Podcast Search

The Talk Show

215: ‘The “Press Real Hard” Era’ With Marco Arment

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00You see all this crap about how Facebook is using people's two-factor numbers to basically

0:00:05spam them into more engagement?

0:00:07Yeah, it's awful.

0:00:08Why would you do that?

0:00:09And you're literally punishing people.

0:00:11You're punishing people for doing the right thing.

0:00:15If you think that the right thing is setting up two-factor, which I actually think is sort

0:00:19of debatable if one of the factors is your cell phone.

0:00:23Yeah, it seemed like a good idea at the time it was first started being used.

0:00:29what almost 10 years ago but I think that's as we've seen like security-wise

0:00:35that's actually not that great not as great as we think it is no you know

0:00:41butcher his name Mac Jay Cichlowski that the pinboard guy mm-hmm so he was in

0:00:48town over the summer I think and we met up and he sort of he's sort of like

0:00:54thrown himself in head over heels into the world of best practices for personal security.

0:01:01And he's doing it. He's an activist for a bunch of Democratic candidates for Congress

0:01:08for this coming year.

0:01:09Tim Cynova Oh, yeah, the Great Slate.

0:01:11Dave Asprey Yeah, the Great Slate. It's absolutely

0:01:13fantastic including the district that's my—the home district where Amy and I grew

0:01:19up, which is arguably, literally, in the entire country, the single most gerrymandered congressional

0:01:24district in the country. It's unbelievable. If you grew up in the area, like if you just

0:01:29look at the map, it truly has got these little tiny slivers that connect areas. But if you

0:01:35grew up in the area like I did and think about how disparate the areas are, it's absolutely

0:01:43preposterous. And anyway, there's a great candidate that the great slate is running

0:01:47for there. And I'm thinking about really putting some significant promotional effort

0:01:52into it on the during fireball this year to get her elected anyway he came by and and

0:01:59you know he's doing things with these Democratic candidates to teach them like hey what's the

0:02:03best way to protect your email so that the you know Russians can't get into your Gmail

0:02:07like they did you know two years ago and one of his big things and I believe it he totally

0:02:12convinced me is go through if you have a Google account you know you could use Gmail as your

0:02:19Google account. Not, you know, relatively safe. But if you use two factor, get it off

0:02:23yourself. Don't don't let Google know your cell phone. Just completely disconnect your

0:02:28cell phone from your Google account. Because as soon as you hook up your cell phone as

0:02:33this as a factor and two factor, you're at the mercy of your carrier and the carriers

0:02:37are awful, just awful. Somebody calls up and says, Hey, I'm Marco Armond. And I'm having

0:02:43trouble with my my cell phone. You know, all of a sudden, they've got like a SIM card with

0:02:48with your phone number on it.

0:02:49And then, boom, game over for two-factor

0:02:52if they also know your email.

0:02:54It's really terrible.

0:02:54It happens all the time.

0:02:56- Yeah, it's one of those things like,

0:02:59the foundation of that being secure was on the assumption

0:03:03that, well, nobody else can get my phone number

0:03:05except me, obviously, right?

0:03:06But I don't think people realize,

0:03:08no, that's actually fairly easy for people

0:03:10to clone your phone number and start receiving things

0:03:12that are supposed to be going to your phone number.

0:03:14- Right, and it's not quite as easy

0:03:16going in with the name, but I mean,

0:03:18you don't need much information to go into your local AT&T

0:03:21or Verizon or whatever, T-Mobile,

0:03:24and just have some $11 an hour clerk print up a SIM card.

0:03:28(laughing)

0:03:31There you go.

0:03:32I mean, it happens, it's really crazy.

0:03:35So anyway, get your, think about that, anyway.

0:03:38And anyway, that's what Facebook has done,

0:03:40is they got people to sign up with Two Factor,

0:03:43And then the longer you go without signing in to Facebook,

0:03:47the more often they send you text messages asking you.

0:03:51And it's so stupidly passive aggressive.

0:03:56It's like, are you having trouble signing in?

0:03:59It's like, no, I haven't signed in.

0:04:01- Yeah, it's worded as though, like, obviously,

0:04:05if you haven't signed in recently,

0:04:07there must be something wrong with your account.

0:04:08It's not that you don't wanna sign into Facebook.

0:04:11I saw one guy who got hit by this and he tweeted that he's texting, you know, he's getting

0:04:18these text messages and he's trying like the, those SMS bot interfaces. So he's trying things

0:04:24like stop. I forget what else he tried. And then he went and checked and Facebook, I swear

0:04:31to God, posted his things that he texted back to the SMS bot. They posted him to his wall

0:04:37and Facebook.

0:04:38So it was also, I felt like, stop, opt out, unsubscribe?

0:04:42Yes, yeah.

0:04:43That's amazing.

0:04:44It all caps.

0:04:45It's interesting because, you know, I famously, or perhaps not famously, I've still never

0:04:52signed up for Facebook.

0:04:53I do have an Instagram account, though, so I don't know, you know, I don't know how,

0:04:57it's, I can't, I can't claim any sort of, you know, holiness in this regard.

0:05:05But I never signed up for Facebook. Certainly as the years go on, it's looking like a better

0:05:11and better decision. It, to me, is reminiscent of my decision to never put comments on Daring

0:05:16Fireball. There were some early years where it seemed like, "Hmm, maybe I'm missing out.

0:05:21I don't know." And then it crossed a certain threshold and it was like, "Dodged a bullet

0:05:25on that one."

0:05:26Yeah, you're playing the long game on Facebook. You're going to have 10 years of people saying,

0:05:34how can you not be on Facebook, but you know,

0:05:36it's starting to appear like a reasonable choice recently.

0:05:39- But--

0:05:40- I mean, like Tiff, so you know,

0:05:41my wife Tiff deactivated her account on Facebook

0:05:44over a year ago, I think, and really hasn't missed anything.

0:05:48I have an account there, but I don't really ever use it

0:05:53for much of anything, and all I get is like,

0:05:56emails basically spamming me with like,

0:05:59"Somebody commented on the Overcast page.

0:06:01"You should really log in and read it

0:06:03and respond to increase your rate of whatever.

0:06:05And then I get emails from like strange members

0:06:08of my family, like look at their comments.

0:06:10I don't want to look at their comments.

0:06:12I'm not speaking to them.

0:06:13And it's like all I get is like this is like,

0:06:17either spam about engagement on my Overcast page

0:06:19or like stuff with people that like Facebook

0:06:23just doesn't get the hint that like I actually

0:06:25don't want to interact with some people.

0:06:27And it's just like, and you know,

0:06:30I read something earlier on Twitter.

0:06:32I forget who it was, I'm sorry, but it was like,

0:06:34it was somebody who was saying like,

0:06:36she's getting these spam text messages from Facebook

0:06:39and it's all about like her ex-boyfriend who like she,

0:06:41you know, it kind of hurts to hear about him

0:06:43and you know, it's like Facebook just doesn't,

0:06:45either they, you know, their algorithms don't get it,

0:06:48which is certainly likely,

0:06:50but also I think they just don't care.

0:06:52You know, they're shameless and they will spam the crap

0:06:56out of everybody relentlessly because they know that,

0:07:00you know, it works for X percent of people

0:07:02to get X more page clicks and more engagement

0:07:05and they need to keep their numbers up

0:07:06because they're apparently bleeding users.

0:07:08- Yeah, that's the thing is that it's the,

0:07:11I'm not gonna say that they're in trouble

0:07:13or that they're to bring out everybody's favorite

0:07:16classic Apple word, beleaguered.

0:07:18- Doomed.

0:07:20- They're making more money than ever,

0:07:22but that's really more that they're getting more efficient

0:07:28at getting more money per user,

0:07:30not that they're getting more users.

0:07:32Like, logins in the US are actually down for the first time,

0:07:36which if I were on Facebook,

0:07:37would probably keep me up at night,

0:07:39because I would be very concerned about that.

0:07:43- Isn't that actually also kind of what's happening to Apple?

0:07:46Like, you know, basically making more money from users

0:07:49rather than growing the user base itself?

0:07:51- That's very possible.

0:07:52I read an article today,

0:07:54'cause I tried trying to write less and less

0:07:56about the financial stuff, and we can get into it.

0:07:59I find it excruciatingly boring.

0:08:01- There was a great Walt Mossberg tweet

0:08:03I'll probably get to later in the show

0:08:04just about focusing on the financial stuff

0:08:07is the wrong way to look at it.

0:08:09If you're really trying to look at it from the,

0:08:13is Apple making good products?

0:08:15Which is really what I'm interested in.

0:08:17But I read a thing that, it was just some,

0:08:21somebody was like, "You should file this as claim chowder."

0:08:23And it was just some shitty Forbes columnist

0:08:25who's saying that Warren Buffett at Berkshire Hathaway

0:08:30has upped his investment in Apple in the last year,

0:08:33and this guy was making the argument

0:08:34that that's a huge mistake,

0:08:36and that instead, if he wants to invest in a tech company,

0:08:39he should invest in Amazon.

0:08:40And I don't like to get into the investment type stuff,

0:08:46but I actually think that this guy maybe has a point

0:08:48because I kind of feel like Apple,

0:08:50if I were going to give investment advice,

0:08:53I think it's quite possible that Apple's growth is over,

0:08:57or at least slowed down significantly.

0:08:59And this is his argument from the last two years

0:09:00that Apple's only grown at like six or seven percent

0:09:03the last two years, which is fine growth

0:09:05for a giant company or the biggest company in the world,

0:09:08but it's not, you know, if you want,

0:09:10trying to be super aggressive with your investments,

0:09:13it's probably not, whereas Amazon, who knows?

0:09:15I don't know what the hell backs up their stock

0:09:17other than the fact that, you know,

0:09:19it has nothing to do with profits.

0:09:20It has just to do with their,

0:09:22the idea that whenever they get into something,

0:09:24they dominate.

0:09:26I think it's possible that Amazon stock could go up

0:09:28way more than Apple's in the next, say,

0:09:30two, three, four years, I don't know.

0:09:31But I don't think that's a ridiculous argument.

0:09:34But anyway, I think the argument that Apple's sort of

0:09:37reached peak Apple is possible, at least in terms of reach.

0:09:41- I mean, maybe not peak, but just like,

0:09:43it's like they've transitioned, I think,

0:09:45I mean, granted neither of us are financial analysts,

0:09:47or really even experts in this field,

0:09:49but it does seem like they have transitioned

0:09:51from a growth company to a stable, long-term,

0:09:56like a high-risk stock to a low-risk stock, basically,

0:10:00in the sense that I don't expect them,

0:10:04whatever their price is now, I don't know,

0:10:06100-something, I don't even follow.

0:10:08I don't expect it to be 200 next year.

0:10:10I wouldn't expect that kind of growth anymore.

0:10:13- And you're just never gonna--

0:10:14- They're so big.

0:10:16- You're just never gonna see the sort of

0:10:17quarter over quarter, year over year,

0:10:19every single, for a whole series of years

0:10:22after the iPhone came out, it was every single quarter

0:10:25was up 28% year over year, up 30% year over year,

0:10:30up 50% year over year.

0:10:31Just quarter after quarter after quarter,

0:10:34every single quarter of the year,

0:10:35year after year after year,

0:10:36were these insane consistent growth numbers

0:10:39because the iPhone was growing insanely.

0:10:43But you don't have to be a genius to realize

0:10:46that the iPhone is possibly never going to be replicated

0:10:51by any company in our lifetimes in terms of being a product

0:10:55that will be used by such an incredibly large percentage

0:11:00of the people who might reasonably buy one

0:11:04and sells for a relatively high price,

0:11:07what the average selling price now is up to 800 bucks,

0:11:11and gets replaced every two to three years by normal people.

0:11:15Like there's no other product in the world like that.

0:11:18- Yeah, I mean, especially now that the subsidy thing

0:11:22in the US has largely shifted and kind of gone away

0:11:26or at least changed, like the price of the phones

0:11:28is more visible to people.

0:11:30Well, I guess maybe you could argue it isn't

0:11:32'cause now everyone's just paying

0:11:33on these monthly installment plans.

0:11:34But it's remarkable that people find a way,

0:11:39whether it's subsidized or parceled up by months

0:11:43or whatever it is, that people are buying a brand new

0:11:48$800 plus phone every one to three years

0:11:53in pretty large quantities.

0:11:54That's remarkable.

0:11:56- Yeah, they just accept it.

0:11:58- Because people never bought computers at that rate.

0:12:01Even people like me who are like,

0:12:04I'll buy lots of things 'cause I like them

0:12:06and I like computers a lot,

0:12:07and I don't buy a new computer every year.

0:12:11- Now wait a second.

0:12:12- Well, if you exclude laptops.

0:12:15- That's only because Apple doesn't come out with them

0:12:17frequently enough.

0:12:18You buy a new Pro desktop as frequently as Apple

0:12:21comes out with them.

0:12:22- No, that's not true.

0:12:23I had my 2014 iMac, the same one that you, I think,

0:12:27are still using.

0:12:28- Yes.

0:12:29- I bought that in 2014, and there were three other updates

0:12:32to it that I didn't buy before the iMac Pro came out.

0:12:36- Hmm.

0:12:38- I mean, they were minor updates, really, but.

0:12:40- Yeah, none of them have even vaguely tempted me

0:12:43to be truthful.

0:12:43- Well, like changing a desktop is a pain in the ass.

0:12:46Like, I don't wanna have to change that very often.

0:12:48- Oh, I hate it.

0:12:49- It's a big deal.

0:12:49And again, and you know, when the gains to be had

0:12:53are fairly incremental, then it's kind of dumb

0:12:57to go through the expense and logistical crap

0:13:01of replacing your desktop every year

0:13:03when you're getting, what, a 5% increase

0:13:05in performance maybe?

0:13:06Like, that's not enough to make that worth it.

0:13:08- Yeah, and it's also, I mean, this has been a recurring

0:13:11theme on the show ever since I started it with old Dan

0:13:15back in the day.

0:13:16I mean, I just hate setting up a new Mac.

0:13:18- Old Dan.

0:13:19- Yeah, I just hate setting up a new Mac, I really do.

0:13:22I liked, so I just, whether it's a desktop or a laptop,

0:13:27I just buy the best one I can afford, which, you know,

0:13:31now that I'm older is actually like the best one they make.

0:13:33So like the iMac, 5K iMac I bought in, what was that,

0:13:37- 2014 or 2015?

0:13:39- Yep, 2014.

0:13:40- I just bought the maximum everything.

0:13:43I just got the fastest i7 chip.

0:13:47I put, what is it, 32 gigs of RAM?

0:13:50It's gotta be 32. - 32 gigs of RAM,

0:13:51one terabyte SSD.

0:13:53- One terabyte SSD. - And very young,

0:13:54something 290, I think, or 90, something like that.

0:13:56- I don't know if I upgraded the video.

0:13:58I'd have to double check on that.

0:13:59- It was a small additional expense,

0:14:01and I think I did it just because I didn't,

0:14:04like I'd upgraded everything else, same as you,

0:14:06and I'm like, I don't wanna regret this later,

0:14:08and so I did it.

0:14:09Although I didn't, on the iMac Pro,

0:14:10now I didn't get the fancy GPU for that,

0:14:12because the number, it was like $600 more,

0:14:16and I don't do anything with the GPU, really,

0:14:19so I got the base GPU.

0:14:20- So back to the iPhone,

0:14:25there's just never gonna be anything like that again.

0:14:28Or if there is, whatever it is is unforeseen at this point.

0:14:33There's nothing on the market that's going to be like that.

0:14:36And so I just, like the insane growth for Apple is over.

0:14:41The fact that they're sustaining it,

0:14:42the fact that like the numbers

0:14:43that I just linked to a thing today,

0:14:46that for the first time ever, Apple, some group,

0:14:49who knows if it's accurate or not,

0:14:50but some groups at Apple took 51% of the revenue

0:14:54in the global smartphone market,

0:14:57which is insane for a product that sells for $800

0:15:01on average, and all competing devices sell

0:15:04for an average of 300, and Apple has 51% of the revenue.

0:15:08It's crazy.

0:15:09- I mean, look, Apple is really good

0:15:11at making lots of money.

0:15:13Like, they are really good at that.

0:15:15You know, we can get into lots of debates,

0:15:17and we probably will, about things like, you know,

0:15:19competitiveness and market share in certain areas,

0:15:21but like, they're really good at making money

0:15:23with whatever market share they have in something.

0:15:25- Yeah.

0:15:26That's very true.

0:15:28Same thing with the watch, really.

0:15:31- Yeah. - Which is funny,

0:15:32'cause the watch are coming at it a different way,

0:15:34where there was a story this week

0:15:35that they sold more watches

0:15:37than the entire Swiss watch industry combined,

0:15:40I think last quarter, not last year.

0:15:43But holiday quarter's a big one for watches,

0:15:45'cause people get 'em as gifts.

0:15:47And I think that they said that the average Swiss watch

0:15:51sells for something like $780,

0:15:54and the average selling price of an Apple watch,

0:15:57I think both by common sense and by Horace Dedue's estimates, which have some actual

0:16:04factual analysis of Apple's financials behind them, pegs at around like $330. And by common

0:16:12sense, I mean a $330 average selling price for Apple Watch means the average Apple Watch

0:16:17is the base model made out of aluminum.

0:16:19Yeah, because you figure like they probably sell more of the 42 size than 38 size.

0:16:24Right.

0:16:25And what does that cost? 300 for the 42 base model?

0:16:27- Something like that, yeah.

0:16:28And you know-- - Yeah, so that makes sense.

0:16:30- And you know, whether or not you get it

0:16:31with the cellular or whatever.

0:16:33- Yeah, yeah.

0:16:34- But it's all centered around the base models

0:16:36and the total number of people buying

0:16:38the stainless steel ones, let alone the edition,

0:16:41are so few that it hardly even moves,

0:16:44hardly even nudges the average selling price.

0:16:46And anecdotally, from what I see on people's wrists,

0:16:49that's exactly it.

0:16:50And it's, you know, makes common sense.

0:16:52For most people, a $300 watch is a really expensive watch.

0:16:56- Oh yeah, especially one that you basically

0:16:58have to replace every two years or so,

0:17:00because its battery becomes useless.

0:17:01- Right, I mean--

0:17:02- Is there gonna be a battery gate for the watch?

0:17:05(laughing)

0:17:06- I wonder.

0:17:07- I hope not.

0:17:08I don't wanna have to talk about that for six months.

0:17:10- Anecdotally, it does seem like Series Zero watches,

0:17:14like the original Apple Watch,

0:17:16they're getting worse battery life.

0:17:18Like, we got Jonas one when it was brand new,

0:17:20and he's worn it, he's worn it pretty much every day,

0:17:25or certainly like every school day,

0:17:27ever since they came out,

0:17:28and his battery life has gotten worse recently.

0:17:31And it makes sense.

0:17:33It's what, two and a half years of charge cycles,

0:17:36of nightly charge cycles in,

0:17:38and I think the battery's worn out.

0:17:40- Yeah, yeah, I think as a developer,

0:17:45it's really hard to support the first gen Apple Watch,

0:17:48and I think a big thing holding back

0:17:51what watchOS can offer for developers,

0:17:54like API-wise and backgrounding-wise,

0:17:56things like my background audio requests.

0:17:59I think a lot of that is being held back

0:18:01by the first generation watch hardware,

0:18:03but it's kind of, from that angle,

0:18:05it's not so nice if you have one,

0:18:07but it's kind of nice from that angle

0:18:08that these watches are just really becoming

0:18:12not very useful anymore en masse this year,

0:18:16because the batteries are now so old in them

0:18:18that they're not holding a charge

0:18:20throughout the whole day anymore,

0:18:21for most people who have them.

0:18:23- Yeah, I think that's true.

0:18:25I don't know if it's gonna be a scandal or not.

0:18:27I don't know, it's hard to predict.

0:18:30- Probably not.

0:18:31- I do feel like-- - The first generation

0:18:32watch was so slow, like can you even tell

0:18:34if it's being throttled?

0:18:35- Yeah, I don't know, I don't know about that.

0:18:38It felt like maybe they just turned on throttling

0:18:42right out of the factory.

0:18:44(laughing)

0:18:46It's funny, I was thinking about that recently,

0:18:50and I was thinking about it in, we can get to it,

0:18:54in light of the balance between shipping stuff

0:18:59on a schedule, shipping stuff with a certain number

0:19:05of features, and shipping stuff with a certain quality level

0:19:08that those three things, it's not, you pick one,

0:19:11you wanna balance all three.

0:19:14And I don't know, I kind of, Apple Watch did ship late,

0:19:19I think a little bit later than even Apple hoped.

0:19:21I mean, there were reports that they were,

0:19:23that the year that they announced it in September

0:19:26and even said then it'll ship next year.

0:19:29And it didn't ship the next year until like May.

0:19:33And even then it was like six weeks back ordered

0:19:36for most people.

0:19:37- Yeah, it was like immediately back ordered

0:19:39for most configurations.

0:19:40- Right.

0:19:41- For up until, like I think it officially launched

0:19:44in April, but you couldn't really get

0:19:46a lot of the configurations until like June or July.

0:19:48- Right, and it was a product that by several accounts,

0:19:53Apple had been hoping until pretty late in the game

0:19:58that they might get out for the holidays the year before.

0:20:02And it came out as late as it did

0:20:03and really was sort of a subpar,

0:20:06both software and hardware thing.

0:20:10I honestly, in hindsight, I'm, in hindsight,

0:20:14I've been wondering, should they have waited another year?

0:20:18should like what we now call the Series 1 watch

0:20:21have been the original Apple Watch.

0:20:23I kind of see why they did it,

0:20:26and the other factor you have to recall at the time

0:20:29is they were facing a daily battery of,

0:20:33Apple hasn't released anything new

0:20:34since Steve Jobs died, reports.

0:20:36- Oh yeah, 'cause that was not that long after the

0:20:41can't innovate anymore my ass thing.

0:20:43That was like, what, about a year later?

0:20:45And you know, 'cause that really was,

0:20:47that was the narrative back then was Apple can't innovate anymore, Samsung was doing

0:20:50all the innovation and it turned out that was mostly about big phones. It turned out

0:20:55that Apple wasn't making big enough phones and then they started making big enough phones

0:20:58and everyone stopped talking about that. So that was kind of BS, it turns out. But the

0:21:04Apple Watch Series 1, or the first generation Apple Watch had so many problems with just

0:21:10like focus. You know, like the software was a disaster, it was a total mess. The third

0:21:16party app implementation was horrible with like the watch kit where like the

0:21:21everything was running on the phone and just kind of sent like basically

0:21:24drawing commands to the watch that would end it was so slow almost nothing worked

0:21:29everything would time out or fail like it was it was really rough and then all

0:21:34of the you know marketing focus on things like they wanted you to like be

0:21:38browsing like news feeds on your watch and and all the stuff about like that

0:21:42like the digital touch sending people your heartbeat and doodling little

0:21:45pictures and poking your friends through their wrists.

0:21:48Like there was so much weird stuff

0:21:50in that first watch release that fortunately

0:21:52they've mostly moved past or mostly fixed.

0:21:55There's still some of that weirdness in the watch.

0:21:57Like, you know, like I think the honeycomb screen

0:21:59is still terrible and there's like digital,

0:22:02at least digital touch stuff,

0:22:03they like buried pretty well now.

0:22:05You don't usually find it.

0:22:06But yeah, there's still so much about watchOS

0:22:11that seems like it was made on a different planet

0:22:14than Apple's other products?

0:22:15- I definitely think that they should have, in hindsight,

0:22:18maybe they should have released it

0:22:19when they did as a product,

0:22:21and maybe it was useful enough,

0:22:23and maybe by releasing it when they did

0:22:26and getting feedback from real people

0:22:29that the subsequent watchOS 2, 3, and 4

0:22:32were better than they would have been

0:22:34if they'd waited a year.

0:22:35They would have been a year behind

0:22:36on sort of zeroing in on, okay,

0:22:39notifications and fitness tracking, that's it.

0:22:43That's what people like and use about this product.

0:22:46So I get being wrong about things like digital touch,

0:22:51you know, was that a thing or not?

0:22:53But the one thing that they clearly should have known

0:22:56before they released it was that the original SDK

0:22:58was garbage.

0:22:59This is, that this is, this is, yeah.

0:23:02Just in, it's the only time I can ever recall.

0:23:06And now it's, you know, it's been a long time.

0:23:10I don't know, however long.

0:23:12The first review product I ever got from Apple

0:23:15was the Verizon iPhone 4, so I think that was 2010.

0:23:19So since 2010, I've been getting products to review,

0:23:23and every time I've gotten--

0:23:25- It was early 2011, I think.

0:23:26- Maybe it was 2011, maybe it was like--

0:23:28- The 4S was fall of 2011, right before Steve died.

0:23:31So I believe that came out like January or something.

0:23:33- All right, you're right then, so 2011,

0:23:34so seven years of me getting products from Apple to review.

0:23:42And every time I've gotten a product to review from Apple,

0:23:47and everybody I know who gets products to review from Apple,

0:23:52when you get it, they don't just ship it to you.

0:23:55Every once in a while, there's an exception,

0:23:57like with the MacBook Pros, the new MacBook Pros.

0:24:01I did have a briefing, but they didn't have--

0:24:05- Their new MacBook Pros?

0:24:06- No, the last time when they came out

0:24:08with the Touch Bar ones.

0:24:10Every time I've gotten a review product,

0:24:11I've had a product briefing with somebody

0:24:13from product marketing and somebody from Apple PR,

0:24:16either by myself or in a very small group,

0:24:18like say just me and Dalrymple together.

0:24:21And they show you what they wanna show you

0:24:25and they take your questions, which is great.

0:24:28But they never just give you the product

0:24:32in like a PDF pamphlet or something like that.

0:24:35They wanna tell you about it.

0:24:36And like the exception I was gonna say

0:24:39with the MacBook Pros is I had a product briefing,

0:24:41They didn't give me like all of them and then because they weren't ready yet

0:24:44And so they did ship me like the 15 inch like a week later or something something like that

0:24:49So it's not like they're gonna make you if they're gonna give you two or three MacBook pros to review

0:24:54That's right

0:24:54Like everyone only got the MacBook escape to review right first time and then like the touch bar 15 came later, right?

0:25:01So yeah, exactly

0:25:02So the escape and and there was a briefing where we could play with the touch bar

0:25:06But they didn't have them for us to take with us and so they shipped them to us a week later

0:25:11But there was a briefing where we had the touch bar thing in front of us and could ask questions about it

0:25:15So it's I would call that like the podcast equivalent of a footnote

0:25:20It's a minor exception. Anyway, the only product I can ever

0:25:24Remember where the briefing was mostly

0:25:28Apologizing for problems with the product was the original Apple watch

0:25:32It was like this is gonna be slow like even in the product briefing with a prepared Apple watch and their prepared demo

0:25:39There were things, aspects of it that they were like,

0:25:42this is gonna be slow, we're working on it.

0:25:45And it's just so unusual.

0:25:47- Like in so many ways it was kind of the opposite

0:25:50of the first generation iPhone.

0:25:51Where like the first generation iPhone,

0:25:53it was similarly to the watch,

0:25:55it had like extreme technical constraints

0:25:57to try to get an acceptable amount of processing power

0:26:00and battery life into something that size,

0:26:01running this kind of advanced OS.

0:26:04But with the original iPhone,

0:26:05they chose to basically have it do less,

0:26:08but have the things it does be executed very well.

0:26:12Whereas the first generation watch,

0:26:14and to this day I think still kind of the entire watch,

0:26:17it's not as bad now, but the first generation watch

0:26:20had the kind of the opposite approach of like,

0:26:22we're gonna have this do a whole bunch of crap

0:26:24even though we don't actually think it can do

0:26:26a lot of it very well because we wanna

0:26:29kinda see what sticks.

0:26:30And that was, it's a fundamentally different approach

0:26:32and you know, it's easy for us to argue in hindsight,

0:26:34like well, turns out it's only used for notifications

0:26:38fitness or whatever, you know, whatever the use case is,

0:26:43it's easy for us to look back on it now and say,

0:26:45launching that first SDK was almost certainly a mistake.

0:26:48Like, it should have launched without third-party apps

0:26:52because it was clearly not able to handle third-party apps

0:26:55yet in both hardware or software.

0:26:58So it should have launched that.

0:27:01But it's hard, like thinking back,

0:27:01like when you're actually in the process of making these

0:27:04products, it's really hard to make the right call on that

0:27:06that kind of thing every time.

0:27:07Like, do you support third-party apps or not?

0:27:08And I think at some point during some interview,

0:27:11I think somebody asked Schiller about that.

0:27:13It might have been on your show at WBC.

0:27:15I can't remember whether it was that or not,

0:27:17but it seemed kind of like Schiller,

0:27:20in the most verbose way that he ever will,

0:27:26said something along the lines of,

0:27:28it was a hard decision and maybe we picked wrong

0:27:30on whether to ship with support for third-party apps.

0:27:34- Yeah, I don't remember if it was on my show or not,

0:27:35I have terrible podcast amnesia.

0:27:37But that sort of feels true, and in hindsight,

0:27:39that's sort of how I feel.

0:27:41And they could have gotten away with

0:27:43the third party interaction with the watch,

0:27:45could have been, on that first version of the watch,

0:27:48could have been entirely through the mirroring

0:27:50of notifications from your phone.

0:27:53- Oh yeah, and in fact, I think a lot of apps

0:27:55are actually doing that now.

0:27:56A lot of apps are realizing now that

0:27:58actually just using rich notification functionality

0:28:01from the phone provides a better overall watch experience

0:28:04than making a watch app.

0:28:05- Yep, it's the only thing I ever use, honestly,

0:28:07other than playback controls for my AirPods, really.

0:28:10And it would've been fine, I think, in the first year.

0:28:17Anyway, that's sort of a sidetrack.

0:28:18While you're here, it's so funny, too,

0:28:22'cause I have other people on the show

0:28:24who have their own podcasts,

0:28:25and I listen to them on their shows.

0:28:27But you're the only one, possibly because ATP,

0:28:30and I'm not just here to butter your toast,

0:28:32but it's the only show I can think of

0:28:34where I try to listen to every episode.

0:28:37So I listen to a lot of it.

0:28:40I keep thinking tonight that you sound

0:28:41like you're talking real slow.

0:28:43(laughing)

0:28:45- You sound the same way to me.

0:28:47- I just keep thinking, God, why is he so slow?

0:28:51Is he tired?

0:28:53And then I realize it's, you know, we don't have.

0:28:55Wait, smart speed is where it takes all the gaps

0:29:00in my sentences.

0:29:02What's the other feature?

0:29:02Just speed up.

0:29:03Is there a name for that?

0:29:04- Well, there's, yeah, there's variable playback speed.

0:29:07Every podcast app offers that.

0:29:09Yeah, so that's just literally speeding up all the audio

0:29:11by a certain rate, and smart speed is what shortens

0:29:13the silence is more than the surrounding audio.

0:29:15- You know what, that's one reason why I don't mind

0:29:18at the moment that I can't just tell HomePod

0:29:23to play something from Overcast.

0:29:26Like, I wrote about it in my HomePod review,

0:29:29but I tried out the built-in play a podcast thing.

0:29:34You just tell it an episode of a podcast

0:29:36and it gets it from iTunes library and it works pretty well.

0:29:39And there's too many podcasts that have ambiguous names,

0:29:42including mine, unfortunately.

0:29:43But although it kind of worked for my show, I don't know.

0:29:48Some people said that it say that it doesn't.

0:29:50Some people, speaking of old Dan,

0:29:51some people say that when they try to get my show to play,

0:29:53it plays like an old episode with me and Dan Benjamin.

0:29:57I tried it with my show and it played the newest episode with Moltz or whoever it was.

0:30:03But then other times it just plays like some other show that's called a talk show or something.

0:30:07Anyway, it works. But because I use Overcast to follow the podcasts I listen to, I don't

0:30:14want to listen to anything outside it and then not have it be marked as read or for

0:30:18like long shows like ATP to keep my playback position for when I return. So I just use

0:30:24you know, and the nice thing about podcasts is that unlike a song, which is only three minutes,

0:30:31three, four minutes, and if you're doing it by airplay, you've only got three minutes before the

0:30:38next thing is up, you know, whereas a podcast tell it to play an hour or two hour podcast.

0:30:43I don't care if you know, because I can still talk to the HomePad and tell it to

0:30:47pause or play or something like that. And it'll keep going. But doing it with airplay through

0:30:52through overcast, I still like having the variable speed too. It's ruined me, really.

0:31:00I can't listen to any kind of audio show, like radio thing, and not feel like they're

0:31:06talking too slow. Even the morning news feature where you come down and you're making coffee

0:31:11and you're like, "Hey, HomePod, tell me the news," and it's like, "Why do these people

0:31:16on NPR talk so slow?"

0:31:19- What's really hard for me is watching YouTube videos

0:31:22because obviously there's no audio manipulation

0:31:24going on there.

0:31:25Although why they don't add a dynamics compressor

0:31:28to make everyone's volume high, I don't know.

0:31:31Why is that not an option in either production or playback?

0:31:34I have no idea.

0:31:35'Cause YouTube volume levels are all over the place.

0:31:38So that's a huge problem that they should solve.

0:31:41But yeah, it's really hard for me to watch YouTube videos

0:31:43because they just move so much more slowly

0:31:46than what I'm accustomed to hearing,

0:31:48which is podcasts with smart speed at like 1.25x.

0:31:52So it isn't a huge difference,

0:31:55but it's noticeable enough that it just,

0:31:57every YouTube video to me seems really slow paced.

0:32:01It also doesn't help that nobody seems to edit.

0:32:05(laughing)

0:32:07- I don't know, we can get into YouTube later

0:32:10when we talk about their Apple TV app.

0:32:12But anyway, I listen to your show all the time.

0:32:14- I am a little curious though,

0:32:15Like with the HomePod and podcasting, like, so you know, I would love so much, and I talk

0:32:20about this everywhere, so I'm not gonna dwell on it too long, but I would love so much for

0:32:23there to be an audio Siri intent, which would also enable things like Spotify, just to be

0:32:29able to tell, you know, "Hey, Dingus, play, you know, play the latest episode of the talk

0:32:34show in Overcast."

0:32:35You know, the same way you can tell Siri to add things to your to-do list in other apps,

0:32:42in things, in OmniFocus.

0:32:43You can use other app names for certain intents,

0:32:46and they work pretty well.

0:32:48So I would love to have that kind of thing with Siri,

0:32:52just to have an audio intent.

0:32:53The main challenge to this IC is, I guess, twofold.

0:32:58One is you have to build some kind of indexing interface

0:33:03so that the audio app can provide Siri

0:33:07with a list of what content is available in it.

0:33:11And for something like Overcast, that is fairly easy,

0:33:14because if you limit it to only things

0:33:17that you already subscribe to in the app,

0:33:19that might only be between two and 30 entries

0:33:22for most people.

0:33:24But for something like Spotify, it's like,

0:33:26well, are you gonna ask Spotify

0:33:28for all the music that they have?

0:33:30Like, that's a bit of a challenge to implement that,

0:33:33and maybe they don't wanna tell you

0:33:34all the music that they have,

0:33:35so there's challenges there.

0:33:37So that's why I think they probably haven't done

0:33:39something like this.

0:33:40But another thing is, and this is kind of a bigger problem

0:33:45I think with the HomePod, is that Siri is still very

0:33:48device specific with what you're asking it

0:33:52when it comes to those APIs.

0:33:55The HomePod has a built-in Apple Music client,

0:33:57so it can directly query Apple Music with no phone nearby,

0:34:00and it can get songs and things from Apple Music

0:34:04and from the podcast directory.

0:34:07But if they built something, if they built the Siri audio intent

0:34:09that would allow Overcast and Spotify and things like that,

0:34:12if they built it the way that these things are built so far,

0:34:15they're only running on the phone.

0:34:17And so that phone would have to be nearby

0:34:20for it to say, hey phone, play this thing,

0:34:22and the phone would have to look at its own

0:34:24locally stored index of what's available

0:34:27and then tell the HomePod, okay, play this thing.

0:34:30And doing it that way would provide something like,

0:34:32well, maybe would provide something like Smart Speed.

0:34:35Because if the app is just running on the phone

0:34:38and the Siri command just tells it what to play,

0:34:43and preconfigures the AirPlay output

0:34:46to say send to the HomePod, that's great.

0:34:48But a much more powerful way to do this

0:34:50is the way that I think all of the other assistants work,

0:34:52and the way Sonos works,

0:34:55which is, and Google's Chromecast protocol,

0:34:57or casting protocol,

0:35:01is like if you have some kind of scalar integration

0:35:02with the voice assistant,

0:35:07you tell it, play this thing in Overcast,

0:35:06and it queries overcast's web service.

0:35:09And doesn't involve any phones or iPads at all.

0:35:11It queries the web service and the web service tells it,

0:35:14here's a URL, start playing this URL.

0:35:18And it fetches that and plays it

0:35:19without the involvement of phones.

0:35:21That is a much more versatile and resilient way

0:35:25to do things, but that's not how Siri Kit

0:35:29works right now at all.

0:35:30And when you're just talking about Siri on the phones,

0:35:34the iPad on the watch, that's kind of okay, although it does limit the watch over LTE,

0:35:38but that's otherwise that's kind of okay. But now that you have the HomePod, it kind

0:35:43of raises the question like, is that the right design for this? And, and, you know, would

0:35:48they be better off doing something that's more web service based? But honestly, I don't

0:35:54think I see Apple doing that or being good at that.

0:35:57It just seems outside their DNA. It's like they're so app centric, you know, like, I

0:36:02I don't think that the reason that this thing comes out of the box not being able to support

0:36:06Spotify, I really don't think it's pure competitive spite.

0:36:10You know, like, screw Spotify, we want everybody to sign up for Apple Music, so we're only going

0:36:15to support Apple Music.

0:36:16I think it's way more complex than that.

0:36:18I think that it's entirely possible that they want, like what you said, an audio intent for

0:36:24SiriKit that would let Overcast hook up to it and would let somebody like Spotify hook

0:36:31up to it if they wanted to, through the phone app and only work when the phone is at home

0:36:38on the network. I don't see them, but like most of these other devices, and I'm a bit

0:36:46of a rube when it comes to Spotify, but I've learned since Ombod came out, you know, that

0:36:52what's it called Spotify Connect or something is the name of their cast like service.

0:36:56Yeah, that sounds awesome.

0:36:57- Right, but it's like you said,

0:36:58it's driven by the truth is,

0:37:02as Steve Jobs said, the truth is in the cloud.

0:37:05And so you can give the direction from your phone

0:37:08and the direction goes from the Spotify phone app

0:37:12to Spotify server.

0:37:14And the direction is play whatever playlist

0:37:17and play it on my kitchen speaker.

0:37:20And the server says, okay,

0:37:22and then pings your kitchen speaker,

0:37:24which is already signed into your account

0:37:25and says, yeah, like you said, here, play this URL.

0:37:28And then it plays.

0:37:29And so it's going from whatever device

0:37:31you issued the directive on to Spotify in the cloud,

0:37:35from Spotify in the cloud to whatever device that is,

0:37:37which might be the same device, you know,

0:37:39could just come right back, but then it plays right there.

0:37:41- And then from that point forward,

0:37:43once the playback has started,

0:37:44the source device is not involved.

0:37:47- Right, but I don't see Apple,

0:37:49I don't blame Apple at all for not supporting Spotify's

0:37:54own proprietary connection thing.

0:37:59It's not just as much, it's not simple,

0:38:03we're not gonna let any third party audio play at all.

0:38:06So I could see them adding support for this

0:38:11and I don't know if Spotify would do it though

0:38:12if it's not Spotify Connect, who knows?

0:38:14- Ultimately, I don't know what Apple's strategy here is

0:38:20but I think they could sell a lot more of these

0:38:24probably high profit $350 speakers

0:38:27and presumably there's probably gonna be

0:38:29more than one HomePod model in the future

0:38:31so they could probably sell many different items

0:38:33in the family of HomePods.

0:38:35Selling a lot of high profit hardware

0:38:38if they covered more use cases

0:38:41and supported more third party services.

0:38:44And I would imagine,

0:38:46while there is a lot of long term strategic value

0:38:50to boosting Apple Music, Apple Music itself

0:38:52is probably not much of a money maker.

0:38:54You know, music streaming is famously unprofitable,

0:38:57as Spotify knows very well.

0:38:59So it, like, I would imagine Apple is probably better suited

0:39:03making sure their hardware sells really well,

0:39:06rather than trying to artificially hamper the hardware sales

0:39:11to boost an unprofitable web service.

0:39:13That doesn't really sound like Apple.

0:39:15- Well, anyway, we can keep talking about HomePod

0:39:17in a minute, but I wanna take a break here.

0:39:19But it reminded me with you on the show,

0:39:22and I've been meaning to say this on the show,

0:39:25I just posted on "Daring Fireball" yesterday

0:39:27about sponsorships and sponsoring a podcast in particular,

0:39:31that I never, the podcast has been doing,

0:39:33my podcast has been doing well.

0:39:35I think ATP's been doing well.

0:39:38Lots of shows, you guys do 52 shows a year, which is nuts,

0:39:42but lots of shows, three sponsors a week,

0:39:45and it's great, and I'm very happy about it.

0:39:47And I love all the sponsors that have come back.

0:39:49I love sponsors that have been with me for years

0:39:52and I'd like it because it seems to me like validation

0:39:57that it actually works, that paying money for me

0:40:00to tell you about such and such company

0:40:03and then years later, they're still sponsoring

0:40:05an episode, one episode a month or even more than that

0:40:09shows that they must be getting good results,

0:40:11so that's great.

0:40:11But then I never have to, I don't have to pimp it

0:40:15for lack of a better word.

0:40:16I never say, hey, you know, like if you have an app

0:40:19or a service, or you work at a company

0:40:21where you think their thing would do well

0:40:23with the talk show or Daring Fireball audience,

0:40:26you should think about sponsoring the show.

0:40:28And I almost, in the back of my head,

0:40:30I think that I've got a lack of variety

0:40:35on the sponsors on the podcast.

0:40:38And I think, duh, because I never tell anybody

0:40:40that you can sponsor it because I don't have to.

0:40:43And so I'm taking a moment here

0:40:44before I introduce our first sponsor,

0:40:48who happens to be a new sponsor, which is very cool.

0:40:50But just to you, the listener, to think about it,

0:40:54if you've got an app or something like that,

0:40:56the rates for the podcast are less than half the rate

0:41:00to sponsor the weekly sponsorship thing at Daring Fireball.

0:41:02So it's more affordable.

0:41:04It is, to me, I think a terrific audience.

0:41:08And just to me, just to sell it,

0:41:11the number of sponsors who come back over and over again

0:41:13is sort of my proof that it's a pretty good,

0:41:17effective way of spending your ad money.

0:41:19And the other thing too that I run into both

0:41:21with the podcast and when I sell the weekly sponsorships

0:41:24in particular is that a lot of the sort of indie type

0:41:28companies that sponsor it, the whole idea of buying ads

0:41:33is new to you and therefore weird.

0:41:36Just to name a company, like Squarespace knows

0:41:42how to buy ads.

0:41:43- Yeah, they're pretty good at it.

0:41:45- Right.

0:41:46You know and it can be scary to say I'm gonna spend a couple thousand bucks to sponsor a podcast I get it

0:41:54But you know if you've ever been thinking about it, seriously, it's not hard and you can just go to

0:42:00For me I had the landing page for me if you're interested

0:42:03Is that neat any AT fm? That's Jesse char who handles booking the the spots here?

0:42:11Because I'm too disorganized to to keep that together

0:42:16But she's very nice and you can go there and I think at least through the end of March

0:42:22I think you guys are doing the same thing but for new sponsors if you never sponsored the show we're offering a discount

0:42:27And I would love to have some new sponsors just for variety's sake

0:42:32not yep, same deal with ATP through the same site through the same nice person Jesse char and

0:42:37Yeah, it's and what I would say is

0:42:42Podcast listeners, just business-wise,

0:42:44how you're gonna spend your money,

0:42:46podcast listeners are a little bit expensive

0:42:49to get relative to other listeners.

0:42:51- CPM, right. - Because we are so valuable.

0:42:54- Right. - And so where this pays off

0:42:57is if you stand to make more than a couple bucks

0:42:59per new customer.

0:43:00So I actually don't recommend it.

0:43:02We occasionally get inquiries from people

0:43:04who are selling apps for $3 on iOS,

0:43:07and I actually tell them, you probably shouldn't do this.

0:43:09- I do too. - Because that,

0:43:11Where podcast really pays off is like podcasts,

0:43:16especially our podcast because we are so awesome,

0:43:21have an audience of people who are willing to spend

0:43:23good money for good products.

0:43:27And so that's why you have something like Squarespace

0:43:29because this is like a nice web hosting platform

0:43:33and the value of a customer to Squarespace

0:43:36is probably in the hundreds of dollars over time range.

0:43:38If you're buying a nice mattress from our friends at Casper,

0:43:41you're spending like $800 on a mattress.

0:43:44Basically, our audiences are willing to pay for good stuff.

0:43:49So if you're selling something where you stand to make

0:43:54like 30 bucks per customer, let's talk.

0:43:56If the most you can make from somebody is like a dollar

0:44:00from the app store, that's probably not a good fit.

0:44:03There's lots of businesses where this is a good fit.

0:44:06things like subscriptions and nice priced items,

0:44:09like nice things, and for that, please contact us.

0:44:13- Yeah, I completely agree, and I've done the same thing

0:44:16with like two or three dollar apps.

0:44:18There was somebody who just came out with a,

0:44:20it's a pretty cool puzzle game.

0:44:23I don't even play games on my phone,

0:44:24but I kinda, this one sucked me in for at least 20 minutes.

0:44:27But at three bucks a pop, and if you really are hoping

0:44:32that you're gonna multiply that by whatever number

0:44:35to at least break even, it's probably not gonna happen.

0:44:38You're gonna sell some copies of the app,

0:44:41but it's probably going to leave you in the red,

0:44:43and it may not, in the long run, help you get in the black,

0:44:47because it's just not that type of thing.

0:44:50So I do the same thing.

0:44:51I never, ever, ever, and hopefully I've never,

0:44:54in all the years I've been selling sponsorships and ads,

0:44:56I've never taken a dollar from somebody who I thought,

0:44:59like, ooh, they shouldn't be spending this.

0:45:03I sleep like a baby every night.

0:45:05So I'm--

0:45:06- Exactly.

0:45:07On a castor mattress, on a hollow pillow.

0:45:10- Right, by certain standards,

0:45:11I am a terrible businessman because that's,

0:45:14there's, you know, I don't think there's any salespeople

0:45:17who listen to our shows, but if somebody out there

0:45:20is like a professional car salesman or something like that,

0:45:23they're like, "What the hell are you talking about?

0:45:25"Somebody wants to spend money

0:45:26"and you tell 'em not to buy your thing?"

0:45:28But I, you know, I would rather sleep well.

0:45:31- I think it's also a good long-term business.

0:45:35If you take someone's money knowing

0:45:36they're gonna not see a return on that,

0:45:39then maybe down the road, if they were gonna buy something,

0:45:44if they're selling something down the road

0:45:45that could benefit from it,

0:45:46or they could make money from it,

0:45:47they're gonna be less likely to go to you.

0:45:48Or if they tell a friend,

0:45:49they're gonna be less likely to recommend you,

0:45:51or they're gonna actually trash you,

0:45:52or the idea of podcast advertising to their friends

0:45:55or their company or whatever else.

0:45:57It's not good long-term business

0:46:00to take people's money knowing that you're

0:46:02kind of burning them.

0:46:02- Right, exactly, like it could show up on a Quora

0:46:05forum thread a year later where somebody would be like,

0:46:08"Hey, is sponsoring the talk show a good idea?"

0:46:10And somebody would be like, "Yeah, I spent a couple

0:46:12"thousand dollars and got $20 in sales."

0:46:16No, it's terrible.

0:46:17- Or like, you know, they could go work for an ad agency.

0:46:19Who like is, you know, some client asks them,

0:46:22"Hey, should we be buying podcast ads?"

0:46:24And they'll say, "Oh no, they're a terrible deal."

0:46:26Like, it's much better to actually like,

0:46:28Keep people happy and not take their money when you know that they're not going to see

0:46:31a return.

0:46:32Well, anyway, our first sponsor this week is a new sponsor.

0:46:36I can't do the read right now.

0:46:37It is a company called Tres Pontas.

0:46:39Tres Pontas, they're a Brazilian company and they sell coffee and olive oil, which is the

0:46:45most intriguing mix of products I've ever seen from a company.

0:46:50And tomorrow, I'm getting by FedEx some of their coffee and I'm going to make it and

0:46:55I'm gonna and then I'm gonna through the magic of editing. I'm gonna jump in right around right here and

0:47:00I'm not gonna lie to you. I'm not gonna cheat you Marco and I recording on Thursday night, but on Friday

0:47:06I'm gonna jump in here with the recording and I'm gonna tell you what their coffee tastes like

0:47:20Okay, this is next day John Gruber

0:47:23I'm recording this about 12 hours after the show last night with Marco. I got my shipment of tres Pontes coffee this morning

0:47:30They sent me their cut to a and I'm probably butchering the pronunciation of that. It's Portuguese cat

0:47:37you a I and

0:47:39They sent it to me in four roasts light medium dark and French roast. I've had two pots of this coffee

0:47:46I've made two for some a/b testing with the dark roast light roast. It's excellent coffee. I love it

0:47:51I've drank way too much of it

0:47:54Quite frankly, it's really good

0:47:58I think I prefer the light roast did a lot of done up did a lot of a/b testing between the light and the dark

0:48:03I guess I'll do medium and French tomorrow

0:48:06It's really good stuff. So here's the deal trace

0:48:10Pontus coffee, you've probably heard of single origin coffee

0:48:13Well, tres pon tas coffee is takes it to a new level. It's single farm

0:48:18coffee

0:48:21all of it comes from

0:48:23the

0:48:24race re is race family farm

0:48:27Just underneath the peaks of the tres pon tas mountains in Brazil

0:48:32For over a hundred years and three generations the race family has been growing some of the best coffee in Brazil previously

0:48:40They only sold it to local roasters

0:48:43Recently, they've only recently started exporting it

0:48:46here to the United States.

0:48:48And so this is a new product

0:48:49that you really couldn't get before,

0:48:50and you can get it now, and it's just excellent.

0:48:52You have two ways to find out more information

0:48:57and to order it.

0:48:57You can go to their website, traspontas.com,

0:49:00T-R-E-S-P-O-N-T-A-S.com/coffee.

0:49:04You can find out all sorts of more information

0:49:06about their coffee.

0:49:06You can order it right there.

0:49:07And when you order their coffee, that's when they roast it,

0:49:11and then they ship it to you immediately.

0:49:13The coffee I got, it's stamped,

0:49:14it was roasted yesterday, which is insane.

0:49:17But getting fresh roasted coffee

0:49:20is probably the number one way

0:49:21that you can up your coffee game.

0:49:23Just about any coffee you get in a grocery store,

0:49:26even a quote unquote gourmet store

0:49:28that's been sitting on shelves,

0:49:30even for just a couple of weeks, loses freshness.

0:49:33Roasted coffee is a commodity that goes,

0:49:40just loses its flavor quickly.

0:49:43Fresh roasted coffee really does make a difference

0:49:46and Tres Pontas coffee only gets roasted once you order it.

0:49:49The other thing you can do is you can go to Amazon.

0:49:51This is so much easier if you just wanna try it.

0:49:53Go to Amazon and search for Tres Pontas.

0:49:55T-R-E-S-P-O-N-T-I-S and their coffee

0:49:59will be the first thing you see.

0:50:00And when you buy on Amazon,

0:50:01your coffee will still be roasted fresh to order

0:50:04and shipped out from Tres Pontas right away.

0:50:06When you get it from Amazon,

0:50:07it's not like it's sitting pre-bagged in warehouses

0:50:10or something like that.

0:50:11It's just a front end.

0:50:12The order goes through to Tres Pontas.

0:50:14They roast the coffee and they ship it to you.

0:50:16You can get it in any one of those four roasts,

0:50:19light, medium, dark French roast,

0:50:20and you can get it pre-ground or whole bean.

0:50:22I recommend whole bean, quite frankly.

0:50:25And all orders enjoy free shipping,

0:50:27regardless of where you order it.

0:50:28I don't, that seems too good to be true.

0:50:31The other thing you can do,

0:50:33if you get it, you like it, you wanna get more,

0:50:34is you can sign up for a coffee subscription

0:50:36from Tres Pontas and get roasted beans

0:50:38to you every one, two or four weeks, your choice. And when you sign up for a coffee subscription,

0:50:43you save 10% off every bag of coffee. Now here's the really good deal. Listeners of the talk show

0:50:49can get an extra 10% off using the code "THETALKSHOW" with the "the" at checkout when you buy a coffee

0:50:55subscription. This means you get a total of 20% off every bag of coffee in your subscription in

0:51:00perpetuity with that code. Just remember to enter the code "ATCHECKOUTTHETALKSHOW" when you sign up

0:51:05subscription. So my thanks to Trace Pontas for sponsoring the show and for

0:51:10sending me this excellent coffee to sample. Now we're back. We're back

0:51:15after my magically inserted review of Trace Pontas coffee. I do know one thing

0:51:22about their coffee. I do know how I'm going to grind it and that will be with

0:51:27what's the name of the thing I have, Marco? The Baratza Virtuoso. The only

0:51:31- The burrata grinder you should have.

0:51:32- The burrata virtuoso.

0:51:33This was a source of conflict in our friendship

0:51:38for years and years because I had a piece of crap burr,

0:51:43well no, a burr grinder is what I have now.

0:51:45I just had like, it was just like a little--

0:51:47- Yeah, you had the spinning blade.

0:51:48- Yeah, a little spinning--

0:51:49- The kind that everybody has, yeah.

0:51:50- A little spinning propeller from KitchenAid, I believe,

0:51:54for years, and I said, "Well, what should I buy?"

0:51:59And then you told me what to buy,

0:52:00and I figured out how big it was,

0:52:02and it literally wouldn't fit in our old kitchen.

0:52:04But now we have a new kitchen,

0:52:06and it's a much bigger kitchen,

0:52:07and it's so big that I have my own cubby hole

0:52:11where I'm allowed to put stuff.

0:52:12(laughing)

0:52:13So I have the Baratza Virtuoso,

0:52:18and I like it, I like it every day.

0:52:21I don't know--

0:52:22- I still remember,

0:52:23you gave me one of my favorite compliments of all time.

0:52:27when I visited you in your old kitchen

0:52:30and your old place a few years back,

0:52:32and I brought some of my own coffee that I roasted.

0:52:35Oh no, no, it wasn't even that,

0:52:36it was when I mailed it to you at some point.

0:52:38- Oh yeah. - And you told me

0:52:39after you tried it, you said,

0:52:42"I almost wanna say fuck you, this is so good."

0:52:45(laughing)

0:52:46I was like so, so perfect.

0:52:49And there's been times in my life

0:52:50where I have said that now to other people about things,

0:52:53because it's just so, it's so perfect.

0:52:55- It was good coffee.

0:52:56It was very good coffee, I have to admit.

0:52:59I don't know that I could Pepsi challenge the difference

0:53:03between fresh ground coffee,

0:53:05ground with the Baratza Virtuoso,

0:53:07versus the old crappy grinder that I used to have.

0:53:12I think I probably could.

0:53:13I do feel that on a daily basis,

0:53:16I'm giving my coffee more Bs and As,

0:53:23and fewer Cs and Bs,

0:53:25in terms of how good I think it tastes.

0:53:28I don't know how much of it's due to that,

0:53:29but it just works better.

0:53:32I like that I can just set the dial and walk away.

0:53:35And the way that it cuts it up,

0:53:38even if it doesn't taste better,

0:53:40it's a much neater grind for,

0:53:43I do pour over almost every day.

0:53:45But even when I make, I think I use a finer,

0:53:48I always have to look it up.

0:53:49I think I use a finer grind for the plunger thing,

0:53:53the AeroPress. - The AeroPress.

0:53:54- Yeah, you should.

0:53:55But on the AirPress, you should be setting that dial

0:53:57to roughly like 10.

0:54:01- I think I do 12. - The dial goes like zero

0:54:03to 40, and yeah, for the AirPress, you should be around 10.

0:54:06- I do like 12, and I do 20 for pour over.

0:54:09- Yeah, that's about right.

0:54:11- But the bigger difference, whether it tastes better or not

0:54:14is it's way neater.

0:54:16Like it comes right out of that little plastic thing,

0:54:20and there's just a couple of little pieces of the husk

0:54:23that are sort of floaters, you know.

0:54:25- But Jeff, yeah.

0:54:26- Right, but they clean up real easy,

0:54:28just like one swipe with a wet towel

0:54:30and they're off the counter.

0:54:31- Yeah, most of that's just static.

0:54:32- But there's no dust, it's not like dust

0:54:34like the old grinder.

0:54:36- Well, it's also, it's a much more consistent grind size,

0:54:40like the grains that come out are much more consistent size.

0:54:42Like the problem with the spinning blade grinders,

0:54:45it's kind of similar, if you ever use a food processor

0:54:47or a blender, like you try to blend something

0:54:50that's like a little bit thick or chunky,

0:54:52like vegetables or a smoothie or something.

0:54:54And the part near the blade gets totally pureed

0:54:58and then the stuff around the edges

0:55:00that just kind of sticks to the walls

0:55:01just kind of stays all clumpy and everything,

0:55:04it doesn't get blended.

0:55:05So you have this huge variety between

0:55:07the stuff in the middle, which is super finely blended,

0:55:09and the stuff on the outside, which is really not.

0:55:11That's what a blade grinder does to coffee.

0:55:13So you have some of the grounds

0:55:16that are really finely ground

0:55:18and some that are really coarse.

0:55:19And depending on how you're brewing it,

0:55:22this may matter or it may not.

0:55:24Typically, like the pour over or drip methods

0:55:27are pretty forgiving of grind size.

0:55:29AeroPress and French press are really not.

0:55:33For French press, you want them to be really big

0:55:36so they don't seep through the filter.

0:55:38And for AeroPress, you want them to be really small

0:55:40because one of the great advantages of the AeroPress

0:55:42over any other method is that you can have

0:55:43a really fine grind and get tons of dense flavor

0:55:47packed into a small amount of liquid

0:55:49without having all the grounds seep through the filter.

0:55:52- Yeah.

0:55:54I tried French press years ago

0:55:55when I first started getting even semi-serious about coffee

0:55:59and I think compared to you who roast your own beans,

0:56:03I still can only say I'm semi-serious about it.

0:56:05Way more serious than anybody else in my family

0:56:08and way less serious than a lot of people.

0:56:11But I thought, well--

0:56:13- By the way, I'm way less serious than a lot of people.

0:56:15- I know.

0:56:16- The way I roast is pretty casual.

0:56:19Like I don't get into like, you know,

0:56:20custom roasting profiles and tweaking the temperatures

0:56:24just right to like during the roast

0:56:25to get these right curves.

0:56:26I don't do any of that.

0:56:27I basically do like the stock preset on the roaster

0:56:31of how to roast and I just decide like,

0:56:33how far do I go before I stop it?

0:56:35That's it, that's the only decision I make.

0:56:37- I do think though, I did try French Pest years ago

0:56:45and I fucking hated it.

0:56:47But it was because it was too much of the coffee

0:56:50was getting into the, you know, the beverage.

0:56:54- Yeah, 'cause you had the wrong grinder.

0:56:55- Right, I had the wrong grinder.

0:56:57And I was like, yeah.

0:56:57- French press can be amazing.

0:56:59The reasons that I don't like it are mainly

0:57:02that it's a pain in the butt to clean,

0:57:04which everyone has this problem.

0:57:06And also that I prefer the, like,

0:57:09AeroPress gives a little bit stronger of a flavor,

0:57:11and I just prefer that.

0:57:12But French press is also very good, very respectable.

0:57:15If I'm at a restaurant that has some kind of

0:57:17nice coffee as a French press option

0:57:19that you can order after the meal.

0:57:21I'll sometimes do that and share it with somebody

0:57:23'cause it is kinda nice.

0:57:24- Yeah, but it definitely has to be ground right.

0:57:26Otherwise it's like you're drinking mud.

0:57:28Oh, I had one other coffee related thing.

0:57:32Oh, I know.

0:57:33Everybody had always told me for years,

0:57:36and I believe it, but the optimal water temperature

0:57:40for pour over is, I don't know,

0:57:42like 185 degrees Fahrenheit, somewhere around there.

0:57:46- Depends who you ask.

0:57:47- Yeah, I guess it depends who you ask,

0:57:48but definitely not 212.

0:57:50- Right, although a lot of coffee pros

0:57:55think it actually isn't that far off 212.

0:57:57Like, I think, I forget what the SCAA,

0:58:01the Specialty Coffee Association of America,

0:58:03they have like a bunch of standards.

0:58:04I think their temperature is 204.

0:58:07So it doesn't need to be that much off.

0:58:09Like, I use an electric kettle,

0:58:11and it has presets for basically every 10 degrees,

0:58:14And I use the 200 preset and it's fine.

0:58:17- So I don't have an electric kettle

0:58:18and I don't feel like, you know,

0:58:21I do have my own cubby hole but I'm running out of space

0:58:24in there with that and a SodaStream.

0:58:26So I just-- - Trust me,

0:58:28I was an electric kettle skeptic for a long time

0:58:31and what happened basically,

0:58:33like my favorite glass kettle finally broke.

0:58:36- The one that had the-- - Somebody had the,

0:58:38I did, the aerial printing.

0:58:39- The aerial printing. (laughs)

0:58:41- Yes, I called it the Helvetic Kettle for years,

0:58:44friends with you and later learned that it was actually printed in Arial.

0:58:47Right. And the problem was that if you get the same kettle it's the

0:58:51Medelko like glass kettle and the problem is if you get it after a few

0:58:55years ago they changed the font that it's printed and it's now printed in

0:59:00something that was kind of like italic comic sans. Like it's completely the

0:59:04opposite of what you'd want. Wait what's it called? It's Medelko and it's like just

0:59:10the Medelko glass kettle. It's like 12 bucks and and like and and then and the

0:59:15picture on Amazon did not reflect the font change for a long time. I don't know

0:59:18if it does now. Let me see. I don't know. Hold on. No, I don't think so.

0:59:27Although there's two. So see here. So this is so there are two that like

0:59:31there's one that still shows the old font and it's M-E-D-E-L-C-O if you search

0:59:37Medelko kettle one so she was the old font and right next to it is one that shows oh

0:59:41Oh my god, it's it's as though somebody at that company

0:59:48Who doesn't it does not see the difference between Helvetica and and

0:59:54Ariel and enough people like me wrote to them to complain and they were like, oh, yeah

1:00:00You want to complain about the font? Fuck you buddy. Here you go

1:00:05Exactly. So it went from almost Helvetica to

1:00:09To knock off Comic Sans. It's not even

1:00:13Better if it was actually Comic Sans

1:00:16There might be some because like if you look at where it says 12 cup capacity that looks almost exactly like Comic Sans

1:00:21Oh, it almost looks like it's doing a fake italic. We're just slanting the text

1:00:25Whistling kettle looks correct. Yeah, maybe that was like an actual italic. Maybe I don't know what Comic Sans italic is

1:00:33Maybe that's just Comic Sans italic. I'm sorry. The problem is like imagine so like, you know, imagine God even the numbers you order the aerial

1:00:40It's amazing it's like who would want this

1:00:45That's so funny though, because I literally did not buy it even though you said that you recommended it

1:00:51I literally didn't buy it years ago because it was printed in aerial and now they've done this. It's so much worse. Oh my god

1:00:58I've since moved on to because yeah when that broke I knew I couldn't get a new one

1:01:03and so I dug out an electric kettle

1:01:05I had bought a while ago for a camping trip

1:01:07and we've been using that since.

1:01:08And Europeans laugh at me whenever I would say

1:01:12like how I boil things in the kettle,

1:01:13they're like, "Wait, what?

1:01:14"Like on your stove?

1:01:15"What are you doing?

1:01:16"Like that's barbaric."

1:01:17'Cause like most of the rest of the world

1:01:18has figured out by now that electric kettles

1:01:20are way better at boiling things,

1:01:22boiling water for coffee and tea.

1:01:24- Why?

1:01:25- We are the only, first of all, they're way faster.

1:01:28- Oh, I don't know about that.

1:01:29I got it, we have a new range and I'll tell you what,

1:01:32that fucker boils water fast.

1:01:34- You have induction, right?

1:01:37That's pretty crazy.

1:01:38- No, well, we do have induction,

1:01:40but I just boil it right over a big old gas flame.

1:01:43- Oh, so you have gas, okay.

1:01:46- Yeah, we have gas.

1:01:47- We also have a really heavy-duty gas stove,

1:01:50and so it would boil pretty fast in the aerial kettle,

1:01:53but it's either the same speed or it's faster

1:01:58in the electric kettle.

1:01:59It's super fast and electric

1:02:01because they just draw tons of power

1:02:02and are pretty efficient at converting that to heat.

1:02:05And then what's nice about it is that first of all,

1:02:07you can set it to a certain temperature

1:02:09and have it hold it at that temperature,

1:02:10which is very nice.

1:02:11Especially if you're doing something

1:02:12that's not a full boil,

1:02:14if you're doing green tea,

1:02:16green tea has to be 170, 175,

1:02:19you don't want it to be any hotter than that.

1:02:20And it's always kind of a pain to do that

1:02:23with a kettle on the stove.

1:02:24- Right, or if you're halfway--

1:02:25- So you can hold it at certain temperatures.

1:02:26- If you're halfway through making coffee

1:02:27and get interrupted 'cause the UPS guy shows up or something.

1:02:30- Right, exactly.

1:02:31It can also hold it at a certain temperature

1:02:33for like a half hour.

1:02:34So if you're like, if you wanted to just start it

1:02:36while you prepare everything else,

1:02:38by the time you're done assembling the AeroPress

1:02:41and grinding up the coffee and everything,

1:02:43it's boiling, it's ready.

1:02:44And it's holding it at the temperature you requested.

1:02:46So that's really nice.

1:02:47It also just boils it, it's really fast,

1:02:49it holds a ton of water.

1:02:50The one I have holds like one and a half liters at once.

1:02:53So if you're making a lot, it's great.

1:02:55If you're making back to back, it's great.

1:02:57And then finally, you can do it

1:02:59in a different part of the kitchen.

1:03:00you're not taking up a burner on the stove.

1:03:02So what I found is it allowed me to like

1:03:05compact my coffee preparation area

1:03:08from like this big triangle that like spanned

1:03:11from the cabinet to the stove to the sink.

1:03:13It was basically like my whole kitchen.

1:03:14Now I can do it like all in this one little countertop

1:03:17next to the sink.

1:03:18'Cause it's all like I'm able to have it wherever I want.

1:03:20So that part's nice too.

1:03:21And also it just saves wear and tear

1:03:22out of my stupid gas burners that break constantly.

1:03:24Never get a Viking stove or a house

1:03:26that has a Viking stove already in it.

1:03:28- Ugh. (laughs)

1:03:30- So, go electric.

1:03:32It seems a little weird for the first day,

1:03:35and then you're like, how did I ever use the stove

1:03:38every day like an ape?

1:03:40- Where do you put it?

1:03:41I mean, it's just like on a countertop?

1:03:44- Yeah, you basically put it where you make your coffee.

1:03:47- No way, yeah.

1:03:48I like cooking. - 'Cause you already have

1:03:49a grinder plugged in, so put it next to your grinder.

1:03:51- Nah, I don't have room for it over there.

1:03:53No, I like cooking-- - Don't you have like

1:03:54four sinks in there?

1:03:56- Nah, two sinks.

1:03:57And there's no room by my sink.

1:04:00No, I figured out in my optimal solution

1:04:02is I put just the right amount of coffee in the kettle.

1:04:05I put it on the high flame.

1:04:08And then as I grind the coffee and get it prepared,

1:04:11by the time I'm ready for it, it's boiling.

1:04:14And then here's my trick.

1:04:16My trick is, and I go over and I get two ice cubes

1:04:21and throw two ice cubes in,

1:04:23and it immediately turns the 212 water

1:04:25into a better temperature, which I have measured precisely

1:04:29with my Thermapim, and it's exactly like 188

1:04:33or 190 or something.

1:04:34- All right, that's, I mean, as long as you can do that

1:04:38in like a repetitive way, which just sounds like you can,

1:04:41then that's fine, I guess.

1:04:42- I'm not even fully awake, and I've got the ice cubes

1:04:45in my hand ready to toss 'em in.

1:04:47And I don't know--

1:04:47- It's a little easier to just hit a button

1:04:48that says 185 and just move on.

1:04:51- I don't know, to me, there's something cool

1:04:52about throwing ice cubes into boiling water.

1:04:55(laughing)

1:04:56- Fair enough.

1:04:57- Where were we?

1:05:01We were talking about HomePod.

1:05:01How about this thing with the HomePod

1:05:03leaving rings on people's furniture?

1:05:05I'm astounded by this.

1:05:07I really am.

1:05:08- It just seems, yeah.

1:05:10- Do you know how much fucking trouble I would be in if--

1:05:15(laughing)

1:05:16- Oh yeah.

1:05:17- Like we've got, I don't even know what material they are,

1:05:20there's some kind of stone type material that are countertops in the kitchen.

1:05:24I, you know, they're not marble,

1:05:28but they're some marble like material that we've either granted or courts. Yeah.

1:05:32One of those and it might, I forget, but it's something like that. And, uh,

1:05:36you know, meticulously picked out at, you know,

1:05:40some input by me, but you know, the whole thing was designed by Amy. Um,

1:05:45and I mean, you've been, you've seen, it's a really nice, it's,

1:05:49She did good work. It's it's a really designed kitchen if I'll tell and that's where I set up the home pod and

1:05:54When I first got to review it, I'll tell you what if I left a fucking ring on that counter from that home pod

1:06:00You have any much I'd I would be fucking dead. I I cannot I

1:06:04Mean she would literally kill you we would not be told doing this podcast right? I mean literally killed I

1:06:09And I realize it doesn't leave rings on that material. Thank fuck. Thank God, but

1:06:16You know, I've seen pictures of some of the people like who've had it on

1:06:21You know the the tables and and shelves that that they've left these rings on they all seem like perfectly reasonable

1:06:28Places to put a home pod. Yeah. Well, and you know, it's a really popular countertop material butcher block oiled wood, right?

1:06:34Exactly really popular right and that's just it is that in some alternate universe, you know

1:06:40I could very easily imagine that that would have been the direction we would have gone

1:06:45You know it maybe if I picked it would have been the direction we would have gone

1:06:49I you know I've been in you know new kitchens that or even old kitchens

1:06:54But you know nice kitchens that have that type of material. I could totally see it I

1:06:59That's it's just crazy to me that that that product didn't ship with a

1:07:05I mean if there's some kind of thing of that that's that

1:07:11That's the way to go with the silicon material at the base and I realize there's an acoustic component to that right that this

1:07:18That the home pod the way that it shoots audio in all directions including down

1:07:23that the

1:07:25material and how it

1:07:27Rests on the thing it's sitting on has some kind of an effect on that and there might there might be that they were well

1:07:32aware of this and went with it anyway, but the fact that it didn't ship with a

1:07:36discrete

1:07:38warning about it along the lines of the way that they said like hey if you buy the jet black iPhone 7

1:07:44It's gonna pick up scratches all micro abrasions or whatever. They called them all over the back, you know, just let people know

1:07:50Yeah, like like the the the iPhone 7 micro abrasion thing

1:07:55I think was that is the best parallel to like how they should have gone like assuming that

1:07:59assuming that they didn't want to or weren't able to

1:08:01Change the material before this thing shipped which that's a big assumption

1:08:06I think they probably should have found this during their apparently widespread and long-standing

1:08:11test of these home pods that were in employees' homes and being tested.

1:08:15This had to have come up.

1:08:18So there's possibly a process issue there where either this wasn't found in the test

1:08:25because they didn't do enough testing, or it was found and they decided to ignore it

1:08:28for whatever reason.

1:08:29Maybe they had good reasons, who knows?

1:08:31But either way, there's probably a process problem there.

1:08:35And then there's definitely a communication problem

1:08:38both in the fact that we weren't warned ahead of time,

1:08:40that it's not like a little note

1:08:41in the instruction manual or anything.

1:08:44And honestly, I thought their response

1:08:45to these claims yesterday was kind of dismissive

1:08:49and almost as bad as the, you know,

1:08:51you're holding it wrong thing.

1:08:53It was really not, I think, a good moment in Apple PR.

1:08:57But it just seems like, you know,

1:09:00it's such a dumb little thing.

1:09:03This is not a big deal.

1:09:05This is, like I said on ATP, it's not a big deal.

1:09:07It's not gonna like sink the home pod.

1:09:10It's not going to result in like a massive recall

1:09:13in all likelihood.

1:09:14I mean, you know, Watson announced it tomorrow

1:09:16and put me wrong, but like I don't think

1:09:17they're gonna do anything about it.

1:09:18I think it's gonna be like a footnote

1:09:20in the support documents basically says like,

1:09:22hey, don't put this on certain services

1:09:24without some kind of protection.

1:09:27And you know, but you know, like the response of,

1:09:31well, you should probably just refinish your table.

1:09:33(laughing)

1:09:34- That's not a good response.

1:09:36- Right, and you know, it's--

1:09:37- And it seems like it's kind of like an unforced error

1:09:40because like lots of other products

1:09:44sit on these surfaces without leading marks.

1:09:47And it's not to say that like,

1:09:49I think I saw something earlier today

1:09:51that apparently the Sonos One leaves very, very faint marks

1:09:55on its four corners, like four little L-shaped corner pads,

1:09:58and apparently it leaves some mild version

1:10:00of the same thing.

1:10:01So like it's not that the HomePod

1:10:02is the only thing that does this.

1:10:04You know, similar to how like the iPhone 4

1:10:06was not the only phone where you hold it a certain way

1:10:08to block the antenna.

1:10:10And they spent a lot of that press conference

1:10:12telling you that.

1:10:13But it is Apple's problem in the sense that, you know,

1:10:17this is the big story about it.

1:10:18This is something that the HomePod seems to do more

1:10:21than anything else.

1:10:22And I don't think it's reasonable to expect people

1:10:27to know this ahead of time.

1:10:30Like just to automatically know,

1:10:32oh, you shouldn't put things with rubber feet

1:10:36on your oiled wood countertops.

1:10:38To me, something with rubber feet

1:10:40seems like it would be totally fine.

1:10:41- Clean, especially. - It's not totally inert.

1:10:43It seemed like that would be protecting

1:10:45the surface from damage.

1:10:46- Right, and I'm even-- - And even though--

1:10:47- I'm even careful about things

1:10:49like getting my finger grease on something.

1:10:50So when I took the HomePod out of the box,

1:10:53I was careful to only touch it by the sides

1:10:56and from Shenzhen, China, until it touched my countertop,

1:11:01the bottom had never been touched by human hands.

1:11:04You know, and I thought like, well, that's clean.

1:11:06You know, it's a clean countertop

1:11:08and the HomePod is certainly clean

1:11:10because I just took it out of the box and never touched it.

1:11:13It never would have occurred to me in a million years

1:11:15not to put it on wood kitchen countertops

1:11:18if we had had wood kitchen countertops.

1:11:20Just wouldn't have even entered my mind as like a,

1:11:24hmm, maybe I shouldn't put it there.

1:11:26You know, like things like, hey, maybe I shouldn't put it,

1:11:29you know, I would think of things like,

1:11:32well, maybe I shouldn't put it next to a sink

1:11:34because, you know, an accidental spill could happen here.

1:11:37Like, you know, I just put it next to where our echo was.

1:11:42So, but that spot was chosen because, you know,

1:11:45it seemed like a spot that is almost always dry

1:11:48and doesn't have accidental spills.

1:11:51So that occurred to me.

1:11:53The idea that it would leave rings

1:11:54never would have even occurred to me.

1:11:56- Yeah, and it's the kind of thing like,

1:11:58Obviously, like Apple should know,

1:12:00and I'm sure they do know,

1:12:01that this category of product,

1:12:04as much as they are trying really hard

1:12:07in the marketing and the PR

1:12:09to make this about audio quality

1:12:10while it's sitting in your living room,

1:12:12the fact is this category of product

1:12:14is very often used in kitchens.

1:12:16And a very common place to put it is on a countertop.

1:12:20And so they should have, and I hope did,

1:12:24test it on every popular countertop material

1:12:27that's available.

1:12:28And they would have found this if they did that

1:12:31because butcher block is very, very popular

1:12:33and very common because it's really nice

1:12:36and pretty inexpensive.

1:12:37And so they should have found this and they didn't

1:12:40or they decided to ship it anyway.

1:12:42And so it's just, again, this isn't a huge problem.

1:12:47There's already like 10,000 awesome little coasters

1:12:50that people will sell you for $30 made out of leather

1:12:52and metal and stuff and custom engraved,

1:12:55artisanally hand-stitched leather coasters for it.

1:12:58And maybe Apple will sell their own this fall

1:13:02for $100, this little leather circle

1:13:04with an Apple logo in the middle of it.

1:13:05But it isn't a big problem,

1:13:09but it's just kind of embarrassing,

1:13:10and I think it does reveal some potential process flaws

1:13:14in how this got out without even a warning.

1:13:17- Just seems very surprising to me.

1:13:20I think the two most, I don't know,

1:13:24Everybody's different, I don't know.

1:13:26But to me, the two most natural places for one of these

1:13:30are a kitchen and a bedroom.

1:13:31'Cause I don't think it's a great living room product

1:13:34if your living room is your TV room.

1:13:36Like I use that interchangeably.

1:13:39So I realize that in like a lifestyle magazine,

1:13:42people don't have a TV in their living room

1:13:44because it's meant for hosting parties and everybody.

1:13:48- In the magazines, they also have white couches.

1:13:50- Right, everybody, all the chairs face around each other

1:13:53so you can talk to each other and there's no place for a TV.

1:13:56Well, our living room has a TV.

1:13:58But because it is, you know, if you have a TV,

1:14:01a TV room is not a great place for a home pod

1:14:03unless you really listen to enough music

1:14:05independent of your TV that having a sound system

1:14:09that's completely independent of your

1:14:11home entertainment system makes sense to you.

1:14:14It doesn't really make sense to me that way.

1:14:17Kitchen though is perfect because traditionally

1:14:19most people don't have a good sound system in their kitchen.

1:14:24And a lot of people spend a lot of time in their kitchens.

1:14:27A lot of families eat their meals in the kitchen.

1:14:30So it's a great place for that.

1:14:33And a bedroom would be another place

1:14:35where maybe you don't have a good sound system.

1:14:38But that's another place where you might have wood.

1:14:41I'm still not sure about the details of what types of wood,

1:14:44what types of treatment.

1:14:46It's like ones that have a polyurethane coating are safe,

1:14:49and ones that are just sort of oiled aren't.

1:14:52But it seems to me like a lot of people

1:14:54might have bedroom furniture

1:14:55that exactly is along those lines too.

1:14:58- Yeah, it seems like the problem is that,

1:15:01it's in surfaces that their main treatment is just oil

1:15:06that is like slightly seeped into the wood.

1:15:09And that the problem therefore is that

1:15:10when you stick the silicone on top of it,

1:15:13that the silicone absorbs some of that oil into itself,

1:15:16pulling it out of the wood

1:15:17and creating basically an unfinished circle in the wood.

1:15:21And that's why it goes away after a few days,

1:15:23'cause the oil has time to reabsorb

1:15:24into that area of the wood.

1:15:26- So I had a tweet the other day, yesterday actually,

1:15:30that went semi-viral for me, at least, 1,322 likes.

1:15:34It was an interaction I had.

1:15:35It was with a HomePod in my office.

1:15:37The entire tweet-- - Oh, the courts thing?

1:15:40- Yeah, the entire tweet is just my, the playback.

1:15:45And I believe it's word-for-word accurate.

1:15:46So here's me, hey Siri, oh I shouldn't say that, I'm sorry.

1:15:49Hey, you know.

1:15:50- No, if Phil Schiller said it on your show,

1:15:52you can say it on your show.

1:15:53- Well, I'm gonna say, hey HomePod,

1:15:54hey HomePod, how many quarts are in a gallon?

1:15:57And HomePod said, what would you like me

1:15:59to convert one gallon to?

1:16:02And I already knew we were off to a rough start,

1:16:04and I said, quarts.

1:16:05And there was a little bit of a pause,

1:16:08and HomePod said, quarts is a mineral compound

1:16:12composed of silicon and oxygen atoms

1:16:14in a continuous framework,

1:16:16blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

1:16:18It was verbatim the first paragraph of Q-U-A-R-T-Z

1:16:23from Wikipedia.

1:16:25And I thought it was so funny.

1:16:28And it was weird, and I actually know this.

1:16:31I actually, it was a weird conversation

1:16:34when Amy was doing something and she said,

1:16:37how many quarts are in a gallon, two?

1:16:39And I was like, no, no, four,

1:16:40because that's the quart and quart is a quarter,

1:16:44and it's a quarter gallon.

1:16:46That's how I remember it.

1:16:47- Wait, is it really?

1:16:48- Yeah, there's four quarts in it.

1:16:50- I never knew that.

1:16:51- Yeah, so there's four quarts in a gallon

1:16:52and the way to remember it is that the Q-U-A-R-T

1:16:56is the same whatever route as quarter.

1:16:59So there you go, you'll never--

1:17:01- Oh, that's awesome.

1:17:02- Yeah, so I actually knew it.

1:17:04I hate the dipshits on Twitter who were like,

1:17:06"Oh, don't you know that?"

1:17:07And it's like, you know what,

1:17:09I'm a big fan of Fahrenheit, everybody knows it.

1:17:13I'm okay with miles instead of kilometers.

1:17:16But you know, like for the volume,

1:17:21I mean, the imperial system is terrible.

1:17:24I mean, you know.

1:17:26And it even shows, like, you know,

1:17:28that you can buy like a two liter of soda, you know,

1:17:30like we do sell products and like the liter

1:17:33is the one thing that sort of seeped into American life.

1:17:36So I'm down with that.

1:17:37I can't remember for the life of me

1:17:39how many cups are in anything or anything like that.

1:17:41But I knew the answer to this,

1:17:43But I just thought off the top of my head, hey,

1:17:45here's a question to ask Siri on the HomePod.

1:17:50And the way that this interaction went bad was--

1:17:54I swear to God, this is verbatim, word for word,

1:17:56what she said.

1:17:57And then I immediately, after this,

1:18:00immediately tried it again.

1:18:02And I said the same thing.

1:18:03Hey, HomePod, how many quarts are in a gallon?

1:18:05And it got the right answer.

1:18:08I said, there's four quarts in a gallon immediately.

1:18:11So I got it.

1:18:12I had this comical response, immediately asked again,

1:18:16and it gave me the right answer.

1:18:18And so a whole bunch of people on Twitter,

1:18:21I didn't explain it.

1:18:22All I did was post the transcript of my interaction

1:18:24and a whole bunch of people said,

1:18:25"I just tried it, it works for me."

1:18:27But I thought it was kind of enlightening

1:18:31that the way that this blew up

1:18:34and became a widely retweeted and liked and everything,

1:18:37clarified for me some mushy thinking

1:18:40on what's wrong with Siri.

1:18:43And that sort of like, hey, I tried it, it worked for me.

1:18:48And the fact that it worked for me, five seconds later,

1:18:51I get it, I see that all the time.

1:18:53And that to me is the fundamental problem with Siri today.

1:18:58And it's not how much Siri can do

1:19:01and how many features Siri has.

1:19:05And even though I think that's what too many people

1:19:07focused on compared to the Amazon Alexa on the Echo products and the Google on theirs

1:19:14and how many home, smart home stuff they can hook up to and what syntax you have to use,

1:19:19blah, blah, blah. To me, that's way--you're already past the fundamental problem, which

1:19:23is that Siri is completely unreliable, even at the things that Siri can do and maybe even

1:19:30does most of the time correctly. But if you can't count on it--I don't know what percentage

1:19:36of my queries like how many courts are in a gallon go wrong like this. But whatever

1:19:43that percentage is, and I'm going to guess it's, I'm going to say off the top of my head,

1:19:47it's 10%, maybe 15%. And I could be way wrong either way because I don't keep track of it

1:19:54and human memory is very faulty. But whatever that percentage is, it's way, way, way too

1:20:00high and it breeds contempt. It breeds absolute contempt for the feature. And the analogy

1:20:10I would draw is that when I click or tap, you know, on the Mac I click and on the iOS

1:20:18I tap a button on the screen. And I know that I've hit the target correctly, that my mouse

1:20:26is within the buttons region or my finger is with touches within the button tap region,

1:20:33what percentage of the time does that button actually activate when I tap it? That percentage

1:20:38is very, very close to 100% and it may well be 100%. It may well be that I, in the what,

1:20:47five, six months I've been using an iPhone 10, that I haven't once tapped the screen

1:20:51on a tap target and not had the tap target fire.

1:20:56When I type a key on my keyboard, and this gets to some of the problems with the new

1:21:00MacBook Pro keyboard, when I type a D key, how many times do I get a D on the screen?

1:21:06A hundred percent of the time.

1:21:08Not 99% of the time, not 99.8% of the time.

1:21:11A hundred percent of the time.

1:21:13And anything less than that is unacceptable.

1:21:16And I feel like that's the problem with Siri.

1:21:18And I get it that Siri's not, in the year 2018,

1:21:22Siri's not going to be at 100%,

1:21:24and it's probably not gonna be at 99%,

1:21:27but it should be in the high 90s,

1:21:29and it's nowhere near that.

1:21:31- Yeah, Siri has a lot of, I think, pretty big problems

1:21:36and pretty big challenges,

1:21:37but the reliability is definitely, I think,

1:21:41one of the biggest, because when this was introduced,

1:21:45again, in 2011, that was a long time ago,

1:21:48and Apple really was indeed way ahead of the competition then.

1:21:51You know, it's kind of like, you know,

1:21:52when they introduced the iPhone and Steve sat on stage

1:21:56that they were five years ahead of the competition.

1:21:58And that proved to be roughly correct.

1:22:00- Right.

1:22:01It really did.

1:22:02- With Siri, I think they were, you know, similar,

1:22:05you know, maybe like three to five years

1:22:06ahead of the competition.

1:22:08But it seemed like the competition then, of course,

1:22:11caught up in that time, like Siri, you know,

1:22:13like many Apple innovations do,

1:22:14Siri kind of set the roadmap of the rest of the industry

1:22:18for them, and so they did, the industry followed.

1:22:22But it seemed like Siri has not gotten better

1:22:27at anywhere near the rate

1:22:28that everyone else is getting better.

1:22:30It seems like Siri gets better

1:22:32at an absolutely glacial pace compared to developments

1:22:37at Amazon, Google, and even Microsoft.

1:22:41- Mm-hmm.

1:22:42So it seems like, and I don't know what it is,

1:22:46I don't know what exactly Siri's challenges are,

1:22:49whether there's like problems with the project or whatever.

1:22:52I have no idea, it doesn't really matter.

1:22:53What matters from the outside is that it is fundamentally

1:22:57way too unreliable compared to its competitors

1:23:02and also seems to be improving way too slowly.

1:23:06And there's a lot of things the competitors can do

1:23:09that Siri still can't do.

1:23:11There's a lot of basic things that the competitors do

1:23:13faster and more reliably than Siri does.

1:23:17And there's a lot of things that I think

1:23:20the competitors have figured out about

1:23:21how to design the system, how things should respond,

1:23:25how things should be that Apple seems to either

1:23:27disagree with or not care about.

1:23:29Like one of the big things there is like

1:23:31Siri is very kind of a smart ass about certain things.

1:23:36- Yeah, I've mentioned that before.

1:23:38You can be a smart ass if you're really,

1:23:40really good at your job.

1:23:42You can occasionally be a smart ass.

1:23:44- And you know that as a smart ass yourself.

1:23:47You know that.

1:23:48And I know it as somebody who's a bit of a smart ass

1:23:51and in my youth was an intolerable smart ass.

1:23:55But only when I knew that I was the smartest person

1:23:57in the room. - Now you're definitely not.

1:23:59Yeah. (laughs)

1:24:01But if I was somebody's assistant

1:24:03and I acted the way that I do

1:24:06while I also messed up a third of the things

1:24:08that I was asked to do in comically obtuse ways,

1:24:12I would be fired in a day.

1:24:13Like it would take less than a day I'd be fired.

1:24:17Like Siri, I think there's always been this design

1:24:21of Siri to be like kind of a smart ass

1:24:23and that was kind of cute in 2011.

1:24:26But, and it would still be kind of okay.

1:24:29I mean, not always, honestly, I think a lot of,

1:24:31it turns off a lot of people,

1:24:32but it would still be kind of okay

1:24:35if Siri was just awesome and if it did everything like awesomely.

1:24:40But the reality is like, you know, no voice assistant

1:24:45is as reliable as our keyboards and our other input devices.

1:24:51And that's kind of a shame, honestly. If you think, you know, your earlier thing about, you know,

1:24:55how often does a keyboard fail or does tapping on a screen fail?

1:25:00I'm not sure there's any other area of consumer computing that we tolerate as high as we can.

1:25:04rate as high of an error rate as we do with with voices. No, it's no, I mean, the only

1:25:10other thing I can think of is is my Apple TV remote is not as accurate as my as my mouse

1:25:19at my iMac, my trackpad on my MacBook Pro or my keyboard like or the touchscreen on

1:25:27my iPhone and iPad. There's definitely a, I overshoot things with that remote or, or,

1:25:34but it's still way more accurate and efficient, you know, a combination of accuracy, reliability

1:25:41and efficiency than Siri way more. It's, it's not even close. And I've been, I was puttering

1:25:47around with the fire TV again recently, just, I wanted to see, I want to get to it later,

1:25:54to talk about the updated YouTube app for Apple TV.

1:25:58And I wanted to see what was going on

1:26:00on the Fire TV with YouTube,

1:26:02because there's that whole pissing match

1:26:04between Amazon and Google,

1:26:06where Amazon booted off the official,

1:26:10or YouTube yanked the official YouTube app

1:26:13or started blocking it, and we could get into that.

1:26:16But their remote is sort of Apple TV-like in its minimalism.

1:26:21I don't know if you have one.

1:26:24Do you have a Fire TV product?

1:26:25- I bought the first one, I have since sold it,

1:26:29but does it still have that same kind of black,

1:26:31almost like triangular profile remote?

1:26:33- Yeah, sort of.

1:26:35It's got a circular D-pad at the top,

1:26:38sort of a lot like the old Apple TV remote.

1:26:40It's got a circular D-pad at the top,

1:26:43a home button, a back button, and a menu button.

1:26:46The menu button is the one that puts it a little bit more

1:26:49in the more buttons than Apple has.

1:26:52But it's, you know, it's roughly Apple TV-like

1:26:55and it's minimalism.

1:26:56And it's not, I like the Apple TV,

1:27:04maybe it's 'cause I'm used to it,

1:27:06'cause I use Apple TV almost every day.

1:27:08I like the Apple TV, we could do a whole show

1:27:13and we all, you and I always go along,

1:27:15and we could do a whole show about the problems

1:27:17with Apple TV's remote.

1:27:20But the basic idea of a touchpad on a remote,

1:27:22I think, is definitely a solid one.

1:27:26There are times when it's so much-- it is nice and efficient.

1:27:29It feels like I can go more than one row.

1:27:31Like, the D-pad on the Fire one, it's like one click at a time sucks.

1:27:36And if you press and hold, it goes way too fast.

1:27:38But even so, I never feel as completely frustrated

1:27:45as I do when a Siri interaction goes wrong.

1:27:47And think about that.

1:27:48I do think that this one that I tweeted, it's really interesting how it went wrong.

1:27:53So the it's four interactions, two for me, two from Siri.

1:27:57And my first one is how many courts are in a gallon, which should be,

1:28:02you know, and again, I don't know, you know, to Apple's credit,

1:28:06they at least have the right goal,

1:28:08which is that they want to allow arbitrary syntax.

1:28:13Like you don't have to say, maybe I would have gotten a better result if I said,

1:28:18"Hey, convert one gallon to quarts."

1:28:22I don't know if that's better

1:28:24than how many quarts are in a gallon.

1:28:26But Apple's stated goal, which I think is admirable

1:28:29and which is correct,

1:28:30which is that it should just process language the way we do,

1:28:33where if I asked you, a human, thinking you knew the answer,

1:28:38it wouldn't matter to you which way I put it, right?

1:28:41And so I think it's admirable from Apple's perspective

1:28:44that they're approaching it that way.

1:28:46And her response is, "What would you like me

1:28:49"to convert one gallon to?"

1:28:51So she obviously knew I was converting something to gallons,

1:28:56but must have misheard me say quarts,

1:28:58but it's just a weird thing.

1:29:00But then she asks me, "What would you like me

1:29:02"to convert one gallon to?"

1:29:04And all I said was the one word answer, quarts.

1:29:06And so she was in the mode where she's listening

1:29:09for me to respond.

1:29:10I didn't have to say, "Hey, HomePod, quarts."

1:29:14I could just, you know, there's certain multi-step things with Siri where she's expecting an

1:29:19answer and you can just say it.

1:29:21So what would you like me to convert one gallon to?

1:29:24I say one word, quartz, and somehow this gets misconstrued as what is quartz, the mineral.

1:29:31Like how…

1:29:32It's a…

1:29:33Yeah, that's…

1:29:34There's no excuse for that.

1:29:35It's a really strange interaction.

1:29:39really bizarre to me that she asked me what would I like to convert one gallon

1:29:43to and and if anything knowing that I was converting a gallon you would think

1:29:48you know listen for common forms of you know volume measures of volume you know

1:29:55whether they right yeah you didn't say like miles or airplanes or whatever it's

1:30:00like it was something that's very that it should be a very expected and common

1:30:04response to that question and and quartz should be on a very short list of things

1:30:09an English speaker might want to convert one gallon to. It's a very bizarre way for that

1:30:14to have gone off the rails. And again, immediately, within 10 seconds, I took a little bit of

1:30:21time just to jot it down, because I really suspected I wouldn't be able to reproduce

1:30:25it. So I wanted to get it down as best I could. And I even quick looked up the Quartz QRTZ

1:30:33Wikipedia page to make sure that—and it was word for word, so I didn't have to memorize

1:30:37that portion of it. I could just copy and paste it from Wikipedia. And then immediately

1:30:42tried it again and it worked. And it did. But to me, that level of unreliability is

1:30:48why people stop using it. And the problem is we're no longer at the point where Siri

1:30:56is, "Well, it's okay if it sucks because it's just sort of an extra and nobody really

1:31:01depends on it." Because now, with HomePod, they're shipping a product where the primary

1:31:05interfaces Siri. And again, even just leave aside, just leave aside the comparisons to

1:31:13Alexa and Google Assistant. Just judge it on its own merits. Is it good enough? And

1:31:19I really do think the answer is no, it's it's not it's like having it would be like shipping

1:31:23a touchscreen phone before capacitive touchscreens, right? Like back in the when you had to press

1:31:30real hard era.

1:31:32- Yeah, exactly.

1:31:33Like this, Siri is very frustrating to me

1:31:37because I want so badly to only be

1:31:40in the Apple ecosystem for this stuff.

1:31:43Like I want so badly to not have an Amazon cylinder

1:31:47of commerce and creepiness in my kitchen.

1:31:49Like I want that to be a HomePod.

1:31:51I want to be all in on Apple stuff

1:31:53because a lot of stuff just works better that way

1:31:55and I like their privacy and I like their apparent

1:31:58sound quality and niceness of their devices and everything.

1:32:00are like, I want so badly for that to be the case,

1:32:03but Siri, I really think is holding them back

1:32:06in some pretty big ways.

1:32:08It just is not good enough.

1:32:10You know, I think you're right.

1:32:12The rate of just errors and weirdness and unreliability

1:32:17and honestly, fragmentation is another major concern here.

1:32:21Of like, you know, Siri on different platforms

1:32:22handling different things or not handling different things.

1:32:26I think that's a pretty big problem.

1:32:28There's lots of problems with Siri,

1:32:29But it all comes down to the fact that like, it is now seven years old, and it's still not reliable.

1:32:38And not to the sense that it's like 100% reliable, because as I said earlier, like, none of the voice assistants are 100% reliable.

1:32:45But like one of the most shocking things to me when I first got the Amazon Echo, after only having used Siri before that,

1:32:52was that the Echo, even though in some ways it is less advanced,

1:32:57like it's less advanced in things like non-English language support,

1:33:01in things like what order you say certain phrases in with like understanding the syntax.

1:33:06So there's areas that like Apple and its fans are always happy to try it out and say,

1:33:11"Well Siri is really advanced in these areas, fine."

1:33:15But the Amazon Echo is 100% reliable for me in what it can do.

1:33:19It almost never misunderstands me.

1:33:22It almost never gives me, I think I've heard

1:33:25like their version of like the, like when Siri says,

1:33:28sorry, I can't help you right now,

1:33:29where it's like basically like a server error happened.

1:33:32I've heard that on the Echo, I think twice in two years.

1:33:37And we use it multiple times a day for lots of stuff.

1:33:41So the Echo is clearly way ahead in reliability.

1:33:46It's also way ahead in speed.

1:33:48Like I remember when I first got it,

1:33:50just being amazed compared to Siri,

1:33:51just how quickly and how consistently

1:33:54it responded to things.

1:33:55So we have speed, consistency, and reliability

1:33:59with the Amazon Alexa service

1:34:01that we just don't have with Siri.

1:34:04And I think that, like, that shouldn't be the case.

1:34:08This is not one of Amazon's like core competencies,

1:34:12historically, this is not the kind of thing

1:34:13that like their products heavily depend on it.

1:34:16Well, now they do, but they didn't at the time.

1:34:17Apple should be kicking Amazon's butt in this area.

1:34:21And the fact that they're not, I think,

1:34:22should be cause for serious concern in the company

1:34:25because this is not just some toy accessory feature

1:34:30that is kind of a fun thing.

1:34:32Like you said, this is becoming a really important feature

1:34:35and in some ways the most important feature

1:34:37of certain products.

1:34:38And it's just embarrassing that Apple seems to be

1:34:44unable to compete to that let to even a basic level of reliability and quality compared to

1:34:50What the other players in this same market were able to do in less time

1:34:55It's in arguable to me that Siri is the primary interface to home pod

1:34:59I don't see how else you I don't see how you could argue. Otherwise sure you can control it by airplay and

1:35:05Yes, there are hardware volume buttons and you can tap it for play pause, but it's it's clearly

1:35:12I mean, it doesn't ship with a remote control.

1:35:14I mean, there's no--

1:35:15- Oh, yeah.

1:35:16- The fact that it doesn't ship with a remote control,

1:35:18and it's conceived that the remote control is your voice.

1:35:22- And one could argue that the Siri might even be

1:35:26a pretty close second interface for the Apple Watch.

1:35:28- Exactly, you took the words right out of my mouth.

1:35:31And AirPods, AirPods a little bit less so,

1:35:36but I think if Siri was better on AirPods

1:35:39and faster to respond, it would be primary.

1:35:43Like it's only not primary because it takes so long

1:35:46and isn't reliable for like, you know,

1:35:50changing what you're listening to or play pause

1:35:53or you know, changing the volume and stuff like that.

1:35:58And their future products are going to be,

1:36:03I mean, what is Apple great at?

1:36:05They're great at making personal computers

1:36:08smaller and smaller and more personal and more personal.

1:36:11And once you get beneath the size of a phone,

1:36:15a screen is really not that great as a primary interface.

1:36:19I mean, that's a big deal.

1:36:21That's why I wanted to bring up Apple Watch and Siri

1:36:24and you saw it coming.

1:36:26It's good for, it's okay for literally displaying things

1:36:31like taking a glance at your watch to see what that tap was.

1:36:35But for responding, Siri would be,

1:36:37I would be better if Siri were reliable and fast enough.

1:36:41- Yeah, and I think we're seeing,

1:36:44like this is the direction

1:36:46that some pretty big markets are heading.

1:36:48Like obviously, I don't think Siri has a ton of,

1:36:53I don't think it's massively holding back

1:36:56the Mac or the iPad, and maybe not the phone,

1:37:00but that's kind of a maybe.

1:37:02But a lot of these markets where things are getting smaller

1:37:05and especially anything wearable, as you said,

1:37:07like anything where you have either no screen

1:37:09or a very small screen,

1:37:10that's only gonna get more important.

1:37:12And the other voice assistants are not standing still.

1:37:15They are really advancing quickly.

1:37:18And Amazon I don't think is gonna ever

1:37:21have great multi-language support

1:37:23because Amazon, the company,

1:37:25doesn't really have a lot of great support

1:37:26outside of the US for pretty much anything.

1:37:29Google does, and Google I think is doing pretty well

1:37:31in that area so far.

1:37:33Microsoft, probably also with Cortana,

1:37:35I don't know much about that, but from what I hear,

1:37:37it's pretty decent.

1:37:38This is an area where, again, Apple should be

1:37:42leading the way, this is user interface.

1:37:45And Apple, in their DNA and in their history,

1:37:49they have cared so deeply about making really great

1:37:53user interfaces and user experiences.

1:37:55And this is one area where, when it came out in 2011,

1:37:58it was like, well, it's kinda crappy and kind of unreliable,

1:38:02but it's pretty cool, let's see where this goes.

1:38:05And hopefully Apple will have the best one of these

1:38:08like forever, the same way they usually

1:38:09have the best interface.

1:38:10And that just hasn't happened,

1:38:12and it's been quite the opposite,

1:38:14where now like Siri seems like Windows

1:38:17by comparison to even the most basic Alexa interactions,

1:38:21because the Alexa interactions are just so damn fast

1:38:24and reliable and pretty smart, honestly.

1:38:28Like when I ask like general knowledge questions

1:38:31or like local questions.

1:38:32I will often try Siri first if I have my phone with me.

1:38:38And so often it just gives me bad results

1:38:41or no good results or a web search.

1:38:42And I ask the exact same question

1:38:44and the exact same phrasing to my Amazon Echo

1:38:47and it gives me the answer.

1:38:48And this doesn't happen every time that way

1:38:50but it happens a lot that way

1:38:51and it doesn't usually happen the other direction.

1:38:53So it's concerning to me like just quite

1:38:56how far behind Siri appears to be

1:38:59and how slowly it seems to ever change.

1:39:02It just seems like what I hope is coming

1:39:06is a massive reset or like a big Siri 2.0.

1:39:10I hope there's massive changes underfoot

1:39:13that we just aren't seeing yet

1:39:14because whatever they've been doing to date with Siri,

1:39:18it's just not good enough.

1:39:19And it doesn't seem to be getting good enough,

1:39:21quickly enough to ever catch up

1:39:24or ever even reach a minimum level of good.

1:39:27There was a funny thing, and it is funny because we were talking about how we don't like

1:39:34it when Siri tries to be funny, but there was a—Amy was the one who found it. But

1:39:44before the Super Bowl, if you asked the Echo who's going to win the Super Bowl, like,

1:39:49Siri has been—one of the things Siri has been ahead of is Siri's been hooked up to

1:39:52like sports betting lines for a while. So you can ask like who's the favorite in an

1:39:57upcoming major sports event, and Siri almost always can tell you exactly what the point

1:40:02spread is or if it's a different type of sport where it's just odds, what the odds

1:40:06are.

1:40:10But when you asked—did you hear about this?

1:40:11When you asked the Alexa before the Super Bowl who was going to win the Super Bowl,

1:40:14they programmed her with a total jab at the Patriots.

1:40:18Did you see this?

1:40:19She said, "The team favored to win is the—excuse me.

1:40:24Excuse me. It's the Patriots. That was tough to get out. But I'm flying with the Eagles

1:40:32on this one because of their relentless defense and the momentum they've been riding off

1:40:36their underdog status. E-A-G-L-E-S. Eagles. For whatever reason, Eagles fans, their chant

1:40:46is to just spell out the word Eagles, but they're very into it. I thought it was amazing.

1:40:53are speculating that it comes from the fact that Bob Kraft, the owner of the Patriots,

1:41:02is best friends with Trump, and that Bezos has his issues with Trump. Perhaps that was the reason.

1:41:10But for whatever reason, Echo was totally down with the Eagles in the Super Bowl. And I thought

1:41:15that was actually pretty charming. I thought that was actually one of these assistants trying to be

1:41:19be funny where it came off as pretty funny.

1:41:22- Meanwhile, I asked Siri the morning of the Super Bowl,

1:41:27who is playing the Super Bowl?

1:41:30And it told me Justin Timberlake.

1:41:32- Well, that's true.

1:41:34That is true.

1:41:35- Right, exactly, yeah, it's like, okay.

1:41:37And if you said who is playing in the Super Bowl,

1:41:39it would tell you the right answer,

1:41:41but if you said who is playing the Super Bowl,

1:41:43it treated that as a musical venue.

1:41:45Because as everyone knows,

1:41:48Super Bowl is primarily a musical venue. It's like you knew that the Eagles had a backup

1:41:53quarterback in but you didn't realize they were so desperate that they were going with

1:41:56Justin Timberlake. Yeah like it and it's like it's again it's like one of those it's just

1:42:03a great example of like okay I can see why a smart ass computer that isn't very advanced

1:42:10gave me that answer because like it interpreted who is playing place name as a musical venue

1:42:17question. Even though the Super Bowl halftime show is a very large event, sure,

1:42:24and it is a musical event, but if you say who is playing the Super Bowl that could

1:42:31have multiple meanings and I think the far more common interpretation of that

1:42:38is who is playing the sports game. Because I didn't say who was playing the

1:42:42Super Bowl halftime show. Like the Super Bowl halftime show is the name of the

1:42:45musical venue, the Super Bowl is a sporting event.

1:42:48And so there's like, it should have gotten that right.

1:42:52And again, it just, like your court saying,

1:42:54it just said something totally, to me, bonkers,

1:42:57even though it's not quite as bad as yours,

1:42:59'cause it at least like, you can at least see

1:43:01why it got there.

1:43:02- I feel like the next level of this needs to be

1:43:07a sort of, just, you know, I often say this

1:43:11as like a life lesson, like, honestly,

1:43:14I feel like where I sort of crossed from adolescence

1:43:18into adulthood was when I realized that there's no shame

1:43:22in saying I don't know when you don't know.

1:43:25And so, you know, it was just like a breakthrough in my life

1:43:27where I always was so, you know,

1:43:31worried about how smart I was,

1:43:32or if I didn't know something that it was shameful,

1:43:34I, you know, I should know the answer to everything.

1:43:37And it's like, if you just suddenly relax

1:43:38and realize that if you don't know something,

1:43:40don't waste people's time to say, you know what?

1:43:42I don't, I don't understand either.

1:43:43I don't understand this, can you stop and explain this to me

1:43:46in a way that I understand or if somebody asks you

1:43:49a question and you don't know, just say I don't know.

1:43:51I don't know.

1:43:52I want Siri to gain I don't know.

1:43:56So if you ask that question and she doesn't know,

1:43:59she's pretty sure you're either asking who's playing

1:44:01the halftime show or who's playing the game, just ask.

1:44:04Do you mean the game or the halftime show?

1:44:06Like what a human being would do.

1:44:08- Right, that would have been, yeah.

1:44:11Well a human being would have said the team names

1:44:12playing in the sporting event. But yeah, but even if a human was unsure and thought, you

1:44:17know, like, you know, it, there's an uncertainty to these virtual assistants that I will that

1:44:24that, you know, like a human should a normal human should pick that up. But you know, I

1:44:30could see how some an assistant, especially an AI one that isn't a human could think,

1:44:35Well, I don't think Marco is really all that into sports. So I'm not sure what he's asking

1:44:41about here. Just ask, and you could just say it quickly. Just say, "Do you mean the game

1:44:45or the halftime show?" And you could say, "The game," and then she would tell you who's playing

1:44:50in the game. That would be fine. You would walk away from that interaction without even

1:44:54thinking about that question in the middle, if it happened fast enough, roughly at the

1:44:59speed that it would happen if it was a human being. And computers are so much faster than

1:45:04human beings that there's no reason it shouldn't, even if it has to round trip to the cloud

1:45:09briefly, right? It could still happen at roughly the same speed as human interaction.

1:45:14You know, just think about the little questions you get asked. I've been thinking about this a

1:45:20lot lately, and it's like, we have a little, great little grocery store here in Center City,

1:45:26Philadelphia. It's called the Bruno Brothers, and they, you know, all sorts of great, like, Italian

1:45:33lunch meats and stuff and fresh break bread. So I stopped in and all I did is just get

1:45:38a big long loaf of Italian bread. And it comes in its own little paper sleeve. And I rang

1:45:46out. That's all I needed. And I rang out and the guy was gonna, you know, he was like,

1:45:50do you want to know you want a bag? And I was like, nah, because it's in a bag. But

1:45:53like him asking me, do I want a bag for my bread that's already in a bag? And that's

1:45:58all I've got to carry. Like, I didn't feel interrupted by that. You know, it because

1:46:02it happened at a speed and a pace and there's no reason that our virtual assistant shouldn't

1:46:08be able to interact with us like that. Like I don't expect it all to come out in one fluent

1:46:12query from a human that gives the answer, you know, but just have some back and forth.

1:46:16I love like if you were Siri, you would have asked a bag for what? And he would have said

1:46:24your bread and you would have been like bread is a big food product made from wheat. Right?

1:46:29The fact that she forgot we were talking about units of measure, it almost is like she's got a head injury.

1:46:36Right, yeah.

1:46:38You've hired an assistant, like a human, and it's great.

1:46:43And then, oh my God, terrible news.

1:46:46She's in a car accident, and she's injured her head, and then she comes back.

1:46:50And you ask a question like that, and all of a sudden she starts telling you about Quartz the mineral.

1:46:56know two seconds ago she just asked you a question about what do you want to

1:47:00convert gallons to you would feel terrible but you would think like well

1:47:03I've got a fire right yeah it's like this clearly this person like this is a

1:47:09tragedy but this also means this person probably can't write job you know and

1:47:13and it's like yeah here you don't have the human connection it's just this

1:47:16person can't do this this AI really is not very good at this job all right let

1:47:21me take a break here and thank our next sponsor that's our good friends at ero

1:47:25E-E-R-O. Eero makes Wi-Fi systems for your house and they use what's called a mesh network

1:47:35where you just plug a bunch of them in and you don't have, there's no special magic one

1:47:40that's the base system. You just plug the same little puck size thing which is very

1:47:47nicely designed. You plug them in all around your house depending on how big your house

1:47:51is or what their shape is and there's all sorts of information at their website that

1:47:55they can help you choose how many of them to buy. Well, they've got their second generation

1:47:59product is out. And the second generation product is better as more speed, more range

1:48:07and in same high quality elegant design as the original. And they've got these new ones

1:48:15that are like a little, they call them a beacon. And the beacon, you just plug in like a night

1:48:20light goes right in the socket. There's no cable or anything. You just plug it in a socket

1:48:25somewhere like maybe at the top of some steps, stairway or something like that. And it even

1:48:31has a light because it could be a nightlight. So it has a nightlight. But if you don't want

1:48:36the nightlight, they're wonderful, excellent Euro app that you install on your phone, which

1:48:41is where you control the whole system from. You could just turn off the light or turn

1:48:46it on or put it on schedule or whatever. But anyway, the whole second generation system

1:48:51from Eero adds a third 5 GHz radio and that makes it that's now tri-band and it's now

1:49:00twice as fast as its predecessor. And the first generation Eero is the fastest Wi-Fi

1:49:05system I ever had in my house in my life and it was great, still great. And you can just

1:49:10if you already have first generation, you can add second generation hardware and it

1:49:14just works together. And the app is great. And the app lets you do all sorts of terrific

1:49:19things like do speed tests to make sure see what kind of upstream downstream connection

1:49:23you're getting. It's really it's just a great product. The beacon is half the size of the

1:49:30little of the normal stations that they have. And it really is it's very discreet. It is

1:49:35the sort of thing that doesn't junk up your house or anything like that no one will even

1:49:38notice that you've got it. But what you wind up with is a solid Wi Fi network, a single

1:49:44network mashed together with these multiple hardware units. So it's not like when you're

1:49:49moving from one area to another, your devices are going from one network to another. They

1:49:54just see one network and it really can thoroughly cover a large house or a difficult house with

1:50:01walls or something like that. It's really great. I use it here. You're hearing me right

1:50:06now speak to you over in the Eero network. I really do like this product. And to me,

1:50:12thing that I like is that it's just it could not have been easier to set up. I just plugged

1:50:17them in and told the Eero app what room each one was in and that was it. I've never done

1:50:22any more work than that to configure it. For someone as lazy as me that just wants good

1:50:29Wi-Fi throughout the house, that's really pretty great. What more am I supposed to tell

1:50:37I think I'm supposed to give you a URL and that's a euro.com. But what you got to remember,

1:50:45you got to remember is the code and it's a code that will get you free overnight shipping

1:50:56to the US and Canada. And that code is the talk show, T H E T A L K S H O W. So use that

1:51:06code the talk show talk show with the the which I always pleases me a little bit and

1:51:12you get free overnight shipping in the US or Canada to great product and a good deal

1:51:18get free overnight shipping you're listening to me right now you can have this thing in

1:51:21your house by tomorrow so there you go my thanks to euro.com for sponsoring the show

1:51:26what do you do on the underscore show do you do the ads due to the sponsors or does underscore

1:51:34- I do 'em, it's basically like a smaller version of ATP.

1:51:39- So do you like, is it relaxing

1:51:41to not have to do the sponsors?

1:51:43- Oh, it's glorious.

1:51:46Like what I love about doing this show

1:51:48is I can just walk over to my desk

1:51:50five seconds before we were gonna record

1:51:52and just sit down and just start.

1:51:54And I don't have to have any windows open,

1:51:56I don't have to be like watching like the script

1:51:59or the program or you know, having the list of sponsors out.

1:52:02Like with ATP, at first I started,

1:52:05for years I would do the ads live as we recorded,

1:52:07and that was terrible,

1:52:10because not only would I screw them up a lot

1:52:12and require lots of editing,

1:52:13but the whole show, I was like,

1:52:16I was always like a little bit distracted that,

1:52:20oh, I had this ad I have to fit in sometime,

1:52:22like I have to like wait for a time and then jump on it

1:52:24and just start doing it,

1:52:26and it was always distracting me

1:52:27from listening to the conversation

1:52:29or really being more in-depth about my own conversations.

1:52:34And so I started about, I don't know, six months ago

1:52:37or a year ago, I started basically pre-recording them,

1:52:40but I want it to sound like I'm doing them live.

1:52:43So I record them like a half hour before I record the show.

1:52:47So it's like my same setup,

1:52:48like it's the same night I'm recording,

1:52:50my voice sounds the same, the room is the same.

1:52:52So it's still kind of like a mad rush

1:52:56to get everything done before each show,

1:52:59But now I at least like during the show,

1:53:00I don't have to worry about it so much.

1:53:02So during the show, like I can be more present

1:53:04in the conversation and not be constantly looking

1:53:07at the sponsor list and trying to figure out

1:53:09like when I can do each one.

1:53:10The downside is that it allows me to be

1:53:13a little bit more of a perfectionist.

1:53:15So a lot of times I have to do an ad read

1:53:17like five times before I actually get it right.

1:53:19- That's the same with me.

1:53:2090% of the ad reads I do on the talk show,

1:53:23I just do live during recording

1:53:25like I did right there with Eero.

1:53:28probably more than 90%, but then every once in a while,

1:53:30something happens, either I botch it

1:53:32or something happens in between recording

1:53:35and doing the show, or I go to record

1:53:38and there's a sponsor who's set to go,

1:53:40but they still haven't given us the thing

1:53:43and I have to do that the next day.

1:53:45And when I do that, I almost never ever redo a read

1:53:50when I do it live during the recording like this.

1:53:52And every single time I do it independently by myself,

1:53:56I botch it.

1:53:58I can't, there is something,

1:54:00I've developed some kind of mental muscle

1:54:03where I no longer feel weird or awkward

1:54:11talking to somebody like you doing the show.

1:54:14Like I'm very comfortable right now

1:54:17having this conversation with you,

1:54:18even knowing that we're recording it

1:54:20and tens of thousands of people

1:54:22will soon be listening to it,

1:54:25which originally I always felt very self-conscious about,

1:54:28but I've developed a comfort.

1:54:30But when I'm here just talking into the microphone

1:54:34and nobody's listening to me, I feel incredibly awkward.

1:54:37I don't know if you took notice that one of the reads

1:54:43last week I had to redo, Paul Kaphasis was the guest,

1:54:48and I had to do one of the reads the next day.

1:54:53I don't know if you noticed. I forgot. Honestly, I usually skip ads. I thought it was a good

1:55:01one. What was it? It was the Casper one because Casper had, you know this too because I think

1:55:11they were on ATP. Yeah, the President's Day sale. And it was sort of like, they were like,

1:55:20If your show airs on these dates in February, we want you to do the President's Day sale.

1:55:25And the show is going to come out the day before, but at night.

1:55:29And so we had the same issue.

1:55:31And we actually went ahead, Jesse, like, go check with them.

1:55:34Like, can we do it?

1:55:35Like, what should we do the day before this day was going to come out at like, like 1030

1:55:39at night the day before.

1:55:43And they were like, we'd rather have the President's Day sale.

1:55:45So I was like, I can do that.

1:55:47I can do it the next day.

1:55:48But I also had, I don't know if it sounded weird to people, if any, you know, backstory,

1:55:52if you thought that the Casper's President's Day sale sounded weird last week, it was because

1:55:58when I recorded with Paul, my voice was still really hoarse from having been out in Las

1:56:03Vegas for the Super Bowl.

1:56:05And I always come back from Vegas with a hoarse voice because it's dry and people smoke cigarettes.

1:56:10And I'm not used to either, I'm not used to desert air and I'm not used to breathing cigarette

1:56:14combined with the fact that in while watching the Super Bowl it's a really

1:56:19noisy big cavernous room and to say anything you have to yell so when I

1:56:24recorded I think on Wednesday with Paul my voice was still a mess and by

1:56:27Thursday it was already sounding better but I was as I'm recording the ad I'm

1:56:31like I should I should like scream a little or something to horse it up my

1:56:35voice to get it back to where it was anyway yeah this is why like whenever

1:56:41you record I do it the same night like right right before the show because

1:56:44because otherwise it sounds different.

1:56:46And I think most people really don't care, but I care.

1:56:50Like when I'm doing it, I care that I want this to sound

1:56:54totally seamless.

1:56:55- Speaking of ad skipping, one of the recent things

1:56:59that have come out in the world of podcasting

1:57:00is Apple's long-awaited analytics have come out.

1:57:04And so if you have a podcast in the iTunes store

1:57:08and you've signed up for their,

1:57:10I guess I don't think you can get listed

1:57:12which are not in Podcast Connect, right?

1:57:14Like they don't just list podcasts.

1:57:17- Yeah, you have to sign up.

1:57:18I think the only question is like,

1:57:20you know, if you signed up a while ago

1:57:22and you forgot what email you used,

1:57:24like you might have to like basically like claim it

1:57:26from them or register in a certain way with them.

1:57:28I forget how, I did it a while ago,

1:57:29so I forgot how to do this,

1:57:30but like I was already registered in some way.

1:57:33- Well, I have a cheat move 'cause I know,

1:57:35I know some people on the podcast team there.

1:57:37- Yeah, that's totally BS.

1:57:38- But I do think though that,

1:57:40Everybody, I think that's why they have the one special iTunes tag for the RSS feed

1:57:46with an email address. That if you can email from the address that's in your RSS feed,

1:57:51they trust it. And that makes a certain amount of sense that, you know, if somebody has right

1:57:58access to your RSS feed for your podcast, you're screwed already.

1:58:02You know.

1:58:03Yeah, yeah. The game's over at that point.

1:58:07But anyway, they came out with these analytics and what the advertising industry wants is,

1:58:14of course, their JavaScript to be running all the time, turning on your camera to look

1:58:22at you while you listen to podcasts.

1:58:24The most intrusive thing you can possibly imagine, like all of standard web advertising

1:58:29technology has fallen into where your fucking battery goes dead because of ads on web pages

1:58:35now.

1:58:36Of course that's what they want and of course Apple wasn't willing to give them anything

1:58:41close to that, but they do have some basic listening stats.

1:58:46And I was super happy but totally not surprised that the graph of every episode of my show

1:58:53looks pretty much the same, which is that most people listen to the end, there's some

1:59:02drop off, but that, you know, and I think some of that could correspond to people who

1:59:05started listening to it and then listen somewhere else and it's not connected there. And you

1:59:11can see in each episode, three dips where the sponsor reads go, and those dips are surprisingly

1:59:19shallow. So yes, there are people who skip ads, but it is a definite minority of listeners.

1:59:28And I, you know, I've said before, I often say it when you're on because we get into

1:59:31shop talk about running a podcast. But I just see my job doing these ads as trying to make

1:59:37them as interesting as possible, both for everybody's benefit, for the sponsor's benefit.

1:59:43Even if you've heard me talk about ERO before or Squarespace, what can I say that maybe

1:59:47would throw a monkey wrench in there and make you want to listen for another minute? And

1:59:54if you want to skip, skip. I'm not going to try to fight you. It's my job to make it interesting.

2:00:01We found pretty similar patterns when we looked at ATP stats in the same thing, which probably

2:00:08makes sense because we probably have a lot of the same audience, where it turns out most

2:00:12people listen to most shows all the way through and there's a small dip at the ad breaks that

2:00:18you can see, but it's on the order of maybe 15% fewer people listen to the ad breaks.

2:00:24It's not a huge jump down.

2:00:26You can also see where they're using a 30-second skip.

2:00:29it starts to come back in the second half of the ad read.

2:00:32It does.

2:00:33- Right, exactly, yeah.

2:00:34- So I appreciate that.

2:00:37I've always wanted to know, but I'm not surprised.

2:00:41I often get emails from people when I mention it,

2:00:42and people are so nice,

2:00:44and I think it's because they realize that me,

2:00:48and I'm sure it's true for you guys too,

2:00:52I'm sure it's true for everybody at Relay,

2:00:55all the people who have shows there,

2:00:59But people realize that we're all very low to the ground here.

2:01:04There's no employees at Daring Fireball.

2:01:06There's no-- Six Colors doesn't have a sales department.

2:01:09There's not much-- there's really

2:01:14nothing between us and our readers and listeners.

2:01:19And I often get email that takes that into consideration.

2:01:23And they want us to succeed.

2:01:25And the gist of these emails often are, hey,

2:01:28I'm a long time listener of your show.

2:01:30I love it, I love every episode that comes out.

2:01:33I feel guilty though 'cause here's my personal,

2:01:37and it's so funny how many people repeat the same thing.

2:01:39They're like, I will listen to every sponsor

2:01:41for the first time and sometimes a second time,

2:01:43but then after that, I'll skip.

2:01:45And I'm like, that's great.

2:01:47And they're like, I write back,

2:01:48you don't need to apologize, that's fantastic.

2:01:51- Yeah, I'm happy with that.

2:01:54I mean, when I started doing chapters in ATP,

2:01:58question obviously becomes like you know how do you chapter ads like you know

2:02:01some people don't put chapters in the ads so you so it's harder to skip them

2:02:05if you want to. I decided I basically worked through a bunch of things and

2:02:10decided what I do is I put a chapter at the start of the ad when the ad is

2:02:17playing it shows it says sponsor colon name of sponsor and it links to the

2:02:20sponsor URL so it's actually kind of better if you're you know if you're

2:02:24interested in the product you get a link right there in the chapter title so like

2:02:27it's showing right on screen.

2:02:28You don't have to like go over to the show notes,

2:02:30scroll down to the bottom and find it like it's right there.

2:02:32So it's super easy.

2:02:34If you want to look at the sponsor, the link is right there.

2:02:36So I think sponsors are getting some additional value there.

2:02:39And then you can skip that chapter,

2:02:42but where that chapter ends is not at the end

2:02:46of the sponsor read, but like 10 seconds

2:02:48before the end of the sponsor read.

2:02:50And so if you skip the sponsor read,

2:02:53what you hear is the very end summary

2:02:56where it says, "For a great mattress, go to this URL

2:02:58"and use this promo code."

2:03:00That's what you hear.

2:03:02And so you're basically hearing a 10 second version

2:03:05of the ad or so.

2:03:07And that is what I found to be a very good compromise,

2:03:11where if you've heard the ad a million times,

2:03:13you already know what this company does.

2:03:15You hit skip, you get reminded of the URL

2:03:18and the promo code, and you move on.

2:03:22I've heard from both listeners and from advertisers

2:03:26that that seems to be a very good balance.

2:03:29- I wrote to Caleb Sexton who,

2:03:32after you posted that you did that,

2:03:34and he edits this show, and I said,

2:03:36"Hey, that's pretty clever, maybe we could do that."

2:03:38And he was like, "I've been trying to do that all along."

2:03:40And I was like, "Oh, I'll try to do a better job

2:03:42"of doing a good summary at the end of this spot, thanks."

2:03:46Or by all along he means ever since he's been using forecast

2:03:50or whatever the--

2:03:51- Yeah, right, yeah, yeah, forecast, yeah.

2:03:54Yeah, 'cause it, and you do have to like kind of,

2:03:56you know, structure your reads, like to,

2:03:58what I basically say is like,

2:04:00we're brought to you this week by so and so,

2:04:01here's the URL and the promo code,

2:04:03and then big long explanation for two minutes,

2:04:05and then here's, once again, go to this URL, promo code,

2:04:09thanks again, thanks to sponsor, you know,

2:04:10like so you have to structure it in a way where

2:04:12if you cut out the whole middle of it,

2:04:14it still makes some sense.

2:04:16- So when you guys record ATP, you guys,

2:04:18you sit there and you've got a soundboard thing,

2:04:21And so when like when Syracuse had mentioned file systems

2:04:25and you play the ding, that's live when you're recording.

2:04:27Like you don't do that in post.

2:04:29- No, it's a bell.

2:04:30I got, it's an actual bell.

2:04:32- So it's not even a soundboard app.

2:04:34You actually-- - I have a bell on my desk.

2:04:35- Keep a bell and you do that.

2:04:37What about--

2:04:39- Yeah, the only time I've ever used a soundboard app

2:04:41is when we did our live show last year.

2:04:43I had a soundboard app running

2:04:44so I could play like our ad transition music

2:04:47and the outro music and the theme song.

2:04:50That's the only reason I've ever used one.

2:04:52But when we record live, I have a bell on my desk

2:04:54and I bring it out and the first time

2:04:56he mentions file systems, I hit that bell

2:04:58and I put a bell away.

2:04:59- What about the car door for car talk?

2:05:01- I put that in during editing.

2:05:03- Ah, so that is in post.

2:05:04I thought that might have been live, I wasn't sure.

2:05:07- Although, that is actually my car door

2:05:09from the BMW I had like five years ago.

2:05:13I actually went out one night and recorded those sounds.

2:05:15So that was actually my car.

2:05:17- Speaking of cars, I wanna say,

2:05:19and while we're talking about ATP,

2:05:20before we get back to the max stuff,

2:05:21I wanna thank you guys for turning me on to the Grand Tour.

2:05:26I never watched Top Gear, and I'm not really a car person,

2:05:31but I've heard what--

2:05:32- Did we turn you on?

2:05:32I think we've hated the Grand Tour.

2:05:33- I know, but I know.

2:05:34- Did we actually turn you on?

2:05:35- Well, in a way, but you guys seemed to like

2:05:38Top Gear enough, and this Grand Tour thing

2:05:40was intriguing to me enough.

2:05:42And Jonas and I started watching it together,

2:05:46and we both love it.

2:05:47absolutely we watch season 2 first and just tore through it and

2:05:52We don't have Jonas and I don't have a lot of shows that we both like

2:05:57And and a lot of the ones we do are ones like Saturday night live that we watch with Amy -

2:06:04And I mean, it's not like I'm looking for shows that only Jonas and I watch but it's you know

2:06:09It's like a nice thing and like when he was growing up

2:06:11We loved the Star Wars the Clone Wars animated series and and the rebels thing

2:06:17But he's not into sports at all and a lot of what I watched during the day or like when he's still awake is sports

2:06:24And we both love the grand tour

2:06:27And and the thing I don't get though is you guys all seem to like when you watch it you like skip around like what?

2:06:33What are the parts that you skip past you just watch the parts when they're like actually reviewing cars

2:06:38Usually I will skip past any parts that have them in the studio. I love I love the parts. Oh yeah

2:06:46- Yeah.

2:06:47- A lot of them get pretty cringe word.

2:06:50Like not all of them, but yeah, a lot of them do.

2:06:52- It is.

2:06:53- And like back when it was Top Gear,

2:06:55I used to skip through a lot of that stuff

2:06:57because I would skip through the celebrity part

2:07:00because it would bring on usually like a British celebrity

2:07:03who I didn't know.

2:07:04And so I would skip it,

2:07:05I was like, well, I don't even know this person.

2:07:06I have no interest in this.

2:07:07And I skipped that section and just jump in

2:07:09to whatever they did next.

2:07:11The problem with the grand tour of the US,

2:07:14new US show is that they just I think need a lot more editing than what they

2:07:18are guys see I and a lot of the jokes and stuff that they do in the indoor

2:07:23segments I think are pretty I really disagree and Jonas likes it too we

2:07:28watch the whole thing straight through and it's I'm not gonna say every bit

2:07:32works but I think that they actually do a pretty good job of not letting any

2:07:37segment run too long and like when they do the thing that's most like a podcast

2:07:42the conversation street, it's always too short. It's like I would listen to those guys talk

2:07:47about cars for three times as long per episode. So I feel like they do a really good job of

2:07:52sort of leaving you wanting more. We love the show, we really do. And now we're like

2:07:57halfway through season one. And I give credit to you guys.

2:08:02I'm glad you enjoy it. Somebody has to.

2:08:04I think you should give it another shot when new episodes come out. I think you should

2:08:08just try just you know crack open an IPA or something just to take the edge off

2:08:12and then just just watch the whole show straight through I'm telling you it

2:08:15there's there there's something going on I don't know I I'm I really can't

2:08:20believe I never watched these guys before I really like it and I'm not even

2:08:23all that into cars well I'm glad you all right there was a thing last week and

2:08:33And actually the original scoop, it wasn't "Gurman,"

2:08:36it was actually, you know,

2:08:40Fried at Axios actually had the first story.

2:08:43I'm really digging Axios, by the way.

2:08:47I don't know if you read news on Axios,

2:08:48but Axios is this newish site that launched like last year.

2:08:53And they just, like the whole style of Axios,

2:08:57whether it's tech or politics or anything else they cover,

2:09:00is sort of breaking everything down

2:09:02into just like bullet points,

2:09:04which isn't how I'd wanna read everything,

2:09:07but it's really kind of efficient.

2:09:10And it's like, I either wanna read something

2:09:13that's truly a well-written article by a good writer,

2:09:16and you could really dig into it like a piece of steak,

2:09:20or I just want like the snack size tidbits.

2:09:23And I feel like so much of the news industry

2:09:26has sort of grown up around this idea

2:09:29You know if you've got three sentences to say you've still got to dress it up in 750 words

2:09:34History and whatever just to make it article length

2:09:38But anyway, you know had this story first before german that there was some kind of meeting

2:09:45Craig Federighi held

2:09:48To give a revised plan to employees

2:09:50and

2:09:52And mentioned some features that were originally going to be set for iOS this year that got that are being pushed a year back

2:09:59including a refresh of the home screen and the CarPlay interface and some other things,

2:10:08but that there are new features, but that they're somehow doing something to focus on quality and

2:10:14performance a little bit more than before and giving certain projects more time to go.

2:10:20And then Germin, I think, had the story the same later in the same day, and I don't know

2:10:25if it was pressured because Ina had it first or if it was going to run anyway. But his

2:10:32story took more of an angle indicating that this is sort of a radical departure and that

2:10:38people who heard it were surprised by this, that this is a big change. And my take on

2:10:46it is that it's not a big change. It's like a course correction. And then there was a

2:10:51a good thread on Twitter by Steven Sinofsky who was you know used to head up

2:10:55the Windows division at Apple or Microsoft not Apple who sort of was

2:10:59making the same case that this sort of three-way three-headed thing of schedule

2:11:05quality and new features is always you know a balancing act I'm curious what

2:11:13you what do you think about this it's hard for me to really have a

2:11:20reasonable or useful opinion on the internal mechanics

2:11:25of how big companies balance this stuff,

2:11:27because I've never worked in a big company.

2:11:29So I really am not familiar with that kind of thing at all.

2:11:33All I can do is comment on what I see from the outside

2:11:36and what I experience with the products.

2:11:38Any way that I develop my stuff

2:11:42or that I prioritize quality and time and everything else

2:11:45is not at all the same way that a company like Apple

2:11:47would do pretty much anything.

2:11:48So what I can see is, I think it's clear that in recent years, Apple has struggled with quality,

2:11:57and they have been seemingly torn between a lot of competing desires of, you know, moving fast versus

2:12:05getting good quality stuff out there versus bug fixes versus expansion.

2:12:09And these aren't easy problems to solve, and they've been doing overall a pretty decent job of most of it.

2:12:17most of it. Like it's, the reason we're able to complain about minor problems here and

2:12:23there is because almost everything is great and almost everything has been working well

2:12:29for a long time and so you know the small stuff sticks out more. All I can see is that

2:12:40platforms and products that I like a lot, that I depend on a lot or that I feel like

2:12:45need attention, oftentimes don't get the attention.

2:12:50It seems like Apple has always been pretty bad at multitasking.

2:12:54And this isn't a Tim thing, this goes back

2:12:59to the Steve era too.

2:13:01Apple has been pretty bad at really well maintaining

2:13:03multiple platforms and many products.

2:13:09They do seem to have tunnel vision at times,

2:13:11where certain things will get the focus

2:13:11and everything else gets neglected pretty badly for a while.

2:13:15And then eventually it'll come around

2:13:18and the things that got neglected for a while

2:13:19will get a big burst of investment

2:13:21and then nothing for a few years or more.

2:13:23And again, they had this problem under Steve.

2:13:26- And it almost seems like that's happening again

2:13:28with the iPad, where last year iPad,

2:13:30for years people have been clamoring,

2:13:31well look, this thing is supposed to be

2:13:32a laptop replacement and it still has

2:13:34all the same multitasking features of a phone.

2:13:41of a 13 inch screen on my iPad Pro,

2:13:43why can't I put two apps up side by side, et cetera.

2:13:46And they finally addressed it, but now it seems like,

2:13:48according to these rumors, that big new, you know,

2:13:52major features like that for iPad

2:13:54are punted for next year again already.

2:13:56- Yeah, and it's hard to draw comparisons

2:14:01for like the way things used to be.

2:14:02Like, you know, people always say, well, you know,

2:14:04when the iPhone came out, like then,

2:14:06whatever version of Mac OS was that year,

2:14:08I forget, like it was delayed.

2:14:10And they famously said it took them too much effort

2:14:13on the iOS, anyway.

2:14:15It's really not that useful to make comparisons

2:14:18to how it was back then because Apple today

2:14:21is just vastly bigger and the competitive landscape

2:14:24is vastly different.

2:14:26It's such a different beast and such a different problem

2:14:29today that you can't just apply blanket wisdom

2:14:33or examples from the past.

2:14:35But it does seem like they still don't multitask very well.

2:14:40very well, like if they're all there growth

2:14:42and all the new product lines they've launched

2:14:44and everything, they still have that fundamental problem.

2:14:47And I don't know, some analysts like to talk about

2:14:50the corporate structure of Apple being

2:14:54functional rather than divisional or something like that.

2:14:56That's it, right?

2:14:56- Yeah.

2:14:57- Whatever that is.

2:14:59And I don't know, maybe that's holding them back

2:15:01in this area, I don't know.

2:15:03But whatever the cause and whatever possible solutions exist

2:15:07The problem to me is the same problem they've had

2:15:12for a very long time, which is they just don't multitask

2:15:15very well.

2:15:18But today they have more platforms and products than ever

2:15:20that they're trying to maintain.

2:15:24And so even if, you know, back 10 years ago,

2:15:27maybe they could only really maintain like one or two things.

2:15:30Well now, maybe they can maintain 10 things,

2:15:33but they have 12.

2:15:32You know, like it's something like that.

2:15:34Like even if they've gotten better at it,

2:15:37they're still not able to do it well enough

2:15:40at the scale they're at today.

2:15:42And so you have things like, you know,

2:15:43things being neglected for a long time.

2:15:45You have like, I think one of the biggest,

2:15:48you know, for a while you were right,

2:15:49for a while the iPad was one of these things

2:15:51where it just seemed like iPad,

2:15:54the iPad OS was getting very little attention

2:15:56to Frankel for years.

2:15:58Fortunately, that seems to have turned around.

2:16:01Today I would say one of the big dangers of that is the Mac.

2:16:06I don't think I'm gonna make a lot of argument about that.

2:16:07The Mac has had not seemingly a ton of software investment

2:16:12in recent years, and it's really starting to have

2:16:17some pretty big problems.

2:16:18But again, I say this on a Mac, it's working.

2:16:21Everything's relative, I guess, but it seems like

2:16:27almost every week there's some kind of embarrassing

2:16:30quality or security flaw in Mac OS.

2:16:33And so like, obviously this is not getting

2:16:36the type of attention it deserves,

2:16:37or the time for bug fixing or quality assurance

2:16:41that it needs.

2:16:43So I think this is a problem that Apple can fix.

2:16:47Like, they have a massive amount of resources

2:16:51at their disposal.

2:16:52I think, you know, you can't just throw money

2:16:55at something and make it go away, it isn't that easy.

2:16:57but it's also really hard to argue

2:17:00that Apple can't do something

2:17:02because they don't have enough of something.

2:17:04That is really a tough argument

2:17:06because they have all the resources in the world.

2:17:10For example, if they can't hire enough engineers,

2:17:15well, fix that problem.

2:17:17Find ways to hire more engineers.

2:17:19More engineers exist, they work at lots of other places,

2:17:22why not Apple?

2:17:23And so maybe there's changes to policies or cultures

2:17:28or geographies that they need to make.

2:17:31I don't know, I don't know what the problem is,

2:17:32but these are problems that are within

2:17:35their control to solve.

2:17:36And so that ultimately what we need is a company

2:17:38that is able to maintain the many products

2:17:43and platforms and services that they keep launching,

2:17:48they keep expanding into.

2:17:50To me, it's not good if they just keep launching

2:17:54new platforms and new services and stuff

2:17:56and then just leave them to die

2:17:58while they work on the next big thing.

2:17:59That's not long-term gonna be healthy.

2:18:01- Yeah, it's a hard argument to,

2:18:06it's inherently mushy to say that it comes down

2:18:11to three things, schedule, features, quality.

2:18:13That's arbitrary to say those are the three things,

2:18:18But it's not a bad way to break it up.

2:18:22It's like the old analogy that you can have,

2:18:24what, good, soon, or cheap, pick two.

2:18:30The real thing is you can pick one,

2:18:32that they're all at odds with each other.

2:18:34But I do think that they've gone off the rails

2:18:39in recent years a little bit.

2:18:42And again, it's a course correction more than turning,

2:18:46Apple, especially the iPhone, you know, it's just this massive, massive ship analogy-wise.

2:18:52Just, you know, the biggest cruise ship you could imagine. And it's not like they need

2:18:57to turn this thing 90 degrees and go in a totally different direction and break all

2:19:01of this massive momentum they have. They need like a minor course correction, in my opinion.

2:19:05But in the long term, just a handful of years, if you're off by just a few degrees, you can

2:19:13wind up, you know, hundreds of miles away from where you should be. You know, it's

2:19:17important to make course corrections because even a minor course correction

2:19:21over time can get you way off track. And I feel like where Apple has gone wrong

2:19:27in recent years is emphasizing new features over improving

2:19:35existing features. It is the single biggest thing, and I think that's true

2:19:39across all their platforms. And I really, I just think that there's like, the Mac to

2:19:45me is the one that means the most to me personally. It's the one I love the most. If I could only

2:19:49use one Apple platform, I swear to God, I would give up my iPhone before I gave up using

2:19:53a Mac. That's how much I wouldn't even hesitate. If I had gone to my head, I wouldn't even

2:19:58really be a tough decision. And I might bitch about it every day for the rest of my life

2:20:03as I use a Google Pixel, but it's just too important to my work. If anything, maybe having

2:20:10a phone I like less would be better for my attention or something like that.

2:20:14And I worry the most about the Mac because I see weird things happening with the Mac

2:20:22that to me are worrisome because to me, as somebody who to me gets the Mac and what makes

2:20:29the Mac the Mac in a way that I even as a writer have trouble expressing

2:20:33sometimes because it's it's like trying to explain why I love my wife you know

2:20:38it's like I can give you reasons but there's also something ineffable about

2:20:43it that I can't explain and I see weird things happen on the Mac that to me are

2:20:48like this is weird and I'll just give you one minor example it's like I forget

2:20:52like two or three years ago when they added tab documents to to cocoa yeah

2:20:58Yeah, like I get it. I use tabs in Safari. I do I use tabs and terminal too

2:21:03and then they added it to like NS document and like any NS document based app could have tabs and

2:21:10It was all just so it it

2:21:14weird because it wasn't designed the system the UI wasn't designed from the get-go to have tab windows and

2:21:22Browsers kind of pulled it off because browsers have always sort of been a weird little world within a world where you can run apps

2:21:29within a browser, you know and

2:21:31Terminal is terminal and terminal is not really a normal app, but then to do it document wide and

2:21:38It's like well what keyboard shortcut are you gonna use because all these other apps that have tabs have command T

2:21:43For making a new tab, but all NS document apps have used command T since like 1988 with next step for opening the font panel

2:21:52And I thought well, there's a lot of things that they're gonna

2:21:55I can't wait to see how they clarify all these things and they they didn't really do anything

2:21:59And to me I know there's people who love spaces, but I really cannot get into spaces and to me

2:22:07It's just confusing and I often feel like where the hell am I and I get the idea of having multiple

2:22:12Doc, you know multiple desktops that you can go between and maybe divide your work up between them

2:22:19I get the idea but to me the fact that the system wasn't designed originally with spaces in mind and to me

2:22:26They never really they never really clarified it and unified it into a hole and there's just a whole bunch of little things like that

2:22:33so to me wanting Apple to add new features to Mac OS is

2:22:37The wrong way to look at it

2:22:41I almost feel like I feel like the desktop the idea of desktop computing in a window, you know mouse pointer and a

2:22:48Windowing system and the max style of having the menu bar at the top. They've got that down that doesn't really need to be rethought

2:22:55It's this is what it is and it'll have the future that it has and it's good for what it's good at and better

2:23:00Than anything else for what it's better at

2:23:03I feel just make those features work better. I feel like adding, you know, here's the thing that's all new it just

2:23:10messes it up

2:23:13Yeah, and to me like I I

2:23:17I disagree somewhat with the concept that,

2:23:19I know this is not what you just said,

2:23:20but a lot of people think of this in a similar way,

2:23:23where people think like desktop OSes

2:23:26are kind of just a solved problem,

2:23:27that they're just done,

2:23:29and there's really nowhere to go with them,

2:23:30and I fundamentally disagree with that.

2:23:32Like, there's so much improvement that Mac OS could have,

2:23:36and there's lots of different areas.

2:23:37You know, just as a quick example, like app installation,

2:23:41like the whole thing with like,

2:23:42well you download a DMG,

2:23:44and then you open up this virtual disk image

2:23:48and you drag this, like that's crazy

2:23:50and incredibly confusing to anybody

2:23:52and that's no wonder that's a problem.

2:23:54Also the fact that apps can just write all over the system

2:23:57with temp files and other garbage that goes all over

2:23:59like library and everything, that's kind of weird.

2:24:03And that when you delete an app,

2:24:04all of its crap isn't deleted.

2:24:06There's a lot of things that we learned from iOS

2:24:07that I think would be nice to be brought to the Mac

2:24:10for things like the ease of software installation

2:24:13deleting things and everything. The Mac App Store kind of went halfway with that,

2:24:17but it has been done so poorly and so half-assedly for its entire lifetime

2:24:24that it really doesn't do a great service to these concepts at all and

2:24:29might even be doing more harm than good to some of these concepts and to the

2:24:32advancement of the platform. But so to me like there's a lot of ways that

2:24:36the Mac can move forward and needs to move forward. From simple things like

2:24:42features like for instance I still very firmly believe that we need cellular

2:24:47Macs. We need cellular Mac laptops and the system has the concept of

2:24:53distinguishing a network connection request between cellular between like it

2:24:58should run over cellular and this shouldn't run over cellular. It's been

2:25:01there since iOS got it like three four years ago at least. So like there is a

2:25:05framework there for apps to like control their data usage. There's also third-party

2:25:09like trip mode that allow the user to control this.

2:25:13So like the software support is either there or easy to add,

2:25:18so they need to add cellular Macs.

2:25:20I don't know why they still don't have them.

2:25:21The PC industry's had them for 10 years.

2:25:23- That's the sort of problem

2:25:24that I always look to Apple to solve, right?

2:25:26It is a problem that if you have a cellular Mac,

2:25:29you wouldn't want it to behave the same way it would

2:25:32when it's on unfettered WiFi.

2:25:34And I can vouch for this,

2:25:37having been on a cruise ship where you pay for the Wi-Fi

2:25:42by very expensive one gigabyte doses,

2:25:46where I quickly learned that even with trying my best to,

2:25:51the last time I did this,

2:25:52I knew that Jason Snell had recommended an app

2:25:55and it ends up it was the trip mode,

2:25:58but I didn't have it yet.

2:25:59So even just getting it was hard

2:26:01because it was on this terrible cruise ship Wi-Fi.

2:26:04But literally just opening my Mac

2:26:06and like having a Safari that didn't have any tabs open

2:26:09in the background and don't open mail,

2:26:12and it's like, it didn't matter what I did,

2:26:13I'd mow through a gigabyte in like 10 minutes,

2:26:16and it'd be like, what the hell just happened?

2:26:17I don't even understand what the hell just happened there.

2:26:20I've looked at Apple to solve that,

2:26:22like, and I hate to say it to the Trip Mode people,

2:26:24but what I would look for Apple to do

2:26:27if they came out with cellular Macs

2:26:28is coincide with an OS feature that puts,

2:26:32you know, that puts Trip Mode out of business

2:26:34by making, just giving you explicit control

2:26:38over what can do what over cellular

2:26:41and treating it very differently.

2:26:42It's totally a solvable problem.

2:26:43- Just like we have on iOS.

2:26:45Like iOS solved this problem years ago with settings.

2:26:48- Well, iOS solves it in a different way though,

2:26:51where iOS has a very different concept

2:26:53of what an app can do in the background,

2:26:55meaning it's not the front most has input focus.

2:26:58Like the Mac would have to solve it in a different way.

2:27:00But it's totally solvable.

2:27:02But iOS has a settings panel called cellular,

2:27:05and you can go in there and you can see

2:27:06how much data each app is using, you can turn them off.

2:27:08And you can say, well this app is okay over Wi-Fi,

2:27:11but don't use cellular for this app.

2:27:12- Well I would imagine that in my mind,

2:27:14and I could be wrong, you always have to try it

2:27:16and see if it's good, but my mind,

2:27:18if they came out with cellular Macs,

2:27:20my mind, in my mind it would be something

2:27:22more active, interactive, where like,

2:27:25you turn on cellular and as soon as an app

2:27:27tries to hit the network the first time,

2:27:29you'd get some kind of alert like, "Hey, Tweetbot is trying to use the internet over

2:27:36cellular. Do you want to allow this?" And have an option where it's only allowed to

2:27:41do it when it's front most. I don't know.

2:27:44That's interesting. Almost like Little Snitch telling you, "Hey, this app is trying to do

2:27:48this."

2:27:49Yeah, exactly. Little Snitch is actually what I have in mind, where some kind of thing like

2:27:53that. And then once I say for the first time, "Oh yeah, Tweetbot, I always have that running,

2:27:58But yeah, you know what, that would actually be fine on cellular if it only could use the

2:28:02internet while it's the front most application.

2:28:04That's fine.

2:28:07And mail.

2:28:08And just say, "Hey, when you're on cellular, do you want to turn off everything except

2:28:11just downloading the text of mail?"

2:28:13You don't want to...

2:28:14And the iOS is very smart about this, where it won't download images in email and stuff

2:28:19like that.

2:28:20It's solely solvable.

2:28:21What do you call it?

2:28:22It's a Microsoft.

2:28:23You guys talked about an ATP.

2:28:24Microsoft has cellular Surface laptops and they're--

2:28:29- Oh yeah, there's been cellular PC laptops

2:28:32literally for over a decade.

2:28:33Like this is not a rare thing.

2:28:35I'm not asking for something that we don't know

2:28:37whether it's possible or not.

2:28:38No, we know it's possible.

2:28:39The rest of the industry does it.

2:28:40People buy it and it's fine.

2:28:42So yeah.

2:28:43And what worries me ultimately with the Mac is like,

2:28:47it's hard to see a lot of those big features like that

2:28:50getting done and/or getting done well.

2:28:55Because what seems to be Mac involvement,

2:28:57or Mac investment in recent years,

2:29:00is a lot of stuff just never comes to the Mac.

2:29:03Stuff that is introduced on iOS

2:29:05that becomes fairly standard

2:29:08that you kind of want everywhere.

2:29:09Things like iMessage effects.

2:29:11- And stickers.

2:29:12- Where you can do them, yeah, you can do it on iOS,

2:29:15you can't do it on the Mac,

2:29:16and there's kind of no clear path

2:29:17of how they would even do that on the Mac

2:29:18in the current environment.

2:29:20- I'll tell you which one gets me.

2:29:22I love the tap back feature on iOS messages

2:29:26where like somebody sends you an iMessage

2:29:29and you can just press on the thing and give it a thumbs up.

2:29:32I love it.

2:29:33It's such a great way to communicate.

2:29:35Instead of sending them an entire message

2:29:37to just say, okay, good or whatever,

2:29:39just put a thumbs up on their last message.

2:29:41And on the Mac, you can do it,

2:29:44but you've gotta like first bring up the contextual menu

2:29:47and then tap back and then you get the tap back options.

2:29:51Why aren't those thumbs and hearts,

2:29:54why aren't they right there in the contextual menu?

2:29:56There should just be a row of them.

2:29:57- That's a good question.

2:29:58You can also long click on it,

2:30:01like as if you were doing a long press on iOS,

2:30:03and that brings up tap back immediately,

2:30:05but it's still almost funky.

2:30:06- Yeah, but who the hell wants to do a long press?

2:30:08That sucks.

2:30:10- Yeah, and long click on Mac isn't a thing.

2:30:13That's not a thing anybody wants to try,

2:30:14'cause that's not a gesture in the system.

2:30:16Anyways, so my point is for features like cellular Macs

2:30:21or other major platform changes,

2:30:25it's hard to see that happening

2:30:27because it seems like the Mac

2:30:29doesn't get a lot of those anymore.

2:30:31You can look at recent things and you say,

2:30:33oh, well the Mac got APFS, the new file system,

2:30:35that's a big job.

2:30:36But the main reason APFS existed

2:30:38is probably for iOS devices.

2:30:40That was something that wasn't just investing in the Mac,

2:30:42that was investing in all of their software platforms,

2:30:45including the big ones that get off the headlines

2:30:47and make most of the money.

2:30:48So it's hard to say that was like a Mac thing.

2:30:51- In the hypothetical world where,

2:30:53just bear with me for a second,

2:30:57but if Intel-based computers had to use different SSDs

2:31:02at a technical level than ARM devices,

2:31:07like let's just say that in this hypothetical world,

2:31:10SSDs are built into the CPU.

2:31:13And there's a fundamental difference in the way

2:31:15Intel does it from the way ARM ones do it. Would APFS have been written to

2:31:18support both? I think that's a really... Right, it's like I want to say

2:31:24yes that they would have abstracted away because HFS+ really was long in the

2:31:29tooth. You know, you could play your little ding there, you only do once a

2:31:33show. But my heart is telling me, yeah, I don't think that... I think

2:31:40- Max would have been on HFS Plus forever.

2:31:44Like it's a fact that they use fundamentally the same SSDs

2:31:49that allowed that work to be justified.

2:31:52- Yeah, and like when the Mac does get significant effort

2:31:59put into it, it seems to be, like I often use the phrase,

2:32:03it's kind of like a drive-by update,

2:32:05where like some subsystem will be rewritten.

2:32:08we had Discovery D a few years ago.

2:32:10I think in Sierra we had the USB subsystem,

2:32:13and that's why Sierra had so many USB audio bugs.

2:32:16In High Sierra, I think the window manager was rewritten

2:32:20to be metal-based, and so everything is,

2:32:23that's one of the reasons why it's so much faster

2:32:25in certain ways.

2:32:26And then there's the PDF subsystem that was rewritten,

2:32:29I think one or two versions ago.

2:32:30- Yeah, I remember Michael Sauer writing about that.

2:32:32And it was f-ed up in a bunch of ways.

2:32:33- Right, and the problem is when, right,

2:32:36like when these subsystems and things get rewritten

2:32:38Mac OS they get brought up to like what basically seems like a beta. Disc utility.

2:32:44Instability and features. Yeah the new disc utility that had like you know

2:32:47grammatical errors and the dialog box and stuff like and the crazy password

2:32:51authentication. It seems like these things get rewritten to like you know

2:32:57it's almost done it works for me and then they ship it and then they never

2:33:01fix it. So it's like it not only is the Mac not getting like really major

2:33:08platform changing work put into it it seems but also what work is going into

2:33:14it seems to be done in a more rushed fashion and it introduces bugs that seem

2:33:21to never really get fixed and that is that to me that's what's most concerning

2:33:26is not only that the platform is not moving forward in ways that I think it

2:33:31could and should, but also that what we have,

2:33:34in some ways, is getting worse every year

2:33:36as more bugs are added for kinda three-quarters-assed

2:33:41rewrites of system--

2:33:42- Well, and it ties in with a couple of other recent rumors.

2:33:45There's the other one that Germin had

2:33:46where there's Project Marzipan,

2:33:49which is supposedly some kind of way

2:33:52to have universal iPad, iOS, Mac apps.

2:33:57It's, you know, we can't get into details on it.

2:34:00I talked about it on this show too.

2:34:03I don't think, I think in typical German fashion,

2:34:06there's probably something to it,

2:34:08and it's, what it actually is,

2:34:12is not really interesting or understandable by him,

2:34:16and so it's misrepresented.

2:34:18But it very likely could be some kind of either UI kit

2:34:24on Mac or UI kit-like version of app kit on Mac.

2:34:30And and to make a very long story very short UI kit is the fundamental framework for making iOS apps and app kit is

2:34:38the Mac framework for making apps that dates back to next in 1988 and UI kit is

2:34:44unsurprisingly

2:34:47almost universally held as

2:34:49What would you know a company?

2:34:5218 years into app kit in 2006. What would they change if they had it to do all over again?

2:34:58again. And therefore is easier, more convenient in certain ways for developers. AppKit developers

2:35:08find it much easier to move to UIKit and, "Ooh, this is suddenly a lot easier." And UIKit

2:35:14developers such as yourself often find it very frustrating to move to AppKit because

2:35:17all of a sudden there's more grunt work to be handled by the developer. And so something

2:35:26that would enable people with UI kit skills

2:35:29to more easily make native Mac apps would be great,

2:35:31if done well, in theory.

2:35:36- Yeah, I am very excited about that possibility.

2:35:40That, because as an iOS developer

2:35:43who kind of reluctantly makes some Mac apps,

2:35:45like I would love to make more Mac apps,

2:35:48but it feels like my iOS skills

2:35:51are almost completely useless.

2:35:53Like it feels like it's a whole new platform,

2:35:55Because in many ways, it's kind of a--

2:35:56Forecast probably would have been a perfect app for that,

2:35:59or maybe it would be.

2:36:00Maybe it's so perfect for it that if it comes out

2:36:03that you'd rewrite it using it, if that's basically what it is.

2:36:06Because I think where AppKit really shines over UIKit

2:36:09is on truly complex code bases.

2:36:13Think about apps like the big Omni apps,

2:36:17or some of Panic's apps, and stuff like that.

2:36:21Apps that truly are way more complex than anything

2:36:23could reasonably get by with on iOS.

2:36:26AppKit is great at making that manageable.

2:36:29And UIKit is better for sort of,

2:36:32hey, all I need is this one screen, really,

2:36:34and it'll have a list here of things

2:36:37and a couple of buttons and a text field.

2:36:39- Yeah, and like, I mean,

2:36:42forecast is kind of an okay example.

2:36:45A better example is overcast.

2:36:47- Yeah, yeah.

2:36:48- Overcast, like, it's,

2:36:49most people listen to overcast on their phones.

2:36:52And by far, I think it's something like 92% phone,

2:36:57and then the rest is iPad, something like that,

2:37:01like in that neighborhood.

2:37:03And so it is primarily a phone platform,

2:37:05but because I've written Overcast using a lot of stock

2:37:08UI kit components, it is not that much effort

2:37:11to also maintain an iPad version of it.

2:37:14And even though the iPad version is only 7 or 8%

2:37:17of the usage, first of all, I use the iPad version,

2:37:18so that's kind of enough of motivation right there.

2:37:21But also, it is only about seven or eight percent

2:37:25more effort to maintain the iPad version to the degree I do.

2:37:28Now I could make an incredibly awesome,

2:37:31more customized iPad version that would take

2:37:33way more effort, but it probably isn't worth that,

2:37:36but it's fine, it only takes five percent more effort

2:37:39to reach five percent more people.

2:37:41If the Mac became a similar type of extension,

2:37:45where I already have this entire iOS code base

2:37:49with iOS UI in a lot of places.

2:37:53I know it wouldn't be the most amazing Mac app in the world

2:37:56in the same way that it isn't the most amazing iPad app

2:37:58in the world, but if I could get a Mac app out of Overcast

2:38:02for 10% more effort, I would totally do that.

2:38:07Whereas right now, it would be nearly 100% more effort,

2:38:11and the market is not able to justify that.

2:38:13it's not a big enough market for that,

2:38:15and it's not worth, I don't have that much bandwidth

2:38:18to spare on something like that.

2:38:19Whereas anything that would make it easier,

2:38:22if it's gonna make developing for Mac from an iOS code base

2:38:27about as much work, or even if it's more work,

2:38:30but it's not that much more work,

2:38:31than it is to port an iPhone app to the iPad,

2:38:34that is going to enable a ton more Mac apps.

2:38:38And yeah, they won't be the best Mac apps in the world.

2:38:41There will be a lot of crappy ports,

2:38:43just like there are on iPad, there will be a lot of

2:38:47behaviors that are really a little too iOS-y

2:38:51that feel a little bit weird on the Mac,

2:38:53but it is better for the Mac on a whole if that exists,

2:38:57and it's better for the iPad, because what you basically do

2:39:01is, assuming that developing an iPad,

2:39:04or assuming if you have an iPhone app,

2:39:07that expanding it onto the iPad and the Mac

2:39:11are probably kind of similar in a lot of ways,

2:39:13then what you've basically done is you've almost doubled

2:39:17the value of what a developer would get

2:39:20out of making the app from their iPhone app

2:39:23into this larger type of app.

2:39:25And so you increase the odds that more developers will,

2:39:28and you increase the amount of resources

2:39:30that they're able to justify devoting to it.

2:39:33And so what that does is have way more and better apps

2:39:37for both the iPad and the Mac,

2:39:40which both of those platforms could honestly use.

2:39:43- Yeah, the Mac has such a great library

2:39:46of long-standing apps, you know,

2:39:49and I was looking at it the other day,

2:39:51and most of the apps that I use have been around

2:39:53for quite a long time.

2:39:55BB Edit, Transmit, they both date back to classic Mac OS,

2:40:00Omni Outliner, even Mars Edit is a long-standing app

2:40:05at this point, I think Brent first shipped it in 2004,

2:40:09I don't know but

2:40:11You know it. I don't need a lot of new apps and these are the apps that I use on

2:40:16You know acorn is a relative to me in my mind is still a relatively new app

2:40:20It's up to like version 6.0. So it's not it's not that new

2:40:23Yeah, like apps that succeed on the Mac tend to last for a long time

2:40:28And those apps are great and are all in active development. There's new versions

2:40:34I think of just about every one of those apps that I just mentioned brand new versions that have great new features in

2:40:39Just like the last year BB edit transmit Mars edit

2:40:42Tweet bot hasn't had a new version in a while on a Mac

2:40:48But I'm just looking at the Mac apps that I rely on the most things

2:40:51Has a new version out

2:40:54But I still I do feel like so I'm not worried about those apps and app kits not going anywhere and they can keep using

2:41:01It but I do worry about when's the last time like somebody shipped a new Mac app that you're like, wow

2:41:06I love this is a new Mac app and I really do worry that that that's sort of a canary in the coal mine

2:41:12for the platform, you know that

2:41:15And it has so much momentum and so much, you know and sales of Mac hardware still as like all-time highs

2:41:23It's all good

2:41:24but as a platform I worry about the fact that

2:41:27all the apps that I consider my most used and beloved and best examples of good apps on the platform are like

2:41:36you know, even the new quote-unquote new ones are ten years old.

2:41:40Yeah, and you know if you listen to you know, people like Mike Hurley and and other like Federico Vatici

2:41:48people who are really into getting their primary work done on iOS

2:41:54one of the most common reasons cited for that is

2:41:58that there's honestly just more action on iOS with like what new apps are coming out, new

2:42:05concepts and apps, new developers becoming prominent,

2:42:09new design languages and new workflow strategies

2:42:13and everything, there's so much more happening on iOS.

2:42:17The Mac, there's not a lot of software innovation

2:42:22and just software health that's really growing on the Mac.

2:42:28Like the old apps that have been here forever

2:42:31seem to be doing fine.

2:42:32all of them, honestly. But many of them seem to be fine.

2:42:35I just checked Acorn's about box. It's copyright 2007 to 2018, so it's 11 years

2:42:41old and I just acted like it was brand new. I knew it wasn't, but still, compared to

2:42:46BB Edit and Transmit, it's…

2:42:47Yeah, right. Time flies.

2:42:48Compared to BB Edit and Transmit, it's…

2:42:49Time flies when your platform is being neglected.

2:42:51Where's Transmit? Transmit is copyright 1997 to 2017.

2:42:55BB Edit.

2:42:56I was in middle school.

2:42:58I know I first started using BB edit in

2:43:011992 and so

2:43:05It's pretty old

2:43:09Yeah, yeah, so like

2:43:12My concern with the Mac is that if they don't do something like this if they leave the status quo

2:43:18Where you have the Mac with its own?

2:43:21You know API's for everything that are older and clunkier, you know

2:43:26though richer in a lot of ways, but still older and clunkier

2:43:30and basically turning off a lot of modern developers.

2:43:33If you leave this the way it is,

2:43:35I think we're just gonna keep seeing a continuation

2:43:38of what we see now, which is not a lot of new developers

2:43:41coming to the Mac, not a lot of new apps,

2:43:43not a lot of new concepts, all the action continuing

2:43:47to happen in the US. - I honestly--

2:43:47- And that's not good for the Mac.

2:43:50- If I could chew the ear of Apple's executive team

2:43:52on what to do with the Mac going forward,

2:43:54Honestly, I really think and and that's why I'm happy

2:43:57I'm optimistic about this marzipan rumor is that I would rather see them focus almost entirely on

2:44:04Stuff for Mac developers or would be Mac developers then actual

2:44:11You know, here's a thing that you the user get from Apple right when you install the OS features

2:44:17Like you the features are all there. There's windows. There's menus. There's buttons

2:44:23But I feel like enabling people to making it

2:44:26Doing for you know like when Coco was first came out, and it was just like man

2:44:31You can make an app that is rich and has all you know complete rich text editor and all of these features for free

2:44:39And just focus on the features you want to add for your app

2:44:45And and you really could like a smaller team of developers or one person could make an app that

2:44:52one person could never make on Windows because you just didn't you didn't get that much with the framework and I feel like

2:44:58At this point they need to level that up again and make it like that again

2:45:02I just wrote this week about how like to me the biggest threat to the Mac is this proliferation of

2:45:07Non-native apps that people just accept as being well, that's what an app is these electron apps and shit

2:45:13Like that's the way slack works

2:45:15I think it's a threat to the platform that if the longer it goes on where that's accepted where

2:45:21a 300 megabyte download app that consumes 500 megabytes of RAM just for opening one

2:45:28window and is slow and doesn't use native controls and breaks a bunch of native conventions

2:45:34and uses weird Moonman keyboard shortcuts. If that's just accepted as the way that it

2:45:39is, then the Mac loses its reason for existence because any system, a Chromebook is as good

2:45:47as that because the same app will run with the same keyboard shortcuts. All you need

2:45:51is something that runs a web view. And if that's what desktop computers devolve to,

2:45:59where it's really not about the OS but just about the form factor of having a clamshell

2:46:03laptop that opens up and a keyboard that's connected and a trackpad, the Mac OS loses

2:46:09its reason for existence. The whole reason that the Mac thrived or survived in the rough

2:46:14years and thrived in later years is that it was better. And the reason it was better was

2:46:20is that it had better apps.

2:46:21And if new apps aren't coming out

2:46:25that follow in the same mold as their predecessors,

2:46:28it's a long-term problem for the platform,

2:46:31like a serious problem.

2:46:32- Yeah, and because, you know,

2:46:35and when you have something, you know,

2:46:38like you have apps that are just like web views

2:46:40shoved into standalone apps for the Mac,

2:46:44that's only a continuation of what we had a few years ago

2:46:47before this became so common,

2:46:48which is basically like the solution was on your phone,

2:46:51you can use a cool native app,

2:46:53and when you're on your computer,

2:46:54you just have to use our webpage.

2:46:56Like that just sucks, and I know why it's done that way,

2:47:00but it sucks.

2:47:01- It depends what the app or service is though.

2:47:03Like OpenTable, I'm fine with OpenTable being nothing more

2:47:06than a web thing on the Mac.

2:47:07I don't wanna, I wouldn't install an OpenTable app

2:47:09on my Mac, why would I?

2:47:11- Sure, but what about things like Netflix?

2:47:13- Right.

2:47:13- Right, like Netflix should be a native app,

2:47:15but instead it's a web view.

2:47:16And you know, Slack is kind of a special case

2:47:19'cause it's like, it's kind of a web view

2:47:21on all the platforms, I think, but it's like,

2:47:25there are a lot of apps where, you know,

2:47:27they're willing to invest the effort into an iOS app

2:47:31because the market supports that and the platform

2:47:34really makes it hard to do anything else in a good way.

2:47:38So like, you know, they're willing to do that,

2:47:39but when it comes to the Mac, they're just like,

2:47:42ah, well, you know, just web view is fine

2:47:44because it isn't worth them making a whole separate

2:47:49app kit code base just for this portion of the user base

2:47:52when they can just throw the webpage at them.

2:47:54So anything that Apple can do to help companies

2:47:58leverage their iOS code base that they're writing anyway

2:48:02to also make a Mac app fairly easily will pay off big time

2:48:06because lots of companies are doing that calculus.

2:48:09They're saying, well, it's not worth making a whole Mac app

2:48:11from nothing, from scratch,

2:48:13and not being able to reuse anything really.

2:48:16But they would have a very different calculus

2:48:18if the barrier was lower,

2:48:21if you could share more of that iOS code.

2:48:23And I wouldn't expect it to be like a new checkbox

2:48:27in Xcode, just make Mac app and that's it, you're done.

2:48:30You know, it's not gonna be that easy,

2:48:31but I hope it can be more like what it is

2:48:36to have an app go from iPhone to iPad,

2:48:39where it does take some work to get it to be usable

2:48:41and to get it to be nice,

2:48:43but it's at least possible to do

2:48:46without rewriting your entire UI from scratch.

2:48:49- All right, let me take a break here

2:48:51and thank our third and final sponsor of the evening,

2:48:55two good friends at Squarespace.

2:48:56Squarespace, look, when you wanna make a website,

2:49:01what are you gonna do?

2:49:02You're gonna start coding,

2:49:03you're gonna start opening up a web hosting account,

2:49:06you're gonna start writing PHP, HTML, all that stuff,

2:49:11the way websites were made back in the stone ages. You could,

2:49:15you could do that. You know what?

2:49:17To be a lot easier way to do it is start at Squarespace,

2:49:20go to Squarespace and spend half an hour making a new website.

2:49:25Sign up, you get a free account, you get a free trial. Just to start going.

2:49:28Squarespace handles everything. They are the host.

2:49:31They provide the templates you can start with. They provide the,

2:49:35the widgets that you can add to your page to add something like a store or to

2:49:40add like image portfolio and then you can just upload the images and it'll go right

2:49:46in. It is so much easier and takes so much work out of the process, especially if you

2:49:54are like a technically minded person who listens to the show and people come to you and they're

2:49:59like, Hey, I need a website. What am I supposed to do? You can build them a website at Squarespace,

2:50:04get them started and then just hand it off to them and they can take care of everything

2:50:08after that and do the updates. Back in the day when I was doing consulting and making

2:50:14websites for people, I'd make the website and I thought it was all the work and then

2:50:18I would just get all this continuing consulting work from them just to do content updates.

2:50:24It was like, "Well, thanks for the work, but it's like you're paying me to just be a typist."

2:50:29With Squarespace, a normal person, you can hand it over to them. It's a WYSIWYG interface

2:50:34and they can take care of updating content, adding new posts if you give them a blog or

2:50:40something like that on their Squarespace site. It really is so much easier and Squarespace

2:50:46has amazing technical support that they can just, normal person can just call them up

2:50:52and get help and instead of calling you, they'll call Squarespace. It's such a great product.

2:50:58Let me tell you, I like to do this because they sponsor the show a lot. I keep telling

2:51:02you more websites that you use on a regular basis are Squarespace sites than you would

2:51:07believe and I don't know what is wrong with me that I do it I guess it's because Squarespace

2:51:11sponsors the show so often but I every so I just view source and look for some of the

2:51:16things in the HTML that indicate that it's a Squarespace site and I'm like damn I this

2:51:22looks nothing like any other site I've seen it's totally branded to the company it doesn't

2:51:26look like it came from a cookie cutter template. So I had relatives in town from both sides

2:51:33of the family recently. They wanted to come to Philly, stay here at Daring Fireball headquarters

2:51:39for the Eagles Victory Parade last week here in Philadelphia because you couldn't get a

2:51:43hotel. The city was nuts. There were 3 million people at this damn parade. What do they want

2:51:49to eat the next night? Of course, everybody wanted to get cheesesteaks because that's

2:51:52you get in Philadelphia. Well, there's a great new cheese steak place pretty close to us

2:51:57here in Philadelphia. Cleaver's C L E A V E R S. Um, and their website is cleavers,

2:52:06philly.com. You can go there. It's a beautiful website. They have a beautiful restaurant

2:52:10and they make delicious sandwiches and they have great sides. Uh, I love that you're doing

2:52:16an ad for, well, guess what? Guess what? View source. It's Squarespace site. It is so

2:52:22so great. It's a great website. What do you want? You want a menu? You want to see pictures

2:52:28of their food? It's great. Go there, check it out. Check out to see what you can make

2:52:32with Squarespace. Go to cleversphilly.com. When you want to make your own website, though,

2:52:39where do you go? Well, you go to squarespace.com and you enter offer code. Now, this is what

2:52:45you do when you're ready to pay. You can just go there, go to Squarespace. That's all they

2:52:48care that you do to get started. Take their free trial and build what you want to build.

2:52:55And then when you go to pay, that's when you've got to remember this code. This is the thing

2:52:59you got to have long term memory for this. All you need to do to get started is go to

2:53:02squarespace.com. There's no special URL. But then when you go to pay, when you sign up,

2:53:07just remember the offer code talk show. No, the just talk show and you'll get 10% off

2:53:12your first purchase. So that's Squarespace is where you go to build a new website. I'm

2:53:15I'm telling you, the reason these people can make

2:53:18these great cheesesteaks is they didn't waste time

2:53:20building a website, other than going to Squarespace

2:53:25and putting their design out.

2:53:26They're not sitting there writing PHP,

2:53:27they're sitting there cooking up steaks.

2:53:30So go to squarespace.com and remember that offer code,

2:53:32talk show, know the.

2:53:34My thanks to Squarespace.

2:53:35That's not your favorite cheesesteak place.

2:53:38What's your favorite?

2:53:39You don't like Campos either.

2:53:40You go to the one that's a couple doors down

2:53:42from Campos when you're here.

2:53:45I forget what it's called, but it's it's the yeah, but campus is good too campus is really good

2:53:50You got to go to next time you're here that will take you to cleavers cleavers is I'm telling you. It's really good

2:53:54Now which is the one that I'm like the famous one that I don't go to that I'm supposed to be going to

2:54:01Every time I take a picture, okay

2:54:03The one I like a sunny is good sunny's is my favorite, but you've never been to campus

2:54:07so it says every time people will probably tell you to go to

2:54:12Well, there's Pat's and Gina's here and there's the one on South Street. What the hell's it called? Yeah, I hear Jim

2:54:17And Dallas, I don't want to

2:54:20Jim's Jim's if you google it Jim's has a lot of problems where every year or so they get busted for selling drugs

2:54:28It's and in my opinion that it's not a great steak it's really not

2:54:34It's a see when I have Sonny's I think why I'm not in Philly that much

2:54:41much. Why, when I come here, would I not get this?

2:54:45Well, like it's so good when I have it. I'm just like, I don't, I wouldn't want to

2:54:49like waste a meal. But you're a couple of miles away. You could save, you could, you

2:54:54could save a lot of driving or whatever by going to Cleaver's. You should, but see, and

2:54:57you should try more than one. I'm telling you, Cleaver's is the way to go. If you wanted

2:55:01to bust out and try one on the other side of Broad Street just because they, you know,

2:55:06It's similar sort of small shop atmosphere

2:55:09Jim's on South Street is designed to get like the most people through in the shortest amount of time like when they're busy

2:55:16They I don't know I wouldn't be surprised if they serve

2:55:1950 60 people an hour whereas you know like when you go to Sonny's it's like just going into a busy lunch place

2:55:24There's not like a crazy line out the door

2:55:26Yeah, that's fair but anyway I

2:55:34Had a thing what's what's the shortest show no no you and I often go

2:55:38All time record is me and Ben Thompson. Todd Visserie just updated his

2:55:43Talk-show episode length chart, although I don't think he posted it publicly. He sent it to me privately

2:55:48It's actually been going. Yeah, but we did one that was so long you split it into two

2:55:53Oh, so, I don't know. I don't think would that actually got credit for that one? No, it is. He's going by episodes

2:56:00Let me see here

2:56:04I'll send this to you. Where'd you go? There you are. I had a thing that kind of ties into

2:56:14what we were just talking about. Let me see if we have this in the notes. Oh, well, you

2:56:21were talking about two Do apps on ATP recently, and I wouldn't mind talking to you about this

2:56:25recently.

2:56:26Mm-hmm. Sure.

2:56:27Sure, but I had this thing I've I've moved for years. I was using an app called itta ita

2:56:33From nice mohawk software for managing I had like a list of things

2:56:39I take with me every time I leave the house for like a trip

2:56:41And I've recently moved that into Apple notes and put it in one of the notes and use their checklist feature

2:56:49Just to sort of have one less one fewer app to use and it seems like it might be sort of

2:56:55Put out the pasture those guys are working on some cool new

2:56:58Home energy monitoring stuff. I don't think it has been updated for iPhone 10

2:57:05Etc. So anyway doing a checklist and Apple Notes. It's not really a to-do app type thing

2:57:11It's a little bit more simple

2:57:13but it's a nice way to have this note and every time and the way I update it is every time I

2:57:21Leave the house for a trip and wind up thinking. Oh, I should have brought whatever

2:57:26Then I just add it to the end of the list and I'll never forget it again

2:57:30But the thing is and indeed it is not updated for the iPhone 10

2:57:34After I pack for the trip I either as I pack everything on my list

2:57:41I check it off and if it's something that's not relevant like I'll put

2:57:44Swimsuit, but I'm going somewhere where there I'm not going to swim

2:57:48Well, I'll just check it off because I know I don't need it. So checking it off the list either means I've packed it

2:57:53It's in a bag that I know I'm not gonna forget or I don't need it

2:57:56What do you do for your next trip?

2:57:59Well, what you want to do is uncheck all of those check marks right and start all over on

2:58:04iOS as

2:58:06Far as I can tell the only way to do that in Apple Notes whether you're on iPad or phone is to go through each

2:58:13Goddamn item and uncheck everything whereas in the Mac app

2:58:17app in Notes, you can, there's a menu command where you can uncheck everything. It's like

2:58:27mark as checked and then if you select them all, you can do mark as unchecked, like marking

2:58:32multiple messages as unread. It's a menu command in the format menu, which seems like something

2:58:39a computer program should do, right? Computers are supposed to alleviate us of tedium. Isn't

2:58:45that great, right? But there's no way to do it. So these people like Mike Hurley and all

2:58:51these other iPad lifestyle people, I believe them. I'm not disputing that they're leading

2:58:57a happier life for them using an iPad as their main computer. But that's the sort of thing

2:59:06that makes the iPad a complete non-starter is my main computing platform. Because the

2:59:13fact that I would have to do that and that on the Mac version I can just hit a

2:59:16menu command and have it all unchecked all at once is exactly why I like using

2:59:22a computer as opposed to you know mimeo graphing 20 copies of the same

2:59:27checklist on paper I mean and you know in there in the iPad users defense like

2:59:33there are apps that do this better like so like the solution for something like

2:59:38that where it's like well you can't do this very well on the iPad where the Mac

2:59:42can do it.

2:59:43The solution on the iPad is probably,

2:59:44well, if you use this other app, this can do that.

2:59:47So it's not that it's impossible,

2:59:50but it's often that you have to seek out

2:59:52a more power user-y app or a more obscure app

2:59:56to do these kinds of things better.

2:59:57- To me, it comes down to the most mundane and overlooked

3:00:01and it's, 'cause it's been here since,

3:00:04right since 1984 when the first Mac shipped,

3:00:07but the menu bar, and I'm not saying that iOS

3:00:10should get a Mac style menu bar because it wouldn't work.

3:00:13But the fact that Mac apps have a menu bar

3:00:16and you can put commands in there,

3:00:18and in recent years, in the old days,

3:00:21Mac apps didn't have toolbars at all.

3:00:24Like the only thing in the window chrome

3:00:26were the controls to close the window, zoom the window,

3:00:29or like minimize the window at some point

3:00:34when they didn't even have that at first.

3:00:38And anything you wanted to do was mostly done

3:00:41by using menu commands.

3:00:43That was like the main way of doing it.

3:00:46And I get it, 'cause they're hidden,

3:00:48everything in a menu bar is at least one level down, right?

3:00:52Like if you wanna save, you can't just click one button,

3:00:55you have to go to File and then go down to Save.

3:00:58I get it that even one level of indirection

3:01:03is gonna put some people off who are less likely

3:01:07to be technically minded. And normal people don't memorize keyboard shortcuts. That's

3:01:12all fine. I get it. And I think the overall trend to putting the main functions of an

3:01:16application as visible buttons that are always present in the window is a good trend. But

3:01:23the max menu bar, the fact that it's still there and still useful is organized, if well

3:01:29done and well designed, organizes things in a way that you know where to look for them

3:01:36is such a powerful feature for something like

3:01:39uncheck all of these check boxes,

3:01:41which maybe most people will never need or want to use

3:01:46or it wouldn't even occur to them that it exists,

3:01:49but there it is, a feature for me who wants to do it

3:01:51and thinks I should be able to do it.

3:01:53Oh, there it is.

3:01:54And there's no good way,

3:01:57and the point of my story is I can't think of a good way

3:02:00to put that many commands,

3:02:02even just from the simple Apple Notes app,

3:02:04How would you put as many commands that Apple Notes on Mac has in the iPad version?

3:02:10Where would you put those commands?

3:02:12Yeah, I mean this has been one of the big challenges to trying to bring touch screens

3:02:21into like the more like pro computing markets or into more like, you know, pro software

3:02:28uses.

3:02:29And you know, it's a problem that I don't think we've really figured out yet as an industry,

3:02:33how to design touchscreen-based apps in a way that can support the level of complexity

3:02:41and functionality that we can have on desktops.

3:02:43And there's two different problems to this, I think.

3:02:46One of them is that you have far less precision in the input than you do on a PC, whether

3:02:54it's a laptop or a desktop, whether it's Windows or a Mac.

3:02:57On a PC you have a very precise pointing device,

3:03:01in either a mouse or a trackpad or whatever,

3:03:04where you can really get down to the pixel-level

3:03:06precision there, so you can cram a lot more

3:03:10click targets on screen than you can by using

3:03:13our fat fingers on a 10-inch screen with a touch screen.

3:03:16And then the other problem that you have is,

3:03:19and you have this massive keyboard where you have

3:03:23100 keys and conventions that have been going on

3:03:26for decades of things like holding down certain modifiers

3:03:30and certain other keys to do certain common actions.

3:03:33And iOS has some support for common keyboard shortcuts,

3:03:38but not great support for it.

3:03:40And there's also like, there's conventions that you can do

3:03:42with the keyboard and mouse that have not yet been

3:03:46really established on iOS.

3:03:47So for instance, like, power users pretty quickly discover

3:03:50things like, you can drag a box around a whole bunch

3:03:53of icons and then pick them all up at once.

3:03:55or you can, if you're on one mail message,

3:03:59you can hold down shift and click one really far away

3:04:01from it and it selects all of them in the meantime.

3:04:03Like, you can do things like that

3:04:07that allow you to very efficiently work

3:04:10in the Mac and PC type form factors

3:04:14that the touch devices just haven't developed

3:04:16those standards yet and in some ways,

3:04:18it's kind of hard to see how they can

3:04:20because of the limitations of their input.

3:04:22Just not being, obviously it does certain things better

3:04:25like drawing and stuff like that,

3:04:27but because you don't have the incredibly precise

3:04:31pointing device of a mouse and a mouse cursor,

3:04:34and you don't have the incredibly rich button-filled

3:04:37like 100-key keyboard, it's just very, very different.

3:04:40And then the other problem is a visual design problem

3:04:44of your menu bar thing.

3:04:46It's like how do you expose lots of complex features,

3:04:51or just how do you expose lots of features

3:04:55in a UI on a touch screen.

3:04:57You don't have a lot of the discoverability conventions

3:05:02that we've had on PCs.

3:05:03You know, you don't have hovering the mouse pointer

3:05:06over something to get a tool tip to explain what it is.

3:05:09You don't have right clicking really.

3:05:11You have like forced touching or long pressing,

3:05:14but those are, it's very hard to, I mean honestly,

3:05:17I guess right clicking has the problem.

3:05:18It's very hard to know like what you can force touch

3:05:20and what you can long press.

3:05:22And there's not a lot of like conventions

3:05:24of how to show users that.

3:05:26And then the way that you accommodate things

3:05:29like that you would typically get like in a menu bar

3:05:32where like, you know, a menu bar has a very, very small

3:05:35amount of screen space devoted to it,

3:05:37but you can click on it and then you get expanded

3:05:41these lists of commands that they themselves can have

3:05:44their own subcommands that expand out

3:05:46when you hover over them.

3:05:48So you can cram a whole bunch of functionality

3:05:50into a relatively small amount of screen space

3:05:54that is out of the way when you don't need it, et cetera.

3:05:57In addition, it really enables power use

3:05:59because it shows you what the keyboard shortcuts are

3:06:02for these things.

3:06:02So if you keep going to the same menu commands

3:06:04over and over again, eventually you might notice

3:06:07those little characters after it and figure out,

3:06:09oh, that's the symbol on the keyboard,

3:06:11oh, I can hit Command + T and do this thing, right?

3:06:14And so it enables both the progressive disclosure

3:06:19and management of lots of functionality,

3:06:22as well as it kind of shows you as a power user

3:06:25how to get faster at these things.

3:06:27And on touch devices, we really don't have

3:06:29good conventions for these yet.

3:06:31We don't have good ways to show power users

3:06:34how to do things faster.

3:06:36We don't really have concepts of things

3:06:38like keyboard shortcuts being incredibly discoverable.

3:06:41I know on an iPad you can just hold down command

3:06:43on an external keyboard and it shows a little overlay,

3:06:45but that only applies to the iPad

3:06:48and only when you're having a keyboard attached

3:06:50and a lot of people are using a lot of Tux devices

3:06:53that don't have keyboards attached to them that way.

3:06:56And we don't also have in our UI paradigms

3:06:59the amount of progressive disclosure that you get

3:07:04from a menu, we don't have that really

3:07:06in our design vocabulary on Tux OS software yet.

3:07:10And instead, Tux OS things tend to do that

3:07:14with just having lots of modes,

3:07:16where you tap this toolbar icon

3:07:18the whole interface changes to be this mode, and then it's, and that just gets very confusing

3:07:23very quickly. And even then, you're usually using iconography, not text, to show what

3:07:30the actions are, which makes it, in some ways it makes it more accessible if like, you know,

3:07:36if it's not in your language or if you don't understand some of the terminology used. But

3:07:40it also makes it a lot harder to skim and browse and kind of learn the ins and outs

3:07:45of for a lot of people. So we have like, you know, it took us a long time to figure this

3:07:49stuff out on desktops, or on PCs rather. And I think tux just, it's just too early in the

3:07:57tux OS's and in how we design software for them to know how to how to solve some of these

3:08:04problems because you can't just take the solutions from PCs and translate them right over in

3:08:09a lot of ways because it just doesn't fit.

3:08:11- And it's not quite true that you could use the menu bar

3:08:14to explore the entire functionality of an app.

3:08:16And like a perfect example of that

3:08:18is like in Adobe apps, like Photoshop.

3:08:21- The paradigms of good user interface.

3:08:24- Well, even going back to the early days of Photoshop

3:08:27when it was truly a good Mac app.

3:08:29But you could, you can always,

3:08:30as long back as I can remember,

3:08:32let's say you have an image

3:08:33and you're zoomed in way bigger than your screen, right?

3:08:36But you still wanna pan around the image.

3:08:38You can just hold down the space bar wherever you are

3:08:41and the mouse cursor will change to the Mickey Mouse hand,

3:08:45and then you can click and drag

3:08:47to just drag the canvas around screen.

3:08:50Well, that's not a menu command.

3:08:51That's something you somehow you have to learn that.

3:08:53And for whatever reason, QuarkXPress back in the day,

3:08:57the desktop image or layout program,

3:09:00desktop like publishing program

3:09:01that at one point I practically lived my life in

3:09:05had the same feature, but they used the option key,

3:09:07which I actually always liked better than space bar

3:09:10'cause it always felt like it should be a modifier

3:09:12and just plain option clicking on something

3:09:14was completely unused, right?

3:09:16Command clicking, open links,

3:09:17and control clicking opens control menus.

3:09:20Option clicking was right there, but you had to learn that.

3:09:23But for the most part though, if you just wanna learn

3:09:25what's everything this app can do,

3:09:27if you just go through the menu bar, you'll find it all.

3:09:30And I'll give you a perfect example of that.

3:09:32I've lost that curiosity almost,

3:09:35or the instinct to like, when I have a new app, to do that,

3:09:39Because even me, as somebody who thinks of himself primarily

3:09:43as a Mac user, I've gotten so accustomed to the,

3:09:47look, if it's not an icon in the window that I can click,

3:09:50don't think about it.

3:09:51Like when I was looking for that uncheck all thing in Notes,

3:09:55I found another feature that I had no idea was there.

3:09:58This is probably new to almost everybody

3:09:59who I'm going to tell this to,

3:10:00because you didn't even think to look at it.

3:10:01But in Apple Notes on like Sierra and Hi Sierra,

3:10:05you can open a note in its own window, right,

3:10:08double-clicking it and then if you go to the window menu there's a float on top

3:10:12command and that window will stay floating on top of all other windows did

3:10:17you know you could do that open any note you want float on top and now it's like

3:10:25an always on top thing look at that you can you know you can keep a little

3:10:28skinny window open on the side while you're doing other work gathering notes

3:10:32and it's always there for you to like drag stuff to it's fantastic but there's

3:10:37There's no other way to do it other than to go to the menu bar

3:10:40Anyway, that's my I really feel like that's the biggest one of the biggest problems facing the iPad

3:10:46especially like because I don't think you want apps with an extra, you know, the

3:10:50Even the biggest phone possible whatever whoever in China is making a six point whatever inch phone

3:10:57It's it's a small enough screen where the maximum complexity of an app is

3:11:03dictated by the size of the screen.

3:11:05But there's no reason in theory that a 11 inch

3:11:08or 13 inch iPad shouldn't be able to support apps

3:11:12of the same complexity as a Mac,

3:11:14but the UI metaphors just aren't there

3:11:16for where to put those commands

3:11:17that can't be shown on screen at all time.

3:11:21- Yeah, like where do you put a whole bunch of functionality

3:11:24and also how do you show users

3:11:27how to use the app in a more powerful way?

3:11:31So with the equivalent of keyboard shortcuts

3:11:34and things like that,

3:11:35like how do you show users what is possible?

3:11:38- Yeah.

3:11:39I don't know.

3:11:41(laughing)

3:11:45What else did I have to talk about this week?

3:11:47Oh, I wanna talk about the sad state of Apple TV apps.

3:11:50I really wanna talk about this.

3:11:51- So do I actually.

3:11:52I don't know, are you gonna release a three hour episode?

3:11:55Like how do you do this?

3:11:56- What are we at?

3:11:57I see we got interrupted by a Skype drop before,

3:11:59so I don't know where we are.

3:12:00- Yeah, we're gonna be at about three hours.

3:12:02- We'll be close.

3:12:03Well, there you go, you get your money's worth

3:12:06out of this episode.

3:12:07- I'm finally gonna get counted in your episode

3:12:12length records. - Yeah, I'll tell Vasiri

3:12:13to update his chart.

3:12:14The sad state of Apple TV apps.

3:12:16And this popped into my bubbled up,

3:12:18I wrote recently about the long awaited Amazon Prime app.

3:12:22And I was just telling you, in fact,

3:12:24all of those episodes of Top Gear,

3:12:26the reason I hadn't watched it until now,

3:12:28not Top Gear, Grand Tour. By the way, have you realized how clever the name Grand Tour is? For

3:12:35people who don't know the backstory, the three guys who did the Grand Tour for years did a BBC

3:12:40show called Top Gear, and it was very popular around the world. And then one of the guys,

3:12:46Jeremy Clarkson, was at a steakhouse and having dinner with one of the producers, and I don't

3:12:54know what happened. Nobody really seems to know what happened, but he punched the guy out.

3:12:58(laughing)

3:13:00- That wasn't quite what, yeah, it's close enough.

3:13:03- Well.

3:13:03- Yeah, he punctured a staff member,

3:13:07and therefore, like the BBC basically had to fire him.

3:13:10- And the other two guys in solidarity left,

3:13:12and they went to Amazon,

3:13:13and they've started what's effectively the same show.

3:13:16Do you realize how clever it is

3:13:17if you're well known for a show called Top Gear,

3:13:20how perfect a name Grand Tour is,

3:13:23because you're taking the same two letters,

3:13:25T and G, and just replacing them,

3:13:28And there's something, at least in my mind,

3:13:31where they get filed right next to each other

3:13:34in the hash table, in my mind.

3:13:36They sound the same, Grand Tour, Top Gear.

3:13:39They have the same cadence.

3:13:42Like for three guys who couldn't take the name Top Gear

3:13:46with them, the name Grand Tour is,

3:13:50it's unbelievably perfect.

3:13:53It's really crazy.

3:13:54And I find myself saying,

3:13:55even though I never even watched Top Gear,

3:13:57I find myself saying Top Gear all the time just because it's, like I said, it's like

3:14:01in the same, it's like a hash table collision in my brain because it's so perfect. Anyway,

3:14:07the whole reason I put off watching it, even though you guys started talking about it when

3:14:10their Amazon show launched last year, was because I couldn't watch it on my goddamn

3:14:14Apple TV. And it's not like I'm spiteful and only watch stuff on Apple TV. It's just that

3:14:20switching to something else never seems convenient enough.

3:14:24Yeah, it's nicer to watch an Apple TV.

3:14:26So now that there's an Amazon Prime app on Apple TV, and even though it's a garbage

3:14:30app, which I wrote about, it's just horrible. And it's just a direct port from the Prime

3:14:37app on all these other platforms. It's terrible. It's just really, really a bad app. It disobeys

3:14:44so many conventions of Apple TV. It doesn't work like any other normal Apple TV app. But

3:14:49The one saving grace that it has is it does integrate with Apple's Apple TV app.

3:14:54So you can just go to the Apple's TV app and it seems to do a good job of

3:14:59saying, Hey, you just watched episode three of season two of this.

3:15:02Do you want to watch season four?

3:15:04And I don't really have to interact with the Amazon app. But anyway,

3:15:08this week YouTube came out with a new,

3:15:10an updated version of their Apple TV app and it's like the exact same thing as

3:15:16story is the Amazon app where it's just a direct port of their youtube.com/tv web app

3:15:23doesn't look or act anything like an Apple TV app doesn't work well with the whatever

3:15:28you think of the Apple TV remote control. Certainly this app isn't meant to be used

3:15:32with it and it doesn't even make noises you move around. You know how like on Apple TV

3:15:36you go up down left, right? It goes beep, beep, beep, beep. It doesn't doesn't make any

3:15:40noise and I have a stupid TV setup where I don't have one button to hit to turn everything

3:15:45on. I've got to hit a button to turn on the TV and a button to turn on my sound system.

3:15:51And then, like, I always have to wake up the Apple TV, so that's the third button. So when

3:15:56it wasn't making noise, I just assumed that when I went to turn on the sound system, I

3:16:01didn't hit it. And now I'm like, well, shit, the green light's on. Oh, maybe I have to

3:16:04turn the volume up. And I turn the volume way up. And if I turn the volume to, like,

3:16:08you know, too loud. And I'm like, holy shit, they shipped an Apple TV app that doesn't

3:16:12make noises you navigate. Yeah, this is so I pose a question in our notes here and

3:16:20I think it might be a discussion like were in retrospect and and I'm not

3:16:26saying Apple should have known this but it just as a question now in retrospect

3:16:31was this model of letting everybody make their own apps for the Apple TV actually

3:16:36the right model was it was this actually better than the previous Apple TV

3:16:41software like before they had the fortune what was in 2015 before that one the app the

3:16:47old Apple TVs before they were apps Apple basically wrote all of the like kind of channels

3:16:54that that appeared there and they were all based on you know like a common code base

3:17:00where it was basically like being fed like a list of things that can be played and they

3:17:04were you know some structures it's a TV ML or something like that TV markup language

3:17:08it was sort of like, well that's the new one.

3:17:11- I thought that was the old one.

3:17:12- Anyway, so, I don't think we ever knew the name

3:17:16of what the old one was like.

3:17:18It was basically, it was like a version of XML

3:17:20that would like render.

3:17:21- It was just an XML file, right.

3:17:23- Right, and so all Apple TV video sources,

3:17:27in the previous generation of Apple TVs,

3:17:29all would work the same way.

3:17:30Like you'd have the same kind of menu structure,

3:17:32everything would look basically the same,

3:17:34you'd just be accessing,

3:17:35oh now you're running HBO's content,

3:17:37and now you're running so-and-so's content.

3:17:39And it all looked and worked in the standard way,

3:17:43which is how TV stuff had always worked before.

3:17:47Like your cable box, every provider who does things

3:17:51on a cable service doesn't have their own app

3:17:53that you don't have to navigate to.

3:17:55Like if you wanna watch a show on a different channel

3:17:57on a cable service, it works exactly the same way

3:18:00as every other channel that you have access to

3:18:02in your channel guide and whatever.

3:18:04Everything works the same.

3:18:05And so when Apple moved to the fourth gen,

3:18:09there was a lot of questions about how they should do this

3:18:13and people saying what they should and shouldn't do.

3:18:15And what they did at the time,

3:18:16which I think was probably the right move

3:18:18with everything we knew at the time,

3:18:19was now we just make everything apps.

3:18:22And video providers and other people

3:18:25can just make their own app however they want it to be,

3:18:29and that's how they can bring their content

3:18:31to the Apple TV, which is great in a number of ways.

3:18:34it lowers barriers, it makes it so that, you know,

3:18:37Apple doesn't have to hand create every one of these

3:18:40video providers' channels on the TV, like,

3:18:42the people can make their own apps,

3:18:44and they can make them really awesome.

3:18:47The problem is, when big companies make their own apps,

3:18:50they often don't make them really awesome,

3:18:52and they often have their own goals in mind,

3:18:54like, you know, Amazon wants the Amazon app

3:18:57to look the same way on all platforms,

3:18:59Netflix, you know, same thing, YouTube,

3:19:01probably the same thing, like,

3:19:03So what we have now is companies that they control

3:19:08the entire experience rather than Apple,

3:19:11and what they've chosen to do is to make

3:19:14kind of a crappy Apple TV experience.

3:19:17- Not even kind of.

3:19:18- Now there's no more recourse for that.

3:19:19- And they both, I think Amazon at least

3:19:22is using standard playback controls for the video stream.

3:19:24Like once video is streaming,

3:19:26it's a standard Apple TV video stream,

3:19:28but YouTube uses their own video playback controls.

3:19:31and they don't support, I mean, things that are fundamental

3:19:35to the platform, like being able to tap, not click,

3:19:38just tap the touch pad on the remote to bring up like,

3:19:43"Hey, where am I?"

3:19:44That doesn't work.

3:19:45It doesn't do anything.

3:19:46It's so literally tied to the idea

3:19:50of a generic shitbox TV connected thing

3:19:52with a D-pad and a select button

3:19:55that anything other than that on the Apple TV remote

3:19:58doesn't work, including just fundamental to the platform,

3:20:00just tap on the thing to see where I am.

3:20:03And the playback controls look all weird.

3:20:05And they even bring up like a stupid picker,

3:20:08the way that YouTube is so obsessed with always,

3:20:11no matter where you are in a video,

3:20:13you could be watching like a half hour YouTube video

3:20:15and you're only 10 minutes into it.

3:20:16But if you do anything, they immediately present you

3:20:18with eight options for other things

3:20:20you might wanna watch right now, right?

3:20:21Like, I don't know how somebody

3:20:24with a genuine attention deficit problem,

3:20:28how they could ever watch anything on YouTube.

3:20:30Like I don't have any kind of issues in that regard,

3:20:33like in a clinical sense, but even I feel badgered.

3:20:37Like I just wanted to pause the show.

3:20:39Why are you telling me about eight other things to watch

3:20:42and taking up a quarter of the screen?

3:20:45All I wanted to do was freaking pause

3:20:46and maybe see where I am in the video.

3:20:48So the other thing I did, I told you earlier in the show,

3:20:53I fired up the Fire TV 'cause I wanted to see

3:20:57what the hell's going on with YouTube over there.

3:20:59And so they have a youtube.com, at least on my Fire TV.

3:21:04It was like one of the top two or three suggestions

3:21:06for things to do.

3:21:08And I was like, "Ooh, that's interesting."

3:21:10And it didn't have the YouTube logo.

3:21:11It was even a blue rectangle and not red.

3:21:14So they weren't even trying to impersonate YouTube.

3:21:17It's just a blue rectangle that said youtube.com.

3:21:20And I clicked it and it said,

3:21:22"You have two ways of watching YouTube on Fire TV.

3:21:25"You can download Firefox,

3:21:27or you can download Silk. That's Amazon's web browser. So I downloaded both. And when

3:21:36you fire up either Mozilla or Silk, both of them assume that the only reason they exist

3:21:44is to show YouTube. Like they're effectively both YouTube apps. So you download Silk on

3:21:51the thing and it's just like, "You want to watch YouTube, right?" And they're like, "Yeah."

3:21:55and then it just turns into the YouTube app.

3:21:57And it looks exactly like the Apple TV app.

3:22:01So running YouTube as a website in a web browser

3:22:06on the Amazon Fire TV box is exactly the same interface

3:22:13as Apple TV, with the small exception of at the very least

3:22:17on Apple TV, the currently selected item does have the 3D

3:22:23pops out effect and you can kind of jiggle it around

3:22:26a little bit.

3:22:27But every other thing is exactly the same.

3:22:29So somehow, and my, I guess, is that the new YouTube app

3:22:33on Apple TV somehow got an exception

3:22:36and is running a web view, even though the web view

3:22:39isn't really part of the Apple TV SDK.

3:22:43And I think that they--

3:22:45- Or it might not technically be a web view,

3:22:48maybe it's some kind of thing where they're using

3:22:50JavaScript under their hood to do most of their logic,

3:22:53but they're rendering it differently.

3:22:55But it doesn't necessarily have to be a WebView to do that.

3:22:58But yeah, it's still some kind of cross-platform

3:23:01gallery for people.

3:23:02- And the other funny thing about the Prime app,

3:23:04which is a great example, was the people who still have

3:23:08the previous generation Apple TV,

3:23:11the one from three generations ago,

3:23:14the one before it was running on a version of iOS,

3:23:17they got a Prime app too, a software update.

3:23:22And it's exactly like you said,

3:23:23it just looks like every other standard Apple TV app

3:23:27just with Prime content.

3:23:29So they get, in my opinion,

3:23:30way better Prime experience under Apple TV

3:23:34for sticking with the old Apple TV

3:23:37than anybody with a new Apple TV gets

3:23:40because they get a truly native to Apple TV experience.

3:23:43I think that these apps are a disaster.

3:23:47I think that the state of Apple TV

3:23:50outside of Apple's own apps is really pretty bad. Netflix is okay, I would say, and I watch

3:23:55it a lot on Netflix. I think it could be...

3:23:57Yeah, it's okay.

3:23:59At the very least with Netflix, I don't feel like the people who made the app aren't actually

3:24:04Apple TV users themselves. I feel like they could go more standard and just keep Netflix

3:24:11branding as logos and nobody's going to be confused about what app they're in. But it's

3:24:17heads and shoulders, it's at least trying to be a good Apple TV app.

3:24:20Whereas the Prime one and YouTube in particular, it's just unbelievable how little attention

3:24:27they pay to what Apple TV is trying to do as a platform in terms of user experience.

3:24:34Yeah.

3:24:35And, like, you know, it's almost, you know, tying it back to the beginning of this conversation

3:24:41five hours ago, it's almost like, you know,

3:24:45when the watch launched and it had its whole

3:24:47terrible app platform, like, you know, in retrospect,

3:24:50it probably shouldn't have had that.

3:24:52I feel like a lot of that same thing applies

3:24:54to Apple TV apps, where like, you know,

3:24:56it launched with this brand new app model

3:25:01and this brand new app library and framework,

3:25:04you know, about two and a half years ago,

3:25:06and they presented it as though we were gonna be doing

3:25:11like our shopping and browsing for hotels and stuff

3:25:14on Apple TV and doing all sorts of things.

3:25:17But I think what most people do on Apple TV is watch video

3:25:20and a few of them play games,

3:25:22but even that has been pretty badly neglected.

3:25:25So like what we really have is still mostly

3:25:29just a video device that happens to occasionally

3:25:31have some games, but that's about it.

3:25:34And they launched it with two different APIs

3:25:38for how you could make your user interface.

3:25:40One of them is called TVML, and that is basically

3:25:44how the old one worked, but it lets you create,

3:25:48not just something that looks like the old one,

3:25:49it lets you create stock interfaces really easily

3:25:53that look and work just like the built-in ones.

3:25:55One of the biggest examples of this, I believe,

3:25:57is the Plex app, I think is still a TVML app,

3:26:00and that's why the Plex app looks like

3:26:03all of Apple's built-in stuff,

3:26:05like it just works the same way, it uses stock stuff,

3:26:08what you can do is you can have your own native binary code running the logic libraries under it all, but the UI is being rendered by this layer that is basically XML driven and is using stock components for everything.

3:26:25Then they also let you build entire applications using a

3:26:30basically a slim-down version of UI kit.

3:26:33So they have these two different ways you can build interfaces for your apps on Apple TV.

3:26:38I think in retrospect, and again I don't expect them to have known this at the time, I'm not saying this is a big mistake that they did,

3:26:44but I think in retrospect, the better move and the way to make a better experience for their customers

3:26:51would have been to only launch TVML-based apps

3:26:55and to force all third-party apps

3:26:58to use a TVML interface layer.

3:27:00And maybe they could have an exception,

3:27:04like maybe the games would have to do it.

3:27:05- Right, exactly, that's what I was gonna say,

3:27:06is if your app's primary purpose is to play video,

3:27:09you need to use this framework.

3:27:10And you can style it, you know,

3:27:13you can add your decorations to make it look branded.

3:27:16And I don't think that was ever a problem

3:27:17on the old Apple TV.

3:27:18I was never confused when I was in the HBO app or whichever one it's called. I'm like

3:27:23you. I can't. I can't remember. I need, I need the opposite one of you because we have

3:27:28still have cable TV service. So I need the HBO app. I think, I think I'm HBO go, but

3:27:34maybe you're HBO. I don't know. HBO. Maybe I'm now. I don't know. I can't believe that

3:27:40you're John Syracuse is yelling at his podcast player. I always cracked me up that the two

3:27:44of them together are go now, which is I get angry and that's

3:27:48what I want to do. But I never got confused on the old Apple TV

3:27:51that I was in the HBO app. It looked like HBO. It had HBO

3:27:54branding and colors and felt HBO. But it always always also

3:28:00felt like an Apple TV app.

3:28:02Right, exactly. And, and I think what we've seen now with a

3:28:07couple years experience in this world, we've seen that these big

3:28:11content providers are not really able to make good apps.

3:28:15Like, they keep showing us that over and over again.

3:28:17That like, the more they deviate from the stock stuff

3:28:20on the Apple TV, the worse their apps tend to get.

3:28:23And I think it really is a better user experience

3:28:28if the makers of these apps have less flexibility

3:28:32in what they can do on this platform.

3:28:35Because the Apple TV is not an iPhone, it's not an iPad.

3:28:39we don't have the ability to have like rich, awesome

3:28:42interactions with this.

3:28:43We are controlling a six foot wide TV

3:28:48from a little tiny remote in our hands

3:28:50that's like five buttons.

3:28:51Like it's a limited interaction.

3:28:53There's only so much we can do.

3:28:54We need the system to have really like a strong UI

3:28:59consistency and leadership from the platform vendor

3:29:05and just have it be perfectly optimized

3:29:09isn't tailored for what it really is.

3:29:14And we're not getting that now.

3:29:16What we're getting instead is really crap,

3:29:18you know, least common denominator platforms

3:29:21designed by marketing people in these big video providers

3:29:24that are all different from each other.

3:29:28And like you said earlier about how there's not much reason

3:29:29for the Mac to exist if all the software is just web views.

3:29:33There's not much benefit to the Apple TV

3:29:34if every video app on it is just a clone

3:29:37of the way that service looks on every other TV stick

3:29:42and the built-in crappy apps on your TV.

3:29:44Like, there's no, why does Apple TV exist for them?

3:29:47So I think, I don't know if Apple can put this cat

3:29:50back in the bag, but honestly, I think a TVML-only policy

3:29:55for video apps on the Apple TV

3:29:57would be a huge benefit to Apple TV users.

3:30:00- I almost feel it's a case where,

3:30:02with the whole idea of app stores in general,

3:30:06ever since the iPhone first shipped its app store

3:30:0810 years ago,

3:30:09the reasonable and in some cases,

3:30:15many cases over the 10 years warranted concern is,

3:30:19wow, this is dangerous idea putting all this

3:30:21in this yes or no power in the hands of a company

3:30:25as capricious as Apple,

3:30:27that they're going to say no to apps that,

3:30:30for reasons that most of us would disagree with.

3:30:32It's gonna be too hard.

3:30:36There should be, let the market sort it out sort of thinking

3:30:39and there are gonna be dicks about this.

3:30:42I would honestly say, at least on Apple TV,

3:30:44I wish they were being more of a dick.

3:30:47I wish they were like,

3:30:48"What is this hot pile of garbage Amazon?

3:30:50"Go back, get this out of her face and do this right."

3:30:54I don't know.

3:30:59I know that the way computers have always used to work

3:31:03in the old days, pre-App Store,

3:31:05was whatever you wrote, you wrote,

3:31:06it was you're the developer, you can make it,

3:31:07you wanna make a shitty app, make a shitty app.

3:31:09But I thought the whole point of App Stores was,

3:31:13from Apple's perspective,

3:31:14was to sort of guarantee a baseline of quality.

3:31:16And it's like the opposite has happened.

3:31:19- I mean, and to be fair, it kinda never has done that.

3:31:23Even on the iPhone from day one,

3:31:24you had those crappy fart apps and stuff,

3:31:27and you're like, oh, I guess this isn't actually

3:31:29gonna be a quality thing more of like a kind of safety thing.

3:31:32But also like, and you know, in Apple's defense also,

3:31:35like I think one of the reasons maybe they aren't

3:31:37going to clamp down on this is that I'm not sure

3:31:41that they're in a position of power to do that

3:31:44on the Apple TV.

3:31:45Like if Amazon and YouTube, especially,

3:31:48I mean Amazon, you know, they did without Amazon

3:31:50for a while and they could keep doing that

3:31:52if they wanted to.

3:31:52But like if YouTube decides they don't wanna support

3:31:55the Apple TV anymore, that's a much bigger problem

3:31:58for the Apple TV than it is for YouTube.

3:32:00And because the Apple TV just doesn't have enough

3:32:04market share and power in the industry

3:32:07to be able to really piss off one of the most important

3:32:11video providers.

3:32:12Like they just, they really can't do that.

3:32:14Like I don't think it's strong enough.

3:32:16I don't think it's in a strong enough negotiating position.

3:32:18So maybe Apple did actually apply pressure to Amazon

3:32:23and to YouTube to say like, hey, you gotta make your app

3:32:27a little more native, and maybe they just said no.

3:32:30And like, what's Apple gonna do, reject their apps?

3:32:32Like, that's not gonna happen for these services,

3:32:34so it's kind of a, it's a problem that maybe Apple

3:32:39did try to solve and they just can't.

3:32:42- How are we doing on time?

3:32:44I think we're plenty long.

3:32:47- I think we're probably done.

3:32:48- I'm gonna say done.

3:32:49- I think a little long.

3:32:50- I'm gonna say that, I'm gonna say one thing

3:32:51I just wanted to touch upon.

3:32:52I just wanted to touch upon--

3:32:54- One more thing. - The one more thing.

3:32:55Did want to touch it was it was one of those funny things I feel like lately

3:32:59I just feel like I don't know last few months or so more than usual as I listen to ATP

3:33:05I've been more decidedly and consistently on Syracuse's side on a lot of points and I you know

3:33:11You know, I should have him on the show too, but he hasn't been on in a while

3:33:16But you had one where you started talking about that

3:33:20You never really used a to-do app or a task tracker or whatever you want to call it

3:33:23And to me that's part of the problem with the whole categories. I don't even know what to call them

3:33:26But that you settled on things recently

3:33:29What's who's the company behind that is that the soul men?

3:33:33culture code

3:33:35And that's the app I used to but I still don't put everything in it

3:33:41and

3:33:43Some of the stuff you said I was like, yes

3:33:45Like you said like you in general even though things does have an inbox

3:33:49You don't like apps to do apps that have like an inbox because where the hell is that where's inbox?

3:33:55I I don't want an inbox because it's like inbox means I'm gonna have to do work later to put it where it's supposed to

3:34:02Go and you're I was like, yes. Yeah, I think it comes out of the GTD

3:34:06Model I think but but like it's like I don't like I don't want to practice GTD

3:34:11And so the more a task manager can let me not do that

3:34:16The more the better we're gonna get things has always had this and I've and it's always had like the eye for UI design

3:34:22It's always been a pretty neat looking app on Mac and iOS

3:34:26But it's always had this built-in thing where there's by you can't even get rid of them, but there's an inbox. There's a today box

3:34:33Now I get that I get today today I get that makes sense

3:34:37Right things I want to do today then there's upcoming anytime and someday

3:34:43I'm already I use things things is what I've settled upon because after years of

3:34:48Wandering back and forth between various apps and hating all of them even worse

3:34:54Things is the one I hate the least but I still it just bothers me even though I never use upcoming anytime or someday

3:35:00That they're there. I just hate that they're there

3:35:04Well, I'll tell you what for me what made things click for me and it is and again

3:35:11I still wish that there was some like checkbox option to just not use the inbox ever. But so the inbox is like, you know, the inbox is basically considered a project submit like semantically like in the way it stores things. And what clicked for me is that you can assign tasks to no project. And if you if you if you make everything no project and on the Mac, there's even an option for the quick entry window that when you hit command T or whatever, whatever your map is for that, like, there's a there's an

3:35:41an option for quick entry things to default to no project

3:35:45instead of inbox.

3:35:46But if you make everything that you create

3:35:50a no project entry, then your home screen

3:35:54can be the any time tab.

3:35:56And so that's, the way I use the app is

3:35:58I'm always viewing the any time tab.

3:36:00Unless I'm like diving into a project's details,

3:36:02but for the most part, I'm looking at the any time tag.

3:36:05So that way, anything that is rated for today,

3:36:08it gets a little star next to it so it stands out

3:36:09so I can see it easily.

3:36:11But otherwise, I'm looking at a list of things

3:36:14that are either set for today or sometime in the past

3:36:19or have no due date.

3:36:22So things that are in the future are still hidden.

3:36:24Things that are in some day are hidden.

3:36:27And it shows a nice overview of active items

3:36:31in my projects right below the stuff on top,

3:36:35which is the no project stuff.

3:36:37It is, for things to be closer to perfect for me,

3:36:41All I basically want is for the inbox to not exist

3:36:44and for all new tasks created by any means

3:36:48that don't specify a project to default to no project

3:36:52instead of inbox.

3:36:53- I guess I use it in a very different way.

3:36:55I use it where I just pretend that inbox is,

3:36:59instead of being called, I just pretend it doesn't have

3:37:02that name, that it's just like, that's just like everything.

3:37:05It's just like all music in iTunes.

3:37:09Yeah, yeah, but then the problem there is then like you don't you can't really see anything

3:37:14you've assigned to a project like like what I want is like one screen to be like my overview

3:37:19from right now. And that's what the anytime thing gives me if you tag everything as no

3:37:24project that isn't in one rather than using inbox as the project. The way I've gotten

3:37:29around that is that I'm either doing a project that's a multi step thing. And it deserves

3:37:35to be made a proper project and that's like a separate thing. Or it's just like a task.

3:37:41Like I have one here called dentist. You know, I haven't had a dentist appointment in a while,

3:37:45so that's, that's in there. Um, and I just keep it all. I just keep everything in the

3:37:50inbox and it's just a place where I'm not going to forget it. And then every once in

3:37:54a while I just go through and drag a couple of them to today and then I have a nice little

3:37:58thing that I can make a small window out of with like four or five things that I can reasonably

3:38:02- Yeah, I mean to me it's a hard problem to solve

3:38:07with to-do apps because you're trying,

3:38:15I said this on ATP too, you're trying to basically

3:38:17codify people's mental systems, their mental models

3:38:21for how they want things to be done,

3:38:23and everyone wants it to be done differently.

3:38:26That's why it's really hard for anybody to ever be

3:38:29more than like 70% satisfied with their to-do app.

3:38:33And that's why people like try different ones

3:38:35and are oftentimes just kind of bounce between them.

3:38:38And like it isn't the fault of the apps,

3:38:40like it isn't that everyone who designs to-do apps

3:38:42is an idiot, it's that it's not really

3:38:45a generalizable problem.

3:38:47Like the only way you can really get to have a to-do app

3:38:51that is perfect for the way you want to do things

3:38:53is usually to just write your own,

3:38:54which is probably why there's so damn many of them.

3:38:57- There's a couple of categories of apps like this,

3:38:59like Notes apps and Calendar apps and contact,

3:39:04address book apps, whatever you wanna call the category.

3:39:06And people have strong opinions about them

3:39:09and people have strong opinions about the system ones

3:39:12or the Microsoft ones or whatever.

3:39:14And our email clients probably qualifies as this too, right?

3:39:18The sort of app that's sort of like,

3:39:20everybody needs something like this.

3:39:22But the, I don't know, like I said,

3:39:24what do you think of things as?

3:39:25as a task manager, a to-do app, a reminder app.

3:39:30- I just call this whole thing to-do apps.

3:39:32And I don't know if that's--

3:39:33- I feel like it's the one that is the least,

3:39:37it's the least naturally,

3:39:41here's the natural way to do it.

3:39:43And like you said, it's the one that is the most dependent

3:39:46on everybody's unique, weird mental model

3:39:49of how am I gonna, you know, what am I gonna do today?

3:39:53and how do I think of tasks and to-dos and stuff?

3:39:57Whereas the basic concept of an address book

3:40:00is kind of well-defined,

3:40:02and you're just sort of making an efficient way

3:40:04to access ones that are already there,

3:40:07do things with the ones that are already there,

3:40:09like send an email from the contact

3:40:11based on the email that's already there,

3:40:12and how to create a new one.

3:40:14Whereas the task management thing,

3:40:16like where's the division between projects and items

3:40:20and notes within items is all so mushy.

3:40:24It's so dissatisfying.

3:40:26- Yeah, and it's so hard to accommodate

3:40:30what so many people want.

3:40:31Like, a lot of people want something

3:40:32that lets them practice GTD.

3:40:34A lot of people want something that is GTD-like,

3:40:36but not quite GTD.

3:40:38A lot of people want some other methodology.

3:40:41There's so many different methodologies

3:40:42of how you're supposed to manage things that you need to do.

3:40:45And they change.

3:40:47Like, every few years, a new one comes out

3:40:48people want to try or want to practice.

3:40:50And again, it's just a really hard problem

3:40:54to generalize into a sellable product

3:40:57that can sell to anywhere near a decent number of people

3:41:01to justify the pretty large amount of work

3:41:03that these things take to actually be nice apps

3:41:05available on all of the platforms and things like that.

3:41:09So it's a tough problem.

3:41:11Things is pretty good, so I'm happy with it.

3:41:13Again, it isn't like a perfect fit,

3:41:16but it's close enough and it's better than the other ones

3:41:18for me, so there we go. - So, true story,

3:41:20Vesper started out as a to-do app.

3:41:22- Yeah, actually, this is when me and Koi Vin

3:41:27took the train to visit you. - Yeah, yeah, yeah.

3:41:29I forgot that you knew that.

3:41:30I forgot about that.

3:41:31We talked about doing that together.

3:41:33And it even started out as a to-do app

3:41:35with me and Brent and Dave.

3:41:36And then because of reasons like this,

3:41:39we were like, you know what, this would be a lot easier,

3:41:40and it'd still be useful as a notes app.

3:41:43And we would eliminate all of these very tricky,

3:41:47hard to solve problems.

3:41:48So the other thing too is that this is also the main reason

3:41:51why I still carry around like a little pocket size notebook,

3:41:54usually Field Notes brand in my back pocket

3:41:57is on a daily basis for quote unquote today,

3:42:01I just, my quote unquote system is to open up

3:42:05a new two page spread in a notebook,

3:42:07write the date at the top on the left side,

3:42:10write anything truly important on that left side

3:42:13and anything else on the right side.

3:42:16And every day I just turn a new page

3:42:18and I'll look back on the previous page

3:42:20and see if I forgot anything important.

3:42:22And if I did, write it down again on the new page.

3:42:25- That's a little too manual for me.

3:42:30- It is very manual.

3:42:30And a benefit to the manual nature,

3:42:32and the cheat, the lazy thing I do,

3:42:34is some days if I haven't been busy,

3:42:36I'll just use the, I won't start a new page.

3:42:38I'll just work on yesterday's until it looks like a mess

3:42:42'cause I've crossed stuff off.

3:42:43But the advantage to rewriting it

3:42:45is it's a little bit of an anti-procrastination hack

3:42:48where it's like, maybe instead of writing this down again,

3:42:51I should just do it.

3:42:53You know, like call the dentist.

3:42:54Like, rather than--

3:42:56- The funny thing is, like, I think you actually

3:42:58might be practicing some rudimentary form of GTD there.

3:43:00- I might be, I don't know.

3:43:01(laughing)

3:43:02- If you call that a review, I don't know.

3:43:05I haven't read the book, but I think that might be part of it.

3:43:08- But that's why I've always done it.

3:43:10Anyway, I thought it was interesting

3:43:11to hear you talk about it.

3:43:12such a weird software problem. It feels to me the reason that I it feels to me like the

3:43:18one that software should be able to do better than any paper system compared to all these

3:43:22other things like an address like a Rolodex or a paper calendar or whatever but I think

3:43:28in truth it's actually the one that software is the least better than doing it on paper

3:43:32then.

3:43:33Yeah because you know software has a lot of flexibility in what it can allow you to do

3:43:40Like you can, for instance, like you can move stuff around much more easily.

3:43:43You can index where things are. You can have the concept of like tags where you can have an entry show up in multiple places automatically.

3:43:51Where, you know, those things are hard to do with paper.

3:43:53But the problem is with software, like as soon as you codify anything into software, you are by nature excluding other things, other ways you could be doing it or other things you could do with it.

3:44:05Whereas the paper, it accommodates whatever system

3:44:09you want to do, as long as what you want to do

3:44:11can be represented in the analog world.

3:44:13It accommodates that.

3:44:14And you can change it and you can make little exceptions.

3:44:17You can draw an arrow between this thing and this other thing

3:44:19or you can draw it kind of sideways and explain this in a way.

3:44:22And software never has that kind of flexibility.

3:44:25It has other types of flexibility,

3:44:27like moving and copying and syncing and tagging

3:44:29and things like that.

3:44:30But the way you lay out your own thoughts,

3:44:34it's very hard to have software

3:44:36for the kind of flexibility that actually,

3:44:39that people actually want with that.

3:44:40- Yeah, and I think that's the best way to put it,

3:44:41and we can wrap up with that.

3:44:42But that is the problem, is that this app category,

3:44:46to-do apps, is trying to map your thoughts

3:44:50in a way that other things aren't, right?

3:44:52The model for things in, for me, that I wanna do

3:44:55is mostly thoughts, thoughts I wanna complete,

3:44:58whereas a calendar event, I know what that is.

3:45:02that actually maps very well to a computer data structure.

3:45:05And thoughts really don't, at least my thoughts don't.

3:45:09Anyway, Marco Arment, thank you for your time.

3:45:11This is, it's long, it's way too long.

3:45:14It's always too long when you're on.

3:45:15That's probably why I should have you on more frequently.

3:45:18If I had you on more frequently, maybe we would be.

3:45:20Although I have Ben Thompson on a little bit more frequency

3:45:22and he tends to keep my attention long too.

3:45:25- I'm just glad that I believe I have now finally passed

3:45:29Craig Federighi and the number of appearances

3:45:32Well, that's a good benchmark.

3:45:34I think we were tied before.

3:45:35He caught up quick.

3:45:36He was on a couple times last year.

3:45:37He did, yeah.

3:45:38Exactly.

3:45:39I want to thank our sponsors, new sponsor, Tres Pontas, coffee maker.

3:45:45I'll be interested.

3:45:48There's a little bit of time travel involved where I don't know yet, but you'll know.

3:45:53You know by the time you hear me thanking them what I think of their coffee.

3:45:57makers of very, very, very good, very easy to set up Wi-Fi equipment and Squarespace,

3:46:04where you go to set up a new website.

3:46:06People can—I can't believe there's anybody listening to this show who doesn't know that Marco Arment does a podcast called ATP with John Syracuse and Casey Liss at ATP.fm.

3:46:18And most of you are probably listening to it.

3:46:20In fact, I'm almost nearly 100% certain

3:46:23that a majority of you are listening to it

3:46:24using Marco's podcast app Overcast,

3:46:28which is also, I believe, an FM domain, right?

3:46:31Overcast.fm?

3:46:32- That's right.

3:46:35The wonderful, expensive,

3:46:37Federated States of Micronesia domain names.

3:46:39- And if we wanna throw in an extra shout out,

3:46:44we could, I just saw it tonight before we started recording

3:46:47that your wife Tiff has a new podcast of her own

3:46:51with Mike Hurley, right?

3:46:54A video game podcast.

3:46:55What's it called?

3:46:56- Yep, it's called Playing for Fun.

3:46:59It's on the Real AFM network and it's nice.

3:47:01It's a great take on games.

3:47:03It's basically like only the fun stuff,

3:47:05only the positive stuff.

3:47:06Like just games that they just love,

3:47:08not getting into like criticism and critiques,

3:47:11like industry discussions.

3:47:12Like just fun, just enjoying a fun game.

3:47:15Like it's a great refreshing take.

3:47:17And I listened to the first episode today,

3:47:19but it came out and it's really great.

3:47:21I am a little bit biased, but it's pretty great.

3:47:23- You know that Mike Hurley,

3:47:24you know he's a big phony, right?

3:47:26(laughing)

3:47:28You know he doesn't, the British accent fake.

3:47:31He grew up in Tennessee.

3:47:33- Yeah, that's-- - Honest to God truth.

3:47:38I mean he comes across as a nice enough fellow,

3:47:40but he's a big phony.

3:47:44I also promoted these on ATP this week

3:47:47and I want to promote them here too.

3:47:48Two awesome podcasts.

3:47:50One of them is called The Menu Bar.

3:47:52It's a new podcast that has some really insightful criticism

3:47:56and thought provoking questions about the tech business.

3:48:00Some of it's Apple focused.

3:48:01Honestly, most of it isn't.

3:48:02And I was actually on it.

3:48:04My episode's gonna come out,

3:48:05I think about the same time as this.

3:48:07And we talked a little bit about Apple

3:48:09and honestly a lot of other stuff.

3:48:10Facebook, Twitter, stuff like that.

3:48:12And I think it's pretty good.

3:48:13And then I also wanted to promote the season just ended

3:48:17of Mark Bramhill's wonderful podcast, Welcome to Macintosh.

3:48:22And the whole season is great.

3:48:25It's the second season he's done.

3:48:26It's like what you'd expect if like something

3:48:30with the like budget and skill and production value

3:48:34of 99% Invisible maybe, did a show about like

3:48:38Mac nerd stuff.

3:48:39Like that's how good this show is.

3:48:41And the last episode just aired

3:48:42and it's about, it was an interview with the founder

3:48:45of iFixit, and talking a lot about like, you know,

3:48:48the problems of e-waste and recycling and stuff,

3:48:50and it's very thought-provoking, very well done,

3:48:52very interesting, and the whole season is great,

3:48:54so definitely check out the Menu Bar,

3:48:56and welcome to Mackintosh.

3:48:58In addition to my wife's awesome new podcast.

3:49:00- I'm halfway through the Menu Bar episode

3:49:03with Bob Burroughs, and it's episode two.

3:49:07- That was controversial.

3:49:08- Was it?

3:49:09Well, I'm halfway through,

3:49:10and I didn't get the controversy.

3:49:11I get the impression that people inside of Apple

3:49:16did not appreciate that very much,

3:49:19but I thought it was interesting.

3:49:20Again, I said on ATP too,

3:49:23if you're tired of me complaining about Apple,

3:49:25this is not that.

3:49:28Their critique of Apple is very differently done,

3:49:29and in my opinion, I think it's more interesting

3:49:32than on me complaining about people.

3:49:35I don't know Bob other than through Twitter.

3:49:35Bob Burrow was an electrical engineer in manage,

3:49:38I think he was electrical engineering, it seemed like it.

3:49:40An engineering manager at Apple working on the iPhone

3:49:43and I guess iPad.

3:49:44I think he started just after the iPhone was announced,

3:49:49so like early 2007 and I think he was there

3:49:53seven or eight years.

3:49:54Some pretty interesting stories.

3:49:57Not surprised that it maybe didn't go over so well

3:50:01inside Apple, it doesn't seem like he's setting himself up

3:50:03to return to Apple, like a lot of people leave Apple,

3:50:07something else for three or four years. But you know, I think he's very comfortable with

3:50:13that as well and it does not also does not seem to me at least that he's stirring up

3:50:19shit you know unnecessarily. It seems to me like he's just being honest and giving his

3:50:23honest opinion and experience. You know, but it's unusual because it seems like the cone

3:50:32of silence from Apple employees generally extends even after they've stopped working

3:50:37for the company. And there's no, not for legal reasons or for job security reasons,

3:50:41but it's just the culture. And, you know, so I guess I'm not surprised that didn't

3:50:46go over. Anyway, it's a great, it is a great show. And, and, uh, welcome to Macintosh.

3:50:50I love, I feel like I don't mention that enough. It's sort of the inverse of the talk show,

3:50:56especially this rambling three hour show after this welcome to Macintosh is so tightly edited.

3:51:04It is absolutely a leave you wanting more type show.

3:51:08I'm a little behind on this season as well,

3:51:12but episodes are often like 20 minutes.

3:51:14They're great little small doses.

3:51:16They're super well produced.

3:51:18I loved the one with Panic earlier in the season.

3:51:21It might have been the season opener.

3:51:22Anyway.

3:51:24- And he gets great interviews too.

3:51:25It's usually an interview show and it's really, really good

3:51:29and just produced and put together so well

3:51:31Gets great guests and and I like travels to different places like so it isn't just like a Skype call with somebody like you like

3:51:38You know the way we do our show is like it's it's like really a very very high production value show about nerdy max stuff

3:51:44It's a couple years ago in person when I hosted

3:51:49Rick Tetzel e and Brent

3:51:52What's his forget his last name cheese

3:51:57Yeah, that'd be Steve Jobs

3:51:59right

3:52:01at New York's Apple Store.

3:52:04They, Brent Schlender were the two co-authors

3:52:08of an excellent book.

3:52:09And I was invited to host them

3:52:11for like an hour long interview at the,

3:52:14I think it was the Soho Apple Store,

3:52:15I forget which one it is,

3:52:16whichever one's in Southern Manhattan.

3:52:18And Mark Bramhill, I think he was only like 19 at the time.

3:52:23I don't know, he was really young,

3:52:23but he and his dad were doing like a cross country road trip.

3:52:26And I only announced it on Daring Fireball like that day

3:52:29'cause I was kind of worried that,

3:52:31and it actually happened, and it was standing room only,

3:52:34even with minimal promotion from by me

3:52:36'cause it's a limited space.

3:52:37And he and his dad just happened to be driving

3:52:40cross country, and they were in New York at the time,

3:52:42and so made it to the show.

3:52:44So just out of the pure coincidence

3:52:46that it was their day on a cross country drive

3:52:48where they were going through New York, they were there.

3:52:51And I'd already been in contact with them over the internet,

3:52:53and I was a terrific fan of his wonderful work.

3:52:56And I love that somebody as young as he is

3:52:58is enamored with old 1984 style Macintosh UI design

3:53:03and fonts and stuff like that.

3:53:05So that was terrific.

3:53:08Anyway, that's my Mark Bramhall story.

3:53:10He's a really good kid.

3:53:13- It's a great show.

3:53:13- And his, he reminds me of Cable Sasser in a way

3:53:16where he's just got like an enthusiasm and an optimism

3:53:19and it makes me feel like more of a misanthrope

3:53:22than I usually feel like.

3:53:26- Yeah, I have a feeling he's gonna have

3:53:29a nice long career in this stuff.

3:53:30- Oh my God, he's so talented.

3:53:31And he has such a great attention to detail.

3:53:33That's the thing.

3:53:34He really sweats every little,

3:53:36you can just tell when you listen to the show.

3:53:37My God, it's really, really good.

3:53:40Anyway, Marco Arment, why'd you keep me up so late?