0:00:00How are you, Jason?
0:00:01I'm doing good. I'm doing good. It's been a busy fall.
0:00:05Apple did a lot of stuff this fall, kept, I think, all of us really busy,
0:00:08so it's kind of nice to almost relax a little bit at the end of the year.
0:00:13Yeah, I'm almost at that point.
0:00:14But I still have, like, a bunch of really good articles,
0:00:17or at least I think good articles, that I've been meaning to write,
0:00:19and I really cannot believe that I may not get to them all by the end of the year.
0:00:23Like, I thought, "This'll be great. I've got—I want to write about this marzipan stuff."
0:00:27I have a couple of them, but, and they're all still in gestational form. But it's not for lack
0:00:36of work, and it's not for lack of other things that I have written about, etc. It's just a lot
0:00:41going on. Well, Apple this year, and a little bit last year, they staggered all their releases,
0:00:46right? So you got one set of phones, and then the next phone, and then the iPads and the Macs,
0:00:51and it just was a very stretched out period. So there was like, there's always something else
0:00:56else happening right around the corner that required sometimes travel, sometimes spending
0:01:03a lot of time focusing on a particular product and right and then so you know this that you
0:01:07end up with this just six weeks, eight weeks where you your time kind of isn't your own
0:01:13because there's always another thing that's popping up.
0:01:16Yeah, totally. Let's lead with the news, the hot news, which may or may not be. It'll either
0:01:25be a totally different story by the time this podcast airs. We're recording on Friday, December
0:01:2821st. I don't expect the show to air till Monday. So who knows what will happen over the weekend.
0:01:35But there's things I want to say about it that should hold up no matter what happens. But it's
0:01:40the new Ben Gate with iPad Pros. Oh, yeah. Oh, boy. Oh, boy. So it started, I think, two days ago
0:01:49with a report at the verge by Chris Welch. And the headline of the piece was,
0:01:57Apple confirms some iPad pros ship slightly bent, comma, but says it's normal.
0:02:06And, you know, and he describes reports from people online,
0:02:12Mac rumors, forums, etc. People with some photographs of iPads that show a slight bend.
0:02:19And then he claims is the most intriguing part to me is he claims that he purchased a brand new one.
0:02:25And in retail, and out of the box, it was slightly bent, which, you know, and not to denigrate people
0:02:32who contribute to the fine forms at Mac rumors and other sites, but it's, you know, it's a lot
0:02:36more credible than when a byline staff writer at the verge says he's seen it. The headline certainly
0:02:43certainly didn't help. And he did talk to Apple, but he did not have a quote from Apple.
0:02:52You know, it's and you and I, again, this is inside baseball, but I think it explains
0:02:56a lot is, you know, I speak to representatives at Apple PR frequently I have spoken to them
0:03:02about this particular issue because I had some questions. And for the most part, when
0:03:06you speak to Apple PR, it is off the record. When you do get something from Apple on the
0:03:12record. It is, in my experience, always in the form of a very carefully written statement
0:03:19that they will email to you and tell you, you know, you can attribute this to an Apple
0:03:23spokesperson and basically they are extremely careful with their words and they want to
0:03:31get it in writing. And you know, just extemporaneous conversations over the telephone or, or whatever
0:03:39they know people don't speak as carefully as they do when writing.
0:03:43I mean, this very podcast is evidence of the same phenomenon.
0:03:47Exactly.
0:03:48And so The Verge reached out. They obviously spoke to Apple. Apple said something that
0:03:55The Verge paraphrased as, you know, that this is, that there's slight bends are normal.
0:04:01I have a feeling, and I'm not trying to hold this against Chris Welch or The Verge or anybody.
0:04:08I have a feeling that they didn't use the word normal.
0:04:11None of the words were in quotes.
0:04:13I don't have any doubt that it's not an unreasonable
0:04:17paraphrasing of their summary, but I really, really doubt.
0:04:21The paraphrasing that The Verge went with
0:04:23made Apple seem very flippant about the issue.
0:04:25And I don't, I think people who read that were rightfully,
0:04:29whether they have a bent iPad Pro or not,
0:04:32and we should get into,
0:04:35is this actually a major problem or not?
0:04:37But even if you don't have a bent one,
0:04:39it certainly seems like an alarming attitude.
0:04:42- Yeah, it's the, it reminds me of back
0:04:47when Apple made its own displays
0:04:49and there was a certain number of dead pixels
0:04:52that were allowable.
0:04:55And it was like, literally,
0:04:56you'd get a brand new display from Apple,
0:04:58you take it home and there'd be dead pixels.
0:05:02And I forget exactly what the policy was.
0:05:03It was a certain number or in a certain place
0:05:05within a certain distance from one another. There was a whole thing. But in the end, what
0:05:11that policy said was, if we have dead pixels in a monitor you bought, it's fine. Even if
0:05:19you don't think it's fine, trust us, it's fine. And we don't consider that a defect.
0:05:25Or it's like a discoloration or other some sort of like visible flaw that the and a company
0:05:33says, "We don't consider that a replaceable issue. It's just, yeah, sure, some of them
0:05:38have weird flaws and you just have to deal with it." For a premium product, you would
0:05:44think that the company's attitude should probably be, "If this makes you uncomfortable, bring
0:05:50it back and we'll give you another one." If they're not saying that, part of me thinks
0:05:54that they have too many of these that are like this. It's weird because nobody's really
0:06:00saying that it gets worse, right? It's part of the production process. So the question
0:06:04is, is this something that they saw in the production process and we're like, Meh, it's
0:06:08fine. Nobody will notice because I can't believe anybody at Apple would ever say nobody will
0:06:13notice about anything ever because everything will be noticed. Yeah. And my conversation
0:06:19with some people at Apple PR yesterday was along those lines of that. They, they don't
0:06:24think this is, they definitely do not think this is a major issue. They, I think it's
0:06:28it's probably going to blow over. So I think this conversation is, at this point, I think
0:06:33it was worth having on the show to talk to you more about how Apple works and how these
0:06:38things work than this particular issue. We shall see.
0:06:40- Kind of a time capsule. I also would not be surprised if the end result of this is
0:06:44Apple releases a statement saying, "If anybody gets something like this and they don't like
0:06:49it, we will replace it."
0:06:50- Yeah.
0:06:51- And just, that's it.
0:06:52- That would be the next level. So there is actually the closest thing to a statement
0:06:56I think so far. Somebody emailed Dan Riccio and got an email back. And MacRumors verified
0:07:04that it looks like it actually came from Dan Riccio. And here's what Dan Riccio said, "Relative
0:07:09to the issue you referenced regarding the new iPad Pro, its unibody design meets or
0:07:14exceeds all of Apple's high-quality standards of design and precision manufacturing. We've
0:07:19carefully engineered it and every part of the manufacturing process is precisely measured
0:07:24and controlled. Our current specification for iPad Pro flatness is up to 400 microns,
0:07:31which is even tighter than previous generations. I think that phrase is interesting. This 400
0:07:37micron variance is less than half a millimeter, or the width of fewer than four sheets of
0:07:42paper at most. And this level of flatness won't change during normal use over the lifetime
0:07:47of the product. Note, these slight variations do not affect the function of the device in
0:07:54anyway. Now I actually have a statement from Apple PR that I haven't published at Daring
0:08:02Fireball, but it is Dan Riccio obviously is aware of their official statement because
0:08:08it is extremely close. But anyway, so the thing that Riccio is saying is that their
0:08:17tolerance for flatness on this iPad is better, higher, tighter, whatever you want to say,
0:08:22better than previous generations. So however big a variance 400 microns is and it the to
0:08:30normal scale, I looked it up 400 microns is point four 0.4 millimeters. So is that a lot?
0:08:36I said this is the thing I don't know. I don't know. Is that a lot? Like if you gave handed
0:08:40me a brand new iPad that had 400 microns of non flatness, would I be able to would I pick
0:08:47it up and say, Hey, this iPad is bent? Or is that the sort of thing that like maybe
0:08:51my iPad is bent a few hundred microns and I don't notice it. I don't know.
0:08:57Yeah, I have been sitting here, so I have an 11 and a 12.9 iPad Pro sitting in front of me right
0:09:02now and I've been looking at them and honestly after a while I can't tell like the optical
0:09:08illusion. I start to see bends that I think aren't there and this has to do with your focal length,
0:09:13you know, the focus of your eyes and where the stripes are on them, like the cellular antennas,
0:09:19all of these things kind of feed in and then you kind of lose track. Although our friend,
0:09:25Dr. Drang, who is an engineer and gets this stuff at a kind of a structural level, did
0:09:32say to you today, "As devices get thinner, every out of straightness becomes more noticeable."
0:09:37And I think there's some interesting truth in that, the idea that the thickness of the
0:09:42device is so much less now that any deviation out of true is more is potentially more noticeable.
0:09:50I don't know. I mean you put these down. That's the thing about that some of these visible
0:09:54bends that are in some of these photos on the internet is I look at that and I think
0:09:58that can't be that can't be four tenths of a millimeter right bend. That's got to be
0:10:02more than that. That's got to be the kind of thing where Apple should be like yeah where
0:10:07that's that's not acceptable. It shouldn't have gotten out of our factory and we'll replace
0:10:11it for you. Yeah, that's what I think with some of the photos. But again, I don't know,
0:10:16you know, certainly seems like it but it is true that this is the thinnest iPad ever made.
0:10:21It's only five point so you know, for scale 5.9 millimeters thick overall. The camera
0:10:27bump is by my measurements with a handy dandy little digital caliber I bought this year,
0:10:33which is like seriously can't believe I didn't buy one before because it was only like 20
0:10:38It's a little over two millimeters.
0:10:41I have it at like 2.1 millimeters,
0:10:43but you know, one 10th of a millimeters, you know,
0:10:46who knows?
0:10:48So we could even call it two millimeters.
0:10:50But what they're saying is an out of variance
0:10:52or within acceptable variance and flatness
0:10:55is like one fifth of the camera bump.
0:10:58I don't know, that sounds like it could be noticeable.
0:11:01- I don't know, on a thin product that's very long,
0:11:05like the long side of the 12.9 model, maybe.
0:11:08But it is, yeah, this is weird.
0:11:11One of the things, I mean,
0:11:12talk about taking it up to like how Apple does things
0:11:15and looking at it at that level.
0:11:18This reminds me of some other stuff
0:11:19where there's an initial reaction
0:11:21and then there's some investigation
0:11:22and then there's obviously a policy conversation
0:11:26that happens inside of Apple
0:11:27and then a PR conversation that happens inside of Apple.
0:11:31And sometimes when Apple doesn't have a response,
0:11:33it's because they are formulating a response, right?
0:11:37They're figuring it out and they don't want,
0:11:38I remember with a couple of controversies
0:11:40in the past few years,
0:11:41I had those ongoing conversations with Apple
0:11:43where they're like, I don't have a statement for you yet.
0:11:46Or I've got this statement, but it's kind of wishy-washy
0:11:48and we'll work on the next one.
0:11:51Because yeah, it may be that they don't,
0:11:53they haven't seen as many of these.
0:11:55They don't know that they know
0:11:56what their allowed variance is,
0:11:58but maybe there's someplace where things
0:11:59that are more bendy are getting out.
0:12:02I think what's most interesting to me is the fact that their attitude is that this is just
0:12:06a cosmetic defect and that it's not going to get worse. It's not that big a deal. That's
0:12:13good, right? Because I think it's a much bigger story if these things are bending in actual
0:12:18use and are going to break because then it's a major problem for everybody who bought one.
0:12:24But if it's just that some of them have a cosmetic defect, probably the right thing
0:12:29to do though if your Apple is to say yes if you get one bring it back and we'll get you
0:12:34a one that isn't because that you know if you can notice four tenths of a millimeter
0:12:39of a variance or beyond then you shouldn't you know we shouldn't make you look at that
0:12:45on your seven eight nine ten you know thousand dollar product right like it's just just we'll
0:12:50take it back we want you to be happy yeah and one of the things that ties into this
0:12:54story is and there's certainly a recurring theme of the last quarter of
0:12:59Apple products is the prices that they charge and that you have to pay I mean
0:13:04the iPad Pro is a premium tablet I mean there's no question about it and so that
0:13:09you know the the a side of the argument is you know just about whether the
0:13:15prices are too high or are they pricing themselves you know pricing loyal
0:13:18customers out of their best products etc etc the B side though is that somebody
0:13:23happily pays the price or even unhappily but pays it certainly has a reasonable expectation
0:13:30for the cost of an iPad Pro that they're going to be extremely pleased with the way that it looks as
0:13:36they take it out of the box. Absolutely 100 percent right it's a that comes back to it's a premium
0:13:41product. Apple is playing in the premium product game here and if you it would be the same as if
0:13:47people discovered that sometimes the aluminum backs had weird blob colors on them of the
0:13:53wrong, like the space gray got lighter or darker in patches and it was all patchy. And
0:14:01Apple would be like, "Nah, it's fine." Like, "No, it's not fine. I paid $1,000 for this
0:14:05thing and you got blobs on the back and I don't care that it's part of your production
0:14:09process and that you've determined that this many shades of gray off of space gray is allowable
0:14:15and that it's not gonna get any worse.
0:14:17- Right.
0:14:18- I paid $1,000 for a product that has ugly blobs
0:14:22on the back and that's not acceptable to me.
0:14:24- Yeah, it's like when you buy a car, you buy a new car
0:14:28and you pick out the car and then they wait and it comes
0:14:32and then the guy says, "Your car's here,"
0:14:33and then you go, you pick it up.
0:14:35And then it's like you walk around the car
0:14:39and you double check that, I'd say it's a brand new car.
0:14:42You walk around the car and you make sure
0:14:45everything is just right.
0:14:47And then you sign off that everything's just right,
0:14:50they sign off that everything's just right,
0:14:52and you drive off the lot.
0:14:53And then Stone hits your windshield or something like that,
0:14:56and you get a mark, or you're in a parking lot,
0:15:00somebody dings your door, that's life with a new car.
0:15:04But you know you didn't get it like that, right?
0:15:08- Right.
0:15:09- There wasn't a bend in the door.
0:15:11Apple can't afford, like a thousand dollar iPad
0:15:13isn't enough to justify that you get a, let's verify that it's mint one on one with an Apple
0:15:20specialist as you buy it. And a lot of us prefer to buy mail order rather than, you
0:15:27know, you know, it's a lot easier just to listen for the doorbell than to go to the
0:15:30Apple store. So it doesn't quite scale to that sort of thing. And the prices aren't
0:15:34quite commensurate. You know, a thousand dollar iPad is a lot for a tablet, but it's not a
0:15:38a $40,000 car. But it's on that spectrum. Like if your $129 Chromebook has a one-millimeter
0:15:47bend, it's like, well, that's life with a $100 plastic Chromebook.
0:15:51Yeah. Yeah. Well, that's, yeah, exactly right. Yeah. I'm going to scream bloody murder a
0:15:55lot less if I'm buying a $300 product than a $1,000 product.
0:15:59All right. Here is Apple's official statement, which is very similar to what I read from
0:16:04Dan Riccio is the new iPad Pro with its gorgeous unibody design meets or exceeds all of Apple's
0:16:10high quality standards of design and precision manufacturing. We've carefully engineered
0:16:14it and every part of the manufacturing process is precisely measured and controlled. Our
0:16:20current specification for iPad Pro flatness is up to 400 microns, which is even tighter
0:16:25than previous generations. These slight variations do not affect the function of the device in
0:16:29anyway. So you could see Dan Riccio was involved, was familiar with the preparation of the official
0:16:37comment. I found it funny that he didn't include the opening line of the new iPad Pro with its
0:16:42gorgeous unibody design because... Little salesmanship there. Yeah, it's like,
0:16:48screw that, I'm not selling this thing, but I'm gonna, you know, talk about the precision.
0:16:52So it does, you know, who knows that? And again, to me, the most interesting part of that is that
0:16:58it's a tighter tolerance than previous generations. And so who knows, maybe there've been whatever
0:17:03is going on out there in the field with these things. Maybe it's been going on with iPads
0:17:07for 10 years and nobody really noticed because until it got this thin with these exact flat
0:17:16sides, it wasn't noticeable. You know, maybe that, that, that really interesting trick
0:17:22that they've been using for years to curve the aluminum on the back disguised a significant
0:17:29amount of non-flatness. And nobody noticed.
0:17:32Right. And you throw in the existence of a camera bump, and then it's easy to wave things
0:17:38away as saying, "Well, who can tell because there's this part that sticks out?" So I can't
0:17:43even tell. Yeah. I mean, the idea that it's down from their previous standard is fascinating,
0:17:49fascinating, right? So it's like it used to be more than maybe more than half a millimeter
0:17:52of bend in a run of aluminum. They'd be like, yeah, it's fine. And maybe nobody noticed
0:17:57and there's just something about this model. I'm still not entirely convinced that these
0:18:02photos that we're seeing are not items that are beyond Apple standard that somehow got
0:18:07out there. And that Apple's going to say, yeah, those shouldn't be out there. And if
0:18:13you can see it and it's that big, then you should get that replaced. That's our failing
0:18:17on letting that out. Yeah, like maybe I don't know, maybe you would think that if it bent
0:18:22in transit, you would notice a damaged box. But like I presume that that with a lot of
0:18:29this stuff and I know with certain components they certainly do. You know, when they check
0:18:33the they've they've even bragged about it in their product marketing videos about the
0:18:39the way that they automate, you know, the precision of verifying that the S this component
0:18:43meets our specs with fancy sensors and stuff like that. I would just presume that the unibody
0:18:49aluminum is measured for preciseness through a systematic way, let's say.
0:18:57Right, right. There's actually a test it has to pass and presumably they're testing all
0:19:02of them or at least, or maybe not, maybe they're testing samples and some can get through or
0:19:09it wasn't calibrated right because these are very fine measurements that are happening
0:19:13and some overly bent ones got through. I don't know.
0:19:15Dave Asprey Right. It's possibly because she's on my
0:19:17mind because she just passed away, Penny Marshall. But I think of the opening credits of Laverne
0:19:22and Shirley where they were inspecting bottles of just a linch of beer.
0:19:26Jeff
0:19:26And she sticks a glove on the beat and it goes through the whole assembly line with
0:19:31her rubber glove on it.
0:19:32Yeah, and there's just hundreds of iPads flying past two people who aren't really
0:19:36paying attention.
0:19:38Or it's that I Love Lucy sketch, right, where they're trying to take the candy and
0:19:42all that and it's just out of hand. And yeah, that's it. The people with the calipers
0:19:46are on the assembly line trying to measure the iPads. It's like, "Oh, there's too
0:19:49many iPads."
0:19:50Right. It takes like two minutes to measure it correctly. And yet they're coming by
0:19:55at like four per minute. Just like, Oh, God, I'm gonna get fired. They're good. Good. It
0:20:01looks fine. That one didn't bend. It's fine. I don't know. One thing, too. The other thing
0:20:05that's interesting when you know Apple, the people at Apple PR, and I think it I think
0:20:12it's a tremendous advantage that they have being a completely in house team, you know,
0:20:16and I think one thing other people don't. I think that the industry has sort of moved
0:20:20moved in Apple's way. But Apple was unique in that way for a long time where most tech
0:20:23companies used outside PR firms. Oh, yeah. I mean, like we worked with what was a wagon
0:20:30or Edstrom was Microsoft's PR. Yeah. Or Edelman. Well, well, yeah. So Wag Ed was the PR firm
0:20:37for Microsoft forever for a long time. And then Edelman, they hired eventually to do
0:20:40the Mac PR, right? But it was like outside PR, right? Like they would be and you'd have
0:20:46these back when I was a macro like you'd have these three way email exchanges where it was
0:20:54like a weird negotiation between you and the company and the PR person which is like yeah
0:21:02right whereas with Apple it was always my entire time dealing with Apple there was always
0:21:06inside PR at Apple like that was that was who you dealt with you didn't deal with outside
0:21:10PR.
0:21:11Well, one of the reasons that it's an advantage for them is just clarity of communication.
0:21:19But the other thing is that—and this has happened before, like, you know, these little
0:21:22mini—I don't even want to call them scandals—kerfuffles, you know, it's certainly not a scandal yet,
0:21:28but hubbub, whatever you want to call them.
0:21:31They, you know, part of the reason that they're like, "We're on it, we're looking into it,"
0:21:36But they do things and they can do things like check with retail and say is this you know
0:21:44are you guys seeing a an
0:21:47Unusual number of complaints of customers with new iPad pros with a bend, you know, what's going on? Like they
0:21:54They're not just guessing, you know
0:21:57They actually go and double check is is there like an issue that should have raised a red flag that we haven't noticed in the data
0:22:04of
0:22:06You know the aggregate issues coming into the Genius Bar and I was told no there is at you know
0:22:11There's absolutely nothing unusual in their support increase regarding
0:22:15recent purchasers of iPad pros
0:22:18So, I don't know what's going on well the problem I say this every time there's a gate right the problem is that
0:22:26anecdotal
0:22:28Anecdotes and it's not even anecdotal evidence anecdotes posted on the internet are
0:22:34very hard to gauge whether it's 0.001%, 0.1%, 1% or 10% of products that are experiencing
0:22:45any given failure. And Apple ships so many, especially of iPhones, which is when the gates
0:22:51usually happen, right? The gates open when an iPhone is released. There's so many iPhones
0:22:55that are sold that even if it's 0.001%, there could be thousands of lemons that Apple has
0:23:04produced so that it can be it's a tough game like if you produce even a tiny number of
0:23:08lemons percentage wise and it's a huge product you you know there are bad phones that are
0:23:13getting out there so for the iPad this is one of those examples where it's like are
0:23:18there 10 weird bendy iPads out there and one of them happened to go to a Mac rumors reader
0:23:25are there a thousand but only five people have noticed are there 10,000 like that I
0:23:31don't know. Like there's no real way to know and you can react and poo-poo it and say,
0:23:36"But it's probably not a problem." Or you can freak out and say, "Oh my god, all the
0:23:39iPads are bent." But the truth is somewhere in this range that is an uncomfortably wide
0:23:44range of it being incredibly minor and the end of the world. And it's hard to tell because
0:23:52the internet magnifies. If somebody finds something wrong with an Apple product in terms
0:23:56of its manufacturer and posts it on the internet, it will get amplified, right? It will become
0:24:00the next potential scandal?
0:24:03You know what it is? The internet makes something possible that would have been impossible when
0:24:09you and I were kids. It allows these people to find each other. If there are 50 people
0:24:18who've received truly defective bent iPad Pros and they're upset about it and they start
0:24:25Googling 2018 iPad Pro shipped bent. They are going to find each other. Like a query,
0:24:32you know, like you don't have to be, you know, everybody's kind of gotten good at Googling,
0:24:37right? You know, right. And also, then you places, you know, you can go like that. People
0:24:42go to MacRumors or people go to the Apple discussion forums. Like there are certain
0:24:45places that people are you go. There's a lot of these things, not necessarily for Apple,
0:24:50but in general, come out of Reddit, right? Because somebody just posts in an interest
0:24:53group in Reddit about the product that they have a problem with and it kind of goes viral,
0:24:59which is the that's the trick, right? It's like if it's the right person with the bad
0:25:03product and there's literally only one, it still can get magnified. Or if there are literally
0:25:09only five, but there could be 10,000 like you just can't tell.
0:25:13All right, let me take a break and thank our first sponsor. It's Linode. Now I've been
0:25:19pronouncing it line node and I know it's a running gag on this show that I pronounce
0:25:23things wrong. But I've been informed not by them, they haven't complained. But I've been
0:25:29informed by several people out there in the show that I should be pronouncing it Linode
0:25:32in the same way that Linux is not Linux.
0:25:36I'm with you. I had a Linode server for like 10 years and then I got the ad copy and I
0:25:42discovered that somebody said it's pronounced like Linux. It was actually in my ad copy
0:25:47for whoever was like Lex Friedman or somebody put it in there and I was like, oh, like I
0:25:52no idea. You know what, I'm gonna make that a new year's resolution for 2019. Then I'm
0:25:57gonna need I need all of my ad reads spelled out phonetically phonetically just assume
0:26:01on your hands everything wrong. It certainly looks like line node. It certainly makes sense
0:26:07because of the Linux thing that it would be pronounced Linode instead. Either way, it
0:26:11is a tremendous hosting service. So you can pronounce it however you want. It's l i n
0:26:16ODE and they allow you to deploy and manage an SSD server in their Linode
0:26:22cloud and you can get a server running in seconds literally they say like 30
0:26:27seconds you can just have a new server instance up and running with your choice
0:26:31of Linux distribution resources and node location they've got 10 10 data centers
0:26:39worldwide so if you if the actual physical location of your data center
0:26:44and that ping times to other resources in a region matter to you. They've,
0:26:48they've got them spread all around the globe. Literally plans start at one gig
0:26:53of Ram for your instance for just $5 a month.
0:26:59That's just tremendous. And they've got a special deal for talk show listeners.
0:27:04You get $20 credit with code. I'll tell you at the end.
0:27:07So that means you could get a server for four months with the code. It's crazy.
0:27:12four months of like a top tier world class SSD server.
0:27:18You can configure your memory as much as you want.
0:27:20They've got high memory plans that start at 16 gigabytes.
0:27:23If you need more, you can get more.
0:27:26Seven day money back guarantee.
0:27:27So if you cough up the money, you get started.
0:27:30Something about it makes you unhappy.
0:27:32You have seven days to get all of your money back.
0:27:34That's how confident they are.
0:27:36And they really do allow you to get a new server instance up
0:27:40and running just by clicking a few buttons.
0:27:42It's super easy, super quick.
0:27:43They have a great, great interface
0:27:46for managing all of this stuff.
0:27:50Just a great dashboard interface.
0:27:53Hourly billing with a monthly cap on all plans
0:27:55so you won't get surprised if something happens
0:27:57and you're not gonna unexpectedly get a huge bill.
0:27:59Native SSD search, that's really important.
0:28:02I know that's the way the whole world's going,
0:28:05but you don't wanna have an important server
0:28:06running with a spinning hard drive.
0:28:07That's irresponsible.
0:28:08Go SSD all the way.
0:28:10Anyway, it's just a great service.
0:28:15I paid for it.
0:28:16It is actually what I use.
0:28:18I would endorse them
0:28:19even if they weren't sponsoring the show.
0:28:21That's, they're a great company
0:28:22with a tremendous reputation and a great support team.
0:28:26And they're hiring.
0:28:28So you can go to linode.com/careers
0:28:31if you are the sort of person who works in a field
0:28:33where you might work for a hosting company,
0:28:37programming, network administration, that sort of thing.
0:28:41They're doing so well, they're hiring.
0:28:42So go check out linode.com/careers
0:28:45if you're looking for work.
0:28:46And anyway, here's the deal.
0:28:4820 buck credit for everybody who listens to the show
0:28:51by going to linode.com/thetalkshow.
0:28:56And then the promo code, that's not quite enough.
0:28:59The promo code you gotta remember is talkshow2018.
0:29:02T-A-L-K-S-H-O-W 2018.
0:29:06My thanks to Linode, great sponsor, great company. I sold t-shirts last week.
0:29:15I saw that.
0:29:16Hoodies too. Everybody's getting them. It's always exciting to me. The part where you're
0:29:21selling them is more, I mean, it's nice and, you know, like I have my little email set
0:29:27up to, like it's a trick I learned from Jim Kudol. I don't know if they still do it because
0:29:32Field Notes has gotten so big, but Kudol had a thing set up at Field Notes so that when
0:29:36everybody, whenever somebody bought field notes, it played its specific sound. I think
0:29:41it was just a simple mail filter, but it's like that sound was one thing and one thing
0:29:45only, which was a sale of field notes. And so I have that set up for the t-shirts and
0:29:51it's nice. You hear it. Oh, dang, dang. At least people are buying them, you know, but
0:29:54to me the fun part is when people start getting them on Twitter and they start posting pictures
0:29:58of, of wearing them or doing them. I did stickers this time for the first time. I don't know.
0:30:05I need to start moving faster, Jason. I feel like 2018 is way too long.
0:30:10People love stickers. They love them. People like pins too, apparently, but I've never done the
0:30:16pins. I never got pins, but I started doing pins last year and people love pins too. So it's one
0:30:21of those things where you got to get outside yourself and say, "I don't particularly do a lot
0:30:24of stickers or pins, but people love them and that's fine." And the t-shirts. Yeah, we just did
0:30:29a bunch of stuff for comparable and relay and all that. Everybody's doing the merch because it's the
0:30:34the holidays and all of that. It is fun to see those pictures come in on Twitter. And
0:30:38I'm jealous because I haven't gotten mine yet, so I'm seeing other people with them
0:30:41before I get my, you know, my incomparable pin or my—Mike and I did a "Dongletown"
0:30:47t-shirt this year, which is in the style of like the Hollister, California, you know,
0:30:53those kind of t-shirts. But it's for "Dongletown." It's got a little USB-C port and it says
0:30:59Port Authority on it.
0:31:00Yeah, that's good. That's very funny.
0:31:02So I'm looking forward to getting my dongle town shirt and mystify everybody in,
0:31:06in my town who doesn't understand computers.
0:31:09Donkle town port authority would be a,
0:31:11a not bad name for like the store at the airport where you buy,
0:31:16you know, you know that store at the Cupertino airport,
0:31:20there's a dongle town port authority, right? You know, the store for, you know,
0:31:23you forgot your USB charger. Actually. Oh man, we should get,
0:31:27get on trademarking that. I know. That'll be the place you go for all your adapters.
0:31:30Or maybe it's just like a little vending machine or something for all your adapters. I realized
0:31:34switching to the iPad Pro, I now have, I already was embarrassed because I have a pair of wired
0:31:39headphones that I love that I have a carry around in a little carrying case. And I always
0:31:46felt bad because I had the little white lightning to headphone jack adapter in there. And now
0:31:53I also have the little light lightning USB-C adapter. So I have to choose and the other
0:32:00day I was working and I was listening to something on my iPhone and then I realized I needed
0:32:03to hear something on my iPad instead and I had to do like a switch on the little white
0:32:07dongles. And I thought, boy, it's come to this, but I don't want to give up the wired
0:32:13headphones just yet. So I use AirPods a lot, but for some stuff, especially if I'm in a
0:32:18noisy environment and I want to block other people out, there's a lady at my Starbucks
0:32:23that I go to who who's there all day and is lonely and will talk to you and I have to
0:32:28block her out because otherwise she'll talk to me. So this is my sad story. But anyway,
0:32:33I've got two dongles now in my little carrying case. It's great. Yeah, you know what? That's
0:32:37the main reason that I did the stickers. Well, a I've been thinking about it for years, but
0:32:41I actually want one now myself. I made I made three inch stickers, which seemed like a standard
0:32:46size for circular stickers, but I also made one inch ones and I want the one inch one
0:32:50to put on my AirPods case,
0:32:51'cause now we're up to three AirPod users in the household.
0:32:55And that was the breaking point
0:32:57of who the hell's AirPods are to these.
0:32:58And so I'm actually, this would be like the first
0:33:00Apple product I can recall
0:33:02that I actually want to put a sticker on.
0:33:04- You know the one that I,
0:33:05'cause I am not a big sticker person.
0:33:07I have, at some point I decided I was gonna,
0:33:09for my personal, kind of because of sixcolors.com,
0:33:12I got rainbow Apple logos in the exact size
0:33:16of the Apple logos on like my laptop
0:33:18and my iPad and my iMac.
0:33:19and I got those and put them on.
0:33:21And I thought like that's fitting,
0:33:22but it's literally in the space
0:33:24where the Apple logo already was.
0:33:26I'm just sort of colorizing it.
0:33:27I've never been a, you know, slather stickers
0:33:31all over my Apple products kind of thing.
0:33:33But this folio case for the iPad Pro
0:33:38with that giant gray completely blank expanse,
0:33:44I actually have started putting stickers on it
0:33:46'cause I just can't take it.
0:33:47it's the most boring accessory Apple has ever made,
0:33:51and I've just decided that I need to also to help orient.
0:33:54Like I know which side is which
0:33:55because of the stickers and stuff.
0:33:56And it's just, so that's the first one for me.
0:33:59I do have a sticker on my AirPods case
0:34:01because we have two sets in the house
0:34:03and you can tell them apart.
0:34:04- It's essential.
0:34:06And, but that's just what I thought is I thought,
0:34:07well, what then I started thinking, well, what sticker?
0:34:09And A, because I'm not a sticker person,
0:34:11I didn't have any stickers laying around.
0:34:14B, most stickers are a little too big, you know,
0:34:17the AirPods case is tiny.
0:34:18And then I thought, well, wait a minute.
0:34:19I could put my own sticker on there.
0:34:22- Yeah, little, I assume it's just the
0:34:24during "Fireball Star."
0:34:25- Yeah, it's just a circle that is hopefully very close
0:34:30to the correct shade of gray with a white star in the middle.
0:34:33- Nice.
0:34:34- I haven't seen him in person yet.
0:34:34That's one of the weird things,
0:34:35'cause the shirts ship from my longtime partner in crime
0:34:40in the T-shirt racket, Brian Jeremiah,
0:34:43out in Southern California.
0:34:44So I had the stickers sent to him too,
0:34:46which kind of hurt because I wanted to see them. Yeah. I just did that cause all of our
0:34:50stickers went through cotton bureau in Pittsburgh. And so I just had the, I had all of the stickers
0:34:54shipped to Pittsburgh. So I don't know what they were like. The good thing is I trust
0:34:58Brian's eye. Like Brian knows during fireball brand and he's very, very accurate judge of
0:35:04color and you know, and, and things like, you know, are they cut right and stuff? I
0:35:09mean company, I got him from a place called sticker mule. I don't know. I've used them.
0:35:13- I've used them, absolutely.
0:35:15- But they seemed to have a very good reputation
0:35:17and was a very nice process actually setting it up.
0:35:22- Those places are really designed at this point
0:35:25to mitigate against having you demand your money back.
0:35:28So they like go through like a proof process
0:35:30and they send you the proof.
0:35:31And I've actually been really happy with that
0:35:32'cause sometimes I'll oftentimes like three out of four
0:35:35will be fine and then there'll be one out of four
0:35:38that I'll give them a little feedback and say,
0:35:40that's not what I was thinking.
0:35:41often, you know, 24 hours, sometimes it's like five hours.
0:35:44They send back a second proof.
0:35:46I'm like, that's exactly it.
0:35:47And so they're pretty good.
0:35:48I've been pretty impressed.
0:35:49- Yeah, I forget what my issue was.
0:35:51I had a very small issue.
0:35:53You know what it was?
0:35:54It wasn't even that their proof,
0:35:55it wasn't that the proof they showed me
0:35:57showed any signs of defect.
0:35:58It was, I used to be so involved in the print world
0:36:02'cause I used to do print design and I knew, you know,
0:36:05what do we used to call it?
0:36:06Pre-flight, remember you'd pre-flight your Quark Express file
0:36:10And there was, what was the, there was a great app.
0:36:12- Oh man.
0:36:15- Pre-flight, was it named pre-flight?
0:36:17And what you could do is just,
0:36:19you get your QuarkXPress document, if you had images,
0:36:23those images were external files somewhere else,
0:36:26and they were referenced within the document.
0:36:29You know, it's not at all dissimilar
0:36:31to the concept of an HTML file,
0:36:33where the image isn't actually in the HTML file,
0:36:35the image, you know,
0:36:36the document contains a reference to it.
0:36:39And what you could do with preflight is when you were done,
0:36:42you just drag your Quark file onto this app
0:36:44and it would grab everything, make a copy of it
0:36:47and like put it in a, I was gonna say zip archive,
0:36:50but it was probably like a sit file, right?
0:36:53Like a stuff it archive.
0:36:54And then you'd have just one stuff it archive
0:36:57that you could give to the print shop
0:36:59and then they could stuff it and everything would be there.
0:37:02And including like the fonts, you'd have everything you need.
0:37:05You'd have the fonts, you'd have the images.
0:37:08I'm so out of the game that I don't know
0:37:09you ship stuff anymore. I don't know what is EPS what you want. And Sticker Mule took
0:37:13all sorts of, you know, any file you can imagine. You could send them a PDF, you could send
0:37:17them an EPS, you could send them raster files, which I know is just not the best way to do
0:37:24it. But I send SVG, because I think that's the most modern way to do it, and I think
0:37:31it's the most precise way to specify a color. But I could be wrong. Maybe I'll be inundated
0:37:35with feedback this week that I was an idiot, that SVG is terrible. But what I did is I
0:37:41sent them, and of course I had put this off until close to the last minute, but I think
0:37:46I sent them a PDF at first, and then they showed me the proof, and I didn't really like
0:37:50the color. I don't think they did anything wrong. I just wasn't sure. And I know from
0:37:56past experience, sometimes PDF doesn't round trip that well with color. So anyway, I switched
0:38:02to SVG and they seemingly came out perfect. Enjoying any any beverages as we record?
0:38:09I ran out of beverages. I have a like the teapot but the teapot was drained so I'm tea
0:38:16less now but you know I may go get something during an ad break it's possible.
0:38:21I have some coffee and of course some homemade fizzy water.
0:38:25The problem with the tea in my house now is that my daughter has become a tea drinker
0:38:30And so that teapot gets empty at unexpected times.
0:38:34And then I'm like, and then it's too late.
0:38:37Like it's like, I'm not going to make another pot of tea.
0:38:39It's just, it's over for, for then sometimes I'll go back and make another
0:38:42pot, but sometimes not.
0:38:43All right.
0:38:45Here's, here's the, one of the main things and it's one of my recurring themes.
0:38:48I can't stop thinking about it is this whole notion.
0:38:52Speaking of iPad pros of using an iPad pro for quote unquote work.
0:38:59And you fascinate me of all the other all the people know all the people in this racket,
0:39:05all of our friends, colleagues, everybody, or you know, even people we don't like, but
0:39:11who were right about this stuff. And I have various positions all over the map on where
0:39:16the iPad and the iPad Pro probably in particular stand visit, you know, compared to the Mac
0:39:22as a machine for work. And you fascinated me because you and I are like minded of similar
0:39:29age. And you know, we do kind of the same thing, mostly writing and reading and linking
0:39:36to things. We are both longtime fans of some of the same apps, like I'll just say in particular,
0:39:43BB Edit. Sure. Which just amazingly celebrated its 25th anniversary. Yeah. Crazy. Well, it's
0:39:52both crazy because that sounds like a long time for an app. Like who thinks of apps being
0:39:55around for 25 years. And then on the other hand, I can't remember. Well, I do remember
0:39:59before BB Edit, but it was, you know, I was like a sophomore in college when I first started
0:40:05using BB Edit. And that feels like, yeah, that's a long time ago.
0:40:09Yeah, totally. And for me, it was a, it was my first job that the, the, there was a guy
0:40:14there who was like, you should use BB Edit. I was like, okay. And that was it. I could
0:40:19be off by a year. I'm 99% sure though it was 1992. And I remember where I was, I was
0:40:25in the Tower Dormitory, the new tower.
0:40:29That's how creatively Drexel University named its dormitory.
0:40:33They've gotten a lot better at that in recent years.
0:40:35Because the way the game really works is you
0:40:38find some deep-pocketed alumni who wants a name on a building.
0:40:45In the '80s, Drexel was-- it wasn't on top of that game.
0:40:49And there was a dormitory called the New Tower.
0:40:53Which I wonder, I actually have no idea.
0:40:55I should look it up, but I wonder if they still call it that
0:40:57'cause it certainly isn't new anymore.
0:40:59- Yeah, they might've sold the naming rights for that too.
0:41:01That happened when they built the new Warriors Arena
0:41:04in Oakland that they're now gonna leave.
0:41:05It was the new arena for a long time
0:41:08before Oracle paid up to get the name.
0:41:10- Yeah.
0:41:11I was in my friend, Dave, his name was Super Dave.
0:41:15We had big Dave and Super Dave, Super Dave's dorm room.
0:41:18Super Dave ran an excellent bulletin board.
0:41:21That was that was before you know that was how we communicated with each other. I feel
0:41:26like we're getting older by the minute as you tell the story. I even remember what model
0:41:30computer he had a Mac. He had an excellent he had a Mac to CI which is we go down memory
0:41:36lane is in my opinion one of the greatest Macintosh has ever made totally as far outside
0:41:40my family's budget. But it started life when it was new as like one of the very very top
0:41:46and Mac twos and it remained in Apple's lineup for years to come as it sort of it was actually
0:41:52Apple didn't do this at the time it was sort of what Apple does now is allow a formerly
0:41:57top line product to work its way down the lineup you know the way that you can still
0:42:02go into an Apple store and buy like an iPhone success you know the two ci had that sort
0:42:07of life anyway Dave was on his Mac to ci and I wasn't even wanting to pay it wasn't like
0:42:14here, come here and look at this." I was like, "Oh my God, what's that? What is that?" And he was like,
0:42:19"Oh, it's some new text editor called BB Edit." And I was like, "All right, I need that."
0:42:22Because I had been—there were no good text editors for the Mac, and I was a computer science major. I
0:42:29needed a text editor. I was, you know, stumbling around with—I forget what I was using. I mean,
0:42:36you could use teach text at the time for text files. There were other third-party programming
0:42:43text editors and the think packages you know like think Pascal had well actually think Pascal had a
0:42:50weird thing where it wasn't really a plain text editor it was like before you know was before
0:42:55source code coloring but they did like sort of like what AppleScript does where they would as
0:42:59you wrote the lines of code and think Pascal it would like bold the keywords and stuff like that
0:43:04isn't that why bb edit exists it wasn't because rich seagull used did think Pascal and he wanted
0:43:10to write a text editor for it, a decent text editor for it?
0:43:14- What I need to do, what I really need to do
0:43:16is get rich on the show is what I should do
0:43:17and let him tell the story.
0:43:18But the basic story was it started life
0:43:22as proof of concept that a well-constructed,
0:43:27well-behaved, useful Mac text editor could be written
0:43:32in one source code file of think of Pascal.
0:43:36You know, that there'd just be like,
0:43:38I don't know what he named it.
0:43:39if it was like bbedit. I don't know, jeez, what's the, I don't even remember the file
0:43:43extension for Pascal anymore. Was it dot P? I have no idea. You know, but that one bbedit.p
0:43:50file with, you know, well structured, wouldn't be like a bunch of spaghetti code. You could
0:43:54have one file and hit compile and out would come a useful text editor, hence bare bones,
0:44:02bare bones text editor. So it was a bar bet basically. Yeah, I think so. I think effectively
0:44:07it was a bar bet that he could write it in one file.
0:44:10It has since grown to more than one file.
0:44:13And as long as Outlive, think Pascal to be sure.
0:44:18But not just as BB Edit isn't just going strong.
0:44:20BB Edit is just came out with like a what?
0:44:2412.5 is the new version with some terrific new features.
0:44:28Like it's not just around,
0:44:30it is still super actively developed.
0:44:33- Yeah, it's funny.
0:44:34The ones, and that's no coincidence,
0:44:36ones that are still around are the ones that are actively developed. As we record this,
0:44:40just yesterday Federico Vittucci put out his favorite iOS apps of the year on Mac stories,
0:44:44and one of them is Peacalc, which is also 25 years old, I believe. And it's the same story,
0:44:51which is, and Federico said it in his write-up, which is, this is an ancient code base that was
0:44:56originally a college project for James Thompson. But the reason it's still around is because he
0:45:01aggressively embraces new Apple technology and figures out ways to get it into his product.
0:45:07And like, he's not just sitting there hoping people keep using his old product. And the
0:45:11same is true of BB Edit, right? Like they keep evolving it over the years. And if you're
0:45:17on the beta list, which I am and you are, it's like, they're always pushing the boundaries
0:45:22with that app.
0:45:23- 12.5 has a feature that was based on a request from me. And I swear it was maybe like five
0:45:30years ago. Like, you know how you in the Mac OS X, when you go to the help menu, you can
0:45:37start typing a menu command. And if there's a menu command, it'll kind of highlight and
0:45:42tell you where it is. Yeah, I love that feature. I tell that I tell people about that because
0:45:45it's not a widely known feature. And it's like the best way to figure out if an app
0:45:49does something. It's just literally search the menus for it. And as a power user, you
0:45:54can kind of use it to give keyboard shortcuts to commands that you either don't know the
0:45:58shortcut to—you know, just by, I think, what is it, shift command? Yeah, it's like,
0:46:04I don't know the shortcut. It's just hardwired. So, shift command slash opens the help menu,
0:46:10and you can just start typing. So, my suggestion was that BBEdit should do its own version
0:46:14of that and do it better because it knows about its things. And so, there's now a—I
0:46:20think it's in the go menu, go command, shift command U. And BBEdit has its own built-in.
0:46:26you can just start typing something and it'll,
0:46:29if there's any menu that matches it, it'll be highlighted.
0:46:32And you can of course arrow down and do it.
0:46:34But anyway, it's just proof to me that
0:46:38when you write in with a feature request
0:46:40or something like that, and you get the feedback from Rich
0:46:43or from Patrick or whoever there.
0:46:45I should add that I worked at Barebone Software
0:46:47for two years.
0:46:48It seems like a worthy disclosure back in around 2000.
0:46:54But when they-- they're never going to tell you.
0:46:58They're very nice people.
0:46:59And they treat their customers extremely well,
0:47:03which is probably another reason that they've
0:47:05survived for 25 years.
0:47:08But if they tell you that a feature-- hmm,
0:47:09that is an interesting idea.
0:47:11They might ask more, like, well, how would you use it?
0:47:13Why would that be better than what's already there,
0:47:16so and such?
0:47:17They really do systematically put it away in somewhere
0:47:21where they may not implement it right away.
0:47:23Like, this is serious.
0:47:24I bet this was seriously like a five-year-old feature request.
0:47:26But when it first showed up in the betas for the 12.5 cycle,
0:47:30I was like, hey, that sounds like a great feature.
0:47:32And I was like, wait, I think I asked for that.
0:47:35Anyway, we have very similar taste in software, et cetera.
0:47:39And I truly struggle to try to do my work only on an iPad.
0:47:45And I want to, I think, but I worry deeply
0:47:49that maybe it's not that I can't,
0:47:52But that I'm too old, I don't know.
0:47:55What frustrates me and makes me feel like I always,
0:47:58I often use this analogy, I feel like I'm wearing mittens
0:48:01when I'm using an iPad.
0:48:04And I am really used to having fine use of all 10 fingers.
0:48:09At the other hand, that's a strength in other ways
0:48:14because it's the way that I can have so much going on
0:48:17at the Mac at one time can be distracting,
0:48:21a way that it's not on iPad and it's a little bit, I don't know, mentally quieter. I'm not
0:48:27big on the whole distraction-free writing thing.
0:48:29Yeah, I agree. I mean, that can go too far, but it is like, I'm looking at my Mac right
0:48:35now and I'm talking to you, but like, I've got a Slack window, I've got an iMessage window,
0:48:41I've got our shared notes document, I've got Audio Hijack. Occasionally I will get a push
0:48:48I've got a dock full of items. Like, there's a lot going on here. And iOS can be distracting,
0:48:57but like, even its multitasking is literally all you're seeing is two app windows. That's
0:49:02all you're seeing. And when I'm not using, like, usually Safari to look things up while
0:49:07I'm writing, I'm just—I actually have this wacky stand that you and I went back and forth
0:49:13on on Twitter, and then I think we may have talked about the last time I was on. That—I
0:49:17rotate that into horizontal or vertical. So I'll put it in vertical when I'm writing and
0:49:23I just got a big stack of text and I'm not multitasking at all. And it's just a giant
0:49:28screen. There's only one thing in it, which is my text editor. That's all I'm doing. And
0:49:32yeah, I could see a push notification, although I set those up to not be super annoying. I
0:49:36can switch to other apps if I want to take a mental break, but there is something about
0:49:40it being completely locked in that way. And you know, I could use my MacBook Air in full
0:49:46screen mode apps. I could do that. I just never do because it's a Mac. That's not how
0:49:51I use the Mac. But it's always been how you have to use iOS. And so there's some—I know
0:49:55it's kind of a trick and it's not really true, but it's just enough. It's like quitting out
0:50:01of an app saying, "I'm not going to check Twitter while I'm working on this story. I'm
0:50:04going to quit Twitter." You can always relaunch Twitter, but the act of quitting Twitter puts
0:50:09it just further enough away that you're like, "All right, I can leave it and I'm going to
0:50:13focus. And so some of that is what's going on. I wouldn't say that's the whole picture,
0:50:18but I do think that that's a part of it, is that it's just a kind of a simpler place,
0:50:22and it's not getting in my way, and it's more flexible. That's the thing that I also feel
0:50:27about it is, like, I can pop it in that crazy bridge keyboard case and it feels like a laptop,
0:50:32but I can also pull it off and use it with an external keyboard or that smart keyboard
0:50:37folio or I can just leave it completely unadorned and it's just a pure tablet experience, depending
0:50:43on what I want. And that's not something I can do with a MacBook Air. It's going to be
0:50:46the shape it is 100% of the time.
0:50:50One of the things that I find, it's an obsession of mine. I know I've mentioned it on the show.
0:50:57I think I've tried to write about it, but maybe more in the early days of Daring Fireball
0:51:03than recently is a platform, a software platform to me takes on a life of its own and has character
0:51:13It has, there's, you become intimate with it and, you know, just like the way that anybody,
0:51:21a craftsman can get really used to a particular hammer or tool, you know, or illustrators
0:51:27certainly could become very attached to their pens, you know, pencils and whatever, or certain
0:51:33types of paper.
0:51:34Everybody, you know, and the whole system of an OS can take on a certain character.
0:51:40And one of the very interesting things to me about Apple is that by the late 80s, the
0:51:50Mac was Apple and Apple was the Mac, you know, that as the Apple two died off, the Apple
0:51:57still had ambitions like that.
0:52:00Like the Apple of old would come out with new systems all the time, you know, I mean,
0:52:04And like the Apple IIGS by the end, the last Apple II certainly was a far different computer
0:52:10than the original Apple II.
0:52:13And they famously had the Newton Project in the Scully years, which was almost a tragedy.
0:52:22And for those who weren't there and never used one, it has a bad rap as to the quality
0:52:29of it.
0:52:32It was interesting and good and ahead of its time.
0:52:38And very much not a pocket Macintosh.
0:52:41It had its own character.
0:52:43It really did.
0:52:44Now, there were aspects and the things that you could see that were similar, like, "Yeah,
0:52:49that's kind of Appley."
0:52:53There was certainly some Apple likeness to it that was different than Mac likeness.
0:53:00In that Steve Jobs exile years, a comparison of the Newton to the system seven era Macintosh
0:53:09would be an interesting way of discerning what Apple as a company culturally was about.
0:53:19But let's face it, for the most part, I mean, certainly financially, what kept the company
0:53:22alive was the Mac. And in those years, the Mac had a very strong character, I would say
0:53:27it was stronger than Apple's as a whole and was embraced by third party developers and
0:53:34certainly by users. And you know, at a time it was a time and Apple was weak in certain ways.
0:53:41And it was a time when third party developers big ones like Adobe and Microsoft and Macromedia,
0:53:48which was a separate company at the time, arguably held as much control over the platform as Apple
0:53:54Apple did. I mean, and this played out in public with the switch to Mac OS 10 and the
0:53:59carbon and the cocoa and stuff like that. And it's like, you know, it's easy now to
0:54:03get used to Apple saying, Oh, Hey, everything's going to 64 bit. So, you know, you know, and
0:54:11it's not like they, they, they announced it and like two days later, a ship of version
0:54:14of Mac OS 10 would where 32 bed apps don't work. I mean, you know, they've been very
0:54:18clear about this at WWDC over the years, but there was no discussion about it. It wasn't,
0:54:22not like Apple held negotiations with developers and said, we're thinking about moving everything
0:54:27to 64 bit. What do you guys think? And what do you guys think the timeline should be?
0:54:32You know, Apple made that decision and went with it. Whereas at that time, the initial,
0:54:37Hey, we're going to switch everything to cocoa was met with a, no, you're not. And they had
0:54:43to go back to the drawing board. And I just recently revisited this with going back to
0:54:51the story of word six, which to me is and I when I reread it and really thought about
0:54:58it, I realized that I'd sort of filed this away in the wrong category in my mind over
0:55:01the years. Basically, Microsoft Word was a fine and excel to were very fine Mac applications
0:55:09in the 80s that were, you know, if you think about it, a platform that launched in 1984
0:55:15and got to version five by the mid 90s. They were obviously major versions on a very regular
0:55:20places. Very popular, lots of people used it. Word 5.1 was it 5.1a that they found out?
0:55:29Jon Moffitt 5.1a was the final resting place of that app.
0:55:33Dave Asprey That's like, I very specifically remember
0:55:38the last good version of QuarkXPress. It was 3.32R5. I can't remember my son's friends'
0:55:47games, but I can remember QuarkXPress 3.32 R5. Word 5.1a was very popular. It was good.
0:55:56It looked like a Mac app. It could certainly quibble. There were certainly Microsoft isms.
0:56:03It was never my choice. I never really cared for it. But I certainly had friends in college
0:56:09who used it. When I'd look at it, I wouldn't think, "That's a weird-looking app," or,
0:56:12know, it looked like a Mac word processor. Yeah. And word six was not to rehash the whole
0:56:19argument. I'll, I'll, you know, make a note here. I'll put it in the show notes, but I
0:56:22just linked to it. Rick, I forget his name from the Mac BU wrote a sort of history of
0:56:30it. And basically the problem was word for windows was an entirely different code base
0:56:34than word for Mac. And they, that's a huge, it was a huge problem in terms of what you
0:56:41really want is document. The thing that really matters is document compatibility. And if
0:56:46you couldn't just send a document from a Word for Windows user to a Word for Mac and have
0:56:51it survive with everything intact, that's a problem. And their decision for the solution
0:56:55was to switch to a unified code base for both apps. And basically, they switched to the
0:57:01Windows code base.
0:57:02Exactly.
0:57:03For reasons, whatever. But what they shipped as a Mac app did not look like or act like
0:57:08a Mac app in any way. It wasn't a Windows app running an emulation, but it might as
0:57:14well have been. It doesn't matter. The technical reasons behind it are irrelevant. What happened
0:57:22is the users rejected it. It was like, "This app is gross. This is unacceptable. We're
0:57:29not going to accept this. We're going to stick with Word 5.1. Go screw yourselves."
0:57:34- Yeah, now, so you've linked to that piece by Rick
0:57:38from Microsoft a few times,
0:57:40and I disagree with some of the things in it
0:57:42because I was there too,
0:57:44and writing about Apple and working at a magazine
0:57:47that was all about the Mac.
0:57:49And some of his characterizations are very much like,
0:57:52oh, well, the users wanted to be more Mac-like,
0:57:54which meant they wanted it to be like the previous version,
0:57:57which is sort of implying that the users, you know,
0:58:00didn't want change and their resistance to change
0:58:03was the problem.
0:58:04And that was so not it.
0:58:05I mean, the issue really was that in the,
0:58:07and you remember this from this era,
0:58:09in that period in the 90s, the Mac was dying
0:58:14under heavy assault from Windows.
0:58:16And one of the things that you would use a Mac,
0:58:19you would say is, "I want to use the Mac.
0:58:22If I'm gonna choose to use the Mac,
0:58:24it's because I like the Mac."
0:58:25And what word six said was,
0:58:28"Here, we got you Word for Windows,
0:58:30and now you can use it on the Mac."
0:58:32And a Mac user is like, "Well, why would I do that?
0:58:34I would just use Windows if I wanted Word for Windows.
0:58:37I want Word to be on the Mac."
0:58:40And they just, you know, and I think the truth is,
0:58:43and I heard this from people at Microsoft,
0:58:45that the truth was their clients were IT departments
0:58:48and the IT departments didn't like the fact
0:58:50that the menu items and toolbars and everything
0:58:53were completely different on the Mac than on the PC.
0:58:56And so they wanted them to be the same
0:58:57so that all their support documentation could be the same.
0:59:00and that it gets to say,
0:59:01here's how you get the company letterhead,
0:59:04go to the file menu.
0:59:05- In Word.
0:59:06- All right.
0:59:07- It doesn't matter whether it was Mac or PC.
0:59:10And that was the thing that I think,
0:59:11if your identity is,
0:59:13it's not just your identity as a Mac user,
0:59:15but it's like, I made a choice to you
0:59:16to drink Coke and not Pepsi.
0:59:18And then Pepsi says, good news,
0:59:22Pepsi comes in a Coke can now.
0:59:23It's like, no, no, I don't.
0:59:26I made a choice.
0:59:27And now you're saying my choice is invalid.
0:59:29that was that was at the root of that plus it was slow and bloated and bad like there was there
0:59:33were a lot of things wrong with it beyond the looks of it but the looks of it and the way it
0:59:37behaved were enough to just turn people off of it basically you put your finger on exactly what i
0:59:43don't like i mean it's that he was there and it's first person makes it worth reading but where i
0:59:48disagree and exactly what you put your finger on was that uh what they said it wasn't mac like and
0:59:52and what they meant by Mack like was five word 5.1.
0:59:56And that's not true.
0:59:57It's that it's like what you're skipping is the issue
1:00:01is that being Mack like was a meaningful thing.
1:00:04And it was, it is, it always has been,
1:00:06it was from the beginning very difficult
1:00:09to put your finger on.
1:00:10Brent Simmons years ago, oh man, back in like 2002
1:00:14had a wonderful piece on how, you know,
1:00:20as somebody who clearly got what Mac-like software is,
1:00:24how it still is often unhelpful
1:00:26because your Mac-like is different than my Mac-like,
1:00:29even though we're wrong,
1:00:30and then there's lots of people
1:00:31who just don't get it at all.
1:00:32There is a thing to being Mac-like,
1:00:35and there was, and it was very strong,
1:00:38and it's literally what kept Apple alive,
1:00:40because if Mac-likeness hadn't been an important thing,
1:00:44there's no reason everybody wouldn't have switched
1:00:47Windows at the time that there is more to it than, okay, you've got a rectangular window
1:00:53and the windows all have close buttons and zoom buttons. And then there's a menu bar,
1:00:58you know, with the sort of, you know, agreed upon set of, you know, typical things like
1:01:03file edit font. And you double click on an app, you know, and there's a mouse that moves
1:01:11around and you can select text and then there's a scroll bar over on the side that shows you
1:01:15You could drag this up and down to scroll up and down in a document.
1:01:18And there you go.
1:01:19There's a GUI.
1:01:20And if you can use one, you can use any one, and that's all there is to it.
1:01:25It is true that that's the fundamental description of the modern graphical user interface of
1:01:30a windowing system, but there's so much more to the Mac way of doing things and of
1:01:36organizing things and of feeling at home.
1:01:40It's such an amazing thing when you feel at home in an app you've never used before
1:01:44because it's uses all these familiar conventions.
1:01:46And there were those conventions went so much deeper
1:01:50than just draggable windows with a close button
1:01:53and a menu bar.
1:01:54There was just Mac ways of doing things like-
1:01:59- I have never, and this happens to this day,
1:02:01I have never, I never get more irrationally angry
1:02:04than when I close a window on an app and it quits.
1:02:09- Yes, I know.
1:02:13- And these days, you know, the Mac sometimes will do that
1:02:16because it's trying to save resources.
1:02:17And if you close a text edit window, it will be like,
1:02:19"Oh, I'm gonna shut off text edit," which I still hate,
1:02:22but I understand what's going on there.
1:02:24But that was one of the defining characteristics
1:02:27of Mac-like versus PC-like, right?
1:02:29Is that a Mac app exists,
1:02:32and then windows come and go as a part of its existence.
1:02:35And a Windows app was literally a window
1:02:38with things inside it.
1:02:40And if you close the window, the app is the window,
1:02:43so the app goes away.
1:02:44And yet you'd get these ports from windows,
1:02:48from people who had no idea what the Mac was like,
1:02:51where you close the window
1:02:52'cause you'd wanna move on to a different project
1:02:54and the app would be like, "Great, goodbye."
1:02:56And this was at the time when sometimes it would take you
1:02:58like 30 seconds to launch an app,
1:02:59a really complicated professional app.
1:03:02And you'd be like, "No, no, no, no, no."
1:03:04And it just, it's like, you don't get it.
1:03:06Like this was made by somebody who just doesn't get it.
1:03:09And you're right, like that is,
1:03:11it's not like there's a rule book or something,
1:03:13but a Mac user knew that if you close that window,
1:03:15the app would not bail on you and be like, goodbye.
1:03:19And that was part of the Mac was,
1:03:22we all know how this app is gonna behave
1:03:25when I click this box.
1:03:26Everybody knows the right way to do this.
1:03:29And if you deviate from that,
1:03:31everybody's gonna get a little bit angry at you.
1:03:34- You know, it's like the way,
1:03:35I'm just trying to broadly draw an analogy.
1:03:38It's like, you know, an episode of the X-Files has to feel like an episode of the X-Files,
1:03:44even though maybe it's one of the episodes where it's about the deep multi-season conspiracy,
1:03:51or maybe it's just a one-off that's even a little goofy, but it still has to feel like an episode of
1:03:57the X-Files, right? And there's something that you can't—you can write a book, you know, and there
1:04:03can be a book, you know, and that would be like the HIG, you know, the human interface
1:04:08guidelines and that's a reference that somebody writing software can say, Hmm, I actually
1:04:12don't know how to do this. Should this be two different menu items or should be one
1:04:15menu item, you know, where you can hold down a key and turn it into a different menu item.
1:04:20Let me see what the HIG says, you know, and I'm sure, you know, I know two TV shows have
1:04:24books like that, that the writers can, can consult with to, you know, let's get this
1:04:29right, you know? Yep. But for the most part, if you don't have an intuitive sense of
1:04:33the overall gist of it, you're never going to get it, right? You just, you know, it's
1:04:38got to be something that mostly you feel it and you know it when you see it. And then,
1:04:42you know, every once in a while with the details, you can look it up.
1:04:44Yeah, it's that you get a script for that TV show from somebody on the outside and the
1:04:48people who make the TV show read it and say, have you ever seen our TV show? Like, you
1:04:53don't know who the characters are or how the TV show feels. And, and, and there were outlier
1:04:57apps on the Mac, not as much now, but certainly back in the day where it was that same feeling.
1:05:02Like I was like NetObjects Fusion, which was a web building tool that I reviewed a bunch
1:05:07on an early kind of WYSIWYG website builder.
1:05:11And it was a Windows port and like, you know, it uses little plus minuses instead of disclosure
1:05:16triangles.
1:05:17If you close the window, it quits.
1:05:20All of these things.
1:05:21And like Mac user knew you could pick that out immediately.
1:05:24Like you are the fraud here.
1:05:27You are not a real Mac app.
1:05:28And that's just again.
1:05:30It wasn't that it wasn't usable,
1:05:31and it wasn't that my design sensibilities were offended.
1:05:34It was that I had made my choice,
1:05:38and one of the advantages all apps had
1:05:41was this kind of common frame of reference,
1:05:43and then that app did not share it,
1:05:45and it was frustrating to use.
1:05:47- Yeah, the plus/minus thing versus disclosure triangles
1:05:50is maybe one of the great examples,
1:05:52because I am and always have been 100% convinced
1:05:57that the disclosure triangle visual metaphor is better.
1:06:02It is both more attractive and more intuitive.
1:06:05It looks closed when it's closed.
1:06:07It looks open when it's open.
1:06:09It goes down.
1:06:10The switching from pointing to the side for closed
1:06:14to pointing down to be open
1:06:17creates the opportunity for an animation affordance
1:06:20that makes perfect sense.
1:06:21You could see the triangle flipping in a rotating thing.
1:06:24And maybe in later years,
1:06:26animation got more prevalent in the OS, you could see the contents of the folder or whatever
1:06:31go down. The plus minus thing, plus and minus make no sense in that context to me. And they
1:06:38used to draw the little dotting line. It just led to this crazy visual thing where they'd
1:06:44have all these lines all over the place that weren't necessary, right? All you need are
1:06:48the triangles and indentation.
1:06:50And, you know, it would transfer to things like outliners, right? Like, so you'd have,
1:07:00you know, like one of Dave Weiner's outliners from the early 90s or late 80s would of course
1:07:06use disclosure triangles to hide and show hierarchy of the outline, which is something,
1:07:13maybe it's like an essay or, or research paper you're researching and the way that you would
1:07:18to close, disclose the hierarchy of that worked exactly the same as in the finder when you
1:07:23were dealing with files. No. Right. I mean, I'm the outliner works like that to this day.
1:07:30Right. Um, one of the words I like for it is idiomatic and idiomatic usually was referred
1:07:36to like grammar, you know, and that one of the ways that you can kind of tell sometimes
1:07:41when somebody speaks your native language as a second language isn't that they're wrong
1:07:47per se is that they say things that nobody who's spoken natively, whatever put together,
1:07:52they're unfamiliar with certain idioms. And I, I, I sometimes I wonder how, how I ever got
1:08:02semi decent grades in English, going through school in the grammar classes, because I never
1:08:09knew the rules. I mean, I could, you know, I could I parts of speech I could get. And then once we
1:08:14got past that, it was like, forget it. I have no idea what the hell you're talking about.
1:08:18I just do it by ear. I've always just written and read by ear. And, you know, making good
1:08:27Mac software has always been like that. They're just idioms that you use. And when you violate
1:08:32them, it just seems bizarre, right? Like spelling an OK button, OKAY. Like, it's not wrong. You
1:08:41You can look in the dictionary and there are certain publications that even put in their
1:08:47style guide that the word OK is spelled out OKAY. It is in the dictionary. There are publications
1:08:54that prefer it.
1:08:55It doesn't go in a dialogue box.
1:08:59Not a Mac.
1:09:00I was going to say that the elements of style or a grammar textbook, it's kind of like the
1:09:06HIG for grammar. So you internalize it because you learn the language and you do it by absorbing
1:09:11it and seeing that people use it this way. And then the reason the, you know, learning
1:09:15the parts of speech and all that kind of exists is as the reference material. So if you don't
1:09:20know what to do, you can be like, well, okay, what's the, what are the rules here? But I
1:09:24think mostly it's innate, right? That you absorb it by watching it in use and then you
1:09:30understand it. And for computing platforms to broaden it out, like that is how computing
1:09:35platforms work is that if you're a user of a platform and you may not even know it, you
1:09:38You may not think of yourself as a big computer user
1:09:42or a smartphone user, but you spend time on the iPhone
1:09:45or an Android phone or whatever,
1:09:46you absorb sort of like what the rules are
1:09:48and how things work.
1:09:49And then you get frustrated if things don't work right.
1:09:53And right is defined as, I mean, there's a reason
1:09:55why every app doesn't have a completely different
1:09:58control scheme, right?
1:09:59Because if literally that's how it was
1:10:02in the early days of computing,
1:10:03where every single app ran differently
1:10:06and you had to figure out what its commands were
1:10:09because every single one was different.
1:10:11It's terrible, right?
1:10:11You want to have that common frame of reference.
1:10:13And we all absorb that, which is why,
1:10:16I mean, to this day, that was why I got,
1:10:18I ended up in a very loud room at XOXO a couple of years ago
1:10:23with a designer from Google who was mad at me
1:10:26because I wrote a story complaining
1:10:28about the Google iOS apps using the Google share icon
1:10:34instead of the iOS share icon.
1:10:37And you know, it's the most, like who cares?
1:10:39But I didn't like it because as an iOS user,
1:10:43I looked at the icon and I'd be like, what the hell is this?
1:10:46I don't know what this exploding blob means.
1:10:49I'm looking for a little box with an arrow coming out of it.
1:10:52And you know, that was just, I didn't know that language
1:10:56because it was not my language.
1:10:57- I just ran into that at dinner two nights ago,
1:11:00Amy and I and Jonas were out.
1:11:01Amy wanted to send a link to a product to her sister in a text message. She searched
1:11:10for it. It came up with an Amazon link. She clicked it because it was on her phone and
1:11:16she has the Amazon app. It opened in the Amazon app, not the website. It was the right product.
1:11:26there's nowhere on that page. Amazon's iOS apps are very bad, especially in this idiomatic
1:11:34design language, right? They're very clearly little web things that I don't have my pixel
1:11:40in front of me. I'm quite certain that if I open the Amazon app on my Pixel, it'll look
1:11:44exactly the same. But there is no little box with an arrow coming out of it, like how to
1:11:50copy a link. Like, here it is. Here's the Amazon app showing me the product, and all
1:11:55All I want to do is I want the box with an arrow.
1:11:59Who knows what's in the share sheet?
1:12:00I don't know.
1:12:01Maybe, hopefully, it'll be, you know,
1:12:03maybe I could just go write to messages.
1:12:05But, you know, at very least, there should be copy, right?
1:12:09- Right.
1:12:10- And literally, I couldn't figure it out.
1:12:13Because it didn't stick to the idiom.
1:12:16There's only one.
1:12:17And there must be some way to do it, I guess.
1:12:20But that's something at iOS that is so, you know,
1:12:24Here's the thing, and you want to do something with it,
1:12:27you look for the box with the arrow.
1:12:29- Yeah, exactly.
1:12:31And we could debate whether the Google icon
1:12:34is better or more understandable.
1:12:36You could do user testing, that's fine.
1:12:38But the point is that if you're on iOS,
1:12:41there's a thing you look for.
1:12:43And if you're an Android, likewise,
1:12:44'cause when I wrote this, I heard from people,
1:12:46it's like, oh, well, you know,
1:12:47Apple does this wrong on Apple Music for Android.
1:12:49Is that any better?
1:12:51And my answer is no, it's not better.
1:12:53You should be a good citizen on the platform you live on.
1:12:56And it's not just because I think one platform is better than the other.
1:12:59It's because a platform speaks a language and people learn it whether they know they're
1:13:04learning it or not.
1:13:05And then you want it to be consistent.
1:13:06And that's what good platform design.
1:13:08I know, you know, and all the app developers who listen to this are nodding probably because
1:13:13it's a thing that they have to learn too, which is even if you have a great idea for
1:13:17a better way to do it, if it's completely contrary to the way everybody else does it,
1:13:21it's gonna be a tough sell because nobody is going to expect this behavior, even if
1:13:27it is better. Nobody expects it. So you better, it better be a lot better. And even then you're
1:13:33taking a huge risk. And, you know, it's not something like "Pull to Refresh," which was
1:13:38a kind of painting in an area that was previously unpainted. It's like if you're trying to go,
1:13:44everybody does it this way and you're gonna do it this different way because you think
1:13:46it's better. Even if it might be slightly better, it's the wrong decision because nobody
1:13:51knows how to do that. Everybody knows the other way.
1:13:53I'm going to file a pull to refresh away because that is a really good point. I've got about
1:14:00six threads here in my head and I can't keep six threads going.
1:14:04We were talking about iOS at some point.
1:14:07But one thing I want to finish up before we go on is I want to finish up on my point of
1:14:11why I think I've misfiled the saga of Word 6 for Mac in my head is that when it happened
1:14:17at the time. Again, I wasn't a Word user personally, so it didn't, you know, there was a certain
1:14:23smugness to the—
1:14:25Sure.
1:14:26—this isn't my problem.
1:14:27These poor, poor suckers who use Microsoft Word have to deal with this.
1:14:29Right.
1:14:30And I was. I had to use it in my college newspaper, used it, and then my—obviously, all the manuscripts
1:14:34of the magazine were written in Word.
1:14:36My college newspaper was a Claris house, so we wanted everything in MacWrite format and/or
1:14:44and ClarisWorks worked equally.
1:14:46- Wow.
1:14:47- All MacWrite and Claris.
1:14:49And, you know, eventually there was one columnist
1:14:53who was submitting files in bbedit, text files.
1:14:57But it didn't matter because he was also doing
1:14:59the layout of the newspaper.
1:15:01But for years though, I filed it away as a tragedy.
1:15:06This was terrible.
1:15:07You know, there was an app that was a fine Mac app.
1:15:09And I was already at that point, you know,
1:15:13cared about good Mac apps. Right. And I thought this is a tragedy because here was a fine
1:15:18Mac app from Microsoft. And now Microsoft obviously sees this, you know, you know, saw
1:15:25this as fine to ship for the Mac. And mostly out of danger, you know, because at the time,
1:15:31by that time, Microsoft's growing power in the industry was obvious. And it, you know,
1:15:35was worrisome because man, and if this starts a trend, this is bad news, right? Like, I
1:15:40don't want to see this happening to apps I do use like Photoshop, right? Like I don't
1:15:44want some new version of Photoshop to come out and be the word six of photoshops. So
1:15:51for decades I've had this filed under as a bad incident. Whereas what I realize now is
1:15:55it was one of the finest moments in the Mac history because it didn't work and it made
1:16:00the reaction was so strong from users that just and what is a more typical word. Microsoft
1:16:08Word is not an esoteric app, right? It was literally one of the most popular apps on
1:16:14the platform. I would guess by headcount, I mean, maybe Mac, right? Had more cause I
1:16:19guess they used to ship Mac, right? For free.
1:16:21By the point when word five was out, I would, I would probably argue that it was the most
1:16:26commonly used in a professional sense. It almost certainly was maybe in schools. Mac,
1:16:33right was still more popular, but regardless, it was a mainstream app and it was rejected
1:16:38and it, it, it, the rejection was so strong and the Mac was still deemed by Microsoft
1:16:44to be important enough to care that Microsoft formed an entire business unit, the Mac BU,
1:16:51I mean, creatively named, but they, they said, okay, we, to, to do this right, we need, you
1:17:00You know, we need a real team, big team of Mac,
1:17:04people who get the Mac, and let's do it right.
1:17:08And then Word 98, you know, again,
1:17:12was never really to my liking, but was a credible Mac app,
1:17:16and Word ended up, you know, to this day is still --
1:17:19I mean, I don't know. I don't know what it looks like now.
1:17:21It probably looks like crap just because it's leaked over time.
1:17:27- It's okay.
1:17:28What I would say is ironically enough,
1:17:30it looks like Word for Windows,
1:17:33which looks like Word for iPad.
1:17:36- Yeah, exactly.
1:17:37- Which is kind of interesting.
1:17:38I like Office on iPad better than I like it
1:17:41on the Mac at this point.
1:17:42And I think some of that may just be
1:17:43that the Mac version feels very Windows-like to me
1:17:48and the iOS version feels very iOS-like to me.
1:17:51But it is, I very rarely, I use Excel some.
1:17:54I have an Office 365 subscription.
1:17:56Word is not an app that I particularly use.
1:17:59Although there are people like Dan Morin
1:18:02writes his novels in Scrivener,
1:18:03but the publishing industry is entirely still based on Word.
1:18:07So in the last step he does is compile his book
1:18:11out of Scrivener into a Word file,
1:18:12and then all of his editorial revisions
1:18:15and everything that happens in the publishing process,
1:18:17he's got to do in Word.
1:18:19- Oh my God.
1:18:19- Yeah.
1:18:21- This is why I can't write a book.
1:18:23- Yeah. (laughs)
1:18:25No, but it's a but to me that that rejection of it and and that it was still
1:18:29seemed so important. It's a triumph. It was a triumph of the Mac at
1:18:32maybe and again, not maybe not at the peak of Apple's power, but at the
1:18:36peak of the Mac's
1:18:37platform Integrity and they did the right thing. I mean that that is the
1:18:42the the story that doesn't get told enough about what six is that Microsoft
1:18:46completely
1:18:47reformed itself when it got that feedback it. There were people inside
1:18:51Microsoft who obviously said look if we're going to be on the Mac, we need
1:18:55to actually be on the Mac and not have this be a symptom
1:18:58of us not caring about this platform.
1:19:00And then, you know, that was with the, you know,
1:19:02Bill Gates appears on the screen
1:19:03and they're gonna do an investment
1:19:04and they want Apple to continue and all of that.
1:19:06That was all part of the same thing.
1:19:08And they did, I mean, the Mac BU ended up being,
1:19:11I don't know if it still is,
1:19:13but it was for a very long time,
1:19:15the largest concentration of Mac developers
1:19:19outside of Apple were Microsoft.
1:19:22And they were building all those products on the Mac
1:19:24and they were never quite Mac-like in the same way again,
1:19:29but like that first, even that first release in 98
1:19:33or whenever. They were at least trying.
1:19:34Yeah. Like seriously trying.
1:19:36Like they got the drag and drop stuff to work right,
1:19:39which seems so basic, but like they were,
1:19:41they went into kind of like Olay land,
1:19:43which was like drag and drop for Windows
1:19:45and they had like extensions and stuff.
1:19:47And they're like, they backed out of a lot of that stuff.
1:19:49And then the OS X transition, they committed to it.
1:19:52They were there, they did a good job.
1:19:54Like they got back on the horse after word six
1:19:58and it's to their credit,
1:19:59but it's also because all the people
1:20:01who use that product push back.
1:20:03- Yeah.
1:20:04All right, let me take a break here
1:20:06and thank our next sponsor.
1:20:08Helpfully comes with a pronunciation.
1:20:10It's this hullo pillow pronounced hullo,
1:20:14but here's one it's spelled H-U-L-L-O.
1:20:16Let's just forget that they're a longtime sponsor
1:20:18of the show and I'm familiar with them.
1:20:20I don't know how else I would pronounce that,
1:20:21But here's one which I don't know if they're worried
1:20:26if people are calling them a hula or something,
1:20:28but there's two L's so it's obviously hello.
1:20:31But maybe my reputation precedes me
1:20:33and I do have a pronunciation guide.
1:20:36Well anyway, have you ever tried a buckwheat pillow?
1:20:39They are totally different from the fluffy, soft pillows
1:20:41most of us are used to.
1:20:43Not just a different feeling,
1:20:44they're actually quite heavy.
1:20:45Honestly, it's most similar to a bean bag.
1:20:49Years ago, when I first heard about them,
1:20:51sounded like a really weird idea for a pillow.
1:20:53But turns out, this isn't just something they invented.
1:20:56Buckwheat pillows have been used around the world,
1:20:59especially in Asian countries, for hundreds of years.
1:21:03This is actually a normal pillow
1:21:04in a lot of parts of the world,
1:21:06or a normal way to make a pillow.
1:21:09Now, it supports your head and neck the way you want it to,
1:21:11unlike a traditional squishy soft pillow.
1:21:13They allow your neck to fall flat into a downward bend,
1:21:18which can be uncomfortable.
1:21:19And so hellos not just support the position you want,
1:21:23they also stay cool and dry compared to pillows
1:21:26filled with feathers or foam.
1:21:28Most pillows absorb and retain body heat
1:21:32with a buckwheat pillow, tends to breathe better,
1:21:35air can get through the buckwheat husks inside.
1:21:38And so you don't have to flip,
1:21:39like their thing is that you don't have to flip
1:21:40to the cool side of the pillow,
1:21:41like in the middle of the night
1:21:42where you flip your pillow around
1:21:43because your pillow's too hot.
1:21:44You don't have to do that with a hollow pillow.
1:21:46We have had them for years.
1:21:49My wife and son in particular swear by them, absolutely, positively love them and genuinely
1:21:55complain about them not having them when we travel. They are great products and I'll tell
1:22:01you what, I think it's at least three years, maybe longer. It's got to be at least three
1:22:07years. They last. My wife's pillow pillow, which she sleeps on every single night, it's
1:22:12the original one that they sent years ago when they first sponsored the show. So they
1:22:15They really do last a long time and they're easily adjustable. All you do is unzip it
1:22:22and add more or take more out and that's how you adjust the thickness and it's because
1:22:29you can adjust the thickness and it stays. You don't need a second pillow like one. Even
1:22:33if I like to, you know, if you like to be propped up a little bit, you like to be a
1:22:36little bit more off the bed. You don't need that with a hollow pillow. One, one hello
1:22:40pillow can be, you can adjust it to be flatter. You can puff it up a little, prop it up against
1:22:44the back of the bed and be a little higher up. Really, really easy to adjust and it'll
1:22:48stay the way you have it set up all night long. Hello. The pillows are made in the USA
1:22:55with quality construction and materials. The cotton case certified organic cut and sewn
1:23:01for durability and the buckwheat is grown and milled in the United States. Here's their
1:23:07deal. 60 nights you get to sleep on it. Buy one of their pillows. 60 nights, two months
1:23:13almost. And if hello is not for you, just send it back and they will give you a full
1:23:17refund. All you have to do to find out more is go to hello pillow h u l l o pillow.com
1:23:24slash talk show. Hello pillow.com slash talk show. And if you try more than one pillow,
1:23:31you will get a discount of up to 20 bucks per pillow depending on the size. Fast free
1:23:37shipping on every order and 1% of all of their profits are donated to the Nature Conservancy.
1:23:45That's been true ever since they've been sponsoring the show. That's odd. Just great. So my thanks
1:23:50to HelloPillow. Go to HelloPillow.com/the talk show. Find out more. So here's a great
1:23:55example from that era that I wanted to touch on. Mac Paint was one of the original Mac
1:23:59Mac apps from Apple, famously made by Bill Atkinson, who invented QuickDraw and a bunch
1:24:05of—one of the great—more than just an engineer, an engineer and designer and everything
1:24:14from that era. And a lot of the concepts of Mac Paint would be very familiar to people
1:24:19today using apps like Acorn or Pixelmator or any of the drawing apps, you know, a palette
1:24:27of tools and a pencil for drawing and an eraser and you click on it in the palette and then
1:24:32you can erase and draw blah, blah, blah.
1:24:35I remember when I first saw Photoshop and I don't know what version it was. It was maybe
1:24:412.5, maybe 2.0, I don't know, somewhere in that era. And Photoshop could obviously do
1:24:47a lot more than MacPaint. And there was nothing—I may not know where everything was. Maybe I
1:24:56I didn't know the first time how to do Gaussian blur or something like that.
1:24:59But when I wanted to do something, my first guess as to how to do it was exactly obvious
1:25:06to me.
1:25:07Like it's probably in this menu.
1:25:08Oh yeah, there.
1:25:10And it was a super powerful app.
1:25:14It was amazing what this app can do.
1:25:15It's amazing how big the files are that it can open.
1:25:18It's amazing how stable it is.
1:25:21And the interface was very different in Photoshop back then than it is now.
1:25:25It certainly was a lot more dialogue based where you'd invoke a command and a modal dialogue
1:25:30would come up and you would enter a lot of stuff that you would do visually today with
1:25:37the mouse rubbing over a thing you would do by entering numeric values and cells and hitting
1:25:42buttons in a modal dialogue box and then seeing if you like the result and then if not undoing
1:25:48to try something else.
1:25:50because that was it was the Nate, you know, how we got from there to here, you know, I
1:25:55mean, there just wasn't the computing power to do everything live back then. Really, I
1:26:00mean, that's the main thing. It's not like I think it was obvious that it would be better
1:26:03to directly manipulate the images. But a lot of the stuff you would do in Photoshop, would
1:26:09you hit the close, you know, the OK button to apply it or whatever the action button
1:26:13name, and then you sit there and wait. You know, and it would give correctly, as it should
1:26:19it would give you visual feedback, maybe a progress dialogue if it was long enough, but
1:26:25whatever was needed to show you like, okay, you know, I'm working on it, it would be working
1:26:30on it, and then you'd see the result. But those dialogue boxes had so much power, and
1:26:36had so many great features, and they were organized in a way that felt so Mac like it,
1:26:43there's no other way to describe it. It wasn't like they invented some new language for
1:26:48image editors, it was like they took what a Mac-like image editor should be, a very
1:26:53simple app like MacPaint, and expounded upon it.
1:26:58Sure. But that was an app built by native speakers, right? They knew the Mac in and
1:27:04out, the brothers did, the Knoll brothers.
1:27:06Yeah, yeah. John and Thomas Knoll. I can't remember. John is the one who's still at—
1:27:12John's at ILM, I want to say.
1:27:15Right. And I think Thomas is still at Adobe.
1:27:16And Thomas is still at Adobe?
1:27:17Yeah.
1:27:18Yeah, yeah. That's right. Yeah. And john even got like story credit on the Star Wars Rogue One.
1:27:25Exactly. Right. How's that for a frickin life? co invented Photoshop and made a Star Wars movie?
1:27:32Yeah, pretty, pretty good. Pretty good. I I was visiting ILM with our friend Todd does Eerie and
1:27:39and guy walked by in the cafeteria and Todd says, Oh, hey, john. And then he turns to me,
1:27:47me he says that was John Knoll and I'm like but and he said and I think Todd at the time
1:27:52said you're one of the people who would care more about that he he's the guy who made Photoshop
1:27:57than the guy it was like you're right accurate that is completely accurate I'm more impressed
1:28:01that that's the guy who co-invented Photoshop than his incredibly impressive history working
1:28:05at ILM on Star Wars movies and other sci-fi movies that are touchstones of my life because
1:28:10he wrote Photoshop right like oh it's huge but they knew it the Knoll brothers knew it
1:28:15that they knew the Mac well.
1:28:16And so Photoshop, I had that same experience
1:28:18using Photoshop on the Mac in college
1:28:20that, you know, yeah, you got it.
1:28:22And this is the, you know,
1:28:23I feel like this is a roundabout way
1:28:25of what you're getting to is this question of like,
1:28:28Mac-like versus iPad-like and hanging over,
1:28:32tell me how you feel about this,
1:28:33'cause we're right here at the end of 2018.
1:28:36I feel like 2019 is going to be the year
1:28:39with the most tumultuous change
1:28:42in terms of the identity of the Mac since OS X came out.
1:28:47- I don't know.
1:28:51I think that's possible.
1:28:53And- - Yeah, I mean, it's, yeah.
1:28:56- Well, you tell me in what way?
1:28:58- The Marzipan thing.
1:28:59I think, 'cause you wrote about this
1:29:02on "Daring Fireball" a bit about like,
1:29:04what is Mac like and what is not Mac like
1:29:05and how the Marzipan apps aren't Mac like.
1:29:07And, you know, I reacted to those pieces
1:29:12by saying to myself, I think the problem here is that
1:29:17Apple is going to redefine what Mac like is
1:29:20to be what sort of like app like is.
1:29:25I just get this real feeling that in 2019,
1:29:29what Apple is going to do is say,
1:29:31we now have a unified app platform
1:29:33and iOS apps can run on the Mac
1:29:36and maybe they're gonna make other changes
1:29:39and sort of say, this is how we want apps to behave now.
1:29:42And it's gonna be something that is informed by iOS
1:29:46and the behavior of iOS in a way that is going to be
1:29:50more foreign to Mac users.
1:29:54And especially if you're a Mac user who doesn't use iOS,
1:29:56and I guess those people exist,
1:29:58it will be, I think maybe especially foreign.
1:30:00But the idea that Apple is going to sort of say,
1:30:02this is how we want apps to behave now.
1:30:04And it is a little bit like saying how an app behaves
1:30:08slightly different on an iPhone than on an iPad.
1:30:10There'll be sort of like on an iPhone and an iPad and a Mac.
1:30:14But I just, I feel like the Marzipan thing,
1:30:17you can't bring iOS apps to the Mac
1:30:21and have them just be weird and different.
1:30:24Like the platform has to have some sort of unification,
1:30:28but I think it's most likely that what Apple's going to do
1:30:32is say these Marzipan apps are part of a new way of doing it
1:30:37of thinking of apps on the Mac and that they're gonna kind of redefine what Mac how Mac apps
1:30:43behave as a part of this because I do think ultimately they want a single unified app
1:30:49platform across all their devices. It probably gives them the ability to add touch to the
1:30:54Mac for the first time because they'll be bringing touch first apps to the platform
1:30:59that actually could potentially work with touch not necessarily in 2019 but eventually
1:31:04I just I feel like this is their this is their ultimate solution. The marzipan stuff to what
1:31:10do we do with the Mac in a world where iOS is our most important platform? And the answer
1:31:13is we're not going to replace the Mac, but we might replace the Mac app platform so that
1:31:19the common way we think of a Mac app is something that's built on UI kit and also runs on iOS.
1:31:25I think that's possible and it's absolutely you've absolutely nailed a area of conversation
1:31:31I wanted to have with you. I think that what you just said is entirely possible.
1:31:35You say that with no enthusiasm.
1:31:41I do have no enthusiasm. I have no enthusiasm because what we've seen so far is not good.
1:31:46I should also clarify that just, you know, people who listen to the show probably know it,
1:31:57But Apple hasn't given a name to marzipan like that marzipan is something that leaked as a codename and I
1:32:04Know it is used internally to refer to something. You know this this project to get these four apps
1:32:10news stocks
1:32:13home and voice recorder, yeah
1:32:17Running on the Mac
1:32:21And
1:32:23For all the reasons you said and for general consensus that
1:32:28That that iOS developers of which there are many more than there are Mac developers have largely
1:32:38Rejected creating Mac apps because they see it as too much work and or two different
1:32:46And or slightly difficult in certain ways
1:32:51which we don't need to get into and neither of us are really I
1:32:54Get it at the broad strokes that app kit is old and UI kit is
1:33:00newer and a lot of the things in UI kit that are different than app kit are things that
1:33:05They took the you know, the people who used it the most and created it
1:33:10You know for stalls iOS software team that started it next could say starting in you know
1:33:162005 or 2006, whenever they started that work
1:33:20for the app framework for the iPhone, could say,
1:33:22well, wait, we know AppKit intimately.
1:33:25What are some of the things we hate about it
1:33:27and would do differently if we could do it all over again?
1:33:29'Cause we're doing it all over again
1:33:31and we can even make changes that would break app.
1:33:34We can't just say these are good ideas.
1:33:36We should do them in AppKit too
1:33:37because AppKit has to keep being AppKit, right?
1:33:40It's just one of those things.
1:33:41Here's an opportunity for a clean break.
1:33:43Let's do it that way.
1:33:45And then Mac developers could look at UIKit and say, "Hey, that's cool. This is so much
1:33:52easier in UIKit than AppKit." But now we're at the point where there's probably millions
1:33:57of iOS developers who started with UIKit who look at AppKit, which has the old way, and
1:34:04say, "Well, that seems like a lot of work. Why would I do that?" And who maybe don't
1:34:10get it, period. They don't get the whole Mac-like thing anyway.
1:34:13Right. So I get it. I get that there's a market for that. I don't know though that what we've
1:34:18seen, I don't know that this project actually is that initiative. Like there may even be
1:34:27an initiative along the lines of exactly what you're saying, a more unified UI kit derived
1:34:34way of making apps for all platforms, including the Mac, which would be, here's our new way
1:34:39of doing it. That is not the thing that was used to make these four apps. I mean, maybe
1:34:47it's sort of is, and this is just one little piece of it, but that the whole picture is
1:34:51so much bigger that it's not even worth thinking about, uh, or thinking about based on what
1:34:59we've seen so far in these four apps in Mojave. Like I really think that it might be that
1:35:04shallow an effort. I've, I can't, I agree. And it better be right. Cause these apps are
1:35:09kind of crappy, but it, so I, but I think you're right. I think there's a,
1:35:13Mark Gurman said something at some point about how there's more as a pan,
1:35:17but there's also like a whole bunch of other, uh,
1:35:20efforts that they're doing in terms of ways that developers can build UIs and
1:35:24things like that.
1:35:25I think maybe there is a much bigger picture that we haven't seen that is not
1:35:29just, you know,
1:35:30the same tools that brought you the home app will now be available to everyone.
1:35:34Right. It's good. It's going to be a completely, you know,
1:35:37a much bigger thing, I think, than what we've seen so far.
1:35:40- The thing that bothers me about these apps
1:35:43is that they saw them as being worth shipping
1:35:46because it's the sort of thing that the user
1:35:49shouldn't have to worry about, right?
1:35:52So for example, let's just compare and contrast with,
1:35:55and maybe it's a bad analogy, I don't know,
1:35:57'cause programming languages are different
1:35:58than the application frameworks, but,
1:36:00you know, Apple software development across all platforms
1:36:07is moving from Objective-C, which has been around
1:36:12since the late '80s, to a new programming language
1:36:14called Swift.
1:36:15And every year, more and more of the OSs
1:36:20are written inside Apple and Swift than Objective-C,
1:36:24and the third-party apps are,
1:36:27new ones are often created entirely in Swift
1:36:29from the beginning, and old ones as new features are added
1:36:32are being written in Swift instead of Objective-C.
1:36:36And guess what, from a user's perspective,
1:36:38they could have never heard of either of those things
1:36:40or have any idea what the difference
1:36:42between Objective-C and Swift is,
1:36:43and there's no visible sign of it whatsoever,
1:36:46which is how it should be, right?
1:36:49That's developer problem.
1:36:51So like this,
1:36:53it's totally a developer problem if it's,
1:36:59it is a problem.
1:37:01Is it problematic enough that Apple needs
1:37:04to make a serious effort to fix it
1:37:05to get iOS apps more easily ported to the Mac
1:37:09or sharing more code with the Mac or make the Mac app
1:37:12with the way you make a Mac app more like it.
1:37:14Okay, fine.
1:37:17But then whatever the result of that problem is,
1:37:19it shouldn't be painfully obvious to a typical Mac user
1:37:22who opens the app that this app is weird.
1:37:25- Right, right.
1:37:27This goes back to all our conversations
1:37:30that we just had about weird Windows apps
1:37:32that get ported to the Mac.
1:37:33It's like if it doesn't feel right,
1:37:36like what's wrong with this thing?
1:37:37Why does it play or all those Java apps
1:37:39that we got in the 90s and early 2000s
1:37:41that were just totally not right.
1:37:44Like something is really wrong here.
1:37:45- You'd open them up and there would be,
1:37:48they would have a Mac menu bar,
1:37:49but the Mac menu bar would just be like two items.
1:37:52Like one of which was to quit the app.
1:37:53And then all of the other menu items
1:37:55were in a window style menu bar
1:37:58within the window of the app.
1:38:00So not only was it wrong to have a Windows style menu bar
1:38:04in the window, it also had a Mac menu bar
1:38:07that didn't have the menu items.
1:38:10I mean, it was terrible.
1:38:12These marzipan apps are not that bad.
1:38:14I'm calling them marzipan because we need a name
1:38:16to talk about it.
1:38:17- Yeah, 'cause Apple very aggressively did not name it
1:38:21at WWDC.
1:38:22It's just a new method of building apps
1:38:24that is coming in 2019.
1:38:26- Right.
1:38:27But these apps have that,
1:38:29that this doesn't belong on the platform.
1:38:31This does weird things, stuff, you know,
1:38:36and it's, A, this feels weird for the Mac in general,
1:38:39but it feels really weird to be shipping
1:38:41as part of the system from Apple.
1:38:42I don't have, I'm still not running Mojave as my main OS,
1:38:47so I can't look at them right here,
1:38:49but I mean, just off the top of my head,
1:38:51there's a lot of weird drag and drop problems in these apps,
1:38:53which is the sort of thing you sometimes expect
1:38:56from third party apps, but never from Apple apps.
1:38:58It's like, I think it's the news app, maybe news and stocks,
1:39:05because news and stocks are sort of the same app.
1:39:07It's sort of like stocks is really just a way to get Apple
1:39:09news about the companies that are listed in the stocks.
1:39:13It's like if you make the window wide,
1:39:17you can make the window as wide as you want,
1:39:19but the content doesn't reflow to fit it.
1:39:22Which in and of itself, it's not like you
1:39:24to be a good Mac app, you would have to support
1:39:27a full width of a 30 inch iMac.
1:39:30But if there is a maximum width that you can flow to,
1:39:33that should be the maximum width of the window.
1:39:35Like, it's always been like, I'm sure you'll agree,
1:39:39one of the top signs of a,
1:39:40hmm, you're new to writing Mac apps, aren't you,
1:39:42is if an app would let you make the window too small.
1:39:46Right?
1:39:47Like there's, you know, a good Mac app has always known,
1:39:50all right, you can resize the window,
1:39:52but here's the max that we can handle gracefully
1:39:55and here's the minimum we can handle gracefully
1:39:58and that's it.
1:39:58And when you could get an app that would make you,
1:40:00let you shrink it up as far as you want
1:40:02and you'd start covering up buttons and controls and stuff.
1:40:05It's like, oh my God, you could just fix this and res at it.
1:40:08Marzipan apps have a lot of stuff like that.
1:40:12But the way that like sidebars work,
1:40:14the way that there's no contextual menu items
1:40:16like standard ones that every single app has had
1:40:19since Mac OS X shipped,
1:40:21It's just weird.
1:40:23The sharing thing is one of the ones I've written about.
1:40:26And they did fix it, and I don't know if me writing about it
1:40:29had any effect on that.
1:40:31I don't wanna take credit for it,
1:40:34but even the way they fixed it is so weird.
1:40:37So one of the problems with Apple News on Mojave
1:40:40is if you read, let's say there's an article
1:40:44from Six Colors, and you read it in Apple News,
1:40:49and you're like, this is a good story.
1:40:50I would like to share this. I would like to put it in an iMessage or mail it to a friend.
1:40:57On iOS, you can hit our good old friend from half an hour ago, the square box with the
1:41:03arrow, and one of the options would be like message and you could send a message. And
1:41:10you could copy the URL and get a real URL. Or no, I know what it is. iOS has an open
1:41:16and Safari button. And so you can make the article open from Apple News in Safari and
1:41:21it'll take you to the six colors.com version of the website. If you care enough that I
1:41:26want to make sure I'm not sending an Apple News URL, I want to send the original URL
1:41:32on the Mac version. You there was no open in Safari and there wasn't a way to copy the
1:41:39link. It was like one of the first ways I figured out to get a real URL out of it was
1:41:44to copy the URL, which would copy an apple.news/whatever unique identifier URL. And then instead of
1:41:53using Safari, go to Chrome and paste it in there. And then it would redirect to the original
1:42:00website because Chrome doesn't know the magic. Hey, if it's an Apple News URL, open it in
1:42:05Apple News. But if you opened it in Safari, it would always take you to Safari. There
1:42:09was other than using Chrome or some other third party software, there was no way to
1:42:13to get the original URL.
1:42:15Like that's crazy and very un-Mac like.
1:42:18It's not just limited.
1:42:19Anyway, I don't know.
1:42:22I see that stuff as a,
1:42:24I'm very worried about it to be honest.
1:42:27That if this is actually a sign of where Apple thinks,
1:42:32that these are fine examples of,
1:42:34well, the other thing is that in the latest version
1:42:39of Mojave, they added like a file share
1:42:42or copy Safari link button or something.
1:42:44I forget what they did.
1:42:45I don't use Mojave on a daily basis,
1:42:46so I forget what it was.
1:42:48They added a menu item that does give you the original URL.
1:42:52So there is that.
1:42:53It might even still be in the beta version
1:42:58that's not actually shipping.
1:43:00So anybody out there who's looking in Mojave
1:43:02and looking for it while they listen to this,
1:43:03maybe it's not there yet,
1:43:04but there is a solution in the beta at least.
1:43:07But it's not the right solution.
1:43:10It's certainly not the Mac-like one.
1:43:11So I'm deeply concerned that these are,
1:43:15like they're either some type of prototypes
1:43:20that effectively should have been branded as public betas,
1:43:25that we're shipping public betas
1:43:27of these four apps in Mojave.
1:43:28Mojave will be shipping as a non-beta OS in the fall,
1:43:32and it will include four public betas of these apps,
1:43:36which they did not say.
1:43:39These apps are not branded as public betas.
1:43:41They are branded as the Mac version of home
1:43:43and news and whatever.
1:43:45I'm deeply concerned.
1:43:49If the mistake is that they should have been called
1:43:51public betas and they didn't want to call them public betas,
1:43:54but they've got much better ideas
1:43:56for where they're going with this stuff,
1:43:58well then I can't wait.
1:43:59I look forward to hearing about those ideas.
1:44:02If these are actually indicative
1:44:03of where Apple thinks Mac apps,
1:44:05like what makes a reasonable Mac app from Apple,
1:44:08then I've maybe never been more concerned
1:44:11about the future of the platform.
1:44:13- Yeah, that's the mystery, isn't it?
1:44:15Did they think these were okay?
1:44:17Or are they just trying to...
1:44:18'Cause the advantage of shipping them is,
1:44:20especially for news, news is an important platform for them.
1:44:25It's an important thing for them to do.
1:44:29Home, right?
1:44:30Having home kit support is important to have.
1:44:32I get why you wanna get those in Mojave
1:44:35so you can say, "Finally, the Mac can do these things."
1:44:38I was complaining about no home kit support in the Mac
1:44:40for the last couple of years, right?
1:44:41So great.
1:44:42- It was like when the Mac didn't have Siri for years.
1:44:47- Yeah, exactly.
1:44:47And it's like, you know, okay, so now we can do that.
1:44:50And I get it, but there is,
1:44:54I do think it's an interesting question why they didn't,
1:44:56given how Apple has really become much more open
1:44:59to branding things as beta, shipping beta things
1:45:03in their operating systems for a while now
1:45:06to not have branded these as a beta or something.
1:45:11'Cause I hear, just like you do, I'm sure,
1:45:13from people when you criticize these apps who say,
1:45:15"But you know, it's just a, they're just trying it out.
1:45:18It's just new."
1:45:19And it's like, yeah, but they shipped it
1:45:20in the shipping version of the software.
1:45:21It's not a beta, it's the final version of these apps
1:45:24that ships with the OS.
1:45:26So they obviously have some degree of confidence
1:45:29'cause they didn't slap that label on it.
1:45:31And that goes back to your, I think,
1:45:33concern about the platform, which is,
1:45:36does Apple think that the marzipan apps are are good enough? And I mean, I'm sure they
1:45:41don't but the question is do they think that they're you know close or do they think that
1:45:47they're a completely transitional thing that the was the only way they were going to get
1:45:51in Mojave but they know that that's not the total solution that's going to come in 2019
1:45:57and that's what I kind of assume but you know it is I although I remain optimistic that
1:46:04Apple is going to an interesting place here that could be good for the Mac and good for
1:46:08Apple's platforms overall. You know, every transition like this is fraught with peril.
1:46:16And if you're a Mac user, there definitely is a scenario here where in order to get the
1:46:23iOS stuff over on the Mac, the Mac kind of gets messed up. And that's definitely a possibility.
1:46:30And there are probably people inside Apple whose opinion is basically, "Look, the Mac
1:46:35is a legacy platform, the old apps aren't going away, but if anybody else wants to use
1:46:40this thing, any computer-shaped computers from us in the future, we gotta have the App
1:46:44Store apps on there.
1:46:45So we're gonna just do this and the people who care about the Mac as it was 10 years
1:46:51ago can complain, but we don't care."
1:46:54I think maybe they don't have the upper hand because I think that roundtable that you went
1:47:00to suggest that maybe the Mac attitude has changed at Apple
1:47:05and they've kind of reinvigorated themselves
1:47:08in terms of letting the Mac be the Mac.
1:47:10So that's part of what makes me optimistic here
1:47:12is that I think this is Apple solution
1:47:15to keep the Mac relevant
1:47:17instead of what they might have been planning before,
1:47:20which was to just let it sort of float along on its own
1:47:23until everybody who used it stopped buying computers
1:47:27or died.
1:47:27(laughs)
1:47:28So I choose to be optimistic about this
1:47:30because of the about face they've done on the Mac
1:47:32in so many other areas the last year and a half.
1:47:35- One of the things that Apple and Next in particular,
1:47:40the next half of Apple really took a tremendous pride in
1:47:46and was there really for Next their claim to fame
1:47:50was the ease with which they allowed rich applications
1:47:53to be created compared to what had come before,
1:47:58which we now know as Coco, you know, with the project builder, which is now Xcode, you
1:48:03know, and interface builder, that you could drag and drop your interface in interface
1:48:10builder and set constraints with, you know, tools that were a lot like the tools in drawing
1:48:15apps, you know, with, you know, here's how you set the bounds of a rectangle and you
1:48:19can set the style for a label, text label and stuff. And that you've got all these
1:48:25things that were built in like here's a rich text editing field. So if you want rich text
1:48:31in your app, like, like,
1:48:32Jared Ranere: text edits, it was teach text that it was simple text. Now it's text.
1:48:36Brian Smith Right. That's text edit, jeez, I forgot text
1:48:38edits name. Right. But you can get the full power of text edit in any app just by dragging
1:48:42the control out, you know, and this was, it wasn't like this on the Mac or Windows. And,
1:48:47you know, people could make people could write custom apps or new apps in in on the next
1:48:52step system with a lot less work and a lot less time.
1:48:55And it was a big part of the eventual success of Mac OS X
1:49:02is that it wasn't just a good platform,
1:49:04it was a great platform that really enabled
1:49:07small teams of developers to build really powerful apps.
1:49:10And we see that to this day, right?
1:49:12Where there are apps like, you know,
1:49:16Acorn is from a friend, you know, my friend Gus Mueller,
1:49:22He runs the company with his wife, and Gus is the only developer, and it's a super
1:49:27powerful image editor.
1:49:29He's one person.
1:49:31He's very good, but it would be really, really difficult to do that on another platform
1:49:38because there's so much stuff built into Mac OS X that he can rely on Apple's color
1:49:44management and stuff like that.
1:49:47You know, it's a really big difference from the classic Mac era.
1:49:52Like there was lots of stuff I still love about the classic Mac era, but there weren't
1:49:55going to be a one-man alternative to Photoshop.
1:49:59You know, it just wasn't possible because there wasn't enough built into the system.
1:50:04So anyway, Apple's—all this is to say is Apple has prided itself not on being a good
1:50:08platform for users, but that it's a great platform for developers just insofar as are
1:50:14the tools good and are the frameworks good. And you know, the state of the art always
1:50:21moves forward, right? So my hope would be is both for their internal use inside Apple
1:50:27and for third party developers writing for their products that they are, they've got
1:50:33grand plans inside for where's the next way we take this. So it's not just not even just
1:50:39Here's how Mac apps can be made more easily
1:50:43by iOS developers.
1:50:44But how can the whole state of the art for iOS development
1:50:48be taken to a new level for a new decade?
1:50:51- Right.
1:50:52- So my hope is that their plans are grand like that.
1:50:57These four marzipan apps are not the work of that project.
1:51:00They may be the work of one tiny leg
1:51:03of a many legged stool of that project,
1:51:06but this is not that.
1:51:07There's just no sign of it.
1:51:11Yeah, well these are also, I think they viewed this all as low-hanging fruit, like these
1:51:15are all single window apps, right?
1:51:17So there's obviously multi-window tech.
1:51:18Yeah, but that's part of what sucks about them is they shouldn't be single window apps.
1:51:21Why in the world should voice recorder be a single window app?
1:51:24Why is Apple News a single window app on the map?
1:51:27Why can't I double click an article to open it in a window?
1:51:29Because I want to keep reading.
1:51:30Not wrong.
1:51:31You're not wrong.
1:51:32I want to keep reading new articles.
1:51:35answer is that they haven't either they haven't done that yet or the part that they did they
1:51:40can't release yet because it's part of a bigger something. You're right. You're right. It's
1:51:44insane that Apple News is a single window app. I mean, maybe home makes sense as a single
1:51:49window app, but certainly not Apple News. It's ridiculous. It's really hard to believe
1:51:54that I find I don't find it hard to believe that somebody made it. I don't find it hard
1:52:00to believe that there's there are people at Apple whose experience is so thoroughly on
1:52:04the iOS side of things and they don't maybe weren't Mac users before that they would think
1:52:11you know as a proof of concept. Hey look I do have and as a proof of concept it certainly
1:52:15is interesting right it's certainly worth looking if you didn't know about the project
1:52:19and somebody came up to you and you're a manager at Apple and somebody said hey I got Apple
1:52:24News running on the Mac and they showed you what what they have right now this this in
1:52:30Mojave, you would certainly say, let's, you know, I would say, I would say, let's have
1:52:34a meeting. This looks interesting, right? Let's see who, who should be in a meeting.
1:52:38Let's, let's talk about this. Cause you've got something here, right? You don't have
1:52:42something shippable, but you have a very interesting proof of concept. I find it crazy that that
1:52:49went all the way through to, this is a major part, you know, or not major, but this is
1:52:55and mentionable in the keynote part of Mojave without somebody in a position of authority
1:53:02saying you can't ship this app without support for multiple windows or opening articles in
1:53:06windows.
1:53:07I mean, it's just crazy.
1:53:09I mean, you know, maybe there's no, there's no, again, it's not a written rule.
1:53:13There's no line in the Hague that says that a news app has to be able to open articles
1:53:18in multiple windows.
1:53:19But it's almost because you didn't have to write it.
1:53:23That's the whole point of a Mac.
1:53:24I think the answer is probably that somebody had to make the decision, which is worse,
1:53:29another year where the Mac doesn't support Apple News and HomeKit, or it supports it
1:53:36with apps that aren't quite up to our standards. And they made the decision that it was more
1:53:40important. It's funny, too, because they didn't need to release these apps. And I wonder sometimes
1:53:46about why they did that, because the so they're like, OK, well, we can get HomeKit on the
1:53:51Mac, but what it's going to take is it's going to take us to use this translation layer to
1:53:54do it. And it's not going to be a great app, but it'll work. And, but you know that the
1:53:59moment we ship this, the first beta, everybody's going to take it apart and realize we have
1:54:04a translation layer. And they're going to freak out. So if we do this, we're going to
1:54:08have to say something because we need to, we need to set expectations. Because that's
1:54:12the other thing about this is these four apps, these four apps required them to have those
1:54:17slides where they talked about how this was something that they were going to do in a
1:54:20year. I feel like that was the imprint of Steve Trout and Smith on the WWDC keynote.
1:54:27Apple can't just ship that news app and then go nobody knows the truth, which is that it's actually
1:54:35the iOS version. Because within hours, Steve Trout and Smith would pull it apart and say, "Oh,
1:54:40this is a whole system. Here's how it works. Here's this." So they had to say something about it.
1:54:45Or they could have not shipped the apps, foregone those features in Mojave, and just said, "Oh,
1:54:52we don't know what Mark Gurman's talking about. We have no idea."
1:54:55It's an interesting theory, and I don't know. Again, I really need to start using Mojave
1:54:59on a daily basis more just to be able to form and conceal my opinion on this. But it's possible
1:55:08from what I've seen that maybe home was the one that drove it, because home is the one
1:55:12that they kind of needed. Right? You didn't have you couldn't get your Apple News on your
1:55:17on your Mac, but it was easy. If you were on your iPad or phone and you got or your
1:55:22watch even and you got the alert. If you wanted to read that story on your Mac, you could
1:55:26get it it would just open in Safari right every as far as I know part of the rules of
1:55:31Apple News is that every single article in Apple News is represented by an article on
1:55:36the publisher's website. I don't think there's I don't if I'm wrong, I'd love to know but
1:55:41but I don't think there is such a thing.
1:55:44So you weren't missing out on the news,
1:55:48whereas you are missing out
1:55:49on being able to manage your HomeKit stuff.
1:55:51And we probably won't have time to talk about it,
1:55:56me and you on this show, or at least not in depth,
1:55:58but I think one of the interesting things for 2019
1:56:00is I think Apple's HomeKit stuff
1:56:02is really starting to pay off.
1:56:03I think they were behind Amazon
1:56:06and other companies for a while,
1:56:08based on their security stuff
1:56:10and the way they tried to leverage their MFI influence
1:56:13and had more control and therefore everything went slower
1:56:18because Amazon's is sort of a Wild West of,
1:56:22here's our stuff, ship whatever you want.
1:56:24- Yeah.
1:56:25- But in my personal experience,
1:56:28Apple's home stuff works better than Amazon's.
1:56:33- Yeah, I've gone from having a whole bunch
1:56:36of Wild West stuff to wanting everything
1:56:39be in HomeKit and using the Home app all the time. And I now run on my Mac Mini server
1:56:45that I've got, I'm running this command line utility called HomeBridge. It's basically
1:56:52a software bridge for HomeKit, for non-HomeKit compatible apps. And once I set it up, which
1:56:59you know, you got a bunch of config files and you got to do a bunch of stuff and import
1:57:04plugins for the various devices you've got. But all of my non-HomeKit compatible devices
1:57:09are now in HomeKit because of that. And so now, you know, the jig is up. Now I'm basically
1:57:17only using the Home app to control my stuff and it's good.
1:57:22And that's the one that was a real obvious gaping hole on the Mac. If you're going to
1:57:28throw yourself into the Apple ecosystem and you're a good Apple customer and you've got
1:57:33a phone and a Mac and maybe an iPad and you're buying, you know, maybe you got Apple TV and
1:57:37you're buying HomeKit compatible appliances. It seems crazy that you couldn't use your
1:57:41Mac to manage it. And so I wonder about that. I wonder if that's, I mean, this is absolutely
1:57:48not, this is just based on your speculation, but boy, that certainly is an interesting
1:57:52theory. I mean, it's just a spitball, but it certainly is interesting that they wanted
1:57:56to ship home. That was the easiest way to get it. It's probably the one that it seems
1:58:01the least weird. It doesn't seem particularly Mac-like. It's certainly insane to me that
1:58:06the dialog boxes are iOS dialog boxes.
1:58:09When you set a schedule and you have to turn the little iOS tumbler, that is the worst.
1:58:16I was convinced they were going to fix that by the time Mojave left beta.
1:58:19I really was. I really was too. Because it's a control that it doesn't really make it's
1:58:26not on a touchscreen. It makes no sense. It makes no sense without a touchscreen. It's
1:58:31is absolutely insane that to set the schedule,
1:58:34you get a date picker like iOS.
1:58:36It is crazy.
1:58:37I mean, and in terms of if they had shipped that app,
1:58:40you wouldn't have even needed Stephen Trout and Smith
1:58:41or Guillermo Rambo to take it apart
1:58:44before you knew that it was an iOS app running on a Mac.
1:58:47- Right, if you click on the right places,
1:58:49it's very, very clear from the beginning what it is.
1:58:52Yeah. - Right, and it was--
1:58:54- I would sit at my Mac.
1:58:54I got the light next to my desk on a HomeKit switch.
1:58:58And I would have those moments where I'd be like,
1:59:00"Oh, I need to turn on the light, it's getting dark.
1:59:02"I need to go get my iPhone.
1:59:05"My Mac can't do this, I have to go get..."
1:59:07And that sucked.
1:59:08It's better with Mojave, there's no doubt about it,
1:59:10even if the app is stupid.
1:59:11- Yeah.
1:59:12Well, that's an interesting theory.
1:59:14All right, let me thank my third sponsor,
1:59:16'cause we're going long on time here.
1:59:18And it's our good friends, very good friends.
1:59:19I mean that genuinely, sincerely,
1:59:21because they sponsored my show for a long time,
1:59:24and they sponsor it very frequently.
1:59:25It's our good friends at Squarespace.
1:59:27You've heard of them.
1:59:29If you've listened to this show before,
1:59:30you've almost, it's almost impossible that you haven't at least caught one episode that
1:59:34they've sponsored. But they keep sponsoring because guess what? People keep signing up
1:59:39with code. They've got the data to back it up. And I think what happens is what are the
1:59:45odds that you, Joe or Jane, average listener of the talk show in late December 2018 need
1:59:54a new website right now? Yeah, probably pretty low. But what are the odds you're going to
1:59:58need a new website sometime next year. Probably a lot higher. And I think they keep sponsoring
2:00:04the show because it's filed away in your head that, "Hey, Gruber keeps saying if I need
2:00:08a website, I should try it at Squarespace first." And people do it and it's true and
2:00:14they get a webinar like, "Wow, that was a lot easier than I thought and these prices
2:00:18are great. I guess I'm done." It really is that easy and I really think that's the key
2:00:25thing about, you know, you might go buy a pillow today because you maybe need a new
2:00:29pillow, but you may not need a website right now. But when you do, you build it at Squarespace,
2:00:35file it away in your head that that's where you should try it first. Everything is in
2:00:39the Squarespace system. It is you just go there, you sign up, and you do your design
2:00:44in the browser window, you do the customization in the browser window, you get your analytics
2:00:49right there on the Squarespace system. And they have great analytics is truly one of
2:00:54of my favorite things about Squarespace,
2:00:57because I find almost every analytics passage
2:00:59for like, you know, what's your traffic,
2:01:01where's it coming from, what's popular on your website.
2:01:05I find it to be the most baffling,
2:01:07it looks like an airplane cockpit type thing.
2:01:09Like I have no idea how anybody could ever use it.
2:01:11You look at Squarespaces and it is like so clean,
2:01:14so well-designed, so Tuftian almost,
2:01:16and its clarity of presentation.
2:01:19Really, really one of the great things.
2:01:21They have great customer support.
2:01:23They have great technology.
2:01:25Their websites are rock solid.
2:01:28All of the templates you can use to choose from
2:01:30are super well designed.
2:01:32They all scale perfectly from giant screens
2:01:34all the way down to cell phones.
2:01:36And if you sign up for a whole year,
2:01:38you can get a free domain name registration.
2:01:41So where do you go?
2:01:42Go to squarespace.com/talkshow.
2:01:44Know the, just squarespace.com/talkshow.
2:01:47And when you sign up, you get a free trial to start out,
2:01:51make sure everything works.
2:01:52When you go to sign up, just remember that code talk show.
2:01:55Same thing as the URL, know that,
2:01:58and you get 10% off your first purchase.
2:02:01My thanks to Squarespace
2:02:02as the final sponsor of this episode.
2:02:05What else?
2:02:08We got to talk about keyboards
2:02:09'cause you can't come on the show
2:02:10and we don't talk about keyboards.
2:02:11- I know, right?
2:02:12And baseball season is over.
2:02:13- Yeah, baseball season is over.
2:02:15- It's keyboard season, I guess.
2:02:17- You know what?
2:02:17Can I tell you just tell you one thing about baseball?
2:02:19- Okay, let's do it.
2:02:20- I love the MLB app.
2:02:22I do, I have the alerts turned on,
2:02:25but I know we've talked about this before too.
2:02:27I do move it off my first home screen in the off season.
2:02:31- Sure. - It's over on home screen too.
2:02:32But I still get the news alerts.
2:02:34But in this off season,
2:02:37I would say nine out of 10 of the stories
2:02:39are conjecture about trades or free agent signings.
2:02:44Like who might Manny Machado go to?
2:02:47I don't wanna read any of those stories.
2:02:48I wish, and I don't know how this could be configured
2:02:51preferences. But I want to hear about every news. Anything that seems like a significant
2:02:56signing from any baseball team, I would like to hear about it. I don't want to read any
2:03:00of the speculation. But nine out of the ten alerts are for the speculation. And then I
2:03:04ignore them. And then I find out, like, three days after it happens that the Yankees re-sign
2:03:11Jay Happ. I'm like, "What do you mean they re-sign Jay Happ? I thought he was leaving."
2:03:14And it's like, "Well, how did I miss that? I have the alerts." But it's because I've
2:03:18trained myself to ignore them.
2:03:20it should be on their list like they have very little granularity in their notification
2:03:25setting I'm looking at it right now basically there's a you could do individual team and
2:03:30then there's then there's news on and off for individual teams or for general MLB news
2:03:36and one of the things that I feel like in this era of iOS 12 and having control over
2:03:42your notifications that Apple needs to even push even more to app developers especially
2:03:48like leading app developers like the MLB app. This is always one of the highlighted apps.
2:03:52They have a great relationship with Apple. They need more granularity in their push notifications
2:03:57for content than they have. I actually experienced this. I actually sent a bug report to the
2:04:02Washington Post because I had their, this was last year, I had their news alerts turned
2:04:09on and they started sending me news alerts that were things like feature stories or you
2:04:15know, crossword puzzles or whatever, like things that are not news. And I sent them
2:04:20a bug report and I said, you guys need to separate your promotional story pushes from
2:04:27your news breaking news headlines. Because if you don't, I'm just going to turn off notifications
2:04:34because I, you know, yes, if somebody famous dies and you want to send out a push, I will,
2:04:39I want to see that you can depress me. I get those. There's a point last year over the
2:04:45holidays actually where like I got two push notifications a day from the
2:04:49Washington Post and they were the most depressing things but it's like I signed
2:04:52up for it it's fine but what I don't want is we also have recipes for for
2:04:57Christmas Eve it's like right people want that that's great if they want to
2:05:01get the feature story headlines I think the New York Times and Washington Post
2:05:04both do this now where you can say do you want featured stories or do you just
2:05:10want breaking news. And that's what MLB needs. It needs like news is needs to be broken up
2:05:17into like news that happens. And then like other stories because those rumor roundups
2:05:23are not news per se. I mean, I guess they can be qualified as that. But I get what you're
2:05:29saying is that they all push notification app should have more granularity. The problem
2:05:34is that most of them are like, "Well, yeah, but really, we use this to feed them that,
2:05:41and we want them in the same pipe." But as a user, I want to be able to turn that off,
2:05:46because I don't want the recipe push notifications. I just want the headlines.
2:05:49The Post does a good job. I feel like the two news organizations I have that are allowed
2:05:55to send me—well, three, actually. It's three organizations. The three things that send
2:06:00me news are the New York Times, the Washington Post. I pay for subscriptions to both and
2:06:08Apple News. And Apple News is the one that annoys me the least. And I know there was
2:06:13a feature story recently about the editorial team that they've assembled there. It's
2:06:17a really big editorial team. And of course, there was somebody who was a managing editor
2:06:23who asked not to be named. It was like, only at Apple would somebody be the managing editor
2:06:29of a news publication and not want their name used. Just because they don't want it, they
2:06:34just don't want their name. It wasn't because he or she had a quote that was damning. It
2:06:40was like, "I want to work in secrecy because I'm an apple." The Times is the one that lately
2:06:47has been leaking, to me at least, a lot more like, "Why the fuck are you giving me an alert
2:06:52for this? I don't want to hear about what's new in gingerbread man frosting in 2018."
2:06:59So the post, and I'm not taking credit for this, but at some point after I complained
2:07:03about this, they actually did do this. The post's push alert settings are Breaking News,
2:07:08Editor's Picks, and then Politics, Opinion, the sections. And they've separated Editor's
2:07:14Picks and Breaking News, and they actually say the frequency, you know, expect a few
2:07:18daily, expect a few weekly. But this is the thing where I was able to turn off the Editor's
2:07:23Picks, which means that I'm not getting those feature story things, which if I open the
2:07:27I'll see your feature stories, but I don't want to get the push notification and that's the right way to do it
2:07:31Yeah, hey, did you see the story while we're talking about you see this the the controversy mini controversy that erupted last week
2:07:37Where Apple sent out some promotional push notifications for a new episode of car carpool karaoke?
2:07:43I I did see that I did see that but by the way
2:07:46The Times also has a breaking news top stories thing so you can you think I got to adjust that I got to get in
2:07:51Yeah, yeah, yeah, you know people hate that because
2:07:55technically in the guidelines there are certain push notifications you're not supposed to send but you know my my I
2:08:00Didn't please anybody by saying I don't think it's a big deal because if they're pushing Apple music subscribers about a new piece of content
2:08:07That's available to Apple music subscribers like Netflix does that to me all the time where they're like oh, here's a new show for you
2:08:13And I don't turn that notification off because it's never valuable, but that's that's reasonable
2:08:19It's for Netflix for me. It is often not valuable
2:08:24But it's infrequent enough that I don't mind
2:08:27You know like I know that there are some purists out there who really don't want any note of one
2:08:32I didn't want this notification really is like a grain of sand in their eye
2:08:36You know like you know that they keep their notifications very neat and orderly
2:08:40My notifications are more like the pile of you know junk mail and not I shouldn't say I am
2:08:48but I get way more notifications than I read but with the the
2:08:52the iOS 11 or was it only recently with 12 12 12 so it's that recent I've come so used to it that
2:08:58I'm I'm fine with it Dieter bone and I talked about this in a recent episode where you know
2:09:04he still prefers the Google style but the Google style to me drives me nuts because it doesn't show me enough information, but
2:09:10But the way that I could have
2:09:1320 notifications from at bat and they show up in one stack in the list
2:09:18It doesn't look like they're badgering me because it's all neatly organized and it's only I only have to scroll past the most recent one
2:09:25if I want
2:09:27Anyway the the Apple news one
2:09:30It's are not Apple news the Apple carpool karaoke one. I don't know why people and that's for it
2:09:36it's weird because and it's also weird because
2:09:38Carpool karaoke isn't something Apple even sells like you just get it for free like it's just it's well
2:09:46Well it's part of your Apple Music subscription, I think is how that works.
2:09:49Oh, you have to have Apple Music? Is that what it is?
2:09:51Yeah, I think so.
2:09:52Alright, so you do have to have Apple Music. But then you only got that notification if
2:09:56you have Apple Music.
2:09:57I think that's the idea. And that seems less offensive to me. But I think the answer is
2:10:01people don't like Carpool Karaoke. It's a representative of like the old Apple TV culture
2:10:06before they hired the new TV people. It's a video show in a music service. It is music
2:10:12related but it is a video show and a music service so a lot of people feel it's kind
2:10:16of off-brand and then there are a lot of nerds who are angry because they feel like this
2:10:22is Apple abusing their privilege in a way that third-party developers aren't. I get
2:10:27all the reasons but to me I kind of gave it a shrug like turn off your notifications for
2:10:32Apple Music for Pete's sake. Well and there's actually one of three that you can turn off
2:10:36to stop getting those. Like you can still you know you don't have to turn off all of
2:10:40them you can still get notified for other things you might want that aren't
2:10:43just promotional things but I do think there's something particular about Apple
2:10:48using its position to do this that is a bad look like it's a default app and
2:10:54those notifications are turned on by default whereas a third-party app would
2:10:58have to ask you for notification power so it's a you did somehow technically
2:11:02opt into it or maybe but yeah yeah but not really like I don't think when you
2:11:07launch Apple Music for the first time it's the music app it says would you
2:11:11like us to notify you it's like yes we are going to notify you we are Apple
2:11:14yeah yeah and it all falls under I mean the primary example of it is is the the
2:11:22u2 album right sure the you know we're we've worked out a deal with you to you
2:11:29you too and guess what you're already getting the album it's being sent to
2:11:33your devices right now and people really did not like that for good reason like I
2:11:39kind of do see how that one got approved because I kind of see how it was like
2:11:43you know they're a huge band lots of people do like them I'm sure many many
2:11:48many people appreciated getting the free album and they just didn't think to say
2:11:53anything publicly about it because they're like cool free album whereas the
2:11:57people who did not appreciate the free album and had it forced on them found it
2:12:03offensive and I know there's a certain tone definite. I could see how they were
2:12:06tone deaf to that thinking they were they were excited like hey everybody
2:12:10gets free album isn't that great and didn't think about that that people
2:12:13view that as their personal space that was being cluttered by a corporate
2:12:19synergy thing right and it pushes push notifications are like that I mean I
2:12:24you're watching a movie or you're doing something on your personal device and a
2:12:29little bubble pops up and if it's something that is super intrusive and not at all relevant
2:12:34to you of course you're going to be turned off by that so if I got that carpool karaoke
2:12:38notification I would have felt the same way I the one I got I've seen at least two screenshots
2:12:43of the carpool karaoke one I got it my wife did not I don't think my son did either maybe
2:12:49it's because I'm the one who's subscribed to Apple music that might be even though we
2:12:55share it with the family. But the one I got, it said like new episode of carpool karaoke
2:13:01f t period Jason Sudeikis and the Muppets. And it took me it took me like that. The part
2:13:09that annoyed me about it wasn't that I got the notification. It was that I couldn't understand
2:13:12what Fort Jason Sudeikis is. I swear to God, I was like, what the hell is this even mean?
2:13:19It's like when a when a that's that's music lingo, right for when somebody guests on a
2:13:23a track and they do the featuring that way.
2:13:25See, I didn't know that.
2:13:26I didn't even know that was music lingo.
2:13:28I was like this—I didn't even know that that's a word—I've never seen that word
2:13:31abbreviated before, or at least not in a context where I didn't understand it.
2:13:35Like why not write out the word "featuring"?
2:13:38I spent a long time thinking about what Fort Jason was.
2:13:42It's where we all live.
2:13:46That's where you live, at least.
2:13:47All the Jasons.
2:13:48All right, one more serious conversation.
2:13:50I can't let you go.
2:13:51I know we've stretched this on
2:13:52and it's the holiday season and whatever,
2:13:54but I wanna mention something
2:13:55'cause if I don't, I'm never gonna forgive myself
2:13:58because it ties into so much of what we talked about.
2:14:01With that whole Mac likeness thing
2:14:04and the way that Photoshop could be created
2:14:07in a Mac-like way, even though it was going so much deeper
2:14:11than Apple's own system type apps did.
2:14:16Here's my frustration with the iPad
2:14:18or one of my frustrations with the iPad.
2:14:22I don't think there is such clarity
2:14:24as to what makes a good blank app on iOS.
2:14:29Like I look at the writing apps,
2:14:32or let's just say the markdown writing apps,
2:14:34which is crazily enough to me, like literally a category.
2:14:39And they're all over the map.
2:14:44Yeah.
2:14:44They're all over the map in terms of what they do,
2:14:47how they do it and missing features.
2:14:50I don't wanna slag anybody,
2:14:52but there was one I just tried that looked interesting
2:14:55and I tried it and I downloaded it.
2:14:58And I swear to God, the first thing I tried was Command + F
2:15:01to see how did they do find,
2:15:03because this seems like an unsolved problem on iOS.
2:15:06And guess what?
2:15:07It did nothing.
2:15:08There is no find.
2:15:10- Yeah, yeah.
2:15:14- And I get it.
2:15:15VSEPR didn't have, it sorta had search,
2:15:18but it didn't have search within a note, right?
2:15:21Like not Command + F search.
2:15:23You could search for your list of notes
2:15:25to find the string, of course.
2:15:26And I'm sure this app supported something like that
2:15:28in the source list.
2:15:29But that's a notes app, not a text editor, right?
2:15:34For like writing articles.
2:15:35Like you can't have an article,
2:15:37you can't have a thing that's meant for serious writing
2:15:39where you can't search in the article.
2:15:42- Yeah, it's definitely a problem.
2:15:45I think one of the reasons there are so many Markdown apps
2:15:48is that it's easier to do a plain text editor
2:15:51than a style text editor, to be honest.
2:15:53And so that they're like, oh, well, this is great.
2:15:55Markdown text editor, file access, we're done.
2:15:57Maybe you got, and not all of them are like that.
2:16:01There are a lot that are much more sophisticated than that,
2:16:03but I feel like that's one of the reasons
2:16:05that people said, oh, I can make one of those.
2:16:08And then you're right, like all the other features are hard.
2:16:12And some of them, I forget whether it's, is it,
2:16:15So I use OneWriter for the most part,
2:16:17and I think its search is implemented.
2:16:19I'm not sure whether it's search,
2:16:21there's an app I've used for Markdown
2:16:23where the search is implemented basically as a plugin,
2:16:27because it's got a macro language behind it.
2:16:28And I can't remember whether it's a OneWriter or editorial.
2:16:32And I always thought that was one of the most bizarre things
2:16:34that you would not consider it part of your core app
2:16:37to do search, and instead would have it be like
2:16:40an add-on macro that does search.
2:16:43'cause it seems so fundamental to it.
2:16:45And that's the stuff I miss the most, I gotta be honest.
2:16:47The stuff I miss the most on iOS when I'm writing
2:16:50is stuff like, like a grep, like, you know,
2:16:54search and replace with pattern matching if I want it.
2:16:57That stuff is a lot harder to come by.
2:16:59There are apps that do it,
2:17:00but they all have other issues.
2:17:02Like, you know, Drafts does a bunch of stuff.
2:17:05Ulysses does a bunch of stuff with Markdown,
2:17:08but I don't like its approach
2:17:10'cause it sort of translates the Markdown
2:17:12into more of a word processor like kind of object thing
2:17:16where you can't see the link, which I don't like
2:17:18'cause I wanna see the link.
2:17:19So it's just, you know, it's one of those things
2:17:21where whenever I write about writing about this stuff,
2:17:25writing about writing on iOS,
2:17:27I have to put in all these caveats.
2:17:31I have to say the app I'm using now is,
2:17:34and part of that is that for a while
2:17:35the app I was using was editorial and now it's one writer.
2:17:38And I'm just not that invested in one writer.
2:17:41like, it's okay. It works with my workflow.
2:17:45You can point it at a particular folder in Dropbox,
2:17:48which I've set to be where I use default folder on the Mac
2:17:52to make that my default for BB edit.
2:17:54All of my files that I'm working on go in that folder
2:17:57and I can see them in both places.
2:17:59And because it's all text, that's great.
2:18:01But do I love OneWriter?
2:18:03Do I think it solves all of these problems?
2:18:05It absolutely doesn't.
2:18:07There isn't, you know, and if somebody came up with one
2:18:10Tomorrow, if Federico Vitici tomorrow emailed me
2:18:12and said, "Did you see this text editor?"
2:18:14I would absolutely buy it and download it and try it.
2:18:17And if it was better, I would throw the current app
2:18:19I'm using to the curb immediately.
2:18:21Like there's no loyalty here
2:18:22because none of them are good enough
2:18:24to have built up loyalty.
2:18:26- And I think part of the problem is Apple's shoulders
2:18:29is that I don't think Apple has well-defined enough
2:18:32just what it means to be a good iPad app.
2:18:37I really do.
2:18:38and just in a know it when I see it kind of way.
2:18:43- You know, that's one of my hopes for 2019.
2:18:46When I talk about this idea of the unified app platform
2:18:49that might be coming, I mean, part of my hope as an iPad
2:18:52user is that they are gonna do the work to define
2:18:56what apps should do on large screen devices,
2:19:00including iPads and Mac laptops,
2:19:03because right, two thirds to three quarters of the Macs
2:19:06that are sold are laptops.
2:19:07So basically, 100% of the iPads are between,
2:19:11or well, are between nine and 13 inches, right?
2:19:16In that range, if we include the smaller iPads,
2:19:20I mean, I guess other than the iPad mini,
2:19:22which is maybe coming back,
2:19:24but most iPads are in the nine to 13 space
2:19:27and all, or what, three quarters of Macs sold
2:19:31are between 12 and 15 inch displays.
2:19:34They're all kind of in the same ballpark.
2:19:37And what I'd like is for part of this unified approach
2:19:41to apps to be not stuff that just is like,
2:19:45how do we make iOS apps feel like Mac apps on the Mac?
2:19:48But also like, how do we make iPad apps feel more unified
2:19:53and functional and can iPad apps pick up some of the,
2:19:58some of the attributes of Mac apps?
2:20:02because the problems, I mean, the devices are different,
2:20:05but the problems and the screen sizes
2:20:07are not that different.
2:20:09And so I've talked to Federico about this
2:20:12and to Mike Hurley about this.
2:20:13Like, I think potentially you could get like
2:20:16better keyboard shortcut support,
2:20:18potentially like pointing device support,
2:20:20potentially something that's the iOS equivalent
2:20:23of a menu bar.
2:20:24Like, I feel like this is an opportunity for Apple
2:20:28to make iPad apps richer and more powerful
2:20:32to as a part of the process that is bringing them to the Mac,
2:20:37which is a platform that wants them to be more powerful.
2:20:40- Yeah, like I mentioned recently that like the iWork apps,
2:20:43like Numbers, Numbers is the one I use the most,
2:20:46and but Pages, they all have it,
2:20:49but there's the iPad versions have like a dot, dot, dot
2:20:52button that opens a popover and the popover is full of items.
2:20:57Some of them have sub, some menus.
2:21:00It's a menu bar.
2:21:01Like, is that the way to do it in a dot, dot, dot menu?
2:21:05I don't think so, but if it is,
2:21:07then they should say so, right?
2:21:09And encourage it. - And I think about,
2:21:10could they just do a menu bar on the iPad?
2:21:12I think the answer is probably no,
2:21:14but if not, then it's like, well, what could you do
2:21:18that gives you the kind of discoverability
2:21:21and the density of access to features
2:21:24that the Mac menu bar gives you?
2:21:25And if you can do that and it's not a menu bar
2:21:28and it's still good, then great.
2:21:31But there are, every now and then,
2:21:32'cause I use numbers on iOS a lot and on the Mac,
2:21:35and every now and then you're like,
2:21:37"Oh, I think I've reached the end.
2:21:39"I think I can't actually get to this feature on iOS."
2:21:43And there's no real good reason other than I think
2:21:45they ran out of user interface for some of their features.
2:21:49And it's like, that's not good enough.
2:21:50You should be able to get to those features on iOS.
2:21:53- Yeah, and one of the things I worry about
2:21:55is that they're, they're not just putting, figuring out how to do a menu bar on the,
2:22:02on iPad and be done with it is out of stubbornness and you know, like cause they don't want to
2:22:09do it. They don't want to do a menu bar. And you know about menu bars is that are not cool,
2:22:13right? They're text and they're just, you know, a bunch of words for the menu names
2:22:17and a bunch of words for the menu items, you know, in a list. And, but guess what? Text
2:22:23is actually very information depth rich. You know, it's there's there's a density, right?
2:22:29The information density of the Mac menu bar is tremendous. It's enormous. It is the best
2:22:34place. It's the most I think revolutionary and maybe undersold thing about the Mac interface
2:22:40when it started was the fact that every feature that was available in any given app was discoverable
2:22:44by going through the menus and that there were you could have sub menus. There was an
2:22:50incredible level of detail and while you're navigating the menus you're you
2:22:54can't get lost right the way that you get out is you just move your mouse
2:22:58away and that's it you know it's it was it was it was a very dense and it wasn't
2:23:03you couldn't get lost and you I don't know there's something like that that's
2:23:09missing yeah I agree I agree I mean part of me thinks that the the solution is to
2:23:14to do something that's very much like the menu bar. But I hope, again, in my kind of optimism
2:23:21about this, that at Apple, they've had this discussion of how do we do something that can
2:23:24float all of those kind of features out there somewhere in a way that makes sense on touch
2:23:31interfaces and makes sense on Mac, you know, traditional pointing device driven interfaces.
2:23:38I also sometimes toy with the idea that what they're going to end up doing is saying,
2:23:41"Hey, now that we've built iOS apps
2:23:44that also have menu bars,
2:23:45if you plug in a mouse to your iPad,
2:23:47we'll just show you the menu bar
2:23:49and you can just use this."
2:23:51Like, "Hmm, okay, that would be weird."
2:23:53And I think it's probably the wrong decision, right?
2:23:55To revisit the Mac interface convention on a new device.
2:23:59But, you know, again, they need to,
2:24:02that means they need to invent something
2:24:03that's more appropriate
2:24:04that still has that density and power.
2:24:07- I'll give you another example is Photos.
2:24:09So Photos for Mac came out a couple years ago and replaced iPhoto in a weird way, in
2:24:20a way that Apple often doesn't do, which is, in rare cases, Apple will keep an old
2:24:25app around and introduce the new one.
2:24:28You could still run iPhoto right now.
2:24:30There probably are people still using iPhoto because it's too different and the paradigm
2:24:35is too different, etc., etc.
2:24:38So they stopped updating iPhoto, but--
2:24:42or is it iPhotos?
2:24:43I don't even remember anymore.
2:24:44iPhoto.
2:24:45iPhoto.
2:24:45Two photos, yes.
2:24:46And then there's Photos for Mac, which shares the--
2:24:49and the very best feature of it.
2:24:51And in my personal experience as a thorough user of the iCloud
2:24:55photo system, it is, to me, a rock--
2:25:00has been for a couple of years now,
2:25:01and very rock solid photo syncing system
2:25:04that is both reliable and works fast.
2:25:08And so my photos are everywhere on all my devices.
2:25:10Photos for Mac is sort of an iOS-ish looking app,
2:25:18but it's not like the marzipan apps.
2:25:20And I believe, if I'm remembering correctly,
2:25:22people who dug within it, you know,
2:25:24like Steven Trout and Smith style,
2:25:26found something called UXKit,
2:25:28which some people thought might be,
2:25:30that might be the holy grail
2:25:31that you and I were speculating about an hour ago,
2:25:34that UXKit could be the UIKit for the Mac.
2:25:36it I think it turns out either it was and they decided to just leave it with photos or it was just something the photos team
2:25:43Made to get that, you know, it was and they just right pick that name
2:25:47Like nothing further has come of that there have been no further apps that art on the Mac what photos is for the Mac
2:25:55But there's also and I have gripes about some of the iOS ishness of photos on Mac, but none of them to the
2:26:03To the level of outrage and and I cannot you know
2:26:07WTF that the marzipan stuff is filed under there's something different there
2:26:11But one aspect I put like that some ways the familiarity is nice
2:26:15right like and and the one that hit me just recently because I've been trying to I
2:26:19For a bunch of reasons. I've been using my iPad Pro a lot recently and just visually it is helpful for me
2:26:26Like at the current place where my vision is between the two eyes
2:26:29It is really helpful for me to have a screen very close to my face
2:26:33And guess which big screen is the easiest to get close to my face? It's the iPad. It is really easy it is a
2:26:41really almost
2:26:44Eyewatering accessibility advantage to be able to sit comfortably and read a nice big screen very close to my face
2:26:51And I went to edit some photos and I wanted to make some adjustments beyond the very basic ones
2:26:57And I was like what the hell where'd they move these to?
2:27:01Where's like this those things that you strapped and then I realized they're only on the Mac version
2:27:05you know what I mean you go into edit mode on the Mac and
2:27:08There's more than just filters you can apply there's like
2:27:12individual things you can pop open with disclosure triangles to tie in another topic from a
2:27:17Conversation earlier in the show with detailed things specifically like if you just want to adjust
2:27:22The brightness or the contrast or something like that or the exposure level
2:27:26There's a whole bunch of features
2:27:27I did that are only on the Mac version. And I was like, well, that's crazy because isn't
2:27:31the iPad the one that's supposed to be getting all the attention? Anyway, that just drove
2:27:36me nuts. And I'm sure Apple, they know about it. But it was crazy to me because I really
2:27:40spent like two minutes looking for how to do it on the iPad before I remembered that
2:27:44you can't because I, the iPad seems like it should be able to do everything the Mac version
2:27:48does in that regard.
2:27:49Oh, I you know, I agree that's with with photos since I wrote a book about it for take control.
2:27:57And so I compare and contrast the iOS version and the Mac version and it's fascinating all
2:28:02the ways that they don't sync up and you know, I I can complain about the Mac version not
2:28:06having the new search feature that they added to iOS. It drives me crazy because it's such
2:28:10a it's such a useful thing and you know, you can't you can't search for show me all the
2:28:14photos with snow and dogs like you can't but you can do that on iOS. But iOS is lacking
2:28:21all sorts of editing features that are in the Mac version and on my iPad like why are
2:28:26those not there? There's no I don't understand why I can't do all the same editing things
2:28:31that I can do on my Mac on my iPad and and there's no good reason for it which is it's
2:28:36funny that that also means my standards have changed where it used to be kind of like well
2:28:39I understand it this is kind of the light version of that and I'm I have left that era
2:28:44behind. I'm like, Why is this not here? The Apple rolls out this new iPad and says it's
2:28:48faster than most of the laptops that are sold now and more powerful. It's like, All right,
2:28:52well, then why can't I edit my photos in the same way on this thing? Yeah, it's really
2:28:56comes down to screen size, right? Like I totally get it with the iPhone, you know, like even
2:29:01with the you know, what's the supersized excess Max, you know, get the iPhone XS Max. It's
2:29:06still it's you know, it's a tiny screen. I get it. Maybe there's some advanced editing
2:29:10controls that you just don't want to figure out how to scram them on the screen. But there's,
2:29:15you know, the iPad 11 and 13 inch screens are plenty big enough for it.
2:29:19Yeah, I mean, I use my MacBook Air as an 11. This iPad's got a way bigger screen than that.
2:29:25There's plenty of room. I have that book. I have take control of photos
2:29:33for Mac. I saw my Christmas reading list because I will tell you I'm coming at it as somebody
2:29:39who I know the Mac version pretty thoroughly and like I have no idea about like searching
2:29:44on the iOS version. Like I think I'm I hope I'm in for a pleasant surprise on the degree to which
2:29:49Apple photos are actually searchable because I'm I'm coming. I mean on iOS they don't let you do
2:29:55like smart albums and stuff but you can you can stack up these queries in ways that I mean the
2:30:00example I give in the book is that I said search for dogs and it's got like 800 pictures of dogs
2:30:05yeah but I'm looking for this picture of the time that we took my dog up to the mountains and she
2:30:08was like the only time she was in the snow. And so then on iOS, you search for dogs and
2:30:13you're like, all right, dogs. And then you just type snow and then tap on the, on the
2:30:17snow. And then it's like, here's two pictures. There they are. Those are the two pictures
2:30:21of dogs and snow. And it is the picture I wanted of my dog in the snow. And it's like,
2:30:25yes, that is how this is supposed to work.
2:30:28Trenton Larkin Um, briefly, quick hits before we talk about
2:30:32your keyboard. Uh, I think that that searching stuff, it ties into one last thing I definitely
2:30:37to mention on the show with you is the thing I linked to. Well, two bits of news that I
2:30:42thought were curiously came out the same morning this week was Apple's promotion of John,
2:30:47John, and Drea to a senior vice president level. I can't help but think because he's only been
2:30:54there since summer and he came from Google where he headed up summer. I was actually
2:30:58surprised when they hired him that he didn't start with a senior vice president title.
2:31:01And I just wonder if maybe it's policy now that some new hires even at that level,
2:31:07let's see how this works out, right? Let's see if you're a fit. Like I can't help but think that
2:31:12that was the plan all along. It's like, okay, you're gonna leave Google, you're gonna join us,
2:31:16here's a big pile of money. Let's see how this works. And it's worked apparently well. And now
2:31:22he's promoted to senior vice president level. Because his job's the same. He started as the
2:31:27head of AI and machine learning. And the other bit of news was Loop Ventures. That's Gene Munster's
2:31:34outfit runs. To me, I don't know. I mean, maybe, I don't know how rigorous it is,
2:31:39but it sounds to me pretty interesting. They've run, they've two years in a row, they've
2:31:43run these battery of 800 tests comparing Googles and Amazons and Apples speakers and what they
2:31:50can do and what type of questions they can do. And the really interesting thing to me
2:31:54is probably is a surprise to know when Google Assistant was still the most capable. And
2:32:01and they all improved over the last year. But Siri improved by far the most like, well,
2:32:07you know, like Google assistant got like 7% more questions, right? Siri improved 22% and
2:32:13series wasn't even 12 months. It was nine months because the home pod didn't ship until
2:32:17nine months ago. Right. And basically my theory, and I really think it's true, is I think Siri
2:32:25is getting a lot better in every way. Understanding you, capabilities, and I think it's catching
2:32:33up to Google. I don't think that, I don't think John, Gian, and Dre would have taken
2:32:37the job if their goal was any less than to catch or exceed Google in these areas. You
2:32:43know, I really think it's that serious. But I think Apple has a huge perception problem.
2:32:48I call it a boy who cries wolf problem where I think a lot of people hear the word Siri
2:32:54and they think, ah, that doesn't work. And that's it. And they filed it under and it's,
2:32:59it's the way that like first impressions can last a lifetime. Like people filed Siri under
2:33:03a thing that doesn't work and I shouldn't bother trying.
2:33:06I think you're right. I think a lot of people, um, you know, once you're burned, you just,
2:33:15just walk away and it's hard to get people to reengage and to give it another try. And
2:33:20So with Siri, you know, I almost think that what they need to do, and this is what they
2:33:25should have been doing all along, is keep improving it in the background.
2:33:29And then you'll have a release or a new feature or something that you make available that
2:33:34lets you have say, "Hey, we added a bunch of new things to Siri and it's way better
2:33:39than it used to be.
2:33:40Give it another try."
2:33:42But they're going to need a marketing moment where they try to convince people to give
2:33:45it another try.
2:33:47In the background, it needs to have gotten a lot better in the meantime.
2:33:49so that they can actually,
2:33:51they actually have something that's better
2:33:53to tell people to try.
2:33:55- I think it is evident just from the Loop Ventures thing
2:33:58that they are in fact doing that
2:33:59and rolling out iterative updates.
2:34:02But it also meshes with my personal experience
2:34:05using these things, that it is getting better,
2:34:08not just with OS updates or with features
2:34:10that are get announced once a year at WWDC,
2:34:13but that it is Google style just under continuous improvement
2:34:18and when something, an improvement is deemed ready to ship,
2:34:21it is rolled out on their backend.
2:34:23- Yeah, that's the right way to do it, right?
2:34:26It's cloud features.
2:34:28But then at some point, perhaps there's a marketing feature
2:34:30that they hold off on and announce somewhere
2:34:33and use it as a way to ask people to give it a new try,
2:34:38give it another go, because they know it's got a reputation.
2:34:41They're not dumb.
2:34:42They're aware of Siri's reputation.
2:34:44- Yeah, I think you're right,
2:34:45that they've got to hold off on some kind
2:34:47new integration with the thing. I don't know what it would be, but so that they can say
2:34:51it or maybe, you know, maybe it's, you know, maybe it's a little, you know, good old fashioned
2:34:55advertising campaign, right? Right. Could be, you know, just throw money at it and do
2:35:01make clever commercials and get them everywhere and you know, try to make it a thing. But
2:35:06I don't know, something has to be done. In addition to just making it better, something
2:35:10has to be done perception wise because the better the getting better isn't enough because
2:35:14people won't notice if they don't try it. And it's like you and you don't accidentally
2:35:19try it, right? I mean, you could actually people only know that they remember the failures
2:35:24too. That's the other part of it. So absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah, the time that you asked
2:35:29to go to the pizza place you go to all the time and it gave you directions to North Carolina.
2:35:37I got direction I went to we went Christmas tree shopping a couple weeks ago and forget
2:35:43the name of the place, Linvola Farms or something. It's suburban Philadelphia. And I asked Siri
2:35:50for directions because we go once a year and the roads sometimes change and you want to
2:35:55get the traffic. So I kind of know how to get there anyway. And I know that you get
2:36:00there by starting going south on I-95 out of the city. And that was the directions I
2:36:04was following. And then we kept going and then we wound up across the state line into Delaware.
2:36:11And we got to the welcome to Delaware sign.
2:36:15And I was like, you know,
2:36:15I kind of thought we missed the exit.
2:36:17And then we checked and we were going to some place
2:36:19with a similar name in North Carolina.
2:36:21(laughs)
2:36:23- Yeah, that one still gets me.
2:36:25And that's, you know,
2:36:26'cause maps is the same story as Siri,
2:36:27where you remember the failures
2:36:29and they need to keep getting better
2:36:30and try to find ways to get people to try it again.
2:36:33And that's the maps failure that comes up a lot
2:36:36that I still can't believe that they haven't fixed,
2:36:37which is if it knows your location and you do a search, you'd be really aggressive that
2:36:43they're trying to find something near you. Please pick the thing that's sort of like
2:36:47this in Pennsylvania and not the thing that is like it, but in North Carolina, because
2:36:53I'm probably not asking about North Carolina.
2:36:55Yeah. And, and, and it, the way that these things fall short in so many ways and I, I
2:37:00think we'll get there faster than when we all think. I think it's that old, that a whole
2:37:05Bill Gates thing, and maybe he didn't originate the line, but that technology progresses way
2:37:12more slowly year after year than we ever think and way faster every 10 years than we think.
2:37:17You know, that you look at it year over year and it never seems like we're getting anywhere
2:37:20and you look back 10 years and you're like, holy crap, that was crude. I think, you know,
2:37:25we'll have that sort of moment with this stuff. But like if you got in an Uber or a lift and
2:37:30said to the driver, take me to a Christmas tree farm in North Carolina and you live in
2:37:34Philadelphia, they're going to double check before they take off, right? You can have
2:37:40that conversation very quickly. That conversation doesn't happen when you talk to Apple Maps,
2:37:49right? There is no double checking of the ridiculous, "Are you sure you want to drive
2:37:53cross country as opposed to driving 22 minutes out of the city?" It makes me want to get
2:38:00and Uber and see what they would say if I tried to go to North Carolina. All right,
2:38:05what's your current keyboard, Jason?
2:38:07Jason Buehler, Jr. I am using a Vortex Race 3, which is a, I think, what they call a 75%
2:38:12keyboard. It's mechanical keys. I use the Cherry Brown switches because I like those.
2:38:17But it's small. It's got no keypad. It does have a function key row, and it has dedicated
2:38:22arrow keys. When we talk about these keyboards, you and I, people send links to things that
2:38:26don't have arrow keys. And it's like, yeah, you can hold down the function key and move
2:38:29around with the things that are arrow keys.
2:38:31And it's like, no, I'm not interested in that.
2:38:33I want arrow keys.
2:38:34I've spent my entire life with arrow keys.
2:38:37I want dedicated keys to move around my cursor around
2:38:40on the screen.
2:38:41And it's pretty nice.
2:38:42It's just a USB keyboard,
2:38:44but having that extra function row is nice
2:38:47just for controlling media brightness, stuff like that.
2:38:52And it comes with Mac key caps,
2:38:55which often these keyboards don't.
2:38:58and you know it's programmable so you can put it into Mac mode and then at that point it's just a
2:39:03Mac keyboard and not a you know Windows keyboard with weird keys that you have to pretend are
2:39:08different keys or whatever it that was a nice feature of it and so that's why I'm using now.
2:39:12My weakness on the keyboard front is on the wireless front is I'm more likely to buy a bunch
2:39:20of—and in fact have recently bought a bunch of Bluetooth keyboards before settling on
2:39:27Apple's Magic Keyboard, which I can't believe I didn't try first. Because I had
2:39:33the old Magic Keyboard, the one that took batteries, and I didn't realize how much
2:39:36better the new one is that charges by lightning.
2:39:39So you had the whatever it was called. It wasn't the Magic Keyboard. It was like the—
2:39:43No, I think it was called a Magic Keyboard, but I don't know.
2:39:47I don't think so. I think it was just the Bluetooth keyboard, and that's the one with
2:39:50AA batteries going that little cylinder on the back.
2:39:53A cylinder that honestly looked like it was meant to hold AA batteries.
2:39:56That's exactly right. And then the Magic Keyboard has just the lightning charger. And no, it's
2:40:01really good. And you can get, Studio Neat makes a thing. And then there's another one
2:40:06that Federico.
2:40:07The Canopy. Studio Neat is called the Canopy and it is lovely.
2:40:11And Federico found one that's very much like the old origami workstation thing, which has
2:40:15got like a magnetic fold and all that and the idea there is with either of those you've got a little
2:40:20keyboard holder that is also a stand for an iPad. Yes, exactly. I have to look up Federico's.
2:40:25On the actual plug-in mechanical keyboard front, I'm so loyal to the Apple keyboard too that I'm a
2:40:32little less likely to do what I'm always tempted to do after you're on the show and just buy what
2:40:39what you said you're using. Although I did buy your Matthias, but that's a wireless one.
2:40:46I did buy the Matthias one. Yeah, well, Matthias is the one that's supposed to be the most
2:40:49like the old switches on the... Yeah, I don't agree with it. Yeah, I don't agree with it.
2:40:56Yeah, I don't like them as much as I like the Cherry Brown switches because I got one
2:41:00of those testers that you and I discovered a couple times ago when I was on. But, you
2:41:06know, I have used the Matias with my iPad a lot, like in the kitchen, although now with
2:41:12the iPad, the new iPad Pro, I've been taking, it can power more external USB keyboards than
2:41:18the old one could. The old one was kind of touchy, but now it can power most of these
2:41:22keyboards that I've got. So I've been sort of like just dragging out other mechanical
2:41:25keyboards and using them too.
2:41:27Is the keyboard, are there options for colors or is the one that you show me, like that's
2:41:32the that is it because it's a very it's colorful in the corners it's almost like Lego like
2:41:37a Lego like primary palette so it comes with all just shades of gray and then it's got
2:41:43highlight key colored versions that also come with it that you can put on so by default
2:41:50you can have it be just completely it's like a light gray and a dark gray and that's it
2:41:53and it's standard key caps you could replace them with other key caps if you wanted to
2:41:57But so I've got the I actually put my key. My keys are yellow. My my arrow keys. Yeah,
2:42:04that's what I see in the image you sent me. This is a problem for me because there's I have a
2:42:08couple of pet peeves with keyboards. A I need arrow keys have to have them. I have to have
2:42:14Mac command keys or blank or something, but I can't have a Windows key. I just it offends me
2:42:22and I don't want it. Oh yeah, it's the worst. So I agree. I want Mac style, you know, and it could
2:42:28be, you know, in theory it could say like control instead of, you know, or have the symbols instead
2:42:36of the names, you know. Well, I was impressed that the Vortex Race actually has the Mac keys in the
2:42:40box, so you just lift off the windows and whatever the alt key is and you put on the option and the
2:42:48command and so I like that because most of them do not do that they just don't
2:42:53care about that. This one ticks all of the boxes. Alright, here's another one for me
2:42:58really personal. I cannot cannot buy a keyboard that has Arial as the typeface
2:43:05for the key caps and this one uses Helvetica. Damn it, Jason. It looks good too
2:43:11it's got the um they're big in the center of the keys which is kind of old
2:43:15school typewriter a little bit and I like that about it. You know, these aren't for
2:43:20everybody. I don't know, did you ever figure out what kind of Cherry switches style you
2:43:25liked the best? No, but I think Cherry Brown. I think I'm with Brown too. That's the one
2:43:30that has worked for me. I don't know, I don't want to cost you 130 bucks, but I do like
2:43:36it. I gotta tell you, I know we've been running forever, but it's a short show. I got one
2:43:42story to tell you. I reviewed this Bluetooth mechanical keyboard that they
2:43:46read all the articles I wrote about this stuff and they're like, "Oh, you got to try
2:43:48this out. It's Bluetooth. It'll work on the Mac. It's got backlighting. It's all
2:43:52this stuff." And it's this crazy keyboard. It has backlighting
2:43:55effects where you touch a key and lights ripple out from the key.
2:43:58It's not good, but it's amazing. And I had this moment where I realized I had an
2:44:05inviolable keyboard rule that I didn't know I had, which is they have a... the
2:44:11shift key is on the far side of the arrow keys on the right side so if you
2:44:17want to press shift you have to go past the up arrow oh that's that would not
2:44:21work I started I started typing I was like oh no I can't use this keyboard and
2:44:25I put it away it's like I can't I can't even do it so there's weird keyboard
2:44:29layouts do not work for me I actually bought for this vortex I just bought
2:44:32these things that are they're like they're almost like covers for key
2:44:37switches and they basically block off a key switch. I think they're called, what are they called,
2:44:42switch blockers. Because the only problem I have, my real complaint with the Vortex 3 is that
2:44:48I don't, it's like on new Apple laptops, I have a hard time orienting my hands without looking.
2:44:56- Yes. - Because it's just a grid of keys. And so the right, above the right arrow key on this
2:45:04keyboard is a lot of keys that I never really use, you know, home, end, page up, page down.
2:45:09And I realize what I'm going to do now that I found these things, these switch blockers,
2:45:12is I'm going to take a couple of those keys off and block them. At which point I have
2:45:19a blank space in the keyboard that my fingers can feel and orient properly. So that I'm
2:45:24excited that I knew those must exist somewhere and I finally found them. So I'm going to
2:45:29give that a try and see if that solves. That's the only complaint is that every now and then
2:45:32and I find myself having shifted over a key
2:45:35and everything comes out nonsense
2:45:37and then I'm curse and move and then I get back to it.
2:45:40And I wanna stop that.
2:45:42- What does the PN key do?
2:45:44- That's well, so this is a programmable keyboard.
2:45:48So you hold down PN and you can do stuff.
2:45:50That's how you switch between the Mac mode
2:45:52and the windows mode.
2:45:53And for people who are programmers,
2:45:55I think my understanding is you basically can program
2:45:59multiple keystrokes into a single key
2:46:03using the programming system for the keyboard.
2:46:06But all I did was do what,
2:46:08I looked in the manual and press the button
2:46:10that makes it a Mac keyboard.
2:46:11And then I'm gonna lock that key out too, quite frankly,
2:46:14'cause I don't need to press that
2:46:15and accidentally send my keyboard
2:46:17into some weird key layer thing.
2:46:19But apparently that's a, for some people,
2:46:21that's a real big thing is the programmable keyboards
2:46:24where you've got to fire off a whole bunch of keystrokes
2:46:27in a sequence and you can actually just program them in
2:46:29and then you press one key and it's like a macro.
2:46:32It's like keyboard maestro in hardware.
2:46:35- Hardware, gotcha.
2:46:36- But I don't need that 'cause I got keyboard maestro.
2:46:38- Exactly, I was gonna say that you beat me to the punch.
2:46:42One thing I don't like about the mechanical keyboard world
2:46:45and I like about this one is that this one,
2:46:46it's like you pick your switches and it gives you the keys
2:46:50and you just get a box with everything in it.
2:46:51And then if you wanna pop some keys off
2:46:53and put other ones on, they're all there already
2:46:55and you're done.
2:46:56- Exactly.
2:46:57- There's a lot too many of these that are shipping
2:46:59as like kits that you have to kind of do the assembly on
2:47:03more than just popping keyboards on that.
2:47:05It's like-
2:47:06- Well, there's a whole keyboard kit culture,
2:47:09which is great if you're into that sort of thing.
2:47:11But if you're somebody who just wants a neat keyboard,
2:47:14like, "This is a cool keyboard, I want this."
2:47:16It's like, I don't wanna solder anything.
2:47:18I don't wanna build my own keys.
2:47:21I don't wanna have to choose a particular layout.
2:47:23I just kind of wanna get the keyboard and use it.
2:47:25- Yeah, 'cause I, you know, I've been,
2:47:27I don't wanna spoil any Christmas,
2:47:30but somebody in the household has been very serious
2:47:33about asking for a gaming PC for a long time.
2:47:37- Ah. - And it's been determined
2:47:38that they should get it.
2:47:40And I don't know shit about buying a gaming PC.
2:47:42And I heard people, and I brought this up
2:47:44a few episodes ago, and people wrote and said,
2:47:46you should build them together,
2:47:48that this is, you know, father-son bonding experience.
2:47:50And I know your colleague and everybody's mutual friend
2:47:55on the internet, Mike Hurley has gone through this.
2:47:57- He did this, yeah.
2:47:58I think the bonding is really that Jonas will hear
2:48:03swear words come out of your mouth
2:48:05that maybe he's never heard before.
2:48:08- Well, but I don't know anything about gaming PCs.
2:48:11Or I didn't, now I do because me and John Siracusa
2:48:16got me started and then I figured it all out.
2:48:19But the thing I figured out with an enormous amount
2:48:24of research. Like when I started like ball parking what my time is worth and what I thought
2:48:29I was spending on this PC and how much time I had put into it, I was like, Oh Christ,
2:48:35I, I, I mean, we're almost break even and I didn't buy the damn thing yet. I mean, like,
2:48:40yeah, you should have just paid somebody who was good to have a pre-built one that you
2:48:44just got. This is what we did. Well, what I figured out and maybe I'm wrong cause I'm
2:48:48I'm not in this world.
2:48:49But what I figured out is that they're all
2:48:54build your own PCs.
2:48:56It's just a question of whether you're
2:48:57the one screwing it all together or whether somebody else,
2:49:01you order it and then they mail it to you already
2:49:03put together.
2:49:04And a lot of this stuff you can figure out.
2:49:09I just didn't know what is a good Nvidia graphics
2:49:13card for 2018.
2:49:16But you just pick a CPU.
2:49:17you pick a GPU, you pick a motherboard,
2:49:20you pick what type of RAM,
2:49:22and then you have some kind of case and a cooling system.
2:49:25And it's all stuff, you know what RAM is,
2:49:28and you know what the difference in eight and 16 gigs of RAM,
2:49:30and certainly know what SSD is.
2:49:33But when you buy a pre-built one from a reputable company,
2:49:39you're making all the exact same decisions,
2:49:41and the part names are exactly the same.
2:49:43They just come all together,
2:49:45and I'm hoping are guaranteed to work all together.
2:49:49So I'm not putting you down if you enjoy doing it yourself
2:49:53and maybe you can save some money,
2:49:55but I read some reviews and the reviewers,
2:49:58like at PC Mags clearly know,
2:50:00would emphasize that, okay, this is billed as expensive,
2:50:06but if you look at the components,
2:50:07it's actually not much of a,
2:50:09it's because the components are expensive.
2:50:10This one, you buy this thing from this company
2:50:13and sure that's expensive,
2:50:14But it's, you know, priced out the individual components
2:50:18and it's actually, you know, you're getting a lot of work,
2:50:21assembly work for a very low price.
2:50:24So that's the route I went.
2:50:25But the other thing that really cracked me up,
2:50:27really cracked me up, and it just shows I am further drifted
2:50:32into the Apple world over the decades.
2:50:36What these people consider expensive is not expensive.
2:50:43It is like, oh my god, that's not--
2:50:45I kept reading these things, and they'd say,
2:50:47such and such is expensive.
2:50:49And then I'd look at the prices for it,
2:50:51and it would be like SSD.
2:50:54And they'd be like, whoa, it's pricey.
2:50:55And it's like, well, that's a lot less
2:50:57than I'm used to paying for a 256 to 512 upgrade on the SSD.
2:51:04So the advantage of being ingrained in the Apple ecosystem
2:51:08is you step over to the other side,
2:51:10and it's like you're going to some country where
2:51:13The dollar, you know, $100 can get you into a five-star hotel.
2:51:18It's like, this is not expensive.
2:51:22But the other crazy thing about the PC world,
2:51:23I didn't know if you knew this,
2:51:24I'm sure everybody who's listening to this show
2:51:26is gonna think I'm ridiculously out of touch
2:51:28for not really being in tune to this,
2:51:30but in the gaming PC world, everything has LED lights.
2:51:34Everything.
2:51:36- Right.
2:51:37- Your mouse has lights, your keyboard has lights.
2:51:40- It's like that keyboard that I tried,
2:51:42which I think that's why it has those lights is because it comes from the from gaming background and it's like
2:51:47You can have them do random patterns that have nothing to do with anything
2:51:51You can have them like it like eight different programmable ways that your keys can dance in front of you as you type
2:51:58I'm I'm not making this up Jason the displays have lights
2:52:02Like not the display but like the back of the display has lights that can shine onto the wall
2:52:08Oh, yeah, then - yeah totally so it's like that Phillips thing
2:52:13You know like Phillips had a thing for the TVs where they could shine a light on the wall
2:52:16I'm like the dominant color of the what was on the TV and broadcast that onto your wall
2:52:21So it was more immersive right and I'm laughing and you know I here I am
2:52:26someone who enjoys vacationing in Las Vegas, but it you know, so I'm not a
2:52:30immune to the charms of
2:52:34brightly colored flashy lights
2:52:36It just seems like the craziest thing in the world that it's it is absolutely 100%
2:52:41That's just assumed that your gaming PC will have a ridiculous sort of Vegas
2:52:47strip sky
2:52:50You know, it's gonna look like the sign to a motel two blocks off the Vegas strip. Yeah, right
2:52:57Including the words I the keyboard thing kills me
2:53:01I mean, how could you look at that?
2:53:02And of course you can always turn it off, I guess,
2:53:04but well, it seems crazy.
2:53:06- Yep.
2:53:09- So you've avoided the whole gaming PC thing?
2:53:13- I have, and my son is a gamer,
2:53:18and I think would love one.
2:53:20And I think even he knows that it's maybe a bridge too far.
2:53:23I've offered to let him, I have bootcamp on my iMac Pro,
2:53:26which is a pretty good, you know, graphics wise,
2:53:28pretty good.
2:53:29He could just come out here and play PC games.
2:53:31I think the fact is that he is mostly satisfied
2:53:33at this point with console games and iPad games.
2:53:37But I have thought about it.
2:53:38It's actually one of the things that frustrates me
2:53:40about the Apple's current lineup is,
2:53:41I kind of want to buy him a new Mac
2:53:43'cause he's got a very old MacBook Air.
2:53:46But I want to get him one that's got decent enough power
2:53:48and graphics that I could put bootcamp on it
2:53:50and let him play PC games on that.
2:53:52And right now that would be like the MacBook escape,
2:53:56I guess, which is old and it hasn't been updated.
2:53:59- Yeah, it's not a good purchase.
2:54:00- So I'm just sort of sitting it out,
2:54:01'cause that's what I thought I might do,
2:54:03is get him a Mac that could play PC games too.
2:54:06- It's especially a tough sell
2:54:08if you're going to be taxing it, right?
2:54:09Like the year and a half old MacBook escape
2:54:12is a really tough sell.
2:54:13It might be perfect for some people right now,
2:54:16but for somebody who's going to be taxing the graphics of it
2:54:18it's a really hard sell.
2:54:20- Yeah, exactly. - It was a very good one.
2:54:22- Exactly, so I do fear that moment where he comes to me
2:54:24and says, "It's time for me to get a gaming PC,"
2:54:27'cause I really would rather not go through that,
2:54:30but it might happen.
2:54:32- It's an eye-opener.
2:54:34Anything else you wanted to talk about?
2:54:40- Oh, I think we've done all that two human beings can do
2:54:45in three hours and seven minutes.
2:54:46- Yeah.
2:54:47It does seem like graphics cards,
2:54:49but it does seem like the connector story
2:54:51has straightened out on the PC side.
2:54:52It seems like everything is a DisplayPort and power.
2:54:56That's good. That's good. And USB, you know, I don't know, but we'll see how this goes.
2:55:03I'm surprised, Jon. I mean, having a PC in your house is a big step just on its own.
2:55:09Like Jon, you mentioned Jon Siracusa, like he won't have an Xbox in his house because
2:55:13it's like it's Microsoft. He's not going to allow it.
2:55:15Yeah, see, I don't have that. I don't have any kind of religious aversion to having a
2:55:19PC in my house. I've never been that type of, you know, I used to have an Xbox. It never
2:55:25bothered me because it wasn't, you know, it had nothing to do with why I used a Mac.
2:55:29Yeah. We have an Xbox. It's fine. Yeah. I always liked it. I actually liked it a lot.
2:55:33That's not the issue. To me, it's I don't know what to do. Like, I'm not, it's, you know,
2:55:44I have no idea how Windows 10 works. I don't know. I mean, is it going to be self-explanatory? I don't
2:55:51know. My son doesn't use it either, and he seems to think he'll just pick it up, and I'm hoping
2:55:55hoping you will because but I don't know. It confuses the heck out of me because I learned
2:56:01how to use I can get around an XP right but doesn't help doesn't help anymore with now
2:56:06because my boot camp now is Windows 10 it's like I have no idea what's going on there
2:56:10yeah I haven't had boot camp I've never even installed boot camp I haven't had Windows
2:56:14installed on I think the last time I ran Windows on a Mac it was a virtual PC I wasn't even
2:56:22like "Parallel." It was like back in the Power PC era. Yeah, I think it was in the Power
2:56:27PC era when—and it was so slow because—
2:56:30Jon Streeter Like soft Windows or virtual PC, yeah.
2:56:32Dave Asprey Yeah, I think it was—I was a virtual PC
2:56:33fan for some reason, and it was important for me to—just for testing in PC browsers
2:56:40because I was doing web development work. And, you know, however slow it was, if it
2:56:45rendered correctly, you could just assume it would be fast enough and somebody else
2:56:48or do final testing to make sure it wasn't actually slow, you know. But rendering issues
2:56:52were just the whole thing and I could use it for that. But that, I mean, we're talking like
2:56:551997 or something like that. Yeah. Yeah. PCs have advanced since then. Yeah, I'm sure they have,
2:57:01but it's, I'm not so sure they've advanced in that they've, that Windows has gotten better. It's just,
2:57:06I'm just lost. I don't know. But it's quite a, quite an eye-opener buying these things.
2:57:13And I do see, you know, conversely, I see the, I didn't doubt it, but I do see the problem some
2:57:18people have with perceiving Apple's equivalence as being expensive. Although I will say this,
2:57:23here's another thing now. So most of the stuff like going from 256 gigs of SSD storage to 512,
2:57:31you you pay Apple more than you pay most of these companies, you know, and you can buy components
2:57:35that are of course, you know, people who want to build out a $7,000 gaming PC or more, I'm sure.
2:57:40and you can buy the world. There's all sorts of ways that you can certainly put yourself
2:57:45well up into the stratosphere of Apple pricing on the PC side. But as far as I can see, there is no
2:57:54equivalent of the Apple's 5K Retina iMac display for a PC for the prices that you assume the
2:58:02display is worth in the iMac. And gaming stresses it in different ways. And what makes the iMac
2:58:145K monitor great for the stuff that Mac users use it for, it may not be suitable for gaming
2:58:19at all. But 4K gaming is a real stretch right now, as far as I can see, within relatively
2:58:27reasonable budgets and there's very few displays out there. Whereas I've had a 5K display on
2:58:33my desk at a reasonable price for I don't know how many years now, right? I don't know.
2:58:39So that's one area where Apple is still, you know, when they pick and choose their places,
2:58:44they're incredibly advanced and capable. And I remember that all that crazy stuff they
2:58:48did where they had like tool to the way they got the 5K iMac to work is it really had like
2:58:54two Thunderbolt things speaking and doing half the screen and they just made it so you
2:58:58couldn't tell. Anyway, it's a bad world out there. I don't count yourself lucky. Anyway,
2:59:05Jason Snell, thank you so much for coming back. Always a pleasure. Have a good holiday
2:59:11season. Everybody can read your work. You can find all of your work at six colors.com.
2:59:18I always like to know you can spell colors however you feel it should be spelled. On
2:59:23Twitter at J Snell and for your podcast listening enjoyment. Jason has about 30 different podcasts
2:59:34including oh, I should definitely mention the episode of the incomparable that we did
2:59:41where we talked about 2001 a Space Odyssey. I linked to it a few years ago, but and other
2:59:47people who have been mentioned on this show were there as well. John Siracusa, Dr. Drang,
2:59:52who is delightful and probably needs to have a podcast.
2:59:56But I thought that came out so well.
2:59:58I don't know.
2:59:59I was really worried 'cause it's a very difficult film
3:00:00to talk about.
3:00:01And I thought that was really interesting.
3:00:03- Yeah, I was glad you could be on
3:00:06and it was fun to talk about.
3:00:07That's one of those movies that you could,
3:00:08I mean, you could literally talk about it for days
3:00:11and not scratch the surface of it.
3:00:14But I felt like within the context of a 90 minute,
3:00:17two hour or whatever podcast,
3:00:18we covered a lot of the highlights
3:00:20and it was fun to have that conversation.
3:00:22So thanks for being on.
3:00:23- Yeah.
3:00:24What other podcasts?
3:00:25- The one maybe of most interest to talk show listeners
3:00:30is Upgrade that I do with Mike Hurley every Monday.
3:00:33And I do with some other stuff over at Relay.
3:00:34So Relay FM for that and the incomparable.com
3:00:37for the incomparable stuff.
3:00:38And I post most of those highlights at Six Colors anyway.
3:00:42- Yeah, so just go to Six Colors and you'll find it all.
3:00:45Anyway, have a great holiday season.
3:00:46Best to you and the family.