Podcast Search

The Talk Show

217: ‘Our Name Is Our Address’ With Jason Kottke

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Finally. That's what you say, right?

0:00:04That's what I say. I'm the master. I'm the licensee of "finally." One of the

0:00:11reasons that you're here now is that your website, kotke.org, has hit the 20-year marker,

0:00:18which now that I say it, this is the first time I've actually spoken it aloud, and

0:00:22it just put like a dagger of old age down my heart.

0:00:26No, it's, I mean, it's crazy. It's crazy.

0:00:30But one of the things that I wanted to talk about with you is over the years, I've noticed

0:00:35many times, often commemorating anniversaries like the 20th or the 15th or whatever, you'll

0:00:41say or you'll write that you don't consider yourself a writer, which I think is a very

0:00:47strange thing to say for somebody who's written so much, but I know what you mean, I think.

0:00:52I consider you to be an absolutely perfect writer. You write what you want to write. And I feel like

0:00:59to me, you're conveying exactly what you want to convey perfectly.

0:01:03Yeah. I mean, I guess I would consider myself a blogger first. Someone who uses writing in

0:01:15the goal. I don't know, maybe there's a different goal. Like a novelist is a novelist,

0:01:21and they use writing to pursue that, the goal of doing all the things that a novelist does.

0:01:28But I feel like my primary interest is, "I want to share this thing with you or this

0:01:38other thing that this real writer wrote about something. I want to share that with you."

0:01:51I talk, like I, you know, and the site is very much, you know, the voice of the site

0:01:58is very much me writing an email to a friend about this cool thing that I saw.

0:02:03Well, it's the weird thing is that there is no one way to be a writer. And, you know,

0:02:08and I guess the idealized form, and maybe kids today don't feel it anymore, but at least when

0:02:13I was growing up, a novelist would be like the top rung of the ladder, like, you know,

0:02:19the Hemingways and Fitzgeralds and just name of—either historical or even current day. That is

0:02:26the pinnacle of—indisputably, you are a writer if you have written and published novels and moved

0:02:34down from there. And as I've gotten older, I kind of think that's a little BS. And I think most

0:02:42novelists would probably agree, you know, that it's, you know, that they might feel that they

0:02:48couldn't do what, like, their favorite newspaper columnist does, right? That, you know, like,

0:02:54there might be novelists who can't imagine being Paul Krugman and having two times a week making

0:03:00a point in exactly 750 words, two times a week, every week for 15 years. Which I'm personally in

0:03:09off because to me one of the great breakthroughs of blogging as a medium is that your post can be

0:03:16exactly as long as it needs to be whether that's extra long or in most cases you know very short

0:03:21compared to a like a newspaper column that people just have different people just have writers just

0:03:27have different natural lengths right or like you you know you get used to a certain length like i

0:03:34you know, like I, I've thought about writing a book of some sort, you know, over the years,

0:03:39but I cannot imagine just how that would happen for me, you know, because everything I post is

0:03:46so short and so chunked up and like, you know, how can I, how can I write more than five paragraphs

0:03:51about something, you know, much less like 13 chapters or something, you know?

0:03:55Trenton Larkin Yeah. Yeah. I, I've, you know,

0:03:58it's like a frequently asked question for me, if I ever thought about writing a book and

0:04:02And I've thought about it in the abstract,

0:04:06but I've never had like an idea.

0:04:08In the early, early days of "Daring Fireball"

0:04:12and trying to go independent,

0:04:13I had an idea that maybe I would write

0:04:15like an advanced nerds book on how to use BB edit.

0:04:20And I could have, I think I had like book length,

0:04:26but sort of like even there though,

0:04:30like in the heyday of O'Reilly books,

0:04:33it's like each chapter is really just an article, right?

0:04:36It would still just be sort of like

0:04:37stringing together 10 articles about BB Edit

0:04:40and calling it a book and selling it.

0:04:42- Right.

0:04:43- It's not--

0:04:44- There's no grand narrative you have to worry about.

0:04:46- Right, not one big 200-page or longer idea

0:04:50that I'm filling in the details on.

0:04:53It's just never happened to me.

0:04:54I don't know.

0:04:56- Yeah, I mean, I feel like it's that kind of thing

0:04:59it's like, you know, like people who are into books, they could, you know, they probably,

0:05:04they probably look at a site like yours or a site like mine and they're like, oh my God,

0:05:08like this person could totally write a book and they can see it in their mind. But I can't

0:05:14see that, you know, I can't see that. I don't, you know, I can't look at it that way. I don't

0:05:20have the experience of, of, of, you know, like picking out books like that. You know, maybe it's

0:05:27Maybe it's like a forest for the trees type of thing.

0:05:29Like I'm sowing the weeds that I can't even see it.

0:05:33I don't know.

0:05:34- One of the things that to me was a breakthrough,

0:05:37and 1998 when kotge.org started,

0:05:42well, let's start with this.

0:05:43The fact that it's never been quite comfortable to me

0:05:47speaking about your website,

0:05:48because the name of the site,

0:05:50it doesn't really have a name, right?

0:05:53(laughing)

0:05:55- Right, yeah, it's never really,

0:05:57- You know, kotke.org is the name.

0:06:00Most people call it Kotke, which is also my last name,

0:06:03which is a little weird.

0:06:04And so when I talk about it, I always say kotke.org

0:06:07because if I say Kotke, then I'm talking about myself

0:06:10in the royal sense, which is stupid.

0:06:14You know, I'm not Ricky Henderson.

0:06:15- But it is, it does make it sometimes grammatically weird,

0:06:22but somehow feels exactly right.

0:06:25'cause I can't imagine it any other way.

0:06:27- Yeah, I mean, I've often thought about,

0:06:31I mean, not so much anymore,

0:06:32but in the early days I thought about changing it.

0:06:34Like, oh, I should actually give it a name,

0:06:36so it's not my name.

0:06:40- Kotke's daily links.

0:06:42- Yeah, to make it more serious, I don't know, something.

0:06:44- Right, but it actually says,

0:06:46like you go there right now and the banner says kotke.org,

0:06:51and then there's a little heart,

0:06:5220 years of hypertext products.

0:06:55It always reminds me of here in Philadelphia,

0:06:57there was, they're gone now.

0:06:59I think they still exist, but they're like in Delaware.

0:07:02But there was a jewelry store

0:07:04that ran commercials all the time.

0:07:08Any kid of our age who grew up like in the '80s

0:07:12is gonna know who I'm talking about

0:07:13'cause they had like, they used to advertise

0:07:15on like the after school, I don't know why,

0:07:17like the after school rerun type shows.

0:07:21You know, like when you'd watch old Gilligan's Island

0:07:23the Brady Bunch and stuff and the name of the store was Robin's eighth and Walnut.

0:07:28And that was their actual name of the store and their location was eighth and Walnut.

0:07:34And they even had a jingle. I'm not going to sing it. Maybe we can dig it up on YouTube and insert it here.

0:07:49"Robin's 8th and Walnut, our name is our address."

0:07:52(laughing)

0:07:54- And I often have thought about it

0:07:56when I've thought at the meta level of kotki.org

0:07:59being the name of the site,

0:08:01it always inevitably pops into my head

0:08:04that the jingle from "Robin's 8th and Walnut,

0:08:06our name is our address."

0:08:08- The jingle is also self-referential.

0:08:11It's perfect, I love it.

0:08:13- It is in fact, and I will also say this,

0:08:17in fact, where I got my wedding band that I'm wearing right now.

0:08:21No, there you go.

0:08:22Now they're now it's a good it's a coffee shop.

0:08:25You got to get him in as a sponsor. Oh, they're no longer there.

0:08:28Well, I do believe that they still exist. I don't want to get it. I don't want to get into it. But

0:08:33there was some kind of thing. Let's talk about the Jewish. There was some kind of family dispute,

0:08:38I believe, like where the the patriarch of the family died and the next generation squabbled

0:08:45over it and I don't know some kind of messy thing like that. But I believe they still

0:08:50have locations in Delaware. And that's the strip strategy there is that Delaware has no sales tax.

0:08:58So you could save money. I don't know. There's a lot of jewelry stores in Delaware.

0:09:03Right. They should put that whole story in their name now.

0:09:07Like the part about like, we had a disagreement in the family. No, we're only in Delaware with

0:09:13with no sales tax. It's right in the name.

0:09:15That's the name of the store. Robbins, we had a family disagreement and now we're

0:09:22only in Delaware where there is no sales tax.

0:09:26Exactly.

0:09:29So, one of the things from the early days and going back to 1998, the format of a blog

0:09:40was not, it seems self-evident now,

0:09:43but it was not self-evident then.

0:09:47Meaning that you have this thing and you type a new post

0:09:51and then on your homepage of your site,

0:09:54the most recently thing that you posted is at the top

0:09:57and the next time you post something, it gets pushed down

0:10:00and that's it.

0:10:03Like it sounds so simple, but I struggled for years.

0:10:07Like one of the reasons during Fireball

0:10:09was four and a half years after Kotke,

0:10:12wasn't that in 1998 that I wasn't thinking about

0:10:15having a website, it was 'cause I didn't know

0:10:19how to make it, I didn't know what format.

0:10:22I was stuck for years thinking about issues,

0:10:25but that there would be like, I'd do this thing

0:10:27and there'd be like, every Monday there'd be a new issue,

0:10:30'cause I came out of the student newspaper world.

0:10:33I couldn't get past it.

0:10:34- Right.

0:10:38the early days you started with what was the site oscillate right yeah oscillate yeah which is sadly

0:10:44no longer online it's on my hard drive somewhere and i i you know it's one of those things like

0:10:48i should put it back up but i still have the domain i do yeah well that's good

0:10:55well tell me about oscillate what was the oscillate because oscillate wasn't a blog

0:11:01but i remember it but it's a lot harder to describe yeah it wasn't a blog so it was it was

0:11:07there were a series of episodes and so like the when you come to the front page

0:11:11of the site it was it was basically you know like in the olden days back in the

0:11:16olden days you know splash pages were kind of a thing you know particularly

0:11:25with flash and stuff but this was like even you know I think flash was around

0:11:29but basically the front page of the site was a splash page and if you

0:11:35clicked it, it launched a pop-up and it had that, you know, weeks or months or, you know,

0:11:41the current episode. It was episodic and every, you know, every two, three, four weeks, you know,

0:11:48and then it was a couple months and then six months. But every once in a while, I would come

0:11:53out with a new episode and there would be a completely new splash page and completely new

0:11:57design for whatever that episode was. And it was, you know, writing was a component, photography,

0:12:04You know, I was a 20. I mean, I started Oscillate in 1996, I think. So I was like 22 years old and

0:12:15trying to figure out what to do with this new medium along with everyone else.

0:12:21And, you know, Oscillate was a way to do that, you know, and, you know, it was also a way to

0:12:28try and get a job doing this stuff, you know? Yeah, I think the thinking back then, and,

0:12:34you know, I had other some little things I played around with with friends, nothing really solo, but

0:12:39the idea was like for some sites, it always seemed like a splash page was instantly even at the

0:12:46beginning. It was like this is stupid. Like if I'm going to an online bookstore, you should not show

0:12:50me a splash page. You should just take me to where I want to go. But people wanted them. And I

0:12:57remember a friend and I built the first website for Drexel's College of Design Arts after we

0:13:03graduated. And we didn't want there to be a splash page. Our idea was that when you'd go there,

0:13:09the main page would be sort of an overview of the College of Design Arts. And, you know, you could

0:13:16go from there, like, you know, like, on one side, here's resources for existing students in the

0:13:20college. On the other side, here's resources for students thinking about it, blah, blah, blah. And

0:13:24when they were like, No, no, we need like a splash page, something that, you know, we're like, all

0:13:29All right.

0:13:30But then there were other sites

0:13:32where the homepage was the whole site.

0:13:34Like that was, so it's not really a splash page.

0:13:36It's just that it wasn't a site

0:13:38consisting of multiple pages that needed an index.

0:13:40It was just like you'd go there

0:13:42and whatever it was would be on the homepage.

0:13:45And then when they'd come up with something new,

0:13:46they would just replace the homepage.

0:13:49- Right.

0:13:50Yeah, I mean, you know, like Drudge Report

0:13:54is a good example of that.

0:13:57That's, you know, even probably,

0:13:58I don't know when Drudge started, but it's gotta be, you know.

0:14:03- Oh man, it has to be.

0:14:04- It's gotta be 20-ish years old.

0:14:05- Yeah, or more, right?

0:14:07Because Drudge was so instrumental

0:14:10in the whole Lewinsky thing.

0:14:12- Yep.

0:14:13- And so that was like '97, '98,

0:14:17and it was already a thing.

0:14:18It wasn't like a new website.

0:14:19So I'm gonna guess Drudge started around '95 or '96.

0:14:22- Yeah, yeah, I think that's probably right.

0:14:27- Yeah, but you know, oscillate was like,

0:14:29it was like, I'm not gonna call it art

0:14:34because it wasn't that, but it was like design experiments.

0:14:39So like the splash page idea sort of felt like it was good,

0:14:44you know, particularly in that era.

0:14:47And like, you know, it was my thing.

0:14:49So like, I really liked designing those splash pages

0:14:52because it was like this chance to use,

0:14:56you know, sort of these things that were not,

0:15:01that you couldn't use on like a site for a client.

0:15:04You know, you couldn't put these massive images up

0:15:07and I mean, massive for that time,

0:15:09but you know, they probably look tiny now,

0:15:11but you know, just to do stuff you couldn't do elsewhere

0:15:16and just like, what about this?

0:15:18What about this?

0:15:19What about this?

0:15:20You know, it was a constant sort of like,

0:15:22can it do this?

0:15:23Okay.

0:15:24- Yeah, just to sort of scratch that itch of,

0:15:28I have these very strong opinions

0:15:30of how a website should be or could be,

0:15:33and if I don't just do it myself

0:15:36and do it with whatever silly ideas are in my head,

0:15:38I'm never gonna get to do it,

0:15:39because I can see the way it goes with client work.

0:15:42It always devolves into give us this thing

0:15:45that's just like what everybody else is doing.

0:15:48- Yeah. - At a certain level.

0:15:51- Here's a news break here from talk show headquarters.

0:15:54The Drudge Report started in 1995 as an email newsletter

0:16:00that he was charging, I think, $10 a month for,

0:16:02and then he started the website in 1997

0:16:05as a supplement to his $10 per year email newsletter.

0:16:10Talk about ideas that come around and go around,

0:16:13email newsletters. - Yeah, exactly.

0:16:15- So there's the vintage on that.

0:16:17He's a year before kotki.org.

0:16:20- All right.

0:16:20- So how do you get from Oscillate to kotki.org?

0:16:27And at some point they were both

0:16:29still actively maintained, right?

0:16:31You didn't really think of it as like,

0:16:33I'm gonna put Oscillate on ice and switch to this.

0:16:36It was sort of like, here's a new thing.

0:16:38- Yeah, so what became kotki.org started out

0:16:44as an episode of Oscillate.

0:16:46It was sort of like, okay, there is these, you know, online journal things that have

0:16:52been around for quite a while.

0:16:53And, you know, there are these sort of new things called blog, you know, well, they

0:17:00weren't called blogs at the time, but web logs.

0:17:02And, you know, I was like, you know, I think part of it was just that I wanted

0:17:08to design a site or an interface or, you know, a reading interface that was, that

0:17:14it was four regularly updated content in this way.

0:17:19Not just sort of like, oh, I have to think

0:17:21of some completely different thing every time.

0:17:24It's like, I wanted to design a container

0:17:26where I could just write more regularly.

0:17:31I think that, and that was definitely part of it.

0:17:36And then I did that for a while,

0:17:39And it lived on oscillate in this pop-up window,

0:17:44which was a very unwieldy way to use it.

0:17:48And I think, probably in a few months,

0:17:51I moved it over to its own thing.

0:17:55- What were you using as a CMS spec then?

0:17:59'Cause that predates movable type.

0:18:00Removable type, I think, came out either in early 2002

0:18:05or late 2001, but it was right around the time

0:18:09when I was planning "Daring Fireball."

0:18:10And I was like, "Oh, this will be better

0:18:13than the whatever crazy thing I was gonna make myself."

0:18:16- Right, I mean, I was hand coding everything.

0:18:19(laughing)

0:18:20So I would update the front page

0:18:23and then I would copy and paste that update

0:18:25to whatever archive file

0:18:29and then I would FTP them to my server.

0:18:31I know.

0:18:33- So Zeldman hand-edited, Zeldman, the daily report,

0:18:38for years after like movable type and other things like he he did it not because he wasn't aware of

0:18:44the advantages of using you know movable type or back then was the gray matter and

0:18:51Eventually WordPress it was because he thought it was good and maybe he's right, but he thought it was good

0:18:57Like hygiene to keep his like HTML editing

0:19:02You know, this is keep us keep those muscles working

0:19:07And I remember telling him the one he told me that it was like years after you know, like, you know

0:19:12Like 2004 or five six and I was like you're not you're absolutely crazy

0:19:17yeah, I was like this like I

0:19:20It's like breaking down your door every time you come into your house and then immediately rebuilding a door

0:19:27Yeah, I mean I I

0:19:31Didn't switch to you know, like everyone

0:19:34I mean everyone in late '99, 2000, switched to Blogger.

0:19:39And Blogger at the time,

0:19:41there was no blog spot or anything like that.

0:19:44Blogger was an interface.

0:19:45You could write these posts,

0:19:48and then it basically,

0:19:50you gave it the FTP information for your server,

0:19:54and it would FTP the files.

0:19:56- Right, I remember that.

0:19:58- And so I was like,

0:20:02I have always been very particular about the design of my site and sort of, you know, for

0:20:07various reasons, perhaps related to my personality. But, you know, and Blogger really didn't,

0:20:17Blogger didn't have, couldn't do it exactly the way that I wanted to do it. And so I was

0:20:23one of the few, I think, that didn't switch and, you know, sort of held out until movable

0:20:29type was kind of robust enough to be able to do everything and then I made the jump. But later

0:20:36than a lot of people, I was still, you know, into the 2000s, I was still, you know, coding it by

0:20:42hand and FTPing like a caveman. And then did you backport all the old posts from that hand editing

0:20:51era into movable type? I did. I did. Did you do that manually or did you figure out a way to do it?

0:20:58You know, I probably slightly automated it, but it was probably mostly manual, I would say.

0:21:03So the entirety of katky.org, like from the beginning onward, is still there. Like,

0:21:12it's all... Do you ever... You must know about this because it just breaks my heart on a regular

0:21:20basis. But like, have you ever like, gone looking at like the... I don't even know what year to call

0:21:25it off at, but let's just say the early 2000s. But you go back and look at posts in early 2000s

0:21:30and see how many of the things you link to are now 404s. Yeah, I mean, there's so much stuff.

0:21:35It's a majority of it. Yeah. It's even from two years ago. It's shocking how much stuff from just

0:21:42a few years ago is now 404. But it's absolutely horrifying when I go back to the early years of

0:21:48Daring Fireball and start looking at it. And so like, I've had this long simmering project in my

0:21:53ahead to, I guess, you know, to be honest, pay someone. But create a tool that hunts

0:22:03down all the 404s and then just pay someone to go through and replace them as best they

0:22:08can with links to the Internet Archive.

0:22:10Right, exactly. Yes, I mean, same. We should, we should find, we should pay the same person

0:22:16to do this for both of us.

0:22:18Right. And then I think, my God, that would be so much better. And then I get terrified

0:22:22and thinking about how the Internet Archive is this single thread holding the entire history

0:22:29of the Internet together, then it's just, you know, I think that it's well funded. And I think

0:22:36that they have a very, you know, good plan to stay going for the future. But it just seems crazy to

0:22:41me that there's a single point of failure. And it's just an independent organization. It's not

0:22:47like the Library of Congress or something like that, which I'd have a little bit more. I'd feel

0:22:51better if there was somebody else, if there were like a arch rival to the internet archive.

0:22:56Yeah. I mean, God bless Brewster Kahle that he, you know, that he had,

0:23:01yeah, I don't know, like he had the vision to do this and like the, the, you know,

0:23:07the resources to do it as well. But what are the, you know, like one of them talking about like

0:23:15old links and stuff. Like one of the reasons, you know, like Amazon, I think

0:23:20is, you know, a increasingly problematic company for a lot of people.

0:23:26Uh, you know, but I linked to Amazon regularly, uh, you know, just books,

0:23:33movies, music, that sort of thing.

0:23:35And one of the things that I really like about them and one of the, one of the

0:23:38reasons why I still do link to them is that if you look at the earliest links

0:23:43to Amazon on kotk.org back in like 1999, they all still work. Yeah. Like, you know, one

0:23:52of the first things I linked to was like a DVD of office space. And if you go and click

0:23:59that link, it takes you to the DVD page for office space on Amazon, even if it even if

0:24:04it needs to redirect, you know, like it may exactly right, but they've every time they

0:24:08change their system in a way that the old URL is no longer the canonical URL.

0:24:14They have redirects in place. I've noticed that for years that Amazon is

0:24:19truly a believer in cool URL. What's the slogan? Cool URLs never change, never

0:24:27die. Exactly. Something like that. Yeah. Yeah. No, I mean, I think it's

0:24:34probably a business thing for them because like, you know, if let's say 10% of their links break,

0:24:40then like, you know, how many how many percentage points on their total business revenue for the

0:24:47years that probably significant. Yeah. When you look at, you know, what their profit margins are.

0:24:52One of the things I remember still, I, you know, in hindsight, it at the time, it didn't seem like

0:25:01it was new because I'd been reading Kottke for years at this point. But in 2001,

0:25:05I very much remember—and this was a time when I was—that's about a year before I started

0:25:12Daring Fireball. And Daring Fireball started August 2002. But when 9/11 happened, and I—you

0:25:26were in New York at the time, right? Or were you not?

0:25:29No, San Francisco. You're still in San Francisco, but it obviously affected everybody profoundly but and everything

0:25:35I know everybody was rightly obsessed with it whether you're talking about television or newspapers or any other medium

0:25:42But I just remember at the time I'd already had like this huge, you know

0:25:46Huge and growing collection of bloggers or journalists or you know, meaning journalers

0:25:51I suppose would be what I'm saying whatever you wanted to call it and everybody was writing about it and I just it I

0:25:58at one point I in one way I felt like I wish I now I really wish I had already started something like this so that

0:26:04I could express myself and then in another part of me was like I don't know how I would but I remember that you're writing

0:26:09on 9/11 was

0:26:11Because it was so different and much more personal than what you had typically done at cocky, but it was so like

0:26:20Cathartic to read like not hyperbolic not hysterical. You're not freaking out, but it was just

0:26:27everybody was so emotional at the time. Yeah. And it was such a weird and it took a while.

0:26:35It wasn't, you know, it was the sort of thing that wasn't, you know, like, oh, a couple of days and

0:26:41then, you know, back to normal. I mean, this was, you know, that was, it's kind of, I can't think

0:26:46of another thing that's happened since that even compares in terms of how, how the entire nation,

0:26:51and maybe the Western world was obsessed with it

0:26:55for months, months and months.

0:26:57- I mean, it's still reverberates.

0:27:01In a lot of ways, like we're still living in a world

0:27:06that was created that day.

0:27:07I'm not sure anybody at the time quite knew

0:27:13how extensive the impact was gonna be.

0:27:17- Yeah.

0:27:20think about that too. And you and I are almost the same age. I think you're one year younger than me,

0:27:25but like, I feel like growing up in a, we grew up in a very particular era of the U S foreign affairs

0:27:36where we're post Vietnam. And by the time I sort of got any kind of, you know, seven, eight,

0:27:44nine years old when I had any kind of vague notion of, you know, what the Vietnam war was like and

0:27:50and what it meant.

0:27:50It just seemed to me, and then growing up in the '80s,

0:27:56it just seemed to me that the US was a place

0:27:59that used to get into wars all the time,

0:28:01but now doesn't really get into wars.

0:28:03I had one of my best friends in high school,

0:28:10we haven't really stayed in touch

0:28:11'cause I don't really stay in touch with anybody,

0:28:13but one of my best friends in high school

0:28:17went to Penn State on an ROTC and then joined the army. And he's still in the army. And my mom just

0:28:24said, we can get into Facebook later because I'm not on Facebook. I don't hear about things,

0:28:28but my mom said that he's just been promoted to a lieutenant colonel or colonel. I don't know.

0:28:34He's like a career army guy, apparently very successful. And I'm not surprised because he was

0:28:42very smart and driven type individual. But I remember when he decided to go that way,

0:28:49I just remember thinking like, good for him, I wouldn't really like the structure of military

0:28:53life, but it never occurred to me that he would be in wars for 20 years. And he's been to,

0:29:00I mean, I can't even imagine it. I just thought that he'd be a civilian, or not a civilian,

0:29:08but a peacetime army officer, as opposed to spending 20 years as a wartime officer.

0:29:15Like that's, it was just inconceivable to me at the time. And that's one of the ways that 9/11

0:29:19to me has truly changed. Like we just sort of accept it now. And I don't think we should,

0:29:24that the US is always at war in multiple campaigns.

0:29:29Yeah, I mean, you know, the thing that I remember most as a kid is, you know, the Cold War.

0:29:36And you know, the 80s.

0:29:44Vietnam wasn't, you know, for a kid who was, you know, I was, let's see, in 1984, I was

0:29:5010 years old.

0:29:52And the Cold War was this thing that was, people don't really understand it.

0:30:00You get little inklings of it here and there whenever the recent saber rattling with North

0:30:05Korea happens.

0:30:06But it was this pervasive thing where it's like, "Holy shit, we are literally moments

0:30:13away from being annihilated all of the time."

0:30:18lot of ways like you know when you're like when you're a little kid like that's kind of terrifying

0:30:22I mean as terrifying as an adult but at the same time you know we weren't you know like you said

0:30:30like we weren't at war we weren't you know Vietnam was in the past and and it didn't you know there

0:30:36were little things here and there like Panama and and things like that but yeah you're right like

0:30:41you know, the US wasn't really at war. And, you know, 9/11 did, you know, did change that in a,

0:30:48in a big way. I mean, there's, you know, there's a lot, a lot we can say about it, but,

0:30:55I mean, I remember at the time, you know, I woke up that morning and, you know, the, I think the,

0:31:02you know, I was on the West coast. So the, you know, the first tower, I think had already fallen

0:31:08And there were already, you know, there were these aim chat rooms that were going with all

0:31:15of these people, like freaking, you know, kind of freaking out, but also sharing information.

0:31:20And, you know, there were the blogs at the time, like people were posting and things like that.

0:31:26And it was halfway between like, Oh my God, I need to turn this off. I can't deal with this right

0:31:33now, like this isn't, it's almost not appropriate to kind of say anything, but at the same time,

0:31:50something needs to be said.

0:31:51Yeah, I almost felt compelled to do it. Like, you know, if I'm going to be a blogger,

0:31:58like I'm going to, you know, you kind of, at a certain point, you kind of have to embrace

0:32:01it and charge into the fold.

0:32:04So I just started sharing all these links and information and people posting pictures

0:32:08and what was going on and tiny little videos, which at the time were melting people's

0:32:19servers.

0:32:20Because posting these six megabyte QuickTime videos and servers were getting melted because

0:32:25CNN would pick it up and point at it and it would melt.

0:32:29CNN was down half of the day and CNN.com.

0:32:32- I remember that.

0:32:33- Yeah, and--

0:32:35- What I remember, I'll tell you my 9/11 morning story.

0:32:38I think I've mentioned this before,

0:32:40but not for a long time, but at the time I used to go,

0:32:44I was working at Barebone Software in Massachusetts

0:32:46and they had flex time.

0:32:49So instead of going at rush hour,

0:32:52I would usually come in around 10.30 in the morning or so,

0:32:55or arrive around 10.30.

0:32:57So I was still at home and Amy,

0:32:58we only had one car and Amy wasn't working

0:33:01and she would go to the gym early in the morning

0:33:03and then she'd come back and then I'd leave for work.

0:33:05And so she was at the gym and called me

0:33:08and she was out of breath

0:33:09because she had been doing cardio and she was panicking,

0:33:12but they had, all the TVs in the gym switched to,

0:33:15like when the first plane hit and she said,

0:33:18she woke me up and said, "We're under attack."

0:33:20And I said, "What?"

0:33:21And she goes, "New York City is under attack."

0:33:24And I said, "By who?"

0:33:25And she goes, "I don't know, but go turn the TV on."

0:33:28I remember turning the TV on and it just sitting there.

0:33:30But the moment that really gets me,

0:33:33I just can't believe I was watching ABC

0:33:35and Peter Jennings was on

0:33:37and they have footage of the two towers,

0:33:39both had been hit and they were smoking.

0:33:41And then when the first tower fell,

0:33:45they like didn't know what to say.

0:33:47And there was so much smoke,

0:33:50like you couldn't quite tell that the tower was gone

0:33:53because it was replaced with smoke

0:33:55and I guess ash and dust.

0:33:58But it was obvious to me what had happened,

0:34:01that the tower had collapsed.

0:34:03But nobody was saying it because it was so,

0:34:06nobody said, "Oh my God, that tower just collapsed."

0:34:09They were like, "We're not sure what's happening here,"

0:34:12because you couldn't see the tower anymore.

0:34:14And it was minutes before they acknowledged verbally,

0:34:18like literally minutes, at least it seemed like it to me,

0:34:21before they acknowledged that it seemed,

0:34:23but they wouldn't even say that it collapsed.

0:34:25like it might have. You couldn't see. And that was so horrible that they couldn't. And then the thing

0:34:34that really got me and the thing that the first time I burst into tears was that when they finally

0:34:40acknowledged that that tower had fallen was, and they wouldn't say it, but they were talking around

0:34:48it was that if the first tower fell because a jet hit it and the same type of jet hit the second

0:34:54tower 18 minutes later or however long it was, then the second tower is going to fall too. And

0:35:00we just have to sit here and wait for it. And I just like that realization, but just, I just

0:35:07burst into tears. I think by that time, Amy was home and we were together, but it's sort of a

0:35:12blur, but I'll just never forget that feeling. I don't know how we got sidetracked by this, but

0:35:17Yeah. To me though, the point is that to me, when I think of 9/11, katki.org is primarily mixed into

0:35:32that. I remember Letterman going back on the air, but I just remember never more needing to check

0:35:41your website every day just to see what you were saying. Dave

0:35:47Weiner too.

0:35:47Yeah, Dave Weiner. Dave Weiner was definitely like, he, you

0:35:53know, I think a lot of people were definitely, you know,

0:35:56following him and refreshing and that stuff. You know, and, you

0:36:03know, 911 was one of those sort of, you know, pivotal moments, I

0:36:09moments I think in the site like it it I mean it it it

0:36:13basically increased my traffic by 50% within like 3 days and

0:36:16it and it stayed.

0:36:19And you know it was just it. You know it's just one of those

0:36:25things like it was like it kind of I think in hindsight, I

0:36:30don't know I've never really thought about this, but I think

0:36:32I I do think in hindsight like it was one of those things

0:36:34It was like, "Oh, this is a thing that is important to me and I think at least somewhat

0:36:43important to other people."

0:36:44Yeah.

0:36:45Well, and in addition to the fact that you were expressing thoughts that I think a lot

0:36:49of people shared and maybe were themselves having trouble articulating, the format of

0:36:54a blog was actually perfect in those days and weeks afterwards where there was so much

0:37:02else on the internet worth, you know, like linking to and the nature of a blog where

0:37:11you could just link to it, right? Like if there's this, somebody had a video about something

0:37:15and you could just link to the video and it, you don't have to write a whole 700 word article

0:37:19about it just to link to it. It was a perfect format, right? It's it, you know, it's great

0:37:24for a lot of things, but it's really great when you're trying to make sense out of a

0:37:28sprawling saga.

0:37:30Yep. Yeah, exactly. And in the weeks and months after 9/11, there were the so-called war blogs

0:37:42that sprang up. This is sort of like the... I mean, it was really the genesis of blogging

0:37:49about politics, 9/11 sort of like kicked it off a little bit.

0:37:56And people were really like, holy shit,

0:37:59like this blogging is perfect for talking about this stuff.

0:38:03Because like you said, you can synthesize

0:38:05a lot of different types of information

0:38:07from all over the place.

0:38:09Like, oh, CNN's saying this, but the New York Times

0:38:11is writing about this.

0:38:13And then InstaPundit said this, and Dave Weiner said this.

0:38:18and you know, like hypertext and in particular, like the bloggy sort of, you know, extension

0:38:26of that is, is really great for, for doing that sort of thing. And it still is, you know,

0:38:31in a way that, yeah, you know, in a way that something like Facebook maybe isn't, but Twitter

0:38:38is maybe even better. I don't know. Yeah. Twitter's better in some ways and, but worse

0:38:45and others because the one thing that you could do that was easier or it still is easier

0:38:49with the blog is if I've got other, you know, I have a real life to run and a job and a

0:38:56family and et cetera. And I just want to catch up on what did kotk. You say today I can just

0:39:02go to the browser, hit command and, and just type K and it's already auto complete. You

0:39:08You know, I'm like two keystrokes away, command N, K, return, and there I am.

0:39:15And there's your thoughts on the day.

0:39:16Whereas Twitter, it's all over the place.

0:39:18It's because it's interspersed with everybody else.

0:39:21Right?

0:39:22We can talk about Twitter later.

0:39:23Anyway, let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor.

0:39:26It's a brand new sponsor.

0:39:27I'm very excited about this because I think it is a perfect use of podcast sponsorships.

0:39:32It's a new podcast themselves.

0:39:34It's called Tech Meme Ride Home.

0:39:37you can just go whatever your podcast app is just go there the easiest way to find out more just use your podcast app and

0:39:43search for tech meme ride home t8 t e ch m e m e

0:39:48So tech meme comm is a fantastic site. I've talked about it many times over the years. It's one of my very very favorite

0:39:56It's one of the websites. I check every day just to see what the heck is new in

0:39:59the sort of things that I tend to read and link to and care about

0:40:05But it's effectively a sort of ranked by order of importance daily tech news site of things around the web

0:40:13and

0:40:16It's not entirely algorithmic. I think they do have some algorithms behind it, but they use human editors to sort of

0:40:22Put things in order and decide where to link to and when there's a story with a bunch of other people

0:40:28Linking to the same thing they they aggregate all of those links into topics

0:40:34It's really a great site if you've never checked it out. But anyway, what they've done with

0:40:38this podcast is they're taking what Techmeme is good at and distilling it into podcast

0:40:42form. And they call it the ride home because they're doing it every weekday, Monday to

0:40:47Friday, posting around 5 p.m. Eastern each afternoon. And each episode is only 15 to

0:40:5320 minutes long. It's a great format. It is hosted by Brian McCullough, who also hosts

0:41:01a great podcast called the Internet History Podcast. Internet History Podcast has been

0:41:05around for about four years now. And they've had great episodes. I'll put them in the show

0:41:11notes, but they have one with Don Melton, who was, you guys should probably know, is

0:41:15one of the originators at Apple of the Safari project. Oh, Malik had a great episode. But

0:41:23anyway, Brian is a terrific podcast host, and he does a fantastic job. Think of tech

0:41:29me ride home as sort of like NPR for technical nerds for tech nerd news. It's really, really

0:41:37good. So my thanks to them for sponsoring the show. And rather than give you a URL,

0:41:43although the internet history podcast is at internet history podcast.com. But for tech

0:41:49meme ride home, really, instead of a URL, the best thing to do is just search for tech

0:41:53meme ride home in your podcast app and subscribe, give it a listen. I really like it. It's really

0:41:59good. And again, only 15, 20 minutes long, so it's not like you're signing up for two hours or

0:42:05something like that. Really, really a great show. I really like it. All right, what were we talking

0:42:12about? Early days, 9/11. The early days. While we're talking about downers, like 9/11, I think,

0:42:21you know, why don't we get it out of the way and talk about Dean Allen and textism in terms of

0:42:28So Dean, a little bit like you, for those of you who don't know, Dean Allen wrote a

0:42:34website called Textism. I don't forget when it's, he sort of hung up, but it started before

0:42:41Daring Fireball. I believe it was around 2001 when Textism started. And I think he stopped

0:42:47around 2006 or 2007. And then he came back briefly, but then sort of disappeared mostly

0:42:54from the web, and then sadly took his own life a few months ago. Man, was textism great. That's

0:43:07the thing that came out of Dean's passing and those of us who knew him, either personally or

0:43:13even if you just knew him through the website, was how many people, how many discussions I had

0:43:17uh just with and they just all revolved around holy **** was

0:43:23text is the **** or not. Yeah. Do you remember when you first

0:43:28saw this? I don't remember when I first saw it but I remember

0:43:32how I felt every time I you know like saw a new post and it

0:43:38was like this sort of like and I was like damn it like my I

0:43:46I can't write that well.

0:43:48Like I can't do it.

0:43:49I can try, but I'm not gonna be able to do it.

0:43:53Like I think Paul Ford,

0:43:57like whenever Paul Ford writes something,

0:43:59I'm just like, Jesus Christ.

0:44:01How does he, ah, damn it.

0:44:05I'm never gonna be able to do that.

0:44:07And Dean was like, every post it was like, ah.

0:44:12And it didn't have to be long.

0:44:14And it was always so simple and straightforward

0:44:17and just sort of, you know,

0:44:18like talking about like nothing basically.

0:44:22And it was just, you know,

0:44:23they were just like these perfect little

0:44:25chunks of wonderfulness.

0:44:29- What was your one that you,

0:44:30I remember talking with you about it,

0:44:32your favorite one was,

0:44:33was it like how to cook a chicken or?

0:44:35- Yeah, it was like how to cook soup.

0:44:38- Oh yeah, how to make soup.

0:44:41- Yeah, and you know, he starts off with like,

0:44:43you need hydrogen and oxygen to make the water,

0:44:48it sort of starts from there.

0:44:49And that actually, I don't think that was on Textism.

0:44:55I think he ran another site called Cardigan Industries.

0:44:58And I was never clear on what the difference was

0:45:02between that and Textism.

0:45:03But the soup thing was on there.

0:45:09- Yeah, I've got a link to the archive.org thing.

0:45:12I'll put it in the show notes.

0:45:14Yeah, it was Cardigan Industries.

0:45:19I'm not sure what the difference was either.

0:45:20And I even got to know Dean personally for a while,

0:45:23but he was, you could ask him questions like that

0:45:27and he would evade them.

0:45:30- He was like Tom Bombadil, you know?

0:45:33- Yeah, he was.

0:45:34- It was just like you ask him a question

0:45:36and he starts singing a song about something,

0:45:38it's like he wouldn't sing,

0:45:39but it's the same sort of thing.

0:45:41It was like, you know, just, I'm not going to talk about that.

0:45:43Yeah. But he had, it was, it was,

0:45:45it was sort of like meeting a street magician too,

0:45:50where you don't even realize what's happened until it's happened.

0:45:53It wasn't like you'd ask him like,

0:45:54what the hell is the difference between cardigan and textism?

0:45:57And he wouldn't just give you like no answer and be rude about it.

0:46:00He would make you feel as though he, you know,

0:46:04it wasn't the least bit rude at all.

0:46:09But you'd realize at the end of it that he hadn't said it,

0:46:12he hadn't explained it in the least bit. Yeah.

0:46:16There's a funny gag. I'm,

0:46:20I'm looking at the Cardigan industries and I still enjoy it, but, uh,

0:46:24the way he formatted the dates is he has in text January 10,

0:46:29uh, and then the year,

0:46:33the first two digits of the year are rendered as an image, the two O,

0:46:37and then just the O-1 is text.

0:46:39And that's such a Dean Allen gag.

0:46:43- Yeah.

0:46:46- It's like a throwback to like,

0:46:47I don't know, like mechanical devices

0:46:53that would tell you what the day is or something like that.

0:46:55But they would, like growing up,

0:46:58they would have like the 19 was pre-rendered

0:47:00or something like that.

0:47:01- Exactly, exactly.

0:47:02Yeah.

0:47:03And then that, you know, that was the other thing

0:47:05that his sights were beautifully designed. It was sort of like, again, that feeling for me of like,

0:47:14"Damn it, that's so good. I can't quite get there."

0:47:19Pete: Right. "Fuse two hydrogen with one oxygen and repeat until you have enough."

0:47:28Exactly. What a beautiful sentence. While the water is heating, raise some cattle.

0:47:33Pay a man with grim eyes to do the slaughtering, preferably while you are away.

0:47:39It's so good. It really is. So good.

0:47:46He, you know, it's easy to get maudlin about somebody after he's passed. But I,

0:47:56and I would have said it while he was alive. He was just the best at it, of having a site that's

0:48:03like your site and you post these little things either on a daily basis or somewhat regularly.

0:48:10He was just the best at it. He really was.

0:48:14Jon Moffitt I totally agree. I totally agree.

0:48:17Uh, huge inspiration for me and you know, and you too, absolutely. You know, cocky was absolutely

0:48:25huge inspiring me and sort of figuring out a format that I could do it. Um,

0:48:31but it's an inner like you and Dean, like as dual influences, it was like, and I think, I don't

0:48:40think you'll take this the wrong way. It's not cause I certainly don't mean it as an insult in

0:48:44in the least, but it was like, I totally got what you were doing. And with Dean, I, I didn't

0:48:50even get it. I just knew that I loved it. Like, I don't even know what you did there.

0:48:54It's like, I loved, I'd read a post from him and I'd, I would think I'm not even sure what

0:48:59he did there, but I loved it. Yeah. I would like to try to do something like that. Yeah.

0:49:07There was, yeah, there was clearly something else going on behind the curtain that you

0:49:11know about. Whereas, you know, like I can't help being just straightforward. So like it,

0:49:19you know, it's pretty much what you see is what you get. But it's always nice discovering those

0:49:24sites, you know, like Dean's site where you don't quite understand where they're coming from, but

0:49:32God, it's wonderful to read, you know? All right. Yeah. It always felt like there was a backstory

0:49:40and in joke, in very, you know, like a whole bunch of people who know exactly,

0:49:45it was written as though everybody knew what was going on. And then I remember at one point,

0:49:50like saying, like, well, the hell with this, I'm going back to the beginning and reading this whole

0:49:54thing, you know, going to his archive, I'm going to read the whole thing, and then it'll all make

0:49:57sense to me. And it didn't, it was, it just started like the first post, the first few posts

0:50:02started from the idea that everybody knew what was going on here. But it, it wasn't.

0:50:10I don't know. And we can parlay from our remembrances of Dean to just sort of talking about that era

0:50:20as a whole. And I don't want to make it seem as though you and I are like the last two

0:50:31gunslinger standing from an era because there's all sorts of people who wrote back then who are

0:50:36are still around. And there's people like Dave Weiner who were doing it, you know, effectively

0:50:43started, you know, blogging like at Hotwired in like '94, '95.

0:50:48Yeah, yeah.

0:50:50You know, who's, as far as I know, has published on a regular basis, daily basis probably, other

0:50:58than when he was like, you know, dealing with like, you know, family issues or something

0:51:02like that, you know. I mean, these guys never stop.

0:51:05Yeah

0:51:07but there was like a a

0:51:10Community and and you know and it sort of ties together with like the early years of South by Southwest where at least that's where we'd all

0:51:18get together

0:51:20And there's so many people who were writing back then who just over the years

0:51:24Stopped or moved on to other things at the very least and there aren't many sites from that group of people

0:51:32Who what did we used to call it? Even you when I can the sidebar of your site?

0:51:36You'd have like a list of other recommended sites. We had like a name for a blog role blog role. That's it. Yeah

0:51:42There just aren't many sites from that era that are still around

0:51:47Yeah, and there's something sad about that and I don't know if you you know

0:51:52What is it about about doing this that that you think has kept you going on a regular basis?

0:52:00- Ugh. God, I don't even know. I mean, I think that, you know, I mean, it became my job several

0:52:15years ago. So that's one thing. - Well, when did that happen? When did you go full time?

0:52:19- So 2005. So like February 2005. - Right.

0:52:23And, you know, I did it, I basically had a, you know, like a PBS NPR-style pledge drive

0:52:31where I said, "Hey, I just quit my job. Like, I want to do kotka.org full-time. Like,

0:52:36will you support me? You know, please sign up for, you know, please give me, you know,

0:52:4320 bucks or something." And I had all sorts of prizes. Like, I had books signed by Malcolm

0:52:48Glidewell and, you know, memberships in various things and free software and all that sort of

0:52:56stuff. And, you know, I was able to get enough to do it to, you know, sort of bootstrap it for the

0:53:06first year. And what were you doing before that to support yourself? I was a web designer. Just

0:53:12like freelance, right? No. So I worked at a financial services organization in New York

0:53:19called the Bond Market Association. And yeah, so it was basically all these big companies that

0:53:28traded bonds in 2004, 2005. They were all the companies that blew up the country,

0:53:36or almost blew up the country two, three years later. We were at work and we're like, "Hey,

0:53:44there are these new things called CDOs. Maybe we should make a site that explains what they are

0:53:52and collects information about their pricing and all that sort of stuff."

0:53:58And we presented that idea to these bond companies and they were like, "Nope."

0:54:06We don't want any transparency about this.

0:54:08I had no idea that you know.

0:54:12Yeah, yeah.

0:54:13We don't want people to know what's going on.

0:54:14No, they didn't.

0:54:16You know, with good reason. There was nothing good going on.

0:54:22We do not want people looking behind this curtain.

0:54:27No, no.

0:54:29We're sort of, you know, and they're like, you know, they're basically, you know,

0:54:33all these companies are like basically paying the dues, paying their dues, paying for this

0:54:40bond market association to exist. So we were like, yeah, okay, I guess we're not going to do that.

0:54:44There was, so going pro and being able to do it full time, I think you're saying is one of the

0:54:55reasons you've been able to keep doing it. And I think that that's probably true for me as well.

0:55:00I think if I hadn't been able to do it full time, I don't know that I would have stopped

0:55:06writing during Fireball, but I think it might have gotten very sporadic because I, I doing it as a

0:55:12side thing was exhausting. I was exhilarated by it, but the thing that, the only thing that kept

0:55:19me going, uh, like in the first four years before I went full time in 2006 was the notion that there

0:55:26I'd figure out some way to do it full time. And if that had never happened, eventually that would

0:55:33have given enough years. It's like, "Oh, this is not going to happen." I think without that carrot

0:55:42in front of me, it would have been too hard to keep going. And I don't blame people. That's the

0:55:48other thing is I get it that there were lots of people with very popular web blogs back then who

0:55:53who had no desire to do it full-time. But I also see how it wasn't sustainable to

0:55:58write as regularly as they were without that.

0:56:02Well, I mean, once people start stopping, then your impetus to keep going, to keep sort

0:56:10of writing within this group of similar-minded people, a little bit of that goes away every

0:56:16time someone stops. And people were getting married, having kids, starting companies,

0:56:25and just plain had other responsibilities.

0:56:28I don't think after my son was born, if I wasn't doing the site full time, I think

0:56:34it would have just stopped completely because I would have had a job and a new son and that

0:56:43would have been the thing that had to go, you know?

0:56:46- That's interesting.

0:56:47See, for me, it was the opposite.

0:56:48Jonas was born in 2004, so that was two years

0:56:51before I went full-time.

0:56:53And I found it to be one of the most remarkably

0:56:58productive periods of my life.

0:57:00Now, part of it was that what I was doing to support myself

0:57:03was like mostly freelance web design

0:57:05and other consulting type stuff.

0:57:08So I was doing it from home, so I didn't have to go

0:57:10somewhere at nine in the morning.

0:57:12But like, I literally,

0:57:16I think the original version of Markdown came out

0:57:20right after Jonas was born and all of the stuff,

0:57:23you know, like that whole first year,

0:57:25in addition to writing during Fireball

0:57:26was when Markdown went from like a public beta to a 1.0.

0:57:31All while I had like an infant son.

0:57:35But I just have this vivid,

0:57:37I remember where my desk was in our old house

0:57:39when he was born. And I would just be the one who, if he was up late at night, that

0:57:44I would get him and take him out of the bedroom. And I remember doing so much work on Markdown

0:57:52with Jonas literally on my lap. Like I'd put my one leg on top of my knee and just

0:57:57sort of use it as a—my lap as a cradle, and I'd be sitting there typing "Pearl

0:58:03Code." And I just, I also remember writing a lot of daring Fireball articles at like

0:58:08three or four in the morning with him on my lap. So I totally get it that if you have a day job,

0:58:15it is incompatible. If you have to actually, you know, and then I would just sleep till noon or

0:58:18whatever. But I get it. I do get how, you know, the group of people I'm talking about, we were

0:58:28largely about the same age and certainly the older we get, it's effectively the same age. You know,

0:58:33like back then, you know, it felt like, you know, if I was 29 and somebody else was 33,

0:58:40it'd be like, "Oh, you're a couple years older than me." Now it's like, "Yeah, we're exactly

0:58:45the same age." Yeah. And I think starting companies too, like so many of the people we know from back

0:58:53then started their own companies and it was, you know, with actual products and stuff like that.

0:58:57in it. So yeah, super, super time consuming. So I can I get it. Yeah, I mean, you know,

0:59:05Stuart Butterfield, who, you know, is now the CEO of Slack, and, you know, co founded Flickr and

0:59:11all that stuff. Like he, his blog was one of my favorites. Yeah, I actually had Stuart in the back

0:59:16of my head for this. And it's like, well, I kind of get why he, he stopped blogging. Of course. Yeah,

0:59:23Of course. It's kind of fascinating watching, just as a side note, watching,

0:59:32like I kind of love good 2.0s. And it's kind of fascinating watching Slack and seeing it as

0:59:43Flickr 2.0. And like, you know, because I think in hindsight, he clearly, I think he and Katarina

0:59:50sold Flickr to Yahoo way too soon for way too little. And then they regretted eventually,

0:59:57you know, quickly regretted all the loss of control that they had. And now with Slack,

1:00:02it's sort of the opposite. And he's sort of built it up as this thing that he's, he's not going to

1:00:07have, you know, if he ever, if Slack ever does sell or whatever, it'll be on his terms. It's

1:00:13It's so interesting to me to watch it.

1:00:15- Yeah.

1:00:17- And yet there's still certain aspects of it

1:00:20that are still so stewardy, you know?

1:00:22In a way that the original version of Flickr was very,

1:00:26you know, you could see the DNA.

1:00:28- Exactly, yeah.

1:00:31You know, and I feel like, you know,

1:00:35Ev is trying to do a similar thing with Medium.

1:00:37Like, you know, he keeps bashing away at the same problem.

1:00:42- Right, right.

1:00:43- And Medium's like a 3.0.

1:00:44- Right.

1:00:45- It's like Vlogger and then Twitter and then Medium

1:00:49for him.

1:00:49And maybe Odeo is like a 0.5 in there somewhere.

1:00:54Which is, you know, Odeo's super interesting

1:00:58because it's like, you know, talk about being too early.

1:01:00- Right.

1:01:01- You know, it was like riding like the second wave

1:01:03of podcasting and now we're in like the eighth wave

1:01:05of podcasting or something and it's like really going now.

1:01:08- Yeah, now it's really become a thing and you know,

1:01:11Everybody mainstream, like CBS News has podcasts.

1:01:16It's like you couldn't get more mainstream.

1:01:19And Odeo, they clearly, Ev,

1:01:21he's always been so good at seeing

1:01:25where internet-based publishing in general is going

1:01:30and what would be the next big thing.

1:01:31And he was so clearly right that podcasting

1:01:34had a big, bright future ahead of it.

1:01:35It was just the wrong time.

1:01:38- Yeah.

1:01:40- Yeah, Ev is like one of the best,

1:01:42I think product people like ever.

1:01:45- Yeah, totally.

1:01:46I totally agree.

1:01:47Because he has that Steve Jobsian thing

1:01:51of being able to see where it's going way long in advance.

1:01:56That this is, we're not gonna,

1:01:59literally like one of Jobs's famous quotes

1:02:02was something to the effect of,

1:02:04we don't build what people ask us to build.

1:02:07We figure out what they want

1:02:09and then build it for them.

1:02:11- Right, right.

1:02:13Yeah, and going back to the early days of blogging

1:02:16and Blogger and stuff like that, I remember,

1:02:19Blogger at the time was still this thing that FTP'd files

1:02:27to people's shell account.

1:02:31They were talking about it when they were thinking

1:02:38about doing blogspot like a hosted blogger thing,

1:02:41they were talking about like, this is gonna,

1:02:44Chinese people blogging is gonna like revolutionize

1:02:51politics in the world.

1:02:53And like they knew, like Matt and Ev,

1:02:58Matt Howey and Ev and Meg and Paul Bausch,

1:03:06like the discussions they were having are still like these same discussions that were like,

1:03:11like it, you know, it happened, you know, all of that stuff came to pass.

1:03:15I always felt a bit guilty because I could see that they were doing that and I could tell that

1:03:20they were right. And I found it terribly exciting. And I really didn't have a desire to contribute

1:03:27to building that sort of thing. I just wanted to use it myself. Like, like, I think it's,

1:03:34you know, I honestly feel it's, you know, not to get corny about it, but I honestly feel that with

1:03:40Daring Fireball, I feel like I've always felt that I was born at the right time. Like, I've always

1:03:45felt very, very comfortable with like being a child of the 80s and, you know, going through

1:03:51the 90s as a young adult. But I just, in my bones, I feel like Daring Fireball is what I was meant to

1:03:59to do, you know, like rather than, I guess I contributed in some ways by inventing Markdown,

1:04:04you know, to helping other people publish, but for the most part, I just wanted to use

1:04:10it. Like what keeps me going is that I never, there's never been like a week I've been doing

1:04:16this for 15 and a half years, something like that. I never finish a week and think that

1:04:21I wrote about everything I wish I had written about for the last week. Like there's never,

1:04:26You know, like I've never felt like the ideas are dry.

1:04:31That's like the opposite.

1:04:33I have the opposite problem of what I think about

1:04:36when it comes to like, "Mm, should I write a book?"

1:04:39Ideas. - Right.

1:04:40- None. - Right.

1:04:41- It's just a box, like a very dusty box

1:04:45that is completely empty.

1:04:46Whereas ideas for things to write about

1:04:49or link to on "Daring Fireball," I never catch up.

1:04:52It's like I've, it's like the Lucy at the chocolate factory.

1:04:57- Exactly.

1:04:58Yeah, I mean, and I feel like it's been getting worse for me

1:05:03like now it kind of bothers me like at the end of the week,

1:05:07I'm like, God damn it, I did not get enough done.

1:05:10Like I need to hire some more people

1:05:12or I don't know, something.

1:05:14Have you ever wanted to hire anybody to like grow the site?

1:05:19- Let's hold that thought.

1:05:21- Let's hold that thought. - Okay, okay.

1:05:23- I'm gonna thank another one of our friends

1:05:25and we will pick it up right there

1:05:26'cause that is actually one of the things

1:05:28I wanted to talk about.

1:05:29Our next sponsor is another new sponsor,

1:05:32very, very excited about this one too, Flow.

1:05:35What is Flow?

1:05:36Flow is a beautiful project management system

1:05:39for teams everywhere.

1:05:41It is the easiest way to run your team,

1:05:43to manage projects, to track tasks,

1:05:45and stay up to date with everything happening at work.

1:05:49If you're having trouble managing a busy team,

1:05:51battling floods of email and notifications,

1:05:54and just struggling to keep up with who's working on what,

1:05:57who's assigned to what, then Flow is for you.

1:06:00And one of the best things about Flow,

1:06:01and I think it's a perfect fit for my audience,

1:06:05is that it is designed by real designers,

1:06:09and it looks beautiful, and there's so much clarity

1:06:13in the interface in terms of what am I looking at,

1:06:17what is this?

1:06:18so clear when you look at it in terms of how it works. It's so clearly not like a task

1:06:24management project management system built by non-designing engineers. Really, really

1:06:32great. You can just go to the website and check it out and you'll see it instantly

1:06:35that it's really, really good for designers. Their world-class design team has worked with

1:06:40companies like Apple, Slack, TED, and Starbucks. That's some of the people who've worked

1:06:46with them. It's really simple and beautiful to use. And this year, now Flow's been around

1:06:52for a while, but they've done like effectively a 2.0 and rebuilt Flow from the ground up

1:06:56to focus on making it the fastest, easiest, and most flexible way to visually plan and

1:07:01manage all of your team's work. So they have a brand new look and feel with new features,

1:07:07and they're offering listeners of the show something special, an exclusive first look

1:07:11at this all new Flow. So there's no reason that you should feel overwhelmed and distracted

1:07:15by the tools that are supposed to be doing the opposite, helping you feel organized and

1:07:19productive. So what you can do to find out more is go to getflow.com. That's their

1:07:28domain name, getflow.com/thetalkshow. So not only do you get a sneak peek at the new stuff,

1:07:35but they also have discounts for people who follow that link. If you sign up for an annual

1:07:40plan, you save 50%, which is a huge discount. I can't remember the last time anybody's

1:07:44offered a 50% discount. If you go monthly, it's a 30% discount, which is still pretty

1:07:49significant. So go to getflow.com/thetalkshow and check them out. You really got to look

1:07:55at it and see it. It's very, very, very nice to look at. My thanks to them.

1:08:01So have I ever thought about hiring somebody? To me, it's one of the big differences between

1:08:06Kaki and Daring Fireball. There's never been anything on Daring Fireball not by me. Have

1:08:14I thought about it? Yeah. But it's this point, it feels like Cal Ripken's streak. Like I,

1:08:22like, and part of it too, is that I feel like you're, you're more like Johnny Carson,

1:08:31like the, you don't, there's your natural and Johnny had, you know, guest hosts,

1:08:36you know, who went on to bigger and better things, including Letterman and Leno and,

1:08:42you know, all sorts of Gary Shandling, all sorts of people who went on to great things,

1:08:46guest hosted The Tonight Show so that Johnny could take it easy and work, as Letterman once said,

1:08:52backbreaking three nights a week for 40 weeks a year. I also feel like I'm more like Letterman

1:09:02though. Like I'm neurotic and like I'm not comfortable with that. Like Johnny had no

1:09:07reason to be worried about it because he was Johnny Carson. It didn't matter if David Letterman

1:09:11guest hosted on Monday. It didn't matter how good he did. Johnny is still Johnny. And I feel like

1:09:17you've had guest hosts. I forget. I mean, I've lost track of how many guest hosts there have been at

1:09:22Kotke over the years. Yeah. I mean, more than a dozen, I would say, at least. I mean, it started,

1:09:29I mean, the first time was when I went to South by Southwest in, was it 2000, maybe 2001?

1:09:39And I don't know why I felt the need to keep the site updated while I was there or to have

1:09:47the site be updated while I was there. But I asked my friend Greg Nous to fill in. And

1:09:56I don't know, it just seemed like a, I don't know. I can't even remember why I did it.

1:10:02I guess it must have seemed like I needed to. I don't know.

1:10:06Aaron Swartz guest host once or no, no, no, no.

1:10:12I remember Greg doing it. Greg remains one of the world's best experts on movable type.

1:10:20I don't know how relevant that skill is, but it's still,

1:10:28if whenever I need serious help with movable type, I still go to Greg.

1:10:32Yeah. He's also a wonderful writer. Like I love his writing. He's, he's really good.

1:10:38I wish, I wish he would do more of it. If he's listening, Greg, write more.

1:10:44Yeah. For me, I don't know. It's irrational. And at this point it is, you know, I'm not gonna say

1:10:52it's trouble, but it means that like, even when I go on vacation, I'm still posting at least

1:10:58something to "Daring Fireball" almost every day.

1:11:01And I don't mind it, but I wonder at this point,

1:11:07like Andy Baio's talking about people from that era,

1:11:11Andy asked me a few years ago,

1:11:14what's the longest period of time

1:11:16between post to "Daring Fireball" since it started?

1:11:19And in the early days, it might be,

1:11:21it's easily a couple of days because like from 2002 to 2004,

1:11:25I didn't have the short articles,

1:11:28the ones that I call linked list entries.

1:11:30I only had like full big headline articles.

1:11:34But I don't think I ever went a week

1:11:37without an article in that era.

1:11:39And then from 2004 onward,

1:11:44my guess would be I've never gone more than 72 hours

1:11:49without posting something.

1:11:50And if I'm wrong, it wouldn't be much longer than that.

1:11:54- Yeah, I love, you know, like I love doing the site

1:11:59and like it, I mean, it's obviously like the thing

1:12:05that I do that gives me the most,

1:12:07that makes me the happiest sort of overall,

1:12:11like intellectually, emotionally, whatever,

1:12:14but I really love getting away from it and like not,

1:12:18you know, like I was on vacation a couple of weeks ago

1:12:22And a friend of mine, Chris Anthony,

1:12:27took over the site for the week

1:12:29and I didn't read it until I got back.

1:12:32I just didn't read it.

1:12:34I stayed off Twitter.

1:12:37I still use Instagram because I feel like Instagram

1:12:40is more of a personal sort of thing.

1:12:43It's not work.

1:12:44But I just, I love, I don't know,

1:12:47I love getting away from it.

1:12:48And then I come back and I feel like I'm like,

1:12:50okay, let's do this thing again.

1:12:52You know, it's really, I don't know,

1:12:53it's really nice to recharge.

1:12:55- Yeah, I don't know, I don't know.

1:12:59- I don't know what that feels like.

1:13:02- I don't know what that would feel like, I really don't.

1:13:05- Maybe you should give it a try sometime.

1:13:07- I don't know.

1:13:10- Does Amy, like, does Amy give you shit about that?

1:13:14Like, or does she just sort of like, this is the deal.

1:13:17This is who I married.

1:13:20- No, I would say a little bit of column A

1:13:23and a little bit of column B.

1:13:24And I feel like I've gotten good at,

1:13:27Twitter has made it much easier, in my opinion,

1:13:33because we can go on vacation

1:13:36and just by checking Twitter every once in a while,

1:13:39I can queue up things that are good to link to

1:13:43instead of doing it right there and pecking it out.

1:13:46I have a way, I have the movable type iPhone plugin thing,

1:13:51which is a fairly reasonable interface

1:13:54to posting on the phone.

1:13:55But usually what I do is I use,

1:13:57and I wanted to ask you some questions

1:14:01about how you do what you do,

1:14:03but for the most part, if I'm on vacation

1:14:06or just traveling in general,

1:14:08I'll find things that I think are worth linking to,

1:14:11and I'll send those links to Pinboard,

1:14:15the successor, Delicious.

1:14:17And for the most part, everything in my Pinboard

1:14:21is just sort of a waiting queue

1:14:24for things I might post to during Fireball.

1:14:26Even when I'm not on vacation,

1:14:27I use Pinboard for this exact purpose.

1:14:29Like in the morning when I wake up,

1:14:30if I read the, you know,

1:14:31I'm not really ready to post stuff to during Fireball,

1:14:34or if I'm just on the phone in general,

1:14:36I just send it to Pinboard.

1:14:38And I find it useful because when I come back to Pinboard

1:14:42and I have time, like let's say I'm on vacation,

1:14:44but I've, you know, here I'll take 30 minutes here.

1:14:46And sometimes you can, like the best way to tell

1:14:48if I'm on vacation is if I've got, you know,

1:14:52if you look like an RSS where the times are actually there,

1:14:55and I have four posts on a Wednesday,

1:14:57but they're all within 30 minutes, you know,

1:14:59like three to 3.30 in the afternoon.

1:15:02But it's because I've cued them up,

1:15:04and I may not have them written,

1:15:05but I know what I wanna say.

1:15:06But I'll look at like maybe the 10 most recent things

1:15:09that I've cued up, and like six of them,

1:15:11I'm now like, eh, and I'm, nah, that's not worth it.

1:15:15And it's good to have that cooling off period,

1:15:19for me at least, in terms of what's actually

1:15:22worth linking to.

1:15:23- Yeah, I mean, that's exactly how I approach it.

1:15:29I don't use pinboard, I use Instapaper,

1:15:31but that's exactly how I do it.

1:15:33And the thing about the cooling off period

1:15:35is totally a thing.

1:15:37Like I'll find something and then I'll go back to it

1:15:40a few hours later and I'm like, yeah, no,

1:15:42not feeling it anymore.

1:15:44- Yeah, so Amy might have a different answer

1:15:46as to how annoying it is when we're ostensibly on vacation

1:15:50and how much of my day I still spend

1:15:53doing that sort of thing.

1:15:55But I don't think it takes that much time.

1:15:57And for me, the things that take so much time

1:15:59are when I write real articles.

1:16:01And that's something I don't do when I'm on vacation

1:16:04and do take breaks from

1:16:06and do come back sometimes feeling refreshed.

1:16:09Like it's interesting when you look at the

1:16:11Daring Fireball archives,

1:16:13if you just go to daringfireball.net/archive,

1:16:17it only lists my quote unquote full articles,

1:16:22but they're organized by month

1:16:24going all the way back to 2002.

1:16:27And you can see, and it's not purposeful,

1:16:29I don't do it on purpose,

1:16:30but you can see that there are stretches

1:16:33where it's very, very dry,

1:16:35like two or three month period,

1:16:37three, four month period,

1:16:38where I've only had like two or three per month.

1:16:40And then other times where there's seven, eight, nine,

1:16:44a month for months at a time.

1:16:46So there's something to that.

1:16:49But to me, the actual just linking to a few things a day

1:16:53part, it's so easy to me.

1:16:56And I'm so, even when I'm on vacation,

1:16:59I'm still like a news junkie.

1:17:00Like I can't turn that off.

1:17:02- Yeah, I don't know.

1:17:06I am not a news junkie, which is a little bit of a weird thing to say about myself,

1:17:12I guess.

1:17:13Well, that's one of the most interesting things about Khaki over, khaki.org over the

1:17:18years is that it's not really, it's never really been, maybe the nine 11 stretch was

1:17:23an obvious exception. But for the most part, it's absolutely never been about news. Never.

1:17:32I mean, the closest thing to news that I regularly count on

1:17:37is when, you know, it's off, kakia.org is off

1:17:40in the first place where I see the trailer to a movie

1:17:43that, oh yeah, I wanna see that.

1:17:45- Right, right.

1:17:46- So if you call, you know, new movie trailers news,

1:17:49you know, maybe that's the closest you get to it.

1:17:52- Right.

1:17:54Yeah, you know, it's, I feel like,

1:17:59I don't know. I don't read, I don't read the news a whole lot. Like I,

1:18:04I don't keep up with the news, you know, quote unquote the news. Um,

1:18:08I think a lot of it is kind of unnecessary and

1:18:14just sort of, I don't know,

1:18:17there are very few things in my life that I need that much information about.

1:18:22Um, you know, like, like the,

1:18:27there are entire channels devoted to how the stock market does minute by minute. Like that seems

1:18:33insane to me. Like you normal people don't need that information. You know, but there are plenty

1:18:40of sort of normal people that that that do like watch that stuff sort of meticulously.

1:18:46And I don't know, I just don't find I'm just not that way about it. I don't know.

1:18:55No, I get it. I don't think it's healthy. I admit to doing it myself, but I don't think it's healthy.

1:19:04And I think that people who don't pay that much attention to the news are probably much happier

1:19:09than people who do. Right. I mean, I guess maybe it's just a matter of like what you pay meticulous

1:19:16attention to because you know I'm on Twitter all day and you know obviously

1:19:24like I do see the news I'm aware of news happening right but I'm not interested

1:19:31in sort of drilling down into you know a lot of a lot of things you know I guess

1:19:37I'm more interested in I don't know like longer rain you know longer themes and

1:19:44ideas and and and things like that. Um you know in in the you

1:19:52know in the in the sites more expansive moments in the sites

1:19:55you know sort of like at at its best. Um but there are

1:20:02obviously like you know silly videos and stuff too because

1:20:05silly people love silly videos. Do you think I think that

1:20:10that's one of the ways that kaki.org is the most different now from the early days is that it's

1:20:17large, you know, on a regular, almost daily basis, there's videos that are posted. Whereas like you

1:20:24even said, like back in, you know, 2000, 2001, 2002, even for a couple of years after that,

1:20:30it was it's so inordinately expensive to host video. That video was just it, you just couldn't

1:20:39post it. It was too expensive. And the way we would post it back then is you'd have to

1:20:46put it on your own server because there was nothing like YouTube, nothing to even compare

1:20:52it to. And then everybody's hosting account had a monthly bandwidth limit and you would

1:20:58just multiply how many page views you had by how big the video was and you easily got

1:21:03to that limit within like 20 minutes. And then people would get like, forget what the error

1:21:09message was, but you know, there's like an error code, like temporarily suspended. Right. Yeah. I

1:21:16mean, YouTube and Vimeo, like they changed, changed that whole thing where, you know,

1:21:21just made embedding videos on sites easy. You know, and I think, you know, I mean, I was a

1:21:29designer and I, you know, the, like Oscillate was very visual.

1:21:35And, you know, I think it was just sort of this thing where it

1:21:39was like, you know, I, the site, you know, katky.org was on like a

1:21:44friend's server and I wasn't really paying that much for it.

1:21:47And so I couldn't really embed images or, you know, certainly

1:21:53not videos and things like that.

1:21:55And so it was sort of out of necessity that it was very text

1:21:57text heavy. And sort of as things evolved and moved to my own server and all that sort

1:22:04of stuff and bandwidth has just gotten cheaper and cheaper and cheaper and cheaper. Now it's

1:22:10like I want the site to be as visual as possible because that's... I love text and I think

1:22:20Tim Carmody has written on my site that if you bet against text, you will lose.

1:22:25Text will always be around and it will always be a contender for the thing that people are always

1:22:35using. But I think that a lot of what I watch and consume is visual, whether that's good photography

1:22:48or movie trailers like you said, or some weird thing on Vimeo.

1:22:56Did you see, I'm sure you saw, because I know you're a Spike Jonze fan, he did the

1:23:01recent music video for Apple with the HomePod and then today Ad Age I think has it exclusively

1:23:06the behind the scenes.

1:23:08Oh, I didn't see that behind the scenes.

1:23:11Oh, well you're going to love it. I thought this was obvious. I thought it was obvious

1:23:15is both knowing Spike Jonze and having seen the video,

1:23:18that almost everything they did was a practical effect,

1:23:21like all the stretching stuff going on

1:23:23while she danced in her apartment.

1:23:25I could tell that that was all practical.

1:23:27It didn't look like CGI to me.

1:23:29But a lot of people are obviously,

1:23:32I think just so basically assume anything

1:23:35that's a special effect is computer generated now,

1:23:37were blown away at the behind the scenes

1:23:40of how they actually did this.

1:23:41And it's just like they just had two guys behind the wall

1:23:43just pulling it backwards.

1:23:45Yeah, but it's to me effects still rule but to me it's just like a six or seven minute

1:23:52video. It's arguably more interesting than the video itself and I you know, but they're

1:23:57both lovely. But it's the sort of thing that pre YouTube you would have to like I remember

1:24:05I forget the name of it but there were like a series of DVDs that came out in the late

1:24:0990s of like great music videos. Yeah. And I've got it down here in my little podcast cave in

1:24:19the basement. It's in a box somewhere down here on DVD. But it was so fantastic. I remember watching

1:24:24it over and over and over again, because you could then watch the great music videos, but then they

1:24:28had like behind the scenes stuff. But it was the sort of thing that like pre YouTube, you'd hear

1:24:33that there was this great behind the scenes video of, you know, a Spike Jones video, but you'd have

1:24:38to figure out a way to hunt it down on, you know, it was like trying to find bootleg tape

1:24:43tapes back in the 80s. You had to know a guy and you'd hear it was more of like a rumor or a legend

1:24:51than something that you would just click a button and now you can watch it at any point you want.

1:24:55Yeah, I mean, everything, I mean, that's the thing now, like everything has DVD extras.

1:25:03Right.

1:25:03you know? I find, and it is weird, like now that cocky is so video heavy, I do find that

1:25:10it takes me longer to read your site than it used to because you can't, I can read so much

1:25:19faster than a video goes that, but that's largely what I do is I, at the end of the day, I still,

1:25:26to me, one of the sites where I just go to and read, like I don't even bother with RSS

1:25:34for your site. I just, you know, I just have this habit of just going there in a new window

1:25:39so that all the tabs are from this. But I'm just braced now that I'm not just going

1:25:45to open up a bunch of tabs that I'm going to spend at least 15 minutes watching video.

1:25:49- Right, right.

1:25:51- And that's definitely a difference.

1:25:53- Oh, definitely, yeah, it definitely is.

1:25:55And you, like you, I think, you know,

1:25:58maybe have embedded two or three videos all time, maybe?

1:26:03- Maybe, I don't like embeds, I really,

1:26:05I've done my live talk shows videos as embeds from Vimeo.

1:26:13- Right, I remember when I saw, like, I think,

1:26:19like the first embed you had, like even an image,

1:26:24like I was shocked.

1:26:27And I think it was probably like a photo of your son.

1:26:31- Yeah, I think that might've been the first image

1:26:33on "Daring Fireball" other than a graph maybe.

1:26:37- Right, right.

1:26:38It was shocking.

1:26:39It was like, oh my God.

1:26:40- I still get that.

1:26:43I even have like a list here of posts on "Daring Fireball"

1:26:48with photos/images and it's, I don't know,

1:26:53somewhere around 20.

1:26:55- Yeah, it can't be many.

1:26:56- But I know that, I don't think it's complete yet.

1:26:59I think that there might be some older ones that I've missed

1:27:01but every time I encounter one, I do that.

1:27:03Because what happens is I'll post something

1:27:06and I'll put a photo in it and I'll get like on Twitter,

1:27:10like holy shit, is this the first time

1:27:12there's ever been an image on Daring Fireball?

1:27:14And I'm like, no, it's happened like 20 times

1:27:17the last 16 years, you know. And I'm usually not, I'm usually not the sort of person who,

1:27:25I just assume that there's almost nobody who reads everything I post, right? I don't expect anybody

1:27:31to be a completionist. I'm sure there's a handful of people who are, and I know I thank them. I'm

1:27:36glad. There's way more than a handful based upon like the feedback that I've gotten in my inbox.

1:27:42There are people that pay meticulous attention and there are a lot of them.

1:27:46Well, I think it's healthier though for us to pretend that there aren't, right?

1:27:51Now don't assume that somebody is a complete, you know what I mean? Like it's, it's,

1:27:55yes. But with the images thing, I sometimes get a little, I get a little sour about it. It's like,

1:28:01it's not that rare. When are you going to update your design so it's like nice and responsive?

1:28:07Oh, it's like, whatever. I was, let's open that can of worms. A year ago, a year ago,

1:28:13I started promising people that it would happen by the end of summer because I thought if I publicly

1:28:18I mean if I publicly you told me about it. Yeah, if I publicly promised on twitter that would make

1:28:24me do it, you know and then it turned out summer was not I thought well summer will be a good time

1:28:31because there's not a lot of news and stuff and I can I can have time and then it like summer came

1:28:36and went and it didn't happen so I don't know soon I would like it to be so I don't really I'm not

1:28:41you know, there's no, there is something, it is age-related, there's no doubt about it, where if

1:28:48the, if I were my 30-year-old self, it would be done already. It's, there is some part of me

1:28:55that is, that I can tell is different and is more resistant to change. Like, I wish that it were so,

1:29:06I really don't, and the worst thing that ever happened in my opinion to it is that I've,

1:29:11when the iPhone first came out,

1:29:13I forget what the meta tag is,

1:29:16but there was something that I,

1:29:17it was a very easy bit of meta tag

1:29:20that I could add to HTML

1:29:21that made it so that if you double tap on the text column,

1:29:25it pretty much looks like what it should look like

1:29:28by default when you load it.

1:29:29So you're really just one double tap away

1:29:31from it looking pretty good on an iPhone.

1:29:35And I think that's the worst thing

1:29:36that ever happened to it.

1:29:37I think it would have been better if my existing design

1:29:40just could not be made to look good on a phone

1:29:43'cause then I would have to do it.

1:29:46It is bizarre though, and you're right to call me out on it,

1:29:49and I really don't have a good excuse

1:29:51other than laziness, I guess.

1:29:55I don't know, it just never seems like,

1:29:58it's the same reason my office is a mess,

1:30:00even though we just moved,

1:30:01is it never feels like today is the day

1:30:03where I should spend all day decluttering my office.

1:30:07I could just, you know, there's real work to be done,

1:30:10which is dicking around on the internet and posting links.

1:30:12It's like putting a healthy meal

1:30:19and some candy in front of a child.

1:30:21The candy to me is posting stuff to Daring Fireball.

1:30:25And I can't resist it.

1:30:28But I have no excuse for it.

1:30:32I don't know about you, but the iOS,

1:30:35or an iPhone in particular,

1:30:36is the majority of my traffic these days.

1:30:38If anything, I would, by the number of people

1:30:41and how much traffic I serve,

1:30:43I would be better off with an iPhone-only design

1:30:46and showing the iPhone design to people on desktop browsers

1:30:49than the other way around, just in terms of the numbers.

1:30:53- Yeah, I mean, you know, that was,

1:30:55you know, my most recent design wasn't quite mobile first,

1:31:01but it was, you know, mobile in a tie for first,

1:31:05you know, with desktop.

1:31:07as far as like how I thought about the design.

1:31:09'Cause you know, like, I don't think,

1:31:13I don't think the majority of my traffic is on mobile,

1:31:17but you know, it's trending,

1:31:19it's trending that way, certainly.

1:31:21- Yeah.

1:31:22Yeah, I don't have a good excuse.

1:31:24- Does Jonas know HTML?

1:31:27Like can you get him on the--

1:31:28- No, he's not, he's not interested.

1:31:31He's on a computer all the time, but he's really not,

1:31:37And I don't think I'm a poor father.

1:31:39It's not like I haven't tried introducing him to it.

1:31:41He just doesn't really have an interest in coding.

1:31:44And I don't know, you know,

1:31:46it seems like the sort of thing that could suddenly ignite,

1:31:52but I don't know.

1:31:52I know that by the time I was his age,

1:31:54I would have been all over it.

1:31:56It's just, you know, I don't know.

1:31:59I don't know what to do as a parent sometimes

1:32:01in terms of how much to encourage him to do things

1:32:03that I think he should be doing

1:32:04and how much I should let him follow his own interests.

1:32:08- Totally.

1:32:08Yeah, I just, like last week, I just sat down with Ollie.

1:32:13He's 10 now, and we installed Swift Playgrounds

1:32:18on his iPad, and so he played around with that.

1:32:22And you know, he's done stuff like code.org

1:32:25and a little bit of Scratch, and what's the other one?

1:32:29I can't remember the name of the other one.

1:32:32But you know, he's done some programming stuff,

1:32:34So he's aware of loops and variables and functions

1:32:39and all that sort of stuff.

1:32:40And he's done it in several different types of programs.

1:32:43But he was like, "Daddy, I think Swift is the best one."

1:32:50(laughs)

1:32:52I was like, "Oh, interesting."

1:32:53And I think one of the things that's really exciting to him

1:32:56is that I told him, I was like,

1:32:58"Okay, so once you do code here,

1:33:00you can put it into Xcode,

1:33:02which is this program that you can use

1:33:04to write actual iOS apps.

1:33:06And he was like, "Oh."

1:33:08You know, that was the thing.

1:33:09He was just like, "Oh, geez."

1:33:12- I tried, I didn't force Jonas to do the Swift playgrounds.

1:33:17You know, you're talking about the thing where you,

1:33:20like the learning to code playgrounds,

1:33:21where there's like, it's like you're guiding

1:33:23a little video game character around a 3D landscape

1:33:26with turn left, turn right, go forward.

1:33:29- Exactly.

1:33:31- I had Jonas do it, I think last summer on his iPad

1:33:35as like, well, in addition to like your summer reading,

1:33:37here's something you can do

1:33:39that's actually not just watching friends reruns on Netflix.

1:33:44And he did it, but he was sour about it

1:33:50and purposefully did it stupidly.

1:33:54When he got to the lesson about learning loops,

1:33:58instead of doing it in a loop,

1:33:59he'd just copied and paste four times

1:34:02and was sort of like doing them the worst way possible.

1:34:07And I was like, you know, that's not the right,

1:34:11that wasn't the right way to do it.

1:34:12It was like, I would say like, hey,

1:34:13did you get through three or four playgrounds,

1:34:17steps in the thing?

1:34:17And he was like, yeah, yeah, I'm done.

1:34:19And then I looked at his solutions and they were awful.

1:34:21And it was like, he was just doing it as fast as he could

1:34:25to get to watching friends reruns on Netflix.

1:34:29- Right.

1:34:30- And I was like, well, I'm not gonna force it

1:34:32down his throat.

1:34:33'Cause I feel like that it would have the opposite reaction.

1:34:36I gotta wait for him to come to me.

1:34:38I'm also dreadfully fearful at this point

1:34:44that when I go to modernize the Daring Fireball layout,

1:34:47that it'll be so much less work

1:34:50than I'd been anticipating for years,

1:34:52that it'll make me feel bad.

1:34:55- I mean, everything is,

1:34:57like you have everything templated on the backend, right?

1:34:59- Yeah.

1:35:00- So you can just change like headers and footers

1:35:02and you know, this and that.

1:35:04Yeah, and yeah, that's probably true.

1:35:08That's probably true.

1:35:09- The other part, if I have a good excuse,

1:35:11the other part is that I would like to,

1:35:13like I'm happy with the longevity of the current design

1:35:17and I would like to, with the next redesign,

1:35:21I would like to have it be like,

1:35:25this is the one for the rest of my career.

1:35:27Like just one more and measure twice,

1:35:31but at this point it's more like measure 40 times, cut once.

1:35:35- Yeah, yeah, that's a huge burden to put on yourself.

1:35:40- Right, and yeah, and as evidenced by the--

1:35:43- I can see why you're stuck in the mud

1:35:44spinning your wheels on this.

1:35:46- Right, I get in the back of my head,

1:35:48I've had this idea of, you mentioned this

1:35:50in your 20-year anniversary post

1:35:52that you think you could go another 20 years,

1:35:54And I feel like I could easily go another,

1:35:57I would love to be doing this for another 20 years,

1:36:00but thinking like, how do I make a design

1:36:01that'll last 20 or 25 years,

1:36:04is it can be a little paralyzing.

1:36:07Like I really probably, it's not helpful at all

1:36:10to have that in the back of my head.

1:36:11(laughing)

1:36:13- Okay, so take, number one, take a vacation

1:36:16and leave your phone in the safe in the hotel.

1:36:20And number two, like, you know, think simple about, about the redesign thing. That's my advice to you.

1:36:27All right. You're probably right. How many times have you redesigned kotke.org over the years?

1:36:36And your redesigns have been truly significant. Like the redesign that I have envisioned for

1:36:43Daring Fireball is the least exciting. Like the colors aren't changing. It would just be

1:36:49update the fonts and update the sizes of the fonts and make it responsive, more or less.

1:36:54Right. I mean, your task would be to make the Daring Fireball design more of itself.

1:37:02Yes.

1:37:03And also, you know, of the present era, let's say.

1:37:09Right.

1:37:10Charitably. No, I mean, I love the design of Daring Fireball.

1:37:18It's like this constant in sort of this ever-changing world

1:37:23of the web that changes all the time.

1:37:29But yeah, I don't know how many times I've redesigned,

1:37:37probably eight, six or eight, like major ones.

1:37:42- I still think of the canonical kotki.org design

1:37:46as the one that had the,

1:37:49that ever so slightly greenish yellow banner at the top

1:37:53where the khaki.org part was in Din.

1:37:57I don't know what era that is.

1:38:01It's probably somewhere around 2003, 2004,

1:38:04something like that.

1:38:05- Yeah, somewhere in there.

1:38:07Maybe even a little bit earlier.

1:38:09- Yeah, maybe.

1:38:10- I always think of the concentric,

1:38:15the concentric yellow.

1:38:16- Yeah, yeah.

1:38:17- Yellow one, I think that's my,

1:38:20like when I look at that, I was like,

1:38:22I fucking knocked that out of the park.

1:38:24(laughing)

1:38:25- It was good, it was very good.

1:38:26- And you know what, I'm not that kind of guy

1:38:28where I'm like, yeah, I did a good job.

1:38:30Mostly it's like that sucked, but it's done.

1:38:34- That was a good trick.

1:38:36It's also a sort of thing that sounds like a terrible idea

1:38:40that you're gonna have concentric color gradients

1:38:43around the entire four sides of the page.

1:38:46That sounds terrible to me, but the way--

1:38:49- It's horribly distracting.

1:38:50- Right, but the way it actually turned out

1:38:52was actually, it was like perfect, just right.

1:38:55All right, let me take one more break here

1:39:01and thank our third and final sponsor of the show.

1:39:03It's our good friends at Fracture.

1:39:06You guys know Fracture, of course.

1:39:08Fracture makes handmade photos

1:39:13prints directly on glass. Here's the gist of it if you haven't heard of them. You have photos that

1:39:20you've taken with your camera or iPhone camera, whatever other camera. You pick your favorite

1:39:25ones, you send them to Fracture, you go to their website, you pick a size from them. Could be

1:39:30really big. They've got really, really big ones that can fill up a whole wall. They've got really,

1:39:34really small ones that you can put on your desk or your mantle. And they've got all sorts of sizes

1:39:38is in between. They have square, they have rectangles. You put your picture, you show

1:39:43it to them, you send it to them, you pick your size, they send it to you and it's your

1:39:47photo directly on glass. Not like a piece of paper that they glue to the glass. Somehow

1:39:53they print on glass. I don't know how they do it. But the effect is really, really impressive.

1:40:01And then what you can do with it, it's just edge to edge, corner to corner. There is no

1:40:05no frame, there's no bezel. So like the whole direction like our cell phones are moving

1:40:10with these ever smaller bezels, like a fracture print is like the canonical ideal of where

1:40:15that's going, where it's just edge to edge picture and everything you need to hang it

1:40:19on a wall or prop it up like on a desk or whatever. It all comes in the cardboard box

1:40:24that the print comes in. So you don't need to buy anything else to hang it up. They look

1:40:30so great and it is so fun and it's so great to get your pictures off a little four-inch

1:40:37piece of glass in your pocket and actually see them really big. Like everybody, you know,

1:40:43like the megapixel wars in cameras are sort of over. Nobody really brags about megapixels

1:40:49anymore, but it turns out that like the 12 megapixel camera on your phone can take pictures

1:40:54that look really big, really good at an incredibly big size. Like you'd think, no way would

1:41:00an iPhone picture look good at like a 20-inch picture. Turns out it looks great. You've

1:41:06got plenty of pixels to spare. And looking at your pictures really big is so, it's

1:41:12just, I don't know, it's just very different than looking at them on a little tiny thing

1:41:16that fits in your pocket. Cannot recommend it highly enough. And I always say this when

1:41:21and Fracture sponsors the site.

1:41:23They are, this is like the single greatest gift idea

1:41:26for family in the history of mankind.

1:41:29So like with Mother's Day coming up,

1:41:31Father's Day after that,

1:41:33getting fracture prints of your pets or your kids

1:41:36or just you and sending them to your family,

1:41:39your parents and stuff like that,

1:41:40it's just absolutely amazing in terms of how easy it is

1:41:44to take care of the nagging idea in the back of your head

1:41:47that you have to get a gift for your mom or whoever else.

1:41:51cost effectiveness. And then just how happy they make the people you give them to really is a great

1:41:55idea. So here's where you go to find out more. Just go to fracture.me. And when you go to buy,

1:42:02you can say 15% on your first order with this exclusive code, talk ta lk 15, the digits one,

1:42:11five, talk 15. And you'll save 15%. And then don't forget to mention this podcast in there.

1:42:17one question, where did you hear about Fracture Survey?

1:42:21It helps support the show and helps them know

1:42:24where their ad money is well spent.

1:42:26So my thanks to Fracture.

1:42:27What were we talking about?

1:42:31I always forget.

1:42:32- I can't remember.

1:42:36I was listening to the Fracture thing.

1:42:40I don't have any fracture in my house

1:42:43and I think I probably need some now.

1:42:45- You really should.

1:42:46It's amazing.

1:42:47I always think I have enough.

1:42:48And then I was at Marco's house a while back.

1:42:51And they literally, I know he says it

1:42:53when on the Accidental Tech podcast

1:42:55that their house is filled with fractures.

1:42:56But it really is.

1:42:57And it's kind of amazing.

1:42:59I mean, it helps that Tiff Arment

1:43:02is actually a professional photographer.

1:43:05The pictures are actually a lot better

1:43:07than my ham-fisted pro-sumer level of photography.

1:43:12But it's one of those things

1:43:15that you really can't get enough of.

1:43:17no home that has too many photos of family members or places that you've gone, et cetera.

1:43:22Well, we could talk business. I mean, like, one of the things that's challenging doing this,

1:43:35and I think that so—I'm a little disappointed at how few people do what we do. Like,

1:43:42when I first went pro you went you know started doing cocky full-time in 2005 was a huge

1:43:47inspiration for me I started in 2006 was the last time I had like a job job and I thought at the

1:43:57time that that we were ahead of the pack because we had the background that you know the technical

1:44:07background in that era to know about things like HTML and CSS and even just getting movable

1:44:14type installed, you know, you needed to be somewhat of a nerd. And I thought, you know,

1:44:19it's no surprise that a lot of the early popular bloggers were people who had some level of

1:44:25technical acumen. I mean, Dean Allen wrote his own CMS textile or no, textile was the format.

1:44:33what was it called? Text pattern. Mark Pilgrim was a good programmer, or is it still a good

1:44:41programmer? It's no surprise that the people who were nerdy enough to know what FTP is and HTML

1:44:49were the early ones. And I thought, well, now that it's getting easier and easier to publish,

1:44:56and you can just go to WordPress.org and sign up, and you don't have to know anything about

1:45:01web hosting and you don't have to know HTML and CSS that there will be more people who

1:45:05do this independent publishing thing as their occupation and it turns out no that didn't

1:45:13happen at all and if anything there's fewer people now doing it than before.

1:45:20Yeah, I mean, you know, pro blogs were a thing before, you know, before I went, you know,

1:45:28before I went independent. You know, Gawker, well, Gizmodo was the first site, and then

1:45:35Gawker was the second site, and that was in 2002. So I, you know, I think there was an,

1:45:44there was already an sort of an established thing where you could, you could do, you could

1:45:48do blogging professionally, but you were hired to do it.

1:45:56Like it was a media site, and so you

1:45:57were hired to be a blogger for someone else.

1:46:00And that was sort of this established thing.

1:46:02And doing it by yourself was not-- you're right.

1:46:06It was not really a thing, and surprisingly few people

1:46:10picked it up afterwards.

1:46:13But I do think it's interesting now, especially

1:46:18with YouTube and Instagram, there are tons of people who are doing what we do just, you

1:46:25know, in sort of, you know, different media, like, you know, you, you know, there are plenty

1:46:29of YouTubers making, you know, a living, yes, doing, doing videos and, and, you know, there's

1:46:36people on Instagram that, that, that make money doing, you know, sponsored posts and

1:46:40all that sort of stuff if they, you know, if you have enough followers. And so, I mean,

1:46:46It's interesting. It's like, I don't know why blogs didn't take off in that way. Like

1:46:53independent pro blogs.

1:46:56Yeah, I don't know either, but YouTube is a fantastic counter example where there's

1:47:01probably an uncountable number of people, individuals who are supporting themselves,

1:47:08in some cases very, very well just doing their own YouTube channel. That's a great example.

1:47:15And I don't know why it's different.

1:47:16I don't know.

1:47:17There's something different about it.

1:47:20But one of the--

1:47:21- And now with, sorry, and now with sites like Patreon, like you've got people who,

1:47:27you know, that's, you know, you can, so you can have a YouTube channel and you can run

1:47:32ads and, you know, Google will pay you what they think is right.

1:47:38But you know, you can also appeal directly to your viewers and, you know, stick a page

1:47:42on Patreon and say, "Hey, if you like this, you should support it." And people are using

1:47:47Patreon for stuff like... And also Kickstarter has a new thing called Drip, I think. And

1:47:56people who write newsletters, people who write blogs, people who do all of those sorts of

1:48:01things or who are freelance journalists, they're using that as a way to support their independent

1:48:08And so it's it's interesting to see this kind of like boomerang back around again, you know

1:48:12yeah, and that's exactly where I'm going with this where like

1:48:16Just referencing back to the Drudge Report starting as a $10 a year email newsletter like email

1:48:23Newsletters are back in a big way and that's one of the way people are you know, supporting themselves individually Ben Thompson?

1:48:30Who's often on this show at Stratechery?

1:48:32and a whole bunch of other similar sites where

1:48:36where the basic formula that Ben kind of carved out is one time a week he posts a thing that's

1:48:46up publicly for everybody to look at, but then the other days of the week it's a members-only

1:48:52email newsletter. And the only way to see it is to pay, and people—because it's

1:48:58people are willing to pay. But what an old-school idea, right? I mean, that literally, you know,

1:49:05Drudge was doing it in 1995 before the web was really even a thing. Anyway, you wanted the things—and

1:49:16I think you started this last year, where you rebooted the idea of a membership system at

1:49:21kaki.org. Was it last year? Yeah, it was in 2016. All right, I forgot what year it was.

1:49:29I knew it was 2016 and I'd already forgotten that it's already 2018.

1:49:33So two years ago or a year and a half ago or something like that. Yeah, a year and a half ago.

1:49:38And like you said, you'd tried a membership type thing in 2005 and I'd tried a membership

1:49:46type thing in 2006 that was really ultimately just about selling t-shirts. But I did really well

1:49:53selling t-shirts. I literally could not have gotten Daring Fireball off the ground as a full-time

1:49:58job without that initial batch of t-shirts. I made like 30 grand from—or at least revenue was

1:50:05like 30 grand. Because every single dollar counted, instead of outsourcing any of it,

1:50:13I did the whole thing locally. And Amy, like every single person who bought, like from the first two

1:50:22years of me selling t-shirts, your shirt was hand-packed by my wife. And I had hundreds,

1:50:30thousands maybe of t-shirts that I had to both ship, get to my house from the local print shop

1:50:37here in Philly and then get to the post office with postage and for all the over out of the

1:50:43country ones with the custom slips filled out by hand. Wow. And all I had was a little Subaru

1:50:50Impreza, not a hatchback, like just like the smallest, the smallest four-door sedan that

1:50:57Subaru made. Like it was absolutely not designed for boxes and boxes. And it was just, I'm sure

1:51:05I'm sure there might have been a better way,

1:51:06but I just remember I'd get to the post office

1:51:09and I couldn't do it like all in one trip.

1:51:11I would just be as much as I could possibly stuff

1:51:13in the car at a time.

1:51:15But then I was like, with no one else to help me,

1:51:18it was like I would have to park the car

1:51:20as close to the post office as I could get,

1:51:22which in the city is often not that close,

1:51:25and then carry as many boxes of T-shirts

1:51:27as I could into the post office

1:51:29and hope, you know, trust that nobody was going

1:51:32to steal them while I went back to the car

1:51:34get the rest of the boxes of shirts and then get in line and push like eight boxes of t-shirts up

1:51:40with me until I got to the counter. And then one by one, they would start taking and scanning these

1:51:47shirts. And it was like, I was like the guy you did not want to get behind at the post office.

1:51:51Right. Yeah. I was just imagining like the people coming in behind you and saying, "Oh my,

1:51:55well, who's this fucking asshole?"

1:51:57It was funny because I got to know there were three women who worked at the post office I went

1:52:03to. And there was two of them obviously did not want to deal with me. And the third was

1:52:08very nice and very sympathetic. And so, you know, it's sort of like, like when you go

1:52:13to a barbershop, but you know, like, instead of just going next, if you've got, you know,

1:52:17like Tony is your guy, you'll wait until Tony's free. Like I would wait until she was the

1:52:22next of it. I would let people go ahead of me until I got the one who I knew was going

1:52:26to be nice to me. But that was those initial rounds of t-shirt sales with me admitting

1:52:35publicly that, "Hey, this is how I'm hoping to get this off the ground. We're instrumental

1:52:40to it."

1:52:41Yeah, no, I remember that. And it's still a very unique approach.

1:52:51But I never really did anything with memberships. The only thing I did for members was that

1:52:55that at the time, for like a year,

1:52:59it was the only way to get the full content RSS feed

1:53:02that the regular free RSS only had the headlines

1:53:05and the first few words of a post.

1:53:07And if you wanted everything,

1:53:08you'd have to be a subscriber.

1:53:10I won't go into it,

1:53:12'cause I talked about this at XOXO a couple of years ago,

1:53:15but how I accidentally stumbled

1:53:17upon the best business idea I've ever had,

1:53:20which is long story short,

1:53:21that the password protected RSS feeds

1:53:25never worked with Google Reader.

1:53:27And I always thought, I thought for a long time,

1:53:30well, eventually they will, because of course it's,

1:53:32you know, it's a good, and then I realized

1:53:34it suddenly dawned on me, no, they're never gonna support

1:53:36password protected feeds because the whole point

1:53:40of doing anything at Google is to be able to do it at scale.

1:53:43And there's absolutely no way that they wanna hit

1:53:46my RSS feed a couple thousand times

1:53:50for a couple thousand paid subscribers,

1:53:52they wanna hit it once and give it to everybody.

1:53:54And so they're never gonna support

1:53:56password protected feeds.

1:53:58And I, everybody, I kept getting email on a daily basis,

1:54:02you know, like very nice, but like, hey, I use,

1:54:04I've switched from whatever to Google Reader.

1:54:06How can I get my full content feed to work?

1:54:09And the emails were always of, how do I get this to work?

1:54:13'Cause surely there must be a way to get it to work.

1:54:15And I feel bad asking you, but I couldn't figure it out.

1:54:17And then I have to explain, no, it actually doesn't work.

1:54:19And I thought, well, how can I still make money

1:54:23and make everybody happy?

1:54:24And I thought, well, maybe I could sell a weekly sponsorship

1:54:27for the RSS feed.

1:54:28And it turned out to be way more lucrative

1:54:31than the membership thing that it replaced.

1:54:34- Yeah, yeah.

1:54:35- So I completely stumbled into it accidentally.

1:54:39And thanks to Google Reader,

1:54:40which still is something of a sore spot for me at least

1:54:44in terms of when it went away, you know.

1:54:48we talked about this before too, right?

1:54:50Like when Google readers shut down traffic to during fireball dropped by a

1:54:54third and never recovered. Hmm.

1:54:57I don't think I lost readers, but I lost, I lost regular,

1:55:02like Mo, you know, I don't think people dropped off,

1:55:05but I think the number of times a day they hit the site dropped off.

1:55:08Right. Right. I, you know, I didn't see that,

1:55:13that sharp decline like that. I, mine has been

1:55:16it's been more steady and you know I think definitely Google, Google Reader is a you

1:55:24know was a was a factor but more I think it's you know like mobile and you know Facebook.

1:55:31Yeah consuming more and more people more and more people's attention. Yeah I still get a ton of

1:55:38traffic to the Daring Fireball homepage. Surely you get a ton of homepage traffic like it doesn't make

1:55:45sense to me when I look at newer sites and I get it, like sites that have evolved or

1:55:51were created in the social media era where their homepage isn't even really a thing.

1:55:56It's just, you know…

1:55:57Right. Everything is the homepage.

1:56:00Right. Whereas, you know, I still feel it works very well that your site and my site,

1:56:07all you have to do is go to the homepage and you can just scroll down for a while and then

1:56:11when you see the last post that you read before,

1:56:14then you know you're done and you're caught up.

1:56:15- Right, yep.

1:56:17- Like one page view every couple days is all I ask.

1:56:21Just come to my homepage once or twice a week

1:56:24and you can get everything.

1:56:25Like two page views a week, that's great.

1:56:28- Yeah.

1:56:30- Well, anyway, you've relaunched two years ago,

1:56:32you relaunched the idea of memberships.

1:56:34And I think, I mean,

1:56:37it seems like it's actually pretty successful.

1:56:40- Yeah, I mean, it's been great.

1:56:44The first time I did it in 2005, I did it,

1:56:49and after a few months I started feeling,

1:56:52you know, and this was just sort of my own internal thing.

1:56:57It didn't have anything to do with anyone else.

1:57:00It was, I started feeling like I had

1:57:03over a thousand people who are my boss now.

1:57:08know, the sort of paying, paying patrons, micropatrons, I called

1:57:12them, who, you know, had some more say in what I should be

1:57:20posting, then, you know, the the usual reader. You know, and

1:57:27again, like this was completely in my head, like, nobody was

1:57:30saying this. You know, I, my inbox wasn't full of email

1:57:34saying like, well, you said you were going to do this, and

1:57:36and you're not doing it, what the hell's going on?

1:57:38Like none of that was happening.

1:57:39It was just all in my brain.

1:57:41And I, you know, I didn't like that sensation.

1:57:46I didn't feel like I was sort of free to do

1:57:49what I wanted to do anymore,

1:57:51which is sort of ridiculous because of course I was.

1:57:56But, you know, I sort of talked myself into, you know,

1:57:59feeling that way about it.

1:58:01And, you know, so after a year,

1:58:03like I discontinued the membership thing

1:58:06And I think it was a couple months later

1:58:08where I put the deck ad on the site.

1:58:12It was sort of this like, oh shit, this isn't gonna work.

1:58:14And then the deck came along and I was like, oh, cool.

1:58:17Let's do this.

1:58:18But increasingly,

1:58:24probably like three or four years ago,

1:58:28I started thinking, I'm just like, well, what if I,

1:58:31I'm a different person now.

1:58:32Like what if I went back and like did this membership thing?

1:58:35And there's this, I think Patreon was just sort of becoming a thing.

1:58:40And it seemed like there was this idea that content online was worth paying for, which

1:58:55back in 2005 was not really a concept that made sense to anyone.

1:59:00Online things were free.

1:59:03Wall Street Journal had a paywall, but that was about it. The New York Times experimented with

1:59:08paywalls periodically, and other sites, other news sites did too. But I think, especially three,

1:59:19four, five years ago, people started coming around to this idea that, huh, advertising is

1:59:30problematic, to put it gently. And, you know, in some cases, in most cases, I would say.

1:59:40And, you know, but so if advertising doesn't work, like, how are we, you know, how am I going to

1:59:48read this thing? Like, maybe I should support this thing. You know, and I think, once that started

1:59:55happening, I started thinking, I was like, you know, I bet, you know, I bet I could,

2:00:01I could do a membership thing again and feel okay with it. And, you know, I would get probably like

2:00:08once every two weeks, I would get an email from somebody saying like, can I pay you for this? Like,

2:00:14what the hell? Like, why, why can't I pay you for this? You know, and I think the, that feeling of,

2:00:22of it being a more acceptable thing

2:00:26or something that was in the air of like,

2:00:29oh, we need to pay directly for content

2:00:33that we love online.

2:00:36And people wanting it was just sort of hard to ignore

2:00:40after a while for me.

2:00:42- Yeah, and so now you've got three levels,

2:00:46patron for 30 bucks a year, right?

2:00:49Superstar, 60 bucks a year,

2:00:51and then the crazy one, 600 bucks a year. And then what members get is A, that the good feeling of

2:00:59paying you for the work that you're doing, but then they also get a good old-fashioned email

2:01:05newsletter, which is out of, you know, the same type of thing that you post on khaki.org, but

2:01:12different and, you know, more written longer and sort of a slightly different tone, in my opinion.

2:01:21Dr. Jonathon Leach Right. Well, there's,

2:01:22there's, so there's, so there's the members newsletter, which I think I've only sent out,

2:01:27probably like six or seven of maybe eight. It's not spammed. It's not spam. It's not spam.

2:01:39And then there's a separate newsletter that I started with Tim Carmody in December,

2:01:45I think, called Noticing. And that is obviously member supported, but you don't have to be a

2:01:51member to read it. I mean, my thing is that I didn't want to have any sort of members only

2:02:04stuff or very little members-only stuff. I wanted people to know upfront that they were

2:02:10supporting the work that was already going on and that part of their contribution was

2:02:15going to make sure that that stuff stayed open and free and available. It's part of

2:02:23the whole deal. It's purposefully not a paywall.

2:02:28Yeah. Yeah. I'm personally, I think you've, I think what you said is exactly how I feel.

2:02:33Like I, I think like what Ben Thompson does at Stratechery is, you know, fantastic. I love getting

2:02:39his emails. And I think he's built a very successful business at it, but it would drive me

2:02:47nuts writing, because the better the piece was that was behind the paywall, the more I would wish it

2:02:55weren't behind a paywall. Like, there's a part of me that I—if I write something,

2:03:01it's again, like, me feeling like I was born at the right time. I love that everything I write and

2:03:08post it during Fireball is there for anybody in the world to see. Like, it's—I can't explain it,

2:03:17but it's just a part of my personality that I'm just not cut out to write behind a paywall.

2:03:23like it would just drive me crazy. It would, it would bother me like knowing that I've

2:03:27lost my keys. Like I can't stop thinking about where they might be. Like if I had a post behind

2:03:32a paywall, I would never be able to stop thinking, boy, I wish that weren't behind a paywall.

2:03:36Yeah. I mean, that's, that's exactly my, my feeling on it too. And, you know,

2:03:44there's something, I think there's something about,

2:03:49I don't know, one of the, you know, the web brought with it all of these new possibilities

2:03:56in thinking about how people do things and things like that. And one of those things was,

2:04:06you know, you can write something and put it online and anybody who wants to stop by

2:04:15to read it, can read it and share it with others. And, you know, at a certain point, like, I mean,

2:04:22I loved, I loved that about the web and it's just, I think doing, you know, something like

2:04:30putting something behind a paywall is just not, it just doesn't feel like the right thing to do

2:04:35with the web for me. And I do think you're right that like in 2005, it was an idea ahead of its

2:04:45time and I think fundamentally based on the fact that in 2005, 2006, it still felt like

2:04:53everybody agreed that everything on the web should be quote unquote free. And something

2:04:58changed in the decade after that. And I think part of it is just that in the ensuing decade,

2:05:04people have seen things that sites that they loved before either go away completely or

2:05:12mostly dry up and I think it gave people like the

2:05:16See having had sites that they loved go away, you know

2:05:21I think and made made people more willing to say I would like to keep this going and and if I can help by giving

2:05:2930 bucks a year or whatever

2:05:31I'm happy to do it. I

2:05:33Think that's what I mean

2:05:35The difference is whether they're happy doing it or not

2:05:38And I think in 2005, there weren't very many people who were happy about paying for anything online. Whereas today there are

2:05:44Yeah, I mean, you know you like you look at the last five years in online media and you know, it's it's like

2:05:52just the

2:05:55the consequence of not paying directly for things and sort of relying on advertising and you know VC money is

2:06:03You know, like there are a lot of advantages to both of those things

2:06:06But the disadvantage is that when those things dry up for one reason or another like that thing that you loved is gone

2:06:13You know, yeah

2:06:16Whereas like I feel now

2:06:20with you know sort of this, you know, the the membership is is

2:06:25you know more than 50% of my revenue now and I feel like in a lot of ways like

2:06:33It that is way steadier than

2:06:35Advertising ever felt. Yeah, like I feel like a large chunk of that is going to be there for

2:06:42Ever a long time. I mean, yeah, it just feels so solid to me and it's like it's so

2:06:51It's such a base, you know that I can that I can count on yeah, it just feels amazing

2:07:00talking about early era bloggers

2:07:02I think he started sometime after you but it was before daring fireball would be josh marshall at talking points memo and

2:07:11He's evolved TPM in a way. That's you know

2:07:15Very, you know certainly different than what I've done where he's built it out into a real news organization with a staff of I think

2:07:21somewhere around like

2:07:2420 people

2:07:26You know, it's a real publication, but it's also very small by the historical standards of a news publication

2:07:34It's still like if you're a regular reader of talking points memo you you kind of you know

2:07:39You can just see by how few bylines there are that it's you know, it's a small group. It is still in a way personal

2:07:45and

2:07:48You know, they've done the same thing where they call it TPM Prime

2:07:52But they you know get the they're there thousand true fans or you know

2:07:57Several thousand biggest fans to sign up for TPM prime and they do have some paywall stuff

2:08:02but their news articles the you know, the heart of their reporting they do aren't behind and a

2:08:06paywall, it's sort of like you get to see like the reporters notebooks if you're

2:08:12Effectively if you're a member, but I think for the most part

2:08:16It's driven by people who really just are happy to pay it to keep TPM

2:08:21a float and or not even a float not like they were in trouble but and josh has written about it

2:08:26but that it just makes him feel better about their business if 50 of the money isn't from

2:08:32advertising if it's direct support from readers it just like you said it just feels like this is

2:08:37something that they can bank on as they try to hire more reporters and stuff and they don't have

2:08:42to worry about the ebb and flow of the ad industry that if they've got these readers who subscribe

2:08:48for an annual thing that they can count on, you know, as long as they're doing the good work that

2:08:52they were doing to get them to sign up in the first place, they're going to be able to count

2:08:55on it going forward. Right. Yeah. And I mean, it's interesting, like, I didn't anticipate

2:09:02that it would feel differently like that. And it also feels differently from a, from the perspective

2:09:10of like, what I write about and how I write about it. Like, I feel, I feel way more free to just

2:09:16sort of write about, I mean, I've always written about anything and everything, but I feel,

2:09:21you know, there, there was never the sense that I was writing for page views, but it was always

2:09:26like a little bit in the back of my mind and now I don't worry about it at all. And I also don't

2:09:34worry about, I'm worrying less about if things are on the site or not. Like if, if I wanted to

2:09:45I don't know, like if I wanted to increase my, you know, Twitter activity a lot, I could

2:09:56do that because, you know, the people who are paying for the site are paying sort of

2:10:01for my activity in general. And so like, you know, it's hard to talk about it. It's, it's

2:10:10really, I feel like it's really freed me up to do different stuff, to think about it in a different

2:10:16way. I don't know. It's hard to talk about. Well, from the outside, I mean, we're friends,

2:10:23but we don't talk often because I'm bad at being friend. So I can't say, it's not like we don't

2:10:32know each other personally. But from my, you know, primarily, though, my interaction with you is

2:10:38reading your website and vice versa. And I've noticed, it seems to me that since you launched

2:10:46this, that and you indicated that, hey, this was even more successful than I thought it would be.

2:10:53Thank you, everybody who's on board. I've noticed that it seems like you're in a better mood,

2:11:00just judging you from the post on khaki.org. You know, and, you know, that could just be me.

2:11:07I don't know. And, and also that it seemed like it freed you up to change things a little bit more,

2:11:12I think. Yeah, I mean, you know, the like, launching the newsletters is, I think, a good,

2:11:18a good example of something that I don't know, I'm not sure I would have thought about it because

2:11:27because it was like, oh shit, I got to figure out how to fund this thing. Like, okay, I

2:11:32need to get sponsors for it. So like, we need to get it up to a certain level. You know,

2:11:36and I'm still thinking about those things because, you know, I think one of the, one

2:11:40of the things I've learned is that you need to have multiple sources of income in case,

2:11:44you know, one goes flat and all this other stuff. You know, it's always good to diversify.

2:11:50But you know, the newsletter is definitely one of those things. And, you know, I think,

2:11:56you know, going to, you know, what you said about me being happier. I definitely, you

2:12:02know, I definitely feel more energized. You know, I think the membership thing has really

2:12:08energized me. And really,

2:12:14Maybe that's what's more, maybe that's a better word to them. I detect on the site energized.

2:12:20Yeah, that I mean, that's how I've sort of been thinking about it as as I've, you know,

2:12:24didn't notice it right away, but I've definitely in the last few months particularly. Maybe there

2:12:30was this thing of me taking the site for granted a little bit for a while. And I think that's kind

2:12:37of in the rearview mirror a little bit. And I really, I don't know, I'm just really back into

2:12:43it in a way that I wasn't maybe three, four years ago. And there was some personal life shit going

2:12:49on to that really like drove my life into the ditch for a couple years but um you know and and

2:12:56you know katie.org was this thing that was you know sort of the through line that that

2:13:03i could depend on even when the rest of my life isn't you know shit like this is the thing that

2:13:11i know how to do and i can sit down and do this and you're in control of yeah exactly i feel that

2:13:17way about—I absolutely feel that way about daring fireball when real life is not that great. I

2:13:25always, I do, in some ways when real life isn't that great, sometimes that's when

2:13:30I'm more productive at daring fireball, just because it's something I can hide away from

2:13:37everything else. I can't help but feel a little personally slighted by this, though. On your

2:13:43membership members page, the first level of the patron, it's here's the description for pennies

2:13:48a day. This is a $30 a year membership. For pennies a day, you can become one of khaki.org's

2:13:531000 true fans. Please don't make me have to start a rambling two hour podcast.

2:13:57Yeah, yeah, we're at like the 215 mark. Yeah. So

2:14:10You should feel a little slighted by that, but at the same time, it's funny. I'm not a big podcast

2:14:19guy. I'm not a big podcast listener. And my sweet spot for podcasts is 20 to 30 minutes as a

2:14:30listener. So yeah, sorry. I have found I could be wrong. I have found that I think it, I think

2:14:42the worst length for a podcast is about an hour. Because when the talk show episodes were shorter,

2:14:52I'd get a lot of complaints about the length from people who thought it was too long because there's

2:14:58There's an awful lot of people who they like you said 15, 20 minutes is the sweet spot.

2:15:03And you know, remember our sponsor, the tech meme, uh, ride home show, which is 15, 20

2:15:11minutes.

2:15:12If people want it one way or the other, and it's like the, nobody wants the middle bowl

2:15:17of porridge.

2:15:18They either want it cold or they want it hot.

2:15:20And uh, there's other people who can't get enough, you know, who, you know, when I talk,

2:15:26an episode and talk about length of the show. They're like, make them longer. They're, you

2:15:29know, I have a really terrible commute, so please make them longer and come out with

2:15:34them more frequently.

2:15:35Well, it's interesting as a, as a guest. So I, I've done, I've probably done like three

2:15:44or four podcasts in the last like month just because I kind of made a concerted effort

2:15:48to reach out to people and people have been reaching out to me because of the, you know,

2:15:52anniversary thing. And I did one with Craig Maud. He does this podcast called On Margins,

2:16:02I can't remember which it is, which he hasn't posted yet because he's like me,

2:16:06he's like this meticulous, like he meticulously edits these episodes to within an inch of their

2:16:14life. But it was interesting. I talked to him, I think for about an hour and I felt like we

2:16:22were just kind of getting going. We were just in a good place where it's like, "Oh, okay,

2:16:25we can really have a conversation now." And then he was like, "Okay, we're done."

2:16:30And we talked for 20 minutes after that. And we should have hit record again, probably.

2:16:37But it was interesting that that hour wasn't enough as a guest. All of the other ones that

2:16:48I've done I think have been around, you know, 40 minutes to an hour. And it was just sort of like,

2:16:52oh, we were just we were just getting somewhere. Well, you don't have that problem with me.

2:16:56No. I what's interesting about this is that, I mean, this is, I don't know, it like,

2:17:05we talked a little bit, like I texted you yesterday, and I was like, Okay,

2:17:10can I do anything to prepare? And you're Nope, you're like, Nope. Okay.

2:17:17And then like 10 minutes before the show, you're like, okay, here's my Skype. I was like, oh,

2:17:22we're doing this on Skype. All right. And then you call me on Skype and you're like, hey,

2:17:27how's it going? Good. Okay. Can you record this? Yep. Hit record. Okay. And then it was,

2:17:33and then boom, we're in. And I was like, okay. I didn't want to make you nervous. I, and it is

2:17:39weird because I tend to rotate between regular guests who know how it goes. And I liked it,

2:17:44have more, like one of my things I'd like to do this year is have more fresh voices on this show.

2:17:51And I realized as I was doing it, I was like, "Oh, I bet Jason's freaking out a little bit,

2:17:59just because I know you don't do this a lot." But I was completely confident because I've done this.

2:18:04I knew exactly how it would go. And I knew it would be pretty good. I think it has been.

2:18:12but I still can't help but feel that a rambling two-hour podcast is…

2:18:15Yeah, that was maybe a shot across the bow.

2:18:18This has been great, but we have gone long enough. I think it's enough rambling.

2:18:26All right.

2:18:27But I will promise that you will have to come back at some point and not let 200 episodes go by.

2:18:38So for anybody who wants more, if you don't know kotke.org, I don't know how that's possibly the

2:18:43case. But that's Jason's website. On Twitter, there are two Twitter accounts that I know of.

2:18:51There's @Kotke, which is sort of like the official links, you know, like the Twitter

2:18:59account for the site. And then there's JKotke, which is your personal Twitter.

2:19:03Right.

2:19:04Everything's Kotke branded. It's sort of like Trump.

2:19:07Yeah, ugh, Jesus, did we have to end on that note?