Podcast Search

The Talk Show

231: ‘It’s a Deep Notch’ With Dan Frommer

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Did I tell you that I figured out what the heck that was?

0:00:02I don't think so. No. So the backstory on this is that Dan and I were in the Steve Jobs theater

0:00:09together sort of towards the back, maybe like five or six rows from the back. And during the event,

0:00:14especially the first half, there was a lot of noise from seemingly like, like, I couldn't quite make

0:00:20it out. But I thought it was like Asian language, sort of like speakerphone noise. And I thought

0:00:27someone was on the phone and I thought so too. I completely thought it was somebody who was on the

0:00:33phone like with you know like like like Chinese media and they were on the phone with somebody

0:00:39at their office back in in China like to let them listen to the keynote live and I'm like dude

0:00:44they're streaming it like you don't have to you don't have to let them listen in on speaker phone

0:00:50you know and why are they talking um and it was a bit distracting and it was also kind of baffling

0:00:56because I would like turn around to see who it was to maybe shoot them a dirty look and

0:01:01and it it was like it seemed to like be moving around the theater like at first I thought

0:01:06it was over my shoulder to the left and it seemed to be coming from over my shoulder

0:01:08to the right anyway long story short what it is what it was is that Apple provides non

0:01:16I don't know how many languages they support but if English is not your first language

0:01:20they they give media like a little earpiece and they can get a live translation from somebody

0:01:26you know, that Apple hires to translate it on the fly. And which is cool. But what happened was

0:01:33they had them turned up way too loud. And I guess there's no volume on the actual thing that goes in

0:01:38your ear. It's like Apple was controlling it and it was way too loud. And so what people were doing,

0:01:44because it was so loud in their ear, is they took it out of their ear and were just sort of holding

0:01:48it. And it was so loud. Like, it was supposed to be like an earpiece, you know, so you wouldn't

0:01:54and distract people, but it was so loud

0:01:56that that's what everybody could hear.

0:01:57It was like, that's how loud it was.

0:01:59- Oh, funny.

0:02:00- And the reason it went away about half an hour

0:02:02in his apple, figured out what was going on

0:02:03and turned the volume down

0:02:04and everybody stuck them back in their ears.

0:02:07- I had an amazing meeting once in Tokyo with the,

0:02:12I wanted to do a story on the evolution

0:02:14of the Japanese vending machine.

0:02:17And I met with the guy at Coca-Cola Japan

0:02:19who runs all their vending machine operations,

0:02:22which is a fascinating story.

0:02:24and I'm not gonna get into the details now,

0:02:26but in this meeting, and also I think

0:02:30in a few other meetings I've had in Tokyo,

0:02:32someone is an interpreter who sits in the room

0:02:34and you have an earpiece where you can hear her speaking,

0:02:38translating into English in real time

0:02:40while you're sitting there in the meeting.

0:02:43It's fascinating, it's very cool.

0:02:45- Sort of like being at the UN or something.

0:02:46- Yeah, exactly, yeah.

0:02:52I gotta say, it was, you know, it had been a year

0:02:54since we'd been in the Steve Jobs Theater,

0:02:56and it's still a really impressive place.

0:03:01I think you probably talked with Eli about this last show,

0:03:06but the sound blew me away.

0:03:09I forgot that they went completely all out

0:03:14with the sound system and the projector and everything.

0:03:17When they were playing that intro sequence,

0:03:21Mission Impossible thing. The room was shaking. The bass was so strong. Not in an obnoxious way,

0:03:28either, in a really, really compelling way. No, it's the best sound I've ever heard in a theater.

0:03:32Literally no echo. It is super crisp.

0:03:35That's all right. We love dogs on the talk show. Joanna's dog is always a problem. What's your dog

0:03:50dog's name? Ralphie. Oh, that's a good name. Try to mute when he's that's all right. He's

0:03:55guarding the door. So that's his job. Yeah, like it is his job. No, that's totally allowed

0:04:00on this show. Now it is fantastic sound and I talked to some Apple people and I think

0:04:06that they use it a little bit more internally than I was initially led to believe like I

0:04:10heard from I wrote about how you know what a remarkable place it is combined with the

0:04:15fact that at least publicly they only use like once a year. They do use it internally

0:04:20a couple times a month they have team meetings and stuff there. It doesn't just sit unused

0:04:26all year long. They do make some good use of it. I heard from a couple people that they

0:04:34had a screening of The Incredibles 2. Employees were allowed to bring their kids and everything

0:04:41like that. I haven't seen it yet. I love The Incredibles. I go to the theater so little

0:04:47now it's criminal. It was sort of like a New Year's resolution for this year that I missed,

0:04:53but I want to start going to the movies more often again because I love going to the movies,

0:04:57and I don't know why I don't go. But I haven't seen The Incredibles 2 yet, but there's apparently a

0:05:00scene where the little baby Jack-Jack is up in a corner, hiding—I don't know. This is not really

0:05:09a spoiler—but he's up by the ceiling, hiding in a corner, back right, and he makes a noise.

0:05:15and the theater, it made it sound like he was in the back corner of the theater.

0:05:18Like my one friend at Apple was like, you know, me and my two kids,

0:05:21we all just turned around and looked up there.

0:05:23That's amazing. Yeah. That's cool.

0:05:26How the promise of surround sound.

0:05:30So what's coming up? I guess we, before we get into the news, we can, while we're talking about

0:05:35the Steve Jobs theater, we can, we can speculate on what's coming up for Apple. Cause it,

0:05:39everybody is expecting them to announce new iPad Pros and probably new MacBooks that are not pro

0:05:47at an event, which I'm guessing—I honestly have no inside information about this. We're recording

0:05:53this on October 15. Nobody has told me a damn thing. But I'm guessing it's going to be Tuesday,

0:05:59October 30. But the question for me is where? Are they going to do it in the Steve Jobs Theater,

0:06:04or are they going to do it like, you know, like they had that. Remember, were you there at the

0:06:10Chicago thing? I was Yeah, yeah. had Lane tech where I took the SAT. That's exactly right. I

0:06:16forgot about that. Right. What a small world. The place where you took the SATs was the I don't know

0:06:26I have no idea what they're gonna do. But I feel like Tuesday, October 30 is the right day because

0:06:31it's obviously not going to be this week. I mean, invitations haven't gone out yet. And I, in theory,

0:06:39you know, they could send out invitations now for something next week, but I don't think they'll do

0:06:43next week. And I don't think they ever would because next week is like this Friday is when

0:06:50the iPhone 10 r goes on sale or pre pre order. And then next Friday is when it ships and I don't

0:06:55don't think they would hold an event in between there because I would guess that

0:07:00like reviews of the XR will be coming out at some point in between then and there. And

0:07:05they're not going to have—they don't want to have reviews of a major new iPhone

0:07:08coming out at the same time that they're announcing new things. Like, it doesn't

0:07:13really make any sense from Apple's perspective.

0:07:15Tom Bilyeu (01h00): Yeah, the minute you—I forgot where I read

0:07:18that thinking first, but that made sense. I mean, there was a world in which—and maybe

0:07:23this would have happened four years ago, they would have put out the invitations the day

0:07:28of the Google Pixel event.

0:07:32They did used to do stuff like that.

0:07:36My guess is that you're right, the discipline of not messing up with the signal of the new

0:07:43iPhone, no noise about iPads or anything else, just keep one story at a time, that makes

0:07:49sense.

0:07:50- Yeah, so if I had to bet,

0:07:53I would bet that they'll have it

0:07:54at the Steve Jobs Theater again.

0:07:56But that's, it's simply, I don't know why I think that.

0:08:01I really don't think that they would ever hold an event

0:08:04at the old town hall on the old campus again.

0:08:07- No. - Like why?

0:08:08I mean, it would seem like--

0:08:09- Yeah, that doesn't make sense.

0:08:10- Even if it's not supposed to be as big a deal

0:08:13as new iPhones, I think new iPads are pretty big.

0:08:18- Oh man, I need one, so I hope it happens sooner than later.

0:08:23Yeah, that's a good question.

0:08:25Is it more work for the events team to do it on campus?

0:08:29Or it's probably a lot less work

0:08:32than having to do it somewhere else.

0:08:34Even if it were in San Francisco or Cupertino,

0:08:37even if it were in Silicon Valley,

0:08:39it's probably a lot easier for them.

0:08:41- I think it's a lot less work, a lot,

0:08:43because it's less travel, obviously, for everybody,

0:08:45because they're just doing their normal daily commute,

0:08:48And I think for the, whatever you want to call the team

0:08:51that does the setup, they don't have anything to set up.

0:08:53I mean, not that they don't,

0:08:55I mean, they put up some decorations

0:08:56and stuff like that in the theater,

0:08:58but it's nothing like the pop-up theaters

0:09:00that they've been making in recent years

0:09:02at places like the Bill Graham Civic Auditorium

0:09:05and other places.

0:09:07- Even Lane Tech High School,

0:09:09like that was by far the cleanest day

0:09:11in the history of that school.

0:09:12(laughing)

0:09:13And forever after, like it will never be as clean

0:09:17it was the day that Apple went there. Right. Yeah, I guess there's the argument that like,

0:09:23oh, keep, keep the Steve Jobs theater for only the most important special events, the iPhone event,

0:09:28but I don't that doesn't really know. I don't think that means anything. Yeah,

0:09:33I think it made sense, maybe for the first event to be there to be for last year's iPhone, you know,

0:09:39the biggest event of the year is the iPhone announcement. I think it sort of made sense

0:09:43to christen the theater with that event. But now it just, to me, makes sense that you'd

0:09:48use it whenever you have something to announce. And the reason they only used it once last

0:09:51year is it was a year where they just didn't have anything else to announce. I mean, one

0:09:56of the reasons that people are so excited about new iPad Pros is that the iPad Pros,

0:10:00our current ones, are really two generations old. They sort of skip the whole A11 CPU cycle.

0:10:09So I think people are really excited. People who love the iPad are really excited about

0:10:12because it's--

0:10:14I hate to use the word overdue, but they're maybe

0:10:18a little overdue.

0:10:19No, I think that's super fair.

0:10:21I mean, if you look at--

0:10:22especially not even just in a vacuum,

0:10:24but if you look at competition, it's getting better.

0:10:27And that's not to say that they have

0:10:29to respond to any sort of increased cadence pressure,

0:10:33but there needs to be a new iPad Pro now.

0:10:38And it seems like, especially if the idea is that it won't

0:10:41have a home button and there's probably more to the story,

0:10:46that's not just gonna be a press release update.

0:10:49I think that commands an event.

0:10:51So.

0:10:52- Yeah.

0:10:53Remember when they did the Apple Watch and I think,

0:10:56what was it?

0:10:58I forget what year, when they announced,

0:11:01there was a 2015 when they originally announced

0:11:03the Apple Watch, maybe it was 2014.

0:11:05But the, and they had that event on the college campus

0:11:07in Cupertino, what's the name of that college?

0:11:11- Yes, I don't know.

0:11:13- But remember they built like a gigantic,

0:11:15like a literal building out front for the hands-on area.

0:11:19Like they built the equivalent of an Apple store

0:11:24all temporary just to have an open air hands-on area

0:11:29after the event, it was crazy.

0:11:33- I mean, even the stuff they do in that convention center

0:11:37where they have WWDC is pretty intense.

0:11:42I think last summer they had a big demo area

0:11:46and I don't remember, now I'm making things up.

0:11:51But yeah, the construction they will do

0:11:53inside of someone else's space is pretty intense.

0:11:57So to go back to earlier, yeah,

0:12:01I think that if there's going to be something

0:12:04and they don't have a good reason

0:12:05for it to be somewhere else,

0:12:06the past they've had like events at like what the maybe I'm blending with Amazon too, but

0:12:13like they'll have something at a library somewhere or something like that. Or, you know, the

0:12:17education event this spring was at a public high school. But there doesn't seem to be

0:12:22a place like that where they would have an iPad event. So and they used to have a member

0:12:26they used to have events at the what's that place in San Francisco, your boy now your

0:12:31Yerba Buena. It was just too small. It really wasn't that much bigger than Town Hall.

0:12:37I guess it was a little bit bigger, but it always felt a little cramped. And the hands-on

0:12:43area was always super cramped in there, too. I remember the one time just talking about

0:12:47how over the top they go at Yerba Buena. It might have been the last year that Katie Cotton

0:12:52was still there. And they knocked out a wall. The room where the hands-on thing was at Yerba

0:12:59on thing was at Yerba Buena, they always painted—or I don't know if they used paint, but draped

0:13:05with black, so it was sort of a very dark room with spotlights shining on the tables.

0:13:12And they just took out a whole wall of the building so that it would be airy and sunshiny,

0:13:18and then just paid to reconstruct it. It wasn't like a removable wall. They literally figured

0:13:25out. They wanted open air. They did the work in advance to figure out, "Yeah, there's

0:13:32no supporting beams in there. We could just knock this out, and then we'll just rebuild

0:13:35it the next day." That's crazy. It's absolutely insane what they spend on these

0:13:40events.

0:13:41Tom Bilyeu (01h00): Yeah. It's amazing though. And it shows. It's

0:13:45just attention to detail. And really, why spare any expense? I mean, sure, spare some

0:13:52but not, you know, what's a couple, what's $10,000 here or there when that's like selling

0:13:59100 iPhones?

0:14:01Yeah. Speaking of iPad Pro, did you see that—

0:14:04100, no, sorry, that's like selling 10 iPhones.

0:14:07Yeah, exactly. It's like selling eight of the $1,500 ones.

0:14:11Yeah.

0:14:12Did you see that Adobe—I mean, it's sort of a poorly kept secret, but that today at

0:14:18their Adobe Max conference, they preannounced Photoshop for iPad.

0:14:22Right, which made me wonder, is this something that they announced last time there was a

0:14:27major iOS event, or is this something that they will announce at the next major iOS event?

0:14:33I would eat my hat if they don't have Adobe on stage at this next event.

0:14:38Yeah.

0:14:39And, you know what, I was actually watching some of the Adobe Max conference today live.

0:14:43They had a great live stream. And Phil Schiller was on stage for a while. They Yeah, which

0:14:49is I can't remember the last time. Wow. Somebody or Phil, I can't remember the last time Phil

0:14:54Schiller was at somebody else's conference. I think it just goes to show how serious Apple

0:15:00is about wanting stuff like Photoshop for iPad. And it's funny because the verge had

0:15:05a really great hands on preview they got, you know, they got to play with it's not coming

0:15:09out till 2019. So who knows if that means early 2019 or later 2019. I suspect that it

0:15:16might be a little later. I wouldn't hold my breath for Photoshop for iPad in January.

0:15:22Because there's definitely some, it's not just that it's beta, there's some features

0:15:27that just aren't there yet. Like there's things you can tap on it, but it doesn't do anything.

0:15:34But the Verge had a great hands on and they let their production staffers use it and put

0:15:39play with it for a while and they had a great video today. I'll put it in the show notes

0:15:43with their first thoughts on it. But the thing that keeps coming up is both from Adobe and

0:15:47the people who are trying this pre-release version that it's quote unquote the real

0:15:51Photoshop. It's not just an image editing app that they've put the Photoshop brand

0:15:56name on. It really is Photoshop that we know and love from the desktop running on an iPad,

0:16:02which is kind of crazy.

0:16:04which makes you wonder why why they're doing it yeah I I'd add to good

0:16:12question and I I wonder about that I I think it is a bet on you know that this

0:16:18really is the future and I think it is a really good form factor for a lot of the

0:16:24stuff people do in Photoshop sure there especially read you know retouching yeah

0:16:29or well the one guy for the drawing the one guy for the verge made a great point

0:16:33point, just a fantastic point where he was like taking an image of a sword and he just

0:16:39wanted to get the background out, just to cut out the sword. And he said, "One of

0:16:44the things you can do here, you just don't think about it, is you just rotate the iPad

0:16:48as he goes around. It's like the way when you're drawing on a piece of paper, you

0:16:51can just turn it upside down to do another part." He's just turning it around upside

0:16:55down, turning it left, turning it right. That's something you can never do with a MacBook.

0:17:02So I don't know. And I think a lot of the stuff with the pencil is obviously uniquely,

0:17:11at least on the Apple platform, is unique to the iPad platform. And it looks to me,

0:17:18from watching the Adobe Max thing, that they're doing it at a really, really high refresh

0:17:24rate. They had a guy doing a demo with simulating oil paint. And just the way that he was swirling

0:17:32two colors together, it was really just stunning that it wasn't—it just looked like a photograph

0:17:38of, you know, like high-def photograph of like a Bob Ross-type guy using actual oil

0:17:43paint. But that's really the secret. I mean, it's no good if there's latency there

0:17:49between the pencil and the thing, but it looks to me like they're doing it right. So I

0:17:53would guess that's the reason why.

0:17:55- Yeah, also I guess in the era where you're,

0:17:59if you're a creative professional,

0:18:01you're probably paying for a subscription to Adobe now.

0:18:06So it doesn't really matter.

0:18:08The idea that you're not buying a $20 iPad version

0:18:12of the app, you're subscribing to whatever

0:18:14the yearly or monthly subscription is.

0:18:16So at that point, they should get you using it

0:18:19on every device you have and not just your one Mac

0:18:22or something like that.

0:18:23- Right, we could do a whole thing.

0:18:24we could do a whole digression on software as a service and subscription versus buying and I know

0:18:28that there are people out there I know because I get emailed from them all the time I know that

0:18:33there are people listening to us who hate it who just who really really really feel strongly that

0:18:39they want to give Adobe you know $299 or whatever and then they get to use Adobe Photoshop version

0:18:47X.0 for as long as it runs on their computer and then choose whether or not to upgrade when

0:18:52and X plus 1.0 comes out, you know.

0:18:55And I, you know, there's all sorts of pros and cons

0:18:58to subscription, but a certain absolute pro

0:19:02is if you're already in, you're already paying,

0:19:04you know, the monthly fee for the CC, the Creative Cloud,

0:19:08and then all of a sudden next year at some point,

0:19:10you just get Photoshop for iPad.

0:19:13I mean, that's pretty sweet.

0:19:16- Yep.

0:19:17Yeah, now I'm gonna watch, now I gotta watch this video.

0:19:20It looks cool.

0:19:21It really is cool. I know at least one person is working on the team. It's the real deal.

0:19:30I mean, it's top-flight talent at Adobe, and it is the real Photoshop. They're not just saying it.

0:19:37So that's very cool. Here, why don't I take a break and thank our first sponsor?

0:19:42Keep this show moving. Our first sponsor is our good friends at Casper.

0:19:48Casper products are there. They're the sleep experts and their products are all cleverly designed to mimic human curves

0:19:55And they provide supportive comfort for all kinds of bodies. Everybody knows them for their mattresses. That's the main thing

0:20:00That's what they that's how they got started. Look you spend one third of your life sleeping

0:20:04I spend well over a third of my life sleeping, but you should be comfortable

0:20:08Why in the world would you not get a nice mattress you spend an entire third eight eight nine hours?

0:20:12Hopefully every single night you're sleeping. Why not get a night great mattress

0:20:17Look, they've got the original Casper. That's that's their their flagship mattress

0:20:21It is has multiple types of supportive memory foams for a quality sleep surface

0:20:27It's still the it's just a fantastic mattress. We have one here

0:20:31It still feels like brand new

0:20:33I mean we've we've had this mattress since whenever Casper first started sponsoring the show which was years ago

0:20:39And it's just like new like it you'd never know. It was a couple years old

0:20:46They've got great reviews you can go to Amazon and and check out all the great reviews and how it is everything

0:20:52They make is all design developed and assembled right here in the United States

0:20:57And they have a wide variety of other sleep products now like pillows and sheets and all sorts of stuff like that

0:21:04We've got we were like all in on the Casper stuff. I love their pillow. It is absolutely fantastic

0:21:10The sheets are good. It's all you know all nice. Everything is nice

0:21:14high thread count everything you want check check check check them all off and

0:21:18here's the deal they have better prices than you get for a premium mattress and

0:21:23a mattress store because they cut out the middleman and they sell directly to

0:21:26you and they have hassle-free returns if you're not completely satisfied you can

0:21:31be completely sure of your purchase because they have a hundred night

0:21:33risk-free sleep on it trial that's over three months buy it get it in the little

0:21:40adorable box that is seems ridiculously too small to have a mattress put in your

0:21:44room, follow the instructions, open it up, sleep on it for three months. And if you don't

0:21:48like it, they just come take it away. No questions asked, no hard sell. It's not like trying

0:21:53to cancel your cable subscription or something like that. They just come and take it. They've

0:21:57got free shipping and free returns in the US and for our northern friends, Canada too.

0:22:05We've got a couple of Casper mattresses here in the house. We love them. They're great.

0:22:10they have a special deal just for listeners of the show 50 bucks you can say 50 bucks

0:22:14towards select mattresses by visiting casper.com casp er.com slash talk show casper.com slash

0:22:23talk show and remember that code talk show know that just ta lk sh o w at checkout and

0:22:29you will save 50 bucks terms and conditions apply

0:22:32all right speaking of tablets I don't know we got a couple of things talked about this

0:22:39show but we could jump right into the Google Pixel event.

0:22:43Yeah, which I was going to go to but I didn't. I did not.

0:22:48So I was going to go and timing wise it didn't really work out that great for me. They had

0:22:55like it was a Tuesday. Last Tuesday was the keynote but because they had it in a sort

0:23:00of like it wasn't a very big venue. It seems like it wasn't a lot of seating in New York.

0:23:06They had a full day of press stuff Wednesday too. So that's what I did. I went up on Wednesday.

0:23:15And it was nice. They had a nice little setup. They had a big, huge—I don't even want

0:23:21to call it a studio—but a big, huge open space there in New York. And then they set

0:23:24up a bunch of kiosks and a bunch of little fake rooms. They had a fake kitchen and a

0:23:30fake bedroom and a fake living room. And then in groups of three, they were taking—I got

0:23:36paired up with two other people from the media. And then we just sort of round robin go from

0:23:40each station to the next and see everything. It was a nice way to do a hands-on thing.

0:23:46That's cool. And I watched the keynote on video. It was a typical Google keynote, way

0:23:53too long, way too many people. I always say it's so obvious. Like the one thing Apple

0:23:58does and to me it would be like a canary in the coal mine if it ever started going the

0:24:03other way in terms of, well, you know, Apple's really going downhill is with like a company

0:24:08like Google, you can see the politics of the internal politics of who gets on stage, you

0:24:14know, like it. It's like, well, we got to get somebody from this team up on stage. So

0:24:19here, let's find some reason for them to be on stage, as opposed to just sort of telling

0:24:24a story straight through about the products. I thought it could have been a much shorter

0:24:29event but the tablet yeah so they have intrigues you a little bit I just set up

0:24:38my my pixel XL which we can talk about later but yeah well the one thing I'll

0:24:43say this in favor in Google's favor I thought it was a very cohesive group of

0:24:47products to be announced three things the Google the new Google pixel 3 in two

0:24:52sizes the brand new pixel slate tablet slash keyboard cover and their their new

0:25:01talk to it device with a screen called the home hub and one two three those are

0:25:07the three products they wanted to talk about I thought that they fit together

0:25:10in in a you know an event very well the slate is interesting because it is their

0:25:18first Chrome Chrome OS tablet like but it runs Android apps you know and I know

0:25:25that they've been working on getting Android apps running in Chrome OS for

0:25:30years now and I kind of feel like I kind of feel like the whole I kind of feel

0:25:36like the whole reason maybe not the whole reason but a big driving factor in

0:25:40that is to get it you know to for tablets I think because I think it makes

0:25:45most sense there. I don't think using an Android app on a laptop makes all that much sense,

0:25:50but on a touchscreen tablet type thing, maybe it does.

0:25:52Tom Bilyeu (01h00): Right. Unless they do something like the new

0:25:56OS X, is it called Marzipan or not? What are we calling it?

0:26:00Jay Haynes (01h00): No. Well, we have to call it Marzipan so we

0:26:02can have something to call it, but Apple is definitely not calling it Marzipan publicly.

0:26:09But we can call it Marzipan.

0:26:10Tom Bilyeu (01h00): Got it.

0:26:11Jay Haynes (01h00): Yeah. And my first thought when I picked it

0:26:14up is, man, this thing is way too heavy. This is too heavy. And then I did, like on the

0:26:22train ride back to Philly, I did the, I like looked up what the iPad Pros weigh and it's

0:26:27actually only ever so slightly heavier than the 12.9 inch iPad Pro. The reason I thought

0:26:32it was heavy is I'm used to the 10.5 inch iPad and they only have one, the Pixel Slate

0:26:37only comes in one size, which is roughly equivalent to the 12.9 inch iPad Pro. So it actually

0:26:43isn't heavy compared to an iPad Pro.

0:26:45It just felt heavy to me at first.

0:26:47Has a very nice screen.

0:26:49They're touting it.

0:26:51I guess Apple's are all 264 pixels per inch

0:26:54and then the pixel slate is like 295 pixels per inch.

0:26:58So they're bragging about having the most pixels,

0:27:00but it's most pixels per inch, but it looks good.

0:27:04I will say this, just tapping around though

0:27:07with the demo apps that they had,

0:27:09a lot of it, they had like a text editor,

0:27:13like, you know, sort of like a BB edit, you know, like a not like a word processor, but

0:27:18like a good old fashioned plain text text editor. I forget what it was called. And I

0:27:24should have asked. I wasn't sure if it and I guess this is actually a good thing. I couldn't

0:27:28tell if it was a Chrome app or an Android app. But the fonts were just tiny, just like

0:27:34I know I've my eyes. I'm 45 and kind of crap eyes. But I mean, by anybody's standards,

0:27:42this was like, it was like the small print

0:27:44on a credit card application.

0:27:47You know what I mean?

0:27:48Like when you're signing up for a new credit card

0:27:51and there's like all this like tiny little small print

0:27:53or like the small print when you buy like a iPhone

0:27:56or something and there's like, here's the warranty.

0:27:59It was like four point type.

0:28:01And I don't know if it's configurable or not,

0:28:03but it seemed it was a weird thing to have

0:28:05on a demo machine, you know, like ready to go to tap on.

0:28:08Like this does not seem thoughtfully designed.

0:28:11The other thing that really stuck out to me compared to an iPad, the big thing for me

0:28:17is that the keyboard cover, that it has real keys and a trackpad. And I tried playing with

0:28:25it like snapping it out of the case back in and as soon as you snap it out, there's like

0:28:29a little black arrow cursor for the trackpad. As soon as you disconnect it from the keyboard,

0:28:34the moment it's disconnected, the arrow cursor just goes away. And then as soon as you snap

0:28:38it back in and move the trackpad around, the arrow cursor shows up again. So it's all,

0:28:42you know, I would really like to see Apple do something like that with the iPad, even

0:28:46though there's no indication that they are. Because I find that one of the, to me, one

0:28:51of the things that drives me nuts if I ever try to do like writing on an iPad is it text

0:28:56selection. Just poking around with my finger on the screen, it seems so crude compared

0:29:01to what I could do with a trackpad, how precise I can move it and double click on words and

0:29:06how my hand is already right there by the trackpad.

0:29:09- Yeah, unless you have a,

0:29:12and I guess if you have a stylus,

0:29:13if you're holding onto the pencil thing,

0:29:15but if you are, you're probably not typing too.

0:29:17It's not super comfortable to hold that.

0:29:20- Yeah, but I don't think Apple doesn't let you

0:29:22use the pencil to like move the insertion point around.

0:29:25It's like only really meant for drawing.

0:29:27So there's really no good way to select text,

0:29:30in my opinion, on iOS period.

0:29:34It's just, to me, is just a glaring hole

0:29:37in the iOS experience, especially in that,

0:29:40when you have the, whether it's the Apple Smart Keyboard

0:29:44cover or some, any of the various third-party keyboards

0:29:47you can get to use with an iPad,

0:29:49it's like when you have it set up like a laptop,

0:29:52using your iPad in a rough, either very laptop-like

0:29:55or roughly laptop-like fashion,

0:29:58not having a trackpad, to me, is just a huge,

0:30:01it never, I never get used to it.

0:30:03I mean, maybe I'm too Mac-centric,

0:30:05but it certainly seems nice on the Chromebook.

0:30:09- Yeah, I mean, I think that's one of the main reasons

0:30:11I have not, like every time I do try to use

0:30:15an iPad Pro for text, you know, for editing basically

0:30:21or writing, I immediately grab my MacBook

0:30:24and just go back to that.

0:30:25I think you're right.

0:30:27I don't think about it a lot, but the text,

0:30:29The cursor insertion and just text selection is pretty bad.

0:30:33- Yeah, and you know, it's the Surface, you know,

0:30:37there's, I guess the, you know,

0:30:39the battle for these tablets now is iPad,

0:30:42the Microsoft Surface ones, and now, you know,

0:30:46it's like a full reset.

0:30:48Like Google is seemingly really backed away from Android

0:30:51as anything other than a phone OS,

0:30:53and this Chrome OS that runs Android apps

0:30:56is their new tablet OS, and you know,

0:30:58this is the first product that ships with that,

0:31:02that's their entry in this.

0:31:03The other two, Microsoft and Google,

0:31:05all have trackpad support.

0:31:06- Oh wow, all right, well now we're on, right?

0:31:11It's on now.

0:31:12Who'd you get the sense that they are building this for?

0:31:15'Cause 12-inch screen is not a super portable tablet,

0:31:20did you get a sense that this is a work device

0:31:23and not a ever on the house thing?

0:31:26- It's a good question.

0:31:28I thought about that too. And the other thing too is it starts at $599 but it goes up to

0:31:35like $1400, $1500, mostly dependent on, I think you can either get it with like 64 or

0:31:44128 gigabytes of storage, but then the CPU goes up too and as you pay more for a better

0:31:51CPU, and this is an Intel device, it is not running an ARM chip, which is to me interesting.

0:31:56- Yeah.

0:31:57- But it, you know--

0:32:01- Are those Chromebooks Intel?

0:32:03- I guess, I would guess that they are.

0:32:07They're just--

0:32:08- I should probably know, but--

0:32:09- Yeah, I think that they are, but I don't know.

0:32:13But this is, and you have a, you know, I don't know,

0:32:16I've dropped off, you know, I just don't pay attention

0:32:19to Intel's chips anymore, you know,

0:32:21when I buy a MacBook, you know, I just,

0:32:24there just aren't that many options

0:32:26on the Apple side of things.

0:32:27But there's like eight different CPU configurations

0:32:29for the Pixel Slate with very different prices.

0:32:32And you get a little bit more RAM

0:32:34if you buy the more expensive ones, too.

0:32:37So I do wonder who's buying a $1,400 Chrome OS tablet.

0:32:42I mean, it's certainly not targeted

0:32:44at that low-end Chromebook market

0:32:47that is dominating education,

0:32:49where there's like $199 plastic laptops.

0:32:53It's definitely not that, starting at 599.

0:32:56- I mean, I think this speaks to the bigger question.

0:32:59If you zoom out and look at Google's hardware strategy

0:33:02in general, especially for the phones,

0:33:05and it seems like this too, you just kind of have to wonder

0:33:09why they're doing it the way they're doing it.

0:33:12I mean, it basically seems like they're pushing

0:33:16for the super high end of the market,

0:33:18they're trying to compete with, and in some cases,

0:33:21seem to be very successfully either at Apple's level

0:33:26of blending hardware and software or approaching it,

0:33:31they're clearly not going mass market with these things.

0:33:36You can see that the pixels are not flying off the shelves,

0:33:40they're not super successful commercially,

0:33:43even though they are really nice devices.

0:33:45So this kind of fits in with that strange strategy.

0:33:49I forgot who maybe it was,

0:33:53I don't even wanna misattribute this,

0:33:55but someone said like maybe they're just being a troll

0:33:57by doing all this stuff?

0:33:58Like they're--

0:34:00- I don't think so.

0:34:01And there was a couple of pieces.

0:34:03I wanted to link to one,

0:34:04maybe I'll get it by the end of this week.

0:34:06There was a piece somebody wrote, maybe at Bloomberg,

0:34:09kind of scoffing at the whole idea of Google doing phones

0:34:13and why are they even bothering?

0:34:14This is effectively like corporate masturbation

0:34:17because they're not selling enough of these

0:34:21to make any kind of dent in the market

0:34:23or dent in their bottom line.

0:34:25And I disagree with that.

0:34:26Well, I don't disagree that it's a blip financially.

0:34:31Somebody did the math and figured out that Apple,

0:34:34like Apple sells as many iPhones in eight days

0:34:37as Google sold Pixel phones in an entire year.

0:34:40I'm almost surprised that it's not even

0:34:42more lopsided than that.

0:34:45But I think that there's no other Android phones

0:34:50that are like the Pixel phones in my opinion.

0:34:52I've described them a year or two ago.

0:34:54I have a Pixel One, I skipped the Pixel Two generation,

0:34:57and I've already pre-ordered a Pixel Three.

0:35:00'Cause I like to, to me,

0:35:02it's the most interesting Android device.

0:35:04I've described it as an,

0:35:06it's an Android device for people who want Android,

0:35:09but they want an iPhone-like phone.

0:35:13because to me the rest of the Android,

0:35:15especially the high-end market,

0:35:17has sort of gone in a very different direction.

0:35:20I mean, for all the legal consternation

0:35:23between Apple and Samsung over the early Galaxy devices,

0:35:27the lawsuit that went on for 10 years over the look and feel

0:35:33or whatever you wanna call it.

0:35:34And remember there was a moment where somebody held up,

0:35:40there was a Samsung expert witness on the stand

0:35:43and one of Apple's lawyers held up one of the phones

0:35:45and said, "Here, can you tell if this is an iPhone

0:35:49"or the Galaxy Note 3?"

0:35:51And the guy was like, "No, I can't."

0:35:53It was seemingly a good moment.

0:35:56But I don't think that's like that anymore.

0:35:57There's no confusing high-end Samsung Galaxy S9

0:36:02or the Note, whatever they're up to.

0:36:04They look very different.

0:36:05They have a very different design language.

0:36:07They have both software and hardware, they look different.

0:36:12whereas the Pixel phones,

0:36:13I'm not saying they're iPhone ripoffs,

0:36:15but they're definitely iPhone-like in hardware.

0:36:19- And very nice, like I'm holding a Pixel 3 XL

0:36:22and an iPhone XS Max in two hands,

0:36:26and neither one of them is much obviously nicer

0:36:31than the other one, like very, very nice devices.

0:36:34Both have really, really impressive screens,

0:36:36and I could, you know, I mean, to some extent,

0:36:41it probably is helpful for Google

0:36:43to be able to show their employees,

0:36:45like, hey, look at,

0:36:46we can actually make this really good stuff too,

0:36:47and you can own this and use Android as intended

0:36:51on this device.

0:36:52- Yeah, the other thing they do,

0:36:54to me, the hardware is definitely iPhone-like.

0:36:57I wouldn't mind running iOS on one of those devices

0:37:00just in terms of how they feel.

0:37:02They feel really nice in hand, they've always did.

0:37:04And especially, they've really made it better

0:37:06in the last two years.

0:37:07Like, my Pixel 1 is okay,

0:37:10but there's things about it that I think were mistakes

0:37:12like the power button,

0:37:16they like etched like a ridging on the side

0:37:20and it's just not pleasant.

0:37:21I think that because they put the volume button

0:37:23right below the power button,

0:37:25my guess is the thinking was,

0:37:27well, let's give the power button this rigid feel

0:37:30so you can tell, but it's like, you don't need that.

0:37:32You just know which one's up and which one's below,

0:37:35and they've gotten away from that.

0:37:38They just feel better now.

0:37:39But the other thing that they do with their phones,

0:37:42you said the displays are,

0:37:42I think the displays are fantastic.

0:37:44But they're also to me, very iPhone-like

0:37:47in terms of color reproduction.

0:37:49Like they're not super saturated.

0:37:51You know, like to me, the Samsung phones

0:37:53and the LG phones all look--

0:37:56- Ridiculous.

0:37:57- Yeah, to me, they're just not to my liking.

0:37:59They're just so over the top, oversaturated.

0:38:03And it's, you know, some people like that.

0:38:05And I've heard from, you know, like in China,

0:38:07there's a lot of people who really, really like that look.

0:38:09They like that it's not really realistic.

0:38:12It's like hyper-realistic.

0:38:14The Pixel phones are like iPhones to me

0:38:17in terms of having a natural sort of color landscape.

0:38:22- Yeah, it looks great.

0:38:24Man, the one thing that really is throwing me off though

0:38:27are the missing gestures from iOS,

0:38:30like not being able to swipe backwards

0:38:33and some of this stuff.

0:38:35I've had it set up for about half an hour or so.

0:38:39- I'll get used to it, or maybe not, but it's super weird.

0:38:42However, I just discovered something very, very smart,

0:38:45which is you can, I don't know how they do this,

0:38:47but you can squeeze the phone,

0:38:50and it activates their assistant, which is really clever.

0:38:54- It seems like a gimmick, but when I played with it

0:38:57in their hands-on area, it works pretty well.

0:38:59- Well, and they use haptic feedback to make it feel

0:39:02like you're actually squeezing the phone,

0:39:04which I don't think I am.

0:39:05Like, I hope it's not.

0:39:06(laughing)

0:39:07I'm not actually bending the phone, but it really feels like I am, which is cool.

0:39:12I just hit it, I agree without reading the screen.

0:39:14I don't know what they're collecting on me now.

0:39:16Yeah, well, everything.

0:39:18Uh-oh.

0:39:19Yeah, it's really nice.

0:39:22So to me, you asked before, who is the Pixel Slate for?

0:39:26I'm not entirely sure about that answer.

0:39:29It's not for me, because I'm not a big Chrome user.

0:39:34I guess if you're all in on Chrome, though, and you want a tablet, this could be really

0:39:37nice if you're sort of living the Chrome OS lifestyle. I don't know.

0:39:42If you live in Google Docs, it might be a compelling device. I don't know.

0:39:46Right. And it's, you know,

0:39:48A lot, by the way, like tens of thousands of people in Silicon Valley live in Google

0:39:51Docs all day. So,

0:39:52Yeah, I do see it. You know, I have an iPad, I have a Mac book and, you know, I use them

0:40:00at different times for different things. And, but there are, I can see how it would be nice

0:40:06to reduce it to one device in some ways. Like, let's say like, I'm a notorious tab lever opener,

0:40:12you know, I've at any given time, I've got like, six windows, each with, you know, 20 tabs open in

0:40:18them. And if I've, you know, I wanted to read that, that story that Dan wrote about whatever,

0:40:23and I know I've got it open in a tab, but I'm on the iPad. It's like, you can get it out of iCloud.

0:40:28But it's like, I don't remember which device it was on sometimes. And I don't know where to look

0:40:32for it. Whereas if it's one less device, the tab I have open with the article I've halfway

0:40:38read is right there, even once I've detached it from the keyboard and I'm just sitting

0:40:42on the couch at night. So I can see that, but I don't know. But with the phones, I definitely

0:40:48see who the market is. And the thing that really strikes me about the Pixel owners,

0:40:53and it just hit me this year, is I think in some ways, the Pixel aficionados right now,

0:41:01Pixel phone aficionados, remind me a lot of being a Mac user in like the late 90s. So,

0:41:10you know, and that was the era when, you know, there were all sorts of same thing, this same

0:41:15argument like, hey, why does Google even bother making these things or market share so low,

0:41:20it's all irrelevant, they should just give up because the market share so low. That's

0:41:23everything everybody said about Apple in 1995, right, that they should give it up. You know,

0:41:29Michael Dell said, what would he do if he ran Apple?

0:41:33He'd liquidate the company and give the money back

0:41:36to the shareholders.

0:41:37But if you, like me, were a Mac user in the late '90s

0:41:42and you really were passionate about the things

0:41:44that the Mac still did, even at a technical level

0:41:49when the OS was really behind the times,

0:41:52at a user interface level, they never lost that lead.

0:41:56and it was always a nicer user experience.

0:41:59The word beleaguered was always thrown around,

0:42:03but that's sort of what we felt like.

0:42:05And I was never a big,

0:42:07remember people would spell Windows W-I-N-D-O-Z-E

0:42:12and stuff like that, and get in,

0:42:15every single Usenet group, whatever it was,

0:42:17it could be about the weather, like alt.philadelphia.weather.

0:42:22Eventually it's gonna break into a Windows

0:42:24versus Mac flame war. Like there was, there was no news group. Hey, those were fun though.

0:42:30There was no news group that didn't eventually break into a windows versus dos flame war,

0:42:35whether it was computer related or not. Probably the computer groups were the least likely

0:42:39because everybody had gotten it out of their system. Um, but I just see it like on Twitter

0:42:45when I see that the pixel people like touting like their, their, you know, photo advantages

0:42:51and stuff like that. Like I see that passion and I see their frustration that it's not

0:42:56more popular, right? That they're, they're like, it just seems like Google should be

0:43:01selling more pixels than they are because it really is a very compelling device and

0:43:06software experience. It just doesn't seem right that it's, that it's not more popular.

0:43:11And I think that's a really good analogy. I think Mac users had that frustration for

0:43:15a long time. They really did. And I see it, you know, I mean, there was a lot of reviews.

0:43:19I can't speak to it because I don't have a Pixel 2. I'm getting the Pixel 3 soon.

0:43:22But there's a bunch of reviews, like Nilay and a few others, all said that the Pixel

0:43:282 from last year was still a better still camera than the iPhone XS. So who knows how

0:43:34good the Pixel 3 is?

0:43:36Yeah, I haven't had a chance to test it, but it seems to be great. The fact that they're

0:43:40even in the same sentence is astounding. Whether it's 10% better or worse or even more than

0:43:49That's pretty remarkable considering much like Apple, Google did not have much of a

0:43:56hardware or sorry, did not have much of a camera and smartphone background before they

0:44:02just started.

0:44:03So yeah, there's a couple of features I wrote.

0:44:06I wrote about it briefly on during Fireball, but there's a couple of features in the

0:44:10Pixel 3 and it's a little confusing.

0:44:12What's what's Pixel 3 specific and what is going to ship in a software update for

0:44:17existing Pixel 1 and Pixel 2 owners later this year. There's a bunch of features they

0:44:22talked about at the event. Some of them are specific to the Pixel 3 and some of them are

0:44:26coming to supposedly coming to older Pixels later. But almost like that, who cares? But

0:44:34the one feature that really blew me away is the one they're calling Top Shot, which is

0:44:40like you, you don't have to go to a special mode. It's just I guess you can turn it off.

0:44:44I don't see why you would though because it seems great you take a photo and

0:44:47It keeps a couple of frames from before you tap the shutter button and it takes a couple of extra frames after

0:44:55You hit the shutter button and it shoots a video in between as well. So it might take let's say five stills

0:45:03At the full resolution with all of the everything, you know

0:45:07They're all they get the same HDR processing everything you'd want and then in between knows there's video

0:45:14And so the if you if you take one of the video frames you're gonna get less resolution

0:45:18you know and it's not quite as good of a photo, but the idea is

0:45:22Like let's say you're shooting a sporting event or or you know

0:45:27And a whale is jump you're on a boat and whale jumps out of the water and you take a photo

0:45:32That the absolute best image that you get might be one of those video frames even though it's a slightly lower resolution

0:45:41Image it might be the one you want to keep because it's the perfect moment, right?

0:45:46It's that perfect fraction of a sentence or second when the moment was just perfect

0:45:50But it in practice it really seems to work. I again that this is something

0:45:56I don't have a pixel in hand yet, but I only got to do it during the hands-on area

0:45:59But what they did is they gave us each a pixel to walk around with and while they were explaining the feature to me

0:46:04I took a picture of the the woman from Google product marketing who was telling me about it and I swear

0:46:10As I took the picture, I actually caught her at a bad moment when she was looking down and her eyes

0:46:14were closed. And as she's telling me about the top shot picture, I took a picture of her. It was a

0:46:20bad, very unflattering photo because her eyes were closed and she's looking down. And it immediately

0:46:25says, "Would you prefer to use this one?" And it went back like half a second and she looked

0:46:30perfect. And she's looking right at me. It's like I gave myself the perfect demo of the feature.

0:46:37And so when you take a good photo

0:46:39and Google thinks it's a good photo,

0:46:41it doesn't even ask you.

0:46:43It like only is when it recognizes something like,

0:46:45hey, there's a subject here with her eyes closed.

0:46:48We should see if we can suggest something better.

0:46:52And it happens instantaneously.

0:46:53It happens right after you snap the shutter button.

0:46:56- That's cool.

0:46:57You can do that manually with live photos.

0:47:00- Right.

0:47:01Well, but the--

0:47:02- You can scrub it a little bit.

0:47:03- Right, so it's--

0:47:04- The fact that this note,

0:47:05This is like proactively recommending to you.

0:47:08- Yeah. - That's cool.

0:47:09- Yeah, and it really does, again,

0:47:11I shot like five minutes worth of photos,

0:47:14but it really does seem to only suggest it to you

0:47:18when the photo really was taken at the wrong moment

0:47:21and doesn't bother you

0:47:22when you've taken a fine photo right away.

0:47:25So it doesn't annoy you needlessly

0:47:27and when it does interrupt, it's right.

0:47:30That's pretty cool.

0:47:33What was the other feature that I liked?

0:47:35- I love how both of these come,

0:47:38both Google and Apple though are using software

0:47:40to make photos, you know, what, 50 to 100 times better

0:47:44than just hardware alone would make them.

0:47:45- Absolutely, yeah.

0:47:46And it's great that they're pushing each other, you know,

0:47:50and there's, you know, I'm not saying that Google's ahead

0:47:52in every single regard, but it's great though

0:47:55that somebody else is doing similar type things.

0:47:59And I know Samsung has some AI features too,

0:48:02everybody's sort of doing it,

0:48:03but it seems to me like Google and Apple

0:48:05are ahead of everybody else here in different ways.

0:48:08- And who's not doing it are the camera companies.

0:48:09Like I almost never,

0:48:11I still love the photo that will come out from my Fuji

0:48:16more than, it just feels like I'm taking a photo

0:48:19in a way that an iPhone photo still does not.

0:48:23But when you do it side by side,

0:48:26a lot of times the iPhone photo actually does look better.

0:48:30- Yeah.

0:48:32Another cool feature they have,

0:48:33I guess it's not a camera feature,

0:48:34but it's the, did you see the call screening feature?

0:48:39- I did, yeah, that was cool.

0:48:41- That is really-- - It's very Googly.

0:48:43- It's very Googly, and it really, you know,

0:48:46and they did, again, they demoed it exactly the right way

0:48:48where there was like a Google employee up in a,

0:48:51you know, like in a different room who called us,

0:48:53and we got a real phone call.

0:48:55- In an unmarked restaurant in Silicon Valley.

0:48:59- Well, it was the complete opposite of duplex,

0:49:02because it was a real demo of a real feature and super useful. And it's like they said,

0:49:07I mean, they even acknowledged that the spam phone calls are worse than ever. I get them

0:49:14all the time. So I would love to have that feature on iOS. And it just makes so much sense that

0:49:20it just takes… For all these years, I mean, going back before iPhone, going back to the original

0:49:28cell phones where they had a green button and a red button. There have always been two

0:49:31buttons for when a phone call comes in. Take it or don't take it. And now there's this

0:49:35third option where it's like, "Okay phone, you talk to this jerk. See who it is." Right?

0:49:41And if it turns out it's somebody you know, if it's like, you know, your accountant is

0:49:45calling you or somebody you know is calling from a weird number, you can see it on the

0:49:49transcript and then just jump right into the call and be like, "Oh, okay. I didn't know

0:49:52who it was. It's a very, very cool feature and like you said, very, very googly. What

0:49:59else? Do you have both phones as a review unit?

0:50:05Tom Bilyeu (01h00m 9s): I do, yeah. I've only done the big one. I've

0:50:10not taken out the… I just picked them up today, so I have not.

0:50:14Jay Haynes (01h00m 19s): I will say I think it's a little weird and

0:50:19it is a little, they've gone the wrong way.

0:50:22Like one of my very, very favorite things

0:50:23about the iPhone XS is that the XS and the XS Max

0:50:28are the only difference is the size.

0:50:30That the cameras are exactly the same,

0:50:33the CPU's exactly the same, they have the same amount of RAM

0:50:36it's just you want a bigger one, you know,

0:50:37so the display is bigger and the battery is bigger

0:50:39because the, you know, because it's more room

0:50:42for a bigger battery, but that's it.

0:50:44They look the same, you know, and I just think,

0:50:48Anyway, this is my way of saying,

0:50:49I can't believe they put a big ugly notch

0:50:51on the one and not the other.

0:50:52- Yeah, and it doesn't seem to,

0:50:55maybe I'm not finding it,

0:50:57but there does not seem to be the Face ID type thing.

0:51:00- No, they don't, no, there is no Face ID type thing.

0:51:03It's only there to have the two cameras.

0:51:06So the other weird thing, I'm not weird,

0:51:08but certainly different from Apple,

0:51:11I'll just say different,

0:51:12is that they still only have one camera on the back

0:51:14as the main camera,

0:51:16but now they have two cameras on the front,

0:51:19one of which is like a normal focal length selfie camera,

0:51:23and now they have this super wide angle,

0:51:25almost fisheye selfie camera to get a wider field of view.

0:51:30- Oh, weird. (laughs)

0:51:34I can see my whole apartment in one.

0:51:36- Right, right.

0:51:37So you zoom, it's like you go to the selfie camera

0:51:40and then you can zoom the other way.

0:51:41Instead of like zooming in like a telephoto,

0:51:43you zoom out and it's super wide in there.

0:51:46- It seems interesting, I guess.

0:51:48I don't know. - You know what?

0:51:49I would use this all the time. (laughs)

0:51:52As someone who has an embarrassing number of selfies,

0:51:54I would probably use this all the time.

0:51:56That's cool, all right.

0:51:59But it looks, I mean, it actually looks

0:52:01kind of like a person looking back at you

0:52:02'cause there's two.

0:52:04It looks like a smiling creature of some sort.

0:52:08But yeah, I was surprised there was no face ID type thing.

0:52:11- No, no, it's still--

0:52:12- I'm now hooked on this fingerprint thing,

0:52:15and get rid of it.

0:52:17- Yeah, it's, I don't know.

0:52:19I know that there are all sorts of people out there

0:52:21who have mixed feelings about Face ID versus Touch ID

0:52:24and who should not be holding their breath for it

0:52:28but are secretly hoping that Apple is working on Touch ID

0:52:32under the glass.

0:52:33Like, I'm telling you, don't worry.

0:52:35I don't think it's gonna happen.

0:52:37I don't think.

0:52:37- No.

0:52:38- And I actually think, who knows?

0:52:40I could be wrong.

0:52:42Maybe it would work well in addition to Face ID,

0:52:44but I sort of feel like there's an advantage

0:52:47to only having one biometric ID,

0:52:51that you don't have to choose

0:52:52between fingerprint and face ID.

0:52:54It's like if you've got the new phone, you use face ID,

0:52:56and if you have an older phone, you use touch ID.

0:53:00- I agree with you, though.

0:53:00They definitely lose style points

0:53:02for having the notch on one of them, but not the other.

0:53:06So 99.9% of people will never have both of them

0:53:11at any point.

0:53:13And nor nor is this like iOS where they dictate how every phone looks like yeah

0:53:19You know the whole point of Android is that it works on?

0:53:24You know a hundred thousand different phones, so it's a weird-looking notch too, though

0:53:29It is it's a it's the biggest notch. I've ever seen it's a deep notch. It's a deep notch and I

0:53:35Know it's you know it's been amusing to watch like the the larger Android

0:53:42fan droid world of people are very down on this notch.

0:53:47To their credit, that they're being honest.

0:53:50They're not just, oh, I love Pixel phone,

0:53:52so I'm gonna say this notch is the best notch.

0:53:55No, instead the consensus seems to be

0:53:56that this notch is hideous.

0:53:59It's just ungainly.

0:54:02- Yeah, it's not bothering me at all.

0:54:04Well, it is kinda weird, but I don't know, it's fine.

0:54:09- I still don't like the notch on the iPhone X.

0:54:11I am used to it though.

0:54:13I am very used to it.

0:54:14- I don't even see it anymore.

0:54:16- But it just is weird that the two phones

0:54:19have different foreheads,

0:54:21'cause the one has a regular forehead

0:54:23and the other one has a notch.

0:54:25- Are you back to the normal 10 size now?

0:54:28- Yes, this is a weird thing.

0:54:32I know that when you put the XS Max

0:54:35next to a previous Plus phone,

0:54:38like an iPhone 8 Plus or 7 Plus, whatever,

0:54:40They're almost exactly the same size.

0:54:42It's like less than, I think it's like a millimeter,

0:54:46the iPhone XS Max is like a millimeter smaller

0:54:51in each dimension or something like that.

0:54:53It's very, very similar.

0:54:55But for some reason, it looks and feels smaller in my hand

0:54:59than the plus size phones did.

0:55:01I think it's just like an optical illusion created

0:55:03by the fact that it has so much greater

0:55:06screen to body area ratio.

0:55:09It somehow feels smaller.

0:55:11So I never liked the plus size phones at all

0:55:14and never was tempted to buy a six plus or seven plus

0:55:17or any of those, even though it always bothered me

0:55:20that they had slightly better cameras,

0:55:22with optical image stabilization and a few features

0:55:25that the smaller one didn't have.

0:55:27It just, the XS Max was actually somewhat tempting to me.

0:55:30It was the first time Apple made a larger phone

0:55:32that I was like, hmm, maybe.

0:55:35And there were times when I was testing it

0:55:36when I forgot which one I had.

0:55:38I was like, wait, is this the bigger one or the smaller one?

0:55:40But I did end up buying the smaller one.

0:55:44- Yeah, I haven't, I'm still in the review unit stage.

0:55:47I was a plus guy for the three years

0:55:51or whatever it was during that era.

0:55:54And now I'm testing out this Max

0:55:57and boy, that screen is gorgeous.

0:56:01And to me, the most underappreciated thing

0:56:03about the bigger phones is that typing is much more accurate

0:56:07'cause the keys are wider.

0:56:09But I'm not really using the whole screen for anything.

0:56:12I still find myself reading in the top third

0:56:16of the screen almost or top fourth of it.

0:56:18And this thing just feels big in your pocket.

0:56:21Although having the new Apple Watch Series 4

0:56:27makes it kind of a different game

0:56:29because the, and we can talk about the new watch for a bit.

0:56:32I mean, it is a really damn good device.

0:56:36it feels like a computer on your wrist now

0:56:39in a way that it just did not previously.

0:56:41And I would say that's 80% just speed.

0:56:45Like it actually responds to your clicks

0:56:48and doesn't get caught up in a series of commands.

0:56:53But the software is starting to get really good too.

0:56:57I mean, especially the watch face like that.

0:56:59- Well, hold that though.

0:57:00Let's save it for a different section.

0:57:03I got the feeling at the press thing

0:57:04And I feel like I'm clearly in the minority.

0:57:07I don't know, and it's the sort of thing

0:57:09Apple doesn't like to talk about.

0:57:11They'll give unit sales for iPhones,

0:57:13but they don't like to break it down by model.

0:57:15I would love to know what percentage of people

0:57:18are buying the regular XS and who are buying the XS Max.

0:57:21I really don't even know how to guess how that's going.

0:57:24But at least among the enthusiast crowd,

0:57:28like the sort of people who go to a Google press event

0:57:32to see the new phones,

0:57:33The bigger size is clearly the more popular.

0:57:38It's like, 'cause, and you know, it's a funny thing

0:57:42because like you go to the Apple event

0:57:44and almost everybody's carrying an iPhone around.

0:57:46Like at the Google thing, most of the press

0:57:48who I was there looking around with were carrying pixels,

0:57:51you know, 'cause they're sort of Google,

0:57:52you know, it's gonna draw Google-oriented

0:57:54members of the media.

0:57:56- Totally.

0:57:57- But it really looked to me,

0:57:57just doing a quick eyeball survey,

0:57:59that almost all of them had the Pixel 2 Plus

0:58:02or whatever, what do they call the big one, Plus?

0:58:04XL, XL, yeah, Pixel 2 XL.

0:58:08Whereas I like the smaller one better, for sure.

0:58:12But it is weird, it does look a little dated,

0:58:14because it has a forehead and a chin.

0:58:15I mean, here I am knocking the notch on the other one, but.

0:58:18- Yeah.

0:58:19- And it seems, it's just one of those things

0:58:21that Apple does better than anybody,

0:58:24but, you know, and Google as sort of hardware

0:58:28being not their forte.

0:58:30The fact that even the one with the notch

0:58:33still has the chin down below at the bottom,

0:58:35it just is, it's not a premium look.

0:58:41- Yeah, you wonder why they kept it,

0:58:46whether they had to or they chose to.

0:58:50- Yeah.

0:58:51- I don't know.

0:58:52- It does feel last year.

0:58:56- I think they had to.

0:58:57I think that it's technically super, super hard to go edge to edge.

0:59:03Even though they're OLED, which makes it easier and not LCD, but everything I've heard from

0:59:10people at Apple is that getting the iPhone X and XS to get as close to corner to corner

0:59:16as they are is technically very hard.

0:59:19and the XR, which we can get to, is even harder because it's an LCD screen, not an OLED. It

0:59:27just looks weird. It just is sort of a weird look for the pixels, in my opinion. I also

0:59:33thought that they were a lot lighter. I don't know what they weigh compared to a XS, but

0:59:38I don't mind how much the XS weighs, but it is true. I mean, steel weighs more than aluminum,

0:59:43So it is a heavier device.

0:59:46I feel like the Pixels really compare better to the XR because they're more just off the

0:59:53top of my head.

0:59:54They're both glass on the front, glass on the back, aluminum on the sides, and then

0:59:58a single camera on the back.

1:00:00So it's sort of the XR is the one and the starting price is around the same, around

1:00:05$750, $800.

1:00:06It's like the XS is sort of a different class device than even the best Pixel.

1:00:11It's true. We're entering a 10-R world. I need to recalibrate all my analysis now.

1:00:19Yeah. I can't wait to find out more about it. Like the 10-R was sort of… it's like

1:00:26they announced it and it was interesting. And you know, it was kind of rumored and here

1:00:29it is. And it's this, you know, it's just so strange in so many ways because it's

1:00:34like it's not the same size as the 10-S or the 10-S Max. It's in between. It's

1:00:40size and it's in between which is a weird third size and it only has one camera but

1:00:45it's the same great camera you know that the 10s has and it comes in a bunch of fun colors

1:00:53which Apple hasn't done with an iPhone since all the way back at the 5c you know it's different

1:00:58in so many ways and I kind of feel and I just feel like most people feel like 800 bucks

1:01:06is already a ton of money to spend on a phone and so I just can't help but think that the

1:01:10is going to be an incredible seller, you know,

1:01:14'cause it has the look and it has the performance

1:01:17of an iPhone 10 and, you know, saving 250 bucks

1:01:21for a, you know, primarily missing out

1:01:24on a 2X telephoto camera that I'm guessing

1:01:27a lot of people never use.

1:01:29It's, you know, seems like, it seems like a lot of people

1:01:31are gonna go into the Apple store and be like,

1:01:33why would I even think about buying the more expensive one?

1:01:35- Yeah, that's gonna be really interesting

1:01:39because once you divide it into the monthly payments,

1:01:43it's not as drastic a dollar difference,

1:01:48'cause now very few people

1:01:49are actually buying the phone outright.

1:01:51But even on a monthly basis, it's probably,

1:01:55I don't know, what, 10, 20 bucks cheaper a month?

1:01:57So maybe.

1:01:58- And I just don't think typical people

1:02:02are going to see the difference.

1:02:03I mean, not like they wouldn't be able to tell them apart.

1:02:05I mean, certainly the colors tell you that, you know.

1:02:08But I really don't think that a typical person

1:02:11would look at an iPhone XS and XR side by side

1:02:14and think that the XS is that much better.

1:02:19- Especially inside.

1:02:22If you're outside, I would never wanna not have,

1:02:26well, I don't know, I haven't tried the XR outside.

1:02:28Maybe it's amazing.

1:02:29But you can tell OLED outside in a way that

1:02:37LCD just was not as good before.

1:02:40- Yeah, and you know, I mean, you see it when you play games

1:02:43and watch movies or something like that too,

1:02:45where OLED has these richer blacks,

1:02:46but I, to tell you the truth,

1:02:48I don't really watch movies on my phone.

1:02:50I mean, I either watch on TV or if I am on an airplane

1:02:53or something, I want a bigger screen than the phone.

1:02:55So, you know, I kind of miss out on that.

1:02:58- Do you think this new, what is it, liquid retina?

1:03:01Do you think that's what they're gonna call

1:03:03the iPad Pro screen too?

1:03:04- I wonder, that's a good question.

1:03:06I guess I would guess so. I wouldn't be surprised if it's the exact same technology. I do have

1:03:14another theory, by the way, because the other feature that's missing from the XR is 3D touch.

1:03:20And it has been widely reported, you know, and this was one of those things that Ming

1:03:24Qi Kuo had leaked a report back in February or something. So it's a long time ago it came

1:03:30out that Apple's 6.1-inch mystery phone was going to lack 3D Touch. And it's all been reported as

1:03:38like a cost-saving measure because this is the lower cost new iPhone. But it's not really a

1:03:43lower cost new iPhone. It starts at $800 or $750. Like that's the normal price for a new flagship

1:03:50iPhone. Like the XS and the iPhone X, it's created a new super tier above the normal price. And,

1:03:59And when they first introduced, I just looked it up last night

1:04:03for the show, actually.

1:04:04But 3D Touch debuted with the iPhone 6S.

1:04:08And that was a phone that started at $699.

1:04:12That was the entry level price back then for the 6S.

1:04:15And they all had 3D Touch.

1:04:16So it's not cost, per se.

1:04:19If a $699 phone four years ago could have 3D Touch,

1:04:24then cost-wise, surely the $750 10R could have 3D touch.

1:04:29I think it's a technical problem

1:04:31that whatever shenanigans and technical wizardry

1:04:37they had to pull to get an LCD screen

1:04:39that comes as close to corner to corner as they did.

1:04:42I mean, the whole reason that LCDs

1:04:43have always had foreheads and chin

1:04:45is for the backlighting stuff.

1:04:48I think that whatever they had to do to get,

1:04:53they sacrifice 3D Touch to get it to look like an iPhone X that goes corner to corner.

1:04:59And I'm betting that it's an engineering problem, not a cost problem. And if it saves seven

1:05:03bucks per phone, I'm sure that makes Tim Cook happy too. But it is weird for the product

1:05:09experience though that they work in different ways for stuff like turning on the flashlight

1:05:13and stuff like that.

1:05:14Yeah, that was one of the things I just noticed on this Pixel 2 is not having... Because I

1:05:21I basically only use it for cursor movement,

1:05:25moving the cursor, but that alone to me

1:05:27pays for the feature, so not having it--

1:05:31- All right, this might blow your mind.

1:05:32This might blow your mind.

1:05:33Did you know, I think it's an iOS 12 feature.

1:05:36I don't think it was there in iOS 11,

1:05:37but Apple has added, and I think it was specifically

1:05:40with iPads and the XR in mind.

1:05:44You can now get that cursor move around feature

1:05:47on a non-3D touch iOS device

1:05:49by holding down on the space bar.

1:05:51hold down on the space bar for a little bit

1:05:53and then you get the same thing.

1:05:54- Oh, okay.

1:05:56- So you can buy a XR and you don't miss out on the--

1:06:01- Oh yeah, look at that, wow.

1:06:04- And for those of you listening

1:06:05who don't know what I'm talking about,

1:06:06'cause one time a couple episodes,

1:06:08six months ago I mentioned this

1:06:10and I got so much email from people saying,

1:06:11"Oh, holy shit, that's the greatest tip ever."

1:06:14I had no idea.

1:06:15Is that on a modern iPhone with 3D touch

1:06:18when you're typing,

1:06:19this actually gets to the point we were talking about earlier with the trackpad support where

1:06:22you can 3D touch anywhere on the keyboard and it turns the keyboard into a trackpad

1:06:27where you can move the insertion point around whatever text it is you're editing. And if

1:06:32you touch again while you're moving it, it'll select text. Once you know to do it, it is

1:06:40a truly, I know it's a cliché, but it's a game-changing feature. You can do it now on

1:06:46non-3D touch iOS devices by holding down on the spacebar for a fraction of a second, and

1:06:50it's a fantastic feature.

1:06:51Well, there you go.

1:06:55We just paid for the…

1:06:57Before we go on, here's the other feature I wanted to mention with the Pixel cameras,

1:07:02and it seems very cool.

1:07:03It's called motion autofocus.

1:07:05So you compose your shot, and you tap and hold on the subject.

1:07:09Let's say it's a dog or somebody at Google actually went to a concert the night before

1:07:14and shot, it was a great little video, really cool,

1:07:19but you can tap on the subject,

1:07:22and then once you tap on it, if the subject moves around,

1:07:25the focus stays on that person as they move around,

1:07:29using artificial intelligence to identify what it is.

1:07:33So for a moving subject, it's absolutely,

1:07:36it seems absolutely amazing, and once you see it,

1:07:38you think, oh my God, every camera should have this.

1:07:41And again, like you said, where it's Google and Apple

1:07:44were inventing these things and the camera companies seem to be just leaving, leaving,

1:07:50leaving all this stuff on the table.

1:07:52Yeah, this is exactly what I need on my Fuji. So right, cool. All right. Great. Fuji is

1:07:59probably the closest in my opinion. I'm not really, I can't say I'm a camera expert, but

1:08:03I think Fuji of the major camera companies is the company that seems to me to be most

1:08:07taking seriously the world of computational photography. Maybe I'm biased because I have

1:08:13Fuji X100s, which is now a couple years old. I'm sure the newest ones do even more, but

1:08:18it just seems to me like Fuji is doing more, more, more confidently moving towards the world

1:08:27of computational photography. And whereas like Canon and Nikon to me still seem to be treating

1:08:33digital sensors as like, it's like a 35 millimeter strip of film.

1:08:41I guess I'm looking in the wrong spots then. I need to do some more research on that because

1:08:47I buy Fuji for the glass and for the look and feel of the camera and also the amazing image

1:08:57quality. I have not noticed much of the computational photography, but I will have

1:09:01to do some reading on it now. I think compared to Google and Apple, they're still light years behind.

1:09:08And this motion focus tracking is just mind-blowing.

1:09:11But once you see it, it's very cool.

1:09:14You can do it.

1:09:15You don't even have to be a person.

1:09:16Like somebody at the hands-on area last week just did it, like showed their watch and then

1:09:22it like moved their hand around the frame.

1:09:23And as they move the hand around the frame, the little white square stays on the watch.

1:09:27It's really cool.

1:09:28I mean, and the best part of all this, it just seems intuitive.

1:09:30Like this is how photography should work.

1:09:33you know, ignoring all the technical constraints

1:09:36of the actual process of using sensors

1:09:39to take a digital image, like, you know,

1:09:42even the simplest thing of being able to zoom

1:09:45by pinching on the viewfinder screen on an iPhone,

1:09:48like, yeah, duh, of course that's how

1:09:50a photo feature should work, so.

1:09:53- What else is Google doing?

1:09:54They had a cool feature, I don't know how well this works,

1:09:56I mean, 'cause they obviously knew,

1:09:57they had like a pair of Nikes, and you point,

1:10:00I think it's a different mode you put the camera in,

1:10:02but you put it like in ID mode, show the Nike's

1:10:06and then it immediately says,

1:10:07oh, these are the Nike Air Max, whatever, whatever.

1:10:11I have to, you know, I hope Panzareno doesn't listen to this

1:10:14but you know, whatever model of Nike this is,

1:10:18you know, it tells you exactly what model it is

1:10:20and gives you options for where you could go buy them

1:10:22right now and stuff like that.

1:10:24How widely that works with, you know,

1:10:27all brands of shoes and shirts and whatever else

1:10:30you might identify, who knows?

1:10:31but apparently it works great with like movie posters.

1:10:33So you pointed at a movie poster

1:10:35and tells you everything you wanna know about that movie.

1:10:38It's a pretty cool feature.

1:10:39All right, let me take another break here.

1:10:41Thank our next sponsor.

1:10:43And it's our good friends at Squarespace.

1:10:46Look, Squarespace makes building a new website

1:10:49as easy as it can possibly be.

1:10:51I honestly can't even fathom how you could get

1:10:54a custom made, custom designed website

1:10:56that you have complete control over

1:10:57in a way that is like less busy work,

1:10:59less fiddling, less tedium than Squarespace.

1:11:04And it really is soup to nuts.

1:11:06Everything from registering domain names,

1:11:08picking templates, adjusting the look and feel,

1:11:11actually being a CMS.

1:11:13So like if you're one of the preachers on your site

1:11:15is a blog or if you wanna host a podcast

1:11:17on your Squarespace site, you enter, you know,

1:11:19you actually, you know, the CMS for making a new episode

1:11:23or making a new blog post,

1:11:24all of that is right there in Squarespace.

1:11:27All of it is right there.

1:11:28It really is just a fantastic service.

1:11:32They've been sponsoring this podcast

1:11:34for as long as I can remember,

1:11:36and people keep signing up,

1:11:37and that's why they keep coming back as a sponsor,

1:11:39but it really is great.

1:11:42I say it all the time,

1:11:43that the next time you have to make a website,

1:11:44or even more importantly,

1:11:45if somebody, your friend or family,

1:11:47somebody comes to you and they don't know jack

1:11:49about making websites, and they know you do,

1:11:52and they come to you for help,

1:11:54get them started on Squarespace,

1:11:55and it'll get them out of your hair.

1:11:57And then everybody will be happier.

1:11:59You'll be happier because you're not building a website

1:12:01for them as a favor.

1:12:03They'll be happier because they're gonna get

1:12:04a terrific website and they're gonna have control over it.

1:12:07And if they need help, they can get help from Squarespace.

1:12:09They don't have to go to you.

1:12:10It really is a fantastic service.

1:12:12And you just cannot believe if you ever start

1:12:15doing view source on various websites,

1:12:17you just wouldn't believe how many websites

1:12:19on a daily basis you use that are Squarespace sites.

1:12:22Every time you see a new website from a cool new restaurant

1:12:26or something like that.

1:12:27If you do view source, I'll bet it's a Squarespace site.

1:12:29'Cause you know what?

1:12:30Like if you're opening a website,

1:12:31you know what you don't wanna do?

1:12:32You don't wanna screw around

1:12:33and waste weeks building a website

1:12:35and you don't wanna spend a fortune hiring somebody

1:12:38for tens of thousands of dollars to build one.

1:12:40You just wanna get your brand out there,

1:12:42get your menu up, tell people where the hours are.

1:12:44You could do it yourself on Squarespace.

1:12:46It really is super easy for non-technical users,

1:12:50non-designers even to build a really great looking website.

1:12:55website that works great, super fast, everything you'd want. Responsive designs, looks good

1:13:01on everything from phones to a giant iMac. It's really great. So check them out next

1:13:07time you need a website or somebody you know needs a website. If you sign up for a year,

1:13:13you get a free domain name registration. So start your trial today. You get a free trial,

1:13:17by the way. That's the other thing. You can build it and use it for a while, like 30 days,

1:13:22You don't have to pay a dime.

1:13:24When you do pay, go to squarespace.com/talkshow, just squarespace.com/talkshow and remember

1:13:30that code talk show, know the, and you will save 10% off your first purchase.

1:13:37So you can save 10% on that whole first year, save 10% and get the free domain name.

1:13:42That's squarespace.com/talkshow.

1:13:43- Kind of want to start bribing and or forcing all restaurants to just move over to Squarespace.

1:13:55- When there is a bad website for a restaurant, I think the exact same thing.

1:14:00- It's like half an hour out of my day just to find the menu or the reservation link or

1:14:05whatever.

1:14:06- Right.

1:14:07- Flash still?

1:14:08- Flash still?

1:14:10- I feel like restaurants always had,

1:14:13they were always flash.

1:14:15I would say there was no industry in the world

1:14:17that was more likely to have a flash player website

1:14:20than restaurants.

1:14:21I feel like they've gotten their act together

1:14:23in recent years.

1:14:24I feel, especially in new places,

1:14:25at least here in Philly, it seems like a lot of new places

1:14:28have pretty good websites.

1:14:29- Well, it's 'cause if you view source,

1:14:31they're pretty much all Squarespace now.

1:14:33There are a couple other tools that exist,

1:14:35but they're not as good.

1:14:36So, and you know, and I also feel like website, websites,

1:14:41it was like you could just do like a talk

1:14:43at like a web design conference

1:14:44about how bad websites for restaurants were.

1:14:47People want the exact same thing.

1:14:49For every time they go to a website for a restaurant,

1:14:52they want like three things.

1:14:54They wanna see the menu, they wanna know the hours,

1:14:58and they wanna know how do you make a reservation?

1:15:00You know, it's, and usually now it's open table,

1:15:04but just put a big button there so they can tap it

1:15:06and shoot them right over to OpenTable

1:15:07to make the reservation.

1:15:08But that's all people want,

1:15:10and websites used to hide all of those things.

1:15:14Like how could you have a restaurant

1:15:15and not put the menu up?

1:15:16That's what people want to know.

1:15:17Is there something here to eat that looks good to me?

1:15:20- Yeah.

1:15:22It's nuts.

1:15:25- All right, the Home Hub,

1:15:27that's the last thing from Google that I didn't talk about.

1:15:29It's like a little, you know,

1:15:31they've got a whole bunch of these,

1:15:33they're little speaker type things,

1:15:35and this one has a screen.

1:15:36I kind of-- - What do you think

1:15:39of these things, these screen speakers?

1:15:41Amazon has one, you know,

1:15:43we don't need to get into detail about Facebooks, but--

1:15:46- One of the things they mentioned very, very prominently

1:15:50was that they deliberately did not put a camera

1:15:52in this device.

1:15:53And I thought that's pretty interesting coming from Google.

1:15:56You could see Apple bragging about making a thing

1:16:00without a camera for privacy's sake,

1:16:01but I thought it was pretty interesting

1:16:04that Google did. I don't know about these things with the screen. I guess I kind of

1:16:12get it. I think that the Home Hub though is too small. That's my take because it's

1:16:20sort of like this, I don't know what the diagonal measurement of the screen is, but

1:16:24it's sort of like either a very, very small tablet, even smaller than an iPad mini or

1:16:30like the world's biggest phone, like the biggest phablet ever made. But if you're

1:16:36going to have it in your kitchen and it has a screen, I feel like people want to use that

1:16:40as a TV at some point. They want to watch video. They own YouTube and they definitely

1:16:46mentioned YouTube in terms of like, "Hey, you can talk to the thing and get it to show

1:16:51YouTube videos." But I feel like it's too small of a screen in a kitchen to be that.

1:16:56I feel like you want something more like the size

1:16:58of a regular iPad as a minimum.

1:17:01And then the other area where they showed it off

1:17:03was like as a bedside table dingus.

1:17:08And I don't feel like that makes any sense at all

1:17:10because everybody charges their phone next to their bed

1:17:12so they don't need a device that size.

1:17:14And in fact, Google even came out

1:17:16with their own little Qi charging pad stand

1:17:19that stands your iPhone up

1:17:21so it can serve as a bedside clock/picture viewer.

1:17:26So I don't get the home hub.

1:17:29I get the idea of having a screen on these talking devices,

1:17:32but I feel like if you're gonna have a screen,

1:17:33you want it to be at least like 10 inches,

1:17:36at least for use in a kitchen.

1:17:38I just feel like this one is too small.

1:17:40- Yeah, yeah, that's a good point.

1:17:42I've watched many '90s Cubs games

1:17:45on a four-inch tube TV in my kitchen,

1:17:48but you don't have to do that anymore.

1:17:51- I watch my iPad a lot.

1:17:54When I do watch video, it's often in the kitchen,

1:17:57'cause we only have one TV,

1:17:59and so I'll often watch baseball games on the iPad,

1:18:03and I just can't imagine doing it on a smaller screen

1:18:06than a 9.7-inch iPad.

1:18:07It's nice for me, and it's certainly, at 9.7 inches,

1:18:11it isn't something that you would be,

1:18:15it wouldn't be great for a communal viewing, right?

1:18:18It's sort of personal.

1:18:19It's like a nice size for you to watch one thing.

1:18:22You wouldn't really wanna have a group of four people

1:18:24staring at an iPad, but.

1:18:26- Yeah, and it's ambient, especially these kitchen things.

1:18:29I'm kind of interested in these.

1:18:31I don't own any of them, but in the Facebook one

1:18:33is its own kind of can of worms,

1:18:36but which does have camera that will track you around

1:18:40if you wanna do video conferencing on it.

1:18:43I think the idea of having kind of a purpose-built device

1:18:48that's just on in the kitchen,

1:18:50you don't have to go find the iPad.

1:18:54maybe don't have your phone with you.

1:18:57I think it's interesting, especially for ambient TV,

1:19:00like a sports game where you're gonna ignore 75% of it,

1:19:05but then maybe lean over and watch the at-bat

1:19:08or the field goal.

1:19:11But for looking at recipes or playing music or whatever,

1:19:17it's an interesting genre to me.

1:19:19I haven't spent my own money on any of them.

1:19:21I don't know if I will.

1:19:23To me it's like, okay, I have an old iPad

1:19:26that does a lot of that already.

1:19:28But I can see why Amazon and Google and Facebook

1:19:32are making them.

1:19:34They don't have to be the thinnest thing imaginable.

1:19:38They don't have to, in many cases,

1:19:40they're plugged into the wall,

1:19:41so they don't even have to have a good battery life.

1:19:44So it's kind of interesting.

1:19:47Kind of serves the purpose that the home PC

1:19:50may have once had, like the living room,

1:19:53computer where the family can each check their email or do things. You're not going to do

1:19:58your homework on it.

1:19:59Right. No, and the interface is interesting exactly along the lines you're talking where

1:20:04instead of being, I don't even know what OS it's running. I don't know if it's running,

1:20:08if it's Android under the hood. I guess I should have asked. That's a question I guess

1:20:11I could have asked. I guess it might be Android, but it's not Android like, it's not like a

1:20:17phone. You know, there's no home button and a screen full of apps and text that is meant

1:20:23to be held 18 inches from your eyes. Everything on it is big. The text is big and it's, in a way,

1:20:32even an iPad is still sort of, it can't do everything. You can't have an interface that

1:20:40works both 18 inches in front of your face and five feet away. And so for things like

1:20:48cooking instructions and stuff like that. The text is comically large compared to a

1:20:53phone, but it actually seems exactly right for something that might be well over an arm's

1:20:58reach away while you're making whatever it is you're making. I just feel like it

1:21:03should be bigger, I think. I don't know, though.

1:21:07I just don't know if this is the device that people all of a sudden decide they love

1:21:13and need. But I probably would have said that about the first Echo devices too and the smart

1:21:19speakers. And here we are and everyone has one now. So, and I use mine every day.

1:21:24Yeah, I, you know, that's funny. I digression, I guess, but we have like smart shades.

1:21:35Ooh, I need those.

1:21:38Oh, they're great. They're from Lutron and they're super quiet. And for a long time,

1:21:44we have buttons, little remotes that control them and they're okay. But it's really better when you

1:21:52issue voice commands and you can raise all of them like on our main living floor all at once.

1:21:57But we had it for a long time where we had the only integration that ours supported was Amazon.

1:22:05So we had to do it through the echo. And you had to give these exact commands. So to open

1:22:14the kitchen shades, it was, "Hey, dingus, turn on kitchen shades up." So the name of the scene

1:22:21was "kitchen shades up." And to make it happen, you had to say, "Turn on." So grammatically,

1:22:27that's a mess. Turn on kitchen shades up and then turn on kitchen shades down.

1:22:32And there was also this weird rule,

1:22:34and again, I'm not blaming Amazon.

1:22:36It might have been Lutron whose fault it was,

1:22:39and maybe with other things it would be better with Amazon.

1:22:44But not only that, but in your scene names,

1:22:46you couldn't use the words on and off.

1:22:50(laughing)

1:22:52And it's just, it was, and it's so much,

1:22:55so we got like the base station for the Lutron thing.

1:22:59It's just looks like a little like Wi-Fi router.

1:23:03But we got that swapped out

1:23:06with one that's HomeKit compatible.

1:23:08And I like doing this stuff through Siri so much better.

1:23:12And I know that all sorts of people think Siri's garbage

1:23:16and Alexa is so much better, but you can,

1:23:19in the Home app, you can like, it's so much easier to,

1:23:22A, it's way easier to program and to adjust it.

1:23:26And you can give it whatever name.

1:23:27And it's like with the Amazon thing,

1:23:29I could never, I honest to God couldn't figure it out.

1:23:31It was like, it's like once we had it set up, that was it,

1:23:34but I didn't know how to change it.

1:23:36But it still is sort of confusing.

1:23:38And Siri lets you speak to it so much more naturally.

1:23:41You can just, you know, name it, name something,

1:23:44kitchen shade, open the kitchen shades,

1:23:47and just say, you know, hey, dingus,

1:23:49open the kitchen shades.

1:23:51And you can say all sorts of things like,

1:23:54just, you know, open up the shades in the kitchen

1:23:56and it'll do it.

1:23:58It doesn't have to be the exact right command line style incantation.

1:24:02It understands natural language.

1:24:05But it was funny.

1:24:06I was confused and thought it was broken because I programmed it so that both our living room

1:24:12and our kitchen are on the same floor.

1:24:14And I made a scene called "Open all shades and close all shades."

1:24:18And then I would say, "Hey, Dingus, open all shades."

1:24:20And sometimes it would work and open them all.

1:24:22And then other times it would open every shade in the house, including our bedrooms.

1:24:27And it was because I named it was like I gave it a bad scene name because sometimes Siri

1:24:31would interpret it as this is the exact name of a scene you defined. I'll do it. And other

1:24:37times it was like, I'll open every shade I know about because you said open all the shades.

1:24:43Which is actually, it was almost like it was too clever. So I changed the name of the scene

1:24:46to like main floor shade, open main floor shades and close main floor shades. And now

1:24:51there's no more confusing. But I have to say that editing that stuff in the home app and

1:24:55iOS is so much nicer to me, way nicer and way more sensible and very visual in terms

1:25:02of, "Oh, I see. Here's the icons for all the shades that'll go up when I turn this

1:25:06scene on." It's super, super visual and really nice, and I almost feel like Apple

1:25:12doesn't get enough credit for how nice that is.

1:25:14Tom Bilyeu: Yeah, especially now that—and I haven't actually spent much time in the

1:25:19Siri, whatever the automator thing is called,

1:25:23the workflows.

1:25:24- Yeah, shortcuts.

1:25:26- Shortcuts, yeah, but being able to stitch

1:25:28all those things together really makes HomeKit compelling

1:25:32if you already have all the devices.

1:25:34- Yeah, it's a big if, but once you do,

1:25:36it's really pretty sweet.

1:25:38- Yeah, but even just like the Home app,

1:25:40being able to toggle that stuff without saying anything too

1:25:44can be useful.

1:25:46- Yeah, totally, absolutely.

1:25:49just open it up, hit a button, there it goes.

1:25:51- Yeah, much like live photos,

1:25:54I can imagine HomeKit being one of those things

1:25:57that just becomes quietly more and more popular and useful

1:26:01and the kind of thing that,

1:26:03I only have one smart light bulb,

1:26:06so that doesn't do anything,

1:26:07but when we move, we'll probably have a bunch of stuff.

1:26:10- Yeah, and I have to say, it was really pretty cool too,

1:26:15because at some point when we first bought these shades,

1:26:18we had to set up this Lutron app

1:26:20and we got an account with Lutron.

1:26:22But I haven't opened that Lutron app in over a year.

1:26:26In fact, I'll bet that on my iPhone XS,

1:26:29I'm not even logged in because I don't think

1:26:31I've, I haven't opened it since I got a new phone.

1:26:33But once you've got it configured,

1:26:35when you open the iOS Home app,

1:26:38it already knows about all these things

1:26:39'cause the Lutron app uses the APIs to say,

1:26:42okay, I'll report to HomeKit,

1:26:43here's everything I know about.

1:26:44And so you open the Apple Home app

1:26:47and all of the stuff that it can control,

1:26:49it's all just there.

1:26:50You don't have to add devices to home

1:26:54once you've configured them

1:26:55in whatever the app is for the thing.

1:26:57It's really, really pretty nice.

1:26:59And I feel like exactly what you said,

1:27:01that it's sort of, everybody was like,

1:27:04ah, you know, and there was that whole thing

1:27:05when HomeKit was first announced where,

1:27:07because they had sort of a lot tighter review process

1:27:12and security concerns,

1:27:15that there were hundreds and hundreds of things

1:27:17that you could control through the Amazon devices

1:27:22and there were a lot fewer for HomeKit

1:27:24because Apple had these more stringent things,

1:27:26but I feel like quietly they've gotten a lot of these things

1:27:31into the system.

1:27:31I don't know, it's something that if anybody blew it off

1:27:36years ago, it's worth another look

1:27:37if you haven't looked at it recently

1:27:39is what I'm trying to say.

1:27:40What else do we got here?

1:27:44We didn't talk about it. We were saving it. We were saving the Apple Watch Series 4.

1:27:48Yeah. Why don't we...

1:27:50Yeah, let's talk about it. It's like you said. We can fit it in with the new Palm phone that came out.

1:28:01Which is basically an Apple Watch with no band on it, right?

1:28:05Right. I linked to it on Daring Fireball. I guess I'll put it in the show notes. Dieter

1:28:09Bone, of course, who's the the palm guy, the palm guy. Love it. It's a it's so weird that

1:28:18somebody bought the name palm and put this on this because there's nothing palm like about it. It just

1:28:24says palm but it's not web os. It's android. It's mostly stock android. It's a little phone that

1:28:31Verizon is selling very heavily. Verizon, I guess, is a big part of it. I don't think it's even on

1:28:38any other carriers. It even has a little Verizon thing on the glass on the front, sort of subtle

1:28:43down at the bottom.

1:28:45Which in itself is, like as Dieter points out, is kind of messed up because Verizon

1:28:50arguably like sunk the Palm by not selling the Pre or whatever.

1:28:56Right. When Palm was worth saving and really was making very interesting products that

1:29:05just couldn't get traction for some reason, Verizon definitely helped sync them. And now

1:29:12they're selling a device.

1:29:13And now they're back with Steph Curry.

1:29:15Yeah, so it has a 3.3 inch screen, which is actually smaller than even the original iPhone.

1:29:21The original iPhone is 3.5. It's a tiny little phone. It obviously has smaller bezels than

1:29:26an old iPhone 2, so it's not quite corner to corner, but it's pretty small. It's certainly

1:29:32one of the smallest touch screen phones I've ever seen. And it looks adorable. But to me,

1:29:39the thing that is just like, what are they thinking, is that it's designed as a secondary

1:29:44phone. In the same way that with the cellular Apple Watch, you pay 10 bucks a month to Verizon

1:29:50so that you can have this second phone that technically has its own SIM card and phone

1:29:56but instead because it's paired with your main device, you're, you know, if you put your main

1:30:03phone away and you go out with your little new palm phone and somebody calls your regular number,

1:30:07the palm phone will ring and you'll talk to it on there and you'll get your text messages there,

1:30:12etc. It's like an alias to your phone as opposed to a second phone. Right. But what it's like,

1:30:19Like to me, having the cellular Apple watch is pretty cool in that regard.

1:30:25And especially now with the new watchOS, and now that third-party apps like Overcast can

1:30:34actually do podcasts from the watch, when I go jogging now, I don't have to put my phone

1:30:41in a ridiculous fanny pack underneath my shirt.

1:30:45I can literally just leave the house with just my watch and AirPods.

1:30:50And it's such a great AirPod feature, the way that if the AirPods are paired with my

1:30:54phone but I leave the house without them with my watch, they just automatically go to the

1:30:59watch.

1:31:00And it's like, "Okay, I'll just play the audio from the watch."

1:31:02And you don't have to fiddle around with anything.

1:31:04It just works.

1:31:05And I go to Overcast, play a podcast, and I'm listening to it.

1:31:09It's fantastic.

1:31:10And I know that if somebody calls me, I'll get the phone call.

1:31:13It's really a great feature, but I can't see I can't like having it on a watch having your watch be a secondary phone

1:31:20It seems like a great feature and I really do like it. It's definitely worth ten bucks a month to me

1:31:25Having a second phone not so much like it just doesn't make any sense to me. I

1:31:32Wish that they had just made a phone at this really tiny adorable size and made it good enough that it could be your main

1:31:41phone, that it has a great camera. That to me would be more of a statement in terms of,

1:31:48"Hey, how about we focus less on these 5.5-inch screens that absorb so much of our attention

1:31:54every day? How about you take a tiny little 3.3-inch phone and spend less time on it?"

1:31:59That would be more interesting to me. This idea of a secondary phone, it goes back to

1:32:04at Dave Morin from what was it? Path with his day phone and night phone. Anyway.

1:32:13Yeah. No, I, I have, I mean, I have no interest in this at all. I, I've found there's another

1:32:20company that it's called punked or punked that makes like, you know, uh, Android powered,

1:32:26essentially like candy bar phones, like all these things that, that are trying to, to like force you

1:32:33off of your phone, either for convenience

1:32:36or for time well spent, quote unquote.

1:32:40The idea that people are gonna spend another $350 for that

1:32:44just doesn't make any sense to me.

1:32:45Like it does not seem like, I don't know.

1:32:49The watch, I guess that's how much my problem,

1:32:52I think my new watch actually costs like $500,

1:32:54so here I am, a huge hypocrite.

1:32:57But that, again, to me, has different utility.

1:33:03Like it's a purpose-built device as opposed to having just a second smaller phone that doesn't have I

1:33:09Guess if you're on Android, maybe it's like if you're on an iPhone

1:33:13I don't know how you what just switch over to Android at nighttime or something

1:33:17I guess it's clearly meant for people who have an Android phone. It's not yeah, it doesn't it won't do I message either

1:33:23So, oh, yeah true, right? Yeah, that's why I was scared to put my SIM card into this pixel 3

1:33:29I don't want to mess up my iMessage.

1:33:32- Oh, I forget how that works now.

1:33:33That's why I bought a second SIM card years ago.

1:33:37- I'm gonna get a second SIM card for that.

1:33:39- Yeah, I got it at T-Mobile and it's great.

1:33:41I forget what I pay per month,

1:33:42but it really is like no nonsense.

1:33:45It's like 40 bucks a month or something like that.

1:33:47And the bill really is like 40 bucks a month.

1:33:50It's not like--

1:33:51- I kinda wanna try the Project Fi.

1:33:52- Oh, that's another Google too.

1:33:53- Google's thing.

1:33:54- Yeah, especially if you're gonna be popping it

1:33:56into Android phones.

1:33:57It's probably a good thing to try.

1:33:58- I don't know how easy that is to start and stop.

1:34:02- Yeah.

1:34:03- I don't really wanna keep paying for it.

1:34:05- Yeah, the T-Mobile one is great 'cause it's prepaid

1:34:08and you can sign up to automatically renew every month,

1:34:12but if I ever do wanna cancel,

1:34:14I would just go to their website, say I wanna cancel,

1:34:19and then at the end of the month,

1:34:21my SIM card will just stop working.

1:34:23So there's no contract, no funny business.

1:34:26It's really a great way,

1:34:27If you're gonna get a, it just seems so much easier

1:34:30than getting a sim, like a secondary quote unquote sim card

1:34:33from like the AT&T or Verizon.

1:34:36- Yeah, totally.

1:34:37Yeah, anyway, so the watch, yeah, so the Palm,

1:34:43I don't really have much to say about the Palm

1:34:46other than that, as someone who loved, loved, loved Palm

1:34:50for I don't know what, 15 years,

1:34:52like sad to see this era, but this too will pass.

1:34:57pass, I guess? I don't know.

1:34:58Yeah, it's such a, it's the saddest story in the entire,

1:35:03I'm gonna, to me, the iPhone marks the beginning of like a new era of personal computing. And it's

1:35:10very, it just seems so clear in hindsight that there's pre-iPhone and post-iPhone.

1:35:14And that is just, it's every bit as big a deal as like the Mac was for computing. And in the

1:35:22In the post-iPhone world, to me, the greatest tragedy is that Palm didn't make it because

1:35:27they were doing such interesting stuff with their user interface.

1:35:29I mean, Dieter never misses an opportunity to point out how many of the things, the new

1:35:36features of the iPhone X with the swipe up from bottom to go to a card view of running

1:35:42apps and all sorts of things that Palm's webOS was doing in 2008, 2009.

1:35:49It was.

1:35:50They deserve so many kudos.

1:35:51And it was a super attractive OS.

1:35:54It looked great.

1:35:55It was really, really well done.

1:35:56And I know there were a bunch of ex-Apple people at Palm.

1:36:00And I always said, like the Palm Pre,

1:36:05you could easily have gone back,

1:36:07if you took like a 2008 Palm Pre

1:36:10and went back 10 years to like 1997 in time

1:36:14and showed it to people and said,

1:36:16this is, you know, covered up the logos

1:36:17and said, this is Apple's cell phone from 10 years ago.

1:36:20everybody would say, oh yeah, definitely,

1:36:21oh my God, that's amazing, I can't wait to get it.

1:36:23And you could totally sell it as the Apple phone

1:36:26from 10 years in the future.

1:36:28'Cause just in terms of the system design

1:36:30and what it looked like, it just was so copacetic.

1:36:34- Curve corners. - Yep, curve corners.

1:36:36It just, you know, if you like Apple stuff,

1:36:40it was hard not to like the Palm stuff.

1:36:42And if anything, it was almost more of a classic

1:36:46pre-Steve Jobs Apple look and feel

1:36:49than the post Steve Jobs look and feel.

1:36:52There was, you know, it was almost more like

1:36:54the classic Apple, which I loved,

1:36:57and in many ways, you know, I was just looking.

1:37:01Somebody actually reported a typo on Daring,

1:37:04over the weekend, somebody reported a typo

1:37:06from October 11th, 2002 on Daring Fireball.

1:37:10- Excellent.

1:37:11(laughing)

1:37:12- So I said-- - What was it about?

1:37:13- It was just, I missed the word A.

1:37:14It was just like this, I don't, it was like this,

1:37:18this should have said like, "This is a big deal," and it just said, "This is big

1:37:22deal," or something like that. So I fixed it and said to them, "You've just broken

1:37:27the record for oldest typo ever," because I only started the site in August 2002, so

1:37:32it was like 10 weeks into Daring Fireball, and I just fixed it now. But I remember, and

1:37:41then it sucked me into reading old 2002 Daring Fireball articles. And a big theme back then

1:37:47all the various ways that Mac OS X was crummy compared to Mac OS 9. And to me, the Palm

1:37:53Pre sort of had that Mac OS 9 niceness in terms of no weird, fiddly things. I don't

1:38:05know. It's a sad story.

1:38:07I think 8.5 for me was the one closest to my heart.

1:38:12Yeah, probably for me too.

1:38:14- Could have just been the point of my life

1:38:16that I was at, I don't know.

1:38:17- I don't know, I also have a soft spot for system 7.5.

1:38:22I thought 7.5 was a really sweet one.

1:38:25Although it was the current version for so long

1:38:29that maybe it was like Stockholm syndrome.

1:38:347.5 was like-- - That's true.

1:38:36- 7.5 was the classic Mac OS that was like

1:38:41at the time when Apple was flailing with these,

1:38:45eventually all these efforts for quote unquote

1:38:47next generation OSs that never really even came close

1:38:51to seeing the light of day.

1:38:52And so therefore it just sort of sat around

1:38:55as the current version of Mac OS for a long time.

1:38:58But that's neither here nor there.

1:39:01Apple Watch Series 4.

1:39:06- Well, so to me the most interesting thing I've seen,

1:39:09- Well, and you posted the good links

1:39:11to the 9to5Mac story on making the Infograph face

1:39:16more useful, and I've got a couple of those utility apps

1:39:20that I had never heard of before, which is kinda cool.

1:39:23But to me, the most exciting thing is just this idea

1:39:27of the UI playground that is the Apple Watch face

1:39:30now that there's enough space to poke around

1:39:35and Steve, was it Steve Trout and Smith?

1:39:40Is that how you say his name?

1:39:42- Yeah, so I'll put a link to this in the show notes.

1:39:44I think I've got it here already, yeah.

1:39:45But Steve Trout and Smith, who is hacker extraordinaire,

1:39:49he's one of the, you know his name,

1:39:51he's one of the guys who sometimes finds things

1:39:55in beta OS releases of iOS that reveal

1:39:58upcoming hardware products and stuff like that.

1:40:00He's also a very, very talented programmer.

1:40:03But he's been on a kick since, if anybody is,

1:40:05by the time you listen to this,

1:40:07he'll be maybe closer to a week.

1:40:08But for the last maybe half a week or so,

1:40:12he's been, a recurring theme with Apple Watch

1:40:15is how come they don't allow third-party watch faces?

1:40:19There's apps, and then your app can provide complications

1:40:23that fit in these predefined, okay,

1:40:26there's a corner complication, monochrome,

1:40:31for the certain watch face,

1:40:32and then there's a corner complication on the utility face

1:40:35that is color and you provide,

1:40:38you get to use these APIs to make a complication

1:40:41for your app that provides data that fits

1:40:44in these little complication areas

1:40:46that are predefined by Apple,

1:40:48but you don't get, nobody's allowed,

1:40:50nobody but Apple is allowed to make watch faces.

1:40:53And that's been a source of controversy or debate

1:40:56ever since the Apple Watch shipped is,

1:40:58what is Apple thinking in this regard?

1:41:01Is it something they haven't gotten around to yet?

1:41:02Is it something they're on the fence over or are they like, "Hell no, we're never going

1:41:05to let people make watch faces."

1:41:09And if so, why not?

1:41:10But so rather than just talk about it, Stephen Troughton Smith just started making them.

1:41:16And it's not even like a hack.

1:41:17It's not really a watch face.

1:41:18What he's done is he's making apps and then he turned on the setting in the Apple Watch.

1:41:23I think you have, I don't know if you can do it on a watch itself or if you have to

1:41:26use the phone app.

1:41:27But there's a setting for last used app.

1:41:32And it's like, I think by default, it'll, you know, like when you raise your wrist,

1:41:36does it show you your watch face?

1:41:37Or does it show you the last app you were using?

1:41:39And I think by default, it's like after two minutes, it goes back to your watch face.

1:41:44So like if you're using, you know, a weather app or something like that on your wrist,

1:41:49and you tap around, you don't have to like quit it or go back to home, you can just lower

1:41:53your wrist and go about your day.

1:41:55five minutes later when you go to check the time it just goes back to your watch face.

1:41:59But what he's done is set it so that it always goes back to your last running app. And he's

1:42:05made these apps that look like watch faces. And so every time he raises his wrist, it

1:42:10just shows his custom app that shows a watch face. And he's literally, you're going to

1:42:18think I'm making this up, but he's made like a system where he can generate, he's got like

1:42:24a bunch of options for color schemes and dial schemes. He's generated like 65,000 of these

1:42:32things algorithmically by randomizing the colors and the options. Most of them look

1:42:39really cool.

1:42:40It is amazing. It is super cool.

1:42:42I'll put a link in. If you haven't looked at these things, it is really, really cool.

1:42:47One of the options he has is something that emulates the very clever—I've never seen

1:42:53anything like it just because it could only happen on a digital face. But the Hermes watch faces for

1:42:58Series 4 have an option where half the screen is one color and the other half is the other color,

1:43:06and the dividing line between them is based on the minute hand of the watch. So as time changes,

1:43:13the color scheme slowly changes over the course of 60 minutes. So he's replicated that and has

1:43:20literally like, I think that's how this started. Yeah. He was just trying to clone that maybe. I

1:43:24don't know. Yeah, but it's, it's, it's really awesome. I love it. Yeah. And the other thing

1:43:30he's doing, and they do look plausible because the one thing about Apple watch faces branding wise,

1:43:37and we're talking about analog style ones, ones with an hour hand and a minute hand.

1:43:41The one thing all Apple watch faces to date share in common is they use the exact same style of

1:43:48of hands, which I've actually asked around.

1:43:52When I was on the Houdini podcast a couple of weeks ago

1:43:55talking about Apple Watch, and I actually asked,

1:43:57'cause those guys know more about watches than anybody,

1:44:00I asked if there was a name for this style of hand.

1:44:02Like there's all sorts of watch lingo

1:44:04for like different style of hands.

1:44:05Like there's some that are called like fence post hands

1:44:09because they're like straight

1:44:10and then they have like a triangle at the end.

1:44:12Think about like a traditional Americana fence,

1:44:15you know, a picket fence.

1:44:17There's sword hands, like certain kind of hands

1:44:20that look sort of like a sword.

1:44:22But this style of hands doesn't really have a name.

1:44:25It's used, a couple of high-end watchmakers

1:44:28use hands like this, but everybody knows the look.

1:44:30It's sort of like a capsule with a little skinny thing

1:44:33at the end to connect it to the center,

1:44:35like an oval, these oval-shaped hands.

1:44:38He's, Stephen Troughton Smith's faces

1:44:39use Apple Watch's hands.

1:44:41Like he's somehow, genius that he is, fished out.

1:44:44He figured out where on the Apple Watch OS

1:44:46the hands are stored, and so he's not replicating

1:44:49their hands, he's using Apple's hands.

1:44:50- I didn't realize that, that's awesome.

1:44:52- Yeah, it's really cool.

1:44:53And then I actually play this very small role in this,

1:44:57I actually, 'cause I know him and I pinged him

1:45:00over the weekend, is his first ones,

1:45:04the proportions were slightly off,

1:45:06like his second hand stuck out over the,

1:45:10you know like on the, if you have a round watch,

1:45:12and Apple Watch, and there's little tick marks

1:45:15to mark the seconds, a bunch of the faces have them.

1:45:17The second hand should be exactly the radius

1:45:21of those tick marks so that the tip of the second hand

1:45:24exactly touches the tick marks as it goes around.

1:45:28His hands were a little bit too small

1:45:30and I helped him with a little bit

1:45:32of proportion sizing on that.

1:45:34It's just the sort of thing you don't really notice

1:45:35but then once he fixed it, he was like,

1:45:37"Holy crap, that looks so much better."

1:45:38It's exactly right.

1:45:39But these are amazing.

1:45:42- So the bigger question then is,

1:45:44Is this the kind of thing that Apple ever opens up

1:45:48or is that on purpose?

1:45:50- Yeah, I don't think they will.

1:45:52I think that they don't

1:45:53and I think it is definitely on purpose

1:45:55for a couple of reasons.

1:45:57And it's not gonna make Apple Watch users happy

1:46:00to hear me say that, but I don't think it'll ever happen.

1:46:03What do you think?

1:46:04I can give you what I think the reasons are.

1:46:06- Yeah, what do you think they are?

1:46:07- I think one, they don't want people

1:46:11to make ugly watch faces.

1:46:12And if they opened it up,

1:46:14there's pros and cons to opening it up

1:46:18because some of them would obviously be beautiful.

1:46:20I mean, we can see from Stephen Troughton Smith's work

1:46:23that some of them are really beautiful.

1:46:25And it would be so much more,

1:46:27so much greater variety in choices,

1:46:30but a lot of them, most of them would be ugly.

1:46:33And I don't think they want to allow that.

1:46:35I actually, I kind of know that the one watch face

1:46:40that is on Apple Watch that they are deeply ambivalent about

1:46:43is the photo's face, the one that lets you pick a photo

1:46:45of your own to put on a watch.

1:46:47And the reason they're sort of like,

1:46:49is that a lot of people's pictures

1:46:52they put up on their watch are ugly, and they don't like it.

1:46:55But they kind of knew, like, that's just the one thing

1:46:57that the story I heard is that knowing how people

1:47:00set their wallpapers on their phone and stuff like that,

1:47:02and how many people wanna have a picture of their kids,

1:47:04or their spouse, or their dog,

1:47:07and that's what they've done.

1:47:09It's the wallpaper on their computer.

1:47:11It's the wallpaper on their phone.

1:47:12It's just what people do.

1:47:14And so they go, "Oh, we gotta do it.

1:47:17"We gotta let people put a picture of their kids

1:47:18"on their watch if that's really what they wanna do."

1:47:20But that's the one face that can be ugly.

1:47:22Otherwise, and as many gripes as we've all had,

1:47:26Marco Arment had a great story this week

1:47:28talking about why all of, effectively,

1:47:31he started talking about Infograph.

1:47:34Like you said, with the "9to5" article,

1:47:36it was sort of like,

1:47:36"Hey, Infograph is overwhelming by default,

1:47:38but if you turn everything off and then just slowly start adding stuff back, you can kind of keep it sane.

1:47:43But ultimately... I'm very happy with how I have mine set up right now.

1:47:47Marco makes a very convincing argument that all of the analog faces for Apple Watch are dissatisfying in some way.

1:47:53Yeah. And, you know, you could solve that if you could open it up to third parties.

1:47:59But I don't think Apple wants to do that because they don't want to allow ugly watch faces.

1:48:03And I think the second reason is...

1:48:08It's probably even gonna be even less popular among people who are hoping to see custom watch faces on Apple watch is I

1:48:14Think marketing wise it's a huge they see it as a huge advantage that Nike and Hermes watches have watch faces that other

1:48:22watches don't have

1:48:24And that is true

1:48:25You know and some people said oh, it'll be a copyright nightmare because somebody's gonna make a knockoff Rolex watch face

1:48:31And then Rolex will sue Apple and stuff like that

1:48:33Like I don't think copyright's the issue because it's like people could make a fake Rolex

1:48:38Watch face for the phone. I mean you could do anything on the phone, you know, I mean, I I don't

1:48:43I don't think the watch is special in that regard

1:48:45But I just but I do think though that like the they don't want people like Steven Troughton Smith making these watches that give you

1:48:53the Hermes look and feel

1:48:55without

1:48:56Spending the money on an Hermes watch

1:48:58Yeah

1:49:00It's interesting like that the copyright stuff

1:49:04Yeah, every once in a while you see something in the App Store

1:49:07That's a clear copyright violation, but it seems to police itself pretty well like the App Store is not

1:49:13Terrible in terms of well, I don't know. I'm in the high side if you look for it. Sure

1:49:21You'll find stuff wherever but yeah, it's not you know, the way that things work is the

1:49:27What rises up?

1:49:30If you search I'm sure you can find Disney knockoffs or whatever, but it's not like it

1:49:36Those things can't become very popular before they get taken down. So yeah

1:49:40Yeah

1:49:42The Mickey Mouse face is another good example of that where there's obviously some kind of financial arrangement between

1:49:47Apple and Disney for the Mickey Mouse and the Pixar one and they're you know, they I think I think they enjoy I

1:49:54Don't know who's paying. I don't even know who's paying whom they're

1:49:57Like, who is paying? Is Apple paying Disney or is Disney paying Apple? I honestly—

1:50:05That's an excellent question.

1:50:06I don't know, but I feel like they don't want Universal making one for the minions without

1:50:14Apple's involvement. Just, you know, here you go, here's your minion's watch face. You know,

1:50:18they like having that control. So I don't think it's going to happen.

1:50:22- To me the argument would be out of functionality's sake,

1:50:26now that this watch face is basically becoming

1:50:30the equivalent of the panic activity monitor screen

1:50:34or whatever that, you know.

1:50:36- Status board.

1:50:38- Status board, yeah.

1:50:39I guess the info graph and the digital info graph

1:50:44provide enough of a canvas that you're more limited

1:50:48by what Apple allows you to do functionally

1:50:50than by how it looks necessarily or how it's laid out.

1:50:54But I could see a world of different possibilities

1:50:59of different configurations and features

1:51:04that a built-in watch face would never really support

1:51:08out of the box that could be potentially useful

1:51:10or interesting.

1:51:11But it's been interesting to see over the years

1:51:16what they allow you to customize and what they don't.

1:51:19Like on the iPhone, first you couldn't even set

1:51:22the background, now you can.

1:51:24So you can make your phone as ugly as you want it to.

1:51:26But you still can't custom configure icons.

1:51:31Apple is still the only, I mean, sort of,

1:51:34like Major League Baseball Apple let you change

1:51:36the icon to your favorite team.

1:51:40But I believe Apple is still the only calendar app

1:51:43that has the correct date in their icon.

1:51:46- Right, and the way that their clock app

1:51:49has an actual moving second hand.

1:51:51- Yeah, and is that just a battery and CPU consideration,

1:51:56or do they just not want to see,

1:51:58the way that Twitter stopped letting you use an animation

1:52:02as your avatar, do they just not want to imagine a world

1:52:06where every app icon is moving all the time?

1:52:09- Right.

1:52:10- So I could see them being, I could see a case where,

1:52:13obviously they haven't gotten to it yet.

1:52:15There seems to be not much,

1:52:18they definitely seem to be aware

1:52:20how useful the watch face is.

1:52:22Like it is clearly the most useful screen.

1:52:25So they're onto that.

1:52:28As to whether or not they let you as a developer

1:52:33decide how the things are laid out

1:52:37or the size or the functionality of them,

1:52:41you're right, it probably seems,

1:52:43That seems like two or three steps beyond where we're going.

1:52:47- And again, I don't mean to be a Debbie Downer here on this.

1:52:51I just don't think they want to do it.

1:52:53And if I, like as an outsider,

1:52:56somebody who just is a customer and has an Apple Watch,

1:53:00I kind of wish they would allow it because I would,

1:53:04I am vaguely dissatisfied with every single Apple Watch face

1:53:08and I feel like if third-party developers

1:53:12could make their own, I could get one that I think is perfect. And so, me as a user kind

1:53:18of wishes they would open it. But if I worked at Apple and it was my decision to make whether

1:53:23Apple Watch would open to third parties, I'd probably say no because I would selfishly—I

1:53:29would enjoy the fact that we have complete control over the watch faces. And I do think

1:53:34that it's because Apple sort of sees itself as a "real watchmaker," you know, that

1:53:41treat the watch a little differently than they treat other devices and they're a little

1:53:45bit more protective of what it looks like. Every single watch face that they provide

1:53:53is like they think that this is copacetic with the Apple Watch brand. And if they opened

1:53:59it up to all third parties, they'd lose that. So maybe the best case scenario—and

1:54:04I know Stephen Trouton Smith even said this on Twitter at some point over this thread—is

1:54:08is that what he hopes would be like a middle ground,

1:54:11where instead of like the app store,

1:54:13where there's 10,000, 10, 20,000 developers

1:54:16and they're all submitting watch faces,

1:54:17if Apple just picked a hand-selected limited third parties

1:54:22to be able to bless them with the ability

1:54:24to provide third-party faces,

1:54:27that that's an interesting middle ground.

1:54:29And Steven said that he'd be happy with that

1:54:31because if that was even possible technically,

1:54:34he could hack it and make his own.

1:54:38Like all he needs is for them to allow it at all,

1:54:42and then he could just make his own watch faces

1:54:44and it'd be fine for him.

1:54:46- That's funny.

1:54:46- Which cracked me up, really.

1:54:49So I could see them doing that, but I don't know.

1:54:53- You know, I also thought there would be more

1:54:55partners in the way that Nike and Hermes

1:55:00are partners by now.

1:55:01- Yeah, I did too.

1:55:02- I'm actually a little surprised

1:55:03how few official band partnerships there are

1:55:06and that kind of stuff.

1:55:07So I don't know, maybe they're keeping it tighter than before, but I also would not be shocked

1:55:11if next year, watchOS, what was it, five, six?

1:55:15Six will be next year.

1:55:16Has face kit or something like that.

1:55:18And even if it's limited in certain ways, like for example, I would be shocked if they

1:55:23didn't, if you make an analog face, I'm nearly certain they would force you to use their

1:55:28hands.

1:55:29Like their hands are the brand.

1:55:31Way more than, you know, typically typography is how you establish a brand.

1:55:36But like the Nike watch faces use Nike's font,

1:55:40Futura Condensed Bold, and they look very, very Nike,

1:55:44but they use Apple's hands.

1:55:46And it's just very, very interesting to me.

1:55:49And I even talked to someone that Apple,

1:55:52on the watch team who even talked about it,

1:55:53that they were super, they love their Mez partnership

1:55:57and the Nike partnership.

1:55:58And they're even inside the Apple Watch design team,

1:56:01they're just blown away by how,

1:56:03and so happy with the way that these,

1:56:06like the Nike faces can look both Nike and Apple watchy

1:56:10at the same time and that their Mez faces look so or Mezi,

1:56:13with their distinctive weird,

1:56:16but very distinctive typefaces

1:56:19that they use for the numerals.

1:56:21And yet because of those hands,

1:56:22it still looks very Apple watchy.

1:56:24- Yeah. - So I don't know.

1:56:29I wouldn't hold my breath on this,

1:56:30but it is this exercise that people are doing,

1:56:34making these apps that just act like watch faces

1:56:36is fascinating to watch.

1:56:37And it's just funny the way it just burst onto the scene.

1:56:40And now if you look on Twitter

1:56:41and look at like Stephen Trout Smith replies,

1:56:43David_Smith is making some too.

1:56:45Did you see the one he made?

1:56:47It was really, it made me laugh.

1:56:49Well, A, he made one that uses Roman numerals,

1:56:52like tells it, like a digital watch

1:56:54that uses Roman numerals.

1:56:55It just seemed like it was mentioned.

1:56:57- Just for you. - Just for me.

1:56:58I tweeted at him, I said, "You should be arrested."

1:57:01But he also made one that looks like the classic,

1:57:05going, just talking about classic Mac OS,

1:57:07that looks like the classic Mac OS stopwatch cursor.

1:57:10- Ooh.

1:57:11- It's just this super fat 32 by 32 pixel grid

1:57:14of black pixels on it.

1:57:15- Oh, nice.

1:57:17Ooh, I like that.

1:57:18- Super cool. - Yep, I like that.

1:57:21And so, I mean, hey, look,

1:57:23this is one of those situations where like, you know,

1:57:26the community could inspire Apple to change their approach.

1:57:31If they see the UI, I hate to steal your term

1:57:36for I don't know what, Twitter apps,

1:57:37the UI playground right now is in watch faces.

1:57:41So maybe they'll see them and go crap,

1:57:45I guess we gotta figure something out.

1:57:47- Ken Cascenda, who adds that the book

1:57:49that just came out recently, the Creative Selection,

1:57:53which is a great book.

1:57:55But he even tweeted, more or less in favor

1:57:57of allowing third-party watch faces,

1:57:59which is that the story isn't that much different

1:58:02than it is with apps with the phone.

1:58:04You get your brand new Apple iPhone and you open it up,

1:58:07and every single app is there, is from Apple,

1:58:11and it all meets Apple standards

1:58:12for how apps should look on an iPhone, and that's it.

1:58:16And then if you wanna go get third-party apps

1:58:19and you think that there's ugly apps,

1:58:21but you wanna use them, that's up to you.

1:58:23of, you know, and it'd be the same way with the watch face. We're here. We give you, you know,

1:58:2715 or 16 of these watch faces and they have a bunch of configurations and they're all approved

1:58:32by us. But if you want to go outside that box and start downloading third-party ones, that's up to

1:58:37you. We'll ship you a watch that meets, that we're happy with every, every single watch face, but

1:58:42we'll, you know, why not let people do it? And in the meantime, there is the complications themselves

1:58:50are—it's tricky. It's not really—this discoverability is pretty bad, actually, of

1:58:57good complications, which is why that 9to5Mac article was so useful. And really, there could

1:59:02be a whole micro website of just cool iPhone or Apple Watch complications, but it's a

1:59:10start.

1:59:11Yeah. What watch face are you using?

1:59:15I have infograph right now. I'm going to admit to something embarrassing. I still have a

1:59:21hard time figuring out what time it is with just the hands. That's actually very common

1:59:27though that's actually not unusual. I'm I get that because I remember as a kid, my grandparents

1:59:35had a clock in their kitchen that didn't have numbers and I was like, mind blown. How does

1:59:40anybody know what time it is? I was very proud of myself that I was able to tell time. I

1:59:46feel like I could tell time on a clock at a fairly early age and it seemed like an accomplishment.

1:59:54And then I'd go to my grandparents' house and I'd be like, "I have no idea what

1:59:57time it is. I have none at all." Without the numbers, I had no idea.

2:00:01Tom Bilyeu (01h00m 10s): In school, we had the round clock, but it

2:00:05had the numbers on it. And a lot of these faces just don't have it. But a lot of these

2:00:10just don't have it.

2:00:10By the way, I just noticed that the iPhone SIM tool

2:00:13looks exactly like the watch.

2:00:15- Oh, it does.

2:00:16- Hand, interesting, all right, good to know.

2:00:18- That is awesome.

2:00:19- So I'm using Infograph, is that what it's called?

2:00:23- Yeah.

2:00:24- And I have the middle,

2:00:27I still have the little calendar thing in the middle.

2:00:29I turned off the white background,

2:00:30I don't know why that's the default, that's terrible.

2:00:32- It is terrible, that is baffling to me.

2:00:35And it's so funny that it's the default,

2:00:36but Apple's, all of their product marketing shots

2:00:39and show it with the black.

2:00:40- Yeah, I don't get it.

2:00:42- I don't get that either.

2:00:44I almost feel like there must have been an argument

2:00:47inside the company and somebody won the argument

2:00:50and got the white one as the front face

2:00:52and the product marketing people were like,

2:00:54well, we lost that argument,

2:00:56but we're still not putting it on the box

2:00:58and we're not putting it on the billboards

2:00:59and we're not showing it in the commercials.

2:01:01(laughing)

2:01:03- Imagine the meeting.

2:01:04- Yeah.

2:01:05- Yeah.

2:01:06- So I have most of the stuff turned off, however,

2:01:10so I can, and there is an option to make the center

2:01:13a digital time, but the curse, it's with the second,

2:01:18it's not just the minute, it's the seconds,

2:01:21and the colons blink, and I'm not into that.

2:01:25(laughing)

2:01:26It was too flashy, too blinky, it made me feel like

2:01:30there was a blink tag on a website.

2:01:31- I appreciate, though, that you're,

2:01:34'cause it's true that once you start fiddling with it,

2:01:36Just the littlest thing like a blinking colon

2:01:38will drive you nuts on a watch.

2:01:39- I would actually pay five bucks for a watch app

2:01:43that has a complication that has a non-blinking

2:01:46or configurable digital clock.

2:01:48In the meantime, I'm using the world clock

2:01:53in the lower right corner with New York City.

2:01:56And so I can see what,

2:01:58the other thing is my sleeve usually covers my watch.

2:02:02So if I just creep the sleeve open over the right corner,

2:02:06I can catch the time without having to unsheathe

2:02:10the whole watch, which is kind of a nice little thing.

2:02:13I used to use the color face on the old ones.

2:02:17And that was the one, I had that similar setup

2:02:20where I could just peek out the kind of the far corner

2:02:23of the watch and see what time it is

2:02:24without having to pull my whole arm out of my sleeve.

2:02:27And then, you know, pretty simple.

2:02:29I still have the calendar thing on.

2:02:31I kind of like it, I kind of hate it.

2:02:33I don't really, like the showing your next appointment thing.

2:02:38It's sort of useful when I'm at the office

2:02:42and I want to see like what conference room

2:02:43I'm supposed to be in next, but it also is stressful.

2:02:47So I might lose that at some point.

2:02:48- I think that replacing like the 10, 11, 12, one, two,

2:02:53our tick marks with the text right along the outer rim

2:02:57is clever, but it's like too clever for me.

2:03:01I'm like, I got tired of that after a day.

2:03:04I was like, that's too much.

2:03:05- Yeah, I might lose that.

2:03:08Otherwise, I love the new weather thing

2:03:11where it shows you the range of temperature for the day.

2:03:14- Absolutely.

2:03:15- I do miss the, on the three, I used the Explorer face

2:03:20'cause it would show you the cellular signal.

2:03:23I do miss having a good description of the actual weather,

2:03:27whether it's raining or not.

2:03:30Some third, I don't know, I imagine like Dark Sky

2:03:34will do that, but I had trouble getting that to work.

2:03:36So I don't know.

2:03:37- Yeah, if you haven't tried it yet,

2:03:39an app that I would really recommend is Carrot Weather,

2:03:42C-A-R, like what Bugs Bunny eats.

2:03:44- Oh, I haven't tried that.

2:03:45- Carrot Weather is sort of a, it's very hard to describe,

2:03:49but it's a very, it's sort of a sarcastic weather app,

2:03:52and you can dial up, like, it's not really,

2:03:55the sarcasm thing, I probably would have really loved

2:03:58when I was a teenager, and it seems a little too cute

2:04:01by far now, but it is also a great weather app

2:04:04if you turn off the thing that makes it talk

2:04:08to you sarcastically.

2:04:09But the complications it offers are tremendous.

2:04:15The watch stuff, it's just, oh my God,

2:04:17it's really fantastic.

2:04:19So the 9to5 Mac guy had the humidity on his infograph.

2:04:23That's, he got that from Carrot,

2:04:25and it does the same thing as the weather

2:04:26where it gives you the range for the day.

2:04:29- Oh, cool.

2:04:29- So anybody's looking for some cool weather-oriented

2:04:32watch complications, check out Carrot.

2:04:34It's like, I think it's a free app,

2:04:36and you have to pay-- - Looks like it's five bucks.

2:04:37- You pay five bucks a year for a subscription

2:04:40to unlock all the watch stuff.

2:04:41It's a great, five bucks, Jesus.

2:04:43- Yeah. - It's really great.

2:04:44And it gives you so many options.

2:04:46You go to your phone, and it's just like, oh my God.

2:04:48You can set it up so that it's like,

2:04:51so you can have two of them, and it's like on Infograph.

2:04:55and if it's the lower left corner, it's humidity,

2:04:57and if it's the lower right corner, it's something else.

2:05:00- So cool. - You can specify it

2:05:02to the utmost if you wanna fiddle around with it,

2:05:06which of course I do.

2:05:07- Yeah, and to me, this is now inspiring a lot of ideas.

2:05:11Could I do a chart beat complication

2:05:14that shows the traffic on recode for the day

2:05:17or something like that?

2:05:18- Right. - How many of these little,

2:05:20and remember spark lines were a thing for five minutes?

2:05:24How many spark lines could I configure on this thing?

2:05:28And that can be really interesting.

2:05:29So I'm just getting started with that.

2:05:32I really love the possibilities that it allows.

2:05:36- And it is funny.

2:05:37It's funny how many ways you can configure just the,

2:05:39we're talking about wanting thousands

2:05:41of third-party watch faces,

2:05:42but it's funny how much time you can spend,

2:05:44especially to me, it just seems like on series four

2:05:48with the Infograph stuff,

2:05:49it's like you can really just sync 90 minutes

2:05:52into screwing around with your watch faces easily.

2:05:55And some of them have like 40 different colors

2:05:59to choose from.

2:06:00- Yeah, yep.

2:06:01- There's like 18 different shades of blue.

2:06:04- Yeah, it's-- - And I don't mind that,

2:06:05but it is, you end up, you do kind of end up scrolling

2:06:09with the Digital Crown an awful lot

2:06:11to go through every single color combination.

2:06:12- I think they're trying to match every band

2:06:14they've ever shipped or something like that.

2:06:16- Yeah, I think so.

2:06:17I think it's like, and it's like,

2:06:18they may only be selling 20 bands right now,

2:06:21but they have like color options from, you know, the spring 2017 collection. Yeah. Yeah.

2:06:27All right here. Let me take a break here and thank our third and final sponsor before

2:06:30we get any further, but it's, it's our good friends at trace Pontus trace Pontus

2:06:36cells, freshly roasted gourmet coffee, and it is shipped directly to you.

2:06:40Their coffee beans are roasted to order your order and they are shipped out immediately.

2:06:46So it's not like they roast coffee, put it on a shelf, and then it sits there for who knows how

2:06:49many days or a week or two weeks or whatever. They're roasting coffee every day. You place

2:06:54an order, you get freshly roasted coffee and it goes right to you and it makes a big difference.

2:06:59Coffee is a perishable item, I'm telling you. And it's like you can have weeks old coffee

2:07:04beans and it's not like it's undrinkable, but it isn't like having freshly roasted coffee.

2:07:10Trace Pontes coffee is all, it's named after the mountain range in Brazil and the race

2:07:16family. Our EIS has owned this family for generations. Uh, and they've been making this

2:07:21coffee for over a hundred years, a hundred years, three generations, this family. But

2:07:26for the most part, most of that time they've only been selling it in Brazil. Now they have

2:07:31trace Pontas and they sell this coffee all around the United States and it's great. And

2:07:35so what you can do, you can go to trace pon tots.com or some coffee. That's fine. You

2:07:41also go to Amazon and they encourage you to do it if you want to and buy it at Amazon.

2:07:46Just search for T. R. E. S. P. O. N. T. A. S. And it's just a storefront for them. So

2:07:51when you buy trace Pontes coffee at Amazon, it's not again, not sitting on a shelf in

2:07:56a warehouse at Amazon for weeks and weeks. Trace Pontas still does the fulfillment. So

2:08:00the coffee you get buying it on Amazon is just as fresh and shipped right from the same

2:08:04place as when you buy it directly from trace Pontas. It's just easier because you know,

2:08:08got the one click and they encourage you to do it. It's really good coffee so you can

2:08:14try some buy some get it see if you like it and that's great just like buying regular

2:08:20coffee but the other thing you can do is you can get a subscription you can get a weekly

2:08:24subscription a two week subscription get it every four weeks it's your choice you can

2:08:27change it at any time and when you sign up for one of these coffee subscriptions you

2:08:32you save 10% off every bag of coffee compared to buying it bag to bag. Uh, and listeners

2:08:39of the talk show get an extra 10% off by using the code, the talk show, all one word, the

2:08:45talk show at checkout at the trace Pontas website when you buy a coffee subscription.

2:08:50So you automatically save 10% just by buying a subscription. You save another 10% by using

2:08:54that code, you're saving 20% off your subscription and then the coffee just shows up at your

2:08:59house every day. I wish I had some right now. I drank it all before we started recording.

2:09:04Enter that code at checkout the talk show at trace ponntas.com. My thanks to them for

2:09:09making excellent coffee and for sponsoring this podcast. Oh, anything else on the watch?

2:09:17The only thing I had on the list to talk about was the big hack, which I don't know. Why

2:09:21don't we, why don't we, uh, why don't we do that? Yeah. I haven't done a show since this

2:09:26big hack thing came out. And I guess, sorry, I do have one more thing in the

2:09:30marriage. All right. We'll just get it out of the way. Yeah. I gotta say it,

2:09:35this idea that the cellular, you know, having, having LTE on your watch will

2:09:42let you leave your phone behind. Um, the first year of that, it didn't really

2:09:47work for me because I'd go walk the dog and realized three minutes in that,

2:09:53"Oh, it's actually kind of boring

2:09:54"to not have your phone with you."

2:09:56Like, "Oh, it would be nice to have Instagram

2:09:59"with me right now."

2:10:01But now that you can do podcasts

2:10:03and it just feels like the new Series 4 is fast enough

2:10:08that you really do have a responsive device on you.

2:10:12And not every app works.

2:10:14I don't know, half the time the Uber app

2:10:16doesn't look like it's working.

2:10:18I don't know if it's gonna work now or not.

2:10:19But it feels like we're finally getting to a place

2:10:22several years in now where this is a compelling device

2:10:27that is not going to replace your phone,

2:10:29but it's certainly part of the,

2:10:32whatever the quote unquote,

2:10:35this is kind of a silly jargon term,

2:10:37but like the personal cloud of whatever you're gonna have

2:10:39in the future, whether it is your watch and your glasses

2:10:43or your watch and your AirPods and some other sensors,

2:10:46like this is definitely, we're getting to a place

2:10:49where you can see the shifts happening

2:10:52It's a remarkable combination with AirPods. It really does feel that, and to me, it's

2:11:00exactly what you said. It's this watchOS 5. Maybe? I still have my personal Apple watch

2:11:05is still a Series 3, and I don't know how much a Series 4 definitely feels faster, you

2:11:10know. But my Series 3 still works just as well. I think it's mostly watchOS 5 and

2:11:18a somewhat recent Apple Watch, whether it's this year's new one or last year's.

2:11:22But yeah, the performance is there. I no longer, and again, maybe it goes app by app. I actually

2:11:28don't think I even have the Uber app on my watch, but like with Overcast, like it never happens

2:11:32anymore. Well, I'll go to launch Overcast and I get a spinner and it just spins and spins. And

2:11:37it's not like Overcast fault. It's like the system is just like, uh, the, I don't know,

2:11:43you know, that just doesn't happen anymore. It just launches and you hit play and it just pumps

2:11:47through your AirPods right away. And it just feels, it does feel like the future.

2:11:51Tom Bilyeu (01h00): And you go for a run, you start the Nike app,

2:11:55you start your run, you play a podcast, you change a podcast, you use Siri to download or stream a

2:12:02new podcast over the air, you get back, you stop your run, and nothing is lost. Like it hasn't

2:12:08accidentally knocked you offline or, and your battery still has the whole day's charge left. So

2:12:16I don't know, it just feels like we're getting somewhere

2:12:19with this and it's gratifying.

2:12:22- Yeah, the one thing I sometimes miss

2:12:23is not having a camera because it just seems,

2:12:26it's like sort of like the Murphy's Law type thing,

2:12:29like, you know, the way that if you drop buttered toast,

2:12:32it's always gonna land butter side down.

2:12:34It just feels like if I go for a run,

2:12:35something interesting is gonna happen

2:12:37that I wanna take a photo of. (laughs)

2:12:38- That did happen to me yesterday, yeah.

2:12:41- It's like, oh my God, I wish I had a camera.

2:12:42And then if I take my phone with me,

2:12:44nothing happens, absolutely nothing of interest.

2:12:46I don't spot any interesting things to take a photo of.

2:12:48But as soon as I leave without my iPhone,

2:12:50there's some ridiculous scene or something

2:12:53that I wish I could take a picture of.

2:12:55- Yeah, and I don't think that's coming.

2:12:57- Yeah, just form factor wise, it seems really difficult.

2:13:00- Just feels weird, but.

2:13:02All right.

2:13:04- All right, the big hack. - The big hack.

2:13:06- So that's Bloomberg's truly blockbuster story

2:13:12alleging that these servers from a company,

2:13:17what was the name?

2:13:18I have, who?

2:13:19- I don't know.

2:13:21- Elemental Technologies.

2:13:22And they're using, they make the servers

2:13:25and they're, they've formed--

2:13:27- Super Micro.

2:13:28- Super Micro, which sounds like such a made up,

2:13:30(laughs)

2:13:31sounds like such a made up name.

2:13:33- Well, it sounds like it was made up in 1987,

2:13:36which it probably was.

2:13:37- Right.

2:13:37I always thought Microsoft sounded like a made up name.

2:13:40Right?

2:13:41Microsoft was such a typical, just a typical 1979 company name in our industry, but Super

2:13:51Micro makes these boards and according to Bloomberg was shipping, somehow the supply

2:14:00chain got compromised and the Chinese, the government got them to put these tiny little

2:14:08grain of rice-sized chips on the motherboard that enabled all these superpowers where they

2:14:13could phone home and then they could effectively backdoor all these servers that were used

2:14:17on Amazon and Apple's data centers. Then the story got really weird because Apple and

2:14:25Amazon both said adamantly, "No, this didn't happen. We've been telling them. We've

2:14:30been working with them on this story for over a year and we've been telling them this

2:14:33didn't happen. We don't know of any incident like this and it's very, very strange. And

2:14:42nobody really knows what to make of it. The cynics, the people who are cynical about companies

2:14:45like Apple and Amazon are, you know, and I get it, but they're, they're, they're, they,

2:14:50I've seen so many people read Apple's and Amazon statement and try to find loopholes

2:14:55and be like, well, here they say, you know, a, b and c, but they don't say d. So maybe

2:15:00you know, that's their little wiggle room. But I don't think that's the case. Like if it turns out

2:15:04that the story is true, or mostly true, that it's fundamentally true, Apple and Amazon look terrible

2:15:10because they denied it, you know. And they even said things like, and we're not under a gag order

2:15:15because of that. Right. That was the one thing where it was like, No, we're not under a gag

2:15:20order. And they just denied it in a way that they never deny anything, right? They put posts on their

2:15:27their websites.

2:15:28And I've never seen them deny anything on the record in public like that before.

2:15:38And I think the situation calls for it.

2:15:43Not only are they being accused of being compromised, but in a way that makes it seem like they

2:15:49could be compromised again.

2:15:52This thing got snuck in under their watch

2:15:55and they're dummies and they fell for it and whatever.

2:16:00But I've never seen them deny it.

2:16:04Now, to me, the one thing is like,

2:16:07and it's kind of strange 'cause they were like,

2:16:10"Oh, more than 30 companies were affected by this."

2:16:13But I haven't seen much about any other companies

2:16:17since then. - No, and nobody,

2:16:19right, and nobody has come up with,

2:16:21it's been a couple weeks now,

2:16:23nobody independent security researcher

2:16:25has gotten their hands on one of these and said,

2:16:27"Aha, here's the chip."

2:16:29And part of what makes it,

2:16:30I think there's some egg no matter what on Bloomberg's face

2:16:34'cause I think it was a journalistic crime

2:16:37to illustrate the story the way they did.

2:16:40They have like the cover of the magazine that it shipped in

2:16:45had a fingertip with a little tiny chip on it.

2:16:48And it makes it seem as though that's the chip

2:16:51And then there's pictures of a motherboard

2:16:52and they show a little tiny chip on it.

2:16:54But that's, it's all just like hypothetical.

2:16:58- Right, yeah, fantasy basically.

2:16:59- Right, like these, but every,

2:17:01so many people reasonably and reasonably so

2:17:04came away thinking, oh, they even have a picture

2:17:06of one of these compromised motherboards

2:17:08with the chip on it.

2:17:09But that's not, it's just like,

2:17:10this is what it could look like, you know.

2:17:13It's very strange and to me, it's very telling

2:17:15that nobody has come up with one yet

2:17:17because they're even, you know,

2:17:18they even said 30 companies were hit,

2:17:21the company was selling thousands of these servers, so they're out there. And apparently,

2:17:26according to the story, they didn't even, the FBI didn't even tell everybody who was

2:17:30involved. Like, like they, they because they didn't want to, you know, it was an American,

2:17:35you know, that, that, according to Bloomberg, part of the story was that this elemental

2:17:39and super micro are American companies, and they didn't want to cause irreparable harm

2:17:44to their reputations or something. I don't know, it's all, but it's very, very telling

2:17:49to me that nobody has come up with aha here I'm you know, because some independent if

2:17:53some independent security researcher could come up and say here I found the chip on this

2:17:58board that you know, this company who you know, hired me, you know, I found it. And

2:18:05a lot you know, a lot of people have made the case that what they're saying they did

2:18:08maybe is technically possible, but it would be like the hardest possible way to do this.

2:18:13And that companies like Apple and Amazon really do things like photograph and their motherboard

2:18:19that come in and make sure that there's no funny business on them. Like it would be so much harder

2:18:24to detect if they did something like this in firmware, meaning the software that runs on an

2:18:30embedded chip so that the mother, right, so like you've got an uncompromised motherboard, and I've

2:18:36got a compromised one, but they're physically the same. The only difference is mine has bad firmware

2:18:42and yours has the right firmware, you know, that would be a much harder detect way to do it and

2:18:47would be easier. I would think it's just super weird that that because the story quotes three

2:18:56quote unquote Apple insiders who you know, that is one of those officials. It's very curious that

2:19:05they quote, quote unquote, Apple insiders, but that is also a very weird way to say it. Are they

2:19:10employees? Or are they some, you know, who are these people? Who are their sources that they

2:19:14blog for appleinsider.com. Right. It's very strange. So I have a theory about what is

2:19:20actually going on. Oh, I'd love to hear it. Well, my theory is that it is effectively

2:19:25just part of what's the word agitprop, A-G-I-T-P-R-O-P. It's just propaganda from the Trump executive

2:19:35branch who are trying to stoke the flames of the Chinese trade war, which is actually

2:19:40underway. It's not like a conspiracy theory to say that the U.S. is trying to engage in

2:19:45a trade war with China. If they say it, they come out and say, "Yes, we would like to start

2:19:50a trade war with China." Making China look bad and making it look like China is hurting

2:19:55good U.S. companies like Apple and Amazon all fits in the narrative that the Trump administration

2:20:02is trying to provide. People have asked me, "Do you think these Bloomberg reporters made

2:20:08the whole thing up. I mean, are they committing fraud? No, I don't think so. I mean, Bloomberg's

2:20:12a super reputable publication. I'm sure they did talk to national security officials and

2:20:18that the national security officials told them these things or, or said, Yeah, yeah,

2:20:22that's it. Because there was like a podcast that the one guy who was a named source came

2:20:27out on last week and said that he was talking to the Bloomberg report. He doesn't know anything

2:20:31about the specifics of this case. He was just giving them background information on what

2:20:34might be possible in a hardware hack. And then the story like everything he said that

2:20:39they might do like the story says they did do and he was like that's either I'm really

2:20:42prescient or something weird is going on here. So I think it was sort of like they got information

2:20:48from national security people who were just trying to get that story in the press that

2:20:52China is screwing around with Apple and Amazon and other companies servers and bad China

2:20:59and didn't really give him specifics and they tried to get specifics and then I got like

2:21:03some hypothetical things, ran it by them. And they're like, Yeah, yeah, that's it. Sure. Whatever.

2:21:08Because they just wanted the story out there. That's my theory. And to me, everything that's

2:21:12happened since fits with that. And knowing and this is the one thing I was thinking, like,

2:21:19there's, there's basically no situation in which Apple can publicly bad mouth China. Right. Because

2:21:28And that stokes the cynicism of people. That's why people are so cynical about Apple's reply as,

2:21:34"Well, of course Apple's going to say it didn't happen because they can't piss off China."

2:21:37Yeah. Not only as a place where a lot of people buy phones, but also with everything they have

2:21:45is made. If for some reason Apple had to stop doing business in China, there would be no more

2:21:51Apple for a long time. Right. It would be devastating to Apple.

2:21:56it's probably the single biggest danger Apple faces, or certainly uniquely to Apple, you know,

2:22:01that, that, you know, you know, the Chinese government is an authoritarian communist regime

2:22:06that can really do whatever they want at any moment, you know? So it's truly at this point,

2:22:13an existential threat to Apple, because, you know, at least, you know, maybe not existential,

2:22:19but it would be devastating, profoundly devastating, right? They would have to

2:22:23figure out how to move everything to Brazil, India,

2:22:26where, you know, in a matter of days,

2:22:29which is probably impossible, or at least super hard.

2:22:33- Or it would take years to rebuild.

2:22:36Years and billions and billions of investment,

2:22:39it would be very difficult, but--

2:22:41- So it's interesting how strongly they denied it

2:22:44while also not saying anything remotely bad

2:22:49about Chinese government or anything like that.

2:22:53It's weirdly specific about certain things

2:22:57that either are pure fantasy or had to have happened,

2:23:02or I guess there's a middle ground,

2:23:05but it just seems very weirdly specific

2:23:10about certain things.

2:23:11It's interesting to me that none of these bylines are,

2:23:15I don't think from their tech desk either.

2:23:17Like I think this is the DC desk or something like that.

2:23:21- Yeah, I think so too.

2:23:22- I don't know if the tech editors were involved in editing.

2:23:26I haven't been to a good New York media cocktail party

2:23:30in a little while.

2:23:31So I don't have the gossip on like who actually edited this.

2:23:35But still Business Week is arguably

2:23:39one of the highest standard publications that exists.

2:23:42So they're not, I would be really surprised

2:23:45if they kind of flubbed the,

2:23:48I don't know if they have fact checkers,

2:23:50but if they flubbed the diligence on it.

2:23:53- I just think it all comes down to the,

2:23:55they took, they bought a bill of goods

2:23:57from these national security sources

2:23:59whose goal was specifically just to fan the flames

2:24:02of a trade war.

2:24:03So they've got sources who told them

2:24:05the things they're saying sources told them,

2:24:06but I think the sources are the ones who were full of shit

2:24:09or exaggerating or were vague upfront.

2:24:12And then when asked, could it have been like this,

2:24:15that they were like, yeah, yeah, sure, whatever.

2:24:18You know, they just wanted to see the story in print

2:24:20because it makes China look bad.

2:24:22- Terrible, yeah. - Anybody who believes

2:24:23the story, it makes China look absolutely terrible.

2:24:26And of course, China's official statement was so cryptic.

2:24:29(laughing)

2:24:32Like they didn't do themselves any favors

2:24:34by issuing a statement that was sort of a non-denial denial.

2:24:39Like who knows what's going on in cyberspace?

2:24:42I think the Chinese statement

2:24:44literally used the word cyberspace.

2:24:45- Awesome.

2:24:46By the way, you have to look at the supermicro.com

2:24:50homepage. It looks like it was made on Adobe fireworks. This is a very 2002 homepage.

2:25:00Oh, I would say 1998. It's not even retina. It's all rendered in graphics and none of

2:25:04the graphics are retina resolution. So everything looks blurry.

2:25:08Has an amazing drop shadow that is cropped so you can see the hard edge on the shadows.

2:25:14I will put a link to the Supermicro website in the show notes. Boy, Supermicro, I don't

2:25:19if they've recovered when I checked it, they lost like their stock price took like a 50%

2:25:23hit. All right. I got, I'll put a link to that recode story in there too. All right.

2:25:26I guess we should wrap it up. We've gone on long enough. I don't really have much more

2:25:30to say about this big hack other than that. It's crazy. I don't either. We'll see. I mean,

2:25:35I'm surprised there hasn't been anything corroborating it or, or, you know, adding it. And they supposedly

2:25:43were reporting this for a year. So I don't know. Well, the thing that to me, you can't

2:25:48prove a negative, but it's very, very suspicious to me that we don't still have corroboration

2:25:53because supposedly it was thousands of servers and they're out in the real world for anybody

2:25:58who knows their shit around a motherboard to say, "Yeah, here it is. Here's one of these

2:26:04motherboards and here's this rogue chip." The fact that we haven't gotten that yet is,

2:26:09to me, very suspicious. Again, it doesn't prove anything, but as time goes on and if

2:26:13if it continues that nobody can show one of these compromised boards,

2:26:17it sure looks like a bogus story.

2:26:19Agree. Yeah. Dan, thank you for your time. Everybody can read your work.

2:26:25Your team's fine work at recode.net.

2:26:29Dot net dot net is where all the best domains are. Frankly, that is correct.

2:26:33And of course they can follow you on, on Twitter at from dome F R O M E D O M E.

2:26:38It's always good to see him. If I might plug one thing, of course you can plug.

2:26:42anything. I took the summer off because I was very busy at work,

2:26:46but I'm relaunching my travel slash credit card points

2:26:51newsletter slash blog at points party.com. Please sign up if you

2:26:56if you want a friendly guide to the complex world of chase

2:27:00Sapphire and MX platinum and American Airlines and all the

2:27:03alliances how to get the most out of your points, make them go

2:27:08farther have very posh hotel free hotel stays like I do around the world or sit

2:27:13in the kind of airline seats that give you pajamas check it out I am so glad

2:27:20that you've got your reinvigorated to do points party calm because I back at it

2:27:25it's it's the sort of thing that I really really care about but I don't

2:27:28care enough about to do the research and so what I want is you to just tell me

2:27:32what to do that's the plan I'm gonna do the research and yeah I should have a

2:27:37new newsletter out within a week or so. I can't wait. Well, everybody, I'll put that in the show

2:27:42notes as well, but at pointsparty.com, I highly recommend it. And Dan really does. He really does

2:27:47know this stuff. And so what I fall asleep reading every night.