0:00:00Glenn Fleischmann, it is so good to have you back on the show.
0:00:03It's a pleasure to be back.
0:00:05There is so much going on.
0:00:07There's a lot going on.
0:00:09A lot going on this week.
0:00:10Which is good news, I guess, if you're in the business of talking about stuff that's going on.
0:00:15It's bad news if you're like me and at a couple of weeks here where it's just been really hard to make time to record a podcast.
0:00:21I feel like I'm looking at the show notes I made and I'm like, "Oh my God, this is like a month's worth of shows."
0:00:27- It's July, there's not supposed to,
0:00:29well it's August now, there's not supposed to be any news.
0:00:30- It hasn't been like that.
0:00:32It hasn't been like that all this summer.
0:00:33It's great though, really, it really is.
0:00:35I remember when it used to be
0:00:38when there was nothing going on in August.
0:00:41- Yeah, WWDC would happen,
0:00:42and then it would just sort of peter out,
0:00:44there'd be no news, but now we have lawsuits,
0:00:46we have Chinese intervention,
0:00:48we have hackers being arrested on their way out of DEFCON,
0:00:52we got all kinds, or Black Hat, or other--
0:00:54- No, I thought it, or was it--
0:00:55Anyway.
0:00:56- Was it Defcon?
0:00:57- I forget.
0:00:58But they used to be-- - It's Defcon.
0:00:59- Apple used to have little quiet Mac events in August.
0:01:02Remember those?
0:01:03Like, I think like--
0:01:05- Were they introducing new Mac models, not--
0:01:08- Yeah, or maybe like when they first came out
0:01:10with the iWork Suite, they did it like in August.
0:01:13It was like, you know, it'd be like--
0:01:14- It's in August!
0:01:16I never went down for those.
0:01:17I would go down for hardware,
0:01:18but not software in the olden days.
0:01:21But I remember going down to like Aprils
0:01:22and Septembers, typically.
0:01:24Those events, that was before my time of attending events.
0:01:26That was when I did everything remotely from Philadelphia.
0:01:30But I don't even know if I would go out.
0:01:32I guess I would go out for it,
0:01:33but they don't really do small events anymore.
0:01:35Not like that.
0:01:37- Yeah, there's nothing small,
0:01:38'cause everything they do is a $10 billion
0:01:40more line of business, or starts at that and then goes up.
0:01:44- Right.
0:01:44So where do you wanna start?
0:01:46What do you think is the one thing?
0:01:49- Jeez, well, I'm interested,
0:01:51the Chinese market is interesting to me.
0:01:53We start with the VPN?
0:01:54And we have things to say about that.
0:01:56Although it's also a little more, it's a funny situation.
0:02:00'Cause so Apple removed some.
0:02:03I thought there was this, neutrally it sounded like,
0:02:06'cause you can't really check the Chinese app store
0:02:08from another country very easily.
0:02:09It sounded like a lot of VPN apps,
0:02:12virtual private network apps that were being removed.
0:02:15And so there's this thing that, the background is too,
0:02:18so China has various kinds of interception
0:02:20and blocking tools to keep people who are either
0:02:24residents or citizens of their country from
0:02:28reaching outside the country for data.
0:02:30And so, some things are approved and some are not,
0:02:33but they've really been cracking down on a lot of
0:02:36ability to get outside of China or get out at least
0:02:39at some kind of speed that makes it functional
0:02:41to do things.
0:02:42And Google famously left China in 2010 and set up
0:02:45shop in Hong Kong, even though that's, you know,
0:02:47part of China, but it's very confusing little
0:02:49relationship, how that works, that's an ongoing change.
0:02:54And Apple stayed in, it's gotten bigger and bigger.
0:02:57But so the Great Firewall of China is an effort
0:03:00by the Chinese government to, so like standard VPNs,
0:03:03my understanding is you can't just use,
0:03:05you can't just sign up for like a regular VPN service,
0:03:08forget the app part and just use it inside China.
0:03:11So the standard protocols are now being broadly blocked.
0:03:14So you have to use a service that does some other kind
0:03:16tunneling or uses SSL-based or some other system
0:03:19that's not just using the old-fashioned stuff
0:03:22like IPSec and over L2TP and all that.
0:03:26So that's my understanding.
0:03:27So all these services have thrived
0:03:28because they use different ways,
0:03:31and a lot of them are sold worldwide,
0:03:32so it's not just they're being sold in China.
0:03:34Some are China-specific and some are worldwide.
0:03:36And so three of them at least have been removed
0:03:39from the App Store by Apple
0:03:40because the Chinese government says
0:03:43they lack the appropriate license
0:03:46that allows them to operate in China.
0:03:48And Apple said hundreds of other VPN apps remain available,
0:03:53including those by companies that are outside China.
0:03:56So the VPN companies themselves are kind of peeved.
0:04:01They made a lot of noise about it,
0:04:02but it gets us the whole question of like,
0:04:05what is compliance to local law?
0:04:08So we don't think that this law requiring registration
0:04:12of services and compliance with whatever rules China has
0:04:15that might allow blocking and sniffing and other things,
0:04:18this doesn't comport with our feelings,
0:04:20and it might, you know, not,
0:04:21I'd argue it's probably in violation
0:04:23of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
0:04:26in terms of freedom of expression and freedom from--
0:04:29- Well, and let's just stop it right there and admit
0:04:31that whether this particular move is in violation
0:04:35of the Declaration of Human Rights,
0:04:38the People's Republic of China has an awful lot,
0:04:40as official policy, has a lot of policies
0:04:42that are violations of human rights.
0:04:44So fundamentally, this is the thing
0:04:49that frustrates me about that.
0:04:50It is an interesting story.
0:04:51It is absolutely worth noting.
0:04:54It is worth making a stink about.
0:04:55But the knee-jerk reaction from a ton of people,
0:05:00even after I tried to painstakingly,
0:05:02and this is just feedback from people who read my site,
0:05:05but painstakingly tried to say,
0:05:06"Hey, you could be upset about this.
0:05:09"You can even object to what Apple's done,
0:05:11"but you can't just say Apple should've said no
0:05:14and kept the apps in the App Store.
0:05:16Right.
0:05:16Because it's like--
0:05:18I sort of didn't really use the analogy that great.
0:05:21But I said, you pull that thread--
0:05:23like, OK, it's just a little thread, which is saying,
0:05:25no, we're not removing any of these apps from the App Store.
0:05:30You can't say Apple should pull that thread
0:05:32without acknowledging that an awful lot of stuff
0:05:34is going to happen after they pull that thread.
0:05:36It isn't something that they can do in isolation
0:05:38and not expect retribution.
0:05:40My guess is if Apple just said,
0:05:44"No, we're keeping these available in the App Store,"
0:05:46that the great firewall would start blocking
0:05:48the App Store entirely.
0:05:50- Apple would very likely have to exit the market.
0:05:53So there's things in China that are official policy,
0:05:57that are promulgated as laws and regulations,
0:05:59and there's things that are informal,
0:06:00and the government demand stuff happens behind the scenes,
0:06:03and it doesn't conform to any process, right?
0:06:05So this, to some extent, you could say,
0:06:08is like a promulgated law.
0:06:09there's a regulation, you can look it up. They announced they're going to be doing this big
0:06:13enforcement action. So, you have to say, then Apple is saying, we are in opposition to a law
0:06:21regulation in a country in which we're doing business, and we are resisting it without using
0:06:24the channels available to us. Because we don't know, the Chinese, you know, legal system is
0:06:29very opaque. We don't know if they've gone through judicial processes, if they've been working
0:06:32through government agencies. I assume they have. I mean, Apple is no, there's no reason for Apple
0:06:36to court to go like, "Yeah, yeah, we'll just remove whatever they say." So, I presume they've
0:06:40spent the six or seven months since China said they were going to step up this policy in January.
0:06:44I presume they've been lobbying and just saying, "Look, you know, what can we do? What can we do
0:06:49to make this happen where we're not creating a public relations nightmare for everybody,
0:06:54it doesn't become a deal?" And you know, China, I don't think per se cares,
0:07:00the Chinese leadership cares about that part because it's not, it's not something that
0:07:07affects how they govern the country to worry about the response to it, right?
0:07:13Tom Bilyeu (01h00m 10s): The question is, should Apple be in China or not? And honestly,
0:07:19and if they are, if they're going to sell iPhones and Macs in China, this is the sort of thing that
0:07:25they have to do because it is compliant,
0:07:27it's complying with the law.
0:07:28I don't think, for example, that Apple is particularly happy
0:07:35about the Amber Alert thing that your iPhone does
0:07:41when it goes off.
0:07:43I don't think they like that sound.
0:07:44I don't think, frankly, I don't think it's a good law.
0:07:48I think it's, to my knowledge,
0:07:51it's never once helped rescue a child.
0:07:54- No, I think it did once. - Or has it?
0:07:56- It didn't really?
0:07:57- Yeah, I think there was, well, versus the phone,
0:08:00I believe that some of the alerts
0:08:02that have gone up on highway signs and through other means,
0:08:05I think that has actually helped track people down.
0:08:08- But has it helped to have everybody in a certain area
0:08:11have their cell phone make a terrible noise all at once?
0:08:13- Right, I mean, everybody in the north,
0:08:15I got one the other day where it said,
0:08:16like, Meade, Washington, just yesterday at 84,
0:08:19like, Meade is hundreds of miles from here,
0:08:22And I totally get the reasoning behind it.
0:08:25It's not regionalized enough, right?
0:08:27That's the problem.
0:08:27- Right, so, but does Apple have a choice in the matter?
0:08:29No, the law says in the United States,
0:08:32if you're gonna sell a cell phone,
0:08:33it has to, you know, made after a certain date,
0:08:35it has to do this thing.
0:08:36I guess, I think there's a way to turn it off.
0:08:39I think I'm pretty sure I turned it off on my phone.
0:08:41- Oh yeah, you can disable it, that's right.
0:08:44- Right, but by law though, it has to be on by default.
0:08:47- Right.
0:08:49And again, this is not an issue of human rights.
0:08:53It's not an issue of free speech,
0:08:55but it's just the nature of being
0:08:57a multinational corporation that sells
0:09:00in a bunch of countries is you've got to be compliant
0:09:02with the law in every country you're in.
0:09:04I mean, it's a, you know, there's a reason
0:09:07why Apple's legal department is humongous.
0:09:09It's not because Apple has just allowed it
0:09:12to grow into a giant bureaucracy just for the hell of it.
0:09:16It's a hell of a thing.
0:09:17And China is a country where complying with the law
0:09:19is gonna involve things that deeply offend,
0:09:22in my opinion, correctly so, the sensibilities
0:09:24of people in Western civilized democracies.
0:09:28Or democracies anywhere, really.
0:09:31- Yeah, and then of course, and then there's this very easy,
0:09:35the what about-ism response,
0:09:36which you can look up on Wikipedia.
0:09:38It's a great entry for what about-ism.
0:09:40Then you say, well, what about the US?
0:09:42We have all this garbage we do here.
0:09:43We have warless wiretaps.
0:09:46have extraordinary rendition, we have secret FISA courts, all this stuff. But you say,
0:09:50by and large, things come out. Like, by and large, there's a process and most of the, I would say,
0:09:55most of the friction we have about government, let's see, like a continuous thing under any
0:10:01administration, I want to say like, not most of the friction we have about government, but one
0:10:05of the big issues about privacy is that so much of what should be subject to due process and
0:10:13constitutional protections seems to have been exempted without any review of the constitutionality
0:10:18without a good way to overturn that. So, you have lots of organizations in the United States working
0:10:22on that, but we have a process, we have courts, we have SCOTUS, we have a thing that we agree
0:10:26as a mechanism. So, even when we veer towards something that is anti-constitutional, there
0:10:30should be a way to veer back. And it may take sometimes years or decades for that to happen,
0:10:34but we tend to hew towards upholding constitutional rights, which include upholding, you know,
0:10:41which broadly upholds human rights. And we'd argue maybe that, so, my what aboutism is like,
0:10:46well, okay, we're criticizing China for this. But America has all these issues. You know,
0:10:49we have all these things we've done. We've got people in Guantanamo, we've got, you know,
0:10:53trillions of bytes of data being collected every month by people on black budgets who are
0:10:58contractors to the government, sorting through, you know, blah, blah, all this stuff's going on.
0:11:02But I would say we are still fundamentally, we are a democracy with a rule of law,
0:11:06with a justice system that's judiciary, that's independent, and has review,
0:11:10and were wrestling with some of those fine points. So, when Apple opposed the FBI in the
0:11:14San Bernardino case, Apple had a process. It was not ordered to do something, people didn't come
0:11:18in with guns the middle of the night and, you know, point them at Tim Cook and make him march
0:11:23out and find engineers. They went through a process, most of it was public, and the FBI
0:11:28eventually bought tools from hackers to break into the phone and found apparently nothing useful.
0:11:34So, we'd argue, I guess, that in China, it's, you know, partly they have, don't have the same
0:11:39orientation towards the primacy of human rights and individual expression that many other countries
0:11:45do and that we believe is kind of the foundation of, you know, I believe—I don't agree with
0:11:50China's approach to human rights and freedom of expression. I'm not sure it's a valid—I can't
0:11:54even say I think the approach is a valid one in terms of how it crushes the human spirit, right?
0:12:01But I can also understand if I step back and say objectively, they have a different orientation
0:12:05to that, and they are a sovereign nation. They've established their sovereignty. And if Apple wants
0:12:09to work in that market, they have to work within the constraints of a system that is not organized
0:12:14in a way to provide this kind of a judicial access and appeals process and transparency to what they
0:12:19do. Yeah, I totally agree. I think the thing that we do as the United States that's most objectionable
0:12:24on our front are those, the secret orders. I think you mentioned it, right? The ones where
0:12:29the company.
0:12:29Pete: Oh, the FISA court things, right?
0:12:31Is that, or there's also-
0:12:32Michael Gentry. Legally not,
0:12:33legally not allowed to notify the person that it's been issued, which is bullshit. That's,
0:12:38that's to me, a violation.
0:12:40Pete; That is a different thing. Those aren't FISA,
0:12:42has that FISA court, it's, that's a different thing where the government, right, can issue a,
0:12:46right, and that's where you have the canary documents on the site, right? Where you can say,
0:12:50Apple, I forget which site everybody has it, but you have a document that says,
0:12:53the government hasn't asked us for this yet. And if that document were to disappear,
0:12:57that's legal, and it means the government has asked them for something, right? That's a
0:13:02great little mechanism to get around that limitation of—because right, there's an argument that it's
0:13:07probably not constitutional if it were firmly tested. I don't believe SCOTUS has taken up
0:13:12that particular issue.
0:13:14Tom Scott No, I don't think so. So, I really do. I just,
0:13:19it frustrates me that people don't, really don't think this through. And I really do think, so,
0:13:26Somebody, and then some people I've seen,
0:13:28some people arguing that Apple should
0:13:29just pull out of China.
0:13:31They should not, they just should not sell products
0:13:34in a country with policies like this.
0:13:37And I think there is a line that,
0:13:40and I think there are lines that China could feasibly,
0:13:44it might actually happen where China would make a demand
0:13:47that would prompt Apple to actually pull out of China
0:13:50and sacrifice all the money.
0:13:51I think, for example, if China mandated
0:13:53that there has to be a backdoor to get into the,
0:13:57like a San Bernardino backdoor, some kind of golden key
0:14:00so that a confiscated phone in the People's Republic
0:14:03of China that the government could decrypt it.
0:14:06And any phone sold in the country
0:14:09must have such a mechanism.
0:14:11I don't believe Apple would make a separate SKU
0:14:14for iPhones to comply with that.
0:14:17I really don't.
0:14:18- I don't think so either.
0:14:20I think, so there's this issue of would China push Apple to a point where it knows that Apple
0:14:26would exit? And that might actually occur because China, I mean, I forgot if you had Ben Thompson
0:14:31on to talk about this or you were talking about it. He wrote that great thing several months ago
0:14:36about the key, and I've seen it repeated a number of times since, and I don't know if his insight
0:14:41was original, but it's Ben's, so I'll claim it was. That in China, the app has primacy, not the
0:14:47ecosystem, right? So you have WeChat and Alipay and other kinds of things that are app-based,
0:14:53and they work the same across every platform that's available. So you can buy a cheap Linux
0:14:58phone that's not Android even, you can buy Android phone, whatever, iPhone, and you're using the apps
0:15:04and the apps are the thing that are primacy. So this explains just not as much, even though there
0:15:09was originally very clearly this brand awareness and brand desire for iPhones in China, it sounds
0:15:15like that's faded somewhat, and we can see that in sales and so forth, and that people have now
0:15:20kind of very rapidly switched over to just thinking about the efficacy of the individual apps.
0:15:25So, Apple has less of a, I don't know, like when they were selling more devices and were a more
0:15:31critical part of that market, they might have had more leverage. I think this boils down to,
0:15:35you know, would China care if Apple left the market? Would it harm China as a country?
0:15:40Probably not that much, because they have all the alternatives they need. It wouldn't be harming
0:15:44competitiveness or whatever, it does, of course,
0:15:47then you get into this whole, okay, well, you
0:15:48know, Apple not only does it make like, made $10
0:15:51billion in the most recent quarter in revenue in
0:15:54China, which was down year over year, but they
0:15:56have all this manufacturing operation that they
0:15:59contract, Foxconn and everybody else, some
0:16:01billions and billions of dollars. I don't know
0:16:02what the scale is that's dedicated to Apple. What
0:16:04happens to that? If Apple refuses to obey, just
0:16:07suddenly all those production lines get shut
0:16:09down and they're incapable of making iPhones? I
0:16:11I really don't know what would happen there,
0:16:15but the Chinese government is supreme and centralized,
0:16:18and it can do whatever it wants at some level.
0:16:21- Right, Apple's relation with China is unique,
0:16:26and the only other country where they have a relationship
0:16:29as unique would be the United States,
0:16:31since their headquarters is here,
0:16:33and most of their employees live here.
0:16:35I would argue that Apple's relationship
0:16:39with the United States, though,
0:16:40though it's almost not a relationship because it's like,
0:16:43that's, this is where the roots of the company are.
0:16:47You know, it's like intertwined.
0:16:49Their American identity is almost,
0:16:51you don't even think of them as having a, quote,
0:16:53"relationship" with the United States because they're here
0:16:55and that's where their headquarters is.
0:16:57But their relationship with China is inordinately complex
0:16:59and China is not just the second biggest market.
0:17:03You know, and the people who want to be cynical about it
0:17:07and say that Apple is bending over, you know,
0:17:11kowtowing, kowtowing, how do you say the word?
0:17:14- Cowtowing. - Cowtowing.
0:17:17Just because of the money.
0:17:19And that would be true if, let's say,
0:17:23they did all of their manufacturing in Japan,
0:17:26or I don't know, Taiwan's not a good example
0:17:29because it's sort of tied to China.
0:17:31But let's just say that they didn't have
0:17:33any actual manufacturing and assembly footprint
0:17:35in mainland China.
0:17:36That still would be a tremendous,
0:17:40just the size of the market makes it important.
0:17:42But because that's actually not true,
0:17:44they do have a massive manufacturing
0:17:47and assembly footprint in China,
0:17:49and so many of their suppliers also are there.
0:17:53I mean, part of the whole success of Foxconn in China
0:17:57is the proximity.
0:17:58It's not just Apple and Foxconn.
0:18:01It's the proximity to the companies
0:18:03that drive the trucks in every day
0:18:05with pallets full of one tiny little thing for the camera.
0:18:10It's the proximity to it that also,
0:18:15that further tightens, would make it so hard
0:18:18for Apple to move manufacturing somewhere else.
0:18:21And it's, let's face it, so Apple's relationship with China
0:18:26on any of these matters is way more complicated
0:18:29than simply, than it would be if they were simply
0:18:32products to the people of the country.
0:18:33Yeah, I totally agree with all that.
0:18:36It's that you can't—I mean, and I thought Tim Cook expressed the frustration pretty frankly.
0:18:40I was sort of surprised in the analyst call a few days ago, where it was, you know, he has to be very
0:18:46careful what he says, but it wasn't—what do I want to say?
0:18:53It was a very—it was balanced, but I thought it was also sort of frank about the fact that they
0:18:59want to engage with what's going on. And if they can't, you know, as we said, they can't just say,
0:19:05"No, that's not going to, you know, that's not going to cut anything for them just to say no."
0:19:12But because they don't have the basis under the law or in process to do that, and, you know,
0:19:19I was saying, you know, Apple, I actually feel like Apple should take a stronger stance,
0:19:22even if it's not saying no. I feel like they should be making more effort, and I think Tim's
0:19:28comments went more towards that. Because one of my concerns is that by agreeing to Chinese
0:19:34restrictions, regardless of how legal they are under Chinese law, even in self-consistent,
0:19:39it empowers more countries to ask for more, and the US and UK in particular are asking for it.
0:19:45So, with that in mind, I feel like there's a danger that this, and this is kind of an ongoing
0:19:53thing, the bigger power China gets, the more it was seemingly going to have to liberalize because
0:19:58It was facing the reality of more citizens with more money, a higher standard of living,
0:20:02and a middle class demands more indifferent, and it's more comfortable, and thus it's not
0:20:06as malleable, and there's more power that's distributed when money is distributed that way.
0:20:10So, the Chinese government, I think, I mean, not to get, I'm not a Chinese scholar, Chinese scholar,
0:20:15I don't know how long the current structure can stand. It seems very fragile to me,
0:20:20and there's all this money and pressure and what have you. But as it's grown as a power,
0:20:25as economic and market and world power, people are learning the wrong lessons from it. So,
0:20:31democracies have adopted more restrictive policies. I mean, you see Russia, which has always
0:20:35had kind of totalitarian, centralized, whatever, like when has Russia actually been free?
0:20:40Pete: Right.
0:20:40Alan: Maybe sort of under Yeltsin, but I don't know. But it's, it's frustrating to see that
0:20:46the wrong lessons are being learned, they're being imported into democracies, that democracies learn
0:20:50how they can repress their own citizens better because they're seeing it demonstrated with
0:20:54with no repercussion in countries that are not democratic.
0:20:57- I think that, so somebody on Twitter,
0:21:02and it seems like he deleted the tweet.
0:21:04I don't know if he's somebody who deletes his,
0:21:06it was like a conversation, a public conversation we had.
0:21:11But I'm not gonna, I still have it here to read,
0:21:13but I won't say his name, but just because I'm worried
0:21:18that he deleted it for a reason.
0:21:20But anyway, it was somebody who objected to,
0:21:24accused me of defending Apple, just blindly in the face,
0:21:28simply as, and I said, well seriously,
0:21:31what would you have them do differently?
0:21:32Do you really want them to pull out of China?
0:21:36And let's face it, when we talk about this,
0:21:38pulling out of China is not just a decision
0:21:40to forego about 25% of their current revenue.
0:21:43It quite possibly would, it could,
0:21:48I mean, cost Tim Cook his job, I mean,
0:21:51because it's quite possible that a majority
0:21:54of Apple's shareholders would look at this
0:21:58and say this is not worth pulling out of 25% of our revenue
0:22:03for the foreseeable future
0:22:06and jeopardizing our relationship with this country.
0:22:08- Apple actually makes a ton of profit,
0:22:11so it's not making all its profit in China,
0:22:14but voluntarily giving up all that revenue
0:22:16and all that profit, right?
0:22:18And so this person was reasonable though.
0:22:21It was a good, it was a very, it was an adult argument.
0:22:26Argument gets a bad rap as a word
0:22:28'cause everybody, you become so overly sensitive
0:22:31that we think argument is a fight.
0:22:33But no, it's a logical argument.
0:22:35But his thing was that Tim Cook
0:22:36should personally state his opposition on Twitter
0:22:39as he has to many other political issues in the US.
0:22:42Like he has, for example, Tim Cook has publicly come out
0:22:46in opposition to the Trump administration's
0:22:48immigration policies.
0:22:50- Right.
0:22:51- I don't think, that's a reasonable opinion
0:22:57to say that Tim Cook should do that.
0:22:59That wouldn't cost Tim Cook his job.
0:23:01He could do that.
0:23:02I'll bet he's thought about it.
0:23:03I wouldn't be surprised if he does at some point.
0:23:06But, you all, and again, I'm not a Chinese expert
0:23:09in any way, neither are you, I don't,
0:23:10but I do know enough about China that
0:23:15politically you must be extraordinarily delicate.
0:23:20It is a culture and a government that,
0:23:25on both sides, both in what they say
0:23:28and what they expect to hear,
0:23:29they value subtlety.
0:23:34- I'll tell you something, I talked to a Chinese expert,
0:23:37this fellow whose name is Rajer Krimers, who's Dutch.
0:23:42He's an expert in Chinese law and governance,
0:23:45of studied this kind of thing. I said, what could Apple do? And he has some, you know,
0:23:49what kind of response could they have other than what they did? And he said, you know,
0:23:52this is Chinese—we talked about this earlier here—but he said this is Chinese law. And
0:23:56they could become part—there's a board, the TC 260 is the committee that oversees this. Microsoft
0:24:02and Cisco are members of this board, Apple is not. They could. He thinks that actually,
0:24:08I think his stance is very interesting for someone who is from a Western democracy. Like I say,
0:24:14I believe he's from the Netherlands, he's taught and researched the Netherlands and
0:24:19England and Oxford, and he thinks that actually this sort of unfettered ability of expression
0:24:25on the internet may actually not be in the best interest of citizens, not just a governmental
0:24:30thing, which is an interesting stance.
0:24:33The reason we limit rights by law is that their unfettered exercise might cause undue
0:24:39harm limiting the liberty of others.
0:24:41It's long overdue.
0:24:42notion is introduced to the online sphere. Acts that are unlawful in real law should not be
0:24:46condoned just because one happens to commit them in cyberspace." And after having seen—so,
0:24:50that's distinct from free speech, right? People would read that, and originally I thought, well,
0:24:53that seems awfully harsh. And then I thought, aren't I one of the people who would like to
0:24:57see consequences happen when people commit, you know, basically crimes in Twitter, or have some
0:25:04consequential mechanism for things that are not simply about the ability to state an opinion
0:25:09and exercise free speech, but have a real world consequence,
0:25:13like doxing things that are in fact illegal under some state
0:25:16and federal laws.
0:25:17But he says this, which is I think interesting.
0:25:18He says, "The Chinese starting point is that historical
0:25:21political mission needs to be fulfilled,
0:25:23which requires the mobilization of the entire society
0:25:26and therefore the imposition of discipline.
0:25:28This requires the state not to be limited and controlled
0:25:31in its power, but to have the ability to quickly
0:25:33and decisively intervene to clear roadblocks.
0:25:35That is anathema to the US and to most democracies,
0:25:39But I, you know, it's good to get insight from
0:25:41someone who studied this so deeply, who says
0:25:42this is, you know, their guiding philosophy is
0:25:45that that is the most important factor.
0:25:47We have, in our country, we want to be able to
0:25:49carry our, you know, our guns and our liquor and
0:25:51drive 100 miles an hour.
0:25:53All at the same time.
0:25:54And not have anybody pull us over.
0:25:55All at the same time.
0:25:56We want the drive-through liquor store and
0:25:57whatever.
0:25:58And there's Americans.
0:25:59With a gun on the passenger seat.
0:26:02Right.
0:26:03Right, you got broken glass in the back seat
0:26:05with your child sitting in it, no seat belt, and
0:26:07that's what you want.
0:26:08I mean, I'm making a character sure, but it's true is that we favor individual expression,
0:26:13individual rights, there's a primacy of it that's encoded in the central tenet of our government,
0:26:18and there's various, I mean, look, we have a lot of disagreements about what those limits are. But
0:26:23what Roger's talking about is really that is like, some political parts of the political spectrum
0:26:30want to impose more rules in some ways on people's bodies or property and others want less. And it
0:26:35It surprises me sometimes which end of the political spectrum wants government to impose
0:26:40rules on others in those fashions.
0:26:42With China, it's just a much more monolithic—the society becomes paramount, and this ability
0:26:49for us to control things and mobilize all the forces at once and move us forward in
0:26:53a single, central direction is the most important thing.
0:26:56Dave: I really do think—and I have yet to be proven wrong, and I know that there are
0:27:01There are some people who simply say Apple is a for-profit corporation and because they're
0:27:07so insanely profitable, literally the most profitable country in the world for the last
0:27:11few years.
0:27:12I mean, that won't last.
0:27:13That's true.
0:27:14No.
0:27:15Yeah, that's a bite.
0:27:16There's zero doubt in my mind that that won't last because it never lasts.
0:27:19That's the sort of thing, but they should remain very profitable for a very long time
0:27:26and that inherently any for-profit corporation is full of shit and nothing they say can be
0:27:30believed and they're usually, usually you should default to assuming that they're lying
0:27:34in anything they say. Okay, but in my experience as a very close watcher of this particular company
0:27:41and somebody who has a personal relationship with their PR department, I've never been lied to
0:27:48by anybody at Apple. Not off the record. Never. Not once have I been told something that turned
0:27:55out not to be true. They often give no answer. They often refuse to answer. Every once in
0:28:01a while, they give a circuitous answer, but not one that is like Bill Clinton style, depends
0:28:11what the meaning of the word is, is or something like that. And I say this as a huge Bill Clinton
0:28:16fan. I'm just saying, I found them to be, I think that they are a tremendously honest
0:28:22And again, they don't necessarily say,
0:28:25they'll give a lot of non-answers.
0:28:27And I think Tim Cook's public statements,
0:28:31if anything, if there was anybody in the company
0:28:35who said things that weren't true, it was Steve Jobs.
0:28:37And that he wasn't really a liar, but that he would,
0:28:41the reality distortion thing.
0:28:46So I would say in the post-jobs era,
0:28:48the company has been, one difference
0:28:50between the Steve Jobs era and the post Steve era
0:28:53is that the company has become completely honest,
0:28:56in my opinion.
0:28:57And I think Cook's remarks on the call
0:29:00were honestly what he meant.
0:29:03And I think you're right that they were very carefully
0:29:07considered so that he could state his opposition
0:29:11in terms that were politically digestible
0:29:15to the Chinese ears.
0:29:16But I think his overall argument of,
0:29:19we think it's better to be engaged than not engaged,
0:29:22was true, and that's also what he said
0:29:25about his involvement with the Trump administration,
0:29:28that it's better to be involved,
0:29:30and if I can get his ear and make my case
0:29:33for why he's wrong on these things,
0:29:35I have a better chance, we have a better chance
0:29:39of affecting it by being engaged than not engaged.
0:29:42Do I think he enjoys putting a suit on
0:29:44and sitting there next to Trump?
0:29:47And he's always conspicuously right next to Trump
0:29:50because he's the CEO. - The richest one.
0:29:53- Right, he's the, you know,
0:29:54maybe not the person, personally not the richest,
0:29:56but he certainly is the one of the company
0:29:58that's the richest.
0:29:59Do I think he enjoys it? - I thought about that right.
0:30:02- Do I think Trump? - They probably rank it
0:30:03by company size, right?
0:30:05If you're half trillion dollars, you're over there.
0:30:06If you're three quarters trillion dollars, you're there.
0:30:08- I don't think the other administrations would do that.
0:30:10I think Trump though certainly would, you know.
0:30:13- No, I agree.
0:30:15I mean, I think it's a direct relationship too,
0:30:16is, you know, there was an argument, is that Apple, especially with its progressive policies,
0:30:21with a gay CEO, with its history and interest in immigration, with its employees all over
0:30:28the world, including in affected countries that were affected by the travel ban, that
0:30:33they should completely, you know, create a kind of Cold War situation with the Trump
0:30:37administration and just support and battle elsewhere.
0:30:42And I, you know, as much as I would prefer Trump to be frozen out, on the other hand,
0:30:46it doesn't do any good for the US economy, doesn't do any good for Apple, for its employees,
0:30:50its shareholders, you know, Apple's customers.
0:30:54It just, it makes things worse, as unpleasant as it might be to see what feels like, you
0:31:00know, co-opt, being co-opted or being used.
0:31:03Like Trump's comment, you know, "Oh, they're opening three big, beautiful plants."
0:31:06This makes things up as we know.
0:31:08Three big, beautiful plants.
0:31:09It turns out that was total bullshit.
0:31:11I thought it was.
0:31:11- The fox, the fox, can we talk about,
0:31:14I wanna segue slightly, if that's right.
0:31:16- Let's hold this, let's hold this thought.
0:31:18Remember that we're gonna come back to this.
0:31:19I just wanted to say this.
0:31:20- I'm gonna pause and fox-
0:31:21- I wanna say this about the China thing,
0:31:23is that to me, the thing that I think
0:31:25that the zealots who want Apple to stand up
0:31:28and shout a no, no, no about this,
0:31:30that they are overlooking is the welfare
0:31:32of the people of China.
0:31:33Isn't that the most important thing?
0:31:36It's not the abstract notion of are you,
0:31:40are you hindering free speech?
0:31:42Second, the notion of why free speech is important
0:31:48is fundamentally about are the people,
0:31:50it's the welfare and the freedoms of the people that matter.
0:31:53And are the people of China better off or worse off
0:31:56if Apple completely pulls out of China?
0:31:58I would say they're worse off.
0:31:59It's better-- - I think that's the issue.
0:32:01They're so big, it'd be one thing
0:32:02if we were a smaller company, they're so big
0:32:04and they're so intertwined with the Chinese company,
0:32:07they have sales, they have customers,
0:32:08they have employees, they have stores,
0:32:11they have manufacturing partners.
0:32:13Regardless of what people think about Chinese
0:32:15outsourcing and manufacture, the iPhone's would not be made
0:32:18if it were not for China, it would not be affordable.
0:32:20- China is cracking down on end-to-end
0:32:22encrypted messaging systems.
0:32:26They just stopped, they pulled the plug,
0:32:29well not pulled the plug, but they set up
0:32:30the great firewall to block WhatsApp two weeks ago.
0:32:34- But iMessage and FaceTime are still working.
0:32:37- Right, and iMessage and FaceTime,
0:32:39and I know that there are cynics out there
0:32:41who think, ah, Apple probably gave China
0:32:43the back door or something like that.
0:32:45They really are engineered, I can't prove this,
0:32:48I'm not an encryption expert, I don't have the source code,
0:32:50but everything I know about them is that they were drawn
0:32:53from the ground up so that there could not be
0:32:55a man in the middle back door just for China
0:32:58or something like that.
0:32:59They really are--
0:32:59- There is a way to do it, but we require changes
0:33:04that I think if we discovered that Tim Cook had authorized,
0:33:08or anyone in the company had authorized
0:33:09those kind of changes, and they'd been rolled out,
0:33:12it's possibly he'd be committing a crime under US law.
0:33:15So it's, right, you wouldn't,
0:33:17I don't think he could do it.
0:33:19It would be, it could be fraud.
0:33:20I mean, their marketing materials,
0:33:22everything they say says they don't do it,
0:33:23so they would be committing certain kinds
0:33:25of consumer and criminal fraud potentially
0:33:27if they changed that.
0:33:28- Right, the hit to their credibility
0:33:29would be worth more money financially
0:33:31than the Chinese market.
0:33:32It would absolutely devastate the company.
0:33:34It would crater the company.
0:33:35And do I think, is it possible
0:33:38that they might start blocking iMessage?
0:33:39And is that the line where they would pull out of China?
0:33:42No, probably not.
0:33:43I'm just saying, I cited iMessage and FaceTime
0:33:46as end-to-end encrypted things
0:33:48that completely work in China.
0:33:50Not as that's the only reason why Apple should stay in China
0:33:54but just one example of why I think it should.
0:33:56And that the main thing is to think about,
0:33:58is it good or better or worse for the Chinese people?
0:34:02Anyway, that was my thing.
0:34:04What do you wanna talk about?
0:34:05You had a Foxconn idea?
0:34:07- Well, I just wanna, this is a little bit of a segue,
0:34:09but it's kinda very similar.
0:34:10So you know, Foxconn, so Trump had that big announcement
0:34:12with Scott Walker in Wisconsin that,
0:34:14"Hey, I've brokered this deal and Foxconn's coming,
0:34:17"even though the deal has been in progress since 2014."
0:34:19And Foxconn's been talking about it.
0:34:21Foxconn's enabling the presidency
0:34:22by allowing these kinds of messages to be said,
0:34:25and you know, so that's a deal.
0:34:27But so here's the thing that cracks me up,
0:34:28is this is the kind of good deal we're getting,
0:34:30is that, of course, states unfortunately work—they're actually all competing against each other to
0:34:37lure businesses, and it winds up—Boeing got billions of dollars from my state, Washington
0:34:41State, and then immediately, almost immediately, started laying people off and restructuring
0:34:44its operations.
0:34:45And there's a lot of anger here about Boeing because of that, because they got, I think,
0:34:49the largest single tax incentive plan, and it was not structured to only be in effect
0:34:54if—based on employment issues.
0:34:57So you know, they're able to locate new production lines elsewhere.
0:35:00So Wisconsin is very happy to offer $3 billion in state tax breaks, which winds up being
0:35:06$230,000 per worker, assuming the factory employs 13,000 jobs.
0:35:14So this is a 15-year deal, and in 15 years, 13,000 jobs probably won't generate tax revenue
0:35:19that even approaches that much.
0:35:21I mean, there's the issue about the tax, there'll be revenue booked from the plant that they'll
0:35:25get taxed from.
0:35:26There's other things, although because of this, we don't know what the final thing would
0:35:30be, but I'm just like, this is the kind of big, beautiful deal that's being made, is
0:35:33just giving all this money away. The state's giving away so much that it's going to wind up
0:35:38maybe never making more money. It's great.
0:35:41[laughter]
0:35:43I really, while we're on it, I just have to say that this thing where Trump—was it an interview
0:35:47with the Washington Post? I forget who it was with.
0:35:49Oh, was nothing in your—no, which one is this?
0:35:52I don't know. The one where he said that—I talked to—Tim Cook called me up. He said,
0:35:57"Don, we're gonna build three big beautiful plants
0:36:00"right here in the US."
0:36:03- Yeah, Wall Street Journal.
0:36:03- Wall Street Journal.
0:36:05- Yeah, that was that interview
0:36:06where they didn't release the transcript originally
0:36:08and then it got released later.
0:36:09They got leaked and eternity said all kinds of crazy things.
0:36:12This part was reported.
0:36:13- Apple did not respond.
0:36:15I wasn't sure if that had something to do with
0:36:19that they were only a week away
0:36:20from the earnings call or whatever,
0:36:21but it was obviously asked on the earnings call.
0:36:24and Tim Cook gave another very politically--
0:36:28- That was a very good answer, I thought.
0:36:29- Well considered, but the translation is,
0:36:32we have no idea what the fuck he's talking about.
0:36:35- Right. - We have no plans.
0:36:35- Well, I think the Foxconn, like, it's just,
0:36:38he doesn't, nobody--
0:36:39- I guess that's the kernel. - Summarizes things
0:36:40where he puts it in a bullet point.
0:36:41- I guess that, you know, 'cause he did,
0:36:43he did make political hay out of this Foxconn plant
0:36:46in, not Minnesota, it's Wisconsin.
0:36:50Yeah, speaking of Ben, Ben Thompson.
0:36:51- Yeah, Wisconsin, yeah.
0:36:54And I guess somehow that rattled around
0:36:57in that big emptied skull of his,
0:36:59and somehow Foxconn makes Apple stuff.
0:37:03And so a Foxconn plant for flat panel TVs in Wisconsin
0:37:08turned into three huge factories for iPhones.
0:37:11- It's great.
0:37:14- It literally is the case that Apple hasn't even,
0:37:17the flat panels that they're making at this Foxconn plant
0:37:19aren't even part of anything that Apple would use.
0:37:22So they're not even, there's no,
0:37:24it could obviously change and perhaps
0:37:27they could start making different types of flat panels there
0:37:30and Apple obviously makes an awful lot of devices
0:37:32that use displays.
0:37:33So in theory, it's possible that displays made
0:37:37in that facility might end up in Apple products someday,
0:37:39but it's certainly not an Apple plant
0:37:41in any way, shape, or form.
0:37:43- But the thing I was more excited about
0:37:45is that Cook said they're gonna invest all this money
0:37:47in US manufacture, which is great.
0:37:49I think the big story, so here's the big story
0:37:51I think of the next 10 years is,
0:37:53So, you know, a lot of the thing in China that makes it possible to manufacture goods
0:37:56there very affordably is not just the labor costs, which have been going up steadily.
0:38:00Labor is a tiny, tiny percentage of, at one point I think it was 1% of the retail price
0:38:05of the iPhone was actual labor to assemble it.
0:38:08And a lot of the times you have chips coming from all over the world, you've got components
0:38:11coming from a bunch of places, but the main stuff is all being made and integrated in
0:38:15China and it's the locked-in value of having all of these different industries that work
0:38:20together, making components all in these, you know, sometimes one city or one area that form
0:38:26these close relationships, that's the lock-in advantage they have. But labor is becoming less
0:38:30and less of so, especially as robotic assembly is going to become, you know, even more so than
0:38:35today. But so, what I'm interested about is this, the trend of the next 10 years is how much stuff
0:38:39gets made domestically, whether it's domestically in the US or China for Chinese products for Chinese
0:38:45which is a big push China has as well, is trying to
0:38:48make high-tech products and other things that are
0:38:50made in other countries, which still exists in
0:38:52large quantities. Remember, the U.S. is still the
0:38:55number one, or maybe we're down to the number two,
0:38:57manufacturing economy in the world, despite the
0:38:59fact that we've decreased employment in that
0:39:01industry because we're so efficient. So, there's
0:39:04this big trend. Stuff's going to come back here
0:39:06because everything's gotten more, it gets more
0:39:08expensive to move things around. It gets more
0:39:10expensive to, like, I was just reading a great
0:39:14a great article the other day about companies that are switching to software development in like,
0:39:19you know, companies are hiring in Indiana and smaller states and mid-sized cities, not rural
0:39:24yet or small towns, but they're hiring in these places where they have plenty of qualified people,
0:39:29people willing to be trained. They pay them a great salary for the area, but it's a fraction
0:39:33of the salary in Silicon Valley or New York or Seattle. They're in the same time zones or within
0:39:40companies you're dealing with, they're native
0:39:42English speakers. And as much as I want to, I mean,
0:39:45I am not making any bias against people who learn
0:39:47English as a second or third or fourth language,
0:39:49because many people communicate perfectly well
0:39:51in those. But when you add all the things up, it's
0:39:53like they're finding, and wages in India have now
0:39:56gone up as well as China. So, this article noted
0:39:59that I think wages are now maybe, maybe cost half
0:40:01as much on an hourly basis for a programmer in
0:40:04India, but they're, all the things added up make
0:40:06it harder to turn stuff as fast. It makes, it puts
0:40:09it puts in enough friction that these companies
0:40:12are now delighted to have people they can call
0:40:13and work with in real time who are in the culture
0:40:18and in the regulatory environment
0:40:20and it's all kind of in the same place.
0:40:21So I think that is exciting to see Apple invest
0:40:24into more of the US manufacturing economy
0:40:27because stuff is coming back and more of it will
0:40:30as the cost and quality of life improves
0:40:33in developing countries.
0:40:35- That's well said.
0:40:36All right, I'm gonna take a break here
0:40:37I wanna thank our first sponsor.
0:40:39Long time sponsor of the show, but they're back
0:40:41and they have a new product, so don't,
0:40:43just stay tuned even if you've heard of it.
0:40:44It's Eero.
0:40:46Eero makes WiFi mesh network equipment for your home.
0:40:50They have a new second generation product, just came out,
0:40:52I really think it might have been even last month,
0:40:54it's brand new.
0:40:56Second generation base station.
0:40:57Looks exactly like the first one, almost.
0:40:59You actually have to turn it upside down
0:41:01and look at the model number to really tell the difference.
0:41:03And they sort of did a little slightly different treatment
0:41:05of the Eero logo on the thing,
0:41:08but it's the same size, same shape.
0:41:10And it can integrate, right?
0:41:11If you already have Eero, you can buy the new stuff.
0:41:13You can buy the new base stations
0:41:15and they hook right into the network.
0:41:17But the new one, they've added a new thing.
0:41:19It's called the Eero Beacon, and it's about half the size.
0:41:22The Eero's are really, really small, the base stations.
0:41:25But now they have a beacon.
0:41:26And in the original setup, the first gen Eero setup,
0:41:29all of the stations were the same.
0:41:30You'd get these little Apple TV style things.
0:41:32One of them's your main one.
0:41:33you hook it up to your ethernet for your cable,
0:41:36wherever your internet comes into the house.
0:41:38And then the other ones you put around the house.
0:41:41Well now they've got this thing, and they were the same,
0:41:42you just pick one to be the main one,
0:41:43hook it up to the internet and you didn't have to do it.
0:41:46Well now they have these ones called beacons,
0:41:47and the beacons are half the size, they're smaller,
0:41:50they don't even have a power cord.
0:41:51What you do is you just plug it right into the wall.
0:41:53It's just a little device that plugs in the wall.
0:41:56Like a nightlight, except it actually has
0:42:01a nightlight feature, which is awesome.
0:42:03It's really, really clever.
0:42:04And if you don't want that, you can turn it off.
0:42:07And it's smart, and it knows it has ambient light sensors,
0:42:09so it only comes on when you want it to.
0:42:12But this second generation thing with the beacon
0:42:15adds a third 5 gigahertz radio.
0:42:19And so the second generation Eero is now tri-band,
0:42:21and it makes it twice as fast as its predecessor.
0:42:24And I had the first gen setup in my house,
0:42:27and it's the fastest Wi-Fi I've ever had in the house.
0:42:30and we have a four-story house,
0:42:34gets really good internet up in the fourth floor,
0:42:38which never would have,
0:42:39with a base station that's on the first floor.
0:42:40So it never could have happened with like a traditional,
0:42:44try to blanket your house from one base station
0:42:47Wi-Fi system, just wouldn't work.
0:42:48If you don't know Eero,
0:42:50the basic idea is that they set up a mesh network
0:42:53where it's like this type of network
0:42:56that like a big office would have at great expense
0:42:58with a professional setup.
0:42:59And instead, you don't have to be an expert at all.
0:43:04You just use the excellent, excellent Eero app
0:43:07right on your phone.
0:43:08And it tells you, walks you right through how to set it up.
0:43:10It gives you advice on where to position them
0:43:13related to stairs and stuff like that.
0:43:15The beacon makes it even easier
0:43:18to just blanket your whole house
0:43:22with really, really strong wifi signal.
0:43:25It's a great product.
0:43:26I really, really love the company.
0:43:28and the second generation one is just better in every way.
0:43:31It's literally faster.
0:43:32The beacons really, really make it better.
0:43:35And last but not least,
0:43:37Eero has incredible customer support,
0:43:39and it's something that the company
0:43:40has really invested a lot in.
0:43:41They wanted to emphasize that I mentioned it here
0:43:43on the ad read.
0:43:44They'll get you, hook you up, you call them up,
0:43:47and they'll put you in touch with a Wi-Fi expert
0:43:49within 30 seconds.
0:43:51I didn't need it.
0:43:52I don't think you would either,
0:43:53but just in case you have a weird thing
0:43:54or you run into something,
0:43:56You can get somebody on the phone in 30 seconds
0:43:59and they know what they're talking about.
0:44:01Really, really, this is just a great product.
0:44:03So go there, figure it out, and you go to the Eero.com
0:44:06and buy enough equipment based on the size
0:44:10of your apartment or home or whatever
0:44:12you're trying to set it up.
0:44:13And remember this code, the talk show, the talk show.
0:44:17And you use that code when you buy your Eero kit
0:44:20and you will get free overnight shipping.
0:44:21So literally, you could just pause this podcast right now
0:44:24and go order up your Eero.
0:44:26If you were thinking, if you've been thinking for a while
0:44:28about getting a new Wi-Fi setup,
0:44:30and you've just been putting it off,
0:44:31well now's the time to do it,
0:44:32'cause the Eero version two is out, so go get it.
0:44:35Pause the podcast, come back when you're done,
0:44:37and it'll show up at your house tomorrow for free.
0:44:40So my thanks to Eero, great product.
0:44:43Back to the show.
0:44:45- I don't wanna provide any, what's the rest,
0:44:50endorsement of products I haven't used,
0:44:51but I have not used Eero yet,
0:44:52but oh my God, is everybody talking about it?
0:44:54So I've gotta try this.
0:44:55As a long time Wi-Fi guy,
0:44:57I have a ridiculously working network now
0:44:59with like TP-Link and Apple routers and CRUD
0:45:02and lots of wires, so.
0:45:03- You used to.
0:45:04- Eero is my future for testing.
0:45:05- For those who don't remember,
0:45:06Glenn used to write a Wi-Fi blog, right?
0:45:10- Every day.
0:45:12- There was, the early days of Wi-Fi,
0:45:14there was so much news that you actually could,
0:45:16and did legitimately have a daily updated Wi-Fi blog.
0:45:20- I've attempted to reboot it.
0:45:22I shut it down in 2011.
0:45:23still get a lot of traffic, which is hilarious.
0:45:25One of the most popular articles in that story is a link, not an article, but a link to David
0:45:30Pogue's review in like 2007 of some Wi-Fi connected speakers, because the Internet's
0:45:35a weird place, man.
0:45:36But I've been tempted to reboot it just to write about mesh, because there's so much.
0:45:39I just wrote like an overview.
0:45:40What was the name of the blog?
0:45:41For Macworld.
0:45:42No, what was the name of your blog?
0:45:44Oh, Wi-Fi networking news.
0:45:45So, it's Wi-Fi netnews.com.
0:45:46Still there, still there.
0:45:47The main part, major article is, hey, I shut this thing down.
0:45:50just wrote a mesh explainer for TechHive, a part of a Macworld sister site, and part of it was
0:45:57just kind of like, you know, so, like, why do you want to, like, what's the point of this? And
0:46:03really, there's like seven or eight systems out there, some are from startups, some are from third,
0:46:08you know, existing companies, and the deal is people are just sick, sick to death of dead
0:46:13areas and configuring things. And you know, I wrote for Harry McCracken, the first article I
0:46:19I wrote for PC World, I want to say it was 10, 12 years ago when Harry was the editor-in-chief,
0:46:25they had gotten this thing back from the survey. They used to do customer surveys at PC World. It
0:46:28was great. They'd go out to read those surveys and get huge amounts of information. And they
0:46:32had found the return rate on Wi-Fi equipment was like 30% to retail. And I would not be surprised
0:46:39if for conventional Wi-Fi stuff, like just the base station router stuff that you get, not the
0:46:44mesh things if the rate wasn't still 30 percent. Just based on people's frustration
0:46:49with setting it up.
0:46:52I just can't say enough good things about the way that Eero works. I know that AdRead's
0:46:56officially over, but I don't care. It's a part of the show.
0:46:58I have to find the thing. Everybody's talking about it.
0:47:01You know how you get like—I had to do it with the stupid cable modem I got from Comcast
0:47:07when I moved, where you end up going to a web page in there. Like, go to this web page
0:47:12and you configure things there.
0:47:14- Yeah.
0:47:15- Always feels janky configuring something
0:47:17from a web app or a web forum
0:47:19and you're typing in IP numbers
0:47:21and you're seeing IP numbers and stuff like that.
0:47:22Setting up an Eero is nothing like that.
0:47:24And you don't, it's one of those things too
0:47:27where you do it on your phone, not on your computer,
0:47:30and it feels right that you're doing it on your phone.
0:47:33It actually, 'cause the experience is so just tap this,
0:47:36tap that, you know, okay this,
0:47:38that doing it on a phone doesn't feel
0:47:41like you're trying to,
0:47:43Like if you're, a lot of times when you do something
0:47:45on the phone instead of on a computer,
0:47:47it feels like you're drawing, getting water
0:47:49from a very, very narrow straw.
0:47:51And it's like, oh my God, if I was on my Mac,
0:47:53I could just drink it as fast as I want.
0:47:55(laughing)
0:47:55That's how I feel. - Exactly.
0:47:57- But with the Eero setup, doing it on the phone
0:47:59is actually ideal because it really is just a big fat,
0:48:03tap this, tap that type of process.
0:48:05Also the build quality on their equipment is amazing.
0:48:10Absolutely amazing.
0:48:11It feels like Apple quality.
0:48:13I really, they can't say that I guess,
0:48:15but that's what I would say.
0:48:16It's like--
0:48:17- This is really, it's a Sonos strategy, right?
0:48:19It's that Sonos was ex-Apple people,
0:48:21but Sonos made a thing that is,
0:48:23as the people liked as much as they like Apple products,
0:48:25which is really hard to do.
0:48:26It had the build quality, the features,
0:48:28they charged a premium price,
0:48:29'cause they did a premium thing.
0:48:30- I'll trash a company.
0:48:32I'll name it, and I'll say Linksys.
0:48:33You ever have Linksys equipment?
0:48:35And I've had it, I've had it.
0:48:36But just, don't even talk about the experience of it,
0:48:38but just the type of plastic that they use.
0:48:40They use the cheapest shit plastic that you could ever do.
0:48:43And if you squeeze the device, it creaks,
0:48:46as a brand new device, it creaks in a way that,
0:48:48you know what I'm talking about,
0:48:49like a cheap plastic gadget.
0:48:51- I, yeah, it's just.
0:48:52- Eero stuff is so solid, it is amazing.
0:48:54What did they say here?
0:48:56There's something in their talking points about it.
0:48:57- Does it give off a pleasant scent also?
0:49:00- No, but it has no scent whatsoever.
0:49:01And it doesn't have that cheap scent, you know what I mean?
0:49:04Here, this is from their talking points.
0:49:06Our manufacturing process rejects any performance flaw
0:49:09cosmetic defense larger than the tip of a needle. And I believe it. They look like museum objects.
0:49:16Anyway.
0:49:16Pete: That's good, though. That's part of the thing. Yeah, it's Wi-Fi still painful,
0:49:21or still, I'm sorry, still painful enough people are inventing more solutions to solve it,
0:49:25like 15 years, 16 years into Wi-Fi being a widespread thing.
0:49:28Ted, that's the truth.
0:49:28Yeah. So, speaking of that, it rolls right out of the Eero topic, or Eero read, is the XKCD comic
0:49:35I linked to this week.
0:49:36Pete; Oh my God, that was great.
0:49:38Where, what's his name, Randall, whatever his name is.
0:49:42The comic is--
0:49:43- Monroe.
0:49:44- Yeah, over time with phone, like starting in 2007,
0:49:49'cause that's like the AD one of the iPhone era,
0:49:54there was this sense of you'd be doing things
0:49:59and if you're trying to do it on the cell network
0:50:01on your phone, you'd say, ah, this is flaking out,
0:50:04this won't load or it's not fast enough or whatever,
0:50:08I gotta do this on Wi-Fi.
0:50:09And that at some point a handful of years ago,
0:50:12around 2011 or so, the reliability of the cellular network
0:50:17surpassed this reliability of Wi-Fi networks.
0:50:20And more often than the other way around,
0:50:22when you're doing something on Wi-Fi,
0:50:24you wind up turning off Wi-Fi and turning on cellular
0:50:27to get it to load.
0:50:31And I find personally for me, that is absolutely true.
0:50:34And I will even say, not here at home with my Ero setup,
0:50:39and I really am saying that, I mean this sincerely,
0:50:42I'm not saying this because they were the sponsor,
0:50:44but Wi-Fi in general, like Wi-Fi at just,
0:50:50like my mother-in-law's house or my parents' house
0:50:52or anywhere else where I might have Wi-Fi,
0:50:54or like at a hotel or something like that.
0:50:56I never get the Wi-Fi, the hotel Wi-Fi anymore.
0:50:58I just use my phone, unless it's like video.
0:51:03it's a funny, I totally, I was laughing my head off when you linked to this because I was just
0:51:08thought, oh my God, I'm thinking of the number of times when I'm, so I have, like I said, I have a
0:51:13hilarious router set up in my house, so it all works, so I haven't changed it out yet because
0:51:17I have good performance everywhere and I paid the money and so at some point I will just swap it all
0:51:21out for mesh because this is ridiculous what I'm doing. I have wires running, I'm a wifi guy, I've
0:51:26got ethernet running all over the house. It's ridiculous, makes me mad. It's terrible. But so,
0:51:32I'm thinking the number of times I am out of my
0:51:34house somewhere and it has a Wi-Fi network and I
0:51:37have to, I'm like, oh God, and I go and I swipe up
0:51:39control center and I turn off Wi-Fi. How many
0:51:42times are you doing that? I mean, I, we get by, my
0:51:45wife and I get by with a three gigabyte a month
0:51:48pooled plan with AT&T. We are very low, we don't
0:51:53spend that much time away from Wi-Fi networks or
0:51:55the house or whatever. And we're starting to
0:51:57exceed it because the networks are so bad and
0:51:58we're like, oh, we're going to have to spend
0:51:59another like $200 a year to upgrade to the next
0:52:02mark because we're burning through it because we need it elsewhere. But it's
0:52:07true. Judging by the reaction I got from people, I got a whole bunch of "yes,
0:52:12that's amazing, I never really thought about it." And I have to admit, until I saw that
0:52:14comic, I just never really thought about it because my first impression,
0:52:20and I think this is true in so many ways psychologically, and it's, for
0:52:26example, just one that everybody who listens to this show is familiar with,
0:52:31with.
0:52:33It took Apple 15 years after it should
0:52:38have been the conventional wisdom
0:52:40that this is a thriving company.
0:52:43I would say it was at least 15 years
0:52:45after the consensus of the business world
0:52:47is that this is a very successful company that has
0:52:49a bright future ahead.
0:52:5115 years of Apple as a company that's on the verge of collapse
0:52:55because they were on the verge of collapse in 1997.
0:53:01And they were on really shaky ground.
0:53:03And people who formed their opinion of Apple
0:53:05as a business in that time, it stuck.
0:53:09It stuck long after it shouldn't have,
0:53:11because that was the first impression.
0:53:13And it was true at the time.
0:53:15And I think that the fact that cell networks are flaky
0:53:19and can't be depended on, and Wi-Fi is definitely
0:53:23a better, more sturdy technology than cellular,
0:53:26was absolutely the truth worldwide, everywhere.
0:53:29And the fact that that's different now,
0:53:33I never really reconsidered that.
0:53:35Even though it was subconsciously without thinking about it,
0:53:38I was raising the window shade and turning off the,
0:53:42whatever you call the thing, the control center,
0:53:44and turning off Wi-Fi.
0:53:45- No, I had the same reaction for a long time.
0:53:48I was a big fan of LTE when it started rolling out,
0:53:51and we got it here in Seattle reasonably early, feels like.
0:53:54And the first time I was testing it, I was like,
0:53:57"Wow, I'm actually getting,"
0:53:59like 20 megabits per second or 10. It was something
0:54:01outrageous compared to 3G, even HSDPA+ or whatever
0:54:06it was at the time that was the big thing. It was
0:54:08like, all right, this is really great, and we're at
0:54:10the bottom of LTE. Like, we're still in the US,
0:54:13we're still, it's not that other countries are that
0:54:16far ahead, but the general LTE flavor that's being
0:54:19deployed or that's deployed everywhere is really
0:54:21still the bottom. Like, we're going to, just like
0:54:23with Wi-Fi where we started at like, you know, 11
0:54:26megabits per second, but it was much higher, it was
0:54:28but it was much lower. And then we went up to 54 and higher and higher. Now we have 802.11ac,
0:54:33and there's different models. You can push, if you're lucky, you can push a gigabit per second
0:54:37or more across two different frequencies with your one base station now, right? And that's amazing
0:54:43when it works correctly. But LTE, yeah, and LTS, so, and there's more advanced, these Wave 2 AC
0:54:51units that are coming out that are going to be, that are much better for throughput and range and
0:54:54because they do beamforming, so they focus energy
0:54:56in the right place.
0:54:57But the LTE still has, there's so much headroom in LTE,
0:55:00and 5G is still a long way away, but like 4G LTE,
0:55:03we will have networks eventually that are hundreds
0:55:05of megabits per second that are just gonna be
0:55:07generally available, and then you have to deal with
0:55:08what the bandwidth cost will be when you're,
0:55:10that kind of thing.
0:55:12But here's the thing, John, this is I think the big thing,
0:55:14is that we forget sometimes, I have gigabit internet
0:55:18at my home, which I am delighted with,
0:55:19and I'm paying too much for it, like 100 and,
0:55:22hundred and, well, I think I'm paying 156 bucks a month and it includes a phone line.
0:55:26If I didn't get the phone line, it would cost $40 a month more, because that's how bundling works.
0:55:30Pete: Cracks me up. Do you actually get, what speed do you actually get?
0:55:34Pete; I get like 600 up and 300 down.
0:55:38Pete; Wow, that's fantastic. That is, wow.
0:55:40Pete; And sometimes more.
0:55:41Pete; I'm coming over.
0:55:42Pete; But it's like, you know, it's awesome.
0:55:43Pete; I'm coming over. I'm coming to see you.
0:55:44Pete; My friend, you know, your friend of mine, Jeff Carlson, is going to come over,
0:55:47we're going to lunch someplace in a few weeks and he's going to come over in the morning and just,
0:55:51do his back plays back up. He's got like 700 gigabytes to go and he's like, can I plug in
0:55:55for a few hours? But yeah, come on over. Use some of my untapped bandwidth. But most people in the
0:56:00country, so I think the average bandwidth, I just found a number from last year, but it's like 50
0:56:06megabit per second downstream is now the average. That's because there is more gigabit and 100
0:56:10megabit per second internet being pushed out. But the, let's see where we're at now. I think it's
0:56:16I think it's the, oh here it is, 18 megabits per second
0:56:18is the 10 fastest average speeds right now.
0:56:22So it's still, I think most people in the US
0:56:26have home broadband that's much slower than LTE
0:56:31in the same area they're at.
0:56:33- Yeah, at my new house we have much,
0:56:36my internet used to be a running joke
0:56:38about how bad the internet was at my old house.
0:56:40It really was, and it really did.
0:56:41I know, Merlin, I still don't know if Merlin believes me,
0:56:44but we've had a couple of, we had that one,
0:56:46one of my favorite episodes of this show ever
0:56:48was with Merlin and we were talking about Comcast
0:56:50and the stupid webpage they had with the,
0:56:52(laughing)
0:56:54the giant orange cone that was,
0:56:56if it was in proportion to the van,
0:56:59it's like a 20 foot, there's a dog chasing a cat.
0:57:03Anyway, but it really did, in my old house,
0:57:06it really did, the internet service
0:57:08suffered tremendously when it rained.
0:57:10(laughing)
0:57:12I swear to God.
0:57:14- Oh my God.
0:57:14- So like if I was set to record the show
0:57:16and it was a rainy day, I knew that we were in for trouble.
0:57:20- That's 'cause there's old rotted cables
0:57:22that rain infiltrates and it disrupts the,
0:57:25there are just holes in your coax.
0:57:27- I forget how long ago it was.
0:57:29There's an episode of it.
0:57:30I'm pretty sure I'm not making this up.
0:57:32There was an episode of the talk show
0:57:33a couple hundred episodes ago.
0:57:34Might have even been back in the Dan Benjamin era,
0:57:36but it was so many Skype drops because it was a rainy day
0:57:39that we literally edited the show
0:57:41and just kept the Skype drops in.
0:57:44Instead of editing around them seamlessly,
0:57:46we just played the Skype connection sound
0:57:49over and over again.
0:57:50What do I get?
0:57:53So here's what I get.
0:57:54It depends, but I can get, I have some speed tests here
0:57:58where I'm getting 220, 230, 238 down,
0:58:03and that's over Wi-Fi.
0:58:06That's Wi-Fi.
0:58:08but up is on the same test, 12, 12, 12.
0:58:13Yeah, it's super consistent.
0:58:14- 12 megabits per second?
0:58:16- Yeah.
0:58:16- 12 megabits per second, what the?
0:58:18Yeah, so this is what I love,
0:58:19so CenturyLink is one of the old baby bells,
0:58:21or no, I'm sorry, it's not one of the old baby bells exactly.
0:58:24It was like, there were different smaller companies,
0:58:27like rural telephone companies, and it all kinda merged.
0:58:30They took over, it was US West and then Quest,
0:58:32and CenturyLink was like Century something else
0:58:35and whatever.
0:58:36they have like the worst portfolio. They have like all wired phone lines and they're kind of like a
0:58:42junk, I mean, I'm being too harsh because I don't know all the business model issues, but you know,
0:58:45like Verizon spun off all of its wired phone lines. Like, Verizon doesn't own any POTS anymore.
0:58:51Pete: Right.
0:58:51Pete; And Sprint, I think, got rid of their, so like,
0:58:53excuse me, there's still millions and millions of wired phone lines in the country, even as they
0:58:59decline super rapidly, it's like, you know, how many modems are in use? We're in that title of
0:59:03Oh my God, wait, sidebar, I'm starting to watch Futurama from the beginning with my
0:59:07other son who is 10.
0:59:08We got to an episode in season two, which is a joke about logging.
0:59:11Good news, everyone! I started, I tried to log on starting weeks ago. We finally got
0:59:15through to AOL. And, you know, it sees they're putting on virtual reality to go this whole thing.
0:59:20And I'm like, oh my God, we pause, my wife and I are explaining for like 10 minutes to my 10-year-old.
0:59:25Okay, so there was a phone and you dial, and he's like, I'm like, so there was a time when the
0:59:30when the internet wasn't always on, it wasn't always available. He's like, "Really?" He's just
0:59:34like, looking at me like an anthropologist, like, "How did that work?" Because we dialed up and it
0:59:39made noises, and it was a thousand times slower than our current connection.
0:59:42Pete: Maybe more. It might be more than a thousand times slower.
0:59:45Pete: What's, what is 56k divided by gigabit? I got a, I got a math program here.
0:59:50Pete: Yeah.
0:59:50Pete: But so, that was hilarious. But so, I interrupted myself.
0:59:54Pete: Do the math. Can you do the math?
0:59:55Pete; I have, yeah, I use Solver, which lets you pipe an arbitrary S-O-U-L-V-R.
1:00:00I love that.
1:00:01You can type in, I can type 56 kilobits per second
1:00:03divided by one gigabit per second,
1:00:05and it tells me, wait, I got the units wrong.
1:00:07It's in percentage.
1:00:10I'm gonna put a link in the show notes to solve it.
1:00:12I'm doing it wrong, wait.
1:00:12One, I gotta do it.
1:00:14One gigabit per second divided by 56,
1:00:16I did it the wrong way around.
1:00:1856 kilobits per second.
1:00:19Oops, I can type right in real time.
1:00:21It is, oh, it's, so I have a connection
1:00:24that is 2200 times as fast as I did.
1:00:27I was correct that it was more.
1:00:29- You're right, more than a thousand.
1:00:30- So mine, 200 megabits would be what?
1:00:34Divide by five, so like 500 times faster, 600 times faster?
1:00:38- Yeah, like 400, 446 times faster.
1:00:41Yeah, so and the scale of things, right,
1:00:43like you know, it's one thing when you say I have--
1:00:45- Did you explain to your son that if somebody picked up
1:00:48one of the phones while you were connected that it would--
1:00:50- Oh yeah, my wife was like, Flynn was saying,
1:00:52so you know, so understand honey,
1:00:54that if you use the phone to connect to the internet,
1:00:57you couldn't use it for something else.
1:00:58He's like, "Huh."
1:01:00He wasn't incredulous.
1:01:00He was sort of like, "This is, okay."
1:01:03- If somebody picked up the phone,
1:01:04it would instantly disconnect you.
1:01:05And if they quick hung up, it didn't put you back on.
1:01:07You had to start all over again.
1:01:09- That's right.
1:01:10There was that call waiting feature
1:01:11that was added in some version of v.something.
1:01:15So that was hilarious.
1:01:17- Yeah, you could even have your connection drop
1:01:20just because a call came in.
1:01:22And you didn't even, even if you don't answer.
1:01:25- Oh, you didn't even call anything.
1:01:26Oh, I know what I remember.
1:01:27So, CenturyLink, so this is the thing, the reason we have Gigabit Internet in Seattle
1:01:31by our phone company is that they are desperately trying to, they're putting in fiber as fast
1:01:36as they can possibly string it up in order to replace the income that they're losing
1:01:40much more rapidly.
1:01:41So what I'm hoping, I assume, and this is probably rude of me because, I don't know,
1:01:45it's a company, I assume at one point, at some point, CenturyLink will be unable to
1:01:49sustain their business model and I will have to switch to Comcast, which now has something
1:01:53that's cheaper but has its limits. So, I have uncapped internet. When I switched over to
1:01:58Blackblaze, gosh, a while ago now, I switched over and I had like, I don't know, 1.2 terabytes
1:02:04to upload. I think it uploaded in like a day or something, like a day and a half. It was
1:02:08ridiculous. I set it to 10 concurrent threads. It's like, you're uploading at 500 megabits
1:02:13per second. I'm like, right on! And I had my whole, you know, life back up there. So.
1:02:17That's crazy.
1:02:18I know. And so, I'm paying it through the nose for it, but as a home worker and as what I need,
1:02:22I could have saved money and got 100 megabit per second.
1:02:26- I would spend it if I could.
1:02:27We don't have the, as far as I know,
1:02:29what I have is the fastest internet
1:02:30that I could possibly get in Philadelphia.
1:02:32Because we're--
1:02:33- It'll keep changing though.
1:02:34Yeah, home of former Adelphia Comcast headquarters.
1:02:37- Well no, they're still there.
1:02:38They're building a new tower one block over.
1:02:40They have the two--
1:02:41- Yeah, so you gotta--
1:02:42- Two biggest skyscrapers in town.
1:02:44Welcome to cable town.
1:02:45- So, oh my god.
1:02:47- But that's why we don't have fiber.
1:02:48There is no fiber in Philadelphia.
1:02:50Because Comcast keeps it.
1:02:51- Docsis 3, this requires them,
1:02:54they have to keep rejiggering channels
1:02:55'cause they give up certain things,
1:02:56but people, they don't need as much
1:02:57and eventually you will be able to get it,
1:02:59but it'll be subject to the one terabyte,
1:03:01not cap, but I guess non-overage fee thing that they do.
1:03:07But it'll come.
1:03:08I mean, I think it's fascinating.
1:03:09I thought actually the rollout of much higher speed internet
1:03:12would take a lot longer than it has
1:03:14because I thought the incentives were
1:03:15in keeping it scarce and charging through the nose.
1:03:17But I think we're seeing just small enough competition
1:03:20And I think the cellular pricing on some networks,
1:03:23especially with T-Mobile with its unlimited thing,
1:03:25even though you can't tether,
1:03:27like the migration to mobile services
1:03:29away from desktop computers
1:03:30and conventional television watching,
1:03:32especially through tablets,
1:03:33I think is forcing the wire line,
1:03:37fiber, cable, DSL firms,
1:03:40I think they've had to up what they do
1:03:41faster than they wanted to.
1:03:43- I'm sitting here looking,
1:03:44I wanted to see how much internet I've been using.
1:03:47And I couldn't find the app on my phone.
1:03:49and I swear to you, I'm telling you the truth.
1:03:51So you know how Comcast rebranded their home services
1:03:54as Xfinity, right?
1:03:56Because the Comcast name is so sullied
1:03:58that they have to call it something new.
1:04:00- Something you can't spell, right?
1:04:02- Right.
1:04:02But their app that you use to see your account and stuff,
1:04:08the icon for the app, the icon has some kind of little logo
1:04:12and then it says on the icon Xfinity.
1:04:14But the name of the app, this is for the iPhone
1:04:19so I can't rename the app.
1:04:20The name of the app is called My Account.
1:04:23(laughing)
1:04:26I swear, I swear to God, go to the App Store
1:04:28and look for it.
1:04:29I swear to God.
1:04:31- That's great.
1:04:33- Like they literally don't even know how you name apps.
1:04:36Can you, I mean, that they put the name on the icon.
1:04:40So anyway, my whole problem was that I couldn't,
1:04:43you can't just go to whatever that,
1:04:46The, what's the search feature called?
1:04:49In, you know, when you pull down on the iPhone
1:04:52and you can search for your apps, whatever you call it.
1:04:54- Oh, the spotlight thing or whatever spotlight?
1:04:55- Yeah, so you can't search for Xfinity or Comcast,
1:04:58you have to search for--
1:04:59- Oh, 'cause it's not named that.
1:05:01- It's called My Account.
1:05:02- It's great spotlight work, too.
1:05:06- Oh my God, you can't make this stuff up.
1:05:08Let me see here.
1:05:13How much, how much internet did I use here?
1:05:16I don't know, I can't find it in the app.
1:05:18I don't know, we use a shocking amount.
1:05:20I thought it was a mistake, I really did.
1:05:22I thought that that was like, well,
1:05:23we can't possibly use that much per month,
1:05:25but I think having a--
1:05:27- Use over a terabyte?
1:05:29- I think so, yeah.
1:05:30Yeah, I think it was--
1:05:31- I think it's pretty easy.
1:05:32If you stream video and you have backups,
1:05:34so do you do internet-based backups, right?
1:05:35You got backplays or something running.
1:05:36- I do.
1:05:37- Yeah, I mean, I'm sure that I am sending
1:05:41several hundred gigabytes a month with backplays,
1:05:44I take, if you take photos and you use iCloud photo library and you do anything else, you're just,
1:05:50I mean, I'll go out, you know, my wife was like, why is my phone falling? I'm like, oh my God,
1:05:54you have like 15 gigabytes of images on there and she had a sync issue and whatever, but you don't
1:05:59feel like you're creating that much. And it just adds up so fast. Cause the, and I'm shooting raw
1:06:04sometimes and on my cameras, cause I like shooting raw and editing later. So yeah, it's easy to add
1:06:10I think Jason stills out of himself,
1:06:12but I think he easily crosses a terabyte a month too
1:06:15with his service.
1:06:16So then you have to pay the overage fee.
1:06:17- Yeah, it's, I don't know if I get, I don't know.
1:06:20I don't even look at my bill.
1:06:22So I don't know.
1:06:23I don't know if they're hitting me with overage fees or not.
1:06:25I just have auto pay on and just pay it.
1:06:28- They're charging you for a modem
1:06:29you didn't rent 15 years ago probably.
1:06:30- No, I finally, you know what?
1:06:31That was great.
1:06:32That was one of the good things about moving is that we--
1:06:35- Finally got rid of it.
1:06:36- Yeah, well, we like canceled the old account.
1:06:39And so any kind of thing that went back in my head
1:06:41that was like a nagging, like am I paying for like
1:06:45some goofy, you know, like you said,
1:06:47like a modem 10 years ago or whatever,
1:06:49like I know that I'm not.
1:06:51Like I have a good, whatever you want to call it,
1:06:56a clean, I was gonna say conscience.
1:07:00- They charged me, I had business service
1:07:02for obscure reasons, 'cause I moved,
1:07:04they wanted to charge me.
1:07:05They have a 75% cancellation fee for your entire contract
1:07:08if you cancel business service within the term,
1:07:11which should be illegal and somehow is not,
1:07:14'cause, so it's ridiculous.
1:07:15So I moved from a business location to my home
1:07:17and I kept the business service
1:07:18and they absorbed all the costs, which was nice.
1:07:20And eventually, I switched to what I have now.
1:07:23They started charging $5 a month for a modem
1:07:25because they didn't have,
1:07:27you couldn't get like an over-the-counter one
1:07:28that worked with their business flavor, which was fine.
1:07:30Then at some point, they upped the rate to like $13 a month
1:07:33and the modems were like 50 bucks.
1:07:35So, I finally realized this and canceled it.
1:07:38Then they just kept keep charging me,
1:07:39and every month I'd be like, "You charged me again."
1:07:40They're like, "Oh, we should be able to take that off."
1:07:42And then at some point I got somebody who's like,
1:07:43"Oh, this is ridiculous."
1:07:44I mean, I got someone actually at Comcast
1:07:45who thought it was ridiculous
1:07:47that I had to be working that hard to get it off.
1:07:49Like, somebody must have been new.
1:07:50And they even think they gave me a credit even.
1:07:52Like, they pulled it off and it never got charged again
1:07:54and I got like a $20 credit 'cause it's such a hassle.
1:07:57But that's their business model.
1:07:59And that person didn't know, they weren't trained yet.
1:08:01(laughing)
1:08:03I was flashing back on the Ryan Block call
1:08:06with Comcast.
1:08:07- I can't find my usage.
1:08:08I have no idea.
1:08:09(laughing)
1:08:10- It's the perfect Comcast infinity experience.
1:08:13- Oh, here it is.
1:08:13Data usage, here we go.
1:08:15Data usage overview.
1:08:1895 gigabytes used this month.
1:08:19And that's--
1:08:20(laughing)
1:08:21- Okay.
1:08:22- That's August.
1:08:23- Three days in as we've heard this.
1:08:26Two and a half days in.
1:08:27- Right, so--
1:08:27- Oh, that's good.
1:08:28That's all right.
1:08:29That's what it's there for to use it.
1:08:31- Right, I am getting--
1:08:32- I am getting, so what they promised me
1:08:34is 200 megabits down and 10 megabits up.
1:08:37So the 12 megabits up that I'm seeing over WiFi
1:08:41is actually more than they promised, but.
1:08:43- Oh my God.
1:08:44- That's great, it's cable town.
1:08:45- Wait till you get better, someday.
1:08:47- Oh, all right, let's take a break.
1:08:48I wanna thank our next sponsor.
1:08:49It's our good friends at Fracture.
1:08:51Oh, do I love this company.
1:08:52You know Fracture.
1:08:53Fracture's the photo decor company that is out to rescue
1:08:55your favorite images from the digital ether.
1:08:58You shoot photos, you pick the ones you like,
1:09:01And then every couple months, go to Fracture,
1:09:04take your favorites, go through your photo favorites,
1:09:08and get a couple of them printed.
1:09:09And what they do is they print them directly on glass,
1:09:13and they add a laser-cut rigid backing.
1:09:15So what they ship you, you open the box,
1:09:17and it's ready to display right out of the box.
1:09:19They even include the wall anchor
1:09:21if you wanna hang it on the wall.
1:09:23And what you get is absolutely amazing
1:09:25'cause it's edge-to-edge, there's no frame around it.
1:09:28It's just an edge-to-edge piece of glass
1:09:31with your photo on it.
1:09:34And it looks like it's printed directly on glass.
1:09:36It's not like they take a piece of paper
1:09:38where the photo is printed on
1:09:40and glue it to a piece of glass.
1:09:42I don't know how they do it.
1:09:43I don't know anybody else who does anything like it.
1:09:45And the effect is simply amazing.
1:09:47It's like the platonic ideal of how to hang a photograph
1:09:52because there's nothing else to distract from it.
1:09:54It's just the photo on a piece of glass.
1:09:56It's almost like the ideal of where like phones
1:09:58are going, like as the rumors come of the bezels
1:10:02on the iPhone getting smaller and smaller and smaller.
1:10:04Well, there's no bezel on a fracture print.
1:10:07It's literally nothing.
1:10:08It's just edge to edge photo.
1:10:09It is so great.
1:10:10Fantastic gift idea.
1:10:12It is a gift idea for family that you'll never, ever,
1:10:15ever get anything but the highest compliments on.
1:10:18And each fracture is handmade in Gainesville, Florida
1:10:23from US source material in their carbon neutral factory.
1:10:27So for more information and 10% off your first order,
1:10:31go to fractureme.com/podcast.
1:10:34And then don't forget to mention the talk show
1:10:37in their one question survey.
1:10:39Guess what the question is?
1:10:40Where did you hear about Fracture?
1:10:42That's literally all they do.
1:10:44So it helps support the show when you remember
1:10:46that you came from here.
1:10:48So go check them out.
1:10:49Really, really, this is just another,
1:10:51It's another sponsor that it's just a pleasure
1:10:53to do the read for because I'm such a big fan
1:10:55of their product.
1:10:56It really is a great company and a great product.
1:11:00All right, moving on.
1:11:03What else do we have on the agenda?
1:11:04So we knocked China out.
1:11:06You wanna do the Apple Park?
1:11:08- Yeah, let's talk about that.
1:11:10Let's talk about that.
1:11:12- Sometime in the interim between the last episode
1:11:14of the show and this one, there was a really,
1:11:17really fascinating and well-written
1:11:19beautifully photographed profile of Johnny Ive and Apple's new campus, Apple Park, in
1:11:28the Wall Street Journal's like Weekend magazine. Lots of interesting details. I guess I should
1:11:33put a link to the article in the show notes. But the part that stuck out, at least in our
1:11:40community, were the pictures of the workspaces for like, you know, the whatever you want
1:11:46you wanna call them, the enlisted men,
1:11:48the rank and file Apple employees.
1:11:51- Enlisted men, yes.
1:11:55- It's largely open floor plans,
1:11:58which is not the way Infinite Loop is set up.
1:12:02Infinite Loop, now Apple's existing campus,
1:12:04they have more than a campus.
1:12:07It's funny 'cause when I was out there
1:12:10back in April for that little Mac roundtable
1:12:13that a handful of press people got invited to.
1:12:16We got to walk around and we went to the new cafeteria,
1:12:22which is, according to this article,
1:12:25I guess somebody said that to me when we were at lunch
1:12:28before we had the meeting.
1:12:30But it was built as sort of a prototype
1:12:33of the cafeteria in Apple Park.
1:12:35There's a new Cafe Max and it's huge and it's spacious
1:12:40and it must be three stories tall
1:12:43and the fit and finish is just phenomenal
1:12:46in the way that everything lines up,
1:12:48like the floor tiles where they meet.
1:12:51If you look, meet perfectly where the beams are
1:12:55that are supporting the weight
1:12:56and then you look at the ceiling
1:12:57and there's tiles in the ceiling
1:12:59and they're not just beautiful,
1:13:00but where the seams are perfectly aligned,
1:13:03either center with something else.
1:13:05There's nothing that you could say,
1:13:07oh, if you had thought of it,
1:13:08you'd have that centered between these two things.
1:13:11Everything like that is like that, it's so beautiful.
1:13:13But the walk from Infinite Loop, like where you park,
1:13:17like where the press usually parks,
1:13:19- Yeah.
1:13:20- To this cafeteria, it's a couple block walk,
1:13:22and you just realize as you walk it.
1:13:24Oh, and the other thing I got to see a lot of too
1:13:27is 'cause I stayed at a hotel across the street,
1:13:30I forget the name of it, but it's right there by the,
1:13:33instead of staying in San Francisco like I usually do,
1:13:35I was like, I'm just here for Cupertino,
1:13:37so I'll just stay there.
1:13:39But the walk from my hotel to where I had to go
1:13:41in the morning, I don't know,
1:13:42a nice little 10 minute walk, beautiful,
1:13:44'cause it's sunny California.
1:13:46But you realize as you walk down Bandly Boulevard,
1:13:52every building is Apple's now.
1:13:53They just bought everything.
1:13:55Anything that's not like a restaurant is an Apple office.
1:13:58And so they have a bunch of offices at the quote,
1:14:00"old campus" that aren't really part of what you would
1:14:03think of as the old Apple campus.
1:14:05They're just any office space anywhere down there
1:14:08they've bought.
1:14:08But anyway, that is to say,
1:14:12I still think most of those offices though,
1:14:14even the ones that are just random real estate pick-ups
1:14:16that Apple's made in the last 10 years.
1:14:18- Yeah.
1:14:19- Most Apple employees have their own office.
1:14:21That's a very long way of me getting to Apple.
1:14:24Most people at Apple have their own office.
1:14:27They always have and they always did
1:14:30and those who are moving to the Apple campus too now won't.
1:14:34I'm shocked by it, because it's not like Apple is run by a bunch of managers who are
1:14:43disconnected from what they do, right?
1:14:46This is, you know, I try not to say if Steve Jobs were live, X, and I feel like this is
1:14:50one of those things I'm baffled by, because again, I don't think Apple is confused internally
1:14:56about how people work best.
1:14:57They have their own history.
1:14:58I wonder about that, though, because it seems like Jobs really was deeply
1:15:04know, they had the spaceship to, you know, famously, his last public appearance was before
1:15:08the Cupertino City Council to pitch this thing, and they had drawings of it. And so I feel like
1:15:15he might have, you know, he and Johnny were both on board with this.
1:15:19Pete: I guess, but it just, I mean, there's decades of really good research about
1:15:24productivity. I mean, people were throwing up studies left and right, because it's not,
1:15:28it's like, we all have our own anecdotal experience. And anybody who's a programmer or
1:15:32writer, I would say virtually, gosh, can I say like 100% of people? That's probably not 100%.
1:15:38But I don't know anybody who's a programmer or writer, and I'm not disparaging people in other
1:15:42professions, but I know specifically where your job is to stare at words and type on a screen and
1:15:47maintain a state of flow. With that, you're not on the phone all the time, where if you're on a
1:15:52phone, you also need privacy and whatever, but you're not on the phone all the time,
1:15:54you're not walking around, you're not constantly in meetings with other people. Your job is,
1:15:59as much of it as you can maintain is a relationship with that screen, right? Is what you're doing.
1:16:06I don't know anybody who wants to be in a place where people are walking around them. They want
1:16:10a place where they can close the door and have as little visual disruption as possible, as well as
1:16:15oral disruption. So, I can't imagine talking to any 10 people in Apple who did those jobs,
1:16:20and any 10 of them saying, "Yeah, that'd be great. I'd love to be in a place where I have to wear
1:16:24headphones all the time, and I have to almost wear blinders to keep, you know, from being disrupted
1:16:28by people walking by."
1:16:28- And they're not doing it because they're cheaping out.
1:16:31There's nothing about this project
1:16:34that is about being cheap.
1:16:35It is like an Apple product
1:16:37and like any Johnny Ive obsession.
1:16:39It is about, you know, maybe not quite spare no expense,
1:16:43but it is, you know, spare little expense
1:16:46at making it exactly what they want.
1:16:48- Yeah, and looking at the photos,
1:16:49it's not like they're saving space per se.
1:16:51It looks like there's a lot of really kind of opened spaces
1:16:54for people to work where you could easily have,
1:16:57even if it was two people to an office,
1:16:58which is not uncommon, or some other thing,
1:17:00at least some spaces that could be closed.
1:17:02- Yeah, and I think that-- - I don't get it.
1:17:05- I realize that there are a ton of people listening to us
1:17:10talk about this now who work in an open floor plan.
1:17:12I realize that that is certainly the modern way
1:17:14to do things.
1:17:15I know that a lot of startups, it's almost assumed
1:17:18that that's how they're going to lay out the floor plans.
1:17:22I realize whether it's for cost-cutting reasons
1:17:25or cultural reasons, because I think startups think
1:17:28fosters a collaboration or whatever.
1:17:32The difference is that Apple already has a culture,
1:17:37an accompanying culture.
1:17:38And it also is sort of self-selecting,
1:17:41where if you're a software engineer
1:17:46and you like having an office,
1:17:51that might be one of the reasons
1:17:52you went to work for Apple in the first place.
1:17:56I don't know, I find this very, very, to me, alarming.
1:17:59I honestly feel like it's,
1:18:00and I've been saying for years,
1:18:02- Oh.
1:18:03- And I always, I have to give him credit.
1:18:04Like Guy English had a blog post, oh man,
1:18:07it might have been, I don't know if it was right before
1:18:09or after Steve Jobs died, but it was right around that time,
1:18:12and just like, what are the biggest,
1:18:14what's the biggest thing Apple should be worried about?
1:18:15And his take was, number one is talent retention.
1:18:19The single biggest threat to the--
1:18:20- Oh God, yes.
1:18:20- The single biggest threat and concern for Apple
1:18:23as a company is talent retention.
1:18:25and that, you know, this was written,
1:18:29he wrote it at a point where the iPhone was clearly,
1:18:32you know, it was on that trajectory
1:18:34where you could see what a sensation, you know,
1:18:36it was going to be for years to come.
1:18:39And obviously was built by a fantastic army of employees,
1:18:44designers, hardware engineers, software engineers.
1:18:47But that having, you know, that's a conquered thing
1:18:53and that the type of people who can make a world
1:18:58where everybody has a flip phone to create the iPhone,
1:19:02those type of people are drawn to new things.
1:19:06Let's tackle the next amazing new thing,
1:19:09not keep making the best, the new 10th iPhone.
1:19:13Obviously, there's a ton of interest.
1:19:16If we have time, we might even get to talk about it.
1:19:18There's a ton of interest in the 10th iPhone.
1:19:22But you could lose those people if they're bored.
1:19:26And there's all sorts of other reasons
1:19:27that people might leave companies,
1:19:29is that there's other thriving companies in the area
1:19:30that might offer them more money, et cetera, et cetera.
1:19:33So we could spend a whole show listing the reasons,
1:19:36the challenges that Apple has
1:19:38at maintaining the talent they have.
1:19:41Where they work, your work environment, is absolutely huge.
1:19:47Because it's every day, it's all day, every day.
1:19:49It's one of the biggest, to me,
1:19:51It's one of the biggest things possible.
1:19:52And think about the people who work at Apple.
1:19:57That it's not just like any random,
1:19:59if they have 10,000 software engineers.
1:20:02Well, it's not just any random 10,000 software engineers
1:20:05from the area, it's a self-selecting group
1:20:08of the sort of people who care about the things
1:20:10that Apple cares about, which is like, how nice is this?
1:20:14Is this app nice to look at?
1:20:18Is the user interface logical?
1:20:21Apple draws people who care about those things.
1:20:23And it's good for Apple that they do
1:20:26because then it reinforces,
1:20:29when the quality of your app or the design of your app
1:20:33draws engineers who are interested in designing nice apps,
1:20:36it makes the apps even better, right?
1:20:38Well, one of the things that people who care
1:20:41about stuff like that care about
1:20:42is they care about their work environment.
1:20:44I mean, I'm sure, I know that there are people,
1:20:47I got email from them when I wrote about this,
1:20:49that there are people who are like,
1:20:50"Ah, I work in an open office,
1:20:52"and I don't really like it.
1:20:53"I'd love to have my own office, but I don't care."
1:20:55It's all right, I put headphones on and I don't care.
1:20:58- Although, well, some of the open offices,
1:21:01I mean, the one advantage of cubicle farms
1:21:03is that you lose some of the visual clutter
1:21:05and some of the noise clutter too.
1:21:06So if you're literally in an open office,
1:21:08and I've seen, I think Wired,
1:21:10when they published that big thing
1:21:11of the $3 million office space they opened
1:21:13that looked like it was for a photo shoot a few years ago,
1:21:17editor has since left, you know, and they were laying people off after that. It's great optics.
1:21:21Great optics. Anyway, that space had a lot of spaces that looked intolerable to me because
1:21:26you're just, you know, you're going to be cheek to jowl with other people. There's no—you're
1:21:29just sitting at like long tables and things. I see some of that in some of the Apple photos,
1:21:33too, where you're just going to be like among people.
1:21:35Yeah, it's not even a cubicle. It's like you're—
1:21:38No. Cubicle would offend Johnny's sensibility. I have a funny story that's like, it's an anecdote
1:21:43that I would relate to this, which is, my grandfather, one of my grandfather's first
1:21:47cousins, so my first cousin twice removed, was the first chair, or sorry, second chair,
1:21:51oboist in the New York Philharmonic for many decades. And he came through, when I was growing
1:21:56up in Eugene, Oregon, the New York Philharmonic, came through Eugene, Oregon. We had this beautiful
1:22:00new convention, or concert hall, and the local whatever boosting group managed to book them.
1:22:08And so we got to hear him play and spend some time with him. And he said, "I love your hall so much,
1:22:12You can hear everybody, you can hear every other instrument. He said, "You know,
1:22:15Avery Fisher Hall, which is the famous hall that was built for the Philharmonic,
1:22:18was originally called Philharmonic Hall, was built in 19—" I was looking this up,
1:22:22it was built in 1962. He said, "We were on tour when the hall, they were interviewing the architect
1:22:29who was building the hall, and he said, 'Wood is an overrated material for concert halls.'" So,
1:22:33we said, "Oh, no." And we get back there and we play in the hall and it's terrible. It's so dead
1:22:36you can't hear people, two people away. And I found an article from 1974, I just searched on
1:22:42Lady Official Hall, 1974, this article in the New York Times is discussing what a disaster
1:22:48this space is. And they made some changes over the years, whatever. But he said,
1:22:53"We know there's concrete in the floor. They swear there isn't. It took many years." I think it was
1:22:56only 10 years ago they were renovating the hall, maybe 15. They discovered there was concrete under
1:23:01the stage. They had been told there was no concrete. They pulled it out and the halls,
1:23:06you know, acoustics change.
1:23:07And I was like, it's such a perfect example.
1:23:10We're gonna make a beautiful new conference hall,
1:23:11it's specifically designed,
1:23:13and you're telling the people who know what they need,
1:23:16no, no, no, no, you don't need to hear, you know,
1:23:18wood is an overrated material for acoustical properties.
1:23:21Like, ah!
1:23:22So I sort of feel like I'm hearing that story right now.
1:23:26- I got tons of feedback from Apple employees
1:23:31who either read my settings or maybe listened to the show.
1:23:34And if any of you are out there
1:23:35who have an opinion on this, I would love to hear from you and you can trust me.
1:23:39I'm proud to say that there's not one person who's ever told me anything in confidence
1:23:47that might harm their job if I publicize it or whatever. Not one person has ever told me anything
1:23:54in confidence that they have come to regret telling me. I know how to keep my mouth shut.
1:23:58So anyway, if any of you at Apple have interesting stories to tell about this
1:24:02open office space, I'm all ears.
1:24:05- I'm particularly interested if Apple did,
1:24:08because you know Apple famously doesn't do focus groups
1:24:10for its products, did they have stakeholder meetings
1:24:13with programmers and marketing or whatever
1:24:15to ask them what they wanted from a space?
1:24:17I'm guessing not.
1:24:18- Here's a story I heard that I cannot confirm
1:24:20because it was third hand, so I cannot confirm it.
1:24:23It could be totally false, but it sounds true to me
1:24:27and I think it would be easily checked
1:24:29because if it's true, people will know about this.
1:24:34But I heard that when the floor plans were announced,
1:24:38that there was, I don't know, either a meeting,
1:24:41or however it got were Gianni Cerucci's team,
1:24:43that he's in charge of Apple Silicon,
1:24:46the A10, the A11, all of their custom silicon.
1:24:50Obviously a very successful group at Apple,
1:24:53and a large and growing one with a lot on their shoulders.
1:24:56When he was shown the floor plans,
1:24:57he was more or less just, fuck that, fuck you, fuck this,
1:25:02this is bullshit. - Oh my God.
1:25:04- And they built his team, their own building,
1:25:07off to the side on the campus.
1:25:08So they're not even in-- - Oh my God.
1:25:10- Not only are they, they're not going along
1:25:12with the open floor plans, but that Suruji's team
1:25:14is in their own building.
1:25:15And they might, maybe internally, they're saying
1:25:18it's for security or that it's, you know,
1:25:21that they're just off, you know,
1:25:24that there's a logical reason for it,
1:25:25But my understanding is that the building was built
1:25:30because Suruji was like, fuck this,
1:25:32and my team isn't working like this.
1:25:34- Don't I remember too, the spaceship
1:25:36is already totally outstripped, right?
1:25:38Like they built it, they already have more people, yeah.
1:25:41So that's gonna be a fraction of the,
1:25:43can I talk to Amazon for a second?
1:25:45This will sound like a segue or whatever,
1:25:47but it's really about this.
1:25:48I'm working on a story right now for Fast Company.
1:25:50I'm not giving away a secret by, it's not out yet,
1:25:52but I'm looking into like, it's not a secret,
1:25:55nothing proprietary about it. It's just, I'm living in Seattle. John, I don't know if you know,
1:26:00if you've seen any of the coverage about what's happening to my city? Does it make the newspaper?
1:26:04Like, okay, it's crazy.
1:26:05I know we were just talking about it privately, but I did see it somewhere. I did.
1:26:09Outrageous. We have more cranes, we have almost twice as many cranes in our skyline right now in
1:26:14the city as Los Angeles, which has six times the area of Seattle. We have more, a higher
1:26:20percentage of open jobs in software and related fields than Silicon Valley. We have, you know,
1:26:26we have the richest or second richest, actually sorry, we have the first and second richest people
1:26:30in the world in our area. We have—
1:26:32Trenton Larkin That would be Jeff Bezos and Bill Gates in that order.
1:26:35David Zucchino Yeah, they're competing right there. Well, except I think it shifted back,
1:26:39like they lost a buck—
1:26:40Trenton Larkin Ebs and flows by Microsoft and Amazon stock price.
1:26:44David Zucchino We have so much construction going on. So,
1:26:46We had this minimum wage debate, and we got a socialist on the city council, and she is
1:26:51a firebrand, and she reignited this thing in our liberal progressive town, which is
1:26:55very proud of itself for being liberal progressive.
1:26:57And, but hey, you know, wages!
1:26:59They're like, "No, no, no, we don't want to rock the vote, no honor buck."
1:27:01She comes in, she makes this her thing, and then everybody takes it up, because they don't
1:27:06want to be left behind.
1:27:07We now have, we are on track, we have a $15 an hour minimum wage if you're a large employer,
1:27:13500 or more employees, and you don't pay towards medical benefits.
1:27:16If you're a small employer in Dew, it's 11.
1:27:18We're on track, we have a staggered introduction.
1:27:21So it's inflation-based, so it's gonna keep going up.
1:27:24In a few years, it's gonna be like $18 an hour.
1:27:26It's gonna keep going up from there.
1:27:28So, and everyone predicted doom and despair,
1:27:30all the restaurants would close, whatever.
1:27:31We have more restaurants now, more openings.
1:27:33All the restaurants, the restaurateurs
1:27:35who threatened to leave have opened more off.
1:27:38You know, it's hilarious.
1:27:39We have a shortage of short-order cooks.
1:27:42We're becoming aspen in terms of people being able to live
1:27:45in the city affordably and work in the city, even though the wages have gone up.
1:27:49You know, the $15 an hour is a starting point for these larger companies, and you can be like
1:27:55a bottle washer, and you can get a rate of $16, $17, $18 an hour. So, we're in the middle of this
1:28:00weird, crazy, overwhelming prosperity. Our housing prices went up by more in the last period of time,
1:28:07like 18% versus like 5% nationwide. Like, everything is out of control here. And Amazon,
1:28:13And I say this with all happiness, too.
1:28:15Amazon is, they have two giant buildings downtown.
1:28:19They built these signature sphere, biosphere thing
1:28:22that's actually, I was appalled by when I first saw the plans.
1:28:25It's actually really cool.
1:28:26I've been letterpress-printing a book at a school
1:28:30that is like two blocks from the Amazon headquarters,
1:28:33and they're building a third big tower.
1:28:35They have like 30-something buildings.
1:28:37They own, Amazon is leasing almost 17%
1:28:39of all office space in Seattle right now,
1:28:42of all office space.
1:28:43not just downtown. The whole pace, they have 8 million square feet and they're on track to
1:28:48like 10 in a couple years. They have 10,000 open jobs in our state. I think that's just
1:28:53like white collar jobs, not including, I mean, just in our state, I think mostly downtown.
1:28:58So, the pace, it's just unbelievable. But the most interesting thing to me is they chose to
1:29:03stay downtown. They were kind of always around there. Like, Jeff founded the business in his
1:29:10his garage in Bellevue, which is on the east side,
1:29:12not Seattle proper, and that was just a temporary thing.
1:29:14But then they had an office down south
1:29:17of what used to be the Kingdome, we still call it Soto,
1:29:19next to Pecos Pit, the best barbecue in Seattle.
1:29:21Then they were in the beautiful
1:29:23heroin district of Seattle.
1:29:24That's when I worked there for about six months,
1:29:2611 years ago.
1:29:28We were across the street from the methadone clinic.
1:29:31And then they started, then they moved to the,
1:29:33the Lex Luthor building on the hill.
1:29:35It's the tallest building, or the highest point in Seattle
1:29:37with a giant building on it.
1:29:38It's an old medical center.
1:29:39They immediately outstripped that.
1:29:41Then they started having all these, they started
1:29:42leasing all these Paul Allen buildings, and then
1:29:45they have all this stuff built.
1:29:46So, Vulcan and some other local, Vulcan is Paul
1:29:48Allen's real estate company.
1:29:50They've been selling property to Amazon, other
1:29:52local contractors.
1:29:53Anyway, so it's this massive, massive building
1:29:56boom, and it's not just Amazon, it's Google and
1:29:58Facebook have bigger and bigger operations.
1:30:00I was in Facebook's kind of small temporary
1:30:03offices, which I think has like a thousand people
1:30:05in it, that's not quite in downtown, and they're
1:30:08and they're building a big, so it's out of control.
1:30:10But here's my thing, they're downtown
1:30:14and Apple is in Cupertino, Facebook's in what,
1:30:17Mountain View or something?
1:30:18They're out in the middle of nowhere.
1:30:19All these other companies are often the burbs
1:30:22'cause they got founded out there and they grew
1:30:23and there's no, they're not part of the life of the city.
1:30:26So, this whole long thing is employee retention,
1:30:29a lot of young people and a lot of people looking
1:30:31for a change in life who are not necessarily young, young,
1:30:34they want to be in a city and they're making wages
1:30:36where they can afford to have a condo and apartment
1:30:38that's very nice and it's within walking distance
1:30:41or we have streetcars and light rail now and all this stuff.
1:30:44So being, you know, the spaceship in the suburb
1:30:47is maybe not the best strategy for future retention.
1:30:49- Seattle's not cheap, but it's the,
1:30:51like housing is not crazy like San Francisco.
1:30:53San Francisco housing.
1:30:54- Yeah, we're like half or something.
1:30:56We're like half as much, I think,
1:30:57but it's growing very rapidly, but we're still much--
1:31:01- But that's a big, and it is a recruiting problem
1:31:03and it certainly is true for the younger you are,
1:31:05the more likely you are to wanna live in a city
1:31:07and it's a big problem for these valley companies
1:31:09because they can shove all the money they want
1:31:12and make the buses as nice as they can,
1:31:14and they are, by all accounts, very nice buses,
1:31:17so that if you live in San Francisco,
1:31:21you can catch the Apple bus instead of driving to work
1:31:24and be annoyed.
1:31:25- Yeah, but you're still on,
1:31:26it's like still an hour plus on the bus, right?
1:31:28- Right. - Something or more,
1:31:29there's an hour at least on the--
1:31:30- It depends on the time of day.
1:31:31- Which is a lot of Amazon employees,
1:31:33there are a lot of Amazon employees
1:31:34who are living in an apartment
1:31:36like, a view of the water and they go downstairs and they walk a few blocks and they're at work,
1:31:40which may be healthy or not, but, or we have, like, there's all these condos, I mean,
1:31:44I've lived in Seattle for 20 something years and I much prefer, talking to non-profits too,
1:31:50about how this has affected them. Non-profits serve like, endangered communities, women who
1:31:55need shelter and homeless, voting homelessness and so forth. And everyone's saying the same thing
1:32:00as like, this is really hard on everybody, the housing increase, but would we prefer the reverse?
1:32:04no, like less money, no growth, no jobs, no, that's terrible.
1:32:09So we can, with money and resources,
1:32:11we can kinda help people and lift up folks,
1:32:14'cause there's the work there for them,
1:32:15but it is like being in one of those cartoons
1:32:19where there's going bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum,
1:32:21bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum, bum,
1:32:22in the background the whole time.
1:32:24- So anyway, I understand, I don't know
1:32:26what the original Apple plan was with the new campus.
1:32:28With it was, if the original idea was that almost all
1:32:32Apple employees would move there,
1:32:33And they would like, I thought it was, I think, I think so.
1:32:37And I seem to recall that Jobs kind of tackled it the way he tackled, you know,
1:32:43his deep, deep involvement with Pixar's, um, campus, you know, and that he, you
1:32:50know, which by all accounts is, is, uh, you know, Pixar people love their, their
1:32:54building and they love, you know, there's these ideas that he had that, you know,
1:32:59Everybody would have to--
1:33:01restrooms are located strategically in a way
1:33:05that you're going to bump into people who aren't just
1:33:07from your team and stuff like that.
1:33:10And that all of these ideas that he had worked out.
1:33:14And I think that that was sort of the idea,
1:33:16a lot of the idea of Apple Park, or at least the spaceship,
1:33:20that it would be designed in a way that
1:33:21would foster people bumping into each other and blah, blah, blah.
1:33:25But my understanding now is that Apple
1:33:27isn't leaving any office space.
1:33:30I don't, maybe some of the--
1:33:30- No, I think that's what I heard is,
1:33:32they're keeping, I think they're keeping everything
1:33:34'cause they've grown faster than they could've,
1:33:35I mean, I thought they were gonna try to get
1:33:37almost all their core teams,
1:33:39so maybe there's outlying teams or different groups,
1:33:42or maybe, I don't know, maybe marketing wouldn't be in there.
1:33:43I mean, sorry, marketing would be not, but.
1:33:46- There might be some small,
1:33:48some of the small buildings that you wouldn't think of
1:33:50as Apple buildings when you drive down the street
1:33:52in Cupertino, maybe they'll get rid of,
1:33:54but the main Infinite Loop campus
1:33:56is gonna remain fully occupied.
1:33:57- Yeah, I think it's, this is actually one more
1:34:01Amazon point related to that though is,
1:34:03because Apple's in, you know, they're in a suburb
1:34:05and they're not, I mean, you've walked there,
1:34:07I mean, one of your groups is in one spot,
1:34:08but there's not enough restaurants
1:34:10to absorb this many people.
1:34:12And Amazon specifically, I met with the VP of real estate,
1:34:15they specifically designed their facilities,
1:34:17they can only feed about a third,
1:34:19there's only like room to have a third of the staff
1:34:22actually eat lunch inside the buildings.
1:34:24And they have all these restaurants and cafeterias
1:34:26and whatever, so they are essentially either forcing
1:34:29people to bring food in, and people who are working
1:34:31in these environments typically buy food,
1:34:32I don't know how they bring it in.
1:34:34Because they're making, they're paying piles of money,
1:34:36there's a lot of eat out, so there's a bazillion
1:34:38restaurants, and they also encourage local restaurants.
1:34:41So it's not just big chains, there's a lot of like
1:34:43one-off or small chains all across this neighborhood,
1:34:46and it's part of their philosophy of creating this,
1:34:49you know, downtown, or this environment.
1:34:51And Apple, again, by being in the burbs, it's like,
1:34:53I don't know if you've been to Microsoft's campus,
1:34:55but it's kind of this very self-contained world.
1:34:58- I have never stepped foot in the state of Washington.
1:35:01- No, well, someday you will.
1:35:02Let's give you a tour around here.
1:35:03- I can't explain why.
1:35:04- Stuff doesn't happen here.
1:35:06- I probably have more friends, and I really do.
1:35:11Enormous, Brent Simmons is up there.
1:35:15I know a bunch of people who have Omni, Moltz.
1:35:19- Oh, that's funny.
1:35:20I didn't really never been here.
1:35:21Well, you'll have to come out at some point.
1:35:22jeez, with you and Moltz, I mean, it's like half the regular rotation of the talk shows
1:35:25from last year. But I've never had reason to go there. I've never had reason to go there.
1:35:30Pete: Talk show live.
1:35:30But Microsoft, Microsoft's off in the suburbs. They started out there, they were kind of,
1:35:34you know, they were suburban kids that started Microsoft and they stayed out there. But you know,
1:35:38you can drive places from campus, there's some stuff within walking distance, but not very much.
1:35:42So, it's really an insular thing. And I just think, again, I think this is one of the reasons
1:35:47Amazon built its whole thing. They planned this partly not just to have room for stuff,
1:35:52but they plan it partly to appeal. They are creating a lifestyle mall of sorts around their
1:35:57offices. And they're saying, when you come to work for us, you're not going to be off in a sterile
1:36:01thing with an hour commute away. I mean, you can choose to live out of town, you can choose to live
1:36:04wherever, and they're paying highly competitive salaries so people can choose to live essentially
1:36:08wherever. But like, and they've been underwriting, they underwrite some streetcar service, they've
1:36:12been helping promote transit taxes and ballot measures. So, like, you can take streetcars
1:36:17all, like to Amazon from all these different places now. It's a very different thing than this
1:36:21I come to the spaceship, or maybe the spaceship,
1:36:23maybe it'll be in our old building,
1:36:25and we're off in the suburbs, so.
1:36:27- I don't know, I do think, judging from the private
1:36:32feedback I've gotten from some Apple employees,
1:36:34there is, I'm 100% certain there's going to be
1:36:37some degree of attrition based on the open floor plans
1:36:42where good employees are going to choose to leave
1:36:45because they don't wanna work there.
1:36:47And they don't wanna-- - I can just take--
1:36:49- They don't want, there's no,
1:36:50and if they don't find,
1:36:52and like the one email I got from somebody was perfect,
1:36:55and it's perfectly Apple person sensibility.
1:37:00He's not screaming, he's not angry,
1:37:02it is what it is, and he's dealing with it.
1:37:05He said, "I'm working on something."
1:37:07It's a new thing that I think is gonna blow people's minds
1:37:11when we ship, and like a typical Apple employee,
1:37:15it offers me no clue what it is,
1:37:17and of course I don't ask,
1:37:18'cause I know he's not gonna tell me
1:37:19This is how it is.
1:37:20But he's working on some team.
1:37:22He's working on something cool.
1:37:24He definitely wants to see it ship,
1:37:26but his team is moving to Apple Campus too.
1:37:29And then once they ship, if he doesn't like it, he's out.
1:37:32And he's been there, he's an 18-year veteran of Apple.
1:37:34He's been at Apple for 18 years.
1:37:36And I got a couple of others from people like that too.
1:37:40I'm not gonna quit before they move me there.
1:37:42I'm gonna see what it's like,
1:37:45but if it's as shitty as I think it's gonna be, I'm out.
1:37:49yep, I can under, yep, it's like, what's it like to go to work every day and have your entire day, you know, disrupted, if that's what it turns out to be?
1:37:57It may be that there, that what we've seen isn't as full a realization of what it's going to look like, but it's clear there aren't a lot of offices with doors, and even the spaces that look like they're closed spaces are all glass!
1:38:08Look, I have, I discovered in my relatively old age here, I clearly have sensory processing disorder.
1:38:14And it's a very interesting thing, I'm trying to, and it's very common among folks who are
1:38:17programmers and engineer types like myself. I've done a lot of programming in my life,
1:38:21I have a mind for it, and there's an affinity, I think, between different things. And I'm super
1:38:27highly attentive to anything. So, high registration it's called. And so, I see and it's very hard for
1:38:33I get keyed up and I try to work in a co-working space.
1:38:37I really like the people and the space.
1:38:39It was open, it was very affordable,
1:38:41and even with headphones and a screen I was staring at,
1:38:43it was just too much stuff around me.
1:38:45I could not focus, I had to go back
1:38:46into my quiet, day-lit basement.
1:38:48So I have a lot of sympathy for the folks
1:38:50who are gonna be in that environment.
1:38:51- I think I have a touch of that.
1:38:54You know what I do?
1:38:55I cannot help but look at a TV.
1:38:58And so whenever we go out to eat as a family,
1:39:00I strategically, they don't make a big deal out of it.
1:39:03It's not like I'm a princess on the P,
1:39:08and I absolutely have to have a seat with no view of a TV.
1:39:11But I do try, when we get like, oh, here's your table,
1:39:14I try to pick a seat where I don't have a sight line
1:39:16to a TV, because if I do, I'm going to be looking at it,
1:39:19and my wife's gonna be like, what are you looking at?
1:39:20You don't even know if it's like a basketball game
1:39:22or something, you know, of two teams I don't care about.
1:39:24Like, why are you watching that?
1:39:25And it's like, I don't know.
1:39:27I don't know, but there's a TV in my view line,
1:39:31I'm going to be looking at it.
1:39:33- There's a book called "Too Loud, Too Bright"
1:39:35that I've been reading and marking up.
1:39:36I don't mark up books, and this one I have,
1:39:37I've never done it before, my wife's like,
1:39:39"You should mark this up."
1:39:40I have highlighters and like those post-it tags
1:39:43all over the thing, because I'm just, it's like all,
1:39:45it's like I feel like I've been written in a book.
1:39:48It's a bunch of different traits you have about yourself
1:39:49you didn't realize were actually all connected
1:39:51to one neurological state, and there's ways to train yourself
1:39:54out of responsiveness to it, so I haven't gotten
1:39:57to that part yet, but it's, you desensitize yourself
1:40:00so you can function better in the world.
1:40:01If you walk into Costco or Ikea
1:40:03and you need to go cry in a corner,
1:40:05you may have, well, you may be just a normal person also,
1:40:07but you may have the sensory processing as well.
1:40:10- I have a friend who works at Apple
1:40:11who I know is not looking for,
1:40:13is definitely on a team that's moving to AC2.
1:40:16I keep calling it AC2.
1:40:17I can't get used to Apple Park
1:40:19and is not looking forward to it.
1:40:20He has not, I don't think he's,
1:40:23he hasn't said anything like,
1:40:24if I don't like it, I'm leaving.
1:40:25He just thinks it sucks.
1:40:26And so when I linked on Daring Fireball,
1:40:29I don't know if you saw it, but I--
1:40:31- I saw that.
1:40:32It was like you Rick rolled me and I'm like,
1:40:34"Wait, what are these?"
1:40:34Like, oh--
1:40:35- I love a post like that.
1:40:36It's like to really make this like a director's commentary,
1:40:39like me talking about how I write during Fireball.
1:40:41So I wrote, I had a post, a link post, very short.
1:40:45The headline was video footage
1:40:47from one of the open workspaces in Apple Park.
1:40:49And I wrote, "Really does seem like a different vibe
1:40:51"from the Infinite Loop Campus.
1:40:53"Some engineers are getting their own offices,
1:40:56"but they don't seem great either."
1:40:58- Oh my God.
1:40:59Goes to footage from Terry Gilliam's masterpiece Brazil and there's a great tracking shot of this open area
1:41:05It's it if you've not seen Brazil it is it is 1980
1:41:10It's like that the pitch is let's do 1984, but make it will make it a comedy
1:41:14Except it's a it's such a great film except. It's actually a more profound tragedy at the end than 1984
1:41:21Sidebar have you seen the made-for-tv edit? Yes? Yeah?
1:41:25I used to be upset when I was in the 90s.
1:41:27- Travesty.
1:41:28- When I was in the 90s,
1:41:30I actually thought maybe I would like to be a filmmaker.
1:41:33I really have such a profound love of movies.
1:41:36And a friend of mine and I from college,
1:41:38we got deep and we just started,
1:41:41like when our eyes were opened
1:41:43to the great world of cinema
1:41:46and that it was that,
1:41:49and that old movies,
1:41:50there are old movies that are every bit as good
1:41:53or better than new movies.
1:41:54Just don't let the production quality,
1:41:58or like the black and white, you know,
1:41:59like deep dive, like watch 20 Hitchcock films,
1:42:02watch, you know, just went on benders like that.
1:42:06But Brazil became like one of our obsessions,
1:42:09where like we watched it over and over again,
1:42:11and then when we found out there was a terrible TV edit,
1:42:13we're like, well, we have to watch it.
1:42:15And it was great though, because we had seen, you know,
1:42:18Gilliam's vision of it so many times
1:42:20that we knew it by heart, and so.
1:42:22- Yeah.
1:42:23It's not just the brutal parts of the TV edit.
1:42:26It was like even the little things.
1:42:27Like, oh my God, why would they take that out?
1:42:30But anyway, I linked to that and it's a very great movie.
1:42:34Anybody listening to this, if you've never seen it,
1:42:36Brazil, I swear to God, move it to the top of your like,
1:42:39I don't know if it's on Netflix, but if you, go watch it.
1:42:42It is such a wonderful, wonderful movie,
1:42:44but it's a dystopic, open floor plan workspace.
1:42:47- Tiny admission is, I used to get a little high as a kid
1:42:51back when, before it was legal in my state,
1:42:54in various states, and I was a huge Brazil fan.
1:42:56I'd watched it a bunch of times, and it comes on TV,
1:42:58and I'm at some friend's house, and we're toasted,
1:43:01and I actually thought I had a psychotic break,
1:43:03'cause I watched the TV, it was the first time
1:43:04I'd seen the made-for-TV version,
1:43:06and it didn't end the way I remembered,
1:43:07and I thought, oh my God, I'm hallucinating.
1:43:08(laughing)
1:43:09And I was also like, it's terrible,
1:43:11my hallucination is so awful.
1:43:12What is my brain doing to me? - Nancy Reagan was right.
1:43:15(laughing)
1:43:17No, but anyway, I sent, after I posted that,
1:43:20I sent my friend at Apple a DM and I just wrote,
1:43:23(laughing)
1:43:24I just wrote, this was for you, and sent a link to it.
1:43:27And then he wrote, he wrote,
1:43:29that was DF's best post of the week.
1:43:31(laughing)
1:43:33So anyway, Apple employees are definitely,
1:43:36have strong opinions about this open floor plan
1:43:39and for the most part, it ranges from hatred
1:43:42to at best ambivalence.
1:43:45This is something to keep an eye on,
1:43:48in my opinion, moving forward.
1:43:49Anyway, I gotta take a break here.
1:43:50I gotta thank our next sponsor.
1:43:51We gotta wrap up the show.
1:43:52We've been getting close to the end here.
1:43:55And I wanna thank our friends at Squarespace.
1:43:58Make your next move, make your next website.
1:44:00Make your next move with Squarespace.
1:44:03Make your next website using Squarespace.
1:44:06What is Squarespace?
1:44:07I can't explain strongly enough
1:44:11that Squarespace is literally
1:44:12an all-in-one website platform.
1:44:16You can register your domain there.
1:44:18They host the site.
1:44:20They have the CMS so that if it's like a blog
1:44:23and you have updates, you do it all through Squarespace
1:44:26and it's a great interface for something like that.
1:44:28You can host a podcast there.
1:44:30You can have a store there.
1:44:33And if you have a store, if you need to have stuff to sell,
1:44:36the commerce part of it is all built
1:44:38into the Squarespace platform.
1:44:39So it's not like, oh, now you have to go to PayPal
1:44:42or whatever you wanna use as your backend
1:44:44and figure out a way to hook it into,
1:44:46there's nothing to hook in or hook up.
1:44:47It's a just turn it on and say I wanna have a store
1:44:50and I wanna start entering SKUs and pictures of the items.
1:44:53That's all you have to do.
1:44:55I cannot explain just how all in one,
1:44:57the all in one nature of Squarespace is.
1:44:59And I also cannot emphasize strongly enough
1:45:01just how many of the websites you use on a daily basis
1:45:04are in fact Squarespace sites.
1:45:06You'd be shocked.
1:45:07I swear to God, go look at Pixar.com.
1:45:12Pixar.com and then view source on it
1:45:14and you will find in the source
1:45:16that it's a Squarespace site.
1:45:17I don't know if the whole Pixar.com is.
1:45:20I wouldn't be surprised if they have parts that are not,
1:45:22but the homepage with the big cars three thing
1:45:24is made with Squarespace.
1:45:26I mean, this,
1:45:27I cannot emphasize.
1:45:30In the back of my mind, I always think that
1:45:31if there's a reason that people don't try Squarespace
1:45:33is that they think, 'cause this is what I would think
1:45:35if I was out there listening to me
1:45:37tell you to try Squarespace.
1:45:38I would think, eh, I don't wanna pick from 10 templates
1:45:41and all 10 of 'em look like a Squarespace site.
1:45:43You know, like back in the day when you'd install WordPress
1:45:46or something like that,
1:45:47and there were only like three default themes.
1:45:49And so as soon as you looked at a site,
1:45:51you could say, "Ah, I can tell they used WordPress
1:45:52"'cause it's a default theme."
1:45:53Squarespace is so profoundly open to design ideas
1:45:57that you know, it'll have your brand on it
1:46:01to the degree that you would a site that you built
1:46:04from the ground up the old fashioned way with code.
1:46:06So go check them out.
1:46:08The website is squarespace.com/talkshow.
1:46:11Go to squarespace.com/talkshow or maybe it's slash grouper.
1:46:19I forget.
1:46:20Try them both.
1:46:21Try slash grouper or slash talk show and one of them is going to give you 10% off your
1:46:25first order.
1:46:27My thanks to Squarespace.
1:46:28You want to talk about some letterpress?
1:46:30Yes, let's do that.
1:46:32I want to do that because I love, love, love getting people to pitch their things on this.
1:46:37So you, tell me about, you've got a book that is on the cusp of coming out?
1:46:42It's, yeah, well, it's been a very interesting thing is I've been, I'm printing a book
1:46:49of reporting I did about, I say reporting, I keep thinking of saying like, well, it's
1:46:54a book of writing on it.
1:46:55It's like, no, these are actually reported pieces I did.
1:46:57Some appeared in the Atlantic, some appeared at Meh.com, which has had me write stuff for
1:47:02their forums and some I've written for the book or for other places.
1:47:06And it's reporting on things like the history of unintentionally, or intentionally blank
1:47:10pages, which dates back to like the 1470s, it turns out.
1:47:14People started to mark this page intentionally blank.
1:47:16And like, whether, I wrote a piece for the Atlantic about quotation marks, whether we're
1:47:21going to stop seeing curly quotation marks, they might disappear because people have lost
1:47:25the desire or finesse and was there ever a reason.
1:47:28And so, I collected, I was like, you know, I want to do something with this.
1:47:30I want to do something for myself that's new and creative in 2017.
1:47:34And I called up the woman who runs the letterpress program at the School of Visual Concepts here
1:47:40in Seattle, who had taken a letterpress class from, and I'd done some letterpress back in
1:47:43the 1980s also.
1:47:44You know, I've been a graphic designer for 30 years, I've studied graphic design, I've
1:47:49designed books, and I'm like, you know, I called her to see if she had any ideas about
1:47:51where I could get something like this printed, thinking some offset or digital printing thing,
1:47:55and she said, "You should print it on letterpress, you should be our designer in residence for
1:48:00this year, we're starting the program, you should be our first person."
1:48:02I'm like, "Okay, great!"
1:48:03And so, I threw myself into classes, got up to speed, designed the book, and then the last,
1:48:09till about last week, I spent six weeks printing the book by hand on a proof press that's about
1:48:1770 years old, flatbed proof press, and it's getting close to being done. I've got to do a
1:48:23little more work. I have endpapers to print and a cover, and then I've got a bookbinder who's
1:48:27actually putting the thing together for me and handing off that piece of expertise.
1:48:30But that's the project.
1:48:31- That's the project. - The status,
1:48:32and so you did a Kickstarter,
1:48:34and you only sold 100 copies of the book.
1:48:38- Yeah, it's a numbered,
1:48:39signed, numbered, limited edition run.
1:48:42- All right, I gotta-- - And I'll have some.
1:48:43- I gotta tell you something right now.
1:48:45- Yeah. - I gotta tell you.
1:48:47I knew you were gonna do this.
1:48:49I think you told me before you did it,
1:48:50and I'm right up my alley.
1:48:52I love, number one, I'm just a fan of your work,
1:48:55but I love graphic design. - Thank you.
1:48:57- I love the idea of doing something by hand,
1:48:59so of course I was on board.
1:49:01And then the Kickstarter came and went,
1:49:02and I just wasn't paying attention,
1:49:04and I didn't get in, so I didn't get a copy of your book.
1:49:07- Well, you know, we'll have some artist proofs afterwards.
1:49:10So I'm gonna have to make, so it's this whole,
1:49:12so actually, I'll tell you about this too,
1:49:14'cause I thought this was, this is actually great
1:49:15for your own-- - Can you hook a brother
1:49:16up, Glenn? - I can, I will have, yeah.
1:49:18So you gotta do, there's like a yield issue,
1:49:20because this is the first time,
1:49:21I've never printed a book before.
1:49:22I've done other letterpress projects, the scale of this.
1:49:25And for starters, I didn't, this is not a handset book.
1:49:28This is a book I'm using, a process called
1:49:30which is a technology used for printing packaging
1:49:33materials mostly, but there's a subculture of it
1:49:36that uses the same material.
1:49:38There's service bureaus, and you, so I designed
1:49:40this in InDesign, picked appropriate fonts that
1:49:42would work and licensed correctly and sent it off
1:49:45to the service bureau, and they send me back
1:49:47printing plates, and they're like, it's like a
1:49:49rubbery material.
1:49:50So, you expose it, just like in the old days,
1:49:52we'd, you know, you'd make film and the film would
1:49:54be exposed to an offset plate, and you'd wind up
1:49:56with an offset plate that would go on press.
1:49:58an offset plate that would go on press, I get this stuff is relief material, and it's used mostly,
1:50:03like I say, like 99.9% of it is for printing plastic bags of mulch and the labels on your
1:50:11stuff. Anything that's an irregular surface or whatever is printed with flexography using
1:50:15photopolymer plates. And anyway, so this is printed on a letterpress, but it's not printed with,
1:50:21it's not metal or wood type. Although I did, I put an Easter egg in, there is actually a line set in
1:50:27six-point italic type that's in the book that's a little joke that I did in metal, and I did the
1:50:32last thing I did is that last little bit. But, so there's this, so the thing I realized in doing
1:50:37this, I was working on this and I'm kind of churning away, and I'm on this press that has,
1:50:40it runs the ink rollers automatically. So, you put ink on a metal roller and it distributes it,
1:50:45and it has a reciprocating thing that moves back and forth to make it even. So, you can get presses
1:50:49that are even more primitive, where you're actually running a brayer over the stuff you're trying to
1:50:52print. In this case, I've got like, this is a motorized thing, it takes a big part of it out,
1:50:56But there's still a manual crank so I'm sitting there takes about three turns of the crank to go from one end of the press
1:51:00To the other to do each sheet and I wound up. I think I've done about
1:51:0312,000 passes on the press to do this book so far
1:51:07So right now the status of the book is that it it's been printed and so it's on paper
1:51:11There are sheets of paper on paper
1:51:13And you had to do did you have to do the thing where you had to collate it so that like page 11 is on?
1:51:19One side. Oh my god
1:51:2147 or whatever, you know, 88 is on the other side, right?
1:51:24I know you love this stuff, so I'll tell you, yeah, I actually posted, I had this planning
1:51:29document, I started with a simple document, and I was like, well, I should just lay this
1:51:32out, I needed the imposition, and then it got more and more complicated, and now it's
1:51:35like this incredibly dense thing with like ink color and I'm using a paper that has a
1:51:39deckle edge, but the parent sheets are 25 and a half by 38 inches.
1:51:44So the deckle is along the long edge.
1:51:48It's machine-made, so it's made continuously, so it only has a deckle edge on, this is the
1:51:52Decal edges, that's that rough edge you see.
1:51:54Sometimes it's made by like actually being stamped
1:51:57out by a form.
1:51:57So, a lot of books get a book club edition book
1:51:59and has a fake decal edge that's stamped out.
1:52:02And you can tell it's fake because the decal,
1:52:04the edge is even all the way across.
1:52:06If it's a true decal edge, it's the edge of the
1:52:08form, which is called the decal that the wood
1:52:11pulp is sieved on top of and the water's drained
1:52:14out, it's pressed and dried.
1:52:15If it's a true decal edge, it's feathery on the
1:52:17edge, that's how you tell the difference.
1:52:19So, I got a paper with a decal edge, but because
1:52:21but because the sheets are so big, I can only have a decal edge on every other sheet of paper.
1:52:26This is a 64-page book finished. I'm printing it four up on each side.
1:52:32So each press sheet is four pages on each side.
1:52:34So, in order to get the decal edges to alternate, not only did I have to figure out how to impose
1:52:39four 16-page signatures, but also rotate each sheet.
1:52:45One of the folios, the two-page things that are going to be folded in half when it's cut down,
1:52:51I had to flip that so the deckle edge would be alternating when the final book was made.
1:52:55It was a little, so I made folding dummies out of paper and numbered them and took them apart
1:53:01and then turned this into a digital document. It was a lot of fun.
1:53:04I, it's one of those, being a printer is sort of one of those things and, and, and I think you
1:53:10and I share, have somebody shared interests, but like one of the other things, I, I really love
1:53:13mechanical watches and I think watchmakers, watchmakers think like programmers. It is,
1:53:18it might be what I if I was living 100 years ago, maybe what I would have done is get into watchmaking because it's
1:53:23It's all if this then that you know, this will turn at this rate and if this every once every you know
1:53:31eighth of a second it's gonna hit this and when it hits this it's gonna turn this and
1:53:34One logical this then it'll touch this and then the second hand will tick 1/8 of a second on the dial of the watch
1:53:44- Yeah, printers have the same thing,
1:53:46like where printers sit there and can strategically,
1:53:49algorithmically, well, one goes here,
1:53:53two goes there, three goes there.
1:53:54And that's why I always loved spending time
1:53:56in the print shop, back in my graphic design days.
1:53:58I loved going there, and I just loved picking the minds.
1:54:02Well, show me how you set that up.
1:54:03And most people who take pride in their work,
1:54:08and that's another thing, too.
1:54:08I don't know anybody who ever went to work
1:54:10in a print shop is like a printer
1:54:11who didn't take tremendous pride in their work.
1:54:14They're all, and they could spot errors
1:54:18a million miles away.
1:54:19- Yeah, you wouldn't last is the kind of thing.
1:54:22But here's the thing, at some point,
1:54:25actually I was talking to my friend Becky Slatkin,
1:54:27who is one of the funniest people,
1:54:30I'm gonna embarrass her if she's listening to this,
1:54:31'cause she's one of the funniest people on Twitter,
1:54:33doesn't tweet a lot, she's an iOS developer back east,
1:54:35Rebecca Slatkin is her Twitter handle.
1:54:37I recommend following her if you're a programmer
1:54:39or you like programming-related humor,
1:54:41because she's just so dry.
1:54:43no vermouth in her tweets at all. And I was talking the other day and she's asking how the
1:54:47book was going, and I was like, "You know, I just realized something. Your programming tweets and my
1:54:52letterpress actually have a lot in common." She's like, "What are you talking about?" And it was,
1:54:56I realized this letterpress I'm working on, it's like Xcode. And I'm not even kidding because,
1:55:02you know, you see the metaphor. It's like, it's like, I have a device that I didn't make,
1:55:07and it's kind of wonky and weird. And when you're using letterpress printing, you have
1:55:11these parameters. You have where the relief, it's a relief process, so you have to raise it off the
1:55:16bed of the press by exactly .918 inches, it's type high. So, anything that takes ink should be
1:55:22exactly that high, no higher or no lower, which is a whole thing when you look at the history of how
1:55:27type was made, that it was possible in early industrial days that they could get it that
1:55:31exact. Gutenberg was a genius, right? So, there's that thing. Then you have ink rollers, which can
1:55:35be raised or lowered, and the ink rollers have to have the relationship, because you don't want to
1:55:38you don't want to under ink.
1:55:40Then you have this thing, and what I'm using
1:55:42is a cylinder press, and there's a timpen on top,
1:55:44which is a piece of paper, like a kind of slightly
1:55:46waxed oiled paper, which you place the paper
1:55:49that you're printing on over.
1:55:50The timpen is packing underneath,
1:55:52and the packing has to be raised to,
1:55:53I mean, working in thousandth or five, ten thousandths
1:55:57of an inch increments.
1:55:58We have a digital caliper, so I'm constantly working
1:56:02on the difference between, say, .047 and .046 inches,
1:56:06sometimes a little bit less than that. So, this is the degree of precision you're working with
1:56:11on equipment that, again, it's 70 years old, and we have presses in the shop that are like 120 years
1:56:15old that are a little different. So, I realized I'm messing with this machine, I'm like, this is
1:56:20really, this is so much like programming, even though I'm working in this very analog environment,
1:56:24you're making tiny changes, you're tweaking stuff, then you kind of run your tests and you see,
1:56:29you're looking at the feedback out of the machine, it's a little bit of a black box. You're looking
1:56:32at it and I'm building in my head a mechanical model of the press. And the better I can model
1:56:37in my head what the press is doing and all the relationships between all the parts, the better
1:56:41I can program in all these settings that are all, you know, I'm pulling off these rollers, there's
1:56:47like a set screw, you use a hex wrench and you're turning, there's no mark. So, I have to turn
1:56:52something like one eighth of a rotation of a screw to move the ink rollers up, you know, one thousandth
1:56:57of an inch. And it actually struck me as a long-time programmer on a low level, like I'm
1:57:03a scripter, not an Objective-C writer, it struck me how much this felt like actually debugging code.
1:57:08Pete: Yeah. Yeah, very much so. Yeah, debugging, it's that right mindset, right? Or you
1:57:13gotta start working backwards, you know? And well…
1:57:17Pete: Yeah, fine detail.
1:57:18Pete; And you can, well, let's just do this and at least show us if that's the problem, you know?
1:57:23Like putting a print statement in.
1:57:24- And then like with Xcode, sometimes you just baffle,
1:57:27just throwing out errors and you're like,
1:57:29why won't you sign this code and upload it?
1:57:32What's the pattern?
1:57:33- All right, so I wanna mention, before we move on,
1:57:36I wanna mention that the print edition of the book
1:57:39is a limited edition.
1:57:40There is some mention on your site
1:57:41that there are gonna be a couple of copies
1:57:43that you might sell for and donate the proceeds
1:57:45to a charitable cause or something like that.
1:57:47I would like one of those, that's what I would like to do.
1:57:50I don't want a freebie, I wanna put some money
1:57:53towards a good cause.
1:57:54But I do want to--
1:57:55- I will alert you, I gotta figure out the best cause.
1:57:56It might be ACLU, it might be
1:57:57Canadian-American Islamic Relations.
1:57:59I gotta figure out a good cause for it.
1:58:01'Cause I feel like this was a great thing.
1:58:03The Kickstarter funded all my expenses for all materials.
1:58:05It's kind of breaking even.
1:58:07But I feel like this year especially,
1:58:08I'm like, this was for me, it was great.
1:58:10But I wanna do something that affects other people.
1:58:12- I feel like the ACLU, they don't really have much
1:58:14going on.
1:58:15- They gots, I know.
1:58:16They've been doing okay with fundraising.
1:58:18I wanna find another group that needs a little more money.
1:58:22But I'll have some artist proof.
1:58:23- So this is like this incredible thing too.
1:58:24So I started, I want 100 copies of the book,
1:58:26so essentially I started with printing 200 pages
1:58:30or 200 sheets for each press sheet
1:58:33because I knew things could go wrong.
1:58:35So it's actually some pages have three colors on them,
1:58:37which means multiple passes, which means more to go wrong.
1:58:39So I'm hoping I'm gonna be able to get out
1:58:41about 125 to 140 copies at the end
1:58:44that are good quality copies,
1:58:46and then I'll have some to give to people
1:58:47who are help with the book,
1:58:49and then I'll have some to sell as artist proofs.
1:58:51But how much pressure did you feel to not have typos?
1:58:54Like what's the over-under do you think
1:58:56on how many typos have made it in?
1:58:58Are you aware of any now that you've printed it?
1:59:00Are you aware of any typos already that now you can't fix?
1:59:03- No, I know, isn't this the terrible,
1:59:04it's a terrible feeling.
1:59:05I mean, it's like the worst thing
1:59:06when you're used to working with interactive media
1:59:08to go like, oh my God, I can never fix this.
1:59:10So, so far, I have not spotted anything
1:59:12that's wrong in the book, which is astonishing
1:59:14'cause I've been looking at it a lot.
1:59:16Some of these pieces that already appeared in print
1:59:18had been proofread.
1:59:19Others of them had not, or I'd taken an earlier, longer form than it wound up online.
1:59:25And Jeff Carlson, he has no responsibility for errors, but he did an editing and proofing
1:59:29pass for me at the end of the whole thing too.
1:59:31So, it's pretty, I mean, I've looked at it so much, I think I fixed everything.
1:59:37But you know what I'm thinking of doing, John, is I think there was enough interest
1:59:39in the book that I've been thinking of doing an offset edition that'll be twice as long.
1:59:44So, I got a bunch of stuff I couldn't fit in.
1:59:45Well, that's good.
1:59:46In the same vein.
1:59:47I just wrote a long piece for Wired about like letterpress and technology and I have the rights
1:59:52back to that after 90 days, so, which is only a couple months away. So, I may do an offset
1:59:57edition that's like 128 pages and I'll, including, I have, with this campaign, I did both the limited
2:00:05edition, but there's also an ebook that's going to include writing about the process of making
2:00:09the book, so that'll wind up in an offset version too.
2:00:11- And I definitely wanna mention this,
2:00:14is that the ebook, you can still get it right now.
2:00:16Like it's, or you could--
2:00:18- Yeah, I'm selling it on the site.
2:00:19So you can go in, I've got a commerce page
2:00:22and you can buy a--
2:00:23- Where is that?
2:00:23What site is that? - You can buy a copy of it.
2:00:24- What's the best one to go to?
2:00:25- It's, if you go to, it's a good question,
2:00:28I know, I'm so organized about this.
2:00:31It's, I've got a destination page,
2:00:34and of course I can't remember what it is.
2:00:36If you go to glog.glennf.com,
2:00:40I will put a, I should put a link up,
2:00:42'cause I had a link up about being able to buy copies
2:00:45and what is it?
2:00:47Oh, it's glog.glennf.com/pans-on-patronage,
2:00:52which is a terrible URL.
2:00:54But that's the URL.
2:00:57And then there's also a keepsake that's part of the project
2:01:00that I'm printing as well.
2:01:01That's not related to the book that I'm still working on.
2:01:05- So anyway, this is great.
2:01:06I am so looking forward to it.
2:01:09and you know how fast it was. - It's a lot of fun.
2:01:10- Does the room where you printed it,
2:01:13does it have a good smell?
2:01:14- Oh yeah, it's great, and I'm using,
2:01:18I mean, the room is full of metal type and wood type.
2:01:20- Most print shops, to me, have the most amazing smell.
2:01:23I just love it.
2:01:24- Yeah, the ink, you know, it's a incredibly physical thing,
2:01:29so I would be sometimes printing for eight or nine hours
2:01:31a day, and I'd look at my Fitbit,
2:01:33and I'd walk 10,000 steps in the shop,
2:01:35just walking three steps forward, three steps back
2:01:38to crank that thing.
2:01:39- The smell, it's sort of, the closest I can think of
2:01:41is it's sort of like any kind of machine shop
2:01:44has that smell of metal and grease.
2:01:46But ink has a smell too, and paper has a smell
2:01:50that sort of gives a print shop a unique,
2:01:53different than like any other, something else,
2:01:55like a metalworking shop or something.
2:01:57It's a great smell. - Everything feels good too.
2:01:59It's like everything has a texture and your list,
2:02:00it's also this whole thing,
2:02:02one of the things that letterpress printers
2:02:03talk about a lot and I've been learning is
2:02:05there's a sound, it's a machine.
2:02:06So if you get the wrong sound,
2:02:08then you should be able to hear that
2:02:10and know that something's wrong.
2:02:12And I've been tuning into that.
2:02:13We have a platen press, it's a pinwheel thing
2:02:16where you spin a wheel and there's a,
2:02:18this one has a foot pedal on it, foot treadle.
2:02:20And I recorded it in slow motion one night.
2:02:23And then listening to slow motion,
2:02:24it makes a tolling of a bell.
2:02:26The spring action, when it's slowed down,
2:02:27it's just bong, bong, bong.
2:02:30It's this beautiful thing.
2:02:31- One of the most amazing things,
2:02:34I couldn't believe it, but back in college,
2:02:37I don't even know how I walked into this,
2:02:39but there was a trade show here in Philadelphia,
2:02:41like a big convention of print, print stuff,
2:02:45and people trying to sell you big, expensive,
2:02:47professional print things and stuff like that.
2:02:50And I got to go with the dean
2:02:52of Drexel's College of Design.
2:02:54I don't know how, 'cause I wasn't in the College of Design.
2:02:57- Oh, yeah.
2:02:58- I guess it might have been the year after I graduated,
2:03:00'cause I was hired to build their website,
2:03:02and I guess that's how I went,
2:03:03But I did take a lot of class, anyway.
2:03:05But it was me and the dean of the College of Design
2:03:07touring this convention, and he said,
2:03:08"Hey, you wanna take notice of something.
2:03:10"Notice how many of the guys,
2:03:11"when you shake people's hands,
2:03:12"you just walk past them.
2:03:13"Notice how many people are missing."
2:03:15Do you know what I'm gonna say?
2:03:17"Notice how many people are missing a finger
2:03:18"or like the tip of a finger."
2:03:20And the idea is that so much happened so fast
2:03:24in print shops, and there's so many ways
2:03:26that you could lose the tip of a finger.
2:03:29And you tour here, and it's all these guys,
2:03:31like, you know, in the '50s, '60s,
2:03:33guys who had spent their career in print.
2:03:35And it was unbelievable how many people were missing
2:03:37like the tip of a finger or like a pinky
2:03:39or something like that.
2:03:40And he said, "There's an awful lot of people
2:03:42"who lose the tip of a finger,
2:03:43"and it's the sort of mistake you only make once."
2:03:46- Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, this is, this is,
2:03:48we have in the north, in Seattle,
2:03:50we have a fellow who's a letter press repairman,
2:03:52and it's sort of his full-time job.
2:03:53He prints too, but he used to be a motorcycle racer,
2:03:56and he had an accident that made it impossible
2:03:59him to race comfortably after that. But he knew how to take apart and rebuild motorcycles,
2:04:03and he gets kind of a wind of letterpress and discovers, and this is, I mean, I'm talking
2:04:07about just several years ago, not like 30 years ago, he's a young guy. And he realizes letterpress
2:04:12are much simpler to his mind than motorcycles. So, he learns, reads the manuals are all online.
2:04:17I mean, you can find these scanned Google books of things from 70, 100 years ago,
2:04:21and he learns how to take these things apart. And because of him, if it weren't for him,
2:04:24I think a lot, there's a pretty big Northwest letterpress community, and I think Seattle
2:04:28would be impoverished without his assistance,
2:04:32'cause he knows stuff that people haven't known
2:04:34for 50 years or 40 years.
2:04:37He has relearned it and taught it to other people.
2:04:40- Yeah, I believe it.
2:04:42I believe that one person could make a difference in--
2:04:45- Oh yeah, he's missing part of a finger.
2:04:46That's why I was thinking that.
2:04:47(laughing)
2:04:49That's the sad part.
2:04:50- Hey, let me take one last break here
2:04:52and thank our last sponsor,
2:04:54and that's our friends at MailRoute.
2:04:56Do you know who should handle your email security
2:04:58and delivery, people who do only that.
2:05:00That's MailRoute.
2:05:01MailRoute's a team of people who've been in business
2:05:03for a long time, and all they do, the whole company,
2:05:06is just devoted to email.
2:05:08That's really what they do.
2:05:09They don't even host email.
2:05:10What they do is they know how to filter email.
2:05:14Postini went away, McAfee and MX Logic,
2:05:19they had similar services.
2:05:20They've gotten out of the business,
2:05:21and even Google has come out and said that if you want,
2:05:23that they recommend that you use a gateway service
2:05:25like MailRoute to filter your mail.
2:05:27Here's what you do.
2:05:28keep your domain that you already have for email and you just change the MX
2:05:31records just that's the DNS that you know that so that everybody knows that
2:05:35like at daring fireball dotnet where's the server the MX record says to email
2:05:42another email server that's sending email if you're sending it to somebody
2:05:44there that's where the server goes so it goes to mail route first they filter out
2:05:49all the junk and then they just forward it immediately like in a hundredth of a
2:05:52second right on to your existing mail server so in other words what would have
2:05:57come right into your mail server,
2:05:58instead just goes through a thin filter at mail route first
2:06:02and then goes on to you.
2:06:03And they keep all the junk and viruses.
2:06:04And that's all that they do.
2:06:06That's their service.
2:06:06But because that's all they do, this
2:06:09is like the Cadillac of mail filtering.
2:06:12I mean, this has got everything you would want.
2:06:14They have APIs.
2:06:15So if you're a programmer, you can customize
2:06:18the way all this works.
2:06:20They have all sorts of great things.
2:06:22If you want, you can get a weekly digest
2:06:24for every user, every email address that
2:06:27gives you a list of here's what's been filtered,
2:06:29here's the list of emails that were like maybe on the fence
2:06:33and you can quick eyeball that list
2:06:34to see if anything got flagged that shouldn't.
2:06:37And if you want that more frequently,
2:06:39you can get it more frequently.
2:06:40If you don't wanna get it all,
2:06:40you don't have to get it at all.
2:06:41You can just set it and forget it.
2:06:43It is absolutely a fantastic service,
2:06:46a do one thing and do it as well as you can type thing.
2:06:50I don't know of any other company that does this,
2:06:52that does what MailRoute does as a dedicated service.
2:06:56Where do you go to find out more?
2:06:58And by the way, get a 30-day free trial.
2:07:01So you go try it for an entire month,
2:07:03completely free of charge.
2:07:05And if you don't like it, all you have to do to undo it
2:07:07is just change your MX records back to where they were before.
2:07:11I just can't explain how easy it is to turn this on
2:07:14and how easy it is to turn it off
2:07:16if you're tempted by this free trial.
2:07:17Go to mailroute.net/ttstts for the talk show.
2:07:22And if you use that code, if you use that URL,
2:07:26you'll get 10% off for the lifetime of your account.
2:07:29As Marco Arment says on ATP,
2:07:31it's the best deal on the internet
2:07:32because you could use this for 20 years
2:07:34and you're still getting that 10% off every single month
2:07:36for the lifetime of your account.
2:07:37My thanks to MailRoute for sponsoring the talk show.
2:07:41We gotta go into speed round now, Glenn.
2:07:43We've been going for a while.
2:07:45- Boom, okay.
2:07:47- Apple inadvertently leaks HomePod OS,
2:07:49spilling many beans. - Oh, I was embarrassed.
2:07:51- Wow. - It's always that thing
2:07:52of like, did somebody get fired?
2:07:54I don't know.
2:07:55It's just, wow, that's the worst thing for them.
2:07:58- I almost, I suspect nobody got fired
2:08:00because I think whoever was ultimately responsible for that,
2:08:03nobody feels worse than they do.
2:08:06So what happened is Apple was apparently,
2:08:09this is, I can't prove it, this is what I've heard,
2:08:12was on the, Cosper, maybe they already have,
2:08:15but they were about to start rolling out a lot,
2:08:18I don't know, hundreds, let's just say hundreds
2:08:20of prototype HomePods to employees.
2:08:23- Right. - Maybe even more.
2:08:25And because it's a revealed product, the wraps are taken off, they can do this.
2:08:33And apparently this software update that got leaked was meant for them.
2:08:36And I don't know enough, so that's the why, of why in the world would Apple have an OS
2:08:43release for an unreleased product.
2:08:45Well it's sort of like the cold opening, it's being released to employees at this point.
2:08:51it was a world readable disk image and there's some guys like our friend Steven
2:08:57Trout and Smith and a couple of other people who man do they know what to do
2:09:03when it so it's running apparently it's running a beta version of iOS 11.02 I
2:09:09mean it's I think that you know the numbers get weird but it's you know yeah
2:09:13and what they usually do for like for example with the public betas and the
2:09:18developer betas of iOS right now. Inside Apple there are versions of the beta
2:09:22versions of iOS 11 that are running on the prototype new iPhones or
2:09:28pre-production whatever whatever stage of production are at now in August. And
2:09:32the version that goes to me and you or you good listener of the show if you're
2:09:39in the developer beta or the public beta of iOS they they have in programming
2:09:45terms to #ifdef statement in C where you can say in your code if this
2:09:51variable has been defined, do this. And if it's not, then that code
2:09:57doesn't even go into the compiler. It's called, you know, I want to
2:10:03make this as layman friendly as possible. It's the C preprocessor.
2:10:07So this gets processed before the code goes into the compiler. And so all the
2:10:12stuff specific to like the new secret iPhone Pro or whatever doesn't even hit
2:10:17the compiler when they do a build for public release because this this HomePod
2:10:25OS release wasn't meant for public consumption none none of that stuff was
2:10:30defined out I almost feel like that would had to be a mistake because I could
2:10:35see why the HomePod specific stuff wasn't but why in the world the release
2:10:39had the images on I guess it didn't really I guess that's it the that it
2:10:44that the icon that leaked was somehow related to the home pod somehow I don't
2:10:48know but anyway all sorts of stuff leaked out including an icon showing the
2:10:52the deal at d22 codenamed iPhone Pro with the the notch you know the bezel
2:10:59to bezel design and the little notch at the top for the the camera and other
2:11:04sensors. Boy, what a screw up.
2:11:06Pete: Yeah, it's funny. It's, I feel bad, well, it's interesting because you feel bad for the
2:11:14people involved because this isn't, like, I had this discussion with somebody the other day,
2:11:19it was about like, leaks at companies and like, well, I like to find out stuff that's coming
2:11:22before it happens. It's also, you know, when stuff's purposely leaked, you're like, well,
2:11:26unless this is the company's intent, this is somebody who kind of wants to be, you know,
2:11:30It's like there's fine color about an issue and there's like okay. Here's what's coming next when it only has a commercial interest
2:11:35There's not a like public service interest or you know, something's wrong and was being fixed in this case
2:11:41It's just it was just a screw-up. And so it's sort of the whole thing is sort of sad
2:11:45So let me it's among the details that were revealed
2:11:48This is what I noted in my post on during fireball the sound effects of the home pod
2:11:52So you can hear some of the things that the little wave files that they have
2:11:58the icon for the new high-end iPhone matching the descriptions. Now, that's a bad one.
2:12:03That's bad.
2:12:05But on the other hand, if, for example, if the poor soul who was ultimately responsible for this is a
2:12:11listener of the show, you can feel a little better because there are part leaks.
2:12:16I mean, it only confirmed what the rumor mill had already said. It wasn't like this came out of the blue and nobody
2:12:21wasn't expecting it. That's actually,
2:12:24at least at an icon level, exactly what we as close followers of the company were expecting.
2:12:29The code name for the new high-end iPhone is D22. As far as I can tell, I did find a link to like an
2:12:36Apple insider report from back in December. That was the first instance I found of D22,
2:12:42where some random source in China from the supply chain leaked a thing that said,
2:12:48"Here's a schematic of where the SIM card is moving, and the code name for this phone is D22."
2:12:53Well, it turns out that whoever that source was was exactly right.
2:12:56It is code named D22.
2:12:58Is that really a big deal?
2:12:59No.
2:13:00It's not.
2:13:02It's not like that Apple doesn't really talk about those code names.
2:13:05It's not like you spoiled something from the keynote.
2:13:08We've got the display resolution, 1125 by 2436.
2:13:12So that's interesting because it's actually different than what Ming-Chi Kuo said.
2:13:16He said it was going to be like 12 something by 2800 and that there would be an 1125 by
2:13:23by 2436 area within that, that's the usable display.
2:13:27But from what Steven Trout and Smith has uncovered,
2:13:31it doesn't seem like it.
2:13:32It seems like that's the actual display.
2:13:34So there's a little bit of a mystery there.
2:13:37We learned that the HomePod does have a color display,
2:13:40and we learned that there are APIs for the phone
2:13:42to have an infrared-based face recognizer.
2:13:45Well, all of those things only confirm rumors
2:13:47that have already been out there.
2:13:49- Right, it's nothing particularly new,
2:13:50but it's still, I mean, Apple's always fighting
2:13:54against the sale of the next model they haven't made yet,
2:13:56right, and every detail about something that's gonna come,
2:14:01although I think they've defeated, in some level,
2:14:03they've defeated that cycle a bit
2:14:04because they're now in a routine cycle for now years,
2:14:07and we know, and people buying a phone know
2:14:10that in September-ish, there's gonna be a new series
2:14:13announced, it'll be available either shortly after
2:14:15within a few weeks, and it's gonna be somewhat better.
2:14:17So it's not like people don't know
2:14:20when they get a phone, what's gonna happen.
2:14:21The iPhone 8 or whatever it'll be called,
2:14:25I think the word that it's gonna be an expensive phone
2:14:27doesn't mean that people are not gonna buy a phone now
2:14:30either if they're planning to or they need one.
2:14:33But I assume sales get really slumpy around now
2:14:35except for people who just don't care.
2:14:37They're just like, it's 20 bucks a month, or you know--
2:14:38- I think it's surprising how many people don't care.
2:14:41I mean, obviously, you can see it.
2:14:42You can look at the charts,
2:14:44and you can see that there's a huge spike
2:14:47for when the phones just come out.
2:14:49So the October, November, December quarter
2:14:52has a huge spike because even though the phones
2:14:54usually technically go on sale in September,
2:14:56it's just like at the end of September.
2:14:59Whereas, and they often have trouble,
2:15:02or almost always have trouble meeting demand,
2:15:04and so the sales don't go on the books
2:15:05until they actually sell it.
2:15:07So it's that October, November, December quarter
2:15:10is the biggest quarter.
2:15:11But it's also the biggest quarter
2:15:13'cause it's the holiday quarter,
2:15:14and people get iPhones for the holidays.
2:15:16I mean, the iPods used to have that huge spike
2:15:21in the holiday quarter too, because they were amazing gifts.
2:15:24And I think it's a little bit easier
2:15:26to give somebody an iPod, because you're just giving them,
2:15:28it's like giving them a Walkman.
2:15:29You're just giving them an electronic device
2:15:31and you're on your own, whereas giving somebody a thing
2:15:32that comes with a $30 a month or an up,
2:15:36I wish my cell phone was $30 a month, whatever.
2:15:39But you don't just give somebody an iPhone
2:15:42if they didn't ask for it.
2:15:43But I'm sure there are tons of kids and families
2:15:46and spouses and stuff, and it's like,
2:15:48you know what, you can get me this year,
2:15:49I'm gonna get a new iPhone,
2:15:49and give it to me as a Christmas gift.
2:15:51- Yeah, just add it to the, yeah.
2:15:53But I'm, you know, it's actually,
2:15:55I'm encountering this problem
2:15:56'cause I wanna sell my iPhone 6S.
2:15:57I have a 7 Plus, and I was reluctant to switch to it,
2:16:00but I'm like, yeah, it's probably time,
2:16:01but then I'm like, well, I'm gonna get a new phone
2:16:03'cause of the computational photography stuff
2:16:06that I'm interested in.
2:16:07I will almost certainly get a new phone when they come out,
2:16:09so now I'll have two phones to sell,
2:16:11and nobody wants a 6S right now,
2:16:12even though it's in good shape,
2:16:13because why buy it at 400 something dollars,
2:16:17a used version of this, when the price is gonna drop
2:16:20after the 7S ships and people will then
2:16:23be able to get it for 100 bucks.
2:16:24So I think people who are looking at a used phone
2:16:26are actually savvy about waiting
2:16:27'cause have not been able to find a,
2:16:29usually can sell any iPhone very quickly
2:16:32if it's in good shape and this time not.
2:16:33- Yeah, I don't know though, anecdotally,
2:16:35a lot of people in my family over the summer
2:16:37have been asking me, hey, if I'm thinking
2:16:38about getting a new iPhone, which one should I get?
2:16:40And I'm like, just wait.
2:16:41- Oh, you're like, just wait. - And they're like, oh,
2:16:42and they're like, why?
2:16:42I was like, well, the new ones will come out in September,
2:16:44and they're like, really?
2:16:45And I'm like--
2:16:46- Well, although a lot of the features don't appeal,
2:16:48I mean, some people don't see the incremental features
2:16:50as more than like Chrome. - No, they don't.
2:16:51No, and that's why they-- - You don't study it.
2:16:52You're like, well, it's a new collar, right?
2:16:54It's like, no, it's not a new collar.
2:16:55It's actually a whole better device.
2:16:56- And so even though there is a spike,
2:16:58they still sell, I don't know,
2:16:5940 million of them every quarter.
2:17:00They'll sell 40 million or 10, 15 million of them this month
2:17:05in the month of August, in five weeks
2:17:07before the new ones come out.
2:17:08Because most people don't care about that.
2:17:11In the same way that most people, including me, frankly,
2:17:16I bought a 2006 car in December of 2006.
2:17:21The 2007s were already out 'cause I didn't give a shit.
2:17:25I don't know what the difference was between the 2006, 2007,
2:17:27but I knew I didn't give enough of a shit
2:17:30compared to the thousands of dollars that cost less.
2:17:33- Exactly, exactly.
2:17:34- And I think that there's an awful lot of people
2:17:36who feel that way about their iPhone.
2:17:37They just don't care.
2:17:38They accept, they know, I'm sure they believe
2:17:40that for people who are truly tuned in like we are,
2:17:43that we know, oh my god, the camera's gonna change
2:17:46from F1.8 to F1.6 or whatever.
2:17:50They don't give a shit.
2:17:52They don't even know what the hell that means.
2:17:54- What's the Merlin Mann line?
2:17:55Isn't it something like, it has more mega-florps.
2:17:57- Yeah, mega-florps, exactly.
2:17:59That's what people think.
2:18:00- That's what it, the thing that, I'll tell you,
2:18:02the one statistic that floored me,
2:18:04I still think about on a regular basis,
2:18:06is when Jason Snell backed out the
2:18:07how many simultaneous production lines there has to be.
2:18:10was Jason, right? How many simultaneous production lines do you have to be?
2:18:12No, wasn't it Jean-Louis Grasé?
2:18:14No. Was it him? Oh, well, I confused the two of them, I guess.
2:18:17Yeah, maybe Jason quoted it. Yeah.
2:18:18All right, one of those guys. But that how many simultaneous production lines have to
2:18:23be going to achieve the number because of the end-to-end time it makes to assemble an
2:18:27iPhone, so it was some thousands, right, that are being made simultaneously. And I thought
2:18:32that floored me more than—like, 40 million is a number, but when you're like, "No,
2:18:36at the same time going down parallel production lines
2:18:40all over Foxconn plant, you're like, that is astonishing.
2:18:44But that came out, you talked about,
2:18:46I don't want to get too deep,
2:18:47I know we're near the end of the show,
2:18:47but is that you talked about that issue of the scaling,
2:18:50it's like any part you make, you can't come out
2:18:52with a certain kind of innovation anymore
2:18:54because it has to scale to hundreds of millions of times,
2:18:56has to work instantly, the availability,
2:18:59it has to be so extraordinary.
2:19:01It's going to be a problem they have for years now.
2:19:03It's gonna be a problem they have for years now.
2:19:05- I'm sure of it.
2:19:07It's, you know.
2:19:08- Well, I think they're, I think they're,
2:19:10I mean, we'll see how it goes,
2:19:11but I think they're, with this D22 phone,
2:19:15I think that they're trying to get the,
2:19:17wiggle their way out of it.
2:19:19- Yeah, yeah.
2:19:20- Yeah, I mean, again, it's like I said.
2:19:22- They're only gonna sell 50 million of them
2:19:24instead of 200 million or something, right?
2:19:25- I don't know.
2:19:26I don't know.
2:19:27Let's see.
2:19:28Also, the other thing was that that year ago report
2:19:31that had the D22 code name also said that internally
2:19:34it was nicknamed Ferrari, which I thought was,
2:19:38and so since they had the D22,
2:19:40it certainly adds a lot of credibility
2:19:42that the Ferrari was a real nickname for it.
2:19:44And like I wrote on there,
2:19:45Fireball Ferrari does sound like a nickname
2:19:48for a product that might be a little bit more expensive.
2:19:51I really don't think it's gonna be Ferrari expensive,
2:19:56but I'm pretty sure I'm right
2:20:00that this is going to have a surprisingly high,
2:20:02surprising to many people high price.
2:20:04We shall see.
2:20:06Last but not least, the other thing I had on my list here
2:20:11was this Facebook post from Vic Gundotra.
2:20:14- Oh my God, oh my God.
2:20:16- So you may or may not remember.
2:20:18- Cotton it for you.
2:20:19- Right, I still haven't linked to it from Daring Fireball
2:20:21because I haven't had time 'cause I,
2:20:24it's almost like, did this really happen?
2:20:27So Vic Gundotra used to work at Google
2:20:29and he was the most, you know, he was in charge of Android,
2:20:32or not really in charge of it, but he was,
2:20:34like he was the ringleader of their keynote in 2010,
2:20:37when they most harshly went after iPhone and Apple directly
2:20:42with, you know, just like,
2:20:44we, you know, if it wasn't for us,
2:20:48meaning Google and Android, we'd live in a world
2:20:50where one man, one company controls the future,
2:20:53you know, this sort of dystopian, you know,
2:20:54Steve Jobs controls everything,
2:20:57and has all sorts of quotes over the years.
2:20:59I'll put some links in the show notes,
2:21:01but more or less tearing into Apple for being closed
2:21:04and closed is bad and open is good.
2:21:06He had a post on Facebook where singing to high praises,
2:21:12the portrait mode on his iPhone 7 Plus.
2:21:16And here, the money line is bottom line.
2:21:21This is a quote from Vikhoon Dothra,
2:21:23who's doing something else now.
2:21:23He's left Google a couple years ago.
2:21:25If you truly care about great photography,
2:21:27you own an iPhone.
2:21:28If you don't mind being a few years behind, buy an iPhone.
2:21:31- Oh my God, so rude.
2:21:33It's true, but it's also.
2:21:35- The funny part to me was reading the comments.
2:21:37And he's obvious, I don't know how Facebook works exactly
2:21:40'cause I've never had a Facebook account,
2:21:41but this post is available, it's world readable,
2:21:44so I could read it and I could see these comments.
2:21:46But there are an awful lot of people who follow him
2:21:48or whatever you do to people on Facebook
2:21:50who are in a circle, whatever the hell they have,
2:21:54who are obviously Android fans and they were,
2:21:57he did not take this very well at all.
2:22:00But they're also deeply in denial.
2:22:02Like there was somebody who obviously fancies himself
2:22:04as a technical person, you know,
2:22:06but somebody was trying to say that the Samsung S8
2:22:09has the same feature and it's better implemented.
2:22:12The Samsung, I mean, whatever you wanna say
2:22:13about the Samsung Galaxy S8 as a camera
2:22:16compared to the regular iPhone 7, maybe it's as good.
2:22:19I know that, I'm sure it has a very good camera.
2:22:21I own a Google Pixel upstairs.
2:22:23The Google Pixel has an excellent camera.
2:22:25I don't, I honestly don't know if it's better or worse
2:22:29than my iPhone 7.
2:22:29I'm familiar with the iPhone 7,
2:22:31but I can see that they're technically
2:22:33on par with each other, you know.
2:22:35Somebody cited the Pixel thing and that stupid DxOMark
2:22:40that ranked the Pixel as having the highest rated sensor
2:22:43in their history.
2:22:44That DxOMark thing is bullshit.
2:22:46It's total bullshit.
2:22:47The people pay to be in it.
2:22:50The reason that they rated the Pixel
2:22:52before that even came out was 'cause Google paid them
2:22:54to do it.
2:22:55It's a bullshit metric.
2:22:57And even if you believe the metric,
2:22:59it's only rating the sensor of the camera.
2:23:01It's not even telling you whether it takes good pictures
2:23:03or not, it's saying it has the best sensor.
2:23:05But it's obviously, it worked to Google's advantage
2:23:08where people who want to believe it took it as meaning
2:23:10that some independent firm has certified
2:23:13that the Google Pixel has the best camera on any phone.
2:23:16It doesn't.
2:23:17The iPhone 7 Plus has the best camera on any phone.
2:23:19And I say this as somebody whose daily phone,
2:23:21phone I own is an iPhone 7, not the 7 Plus, because I like the size better.
2:23:25I love the 7 Plus so much.
2:23:26But it hurts my heart.
2:23:27I carry—
2:23:28The 7 Plus is so much better as a camera. It's ridiculous. It's absolutely ridiculous.
2:23:32And portrait mode is amazing.
2:23:33It's astonishing.
2:23:34And it has gotten—
2:23:35Yeah.
2:23:36It has gotten so much better since it came out last year. The edge detection is so much
2:23:39better. But the Galaxy S8 camera, they do have a—they call it like fake bokeh mode
2:23:43or something, and it has something that tries to do it, but it's still just a one-lens
2:23:48camera and it's doing it all with edge detection and it's all software, whereas there's no optical
2:23:53aspect to it like there is with the iPhone.
2:23:54Pete: Yeah. His point he makes is, I mean, I think, I think he, I actually think that he
2:24:00isn't betraying what he said in the past. I think he did not like, it's clear the evolution of
2:24:06Android was not the direction he thought it would go. And his statement in the Facebook post in
2:24:10reply to people are like, well, you know, when you don't control the hardware and you got to
2:24:15make compromises in all the software, you can't do great things like this. Google was way ahead,
2:24:19and they really were. Google is way ahead. Project Tango is really interesting, where it has a depth
2:24:24camera in addition to a regular camera. And I wouldn't be surprised if Apple ads, actually,
2:24:29a literally separate depth finding lens or thing. It's kind of, well, it's not a lens, like a laser
2:24:36bouncing thing. But anyway, it makes a lot of sense to do that for, if you're trying to do AR
2:24:41and other kinds of depth-based things.
2:24:43Two lenses is good, and this is even better.
2:24:46So anyway, Google has been more advanced in
2:24:48computational photography.
2:24:49They acquired, sorry, they hired away the father of
2:24:53computational photography from Stanford, you know,
2:24:56went to work there.
2:24:57I tried to interview him for an article.
2:24:58He said, yeah, let me talk to PR.
2:24:59And there's dead silence.
2:25:00After that, wasn't able to get him into a piece I did
2:25:03for a fast company last year about the future of
2:25:05computational photography.
2:25:07And without being able to enforce and push stuff down low enough, they can't do the stuff
2:25:13Apple can.
2:25:14And he admits it, and I think that's obviously, I don't know why he left the team or what
2:25:18happened there, but it's clearly a point of frustration for him.
2:25:21And he's not wrong about the iPhone 7 Plus.
2:25:23I own one.
2:25:24I bought it specifically for photography, and I carry it like I have a nice mirrorless
2:25:28camera I really like, and I pick up the iPhone 7 Plus all the time.
2:25:32Now, when we had double rainbows the other day, we had a crazy 180-degree double rainbow
2:25:36of a weird weather thing, I grabbed my nice camera
2:25:38and a zoom lens and went out and shot all kinds of shots.
2:25:41And when I was doing some other photography
2:25:43in a nature area near here, I brought my nicer camera,
2:25:46my camera with the lens.
2:25:46But the iPhone 7 Plus is the most fantastic
2:25:51cell phone camera you can get.
2:25:52- I have the, I think I mentioned this with Renee
2:25:55in a recent episode, but I still have the red,
2:25:58when the red iPhones came out mid-year or mid-cycle,
2:26:02Apple gave me a review unit, very nice of them.
2:26:05I mean, I don't know what to do.
2:26:06I mean, you know what I mean?
2:26:07It's exactly the phone I reviewed six months earlier,
2:26:09except now it's red, you know.
2:26:12But that's nice.
2:26:12So I still have it.
2:26:14That's the phone I've been using
2:26:16the iOS betas on all summer.
2:26:17And because I'm running the betas on it,
2:26:20I took it, we had a family wedding down in South Carolina,
2:26:24and we were there for a week.
2:26:25We had a family that rented a beach house,
2:26:28and it was very nice.
2:26:29And we went to right near Charleston,
2:26:32which I'd never been to Charleston before.
2:26:34Beautiful city.
2:26:35oh my God, if you ever have a chance to go
2:26:36to Charleston, South Carolina, it's truly, truly beautiful.
2:26:40And it's really interesting to me as a Philadelphian
2:26:42to see a city with roots from the exact same era,
2:26:45pre-colonial, colonial times,
2:26:47and to see certain things that are the same
2:26:49and certain things that are so different
2:26:51between Philadelphia and Charleston.
2:26:54But anyway, took my Fuji X100S,
2:26:59which is, if you're not a camera nerd, it's not an SLR.
2:27:02It doesn't even have detachable lenses.
2:27:04as one lens, a 35 millimeter equivalent lens.
2:27:07But a really, really nice mirrorless camera.
2:27:11I really love it.
2:27:12It's a couple years out of date.
2:27:13I think there's two successors already.
2:27:16But it really is a great camera.
2:27:17It takes great video and really nice stills.
2:27:21And I took my regular iPhone,
2:27:22and I also took the iPhone 7 Plus
2:27:24just because I was testing iOS betas at the time.
2:27:27And so I took a portrait of Jonas in Charleston.
2:27:31It was just real nice light.
2:27:33I took a portrait of my son using the iPhone 7S,
2:27:36or the 7 Plus, and then took one with the X100S
2:27:41from the exact same spot, you know.
2:27:43And I do have to say, the X100S shot definitely looks better.
2:27:47I could see it, it is, there's no shame in that.
2:27:51I mean, it's a dedicated camera that cost me like $1100.
2:27:55But boy oh boy does the portrait mode get close.
2:28:00And boy oh boy does the portrait mode take a picture
2:28:03that looks so much better than anything you can get
2:28:05with the regular iPhone 7.
2:28:07- Oh, and holy cow, after WWDC,
2:28:11when I went through the presentations
2:28:13and looked at what they were demoing
2:28:15or showing in presentations and then read stuff
2:28:17about developers who were testing that,
2:28:19that is gonna be so amazing with the depth API added.
2:28:22They're showing, I mean, I think it's seven different
2:28:25distinct layers of depth that, if I'm remembering right,
2:28:27at least in the current version,
2:28:28and just the idea of you'll be able to have
2:28:30black and white background, color foreground,
2:28:33drop people into things, automatically do silhouetting,
2:28:35which is useful for all kinds of purposes.
2:28:37The AR integration relies on depth mapping,
2:28:41that's a whole other thing, but I think the two camera phone,
2:28:45I mean, I'm curious if the premium phone
2:28:47is gonna have two cameras,
2:28:48'cause it would be weird if it didn't, right?
2:28:50But-- - I think it does.
2:28:51I think the premium phone-- - It does?
2:28:53- My big question is-- - Has to.
2:28:55- I don't think the rumor mill has answered it,
2:28:57is are all of the new ones gonna have dual cameras?
2:28:59Like, will the-- - All the phones?
2:29:01- Right, like, I don't know--
2:29:02- They should, it's not very expensive
2:29:04to add a second camera at this point.
2:29:06I mean, they're building the camera system already,
2:29:07it's more about space.
2:29:08- Yeah, and so far in the plus era,
2:29:11meaning starting with the iPhone 6,
2:29:13the plus model has had a better camera
2:29:17than the non-plus model, but every single year,
2:29:20the next year, the regular model gets
2:29:24whatever the one had before,
2:29:26whereas the first one was optical image stabilization.
2:29:30And I think the iPhone 6S, the iPhone 6S got it.
2:29:34But it was optical image stabilization
2:29:36that only worked for stills and not video.
2:29:38But then the iPhone, when the 6S got it,
2:29:41the 6S Plus got optical image stabilization
2:29:44that works for video too.
2:29:46And then last year, now the iPhone 7
2:29:49has optical image stabilization that works with video.
2:29:52And that is one of the most striking things too,
2:29:54where I did notice that, where optical image stabilization
2:29:57on video on these phones is so unbelievably good.
2:30:01I realize, and so for example,
2:30:03on the X, my X100S doesn't have it.
2:30:06And so the video, in terms of the still quality
2:30:09of the frames of video, it's unbelievably beautiful.
2:30:13But because it doesn't have optical image stabilization,
2:30:15or not optical image, yeah, optical image stabilization.
2:30:18- Yeah, yeah.
2:30:19- The video I shoot on my phone looks way better
2:30:22for like, you know, just typical,
2:30:25taking stuff on vacation, walking around.
2:30:27It's not on a tripod, it's handheld.
2:30:30The smoothness of that makes it so much more,
2:30:34it looks, honestly, if you'd have shown it
2:30:37to somebody 10 years ago, it looks like professional video.
2:30:39Like, there's no way, how could an amateur shoot video
2:30:41that we were walking down a sidewalk and it's not shaking?
2:30:45How could you get-- - Yeah, it was weird.
2:30:46I was shooting something the other day
2:30:48and it was bizarre to me.
2:30:49I thought something was wrong with the camera
2:30:50because it was so smooth.
2:30:51There's like, oh yeah, yeah, it's OAS.
2:30:53I was actually doing the right thing,
2:30:55but it was so smooth, it was,
2:30:56it felt like it wasn't tracking me correctly,
2:30:59and it was just doing it the right thing.
2:31:00- I honestly think it's a bigger difference
2:31:02for consumer video than the move
2:31:05from standard deaf to high deaf,
2:31:06at least in terms, if you compare it
2:31:08to the last years of standard deaf, the quality.
2:31:13Like when Jonas was born, Jonas is 13,
2:31:15so we got a video camera right before he was born,
2:31:17so it was like the best mini DV was the tape technology.
2:31:22I got the best mini DV that I could,
2:31:25It was within my budget from Panasonic.
2:31:27So the first couple years of his life,
2:31:29our video of him is all shot on a standard def.
2:31:33And you could see it, and the frame is four to three,
2:31:35it's not 16 to nine.
2:31:37But the quality's not that bad.
2:31:38It was really, it really doesn't look so bad.
2:31:41Like when we watch those old movies now,
2:31:43the aspect ratio stands out more than the image quality.
2:31:48I mean, the image quality's there, you could see it,
2:31:49but I think that the biggest difference in consumer video
2:31:53is the optical image stabilization,
2:31:54because the video I shoot on my phone now,
2:31:56I'm just shocked sometimes at how smooth it is.
2:31:59One thing, you know where I got on this rant,
2:32:03was I noticed it was the Clips app.
2:32:06I don't wanna go on a long rant here,
2:32:08I know we gotta wrap up, but Apple's Clips app,
2:32:11when you shoot video in Clips,
2:32:12it doesn't have optical image stabilization.
2:32:15And it stuck out to me like a sore thumb
2:32:18when I was making just a little clip of a family birthday,
2:32:22second birthday of like a niece or a nephew,
2:32:25I forget whose birthday it was earlier this summer,
2:32:26I made, shot a bunch of clips with it,
2:32:28and then when I watched it, I was like,
2:32:30this looks like shit compared to my usual videos.
2:32:32And then I realized that when you shoot a clip in clips,
2:32:34and I wrote to Apple and confirmed it,
2:32:36it doesn't use optical image stabilization.
2:32:39I don't know why.
2:32:39- Oh, that's, might be, well, it's weird,
2:32:42because you think it'd be pulling it out of the,
2:32:44what is it called, the image, the ISO,
2:32:47no, what is it, the thing that does the image processing
2:32:50on the--
2:32:51I don't know if it's a battery thing or what,
2:32:53but you know, huh, it's interesting.
2:32:55But it really sticks out.
2:32:56And so if you do this, if you just like,
2:32:58just in your house, just like shoot, use the camera app,
2:33:01take a video of yourself walking down a hallway,
2:33:04and then go back to the beginning, go to the Clips app,
2:33:08and reproduce the shot, and try to hold the camera still,
2:33:13and then put the two clips side by side and watch,
2:33:15and I guarantee you, you will see the difference.
2:33:17Anyway.
2:33:20Anyway, my big hope, my single biggest hope
2:33:23for the iPhone this year, and I don't think
2:33:25the rumors have answered it.
2:33:27If they are, somebody let me know.
2:33:28But I don't think we know yet whether the iPhone 7S,
2:33:32if that's what they're gonna call it,
2:33:33but the new 4.7 inch new iPhone has dual cameras or not.
2:33:37And I certainly hope it does, because it's a huge, huge,
2:33:41it's just a game changer.
2:33:43- It's so great, and they've barely,
2:33:44I mean, what Apple and tech parties can do with it
2:33:46is really, we've barely seen anything.
2:33:49Computational photography for me,
2:33:50why I wrote the piece for Fast Company last year. It's the most exciting thing nobody talks about
2:33:55because it requires too much background to understand what the future might bring,
2:34:00so you have to see examples of real things happening and then be able to do it yourself.
2:34:04And portrait mode is a taste of that, but there's so many things you can do because it gives you
2:34:09the ability, especially with two cameras that have different characteristics, you essentially
2:34:13can combine those in a way that gives you almost like more F-stops. You can de-blur things because
2:34:19you have two images, you can actually interpolate a deblur. There's like a million things that are
2:34:24super cool. And we've seen one of them. We've seen HDR, which dates back years. That's a form of
2:34:31computational photography. And now we're seeing this portrait mode, and there's like 50 other
2:34:36cool things that are gonna come that will be exciting as a photographer to use as an
2:34:40additional tool in your art studio.
2:34:41- Do you know what I've noticed too? I don't know if you have. I noticed this summer,
2:34:44and I guess in shocking summers when I'm outside and not in my little cave.
2:34:49But like I noticed with some shots we were at Disney World last month, I noticed that I almost
2:34:55always now, I have when you have HDR on it, I have it set so that it saves two, it still saves
2:35:00two versions of the photo, one with and one without. And the reason that preference exists
2:35:05is that when the iPhone first got HDR, sometimes it did, sometimes it made the photo better and
2:35:11sometimes it definitely didn't. Sometimes it would, there'd be like a weird double exposure
2:35:15type thing or something would just look wrong in the HDR version. I'm on the cusp
2:35:20of just turning that preference off because whenever it's on, I always
2:35:24prefer HDR now. I can't find one in my last several hundred shots where I
2:35:28prefer the non HDR version. Yeah, if it takes an HDR shot, there's a reason
2:35:33for it and the non HDR one is blown out or something else. They've gotten better
2:35:36though, they've gotten better at avoiding it and it's the sort of incremental
2:35:41improvements that nobody really sings the praises off. So if you're there on
2:35:44on the HDR team at Apple's photo engineering team.
2:35:47- We noticed.
2:35:48- We noticed and I thank you for your blood, sweat, and tears.
2:35:51- I should turn that off too.
2:35:52I'm taking all these extra shots for no good reason.
2:35:54- Yeah, I've got all these extra shots
2:35:55and I realize now that I, but I used to think,
2:35:57well, I, but I, you know, look at this one.
2:35:59This one looks weird with HDR
2:36:01and now I don't see that anymore.
2:36:03- The funny thing is that the one thing
2:36:04that I had to deal with recently,
2:36:05I was trying to take a very long,
2:36:07I wanted to take pictures of me printing a time lapse
2:36:10and I looked into Apple's options.
2:36:12You know, Apple's time lapse has this thing
2:36:13dynamically adjust so it's always about the same length when you're done. It just starts
2:36:17dropping frames and kind of reworks it. So, I used a, what's it called, Frame,
2:36:21not Framoleum, it's from our friends at Studio Neat, Framographer, which is, I think, is an old
2:36:30app. They still sell it and it's actually, it was incredible. It's, the interface seems a little
2:36:34outdated, so I think it may be made for an earlier iOS version. And it's great. So, I was able to do
2:36:41I used it with the iPhone 7 Plus to get a better image.
2:36:46And at one point recorded like seven hours, I think,
2:36:50or five hours, and wound up with a few minutes,
2:36:52and it just was fantastic to get a,
2:36:54but I wanted it spaced a certain interval apart
2:36:57as opposed to having it dynamically shrunk to a certain,
2:37:00to fit to a certain total length.
2:37:02- Anyway, I imagine there was some laughter
2:37:07within Cupertino when this Vic and Joe Terpo
2:37:10(laughing)
2:37:11- Passed around.
2:37:12- Oh, it's okay to have some shot in front of it,
2:37:14but I think, I mean, it's great that he came to see
2:37:16what the truth was, right?
2:37:17- Well, between him and now with Steven Stanofsky
2:37:20being probably one of the top three or four
2:37:22iPad proponents in the world.
2:37:25- Oh my God.
2:37:26- Outside Apple, at least.
2:37:28I mean, he's like right behind Federico Vidicci.
2:37:31I mean, that's how staunchly Steven Stanofsky,
2:37:34who, if you don't know the name,
2:37:35was formerly at Microsoft and was sort of the brains
2:37:38behind the whole Surface tablet thing,
2:37:41you know, and left a couple years ago.
2:37:45Now it's a huge, huge iPad proponent.
2:37:47And a good writer on the subject as well.
2:37:51But anyway, that's it for me.
2:37:53We're gonna run out of tape here on the tape machine.
2:37:56- That's right, I know the tape,
2:37:57that's why the tape machine started to slap.
2:37:58- Either that or we'll flip it around and go to side two.
2:38:01(laughing)
2:38:03Anyway, Glenn, I thank you for your time.
2:38:05- It's a pleasure.
2:38:07- I can't wait to get my hands on a copy of this book.
2:38:09Glog.glennf.com is the main headquarters
2:38:13for your sprawling empire of web presences.
2:38:18And then on Twitter, you are Glenn F.
2:38:20G-L-E-N-N-F.
2:38:23He's paid for the extra N.
2:38:25- Come for my fights with Eric Trump.
2:38:28Stay for the tweets about letterpress printing
2:38:29and books from the 1800s.
2:38:31- Personally, I don't know about you personally,
2:38:33almost every single name where there's alternate spellings,
2:38:35I prefer the one with the extra letter.
2:38:38I like G-L, I like my Glens with two Ns,
2:38:40I like my Saras with an H, and I like my Johns with an H.
2:38:43Now maybe I'm biased on the John issue,
2:38:46but I like a Sarah with an H.
2:38:48If you're out there and you're an S-A-R-A,
2:38:53I still think it's a lovely name,
2:38:54but I like the extra letter.
2:38:57And I'll tell you what, I don't like a Glenn
2:38:59with only one N, untrustworthy.
2:39:00- I know, those people, I know they have problems with them.
2:39:03shifty in my opinion, in my experience.
2:39:06I would never buy a car from a Glenn with one end.
2:39:09I'd walk right out of the dealer.
2:39:10(laughs)