Podcast Search

The Talk Show

242: ‘The Butts Incident’ With John Moltz

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00What a week. I tell you, I upgraded to Mojave. No, really? Oh, we'll have to get to that. Oh my

0:00:08god. So what do we got? We got big news, Jon Moltz. We got we got FaceTime. Yeah, big FaceTime bug.

0:00:14We got a big Facebook scandal. Couple Facebook scandal. All the face stuff. We got Apple quarterly

0:00:19results. I say we go with Facebook first. Okay. That sounds like fun. So as we record,

0:00:27we're recording on Wednesday, January 30. It's still breaking on this story. We don't quite know

0:00:32how it's going to end up. But what we know is that yesterday TechCrunch ace reporter Josh Constein

0:00:37broke a big story that Facebook got caught running some kind of spyware effectively like it was opt

0:00:47in. Hey, pay is it is it spyware if they're paying paying you for to spy on you? I guess it still is.

0:00:54right? All right, let me try to summarize the story. So yeah, years ago, Facebook,

0:00:57beginning years ago, Facebook bought a VPN app called Obama. And this is a free VPN that was

0:01:05supposedly advertised as, you know, protect your traffic. And a VPN can be totally legitimate way

0:01:11to protect your network connection so that you know, you connect via VPN, and then you

0:01:16could go to a public Wi Fi and all of your traffic goes over the secure SSH tunnel to the VPN server.

0:01:23And so anybody on the local public Wi-Fi can't, you know, spy on your traffic. All they see is this

0:01:30encrypted connection. All sorts of companies, of course, require the use of a VPN to connect to

0:01:37company, you know, sensitive company data. And consumers can use a VPN to do things like

0:01:42masquerade their location. Maybe you could use a VPN to get. If you're outside the US,

0:01:48Maybe you can get us only content or something like that

0:01:51But anyway Facebook bought them not out of the goodness of their heart shockingly

0:01:56But because they ever done anything kind of the goodness of their heart the thing is when you connect via a VPN

0:02:03You you're safe from the the network your local network

0:02:06But you you are you're you're handing everything all of the everything funnels through the VPN and and whoever owns the VPN knows everything

0:02:15Right you it's you might as well just let somebody sit down at your computer, you know

0:02:19you have to trust them as much as the VPN as much as you would trust somebody sitting in front of your computer and

0:02:24Facebook use this of on Oh was popular enough. Obviously everybody didn't use it

0:02:30It's not like it was something that everybody who uses Facebook was secretly running behind the scenes. You had to you know, download of on oh and

0:02:36You know run it but enough people were running it that Facebook could use the data

0:02:41they were collecting and they were collecting data on everything everybody who installed it did every app they launched every network connection

0:02:48what apps they used for how long and

0:02:50They used it to to make decisions like buying WhatsApp for 19 billion dollars because that data they had showed

0:02:57Hey, this is popular and getting more popular. We should buy it

0:03:00And in September Apple put the kibosh on it when it came to light just how much they were collecting and you know

0:03:08I I think it's fair to say it was

0:03:10being billed under false advertising by declaring this was for privacy and then using it to

0:03:16spy on

0:03:18Violated terms of the the App Store. Yes. It wasn't simply arbitrary or you know, we don't like, you know

0:03:25We didn't think of this it it really was

0:03:27Violating the terms of the App Store

0:03:30Immediately we now know as of yesterday immediately thereafter Facebook started doing something very similar

0:03:35through a privately distributed beta that was signed with their enterprise certificate.

0:03:42Now that's something, for example, so like a big company like IBM or any company really

0:03:46can have an enterprise certificate and use that to distribute apps to employees that

0:03:53don't go through the app store.

0:03:54So it could be like an app that's just for internal use in your company that you want

0:03:58on iPhones or it could be for testing betas of things that, a public app that will go

0:04:04through the App Store, but while it's in development, your employees can use it without

0:04:08going through the App Store. TestFlight, which a lot of people probably know as Apple's

0:04:14publicly facing beta distribution thing, is sort of one way to do that. But an enterprise,

0:04:21a company like Facebook, doesn't have to go through TestFlight to do that. So it ends

0:04:26up that they were distributing an app.

0:04:29Well, number one, Apple's terms for the enterprise specifically say that this is for the use

0:04:36of your employees for testing apps and using internal apps.

0:04:42Facebook was advertising, trying to get people to sign up for this program.

0:04:46They were paying them $20 a month.

0:04:48And then, you know, and then they, for some reason, wanted a screenshot of your recent

0:04:53Amazon purchases.

0:04:54Isn't that out of left field?

0:04:57I mean, I don't even like, oh man. Like that's the part where you got to think like I can

0:05:07see and what am I doing? Yeah. And they were, they were asking for, for kids down to 1313

0:05:13to 17 year olds. I guess they were, I don't know how well they were enforcing it, you

0:05:17know, that they were supposedly for 13 to 17 year olds requiring parental permission.

0:05:22Yeah, that's it. I couldn't, didn't get a good answer on that because it seemed like

0:05:26like, in some cases, it was just like, it was like a checkbox, like, does your parent

0:05:30agree to this check? Right? Like, you know, any kid, any kid could do that. Right? Like,

0:05:35yeah, I, it's unclear to me how enforced that was. Is it sort of like, you know, like, we

0:05:41I've got it set up so that when Jonas gets by a buys an app, you know, we have a family

0:05:47account and me or Amy has to authorize it. Is it like that where the parent, you know,

0:05:51there's like a connection within Facebook didn't seem like it and be in these things.

0:05:55don't with provisioning profiles that any anybody can install it from a website. You don't have to

0:06:03write. There's no there's no restriction in parental controls that controls that.

0:06:08Right. And I have found that I found that out the hard way. Believe me.

0:06:11But there's a whole bunch and Facebook isn't the only one that like issues these things to

0:06:18widely and for free on the Internet. There's a whole bunch of other instances where this happens.

0:06:23and like some like there's a there's a Minecraft thing that helps you like you can install like one

0:06:29of the knocks against the iOS version of Minecraft is that it doesn't let you install mods like like

0:06:34on Android you can actually install mods because you know the apps can interact with each other

0:06:39more and this supposedly this I have not tried it but this profile will let you do that on iOS

0:06:46and so obviously Hank you know downloaded that without thinking um and it's you know and it's

0:06:51like the signature on it. I wish I had his device in front of me, but it's something like the

0:06:55Shenzhen industrial.

0:06:58[laughter]

0:06:59Tom: So that's technically against the App Store rules, right?

0:07:04Ben, off screen Yeah, right.

0:07:05Tom; Yeah. I wonder how widely this is being abused. Just before we started recording,

0:07:09somebody on Twitter sent me a DM that showed that Google seemingly has a very similar app.

0:07:18Ben, off screen Right.

0:07:20Yeah, so this the screen wise meter app on an iOS device

0:07:24It does not seem this seems like it might be a similar scandal by the time

0:07:30This is what I mean by that. We're recording on Wednesday held by tomorrow that who knows maybe Google's gonna be in hot water

0:07:36But anyway, they were paying paying people $20 kids even

0:07:41Isn't other insult for me and you it was they only wanted people aged 13 to 35

0:07:46we're not even close where we don't care. Right. It's like, it's like as you age and

0:07:57you fill out forms, you know, and it's like, what age group are you in? Yeah. And it's

0:08:01like, it never for whatever reason, it never goes by the decade. It's like, are you in

0:08:06your 20s? Are you in your 30s? Because you know, I mean, you roll over, you hit 40 or

0:08:10you hit 50. And you know, hit those things. And it always, you know, whether you're particularly

0:08:15sensitive to that or not. I'm not. I don't like get depressed if I when I hit a landmark birthday,

0:08:20but you know, even if you're like me, and you're a bit cynical and jaded and except the warm and

0:08:26breath of death, that's it's still you note it, right? And when other people get, you know,

0:08:33maybe you really get upset when they hit hit some of these marks, but they don't ask you that. It's

0:08:36always weird, weird ranges, you know, like, are you different? Yeah, they vary by whoever's asking

0:08:42the question. Yeah, you 18 to 24, 25 to 33. You know, the thing that bugs me, though,

0:08:49is there's usually like a 55 and up or something. I am quickly approaching that like, right.

0:08:55And you just know that when you click that one, it just goes right in a circular file. Right?

0:09:00Yeah, right. Right to dev null. Thanks. Thanks for reading. Don't care. Well, anyway, we're not even

0:09:07close to being in a range of where Facebook… Facebook doesn't even want to spy on us.

0:09:11Anyway, $13 to $35. They're paying them 20 bucks a month.

0:09:17AARON: The Facebook one, isn't it? The Google one, you get points toward the Google Play Store

0:09:22or something like that? Seems worse almost. Although, if they're going for kids, that's

0:09:29probably what the kids want anyway. But…

0:09:30Yeah, I wonder

0:09:32But they shouldn't be going for kids

0:09:35You would hope not yeah, but anyway, they called it a Facebook research app, although the the webpage

0:09:42I mean there was a way that if you paid attention as you were clicking through that you could see this was going to Facebook

0:09:47but they kind of disguised it like the initial webpage where you'd sign up was

0:09:51Administered through beta testing services applause beta bound and you test

0:09:59And it did seem that they were sort of the shins in industrial complex, right?

0:10:03Right. It wasn't like they've registered a fake name or something. There was you know, eventually you could see that it was

0:10:09Facebook but it didn't seem like they were upfront about it. I

0:10:13Can see I worry I actually even mentioned to my son I brought this up to Jonas yesterday

0:10:20I could see that if if it seemed like you were gonna get 20 bucks a month

0:10:24I can I could see him signing up for this. Oh, yeah

0:10:28Like I it's like the old what would you go? Yeah, I mean I need to go check Hank's device and make sure that's not on

0:10:34There because I would not be surprised at all. It is it's like the old what would you do for a Klondike bar?

0:10:39Who do I have to kill

0:10:43One of my all-time favorite tweets from the old days when we all we used to do like circa

0:10:482007 was just cracked one-liners on Twitter is the one time I don't know how many and

0:10:53It was back in the old favorite favorite favorite whatever favored whatever it was called. Yeah, I tweeted

0:11:01You don't want to know what I would do for a Klondike bar

0:11:04But I just thought it was a funny tweet back in the day when we did that anyway

0:11:11I don't want to know what my son would do for $20 a month

0:11:13What would you install for $20 a month? Yeah, it's hard to it's a hard thing to explain to a kid

0:11:21Yeah, why this is important. Yeah

0:11:24And I don't think Hank fully gets it yet. But I mean that's serious money. I mean, what is it?

0:11:31$480 a year am I doing the math, right? Yeah ten times. No ten times. No

0:11:36280 no 240 240 I doubled it before

0:11:39Math majors clearly but 240 bucks a year just to sign up and let Facebook see what you're doing on your phone tells you how how

0:11:48Valuable that information is to Facebook

0:11:51right, yeah, I

0:11:53Mean they probably wouldn't pay everybody, you know, they're not gonna what do they have like 1.7 billion users?

0:12:00They're not gonna pay 20 billion dollars a month to get it on everybody

0:12:04But you know to get you know, however many I'd be fascinated to know how many people they got to sign up for this

0:12:09By the way, it's too bad the jigs up I would sign up and then just like screw around with it. I

0:12:13Got an iOS device lying around here that I'm not using

0:12:17Anyway, so the story broke yesterday. It's very clearly against the terms of the developer

0:12:27enterprise certificate, which very clearly says this is for your employees. And Facebook

0:12:34somehow initially, this is this is what gets me is TechCrunch does the you know, the responsible

0:12:40thing there. They're straight and narrow reporting operation. So they contacted fate, you know,

0:12:46They figured all this out.

0:12:47They obviously caught them red-handed,

0:12:49but then they contacted Facebook for comment.

0:12:51And comment-- Facebook said that what they were doing

0:12:54doesn't violate Apple's enterprise certificate policy.

0:12:59Nothing to see.

0:13:00Move along.

0:13:02But the actual words that Apple uses

0:13:07are "distribute provisioning profiles only

0:13:10to your employees and only in conjunction

0:13:14with your internal use applications for the purpose of developing and testing."

0:13:18Like that's a direct quote. It really does. It's not just that they broke the rules flagrantly

0:13:27and that this is a sketchy thing to even want to do, right? Like the idea that you would even

0:13:32have a meeting to say, "Well, how can we put something on a couple of thousand people's

0:13:37phones, including especially teenagers, and figure out what the hell they're doing?"

0:13:41like that's a weird you're you're already at a weird place where you're even thinking about it

0:13:46yeah and it's not just that they did it but it's that that to me that the the cherry on the top

0:13:52is their initial statement was well this isn't even against the rules

0:13:57what could be wrong what could be wrong with this right certainly nothing we were just talking

0:14:05we were reminiscing because jonas had a birthday recently and you know it brings up you know

0:14:10remember when, remember when, when Jonas was little. And Jonas had a thing, it was so funny,

0:14:16and I think it's genetic, and he got it from me, was if we caught him doing something he wasn't

0:14:21supposed to do, like trying to get a cookie, which literally had happened. I know it's a cliche,

0:14:28kids stealing cookies from the cookie jar, but we caught him trying to get a numino when he hadn't

0:14:33asked if he could have a numino. And Amy would say, or Amy or me would say, "What are you doing?"

0:14:39he would he would say don't look at me at the time it was a little angering and in hindsight

0:14:51it's adorable yeah right don't look at me don't look at me

0:14:54is he i think he was trying to do like a force you know like yeah an obi-wan thing right yeah

0:15:01don't look at the droids these aren't the droids you're looking for

0:15:05[laughter]

0:15:10Facebook's reaction seems like the corporate equivalent of that. This isn't against the rules.

0:15:16It does seem like they tried to pull a Jedi mind track.

0:15:18God. And you do get the sense, though, that they just don't have any clue that what

0:15:25they do is wrong.

0:15:27Well, no, I think they do know it's wrong. I think they do know it's wrong, because I really do. I

0:15:33I honestly think that, I'm not saying,

0:15:36and I'm sure that there are Facebook,

0:15:38there's so many gazillion Facebook employees,

0:15:40I'm sure there's some who listen to the show.

0:15:42And so I'm not trying to say everybody who works at Facebook

0:15:45is a bad person.

0:15:46But there are parts of the company,

0:15:52you kind of have to, what's the old quote,

0:15:55"Hard to make a man understand something

0:15:58"when his paycheck depends on not understanding it."

0:16:01- Right.

0:16:02you know, and there are people there who are clearly either bad people or

0:16:07Just so a a moral if not immoral because one of the other stories that's that's come out in the last week was that

0:16:17That they had paid pay to play games

0:16:21where they were

0:16:24knowingly taking money from children know right who their own investigation showed that the kids

0:16:31Would be very likely to think that they were spending

0:16:34Virtual in-game currency right because that's a huge thing like there's a ton of games where you know

0:16:40You run around and collect, you know coins or whatever

0:16:42Yeah, and it's and then you can cash the points or the coins in for weapons or upgrades or second chances, whatever

0:16:50But it turned out that they were spending their parents money because it was like the parents were like here

0:16:54You know play this Facebook game play this game and they and there was no like unlike iOS or even Android

0:17:00There was no mechanism for a parental approval. It's like you put your credit card in and anything that gets bought

0:17:06Right immediately gets rung up, right?

0:17:09And I I'm not saying you know, I I know that there have been cases where kids have run up bills on iOS, too

0:17:15but you you've got to

0:17:18You know and I guess the most likely way would be handing your phone over to a kid

0:17:24But even then it still prompts for like your you know your your fingerprint. Yeah face. It's gotten better

0:17:30I mean I think in the early days it was I

0:17:32People were still trying to understand it on iOS and also I think Apple was still struggling to make the system work a little bit

0:17:38Better yeah, I mean I kiss yeah, I mean Hank Hank did exactly that he got he like with the iPad he rang up like

0:17:47$25 bill at one point and you know and they were

0:17:50They were very good about just like going. Oh, yeah. Okay and refunding it

0:17:55Right, very good about refunding it. Whereas Facebook's thing this story

0:18:00Suggested is that they were very resistant to refunding it. Yeah, then they had a name for the kids. They were whales. Yeah, they well the

0:18:08Big spender it's exactly which is exactly the terminology from the casino industry the casino

0:18:15Angry Birds of all games. And here's a quote, this is a story that I linked a week or so ago

0:18:24from Reveal. In nearly all cases, the parents knew their child was playing Angry Birds,

0:18:29but didn't think the child would be allowed to buy anything without their password or authorization

0:18:34first. Surprise! That's actually a reasonable assumption, right? That you'd, you know,

0:18:40well, my kid isn't gonna be able to buy anything unless I authorize it. Well, guess what? You just

0:18:44click a button and you bought something. This lawsuit has uncovered actual internal documentation

0:18:56from Facebook. So it's not just speculation. These are actual communications within the

0:19:01company. Truly outrageous. I don't see how you can debate that these are bad people.

0:19:08Again, I'm not saying everybody on Facebook is bad, but there are clearly bad people in

0:19:12decision making positions. Yeah. Yeah. And some of the comment

0:19:17the back and forth that they quoted was like, you know, like,

0:19:20are we refunding this? Like, no, lol. Okay. Yeah, yeah. Here's,

0:19:23here's the I'm gonna read the transcript. Here's the

0:19:25transcript between two employees. Jillian is is the one

0:19:29investigating a refund request. And Michael, I guess is her

0:19:33supervisor Jillian. Would you refund this whale ticket user is

0:19:36disputing all charges? Michael, what's what's the user's total

0:19:41lifetime spend. This sounds a lot like being in a casino. Jillian, it's $6,545.

0:19:49But the card was just added on September 2. They are disputing all of it, I believe.

0:19:54That user looks underage as well. Well, maybe not under 13. Michael, is the user

0:20:01writing in a parent or is this user a 13-ish year old? Jillian, it's a 13-ish

0:20:08year old says it's 15 looks a bit younger she not it's lol Michael I wouldn't refund

0:20:18I wouldn't refund Julian oh that's fine cool agreed just double checking $6,500 oh my god

0:20:27and the worst part is that's not even Facebook's primary business model right making money

0:20:31from games I mean I'm sure it adds up I mean but it's mostly advertising the idea that

0:20:37they would be, you know, I mean, these are people who knew it was a kid. I mean, it had

0:20:41to be a mistake. How do you not just say, you know, again, you know, small mom and pop

0:20:48business, a $6,500 refund is something but when it's virtual, you know, it's not like

0:20:52they gave the kid $6,500 worth of goods. You know what I mean? Yeah. You know what I mean?

0:20:57Some kid goes on Amazon walk away with something actually physical. Yeah, right. Some kid goes

0:21:02on Amazon and buys a $6,500 gaming PC. Again, something that Hank, I bought him a book one

0:21:11time when he was little, and this was a long time ago, and on a computer and I stupidly did it on

0:21:17his computer and left the credit card in there. What does it matter with you? I don't know.

0:21:22And so he's on Amazon and he's just like, he's looking up wetsuits. He bought a thousand dollars

0:21:30worth of wetsuits. I mean, unfortunately, we were able to return all of them.

0:21:35The funniest part, too, is that you—

0:21:38It was just like, "Oh, I didn't—" I was just clicking buttons. I didn't know what I was doing.

0:21:44The funniest part is that you do a parenting podcast.

0:21:46Well, I've always said that it's a cautionary tale. I don't claim to have any good advice.

0:21:57I mean, it's just, it could not be more outrageous, right?

0:22:01I mean, there's no physical goods.

0:22:02It's not like there's $6,500 worth of wetsuits that,

0:22:06okay, you have to send the wetsuits back,

0:22:08then we'll issue a refund, right?

0:22:09I mean, that would be fair.

0:22:10And I think Amazon would do that.

0:22:12Amazon has a pretty generous return policy.

0:22:14You know, with the virtual in-game stuff, you know,

0:22:18it's, you know, I'm sure it gets abused.

0:22:20I'm sure that there are, you know,

0:22:23wouldn't it be fascinating to talk to someone at Apple

0:22:26who deals with this at a management level.

0:22:29Like, where do they draw the line where

0:22:32an adult, fully knowledgeable, blows more money

0:22:37than they're comfortable with on Candy Crush or whatever,

0:22:41and then asks for a refund?

0:22:44I think I told you, I don't think I ever talked

0:22:48about this on the show, but apparently that's a big problem

0:22:51at hotels with the in-room mini bars.

0:22:55um i forget what i was talking to who knew about it uh i was like talking to someone who worked at

0:23:01a hotel and and the gist of it is that you would you know basically you would not believe how many

0:23:08mini room charges are disputed that they are like i didn't drink it yet uh yeah yeah what do you mean

0:23:15i what do you mean i drank all the vodka in the fridge i didn't i didn't touch it you mean like

0:23:19lyingly disputed?

0:23:21Yeah, like they know. I've never once checked into a hotel and had like a half empty mini

0:23:27bar, right? Like if there's a mini bar, it is always, you know, it's very orderly. You

0:23:34could see where the slots are for the things, you know, but they, you know, apparently it

0:23:38is extremely common for people to partake of the mini bar. And then when they're presented

0:23:44with the bill, dispute all of it and just say, "I didn't do it." And that the hotels often

0:23:48just say, "Okay, we did just eat it," you know, whatever. I don't know how often—I

0:23:53would imagine there's a similar situation with legitimate in-app game purchases, right?

0:24:00I would imagine that somebody wakes up and realizes they spent $100 on Clash of Clans

0:24:08or whatever, regrets it, and then says, "Hey, that was my kid," you know, whatever. I

0:24:12don't know how they adjudicate that because obviously that is legitimate.

0:24:16legitimate. There's probably like a read. They probably, I mean, they must keep track of them

0:24:20in some way and say, you know, like if you're if you're calling up every other day and doing it,

0:24:23right, then right. There has to be eventually you get out. Right. You either have to do some

0:24:30real parenting or you you have a problem. Yeah, it would be fascinating to know how that goes.

0:24:34But when the first one comes in, I mean, and these people are saying they even know it. It's

0:24:38the 13 year old. The fact that it's the 13 year old who who is the girl who's who's contacting

0:24:44Facebook for this makes me it almost breaks my heart because it makes me think because it's not the parent writing and it's the girl

0:24:50And it's like she must know she's in trouble screwed up. Yeah, right and and

0:24:56it's I

0:24:58It's oh it's it's it the whole thing

0:25:02We laughed at it

0:25:02But it actually the fact that it was the girl writing in and that they're just lolling at her and I wouldn't refund

0:25:07I figured just checking. It's like it actually to me makes it

0:25:14heartbreaking in a way that that it wouldn't if it was the the adult writing in

0:25:18Yeah, it's just crazy though. I mean, obviously that's a mistake. There's no there's no universe, right?

0:25:24Like a billionaire, you know

0:25:29Howard Schultz's daughter could be writing in and it's like there's no way even a billionaire isn't gonna let his 13 year old by

0:25:35$6,500 worth of Angry Birds. I

0:25:37Would hope not I would I guess I would

0:25:43I don't know. I bet maybe there's somebody maybe there is somebody but I would hope nobody does that. Well, it's

0:25:49In a lot of ways it's a bad company and this thing is really interesting to me

0:25:54Well anyway back to this this latest thing with this Facebook. Yeah

0:25:58So they're up in arms over there now, right? I mean today they're having a bad day over at Facebook because they none of their stuff

0:26:05Works, right? So what Apple did last night was

0:26:09revoke their enterprise certificates, plural, according to recode because apparently they

0:26:16have several. So their apps are all in the store. You can still download, you know, Facebook's still

0:26:21in the App Store, Instagram, all the dozens of apps they have. And they still work perfectly

0:26:28on your phone. But internal to Facebook, because they've disabled their enterprise certificate,

0:26:32the employees versions of all these apps stopped working. Like when they revoke your certificate,

0:26:39It means, you know, that it, I guess it doesn't delete the app from your device, but it means

0:26:45that it doesn't work. Yeah. So I don't know how many thousands, tens of thousands of employees

0:26:51Facebook has, but all of their installed versions of Facebook's app stopped working today.

0:26:56I don't even begin to understand the processes that would be in place at a big company like that.

0:27:05But I have friends who work at similarly sized companies or similar popularity companies.

0:27:14The things I've heard this morning were like, "To say that this would be disruptive for us

0:27:20would be an understatement." It's not just that you've got to go to the App Store and download

0:27:25Facebook from the App Store and install it, but there's all sorts of automated testing and

0:27:29et cetera, during the development, you know, the whole development workflow revolves around

0:27:34having a working developer certificate. Testing, you know, in the production version of the app is

0:27:42A, difficult and B, not recommended. So how permanent this is, is still, you know, at

0:27:50press time here, as they say, you know, unknown. But even if it's just a day, it is obviously a

0:27:59a bit of a wrap on the wrist from Apple to Facebook.

0:28:02- Yeah, it'll be interesting to see

0:28:04what happens with Google now.

0:28:06- Yeah.

0:28:07- With this other thing.

0:28:07- Yeah, I wonder.

0:28:08It makes me wonder how much of this is going on

0:28:11from other companies.

0:28:11Like how many people are doing this?

0:28:13- Yeah, well like I said, I mean, every once in a while

0:28:15I see that Hank has downloaded one of these things.

0:28:17And so this stuff is out there considerably, I think.

0:28:22And it's been going on for years.

0:28:26- Yeah, people's hunger for data,

0:28:28companies hunger for data is just insatiable. It really is. And it's fascinating to me,

0:28:35even with the App Store in place, and even with Apple's policies, making the App Store

0:28:40more stricter App Store than say the Google Play Store in terms of what goes through.

0:28:47And Android famously has, has, you know, built into the system, the ability to you, you as

0:28:52the user can say, you know, I think I'm on almost all Android phones, it's off by default,

0:28:57you can turn on, you don't need to use like a secret, you know, thing. It's an officially

0:29:02supported preference to sideload applications from other sources other than the Play Store.

0:29:07Obviously, like in China, where Google it, this stuff doesn't really go through Google's Android,

0:29:11everything is sort of a fork of the open source Android, you know, who knows what's going on.

0:29:16But even with Apple's policies in place, where sideloading isn't really possible, it's a it

0:29:23it seems like this developer certificate thing, the more we look at it in the last 24 hours,

0:29:27it might be widely being used to sort of effectively do side loading. And B, it's sort of distressing

0:29:35how much stuff goes through the App Store anyway, right? How much trackers and all sorts

0:29:40of stuff is going on when people analyze what apps in the App Store are actually keeping

0:29:46track of. Yeah. I feel like the political angle on this is you can't escape it. That

0:29:54it's and I realize it's not the law. Right? Like, what Apple says our app store policies

0:30:00doesn't mean it's illegal, right? I'm not saying Facebook did anything illegal, although

0:30:04I there ought to be a law, as they say, right? Yeah. Well, it's Yeah, I mean, it seems like

0:30:10there should be I mean, it certainly should be for adults only. I mean, like, a kid should

0:30:14not be targeted by this stuff. Absolutely. I definitely think a kid shouldn't be. And I think

0:30:20in adults, it seems almost like a kin to the kind of like medical experimentation where you get,

0:30:26you know, you get paid to come in and like, take a drug or something like that. And I mean, that

0:30:35stuff happens. They have conditions for those. So situations, there's a security expert named will,

0:30:43I hope I pronounced his surname correctly. Strahfach. I followed him for years on Twitter.

0:30:49He goes under the Twitter name "Chronic." But he's an outstanding security expert who's either

0:30:58uncovered all sorts of shenanigans over the years or can analyze shenanigans that are discovered by

0:31:06others. TechCrunch reached him for expert commentary. To me, this whole thing, TechCrunch has been

0:31:15on a real roll. I thought it was an outstanding report because sometimes when a bigger publication,

0:31:23say the New York Times or somebody gets something technical, you see that they get technical

0:31:28things wrong or they go to the wrong—they go to an analyst for—like a business analyst

0:31:34for commentary as opposed to TechCrunch who went to a legitimate, well known, highly regarded

0:31:39security expert. Anyway, here's what he said. This is a quote he gave to Facebook, this hands

0:31:44Facebook continuous access to the most sensitive data about you. And most users are unable to

0:31:52reasonably consent. There is no good way to articulate just how much power is handed to

0:31:57Facebook when you do this. I thought that the key part of that is well, a good to emphasize that yes,

0:32:03this hands over it that it's hard to even say how much how much Facebook knows about what you're

0:32:08doing on your phone when you consent to this. But this idea that that users are unable to reasonably

0:32:15consent. And I think that's going to be controversial, or people will disagree. Yeah. Like

0:32:22I saw this morning, there was a headline that Facebook's controversial data tracking blah,

0:32:26blah, blah. And I was like, this isn't controversial, because there's not really people

0:32:29on the other side. Controversy is when there's people arguing one side and other people arguing

0:32:34the other. Taxes are too high. No, taxes are too low. Well, there's two groups. It's controversy.

0:32:38Nobody's really saying, "Hey, this is okay." Although there was one guy on Twitter,

0:32:45and I don't want to call him out by particular, but it's a somewhat reasonable take. His take

0:32:50was sort of the, "Hey, it's a free country." I think he even said it in the tweet to me that,

0:32:54"Hey, it's a free country." It's not like they surreptitiously installed this.

0:32:58They, you know, paid people $20 a month, told them, you know, what it does, and they agreed

0:33:05to it.

0:33:08Now that that angle.

0:33:10Yeah, well, that disregards the you're violating Apple's terms.

0:33:15But I so I think and I think he knows that this guy I don't think he was saying yeah,

0:33:19yeah, no way.

0:33:20I think he was just talking about the general moral universe of this action.

0:33:26I side with Straphic that people, yes, people agreed to the terms, but I don't think that

0:33:33normal people, most people could really understand the profoundness of what they're handing over

0:33:39to Facebook.

0:33:40Yeah.

0:33:41And we don't, there's other things that we don't, we don't allow predatory lending practices.

0:33:44Well, you know, we don't allow some, but we don't have enough restrictions on predatory

0:33:49lending practices.

0:33:50I won't say that, but there are certain restrictions on predatory lending practices.

0:33:53Right.

0:33:54In fact, it's actually, I feel like that's one of the areas where the United States really

0:34:01needs to take back. That's a great analogy in my opinion, right? Like payday lending

0:34:11at exorbitant interest rates.

0:34:14Well, and you think about the kind of, I mean, like you could make the, some people I've

0:34:18seen making the argument like, well, who would do this and why would they do it? Well, like

0:34:21you don't have very much money, 240 bucks a year might seem like an awful lot. And that might seem

0:34:27like, oh, okay, well, you know, Facebook's getting something, they're getting something. So why not?

0:34:30Well, because Facebook is getting a lot more than the people who are getting the money realize.

0:34:37Trenton Larkin It is true. And I don't, you know,

0:34:40I don't want to say it's the capital L libertarian parties, but lowercase L libertarian philosophy

0:34:47that people should be free to make their own choices would suggest that a payday lending

0:34:53place that tells you, "Hey, we're going to charge 20% interest per week," if they charge what they

0:35:02told you and you agreed to it, then why is that not allowed? Why can't you choose willingly and

0:35:07openly to pay 20% weekly interest or whatever they might want to charge? And I'm of the opinion,

0:35:16And I think the majority of people would agree that part of the role of government is to protect

0:35:22people, protect the populace from themselves. And the truth is, too many people don't understand

0:35:28how interest works. We're getting into philosophical ground here. But I think that

0:35:40there should be things that are outlawed, not because they're deceptive, but just because

0:35:46it's outrageous. They're simply taking advantage of—they're taking advantage—this company's

0:35:55taking advantage of people. I just read a thing the other day, another example. It is legal right

0:35:59now, and I really, really feel like it's something that the United States has really ought to crack

0:36:03down on our overdraft fees in bank accounts. And I forget the stat. I think it was like—I

0:36:13don't know if it was for the quarter or the year, but somebody had a—and they had a link

0:36:16citing it, but effectively they were like, "US banks made $3.5 billion last"—I'm going to say

0:36:22year—"$3.5 billion on overdraft fees," which means they took $3.5 billion from people who were broke.

0:36:31Right? Right. And you know, all right, so maybe your checking account, it was empty,

0:36:36but you weren't broke because you had a savings account. But effectively, that's $3.5 billion

0:36:41from people whose checking account was down to zero. It's wrong, right? And yes, you know,

0:36:47when you sign up for your bank account and you get this booklet of all the rules and

0:36:52regulations, I'm sure it's written in there exactly what the overdraft fee is, exactly

0:36:56how it can get triggered. I'm sure it's all perfectly, you know, and it's been triple

0:36:59check by all of their lawyers. Again, I just don't think I don't think it's right, you

0:37:04know, and I don't think I think traffic is right that you can't expect non technical

0:37:10people to understand exactly what they're giving over to Facebook in this case. Right.

0:37:14Yeah, I mean, I obviously completely agree. And there are many more cases that we can

0:37:20I mean, other examples of similar things that we can cite. But yeah, I think the interesting

0:37:26one of the interesting angles here is the sort of game of chicken that Facebook is obviously

0:37:31willing to play with Apple, right? Because if you and I started a company and we made an app

0:37:40and we use our developer certificate, if we did exactly what Facebook did, and we just did

0:37:49exactly what they did, paid people $20 a month and use our developer beta certificate to go around

0:37:55on the App Store and install a VPN that was collecting all of their data. The John and

0:38:02John company is their apps in the App Store are probably going away. Yeah, right. Probably

0:38:11not much of an appeal process. You know, there's obvious angle to this. And again, this is

0:38:18where I was going minutes ago with my look, I know Apple is not the law. But when we talk

0:38:23legally there's a principle that doesn't really hold true effectively, but it's a good guiding

0:38:32light, which is that the law applies equally to everyone. No one's above the law. It is hard not

0:38:39to say that bigger companies in the app store are treated differently. That's clearly not exactly

0:38:47how the app store has played out. Right. If you're big enough, you get treated differently.

0:38:53A good example of that was Uber a couple of years ago was caught geofencing Apple's

0:39:04campus in their app.

0:39:06I forget exactly why, but the gist of it was the Uber app acted differently when the geo,

0:39:14the location was within blank of Apple's campus in Cupertino and outside that area

0:39:22it differently. So that when on the assumption that it was going to be tested by App Store

0:39:28testers in Cupertino, they would miss behavior. They wouldn't see behavior that Uber was

0:39:35trying to hide from Apple. And once uncovered, you could prove that the app was doing this.

0:39:41You don't have to have the source code to notice that it does this only when you're

0:39:45not near Apple's campus. Uber did not get kicked out of the App Store. Apple, they're

0:39:52probably made a phone call.

0:39:54- Yeah.

0:39:55- You know, which I, wouldn't it be great,

0:39:57I wish someday it would be great

0:39:59if Apple just released all these uncomfortable phone calls.

0:40:02(laughing)

0:40:04Uncomfortable phone calls we've made to app store violators.

0:40:07Like wouldn't you love to hear that call?

0:40:09It's, you know, hard not, again,

0:40:12it's hard not to think that if you and I submitted an app

0:40:15to Apple that tried to geofence their Cupertino.

0:40:21seriously. We're not still going to be in the app store. Yeah. Anyway, so it's, it really seems

0:40:27like Facebook has a sort of, a sort of assumes that they can do whatever they want until they

0:40:35get caught and pay no price for it. Because what are you, what are you going to do? Pull Facebook

0:40:40from the app store and say, there's no Facebook on iPhone. Yeah. And I mean, you know, in this

0:40:46instance, it is fortunate in a way that it, well, I mean, I don't know if it's fortunate or not,

0:40:51because eventually it seems like this is going to come to a head, but that Apple was able to

0:40:55do something that really does seem like it's hurting Facebook internally without pulling

0:41:01the public facing app. Yeah.

0:41:03I don't know, but it's, you know, it's in an interesting dynamic to me that Facebook,

0:41:12I think you know implicitly it seems to believe that they can

0:41:17Keep keep breaking as many rules as they want and they'll just have to stop doing it

0:41:23You know stop doing the thing and face no further

0:41:26repercussions because what's Apple gonna do pull them from the App Store and I actually see that I you know

0:41:32I see that they have a point it would be

0:41:35You know, what would typical app?

0:41:38you know, what if can fake can Facebook cross a line where Apple would literally pull that

0:41:42Facebook app from the App Store? Yeah, it would be interesting to see what would happen because

0:41:47I mean, if they would just like said, okay, we're just on Android now. Right? It's that's,

0:41:52you know, just, you know, it's seems unlikely, but it's possible. Right? There has to be some

0:41:59line that they could cross, you know, and that would have that happen. And what would iPhone

0:42:04owning Facebook users think. And would that death penalty include all of their apps, which

0:42:12would include Instagram, WhatsApp? Even with the App Store in place, they hold an enormous

0:42:23amount of power in this relationship. In some ways, it's incomprehensible to think that

0:42:33Apple would pull Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp from the App Store.

0:42:37Yeah, yeah. Now you've never had a Facebook account, right?

0:42:41I have not. I'm thinking about signing up, though.

0:42:45Well, you can get $20 a month, man.

0:42:47I'm also thinking about taking up cigarette smoking.

0:42:51And heroin. I had one and I deleted it

0:42:55last September or something like that, August, September, sometime around then.

0:42:59time around then.

0:43:02But my wife relies on it heavily.

0:43:05For years she relied on it just to keep in touch with her parents who used to live back

0:43:09east and now have since moved out here.

0:43:11So that's less of a factor.

0:43:13But one of the things that I mean, she uses it for work because she's a private investigator.

0:43:17And one of the amazing things about it is that people are so careless with the stuff

0:43:22that they put on Facebook that it is a great boon to her business because she's able to

0:43:27figure things out about people and find people that she's looking for and do stuff like that

0:43:33just through Facebook. Yeah, and you see all sorts of stories all the time about people's,

0:43:39just from politics to gossip-type scandals, all sorts of stuff ends up through stuff that was

0:43:50posted on Facebook. I don't know how much of it is through dark pattern design and how

0:43:59much of it is simply human nature on the part of users that once they're using it, they

0:44:04get comfortable. But yeah, people clearly share all sorts of stuff.

0:44:10I will say this, that I have an Instagram account. I signed up for Instagram the first

0:44:15day that Instagram went was in the app store. And I had heard of it before. I know MG Sigler

0:44:22was a beta tester and I'd seen him tweet like they weren't exactly like they weren't completely

0:44:28cloaked. There were beta users of Instagram who were tweeting like screenshots and stuff. So I

0:44:37kind of knew the gist of what it was going to be and I thought it looked pretty cool.

0:44:42And I think I probably learned from MG when, you know, like, "Hey, it's in the App Store now."

0:44:47And I, you know, I'd been intrigued by it. And of course, in a panic, really wanted to get

0:44:52at Gruber. So I quick downloaded it, and I was like, "Got it." So I've been using it literally

0:44:58since the day that it hit the App Store. And I used to like it a lot, and now I like it less.

0:45:07But as still a continuing user of Instagram, I don't take any sanctimonious

0:45:14angle on my "I've never had a Facebook account" because at this point, having an Instagram account

0:45:22and continuing to use it puts me on no better whatever you want to call it, moral or, you know,

0:45:29again, sanctimonious ground. I might as well have a Facebook account for all that matters.

0:45:35I'm sure they're tracking everything through it, you know, so I'm on the fence about whether to

0:45:40get off Instagram. But yeah, I am. I am as well. I am on Instagram still, you know,

0:45:44but I've used it. I've started using it a lot less than I used to. I don't think I've talked

0:45:49about this on the show for it famously. Well, famously, in my mind, I didn't see ads. And I

0:45:55continued not to see any ads in Instagram. And that that gravy train ended for me. I'm gonna say

0:46:02like two months ago maybe yeah yeah you mentioned this someplace and it it worked for me for a while

0:46:11and then but it's been you know it's been at least i mean it's been well over a year for sure

0:46:15i don't know i've never understood i don't know anybody at instagram i don't know i never

0:46:20understood why i wasn't getting ads for so long uh i certainly wasn't i was curious i in some ways

0:46:27ways I was like, I'd like to see these ads, I hear about them. Boy, I sure missed the

0:46:33days when I didn't have Instagram ads. Because boy, oh boy, do they show a lot of them. Like,

0:46:40and I don't know if that was it was I would presume that for most Instagram users, it

0:46:47was the slow, slowly temperature rising frog in a pot, you know that, you know, it started

0:46:53little warm and then it got hotter slowly over time. But when you go from no ads to

0:47:00the late 2008 number of ads, it is jarring. I would honestly estimate, I presume this

0:47:08is typical, I would say at least one out of four posts in my Instagram stream is an ad,

0:47:14possibly closer to one out of three.

0:47:16Yeah, that it's like the thing that's the thing that's super annoying is that they look

0:47:21just like everything else.

0:47:23And and the people who are making the ads go to great lengths in order to try to make

0:47:27them look like pictures that some friend of yours took.

0:47:29Yeah.

0:47:30One of the things that I really I mean, I, you know, I wish Tumblr was Tumblr has many

0:47:36problems and I hardly use Tumblr anymore.

0:47:39But one of the I think the way they implemented ads was a lot better because it's when it

0:47:43scrolls it's like it's like you're scrolling up and the posts go away and like suddenly this ad

0:47:49reveals and then you keep scrolling and then more of your posts come back up over the ad so it looks

0:47:55like the ad is like a static thing in the background. I don't use tumblr anymore. I'll have to take it.

0:47:59Yeah I know I mean I barely use it either but it's just a much it's a much more refreshing way to

0:48:05have to deal with ads on a platform like if you're going to do it I wish they would do it that way

0:48:10but of course they don't want to do it that way because they want you to think that it's like some

0:48:12post that your friend made. I will say their ads are strikingly accurate. I mean they're way more

0:48:20they really are. I mean some of it is obvious. I follow a bunch of watch brands on Instagram so I

0:48:26see a lot of watch type stuff but I saw I got an I don't know where they got it I mean but I saw

0:48:32an ad for American Giant. American Giant is that company that a couple of years ago they make

0:48:40hoodies and sweatshirts and stuff like that. They're almost like a higher-end American apparel

0:48:45who doesn't really exist anymore. But they made a hoodie that, five or six years ago,

0:48:53was heralded as the greatest hoodie ever made. And all of a sudden, it was backordered by six

0:48:59months. And I actually own one. I have one. And it is a very nice hoodie. But they showed me an ad.

0:49:07And that was interesting.

0:49:10And then I actually tapped on it to see more.

0:49:12And then, oh my God, did I start getting ads for hoodies and American Giant.

0:49:17Yeah.

0:49:18Yeah.

0:49:19And then I got an ad about a week ago.

0:49:21I saw an ad in my Instagram feed for some kind of like an elastic strap you put on your shoulders.

0:49:28Sort of looks like, you know, how like the James Bond holster that he puts for putting a gun under

0:49:33suit. Like that sort of thing, but it's symmetric. And the idea is you put it on and it helps

0:49:38with your posture. Keep your shoulders back or something. You can wear it on a clothes

0:49:42suit.

0:49:43I could probably use that.

0:49:44That seemed to, well, maybe my posture could use some help too. But it intrigued me because

0:49:49it seemed like it was out of nowhere. Although on the other hand, I was like, "Do they know

0:49:53I have bad posture?" The other stuff is accurate enough that it kind of spooked me.

0:49:58We've looked into pictures of you.

0:49:59But as an experiment, I tapped it.

0:50:03And all of a sudden, I started getting ads

0:50:05for the same sort of device, but from three or four

0:50:08different companies.

0:50:10So in some sense, it's not like, wow,

0:50:13what a crazy AI Skynet-type system

0:50:17they must have to target me.

0:50:19At some level, the initial ads did have that aspect.

0:50:23Like, how did they know that I'm interested in some

0:50:25of this stuff?

0:50:26It actually is up my alley.

0:50:27But then once you click on something,

0:50:29It's just the most obvious thing possible.

0:50:31They just show you as many variations

0:50:33of this thing as possible.

0:50:35- Right.

0:50:35- So I don't-- - A la, like Amazon.

0:50:38- Yeah.

0:50:40I've seen people say,

0:50:41"Could Apple take on Instagram?

0:50:44"Could Apple do something that is like Instagram,

0:50:48"but without all the bad stuff of Instagram?"

0:50:52This comes up every time you complain about Instagram.

0:50:56- Yeah.

0:50:57Well, that's the one thing

0:50:58I've started doing more of is sharing just through shared iPhoto folders, whatever they called.

0:51:06Trenton Larkin Yeah, iCloud sharing groups. Yeah.

0:51:09Brian "Brent"

0:51:12Bad about like, if I completely get off of Instagram is, you know, my mom and my dad won't

0:51:16be able to see pictures of Hank and stuff like that. But, you know, I just I share a folder

0:51:22with them. And now problem solved. Trenton Larkin

0:51:25Yeah. So to me, that's not an Instagram thing because I don't know, it's not no, it's not the

0:51:30same. But I think it's that particular part of the problem. It is a Facebook alternative, though,

0:51:35right? Because that's the sort of thing people use Facebook for is right, you know, the,

0:51:39you know, your niece has a third birthday party and you take a bunch of pictures,

0:51:43you don't want to post them publicly. So Facebook is the sort of thing where you can post them

0:51:47privately. The iCloud sharing thing takes that role in my life, you know, we have some just a

0:51:54a few shared groups, like one for just me and Amy and Jonas, one for Amy's side of

0:52:00the family, which is more active. I think there's one where my mom is invited. I don't

0:52:06know. She has iCloud, so I think there is. But that's what we put there. I take pictures

0:52:12at niece or nephew's birthday party, and then I'll post the good ones there. I don't

0:52:19know, though, because I don't know if you know this, but Apple doesn't really have

0:52:21a great record with social media networks?

0:52:26Just put them all in ping.

0:52:27All right, hold on a sec. Let me take a break and hit the money button here. I tell you

0:52:33about our good friends at Casper. Casper products are cleverly designed to mimic human curves,

0:52:40providing supportive comfort for all kinds of bodies, mattresses. That's what Casper

0:52:46specializes in. Look, you spend one-third of your life sleeping. I spend well over a

0:52:50third of my life sleeping. So you should be comfortable. Trust me. I mean, sleep is my

0:52:56favorite thing to tell you the truth. The experts at Casper, they're not just white-labeling

0:53:02mattresses and putting a Casper sticker on them. They've got an engineering team, mattress

0:53:07engineers. It sounds like a joke, but everything is engineered. Everything's designed. Casper

0:53:11designs their own mattresses. They design the material. They design every aspect of

0:53:17of it. And they have a breathable design. All of their mattresses that helps you sleep

0:53:25cool and regulate your body temperature throughout the night. They offer three mattresses. They

0:53:30got the regular Casper mattress that used to be the only one. But they've got two new

0:53:34ones that they released in the last year or so, the Wave and the Essential. The Wave features

0:53:38a patent pending premium support system to mirror the natural shape of your body. And

0:53:44have the essential which has a streamlined design and a price that as they say won't

0:53:50keep you up at night. In other words, it's a lower price but it's still a great mattress.

0:53:55And they offer a wide array of other products, pillows, sheets, that sort of thing, anything

0:54:00sleep related you can get from Casper. And it's all designed, developed and assembled

0:54:07right here in the United States. Now they've got affordable prices, really affordable prices

0:54:13premium mattresses compared to mattress stores because they've cut out the middleman. They

0:54:17make, they design them, they make them and they ship them directly to you. There is no,

0:54:23you know, retail mattress operation. Now you can do this though. You can buy these internet

0:54:28mattresses from Casper with the safety, the security of knowing that you can get a hassle

0:54:35free return if you're not completely satisfied. A hundred night risk free sleep on it trial.

0:54:41That's just amazing.

0:54:42You get three full months and you don't like it, no hassle.

0:54:45They'll just come right to your house, take it back,

0:54:47give you all your money back.

0:54:48And they've got free shipping and free returns

0:54:50in the US and Canada.

0:54:52So our friends up north can partake

0:54:55in the Casper Fund as well.

0:54:56Look, we've got Casper mattresses here in the house.

0:55:01We love them.

0:55:02They're terrific products.

0:55:03They last for years.

0:55:05I've been to Casper's sponsoring the show for years now.

0:55:07We've got one that they sent before the first time

0:55:10sponsored the talk show still seems good. It's new and they got a special offer for

0:55:15those of you who listen to the show. You can save 50 bucks towards select mattresses by

0:55:19visiting casper.com/talk show and using that code talk show. No, the just talk show all

0:55:26one word at checkout. That's casper.com/talk show select mattresses 50 bucks off using

0:55:33that special code talk show terms and conditions apply. Yeah, so we were talking about the

0:55:41idea of an Apple alternative to Instagram. You know, what is it? You know, is, is the

0:55:48stories feature integral to Instagram? I mean, I don't, I don't use the stories thing. I

0:55:52don't get it. I know I'm old. I know people know how to do it. I saw Marco. I don't either.

0:55:57I get over in that area and it's like, where the hell am I?

0:56:00I really miss when Instagram was, you follow people

0:56:07and then they carefully select the photos they wanna post

0:56:13and they tend to either be like momentous occasions

0:56:16or just particularly pleasing photos

0:56:19and then you stream down and in a chronological order,

0:56:23you see the posts, the photos from the people

0:56:27who you chose to follow. And then if you're all heavily filtered, right. And then if you

0:56:32want to, there's comments that are neatly organized as you know, one level in, you know,

0:56:38so if you want to see them, you can but if you don't, you don't have to like scroll

0:56:42past them. And then that was it. I really I that's the Instagram I liked and I'm

0:56:48you know, I'm sure they're making much more money now than they were before. But

0:56:54But boy, I sure miss that.

0:56:56- Yeah, yeah, me too.

0:56:57- In theory, Apple could do it.

0:57:01And could be iPhone only,

0:57:03and then it's all of them are in place.

0:57:05You don't have to tag them shot with iPhone.

0:57:07I get, well, I mean, I guess you can't keep people

0:57:09from uploading a--

0:57:10- Uploading other stuff, yeah.

0:57:11- Yeah, but keep it iOS only.

0:57:16How they would deal with usernames, I don't know.

0:57:19Right, because you wouldn't want to expose your Apple ID.

0:57:23Right you you might want to but you you probably I wouldn't you know, you know

0:57:29It's not like you want people all of a sudden face timing you which will get to another segment of the show

0:57:34Right. I don't want my Apple ideas my you know in the hypothetical world where Apple launched an Instagram competitor

0:57:43for publicly posting

0:57:46images in a timeline

0:57:49You know, you'd want to have a username that was separate from your Apple ID

0:57:53I mean, I guess Apple could just open up a new username space, you know, and have there'd

0:57:57be like a gold rush to claim your your desired name. Yeah. I don't think Apple would do it.

0:58:03I don't think they really have an interest in it. I see how they have an interest in

0:58:07the private iCloud photo sharing, which again is a great feature. I don't know that they

0:58:14have an interest in the public Instagram type thing.

0:58:17No, it seems like another one of those things like the, you know, making books from pictures.

0:58:26Yeah.

0:58:26Right. And photos that they would, if they did it, that they would do it for a while and then they

0:58:31go, eh, we're not doing this anymore. Yeah. And that's, that's one where they were already

0:58:35doing it. All they had to do is keep doing it. And they had so little interest in it that they

0:58:39canceled it. Right. So I don't know. I don't know what the solution is, you know, and, you know,

0:58:45given their track record with ping and uh they even just canceled i don't see i definitely don't

0:58:51see it happening yeah it's it you know i don't know what the betting odds would be that it would

0:58:57succeed but it'd probably be pretty low based on their track record but at least they would have

0:59:01a chance because it's apple and they could publicize it and they could get it in front

0:59:05of people with iphones you know they could make it uh you know prompt you in the photos app or

0:59:10something, you know, whereas it's, I think the ship has long since sailed for some, you know,

0:59:16again, the John and John startup company to start an Instagram clone, right? Like,

0:59:21like, I think if we went around and tried to raise capital to, we're gonna take on Instagram.

0:59:25You know, even if we could prove that we had the technical chops to do it, it's, it's, you know,

0:59:33at this point, it's, we're gonna, we're gonna use an enterprise certificate. You're gonna download

0:59:38- I downloaded it from a website.

0:59:41- But it's a shame because Instagram is,

0:59:44the good parts of Instagram still remain good,

0:59:45but man, they're getting buried in there.

0:59:47- Yeah, yeah.

0:59:48We used to all be on Flickr, remember?

0:59:50I mean, that was the big thing right before Instagram.

0:59:53And then everybody jumped ship to Instagram

0:59:56and killed Flickr.

0:59:57And then now, I mean, the Flickr app is not bad.

1:00:01- Yeah, but it's a different mindset though, right?

1:00:04- No, it's completely, yeah.

1:00:05- Right, and because Facebook, or not Facebook,

1:00:08Flickr predated, like Flickr should have in theory

1:00:12been Instagram before Instagram,

1:00:14but it would have required Flickr

1:00:17to do what Facebook has done fairly well,

1:00:20which is know when to put stuff in Facebook proper

1:00:25and know when to buy Instagram or buy WhatsApp, right?

1:00:30What Flickr should have done is spin out a separate app

1:00:34for this concept of curated streaming.

1:00:39Because the thing with Flickr is that

1:00:41the design of Flickr is, I haven't used it much in years,

1:00:45but I presume though it's still the same word.

1:00:48The idea though is if you go on a trip,

1:00:49you upload all your pictures from the trip to Flickr.

1:00:52Not just the keepers.

1:00:54And so if you're following me,

1:00:56you don't wanna see 20 pictures in a row

1:00:58of me at Disney World.

1:00:59You wanna see the one.

1:01:00And that's--

1:01:03They don't show I think they do a similar thing to the thing where you can post multiple pictures to Instagram like so if you upload

1:01:10Like you see one. Yeah that whole set right and then you can thumb you can you can thumb sideways through the other ones

1:01:16But you don't have to see all of them. Yeah, I did see I have to look into it. I hope I'm not too late

1:01:21I saw something where

1:01:23you know flickers under new management now and

1:01:25There's some kind of thing where you've got to pay to keep your flicker right going and

1:01:32And I've got enough ones there that I kind of want to,

1:01:36I don't want to lose them.

1:01:37I don't want them to go 404.

1:01:38Like I don't really use it.

1:01:39I don't actively use Flickr.

1:01:41So it seems wrong to pay.

1:01:42- That's the thing, yeah, I didn't either.

1:01:44I was, and I had been paying for pro for years

1:01:47for some reason.

1:01:49And then I, you know, I finally,

1:01:50like right before they got bought, I discontinued it.

1:01:53I stopped paying for it.

1:01:54And then the new, I think the new fee is like,

1:01:57it used to be 25 bucks and now it's like 50.

1:01:59And I was just like, man, I just don't, I mean,

1:02:01I didn't use it enough for 25 bucks. I don't think I'm using enough for 50. So, but they,

1:02:06yeah, you can download your, your old, all your old photos. So I did that. And then I, and I went,

1:02:12so you can keep a thousand, like up to a thousand in the regular account, you know, like for free.

1:02:17And so I went through and I just deleted a bunch that I decided weren't worth keeping anyway.

1:02:22Yeah. I don't know what the deadline is on that, but I got it. It's February,

1:02:25it's mid February. Well, then I got time. I'll wait till the last day.

1:02:31I like an idiot. I've got stuff there that's not just personal too. I've got Daring Fireball stuff

1:02:36there. Even just as recently, I think as a couple months ago, shooting iPhone camera comparisons

1:02:43posted, "Here's the old camera. Here's the new camera comparisons on Flickr," just because I

1:02:52don't really have a good mechanism. I don't have any mechanism really for that sort of thing on

1:02:57on Daring Fireball itself. It was always a good way because Flickr does all the moderation.

1:03:06Being able to comment on those photos, it never went out of control. It wasn't like

1:03:10there were 400 comments on them because I posted them from Daring Fireball, but people

1:03:14could comment on them. I feel like I can legitimately call it a business expense to keep it going

1:03:21so that those previous—those year's worth of things keep going. But anyway, Flickr.

1:03:27Not going to beat Instagram.

1:03:30Brian Kardell: No. Sorry to say.

1:03:33Tom Bilyeu: Yeah. I don't know. I think we beat this Facebook thing to death.

1:03:38Brian Kardell Yep.

1:03:39Tom Bilyeu Let's go to the FaceTime bug.

1:03:40Brian Kardell Okay.

1:03:41Tom Bilyeu Oh, what a doozy.

1:03:42Brian Kardell It's not good. So it was group FaceTime, right? And so you make a group FaceTime

1:03:49call and you can hear and see the person before they pick up.

1:03:54Yeah, so the trick to trigger it was I call you, your phone starts ringing. While your

1:04:01phone is ringing with the FaceTime call from Jon Gruber, I go down to the add person button

1:04:07to do great group FaceTime and add myself, add me. I don't know how that's even possible, but

1:04:14then once I do that, your phone starts broadcasting the audio to me, even though you haven't answered it.

1:04:23And that there's a, I don't know how reliable this was. Supposedly then, if you hit the power button

1:04:33or I hit the power button, I'm not sure which way it was, somehow there's a way that in some cases

1:04:38people were able to trigger video as well, that it would start broadcasting video. Bad bug, really,

1:04:44not a nightmare book. There's no other way to underplay it. It surely was a real jolt.

1:04:51Once Apple, somebody at Apple, you know, the FaceTime team really got their hands on what

1:04:54was going on, I'm sure it was, you know, a truly electric flop sweat moment.

1:05:00Because that's bad, right? And it just, it's as bad as it sounds, right?

1:05:06Right.

1:05:06It's not. And of course, people, you know, took it too far. Because that's the world we live on.

1:05:13Everybody's got to take it to the extreme and say that it's you know that it was it enabled surreptitious

1:05:18Surveillance and there was an obvious trail right like you you're gonna if it happened to your phone if somebody took advantage of it

1:05:25Let's say you're you didn't even hear it ringing like you left your phone and on your desk or something

1:05:30I went away you there still is a notice that you got a FaceTime call, right? It's not

1:05:34Mm-hmm, and it's you know, it's not too hard to turn off FaceTime, you know, but you know that you got a FaceTime call

1:05:41It's not like somebody could do it and your phone didn't even ring or light up and people could use

1:05:46it to listen to you. It's, you know, it's not that bad. Although some people wrote about it as though

1:05:52it were. Yeah. I think the worst, I mean, the, the it's bad, it's a, it's a bad bug and it obviously

1:06:00should never, should never have shipped that way. And that's a very weird, it's, it's a very weird

1:06:06thing to have happen. Yeah. But I mean, I think the worst thing is that they seem to have been

1:06:14notified about it like almost a week beforehand, right? Right. That there was a 14-year-old kid who

1:06:21apparently discovered this while setting up a FaceTime with his friends while gaming,

1:06:26which is of course a huge thing, you know, using any, you know, FaceTime or there's something

1:06:35called Discord that Jonas uses now. FaceTime's obviously iPhone, iOS, Apple only. But even if

1:06:43you're playing PC games, if everybody in your circle has iPhones, you could use FaceTime.

1:06:47But anyway, Kidd was trying to set it up, uncovered this. And then his mom seemingly

1:06:54did everything. She's apparently an attorney in Arizona. And they're not a technical expert,

1:07:01and her messages to Apple were clear about that, but a very clear communicator. And seemingly did

1:07:09everything she could possibly do. She went to Apple support, which is probably not the right

1:07:14place, but it's a good start, and eventually got directed to the actual channel where you're

1:07:20supposed to report security issues and submitted it. And I think with an accurate enough reasonable

1:07:31accurate enough steps to reproduce, you know, because that's always the thing with with bugs,

1:07:37you know, all bugs should be reported. But if you can, this thing happened, and I don't know why.

1:07:42And yeah, yeah, but a bug report that says here, do do a B, C, D, in that order, and you expect

1:07:49blank to happen. And instead, this happens is a great bug report, especially if it really can't

1:07:56be reproduced on other devices, not just your device. And this apparently could be reproduced

1:08:00on anybody's device. Yeah, like a week ago, and it seemingly did not trigger any response

1:08:09from Apple. I don't think we know what the explanation…

1:08:13Mike

1:08:13Adam: …the explanation.

1:08:14Adam O'Brien Right. Were they—did they recognize what

1:08:19was happening and were hoping to fix this quietly without having any publicity? Or was

1:08:26this ignored, whether because they get a thousand of these things a day and it was lost in the

1:08:31shuffle, or, you know, they just—the whole thing just goes right down that circle, you

1:08:39know, like I said, the circular file?

1:08:40Yeah. I mean, you think you get faster is the, I mean, what would you do? What would you and I do?

1:08:48I mean, so years ago, Hank discovered that if you if you said butts to Siri,

1:08:54it would bring up the Wikipedia entry for anal sex.

1:08:57I believe this has come up on the show before. Yeah. Well, yeah, it should come up every time.

1:09:03Shortly after the after this. And so the butts incident. I yeah, right. The butts of the famous

1:09:09but since it enough 2012 or whenever it was, um, I talked about it on Twitter and then I,

1:09:17I filed a bug report, um, because I had a, you know, a developer account. Um, and that seemed to

1:09:23get, that seemed to get some traction and actually, I mean, I think within like a week or so it was,

1:09:30it was closed. Oh, that's the other thing that this, the mother did the mother at one point was

1:09:34told to file a radar, which is really out there. I mean, and, and so she did, though, she saw she's

1:09:41not a developer, but she went as far as to sign up for a developer account and filed a radar about

1:09:47this. That's the which is really ridiculous. Going to through the security channel should be enough.

1:09:52Right. You know, I tend to think though, that this is a, I don't think that Apple was hiding it. I

1:09:59I don't think anybody at Apple who recognized the severity of this tried to hide it.

1:10:05I just feel that the whole thing is sort of a yada, yada, yada.

1:10:12There's so much noise, we don't bother looking for the signal sort of attitude in

1:10:17there.

1:10:18Because I really think that if this had been—if anybody in a position to recognize just how

1:10:25bad this bug is and how bad the publicity is, it would have escalated to the point where

1:10:30they pulled—and the temporary fix—Apple has issued a statement saying that there will

1:10:35be a software update by the end of this week to address it, but the temporary fix of disabling

1:10:41the group FaceTime server, like I believe that right now as we record, you can't make

1:10:46a group FaceTime.

1:10:47That is, yeah. I haven't tried, but I mean, that's my assumption since they took the

1:10:53the group FaceTime server down, yes.

1:10:55You know, that's a good enough stopgap, you know. And I feel like they want to get—they

1:11:02need to fix it in a way that even when the software update is in place, that people who

1:11:07haven't gotten the software update yet aren't affected. I don't know how they do that,

1:11:13but in the meantime, anybody who—I really firmly believe that anybody at Apple who would

1:11:17recognize this properly. And if it had gotten to the next step, somebody recognizes it and

1:11:23somebody has the ability inside Apple. And presumably the people reading those, the security

1:11:29report channel would have this ability to contact the FaceTime team. And the FaceTime

1:11:33team would reproduce it and then immediately go and hit that button that turns off. Holy

1:11:39shit. I would turn off the group FaceTime server before contacting Phil Schiller. I

1:11:45I mean, I wouldn't wait.

1:11:49If you had the ability to hit that red button

1:11:52to turn off the group FaceTime server,

1:11:54I would hit it at that point.

1:11:56I mean, it's that bad.

1:11:57I really think that it was a,

1:12:01what are you gonna say?

1:12:04Over, just not paying enough attention,

1:12:08not willfully trying to hide this.

1:12:11- Yeah, I wouldn't think so.

1:12:14just out of character. So it seems like it's a process problem, right?

1:12:19Yeah, I would say it's very much a process problem.

1:12:21And it does seem like it's not the first time that this kind of thing has happened.

1:12:25Right. But, you know, somebody brought up, there was something that somebody reported on

1:12:29like a support forum recently. I forget what the issue was, but there was a bad bug and somebody

1:12:36filed a, you know, like on the help.apple.com support forums or whatever the URL is.

1:12:41I can see that Apple doesn't go through those and make sure that every single one

1:12:47of the thousands of posts per hour doesn't have a critical security bug that somebody's—because

1:12:51it's just too much. But when somebody takes the time to officially report it through the

1:12:55security channel, boy, you'd like to think that there's a process in place no matter

1:13:00how much noise there is through that channel. You'd like to think that there's something

1:13:05looking for—always vigilant for stuff like this. You know what I mean? When you're

1:13:10a lifeguard at the beach, there's a thousand people in the water, but you really—it's

1:13:14the one who's drowning that you've got to look for. So yeah, this is not a good look

1:13:20for Apple.

1:13:21But, you know, and I've seen people saying, you know, it is a little coincidental that

1:13:25it's happened at the same time as this Facebook thing, and how can Apple preach about privacy

1:13:30when they have this terrible privacy bug? But it's, to me, the fundamental difference

1:13:35here between the two is that this is clearly a bug. This was not something that they did

1:13:39on purpose.

1:13:40It's a manslaughter versus murder, I guess.

1:13:46Right. Whereas Facebook doesn't really have like a "whoops, we didn't mean to do that."

1:13:51Yeah.

1:13:52"We didn't mean to pay people $20 in this program."

1:13:55Like they don't really have much of a leg to stand for there on intent.

1:14:00Right. Yeah. Repeated, you know, serial killer.

1:14:07Yeah, so I don't know. I'd like to hear something about this process, but I doubt that we will.

1:14:11But hopefully—

1:14:12That doesn't seem like the kind of thing that would come out.

1:14:14No, but hopefully they're looking at this internally and will address it because it's

1:14:18not a good look. On the upside, you know, it doesn't—because it really only got publicized

1:14:27yesterday. I mean, I don't know how many people—I don't know how many jerks tried to take advantage

1:14:32of it yesterday before they shut down the group FaceTime server. But I haven't seen any horror

1:14:36stories about it yet. So no, hopefully nobody really got, got taken advantage of in this way.

1:14:41Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think, yeah, I mean, well, I mean, bugs happen. This is a really bad one

1:14:49though. Uh, yeah. And I keep struggling with this whole thing. Like, I mean, is Apple buggier than

1:14:56they used to be? What do you have? Do you have an opinion on that? Because I remember bugs from

1:15:04days gone by and you know it's hard it's a hard thing i think and i don't think this is a case

1:15:12of that i don't know what the code path is here that triggered it i'm guessing that this is just

1:15:17a this isn't really sloppiness it's just some kind of face palm duh of course you know looking at the

1:15:23source code you know this this whole add yourself to the group facetime thing is such a weird

1:15:31idea, you know, hopefully, you know, it should have been tested but and

1:15:34Even if it was tested, I'm not sure that they would test the angle of hey the other person hasn't answered yet

1:15:42you know, like I just feel that there's a

1:15:44There's something here. That's just an oversight. I don't think it's ineptitude. I think it's just the sort of bug that anybody

1:15:50Yeah, even I'm so it's a talented and testing. It's a flaw in the testing processes. I guess I don't know. Yeah

1:15:55Yeah, overall is Apple's stuff buggier than it used to be. I don't think so

1:16:00I just yeah, I don't think so either but yeah, I see a lot of people claiming that that's true

1:16:05Yeah, I don't see bugginess what I see that is worse than it used to be is an eye for details

1:16:11you know that there are

1:16:13Check boxes that don't a lot align with their labels, you know that are two pixels off

1:16:20And I really do things that you would notice more than other people, right?

1:16:24and they're the sort of thing that Apple never got wrong because

1:16:28And the reason they almost never got stuff like that wrong is that every single engineer at Apple?

1:16:34Had the eye that that sense, you know that they cared about things like having the label for the checkbox

1:16:40perfectly aligned with the checkbox

1:16:43Like it just was what it's what drew people to the Mac in the first place and would draw a

1:16:50software engineers to want to work at Apple writing this apps and control panels and system pref panels for Apple and

1:16:58is that they cared about details like that. And there's obviously, you know, sort of,

1:17:04as they've grown the headcount, I'm not sure that they've managed to maintain the culture as well.

1:17:12So I see more stuff like that, like just little HIG violations that it's like, oh my God,

1:17:17nobody would ever do that. Dialogue boxes, like if you have two dial, if you have two boxes in a

1:17:21dialogue like "cancel" and "do the thing," those two buttons should be the same width.

1:17:27No matter, you know. So like, for example, if it's just "cancel" and "okay,"

1:17:33and it's properly spelled just "okay," the "okay" button shouldn't be the size

1:17:37of the word "okay." It should be at least as wide as the "cancel" button. And I

1:17:43see a bunch of dialogue boxes throughout the Mac OS X now where the "okay" button,

1:17:50it says okay or something else is smaller than the cancel button. It just bothers me

1:17:56every time. I know one of them is the dialog box that you get when you author—what I

1:18:02just talked about. If Jonas goes to buy something and I approve it, it's like when I type

1:18:06my Apple ID password in to approve it, the button that you click is smaller than the

1:18:12cancel button. It drives me nuts every goddamn time because I just can't see how anybody

1:18:17who works at Apple doesn't know that you don't do that. And in fact, the guides in, if you

1:18:21use the actual guides in interface builder and Xcode, it should auto size them that way.

1:18:27Like you have to go out of your way to make a button smaller, smaller. They think that

1:18:30they're doing something better. Yeah. So anyway, I see some stuff like that and I don't want

1:18:35to take up the rest of the show, but I, the, my, my still in progress rant about the marzipan

1:18:42apps, you know, I just don't like the fact that they got approved to me as a sign of

1:18:46the same sort of thing. They're just weird in so many ways and un-Mac-like and I don't

1:18:52see it. But I don't think bugginess is a problem. I've said this before too. My big

1:18:56complaint with Apple in—I don't know how far back it goes. It's a longish trend.

1:19:05And I've been saying this for years and obviously to no effect. But my big problem

1:19:08is that they have sort of, without saying so, clearly switched to a policy of preferring

1:19:16silent failure over showing an explicit error dialogue. So all sorts of stuff that can go

1:19:23wrong often goes wrong and you don't see any error. Like, you know, I just as an example,

1:19:28I give your your your photos, in count, you got a bum photo in your photo library, and

1:19:37photo won't sync to your iCloud library. It just doesn't sync to the iCloud library. They

1:19:43don't show you an error and say, "Hey, this photo is corrupt," and tell you which photo

1:19:46it is. I had a thing—and this was years ago, and I think they fixed it. I'm really,

1:19:50really happy. I hate to single out iCloud photo syncing because iCloud photo syncing

1:19:54has been incredibly good for me in the last few years, just incredibly good and surprisingly

1:20:01fast, even when I've shot a bunch of 4K videos and stuff like that. It syncs to other devices

1:20:05very fast. But a couple of years ago, I had a thing that was driving me up. Just like

1:20:12somebody couldn't target driving me insane better was that when it tells you at the bottom,

1:20:17how many photos you have, I had one device, I forget which device, it doesn't even matter.

1:20:21But I had like two Macs, an iPhone and iPad. And one of them had one fewer items. Or one

1:20:28more I forget if it was one more. One more, right? It was one was corrupted. It would

1:20:32be on that device, but would not think to the other ones.

1:20:35- Yeah, it had one more photo than all the other devices

1:20:38and never showed me an error.

1:20:41It just had a different count.

1:20:42And I mean, I honest to God,

1:20:45it is lucky that I didn't have an aneurysm.

1:20:47I mean, maybe somebody at Apple who doesn't like me

1:20:49wrote this bug to drive me insane,

1:20:52but I mean, and how do you find it?

1:20:54And I figured it out eventually.

1:20:55I figured out that you can make,

1:20:56there's a way to make a smart library,

1:20:59a smart album on the Mac version of photos

1:21:02where the criteria is, is not synced to iCloud,

1:21:06something like that.

1:21:07You can say, show me all the photos

1:21:09that are not synced to iCloud,

1:21:10which should be empty at all times.

1:21:12And I had one photo. - That's interesting.

1:21:14- Yeah, it was actually a photo of me

1:21:15and Om Malik and Matt Mullenweg at the,

1:21:20I actually remember the exact photo

1:21:23at the Yankees-Astro's wildcard game

1:21:27three or four years ago.

1:21:29And the worst part, it was a duplicate.

1:21:32I had two versions of the photo somehow. So I could delete the one that was somehow not—once

1:21:38I figured out which one it was, I just deleted it. And I didn't even lose the photo because

1:21:41I had the identical photo. I had another copy of the photo in my library at the time. But

1:21:46I actually remember that. I also remember that the Yankees lost that game, which was

1:21:50terrible. Freaking Dallas Kite.

1:21:54That's a shame.

1:21:55Yeah, it's a real shame. But anyway, that drove me nuts. But anyway, the fact that the

1:22:02The thing that really drove me nuts is that they didn't show me an error message. Clearly

1:22:04that it could have, right? They knew there. Some of the syncing process knew that this

1:22:08photo was stubbornly not going to iCloud. Why not show me an error dialogue and help

1:22:13me find which one of the 29,000 items is, is the problem. Yeah. Uh, I can't, I don't

1:22:19have it off the top of my head. I don't have another lid, but there's all sorts of things

1:22:22that I think Apple does. I'm sure you can come up with some examples with in iTunes,

1:22:26um, of similar stuff with music, um, because that stuff has always been somewhat problematic.

1:22:33Right. I don't have too much of a problem with it anymore, but, um, actually I never had a huge

1:22:37problem with it, but you'd, you'd often get weird results of like, I would have the studio version

1:22:45of a song on my Mac. And then when I would sync a playlist, it would put in like a live version of

1:22:51the same song. And I, the reason it offends me this trend of not giving you errors for that,

1:22:57you know, and just tell you what's, what's, what is the sync problem here? What songs are,

1:23:00are, is iTunes sync confused by? I get it that it's like a sort of aesthetic ideal that error,

1:23:08error dialogues are ugly and unseemly, right? Yeah. Yeah. I mean, Windows is usually the,

1:23:15the counter example where it's like, we're going to give you a neuro dialogue for everything.

1:23:20and they're gonna cascade. Yeah, you have to close all of them. See how fast you can close them.

1:23:26Right. But I think that's the, you know, to me, it's blaming the wrong thing. The problem isn't

1:23:35the error dialogue. The problem is the bug that resulted in the error dialogue. Right? Yeah.

1:23:39When you don't show that nobody suffers for the bug. Right. So that's my bigger complaint with

1:23:47Apple's trends. I don't think that they do have more bugs though, and I don't think the

1:23:50reliability is lower, although there's certain products that could be better. Having two

1:23:57HomePods in our kitchen thing, again, I don't think we have time to really go into it, but

1:24:02it's—I have to unplug and replug the HomePods on a surprisingly regular basis, although

1:24:10in recent weeks I don't know that I have, so it may finally be getting better. But even

1:24:16Even through Christmas, it was still semi-regularly, all of a sudden, one of the two HomePods in

1:24:21the kitchen would stop playing or just stop answering. It just a lot—and unplug it,

1:24:31replug it, fixed it, because there is no reset button and you can't tell it to reset. The

1:24:36only way to reset it is to actually go back to 1978 and pull the plug out of the wall.

1:24:43But I wouldn't hold that up as a company-wide problem.

1:24:45All right, let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor.

1:24:48It's our good friends at Audible.

1:24:51Look, could listening, just listening, make you a better parent, a better leader, even

1:24:55a better person?

1:24:57Could listening to motivating fitness programs get you fit?

1:25:02Could listening inspire you to start something new?

1:25:04Look, it's the new year.

1:25:06There's never been a better time to start listening on Audible.

1:25:10Audible you get access to an unbeatable selection of audio books including bestsellers, motivation,

1:25:15mysteries, thrillers, memoirs, and more. Audible has the largest selection of audio books on the

1:25:21planet and now with Audible Originals the selection has gotten even more custom with

1:25:28content made for members that you can't get anywhere else. Hey, they always want you to pick

1:25:33a book. I wasn't going to read this book. And now I can't wait to read it. It's a memoir

1:25:41from Lisa Brennan Jobs. That's Steve Jobs' first daughter. And it's called Small Fry.

1:25:47Because it's a personal memoir and I knew it and it's not the book isn't about Steve

1:25:50Jobs. It's about her. But he's obviously you know, he's her father and they had a

1:25:54fractious relationship. It's obviously he's obviously in it. But I'm just not a reader

1:25:59of personal life stuff and in the various jobs, biographies, and stuff about his personal

1:26:04life was the least interesting to me. I'm more interested in his life. But Lisa Brennan

1:26:08Jobs was on Craig Mod's On Margins podcast. I'm going to put a link to the show On Margins,

1:26:14the episode where she was his guest in the show notes, I promise. And it's one of the

1:26:19most remarkable interviews. It's a one-hour interview. It's a great show. But Craig is—I

1:26:23can't put—he's such a good interviewer. And Lisa Brennan Jobs is an incredibly engaging

1:26:28guest and they spent the first half of the show talking about the design of the cover.

1:26:33So I really, really liked it. But it really, I went from really having no interest in the

1:26:40book but wanting to hear how she was on my friend Craigmont's show to at the end of it

1:26:45being I've got to buy this book. And it is on Audible so you can get it. And the Audible

1:26:52version has the same great cover. So you'll know what they're talking about when you listen

1:26:56to that. That's Small Fry by Lisa Brennan Jobs. That's my recommendation. I'm going

1:27:00to read that. Anyway, when you become an Audible member, you can choose three titles every

1:27:04month, one audio book and two Audible originals that you can't hear anywhere else. Audible

1:27:09members also get access to exclusive audio fitness programs so you can start the new

1:27:13year off on the right foot fitness-wise. Listen on any device, anytime, anywhere, at the home,

1:27:18at the gym, on a commute, or just on the go. You can enjoy easy audio book exchanges, roll

1:27:24over credits and an audio book library that you keep forever even if you cancel when you

1:27:29buy books. Audible, the most inspiring minds, the most compelling stories, the best place

1:27:33to listen. Get started with a 30 day trial when you go to audible.com/talk show or text

1:27:42talk show to 500 500 and listen for a change. That's audible.com/talk show. What is left?

1:27:52You got Apple's financials that came out yesterday, end of the quarter. Now this is, in some ways,

1:27:59the least surprising quarterly announcement ever because a month ago, or at least four

1:28:03weeks ago, Tim Cook had issued this extraordinary warning letter to investors, warning that

1:28:09their guidance for the quarter they just reported was off by $7 billion, which sounds terrible,

1:28:16but then you realize they still made $84 billion, the second most in company history and therefore

1:28:22the second most in the history of corporations, period. Just to put perspective on it. And

1:28:33as everybody, you know, when he issued that letter at the beginning of January, they knew

1:28:40exactly where they were going to be. They said, "Look, it's going to be 84 billion."

1:28:43It ends up it was 84.3. But they, you know, they could announce something like their revenue

1:28:51as soon as the quarter's over. They've got systems in place and numbers. They knew

1:28:57that was going south. I don't know exactly. Maybe some of the stuff they report in these

1:29:02things does take some time to compile, but the big ticket numbers like the margin and

1:29:07revenue, they know right away. It's not like somebody's sitting there with a calculator

1:29:11for four weeks. Luca isn't there. 111, 375, 6.

1:29:15one three seven five. So there's tax stuff and yeah, I mean things like that that yeah,

1:29:20I you know, I think that there's some stuff that takes time to compile but you know when

1:29:24he said it's going to be 84 billion you could pretty much bet the house it was 84 billion.

1:29:29I seem to remember we because I used to work in the finance department at a company. I

1:29:34mean much obviously a bit smaller than Apple but it took us like two weeks to get the finance

1:29:42to get the financial reports out. It used to like when I got there it was like it was

1:29:46like a month and this was back in the mid 90s and and then we you know we one of the

1:29:51reasons I got hired was to implement a new financial system and so we did all this stuff

1:29:54and then eventually after we did all this stuff it took like two weeks.

1:30:00I you know what else is you know so in some ways it wasn't surprising but it was interesting

1:30:04to me it was the most interesting I was to read Tim Cook's prepared remarks in a number

1:30:10of quarters to see. So they they they famously did or not releasing iPhone units anymore,

1:30:17but they gave a lot of other information. Like what? Well, like one of the things they said,

1:30:23they said like 1.4 billion. They installed base, right? Well, they said that the number I saw was

1:30:31that the installed base, I think that's just talking iPhone. I don't think it was iOS devices,

1:30:35but whatever that even though the—

1:30:38No, he said iOS devices 1.4 billion and then he said—then they said iPhones was 900 million.

1:30:45Yeah, but one of those was up—the active user base was up 100 million for the year,

1:30:50even though sales year over year were down a bit. And the explanation for that,

1:30:56the common sense explanation for that is that with people using iPhones lasting longer,

1:31:03there are more older iPhones that are in use either through the secondhand market or through

1:31:09hand-me-downs within a family or among friends, where your kids are using iPhones. Previously,

1:31:16the parents and the parents have the new iPhone. And so even though only one new iPhone

1:31:20was bought by somebody who already had an iPhone, the installed base grows because the

1:31:24the hand-me-downs in use. What else was interesting? The China explanation, again, not surprising,

1:31:36but it was the first thing that he addressed, which is basically—

1:31:41- Yeah, it was like down 27% or something, right?

1:31:45- Yeah.

1:31:45I thought that, what was it?

1:31:49Was the iPhone revenue was down 19%, is that right?

1:31:54Or is that?

1:31:55It's like iPhone was down pretty bad.

1:31:58iPhone was down a lot, but everything else was up.

1:32:03Or no, that's it, the 19% was everything else.

1:32:06Apple's non-iPhone business grew 19%,

1:32:09but the iPhone business shrunk.

1:32:11And in some ways,

1:32:15I'm not trying to spin this as wow, this is good news,

1:32:21but in some ways, it's good news that the iPhone

1:32:26is looking like less of an outlier.

1:32:30It's less like the other aspects of Apple's business growing

1:32:35and the iPhone coming down to normal

1:32:38makes the company a little bit less lopsidedly.

1:32:42- Yeah, right, right.

1:32:43Well, it's been a complaint about Apple

1:32:44for a number of years is like, oh my gosh,

1:32:47they're so dependent on the iPhone

1:32:48as if something was gonna happen to the iPhone.

1:32:50But yeah, I mean, so if they're less dependent

1:32:55on the iPhone, that's probably a little bit better.

1:32:57- Right, like if you own five restaurants

1:33:00and 85% of your revenue comes from one of them,

1:33:04it's a little bit more worrisome.

1:33:07it's better if all five are a little bit,

1:33:09even if the one is more popular than the others,

1:33:11it's better if the others are pulling more of their weight

1:33:14in terms of the overall revenue and profits of the company.

1:33:17Mac is up, iPad, or revenue at least.

1:33:23Mac revenue is up, iPad revenue is up.

1:33:25Services revenue is way up.

1:33:27Although I've seen some stuff that,

1:33:32what exactly constitutes a service in Apple's accounting?

1:33:36much of that is smoke and mirrors and how much is legit? Because they don't break

1:33:41it down. They don't tell you, "This is from Apple Music. This is from iTunes Music

1:33:47and video sales."

1:33:49Why do you say smoke and mirrors?

1:33:51Well, because I think that they're accounting—I think some people speculate that they're

1:33:55accounting for some part of hardware sales as services. I don't know.

1:34:00Okay.

1:34:01I don't know.

1:34:02I don't know what that would be, though.

1:34:03I don't know. But that it's ambiguously enough to find that they can… I don't know. I'm not

1:34:10accusing them of any kind of fraud. I'm just saying I'm not sure that everybody buys that

1:34:14the services stuff is completely independent of hardware sales.

1:34:18Yeah. What about that margin on services?

1:34:22Did they say what it was? I didn't see that.

1:34:25Like 65%, right?

1:34:26Wow.

1:34:28or 60 something was 60 something percent. I can't remember if it was 65, but it was up there.

1:34:33Well, and some people are like, "Whoa, that's too much." Some of that comes out of the 30% thing,

1:34:43so that leads into that argument again. Well, but it makes you wonder because some of it can't be

1:34:47more than 30%, right? Because it's coming from a 70/30 revenue split, right? So it makes you

1:34:56wonder where the part that 60% comes from, you know? Allow me here to hit Insert. This is like

1:35:06the podcast equivalent of a text expander snippet. Let me insert my rant here that I

1:35:13worry deeply that Apple's focus on growing services revenue puts the company's financial

1:35:22interests at direct odds with the user experience of iCloud storage by keeping the free tier

1:35:31at a ridiculous 5GB. I don't think the paid tiers, any of them, are that out of line with

1:35:41what you pay for. To me, it's that free tier. 5GB just is not enough.

1:35:50I really just, I don't know.

1:35:54It just bothers me how many people aren't getting

1:35:58iCloud backups of their devices that could be.

1:36:02And the services thing where they're trying to make money

1:36:09from people by doing it, which isn't wrong,

1:36:11but I just wish the free tier was more

1:36:13and would encompass enough more for more people

1:36:17to be able to use it, to back up their entire device.

1:36:20At least like just back up one iPhone.

1:36:22- Right.

1:36:25Well you can, I mean isn't the backup now though is

1:36:29not backing up all the apps, right?

1:36:33- No, it doesn't back up the apps

1:36:35because you can redownload them from the app store.

1:36:37- Yeah, so depending on your device

1:36:40you could back up to a five gigabyte here.

1:36:42- Yeah, but I just feel like people's photo libraries alone.

1:36:45- I don't disagree with you, I'm just saying that.

1:36:47you could, you know, technically do it.

1:36:51- Yeah, I wonder, I would love to know,

1:36:52I'd love to know the numbers on that,

1:36:53what percentage of iPhone users can fit an entire backup

1:36:56in a five gigabyte plan.

1:36:59Or I guess the more interesting number

1:37:00is what percentage of the ones who are on the free plan

1:37:04can back up their device to iCloud.

1:37:07- Right.

1:37:09- You know, because I think that the whole,

1:37:11the fact that you still can back up to iTunes,

1:37:13you know, for free, you know,

1:37:15it's presuming your whatever Mac or PC you're running iTunes on has a free space for it.

1:37:19I would like to know what percentage of iPhone users even know that you can connect your iPhone

1:37:27to a PC running or Mac using iTunes and do a backup that way. I would guess it's tiny.

1:37:32I mean, I just don't think that's just not the way people use iPhones anymore.

1:37:36And I don't even know that it would occur to most people. I mean, my mom has an iPhone now.

1:37:44I don't think it would occur to her in a million years to connect it to her Mac by USB. Other

1:37:50than to charge it. And I don't really…

1:37:54I can't think of the last time. I used to do it for a long time. And that's the way

1:37:57I did it. I mean, I did it for like a crazy long time. But I have not done that in years.

1:38:02All right. Here's the numbers. Before anybody writes in the correct. So here's the right

1:38:11from the horse's mouth at Apple. Revenue from iPhone declined 15% from the prior year,

1:38:16while total revenue from all other products and services grew 19%. So that's it. 15% decline

1:38:21year over year for iPhone revenue. But in 19, everything else went up 19%.

1:38:25Yeah. iPad up 17%, right?

1:38:29Yeah. Which makes me think and, you know, unit sales are pretty flat, I think. Just makes it.

1:38:36Well, they don't break those out either.

1:38:38Oh, no, it's revenue. I don't know.

1:38:40Yeah.

1:38:40It's just hard not to think that that's the the iPad Pro is sure pretty popular, right, right

1:38:47Because it came out last quarter. So presumably a lot of people were waiting for a new iPad and bought the expensive iPad pros

1:38:54Yeah

1:38:56And it was expensive

1:38:57Yeah, I think I talked about that the last time I saw it was like it's like I got the back at the bottom line

1:39:05With just like a like a cover and it was like a thousand bucks practically. Yeah, I think it's pretty you know, there's a rumor

1:39:10I don't want to you know, we have enough news to cover that we can do it

1:39:13But there's rumors of upcoming iPad like regular iPad non pro updates and you know, the iPad mini apparently is

1:39:21Still alive and we'll be getting an update of some sort. Yeah, and the iPod touch. Yeah, and the iPod touch

1:39:27Which is yeah, that is interesting to me like it's on the one hand

1:39:32It's overdue for an update and then the other hand who's buying iPod touches, right?

1:39:37like I

1:39:38Genuinely ask because it seems to me like most people who even give a device like this to their kids are giving them old iPhones

1:39:45Probably right, you know and it's still the iPod touch is 300 bucks. So it's not like it's cheap, you know

1:39:53It's not like buying an iPod shuffle. Well, I know that mean certain I mean developers were buying them right for a while to test

1:39:59Yeah, but are they still versions? But again, I don't know. Yeah, I don't know I

1:40:04Don't have the numbers. I feel like that was a vestige of the era when there weren't a lot of quote-unquote old spare iPhones

1:40:10floating around everybody's house and now there are

1:40:13but you know, or is it like an institutional thing like, you know hospitals and

1:40:18Warehouses and anywhere else where people are running little, you know

1:40:23This leads me to a two-prong question. I guess like do you think that they are

1:40:28Just trying to increase the number of devices

1:40:33releases that they have in order to maximize like you know they know that the overall units

1:40:40are going to be continued to be flat I don't know in forward and are they just trying to

1:40:45to like get into more niches that they might have missed earlier in order to keep that

1:40:52service revenue going I don't know I really I don't know I would love to know who the

1:40:57market market is for iPod touch I mean you know and I've always thought I never bought

1:41:01I've never bought one. I've always thought it's adorable.

1:41:04I think it went through a couple of them, I think.

1:41:08I remember in the early days—forget if it was a WWDC. It probably was a WWDC because

1:41:16it might have already been after Macworld Expo was no longer a thing. But I just remember

1:41:21milling about the top floor of Moscone West before a keynote on a Monday or Tuesday, whatever

1:41:26day. And 45 minutes before they opened the doors, but there's coffee and donuts and

1:41:34there's hundreds and hundreds of people. And I saw somebody talking on the—or using

1:41:39an iPhone, and it was so clearly—I was like—my first thought was, "Holy shit, someone

1:41:45from Apple is here using a prototype iPhone. This is insane. Why would you do that?"

1:41:50Because it was so clearly thinner than the existing iPhones. And it turned out it was

1:41:55guy with an iPod touch. But without thinking about it, I thought it was next year's iPhone

1:42:00and it was amazing. And he's just out here using it in front of hundreds of people. I've

1:42:06always liked the product. It's always been intriguing to me, but I don't know anybody

1:42:09who buys them. So I don't know. I think what's interesting, what occurred to me with these

1:42:13rumors and just looking at the prices, you can get a new iPad starting at like, it's

1:42:18like 300 and some bucks.

1:42:20Yeah, and their sales on them are down to like below 300.

1:42:27And so to me, that really interesting, something I guess I knew, and everybody knows because

1:42:33it's out there, but I just had never really thought about is that the iPad lineup is very

1:42:40different than the Mac lineup, where the big complaint a lot of people have after last

1:42:45Fall's announcement of the new MacBook Air is, boy, Apple has a lot of MacBooks for around

1:42:52$1200 or $1300. The MacBook, the MacBook Air, and the MacBook Pro without the touch bar

1:42:59that have various trade-offs between them. But if you're kind of looking to spend $1300

1:43:07on a MacBook, you've got a widely variety. You've got three different, very different

1:43:12things to choose from. Whereas the iPad lineup is very differentiated by price, right? You've

1:43:18got like these $300 to $400 ones and then you've got these $1,000 plus ones. And I'm

1:43:25sure you can get a regular non-pro iPad and max out the storage and get it with cellular

1:43:32and get the price up, that there's ways to fill in those price gaps. But if you're

1:43:37really price sensitive, you're looking at it's very clear which one to buy. And if

1:43:41And if you're really looking to max out your iPad,

1:43:44it's very clear which one to buy.

1:43:45There's a lot, it's a lot more of a,

1:43:47it's a much more clear product lineup

1:43:49than the MacBook lineup.

1:43:51- Yeah.

1:43:52- You know.

1:43:53- You know, and what's interesting,

1:43:54we, so I got a new iPad

1:43:58and I gave my father-in-law my old iPad Air 2

1:44:03and 'cause he had an, he had my old iPad Air.

1:44:08And so I, you know, he was like,

1:44:09I'm not going to use the iPad Air if you want to take that back go ahead. So I took the iPad Air

1:44:13back and then I updated it and and it's it's still it's not a bad device. Well, it still does

1:44:20everything. Yeah. And it's really old now. Yeah, I Well, I think that is clearly now that again,

1:44:27they're not issuing. They're not telling you unit sales. But it seems as though the bleeding has

1:44:32stopped in terms of iPad selling, you know, going downhill in terms of unit sales. And my gut

1:44:38That feeling always has been, and I think it's starting to be backed up by what we see

1:44:42in the data, is simply that people buy an iPad and it just keeps working.

1:44:48And for what they use it for, it keeps working perfectly.

1:44:51Right.

1:44:52And that was like with the iPad Air 2, it was doing everything that I needed it to do,

1:44:56but I just thought, "Oh, I've had this for a number of years.

1:45:00I should get a new one now."

1:45:02I really do think that's the explanation for why they were selling like 10 million of them

1:45:08a quarter or 20 million a quarter and then went down to like 9, 10 million a quarter.

1:45:13It's just that in the initial run-up, nobody had an iPad and therefore all the people who

1:45:18kind of wanted one or could use one bought one. And a whole bunch of them are just still

1:45:22using them. And really, I see what people do. For playing Candy Crush and browsing the

1:45:30web, you really don't need a newer one. And they last. They're really well-made. I don't

1:45:36think they take nearly the abuse that a phone takes because they're not going in pockets and

1:45:40purses and right yeah the other thing he had he had the original like we had given him the original

1:45:45ipad again um and uh so he gave that back to me too that thing is a tank it's hilarious to hold

1:45:53one of those things now and the bezel on it oh my god yeah it's really big and and pregnant on the

1:46:00the back. It's very bulbous compared to the new ones. That whole bent iPad thing seems

1:46:08to have gone away. Remember? There was a mini scandal for a day that people were getting

1:46:15brand new iPad Pros and they were bent out of the box or too easily bent. And then Apple

1:46:20didn't issue a statement, but they issued an off-the-record "don't quote a statement"

1:46:25The Verge interpreted it as that's normal. But it seems like that died down and I haven't seen

1:46:32anything again. I was curious about how that would play out after the initial kerfuffle. Would people

1:46:38be able to say, "Look, here's one I just bought. It's clearly outside the four micrometers," or

1:46:45whatever the hell they were saying, the four sheets of paper thickness that's within their specs.

1:46:51Yeah, that seems like it went nowhere. Yeah, I mean, presumably, maybe it was just an early

1:46:59flaw in the production process or the shipping process or something and they stamped it out.

1:47:03Yeah, I don't know. I don't know. It seems like they got it. Yeah. All right, let me take a third

1:47:07break here and thank our friends at Squarespace. I love Squarespace. Look, you need a website.

1:47:12Do you have an idea for a new website? Do you have an old website that needs to be updated

1:47:16desperately, try Squarespace. Squarespace has everything you need for a website. You go there,

1:47:24you can register your domain, you pick out a template. They've got award-winning templates,

1:47:28really beautiful. Every Squarespace website looks so professionally made. And their templates,

1:47:34they scale from everything from the phone up to a giant display, responsive design.

1:47:39You need to sell stuff. You can drag and drop out a store right there on the site. They handle

1:47:45all the credit cards, all the security stuff. You want to start a blog, you want to start

1:47:48a podcast, you can do it right there on Squarespace. You have a Squarespace website and it doesn't

1:47:53have a blog but you decide you need a blog, you can just add a blog. And you do it all

1:47:58right there in the browser. It's all drag and drop, all visual, and they have award-winning

1:48:04technical support if you do get stuck. And they have a 30-day free trial. You get a free

1:48:10free trial, start today, build it, see if you like it, and then you only have to pay

1:48:16at the end of that period if you like it. You can't lose anything. So that's my advice.

1:48:21My advice is you need a new website, you have an older website that needs an upgrade, needs

1:48:26to be started over. Try it at Squarespace first. Give it an hour, give it half an hour

1:48:31even. See how far you get. You'll probably be surprised. It's really great. And people

1:48:37who listen to this show just keep signing up for Squarespace, which is great. Got a special deal

1:48:44for you. Start building your website at squarespace.com. And when you do pay,

1:48:48when your free trial's over, just remember this code, TALKSHOW. Know the talk show. All three

1:48:54sponsors today have same code, TALKSHOW. And you'll get 10% off your order. You can prepay for an

1:48:59entire year, save 10% off the entire year. It's a great service. My thanks to Squarespace. Go to

1:49:06to squarespace.com/talk show today. squarespace.com/talk show and just remember that code talk show

1:49:13when you check out.

1:49:14Well, what's else on your list? What else we got? Trying to think.

1:49:24Those stories were pretty big.

1:49:25Yeah, that was pretty big. Do you see the New York Times story on the Apple having trouble

1:49:29getting screws in Texas?

1:49:31Oh, yeah. Right. I did see that.

1:49:35Interesting, but seemingly, you know, I don't know. It's an interesting story

1:49:39It was interesting to hear the details about a specific component, but specific component

1:49:44I don't know where I can put the word specific, but it's gonna be it's new now

1:49:48It's in the lexicon

1:49:51What about Apple TV I wrote yesterday

1:49:58There was a rumor from November that the information had the information is usually pretty subscriber only but usually, you know

1:50:04their stuff pans out. And they didn't say Apple is coming out with a dongle, you know, one of these,

1:50:09like a Chromecast thing where you just plug it into an HDMI port. But some kind of, you know,

1:50:15instead of $150 to $200 Apple TV, something cheaper, like a dongle.

1:50:21- This is, yeah, I mean, one of our favorite, one of my pals on the rebound, one of our favorite

1:50:26saws is just how expensive and out of whack with the rest of the market the Apple TV is.

1:50:32And I feel I always joke about how particularly taken I feel for having gotten the one with a

1:50:39larger drive capacity. I did too. Why did I do that? That was 40 bucks or whatever. It's like

1:50:47just flushed down the drain. It's what's the there's the fear of missing out, right? There's

1:50:52Yeah. So I've got fear of running out of space. Right. So yeah, yeah. So I mean, if they're right,

1:51:00I mean, if they're, if the rumors of the streaming service are true, which they seem like they

1:51:06probably are, then it seems like they need to reduce that price a bit so that they can get

1:51:15that into more homes. Cause otherwise, you know, I mean, they're not going to, you got to run out

1:51:19and you got to buy $150 Apple TV, and then you got to pay whatever a month for the streaming service.

1:51:24That doesn't seem like that's going to go very far. Yeah. And really the way typical people think

1:51:28is they're, you know, as the world moves from everything you watch comes through your cable

1:51:35or your satellite, whatever traditional TV to a, I want to stream stuff over the internet. I want

1:51:41to get my net. I want to watch Netflix. I want to watch Hulu. I want to watch HBO, but not through

1:51:47my cable company or Amazon prime. Another perfect example, very popular, you know, I've got Amazon

1:51:53prime. So I know I've already, I've already got access to these stuff. I want to watch it. How do

1:51:58How do I do it? Option A from Amazon, Option B from Roku, $69 or $50 or something like

1:52:11that. Option C from Apple starts at $150 and it's $180 if you want 4K. It looks out of

1:52:20whack. It's not a little bit more expensive. It's a lot more expensive. I don't think

1:52:24it's surprising. Why does Apple charge so much more?

1:52:27One thing I've heard from reliable little birdie is Apple effectively sells them at

1:52:33cost. They really are like $180 box. You think like, "Wow, this is amazing. It has an A10

1:52:40processor," which we know is super fast and has crazy good graphics. I've heard the same

1:52:48thing about HomePod too. Why is HomePod so much more expensive than these other speakers

1:52:52you can talk to? Well, HomePod, I actually have reason to believe, is actually Apple

1:52:56actually sells it at a loss. Like, I don't know, I can't prove it. But you know, I don't

1:53:03think it's a big loss. You know, I've always thought that the and again, who knows, you

1:53:10know, over time, things get cheaper to make the same thing that was, you know, cost x

1:53:15in 2016 doesn't cost x it costs x minus something in 2018 because everything gets cheaper over

1:53:21time. But I always thought and I don't have any source on this other than the oddity of

1:53:25the price of AirPods that they're $159, which isn't—it's not an even price. Like,

1:53:32$149 is even because that's $150. I have always thought that AirPods probably cost—or

1:53:38at least did when they debuted—were like a $160 product.

1:53:45I know company-wide, Apple very famously has very high margins and somehow, almost to a

1:53:52a spooky degree company-wide. It always is right around—for years now in the Tim Cook

1:53:57era, there was more fluctuation in the jobs era. But in the Cook era, even though they're

1:54:02selling more stuff and you'd think there might be more fluctuation, it's very consistently

1:54:0538 to 39 percent company-wide margin. I think that with Apple TV and HomePod, they can sell

1:54:12them at little to no margin or even negative margin on HomePod and it doesn't really

1:54:17show up because the numbers are so low. It's spitting into the ocean.

1:54:21So, if anything, if you think it's a problem that these products are so expensive compared

1:54:30to their competition that too few people buy them, it's not because Apple is charging too

1:54:36much. It's because Apple engineered and designed too good of a product or too expensive of

1:54:44a product. People want to buy scooters and Apple's building motorcycles.

1:54:50But I think a dongle for Apple TV would make a lot of sense.

1:54:55And maybe a year or two ago you'd say, "Well, Apple wouldn't do that."

1:54:59But now that they're building iTunes into Samsung TVs this year, obviously not selling

1:55:05any kind of—even a $50 dongle to get your iTunes stuff on the Samsung TVs, what about

1:55:12the 10 gazillion TV sets that people have bought over the last five, six, seven, eight

1:55:17years that are perfectly happy with don't have iTunes built in. You know, like, building

1:55:23I, you know, having this announcement where these TVs from Samsung and Sony and these

1:55:28companies are all going to support AirPlay 2 out of the box. That's great to extend the

1:55:33reach of AirPlay, but there's a gazillion TVs that people aren't in any mood to replace

1:55:38that don't have any Apple stuff built in. So I would say, you know, like some kind of

1:55:45dongle that doesn't, you know, presumably wouldn't be able to offer the full Apple

1:55:49TV experience. I would say just skip the App Store and sort of build a dongle that works

1:55:53like the old Apple TV where you get what's built into it and that's it. You know, it's

1:55:57got iTunes and…

1:55:58Adam Boffa - Which seems like a, you know, a continuing series of nails in the coffin

1:56:03of the Apple TV App Store.

1:56:05Trenton Larkin Right.

1:56:06Adam Boffa - Because that does not seem to be going anywhere particularly.

1:56:09Trenton Larkin No. And if it, you know, and then Apple…

1:56:11Other than things that are streaming apps and that kind of thing

1:56:14But there's no like the gaming the gaming aspect of that is I mean

1:56:18I have not touched a game on the Apple TV and I can't remember how long I have and I have a control

1:56:24Yeah, I bought the Nimbus controller too and I don't nice controller, but yeah, it's not great though either. It's you know, yeah, it's alright

1:56:31No ever since we bought a switch. I haven't played I don't really play a lot on the switch either

1:56:36But if I'm gonna play games I play on the switch. I don't plan it TV. Yeah

1:56:41But if they were ever going to try to make a second run at making the Apple TV a gaming platform, you know, that might be

1:56:47You know, maybe that's the way to do it

1:56:50I feel like the critical error they made to have any hope of making Apple TV a gaming platform was not including a

1:56:55Controller in in the box. Yeah, I think we've talked about this before. Yeah, absolutely and requiring all games

1:57:03to work with the Apple TV remote as a gaming controller so that you can't even make a game that requires a

1:57:10a real gaming controller, even though it's not included in the box. Those two things

1:57:15combined were… I don't see how they ever hoped to get that off the ground. I really

1:57:21don't. I mean, whatever our complaints are about the Apple TV remote as a remote for

1:57:26watching videos, TV shows and video, and there are plenty in every podcast that even has

1:57:34mentioned Apple has mentioned all those problems. As a gaming controller, it is to gaming controllers

1:57:44what the stuff you make in a toilet in prison is to real booze.

1:57:47[Laughter]

1:57:48Tom Bilyeu (guest): Prison game controller.

1:57:53Tom Bilyeu (guest): Right? I mean, it's all you got, I guess, right? If you're on a desert

1:57:58island with an Apple TV and an Apple TV remote, I guess you'll play those games with the Apple

1:58:03TV remote, but it is not good. There's only so much interest you have in games that are

1:58:10like "Cannibalt" where it's like, "Just tap a button." And even there, the Apple

1:58:16TV remote, it isn't that good. Even as a single button controller, it's not that

1:58:21good. Did you see the other thing related to that, though, was the rumor about Apple

1:58:28having a subscription gaming service?

1:58:31Oh, yeah, right, right. That was I was trying to think of what the other thing was. Yeah,

1:58:33the second side of that coin. Right. Right. And, you know, we've you and I have both heard from

1:58:40little birdies that there's some some legitimacy, there is some legitimacy to that, not that we know

1:58:45it's going to happen, but that they've approached some people, they have approached people.

1:58:50And, you know, I think that totally makes sense. Because what are the three ways people

1:58:55entertain themselves with subscription media content. They subscribe to subscription music.

1:59:01They subscribe to subscription video where you watch TV and movies. How else do people

1:59:07entertain themselves? Video games, right? That's it. And we know Apple has Apple Music.

1:59:14We're 100% sure they're doing original video content. We don't know how they're going

1:59:17to charge for it, whether they're going to bundle it with Apple Music or do it separately,

1:59:21definitely doing it. So why not do it with games where they have a dominant position in mobile

1:59:27gaming, however bad their position is on TV gaming and PC gaming? And it sounded like it was not going

1:59:38to be the big name games. No, I don't think so. Because I don't ties into that because apparently

1:59:43it's going to be you. You can't sell them on on Android as well. Right? Yeah, the idea is they

1:59:50have to be iOS exclusive, right? Or at least, you know, as far as mobile platforms.

1:59:55Right, right. So you could do like a PC version and you could do, you could have a console version,

2:00:00but on mobile it would be iOS exclusive. And you could see why like the EA's of the world,

2:00:07the big companies wouldn't be interested anyway, because they want to make their money on their own.

2:00:10They're never going to agree to that.

2:00:12Right. You know, it sounds like something Apple should do and it sounds like something a company

2:00:19any interested in increasing services revenue should do.

2:00:23And it could be a good idea, you know,

2:00:24especially if they cultivate it and get a bunch of games

2:00:28and you just pay this one flat fee per month

2:00:31that you're willing to pay.

2:00:32And then all of the games that you get are both good

2:00:36and don't nickel and dime you to death

2:00:39for in-app purchases.

2:00:40- Yeah.

2:00:41And it's, the other thing that I thought was interesting

2:00:43about it sounded like the, I mean,

2:00:45it might be actually be of interest to,

2:00:47I mean, people have been saying, well, gosh,

2:00:48why would independent gamers be interested in this?

2:00:52The app store pricing is already so bad for them,

2:00:55but that they would get almost like a book deal.

2:00:58- Yeah, yeah.

2:00:59- You get a bunch of money upfront to do it,

2:01:01and then you get like a, you know, as your game is used,

2:01:05you get like a sort of a smaller amount

2:01:07that continues on presumably for a number of years.

2:01:10- Right, the idea that it would be like a book advance

2:01:12would take a lot of the uncertainty out of it, right?

2:01:16Where you can at least say,

2:01:17We don't know what our royalties will be going forward because we don't know how popular

2:01:20it would be.

2:01:21But if this upfront number looks like it's, you know, hey, that's already makes it worth

2:01:27our while to try it, you know, it would take a lot of the uncertainty out of it.

2:01:32They certainly have the market, you know, in terms of the installed base multiplied

2:01:37by the number of developers who already are writing games for the platform.

2:01:41So I don't know.

2:01:42I buy it.

2:01:43I would encourage…

2:01:44- That's really very interesting.

2:01:45Yeah, I mean, depending on the games that are involved,

2:01:47but I mean, I don't get many games anymore,

2:01:52but I'm not gonna care what I used to get.

2:01:55- I'll sign up for it and then never play any games.

2:01:58(laughing)

2:02:00But you know what, Amy and Jonas play a lot of games

2:02:02on their iOS devices.

2:02:04So assuming that the subscription will work

2:02:06at the family plan. - Maybe that's the thing.

2:02:07- It would actually-- - Yeah, right.

2:02:08I wonder how I assume that it would work

2:02:10for the family plan.

2:02:11- Yeah, so if it's 10 bucks for a person and 15

2:02:14add it to your family plan. The way my family plays games on mobile devices, even without me,

2:02:19it would be easily worth it. Easily. So I don't know. I say go Apple Go with that idea.

2:02:25Yeah. No, that's that aspect is makes it probably definitely financially worth my while.

2:02:32That's it for me, John. It's always good to have you in the show. I spent too long.

2:02:38Always nice to be here.

2:02:38We didn't have you on in 2018 enough. We're going to make 2019 a year of molt on the talk show.

2:02:42Oh, excellent. I'm happy to hear that. I'll see. I'll see in December.

2:02:46Everybody can get all the bolts they want on on other podcasts, including turning this car around.

2:02:57Where do you go for turning this car around? You could search for it in your remember,

2:03:02I guess, this car around net or com. So yeah, you go to iTunes and you search for turning this car

2:03:09That's regular regular Mac nerdery Mac and Apple nerdery at the the rebound correct and you can just same place

2:03:17Go to iTunes. Yeah, just or overcast or whatever your podcast is. Yes, sir. Sure the rebound you find it

2:03:22Anyway good talking to you or just drive by my house. Yeah, just free Wi-Fi

2:03:28Bye.