Podcast Search

The Talk Show

201: ‘Much More Smarter’ With Matthew Panzarino

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00So we spent pretty much the whole beginning of the week together.

0:00:04And it started, we had a wonderful dinner on Monday night with our mutual friend Michael

0:00:10Lop, where you two wanted to talk entirely about Destiny 2, but all I wanted to talk

0:00:17about is how is Apple going to pronounce the X in the name iPhone X, because the name had

0:00:21leaked.

0:00:23The name had leaked, and we had one and only one reason why they might call it iPhone X,

0:00:29which was that we're 10 years away from the original iPhone.

0:00:32And we came up with a list of like 15 good reasons

0:00:35why they would pronounce it iPhone X.

0:00:40And we just left the dinner like,

0:00:41well, that's a settled deal.

0:00:43It'll be iPhone X.

0:00:45And then I stayed in the city, could not get a hotel.

0:00:49It's bizarre that I could not get a hotel near Cupertino.

0:00:54So I just stayed in the city and you swung by kindly

0:00:56and picked me up the morning of the event.

0:00:58and we drove down and as we're driving

0:01:00from San Francisco to Cupertino,

0:01:02I said, "You know what, I'm gonna write that up."

0:01:05And right there in the front seat of Matthew's car,

0:01:08I wrote the article I headlined X-Man,

0:01:12explaining exactly and predicting,

0:01:16only an hour before the event,

0:01:17hour, two hours before the event,

0:01:18exactly why I thought they were gonna call it iPhone X.

0:01:21(laughing)

0:01:23Well, it turned out--

0:01:25- And you know, I was there to be the voice of reason

0:01:28And I just didn't speak up.

0:01:29(laughs)

0:01:30Honestly, I bought in though.

0:01:31I bought into your reasoning.

0:01:32- No, we were all convinced.

0:01:35I was the one who started Dinner Convinced

0:01:37and you and Michael were both like,

0:01:39I could see it both ways.

0:01:40And by the end of it,

0:01:41and half of the reasons I came up with,

0:01:43I stole from you and Michael.

0:01:44(laughs)

0:01:45Like it wasn't just even my reasons.

0:01:47Like, I'll take the heat for it,

0:01:49but quite frankly, it should have been like--

0:01:51- Crowd sourced.

0:01:52- It should have been a three byline article.

0:01:54Me, you and Michael Lop.

0:01:56eating prime rib, deciding it was ugly.

0:02:00- Oh my God, now I'm hungry.

0:02:02Yeah, I still am fine with it.

0:02:05I'm fine with the logic behind the reasons.

0:02:09But I think in the end,

0:02:10I told somebody this the other day about something different.

0:02:13It was something, some of the decision that Apple had made

0:02:16or was going to make or whatever.

0:02:17I said, you know, in the end,

0:02:19there can be like lots of logical reasons

0:02:21why X or Y or Z would be the choice that they would make,

0:02:26But when it boils down to it, if you go back,

0:02:30write up a scorecard of all the decisions they've ever made

0:02:33and all of the things, all of the pre-thinking

0:02:36that everybody put into, oh, what will they do?

0:02:37What will they do?

0:02:38In the end, they typically do the most,

0:02:40absolutely the most obvious thing.

0:02:43The most obvious thing is the thing that they do

0:02:45because they're working at such enormous scale.

0:02:48That's what makes sense typically.

0:02:50So iPhone X, just, yeah, the other one was iPhone 8.

0:02:53Why wouldn't we call this iPhone X?

0:02:55That's just like logical.

0:02:57- So I will say this, I ran into Phil Schiller

0:02:59after the event and the first thing he said to me was,

0:03:03"Hey John, sorry about the 10 thing."

0:03:06(laughing)

0:03:09Which blew my mind because I literally published it

0:03:12like 90 minutes before the thing.

0:03:14So how could he possibly have been aware of it?

0:03:17'Cause you'd think he would be like in like

0:03:19concentration mode.

0:03:20- A little busy, you would think.

0:03:23- And he laughed and I laughed.

0:03:24And then all he said was,

0:03:26"We spent a lot of time on the name."

0:03:27(laughing)

0:03:30- And ended up back at one.

0:03:32- Right, I think you're exactly right.

0:03:34I feel like they probably did spend a lot of time

0:03:37and they ended up at the most obvious thing possible.

0:03:40- Yeah.

0:03:42- So the other--

0:03:42- It was pretty good.

0:03:44So yeah, you published it and we go,

0:03:45we're so harried.

0:03:46I mean, you and I are harried.

0:03:48- Right, right.

0:03:49- Trying to find the place and get in,

0:03:51'cause it's brand new.

0:03:53We're running into a literal blockade

0:03:55'cause they had blocked an entire street off.

0:03:57And I got a rash of crap from Apple people

0:04:02about using Waze instead of Apple Maps

0:04:04'cause they said that Apple Maps

0:04:05would have directed me appropriately.

0:04:08- This is too good of a story.

0:04:09So we've plugged the address in.

0:04:12And you and I both, when you get an invitation

0:04:15to one of these events, somebody in Apple PR emails you.

0:04:20There's somebody who's like your point person

0:04:23and your, hey, if you have any questions,

0:04:25contact me person, and it varies by event,

0:04:28but that way everybody's taken care of,

0:04:29and there's tons, I don't know how many people,

0:04:32there are in Apple PR, but there's,

0:04:33it's, you know, a pretty large group.

0:04:35And you and I both had emails that seemed to imply

0:04:41an unusual amount of familiarity.

0:04:43It was just like, hey, we'll see you there.

0:04:46You've got briefings the next day after the event,

0:04:50or after the event at 11.15,

0:04:53and we'll meet you at the cafe.

0:04:55And it's like, well, where's the cafe?

0:04:57- Oh yes, the cafe, got it.

0:04:59- I have no idea.

0:05:00It just implied an unusual amount of familiarity

0:05:03with a campus that we obviously have no familiarity with,

0:05:06but they did give us a street address,

0:05:08and you plugged it into Waze, and we're going there,

0:05:11and like you said, literally they had the street closed.

0:05:17And it was obvious that it was Apple people

0:05:20who had closed it, they're there manning it.

0:05:22And we're looking at the--

0:05:23- It was a mixture of people,

0:05:24but some of them were definitely wearing that like,

0:05:27white shirt, black pant, Apple security,

0:05:30traffic control uniform.

0:05:32- And from within the car, we gave like a,

0:05:34"Hey, what do we do?"

0:05:36And there was a woman who gave us sort of a,

0:05:38"You can either go left or right."

0:05:39And so we made a right, and next thing you know,

0:05:42we're like--

0:05:43- It was like, it was the "Wildly Coyote" thing.

0:05:44like the two arms crossed pointing either direction,

0:05:49like Alice in Wonderland, gesture cat, you can go this way.

0:05:53So we made a choice.

0:05:55- And we ended up behind, it was not the main building,

0:05:59it's some of these peripheral buildings

0:06:02that it's obviously part of the campus,

0:06:03obviously new construction,

0:06:05and the ones we were behind were obviously unfinished.

0:06:08It was these buildings that run finished.

0:06:09There was a garage back there,

0:06:11But we were 100% certain that this is not

0:06:14where we were supposed to go.

0:06:16And so we both made some text, placed some text

0:06:18to PR people, like, hey, what are we supposed to do?

0:06:22So we got a call from Apple PR, and they were like,

0:06:26you gotta go around the block.

0:06:28And they were like, what are you using, Google Maps?

0:06:30And I thought it was a joke from Apple.

0:06:32I thought it was like, oh, that's just the type of joke

0:06:35Apple would make. - Like, aha,

0:06:36yeah, what are you using, Google Maps, get real.

0:06:38- Yeah, but the truth is that Apple had seeded,

0:06:43I guess in some way, Apple Maps,

0:06:45with where if you plugged the address that they gave us in,

0:06:49it was like 10600 Tantal Drive,

0:06:52it would give you the exact right directions to get there.

0:06:55And Google Maps literally led you right into the blockade.

0:07:00So it really was the truth.

0:07:02And it kind of reveals the thinking at Apple

0:07:04where they're so on, you know,

0:07:08it just didn't even occur to them

0:07:10that people wouldn't be using Apple Maps.

0:07:13- Right, right.

0:07:14Like why are you lost?

0:07:16Obviously you're using our first party mapping application

0:07:19we spent billions of dollars to develop.

0:07:21I mean why wouldn't you?

0:07:22- Right, and that we literally spent time

0:07:24before the event like routing people around it.

0:07:27'Cause you and I went back the next day

0:07:29and the next day even Apple Maps led us that way.

0:07:32Like they literally seemingly on the day of the event,

0:07:35they changed Apple Maps driving directions

0:07:37to get you around the street blockade

0:07:39that they set up for one day.

0:07:40- To make sure everybody ended up on the right side

0:07:42of the blockade to get directions

0:07:43and park appropriately and all that, which was fine.

0:07:45We literally had to go around Apple Park.

0:07:47We drove around the perimeter of Apple Park

0:07:49and ended up in the right spot.

0:07:51But it was just one of those things where you go,

0:07:53oh yeah, they make the map.

0:07:54They can just make the map point wherever they want.

0:07:56- Right, so literally instead of like sending us

0:07:59those explicit directions in the email,

0:08:01they just presumed that we'd be using Apple Maps

0:08:04and they just put it into Apple Maps,

0:08:05which I found incredibly amusing.

0:08:08- Yeah, and I just got razzed by it the entire day,

0:08:14'cause apparently they shared the information with everybody.

0:08:19The person I texted shared it with the whole PR team

0:08:22and everybody was very aware that I was using

0:08:24a Google product to try and navigate my way to Apple Park.

0:08:28- Right, every single person at Apple PR

0:08:30who came up to you the rest of the day was like,

0:08:32what's wrong with you, why do you use Google Maps?

0:08:35(laughing)

0:08:36- I'm sure we're right up the chain.

0:08:38- Right, their back channel must be, is quite efficient.

0:08:42- Right, yep.

0:08:46- All right, so we do get there.

0:08:49And it's effectively where they wanted us to park

0:08:53was at the new visitor center.

0:08:54And the visitor center is across a street

0:08:57from the block where the main building is, the ring.

0:09:02And the Steve Jobs Theater is also across that same street,

0:09:07but it is wholly separate.

0:09:10I mean, it's quite a distance from the main building.

0:09:14So-- - Yeah, the Steve Jobs Theater

0:09:16is inside the fence of the compound.

0:09:21- Right. - You know, where Apple,

0:09:22it's in Apple Park, right?

0:09:24If you wanna call Apple Park

0:09:25the literal park land that they built.

0:09:27And then the visitor center is across a small,

0:09:31but street that separates that park

0:09:35from ancillary buildings.

0:09:37- Right.

0:09:38So it's fundamentally a different layout

0:09:44than Infinite Loop was, where there's now a store

0:09:48at Infinite Loop.

0:09:49There was always sort of a company store,

0:09:51but it wasn't really, it was different than the Apple store,

0:09:53but now it's like a real Apple store.

0:09:55But the Apple store-- - That Apple park, right.

0:09:58- Well, no, but the old campus at Infinite Loop,

0:10:00the store is literally in-- - Oh, right, yes.

0:10:03The company store, right.

0:10:04- Yeah, it's in and always was in one of the buildings.

0:10:08Like if you went to Infinite Loop,

0:10:10the old campus, you wanted to see it,

0:10:12you were there in a building.

0:10:14I mean, obviously, there's no back door of the store

0:10:17where you could go into a secure area.

0:10:19It's only like from the sidewalk,

0:10:21It's like parking lot sidewalk, now you're in the store.

0:10:24But you were fundamentally in a building full of,

0:10:27where there were Apple employees above you

0:10:29secretly working on Apple stuff.

0:10:31Whereas now the visitor center is, it's contained.

0:10:36- It's separated by an asphalt moat

0:10:39from anywhere that work is being done.

0:10:41- Right, there is no chance of contamination.

0:10:44And even with the press--

0:10:46- I wonder if they'll close the other one.

0:10:48I wonder if they'll close the other store.

0:10:49- I don't know, that's a very good question.

0:10:51I would guess that they will.

0:10:53- 'Cause this store is nice, it's a broad open layout

0:10:56with the tall glass walls, just like a new Design Apple store

0:11:01and the other one is not, you know,

0:11:02they kind of updated it recently, but not,

0:11:04it's not a crazy update.

0:11:05- Yeah, I think that they probably will, right?

0:11:07But maybe they'll keep 'em both open for a bit,

0:11:10but I would guess that they'll close the other one

0:11:12and sort of, it's a good question,

0:11:17'Cause they're obviously, Infinite Loop is staying occupied.

0:11:20They need all of the space.

0:11:22- Oh yeah.

0:11:24Yeah, they're already full, yeah.

0:11:26- They're not moving from Infinite Loop to Apple Park.

0:11:30They're just sort of like,

0:11:31they're like bulged into their current office space

0:11:35and they're just sort of like, let out the excess.

0:11:37- Doubling up on desks and stuff, yeah.

0:11:40- I would guess that they will close the store

0:11:42at Infinite Loop.

0:11:43I don't know though, that's a good question.

0:11:46- It's definitely, and even with the press too.

0:11:49So it's A, just the random riffraff who want to pay homage

0:11:53and come to Apple's headquarters and buy some T-shirts.

0:11:56You are not really in the real building now.

0:12:01It is an entirely self-contained building,

0:12:03like you said, across an asphalt moat.

0:12:05And even the theater, even the press,

0:12:07are no longer like in the compound.

0:12:11Like you can't complain about the theater.

0:12:14And we can talk about it in detail.

0:12:15The theater is exquisite and it is nice,

0:12:18but it is absolutely, positively not

0:12:21you know, near the main building.

0:12:25- No, it's the standing at the theater

0:12:28and looking towards the main building

0:12:30is the equivalent of looking across

0:12:33probably a football field's worth of grass and rolling.

0:12:38- I would say even--

0:12:39- Or just freshly seeded grass.

0:12:41- I would say--

0:12:42- Yeah, probably a couple of football fields, right?

0:12:43- Yeah, I think it's like a par four, yeah.

0:12:45It's at least like three or four hundred yards.

0:12:48- Right, it is.

0:12:50And it's still massive at that distance,

0:12:52which says something about the scale of the building.

0:12:54- Yeah, and it is true, like the way that we drove in

0:12:57where we got turned around at this blockade

0:12:59and had to go around, effectively what we had to do

0:13:01is drive all the way around the Apple Park,

0:13:04all the way around.

0:13:06And the Vantage, you know it's a big building.

0:13:11Everybody knows it's a big building,

0:13:12But it's really kind of stunning driving right by it,

0:13:17just how massive it is.

0:13:18It really, it's just,

0:13:21whether you like the way it looks or not,

0:13:24it's truly magnificent in terms of just the scale of it.

0:13:28- Right, and I think we're used to seeing

0:13:31a lot of buildings that are vertical,

0:13:33especially in the city, right?

0:13:35So you're next to a big building in New York

0:13:38or even downtown San Francisco or whatever,

0:13:41and you look straight up and you're like,

0:13:42"Wow, look at that, it's a skyscraper, it's really tall."

0:13:45I mean, Seals Force Tower in San Francisco is enormous,

0:13:47it dominates the skyline now.

0:13:49But this is a different kind of scale

0:13:52because it's so broad and massive.

0:13:55It's just like, there's a lot of mass there,

0:13:57it's very broad, and something with a circular nature of it

0:14:00when you're up next to it, like when we're driving next to it

0:14:03and looking to our left at a point at which

0:14:05it was fairly close to the street, you know,

0:14:09'cause it kind of grazes the street

0:14:10on a couple of dimensions.

0:14:12and when you look that way, it curves away into the distance

0:14:15like it's heading towards the horizon.

0:14:17- Right.

0:14:18- The curve almost gives you a greater sense of size

0:14:22and scale than if it's a squared off corner.

0:14:25You're like, oh, that's where it ends.

0:14:26- Yeah.

0:14:27- There's literally no end in sight.

0:14:28- I don't know what to compare it to

0:14:30'cause I've never seen a building,

0:14:32I've never seen anything like it.

0:14:34I really haven't.

0:14:34I've seen many towers.

0:14:35- It's kind of like Epcot.

0:14:37Like when you get close to Epcot maybe

0:14:39or something like that, one of those types of buildings

0:14:41where it's a themed building that's built specifically

0:14:44to be massive.

0:14:45- I don't know, it's just so, it really seems almost,

0:14:48it's so, I've thought of this before,

0:14:51but now having seen it in person, it is,

0:14:55it's so funny that the old campus was named Infinite Loop,

0:14:59which is a programming pun, but my God,

0:15:02would Infinite Loop be a better,

0:15:04a perfect name for that building.

0:15:06- Right, it's a literal infinite loop.

0:15:09- When you're looking at it at Street View,

0:15:10up against it. It really seems as though it just is infinite. Like you said, it just goes off into

0:15:16the horizon. It's like you can't even see where it ends. It's truly magnificent.

0:15:21And that's as close as we got to the main building. I mean, that's as close as anybody

0:15:27was able to get is outside the fence looking towards it. You know, the theater, obviously,

0:15:32quite a bit further away even. So that's as close as we got to see it, but it was pretty big.

0:15:36Yeah, in recent years, and I do think it correlates directly, I'm like 99% sure it correlates

0:15:45directly to the Katie Cotton era and the Steve Dowling era of Apple PR, where in the Katie

0:15:53Cotton era, when we had events at town hall at the old campus, you came in the front door,

0:16:00and then you went out the front door.

0:16:03And that was it.

0:16:04So you got to park in the Apple parking lot

0:16:07and you got to walk on an Apple sidewalk

0:16:10and you came in a door and there was a lobby

0:16:12and you'd go in and even if you had briefings or something,

0:16:16if you had meetings after the event,

0:16:17you were in the same building

0:16:19and you just went up the stairs.

0:16:20And then the only door that you could leave by

0:16:22was the one that put you back on the sidewalk,

0:16:25back in the parking lot.

0:16:26And in the last, I don't know, three years or so

0:16:30when they've had events at town hall,

0:16:31they've let us in the main entrance.

0:16:34I forget which building it is,

0:16:37but instead of going in the building where Town Hall is,

0:16:39they let us in a nicer building,

0:16:41and then you can walk through the courtyard

0:16:44in the middle of the campus,

0:16:45and they'd have some food and coffee outdoors.

0:16:51It was a nicer spread,

0:16:53and you felt like you were actually inside.

0:16:56But every step of the way,

0:16:57there were T-shirted Apple employees.

0:17:01It did feel more hospitable, but it was also very clear that every step of the way, I mean

0:17:08literally like every 10 feet, there was an Apple employee to make sure nobody wandered

0:17:12off.

0:17:13Right, right.

0:17:14Even though the buildings are access controlled, there's a first line of defense.

0:17:19Right.

0:17:20Just to make sure nobody even accidentally wanders off the path that was laid out for

0:17:25the outsiders to go from A to B. There will be none of that at the Apple park.

0:17:31(laughing)

0:17:33- The line of people in Apple Park that were there

0:17:42to do roughly the same thing,

0:17:44keep people moving and make sure they didn't wander off

0:17:47into the, literally the woods where 9,000 trees

0:17:49or whatever are planted.

0:17:51But they were there maybe every 10 to 15 feet

0:17:56and they were very aggressive about saying hello

0:18:00and hoping you had a good day,

0:18:02and how are you enjoying everything?

0:18:04But literally every single person was doing it.

0:18:07After a while, it's a little bit like,

0:18:08okay, oh, we're doing this again, okay, good.

0:18:11So I just started to go on the offense,

0:18:13and I would just preemptively,

0:18:14right before I crossed the threshold of attention,

0:18:17I would say, hey, how are you doing?

0:18:21And they were a little thrown off their script

0:18:22because they were, oh, fine, yeah.

0:18:25I was like, please leave me, it's like a mace.

0:18:28They're gonna mace them with kindness.

0:18:30- So the Steve Jobs Theater itself is truly magnificent.

0:18:37I don't have enough superlatives for at least aesthetically

0:18:42how pleasing a building it is, how striking it is.

0:18:46I guess I knew this.

0:18:48I mean, there's renderings of it, but then you see it.

0:18:51And I realized that carbon fiber is a lightweight material.

0:18:55That's what makes it so interesting.

0:18:57and this is like the largest carbon fiber roof

0:19:00of any building in the world apparently.

0:19:03But the lobby of the theater is a circular pavilion,

0:19:09for lack of a better word, enclosed in glass

0:19:12with a carbon fiber roof,

0:19:14and there's literally no columns supporting the roof.

0:19:19It's wholly supported by the glass walls.

0:19:22And when you realize, I didn't really,

0:19:26It wasn't as striking when we got there in the morning,

0:19:28'cause we got there around 8.30,

0:19:30it was like an hour and a half before the event,

0:19:32and it was already jam-packed.

0:19:34Like, you know, there were hundreds of people

0:19:36who were already there.

0:19:38And when you're in a room filled with people,

0:19:41and there were people outside it on the sidewalk,

0:19:44'cause that's where they had the food and coffee,

0:19:46when you're surrounded by that many people,

0:19:47you see the people.

0:19:48And it was only when we left in the afternoon,

0:19:51after most of it was cleared out,

0:19:53and I took a really cool photo

0:19:55where there weren't even any people in the sight line

0:19:58of the camera anymore.

0:20:00When it was mostly empty is really when it was striking,

0:20:02like, holy hell, what is holding this roof up?

0:20:07It's, architecturally and engineering-wise, it is a marvel.

0:20:12- Yeah, when you're standing in the building,

0:20:15especially when you walk right in the doors

0:20:17and nobody's in there or come up the stairs

0:20:20and nobody's in there, the feeling of openness

0:20:22and outside in, obviously, was the whole point of it.

0:20:27It really is impactful.

0:20:29And the only thing that obstructs your sight line

0:20:32in any direction, because there are no physical supports

0:20:34beyond the glass itself, is the elevator.

0:20:37And that comes up out of the floor.

0:20:39But even the stairwells, there's only a slight wedge,

0:20:44and then they just sink into the ground.

0:20:46There's not like a big boxy, oh, here a stairwell begins.

0:20:51they're cut into the ground, so to speak.

0:20:53So it's quite interesting.

0:20:54- Yeah, somebody commenting on my photo said,

0:20:56it looks like the lair of a Bond villain.

0:20:59And it truly does.

0:21:02I mean, it's, and the stairs really do,

0:21:05it was sort of like when I first got there,

0:21:06I was like, where the hell are the stairs?

0:21:08I didn't even, I couldn't even tell where they were.

0:21:11It's sort of, it's freaky almost, I don't know.

0:21:16- Yeah, and it's one of those buildings where,

0:21:20and I like architecture a little bit

0:21:22and pay attention to it when I can, when I'm traveling.

0:21:25And it's one of those buildings that you look at

0:21:26and you go, you know what,

0:21:27somebody's definitely gonna use this in a movie, right?

0:21:30But Apple's not the kind of company,

0:21:32they don't need people to use it in movies,

0:21:34so it probably will not get used in a movie,

0:21:36but it's one of those pieces of architecture

0:21:39where you go, oh wow, some site researcher

0:21:44would love this place.

0:21:46You'd be like, oh, we could shoot a scene here.

0:21:48And yeah, it could definitely like slot into a Bond film like, oh, this is the entrance to the lair.

0:21:52Yeah. So we, you know, it gets the time, you know, the word spreads that they're letting people in,

0:22:00it's time to go. You descend the staircase. The handrails to the staircase are literally carved

0:22:08out of the walls. It is, it feels like it's carved out of stone. It's not stone. It's some kind of

0:22:16artificial, I forget the name of it. I found out the name of it, but it's, it's the same surface

0:22:21that's like an expensive kitchen countertop surface, surface. But the effect of having them

0:22:27carved out of the wall, it feels like you're in that, that temple in the Indiana Jones and the

0:22:33last crusade, you know, that's carved into the mountain. It really feels like the theater is

0:22:38carved into the ground. Not that it is an underground theater, but that it's carved out of,

0:22:45you know, a massive block of marble or something that was on the site for millennia. It really is

0:22:52the effect that you get. And it's funny, like I've had a bunch of questions about the hidden

0:23:00hands-on area where people are like they don't understand. They don't understand what we're

0:23:06saying when we say that there's this retractable door, but it doesn't look like something is hidden.

0:23:12It just looks like that's the way it's supposed to be when we went in and then when the show was over and we went back

0:23:17the wall was gone and

0:23:19There's the hands-on area but the bet the best expert, you know, excellent visual explanation

0:23:25I can think of is is Dan Fromer's photo essay at

0:23:28At recode he had before and after shots that I think show it about as well as it can be shown

0:23:33So I will put a link to the show notes and I linked to it from during fireball earlier, but it it is quite a thing

0:23:40Yeah, and that area that, you know, display area that they had for the hands-on stuff is completely hidden.

0:23:51And I think there were some architectural renderings or, you know, some plans or something at some point that, or maybe even early shots that somebody had posted to the internet a few weeks ago.

0:24:02ago and in those shots it makes it look like there's a wall that retracts away

0:24:08like you know kind of a slightly curved wall that maybe retracts left to right

0:24:12or splits or whatever and then you're led into a separate room for the demo

0:24:18area and there and people were wondering out loud how are they gonna hide that

0:24:21area when you walk down the stairs and you come in how are they going to make

0:24:26it so that you can't see what's in there as you walk into the theater because it

0:24:30literally shares the same space. You walk down the stairs and through the doors

0:24:34into or through the opening into the theater which is even further

0:24:37underground and that area is right there. You know you're boom you walk into it

0:24:42and so people were wondering how are they going to obscure it and of course

0:24:46once you come down the stairs we came down and it was immediately obvious the

0:24:50way they obscure it is that it's an entire cylinder. It's not just a wall

0:24:55it's a cylinder that wraps all the way around the exhibition area I think they

0:25:00call it, our exhibit area. And that exhibit area is completely closed off by a column

0:25:06of metal paneling that matches the paneling of course used above, at least in its aesthetics.

0:25:14And that's it. You walk by this huge metal cylinder and into the theater, but you get

0:25:19no glimpse of anything inside the cylinder when you walk by it.

0:25:22- Right, because this cylindrical wall,

0:25:26I don't know how you would just,

0:25:29it's sort of like an,

0:25:30escalator's a bad comparison,

0:25:33but there's, I don't know, five or six foot wide panels

0:25:38with I guess some kind of hinge between them,

0:25:40which is how it rotates.

0:25:42But when it's hidden,

0:25:45when it's open and the exhibit area is open,

0:25:49you would never think that it's possible

0:25:51that there's a wall that could slide out and hide it

0:25:53and when it's hidden,

0:25:54you would never think there's a room behind there.

0:25:56It just looks like this is like a big column

0:26:00that supports the lobby above us.

0:26:01- Right, exactly.

0:26:05And it like it was built, you know,

0:26:07built into the building and not meant to move at all.

0:26:09- Yeah, it looks right both ways is what I'm trying to say.

0:26:13All right, and we go into the theater itself

0:26:17and the theater itself is just fantastic

0:26:21every single thing about it.

0:26:22The seats are like plush leather, they are comfortable,

0:26:27there is truly a generous amount of leg room

0:26:31between the rows.

0:26:33All of the back area, every seat has power.

0:26:39We sat a little bit closer like at the back row

0:26:41of the front area, which was more like couch seating almost.

0:26:46It wasn't even like we had individual theater seats,

0:26:49It was sort of like, it was more like a bench,

0:26:52but it was so spacious that it's more like

0:26:54sitting on a sofa.

0:26:55It was kind of crazy comfortable.

0:26:59Which is--

0:27:00- Yeah, it was, it was.

0:27:01It felt a lot like a car seat, it really did.

0:27:04It felt like a luxurious, spacious bench seat

0:27:08of a luxury automobile.

0:27:10One that you have a driver for.

0:27:13- Yeah, and they even had the armrests

0:27:14that popped back into the seat,

0:27:17so you can keep them all up

0:27:19and then there's more room for seating.

0:27:21But if you have room and there's nobody next to you,

0:27:23there was like a big plush automobile style armrest

0:27:28that you can retract down from the seat.

0:27:30It was...

0:27:31(laughing)

0:27:33- Yeah, it's got the little loop

0:27:34that you hook your finger through and pull down,

0:27:36just like a back car seat.

0:27:38I pulled it down, but no cup holders.

0:27:40It definitely was a European car, not an American car.

0:27:45- So the blueprints for all of this, I guess,

0:27:47have to be released publicly, I don't know, to get approval.

0:27:50So like, I'm sure Apple, if they could have,

0:27:52would have kept everything even more secret.

0:27:55But the blueprints for this were already out,

0:27:57and I had seen them.

0:27:58But I'm particularly terrible, I think,

0:28:01at looking at blueprints for a building

0:28:03and visualizing what it actually is like to be there.

0:28:06And when I saw the theater on blueprint,

0:28:08I thought, well, that looks like

0:28:09it has an unusually low ceiling.

0:28:11And I was like, well, I guess that's what happens

0:28:13when you build it underground, but that seems weird.

0:28:15But when you're in there, I mean, that ceiling is cavernous.

0:28:19It is like being in a cathedral.

0:28:21My reading of the blueprint was obviously

0:28:24totally dipshit wrong.

0:28:25It's just a truly, truly cavernous space.

0:28:30- The lowest point is when you're walking through

0:28:33the short tunnel, or whatever you wanna call it,

0:28:35the transition area from the exhibit area

0:28:38to the theater itself is, when I say low,

0:28:41it's like a 12-foot or whatever ceiling.

0:28:44that's the lowest point and from there,

0:28:47you know, the theater slopes down,

0:28:50way down in a amphitheater style seating.

0:28:54So by the time you get to the bottom sections,

0:28:56the ceiling is quite high above you.

0:28:58And I can't remember off the top of my head,

0:29:01but I'm almost positive it's cut upwards as well.

0:29:04- Yeah, I think so. - To meet the top

0:29:05of the screen.

0:29:06'Cause you know, they have projectors

0:29:07and all kinds of other stuff that they need to mount.

0:29:09And so I'm sure it goes upwards on the ceiling as well,

0:29:12as you go towards the screens.

0:29:14- Yeah, and I noticed that there's a lot less

0:29:19visual, visually exposed like stage lighting.

0:29:26Like they know what kind of shows

0:29:28they're gonna put on there.

0:29:29So they don't really need like a lighting rig

0:29:32that could accommodate anything and everything.

0:29:35I don't know, or else they just spent, I don't know.

0:29:37It seems like they hid a lot of the lighting stuff

0:29:42that when you look up in a theater nowadays that you see,

0:29:46'cause it's like, what else are you gonna do?

0:29:47It's up there.

0:29:48It's just like instead that even the ceiling of the theater

0:29:51was cleaner and more,

0:29:54just simpler than any theater I've seen before.

0:30:00- Yeah, when you build up a spoke

0:30:02and you know exactly what it's gonna be used for,

0:30:04I mean, theaters, remember, have to be multipurpose.

0:30:06They have to be music venues and in true theaters

0:30:11to support different kinds of lighting rigs.

0:30:12And essentially something like a contact point, right?

0:30:17That's what these trusses are in a normal theater

0:30:20where you're like, hey look,

0:30:21you've got 180 different possible contact points here

0:30:23that you can hang whatever you want from.

0:30:25Lights or strobes or speakers or whatever.

0:30:28And then that's what the grips come along

0:30:31and get all that set up.

0:30:32But in this theater, they know exactly,

0:30:35precisely what it's gonna be used for.

0:30:37So they probably just put in exactly what they needed

0:30:39and no more, you know?

0:30:41And it probably allowed them to build it directly in

0:30:43rather than having a universal rigging.

0:30:45- Yeah, I was kind of curious what, going into it,

0:30:48I was kind of curious what the screen would look like

0:30:52because they could do anything.

0:30:54It's their theater.

0:30:55They could make like some kind of wraparound screen,

0:30:57a curved screen that takes up the whole front of the stage.

0:31:00They could put three screens up there,

0:31:02you know, one on the left, one on the right,

0:31:04one in the middle.

0:31:06And again, like your thing before,

0:31:10your observation that usually they just do

0:31:12the simplest and most obvious thing possible

0:31:14is they just had one rectangular flat screen

0:31:19in the middle of the back of the stage

0:31:22and it's just really, really fucking nice.

0:31:25Right, like what is the simplest

0:31:27and most obvious thing they could do?

0:31:28Just put a really nice fucking screen,

0:31:31rectangular, flat, right in the middle of the fucking stage.

0:31:33And it was magnificent.

0:31:36And the audio quality, I mean, it was crazy, right?

0:31:41- Yeah, it was very good.

0:31:42It was very good.

0:31:43I mean, like I've listened to, I've seen movies,

0:31:47you know, like they do this every once in a while,

0:31:49the Dolby Atmos will put on a presentation and say like,

0:31:52"Hey, you know, we helped with the sound design

0:31:54"on this movie," or "We think this shows off

0:31:56"our system really well, you can come look,

0:31:57"check out our screening."

0:31:59There's some Dolby Atmos theater in San Francisco

0:32:01that people can go to.

0:32:02And that is obviously top shelf sound.

0:32:06And I don't know if it was quite at most level

0:32:08'cause it doesn't need to be necessarily a home theater

0:32:11or theater type setup, but it was close.

0:32:13It was really crisp, really booming.

0:32:16And when they had the segments with music,

0:32:18like the commercials and things like that,

0:32:20the ad spots that they had with obviously mostly music

0:32:24in those things, I definitely felt the rumble

0:32:26through my seat.

0:32:27It felt like there was some, probably some subwoofers

0:32:30built in somewhere under the seats.

0:32:32It was good.

0:32:33The sonic aspect of it was really, really solid.

0:32:36- I noticed that it was the first time

0:32:38since they've gone to high dynamic range displays

0:32:42where during the keynote they didn't have to say,

0:32:44now we can't show you this because the screen can't show it.

0:32:47And instead they could show you what it looks like

0:32:52with high dynamic range versus--

0:32:53- Right, we're gonna switch over to our HDR,

0:32:55top of the line projectors with 4K

0:32:59and all of the stuff and just show you it right here.

0:33:01Instead of going, you'll just have to imagine

0:33:04that this looks better.

0:33:05Yeah, and that's pricey.

0:33:08- I would, I don't even want to tell you

0:33:10how much money I would pay to see Star Wars Episode VIII

0:33:14in that theater.

0:33:16Like, to get a center anywhere.

0:33:18I don't care if I'm in the back row,

0:33:19but anywhere near the center in that theater

0:33:23is where I would love to see Star Wars Episode VIII

0:33:26because it is the nicest theater I've ever seen in my life.

0:33:30It's truly, truly magnificent.

0:33:32All right, let's take a break,

0:33:35and I'm gonna thank our first sponsor.

0:33:36Now we can talk about what a shit-show-the-hands-on area was.

0:33:39(laughs)

0:33:41- Yes, let's.

0:33:42- All right, our first sponsor is Eero, E-E-R-O.

0:33:48Now, Eero makes Wi-Fi base stations,

0:33:52but they're not just like regular base stations.

0:33:54they create a mesh network in your house.

0:33:57And now they have their new second generation hardware.

0:34:00And it's even better than before.

0:34:03But it works with the first generation stuff

0:34:05if you already have it.

0:34:07Now, unlike other router companies,

0:34:09typically to get Wi-Fi that goes through your whole house,

0:34:12they just make routers that are even bigger

0:34:14or have bigger antennas or something like that.

0:34:17And instead what E-Radu does is create a mesh network

0:34:20where you get, the basic kit comes with I think three

0:34:23and you have one that's like your main one,

0:34:25you plug it into your cable modem

0:34:28or wherever it is that you get your internet,

0:34:30and then you plug the other ones in around your house.

0:34:33And their app, which is awesome,

0:34:36just put the Eero app on your iPhone,

0:34:38their app will even guide you

0:34:40and help you kind of strategize

0:34:42like where in your house you should put them

0:34:45to get like the best coverage throughout the house.

0:34:48Now the second generation hardware

0:34:50adds a third five gigahertz radio.

0:34:54And so now it's tri-band, and it's twice as fast

0:34:57as their first generation hardware.

0:34:59And their first generation hardware got rave reviews

0:35:02from everybody who used it.

0:35:04So it's even better now, but that third tri-band

0:35:07helps them keep, like saturate your whole house,

0:35:10whether your house is like wide,

0:35:13like you've got like a lot of area to cover,

0:35:15or whether it's tall and it has a lot of floors.

0:35:18Either way, Eero really helps saturate your home

0:35:21with really strong WiFi signal.

0:35:24And the thing is, it's not like,

0:35:25oh, well, if you have three of these set up,

0:35:27now you've got three networks

0:35:28and you're switching networks or something like that.

0:35:30Like your devices, you just sign in to your network

0:35:33and like your phone or your MacBook or whatever it is

0:35:35that you're getting on a WiFi with,

0:35:37it just connects to the nearest one automatically.

0:35:41Like Eero handles that.

0:35:42It's just one network with one password,

0:35:45but with three, four, however many of the space stations,

0:35:49the little things you need,

0:35:50you don't have to worry about that.

0:35:53It just works.

0:35:54It's so super simple.

0:35:55And the hardware is really, really beautiful.

0:35:58It's so small, so simple, so elegant.

0:36:00It's not the sort of thing you're gonna have to figure out

0:36:03a way to hide or something like that.

0:36:05It looks great.

0:36:06And the new ones, the new little extra ones,

0:36:08just plug into the socket.

0:36:10You don't even need a cable.

0:36:11And they even have a nightlight,

0:36:14and they even have a nightlight underneath

0:36:16to illuminate the floor underneath them,

0:36:18which if you don't want, you can simply turn off.

0:36:21But it could not be easier,

0:36:23could not be less visually, almost invisible.

0:36:27It's truly, truly a great product.

0:36:29The whole reason that I can connect to Matthew right now

0:36:32is through an Eero.

0:36:33It's really a great thing that's made the WiFi in my house

0:36:38so much better.

0:36:39So here's what you do.

0:36:43go to ero.com and if you remember this promo code,

0:36:46The Talk Show, that's The Talk Show, use that at checkout,

0:36:51you will get free overnight shipping.

0:36:53It's so, like right now you could just pause the show,

0:36:58go to ero.com, place your order, use that code,

0:37:00The Talk Show, and by tomorrow at this time,

0:37:03it'll ding dong, it'll be right there at your door

0:37:05with free overnight shipping.

0:37:06So my thanks to Eero, I recommend them wholeheartedly.

0:37:09I would recommend them even if they weren't

0:37:10a sponsor of the show.

0:37:11It's really, really one of the best products

0:37:13I've got in my house, so my thanks to them.

0:37:16Okay, hands-on area after the show.

0:37:18- My kid loves to pull out my ear on the wall.

0:37:22- Pull it out of the wall.

0:37:23- 'Cause he can reach, yeah, he can reach.

0:37:25One of them is in the bathroom,

0:37:27and it has the nightlight on it,

0:37:28so he's like, ah, and he yanks it out.

0:37:30And half part of my mesh goes down.

0:37:32I'm like, dang it.

0:37:35Like, literally, my internet will get slower.

0:37:37I'm like, what happened?

0:37:37I'm like, oh.

0:37:39- You know what, they are-- - Sorry, I digress.

0:37:40But they're adorable little things.

0:37:43I can see why he's drawn to it, because it is sort of like,

0:37:47I don't know, it's sort of like the same industrial design

0:37:49as like Eve from Wall-E, you know?

0:37:51It's just this sort of--

0:37:53And it's light up, you know?

0:37:55And he can reach it, all of the things.

0:37:56It's got all the good things that he likes.

0:37:59It's light up, he can reach it, and it comes apart.

0:38:03It's really nice to touch.

0:38:05Yeah, exactly.

0:38:06Hands on, hands on.

0:38:07All right, so the hands on area.

0:38:09I linked to a picture Brad Ellis linked to

0:38:11where he observed that the tables for the hands-on area

0:38:15are concentric with the walls,

0:38:18the round walls of the atrium of that hands-on area,

0:38:21meaning that they have the same center.

0:38:24And even the pads on the tables on which they laid out

0:38:29the watches or the phones or whatever

0:38:31you were trying to get your hands on

0:38:33were concentric with the table.

0:38:35Like custom tables, the wood grain is perfectly aligned

0:38:39with the radius of the table.

0:38:42The pads are custom made.

0:38:44It truly was beautiful.

0:38:46And I would say it was at best half the size it needed to be

0:38:51to accommodate the number of people were there.

0:38:53Maybe only one third of the size.

0:38:56Like each table, every single thing, it doesn't matter.

0:39:01Like what was the least exciting product they announced?

0:39:04- Probably, maybe Apple TV.

0:39:05They didn't even have Apple TV set up.

0:39:08There was no Apple TV in the hands-on area.

0:39:10So-- - Yeah, let's say

0:39:11new watch bands, right?

0:39:12I know some people love those,

0:39:14and the fashion people certainly made a beeline.

0:39:16Like I was near the watch band table at one point,

0:39:18and they were like, you know, (imitates whooshing)

0:39:19you could tell they were the fashion people,

0:39:20'cause they actually were dressed nice.

0:39:22- Right. (laughs)

0:39:23- I'm just being honest. - Right, right.

0:39:27- They got a bunch of bloggers in there,

0:39:28and you know, sweatpants, basically.

0:39:33But yeah, they had them arranged around in a circle

0:39:36and even the lower attention products,

0:39:41not the X or not the new iPhones, but the bands,

0:39:45you could not even get there.

0:39:46It was four deep away from even being able to touch it

0:39:49for an hour or more after the thing was over.

0:39:52- I have vaguely, not vaguely,

0:39:54but I have complained about the scrum

0:39:57of hands-on areas for a while now.

0:39:59And I realize that this is an incredibly privileged

0:40:02And I still feel, I feel so happy.

0:40:07And I really am that I get invited to these events

0:40:11because 10, 15, 20, even 20 years ago,

0:40:15I always used to think like someday I would love

0:40:17to be somebody who writes about this stuff

0:40:19and gets invited to be at these Apple keynotes.

0:40:21I would like to be there and cover this.

0:40:24And 10 years into being somebody

0:40:27who gets these invitations and goes there,

0:40:29I still appreciate it.

0:40:30and I realized that there's thousands of people

0:40:34listening to us talk right now,

0:40:35who in the back of their minds think,

0:40:37boy, that would be cool if I got to be there.

0:40:38And it really was cool to be there.

0:40:40So file this complaint under,

0:40:43it's a privilege to be there,

0:40:44and really the overall experience was great,

0:40:47and the show was great, and everything was great.

0:40:49But, you know, so I just keep that in mind

0:40:53when I complain about the hands-on area.

0:40:55But effectively, the effect of these hands-on areas

0:40:58has been going downhill for a while,

0:41:00because of the need for so many people

0:41:03from so many publications to get video of the stuff,

0:41:06which takes up so much physical space

0:41:08because you've got a camera person and,

0:41:11for lack of a better word, talent handling it

0:41:15and trying to talk to them.

0:41:16And there's so much more jostling.

0:41:19And it's been like one or two deep around the tables

0:41:22for events for a while now.

0:41:24But to say, like you said,

0:41:25that this was three or four deep, it really was.

0:41:28This was like an entirely different level

0:41:30where it was like four people deep around the table,

0:41:32where at least at previous events,

0:41:34it's like, okay, I'm not even gonna get literally,

0:41:36they call it the hands-on area.

0:41:38I'm not actually, I may not actually get to touch

0:41:40these things with my hands,

0:41:41but I'll at least get to see them.

0:41:44You couldn't even get close enough to see this stuff.

0:41:46It was really, and then the funny thing is then,

0:41:50you'd run into Apple people afterwards,

0:41:52and they'd be like, isn't the hands-on area beautiful?

0:41:54Isn't the hands-on area beautiful?

0:41:56How about that hands-on area?

0:41:57And it's sort of like, well, it is beautiful,

0:42:01but from our perspective, as people who actually

0:42:05would like to get our hands on these things.

0:42:08(laughing)

0:42:09- Right.

0:42:10The hands-on area is great at many things.

0:42:15One of those things is not actually allowing you

0:42:17to get your hands on.

0:42:18- Right.

0:42:19It's like having--

0:42:20- That's the one thing that doesn't do well.

0:42:22- It's like having an exquisitely beautiful,

0:42:24truly beautiful, put it in architectural,

0:42:26the cover of Architectural Digest magazine restaurant,

0:42:30and you can't get a table.

0:42:32You know what I mean?

0:42:34It's like, well, it is beautiful, but I would actually--

0:42:36- Well, you invite everybody there,

0:42:37and you're just standing three deep

0:42:40behind other people eating.

0:42:41- Yeah, and you're invited to go even.

0:42:43You even get an invite to go, but you don't get any food.

0:42:46- And look, there's a combination of factors.

0:42:53So a while back, I think it was a couple of years,

0:42:56started consolidating all of the other events worldwide into one event. So this kind of

0:43:02coincides with the larger venues like the Bill Graham and things like that. They basically,

0:43:08you remember, I'm sure that they used to have satellite events. So they would have like

0:43:12the UK press would come to the Apple Store Regent Street or some other location and watch

0:43:17a live stream and then have their own hands on area and so on and so forth. You know,

0:43:22had various permutations of that. It wasn't always exactly that way. But there were these

0:43:26satellite events for foreign, when I say foreign, I mean press outside of the US. And they would

0:43:33go there and it made it so that A, they couldn't fit everybody in the room in town hall, right?

0:43:39And then also B, they didn't have to travel and they could just, you know, go locally

0:43:42and it would capture more press that way. So they started consolidating for logistics

0:43:48reasons, I think, and messaging and all of that. And because they started, I think, seeding

0:43:52more units. Remember there was that big surge in increase in seeding demo units and things

0:43:57like that.

0:43:58Well, I mean, famously, let's just look at it. I mean, if we want to talk about the 10

0:44:02year anniversary of the iPhone, the first iPhone was seeded to four people. Steven Levy,

0:44:09at the time was at Newsweek. David Pogue, who was at the Times, Walt Mossberg, who was

0:44:15then at the Wall Street Journal and Ed Begg at USA Today, who's the only one who's still

0:44:19at the same publication. Those were the only four people in the...

0:44:22I saw Ed at the event. Yeah, he was walking around.

0:44:24Yeah. Those were the only four people who were seated with the original iPhone. And I happen

0:44:30to know that each one of them had a personal engineer from the engineering team who was on

0:44:36call 24 hours a day. I know somebody who was one of the...

0:44:41With his soldering gun at the ready.

0:44:42I know somebody who was one of those four people for one of those reviewers. And it was like the

0:44:48the most nerve-wracking experience of his life

0:44:50because it was more or less like,

0:44:52if anything goes wrong with that fucking iPhone,

0:44:54you better fucking fix it.

0:44:55(laughing)

0:44:57- Oh yeah, and there's no manual, so good luck.

0:45:02No repair manual.

0:45:04- And all four reviews actually went off without a hitch

0:45:06and they were all gone.

0:45:07But still, that's a huge difference from the number

0:45:10of people who get seated with review units today.

0:45:12- So there you got a combination,

0:45:14like a perfect storm of all of that that ends up,

0:45:17the end result of it is that you have a ton of people there

0:45:19and a ton of people all mashing into the demo spaces.

0:45:22It doesn't matter whether it's at Bill Graham

0:45:24or Town Hall or wherever,

0:45:27you're still going to probably overload your demo space.

0:45:31That said, they did build this thing from scratch,

0:45:36knowing exactly how many seats they have at the theater

0:45:40and exactly what they are going to experience

0:45:45in terms of volume, crowd volume.

0:45:47- Right.

0:45:48- You know, and look, I know that it's tough.

0:45:50I mean, I know without a doubt, personal experience,

0:45:55that like they get calls from all these people who are like,

0:45:58"Oh, I need to get somebody extra in,"

0:45:59or "Can you fit one more in," and all this stuff.

0:46:01So I don't wanna like, I don't wanna make it seem

0:46:04like they are, the PR people are not doing their job.

0:46:06They're trying to do their job,

0:46:07which is get the most people possible to see these things,

0:46:10get the word out, et cetera.

0:46:11And they do, they're usually unflappable, very courteous,

0:46:16all of that.

0:46:16Like very, you know, they handle a lot of,

0:46:19what I would really blow up at, you know, a lot of behavior.

0:46:22- Yes, yeah. - They handle it by the guests,

0:46:24by press and other people and other guests.

0:46:27But they handle a lot of that with aplomb, right?

0:46:29- Without naming it. - So I wanna give them props.

0:46:31- Without naming any names.

0:46:32We've both heard some interesting stories about

0:46:35the requests that certain publications put in or the--

0:46:39- Right, right, exactly.

0:46:42So look, I'm gonna give them all of that,

0:46:44you know what I mean?

0:46:44But it would have been, it seems like

0:46:47there would have been an anticipated issue

0:46:48as far as the design of this space goes.

0:46:52That look, hey, these concentric rings,

0:46:54'cause this is essentially a big ring

0:46:55that follows the ring of the steel walls,

0:46:57which follows the ring of the stairwell,

0:46:59and the ring of the, so it's gorgeous

0:47:01and incredibly beautiful, empty, right?

0:47:05When you see the space without the units in it,

0:47:08because that's the only time I could see the space empty

0:47:10'cause everybody obviously is gone at that point.

0:47:12It's gorgeous.

0:47:13And it would probably, to somebody who had laid it out

0:47:16and was looking at it the day before,

0:47:18going, "I can't wait till everybody gets to come here

0:47:20"and see this," it would have been,

0:47:22they would have been ecstatic

0:47:23'cause of how gorgeous it is, all of that.

0:47:25- I think it's-- - Logistically, it was tough.

0:47:27- I think it's, you know, they're,

0:47:31you and I both had briefings scheduled after the event

0:47:34and the timing of which, and such that it was convenient,

0:47:38It wasn't like I was asking you a huge favor to wait for me.

0:47:41We both finished about the same time

0:47:42so we could drive back to the city together.

0:47:45But by the time we were done,

0:47:46the hands-on area was taken down.

0:47:48So we couldn't, when we came back from the briefing area,

0:47:51which was behind this thing,

0:47:53it wasn't like they were still out there

0:47:55and we could then play with all the stuff, it was gone.

0:47:58But we could see what it looked like, mostly empty.

0:48:01We saw Jaws was there doing a TV spot with somebody

0:48:05as we went up the stairs.

0:48:07It looks beautiful.

0:48:08it look, when it's empty, it is stunning.

0:48:11But I think it sort of speaks to the weak spot

0:48:16in Johnny Ives design aesthetic,

0:48:18which is that there are times where,

0:48:21I mean, and to go back to a Steve Jobs quote,

0:48:25that design is how it works, right?

0:48:28So if design is what it looks like,

0:48:30it truly is a magnificent exhibit area.

0:48:33But if design is how it works,

0:48:34it is actually a failure of an exhibit area

0:48:37because it was nowhere near, nowhere near enough capacity

0:48:41because this concentric idea, this idea that the tables,

0:48:45there'd be one sort of ring of tables laid out concentric

0:48:48with the walls is just not enough.

0:48:50It should have been laid out more like an Apple store

0:48:53with rectangular benches with some space between them.

0:48:58Like an Apple store like layout.

0:49:01- And I can remember too that the very nature

0:49:03of like a concentric ring means that you're gonna

0:49:05squish people together who are on the inside.

0:49:07So, you know, it's actually tighter

0:49:09'cause you're walking into a ring of tables

0:49:12and then there's a melee in there.

0:49:13'Cause some people are just in the center trying to get,

0:49:15like there were literally people doing hits

0:49:17in the center of it.

0:49:18So you have like ABC or whatever sit up

0:49:19in the center of the ring doing hits

0:49:22'cause that way they have the backdrop

0:49:23of like the products and people behind them

0:49:24and the theater behind them.

0:49:26And they were, you know, I mean that was,

0:49:28that creates its own chaos.

0:49:30And then in amongst that, yeah,

0:49:32you got all of the bloggers with the sticks

0:49:34and doing the selfie style stuff,

0:49:37and then you have the people with actual video people

0:49:39who are shooting over the shoulder

0:49:41and getting the hands-ons and all of that stuff.

0:49:42So it's a mess, and I don't know what the solution is,

0:49:45but it definitely was impactful, I think,

0:49:48to some people being able to get everything they needed.

0:49:51- The solution is to scrap the ring idea.

0:49:53I mean, the room is obviously already a circle,

0:49:56but scrap the ring for the tables

0:49:58and do an Apple Store-like rectangular layout,

0:50:00and you'd get a lot more product on the floor.

0:50:05We spent, you and I spent, and as I mingled,

0:50:08we did, it wasn't like we were attached

0:50:09at the hip the whole time, but most of the people I knew,

0:50:12we spent our time outside that ring

0:50:14because the inside of the ring, like you said,

0:50:15was, it was almost like it had gravity.

0:50:19It was like once you were inside,

0:50:20you just kinda got sucked in.

0:50:22- Yeah, and at one point, Tim Cook and Johnny came out

0:50:29to do some handshaking and photo ops and things like that.

0:50:34'Cause they always bring Tim out and Tim talks to some

0:50:36of the people at the tables and he shoots some video

0:50:39and all of that.

0:50:39And of course, once that happens, the melee ensues.

0:50:42Everybody wants to get a selfie with Tim and say hi.

0:50:44And he's very gracious about all that stuff.

0:50:46But just to get him into the ring,

0:50:49they had to have like five or six people around him,

0:50:53like whatever you wanna call them,

0:50:54bodyguards or handlers or whatever.

0:50:56Just to like get to see like, yeah.

0:50:59"Well, you know, I hesitate to use the word because they weren't rude."

0:51:01It's just like, "Hey, excuse me, excuse me, excuse me, we're gonna get him in."

0:51:04And everybody, you know, is like, "Oh, okay, let me move."

0:51:07- "Whatever." - I remember looking at them.

0:51:08But they're also trying to get their picture.

0:51:09They're also trying to get their selfie, you know?

0:51:11They're dressed very casually, like in polo shirts.

0:51:14But I remember I was looking at them and I was like,

0:51:16"You guys are-- I bet they're all former Navy SEALs."

0:51:19[laughter]

0:51:20No doubt in my mind.

0:51:21Well, all of the guys driving the carts were former cops.

0:51:24- Yeah. - Like all of the people driving you--

0:51:26driving the press up and down the pathways and stuff.

0:51:28No. So I was doing, I was doing a Periscope.

0:51:31I was doing a Periscope video outside the ring showing a group of people going

0:51:35up the elevator. Now the elevator is,

0:51:38for those of you who haven't been following the architecture of this place is

0:51:42sort of a notable in so far as when you come into it on the,

0:51:47in the lobby,

0:51:49it's facing one way and then it opens in the back and rather than put two doors

0:51:54in the elevator car,

0:51:57the elevator actually descends in a sort of helix-like thing

0:52:01so that it rotates 180 degrees as you descend and ascend.

0:52:07And the elevator shaft itself is, of course, made of glass.

0:52:10So you can see this from either upstairs or downstairs.

0:52:14You can watch it as it goes.

0:52:17So I'm shooting a periscope video of the elevator.

0:52:20And that's actually where the door was where--

0:52:23like, as I'm shooting this elevator,

0:52:25For those who were like, I don't know,

0:52:26600 people on my periscope, they got quite a nice surprise

0:52:29where I'm telling them I'm shooting the elevator,

0:52:31and then all of a sudden the door opens

0:52:33and Tim Cook, Johnny Ive, and Laurene Powell Jobs

0:52:36(laughing)

0:52:37walk out of a door and right past me.

0:52:40People on the periscope were like, holy fucking shit.

0:52:42(laughing)

0:52:44That was interesting.

0:52:47It was very interesting watching the people

0:52:49make space for them because it was not like it used to be.

0:52:54- Yeah, and when it used to be, I remember,

0:52:56very specifically, like the Yerba Buena Center,

0:53:00they had that outdoor separate exhibit area.

0:53:03In other cases, they may use for artwork,

0:53:06or they turn it into a gallery or another presentation space

0:53:09but they used it for this exhibit space,

0:53:11for the Apple event.

0:53:11And I remember Tim walking around and kind of standing there

0:53:15and Jim Dalrymple would talk to him or say hi,

0:53:18or somebody would come up or a handler would be

0:53:20standing next to him telling him something,

0:53:22and then he would shoot a little photo op thing.

0:53:25But it was just such a crush this time.

0:53:27It was just very, like impossible crush.

0:53:30- I remember back in the Steve Jobs era,

0:53:33where Jobs would wander around the hands-on area,

0:53:38and it was just Jobs and Katie Cotton.

0:53:41And Katie would, they never stopped and talked to me,

0:53:47but I would watch them, and I could see what it was,

0:53:51was Katie would, in a low voice,

0:53:56tell him exactly who he was about to meet

0:53:57'cause Katie had like the,

0:53:59Jobs couldn't be bothered to remember

0:54:00who the fuck who was, but Katie did.

0:54:02- Yeah. - And so she would say,

0:54:05hey, this is so-and-so from the Wall Street Journal

0:54:07or this is, and then he'd come up and go,

0:54:09hey, how you doing, what'd you think?

0:54:11And that was always, and Tim does the same thing,

0:54:14but Steve Jobs is a question whenever he'd be,

0:54:17and Katie would also help him make sure

0:54:19that he met the right people,

0:54:20that he wasn't wasting time on people like me.

0:54:24Then he talked to David Bogue and talked to Ed.

0:54:27He didn't need to be reminded

0:54:28who Walt Mossberg is, for example.

0:54:30But his question was always, "So what'd you think?"

0:54:33And you could tell he wanted to know, "What did you think?"

0:54:37- Yeah, exactly.

0:54:38And then it was getting filed away somewhere.

0:54:40- It was literally though,

0:54:41just Steve Jobs and Katie Cotton wandering around.

0:54:44And obviously, I mean, people noticed

0:54:46that Steve Jobs was walking around.

0:54:49It was not like he wandered around unnoticed,

0:54:51but it was not like,

0:54:53nobody had to part the Red Sea for him physically.

0:54:56- Yeah. - You know?

0:54:57- I was at the last event that he was at,

0:55:00and I do regret not just saying hi,

0:55:02'cause I was right next to him, but he seemed busy,

0:55:04and I don't know, at the time,

0:55:05I'm trying to juggle cameras and do my thing

0:55:08and all of that stuff,

0:55:09but I do regret not saying hi or whatever,

0:55:11but I felt like I could've.

0:55:13- Yeah, yes. - Like I could've just been

0:55:13like, "Hey, what's up?"

0:55:14And with this, it was just like,

0:55:15"Oh man, they've got some really tough work on their hands

0:55:20"to get him in there, let him talk to a couple of people

0:55:23"who are looking at the table naturally,

0:55:24"like the people that are just organically next to him,

0:55:27"shoot a little over the shoulder stuff for ABC

0:55:29"or whatever interview that they're doing B-roll for."

0:55:32And then they had to literally get him out after that.

0:55:35They just said, "Okay, well let's get out."

0:55:37Because it was creating even more of a congestion issue.

0:55:40Johnny hung around and talked to stuff,

0:55:42but I think people were asking him

0:55:45what his watch was he was wearing and stuff like that.

0:55:47He hung out a little bit more.

0:55:48But with Tim, it was just impossible.

0:55:50And it was a byproduct of the space.

0:55:52- Did you notice what watch he was wearing?

0:55:54I'll bet he was wearing a ceramic.

0:55:55I think the ceramic is--

0:55:57- I would guess so, but I didn't.

0:55:59I wasn't close enough to see, yeah.

0:56:02But yeah, I would guess so.

0:56:03I was talking to another guest that was there,

0:56:06a designer, and at the time, we were just chatting it up,

0:56:11and then out of the blue, somebody's like,

0:56:13tasked me on the shoulder, and was like,

0:56:14"Hey, could you just step this side for just a minute?

0:56:16Oh, just excuse us.

0:56:18Johnny's gonna get a shot for Vogue."

0:56:19And so I had to step away and he stood next to the designer

0:56:21and got their quick Vogue shot.

0:56:23So in the shot in Vogue, I'm just out of frame to the left.

0:56:26(laughing)

0:56:28Not asked to participate.

0:56:30They get their shot and then we continue our discussion.

0:56:36But I thought that was funny.

0:56:36- You should have said then,

0:56:38"Do you wanna get one with all three of us then?"

0:56:40- Yeah, oh, you could.

0:56:41Oh, all three?

0:56:42Oh, yeah, sure.

0:56:42(laughing)

0:56:45- Yeah, exactly.

0:56:46What is he wearing?

0:56:47What are they wearing?

0:56:48What are the stars wearing?

0:56:50- The story I heard was,

0:56:54last thing, I think it's the last remark

0:56:56I have to make about the theater,

0:56:57but when you go from the hands-on area,

0:56:59and like you said, there's sort of like

0:57:01a little low ceiling, feels like a tunnel almost,

0:57:04but like a little hallway between there

0:57:06and the actual theater itself,

0:57:07and it's all stone.

0:57:10Everything on the walls is just stone,

0:57:11but then there's an engraved Steve Jobs theater above it.

0:57:16Type set in Helvetica,

0:57:20which I found slightly odd that it's not San Francisco,

0:57:23but it is obviously not a mistake

0:57:26because the story I heard was that

0:57:28it was the third version of it

0:57:31and that the first one was Johnny came down

0:57:34and looked at it and said, nope,

0:57:35$50,000 in stone etching, rip it out, put another one in.

0:57:40Second one came in, nope, another 50 grand, throw it out.

0:57:45And then the third one was put up and he was like, that's it.

0:57:49A kind of weird, a little slightly weird to me

0:57:53that it's not San Francisco 'cause almost everything else,

0:57:56everywhere is all San Francisco, the software, the hardware,

0:58:01all the signage on campus, everything San Francisco,

0:58:03but the word Steve Jobs Theater engraved into the thing

0:58:06are set in Helvetica.

0:58:09Oh, the other thing we should talk about is the parking garage.

0:58:13I got to figure out how to put these.

0:58:17I'll try to put these into show notes somehow,

0:58:19but we parked on level P one of the visitor center parking garage and there's P

0:58:23two the first day. Oh, P two the first day. Oh, P one was the second day though.

0:58:27And that's the one where the mistake is where there's,

0:58:29there's two elevators and they're not next to each other.

0:58:32Yeah. So if anybody's listening to this,

0:58:34we're going to tell you exactly where you could fix this issue.

0:58:39on level P1 of the visitor center parking garage, there's two elevators. The elevators

0:58:43are facing each other. They're not side by side. And there's only, you know, as you might

0:58:47expect, there's two buttons, one to go up, one to go down. And the one that's correct,

0:58:55the up and down buttons are about six inches above the one seam in the wall. And on the

0:59:00other one...

0:59:01Right. It's a two-tone wall, like two tones of concrete. There's a groove that separates

0:59:06the lighter concrete from the darker concrete.

0:59:08Very nice, you know, nice little concrete work there.

0:59:11- And on the facing elevator, the up and down button panel

0:59:15was obviously misplaced by the workmen,

0:59:17and it actually crosses the seam between the concrete.

0:59:22And as you pointed out, there's even like tape underneath,

0:59:27right, was it tape, what was that?

0:59:29- Yeah, it's like blue masking tape,

0:59:31and they instantly just yanked it off.

0:59:33They had just finished.

0:59:34- But they couldn't get the rest of the tape off

0:59:35because the button panel was placed over the gap in the concrete.

0:59:40It is so obviously wrong.

0:59:43And we both couldn't stop laughing with the knowledge that it's proof that Johnny

0:59:48Ive has never stepped foot on level P1 of the visitor center parking garage.

0:59:54He has never seen this because if he saw this, he would have ripped it out.

0:59:57I really hope he does not.

0:59:58I don't think I really would be surprised if he listens to the show, but if he does,

1:00:01he's going to like pause it and go over there.

1:00:03He's going to be like, "What the fuck are these guys talking about?"

1:00:05and he's gonna go down there and see it,

1:00:06and he's gonna lose his shit.

1:00:09- And you know, look, it's just, you know,

1:00:12junk happens when you're building an enormous,

1:00:16sprawling complex.

1:00:18Things are gonna slip through the cracks.

1:00:20It's just that they spend so much time building it

1:00:22and you have a person whose reputation is like,

1:00:25nothing but like, look, this seam, why?

1:00:28This seam, you know?

1:00:30And then you look and there's an elevator button

1:00:33that's like eight inches too low.

1:00:34And not only that, it wasn't that it was a blank wall

1:00:36and you're like, are they lower?

1:00:38I need to break out my ruler.

1:00:40It was a, like there was a literal demarcation line

1:00:43that allowed you to see immediately

1:00:45that it was really, really wrong.

1:00:47- And it's directly facing one where it's exactly right.

1:00:52- Right, right.

1:00:53It's like, you just look left and right

1:00:55and it's like wrong, right.

1:00:56I think you did like the invitation of what Johnny would do

1:00:59if you stayed in there like,

1:01:00"Like left, what the hell is going on here?"

1:01:03(laughing)

1:01:04Am I taking crazy pills?

1:01:05But like, I grew up finding stuff like that,

1:01:09'cause my dad was that way,

1:01:10he was a fit and finished guy for a lot of years.

1:01:12He did interior decorating and paint and plaster

1:01:16and all of that stuff.

1:01:17And so for him, he'll walk into a room

1:01:20and instantly go like,

1:01:21"Oh, that wasn't cut in properly there."

1:01:23And you're like, "Dang it, I thought I was finished

1:01:25"in this room," you know?

1:01:26And I inherited that thing.

1:01:28And so I was like, we got off that elevator,

1:01:30I'm like, I feel a disturbance in the detail force.

1:01:35What's going on here?

1:01:37But yeah, that was good times.

1:01:40It was good stuff. - Really good times.

1:01:41All right, let me take another break here

1:01:42and then we'll talk about the actual products

1:01:43that were introduced at the event.

1:01:44But I wanna tell you about our next sponsor

1:01:47and it's our good friends at Backblaze.

1:01:48Backblaze offers unlimited native backup for Mac and PC.

1:01:53No credit card required to start, no risk,

1:01:56and you get a 15 day trial at backblaze.com/daringfireball.

1:02:01Here's the deal, you install Backblaze on your Mac

1:02:06and it is great software.

1:02:09I'm not gonna name names, but there's competitors

1:02:11that have these weird Java based apps that are horrible

1:02:14and bloated and take up tons of RAM

1:02:17and have terrible user interface.

1:02:19Backblaze is just a nice system preferences panel.

1:02:22They're actual Mac software engineers

1:02:24used to work at Apple, so they totally know

1:02:26what it means to write truly native Mac software.

1:02:28And back plays never, and I've been using it for years,

1:02:33never, ever, like I keep activity monitor running

1:02:38on my Mac all the time 'cause I'm a nerd.

1:02:39And if I see those levels go up and I'm like,

1:02:41go over there and see what it is,

1:02:43what's making my CPU go too hard, it is never back plays.

1:02:48Like it's not the sort of thing where you need to sit there

1:02:50and like, oh, I'm gonna do something,

1:02:51I'm gonna work right now, I better go turn it off

1:02:54so that it doesn't do a backup.

1:02:55It's like, I have no idea when Backblaze does these backups

1:02:58because it's silent and efficient and it just works.

1:03:02It's just truly invisible.

1:03:05And what it does is it backs up all of your stuff

1:03:08to their cloud backup service.

1:03:11Should it be your only backup?

1:03:12No way.

1:03:13And they'll be the first ones to tell you that.

1:03:16You should have local backups.

1:03:18You should use Time Machine.

1:03:19I use a product called SuperDuper,

1:03:22which creates a clone, a perfect cloneable image

1:03:25of my startup disk.

1:03:26So if anything ever goes wrong with my startup disk,

1:03:28I am never more than like one day's data away

1:03:31from just plugging in the external drive

1:03:33and I can boot from it and there it is.

1:03:36But you should have backups offsite

1:03:39just in case something terrible happens.

1:03:41So maybe you get robbed, maybe there's like a fire,

1:03:45maybe the pipe leaks in the ceiling above your office

1:03:50and soaks all of your computer equipment

1:03:52or something like that.

1:03:53There's all sorts of things that could go bad

1:03:55where you're gonna be like,

1:03:56boy, I really wish I had an offsite backup.

1:03:58Well, Backblaze is the offsite backup that you should use.

1:04:02I use it, I would tell you to use it

1:04:04even if they didn't sponsor the show.

1:04:06Just truly great.

1:04:07And here's the deal, you pay five bucks a month per Mac

1:04:11and it'll back up everything on your Mac

1:04:14and any external drives connected to your Mac.

1:04:16And that's the only limit.

1:04:18And you're like, well, wait, not me.

1:04:20I've got like this giant movie collection

1:04:23on an external drive next to my Mac.

1:04:24Nope, no limits.

1:04:25If it's connected to your Mac, it all gets backed up.

1:04:28That's it, five bucks a month.

1:04:29There's no catch, that's it.

1:04:33So go to backblaze.com/daringfireball.

1:04:38They'll know you came from here.

1:04:40Download the free demo and you got 15 days to try it out

1:04:42and see if everything I just told you is true.

1:04:44So my thanks to Backblaze for their continuing support

1:04:47of Daring Fireball and the talk show.

1:04:48Great, great service.

1:04:50If you're not signed up yet,

1:04:52there's something wrong with you.

1:04:53Which order, what order do you want to talk about the products?

1:04:58Do you want to talk to the order Apple did them or do you want to go reverse because iPhone 10 is the hot shit?

1:05:05I don't know. Let's go reverse.

1:05:09Let's do what? Reverse?

1:05:11Let's go reverse.

1:05:12Okay. iPhone 10.

1:05:14Because I figure if we run out of time.

1:05:16Yeah. Let's give short shrift to retail.

1:05:21(laughing)

1:05:23- It's one of those Apple events where they go,

1:05:28a lot of great stuff happened,

1:05:29but we have too many things to talk about,

1:05:30so everything's going great, okay.

1:05:32- Does it make sense, I don't know that it makes sense

1:05:35to talk about iPhone X separately from iPhone 8, because--

1:05:38- No, I think we should talk about it both.

1:05:40- Yeah.

1:05:41- There's a lot of shared hardware and shared features

1:05:43and shared philosophies, I think.

1:05:45- For showmanship purposes, they introduced them separately

1:05:49and did the one more thing,

1:05:51and they're obviously priced separately.

1:05:54But at a basic level, it's almost impressive

1:05:59how much of the internal new stuff that's in iPhone 10

1:06:05is also in iPhone 8.

1:06:08- Yeah, almost everything.

1:06:12- A11 Bionic chip is, as far as we know,

1:06:16at this point, they're the same speed.

1:06:18And maybe there's, I don't know,

1:06:20maybe there's a megahertz difference, I don't know,

1:06:22or gigahertz, I guess, at this point.

1:06:23But I would almost be surprised if there were.

1:06:26But the fact, like the most impressive fact

1:06:29of the A11 Bionic chip is that the new performance controller

1:06:34that Apple has engineered now allows all six cores

1:06:39to run at the same time, as opposed to previously,

1:06:42and which a lot of, you know, it's not unique to Apple.

1:06:45There's other Android, like the Snapdragons,

1:06:47to do this thing where there's high power,

1:06:50high performance cores and low power,

1:06:53lower performance cores and it switched between them.

1:06:56So when your iPhone didn't really need it,

1:06:58your iPhone 7 doesn't need a lot of CPU performance,

1:07:03it'll use two low power cores.

1:07:06And when it does need more performance,

1:07:08it switches to two high performance cores.

1:07:11On the A11 Bionic,

1:07:14and I can't emphasize what a breakthrough this is,

1:07:17it's always using the low performance cores

1:07:20and when it needs more performance,

1:07:22it adds the high performance cores.

1:07:25And so the multi-core performance difference

1:07:28between these two is, it's absolutely jaw-dropping

1:07:32and nothing like what you would expect

1:07:34in a 12 month year over year upgrade.

1:07:36And the iPhone 8s get them too.

1:07:38- Yeah, they all get 'em.

1:07:41And the performance controller too,

1:07:44it's more sophisticated even than just switching or adding,

1:07:47'cause it can traffic control between all of them,

1:07:50as far as I understand it from the presentation,

1:07:52is that you can get any combination thereof,

1:07:56whereas the previous Fusion chip,

1:07:59it switched them off and on in pairs.

1:08:02Like it was sort of much less sophisticated.

1:08:05So basically, just a more sophisticated version

1:08:07of what they were doing before,

1:08:08but enormously forward in terms of efficiency.

1:08:11And one of the big questions, I think,

1:08:14or big kickbacks right away, everybody was like,

1:08:16oh well, it's getting some performance gains

1:08:20because it got to drop 32-bit, right?

1:08:24Like it doesn't have to do 32-bit,

1:08:25it can do only 64-bit now.

1:08:27And I think that's true, but I don't think that that's,

1:08:30I don't think that should account in people's minds

1:08:32for much of the performance gain.

1:08:33It really is an enormous jump forward

1:08:35and processing power and efficiency.

1:08:38- Yeah, there may be, that's an interesting question

1:08:40as to whether part of this performance controller

1:08:44is the fact that it only has to do 64-bit.

1:08:47My understanding though is that the dropping of 32-bit

1:08:50and the performance gains from that is really more that,

1:08:54it's not really, I could be wrong.

1:08:58There might be a performance controller,

1:09:00CPU level, silicon advantage to that,

1:09:02but mainly it's sort of a RAM issue

1:09:06where supporting both means you have to have both versions

1:09:10of all the OS frameworks.

1:09:12And when a 32-bit app launches on iOS 10,

1:09:15you have to load all of AppKit

1:09:17and whatever other blank kit frameworks,

1:09:21insert camera kit, whatever.

1:09:24In broad strokes, and I'm sure people

1:09:30who truly understand what's going on,

1:09:31they might roll their eyes,

1:09:32but in broad strokes, it's almost like you've got

1:09:34two versions of iOS running.

1:09:35You've got the 32-bit version and the 64-bit version.

1:09:38And the context switching of that is,

1:09:41it's just fairly significant, whereas going 64-bit only,

1:09:45it just drops a whole level of that

1:09:48that you just don't even have to worry about.

1:09:50But you might be right, there might be something,

1:09:51maybe it was just that it was easier

1:09:53to develop the performance controller

1:09:55if you only knew you had one set of frameworks

1:09:57and you never had to worry about

1:09:59that sort of context switching.

1:10:00Yeah, and I think that there's, there are going to be people who will try to dampen,

1:10:09which it's only right to do, dampen the amount of like over the top enthusiasm about this

1:10:15process or by saying, well, you know, look, here are the caveats, here are the things

1:10:20that may, you know, they may be doing to get these performance numbers or whatever, because

1:10:25we've seen some of the geek bench, public geek benches already, you know, coming from

1:10:28test devices out there that are showing like Macbook Pro-like performance.

1:10:35My hat's off to the people in the hands-on area who managed to get to the App Store and

1:10:38down.

1:10:39I know.

1:10:40Because when you're using it, there is somebody from Apple supervising you.

1:10:46I don't know.

1:10:47I'm not quite sure how that happened.

1:10:49Because what they...

1:10:50Whoever was able to do that.

1:10:51Right.

1:10:52How did they sign into the App Store?

1:10:53I'm not even sure if that's how these numbers linked.

1:10:54I don't know.

1:10:55I don't know if it was...

1:10:56Yeah.

1:10:57- Right, right. - Right on the Twitters.

1:11:00And it was showing a MacBook Pro performance

1:11:03coming out of that thing.

1:11:04And then of course there are people who are like,

1:11:05"Ah, well, you gotta take into account the 32-bit switch,

1:11:09"you gotta take into account this and that

1:11:11"and the other thing."

1:11:12And I get all that, but I have two things to say about that.

1:11:15One, Apple did it, right?

1:11:19Like their Silicon team did it.

1:11:21All of those things that you're saying,

1:11:23oh, they just dropped 32-bit.

1:11:26"Oh, okay." But they had to drop 32-bit. They were literally the first phone ever to use

1:11:30a true 64-bit processor, and they spent three years building that, you know? And now it's

1:11:35paying off, right? Like, they transitioned their file system, the 64-bit file system,

1:11:39without a hitch to, like, a billion devices, you know? Like, zero problems. Like, nobody.

1:11:48I never saw a single person say, "Oh, I upgraded to iOS, Tindo, whatever, and my file system

1:11:54screwed up. No, not a single one. I mean, that's ridiculous, right? So they had to put in the work.

1:11:59Right. And then the second aspect of it is what I feel is important to point out, even though it

1:12:05won't affect people in the near term, the A11 is putting up these numbers and performing this way

1:12:12on a battery powered device. Like, can you imagine how powerful that thing actually is?

1:12:20if it can put up a MacBook Pro-like number on a battery.

1:12:25Imagine the performance your MacBook Pro, your battery life performance your MacBook Pro would

1:12:30get if it had the iPhone 8 battery. Right. Like imagine an iPhone with a MacBook size battery.

1:12:37Right. Exactly.

1:12:38That's how good your MacBook's battery life would be. So look, everybody's always like just chamfered

1:12:46it at the bit to know when Apple is going to switch over and put ARM CPUs into Macbooks

1:12:51and all this stuff.

1:12:52And, you know, a lot of people see the Touch ID and the Touch bar as testing the waters

1:12:58because that obviously has an ARM CPU in it or ARM part in it.

1:13:03But I don't know.

1:13:04I'm not a prognosticator in that regard.

1:13:06And there are tons of people that are much more smarter, much more smarter, obviously,

1:13:10much smarter than I am.

1:13:12Much smarter than I am about processor lifespan and like when that's the right thing for them to do.

1:13:18And I don't know system architecture on a low level to know are they ready to do that and all that, right?

1:13:23But just coming from a purely strategic standpoint in terms of what they're building there, they could probably switch now, right?

1:13:32They could probably switch very, very closely to now.

1:13:35And that's crazy, crazy impressive over the past three years what they've done.

1:13:41And I'd like to point out that all these really massive,

1:13:45fun, and incredibly technical, obviously, improvements

1:13:49have been made on quote, unquote, S years.

1:13:52You know, the years that most people were like,

1:13:54oh, you know, who cares, right?

1:13:56It's like, well, you should care

1:13:58'cause they're literally building the future

1:14:00of your processing power on your laptop

1:14:02in front of your face, you know?

1:14:04- I saw somebody, somebody I know at Apple

1:14:08works on iPad and they were at the event and you know a typical Apple person

1:14:13they're not gonna tell me anything but all I said I said to him was holy shit

1:14:19the a11 and he just smiled so you bring this up I wrote about this at during

1:14:28fireball I wrote about this that I retweeted that screenshot floating

1:14:33around with them because somebody's I somebody said I got like a I don't know

1:14:36a thousand goddamn likes on it.

1:14:38But somebody said, "Holy shit,

1:14:39"this is like MacBook performance."

1:14:40And I retweeted it with a comment,

1:14:42"Macbook Pro performance."

1:14:44"Macbook Pro, not MacBook."

1:14:45Like, this blows the standard MacBook away.

1:14:48Like, the nicest regular MacBook that you can get,

1:14:52the CPU performance on your iPad 8,

1:14:54not even if you just get the 8,

1:14:56that $699 iPhone 8 beats the MacBook.

1:15:01It's MacBook Pro performance.

1:15:02And of course, out of the woodwork

1:15:04come the Android fans and they're like,

1:15:07I thought benchmarks don't matter.

1:15:10You know, I thought benchmarks don't matter.

1:15:13And nobody ever said this is why.

1:15:15Nobody is saying you should buy an iPhone

1:15:17because it performs, has great Geekbench benchmarks.

1:15:21Nobody is saying that.

1:15:23But this is unprecedented

1:15:25in the history of personal computing.

1:15:26Like because in the old days, there were times,

1:15:31like it sort of was like a tide coming in and out

1:15:34where every once in a while Apple would make

1:15:36this breakthrough back before they switched to Intel.

1:15:39Like when they first switched to PowerPC,

1:15:42the Macs were, Power Macs, when they first had came out,

1:15:45they were arguably, and I think it's fair to say,

1:15:48they jumped ahead of the PC.

1:15:51And then very quickly Intel passed them again,

1:15:58and the PowerPC architecture sort of languished.

1:16:02And then there were times like the Power Mac G4,

1:16:07was it, yeah, the G4 sort of put them back in the game

1:16:16and then it quickly languished

1:16:18and then it just never went anywhere.

1:16:20And so there were times when as an Apple user,

1:16:22as a Mac user, you were sort of,

1:16:24you really were effectively making a conscious choice

1:16:26to use a platform that in terms of pure computing performance

1:16:29was behind the rest of the industry.

1:16:31And I did so, I stuck with the Mac through all those years

1:16:36because I liked the software, I liked the design.

1:16:39But I was aware, I wasn't like in denial

1:16:43that dollar for dollar or just in terms of like,

1:16:46what's the fastest performing computer I can buy?

1:16:49Is it as fast as the fastest performing PC?

1:16:51No, I knew it wasn't, but I was fine with that

1:16:53because I liked the platform.

1:16:55It's never been the case though that the people,

1:16:58And in some broad sense, Android is the new Windows

1:17:01because it's the platform that is licensed

1:17:04and everybody uses it.

1:17:05It was never the case that Windows users had to accept

1:17:09that Macs had blow away performance that blew them away.

1:17:13But that is the case now

1:17:16and they're losing their minds over this.

1:17:19There's a certain contingent of Android user

1:17:24who prefers the platform, which is totally reasonable.

1:17:27I get it. I don't like it as much, but I could see why some people might, but who also want like the best performing hardware in the world and they can't have that.

1:17:37And it's like causing cognitive dissonance in their minds.

1:17:47That like one-usmanship is sort of where the specs discussion falls apart for me, right?

1:17:56I mean, and like you mentioned earlier, people are going like, "Oh, I thought the specs don't matter," or whatever.

1:18:00But the effects of the specs do, right?

1:18:03The effects of what is being done there matter.

1:18:08And that's what it's capable of.

1:18:10So you honestly, I don't even,

1:18:14I really wish people who are in Android

1:18:17that feel some sort of FOMO or whatever

1:18:19about even the processing power,

1:18:22let's just say that, right?

1:18:23They're like, oh man, I want a phone that uses Android

1:18:26that has the most powerful processor in the world.

1:18:28And my question to them is why?

1:18:31Like why do you want that most powerful processor

1:18:34or whatever?

1:18:34Is it just because you know holding your hand you have that?

1:18:37And the answer for some people would be yes.

1:18:39Like they just want it.

1:18:40They want to know, like honestly it's the same reason

1:18:43I upgrade my GPU like habitually.

1:18:46Like I want to know if I pull up Destiny 2 on a PC

1:18:49in October, it's gonna run like 4K with all of the

1:18:52water droplets and body fluids and everything looking crisp.

1:18:57And that's fine.

1:18:58That's just, I do it consciously knowing that I'm

1:19:01probably spending money before I need to

1:19:04to upgrade my GPU.

1:19:05And some people do the same thing with an Android phone.

1:19:07They're like, "Colin, I got the new hotness

1:19:09because it's the fastest in the world or whatever. And so now they are faced, as you said, with this dissonance problem where they're like, "Oh, I cannot get something that goes blow for blow in Android, you know, goes blow for blow with an A11." But my question to them is like, why do you want that processor? And I think that that's the strength of iOS, because it gives people that unified platform to build for and the ceiling of maximum power that they know

1:19:39they can target. Like they know the rules of their world. And so when they go in there, they know they

1:19:46can cast a fireball or they know they can, you know, summon a dragon or whatever. They know

1:19:53exactly what they can do within the frameworks of that world that Apple has built for them. Whereas

1:19:58on Android, as a developer who wants to push the limits, your targets get narrower and narrower and

1:20:04narrower, the more you want to push the platform. And so that's why I always ask people like, why?

1:20:09Why do you want a more powerful processor on Android? Because guess what, all you're going to

1:20:14get is a handful of demo apps that can even take advantage of it. And those apps will probably not

1:20:19scale. Obviously, there are a few apps from major developers like games that may push it, right, and

1:20:26are built to push it. But by and large, if you're going into an A11 powered iPhone, like

1:20:35an iPhone 8 or an iPhone 10, you know that the apps getting built for that thing by the

1:20:40people that know how to do it are going to be pushing the boundaries of what that's capable

1:20:45of. Like you're going to within months, you're going to be seeing what really truly what

1:20:49that thing is capable of. And that doesn't happen on Android because it's not a symbiotic

1:20:56relationship between the developer ecosystem and the actual hardware that you're using?

1:21:01It really is as though like in the mobile era, it's as though imagine if like Microsoft and Intel

1:21:09had been one company and kept the chips to themselves. And, you know, it's undeniable that

1:21:18Apple's chip team is better than Qualcomm's

1:21:23and better than Samsung.

1:21:25Samsung has their own chips, I forget what they call them,

1:21:28like in the weird way that there's literally

1:21:31like two different Galaxy S8s, one with a Snapdragon

1:21:34and one with the custom Samsung chip.

1:21:38But the performance on the Samsung chip

1:21:40isn't really all that different than the Snapdragon.

1:21:42Like Apple is literally like two years,

1:21:44maybe even more ahead of the industry.

1:21:48And there's just no precedent for that

1:21:50in the PC side of things.

1:21:52And again, you get this if you get the base model iPhone 8.

1:21:58And again, this is not the main reason why.

1:22:01You had a very good line in the car when we were driving

1:22:04where it's not the specs that matter,

1:22:06it's the effects that matter,

1:22:07meaning how does the user benefit from this?

1:22:14But they are real effects, you know,

1:22:16and one of them is battery life,

1:22:17where this faster performance means

1:22:19if you want to do this thing on your phone

1:22:22and the processor can do it without even breaking a sweat,

1:22:26it takes less of the battery life away

1:22:28and you get longer battery life.

1:22:29- That's right, that's right, yeah.

1:22:31It's like you got Joe DiMaggio out there

1:22:35playing in your neighborhood ballpark.

1:22:38- Right.

1:22:38- Like is it gonna be an effort for him

1:22:39to crush it out of the park?

1:22:41No, you know, he's gonna be fine.

1:22:43And so that it does allow-- overhead is important, right?

1:22:48So just to give you an example, ARKit, one of the reasons

1:22:53that many developers are excited about it after they learn

1:22:56this fact, they're excited about it,

1:22:58is that it uses almost none of the GPU.

1:23:02I mean, almost none.

1:23:04I think it activates it and uses some bare minimum amount of it.

1:23:07But nearly all of the GPU is completely

1:23:10untouched by just firing up the ARKit framework.

1:23:14So all of the work that ARKit does for the developer in getting a point cloud and plane

1:23:20detection and tracking and updating that tracking and et cetera, et cetera, it's all CPU-based.

1:23:27And the GPU is left completely alone because Apple knows that many of these developers

1:23:31will be building in Unity or in Unreal and they're going to need all of that GPU to

1:23:37perform those calculations to render those scenes.

1:23:40So ARKit, all that stuff is on the processor to do.

1:23:44And in order to do that efficiently and consistently,

1:23:47they need precise understanding of the capabilities

1:23:51of the processor, incredibly good handling

1:23:54over the power utilization of that processor,

1:23:57and then of course, you know,

1:23:58a handling over the rest of the hardware,

1:23:59like the sensors and things.

1:24:01And that kind of like, you know, blended efficiency

1:24:06only comes when you build the silicon

1:24:07and then you build the framework.

1:24:09- Yeah.

1:24:09I think that another good example of that,

1:24:13and again, Apple does like to put features

1:24:16in the new hardware that's exclusive to them.

1:24:19I'm lacking a better word here.

1:24:21This sounds mean-spirited, but out of marketing spite,

1:24:25let's say, that hey, you can only do this

1:24:27if you buy the new iPhone.

1:24:29But I think that the new portrait mode lighting effects,

1:24:33It's not just spite of, hey, sorry iPhone 7 Plus users,

1:24:38you don't get this, it's only for iPhone 8 and iPhone 10.

1:24:41I don't think so.

1:24:43I think it actually has to do

1:24:44with the increased performance overhead,

1:24:46because it's all rendered in real time when you do it.

1:24:49Meaning portrait mode on the iPhone 8 Plus

1:24:52and on the iPhone 10 has these lighting effects

1:24:55that you can do.

1:24:55And as Phil Schiller explained on stage,

1:24:57they're not filters.

1:24:59They truly are computationally simulating

1:25:02advanced lighting effects of like,

1:25:06it detects eyes and simulates placing a light

1:25:11the way that a professional portrait photographer

1:25:14would place a light just to highlight your eyes.

1:25:17And it's not just after you snap the photo

1:25:21and then it goes and a little spinner shows up

1:25:23and it like does it, it's all rendered in real time.

1:25:26I think that's another example of it

1:25:30where the hardware has a, the performance of these chips

1:25:34truly has an effect on the experience of using the device

1:25:39in a way that people can appreciate.

1:25:40- Yeah, even if it's not, yeah, even if it's not,

1:25:42I think some people would go, like,

1:25:44hey, Apple doesn't chip stuff on purpose,

1:25:47and I know people will pull examples out

1:25:49and wave them around if you ask,

1:25:51but in terms of something like the portrait mode,

1:25:55I think that even if they could be supported,

1:25:57my gut tells me they could probably get it to run

1:26:00on like an iPhone 7 Plus, right?

1:26:03But even if they could support it there,

1:26:04the experience might not be, you know,

1:26:08as flawless as they showed it on stage,

1:26:10where it's just like, bing, bang, boom.

1:26:11And maybe the live preview wouldn't work,

1:26:13but afterwards it would work.

1:26:15Or maybe the processing time is just longer,

1:26:18so that when you snap it, you get the spinny, right?

1:26:21Where, you know, as you saw on stage,

1:26:24it's like, bang, you know, you shoot the picture,

1:26:26and that's it, right?

1:26:27There's no waiting around.

1:26:29It doesn't go to a splash screen.

1:26:30It doesn't say, "Okay, give me 10 minutes, check back."

1:26:33And it's just, I think experience is sometimes

1:26:35why those decisions are made,

1:26:37even though they can support it or can ship it.

1:26:40And some people will cry foul, like,

1:26:41"Hey, I don't mind, just give it to me."

1:26:44I think that sometimes it's a matter of that.

1:26:46Sometimes it's a matter of resources

1:26:47and supporting it or whatever.

1:26:49But I guarantee that the best experience you're gonna have

1:26:52is with the A11, 'cause this stuff is cutting edge.

1:26:54And they built the silicon to support it.

1:26:57They really said like, oh hey, we could do this?

1:27:00Okay, well what do we need to get this done?

1:27:02And they went and asked their silicon teams to build it.

1:27:04You know, that's how it works.

1:27:05- Then what else is new?

1:27:08So all of the new iPhones, including the iPhone 8,

1:27:11get a True Tone display.

1:27:13And anybody who has an iPad Pro with a True Tone display,

1:27:18which heretofore was the only Apple product with True Tone,

1:27:21I love True Tone.

1:27:25I cannot wait for it to, it's not quite as profound

1:27:29as going from non-retina to retina, but it is close.

1:27:32And it just like with retina,

1:27:36once you have one device that's retina,

1:27:37when you look at non-retina devices,

1:27:39you're like, oh my God, look at these big fat pixels.

1:27:41And it's like when you have a true tone device

1:27:44and then you look at a non-true tone device

1:27:46indoors with incandescent lighting,

1:27:47you're like, why is everything so blue?

1:27:49It's not an iPhone 10 only feature.

1:27:53It is iPhone 8 and a serious, serious upgrade year over year.

1:27:58Trying to think what else.

1:28:03- Yeah, TrueTone's great.

1:28:04I love that, I love that thing.

1:28:05I mean, as somebody who's also hypersensitive

1:28:07to color temperatures, it's been a huge, huge plus for me

1:28:11with the iPads, so I'm really happy

1:28:13to see that come to iPhone.

1:28:15- In other words, and I think there were so many people

1:28:22that I spoke to, you know, just other writers,

1:28:26you know, Jim Dalrymple and other people,

1:28:28like if there were no iPhone X this year,

1:28:31the iPhone 8, as are, as they are,

1:28:33exactly feature for feature and dollar for dollar,

1:28:37what they cost, what they do,

1:28:38would be a very solid year over year update.

1:28:42- Yeah, I think you'd have to endure,

1:28:45Apple would have to endure that same wave of like,

1:28:48oh, is the iPhone boring, you know, stuff,

1:28:50But it would be fine.

1:28:52Like the people would buy them.

1:28:53People that needed an upgrade would get the upgrade.

1:28:56You get nice solid camera upgrades.

1:28:58You get a great new portrait lighting feature,

1:28:59which I think is a really, really cool application

1:29:03of computer vision.

1:29:04You get a lot of nice things.

1:29:06- A very, if you don't use a case,

1:29:08a very different look with the glass backs.

1:29:10- Yeah, the glass backs that we saw,

1:29:15I mean, I really liked the gold.

1:29:17I think it's really cool.

1:29:18It has like a sort of pink cast to it in the back underneath the glass.

1:29:22I guess it's like coated on the back as a sort of like millennial pink type pink.

1:29:27Very Tope-y pink.

1:29:29But it's good. I like it.

1:29:31Part of the reason I wanted you to be on the show is that if you weren't the guest

1:29:34for this wrap up show, I was going to have to rip you off in so many ways because

1:29:38so many things that you said privately to me that I want to repeat.

1:29:42But like, I like that they went from having two golds to having one gold.

1:29:46and you described it as a, it's not rose gold,

1:29:49but it is a rosy gold.

1:29:51- Right. - And I think that is,

1:29:54I can't explain it, if you've only seen it in photos

1:29:56and you haven't seen it in person yet,

1:29:59that's the best way to describe it.

1:30:00And I think it is a very,

1:30:03again, I probably shouldn't speak to fashion,

1:30:07but it's, to me, seems like, from what I've seen

1:30:11in storefronts and stuff like that--

1:30:12- It's the kind of gold that changes

1:30:14depending on what light you look at in it.

1:30:16Like in the sunlight, it'll be very pink or whatever,

1:30:18and then like under fluorescence,

1:30:20it may look more straight gold.

1:30:22But I don't think it's the death of rose gold

1:30:24like everybody thinks it is.

1:30:25- No, no, but it's like a shift

1:30:27in what is the hot flavor of rose gold.

1:30:30And the color of the glass is a very,

1:30:35it just seems of the moment.

1:30:36I don't know that it's a timeless color, I think,

1:30:40but it's a very 2017, 2018 color.

1:30:44- I think that's partly why so many of them--

1:30:47- Which is fine.

1:30:48Like it should be a color of the time, you know?

1:30:50- Yeah.

1:30:51I think rose gold as it was is over, you know?

1:30:55And it's interesting to me that they've kind of narrowed in

1:30:58on one flavor of gold.

1:31:01It looks great.

1:31:02- Yeah.

1:31:04- Yeah, looks good.

1:31:05And the silver looks good, you know?

1:31:07All you gotta do is look over people's shoulders

1:31:10at the thing and you see that the glass,

1:31:13the glass back is definitely more active.

1:31:17It feels like the backs of the aluminums

1:31:20did feel a little bit static.

1:31:22I think that's the best way to put it.

1:31:23It's like, it feels solid, it feels static,

1:31:25and some people like that, I get it.

1:31:27But the reason I went with Jet Black with my iPhone 7

1:31:29is 'cause it felt more alive.

1:31:31It's like sparkly and shiny,

1:31:32and you get a lot of cool reflections,

1:31:36and just feels more, I don't know, more active to me.

1:31:40And I think that the glass backs on the 8s

1:31:43just make them feel there's translucency there.

1:31:46There's more going on, you know?

1:31:48And that may, it'll encourage more people

1:31:50to use clear cases or no cases, all of that stuff.

1:31:54- Yeah, I wonder if--

1:31:55- You know you mentioned, you mentioned the thing,

1:31:56oh, sorry, go ahead.

1:31:57- Well, no, you keep going.

1:31:59- You mentioned the thing, I just wanted to loop back,

1:32:02'cause you mentioned the thing about

1:32:03if they had not released an iPhone X.

1:32:05And this might be an interesting time to talk about this,

1:32:07But I've been thinking about this.

1:32:12And I was gonna write about it at some point,

1:32:14but I'll just say it here and maybe I'll write about it.

1:32:17I don't know.

1:32:18But I really think that there's a lot of people

1:32:19with a lot of angst over the notch, right?

1:32:22And over the screen not being full screen.

1:32:25And they see it as a betrayal, you know,

1:32:27of Apple's attention to detail and that, you know,

1:32:30I mean, quite literally Steve Jobs would never have shipped

1:32:33this device or never agreed to let it be shipped.

1:32:35'cause it's like, oh, find a way to get rid of the ears

1:32:38or whatever.

1:32:39Or heck, they're just, software-wise,

1:32:42just put black up there, or whatever it is.

1:32:45And I get it, I get it, I think honestly,

1:32:48the arguments are valid.

1:32:50I'm not out there carrying water for Apple

1:32:52and saying, oh, you should love the horns

1:32:53and all of this, right?

1:32:54It is what it is.

1:32:56But I think that it is, while not creating excuses

1:33:02or any of that, I'm just a person who likes to ask why.

1:33:04Like, why?

1:33:05Why would they release it like this?

1:33:07Why would they release it before they could figure out a way

1:33:10to eliminate those things?

1:33:11If that's what you think that they were trying to do

1:33:13and couldn't do, right?

1:33:15Eliminate those little ears or the notch

1:33:18or whatever you wanna call it.

1:33:19And the way I think about it, I believe,

1:33:22and I have not verified this with anybody at Apple,

1:33:25this is not based on inside information, any of that junk.

1:33:27This is just me thinking.

1:33:29It seems to me that the iPhone X,

1:33:31I'm gonna crib word from you

1:33:33talking about the AirPad charger,

1:33:34But the iPhone X is like a super set of the iPhone 8.

1:33:39In other words, it's like we got the iPhone 8 as a base.

1:33:44Now, what can we do to make sure that we are catching

1:33:49what we believe in our hearts

1:33:51to be the next wave of platform change?

1:33:54And right now, that's all about computer vision

1:33:59and augmented reality.

1:34:00like computational computer vision based interfaces

1:34:05and input mechanisms are all anybody thinks about

1:34:10in tech right now.

1:34:11Even if that's not their space, they're like,

1:34:13hey, how will our business be affected by this shift?

1:34:15If it happens, 'cause everybody's sort of like

1:34:17thinking it's gonna happen.

1:34:18And if you're shifting to AR as an interface

1:34:21and the camera as an input mechanism

1:34:23and all of these things,

1:34:24if you look at Apple and Apple's thinking about these things

1:34:27and they plan three years in advance,

1:34:29So three years ago, they were thinking about these things,

1:34:32when they started building out the system,

1:34:35and get all the silicon ready for it and all that stuff,

1:34:37and buying the companies.

1:34:39You know, in 2013, they started buying these companies.

1:34:41And all of that, they're planning for all of this.

1:34:44If you look at it now versus 12 months from now,

1:34:48if the platform shift happens the way people think

1:34:50it happens over the next year,

1:34:5212 months later would be too late.

1:34:55They needed to get out there now with a camera

1:34:58that shows off not only their ability,

1:35:01but also inspires people to think about it

1:35:03and develop this to start developing for it,

1:35:05where they have this true depth camera,

1:35:08they have all of these tools that allow people,

1:35:11more precise accelerometers,

1:35:13the A11 is optimized for AR and for AR applications

1:35:18and for computational photography and obviously Core ML

1:35:21and all of that, all of these stuff is all adds up, right?

1:35:23To a perfect storm of, we need to ship this now

1:35:26and plant our flag in this new platform generation now

1:35:31to pull ahead of our competitors

1:35:33or to push forward in this way.

1:35:36Whereas like Google with Tango,

1:35:38they've got to refactor significantly now

1:35:41and try to, you know, they launched obviously

1:35:43Core AR Core and all of that,

1:35:46and which is fine I hear, you know,

1:35:47it's not like crazy bad or anything,

1:35:49it's they took a lot of Tango

1:35:50and just cut out some stuff, right?

1:35:52But they don't have a Tango device that's mass market.

1:35:55They don't have a, you know, however many they're going to sell these things, 100 million device Tango phone.

1:36:01They tried that and it didn't work.

1:36:03And so now Apple, I think, sees a lot of opportunities for them.

1:36:06They can get a device that has the depth of camera out in the market at massive scale.

1:36:10They can plant the flag in computational photography.

1:36:13They can plant the flag in AR and depth sensing as an input mechanism and output mechanism.

1:36:19They've got a lot of positives here.

1:36:21So they go, why not now?

1:36:23Why can't we take all of the technology that we have

1:36:25and put it in this thing and hell,

1:36:27if we're gonna need this tab to put these cameras in,

1:36:31fuck it, you know, pardon my French.

1:36:33But it's just like we're gonna do this

1:36:35because we feel it's the right time.

1:36:37It's still a great experience.

1:36:38We don't feel it compromises it.

1:36:39Now you can argue that.

1:36:41And then that's what we're gonna do.

1:36:43So that's the way I've been thinking about this.

1:36:45Like it's a superset of the iPhone 8

1:36:47that they were able to launch now to plant a flag

1:36:49for this next generational shift in platforms.

1:36:52- I'm, you know, that was great.

1:36:55That was absolutely one of the great rants

1:36:58I've heard on a podcast in a long time.

1:36:59And I agree with every word of it.

1:37:00- And now here's why it's wrong.

1:37:01- No, no, I agree with it.

1:37:04And so I'm, you know, if I were at Apple

1:37:08and in a position to vote thumbs up or thumbs down

1:37:10on the hardware aspects of the notch, I would,

1:37:15you know, for everything that you just said,

1:37:18I'm gonna give it a reluctant thumbs up.

1:37:20Like, do I wish that they could have all the features

1:37:23and all of the dot projector and the camera and everything

1:37:26and somehow fit it behind the pixels of the display?

1:37:31Sure.

1:37:32Do I think that the, I think the ideal form

1:37:36of the iPhone X design would be a,

1:37:40the same thing with no notch.

1:37:41That's the ideal form of it.

1:37:44And they can't do it, and therefore,

1:37:47since we can't do it, what do we do?

1:37:49I think the notch is reasonable

1:37:52because I think if you didn't have the notch,

1:37:54if you just had a forehead that was of that thing,

1:37:58then you would have to have a corresponding chin

1:38:00because I think the symmetry matters

1:38:04and I feel like the symmetry is maintained in portrait mode

1:38:07while you're holding the phone vertically.

1:38:10Even with the notch, there is a certain symmetry to it.

1:38:13My problem with the notch, and I think I wrote this,

1:38:18but effectively it's not the notch itself in hardware,

1:38:20it's the way the notch is handled in software.

1:38:22And I'm even willing to go with the

1:38:24embrace the notch UI style,

1:38:26again while you're holding the phone vertically.

1:38:28It's the fact that when you hold it horizontally

1:38:30that they're going with this,

1:38:32you can see it and you scroll,

1:38:35it's over there on the left all the time.

1:38:37I think it's ridiculous.

1:38:38I think that when you hold the phone sideways

1:38:40they should cover the notch with black.

1:38:42And the thing that I find so surprising about it

1:38:45is that it's when they went to OLED

1:38:46and OLED has the blacks that can hide it.

1:38:49And the best example of it is Apple Watch, right?

1:38:53Like you can't, except in extreme sunlight,

1:38:56you can't see where the display ends

1:38:59and the bezel starts on Apple Watch.

1:39:01The black of the background of Apple Watch,

1:39:04except in the most extreme of sunlight,

1:39:06you just can't see it.

1:39:07And even in extreme sunlight, it's sort of subtle.

1:39:09You have to kind of look for it.

1:39:11So they could do it.

1:39:13And I think it's almost ridiculous that they don't.

1:39:16Right. And I don't I don't I am not the I am not of the camp that I'm trying to say.

1:39:23Apple loves the notch and are just a big fans of the notch.

1:39:29And why can't you see why they're right?

1:39:31I think that they would, as you said, eliminate the notch that they could.

1:39:35I really firmly believe that.

1:39:37I think that it's my my perspective on it is they felt that the notch was worth it, given

1:39:44what the trade-offs were, what they could accomplish.

1:39:48And some people disagree, and some people are like,

1:39:50well they shouldn't ship it because Apple's a company

1:39:52that thrives on detail and look at all of these caveats

1:39:55to this notch, blah, blah, blah.

1:39:57But I honestly think that Apple's guidelines,

1:39:59like design guidelines, if you look at those

1:40:01about making the notch work in your designs or whatever,

1:40:05none of those guidelines are like,

1:40:09the notch is the way of the future, right?

1:40:11They're like, here's how to make your apps work

1:40:13with the notch.

1:40:14- Right.

1:40:16- It's less like, plan for the notch

1:40:18to take over Apple's line of hand computers.

1:40:23It's, this is how you deal with the notch,

1:40:25plain and simple.

1:40:26And that, I think, speaks to me to be like,

1:40:29maybe our next one won't have the notch.

1:40:31And maybe it will for another generation,

1:40:34but eventually that notch is going bye-bye.

1:40:37- And in terms of the keynote,

1:40:39I do kind of admire the keynotes,

1:40:42embrace the notch aspect.

1:40:45And compare and contrast, and I wrote this,

1:40:47but I think it's a very good comparison

1:40:49to the camera bump on the iPhone.

1:40:51And I do think that the notch is very analogous

1:40:54to the camera bump.

1:40:55It's the front-facing equivalent.

1:40:57Ideally, you would want a phone like the iPhone SE

1:41:03and all the phones from the iPhone S and earlier

1:41:06where the camera is flush with the back

1:41:08and you don't feel it, it sits flat on a table,

1:41:11and there is no bump.

1:41:13But I understand why the bump is there,

1:41:16because a thinner phone everywhere except for the bump

1:41:20feels better in hand and thinner is,

1:41:23for lack of a better word, sexier on hardware.

1:41:26And yet the physics of photography mean that the lenses

1:41:31need to be a certain distance from the sensor

1:41:34and bigger sensors require bigger lenses

1:41:37that are further away.

1:41:38It's in conflict.

1:41:42So I get it.

1:41:43But the early pictures of,

1:41:45there were promotional photos of the iPhone 6

1:41:47that were a mini little controversy in our world

1:41:50where they had pictures of the phone from the side

1:41:52where you couldn't see the bump.

1:41:54And the question is, did Apple fake that?

1:41:56And if you sit here and hold it,

1:41:57you can hold it at a certain angle

1:41:59where sideways you can hide the bump.

1:42:01And I think that they were genuine photos

1:42:03that they didn't Photoshop.

1:42:04- That's the way I stand when I go on stage,

1:42:06like just a certain way.

1:42:08- Right. - It's just a certain way.

1:42:09So I look bitter.

1:42:10- And that's what they did.

1:42:14But there's a certain argument to be made

1:42:16that that's actually, even if it's a genuine photo

1:42:18that wasn't Photoshopped, it still is sort of disingenuous

1:42:21not to show the bump.

1:42:22And so they've gone the opposite way with the notch.

1:42:24And literally to the point where one of the things

1:42:27that had people almost like a pop leptic,

1:42:31was that they, in the Johnny Ive narrated video,

1:42:34design video, when they showed video playing,

1:42:36like somebody watching Wonder Woman,

1:42:39the notch was literally overhanging the content of the video.

1:42:44The video is filling every pixel of the display,

1:42:47including round corners,

1:42:49so it's cutting off the corners of the video,

1:42:51and the notch was actually overlaid

1:42:54over the content of the video.

1:42:56And people were like, "WTF, including me."

1:43:01And the truth is, it's just like now,

1:43:05where you can switch between, you double tap on a video

1:43:09and it, you know, even on an iPhone 7

1:43:11and it'll either fill the screen

1:43:12and cut off some of the video

1:43:14or it'll preserve the perfect aspect ratio of the video

1:43:17and use black bars at the top or bottom as necessary

1:43:20to do that.

1:43:21And it's the same way on the iPhone 10.

1:43:23And by default, it actually defaults to doing

1:43:26what I would strongly argue is the right thing,

1:43:28which is preserving the aspect ratio of the video.

1:43:31So it's actually, Apple actually went to the non-default

1:43:34in the video just to not hide the notch,

1:43:38which I kind of admire.

1:43:39- Right.

1:43:41Right, you gotta give 'em sort of credit for that.

1:43:44- Right, like there's-- - In some way.

1:43:46- There's a certain integrity to it, I would say.

1:43:49(laughing)

1:43:50- Right, exactly.

1:43:52Yeah, you know, so the camera bump thing,

1:43:55I think that there is a, as you said,

1:43:59there's a straight up allegory between those two.

1:44:01However, that camera bump's only gonna get bigger

1:44:04over the next couple years.

1:44:05So it makes me wonder how the notch will do,

1:44:09how soon it will go or how soon it will,

1:44:12they'll find a way to circumvent.

1:44:14And whatever that is, by the way,

1:44:16they're already working on it

1:44:17and have been for a year or two, right?

1:44:19Like whatever we're trying to divine,

1:44:22they've already done it or already figured out

1:44:25how they're gonna do it.

1:44:25And like the camera bump, you look at next year,

1:44:28that camera, I'm saying next year, right,

1:44:30I'm just pulling this out of my butt.

1:44:31I don't know when they're gonna actually do it,

1:44:33but next year whenever they decide to put a depth camera

1:44:37on the other side of the phone,

1:44:40that bump's gotta get bigger,

1:44:41or they gotta rearrange the elements inside it

1:44:43to make room for the IR emitter and projector

1:44:46and all that jazz.

1:44:47Now it's less effective on that side of the phone,

1:44:49to be honest.

1:44:50It's much more effective when it's close,

1:44:53so they may be working on other systems

1:44:55for the other side of the phone.

1:44:55They may not be an exact mirror,

1:44:58'cause IR is obviously much more efficient at close range.

1:45:02But whatever it is, it's gonna have to go in that bump.

1:45:05- I do think, again, I have no inside juice on this

1:45:10whatsoever, and I could be totally wrong.

1:45:13But again, I think you're right,

1:45:14that it probably either won't be IR,

1:45:17or if it is IR, it won't be quite as effective

1:45:19because IRs, it's mostly there for your face,

1:45:23and for portrait photos, and for the face ID.

1:45:26But there might be something else that they can do

1:45:29to do a depth map on the back.

1:45:32And I do feel like that's part of how phone photography,

1:45:37meaning no matter how big that camera bump is going to get,

1:45:42in theory, it has to be easy enough

1:45:45to still slip in your jeans.

1:45:47So it's never gonna be the size that,

1:45:50and I don't think it's ever going to telescope out

1:45:53like some point and shoot cameras do.

1:45:55It's never, the camera lens is never gonna be that big.

1:45:58So within the confines of the physics

1:46:01of a phone-size camera system,

1:46:05I feel like the way that phone photography

1:46:09is going to continue to catch up

1:46:11and/or pull ahead of true photo,

1:46:16you know, true camera cameras,

1:46:18would be things like depth mapping

1:46:21combined with the, it's computational photography,

1:46:25but it needs, I think it,

1:46:27there's room for additional sensors back there.

1:46:29In not not physically, but room in in in the system.

1:46:34- Philosophically.

1:46:35- Philosophically, perfect.

1:46:36- Yeah, yeah, yeah.

1:46:37And 'cause I think that there's definitely not a scenario

1:46:42where you just take the exact same array and flip it around

1:46:45and it's really all that useful.

1:46:47But whatever it is,

1:46:49they're definitely working on something there.

1:46:50And so that bumps not going, not going bye bye.

1:46:52- One thing that only really occurred to me like yesterday,

1:46:55thinking about this is that this is the first time

1:46:59to my memory, unless I'm missing a feature,

1:47:01this is the first time that there is something

1:47:04to the front-facing camera that is way better

1:47:07than the back camera.

1:47:09Like the, you know, whatever you wanna call it.

1:47:11I mean, I'll just say it, I'll just say the word selfie.

1:47:16The selfie camera has always been--

1:47:20- Did you break out in hives?

1:47:22- Well, if Shiller can say it, I can say it.

1:47:24I guess they call it, what do they call it?

1:47:28The FaceTime camera, I think they still call it,

1:47:30but they should call it the selfie camera.

1:47:33But the front-facing camera has always been a subset

1:47:37and really a sort of severe subset

1:47:39of the back-facing camera.

1:47:40It's always had smaller sensor

1:47:41and it's just not as good a camera.

1:47:44The depth stuff, the stuff that's in the notch,

1:47:50it in some ways makes it better.

1:47:53It actually is, you know,

1:47:55it's a really interesting piece of technology

1:48:02and the back camera doesn't have it.

1:48:04Kind of interesting.

1:48:05- Yeah, that's true.

1:48:06I didn't think about that either.

1:48:08That makes total sense.

1:48:10I mean, I think that, it's never leapfrogged.

1:48:13It has come on parody at some point, I think.

1:48:17Like, and remember too that like, you know,

1:48:20with the caveats that the lens elements

1:48:22are always different, front versus back,

1:48:23'cause you need different field of view and all that.

1:48:25I think at some point it reached sensor resolution parity

1:48:30or sensor parity, but then they always

1:48:32kinda go back and forth.

1:48:34But yeah, I think so, I think you're right.

1:48:36Definitely it speaks to the times

1:48:39and how people use their phones.

1:48:40The rise of the selfie is not just about

1:48:43taking pictures of yourself,

1:48:45it's about how people communicate.

1:48:47The Snapchat generation and people that are comfortable

1:48:51communicating either via video or image in place of text.

1:48:56It does definitely make sense to focus on that camera more

1:49:01and devote technology to it.

1:49:03And of course, Face ID, you know, all of that.

1:49:05It's an amalgam, right?

1:49:06It's not like, oh, this is the reason.

1:49:08But yeah, yeah, yeah, definitely a good point.

1:49:11- Should we jump to talking about Face ID?

1:49:17Is there anything else on, I mean?

1:49:21- Yeah, we can.

1:49:22I mean, you had Craig on your show,

1:49:24I already had that, which was nice.

1:49:26- You had an interview with him for TechCrunch,

1:49:28which was also nice,

1:49:31and you covered the privacy-related aspects of it

1:49:34that kind of slipped my mind,

1:49:35so that's kind of interesting.

1:49:37So I guess we don't have to spend a ton of time on Face ID

1:49:39because you've written about your interview,

1:49:41previous episode of the show is me talking

1:49:43to Craig Federighi about it,

1:49:44and I don't think there's much left on the table,

1:49:47but I, you know--

1:49:48- I don't think we're more qualified

1:49:49to talk about it than Craig.

1:49:50- Right.

1:49:51Do you know what really, what blew me,

1:49:53what blows me away about Craig is

1:49:55that he clearly understands every single aspect

1:50:00of everything Apple is doing at a technology level

1:50:04in the sense of that great Richard Feynman axiom

1:50:08that the only way to prove

1:50:12if you truly understand something

1:50:14is if you can deliver a freshman essay

1:50:17essay, or not essay, but what do you call it, lecture about it.

1:50:23Can you explain it?

1:50:24Explain it to a five-year-old.

1:50:25Let's put it that way.

1:50:26If you can't explain it in plain terms, then you don't truly understand something.

1:50:30And Craig excels at explaining how all of this stuff works, like differential privacy

1:50:36and all the complex ways that they're managing.

1:50:40So he understands everything they do and has time to manage all these teams.

1:50:47It's like I kind of get it that it's useful for Apple

1:50:52to have a senior executive who truly understands

1:50:54all of the technology the company's working on.

1:50:56I get it, but I can't believe that that individual

1:50:59is also somebody who manages all of the software teams

1:51:02at the same time, which you would think would be,

1:51:06take up 60, 70 hours a week.

1:51:09- Yeah, and it reminds me of this, the anecdote,

1:51:15And I'd heard the anecdote before, but I heard it first person as well.

1:51:18Um, that he, and, uh, from a buddy that, you know, uh, I think, uh, works at,

1:51:25works at ILM, uh, Todd Vaziri, who's, um, you know, I think he's spoken about this

1:51:30on Twitter too a little bit, but he, I guess he, you know, worked with James

1:51:34Cameron at one point, um, on one of his shows and you get, you just get this

1:51:39vibe from, from Cameron that he could do your job or that at least he knows the

1:51:45fundamentals of your job and you are in doubt as to whether or not he could do

1:51:49it better than you. Like, I mean, he may not, right? He may need to sit down and

1:51:52learn all your tools or whatever, but he understands the fundamentals of what

1:51:56you're doing and how to get the performance out of you that he wants.

1:52:00And you have this understanding that if he had the time and if it was in his,

1:52:07you know, schedule to do so, that he might be able to sit down and do this

1:52:10thing that you're doing and that you want to impress him, you know, and that

1:52:14you can impress him because he knows how hard it is to do what you do, you know, or how

1:52:19tough of a task he's giving you, right? Because there's a difference between a manager like

1:52:23that and a manager that's like, has no concept of how hard it is to build a system that you're

1:52:29building or to squash a bug that you're quashing. And one who has been in the trenches and who

1:52:35knows it, or at least, you know, has an understanding of how hard it is. And you want to work harder

1:52:41for those people. You want to do better for those people because you know that they will

1:52:45appreciate it. And I've always kept that in my mind and I'm no Jim Cameron, but I always

1:52:50try to make sure that I'm at least understanding the scope of the things that I'm asking people

1:52:54to do when I'm managing them. And I personally always love it if I've actually tried to do

1:53:01it at least once. And whether that's like pull off a particular tone in a piece or whatever

1:53:09and in editorial, that's that.

1:53:11But in Craig's world, you get the feeling like if he's in there asking you to accomplish,

1:53:17you know, pulling something off like Face ID, where it's like, oh, it takes three quarters

1:53:23of a second.

1:53:24And he's like, no, it should take a third of a second or whatever, that you he knows

1:53:28what's needed to get there.

1:53:29And you want to impress him by getting you there.

1:53:31And so that's a different kind of vibe than a manager who who you think is really just

1:53:35there to manage you as a cog.

1:53:37- Yeah, and Cameron is, he's spoken,

1:53:42I've seen him speak about Stanley Kubrick.

1:53:44He's a huge Kubrick fan, and I think that same thing

1:53:46was true with Kubrick, where he mastered all aspects

1:53:49of movie making.

1:53:50He could edit, he could shoot.

1:53:52Famously, had the camera in his hand for tons of shots.

1:53:55And I remember reading a story,

1:53:58I'm gonna botch this a little bit

1:53:59'cause I'm doing it from memory,

1:54:00but one of Kubrick's early studio movies

1:54:03was a great, great heist movie called The Killing.

1:54:06I love all those movies, but if you like heist movies,

1:54:10but you're wary, you're like, I don't like old movies,

1:54:14but this is so good, and it so sort of presages

1:54:17the Tarantino style.

1:54:18- It's influenced The Dark Knight too, like so much,

1:54:20you know, all of that.

1:54:21- But there's this great anecdote.

1:54:22There's an early scene, I forget when they put it,

1:54:27'cause it is chopped up chronologically,

1:54:29but there's a scene where they're planning the heist,

1:54:33and it's in the one guy's apartment,

1:54:34and it takes place in two rooms,

1:54:35and there's a dolly shot where they're in one room

1:54:38and in one take the camera pans or dollies sideways

1:54:42to go from one room to another.

1:54:44And it was one of the first shots they shot at least.

1:54:46It was one of the first scenes that they shot and the thing.

1:54:49And the cinematographer had this all set up

1:54:51and Kubrick came in and like looked at it

1:54:53and it was like totally like lazy,

1:54:55you know, like the way that it was lit.

1:54:57And he's like, no, no.

1:54:58And the guy was like, well, you know,

1:54:59it's gonna take forever to do it the other way.

1:55:01And Kubrick was just like, fuck you.

1:55:02And he like went and did it

1:55:03and just set up all the lights the right way

1:55:06and said move and just did the dolly shot himself.

1:55:09And then like the cameraman was like, oh shit,

1:55:11this guy could do my job.

1:55:13And so it's like, I better up my game

1:55:15or I'm gonna get fired.

1:55:16And totally changed the way he came in to every single scene.

1:55:21He's like, I better do the best that I can do.

1:55:23And I think you're exactly right.

1:55:24What else is there to say about iPhone 10?

1:55:29I mean, it's, what are the differences

1:55:32- Between iPhone 10 and iPhone 8.

1:55:34The screen is obviously different.

1:55:36- The depth camera.

1:55:37- Depth camera. - Yeah, the screen is different.

1:55:40The screen is OLED, you know, obviously.

1:55:43That's a huge jump.

1:55:44One thing, and I don't know the answer to this,

1:55:46but one thing a lot of people are talking about right now

1:55:48is whether that OLED is pen tile construction or RGB.

1:55:52And they're leaning towards pen tile

1:55:54because of the dithering at the corners

1:55:56that gives it that nice smooth curve.

1:55:59It's a sub-pixel anti-aliasing, I guess,

1:56:00that's being used for that curve.

1:56:03And the question then is, if it's pen tile,

1:56:07because of the way the pen tile screens are constructed,

1:56:10the apparent resolution may be actually less

1:56:12than the actual resolution.

1:56:15In other words, they're wondering if it's sharp or not,

1:56:18as sharp as the iPhone 8.

1:56:19I don't know, 'cause I've only seen it briefly,

1:56:21obviously, there at the event,

1:56:23how those screens compare.

1:56:27But that's an interesting thing that I wanna look into.

1:56:31Well, who knows what that'll be,

1:56:33but that might be a minor controversy.

1:56:35- Yeah, I suspect, though, that even if it is pen tile,

1:56:38and I have no idea, but even if it is,

1:56:41there are so many virtual pixels print,

1:56:45or what they claim to be the pixels print,

1:56:48that even if it is pen tile,

1:56:49it still should be smoother, I think, than an iPhone 8.

1:56:53Whether it would be smoother than an 8 Plus, I don't know.

1:56:56But the 8 Plus has the weird thing

1:56:58where it's still a scaled down interface.

1:57:01It still is not really a true 3X.

1:57:04It's like you treat it as 3X,

1:57:05but they scale it to a certain degree,

1:57:08which decreases the actual sharpness of it to some degree.

1:57:12I don't know.

1:57:13And if I had-- - Yeah, and the iPhone X

1:57:14is 3X too, so it's gonna be different.

1:57:17- So even if it's pen-tiled though,

1:57:19I feel though that it should be at least as sharp

1:57:22as the 8 Plus.

1:57:23I don't know, I had about 10 minutes with it in my hand

1:57:26in the hands-on area, and to my not great eyes,

1:57:31but good enough, it looked very good.

1:57:34And I thought the color was excellent,

1:57:36which is my big concern with all OLED screens.

1:57:39I thought the color was totally,

1:57:41and I saw it side by side with an iPhone 8,

1:57:45and the color was just spot on.

1:57:48So I don't know, I have no hesitation.

1:57:52I can't wait to spend more time with it,

1:57:54but I think it's a very nice display.

1:57:56So the display's better. - Yeah, we got that.

1:58:01Oh, both cameras are OIS now on the back.

1:58:05- Only on the X though.

1:58:06- Which is nice, only on the X, right?

1:58:08But you were asking about differences.

1:58:10And so that's one difference, the iPhone 8.

1:58:12- And the telephoto on the X. - Telephoto is not stabilized.

1:58:15- Yeah, and on the X, the telephoto lens is F2.4

1:58:20as opposed to F2.8, which if you're not

1:58:23photography nerd just means that it's one entire stop better in low light?

1:58:29It's about like 36% I guess is the number that they cited. So the gains are not, you know,

1:58:37it's not not unnoticeable. 36% is a bunch. So when you're shooting in low light with that

1:58:45telephoto lens, like let's say at a concert, you know, trying to zoom into the stage,

1:58:49that it might default to that telephoto

1:58:53or use more of that telephoto data

1:58:54'cause it'll be a little bit sharper.

1:58:56Won't be jittery as much, especially with the OIS too.

1:59:01- Right, yeah, so it's with even OIS aside,

1:59:05it's a full stop faster and you have OIS

1:59:08and OIS should add at least another stop.

1:59:10So you should get at least two stops,

1:59:12which is pretty significant.

1:59:14Maybe more, depending on how good the OIS is.

1:59:18but the camera's definitely better.

1:59:20I think that from the time I spent with it,

1:59:24it's even more of an embrace the camera bump

1:59:27industrial design.

1:59:28Like the bump is truly--

1:59:31- Yes, it's got a straight,

1:59:32like it comes straight out from the body

1:59:34instead of having any hint of a bezel.

1:59:36- Yeah.

1:59:37- 'Cause like the, or a--

1:59:39- Slope?

1:59:40- I guess I would say call it a slope, right.

1:59:41'Cause it's not, it's a slope with an additional camper

1:59:44on top of it, but the, or chamfer?

1:59:46I never know which one it is.

1:59:48But this, on the 8, it's straight up out of the body,

1:59:53out of the glass back.

1:59:53It's like bang, you know, like here it is.

1:59:56- Yeah.

1:59:57Trying to think what else.

2:00:01Even just in 10 minutes, you could,

2:00:02and it was nice because in a hands-on area,

2:00:05you could pick both up side by side.

2:00:06It's heavier than like an iPhone 8.

2:00:10I don't know if it's as heavy as the Plus,

2:00:12but the Plus feels so much bigger in hand

2:00:14because it's so much wider.

2:00:15But I think it's just the nature of using stainless steel

2:00:19for the sides instead of aluminum.

2:00:21It's not like it's too heavy, like wow,

2:00:23it's not like I'm telling people this is a reason

2:00:26not to buy the 10, but to me it's heavy

2:00:29in the premium sense.

2:00:31Sort of like the way that the stainless steel watch

2:00:33is heavier than the aluminum Apple watch.

2:00:36It's not like you feel like you have a weight on your arm,

2:00:39but you just feel like you have a premium watch

2:00:41on your wrist instead of a regular watch.

2:00:45- Yep, yep, exactly.

2:00:49Just a little bit heftier.

2:00:51And because it's not as large as the A+,

2:00:54the A+ may feel, as you mentioned, more heavy

2:00:57because if you're holding it,

2:00:58especially if you're holding it from the bottom,

2:01:00'cause I think most people,

2:01:01when you pick up the iPhone 8+,

2:01:03you're gonna hold it from the bottom,

2:01:04and the leverage or balance of the phone,

2:01:08it's gonna be top heavy.

2:01:09And so you have more exertion there holding it upright

2:01:13than you do with the X.

2:01:16- Yeah, bottom line, I think, is if you're on the fence,

2:01:20if there's anything, you know, if you're thinking,

2:01:22I think I want the iPhone X, but I don't know,

2:01:25you want the iPhone X.

2:01:27But on the other hand, the iPhone 8 is, you know,

2:01:30it's really good.

2:01:32I don't know, it's so,

2:01:33I have no idea how this is gonna play out.

2:01:35One thing we know as we record,

2:01:38they've been on sale for two or three days.

2:01:40They're still available.

2:01:40If you, you know, iPhone 8 is on sale,

2:01:42iPhone X is not going on sale till late October,

2:01:44but if you go to buy an iPhone 8 or 8 Plus today,

2:01:47you can still get it on launch day.

2:01:50So, and that is unlike years past,

2:01:53where quickly, sometimes within minutes,

2:01:56it switches from same day, launch day delivery

2:01:59to two to three weeks or four weeks or something like that.

2:02:02So that's not the case.

2:02:04But I don't think that's surprising,

2:02:06because I feel like the overwhelming number of the 100,

2:02:11hundreds of millions of iPhones that get sold every year

2:02:15go to normal people who just feel like

2:02:17they're buying a nice iPhone.

2:02:19And that the number of people who really, really care

2:02:22about having the newest iPhone on the first possible day,

2:02:25it's easy to, 'cause we all talk to each other on Twitter

2:02:31and on podcasts and we read their sites

2:02:34and it's easy for people to overestimate just how many,

2:02:39I don't think that Apple's going to have a hard time

2:02:42selling the iPhone 8 and 8 Plus,

2:02:44but I'm not surprised that they,

2:02:47I'm also not surprised that they didn't sell out already.

2:02:50Because I feel like the people who are gonna sell out

2:02:51a launch weekend thing are all gonna wait for the 10.

2:02:54- Right, yeah, the people that have to have

2:02:58the newest thing, the iPhone 10 is technically

2:03:01three minutes newer, so. (laughs)

2:03:04They're gonna want that.

2:03:06(laughs)

2:03:08It's a twins joke.

2:03:12Yeah, I think that's right.

2:03:15I think that there's going to be a contingent of people that are buying this early that

2:03:19are really just going to gravitate towards the X because of who they are, what kind of

2:03:21buyer they are, what kind of user they are.

2:03:24I think that there are some people going like, so I was asking, I asked a couple of people

2:03:29while I was there.

2:03:30Horace Didier was there, analyst extraordinaire, and Ben Meharian, also an analyst.

2:03:36And I asked them both what they thought about the gap between the pre-orders, between the

2:03:42iPhone 8 and 8 Plus and the X, and whether it would hurt Apple or how it would affect

2:03:47their guidance or quarters or whatever.

2:03:51And Ben said that the guidance that they gave last time was so wide, so broad, that it basically

2:03:57indicates to him that they don't know.

2:04:00They don't know exactly what the mix will be and that the guidance was so wide as to

2:04:04give them latitude so that it wasn't like, "Oh, they missed their guidance," or whatever.

2:04:08It was just like very wide in terms of range. So it could be, "Oh, we sold a ton of tents.

2:04:15The mix is going to trend later and miss this quarter." Or, "We sold a ton of eights and

2:04:21it's going to hit this quarter versus next quarter." But I asked Horace the same thing,

2:04:27what he thought was a problem, and he said he didn't really think so. As long as it got

2:04:31I heard before Christmas, both models,

2:04:33that it really wouldn't affect the quarter that matters,

2:04:35which is Q1.

2:04:35And I have a semi-informed as well opinion

2:04:42or feeling, whatever you wanna call it,

2:04:47that they don't care.

2:04:48That if you buy a 10 instead of an eight,

2:04:51the answer is, okay, what do they care?

2:04:54They don't care.

2:04:55They're fine with it either way.

2:04:57It's not that they're hoping to sell a ton of one

2:04:59or not the other, they're completely fine.

2:05:02I'm sure they have an idea of what they wanna sell

2:05:04or whatever, but a lot of people forget

2:05:06that Apple, under Tim Cook, one of the superpowers,

2:05:10is that it can have as little as two weeks of inventory

2:05:13at any given time.

2:05:15That is an enormous tactical advantage

2:05:18when you're releasing serialized devices.

2:05:21'Cause you can go, hey, let's just hold off on producing,

2:05:24let's produce 20% less, and that change gets

2:05:27into your inventory channel within two weeks.

2:05:30It's not months where you're eating like tons of devices

2:05:34like Samsung, which was like shuffling devices around

2:05:37at one point, trying to get them into carrier channels

2:05:39to like bolster their quarter,

2:05:41and then the next quarter was like down in the dumps.

2:05:44So that's that advantage they have.

2:05:46- Yeah, and obviously the shipping delay

2:05:49on the iPhone 10 is not perfect.

2:05:52I'm sure that in a perfect world,

2:05:54it would be the pre-orders for both would have been

2:05:57the same day and they'd both be coming out

2:06:00at the end of next week.

2:06:01But I got the sense talking to people at Apple

2:06:05that it is what it is and this is what happens

2:06:08when you're pedal to the metal trying to do the most

2:06:12that you can't, you know, that this happens.

2:06:15That if we never miss a ship date, if we never miss a goal,

2:06:18that means we're not trying hard enough.

2:06:20- Yes, yes, exactly.

2:06:24If you hit it every time, it means that you let off the pedal

2:06:27somewhere along the line.

2:06:28- And I think-- - And to hit a target

2:06:31within two weeks or four weeks from three years away,

2:06:35that's pretty good.

2:06:36- Well, and let's-- - We hit two different

2:06:38projects within a gap.

2:06:40- Well, let's see though. - Not bad.

2:06:41- 'Cause one thing we don't know, and I'm sure,

2:06:44not sure, but given that it's late,

2:06:46it's obviously difficult to produce.

2:06:50I'm pretty sure that every time Apple is late

2:06:55on delivering hardware, it also is,

2:07:00they can't meet demand immediately.

2:07:03So I'm almost certain, I would be shocked

2:07:06if this thing goes on sale on,

2:07:09I don't know what day of the week it is,

2:07:10if it's like midnight Pacific on a Thursday in October

2:07:14when it goes on sale,

2:07:15if by like the time you wake up Friday morning,

2:07:17it's four to six weeks delivery.

2:07:19Let's see how many they actually ship

2:07:22before the end of the calendar year.

2:07:23But I get the sense too,

2:07:25that whatever that means for Q1,

2:07:28if a lot of them don't get into,

2:07:30even if you pre-order right away late October,

2:07:34you may not get it until December or something.

2:07:38It's very likely to me

2:07:42that it might not be till January or February

2:07:45where they catch up with demand,

2:07:47but even so, they're gonna,

2:07:48If they sell the same X number of iPhone 10s

2:07:52in the 12 months, so be it.

2:07:56It's still, they're just not that quarterly driven.

2:08:00Yes, they wanna have a great holiday quarter

2:08:01and they wanna deliver as many of them as they can

2:08:03and I'm sure they're busting their asses

2:08:05to make that possible.

2:08:07But if they sell 100 million of the things in 12 months,

2:08:13that's still 100 million of them sold in 12 months

2:08:16and that's fun.

2:08:18I guess the last thing, if we do talk about face ID, the thing, and I know I brought it

2:08:27up with Federighi, but we can talk about it a little bit freer.

2:08:32It was a little uncomfortable to bring it up that I spoke, you know, I have friends

2:08:35who work at Apple and I, you know, at least two of them who have been disclosed and have

2:08:41been carrying iPhone 10 around for a while, who I spoke to when I was out last week.

2:08:46And they, again, and I have, however much I often say that Apple has never lied to me.

2:08:55I've never been told a lie by Apple PR.

2:08:58When I've spoken off the record with executives like Phil Schiller or whoever, I've never

2:09:04been lied to.

2:09:06It's part of the company.

2:09:07It's why they have integrity like that.

2:09:10And they have their view on the long run, right?

2:09:13where they're not gonna tell a lie,

2:09:15which would then make me mistrust everything

2:09:17they tell me henceforth.

2:09:19Have I ever been told things that I suspect are spin?

2:09:22Of course, right?

2:09:23They always try to put the best spin on things.

2:09:25But when I talk to friends who work

2:09:26in the lower levels in engineering, they don't spin.

2:09:29They'll either not say anything or give me a look

2:09:33or tell me what they really think about something.

2:09:37Because why wouldn't they?

2:09:39It's not their job to spin things.

2:09:42what I've heard talking to people who've been,

2:09:44had firsthand experience with Face ID

2:09:46is that it works great.

2:09:48It is like the facial, you know,

2:09:50facial equivalent of Touch ID.

2:09:52Once you get used to it, you can't go back.

2:09:55And all of the people who are worried

2:09:57that this is gonna suck,

2:09:58and I really think Samsung in particular

2:10:00really pissed in the well on this one

2:10:02by shipping a shitty camera-based Face ID feature years ago,

2:10:09which could be spoofed by a printout of a photo of you,

2:10:12and which Samsung, knowing that it wasn't all that secure,

2:10:16wouldn't let you do things like authorize payments with it.

2:10:19It was only really used for unlocking the phone.

2:10:22- Yeah, and they warn you that it's a convenience feature

2:10:25and not a security feature and all this stuff,

2:10:27but that's not the way people absorb that.

2:10:30They just say, "Oh, face ID, facial recognition."

2:10:34That's it, all phones in the same blanket.

2:10:36- Can I vouch for it firsthand?

2:10:37No, because I have never once used Face ID

2:10:40because I couldn't set it up in the hands-on area

2:10:43on a demo phone and I don't have a iPhone X yet.

2:10:48So, you know, I can't vouch for it.

2:10:50But based on what I've seen

2:10:52and seeing people who do have it use it,

2:10:55it really just works.

2:10:56And the analogy is, I brought it up with Federighi

2:11:00and I really think it's true.

2:11:01Is it seems to me like it's exactly like the way

2:11:04with the original iPhone back before,

2:11:06in our naive days where people didn't even lock their phones

2:11:10and it was just, you'd wake the phone

2:11:12and there was a nice little thing there,

2:11:13swipe to unlock and you swiped it and you were in.

2:11:16And now you just pick up your phone

2:11:18and because of the, what's the name of the feature

2:11:20where it wakes up, the phone wakes up

2:11:23just by the accelerometer, whatever they call it.

2:11:26But you don't even have to hit the power button now.

2:11:28Your phone just, the screen turns on

2:11:30because it sees that you've picked it up

2:11:32and you just swipe up from the bottom and you're in.

2:11:35You don't have to think about the face ID part

2:11:36because you just look at it and the face ID happens

2:11:39and you just swipe up and you're in.

2:11:40It seems great.

2:11:42- Yeah, and that moment of first unlock or whatever,

2:11:50that's the only thing that's really gonna convince anybody.

2:11:54You could say it, so you're blue in the face,

2:11:56you can ask people, and I ask people too,

2:11:58and they were very positive about their experience

2:12:00was over weeks or months.

2:12:02But none of that really matters.

2:12:06I think that they have, if anything,

2:12:10is probably making Federighi grit his teeth

2:12:13over the next four weeks is that people haven't tried it

2:12:16and they're already assuming that it's crap.

2:12:18And they're doing that because of the institutional

2:12:21knowledge they have from unreliable systems of other types

2:12:25that are in the same bucket.

2:12:27- Which iPhone X do you think looks better?

2:12:29- Mm.

2:12:31- It's a hard one, but I don't know,

2:12:34I'll probably have to go with black.

2:12:35I just like the, 'cause I'm a Jet user, you know?

2:12:38So like the Jet, it's the same thing as the Jet for me,

2:12:41'cause it's all black.

2:12:42- I'm gonna get black, but I've always gotten black,

2:12:48and I always will get black, but I kind,

2:12:50there's a part of me that wishes that the black one

2:12:52had the same chrome sides as the white one,

2:12:56'cause I really kinda like that pure chrome

2:12:59stainless steel look on the first one.

2:13:02- Yeah, and it's not chrome, it is stainless steel,

2:13:05but it looks like chrome, and that's stainless steel,

2:13:07so it's not a coating or anything like that,

2:13:09it's just stainless steel.

2:13:10- Yeah, I'm using chrome in the terms of that

2:13:12it's just that sort of shiny, pure steel-colored steel

2:13:16as opposed to the black, on the black one,

2:13:19the sides are darkened somehow, it's space black

2:13:22or whatever, space gray, whatever they're calling it.

2:13:25They both look good and it's a very, very close call.

2:13:27I've never bought a white one,

2:13:30but the fact that the face on both is black

2:13:32at least puts it into play for me

2:13:34that I would maybe get the white one,

2:13:35but boy, that really does look good.

2:13:38I don't have anything else on iPhone 10.

2:13:40I'm ready to move on.

2:13:41- Yep. - All right.

2:13:43Let me thank our third sponsor of the show.

2:13:45It's our good friends at Audible.

2:13:48Audible has an unmatched selection of audio books,

2:13:50original audio shows, news, comedy, and more,

2:13:53and you can get a 30 day free trial at audible.com/talkshow.

2:13:57Just slash talk show.

2:13:59If you wanna listen to it, Audible has it.

2:14:01You can listen to audio books from virtually every genre,

2:14:04anytime, anywhere, best sellers,

2:14:07things from the back catalog.

2:14:09And you can play Audible's audio books

2:14:12on almost any device that you have.

2:14:14Your phone, your tablet, your computer,

2:14:16most modern Kindles and even iPods.

2:14:19Remember iPods?

2:14:20Audio books are great for flights,

2:14:22They're great for long road trips,

2:14:24and they are great for your daily commute.

2:14:26If you run out of pod, I always say this,

2:14:29you're listening to me tell you this,

2:14:31you obviously are a consumer of spoken audio content.

2:14:36Audible is the perfect sponsor for a podcast

2:14:39because they can fill, if you ever think like,

2:14:41man, I wish there were more podcasts.

2:14:42Well, guess what?

2:14:43Audible can fill all of that time in your commute

2:14:46or wherever it is where you wish

2:14:47you had more good stuff to listen to.

2:14:51It's just truly great.

2:14:53So with audiobooks and spoken word products,

2:14:56you're gonna find what you're looking for at Audible.

2:14:58And you can get a free 30 day trial

2:15:01by signing up at audible.com/talkshow.

2:15:04That's audible.com/talkshow.

2:15:06And when you get that free trial,

2:15:09you get your first audio book for free

2:15:10and there's no stress or obligation.

2:15:12You can cancel your membership at any time.

2:15:15So you get a free book, you can't lose.

2:15:17So go check them out.

2:15:19I don't have nearly as much to say about the other products

2:15:21that were announced.

2:15:22I think they're interesting.

2:15:24If we go backwards, what would be next?

2:15:26I guess the watch--

2:15:27- I got an hour and a half on the old watch bands.

2:15:32I got time.

2:15:33- I guess the, what was first, watch, I guess.

2:15:39So I guess if we're gonna go backwards,

2:15:40it would be Apple TV 4K.

2:15:42Apple TV 4K is Apple TV.

2:15:45It is faster because it has, I think it has the A10 now.

2:15:48And it supports 4K and Apple is working with the studios to get all of the movies, you know,

2:15:54in iTunes at 4K and they've already got Netflix at 4K and they've put a rubber ring around the

2:16:01menu button on the remote. Oh yeah, I was wondering what that white thing was. So that's it. So that's

2:16:10how they have fixed everybody's complaints about the remote control is they put a white rubber

2:16:15ring around the menu button. So it does feel different. It's not just painted on. There is a sort of...

2:16:21Like it's a physical thing. Yeah, it's a physical like rubbery ring around it.

2:16:26And I guess that the theory is that helps orientation, right? Like so you know what direction you're grabbing it in.

2:16:31But that was never really my problem. It's that it's as slippery as hell and like you can't really control it well.

2:16:39I just think I being in stuff I really wish that they had made it asymmetric. I don't

2:16:44know how but there should be some way that it is a nice looking remote and but I'm sure

2:16:50there's some way that they could make it somehow like a wedge shape in a way or something that

2:16:56would easily and no matter which way you pick it up would instantly let you know whether

2:17:01it's forward or backwards. And I feel like now that you've still got to reach for the

2:17:05the middle and figure out where menu is.

2:17:07It's better, but it's like the least they could possibly do

2:17:10to improve that remote.

2:17:12- Yeah.

2:17:14I don't know, I think a lot of the improvements

2:17:17for the remote for me could come in software.

2:17:19Like, you know, a little bit more of a snap to.

2:17:22- Yeah.

2:17:23- Which, you know, I haven't played with the new tvOS,

2:17:25so maybe there is, but.

2:17:26It's just like I have a lot of problems with the,

2:17:30how fast it scrolls and how much of a snap there is,

2:17:34'cause I'm never sure how far over to move my thumb

2:17:37and all of that.

2:17:38I don't know, it's just not a very good remote.

2:17:40- Yeah.

2:17:41I'm not surprised that Apple did this,

2:17:43but to me the nicest part of the announcement

2:17:45is that if you've already bought movies in HD,

2:17:49when those movies that you've already bought

2:17:51get 4K versions, you'll get 4K versions of them

2:17:55because you've already bought 'em.

2:17:56You don't have to worry about it.

2:17:57And I feel, as somebody who has personally

2:18:00pretty much entirely shifted from buying Blu-rays

2:18:03to just buying movies on iTunes, just out of convenience.

2:18:08It is, I'm very thankful for that

2:18:12because that wouldn't be the case with the Blu-rays, right?

2:18:15Like I'm going to get better looking,

2:18:17all those movies that I've bought on iTunes,

2:18:19instead of buying the Blu-ray,

2:18:21I don't have a 4K TV yet, but when I do,

2:18:25I'm going to get a better picture than I would

2:18:27if I were still getting up

2:18:29and physically putting discs in a player

2:18:33Or if I had done the,

2:18:36something I've never done was do the whole thing

2:18:38where you rip them and somehow set up a media server

2:18:41in your house.

2:18:42Like, you know, upscaled 1080 is never gonna look as good

2:18:45as 4K downloaded from, streamed from iTunes.

2:18:48So, hooray to Apple for doing that.

2:18:51- Yeah, that was easily, I feel, the best feature

2:18:56of the Apple TV 4K, right?

2:18:58'Cause like, you know, 4K is a standard,

2:19:00And yes, Apple can argue, and I'm sure they will, that their implementation of it is pristine

2:19:07and they're doing a good job, all this blah, blah, blah.

2:19:10But 4K is really a sort of binary choice in a media player.

2:19:14If your bit rates are strong, if your FPS is high, your Hertz is high, you're looking

2:19:21at 4K, 60 Hertz, HDR in both acceptable formats, Dolby Vision and HD 10.

2:19:28And WVision is sort of a super set of HD 10, but it all pans out to whatever your TV supports.

2:19:36As long as you're doing all those things right, correctly, then it is what it is.

2:19:40Like great.

2:19:41You made yourself a relevant player for the next couple of years as 4K takes off.

2:19:48So good.

2:19:49Good job.

2:19:50Like thank you.

2:19:51But the treat, the flourish, the reveal is that deal.

2:19:56You know, that whoever, Eddy Cue deal,

2:19:59you know, where it's like, oh,

2:20:01this is the promise of digital.

2:20:03You buy a thing and it evolves with technology.

2:20:05You don't buy a physical copy

2:20:06and have to rebuy a physical copy.

2:20:08And I'm sure that the arguments, the arm wrestles over

2:20:12the not-- - With the studios.

2:20:15- People not rebuying, yeah, with the studios,

2:20:17were epic, you know, I'm sure they were.

2:20:20As evidenced by the fact that Disney didn't buy in.

2:20:22So Disney's not currently sold on that idea.

2:20:27- The king of the back catalog, really.

2:20:29- Right, really, exactly.

2:20:31The king of re-releasing.

2:20:33- And they were resistant from home video

2:20:35right from the beginning.

2:20:37Because they had this sort of historical strategy,

2:20:40like I'm revealing my age,

2:20:41because I don't, it just sounds ridiculous

2:20:44by today's standards.

2:20:45But when I was a kid, what Disney would do is,

2:20:50I remember going to see Dumbo in the theater

2:20:54and Dumbo was made in like, I don't know,

2:20:56like 1940 something, I think.

2:20:58And every like 10 years, they would make a big deal

2:21:01and reissue one of the classics from their back catalog

2:21:04with all of the promotional fanfare of a new release,

2:21:07you know, TV commercials.

2:21:09And it just like a first run release,

2:21:11like here, we're gonna put Dumbo,

2:21:13you know, this summer you can go see Dumbo

2:21:15and, you know, made tons of money of her.

2:21:18But that way, as a kid who was born in 1973,

2:21:22I grew up and saw Dumbo and Bambi.

2:21:26And I vividly remember Pinocchio.

2:21:28Pinocchio I frickin' loved because that whole,

2:21:32I don't know, I won't get into it,

2:21:34but man, oh man, Pinocchio blew me away

2:21:36'cause it was so dark, right?

2:21:38- Yep. - Really dark.

2:21:39I was like, I can't believe this.

2:21:41This is like the sickest, this movie is sick.

2:21:44(laughing)

2:21:46- It's like a David Lynch Disney fairy tale.

2:21:49- Yeah, that movie is fucked up.

2:21:51It really is.

2:21:53And I remember my sister was like,

2:21:55my sister's two years younger than me,

2:21:56and she was like messed up, but I loved it.

2:21:59But I saw all those movies in the theater,

2:22:01so they were resistant to it,

2:22:02and I can see why they're resistant to it now.

2:22:04But to me, the argument is, look, times change.

2:22:07You know what I mean?

2:22:08Just in the same way that like VHS and home movies changed,

2:22:14It changed the world in the '80s,

2:22:17and everybody had to get on board eventually.

2:22:19Streaming services like Netflix, just to say Netflix,

2:22:23but Netflix and all of the other Netflix-like services

2:22:28around the world have changed things,

2:22:30where there are fewer people who buy movies now.

2:22:32There's a lot of people who,

2:22:34if they're gonna watch something,

2:22:36they just go to Netflix and watch the most interesting thing

2:22:40that Netflix has available to them, and that's it.

2:22:42and the idea of paying $4.99 to rent a movie

2:22:46or $15 or whatever to buy a copy of the movie

2:22:51so they can watch it multiple times

2:22:52just never even, does not compute.

2:22:54So I feel like for those of us like me

2:22:57who are perfectly willing and happy to spend $15

2:23:00to buy a copy of a movie

2:23:01that I know I wanna watch several times,

2:23:03you should work to keep me in that camp

2:23:08as opposed to making me feel like a schmuck

2:23:10who has to spend another 15 or $20

2:23:13to buy a movie I just bought two years ago.

2:23:16- Yeah, 'cause you're gonna be making more movies

2:23:17and I'm gonna buy those.

2:23:18- Right, and that's the best way I can say it.

2:23:21If I have to spend $20 to get a 4K version of a movie

2:23:26that I've already purchased from iTunes for $20,

2:23:29I'm gonna feel like a schmuck doing it.

2:23:30I'm either not gonna do it and just watch it upscaled,

2:23:33or if I start watching it upscaled and I'm annoyed,

2:23:36I'm gonna feel like a schmuck coughing up that 20 bucks.

2:23:38And I feel like making me feel like a schmuck

2:23:40is not a good way to encourage me

2:23:41to keep doing what I'm doing.

2:23:43- Right, yep, I agree.

2:23:46And so hopefully they'll come around.

2:23:48I mean, there's also, they've got, Disney by the way,

2:23:50it's what I'm referring to,

2:23:52but they've also got that, the movie streaming service,

2:23:56you know, that they're launching, and like, you know.

2:23:58So there's a lot of variables, and I get it,

2:24:00but it seems like they should, you know,

2:24:02should come around, but the fact that we got so much of it

2:24:06right off the bat, and that I'll be able to,

2:24:09And you and I and everybody who buys one will be able to launch their catalog and start

2:24:12watching super crisp 4K stuff as long as their TV is already 4K.

2:24:17That's great.

2:24:18And I think that there is a little bit of market pressure built up and that people who

2:24:20have been replacing their TVs over the last couple of years and if they did, they probably

2:24:24got 4K.

2:24:25You know, it was pretty expensive to buy a 4K TV in like, I don't know, 2014, 2013,

2:24:322014, but it hasn't really been off the charts expensive in a while now.

2:24:37You can get a 4K TV starting at 350 bucks

2:24:40if you're prepared for it not to be such a great 4K TV.

2:24:43But even the high-end ones are still a couple of grand,

2:24:46not 10,000.

2:24:48- Right, yeah.

2:24:49It's entering.

2:24:50To me, I know that Apple TV debuting right now

2:24:55is not the first 4K box that you can connect to your TV.

2:24:59But to me, it feels like they timed this perfectly.

2:25:02Fall 2017 is exactly the right time for Apple

2:25:04to have a 4K Apple TV.

2:25:06Like I don't think they're late to this at all

2:25:08'cause I feel like you said,

2:25:09like the prices on actual 4K TVs

2:25:13are now entering normal people's,

2:25:15this is what I feel like is a reasonable amount

2:25:16to spend on a TV.

2:25:18And if they came out next year,

2:25:19I feel like it would be too late.

2:25:20So I feel like the timing is right.

2:25:23- For sure.

2:25:23- I don't have anything else.

2:25:26I guess there's the whole sports angle,

2:25:28which is obviously,

2:25:29that's really the only content thing

2:25:31other than getting movies into 4K,

2:25:33but the only real content angle on Apple TV,

2:25:37or at least I guess it's more of a tvOS thing,

2:25:40was the sports angle,

2:25:41which I think is interesting as a sports fan,

2:25:43but we'll see.

2:25:46It certainly is one angle.

2:25:48It's the one thing that they talked about on stage

2:25:50that was about getting people to switch

2:25:52from watching regular cable TV

2:25:55to watching TV content, normal TV network content

2:26:00through Apple TV instead.

2:26:02Mm-hmm. Right. Yeah, it- the enhanced version of TV that everybody's been trying to sell everybody forever, you know, here- this was their concession to that or their nod to that in this keynote, in this release cycle.

2:26:18cycle. It looks cool. I mean, I think that they, you know, they executed right from what

2:26:26I could see on the sports side of things. Like, oh, yeah, what's the score? Or I could

2:26:30turn the scores off if I don't want to see them or, you know, that I could see where

2:26:35in the game this is. So I know if I want to tune in or not. Those are all things that

2:26:39the NFL has already proven out that people want with like Red Zone and stuff like that

2:26:43and the big dish packages.

2:26:45Until you get a major league to sign on to that

2:26:51and to sign on to the kinds of enhancements

2:26:55you want to deliver beyond just that little score thumbnail.

2:26:58You know, if you want running stats

2:27:00while the thing is open and all that,

2:27:01like some of the apps already do,

2:27:03like MLB's app already does it.

2:27:05But once it's built into the tvOS level,

2:27:09because those, you know, MLB only built

2:27:11that really nice cool app so that you buy a subscription.

2:27:15Like the fact that it's a nice cool app is a byproduct.

2:27:18Thank you, right, for building a good app,

2:27:21but in reality, they want you to subscribe,

2:27:23which is legit, like that's their business.

2:27:26So if Apple could say, look, what if we get you

2:27:28the same amount of subscribers, but we wanna build

2:27:30a lot of those features directly into the OS,

2:27:32I don't think you're gonna find too many objections there.

2:27:35So it's just a matter of getting the sign on.

2:27:37And so right now, I believe the way it works is,

2:27:40It's apps that A, enable this hook or whatever, and then B, that have live streams in them.

2:27:49So it's pulling from whatever apps already do live stream.

2:27:52There's not an additional deal being cut here to provide live streaming directly to

2:27:57Apple TV or any of that.

2:27:59It's just being pulled out of the apps and then this overlay is being put on top of it.

2:28:04And when you click on one of them, it takes you to that app to watch it or whatever, which

2:28:07is fine.

2:28:08It's a way to get it done now.

2:28:11But it just, if you look at it,

2:28:13it just gives you that glimpse of the future

2:28:16that I've always been convinced is what the whole,

2:28:20I think of cracked it thing is about,

2:28:23what Steve said about the Apple TV,

2:28:25which is that a completely agnostic experience.

2:28:30So whatever you wanna watch,

2:28:33whenever you wanna watch it from whatever source,

2:28:36It's all available in one interface built by people who are interface builders, not

2:28:41by a network or a service or whatever.

2:28:44And it's just like you go like a little, you know, I want to watch the Little House on

2:28:47the Prairie right now.

2:28:48And the system says, oh, well, you have access to Little House on the Prairie free.

2:28:52So I'm just going to start playing it for you.

2:28:54And if the system says, oh, you don't have a Little House on the Prairie, any services,

2:28:57none of the services that you signed in for or your single sign on has Little House on

2:29:03the Prairie, here's six options to buy it.

2:29:05and click on one and face ID that or touch ID that

2:29:10or whatever and boom, you're on your way.

2:29:14And I think that that confidence level of being able

2:29:18to deliver you a multitude of different content

2:29:21across a bunch of different networks all in one interface,

2:29:24it's just so far away yet because of the deals,

2:29:28because of the nature of it.

2:29:30- It is better than it used to be though.

2:29:31I mean, and our family, we like to watch movies,

2:29:35three of us and it is our habit now that if we decide

2:29:40upon a movie, if we know if we aren't just browsing

2:29:43and then like, oh yeah, let's watch that one as we browse.

2:29:45If we have a movie in mind, we speak it to Siri

2:29:47on the Apple TV just to see if we can already get it

2:29:50from Netflix or Hulu where we have subscriptions for free

2:29:53before we spend money doing it.

2:29:55And it really does work great and it's become a habit.

2:30:00And let me take this moment, I have a bit of follow up

2:30:03from a previous show, it's two episodes ago,

2:30:06counting the Craig Federighi show with Jim Dalrymple.

2:30:10I pronounced the R-O-K-U competitor to Apple TV,

2:30:14I pronounced it rock you.

2:30:16And it's in fact pronounced Roku.

2:30:19And the funny part-- - You pronounced it rock you?

2:30:21- Yes.

2:30:22And the funny-- - Wow.

2:30:24- The funny part about that-- - That's great, I love it.

2:30:25- The funny part-- - That's such a good name.

2:30:27- Well, the funny part about it is,

2:30:28at least a year ago or more, I mentioned it on the show,

2:30:33and I called it Rock You, and I got the feedback

2:30:36from listeners that, and they always say like,

2:30:39I don't know if you're just fucking with me or what.

2:30:42(laughing)

2:30:43But in, and the first time I did it,

2:30:45I did think it was called Rock You.

2:30:46I just, I looked at it and thought it was Rock You.

2:30:50And when I said it with Jim last week,

2:30:53my instinct was to pronounce it Roku,

2:30:58and I thought, wait, but I know I pronounced it wrong.

2:31:01I better say it the other way around.

2:31:03And so I said, "Rock you," thinking that I was correcting myself.

2:31:07But in fact, I had internalized the Roku pronunciation, but my apologize to

2:31:11everyone. And, but that really was my thought process. And I'm not screwing with you.

2:31:15I don't have anything else on Apple TV. We're going long.

2:31:21We have Apple Watch to talk about. I don't have a lot to say about it. I mean,

2:31:26it's, I think it's, I think the whole cellular thing is, is,

2:31:31I didn't even set it on stage.

2:31:33This was our vision from the beginning.

2:31:35And I'm not saying they shipped it too early.

2:31:37I'm not saying they should have waited until now.

2:31:40And in the big picture,

2:31:43I do feel like Apple Watch gets such a bad rap.

2:31:46And I'm not the biggest fan of Apple Watch.

2:31:49I didn't even take mine to California

2:31:50'cause I thought, I don't wanna have the charger.

2:31:54I don't know.

2:31:55And I have mechanical watches that I like and love.

2:31:58And so no matter what, I like to switch my watch around

2:32:00But I see so many people wearing Apple Watch on a daily basis.

2:32:04I can't believe that people try to crack jokes about it.

2:32:09Because the whole thing where the Boston Red Sox were caught using an Apple Watch in a dugout

2:32:14as part of a scheme to steal signals from other teams.

2:32:17And the joke that was on Twitter with like 12,000 retweets and all sorts of likes

2:32:22was the real story here is that somebody finally found a use for Apple Watch.

2:32:26and people want to believe that.

2:32:29But I can't believe it 'cause I know so many people

2:32:33who it is their fitness tracker of choice.

2:32:36It's true that it was more ambitious at the start

2:32:41and they weren't sure what it was good for

2:32:44and they talked more about apps

2:32:45and going to that honeycomb app screen and launching apps.

2:32:49And they've narrowed it down to the two obvious things

2:32:53that the watch is really good for,

2:32:55which is notifications and fitness tracking.

2:32:57And they keep making both of those better.

2:33:00And I see so many just regular people

2:33:03on the streets of Philadelphia or San Francisco

2:33:06or the airport who are wearing Apple Watch.

2:33:09It's super popular.

2:33:11And Cook even said in the thing that it's now,

2:33:15presumably by revenue, they never say

2:33:16when they have this list of top watches in Apple is now,

2:33:19was number two behind Rolex.

2:33:21If Rolex was number one, it has to be revenue

2:33:24because it can't be quantity because there's no way

2:33:27Rolex is the number one watch by quantity.

2:33:31Has to be by revenue.

2:33:32And however they've computed this,

2:33:35they now are the number one watch company by revenue,

2:33:38presumably in the world.

2:33:39I don't get the hate on Apple Watch.

2:33:42Like I totally get it if you're not into it.

2:33:45Like I said, I'm personally not super into it.

2:33:48I like it.

2:33:49I really love the unlock my Mac with it feature,

2:33:52which is why I wear it usually like on a work day.

2:33:54It's killer.

2:33:56So the way I look at it is like, you know, I agree with you completely.

2:34:00Obviously, this has been gone over ad nauseam by a lot of smart people that, you know, they

2:34:05were sort of, we don't know what people are going to like, you know, initially when

2:34:09they launched it.

2:34:10We don't know which portion of this is the killer feature.

2:34:15And over the last two generations, they have figured it out.

2:34:17It's fitness.

2:34:18Fitness is the killer feature, period.

2:34:20The rest of the stuff is icing.

2:34:22And that icing is getting good.

2:34:23You know, there's some good stuff about that icing.

2:34:25Honestly, the cellular edition is another piece of icing.

2:34:29It's like, hey, take your workouts and take the anxiety you have of being away from your phone

2:34:35so that if your kid's preschool calls, you're not in the middle of your run,

2:34:40and you've got your phone flapping against your leg the whole time

2:34:42because you're just convinced that some emergency might happen,

2:34:45boom, you've got it right on your wrist.

2:34:46You can at least call and say, "Okay, cool, I'm going to get in my car and I'll be right over," or whatever.

2:34:50"I'm coming back."

2:34:51And it takes a layer of anxiety of being separated from your phone out of it, which whatever

2:35:00you want to say about modern life, I don't care, but people are addicted to their phones.

2:35:03And not just because they want to waste time on them, but because they connect them to

2:35:08the rest of the world, families and all of that.

2:35:11You and I were talking about this last week, but I'll repeat it for everybody who wasn't

2:35:15in your car with us.

2:35:17But I realized that from thousands of years,

2:35:21mankind survived with children

2:35:26wherein you couldn't communicate with them

2:35:28if you were out of earshot, right?

2:35:30Like, you'd only find out how your kid was doing

2:35:33if you were within the distance where you could hear them

2:35:36or they could hear you.

2:35:37And we survived.

2:35:39But guess what?

2:35:40- How do you get them to come home?

2:35:41You yell, you holler.

2:35:42- A lot of kids did die, though,

2:35:43during those thousands of years.

2:35:45Like I'm not a worry warp parent.

2:35:47I don't think my wife is either.

2:35:49I think we're maybe even more relaxed

2:35:52than many of our peers.

2:35:54But we do live in a cell phone world now

2:35:58and now that we have them, it is like,

2:36:01so my example is that Amy's not super into this stuff.

2:36:05Why would she be?

2:36:07But we went out to dinner before,

2:36:10the last weekend before I flew out

2:36:11and just as part of the conversation,

2:36:13I just sort of gave an overview of what we expected.

2:36:16I mean, pretty much came up in the context of that leak

2:36:18from the OSGM.

2:36:21And like, here's what we already know.

2:36:23And when I said that, I think,

2:36:26it looks like Apple Watch is gonna get cellular.

2:36:29And the way I think it will work

2:36:30is you'll just pair it with your phone

2:36:32and you won't have to worry about it.

2:36:34I guessed how it was actually going to work,

2:36:37where you don't get a new phone number

2:36:38and people have to call your watch.

2:36:39You just separate yourself from your phone.

2:36:42And she said, "So you mean I could go to the gym

2:36:44"and leave my phone in the locker,

2:36:47"and if the school calls, it'll come to my wrist?"

2:36:49And I said, "Yes."

2:36:50And she goes, "Well, then I need that."

2:36:52And so for example, she still has an original Apple Watch.

2:36:55And when Apple Watch 2 came out last year,

2:36:57she saw no reason to upgrade.

2:36:58And as soon as she heard this,

2:37:01she instantly was like, "Well, I need that."

2:37:03And specifically in the context of a week like last week

2:37:06where I was gonna be away for a couple days.

2:37:09because ordinarily, she doesn't feel so bad

2:37:12being away from her phone,

2:37:14where her phone's in the locker at the gym

2:37:16and she's upstairs, because she knows

2:37:18that if something happens, they're gonna call me too.

2:37:20And I'm around.

2:37:23But like last week when I'm in California,

2:37:24it's just low-level anxiety.

2:37:27It's not like she refuses to go to the gym

2:37:30if I'm in California, it's just though

2:37:32that in the back of her head, she's like,

2:37:34in the back of her head, she's worried

2:37:36that her phone is going off in her locker downstairs.

2:37:39I think it's a killer feature.

2:37:40I really do.

2:37:41Soterios Johnson Yeah, I do too.

2:37:44And I think that that addition of that layer of anxiety pill or removal or whatever is

2:37:53going to appeal to a lot of people because as Apple said, like this is their vision,

2:37:57whatever, it feels logical.

2:37:59Like it just feels logical that this computer on your wrist should be independent.

2:38:04You know, the tether model is going to the dogs

2:38:08or by the wayside or whatever analogy you want to use.

2:38:11The tether model is gone.

2:38:13- Right.

2:38:13- You know, this whole idea of like this thing

2:38:15has to exist in conjunction with this other thing.

2:38:19About the only thing I think is gonna really

2:38:21be pervasive over the next couple of years

2:38:25is the AirPods because they're just,

2:38:27they don't know how to make them independent yet.

2:38:29- Yeah.

2:38:30- You know, but at some point, if you could put an AirPod

2:38:31in and stream Apple Music directly to it,

2:38:33Like maybe the case is the cellular radio.

2:38:35As long as you have the case in your pocket,

2:38:37because you've got to have that anyway to charge.

2:38:39And then it streams to your AirPods or whatever.

2:38:41I don't know what the hell they're going to do.

2:38:43But I could see them making them independent or wanting to.

2:38:48And so the watch has always felt that way.

2:38:50It's always felt logical to have a cellular radio in there.

2:38:53Now they figured out how to do it

2:38:55while making the watch exactly the same thickness

2:38:57and then a little bump on the back,

2:38:59like a couple of millimeters or a millimeter picker

2:39:01or something less.

2:39:02I thought that he said tiny bit bigger.

2:39:04I could I have to rewatch it.

2:39:05I could swear that what he said was that it's two tenths of one millimeter thicker.

2:39:12I think that's what he said.

2:39:13I say a couple of millimeters, but yeah, it was not that.

2:39:16It was smaller than a millimeter.

2:39:18And if that's literally what Jeff Williams said, again, hats off to Apple for having

2:39:21the integrity of actually admitting it publicly, you know, because I think two tenths of one

2:39:26millimeter you could legitimately get away with.

2:39:28It's the exact same size.

2:39:31- Whereas two millimeters. - But then you know,

2:39:31you get the guy with this caliper out.

2:39:34- Right. (laughing)

2:39:36Starting a class action lawsuit.

2:39:39- Yeah, exactly.

2:39:40- Yeah.

2:39:42And you know, let's acknowledge it.

2:39:44It's reasonably priced, but it isn't cheap.

2:39:48Like, it seems like most of the carriers

2:39:50are gonna charge you $10 a month

2:39:52for the privilege of using this.

2:39:54So that is $120 a year that you're just, you know,

2:39:56in addition to the 400 bucks you pay

2:39:59for the watch in the first place.

2:40:01That is, in some ways, it makes it a premium product,

2:40:06but I thought, I'm not surprised by that at all.

2:40:10I thought no way in hell is any carrier

2:40:12going to let you do this for free,

2:40:14and it seems to me like in my experience

2:40:16with AT&T and Verizon, anytime you wanna add,

2:40:20quote unquote, add a device to a plan, it's 10 bucks.

2:40:24- Yeah.

2:40:26So it is what it is, but I am I going to get one?

2:40:30I don't know. Cause I don't wear it every day. I don't know.

2:40:33But Amy was a sure thing. A hundred percent. I'm on, you know,

2:40:36she's on board and I think I probably will too.

2:40:39What about the red dot?

2:40:42I like get it, but I don't get it. I wish it wasn't there.

2:40:48And I think it's going to be silly with some bands.

2:40:51I just think it's not a great choice to be honest.

2:40:55like if they're to differentiate the cellular watch,

2:40:58but in my opinion, the cellular watch is differentiated

2:41:01by the fact that it's cellular.

2:41:02I don't know what their vision is

2:41:04that people have multiple watches

2:41:05and they wanna make sure to grab the cellular one,

2:41:07I don't know.

2:41:08- I don't get it.

2:41:10I did notice in person that it isn't,

2:41:14I mean, it's obviously red if you're looking for it,

2:41:16but it doesn't seem to jump out as much

2:41:18as it does in some of their photos,

2:41:19but exactly for the reason that you just said,

2:41:21like black is a neutral color.

2:41:25It's arguably the neutral color.

2:41:29And so having black on that side of the crown

2:41:33goes with every strap you could possibly,

2:41:37and/or watch face that you choose,

2:41:40whereas red is a very, I don't know,

2:41:43it doesn't go with everything.

2:41:45I don't hate it.

2:41:46It certainly wouldn't keep me from buying the watch,

2:41:48but I do find it a little curious.

2:41:51- Yeah, I mean, red goes with a gray band or a black band

2:41:55You can even say it might go with a pink band,

2:41:58but it doesn't go with an orange band.

2:42:00- Right, right, orange is a perfect example, right.

2:42:03It's just a little weird, I don't know.

2:42:05So Tim Cook's been wearing,

2:42:08and I've seen just a handful of other Apple Exists,

2:42:11but Cook's is the one who's conspicuous

2:42:12'cause it's been photographed.

2:42:13He's been photographed with a stainless steel Apple Watch

2:42:16with a red thing on the crown for, I don't know,

2:42:20like a year and a half, from even before series two.

2:42:24And it's, you know, other people have noticed this,

2:42:28like, do you think he's been wearing

2:42:29a prototype cellular watch for in 18 months?

2:42:32Or do you think red just used to mean special?

2:42:35Because the original edition gold ones had red there too.

2:42:39I think it was just something special.

2:42:42I don't think he had a prototype cellular one.

2:42:44I think it's possible, but I feel like,

2:42:46I feel like there's, the engineering couldn't have been

2:42:49there back then, even at a prototype level.

2:42:51- I think it's a little far out.

2:42:53- Yeah. - Just my gut.

2:42:54That's just a gut feeling, yeah.

2:42:56- Anything else on Apple Watch?

2:43:00I will say this.

2:43:02There was a black, the older,

2:43:05the first generation of the nylon,

2:43:07their nylon watch straps, woven nylon,

2:43:11there was a black one that I bought,

2:43:13which is my favorite Apple Watch strap ever.

2:43:15I just like the way it looks,

2:43:17and I also find it extremely comfortable

2:43:18in all weather and situations.

2:43:20And in fact, I've worn it so much

2:43:23that it's worn a little bit.

2:43:25Like it doesn't look bad,

2:43:26but it's obviously showing a little bit of wear.

2:43:28And I've been thinking in the back of my head,

2:43:31I should buy another one of those just to have it,

2:43:33because I think that all of these type of straps

2:43:36are limited edition.

2:43:39And lo and behold- - Yeah, they come and go.

2:43:40- Yeah, lo and behold, that one's gone.

2:43:43But I did find one the other day on bestbuy.com,

2:43:45I was still selling them, so I quick ordered one.

2:43:48But I think that there are totally,

2:43:51I think that that must be, if you're like a designer,

2:43:54I think that must be such a fun team to work on.

2:43:56'Cause I feel like they are having so much fun

2:43:59doing like a variety of watch straps

2:44:03that change every six months.

2:44:04And really running the gamut from playful

2:44:08to subtle to elegant.

2:44:13- Yeah, well the new Velcro ones they showed off there,

2:44:19You know, it's just, it's, (laughs)

2:44:22it just makes sense that if Apple's gonna do a Velcro watch,

2:44:25the entire band's Velcro.

2:44:26- Right.

2:44:27- Like the entire band is the loop.

2:44:29- Right.

2:44:30- The Velcro hooks to, you know, the loop material.

2:44:32Like it's not a patch.

2:44:34Almost every Velcro watch,

2:44:36it's there's a patch of contact material that's the loops.

2:44:39And then you have the Velcro hook material on the other side.

2:44:44And the Apple way is to go like,

2:44:46nope, we're gonna make the entire thing loop.

2:44:48So you can attach it anywhere you want.

2:44:50And they know most of the band's not gonna be used.

2:44:52But at the same time, it gives them

2:44:53infinite adjustability and continuity of look.

2:44:57The whole thing looks the same.

2:44:59And from what I felt there, it's kinda fuzzy.

2:45:02- Yeah, it feels very nice.

2:45:04I'm not a Velcro kind of guy, but I have to say,

2:45:07it's the nicest Velcro I have ever seen in my life by far.

2:45:11It's the first time I've ever seen Velcro

2:45:12and thought, this is really nice Velcro.

2:45:17In fact, I even wonder, is Velcro like a trademark,

2:45:20like Kleenex?

2:45:22I wonder if it even--

2:45:23- Well, that's a good question, I don't know.

2:45:24- I wonder if it technically is Velcro with a trademark

2:45:27or whether it's like a Velcro-like, you know,

2:45:31scratchy side on one thing and soft side on the other.

2:45:34- Yeah, but it is definitely a registered trademark, Velcro.

2:45:37So I think you have to use like hook and loop fastener

2:45:40or something like that.

2:45:42- All right, well, I'm about at the end of my list.

2:45:45There was one last thing in the keynote.

2:45:46- Oh, I guess we could talk about

2:45:47the opening Steve Jobs tribute

2:45:48if we're gonna go backwards.

2:45:50I mean, and there's the Angela Orange thing.

2:45:52The Angela Orange thing was interesting.

2:45:53I don't know what else to say about it though.

2:45:56I mean, it's like, you know,

2:45:57here's their new flagship stores.

2:45:59They are architecturally fantastic.

2:46:01They are obviously of the same architectural design language

2:46:05as the Steve Jobs theater itself and the new campus.

2:46:10You know, it's obviously one cohesive architectural language

2:46:15that they're using around the world,

2:46:16including at their campus.

2:46:18But I don't know what else to say other than that.

2:46:22- Yeah, I mean, I think there's some controversy

2:46:24over calling it town halls or whatever.

2:46:26- Or town squares.

2:46:28- Town squares, there you go.

2:46:29And I mean, I'm not the right person

2:46:31to debate civic responsibility

2:46:36and adoption of those things,

2:46:39co-option of those things by corporations.

2:46:44I get the arguments.

2:46:45I don't know, it didn't strike me as particularly egregious, but there, you know, some people

2:46:50are getting all mad about it.

2:46:51But I think that they're already, if you go to like the one in San Francisco that is already

2:46:57converted over to that new model of that town square model or whatever, whereas like indoor

2:47:03out as the patio area and the big doors that open so people can walk through it and all

2:47:12that stuff.

2:47:13Like I get it, they're co-opting something that is theoretically public space, but it

2:47:17is private property and it is a corporate drive.

2:47:20They're trying to sell products and all that stuff.

2:47:23But I think they did a pretty decent job of making those things feel like they had a variety

2:47:31to them that didn't exist in Apple stores before.

2:47:34I think it did at one point, like when a lot of the stores had theaters and stuff like

2:47:38that, you felt like there was always something going on you could go there and see.

2:47:42but I think it hasn't felt like that in a while.

2:47:44And I think that you're now kind of seeing them

2:47:48try to return to that a little bit

2:47:49and bring back the fact that like,

2:47:51hey, you got other things to do here than just buy stuff.

2:47:54- I don't get the controversy over it.

2:47:55I feel like it doesn't matter which company it is,

2:47:58but if you have a retail space,

2:47:59you can either have it be like,

2:48:02you're either, make it feel like you're either in here

2:48:04to buy something or you can either come here

2:48:07to buy something or you can be on our property

2:48:10for a free reason, you know, to see a show

2:48:13or to have a class or just to hang out

2:48:15and sit on a bench and feel welcome doing it.

2:48:18So I don't see how that that ladder

2:48:21is worse than the former, right?

2:48:24Like, how is that not better?

2:48:26And secondarily, I don't think that it was implied

2:48:29in any way that they're going around

2:48:31and telling cities around the world,

2:48:33like, "Scratch your, you know, get rid of your public parks.

2:48:36"We'll take care of it."

2:48:37- Exactly.

2:48:38You know, they're not trying to replace public parks.

2:48:40You know, they're saying that in addition to the public parks

2:48:43that these cities already have, we're

2:48:44going to have a space that's welcome to the people.

2:48:47I don't get it.

2:48:48So I don't--

2:48:49Yeah, I thought it was really great to see her on the stage,

2:48:52regardless.

2:48:52Yes.

2:48:53It did answer--

2:48:54Really, really nice to see her out there.

2:48:55Yeah.

2:48:56That was-- it was the answer to the longstanding question

2:48:59of when is Angela Arnn's going to be on stage at an event.

2:49:03a cynical part of my mind says that maybe,

2:49:06if not for Angela Ahrendts,

2:49:11I don't think there would have been any women

2:49:12from Apple on stage at that event,

2:49:14unless I'm forgetting somebody who did a demo,

2:49:16but I don't think so.

2:49:17Because it was truly the only,

2:49:19but it wasn't like there was a cavalcade of men either.

2:49:22It was really just Cook, Schiller, Federighi, Q,

2:49:26and Jeff Williams.

2:49:27And as I've said many times,

2:49:32they don't pick people to do the segments that the people who come out for the segments

2:49:35of the people who are in charge of them, you know, and so Angela aren't isn't going

2:49:38to be on stage until they decide to speak about retail on stage. And lo and behold,

2:49:42what she was there to talk about was retail. But she was super great. That's, that's

2:49:47the thing people have been itching to see her on stage because they've seen her speak

2:49:50in public places on videos and stuff before and she's obviously a very dynamic, engaging

2:49:54personality. And so, you know, it, you know, the capability was obviously there.

2:50:00And I think the people in the fashion world who knew her before, as the CEO of Bribri,

2:50:06and then also the people who are paid to sort of think about these things and know these

2:50:11things know that she was the CEO of a major fashion corporation and effectively took what

2:50:18you might consider a downgraded position, but certainly an upgraded, outsized impact

2:50:23and influence and size of job.

2:50:26I think size of job wise, bigger job, hands down.

2:50:30But it was good to see her out there because I think that she's just like an enormously

2:50:35capable executive and has been doing a lot in getting her to present her work.

2:50:42Getting to see her present her work is always a treat.

2:50:44It's always nice to see people, as you said, who have done the work and who have been in

2:50:48the trenches working on a product, you know, present that product.

2:50:52And I think it showed that she had done a bunch of presentations around the world.

2:50:57I've been at a couple of, I think it's one of them, she did local presentations at

2:51:02the stores themselves.

2:51:04And she's been doing some of that, but we hadn't seen her on the stage proper.

2:51:07And I think she, you know, she felt very comfortable up there and obviously, you know, was presenting

2:51:12things she had worked on closely.

2:51:14I found this interesting link, this fashion blog called The Fashion Law had written about

2:51:20her out there.

2:51:22And they were, you know, obviously saying, you know, she's an executive who's presenting

2:51:27her work and all that went really well. But they pulled some like fashion marketplace

2:51:32or whatever. And this one fashion marketplace said that, you know, during and for two hours

2:51:37after the time she was on stage, users search for and viewed that pale pink Burberry trench

2:51:43coat that she was wearing, a lace one, every 12 seconds. And like searches on the platform

2:51:51on this listen platform was for the terms lace,

2:51:55pink and trench coat grew by 830%.

2:51:58- That's absolutely amazing.

2:52:00- It's not that she's just out there

2:52:01giving this presentation, she's out there like,

2:52:03I'm a fashionable, trendsetting woman

2:52:08who is also an executive at this company

2:52:10and I'm not gonna come out here and try to untuck my shirt

2:52:14or whatever, I'm gonna dress how I dress.

2:52:16I'm gonna dress how I feel comfortable.

2:52:19And I think there was some nice resonance there with people.

2:52:23- Can I, now's as good a time as ever to bring it up,

2:52:25but I find it so funny personally because, you know,

2:52:29those of you who are longtime followers of me on Twitter,

2:52:33I had a habit for years of when I would go in the keynote

2:52:36and when speakers would come out,

2:52:38I would note who had worn their shirts tucked and untucked

2:52:41and keep a tally for each keynote.

2:52:44And I gave it up at some point around two years ago

2:52:49and because I realized it was completely biased towards men

2:52:52because it doesn't, you know, and I've, you know,

2:52:55it's just one of the ways that I'm trying to be

2:52:59more cognizant of that,

2:53:00and it doesn't seem fair to keep track of it.

2:53:03I'll only keep track of it for men and not women,

2:53:05and it's different, so I just don't do it anymore,

2:53:07but I used to.

2:53:08Here in Philadelphia, we have a nice Apple store

2:53:12on Walnut Street, and right next door to it

2:53:14was an American Apparel.

2:53:15Well, American Apparel went bankrupt

2:53:17and closed all their retail stores.

2:53:18The store that took over that space literally right next to the Apple Store?

2:53:23Untuck it.

2:53:24Wait, wait, let me guess.

2:53:25I was just gonna say it's untuck it, huh?

2:53:27I'm so sorry I spoiled it for it.

2:53:29Untuck it.

2:53:30I will put a photo in the show notes.

2:53:34I will link to a photo of the untuck it next to the Apple Store, which it amuses me to no end.

2:53:39So sorry I spoiled that.

2:53:42That's great.

2:53:43There's one in Soho very near the Apple Store, too.

2:53:45Yeah.

2:53:46And I always see it and laugh when I walk through it.

2:53:48Those of you who don't know, Untucked is a store that,

2:53:50the entire point of the store is that they sell shirts

2:53:53that are meant to be worn untucked, which is what it is.

2:53:58But anyway, I find it so funny that they open

2:54:01next to the Apple store.

2:54:02Yeah, Angela Arnts did great on stage

2:54:05and I'm sure it won't be the last time that we see her.

2:54:08And then the opening, last but not least,

2:54:12going backwards would be the opening Steve Jobs tribute,

2:54:14which I don't even know what to say about it

2:54:19other than I thought it was perfect.

2:54:22I thought that the little passage

2:54:27that we heard of Steve Jobs himself

2:54:29was absolutely fantastic.

2:54:31I've been writing about Apple

2:54:34ever since I started "Daring Fireball"

2:54:36and it so summarizes what it is that I,

2:54:42it puts it, he put his finger on what Apple is

2:54:45and why they do what they do.

2:54:46And why do they go to the extraordinary lengths

2:54:48that they go to and do the unnecessary?

2:54:51You know, why are the handrails cut out in the theater

2:54:54that they're gonna use twice a year for keynotes

2:54:57carved out of stone, you know?

2:54:59Why do they go to these lengths

2:55:02to do things that they don't need to do?

2:55:04And it's, you know, to show their appreciation

2:55:06for fellow humans who they're never gonna meet,

2:55:09never gonna shake their, I don't wanna go out,

2:55:11It's just so perfect to me.

2:55:13And I never heard it before.

2:55:14I asked-- - From what I understand,

2:55:17what I was told was, oh yeah, you asked.

2:55:20- Well, what did you hear?

2:55:21You tell me.

2:55:22- Well, I heard that it was from an internal company meeting

2:55:25and that it was recorded as the internal company meeting

2:55:28and it had never been heard outside of the company anywhere.

2:55:30And I don't even think that it had been replayed maybe

2:55:33since then or I didn't get that vibe

2:55:35that it was like, oh, we listen to it all the time.

2:55:37I think they discovered it, maybe uncovered it

2:55:39or somebody remembered it,

2:55:41'cause there are obviously many people

2:55:42who worked with them for years at Apple

2:55:44that are still there.

2:55:45But it was an internal meeting, speaking to employees,

2:55:48off the cuff, unprepared.

2:55:51This was not a speech he was giving.

2:55:52- Right.

2:55:53- Or something where it was prepared externally

2:55:56to talk to press or talk to even a graduating class

2:56:00or any of that jazz.

2:56:01This was just an internal meeting,

2:56:02talking to employees about why they did what they did.

2:56:04- I have it, so that's, I was told the exact same thing.

2:56:07So as usual, I think Apple actually had a prepared answer

2:56:10ready for-- - Probably.

2:56:12- I have a theory.

2:56:13Now this, I have no little birdie.

2:56:15I was told only what you were told,

2:56:17but my theory is maybe that was from one of those

2:56:21top 100 meetings.

2:56:23You know, that Steve Jobs started a tradition

2:56:26where once a year, I think around May,

2:56:28Apple holds a offsite like over a weekend

2:56:33for what they call the, it's like the top 100

2:56:36and it's executives and managers,

2:56:37and it's 100 people from within the company

2:56:40who are considered like, here's the best,

2:56:43here's our top 100 leaders within the company,

2:56:45and they go and they review product plans for the next year,

2:56:49and who knows what else,

2:56:50but it's obviously, shockingly, very secret.

2:56:52Obviously, politically inside the company,

2:56:57it's a sign that you are on,

2:56:58if you get invited for the first time,

2:57:01it's obviously a sign that you're on the fast track

2:57:03to management.

2:57:05I have it, that's my theory.

2:57:06It's my theory it was from one of those,

2:57:08perhaps the last one that he attended maybe, I don't know.

2:57:12- Yeah.

2:57:14- But it was very, very touching.

2:57:15- It sounds reasonable as anything.

2:57:16- Yeah.

2:57:17'Cause that's the other, the only other thing I was told

2:57:20was that, yeah, it was internal meeting,

2:57:22never before public, and I even,

2:57:24the other thing I was told,

2:57:25maybe you were told the same thing,

2:57:26this would prove that they had it prepared,

2:57:27was that even most Apple employees hadn't heard that before.

2:57:30And the even most Apple employees hadn't heard it before

2:57:34It was what made me wonder if maybe it was

2:57:35that top 100 meeting.

2:57:37- Right, right.

2:57:38- But anyway, it was great.

2:57:39And then I thought Tim Cook's remarks

2:57:42were incredibly touching.

2:57:44And I don't know him personally.

2:57:47I mean, I've spoken to him very briefly a few times.

2:57:49But I don't think he's hard to read.

2:57:53I think most people would agree that even just

2:57:57from his public appearances,

2:57:58he's not really the sort of guy to tear up easily.

2:58:02I think he's a pretty hard-baked individual,

2:58:07at least in public, and I think that the emotion

2:58:09that he showed while speaking about Steve

2:58:12was truly profound.

2:58:14I watered up.

2:58:16You and I were sitting next to each other.

2:58:17I don't know, I watered up.

2:58:19I mean, I didn't have tears running down my face,

2:58:21but they were there.

2:58:23They were like, they were at the starting line.

2:58:25- Yeah.

2:58:30You gotta say, you gotta think that, you know, sharing something like that with the public

2:58:38for the first time, you know, there's emotions attached to that, there's emotion attached

2:58:42to the theater that has his name on it, you know, all of this stuff.

2:58:46Some of it was mentioned by them, but you just gotta think, like, on a personal level,

2:58:52these are still people, they still work with one another, they still built relationships

2:58:55with each other, you know, Steve with his coworkers and his employees, and they had

2:59:01a life, you know, lifetime shaking relationships with these people.

2:59:07And I think that a lot of times people get hyper cynical about this because like, ah,

2:59:10it's a show and it's Pomp and Circumstance and all of this stuff.

2:59:13And it's like, yeah, I get it.

2:59:15But it's really only the most hard bitten and cynical of people that can really manipulate

2:59:20people on that level.

2:59:22And if you do that, it'll be evident in the other ways that you do business, in the other

2:59:26ways that you conduct yourself.

2:59:28And so for me, it felt genuine.

2:59:30It felt straightforward.

2:59:31It felt exactly as it was.

2:59:34People in that auditorium, many of them, especially the senior people, owe their careers and lives

2:59:43and the ability that they have to impact millions of people to Steve and just to be like, "Hey,

2:59:49here's a tribute to you."

2:59:50Hell, if you're going to cry at the end of Fast and the Furious when Diesel drives

2:59:57on one road and Paul drives down the other, why don't you cry when you've got a person

3:00:09that you really, really felt love for in that filial employee way or heck, even friendship

3:00:16way, makes sense to me.

3:00:18Yeah, I thought it was really nice. You could feel it. Yeah, you could feel it in the in the auditorium

3:00:23Well, that's it for me. I mean we were three hours into this

3:00:27for a two hour

3:00:30Just go ahead and cut down to an hour and a half and we'll be fine

3:00:34You've got a big week coming up by the time this airs. You will be knee-deep in

3:00:39TechCrunch disrupt event taking place next week and among your

3:00:44Featured people on stage is going to be laurine pal jobs

3:00:47>> Yes, that's correct. She'll be on stage talking about various efforts to do with students and technology, involving students in tech early and making sure that the pipelines are appropriate.

3:01:00She's been an outspoken advocate of DACA, obviously, of the Dreamers Act, and maintaining that and keeping those opportunities open for immigrants.

3:01:11And then we also have Lisa Jackson.

3:01:15I'll be talking with Lisa Jackson,

3:01:17Apple's head of environment and social issues.

3:01:21- Former guest on the talk show.

3:01:24- That's right, that's right.

3:01:24You've had her before as well.

3:01:26What should I, how should I prepare?

3:01:27Is she a hard subject?

3:01:28- Well, be ready, she's sharp.

3:01:32(laughing)

3:01:34- That's my impression so far.

3:01:35I think I need to be on my toes.

3:01:37- Do you know what?

3:01:38- Definitely gonna get one of this week.

3:01:39- I think that when she was on the talk show,

3:01:41it was evidence of the same thing I said about Federighi,

3:01:43which is that she clearly understands everything

3:01:46in her domain because she can explain it

3:01:48to someone like me who doesn't know jack squat

3:01:51about this stuff so thoroughly.

3:01:54Like, I don't know, her explanation

3:01:55for the environmental design of the new main building

3:01:58at the headquarters was just, it was just like, wow.

3:02:01It's like, I can't believe you're not an architect.

3:02:03So anyway, that's great.

3:02:04So I'll bet, and you guys publish videos

3:02:07of those things, right?

3:02:08- Yep, yep, it'll be up.

3:02:10So those will be videos that I'm,

3:02:11those are two right there that I'm sure listeners

3:02:13of this show will be interested in.

3:02:14So break a leg on the show.

3:02:15Can't wait to see those videos.

3:02:17- Thanks so much.

3:02:18Thanks for having me on.

3:02:19- And everybody can follow you on Twitter

3:02:20at @panzer, P-A-N-Z-E-R.

3:02:23- You got it.

3:02:25- All right, see you soon.