Podcast Search

The Talk Show

227: ‘Little Q&A’

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Hey, it's your internet pal, John Gruber, trying something different, something new

0:00:05after 226 episodes of this edition of the talk show. It's just me today, no guest. And

0:00:13it's July 31st. I have two sponsors scheduled for July, sort of been remiss this month doing

0:00:24regular episodes. So I'm trying something new. It's just me. And I'm going to talk in

0:00:30your ear here. And for what to talk about, I tweeted this morning asking for questions,

0:00:39ask me anything more or less. And I am overblown. I thought I could knock this out in an hour,

0:00:45get all the good questions. One, I like a sort of a short one hour episode, get through

0:00:49all the questions. There's no way that that's going to happen. I have just spent the last,

0:00:54probably close to four hours sorting through the questions on Twitter. They're terrific.

0:01:02I've categorized them. I don't think there's any chance. I'd be lucky if I get through half of them.

0:01:07I think it could be really fun. So my thanks to everybody who asked questions. My apologies to

0:01:15everybody whose questions I don't get to. Maybe I'll do another episode like this, but anyway,

0:01:19it's just me answering your questions today on the talk show. And before I do,

0:01:25why don't I knock this out of the way and tell you about Squarespace?

0:01:30Squarespace has been sponsoring this podcast longer than any other sponsor I can think of.

0:01:37There's a bunch of repeat sponsors who I'm sure you're all familiar with, but Squarespace

0:01:42is the king, and I thank them for their continuing support.

0:01:46Here's the thing, though.

0:01:47I truly believe in Squarespace.

0:01:50I really do think that it is the best way

0:01:54for almost anybody to get a website off the ground.

0:02:01And it doesn't matter what type of website you're building.

0:02:04You could host a blog, you could host a podcast,

0:02:08You can put up a store, you can set up a portfolio,

0:02:13and you get so much customization.

0:02:17The main thing, I hear, oh, you go there,

0:02:20you get templates to choose from, and I start thinking,

0:02:22ah, you're gonna get like a cookie cutter site.

0:02:25You use Squarespace sites every day,

0:02:27and you don't even realize it.

0:02:28I do this all the time.

0:02:29The main reason I often find out

0:02:31that somebody's using Squarespace

0:02:33is I see a typeface that they're using,

0:02:35and I select it, and I go into the Safari web inspector,

0:02:38and start looking at the source code

0:02:39to see what typeface it is.

0:02:41This just happened to me this week

0:02:42with a company, a great company, local company here in Philly

0:02:45the Philly Bread Company.

0:02:47You can go to phillybread.com, see their website.

0:02:49They're using, which obviously, some version of Courier,

0:02:53but I could sort of suspect it wasn't like

0:02:56the system version of Courier,

0:02:58and it definitely isn't Courier new.

0:03:00So I went into the web inspector to see what they're using,

0:03:03and in fact, it is Courier STD,

0:03:05which is sort of a web-hosted version of Courier.

0:03:08looks great. It's a great look for their site. It's a great fit for their brand. Anyway,

0:03:12poking around the source code, guess what? It's a Squarespace site. Again, they're there

0:03:16making cool bread. They make the best English muffins. They call them Philly muffins. Oh

0:03:21my God, they are the best English muffins I've ever had in my life. You guys, if you

0:03:24don't live in, if you do live in Philly, see where you can get them. And if you don't live

0:03:27in Philly, you're missing out. But anyway, they're using Squarespace. It makes total

0:03:33sense because all they want to do is make great bread. They're, they're not here to

0:03:38website and spend a lot of time on it and maintain it etc etc. Squarespace is the way that you can

0:03:45make your website and just have no work. Just make it easy. It just runs and they handle everything.

0:03:54You can register your domain with them. They have the CMS so you can post new content. They also

0:04:02have award-winning tech support. The next time you need to make a website or and knowing the people

0:04:08who listen to this show, the next time somebody comes to you for help making a website, go to

0:04:14Squarespace, get started, give it an hour, give it even just half an hour and see how far you can

0:04:19get. You'll be amazed and it's really just a terrific product and service. Go there and you

0:04:28you get a free trial. I think it's 30 days. Get started. And

0:04:33then just remember this code talk show know that just ta l K

0:04:37sh o w. When you do sign up to pay use that code and you get 10%

0:04:42off. They let you sign up for a whole year at a time so you

0:04:45could save 10% on a whole year of Squarespace hosting just by

0:04:49remembering that code. talk show. Alright, let's get

0:04:53started. There's a lot of questions. Like I said, I don't

0:04:55I'm going to get through them all. First category is questions related to the new 15-inch MacBook Pro,

0:05:02which I've been testing now for about two weeks and pretty much doing all of my computing on.

0:05:08I've kind of thrown myself in knee deep. And let me issue this. This is a correction from the show

0:05:14I did last week with Marco Warmant talking about this. And I raved about Migration Assistant,

0:05:19a product from Apple that lets you get a new Mac, use Migration Assistant. You can copy over

0:05:24all of your stuff from another machine.

0:05:28I said it copied almost everything,

0:05:30except it didn't get my login items.

0:05:33Well, I ended up looking into this

0:05:34and it turns out that the login items,

0:05:38the things in the users and groups system pref panel

0:05:41that are apps that,

0:05:43and a lot of them are usually background apps

0:05:45that start automatically when you log in.

0:05:51A lot of the ones that I thought didn't get moved over, I looked at my source machine,

0:05:55which is my old personal 2014 MacBook 13-inch MacBook Pro. It turns out I looked there and

0:06:02the ones that I thought I had set up as login items weren't set up there either. And so

0:06:07I think what has happened for a couple of these things like TextExpander and the Keyboard

0:06:11Maestro, Engine Keyboard Maestro is a great, great utility. And part of what makes it work

0:06:19is that there's this invisible process in the background and engine and it has to be

0:06:22running otherwise the keyboard maestro doesn't work.

0:06:26Another one that I didn't think moved over was a great little background service called

0:06:29Fast Scripts by Daniel Jalkett. Fast Scripts is like a system-wide scripts menu that lives

0:06:36up in the menu bar and lets you have these Apple scripts, shell scripts, anything like

0:06:42that. You can run them anywhere in the system. Love it. I don't know what I would do without

0:06:47it. Anyway, I think that these apps, they weren't in my login items on my previous MacBook

0:06:51Pro. And I think what was happening is that for you, because I do have the preference

0:06:55turned on to reopen previously running apps when I log back in. So if I restart the machine

0:07:02or log out and log in, I have the preference set to reopen whatever apps were already running.

0:07:06I think for years now, because I have that set, those background things have been relaunching

0:07:10automatically every time I restart or install a system update without being login items,

0:07:17were just relaunching because I have that preference on. So my apologies to the migration

0:07:21assistant team. It's even better than I thought because the couple of login items I did have

0:07:26on that machine did make it over to the new machine. So even your login items move over,

0:07:31they're definitely supposed to. And even on my machine, the ones that were there as login items

0:07:35did. So glad to get that off my chest. I felt very guilty about having having besmirched

0:07:43even one tiny aspect of migration assistant given how amazingly good it turned out to be.

0:07:49So here we go. Actbook Pro. James Atkinson asks, "Probably already asked, but does it get loud

0:07:58under load?" Well, that's the first question, so it wasn't asked already, James. That's a very

0:08:04good question. In my personal use, which is not very strenuous, I'm not doing video editing, I'm

0:08:11I'm not doing anything particularly heavy.

0:08:15The fan has never come on, so it is dead silent.

0:08:18And I've done some stuff that is somewhat stressful.

0:08:20I've imported images, shot in raw on my Fuji X100S

0:08:25into photos and had them process in the background.

0:08:29I have installed a bunch of stuff from Homebrew,

0:08:33some of which needed to be compiled

0:08:35by the Xcode command line tools.

0:08:38The fan never came on.

0:08:40The only thing that I've done in the two weeks I've had this machine where the fan came on

0:08:44is when I let my son Jonas play Fortnite on it. And yes, when he was playing Fortnite,

0:08:50the fan definitely came on and the machine definitely got hot. Was it loud? It was no

0:08:58louder than I would expect than it would be for a MacBook under duress, you know, that

0:09:06was being stressful. I don't think it was any louder than previous machines, probably

0:09:10And if anything the people who wish that the thing could run faster under load

0:09:15They probably wish that it got louder that it had a bigger thicker

0:09:19more significant cooling system

0:09:21You can definitely hear it when it's under load, but fortnight was the only thing I've done where that even kicked in

0:09:28Again I don't know how else to say it other than while the fan is running. I don't I don't know how it could be any quieter

0:09:38Next question is from somebody whose Twitter name is

0:09:41ironically racist

0:09:45Satirically, so hopefully that means they're not actually racist. I don't know but it's a good question

0:09:52in your opinion, do you think Apple should not will should a

0:09:57swallow their pride and reverse course with touch bar and

0:10:02and thickness of MacBook Pros, presumably.

0:10:05B, make a new top of the line Pro,

0:10:10MacBook Pro, presumably again,

0:10:11for pros that's thicker with legacy ports,

0:10:14hardware function keys, higher end components, et cetera.

0:10:19Or C, stay the course.

0:10:20So I think A and B here are actually the same thing.

0:10:23I mean, swallowing their pride and reversing course

0:10:26with the touch bar and thickness,

0:10:28and B, making a new top of the line Pro that's thicker

0:10:31is the same thing.

0:10:33So I sort of feel like it's A or B,

0:10:36are they going to make a thicker quote unquote pro

0:10:39or B stay the course?

0:10:40And I suspect, again, he's asking whether they should,

0:10:44not will, I think they will stay the course.

0:10:46Whether they should, I don't know.

0:10:51I think that a significantly thicker

0:10:56like gaming PC laptop style laptop

0:11:01is just not in Apple's DNA

0:11:02and I don't think it should be in their DNA.

0:11:04I don't think they should do it.

0:11:06A little bit thicker, what's the point?

0:11:09I know that there's a lot of,

0:11:12hey, the previous generation was thin enough.

0:11:15Nobody asked for them to make it thinner.

0:11:18Why not keep it the thickness that it was

0:11:20and have it run faster, et cetera?

0:11:24I get it.

0:11:25And there is something to this right where and I think Marco and I talked about this

0:11:31on my show last week where the current lineup of MacBook Pros I think it compared to the

0:11:40desktop is roughly analogous to the regular iMac 5Ks. They are excellent machines. They

0:11:49are premium machines. They are definitely not low end machines. These are premium personal

0:11:54computers with terrific displays excellent consumer to prosumer

0:12:01performance but Apple saw fit with the iMac to do the iMac Pro which is not

0:12:11just like a little name it's not just that they tacked on the word Pro to it

0:12:17and and anodized the aluminum in a space gray color and gave you a black keyboard

0:12:22keyboard and trackpad. Internally, they're using Intel Xeon processors, which are totally

0:12:29professional grade. They're using professional-grade RAM. They didn't just shoehorn those into

0:12:35the same enclosure. It is an entirely different—as much as they look the same cosmetically side-by-side,

0:12:42the cooling system in the iMac Pro is entirely different. If you took it apart, it's just

0:12:47an entirely different system architecture. And it is in every way that it is different

0:12:53than a regular iMac other than the cosmetic difference of the space great aluminum. Put

0:13:00that aside in every other way that they're different. They are different in ways that

0:13:03are truly for professionals who need high end computing performance. Is there such a

0:13:12need in the laptop lineup. And I kind of think there is, I do. There are people who use laptops

0:13:19for whatever reason, like, you know, developers who work at a place where everybody gets issued

0:13:26a laptop, that's just it. Or you move around, you know, and you, you know, even if you want a

0:13:31display, rather than get an iMac or an iMac Pro, you want to plug your MacBook into the external

0:13:37display or another example video and photo professionals who are doing stuff in the field,

0:13:44right? You're out there shooting photos in the field and you want to process them in light room

0:13:49or Photoshop or whatever you're using right there on the spot where you need a portable for that and

0:13:53you need the best performance that you can possibly get. And it's weird. I do. I mentioned

0:14:00this with Marco. I kind of feel that Apple has backed themselves into a corner marketing wise

0:14:06by calling all of the premium non super thin MacBooks quote unquote MacBook Pro. They've

0:14:11already used the pro moniker. So with the iMac, the iMac, again, the regular iMac five

0:14:19K's are amazing machines. They are not like baby computers. They are terrific computers.

0:14:24I use one from 2014 and it is still to my touch super fast. It is super fast, still

0:14:30has a beautiful display. I love it. But the iMac Pro is pro in ways that there is no corresponding

0:14:40MacBook Pro that is that much more "pro" than the standard machines. Is that reason enough not to do

0:14:47it just because they've already used the pro name for the MacBook Pros? That seems a bit silly,

0:14:51and I don't think that actually explains why they wouldn't do it. But I think it kind of belies their

0:14:57thinking on the matter that that they sort of see what they've got what they're shipping

0:15:01is pro. I don't know if that's a good answer for should they it's a little bit rambling

0:15:08but that's the best I can do. I got to move on. J Robert Lennon asks, Have you found a

0:15:14meaningful use for the touch bar or does it seem to you that it's going to go the way

0:15:18of the iPod Hi Fi? Here's a corresponding question from the other perspective. Taylor

0:15:23Alan asks, do you think there's anything Apple can do to change the narrative around the

0:15:28touch bar? I like it and find it useful for editing an email. The touch bar is one of

0:15:34those things, and I think it's as often the case, but the people who hate it, the people

0:15:38who wish that Apple had never done it or that they would just forget about it, brush it

0:15:43under the rug and go back to hardware keys. They seem to think everybody agrees on that.

0:15:49And I don't think that's the case at all. I mean, it clearly Taylor Allen here who asked

0:15:53question likes it. I don't hate it either and I personally wonder how much the the

0:16:01hate around the touch bar is specifically about the absence of a

0:16:04hardware escape key. I use the escape keys somewhat often. I miss it. I don't

0:16:12like the software one on the touch bar but I don't use it as much as some

0:16:17people. Some developers use it a lot just because there are text editors that

0:16:22developers use like them that pretty much you're hitting escape as often as you hit

0:16:26the spacebar that frequently and not having a hardware escape key is it can be a problem.

0:16:33So what I kind of wish that Apple had done with these new MacBook Pros that just shipped

0:16:38this month. I and I think I said this back in 2016 when I first reviewed these machines.

0:16:46I kind of wish that they had put a hardware traditional hardware escape key right up in

0:16:51the top left corner above the tilde and back to key just and made the touch bar go from

0:16:59that escape key over to the touch ID button on the other side. We already have a button

0:17:05up there in the touch bar, a real button. That's the touch ID sensor. That's a button.

0:17:09It's not part of the touch bar. I don't think cosmetically it would look bad if there was

0:17:14hardware escape key up there in the corner and they're already not using the part of

0:17:23the touch bar all the way to the right. That's what I kind of wish that they had done as

0:17:28a 2.0 touch bar and I wonder how much of the complaints that would alleviate. For me personally,

0:17:35everything else about the touch bar I like. I've never liked using the F1 through F12

0:17:40keys for things like brightness and sound. It's always seemed like occludes to me. It's

0:17:45always seemed ugly to me that they've got the F1, F2, all that printed on it, and these

0:17:51cryptic little icons for the brightness and stuff like that. They've seemed very fiddly

0:17:55to me ever since they've started doing it. And it seems to me very un-Apple-like to have

0:18:01those keys. I think that the touch bar is elegant. And for things like brightness and

0:18:05sound volume adjustment. I like the touch bar better than using hardware buttons. It's

0:18:12not perfect though, because you have to look at it. You can't do it by feel. So I guess

0:18:18if you really memorize where the volume keys are, you could get there without having to

0:18:22look. But I think this is more elegant and I like it. And I don't think it's going to

0:18:29go away. I don't think that Apple is going to abandon it.

0:18:33week on my show Marco mentioned a trick that you can use. You don't need third-party software

0:18:40at all. You can go into System Preferences, Keyboard, and there's a modifier keys button,

0:18:47and then it brings up a little alert where you can change what the modifier keys do,

0:18:51and you can change the caps lock key to map it to escape. And that's what Marco's been

0:18:56doing with these keyboards. I've turned it on, and I think it's pretty cool because I

0:19:01don't really use caps lock for caps lock.

0:19:03Using it as escape is a pretty good workaround

0:19:10and it's really smart.

0:19:11It even is smart enough to know once you've said,

0:19:13hey, use the caps lock key for escape,

0:19:16it no longer triggers the green light for caps lock.

0:19:18So it's not like every other time that you use caps lock

0:19:21for escape that the green light for caps lock

0:19:23comes on and off.

0:19:24It just never comes on once you've said,

0:19:26don't use it for caps lock.

0:19:28That's a pretty good workaround.

0:19:30Otherwise though, if you really want a high-end MacBook

0:19:34with hardware function keys, I think you're out of luck.

0:19:37I think that that chip has sailed.

0:19:38And honestly, I don't get it.

0:19:41I don't get what you'd want the other F keys for.

0:19:44Sorry.

0:19:48Josh Senners, editor at Tidbits, wrote,

0:19:53"I have a friend wanting to max out a MacBook Pro.

0:19:56"Is the i9 a good buy after the fix?"

0:19:59meaning the supplemental software update

0:20:01that came out last week to fix the weird bug

0:20:03where in some certain cases,

0:20:04the Core i9 high-end MacBook Pro

0:20:09actually was performing worse than the four core Core i7.

0:20:13Or is it too limited thermally?

0:20:16To go back to Joss's question.

0:20:18As far as I can tell,

0:20:19after the supplemental fix last week,

0:20:21the Core i9 is working perfectly.

0:20:24Again, I haven't run extensive benchmarks,

0:20:26but I've looking at the YouTube YouTubers like Dave David Lee, I think his name is who

0:20:32originally reported the issue where Adobe Premiere Pro was actually running slower on

0:20:38the core I9 and only got acceptable performance when he literally put it in this freezer and

0:20:46then got similar results running it not in the freezer after the supplemental fix. As

0:20:51far as I can tell, the supplemental fix actually fixed it. It was a bug. It was relatively

0:20:56simple in the core. I nine runs as fast as Apple promises. If you look at Apple's promised

0:21:03performance gains and you know, I think they say like up to 70% faster than last year's

0:21:07ion model. That's about right. I don't think the core I nine is magic. I think as Marco

0:21:15said last week on the show effectively, they, they really probably should have just kept

0:21:19it as a, they still should have called it a core. I seven. It's not really like a new

0:21:24They've added two cores, but they've stayed on a 14 nanometer process.

0:21:30And you effectively get the performance you'd expect going from four cores to six cores.

0:21:36And that's it.

0:21:37So if that sounds good to you, I would definitely recommend this machine.

0:21:40I think it's exactly what Apple describes it as.

0:21:42I don't think there's any thermal problem with it.

0:21:45And it's a good time to buy, because we know that Apple doesn't really update machines.

0:21:50not going to come out with new MacBook Pros three months or six months from now. They,

0:21:54you know, pretty much the best you can hope for is once a year. So if you have the professional

0:21:58need and you want the fastest possible MacBook that you can get, you should definitely get

0:22:03the core I nine MacBook Pro. It is. It is absolutely what Apple says. It's the fastest

0:22:08MacBook Pro you can buy. It's faster at everything. How much faster? It depends on how much you

0:22:15know, whatever the task is, how much it can be multi-threaded or parallelized, whatever

0:22:19you want to call it. But I think it is exactly as Apple describes.

0:22:24Cameron Williams asks, Apple still makes the best laptops, but would you say they're still

0:22:29great laptops? I say yes. Do I think they're perfect? No, but I don't know that they've

0:22:35ever been perfect. Probably the closest to perfect was around 2014. And you know, there

0:22:43are, you know, that's what I own and I love that machine. It's obviously slower than the

0:22:50current ones. It's four years old, but boy, that was as close to perfection as, as Apple

0:22:56could get, had great battery life, had a retina display, had a great selection of ports. And

0:23:03I think if there's any downside, there are two things that you, you know, people, they're

0:23:06all, they're both obvious and they've both been discussed to death, but the two things

0:23:10that are questionable on the current MacBook Pro lineup are the keyboard and the port situation.

0:23:17On the keyboard front, the reliability issue was a huge problem. Does this silicone membrane

0:23:25that they've started shipping as of this generation this month, does it fix the reliability problem?

0:23:31The jury's out. Only time will tell. I've used this thing for two weeks. I had it at

0:23:36Marco's Beach House. I mean, I didn't take it to the actual beach, so it's not like I

0:23:40actually exposed it to sand. But I've had no problems with any of the keys. But two

0:23:46weeks in, who does? I mean, the problem a lot of people have is it happens a year in

0:23:50or two years in or three years in. I expected a keyboard to work for years and years. There's

0:23:57no reason with a 2000 or 3000 or even more MacBook that you shouldn't expect it to work

0:24:03for years and have the keyboard work with perfect reliability. So the jury's out on

0:24:08whether this fixes that. In terms of the keyboard working as designed, you know, the big issue

0:24:14is the travel. In other words, these keys don't move as far down as the previous ones.

0:24:20But Apple's been doing that. That's that's been true forever. The keyboard, you know,

0:24:24Apple's laptops going back to the power book era have always moved in one direction in

0:24:29the long run. They've always gotten thinner and because the machines get thinner and lighter,

0:24:34the keyboards necessarily have to get thinner. I two weeks in, especially using this machine

0:24:42almost exclusively for the last two weeks, I'm getting used to the keyboard and to me,

0:24:47laptop keyboards are always a compromise. I mean, and I'm weird because I like to use

0:24:52an old Apple extended keyboard to mechanical keyboard

0:24:56with lots of travel and clicky feel

0:25:00that has a keyboard, a hardware keyboard at my desk

0:25:03that has way more travel and clickiness

0:25:05than anything that Apple sells

0:25:07or any modern keyboard really has

0:25:09other than new mechanical keyboards.

0:25:11And compared to that,

0:25:14compared to a real mechanical keyboard,

0:25:17no laptop keyboard ever has felt great to me

0:25:20in terms of what I think typing on a laptop compared to typing at my desk. And you get

0:25:26used to it. It's always a compromise. I find that I'm used to this. Even as someone who

0:25:32really likes a clicky keyboard with lots of travel, I can get used to this. And the longer

0:25:35I use it, the more it feels okay. But it's a personal preference. But I don't expect

0:25:44them to go back to more travel. I think once they go to this, if you don't like it, if

0:25:49if you think that the travel isn't enough,

0:25:51bad news for the future,

0:25:53'cause I don't think they're ever gonna go back.

0:25:55The port situation is the bigger problem, I think.

0:25:58And again, Marco Arman and I talked about this at length

0:26:02in the previous episode of this show,

0:26:04but the USBC ecosystem several years

0:26:09into these USBC-only MacBooks

0:26:12simply isn't where Apple surely expected it to be.

0:26:16You can't get a good USBC hub.

0:26:19You really can't.

0:26:20And there are tons of USB-A plugs and peripherals out there.

0:26:25And at the very least, I don't use a lot of USB peripherals,

0:26:31but even as someone who doesn't use a lot of them,

0:26:35even I already need a USB-A to USB-C adapter.

0:26:40Even right now, I'm recording this podcast

0:26:44using the 15-inch MacBook Pro.

0:26:46I need a USB adapter just to plug my microphone in.

0:26:49I mean, I guess I could buy a different cable,

0:26:52but I don't have that cable, so I needed the adapter.

0:26:55That's a downside, but I don't think it means

0:26:59that they're not great laptops.

0:27:00I still think they're great laptops.

0:27:01I think that they have tremendous fit and finish,

0:27:04absolutely beautiful displays,

0:27:07and overall, and great track pads.

0:27:14I think they're great laptops overall. I really do. Tom Bridge asks, does the true tone display

0:27:21actually matter? I think it does. And I think it's exactly the same on the Mac as it is

0:27:27on iOS, where for me at least true tone isn't something I notice. It's something I don't

0:27:34notice. But then when I look at a non true after I get used to it, when I look at a non

0:27:38true tone display side by side with a true tone display and indoor lighting, I am appalled

0:27:43by the non true tone display. I think it looks off. I it's again, it's just something that

0:27:49you don't appreciate until you see it till you get used to it and then go back to one

0:27:53that doesn't have it. I love that this machine has it and it's probably my single favorite

0:27:58thing about it compared to my personal 2014 MacBook Pro. Here's a question from Brandon

0:28:08Miller. I'm curious about the difference you see, meaning me, between night shift and true

0:28:14tone. You're pretty on the record about liking true tone, but to me they're pretty similar

0:28:19and make the screen look terrible. We have these great accurate screens and they make

0:28:22it look like someone peed on them. So that's interesting. But to me, I think there's a

0:28:29big difference between night shift and true tone. I believe it that Brandon here and I

0:28:33I believe other people can see the true tone effect and don't like it that they can tell

0:28:38no matter what the color is ambient color in the room is they can see that the display

0:28:44is doing something faking something you know doing a color shift to accommodate for it

0:28:50and it throws everything off I believe you that you see it and if you do see it I'm sure

0:28:53you hate it but I think the point of true tone is that for most people they don't see

0:28:59it and it actually makes the display seem more natural even though it's actually not

0:29:05showing true colors. Whereas night shift is purposefully shifting the color in a way that

0:29:11is supposed to be noticeable. You're supposed to be, you know, there's no way that people

0:29:15don't notice that there's everything is as a yellow greenish sickly tint to it. When

0:29:21I see somebody using night shift on an iPhone, I'm appalled. I often think, cause I go, I

0:29:26I don't have it turned on.

0:29:28Nobody in my family uses it,

0:29:29so I don't see it for weeks at a time,

0:29:31and then I see somebody using it,

0:29:33and I often, my first thought for a moment

0:29:35is always like maybe they dropped their phone

0:29:37and broke the display in some way,

0:29:39and now it shows weird colors,

0:29:41and then I think, oh no, no, they've got night shift on.

0:29:43Like to me, it looks so gross that it seems broken.

0:29:46Your mileage may vary, obviously.

0:29:50Other people might have the same feeling with True Tone,

0:29:52but to me, night shift is doing that on purpose,

0:29:54And I still believe that the,

0:29:56if it works with your eyes,

0:29:59if you feel like your eyes aren't bothered as much

0:30:01when you're using night shift,

0:30:03good for you and keep using it.

0:30:05But I think the pseudo science

0:30:06that it makes you sleep better is a crock of shit.

0:30:08I don't think that there's any truth to that at all.

0:30:11Again, if your eyes are comfortable, you can tell.

0:30:13But I think this idea that it helps you sleep better

0:30:15at night because you're not showing blue tones

0:30:17on the screen is a big pile of horseshit.

0:30:20Dimitri, no last name, asks,

0:30:24Do you think it's worth to upgrade from a 2017 base 15 inch

0:30:29to the new base model 15 inch with upgraded RAM

0:30:33and for two extra cores?

0:30:36Also, can fan speed be adjusted by the user?

0:30:39I don't think it's worth upgrading from a 2017.

0:30:43I really don't.

0:30:45Unless you're really RAM constrained,

0:30:48but if you're RAM constrained, you know it.

0:30:50If you really need 32 gigs of RAM rather than a 16 gig config, you know it, and I guess

0:30:57it is worth it if the work you're doing actually maxes out the RAM. Otherwise, I can't see

0:31:03that it would be worth upgrading from a 2017 model. I would just use that for a couple

0:31:09of years and then upgrade. Can the fan speed be adjusted by the user? No way. I mean, I

0:31:15don't even know where you would do that. I mean, maybe there's some kind of command line

0:31:18stuff you can do that's off the books. But it's certainly in terms of the controls that

0:31:23Apple exposes and system preferences, there's no control over fan speed. But I don't think

0:31:27you need to worry about it. The fan never kicks in for me. Joel Houseman asks, "Does the new keyboard

0:31:35with the membrane feel any different than the previous version of this horrible keyboard?"

0:31:40Tell us what you really think, Joel. I think it definitely feels a bit different.

0:31:46I don't have an extensive number of these side by side to compare with, but I did compare it to

0:31:51the regular just plain MacBook from 2017. And I remember using these, the first generation of it,

0:32:00or maybe that was the second generation and the 20s. I think the first generation butterfly was on

0:32:05the original one port MacBook. Second generation started with the 2016 MacBook Pros that switched

0:32:11to this design. And now this is the Apple's calling the third generation. I think it definitely

0:32:16feels better, feels different and better. And it definitely sounds better. There's no

0:32:22question about it. It's there's, there's, it's just quieter and it's a more pleasing

0:32:26sound while you're typing. It's it truly is a third generation keyboard. There's, you

0:32:31know, whether you like it or not, whether you think it's still a horrible keyboard,

0:32:36there's no question in my mind that it's more than just a putting a membrane on the old

0:32:40keyboard. It's a different, you know, it's definitely a generation ahead. It's like a

0:32:443.0. And I like it better. Jeff, no last name, asked why didn't Apple include a plug adapter

0:32:52extension given the cost is $2800? That's a great question. So for those of you, if

0:32:58you don't know, up until this up until they started switching to these USB C adapters

0:33:03for MacBook Pros, you're when you bought a new MacBook or MacBook Pro of any kind or

0:33:09or a power book going back to then,

0:33:10you'd get the rectangular power adapter,

0:33:12which by default has a little prong

0:33:15that you can open up and plug right into the wall.

0:33:17So the adapter's right in the socket.

0:33:20Or they'd ship an extensive, maybe a five or six foot cord,

0:33:24and you could swap, pop the little prong

0:33:27off the power adapter, put the extension cord on instead,

0:33:30and get an extra six feet.

0:33:32And they used to include that in the box,

0:33:33and they don't anymore.

0:33:38Presumably why they didn't include it is that Apple has determined or guessed or figured that most people don't use it

0:33:44and therefore they can save some money by not including it and

0:33:48Perhaps more than the cost of the extension cord itself

0:33:53I feel like the the big savings is in space in the packaging that the packaging

0:33:58I don't have the box in front of me, but the box for this

0:34:02I don't believe that that they could fit that power cord in the box

0:34:07the box that they're actually shipping these things in,

0:34:10they'd have to make the box at least a little bit thicker

0:34:13to include a power cord.

0:34:15And so I guess, you know, they're saving a bit of money,

0:34:21but as Jeff says for $2,800 plus,

0:34:24what could be an up to, you know,

0:34:26the config I'm using here is like a $5,000 config.

0:34:29And I think it goes up to like 7,000

0:34:30if you maxed out the SSD storage.

0:34:33For a multi-thousand dollar laptop,

0:34:36I think it's a nickel and dime move not to include the power cord. So I sort of feel

0:34:40like where Apple should meet users halfway. My idea would be that, okay, if you don't

0:34:44want to include it by default, because most people don't use it, don't. But anyone who

0:34:48buys one of these machines who wants one should be able to get one for free. Like maybe while

0:34:54you're buying online, they could say, would you like a power adapter cord? And if you

0:35:00say yes, it would ship in a separate little box. And if you're buying in the store, they

0:35:04could ask you as you're buying it and then just give you one. I really think it's ridiculous

0:35:08that you have to with a 20 to 3000 $4,005,000 laptop that you have to spend money to get

0:35:14a power extension cord. I'm personally a fan of them with my personal MacBook, I keep the

0:35:20extension cord on the power adapter, at least in my the one that I take with me in my backpack

0:35:26traveling because I usually don't need it. Usually the the length between the adapter

0:35:33in the mag safe thing is long enough for me,

0:35:36but often enough, I do need the extra length

0:35:40that the extension cord enables

0:35:42that it's worth keeping it in my backpack.

0:35:44So, you know, at least a couple times a year,

0:35:47I find myself needing it, and so it's worth having.

0:35:50And I do feel like it's sort of a nickel and dime move

0:35:52with these machines not to include it.

0:35:55Paul Sprangers asks,

0:35:58"A thicker MacBook Pro which has more ports,

0:36:01more CPU power, more GPU and battery life.

0:36:04Should Apple get on that?

0:36:05Well, this is sort of a repeat of a previous question.

0:36:07Best I can say is in theory, yes, but I don't expect it, no.

0:36:14Sam Armstrong asks, will Apple ever back down

0:36:19from their current laptop keyboard?

0:36:23I am planning on getting a Windows machine

0:36:25unless they make major changes.

0:36:26Back down is the wrong way to look at it.

0:36:29If you're expecting them to go back to the previous keyboard design,

0:36:32it is not going to happen. And I don't think it should. I don't think it's,

0:36:35I think that while there are some people who hated and hate this design and wish

0:36:39that they would, I don't think that that number is enough to justify it.

0:36:43In theory,

0:36:45would they ever go to a keyboard with more travel in a,

0:36:49in some future world where maybe with arm based max,

0:36:54the actual computer part is so much smaller and it maybe needs

0:36:59so much less physical battery inside the case that without making the machine thicker, they

0:37:04could put a keyboard in that has slightly more travel. In theory, they could do that.

0:37:09It would make me happy. I don't expect it to happen though. Why should one consider

0:37:16the core I nine is a question from a guy named mayor and may why you are no last name or

0:37:21no first name. I don't not sure which but why should one consider the core I nine over

0:37:25where the Core i7, given the core count is the same,

0:37:28is typing uncomfortable on the laptop when it gets hot.

0:37:31Well, the core count isn't the same,

0:37:35so I'm a little confused by this,

0:37:36because the Core i9 has six cores,

0:37:38and the Core i7 models have four cores.

0:37:41So if you need more cores,

0:37:42the Core i9 actually is worth it.

0:37:44I think it is also slightly faster

0:37:48at single-threaded stuff.

0:37:50But if you don't really have multi-core needs,

0:37:53If you don't do stuff that can be parallelized,

0:37:56you probably shouldn't buy the Core i9 model.

0:37:57You should save the money and get a quad core Core i7.

0:38:01When the machine gets hot,

0:38:03the only time it's gotten hot for me

0:38:04is when my son was playing Fortnite.

0:38:07And like most or perhaps every other MacBook

0:38:11I've used in recent memory,

0:38:13it really only gets hot in the area above the keyboard

0:38:17in that aluminum strip between the top of the keyboard

0:38:21and the display hinge.

0:38:23That's really the only spot where I see it,

0:38:27I feel it getting hot.

0:38:28The keyboard itself doesn't get hot,

0:38:30so I don't think it gets uncomfortable.

0:38:32Mikey Lauren asks,

0:38:39"Is 13 inch still the best compromise for you?"

0:38:43That's a very good question.

0:38:45I've been a fan of the 13 inch MacBook Pros for a while,

0:38:47and even before that,

0:38:50Before I was using a 13 inch MacBook Pro,

0:38:52I was actually using an 11 inch MacBook Air

0:38:54for a few years as my portable.

0:38:56Using this 15 inch though for the last two weeks

0:39:01has been eye opening in some ways

0:39:03in terms of really appreciating

0:39:06the extra screen real estate that it provides.

0:39:08I've done a lot of stuff with side by side windows,

0:39:13including putting together all these Q and A's.

0:39:16I actually solicited them by Twitter

0:39:19and I also said you could send them by email.

0:39:22As I said before, I spent close to four hours

0:39:24putting these questions together,

0:39:26and I only got through the ones sent by Twitter.

0:39:29I actually literally have not looked at my email

0:39:31in like 48 hours, so just going through Twitter.

0:39:36But putting them together, I had a BB Edit window

0:39:39with a bunch of open text documents based on categories,

0:39:43and Tweetbot over on the right,

0:39:45and I could drag tweets over from Tweetbot to BB Edit

0:39:50in a way without overlapping the windows,

0:39:52just side by side, full width for both windows

0:39:56that I don't think I could have done on the 13 inch.

0:39:58I mean, I could have, but something would have,

0:40:01the BB Edit window probably would have had

0:40:02been uncomfortably narrow.

0:40:03I do appreciate the size.

0:40:06For me personally though, because it's not my only machine,

0:40:09because primarily I, at home, and mostly at home,

0:40:13I use a 5K iMac at my desk.

0:40:16The portability advantages of 13 inch,

0:40:21that it's smaller, it fits in a smaller bag,

0:40:25it's a little bit lighter.

0:40:26You can use it in more crowded conditions

0:40:31like a coach seat on an airplane more comfortably

0:40:35than you could a 15 inch.

0:40:37I think for me personally,

0:40:3813 inch is still the best compromise,

0:40:39but I have to admit using this 15 inch for two weeks,

0:40:42I'm a little bit more torn on the issue

0:40:46than I was two weeks ago.

0:40:48But if I had to, if you said you have to buy

0:40:50a new MacBook Pro today, I would probably buy a,

0:40:54I would buy a 13-inch MacBook Pro.

0:40:56But it's close.

0:40:58Here's a guy whose name on Twitter is Squash Alcatraz.

0:41:04I don't believe that's his actual given name.

0:41:07It's probably a pseudonym, but if it is your name,

0:41:10You know, your parents probably owe you an apology.

0:41:17Which is the bigger dud? MacBook leather sleeves or iPod socks? I love this question. For those

0:41:23of you who don't remember, iPod socks were a real product that Apple came out with probably

0:41:28sometime around 2003 2004. But maybe 2003 I don't know. But it was in the spinning hard

0:41:33drive era of iPods when they were thicker, more like the size of a pack of cards. And

0:41:43one year they came out with new iPods and they also came out with these socks, which

0:41:46were literally like socks. And the idea was you could slip your iPod into it and then

0:41:51throw it in your backpack and not worry about the iPod getting scratched up. It wasn't really

0:41:55padded but it would certainly scratch proof and it was easy to slide them in and out.

0:42:00I believe that they sold for something like 19 or $20.

0:42:05Maybe they were $29 knowing Apple.

0:42:07I'm almost certain they weren't more than $29

0:42:10'cause I think that would have been scandalous.

0:42:12I had one, I had a gray one, of course,

0:42:15not really much for colors.

0:42:17I liked it.

0:42:18It was actually a useful way.

0:42:19I actually used it as intended.

0:42:21Like when I was throwing an iPod into a bag for travel,

0:42:25I would put it in the sock.

0:42:29Was it overpriced for a cotton sock?

0:42:31Even if it was $19, yeah, I guess,

0:42:33but I thought it was useful.

0:42:35So I would say the bigger dud

0:42:36are these new MacBook leather sleeves,

0:42:38because I think people did buy the socks.

0:42:40I don't think they were a hit.

0:42:42They didn't really, they came out with them once,

0:42:44only talked about them once, never talked about them again.

0:42:46But these leather sleeves are 180 for the 13-inch

0:42:50and $200 for the 15-inch,

0:42:52and I don't think they're worth it.

0:42:53I don't think they're good.

0:42:54I don't think they're, they don't feel premium to me.

0:42:58Somebody last week after Marco and I laughed about this thing on the show last week, somebody

0:43:06pointed me to a company called Saddleback Leather and they make leather sleeves for

0:43:11Mac books and I haven't touched them but they certainly look like better leather and they

0:43:16have like a lifetime guarantee or a hundred year guarantee. I mean literally like they

0:43:21guaranteed past your lifetime to last.

0:43:24And they're only $100.

0:43:26I mean, it really, it does seem like the prices

0:43:29on these MacBook leather sleeves are exorbitant.

0:43:31It doesn't really make sense to me

0:43:32to spend $200 on these things.

0:43:34I mean, I think the discussion would be very different

0:43:36if they were, I don't know, $70 or something like that.

0:43:41I don't expect these to sell at all.

0:43:43So I would guess the bigger dud

0:43:45is the MacBook leather sleeve.

0:43:47TJ Draper asks, "I9, do the fans run much? How loud?" Again, for me, only playing Fortnite,

0:43:55and that was Jonas playing Fortnite. Other stuff I do, they don't, and they're not that

0:43:59loud. They're no louder than you would expect.

0:44:05Samer Farha asks, "Is not having a physical escape key an issue, or is it fine in practice?"

0:44:11Well, I talked about this.

0:44:14I think it is an issue, but it is fine.

0:44:16And being able to map caps lock to escape, I think,

0:44:19does alleviate it to some degree,

0:44:20although you're going to have to change some habits to get

0:44:23used to that.

0:44:24If Apple sold upgradable storage and RAM, but thicker MacBook,

0:44:29would you consider it?

0:44:30This is a question from Gordon McDowell.

0:44:33If Apple sold upgradable, but thicker iMac,

0:44:36would you consider it?

0:44:38Their phones get thicker, but their laptops get smaller.

0:44:41Or phones get bigger, but the laptops get smaller.

0:44:44I think upgradable components,

0:44:48they're trade-offs, and that's the way the world used to be,

0:44:53that you could buy a machine

0:44:54and upgrade the RAM a year later.

0:44:56You could upgrade the storage at any time.

0:45:01You can't do that anymore.

0:45:02Everything's all sealed up.

0:45:05The RAM is soldered onto the motherboard.

0:45:07Uh, it is what it is. I think that it's the way of the future though. Uh, and, and we're

0:45:12never going to go back. Uh, and it, to me, it's not really a selling point. I do appreciate

0:45:17when I was younger and, and I was strapped for money. I do appreciate the fact that I

0:45:22could get the best machine I could afford, which wasn't necessarily the best machine

0:45:26period. And then later, uh, a year later, maybe two years later, I mean, at one point,

0:45:32I think I upgraded the RAM in my 1991 Mac LC like four or four years after I bought

0:45:38it, maybe five. I don't know. But I upgraded from four megabytes to 10 megabytes of RAM.

0:45:48I think that the LC had two megabytes built in and then there were two slots, which I

0:45:55to one megabyte SIM cards in and then I upgraded to two four megabytes Sims a

0:46:01years later for a total of ten megabytes of RAM which is funny because you know

0:46:08like a fart sound uses ten megabytes of RAM these days I appreciate that that

0:46:15you know and I'm sure you know there's always you know the students today who

0:46:19probably can't buy a maxed out MacBook and then years from now maybe they could

0:46:23could upgrade it in theory. So I, you know, I'm not saying that upgrade ability has no

0:46:31positive sides, but it's just the way the, it's just the way of the world today. And,

0:46:35and I think the way that machines have gotten thinner, the way that the, the unibody construction

0:46:40of these things it's just, just how it is. I mean, it's, it's no more, you know, I get

0:46:49over it is my answer. Nick here, author of the excellent pixel envy website asks, and

0:46:57he prefaces his question with in parentheses for real. In what ways does this meaning this

0:47:0515 inch MacBook Pro not feel like a spiritual successor to say the first 15 inch MacBook

0:47:11Pro or the power book G4? And is that a problem or is it simply evolutionary? It's a good

0:47:18I feel that it mostly does feel like the true spiritual successor to me the modern Apple laptop era starts not with the power book

0:47:25G4 well

0:47:27specifically the titanium power book G4

0:47:29Where Apple moved from plastic and you know black or very dark plastic

0:47:37construction to metal cases

0:47:40Titanium was obviously substandard in many ways it flaked it it you know

0:47:47It didn't last.

0:47:50It showed a lot of wear on the palms

0:47:53because it just wasn't adorable material.

0:47:55Aluminum clearly is Apple's go-to material for the last,

0:48:00geez, I don't know, what, 15 years?

0:48:05Maybe more.

0:48:08And the aluminum era, for Max,

0:48:16for iPods, for watches, they use it everywhere.

0:48:21And I don't see that coming to an end soon.

0:48:25I mean, eventually they'll move on to something, I guess.

0:48:28But they really, really use and have redefined

0:48:32the way that machines are constructed.

0:48:35I mean, you find aluminum laptops now,

0:48:37and it's the standard across the industry

0:48:39'cause they all copy Apple.

0:48:40But that's clearly, this is where they,

0:48:44To me, there's a clear evolution from the titanium G4

0:48:49to this month old 15 inch MacBook Pro.

0:48:53I think it is the spiritual successor in almost every way.

0:48:56And if there's any way that it's not,

0:48:58it's the port situation.

0:49:00Where especially for the 15 inch pro laptops,

0:49:05Apple obviously, and you know,

0:49:08it's obvious to anybody who follows the company,

0:49:10even remotely, Apple moves away from legacy ports faster

0:49:14than any other computer maker.

0:49:17You name the port, Apple is probably the first

0:49:21to abandon it, even if you include the floppy disk

0:49:24as a port, which I think is fair.

0:49:26Apple moves away from ports faster than anybody,

0:49:31but the 15-inch Pro laptops have always had

0:49:34what I would, at least by Apple standards,

0:49:36a generous assortment of ports

0:49:39that people would find useful.

0:49:41I think it's most telling that Apple had for years

0:49:45included an SD card reader in their Pro laptops,

0:49:48even in the 13-inch model,

0:49:50which is sort of an Unappley type thing to do,

0:49:54to include something so specific, but it's useful.

0:49:58And I think that given,

0:50:02if the USB-C ecosystem were in better shape

0:50:05and it was easier to get everything with USB-C by default,

0:50:10and if there were really good USB-C ports

0:50:13or hubs available that could power,

0:50:17supply power and multiple other ports,

0:50:19it might be a little different,

0:50:20but I feel like the failure in this

0:50:22is the failure of USB-C as a whole,

0:50:25and that's the one area where it feels,

0:50:27but it doesn't, it's not for lack of spirit, right?

0:50:31I feel like the spirit is there,

0:50:33it's just that the actual market

0:50:36has failed Apple in this regard.

0:50:38All right, that's the end of my MacBook Pro questions.

0:50:40Here we are, we're almost an hour in.

0:50:42I'm never gonna get to all of these topics.

0:50:44I've still got a whole topic on the Mac in general,

0:50:48not specific to the MacBook Pro, iOS,

0:50:52and including both the software and iPhone and iPad,

0:50:57a whole category on HomePod, Apple TV, entertainment,

0:51:01category on Apple in general,

0:51:04and then last, a miscellaneous and personal

0:51:07category of questions. There is absolutely no way. I'm one out of six categories down

0:51:12and I'm almost an hour in and I really thought that this whole thing was only going to last

0:51:15an hour. So I don't know what I'm going to do. If this proves popular, maybe I'll do

0:51:19a second episode with the same sort of format, no guests, just me answering these questions.

0:51:27But before I get to the rest of these Mac questions, let me take a break and thank my

0:51:31my other sponsor today. And it's a great company. I love this company. Casper Casper are the

0:51:39sleep experts on the internet. You spend one third of your life sleeping, so you should

0:51:44be comfortable when you do it. The experts at Casper work tirelessly to make sleep as

0:51:52great as it could be quality sleep services, mattresses, and a lot more. The original Casper

0:51:58mattress combines multiple supportive memory foams for a quality sleep surface with the

0:52:03right amount of both sink and bounce. Their breathable design helps you sleep cool and

0:52:09regulate your body temperature throughout the night. They have over 20,000 reviews and

0:52:13an average of 4.8 stars across their own website, Amazon and Google. Casper is becoming the

0:52:19internet favorite mattress. Now that they offer two other mattresses now in addition

0:52:24to their original the wave and the essential the wave is sort of their higher end model.

0:52:31It features a patent pending premium support system to mirror the natural shape of your

0:52:35body. The essential has a streamlined design at a price that won't keep you up at night.

0:52:42And they also offer a wide array of other products like pillows and sheets comforters

0:52:49Just just about anything you need to go on a mattress. They offer it and it's really

0:52:54great stuff. I've got one of the pillows now. I love it. I think we have the comforter upstairs.

0:52:59It's really, really great. It's just so comfortable and it really does help you regulate your

0:53:04temperature. You don't get too hot. Keeps you warm when you want to be warm. It's really,

0:53:08really great. All of their stuff is really great and everything they sell is designed,

0:53:13and assembled right here in the USA. Look, they sell these things at affordable prices

0:53:20for high quality premium mattresses. Their prices cannot be meet cannot be beaten by what you see in

0:53:26like a brick and mortar retail mattress store. It's just unbelievable for the quality that you get.

0:53:33And the reason is simple. They cut out the middleman and sell directly to you. They design it,

0:53:39they make it they ship it to you that's the deal uh hassle-free returns if you're not completely

0:53:46satisfied look that's the big deal you go to a mattress store you can try it you can sit on it

0:53:50you can see if you like it uh kind of gross in my opinion but you can at least try it out before you

0:53:55buy it you can't do that with an internet mattress but casper has you covered they have a hundred

0:54:00night risk-free sleep on it trial that's over three months you can spend three months with the

0:54:05the Casper mattress. And if you are not completely satisfied, go back to their website, say,

0:54:10"I want my money back." They'll give you your money back. They'll come, they'll take the

0:54:13mattress away. No hassle. It's just not like when you cancel your cable service and they

0:54:19give you the runaround and stuff like that. They make it easy. I've even heard from a

0:54:23listener or two over the years that they've been sponsoring who said, "You know, I bought

0:54:27this thing. It wasn't for me. I really didn't believe that it would be that easy to send

0:54:31it back and it really was. We've got a bunch of Casper mattresses here in the house. I

0:54:37think we're up to three and we love them. They're great. They really are. I wouldn't

0:54:41say that if it weren't true. They're really great products. I really like them and they

0:54:48come to you and they're amazing. How do they do that size box? We just got the Wave recently

0:54:54so we just got one. And again, it's hard to believe that that is a queen size mattress

0:55:00doing when it shows it up at the door. You just think that's just no way and opens up.

0:55:05There it is a full size mattress. Kind of amazing. They've got free shipping and free

0:55:12returns in the United States and Canada. A hundred day risk free guarantee and a special

0:55:21offer special offer just for listeners of this show. You get 50 bucks towards select

0:55:28mattresses by visiting casper.com/talk show. That's just casper.com/talk show. And remember

0:55:35that code talk show at checkout casper.com/talk show and that special code talk show and you

0:55:42save 50 bucks towards select mattresses. That's 50 bucks in your pocket. Terms and conditions

0:55:48apply. My thanks to Casper for sponsoring this show. All right, let's move on to questions

0:55:55about the Mac and then I don't know what I'll do. Ben Beard asks, what are your thoughts

0:56:03on future MacBooks with ARM processors? The ATP guys think it could happen as soon as

0:56:082020 related question. Jay dubs asks, do you think Apple will put a powerful, more powerful

0:56:15a series chip in the MacBook pros and use it just to power marzipan apps as a way to

0:56:21transition to arm and extend battery life. I don't think that that's going to happen.

0:56:29I think that putting a, a, a, an Apple arm chip in as the touch bar processor as a little

0:56:39side, a computer within the computer makes sense, but only in the sense that it's a peripheral

0:56:44in terms of actually using it to run apps. I don't think that that makes sense. I think

0:56:48Apple will switch to ARM.

0:56:49I think they are absolutely full steam ahead working on it.

0:56:53I agree with the ATP guys

0:56:54that it could happen as soon as 2020.

0:56:56I really don't think it could happen next year.

0:56:58I think 2019 is probably too soon.

0:57:00If I had to guess, my guess would be

0:57:04that they might announce it next year at WWDC

0:57:09to get developers on board

0:57:10with recompiling their apps for ARM,

0:57:12which shouldn't be too big of a problem, hopefully,

0:57:17'cause hopefully developers have seen this coming

0:57:18and haven't been doing anything Intel specific

0:57:21for years now, but who knows?

0:57:24But that's what they did when they switched

0:57:26from PowerPC to Intel is they announced it at WWDC,

0:57:30said it would start shipping next year.

0:57:34And early the next year, I think in like February,

0:57:36they came out with the MacBook Pro.

0:57:39They started with the MacBook Pro, but it just switched.

0:57:42And I think that's what they'll do again.

0:57:43It's not gonna be that you have an Intel processor

0:57:46and an ARM processor that's powerful enough to really run apps. There's no reason really

0:57:54for Marzipan to need an ARM processor. I really don't think there's anything, you know, there's

0:58:03it runs just fine on the Mojave beta, you know, running on Intel, the power savings that you might

0:58:14get from theoretically running marzipan apps

0:58:16on an ARM processor while everything else runs on Intel,

0:58:21I think is far outweighed by the cost that you'd incur

0:58:25by including both a premium ARM processor

0:58:28and an Intel processor in the same machine.

0:58:31That's just wasteful.

0:58:32And that's just not how transitions work.

0:58:34Transitions work by ripping off the Band-Aid.

0:58:36It's just, here you go, here's a new MacBook

0:58:39that instead of having an Intel CPU

0:58:40uses an Apple A series ARM CPU.

0:58:44That's how it works.

0:58:45And before you say it, yes, I remember,

0:58:49I think there was some kind of weird thing

0:58:51where you could get like a 68K coprocessor back

0:58:54when the PowerPC Max first shipped, I don't remember.

0:58:58But for the most part,

0:59:00once when Apple switched from 68K to PowerPC,

0:59:02it was just here's PowerPC Max.

0:59:04Everything is running either natively as PowerPC code

0:59:08or emulated 68K.

0:59:09when they switched from PowerPC to Intel,

0:59:11it was here's, this machine is now Intel-based,

0:59:13not PowerPC-based.

0:59:15And I think they'll do the same thing with Arm.

0:59:18Daniel Alm, ALM, he's the developer

0:59:21of the excellent timing app for Mac,

0:59:24just sponsored during Fireball recently, actually.

0:59:26It's a great app, it's sort of like,

0:59:28helps you keep track of what apps you're using

0:59:31and what you're working on without doing any kind of work.

0:59:35You don't have to log in, it's a great app, check it out.

0:59:38He asks, "Theory, next Mac Mini will essentially

0:59:42"be a rebranded Apple TV 4K with an A11 or A12 processor.

0:59:46"What do you think?"

0:59:47In theory, that sounds great, because the Apple TV,

0:59:54as it ships today, the Apple TV 4K is,

0:59:57is when you run, when you try to run benchmarks on it,

1:00:02very, if not faster than the currently shipping Mac Mini,

1:00:05which is ridiculously old.

1:00:06that's faster or as fast, and it's way smaller.

1:00:10So in theory, that would be great

1:00:13'cause it would be cheaper, it would be smaller.

1:00:16The performance is definitely there.

1:00:18But I kind of hope not.

1:00:22'Cause I really feel like the Mac Mini

1:00:25is so ridiculously outdated at this point

1:00:27that I really, really hope that they come out

1:00:30with a new one this fall.

1:00:32Not just faster, but it has to be smaller

1:00:35because as I've written on Daring Fireball recently,

1:00:37the Mac Mini isn't even mini anymore

1:00:39compared to these Intel NUC computers.

1:00:43I don't know if they pronounce them NUC or what,

1:00:45but there are Intel-based mini computers

1:00:50that are the size of an Apple TV or smaller.

1:00:52It's ridiculous that Apple is still selling the Mac Mini

1:00:56and calling it mini when it's way bigger

1:00:58than these things, ridiculously outdated.

1:01:01So my hope is that Apple ships a new Mac Mini this year

1:01:04in the fall. And if they do, as I said a couple of questions ago, there's no, I don't think

1:01:08that, you know, there's no way that they're going to switch to arm this year. So it would

1:01:12have to be Intel based. Peter Zignigo, Zignigo perhaps asks the discussion of Fortnite not

1:01:24being supported on Intel integrated graphics with Marco Arment is the fact that it runs

1:01:29"is great on modern iOS hardware,

1:01:31"evidence of Apple's lead in mobile graphics

1:01:34"and/or Epic's willingness to put in extra effort

1:01:36"for that market."

1:01:38I think indisputably, I don't think there's any question

1:01:41that the fact that Epic put the work in

1:01:44to get Fortnite running well on iPhones and iPads

1:01:48and doesn't have it, doesn't really,

1:01:51I think it might run on integrated graphics,

1:01:54but they definitely tell you that it's not great.

1:01:58and it isn't great.

1:02:00It certainly doesn't run anywhere near as well

1:02:02as it does on iOS hardware.

1:02:04Of course that's proof that,

1:02:06it's proof of the importance of the iOS market.

1:02:10And the iOS market is so big and so important

1:02:13that developers like Epic are willing

1:02:15to target it specifically.

1:02:19And the Metal APIs are only used on Apple platforms.

1:02:24It's not a cross-platform set of graphic APIs.

1:02:28And it's worth it for developers to support it,

1:02:33even though it's specific to Apple's platforms,

1:02:35because the iOS market is so big.

1:02:38And the Mac market has famously, infamously,

1:02:42I mean, I'm not gonna go on at length about this,

1:02:44but the Mac has never been known for gaming.

1:02:48It's always been behind PCs and gaming,

1:02:50and perhaps it's further behind

1:02:52than it ever has been at this point.

1:02:54You know, 'cause there's this whole concept,

1:02:57well, I talked about it on the last episode,

1:02:59where my son wants to get a gaming PC.

1:03:01The phrase gaming PC is now,

1:03:04it's just like a whole category.

1:03:06And it wasn't years ago.

1:03:08I mean, PCs were known to be better for gaming.

1:03:11People who were serious gamers did buy PCs

1:03:13that they'd configure specifically for gaming.

1:03:16But now it's just like an entire product category.

1:03:20There's no question about it that the Mac is not really relevant. And you know, the bigger tell to me

1:03:25isn't the fact that it doesn't run well on integrated graphics. The bigger tell to me

1:03:29is that bug that I talked about on the last episode with Marco, where when you run Fortnite on,

1:03:34I don't know if it's every Mac, but certainly on the 15 inch MacBook Pro, the first time you try

1:03:40to join a game, it literally takes, there's a bug where it takes 10 minutes before you get in. And

1:03:45and it just sits there saying loading dot dot dot.

1:03:48And the solution is to literally just sit there

1:03:51and wait 10 minutes and it lets you in

1:03:53and then subsequently you can join games

1:03:55with a regular amount of weight.

1:04:00A couple of people wrote to me

1:04:01and thanked me for mentioning that

1:04:02because they ran into the same thing

1:04:04and made the same assumption that my son and I made

1:04:07at first, which was that it was a never ending bug.

1:04:10Once you wait two, three, four minutes to join a game,

1:04:12it's a pretty safe assumption

1:04:14that you should just force quit the app and try again,

1:04:16and if you run into it, just give up.

1:04:19But this is actually, truthfully,

1:04:20a thing where you have to wait 10 minutes and let you in.

1:04:23So a couple people wrote to thank me for mentioning that

1:04:25because they run into it and just gave up.

1:04:28But the fact that that bug has been around

1:04:30at least since April,

1:04:31which is the first time I saw it mentioned on a forum,

1:04:33and they still haven't fixed it at the end of July,

1:04:36is ridiculous.

1:04:36I mean, if the PC version had a bug like that,

1:04:38they'd fix it the next, as soon as they possibly could.

1:04:41And the fact that they've let this languish on their Mac

1:04:43tells you everything you need to know

1:04:45about how important Epic sees the Mac

1:04:47as a platform for Fortnite.

1:04:49Mumper asks, "Do you have a preference

1:04:56"on minimizing Windows versus using the close button?

1:04:59"If so, why?

1:05:00"I still struggle to see the difference

1:05:01"or any reasoning to use one over the other."

1:05:04This is a crazy question to me.

1:05:05I personally don't use minimize at all.

1:05:10I think by default, when you minimize Windows on Mac OS X,

1:05:12it sticks the window into the dock

1:05:14as a separate little icon.

1:05:16The window itself becomes an icon in the dock.

1:05:18And then there's a preference you can turn on

1:05:19in the dock settings to have minimized windows

1:05:22effectively go into the app they belong to.

1:05:25So let's just say you're using TextEdit

1:05:28and you minimize a window if you have that preference on.

1:05:31It goes into, the animation shows it

1:05:34going into the TextEdit app icon on the dock

1:05:36and then to get back to that window,

1:05:40you click on the app in the dock to get the menu

1:05:44and you can choose it from there.

1:05:47I don't minimize Windows, almost never.

1:05:52I just don't find it useful either way.

1:05:55So I either have the window open

1:05:58and if I'm done with it, I close it.

1:06:00I don't minimize.

1:06:01The minimize feature could be totally broken

1:06:07and I wouldn't notice for weeks or months

1:06:10because I just never use it.

1:06:11Back in the day, in the classic macOS era,

1:06:16I thought that instead of minimizing what you could do,

1:06:20they called it window shade, and you could double-click.

1:06:23There was a button you could click

1:06:24in the top right corner of the window,

1:06:26or you could just double-click in the dead space

1:06:28anywhere in the title bar of a window,

1:06:30and the whole window would effectively window shade.

1:06:35The window would go up,

1:06:36and all you'd be left with is the title bar,

1:06:40and it was a really convenient way to get at something

1:06:43behind the window you were currently in.

1:06:45And one of the things that made it cool

1:06:47was because the title bar didn't move,

1:06:49you could double click the title bar

1:06:50to window shade the window and either look behind the window

1:06:53or drag something behind the window.

1:06:54But if you just wanted to look behind the window,

1:06:57the title bar was still there,

1:06:59still underneath the mouse pointer.

1:07:00So you could just double click again to open it back up.

1:07:04Part of what, to me, what makes the Mac OS X model

1:07:08of minimizing, which has been here ever since Mac OS 10.0

1:07:13back in 2001 or 2002, whenever the hell it shipped,

1:07:15is that you can't undo, you can't un-minimize a window

1:07:21without moving the mouse over to the dock,

1:07:24whereas the classic Mac OS window shade feature,

1:07:27you could double click, look behind, double click again,

1:07:30and undo what you've just done without moving the mouse.

1:07:36That was huge, huge, one of the many thousand paper cuts

1:07:40of ways that Mac OS X to me remains inferior

1:07:45to the classic Mac OS and UI design.

1:07:48But that's a can of worms, we can't get into here

1:07:52if we wanna finish any reasonable amount of time.

1:07:55Next question, Steven Fosket asks,

1:08:01do you think Apple really has an insanely great idea

1:08:04for the new Mac Pro, if so, what will it look like?

1:08:07First part of the, first question, yes,

1:08:09I do think they have a great idea,

1:08:10or at least they think they have a great idea,

1:08:12because I also think they thought

1:08:13the Trashcan Mac Pro was a great idea.

1:08:15But based on what they've told us publicly,

1:08:18they seem pretty clear that they see that it was a mistake,

1:08:25that the Trashcan Mac Pro was not designed

1:08:29around what's now obvious, the importance,

1:08:33growing importance of multiple GPUs and having a thermal envelope that could take significantly

1:08:44hotter GPUs than the trashcan is designed to take. So I think they've got their, I think

1:08:49they've recalibrated and now have their focus on where the highest of high-end performance

1:08:55computing is going in 2018, 2019. What will it look like? I have no idea. None. I don't

1:09:02I don't have any little birdies

1:09:04who've spilled anything about it.

1:09:06Apple's lips seem to be sealed on this.

1:09:08I haven't seen even any rumors

1:09:09about what it's going to look like.

1:09:11I have no idea.

1:09:12But I do expect it to be super high performance.

1:09:18I mean, to me, the most intriguing thing

1:09:21is given the super high performance,

1:09:23universally hailed, of the iMac Pro,

1:09:26what exactly, how much faster could the Mac Pro,

1:09:31to justify its existence has to be a lot faster than that.

1:09:34And that's pretty interesting

1:09:35'cause the iMac Pro is very fast.

1:09:36Bruce Wager, Wagger asks,

1:09:43"Is it believable that Apple can't make a good Mac

1:09:46"for less than $1,000?

1:09:48"Seems like their choice, not a question of ability."

1:09:51Of course, there's no question

1:09:52that they could make a cheaper Mac.

1:09:55I think that's always been true though.

1:09:56It's been true for 25 years or 30 years,

1:10:01however long the Mac is, what, '94, 2004.

1:10:05Yeah, 35 years, 34 years of Mac.

1:10:10Maybe back in 1984, they couldn't make a cheaper Mac.

1:10:16But certainly for the last 25 years,

1:10:19they could have if they wanted to.

1:10:21It's a marketing decision that they don't.

1:10:23And the fact that they make iPads

1:10:26that are performance compatible,

1:10:28certainly as performant enough

1:10:30that they could run Mac OS X if Apple so wanted,

1:10:33and they sell them for as low as $300

1:10:36with a very nice display,

1:10:39is proof positive that they could make a cheaper Mac

1:10:41if they wanted to, but they choose not to

1:10:42for whatever reasons.

1:10:44Vikram Nair asks, "How ridiculous is it of Apple

1:10:52"to sell the Mac Mini or Mac Pro

1:10:53"at anywhere near the full price as when it came out.

1:10:57"What is Apple doing here and why?"

1:11:00That's a good question, and I think it's often misunderstood.

1:11:03I think that Apple's pricing scheme for Macs,

1:11:07and the fact that the Mac Mini is years and years old,

1:11:11the Mac Pro is five years old or something like that,

1:11:14and they still sell them at the same prices

1:11:16as when they came out.

1:11:17That's because Apple sees the price

1:11:22as part of the branding and marketing of its devices.

1:11:27And it really only works if they update them regularly.

1:11:35When they don't update them regularly,

1:11:37it starts to get absurd.

1:11:39And in theory, absolutely,

1:11:40if they're gonna continue to sell years old Mac Minis

1:11:45and Mac Pros, the prices should be significantly lower today

1:11:48than they were when they came out.

1:11:50But they don't because they want to effectively

1:11:54protect those price points so that when new Mac Pros

1:11:57do come out or new Mac Minis do come out,

1:11:59they can keep them at the price that they want them to be at

1:12:02and not have it seem like a price hike.

1:12:06So let's just say if they had started,

1:12:08in an alternate universe where they had still,

1:12:13the Mac Mini was just as old today as it is in our universe,

1:12:17but they had lowered the price by $100 every year

1:12:21that it went un-updated.

1:12:23And then they come out with a new Mac Mini this fall

1:12:26and it goes back to the original price,

1:12:28it would seem like this huge price hike

1:12:30and they wanna avoid that.

1:12:31I don't think there's any magic to that.

1:12:39It is a bit stubborn and it is something that Apple

1:12:43and possibly only Apple can get away with

1:12:46in the PC industry because Apple's brand

1:12:51and user allegiance allows them to.

1:12:54But they just don't, their computers aren't commodities

1:12:56in a way that Dell computers are,

1:12:59and that raise and lower by fluctuate

1:13:02as component prices go up and down.

1:13:04They come out with a price,

1:13:05and the price is part of the brand of the device,

1:13:08and it stays the same even when it gets a bit ridiculous,

1:13:11as is the case with the Mac Mini and Mac Pro.

1:13:15Jackson Kernian asks, "Do we know any more about how and why

1:13:20"Apple got App Store skeptical Mac developers

1:13:23"back into the store as announced at WWDC?"

1:13:25I don't think there's any secret to it.

1:13:27I don't think there's anything that's on the record.

1:13:30But apps like BB Edit, which had been out of the store,

1:13:34now coming back, Panix,

1:13:35I believe it's Coda, not Transit, Transmit?

1:13:41I forget, I don't know which of Panix apps

1:13:44is definitely coming back to the store.

1:13:46I think it's Coda.

1:13:47And I know Rich Segal at Barebones,

1:13:52I know the guys at Panic,

1:13:54and I don't think there's any secret to it.

1:13:58It's just good old-fashioned developer relations.

1:14:01And I know there's a whole bunch of other apps

1:14:03that this is the case for,

1:14:04but I honestly think there's no secret to it.

1:14:07It's people at Apple who work in developer relations

1:14:11on a one-on-one personal basis,

1:14:12reaching out to Mac developers whose apps

1:14:16either were in the store and were pulled

1:14:18or were never in the store,

1:14:19and saying, "What do you need from us, from Apple?

1:14:23"What can we do differently?

1:14:24"What APIs can we change?

1:14:25"What can we change with sandboxing?

1:14:26"What can we improve?

1:14:27"What would make the App Store,

1:14:29"what would make you get back in the App Store?"

1:14:32Listening and then doing what needs to be done.

1:14:36Just good old-fashioned developer relations.

1:14:39And it's, to me, a great sign of Apple's belief and support of third-party Mac developers

1:14:48and a great sign for the platform going forward.

1:14:56Next question.

1:14:58Dave Swallow asks, "Do you think Apple will ever release a Mac mini, a new Mac mini to

1:15:05compete with an Intel and you see a small Mac that can be a home server. Well, I hope

1:15:10so. I honestly don't know what to think at this point, though. The Mac Mini is so

1:15:14old that I really hope they come out with a new one, and if they come out with a new

1:15:18one, I certainly hope it's a lot smaller, possibly cheaper. But at this point, I wouldn't

1:15:26be surprised if they never updated either. I don't know why they continued to sell

1:15:29it, though, if that's their goal. But look at what they did with AirPort hardware, where

1:15:33kind of stopped updating it years ago and continued to sell it long after they'd seemingly

1:15:39internally decided to no longer create new hardware.

1:15:46Next question, Kevin Van Harren asks, "Since you just found out Migration Assistant is

1:15:52decent, do you keep your documents/desktop in iCloud?"

1:15:57I do not, but it's not because I think it's very different.

1:16:02Assistant, I really underestimated. I really just figured based on old experience from

1:16:08the early 2000s, at least when it didn't really do a good job of moving everything I wanted

1:16:14from an old machine to a new machine and I found it to be less work to just start from

1:16:17scratch and add it by hand. I really underestimated the modern migration assistant. I think I

1:16:23understand exactly what when you when you decide to share your documents folder. In

1:16:28In other words, the documents folder

1:16:30at the root level of your home folder

1:16:32and your desktop in iCloud.

1:16:33I know exactly what it's supposed to do

1:16:36and whether it works seamlessly or not, I don't want it.

1:16:39I don't want my desktop, the files on my desktop

1:16:42on my various Macs to be shared between them

1:16:44and I don't want my documents folder

1:16:47to be shared between Macs.

1:16:49I have Dropbox.

1:16:50I also use iCloud storage within apps like Numbers

1:16:55within apps like Numbers, the iWork suite,

1:16:58what's it called, iCloud Drive.

1:17:05I use iCloud Drive, I use Dropbox,

1:17:07Dropbox, both of those.

1:17:10At this point, I don't know if I could do without either.

1:17:14And if I want a file to be synced between machines,

1:17:19I will either store it in Dropbox

1:17:20or store it in iCloud Drive.

1:17:23I like having a documents folder in my home folder

1:17:28on each Mac that is local to that Mac

1:17:30for when I do have files that I don't want to sync

1:17:33for whatever reason between machines.

1:17:35So no, I don't use that.

1:17:37And to me, syncing the desktop in particular

1:17:39just seemed, would just seem weird.

1:17:41The desktop clearly to me is supposed to be

1:17:44conceptually local to the machine.

1:17:46It would be very strange, I would find it very undesirable

1:17:49to have my document or my desktop sync between machines.

1:17:52Next question, trying to wrap these Mac questions up here.

1:17:57Michael Rockwell asks, do you expect Apple to transition

1:18:04the iMac to SSDs as the default option?

1:18:07It's a great question.

1:18:08I think that this is possibly a sign of the difference

1:18:13between the Tim Cook Apple and Steve Jobs' Apple.

1:18:18I think if Steve Jobs were still around,

1:18:19the iMac maybe already would be SSD by default, or SSD only. And the iMac Pro is SSD only.

1:18:32The advantages of SSD over spinning hard drives in every single regard other than cost, that

1:18:38you can get more storage for significantly less money with a spinning hard drive than

1:18:43than SSD. But the other advantages of SSD are so great in terms of reliability and performance

1:18:51and even the fact that they're dead silent are so great. And to me, that's what Apple

1:18:57computers, Apple products are supposed to be is great. They're so great that it's worth

1:19:02the premium you have to pay. If you really need more storage and you want to pay spinning

1:19:08hard disk prices, then you should have to—I think Apple should make you use an external

1:19:14drive. I believe Apple—the iMac should be SSD only at this point. So I definitely think

1:19:20it will be at some point, but I think the more interesting thing is that, to me, I think

1:19:24it should be already, and I think it would be if Steve Jobs were still CEO.

1:19:30Derek Martin asks, "Do you think it's possible that Apple could release Macs primarily

1:19:34powered by an Apple ARM chip, but which also contain an x86 chip for backward compatibility."

1:19:40I kind of answered this before. That's not how transitions work. I don't think they'll do that.

1:19:43I think that once they switch to ARM, it'll be all ARM and possibly with some kind of

1:19:49emulation layer so that un-updated apps that are x86 can still run even through an emulator.

1:20:01Saint Chris asks, "Were you a fan of tabbed folders in Mac OS 9 where you could pin a

1:20:05folder to the screen edge as just a title bar tab?" It was the central organizing principle of

1:20:12my workflow. I haven't found anything that can replicate it in Mac OS 10. I was a huge fan.

1:20:16I wouldn't call it the central organizing principle of my workflow back then, but it was

1:20:20a great feature. And yet again, especially with the Finder, just a terrific example of how the

1:20:27The Classic Finder was a just vastly, infinitely better design than the Mac OS X Finder ever

1:20:33was or probably will be.

1:20:35The idea was you could just drag a window, take the title bar, drag it down to the bottom

1:20:39of the screen, and when it got to the bottom, it would change from a window into a tab,

1:20:44and the tab would stay anchored at the bottom.

1:20:47And while it was there, you could click the tab and it would pop up, and you could access

1:20:53the stuff in it and then click it again and it would go back down to a tab. Super convenient

1:20:59for your current project, if your current project is organized in a single folder in the Finder,

1:21:05or frequently accessed folders. It was just terrific. Great feature. And again, I miss it.

1:21:14Ryan Jones asks, "How do you feel about the decline of exquisite attention to detail in Apple

1:21:22products, specifically software, such as more inconsistencies or fewer subtle delights?"

1:21:28That's a good question, and I definitely think he's right. I would go so far as to say it only

1:21:33pertains to software. To me, Apple's attention to detail and hardware is greater than ever. I think

1:21:39that their hardware is more refined, more closer to the perfection than it's ever been. Not to go

1:21:48to go off on a tangent, but just one example is the hinge

1:21:51on the current MacBook Pros, the hinge between the display

1:21:55and the main body.

1:21:58It works with so little effort, yet it stays

1:22:03in whatever position you put it in with,

1:22:06you can get it exactly at the angle you want it to

1:22:08with less effort.

1:22:10The hinge even looks good.

1:22:11It's almost like it's not there.

1:22:12You hardly even see anything.

1:22:14It looks good, it feels good, it is super reliable.

1:22:17It's just exquisite attention to detail.

1:22:21Say what you want about the new keyboard,

1:22:24but the fact that it has this,

1:22:27about what do you think about the low travel.

1:22:31But the way that the keys on these butterfly switches

1:22:34move all at once up and down is such a,

1:22:39it's so nice and it really is something

1:22:41that when I go back to my old keyboard,

1:22:43it really does feel a little junky.

1:22:45The hardware attention to detail is terrific.

1:22:48And I could go on and on about the hardware of the iPhone,

1:22:51which is just terrific.

1:22:55The software, definitely, there's no doubt in my mind

1:22:57that there is less attention to detail in Apple software

1:23:02than in the old days.

1:23:05In the old days, and I would say especially

1:23:07like in the classic Mac era,

1:23:13It was very hard to find any user interface mistakes

1:23:16in Apple's own software.

1:23:18It was just in terms of just little details.

1:23:24There's things now, and it's been this way

1:23:26in Mac OS X forever.

1:23:27I forget exactly where.

1:23:28I think, let's see if I can find it here.

1:23:35There's things in system preferences

1:23:36where there's a little sheet that comes down

1:23:40and system preferences where there's an okay

1:23:42and cancel button and the okay button,

1:23:45rather than being the same width as the cancel button,

1:23:48it's only wide enough for the word okay, which is wrong.

1:23:53It's clearly a user interface mistake.

1:23:57It's wrong according to the HIG and it's wrong

1:24:00according to just my native UI instincts.

1:24:05I can't believe that Apple employs somebody

1:24:09who would make such a mistake

1:24:12while laying out a dialog box.

1:24:15And furthermore, I cannot believe even more

1:24:18that even given the existence of some engineer

1:24:22who isn't aware of that UI convention

1:24:25that an OK and a cancel button should be the same width

1:24:28even if the word OK has to float

1:24:30in a lot of horizontal white space.

1:24:32I can't believe that it got approved.

1:24:37And furthermore, Cana can't believe that it's been there for years and Apple still hasn't

1:24:42fixed it. There's all sorts of little things like that in Mac OS X. You know, it is what

1:24:51it is, but I just feel like and I think part of it is just that Apple has had to, you know,

1:24:58they've expanded and they have so many engineers that they can't only hire engineers who are

1:25:05familiar forward and backward with every single UI convention of the Mac. I do find it a little

1:25:12depressing. Let's keep going here. Next question. Got to wrap this up soon. I'm running out

1:25:21of steam. It's surprisingly hard to do this without a guest. Let's see here. Do I think

1:25:30touch will ever come to the Mac?

1:25:32This is a question from Jamie Halmick.

1:25:34Not like the touch bar,

1:25:38but real touch interaction on the screen.

1:25:40Conversely, do you think mouse support

1:25:42will ever come to the iPad?

1:25:43A couple other people asked about this.

1:25:45Touch support for macOS, just a matter of time,

1:25:47never going to happen, Walford East wrote.

1:25:50I certainly think it never should come to the Mac.

1:25:55I really do believe, I firmly believe

1:25:58the Apple party line on touchscreen Macs,

1:26:00that the Mac is designed, fundamentally designed

1:26:04from a user interface perspective to be used

1:26:07with your hands on a desk or table, palms down,

1:26:11on a keyboard, on a mouse, on a trackpad,

1:26:15and that ergonomically reaching up and touching a screen

1:26:18is suboptimal, and that the Mac has user interface controls.

1:26:28Everything from the red, yellow, green buttons to the menu bar

1:26:31to the way menu bar items are arranged

1:26:33to how small items in the dock can

1:26:36get when you're running a bunch of applications.

1:26:38They have all sorts of controls throughout the UI.

1:26:40Just think about the main palette in Photoshop and apps

1:26:43like Photoshop, how small the buttons are.

1:26:46With a precision pointer using a trackpad or mouse,

1:26:49you can pack controls that are very small and close

1:26:53to each other, and they remain totally functional.

1:26:56and on a touchscreen, they need to be bigger

1:26:58and further apart to accommodate the fact

1:27:00that your finger touching a screen is imprecise.

1:27:04So the Mac UI as it is, things are too close, too small

1:27:11to be touch friendly.

1:27:13And if Apple were to issue touchscreen Macs

1:27:16and an edict that everything should be redesigned

1:27:20to be touch friendly, then you'd be wasting

1:27:22all this screen real estate

1:27:23when you do use a mouse and trackpad.

1:27:25I really think it's a bad idea.

1:27:28I really do, and I don't think it's ever going to come.

1:27:31Would I be shocked if it did come?

1:27:33I don't know, because people seem to be clamoring for it,

1:27:36but I think that they're wrong,

1:27:37and I think Apple should and will stick to its guns.

1:27:40I really don't think a touchscreen Mac is a good idea.

1:27:43When, oh, let's see here, next question.

1:27:50I've lost my train of thought here in these questions.

1:27:53Oh, here's a good one.

1:27:54Ryan Humphrey asks, "If you were starting a business today where long-term success was

1:27:59going to be dependent on heavily investing in either Apple or Microsoft's commitment

1:28:02to desktop/professional hardware, would you be comfortable locking yourself into Apple?"

1:28:06Absolutely. I don't think there's any reason to doubt Apple's commitment to the Mac as

1:28:11a platform going forward. I think these two statements can both be true. Apple is as committed

1:28:16to the Mac as you could want the company to be today. And Apple is primarily—the primary

1:28:27focus of the company, the single most important product is the iPhone. I think both of those

1:28:31things can be true. That yes, the iPhone is Apple's most important product. It's the most successful.

1:28:35The one with the most users generates by far the most money and therefore justifies being the

1:28:40the company's prime focus of attention,

1:28:43but that the company remains totally committed to the Mac.

1:28:46I think both of those things can be true and are true.

1:28:49NBA asks, same question asked on ATP this week,

1:28:56"When do you expect to see the first ARM Mac?"

1:28:58It's sort of a repeat question, sorry about that.

1:29:00I'm gonna say 2020, and if not 2020, 2021 at the latest.

1:29:09P. Krishna asks, "Which keyboard are you going to use

1:29:11"if your Apple Extended Keyboard 2 broke?"

1:29:13I would just take out one of my Mint condition

1:29:16unopened Apple Extended Keyboard 2s that I have in storage

1:29:19and use one of those if my current one broke.

1:29:22But I guess that's sort of a non-answer.

1:29:25I think what you're really asking is what if,

1:29:27at a technical level, the ADB to USB adapter I used

1:29:31to do it stopped working with Mac OS X?

1:29:34I guess I would buy some sort of mechanical keyboard.

1:29:36I'd probably talk to Jason Snell and see.

1:29:39I've still never found a mechanical keyboard

1:29:41that I would be satisfied with,

1:29:42but I'm sure I could find something

1:29:44that I would like better than anything else.

1:29:47Phil Swenson asks, "Heard anything about the Apple monitor

1:29:54"promised last year?

1:29:55"Seems like a reasonably priced for Apple at least,

1:29:57"monitor with more ports would migrate,

1:30:00"mitigate port issues, and no one wants the LG."

1:30:06I haven't heard anything. I just presume, and I think this is pretty obvious, that whenever

1:30:10Apple's Mac Pro is ready to, the new Mac Pro is ready to come out, it will debut alongside

1:30:16the Apple branded 5K or perhaps even 8K monitor that Apple talked about last year. And I would

1:30:23certainly hope that it includes a bunch of ports so that people with like a MacBook Pro

1:30:29who plug into the new monitor could get things like extra USB ports and stuff like that.

1:30:38But I haven't heard anything about it and presume it won't come before and won't come

1:30:42after it'll cut debut alongside the new Mac Pro. Richard Martin asks, "Would a MacBook

1:30:48with a massive glass keyboard touchpad/Apple Pencil abstracted interface area in lieu of

1:30:54the current keyboard touchpad area be a good product?

1:30:57I'm gonna say no, it would be a terrible product.

1:31:00Absolutely terrible.

1:31:01To me, and it runs into this with these low travel keys,

1:31:06and particularly with the lack of an inverted

1:31:12arrow key arrangement, inverted T arrow key arrangement,

1:31:17which Marco and I talked about last week,

1:31:19it would be terrible.

1:31:23because the thing about it,

1:31:24it's not even what it would be like

1:31:25once you look at the key and get your fingers on,

1:31:28let's just say it would be like an iPad, right?

1:31:30Like you have an iPad keyboard on a glass surface

1:31:33of the top of the,

1:31:34where the hardware keyboard on a MacBook is now.

1:31:37Put aside what it would be like to actually type

1:31:42on that keyboard once your fingers are in the right place,

1:31:46which I think clearly would be inferior,

1:31:49no travel keys, even with some sort of haptic feedback

1:31:52along the lines of the way that the current track pads

1:31:57don't really click but have haptic feedback instead.

1:32:00Put aside what that would be like typing,

1:32:04which I think would be inferior,

1:32:06but the big problem is that you have to look to do it.

1:32:09Like the whole, one of the huge advantages

1:32:12that a hardware keyboard on a laptop has

1:32:16that's irreplaceable is the fact

1:32:17that you can get your fingers,

1:32:19you get your hands in the right place simply by touch alone.

1:32:22And there is absolutely nothing that a glass keyboard

1:32:26could do to replicate that.

1:32:28I guess in theory, they could put little nubbins

1:32:33where the J and F keys are on the glass

1:32:36and there'd be permanent nubbins on the glass

1:32:38and you could kind of get your fingers in the right space,

1:32:40but I don't see, I just don't see how it could ever be good.

1:32:43I think it would be terrible, just a terrible product.

1:32:46I think so much of the appeal of,

1:32:50who knows how many times a day,

1:32:52like in a full day of work on a MacBook

1:32:54or a laptop of any kind,

1:32:55how many times a day does an experienced user

1:32:59put their hands on the keyboard and get their,

1:33:03which also puts your thumb in a position

1:33:05to use the trackpad without looking.

1:33:07Hundreds, maybe.

1:33:09I mean, just hundreds of times a day.

1:33:11And to have to look every single time

1:33:13would be such an enormous step backward,

1:33:15I think it would be a disaster.

1:33:16So hopefully Apple has no plans to do that.

1:33:19And I say hopeful because, you know,

1:33:22Apple's, you know, as I've said,

1:33:27MacBooks get thinner and thinner as years go on,

1:33:30and the keyboards get thinner and thinner along with them,

1:33:32and the ultimate in keyboard thinness would be

1:33:35a keyboard that has no travel whatsoever.

1:33:37So hopefully that's not on our radar,

1:33:40because I think it would be a terrible step backward

1:33:43that they'd never recover from,

1:33:44or that the experience would never recover from at least.

1:33:47A related question from Saint Chris,

1:33:51who I think had a question earlier.

1:33:53Do you wish Apple would move the quote tactile nubs

1:33:57from the index fingers back to the middle fingers

1:34:00on the home row of their keyboards?

1:34:02Now, for those of you who don't remember,

1:34:04now think about this on a US QWERTY keyboard,

1:34:07he's talking about these,

1:34:08the little things on the F and J keys,

1:34:10the ones that you put your index finger on,

1:34:11there's little tactile nubs, whatever you want to call them.

1:34:16Back in the day,

1:34:18including on my beloved Apple Extended Keyboard 2,

1:34:21Apple Keyboard put those nubbins on the middle finger keys,

1:34:24which in the US would be the D and K keys.

1:34:27And I have to admit, I prefer that.

1:34:30I don't know why.

1:34:31I don't really think there's any logic to it.

1:34:34I don't know how much variation there was

1:34:38between various computer manufacturers back in the '80s.

1:34:41But Apple, like the Apple extended, or the Apple IIs, I say,

1:34:46had those nubbins on the D and K key,

1:34:48and then early Mac keyboards stuck with the Apple II design

1:34:52of putting them on the index finger.

1:34:54I can't justify it rationally,

1:34:55other than that it just always has felt right to me.

1:34:58And I don't think it's just because my first computers

1:35:01that I used were Apple's.

1:35:03I think that to me there is something intuitive

1:35:05about the fact that your longest finger,

1:35:08your middle finger, is the one

1:35:10that reaches the keyboard first

1:35:11and therefore finds those nubbins.

1:35:13So me personally, I do wish that Apple

1:35:16would move them back to the middle finger,

1:35:18but I think that that chip has sailed.

1:35:21The rest of the, you know, Apple has used this,

1:35:23you know, moved them to the index fingers

1:35:26at least 20 years ago, all right, 20, 25 years ago.

1:35:29The whole, everybody, every keyboard I've seen

1:35:32for 20, 20 some years has them on the F and J key,

1:35:35so I don't think Apple could move this

1:35:36without seeming like they'd lost their corporate mind.

1:35:39But for me personally, do I wish that I could,

1:35:43for example, custom order,

1:35:45if I custom order a MacBook and as a preference

1:35:51could get the nubbins on the D and K keys,

1:35:53I would do it in a heartbeat.

1:35:55I really do like that.

1:35:57I thought this was a pretty interesting question.

1:35:59All right, last Mac question,

1:36:02and I guess it's gonna be the last question of the episode.

1:36:08What is a voice or perspective about tech

1:36:10that Apple isn't listening to

1:36:12that could turn into a major problem?

1:36:13Examples, but not my answer.

1:36:16India, where Apple is sort of missing the boat on mobile.

1:36:20Gamers, teenagers, artists, iOS only people, et cetera.

1:36:27This is a question from Jason Becker.

1:36:30I am going to say that the single,

1:36:33I don't think that Apple's missing or isn't listening to.

1:36:37So maybe I'm not answering the question.

1:36:40But I think the biggest problem that Apple faces

1:36:43that might really be a problem is the growing,

1:36:46the growing rise of non-native web-based apps,

1:36:55these things that are based on Electron and stuff like that,

1:36:59that don't use native, and it's a Mac-specific problem.

1:37:04It's not an iOS problem, at least not yet,

1:37:06although it might be for the iPad as time goes on.

1:37:09The only reason the Mac can justify its existence

1:37:14is the fact that Mac software, for some people,

1:37:17is vastly superior to anything else.

1:37:20It's the superiority of Mac software

1:37:22that justifies the existence of the Mac

1:37:24alongside Windows and whatever else you could use

1:37:27on a desktop computer.

1:37:28And as it's never, I don't think we've ever seen a case,

1:37:33back in the day with Java, there were cross-platform apps

1:37:36and there was Flash and there's always been

1:37:39cross-platform solutions, but none of them

1:37:41have ever really taken off in a way

1:37:43that these Electron-type things have.

1:37:45And they're A, terrible, B, they're no better

1:37:49on the Mac than they are on any other platform.

1:37:51So if all you use are Electron-based apps,

1:37:54there's really no reason for you to have

1:37:58any allegiance to the Mac.

1:37:59It doesn't really matter what you use.

1:38:04I think it's a problem.

1:38:05I think Apple sees it as a problem,

1:38:07and that's partly why they're going with this Marzipan thing,

1:38:09where if companies aren't going to do the work

1:38:12of doing a first-class native Mac client,

1:38:15but they do wanna have a quote-unquote Mac app,

1:38:20it would be better if they used their iOS app code base

1:38:25to get something running on the Mac,

1:38:27even if it's not optimal,

1:38:28than it would be to shoehorn a stupid web app

1:38:31into a web app shell like Electron.

1:38:33But I feel like that's a concession to the point that the true solution for most of these

1:38:40apps would be to just do a real Mac app. And I think it's a bit of a problem. All right,

1:38:48that's it for the Mac questions. There's a whole bunch of other topics. I guess I'll

1:38:51have to do another one of these shows. Hopefully people like this. I don't know how interesting

1:38:54it is. I want to thank the two sponsors for this episode, Squarespace and Casper. And

1:39:01I wanna thank everybody out there who sent these questions

1:39:03and it's been a lot of fun.

1:39:05I can't believe that I only got through

1:39:06two out of six categories.

1:39:08[BLANK_AUDIO]