0:00:00How you doing? All right. Yourself? Great. Really? Well, I'm all right.
0:00:06It's like a Woody Allen line. I know we're not supposed to talk about Woody Allen anymore,
0:00:17but Woody Allen. I went back to being honest. Well, you know what? Yeah, exactly. There's
0:00:23so many. You know, I know that Mike Michael Jackson is the celebrity of the moment who
0:00:31because of this HBO documentary, there's a serious and, you know, correct discussion
0:00:39about, you know, hey, what do you know? We've got his legacy. We're allowed to music and
0:00:45we still listen to his music. Yeah, exactly. Can you still play Michael Jackson? That's
0:00:48the wrong way to phrase it. I guess like, can you personally I think is like the right
0:00:52way to phrase it. Like, can you personally justify it? You know, I think that's the question
0:00:56we're all having to ask ourselves.
0:00:58Right. I was out with friends over the weekend and we were at an establishment and you know,
0:01:03they were playing Michael Jackson music. I didn't even really notice it because Michael
0:01:08Jackson music to me is just one of the, you know, you just hear it all the time. I wasn't
0:01:11really thinking about it, but somebody was like, Ooh, kind of awkward. And then, you
0:01:14know, it is, but it's like, do you want, so do you even want to play it? Let's say you
0:01:17want a restaurant, do you play Michael Jackson music? If you know, you just don't want to
0:01:21people thinking about stuff like that.
0:01:22But on the other hand,
0:01:23it's some of people's favorite music of all time.
0:01:27It's a tough decision, you know?
0:01:30- Yeah, it's hard to think with music and movies,
0:01:32because, you know, creative works in general,
0:01:34because we attach our own memories to those things
0:01:37and our own meanings to them, which is good.
0:01:40That's how art should be.
0:01:41You know, we sort of attach things that happen in our lives
0:01:45or people or memories or whatever to them,
0:01:47and, you know, they become greater
0:01:49than what they were created for. Like, the person who sang the song had their purpose,
0:01:54their reason for singing the song, but it may mean something completely different to
0:01:57us. So, I think it becomes much harder to like, to then think about how to separate
0:02:01those things. With somebody living, I think it's almost easier, because you're able
0:02:06to say, "Well, I don't want this person who did these horrific things to continue
0:02:10to benefit, you know, from this relationship." But I don't know. It's a tough one.
0:02:17And then there's, you know, yeah, like let's say someone like Kevin Spacey, you know, who's it was so
0:02:22The allegations against him were so significant and compelling that they literally took a movie
0:02:30What was the name of that movie? I forget it was a Ridley Scott movie
0:02:33Where he played like John Paul Getty. I
0:02:35Mean it was like it it didn't have the name wasn't very evocative of the subject matter
0:02:41so I can't recall. But the movie was effectively in the can and was only a few weeks out from
0:02:47coming out and they re-shot the movie with a new actor, Christopher Plummer, in the role.
0:02:54Which is remarkable. And I remember watching the movie, which is a spoiler. Well, I guess because
0:03:03they took him out of the movie, I didn't face any sort of moral conundrum over whether to watch the
0:03:07the movie. So I guess that's not a spoiler, but I watched the movie and it was immersive enough
0:03:14because Ridley Scott is super, super talented. One of my all time favorite directors that I,
0:03:20I tried to watch thinking, can I tell that this was reshot without plumber? Like everything,
0:03:27you know, like single shots of plumber as opposed to two shots with him and other characters.
0:03:33And like, Oh, the wig is different. Well, not the wig, but just the shots,
0:03:37You know like how many of them are two shots where you can tell you know?
0:03:40Oh, huh either. He is in the room with the other actors or they've sufficiently done
0:03:47Special effects to convince you he's in the room with the other actors
0:03:51And how many of them are it's a one-shot on his character cut to the opposite angle on the other characters
0:03:57and they just took shots where they were playing against spacey and
0:04:02and use, you know, and then I see what you're saying. If you keep your eye open for that and
0:04:07you just kind of if you've ever edited even just edited video, not like serious films,
0:04:11you kind of know what that's like. If you try to just edit a conversation where there's,
0:04:16let's say three shots, there's one with both characters, one on Michael or Matthew and one on
0:04:22John and then you intercut between those three shots. But I got lost. The movie was good
0:04:33enough that I got lost to keeping track of it, which is, you know, the way it should
0:04:36be. But there were some where I could tell. I don't think this was supposed to be so
0:04:40one shot, A shot, B shot. I think there should have been more of a master shot, but eventually
0:04:45you lose it.
0:04:46- Right, right, yeah.
0:04:48You sense like the tempo of the conversation says,
0:04:51"Hey, there should be some sort of, you know,
0:04:53kind of establishing shot
0:04:54relating to characters one another, but it's not there."
0:04:57- Right, and then what else was Spacey?
0:04:58With Spacey, there was the whole thing
0:05:00where he was the star, co-star, I should say,
0:05:02of "House of Cards."
0:05:04And they had one season to go when the scandal broke
0:05:09and, you know, he was alive at the end of the last season
0:05:13and then they just decided he was dead
0:05:15to do the last season and didn't seem to go very well in terms of popularity. But what
0:05:23to do? They also, they're caught between a rock and a hard pace. I don't know. I
0:05:30tend to, I've mentioned this on the show before, I tend to disassociate the artist
0:05:34from the art. And so like, I have no problem watching Kevin Spacey movies, but I also understand
0:05:41they're not making new Kevin Spacey movies. I don't have a problem listening to Michael Jackson
0:05:46music, but yeah. I don't think there's any hard fast rule for me. I mean, I think a large part
0:05:53of it for me is sort of, you know, I listen to the way people think about it and the way that they
0:05:58talk about it and how it feels to them. And I try to always work from that angle. And I know
0:06:04it's weird because like the older I get, and I don't think this is purely just age, but
0:06:10it is certainly an experience based thing. But the older I get, the less likely I am to just
0:06:16say things. You know, you know what I mean? Right? Like you get you just become more cognizant of
0:06:21powers the wrong word. You know, we do have some sort of small power in the in the platform that
0:06:28we you know, that we have in terms of media or whatever the case may be. But even just as a
0:06:33person on a person to person basis, you have some sort of power based on like your reputation or,
0:06:38you know, your cache with your friends or audience or whoever it is you're talking to.
0:06:43And I just think that as I get older, I realized that when I was younger, I was really full of
0:06:49shit. And, you know, it's just like, you know, we're all we're all full of it to some degree,
0:06:53because we're figuring it out as we go. You know, sometimes we're saying things about what we
0:06:57believe, and we're figuring out what we believe as we're saying it, you know, it's not like we've
0:07:02spent hours pondering this thing and have like a concise opinion on every matter, right? We're all
0:07:07figuring things out as we go. I just figure I just find out like as I'm older, the more I like,
0:07:12instead of taking a hard fast, you know, opinion on things, or even making sure that I have all of
0:07:17these opinions ready, I just listen more and talk less about those things, you know, and that I
0:07:22think is one of those topics that I still am doing a lot of that. I just don't know. You know, I don't
0:07:27know, I don't have any sort of hard fast rule. I think there are some things that I still enjoy
0:07:31personally, but that I would never go like, Oh, I still watch this. You should too, you know,
0:07:36I would never do that about those things.
0:07:39Trenton Larkin Yeah, I kind of, there's a part of me,
0:07:43I don't want to get in trouble. There's a part of me that thinks the whole, the best thing going on
0:07:53to me is the cultural change at a very deep level across multiple industries. And it's spreading like
0:08:00wildfire to every industry, which is that when people do bad things to others, the people
0:08:08who had the bad things done to them should be have a venue to speak up, report it, have
0:08:14it dealt with in a fair way. And, you know, almost all of these things have been it the
0:08:24root problem. I don't want to say one's a bigger problem than the other, like the bad
0:08:29Bad behavior is bad behavior and should be punished. But the structural problem is that
0:08:33in all of these industries, there was so much set up to keep people from reporting it. And
0:08:41if they did report it, report it to bury it and punish them or something like that. So
0:08:47as to send a message to other people who suffered similar harassment or abuse or whatever it
0:08:55is, you know, to send the message to keep quiet and like the dam has burst on that and
0:09:01I got them finished or maybe the dam has, you know, severely cracked and there's spouts
0:09:06of water coming out and it's inevitable that the rest of it's going to come down. And I
0:09:10think that's a good thing. I feel like sometimes people, you know, the, the sort of want to
0:09:17shaming you for watching Woody Allen movies is a little bit sanctimonious and it's the
0:09:22person telling you that trying to inject themselves into the story of where's they really had
0:09:27no no part in it. You know, but virtue signaling right to some degree. Yeah. Right. Like if
0:09:35you don't want to watch Woody Allen movies, that's, you know, to me, that's, that's the
0:09:38line that I, I, I wouldn't feel comfortable crossing is it's telling other people not
0:09:42to enjoy Woody Allen movies or Michael Jackson music or Kevin Spacey movies or what have
0:09:46you, but certainly as a personal choice, it might be. Yeah, I think that's valid. Yeah.
0:09:52mean, I don't feel that imposing your worldview on other people is ever the right way to go. But
0:09:59I think certainly in terms of moral or ethical issues, it's in fact the worst thing you could do.
0:10:05Pete: Yeah.
0:10:05Jai: It's actually harmful because it does not create any sort of lasting, you know,
0:10:13change of lens for that person. So, if you're like, "Oh, hey, here, let me explain why I don't. Let
0:10:18me kind of give you my POV on this and let me explain why it's problematic or why I have a
0:10:24personal issue with it or my personal connection or whatever." And that is far more likely, I think,
0:10:30to end up with a scenario where you have somebody going, "You know what? My lens is a different
0:10:37color now." Or it's shifted in its angle or viewpoint rather than some sort of thing where
0:10:41you're shaming somebody because I think you end up having, it ends up having a lot of negative effect.
0:10:47and while you may cauterize the problem in the near term, it doesn't cure the infection or whatever,
0:10:54if you want to call it. Yeah. Update from the control booth. The movie was called
0:10:59All the Money in the World. That was the Ridley Scott film where they raced Kevin Spacey and
0:11:04replaced him with Christopher Plummer. Not surprised they didn't remember the name.
0:11:09Yeah, that's actually not a very good title, in my opinion. A little generic. Almost sounds like
0:11:13James Bond movie, like one of the Brosnan Bond films. Could you trick…
0:11:22Theme song by Ariana Grande. How many people could you trick into believing that they saw
0:11:29a Brosnan Bond film called All the Money in the World? I'll bet you get a lot of them.
0:11:34You might get me. 30, 40 percent.
0:11:36More. There were at least two that were close to that.
0:11:42that. Oh my God. I hope there's somebody from like Eon Productions who's listening, who
0:11:48listens to the show and they're like, "Damn, that would have been a good title."
0:11:53If only.
0:11:57We just hit the 30th anniversary of the World Wide Web, which is…
0:12:03Yes, we did.
0:12:05crazy. I certainly never heard of it in 1989 or 1989. I forget when I heard of it though.
0:12:15I believe it was, what was the app before Netscape? Was it called Mozilla?
0:12:21I forget what it was called. Mosaic? Mosaic. That's it. Mosaic. So I remember Mosaic like 1.0.
0:12:29Obviously there were other people who were on it before that, but 30 years since.
0:12:34to your job. - Netscape was my first browser.
0:12:36I'm almost positive, and once again, I can't pinpoint it,
0:12:41and I think I probably could if I sat down
0:12:44and talked to a bunch of people,
0:12:45or not a bunch, but a few key people, you know,
0:12:49who sort of introduced me to it,
0:12:51but it had to be about '92 for me, maybe '91.
0:12:55Simply because that was when I got my first modem.
0:13:00- Yeah.
0:13:00What I remember, and I've said this before on the show,
0:13:03a good thing I wasn't, I was very young at the time, so maybe I'd be forgiven. But I would have
0:13:07been, I would have been eating a lot of my own claim chowder on the future of the web.
0:13:12Where I thought that the web, I thought it was an interesting demo. This is in the mosaic era,
0:13:21but I was like, but it was so slow that I was like, who the hell would ever use this? Because
0:13:27everything I was doing on the internet was all terminal based. You know, you would open up a
0:13:31Z term Z term was the app on the Mac where you could dial in to the school modems and
0:13:36Even if you didn't have a great modem
0:13:39Even if you had like a 9600 baud modem or even 2400 would be 2400 was like slow enough
0:13:45We're even if you had a clean connection and you if you were a good typist, you could probably out type the buffer
0:13:499600 was like got it. If you got a clean phone call
0:13:53Everything you did was fast and that to me was the most important thing. I was you know
0:13:59simultaneously a Mac native Mac app UI snob for all of my regular computing and
0:14:06a total terminal snob for
0:14:09Internetting for lack of a better right because it was fast and it just seemed like this is what
0:14:15And it was also what the internet at the time was was built for it was built for these pure text connections
0:14:21But then you could like log in and the longest part was just waiting for the modem to connect
0:14:25type Elm
0:14:27All of a sudden the whole screen was filled with your email
0:14:29You could see everything that was new and then you could just sort of down arrow right arrow return
0:14:34You know a couple of keys, you know
0:14:35If you only had like three new messages you'd be in and out and you'd be done
0:14:38And whereas like if you tried firing up mosaic at the time
0:14:42Like you'd watch even if you had a clean connection, you'd watch every page paint in
0:14:48Yep, top to bottom or interleave
0:14:53Line over line it'd be like ah 50% of the lines we've surrendered them now
0:14:57We're gonna go back and render the other 50% didn't wasn't that what we did with we had like was it?
0:15:02GIF or JPEG that had the you could be in G. I believe now. This is before PNG
0:15:08It was no energy wasn't invented yet PNG was invented in the mid 90s
0:15:12The I don't want to go on a long sidetrack on it, but the backstory of PNG is that Eunice?
0:15:18What's you know Wow Christ they used to be a big computer company started with Una I
0:15:23Was gonna say UNICEF, but that's the charity, but yeah, I don't know it was a company that held a pound my data
0:15:30Thanks
0:15:31There was a company that held a patent on the GIF format, and they never enforced it
0:15:36I will put a link to the Wikipedia era though Jeff. Let's see what they say
0:15:43but anyway, they held a patent, but they didn't enforce it and so
0:15:47The various web browsers used it because it was very efficient for certain images that JPEG wasn't for
0:15:53Mm-hmm
0:15:55And then it took off and all of a sudden
0:15:58They they had a very strong interest in enforcing the patent before it expired and it was such an old thing that it was
0:16:05It it was expiring soon and so ping was sort of a let's save the internet and come up with a replacement for ping that
0:16:14Is unisys that's the name of the company
0:16:16- Gotcha.
0:16:18- Sorry for all, I apologize to every listener
0:16:20who thought of it instantly and was dying
0:16:22while I waited for it.
0:16:23Somewhere out there is somebody who also knew
0:16:26all the money in the world right away
0:16:27and wanted to ring in.
0:16:30So I've got two strikes. - Yeah, exactly.
0:16:32- Somebody's ready to stop listening to this episode already.
0:16:35- I bet you get a lot of the tweets
0:16:36where people aren't done listening and they're like,
0:16:38they're tweeting you in the name of things.
0:16:40- Yeah, yeah, yeah.
0:16:41I don't mind, I don't mind keep tweeting them, that's fine.
0:16:43- No, yeah, that's totally fine.
0:16:44- I actually enjoy it.
0:16:45- I'm like an engaged audience, right?
0:16:46- Exactly.
0:16:47It is a reason though, I probably should host a live show
0:16:51all the time with an audience so they can shout answers
0:16:53at me.
0:16:54(laughing)
0:16:55I guess the answer, I guess some of the shows do
0:16:56the IRC thing and people type answers, but.
0:16:59- Yeah, I can't remember what it,
0:17:01I was filming an episode of the computer show one time,
0:17:05well live one, the computer show by Sandwich Video, Adam.
0:17:10- Yeah, yeah, yeah.
0:17:13And Adam Lizagor, and it's a great show, super fun.
0:17:18And he was very kind and did a live show in SF
0:17:21and I was one of the non-jokey, serious straight man guests
0:17:26that they had on the show.
0:17:28- How did they miss this?
0:17:30- I don't know.
0:17:31I don't know if you weren't, you probably weren't in town.
0:17:32It was in SF.
0:17:33It wasn't in any particular event or anything.
0:17:34- Was it recorded?
0:17:35But did it ever air?
0:17:36- I don't think they did.
0:17:37I think he recorded it for posterity
0:17:39but not for release kind of thing.
0:17:42But you'd have to ask him or I'd have to check.
0:17:44But I don't think it was ever released.
0:17:46It wasn't that kind of thing.
0:17:47It was like, hey, let's do a live show.
0:17:49And they had the host there.
0:17:51It was a lot of fun.
0:17:53Matt from June Oven was on there,
0:17:58and myself, and pardon me, the other guest, I forget who.
0:18:03But it was fun, it was a lot of fun.
0:18:07But while we were on the stage,
0:18:11the hosts, you know, very straightforwardly asked me, I can't, I'm gonna even forget what
0:18:17it was, but I think it was something so simple, like, HTTP or URL or something, you know,
0:18:23like, what does that stand for? What does that mean? You know, the answer, the answer
0:18:27was wrong. It was so embarrassing. Like, I was I was dying. I mean, I, you know, it is
0:18:35what it is. But it was so funny to me later, especially because I was like, a room full
0:18:40of nerds, I mean, uber nerds who came to a, you know, a faux computer show, a comedy about
0:18:47a show that never existed in the 80s, or in the early 90s. And I gave them the wrong answer. But
0:18:54it was it was a lot. It was correct me if I was dying. It's like my nightmare, you know, you're
0:18:59in front of a highly technical audience, and you're supposed to, you know, have some sort of
0:19:02acumen and you somebody asks you a fairly simple question in your mind just goes, whoop. It's the
0:19:09the best.
0:19:10- Anyway, 30 years of the web.
0:19:11Do you see there was a group of people who remade
0:19:13the original browser, which was written by Tim Berners-Lee
0:19:18on the next workstation.
0:19:20It was sort of-- - So nice.
0:19:22- Do you know that?
0:19:22You didn't know that?
0:19:23The original-- - No, no, I did know that,
0:19:25but I didn't know somebody had remade it for this.
0:19:26- Oh, they recreated it.
0:19:27- Yeah, yeah, that's cool.
0:19:28- Well, I'll have to--
0:19:29- I saw somebody tweeted a picture of the actual workstation
0:19:32which was cool.
0:19:33- Oh, that is cool too.
0:19:34But they remade it in the web,
0:19:36like using modern web technology
0:19:37so you could play with it right in your web browser.
0:19:41And it's a pretty good--
0:19:42- Do they have BOD settings?
0:19:44- No.
0:19:45- Give people a real feel?
0:19:46- No, 'cause I think the idea was that next workstations
0:19:49at the time were all hooked up to university networks.
0:19:52But even the university network was so slow.
0:19:54That's what drove me nuts about Mosaic.
0:19:56I was like, this thing has no future.
0:19:59- I know.
0:19:59I mean, people were like, oh yeah, I had a 14.4 modem.
0:20:03I'm like, no, no, that's thousands.
0:20:05Let's talk in hundreds.
0:20:06Jared: Classic. But yeah, I mean, I think it was a certainly a world where everybody was trying to
0:20:17understand and the only, the only movie from the era that even got it remotely right was
0:20:24essentially made to be a comedy, which is Hackers. I mean, I feel that they just got so much right
0:20:28with that movie. And it was not really meant to be a serious movie at all. And in fact,
0:20:33got a lot wrong. But like the ethos was, wait, hackers or sneakers? Hackers? No, no sneakers,
0:20:38for sure. Like that era was was a little bit before that. But I, I think in terms of like the
0:20:44the emergence of the web as a populist enterprise, not a thing for nerds or enterprise, because
0:20:50technically sneakers is about an enterprise, you know, skunkworks project, right? It's it's not
0:20:56about users or consumers. And I think that the first like, big for me, the best big like, movie
0:21:02that got how the web was going to relate to like teenagers and hackers who would go on
0:21:07to essentially build the world's largest companies on the internet was hackers for
0:21:12me.
0:21:13That was…
0:21:14Pete: Did you see that the Captain Marvel website was designed to sort of, because the
0:21:20Captain Marvel movie, which I haven't seen yet but I'm looking forward to, it seems
0:21:23like it's a good movie, but I think it takes place in like 1995 or so.
0:21:28And so they made the film's official website look as though it were like a GeoCities website
0:21:35from 1995.
0:21:37But then, I think it was the first person who pointed it out that I have to say it did
0:21:41kind of offend me.
0:21:42As somebody who made websites back then and used to sweat the details like using what
0:21:48was a debabilizer, which was like the ultimate way to crush every possible bit out of a GIF
0:21:56without losing any of the actual colors.
0:21:58Like if there was a vague,
0:22:00like an eight byte metadata field that was optional,
0:22:03it would strip it out, you know, just to save the byte.
0:22:06- Right.
0:22:07- The Captain Marvel website is like totally,
0:22:10even though it looks like a 1995 thing with the blink tags
0:22:14and it's low res GIFs and stuff like that,
0:22:17it's like gigantic.
0:22:19It's like a 20 megabyte download.
0:22:20(laughing)
0:22:21Downloads all of the--
0:22:23- Would you take it a week and a half?
0:22:24(laughing)
0:22:25- Right, no, it never would have finished.
0:22:28No modem connection in history
0:22:31has ever stayed up long enough.
0:22:32- Has it ever stayed up that long?
0:22:33- At least in that time, to download all of this.
0:22:35And there's no computer that could have run it.
0:22:37There was no, nobody had like a computer
0:22:40that had enough RAM to render one tab
0:22:43that would have been that complex.
0:22:45It's sort of a cheat.
0:22:49Like I don't even know if you could make,
0:22:51if you use 1995 markup, would it work?
0:22:55Would it still look like that?
0:22:56I think it would.
0:22:57It just speaks to me of,
0:23:00they should have just found some old timers
0:23:02who typed all their HTML by hand.
0:23:04- Yeah, they were really dedicated, right?
0:23:05- Right.
0:23:06Anyway.
0:23:08- Have you seen "Captain Marvel?"
0:23:09- No, I told you I haven't seen it.
0:23:10- And we probably shouldn't talk about it this soon.
0:23:12Well, you haven't seen it anyway, so we won't talk about it.
0:23:14But yeah, it's really good.
0:23:15I thought you enjoyed it a lot.
0:23:16- No, it seems like a good premise.
0:23:17I love the idea that it takes place in 1995.
0:23:21Anyway, I'm looking forward to it,
0:23:22but I have not seen it.
0:23:24Yeah, yeah. I really wanted but completely spoiler free that I think I'll put this out into the universe but I really feel it is one of the first I mean it's certainly one of the first superhero movies but and certainly the highest grossing movie ever to examine to sort of put on screen.
0:23:42And I speak about this from a distance, but have read and listened to talk to other people about it. But it sort of puts a, the female internal life onto the screen in a way that is very, very interesting. It's a very emotionally driven superhero movie that is not about, you know, how a person's physicality can affect the world, but instead how they feel and think, you know, and putting that on screen in a way that is not
0:24:11It's, you know, almost painterly in its application of the way that it does that and
0:24:18certainly not in the very straightforward way that, you know, you normally see a male
0:24:25superhero interact with the universe or the world and you go like, "Oh yeah, I can see
0:24:30what he feels or how he thinks or whatever."
0:24:33You know, it's very, very interesting.
0:24:35But I'll just put that tidbit out there.
0:24:36It's cool.
0:24:37I loved it a lot.
0:24:38Why don't I take that perfect segue of the 30th anniversary of the web and tell you about
0:24:46our first sponsor, our good friends at Squarespace. Web may be 30 years old, but I'm telling you,
0:24:53I don't think it's ever been more important that if you want to get yourself out there,
0:24:57whether it's a personal site, a business, a blog, something like that, to start with
0:25:03the solid website. I think there's this backlash against doing everything on social networks.
0:25:09I think it's catching up to people. I think we've all figured out that for an awful lot
0:25:13of stuff, you shouldn't be thinking that all you need is an app. You need a website. And
0:25:18I'll tell you what, the best way to make a website, especially if you're not an expert.
0:25:23But even if you are an expert, even if you are somebody who remembers what I was talking
0:25:27about using Debabilizer back in the day, and you know HTML and CSS and JavaScript and JavaScript
0:25:33frameworks. Squarespace can get you up and running with a professional looking
0:25:37website so fast and it gives you all the control you want. If you're a totally
0:25:43non-technical expert you'll never leave the WYSIWYG environment of the
0:25:47Squarespace website. You use the website itself, you log in, what you see is what
0:25:51you get. When it looks the way you want it to look, you're done and when
0:25:55everybody visits your site they'll see exactly what you saw when you were
0:25:58dragging and dropping and modifying everything.
0:26:01You visit, I guarantee you, you visit websites every week
0:26:06and you have no idea that they're Squarespace built,
0:26:08Squarespace hosted websites.
0:26:10'Cause they don't all look the same.
0:26:11They all let you brand it exactly as far as you want
0:26:15or need to to express your brand.
0:26:17And they have all the features you could want.
0:26:19You can host a blog, you can do podcasts,
0:26:21you can sell stuff, they handle all the commerce.
0:26:24Anything you wanna do on a modern website,
0:26:26can do through Squarespace. It's a great company. Think about them next time you or somebody you
0:26:32know who comes to you and wants your help and you start rolling your eyes like, "Ah, now I'm in it
0:26:36because somebody in my family, my brother-in-law needs a website." Send them to Squarespace. He'll
0:26:40do it himself. It's so great. What you need to remember, you can just go there and start building
0:26:45your website. You get a free trial. Spend like 30 days, get a free trial. Then you have to pay.
0:26:51And when you do pay, remember this code talk show just T A L K S H O W and you get 10% off and you
0:26:58can get 10% off as much as you pay when you first sign up, including an entire year at advance.
0:27:04So go to squarespace.com/talk show and remember that code talk show when you actually pay and
0:27:12you'll get 10% off my thanks to Squarespace who haven't been around for 30 years, but
0:27:18feel like they've been sponsoring my show for 30 years.
0:27:20I've got a lot of other stuff to talk about. I was thinking I would save the Disney stuff
0:27:28for the end. Sure. But this is going to turn into America's favorite Disney podcast
0:27:35by the end of this. I have so many questions to ask you and so many things to say.
0:27:43Let's run through some news. So what else do we have here? WWDC dates were announced earlier
0:27:48today. We're recording on Thursday, March 14th. No surprises at all. June seven or three to seven.
0:27:55A lottery for tickets that starts today runs for a week. A little bit shorter window this time,
0:28:04but by like one day or something. Yeah. It's like last, not too much last year. I keep track of
0:28:10of this last year they announced today they announced on March 13th and it didn't start
0:28:15till June 4th and I think there was a little bit more of a window for signups for for lottery.
0:28:21I think what they've figured out is that people who want to go most of them sign up are probably
0:28:28already signed up right now four hours after it was an they don't need to give them so
0:28:32much time right right like there's other people a little bit there's other people who I guess
0:28:37are waiting for permission from work. But in some ways you can sign up for the lottery
0:28:42before you get permission and get the clearance after you win the ticket.
0:28:49Same location.
0:28:50I will tell you, just speaking from personal experience, sometimes getting clearance for
0:28:53these things is an effort. And so why would you do that if you don't know if you can even
0:28:57go?
0:28:58Right.
0:28:59How would you go for it?
0:29:00And I get it, they are non-transferable. It's not like you've got a golden ticket you can
0:29:03just hand off to somebody. I think they're non-transformable. I mean, you'd have to,
0:29:06you know, it's like if I'm going to ask for an exception. Yeah. Yeah. Um, and there's
0:29:12more students slots this time, 350 or so. Oh, I didn't see that. Yeah. That's good to
0:29:18know. Uh, I enjoyed that part last year. Uh, they had a, uh, I spent more time inside last
0:29:26year than two years ago. That last year was the second year at the San Jose convention
0:29:32center or whatever the person's name was on it. And inside the entrance, as I recall,
0:29:38you know, they, they also had a new fangled like RFID type entrance thing where you would
0:29:47take your badge. I think they even put it on a nice little snap, you know, thing that
0:29:51you could extend and then it would be like, welcome, John. And you'd come in and there
0:29:57was a nice little thing that sunlight, you know, but that was like where they had the
0:30:03Ethernet connections, etc. for fast downloads of all the betas, because they don't let
0:30:08you do those over the Wi Fi for for obvious reasons, even though they have very good Wi
0:30:11Fi there. I think part of the reason it's very good is they don't let people download
0:30:15six gigabyte betas of Xcode over the air. So there's an area where you can plug in
0:30:22and they have Ethernet cords and Thunderbolt cords and probably USB-C cords for whatever
0:30:28MacBook you have. And they also had the AR area. Do you remember this? Remember they had a couple
0:30:35of games last year? That's right. You know, and unsurprisingly, the students were very interested
0:30:42in those AR games. And they were also very good at them. Remember there was one where it was like,
0:30:46I think it was like Jenga blocks effectively, and you had like a virtual like slingshot on your
0:30:51phone and your goal was to knock over, sort of like a game of ping pong, two people across
0:30:57from the table from each other. But instead of hitting a ball at each other, you were
0:31:02shooting balls at their blocks. And there was this one kid who looked like he was like
0:31:0612. He really might have been 12. And he was like an ace. If there was an ESPN version
0:31:13of this game, he'd be on it. And it's crazy because the game just came out like a day
0:31:17before. They were actually like the Apple people who were staffing the table. They saw him playing
0:31:24and they ran to get one of the other staffers who I guess was the best among their staff.
0:31:31Like you got to see this kid. It was all very fun, but the kids definitely bring up the energy level.
0:31:38They do. And I think it's also a good sort of concession to the fact that if you're going to
0:31:45invite a chunk of the development audience to come and sort of get them excited about this stuff.
0:31:51Why not, students? I think it's a great idea.
0:31:52Pete: Yeah. So, it's good. They've regularized everything from the announcement date to the week
0:32:01that it is. Everybody expected June 3 to 7. There were telltale signs in the
0:32:06public filings for public spaces in San Jose where, I think it actually even said Apple,
0:32:13which I guess is a no-no, but it's the worst-kept secret in Apple, on Apple's annual calendar,
0:32:21just for various reasons. But yet—
0:32:23Jared: Which isn't, I don't know, I think it's not necessarily a bad thing.
0:32:28Ted, you know?
0:32:29Ted, I think that a large portion of the reason they keep it secret is that just, you know,
0:32:36things can change, right? And then everybody's like trying to read into the change, but—
0:32:40- Right.
0:32:41- Once you have it locked, announce it.
0:32:43- Right.
0:32:44They just, you know, there's some part of them,
0:32:47it's, you know, the old saying, I'm sure you know,
0:32:52if you've probably heard it from your dad,
0:32:54measure twice, cut once.
0:32:56- Right.
0:32:57- I think with a lot of these things,
0:32:58Apple is like measure 100 times, cut once.
0:33:00You know, like they're not going to, you know,
0:33:04they have X, Y, and Z that they definitely want,
0:33:06hope to announce in WWDC.
0:33:09And unless they are that, you know, a hundred percent convinced that there'll be at least
0:33:14an announceable shape, they're not going to announce WWDC. Like they might, you know,
0:33:18like if something happened and, you know, Federighi had to say, look, I hate to say
0:33:24it, but we're not going to be able to announce iOS 13 on June 3rd. We can't, you know, X,
0:33:29Y, just something's not right. Something will not be ready. They would, they would postpone
0:33:32WWDC, you know, there was that one year, like way back, like 2006 or 2005 or something where
0:33:38they did cancel or postpone it to like August or something, which was very strange. But
0:33:44those were, it's almost a different era at Apple. I also love the way they don't
0:33:53announce that there's going to be a keynote. That's a separate announcement, usually
0:33:57like a week before they're like, "Tim Cook will host a keynote to kick off WWDC."
0:34:04- Oh, were we supposed to believe
0:34:06that Tim might've been too busy,
0:34:07that he's got other things going on or?
0:34:09(laughs)
0:34:11- That one, and again, Apple PR,
0:34:14who you and I both have good relations with,
0:34:17but they don't like to explain themselves.
0:34:20And they're also ready for you to ask them
0:34:24to explain themselves, and they always have pat answers
0:34:27of, that are more than, they don't just say,
0:34:31ah, no comment, they've got like an answer,
0:34:33but it is effectively no comment.
0:34:34My guess is that they do that
0:34:39just for the pure publicity of getting a boost,
0:34:45getting a little pre-WWDC boost into the news cycle.
0:34:50- Sure.
0:34:51- But it always cracks me up
0:34:52when it's like at the top of tech meme
0:34:53that WWDC keynote over Monday, June 3rd.
0:34:57- Yeah, my reaction is how did they get,
0:35:00how did they get Tim Cook?
0:35:02- As somebody who runs a conference.
0:35:04That's my joking response.
0:35:07It's like, oh man, how'd they get Tim Cook?
0:35:09- Again.
0:35:10- His schedule's so busy.
0:35:11I can't even get him to come to our conference.
0:35:12- How'd they get him again?
0:35:15- Yeah, yeah, again.
0:35:16Every time, man.
0:35:17They're playing favorites.
0:35:18- All right, and imagine how weird it'd be
0:35:20if there were no keynote for WWDC.
0:35:22Everybody would be like, what the hell's going on?
0:35:26- Yeah.
0:35:27- This is nuts.
0:35:28If they just started with the technical state of the union
0:35:30it's showing up Objective-C and Swift code on slides two minutes.
0:35:36I would love it. I would love it. That'd be amazing. Like CNN is there going expecting the
0:35:43big corporate news and they're like, wait, what API what? Right. In theory, that would be, you know,
0:35:50the way to do a developer conference keynote, you know, the I always say that's the best way to
0:35:54think of the State of the Union, the State of the Union is like the technical keynote.
0:35:58That's right. You know, it would work for the audience. It would not work for the CNNs of the
0:36:05world. Yeah. I mean, and then, you know, the thing is, yes, there's a different sort of, like, the,
0:36:13I don't know, inside, inside baseball on some of this stuff, which you well know, but some audience
0:36:18members might not know is that they kind of consolidated press for a lot of their events.
0:36:23So a lot of these events, WWDC has always, to some degree, been that way, because it's the one,
0:36:27it's one thing, right? It only happens one place always does. But a lot of their events, they've
0:36:31taken a lot of international press and people that would have normally maybe had their own events in
0:36:36their own cities, hosted in an Apple store, or, or hosted, you know, kind of tell it, tell it,
0:36:42telegraphed or whatever. What do you call it? Oh, my gosh, you know, conference, teleconference,
0:36:48Dan, or whatever. They brought them all in person, which is great. You know, I think that's fine.
0:36:52And why shouldn't people around the world, Apple's a global enterprise, iPhone goes on sale in every country right away. Why shouldn't they have all these international press there. But it certainly has changed the mix a little bit and press and certainly of course, in this new era of Apple, the mix of press has changed significantly.
0:37:10But the audience makeup at those things is by nature always going to be these nerds.
0:37:16And for a lot of you will see the tweeting patterns.
0:37:19I mean, you and I follow a lot of these folks and we are these folks to some degree, you
0:37:23know, and so you'll see the tweeting patterns.
0:37:25You'll see people going like, "Oh, here's the corporate jumbo, you know, like all of
0:37:29this stuff.
0:37:30And oh, here we go.
0:37:31Retail update."
0:37:32Like people around the world are sort of like taking the numbers, even, you know, my staff,
0:37:38reporters. They're taking those numbers, comparing them against previous numbers, writing analysis of
0:37:42that, okay, here's the growth curve, and you know, etc, etc. Right. But the people in this audience
0:37:47are like, hey, give us the stuff, man. Like, you know, they start to get excited the moment they
0:37:51see something announced on stage that they see that they could maybe integrate, take advantage
0:37:55of, you know, or sort of build, you know, something with that's their, that's their thing. So it's an
0:38:01interesting audience. I always like it, I enjoy it. It's a different energy than, say, an iPhone
0:38:06um pure press event right sure exactly um yeah if they telegraphed the thing it would that would
0:38:14take them right back to like the 2400 baud modem era telegraphed it yes that would do it did it did
0:38:23yeah maybe you should have flown from asia over to galibornia because if you don't know morse code
0:38:30i'm sorry all of our remotes are via teletype this year so no i've told this story on the show
0:38:34before, but last year, it must have been the phone announcement because it was in the Steve
0:38:40Jobs Theater and they supplied the foreign, I don't know how many languages, but it's certainly
0:38:48at least Chinese, I think, maybe Japanese too. But a couple of the foreign language people got
0:38:55little in-ear pieces like you get it like the UN. And so they were sitting live in the Steve Jobs
0:39:04theater, but they were getting a live translation of what was being said on stage. And there was
0:39:09some sort of, I don't know if it was a malfunction or just it, they were poorly set up, but they were
0:39:14turned up too loud and it was too loud to be in their ears. And so they took them out and I don't
0:39:21blame them. I wouldn't put something too loud in my ears, but they took them out and it was loud
0:39:25enough that they could hear it just holding next to their ear. But it also meant that while you
0:39:29were sitting in the audience, you heard these this like, why do I hear like electronic Chinese
0:39:35language? What do who's doing this? And then, like you turn around, it'd be like, I thought it was
0:39:39over my left shoulder, and then all of a sudden, it's over my right shoulder. And I'm like,
0:39:42what the hell is going on? I really thought somebody was doing like a FaceTime call. And
0:39:45I thought it was very rude turned out. It wasn't. It wasn't rudeness at all. It was just like a
0:39:50technical thing. But it really it emphasized, right? Just how many of the members of the press
0:39:55really are from around the world at these events. And that did not used to be the case.
0:40:00Jared: That's true. And then one of the byproducts of people being around the world is that they are
0:40:05interpreting, many of them stream it or are, you know, kind of producing videos live. And so,
0:40:11they will translate for their audience live and they have no compunctions about translating it
0:40:15full volume right next to you. It's great. Like, I have no problem with them translating
0:40:23live because I think they're definitely they're providing the same service we are, you know,
0:40:28is just sometimes a little difficult to hear over them. It's a lot of fun having everybody there,
0:40:34though. I love the fact that it's international community and it's people that I wouldn't get to
0:40:39interact with from the press, even though we're in the same industry and same business and they're
0:40:43writing for a very similar audience, just in a different language. I love being able to, like,
0:40:47talk to them and interact with them and get their viewpoint. And they're always so enthused about
0:40:52being there and talking to people in the US. So it's a lot of fun. It's actually quite
0:40:58a different vibe than it used to be where you'd see the same people sort of in every
0:41:04event. So that aspect of it is really, really cool to me.
0:41:07Yeah. We were at—we probably talked about it the last time you were on the show—but
0:41:10you and I sat together for the Brooklyn event in October, and there were a lot of retail
0:41:16employees from around the country who'd been invited. And some part of Apple has always
0:41:23filled seats with Apple employees. If their watch team has a big announcement, some number
0:41:29of people from the Apple Watch team get to attend the keynote.
0:41:32So, famously last year in the September event when Jeff—why am I drawing a blank on his
0:41:43the C COO, Jeff Williams came on stage. He got a super enthusiastic amount of applause from one
0:41:52section of the theater. And that was the watch team. And you can't blame them. But it was a
0:41:55little weird when you were there. Like, why? Why are those people so nuts for Jeff Williams?
0:41:59Yeah. But like the
0:42:03Jared Ranere was about to announce his collab with Pitbull, his new single. Yeah.
0:42:07- Yeah.
0:42:07- The enthusiasm of those retail folks in the audience
0:42:11though was different and more palpable
0:42:13because none of them had ever seen a keynote live.
0:42:15They obviously got selected by being the good employees
0:42:20who maybe were there a long time,
0:42:22but were enthusiastic about Apple stuff.
0:42:24And they were, some of them were sitting right behind us
0:42:26and they were just, their enthusiasm was so palpable.
0:42:28And it's like you and I just sit there and sort of have a,
0:42:30we don't clap at press events thing.
0:42:33And there's people behind us going absolutely nuts,
0:42:35not like in a phony way. And I, you know, just made it a cool thing. I like WDC, you know,
0:42:43because it is unique. It's there is no other even, you know, the Brooklyn thing was in the Academy
0:42:48of Music, and it's a beautiful venue. And they've they've done this thing where they go around the,
0:42:52you know, country these days for certain of their special event. But nothing compares to having like
0:42:57five or 6000 people in a room. It's it and most, most of them just being attendees, you know,
0:43:03and every year now it's a ton of first time employees or attendees, not employees, attendees.
0:43:08The energy level is just not comparable to any of the other events.
0:43:14Did you go to you don't go to the annual shareholders meeting, do you?
0:43:20No, no, I've never been either. A I'm not a shareholder. I guess I could get a press pass.
0:43:26I don't know. But it's just you can get a press pass. But yeah, I'm not a shareholder.
0:43:31nothing. It doesn't seem worth a cross country trip. There's no because it's just not I don't
0:43:34write the finance angle much. And I whatever I do, I'd rather just read a summary of somebody who
0:43:40knows more about it than I do. But somebody who went, who's just a DF reader, but was really happy
0:43:47to go because I think this is the first year where they held the shareholders meeting in the Steve
0:43:52Jobs theater. And Oh, cool. Yeah. And so that it is a cool thing to see. I mean, it is a gorgeous
0:43:58theater and it is unlike anything I've ever seen. So I could see why somebody, you know,
0:44:05if it weren't cost prohibitive to make the trip and I were a shareholder and I'd never been to
0:44:10the Steve Jobs Theater, I'd be interested to do it just for that. But anyway, this reader
0:44:14sent me a picture from his audience. He was like, I've always heard that the screen is amazing here,
0:44:19but this is, you know, this looks like 640 by 480 projection. And it's hard to tell from an iPhone
0:44:24photo, but it really it certainly wasn't the screen that they use at the press events.
0:44:28It was a it was clearly projected, you know, there's sort of that look,
0:44:33share of a projected image, and projection, yeah, from projection. And the screens that they have
0:44:40now are like LEDs, or OLEDs, or I don't know, some kind of thing that the screen itself lights up.
0:44:45So I don't know what the reason is, but they, they cheaped out on that for shareholders,
0:44:52apparently unless this photo was tremendously misleading along with this DF reader's eyes.
0:44:57So anybody out there…
0:45:00They broke out the Mac classic projector.
0:45:02Well, I just wonder when he said that and he wrote. And I know that I've raved about the
0:45:09display technology in the Steve Jobs theater and the audio quality. And I just wonder how many
0:45:15other Daring Fireball readers went to this and thought, "What the hell is Gruber raving about?
0:45:20This screen looks like it cost 50 bucks.
0:45:25What is going on with this guy's eyes?
0:45:28Oh, man.
0:45:30That's funny.
0:45:31All right.
0:45:33WWDC.
0:45:34Nothing else to say, though, other than dates.
0:45:37The other Apple thing, which is breaking news, coming out tonight and will be out by the
0:45:42time this show is out, is Apple has a new TV commercial about privacy.
0:45:48And then you have a piece in TechCrunch with a preview of it.
0:45:51- Yeah, yeah, it's,
0:45:54you know, been marketing privacy stuff for a while now.
0:45:58I really don't think it's a, you know,
0:46:00any secret to anybody that they view this as
0:46:02a tool for marketing now,
0:46:05as well as an internal, you know,
0:46:08belief framework, whatever you wanna call it.
0:46:11- Yeah.
0:46:13- Certainly there's been, over the years,
0:46:15They've had a natural inclination towards privacy and protecting users' data and that
0:46:25sort of thing.
0:46:26But it was only a couple of years ago that they really started to try it out as a marketing
0:46:30tool and sort of positioning tool both in terms of personal speeches, things that Tim
0:46:35Cook said, interviews and then also of course marketing.
0:46:39Obviously there's big marketing efforts.
0:46:43Apple had a big billboard at MWC with the iPhone, you know,
0:46:47touting its privacy features and things like that.
0:46:49Right. It was like what it was. Cause, but cause that's in Vegas,
0:46:52it was like a, what, what happens?
0:46:54No, no. MWC is in Barcelona.
0:46:57Oh, well they had one in Vegas too. Oh, okay. Gotcha. It was like, what happens?
0:47:01I didn't see that one. On your iPhone stays on your iPhone, you know,
0:47:03playing off the, what happens in Vegas stays in Vegas.
0:47:06Catchphrase of this, of the city.
0:47:09Yeah. It makes sense. Um, but anyhow,
0:47:12They've been doing that for a while now. So this is a primetime TV commercial. It's going to be on their YouTube channel by the time you hear this.
0:47:18And then, of course, you can see it in my piece. But the actual commercial is airing on primetime TV. So, you know, evening, wherever you are in the US.
0:47:31That's going through March Madness. And then it's going to be airing, I think, worldwide after that in select regions.
0:47:39But it's a you know, it's a big buy. It's an ad buy for them that they would normally buy it is an iPhone commercial, right at its core. But it's just the point of it is basically instead of Hey, here's the new iPhone, you should buy it because of the camera. It's here's the new iPhone, you should buy it because privacy. That's the sort of
0:47:58sort of. And not to spoil it, but it's a commercial, so I don't mind spoiling it.
0:48:02But it basically it doesn't tell you upfront it's an iPhone. You don't see people using
0:48:06iPhones. You instead see people are in real life situations like using a public restroom
0:48:12or a woman putting on makeup in a car and the guy next door is staring at her and she
0:48:17just rolls the window up, you know, to get a little privacy. It's just a whole bunch
0:48:21of maybe three, four second vignettes of places in real life where you might want a little
0:48:28privacy in the public space and what people do to do it. Nothing's really hysterical,
0:48:35but they're all vaguely amusing. But you're like, "Where's this?" I think part of
0:48:38the gimmick of the ad is the first time you see it, where's it going? Who is this for?
0:48:43And then the closure is, "Hey, if you want privacy, you care about privacy in real life,
0:48:48you should care about it on your phone," or something like that.
0:48:50- Exactly, and it's one of those ads
0:48:52where the product really isn't in the commercial until--
0:48:56- No, nobody has an iPhone out in it
0:48:58throughout the entire commercial.
0:48:59It's all about real life scenarios,
0:49:00and that to me is the interesting angle.
0:49:02Like it is amusing, it's a couple of things
0:49:04that are kind of funny, but the underlying premise to me
0:49:09really emphasizes how we've collectively
0:49:13have gotten into this mess where our digital online lives
0:49:17such a privacy nightmare is that in real life, it's sort of intuitive, you know, like the one,
0:49:25you know, it's, you know, silliest form of privacy, but there's one where there's just a line of
0:49:30urinals in a public restroom and one's being used and a guy is sort of absentmindedly walking up,
0:49:34realizes he was going to take the one right next to the guy, and then just backs over and takes
0:49:39one, you know, two spots away. Right. You, you, you don't even think about things like that. You
0:49:45just intuitively think, "Oh, I'll take this one because it'll give me the most privacy
0:49:48while I do it." And it's not so obvious online. And then in fact, as we've seen more and more,
0:49:59a lot of it is insidious and you need to be like an expert level network wizard to even
0:50:08figure out what's being tracked. There's no way that a normal person would even
0:50:14realize how cookies are being used to get you the ad for the pair of boots you searched
0:50:22for on Amazon on a movie preview site a week later.
0:50:27It's not intuitive.
0:50:29Yeah, the systems experts that build these systems are building them.
0:50:36And you could, I think in many ways you could argue that their intent isn't necessarily
0:50:43to obfuscate the fact that your information is passing through several hands before it,
0:50:49you know, causes this effect or whatever the case may be. But the product, the result is
0:50:55that. The result is that it obfuscates that stuff. So, it makes it completely unaware
0:51:00to the normal person. And in many cases, not all, but many cases, they are intending to
0:51:06obfuscate it because it doesn't do them any favors to explain it to you clearly. Just
0:51:12sounds creepy, you know? You know, and to make a super obvious point, throughout history,
0:51:21until very recently, your privacy could be regulated using just your natural senses,
0:51:29you know, your sense of vision, your sense of hearing, you know, if you're in a restaurant,
0:51:35and you're telling somebody something private, you regulate the volume of your voice in a
0:51:39a very natural way without thinking about, you know, you just kind of know, like, "Hey,
0:51:46there's somebody at the table right next to me. I'm going to speak to this in a lower
0:51:50voice because I'm saying something I want to keep private." There is no way that your
0:51:56five senses really help you online in terms of keeping track of that and what's being
0:52:00stored and what's not and what's encrypted and what's not.
0:52:04you know, and I think,
0:52:07- Yeah, I mean, there's the closest thing that we have
0:52:09to that kind of ESP is a network monitor, you know,
0:52:13and most people don't know how to install those,
0:52:15don't even know what they are,
0:52:16and then even if you know what they are,
0:52:18it's still a pain to use one,
0:52:20and then you have to be able to interpret them,
0:52:22and once again, they do their best to obfuscate,
0:52:25you know, that traffic.
0:52:27- Right, it's, you know, so technically you are using
0:52:30your eyes to look at the output of the network monitor,
0:52:32but it's a cerebral action to understand it
0:52:35and to process it and see how to do it.
0:52:37Whereas knowing to lower your shades
0:52:41when you change your clothes or knowing to lower your voice
0:52:44when you're speaking a secret, it's not cerebral at all.
0:52:48It just comes naturally unless you're some sort of idiot.
0:52:51I think it's a good ad.
0:52:56I think it's a good ad and I think it's interesting
0:52:57that Apple's doing a push around it.
0:53:00And I know a lot of people out there aren't
0:53:02quote unquote sports ball fans,
0:53:04but like a big March Madness buy is pretty big
0:53:06and it's a good way to reach a very broad audience.
0:53:09It's certainly one of the most popular.
0:53:11- It's a good 18 to 24 demo audience,
0:53:15people with buying power, purchasing power.
0:53:17So there's a lot of savvy that goes into these buys,
0:53:20but that they would put, instead of the camera
0:53:23or some other feature, screen,
0:53:27that they would put privacy in that slot
0:53:29is an interesting, certainly an interesting display
0:53:32of how strongly they believe that that is
0:53:34a differentiating factor for them.
0:53:37You know, I don't know, I mean,
0:53:40we don't have to discuss the ins and outs of all of it here,
0:53:43but I absolutely think that people will,
0:53:46and to some valid degree, you know, point out that,
0:53:49well, I'm just gonna point it out,
0:53:53taking an ethical or moral high ground
0:53:55and making it a product feature is a,
0:53:59a dangerous maneuver.
0:54:01'Cause then you have to sort of, you have to back it up,
0:54:04you have to realize that if you're gonna pitch this
0:54:08as a product, that product has to work right, right?
0:54:10It has to be consistent.
0:54:12And they certainly, there's very many cases you can make
0:54:17for the efforts that Apple has made to sort of
0:54:20put the money where their mouth is
0:54:24and certainly make effort to make sure
0:54:29that their product decisions and sales decisions
0:54:34and relationship with the consumer aligns well
0:54:37with that message, right?
0:54:38So they definitely do.
0:54:40They're not just, it's not complete BS in other words.
0:54:43But there's a, this spot for instance,
0:54:47very, very closely associates the concepts
0:54:49of privacy and security.
0:54:51They're separate, but they're interrelated obviously, right?
0:54:54And they've had some issues recently with like the FaceTime bug that allowed that kind of like eavesdropping thing, obviously unintentional, patched, you know, they apologized, etc. But then you have things like, you know, Facebook kind of being able to ship this sort of spyware or malware app. malware may be a little strong, but definitely spyware app on the App Store.
0:55:18scattering of bad actors using the Enterprise Certificate Program to ship gambling apps,
0:55:24other things that Apple doesn't allow on the store to iPhone users at scale. We're not talking about
0:55:30just one example, but hundreds of thousands or more people. So they've had recent incidents that
0:55:36have pointed out that it's not perfect. Their stance is not perfect. It's not a completely
0:55:43pristine wall that they're offering. But I think, personally, I do feel that, you know, there's
0:55:52still a major difference between a company that has a situational loss of privacy, either via a bug
0:55:57or whatever, while having a system systemic dedication to privacy, and that most of the rest
0:56:03of the ecosystem that exists out there operates as like with this invasion of privacy as a service
0:56:09model. And there's a significant difference between those two things, between a company
0:56:14that's willing to back up their stance, and to make honest and genuine and significant efforts
0:56:20to keep user data private and to keep that data secure, of course, to then ensure the privacy.
0:56:25And then, you know, a lot of what the rest of the industry does. Basically, you know, stating
0:56:31privacy as your mission is still supportable, even if you have bugs, but attempting to ignore that
0:56:37that you host the data platforms that thrive on this stuff is a little bit of
0:56:42prestidigitation on their part. But I still think that they have a they have a leg to stand on
0:56:47basically in this in this regard. I mentioned on my last episode with Renee, I won't go into a long
0:56:53rant on it again, because it was a good rant on the last episode. But basically that to me,
0:56:57the elephant in the room on Apple's pro privacy slant is very specific. And it's their it's their
0:57:04deal with Google to make Google search the default search in Safari. And, you know, that's
0:57:10a very tightly held secret. Neither company is I don't think officially revealed it.
0:57:15But like Goldman Sachs has estimated it that last year, it was like $9 billion. And that
0:57:20for this 2019, it's going to be like 12 billion or something like that. It's a lot
0:57:26of money. And it's very hard to say, to me, there's there's a hole in the argument
0:57:32or if they say we value your privacy and Google doesn't.
0:57:37And I know they're not calling Google
0:57:38or anybody else specifically out by name in this ad,
0:57:40but they're certainly implying that every,
0:57:43there's sort of an everybody else that isn't.
0:57:46Yet we're going to take $10 billion
0:57:48to give them the default web search,
0:57:50which is one of the ways that they track you
0:57:54and what you're searching for and they keep you logged in.
0:57:56And when you log into any Google service
0:57:58and they encourage you to log in just for using web search,
0:58:02I'm not saying it makes them hypocrites, but it makes them at least partial hypocrites.
0:58:09And just the thing that occurred to me after that episode, before this episode, but only
0:58:14shortly enough before the episode that I searched for it for five minutes, was just to put $10
0:58:21billion a year, because let's just call it that for the sake of argument, if it was estimated
0:58:25at 9 billion last year and 12 billion this year, let's just say right now it's up to
0:58:2810 billion a year.
0:58:31does that compare to what these companies pay in corporate income tax? And Apple pays
0:58:38more than anybody in corporate income tax. They paid something like $15 billion. So Apple
0:58:43almost makes enough from Google to cover its corporate income tax. Google has had a very
0:58:49flux the last three years, they got hit hard by the repatriation. So they paid a bigger
0:58:54lump sum two years ago. But like in 2017, they only paid like $5 billion in US corporate
0:59:02taxes. So they pay more they pay by what I'm looking at over the last few years, they pay
0:59:08more on an annual basis to Apple to make Google search the default Safari search, then they
0:59:15paid to the US government and corporate income tax, like a lot more, maybe arguably around
0:59:22double. So that just puts it in scale just how much and the other thing I looked up is
0:59:27Google last year, they had a record breaking year for revenue, they had 130 some billion
0:59:32in revenue, and paid Apple roughly 10% of their revenue. Or at least they're paying
0:59:39them this year, roughly 10% of last year's revenue to make to keep Google search the
0:59:44default search in Safari, which puts it in scale and I think tells you just how unbelievably
0:59:52profitable the iOS using audience is to Google in terms of how they make money from web ads.
1:00:01**Matt Stauffer:** That's right. Yeah, it's insanely valuable
1:00:05to them. I mean, it's like propping the door to your house open with a diamond because
1:00:11it's that important that you get air. You know what I mean? It's nothing to that,
1:00:14diamond is nothing to them compared to the diamond mine that they have. I mean, I think there's a
1:00:19absolute argument that when it comes to Apple adjudicating what should be considered
1:00:26a societal norm when it comes to the use of personal data on smartphones, if it's going
1:00:32to be the absolute arbiter of what flies on the world's arguably most profitable application
1:00:38Marketplace it might as well use that power to get a little bit more feisty because that make their living on our data, you know
1:00:45So, you know, I don't know I think there's absolutely an argument for that
1:00:50Hey while we're on this there was a story that broke and follow it closely because I just had a lot of other stuff to
1:00:56Read but there was a story that broke that Facebook is under an actual criminal
1:01:00investigation
1:01:02did you see anything about this for privacy violations and that the if this was like in the Eastern District in New York and
1:01:08and that two US cell phone manufacturers were like listed as like witnesses or something like that.
1:01:16And I had a couple people say, "Do you think this is Apple? Do you think this is about like back
1:01:22when Facebook was built into iOS?" And I was like, "I don't think it's Apple because it seems to me
1:01:28like this is something different. This is like some kind of co-marketing deal where Facebook
1:01:32was paying companies to allow them to collect data that was never prompted the user, even in
1:01:42an obfuscated way to get their permission. It was like they made a deal with company X so that
1:01:48Facebook was able to track certain things that a user used on company X's phones. But this thing
1:01:55that was announced about it doesn't say who the companies are. So I don't know. And there aren't
1:02:00that many US companies that make cell phones? I mean, there's Motorola. I'm trying to think
1:02:05who else? I don't know. I feel like it's a story we have to keep our eyes on. We don't really know
1:02:10much about it yet. Yeah, I don't know much about it either. I know. I've got people tracking it,
1:02:15but I haven't personally been tracking it. So I don't know. I did know that it happened,
1:02:19but that's about it. Yeah. We'll file it away for future episodes. All right. Let's,
1:02:24well, I guess we could keep going with the Boeing thing. Do you want to talk about the
1:02:29the Boeing thing. Are you an airplane nerd? I am a little bit of an aviation.
1:02:33All right, let's go with the Boeing thing and then we'll take a break. You know, it's
1:02:36tragedy. So it's hard. You know, on the one hand, I wanted to say this, you know, to anybody
1:02:40if you know, happened in Ethiopia, the latest crash, so it may not be anybody listening
1:02:44and knows anybody, but it's a tragedy. And I feel a little guilty nerding out on this.
1:02:49Like it's a bug, you know, like the FaceTime bug that you mentioned, bad bug, really bad
1:02:55bug. Nobody died. You know, we're talking about a thing here that left a couple hundred
1:02:58people dead. Let's just acknowledge that that's a tragedy. But as nerds, I find the story,
1:03:05the more I read about the story of this, the more fascinating it is as a tragedy of human
1:03:11error. When I first saw it, when I first saw the story, I saw that another plane had crashed.
1:03:20The first one was, where was the first one? Indonesia or something? I forget. But you
1:03:25a second foreign somewhere else around the world is Boeing 737 Max 8, which is their latest model
1:03:31for a single aisle passenger plane, meaning it's small enough. Mostly I'm guessing almost everybody
1:03:38listening to this has been on a 737 or an Airbus 320 or 321. Just a typical single aisle plane,
1:03:46three seats on the side and coach two seats on each side and first class or business.
1:03:51Second one had gone down and because it was the second time since October a lot of places around the world
1:03:58Just sort of hit the panic button and said, okay, let's ground these planes
1:04:01And the FAA in the US didn't and Canada didn't
1:04:05And the FAA is kind of considered the gold standard for this sort of thing around the world
1:04:13At least in my opinion there I was talking to Ben Thompson is also an aviation earner and he agreed
1:04:18And so it's a little weird that everybody else didn't follow the FAA lead, but instead
1:04:23they grounded them while the FAA was still saying, we, we, you know, we think this is
1:04:27okay.
1:04:28And Boeing was still saying, we think this plane's okay.
1:04:34But as more and more,
1:04:35Yeah, and the FAA has always been aggressive.
1:04:38It falls across all kinds of regulatory things.
1:04:41I mean, anytime you ask yourself a question about, you know, why does some nonsensical
1:04:45thing happen with air travel or planes or grounding or delays. It's usually, you know,
1:04:50because the FAA is being overly cautious, right? They're typically known for being relatively
1:04:54conservative, right? And the reason, you know, and, and the results show it air travel historically
1:05:01has been a very safe way to travel. Famously, everybody knows that statistically to go from
1:05:06point a to point B in a motor vehicle on the road, no matter what type of motor vehicle,
1:05:12have a way higher chance of being injured or killed way higher than you do in air travel.
1:05:16It's really the safest way to go from point A to point B statistically. But psychologically,
1:05:22if for obvious reasons, you know, putting yourself into an aluminum tube, 30,000 feet
1:05:28in the air is not exactly something we're hooked up to accept psychologically by evolution.
1:05:34You know, if you're up in the air, more than a few about to die, you're you're in big trouble,
1:05:41alone 30,000 feet. So psychologically, and you know, I, so I'm not making fun of anybody
1:05:46who has flight anxiety. I tend not to. But I totally understand it. It is easily one
1:05:53of the most understandable phobias from even a rational sense just because it just seems
1:05:58crazy. But the long story short of this is that Boeing really put themselves as, as I
1:06:08I understand it, Boeing put themselves in a bad hole because they were developing the
1:06:11787, which was a bigger plane, um, and decided to develop it in a different way for Boeing,
1:06:19where they outsourced a lot of it as opposed to doing it in house and thinking that would
1:06:25save money. And it was, it didn't, it led to all sorts of delays and delays cost them
1:06:32money, tons of money. So it ended up costing them a lot more and the 787 was very late.
1:06:38And because of that, they sort of got like the moneymaker is the 737. And I think most of us
1:06:47who fly frequently know that most of you're way more likely to end up on a 737 or A320
1:06:53size plane than you are a bigger bird 747. - Yeah, there's a fuel efficiency and route length.
1:07:00Yeah, and just how many passengers they expect on the plane. They're not going to fly an
1:07:03empty plane. They're only going to use those big ones when they can fill the seats. And
1:07:08who knows, maybe on a lot of them, it'd be easier to fly two smaller planes than one
1:07:12bigger plane to get everybody from city A to city B. But the 737 has long class has
1:07:19long been Boeing's big moneymaker. And but they sort of let it languish while they were
1:07:25wasting all this money on the 787 and in the meantime their arch rival Airbus has come
1:07:31out with a new 320, the 320 Neo I believe it's called, which has bigger engines. The
1:07:38bigger engines make it more fuel efficient. I believe it, I believe the exact number is
1:07:4314%. So if you replace like a regular, you know, the previous 320 with the new 320, you
1:07:47save 14% on each trip on fuel, which is super significant, you can imagine.
1:07:55And in the meantime, Boeing didn't really have anything and really was originally planning
1:08:00to do a ground up. We're going to make an all new airplane to replace our 737. Who knows,
1:08:05they probably would have come up with a new number for them. But their single engine or
1:08:09single aisle, which is something I hadn't really thought of before, but it's a great
1:08:12way to describe this class of plane, the single aisle passenger plane, they they decided we're
1:08:18too late, you know, like we don't have enough time to do this Airbus is killing you know,
1:08:23taking our business and this is our most profitable thing. And so they're like, well, what can
1:08:26we do with the 737 to, um, to get a new 37, 737 into this with the fuel efficiency, uh,
1:08:38that led them to put bigger engines on a 737, which in turn changed the aerodynamics of
1:08:42a plane that wasn't originally designed for it and notoriously as sort of low wings and
1:08:48doesn't really have a lot of room. And the other x factor is that to keep costs down.
1:08:57This is something I had no idea about that pilot certification is such that you can come
1:09:00out with like a new 320 that like the 320 neo if a pilot is already certified on the
1:09:05previous 320 the 320 neo is sufficiently similar that they count as certified on the neo. And
1:09:13If it's new, too new and too different, and the pilots all have to be recertified, that's
1:09:18a big cost for the airline because they've got to spend all this money to get all of
1:09:22these pilots certified on a new plane.
1:09:24And so this and this is where it all went bad for Boeing.
1:09:27I think they they put this software MCA as some kind of automatic control system in that
1:09:36way, modified the, you know, the flight pattern of the plane automatically to somehow make
1:09:41it fly more similarly to previous 3737s? And can you take it from here?
1:09:48Yeah, I mean, the automated software was a it absolutely was a a pilot assist feature. Right?
1:10:10Right. And the pilot assist feature was a, I think it was mostly like an altitude related feature.
1:10:19Yeah, I did read that.
1:10:20So, yeah.
1:10:22And an angle of attack.
1:10:23Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah. And you're basically what you have in a plane is like, there's a,
1:10:29there's the most efficient way to fly it. And then there's like the safest way to fly it. And usually,
1:10:34you know, you're somewhere in between because you want to, you don't make your flight efficient,
1:10:37but you want to make it, you know, you also want it to, you know, come in safely. So there was,
1:10:45like, the, they analyzed the flight pattern of the crashed jet, and they looked at it at takeoff,
1:10:52and they looked at the Lion Air crash. And they saw that they basically showed similar fluctuations
1:10:59in height, like vertical, what they call them oscillation or fluctuations in height. And they
1:11:04basically were able to, once they looked at the wreckage and analyzed it, they were able to do
1:11:11that, take that and satellite tracking and understand that they needed to investigate
1:11:15further and that it was very likely this software package that was, you know, the issue and the
1:11:21pilots reported on the Ethiopian Airlines flight reported flight control problems to the aircraft
1:11:28controller before they came down. But the computerized system that they put in place was a
1:11:34it was supposed to basically assist them
1:11:37in keeping the proper altitude to get the proper lift,
1:11:40but what happened is after,
1:11:42if it decided that it was not working right,
1:11:46it would just cut out,
1:11:50and then they couldn't take proper control over it.
1:11:53- Yeah.
1:11:54I got an email from somebody who obviously knows
1:11:56exactly what he's talking about.
1:11:57He wrote his PhD dissertation on the complexity
1:12:00of commercial airline cockpits.
1:12:04And it was a super, super interesting email.
1:12:06But like one of the things he said is,
1:12:10as you might expect, this is probably no surprise to you,
1:12:12but like a sensor on an airplane,
1:12:14a faulty sensor, a sensor that has, you know,
1:12:18like it needs a complete fleet wide recall.
1:12:21The difference might be 99.99% accurate versus,
1:12:26or success rate versus 99.999% accurate.
1:12:31Like this is, it's not like, you know,
1:12:33it's like a one in 10,000 thing,
1:12:34one in 10,000 is unacceptable in the airline industry. And one of the problems with this
1:12:38MCAS system is that it was relying entirely on one sensor to detect the thing that it was trying to
1:12:45detect and that one sensor people are suspecting may have a higher than acceptable prosperity to
1:12:52give an erroneous result. Yeah, basically the MCAS given the very, very tiny amount of like
1:13:02Difference that it saw that was like a 20 degree difference an angle of attack
1:13:06Between the left and right sides of the plane and so it basically kept taking the yoke out of the pilots hands
1:13:13Yeah
1:13:13And pushing it forward like pushing the nose down and then they basically had to keep yanking the the yoke back up forcing it
1:13:20Yeah to come back up
1:13:22So the other thing that this this guy's email said and I haven't read this anywhere else and he said this is speculation
1:13:26And so this could you know, this could be wrong and who knows so, you know, this is a podcast so it's alright
1:13:31But on on most other commercial airliners one of the one of the ways to just to to disable all
1:13:39Autopilot features is to just pull back hard on the yoke you pull back hard enough on the yoke and all autopilot
1:13:46Oh, you don't yeah, you don't want me to take in control anything autopilot related turns off, you know
1:13:51And then there's switches and he thinks that with this MCS thing. It's only a switch
1:13:57Got it. And so yeah that oscillation specifically cover controls trim
1:14:03I believe and is basically it if they'd have known I don't think they even knew that's what the
1:14:10Conclusion is so far that they didn't even know the MCS was causing the problem, right?
1:14:15So they didn't know to switch it off right so they could have but yes
1:14:19I believe you're right
1:14:20Like it wasn't this thing where it was kind of connected to the autopilot features where they grab the yoke and yank it and they expect
1:14:27Okay, I'm back in control of this thing. And in fact, the MCS was still at work, still with its faulty data about about angle of attack, and it's pushing the nose of the plane down. Yeah. And they didn't know to switch it off. If they just switched it off, they could have gained control back. Right. But since they didn't know that it was the issue, they couldn't actually do it. Right. And those oscillations you're referring to on both flights were exactly like 15 seconds apart each time. So they would like take control.
1:14:56and be like, okay, we got it. And then 15 seconds later, it would dive again. And they were like,
1:15:00you know, I'm sure they were panicking. I'm sure. Well, probably not panicking because pilots are,
1:15:04you know, trained, you know, their pilots, because they don't, but they were probably
1:15:07in aviation called being behind the plane. And that's when you don't understand why a
1:15:11plane is doing something. And that's what I think the state that they entered into was,
1:15:15it's you end up in this scenario where you are trying to make corrections for something,
1:15:20but you don't know the cause of it. Right. But having these, you know, you'd, you'd,
1:15:23you'd get the plane going back up, and then 15 seconds later, the plane would decide itself to
1:15:29point the nose down. And then 15 seconds later, the same thing happens. It does look exactly like
1:15:34a software problem. Like 15 seconds is when it, you know, the scent, you know, the thing goes,
1:15:38let's take a reading up reading still bad go down. Whereas like they said, like an often form of
1:15:44oscillation in general, of course, is turbulence, but turbulence doesn't tend to come at exact 15
1:15:49second intervals. It might be seven seconds, then 20 seconds, then 17 seconds because it's
1:15:57a natural phenomenon, not something written in software. I thought the yoke argument, and again,
1:16:02speculation from somebody, I didn't read that in a confirmed thing, but I do think as a user
1:16:08interface nerd, I think that's super interesting because what is the best user interface for a
1:16:13Pilot to take control of the airplane from autopilot that that they suspect is gone awry pull back on the yoke, right?
1:16:21Mm-hmm pull back on the yoke disconnects it, you know
1:16:25I mean isn't that how I don't really use cruise control a lot on cars
1:16:31But isn't isn't like when you hit the brake cruise control goes off. Usually it's a break tap
1:16:35Yeah, and and I don't remember and I mean I've had cars to cruise control for years and I think feel I should know this
1:16:42But I think some cars most cars perhaps with cruise control if you hit the gas it does not disengage it
1:16:49It allows you to speed up right and it will fall back to this last setting, right? Yeah
1:16:53Yeah
1:16:53That's how my cruise control works is gas you can use to go a little faster than you had it set and then it just drops
1:16:58You're right back to where you had it set which for me is usually still extremely fast, you know
1:17:0291 92 miles an hour
1:17:05But brake is like okay turn off the cruise control
1:17:08which is obvious sense and you don't want somebody stabbing at the little cruise control button on the
1:17:13Steering wheel to disable it, you know, and again, I'm not trying to you know, it's an oversimplification to compare driving a
1:17:22Honda with
1:17:24Flying a 737 max but still there's that moment of I got a you know, oh
1:17:29What's your instinct and as a driver you hit the brake and as a pilot you pull back on the yoke?
1:17:33Especially if the problem is the nose going down
1:17:37so
1:17:39it's sort of a user interface problem sort of a corporate planning problem sort of a a
1:17:44Cheapskate bureaucracy problem in terms of this, you know
1:17:51The whole reason for this software patch in the first place was to avoid having to retrain
1:17:55Pilots on this plane that they probably should have had to now, you know, not again
1:18:01Maybe there's you know, there's nothing fundamental any fundamentally wrong with these planes
1:18:05but if the pilots had been retrained on them as though they were the
1:18:08new planes they should have been treated as
1:18:11It every every pilot would have known what to do how to identify it and what to do
1:18:16Yeah
1:18:19yeah, I mean it's
1:18:21the software assistance is
1:18:24One of those things that you know, I mean obviously has existed and will existed
1:18:32or will exist for forever, you know with with aviation, but it is a
1:18:37There's a reason that we still have human pilots, you know, and there's a reason that almost every aviation disaster that's averted
1:18:46can be linked almost directly to pilot experience and that you know,
1:18:51That's that's just this right in the pocket of this thing, you know that happened here
1:18:56One of the things I read is that Boeing has a reputation in the world of aviation as being a very
1:19:01Pilot forward company that they've always thought the pilot should be at the center of this, you know that they're not trying to
1:19:07Obviate pilots, they're they're trying to help them but that they've you know famous, you know
1:19:13Maybe more than other companies have designed around
1:19:15We just wanted we're gonna assume that there's an expert pilot at the at the helm at all times
1:19:20Mm-hmm. Yeah, and how do we augment their ability to keep the the plane safe and you know
1:19:26know, fly the plane rather than how do we supplant them as a decision maker, which is,
1:19:32I think, you know, it's definitely an argument for and against in the aviation industry because
1:19:36they feel that, you know, pilots get tired and they're human and they're fallible and
1:19:40all of this stuff. But yeah, it's the back and forth over that.
1:19:44Pete: Right. And then the other thing that looks really damning, and I know it's only
1:19:47five reports, but the Dallas Morning News found five reports that pilots had filed over
1:19:54last few months ever since the Lion Air crash in October, flying 737 Max 8 planes in the United
1:20:03States. And all seemingly with the in the same scenario shortly after takeoff, a bit of a loss,
1:20:11you know, the nose goes down. And you know, these guys all figured out it's the luckily, I guess,
1:20:17or, you know, all figured out it was this MCS system disabled it took control of the
1:20:22plane, everything was right afterwards. But one of the complaints from the pilot called it like,
1:20:28use the actual word unconscionable that, you know, that the manual that they had for the
1:20:32plane doesn't really emphasize this enough, you know, that they sort of had to figure it out on
1:20:36the fly. Which again, speaks to this whole, not that there's anything wrong with the plane,
1:20:44but that there's something wrong with trying to say this, if you're good on any previous 37,
1:20:49you're good on this new one. And it really wasn't, you know, and that's purely for financial reasons,
1:20:53which is a really bad look when it when the stakes are so high. Right. The other conclusion to draw
1:21:02from this, I have to say, you know, again, it's a bit of speculation, but it's a bad look at the
1:21:07moment, at least is that like you said, the FAA and my understanding is the FAA has a reputation
1:21:12of being aggressive on calling for like grounding of a plane or, you know, calling, you know,
1:21:19doing something, even if it means greatly inconveniencing air travelers, you know, in
1:21:24the name of safety and that the FAA was last to do it. And Boeing happens to be the US
1:21:32manufacturer sort of is a bad look at the moment. And I wouldn't be surprised if that
1:21:36turns into some aspect of the scandal. You know, that if this had been an Airbus plane
1:21:43with the same problem in those two countries, maybe they would have pulled the trigger on
1:21:47grounding them sooner.
1:21:48Jared: Mm hmm. Yeah, that's so true. And you know, it really sucks, you know, that
1:21:56you have to think this way. This didn't stay in age, but it really does. I mean, you
1:22:00know, some people who are, and I'm not by any means a Washington insider or nor do I
1:22:06follow this stuff. But in some people who hear this may be like, yeah, duh, you know, this is
1:22:11the way the world works. But, you know, the moment like Trump tweeted something about, you know,
1:22:17hey, this is, you know, we're gonna ground these things or whatever, they should be grounded, etc.
1:22:21And then the FAA quickly announced that they were doing it. I don't know which came first or
1:22:26whatever. But the first thing I did was I thought to myself, let me Google who the senators are in
1:22:33in Illinois where Boeing is headquartered. And they're both Democratic.
1:22:37Dave: No, you mean--
1:22:38Chris: Just Democratic Senator.
1:22:39Dave; Seattle, is it? I thought they were a Seattle, Washington company.
1:22:41Chris; Oh, I think Boeing Corporation is in Chicago, but I could be wrong. Anyhow, but
1:22:47you know, it doesn't really matter even if that was the case in this case. But it's
1:22:51the political and money motivations, you know, behind, "Yeah, keep these Boeings in the
1:22:56air. You know, that's bad press. We can't have them having that. We'll fix it quietly."
1:22:59or I'm gonna say something about it
1:23:02because it'll hurt the other guy.
1:23:04It doesn't matter.
1:23:04It doesn't matter if that was the case here.
1:23:06It always is the case.
1:23:07- Well, in addition to Boeing,
1:23:10the other two big corporations that are most direct,
1:23:13US corporations most directly involved
1:23:15are Southwest and American Airlines
1:23:17'cause they're the two that have purchased the most of them
1:23:20or have the most in their active fleet.
1:23:22So like for Southwest, you'd wanna look at Texas
1:23:24where you've got, I know offhand,
1:23:26you've got Cornrin and Ted Cruz
1:23:28who are Republican senators.
1:23:29Although Cruz, I saw that Cruz who heads like a Senate committee on aviation was calling
1:23:35for them to be grounded before the FAA actually said it.
1:23:38So I'll just point that out that from what I've seen about that, I don't think there
1:23:44was an angle there that like Ted Cruz was pushing for them to stay in the air because
1:23:48of Southwest Airlines being headquartered in Texas.
1:23:51I think the opposite.
1:23:52I think Ted Cruz was a little bit ahead of the curve on, you know, let's put these things
1:23:56on the ground.
1:23:57Anyway, I don't think Boeing has handled this well in my opinion because Boeing also was
1:24:01you know
1:24:04defending it and even to this point and and even you know, they've they're grounded worldwide, but they
1:24:10didn't get out ahead of this and I all I can think of to compare it to is the
1:24:15The Tylenol scandal which I don't have in front of me, but do you remember you were probably yeah kid
1:24:20Oh, yeah, I was but I do remember it probably from discussion later on not at the moment
1:24:26So I again didn't do the research,
1:24:30but so I'll speak off the top of my head
1:24:31and probably get something wrong.
1:24:32But at some point in the 80s,
1:24:34at some point in the 80s,
1:24:36some psychopath working in a factory,
1:24:39it put like cyanide in a bunch of Tylenol packaging
1:24:42and people, I think people died.
1:24:44Not too many, but you know,
1:24:47but it somehow it was quickly determined
1:24:51that these people had all taken Tylenol
1:24:54and Tylenol figured out where these packages had come from,
1:24:57from the serial numbers on the packaging,
1:24:59and they knew very quickly,
1:25:02they could have said, just take all cereal,
1:25:04everything that came out of this,
1:25:06like let's say plant, take them all off the shelves.
1:25:09But instead what they did, and very quickly,
1:25:12is like the CEO of Tylenol said,
1:25:14"Take anything with the word Tylenol on it,
1:25:17"of any product from any place,
1:25:18"take it all off the shelves and destroy it all.
1:25:20"Just let's get rid of it all
1:25:22to be as safe as possible, even knowing that that was actually well above and beyond what they
1:25:29needed. They knew where this guy worked, they figured it out, they could have just taken off
1:25:33the products that might have been from the place where he worked. But by doing that, it like kept
1:25:41the Tylenol brand from being tarnished in the least. Like, like, worldwide people were like,
1:25:47yeah, I can still, you know, even though people had just been poisoned by Tylenol, they bought
1:25:51the fact that like, you know, with within days of this thing even happening, the CEO is saying,
1:25:56let's just destroy every every bit of it worldwide. And, you know, you know, and then they
1:26:01came up with tamper proof packaging, etc, etc. You know, back when I was a kid, you just open a pack
1:26:06of pills from the store and you didn't have to poke holes in anything. It was right. But famously
1:26:14considered one of the sages. public relations moves an executive has ever made, you know,
1:26:22and who knows how many untold millions, hundreds of millions who how much money and Tylenol
1:26:28product was destroyed. You know, that didn't need to be, but it was all in the name of
1:26:33let's not forget that whatever many millions or billions of dollars of Tylenol is out there.
1:26:39I think they even told people to throw the Tylenol out in their home, you know,
1:26:42if you've got any talent on your home, throw it out. And, you know, it also I think there's a lot
1:26:51of people who would think, well, that's, that's the risky PR move, right? The risky PR move is to
1:26:56be there saying, throw it all out, you know, sure. But in hindsight, it's considered, you know,
1:27:03an active, you know, to borrow a Phil Schiller term courage, you know, and I think everybody
1:27:08would agree it was and everybody agrees in hindsight, it was the right way to do it.
1:27:12I can't help but think that maybe Boeing should have been way ahead of the curve, like after this
1:27:18Ethiopia, this second crash, and saying, Hey, we don't think there's anything wrong with these
1:27:23planes, but we would like everybody around the world to ground them while we do conduct a thorough
1:27:28investigation. I can't help but think that that was a better way for Boeing to play this,
1:27:34especially from everything I've read in the last like 48 hours.
1:27:40Yeah, I mean it just seems so obvious, you know, that you would just go ground them immediately
1:27:47until we figure it out, you know, and we'll figure out, we'll help the airlines figure out how to get
1:27:53you where you need to go, but we can't use these planes. It's just, you know, after even the first
1:27:58crash, because it's, it was obvious with the first crash that there was some sort of plane fall and
1:28:03it's like, I don't know, systemic, you know? And that's, it just boggles, it boggles.
1:28:11Money really screws with people. It really does.
1:28:16Yeah, there's like an old saying, "Once is chance, twice is coincidence, third time is a pattern."
1:28:22And I kind of feel with something like air travel, once you get to twice,
1:28:27You lower that by at least once. I say, yeah, you lower it by at least one, I think.
1:28:33I think you say two is a pattern and write an act from there.
1:28:37And I have to say that's as contrary to my initial read
1:28:39over the weekend when I wasn't really paying attention.
1:28:42I kind of feel like I, as a non-expert, total non-expert
1:28:47and not even really an aviation nerd,
1:28:49although I'm suddenly turning into one with this.
1:28:52There was a story I linked to,
1:28:55his name is John Ostrower.
1:29:02he writes, he's a longtime aviation industry reporter, and he writes his own website now
1:29:06called The Air Current. And he had a great piece, I linked to it from during Fireball yesterday,
1:29:10I learned a lot from it. Really, a lot of what I said before was just restating what I learned
1:29:15from him. But he had a comment, you know, he's well sourced. So he, you know, it's anonymous
1:29:20sources. But somebody in the aviation industry said that if these two crashes had happened,
1:29:25one in October and one in March, but the airlines had been Southwest and American, they they would
1:29:31would have grounded these planes hours after the second one. It was the fact that there
1:29:36was sort of a bias within the FAA that, "Well, who knows how good Ethiopian Airlines is?"
1:29:42Like they don't maintain their planes or their pilots are subpar.
1:29:46And I hate to say that my sort of casual read from the news over the weekend might have
1:29:51been along the same lines. Like I might have just as a knee-jerk pundit screaming at the
1:29:57government what to do. I might have had a different take too.
1:30:02Let's take a break, and I will thank our next sponsor, who is Eero. Look, Eero makes
1:30:13Wi-Fi for humans. Basic premise behind Eero Wi-Fi systems is called a mesh network. You
1:30:20get multiple devices. Basic starting pack has three for Eero. You put them around your
1:30:25home, they talk to each other, and then they envelop your whole house, your whole office,
1:30:30whatever you've got with one network based on these three things that talk to each other.
1:30:34And it's just common sense, really, you don't have to be a Wi Fi engineer to really understand
1:30:40the basic idea that having one router in one spot to cover your whole home, your whole office,
1:30:48wherever you're trying to do it, it's going to have trouble getting through all the walls
1:30:52and everything, and then spreading a couple out that all can talk to each other and create
1:30:57one seamless network is an easier way to do it.
1:31:02But in addition to the fact that it's just a better way to envelop your whole home with
1:31:07one Wi-Fi network, it's really, really easy to set up and administer.
1:31:17do the whole thing with an app on your phone or on your iPad, couldn't be easier to set up.
1:31:23It's super easy to do things like add a new one. You just go in there and say add one. And it says,
1:31:30what do you want to name it? Like you can name it like, you know, third floor hallway, whatever
1:31:34you want to do. Add one, that sort of thing. You can monitor all the devices that are on the
1:31:42network you can easily set up a guest network which I'm a fan of I don't really like having
1:31:48people come to my house and get on my main network. I love having a guest network super
1:31:53easy to set it up super easy to monitor it and they've also got Euro plus. Euro plus is a service
1:32:03that you pay extra for and it lets you do all sorts of extra stuff lets you set up your own
1:32:11way to block malicious and unwanted content across the network. You can filter for adult content for
1:32:17stuff like monitoring your kids or something like that. It does ad blocking, optionally content
1:32:24blocking. It can automatically tag sites that can contain all sorts of stuff like violent, illegal,
1:32:30adult content. So you can choose what the people on your network can see, don't see. They even have
1:32:38features when you sign up for it. You even get stuff like VPN protection from encrypt.me,
1:32:45password management from the great 1Password, and even antivirus software from Malwarebytes
1:32:50if you want it. It's a great setup. Really, the single router model is just going the
1:32:56right way, the dodo bird. So if you're looking to upgrade your home network to something
1:33:01with a mesh network. Eero has a great starter kit. And also, I will add this, I've used
1:33:09it. They have incredible customer support. And it's something that they've really invested
1:33:14deeply in. You can call them up and just get a hold of a Wi-Fi expert within 30 seconds.
1:33:19You get a real human being right here in the United States. And if you have any kind of
1:33:23problem during setup, you can do it. I forget the problem I had like a year ago, something
1:33:28when I moved, but I called them up. They walked me through it. Couldn't have been easier.
1:33:33Very, very simple. So we I'm talking to right now, if you hear this, I'm talking to Matthew
1:33:39over an Eero network really has changed the Wi Fi in my house for the better tremendously.
1:33:44I've been using them for years. Here's the deal. Never think about Wi Fi again, get 100
1:33:51bucks off the Eero base unit and two beacons package. That's the base unit. That's the
1:33:57little thing of puck size thing about the size of a Apple TV and the beacons are little
1:34:02wall units that even have like little nightlights. You just plug them right into a wall socket
1:34:08and one year of Euro plus. So save a hundred bucks on that. You get the base unit, two
1:34:13beacons and a year of Euro plus service. Just go to ero.com/the talk show, ero.com/the talk
1:34:23show and at checkout just enter that code the talk show my thanks to ero for their continuing
1:34:31support of the talk show I don't want to spend too much time on it because I want to nerd
1:34:38out on Disney but I'm sure you read the Elizabeth Warren let's break up these tech companies
1:34:43thing. Yeah. And her initial, it was a post on medium and it was, uh, of course, uh, focused
1:34:54on Amazon, Facebook and Google. Uh, and then, uh, I think she was at South by Southwest.
1:35:00I think that the, the medium post was timed for that. And, uh, the verge got an interview
1:35:07with her and asked the obvious question that there's one company that's obviously missing
1:35:11from that. And she said, Apple, and they're like, What do you want to break Apple up to?
1:35:15And she said, Oh, yeah. I have a lot of thoughts on this. And I haven't been able to express
1:35:22it. Number one, a lot of what she's saying isn't really breaking these companies up.
1:35:26I get it, you know, but like 18, the old AT&T, the old mob bell thing that was breaking up
1:35:33a monopoly that was taking a nationwide company and breaking it up to a bunch of regional,
1:35:38much smaller companies. You know what she's proposing in each of these cases isn't really
1:35:44breaking up with possibly the exception of Facebook which I guess would kind of qualify
1:35:49as a breakup because I think what you know the gist of her argument with Facebook is
1:35:52that they shouldn't be allowed to own Instagram and WhatsApp too. And so I guess in the work
1:35:58component parts they could become component parts again it sort of makes sense. Yeah it
1:36:02It also seems like the less, you know, it, yeah, it's breaking up Facebook, the corporation,
1:36:08but not breaking up Facebook, the thing that we think of as Facebook. And honestly, probably
1:36:15not a bad idea. Like of all of the parts, like I, my thoughts on her advice for these
1:36:21companies range from, hmm, this Facebook thing maybe ought to be pursued. And, you know,
1:36:31The Instagram thing, when that was approved,
1:36:34I forget what year it was.
1:36:35I know they bought them for the, at this point,
1:36:37famously good value of $1 billion.
1:36:40I don't know that--
1:36:42- It's also known as one Instagram for quite a while.
1:36:45- What?
1:36:46- 'Cause that's like, that we use that,
1:36:48oh, how many Instagrams, two Instagrams?
1:36:51That's what they bought it for.
1:36:52- When they bought WhatsApp for 20 Instagrams,
1:36:56I feel like we as a country at that point
1:36:59should have known better and that one should not have been approved.
1:37:07With Amazon, well with Google, she's got this argument, I hate to paraphrase it all, but
1:37:15basically her problem with Google, I mostly agree with too, which is that they shouldn't
1:37:19be able to leverage Google search to favor their other properties.
1:37:24- Right, I mean that's something that,
1:37:26(laughing)
1:37:28Stop Open from Yelp has been screaming about for years.
1:37:31- Yeah. - You know what I mean?
1:37:32I mean, people have been pissed about that
1:37:33for a very long time.
1:37:35And in fact, they have been fined several times
1:37:38over this scenario where they were taking,
1:37:41saying like, oh hey, you can pay for an ad
1:37:44to go above a competitor's thing.
1:37:46But then they're putting their own listings,
1:37:48when you just search for a random thing,
1:37:50you think you're getting the listing that you search for,
1:37:52where really you're getting something that pays Google.
1:37:54So they're earning money on both sides of the deal.
1:37:57- So I'm amenable to that argument and I'm with you.
1:38:01Like Yelp is a really good example
1:38:03where that really does seem like what they did to Yelp.
1:38:06I mean, Yelp is still around.
1:38:07They haven't put Yelp out of business,
1:38:09but I do think that they damaged Yelp
1:38:11in a way that qualifies as traditional
1:38:13illegal anti-competitive behavior
1:38:16where they leveraged Google search
1:38:18to favor their own listings for these restaurants
1:38:20and encouraged people to rank them and rate them
1:38:23and do Yelp-like user things
1:38:26so that Google could build their own Yelp-like service.
1:38:29But it is, I have to say though, it is hard.
1:38:36It is a little bit to me less cut and dry.
1:38:38The analogy in the tech world I think would be
1:38:40to the Windows, the Microsoft Windows antitrust saga
1:38:44of the '90s where one of the things they were accused of
1:38:49was favoring their own office apps over competitors
1:38:53like Lotus 1, 2, 3, and WordPerfect, and et cetera.
1:38:58But even that, and I've said this over the years
1:39:02on the show a lot, even, you know,
1:39:04I don't have the archive going back far enough
1:39:06at Daring Fireball to say it,
1:39:08but even as a strong Mac fan at the time,
1:39:13and someone who did not see Microsoft's incredible dominance
1:39:19the industry as a good thing for the industry. I always felt about the whole antitrust argument
1:39:25because to me, yes, they did take some actions against those apps. You know, to they leverage
1:39:34the windows monopoly in ways that favored office in certain ways, and there probably
1:39:38should have been some action against them. But in other ways, I felt like the arguments
1:39:43against it. We're missing the ways that Microsoft just won in some ways fair and square. Like
1:39:49it was Microsoft that had the idea to bundle all three to make all three the spreadsheet,
1:39:54the word processor and what am I missing? What's the third part of an office suite?
1:40:00Oh, the PowerPoint. Oh yes. Presentation to do all three and bundle them as a suite. And
1:40:07remember, most of those things were sold by seats back then, and they were very expensive,
1:40:13you know, like a copy of word was like 300 bucks. And they were the ones who were like,
1:40:18well, you could pay 300 bucks each for $900 or we'll bundle them all together for $600
1:40:24or something like that, you know, which, you know, in hindsight, you know, today's world,
1:40:28you think $600 for a copy of a word processor and a spreadsheet seems like a lot of money.
1:40:34You know, that was the world we're in then, but you could get this bundle for less. And they did
1:40:38a lot of work to make them work together so that you could put spreadsheets in your word docs and
1:40:44PowerPoint and, you know, get a spreadsheet into PowerPoint, etc, etc. That, that having, you know,
1:40:51a word processor from one company like Word Perfect, and your spreadsheet from Lotus, you
1:40:57didn't get that integration. There were things Microsoft did that part of the rise of office
1:41:01wasn't wasn't just cheating. Similarly, with Google search that at some point, you know,
1:41:08if the best if the whole idea is that if it's truly honest, if they're just being the most
1:41:13honest search engine, they can be and you type words in the field and hit return, and
1:41:19they're making their best guess as to what it is you're looking for. It might be another
1:41:23Google product, right? Right. It's it. Like, it's not easy. It's not easy to say that they
1:41:29shouldn't ever put other Google products at the top of the search list. It requires nuance, you know.
1:41:37And we get to Amazon, and her argument with Amazon to me makes no sense at all. This is the point
1:41:46where to me, her argument belies to me, she doesn't really seem to understand how Amazon works.
1:41:55She keeps talking about these product platforms or, or something like that. And she doesn't want
1:42:01Amazon to act as its own store if they're running a product marketplace, you know, which is what
1:42:06Amazon has evolved into where other sellers, I think we're all familiar with this now that
1:42:11you search for something on Amazon and you look for who the seller is. It may not be Amazon. It's,
1:42:16you know, quite often not, uh, you know, that you and I can start a company selling, you know,
1:42:23coffee cup lids or something like that. And rather than sell them through Matthew and John's coffee
1:42:29cup lid company.com or in addition to we can sell them through Amazon and when people search for
1:42:34them on Amazon now, they'll get them through there. But basically, I don't think this is a
1:42:42stretch. What she's saying is that Amazon shouldn't be allowed to operate its own store, which is what
1:42:47what most people think of Amazon as.
1:42:49- Yeah, I mean, the problem with the arguments about Amazon
1:42:54and to some degree arguments about these other companies
1:42:58is that when you don't have like a true technical
1:43:03understanding of what they are and how they do what they do,
1:43:06I'm not saying that you shouldn't be able to comment on it.
1:43:09There are certain market forces at play, for instance,
1:43:11it's somebody who doesn't understand the technical aspects,
1:43:14but somebody who does understand the fiscal aspects of it
1:43:17are even more qualified to talk about.
1:43:19They're like, "I don't care how it's done,
1:43:20here's why it's wrong," right?
1:43:22But I don't think it's being tackled that way.
1:43:24I think when you tackle things on technical merit
1:43:28or on precise methods of execution of what they do,
1:43:33your arguments can be often blunted or distorted
1:43:38or made ineffective by not truly understanding
1:43:41the way that these things work.
1:43:43And I think that's one of the sort of benefits to having, you know, people who truly understand
1:43:49this stuff, write about it and talk about it and kind of analyze it is because they understand that
1:43:54if you talk about these things, and you have a platform like Elizabeth Warren does, to say, Hey,
1:44:00maybe these companies are too powerful, we should examine that what what should we do about it,
1:44:05you need to get your technical arguments correct. Because if you don't, it blunts the efficacy of
1:44:09your argument. Yeah,
1:44:11One of her arguments and it's like the most highlighted into the way that medium shows you the most highlighted
1:44:15Passage in an article the one that's most highlighted
1:44:19And I don't know if that's because people are agreeing with it or because people are selecting it to say like what the hell is
1:44:23She talking about is she's saying like hey the government
1:44:26Busted up Microsoft in in the 90s. Aren't you glad that we get to use Google for web search instead of Bing and
1:44:34That really wasn't
1:44:39It's a nonsense sentence essentially.
1:44:41- It's, yeah, Google A wasn't even a thing at that time.
1:44:46It was actually all about,
1:44:49well, part of the argument was about Netscape,
1:44:50which most, you know, if she said like,
1:44:52"Aren't you glad we still get to use Netscape
1:44:55instead of being forced to use IE?"
1:44:58That would actually be a little bit more accurate
1:45:01as to what the case was about,
1:45:02and everybody would be like, "I don't use IE.
1:45:04I don't use Netscape."
1:45:06Right?
1:45:07- Yeah, exactly.
1:45:08I mean, being the most highlighted thing
1:45:10makes you wonder whether it's being highlighted ironically
1:45:14or being highlighted genuinely.
1:45:17And that kind of statement, like using Google
1:45:20instead of being stuck with Bing,
1:45:22A, it's painting Bing as an inferior product,
1:45:25which I think many people would make an argument
1:45:27that it is, sure, great.
1:45:29So we're stuck with Bing.
1:45:31Okay, well that's the result of what you did to Microsoft,
1:45:36of what the government did to Microsoft.
1:45:37know. So anyhow, I yeah, it's it is it's wheels within wheels of how you can pick the argument
1:45:44apart. Well, I think that's what the point I was trying to make. It's a weak argument. It's like,
1:45:48it could be the point of the argument is actually worth talking about. But having a weak argument
1:45:53does it as a disservice? It does the conversation at disservice the the the 90s mentality and
1:46:00there's a reason for the mentality because it was true for the throughout the 80s and 90s was that
1:46:06that the important thing was to be the company
1:46:09making the software that ran on people's and businesses PCs.
1:46:13So Microsoft is the one who was the most successful
1:46:16and they made the operating system that ran on your PCs
1:46:20on your PC, right under your fingertips
1:46:22and they made these office apps
1:46:24that ran on your PC right there.
1:46:27And then the web and Netscape became this big thing
1:46:31and Netscape had a big IPO
1:46:32and was getting all this momentum.
1:46:35And there was a mentality at the time
1:46:38that the most important thing to control would be the browser
1:46:41because the browser was the app that ran on your PC.
1:46:44And it still is important.
1:46:46We were just talking about Apple and Safari
1:46:48and how much money they make from Google by having Safari.
1:46:52And Chrome is certainly a big strategic aspect of Google.
1:46:56So I'm not saying that browsers aren't important.
1:46:59But the thing that nobody really foresaw
1:47:01was that there would be companies like Google and Amazon who weren't running any software
1:47:06on your computer and were running in the browser. And it didn't matter which browser it was.
1:47:12Google was Google whether you were using IE or Netscape or iCab. It was, you know, you
1:47:18typed G-O-O and it filled in and you went to Google and that's where you searched for
1:47:22everything. And Amazon was there, you know, Amazon worked in every browser. That was the
1:47:27part of the brilliance of, and again, in hindsight, it seems super obvious, but in the 90s, it
1:47:32didn't seem obvious, at least at a certain point, until a certain point in the 90s, it
1:47:35didn't seem obvious that the way the next wave of big corporations was going to come
1:47:41from service providers that just ran stuff in the cloud that you access from any browser.
1:47:48Right.
1:47:49And then when she got to Apple, I think she really missed the, I think she picked the
1:47:56right part of the company, which is the app store. I do think that if there is an anti-competitive
1:48:02argument to be made against Apple, and I think there is a good one, it does involve their
1:48:08administration and control of the app store. Yeah. All the clearly demonstrable ones are
1:48:12there, you know, the ones that are consumers can feel and see and touch, so to speak, but
1:48:17she completely missed the boat on what it is. It's she's, she's back to this. Uh, you
1:48:21run a product marketplace. You shouldn't be allowed. Apple shouldn't be allowed to, to
1:48:25both control the app store and distribute its own apps on the app store.
1:48:30Which is dumb. That's the dumbest thing is that they should be allowed that no, it should
1:48:33actually be the way it should be done. They should put their ops on the store. Everybody
1:48:38else's absolute store. People would start what they want.
1:48:40Right. I wouldn't necessarily agree with it, but one argument would be that, yes, they
1:48:44should put more of their apps in the app store as opposed to baking them in like, you know,
1:48:49And I think it's a coincidence that Spotify came out this week with their public call
1:48:56for government intervention into the App Store.
1:49:01But if you look at Warren's proposal, it wouldn't really help Spotify at all.
1:49:06That's the thing.
1:49:07Is it Spotify has come out with this thing very publicly calling for that Apple's App
1:49:12Store isn't fair.
1:49:13And what Warren is promoting as a remedy wouldn't really help them at all.
1:49:17I mean, I like it. Yeah, it wouldn't help them at all. What you're saying. And what
1:49:23I'm saying is a possible thing is what if Apple Music had to come from the App Store
1:49:27instead of being built in and not on not just built into every iOS, but literally it's in
1:49:32one of the foremost prestigious spots in the dock. And then right, you know, you'd have
1:49:38to download Apple Music just the same way you'd have to download Spotify. But that's
1:49:42not really Spotify's problem. Spotify's problem is the 30% that they have to pay for anybody
1:49:46if they were to allow people to sign up within the app store.
1:49:49The 30% that's mandatory, though the 30% rate
1:49:54combined with the fact that any in-app digital purchase
1:49:58of a subscription or something like that
1:50:00has to use Apple's payment and has to pay 30%.
1:50:07And so that's the anti-competitive angle is that
1:50:10if Spotify wants- - And of course,
1:50:12the argument to the contrary
1:50:14is that people can buy a subscription to Spotify.
1:50:18They just can't do it via IAP.
1:50:20- Right. - You know?
1:50:22And I think that will be Apple's argument.
1:50:24And Apple's argument, of course, is we built the App Store,
1:50:27we maintain the App Store.
1:50:28If you want to sell things in the App Store,
1:50:31those are our rules.
1:50:32If you wanna sell things outside the App Store, you can.
1:50:35And they could use those things in the App Store.
1:50:37They could download the app.
1:50:39But you just can't, the convenience of buying it,
1:50:43the conversion bonus of buying it in the app
1:50:46is something we're not gonna let you use unless you pay us.
1:50:49And that should be the crux of what
1:50:52Warren should have attacked.
1:50:53- Right. - And she didn't.
1:50:54- Right, and I think there's a good argument there
1:50:56and I think it puts, I think Apple has a defense for it,
1:50:58but I think it's sort of a, you know.
1:51:01- Apple's biggest defense is Google.
1:51:05- Right. - Is Android, ironically.
1:51:07Right, they're like, you know, on one hand,
1:51:10Tim Cook could be like, we weighed like billions on the App Store. But he can also say, but we're so tiny compared to Google. They have all the users, right? And it's like taking a revenue number and comparing it against a user number. And there is some sense of irony in the fact that the government is set up not necessarily to play with those revenue numbers, but to sort of pay attention to and reward or whatever you want to call it or punish people based
1:51:40on the peer user base.
1:51:42So if Apple's to make an argument that Google actually
1:51:46is the one that should be examined,
1:51:48or that they provide them some cover
1:51:51by providing a platform that is widely accessible
1:51:55by a major portion of the population,
1:51:57and not only that, but they also apply many
1:51:59of the same rules, they have cover there.
1:52:03That is probably their strongest argument.
1:52:05- I just feel like fundamentally though,
1:52:08whole thing. And I've been on this for a while. Like I just think that today's antitrust law
1:52:15in the US, the EU might be a little better than the United States, but I still feel like
1:52:19fundamentally the whole thing is still rooted in 100 years ago. I mean, and Warren even brings up
1:52:26like the, what was she say here? Back when railroads were dominant, there's a quote from
1:52:31her and you had to get steel and wheat onto the railroad. There was a period of time when the
1:52:35railroads figured out that they could make money not only by selling tickets on the railroad
1:52:40by all but also by buying the steel company and then cutting the price of transporting
1:52:45steel for their own company and raising the price of transporting steel for any competitors.
1:52:51And that's you know, that is actually something that happened and that actually informs modern
1:52:56US antitrust law, but that was 100 years ago. And I feel like trying to apply that sort
1:53:02of logic to these companies which are entirely digital and that these economies are told
1:53:08these the way that they work is so different is it would be like trying to apply 1804 laws
1:53:17to those companies in the early 1900s right there right you know how in the world with
1:53:22the laws of 1800 have foreseen railroads let alone the steel industry yeah the carriage
1:53:28Law is just not going to fly in a digital marketplace or to evaluate one.
1:53:33Right. And my favorite example of this in recent law was the Apple eBooks antitrust
1:53:39case which really, the whole thing just hinged on whether prices were going up or down for
1:53:45consumers. And I get lots of pushback on this. I've gotten it over the years by saying that
1:53:51I really think Apple was done wrong here. And it's always from readers who say, "But
1:53:56The prices were higher and I want to pay $9.99 for books.
1:54:00But what Amazon was doing wasn't, you know,
1:54:03Amazon's the one who has a dominant position
1:54:05in the ebook industry, a monopoly.
1:54:08They're the ones who, if you talk to publishers,
1:54:10who are you concerned about in the ebook industry?
1:54:13They all say Amazon, not Apple.
1:54:16The whole reason they got into bed with Apple
1:54:19and made the deals that ended up causing Apple
1:54:23to lose that lawsuit was because the actual book publishers
1:54:26were all concerned about what Amazon was doing,
1:54:29which was artificially deflating prices
1:54:31to keep competitors out.
1:54:32And even to the point of selling bestsellers at a loss,
1:54:37just because they could afford to and others couldn't.
1:54:39Like Amazon as a company with a huge market cap
1:54:43and a very high stock price and support from its shareholders
1:54:50Famously of running as a no-profit business just reinvesting all revenue into the business
1:54:57could afford to sell ebooks cheaper than Barnes & Noble could Barnes & Noble couldn't sell a
1:55:02$15 ebook for $9.99 and take a $5 loss on each one Amazon couldn't and they did that's the bullying
1:55:09anti-competitive behavior
1:55:12and it's all based on the fact that US antitrust law is
1:55:17based on the basic idea that if prices go up for consumers, that's bad and if they don't that's good which in
1:55:24Theory makes sense. But when you think about a company like Amazon that can sell things at a loss when others can't it doesn't
1:55:32And again, it's all just based on your own distribution versus creation - there's an argument that falls in it's it
1:55:40It may be in the short run slightly better
1:55:43for a consumer. But if the, you know, if they, if there's no profit being made by the people
1:55:50creating the product, you know, then it's now you end up in a position where they get crushed out of
1:55:56business, or they must deal with Amazon, then who has the stronger antitrust argument, you know?
1:56:01And, you know, Amazon's basic products that that's not the problem. You know, I mean, Walmart has
1:56:09every major retailer has house brand products.
1:56:12- Yep, yeah, Amazon didn't start that.
1:56:15- You know, and I'm not saying Walmart doesn't do things
1:56:17that companies consider bullying
1:56:20from their market perspective, they do.
1:56:22But it's just not the fundamental problem
1:56:26that if you're going to go after Amazon.
1:56:29So I kind of feel like this whole thing is a shame
1:56:31because I do feel like it is good
1:56:33that a major US politician, someone like Warren,
1:56:38right now is perhaps at the height of her influence because she's already been well-known,
1:56:43and now she's announced herself as a candidate for the presidency in 2020. She has a significant,
1:56:49you know, number of, she may not be the front runner, but she certainly is in the running.
1:56:53So something that she proposes like this is going to carry a lot of weight and, you know,
1:57:00she winds up not winning. If she ends up not winning the nomination, she may never be quite
1:57:06as influential again. And I kind of feel like so it's good that somebody is looking at this stuff
1:57:12because I do feel like the government, you know, in the US should be looking at these companies,
1:57:16all four of them in various ways in ways that they haven't. But I feel like man missing the boat
1:57:22at these technical levels is just sort of this. It's very, very disappointing to me.
1:57:28Yep, I agree. Anyway, what I didn't look a lot at the Spotify thing. Yeah, what's the just I know
1:57:34that part of it is the 30%, which I do think is the key thing to attack if you're Spotify,
1:57:40but I haven't seen the rest of their proposal. Have you?
1:57:43Jared Polin No, I haven't read through it in a detailed
1:57:45way. So I couldn't speak to it as far as what they actually want.
1:57:50Dave Asprey Right. But the main problem isn't the fact
1:57:52that Apple distributes apps through the App Store. It's basically the 30% that they want.
1:57:57Jared Polin Yeah, it's the money.
1:57:58Dave Asprey Right. Well, and then maybe-
1:58:00- Which the money is, it's legit.
1:58:03Apple does earn a good chunk of money
1:58:05for a product that they don't create.
1:58:07- But on the other hand, it's,
1:58:10and Spotify is a smaller company than Apple,
1:58:12but Spotify is not like some sort of innocent
1:58:16little two-person garage startup.
1:58:19And in talking about doing things
1:58:24that would be popular or unpopular,
1:58:25I mean, Spotify has spent like $100 million recently
1:58:28trying to build a proprietary podcast thing
1:58:31to get podcasts on Spotify into a more Netflix-like thing
1:58:36where Spotify podcasts are only on Spotify.
1:58:40Whereas Apple, which embraced podcasts
1:58:45at a really extraordinary early stage
1:58:49of podcasts as a phenomenon,
1:58:52and runs what is still widely considered the,
1:58:57It is, it's the biggest index of podcasts
1:59:01and the most popular podcast player,
1:59:03iTunes and the podcast app on iOS,
1:59:06has kept it entirely open in a way that it's,
1:59:11in my opinion, admirable.
1:59:13They've never made even a step in the direction
1:59:16of trying to take any sort of proprietary control
1:59:20over podcasts or done anything that would put
1:59:26Android or Windows or going back far enough,
1:59:29Zoom users at a disadvantage trying to listen to podcasts
1:59:33compared to if Apple hadn't been involved.
1:59:35- Right.
1:59:38- And I say-- - Yeah, never.
1:59:40- I say boo-hiss to Spotify's grab for podcasts
1:59:44being a proprietary platform.
1:59:46- I know, I know, yeah.
1:59:48Well, look, Spotify is a huge company,
1:59:51in terms of, especially in terms of music
1:59:53and how difficult that industry is.
1:59:55their argument is they could have been bigger, which is, it's definitely one way to go. But,
2:00:03you know, I think that they have, I think, an opportunity to kind of speak in a populist way.
2:00:11But I think that their argument comes off a little bit like, well, we could have made more money,
2:00:16though. You know what I mean? But I don't disagree necessarily with their point. I understand where
2:00:21they're coming from. I think the way that they're making the point is a little bit
2:00:24you know, business focused and should maybe be a little bit
2:00:29more populous, 'cause I think they actually gain
2:00:31more support, but you know, we'll see how it pans out,
2:00:35how the message goes across.
2:00:36I think people are starting to get reactions,
2:00:38we're already starting to see some reactions
2:00:40from like lawmakers and other entrepreneurs and stuff
2:00:44who, some of those entrepreneurs feel the same way
2:00:47as Spotify and have come under the same sort of thumb,
2:00:49so to speak, of Apple's, you know, kind of arrangement
2:00:53where they, you know, it's like,
2:00:55pray that I don't make it harder for you.
2:00:57You can just do it, you know what I mean?
2:00:59- My argument would be,
2:01:02and that to me the way it probably should be in some sense,
2:01:05is that an app,
2:01:08if it wants to institute its own payment processing,
2:01:13should be able to,
2:01:15but then you're on your own as the developers
2:01:18and you do your backend and you do the front end
2:01:22and you take the credit card numbers,
2:01:25you deal with subscription renewal
2:01:28and people's in between subscription renewals
2:01:32if their credit card number changes
2:01:33because they got a new credit card or whatever,
2:01:36you deal with all that.
2:01:37All these things that Apple's iTunes payment thing
2:01:41handles automatically, you do it and you're on your own.
2:01:44Or if you wanna use our thing, which is a very easy API
2:01:48and puts people one fingerprint or FaceTime scan away
2:01:52from approving the purchase,
2:01:55and we handle their subscription renewals,
2:01:57we put our trust behind it,
2:02:01and people know that they can trust iTunes for this
2:02:05the way they've trusted it for all their other purchases,
2:02:07then you'll pay our 30% and see how it goes.
2:02:11Ben Thompson has argued pretty strongly,
2:02:14and I think I agree with him,
2:02:15that if Apple were to do that,
2:02:18they would probably have to lower the 30% lower it to where I don't know, but that, you know,
2:02:23in the way that that would be competing against letting app developers roll their own, like having
2:02:28Netflix be, you know, letting Netflix sign you up, but not pay Apple any tax by but handling it all
2:02:34on their own, whatever that number would be, would it be 15%? Would it be 10%? I don't know,
2:02:39it would come down to some other number other than 30% due to competition, which is the way
2:02:44it's supposed to work. That would be my proposed suggestion to Senator Warren if she's listening.
2:02:54[laughter]
2:02:54Jared: Yeah, I think that's absolutely one way to go. I mean, having Apple be the person who
2:03:07controls both of the, both the framework by which they get sold and the architecture by which people
2:03:13can enter into continuing financial relationships with
2:03:16people. It definitely is a bad look, right? Like it's easy to
2:03:20attack. Whether that's fair or not, I don't know. But it's
2:03:24certainly as easy to say, Hey, this is a bad thing. Why? Why
2:03:27does this happen? You know, who should be who could should have
2:03:30this much power or whatever. But I think there's definitely a way
2:03:36to look at it where you're like, Hey, what if we what if as a
2:03:42company, we decided we just didn't need to make this much
2:03:45money off of this particular segment. And what we'll do is
2:03:49look at least appear optically, like we are on the side of
2:03:54entrepreneurs and want to make sure that we're not stifling
2:03:56competition or whatever. And they basically don't charge you
2:03:59until you reach a certain size. This wouldn't help Spotify,
2:04:02right? Right. It would absolutely create this feeling
2:04:05of like, hey, we were fostering entrepreneurship, and we're
2:04:08welcoming competition and all of this stuff. At a certain point,
2:04:11though, once you reach a certain volume or certain intensity of
2:04:15business or whatever, you know, we, you know, it makes sense for
2:04:18us to charge you and who could argue with that, right? And I
2:04:21think that's the way they should go with it personally. But yeah,
2:04:23what's it called the tax bracket system? Oh, yeah, a tax bracket.
2:04:28Well, expert tranches, or, but there's a name for it. And
2:04:32people widely misunderstand it, where people think that if the
2:04:36the top tax bracket goes to 50%.
2:04:41But let's just say if you make $10 million or more,
2:04:46then there's a 50% tax.
2:04:49The way it actually works is you only pay the 50% rate
2:04:52on the income from 10 million and over.
2:04:55- That's right. - Right?
2:04:56So if you make 10 million and $1,
2:04:58you don't owe 5 million and 50 cents in taxes.
2:05:01- You owe a greater percentage of that $1.
2:05:03- Right.
2:05:04But like your first 100,000 is the same rate
2:05:07everybody pays on their first 100,000.
2:05:10And if everybody there's like the earned income tax credit.
2:05:12So like for everybody, whether you're like a billionaire
2:05:14or not like your first 20, $30,000 or whatever is tax-free.
2:05:18That would be, yeah, I've seen other people propose that
2:05:23for the app store where like if you have
2:05:25a subscription service, you maybe pay nothing
2:05:27for the first $100,000 and then you pay 10%
2:05:30on the next 100,000 and 30% on everything above that.
2:05:34Something like that.
2:05:37And again, it certainly would create a lot of goodwill
2:05:41among indie developers and anybody looking
2:05:43to promote startups and stuff like that
2:05:44where you can at least get off the ground
2:05:47and keep 100% or maybe minus credit card fees.
2:05:52So maybe like the initial rate for the first 100,000
2:05:55would be like 2.5% or something like that.
2:05:58reasonable number to cover Apple's credit card processing fees combined with their fraud and etc.
2:06:04Jared: Yeah, and I mean, in like, that would even sign even like the those two options have to exist
2:06:11in mutually exclusive ways, you could do both, you could do a, you know, a scale that says like,
2:06:20hey, you know, for your first bit, this is not that much. And then later on, you could do a sliding
2:06:24scale where you're like, you know, hey, it's X percent if you do this much business and it's
2:06:29less or more if you do more, you know, I don't know. There are a lot of options in between they
2:06:34can't charge and they charge 30%. Yeah, yeah. But that's, you know, it just is very frustrating that
2:06:42that's not what the finger has been put on, you know. All right, last but not least, let's,
2:06:51Before we start the last segment, let's talk about our third and final sponsor of the day.
2:06:55This is one of my favorite companies that sponsors the show, Mack Weldon.
2:06:58Mack Weldon's mission is simple. They make all your basics. This is stuff like t-shirts,
2:07:04underwear, socks. They make them smartly designed. They make them nice to look at.
2:07:09They make them comfortable. They make them easy to buy and convenient to buy. They wanted more
2:07:15out of their basics and they always questioned how something so essential could be such a pain
2:07:19in, well, let's just say the butt to buy. Their eureka moment happened when they were in a
2:07:27department store aisle full of brands that dominated their top drawer and surrounded
2:07:31by a mind-numbing assortment of underwear and socks. They realized consistent fit and quality
2:07:35had become a game of roulette. Are you really getting stuff that's the best fitting, best,
2:07:39most comfortable, or are you just buying a name brand that you knew? They started from scratch.
2:07:43They even engineered their own fabric. They made sure the design process was meticulous
2:07:49So you can count on the fit being the same each time. So if you get a pair of Mack Wendon,
2:07:55Weldon, let's say t-shirts and it fits great. You buy some more, they're all, all the ones you buy,
2:08:01they're all going to fit the same way. Meticulous about it. It's really a better product,
2:08:06almost certainly better than what you're wearing right now. If you're not wearing Mack Weldon,
2:08:10it's a premium men's essentials brand that believes in smart design and premium fabrics.
2:08:16I've got a whole bunch of their stuff. I love it. It's always the first stuff out of the drawer when
2:08:20I'm putting stuff on. I really like in particular, I love their socks. They have terrific socks,
2:08:26very comfortable. Long lasting to a lot longer lasting than a lot of other stuff that I've had.
2:08:33Very comfortable and very stylish. To be honest, they're very fun to buy.
2:08:38I've really gotten into in the last couple of years. I used for years, I would say for
2:08:44like 40 some years of my life. I think every single pair of socks I owned was either white,
2:08:49which was like 90% of my life, or black, which was any time where I felt like, you know,
2:08:53white socks weren't dressy enough. Now I've got all sorts of colorful socks. And you know,
2:08:57I feel like it's a start your day on a brighter note. So not only do their stuff look good,
2:09:04feel good, perform well last long. But they have great prices too. And it's really easy to shop
2:09:10for the stuff. I've got everything. I've got the t-shirts. I've got their underwear. I've
2:09:16got the socks. You know what I like? I'll tell you what else I like my favorite product.
2:09:19I like a v-neck t-shirt because then you can unbutton a button and you don't see the t-shirt
2:09:23underneath. I feel like if you're going to wear an undershirt, they should all be v-necks. I'm not
2:09:27quite sure why anybody doesn't buy v-necks, but all of my undershirts are Mack Weldon.
2:09:33They all do fit the same. I've just got like a whole drawer full of identical Mack Weldon white
2:09:38t shirts v neck and I love them. Here's the call to action. You get 20% off your first
2:09:44order by visiting Mac weldon.com Mac K w e l d o n Mac weldon.com and enter this code
2:09:54talk show no the just talk show and that'll save you 20% off your first order. They've
2:10:02also got a guarantee where if your first purchase something doesn't fit right, they'll just
2:10:08They'll just let you keep it and you pick a new size and go back.
2:10:12Just read all about it on their website.
2:10:13It's really great.
2:10:14They really want you to be happy with your purchase.
2:10:16So my thanks to Mack Weldon.
2:10:17Go to mackweldon.com and remember that code, talk show.
2:10:21All right, here we go.
2:10:25You lucky son of a bitch.
2:10:31I think anybody who listens to this show for a long time knows one of my obsessions is
2:10:34Star Wars.
2:10:35and I think most of you also know I'm a big fan of Disney theme parks, or at least the Florida ones.
2:10:41Not that I'm not a fan of the other ones, but I've never been to any of the other ones.
2:10:46But my family loves going to the Disney Orlando area theme parks. And anybody who follows either
2:10:55of those obsessions knows that Disney is on the cusp of opening major new theme park lands in both
2:11:03California and Florida for Star Wars and you, you lucky son of a bit, spent three days with them.
2:11:08I did. I did. It was interesting. It was sort of just like a three-day mouth agape situation.
2:11:21This was all in California because the California one is A, going to open first and B is where
2:11:28Imagineering headquarters is?
2:11:29Jay Haynes Yes. So the way Imagineering works is they had their headquarters are in Glendale, kind of in a business park, they're fairly unassuming group of beige buildings. And then they have facilities in Florida that are largely about maintenance and storage. But then they also have some research institutes, like in Pittsburgh and a couple of other places, but their headquarters are there. So it was sort of a three day jaunt through the process. This is, by the way, very unusual for
2:11:57Disney. They typically do not do large press kind of, you know, pushes with this stuff, or lengthy
2:12:05explanations of kind of what they're doing. And, you know, I sort of it was revelatory for a lot of
2:12:13people that had been there or that had been covering for the company for a long time. Some of
2:12:16them, you know, were there on this little press tour. I was, there's the Jermaine over at Gizmodo
2:12:24was on this thing. But he was he's sort of their entertainment writer, you know, the kind of movies
2:12:30and entertainment things like that is a good writer. I like reading him. But outside of that,
2:12:36there was almost no tech press. And the only reason that I was even involved with this because
2:12:41they it was, you know, it's Hollywood Reporter, LA Times, Variety, you know, Variety, exactly.
2:12:49several theme park, you know, kind of oriented writers from like, travel and leisure and things
2:12:54like that, right? This is the this is the sort of people that were on this tour. And the only reason
2:12:59I wasn't even involved is because I do have a personal fascination with Imagineering, how they
2:13:05kind of operate, you know, functionally, as well as, of course, what they do, you know, in the sort
2:13:10of business of building themed entertainment and robotics and, you know, kind of interactive
2:13:18experiences and world building and you know all of that stuff right it's just interesting to me
2:13:23and there's a lot of tech in that that is used in that industry and even created for that industry
2:13:30that is just not talked about because they don't talk to the people who care or would understand it
2:13:37or would you know care to interpret it for an audience or whatever so i've spent about three
2:13:41years sort of getting to know those folks over there and convincing them that there are stories
2:13:47that they were not telling that needed to be told or needed to be examined. Basically,
2:13:52pitching them on this idea that, look, you're doing a lot of stuff in this arena, but you're
2:13:57not telling people about it. And my major pitch is, you need to hire roboticists and engineers,
2:14:05software engineers, and, you know, coders and all these people, but they don't know that you have
2:14:09hard problems to solve. And there's only there's no catnip greater to an engineer than a hard
2:14:14problem. So it is a that was basically my microbar that I
2:14:19used to kind of push it this. And that's how I ended up
2:14:21getting the invite. Basically, it was they were like, Oh, yeah,
2:14:23you know, we were going to do this thing. We'd love to have
2:14:27you involved in all this stuff. Everybody else there was from
2:14:29the entertainment world. So it was kind of fun being the only
2:14:32person there who's like, Okay, yeah, cool. Could you explain
2:14:35now that you know, this cat this tool that she's Why didn't you
2:14:38just use CAD? Why did you use this, you know, in house tool
2:14:41and all of this stuff. So what did you do with Nvidia to get GPUs to be able to drive this display?
2:14:47Yeah, basically, there was a lot of I mean, I think, you know, not not to not to telegraph too much, but or, or put too much in words in anybody's mouth, but there was a lot of side eyeing from the engineers who obviously wanted to talk about it. Right. To the PR people like can we please? Can I talk about this? Because I've been living this for for two years, you know, normally they don't let them talk about some of that stuff.
2:15:11or they're not used to being asked about it at the very least. So that was fun. But yeah,
2:15:16the gist of it was to step back. It was a three day tour. We started out at ILM in San Francisco.
2:15:25I don't know if a lot of people know this, but their main headquarters are, aside from Skywalker
2:15:31Ranch, which is a different facility that does a lot of audio and stuff, ILM's main headquarters
2:15:37are in San Francisco on the Presidio. They have a facility there that they share with Lucasfilm.
2:15:42So we started out at essentially Lucasfilm, which is sort of the bottom floor,
2:15:47talking about the originations of the project and the storytelling and kind of how do you start
2:15:53building this world and all the decisions there. And then we moved to Imagineering in Glendale on
2:16:00the second day. And that Imagineering is, you know, obviously where they build a lot of the
2:16:06animatronics. They have a workshop there where they craft a lot of the in-house stuff that they do.
2:16:10They have contractors too, but a lot of the main, you know, key ones are done in-house. And then,
2:16:18on the third day, we actually went and did a site tour at Galaxy's Edge, which is the land that
2:16:25they're building onto Disneyland. The Star Wars land. Glendale is just north of the sort of hills,
2:16:34the Hollywood Hills. Basically, you've got Glendale, the Hills, downtown LA, LA proper,
2:16:41Venice, all of that. And then south of that is Anaheim where Disneyland is. So it's just north
2:16:46of LA, essentially. It's still LA. So did you guys fly between days one and two? I mean, that's a
2:16:50long way because ILM is San Francisco and then the other two days are down in Southern California.
2:16:56Exactly. Yeah, yeah, we flew. I book all my own travel when I go on these things. I don't let
2:17:02junkets pay for me. I'm kind of a policy of ours. We just don't really do it. Every once in a while,
2:17:08there's some weird thing where it's like, "Hey, this is our thing and just come," right? And it's
2:17:12like, "Okay, we'll disclose it." But by and large, we pay for our own travel. So when we flew between
2:17:17the two, just speaking, this is just a fun side note as an aviation nerd, but flying between the
2:17:23two, we flew out of Oakland. So we drove, we took a little bus from Imagineering to, or excuse me,
2:17:31from Lucasfilm to the Oakland airport. And I fly out of Oakland, but not regularly. I usually fly
2:17:38out of SFO or LAX, depending on where I'm going, if I'm not flying out of Fresno. And Fresno doesn't
2:17:45have a lot of direct flights to Oakland or a lot of direct flights to—definitely no direct flights
2:17:53to John Wayne, which is in Anaheim, or the Burbank Airport, which is the one that's
2:18:01closest to Glendale. But if you fly out of Oakland, you can get a JetBlue flight out
2:18:07of Oakland to Glendale. And it's, depending on the day, it can be as little as 70 bucks
2:18:13Wow, the fly, which is great. And that's what it was. So my airfare was full disclosure,
2:18:18my airfare was $70. I think that's what I swear to God, I think that's what I paid
2:18:21for an Uber to get from SFO to San Jose last year.
2:18:25- Seriously, exactly, exactly.
2:18:27And here's the really cool thing about it.
2:18:30JetBlue, because of, you know, carriage deals, right?
2:18:35Carriage deals in airlines, most people have experienced
2:18:38this at some point, you book through United,
2:18:40but you're actually flying on, you know, some other carrier.
2:18:44Or you book through American, but you're on American Eagle.
2:18:46And whatever, it's a carriage deal.
2:18:48It's basically like, hey, we know we're not gonna be able
2:18:50to fill these flights, so we're going to give you the seats to sell too, and we get
2:18:55a percentage or whatever.
2:18:56And so you basically are flying on some airline that you didn't actually book.
2:19:00The majors don't cross over, but a lot of minor carriers cross over with the majors.
2:19:05So JetBlue has a carriage deal with JetSuite, which is like one of these private jet sort
2:19:14of group deal things.
2:19:16I think that's the one Berkshire Hathaway I think has an investment in.
2:19:21Or if not, Berkshire Hathaway has an investment in one of them.
2:19:23Yeah, exactly.
2:19:24There's NetJets, JetSuite, there's a bunch of them.
2:19:29So anyhow, long story short, I flew private for $70.
2:19:35Was it nice?
2:19:36It was fun.
2:19:37It was great.
2:19:38I mean, hey, you have your own flight attendant.
2:19:39It's only 20 people on the plane.
2:19:42It's very nice.
2:19:44It's definitely not all broken down and burnt out and everything.
2:19:48It was certainly a short flight, but it was pleasant.
2:19:51And it was $70.
2:19:52So I can't beat that.
2:19:55And the best part of it, this is the absolute best part, the plane is whatever.
2:19:59It's nice, but it's a short flight.
2:20:01The best part is that they have their own terminal.
2:20:05So instead of going into the airport, you actually go through the regular airport lane
2:20:09and then sort of circle around and their terminal is just directly adjacent to the airport basically.
2:20:17They come in, you come in, you drive right up to the terminal essentially, hop out, hop
2:20:24into the little waiting room there, you talk to the person at the desk, you're checked
2:20:29in in like 25 seconds, you sit and have some snacks and some coffee and whatever that they
2:20:34have out there and you get on your plane.
2:20:37And then when you land on the other side, you literally just pull up to a hangar and
2:20:41get out and go into the hangar, walk in through the hangar and then exit the hangar after
2:20:46a little waiting room and get in your cab or car and boom, you're gone.
2:20:51So it's quite nice.
2:20:52I think I might get rich now that I know this is how they … I might try that for a while.
2:21:00It was cool.
2:21:01So, one day at ILM, one day at Imagineering, one day at the actual park, which is set to
2:21:07open when?
2:21:08Jared: So, the opening date is May 31st is for Disneyland and then there's another
2:21:16date for Walt Disney World.
2:21:17I don't have it in my brain.
2:21:18But it's later on in the year.
2:21:19Pete: I think it's September.
2:21:21Well, let's call it September.
2:21:27I wonder how badly they had hoped to hit the May the 4th.
2:21:32There's always a big thing.
2:21:35Disney's actually had deals with Lucasfilm for a very long time.
2:21:40There's been the Star Tours ride since I think the 80s.
2:21:43Jared Polin August 29th, sorry.
2:21:46Just wanted to answer.
2:21:47But yeah, there's been deals for a while.
2:21:49Jon Moffitt They've long had like Star Wars celebrations
2:21:52on May the 4th because get it, May the 4th be with you. I'm sure they tried to hit that, but
2:22:00it's coming up. So it must be—
2:22:03Yeah, it is. And you know what, to be honest, so the opening date is—to finish out the opening
2:22:08date conversation, the opening date is May 31st, and both attractions will not be open on that.
2:22:15And there's two main attractions. And both attractions will not be open on that date.
2:22:20So they're pushing hard. I mean, they were working around the clock when we were there.
2:22:23One of the tour folks were telling me, one of the construction managers was telling us that
2:22:30he left one night at like 5 p.m, 6 p.m, and they got in the next morning at 8 a.m,
2:22:36and like a bunch of X-wings had appeared. So they're working around the clock pretty much.
2:22:40Pete: The two places where I've noticed where construction moves really fast is Disney,
2:22:46where you can take like a week-long vacation and see progress having been made on something that's
2:22:51under a crane. And Vegas, where stuff goes up in Vegas and it's like, who knows how the hell they
2:22:57make it happen, but it happens, seemingly, at least to my perspective, happens pretty fast.
2:23:03Jared: Mm hmm. Money.
2:23:05Pete: Yeah, I think so.
2:23:07Jared; Put poor enough money on it, it goes up fast.
2:23:10Pete; And maybe there's less regular, maybe less traditional union hurdles than in like
2:23:15big east coast cities like Philly and New York. There's more red tape or something like that.
2:23:21I feel like down in Orlando, Disney, not that they're cutting corners, but that there's just
2:23:27not as much urban bureaucracy. And I think Vegas is sort of more of a similar money talks sort of
2:23:36thing. But anyway, it can happen fast. Just going meta for a second, I do suspect, I suspect
2:23:44I know there's a big overlap between Apple nerds and Disney nerds or fans, whatever you
2:23:51want to call it.
2:23:54I also think, though, that there's probably a lot of people who listen to this show who
2:23:58maybe are surprised that I'm a big fan of the Disney theme parks because maybe I come
2:24:02across as being a gruff curmudgeon who would think of standing all day out in the sun,
2:24:10going around on ostensible kiddie rides.
2:24:14It wouldn't be my bag.
2:24:17And I'll just say it's hard to explain, but I would just say that the difference,
2:24:22if you've never, I think you had to have been to one of their parks to get it.
2:24:27And maybe you have been and you don't like it.
2:24:29I can certainly imagine if you really just can't stand being in lines, you're never
2:24:33going to like it no matter how much you would otherwise.
2:24:38I just appreciate it as an appreciator of good design in general, or at least thoughtful
2:24:44Because it's incredible the the depth to with which they design things is just astounding to me
2:24:50And that's the main reason that I'm a fan of stuff like this
2:24:53Mm-hmm. Yeah, I think I think there's a lot of aspects to it design is absolutely one major one for me
2:25:00you know the technology that they are using more and more is
2:25:05Sharing a lot of edges with you know, the bleeding edge of what you know is out there in terms of robotics
2:25:13One of the big things that I've been tracking for a long time, one of the big topics is
2:25:24the arena of HRI or human-robot interaction.
2:25:27Because I do feel that HRI is going to become an essential learning or an essential investment
2:25:35for any major company that has any sort of automated or roboticized features or processes.
2:25:44Because it's already, I mean, in practical terms, just to give people like a grounding,
2:25:48HRI is used in the field of industrial robotics to give people greater awareness of their
2:25:56robot co-workers, so to speak.
2:25:59That greater awareness comes with viewing that robot as an entity.
2:26:03if you think of it as a personality or a thing that has a, you know, a bit of a personality
2:26:08or whatever, you're more aware of it. And so you're safer, you know, if the robot arm is moving
2:26:12around in your workspace, you're more aware of it if you think of it as a, you know, a being,
2:26:17an entity or whatever you want to call it. It's kind of a weird kind of hippie dippie
2:26:22discipline in some ways. There's a lot of, you know, Berkeley professors thinking hard about it
2:26:29and stuff like that. But it is absolutely clear that Disney is one of the foremost world leaders
2:26:36in HRI because of the way their learnings over decades of the way people interact with creatures
2:26:41and characters, the way they interact and view animatronics, the way that they partake in themed
2:26:48entertainment and that kind of thing. So they're doing some fascinating stuff there. And then on
2:26:52top of that, you have this layer of world building. That design that you were talking about, where
2:26:57You're able to be ensconced in a thing that transports you.
2:27:02And the detail, the attention to detail is absolutely fascinating and enjoyable.
2:27:08I mean, if you want to understand the level of detail that Disney engineers put into things,
2:27:14or these Imagineers put into things, you just look at the next time you're at Disneyland
2:27:18or Disney World, look at the railings.
2:27:22Just look at the different railings they have throughout the park and the way they transition
2:27:25from one land to another and kind of ease you into this place that you're, you know,
2:27:30you're leaving one place and entering another and that kind of thing. So this just, it's
2:27:33just cool stuff like that that I love.
2:27:35Um, I always like to say I've used this at least some point on the show, but I always
2:27:40like to say that. So I first went to Disney World in Florida like about 12 years ago.
2:27:47And before I went, I was kind of looking forward to it, but I'd never been as a kid. My family
2:27:51never went to Disney World when I was a kid and I didn't go as an adult until our son
2:27:55was like two and a half or three or something like that. I was looking forward to it. I had been in
2:28:02Florida before, but we went to and this is like in my 20s or something, but we went to Universal
2:28:06instead because it seemed like more action packed. I think it was probably the right thing to do
2:28:09because I was still at an age where I didn't feel too old to go on the fastest roller coaster known
2:28:15to man. The thing is, is that I until I went to Disney World, I thought the words amusement park
2:28:22and theme park were completely interchangeable, you know, like, right, like Street and Avenue
2:28:26or something like that. Whereas when I went to Disney World, I finally got it. I was like,
2:28:31Oh, I get what you mean by theme park. You know, like when you go into Tomorrowland,
2:28:39you don't see any of the rest of the park. It's like you're just entirely there, you know, and
2:28:43you use the words multiple times in this article on the galaxy's edge, the Star Wars world,
2:28:49controlling the sight lines. And it works both ways. And it seems like one of the newer
2:28:56trends is controlling the sight ways, the sight lines both ways where the big thing is like,
2:29:01once you're in the galaxy's edge, you're not supposed to see the red, you don't see Cinderella's
2:29:05castle or, or I guess that's actually wrong in California. It's not Cinderella's castle,
2:29:13it's Sleeping Beauty's castle. That's how much of a Disney nerd I am. How about that?
2:29:17that. But that call we would have had angry emails, but that the entrance is controlled
2:29:24as well. Right? Like at least in Florida, like as you're walking into tomorrowland,
2:29:31you see tomorrowland, it's almost like beckoning to you to walk this way. Whereas it sounds
2:29:36to me like the galaxy's edge thing. It's sort of like, you don't see anything and then you
2:29:41come through an entrance and it's boom, a big reveal. Yeah, one of the one of the things
2:29:46they talked about a lot was how to get people from there to here. Like, you know, you're
2:29:52transporting these people from one world to another, and they're guests on this planet,
2:29:56which is also, they say, how they'll explain the fact that you're wearing Crocs, right?
2:30:01Like, you're a visitor. But the basic thesis is like, hey, we're going to create this
2:30:07feeling of compression. So you compress people down to a finite space, and then expansion,
2:30:14you open the world back up to them. And so two of the entrances are essentially rock tunnels
2:30:20that are made to look like they've been laser cut into the rock, you know, by like the
2:30:24empire or excuse me, the first order or the resistance, you know, and that those rock carved
2:30:34or laser carved rock tunnels kind of compress down and bring you down to where you're going
2:30:39through a tunnel and then you have you open up on a vista which is like a frame of film.
2:30:45These frames of film are open up like oh yeah this is the first time you saw x y or z in the
2:30:51films that's what we want it to feel like right and then in the the top most entrance which comes
2:30:58in from Critter Country which is over near kind of Splash Mountain in Disneyland at least in
2:31:04Disneyland, of course, in Disney World, there's only two entrances, but it is sort of wooded
2:31:09pathway, you know, that kind of meanders from one wooded country to a different kind of trees,
2:31:16and all of a sudden, you're, you're in this resistance encampment outside of town, so to
2:31:21speak. So it's that those areas of transition that they create. Yeah. And they've always, that is,
2:31:27again, as an appreciator of the experience design, they've done that with the transitions between the
2:31:33the world's in the parks, at least the better parks, you know, and the better transitions.
2:31:38Like they even do things like as you're going from one to another and there's ambient music
2:31:44playing, the speakers are synced up between the two so that when you're in the part where
2:31:48you'd hear them both, it doesn't sound discordant. They kind of go together. And then all of
2:31:53a sudden it's like it's just like this weird smooth transition where you're like at Disney
2:31:59where you can go from Frontierland to the Liberty Square world, and you're transferring
2:32:07from the Wild West to sort of like, you know, this sort of—it's mostly Philadelphia,
2:32:13but sort of like a cross between Revolutionary War, Philadelphia, and Boston. But you never
2:32:19hear a transition into music. It just sort of works, you know?
2:32:23Yep, exactly. And that that sort of unknown or gentle, unseen transitional thing is what they specialize in. That stuff takes work. I mean, it takes an enormous amount of thought about, you know, where to put speakers and they invented new technology to interleave the sound and all of that stuff. But they're taking basically, you know, 100 years worth of work in this regard, and putting it towards kind of making Star Wars.
2:32:52physical, which is a very, very interesting undertaking because it's such a well-known
2:32:58thing. You know, people have been seeing it for decades now. And so they know what it's
2:33:04supposed to look like and what it's supposed to feel like. That's a lot of responsibility.
2:33:07Pete: So, one of the things that they've done is they made the choice, and you even
2:33:11had quotes from somebody talking about it, where they were like, "Well, what are we
2:33:13gonna do? Are we gonna pick one of the known planets like Tatooine or Hoth or, you know,
2:33:20Cloud City or something like that. Or we just go with something new, and they went with
2:33:25something new. Batuu, is that how you pronounce it?
2:33:29Yeah.
2:33:30B-A-T-U-U. Which I think was the right decision. Just so that they had the freedom to, you
2:33:38know, so that people wouldn't be, "The, the, to continue to, on Tatooine's entrance
2:33:43is actually on the left." You know?
2:33:45Right.
2:33:46That they had the freedom to design everything the way they want, and they're not really
2:33:48Yeah. Withholding to any one thing.
2:33:52Yeah. One of the other things, I think I put this in there, but one of the other things that they
2:33:56mentioned about why they chose to do that is they wanted people to come in on an even footing.
2:34:01Like if you know Star Wars to a casual degree, or just barely from whatever absorbed media you've
2:34:09seen of it, you should still have a good time there. So it shouldn't be like a,
2:34:14you need to know all of the lore of this place before you can enjoy it or understand it. And
2:34:20instead, it should be welcoming to all like they're all we're all starting our adventure together.
2:34:25Like on day one, when everybody walks in, they're all on the same footing. They know just as much
2:34:30about this place and about what's going to happen here as anybody else, you know, and that's that is
2:34:36hard to do with an existing location that you know, somebody who's a more hardcore fan may just
2:34:41know everything there is to know about.
2:34:43Yeah.
2:34:44And that is sort of, I think it's the nature of the beast where Star Wars is by the nature
2:34:50of the franchise as sort of, it's been implied since the very first movie in 1977 that it's
2:34:57a huge galaxy with a gazillion planets and different life forms.
2:35:02And you know, however many of the various aliens we saw in the cantina in the first
2:35:07Star Wars movie, it was implied that, you know, it's the tip of the iceberg in this
2:35:11galaxy.
2:35:12Right.
2:35:13Compare and contrast with Universal, which has the Harry Potter franchise and has two
2:35:20in Florida.
2:35:21They've got the first one they opened at the one park was the Hogwarts area, which
2:35:27in my opinion isn't that great.
2:35:29It's not a great entrance.
2:35:31It's like the Hogwarts itself looks good from certain angles and looks really flat
2:35:36from other angles. And they built it so that it's like a beacon because people are not,
2:35:42I mean, it's like the greatest, I don't know how much Universal spent to get the rights
2:35:45to that, but it was great for them because when you go there, half the kids are wearing
2:35:49like Harry Potter robes and stuff. I mean, that's why people are going there. So they
2:35:53built it, you can see it from anywhere in the park. Because they, you know, they know
2:35:58that that's what people are coming there to see, you know, people come in and they put
2:36:01it like in the back corner. But it's just not a great entrance. But the second one they
2:36:06opened at Universal Studios is Diagon Alley, which has a terrific reveal. It is amazing.
2:36:15You're outside, across from all this other stuff that everybody knows from Universal
2:36:20Studios, and they've just built this lot or this street that looks like current-day
2:36:24London. Very well done. And honestly, there's almost not enough signage. It's almost like
2:36:31we were like, "What the hell is—where's the Harry Potter?" I get it that London is England,
2:36:36and it's like, "Is this it?" And then you go through a little thing that you don't—you're like,
2:36:42"I think we go through here." And you see something—it never seems like there's hundreds
2:36:45of people coming in around. It seems like just six people going, walking through around a corner.
2:36:49You go around a corner, and boom, you're in Diagon Alley. And it's a very specific place from the
2:36:57Harry Potter franchise and just a different way of doing it. It would be like if Star Wars really was
2:37:03Tatooine and the surrounding area around the cantina or something like that.
2:37:09But on the other hand, that would be so limiting because most of the Star Wars worlds, there's
2:37:14really not that much there, right? Most of the planets we have seen in the movies are rather
2:37:19desolate, right? Jared Polin They are. And even if you go Tatooine,
2:37:25Well, that's a frickin' desert with like one tiny little city, you know?
2:37:29Right. And all we really know about it is there's like a bar and there's a place to buy like
2:37:36spaceship parts. Yeah. And not only that, but it's like literally all it's known for is being crap.
2:37:41Right. Like Luke wants to leave. Everybody refers to it as a terrible place. You don't want to go
2:37:48to a place that's known for being awful. Go have lunch at Jabba's Palace.
2:37:52Right, right, exactly. And that's where you end up, you end up having to take really well known places and thematize them, which is sort of anti this modern philosophy that Disney has about these parks is that instead, you should create this thing where you are really building a world and you're not just sort of like taking a theme and slapping it on something.
2:38:13Now, I will say that this project is a marquee project and has all the best people working
2:38:19on it, and this philosophy is very well applied here.
2:38:23There's plenty of examples throughout the parks and projects that diehard Disney followers
2:38:28will be like, "Yeah, but they still chintz out on X, Y, or Z," right?
2:38:32But in terms of this project, no expense spared.
2:38:34They're really going for it, and I think it's no better property to do it with than
2:38:39Star Wars.
2:38:40- Yeah, the other thing too is that they didn't waste time
2:38:45when they, I've always, at least in Florida,
2:38:47at the Hollywood Studios Park,
2:38:50they've had the Star Tours ride for,
2:38:52I think since like the late '80s, at least the early '90s,
2:38:55did a somewhat major upgrade a couple of years back
2:39:00where they didn't really change the ride mechanics
2:39:03but totally upgraded the actual movie
2:39:06that you see in the thing.
2:39:10and much for the better.
2:39:11It's a much better ride.
2:39:13And then they added some Star Wars stuff
2:39:19while they're building this land in an area of the park.
2:39:22It's like right next to the Little Mermaid.
2:39:24So it really, it's not land themed at all.
2:39:29But I think that it's like two extremes.
2:39:32It's like what's the fastest thing we can do
2:39:34to just keep some Star Wars going in this park?
2:39:38And truth be told, the one thing that I think
2:39:41is very different about what they're doing at Disneyland
2:39:46with the Galaxy's Edge in California
2:39:49and what they're doing at the Hollywood Studios in Florida
2:39:52is effectively they shut down half of the park
2:39:56in Hollywood Studios.
2:39:58I think anybody who knows how much of the park
2:40:02has been shut down for the last few years,
2:40:04if you were going there and you only had time
2:40:06go to three of the four parks, the Magic Kingdom, Epcot, Animal Kingdom, and studios. Studios
2:40:12for the last few years should be the last one you went to because it really was half shut down
2:40:17because they closed a whole bunch of the major attractions to have this room to build this,
2:40:23whereas Disneyland is still Disneyland. So they added a whole bunch of Star Wars stuff
2:40:32in Hollywood studios in the meantime in a totally unthemed area sort of like the generic
2:40:38middle of the park area you know and they have like stage shows and every like maybe two hours
2:40:45there's like a a storm trooper trooper parade led by uh captain phasma and they have some state you
2:40:55know again like a cheese ball stage where they actually you know Boba Fett on stage which kind
2:41:01It kind of makes me cringe.
2:41:06But then there is cool stuff, and I can't help but imagine it's all a dry run for this
2:41:11experience, and it's really going to be cool because they've been doing things where they'll
2:41:14just have two stormtroopers or first order stormtroopers walking on parole.
2:41:20Just two guys in real first order stormtrooper costumes walking side by side, and then they'll
2:41:27just come up to people in the park.
2:41:30one time I was holding a beer and the guy just looked at me, pointed at my beer, and
2:41:34he just said, "Watch it." They just come up and interact with people. They come up
2:41:41to little kids and say, "Do you have ID? Show us identification."
2:41:44- Yeah, one of the interactions the troopers will do is that they will abduct you or arrest
2:41:50you, so to speak. Not abduct. They're not abducting any children. But they'll arrest
2:41:56you, especially if you've got a kid. They'll arrest your kid and they'll take him over
2:41:59to the side and then they'll act like they're getting a call from a superior or, you know,
2:42:05whatever they're like, Oh, we're okay. Well, you checked out, you know, you're okay, you
2:42:09can move along or whatever, right. But they do all of that. I mean, you know, the folks
2:42:14that do it well, and that have fun with it, the cast members that do it well, they really
2:42:18use the most, they get the most out of their tools. So the tools that they give them are
2:42:23essentially, you know, switches inside the costume with like, pre pre recorded voices, they don't
2:42:30actually talk. And so that the cast members that utilize those the best and really have fun with
2:42:36it. They do have they get give great guest experiences. You know, my kid got arrested,
2:42:41and she loved it. It was just like a highlight for her, you know, they detained her and took a
2:42:47picture and all this stuff.
2:42:49Well, that's the other thing and like to answer my question from before is why do I John Gruber enjoy it so much part of it
2:42:55I just enjoy the experience I do I just it's a fun place to be you let yourself go you have fun with your kid you
2:42:59Buy some popcorn and stuff
2:43:01But I also there's a part of my brain that is constant
2:43:04It's like going to when I go to see Penn and Teller or some other magician and I'm thinking how the hell did they do?
2:43:07That and I figured out like with the stormtroopers the buttons are on their blasters
2:43:11So they hold the blasters not like they're pointing it at you, but that they hold them
2:43:15you know, to the side, but the buttons are on the blasters and they could, it's just like a little
2:43:19mini keyboard where they can push them and then the pre-recorded voices come out of their helmet.
2:43:23But like you said, the ones who were good at it, it is amazing.
2:43:26Yeah, it almost sounds like they, you know, they recorded it just for you, you know?
2:43:31Right.
2:43:31You know, I think there's a lot of that to come. They didn't show us everything. That was one of
2:43:36the cool things that it's still, it's still going to feel like a surprise to me in a lot of ways,
2:43:41you know, when I go, even though I've talked to people for hours and hours and hours about it.
2:43:45And only, I mean, I published, I published like stinking 7500 words on it. But even then I have
2:43:53pages and pages of notes, right? Because this is just like, I always think of that Austin Powers
2:43:59quote where he's like, "Oh, that's not my bag, baby," right? He holds up the book. This kind of
2:44:04thing is my bag, baby. Well, this is it. You know, it's like, it's a confluence of everything that I,
2:44:10you know, that I find fascinating, you know? And I just, I feel that there's a lot that they're
2:44:16holding back, A, because they want, you know, they still want some surprises and whatnot, but
2:44:20a lot of it is going to come in this, just the genuine immersiveness of this land. So they,
2:44:27they're doing a bunch of things here that they haven't done before. One of them is that cast
2:44:31members have a bunch of different costumes to choose from. So if they are a cast member that's,
2:44:38say, running the smugglers run ride, which is the Millennium Falcon simulation, they can choose their
2:44:44own garments to wear, and then they wear a vest and a hat that identifies them as a sort of crew
2:44:50member of this smuggling organization. And so that that's their uniform, but underneath it, they have
2:44:58a set of a couple of dozen different basic pieces that you might wear as a citizen of Batuu. And the
2:45:06citizens in the village, they get to go in to work every day and they choose from those pieces. So
2:45:11they say, "Hey, my character wears this kind of pant and a vest and a shirt and all this stuff." It
2:45:16gives them some, you know, investment in the character and in the fact that they're going to
2:45:23be role playing. And everybody in the land is going to be role playing. All the cast members
2:45:28are going to be role playing as villagers. So you can ask them what's going on. You can ask them
2:45:33about the resistance and about the the first order and what
2:45:37their feelings are, they might be really circumspect, or they
2:45:39might confide in you, you know that they're a sympathizer or
2:45:42whatever. And then of course, you have the first order in
2:45:45their typical uniforms and and the troopers, and then you have
2:45:49the resistance in the resistance uniform. So it's it's a nice mix
2:45:53of things that is very, very thematic and very in world.
2:45:57You know, there's a lot of companies that have that create
2:46:02euphemisms for employees. I forget, Walmart has something where they call people associates
2:46:09is the word at Walmart. And Disney's always called the staff, the people that work at
2:46:17the parks, cast members. And it sounds corny and honestly, in my opinion, at Walmart, it's
2:46:25a true euphemism. What's the difference between associate and employee? But at Disney, it's
2:46:31been a bit more like performing and there's some that are you know famous
2:46:36you know really are a true performance like the the jungle boat captain where
2:46:41you really are performing for the whole thing right right but it really does
2:46:45matter for worse right but I think it's fascinating that for all of the
2:46:50technological technological advances that are going into this galaxy's edge
2:46:54stuff from everything from materials to the way they make the animatronics
2:47:00and you go into detail about the difference between the old hydraulic system and the new
2:47:04electronic system and how much more lifelike it can be, that just the good old fashioned
2:47:10just way that they can sort of, to borrow a Walt Disney phrase, to plus it is to make
2:47:17the cast members more, even more part of the experience on a personal level.
2:47:23right. Yeah, and I think there, there have, they have a, they, there, there's always been a level
2:47:32of investment in, you know, the sort of experience of Disney that the cast member has, and some
2:47:38people burn out, some people are there for 30, 40 years, right? And I'm really gonna just divorce
2:47:45this discussion, even though, you know, it is interrelated. I'm gonna divorce this discussion
2:47:49from, you know, how Disney treats its cast members and whether or not I can treat them better and all
2:47:53of that, right? Because they're certainly, you know, employees that have a lot of, they
2:47:59give a lot of joy throughout the year and throughout the, have throughout the decades,
2:48:04just through small interactions. And they're sort of empowered in some ways to do that.
2:48:09So they, you know, my daughter has like bought a toy and lost it immediately. They just replaced
2:48:14it for her. They're like, you know, we don't, I don't even need to see a receipt here, you
2:48:17know, she's like, Oh my God, you know, I lost this or, or this broke or was it here? Just
2:48:22take this, you know, and that kind of stuff is obviously corporate policy, right? Let's
2:48:26do it. But it's, it's imbued like the invest this idea in the CMs that they are there to
2:48:35create an experience for people that, you know, yes, it's money, it's time, it's
2:48:41travel. But, you know, you forget like, this may be the only time that this person goes to
2:48:46Disneyland in their entire childhood, and they'll remember forever. Like I wasn't a
2:48:50Disney kid. My parents didn't know about it or like it or even
2:48:55care, you know,
2:48:56It wasn't even on my family's radar. It really was.
2:48:58Exactly. Exactly. I mean, my dad was like, you know, let's go loot
2:49:01a shipwreck. Let's go. Let's go to the beach, you know, and all
2:49:05of that stuff. And that's fine. You know, I thought I was, you
2:49:08know, I'm complaining. It just wasn't a part of my landscape.
2:49:11However, like one time when we were on the travel to somewhere
2:49:14else, they were like, Hey, we got a day. Let's take him
2:49:17Disneyland, right? We've never been, you know, he's never been,
2:49:20let's go. And like, I have a picture of me and I remember it,
2:49:23I still remember the smell of it. I think it was like nine or
2:49:26something. And I have a picture of me on my dad's shoulders with
2:49:30a couple of figurines, like a C3PO and an R2. This is just
2:49:35after Star Tours had opened. And I remember it and it was like,
2:49:40it stuck with me forever, right? And in some ways, cemented my
2:49:44love of, of Star Wars in a way, you know, because it was like
2:49:47Star Wars in real life of its day, right, Star Tours, and then
2:49:51also of the parks that created this feeling in me, my wife, on
2:49:55the other hand, went to Disneyland a lot and loved it
2:49:57and it's sort of a Disney freak. And I did not grow up that way.
2:50:00I grew into, you know, sort of an appreciation for the company
2:50:03and what what he had created what what the organization and
2:50:06created, and its philosophies much, much later. But that may
2:50:11be a revelatory or massively impactful experience for a person.
2:50:17So you're putting a lot on an employee that's not paid a whole lot for what they do and
2:50:24they see a thousand people a day, ten thousand people a day, and they're whatever.
2:50:28But some small interaction that they may give will absolutely make or break.
2:50:33You hear about these things over and over and over again.
2:50:35"Oh, it was the true Disney experience," or "This is why you go," and all of this
2:50:40stuff.
2:50:41that make that.
2:50:42So I'm really, really happy to see them
2:50:44giving them sort of better tools
2:50:47and a greater reason to invest in that
2:50:50sort of interaction with people and all of that.
2:50:53That's fun to see.
2:50:54- Yeah, and I really think it goes toward
2:50:57making the whole area the attraction
2:51:00as opposed to the area as just sort of a central point
2:51:03where you ping pong around to various attractions.
2:51:06I mean, there's very clearly,
2:51:07just look at the map when you go to the park
2:51:09And there's a very difference between the older themed areas
2:51:12and the newer ones where the older ones
2:51:14you'd go to Fantasyland
2:51:16and there's 12 different attractions to ride on.
2:51:19What most people would call rides,
2:51:23what they call attractions
2:51:24and because some of them aren't actually rides.
2:51:27But things you get in line for and wait for a while
2:51:30and then you experience them.
2:51:31Whereas the new ones seem to,
2:51:33and you mentioned it, that the Pandora world of Avatar,
2:51:38which is at Disney's Animal Kingdom in Florida,
2:51:41was sort of, I'm sure James Cameron wouldn't want to hear it,
2:51:44but it's maybe sort of a dry run for the Star Wars stuff,
2:51:48or at least it came first
2:51:49in terms of inventing this whole world.
2:51:51And it seems like they're doing the same things
2:51:53where all of the food when you're there
2:51:55is as though you're in that world
2:51:58and in that camp on Pandora.
2:52:00The beer is literally,
2:52:03there's like a green one and a purple one.
2:52:06And there's one that I like
2:52:07and one that I really don't like.
2:52:09I always forget.
2:52:10- You can never remember which is which.
2:52:11- I can never remember.
2:52:11(laughing)
2:52:13- That's funny.
2:52:13Yeah, exactly.
2:52:14All the food is themed.
2:52:16All of the, and it has a,
2:52:18you know, people may roll their eyes or whatever,
2:52:20but all the food has a backstory.
2:52:21Like this just isn't ribs.
2:52:23It's like, you know, kudu ribs or whatever.
2:52:25It's like the animal that Jar Jar rode.
2:52:28And you know, everybody enjoys killing and eating anything
2:52:30that has to do with Jar Jar.
2:52:31But, you know, I think that there's,
2:52:34there are ways to do that where you honor the fact
2:52:37you're doing a little world building. And yes, it may on any
2:52:40individual level, it may seem silly, but it adds up to
2:52:44something that is greater than some of its parts. I mean, the
2:52:47the merchandise, for instance, barely has any labeling or
2:52:50tagging. They just have just enough of a tag to where they
2:52:54can charge you for it. And you know, it's actually for sale.
2:52:56Outside of that, it's extremely minimal packaging whenever
2:52:59possible. It's all themed to the shops. So like you have a
2:53:02creature shop owner, everything sold in that shop is a creature.
2:53:06and every creature does a little thing like it makes noise or does a you know creature a world
2:53:12or star wars authentic uh noise or activity you know so they're just they're taking it
2:53:19serious they're really just going all the way with it we'll see how much they dial it back
2:53:23you know later or how much they change because these things don't always launch and stay that
2:53:27way as we know but uh it's certainly an interesting bet so one of the things disney's always been good
2:53:33good at is, like I mentioned sight lines before, where from point A, if you're not supposed
2:53:37to see the other world, you don't see it. The other thing they've always been really
2:53:40good at are perspective tricks, forced perspective, where, you know, Main Street USA looks like
2:53:47a two-story town in turn of the last century America, and the buildings really aren't
2:53:54two stories tall. They're like one and a half stories tall, and they do tricks to
2:53:58make that second story look like a full second story from the, you know, three, four, five,
2:54:04six foot height of an adult or a small child. And then you really, really get up close and
2:54:11look at them and you can kind of see that's not as big as I thought. The one thing that
2:54:14is mind blowing about the Pandora in Florida is you get up real close to like those mountains
2:54:19and rock formats. And it's like, what the hell is this? Like, how did the hell did they
2:54:23make something this big. And how does it not tower so high that you see it from everywhere?
2:54:30Like, how in the world is this mostly hidden from the perspective of the other areas of the park,
2:54:35and you can get right under the base of it and you just feel dwarfed by it? Is some of the stuff in
2:54:40the galaxy's edge like that? Yeah, the sense of scale is absolutely there. So the towers,
2:54:47the rock towers themselves are about 135 feet tall at their highest point, which is not small,
2:54:55you know, obviously. But it is the maximum height, essentially, that they can build them due to
2:54:59aviation rules in LA. Similar to the—it's basically the same exact height as the castle,
2:55:06so they can't make it any higher. In addition to that, though, you also have forced perspective
2:55:13at work. So like some of the domes which are layered, you know, back to front with each
2:55:17other, the domes in the back that look like they're far away or in fact, only like a foot
2:55:21behind the other one, but they're smaller, right? So they're still using a lot of their
2:55:25same old tricks because you know, those work. They're they're tricks based on the human
2:55:29mind, right? But they they absolutely are doing things with scale there that they've
2:55:35never done before. Like the buildings are bigger, the space public spaces are larger
2:55:39than any other land. It's 14 acres total. That includes ride space.
2:55:43Trenton Larkin And is that is that backstage? Is that both
2:55:45Florida and California? They're both 14 acres. Okay.
2:55:47Jay Haynes They're both parks are almost exactly identical
2:55:51in terms of layout and size. About the only major difference structurally is that the
2:55:56Florida Park has two entrances. And the new one has three so or the new one, not new one,
2:56:03but the Disneyland that we're in as three. Yeah. But yeah, it's the so walking you walk
2:56:08into the land, we walked in is still very much under construction, right? So with that caveat,
2:56:14the scale is enormous. I mean, it's immense. The cue for the resistance ride is,
2:56:20it's the longest I've ever seen. It's the first one I've ever seen with a bench in it.
2:56:27That's in one of the engineers viewed that as like a, imagineers view that as like a personal win,
2:56:36because he's like, "I'm a dad and I've never had a line with a bench in it, and so I'm really happy
2:56:40I got this line with a bench in it." Because a lot of times when you're the dad, the problem isn't
2:56:46you the dad and it's not you the kid, it's the fact that you're the dad with the kid on your shoulders.
2:56:50Yeah, exactly. Exactly. And come back with scoliosis.
2:56:55Right. That's where the bench can really help everybody.
2:56:57Yeah. And we're all in this together. We're all trying to make it through. But yeah,
2:57:04the sense of scale is there. You're gonna feel it like this is a real living, big city or big
2:57:13village that I'm in. The buildings are full height. They are not scaled down. And it doesn't feel like
2:57:18when you get close, like, "Oh, okay, I see what they did here." It's actually full height. A lot
2:57:25of the park is, or a lot of the land has been built to a way where one of the big problems has
2:57:32always been like seeing what's going on. And so they built the entire thing on a tiered structure,
2:57:38which they've never done with any other land. And there's some other lands that have like a
2:57:42transition, like you're going from here to there, up to down or whatever. But never in this sort of
2:57:47like sloping tiered way, they essentially built it so that you're always looking over people at
2:57:54something. So that there's the performers, for instance, of the cast members, when they come out
2:58:00out from backstage, they have their own entrance from
2:58:02backstage, directly to where they're going to do their thing,
2:58:06like say, repair an X-wing that's, you know, sitting there
2:58:09in need of repairs, or, you know, maintain the Falcon or
2:58:14whatever, if it's chewy, for instance, they can come right in
2:58:17from backstage, they can come into an area where they're
2:58:21elevated, so people can see them from all around. You know, you
2:58:24don't have to, you're not crowding in to see what they're
2:58:26doing or to try and get a glimpse of them. So they built
2:58:30this and it seems all logical now, but none of the other lands have been built this way.
2:58:34And it's always been a big problem for CMs. They got to get from backstage to where they
2:58:39are or where they're performing or whatever they're doing. And there's always that
2:58:43awkward thing where they're walking and people are trying to meet them or stop them
2:58:48or say hi or take a picture and they're like, "Yeah, I got to skedaddle." And then
2:58:53when they're there, you got to wait in line to see them. You can't see them. So there's
2:58:58of interesting things like that that they did, which is a first for any land. But like, I will
2:59:04tell you, the moment you turn the corner and you see the full-size, 100-foot-long Falcon for the
2:59:12first time, I literally, I said bad words. And it wasn't, I don't generally do that much. Like,
2:59:20when I'm taking a press tour, I'm not like, you know, Apple show me the iPhone. I'm like,
2:59:25cool, this is neat, you know? Oh, what does this do? You know, I'm not like,
2:59:28I don't fall over in awe, you know what I mean? But when you see the Falcon for the first time,
2:59:34in real life, it is, it's intense. It's intense. People are going to lose their minds.
2:59:39- You came here in this, you're braver than I thought.
2:59:42- Yeah, exactly. Everything runs through your mind, you know? All the things run through your
2:59:47mind. And it's cool, man. They're going to have it set up to where it like, you know,
2:59:51it'll make engine noises, like they're trying to start it up and repair it. It's going to feel
2:59:55steam and stuff like that. Exactly. Exactly. Do you know what, what are they doing with the Star
3:00:02Tours ride? I can't imagine they're getting rid of it. I mean, in Florida, is that going to be
3:00:06within the confines somehow? Well, no. So they're not moving either one of them. They're staying
3:00:12where they are. That's their current, that's their current statement. Right. So I don't know what
3:00:17their actual plans are. Sometimes they're different than what they say. But what what they said very
3:00:22carefully is there are no plans this time to move them. So, you know, they're staying where they are.
3:00:28They're not moving. They're staying, you know, the Disneyland one is staying in Tomorrowland.
3:00:33So they're just going to keep them there. I mean, you know, what can you do? It's either that or
3:00:39you move them. You know what I mean? And that's not an easy task. So I think they're basically
3:00:46just trying to open this thing and see how it goes. Yeah. One of the things it seems to me,
3:00:53one of the things that bugs me as a Star Wars nerd, let me get a little Star Wars nerdy here
3:00:57and not Disney nerdy, but one of the things that bugs me about the new Star Wars, the updated Star
3:01:01Tours is that you go in that you're in, you know, the basic premise is you're in a, like a commercial
3:01:06sightseeing shuttle. And things go wrong and somehow you're on a mission of racing away
3:01:16from the Empire or the First Order or something. And you hit hyperspace and you go somewhere
3:01:23and you go somewhere that's from one of the movies. And you're getting shot at and
3:01:28all sorts of danger and cool things. And then it's like hyperspace again, and you have
3:01:33another adventure from one of the other movies and then you hyperspace again and you finish
3:01:37up and then it's you know there you go get the hell out you know next next group's coming
3:01:42in and it's cool because they mix it up and it's randomized and so you can go twice and
3:01:48hopefully you'll have the luck that you won't you know you might you might go three times
3:01:52and not see the same segment twice that's right which is really nice but as a star wars
3:01:59nerd it drives me nuts because the whole rides premise is that you're the passengers on a ship having a
3:02:05continuous adventure that is separated by three jumps to hyperspace, but the segments come from
3:02:10Three different trilogies that take place 20 to 30 years
3:02:14Traveling through time and space everything it was like all of a sudden you're on Hoth in the Empire Strikes Back
3:02:21And then you're back
3:02:24you know on the
3:02:26Attack of the clones or something like that and then you wind up in you know
3:02:31You know the new trilogy with Rey and and those characters and it makes no sense at all
3:02:38It gets you know, I get it that you know the original star tours because it was from the 80s
3:02:44They just stuck to the original trilogy and while it was not as good a ride
3:02:48At least it made chronological sense in the Star Wars universe and I get that they they didn't want to pick one trilogy
3:02:55You know for the update because which one would you pick?
3:03:00And they certainly weren't going to not have it updated for the new movies as they come out which weird
3:03:07You know which would so I get why they did it
3:03:11But it bothers me as a Star Wars nerd what I like from your description of batu the whole land is it seems like the land
3:03:17Takes place in a consistent consistently in the new trilogy the latest third trill. That's right
3:03:24timeline. Yes, it's not it's not around us at a specific movie or during a specific movie is a in
3:03:31that era, right? That's the way they refer to it. So there, I don't believe they're gonna know of
3:03:36things going on, you know, in that in the movie timeline. And Batuu has already been integrated,
3:03:43as Disney does, in many of its books, and it's mentioned in the movie already, and all of that
3:03:50stuff, you know? But it is going to be a part of the universe, and you're going to be in this place
3:03:57while the movie trilogy era is happening, but not at a specific time.
3:04:02Pete: No, but I think that's the right way to do it, right? I think that putting it in that era-
3:04:07Jared, off-screen Just specific enough, right?
3:04:08Pete Yeah.
3:04:09Jared Yeah, you're within a year or two that, you know,
3:04:12the span of the movie happens.
3:04:14Pete Yeah, and I think it's the right move, you know,
3:04:17I'm of course in the most nostalgic for the original trilogy
3:04:20But I feel like the kids of today are going to be the most excited about the latest trilogy
3:04:25And so it makes sense to put it there all right
3:04:27Let me get really Star Wars nerdy on you here and one of the characters that's an animatronic is Hondo, Onaka
3:04:32Now I remember him because I watched the animated Clone Wars series
3:04:36And he was a major recurring character, and it sounds like he's a really cool animatronic
3:04:41But from your article Hondo is now the proprietor of the Onaka transport solutions and has been loaned the Millennium Falcon
3:04:49By Chewy for some quote deliveries. All right, let me just say there is no
3:04:54Way Chewbacca is loaning the Millennium Falcon to anybody let alone to Hondo and NACA. I
3:05:02Got a real problem. I got a real problem with that
3:05:06Why isn't Chewie flying the thing and then the next character you talk about is?
3:05:11One of my all-time favorite little characters who who in the world knows why I knew his name because he's got like two lines
3:05:17but mean numb who uh-huh
3:05:19Most people will remember was Lando's co-pilot for the Falcon during the climactic battle scene in the return of the Jedi
3:05:27Now neen numb is on the other ride though. He's on the resistance attraction, right?
3:05:34Right. Well, they should have put mean numb as the guy who flies the Falcon because he
3:05:38Chewbacca maybe would loan it to Neline, you know, let me know
3:05:44right
3:05:46Well, there is a book that explains
3:05:49explains why
3:05:52Why he has they did give it to us it's actually a children's book and I gave it to my daughter but
3:05:59it explains why they
3:06:03This is happening, you know why he has lint in the focus
3:06:06So there is some sort of in-universe explanation, but that said I completely understand where you're coming from. It's like wait
3:06:12The animatronic is super stellar though. It's it's very very very smooth. I think that you know, it's as far as
3:06:23levels of
3:06:27Complexity the the shaman is still above it
3:06:30You know in terms of how much it can do and that's the shaman is the shaman is is a pandora and a native pandoran
3:06:38on the
3:06:39Navi River ride over in Pandora
3:06:41Exactly. Yeah, and that Navi shaman is
3:06:44incredible animatronic absolutely incredible
3:06:47We had the head a couple years ago at one of our robotics events just the head and they de-skinned it for us
3:06:53It was super super cool to watch up close. Well, but even when you're watching the ride, it's amazing
3:06:58Let me say this I've been on the ride and let me take the devil's advocate position and say I totally appreciate and but part of
3:07:05This is because I read your article and knew it going in the face and head is amazing
3:07:11But the whole animatronic as a whole is a bit static
3:07:16I mean, I guess that's a shaman isn't supposed to move but it writes
3:07:20It makes sense that almost all of the the amazing, you know, look how amazing this is is all in the face
3:07:27Mm-hmm. And the other thing I'll say well, let me ask you this the two ruts are the two attractions
3:07:32There's the resistance ride and then there's the Falcon ride
3:07:35It sounds from to me from your description that neither one of them is really the a ride and the B ride
3:07:41They both seem like a rides
3:07:44Yeah, they would both be considered an e-ticket in the old parlance, right?
3:07:50they absolutely were double e ticket if if that existed right because they're they're absolutely a
3:07:56a high level of world building, high level of theming,
3:08:01intense amount of work that went into them.
3:08:05However, the Rise of the Resistance ride
3:08:08is significantly bigger in terms of the size,
3:08:13length, complexity, all of that.
3:08:17It's the first ride that Disney has done of its kind,
3:08:20I believe, and the Falcon ride is essentially like,
3:08:23what if we built Star Wars with Star Tours with today's technology and made it interactive, which
3:08:29is not a small feat, you know, but it's it's also known it's a known quantity, you know, whereas the
3:08:36Rise of the Resistance is a new thing. There is guest interaction by cast members during the ride
3:08:41there is you're on foot you're you're on a vehicle that quote unquote, flies, then you're on a
3:08:49Riding vehicle like you're in multiple venues death star travel from place to place our hangar
3:08:56Not a Death Star hangar, but a Star Destroyer hangar Star Destroyer hangar
3:09:01Yeah, and so, you know, you're in a hangar you're you're flying on a resistance vehicle. You're in a resistance base
3:09:07You're in a in a cell like a detention cell, you know, you move from place to place
3:09:12This none of this happens, you know in on a ride, right?
3:09:16So it is a it is an experience in a way that is different
3:09:19So I don't think that either one of them necessarily are you know? Oh, this is the a ticket is the B ticket
3:09:25They're both gonna be
3:09:27Incredibly popular and I think just as popular different people who want different things
3:09:32Like if your dream has always been to fly the Falcon, I mean, there's no substitute
3:09:35You know, you can't see this on an audio podcast, but I just raised my hand
3:09:43- I just raised my hand and my eyes are watering up
3:09:45a little bit.
3:09:46- Right, and that sense of,
3:09:48(sighs)
3:09:50- Right, if the less,
3:09:52- You're gonna be, yeah,
3:09:53- If the less expansive of the two rides
3:09:56is the one where you fly the Millennium Falcon,
3:09:58that's the song.
3:09:59- Right, exactly.
3:10:01That's the like, oh cool, we'll do that too,
3:10:04then yeah, you're in good shape.
3:10:06- So the difference between Pandora,
3:10:08have you ever been there?
3:10:09Have you ever been to the Florida parks?
3:10:11- You know, no, uh-uh.
3:10:12- No, so you've never been to the Florida ones
3:10:13and I've never been to California.
3:10:15- Exactly. - So we go every year.
3:10:17So I've been to the Pandora a couple times
3:10:20and the two, they do this, it's the same sort of formula.
3:10:24It's an all-encompassing world, surprisingly big,
3:10:26all these rocks and very immersive,
3:10:28all the food, all the merchandise.
3:10:30There's all sorts of stuff when you're not in a ride
3:10:34that's really technically impressive.
3:10:35One of the things in the Pandora world that they have
3:10:38is you know how in that Pandora universe,
3:10:40the humans have these big robots that they ride in, you know, like, they have one, they
3:10:50have a real one. I mean, like that there's a real guy in and it walks around. And then
3:10:54he takes, you know, he'll stop and he'll take questions from kids about who'll ask, you
3:10:58know, all in universe, like, you know, how high can you jump? And he's like, well, this,
3:11:03this, this model, the one I'm in is actually set to a low power mode for the safety because
3:11:07we know there's a bunch of you around here, but if we turned it on, I could jump about
3:11:12five feet in the air.
3:11:13Yeah, gotcha.
3:11:14You know, and it's super, but the cool thing about that sort of thing is they're making
3:11:20it there's so much more fun that you can have that you never knew you were going to have
3:11:24that you're not waiting in line for it. You're just there and all of a sudden this guy in
3:11:28a robot suit comes out, you know. But the flight of passage attraction, they have two,
3:11:34So part of the formula to two attractions, big land, the flight of passage ride is the
3:11:39greatest theme park attraction I've ever been on in my life. It is. And my wife and
3:11:45son were in unanimous agreement. It is mind-blowingly immersive. I almost don't even want to say
3:11:51anything on the show other than it really does feel like you're flying around Pandora.
3:11:56is and the scope is amazing. The scale, it's just incredible. The Navi River Passage is
3:12:05like a boat ride. It's like you're on a really nice version of It's a Small World.
3:12:19It is not, it is very clear difference between the two, which one is the bigger attraction,
3:12:26if you can only do one, which one you should do. Whereas it seems like in Star Wars, it's,
3:12:30it's a lot closer call. Yeah. I mean, I think that maybe I don't want to, I didn't, I don't have any
3:12:37inside info on this, but I think maybe they know that, right? Like maybe they, they understand that
3:12:41the boat ride is awesome, but if you're going to do Star Wars and you're going to promise this
3:12:46interactive, you know, kind of immersive world that has to extend to the rides too. And it really,
3:12:53from I wasn't able to ride the completed ride because it's literally not completed. But from
3:12:57what we were able to see of the experience that is true of this it is not you don't sit passively
3:13:05on a boat or on a car and let it you know, rush over through the right yeah, you just you just
3:13:11you're not sitting there just watching a bunch of animatronics do their thing. You know, that's not
3:13:16what this is about. It's, you know, multiple characters you're interacting with multiple
3:13:22experiences that you get to that you get to take part in, you feel like you are part of the
3:13:28universe, you're, you know, the, the adventures that you're having are in universe and sort of,
3:13:33you know, feel like they could be in the movie, you know, that kind of thing. And they're using
3:13:39a bunch of different tech to get it done. So that's not, this isn't the same deal as that.
3:13:44It's not like, hey, we're taking an existing ride thing, we're putting a new theme on it. And we're
3:13:49we're putting some cool animatronics in front of you. It's not that.
3:13:52So the bay and the basic description of the Falcon ride seems so cool. It's like you're in the real
3:13:56Falcon. It's the room, you know, there's the chessboard. It's all to scale. It's like you're
3:14:00really there. And then in groups of six, they load you in and you're in the Millennium Falcon cockpit,
3:14:06and then everybody gets roles. Like there's two pilots and two gunners and two, I forget what
3:14:11else there were. But you all have things to do. And it actually really does interact with the
3:14:18the result of what you get.
3:14:21Like you have to push buttons at the right time
3:14:24and you can get, like, you know, I guess that no matter
3:14:27what, like the Millennium Falcon isn't exploding.
3:14:30- Yeah, look, your ride, they were very explicit
3:14:34in that your ride would always complete.
3:14:36So you're always gonna be, the mission,
3:14:38the Falcon's mission will always be successful,
3:14:40I think is the phrase that they used, right?
3:14:42They don't want anybody getting, you know,
3:14:43waiting hours to get this ride.
3:14:45Some guy doesn't do his piloting job out the gate
3:14:48you crash immediately and you have to get off.
3:14:50And I know it's laughable for the next 10, 15, probably 20 years that there's going to
3:14:56be an empty seat.
3:14:58But you know, right, 30 years from now, when God Star Wars galaxy edge is no longer the,
3:15:04you know, the main attraction, and it's the end of the night, and you get in and there's
3:15:07only three of you and there is nobody in the gunner's seats, you're not going to get you
3:15:11know, you're not going to get blown up.
3:15:12That's right.
3:15:13That's right.
3:15:14said is instead you have two pilots, two engineers, two gunners. And so each person has a role.
3:15:21So if the pilot does their thing at the right time, you execute a maneuver and avoid a TIE
3:15:26fighter's fire, great. If you don't do it in time and you get hit, now the engineer
3:15:32has work to do, right? And so they can put out the fire that was caused by the TIE fighter
3:15:38blast
3:15:39By the blaster blast they can
3:15:41You know your your gunner can shoot it down if he shoots it down late
3:15:46Maybe you get you know, it's a trap and then we're working together
3:15:48So they come through battered but you're gonna get through so there's a ride at Epcot called mission space and the basic idea
3:15:55is that you're on like a
3:15:57Experimental mission to Mars and there's four of you in each little thing
3:16:00And there's like a sim. It's a similar, you know, obviously a similar thinking and you know
3:16:06one of you is the pilot, one's the mission commander, one's the engineer, and one is
3:16:09navigator or something. And there's points in it where you're supposed to flip switches and stuff.
3:16:16And much like you said about the Falcon stuff, you've got all these switches to flip and you
3:16:20push buttons and they beep and they bloop and they all feel like real NASA quality switches.
3:16:25And they must be because they've been there for 10 or 15 years at this point and they're all still
3:16:30in working order. They're all like serious industrial grade switches. But it's cool because
3:16:35you can start playing with them before the ride starts. Like you, you, you load in, you put your
3:16:39seatbelt on and lower your, your harness. And then you can sit there and like bleep and bloop and
3:16:45flip all these switches. But then there's a certain part in the mission where you're supposed
3:16:47to do stuff. Well, if you don't do it, not one thing changes. Like you can do everything wrong.
3:16:54You like, absolutely nothing changes. It makes you feel like something changes. And maybe if you're
3:17:00a young enough kid and you're not really paying attention, you might think you did something,
3:17:04but having been on it numerous times, there is no, not one iota changes of what you actually see on
3:17:12the screen. So it's not very empowering. No, but it makes sense because it seems like that's an
3:17:18easier way to make a ride where you're loading hundreds of people in an hour. Whereas to have
3:17:23it actually be interactive is seems like a genuine technical breakthrough.
3:17:29Yeah, it is. I mean, each cockpit of which there are multiple, obviously, to get,
3:17:37you know, otherwise you'd be there all day. Six people at a time.
3:17:41Yeah, six people at a time. 75 people can get on this today out of 10,000.
3:17:46I love that you asked how many cockpits they have and they wouldn't answer.
3:17:52That's exactly-
3:17:52No, they wouldn't tell me.
3:17:54That's exactly the way that Disney is like Apple, right?
3:17:58exactly. Like if I'm like, Oh, cool. Yeah. How many how many
3:18:01transistors and all like, does that really matter? But yeah,
3:18:06the the multiple cockpits basically enable them to load
3:18:11multiple people. But each of those cockpits has to be a
3:18:14completely independent projection system that reacts in
3:18:16real time. So it's rendering everything in real time, as you
3:18:20make your decisions. So each one has to have its own rendering
3:18:23pipeline and basically render farm attached to it that can make it happen.
3:18:29I can't wait. I'll be flying the Falcon. I know I'm going to wind up stuck being the
3:18:35engineer. How long do you think the wait's going to be for pilot?
3:18:38I don't know. Did they?
3:18:40You can wait for the front, right? They didn't say. They didn't say, but that's good. Okay,
3:18:46stand over here and wait with these other 10,000 people that want to be the pilot.
3:18:49And sit in the front. Do you think they'll make them sit differently? A lot of times at Disney,
3:18:52don't really let you wait for the front like that. Like they just kind of, I don't know.
3:18:57I don't know. I think most of the coasters, they let you wait for your spot, but I don't know. Yeah.
3:19:02It's going to be, that's going to be a Roshan Boeing, I think, amongst your pilot group,
3:19:07your flight group. If you go, go in groups of six, because then you, you guys can come to a
3:19:13gentle person's agreement. All right. That is fantastic. I can't wait to see this myself,
3:19:20although I won't be able to see it this summer because in Florida it won't open till September
3:19:25or something but I'm still looking forward to it and I absolutely loved your article and honestly
3:19:30came away from your 6,000 word well illustrated piece with so many questions.
3:19:34Yeah. I thank you as always for your time. You are @panzer, P-A-N-Z-E-R on the Twitters
3:19:46and everybody can read your fine work and the work of your staff at a tech
3:19:51crunch dot com. Anything else you want to, you want to mention?
3:19:54No, I think I'm good. All right. May the force be with you. Appreciate you.
3:19:58I really appreciate you as well.