Podcast Search

The Talk Show

212: ‘Arbiter of Finallys’ With Rene Ritchie

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00So you, this is amazing, might as well open up with it.

0:00:02There's, I'm reading Twitter last night and all of a sudden I'm thumbing through my Twitter

0:00:07and there's a picture of you with Tim Cook at a Maple Leafs game.

0:00:13Yeah.

0:00:14I was as surprised as anybody.

0:00:16How the hell did that happen?

0:00:19So I didn't know.

0:00:21I was just, like I thought there was going to be just some briefing.

0:00:24Apple does a lot of these and you do them too.

0:00:26they would announce something about Hour of Code, or they're going to do a French version,

0:00:31or they're going to have Canadian-specific content or something. I had no idea. And then

0:00:36I see the Globe and Mail says Tim Cook is in Canada for a code, and he just dropped

0:00:41by. He does this. They don't announce it. I'm guessing for security reasons, but also

0:00:46because it's Apple and it's all about surprise and delight. He just crashed the code session

0:00:50at the Apple store. And people love that kind of stuff. And he did a couple of interviews

0:00:55while he was there. And I'm like, "Oh, if I had known, I would have gone. I mean, it's

0:00:59not that far. It would have been awesome." I'm like, "Oh, too bad." But then I was supposed

0:01:02to do this meeting later. And then they were very quiet about it. And eventually I just

0:01:09got a call saying, "Come here, do this, do that." And then, "Okay, Tim's here." And I

0:01:14just like, "Okay, wow." And he was watching the Leafs game. He was sitting down there

0:01:19with one of the Hockey Night in Canada announcers, former hockey player, just enjoying the show.

0:01:25And then he came up and said hi to some of the Apple people there.

0:01:28And then I was towards the back of the line, and then eventually I got a chance to say

0:01:32hi to him as well.

0:01:38That's amazing.

0:01:39Who won the game?

0:01:40The Maple Leafs did not win the game.

0:01:42The team formerly known as the Quebec Nordique, which I think now use some weird name like

0:01:46the Colorado Avalanche one.

0:01:48Hmm.

0:01:49Americans take a lot of Canadian teams and make them super successful, so we're a little

0:01:54bit bitter. All right. So it's a good thing. It's funny because I originally was going

0:02:01to try to record this with you yesterday, which was Monday, the 22nd of January. And

0:02:09instead we had to push it back till today, the 23rd. And in the meantime, he went to

0:02:13a hockey game with Tim Cook and Apple. Can I say finally, I believe I'm the arbiter

0:02:22of finalies, of appropriate finalies. And I'm going to give this a finally plus a

0:02:31pending finally. They've finally announced that HomePod is coming out and what the schedule

0:02:38is. Orders start this coming Friday, probably a few days after this episode lands, and it

0:02:47start shipping two weeks after that on February the 9th and I guess it will be in retail stores

0:02:52at the same time too. Presumably there will be reviews in between as we record and February 9th,

0:03:03but I don't know anything about that yet. No, and we can't even draw upon AirPods because those,

0:03:09I mean, they originally planned to get those out earlier and they seeded them and then they didn't

0:03:14get it out. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, that was weird. Because we got

0:03:17priest. It is funny. And I will come back to that. Because the

0:03:21more we learn about home pod, the more it really does kind of

0:03:25seem like AirPods as speakers. Yes, that's exactly the way I

0:03:32would describe it. And it's similar even down to the fact of

0:03:36being late. But one difference is that when AirPods were on the

0:03:43the cusp of shipping a year ago. Did you get up the pre release

0:03:47pair? I don't think that I think they were seated pretty

0:03:50liberally. We got pre release air pods that, in my experience

0:03:58using them was indistinguishable from the final ones, although I

0:04:01think maybe, although I don't know if it was a hardware thing

0:04:05or subsequent software things. As much as I loved them right

0:04:11the first day with the prototypes, I have to say that now, a year later, I think they're

0:04:16even more reliable than before. But they were very serious about those being prototypes.

0:04:25And when they shipped the shipping ones, they wanted those prototypes back in the mail the

0:04:29next day. It was the only review product I've ever gotten from Apple where there was any

0:04:35hint of pressure of "send it back right now."

0:04:38It's like I wondered if there was like, maybe it didn't use lithium ion, maybe it used kryptonite

0:04:42as the battery just to make it work.

0:04:44I don't know.

0:04:45The demeanor was always Apple friendly.

0:04:48It was always, it wasn't like they sent the Brute Squad, big angry people to come collect

0:04:56them.

0:04:57But it was, get them in the mail.

0:05:02I have no idea why.

0:05:05I think just in general, Apple is one of those companies that they don't want pre-release

0:05:08stuff out there because you never know what's going to happen to it.

0:05:10So, who knows what the difference is? I think that because these are a little bit less of

0:05:17a justice, you know, there is some similarities to AirPods, but I don't think, I'm not surprised

0:05:23that they didn't seed prototype HomePods outside the company.

0:05:27Yeah. Although they did a huge seeding of prototype HomePods inside the company.

0:05:33I have heard the same thing that it was pretty widespread internal seating amongst employees.

0:05:40And you know, I guess we in geographies beyond what they've already announced.

0:05:44Yeah. And I think that doesn't that go all the way back to the big on the eve of the

0:05:50iPhone 10 and iPhone eight announcement the it was a HomePod firmware update that leaked

0:06:00a bunch of details like the name iPhone with a capital X that we didn't know how to pronounce.

0:06:06It was a HomePod release. And I guess the reason that that was even possibly on and

0:06:11over the, you know, public to the world server was that they were already at the time, seated

0:06:17widely within the company to people to use it on. Absolutely. Alright, so the that's

0:06:22the dates, the price is the same. I don't think we learned much more about the functionality

0:06:29from the updated product page. But my pending finally is that in some very small print,

0:06:40not one of the headlines, the iPod or the HomePod announcement also included the news

0:06:46that AirPlay 2 will be coming later this year. And what that means for HomePod early adopters

0:06:54is that at least three of the promised features

0:06:59will have to wait until Airplate 2 ships, those are.

0:07:04First, the ability to buy two HomePods,

0:07:09put them in the same room and have them coordinate

0:07:12with each other to work in stereo,

0:07:16which I believe they demoed that for us back at WWDC, right?

0:07:23I'm not misremembering that.

0:07:24I seem to recall.

0:07:24- No, absolutely, they had two of them.

0:07:26So I'm confused about the stereo part of this.

0:07:28So, and maybe it's because I'm completely ignorant

0:07:30about audio, but the way that it works

0:07:33is it uses computational audio to sort of model the room

0:07:36and then project sound into different parts of it.

0:07:38So the way that you traditionally think about stereo

0:07:41is if you want sound on the left,

0:07:41you have to have a speaker on the left.

0:07:43If you want sound on the right,

0:07:44you have to have a speaker on the right

0:07:45where this projects and bounces sound

0:07:47to all different parts of it.

0:07:48So the stereo thing doesn't seem to fit for me.

0:07:52And I know Apple is using the word

0:07:53And I just wonder, like originally my understanding was

0:07:56you'd put more home pods to fill bigger areas that,

0:07:59because it's a speaker, it's still got limited range.

0:08:01And if you wanted a bigger room, you'd put two.

0:08:04If you wanted an even bigger room, you'd put three.

0:08:06But when we talk about stereo,

0:08:07I just, I wonder maybe it's cleaner

0:08:09because you don't have to do the bouncing

0:08:10or the sort of trickery or the magic

0:08:13to get the sound in different parts.

0:08:14And you can more clearly isolate them.

0:08:16So maybe it's a better stereo or surround experience

0:08:19with multiple home pods.

0:08:22Yeah, I that's actually interesting. And linguistically, I'd never thought I've I had the exact same

0:08:29thought Renee and I'm wondering if it'll be possible if they say two but if if like you're

0:08:33saying like, once airplane two comes out, could you get three or four to fill like a

0:08:38sufficiently big?

0:08:40I asked and they they just said like, if you really want to it should and I don't know

0:08:44if this has changed or if I'm remembering it wrong. But my understanding was you could

0:08:47put several of them in and it would just figure it out. But that most people would never need

0:08:50to put that many in one room.

0:08:51Right. And I do think it's, you know, again, it's often best to take Apple in its most

0:09:00obvious way. The name is HomePod. So it's not, you know, these things aren't meant for

0:09:04like a commercial, you know, a big commercial space that would be bigger than what someone

0:09:10would typically consider a home.

0:09:11StadiumPod.

0:09:12Right. But it is interesting. I've always thought of stereo, the word stereo, like you

0:09:18just said, like just left and right. Literally left, not just two, but left and right. But

0:09:25now that I think about it as like a word nerd, the root isn't like duo or something. It's

0:09:33not duophonic. And so I'm looking up stereo here. And the dictionary word, the first one

0:09:39is sound that is directed through two or more speakers so that it seems to surround the

0:09:44the listener and come from more than one source stereophonic sound. But if you scroll down

0:09:49to just the prefix "stereo" as a combining form, this makes more sense. "Relating to

0:09:57solid forms having three dimensions stereography." So I think in theory you could have more than

0:10:03two and it would just figure it out. And I think even when you do have only two, I think

0:10:06be a lot less about left and right and a lot more about how best to make it sound like

0:10:15the music is coming from as many sources as possible.

0:10:17Right, better making that 3D model for the room.

0:10:21Right.

0:10:22Yeah, that makes sense.

0:10:23Yeah, I think thinking of it as 3D makes more sense as to how the two will coordinate than

0:10:28left-right.

0:10:29Yeah.

0:10:30Right?

0:10:31And it's almost like left-right literally is just two-dimensional, whereas it's really

0:10:34more about three-dimensional.

0:10:36And I seem to recall that from the demo.

0:10:38I mean, what I recall, I mean, and you know, this is, geez, what was that like eight months

0:10:43ago?

0:10:44Yeah, June 2017.

0:10:46I remember that it sounded good.

0:10:47And almost most of the demo was here's a song, we'll play it on the on one, you know, the

0:10:53single home pod, then we'll play it on the, what was it a Sonos thing?

0:10:57Yeah, and then we'll play it on the little set of Amazon tin cans.

0:11:02Well, the Amazon thing really came off looking bad in that demo.

0:11:06I was in with, as much as I don't know music, but I was in with Dalrymple, which was hugely

0:11:11informative for me because he is, I don't know what the right, but he is like almost

0:11:16angry about the quality of his music.

0:11:19And they showed us, they played normal songs and they played some live recordings.

0:11:24And as little as I know or appreciate sound, I have Sonos at home.

0:11:28I've had it for years.

0:11:29I'm all in on Sonos.

0:11:30It was way better than Sonos for almost all the songs.

0:11:33I think one of it, it sounded about as good as Sonos,

0:11:35but the live stuff and some of the other stuff,

0:11:37it sounded just as good.

0:11:38And it totally, rightfully so,

0:11:40because the Amazon really was a speaker second

0:11:42and a voice assistant first,

0:11:44but it totally embarrassed the Echo.

0:11:46- Yeah, I'm an interesting contrast to Jim

0:11:48because I'm, not that I don't care about audio,

0:11:52but I really just, I just don't think I have good ears

0:11:55for it, you know, and I'm not musical at all.

0:11:58I like music, you know, certain types of music.

0:12:02But it's a much more, as opposed to like my opinions

0:12:07on let's say a TV, you know, the way a TV set looks.

0:12:10I have very strong opinions about every regard.

0:12:13- Exactly, yeah.

0:12:15- But as a casual music fan,

0:12:18I would have to look back at my notes,

0:12:19but as I recall, that was my take exactly.

0:12:21There was one song where I didn't feel like I could

0:12:24Pepsi Challenge and prefer the HomePod over Sonos.

0:12:29I would have called it a draw, but every other one,

0:12:31I felt confident that even as a, as you would say, a punter,

0:12:35that I thought the HomePod sounded better.

0:12:41And anyway, at the end of the demo, then,

0:12:43it was like, here's the one more thing of the little demo.

0:12:45I think it was always with,

0:12:46it was like groups of like four and five at a time

0:12:49in a sort of living room size space.

0:12:53I was going to say Moscone, but of course it's not called Moscone. What's that place

0:12:56called?

0:12:57Jon Sorrentino San Jose.

0:12:58Jon Scieszka The San Jose.

0:12:59Jon Sorrentino The San Jose.

0:13:00Jon Scieszka The San Jose mouthful convention center.

0:13:01There was, you know, typically, it's just the Apple formula. It's like, here's the one

0:13:08more thing. If you have a second one, you can do this. And it was like, here's what

0:13:12the song sounds like with one home pod and sounded pretty good. And I remember when the

0:13:16second one kicked in, it did sound better. And it did sound fuller.

0:13:20Jon Sorrentino Fuller. Yeah.

0:13:22That's what I remember, the noticing the difference with Sonos. And again, I've used Sonos for

0:13:27years. I have a ton of their stuff. It just sounded richer and deeper and more like, like

0:13:33more of an emotional experience. And then when the second one came on, it was just written,

0:13:38just even better. It was just fuller.

0:13:40Yeah. It's like I know, it's like somehow I know when I come into, you know, somebody's

0:13:46house and they're playing music or movies or something and or you're in a bar or something

0:13:52and you hear it. There's a certain part of me that can detect, "Hey, this is a serious

0:13:56sound system." I can't explain why. I can't tell you what it is. I can just tell somebody

0:14:02put some money into this thing. And that's absolutely what it sounded like with the two

0:14:09HomePods.

0:14:10Yeah, totally. It's like when you go in and you hear someone listening to a sound bar

0:14:14as opposed to hear them listening to a 5.1 or 7.1 surround system that's been properly

0:14:18set up.

0:14:21Still though, lots and lots of unanswered questions about HomePod, in my opinion, which

0:14:30I hope we'll get before it ships, but which I don't think we're going to get before pre-orders

0:14:37open, which leads to the interesting dilemma, probably for an awful lot of people who are

0:14:43listening to us on this show of do you wait until you find out more before you spend $350

0:14:51on this thing or do you buy in advance hoping that the answers will either be good or do

0:15:03you take your chances that maybe if you wait until you do get the answers that it won't

0:15:09be backordered for four months or something like that, right? Because that's the dance

0:15:13you have to play.

0:15:14I was just joking about that on Twitter. It seems like every time Apple announces something,

0:15:18Twitter starts saying how stupid Apple is and how stupid the product is. And then when

0:15:21they ship it, Twitter starts talking about how stupid it is that they can't order it

0:15:24immediately.

0:15:25Yes.

0:15:26Like that's like the seventh stage of the Twitter.

0:15:28You never know. And Apple, you know, talking about things like, "Hey, this is going to

0:15:32be in short supply," isn't really what people who know talk about even off the record. But

0:15:39But my gut feeling is that it may not be back ordered, like, certainly not like AirPods

0:15:47were for most of the year last year.

0:15:49Well, it's so restricted, like AirPods were an international product.

0:15:52This is only launching in the US, Australia and the UK right now.

0:15:55And then sometime this spring in France and Germany.

0:15:58So it's a much smaller market for them to service.

0:15:59Well, and the other thing that I have heard, and I suspect you've probably heard similar

0:16:05is that the hardware was way ahead of the software on this.

0:16:09And that, I think if it weren't for software,

0:16:13this would have shipped as promised in calendar year 2017.

0:16:18- Totally, and people immediately blame Siri,

0:16:20but SiriKit shipped for the Apple TV last,

0:16:23sorry, for the HomePod last fall.

0:16:26AirPlay 2 is still not fully out.

0:16:29- Yeah, and it, you know, so certainly

0:16:31the development of AirPlay 2 is one factor,

0:16:35because they were originally planning to, you know,

0:16:39features that were advertised as this is gonna be

0:16:41in this thing by the end of the year

0:16:43were based on AirPlay 2.

0:16:45So given that AirPlay 2 still isn't out,

0:16:47the delay, you know, whatever's the delay of AirPlay 2

0:16:51is certainly one reason.

0:16:52I suspect that there are others, I don't know,

0:16:55just some things, I don't know anything else specific.

0:16:57But I heard multiple times though

0:16:59that it's the software, not the hardware.

0:17:02- Yep.

0:17:03And I've heard multiple times too

0:17:04that it's not, I mean, there is a legitimate complaint

0:17:07to be made that Siri, I mean, we could back up a little bit.

0:17:09Apple's been working on this for years.

0:17:11And when I look at an Apple product,

0:17:13I try to figure out what problem is Apple

0:17:15trying to solve with this.

0:17:16And it looked, at least I think to Apple,

0:17:19it looked like we don't have a solution for you.

0:17:21You have all this Apple Music stuff,

0:17:23you have, and you just can't drop something in.

0:17:25And it's sort of what the iPod Hi-Fi

0:17:27was trying to solve as well.

0:17:28And we wanna give people a way to just buy something

0:17:31that's Apple designed, and that is incredibly simple

0:17:34to just drop into your room and it sounds really, really great.

0:17:38And it's easy to set up, as easy as AirPods--

0:17:40AirPods shipped earlier-- as easy as AirPods to ship up,

0:17:42we have that technology.

0:17:44And we've done computational photography.

0:17:46We can do computational audio.

0:17:49And in that light, the Siri stuff is secondary.

0:17:52AirPods are controlled through Siri.

0:17:53And they can access the vast catalog of Siri things.

0:17:56But that's a convenience.

0:17:57It's the best way to interface with that product.

0:18:00And HomePod is the same.

0:18:02It can do Siri stuff.

0:18:03It's controlled with Siri and you might as well use it to control home kit and to do those things

0:18:08But it really it really was an audio solution

0:18:11It really was a speaker that Apple spent a lot of time and put an incredible amount of technology into making a

0:18:16Lot of people have been asking me today

0:18:19What do I think the reason is for the software delay

0:18:25What's the reason and I I don't know I don't have any inside information on anything specifically other than obviously

0:18:31Airplay 2 is taking on but why is it airplay 2 taking longer? I

0:18:35That's the nature of software. I mean software projects often take

0:18:41longer sometimes a lot longer than you thought they would even when what you thought they would you

0:18:48Multiplied by 2x because you think well, here's how long I think it'll take

0:18:53I'll multiply it by 2 because it always takes me twice as long as I think and you still come up short

0:18:58It's just the best way to describe it without like well

0:19:02I think the best way to describe it is let's say you wanted to ship the

0:19:04iPad the iMac Pro and you put that to that t2 chip in and in the process of setting up t2 you realize that there

0:19:11was a

0:19:13web of

0:19:14authentication stuff that had been built up over the years but had some architectural issues that you really that you'd never taken the time to

0:19:21Go back and fix but we're now

0:19:23Problematic to get that product to ship now that did not happen with the eye with the iMac Pro

0:19:28We did get you know, the ridiculous root blank stuff that surfaced but nothing to stop the product

0:19:34And I think this is similar to in making airplay - they hit some things that that were just long

0:19:39Long existing issues in the code that they never needed to address before and in order to make this work

0:19:44They had to go back and address them and they've addressed to the point where it functions now

0:19:49But it's not at the point yet where all those features are available

0:19:51Yeah, and either going back to fix things that you didn't think would be so hard to fix or solving problems that you didn't

0:19:59And you know that some step along the way was a lot harder

0:20:02Than you thought it was going to be or some step along the way of solving this new problem

0:20:07You you go down a dead end and have to go back because it actually doesn't work. I mean, that's

0:20:13software is like

0:20:17It's a lot like writing and to me it's always often very similar to the idea

0:20:22You know that it's like being a lawmaker, you know

0:20:26Like trying to you know, when you when lawmakers write laws

0:20:30They hopefully should take take their time and write them in a way that it's very clear

0:20:36What is and is not against the law?

0:20:39But if you think like you've got you know

0:20:44we've got here's an mpeg3 audio file and

0:20:48We want it to go through this speaker

0:20:52over the air in a certain way over a certain protocol and have certain things happen to analyze the music and

0:21:00Then come out of these tweeters in this base in this way, you know, yeah

0:21:06That's not fully thought out that's just an outline and as you fill that in

0:21:13to actually make it completely thought out, that's the actual programming, right?

0:21:18It's never actually fully thought out until the programming is complete.

0:21:23And so you never know when you're going from the plan for the software to the actual software

0:21:29where you're going to hit a point that is

0:21:31way tougher, trickier, takes longer than you thought it would.

0:21:35Yeah, and the requirements, like we've all experienced issues with airplay and with core audio that are

0:21:42mildly annoying when you're just trying to project your video or record something, but

0:21:48there would be absolute deal breakers if the product had to be rock solid, reliable streaming

0:21:52audio all the time. And that just can't ship that way. Like you've got to go back and fix

0:21:55all that stuff.

0:21:56Yeah. I mean, I'm not making excuses for them. It does look bad. That's something that they

0:22:02were promised that they promised to ship by the end of 2017 in June. Now in January is

0:22:09later 2018. I mean, it could be pushing up for all we know, it could be pushing up against

0:22:15WWDC again. I would guess that it's better than shipping it because if they shipped in

0:22:23that didn't work, that would be even worse. Right? That's what I don't get. Like, I'm

0:22:27not saying Apple comes out. I'm not making excuses for them. I'm just explaining what

0:22:31I tried to explain what the situation is. And you know, you could say that, you know,

0:22:39You can be mad at them if you want and you can say that this is a worrisome sign that

0:22:43maybe the company is slipping. It's not like it used to be even though I can name

0:22:48a long list of products that shipped late. I was just pointing out earlier this week

0:22:53on an article I wrote that this wouldn't have happened under Steve Jobs' crowd. Steve

0:22:59Jobs was there when the white iPhone 4 shipped 10 months late. It was almost a full year

0:23:06after the black version shipped, which I remember distinctly because my wife was like, "You

0:23:11know what?

0:23:12I'm going to get the white one."

0:23:13No, I had the same experience.

0:23:16We should make a name for this law, but whenever someone says Steve Jobs would never, almost

0:23:21certainly he did at some point or was involved in the decision-making process that led to

0:23:25the product you think Steve would never have let Apple make.

0:23:28Yeah, it's a lot like there's always a Trump tweet for whatever.

0:23:31Like with this government shutdown that we had here in the US last weekend, there were

0:23:35all these, the last time that the US federal government shut down, Trump was on TV and

0:23:41on Twitter reiterating one message, which is that no matter what, the government shutdown

0:23:48is always the fault of the president.

0:23:50Yeah. No, I mean, it's absolutely true. And I would just rather people stop making that

0:23:57argument because you never look good in hindsight.

0:24:00But anyway, it is what it is.

0:24:03But the interesting dilemma, as you alluded to, is you wish that there were no delay.

0:24:08You wish everything was all ready and the thing had shipped before Christmas and AirPlay

0:24:122 is bug-free and solves all the AirPlay problems.

0:24:16But that didn't happen.

0:24:17Well, it would have been better for Apple because the competitive market is much different

0:24:21now than it was.

0:24:22When Apple first announced it, there were no products, as far as I can remember, that

0:24:28were doing multi-personal assistance.

0:24:29that would do voice ID and try to figure out different people.

0:24:32There was no Google Home Max.

0:24:34There was no product that really had a good speaker attached

0:24:36to a good assistant.

0:24:37And in the months since the products have been delayed,

0:24:40Google put that service online.

0:24:41Amazon put that service online.

0:24:43They're both producing better speakers now.

0:24:44So Apple's entering a market much later

0:24:47with a much earlier product than they would have liked.

0:24:49Yeah.

0:24:50So given where they are as of late December 2017,

0:24:55with hardware that is apparently ready to go

0:24:57and software that could be made ready to go

0:25:02modulo AirPlay 2, therefore missing some features

0:25:05in the meantime.

0:25:06What do you do if it's your decision to make the call?

0:25:09Do you make the whole product wait until AirPlay 2's ready,

0:25:13or do you ship what you have and crack the whips

0:25:17on the AirPlay 2 team to get it out as soon as you can?

0:25:20I think I--

0:25:21- I don't think that team has slept since before Christmas.

0:25:23- I think I would have made, if it was up to me,

0:25:25I would have made the same decision Apple has made

0:25:27and ship it now. I mean, we'll see once I get the product. I mean, you know, maybe the

0:25:30thing's a disaster, but you know, assuming that it's everything that they are saying

0:25:34it will do right out of the box on day one works. I think it's worth shipping. I think,

0:25:40you know, I think there's a benefit to shipping both hardware and software for an indie one

0:25:45person creative shop or the world's most profitable corporation. Shipping is, you know, it's good

0:25:53and waiting for perfection can lead you to very long delays.

0:25:58You can't ship a product that doesn't

0:26:00perform its basic function, which

0:26:02I think was why Apple delayed it to begin with.

0:26:04It's got to be rock solid in terms of being a speaker.

0:26:07Once that happens, if it's missing

0:26:08a few of the more advanced features, it's not ideal,

0:26:11but you can ship it and get it in people's hands.

0:26:14And that's one of the things with Apple.

0:26:16Johnny Ives said this, that they don't really

0:26:18believe they understand their own products

0:26:19until they get them to the hands of the customers,

0:26:21because often the reaction to them

0:26:23Informs where Apple takes them and this gets that into people's hands it there

0:26:26They're late to market but they're not as late as they would be if they kept it

0:26:29Off market until airplay 2 is finished. So I think it's it's the best situation they can do right now

0:26:34Boy, is that isn't the best example of that ever the Apple watch where yeah

0:26:39It's so there's so much more clarity in Apple's direction of it

0:26:44Starting a year after it came out

0:26:47You know focusing it on notifications and fitness

0:26:52Yeah, and you know reliability, I mean there's some of the stuff like the fact that the first one was so slow

0:26:58Well, duh everybody. I mean Apple knew that I mean

0:27:00Honestly, it's probably the only product I've ever seen in history where I you know during the product briefings

0:27:08I was I was they apologized for how slow it was

0:27:12Yeah, and I was operating at the thermal limits of that casing at the time, right?

0:27:15We're sorry. That's so slow

0:27:20But that's really true for Apple watch

0:27:22All right. Let's take a break. But when we come back I want to talk about

0:27:26HomePod versus in the competitive landscape, which you just alluded to about what and especially the post June

0:27:33Competitive landscape which really is different

0:27:36But first

0:27:40Do you know what's a fun thing to do on the internet I'll tell you what's a fun thing to do on the internet is

0:27:46buy a mattress

0:27:47Casper is a company who makes products

0:27:51that are cleverly designed to mimic human curves,

0:27:56providing supportive comfort for all kinds of bodies.

0:27:59And they make it so easy to buy a mattress

0:28:03or any of their other sleeping products.

0:28:05Look, you spend one third of your life sleeping,

0:28:09so you should be comfortable.

0:28:11It really is, getting a nice bed and a comfortable mattress

0:28:15is money so well spent, really is.

0:28:18The experts at Casper, they work tirelessly

0:28:22to make a quality sleep surface

0:28:24that cradles your natural geometry in all the right places.

0:28:28The original Casper mattress combines

0:28:30multiple supportive memory foams

0:28:32for a quality sleep surface

0:28:34with just the right amount of sink and bounce.

0:28:37Has a breathable design, keeps you cool,

0:28:39regulates your body temperature through the night.

0:28:42And they have over 20,000 reviews

0:28:44and an average of 4.8 stars across Casper, Amazon, and Google.

0:28:50Maybe you say, "Well, maybe on their own site, you can't really take that." You can't fake

0:28:53those Amazon reviews, really. It really is a popular product. I know a lot of people

0:28:59who've bought them. They advertise on a bunch of podcasts. Like I said upfront, it's a gimmick

0:29:05now. It's almost like a joke buying mattresses on the internet, but it's a real deal. It

0:29:10really is. They now offer two other types of mattresses, the wave and the essential.

0:29:15The wave features a patent-pended premium support system to mirror the natural shape

0:29:18of your body. The essential has a streamlined design at a price that won't keep you up at

0:29:24night and they also offer a wider way of array of other products like pillows and sheets,

0:29:31anything you need for your, as they call it, your sleep experience. Super convenient, affordable

0:29:37prices because Casper cuts out the middleman. They have hassle free returns if you're not

0:29:42completely satisfied. I've gotten a couple of them. I've they've been sponsoring the

0:29:45show for so long. I've gotten a couple of emails from people who said, you know what?

0:29:49I listened to your show. I bought a Casper. I actually didn't like it. Uh, and the one

0:29:54that I got like two or three of these over the years from, from people who said, you

0:29:57know, the most amazing thing is the one thing I just didn't, didn't believe is that it really

0:30:01would be easy to send it back and it really was. And they thought that was great. They

0:30:04They were like, "So that's a mattress?"

0:30:05I wound up not keeping it, but I super impressed

0:30:09with the company because they made it easy to return.

0:30:12And inside the US, they have free shipping and free returns.

0:30:17You can be sure of your purchase

0:30:20with Casper's 100-night risk-free Sleep On It trial.

0:30:24We've got some Casper mattresses here in the house.

0:30:27We love 'em.

0:30:28They're really great.

0:30:29You get 50 bucks towards your select mattress

0:30:33visiting casper.com/the-talk-show and using the code "THETALKSHOW" at checkout. Terms

0:30:39and conditions reply. So that's 50 bucks off the mattress of your choice. Casper.com/the-talk-show

0:30:47and that code "THETALKSHOW." My thanks to Casper for their continuing support of the

0:30:52talk show. A lot of people out there sleeping on Internet mattresses, Rene.

0:30:57I've been using Casper for years. I absolutely adore it.

0:31:02Competitive landscape. So I can think of two things in this regard. One, and you alluded

0:31:08to this, the audio quality of some of the competing products has gotten better since

0:31:14June. Two, and I think this is the more important one, is that the competing products, which

0:31:26I think it's safe to say are primarily from Google and Amazon, right? It's Google and

0:31:30Amazon. Microsoft has Cortana speakers, but they're not a thing really. I never hear anybody

0:31:35talking about it. The other ones, the Google and Amazon ones are sort of assistant first

0:31:43audio quality second. And I always say this is like maybe one of the top three themes

0:31:48of my entire body of work is that the order of your priorities matters tremendously. Like

0:31:56Like it's not enough to say that you want something, you know, we want it to be well-designed

0:32:04and high quality.

0:32:08If you want it to be high quality and well-designed, you might end up with a different product

0:32:12just by taking those two things and putting them in a different order, right?

0:32:16Like you might, you know, if the highest quality like durability is more important than the

0:32:21elegance of the design, you might end up with something that's a little thicker, uses different

0:32:26materials, etc. Even though those are two priorities that might go hand in hand in many

0:32:31ways, a subtle difference in order makes a difference.

0:32:36Absolutely. And for some people, the people that Apple chooses not to compete in usually

0:32:40is the people for whom the low price is the most important feature.

0:32:45Right. And that certainly is going to be true in this regard because one of the most, right

0:32:51off the top you can't miss it. The difference is that these other devices are sort of hovering

0:32:56around the $150 range. Amazon has the little pucks that give them away with some things

0:33:05I think.

0:33:06They're going to start paying you soon to take them.

0:33:07Right. I wouldn't be surprised. Yeah.

0:33:09You said this so well with the AirPods. People complained about the price there too because

0:33:14they were comparing them to traditional headphones or traditional Bluetooth headphones or headphones

0:33:19that they thought sounded better, but it was not at all about the sound. It was about the

0:33:22technology from the W1 chip to the sensors. That was expensive components. And if Apple

0:33:28could have charged less for it, I think they would have because that was not a product

0:33:32they wanted to make margin on. That was a product they wanted to create market for.

0:33:37I'm just imagining, I've suddenly imagined a, a idiocracy like near future where Amazon

0:33:48has flooded the world with free Echo pucks with free offers and everywhere you go, you

0:33:54goddamn things are like, would you like some paper towels?

0:33:57Hey, you want more?

0:33:58Can you turn on my lights?

0:34:00Sure.

0:34:01We can turn on your lights.

0:34:02We could also order you three more and have you, would you like a coupon for your morning

0:34:04coffee?

0:34:06Do you need more trash bags?

0:34:09No, I mean, so that's the other thing here,

0:34:11is that privacy and security are also a feature.

0:34:14I know a lot of people just kind of lump all these products

0:34:17together.

0:34:18And I've said this before.

0:34:19I really don't want a Google speaker or an Amazon speaker

0:34:24in my house.

0:34:24And famously, every year, I buy whatever the new Nexus

0:34:27or the new Pixel is.

0:34:29And I still can't use Google Assistant,

0:34:30because the first thing it does is say,

0:34:32can we monitor all your app and web activity?

0:34:35and I say no and it says, well,

0:34:36then you can't use Google Assistant.

0:34:38And that's a lie.

0:34:39I could absolutely use it.

0:34:40They don't need that to give me basic,

0:34:41like to say, turn on my lights or something,

0:34:43but that's the deal.

0:34:44Like they don't want you to pay with money.

0:34:45They don't want you to pay with time.

0:34:47They want you to pay with attention and with data.

0:34:49And I would rather not.

0:34:51And with Apple, yes, in some ways it's similar,

0:34:55but the way Apple treats my data

0:34:58and the way that it runs its business

0:35:01makes me feel more secure

0:35:02in having an Apple speaker in my house.

0:35:04and I'm willing, if I am paying a premium,

0:35:07I wanna see everything about it before I say that,

0:35:09but even assuming I am paying a premium,

0:35:11to go back to your point about the order of priorities,

0:35:13that's a high level priority for me.

0:35:15- Yeah, and it seems to me very clear,

0:35:18and we'll see, I could be wrong,

0:35:20but it seems very clear that the number one priority

0:35:23of HomePod, at least this first one,

0:35:25is to make awesome sounding audio.

0:35:29And having clever stuff happen through Siri

0:35:34is obviously on the list.

0:35:36I mean, and there's obviously a deliberate choice

0:35:39to make Siri the interface to interacting with the device.

0:35:43I mean, there's other things I guess we'll find out,

0:35:47but there's plus minus physical buttons for volume.

0:35:49But for the most part, you're intended--

0:35:50- But I think it was a different thought process.

0:35:51Like it wasn't how do we put Siri in your living room?

0:35:53It's we're putting this in your living room,

0:35:54what's the best way to control it?

0:35:56- Exactly, right.

0:35:57And that makes it a fundamentally different product.

0:35:59And I can't help but think that even if it is successful, meaning not successful necessarily

0:36:06in the market, but successful insofar as that if the product they ship is what they wanted

0:36:13to ship, that it might wind up being deeply misunderstood in the initial reviews because

0:36:21it's going to be compared to Alexa and the Google thing.

0:36:25and there'll be, you know, my Alexa can do these 30 different things, you know, and,

0:36:32you know, the HomePod only does two of them, and, you know, cons and then pros, HomePod

0:36:40sounds more, sounds better. I combine two of my items at once. Sounds better, but then

0:36:48another con costs double the price or two and a half times the price. So why would I

0:36:54pay, you know, conclusion, why would I pay three times as much

0:36:57for a device that only does one third of the things even though

0:37:00it sounds better? Whereas the knock that happens all the time,

0:37:04right, I can't help but guess that that's going to be the

0:37:07summary of a lot of reviews. And it might actually be the

0:37:10sentiment of a lot of people reading a lot of these reviews,

0:37:13if what you're looking for is a intelligent AI assistant to talk

0:37:20to and control stuff in your house. Whereas if what you

0:37:24you really want is awesome sounding music coming in the world where is your music coming

0:37:33from is the cloud, you might get a totally different answer. And it also on the issue

0:37:39of price, in the world of people who want really, really high quality, or I'll just

0:37:47read it. I don't want to say it better. A guy I know, Joe Saplensky, you were in this

0:37:55thread on Twitter, but he had a good tweet. Here's his tweet. "I'm not saying HomePod

0:37:59is a guaranteed success. Far from it. I'm just saying there's a much bigger, more established

0:38:04market for great sounding home stereo equipment than there is for 'smart home appliances'

0:38:10and in that world, $350 is a steal." Now, Joe's a musician.

0:38:14- You literally spend as much money as you have on audio.

0:38:17There is no upper limit.

0:38:18- Right.

0:38:20You know, Joe's a musician.

0:38:21He's in a band with a friend of the show,

0:38:24former Vesper colleague, Dave Whiskus, you know.

0:38:27So he's a musician.

0:38:27He's like Dalrymple, you know, he's obviously,

0:38:30you know, serious musician.

0:38:31You care about the music.

0:38:32But it really is true that in the world

0:38:34of digital assistants, 350 sounds like Apple is coming in

0:38:38at an insanely high price.

0:38:39And in the world of high-end home audio,

0:38:42It is insanely low.

0:38:45- Yeah, and that's absolutely true.

0:38:47You can spend, if you have millions of dollars,

0:38:49you can spend millions of dollars on home audio.

0:38:51There is literally no upper limit.

0:38:54And we've all bought good speakers over the years.

0:38:56Some people, again, they'll go

0:38:57and they'll get the box of speakers

0:38:58and that's fine for them.

0:38:59It's whatever Costco or Walmart

0:39:01or whatever is offering in a box.

0:39:02Other people will carefully select every speaker

0:39:05and you'll get the best amplifier

0:39:06because they care about this stuff.

0:39:08But again, I think what Apple is also solving here is

0:39:11I want better audio in my house and I don't really want to fuss with wires, I don't want

0:39:16to fuss with all these things and I just want to drop it in.

0:39:19And Sonos was the first way of doing that.

0:39:21Sonos still has a good product.

0:39:23They have the Sonos One now, talk about new market, new competitors.

0:39:25They have the Sonos One now which builds in Alexa and I think it'll do Siri bridging and

0:39:30probably do Cortana so that Cortana and Alexa can talk to each other and leave you alone.

0:39:36But that's the solution is I'm in on the Apple ecosystem, I have an iPhone, I subscribe to

0:39:40Apple Music and I just want something in my house that takes care of all this for me."

0:39:44And that's the job you're hiring it to do.

0:39:48We've got the Alexa thing that echoed Dingus in the kitchen. And we haven't hooked up to

0:39:58some lights and some window shades. The window shades are the main thing that I use it for.

0:40:07Which ones did you get? Because I just ordered some.

0:40:10Uh, Lytros? I don't know if that's…

0:40:12Yeah, the Lutron?

0:40:13Lutron, Lutron. That's it.

0:40:14Yeah, that's the one I just ordered. Serena.

0:40:18Yeah, I like the shades, but I still… honestly, I used the buttons on the remote control as

0:40:24much as I use the Alexa interface so far. But Amy's in the kitchen more than me. She

0:40:31She plays music on it.

0:40:33I think it sounds like shit.

0:40:34I really do.

0:40:36And I don't know, in a kitchen where it's bouncing off tiles, it might even be more

0:40:40hard.

0:40:41So I'm really, really—I mean, that's the first place where, when I get my hands on

0:40:44a HomePod, I'm putting it in the kitchen first, because that's where we would use it more.

0:40:51And since it doesn't work with two yet, the living room might have to wait for AirPlay

0:40:562.

0:40:57Really, all she does is she plays music on it and she sets timers.

0:41:02She does like using it to set timers because it's hands-free and that's while cooking.

0:41:08But it does drive her mad.

0:41:09And I have to say, as somebody who cares about the little things, for all the praise that

0:41:14the thing gets, I think that some of the things that it does are so goddamn stupid, it's ridiculous.

0:41:19So if you have a timer going and you check, you're like, "Hey, Dingus, how much time is

0:41:23left on my timer?"

0:41:25It takes forever to get the answer.

0:41:27You have four minutes, 30 seconds remaining on your 10-minute timer.

0:41:34It's so stupid.

0:41:36Who would program it that way?

0:41:37If you understand the question as clearly as she understands the question, how much

0:41:41time is left, just say four minutes, 30 seconds and say it a little faster.

0:41:46Ben de la Torre

0:41:48People get mad when I say this, but it's an incredibly new, incredibly nascent market

0:41:52and there is no real leader yet.

0:41:54the core technology itself is not fully baked.

0:41:57Like if Amy's in the kitchen and she says,

0:42:00I want a scotch or something,

0:42:01it'll get better at understanding that she wants scotch,

0:42:04but it doesn't get better at knowing

0:42:05that Amy prefers scotch as a drink.

0:42:07Like its context is very shallow, very super,

0:42:10all of the assistants, very, it also,

0:42:12right now it responds, like it'll,

0:42:14like you'll say lower the shades

0:42:15and it'll lower the shades.

0:42:17And if you put it on a timer or something,

0:42:19it'll do it programmatically,

0:42:21but it doesn't understand that when you wake up

0:42:24When you pick up your phone, it should automatically raise the shades or turn on the shower because

0:42:27that's what you do after you read Twitter in the morning.

0:42:30They still don't have a deep understanding of us.

0:42:33It feels like it's a fresh enough area where there's not a lot of depth yet.

0:42:37Dave: Yeah.

0:42:38There's some stuff about HomePod that I think is – I'm not dissing Alexa and saying

0:42:49it's series coming out of the box, you know, to fix this and be like the iPhone, what the

0:42:54iPhone was to smartphones for these smart agents. I think it's clearly, absolutely,

0:42:59this year not going to be that. It might be a great music device, but it is absolutely

0:43:04not going to be the, you know, the HAL 9000 in your home that we ultimately want.

0:43:12The consensus I've heard from, you know, mutual friends who've been using it for a long time

0:43:16is that the music experience is phenomenal and Siri for music has been, it's almost like

0:43:21a completely new Siri for music, but Siri is still limited, as you just answered me,

0:43:26but Siri is still incredibly limited. So don't go in expecting it to be. And this isn't like,

0:43:30it'll do the HomeKit stuff because you, again, it's like Apple, we might as well include

0:43:33HomeKit. But it really is music first. And it's interesting too, because they had Siri

0:43:39Kit out for this. So it'll do things like, it'll work with Notes apps, it'll work with

0:43:43to-do apps like OmniFocus and things.

0:43:46And it'll work with--

0:43:47I forget what the third one is.

0:43:48There's a third-- oh, it'll--

0:43:50there's a third thing that SiriKit will work through.

0:43:52There's no SiriKit for music.

0:43:53So if you use Spotify instead of Apple Music, you're stuck.

0:43:57But the architecture that Apple is building--

0:43:59and Brian Romilly, who does all the Voice First stuff,

0:44:02pointed this out to me--

0:44:03Amazon is ahead in terms of integration,

0:44:05but they've sort of painted themselves

0:44:07into a corner because of the system that they use.

0:44:10It doesn't handle differences in grammatical structure

0:44:12well and also it doesn't handle as far as he explained it. Like if you got in on the

0:44:17ground floor and you were pizza, like you were the first developer to make a pizza integration,

0:44:23what happens when Pizza Hut or Domino's come on? And then like some guy already owns pizza.

0:44:27Like it's not clear how well it's going to scale. Where Apple is very, very slow with

0:44:30this stuff and they should have absolutely had more integrations out, more serial kit

0:44:34domains out sooner. They've built a system that will allow many people who speak very

0:44:39differently in different languages and in some cases even multiple languages to

0:44:42interface with it and they're building it in a way that it'll scale as they

0:44:46start rolling out more and more of those domains. Yeah and the other thing I don't

0:44:50think that this is official I don't think that they're they're saying this

0:44:54yet but what I have heard is that you know for like the integration with

0:45:00things like your notes and reminders and there's third-party integration like

0:45:07like they're already saying like the app,

0:45:08the great, great to-do list app things,

0:45:12I guess is already on board with a Siri kit extension.

0:45:16If you want to use stuff like that,

0:45:19it only works with one Apple ID.

0:45:23Like, so you've got to hook up your HomePod

0:45:25and maybe it's me.

0:45:27- Most messages, sorry, that's the third one.

0:45:28- Yeah, messages.

0:45:29And they've got, I think they got WhatsApp on board.

0:45:31So it's not just Apple messages.

0:45:33it's messaging apps can get into this.

0:45:37But there's not, you know,

0:45:39clearly the way that this should work,

0:45:43I'm not saying it should,

0:45:45given the state of technology in 2018,

0:45:47but certainly should ultimately,

0:45:51and sooner rather than later,

0:45:53is your device should recognize who you are.

0:45:56I've said this before, talking about this.

0:45:58You know, whether it's just voice alone

0:46:01combination of camera and voice, but there's absolutely no doubt. I mean, and you know,

0:46:06the tech is there if photos can identify your friends and family in your photos,

0:46:13the device could use the same machine learning algorithms to notice that it's you who are talking

0:46:20right and the same. Just think about this, there's no reason that computers shouldn't be ultimately

0:46:25computers combined with hardware shouldn't be as good as we are of, you know, recognizing who just

0:46:31said something. Right? When you're at the…

0:46:33That's totally true. Right now, they're personal assistants and they need to be multi-personal

0:46:37assistants. And again, another problem with Apple delaying is that in the meantime, Amazon

0:46:41has pushed out multi-user, multi-voice, and Google has more recently pushed out multi-user,

0:46:46multi-voice. And Nuance for years has been doing voice ID to the level that I think banking

0:46:52apps trust it now as a form of biometric authentication. So this stuff all worked. And Apple has been

0:46:57working on it as far as I know, but it's not shipped yet.

0:47:00So clearly this should work where if you've configured the HomePod in your house with your Apple ID and

0:47:07somebody else in your family has also done that and one of you says

0:47:13You know, hey dingus remind me tomorrow when I get to work to

0:47:19Pay Bob the five dollars I own

0:47:22It knows who said that right in the same way that when you're you you and I and a bunch of friends go out to

0:47:29dinner and somebody says, "Hey, can you pass me the salt?" that you don't say, "Okay,

0:47:34who wants the salt?" You just give it to the person who said it.

0:47:38If you say, "Hey, Dingus, read me my messages," or Amy says, "Hey, Dingus, read me my messages,"

0:47:43they should supply the appropriate messages to the right person.

0:47:46Right. And conversely, and I'm curious how this is going to work in the 1.0 version of

0:47:53home play, is that if you come over to my house and I've got it set up for my thing

0:47:58and you say, "Hey, Dingus, play my messages," what's it going to do? I honestly don't

0:48:05even know. I have no idea on or off the record how the hell that's going to work.

0:48:09Because you don't want it to say, "Hey, is that idiot still coming over to your house?

0:48:12I can't believe it."

0:48:13Yeah, exactly. I mean, it's a real disaster.

0:48:16Well, you know, there are several things like they haven't said anything about it working

0:48:20with Apple TV yet, but it is an AirPlay endpoint, so you'll be able to select it from your

0:48:24or Apple TV as an AirPlay speaker and do that,

0:48:26but there's no sort of special Apple magic there.

0:48:29And it's got Bluetooth 5.0,

0:48:31and it'll do speaker phone for iPhone,

0:48:33but Apple's not surfacing like A2DP,

0:48:35or I forget what the new one, the new initials are,

0:48:37so it'll work as a Bluetooth endpoint for other devices.

0:48:40So just a lot of stuff that just seems like

0:48:42it's not full yet, not finished yet.

0:48:45- Yeah, and because it is an AirPlay speaker,

0:48:50you can just use peer-to-peer AirPlay

0:48:53like you can with any other AirPlay device.

0:48:55So right out of the box, if you wanna play your podcasts,

0:48:58even if your preferred podcast app

0:49:01isn't magically able to just interface through the thing,

0:49:06you can just go from your phone,

0:49:07select it as your AirPlay target,

0:49:09and hit play and control it through your phone.

0:49:11So you will be able to use it as a speaker to play podcasts.

0:49:13It's just clearly the way this device is meant to be used

0:49:16is to tell Siri to play your podcasts.

0:49:22And this is the part that sometimes is vexing about Apple.

0:49:25And I think the last example was the Apple TV,

0:49:27where it took years and still felt not fully baked

0:49:30when the new version came out.

0:49:31And this Apple's been working on for years

0:49:33and still feels not fully baked.

0:49:35And yeah, there's always resource constraints,

0:49:37and they're working on multiple products and stuff.

0:49:39But it's clear they sort of know what it should do.

0:49:41Like they knew what Apple TV does.

0:49:42And Apple TV now, is it two years

0:49:44after the new version came out,

0:49:46it's got almost everything that was glaringly missing

0:49:49from when they first launched it.

0:49:50But it's just getting that stuff ready

0:49:52so that it's there when the product ships, it seems to be a challenge.

0:49:57I guess the last point here is that Apple is playing it up as being meant for Apple

0:50:02Music. But I think I saw something that you can use it without an Apple Music subscription

0:50:10and it will play music that you have purchased from iTunes. But I'm wondering what it will

0:50:15do like if you have… will it play anything that you possibly have that is in the cloud?

0:50:24So with the… it is all so confusing to me, but I still think that… let's say I have

0:50:31a CD that has music on it that's never been in iTunes in the store. It's an old bootleg

0:50:37CD of something. And I've ripped… years ago, ripped it into iTunes and I have iTunes

0:50:42match so that it's in my account and when I get a new computer and sign into it, those

0:50:49songs from that disk are available to me, even though they're not in the iTunes store.

0:50:53Will those songs be available to me through HomePod?

0:50:56So that was unclear to me too because we have like, again, Down

0:50:56See, that was unclear to me too because we have like, again, Down

0:51:10It sounded to me, because again, the language wasn't--

0:51:12at least I didn't understand the language that well.

0:51:14So I'm wondering if it's just whatever

0:51:16is in your iCloud music library, because that sort of supplanted

0:51:20iTunes match, and it includes Apple Music if you have it,

0:51:22and iTunes match.

0:51:23Yeah, so I guess that's what I'm thinking.

0:51:25Not iTunes match, but just iTunes Music Library.

0:51:27And I'm hoping-- god, I'm really hoping that that's what it is,

0:51:31because boy, that would just seem--

0:51:34I don't see how you could excuse it otherwise, right?

0:51:36I mean, this is--

0:51:37iTunes is a thing that Apple's been building since 2001.

0:51:42It's all in their court.

0:51:43There's nobody else to blame if that doesn't work.

0:51:46Right?

0:51:47Well, there's two areas here of pain.

0:51:50One's going to be the people like Jim or like Andy and Akko who have these vast collections

0:51:54of music that they've carefully ripped and cataloged and really love to hear.

0:51:58And then there's a whole new generation of people that just don't even remember what

0:52:01a CD is, but maybe they're all in on Spotify and not on Apple Music and their pain is going

0:52:06be that yes, I can airplay it, but oh god, it would be nice to have native support for

0:52:10this already.

0:52:11Right.

0:52:12Right.

0:52:13It's like two edges of the spectrum.

0:52:14Right.

0:52:15My version of the nine versions of the Ozzy song is my collection of live Rolling Stones

0:52:21performances from the '70s and very early '80s, where the set lists are, I don't

0:52:26know, usually about 60% overlap from each tour to tour.

0:52:31So there's, I don't know.

0:52:33least eight different versions of Happy from Exile on Main Street.

0:52:39And the new version is if Taylor Swift drops on Spotify instead of Apple Music Day One,

0:52:44they'll be shook if it's not available to them.

0:52:47Right.

0:52:48Or really, with those live albums, it's great to just listen to them in order as a

0:52:53concert.

0:52:54But I don't think maybe they've made them available, but I'm pretty sure they were

0:52:58never on Apple Music.

0:52:59It's like the Stones were selling them directly and for a while they were selling them through

0:53:04Google or something.

0:53:05I forget how I got them.

0:53:08But apparently the Siri stuff is, like for music, they've done an incredible amount

0:53:11of work to make it far more robust and nuanced and capable.

0:53:15And it'll be interesting to see what sort—like again, it's only music and that sucks.

0:53:19I wish it was everything, but it'd be good to see what sort of the future of Siri holds

0:53:22as they roll that same new system out over other domains.

0:53:27Anyway, let's take a break and I'm going to thank our next sponsor. It's our good friends

0:53:32at Away. Away bags and accessories are super high quality and really, really affordable

0:53:40prices because they sell them direct to you. They use really high quality materials so

0:53:46they can offer a much lower price compared to equivalent quality brands by cutting out

0:53:50the middleman without the retail markup. You can choose from over 10 colors in five sizes

0:53:57Here's the names of their sizes. They're very hard to understand. The carry-on, the

0:54:03bigger carry-on, the medium, the large, and the kids carry-on. They're actually very

0:54:07easy to understand. The suitcases are made with premium German polycarbonate that's

0:54:14very lightweight and bends, never breaks. The interior features a patent-pending compression

0:54:21them. Four 360-degree spinner wheels guarantee a smooth ride. The wheels are my favorite

0:54:27thing about this ride, this thing. I've traveled a lot over the last month or so, had mine

0:54:32everywhere I go, and I'm constantly impressed by how smooth the wheels are in this thing.

0:54:39There's at least two of the terminals at Philly's airport, American Airways as it's now known.

0:54:47You got to go down like a slope to get there.

0:54:49It actually goes downhill.

0:54:51The damn thing, the wheels are so good that it actually, if you let go of it, the suitcase

0:54:55is just going to take off.

0:54:57It's so smooth.

0:54:58It's really, really—that's my favorite thing about the whole thing.

0:55:04Even just clever little things like a removable washable laundry bag that snaps into place,

0:55:08tucks away so you can keep your dirty clothes separate from the remaining clean clothes

0:55:13living out of the suitcase while you're on your trip.

0:55:17Here's the thing. Both sizes of the carry-on can charge all cell phones, tablets, e-readers,

0:55:23anything that's powered by a USB cord. It's got like a 20,000 mega amp battery. You don't

0:55:29have to really charge the suitcase very often. I go months without charging it. Months. I

0:55:34only charge it like, I don't know, maybe like once or twice a year. You almost never have

0:55:39to remember to do it, but then anytime you sit down at the airport, just plug in a lightning

0:55:43cable and you can sit there and charge your phone, which is to me always a huge deal at

0:55:49the airport because my phone is always super low because you get a shitty signal and there's

0:55:54thousands of other people all on their phones. And because you're at the airport, you're

0:55:58on your phone all day. Really, it's just a tremendously convenient thing. Anyway, they

0:56:05have a lifetime warranty. If anything breaks, they will fix it, replace it for free. Really

0:56:11just great stuff. I really encourage you to go check it out. They too have a hundred day

0:56:17trial. Live it, vibe with it, travel with it, Instagram it, take pictures, and if at any point

0:56:24you don't decide that you like it, return it for a full refund, no questions asked. They have free

0:56:30shipping on any away order within the contiguous US. Sorry, Alaska. Carry-on sizes that are

0:56:38compliant with all major US airlines while maximizing the amount that you can pack. They

0:56:45also have retail stores now in New York City, San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Austin, Texas.

0:56:51Beautiful, beautiful Austin, Texas. Really, I love my product. I can't remember the last

0:56:56time I traveled anywhere without it. It's just great. I really recommend it personally.

0:57:03I would recommend it even if they stopped sponsoring the show. That's how much I like

0:57:06ticket. For $20 off a suitcase, visit awaytravel.com/talkshow, awaytravel.com/talkshow, and use promo "talkshow"

0:57:18during checkout and you'll save $20. $20 off awaytravel.com/talkshow. My thanks to them.

0:57:27You can buy suitcases on the internet now, too. You know that, Rene.

0:57:30Rene

0:57:30You buy almost anything. It's an amazing time. We live in I just moved and I don't think I bought anything a traditional store

0:57:36You may be some furniture, but almost everything else I bought I always if it was online. Yeah, I

0:57:41Buy so much stuff online. It has occasionally occurred to me where it's like how the hell does retail even stay in business?

0:57:48Like anything? Yeah, even though sometimes I do like to go and I there are things I like to buy in person

0:57:54But there it there are other things that you used to buy at the stores where I occasionally

0:58:00I occasionally go for an in-person retail experience where since I don't buy any of

0:58:05those other things there, I don't know. I just wonder what the heck is going on. It's

0:58:10very strange.

0:58:11Yeah. It's the same thing like the app store. If I know exactly what I want, I will go online

0:58:16and buy it. But if I'm just bored or I need to get something for somebody and I don't

0:58:21know what I want, I find it easier to just walk through a mall and look at things and

0:58:24get ideas.

0:58:25Yeah, and it's still probably my favorite thing about actual physical retail shopping

0:58:30is still the serendipity of encountering something that I didn't even know I wanted and saying,

0:58:34"Ooh, that looks interesting. I'll get that." Whereas online, I'm usually Target, not shopping

0:58:39at Target, but I'm targeting a specific product. Anything else on HomePod? I think we've pretty

0:58:49much wrapped that up until we get our hands on the damn things.

0:58:51Yeah, I mean, I just encourage again, I just encourage people if you're gonna try it out,

0:58:56go to an app. If you haven't, you know, wait, look at the reviews, but then go try it out

0:58:59because yelling about it before you've tried. Here's a good question. Here's a good question.

0:59:04I'm really curious how they sell this in the REIT speaking of retail, how they say what

0:59:11a segue, I should have a podcast. How is how I've been thinking about this ever since June,

0:59:18the hell are they going to sell these things in a retail store?

0:59:23We had those questions…

0:59:24I was wondering that about AirPod because that seemed like the hardest thing because

0:59:26how do you convince people about what an AirPod is because you can't just have a lineup

0:59:31of them on little strings?

0:59:32I don't know.

0:59:33At the very least though with AirPods, once they're in a customer's ears to demo,

0:59:38they're not blaring music in the store.

0:59:41And the Apple stores are big rectangular spaces that are not really, again, usually stuffed

0:59:51full of about 100 people, which isn't really at least much like my home.

1:00:00Right?

1:00:01I know.

1:00:03They had the Sonos stands for a while where they had like the section of the wall that

1:00:06was Sonos-branded and had like a bunch of Sonos speakers on it.

1:00:10They've had Beats speakers set up with the Pill and other things and they've had Airplay

1:00:14speakers set up for a while.

1:00:17I don't think they ever really demoed them loudly, if at all.

1:00:21I really wonder.

1:00:23I'm really curious how they're going to do this in the retail stores.

1:00:26Maybe they won't.

1:00:27When someone asked me on Twitter, I forget who the name was, but will HomePod technology

1:00:31filter down to the Beats line the way that AirPod technology did?

1:00:34Will you be able to buy a Beats version?

1:00:36If you really like the Beats Pill as a mobile speaker, for example, will you be able to

1:00:39that with some form of this integration stuff into it?

1:00:43I don't know.

1:00:46Like maybe there's room underneath that $350 price tag for a Beats version. It's

1:00:51not as slick as the Apple version, but we'll recognize a HomePod there and

1:00:55mesh its audio with it if you have it in the same room, but then

1:00:57you can take it with you and it'll give you like the Beats version.

1:01:01I remember like in the late 90s in the CD era,

1:01:05maybe mid to late 90s, where record stores

1:01:08started setting up things where like when new releases would come out, they would have

1:01:12headphone stations where you'd go to like station two and they would have like a poster

1:01:20up with here's the ten albums set up here and you could pick from one of ten CDs and

1:01:26listen to it with some pretty good headphones right there in the store. And that felt so

1:01:31futuristic. It was like, wow, imagine this is so amazing. You can listen to a new album

1:01:36them, as long as you want, of your choice, right here before you buy it.

1:01:43Yeah, and I'm pretty sure Apple had those, you know, when they started selling headphones,

1:01:47especially with the, I don't know about the Beats stuff, but they had headphone sections

1:01:51as well, where you could try them out.

1:01:54I don't know.

1:01:55Yeah, it's going to be interesting to see.

1:01:59Anything else?

1:02:00I don't think so.

1:02:01I don't know.

1:02:02Pun.

1:02:03No.

1:02:04Not until we get it.

1:02:05I guess in the news, I've been on hiatus for a holiday hiatus after the Star Wars Holiday

1:02:11Spectacular.

1:02:15So I've missed a couple of weeks here.

1:02:18And I think the whole, in terms of news, I'm not going to try to cover everything.

1:02:23It's not really a cover everything show.

1:02:25But the HomePod Specter, not HomePod, Jesus, Meltdown Specter thing, it sort of happened

1:02:34while the whole, I haven't really had a show in the meantime.

1:02:38Boy, what a nightmare this whole thing is.

1:02:40- Yeah, two critical vulnerabilities that date back to 1995

1:02:44for Intel chipsets and quite a ways back for ARM

1:02:48and AMD chipsets.

1:02:50And there's three vulnerabilities,

1:02:52one meltdown, two Spectre vulnerabilities.

1:02:54The meltdown one, Apple has patched for Mac OS now,

1:02:59going back two or three versions, I think as of today,

1:03:02They patched it in iOS 11.

1:03:04And Spectre, Apple smartly decided

1:03:07not to use Intel's microcode, which is great,

1:03:09because Intel yesterday said, oh, whoops,

1:03:12we're messing up older machines.

1:03:13Please don't use this.

1:03:15Apple only patched it in WebKit and Safari,

1:03:17which is where the JavaScript exploits could live.

1:03:20Yeah, it really does seem like the experts,

1:03:27they've got a handle on, ooh, that's pretty clever.

1:03:30and they kind of get the gist of how the exploit could work,

1:03:35but the understanding of how to fix it in a bulletproof way

1:03:40without sacrificing all of the performance advantages

1:03:45of speculative branching,

1:03:49it doesn't seem like anybody really

1:03:50has a full grasp on this yet.

1:03:52- And the mitigations only address known attacks.

1:03:55So if there are other attack possibilities discovered,

1:03:59they'll have to add more mitigations for them.

1:04:01- Yeah.

1:04:02- Like they're not actually fixing the fault,

1:04:03they're stopping people from attacking those faults

1:04:06in known ways.

1:04:07- Yeah, I have a friend who has a couple of web servers

1:04:12in production and it just seems like,

1:04:17you know, and they've been updated to, you know,

1:04:21with fixes to address this,

1:04:22but then ever since they were updated,

1:04:24they are occasionally just dropping off the internet.

1:04:29and need to be removed.

1:04:30- Yeah, there was an epic,

1:04:32one of the epic games was saying

1:04:34that they were getting a horrendous,

1:04:35and not only a performance hit,

1:04:36but because they had to use more processing power,

1:04:40an electrical hit too, like the power consumption

1:04:42was going way up to make up for it.

1:04:44- Right, like the fixes for this are,

1:04:47this is so low, it really almost couldn't get lower

1:04:51in the chain, you know, as they say, on the silicon,

1:04:56you know, getting close to the silicon.

1:04:57This is pretty close to the silicon.

1:04:59Boy, what a nightmare.

1:05:03It does seem--

1:05:04You have to do page isolation, which adds overhead, basically,

1:05:07to prevent it from accessing kernel memory.

1:05:09It seems as though Apple's products have come out

1:05:12of this fairly well in terms of-- I mean,

1:05:15who knows if they've actually fixed what they're hoping to fix.

1:05:18And they're being sued anyway.

1:05:21Oh, over this?

1:05:22Yeah, I mean, yeah, they're being sued over Meltdown Inspector

1:05:26already because of course they're being scored. I don't know that they could be sued over like

1:05:31the Tim Cook rooting for the wrong team at the hockey game last night at this point.

1:05:36Absolutely. But yeah, no, they, I mean, they, they were, they, they patched the stuff as fast

1:05:44as they could prudently. They didn't sort of deploy any microcode that turned out to be,

1:05:49I think Linus Torval called it garbage. He was quite upset with Intel. And it seemed like Intel

1:05:55has been an ass-covering mode rather than fixing mode throughout most of this.

1:05:58Yeah. Yeah, and it's surprising because Linus Torvalds usually is very diplomatic. It doesn't

1:06:10really speak his mind very often like that. No, not at all.

1:06:13No, but it does seem as though Apple has come out of this pretty well. If they've fixed

1:06:17what they think that they've fixed, it doesn't seem like computers have suddenly taken a

1:06:22a 25% performance hit or anything like that.

1:06:25But boy--

1:06:26No, it's workload dependent.

1:06:27And I think they announced that there was almost--

1:06:29like again, it depends if you're doing a lot of systems calls

1:06:31and what you're doing on a computer.

1:06:34But for most, I think most common tasks,

1:06:36there's almost no performance hit.

1:06:37And I think a 2.5% performance hit

1:06:39for some of the Spectre stuff on one of three Safari benchmarks.

1:06:43Right, the system cost of it.

1:06:45In layman's terms, I think I understand it.

1:06:48But the idea is that if the kernel is always running--

1:06:52well, the kernel is always running,

1:06:53and the kernel has access to all memory, including

1:06:56lots of stuff that individual processes should not

1:06:59have access to, that a process running in user space

1:07:05could take advantage of the speculative processing

1:07:08and trick the kernel into going down a certain branch

1:07:11that it shouldn't have permission-wise.

1:07:14And by the time the permission check happens,

1:07:19and you say, oh, I got to back out of that.

1:07:21But as the processor backs out of that,

1:07:25that memory that wasn't supposed to have been accessed

1:07:27is in a cache, perhaps, that the user land software could,

1:07:34through very clever ways that doesn't really matter how.

1:07:37And I couldn't explain it because I don't understand it.

1:07:39But because it's in the cache, which is accessible,

1:07:41could test it and figure it out and backwards, you know, back out of it what was actually

1:07:48in that protected memory.

1:07:50The best description I heard, I forget who it was from, but that meltdown is like a mugging

1:07:54and Spectre is like a Jedi mind trick.

1:07:58That's pretty good.

1:07:59I like that.

1:08:00But yeah, and it's bad for deployments like Amazon's or Google's because you could

1:08:05go through one virtual machine into the actual machine or into other virtual machines.

1:08:09Right, right.

1:08:10Well, all sorts of hosting services that are virtualized.

1:08:14Shared hosting, like traditional old shared hosting

1:08:16where you're just running those processes,

1:08:18or even virtualized processes, you know, servers,

1:08:21which is how a lot of most, I think, you know,

1:08:24sort of modern way to do shared hosting

1:08:26is where everybody gets their own version of the OS,

1:08:30typically Linux.

1:08:31But because it's really running on the same machine,

1:08:36this can be exploited.

1:08:37And that is sort of, you know, it's, I don't know,

1:08:41you could use all sorts of analogies,

1:08:43but it is sort of like breaking a hole in the matrix.

1:08:46You know, like, you know,

1:08:47when you're running in a virtualized server,

1:08:49it's supposed to be like the matrix where the software

1:08:52isn't supposed to realize it isn't running

1:08:54on its own machine entirely.

1:08:57It's supposed to, you know,

1:08:58think that it's, this is the real universe.

1:09:01I didn't know I was in a simulated universe

1:09:03within a larger universe.

1:09:05and this just pokes a hole right through it, which is really kind of—it breaks a lot

1:09:11of assumptions.

1:09:12Anyway, it's kind of fascinating stuff.

1:09:14Good to know that there doesn't seem to have been any widespread exploits that have

1:09:18come out of it yet.

1:09:19But then in the back of everybody's mind, you don't have to be a conspiracy theorist

1:09:23to wonder whether organizations like the NSA and others around the world have perhaps known

1:09:31about this for a long time.

1:09:36Yeah, I mean, people were wondering because what happened--

1:09:38Google's Project Zero discovered this.

1:09:41And then in rapid succession, the University of Graz--

1:09:43and I forget who the third group was-- discovered it as well.

1:09:46But it wasn't like it was there for 20 or so years.

1:09:50And then suddenly it was discovered.

1:09:52There was a Kaiser, which was page isolation, was proposed.

1:09:55And people were like, oh, we don't need that.

1:09:57Thanks.

1:09:57It's a cute idea, but we don't need it.

1:09:59And then all of a sudden, they were like, yeah,

1:10:01that project? Can we start fast-tracking it?" And it made people more curious. They started

1:10:04investigating along similar lines. Right. I saw that story. It was like people who were briefed

1:10:11on it were trying to propose this thing that nobody thought was solving a problem that everybody

1:10:17thought didn't exist. And then they realized, "Well, wait, why are they pushing this ahead?

1:10:22Why is it getting?" And they're like, "Well, this is a performance hit. Why would you really be,

1:10:25you really want it that badly? Okay, what are we missing here?" Which was super interesting.

1:10:31I'm trying to think, what else in the last month of news is…

1:10:36There was something yesterday, or was it the day before that I just thought, and I absolutely

1:10:40do not want to pick on anybody, but I was reading Business Insider and there was a story

1:10:44about how the Apple Store was such a hellish experience.

1:10:46I don't know if you saw it.

1:10:47No, I don't think so.

1:10:49So this reporter dropped their iPhone twice, and the first time the screen cracked, the

1:10:56second time apart, fell out of the screen.

1:10:58So they took it to the Apple store and they did not have an appointment and they went

1:11:01from one employee to another and they said they'd fit them in and they would replace

1:11:05it within two hours.

1:11:06So you went to a popular Apple store, no appointment.

1:11:10It was a little bit late to be fixed.

1:11:11It was like, I think it took four hours instead of two hours, but they got their phone back

1:11:15that same day.

1:11:16And they traveled to CES and the phone stopped working.

1:11:20And at no point in the story does it say, "Well, I dropped it twice.

1:11:24Maybe that caused more damage than I originally assumed."

1:11:26It was like Apple must have destroyed it when they repaired it.

1:11:29So they went back to another Apple store, another really busy Apple store, again didn't

1:11:34have an appointment, managed to get an appointment, came back and they were really upset there

1:11:39were no lines.

1:11:40And that's a fair complaint.

1:11:41Some people prefer waiting in lines and just milling about.

1:11:44Apple seems to think people like milling about.

1:11:46Some people prefer lines.

1:11:47But then they got a replacement iPhone.

1:11:49The iPhone got swapped out with a refurb and they left seethingly angry about what a hellacious

1:11:55experience this was.

1:11:56And by no means do I want to say that. I don't want to say that experience isn't, you know,

1:11:59they're not entitled to their opinion. They absolutely are. But for me, you know, I, if

1:12:04I went in, did not have an appointment, got my screen repaired, went back in, didn't have

1:12:08an appointment, got a new iPhone or a replacement iPhone at least, I think that was pretty great

1:12:13service.

1:12:14>> Yeah, I don't get that. I'll have to put a link to it in the show notes.

1:12:17>> And there was also this part about like the Google Pixel. They used that as a replacement

1:12:21phone while they were in SES and how great that was. And I have a Google Pixel phone.

1:12:26phone. If I dropped it twice, I'd have no idea how to get that fixed the same day.

1:12:30Dave: Yeah, I think you're SOL. I've heard that they have some kind of mail-in thing

1:12:37that's pretty good, but it's certainly…

1:12:39Jay Haynes Yeah, but it wouldn't be that day.

1:12:41Dave Certainly very unlikely that you're going

1:12:42to find a first party, even third party. I don't see how you could expect to find one

1:12:47of those third party repair shops that would have a replacement Pixel 2 screen ready to

1:12:52go. It doesn't seem like…

1:12:53Jay Haynes This is like one of those things where…

1:12:54Like I don't know how this goes up on like a website because absolutely you can think

1:12:59that's a bad experience but I think other people given the same information wouldn't

1:13:03think that and I certainly don't think it's like a worth castigating the company over.

1:13:07Right.

1:13:08It's like you go through it and you could see how it could be better.

1:13:12You know, it could be like 30 minute turnaround in theory.

1:13:17I've only ever dropped or cracked the screen on an iPhone twice and it was both times with

1:13:23my iPhone 6, which unsurprisingly had a reputation for being slippery. So my no case, no Apple

1:13:34Pay—not Apple Pay, Apple—what's the warranty program? I don't even know.

1:13:38I'm so—

1:13:39Michael Bock Apple Care.

1:13:40Dave Asprey Apple Care. I haven't bought Apple Care since 1991

1:13:42on any device.

1:13:43Michael Bock Wow. Okay.

1:13:44Dave Asprey I bite religiously.

1:13:45The one that made me the most nervous was the—what was it?

1:13:52Jesus, it's been so long, I don't remember the number.

1:13:55I think it was a Power Mac 9100 that I blew the amount of a small car on in 1996 when

1:14:07I got out of college.

1:14:11I haven't bought Apple Pay since 1991 on my Mac LC that I went to college with.

1:14:16So at this point, or 9600, that's right, Power Mac 9600.

1:14:20I can't believe I forgot that.

1:14:22Boy, I'm losing it, Rene.

1:14:24My beloved Power Mac 9600 that I use for probably more than I ever use any Mac that I've ever

1:14:29owned.

1:14:30I haven't bought Apple, what's it called?

1:14:34AppleCare.

1:14:35AppleCare.

1:14:36I can't remember.

1:14:37I can't remember. So I'm ahead. I could have a complete lemon and I could lose. At this

1:14:48point, I've bought so much stuff that I could have like a $2,500 MacBook that goes belly

1:14:54up two days out of warranty and I'd still be ahead compared to how much money. Anyway,

1:15:01I haven't done it.

1:15:02Don't do it on iPhones either because I just don't.

1:15:06I very seldom drop them, not just crack the screen, but I've had a few drops over the

1:15:12years.

1:15:13But the iPhone 6 I did twice.

1:15:14I dropped it, it cracked.

1:15:18And both times I was near an Apple store and took it in without an appointment and got

1:15:24it—I think I got it back within about 60 to 90 minutes both times.

1:15:29So I could see how four hours would be frustrating because it felt like a long time to me, too.

1:15:33But not like, you know, I didn't complain. I thought, "Hey, that's pretty good."

1:15:38You know.

1:15:39You didn't write "hellish experience" as a title on during Claire well.

1:15:41It was funny, though. It was very funny, though, like waiting around to get your phone back

1:15:48in the store. And, you know, you could just, you know, I could go to other stores. They

1:15:52say, "Hey, it'll be about an hour." But they can't take your phone number and text

1:15:57you when it's ready.

1:15:58Yes. Because they have your phone. And I, you know, it's like, come back in about an hour and check

1:16:05in. And I'd come back and it's like, oh, it's almost ready. I think it'd be like 15 more

1:16:09minutes. So I just hopped on like a MacBook in the store and browse around and I'd see something and

1:16:14I would think I want to take a note to remember that and I'd go to get my phone out to note it.

1:16:19And I didn't have my phone. It's very strange. I mean, I only ever damaged one for a long time.

1:16:25and that was an iPhone 4S that got hit by fireworks

1:16:28on New Year's and it melted the oleophobic coating.

1:16:30And I made an appointment, took it in, they looked at it,

1:16:33they decided to capture it 'cause I don't think

1:16:35they'd ever seen that before.

1:16:36And then I got a very kind but stern lecture

1:16:38about taking better care of my belongings.

1:16:40- Really?

1:16:41- But they replaced it immediately and I used,

1:16:44I logged into iCloud and it downloaded all my stuff

1:16:47and I was good to go.

1:16:48And I thought that was like, that was the future for me.

1:16:50But then this year, so I, the slipperiest phone

1:16:54I've ever owned was a Nexus 4.

1:16:55And you could put that in the middle of a dining room table

1:16:57and it would fall to the floor within an hour.

1:17:00But I found the iPhone 8,

1:17:02because they have the same similar

1:17:03inductive charging plates on the back,

1:17:07is also much more slippery than I would have anticipated.

1:17:10And so I've broken two, like in the last two months.

1:17:13- Really?

1:17:14- Just like I broke one the first day I had it,

1:17:16I put it down on the table

1:17:17and I didn't realize it was slightly on the napkin.

1:17:19And it used the napkin as a slide

1:17:21and landed on a stone floor.

1:17:23And it didn't break the back, it broke the front.

1:17:26And then the other one, I was out and I got hit by somebody

1:17:31and it sent the phone flying and it fell down

1:17:34and broke the front.

1:17:35- You got punched by somebody or you got--

1:17:37- No, I think they were just walking by aggressively.

1:17:40Like I was sitting there talking

1:17:42and they just slammed into me and kept walking,

1:17:44which is, I was in the US, I wasn't in Canada.

1:17:47I don't know if there's a difference there,

1:17:48and the phone just fell down and also broke the front.

1:17:53It's iPhone 8 that's just there been my pain so far iPhone 10 has been fine knock wood

1:17:58But I find it and I will say this I my experience making an appointment at an Apple store is in especially in the last few

1:18:04Let's say four or five years excellent where they're ready for you almost on time the amount of time it takes

1:18:11to

1:18:13diagnose

1:18:14Explain slash. Oh, I see. Yes, absolutely

1:18:17Whatever the issue is

1:18:21But I would say ideal, you know, I can't see how they would do better

1:18:24They did bury making a genius appointment

1:18:26Which I hate like it used to just be you go there you hit the genius button and you'd be gone and now you have

1:18:30To fight your way through three or four different layers of stuff before it lets you do that, which I dislike but hmm

1:18:35Interesting. I have it done. It's good. I wonder why they've done that probably

1:18:37Well, I think they wanted to get rid of people who just automatically make a yeah

1:18:41I mean for anything and they wanted you to go through sort of the steps to see if you really needed one

1:18:44Yeah, because I've noticed I haven't been there a lot

1:18:48I also have always been very lucky with non-Lemon Apple devices.

1:18:55I think I talked about it in the show years ago, but my son has the same model as me,

1:19:03a 2013 MacBook Pro 13-inch.

1:19:07And his had an issue where if he ever ran the battery down to zero and it auto shut

1:19:16down, it would never turn back on.

1:19:18There was nothing you can do to make it turn back on.

1:19:21And first, I was like, "Well, why don't do that?"

1:19:25It was like eventually—it happened one time and we got it to get back on somehow eventually.

1:19:31I forget what the deal was.

1:19:33And I was like, "Well, don't run it down."

1:19:34But then he would just do it again because he'd be like playing a game.

1:19:39And it was like that episode of Seinfeld where Kramer had a car where the engine—the gas

1:19:45light came on.

1:19:46And he was like, let's see how far we can go.

1:19:48It was sort of like a thrill seeking.

1:19:51But anyway, eventually we took it in, and they ran some tests.

1:19:53And it just would not turn on.

1:19:55It wouldn't take a charge.

1:19:56It was just inert.

1:19:58And it had to go away for repair.

1:19:59It was all as bad of a thing as you could have.

1:20:02It was like the logic board had to be replaced.

1:20:04It has to be sent away.

1:20:05It couldn't be done on premises.

1:20:06And the whole thing was fantastic.

1:20:08We were in the store for the briefest amount of time.

1:20:10It was obvious that something was wrong.

1:20:12They took it to the mysterious upstairs lab

1:20:16where somebody else confirmed, yes, this is not right.

1:20:19You sign out some forms, you sign your signature on an iPad,

1:20:23and two days later, they called me up

1:20:26and said the thing was back.

1:20:27- Yeah, no, it's terrific. - And it worked perfectly

1:20:30ever since.

1:20:32- Yeah, no, same experience.

1:20:33And I've had, before, I used to have work windows laptops,

1:20:36and we would pay for onsite service from Dell,

1:20:40but it was hideously expensive.

1:20:41And for the people who didn't have that, you never knew you were going to get your computer

1:20:44back.

1:20:45So, yeah, I don't get our friend at Business Insider.

1:20:51Is that what you said it was at, Business Insider?

1:20:53Yeah.

1:20:54That's shocking that Business Insider—

1:20:55I'll find you the link.

1:20:56It's very shocking to me that Business Insider would run something sensationalized like that.

1:21:00Yeah.

1:21:01I had a piece yesterday that a lot of people sent good things about, about these rumors

1:21:06of the iPhone X being produced for only one hour.

1:21:09Oh, God.

1:21:10It's a dud because of Ming Chi Kuo said people in China aren't buying the thing because all

1:21:20they want are big screens and they think the notch is using up too much space and they

1:21:24may only sell 18 million of them and stop production in summer.

1:21:28It's kind of funny how this really transmogrified and I wrote about it before it had even finished

1:21:34spreading where he writes this and Apple Insider does… The one thing about these Ming-Chi

1:21:40Kuo reports is they're not public. Presumably, they go to paid clients of his and then he

1:21:48seeds them to a very small handful of Mac rumor type publications like Apple Insider.

1:21:56Yeah, the KGI security subscribers get them.

1:21:58Yeah. I'm curious whether they go out before he sends them to Apple Insider and MacRumors.

1:22:09Because here's the thought I had yesterday as I was—and I don't typically do this,

1:22:12but I will take an aside here and just mention my long-time thing that I have a personal

1:22:20policy where I don't own any stock in individual companies other than Berkshire Hathaway, which

1:22:28which to me is more like an index fund. The only stock market investments I have are in

1:22:32index funds and I consider Berkshire Hathaway a sort of index fund. The only way I could

1:22:41possibly profit through Apple stock going up would be secondhand through the S&P 500

1:22:47going up, which to me is acceptable. I don't know. But anyway, that's my disclaimer.

1:22:55I don't own Apple stock.

1:22:56I have not owned Apple stock in many, many, many, many years.

1:23:00And even when I did, it was a ridiculously small amount.

1:23:03Anyway, I looked yesterday after all this happened, after the markets closed, and the

1:23:07market overall was up maybe like 2% and most of Apple's peers like Amazon and Google,

1:23:14I forget who else I looked at, were also up roughly 2% and Apple was down 2%, which 2%

1:23:22Up 2% down, that's the stock market.

1:23:25But at Apple's scale, that's literally billions of dollars of market cap.

1:23:31And I really can't help but think that the reason that Apple was down a bit on a day

1:23:35when the market was up a bit was that there were a whole bunch of stories about the iPhone

1:23:4010 being discontinued because it was unpopular.

1:23:44I mean, I don't think…

1:23:47There's this great interview from Jim Cramer from like 10 years ago where he starts off

1:23:51talking about BlackBerry but then finishes off talking about the iPhone.

1:23:54And he's like, this is how it works.

1:23:57I used to run a hedge fund and I know this and I don't think this is legal but you know

1:24:00if you've got to make your nut this is what you've got to do.

1:24:02And what you'll do is you'll start a rumor and you'll call somebody and you know who

1:24:05to call and you'll get them to say oh the Verizon is going to take a pass on the iPhone

1:24:09or the iPhone is going to be delayed and you start shorting and you start shorting.

1:24:12You get this guy to put a put on.

1:24:14You'll get him to call somebody else and you'll get him to say it and all of a sudden there'll

1:24:17be a run on it and you'll just move the market because that's how you got to get your money.

1:24:20That's how you got to get paid.

1:24:21That's what you've got to do to make every, you know.

1:24:23And he goes on to describe

1:24:25the entire market manipulation process

1:24:27of which the media is absolutely complicit

1:24:30because we've seen, there've been,

1:24:32in some years there are Wall Street Journal articles,

1:24:34not like no author name on them, no sourcing,

1:24:37that'll just say, Apple is gonna not have enough iPhones

1:24:40or they're not gonna have enough screens.

1:24:42And the market will react to those.

1:24:43And once in a while, those stories disappear

1:24:45but sometimes they're left up there.

1:24:48And it just seems like blatant manipulation

1:24:50because most of the time, the clients for these companies

1:24:53have been told days before,

1:24:54and they've done, like they've either shorted

1:24:56or they've bought, and then the media reaction

1:24:58moves the market, and it just feels like

1:25:00this is incredibly manipulative.

1:25:02- I really don't think it's a conspiracy.

1:25:06You have to be conspirationally minded to think that.

1:25:09I really do think that there is something to this,

1:25:11and you know, that's what makes me wonder--

1:25:14- It feels like pump and dump, like just basic pump and dump.

1:25:16- Well, that's what makes me wonder

1:25:17whether KGI Securities clients get these reports before they are leaked to the Apple press

1:25:26and can read between the lines of whether this is going to play as good news or bad

1:25:30news and make moves accordingly. That had never really occurred to me before as to whether

1:25:40he sends them to like MacRumors and AppleInsider at the same time or whether he sends them

1:25:44to them like a day later.

1:25:47But I don't think there's any doubt that he moves the market.

1:25:50He really does.

1:25:51Absolutely.

1:25:52I think at least he has his name on these things, but a lot of them, again, are completely

1:25:56– nobody knows who they are.

1:25:58And it's important to remember – and I just won't publish them because I am not

1:26:03their client.

1:26:04They have their clients.

1:26:05They are using me to achieve the ends of their clients and it is not my job to be used for

1:26:10their financial benefit.

1:26:13But anyway, I wrote about it and I think that if there is a kernel of truth here, and Ming-Chi

1:26:19Kuo obviously has some good sources in Foxconn at the very least, if not the whole Asian

1:26:24supply chain, but his sources at Foxconn have been pretty good in many ways, that I would

1:26:32interpret this as meaning that the iPhone X is going to be one of the phones like the

1:26:37the iPhone 5 like the original iPhone and the original iPhone that only are in production

1:26:44for one year. I forgot about the Apple Watch, but that's a good one where the original Apple

1:26:49Watch did not just slip down the pricing matrix to a second level. They actually replaced

1:26:58that with what they called the Series 1. We unofficially gave the original the nickname

1:27:06series zero. Yeah, I think that was Serenity Caldwell.

1:27:10Yeah, I think she did quite well. I do think she did. Thank you, Serenity. And I think

1:27:18that my completely conjectural—because Apple is—why they do things like this are like

1:27:25the holiest of holy secrets, and I think are only really ultimately known by the highest

1:27:31executive level. But I think it makes common sense to think that when they do something

1:27:35truly knew production-wise, like making the first ever watch or the first ever iPhone,

1:27:41that they learn things that they can subsequently even just in the course of 12 months do so

1:27:47much better that it no longer makes financial sense to keep making it.

1:27:53So the original iPhone was on sale for a year and as soon as the iPhone 3G was ready to

1:27:56go, the original iPhone was gone. There was no second, "Oh, you can save some money and

1:28:02get the year-old version, it was just gone. The only really new iPhone, truly radically

1:28:09new iPhone, in my opinion, that did stay for an extra year was the iPhone 4, which did

1:28:17two things production-wise that were totally new. It had the glass back with steel frame

1:28:23aluminum and it had a retina screen instead of a non-retina screen. And the irony that

1:28:29I pointed out was that it was also the one with the most notorious flaw, which was the

1:28:33attenuation issue. Like it was the, it was, of all the iPhones ever made, the one that

1:28:38stayed, it also stayed the longest as the top tier phone because it was the one that,

1:28:44it was the last one to ship at the end of June, early July. And a 4S was the first one

1:28:49that shifted to the fall. So.

1:28:50And it was way late in the fall.

1:28:52the most flawed iPhone and biggest PR debacle the company has ever faced was the flagship

1:29:02iPhone for the longest amount of time and then still remained in the lineup as the second

1:29:07cut iPhone for another year after that.

1:29:10So the thing that gets me is like I think, and I think this is true for a lot of rumors,

1:29:14is that, and Ming-Chi Kuo and other people, is that they get a little bit of information

1:29:19but then they spin a narrative around that information.

1:29:22And not all of them seem to understand Apple very well

1:29:24because the narratives don't often coincide

1:29:26with the way Apple actually does things.

1:29:27And then people conflate the information in their rumor

1:29:30with the context that's been invented

1:29:32to sort of tell a story about it.

1:29:34And then that just snowballs.

1:29:36And in this case, I think your iPhone 5 analogy

1:29:39is really apt because when the iPhone 5S came out,

1:29:41Apple doesn't really care if the phone looks alike.

1:29:44They had the iPhone 6 and 6S and 7 and 8

1:29:47all in the market at the same time.

1:29:48But with the iPhone 5C, the iPhone 5 was difficult to manufacture,

1:29:54and reducing it in cost would be problematic.

1:29:58But also, it wouldn't let Apple reach any newer different markets,

1:30:01where the iPhone 5C was cheaper to make.

1:30:03And it let Apple test the idea of a less expensive, more colorful,

1:30:06more fun iPhone.

1:30:07And here you have an iPhone X, which is expensive to make.

1:30:11It uses a scarce resource like OLED.

1:30:13And if Apple replaces that with an LED iPhone,

1:30:16They can save the OLED supply for the new flagships

1:30:19But also they can make it slightly bigger or do whatever they think they need to test out

1:30:23Like whether it is China or something else to test out a slightly different form factor. Yeah

1:30:27Well, the funny thing to me is how this that there's that old kids game whisper down the alley or whatever

1:30:36It's called where broken telephone broken telephone where it's kids line up in a row and you're supposed to whisper as quietly as possible

1:30:42Somebody starts with something and then that you know

1:30:4520 kids in a row. One kid whispers it to the next and you're split in good faith. You're supposed to

1:30:50try to whisper it to the next person as accurately as possible. I distinctly recall as a child

1:30:56purposefully mangling it in a humorous way. Don't invite John Gruber to your game of broken

1:31:05telephone. But even when kids try to do it, honestly, it is kind of funny how it comes out

1:31:11wrong at the end. And it's really this story in particular quickly got wrong where the

1:31:18original report for Ming-Chi Kuo is the fact he reported was that he thinks Apple might

1:31:27stop production of the iPhone X this summer in the lead up to the new phones, which I

1:31:35would fit exactly with what, you know, not that they would stop selling it. He's completely

1:31:40writing that at some point in July, Foxconn can stop making iPhone 10s and focus on iPhone

1:31:4811s or whatever we're going to call them.

1:31:53Apple will still have these iPhone 10s that had been made through July to sell through

1:31:58mid-September when they switch to the new product line where the iPhone 10 doesn't exist.

1:32:05That's what Ming-Chi Kuo wrote.

1:32:06That's what Apple Insider, I believe, accurately summarized, but I can't prove because I don't

1:32:13have Ming-Chi Kuo's report.

1:32:15Yeah.

1:32:16It matched what MacRumors wrote, which I think means it's pretty consistent.

1:32:21It was then taken up by somebody at Newsweek who made it seem as though the iPhone was

1:32:29was being discontinued now and they'd stop selling it in the summer and we'd go, you

1:32:36know, like in the mid-summer there would be no more iPhone 10s to buy and that new iPhones

1:32:40wouldn't be ready yet because that's how badly the iPhone 10 was selling.

1:32:45So the only thing that makes more sense is to stop selling it.

1:32:48Right. And then it went – it got to the point where the just – the summary of the

1:32:51story was that Apple is right now in the midst of canceling the iPhone 10. And I – this

1:32:56is a true story.

1:32:57Yeah, Forbes was horrible about that too.

1:32:58You may not have seen it. I wrote this story on Daring Fireball right before we recorded

1:33:03and published it. There's a great contractor we've had working on and off in our house,

1:33:09a guy named Wayne. Really nice guy. Does good work. Sort of a technical enthusiast. One

1:33:14day he was here and he was doing work in my office. It probably doesn't really look like

1:33:25an Apple store because it's not very well organized. But it certainly looks like maybe

1:33:30I robbed an Apple store in terms of the number, especially a couple of months ago when I had

1:33:35boxes of multiple new iPhones out on my desk. And he's like, "What do you do?" And I told

1:33:43him. And he was kind of intrigued by it. He's sort of a gadget, a regular person gadget

1:33:49nerd. He was here today and it's like, "Ding-dong, here he is, the doorbell. Hey, how you doing,

1:33:57Wayne? Good to see you, John." Something about the Eagles being in the Super Bowl. Friendly

1:34:03chit-chat. Then he's like, "Hey, what the heck's the deal with this thing I saw yesterday

1:34:08where the iPhone X's been canceled? Is that legit?" I was just blown away. It could not

1:34:14be a more regular person and he's heard that Apple is canceling the iPhone 10. Crazy. It's

1:34:22absolutely insanity.

1:34:24I saw people on Reddit asking, "Well, Apple is canceling the phone. Are they going to

1:34:28take my phone away? Will they repay me?" This is how people react to those kinds of stories.

1:34:33They're not stupid. They just don't understand when they use headlines what it means to them

1:34:38and they start to panic.

1:34:39All right, it really is like the headline. You know, everybody talks about fake news and fake

1:34:45stories and truly out, you know, truly, you know, this nobody really lied here, although I would

1:34:52say there's some mendacity involved in I think, purposeful exaggeration, especially in the

1:34:58headlines. And I really cannot emphasize enough for people who don't think about this because you

1:35:03know, you're not in the business of writing headlines, but headlines have always been

1:35:07important even in the print world. And on magazines, they sell the magazines. So there's

1:35:14always the pre-digital equivalent of clickbait is salacious headlines on the magazines or

1:35:22a newspaper tabloid to sell copies. Like, "Oh, there's an exaggerated sensationalist

1:35:30headline."

1:35:31If it bleeds, it leads. A man bites a dog, all that stuff.

1:35:34Right. But even then you're not a click away, right? Like even if the cover of the New York

1:35:39Post has you intrigued enough to say, "Oh, damn it. I'm buying a copy." You've still

1:35:43got to wait in line. You've got to reach in your pocket and get 50 cents out and hand

1:35:47it over. And you know you're buying, you're not just dipping your toes in. You're picking

1:35:52up a whole 85-page newspaper. You know what I mean? Whereas a click is always, you're

1:35:58just a click away. You could just touch it. Just touch, just touch, just tap here, tap

1:36:02this, tap this, tap this. Listen to this.

1:36:03the tabloids at the end of the supermarket line.

1:36:07Right. Except that you can't, you're just a towel. All you have to do is touch it. Just

1:36:10touch, just touch this spot. Touch this spot on the, you know, and your thumb is already

1:36:14just an inch away. Just move your thumb one inch and tap this and we'll explain this seemingly

1:36:20impossible headline away that the iPhone, you know, Mighty Apple Incorporated is canceling

1:36:29their supposedly best product ever made. But it seeds these, you know, I know meme, the

1:36:41word meme has sort of been co-opted to mean these graphical animated GIFs with headlines

1:36:49underneath. But going back to Richard Dawkins' original definition of just the way that an

1:36:53an idea can sort of spread through a culture. You know what I mean? It's not even like a

1:37:03story. It's not like there's, it's just that headline, just the notion of Apple has canceled

1:37:07the iPhone tent, which is preposterous. Yeah. And I also, I told, and I also thought it

1:37:16was interesting that my contractor friend Wayne, the way he posed it to me, he was like,

1:37:24"That's not right, is it?" He knew to be skeptical. You know what I mean? It wasn't like he was

1:37:28fooled. The problem isn't that people like Wayne have been tricked into thinking it's

1:37:36true that Apple canceled the phone. Because he's not dumb. He just isn't deeply involved

1:37:42this. It's just something he cares about tangentially. And because he's not dumb,

1:37:45because he's actually a smart, bright guy, he knew to be skeptical. But he just didn't understand

1:37:57how to square the two things. He knows this doesn't sound right, but that's what people are saying.

1:38:02That's the essence of FUD. It's fear, uncertainty, and doubt. They're fearful that it might be true,

1:38:06they're uncertain whether it is or true or not, and so start to doubt what they think is real.

1:38:10And it's a huge problem.

1:38:11I remember my mom once called me,

1:38:13she said I was watching BBC

1:38:14and they said that the iPhone had been hacked.

1:38:16And because like I do what I do,

1:38:18I knew what the story was.

1:38:19And it was if you, you know, if you went to a,

1:38:22if you jail broke your iPhone

1:38:24and you went to a specific Chinese cracked iPhone app store

1:38:27and you downloaded certain apps and you were a journalist,

1:38:29they were trying to target you with malware.

1:38:32And it had nothing to do with anything

1:38:34that would affect anyone else who was an Apple customer.

1:38:37But the BBC ran it as though the iPhone was hacked.

1:38:39And another major blog said that Apple's unblemished security

1:38:45record is now broken.

1:38:47It was never not broken, and it wasn't broken now.

1:38:50But this is a narrative that people are getting fed.

1:38:52And then people who are already worried about technology,

1:38:55who don't find it accessible, or who think it's scary,

1:38:58they're just made more afraid.

1:38:59And you're literally victimizing people

1:39:02who would benefit from the technology.

1:39:04Do you read--

1:39:05I love it.

1:39:05I've used it for years.

1:39:07many years, I don't even remember how long, but the website Techmeme, I don't know if it's because

1:39:13I thought of the word meme or not, but Techmeme is sort of an aggregator of nerd tech industry news.

1:39:21Gabe Rivera is the founder. I haven't seen Gabe in years, but I know Gabe a little bit.

1:39:27And the gist of it is if you've never been there, go to techmeme.org. I find it to be a terrific way

1:39:35to just get a snapshot of, hey, has anything big happened,

1:39:39especially like when I'm traveling,

1:39:41if there's a day when I'm busy

1:39:43and I haven't checked anything in a while,

1:39:45just quick look at tech meme

1:39:48and scroll down a bit from the top.

1:39:49And it's a good way to sanity check,

1:39:51have I missed anything big

1:39:52that I really need to know about during Fireball?

1:39:55Nope, or yes, look at that, wow.

1:39:58I need to take a break here and go look at it.

1:40:00And it ranks things,

1:40:03I don't know what quite the algorithm is,

1:40:05but anyway a couple of years ago tech memes switched from running the original publications headlines to

1:40:10rewriting them

1:40:12editorially good old-fashioned human

1:40:14Human writing

1:40:20And a lot of publications really got pissed off about that

1:40:24And made them verbose enough to tell you everything about the story in the headline, which they thought would limit click-through

1:40:32And you know oftentimes but but if you're if you're headlining if that's how much could be if that's how much it's news is in

1:40:40Your story really who's at fault there?

1:40:42Yeah, well if you're not adding value beyond the facts, then you know, it's not their fault the abuse of headlines

1:40:49I can't get off. I can't overstate

1:40:52Just how bad of a problem it is in my opinion

1:40:55Yeah

1:40:55You know and and tech meme goes to the opposite measure of actually rewriting them out of respect for the

1:41:02Visitors detect memes time and attention. Yeah, there's a great Twitter a clown. I forget the name of it

1:41:08I think it's called saved you a click. Yes

1:41:10It's so great and

1:41:15Like I saw one today where it was like it's often movie news

1:41:21but they just in other words, they'll take a totally salacious tweet or headline and

1:41:25Just quote it in a tweet and then tell you and usually in about five words

1:41:31What the story actually is saved you a click. Yeah, and it was one it was like the Russo brothers

1:41:37talk about

1:41:41The

1:41:43What's the movie with Scarlett Johansson where she sees a superhero

1:41:46The Black Widow or the Black Widow Black Widow movie the Black Widow movie and

1:41:52This this saved you a quick summary of the entire story was they're very excited to work on it

1:42:00Yeah, and you know, that's the whole story. Like what are they gonna do?

1:42:04Are they going to have a love-hate relationship with saved you click because in there are some writers who are really good and I want

1:42:09To go on that ride with them like they're teasing out a headline

1:42:12Telling you a phenomenal story and then they'll sing you at the end almost like a like an M Night

1:42:17Shall we have a Shyamalan movie at its finest and then it really could they just said Darth Vader's his father

1:42:21I'd be like, ah, damn it

1:42:22I wanted to go on that ride

1:42:23But there are a lot of cases where there really is nothing else and they do save me a clinic

1:42:27So you're saying that they're not quite they're not quite judicious enough in who they go after yes in terms of

1:42:32It's a really yeah, and yes, it depends on the quality of the writer

1:42:36But I think there are some writers out there that deserve to

1:42:38Let the experience of revealing what they want to say and there are others that are just trying to steal your attention

1:42:42And I think there's a line between the two

1:42:45I

1:42:47Don't think we're gonna get to our your 2017 year in review

1:42:51But we could try to squeeze it in in the last few minutes to the show

1:42:54But in the meantime, I think our third and final sponsor of the week

1:42:57Squarespace

1:42:59Look, you need to make a move. You need to make some kind of new project. You've got an idea

1:43:04You need a website. You should make that move with Squarespace

1:43:09You can make a beautiful website from Squarespace in just minutes

1:43:14You could do 30 minutes and you wouldn't just have a generic website from Squarespace. You could have your website from Squarespace

1:43:22Really, really beautiful, attractive design,

1:43:25all sorts of features, any kind of thing

1:43:27that you really wanna build,

1:43:28any kind of standard pattern for a website,

1:43:30like having a blog, hosting a podcast,

1:43:34hosting a store, putting up a gallery of your work

1:43:38or whatever it is you're trying to show off,

1:43:41you can do it at Squarespace.

1:43:43Or you can come by multiple things and have sections

1:43:45and have one section be your podcast and one be your blog

1:43:48and another place where you sell your t-shirts.

1:43:50I can't overstate just how comprehensive the Squarespace platform is.

1:43:58All visual, you do it right there in the browser, drag and drop, totally visual, WYSIWYG design,

1:44:05the way design is meant to be.

1:44:08But if you have the technical chops, if you know HTML and CSS and JavaScript and you want

1:44:12to get in there and mess with it at that level, you can certainly do it at that level too.

1:44:17You can do it at the technical level.

1:44:18You can do it at the visual level.

1:44:20Really great.

1:44:21You can do everything from registering your domain name to doing the design.

1:44:27All of the hosting, they take care of it.

1:44:29It's a really bulletproof, reliable platform, high performance, really fast website, and

1:44:35they have everything else you need too like analytics, meaning stats, and you can see

1:44:40how many people are coming to your site, where they're coming from, where they're going on

1:44:44your site, everything like that.

1:44:46They have it all. It's really great. I know you've heard me say this before. They sponsor

1:44:54the show all the time. They sponsored it for years. But the reason they keep coming back

1:44:58is that people who listen to this show keep signing up for new Squarespace accounts and

1:45:03telling them they came from here. So if you're in the market for a new website, I implore

1:45:09you to check out Squarespace. I really do recommend it personally and join the—I would

1:45:15love to know just how many people from the talk show have signed up for Squarespace over

1:45:19the years go there to Squarespace calm, just Squarespace calm, no special URL. What they

1:45:25do want you to remember is the offer code talk show just plain talk show. And you use

1:45:31that at checkout, you will get 10% off and you can pay for a whole year in advance. So

1:45:35you could pay 10 bucks, save 10% off an entire year all at once. So start your free trial

1:45:42today at Squarespace.com. You don't have to pay him a nickel. Once you're ready to go,

1:45:48just remember that code talk show and you'll save 10% off your first purchase Squarespace.

1:45:54So we've had extradition, I forget if it's two or three years in a row where you've come

1:45:57on at the end of the year and we've done like a year in review. And I ran out of time last

1:46:04last December, so we didn't do it. But here you are in the first episode of 2018. We could

1:46:08we could whip through it. Yeah, totally. I mean, not much happened, right?

1:46:15I don't have notes on this. What do you think? What's your high-level takeaway of

1:46:23the year that Apple had? The year of the industry?

1:46:26One of those years… I'm not sure if I prefer it or not, but it was one of those

1:46:30years where Apple didn't have a March event and we got used to having them again because

1:46:34'cause they had a series of events

1:46:35for like the 12-inch MacBook and Apple Watch

1:46:38and the iPhone SE and the,

1:46:40the close we got was the product red iPhone,

1:46:43which wasn't an event, it was just sort of pushed out there.

1:46:46But we waited till WWDC to have any sort of Apple,

1:46:50before Apple took the stage at all.

1:46:51And then when they did, we got like a plethora of things.

1:46:54We got all the Kaby Lake, the MacBook, the MacBook Pro,

1:46:58the iMac Pro was shown off, the HomePod was shown off.

1:47:04I don't know if people are wondering why it was showing off so early, why those parts

1:47:08were not so early, if they're going to ship in September, but they've done that in the

1:47:11past.

1:47:13And we got all the new operating systems, and it was just, it felt like we went so long

1:47:16without it, and then everything was just slammed onto us all at once.

1:47:21My high-level takeaway of 2017 is, I don't know if it's my primary interest in the company,

1:47:30but it certainly is, if it's not number one, it's very, very close.

1:47:33But it's probably number one and it's selfish and very selfishly.

1:47:39Everything I've done professionally in my life, other than the high school job I had

1:47:47stocking shelves in a supermarket/pharmacy and scraping gum off the tables of my school

1:47:56when I was in 10th grade during the summer and cutting the grass, I've done with a

1:48:02a computer. 99.999% of that work was on Apple computers. Not through luck, but through actually

1:48:17choosing what I do. I've spent, other than some internships in college, really spent

1:48:24very little time needing to use Windows professionally, and that was by choice.

1:48:31And I see 2017 as an interesting year for Apple as the maker of machines for creative

1:48:38professionals, where I do think that they dropped the ball on the latest MacBook Pros.

1:48:47There's just no question in my mind.

1:48:49There's certain aspects of them that are debatable like, "Hey, maybe they didn't need to make

1:48:55it any thinner. I wish it was the same thickness as before and just put more battery in there."

1:49:02Debatable. I could see why other people would say, "This is amazing. It's as thin and light

1:49:07as a MacBook Air, but it has a retina screen in its performance." But the keyboard is undeniably

1:49:13a step backward. It is failing for people. There's too many people who they're getting

1:49:20keys stuck. And that's just it. The keyboard has to be reliable. It absolutely has to be.

1:49:28And I like to get a Mac and use it until I feel like it's really problematic. So I've

1:49:33still got my recording right now using my 2013 MacBook Pro that I bought with a core

1:49:39i7 and maxed out the RAM at 16 and all big 1GB SSD. The thing still runs really, really

1:49:48well. So I wasn't in the market for a new one. But boy, ever since this report of the

1:49:52unreliable keyboards has broken out and really become well-known months ago, every time I'm

1:50:00traveling or otherwise using my MacBook Pro for work and I'm writing, and guess what?

1:50:06I write a lot. I keep thinking about how I've never had a MacBook or PowerBook or an iBook

1:50:13that had a keyboard that I didn't trust 100%. And how frustrating I would find it to have

1:50:20a keyboard that wasn't 100% reliable. Like 100%. 100%. I've had this machine now for

1:50:28over four years. I don't think I've ever once tried to type a letter on this keyboard

1:50:37and not had the key that I thought I was pressing register the key in the software I was typing.

1:50:45No, I'm sorry. I say 2013. I just checked. It's mid-2014, 2014. So it's a year and

1:50:51so is my son's, the lemon that was fixed. I misremembered. Good thing I went to the

1:50:57about box wouldn't want to get that wrong. So it's a three-year-old computer. But literally,

1:51:02however many keystrokes I've typed since sometime in the second half of 2014 when I

1:51:09bought it and it became my personal laptop, it is literally at 100% to my knowledge. I've

1:51:16never once tried to type a K and not had the K register or had the K stick or something

1:51:20like that. Anything less than that is unacceptable to me. So I really think they have a problem

1:51:26there with the keyboard. I also think that as the as we stand right now, I think that

1:51:32the touch bar is not good enough. I think there's way too many people who don't like

1:51:39it at all and way too few people who have good things to say about it. It's hard for

1:51:43me to judge because I only used it for like two weeks while reviewing them. And I was

1:51:47intrigued by it. But it still seemed like this is really cool idea. Let's wait and see

1:51:52how it shakes out in software.

1:51:54And it seems like the way it's shaken out

1:51:56is that people don't really care for it or love it.

1:52:00So I'm very similar to you in that I have that exact same

1:52:02MacBook Pro, like the 13-inch from 2014.

1:52:05And I loved it.

1:52:05It was probably my favorite computer

1:52:07because I vacillated between the MacBook Pro and the MacBook

1:52:10Air in terms of power and portability.

1:52:12And that one really felt like it had it all.

1:52:14But I'm different in that I've been using the 13-inch

1:52:16with Touch Bar since it came out,

1:52:18since the very first time it was available.

1:52:21And I have two thoughts about it.

1:52:23One is I vastly prefer the keyboard

1:52:25on the new MacBook Pro to the previous ones.

1:52:27But I know that not everybody thinks that.

1:52:30And Apple is the only manufacturer of MacBooks.

1:52:33So you cannot have a product that's divisive.

1:52:35You can have people who like one keyboard more

1:52:37than the other.

1:52:38But if you have a large portion of your customer base

1:52:40who actively hates that keyboard, that's a problem

1:52:43because they have nowhere else to go.

1:52:45And the failure thing is just not debatable.

1:52:47I have had keys fail on older MacBooks,

1:52:50but they were super easy to either clean or replace,

1:52:53like just trivial.

1:52:54And this one is absolutely not.

1:52:56This is an expensive repair.

1:52:57- Yeah, and let me just emphasize that.

1:52:59It's not that in my life I've never had a key go bad

1:53:01on any Apple laptop.

1:53:03I mean, I think I had a white,

1:53:05I know I had a white iBook, the 12-inch white iBook,

1:53:08and I think the keys got a little squishy,

1:53:09but they were fixable.

1:53:11I didn't have to go to a store.

1:53:12I could, you know, jimmy it with a pocket knife or something.

1:53:15I'm just saying, but I'm saying that the 100% record

1:53:17is with this particular MacBook Pro from mid-2014 that I fastidiously never eat food around,

1:53:27which my son does.

1:53:28I'm a filthy blogger, so I thought mine was just waiting to die.

1:53:32My son's keyboard is like Oscar the Grouch's keyboard. It's really kind of astounding.

1:53:40But you know what's funny though? It would drive me crazy. He's got keys that to me stick,

1:53:47But they don't stick stick.

1:53:49They just don't click right, but it actually works.

1:53:52If you just trust that what you think you're typing,

1:53:54you're typing and look at the screen, it actually works.

1:53:57Even though it feels, ugh, it makes me sick.

1:54:00But anyway, I love them.

1:54:02I think it's a problem.

1:54:04And I also think it's interesting on the flip side

1:54:07for professional work, you've got,

1:54:11it was a big, big year for iPad Pro.

1:54:16- But before we move on from the MacBook Pro,

1:54:17the one other thing that I wanted to say about this is,

1:54:20this is one of those things where data,

1:54:22you know, people talk about data a lot,

1:54:23but data is nothing without analysis.

1:54:25And Apple has a ton of data about what we buy.

1:54:28We literally vote with our wallets

1:54:30for everything that Apple does.

1:54:31And people don't buy desktops.

1:54:34When they do buy desktops, they buy iMacs,

1:54:36but they don't buy desktops, they buy MacBooks.

1:54:38And MacBook Air is super popular.

1:54:40And everything Apple is telling them,

1:54:41including the success of the iOS devices,

1:54:43is that the lighter and more mainstream

1:54:45make these products, the more they will sell.

1:54:47And despite people really not liking these MacBooks, they're incredibly popular.

1:54:52And you could say that there was a hunger or a thirst or there's no alternative, but

1:54:55it's also possible that Apple is making more mainstream MacBooks.

1:54:59But they did it at the expense of the pros instead of adding a product.

1:55:03It's great that they had the MacBook escape for people who didn't want everything else,

1:55:07but they didn't have a MacBook Pro Pro the way they have the iMac Pro that was sitting

1:55:10on top of the line that was there for the people who really wanted high memory, high

1:55:15power, high processing, and didn't give a crap if it had battery life or thinness at

1:55:19all. I think that missing product was… I think if they'd had that extra one on top,

1:55:24the way they had the extra one on the bottom, we wouldn't have seen anywhere near the

1:55:27negative sentiment we got.

1:55:28Yeah, I think that's a fantastic point. I wish I had put it in a note so I would have

1:55:33been sure to make it, but you made it well. But I think you're exactly right that they

1:55:36They should, in theory, there should be what the current thinner MacBook Pros are to the

1:55:46iMac.

1:55:50There should be like the 5K iMac.

1:55:53There should be something that is like the iMac Pro and/or Mac Pro.

1:56:01These are really MacBook Air Pros that we got.

1:56:03Yeah.

1:56:04names matter, but I think if you put names aside, and I don't know what you'd call it,

1:56:12somebody that could come up with something, but there should be a thicker, heavier, more USB ports,

1:56:19pro things that... The pro word is so problematic, and I see so many columns and listen to so many

1:56:30podcasts where I get frustrated because it's like almost like if you took the word pro

1:56:36off the MacBook Pro, like you said, just call it like the new MacBook Air or just, you know,

1:56:43or if they just like iPhones just put the word MacBook on all of them, whether it was

1:56:48the MacBook One port, the MacBook Pro, whatever. I think you can easily get lost in the weeds

1:56:55by defining pro as professional and because different people who make their living on

1:57:03it in a professional sense do it in so many different ways. There are people who literally

1:57:08don't need any of the ports. There are people who can use it all day long and get terrific

1:57:13battery life with exactly the thinness and who really appreciate how much thinner it

1:57:17is and lighter to carry around.

1:57:21And there are people who are like, well, I would call new generation pros who they're

1:57:24they're entrepreneurs or they're doing, they're doing a running a business. And to them, they,

1:57:29they consider themselves pros the same way that people old school would be like designers

1:57:33or renderers or anything. And you also have the other end of the scale where you have

1:57:37people who almost see like Apple is taking fire from on high and giving it to the masses

1:57:41and how dare these people be pros. Only what I do is pro and there's assholes on both sides

1:57:45that argument, but in the middle is a bunch of people being underserved.

1:57:48Yeah, and I appreciate that frustration of, "Wow, they used to make a machine that had

1:57:55plenty of ports that I used, and now I can't get one unless I buy the old, you know, I

1:58:01can't get the new one with the ports that I use, and I'm stuck using these dongles."

1:58:06And I thought about it too, because I've always had to use dongles.

1:58:08I had to use DVI dongles and FireWire dongles and all sorts of things, but I realize a big

1:58:13difference here is that USB was never one of the choices they had to make.

1:58:17It was always the fringe stuff that I used dongles for like Thunderbolt or something

1:58:21and USB is something everybody needs. So now the dongle is everybody's problem and not

1:58:24just the nerd niche sort of problem.

1:58:27Yeah. It's, you know, I used to roll my eyes at people barking about SD card slots because

1:58:33I was shooting with a Canon and I had a CF card, so I needed the dongle anyway. And then

1:58:38I bought a Fuji X 100 S and I could just plug the SD card right into my Mac book. And it's

1:58:42like, hey, that's pretty cool. Like, yeah, I'm not angry that

1:58:47they don't have SD card slots on the new ones. But I'm kind of

1:58:50glad that I'm still using one that has one. Yeah. So anyway,

1:58:54it until you need it. Anyway, I do think you're right, though. I

1:58:57think I trust Apple to listen. I also know that, you know,

1:59:02there's an awful lot of people at Apple itself who use Mac

1:59:06books, including, you know, people like Tim Cook and Phil

1:59:09Schiller, who, if their keys get stuck, they're gonna, they might bring it up. Yeah. Yeah.

1:59:18And also their holes, all their engineers and all their software and hardware engineers

1:59:21use Mac books every day and they need them to work. I also think, and I'm kind of excited

1:59:26about it. I think that Apple could appreciate that, hey, we didn't hit it out of the park

1:59:32with the first touch bar. Not to call him out, but I think Marco Arment on the ATP had

1:59:45said his wish would be for Apple to say, "You know what? We tried it. It wasn't a good idea.

1:59:49We're next MacBook Pro. You can buy it fully spec. You don't have to get the lowest end one. You can

1:59:55get any of them without it." I would rather see Apple say, "You know what? It wasn't good enough.

2:00:00let's make it better.

2:00:02Let's do a 2.0 touch bar that people do want to give up

2:00:07the old style function keys for.

2:00:10Maybe with a hardware escape key.

2:00:14- No, but it's super interesting.

2:00:16- Which I don't think is a ridiculous idea,

2:00:17which I don't think is a ridiculous idea.

2:00:20To have a button on the top right for touch ID

2:00:23and an escape key on the left

2:00:24and just do the touch bar in the middle.

2:00:26- But that's the thing.

2:00:27So you could also, you could just call it the home button

2:00:28if you wanna make it super friendly for people.

2:00:29It doesn't really matter, but is touch ID long

2:00:32for this world?

2:00:33Like if we go to face ID, does that disappear?

2:00:35And that's the most compelling part about the touch bar.

2:00:37Like I use a touch bar as a shortcut

2:00:40because I can just swipe across Safari tabs faster

2:00:43than I can actually find the Safari tab I want

2:00:45with the keyboard.

2:00:46And there's all sorts of things that I can do

2:00:48that's just quick on it.

2:00:49But I use that touch ID thing all the time.

2:00:52- I did too.

2:00:52And it was the single thing I hated giving up

2:00:56from the review unit that I had.

2:00:58But I also think now, several months into the iPhone X lifestyle, that there's no doubt

2:01:03in my mind that the Touch ID is not long for this world.

2:01:08And on a MacBook in particular, it seems Face ID would be way more better than Touch ID

2:01:19than it even is on the phone, and I clearly think it's better on the phone.

2:01:22But in terms of getting an angle and working with being completely, I want to say ambidextrous,

2:01:32but not biased towards the right side on your right hand.

2:01:37I mean, Windows Hello works now without any of the technology Apple's applying to it.

2:01:41It would just be a fantastic product.

2:01:43Right.

2:01:44And you've got some time when you open a MacBook, and there's some time there where Face ID

2:01:51already register you. Unlike the phone where you can make arguments about which is faster

2:01:57by the stopwatch, it should clearly be faster on a MacBook, opening it from a closed position.

2:02:03Anyway, so I think it's funny that to me the best part about the Touch Bar system on the

2:02:10current MacBook Pros is the Touch ID sensor, which I think is likely going away. I don't

2:02:16I don't know when.

2:02:19Anyway, I want to move on to the iPad side of things.

2:02:21And I think it was a very interesting year for the iPad

2:02:23Pro, because I think we saw the most serious attempt at making

2:02:31iPad running on-- or iOS running on iPads more like several

2:02:37steps closer to what would this be like if it was primarily

2:02:41for iPads and not secondarily for iPads.

2:02:43like an iPad OS rather than a vanilla iOS.

2:02:47- Right, and I liked all of the ideas.

2:02:50I liked the list of problems they were trying to solve.

2:02:55It all seemed, there wasn't any aspect of it

2:03:01that I would think, and I say this guardedly

2:03:05because I don't use an iPad Pro for a lot of work,

2:03:08so I'm judging it sort of as a tourist, but I liked it.

2:03:13and as a user interface critic.

2:03:15But then as time wore on and they settled in,

2:03:17I still think the biggest problem

2:03:19isn't that they didn't come up with good ideas,

2:03:21but that it still doesn't go nearly far enough.

2:03:24- Yeah.

2:03:24- In terms of things that I find so convenient

2:03:27and so quick and so easy to do

2:03:30almost without thinking about it on a Mac,

2:03:32which feel like I'm doing surgery on somebody with chopsticks

2:03:37when I do it on an iPad.

2:03:40- Yep.

2:03:41- No, I ran into, I was working on iPad Pro.

2:03:45I used it when I traveled a lot

2:03:46and I was working on it the other day

2:03:47and I was trying to get the images off of Apple's newsroom

2:03:50and I couldn't just touch on it

2:03:52because it's got that over effect

2:03:54where it will give you the social sharing stuff.

2:03:57And then I tried to download it and it was a zip file

2:03:59and I could have opened an app to do it

2:04:00but I just realized that using Apple's default tools,

2:04:03I couldn't use Apple's default website.

2:04:05And I pulled out, I just got upset and I pulled out my Mac

2:04:07and I did it in three seconds.

2:04:09and those sort of problems that need to be solved.

2:04:13And as much as people talk about sort of adding

2:04:15parts of iOS to Mac, like touchscreen Macs,

2:04:17it's much more interesting to me

2:04:18to see Apple continue to bring up the iPad

2:04:22and consider things like,

2:04:23we've got basic trackpad support already,

2:04:25but what happens if they make the surface

2:04:27of the smart keyboard capacitive

2:04:29and you can move your fingers over that

2:04:31in lieu of a trackpad, for example,

2:04:33if you don't wanna touch the screen?

2:04:34I think there's a lot of ways they could take that further.

2:04:37Yeah, the precision mousing gets me.

2:04:41I have a long list of things that, if I use an iPad Pro

2:04:45for an extended period of time, eventually

2:04:48make me get itchy to go back to a Mac.

2:04:50And the lack of precision mousing, largely

2:04:53for text editing, is high on the list.

2:04:59So I really hope that this wasn't like Apple's, OK,

2:05:04You guys want some pro features in iOS for iPad here.

2:05:08Okay, now shut up.

2:05:10I really hope it was more of a first step

2:05:12in a multi-year process of doing,

2:05:15making significant strides in that regard.

2:05:17And I still feel like-- - I think it was like--

2:05:21- I also still feel like there are some aspects

2:05:24of that interface that are problematic.

2:05:26I've been suspicious all along of the lack of an indication

2:05:30of where keyboard focus is.

2:05:32You know, let's say you have two apps up, split screen.

2:05:35I kind of, I do like the tidiness of like

2:05:38split screen stuff on iPad,

2:05:40being like it's perfectly 50/50

2:05:43or perfectly two thirds, one third.

2:05:45And you know, and then I look at my Mac

2:05:48and I see this jumble of overlapping windows

2:05:50and there's a tidiness there that I like,

2:05:53but it's like, I cannot believe that in this interface,

2:05:57you have two apps up side by side.

2:05:59You could be typing in either one

2:06:00and you don't know which one you're typing in until you start typing.

2:06:03I find that crazy.

2:06:04We're going to go a waste of step.

2:06:06Yeah, no, absolutely.

2:06:09I think to me this was a second step.

2:06:10We saw iOS 9 take the first step when it introduced the split screen stuff, and they were working

2:06:15on drag and drop for a while and couldn't ship it in iOS 10.

2:06:17They shipped it in iOS 11.

2:06:19And again, they have a certain amount of resources, and they'll focus those on certain features,

2:06:24and maybe we'll get more with iOS 12, or maybe we'll have to wait, and it'll be every two

2:06:27years.

2:06:28We take a big step forward in iPad.

2:06:29But I think it's inevitable that we're going that way.

2:06:31I think there was a sort of a difference of opinion inside Apple as to whether iPad should

2:06:36be left as an incredibly approachable device for mainstream people or whether it should

2:06:41be allowed to be a more powerful machine for pros.

2:06:44And I think there was a second disagreement about whether it was just adopting Mac tropes

2:06:49or whether it was rethinking them.

2:06:50The way like drag and drop on iPad is not just porting over the Mac drag and drop.

2:06:55It was rethought.

2:06:56That's the side that's gaining traction, is that it should be allowed to be a pro,

2:07:00but we're not going to just make it a Mac.

2:07:02We're going to make technology evolve in a way that makes sense to iPad.

2:07:04Dave Asprey Can I tell you, I spent some time over the

2:07:07holidays using an iPad more, specifically for this reason, that I was taking a break

2:07:14from the podcast, doing less work, trying to have a holiday, a real holiday.

2:07:21It was a good device for that.

2:07:22I felt like I wanted to spend more time with it.

2:07:24But I'll tell you what, the drag and drop thing

2:07:26really gets me.

2:07:27Because let's say I want to tap on something in Safari,

2:07:31like a link, and I wanna copy it.

2:07:33And you used to just tap and hold,

2:07:34and you'd get a little pop-up, and then you'd tap Copy.

2:07:37And now you tap and hold, and it jumps up off

2:07:40so you can drag it, and you have to wait longer

2:07:43before I can copy.

2:07:44Whereas on a Mac, I would just Control-click

2:07:50or two-finger click on the link,

2:07:53depending on whether I was using a,

2:07:54and the copy, the menu of options to do on this link

2:08:00would be instantaneous.

2:08:02So the old way on the iPad was a little bit of a wait,

2:08:04which annoyed me from my wanted instantly Mac instincts.

2:08:08And the new way is an even longer wait.

2:08:11And it's one of the tricky things

2:08:13that I think people don't think about

2:08:16when they think in vague yada, yada, yada terms,

2:08:19I'll bet Apple's just gonna unify all this in one OS, right?

2:08:23and you don't think about things like if you just

2:08:28Tap your finger on the screen and move it. What happens does it scroll the view like in a Safari window or does it?

2:08:37select the text

2:08:40right, so when I click in a Safari window, I click and

2:08:44move my finger it selects text instantly no wait no modes just selects how do you

2:08:52do that on a touchscreen so that you could select text instantly or double

2:08:58click to select a word instantly but still allow you to touch instantly to

2:09:02an instantly begin scrolling it can only do one thing and I think it was a good

2:09:07decision a lot of collision it can only do one thing first I just don't think

2:09:11people think about that. And those delays, like waiting to get the copy menu, just to

2:09:15copy a link that's right here that I would have copied a whole second ago, right? I mean,

2:09:21but that second feels like forever.

2:09:23Well, there's like this weird mutation of Fitz's law that I find with pressure sensitivity.

2:09:28And Fitz's law, for people who aren't familiar with it, it's like the easiest way that you

2:09:32can get to an area on a GUI, like the throw distance. And for me, it's like, there's pressure.

2:09:38For Fitz's Law, it's like the harder press.

2:09:40The harder press is the easier one.

2:09:42If I have to stop and do fine manipulations, like that's why I hate floating capacitive

2:09:47screens, because it's just hard to float your finger without touching the screen.

2:09:50But it's easy to jab the screen, and when people aren't certain, I feel like they jab

2:09:53more.

2:09:54And then on an iPhone, you risk, like if you just want to make this stuff jiggle in the

2:09:56old interface, you would have to hold it and not press hard.

2:09:59If you pressed hard, you do 3D touch.

2:10:00That's not what I wanted.

2:10:01You let go, you do it again.

2:10:02Oh God, 3D touch again.

2:10:03And this is the same thing.

2:10:04I just want to copy this.

2:10:05Oh God, it's floating now.

2:10:06I want to I let go I'm floating it again

2:10:09And I just want to copy it and you'd start get frustrated with it

2:10:11And it's not like it's not like it's it's easy to do that fine control for everybody

2:10:16And it just it ends up feeling like this just over like that everything the whole system is overloaded. Yeah, I so I I

2:10:22Really do feel as a high-end, you know, where's Apple going what Apple did last year?

2:10:27I really feel like I I mean it's already too late if they haven't been doing it all along

2:10:31So it doesn't really matter if people that Apple are listening to us

2:10:34Like nothing's gonna happen between now and June if they haven't been working non-stop since last June on what iOS 12 could be on

2:10:41an iPad but boy I sure hope that

2:10:43there's

2:10:46engineers and designers at Apple spending as much time being frustrated by the things that are difficult on an iPad as I am

2:10:54And you know

2:10:56I think conversely I think boy the boy oh boy and one of the reasons that I'd eat as a

2:11:01Somebody who just loves the Mac hopes the Mac has a bright future for a decade or more to come

2:11:06Isn't really looking personally to switch to an iPad Pro

2:11:10But boy, the reason I really want it is boys. Are they nice hardware devices? Yes, really really like, you know for all the complaints

2:11:18We just ran through about pot, you know things people like or don't like or prefer don't prefer about

2:11:23the current MacBook lineup

2:11:27And then downright problems boy. Oh boy is the iPad hardware just amazing the display and and

2:11:34Being the first thing to have true tone and the lightweightness and the new speakers that are promotion

2:11:40Yeah, and promotion and I mean really leading the way in certain hardware

2:11:45regards above and beyond even the iPhone and the Mac

2:11:49You know that it arguably the best product a hardware product Apple ever has ever made

2:11:54It's really remarkable the a series processor in those makes the core M's in I don't know until doesn't call them core M's anymore

2:11:59But that's BS that it makes the core M's cry. Yeah, you can see them wanting to jump off the tables

2:12:04Well, do you you know on that point on that point? Have you seen the battery life that these new Microsoft machines?

2:12:10yeah, Windows machines running ARM processors are getting like that to me is the

2:12:18And hey, where the hell is, you know, something's got to give here.

2:12:22Like for all of the just internally looking at Apple's product speculation, and even if

2:12:27you only look at Apple's products, it sure seems as though Apple ought to be inching

2:12:32closer to releasing MacBooks that have A-series processors.

2:12:39Microsoft released these new surfaces.

2:12:40Or a clamshell iPad.

2:12:41Yeah, or a clamshell iPad, one or both, you know.

2:12:44I don't know.

2:12:47But the new Windows Surface machines running the full version of Windows, not like RT was

2:12:53when they first tried to arm, are getting like 20 hours of battery life.

2:12:57Yeah, yeah, big batteries in there.

2:12:59And people are out in the real world saying, "Yeah, I actually have been using this for

2:13:06three days nonstop and haven't plugged it in once, and I'm still not in the red."

2:13:11Like 20 hours, no joke, battery life.

2:13:14is no there is no Mac that gets that iPads don't get it either. But that's because of

2:13:20how lightweight they are. Apple could easily make an iPad that weighs as much as an iPad

2:13:24from a few years ago that gets 20 hours of battery life. That is battery in the keyboard.

2:13:31I mean, which is what some of them do. Right. You know, iPad, so I would say iPads, right

2:13:37now iPads and iPad pros get that amazing battery life, even if the number is 10 hours instead

2:13:42a 20. That's by design. At this point, given iPads, and now given these arm-based surfaces,

2:13:52there is no MacBook made that you can say gets good battery life. It's only good

2:13:59for Intel, the Intel world. It's no longer state of the art. And I think that's a problem.

2:14:05No, totally agreed.

2:14:09And I think like you said, I don't think the solution is going to come from Intel.

2:14:12I think the solution is that they've got to move to ARM.

2:14:15And if I mean, anecdotally, they've had ARM MacBooks or ARM clamshells running iOS or Mac OS

2:14:24ported to ARM for years, they just haven't pulled the trigger on them.

2:14:27Yeah, I mean, I think everybody after I think after the Intel transition a decade ago, I don't

2:14:34think I don't I don't think anybody is ever going to not believe that there are versions

2:14:41of everything Apple has running on everything Apple has right. Maybe there's not a blogger

2:14:46or podcaster can conjecture about it. Apple has the resources and money certainly to prototype

2:14:52and certainly clamshell iOS device. I can't believe they don't have it. Certainly Mac

2:14:57Mac OS compiling on arm 64. I can't believe that they don't

2:15:03have I'd be I'd be flabbergasted. The only thing I

2:15:06think that was actually public. There was a intern who did it and

2:15:09then he published the paper on porting at least a part of Mac OS

2:15:13to to the arm stack. The only thing I would question is I don't

2:15:18know, do they secretly have a version of iOS running on x 86?

2:15:23I don't think I don't know that they'd even waste time with it

2:15:25because I'm not sure that there's any, is there any scenario where they could see that being a

2:15:30thing? I don't think. Yeah, that would be seeding, that'd be going backwards almost from Apple's

2:15:37traditional desire to control their stack. I wonder though, I remember when I was at

2:15:42Barebone Software, and I forget which compiler was which, but they, it was like during, you know,

2:15:50earlier 2000, 2002. And I think BBEdit was still being compiled with CodeWarrior, but

2:16:01they got it running, compiling cleanly on GCC and Xcode too. One, thinking it was the

2:16:08right thing to do for the future. I could be getting this backwards, but there were

2:16:11at least two. It was a time when there were multiple compilers that professional Mac users

2:16:15could choose from. And bare bones had always kept BB edit running cleanly on both because

2:16:20it was just good practice for your source code. You know, that you don't want to get

2:16:24trapped into something like that, you know, and I think, you know, that was what the next

2:16:28crew did coming over, you know, where next was this portable operating system that ran

2:16:32on originally ran on the Motorola 68, oh, 40. And then they got it running on sun's

2:16:38spark or whatever the hell it was. And then they ported it to x 86. And they had this

2:16:43same source thing that could compile across all this. And then when they needed to port

2:16:46it to PowerPC, when Apple bought Next, it was that, you know, at least going through

2:16:51the source code and getting it to compile was an issue. So maybe they have iOS compiling

2:16:55on Intel just for that, but I doubt it.

2:16:58Maybe they have Apple x86, so there's AMD x86.

2:17:01Yeah, yeah.

2:17:02They've experimented with that.

2:17:03Ooh, that would be neat. What else? Year in review. I feel like we've talked so much

2:17:09much about iPhone in the last few months that it's just a rehash of recent episodes, but

2:17:13I think that the iPhone is in a great place. I think iPhone X is a rousing success in every

2:17:21regard, hardware and software. I couldn't be happier with it, and I really think it's

2:17:29to me it's the best proof that Apple still has it, whatever it is, even if it's not there

2:17:33across the board in every product.

2:17:35Yeah, absolutely. I mean, it's just phenomenal hardware, really, really great software and

2:17:41services integration. And it's absolutely not perfect, but it's one of those things

2:17:45that it makes me feel like the future of phones. It's like when you saw that original iPhone,

2:17:50or you saw the iPhone 4, you go, "Oh yeah, I know what the next few years of iPhone are

2:17:54going to be." And this gives me this feeling like, yes, it's the first version of Face

2:17:59ID and the first version of OLED and all these things, but I'm excited because this is a

2:18:03whole new generation of iPhone again. And they absolutely nailed that from just the

2:18:07point of view of making that next generation product.

2:18:09Right. I feel like, you know, it's, you know, the oldest story in the world that Apple's

2:18:15key is that they do the hardware and the software. But I think it's interesting that, to me,

2:18:21the most important hardware on the Mac side is the MacBooks. Like you said, that's about

2:18:24that's what some people, that's the only thing they consider. Yeah. And so as cool as the

2:18:29iMac Pro is and it's really cool that they've made a really awesome Pro computer that's

2:18:34a desktop. I think it's a real problem that the hardware, the keyboard, and maybe some

2:18:39other things, or maybe just the fact like you said that there's not a wide enough lineup,

2:18:43that there isn't a "hey, here's more ports and a thicker one for pros of a certain need."

2:18:52So you've got the hardware problems on the MacBook. You've got the OS, which is just

2:18:58isn't truly thought through for productivity for the iPad. So you've got fantastic hardware,

2:19:06near-perfect hardware for what they're trying to do with software that still conceptually

2:19:10falls short. Then you've got the iPhone, which I think is really the epitome of Apple,

2:19:16where they've got super great hardware and a really good OS.

2:19:21Yeah, absolutely. iPad Pro, I mean, I think that was a good way to end the year. And like

2:19:28you said, it's obviously it's, you know, desktops are for a niche and the iPad Pro is for a

2:19:32niche within the niche. But boy is it, you know, Apple said, you know, it was interesting

2:19:37earlier in the year when they had a couple of us out there to say, look, Mac Pro, we're,

2:19:43we've got something, it'll be a while, we're gonna have an iMac Pro. We love the pro market,

2:19:48We hear you.

2:19:49We are the pro market here within the company.

2:19:51And it was great to hear that,

2:19:54but the proof is in the pudding.

2:19:57What's that saying?

2:19:58- Well, you need it.

2:19:59It's sort of like,

2:20:00some companies just have to make a hypercar.

2:20:01You have to have that Lamborghini, that Ferrari,

2:20:03that Veyron, that Bugatti on the top

2:20:07because it's aspirational.

2:20:08And the iMac Pro, it's not gonna have the market

2:20:11that the MacBooks have, but it doesn't need to.

2:20:13It just needs to be sitting there

2:20:14showing that Apple can make amazing hardware

2:20:16and making people interested in Mac.

2:20:18Maybe you won't go and buy that,

2:20:19but you're like Apple makes kick-ass computers.

2:20:22And if you don't think that, you start looking elsewhere.

2:20:24So it's important for the overall halo

2:20:26to have those machines.

2:20:27- There's a new Acura commercial I've seen

2:20:28over and over and over again during football games

2:20:30last few weeks that literally does that.

2:20:33It just starts with an NSX roaring

2:20:36around a racetrack corner.

2:20:38And they're talking about the technology

2:20:39that they've put into it.

2:20:40And then it turns into a Honda Accord

2:20:44or something like that, and then to a Honda Civic.

2:20:45I forget if they're all Acuras or if it's a mix, but somehow making the argument that

2:20:51the consumer family $23,000 or whatever in accord costs these days, I have no idea. A

2:21:01very typical top-selling family car benefits from the technology and advances that the

2:21:07NSX super race car has, even if there's no way in hell that a family of four is ever

2:21:15going to buy an Acura NSX.

2:21:18Yeah, totally.

2:21:19But you get the advantage of lower yields and higher price points, so you can experiment

2:21:23more and you can rush.

2:21:24You can shake out that technology and then it does filter down.

2:21:26Yeah, and I think that the excitement with the iPad or iMac Pro, you can tell I'm getting

2:21:31punchy from the length of the show that I'm mispronouncing.

2:21:33Sure.

2:21:34I'm using the wrong name for more things.

2:21:36The excitement of and the frustration before the iMac Pro actually shipped is not just

2:21:42that there are people like us who want that sort of race car computer from Apple and who

2:21:50used to buy them and still need them and want them.

2:21:53It's the knowledge that Apple's current state, their financial wherewithal, their custom

2:22:02chip making wherewithal is that if they set their minds to it, they could do a better

2:22:07job than ever before. Right? That's the first. It's not just that you want Apple to make

2:22:11a pro computer. It's that you know that if they really wanted to, they could do something

2:22:15that would be mind blowing like the iMac Pro, which has all of this performance and really,

2:22:22really struggles to work itself into enough of a lather to have the fans come on unless

2:22:28you open dragthingsaboutbox.com. I'm pretty sure dragthingsaboutbox is not a CPU or GPU

2:22:43stressor. I don't even think it's ready.

2:22:45No, I don't think he's put a YARK kit into that yet.

2:22:47No, but dragthing will do it. Anyway, that's my summary of the year. Anything else before

2:22:53we knock this off?

2:22:54No, I think that's spot on and I think it's gonna be interesting to see you know again people apples riches company world

2:23:01But they don't have infinite resources

2:23:02There's a limit to the amount of people who are willing to work in Cupertino for the amount of money that Apple pays

2:23:07Rather than the allure of startups and they can't focus those people on multiple products every product

2:23:12They focus on is a product that they can't focus on at the same time

2:23:15And that's why I think we get you know, if it's not our favorite product that's getting the attention we get super frustrated

2:23:19So it took them a lot to get the iMac Pro out and it meant we couldn't get a Mac Mini and we couldn't get

2:23:24a Mac Pro. But hopefully as those machines come out, you know…

2:23:28They can increase headcount and they have increased headcount, but it is…

2:23:31Yes. And money alone… and money alone can make

2:23:35salaries go higher, but money alone can't increase the number of A talent designers,

2:23:41engineers, people there are in the world, right? Like the Apple… one of the biggest

2:23:45constraints on Apple, it's always been, and it's a constraint on every company,

2:23:49But talent is an enormous constraint because there's only so much of it in the world.

2:23:55And Apple can't do what we want Apple to do without A-level talent.

2:24:01And I think some of the—

2:24:02And you have these problems because you can't—not everyone who's an A-level talent wants to

2:24:05work in Cupertino or at Apple.

2:24:07And also, once you scale it, you get a whole bunch of other—I think the biggest problem-facing

2:24:12Apple—and I wrote about this at the end of the year—is scaling.

2:24:14That it's hard to take a company that was built the way Apple was built with small teams

2:24:18that focus on solving specific problems and scale them across now four platforms and

2:24:23Podclines that include Mac and iPad and iPhone and Apple watch and air pods and everything else that Apple is doing

2:24:29And just adding people to that doesn't fix it in some ways. It makes it worse, you know one thing I've heard

2:24:35Is you know to go circle back an hour to there to why is

2:24:41Airplay too late. Yes that maybe it wasn't exactly the a team

2:24:46of that was working on AirPlay 2 and that's not because

2:24:50Apple wouldn't want to put the a team on AirPlay 2 but that

2:24:54if the entire a team is already working on

2:24:58Projects that are deemed essential there's you know, if the best you've got or that is the B team to put on AirPlay 2

2:25:05That's that's that's who gets it, you know, yeah

2:25:08Yeah, and you can't put the a team on everything again. Like you put them on iPhone if they're on iPhone

2:25:13that can't be working on iMac. It's one of those things.

2:25:19My thanks to our sponsors this week. Squarespace, well, let's do them in order. Let's keep them

2:25:27in order here. We've got Casper. You can buy an internet or buy a mattress on the internet.

2:25:35We've got Away. You can buy a suitcase on the internet. Now we've got Squarespace where

2:25:40can buy an internet on the internet. René, thank you. Everybody can follow René on Twitter

2:25:47at @RenéRichie. You can see his fine work at iMore.com on a daily basis. And for your

2:25:55listening pleasure, his rejuvenated vector where I've been a guest. I was a guest a few

2:26:01weeks ago with René Richie. So if you missed it, if you like listening to me and René

2:26:05talk, you can go look up the episode of Vector where we were joined by mutual friend Daniel

2:26:10Jalka. And where do you go? What's the best place to go to get information on the podcast?

2:26:16For the podcast, just vector.show. And for the column that goes with it, iamware.com/vector.

2:26:21Vector.show. That's a pretty good domain name. I love these fancy new domain names. Very

2:26:26cool. Very memorable. Anyway, go check out vector.show. I think people are going to like

2:26:30it. Renee is doing it on a daily basis, a weekday basis?

2:26:34Yeah, I do it like five days a week and I'm probably insane, but I'm trying to make it

2:26:39I think it's interesting. I thought it was nuts when I heard it, but it's not you know like this

2:26:43It's not two and a half hours. No at five days a week. It is a little bit more like it's tighter

2:26:50It's you know in a way that you know

2:26:53There have long been radio and TV shows that are five days a week and they're shorter and more focused

2:26:58And I think that's kind of a more super short. I think audio version of my column for accessibility

2:27:04Yeah

2:27:04So I think that's a really interesting thing to do with the podcast form and I think that a lot of the podcasts

2:27:11I listen to are in the form of my show or like an ATP

2:27:14whether once a week or once a week ish like mine, but long and

2:27:19I think filling the gaps in your what's up next and

2:27:23overcast with

2:27:2510 or 15 minute many things is a really really interesting way to play with the form. So I'm enjoying it. Oh

2:27:33Thank you very much. I do feel I feel almost feel like for as long as we've been doing podcasts

2:27:39There's been less play with the forum than we did with the early days of the web, you know

2:27:45Absolutely. So anyway, my thanks to you René. See you next year. Thank you

2:27:49absolutely