I mean, a lot of those New York Times 3 million subscriptions

0:39:34Part of the the Trump bump, right?

0:39:36People actively sort of signaling that they want to support the Times which is great

0:39:41But that's anomaly hopefully

0:39:45So, you know

0:39:47It might be very difficult to get lots of people to subscribe to discrete magazine subscriptions or newspaper subscriptions going forward. Yeah

0:39:55Well, it leads me to the formatting issue which is that somebody

0:40:00Federico Viticci at Mac stories went through and did the diligent work of looking at every single

0:40:06magazine that was in Apple News as of like a day or two after the thing. And it was about a 50/50

0:40:11split between the magazines that were using the new Apple News format in terms of the technical,

0:40:18you know, how are we sending this article, which is a little bit more like HTML and a thing that

0:40:22more easily reflows to anything from a big screen to a tiny little phone screen, and about half are

0:40:28still just doing PDFs, which I think is how texture worked. And it's certainly how all

0:40:34of them on, you know, the iPad magazines back in 2011, 2010.

0:40:38Yeah, mostly. A couple of the iPad magazines like Wired and stuff tried to spend a lot

0:40:42of time and energy trying to make a new thing for digital, but most of them said, we're

0:40:46just going to take the thing we've already made and take a photograph of it essentially

0:40:50and put it over here.

0:40:51Yeah. But pages, it just doesn't work for me, really. I mean, it always, I mean, I still

0:40:55read PDFs and I read things that I have to do that way, but, boy, breaking things into

0:41:01PDF pages as the default distribution online feels, still feels antiquated.

0:41:07Yeah, but you're getting so much of it. It's only $10 and you can subscribe on your phone.

0:41:13I think it'll do okay. I mean, I've been thinking a lot about, you know, what is, what

0:41:16is a reasonable goal for them? They've sold 50 million Apple Music subscriptions in the

0:41:21last how many years, five years?

0:41:25I think people like music more than they like reading, for better or for worse.

0:41:29And also there's a language thing, right?

0:41:31It's harder to sell this in Germany or Japan, I assume.

0:41:34So I don't know, is $25 million reasonable?

0:41:38And if you get to my back of the envelope math there, if that's the case and they sold

0:41:4425 million subscriptions, that's $1.5 billion to cut up between the publishers.

0:41:51a lot of them would be very happy to be a to own piece of that pie.

0:41:54Right. Well, we shall see. The other thing that they emphasized, and it gets into,

0:42:00I mean, I think Google and Facebook were the implied other guys, is the notion,

0:42:08the emphasis on human curation. And we want to show you what's good and truthful and important,

0:42:17not just what you're going to click on, you know, and sort of anti clickbait rant,

0:42:23anti clickbait, and also humans are picking this stuff. It's not we're not leaving this up to an

0:42:28algorithm. And we care about journalism, you know, full full stop, they made a point of saying that

0:42:34when they bought texture, right? This is specifically about supporting journalism.

0:42:38There was an article a couple of months ago where somebody had like a feature of you know,

0:42:43how Apple News works and who they've hired and how they've hired all these professionals who have,

0:42:47you know, serious careers in real journalism. And then there was a quote from somebody who was like,

0:42:53its title is managing editor. And he was like, he asked his name not to be used.

0:42:57Because he works at Apple. And it's like, that's just like for anybody from the media world,

0:43:05that is just, it's insane. And there's one woman whose name is associated with Lauren Kern.

0:43:12Right and sort of the public face of it

0:43:14And she if he went to the Apple event

0:43:15You'd see her walking around you can talk to her that and that is sort of how Apple works where there is

0:43:20A I don't know want to say for sure that it everybody has a VP title

0:43:25But there is a sort of line that you cross in your career at Apple where you're allowed to be named publicly

0:43:33Yeah, and anybody who's not on that side by the way as I

0:43:38I'm sure you notice this they did bring up a lot of newish faces. Yep on stage

0:43:43One important name for you for your readers slash listeners to pay attention to is the guy Peter Stern

0:43:49Mm-hmm. He's the guy who does all the deals now. He's a very important deal guy

0:43:53Yeah for Apple with the media and I you know, I can't imagine another scenario where Peter Stern would get stage time

0:43:59Yeah, so that was different. Yeah

0:44:01There was the guy Wyatt. I

0:44:05Forget his last name, but he had the exquisite white jumpsuit. Yeah, that was a jumpsuit

0:44:11It was the cool haven't seen the jumpsuit go back and look at the jumpsuit

0:44:13I used to do a thing years ago on Twitter

0:44:16well for many years where I would keep track of whether the

0:44:20Presenters at Apple were had a had their shirts tucked in or untucked and I would keep a tally

0:44:26Yeah as a as a completely meta thing just to goof on Twitter during the event and I stopped doing it

0:44:33it because I it was very male focused and at the in the early years of it, it didn't

0:44:41matter because everybody who was coming on stage was a man and so it was fine. But then

0:44:46I think it was one time when Angela orange came on stage, but there was somebody who

0:44:49came on stage and her shirt wasn't tucked in or her blouse, but it really wasn't a shirt

0:44:54and she looked fantastic. And I was like, you know what this whole tucked on tuck thing

0:44:59Really only applies to men and it's I think it's time to put it to put it to rest

0:45:03But I and by the way and and it was I noticed also that was a diverse group of Apple presenters that was different as well

0:45:12I don't think that was pointed necessarily. I just think that was that but I do think that wasn't an accident

0:45:17But when Wyatt came out in the jumpsuit, I thought boy if I were still doing the tucked untucked

0:45:24I don't even know where where that would apply

0:45:28I was like that's good. You retired that one. Yeah, it would have to be an asterisk

0:45:32I think but I would give it an asterisk and the on the side of absolutely winning because it was it was a very cool look

0:45:39Wyatt Mitchell is his name. I wanted to make sure I could go quiet Mitchell and he did a great job

0:45:48He was a designer who worked on Apple news and showed off the cool way that the Apple news formatted once

0:45:54Really do format

0:45:57You know flow very cool between your phone and your iPad

0:45:59Yeah, I think I think this is the kind of thing that if Apple

0:46:03Announced this, you know in a suite of other hardware devices that you could buy we go

0:46:09That's probably kind of cool and we'd move on

0:46:11And the fact that we're focused this much time on on this podcast alone

0:46:15Shows you sort of like how odd this event was or it's the one thing we can actually look at and evaluate

0:46:21And debate whether it's worth the money

0:46:23everything else is is

0:46:26theoretical still yeah

0:46:28Next up was Apple pay Apple card. I don't really have a lot to say about this

0:46:33I've been skeptical all along about Apple getting into the credit card business just because it just seems so

0:46:38odd and

0:46:40It seems like the most transparently

0:46:43This isn't a thing. We would you would think of a computer company making

0:46:47But there's money to be made and we like making yeah, I will confess that I still don't really understand that

0:46:56the real difference between Apple Pay and the Apple card.

0:46:59I mean, I get there are some differences,

0:47:01and my colleague Jason Del Rey,

0:47:03who actually writes about this stuff,

0:47:04he's really great on commerce,

0:47:06can walk you through it if you care,

0:47:08and why this does or doesn't matter,

0:47:10but it's mostly a shrug to me.

0:47:12I gotta kick out of the fact

0:47:13that there's an actual card made out of titanium.

0:47:15- Yeah.

0:47:16- And, you know, if you're into the theater of it,

0:47:19the fact that they're paired with Goldman Sachs,

0:47:20who not that long ago was sort of one

0:47:22of the most despised brands in America, is interesting.

0:47:25I'm not sure that is in the past tense, to be honest,

0:47:29especially judging from a lot of the emails

0:47:32and tweets I saw after this.

0:47:33- Yeah, yeah.

0:47:34- Yeah, basically I would describe it this,

0:47:39Apple Pay is the way that you pay using your device.

0:47:43And it's, you know, and it has,

0:47:45but to do that, you have to have sources,

0:47:48and the sources could be debit cards from your bank,

0:47:51or credit cards, and Apple Pay Cash

0:47:55their virtual debit card that you can use with Apple Pay. And it's just like a bank account,

0:48:01except that it has no interest, but it's, you know, just cash. And then Apple Card now can be

0:48:07another source, a credit card, you know, a replacement for an Amex or whatever.

0:48:13Darrell Bock Right. But the emphasis in the show was,

0:48:16this is a thing you don't need a card for, you just carry it in your phone. So it's, you know,

0:48:20it's effective, you know, if I was buying my coffee with Apple Pay, and if I'm paying with

0:48:24Apple credit card. I get that there are some technical differences and that the

0:48:28who the bank is matters to the banks but if you're a user of some just bought my

0:48:33cappuccino who cares who cares whether it's a car or Apple pay the thing that I

0:48:37find a little worrisome about it is and again it seems like a really good card

0:48:41and you know I don't think the interest rates are groundbreakingly low but they

0:48:45do seem competitive or at the low end of the industry and the no fees thing is

0:48:49all good and the cash back is fine but you know I'm not doing a finance

0:48:55podcast I also assume that Goldman is gonna is going to be replacing whoever

0:48:59the weird bank is that Apple uses now for its phone financing project oh I

0:49:03wouldn't be super yeah that's a good idea I would I would think so you know

0:49:07it makes sense and that and that probably right is going to be a

0:49:10significant part of whatever bundle there is is you're gonna buy a new

0:49:14iPhone and you're gonna pay for it over this many installments and you're going

0:49:17get these other things when you can move that bundle up or down. Yeah. And you know, I know

0:49:21that every other, not every, but every department store you go to has their own credit card and every

0:49:28airline has their own credit card or series of credit cards. And you know, you can get your

0:49:33American Airlines credit card, you can get a Disney credit card, you can, I get it that all

0:49:39of these other companies in, you name the industry, right, you can get gas station credit cards, you

0:49:44know, you know, and there's a reason I'm sure it's profitable, you know, the banks are making money

0:49:50and the companies are making money lending money is a good business, generally. Yeah,

0:49:53I get it. But it also just is all to me a little unseemly. You know, my crack when they first in

0:50:01this first leaked a few weeks ago was what's next? Are they going to start doing payday loans at the

0:50:05Apple Store? Yeah, I mean, again, they they base, they wrap this up in virtue, right? You know,

0:50:13we're not gonna do fees.

0:50:15Goldman will not sell your information,

0:50:20and then there's sort of an asterisk with regards to this.

0:50:24'Cause Goldman's definitely

0:50:24in the selling information business.

0:50:26'Cause that's one of the ways these guys all make money.

0:50:29Yeah, I just, you know, and again,

0:50:31I just cannot get over a titanium card,

0:50:33just cracks me up.

0:50:34Should be aluminum, right, everyone made that joke?

0:50:37- Yeah, I wonder why titanium instead of aluminum.

0:50:40- Sounds cool.

0:50:41- Yeah, I don't know why.

0:50:41I know that they, you remember they used to make the laptops out of titanium when they

0:50:45first went from plastic to metal. The original metal G4 Mac, not Mac books, power books were

0:50:52titanium. I think for about two years, maybe.

0:50:57I'm nodding my head. I trust you on this.

0:50:59The problem with titanium versus aluminum is titanium does not wear anywhere near as

0:51:03well as aluminum. So like an 18 month old well-used titanium G4 had like, it like eroded

0:51:10where your palms touched it.

0:51:12- It also reminded me of the Fyre Festival guy.

0:51:15- A lot of people made that.

0:51:16A lot of people--

0:51:17- Previous to the Fyre Festival,

0:51:19they had the special card.

0:51:20- It wasn't even a credit card,

0:51:23it was just a cool looking card.

0:51:26- I think it was a rebranded.

0:51:28Someone else's card, they rebranded, it was great.

0:51:30- And the entire point of the card

0:51:32was that it was a cool looking credit card.

0:51:35- It was a cool looking card

0:51:36and maybe you could hang out with some jerks

0:51:38in the West Village in a special apartment.

0:51:41And go to places where people would be impressed and actually look at.

0:51:45I think a normal human being doesn't even think to look at anybody else's card except

0:51:51when they're—

0:51:54Ostentatiously showing it off and buying a bottle service.

0:51:57No, I'm thinking like when you split a check with a bunch of friends and then the bill

0:52:00comes back and there's six cards and it's like, "All right, who's got the green

0:52:04one?

0:52:05Who's got this blue thing?"

0:52:06you know, that's the only time anybody normal ever looks at it. So let's stipulate the world is not

0:52:11going to be a set of flame by the Apple thing or maybe there's a more interesting application.

0:52:15Maybe there's more interesting stuff to come from Goldman and Apple. Well, I just don't know how

0:52:20big a dent in the universe it makes to have a better credit card with low, no fees and nice

0:52:25rules and stuff like that. I will say this, the 3% cashback on Apple purchases is probably worth it

0:52:32for me to sign up for it, even if I don't use it for anything other than the money I

0:52:36give to Apple every year.

0:52:37Yeah. Look, I feel bad about the fact that my kids are spending 20 bucks of my money

0:52:42on Fortnite. And if I could reclaim a little bit of that back from their digital dolls

0:52:47they're buying, I'd be happy about that.

0:52:49Yeah. So it's probably worth it just for that. But I don't want to spend more of your time

0:52:53on it.

0:52:54Good. I mean, we'll spend as much time as you'd like, but it's probably not worth it

0:52:57either of our time.

0:52:58Let me take another break here and thank our next sponsor. So good friends at Eero, E E

0:53:03R O. Look, Eero beats the single router model. They provide Wi Fi for the home. What you

0:53:10need in today's world is a distributed system. That's what offices have had for years and

0:53:15years. But with considerable work and expense with Eero, you can install an enterprise enterprise

0:53:21grade Wi Fi system in your home in just a few minutes. So easy. Everything comes in

0:53:26one kit. You plug one of them into your cable modem. That's your main one. Then you just

0:53:32plug other ones in throughout your house. Maybe you need two more, maybe you need three.

0:53:37Depending on the size of your house, how many floors you have, what your walls are made

0:53:41of, stuff like that. Their app will help you decide, or their website will help you decide

0:53:45even before you buy, how many you might need. You can always add another one later. You

0:53:50just plug it in and then use their app to add it to your network. And all of a sudden,

0:53:54additional one that you've plugged into the wall talks to it, it creates one single network

0:54:00throughout your home. Now you've got multiple devices flooding your home with a strong Wi-Fi

0:54:04signal. Now they also have a service for Euro users called Euro plus and it provides complete

0:54:09protection for your network and all the devices. Euro plus offers the ability to block malicious

0:54:15and unwanted content across your whole network. Advanced security. It checks the sites you

0:54:20revisit against a database of millions of known threats and prevent you from accidentally

0:54:24visiting malicious sites without slowing anything down. Content blocking, yeah. Eero Plus automatically

0:54:31tags sites that contain violent, illegal, or adult content so you can choose what your

0:54:35kids can and cannot visit right from the Eero app, which again is right on your phone and

0:54:41is super, super nicely designed. Very easy to understand. And they even have ad blocking.

0:54:46You can get rid of annoying ads and pop-ups on all your devices.

0:54:49Ad blocking also improves load times for ad-heavy sites so you can browse and stream faster

0:54:53than ever before.

0:54:55They also have third-party security apps like VPN protection from encrypt.me, password management

0:55:00from 1Password, and antivirus software from Malwarebytes.

0:55:04All of that is included with Eero+.

0:55:06It's a great system.

0:55:08If you're listening to this podcast, you're hearing me talk over an Eero network right

0:55:12now.

0:55:13I'm really happy with it.

0:55:14And they have a special deal.

0:55:15So you never have to worry about Wi Fi again, once you have a neuro network in your home,

0:55:18you can get 100 bucks off their Euro base unit and two beacons package, which is a great

0:55:24starter kit, probably all you need and one year of Euro plus. So you save 100 bucks when

0:55:31you get their Euro base unit two beacons package and one year of Euro plus and you can get

0:55:36that by visiting ero ero.com slash the talk show. And at checkout, just enter the talk

0:55:42show with the "the" and you'll get that deal.

0:55:46Steven: Another fine read and a good product too.

0:55:49Trevor Burrus Apple Arcade. Again, you're not a gaming expert.

0:55:52I think this one makes a lot of sense though to me just because Apple's really strong in

0:55:58games. The mobile games are a huge deal.

0:56:02Steven

0:56:02Yeah, as a consumer, I looked at it and said, "I don't know that I'm going to play those

0:56:08games, but I could definitely see subscribing to it and giving it to my kids and saying,

0:56:13'Here, one, you don't have to ask me for any upgrades.'"

0:56:16I think that was a big deal, right?

0:56:17It's all—it's going to be all in.

0:56:22And I'm also—Apple's going to pick—Apple's going to have some sort of curatorial control

0:56:26over it, so I'm not going to be worried about them going to some weird cider wrap.

0:56:31I definitely am again if we knew what it cost

0:56:33Right, I'd be very interested in buying and it's you know, they kept this pretty well under wraps

0:56:40I had a guess I made a guess the day before the event that maybe they would add a game subscription

0:56:46Yeah, I think Bloomberg had it a few days a few days in advance. But yeah, it was it was it was quite quiet

0:56:52And part of you know

0:56:54Part of what seems impressive is that these games are exclusive or at least exclusive on mobile to the platform

0:57:01There's some ambiguity as to what means exclusive.

0:57:05I think what they mean by mobile is not Android, and therefore maybe these games might be on

0:57:12your PlayStation or your PC or something like that, but the only way to play them on a phone

0:57:17would be through the Apple Arcade.

0:57:21Right, but these aren't the big sort of like, what do they call them, AAA games?

0:57:24No.

0:57:25The $60 games, and they're not the Fortnite-style free-to-play games, right?

0:57:29Well, is that it's it's it's a specific niche of gaming and I think they emphasized the indie gaming over and over

0:57:34But I mean one of the reasons they didn't leak is that they weren't doing deals with epic or with blizzard or EA

0:57:40Right, right and those triple-a games don't really make sense on a phone in in right in my opinion and in my son's opinion as well

0:57:47I mean my son plays games on a computer

0:57:49Plays games on a PlayStation. He does play games on a phone, but he plays different games on a phone because they just make sense

0:57:57Again, I think this is the kind of thing we're in a suite of things

0:58:00They're going to offer at different price points and different bundle elements. This makes tons of sense

0:58:04Yeah, well and you said your kids play fortnight. I mean, I think the thing that they're pushing back on on this is the

0:58:10slot machine

0:58:13Fication of the whole idea of consumer video games

0:58:16And the idea that the people making the most money and let's face it Apple is making 30% of that revenue from those games

0:58:25games when I go through the app store. I feel like even Apple itself is pushing back against

0:58:33that, even though they're obviously a big source of the revenue, the services revenue

0:58:37they're already making is coming from Candy Crush type game mechanics. And that was a

0:58:44big part of the emphasis to this is you're going to give Apple X dollars a month for

0:58:48an Apple arcade subscription. We don't know what that is. I can't help but think though

0:58:52that it's gonna be ten bucks right I mean I think that's what I would pay

0:58:57right I mean what's not gonna happen though it's not gonna replace fortnight

0:59:01for me but at least I'd say look all right here's ten bucks a month and I

0:59:04cut something else out and I think this is a reasonable thing for me to give my

0:59:07kids for a year and then once you're on it you know that you're not going to be

0:59:11bad badgered for three dollars for a bag of gems or you know yeah whatever

0:59:17you're in, you've got everything, and there you go. And I think that's a super compelling part of it.

0:59:24I think they also had, they did have, they didn't have the big publishers like EA and Epic and,

0:59:29and those, but they had indie game creator, I guess, a hint of what was to come with the,

0:59:34the entertainment, the TV and movie stuff. They had some big names from the gaming world,

0:59:39like Will Wright, the guy who invented SimCity and the Sims. You know, super clever guy with a great

0:59:46history and other people, you know, I'm not really a gaming expert either. But you know,

0:59:50games I've heard of seems like a good deal I get at a technical level, I get why this is fall,

0:59:59because it sure sounds like the hey, these things will run on Apple TV, and your phone and your Mac

1:00:07has something to do with this whole marzipan thing that will make it easier for developers to cross,

1:00:12you know, make one, write one game, and it'll run on all of these Apple devices, which would mean

1:00:18that there's going to be, I'm guessing, a huge chunk of WWDC this June, which will be divided

1:00:24devoted to the technical aspects of here's how this is going to work. So I get and therefore,

1:00:30whatever comes whatever is announced in June at WWDC will ship in the fall with a new version of

1:00:36iOS and a new version of the tv OS and a new version of the Mac OS. And that's what we're

1:00:40waiting for. But in the meantime, you know, what? We wait. Yeah, coming coming later. Yeah,

1:00:50we should we should. Isn't the Apple TV storefront isn't that up and running? Or is that coming May?

1:00:56I think that was another thing that was actually existed, though, right? Well,

1:01:01the channels, right? Right. Yeah. Well, that's next. So why don't we just go right to it?

1:01:05because the gaming thing is, you know, so the, the Apple TV channels, and this is where I'm

1:01:11starting to get more and more confused, right? I get like, so long as this Apple arcade is 10,

1:01:16maybe 15 a month, I get I get it. Okay, let's just assume that's in there. Now we get to Apple TV

1:01:23channels. This is announced for quote, May, which is pretty soon, you know, that's next month.

1:01:31This is the famed skinny bundle, I think is the term that's been bandied about for years.

1:01:36Not really. No. Okay. Now what's the difference? This is this is Amazon channels. This is go.

1:01:44This is what you can't do is pick a bunch of cable channels that you'd like to get better currently

1:01:51in some other bundles. So you can't go and get ESPN but not get Disney or whatever else. What you can

1:01:57can do or buy things that you've already been able to buy, HBO, show time, stars, CBS has

1:02:05its own all access app that's there.

1:02:08So you can still buy those.

1:02:10Nothing has changed.

1:02:12They're going to throw in some other stuff that you wouldn't normally pay for and that's

1:02:16where it gets a little confusing.

1:02:18They put up a bunch of logos and I think probably should be slapped for being deliberately confusing

1:02:25because they threw in people who aren't sort of participants in the store like Hulu.

1:02:28Yeah, that's a big one. I mean, that would really help people confused for days.

1:02:33Yeah. And there's no way you wouldn't understand any of this unless you literally sort of had my

1:02:38job or a handful of other jobs and you were tasked with figuring this stuff out. But for

1:02:43the regular consumer, really, there's no difference. Today, you can buy HBO through Apple TV. And in

1:02:51In May, you'll be able to buy HBO through Apple TV.

1:02:54What might change is that pricing on that stuff

1:02:56might change.

1:02:57Some of the pay channels have deals with Apple,

1:03:00where Apple has now the ability to bundle them and/or change

1:03:04pricing.

1:03:04Apple becomes the retailer.

1:03:06That's different.

1:03:08And this is, again, mostly a technical thing

1:03:10that matters to Apple and to the TV guys.

1:03:12But Apple is going to be the one--

1:03:14for the specific set of products that are in this thing,

1:03:18Apple is going to be hosting the streams

1:03:20and delivering the streams.

1:03:22And so, and they made a point of you won't be bouncing

1:03:26from app to app, which I don't think really matters

1:03:28to most people, but is also, again, not true,

1:03:30because if you are switching back and forth

1:03:32between HBO and Hulu, you are gonna bounce out

1:03:34to the Hulu app.

1:03:35- See, I think it does matter, but I think people don't think,

1:03:39most people don't think it matters.

1:03:40I think it matters 'cause I think about user interface

1:03:43design all the time.

1:03:44I don't know that other people, typical people,

1:03:46consciously think about it, but I think subconsciously,

1:03:50people don't like to be confused. And when Apple changed the Apple TV, and again, they

1:03:56reuse the term Apple TV in so many ways, like it's the device and it's the guide, it's the app.

1:04:03When they made the app into a thing that surfaces individual shows or movies in the same way that

1:04:13Apple news surfaces articles as opposed to publications, right? You go to Apple news and

1:04:19the top five articles are very often from five different publications. You go to the TV app,

1:04:25they want to do the same thing and say, here's five things we think you might want to watch.

1:04:29And it might vary from a basketball game on the ESPN app that you already have installed and

1:04:36authorized somehow to Hulu show to maybe shows a show that's only on iTunes or something.

1:04:46And for the most part, up 'til now,

1:04:51and we'll see how much this changes in May,

1:04:52every time you pick one of those,

1:04:54you bounce out of that TV app into the app

1:04:56where the thing is.

1:04:57- Right.

1:04:58- And I-- - When it works well,

1:05:01it's fine, it's a little weird,

1:05:03then you eventually, you're in the ESPN app

1:05:05and you're not back in the TV guide.

1:05:07I mean, I think it's okay in part

1:05:10because it's better than not having a guide.

1:05:12I think it's a relatively useful guide.

1:05:16I don't use it that much anymore because I got a Roku TV and just by default I'm using that really crummy interface

1:05:21And then the big problem right is it doesn't have Netflix in it

1:05:25And that is TV for most people or lots of people and so you literally can't just use it as your TV guide because you

1:05:32Won't know what's on Netflix. I don't know what point will be in the edited version of the show

1:05:36But on my recording we're one minute and seven seconds in before we mentioned the word Netflix, which I was

1:05:41We're gonna get there. I was trying to withhold

1:05:45and there is my

1:05:47That that to me Netflix is what they are up against and

1:05:53Maybe to a lesser degree YouTube as well and I'm thinking about my 15 year old son and how much time he spends watching you

1:06:01too is

1:06:03There's a confusion aspect and there's also a

1:06:06laziness aspect, you know

1:06:09That you're just I just want to watch something

1:06:12I just want to be entertained and you know

1:06:15And also why should I have to think about whether this thing is on Netflix or YouTube or Hulu?

1:06:20Right, and this is why in the very old days when the the record label guys were

1:06:26Reluctantly trying to figure out digital there were two different competing music services one had like three of the labels one had to of course

1:06:32That was a non-starter right? Who's gonna figure out if Madonna's on this label or not?

1:06:36And to ask you TV users to think that through is obviously a non-starter as well

1:06:42But for you for the same reasons you can you know why it's very important for Netflix, right?

1:06:46And there was a someone has to go to Netflix and every time something like that happens people just get confused and revolt

1:06:52I think there was something similar with the early days of blue did blu-ray versus

1:06:56HD DVDs and it was like there were some movies that would come out on both and then there were some front and it all

1:07:03But depended on the studio there the studio back blu-ray the studio black date back to HD HD

1:07:10What you go into back then? I mean again, this makes me sound old already, but back then you'd go into a store to buy a

1:07:16movie a

1:07:19physical copy of a movie on a spinning disk and it's like

1:07:22Who that most people who the hell knows what device they have, you know, right?

1:07:27They don't know what the hell an HD DVD is versus a blu-ray. They just know if it's you know, right gonna play

1:07:33So we're so we're in that world now

1:07:35I don't think that's gonna change anytime soon in part because Netflix and YouTube are so powerful there and they have no reason yeah

1:07:42To work with Apple, right? Well and YouTube is often its own universe because that what makes YouTube YouTube is not

1:07:50Professionally produced what I shouldn't say professionally because there's some terrific terrific

1:07:55Content producers or whatever they call them on YouTube

1:08:00It also doesn't matter because it if you're so if you're my kids and it sounds like your kid

1:08:04You don't care whether it's professional or not. You know, whether it's interesting or not

1:08:08It doesn't mean you don't value Game of Thrones right, but you equally value some stupid fortnight gaming video, right?

1:08:15something you want to watch and you know, it gets to the

1:08:19The oldest one of the oldest adages in the world is that you know doesn't matter how rich or poor you are

1:08:25You know, we all only have 24 hours a day. There's only so much time to watch shows and

1:08:29Boy, if you can fill it all up watching YouTube and Netflix, there's there's yeah

1:08:34There's not much room and it's very easy very easy at the end of the day to fill up all your time in Netflix

1:08:39So and this what I mean

1:08:42I absolutely get what Apple is trying to do and this is and this is by the way what I think the actual

1:08:46Apple TV strategy is is to run this storefront is to run a TV guide and to sell HBO and Showtime subscriptions and take those

1:08:54cuts

1:08:55Take cuts of that and that part is very straightforward

1:08:57Obviously if you could own the dominant TV guide or whatever we're gonna call TV

1:09:03that'd be incredibly powerful and valuable and

1:09:06Obviously if you could take a if you could extract rent from some of the programmers there

1:09:11That'd be good too. And in fact you end up sort of it. What is a cable model, right?

1:09:14That's why that's why I think when you hear people talking about this being a Netflix killer or or a cable TV bundle

1:09:22That's sort of where it could go. It's just not there right now, right?

1:09:25And so it's different than something like PlayStation view where?

1:09:31You pay for PlayStation V you paid like 40 bucks a month and then you get like a cable TV package

1:09:37I mean they do say with Apple TV channels that you'll get local you'll get local channels. I

1:09:41Don't think so. Well, and I see it then I don't understand how that's a TV replacement

1:09:46I mean it's again like if you subscribe to whatever the live TV thing that you Hulu is you'll get them, right?

1:09:54But Apple certainly hasn't cut deals with local TV providers and local networks again

1:09:58And if you get CBS All Access, you'll get your local CBS affiliate.

1:10:04But they're not.

1:10:05They are not selling-- at one point, they tried very hard to do this, but they're not

1:10:09doing it right now.

1:10:10They're not selling you a replacement bundle of TV channels for now.

1:10:16And if you ask them, they'll say, by the way, we're trying to get rid of the bundle, which

1:10:20is what they've consistently said now for several years after trying to do their own

1:10:24bundle.

1:10:25Again, it's a very similar experience.

1:10:29We were talking about having to log into

1:10:31the Wall Street Journal every couple of days,

1:10:33and you have to re-log in.

1:10:34I run into it.

1:10:35I still subscribe, I still have cable TV

1:10:38from Philadelphia's favorite company, Comcast.

1:10:42Partly out of apathy, partly out of that we really do,

1:10:47and my wife especially, really loves TiVo.

1:10:50And it is a terrific experience.

1:10:54It's still the best fast-forwarding rewind pause experience of anything, because it's

1:10:58all stored locally on a disk and it all works very fast.

1:11:03And it never times out and you never sit there.

1:11:04Ever, never, never, never.

1:11:06And there are no restrictions on it.

1:11:08Right.

1:11:09Because if we could get the Hulu product or the YouTube product or the Hulu product right

1:11:12now, sometimes there's a DVR that lets you fast-forward and sometimes they say fast-forwarding

1:11:17is not allowed.

1:11:18And again, I cover this stuff so I know why there's that distinction, but it's infuriating.

1:11:23And again, as a consumer, you shouldn't have to care about it.

1:11:25- Right, I haven't read it yet.

1:11:26Talk about running out of things to read,

1:11:27but there was an article I saw yesterday,

1:11:30it's in my tabs to read a Medium article

1:11:32on the oral history of TiVo, which I'm looking forward to,

1:11:35but haven't really read it yet.

1:11:37But I've said this on the show before,

1:11:39it's almost tragic where

1:11:42almost everything in the world is getting computerized.

1:11:49Like I think I've got a computerized toothbrush,

1:11:51really do at this point. Probably a sponsor. Yeah, quip, who is a one time sponsor. Pretty

1:11:57sure there's a computer in there. You know, my air pods are computerized. They're little

1:12:01too little. Many computers that sit in my ears. And when TV got computer most of the

1:12:08time when things get computerized, they get better. Right? Air pods are better than wired,

1:12:13non computerized, dumb electrical, your ear pods. When TiVo came about, and who was the rival to

1:12:20to TiVo. There was that there are replay replay right there. There's TiVo and there's replay

1:12:26and when they first came about you'd put this box and you'd connect your cable to it and

1:12:30it would record your shows. And you know this was the late 90s early like when I remember

1:12:36having a mind blown some when someone's like rewound a Kobe Bryant dunk from real time

1:12:41and replay it for me. I was like you can do that. That seems like illegal. I remember

1:12:45where I saw Tiva the first time. In 2000, I went to work at a company, Barebone Software,

1:12:52the makers of BB Edit. And Rich Siegel, co-founder of the company, kindly invited my wife and

1:12:59I over to his house for dinner. And I believe it was, it might have been October, but the

1:13:05Yankees were on in the playoffs. And so we had dinner and watched a baseball game. And

1:13:12like, we want to you want to go to the bathroom? Oh, just hold on here. Yeah. And it was like,

1:13:17what?

1:13:18Yeah, it seemed it seemed not right.

1:13:19And no spinner. No, no, you know, and then you hit another button. And we literally went

1:13:24to Best Buy. And I also remember very specifically, it was Best Buy the next day and bought the

1:13:28exact same TiVo that that Rich Siegel had. We're like, Oh, my God, we need this. And

1:13:32like, it was almost a shame that we couldn't buy it. If we could have if Best Buy was a

1:13:3624 hour a day operation, we would have bought it at like,

1:13:39sound like the people who went to go see the first the first motion pictures and got freaked

1:13:43out by the train coming into the audience. But anyway, the whole point of the computer

1:13:47fication of TV with TiVo was that it put you in control. And if you wanted to fast for you,

1:13:52the person who bought this box, you could fast forward the commercials and skip them,

1:13:58or you could pause the show and go back. And you didn't watch anything you didn't want to watch.

1:14:02And now as the industry has gone forward, as we've computerized further and gotten to streaming,

1:14:08the computerfication has taken that control away from you and given you unskippable interstitions.

1:14:13Yes. Yes. And, you know, as an aside, the programmers spent years trying to sue TiVo

1:14:21and Replay out of existence, right, for that very reason. Failed. And now they've succeeded in a

1:14:25way because they now have this new way of insisting that you watch ads. Unless, of course, they're

1:14:30Netflix and they don't show ads at all. Right. Right. Exactly. Yeah. And, you know, I think

1:14:36I think Netflix is very conscious of it.

1:14:38I'm anti-autoplay with Netflix.

1:14:41I would love to have some way to turn

1:14:44all of my various interfaces to Netflix

1:14:47to not autoplay as my mouse hovers over something

1:14:49and starts making noise.

1:14:51But at least they don't make me watch anything

1:14:54I don't wanna watch.

1:14:54- It's a huge thing.

1:14:55I mean, I get people complaining about the autoplay

1:14:59and stuff like that, but I mean,

1:15:00the amount of control they give you,

1:15:04And again, they're at 50, 60 million US subscribers.

1:15:07That should be the default for how you consume this stuff.

1:15:12And to me, it seems like just a ton of pressure on everyone

1:15:15else to match that.

1:15:17The flip is, if you want to make something free,

1:15:19or at least cheaper, then people will sit through ads.

1:15:22I think about this all the time.

1:15:26There's a Hulu version with ads.

1:15:28There's a Hulu version without ads or with limited ads.

1:15:31And it's like a $4 difference.

1:15:32And to me, it's a no-brainer.

1:15:33She'd pay four bucks to not watch ads,

1:15:35but the majority of Hulu subscribers

1:15:37get the cheaper one with ads.

1:15:39Money means something to people.

1:15:41- Yeah, I've watched my son,

1:15:42I forget what my son was binge watching on Hulu last summer.

1:15:46I don't know.

1:15:47It might've been Seinfeld.

1:15:49I don't know what it was,

1:15:51but he was watching some old sitcom,

1:15:53binge watching it on Hulu,

1:15:54and it was sitting through these unskippable ads,

1:15:56and I got on my phone and looked up,

1:15:59and I was like, "Oh my God, $4 a month.

1:16:01"Here, did you just?"

1:16:02And I was like, "Here."

1:16:03I just bought you something, no more ads.

1:16:05- Yeah, there is a little trend of services

1:16:07like Tubi TV and Pluto that are free

1:16:12and that have some pickup because, again,

1:16:15people are willing to put up with inconvenience

1:16:18in exchange for free stuff.

1:16:19- Well, basically though, where I was going with this

1:16:21with the Wall Street Journal logging in

1:16:23is that I've got all these apps now like ESPN

1:16:25and I can get ESPN on my Apple TV

1:16:27because I have a cable subscription,

1:16:30I can use it to sign in, and son of a bitch,

1:16:32if I don't have to reconfirm my Comcast thing

1:16:37way too often, that every, you know, maybe not days,

1:16:41but every few weeks, and then there's some of those apps

1:16:45or channels, you know, whatever you wanna call them,

1:16:47that I only wanna watch once in a while,

1:16:49and it's inevitable that I'm going to have to start

1:16:52by picking up a device, going to a URL,

1:16:56waiting for a four-digit code, and it's like,

1:16:58God, I just, all I did was tell my wife,

1:17:00I think we're both gonna really like this show.

1:17:02And meanwhile, I've gotta sit there and futz around.

1:17:06- Now, I think some of it got better,

1:17:07but some of it's like, the FX ones were terrible.

1:17:11You'd have to keep re-logging in,

1:17:13and then they would limit your access within the app

1:17:15unless you signed up for like a fan club or something else

1:17:18and gave them more information.

1:17:20And it just inevitably just ended up bailing.

1:17:21It's like, I'll pay to watch Mission Impossible

1:17:24somewhere else where I won't watch it.

1:17:25- I think we ran into that, there was a series on FX,

1:17:29I think with the story of Johnny Versace's assassination.

1:17:33And it was exactly like that.

1:17:35We pay for FX, we're supposed to be able to get this app

1:17:38so that we can watch it whenever we want.

1:17:40And it was really horrible.

1:17:42So what's left is Apple TV Plus,

1:17:47which is apparently wholly separate from Apple TV channels.

1:17:51I guess because the idea is if you already have cable

1:17:58or PlayStation Vue or the, what's the YouTube one called

1:18:01where you get a whole package of cable content.

1:18:05- YouTube Live maybe?

1:18:06- Yeah.

1:18:07- Something, something.

1:18:08- That you might not wanna give that thing up

1:18:12to get channels, but you still wanna pay or not pay,

1:18:17who knows, for Apple's original content.

1:18:19- Super confusing.

1:18:22In part, and Apple has been very quiet about this,

1:18:26isn't telling most of its partners what it's doing here.

1:18:29They're certainly not telling people like me off the record what they're doing.

1:18:33And so you can sort of just make some educated guesses, right?

1:18:37So my best hunch is this is a thing they're going to give you if you're an Apple customer

1:18:43in some way, whether maybe you own an iPhone or you have bought some other bundle and there's

1:18:47some sort of incentive, they're going to throw it in for free or almost nothing.

1:18:53We haven't talked about this yet, but a big change for Apple is they're distributing this

1:18:57video now and the storefront on Roku, on Samsung, on Amazon Fire devices, which is pretty staggering.

1:19:05And so maybe you'll pay something if you want to watch the Reese Witherspoon show or the

1:19:10Steven Spielberg show or the J.J. Abrams show.

1:19:13But even then, they can't charge you very much because they maybe have 30 shows coming

1:19:21And they're probably going to put out two a month.

1:19:24And the way that the TV is sold today, you can't sell a subscription to something that

1:19:29has two shows a month.

1:19:32Everything else, Netflix, CBS, I'll access Hulu, on and on and on, have some smattering

1:19:37of new stuff, in Netflix's case, a ton of new stuff, and then a huge library of stuff.

1:19:43And that's what you're paying 10 or 15 bucks a month for.

1:19:47And I just can't imagine how Apple charges you anything close to that.

1:19:50All right. I, the closest I can think is that what they're, if they do charge something for it,

1:19:55it's that they think they're something like HBO, but even HBO has a library. You can just go and

1:20:03watch all of the old Sopranos you know, and on top of that, and HBO would say this for years,

1:20:08that the majority of their viewing was people watching old movies. Yeah. And they, so they

1:20:14would get you to subscribe because it's a pranos or sex in the city or game of thrones, but most

1:20:18You're watching was Fast and the Furious and I were very clear about this and they spent a lot of money to license those movies

1:20:24from Warner Brothers and other studios

1:20:26Because you can only watch The Sopranos X number of times a month

1:20:31And you know, even CBS has a smattering of new shows. I like the called son of Good Wife

1:20:38I think it's called the good fight

1:20:40But the thing that most people are watching there or they've got the Twilight Zone, right?

1:20:45But you can watch everything else that CBS has ever made and that's the proposition. Yeah Jordan Peele

1:20:51I don't see how I yeah, I don't see a Jordan Peele's thing

1:20:53I don't see how Apple can sell this as a standalone product now. They have called it a subscription service

1:20:59So, you know

1:21:01But I think they still allow themselves a bunch of wiggle room if it if it's a subscription service that is then bundled in

1:21:07We are subscriptions. You can still call it a subscription service, but I just don't see how they're selling this

1:21:11All right, let's pause we'll come back to Apple TV+

1:21:13But let me thank our third and final sponsor of the day of the show of the episode. It's our good friends at Squarespace

1:21:18Look, you need to make a website or maybe you have an old website that you ought to remake

1:21:23You should take out check out Squarespace

1:21:25They have everything you need they will let you register domain

1:21:31They'll let you pick up starting template all visual all graphical you do it right in a browser

1:21:37It's all WYSIWYG while you're deciding how your website's going to look

1:21:40What you see in your browser as you design it is exactly what visitors to your site will see when they visit it

1:21:47All sorts of components you want to have a want to host a podcast you want to do a blog?

1:21:52They've got it you do it you post your updates right through Squarespace

1:21:55You want to have a portfolio if you're a designer you want to have a store because you're selling stuff

1:22:00Just opening up a restaurant. Somebody you know is opening a restaurant or something like that

1:22:05Anything like that you could do it through Squarespace. They make it so easy

1:22:09They have the best analytics interface for seeing who's visiting your website that I've ever seen and rather than overwhelm you with all sorts of numbers

1:22:17It's just a really nice information design

1:22:19And prevent presents everything you want to know to glance has all the details you'd want to know really is a great service

1:22:26They have award-winning customer service

1:22:28People who go to Squarespace are very happy at Squarespace

1:22:31I always say this all the time you visit Squarespace sites every day and you have no idea

1:22:36because a they don't look cookie cutter. It's not like there's three or four templates and everybody's

1:22:41Squarespace sites look the same. It's very easy to customize with your own brand. And it's so easy.

1:22:47You just don't know it. You have to like go to your browser view source and start looking for

1:22:52the little Squarespace things to even know. So it's really, really great in that way of just owning

1:22:57your own website, which I think as we get more and more disdainful of Facebook and other social

1:23:03media as your only your business is only online face. I think everybody's sort of moving back to

1:23:09wanting to own their own website and Squarespace is a great way to do it.

1:23:13So here's what you do. You can just start building a website today. You get a free trial

1:23:18last a whole month at squarespace.com. And just remember this code talk show, know the just talk

1:23:25show and at checkout. When you do pay after your free trials up, you'll save 10% and you can pay

1:23:30pay for a whole year in advance. Save 10% on a whole year. It's like getting a couple

1:23:33of months for free. My thanks to Squarespace for their continuing support of the talk show.

1:23:38I guess the other thing that goes unsaid with the pricing on this whole thing and all of

1:23:42the lack of pricing information is that it's crying for some sort of super bundle where

1:23:49you pay 30 40 $50 a month to Apple and you get music, news, TV, iCloud arcade. Well,

1:23:58iCloud is the big quiet. I would love to see them include that because I think it's it's a

1:24:03running years long running complaint of mine many years at this point that the the free amount of

1:24:12storage they give people at iCloud especially when they're buying 800-900 dollar phones is almost

1:24:19criminal and I think it's just heartbreaking. I mean that in all sincerity but no hyperbole

1:24:27that thinking about people who lose their phone or have their phone stolen or whatever,

1:24:32and don't have an iCloud backup of everything that was on it and the photos and stuff that they've

1:24:37lost because they're maybe they only had one and only one Apple device, their phone. And it's a

1:24:45problem we collectively in the industry have solved if you have enough space so that when you

1:24:50plug it into charge and it's connected to Wi Fi, just uploads everything to the server. And as

1:24:54disappointed as you might be when you have to go buy a new phone because your other one

1:24:57was lost or stolen or it's a simple problem of you maybe it wasn't lost or stolen but you upgrade

1:25:03and how do you get your stuff from the old phone to the new phone and you don't know that if you

1:25:08don't have the iCloud stores that you could go to the Apple store and wait an hour and the genius

1:25:13will help you do it with using a computer to move it between there people don't think like that

1:25:17people may not know that you can do it I mean you know that there's some number of people who are

1:25:20losing. So I would love to see them bundle iCloud into it.

1:25:24Yes. And, and also I resent iCloud. I resent being forced to pay an extra $3 a month because

1:25:31I ran out of space. It just feels I did buy a super expensive phone and it, by the way,

1:25:36if they just said that was part of Apple care and added it there and I didn't see it, I'd

1:25:40be fine. So I think, and I think they can probably do a bunch of different bundles and

1:25:44swap stuff in and out of that. Yeah. And make it easy to manage and easy to say, you know

1:25:49I never play these arcade games. So drop arcade from my bundle. But something like that, that

1:25:57made it easier and made it one bill from Apple per month for recurring stuff would be compelling

1:26:05just on a simplicity front. And if you saved some amount of money, you know, where there's

1:26:11three things to say, they're all 10 bucks a month, but if you get all three, you only

1:26:15pay $25 a month, you know, is also very, very compelling to real people. And I kind of feel

1:26:22like they haven't worked that all out. And therefore they don't want to talk about pricing

1:26:26of the individual things other than news, which they have to talk about because they're

1:26:31actually selling it already.

1:26:32Yeah, I just, I mean, again, I just think that they're, I just think that it's going

1:26:36to be free, right to the majority of Apple users and they don't want to say that yet

1:26:40or, and also because once you, whenever you do put that price on that Reese Witherspoon

1:26:43show. Now all of a sudden, when it comes out this fall, is it worth this much? Whereas

1:26:50if it's just sort of bundled in, you go, great, it's exciting. And so the idea would be that

1:26:56a it would get people buying Apple devices or keep people buying them. But then even

1:27:00if you're using a Roku or Apple or Amazon Fire, and but they're, they've got this thing

1:27:06built in and you can watch the Reese Witherspoon show, which I think I'm hoping is going to

1:27:12be one of the better shows. You know, I'm a huge Larry Sanders fan and I just love the

1:27:17idea of a show about a show. I think it's so ripe for...

1:27:21I like Studio 60. I'll watch any version of it. I liked it when they went to Afghanistan.

1:27:27My wife and I loved Studio 60. Absolutely loved it. And it's my favorite Aaron Sorkin

1:27:33show ever. I loved it. I thought it was like a parody of an Aaron Sorkin show, but I did

1:27:39love it.

1:27:40that's why I loved it though, because I didn't feel like it was actually sanctimonious. I felt

1:27:45it was- I was incredibly sanctimonious. They were treating this SNL show as if it was the White

1:27:50House. And just as important, and again, there was a plot where they had to go rescue hostages

1:27:55from Afghanistan. There was a show about an SNL show. It was great. I thought it was almost,

1:28:00yeah, but I thought it was like you said, a parody of an Aaron Serkin show, which is what made it

1:28:04more digestible to me. I loved 30 Rock. I thought 30 Rock, which coincidentally launched the same

1:28:09year as Studio 60, which was weird because I know confused me, and ordinarily for weeks,

1:28:15because not only were they both shows about an SNL type show, but the numbers 30 and 60

1:28:20are

1:28:21Yes. And we also assume that the Aaron Sorkin show be the one that succeeded not the one

1:28:25from Tina Fey.

1:28:26Yeah, exactly. So I love a show about a show. So this morning show thing and and it has

1:28:31a terrific cast. I think Jennifer Aniston is one of the funniest actresses we've ever

1:28:35seen.

1:28:36This this goes to the thing though, right like so they put out a bunch of shows and you're excited about that

1:28:42I was gonna call it studio 16, whatever the morning show is called

1:28:44I think it's just called the morning show morning show and maybe someone else is excited about the Jason Amo is blind show

1:28:50You just don't know if any of it's gonna be any good the people who are make TV for a living fail most the time

1:28:58Apple this is why I never understood why Apple came out with those two shows a couple years ago

1:29:02Like if you're gonna do programming do a bunch of it because most of it won't work

1:29:05So again, sort of the best case scenario, they'll have a handful of these things will be successes,

1:29:12which again, is why you really can't charge people at least initially for this stuff.

1:29:16One of the ones I don't think unless I fast forwarded, they didn't really mention it. There's

1:29:22one of the shows they've got who was the guy who did the the new version of Battlestar Galactica?

1:29:29Ron, uh, drawing a blank on his last name, but he's got a show coming up, which sounds

1:29:38fantastic, which is, uh, the basic gist is what would have happened if this sixties space

1:29:44race had never ended. You sure that's not an Amazon show? No, it's an Apple show. Okay.

1:29:50See, there's a fusion. Uh, I guess it's still so in the works that they didn't even tease

1:29:56it at the thing. Sounds like a fantastic show. But again, how many people are going to sign

1:30:03up for it if it's only six shows or something?

1:30:05Yeah, and six. And again, like the idea that, that again, maybe you like that show, maybe

1:30:11it's a great show, but, but it's, it's generally those shows have to appeal to one audience

1:30:16or another, which means someone else doesn't like it. I just, I'll just keep saying it

1:30:21over and over. It's just very hard to imagine that I'm having enough stuff that they can

1:30:25and sell actual subscriptions to a significant number of people.

1:30:29Now, if that Studio 60 show, which is not Studio 60,

1:30:32is thrown as a freebie, all of a sudden you're

1:30:35delighted to get it as a bonus, as opposed to being upset

1:30:38that it's not worth paying for.

1:30:40- Ron Moore, no need to send in corrections, folks.

1:30:42Ron Moore was the showrunner for the Battlestar Galactica.

1:30:46And here's a deadline story.

1:30:49I think it's still untitled about the show.

1:30:55I guess that's maybe why they didn't even

1:30:57put them up on stage.

1:30:58It's as yet untitled.

1:30:59But anyway, sounds terrific.

1:31:01And I love alternate reality, alternate universe,

1:31:04science fiction type things like that.

1:31:06- And by the way, I think this is,

1:31:10Amazon Prime is not killing it.

1:31:13But most people aren't subscribing to Amazon Prime

1:31:18for video or they're not, they're certainly not subscribing

1:31:20to the Amazon video service.

1:31:22They're getting free shipping or cheap shipping.

1:31:24and then they're getting some TV alongside it,

1:31:26and that lowers the stakes considerably.

1:31:28- Right.

1:31:30- Yeah, I don't know.

1:31:31But so I guess the idea would be that

1:31:33if they include their shows, if they do it,

1:31:36and just say, look, if you've got a device

1:31:38that plays Apple TV, you could get these Apple TV Plus.

1:31:41But the fact that they're calling it Plus

1:31:43makes me think they're going to charge for it,

1:31:45because there's Apple News, and Apple News is free,

1:31:47and Apple News Plus is paid.

1:31:49And so therefore, Apple TV Plus should be paid.

1:31:53You know if any company would screw around and be that inconsistent with their names. It would be Apple. I

1:31:59Don't I don't I mean this is again very insidery, but the Disney thing is gonna be called Disney Plus, right?

1:32:06And who knows what the the thing formerly known as Time Warner thing is gonna be called someone referred to as HBO max today

1:32:12Yeah, I don't know if it's a real name or not, but someone's got to figure out a different word than plus

1:32:16Yeah, well that was one mystery, but and they're not using the word. They're using the plus symbol sign

1:32:22- Yeah, to make it more complicated for us.

1:32:24(laughing)

1:32:27Yeah, but so yeah, we go back to where we started,

1:32:31which is we don't know what the point of this is

1:32:34as a business, we don't know what the proposition is

1:32:37as a consumer, and we don't even know

1:32:39what these things are.

1:32:40We saw, I mean, they showed us shockingly little stuff.

1:32:43I mean, I've been thinking about this for a week now.

1:32:47If you're gonna get Steven Spielberg and Jennifer Aniston

1:32:50JJ Abrams on stage, you're probably only going to get to do it once. You can't bring them back

1:32:54next fall to stand up on stage again and show off their TV shows. So that's a big ass to get those

1:33:01guys on stage. So to get them up there on a stage and then describe a TV show, but not show it,

1:33:07it just seems crazy to me. Yeah. And I'm not familiar with the up-fronts. You mentioned the

1:33:12term before, but you know, it, like you said that the, my understanding is that typically they'll

1:33:18show the media writers, TV critics, entire episodes.

1:33:23Yes, the entire episodes is usually sort of a rarity, like, we're so confident, we're going to

1:33:29show you the entire episode. Usually, it's a well produced sizzle reel, and you can make anything

1:33:34look good. And it's kind of silly to make, to draw conclusions. But it is the expectation that you're

1:33:39going to see the thing and at least to get a sense of, is it funny? Is it dramatic? Is it whatever?

1:33:44none of the above. Or a trailer, right? Maybe that's the equivalent of a civil real. You could

1:33:50at least get a teaser, right? Which to me is a distinct thing from a trailer. Like a teaser is

1:33:57just— You might be excited. The Joker preview teaser came out today. It's great. I don't know

1:34:07if you've seen it. No, I haven't seen it. It looks great. It looks great and it's so compelling.

1:34:10And again, I've got no idea if the Joker is gonna be a good movie

1:34:13But I'm definitely interested in it now based on a two-minute clip

1:34:16Amazing what I remember my favorite teaser was when when George Lucas announced that he was going to re-release the original Star Wars

1:34:24trilogy and

1:34:26you know, it's something I'd only seen on a big screen as a little kid and

1:34:30And that the teaser was a TV floating in outer space

1:34:35I don't know if the TV was actually showing the Star Wars movies

1:34:38But it was like a cathode ray tube TV and it's like, you know, here's what you've seen and it was you're in a movie theater

1:34:44Here's the big teaser

1:34:45There's a little TV

1:34:46Floating in space starts showing a Star Wars movie and then an x-wing fighter blows it up and zooms through real big

1:34:52Huh, and it's like great, you know coming back

1:34:54Star Wars, you know, there's a teaser right? Boom. There you go. And it's telling you here's everything you need to know

1:35:01It's Star Wars on a big-ass screen and a big theater. You're gonna love it

1:35:06But they didn't even do that. They had they had like shots

1:35:10shots of shows

1:35:13It was really kind of bad for you and I was following along remotely watching listening to watching like the the Twitter and seeing

1:35:21people's reactions and it was just everybody over and over again saying

1:35:24They're not gonna actually not show the shows, right?

1:35:28They're not gonna actually not show the shows right over and over and over and then it got towards the end and they're like

1:35:33They're not gonna show the shows

1:35:35(laughing)

1:35:37- Again, I mean, I'm trying to like spin my way through it

1:35:40or imagine Apple's thinking, and again,

1:35:42when the Steven Spielberg show comes out,

1:35:45they're gonna promote the heck out of it

1:35:47and they'll buy TV spots and it'll pop up on your phone

1:35:50whether you wanna see it or not,

1:35:51and they're really gonna push it,

1:35:52and again, people who don't listen to this podcast

1:35:55won't care that they had this deeply weird event in March,

1:35:58but I just still don't know why you would do that.

1:36:01And again, it's one thing to have Tim Cook come up and say,

1:36:04in the fall we're going to have this stuff. It's going to be great. Check it out." And then it's

1:36:07another thing to like load up A-A-A list stars and have them stand on stage and do that.

1:36:14Pete: Yeah. I don't know. Well, I don't have much more to add, other than I might have to have you

1:36:22back on the show in the fall. [laughs]

1:36:23Chris I did ask the Apple folks, "What are you doing?" And of course, you know,

1:36:27they refused to pretend that there was anything weird about it except that, you know, I said,

1:36:32look, you know, this is how it's done on the upfronts. He said, well, we don't need to do it

1:36:35that way. We're Apple. We're different. All right. I don't think that's going to work, but maybe we'll

1:36:40well, but yes, I will come back in the fall. If you ask Peter Kafka, I really appreciate your

1:36:44time. I appreciate your insight. And I am so honestly, my, my thought here, we, as we wrap

1:36:49up the show, my thought is I thank God Peter is as confused as I am because I've really spent the

1:36:58last week or so. And again, I was away for the first part of it on a vacation. And I thought,

1:37:03maybe I maybe this is why I need to go to these events because I'm confused.

1:37:06John Greenewald You could be equally confused from a remote distance.

1:37:11Yeah. But if you want to hear me being confused on a regular basis, there's Re/Code Media with

1:37:15Peter Kafka available on whatever podcast app you choose, including an episode with yourself

1:37:20with your Well, it's okay. I was on your show. So they can start by listening to the episode.

1:37:23that I was on. That is still one of our best episodes, by the way. That's not just flattery.

1:37:28I enjoyed it. It's flattery, but it's true. I hate talking about what I do. I hate talking

1:37:32about myself, and I enjoyed that episode very much. So. You did a good job. Thanks,

1:37:37Jeff. Peter, thank you very much. Thank you.