0:00:00All right, I'm just gonna say this, right? I want I want everybody listening to know you do not have to hit pause. You don't have to skip.
0:00:05Gonna talk a little bit about the last Jedi right here, but it will be the most spoiler free discussion you could possibly imagine. I totally understand that the movie just came out, and that many or most of you listening to this probably haven't seen it yet.
0:00:18But I do want to talk about it briefly and then most completely spoiler free way possible.
0:00:23But you don't have to skip I promise you, you have my word.
0:00:29Matthew, you had a very exciting story of seeing the movie, right?
0:00:32Oh, yeah. Yeah. I ended up seeing the movie on the Disney Studios lot on Monday, because they had
0:00:46did a couple of press showings. I didn't go to the premiere, which was on, I think, Friday or
0:00:52something, the red carpet. But I did get to see it on the lot, which was fun. I mean, there are
0:00:57theaters obviously top-notch, you know, salmon and visual quality,
0:01:01all of that stuff. Um, but getting, getting to see it on the lot was,
0:01:06was a lot of fun.
0:01:06That's a pretty cool story. I saw it last night and the first showing in a
0:01:10regular centerplex here, um, liked it a lot.
0:01:14Yeah. I saw it last night for the second time too. Uh, I went into it and this is
0:01:19why I am sensitive to the spoilers.
0:01:21I went into it knowing less about this movie than any star Wars movie.
0:01:26movie I'd ever seen in my life. And I've always tried to remain spoiler free. But for some
0:01:30reason, my media blackout strategy was more successful this time than any previous movie.
0:01:39I had seen the poster. But I did not look because it was like unavoidable to not see
0:01:45the poster, but I never looked closely at the poster. Didn't see a single
0:01:50You just looked at it in the corner of your eye.
0:01:52Yeah.
0:01:52But I won't even describe any aspects of the poster.
0:01:57This is how sensitive to spoilers I am.
0:01:59And anybody who has the media blackout strategy that I do for this,
0:02:03that I won't even describe any visual elements of the poster,
0:02:06just in case somebody more successful than me has not even seen the poster.
0:02:10That's how sensitive to the spoilers I am.
0:02:13And then the last--
0:02:15the biggest break, the biggest crack in the dam of my media strike blackout
0:02:20strategy was I was in New York Tuesday night for the Wednesday morning briefing for the
0:02:26iMac Pro that we're about to talk about. And I had dinner with a dear friend of the show,
0:02:32Renee Ritchie. And coincidentally, while we're at dinner, you texted me, "Hey, are you in
0:02:38town?" A little slightly too late to throw you into the mix for dinner. But I got in
0:02:43a cab to go back to my hotel after dinner and this stupid little TV in the back of the
0:02:49to the cab starts it's the way it like you your cap it doesn't kick in until
0:02:55you're like 30 seconds into the cab right car and it cuts into a commercial
0:02:59for the last Jedi and I had to look at it so that I could figure out where to
0:03:04jab my finger to shut it off and I saw you button there the off yeah yeah I saw
0:03:09one shot from the movie that I again I won't describe it at all but I saw a
0:03:17a shot from the movie that I would consider a very, very, very mild spoiler. But still
0:03:23was more of a spoiler than I'd gotten. And I can't believe that it gets you thinking
0:03:27then. And then your brain's like, what does that mean? Does that mean this? It was a shot.
0:03:34It was like a two shots. It was like two shots of a scene that put two characters in a certain
0:03:38situation and it made me think, how did they get in that situation? And the most amazing
0:03:47part about the success of my blackout strategy was that we were even at Disney World for a day over
0:03:57Thanksgiving. We were down in Florida and spent a day at the Magic Kingdom and I thought this is
0:04:01gonna be this is this is where it all breaks down. So the Disney's gonna put something up here that
0:04:06you know breaks it but I didn't I didn't see anything I didn't see any toys I didn't see I
0:04:11I didn't see anything that ruined it. So I was super successful. Anyway, I,
0:04:16anybody, last thing I want to say about it, I thought it was good. Um,
0:04:20I think I enjoyed it more than, um, uh,
0:04:26the force awakens, which I also enjoyed. Uh,
0:04:29but I do want,
0:04:31I do want everybody who's a star Wars fan who listens to the show,
0:04:34you gotta go see it soon. You cannot wait.
0:04:35Cause I do want to have a star Wars, uh,
0:04:39spectacular episode of the talk show probably, you know, tradition would, would put it around
0:04:44new years. So before the end of the year, you got to see this movie or else you're gonna
0:04:48have to skip the star Wars spectacular episode of the show.
0:04:50Yeah. I mean, I've got, I've got so many things to say about it. I mean, I've been talking,
0:04:56I have a private chat group that I've been talking with about this and we've been going
0:05:01back and forth with about it since, since everybody saw it. We sort of like created
0:05:06a branch of our normal chat group to talk about Star Wars so that people who hadn't
0:05:12seen it didn't have to get spoiled.
0:05:15And the branch has been going nuts.
0:05:17We've been kind of going back and forth.
0:05:19Because I guess we should just stop it there.
0:05:22But all over Twitter this morning people are reacting to the movie, obviously, but there's
0:05:27a sort of meta reaction to the reactions.
0:05:30Because I guess it's rated very well by the critics, but the audiences aren't liking it
0:05:35so much, you know, like the rating wise. But I think that's, that's about as far as we
0:05:39need to go with that. But I, I found it interesting, you know, that the audiences were like, you
0:05:44know, had some feelings about it that weren't as positive as the critics did. But I think
0:05:49that that, in my opinion, obviously it's, it's a, it's a good movie and definitely worth
0:05:54seeing that's as far as I'll go with it.
0:05:56Yeah. And then, you know, I'll just mention it, but that the remarkable tie in to this
0:06:02podcast is that the writer and director of the movie is Ryan Johnson, who was on my show to talk
0:06:09about his previous movie looper three or four years ago, with coordinated with friend of the
0:06:14show, Adam, lonely sandwich, Lisa gore, which was amazing. And it's funny, and I know I get emails
0:06:23about this. And I have to fix it, I will fix it, I have those episodes. That episode was in the era
0:06:28when I was on the mule network. And the idiots at mule, they're good friends. But I think
0:06:34it was I think it's stupid to let the website lapse but their website went away. So right
0:06:38now like the canonical archive for that show is like a 404. And I have the files, I just
0:06:45need to integrate it back into the thing I hosted during fireball right now. But anybody
0:06:49who does want to listen to it, you actually can if you just go to the internet archive
0:06:54and look up the old talk show on the mule mule radio. I'll put a link in the show notes
0:07:03I swear with a link to that episode in the internet archive so you can listen to it,
0:07:08which was it's just an amazing thrill to me that I've actually met because we actually
0:07:13recorded that episode in sandwich videos office in L.A. So it was actually face to face, you
0:07:18know, which I think makes for a better episode. But anyway, it's still thrilling to me that
0:07:23I actually did an episode of the show with the writer and director of the movie. Pretty
0:07:29cool. He's doing a cool thing on Twitter too, Rian Johnson, where his, you know, it's obviously
0:07:34the biggest movie he's ever directed. And it's the opening weekend. And he's using his
0:07:39Twitter account to like, link to a couple of other movies that are opening this weekend
0:07:45and telling people to go see him. So it's just a really cool thing. Again, I can't say
0:07:50that he's my friend. He's a guy who I met for three hours in LA one afternoon, but everything
0:07:55I know from reading interviews with him and from the time I did spend with him, he, he
0:07:59honest and, and Adam, Lisa Gordon knows him better than I do. He really is a, by all accounts,
0:08:07a genuine, you know, the type of person who would just do that, like want to, you know,
0:08:12help somebody whose movie might get lost in last Jedi hoopla weekend, which is pretty
0:08:18cool. So anyway, I was in New York. You were in New York. There was a briefing. How many
0:08:27people in the press were there? About a dozen? Yeah, I mean, it's hard to tell because there
0:08:33were several groups that went through, but it seemed to be about that. Yeah, maybe a
0:08:36dozen, maybe 20 members of the press. And it was pretty, I thought it was well done.
0:08:44I thought it was a really good roll out and I also liked the way that like this was Wednesday
0:08:50of this week and then on Tuesday the day before was it Tuesday or was it Monday when a bunch
0:08:56of reviews came out? I forget but it was a day or two before.
0:09:01Yeah Monday I think.
0:09:03Okay so then Monday a bunch of reviews of the new Mac Pro came out and I thought it
0:09:11It was a really interesting selection of people who got seated.
0:09:15They all got it for about a week.
0:09:17Um, among them, uh, Craig Hunter, who I linked to it during fireball,
0:09:23he's a aerospace engineer and iOS developer.
0:09:26So that ticks, uh, sort of kills two birds with one stone,
0:09:31like where he can test it from two different perspectives. Uh, right.
0:09:34Uh, Marquez Brownlee, better known as MKBHD, uh, uh,
0:09:39very well known, very successful YouTube, I guess, YouTuber, and who has been clamoring for better
0:09:48high-end professional Mac hardware because he shoots his videos with an 8K red camera
0:09:56and has been editing on a 2013 Mac Pro, which at the time was such a gorgeous, wow, this is an
0:10:04an impressive machine and it in late 2017 as 2017 comes to a close it makes you laugh
0:10:11thinking about editing 8k video in it on it right who else got it oh cable Sasser from
0:10:17panic was given one trying to think who else but some developers some video people I forget
0:10:26but it was you know and I thought it was a really good rollout and I thought an interesting
0:10:32in my opinion, to the iPhone 10 rollout where that initial batch of here's the first people who've gotten to see iPhone 10 were like these
0:10:40Fashion YouTube type people. Mm-hmm. Yeah, it was it was like a
0:10:48Obviously a an iteration on that thing that they did with the iPhone 10 of saying hey
0:10:55Here's some people with internet audiences who may not read mainstream publications or even
0:11:01tech industry publications or whatever,
0:11:04that we want to sort of give an early look at
0:11:08so that they can talk to those people in their own voice
0:11:12and the people that watch them like TV or whatever
0:11:16instead of regular TV will get that look.
0:11:19So it was less I think about,
0:11:23and it may have been somewhat,
0:11:25about seeding the early buzz with relatively low levels
0:11:30relatively lightweight positive hands-ons,
0:11:33you know, because they weren't reviews.
0:11:35- Right.
0:11:36- They were like, hey, look at this thing, right?
0:11:36And then there was a couple of them
0:11:38that actually got to like use the phone
0:11:40and live with it for a few days.
0:11:42- But not in that first batch.
0:11:43- Still though, very much impressions.
0:11:45- But in that first batch, it was really,
0:11:47and it wasn't even clear, like part of it,
0:11:50it wasn't even clear to me and I pay close attention to it,
0:11:52but in that first batch, they were in New York
0:11:55in the same building where Apple's been holding
0:11:58all these briefings recently.
0:11:59I don't even know how you would describe it.
0:12:02It's like a big, I wanna say townhouse,
0:12:04but it's so much bigger and wider than a typical townhouse.
0:12:07It's, you know, just a big penthouse, three stories.
0:12:11- Yeah, I mean, I could be wrong,
0:12:13but I think that there were some people
0:12:14outside of that group, though.
0:12:15There was, I know what you mean.
0:12:17There was a set of people that they got together
0:12:19and they brought into that room,
0:12:21and you could tell because you looked at the YouTube videos
0:12:23and they're all the same, right?
0:12:24They're all the same surroundings and everything,
0:12:26and they brought them in there and had them play with it,
0:12:29and then they cut together what we would call in the business
0:12:32like a social cut, right?
0:12:33Like a cut of video that is primed for social
0:12:37or for YouTube or whatever the case may be.
0:12:39And some of them cut them differently than others, right?
0:12:43There were some folks who actually I thought
0:12:44did good commentary, like they were sitting there
0:12:47talking to the camera, giving commentary,
0:12:48and then they would cut to them like handling the phone
0:12:51in that room, you know?
0:12:52But you could tell that they didn't have it, right?
0:12:55They weren't like, "Hey, you know, I've had this,"
0:12:57and blah, blah, blah.
0:12:59But I think there was some other influencers,
0:13:00and I can't remember off the top of my head right now,
0:13:04but it's, that had it, that actually they gave it to,
0:13:08but maybe I'm wrong.
0:13:10But I, for the, by and large,
0:13:12the first batch of stuff that we got was that.
0:13:15It was those people that they brought into this room
0:13:18to like handle it for an hour or two,
0:13:20and then they went and cut together a video from it, yeah.
0:13:23- Right, and you know, I had some public snark
0:13:27about that strategy.
0:13:28for the iPhone 10. And then a couple of people, like when MKBHD's video dropped this week
0:13:35for the iMac Pro, I got a couple of tweets like, "Ah, YouTubers again, how come?" And
0:13:42I was like, "No, no, no, you guys are nuts." MKBHD might have been, if they had, Apple
0:13:46had asked me, "Name one person who should get the iMac Pro a week in advance for the
0:13:51first review." He might have been on my short list of people who I would have suggested
0:13:55because what he would do would be exactly what needs to be done, which is truly stress
0:14:00test the performance of it.
0:14:03You know, and it's literally what he does all day, you know, so it's I really like the
0:14:10the philosophy of it's not necessarily like, hey, who's a good reviewer of hardware? Because
0:14:15that's fine. You know, that's definitely one way to look at it. But it's, hey, who would
0:14:20would actually use this hardware in the pursuit
0:14:23of what they're doing, of whatever profession
0:14:26that they're in.
0:14:27And in the case of YouTubers shooting high-res video
0:14:32and needing to turn it around quickly
0:14:35with a lot of visual tricks and cutting
0:14:38and all of that stuff, it definitely fits the bill.
0:14:42And that's why I think it's like a nice iteration
0:14:44of what the iPhone X stuff, 'cause iPhone X,
0:14:47whether you like it or not,
0:14:48whoever's viewing those videos is definitely a different audience than the typical audience
0:14:54you would get in either print or web publications, and that's fine.
0:14:58But I think that in this case, the pre-seed, or whatever you want to call it, the people
0:15:03that were given the Mac Pros, iMac Pros, excuse me, early, were definitely people that would
0:15:10use them in day-to-day scenarios, and it was a nice spread across from software developers
0:15:18to, they had some people in there doing medical stuff, they had people doing audio professional
0:15:27work, right?
0:15:28Right.
0:15:29Logic Pro, amazing experts like high-end producers and stuff of Logic that use Logic Pro, and
0:15:34they had people obviously doing video and that sort of thing.
0:15:36So it was a nice wide gamut of people.
0:15:39And they did not necessarily just cede it to people who just love Apple.
0:15:44Right.
0:15:45Right.
0:15:46Like, "Oh, well, okay.
0:15:47gush about Apple all the time.
0:15:48They ceded it to people who I felt expressed publicly many times, like, you know, frustration
0:15:54or, or, you know, criticism or whatever, not unwarranted and but also not, not necessarily
0:16:01reactionary, right?
0:16:03Or, or unresearched or whatever they actually look, these people are critics because they
0:16:08care.
0:16:09We're going to give them this thing that we think will solve or, or address some of those
0:16:13criticisms about Apple and pro users over the last x days or months or years and we'll
0:16:18see what they think. So I thought that they did a good job of balancing that out. It wasn't
0:16:21just like, let's give Apple friends this thing and so they could say it's great, you know?
0:16:25Yeah, I thought that was good. I thought Craig hunters was a good example of that where he
0:16:29was saying like, here's, you know, he was running like an aerospace simulation of like,
0:16:33here's a wing from a certain airplane. And let's run these tests to get the aerodynamic
0:16:39properties of this wing which as you know, even a layperson can understand yeah, probably pretty CPU intensive
0:16:45Right or GPU. I don't even know but you know one or the other it's computationally
0:16:50Difficult and is like here's a bunch of machines
0:16:55I've run the same test on over the last few years and it you know included some Macs like like I think
0:17:01Mac Pro maybe a MacBook Pro but a lot of the other tests that he'd been running in recent years were on Linux servers
0:17:08You know which again shows you that it's not just from a somebody who's only using Apple hardware and only coming from that
0:17:14You know, whatever it is. It's going to be a Mac perspective
0:17:17You know somebody who's who's as
0:17:20Just looking for the fastest compute possible and therefore is you know more than happy to be, you know, just run it on a Linux server
0:17:27Yeah, and there's I think there is a
0:17:35position on the behalf and I tweeted about this a little bit yesterday because I basically what I said was
0:17:40You know that my the time
0:17:42Writing about it was that
0:17:45iMac Pro is a love letter to developers and I think people took that to mean
0:17:49That Apple had solved all the developers problems and this is the perfect computer for all developers and that you know some sort of like
0:17:56You know, hey geography of their
0:17:58Efforts to build this computer, right and you know, if if you read the article
0:18:04it's not that, but it also, the way that I was going with that is that not necessarily that I meant that this computer was the best computer for all developers, which is definitely how some developers took it and took exception to it, which is fine. You know, you gotta gotta be willing to take the heat if you're gonna jump in the fire. But the way that I meant it, which felt came through if you actually read the piece, is that it was their effort to, to write that letter, and to send it.
0:18:33And now whether you're not, you're in love, or whether or not you believe them, or whether
0:18:38or not it is right for you is a whole different matter.
0:18:41But I do believe it showed a distinct effort by them to address a market that wants an
0:18:46integrated machine, and a machine with an incredibly great screen and high res and all
0:18:52of that stuff, and a lot of power to do whatever they want, but doesn't necessarily need the
0:18:57modularity and buys a new computer every probably four to five years anyway.
0:19:02And this thing should scale for that period of time.
0:19:05And I think that Apple sees that.
0:19:07They see in market terms what you would call a product that goes under another product's
0:19:15umbrella.
0:19:16Right?
0:19:17So they have the umbrella of, let's say, the Mac Pro.
0:19:21You have this high-end umbrella where people need modularity or whatever.
0:19:25And then down below that, you have things like MacBooks and things like that, which
0:19:29which people use professionally,
0:19:30but don't necessarily obviously have the graphics power,
0:19:33specifically, for instance, of something like the Mac Pro.
0:19:37And they figured that there's this bolus of people
0:19:40that were taking iMacs and configuring them
0:19:43to try and fit them into that gap.
0:19:46They were using iMacs in professional settings
0:19:49and configuring them the best that they could
0:19:50to get them into that area.
0:19:52And they're like, "Hey, we can just fill this in
0:19:55and capture that portion of the market."
0:19:58So I think from a market perspective, that's the strategy,
0:20:01and that offering is to those people.
0:20:05And then I think that the people that take exception
0:20:07to that offering or find that it's lacking in some way,
0:20:10which is 100% valid, they are more than welcome
0:20:14to feel that way, and those feelings are valid,
0:20:16and I'm not trying to shoot anybody down
0:20:17that says this isn't the computer for them,
0:20:18and be like, no, it's the computer for everybody,
0:20:20'cause it's not.
0:20:21But it definitely fits a market that they aren't seeing,
0:20:25but that Apple is seeing, you know?
0:20:27And I think that they're out there.
0:20:29And I ran a little poll and my poll pointed out, my poll, which is obviously biased and
0:20:36limited by my followers and blah, blah, blah, right?
0:20:39This is not scientific.
0:20:41But the poll, which you obviously did go out to a lot of people who follow me because I
0:20:45cover Apple, so you got that going for you in this case.
0:20:50It basically came out to a lot of people are going to buy this computer and they're software
0:20:54developers and they like it.
0:20:56And then there was a smaller but very sizable chunk,
0:21:00like half or quarter of that in response,
0:21:04that said, "No, I'm gonna wait for the Mac Pro."
0:21:06And I think that's exactly what Apple sees.
0:21:08I honestly think that ratio is exactly what they see.
0:21:11They see a big chunk of people that will buy this computer,
0:21:13and they see a smaller chunk of people
0:21:14that are gonna wait for the Mac Pro,
0:21:16and that's why they're building it.
0:21:17All right, it's a longer, longish thing,
0:21:19but damn, that's what I think.
0:21:20- And it's some good points to take off from there.
0:21:23But in the meantime, let's take our first break
0:21:25like our first sponsor. It's our good friends at Away. I love this company. I love their products.
0:21:32Away bags and accessories make the perfect gift for the holidays. You still have time to get one.
0:21:40Listen to the show right now. Go jump on their website and you can definitely still get an Away
0:21:48travel bag for someone in your family or ask for it yourself if somebody's looking to because to
0:21:53to me, that's always the problem is people in the family will say, Hey, john, what do
0:21:57you want for Christmas? And it's, it's always hard for me, because I, as soon as I think
0:22:03that I want something, I tend to just go and buy it for myself. So there's really little
0:22:07left in the world. But if you're in the market for a new suitcase, and somebody's looking
0:22:10to get you a gift, this is a great idea. And I'll tell you why I've said this before, too.
0:22:15I suffered for years, I mean, years until I got the suitcase from away and realize what
0:22:21an idiot I was that I'd been using the same carry-on bag since like, God, I don't even
0:22:27know when. It might have even been like in the late 1990s or something like that. The
0:22:31wheels barely rolled. It was more like I drug it through airports. Most of the pockets were
0:22:38ripped. It was frayed. I looked like some kind of traveling hobo or something. Getting
0:22:44a new suitcase, boy, does it make going to the airport easier.
0:22:48So away bags and accessories make a perfect gift. They have a lifetime guarantee. They
0:22:52have a hundred day trial and there's a perfect size and color for everyone on your list this
0:22:57holiday season. Or you can grab an away gift card if you can't make up your mind or you
0:23:02don't know you don't want to pick a color for somebody else or something like that because
0:23:05they really do have a wide variety of colors. Away uses high quality materials and they
0:23:10offer a much lower price for a comparable high quality brand because they cut out the
0:23:16middleman and they sell direct to you. They make it, they ship it right to you and there's
0:23:22no retail markup. They've got over 10 colors and five sizes. The carry-on, the bigger carry-on,
0:23:28the medium, the large, and the kids carry-on for smaller travelers. And they're exactly
0:23:33what you think. The carry-on and the bigger carry-on. The bigger carry-on is like the
0:23:37maximum carry-on you could possibly fit in an overhead on an airplane. But one of those
0:23:44carry-ons that doesn't fit on the overhead on like a medium-sized airplane. Medium, large,
0:23:50exactly what you think they are. All of their suitcases are made with premium German polycarbonate
0:23:54that's very lightweight, never bends, never breaks. I've had mine, I think for two years,
0:24:00maybe a little longer, something like that. Still looks brand new. I thought I had a scuff
0:24:04on it the last time I looked at it and I just like rubbed it with my thumb and it came right
0:24:09off. I don't know what it was. Really, really great. The interior features a patent-pending
0:24:13compression system helpful for over packers. They've got just the right number of compartments
0:24:17inside. You don't have to like read instructions to figure out what's what, but there's like
0:24:20an area for your shirts and then you put a thing on top of it, hold it shut and then
0:24:25your shirts won't get wrinkled. Nothing else will touch them. They have a little bag in
0:24:29there that you can put your dirty clothes in to keep them separate from the clean clothes
0:24:33for 360 degree spinner wheels, a TSA approved combination lock and, and here's the kicker
0:24:42the carry-ons that carry on in the larger carry-ons have a built-in charger with two
0:24:49USB ports. So you're at any seat at the airport while you're waiting for your flight, you've
0:24:54got a charger right there available to you with your suitcase right by you. So you don't
0:24:58have to hunt around the airport for like the two seats that have like a USB socket or a
0:25:03wall socket nearby. I cannot tell you how convenient that is. Really, really great.
0:25:09I just love that feature. And again, there's 100 day free trial and they have free shipping
0:25:14on any away order within the contiguous 48 US 48 states. So there you go. It's a great
0:25:22product. I really love it. You can get $20 off a suitcase if you visit away, travel.com/talk
0:25:28show and use that promo talk show during checkout. So not only is it a great product, not only
0:25:34right now, today is it literally still in time for the holidays, but you'll save 20
0:25:38If you use that promo code talk show and go to away travel comm slash talk show my thanks to away
0:25:49Really like that product anyway
0:25:51I'm a pro love letter to developers and then
0:25:56The developers who pipe up and say well, it's not for me
0:25:59Yeah, I feel like I'm not in love. Okay, I feel like
0:26:07It's an interesting contrast to Apple's
0:26:10current laptop market
0:26:13Which is there is no way to make one computer that makes everybody happy
0:26:18Because if somebody would somebody really wants and I don't know what specific complaints you heard from people who don't
0:26:25Want a pro machine from hardware?
0:26:28Aren't complaining about the price per se realized that that the pricing of the iMac Pro is in line with what it's actually offering
0:26:36But simply don't like it. The thing I've heard already is and and it shouldn't be a surprise
0:26:42I don't even think this was news this week
0:26:44but I think now that it officially shipped they're willing to bark about it is the lack of internal expandability and
0:26:51You you can't even upgrade the RAM
0:26:54As a user there's no little screw panel that you can unscrew and add more RAM or change the RAM
0:27:01Although you can if you buy one that's not like max out on RAM
0:27:05You can take it to us like a service center or an Apple store and get it upgraded, you know
0:27:11as like a
0:27:13official service thing with Apple so it's not like you
0:27:15Literally, it's not like that RAM is soldered onto the motherboard like it is on some laptops
0:27:21But it's just not user accessible
0:27:24that's the complaint I've heard about but
0:27:28It's like that's that's the iMac. You know what I mean? It's it's
0:27:32There's no way to have everything and so the difference I see it's like it's like blaming a platypus for having a bill
0:27:38You know, yeah bills and and I realized that the new Mac Pro is not yet shipping and they're not even suggesting when it might be
0:27:45And as usual for Apple even off the record they had you know, I asked and they had no comment
0:27:52We're here to talk about a iMac Pro today. I
0:27:56Knew that that was gonna be the answer, you know any hint any hand. Yeah, I don't want to quote you
0:28:00I'm not gonna say just like a hint as to like maybe what quarter
0:28:03It's coming and the answer was we're here today to talk about rhyme with flan. You are
0:28:11So I have no inside juice on when the new Mac Pro might ship no little birdies
0:28:17No hint it it literally could be February or it could be next December or it
0:28:24They might even be worried that it won't ship in 2018. I honestly don't know it could be imminent it could be
0:28:31Far off. I don't know my guess though is that it is not imminent. My guess would be that the
0:28:38Best case scenario. This is a pure guess it would be
0:28:42Something parallel to last year where they announced the iMac Pro at WWDC and shipped at the end of the year
0:28:49We're maybe by WWDC. They'll be willing to show it and say what it does
0:28:54and give a later this year estimate but I don't think it's coming anytime soon
0:29:00and I don't I definitely don't think it's shipping in the first half of the
0:29:03year because I don't think they would have rolled out the iMac pros the way
0:29:07they did if it were but that's just I could be totally wrong on that and I'd
0:29:12be happy to be wrong yeah I don't know anything further either obviously and I
0:29:17don't I can't really disagree with you I think that sounds reasonable I don't get
0:29:23the feeling that it is like right around the corner or anything like that either. I think
0:29:27they're they're giving this thing some breathing room. You know, in terms of announcing it
0:29:32and letting it fly and all that. They obviously wanted it out. They promised it out this year.
0:29:37They wanted it out this year and they got it out this year. The iMac Pro. But as far
0:29:42as like, you know, how much that matters for their like holiday quarter, any of that, I
0:29:47really don't think that they're counting on it mattering a ton. No, I don't. They just
0:29:51wanted to get it out and so it's out. That's why we have this late December kind of, "Hey, it's out."
0:29:56You know, and here's the sweet spot, you know, 10 core. You can get that now. Yeah, most people,
0:30:02that's great. And then for science or, you know, ML or other specialists, the higher core options
0:30:09will be shipping in January. Yeah, and so I think the interesting contrast with their laptop line,
0:30:14though, is that even not knowing the specifics of the new Mac Pro or knowing other than that
0:30:20they're working on it and that they took that truly unusual step of talking to us about it
0:30:25last April and saying, you know, you know, talking about having gotten backed into a thermal corner
0:30:32with the trashcan Mac Pro design and saying, look, we hit we're hitting a reset button,
0:30:36but we're committed to the pro market. We're coming out with a new pro machine. We're coming
0:30:40out with a new pro standalone display for the pro machine. But we, you know, it's in the future.
0:30:47And we also have a pro config iMac also in the works that will come out sooner. But I think it's
0:30:53interesting to date. It's two different things. You've got the iMac Pro for the people who,
0:30:59the pros who are perfectly fine with the sealed box, limited, you know, you've got some options
0:31:09up front to buy and then once you buy it, that's it. And pretty much whatever you do to quote,
0:31:13expand it is going to be through Thunderbolt 3 or USB. And on the other side for the pros
0:31:22who really want configurability inside the box is this upcoming Mac Pro. And I think
0:31:29that's interesting to compare with the laptops where the complaints to put the keyboard aside,
0:31:35which I think is to me the biggest complaint about the new Mac MacBook Pros. But the other
0:31:41complaints like hey I don't need a thinner machine I'll take a thicker
0:31:44machine and keep a bunch of USB ports and keep the SD card slot and etc etc
0:31:51that they've really only that they're pro laptops right now really only fit
0:31:56the side of the pro laptop market that doesn't want expandability that doesn't
0:32:02want a whole bunch of ports that doesn't would take a thicker case to have a
0:32:07bigger battery. Like there's room, like I feel like the problem with the MacBook Pro lineup is
0:32:14that I really feel like there should be two types of MacBook Pro like the MacBook Pro that is as
0:32:19thin and sleek as possible and the MacBook Pro that is physically bulkier like you know not fat
0:32:25but let's just say sort of like the 2013-2014 era MacBook Pros but still has a bunch of old school
0:32:34USB 3 ports in addition to USB C ports, etc
0:32:37Mm-hmm. Yeah sort of the you know as powerful as you can get it and still be portable right version
0:32:45Yes, exactly like the as close as you can get to a portable workstation
0:32:49Mm-hmm
0:32:52So I feel like that's basically arguing for like an like an iMac Pro portable, right?
0:32:59Like, you know, the MacBook Pro should be like, "Hey, we have the MacBook Pro and, you
0:33:07know, it'll get you where you need to go, iMac style, where you can configure it pretty
0:33:12powerful."
0:33:13But then we have this other MacBook Pro Pro that can really, you know, maximize your battery
0:33:21life and, you know, you can configure it with massive, massively powerful processors and
0:33:27all that.
0:33:28But anyway, you know, I'm at pros, obviously,
0:33:30what we wanna talk about this week,
0:33:32and I really do feel,
0:33:34if there's anything I wanna convey
0:33:36to the listeners of the show,
0:33:37or the readers of my site,
0:33:39is that if you're just trying to get your head wrapped
0:33:42around the basic story,
0:33:43is do not be fooled by the external appearance
0:33:48of the machine,
0:33:49and think that it's an iMac
0:33:53with a darker, cooler-looking anodization
0:33:57and slightly speed bumped CPUs and components.
0:34:01Like inside, it is truly a completely different architecture.
0:34:06It's really a different computer.
0:34:11I mean, and Apple in the briefing really spoke about it
0:34:13as though it was a different line.
0:34:15It's called iMac, but it's really in their minds
0:34:19a completely different line of computer from the iMac.
0:34:25- Yeah, and they said that the kind of like,
0:34:30impression that you get was that they were designing this
0:34:34as an entirely new machine and that they wanted
0:34:37to make it as powerful as possible.
0:34:39And the only constraint that they had, I guess,
0:34:42in some ways was like, hey, that display,
0:34:45we just came out with it, it's brand new, we love it,
0:34:48everything's fine with that, we have no problem with it,
0:34:51so we're gonna use the same casing and display.
0:34:54And then everything else from then on is like,
0:34:56okay, so how do we make this the absolute most powerful,
0:35:00ridiculous iMac ever?
0:35:03And then go from there.
0:35:04And honestly, just speaking from this perspective
0:35:08of somebody who keeps a PC for gaming and VR,
0:35:11and it sits right next to my Mac,
0:35:12like I have a 4K monitor hooked to my PC
0:35:15that sits on my desk, and a tower, a PC tower under my desk,
0:35:19and then an iMac next to it for most of my daily work,
0:35:23I can tell you that it has been years
0:35:28since the Mac competed on any real level
0:35:31with what I could buy off the shelf graphics-wise
0:35:36on a PC.
0:35:37And now you can argue about price
0:35:40or specific capability or whatever,
0:35:43but right now the iMac Pro is something that you could buy
0:35:47uncomfortably expect to game at top-level graphics settings and use for VR and that's a
0:35:54Massive like it's new for in many years. It has not been the case
0:35:59yeah, and it really is a jump from all the way from I
0:36:05absolutely can't even
0:36:08It can't even use a Mac it's not like you can limp along like you just you couldn't even do
0:36:16the like oculus or HTC vive VR with a Mac any Mac right to
0:36:24and I tried it I did and I mean I did it very early and it was
0:36:27terrible right to you couldn't really it was unusual to these
0:36:30machines being not just credible but very very good machines to
0:36:35drive these experiences well specifically the HTC vive right
0:36:40now I don't think oculus works with it it's not just that all
0:36:43All the demos that we saw this week were on the HTC Vive.
0:36:48And I think it goes through, they all go through the Steam Vive VR thingamajig that I don't
0:36:55really know much about.
0:36:57But it's...
0:36:58Yeah, yeah, they will, the Mac, just to fill in the gap, the Mac got official Vive support
0:37:06via Steam as of WWDC.
0:37:10And I think they shipped it, and I can't remember
0:37:12whether they shipped it in beta or full version at WWDC,
0:37:14but basically, they were, as of Dub-Dub,
0:37:17you were able to launch Steam, get your update,
0:37:21plug in your Vive to your Mac, and start using it for VR.
0:37:25That is, of course, theoretically,
0:37:27because the top tier VR applications
0:37:31really didn't run super well on most iMacs.
0:37:36And even the modern, if you'd bought an iMac this year,
0:37:40you know, with the best capabilities, stuff. But he was definitely not going to give you
0:37:48what we would consider a top tier VR experience. But obviously, they were planning because
0:37:54they knew this was coming out. So
0:38:00it really was and I'll just say this, you know, you're you know, one of the reasons
0:38:03I really wanted to have you on the show this week was that you know more about VR than
0:38:08anybody I know. And so, you know, and I, I don't have to say I know the least, but I
0:38:14know little. And so I want to, I want you there to double check my impressions of the
0:38:20VR stuff that I saw this week, you know, demoed. Another thing, I didn't really mention it.
0:38:28I wish I had in my write up yesterday, but after all, most of the demos that we had,
0:38:33it was sort of like you'd walk around, you know, we were in smaller groups broken up
0:38:36and it was like little demo stations throughout Apple's building. And we'd go see the demo
0:38:41from this company for 15, 20 minutes and then time's up. We'll go round robin, we'll
0:38:47rotate to the next group. And after most of them, especially the ones that I thought were
0:38:51the most technically impressive, I'd walk behind the machine and put my hand to see
0:38:56if I could hear the fan, if I could feel, did it feel like the machine was red hot or
0:39:00anything like that. And in none of the cases, even the ones after where we were like the
0:39:06third or fourth group to go through the demo on the same setup. It never felt hot. I never
0:39:11heard the fan. I'm not saying the fan wasn't blowing. I'm just saying that if there was
0:39:17something going on to push heat out, it wasn't noisy and it definitely wasn't hot. In fact,
0:39:23today I even tried it. Now I've still got the 2014, the original 5K iMac is still my
0:39:28desktop machine here. I put my hand where the fan is on my iMac and it was hotter and
0:39:34I'm not even doing anything. I mean, I've just got, you know, a bunch of Safari tabs
0:39:38open and mail and it's just running. And it is silent. My iMac is…
0:39:42I have a common promo, so you can cook an egg on it.
0:39:45Right. My iMac is silent. It's not making any noise. But I put my hand back there and
0:39:50it was warmer than the iMac Pro in the demos on Wednesday. So the thermal stuff that they're
0:39:58doing is incredible given that it's got this high-end performance.
0:40:02Yeah, I have the same Mac. Well, I mean, you know, if it's the exact same configuration,
0:40:06but late 2014 retina 5k, and it's the i7. And that it definitely, you know, yeah, it
0:40:13gets hot, it gets warm. I mean, I can feel the heat coming off of it. Because it's kind
0:40:17of next to a wall. So it vectors out and I can feel the heat coming from behind us sometimes.
0:40:22Yeah. And I do think that this ties into I for anybody out there who's frustrated that
0:40:29this machine isn't more configurable isn't user configurable that you're why am I going
0:40:34to spend $12,000 which you can easily do you can easily configure one of these things to
0:40:39run 10 11 $12,000 why am I going to spend $11,000 on on a workstation that I can't change
0:40:45the graphics card in or whatever I think the way that they got this thermal performance
0:40:53where it stays quiet and cool is that by limiting it to these two graphics cards for CPU options,
0:41:02that they figured out exactly what the thermal aspects of these specific components are and
0:41:08designed a system just for them. I feel like the close nature of the system, the remarkably
0:41:15small size that it really just looks like a monitor with a bulge on the back, it's no
0:41:20bigger physically than a regular iMac, it goes hand in hand with the limited configurability.
0:41:26Yes, it's sort of like custom built is the wrong word, but sort of bespoke hardware in a way.
0:41:37Yeah.
0:41:37Where it's like, "Hey, look, if you need to accomplish these tasks, here's the minimum
0:41:41amount of hardware space and the maximum amount of power we can give you to get this thing done."
0:41:48And it really, you know, now that it is Visa mountable, because you can remove the foot
0:41:52now, which you didn't used to be able to do, you had to order it from the factory that
0:41:55way.
0:41:56You know, people will be mounting these things everywhere and they'll have like an incredibly
0:41:59powerful workstation in the size of a monitor.
0:42:02And I think that that is overlooked by a lot of people who want maximum modularity, which
0:42:07once again I understand.
0:42:09But a lot of people don't want modularity.
0:42:11And I think that a certain audience of people underestimates how many professional users
0:42:16there are that don't give a crap about modularity and just want the maximum amount of power
0:42:22with the least fuss possible.
0:42:24Like no cables besides power, right?
0:42:28No messing around with towers and where do I mount this and where do I mount that and
0:42:32all of this.
0:42:33And the applications for that are very, very widespread.
0:42:38One of the ones that we saw in the demos was medical application for instance, right?
0:42:44These guys were taking CT scan slices and then turning them into a model in near real
0:42:51time essentially.
0:42:52And then a surgeon can look at that 3D model and rotate it and say, "Look, here's a vascular
0:42:57system from this CT scan."
0:43:00Which, these things were possible, for sure.
0:43:02They've been possible for a long time.
0:43:04So it's not like, "Oh, this is brand new."
0:43:06But the real time nature of it, how quick it is for them to dump a folder full of CT
0:43:12into this program and then pop open a 3D model seconds later
0:43:16and then rotate that model in real time in high res.
0:43:19That kind of thing mounted to a wall in a briefing room
0:43:23or in an office where they can instantly show a patient
0:43:26what they're talking about to try and give them
0:43:28better understanding and alleviate some anxiety
0:43:30or to give them better knowledge going into a surgery.
0:43:34At that point, those thousands of dollars that people say,
0:43:39oh, you got to spend x, y and z on this on this computer and
0:43:43blah, blah, blah. That's nothing. That's nothing. CT
0:43:46machines are in the 10s of millions of dollars. Well, you
0:43:50know, and what do you think this is an accessory, right? You
0:43:53know, and we this company is called Osiris OSI, r i x, with
0:43:59the capital X. And they've been around they said they're a Swiss
0:44:03company, I believe. They've been around for 14 years and they're
0:44:06Mac only, or really Apple only because they have an iOS app
0:44:10too. But they're, to me, they're all I've never heard of them
0:44:12before, because I'm not a medical professional. But to me,
0:44:14they're like the poster children for like, the type of
0:44:17developers Apple loves to talk about where their app looks like
0:44:22a real Mac app. And it totally it's all modernized for, you
0:44:26know, the Sierra High Sierra look. And you know, if you've
0:44:31ever been if you've ever like me, I cannot help it. I look at
0:44:34at the user interface of everything, right?
0:44:37And I think about the user interface
0:44:39of everything I ever see.
0:44:41And whenever I'm in like a doctor's office
0:44:44or the dentist's office or whatever,
0:44:46and I look, it's usually always these janky Windows apps
0:44:50that are just horribly designed
0:44:53and look like they were, probably were in fact designed
0:44:56for like Windows XP in 2001 and it just still running now.
0:45:01Like their app looks like a real Mac app,
0:45:03like the type of thing that a consumer,
0:45:08if it was, you had a consumer,
0:45:09that would be like a consumer app
0:45:11that would look great on the front page of the app store.
0:45:14But they mentioned it.
0:45:16So they've been around for 14 years,
0:45:17or they've been shipping for 14 years.
0:45:18So obviously, the thing that they do,
0:45:22they were running 14 years ago,
0:45:24obviously on far less powerful hardware.
0:45:27But that the big difference between what they could do now
0:45:31on the iMac Pro and where they've been before
0:45:33is that it's gone from like a 2D experience
0:45:36where you're like, let's say somebody has a knee injury
0:45:39and you're like a orthopedic surgeon
0:45:41and you're looking at these CT scans.
0:45:43Instead of like going between a bunch of still images
0:45:47at different depths of the knee in three dimensions,
0:45:50it now can be like a 3D viewing experience
0:45:53where you're kind of moving the camera,
0:45:56for lack of a better word,
0:45:58through the knee in three dimensions.
0:46:00And you could just see the enthusiasm of the developers.
0:46:04They were like, yeah, we were blown away.
0:46:05We never really thought, we never thought
0:46:07when we started this app over a decade ago
0:46:09that it would be a 3D viewer for this stuff.
0:46:12And like you said-- - Right, they said
0:46:13their initial version was literally just an image viewer.
0:46:15You know, it's just like, hey, look, here's a JPEG
0:46:18that you can look at.
0:46:19- Right, and it's exactly like you said
0:46:22that in terms of, well, geez, that must be nice
0:46:27to run on a $10,000 iMac.
0:46:29But for the cost of the medical equipment
0:46:32that's in like a radiologist's lab,
0:46:34the $10,000 iMac is nothing, right?
0:46:39- Mm-hmm, right.
0:46:41Yeah, and so like just so people don't at me,
0:46:45I looked up the cost of a CT machine.
0:46:47'Cause I was like, wait a minute,
0:46:49how much did that actually cost?
0:46:49'Cause I remember them costing this much a while back,
0:46:52'cause I have my wife's in the medical field,
0:46:55the medical industry, and has been for a long time,
0:46:5715 years.
0:46:59But so right now at 360 slice, which is sort of like high end CT scanner will cost you
0:47:04like two and a half to $3 million.
0:47:06So let's call it through a $3 million round it up.
0:47:10If an iMac Pro with this piece of software on it, which is like $700 a seat for the software
0:47:17and then like $4,000 for the iMac Pro, like a bit of $5,000 for the base model, like 10
0:47:23core or whatever it is or you know, something like that.
0:47:25Let's call it five to $7,000.
0:47:27This is literally an upsell accessory that they throw in.
0:47:30You know what I mean?
0:47:31- Right.
0:47:32- Like they're like, "Oh yeah, and we'll get you a full 3D view of it within seconds with
0:47:36our proprietary software or whatever, white-labeled software or this software package and this
0:47:42iMac mounted to the side of it like with zip ties or whatever."
0:47:45You know what I mean?
0:47:47That comes with, so to speak.
0:47:49And I think that people lose perspective on that because a lot of the people that are
0:47:52very vocal about it, which I understand are enthusiasts or independent developers where
0:48:00the budget very much matters to them.
0:48:03And I get it.
0:48:04And this may not be the machine for them.
0:48:06They may want to maximize something where they can make a large investment up front
0:48:09and then smaller investments over time upgrading it as parts or modules can be upgraded, which
0:48:15is 100% valid complaint or not even complaint, but just statement to make, like philosophy
0:48:20to have a bunch of competing purchases. But in many cases, like this will, you know, the
0:48:27iMac Pro will do some jobs for such a long time that they amortized out and it is an
0:48:35incredibly negligible expense. And I think that there's a lot of people that this will do a lot
0:48:40of good work for over time.
0:48:41Yeah. And I thought it was also interesting. I mean, again, you know, in addition to showing
0:48:44off the iMac Pro, the developers who were invited were part of the quid pro quo of,
0:48:51"Okay, you're going to give Apple your time to travel to New York and to spend the time
0:48:55to rehearse and put these things together as they can brag about and promote their products."
0:49:02And these guys mentioned that in 2016 they had 35% growth. And again, this is a 14-year-old
0:49:08app and that this year 2017 they're on pace for 45% growth you know which is to
0:49:15me super impressive for a 14 year old app that it still is obviously rapidly
0:49:21growing in the market I mean 45% growth in a for a 14 year old app is incredible
0:49:26but I really think it shows that it's paid off for these guys to commit
0:49:30themselves to the Mac as a platform mm-hmm yep and I think that there's a
0:49:37A segment of people, and I think that some of them are represented, of course.
0:49:44No surprise in these groups of people that we're demoing, that Apple had brought in and
0:49:50say, "Hey, these people are building really cool Mac apps that will benefit from the iMac
0:49:55Pro's increased power."
0:49:56Very, very evidently, they will benefit very quickly.
0:50:01But then you'll have a long tail of people where you have market segments that are, you
0:50:07have been served by PCs, and I don't think Apple's blind
0:50:11to the fact that if they were to introduce something
0:50:14like the iMac Pro, that it might in fact take some
0:50:18of that market as well.
0:50:19In other words, they're not just eating the market
0:50:21of people who are buying high-end iMacs,
0:50:24they are also going after certain segments of the market
0:50:27where they can fill gaps.
0:50:29GravitySketch, which is one of the other apps
0:50:31that was demoed there, I had spoken to these folks
0:50:34previously, I'd spoken to the co-founder a while back and he was there demoing the apps
0:50:40and he comes from an automotive background and that background basically was in the design
0:50:52and modeling phase of automotive.
0:50:58The issue that they have with that industry is that if they want to appeal to these people
0:51:12with their virtual reality 3D sketch and modeling application for the automotive industry and
0:51:18and other industries that are looking to design
0:51:20straight into 3D.
0:51:22Their issue for a long time had been,
0:51:24hey, we've got these people, these designers,
0:51:26who are working on Macs through the whole process.
0:51:29Like designers love Macs, everybody knows this.
0:51:31So you've got an automotive guy who's working on Mac
0:51:34through his whole process.
0:51:37And then, you know, gets to this point in the process
0:51:42where they want to try this GravitySketch thing,
0:51:46which is in VR, and they have to switch to a PC
0:51:49because this program runs on PC
0:51:52and it needs the power of a high-end graphics card
0:51:56and a high-end CPU to really get them flowing
0:51:59and sketching in 3D and all of this
0:52:02to eliminate a lot of cost in the clay modeling segment
0:52:07of car development.
0:52:09So if you don't know anything about car development,
0:52:11essentially they go through a bunch of design phases,
0:52:13including sketching, but in between each of those,
0:52:15they typically do a clay model.
0:52:17So they'll do like a sketch and then a clay model
0:52:19and then CAD and then a clay model
0:52:21and then aerodynamics and then a clay model
0:52:24and you know, so on and so forth.
0:52:25And so one car can have like a dozen clay models
0:52:28made of it at one point or another
0:52:29and those are expensive and time consuming.
0:52:32And so they're trying to like supplant a lot of that
0:52:34where you could kind of go into GravitySketch,
0:52:37really model it out as you would in a clay model
0:52:40and then dump that into an environment
0:52:41where you can get precise like CAD or something like that.
0:52:44So they are very much a sketch application
0:52:47that takes the place of a lot of physical modeling
0:52:50that would normally take place in the process
0:52:52of creating a new vehicle.
0:52:55But in the case of selling into a company
0:52:59that you already use as a bunch of Macs,
0:53:01they would have to go like, oh, and you have to get PCs
0:53:04to use here.
0:53:04So instead, they've got this now.
0:53:06- I thought their enthusiasm as,
0:53:09look, we know that the people in our target audience
0:53:12are long-time Mac users
0:53:14'cause they're creative professionals
0:53:15and they love their Macs and we like Macs,
0:53:18their enthusiasm for getting this running on the Mac
0:53:21to integrate for exactly the reasons you said,
0:53:23I thought was palpable.
0:53:24And it's the sort of thing that you could say,
0:53:27well, of course they were pro-Macintosh
0:53:29'cause they were at an Apple-hosted briefing,
0:53:31but it really doesn't work like that.
0:53:32Like it was, I thought it was legit
0:53:35and it makes sense for the reasons you said.
0:53:38Yeah, I got to play with Gravity Sketch Wednesday.
0:53:41You insisted that I try all the VR stuff.
0:53:44- Yeah, I found, I was like, so you know, wait.
0:53:48I wanna know, 'cause at the time you said,
0:53:50oh, you hadn't tried it much.
0:53:52So what experience had you had in VR
0:53:54before you put the headset on for the first time
0:53:57at that Gravity Sketch demo?
0:53:58- I had, I forgot about the one,
0:54:00which is actually the one
0:54:01I've probably spent the most time in.
0:54:04So a year or so ago, I got a backstage tour
0:54:09at MLB in New York, the people who make the At Bad app.
0:54:14Actually, Disney's bought a majority stake
0:54:21or bought all of their media thing.
0:54:23- Yeah, they were part of, yeah, MLB AM,
0:54:27which is Advanced Media, I don't know what they're called
0:54:29now, but yeah, they spun out.
0:54:31They're their own company now.
0:54:31They have some of the best iOS developers in the world
0:54:33in my opinion.
0:54:34- And they also have some of the best streaming video
0:54:37technology in the world. Because if you remember, if you go back a few years, when HBO first
0:54:43started trying to stream their stuff, it would fall apart every time a new episode of Game
0:54:48of Thrones came out. And when they hit the reset button and redid it, what they really
0:54:54did was outsource it all to MLB's media. And the fact that everybody can watch the
0:54:59Fail Whale isn't a thing for Game of Thrones streaming episodes anymore. It's all because
0:55:04it's on the MLB backend. But anyway, I was there, took a tour, and one of their developers
0:55:09was working on a VR thing. I think it was like simulated view in a ballpark type thing.
0:55:17So I tried that for like five minutes. I forget what hardware it was, but it wasn't great.
0:55:21I think it was like a first gen Oculus or something, like a developer kit. I bought
0:55:27the thing when I bought the Pixel 1 over a year ago. I bought the headset that Google
0:55:32cells with it. It's like a 60. It's not like the cardboard box thing. It's a step above
0:55:36that, but it's pretty much just put your pixel in this felt visor and I don't know, spend
0:55:43an hour or two playing around with it. And the last thing, which I forgot when we were
0:55:50talking Wednesday, is that my son Jonas has the PlayStation VR and I haven't really played
0:55:55it. I'm not a gamer, but I was interested enough in it as a technology where I was like,
0:56:01"Well, give me this thing, I gotta see what this is like."
0:56:04So I've used PlayStation VR.
0:56:06That's my experience going into this.
0:56:07- And so, so far, and just this is like a setup, right?
0:56:11So, so far up until this point,
0:56:13your experience with it have largely been,
0:56:15okay, early, rough, then the mobile, portable, right?
0:56:20Which definitely have a lot of downsides still, right?
0:56:24They've come so far,
0:56:24but still very much not a top-of-the-line experience.
0:56:28And then the PlayStation VR,
0:56:29which is actually pretty damn good,
0:56:31but it's a purely single viewpoint camera-based experience.
0:56:36So it's got these colored markers, these lights on it,
0:56:38and the camera sees those markers,
0:56:39and that's how it tracks your head movements and all that.
0:56:42So then, going into this experience with the Vive,
0:56:46which you did a couple at this event,
0:56:48you've got what they call lighthouses,
0:56:50which are infrared sensing cameras that are mounted,
0:56:54kind of up and at angles,
0:56:55and so they can see all sides of the headset
0:56:58and the controllers.
0:56:59So you've got hands and head in the world being tracked.
0:57:03So it's like kind of another level of VR.
0:57:05So how did your gravity sketch thing go?
0:57:07- It was pretty good.
0:57:10I certainly am not susceptible to motion sickness.
0:57:15Never have been really, like on boats and roller coasters
0:57:18and stuff like that, or I never really gotten car sick.
0:57:21And like 3D movie, I don't like watching 3D motion pictures
0:57:26'cause I find cognitively I've bitched about it.
0:57:29And I think there's something to it.
0:57:30There's a lot of people, there's research that's shown it
0:57:32that it's, I can't follow the plot, but I don't get sick.
0:57:36So I didn't find it bothersome.
0:57:37I thought it was pretty neat.
0:57:38And with Gravity Sketch in particular,
0:57:40I could totally see right away that describing it
0:57:45as less like sketching and more like sculpting
0:57:47was totally true.
0:57:49Like it's very hard to explain and put into words
0:57:53and to make you believe it.
0:57:55Because at the same time that one person can have the VR headset on and get the actual
0:58:02VR experience, they were simulcasting it to like a big 60-inch TV so that everybody else
0:58:08in the room could see what the person was seeing.
0:58:12But when you see it on a 2D TV, it doesn't really look any different than any 3D app
0:58:17that you've seen for 25 years.
0:58:21If you've seen any 3D modeling app, you're like, "Oh, okay."
0:58:24But when you have it on and you know, you can just move your head around
0:58:28You know, it is very different and it absolutely comes across more like sculpting than than drawing
0:58:36It is you know, even while just making one
0:58:40You know putting one thing into the model, you know, it feels it totally feels 3d at all times
0:58:50Right, and you know, he was he was talking about how people adopt it quickly and stuff
0:58:54And I think some people laugh because they know you know, like hey VR there is an adoption curve, which is true
0:58:59You know, it takes some time to get used to the controllers and all of that
0:59:02But I mean honestly the controllers are a big barrier because they're fairly clunky now
0:59:07Almost all of them are the oculus ones are probably the best
0:59:09The more ergonomic
0:59:14But all of the controllers are pretty subpar until we get full hand tracking
0:59:17we're not you know we're not going to be seeing the true potential but I will say
0:59:21that like I put my dad into a VR headset and he'd been never been in one before
0:59:25and I put him into a headset with the controllers and a copy of Google's sketch
0:59:34well it's I think tilt it's called tilt brush right so it's it's like a
0:59:40sketching and painting app with far less precision it's really about expressive
0:59:45of painting and things like that.
0:59:47But it's quite cool, very, very rich complex stuff with it.
0:59:51And he picked it up like that.
0:59:54And within minutes he had produced a piece of artwork
0:59:57in there that I was like, how do I save this?
0:59:58I'm like, I can't even save this.
1:00:00And it's because it translates incredibly well
1:00:04to people that have a great handle on spatial relationships,
1:00:08like designers, you know, the designer industrialists
1:00:11especially and architects and things like that.
1:00:13They have just in their head, they've got these frameworks
1:00:18that allow them to imagine
1:00:20and understand spatial relationships.
1:00:22And so to them, being able to sketch in 3D
1:00:25is not necessarily, it's not,
1:00:28it's not a barrier to them, it's a release, right?
1:00:34And I think a lot of people assume like,
1:00:36"Oh, they're gonna have to get used
1:00:37to this new way of doing it."
1:00:39And they're like, "No, finally,
1:00:40Like I've been, you know, I've been tied by pencil and paper or by 2D plane this whole
1:00:46time and all I wanted to do was sketch in 3D, you know?
1:00:50All my sketching up to this point has just been trying to get in 3D.
1:00:53That's what I think VR does is it unlocks these new experiences and new ways of doing
1:00:58things.
1:00:59It's certainly no surprise that 30 years ago and prior that all automobile design was done
1:01:06in clay, you know, with actual sculpture. But it's also no surprise to me, even though
1:01:13I'm not a 3D artist or a sculptor, but it's no surprise to me that that stayed through
1:01:18to now long after the CAD revolution, where the CAD schematics for the design of a car
1:01:26can be projected in 3D on a two-dimensional screen and you can, you know, use your mouse
1:01:33or trackpad or whatever to pan it around as a wireframe
1:01:38or to use shading to make it look, you know,
1:01:41there's all the ways that you can make 3D
1:01:45look on a 2D screen.
1:01:47But I could totally see though for the creative aspect of it
1:01:52that doing it in VR is,
1:01:54it really is to three dimensional thinking
1:01:58what the original CAD revolution was to two dimensional
1:02:02where you really are moving from paper and pencil
1:02:04on a sheet of graph paper to doing it on a computer,
1:02:08that VR is really the first time you're doing it in 3D.
1:02:11Like the 3D that you can get on a 2D screen
1:02:14doesn't really scratch that itch.
1:02:15- Yep, makes sense.
1:02:19And I really do feel that there's not much,
1:02:23there's not much you can say to somebody
1:02:27who has never tried it that will express appropriately
1:02:31the transportation or sense of place
1:02:36that being in a real 3D environment
1:02:42bounded by 3D can give you.
1:02:45And that's, I think, one of the things
1:02:46that has honestly hurt VR a lot in terms of adoption.
1:02:50I think there are several large technology hurdles
1:02:53that are the main cause of it not really going wide yet,
1:02:57and those will need to be overcome.
1:02:59But I think that that sense of you have to see it
1:03:02to understand is a real barrier to adoption.
1:03:06'Cause it's impossible to tell somebody,
1:03:08no, like you're really, it is really 3D.
1:03:11And they're like, yeah, yeah, I've seen 3D shit.
1:03:13You're like, no, not quite, it's more than that.
1:03:17It's something more.
1:03:18And I think that people that are,
1:03:20or designers who have been really, really wanting
1:03:23this kind of thing in their workflow,
1:03:25when they see it, they get it,
1:03:27and they adopt it right away.
1:03:28It'll take longer for the world at large but the people that have been really hankering for this
1:03:32Have really wanted this and now they have a Mac that can actually push it which is amazing because then they can go to that
1:03:37Same Mac and launch into their other workflows. I know I'm guilty of it
1:03:41I think anybody who's adept at computers and the the earlier back in
1:03:46Interface that you're adept at a computer like if especially if you're as so adept that you're comfortable at the command line
1:03:53It's easy to overlook
1:03:58uh, just how freeing it is every time the industry levels up and removes a conceptual
1:04:09layer of abstraction. And a good example, a really good example is to me, like the way
1:04:17that, uh, folks on the Asperger's syndrome, especially including ones who are really,
1:04:24you know, really severely affected by it. And that kids who have so much trouble communicating
1:04:33really fly on an iPad and just do amazing things and expressing themselves and learning.
1:04:43And you think like, well, why, you know, and it's really because that that layer of abstraction
1:04:48of moving a mouse pointer around with a secondary controller, it's easy to think like, ah, touching
1:05:00a button with your finger and touching a trackpad to move an arrow on screen to get the button
1:05:05and clicking the trackpad. It's effectively the same thing. One's just direct and one's
1:05:09a layer of indirection. But that layer of indirection is truly profound for some people.
1:05:15And then for people who aren't affected by like, something like Asperger's or any other
1:05:20disability, it, you know, like my dad, my dad is so much better and more effective and
1:05:27communicates and, and I messaged me so much more like from his iPad than, than a Mac.
1:05:34And it's just because it, you know, it, it less to think you don't have to think it through,
1:05:40It just happens.
1:05:41And that layer of abstraction is totally there for 3D,
1:05:46where if you just want to get a slightly different angle,
1:05:48like the model, like when I was using the gravity sketch,
1:05:51there was a car model, and then there was also like a sneaker.
1:05:56And if you just want to get like a slightly different view
1:05:59on the sneaker, the fact that you just move your head
1:06:02the same way that you would get a slightly different view
1:06:04on a sneaker in real life, and that the,
1:06:06the field of view is exactly the same as looking at a sneaker in real life is it it's it's just
1:06:20totally different than if I had to do something click a button or rotate a wheel or move my
1:06:25fingers on a trackpad to rotate the view like the fact that I'm rotating the view the way
1:06:29I always do with everything else in the world by just moving my head is
1:06:32It's just incredible
1:06:36Mm-hmm, like there's absolutely and that yeah that deletion of abstraction as you mentioned is a huge like
1:06:45It's a huge help. It's a huge assist to people that that have issues already
1:06:51But it is a massively forward to for people who who knew what they wanted it
1:06:56and just have never been able to get it.
1:06:58- Right.
1:06:59All right, let me take a break here
1:07:01and thank our next sponsor.
1:07:03It's our good friends at Warby Parker.
1:07:05Warby Parker believes glasses should not cost
1:07:07as much as an iPhone.
1:07:09Their prescription eyeglasses still start at just $95,
1:07:13including prescription lenses with anti-glare coating,
1:07:17no kind of upsell to get the good lenses.
1:07:20You get the good lenses and cool-looking frames at just $95.
1:07:25And at that price, that's part of the reason that they believe it's like that, is that
1:07:29it should be any kind of, just like any other kind of accessory, like shoes or a bag or
1:07:34a necktie.
1:07:35Like, do you only own one pair of shoes?
1:07:38Matthew Panzareno, I know for a fact, owns at least two pairs of sneakers.
1:07:42A couple.
1:07:45Why not have glasses like that?
1:07:46I think like the old days, like I grew up where if you needed glasses, you got a pair
1:07:50of glasses and then you kept them until they broke or until you needed a new prescription
1:07:55and then sometimes even when you got the new prescription you just get them popped into
1:07:58the same frames like that's that's just the way it was well why part of it is that glasses
1:08:03can be super exciting expensive you can get them for ninety five bucks you can get three
1:08:06or four pairs and mix and match you know as your mood changes so new stuff from Warby
1:08:12Parker do you have an iPhone 10 if you do even if you don't need glasses it is absolutely
1:08:17worth doing this because it's a really cool demo of ARKit.
1:08:21Download Warby Parker's app from the App Store and you can try their brand new feature, Find
1:08:26Your Fit.
1:08:27Find Your Fit uses the iPhone X's TrueDepth camera to map and measure key facial features.
1:08:31Using these measurements, Find Your Fit recommends approximately 12 Warby Parker frames that
1:08:36are likely the best fit for your face.
1:08:38The process is seamless and only takes a few seconds.
1:08:41If you're thinking with your iPhone X, like, "What are some cool things I can do with this
1:08:46true depth camera other than the animoji stuff that ships with it. This is absolutely a great
1:08:52example of where this is totally making a new thing possible for apps that just weren't possible
1:08:58before. Something that just like a still camera, just having a front facing still camera, it just
1:09:04doesn't do it like this does. It's really, really cool. Look, I've had a pair of Warby, I have a pair
1:09:09of them right here in front of me. These are my reading glasses, but I've had a pair of Warby
1:09:12Parker glasses, I don't know four or five years, still have my first pair of worry Parker
1:09:17glasses still around. So it's not like they're shoddily made or anything like that and don't
1:09:21last really, really great experience with them personally. Again, they started just
1:09:27$95 lenses include anti glare anti scratch coatings. For every pair you buy this is great.
1:09:35This has always been true right since the first time I've ever heard of Warby Parker,
1:09:38every pair of glasses you buy from them, Warby Parker distribute to pair to someone in need
1:09:42somewhere around the world. So all sorts of people around the world who don't have access to either
1:09:48don't have access or don't have the money for prescription glasses. And so everything they see
1:09:52is blurry. Imagine what that would be like to go through life and knowing that you don't see
1:09:58everything clearly and that you could if you only could get a pair of glasses. Well, Warby Parker
1:10:02helps make that happen all the way around the world. I think that's fantastic. Anyway, and they
1:10:06have a free try on program. So if you're not familiar with Warby Parker from previous podcasts
1:10:11where you've heard about them. You think like, "Well, how do I buy glasses even if I see them
1:10:14in the app? I don't want to just see them in the app and hope that they work for $95."
1:10:18What they have is a free trium program. You order five pairs of glasses from them. They ship them
1:10:26to you free of charge. And they come not with prescription glasses, just like dummy lenses.
1:10:31So you can just try them on like you do in a store and see if they fit, see if you like the way they
1:10:35look with no obligation to buy. If you don't like any of the five, just put all five back in the
1:10:40box. It's all it's already got a label so you don't have to pay for anything. It just ships
1:10:43right back to them. But if you do like them, then you're one step away from having a brand new pair
1:10:51of the lenses that you like sent to you with your prescription lenses. So head to warbyparker.com
1:10:56slash the talk show warbyparker.com slash the talk show and order your free home try ons today.
1:11:04that's warby Parker.com slash the talk show. Anyway, great, great company love their products.
1:11:12So one of the other companies that demoed the iMac Pro, and again, it was VR was a company I
1:11:21had never heard of. But when I came home and talked to Jonas about it, he was like, Oh, yeah,
1:11:25they make a great VR game. A company called SurVios. S-U-R-V-I-O-S. I don't know what
1:11:34the name of their VR game that they previously had was, but they demoed for us.
1:11:39Jared Ranerelle It was Hard Data.
1:11:40Dave Asprey Hard Data, okay.
1:11:41Jared Ranerelle Yeah, it's their biggest hit so far.
1:11:43Dave Asprey Well, Jonas was very impressed that I met the founder. They had a new app.
1:11:51I hesitate to even...
1:11:52Jared Ranerelle Sorry, Raw Data.
1:11:54It's raw data. Raw data is the name of the game. Sorry, go ahead.
1:12:00Hard data is like the Chinese ripoff version of it.
1:12:03Yeah.
1:12:03Electronauts is their new app, and I'm going to call it an app, not a game. And I think it's
1:12:14primarily about the creation of music. But it has the feel of a game. It's sort of like, I would say,
1:12:22two-thirds, three-fourths music creation being a DJ and a one-third game sort of
1:12:31like Guitar Hero. But part of it is that the basic premise was that you don't
1:12:38have to be a musician to do it and that you can't make anything sound bad. So
1:12:43like in a way that like me, an idiot who doesn't know how to play a guitar, if I
1:12:47just pick up a guitar and try to do anything, it literally sounds like
1:12:50Someone who doesn't know how to play a guitar just picking strings on a guitar
1:12:54Whereas you get into this game no matter what you bang
1:12:57So you you put the goggles on and you got two joysticks you calm joysticks. What do you call those things?
1:13:03The controllers there's two. Yes. Yeah. Yeah the two the vibe controllers. There's like one for each hand. Yeah
1:13:10and then that puts like you said before that puts your hands in the
1:13:17field of vision of you and as you move your hands you see them in real time in the VR world and
1:13:22You've got the equivalent of like two drumsticks and you can use it to bang on these things to make tones that go along with
1:13:28This background music that's going but then you also use the sticks to poke at the controls
1:13:34It's sort of like you're standing in front of a
1:13:38Three-way desk like there's a front part
1:13:41That's the main thing
1:13:42You turn to your right and there's things to select over there and you turn to your left and there's things to select over there
1:13:48in the meantime the entire world around you is moving like you're on like
1:13:53The best way I could describe it is you're like imagine like you're on a train and the Tron movie
1:13:58right, it's
1:14:01You know, it's like you're in the Tron universe and it's you're constantly moving at high speed on a train
1:14:08Which sort of gives you that guitar hero feel and then if somebody else is playing with you
1:14:12You can do it to two people at the same time
1:14:14You can turn to your side and see the other person at it at the same type of
1:14:18DJ workstation area over to your side and you can toss these sound grenades at each other that
1:14:25You know make other types of noise to go along with the music
1:14:30super impressive a very very impressive technically
1:14:36But I found it fascinating from a user interface perspective because they really were serious that you know, like real DJs
1:14:42This is something they envision that real DJs could use to put you know
1:14:45Play and customize music perform live in front of you know, like a club or a party type atmosphere
1:14:51And that seems totally credible to me
1:14:54But it was really interesting as a user interface perspective because it it's a it's a pro creation app
1:15:02Like you're creating music and the only interface to it is VR
1:15:06There is absolutely no way that you that this thing would work on a two-dimensional screen without VR. I
1:15:12You know, yeah, I
1:15:15Mean they're there they've done a couple of things that are really cool with it
1:15:21I mean I jumped in because I definitely wanted to try it out. I'm a fan of Serbia's
1:15:25I've been following them for years
1:15:26I saw
1:15:27One of their extremely early prototypes very very early on when they were still doing a lot of hardware
1:15:32They've since pivoted or whatever you want to call it to doing mostly software's because the hardware stuff kind of shook out like Oh
1:15:39Oculus and vibe, you know, those kind of took the took the lead and so they're like, okay, that's fine. That's not our strength
1:15:43Anyway, we're gonna go with XY. So they've been making software and some some of the best software for the platforms, but
1:15:51Really like their stuff
1:15:52I think they have a good handle on what makes VR special,
1:15:55how they've been really pounding the pavement
1:15:58in terms of trying to get,
1:16:00trying to figure out what the best locomotion models are,
1:16:04what the best kind of interaction models are,
1:16:06that sort of thing.
1:16:07'Cause I think a lot of people don't realize that about VR
1:16:09is that nobody really knows what the hell's going on.
1:16:12Like even the people that are making the best stuff
1:16:14for the platform, and that's also why it's so exciting.
1:16:17Right, it's not done, right?
1:16:19Like the best way to use a mouse and a pointer,
1:16:21That's done, it's it, right?
1:16:24Like then you go touch, like what's the best way
1:16:26to use touch?
1:16:27It's not completely done, but there's a lot of that
1:16:29that's done, right?
1:16:30Like people know how to use touch and how to tell people
1:16:35how to use touch when they're building applications
1:16:37and that sort of thing.
1:16:38But VR is very, very open field.
1:16:41There's a lot of people running a lot of different
1:16:43directions on this.
1:16:44And some people out there are doing some really,
1:16:46really good work to say like, oh, this is how.
1:16:49We think that this is the best way.
1:16:51and then you'll see a lot of people sort of funnel into that
1:16:53and then some other people go,
1:16:54"Oh no, how about this way?"
1:16:56But Serbius has been doing this for a while
1:16:59and I think it shows in the precision,
1:17:02but the good feel of their interactions,
1:17:05how you grab different instruments,
1:17:06how you interact with the instruments.
1:17:08- And they do have a bit of haptic feedback
1:17:10like when you pick something up with the stick,
1:17:13there's just a slight amount of haptic feedback
1:17:16and a little visual feedback where now it's glowing
1:17:19so you know you've got it.
1:17:21Right. And it's a little tick like just so you would feel like, oh, I'm picking up something
1:17:25light but I know I have it in my hands kind of thing. And you know, all of those things
1:17:29will get better over time. But they had a pretty good, you know, pretty good base set
1:17:34of stuff in there. Right. What would actually when you go to like start pounding on stuff,
1:17:37right? Like it's, it's sort of a, what would it feel like to pick up a, a, a zero weight
1:17:44electrical thing? You know what I mean? Like if you know, like in the Harry, you know,
1:17:48Harry Potter type universe, like somebody with a wand
1:17:52creates something that's not real,
1:17:55what would it feel like to pick it up?
1:17:56That's exactly the sort of haptic feedback you get.
1:17:59They're not simulating weight,
1:18:02but it's just enough of a tick to,
1:18:05you feel like you've got this thing that doesn't weigh--
1:18:07- Yeah, it's that confirmation and feedback loop
1:18:10that you need to make your mind say,
1:18:14I have accomplished this task of grabbing this thing,
1:18:17or picking this thing.
1:18:19But then the second thing that they've done,
1:18:21and this is sort of like the underlying technology
1:18:24behind this app, is that they have created this system
1:18:29for synchronizing and sort of up-resing
1:18:34your musical abilities.
1:18:39So I don't have very good innate rhythm.
1:18:42I used to actually sequence, do some MIDI sequencing
1:18:44way back in the day with like Tracker on the PC
1:18:46like in the 90s and do a little bit of DJing
1:18:49and stuff like that, but I am terrible with instruments.
1:18:53So I can't really, I'm not very good at holding a beat.
1:18:56I can blow away Guitar Hero,
1:18:59but don't ask me to play a real guitar, right?
1:19:01But my dad is a musician.
1:19:02He's very good and he can play all kinds
1:19:04of different instruments and all this stuff.
1:19:05I did not inherit it at all.
1:19:07So going into this, I was the perfect person to try this
1:19:11'cause it's like I love music
1:19:13and I know how I want it to sound,
1:19:14but I can never really get it to sound that way.
1:19:17And so when you bang on these instruments
1:19:20and we use these tools that they have in there
1:19:22to create music, their special sauce is this sort of layer
1:19:27that takes your inputs and melds them with the beat
1:19:31and tempo and other instruments and other things
1:19:34that are going on in the song already
1:19:36and slides them just a few milliseconds one way or the other
1:19:40and slots them in so that they sound beautiful.
1:19:42So it doesn't matter how discordant you try to make it,
1:19:45like you can just bang indiscriminately on the things,
1:19:47it sounds like you're really trying to make music
1:19:49and that you just made something really cool.
1:19:52That's kind of their special sauce to go with
1:19:54along with the visuals and the other stuff that they've done
1:19:57is to create this sort of, I hesitate to use the word
1:20:00'cause it's so loaded,
1:20:02but it's like an auto-tune for instruments.
1:20:04So that you can sort of go like,
1:20:07bing, bang, boom, a bang, bang, boom,
1:20:08and it's like, boom, like slides it into the beat
1:20:11and it sounds like it was meant to be there.
1:20:12- Yeah. - And this works
1:20:14with all kinds of different tempos and music and stuff.
1:20:16- Yeah, that's exactly what I mean about it
1:20:17being at least one third of the way to being more of a game
1:20:21because it does feel like if you're not good enough,
1:20:24and like me, I literally have no musical ability at all.
1:20:28There's nothing related to music that I can do.
1:20:30I can't carry a tune, I can't sing,
1:20:32I can't keep to the beat.
1:20:34And even I couldn't make it sound bad.
1:20:37Like I was trying at first to see
1:20:38if I could make it sound good,
1:20:39And then I tried to make it sound bad and even I couldn't do it, you know, so someone who can't do anything good
1:20:44Trying to be bad still couldn't get it to be off and then it would you know, I could see how it'd be a lot
1:20:50Of fun, you know
1:20:52Yeah, oh yeah, yeah so you you like I mean it's like, you know, hey
1:20:59I'm transported to this weird platform traveling through this through space right making music, you know
1:21:06And that kind of allowing somebody or I guess at its base level it's empowerment.
1:21:13And people who are in the VR scene talk about empowerment a lot because that's sort of what
1:21:17VR does is it empowers you to do things that you can't do.
1:21:22Whether that's transport yourself to another world or fly or be a really cool cyborg or
1:21:29be a musician or whatever.
1:21:32It has that feeling of transporting you and empowering you.
1:21:35And so that's what they're going after.
1:21:37I think that, you know, obviously I only had a few minutes, I thought it was really cool.
1:21:41But they're working with a lot of like professional DJs and people who are big names and are well
1:21:47respected and are masters of their craft.
1:21:50And they said that what they do have is a setting that allows them to turn off all of
1:21:56the help and just allow those guys to create music.
1:22:00So that's where the music creation thing comes in.
1:22:02There's a bunch of visual music creation tools that are in there right down to a tracker
1:22:07where you can tweak your beats like just one to the left or to the right or any of that.
1:22:12Like it actually pops up what looks like to most people like a sheet of music but is essentially
1:22:17a MIDI tracker where you could like say okay I'm gonna trigger this sound at this point
1:22:21and this sound at that point.
1:22:23That's built in.
1:22:24So if you want to get granular you can.
1:22:27Want to turn off essentially the auto aim or auto assist.
1:22:31You can.
1:22:32And so whatever sound you make happens right when you want to make it and how you want
1:22:35to make it.
1:22:36And so obviously for music pros or people who are musicians, this is a creation tool
1:22:41that is visual and physical and performance-based.
1:22:46So you could perform for somebody in VR, other people could watch you in VR, or hell, even
1:22:52in the physical world, but see the VR representation of you projected on the screen or something.
1:22:57And I could definitely see this being something that people use in concerts and in groups.
1:23:02group settings and things like that,
1:23:04versus a lot of VR, which has sort of an isolation
1:23:07aspect to it.
1:23:09But I thought that was cool,
1:23:10that you could turn off the help,
1:23:11and a real musician can go in there and make real music.
1:23:14And yet, somebody who's really bad at it,
1:23:17like you or I, can go in there and still have a lot of fun
1:23:20creating something that sounds cool,
1:23:22you know, and sounds great, and makes you feel empowered.
1:23:25- Yeah, now they just announced it.
1:23:26We got to see it a day before it was officially announced.
1:23:30So it was officially in this Electronauts app.
1:23:32It's coming in 2018, they say, so who knows how soon.
1:23:37I mean, what we saw seemed pretty, you know,
1:23:40I don't know how much else there is to do,
1:23:41but it didn't seem to have,
1:23:42the part that they showed us
1:23:43didn't really have any rough edges,
1:23:44so maybe it's coming soon.
1:23:46And to tie this back to the iMac Pro,
1:23:49it literally cannot run on any other Mac hardware.
1:23:53There's no other Mac that is capable of running this.
1:23:56And the iMac Pro is so good at running it
1:23:58that while it is cross-platform
1:24:01and it'll ship for other computing systems,
1:24:03the iMac Pro is gonna be like their recommended system
1:24:07for the app when it comes out.
1:24:08- Which is, it's a massive turnaround
1:24:13from just a couple of years ago with VR.
1:24:15- Yeah, I--
1:24:16- Or heck, even earlier this year.
1:24:18- Like, it really does seem like the takeaway for me
1:24:21is that Apple has really jumped from nowhere in VR,
1:24:25completely irrelevant,
1:24:26to completely relevant and credible
1:24:29and yeah, this is a good way to do it.
1:24:31This is a good machine to drive it,
1:24:34I guess would be a way to say it.
1:24:36And again, the machines--
1:24:37- Right, and it really puts them,
1:24:39it puts them in the game, you know, it really does.
1:24:42And I think that that was part of their effort
1:24:45on this part is to get them in that game.
1:24:47'Cause nobody really knows how this is gonna pan out,
1:24:51but almost everybody thinks that VR will have some position
1:24:55in the computing platforms of the future.
1:24:57And if that is true, then you need to have skin
1:25:00in that game.
1:25:01- Yep, and things I noticed is that even with the state
1:25:04of the art right now, you still see pixels
1:25:08in the VR display, like the, you know,
1:25:11just the limits of driving these things,
1:25:15it's like you don't get the VR equivalent of retina yet.
1:25:19Right?
1:25:20So, you know, there's still massive improvements
1:25:23resolution to come. I mean, these are the we were talking about this together Wednesday,
1:25:28but things that have to happen to get this to get VR better. Resolution has to improve dramatically,
1:25:35it needs to get to retina where you don't see pixels. latency still needs to be improved. I
1:25:40get the feeling talking to you that latency is way better than it was even just a handful of years
1:25:46ago in terms of like when you pan your head how smooth is the visual translation and it
1:25:54seems like that's a lot of what made people sick in the early days is that just the wee
1:25:58bit of latency would just make your brain say I'm sick. But latency wasn't bad. I wouldn't
1:26:05say it was bad in any of the demos we saw but it certainly wasn't photorealistic. It
1:26:10wasn't real world realistic. And again not in terms of does everything look like it's
1:26:15a real world, like I'm completely fooled into thinking I'm in a real world, but just
1:26:20the speed of the latency is just not there compared to what I see when I move my head
1:26:24around this office that I'm in right now. And it needs to be. And it will get there
1:26:29eventually. And then the third thing is it has to be wireless. And right now to get these
1:26:35experiences you've got to have the headset hooked up with a wire. And there's just
1:26:38no way that that's, you know, it has to get wireless.
1:26:44Yep, I think that encapsulates most of the major, I mean the technical underlying technical
1:26:49issues that will enable those things are a different discussion. But I think that encapsulates
1:26:54kind of where we need to be, right? It needs to be high res, it needs to be wireless, it
1:26:57needs to have zero latency. And I think there are a handful of other things that go alongside
1:27:02that, that it needs to be, you know, it needs to be lighter and user more user friendly.
1:27:08It is a little heavy. It is a little, you know, I can I can see how it's heavy enough
1:27:12that if I were a designer working on sneakers
1:27:17or working on a car, that the weight of it
1:27:20would definitely be a limiting factor
1:27:23in how long a design session could be.
1:27:26Like it's gonna get tiresome after 45 minutes, an hour.
1:27:30- Yeah, and I have spent like five or six, seven hours
1:27:36in VR at once, like in a stretch.
1:27:40And it does.
1:27:41It's honestly the larger portion of it,
1:27:44the weight you get used to in a lot of the headsets,
1:27:47especially the one that you used there was a Vive,
1:27:50this is sort of like a V2 version of it,
1:27:53which has like the rear head strap
1:27:57has like a nice tightening mechanism on it
1:27:59that the first one didn't have.
1:28:00So it sort of load balances across your head, you know?
1:28:03There's still extra weight,
1:28:05but the larger portion of it is the cable management,
1:28:06to be honest.
1:28:07Like, you know, seven hours in a headset,
1:28:09you spend a lot of time kicking cables around.
1:28:13I put a little carabiner on my cable,
1:28:14then I clip it to the back of my belt,
1:28:16like in the belt loop in the back,
1:28:18so it sort of keeps it behind me like a tail.
1:28:20But still, if you're moving around,
1:28:22especially in an application where you're sketching in 3D
1:28:25or moving around in circles, okay, bothersome.
1:28:28And so you look at those and you go,
1:28:30okay, for somebody who's gonna go to work
1:28:33and get to their desk and be like,
1:28:35okay, I'm gonna put my headset on and work today, right?
1:28:37And then work until lunch,
1:28:38that work after lunch until they quit in a headset.
1:28:41Some things have to improve, obviously,
1:28:43massively in that area.
1:28:45- Yeah, yeah, and it doesn't mean that it's not useful now.
1:28:49And it's definitely got years, many years,
1:28:51probably ahead of it before it really gets there,
1:28:54where there is like boom and explodes
1:28:56and becomes a thing for the mass market.
1:29:01But to me, it's just like every step of computers
1:29:07has that time where it's like, okay, it's good enough to be
1:29:10useful for some, but it's not going to be useful for tons of
1:29:14people yet, you know, like, what did it take for PCs to be
1:29:17something that most people would want in their house? Effectively,
1:29:20it took the internet, because it turns out that the real killer
1:29:24feature for personal computers that would make everybody want
1:29:27to have one was communication. And in the days before the
1:29:32internet, when either you couldn't communicate, you
1:29:34couldn't use a computer as communication or you had to do so esoterically through, you
1:29:39know, BBS systems and dial up modems and stuff like that. It just was no interest to people,
1:29:44you know. And so you can you can say personal computers needed X, Y and Z before they'd
1:29:50explode in the mid 90s and become this thing that every household had. But that didn't
1:29:56mean that from, you know, the late 70s through the early 90s that there weren't millions
1:30:02of us who were enthralled by them and found good uses of them and built careers on them.
1:30:07I think VR is the same way where it's sort of like right now is like a late 80s era PC.
1:30:15It's totally useful. There's people who are totally into it and either having tons of
1:30:19fun with games or doing serious, serious work, but it's not. It's like late 80s away from
1:30:26being relevant to most people.
1:30:30- Yeah, and you could see, like looking at the experiences
1:30:34of the things that happen right now,
1:30:35you could sort of see yourself in the future
1:30:37looking back and going, wow, we put that much effort
1:30:41into doing that task.
1:30:43- Right. - You know, it's like,
1:30:44you know, you look back going, what did we do
1:30:47to put numbers into a spreadsheet
1:30:48and, you know, apply operators to them?
1:30:51You know, the process of doing that,
1:30:54in the late 80s was just, it was nearly insurmountable,
1:30:59but you did it anyway, because it was still better
1:31:02than doing it on paper.
1:31:03- Right, exactly.
1:31:04- But it was certainly a chore,
1:31:06and I think that's how we'll look back at VR
1:31:08in the current state, like wow, all those wires
1:31:10and connected to a big old tower PC or Mac,
1:31:14all of this stuff, just to get a 3D world running
1:31:17in your face, because I could do that with my goggles now.
1:31:22All right, let me take one last break here and thank our third and final sponsor of the
1:31:26show. Our good friends at Casper. Casper is a sleep brand that continues to revolutionize
1:31:31its line of products to create an exceptionally comfortable sleep experience. One night at
1:31:36a time at Casper, perfect mattresses are perfectly designed for humans engineered to soothe and
1:31:42cradle your natural geometry. You spend a third of your life sleeping, so you should
1:31:48be comfortable. I personally have never even before Casper was sponsoring this podcast
1:31:53and I've been pitching their mattresses. I've long been a opponent to the theory of, wow,
1:32:01it's not worth spending a lot of money on a nice mattress because you're only you're
1:32:04sleeping. You're not enjoying it because you're asleep. I say the opposite. I say sleeping
1:32:08is some of the best. It's the best I feel most of the time and you want to wake up feeling
1:32:14great. You wake up on a nice bed, you wake up, you feel great. You start your day feeling
1:32:18great. You sleep on a crummy mattress, you wake up feeling crummy. It's I'm telling you,
1:32:23I think that mindset of, ah, put your, you know, I'll spend my money on things when I'm
1:32:26awake, not when I'm sleeping. It's nonsense. You're alive 24 hours a day. Get a good mattress.
1:32:33And the quality Casper brand mattresses combined multiple supportive memory phones for a quality
1:32:38sleep service with just the right amount of sink and bounce. You really don't have to
1:32:42spend a lot of time when you're shopping for a Casper mattress picking which type it's
1:32:46mostly down to which size. It's really great. You don't have to get into this and they have
1:32:53a no hassle return policy. Free shipping in the US and Canada. So you get it shows up.
1:33:02They call it a how did they do that sized box, you open it up in a room sucks all the
1:33:06air out of the room and then all of a sudden you got a mattress. You got like 100 days
1:33:10to sleep on it. You don't like it, they just call them up or go to the website. They'll
1:33:14I'll send someone to your house, pick it up, get it out.
1:33:17Couldn't be easier, really couldn't.
1:33:20We've got them here in the house.
1:33:22We love them, really great.
1:33:24They're just good mattresses, really, really like them.
1:33:27So here's how you do.
1:33:30Here's what you do if you're in the market
1:33:31for a new mattress.
1:33:33You can get $50 towards any mattress purchase at Casper
1:33:36by visiting casper.com/thetalkshow.
1:33:41And then remember that code, same thing as the URL,
1:33:43Talk show at checkout you plug that code into the little box
1:33:47Casper comm slash the talk show use the code the talk show and that gets you the 50 buck discount on any mattress
1:33:54Terms and conditions apply. I don't know. I don't know which terms and conditions, but they do apply
1:34:00But go check them out at Casper comm slash the talk show
1:34:04I'll tell you what the other demo at that at the iMac event or there's a couple more
1:34:13But the twin motion one really blew me away
1:34:15Twin motion is like this. I guess it's for architects type thing
1:34:22They call it a real-time visualization app
1:34:24But it more or less like if you're an architect you can like take your CAD files
1:34:28Put them into twin motion and it turns them into
1:34:31Effectively like a video game world like but with really high resolution
1:34:39They didn't demo it with VR did they at least when we were there, but I believe it does it does have a VR angle
1:34:45But it like they had what they did for the demo is they had like the
1:34:50architectural plans for an airport and they put them into 20 motion and
1:34:55It it gives you this near photo realistic rendering of the airport
1:35:01That you can move around in in 3d like a 3d shooter
1:35:05but it you know it's so you're not waiting for individual stills to render you're just moving in real time and it
1:35:13animates and it gives you and you can set the camera to different heights and
1:35:17Obviously the one that would be interesting would be like the typical height of a pair of human eyes on
1:35:22the pathway and you just get this sense of
1:35:26What would it be like to be in this airport or to be dropped off outside this airport here? I am outside the airport
1:35:33Sorry.
1:35:36It's my son.
1:35:36Hi, buddy.
1:35:41How you doing?
1:35:43Yeah.
1:35:45Wow.
1:35:45Sorry.
1:35:49Be in the airport.
1:35:51Yeah.
1:35:51Apparently not a fan of an airport.
1:35:54And it's got these you can set what season of the year it
1:35:59is, what the weather is like.
1:36:00Like, what's it going to look like when it's raining?
1:36:02What's it gonna look like at noon when the sunshine is streaming in?
1:36:06You know, what's it gonna look like at five o'clock in the winter when it the Sun is setting
1:36:11Just amazing in terms of visualizing and as somebody who to me you show me the floor plans of a house
1:36:20You know like a two-dimensional architectural drawing of the floor plans
1:36:23It's like I can get a vague sense of what it would be like to be there
1:36:27But I really it just does not my mind just does not extrapolate a two-dimensional drawing into well
1:36:33What would it actually be like to be in this room? I don't get it like
1:36:38Software like this would be phenomenal to me. Just absolutely
1:36:42Game-changing as a just as a client or you know
1:36:46You know if I was commissioning like a new office or buying a new house or something like that
1:36:51To be able to actually see it before
1:36:53You know
1:36:55construction starts at this is unbelievable.
1:36:58Yeah, I mean, the speed at which it worked was sort of the key is
1:37:05like the it's it was definitely possible to do this before, but
1:37:10definitely not at this speed. And I think it was just a
1:37:13recurring theme. And a lot of the stuff that we saw was that
1:37:15people were quoting things like this happens three, five x 10 x
1:37:19faster than we could do it before. And it was definitely
1:37:23repeated, and I think Renee mentioned this in his
1:37:25write up, but it was definitely repeated over and
1:37:27over that they were able to do things now in real
1:37:30time. You know, that took them much longer. It took
1:37:33a lot of cycles of either rendering or processing
1:37:36back and forth to accomplish. So the ability to
1:37:40take a client's model and drop it in and open it up
1:37:45and show it to them in a walkthrough and then make
1:37:47a tweak and show them the walkthrough again almost
1:37:50immediately is, you know, that's the key, right?
1:37:53That's what you want.
1:37:54And you want to be able to have that power to do that.
1:37:57And they were showing off the iMac Pro's ability to do it.
1:38:00It runs an Unreal Engine.
1:38:02It's nothing exotic, you know, on the technology front,
1:38:05but it's a very clean, very usable tool
1:38:08that allows you to, in real time,
1:38:10take a client through various weather conditions
1:38:14and even add and subtract features like trees and water
1:38:19and that sort of thing, and for them to see the results
1:38:22immediately, which is, you know, it's all about
1:38:24that feedback thing.
1:38:25And if you're in an agency setting or a design setting,
1:38:28feedback loops are the killer.
1:38:30Like that's what destroys your time and your turnaround
1:38:33and all of that.
1:38:34It's just, it's the ability to say, make a change
1:38:37and see it immediately that is invaluable in that setting.
1:38:41- Yeah, I have it in my notes here that it was literally
1:38:44that the rendering speed is five times faster
1:38:47than on the current high-end quad core i7 iMac.
1:38:51And that's the difference between doing it in real time
1:38:54at maximum quality or having to sort of stutter through it
1:38:59at high quality or go through in real time
1:39:03at a much lower visual quality.
1:39:05And they do things, they had crazy things in the app too
1:39:07where it was like you could paint trees.
1:39:10You could just get like a paintbrush and in 3D.
1:39:13So like if you had like the front of the airport,
1:39:16It's like it was just grass and they were like,
1:39:18well what if the client says,
1:39:19why can't we fill that in with trees?
1:39:21You just, you know, paint it in with trees
1:39:23and then all of a sudden the trees are there.
1:39:25So instead of like taking a note,
1:39:27render the front with trees and scheduling another meeting
1:39:30and having the client come back to see it again,
1:39:32what does it look like with trees?
1:39:33You know, you're doing it in 15, 20 seconds
1:39:37in real time right there.
1:39:39- Right.
1:39:42And that short circuits that whole loop.
1:39:45And I think that's, you know, it's money, right?
1:39:47It's money.
1:39:48You're paying your, paying people money to sit around
1:39:51and wait for feedback, and you're, you know,
1:39:53you're paying your executives to sit around
1:39:56and wait for the work to be done and all of that.
1:39:58And so it's, it really is a domino effect
1:40:02on your effectiveness and therefore your budget.
1:40:04- Yeah, that was really, that really was the recurring theme
1:40:06of the demos, was doing things in real time
1:40:09that previously either took a rendering stage
1:40:13where you'd have to go get coffee or take a break to see it.
1:40:16Or if you did it in real time,
1:40:19doing it at a lower fidelity
1:40:21and then still having to do a final render
1:40:23to get the true fidelity version of it,
1:40:26whether it was a visual thing
1:40:27or like an audio thing with Logic Pro,
1:40:30that was absolutely the recurring theme.
1:40:33And I think it's just true for all creative people
1:40:38that doing something in real time,
1:40:42makes it feel like it's waiting on your talent as opposed to when you're not working in real
1:40:46time and you feel like you're waiting on the computer.
1:40:48Yeah. And I think that that that is underrated by anybody who doesn't doesn't do it on a
1:41:01daily basis. So I think you'll get a lot of people who are commentating on the, you know,
1:41:11value of that real time nature of things or the value of the loop being short circuited
1:41:20or clipped or whatever. But I'll tell you, when you're doing creative work, and I used
1:41:25to do obviously a lot of Photoshop work when I was doing photography, and I developed a
1:41:32flow of getting your images imported into Lightroom, making broad adjustments, making
1:41:39minor adjustments, bouncing out to Photoshop to make retouching and then back to Lightroom
1:41:45and on through your process, you know, and then to export and so on and so forth. But
1:41:50I'll tell you, when you get in your flow, being able to have things happen immediately,
1:41:55it stops you from interrupting your flow. It really keeps you more productive. It keeps
1:41:59you in that zone that you get into. And for like somebody who's doing video editing or
1:42:05Doing you know audio especially things where the creative nature of the thing that you're working on
1:42:12Really feeds into that flow it
1:42:15It's a huge thing to be able to get that immediate response and feedback and not have to wait for it to do what you
1:42:22Want it to do. It's it's pretty awesome. Yeah
1:42:25I'm trying to think here the other demos we didn't talk about the cinema for d1 that would it was interesting
1:42:33but that was sort of the
1:42:35Just the most, look, this is a thing that is super computationally complex.
1:42:46Well, it's hard to gauge the impact of, right? Because they took something that was literally the level of complexity that you'd find on a feature film,
1:42:54and were adjusting the viewport and saying, "Look, this is happening!"
1:42:58But until you see how long it used to take, like physically, it's hard.
1:43:02It's hard, you know, it's hard.
1:43:03And I've seen scenes that complex,
1:43:06'cause I've done media visits at effects houses
1:43:10and things like that, and people have shown me
1:43:13literally the scenes that have gone into a blockbuster,
1:43:15and like, "Hey, I'm moving this around and showing you
1:43:17"I can change this bridge, the way this bridge explodes,"
1:43:20or whatever the case.
1:43:21And I get it, an extremely complex 3D scene
1:43:24rendered with texture and lighting
1:43:29that nearly matches one to one
1:43:31what you're gonna see on the screen,
1:43:33but being able to view that and show that
1:43:35in near real time with just a couple of minutes
1:43:38in between pretty good and fully rendered is crazy.
1:43:43It's huge and they were stacking up external GPUs
1:43:47to make that happen.
1:43:48They said they could add or subtract
1:43:50depending on the complexity of the scene.
1:43:53But to me, I mean, that's cool.
1:43:55It's just a little lower impact
1:43:56unless you're in that industry.
1:43:58Somebody in that industry would have been like,
1:44:00"Holy shit."
1:44:00but for us it's just like, oh, well, that's cool.
1:44:04But I also believe that it truly will, in the end,
1:44:08it'll improve or expand the ability and options
1:44:13of artists in that industry, because as you and I both know,
1:44:19the moment you expand computing capability,
1:44:22people's desires and ambitions expand to fill app.
1:44:28So once you're able to stack two or three or four
1:44:31or five external GPUs onto these Thunderbolt ports
1:44:35and access all that compute power
1:44:37so to render these frames, people will go,
1:44:39"Hey, my scenes can get two or three or four more times
1:44:42"more complex and more detailed."
1:44:44- It did seem like their role in the demo rotation
1:44:47was to be that that was the one that used external GPUs
1:44:52plugged in via Thunderbolt 3 and to show that,
1:44:55hey, they had two of them or at least two boxes,
1:44:57knows how many GPUs were in those boxes. But, you know, it was again, it was sort of hard
1:45:05because they it almost was the one that I think would have most benefited from having
1:45:09like some other Mac, either a, you know, the highest end Mac Pro or iMac, regular iMac
1:45:17or something side by side to show just how much faster it was. But the guys from Cinema
1:45:24D were very excited about the performance that they were getting. Another demo they had,
1:45:31what else was there? There was Adobe Dimension, which is an app I'd never even heard of before,
1:45:34because I'm sort of just out of that world. But very cool app. It's basically a 3D rendering for
1:45:43regular graphic designers, where let's say the example that they had was the graphic design for
1:45:50a bag of potato chips. So you're doing it as an Illustrator file in two dimensions that
1:45:56shows what the bag of potato chips would look like coming off the printer as a two-dimensional
1:46:04sheet of foil. And then you move it into dimension and all of a sudden it's a three-dimensional
1:46:11bag of potato chips that's sealed up, has the crimp at the top, and you can apply different
1:46:16lighting effects and get a truly photo-realistic rendering of what it would look like as a
1:46:22real package. And that was the one I thought was pretty interesting that the Adobe's thing
1:46:30is CPU bound, not GPU bound, although they did say that they were looking at moving some
1:46:36of it to GPU. But that was one that the more cores you throw at it, the faster the renderings
1:46:42would be.
1:46:44Right. And I think they were emphasizing too that not every application would benefit from
1:46:52more cores. And I think that this has been a constant debate as multi, as hyper-threading
1:46:57and multi-core processors have gotten more common over the last decade. People often
1:47:02judge performance very differently based on the kind of applications that they're throwing
1:47:07at these things. And the more is not always better debate is like a prime example. This
1:47:13This scenario is a prime example of that.
1:47:15An 18-core processor may not actually be all that great
1:47:19for somebody who's doing something that requires
1:47:21a single thread at a high frequency.
1:47:24In the case of a render pipeline, though,
1:47:26when you can assign multiple tasks to different cores
1:47:30and be intelligent about it, it can be very helpful
1:47:33to have those additional cores.
1:47:34- Yeah, Adobe's, the Adobe rep said that
1:47:37their scale's linearly, so you really do,
1:47:40every time you add a core, you get increased performance.
1:47:43Thought it was pretty interesting.
1:47:45And then the last demo, or I guess the other two
1:47:47that were from Apple itself, and they had an Xcode demo,
1:47:50or a developer demo, really, 'cause they emphasized
1:47:53that they know that Macs are super popular with developers,
1:47:55but they also know that developer, quote, unquote,
1:47:57developer doesn't just mean people writing iOS
1:48:00and Mac applications.
1:48:02The statistic they quoted was that 60%
1:48:05of all GitHub developer activity is done from a Mac,
1:48:09that they worked with GitHub to get these stats.
1:48:12And that means all sorts of stuff
1:48:14that purely runs on the web and that sort of stuff.
1:48:18So that's pretty incredible given the Mac's
1:48:20overall market share that it's up to 60%
1:48:22of all GitHub developer activity.
1:48:24So what'd they demo?
1:48:26They demoed three iOS simulators running at once,
1:48:29which is not something that you could do before.
1:48:33Like you'd only have like one iOS develop,
1:48:37simulator running at a time.
1:48:38What'd they have?
1:48:39two iPhones and an iPad running all the same time on screen, running a bunch of automated
1:48:44tests in the simulator to test the app. A couple of VMware, I think it was VMware they
1:48:52were using, but VMware virtual machines, one of them running Linux that was like compiling
1:48:59a bunch of software from scratch, like an Apache PHP sort of environment. Another VMware
1:49:08instance running Windows 10 and they even joked that out you know when's the
1:49:13last time you saw Apple running Windows in a product demo running Chrome which
1:49:19is not known as a you know performance you know something that's light on the
1:49:25CPU so running a bunch of automated automated client-side tests of a web app
1:49:32in Chrome, in Windows, in a VM, while in a terminal window on the Mac itself, they were
1:49:40using Brew to install like a ton of data script installing and compiling from scratch a ton
1:49:48of software for the Mac itself.
1:49:51Yeah, compiling a Linux install from source.
1:49:54Right.
1:49:55Essentially.
1:49:56Yeah.
1:49:57So, you know, all and all of that running at once. And again, I went behind the machine
1:50:03while it was still running, put my hand there and there's no, you know, wasn't like a hair
1:50:06dryer blowing out the back. So, you know, very impressive. And I really do think that
1:50:13was a huge part of the message. You know, I think that's why one of the people who got,
1:50:17you know, to go back to earlier in the show and who got seated with these things a week
1:50:20in advance, why did David Hahnemeyer Hansen, you know, the create co creator of Rails and
1:50:27Basecamp, not really like an iOS developer type person, but they gave one to him and
1:50:34I think he's a very popular individual in that sort of open source web development world.
1:50:42To say, "Yeah, this is a machine for us."
1:50:46- Mm-hmm, yep, and I think that's the goal,
1:50:51is they wanted to capture a spread
1:50:54and to make sure that they didn't pigeonhole
1:50:59the messaging or use, because there is an appetite,
1:51:04a voracious appetite for a more powerful Mac
1:51:09from a lot of different vectors, not just one.
1:51:14And I think that's so important to remember for a lot of people, and it's definitely something
1:51:19that Apple is cognizant of.
1:51:21Frankly, people like the Mac, they like the software that runs on it, they like the environment,
1:51:26they like the fact that people who build applications for it give a crap, unlike Windows.
1:51:31Sorry, but it's true.
1:51:33The Windows Developer System is anemic by comparison, whether you like Windows or not,
1:51:40it's hard to argue that.
1:51:42And they like all of those aspects of it.
1:51:44What they don't like is it being underpowered in relation.
1:51:48And honestly, the cost is one way to look at it.
1:51:52And I think you could look at the cost and some people would say, "Oh, I could build
1:51:55it cheaper."
1:51:56But those people are fine giving up all of the finesse touches, the high security aspects
1:52:02of the T2, the screen being the best on the market, et cetera, et cetera.
1:52:09and they go like, oh well, raw power,
1:52:11I can build it cheaper, whatever.
1:52:13But the people that appreciate those details
1:52:16and need or want them, people in the industries
1:52:20where color correct screens matter a hell of a lot
1:52:24and where screen real estate matters a heck of a lot,
1:52:27those arenas want more power
1:52:31and they are sick of it being underpowered.
1:52:34So I think that they're addressing those aspects of it
1:52:37pretty well with the iMac Pro.
1:52:39- Yeah, and for, you know, there's certain,
1:52:41it does all kind of flow together, you know,
1:52:44in the Apple product ecosystem,
1:52:48but where if you're editing
1:52:525K video with the, what's the extra color depth?
1:53:00- The P3 color space?
1:53:01- Yeah, the P3 color stuff.
1:53:03And you're editing it in Final Cut Pro on an iMac,
1:53:06and then you go and show it to somebody else
1:53:11on an iPad Pro, it looks exactly the same.
1:53:15There's no, you don't need to worry about that.
1:53:20And somebody who's really trying to sweat the details
1:53:22on the exact color grading that you're getting out of this
1:53:25and applying to the source footage,
1:53:28if somebody else is looking at it on an iPad Pro
1:53:33or on their MacBook Pro or something like that,
1:53:36it's going to look the same.
1:53:38And that's just huge for a professional environment.
1:53:42- Yep, exactly.
1:53:43And people that aren't in that industry
1:53:46are in those industries where you've got a high pressure
1:53:51delivery time situation and you need your color correction
1:53:56to show up perfectly on an iPad Pro
1:54:00that you hand somebody for approval
1:54:02as the same as it did on your 5K iMac screen,
1:54:05and they're not gonna get it.
1:54:06But the people that do get it, they're like, finally.
1:54:10Finally I can do that.
1:54:11- So the last thing I wanna talk about
1:54:15was is the future of this.
1:54:17And it's like I wrote in my piece,
1:54:20well, these machines are clearly great,
1:54:23and I think they're a solid value,
1:54:25and they're super useful right now today.
1:54:27But you could say the same thing in 2013
1:54:29when the Trashcan Mac Pros shipped,
1:54:31these are super impressive pieces of engineering. It's obvious that Apple put a lot of work and
1:54:37thought into it, and then they never updated it. And, you know, for these things to really put
1:54:44Apple back in the game as a company that provides truly world class workstation hardware for people,
1:54:50you know, like across the board, developers, designers, 3d people, VR people, it's not enough
1:54:57just to come out with one round of IMAX in December of 2017. And Apple's never going
1:55:04to update them every three months like the way that the component PC industry, as soon
1:55:10as new stuff comes out, you can just custom configured into a box and then just get it
1:55:15there. It's not like they're going to update every three months, but they need to update
1:55:18like at least roughly every year. And that never happened with the Mac Pro. And I think
1:55:25The reasonable concern people would have is,
1:55:27do you wanna make an investment in this platform?
1:55:29Having to hope or trust, I guess,
1:55:35that Apple is going to remain committed to it.
1:55:37- Yep, and the pacing of the industries
1:55:43that they're trying to target with this
1:55:45definitely remains a concern and a big issue.
1:55:48If you are looking at VR,
1:55:50the machines that were running VR at top spec two years ago
1:55:54who are not the same machines as today.
1:55:57And you would see a significant degradation
1:55:59in your ability to develop for those platforms
1:56:01or run them as a consumer if you made a bet
1:56:05on something that was not able to advance along with it.
1:56:08So if they are planting a flag in the VR industry,
1:56:13are they going to have that same position in two years
1:56:16if the iMac Pro is not updated?
1:56:18- Right, and I think, and the concern that people have,
1:56:22and you know, I don't think it's unreasonable is that Apple let the Mac Pro languish,
1:56:29maybe not because they completely lost interest in it, but like that they made some bad bets on
1:56:36where things were going underestimated the importance of, you know, GPUs in 2013. I mean,
1:56:44they more or less said this to us last April, you know, when we talked to Federighi and Schiller,
1:56:49you know, Fedor E even said, you know, that they painted themselves into a thermal corner.
1:56:53I believe that's a direct quote, but if not, it's super, super close.
1:56:56So it wasn't like they completely lost interest. It was like they found themselves painted into
1:57:03a corner. But the reasonable expectation that people can have is they're never going to let
1:57:06that happen. Even if they make a mistake with the iPhone, it's too important to them and they
1:57:11make too much money. They'll pay whatever it costs to correct the mistake year after year.
1:57:18you know, and that the Mac being a less of a financial revenue generator for the company
1:57:26means that you you're at the risk that that they're something else is going to take their
1:57:31attention away from from these products. I think, you know, I feel like we have to wait and see,
1:57:37but I feel like they're in a better spot and that the this these Mac iMac pros aren't going to find
1:57:44themselves in that trap that the Mac Pro did because I feel like they're they're clearly
1:57:49oriented towards the future that they are already very very strongly geared towards
1:57:57GPU intensive computing. I really do feel like that's the case and I feel like what happened
1:58:04they made a bad bet with the design of the Mac Pro in 2013. They're correcting it now and I feel
1:58:09like whatever they're going to come up with is going to be built for the future and they'll have
1:58:13that configurable box for pros that you can do what you want inside the box, built for
1:58:21the future.
1:58:22And I feel like we've never had an iMac Pro before because this is really the earliest
1:58:26that they could do it, that they couldn't make a machine that you would think of as
1:58:29an iMac in terms of form that would have the performance characteristics of a high-end
1:58:34workstation until now.
1:58:36Yeah, I mean, the talk about thermals was interesting because I think this has something
1:58:42like 67 percent more cooling in it than the previous IMAX.
1:58:47Yeah, I think that's exactly right.
1:58:49They doubled the amount of fans on it, all of that jazz.
1:58:54So they were very concerned about keeping it cool and keeping the performance high.
1:58:57And yet, as you mentioned, even though they were really powering through stuff, it really
1:59:02didn't seem like it was being taxed or getting all that hot or outgassing a ton of hot air
1:59:08or anything.
1:59:09So that to me, the amount of power that's in those machines, given the amount of heat
1:59:14that's coming out of them right now, I think they built in a lot of overhead in the cooling.
1:59:19So I think that given that we saw the stuff that was going on with those, all the applications
1:59:24that were pushing those Macs, they weren't getting very hot.
1:59:27The fans weren't going crazy.
1:59:29I think that the current amount of power in them has some overhead as far as the thermals
1:59:34go.
1:59:35In other words, I think they learned their lesson a bit and have built in a little bit
1:59:37of future proofing.
1:59:38I think we're gonna see more power come out of this current
1:59:40iMac casing before maybe they redesign the whole thing.
1:59:44- Yeah, I do too.
1:59:45And I do feel, you know, sometimes failure
1:59:50is the best teacher, you know, and I feel like
1:59:52they're not trying to sweep the 2013 Mac Pro under the rug.
1:59:57It's like I really do feel like they've learned from it.
2:00:00I really do feel like they're not just paying lip service
2:00:02to yes, we love the professional market,
2:00:06and we really do wanna build machines that make them happy,
2:00:09I really do feel like they mean it,
2:00:12and that this is the first tangible sign of that
2:00:16in quite a long time.
2:00:18- Yeah, yeah, I mean, it's easy to get disheartened
2:00:25if you don't see your concerns being addressed
2:00:28or you feel that a whole segment that you belong to
2:00:31is being overlooked, so I think they're doing what they can
2:00:34to sort of counter the messaging
2:00:37and then also deliver some real applicable hardware
2:00:42to a good segment of the market
2:00:44that's been feeling like they've had to make do
2:00:46with whatever they've got.
2:00:47- Yeah, and I don't wanna get into
2:00:49a systems architecture lesson
2:00:51'cause I'm not fit to lecture it,
2:00:54but it really is clear just at the high level
2:00:57and what you hear from them that this is absolutely,
2:01:00this is a lot like modern day Apple
2:01:02is like a head to toe systems maker.
2:01:07Like they're not, this iMac is not some kind of box
2:01:09where there's a, oh we just took this CPU from Intel
2:01:13and we took these graphic cards from Radeon
2:01:16and RAM from whatever company and we just stick 'em all
2:01:20in the back of a display and that's it.
2:01:22Like this thing is in a lot of ways like an iOS device,
2:01:27like an iPhone in terms of being all of these parts
2:01:30are custom designed to fit together.
2:01:32And the best example of it, I don't think you and I really
2:01:34talked about it much.
2:01:35I know you mentioned it.
2:01:36But this T2 chip, the T1 is the system
2:01:41on a chip in the MacBook Pros with the touch bar.
2:01:44And the T2 chip is running on the iMac.
2:01:47Now, the iMac doesn't have any kind of face ID or touch ID,
2:01:51so there's no biometrics.
2:01:53But it does have a secure enclave.
2:01:55It is effectively an iOS, a little miniature iOS computer
2:01:59running in there.
2:02:01But the thing that was most interesting to me is the way that the t2
2:02:03handles the
2:02:06It's the it's the it's the flash controller for the SSD
2:02:12So the controller that handles the reads and writes is no longer on the actual SSDs. It's on the t2 chip
2:02:19Which among other things like the benefit of this is that it handles all the security
2:02:25So all rights to the SSD all rights are encrypted
2:02:29Whether you have out of the box out of the box
2:02:31There's no way around it and and it's one of the ways that like when I wrote about it
2:02:35Like this systems couldn't run a spinning hard disk, even if Apple wanted to there's no way internally
2:02:40You can obviously plug one in by you know
2:02:44USB or whatever
2:02:46But internally it can't even run an H spinning hard disk. It's SSD only
2:02:51They're encrypted out of the box whether you're using file vault or not and it
2:02:57It doesn't use the CPU.
2:03:02The T2 chip handles with a dedicated AES encryption/decryption chip, handles it so
2:03:09that the encrypted/decrypted reads and writes are at 100% performance of the SSD.
2:03:16They happen faster than the SSD can read or write, so you still get 100% performance even
2:03:22though it's all encrypted.
2:03:23Right.
2:03:24with zero performance hit, which is up until this point,
2:03:28you always had to say, look, I'm gonna turn on FileVault,
2:03:30but I know I'm gonna take a little bit of a performance hit,
2:03:33a performance overhead on my CPU in order to do this.
2:03:37And most people were okay with that,
2:03:39that are security minded,
2:03:40but now you get it for quote, unquote, free.
2:03:43- Right, it's sort of, honestly, to make an analogy,
2:03:46it's like the convenience hit you take
2:03:48by locking the doors to your house,
2:03:50and you have to come up, and now when you go in your house,
2:03:53you have to take a key out and put a key in a lock and twist it and then turn the doorknob.
2:03:57Most people who I know accept that and lock their house when they leave, even though it
2:04:03would be easier if you could just walk up. It's the equivalent of just being able to
2:04:08walk. Your house is locked, but it authenticates who you are. You just walk up, turn the doorknob,
2:04:12and go in. You get all the benefits and none of the hits. But that means if you took the
2:04:17SSD modules out of the iMac, you couldn't read or write them once they're unpaired with
2:04:22T2 chip. So the question I have, I wish I would have asked it, I don't know what the
2:04:25answer is, is what's even the benefit of FileVault now as opposed to just putting a
2:04:29firmware hard password on the iMac Pro itself? Because the reason why it's always
2:04:36in luck, because I asked and you probably weren't listening. Oh, did you really?
2:04:40Yeah, I did. Well, this is why I had you on the show. Actually, hold on, let me
2:04:47me buy I think my notebooks right here so I asked that because I had the same
2:04:51thought like okay well so everything's encrypted if you if somebody managed to
2:04:56like grab your machine and take it apart you know the SSD will not function
2:05:01separately from that t2 or whatever so if you if it was to get scrapped you
2:05:05know or whatever the case may be couldn't read it so I asked what the
2:05:10deal what is the deal with fireball is what I asked them and basically they
2:05:15I said that it handled different cases because,
2:05:19let's say for instance, you were to put the machine
2:05:21at the target disk mode, FileVault would require
2:05:24that you had your user password as well,
2:05:27as the system being on and active.
2:05:30Whereas if you were to put it in target disk mode,
2:05:33the T2 would see that as a legitimate read request
2:05:36or write request, and it would handle that interaction
2:05:40'cause it's at the very base level of the system.
2:05:43So you're getting encrypted read-writes from the T2, but the FileVault adds an additional
2:05:47layer of security by injecting your user key into the encryption pipeline.
2:05:52So you have an additional kind of layer of, "This is me, and I authorize this."
2:05:58Whereas the T2 is not really involved with identity at all.
2:06:02It's just saying this machine is secure from external read-write attempts, things like
2:06:06that.
2:06:07you are in the official pipeline of a read-write,
2:06:12the T2 is gonna facilitate it.
2:06:14It's gonna say, "Sure, no problem, absolutely."
2:06:17But the FileVault is sort of an additional lock on that
2:06:20that is like, "Hey, not just anybody that has access
2:06:23"to this machine, but me specifically,
2:06:26"I authorize this to be read and written to."
2:06:30- All right, there we go.
2:06:31Well, that sounds like a show to me.
2:06:34That's exactly, I can't believe that my question
2:06:36actually in your notebook. That's so great. Matthew Panzer, you thank you for
2:06:41returning to the show. It was good to see you this week. Everybody can follow you
2:06:46on Twitter at @Panzer, P-A-N-Z-E-R, and they can read your excellent work and the
2:06:54work of your fine staff at techcrunch.com every day.
2:06:59Yes sir, thank you. Hey, have a good weekend. May the force be with you.