Podcast Search

The Talk Show

214: ‘Only Wireless. Less Smart Than an Echo. Lame.’ With Paul Kafasis

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00[DRUM ROLL]

0:00:03[MUSIC PLAYING]

0:00:06Oh, yeah, I love it.

0:00:07I love that beat.

0:00:08Good.

0:00:11God, this is going to be a nightmare to edit.

0:00:13[LAUGHTER]

0:00:16Sorry, Caleb.

0:00:18Good thing neither of us are editing the show.

0:00:20[LAUGHTER]

0:00:22Paul Kefasis is back on the show,

0:00:24co-founder of Rokomiba Software.

0:00:27Paul, you've been on the show many times.

0:00:28I don't think you've been on in quite some time.

0:00:31- I think I was on some kind of a list.

0:00:33I'm not sure what I did.

0:00:35I didn't rip up a picture of the Pope or anything,

0:00:37but I don't know what I did, but I'm back.

0:00:40- All right, let me see here.

0:00:40I've got a list of former guests.

0:00:44This is episode 214.

0:00:46You were just on, you were on episode 112.

0:00:49(laughing)

0:00:50- Well, we should have waited 10 more episodes.

0:00:52We could have doubled the number.

0:00:54- Or we should have done it two episodes ago

0:00:55and made it a centennial.

0:00:57Oh, there you go.

0:00:58- Yeah, I don't know.

0:01:00Well, I don't know what took so long.

0:01:01I will have to speak to the scheduler,

0:01:03but it is good to have you back.

0:01:05And it's not a complete coincidence.

0:01:07We're celebrating the release of a new rogue Amoeba app,

0:01:10Farago, am I pronouncing that correctly?

0:01:12- You are.

0:01:14- F-A-R-R-A-G-O.

0:01:17- That's right.

0:01:19- And where does the name come from?

0:01:20- Well, it's actually a word that means,

0:01:23it's a word that nobody knows.

0:01:24It's an English word that means basically

0:01:26sort of a melange or a jumble or, you know, just an assortment of things.

0:01:31We were, you know, toying around with a whole bunch of different names as I'm

0:01:36sure anyone who's named anything has experience with you, you try everything.

0:01:39The Mac OS X dictionary says it's a confused mixture.

0:01:44Yeah, it's got slightly negative connotations, so it's not quite like, you

0:01:49know, a medley, but most people don't know the word, so we're hoping to get away with it.

0:01:54All right.

0:01:54any app, it's a Mac app that is a soundboard app.

0:01:58And if you don't know what a soundboard app is,

0:02:00a soundboard app is, that's my handing it off to you.

0:02:03- Oh, I mean, it's the perfect thing for, you know, just,

0:02:07(dramatic music)

0:02:09basically if you want any sort of audio effects

0:02:12in your audio, you're recording a podcast

0:02:15and you just wanna have some great sound effects like,

0:02:17(imitates sound effects)

0:02:19(burps)

0:02:20- I really think this is just what my show needs, I do.

0:02:23I think you need to get 10 times as many sound effects as you have now,

0:02:28and that's really going to draw the listeners in.

0:02:31>> I think it'll greatly reduce the complaints about the speed at which I speak and the number

0:02:38of times I pause before speaking. Marco --

0:02:42>> If you can just toss in sound effects any time you need a break, yeah.

0:02:45>> I've long suspected that Marco added that smart speed thing just for my show.

0:02:49>> For you? Solely for you.

0:02:51[laughs]

0:02:52Right.

0:02:53It should be like the talk show, the Gruber filter.

0:02:55Just take out the long pauses.

0:02:58And now we can fill them with farts.

0:02:59Absolutely.

0:03:00Well, so we were talking about this before the show, and I pulled up, you know, half

0:03:06a dozen, couple dozen different audio effects to fiddle around with.

0:03:10So I got to figure out how to sprinkle them in lightly.

0:03:13I don't want to go too nuts with it.

0:03:14Right.

0:03:15But the idea here is not just that you can play sounds at any point, but you've obviously,

0:03:21everybody listening can hear. You've piped it into the audio pipeline that you're recording.

0:03:26You know, it's, you know, and that's, we could talk about it, just for people who aren't familiar,

0:03:33some of the other apps, or what Amoeba has, that's right up your alley. But then, you know,

0:03:38so at a technical level, you got to understand the way sound works on a Mac. But I think more

0:03:44importantly is that it has gorgeous user interface. Effectively, I you know, correct me if you

0:03:51if you think, you know, you've obviously put tons of thought in this and I've put about

0:03:54five minutes into like looking at it and saying cool. But in effect, it is sort of like a

0:04:02user interface design app for people who need to play sounds at a moment's notice. So you

0:04:08You can arrange, pick the sounds you need,

0:04:11arrange them in the way you want them to be

0:04:14or that makes logical sense to you,

0:04:17maybe not to anybody else,

0:04:18but you can pick this logical order

0:04:19and you have a big visual interface

0:04:21and you can color code the sounds by category or whatever

0:04:25and you've got these big click targets.

0:04:28So it's not like a little tiny thing you have to do.

0:04:30So if you really wanna play a sound right away,

0:04:32it's got a big Fitz's Law target as they would say.

0:04:37Yeah, and also the way we sort of anticipate people to be using it is via the keyboard.

0:04:42So everything's mapped right to your keyboard. So it sort of turns your keyboard into basically

0:04:47like a sample machine.

0:04:48Right.

0:04:49So if you're looking at the visual on screen and you say, "Okay, I know what I need,"

0:04:53and you can see what key you need to hit right away. So that's, it's certainly playable

0:04:57via the mouse, but the keyboard is really the sort of the primary way to use it, I think.

0:05:01And by default, like when you first run the app, does F map to FART?

0:05:05>> Our sample set actually does not have a fart sound in it. I had to download that separately.

0:05:12You know, we've got the -- you know, we've got all sorts of -- we came up with -- I'm trying to

0:05:22look at our sample set. I think it's 25 sounds. And we were scouring the internet to find good

0:05:28sounds and to find things that we wanted. And some of the feedback I got after the app was

0:05:32was released, probably about a dozen different people said, "Oh, this is great. It just needs

0:05:37X sound, and it's like fart noise it needs. It needs a toilet flush." So really, we need

0:05:42another sample pack of the really goofy or juvenile noises that we did not include in

0:05:47the first go-round.

0:05:48I had a brainstorm, and as usual, it came way too late. We started recording roughly

0:05:56an hour and 20 minutes after I told you we would be starting to record. I had an eye

0:06:02doctor appointment that ran late, and various other shenanigans going on here in the city

0:06:07of Philadelphia, which we will get to in a bit.

0:06:10And of course, so an hour and 20 minutes after we were set to record as I come down to the

0:06:14podcast cave, shuffling my various beverages and trying not to trip and fall, I suddenly

0:06:21realized what we should have loaded the soundboard up with.

0:06:23And it's clips of my wife laughing on just the tip.

0:06:28and we could make it sound as though she was here with us and just loving what we're saying.

0:06:38Just dying of laughter every step of the way.

0:06:40Which probably would have driven her nuts.

0:06:46Because I mean, when she listens to the show, all she hears is [sad trombone sound]

0:06:51Yeah, pretty much.

0:06:54If you could make her look a fool, that'd be pretty good.

0:06:57Yeah, that would have been pretty good. Anyway, as usual, a dollar a day late and a dollar short.

0:07:02Forago, Forago? Forago? Forago came out two weeks ago, right?

0:07:09John "Slick" Baum: Two weeks ago today, actually.

0:07:11Pete: How's it doing?

0:07:12John "Slick" Baum I haven't bought a boat yet. So,

0:07:16if the listeners are intrigued, get your 1000 copies and then I can each and then I can get my

0:07:24boat. Pete I know the answer to this question, but I'm going to ask it as

0:07:27though I don't. Direct download, direct purchase, Mac App Store, or both?

0:07:33>> Direct download for free trial, as with all of our software. Direct purchase from our store.

0:07:40And this app actually could potentially be in the Mac App Store, but it is not in the Mac App Store.

0:07:44I mean, I don't know how deep you want to get into this, but we've had two applications in the Mac

0:07:49App Store, and we pulled one of them out because the changes that they made in terms of the rules

0:07:55in the Mac App Store made it not viable to stay there.

0:07:58And so we have one remaining app.

0:08:00- That app was Piezo, right?

0:08:02- Yep, so that's our simple audio recorder,

0:08:04which is actually the recorder that I'm using right now,

0:08:06because my version of Audio Hijack was all,

0:08:09eh, let's just call it messed up.

0:08:11So that was in the Mac App Store,

0:08:14specifically to make it possible to have a recorder

0:08:17that was, that skirted the, sorry,

0:08:20that followed the rules of the Mac App Store.

0:08:23And then those rules changed,

0:08:25and so we eventually had to pull it out because the app was not able to be updated. So we said,

0:08:31all right, we'd rather have a functioning app, a properly functioning app that is available directly

0:08:37than a crippled app that is also in the Mac App Store.

0:08:39Ted

0:08:51connection, file serving connection stuff, effectively had to be pulled at one point

0:08:57from Mac App Store, even though it's an acclaimed app.

0:09:01It's an FTP and a web editor. I mean, like, you wouldn't think this sort of thing would

0:09:05run afoul of App Store rules, but here we are.

0:09:09But you've written publicly, I believe, about Piezo's success after being just going direct

0:09:15download, direct sale only, right?

0:09:17>> Yeah, absolutely. So, I actually just this afternoon, we posted a review of last year, 2017,

0:09:23and I was rereading the post that you're referring to. It was a post from February of last year, just

0:09:27about a year ago. And two years ago is when we pulled Piazzo out of the Mac App Store. And so,

0:09:32after a year, I compared our revenue from the year, the last year when it was in the Mac App

0:09:38Store and the first year when it was no longer in the Mac App Store. And the result was that we

0:09:42actually earned more revenue because our sales were -- our raw unit sales were slightly down,

0:09:49but the difference was not so great that we didn't earn more revenue because Apple takes 30 percent

0:09:54of every sale that you get in the Mac App Store. And when we sell it directly, we're getting

0:10:00somewhere around 95 percent of the revenue. So, it's not terribly difficult to make more money,

0:10:06even if you have slightly lower sales. You're probably going to earn more money on those sales.

0:10:11So and as you're where we are, as usual, many caveats apply that the rules for games might

0:10:19be entirely different than for utilities like piezo.

0:10:26But the bottom line is that the Mac App Store, wherever it is on the scale of zero to 100

0:10:33as a success for the Mac development community, it is absolute I think I can't I think it's

0:10:40undeniably not at the point where it is eating the non Mac App Store market. If anything,

0:10:49the non Mac App Store market is as strong as ever. Like, well, and I think has has started to eat

0:10:57some of the App Store. Because you mentioned you mentioned panic and we pulled an app out and you

0:11:02know, I'd have to look back but there's you can probably find a good dozen fairly major apps.

0:11:06the app store that then left, exactly, just like that.

0:11:11- Right, right.

0:11:12I should try to find it.

0:11:15Rich Segal, founder of BB, co-founder of BB Edit,

0:11:19Bearbound Software, had a great talk at Singleton,

0:11:22but got-- - At Singleton,

0:11:23his Max Q talk, yeah.

0:11:24- Yeah, but Singleton, how many years ago was that?

0:11:26Jeez.

0:11:27- I think it's probably about three or four.

0:11:30- At least, so it's not even that recent.

0:11:32And it was a great talk because effectively,

0:11:35It was like a half hour talk about why he took BB Edit out of the Mac App Store and

0:11:40went back to Direct Downloads.

0:11:42And I don't even want to try to summarize it because what made it such a great talk

0:11:46was it really did take half an hour for him to make his point.

0:11:50And, you know, and that's there.

0:11:52I won't summarize it either, but it's right.

0:11:54I'm sure you can find a link and it's definitely worth a watch if you're at all interested

0:11:57in the Mac App Store or leaving the Mac App Store.

0:12:00Right.

0:12:01peak Mac App Store was early on in the days of App Store.

0:12:05And one of the fears a lot of us had was that,

0:12:08man, if the Mac App Store really takes off,

0:12:11and Mac users just abandon direct downloads

0:12:14and outside the Mac App Store payments

0:12:18and only buy stuff from the App Store,

0:12:21it really, it's not about the 30%,

0:12:24or certainly not only about the 30%,

0:12:27but it's just about, boy, would that make people

0:12:30whose livelihood depends on selling independent Mac App Store

0:12:32feel uncomfortable about having their entire livelihood

0:12:37in a store that is clearly never going to be better

0:12:41than the second favorite at Apple.

0:12:43- Right, absolutely.

0:12:45Yeah, the iOS App Store is clearly what they're focused on

0:12:48and the Mac App Store sort of seemed like,

0:12:50hey, we did this on the phone,

0:12:52so we might as well try it on the Mac.

0:12:54And I think you made a great point that, let's see,

0:12:57I think it's been, was it 2010 or 2011

0:12:59that the Mac App Store came out.

0:13:01I don't want to screw it up.

0:13:03It was one of those two, I'm fairly certain.

0:13:06But it was quite a while ago at this point.

0:13:07And when it came out, everyone said,

0:13:09"Okay, let's get in there."

0:13:10The iOS App Store has been such a success.

0:13:13Let's get in there and this will get our app

0:13:15in front of everyone.

0:13:16And I think a lot of apps did get in there

0:13:19and then over time realized, you know what?

0:13:21This isn't doing a whole lot for us

0:13:23and it's taking a decent chunk of both our money

0:13:26and our energy.

0:13:27And that's when you've seen apps sort of peel back.

0:13:30And like you said, the peak was early on.

0:13:33And I think since then it's been fairly slow.

0:13:37And there certainly hasn't been any major app that I've seen

0:13:40that has only been in the Mac App Store.

0:13:42- Is Pixelmator Mac App Store only?

0:13:47- Ooh, that's a good question.

0:13:49It's certainly possible,

0:13:50but I would bet that they focus on the Mac App Store,

0:13:54but still have a direct download.

0:13:55- Anyway, your memory is excellent.

0:13:57the Mac App Store was announced at Apple's

0:13:59Back to the Mac event October 2010.

0:14:03That was the episode, that was the event

0:14:06where I believe Craig Federighi first appeared on stage

0:14:09and he had a sort of a shaky demo.

0:14:14- He's gotten much better at the on-stage performances.

0:14:20- Yeah, the backstory behind that wasn't really so much

0:14:24that he was nervous, but that there was like a last minute

0:14:28software change and he realized that it didn't work

0:14:31the way they thought it would.

0:14:32It was sort of like, you know, like the rule,

0:14:33like don't change anything in between rehearsals and demo.

0:14:37And it was like, they thought, well, we can change that.

0:14:39And then he realized on stage that

0:14:41we shouldn't have changed that.

0:14:42Anyway, he has gotten a little,

0:14:45he went from being like, wow,

0:14:46why did they put him on stage to,

0:14:48wow, he should be on TV, right?

0:14:50Anyway, October 20th, 2010 was when it was announced,

0:14:54They began taking submissions in November 2010,

0:14:57and then it launched in January 2011.

0:15:01So your 2010, 2011 confusion was actually more accurate

0:15:04than picking one or the other.

0:15:06- Yeah, and you're right.

0:15:07I was just looking at Pixelmator Pro is,

0:15:10it looks like only in the Mac App Store.

0:15:11So that is certainly one that is sort of,

0:15:15the exception that proves the rule maybe.

0:15:17- Well, it's a complicated story.

0:15:20I think Sketch is in there.

0:15:21I don't think Sketch is only Mac App Store,

0:15:23but it is-- - No, it's definitely not.

0:15:25Sketch definitely isn't.

0:15:26- Yeah, well, it's worked out in a weird way.

0:15:30I don't wanna spend too much time on the Mac App Store here,

0:15:32but it just seems like, gosh, now we're seven years in,

0:15:37and seven years in, it's sort of like a nowhere.

0:15:42You know, like it's not a failure,

0:15:45but it is absolutely not put a dent

0:15:47in the independent marketplace. - Not a success,

0:15:48or not a big success.

0:15:50- Right, it's just sort of weird.

0:15:52I don't think that was expected.

0:15:54- I don't wanna, you know, I'm not,

0:15:57I just looked at that one too.

0:15:58Sketch actually is one of the ones that left the store.

0:16:00- Oh, that's right, that's right.

0:16:01- That's what I remember.

0:16:02They're one of the fairly large ones that left.

0:16:04- That's right, because they wanted to switch

0:16:06to a subscription model that the app store

0:16:09doesn't really support or something like that.

0:16:11- Exactly. - Right.

0:16:13Yeah, that's right, that's right.

0:16:14That's why I knew that Sketch was on the--

0:16:17- There was something about it, exactly.

0:16:18- Yeah, something about it.

0:16:19- Well, so all of this is sort of tangential

0:16:23to what you originally asked.

0:16:25And, you know, Forago is something that fits

0:16:28within the confines of the App Store, at least currently.

0:16:30But for us as a developer, as developers,

0:16:34it has not been a priority to get it there.

0:16:37And I was looking back at a post from several years ago

0:16:41and somebody was saying, oh, you know,

0:16:42this isn't in the Mac App Store.

0:16:43You know, no one's gonna buy it, or I'm not gonna buy it.

0:16:45And you're crazy.

0:16:46This is where the puck is going, et cetera.

0:16:49and it was pretty amusing to read

0:16:51because that's not the way that it's worked out.

0:16:54And fortunately for us, we've been able to continue

0:16:56selling this stuff directly.

0:16:58- I mean, there's a part of it.

0:17:00I've been in the racket, as they say,

0:17:02and I understand the...

0:17:04When you're on the side where Apple's taking 30%

0:17:10from the price you set for the app you made,

0:17:12it feels a little high.

0:17:17But I totally understand from the user's point of view,

0:17:20'cause I personally still enjoy buying apps

0:17:22from the Mac App Store,

0:17:23because I love the simplicity of knowing,

0:17:26if I bought it from the Mac App Store,

0:17:27there's one place to go to redownload it

0:17:29on a different machine, or, you know what I mean?

0:17:33There's just one central place to check for that.

0:17:36And that is very convenient, and I do trust it,

0:17:39and I know I'm not gonna get spam

0:17:40from the developer afterwards.

0:17:43Not that I buy a lot of apps that I suspect

0:17:44I'm gonna get spam from the developer for,

0:17:46but I understand the convenience of it, but.

0:17:49- No, absolutely.

0:17:50And it's certainly something where,

0:17:52it's not something we shied away from.

0:17:54And we've mentioned that 30% a bunch.

0:17:56That was never a sole reason to avoid it

0:17:59or anything like that.

0:17:59It's a high number, but it's not so high that you'd say,

0:18:02well, the heck with that.

0:18:03But that coupled with a half dozen other issues

0:18:07that you face as a developer

0:18:08makes it a whole lot less appealing right now.

0:18:10And it's not something where like iOS,

0:18:12you have to be there to get to users.

0:18:14So, fortunately we can avoid it.

0:18:17- All right, let me take a break here

0:18:18and thank our first sponsor.

0:18:19You are never gonna believe who it is,

0:18:21it is our good friend.

0:18:22- It's the Mac App Store.

0:18:23- It's the Mac App Store.

0:18:25Squarespace.

0:18:26Look, it's the new year.

0:18:28It still counts as new year in early February.

0:18:31And if you, people, you know, I think it's cliche

0:18:33that people make resolutions

0:18:35and they're setting out to do new things.

0:18:37But I think it's true.

0:18:38I think it's absolutely true that it's, you know,

0:18:40the winter time is the time you reflect.

0:18:42You think, hey, I wanna set out,

0:18:43I've got this project I've always been wanting to make.

0:18:46Something like that.

0:18:47Or you wanna redo like a website you already have.

0:18:50Squarespace is a fantastic platform to go try it out on.

0:18:57First, it's terrific.

0:18:58Second, it has unbelievable design features.

0:19:03And third, they do it all.

0:19:06They do the hosting.

0:19:08They do the,

0:19:12You could do domain registration there.

0:19:15They have their own stats and analytics package.

0:19:20And I've seen it.

0:19:22And the presentation is so good.

0:19:23Because it's not just about-- like with analytics,

0:19:27it's not just like, do you have all this XYZ information?

0:19:30It's how is it presented to you?

0:19:32Does it make any sense?

0:19:33I'll tell you the truth.

0:19:34I still use Google Analytics during Fireball.

0:19:37I honestly don't understand how to use it.

0:19:39I've been using it for like seven years.

0:19:41And I go in there.

0:19:42and I honest to God feel like I'm reading Greek

0:19:44or something like that.

0:19:45It's terrible.

0:19:46Everything at Squarespace is so easy.

0:19:48It is so clearly made from a company

0:19:52that values good design every step of the way.

0:19:55Not just in terms of you having a good website

0:19:58that looks well designed,

0:19:59but that everything,

0:20:01when your billing interface is well designed,

0:20:03your backend stats interface is well designed.

0:20:07It's just so clear sometimes

0:20:10when a company only values design

0:20:12at the very, very front end,

0:20:15customer facing part of their business,

0:20:17and they don't care about it

0:20:19at the rest of the way down the line.

0:20:20Squarespace is a company that is all about design,

0:20:24really is.

0:20:25When you get started at Squarespace,

0:20:28you can start with a free trial,

0:20:29and you can build the site,

0:20:31there's no limits to it,

0:20:32you can build everything.

0:20:33There's no catch on the free trial

0:20:37other than that it eventually ends.

0:20:39And you can just go to squarespace.com to get started.

0:20:43And when you do sign up to pay,

0:20:45that's the point when you wanna remember this code,

0:20:47talk show at checkout, and you can get 10% off.

0:20:52Start your free trial today at squarespace.com

0:20:55and when you decide to sign up,

0:20:56just remember that code, talk show,

0:20:58and you get 10% off your first purchase,

0:21:00including a purchase for up to a year of service,

0:21:02so you can get like 10% of a year off, big bucks.

0:21:07So my thanks to Squarespace.

0:21:08(laughing)

0:21:11I've got some follow up.

0:21:15I've got some important follow up from last week's episode,

0:21:18episode 213 with John Moltz,

0:21:21who hadn't been on for a long time either.

0:21:23I mentioned, there was a podcast a few years back.

0:21:29Do you remember the show, Paul,

0:21:30it was called You Look Nice Today?

0:21:32- I am familiar.

0:21:33- It's a show, I figured you would be.

0:21:35It's a show that was the,

0:21:37was actually, this is actually, people don't know this, it was actually the first podcast.

0:21:43These three lads invented podcasting a little over 10 years ago, featuring Scott Simpson,

0:21:53Merlin Mann and Adam "Lonely Sandwich" Lisagor, all three of whom have been on this

0:21:58show I think a few times, including Scott, who happens to have been on a very special

0:22:05episode of this show that was recorded with you. It was me, you, and Scott Simpson.

0:22:12That's right. The Velocity Hotels episode.

0:22:15That was the Velocity Hotels episode. We came up with the idea. It was a fantastic idea that

0:22:19we never really followed up on. But we were going to—

0:22:21Well, now has been stolen.

0:22:23Now it's been stolen.

0:22:24I have lawyers working on this, but I don't know if we're going to see any money out of it.

0:22:29The idea, if you don't remember this in the Velocity Hotels episode,

0:22:34that we came up with the idea that, you know, why are hotels only fixed in fixed locations?

0:22:40And what if, you know, you're on a trip and you need to get from point A to point B,

0:22:44we stay in a hotel at point A, you get into good night's sleep, you wake up, and then you've still

0:22:50got to get to point B. Well, what if your hotel could be a bus, a large motorcoach, perhaps,

0:22:56but not like you're sleeping on like a Greyhound and just reclining in a chair, you'd get a nice

0:23:02little luxury seats sort of like those first class cabins on Emirates.

0:23:06Oh yeah, like a light flat bed.

0:23:07Yeah, and maybe there's a lobby bar in the back of the bus so before you tuck in you could have

0:23:13a nightcap. It was a fantastic idea. And the truth is, as you've pointed out, that there's

0:23:21some competitors. While we've been sitting on the idea, some competitors have come out.

0:23:24Do we have lawyers on this?

0:23:29I do. They I don't know exactly what they're doing.

0:23:33I got laughed at kind of a lot.

0:23:35So I'm not it's not clear if that was laughter as you know, they're going to take these people to the cleaners or I hope that's what it was.

0:23:43Well, anyway, while John Moltz was telling a story on the show last week about how he does not enjoy cherries,

0:23:50but he does enjoy cherries when they are soaked in bourbon and put into a cocktail, which does sound good.

0:23:57And I asked him, just for specificity, even though I knew, I kind of knew the answer.

0:24:02I suspected that he was talking about regular cherries.

0:24:04I wanted to make sure he didn't mean maraschino cherries, which are often used as a garnish

0:24:08in cocktails.

0:24:09And he said, "No, regular."

0:24:10And that reminded me of an episode of You Look Nice Today, and I brought it up, where

0:24:16the lads on You Look Nice Today were talking about a cocktail they invented just for the

0:24:21listeners of the show.

0:24:23And I conflated two cocktails, unfortunately, and that's what I need to follow up.

0:24:27I said it was called the Aunt Nancy,

0:24:29like your dad's sister Nancy, the Aunt Nancy,

0:24:33and that involved a fistful of maraschino cherries,

0:24:38ice, and top it off with Maker's Mark.

0:24:42Turns out that's not the Aunt Nancy.

0:24:46That was from a later episode of You Look Nice Today.

0:24:49That drink was called,

0:24:50they called the Shirley Temple of Doom.

0:24:53- I think there's some ginger ale in that, is there not?

0:24:55- Nope, that's the Aunt Nancy.

0:24:56The Aunt Nancy.

0:24:58- Oh, is that, okay, this is why you conflated it, I see.

0:25:00- Right, this is why I conflated it.

0:25:02The Aunt Nancy, in fact,

0:25:04and I will put this link in the show notes,

0:25:05there's a gentleman who runs a You Look Nice Today index,

0:25:10where he went back and re-listened to their episodes

0:25:12and indexed topics.

0:25:13Unfortunately, the Aunt Nancy,

0:25:16I happened to re-listen to the episode

0:25:19on the HomePod I've got upstairs, as a matter of fact.

0:25:22It was-- - I also gave it a listen

0:25:25because it was better than anything else that was going on.

0:25:28- It was ambiguously defined in the episode.

0:25:31But as best as anybody can determine,

0:25:35the Aunt Nancy is ginger ale and maker's mark,

0:25:38served with lots of cherries.

0:25:39- But also.

0:25:41- A plastic drink sword.

0:25:43You know those little swords they use to spear a garnish?

0:25:47So on one of those, you put a buffalo chicken wing,

0:25:53- Predipped in ranch dressing.

0:25:55And then a second sword kebab

0:25:57with eight, spearing eight mentos.

0:26:02And then you put that together and there you got it.

0:26:05That's the best definition anybody has of an aunt Nancy.

0:26:07The only required elements,

0:26:09this is sort of like when you're talking about

0:26:10like an old fashioned and you know,

0:26:13there's bourbon or rye.

0:26:15- 20 different variations on it.

0:26:16- Sugar and bitters.

0:26:19But then other variations on the old fashioned,

0:26:21Some will include a muddled up orange or cherry

0:26:23or something like that.

0:26:24The required parts are not the ginger ale or the maker's mark

0:26:29it's just the speared buffalo chicken wing

0:26:33pre-dipped in ranch dressing

0:26:34and the second sword of eight Mentos.

0:26:37And you could pretty much mix that with any alcohol

0:26:39that you wanted to

0:26:40and I think you could still call it an Aunt Nancy.

0:26:43And I also believe there's some ambiguity

0:26:46about whether you can also substitute a chicken tender

0:26:50Right, there was definitely a beauty about chicken finger versus chicken wing.

0:26:53Yeah.

0:26:54And I, while I was listening to this, I had to raise a couple objections because my parents are

0:27:00from Buffalo and they would roundly chastise me for not pointing out that it's a chicken wing,

0:27:04it's not a Buffalo wing. So, it's the Philly cheesesteak kind of thing. But, you know,

0:27:10my mom always makes sure to point out that Buffalo's do not have wings in case anyone is

0:27:15confused. And ranch dressing is all wrong. It's blue cheese or it's nothing. And then the third

0:27:23issue is I don't think you can spear Mentos. Mentos have a hard shell. So, this is a 10-year-old

0:27:32episode of a mildly popular podcast. But we are doing some deep cut criticism and critiquing of

0:27:41of it. Staring up some significant controversy. Absolutely. But I do I do want to praise them

0:27:47because in the episode, there was a reference to a domain, buttholevideo.com, which a decade

0:27:56later, almost one full decade later still leads to this episode. Buttholevideo.com.

0:28:05Buttholevideo.com. You know, click that and it will take you directly to this episode.

0:28:09I'll bet you 10 bucks Merlin registered the domain.

0:28:12Merlin is--

0:28:14- He's a domain hoarder.

0:28:15- And he's also very good at it.

0:28:17If by good you mean actually keeps them

0:28:20and keeps paying for them, perhaps--

0:28:22- For forever.

0:28:24- By some people's definitions,

0:28:26the people who are good at domains

0:28:27are the ones who forget the ones they've never used

0:28:30and stop paying for them, but--

0:28:32- I was gonna say I bought velocityhotels.com

0:28:35for that episode that we did.

0:28:37and I checked it and I have not been paying for it.

0:28:41So I guess it's a question of whether or not I'm good at it,

0:28:44but I have kept the 30 or $40 that I would have been paying.

0:28:49So my wallet thanks me at least.

0:28:51- So in the show notes for this episode,

0:28:54do I just leave buttholevideo.com as an item

0:28:57in the list of links without any explanation?

0:28:59I think I must.

0:29:00- No context, no context.

0:29:06- I also, and a minor correction on the Shirley Temple

0:29:08of Doom is that I believe the official definition

0:29:13is not a fistful of maraschino cherries,

0:29:17but instead a shitload of maraschino cherries.

0:29:20It's sort of like mixing up teaspoons and tablespoons.

0:29:25So you don't wanna get the wrong proportion.

0:29:26You want a shitload of maraschino cherries

0:29:29and Maker's Mark and I guess some ice and that's it.

0:29:32And that is the drink I have in fact seen Scott Simpson

0:29:35order several times.

0:29:37- Oh, frequently.

0:29:39But I'm looking at Merlin's picture

0:29:40of a Shirley Temple of Doom and there is ginger ale.

0:29:43So I think the Shirley Temple of Doom

0:29:44and the Aunt Nancy are remarkably similar,

0:29:47save for the speared meats and candies.

0:29:51- Yeah, and then I actually was trying to Google this

0:29:53and it's actually impossible to Google.

0:29:57You can get to the Aunt Nancy,

0:30:00even though usually most of the Google,

0:30:02like Aunt Nancy recipe,

0:30:03and it's seriously like somebody's Aunt Nancy's recipe

0:30:06for pumpkin pie.

0:30:07(laughing)

0:30:08And there's absolutely no.

0:30:10(laughing)

0:30:12There are no Mentos involved.

0:30:14Oh, and I should also mention,

0:30:16for those of you who are curious

0:30:17about the chicken wing garnish,

0:30:21that their idea for that is not necessarily

0:30:25that it's a flavor enhancer for the cocktail.

0:30:27It's something that while,

0:30:29like a mixed crowd of adults and children.

0:30:32- Right, it's a distraction.

0:30:33- Right, that you could, if mommy needs a moment,

0:30:36mommy needs a drink, she can order an Aunt Nancy

0:30:39and then take the chicken wing out

0:30:40and hand it to little Joey and he'll have something

0:30:43to keep him quiet.

0:30:44Anyway, which I think is a genius idea, quite frankly.

0:30:49Here's my point, if you Google Shirley Temple of Doom,

0:30:52there's a ton of people who've come up with,

0:30:54it's too obvious a name, the pun,

0:30:59I don't know what you call that

0:31:00when you connect Temple of Doom with Shirley Temple.

0:31:02And you Google it and there's actually an entire slew

0:31:05of people who've used this name to define a cocktail.

0:31:08And the cocktail, they bear no similarity whatsoever.

0:31:10They're just people who thought of the name.

0:31:13Whereas the Aunt Nancy to me is a genius name

0:31:15for a cocktail.

0:31:16And I kind of feel like,

0:31:18I kind of feel like it's up to me and you, Paul,

0:31:19to sort of,

0:31:20I kind of feel like this definition in the guy's index

0:31:25of you look nice today ought to become

0:31:26the official Aunt Nancy.

0:31:27Let's combine them together.

0:31:30We'll have ginger ale, Maker's Mark.

0:31:32I would just go with a splash of ginger ale, frankly.

0:31:35You don't wanna put a lot of ginger ale on a drink.

0:31:38- Mostly Maker's Mark is what we want.

0:31:40- Yeah, a splash of ginger ale, Maker's Mark,

0:31:45a shitload of cherries,

0:31:47a kebab with a buffalo chicken wing or small chicken finger.

0:31:52Now, do you think that we should say

0:31:55ranch dressing or blue cheese?

0:31:58- I wanna nix the ranch.

0:31:59- I say blue cheese or nothing.

0:32:01- All right, blue cheese or nothing.

0:32:02But remember this is for children.

0:32:04And blue cheese is a pretty strong flavor for children.

0:32:10- You make a good point.

0:32:12- I'm gonna say that--

0:32:15- Well, if we're making the cocktail for children,

0:32:17we can go with ranch.

0:32:18- Let's just nix the dressing.

0:32:21Let's just nix it as a, you know,

0:32:23and then it can be--

0:32:24- As a required element.

0:32:25Dressing of your choice.

0:32:26- You know what I mean?

0:32:27Like you can get a martini with a blue cheese stuffed olive

0:32:29and that's not necessarily canonical,

0:32:30but nobody would question that it's still

0:32:32a legitimate martini, it's just up to the choice.

0:32:34- Right, absolutely.

0:32:36- And what do we do about the Mentos?

0:32:38- I really don't think you can spear Mentos

0:32:41with a plastic sword, and I don't wanna make that

0:32:44a requirement and then suddenly no one can make this drink.

0:32:46- Is there a spearable candy?

0:32:48- Ooh, starbursts that have been sitting in your back pocket.

0:32:54- Yeah, I don't think the bartend,

0:32:55I think that's against, I think that's gonna,

0:32:58I think the bar's gonna lose their A rating, Paul.

0:33:00(laughing)

0:33:02I think Starbursts are a legitimate,

0:33:04I think Starbursts are a legitimate substitute.

0:33:08I hate to speak for the You Look Nice Today boys,

0:33:10because they're all good friends

0:33:11and I don't wanna stomp on their intellectual property

0:33:13and I know that they have very good attorneys.

0:33:16But I think Starbursts, off the top of my head,

0:33:19is a good idea and I'll tell you what,

0:33:20it adds a little bit of chance to the drink

0:33:26because you don't know what flavor

0:33:28Starbursts are gonna get.

0:33:30- And it's gonna help the kids even more.

0:33:33They get their dinner, they get their chicken wing

0:33:36or chicken tender, and then they get a little dessert.

0:33:38- Yeah, and they're gonna be barking for those Starbursts,

0:33:40but you gotta tell 'em, not until you eat that chicken wing.

0:33:43I like it.

0:33:45All right, I say we redefine this, see what the boys say,

0:33:48see if we can get an official,

0:33:50and then see if we can get this into some cocktail books.

0:33:53- Some cocktail books, exactly.

0:33:54- All right.

0:33:55- All right, what else do we have to follow up?

0:33:59This one's, nowhere near as fun.

0:34:01- This one is so much nerdier.

0:34:02- There's an app called Nuzzle that Milt and I talked about,

0:34:06which is an app that it's, I really like.

0:34:09It's, you let it have your Twitter credentials,

0:34:13and then Nuzzle keeps track of the people you follow.

0:34:16And at a threshold, you can specify if four people

0:34:20that you follow in the last four hours

0:34:21have posted the same link,

0:34:23Nozzle will send you a notification of it.

0:34:25And then when you just want to see what's up,

0:34:29you can go and there's like a homepage

0:34:31where maybe they haven't reached the point

0:34:34where they would have sent you a notification,

0:34:36but you can see a list of linked articles

0:34:39in order of how many people you follow

0:34:42have recently tweeted the link.

0:34:44And it's truly, for me at least,

0:34:46the people I follow an interesting source of information,

0:34:49a way to find interesting breaking news.

0:34:51I said that they don't use the WebKit browser.

0:34:54Turns out they do, there's an option that you can turn on

0:35:01so that it does support the new SF Safari view controller,

0:35:05which is the in-app browser that looks like Safari

0:35:09and supports content blockers and stuff like that.

0:35:14You have to go to settings, view stories with Safari,

0:35:19and in most cases they'll use Safari View Controller,

0:35:21but even then they don't use it all the time

0:35:23because they also have a view

0:35:25that includes a little dingus at the bottom

0:35:27that shows you which Twitter people you follow

0:35:31are the people who linked this that you can,

0:35:34so you can see who are the people who linked this

0:35:37so that it's in your list,

0:35:38and you can tap on them to see what their commentary was

0:35:41on the link too.

0:35:42And when they show that view,

0:35:43they still use the old web view that's kind of janky

0:35:46and shows a lot of ads.

0:35:47But anyway, that's my follow-up on this.

0:35:51There's a reason I don't do follow-up most weeks.

0:35:53I just let the--

0:35:54- And yet we've got three of them today.

0:35:56- Let the errors fall.

0:35:57This next one I think is gonna be very interesting to you.

0:35:59This seems like something that knowing you,

0:36:00you're gonna have strong opinions on.

0:36:02This one I might have let fly,

0:36:03except I knew that with you on the show,

0:36:05we could have a good conversation about it.

0:36:06And this was that Molson and I were talking about

0:36:09me complaining about a trip to the bank to deposit a check.

0:36:13And I knew this, I knew this,

0:36:15But it kind of slipped my mind during the show

0:36:18because I can't help it.

0:36:19I try not to be too American-centric,

0:36:22especially these days.

0:36:23But I knew this and it kind of slipped my mind,

0:36:28which is that, and then maybe this is news

0:36:30to some of you who are Americans,

0:36:32that the rest of the world,

0:36:33the rest of Western civilization moved away from checks

0:36:37as a means of conducting banking about 20 years ago.

0:36:43And so the idea that we still conduct business by checks,

0:36:47there were numerous listeners of the show

0:36:49who simply expressed laughter.

0:36:53It's like finding out that in America

0:36:56they still don't have indoor plumbing.

0:36:58(laughing)

0:37:01And that literally what I want to do,

0:37:03what I would like to be able to do,

0:37:05is write myself a check and then take a picture of it

0:37:09and submit it through an app

0:37:11so I don't have to go to the bank.

0:37:12effectively do it electronically, but even in that scenario, I still have to rip out a check,

0:37:19a piece of paper, and write it and sign it and then authorize it on the back just to do it. So...

0:37:27John "Slick" Baum: Well, that's what I was going to say is I've got -- I'd have to think about how

0:37:32many checks I get in a year. It's not a lot, but I can do bill pay or, you know, an online deposit

0:37:37of them by taking a picture with my phone. But the fact that I have to get this artifact in the

0:37:43first place and then I digitize it with my, you know, $1,000 pocket computer, send it to the bank.

0:37:51I mean, that's -- we're still dependent on this ridiculous piece of paper that has almost no

0:38:00security features. So, what's the follow-up on this, though? Just, yeah, we're backwards and

0:38:06- Yeah, and it's embarrassing, it truly is.

0:38:09But don't you also think, just looking back on it,

0:38:13the idea of checks are absurd.

0:38:15I mean, at a certain point, the concept of money,

0:38:18it's like, we can--

0:38:19- You don't wanna think about it too much.

0:38:20- You don't wanna think about it too much.

0:38:21It's a collective shared illusion.

0:38:24But checks in particular just seem,

0:38:29it just seems crazy that when I was a kid,

0:38:34half the time I'd go to the supermarket with my mom.

0:38:38You know, somebody in front of us

0:38:41was paying for the groceries with a check

0:38:43and it was just, they would just let the person

0:38:45walk out of the store with $150 worth of groceries with,

0:38:49here, I put my name on this piece of paper, I'm good.

0:38:52Yep, you're good.

0:38:53- But John, they usually made them write

0:38:55a phone number on there too.

0:38:57Not necessarily their phone number, but a phone number.

0:39:00- We're gonna call this number that you wrote on here

0:39:04if there's any problems with this check.

0:39:06It was kind of crazy.

0:39:11I mean, and it's just crazy now.

0:39:13Like imagine if like one of these new payment systems

0:39:15came out, like Apple Pay came out,

0:39:17and Eddy Cue is up there on stage.

0:39:20He's like, we've got, this is a great new system.

0:39:25You just type in how much you want in your iPhone,

0:39:30and then you go down to the share menu and you hit print.

0:39:33(laughing)

0:39:35Go over to your printer and now you've got

0:39:38an Apple Pay certificate and you can take that to any store

0:39:42and they're gonna take it and they're gonna file it away

0:39:45in a register and they're gonna take it

0:39:47to their nearest Apple store at their nearest convenience

0:39:50and we'll turn it into cash.

0:39:51The idea that there's paper involved in this

0:39:57is just nonsensical, it's crazy.

0:39:59So anyway, we understand--

0:40:01What was the check you were depositing?

0:40:03- It was just a payment, a partner payment

0:40:05from my daring firewall company

0:40:07to me and Amy's personal account.

0:40:11- So it was even your own money.

0:40:13You're transferring money between your own accounts

0:40:15and you still had to do it with a check.

0:40:17- Well, and bottom line of this,

0:40:18and there were a couple other people who commented on this.

0:40:20One of them said, and the problem,

0:40:22we can't do the electronic thing

0:40:23because our personal checking has like a $500 limit

0:40:26on the checks that we can scan.

0:40:29So like relatives--

0:40:30- Yeah, you don't wanna get too much money

0:40:31your own account.

0:40:32That's a good...

0:40:33Right.

0:40:34Like a grandparent sends Jonas a check for his birthday or whatever.

0:40:38We can scan that and it goes right into our account because we're not going to give the

0:40:42money to him.

0:40:43No, of course not.

0:40:46But any kind of serious...

0:40:48Anything that would count as a paycheck is over the limit.

0:40:51But a couple of people have said that they had the same problem, but you just go to your

0:40:54bank and say, "Hey, I want a higher limit on this," that they have a lot of discretion.

0:40:58I never tried that.

0:40:59It never occurs to me to try stuff like that.

0:41:01Like a bank tells me, I don't know, I don't think I'm, you know me, Paul, I'm not really

0:41:05like a strict toe-of-the-line rules follower, but I just assume that when—

0:41:11But a bank's rule just seems like that's it, right?

0:41:14That doesn't seem negotiable.

0:41:15When a bank tells me you can deposit up to $500, I just think, well, that's a stupid

0:41:20rule.

0:41:21It doesn't even occur to me that you can't do it.

0:41:25Do you think we should be trying to negotiate like better interest rates?

0:41:28- Yeah.

0:41:30- Is that an option too?

0:41:31- Hey, can I do the same thing with my mortgage?

0:41:34Is that possible?

0:41:35Can I just go and say--

0:41:36- I'm just not gonna pay one month.

0:41:38So what are you gonna do about it?

0:41:40Can we make this work?

0:41:41- Well, what do you say I only pay in a month

0:41:43that I have 31 days?

0:41:44'Cause that seems like the full value of a month.

0:41:46I'll still pay the same number.

0:41:50- Now I got a task for after the show.

0:41:52This is good, I'm gonna call my bank, see what happens.

0:41:54- Well, that's it for follow up.

0:41:57Anyway, checks are ridiculous.

0:41:58We know it and we don't know what to do about it.

0:42:01I'm sure Trump will get on it.

0:42:03- We'll fix that right after we fix our healthcare system

0:42:05and our immigration system.

0:42:07- And our elections being hijacked by Russian propaganda.

0:42:11- But it's fourth on the list, right after those three.

0:42:14- We'll get right on the check.

0:42:16Well, I don't know, why don't I,

0:42:22I'll take another break here.

0:42:24Seems like as good a time as ever.

0:42:27I'm gonna talk to you about another sponsor of the show,

0:42:30Casper.

0:42:32And boy does Casper have a deal for you.

0:42:34They have a special, limited time, President's Day offer.

0:42:39This is the first time they've ever done this.

0:42:41I think it's the first time they've done anything like this,

0:42:44but they've got a terrific offer.

0:42:46Casper is a sleep company.

0:42:49They make three lines of mattresses now.

0:42:52They have the original Casper,

0:42:54the innovative Wave mattress and the streamlined essential.

0:42:59But they're not just a mattress company,

0:43:01they also offer sheets, pillows, and even bed frames.

0:43:06They are the place to shop for President's Day

0:43:09mattress savings this year.

0:43:12I don't know why, President's Day seems to be

0:43:13like a big mattress promotional period.

0:43:16Well, Casper's on board.

0:43:17And they make these mattresses right here

0:43:23in the United States, they're designed and made

0:43:26right here in the United States.

0:43:29And you can be sure of your purchase

0:43:31with whatever you wind up with.

0:43:33With their 100 night risk free sleep on it trial

0:43:38and returns are hassle free

0:43:40if you're not completely satisfied.

0:43:43Really is that easy, you just buy it,

0:43:45it shows up at your house, you unpack it

0:43:48from the clever little box and wait for the air

0:43:51to fill up the foam and boom, you've got a mattress

0:43:53and if you don't like it, they'll just take it right back.

0:43:56You got 100 nights to try it out.

0:43:58Really is that easy, and it really is a terrific product.

0:44:02Great company.

0:44:03We've got Casper mattresses here in the house.

0:44:07Everybody loves them.

0:44:09Guests love them.

0:44:10We got people in the guest bedroom right now

0:44:12for Super Bowl Parade.

0:44:15I worry that maybe we shouldn't have a Casper

0:44:19in the guest bedroom because maybe

0:44:20we have too many people coming back.

0:44:23Maybe we should get like--

0:44:24- Yeah, a real lumpy mattress in the guest bed.

0:44:26- I think we've--

0:44:27- That's where you get the piece of crap

0:44:28from the retail store.

0:44:29- I think we made a terrible decision with that.

0:44:33That's how good these mattresses are.

0:44:35So for a limited time, visit casper.com/savings.

0:44:40S-A-V-I-N-G-S, casper.com/savings.

0:44:44And when you do that, you will receive up to $200

0:44:49off your purchase of $2,000 or more.

0:44:52This special offer expires February 20, 2018.

0:44:57So if you're listening to this show brand new,

0:44:59fresh off the internets, you're fine.

0:45:03If you've waited a couple days,

0:45:04if you're getting close to the deadline,

0:45:06don't wait 'cause this offer expires February 20, 2018.

0:45:11And you gotta see casper.com/terms

0:45:14for more details about this special promotion.

0:45:17So go to casper.com/savings and remember it expires.

0:45:20This special promotion expires February 20.

0:45:24All right, HomePod is coming out on Friday,

0:45:28two days from now, probably a day after the show airs.

0:45:31I've had one for a little over a week now,

0:45:32a review unit from Apple after a trip to California

0:45:37where I also got a tour of Apple's quote unquote audio lab,

0:45:42which I didn't really talk about in my review too much.

0:45:43A couple other people did.

0:45:44I've got some links in here.

0:45:46I thought Dalrymple's review had a good look at the,

0:45:51good summary of the behind the scenes.

0:45:54That's what I was hoping.

0:45:55I was hoping that somebody else who was on this tour

0:45:57would have written that aspect of it up

0:46:00'cause it was pretty interesting.

0:46:02I don't know, what are you curious about?

0:46:07- Wow, I think I'm most curious to see how it does.

0:46:13I mean, we've seen, like you said, these reviews are out now

0:46:15there's probably a good half dozen to dozen of them. And certainly none of them are glowing

0:46:22reviews that say you have to get this device. And I think, you know, that's a pretty high bar,

0:46:27obviously. But you know, that's something that I guess I maybe I've got rose-colored glasses on,

0:46:32but like when the iPhone came out, were there, do you remember what the reviews were like for

0:46:38the first iPhone? Well, they were severely limited. There were only four people who got it. It was

0:46:43Pogue, Ed Begg, Mossberg, and Steven Levy,

0:46:48who was at the time at Newsweek.

0:46:51I don't think they quite knew what to make of it.

0:46:54I do remember that the four of them got together

0:46:57and on the 10th year anniversary,

0:46:59and I did reread them,

0:47:00and none of the reviews had any clunkers in them.

0:47:04And I think Apple was wise,

0:47:08and they knew they were getting four smart people

0:47:11to review it.

0:47:12So nobody had the knee-jerk reaction

0:47:15of every other phone on the market

0:47:18has a hardware green button for making calls

0:47:21and a red one for hanging up and wine,

0:47:24something stupid like that.

0:47:25Wine World doesn't just have this.

0:47:28- The classic iPod slash dot review of,

0:47:32I can't even remember exactly what it was,

0:47:33but like less space than a Nomad, something.

0:47:37- Yeah, 300 hours.

0:47:39- It was like 10 words that they all turned out to be

0:47:42just foolish sounding after the fact.

0:47:44- Right, and nobody wants to touch on GLAAD.

0:47:48The reviews were good.

0:47:49I think the reviews saw the potential.

0:47:51All four of them saw the potential and were pretty good,

0:47:53but none of them were like, "You should run out and buy it."

0:47:55Because I feel like the $699 or $599 starting price

0:48:00of the four gig model was still exceedingly high

0:48:06by cell phone standards, because it wasn't on any kind

0:48:08contract. And I know a lot of people today are no longer buying their phones on contract,

0:48:14but that's after 11 years of weaning us towards having 500 to $1,000 cell phones. Whereas

0:48:2710 years ago, everybody was used to buying quote unquote $29 cell phones that were $29

0:48:34contract from Nokia and your carrier or whoever. But everybody had this mental

0:48:40model that your cell phone cost you know like $29 or maybe if you got an expensive

0:48:45one like a razor or something like a few hundred dollars but the idea of a $700

0:48:51cell phone was so seemed so outlandish that I think they were hesitant to tell

0:48:56people you got to go out and get it just because it was too much and I think it

0:49:00too hard to foresee at the time how people would see value in that in terms of it really

0:49:05replacing your laptop for many purposes.

0:49:10Matt

0:49:26It certainly sounds like it sounds great, but in terms of just comparing to what's already on the market, it certainly isn't blowing anything away.

0:49:36So, I'm curious, I've got one coming on Friday, you know, I need it for work. I don't know that I'd get it for myself.

0:49:42But I'm curious how it plays out over the next, say, three to nine months, more than just any individual thing on it.

0:49:50know, is there anything specific that you—I mean, you just wrote a review of it, obviously—but is

0:49:54there anything specific that jumped out to you that was interesting? Or I guess one thing that

0:50:00you mentioned was being able to give commands to it without sort of yelling over the music,

0:50:06if you're playing music. So that's one that was interesting to me. I'm interested to experiment

0:50:10with that, even if I don't know that it's something that's super useful.

0:50:12Ted

0:50:12Pete: It is super useful, I think, if you ever plan to play music at an even reasonably loud

0:50:18volume. And it really is uncanny. I think that's the word I used in the review. It works uncannily

0:50:25well because you don't expect it, I didn't expect it to be able to work better than human ears.

0:50:32So, imagine if you and I are in the same room where a home pod is blaring music relatively

0:50:38loudly and you're standing eight feet away from me, there's a certain volume that I'm

0:50:45going to, if I want to say to you, "Hey, do you want another beverage?" I'm going

0:50:50to say it at a certain volume that I think you'll probably still hear me. And I, you

0:50:56know, and I think I'm, I think, you know, anybody who's lived life for a while is

0:51:00pretty good at getting that volume about right, you know, where you don't sound like you're

0:51:05screaming too loud, but you're speaking louder than you would without the music on.

0:51:08whereas with the HomePod, you can say, "Hey, dingus," whatever, to it at a volume that

0:51:15if there was another person in the room, you would never think that they would hear it.

0:51:20Or they might hear that you're saying something, but they would never understand it.

0:51:24Right.

0:51:25So that's definitely interesting, and it sounds like, from what you said and from your experiments

0:51:29with it, that it's fairly impressive, and it's not something that I saw, at least, that

0:51:34Apple had touched on or that Apple had—is that something that they at least mentioned

0:51:37to you or is that something that you discovered?

0:51:39No, they mentioned it to us, well, to me at least, to my group, at least while we were

0:51:42in California.

0:51:43Okay.

0:51:44Yeah, and it is at an engineering level, and I think it is inextricably tied both to the

0:51:54hardware of the microphones and the software running.

0:52:00It's a version of iOS.

0:52:01It's like a lot of these other gadgets Apple's come out with, where it's really running a

0:52:05variant of iOS.

0:52:06The version number right now is even 11.2.5,

0:52:09the same version number as the version on your phone.

0:52:12- It's involved with that, right.

0:52:14- It's a combination of the mics being really good,

0:52:18the mics being oriented in a certain way,

0:52:20and the mics knowing exactly how the seven tweeters

0:52:25and the woofer are oriented.

0:52:29And it's one of those funny things

0:52:35Apple wanted to, I'm not surprised that they're not like making it a major advertising component,

0:52:43but they definitely wanted us to know about it.

0:52:46I definitely noticed it in the demos that Apple performed for me that they, you know,

0:52:54she clearly, the woman who was doing the demos clearly wasn't speaking, I thought, loud enough,

0:52:59but it was hearing her almost perfectly.

0:53:01I mean, there were a whole bunch of commands and there was like one or two she had to repeat.

0:53:05But it was -- and I know -- and the other thing combining that is that firsthand as a year-long

0:53:12owner of an Amazon Alexa, with the Alexa, it's not that you have to scream, but you have to talk at

0:53:18least as loud as you'd have to talk to a human being over the same volume of music.

0:53:22Soterios Johnson So, you've got -- I think you mentioned you've got an Echo in the kitchen.

0:53:27Do you have -- how many do you have throughout the house, like two or three?

0:53:29Dave: Yeah, we've got one in Jonas' room and another, a dot in the living room. But

0:53:36the living room and the kitchen are on the same floor, and it's maddening because I'll

0:53:40be in the kitchen—the same thing happens to Amy is we'll be in the kitchen and we'll

0:53:44say the Alexa name—hopefully I said that in a way that won't trigger people's things—and

0:53:53and whatever, at a relatively sane volume.

0:53:57And it's like, for whatever reason,

0:53:59the one in the living room at the other end of the floor

0:54:04kicks in.

0:54:04And it's like, what?

0:54:05It's like crazy.

0:54:06I don't understand how that's possible.

0:54:09And does the kitchen one not kick in,

0:54:11or do they both kick in?

0:54:12No, it's only the other one.

0:54:14I don't know how that is.

0:54:15It's very strange.

0:54:16And it doesn't happen all the time.

0:54:17It certainly doesn't happen most of the time,

0:54:18or I would have thrown the things out the window.

0:54:20it happens enough that it's crazy. And it's like, and one way, one way it manifests itself is,

0:54:28like, Amy certainly sends the most timers, because in the kitchen, because she's, she cooks more

0:54:32things that need to be timed. And I think what happens every once in a while, she'll tell it

0:54:37to set a timer and thinks it didn't hear. And then she'll tell it to set the timer again, and it

0:54:44hears her and it goes off. But meanwhile, the dot out in the other room, I don't know, 30,

0:54:5040 feet away heard it too, and nobody's in there. And it set a timer. And then like, you know,

0:54:5615 minutes later, the dot is making the little alarm sound. And it's like, who the hell did that?

0:55:01Anyway.

0:55:03>> Well, so I'm interested to hear, you know, like you said, you've had these Echo devices for

0:55:10about a year and you've had, did they, they just gave you one HomePod to test with?

0:55:13- That is correct because it's right now.

0:55:16And the HomePod we got for testing

0:55:18is running the production software

0:55:20that will be on the ones that come in the mail on--

0:55:23- In two days. - On two days.

0:55:25Or that you can buy in a store in two days.

0:55:27So because ours are running,

0:55:29which is the way I would prefer it.

0:55:30I would not, I would be,

0:55:33I would have been very uncomfortable.

0:55:34I don't know what I would have done in fact, because I--

0:55:37- Right, throwing in caveats of,

0:55:38you know, I'm testing something that's not yet available.

0:55:40- Right, I would have, if I was running one

0:55:43with a pre-release version of 11.3

0:55:47with the AirPlay 2 stuff on it,

0:55:50I would have mentioned it up front

0:55:52and I would have had to mention it every step of the way.

0:55:54I don't know, it would have made me very,

0:55:57I don't know, so I'm glad.

0:55:58And I think that the same reason that I'm glad

0:56:00is the reason that they gave us the production firmware,

0:56:04whatever you wanna call it.

0:56:06So anyway, they only gave us one

0:56:07because there's really no point to having two yet.

0:56:10I mean, I guess you could set it up

0:56:11as two independent devices,

0:56:12it's not really going to help you review anything.

0:56:14>> Sure. But so, in your actual use case in your house, if you've got three different Echo devices,

0:56:22I guess that's sort of the question is, do you think and does Apple think that people are going

0:56:29to use this in the same way that people use an Echo currently or use a Google Home currently?

0:56:34>> No.

0:56:35>> Or -- exactly. And because they've been so focused on the music aspect of it,

0:56:39but it really seems like, you know,

0:56:40maybe you only get one of these for the house

0:56:42and you put it wherever you have your biggest TV

0:56:45or your stereo system if you still have one of those.

0:56:47And it sort of joins in that way,

0:56:50as opposed to Amazon's idea that, you know,

0:56:52maybe you have one of these

0:56:53in every single room of the house.

0:56:54- Right.

0:56:55Although I think you could have them in multiple rooms.

0:56:58I think it, you know,

0:57:01I think it varies greatly by the layout of your home.

0:57:04Like, do you have this sort of floor plan

0:57:07we're putting one in the dining room and the kitchen

0:57:10and having them sync together to play the same song

0:57:13at the same time makes sense.

0:57:14We kind of do.

0:57:19That might make sense for us to have two that way

0:57:22because from our dining room,

0:57:25you can walk right through to the kitchen,

0:57:26but if the HomePod was in the kitchen,

0:57:29you wouldn't really consider it a source for music

0:57:32in the dining room and vice versa.

0:57:34- Outside of the kitchen, right?

0:57:35- Right.

0:57:35So, I think it comes down to the fact that it really is music first. It really is a thing

0:57:42that's meant to be playing music. And I think the other thing I think that you mentioned

0:57:47that the one place where I feel like the HomePod really doesn't fit is in the room with your

0:57:52TV, or at least not unless you want to use it completely separately from your TV.

0:57:59Right. Sorry, that is what I meant. Yeah. That's the same way that you might have a

0:58:04stereo there that is, at least in my mom's house, she has a TV here and a stereo there,

0:58:08and they're completely divorced from one another or completely unrelated to one another, but it's

0:58:12where you do your listening or your viewing. But right, yeah, that was something interesting that

0:58:18you wrote about was that it's not designed to hook up to your TV, and this is a super high-quality

0:58:23speaker that doesn't have an input and can't really take audio from your TV short of having

0:58:28your Apple TV send to it. Which is, I don't know, you had talked about not having a line input

0:58:35because Apple, you know, is thinking that everything's going to be wireless. And that's,

0:58:39I get that, but it's a pretty cheap part to add to this. And when everything else on this is fairly

0:58:46high end and you, you know, you could say, well, I just want to be able to take my device somewhere

0:58:51and plug in audio to it without having to wirelessly send to it. I don't know, that's one

0:58:57that it wouldn't make me not purchase it if I were interested to purchase it, but it seems like

0:59:02something that doesn't necessarily make sense to cut the same way that they made some changes on

0:59:08like the phone where, you know, a headphone jack supposedly at least had something to do with

0:59:12waterproofing. Obviously, you're not waterproofing the HomePod, so there's not an obvious reason to

0:59:18cut this besides the idea that, no, we just want everyone to focus on wireless audio to this thing.

0:59:22Well, I think there's also a simplicity angle though because if you have a line in and then you're pumping your TV to it

0:59:29And you're watching a movie what happens when you say hey dingus play whatever to it

0:59:35Does it start playing the music you just asked it to play or does it keep playing the TV?

0:59:40Input on line in and what happens when you tap the top of it?

0:59:43Which typically does play pause does it stop and how would top how would tapping the stop button on?

0:59:50on a speaker getting a dumb line-in signal go back to pause the TV. It couldn't.

0:59:56So…

0:59:57No, that's certainly a good point. Yeah, absolutely.

1:00:00You know, I mentioned it in my review. It does seem wasteful. If you want to put it in a room

1:00:04where you already have a TV and some kind of speaker system, it seems wasteful to add another

1:00:09wholly independent speaker system. It is…

1:00:11Right.

1:00:12You know, what is that word? I was going to say duplicitous, but duplicitous means

1:00:15deceitful.

1:00:17Oh, superfluous.

1:00:19Superfluous, right. It does seem superfluous. But I get it. I think it's for a simplicity where

1:00:27it's always just playing either what you tell it to or acting as an AirPlay speaker and acting as

1:00:33an AirPlay speaker never. I don't know though, because you can set Apple TV to talk to it as

1:00:39an AirPlay speaker. I don't know. I don't feel like I feel much stronger. I feel like getting

1:00:48getting rid of the headphone jack on the phones

1:00:50is the right way, I feel like it was the right decision

1:00:53last year, I really do.

1:00:55On the line in, I'm a little bit more ambivalent.

1:00:58I'm okay with this product not having it,

1:01:01but if it did have it, I wouldn't think that they were

1:01:05sticking with an older technology for no good reason,

1:01:07like I would've if they didn't get rid of the headphone jack

1:01:10I'm more ambivalent about it.

1:01:18What else about it?

1:01:19I do think if there's one thing, excuse me, Paul.

1:01:23There's one thing I saw in a couple of reviews,

1:01:25I think Matthew Panzarino's in particular,

1:01:27which was really interesting to me because he knows,

1:01:30and I knew this like a career ago,

1:01:33he was actually working as a salesman

1:01:35in a high-end stereo shop.

1:01:38So he really knows a lot more about

1:01:41why one speaker sounds better than another

1:01:47or where one speaker sounds better and another one doesn't

1:01:50and why and stuff like that than I do.

1:01:52I just kinda listen to one, listen to the other,

1:01:53and then well, I can tell I like that one better.

1:01:56I just, I don't know. - Right.

1:01:57- But he mentioned something,

1:02:01and I think it's absolutely true, is that,

1:02:04and it's just the layout of our current house

1:02:07just and where I could try it.

1:02:09I don't really have a smaller and smaller room.

1:02:15And in a small room, and I heard a couple of demos,

1:02:19'cause when Apple demoed these things for us,

1:02:22it was in an actual house.

1:02:25I don't know if they rented it or whatever,

1:02:27but it was in a real house of real dimensions

1:02:31and had real furnishings and stuff.

1:02:33And I think very typical.

1:02:35I don't think it was, there was nothing weird

1:02:39or set up about it, including some room.

1:02:44camera's on every inch of it and you're in all sorts of videos now.

1:02:47But they had like a downstairs with like a very modern floor plan for a living room, living floor,

1:02:56where the kitchen flows right into the living room without a wall, just with like a kitchen

1:03:02island between them, which is, you know, I've been I know so many people who have a floor plan like

1:03:07that, which is a bigger, bigger, much bigger space, more risk for more ways that you could

1:03:13you get echoes.

1:03:14And then a smaller room upstairs,

1:03:15which would be just a very, very typical,

1:03:18or they even had a bedroom.

1:03:19There was even a very typical bedroom,

1:03:21and then maybe like a very typical home office type room.

1:03:24And in those smaller rooms,

1:03:27it was really more startling how good it sounded.

1:03:31And in my personal testing at home, it sounded good.

1:03:35It sounded better than any other thing

1:03:36I've tried in these rooms,

1:03:38but I feel like our place is a little bit,

1:03:41has more space, bigger rooms and more echoey rooms.

1:03:44So that's one thing too, is there's a lot of,

1:03:49the smaller your room, I think the better

1:03:51this thing is gonna sound, and it really

1:03:53almost sounds phenomenal, and the effect

1:03:56of not quite coming from a single point

1:03:59is way more pronounced in a smaller room.

1:04:02That's the other thing that I remember from the demos.

1:04:05And it's not like it fools you into thinking

1:04:08that there's two speakers on two sides of the room.

1:04:10you could close your eyes and point to where the HomePod is,

1:04:13right?

1:04:14Or like if you're in a small room and there's one HomePod

1:04:19and somebody spins you around like pin the tail

1:04:21on the donkey and they're like, where's the HomePod?

1:04:23You'll get very close to it when you point it,

1:04:25but it doesn't sound like it's coming

1:04:27from a tiny little seven inch point.

1:04:30It really does have a dimensionality, a 3D-ness to it

1:04:33that seems like something, you know,

1:04:36a next level up in small speaker design.

1:04:40So do you think that — all these reviews have talked about, you know, this audio quality, and

1:04:45Apple touted this, and it sounds like that is true, that this has phenomenal audio quality and better

1:04:51than, you know, the other devices that are out there, certainly better than the cheaper devices

1:04:55that are out there, and sounds like better than even the devices that are comparably priced from,

1:05:01you know, the Google Home Max and Sonos. Is that enough to make this thing sell, though?

1:05:07I don't know. I've I thought before I started my review, just knowing what I knew, you know,

1:05:12what Apple had said coming up to it and up to the point where I met with their, you know, engineers

1:05:18and the next day got a briefing and headed home with my review unit before it and after it, I

1:05:25really I have I don't know what I would which way I would bet on how successful this product would

1:05:29be. My guess is that the best case scenario is a sort of slowly building hit, sort of like Apple

1:05:39Watch, you know, where, although without that initial, like, Apple Watch debuted with like a,

1:05:45you could, you know, all of a sudden it was backordered six weeks. Right, everybody wanted

1:05:49that up front. But then once that subsided, it was sort of like you didn't really see a lot of

1:05:54of people with Apple Watch the first year, but then it seemed like through word of mouth.

1:05:59It's the sort of thing that I feel like you need word of mouth for, and that people might

1:06:03come to your house and if you have a HomePod, they might be really impressed by it and think,

1:06:08"Wow, that really does sound good. I might get one of those." But I could see it all

1:06:14the way to being the iPod 2.0, the iPod Hi-Fi 2.0, that Apple built this thing that they

1:06:23seemingly spend a lot of engineering time on and seemingly are very proud of and really

1:06:27think people are going to like and people just don't want to spend 300 plus dollars

1:06:33on something that just plays music from Apple.

1:06:36And was that I'm trying to remember was that $4.99 the iPod Hi-Fi?

1:06:39I don't remember how much it was.

1:06:41We could think that's I, I don't want to, we should look it up.

1:06:46But it was it was definitely I think, even more expensive than this and obviously did

1:06:49a lot less.

1:06:50Right.

1:06:51It was literally just a speaker that took audio from an iPod.

1:06:54- Nope, it was three.

1:06:55- It didn't take commands or anything like that.

1:06:57- It was 349.

1:06:58- Oh, was it exactly the same price?

1:07:00I guess I feel like I remember people saying that

1:07:02now that I think about it.

1:07:04- That's even funnier.

1:07:06My God, is it bigger.

1:07:07It's ridiculous how much bigger the iPod I was.

1:07:10- Oh, it was enormous, yeah.

1:07:12And especially compared to the device

1:07:14that you were putting on it.

1:07:16- I never bought one of those.

1:07:18I had no desire to buy one.

1:07:21But boy, I kind of wish I had one laying around

1:07:23'cause that would be a fun side-by-side review.

1:07:25- Oh, comparison test, yeah, absolutely.

1:07:28- See how much better it sounds.

1:07:29I thought Pansarino, I think it was Pansarino,

1:07:33had another observation that I thought was spot on

1:07:35where he described the iPod Hi-Fi's sound as being,

1:07:39I think he said accurate.

1:07:41- Wait, the iPod Hi-Fi or the HomePod?

1:07:45- Not the iPod Hi-Pod. (laughs)

1:07:46You've got me thrown off, the HomePod.

1:07:49And everybody agreed, if you saw it,

1:07:51if you read it, I'll put a link to a couple

1:07:54of these reviews in there, but there was a strong consensus

1:07:56among everybody that the Google Home Max,

1:07:59which is their $399 dingus, which is the,

1:08:03you know, $50 more than the HomePod,

1:08:06so clearly, you know, fair comparison,

1:08:09is way too base heavy, you know,

1:08:12which some people like, but it's like one of those things

1:08:15that's like the TVs in the store being oversaturated

1:08:20because you're in there looking at 17 different TVs

1:08:24and the ones with the saturated colors look like,

1:08:27wow, that one has, that other one looks bland.

1:08:30This one has pop, I want the one with pop.

1:08:32But you would never, it's like inaccurate.

1:08:35You'd never really wanna tune your TV that way.

1:08:37It's, you know.

1:08:38And I think it's also similar to the way

1:08:43that Apple has calibrated its screens forever,

1:08:48but especially like in the iPhone era,

1:08:51where Apple, one of the reasons that they were

1:08:53one of the last, if not the last major phone company

1:08:57to put out a phone with an OLED display

1:09:00was that in the early days of OLED,

1:09:02while there are some advantages to battery life

1:09:04and certainly all along batteries

1:09:06or advantages to the richer blacks,

1:09:08color accuracy was really, really hard

1:09:12and really has only come in the last few years.

1:09:14And even though once it came on other phones,

1:09:16it still couldn't come in the quantities Apple needed.

1:09:19Like Apple was never gonna ship an OLED phone

1:09:22until they could ship it in the quantities they needed

1:09:25and with the color accuracy that they wanted.

1:09:28And one thing, I'm picky about color.

1:09:31I really, I've always been very picky about color.

1:09:34And the one thing I've noticed with the iPhone 10

1:09:36now that I've had it for months,

1:09:37is even when I see it side by side with anybody else

1:09:40who has like an iPhone 8 or a 7 or any other recent iPhone,

1:09:43is the one thing I don't notice

1:09:44is I don't notice any difference in color.

1:09:46I really don't.

1:09:47And I feel like that is exactly what they've done with sound

1:09:51on the HomePod,

1:09:52where they're being very, very fair to the original.

1:09:55They're not pumping up the bass.

1:09:56They're not doing other,

1:09:58like the audio equivalent of sugar sweetening the audio.

1:10:02- Right, tweaking it to make it sound supposedly better,

1:10:05but bastardizing it a little bit.

1:10:06- Right.

1:10:08I would say that that's very fair.

1:10:10I think the other thing that I got out of this,

1:10:15I feel like there's three factors in the decision

1:10:18of does somebody want a HomePod.

1:10:20One is do you care enough about,

1:10:22do you have a place in your life where a $350 speaker

1:10:26that sounds really good makes sense?

1:10:29And for some people that might be nowhere.

1:10:33You might not have a room in your house or an office

1:10:36where you can do that.

1:10:37if you work in a cubicle or something like that.

1:10:39I don't think your cubicle mates are gonna appreciate it

1:10:42if you set up a home pot.

1:10:44- But it's gonna sound great.

1:10:47- Right, and there might be people out there

1:10:49who like hear the $89 Amazon Alexa play music

1:10:54and say that's good enough for me.

1:10:57And why in the world would I spend four times more

1:10:59on this other thing?

1:11:01So that's one factor.

1:11:02Do you have a spot in your life

1:11:03where you're willing to spend $3.50 for audio

1:11:06that you would appreciate.

1:11:08Two is the issue of where do you,

1:11:13where does your music come from?

1:11:15You know, if your music, if you're heavily into Spotify,

1:11:18and Spotify keeps coming up over and over and over again

1:11:20in all these reviews,

1:11:21because some of these other products support Spotify

1:11:25as a first class like source of talking to the device

1:11:29to play music from Spotify, and HomePod doesn't.

1:11:36there's no way you want HomePod, in my opinion.

1:11:38If you're heavily into Spotify and you don't wanna leave,

1:11:40then I really can't see why you'd want to switch to HomePod,

1:11:45even if the sound is a little better.

1:11:47- Right.

1:11:48- And conversely, if you are on the opposite,

1:11:50if you're heavily into the Apple Music ecosystem,

1:11:53lowercase m, 'cause I'll include in that

1:11:57the Apple Music, capital M, subscription service,

1:12:02iTunes Music Store, any purchases that you've ever made,

1:12:06or see any music that you own in your personal library,

1:12:11if you have iTunes Match or Apple Music,

1:12:14they'll sync to the cloud,

1:12:16and then you can talk to your HomePod

1:12:19and have it play those.

1:12:20And in fact, that's most of the music testing

1:12:22I did this week, 'cause I was so interested in that,

1:12:24is I had it play a bunch of Rolling Stones albums I have

1:12:28that are not and have never been available

1:12:30from the iTunes Store.

1:12:31And it worked great

1:12:33So if you're into the Apple system

1:12:36Yeah, and you could just say and it's funny it got smarter - I have an album

1:12:42I think it's a 1973 live recording called the Brussels affair recorded in Brussels

1:12:48One of my all-time favorite Rolling Stones albums and the first time I asked the home pod to play the Rolling Stones Brussels affair

1:12:56I think that's what I asked for play the Rolling Stones Brussels affair

1:13:00HomePod told me that it couldn't find any music

1:13:02Brussels affair and I thought damn that's this sinking I thought the damn sinking feature wasn't working

1:13:10So I thought about it and I looked in my library and the actual file name I have on the album is Brussels affair

1:13:18parentheses

1:13:19live

1:13:211973 so I said I asked the HomePod to play Brussels play Brussels affair live

1:13:281973 and it said okay. Here's the Rolling Stones Brussels affair live

1:13:321973 and it just started playing

1:13:35That's a little bit of a pain in ass, but that's okay. But then like the next day I said

1:13:39Hey play the Brussels affair and it said okay. Here's the Rolling Stones Brussels affair and then it it worked now

1:13:47I don't know if it learned I don't know if it just needed to sink

1:13:50You know if I asked it the first time before it was done sinking

1:13:54I don't know what happened.

1:13:55You know, and that's one of the things

1:13:57about these talking dinguses,

1:13:59is you never know why it works one day

1:14:01and doesn't work the other day.

1:14:03- Well, so can I pick this bone that I have with you

1:14:08about the HomePod? - Yeah, absolutely.

1:14:09Well, before we do that, let's save that.

1:14:10Let's save that.

1:14:11And I did wanna mention,

1:14:13I wanted to mention one review in particular

1:14:15that I thought was kinda crappy,

1:14:16was Brian Chen's review for the New York Times.

1:14:19Because I feel like all the other reviews,

1:14:22I largely agree, even if I didn't agree completely,

1:14:24I thought they were all pretty accurate.

1:14:26And I thought Chen's review for the New York Times

1:14:28was way out of line because it was sort of like

1:14:31it started with him talking about using it

1:14:33to listen to music.

1:14:34And he said, "Hey, play some music."

1:14:37And it played music he didn't like,

1:14:38and he tried to get it to stop.

1:14:40And instead of stopping, it said it didn't recognize

1:14:43whatever artist he's complaining about's album, Stop,

1:14:46or something like that.

1:14:49And then he kind of went right to like a 14 point comparison

1:14:53of trying to get these, you know,

1:14:55multiple of these devices to do assistant type things,

1:15:00like create calendar events and stuff like that.

1:15:04And creating calendar events

1:15:06is something HomePod doesn't do.

1:15:07Now, I'm not saying it's not fair to mention that,

1:15:09but it's like his whole review was pretty much

1:15:12comparing it.

1:15:15To me, it would be the equivalent of

1:15:19if he wrote a review of the new Amazon Echo

1:15:24and quickly brushed over a bunch of something

1:15:28that Alexa does that does particularly well,

1:15:32and then just skipped right to a 14 point comparison

1:15:35of how good did the speaker sound.

1:15:37Right, and then that's the whole review of,

1:15:40like it's totally fair to mention it,

1:15:44and I think my review and various others,

1:15:48I don't see how you couldn't mention that Siri does less

1:15:52on HomePod than Alexa does on the Echo products

1:15:56and that the Google Voice product, you know,

1:15:59which I feel like needs a name.

1:16:00Like, I don't know what to call it.

1:16:01They call it like the device is Google Home Max,

1:16:04but, and you address it as OK Google,

1:16:07but it's so much--

1:16:09- Right, it doesn't have a personified name behind it.

1:16:11- Right, it's so much easier.

1:16:13It's just a small aside from writing a long review

1:16:15about this is it's so much easier

1:16:17to write about the separation between HomePod and Siri

1:16:21and say the Echo or the Alexa equipped Sonos One hardware

1:16:26and Alexa as the abstract service.

1:16:33I feel like I wish Google would fix that,

1:16:35but I don't, I guess we could just call the service

1:16:39okay Google, I don't know.

1:16:41But anyway, that's an aside.

1:16:43Anyway, I thought Chen's review was sort of

1:16:45deliberately written to make it look bad.

1:16:48I don't see how there was any way

1:16:50that HomePod could come out of his review testing

1:16:52looking good, 'cause he was trying things

1:16:54that he knew in advance it couldn't do.

1:16:57Like, what's the point? - Well, but I mean,

1:16:58is that unfair if those are the things

1:17:01that he wants it to do?

1:17:02I mean, it's not like he went and said,

1:17:04"This car doesn't have any storage space,

1:17:07"so this is a two-seater convertible,

1:17:09"so I'm gonna try and haul two tons of potting soil in it."

1:17:14This is something that I think people who get a device

1:17:17of this type are gonna try and do.

1:17:19And this is, it's something where it certainly is lacking.

1:17:22And Apple definitely wanted to frame this device

1:17:25and I think successfully framed a bunch of the reviews as,

1:17:29you know, there's some shortcomings

1:17:31but the audio quality is great.

1:17:32Or the audio quality is great despite other shortcomings.

1:17:36And his review was definitely,

1:17:38it didn't really talk too much at all

1:17:40about the audio quality said, you know,

1:17:41I listened to some music that didn't work super well.

1:17:43and then Siri itself worked really poorly.

1:17:46Do you think that's about an accurate summary

1:17:48of what he wrote?

1:17:49- Yeah, I think so.

1:17:52I think that's a pretty accurate summary.

1:17:54- So I don't know that,

1:17:56I mean, you're absolutely right.

1:17:57It was definitely one of the harshest reviews of the device,

1:18:01but I don't think that he came at it in a super unfair way.

1:18:04- I wouldn't say super unfair.

1:18:07I would just say a,

1:18:09I just don't think it was helpful.

1:18:13You know what I mean?

1:18:14I don't know.

1:18:15I feel like, I almost feel like the angle he took

1:18:17would be better as a follow-up

1:18:19after reviewing it for what it is,

1:18:21and then having a column of what type of device

1:18:24do you want in your house that talks to you,

1:18:27which is two different things.

1:18:28- Well, I guess to me, it's a question of

1:18:32how similar is this device to the Echo and the HomePod,

1:18:37or sorry, and the Google Home, rather.

1:18:39- Right.

1:18:40- Are these really exactly the same type of device,

1:18:43or are we getting down to the nitty gritty and saying,

1:18:45you know what, there's actually virtual assistant devices

1:18:48that happen to play music, and there's music players

1:18:51that happen to have a virtual assistant,

1:18:52and those are two separate things.

1:18:54And I think to most, I would assume

1:18:57to most potential customers, those are the same thing.

1:19:01And it's just a question of which one of those

1:19:04you care about a little bit more, but.

1:19:06- That's a good way to put it.

1:19:07I think that's exactly a good way to put it.

1:19:08And that's how I tried to frame my review.

1:19:11And in fact, I even caught myself at one point

1:19:13where I, in my review, in an early draft of it,

1:19:16I had that the HomePod and Alexa

1:19:19clearly aren't even in the same category.

1:19:21And I realized that the other day,

1:19:23I had written that they are in the same category,

1:19:25but from different perspectives.

1:19:27And so I caught myself and realized,

1:19:31the way I reworded it, and which I think is more accurate,

1:19:33is that they're at opposite ends of the category.

1:19:36Right, 'cause you really, like, right now,

1:19:38we literally have the Alexa and the HomePod

1:19:41in the kitchen at the same time,

1:19:43both, you know, just mostly for testing reasons.

1:19:46Feature wise, because Amy is actually annoyed

1:19:50that the HomePod doesn't have the one thing she,

1:19:52one of the things she really likes about the Echo,

1:19:54which is being able to set multiple timers,

1:19:56which really feels like it's something that Apple could

1:20:01and should fix right away.

1:20:03Like with Alexa, you can say,

1:20:06set a potato timer for 20 minutes,

1:20:09and then like a minute later say,

1:20:11what else might you be cooking with potatoes?

1:20:16- Remind me about the boiling water in 10 minutes

1:20:18or whatever. - Right.

1:20:19And then you can say, Alexa, how much time do I have left

1:20:23on the potato timer?

1:20:24And she will tell you.

1:20:27And on the HomePod, if you set a timer, you can't name it,

1:20:31it's only one timer.

1:20:32And then if you set another timer, Siri will say,

1:20:36you already have a timer with four minutes

1:20:38and 33 seconds remaining, would you like to replace it?

1:20:42Like that's your only option.

1:20:43And that's, you know, pretty sure that iOS

1:20:46is an A8 processor could handle running two timers

1:20:50at the same time.

1:20:51- Well, now I'm trying to think,

1:20:54does the phone let you do multiple times?

1:20:55- No, the phone doesn't either.

1:20:56- I don't think it does, right?

1:20:58- No.

1:20:59So, you know, and you know, it's a feature she uses.

1:21:05It's not a crazy feature.

1:21:06I don't think that's esoteric.

1:21:08And I feel like once you get, I hear this a lot.

1:21:11It's clearly putting these things in a kitchen

1:21:13is very popular and setting timers is hugely popular.

1:21:16And it's just one of those tiny little,

1:21:20once you get used to, just to go back to it,

1:21:25once you get used to indoor plumbing,

1:21:26there's no going back to outdoor plumbing.

1:21:28People have been cooking for thousands of years

1:21:32and they've used various ways of determining

1:21:35how long to cook a thing.

1:21:36But the idea of having to touch a device to set a timer

1:21:43is, once you go to just doing it by voice,

1:21:46it's so, it just seems barbaric.

1:21:49Because a lot of times, if you're in the kitchen cooking,

1:21:52your hands might be covered with stuff,

1:21:54or you might not be near the device,

1:21:56or various reasons.

1:21:59It's just so nice, and it just, you know.

1:22:02So anyway, that's something Apple's got to get on.

1:22:06>> All right, now can I issue with this thing?

1:22:08>> Absolutely.

1:22:10I feel like this is a fantastic discussion.

1:22:12>> All right, so six, no, I guess about eight months ago,

1:22:15the HomePod was announced.

1:22:17And you had a post that I assume you will link to about

1:22:22the HomePod having a touchscreen.

1:22:24And prior to the announcement, there were all the rumors floating around and

1:22:29multiple rumors sites reported that it did not have a touchscreen, unlike the, what is

1:22:36it, the Amazon Echo Show, I think is the one that has a screen.

1:22:39Which you don't hear about much anymore, by the way.

1:22:41In this whole—

1:22:42Yeah, that came out, and I don't know if it's—I don't know anything about that one except that

1:22:46it has a screen and I guess it exists. But so, after this was announced, you said,

1:22:53"Claim Chowder, it does have a touchscreen." And you and I had a discussion about this,

1:22:58and I said, "I don't think that that constitutes a touchscreen." And you stuck to your guns,

1:23:04and you said, "No, you touch it, and I don't know, you can summarize your own position."

1:23:08JS: Well, I don't think it was multiple rumor sites, though. I think it was a Bloomberg report

1:23:13by Mark Gurman and Alex Webb for Bloomberg, and it was, I think, about a week before WWDC,

1:23:19and their exact words are, "Ahead of Apple's launch, the competition has upgraded their

1:23:24speakers with support for making voice calls while Amazon's gained a touch screen.

1:23:31Apple's speaker won't include such a screen according to people who have seen the product.

1:23:37And then Ming-Chi Kuo, two weeks before that, said, "We also believe this new product

1:23:41will come with a touch panel."

1:23:43Okay.

1:23:44And then you wrote, "HomePod has a touch screen on top."

1:23:47Right.

1:23:48After seeing it at WWDC.

1:23:51This was, I've posted it Tuesday, so it was like within a day of the keynote.

1:23:57And I was under the impression, now this was, I forget if I'd had my hands on, I don't think

1:24:01I had, I don't think they'd had the briefing yet.

1:24:04Maybe I did though, maybe they did that on Monday.

1:24:06I don't remember when, in addition to the one that they had out there for everybody

1:24:10to walk by, but not touch, we also got invited in like little groups of four to hear it,

1:24:17not touch it and we weren't allowed to speak to it or anything. But I saw the plus and

1:24:25minus buttons that you could touch for volume and I saw the Siri, I'll call it a waveform,

1:24:30but the primary colored circular swirly cloud animation and assumed incorrectly that that

1:24:39that was some sort of, like the equivalent

1:24:44of an iPhone screen showing these things.

1:24:48And that it could, in theory, show other things

1:24:52under other circumstances.

1:24:55And I had no idea how it worked,

1:24:56other than that they said you could touch it

1:24:58to do the plus/minus, but they wouldn't let us touch it,

1:25:00so we couldn't see how it worked.

1:25:01(laughing)

1:25:04So you think I was wrong?

1:25:08You think I was wrong?

1:25:09- I'm not saying you're wrong on this.

1:25:10- It does not, I would say I am wrong.

1:25:13'Cause I would not call the thing on top of HomePod

1:25:15a touchscreen.

1:25:16What Ming-Chi Kuo called it a touch panel

1:25:19is probably better.

1:25:20It's weird what to call it because it is,

1:25:23it doesn't show arbitrary pixels.

1:25:27I'm kind of curious for iFixit to get,

1:25:29more curious than for most products,

1:25:31just to have iFixit take this apart

1:25:33because I'm curious what the hell is under there

1:25:36to make the waveform.

1:25:38But what we've since heard from various birdies,

1:25:42not me directly, I think ATP might've had a birdie

1:25:44who said it, is that there's some kind of color LCDs

1:25:48under there, but it's more like, I don't know,

1:25:52like light bright type things, you know,

1:25:54like not pixels that could display anything that,

1:25:56you know, like text.

1:25:57Anything arbitrary, right.

1:25:58Or arbitrary information, but it's really only meant

1:26:00to create that Siri multicolored animation

1:26:04and then some kind of diffuser that makes it look blurry.

1:26:08- Okay.

1:26:10- And like the plus and minus buttons are, I believe,

1:26:13just completely hard, you know,

1:26:14they're just old fashioned buttons that are, you know,

1:26:18there's nothing else that--

1:26:19- Pressed in plastic or whatever.

1:26:20- Right, they're not arbitrary pixels,

1:26:22they're just, you know, plus and minus.

1:26:24- So I looked this up, and Apple refers to it,

1:26:29you can go to their tech specs,

1:26:30and they call it the touch surface,

1:26:33which I guess would apply to pretty much anything you can touch.

1:26:37But it's definitely not -- they don't refer to it as a touch screen,

1:26:42because like you said, I think that to me, I guess, is the definition,

1:26:45is that it can't display an arbitrary image.

1:26:50And that to me is what a touch screen can do.

1:26:53A touch screen ATM can display whatever you put on it.

1:26:56Your phone obviously can display whatever you draw to it.

1:26:59>> Touch surface. I guess that's fair.

1:27:02So, touch panel sounds pretty much right to me as well.

1:27:04That seems like a pretty good name for it.

1:27:06Touch surface just sounds sort of meaningless, but that is the term that they're using.

1:27:10Right.

1:27:12Yeah, I think I was wrong.

1:27:14I don't think German and Webb were right, though.

1:27:16I don't think saying it doesn't include such a screen is right either,

1:27:18because you can't -- there is a touch thing that they didn't mention.

1:27:23Well, so the only thing that -- there, I think there --

1:27:27I think it was poor writing, if anything.

1:27:28They're saying the Amazon device has a true screen that displays the weather and whatever,

1:27:34and the HomePod obviously does not have that. And if you just showed them side by side and said,

1:27:40"This one has a screen and this one doesn't," you'd say, "Yeah, that's right." But because

1:27:44they're writing about things that they didn't have images of and, I think, like I said, didn't

1:27:49necessarily express it properly, then yeah, I think you're right that it was not necessarily

1:27:54written the way that it should have been. - Right, you read it again, and it sounds to me

1:27:57like they weren't told by someone what the HomePod does present to you, a Siri waveform

1:28:04and plus and minus volume buttons, but they were told that it doesn't present to you a

1:28:10what the Amazon device does.

1:28:12Well, I just kicked Syrian somehow. Sorry about that. Sorry, Siri. Here's a weird thing

1:28:21with the HomePod that I forgot to mention in my review. Could it happen to me today?

1:28:27which is really why I forgot to write.

1:28:29I'd noticed it before, but if you don't touch your HomePod

1:28:32or use it in like a day, like let's say,

1:28:35I was using it yesterday and I went to bed

1:28:38and then I woke up today and did some work

1:28:41and then I went out and then I record a podcast

1:28:44and it's been like 18 hours since I've used the thing

1:28:46and I go in there and if I just touch the top,

1:28:49it'll just start playing whatever I left off on

1:28:52like a day ago.

1:28:53- 18 hours later.

1:28:54- Right, and it, you know, and like, I've run into it,

1:28:58and I mentioned in my review that the,

1:28:59at least on the Space Gray run,

1:29:01the touch surface is a fingerprint magnet,

1:29:04and I kind of wish it was either matte finished

1:29:06or had a better oleophobic coating.

1:29:08It's, I've run into it where I look at it

1:29:10and it looks like smudgy, and I wanna just,

1:29:12I kinda wipe it off, and I just go to wipe it off,

1:29:15and it just starts playing music real loud.

1:29:17It doesn't seem,

1:29:19I don't know, it doesn't seem to me like it should,

1:29:22It seems like that's, I could see where it would like wake up

1:29:25and maybe, maybe, you know, Siri should say hello to you

1:29:29or something, if it hasn't been playing for,

1:29:33I don't know what the threshold is,

1:29:34but there's some threshold in ours

1:29:36where if it hasn't been playing music,

1:29:39I feel like just touching it should just sort of wake it up.

1:29:42I'm not quite sure what wake it up means,

1:29:44but I, you know, more or less the prompt you get

1:29:47when you just hold the side button on the phone.

1:29:50- Right, yeah.

1:29:51think it should just start playing. When it is playing, of course, tapping it to pause it is

1:29:56fantastic. It makes all the sense in the world. But just randomly starting to play when you touch it

1:30:02is surprising.

1:30:04>> Well, I'm interested to get it. I'm interested to fiddle with it. I don't know if it's gonna be

1:30:11something that I wind up using or if it's something that I test with, and then that's sort of the end

1:30:15of it. But like I said, I'm definitely interested to see longer term whether this is something that

1:30:20you know, do you think, how about that?

1:30:22Do you think they have a HomePod 2 in development already

1:30:26with, I don't even know what features we think it would have

1:30:29but you know, do they, do you think they have a

1:30:31chain of these or is it something like the iPod HiFi

1:30:34where they made one and that was it?

1:30:36- I think it's more like Apple TV.

1:30:38And Apple TV had, at least in its current incarnation

1:30:43since it went to like a, you know, a TV OS

1:30:45with an app store, it had a very obvious

1:30:48next generation model with support for 4K.

1:30:51I know there are other changes too,

1:30:54but just specifically going, supporting 4K

1:30:57was an obvious need and there's no such thing in audio.

1:31:01Right, like, so I wouldn't be,

1:31:03I think this is sort of like Apple TV

1:31:06without even the obvious 4K upgrade

1:31:08and anything that's improved on this

1:31:11is all going to come on the software side

1:31:14in terms of either some kind of SDK

1:31:17so that other services like Spotify can be addressed directly by talking to the device,

1:31:25and so that apps, like things like podcast players, like Overcast and Castro, can be

1:31:33addressed by talking to the device without having your phone nearby, you know?

1:31:39Or even if it's only with your phone nearby, but some way where you can just talk to it.

1:31:44>> Well, so I guess the only -- so thinking about the hardware,

1:31:47the only obvious thing that you could do to change it would be what we were just talking about is

1:31:51having some sort of display screen on it, which given what you said about the Echo Show not --

1:31:58well, I guess we don't really know. We have no idea how well that's sold or anything,

1:32:00but it certainly has not been in the forefront when you're talking about the Echo. It doesn't

1:32:05necessarily seem like that would be the obvious thing to do with this. So, yeah, it definitely

1:32:09does seem like software is where this will get upgraded. So, that's, yeah, I don't know.

1:32:14The whole thing is interesting to me because they've been talking, they've said that they've

1:32:18been working on this for half a decade. And so, it's very much not, oh, we got to play catch up

1:32:24with a virtual assistant. It seems more like, oh, we have this thing and we can, you know, add a

1:32:29virtual assistant to it. So, we'll do that. That makes sense. But they didn't necessarily want to

1:32:35enter that virtual assistant market as much as they wanted to have a high quality speaker.

1:32:39Yeah. You know, and it's, you know, a lot of people, people who are already invested in

1:32:44Spotify are very, very down on the thing. And I don't blame them if you really are.

1:32:48And talking to a couple of, I'm not, I have like a free Spotify account that I only use for poking

1:32:53around on it. But talking to various friends over the last week or two, some of them are really into

1:32:59Spotify. It sounds like Spotify has some fantastic features, some really interesting features in

1:33:05terms of not telling Spotify to play, you know, having something specific to play in mind, but

1:33:11being able to tell Spotify what you're in the mood for and based on your previous preferences,

1:33:17it's like getting a radio station that is just perfect for you and it plays things that you-

1:33:22Well, it's what Pandora, you know, claimed to do a decade ago and is still around and still trying

1:33:27to do. But yeah, it seems like Spotify has gotten the intelligence of music recommendations pretty

1:33:33well done at this point. Right. I guess the two main things are playing things that you do like

1:33:38but weren't in your mind to ask for and like, "Oh, I love this song," and be exposing you to

1:33:44new music that you might like. Whereas if you only ever ask for what you like or what you already know

1:33:51that you want to listen to right now, it's very different. And I'm not saying that that's how

1:33:55HomePod works, I mean, although that's how mostly how I tested it.

1:34:00You know, and a big factor in that, though, is the limit the current limitation of HomePod

1:34:06only being tied to one iCloud account, which, you know, I spent a fair amount of time on

1:34:10my review.

1:34:11And it's I understand it, especially for a 1.0.

1:34:13But it's, it certainly is obvious to me that the way this product should work is that,

1:34:22at least in the size of a typical household

1:34:24with two, three, five people,

1:34:29it should be able to have five people's iCloud music accounts

1:34:34and identify them by voice.

1:34:38And the competing products, and you say,

1:34:40well, this isn't science fiction,

1:34:43but the other products already do this.

1:34:45The Google products can identify people by voice

1:34:48and the Amazon, and tie them to different Google accounts.

1:34:52So like with the Google products,

1:34:55you can tell it to add an event to your calendar,

1:34:58and it adds it to your Google calendar,

1:35:00'cause it both recognizes your voice

1:35:02and knows which Google account is yours,

1:35:05and then I can ask it to add event to my calendar,

1:35:07and it knows my voice and can add it to my calendar.

1:35:10So it's not like me saying that the HomePod should do this

1:35:15is asking for something outlandish,

1:35:16it's something that competing products do.

1:35:19And for building up--

1:35:19- Are there any Apple devices besides the Mac

1:35:23that do profiles?

1:35:25- No, I don't think so.

1:35:26- Like your phone obviously doesn't,

1:35:28your phone that makes a decent amount of sense,

1:35:30that's your device,

1:35:31even if you have kids or something like that.

1:35:32iPads are one that people have been,

1:35:35I think clamoring for for years to have profiles on.

1:35:37- Right from the beginning.

1:35:38I remember people saying,

1:35:39this would be fantastic in school,

1:35:40but why can't I have profiles?

1:35:43Apple TV is one where individual apps

1:35:47definitely have profiles.

1:35:48You know, if you load up Netflix,

1:35:49it'll ask you who's watching,

1:35:51but there's not an overarching profile

1:35:54where you can just say, okay, now Paul's watching,

1:35:56now John's watching, and just show me my apps

1:35:58or show me my recommendations or whatever.

1:36:02It seems like something that they don't do currently,

1:36:05besides on the Mac, obviously.

1:36:06- Yeah, it seems like a blind spot for the company.

1:36:08I thought about that as an angle for the review,

1:36:10that they're so, you know, their roots as a quote unquote

1:36:15personal computer company really still show through

1:36:20to today, right?

1:36:21And like with a watch, it makes all the sense in the world.

1:36:24You know? - Right.

1:36:25- But with the TV, it makes no sense.

1:36:28And even with the way that they've changed their TV app

1:36:32in the last year to make it, try to make it like your hub

1:36:35for watching stuff. - Right, exactly.

1:36:37- From multiple sources, like pick up on this show

1:36:40you were watching on Hulu or pick up on this other show

1:36:45that you're watching on Amazon Prime

1:36:47or watch this new movie release from iTunes.

1:36:52It's like it's based on the aggregate viewing

1:36:55of everybody in your house, not on you,

1:36:57which really doesn't make a lot of sense.

1:36:59- Doesn't make any sense, yeah.

1:37:01And now I'm trying to remember, OS 9 and earlier,

1:37:04did that not have users?

1:37:06- No, definitely did not.

1:37:08- There might have been some kind of weird,

1:37:11cheaty move towards the end that was like in a,

1:37:16I wish Syracuse were here, but it was,

1:37:18there might have been-- - That's what I'm trying to,

1:37:19I'm trying to go back in time 20 years at this point,

1:37:22but LS-10 is clearly where,

1:37:24that's definitely built around individual users

1:37:27and you have a home folder

1:37:28and you can have 10 home folders on your computer

1:37:31if you have 10 people in your house

1:37:32and everybody can use the same computer.

1:37:33- And everybody can be equal.

1:37:35You can even make everybody an admin.

1:37:37It's not-- - An admin on it, exactly.

1:37:39- You can't, you're not even limited to,

1:37:41well, one person can be the admin

1:37:43and everybody else can be a non-admin user.

1:37:45You can even grant admin privileges to everybody in the house

1:37:48if you want and trust them with the computer.

1:37:50And the non-admin users aren't really limited

1:37:55from what they can do other than modifying

1:37:57the system software and installing apps and stuff like that.

1:38:01- Right, whereas the TV-- - It truly is--

1:38:02- Like you said, that's the big one to me,

1:38:04that the TV and the iPad,

1:38:06where these sorts of things make perfect sense,

1:38:08but I think you're right, it's not in their DNA

1:38:11as a personal computing company,

1:38:12and I think in OS X it sort of happened almost incidentally

1:38:15because they built it on Unix.

1:38:17- Yeah, and Netflix has a great interface for it.

1:38:20Netflix, I'm not even quite sure what their algorithm is,

1:38:23but their algorithm seems to be,

1:38:25if you haven't fired up Netflix,

1:38:28if you've, you know, we've got three family members

1:38:29on one Netflix account, and you know,

1:38:32you fire up the Apple TV

1:38:33and you haven't watched Netflix in a while,

1:38:35it'll say who's watching, and there's the three of us,

1:38:38and you pick who it is, and then it shows stuff

1:38:40based on what you've watched before.

1:38:42And it seems like if you have watched recently,

1:38:46it just assumes that you're the person

1:38:48who was watching recently, but if you want to,

1:38:50you can go back and manually change it to the other person.

1:38:55- Right, if you dip out of it to go back to the home screen,

1:38:57it doesn't immediately ask you who it is again.

1:39:00- Yeah.

1:39:00- But after, yeah, you're right, I don't know

1:39:02what the time is, because I've never thought about it,

1:39:04because it's always just worked the way I expected it to.

1:39:07- Oh my God, it was like a year ago,

1:39:09I had to sit Jonas down and say,

1:39:11you know what, don't be lazy,

1:39:13you've gotta switch this goddamn thing.

1:39:14'Cause my Netflix thing is--

1:39:16- Oh, you're getting the worst recommendations

1:39:17in the world, right?

1:39:18- It was filled up with 30 seasons of Friends.

1:39:22(laughing)

1:39:24- I think Amy told me this, like Friends got big

1:39:27with the middle school crowd last year.

1:39:29- Yeah, like last year--

1:39:30- I don't understand.

1:39:31- It was like a nationwide craze.

1:39:33Jonas watched the entire series of Friends

1:39:36from first episode to last twice.

1:39:38But he did like the first season of it,

1:39:42or first year of it, or first run through the whole thing

1:39:44on my Netflix account, which I honestly have no interest

1:39:48in rewatching Friends, and it really,

1:39:52he watched a couple other stupid things too,

1:39:54and it was all, he understood it, that's the worst part,

1:39:56he totally understood it.

1:39:57He just didn't feel like going back, you know, one level.

1:40:00- Two clicks to get back to his profile.

1:40:02- Son of a bitch.

1:40:03Kids are angry.

1:40:06Hey, let me take a break here

1:40:07and thank our third and final sponsor of the show.

1:40:09It's our good friends at Fracture.

1:40:11Fracture is a company that you send them your photos,

1:40:15they print them directly on glass.

1:40:18And they do this, each one is handmade with love and care

1:40:22in Gainesville, Florida from US Source Materials.

1:40:24And let me tell you something,

1:40:26I've said this back in November,

1:40:27said it I think in early December, but certainly November,

1:40:30These things make incredibly thoughtful, unique gifts.

1:40:33It's win, win, win, because you get,

1:40:37you get an easy place to go to buy the gift.

1:40:44The person you give it to, your friend, your family,

1:40:47who you give it to, gets a very thoughtful gift

1:40:49that's much more personal than anything

1:40:52you could just buy out of a store,

1:40:54and they'll appreciate it.

1:40:55I'm telling you, people love getting these things.

1:40:57And then the best part about it is,

1:41:00is you can just keep going back to the well

1:41:02and giving them as gifts again and again and again.

1:41:04Like I've said before, the worst thing about when you,

1:41:06if you're a bad gift giver like I am,

1:41:08and you finally give somebody who you really care

1:41:10about a gift that they're like, and that they tear up,

1:41:13and they're like, this is fantastic, thank you so much.

1:41:15Well, now you've gotta top it, right?

1:41:17And you can't, if it's like a store bought item,

1:41:19you can't just go and buy 'em the same thing again.

1:41:21Fracture prints, when you buy 'em as gifts,

1:41:23you can just keep going back and giving 'em again

1:41:25and again and again.

1:41:26Like if you've got kids you can take pictures of,

1:41:28or dogs, or if you go on a vacation

1:41:32with certain family members every year,

1:41:33just find a couple of good photos from the annual trip

1:41:36and make a fracture every Mother's Day

1:41:38or whatever holiday is coming up.

1:41:40You can keep going back to the well again and again

1:41:43and people don't, they don't think twice about it.

1:41:45It really is fantastic as a gift.

1:41:47I can't emphasize that.

1:41:49It's also great for filling your own home

1:41:51with pictures from your life.

1:41:54It really is, I can't say enough.

1:41:56And as our cameras get on our phones,

1:41:58especially get better and better.

1:41:59It's like you've got all of these fantastic photos

1:42:02and all you ever do is look at 'em on a five inch screen.

1:42:06It's almost unbelievable how good

1:42:10a modern iPhone picture looks when it's blown up

1:42:13to 18 inches or even bigger.

1:42:15It really does work.

1:42:17It's kinda crazy that we just look at 'em

1:42:19and flick at 'em at these little tiny

1:42:21index card sized screens.

1:42:23It's kinda stunning how good they look big.

1:42:27You can fill up all the walls in your house with these things.

1:42:30Really a great product.

1:42:31It comes, it's just a piece of glass.

1:42:33The picture is printed right on it, edge to edge, and everything you need to hang it up

1:42:37or display it comes in the box.

1:42:39They even include the wall hanger.

1:42:42It's a green company operating a carbon neutral factory.

1:42:46Visit fracture.me.

1:42:49fracture.me is their website.

1:42:50and save 15% on your first Fracture order

1:42:53with the exclusive code TALK15, T-A-L-K, for the talk show,

1:42:5815 for the 15% off you'll save.

1:43:01So don't forget to mention this podcast, The Talk Show,

1:43:04in their one question,

1:43:05where did you hear about Fracture from survey.

1:43:08It helps support the show and it helps them know

1:43:10that their advertising money is being put to good use.

1:43:13So my thanks to Fracture for their continued support

1:43:16of the talk show.

1:43:20sent some fractures to us, I believe. Isn't that true?

1:43:22(Laughter)

1:43:23I was just thinking about that. Amy and I did an episode of Just the Tip that revolved around

1:43:29what we called the fracture swap. And I was wondering where those are. I sent, I believe,

1:43:35basically, Fracture sponsored the show and they gave us basically like a credit to send

1:43:42photos to one another. And she sent me one large photo and I sent her, I think, about five different

1:43:49ridiculous photos that then we spent half an hour laughing about. But I was wondering where those

1:43:53photos are now. There's one of Danny DeVito's naked ass that should be hung in a prized place

1:43:59in your house. I'm they might be packed up, Paul. I bet they didn't make it through the move. That's

1:44:07my guess. And I'm hurt by it. But I understand. I believe one of them was Pete Rose, right? The

1:44:12all time hit came. Absolutely. Yeah. I'll include that one in the show notes. That was a good one.

1:44:18Pete Rose underwear model.

1:44:19He's a handsome man.

1:44:23I saw Pete Rose a couple weeks ago. I was in Vegas.

1:44:25How's he doing?

1:44:27Well, he's still signing autographs.

1:44:29And what's that go for? About 50 bucks a pop?

1:44:34I think so. It might be up to 100 depending on what you want him to sign. I think it might

1:44:38be a sign baseball. It might be 100 bucks. Very strange. Speaking of sports, we had the

1:44:47Super Bowl this last weekend. Did you watch the Super Bowl?

1:44:52Michael Scott I did watch the Super Bowl. I'm in Boston.

1:44:56And so, you know, it's certainly fairly mandatory to watch the Super Bowl when

1:45:00the local team is in it.

1:45:02Trenton Larkin I was out in Vegas for the Super Bowl,

1:45:05which I've done for the last few years. I don't know if you can hear it, my voice. I'm a little

1:45:09hoarse still. Do you hear it? Do I sound a little hoarse?

1:45:13Michael Scott You sound like you've had a weekend in Vegas.

1:45:16- It's a bad combination because it's dry desert air

1:45:21and it's really the last place I go in the world

1:45:28where people are still allowed to smoke cigarettes

1:45:31in public.

1:45:32I personally do not smoke.

1:45:34I've never really smoked.

1:45:35But there's a lot of,

1:45:39you effectively pick up a cigarette habit.

1:45:43(laughing)

1:45:44So I don't know how much of it to blame

1:45:46on the Dry Desert Air, I don't know how much to blame

1:45:49on the ambient cigarette smoke,

1:45:51and I don't know how much to blame on yelling and screaming

1:45:54during the game, but it was pretty wild.

1:45:58It was really-- - It was a good game.

1:46:00- I would honestly, in hindsight though, as time goes on,

1:46:02you end an exciting game, you know, like,

1:46:06you know, last year's game had a very exciting finish,

1:46:08and it had sort of a stunning fourth quarter,

1:46:10and you come out of it thinking,

1:46:11"My God, that was an extraordinary game."

1:46:14And then as the time settles on you,

1:46:16it settles in and you're like,

1:46:18well it was certainly an extraordinary fourth quarter,

1:46:21but it wasn't really an exciting game.

1:46:23The first three quarters were actually rather unexciting.

1:46:27- You're talking about last year's Super Bowl.

1:46:29- Last year's Super Bowl.

1:46:30- Where it was a blowout for most of the game and then, yeah.

1:46:33- The Atlanta Falcons ran up a 28 to three lead

1:46:36on the New England Patriots. - That's right.

1:46:38- Until late in the third quarter,

1:46:41I believe the third quarter finished 28 to 10.

1:46:44And so they still had an 18-point lead going into the fourth quarter, but they had been

1:46:47up 25 points late in the third quarter.

1:46:51And then everything went to hell for the Atlanta Falcons.

1:46:54Whereas this year's Super Bowl was truly, in hindsight, really, in a moment it felt

1:47:00like it was terribly exciting throughout.

1:47:04It was certainly terribly exciting for me as somebody with a large, large wager on the

1:47:08Philadelphia Eagles.

1:47:10Were you one of the million dollar bets?

1:47:12I was not one of the million dollar bets.

1:47:14We were talking about that.

1:47:16That is crazy.

1:47:19They said there were about a half dozen and I think most more of them at least were for

1:47:22the Eagles.

1:47:23That was the consensus.

1:47:24So good for those people.

1:47:25Well word comes around.

1:47:26It's like when you're in Vegas for the Super Bowl weekend, it's just like who knows what's

1:47:32true and what's not.

1:47:33It's not like you go into the sports book where you place the bets and there's like

1:47:37a light up sign that says someone just placed a million dollar bet.

1:47:41But there's some kind of weird certainty that runs around where it's like somebody will

1:47:46say, "I heard somebody dropped a million dollars on Eagles."

1:47:49And then you're like, "Really?"

1:47:51And then somebody will say, "Oh, yeah, yeah.

1:47:52I heard it from my guy at the casino, his casino host," or something like that.

1:47:59What do you think the mechanics of dropping a million dollar bet on?

1:48:03We couldn't figure it out.

1:48:05Like you don't just want-

1:48:06Like how do you back that bet up?

1:48:08Right.

1:48:09my bet, which I could call and considered and certainly felt in my heart throughout

1:48:13the game a quote unquote large bet. My bet was placed with cash. You certainly couldn't

1:48:20do that with a million dollars.

1:48:21John "Slick" Baum: You could. I mean, a million bucks is like that's a suitcase worth, I think.

1:48:27Dave "Slick" Baum" Kelsky "Slick" Baum" Kelsky "Slick" Baum" Kelsky "Slick" Baum" Kelsky

1:48:28"Slick" Baum" Kelsky "Slick" Baum" Kelsky "Slick" Baum" Kelsky "Slick" Baum" Kelsky "Slick"

1:48:29Baum" Kelsky "Slick" Baum" Kelsky "Slick" Baum" Kelsky "Slick" Baum" Kelsky "Slick"

1:48:30I believe that you would have to set up some kind of a line of credit with the casino and

1:48:35maybe do a wire transfer or something like that to an account.

1:48:39And then I don't think...

1:48:40No, you know what it probably is.

1:48:42I think they just write a check.

1:48:44That's it.

1:48:45Well, I mean, this is America.

1:48:48You can just write a million dollar check and hand it to them and they'll walk it over

1:48:52to the bank.

1:48:54Now, you've been in Vegas with me and you've placed sports wagers before and when a normal

1:48:59punter like us goes up and maybe you would like to bet a hundred dollars pre-season on

1:49:06the Red Sox to win the World Series. And it'll pay, I don't know what the current odds are,

1:49:12I bet a Red Sox ticket right now off the top of my head probably pays eight to one or nine

1:49:16to one. So you can play, you know, put a hundred dollars down and then they'll print out a

1:49:22little ticket and it's almost like a receipt. It's a little white piece of paper with that

1:49:28heat type printing on it.

1:49:30- Right, thermal printed, that's super high quality.

1:49:32- Right, and then there's like a little,

1:49:34the equivalent of a QR code at the bottom,

1:49:36and then it'll tell you you've bet $100 at nine to one.

1:49:39And then you can hold that until the World Series is over,

1:49:41and if you win, you can either fly back to Vegas

1:49:44and cash it in, or you can mail it in,

1:49:46and they'll send you a check for your $900.

1:49:48I'm gonna guess when you place a million dollar bet,

1:49:52they don't just print out a little

1:49:54thermal printed slip of paper.

1:49:57But I would love to know what they do print, right?

1:50:00What do they do?

1:50:03And just think about things, think about this.

1:50:05Let's say I go out and I bet $1,000 on the Eagles.

1:50:08And the game is over and the Eagles have won.

1:50:15But I've got a flight to catch.

1:50:16I could just hand you the ticket and I'll just say,

1:50:18Paul, just send me that 1,000 bucks.

1:50:20And I'm off in a cab to the airport

1:50:22and you can walk right up to the counter and hand it over.

1:50:25- Right, there's no verification.

1:50:27just having possession of the ticket is all you need.

1:50:29- They'll just pay you the thing.

1:50:32I'm gonna guess you can't do that with a million dollar.

1:50:34(laughing)

1:50:36Bet on this.

1:50:36- I think it's like a bearer bond.

1:50:38You know, whoever has possession of that slip of paper,

1:50:41it's worth a million bucks now and that's it.

1:50:44And actually, I guess that's the question.

1:50:46Was it a million dollar, were the bets,

1:50:48did they put down a million dollars?

1:50:50And then how much did they win?

1:50:52- Well, there's different ways to bet.

1:50:53So the two ways to bet on a game,

1:50:56If you take the point spread, and now in this game,

1:50:59the Patriots are favored by four,

1:51:01and if you bet on the Eagles on the point spread,

1:51:04you could add four and a half points to the final score

1:51:07in terms of satisfying them.

1:51:08- Right, the Eagles could have lost by up to four points.

1:51:10- Right, so if the Patriots had won by three or even four,

1:51:14they would have won the Super Bowl,

1:51:15and they would have been very happy,

1:51:17but if you bet on the Patriots, you would be unhappy

1:51:21because you would have lost your bet.

1:51:23And then the other thing you do

1:51:24is they call it the money line,

1:51:26where instead of any point spread,

1:51:27it's you bet on the team that wins,

1:51:29and the way that it's adjusted for who's favored

1:51:32and who's the underdog is it pays different odds.

1:51:35If I recall correctly from Sunday,

1:51:40the Eagles, I know what the Eagles went off at.

1:51:41The Eagles were called, were at plus 165,

1:51:44and that means a money line bet on the Eagles for $100,

1:51:48if they won, would pay $165.

1:51:52So however much you wanna bet on it,

1:51:54you'd multiply it by 1.65 and that's your payout.

1:51:58And the Patriots were the other way.

1:51:59I believe that when the game started,

1:52:01they were at minus 190, meaning you had to bet $190

1:52:06to win just $100 if the Patriots won.

1:52:12And the thing that-- - Right, so if you bet

1:52:14a million dollars on the Eagles at 165,

1:52:16you would get back 2.65 million, is that right?

1:52:20- That is correct, 'cause you would give them the mill--

1:52:22And when you place the bet, you give them the money.

1:52:24So they've already got your million dollars.

1:52:27And it's sort of like an escrow.

1:52:29Whereby escrow, I mean in the casinos.

1:52:33- In the vault. - In the vault.

1:52:35And then when it wins, you go over there

1:52:37with your little thermal ticket and they'll pay you.

1:52:40And the ticket will say, you've bet a million

1:52:42to pay 2.65 million to win 1.65 million.

1:52:47You give it to them and then they'll sit there

1:52:51count out 2.65 million in $100 bills.

1:52:54- Sure.

1:52:55(laughing)

1:52:56I don't know why we didn't do this.

1:52:59It sounds like loads of fun

1:53:01and you wouldn't have been at all nervous

1:53:03when the Pats threw a Hail Mary at the end of the game.

1:53:06- Oh God, I was dying.

1:53:09'Cause it seemed like exactly the sort of play

1:53:10that they would make.

1:53:14It really did. - Make the completion,

1:53:15get the two point conversion, go to OT, win by six.

1:53:18- Right.

1:53:19- With another touchdown,

1:53:20us like last year, yeah. Well, so this is interesting, though. I mentioned we should

1:53:24talk about this because you live in Philly, and I live in New England, but you're a Cowboys fan.

1:53:28That is correct.

1:53:29So if anything, I mean, you said you placed a bet on the Eagles, so I guess you're rooting for the

1:53:34Eagles. But if anything, you should be rooting against the Eagles. I know I have plenty of

1:53:38friends who are Giants fans who are rooting for the Pats, which felt weird to them, but...

1:53:43I re- well, I remember specifically, it's funny, the last time the Eagles were in the Super Bowl,

1:53:47I don't remember the year. I think it was 2006 though. I could be wrong

1:53:502005 and that was it was against the Pats right against the Pats and I was never been a fan of the Patriots

1:53:57I was ambivalent a bit ambivalent about that game

1:54:00I don't remember which way my gut swung

1:54:03but it wasn't very hard in either direction because I don't like the Eagles because they're a division rival of the Cowboys and I

1:54:09Right as a Cowboys fan in Philadelphia. I have numerous friends who we have

1:54:15friendly rivalry about that issue with

1:54:17And I don't like the Patriots because they cheat

1:54:21and

1:54:25To be honest, I really don't like the Patriots because as a Cowboys fan what I really like about the Cowboys is that they

1:54:32are a historically great team and that they've won five Super Bowls and I

1:54:38Would like for the Cowboys to be the team that has the most Super Bowl victories

1:54:44But right now with the Cowboys have been stuck at five since I don't know. I was like 20 years old. It's been a long time

1:54:50They're in a very long extended rut stuck at five. I believe when they last one or right no 95 or 696

1:54:58I think is that right? One in 93 95 and 96?

1:55:02No, no, they want they want in to they want back-to-back years because that's where I was going with this

1:55:08Right was that they played the bills two years in a row, right?

1:55:11And they had the blowout against -- so, I mentioned my parents are from Buffalo, so I grew up a Bills fan

1:55:16and had the love of football just beaten right out of me because the Bills lost to the Giants,

1:55:23to the Washington Redskins, to the Cowboys in the biggest blowout in history. And then I was

1:55:29actually at Super Bowl XXVIII, which was in '94, I'm pretty sure, and watched them lose their fourth

1:55:36Super Bowl in a row. Right. Which is astounding. I mean, it's an incredible feat. I'd probably

1:55:43never be equaled. Just getting to four Super Bowls in a row is tremendous. In a league,

1:55:47in any league it would be impressive, but in the NFL in particular you tend to have teams

1:55:51come out of nowhere to get to the Super Bowl and then drop out of the Super Bowl and, you know,

1:55:56be nowhere the next year. So, this past weekend we had you, a Philadelphia resident who likes the

1:56:03the Cowboys who was sort of cheering for the Phillies, for the Eagles rather.

1:56:06No, I was all in on the Eagles. I was all in in this case because the Patriots have

1:56:10only only extended their argument to be the greatest team of all time, so I need

1:56:15that to stop. You want that to stop? I want that to stop, and I just generally

1:56:19find them to be unlikable people. I really do. I, you know, it was noted

1:56:24after the game that when the game was over, Tom Brady didn't go to the

1:56:28midfield to shake hands with the Eagles quarterback Nick Foles. He just went

1:56:32right to the locker room.

1:56:34I, you know, I mean, I don't think that's a huge deal.

1:56:37I mean, you just lost a heartbreaker.

1:56:38Who knows, I might do that.

1:56:39I'm a very poor loser, to be honest.

1:56:42Honestly, I might do the same thing.

1:56:44I wouldn't wanna go shake somebody's hand.

1:56:46But this rubs me the wrong way.

1:56:48I don't know, I don't like 'em.

1:56:49And I happen to, even as a Cowboys fan

1:56:51who generally is predisposed to just like anybody,

1:56:54any other team from the NFC East,

1:56:56this particular Eagles team this year

1:56:58is extraordinarily likable.

1:57:01I said it to Moltz last week,

1:57:02that they've got these guys who are just likable guys.

1:57:04I mean, the one guy donated his whole salary

1:57:07to local schools.

1:57:08I mean, how do you not love that?

1:57:09I mean, it's just like-- - That's right.

1:57:11- Boy, that just seems like,

1:57:12and they're just doing great things in the city.

1:57:14They've been doing it since before this

1:57:16really reached a fever pitch,

1:57:17but they're just really good guys.

1:57:19- And they sold all those dog masks.

1:57:23So, I mean, that's good for somebody.

1:57:25- So anyway, we had to record today

1:57:27because tomorrow we're having a parade here in Philadelphia,

1:57:30and by, where by parade, it pretty much means

1:57:33the entire city is shut down.

1:57:35I mean, like literally, like they're,

1:57:37they're shutting the city down tonight.

1:57:39And I don't think they're real.

1:57:41- So are the schools closed?

1:57:42- Schools are closed, man.

1:57:43They're not even pretending that kids are going to school.

1:57:45There's no school.

1:57:47Schools are closed, which is really kind of awesome.

1:57:50I honestly, I mean, it's,

1:57:51Jonas has never been more interested in sports

1:57:53than when he found out that he gets out of a day at school.

1:57:56- He could get a day off of school.

1:57:58- Yeah.

1:57:59And you know, I just don't think people,

1:58:01people don't realize it's, you know,

1:58:03it really means a lot to this city.

1:58:06It's a city that hasn't had a championship team

1:58:08since the 2008 Phillies, and prior to the 2008 Phillies,

1:58:11I said this last week, I should have double checked.

1:58:12- 25 years.

1:58:14- Before that, it was the '83 Sixers.

1:58:16And that's a long, '83 to 2008 sounds like a long time.

1:58:20And from '83 until Sunday,

1:58:22only have one sneak in the middle was the Phillies.

1:58:25It's, you know, it's been a long time.

1:58:27But of all the teams in the city,

1:58:29the one that's the most beloved is the Eagles,

1:58:31without question.

1:58:32I don't think there's anybody,

1:58:33it doesn't matter how big a Sixers fan or Phillies fan

1:58:35or even, or certainly Flyers fan that you might be,

1:58:38no one would argue that this isn't an Eagles town.

1:58:41And there's nothing they want more than to win a Super Bowl.

1:58:43And they went 52 Super Bowls

1:58:46and only made it to two and lost both.

1:58:48So people went nuts.

1:58:50And to have them win it in quite arguably

1:58:54the most extraordinary Super Bowl game in history

1:58:58is just icing on the cake.

1:59:00I mean, and again, I know there's probably some people

1:59:02who've already stopped the show, but that's all right.

1:59:04But if you're into it, it's mathematically,

1:59:07it's extraordinary that in the,

1:59:09it's not in the history of the Super Bowl,

1:59:11which is 52 games, or the history of the playoffs

1:59:15in the NFL, which is, I guess, a thousand or so games.

1:59:19In the history of the NFL, every game

1:59:21that has ever been played in the National Football League,

1:59:25the game on Sunday had the most total yardage ever.

1:59:29And it was by a long shot.

1:59:30They broke the record in the third quarter.

1:59:33In the third quarter, they had already racked up

1:59:35more total yardage between both offenses

1:59:37than any game in the NFL.

1:59:40And when I was watching, I was watching in this big,

1:59:42big room in Vegas in a casino filled with,

1:59:45I don't know, a couple thousand people

1:59:47and all of these big jumbotrons and real noisy.

1:59:52That's so noisy that that's why I think

1:59:54half the reason I'm a horse.

1:59:56But everybody was just sort of looking at each other

1:59:59like in the third quarter.

2:00:00Like when the first half was terribly exciting.

2:00:04And then you got the big long halftime show

2:00:06and then the third quarter starts up

2:00:08and third quarter just takes it up a notch on both sides.

2:00:10And neither team, every time every team touches the ball,

2:00:13they score.

2:00:14And everybody was just sort of looking at each other

2:00:16saying like, am I drunk, what's going on?

2:00:20This is like crazy, right?

2:00:21This is crazy.

2:00:22And when they came up with that stat

2:00:23that this was the most yardage in any game,

2:00:26not any playoff game, any game ever,

2:00:28and we're only in the third quarter.

2:00:29And it's the Super Bowl,

2:00:31which is often a very defensive game.

2:00:33We were like, okay, this is crazy.

2:00:35- Well, that was the thing.

2:00:37Nobody was playing defense.

2:00:38I mean, if you like defensive football,

2:00:40this was not a very good game at all.

2:00:41- Right.

2:00:43That's my theory.

2:00:44My fundamental theory is where pro football is going.

2:00:45- All the stats I saw were that, like, sorry, go ahead.

2:00:49- Well, my fundamental theory is that

2:00:50that's where football's going,

2:00:52is to be a more basketball-like game, meaning--

2:00:55- Just constant scoring.

2:00:56- Yeah, constant scoring and a faster pace.

2:01:00Both teams-- - I was gonna say,

2:01:04all the stats I saw were about,

2:01:06it was about the Pats and how they're,

2:01:09they got over 600 yards,

2:01:10and that's the only time anyone

2:01:11has ever lost a game doing that.

2:01:13And they got all these great records,

2:01:15except for the fact that they lost this game.

2:01:17- Right, so Brady personally had 500-plus yards passing

2:01:21and three touchdowns and no interceptions

2:01:24and no quarterback who's ever done that.

2:01:26Again, in every single game that league has ever played

2:01:29for like roughly 100 years, probably about 90 years,

2:01:33every game that's ever happened,

2:01:36any time a quarterback has done that, they've won the game.

2:01:38Because you would think, "Well, how could you lose?"

2:01:41(laughs)

2:01:42Right?

2:01:43Well, you can lose--

2:01:44- 'Cause your defense was just slightly worse

2:01:45than the other team's defense.

2:01:46- And the other team only had one time

2:01:49that they touched the ball that they didn't score.

2:01:51Both teams, I believe, had one time they touched the ball

2:01:53that didn't score.

2:01:54One time the Eagles punted, and then at the end of the game,

2:01:56towards the end of the game,

2:01:58one time Brady got hit and fumbled.

2:02:01- Yep, I know they didn't punt, so that sounds right.

2:02:04- Well, usually when you watch,

2:02:05and historically at least when you watch the Super Bowl,

2:02:08you think, "My God, it's hard to score in this league."

2:02:10You either have to do something crazy,

2:02:12or you gotta get a lucky break, or whatever.

2:02:15And there's times where it's like, "Punt, punt, punt,"

2:02:18and you're like, "My God, there's no way,

2:02:19"how does anybody score in this game?"

2:02:21Whereas in that game it was like,

2:02:22(laughing)

2:02:24does the other team even have 11 men on the field?

2:02:26(laughing)

2:02:29- Well, congratulations to the city of Philadelphia.

2:02:33- Oh, it's gonna be something.

2:02:34Hopefully the city stands up to this.

2:02:36(laughing)

2:02:38You know, I guess they're greasing the polls again.

2:02:41I heard that they were not going to grease the polls.

2:02:43I think I told Moltz last week they were gonna stop

2:02:46because the idea was that they criscoed up the polls.

2:02:49We have a tradition here in town

2:02:50where when a Philadelphia team wins,

2:02:53the fans will climb up the street poles for whatever reason.

2:02:58So the cops-- - It's what you do.

2:03:02- Well, the cops to, I don't know, fight against this

2:03:07'cause they don't want people to--

2:03:09- Prevent this, yeah. - Prevent it.

2:03:10They greased them up with Crisco before the Vikings came,

2:03:15and it didn't stop them.

2:03:17And then you're the one who sent me the link that they,

2:03:19What'd you say?

2:03:20They're training for this.

2:03:20That in South Philadelphia,

2:03:22it's a tradition like on certain holidays.

2:03:24- During like an Italian festival or something.

2:03:26- That they grease, they themselves grease the poles

2:03:30and then they have a contest.

2:03:32- And then they put something on top of the pole,

2:03:34grease it, and then everybody tries to climb it.

2:03:36So yeah, they're training for this event.

2:03:38- And so that didn't work.

2:03:40They criss-coed up the poles and people climbed them anyway.

2:03:43And so the word was,

2:03:44they're not gonna criss-co them up again.

2:03:46But what they did is they replaced it

2:03:48some sort of industrial grease. I don't know how much better it worked.

2:03:50Yeah, it was like some kind of oil or something, yeah.

2:03:53Yeah.

2:03:53Well, so did it work, though? I saw a bunch of street poles on the ground.

2:03:58I don't know if that was from climbing or just destruction in general.

2:04:01Yeah, maybe people getting angry that they were so well greased up, where it's like,

2:04:04"Well, if I can't climb it, I'm going to take it down."

2:04:07I might as well knock it over.

2:04:08I don't know how you do that. I really don't. I saw there were a couple of street poles

2:04:12knocked over, and I guess if you just get a couple people rocking it back and forth,

2:04:16you can do it, but it's certain, you know, I've walked by and just given them a knock this week,

2:04:21and it certainly seems like most of them are pretty sturdy. So it's pretty impressive.

2:04:25Hopefully the parade will go off. All right.

2:04:26And is it it doesn't go by your house? Does it? Did you say it goes by Jonas's school?

2:04:33It does. It does.

2:04:35Right by the school. Yeah. He might not have a school come Friday.

2:04:40Yes. He's the luckiest kid in the world. That's what he's not only does he get a day off,

2:04:45He gets the whole rest of the year off.

2:04:47- Yeah, he's rooting for chaos.

2:04:48We're nearby at Center City, Philadelphia,

2:04:49is very, very small, given the size of Philadelphia proper.

2:04:53Center City, Philadelphia is very small.

2:04:55So we're nearby, we could walk.

2:04:56We have a couple of choices of which way to go.

2:04:59But I think our house will be all right.

2:05:02I don't know.

2:05:03Anything else you wanted to talk about, Paul?

2:05:07- No, I think we covered it.

2:05:10I mean, I don't know how much you get into the politics,

2:05:15But I did have -- I did a quick interview that I thought maybe we could just real quick touch on.

2:05:20And, you know, feel free to cut this out, but I was able to reach my good pal, Barry Oboms,

2:05:27and I got his take on the current president of the United States. And it's just a five-second take.

2:05:34I don't know if you'd like to hear what Barry Oboms thinks of President Donald Trump.

2:05:38Now you know that guy ain't shit.

2:05:40Sorry this motherfucker got nothing on me, right?

2:05:43Nothing.

2:05:44(laughing)

2:05:46- And you know, it's from the heart he spoke, so.

2:05:49(laughing)

2:05:51- Letting it fly.

2:05:52- Let it out there.

2:05:54- Telling it as it is.

2:05:55My thanks to Paul and his sidekick, Farrago, over there.

2:06:00I've got some links, I promise they'll be in the show notes.

2:06:04There's a great designing Farrago story

2:06:07on the Rogue Amoeba blog talking about the design of it.

2:06:11It's a terrific app, hope it does very well.

2:06:13And I don't know, I'm not sure what to say.

2:06:16It's like I almost wish that the Patriots

2:06:18had gotten blown out, I could stick it to you.

2:06:20I feel like there's something noble

2:06:22in a five-time championship team

2:06:24also having the single greatest performance,

2:06:29and indisputably the single greatest performance

2:06:31in a loss in Super Bowl history.

2:06:32- In a loss, yeah. - Right?

2:06:34Like there's some way to measure,

2:06:36like when you count the greatness of teams in all times,

2:06:40certain losses are better than others,

2:06:42you know what I mean?

2:06:43Like your Buffalo Bills, the time that they lost

2:06:44on a wide right kick at the last second by two points,

2:06:49well that counts for something different

2:06:50than when the Cowboys beat 'em 55 to 10

2:06:52or whatever the hell the score was.

2:06:54- That's what it was, it was 55 to 10.

2:06:56- So I would say scoring a touchdown

2:06:58every time you have the ball except once

2:07:01and then still scoring a minute later.

2:07:03(laughs)

2:07:04Almost scoring a minute later.

2:07:05Certainly counts for something.

2:07:08There's something, certainly, it's certainly a noble loss.

2:07:11Oh, did you see the crazy thing before we signed off?

2:07:14Did you see the crazy thing with the offensive coordinator

2:07:16on the Pats?

2:07:19- Yeah, Josh McDaniels.

2:07:20- Josh McDaniels had agreed--

2:07:22- He was supposed to go to Indy and be their head coach.

2:07:25- And had gotten so far that they had already scheduled

2:07:28a charter plane to take him there today

2:07:30for the big introduction,

2:07:31and he'd already signed a bunch of assistant coaches

2:07:34who quit their jobs at other teams

2:07:36and had already been signed

2:07:38and are under contract for next year.

2:07:40And somehow Belichick and team owner Bob Kraft said,

2:07:45"Hey, maybe you wanna stay?"

2:07:48And he said, "Okay, Indianapolis, nevermind."

2:07:51(laughing)

2:07:52- It's a real kick in the pants for the Colts,

2:07:55but they deserve whatever they get

2:07:58for stealing the team in the first place, so whatever.

2:08:00Yeah, sort of. I kind of had the same thought there where it's kind of what you get.

2:08:05Anybody who doesn't know the backstory on that, the Indianapolis Colts, long story short,

2:08:09in terms of you want to think like, "Hey, I feel that doesn't sound right that a team

2:08:12would lose their new coach like that." But what happened with the Indianapolis Colts

2:08:16was they were the Baltimore Colts, the beloved Baltimore Colts for decades. And the team

2:08:22owner, Art, what was his name? Modell? Art Modell, for whatever reason, decided he would

2:08:29and moved the team to Indianapolis

2:08:30and knew it wouldn't be popular.

2:08:32And so he had a bunch of moving trucks show up

2:08:35literally in the middle of the night in Baltimore

2:08:37and moved everything out of their stadium

2:08:39in the middle of the night

2:08:41and drove it all to Indianapolis

2:08:43and then announced it there

2:08:45that they were leaving the city of Baltimore.

2:08:48Needless to say, did not go well in Baltimore.

2:08:52I forget if it was Art Modell was the owner.

2:08:54Art Modell might have been the--

2:08:55- No, you solid the wrong man.

2:08:56He's the one that eventually got the Ravens.

2:08:58- He's the Browns, right? - He was the Browns owner.

2:09:00Exactly. - All right, all right.

2:09:01Sorry for-- - It was Bob Irsay.

2:09:03It was the father of the current owner.

2:09:05- That's right, that's right, Irsay, right.

2:09:07- So they got exactly what they deserved.

2:09:09- Modell's the guy who screwed Cleveland over,

2:09:11not screwed Baltimore over.

2:09:14- Well, but he didn't screw Cleveland

2:09:15over the way Baltimore got screwed over

2:09:17'cause when they left Cleveland,

2:09:18Cleveland knew they were getting a team back

2:09:21in like two years or something.

2:09:22- And that they would get to keep the name.

2:09:24- The Browns name, exactly.

2:09:25He didn't steal, that's exactly right.

2:09:27He didn't steal the Browns name.

2:09:28- Right.

2:09:29- He took the team, but--

2:09:30- And when you have a storied success,

2:09:32like the Cleveland Browns.

2:09:33- Like the Cleveland Browns.

2:09:35- Where the only good thing in your team's history

2:09:40was the great Jim Brown, who so hated the team owner

2:09:44that while he was indisputably the single greatest player

2:09:48active in the league, he quit,

2:09:50so he could just go make action movies.

2:09:55When that's the finest achievement

2:09:56your franchise has ever achieved,

2:09:58you certainly wanna keep that name and brand.

2:10:00- You gotta hold onto that name, yeah.

2:10:02And that beautiful color scheme.

2:10:04- Yeah. (laughs)

2:10:07Anyway, Paul Kefastas, "Rogamy," but thank you very much.

2:10:10It's always a pleasure to have you on.

2:10:11I'll see you in 100 episodes.