Podcast Search

The Talk Show

194: ‘Egg Freckles’ With Serenity Caldwell

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Serenity Caldwell, welcome to the show. Welcome back to the show. Good to see you last week.

0:00:03Good to see you too. It's always fun to see people in person after talking to them on the internet

0:00:09for six months at a time. Totally true. I feel like we have like a thousand things to talk about.

0:00:17Right? Yeah, I mean there are only a few things that happened last week, so you know,

0:00:22it's... was it really last week? I don't understand. It feels like a month ago.

0:00:26- All right, so you were there, I was there,

0:00:29and everybody, you know, it's how you make small talk.

0:00:32You're like, "Hey, what'd you think of the keynote?"

0:00:33And most people were like, "Hey, that was great."

0:00:36And I ran into, I would say 20% of the people I ran into

0:00:41were like, "Eh," I'd give it a B minus.

0:00:43And I'm like, "What the hell are you thinking?"

0:00:46- Yeah. - I don't get that.

0:00:48I don't understand how you could, I don't get it.

0:00:52I'm sorry.

0:00:54- No, no, I'm in complete agreement with you.

0:00:57I mean, we were sitting next to each other at the keynote.

0:00:59- That's true.

0:01:00- And I'm pretty sure on multiple occasions,

0:01:02either I turn to you or you turn to me

0:01:04and it just, it felt overwhelming.

0:01:05It felt like a tidal wave of all of these things

0:01:09just to the point where like I couldn't recover.

0:01:11It took me 48 hours to be in a normal state of mind

0:01:15because I just felt like we were constantly

0:01:16being over-washed with, oh, and we've been working on AR.

0:01:19Oh, and we've been working on VR.

0:01:21Oh, and there's a new iMac Pro.

0:01:23Oh, and of course, new operating systems.

0:01:25Oh, and your iPad.

0:01:27Here's a new iPad.

0:01:28Oh, and ProMotion.

0:01:29None of you are gonna know what that means,

0:01:31but you're gonna like it.

0:01:32It's just, I don't understand how you--

0:01:33- Here's a totally new multitasking interface

0:01:36for iPad Pro users. (laughing)

0:01:38Here are brand new MacBook Pros, a new MacBook.

0:01:43Here's brand new iMacs.

0:01:44Like you said, here's the upcoming iMac Pro.

0:01:47And then, in addition to all these things

0:01:50which are like actual products

0:01:51that you can either buy right now today

0:01:54or you will be able to buy later this year,

0:01:57then they were like, here's our AR kit.

0:01:59[LAUGHTER]

0:02:01I really don't.

0:02:03And I understand that maybe people

0:02:05have a pet feature or thing that maybe didn't get addressed.

0:02:10But to me, I have to admit that that was a pretty good keynote.

0:02:14And even if it didn't get your pet feature or product,

0:02:19It's like, you have to admit they knocked down a lot of pins

0:02:22in the bowling alley on that keynote.

0:02:24- They absolutely did.

0:02:27And I mean, I don't understand how at least one

0:02:31of your pet features did not get answered

0:02:34during that keynote because there were so many little fixes.

0:02:37Like drag and drop is a big,

0:02:38I'm like, how is drag and drop not on everybody's list?

0:02:42At least in some minor form

0:02:44or automatic translation on Siri.

0:02:47That's something I've been wanting it to do for, I don't know, four years.

0:02:51Uh, God, the fact that drag and drop also fixes the home screen issue.

0:02:56So you can move multiple icons at once or yeah, there's just, it, I often

0:03:02stammer when people are like, what was your favorite new feature?

0:03:05What was your, like, I haven't even gotten to make my like little features

0:03:09that I liked that you didn't hear about because quite honestly, there are so many

0:03:13that it, it feels, uh, God.

0:03:16It's just like every time I try and think of them,

0:03:18I think of seven at once,

0:03:20and then my brain just shuts down.

0:03:21- I said this during the live show with Craig and Phil,

0:03:28and I apologize that you're following up

0:03:32on Craig Federighi and Phil Schiller.

0:03:34It's either the best or worst slot of the year

0:03:36on the talk show.

0:03:38But I said this, and I did say this,

0:03:40but I'll say it again,

0:03:41'cause I know you can back me up on this,

0:03:44is that it's just sort of a trope in the press area

0:03:50where when those catch-all slides go up, like, oh,

0:03:54and here's the 29 things that are new in Mac OS

0:03:58that we didn't get to talk about here,

0:04:01the way it goes in the keynote is slowly but surely everybody

0:04:05in the press area sort of raises their phone or their standalone

0:04:07camera and they quick snap a photo of that slide.

0:04:10And they're like, well, I'll take a look

0:04:12at that after the keynote's over and look to see if there's anything really interesting

0:04:17that just sort of snuck into that slide. And over and over and over again in that keynote,

0:04:21they'd put that slide up, the catch-all slide, and by the time people got their cameras up,

0:04:26it was gone. And everybody's like, "Oh my god, did you get a picture of that?" It went

0:04:31so fast. It went so fast. Here's a fun thing. There are something like 75 features on that

0:04:39slide. And they're not like little things. Like, I mean, there are a couple little things, right?

0:04:43Like, flashlight support for iPad Pro is probably a little thing. But they also have like these big,

0:04:49giant features that they just kind of snuck in there, like Type to Siri, which is currently

0:04:54an accessibility feature. But I know quite a few people who have been like, "Man, you know,

0:05:00Siri would be really nice if I could just type to it the same way that I typed to Google Assistant."

0:05:04And guess what, in iOS 11, that's gonna be there.

0:05:07The fact that they completely redid iCloud,

0:05:12not only iCloud family plans,

0:05:14which were a big pain point for a lot of people,

0:05:17but file sharing is now going to be a thing in iOS 11,

0:05:21and file sharing with what it looks like,

0:05:23and again, it's still a beta,

0:05:24so obviously things can change,

0:05:26but based on Apple's documentation,

0:05:27it looks like it's gonna be almost as full-featured

0:05:29as Dropbox, where you can just drop people links,

0:05:33and not just from Apple apps, but for anything,

0:05:36for a photo or a video or a document.

0:05:38And you might even be able to use collaboration

0:05:41if the apps support it.

0:05:42And again, not just Apple apps,

0:05:44but we could be getting to a point

0:05:46where you can collaborate on a Procreate document.

0:05:49And it's not there yet, but the screenshot markup thing,

0:05:52which I guess most people aren't really gonna care about,

0:05:55but you and me and quite a few other people, I think,

0:05:58and pretty much any writer on the face of this earth

0:06:00that writes about technology,

0:06:01marking up screenshots is a pretty big deal.

0:06:05- I, you know what, that's one of my very favorite features

0:06:08that they've added because some of these are like ones

0:06:12that are like, hey, when are we gonna be able to have

0:06:16like Dropbox integration at a system level, right?

0:06:20So that's what the Files app does.

0:06:21And there is a, to, you know,

0:06:25belabor the term finally, right?

0:06:28It's like we have everybody who uses Dropbox

0:06:32or has like a team-based system that uses Dropbox

0:06:35has been sort of hoping for this every single year.

0:06:40And so there's a finally aspect to that.

0:06:42The screenshot thing though to me

0:06:44is one of my favorite features because it's like

0:06:46the way screenshots worked up until iOS 11,

0:06:50it's not like anybody was really complaining about it.

0:06:53It's like okay, you hit these two buttons

0:06:55and you get an image of the screen in your photo roll,

0:06:59and then you can do what you want to with it.

0:07:01But the way that this works is, it's really fantastic.

0:07:06And it's very, very obvious that internally to Apple,

0:07:09they obviously take a lot of screenshots

0:07:11for like bug reports or UI type things.

0:07:16And it's so great.

0:07:18It's super, I don't know.

0:07:22It's like nothing that people were asking for,

0:07:25but it's obviously very, very thoughtful.

0:07:27- It reminds me of, speaking of Craig and Phil,

0:07:30what Craig and Phil were talking about with High Sierra

0:07:32and the focus on, you know, oh, we need to, you know,

0:07:35we need to release something that's not just about snazzy

0:07:38new features, but also that makes

0:07:40the operating system better.

0:07:42And there's a lot of that stuff in iOS 11 too,

0:07:44where they're just these, a lot of little tiny,

0:07:47very smart changes that maybe people weren't clamoring for,

0:07:51but it was always like a back of your mind

0:07:53sort of thing, right?

0:07:55The fact that, here's a good one

0:07:57that I haven't really seen a lot of people pick up on yet,

0:08:00portrait mode is better, which is obviously a good thing.

0:08:04It's been in beta for the last year,

0:08:05and obviously it would get better software-wise

0:08:08as Apple figured it out.

0:08:09But in addition to that,

0:08:11the way that they've made portrait mode better

0:08:13with the Depth Map API is really smart

0:08:17in that not only can third-party apps

0:08:19now take advantage of depth data

0:08:21and use it not just to blur out the backgrounds

0:08:24of their images, but they can use it to color isolate

0:08:27and do other really, really smart and interesting things.

0:08:30But portrait mode now because of that API

0:08:33and because of the new image codec,

0:08:35which by the way is a whole nother cool thing

0:08:37that just kind of popped out of nowhere.

0:08:39With the image codec, portrait mode is no longer,

0:08:42there's no longer the option where you like,

0:08:44you either have to save the portrait mode photo

0:08:46or you have to save the no portrait mode photo.

0:08:49it's just one photo with metadata.

0:08:52And so you can toggle it on or off at will.

0:08:55So you can have the portrait mode photo

0:08:57or you can not have the portrait mode photo.

0:08:58And what that tells me is not only do they have that,

0:09:02but it looks like they might be building an implementation

0:09:05so in the future, you might be able

0:09:07to alter portrait mode photos.

0:09:10What was the, was it the Luma, not the Lumu, Luma,

0:09:15the camera that allowed you to--

0:09:18- Yeah, I know you.

0:09:18- Yeah, yeah, yeah, that camera that has vanished

0:09:21from my brain because it's no longer important.

0:09:23Well, apparently it looks like you might be able to do

0:09:26something like that with portrait mode photos,

0:09:28change what's in focus and change how the things look.

0:09:31And again, that stuff that's not there yet,

0:09:34but all of these sort of baseline features have been built

0:09:38that it really, it gets me really excited

0:09:41for the future of iOS in a way that I have not been excited

0:09:45in quite a long time.

0:09:47It shows me that they're thinking not just, you know,

0:09:50what's the next feature that we have to do in six months,

0:09:53but what is our operating system and our feature set

0:09:56going to look like five years down the road?

0:09:58What are our photos gonna look like

0:09:59five years down the road?

0:10:00It's really exciting.

0:10:02- Yeah, very much so.

0:10:03For anybody who isn't as reckless as we are

0:10:06and already has the iOS 11 beta,

0:10:09but what happens when you take a screenshot on iOS 11

0:10:12is as soon as you take the screenshot,

0:10:15instead of going back to where you are,

0:10:17you get a little floating thing in the lower left corner

0:10:20that is the screenshot.

0:10:22And it's sort of like a temporary doc type thing.

0:10:26And you can tap it and you can immediately annotate it

0:10:31with the arrow tool and the other,

0:10:34what do they call them, markup tools.

0:10:37So you can circle the thing that you wanna point to

0:10:39or if you just want the whole screen

0:10:41and then you can immediately send it to somebody.

0:10:43And then after you send it, you can just be like,

0:10:45now throw it away.

0:10:46So that your photo roll isn't necessarily filled up

0:10:50with all of these screenshots,

0:10:52that all you wanted to do is take the screenshot,

0:10:55send it to the developer of the app,

0:10:58like if you're testing a beta or something like that.

0:11:01And then you don't want it forever.

0:11:04There's no longer like a, I have to go back and remember

0:11:07to delete a bunch of screenshots step.

0:11:10- Yeah, or even-- - But if you want to just

0:11:11save it to your photo roll, you can do that too.

0:11:14- Yeah, what I love about this, again,

0:11:17it's a really smart feature,

0:11:20and I appreciate that they're kind of like,

0:11:22yeah, we recognize that people tend to have

0:11:25legions of screenshots cluttering up their photos library.

0:11:30What I find really awesome as somebody

0:11:33who takes a lot of screenshots is that often I will take

0:11:3720, 30, 40 screenshots in a 10 minute period

0:11:40because I'm marking up a how-to, right?

0:11:42I wanna show the steps, I wanna show how that all works.

0:11:45And usually my workflow is take all of the screenshots,

0:11:50write the article, and then like four hours

0:11:52after I've taken the screenshot,

0:11:54go back and try and remember which screenshot

0:11:56went with which step and pull it open in napkin

0:11:59or another third-party annotation app

0:12:01and put the arrows and the loops that focus.

0:12:06And now, with the markup tools,

0:12:07there's a loop built right in there.

0:12:09So all I have to do when I take the screenshot is tap this and then immediately air drop

0:12:14it to my phone or air drop it to my computer and then I never have to.

0:12:18And then I'm just like, "All right, that's the screenshot I want."

0:12:21And I've already cropped it to the appropriate information so I don't have to worry about

0:12:25that.

0:12:26And then I don't have to save it on my phone because it's immediately on my computer where

0:12:29I can upload it to iMore.

0:12:31Everything's fantastic.

0:12:33And that's pretty awesome.

0:12:34And then the other thing that I really wanted to mention really quickly about screenshots

0:12:39is that you don't have to go through the annotation process if you really just want to take a

0:12:43lot of screenshots, like for whatever reason if you're taking a bunch of things.

0:12:47If you take three or four in succession, it'll pile up on your screen for a limited amount

0:12:53of time, something like two minutes, I think.

0:12:56And then if you don't do anything with them, they'll automatically, it'll go away from

0:13:01your screen and they'll automatically be saved to photos.

0:13:04But you can also, if you don't want it hovering on your screen while you're doing other things,

0:13:08you can immediately swipe left to swipe them off the screen, just like you swipe the slide-over

0:13:13panel away in iOS 11 on the iPad, and they just get autosaved.

0:13:17And it's just like, you can deal with those later.

0:13:19So it's just all these little smart gestures and features for, again, a feature that probably

0:13:25only 10% of the install base is going to use, but it's great.

0:13:29It's such a helpful feature for the 10% to do.

0:13:33Right. It's so much better than having them just be dumb images that are in your photo roll.

0:13:40Yep.

0:13:40It really is. And it's exactly the sort of thing. It, to me, is a very appley feature where it's like,

0:13:48"Hey, we're taking a lot of screenshots. We know that, you know, like you said, probably like 10%

0:13:53it's like the power users, you know, the beta tester type audience. But they take a lot of them and they're obviously not

0:14:00Photos, you know, they're they're very different

0:14:03They're a very different thing than the photos you take when you're out

0:14:07Out and about in your daily life and you're like, oh, here's an interesting thing in my real life

0:14:13I screenshot a totally different thing

0:14:14It should be treated as a different thing and now the system treats it as a different thing and it's it's really really nice

0:14:20Yeah, you know

0:14:21I think this is a this was their compromise from all the people filing radars asking for a screenshots album

0:14:29which by the way we also have now.

0:14:32- Yeah.

0:14:32- So, you know, just a little--

0:14:34- You know what, the gist, the entirety of this podcast

0:14:37is going to be--

0:14:38- Just us talking. - Temptation to it.

0:14:40No, temptation to install iOS 11 on all of your devices,

0:14:43even though I refuse to, I have so far refused to install it

0:14:48on my actual day-to-day carry iPhone.

0:14:50- Really?

0:14:52- It's tempting, it's very tempting.

0:14:54Never install beta one on your phone.

0:14:58- No. - That's my role.

0:14:59- Unless you're me, but really don't.

0:15:01(laughing)

0:15:02Yeah, I only did it

0:15:04because I did not bring a second iPhone with me

0:15:06because I was a stupid person.

0:15:08Yeah, I came straight from a roller derby tournament.

0:15:11So I had limited packing space and I'm like,

0:15:14"Do I really want like $10,000 worth of electronics

0:15:18sitting in our locker room?"

0:15:19You know, there's like, ugh.

0:15:21- So I use an app called Itta, I-T-A,

0:15:27and it's like a little to-do list app.

0:15:31And the only thing I really use the app for

0:15:33is I have a list called Packing List

0:15:36for when I go on a trip.

0:15:37And it's everything I wanna take every time I travel.

0:15:41And then once I leave the house,

0:15:43I can reset the list and say, uncheck all the items.

0:15:46And then the next time I open the list,

0:15:47they're all unchecked.

0:15:49And some of the items are only applicable on certain trips.

0:15:53Like it'll say, like, do you have your passport?

0:15:55Well, obviously, if I'm going to California,

0:15:58I don't need my passport.

0:15:59So it doesn't matter.

0:16:01But if I am going overseas, you know, wanna have it.

0:16:04- Probably important. - So I have an item

0:16:05on that list which is extra iPhone for iOS beta,

0:16:09which is really only for WWDC.

0:16:12- Yep, yep. (laughs)

0:16:14It's the break glass in case of iPhone OS.

0:16:18- Right, but if you just take an extra old iPhone,

0:16:21it doesn't really weigh you down.

0:16:22- No. - It's not like you're weighed

0:16:23with pounds and pounds of extra material.

0:16:27- No, exactly.

0:16:28And with the iPad, it was, you know,

0:16:30I'm not gonna bring two iPads, but eh, it's fine.

0:16:34That's why I have a MacBook Pro now,

0:16:36so I don't have to worry about my iPad

0:16:38being completely bricked.

0:16:39- So, all right, let me take a break.

0:16:43I'll take a break and thank our first sponsor,

0:16:44and I'll ask you whether or not you have a new iPad yet.

0:16:48That'll be my topic when I get back.

0:16:49But first I wanna tell you

0:16:50about our good friends at Fracture.

0:16:52Fracture is the photo decor company.

0:16:54You send Fracture your photos.

0:16:56You take 'em with your iPhone or your iPad

0:16:58or whatever camera you want, send 'em to Fracture.

0:17:01They print them directly on glass.

0:17:05I don't know how they do it,

0:17:06but it's not like a piece of paper glued to glass.

0:17:08Somehow they print photos directly on glass,

0:17:11and then they mail it to you,

0:17:13and the thing that they mailed to you

0:17:15is ready to hang on a wall or prop on your desk,

0:17:18whatever you want.

0:17:19It's very clever packaging and backing

0:17:22where it's all ready to go.

0:17:25One of my favorite things about this,

0:17:26and these guys have been sponsoring the show

0:17:29for a long time,

0:17:30but recently people have started,

0:17:31when they get their fractures,

0:17:33they start tweeting me.

0:17:34They're like @GruberMe on Twitter

0:17:36with a picture of their fracture.

0:17:38And they're some of the most amazing pictures

0:17:40I've ever seen.

0:17:42There was somebody, I forget who it was,

0:17:43somebody who, obviously, whoever you are,

0:17:45I love you, thank you for listening to the show,

0:17:47but somebody was at Yosemite National Park

0:17:50and took an amazing picture,

0:17:52got it printed on a huge fracture,

0:17:55like the big 27-inch type thing,

0:17:58and they took a picture of it on their wall,

0:18:00and it's beautiful.

0:18:01And I'm like, "Did you take that with your iPhone?"

0:18:02And they were like, "Yeah."

0:18:03And I'm like, "A, that is amazing

0:18:06"that you took that picture with a phone,

0:18:08"and it looks so good.

0:18:09"And B, wow, the fracture print looks amazing."

0:18:13It's such a great thing to do with your photos.

0:18:18I'm telling you right now, digital photography has,

0:18:23nobody wants to go back to film.

0:18:26It is so much better because everybody takes

0:18:28so many more pictures, and more pictures

0:18:30are better than fewer pictures.

0:18:32But the one thing we've lost is that having all

0:18:36of your pictures just on a little four inch phone

0:18:40is nowhere near as cool as having your best photos

0:18:43printed really big and hang them on a wall

0:18:45for everybody to see.

0:18:47So take your best pictures, get them printed on a fracture.

0:18:49You will not regret it.

0:18:51Here's where you go to find out more.

0:18:52Go to their website.

0:18:53It's fractureme.com.

0:18:56Fractureme.com/podcast.

0:19:00And then at the end of the whole process,

0:19:02when you order your prints,

0:19:04they will ask you where you heard of them,

0:19:05and then it's a one-question survey.

0:19:07Just tell them you heard about it on the talk show,

0:19:09and they'll know you came from the show.

0:19:12But anyway, you will never regret getting

0:19:15as many pictures as you like printed at Fracture.

0:19:17It's such a great service.

0:19:19So my thanks to them.

0:19:20All right, iPad Pro, do you have one yet?

0:19:24- Yes, I do.

0:19:25Yes, I do.

0:19:26- What size?

0:19:28- The 10.5.

0:19:29I'm holding it in my hands right now, actually.

0:19:31- What color?

0:19:32- Space gray this time.

0:19:34- I love the space gray.

0:19:36You know what?

0:19:37I would have ordered two.

0:19:38We're actually traveling soon.

0:19:39We've got like a family wedding

0:19:41and we've got a vacation coming up.

0:19:42And it's like by the time we got back from WWDC,

0:19:45the goddamn things were back ordered.

0:19:47(laughs)

0:19:47- No!

0:19:48- No, they really are.

0:19:49Their delivery date was actually like,

0:19:52we're not even gonna be home.

0:19:54So it's like, ah shit, what are we gonna do?

0:19:56But I think it's not surprising to me

0:20:00that they're back ordered already

0:20:02because these are terrific.

0:20:04So I do have a review unit from Apple.

0:20:06So it's not like I'm iPad Pro-less.

0:20:08- You're not bereft, yeah.

0:20:10- Right.

0:20:11I cannot believe how good a device this is.

0:20:15And I say this as somebody who is the,

0:20:20if you said to me, hey, iPhone, iPad, Mac,

0:20:25we're gonna take one of them away from you forever,

0:20:28which one do you want, you'll never use again,

0:20:30I would immediately say iPad.

0:20:31Like just take away, leave me my phone

0:20:34and leave me my Mac and I'll be fine.

0:20:37Like I'm not an iPad person.

0:20:39But that said, I think this might be the greatest device

0:20:43Apple's ever made.

0:20:45- Yeah.

0:20:46- You know what I mean?

0:20:46Like I'm not the biggest fan of the iPad as a platform,

0:20:50but in terms of Apple doing Apple-y things,

0:20:53that the new iPad Pro is absolutely positively amazing.

0:20:58- I 100% agree.

0:21:00- So I'm fascinated though to hear your perspective

0:21:04as an avid illustrator.

0:21:07And with the pencil already, in my opinion,

0:21:10being the best stylus in the consumer space

0:21:14that you could buy, the difference on the new iPad Pro

0:21:19with this ProMotion 120 hertz refresh rate,

0:21:23it's astounding.

0:21:25It almost feels like with the first iPad Pro

0:21:30and when the pencil first came out,

0:21:33it was like, wow, this is the best stylus I've ever used.

0:21:36with the new iPad Pro and the exact same pencil,

0:21:39there is this moment of like,

0:21:41wait, am I actually screwing up

0:21:43and marking the screen with a real marker?

0:21:46(Brianna laughs)

0:21:47- Yeah, yeah.

0:21:49- There really was this,

0:21:52and it's funny because I take better care

0:21:54of a review unit from Apple than I do my own hardware.

0:21:57You know what I mean?

0:21:58If I own it and I screw it up,

0:22:00it's like, well, that's my own thing.

0:22:01Whereas I wanna make sure

0:22:03that when I mail these review units back to Apple,

0:22:05pristine. And I don't even know why because I don't even think they would care. You know

0:22:09what I mean? Like, what are they doing with the return? I really do feel though that with

0:22:14the new pencil, it's like if you just took a Sharpie and started like writing on the

0:22:19screen, it would look exactly the same and have the same response rate. It is...

0:22:26It's wacky. It's wacky. The way I was debating drawing a comic for ProMotion the same way

0:22:34that I did for the pencil review.

0:22:37And I decided against it in part because of time.

0:22:39But one of the first panels I was doing is I'm like,

0:22:43"All right, everybody take into their minds,

0:22:45remember the first time that you as a person

0:22:48got to use like a really nice pen,

0:22:51as opposed to like the cruddy Bic pens,

0:22:54where you have to press down to get the ink to,

0:22:56and sometimes the ink doesn't work,

0:22:57and then you get ahold of like a space pen

0:22:59or a really high-end ink pen.

0:23:02And when you put the pen to paper, the ink flows out so fast that it startles you a bit at first.

0:23:08Like you mess up and your letters aren't quite as well formed or you blot

0:23:14because you're just not used to that kind of performance.

0:23:17You're not used to that like, "Oh, all this ink is now right here."

0:23:21That's how drawing with promotion feels to me.

0:23:25where it's like suddenly the ink is almost there faster than I have the capacity, the brain power,

0:23:34or the training to draw with it. And you adjust with it, but it's a very, very unnerving

0:23:41experience at first because you've, you know, especially, I mean, I felt a little bit that way

0:23:46when I got the original pencil, but I'd been using Wacoms for years, right, where you kind of know

0:23:52what good drawing on screens feels like versus like bad iPad drawing on screens.

0:23:58And this just doesn't, you're right, it doesn't feel, it doesn't mentally feel like drawing

0:24:03on a screen.

0:24:04Obviously it's still a screen and they haven't figured out the magical wizardry yet to make

0:24:08the tip feel like it's drawing on paper.

0:24:10Although I am convinced that there's some kind of slight magic, you know, voodoo going

0:24:15on because I do think the screen's a little bit tackier than the previous version of iPad

0:24:19Pro.

0:24:20Maybe, yeah, there is something.

0:24:22Apple says no.

0:24:23Right.

0:24:24But I swear, it does feel a little bit, I don't know, maybe it's just promotion tricking my brain.

0:24:29Right.

0:24:29It definitely, it feels like there's a slight tackier thing, but regardless of that, it's a

0:24:36much, much better drawing experience than at this point anything. And I haven't tried the

0:24:41new Surface Pro yet, which I know has 21 milliseconds of latency as opposed to the

0:24:46Apple Pencils 20. I'm gonna try and try that out next next week. But I'm I don't know, I think this

0:24:52might best any digital drawing tool I've used, including a Cintiq.

0:24:56I think I don't get is I don't get the people who want the pencil to be able to navigate the UI. And

0:25:05it does still work. Like if you use the pencil in your mail, you can like tap the upper left corner

0:25:11to go back to your list of mailboxes.

0:25:13I don't think that should do anything.

0:25:15I think that touch should be touch,

0:25:17and the pencil should just be for drawing.

0:25:20And if you tap the pencil to the screen in a context

0:25:24where drawing doesn't make any sense,

0:25:25it shouldn't do anything.

0:25:27Because I feel like what they should do

0:25:29is just keep adding more contexts,

0:25:31where if you tap the pencil to the screen,

0:25:33you're immediately marking up the thing

0:25:35that you're looking at.

0:25:36I just want to draw on the screen with the pencil.

0:25:38I don't understand why people insisted on having it

0:25:42so you can tap buttons and stuff with the pencil.

0:25:44I don't get it.

0:25:46- So I'm of two minds here because on one hand, yeah,

0:25:49especially when you look at the iOS 11's

0:25:52new Instant Markup feature,

0:25:54where as soon as you go into screenshot mode,

0:25:57you can draw with it,

0:25:58or if you tap the pencil to the home screen,

0:26:01it'll automatically launch you in a notes drawing,

0:26:03which is pretty cool.

0:26:05But at the same point, I know people with RSI who have like,

0:26:10yeah, who are 100% like the pencil is the best tool

0:26:15I've used for combating my RSI.

0:26:17And it's really nice to be able to use with a pen.

0:26:21- So allow me to revise my remarks

0:26:23and it should be available as an option,

0:26:25but it should be something you have to turn on

0:26:27as like an accessibility type thing.

0:26:30- I'm okay with that, yeah.

0:26:32- I just don't think by default, it should work as a touch.

0:26:34I really don't.

0:26:35And if you want it to, sure, go into settings

0:26:39and have an option so that you can do it.

0:26:41And if it helps with your RSI,

0:26:44I've had my own RSI issues,

0:26:45so anything that lets you get through that is,

0:26:49God bless, but I don't think it should be on by default.

0:26:53- Yeah, my other argument for it,

0:26:56and again, I think I would be fine

0:26:57with an accessibility settings,

0:26:58is as somebody who draws a lot,

0:27:01Drawing just like anything else is an experience where you're multitasking.

0:27:06You might be drawing on a canvas, but you might want to bring in some photos for reference or

0:27:11something like that. And I really do enjoy, in that instance, working with the pencil.

0:27:16For instance, in Procreate, you can drop colors from a palette into your drawing, or

0:27:24now you can use drag and drop to drag your photo into the drawing. And if I already have the

0:27:31the pencil in my hand, sometimes it's a pain to like, go from the pencil to flipping to touch to

0:27:36going back to the pencil. So like, I get I get the reasoning behind it. But I'm also okay with a with

0:27:43a switch. I could I could deal with that. As long as it's there somewhere.

0:27:47I'll tell you what the most telling thing to me was a couple of days ago, I think it was like two

0:27:50days ago, I went on a mini Twitter rant about the on screen, like, get the app button on that medium

0:28:00shows up on like, when everybody, when you post like a blog post to Medium now, there's

0:28:05like this stupid toolbar at the bottom that I hate. But now they put a button above the

0:28:10toolbar that's like, "Open this in the Medium app." And I don't want to open it in the fucking

0:28:15Medium app. I want to read it in a web browser where it's already open right now. The article

0:28:20is right here. I'm reading it. So why are you telling me to open it in the app? And

0:28:24I know, I know, it's all about engagement. Fuck you, Engagement. I hate engagement. But

0:28:29But I went on this Twitter rant.

0:28:30But I was on my phone, and I was so angry about this.

0:28:34But I wanted to take a screenshot, and it was pure rage that made me want to tweet this.

0:28:43So I wasn't even thinking logically.

0:28:45But the easiest way to do it, in my mind-- I was on my phone at the time-- the easiest

0:28:50way to do it was switch to the iPad Pro.

0:28:54Open the same thing in the iPad Pro from AirPlay.

0:28:58it to the Air, which was great and is one of those features that I feel like people

0:29:04are sort of taking for granted at this point, but is kind of awesome if you have more than

0:29:09one Apple device, where it's like you're looking at a website on your phone and you want to

0:29:12look at it on this other device.

0:29:13I want to get it on this iPad Pro and I want to take a screenshot and immediately just

0:29:18circle this and make a big angry red arrow with a pencil.

0:29:22It was so easy.

0:29:24The easiest way to do it was to switch to the iPad Pro,

0:29:29open it there, take a screenshot,

0:29:31and it's right there, ready to be marked up.

0:29:34And I just tap it, and I can immediately make my angry arrows

0:29:38and say, fuck you, Medium, I hate this.

0:29:41What is going on?

0:29:43And then I'm one sharing sheet away from posting it

0:29:46to Twitter and embarrassing myself.

0:29:48But I-- and then I thought afterwards, I was like,

0:29:50you know what?

0:29:51That is a real selling point for the iPad Pro and the Pencil,

0:29:54which is that it actually felt like easier to switch devices

0:29:59to this thing with the pencil than to do it

0:30:01on the phone itself or any other way.

0:30:05Yep.

0:30:06And now you have ventured into the mindset

0:30:09of the people who are like, I want

0:30:10a pencil for the iPhone Plus.

0:30:15Again, I'm not against.

0:30:16I could see it.

0:30:16Yeah.

0:30:18Obviously, if it didn't make it any thicker or heavier,

0:30:22If the pencil happened to work on the iPhone,

0:30:25it wouldn't be worse.

0:30:27I can kind of see it.

0:30:29- Oh yeah, no, I can absolutely see it.

0:30:32And God knows, I've picked up my pencil

0:30:34before trying to draw on the iPhone

0:30:35and gotten cranky when it didn't.

0:30:39I understand why it hasn't happened yet,

0:30:42but I could also see it happening.

0:30:44Anyway, I agree with you.

0:30:45I 100% agree with you. - I used to be a big pencil.

0:30:47I mean, this'll shock you.

0:30:48I used to really, when I was in high school and junior high,

0:30:51I really cared about which brand of pencil I had.

0:30:54No.

0:30:55Shocking.

0:30:56You?

0:30:58I was a big fan of the Dixon Ticonderoga number two,

0:31:01which is not--

0:31:03I don't know if you know anything about pencils,

0:31:04but Dixon Ticonderogas used to be made in the United States.

0:31:08And now they're not, and they're nowhere near as good

0:31:10as they used to be.

0:31:11They're sort of like some kind of cheap Chinese lumber

0:31:14or something.

0:31:14But the old school ones from when

0:31:17I was in high school in the '80s and '90s were aces.

0:31:21Like this was a pencil that you could like,

0:31:22if you whack somebody in the head with it,

0:31:24it would leave a mark.

0:31:25It was a real pencil, pencil.

0:31:28But I used to think when I was in high school

0:31:32and I used pencils a lot,

0:31:33I liked a pencil when it was about 2/3 of the way done.

0:31:38Like it was a better size to me

0:31:40when you got the pencil,

0:31:43somewhere around 2/3 to 1/2 of the out of the box size.

0:31:50And I can't help but think that if they ever

0:31:54added pencil support for the phone,

0:31:56I'd kind of want the pencil to be smaller.

0:31:59Yeah, I don't think that it needs

0:32:01to be the size of an HB pencil, which

0:32:03is the size of the current Apple pencil.

0:32:07But it doesn't also need to be the size

0:32:09of a teeny tiny stylus.

0:32:11I think the right feeling to me--

0:32:14I'm holding a Relay FM a few years ago,

0:32:16got all of its hosts this beautiful space pen.

0:32:20And it's a pen that's designed to write in both directions,

0:32:23and it's probably, I don't know, holding it in front of myself

0:32:26like, I don't know, four inches, five inches long?

0:32:29It's just enough to fit comfortably in a hand.

0:32:34And I feel like that's the right length.

0:32:36And then you could put it in your butt pocket and your jeans,

0:32:42you know what I mean, and it wouldn't stick up.

0:32:44Exactly.

0:32:46I don't know.

0:32:48I don't know.

0:32:49I'm sold on the pencil.

0:32:50I really do like it, and I'm not even an illustrator,

0:32:53but I can kind of see it happening

0:32:56for the phone at some point.

0:32:57- Oh yeah, no question.

0:33:00As I said, it's an inevitability.

0:33:03It just depends.

0:33:04They need to figure out the right way to sell it.

0:33:07Because the last thing you need is Apple getting the,

0:33:12you know, the headline,

0:33:14"Oh, Apple's trying to compete with the Note,

0:33:16"the phone that exploded."

0:33:18And then we just run into issues.

0:33:21- You know what, there's so many things to talk about,

0:33:24but it's like they totally glossed over this.

0:33:27But the notes app in iOS 11 now has,

0:33:32it's a new, it's a little confusing

0:33:37because they kept, and I think they did exactly right.

0:33:40And obviously I'm the co-designer of an iOS notes app

0:33:45that was abandoned, Vesper.

0:33:47So I have very strong opinions on the design of a notes app.

0:33:50I really, really love the way that iOS 11 note app has

0:33:55evolved, in particular, this new data type of on the fly pencil

0:34:02illustration in the note.

0:34:07Now, prior to iOS 11, what you could do is you could say,

0:34:11add a picture to my note.

0:34:14And you have to hit the plus button,

0:34:15And then you'd get a full screen, what would you call it,

0:34:20canvas, where you could draw.

0:34:22And you could draw whatever you wanted to.

0:34:24There were a couple of tools.

0:34:26You could have a marker or a pencil or a watercolor brush

0:34:31or whatever you want.

0:34:32Just wasn't good.

0:34:34It was a good demo of the pencil support

0:34:37in terms of the latency and seeing how you draw.

0:34:42But the actual interface with Notes

0:34:44wasn't that great because it was so modal.

0:34:47It was like, yeah, had to go in this one.

0:34:48You had to go in there or out of there,

0:34:50and it just wasn't great.

0:34:51Right.

0:34:52Whereas now in iOS 11, you're in Notes.

0:34:55You just make a note, or you're in a note already,

0:34:57and you're typing.

0:34:58And whatever you're typing, it's just like a regular note.

0:35:01And then you just take your pencil and start drawing.

0:35:05You don't have to add to hit a button or go into a mode.

0:35:08You just start writing on the screen.

0:35:12and it makes a little thing,

0:35:15and then if you want to adjust the size,

0:35:18it's all you can do is make it taller,

0:35:20which is perfect, 'cause the thing that I think

0:35:22is so genius is that it has,

0:35:24the width is always the full width of the screen.

0:35:27It's always just adjusting the height.

0:35:29And so it doesn't try to flow around it

0:35:32like a half-width image in a word processing program

0:35:37where the text is supposed to flow around the side.

0:35:40No, it's just full size in the note, full width, I should say, in the note.

0:35:46And you just make it taller or shorter if you want, and you just draw.

0:35:49But the thing that is amazing to me is that it indexes, if it's handwritten words, it

0:35:56indexes those words and it works.

0:36:00Really well.

0:36:01No egg freckles.

0:36:02My handwriting is atrocious.

0:36:05I mean, seriously atrocious.

0:36:07I don't know that there's anybody on the planet who can read it other than me.

0:36:10I can read it.

0:36:11I don't know if anybody else can.

0:36:14And I wrote some stuff, and I wasn't trying to—I was writing in my—just not trying

0:36:20to be particularly neat, just writing the way I write.

0:36:22And then I searched for it, and it all—every single word that I wrote came up.

0:36:26It was amazing.

0:36:27Well, and on top of that, the fact that it's so quick, it's almost instantaneous OCR,

0:36:34character recognition for people. But it's really impressive. And the fact that it's

0:36:41searchable not just notes-wide, but system-wide. So if you write something down from six months

0:36:45ago, you can theoretically find it.

0:36:47In Spotlight.

0:36:48Yeah, in Spotlight.

0:36:50Yeah. What's the egg freckles joke again? I know it comes from Doonesbury.

0:36:54It's a Doonesbury-Newton joke, way back.

0:36:59What was it that the person originally wrote, though?

0:37:01- What, what?

0:37:02- Oh God.

0:37:03- It's like everybody just remembers the egg freckles

0:37:04and nobody remembers what they actually wrote.

0:37:06- Yeah, 'cause egg freckles is just so weird.

0:37:09- And then the other one that everybody remembers

0:37:10is the Simpsons joke, which was,

0:37:13the bully wanted to write beat up Nelson,

0:37:20or no, not Nelson, what's the kid's name, whatever it is,

0:37:23but instead of beat up whatever the kid's name was,

0:37:25it said, eat up Martha.

0:37:28(laughing)

0:37:29Right?

0:37:30- Yeah.

0:37:32Oh, it was Catching On was the original thing

0:37:36that quote unquote egg freckles turned into.

0:37:38- Right.

0:37:39- Oh boy.

0:37:41Yeah, no, it's quite impressive,

0:37:44especially considering that OCR,

0:37:47I reviewed a couple of OCR apps,

0:37:50handwriting OCR apps last year,

0:37:53and there's really only one that doesn't suck.

0:37:57And like three of them are made by the same company.

0:38:01So I don't know why it's only the one that works.

0:38:03But I've been kind of clamoring for Apple

0:38:06to integrate that for ages.

0:38:09So I'm really happy to see that.

0:38:10The other big thing in Notes,

0:38:12which again, it's one of these things

0:38:14that kind of slid under the radar

0:38:15because there was just so much,

0:38:17was the fact that screenshot,

0:38:19or screenshot that scanning is built in.

0:38:22OCR scanning is built into the iPad.

0:38:26And it's easy because it uses AR.

0:38:29It uses ARKit.

0:38:30Right, so it's funny.

0:38:34I've been talking about it on and off on a podcast.

0:38:36But we just bought a new house a couple months ago.

0:38:39And most of the paperwork-- and everybody always

0:38:42says when you buy a house, there's

0:38:44thousands of sheets of paperwork.

0:38:45And they're not kidding.

0:38:47There really is.

0:38:48But most of it we did online.

0:38:50And it was e-documents.

0:38:52And Amy and I were like, oh my god,

0:38:54can you even imagine what this was like before e-documents?

0:38:56Because you're like, just click to sign, click to sign,

0:38:59click to sign, click to sign.

0:39:01Okay, you're good with this, send it,

0:39:02and you click a button that says,

0:39:05I authorized it by clicking this button.

0:39:07It counts as my signature,

0:39:09and it's going to the mortgage company

0:39:11or whatever the hell, wherever the hell these things go.

0:39:14And in the old days, you had to physically sign it

0:39:17and send a courier or fax it or something.

0:39:20But there's still, even today,

0:39:22there still were a number of documents that had to be physically signed and do it.

0:39:27I mean, I don't have a fucking fax machine.

0:39:30I mean, who the hell has a fax machine anymore?

0:39:32Cool. Yeah, exactly.

0:39:33So what I would do is I would put my phone over this piece of paper on a table and

0:39:40try to get the light right and make sure that the phone isn't casting a shadow over

0:39:44the thing but have it perfectly square over the thing.

0:39:48So I didn't want it to look like I took a picture of a photo.

0:39:51I wanted it to look like I scanned the document.

0:39:54I wanted it to look good.

0:39:56I'm sure that if I just took it off center

0:40:01and it didn't matter, it would still count.

0:40:03But I wanted it to look good.

0:40:04But now the built-in feature does the right thing

0:40:08automatically from any angle.

0:40:10It's crazy.

0:40:12Absolutely crazy. - While we're talking,

0:40:14while we were talking, I literally just picked up my iPad

0:40:18and open the screenshot thing,

0:40:20and sitting from the desk,

0:40:22just snapped a picture of an invitation for our wedding,

0:40:26sitting over on the side of the desk,

0:40:28propped up at an angle, so I'm not even at,

0:40:31like, I'm at a 2/3 view here.

0:40:35It was able to instantly get it within like,

0:40:38I don't know, half a second.

0:40:40It's ridiculous.

0:40:43I'm like, I don't understand.

0:40:46The ARKit team, really, they have to be given

0:40:51a huge round of applause.

0:40:53And the really sad thing is no one's going to appreciate

0:40:57the genius of what ARKit has put together

0:41:01and the startup that Apple bought from which it's based.

0:41:06No one's going to appreciate it for another year or two

0:41:08until we actually see the stuff paying off.

0:41:12But screenshots is a really good early example of it.

0:41:16- A real world one.

0:41:17- The scanned documents are amazing.

0:41:19- They are.

0:41:20- It really looks as good as a photocopy.

0:41:23Like from a terrific photocopy,

0:41:25you know, like a high-end photocopier.

0:41:27It's like as good or better.

0:41:29And you don't have to aim it at all.

0:41:32In fact, it looks better if you don't put the camera over it

0:41:35because you're less likely to get a shadow

0:41:38over the document.

0:41:38- Yeah.

0:41:39- Absolutely crazy.

0:41:41Like of all the things, you know,

0:41:44that the narrative of that these devices are replacing

0:41:48all of consumer electronics,

0:41:50like they've replaced standalone cameras,

0:41:54they've replaced tape recorders, you name it.

0:41:59But the fact that they've replaced fax machines now

0:42:01is kind of amazing.

0:42:03- Well, think about how big and bulky

0:42:06those things used to be, right?

0:42:08Where it's just, I mean, you had to have what,

0:42:09a built-in modem and a scanner in one,

0:42:12and now that's all, that's, yeah.

0:42:14and a tiny little piece of technology.

0:42:16Yeah, it's crazy, it really is.

0:42:21(Dave laughs)

0:42:24My words are failing me,

0:42:25because I'm still staring at the screenshot.

0:42:28- So have you installed iOS 11 on your iPad yet?

0:42:33- I have.

0:42:34I did that almost immediately after getting it.

0:42:37'Cause I'm a stupid, stupid human being.

0:42:39- No, I was so torn.

0:42:41I wrote it in my review.

0:42:42I was very honest.

0:42:43I never lie on Daring Fireball.

0:42:46I never lie, period, to tell you the truth.

0:42:48- Honest, honest, John?

0:42:50- Just like our president.

0:42:51(laughing)

0:42:52- Oh.

0:42:53- Well, but saying that I never lie,

0:42:55it sounds like, wow, that's something

0:42:56that people who lie a lot say.

0:42:58(laughing)

0:43:00I actually don't.

0:43:00It's like, in my adult life,

0:43:03I've actually, a great way to live your life

0:43:05is just never lie, and it's kind of liberating.

0:43:09You just never say anything that's not true.

0:43:11We'll get back to that when we talk about Tony Fidell and Phil Schiller at the end of

0:43:16the show.

0:43:18I got the review unit and they give you a little thing you have to sign.

0:43:25Monday is the embargo.

0:43:27And technically you're not supposed to do something like install a developer beta on

0:43:33a review unit.

0:43:34And you're certainly not supposed to review the thing.

0:43:38They don't tell you that.

0:43:39They don't say like, whatever you do,

0:43:40don't install iOS 11 on this.

0:43:43But it's kind of understood.

0:43:45And I also feel like there's a certain fairness.

0:43:49If you go to the Apple Store today

0:43:55and buy the new iPad Pro,

0:43:57you get it and it's running iOS 10.3.

0:44:00And therefore, that is what I,

0:44:02as somebody reviewing the product,

0:44:04should be telling you about.

0:44:08But that said, after seeing iOS 11 last week,

0:44:13it was killing me.

0:44:15Amy and I were flying back east from San Francisco

0:44:20last Friday, and my device for the plane,

0:44:25for the transcontinental flight,

0:44:27was the review unit iPad Pro.

0:44:30And I kept swiping up from the,

0:44:32I was already in the habit,

0:44:34just from being in the hands-on area,

0:44:36I was already trying to use,

0:44:38I'm like, oh my God, this is insane.

0:44:41I cannot, I have to install iOS 11 on this.

0:44:46I've already used this.

0:44:47I haven't owned a device with this operating system yet,

0:44:50and I already have the habit of trying to use it

0:44:52to get iMessages up.

0:44:55So yeah, and once I did, it was like, oh my God.

0:45:00And I wrote my, it's one of my favorite lines

0:45:02I've written in a long time,

0:45:03it. I just feel like one of my hands has been untied from behind my back. I feel like for the

0:45:10last couple of years, every time I've used an iPad in any context, whether I'm reviewing a new one

0:45:16or just using my own personal iPad, I have felt like I've had a hand tied behind my back. This

0:45:23device can obviously do more than I'm doing with it in terms of, "Hey, I'm watching a baseball game,

0:45:30but I'm getting text messages from my friend,

0:45:33why isn't it easier to do both of these?

0:45:36Keep the video up and have iMessages on screen for a moment.

0:45:41Show me my tweets too. Why can't I look at all three?

0:45:45It has felt like I've been hamstrung and all of a sudden,

0:45:50once I have the Beta on it,

0:45:52I've never felt like that before.

0:45:54Like we're putting the iOS 11 Beta as buggy as it is,

0:46:00and it is as buggy as the first developer beta should be.

0:46:05- Should be.

0:46:06- Right, it still feels like I'm 10 times more productive.

0:46:09- Yeah, I completely agree, and it's why that I,

0:46:13normally I do not install developer betas

0:46:17on brand new hardware, because you have that little bit

0:46:21where the brand new hardware is so fast and so delightful

0:46:24'cause you haven't put all your crud on it yet.

0:46:27But no, I immediately went to it

0:46:29because I spent the entire week last week switching between our review unit of the 10.5

0:46:34and my 9.7, which of course had iOS 11 on it the second that I was able to install it,

0:46:40and just switching between the two of those.

0:46:43Again, like you said, I kept on going to the 10.5 and trying to do things that I had gotten

0:46:48instantly comfortable with on the 9.7 and being unable to and being very disappointed

0:46:55by it.

0:46:56And on top of that, I really wanted to see just like the multitasking features work pretty

0:47:02well on the 9.7.

0:47:04Again, even as a developer beta, they work with decent speed, but I really wanted to

0:47:10see the way that the animations looked and everything else with the promotion technology,

0:47:15because we haven't even really talked about that.

0:47:21I also feel that--

0:47:24and I kind of knew that it wasn't coming,

0:47:27or at least I really didn't think it was coming.

0:47:29But like a week before WWDC, I wrote, hey,

0:47:32why not put a trackpad on a smart keyboard cover?

0:47:35And I kind of--

0:47:36I didn't write it--

0:47:37and again, if anybody thought I was writing it

0:47:39because I wink, wink, nudge, nudge, knew that it was coming,

0:47:42it was the opposite.

0:47:43I kind of knew that it wasn't coming,

0:47:45but I still kind of wish that it had a trackpad for text editing.

0:47:50But I will say this, that along the lines of that, where the logic of it is, hey, if

0:47:55you have the iPad on the smart keyboard cover and your hands are in that, you know, on the

0:48:00home rows key, your hands are already in this position.

0:48:04Reaching up and touching the screen is sort of breaking that thing.

0:48:08But doing the thing where you just go to the bottom of the screen and swipe up to get the

0:48:14multitasking doc, your fingers are right there already.

0:48:19It is super convenient.

0:48:21And so in terms of that whole argument of, hey, if you're in laptop mode, poking at the

0:48:28screen is sort of ergonomically problematic, the dock in iPad iOS is actually like the

0:48:38least problematic motion you can make because your finger, it's like the quickest thing

0:48:44you could possibly do on the screen when you're on the keyboard.

0:48:47- Yeah, well, and the beauty of it,

0:48:50again, speaking of teams to give hats off to,

0:48:55the Springboard team and the multitasking team

0:48:58really did a number and a way of figuring out a way

0:49:03to integrate all of this while still making all of it

0:49:08feel like a natural progression from what has come before.

0:49:13We've already gotten comfortable with the idea

0:49:15of swiping up for control center, right?

0:49:17So it's just, now it's just the difference

0:49:19between a little swipe enters the dock,

0:49:21and then if you continue swiping,

0:49:22this is the beautiful thing, right?

0:49:24If you continue that swiping, you get the new app switcher,

0:49:27which is basically control center on steroids,

0:49:30which, you know, with custom control center

0:49:33is something that I know a lot of people

0:49:34have been asking for for a while,

0:49:35and it really comes into its own here.

0:49:38But it just, it feels so natural to be like,

0:49:42yeah, I'm typing, oh, I wanna pull up an app.

0:49:45All I have to do is, as you said, move like half an inch,

0:49:49tap and hold the app, wait until it starts,

0:49:51it pulls forward the same way that like tvOS

0:49:54has the parallax shimmer to it.

0:49:59And then you literally just have to like toss it

0:50:01right up on the left or the right side of the screen.

0:50:03You don't even have to like move it all the way

0:50:05to the top of the screen and then position it.

0:50:08Like it becomes a very quick flick and switch

0:50:12more quickly than you'd anticipate.

0:50:14- Right, you just kind of vaguely gesture

0:50:20in the direction you want it to go,

0:50:21and it just goes there.

0:50:23And it just obeys your commands.

0:50:26- Yeah, yeah, which is awesome.

0:50:28- I think it's a really, really clever design.

0:50:31I really like it.

0:50:32And it's funny to me how visually

0:50:36it pays homage to the macOS dock.

0:50:41But to me, interaction-wise, it's very different,

0:50:45because the macOS doc doesn't really--

0:50:49you either have it on screen all the time or you don't,

0:50:51but it doesn't--

0:50:53it's not like--

0:50:54I don't know.

0:50:54It's not reactive in the same way.

0:50:57Yeah.

0:50:58And the way that you drag apps out of it is--

0:51:02and you were saying that we didn't talk about promotion

0:51:05yet, but it's uncanny the way that you just

0:51:11tap the icon for messages and quick flick it out

0:51:14in the way that the icon turns into the window

0:51:18that you're going to have on the side

0:51:19at 100% fidelity as you flick your finger.

0:51:26- Ah, it feels, so you remember the initial,

0:51:31when Steve Jobs is talking about how everything just feels,

0:51:36I'm not sure if he used the word lickable,

0:51:38But when he was talking about just the reaction of touching the screen and

0:51:43being excited about being able to manipulate objects,

0:51:46I get the same kind of giddiness that I got from initially playing with iOS,

0:51:50playing with the multitasking.

0:51:51Like just, I will sometimes when I'm bored, I've found myself, or

0:51:56not even bored, but waiting for something to render.

0:51:58I find myself just flicking apps around and going from slide over and

0:52:02pulling it down.

0:52:03Just it's a comfortable movement.

0:52:06It's really enjoyable.

0:52:07And as you said, on promotion, or on the 10.5 and the 12.9 with promotion, it just, it flies.

0:52:14It doesn't, it feels like there is no latency whatsoever because there isn't between your

0:52:20touch interface and what the screen is rendering.

0:52:24They're inputting touch from the user at 120 hertz, and then they're exporting it and showing

0:52:29it to you at 120 hertz.

0:52:31So whatever you're doing, it's literally what the screen is doing.

0:52:34I remember when Mac OS X was in beta, or even when 10.00 officially shipped back in 2002,

0:52:44and I worked at Barebones Software, and my friend Jim Correa was one of the engineers there,

0:52:50and how he works at the Omni Group.

0:52:52But when the betas came out, and it was so slow, it looked so good,

0:52:57and I think that's where Jobs said it's lickable.

0:52:59It was describing that initial Aqua interface, but it was so slow.

0:53:03And I remember Jim, we'd get like a beta and we'd put it on a high-end Mac, and we'd have a lot of icons in a finder view.

0:53:11And Jim would just sort of drag the scroll bar up and down real fast. Like, just go up, down, up, down, up, down.

0:53:17And you could see the shearing on screen, and Jim would just be like, "Ah, that's garbage."

0:53:22Because you could just see it. But you'd go real fast, and it's like, well, of course, at this fidelity with this super, you know,

0:53:31you know, thousand color icons,

0:53:36of course it's not gonna be able to scroll in real time.

0:53:39Whereas now, it's not even the indirect motion

0:53:43of like scrolling a mouse bar up and down,

0:53:45but literally your finger going up and down,

0:53:47and just sitting there flicking the screen

0:53:49up and down, up and down, up and down,

0:53:51and having it track your finger 100%,

0:53:54just like you're dragging a piece of paper on a desk

0:53:56is kind of amazing.

0:53:58- It's such a nice feeling.

0:54:01It's such a, it is confusing your brain

0:54:05in a way that's kind of wonderful.

0:54:07Because your brain, like it feels like

0:54:09you're tactilely moving something.

0:54:11Despite the fact that it's just glass.

0:54:13You know, I'm not moving a damn thing

0:54:16except for pixels on a screen.

0:54:18But dragging, like I'm just swiping my home screens

0:54:21back and forth with four fingers right now.

0:54:24And it just, it feels like I'm moving things.

0:54:26My brain is thoroughly convinced.

0:54:28- It's nice.

0:54:29I overuse that word, I think, when I review recent Apple products, but I don't know what

0:54:35other word to use, that they're making things nicer.

0:54:43It's not really a tech thing.

0:54:45There is serious engineering that goes into it and the integration between the hardware

0:54:51to have the screen physically, technically be able to be driven at 120 hertz and to have

0:54:57the software in the OS to actually do it and to do the really cool thing which is dynamically

0:55:05adjust the refresh rate so that if you're watching a 24 frames per second video it'll

0:55:09actually only update at 24 hertz because you don't need the other one.

0:55:15In fact, in addition to saving battery, it actually makes the video look better because

0:55:19you're not doing a pull down and getting interstitial frames that are interpolated.

0:55:24Yeah, I'm gonna pause you there because there's some really, really cool tech in that regard.

0:55:30Have you ever, have you done the demo yet where you put a movie side by side with scrolling?

0:55:35No, I haven't really.

0:55:37So this is where it gets really cool, right? So the way that you, like you normally watch a

0:55:43movie when you're watching at a screen that doesn't do a 3D2 pull down, when it when it

0:55:47It divides equally.

0:55:49You normally watch a movie at somewhere between 48 hertz and I think 72 or maybe 96.

0:55:57And it divides equally down to 24 frames a second because your eyes get like kind of

0:56:02messed up if you just look at 24 screen refreshes.

0:56:08So what promotion does when you have video next to something that's 120 hertz, unlike

0:56:14Like the televisions, right, where if you show slow-mo mode, right, you show sports

0:56:19mode, it just makes the video look really super high speed unless you manually change

0:56:23it.

0:56:24Promotion, when you have two things side by side, it intelligently downsamples the video.

0:56:31It knows that it's video that you're watching, and it says, "Okay, this we're going to down

0:56:36sample to sets of 24, essentially.

0:56:38We're going to show you, you know, an image five times in a second so that your brain

0:56:43thinks it's 24 frames a second, even though we're refreshing the screen 120 times. But

0:56:48on the right side, where you're drawing, we're going to give you the full 120 screen refreshes.

0:56:54So you can watch a movie or like use it as reference and it looks like a movie. But on

0:57:00the right side, whether you're scrolling or drawing, it's as fast as the screen can allow

0:57:06for so you have no latency and it's mind boggling.

0:57:10It's crazy. It's like I said 20 minutes ago. It's the best. I think it's the best device

0:57:15Apple's ever made. I really do, hands down. And it's not my favorite. It's not my favorite

0:57:20Apple device ever made. But I do think it's the best. And I feel like that's sort of putting

0:57:28on your big boy pants to be a reviewer is to be able to separate what you personally

0:57:34prefer versus appreciating that this is the best thing

0:57:37Apple, this is the most Apple-y thing Apple's ever made.

0:57:40- Yeah, it's, well, exactly.

0:57:43Even if you're not an iPad person,

0:57:45even if you are a MacBook Pro person or an iPhone person,

0:57:48yeah, and that's okay.

0:57:50But what this should, like, the reason why the iPad,

0:57:53the 10.5 excites me and the 12.9 excite me

0:57:55as much as they do is, yeah, I'm an artist

0:57:58and I really love the iPad form factor.

0:58:00I love, you know, a lot of things about it,

0:58:03But I also, you know, I care about my MacBook Pro very much.

0:58:06I really enjoy using it on a day to day,

0:58:08and there are things that make more sense on a Mac.

0:58:10But what excites me is that if Apple is developing

0:58:14all of this technology, the same, I mean,

0:58:17you look back to what happened with Retina, right?

0:58:19Where, when the iPhone, was it the 5

0:58:22that came out with Retina?

0:58:24- No, iPhone 4. - Or the 4?

0:58:264, 4, 4, 4, that's right.

0:58:28The iPhone 4 came out with Retina,

0:58:30And Retina is something, when it first came out,

0:58:33there was one person in my life

0:58:35who was really excited about Retina.

0:58:37And that was my boyfriend at the time

0:58:39who was a comics artist.

0:58:40And he's like, "I have been asking for this for two years."

0:58:43And I'm looking at him and I'm like,

0:58:44"I don't really get why it's better until you see it."

0:58:47And then you're like, "Oh, this is amazing."

0:58:51That's how I feel about all of this tech

0:58:53is that it's all going to filter down into the Mac,

0:58:56into the iPhone, into whatever Apple decides

0:59:00to make in the future, whether that be AR goggles

0:59:02or a car or a car interface

0:59:05or something we can't even think of.

0:59:07The fact that Apple is working on technology

0:59:10that ostensibly, just like that screenshots feature,

0:59:14you know, consumers were not asking Apple,

0:59:17you need to make a screen with a higher refresh rate

0:59:19because most people aren't gonna know what that means.

0:59:23But Apple is very focused on making devices

0:59:26that just feel better.

0:59:28They feel less like screens in front of our hands

0:59:31and more like physically tangible devices

0:59:34that are part of our lives.

0:59:36And that is, that's something that we can take advantage of

0:59:41across the line, no matter whether you're a Mac person

0:59:43or an iPhone person or an iPad person or a home pod person,

0:59:46like this is better for you.

0:59:48This is a good direction for the company to be going in,

0:59:52caring about its users and actually seeing all of those

0:59:54years of work pay off.

0:59:58Very much so. I was very excited for retina years before it came out. I remember, I've told this

1:00:04story before but it's worth telling again, where there was like a WWDC, I was like, I don't know,

1:00:09maybe like 2005, 2006, but it was before the iPhone even existed. But there was a WWDC,

1:00:15it was probably like 2006, where Apple made a big push on the Mac for what they called at the time

1:00:21high DPI. And the gist was like, "Hey, stop drawing pixel for pixel icons. Make them like a PDF so

1:00:29that they can scale." And it was as close as they ever come to saying what they're going to do,

1:00:35because eventually we're going to make screens that have higher resolution. And I remember,

1:00:39it was me and Cable Sasser from Panic, and we both got it instantly. And people were like,

1:00:45"Well, what the hell are you talking about? The Mac's already beautiful." And Cable and I were

1:00:49like, well, have you ever seen like a laser printer output, how the fonts, when you print

1:00:54on a laser printer, they look better than they do on screen?

1:00:57And they're like, yeah, because on the screen there you could see the anti-aliasing.

1:01:00And we're like, exactly!

1:01:01Like, imagine a screen that's like a laser printer.

1:01:05And they're like, well, that's never going to happen.

1:01:06And we're like, no, no, that's what Apple's telling us is going to happen.

1:01:10And they're like, no, that's too...

1:01:12That's not going to happen.

1:01:13That's too hard.

1:01:14And they quick, like, do the math.

1:01:16And they're like, "Well, that would be like, you know,

1:01:17four million pixels on a screen."

1:01:19And we're like, "Yeah, that's what they're going to do."

1:01:21That's what, and we thought it was coming like next year.

1:01:23We were like, (laughs)

1:01:25we were like, and famously, I swear, this is true,

1:01:29like, cable got like panicked to do like,

1:01:32like all of their apps were retina ready like in 2007,

1:01:36(laughing)

1:01:37like six years before the Mac had a retina screen

1:01:40because it's probably half my fault.

1:01:43- You knew. - Right.

1:01:44because we got so excited because there was like

1:01:46one session at WWDC 2006 that was like,

1:01:50get ready for high DPI.

1:01:51All right, let me take a break here.

1:01:54- What's the hint?

1:01:54- Let me take a break and thank our next sponsor.

1:01:56It is our good friends at Warby Parker.

1:01:58Warby Parker thinks glasses, like eyeglasses,

1:02:01should not cost as much as your iPhone.

1:02:03Instead, their prescription eyeglasses start at just 95 bucks

1:02:08and when you've got a pair of Warby Parker glasses

1:02:11for 95 bucks, it's not like, oh,

1:02:13but then you have to buy the anti-glare coating

1:02:17and you have to get the scratch coating

1:02:19and next thing you know it's 300 bucks.

1:02:21No, the $95 glasses you get from Warby Parker

1:02:24are like good to go.

1:02:25Like you get the anti-glare, they're scratch proof.

1:02:29There is no upsell.

1:02:30There's no hard sell, there's no upsell.

1:02:33You just get good glasses.

1:02:34It's amazing.

1:02:35I couldn't even be reading this ad to you right now

1:02:40without the Warby Parker glasses that I'm wearing

1:02:42as I read this.

1:02:44I just got a new pair a couple weeks ago,

1:02:47and they're fantastic.

1:02:48It's a great company.

1:02:49They have great selection of glasses to choose from.

1:02:52What you do is you go to their website,

1:02:55and they have tons and tons of glasses to choose from,

1:02:58all sorts of styles.

1:02:59You pick five, up to five that you like,

1:03:02and they'll mail them to you at your house,

1:03:05just like with dummy lenses,

1:03:07just see-through, clear lenses.

1:03:09So you can try them on in your house, look in the mirror,

1:03:14get your opinion from whoever you live with

1:03:16or your friends or whatever, like,

1:03:18hey, do these look better, do these look better?

1:03:20And then you just mail those back to them.

1:03:22And if there's one of them or two of them

1:03:24or more that you want, you just say,

1:03:27hey, here's the ones I want.

1:03:28You send them a picture of your prescription.

1:03:31And next thing you know, like a week later,

1:03:33you've got glasses for 95 bucks.

1:03:36It could not be easier.

1:03:39and the try-on process could not be easier as well,

1:03:44including the fact that when they mail them to you,

1:03:47it already comes with a box with the label on it

1:03:50for mailing the try-on glasses back to them.

1:03:53Like, it literally could not be easier.

1:03:56There's nothing you have to do, no work.

1:03:58So if you're a total lazy person like I am,

1:04:03this is the best way to get glasses.

1:04:06Where do you go to find out more?

1:04:08go to warbyparker.com/the-talk-show,

1:04:12and then they'll know you came from the show.

1:04:14And every time you buy glasses from them,

1:04:17this is the other thing that's really cool,

1:04:19they also, each pair you buy from Warby Parker,

1:04:22they make a pair of glasses to give to charity

1:04:25for people around the globe who need glasses,

1:04:29which is absolutely fantastic.

1:04:31Because imagine living your life

1:04:33and not being able to see stuff clearly.

1:04:35It would be horrible.

1:04:36So Warby Parker is helping to make that,

1:04:38helping to solve that problem.

1:04:41Every time you buy a pair of glasses,

1:04:43they send a pair to people around the world

1:04:46that need glasses.

1:04:47So if you need glasses,

1:04:49next time you need glasses, go to Warby Parker.

1:04:51I don't know what else to tell you.

1:04:53All right, what else do we wanna talk about?

1:04:56There's so much.

1:04:57- Yeah, so actually, you mentioned, you know,

1:05:01figuring out retina based on WWDC sessions

1:05:04from a few years back before it,

1:05:06- Many years back. - I could have, yeah,

1:05:08many, many years.

1:05:09I kind of feel like there are a lot of breadcrumbs

1:05:15in this year's WWDC about where VR and AR are going

1:05:20with Apple and I--

1:05:22- I think so too.

1:05:24- Yeah.

1:05:25I just, I don't know if I have that much more to say

1:05:29about that other than I'm really fascinated

1:05:31with all of the technology that they dropped

1:05:35in the dev sessions this year,

1:05:37because I think quite a lot of it is,

1:05:39again, setting groundwork.

1:05:40I mean, APFS is another good example of something.

1:05:43Obviously, it came to iOS last year,

1:05:46and you talked a bit about it with Phil and Craig last week,

1:05:50and now it's coming to the Mac.

1:05:51But there's a lot in here.

1:05:54ARKit, I mentioned ARKit already,

1:05:57but VR is another really, really interesting thing

1:06:01that comes along side by side

1:06:04with Apple essentially saying, hey, external GPUs,

1:06:08the thing that we've kind of naysayed for years and years

1:06:12because it just wouldn't work well,

1:06:14we're gonna be shipping developers a kit

1:06:17that allows them to develop with an external GPU,

1:06:20with the goal of people being able to buy external GPU kits

1:06:24next year to use in VR.

1:06:27And here are all of these tools

1:06:29if you wanna develop VR games on the Mac,

1:06:31which heretofore not possible.

1:06:34And even though consumers, I mean, the earliest a consumer is really going to be able to play

1:06:41any sort of VR game on the Vive, I mean, technically, I guess you can hook up a Vive to the highest

1:06:47end iMac that's out right now.

1:06:49But really, I mean, I think you're going to see more of a push and steam and everything,

1:06:54the game's coming, starting in December and next year.

1:06:58So it's just, I don't know, it's really interesting to see Apple getting on the bandwagon in this

1:07:04way and positioning it from not from a hey consumers we know you love VR so here are

1:07:11some machines to let you play VR but from a like developers do you want to work on you

1:07:17know the tools that you really like working on to develop VR content and VR movies we're

1:07:22going to give you those tools I what you can do I've said this I think with Ben Thompson

1:07:28I think it was on a show but I've said it numerous times but the way to be right all

1:07:33the time is not to pretend like you can be correct all the time with every decision you

1:07:40make and every statement you make because the nature of being a human being is you're

1:07:44going to be wrong sometimes.

1:07:45You're going to make mistakes.

1:07:46The way to be right all the time is to have an open mind and recognize your mistakes and

1:07:51then just say, "Oh, I screwed that one up."

1:07:55So if it's as simple as just me writing "Daring Fireball," if I post something and it's wrong,

1:08:01way to be right all the time is to as soon as I find out that a post is wrong

1:08:04post an update and say oh this is wrong I screwed up here's the correct thing

1:08:08and it I'm I feel like what Apple's done with the GPU stuff on the Mac is exactly

1:08:17what you want to see it it's a sign of a healthy Apple which is clearly they had

1:08:22their eye off the ball for the last two years or so on Mac hardware and I feel

1:08:29like a little bit, you know, maybe it was because they were at a high level focused

1:08:34on the iPad and the iPhone especially, and maybe a little bit they were taking for granted

1:08:41the Mac market and maybe a little bit they, you know, quote unquote, painted themselves

1:08:48in a thermal corner with the Mac Pro. But they did. But the fact that they can, you

1:08:55You know, like, I don't feel like it's worth raking them over the coals for the mistake,

1:09:00given that they've clearly come back and said, "Okay, we're going to go all in on this."

1:09:06And like you said, with the eGPUs, it's like, here's where the industry's gone.

1:09:10And we clearly, in 2013, when we came out with that Mac Pro design, totally did not

1:09:16anticipate that.

1:09:17Like that 2013 Mac Pro, for all the pros and cons you can say about it, the one thing about

1:09:23that clearly is not true, is that architecture did not

1:09:28anticipate the rise of the GPU as effectively the new CPU,

1:09:36right?

1:09:37And the way that all of this machine learning

1:09:40goes through the GPU, even though it's not actually

1:09:44graphical at all, that's the thing that it's hard for me

1:09:48to really get why that's the case.

1:09:51I don't really understand it, but I know

1:09:53that it's true that this massively parallel processing,

1:09:58when you go through the machine learning,

1:10:00like go through all of my photos

1:10:01and try to find every one that's a picture of sneakers

1:10:04or something like that,

1:10:05it's more efficient on a GPU than a CPU

1:10:08because it's meant to be parallelized.

1:10:12They just didn't foresee it.

1:10:13And now they're like, well, we get it now though,

1:10:16and we're coming back in a big way.

1:10:19- Yeah, and not just here's technology

1:10:22that we kind of screwed up on and we're coming back on it.

1:10:25But I think your point as to taking the Mac market

1:10:28for granted and maybe taking pros for granted

1:10:31and thinking, well, professionals aren't as big

1:10:33of a market anymore, so do we really need

1:10:35to put that much emphasis on it?

1:10:38It feels to me a lot like the early Final Cut Pro 10 days

1:10:41where they release this new thing and they're like,

1:10:44right, okay, we're listening to you

1:10:48and let's show you how much we're listening to you

1:10:51and where that's going.

1:10:52And the interesting thing about this WWDC for me in terms of like the overall story,

1:10:59the where Apple's going story, is the refocus very much so on pros and developers

1:11:05without necessarily abandoning what makes its consumer hardware so great.

1:11:10They have managed to find like a really nice line straddle where they can give all of this,

1:11:17again, this amazing tech that's going to help your average user,

1:11:21but it's really designed for professionals.

1:11:24Yeah, ARKit is a great example of that, right?

1:11:26Because I don't think that they really announced anything Apple--

1:11:30well, the only thing I can think of that they announced that is, like,

1:11:34Apple-made that consumers will use is the feature we were just talking about a while ago

1:11:39about the scanning documents, which is ARKit to get the angle squared up.

1:11:47Other than that though, the ARKit is really just more,

1:11:50here's the great framework and we're giving it to you,

1:11:54the developers, and you guys come up with the ideas,

1:11:57you know, like better Pokemon Go, you know,

1:12:02which is obviously silly, but it clearly looks--

1:12:05- But it's powerful.

1:12:06- It looks so much better, right?

1:12:08- It really does.

1:12:09It's nice to have, you know, the Pokemon sized properly

1:12:11in regards to the background,

1:12:13like as silly and little as that is,

1:12:15or one of the great ridiculous demos that I saw floating around the internet this week,

1:12:21someone built a 3D model of the Titanic and was able to map it to water. And there's just this

1:12:28nine second clip of someone panning, moving the camera up and down and side to side,

1:12:35and basically seeing a virtual 3D model of the Titanic.

1:12:39- Right, that's amazing. Somebody was talking last week, I don't even know,

1:12:43it might already be shipping.

1:12:44I don't know if it was an idea or not.

1:12:46But clearly, this is going to happen,

1:12:48and it's going to be on our phones soon with ARKit.

1:12:52If you're at Ikea and you have a photo of your living room,

1:12:58you'll be able to live--

1:13:01what would this table look like if it was our dining room

1:13:03table?

1:13:04And you'll be able to see exactly what it'll look like.

1:13:07Live scan it.

1:13:08That's super useful.

1:13:11or walk through tours, essentially being able

1:13:15to virtually walk through a home

1:13:19while you're, instead of having to visit

1:13:2120 different places.

1:13:23Or here's a crazy one.

1:13:25360 cameras are one of these things

1:13:28where I'm just kind of like, eh, you know, I'm not,

1:13:31as of yet, until very recently, I'm like,

1:13:35okay, this is cool and all, but is this really useful?

1:13:39And my pal and yours, Andy Anatko,

1:13:43came to a roller derby game recently and shot the game,

1:13:47shot like 10 minutes of the game in 360

1:13:50from the center of the oval.

1:13:53And for people who don't know roller derby,

1:13:54it's a game that's played on an oval track.

1:13:56And it's basically a combination of sprinting and rugby

1:13:59where you have players hitting each other

1:14:01and then you're trying to race around a track.

1:14:03So the action, there's lots of action happening at one time.

1:14:06There's simultaneous offense and defense.

1:14:09And the 360 camera was like seeing that footage,

1:14:13and I just had to like pan through it on Facebook, right?

1:14:16Because I didn't have an applicable AR way of holding it up.

1:14:21But the 360 footage was fascinating

1:14:24because I could see what was happening

1:14:27at the back of the action versus the front of the action,

1:14:30what was happening between the point scorers

1:14:32and what was happening between the point scorer

1:14:33of the opposing team without having to rely

1:14:37on the person who was filming to like zoom in or zoom out.

1:14:40- Right, it's a sport that's not really amenable

1:14:42to TV style, you know, one 16 to nine rectangle frame

1:14:47of action, no, you're exactly right though,

1:14:50it's a perfect example because there's stuff going 360

1:14:53degrees around the track at all times.

1:14:55- Exactly, exactly, and the beauty of that, right,

1:14:59and I'm thinking about, you know, all of this,

1:15:03the beauty of it is that like right now we can,

1:15:07we'll be able to look at those kind of things in AR

1:15:09with a compatible app, you know, on an iPad, right?

1:15:14Or on an iPhone, or you look at Apple's even own demo

1:15:16of Peter Jackson's new software with the 12.9 iPad,

1:15:20you know, holding up, watching the town get destroyed.

1:15:24That's really cool, and it's a cool proof of concept demo.

1:15:28But again, this is, what Apple cares about

1:15:31is not that you're making apps for somebody

1:15:33to hold up their iPad for three hours

1:15:35and play a game in AR,

1:15:37like Apple's thinking five years down the line.

1:15:39Apple's thinking, all right,

1:15:40well, forget about iPhones and iPads.

1:15:43How do we incorporate this technology

1:15:45into whatever's next, right?

1:15:47You're not gonna wanna hold a 12.9-inch screen,

1:15:50so what are we gonna do?

1:15:51And that's Apple's deal.

1:15:53But for Apple to be able to launch that kind of thing

1:15:56in three, five, 10 years,

1:15:58whatever the timeline ends up being,

1:16:00they need the software, they need the bright ideas

1:16:02and the brilliant ideas that are gonna get the,

1:16:05your average Pokemon Go loving user to hop on.

1:16:08'Cause otherwise they're just making Google Glass, right?

1:16:11They're making it a fun proof of concept

1:16:12that has no reason or rhyme.

1:16:15- What do you make of the fact

1:16:21that they've already updated the MacBook Pros?

1:16:23- I think that that's a, gosh,

1:16:30I think primarily it's a, oh, well,

1:16:34Thankfully, Kaby Lake is finally here,

1:16:36so we're gonna shove some Kaby Lakes

1:16:37into the new MacBook Pros.

1:16:39And if we could have launched the new MacBook Pros

1:16:41with Kaby Lake last year, we would have done it.

1:16:44- But we couldn't. - But we couldn't

1:16:45because Intel. - Right.

1:16:47Here's what I think.

1:16:48And I know it seems to me like the sort of typical

1:16:52like damned if you do, damned if you don't,

1:16:54where, and I get it, like if you just bought

1:16:58a new MacBook Pro like four months ago,

1:17:00it kinda sucks that there's new ones now,

1:17:02But that's the way the computer industry used to work all the time, right?

1:17:06There were always new machines nine months after you bought it, and so there was no way

1:17:10to win.

1:17:12You were lucky if you got six months with a top-of-the-line machine that was still top-of-the-line.

1:17:17And so updating October released machines in June is sort of like a return to that.

1:17:24But the way I feel is that this was a unique situation where the MacBook Pros were overdue

1:17:29last year.

1:17:30Everybody wanted new MacBook Pros last year.

1:17:32Oh, yeah, they were overdue and they made the best ones that they could make given what was available from Intel and ship them

1:17:39and now that they can make them a little bit better with Kaby like and get a little bit better battery life and you know

1:17:45It's obviously not radically better. Like if you bought one of the ones that was released last October, you're not like screwed

1:17:51It's not like you know

1:17:53But I think it was worth not waiting until now to do it

1:17:58Yeah, absolutely. Well again, you look at the the overall picture of Apple doesn't like pros

1:18:05Or Apple is abandoning pros without Apple just basically being like hey guys. Okay, we're we're going to give you this concession

1:18:12We're gonna show you the MacBook Pro that we've been working on and no it's not the Mac

1:18:16You know, I think honestly Apple would have liked to release those last

1:18:20WWDC but the Kaby Lake chips just weren't ready with the the low power stuff that they wanted

1:18:27So they had to wait and finally they're like, all right

1:18:30Well, we can't release these with Kaby Lake but you know

1:18:33We want to we want to make sure that people understand that we're not you know

1:18:36We're not sitting on our laurels and twiddling our thumbs. We actually are working on great hardware

1:18:41It's just maybe not as great as we would like it to be

1:18:44I don't know I have a as somebody who cares more about the Mac than any other product that they make

1:18:49I thought that this is a great WWDC even if it means that people who bought a Macbook Pro last October

1:18:56kind of, you know, only got like seven or eight months of top-of-the-line life out of the thing. It's like, well, so it goes.

1:19:03Yeah, it's, and honestly, it's not, as you said, it's not like it's such a big jump in

1:19:08performance that now all of a sudden I'm looking at my 13-inch.

1:19:12It's not the the original MacBook Air versus the 2010 MacBook Airs, right?

1:19:17Where it's all of a sudden you go from a barely usable computer to a very usable computer.

1:19:22My 13-inch that I bought in October is still a very usable computer.

1:19:26It's still a great laptop, and I probably wasn't pushing it to the extent that I could anyway.

1:19:31And the fact that it has Thunderbolt 3 and everything else, that's the really important stuff for the future-proofing down the line.

1:19:38You talk about using the eGPU. I'll be able to use an eGPU on my machine from October.

1:19:44I don't have to buy a machine from June to be able to do that.

1:19:46So that's the important stuff, I think.

1:19:48But the really interesting thing, I think this is the thing that's caught my eye and my memory is, well, Kaby Lake is all well and good, but jumping back to iPad for a second here, one of the things we didn't talk about with the new iPad Pros is the ridiculousness of the A10X.

1:20:08And the fact that I basically have a computer here that's more powerful than, you know, my laptop from four years ago.

1:20:15Yeah, it's crazy.

1:20:16It's crazy.

1:20:17Yeah.

1:20:18Yeah.

1:20:19It's absolutely crazy.

1:20:20And I kind of hinted at it in my review,

1:20:23but I actually feel that Apple has--

1:20:25the combination of the incredible achievements

1:20:31of Apple's in-house chip team and how good the A10X is,

1:20:35combined with--

1:20:38I don't want to say the word ineptitude, but--

1:20:42the hiccups that Intel has had in recent years--

1:20:46- Lack of innovation from Intel.

1:20:49- But I actually feel that from a product marketing

1:20:52standpoint, it's actually put Apple in a very hard position

1:20:55because they really are totally committed to the Mac.

1:21:00And I feel like they've shown it and they've really,

1:21:03it's not just words anymore,

1:21:05like with the product announcements with the MacBook Pros

1:21:08and the new MacBook and especially the new iMacs

1:21:11and super especially the iMac Pro

1:21:15Super super especially the fact that they've said that the iMac Pro is not the Mac Pro that they talked about

1:21:21Two months ago that that's still coming

1:21:23Like there is committed to the Mac as they could possibly be and I feel like the high Sierra story is

1:21:29Exactly what I wanted them to do. Just don't work on new stuff. Just sort of make it better

1:21:35All of that said I really feel like the a10x is so good that they're they're in a hard position because they don't want to

1:21:44denigrate Intel because Intel is an important partner for them and they don't want to denigrate

1:21:49their own products, which the entire Mac line is based on the Intel chips. But the A10X

1:21:56embarrasses Intel, in my opinion. I feel like the new iPad Pro is absolutely a slap in the

1:22:02face. Intel should be ashamed of themselves that this device can't be made using Intel

1:22:07devices. And it's not just the performance because obviously there are Intel chips that

1:22:13can outperform the A10X.

1:22:15It's the fact that it's a fanless, heatless--

1:22:18it never gets hot, right?

1:22:20So--

1:22:20Not even warm.

1:22:21Right, it never gets warm.

1:22:23So given those constraints and how light it is

1:22:26and the battery life it gets, there's

1:22:28no way to make a machine like that with an Intel chip.

1:22:31And the MacBook with the Core M3 is--

1:22:35it's behind the iPad Pro, just in terms of sheer performance.

1:22:40The only reason to choose it would be if you,

1:22:43you know, for the reason that I would,

1:22:44is that I prefer working on a Mac,

1:22:46and I like Mac software, and I like the form factor,

1:22:49but as a computer, just judging it as a computing device,

1:22:53it is so far behind the iPad Pro, it's embarrassing to Intel.

1:22:57- Yeah, it doesn't, and what is interesting to me

1:23:00about that is, you know, Intel currently has the edge

1:23:05on Apple for high-end chips, right?

1:23:08Apple's not gonna be able to make an A series processor

1:23:11that's gonna power an iMac Pro or even a Mac Pro yet.

1:23:15Yet, that's the trick, right?

1:23:17Like, I mean, maybe that's their announcement

1:23:19for the Mac Pro, is they're like, yeah,

1:23:22no, it doesn't run Intel, it just runs the A like 20

1:23:24or something crazy like that.

1:23:25- Or like it has like six 810X or something like that.

1:23:29- Exactly, right, right. - That would be my bug.

1:23:30And I wouldn't be surprised if that's the story, but.

1:23:33- Yeah, well, they've just done,

1:23:36and this entire team has just done such incredible work on silicon.

1:23:40I mean, there's always the story to be said about, you know, Apple being able to make everything in-house

1:23:47means that they're able to customize and really focus their CPU on what it needs to do,

1:23:54as opposed to, you know, meeting the hardware specifications of 20 different computers.

1:23:59But it's really, it is really staggering.

1:24:03again, as somebody who maybe pushes the iPad, I have pushed my iPads in the past to 100%

1:24:10capacity and I have tried just about everything that I can think of on the new 10.5 iPad to

1:24:18try and push it to capacity, including running 3D intensive games and doing crazy stuff in

1:24:25Affinity Photo, which by the way, people who have been looking for a Photoshop replacement

1:24:29since the dawn of the iPad,

1:24:31Affinity Photo is the Photoshop replacement.

1:24:34And in fact, once you learn it a little bit,

1:24:37I would argue that Affinity Photo is in some ways stronger

1:24:40than Photoshop, which is a frightening thing to say.

1:24:43But that's the thing, right?

1:24:46It's like the iPad Pro for many years has been hamstrung

1:24:51by the double whammy of like the processors

1:24:55kept on getting more powerful in the iPad,

1:24:58but they weren't still as powerful as they needed to be

1:25:01to do certain things.

1:25:03And the operating system was not necessarily

1:25:07what pro users wanted to use

1:25:09because there were the hand tied behind your back thing,

1:25:13where it's just not quite what I want.

1:25:15This series of iPad, this series of the A10X

1:25:20and the design and iOS 11 in the fall,

1:25:24This is Apple basically being like pro developers,

1:25:28people who wanna do pro creative software

1:25:31that takes incredibly intense rendering

1:25:34and you wanna be able to work fast.

1:25:38The iPad is now capable of doing this.

1:25:40So why hamstring yourself with a Mac,

1:25:43which in some cases is subpar for your work,

1:25:47unlike in other professions

1:25:50where I feel like the Mac is superior.

1:25:52In some professions now, the iPad is the superior device.

1:25:57And that's a really interesting story

1:26:00for Apple to be able to tell.

1:26:01Not that the iPad makes do for where a Mac could,

1:26:05but you need an iPad to be able

1:26:08to be the leader in your field.

1:26:10That's the thing that's making me,

1:26:12like that's what the A10X and Suruji's Silicon team

1:26:15has basically opened us up to.

1:26:18- And again, ProMotion is in hand with that, right?

1:26:21- Yeah. - It's like, you know,

1:26:23the graphics throughput on this device is insane.

1:26:27It's absolutely insane.

1:26:28- Yeah, the fact that, well, it's constantly pushing,

1:26:32you know, the screen and doing it without any latency, right?

1:26:37When doing high-intensity projects,

1:26:40like the demo on stage of the guy making a movie poster

1:26:44and doing seamless, you know, wave rendering

1:26:47without any time, that's impressive,

1:26:50and it's cool and stuff, but it really doesn't show

1:26:52what the processor is truly capable of.

1:26:54- The one where he did the hair recognition

1:26:57around Johnny Depp for the poster though, that was--

1:27:00- Yeah.

1:27:00- That's, and that's the one where I even wrote about.

1:27:03I actually think that Apple strategically

1:27:06had a third party do it, and he said it was four times

1:27:09faster than on a desktop PC doing it on the iPad.

1:27:13They had a third party say that because they themselves

1:27:16didn't wanna say this thing is actually faster than a Mac

1:27:19doing graphics-intensive things like this, that sort of, you know, select the outline

1:27:27of a very complex, you know, Johnny Depp with Dreadlocks, Captain Jack Sparrow movie poster

1:27:35thing.

1:27:36Yeah, no, absolutely, because they don't, again, they don't want to insult Intel, they

1:27:40don't want to get in trouble with any of their partners, but if a third party's like, yeah,

1:27:44We use this and it's no slouch.

1:27:48It's second basically to having John from Procreate

1:27:51or Adobe come up and say the same thing,

1:27:54but Adobe can't piss off its own partners.

1:27:59- But it's kind of fascinating in conjunction

1:28:01with this whole 10th anniversary of the iPhone and iOS.

1:28:06We'll touch on that in the next segment of the show

1:28:10with the book that came out.

1:28:11But everybody's looking back at it.

1:28:13And the whole story of the origin of iOS

1:28:19with the creation of the iPhone was this, hey,

1:28:23what should it be?

1:28:23Should it just be an iPod that can make cell phone calls?

1:28:28Should it be a new OS based on a very light embedded version

1:28:34of Linux?

1:28:35Or can Apple strip down Mac OS X to the point

1:28:43where it could run on a pocket-sized device in 2007.

1:28:48And the great achievement of that team

1:28:54is that even people on the team thought

1:28:58that's probably impossible.

1:28:59We can't get Mac OS X to be at that level.

1:29:04And they did it, and that's what made the original iPhone

1:29:08such a mind-blowing, once-in-our-lifetime,

1:29:11you know, epic moment in the industry.

1:29:16But it was, at that origin, it was like,

1:29:23I can't believe that they got this to the point

1:29:26where it's actually usable and boots

1:29:28in a reasonable amount of time and a performance is good.

1:29:31But it was clearly slower than the Mac.

1:29:34It was amazing that it ran at all.

1:29:36And here we are 10 years later,

1:29:38and they've gotten the iPad to the point

1:29:40where it's actually more performant

1:29:45than a consumer MacBook.

1:29:48It's absolutely-- - Yeah, baseline laptop.

1:29:50- Right, it has nothing like the original,

1:29:52when the iPad came out in 2010,

1:29:55you didn't buy it because it was faster,

1:29:57you bought it because the--

1:29:59- Because you wanted it.

1:30:00- Right, it was all about the UI and the,

1:30:03hey, I just love this style of computing

1:30:06and I don't care if it's slower,

1:30:09I don't need fast, I just need, I like this

1:30:12lightweight mental model of interaction

1:30:16with direct manipulation of stuff on screen.

1:30:19But here we are today in 2017,

1:30:21and it's actually the faster computer,

1:30:23which is mind blowing to me.

1:30:25- Yeah, I'm looking at Geekbench scores right now,

1:30:28and I just ran it on my 10.5,

1:30:30and it's fun to look at the compute section of Geekbench

1:30:33where it compares your device versus older devices,

1:30:37And I'm looking at their metal score, their GPU score.

1:30:41The iPhone 5S, which really wasn't that long ago,

1:30:43the iPhone 5S had a compute score of 546,

1:30:47and the 10.5-inch iPad Pro has a score of 29,445.

1:30:51- That's crazy.

1:30:55- Right?

1:30:56- Or just look at the graphics performance,

1:30:58where you take a webpage and just scroll up and down

1:31:00real fast, just up, down, up, down, up, down.

1:31:03On the iPad Pro, it looks like you can read it

1:31:06as it moves up and down the screen,

1:31:08and even like a high-end Mac, it's blurry

1:31:11because it just doesn't have that sort of refresh rate.

1:31:14It's absolutely crazy.

1:31:16- It's the difference between wearing glasses or not.

1:31:18The biggest, the processor wow for me

1:31:22was not running all of those high-end tests,

1:31:25but actually, I don't know if you've ever used Procreate,

1:31:28but Procreate has a feature where after you do a drawing,

1:31:32you can go to export, and you can export the drawing,

1:31:35But you can also export a video that basically calculates

1:31:40every single stroke you've made.

1:31:41So you can kind of see like a fun little time lapse

1:31:43of what you've drawn.

1:31:44And those video exports, when I do like a long piece,

1:31:49for instance, like I did the incomparable holiday card

1:31:51a few years back, and it took like three, four,

1:31:54five minutes to export it to, you know,

1:31:56and it's, you know, the display resolution.

1:31:59I've been exporting some of my Procreate projects,

1:32:02including a project that I worked on probably

1:32:04for seven, eight hours, and the export happens

1:32:06in less than 15 seconds.

1:32:08- That's crazy.

1:32:08- It's just, that's the thing where like,

1:32:11the first time I did it when I was with Renee,

1:32:13Renee was like, "Did you just export a photo?"

1:32:15And I'm like, "No, I exported a video."

1:32:17- Did you suspect that it didn't work right,

1:32:19like it was a bug?

1:32:20- Yeah, oh yeah.

1:32:21I was like, "Okay, Procreate's broken."

1:32:23And then I went and I'm like, "Nope, nope, it's there."

1:32:25That's, wow.

1:32:26- It's absolutely astounding to me that at this,

1:32:31to me so quickly, in just a handful of years,

1:32:34it's gone from, look, use this device

1:32:37if you prefer the mental model of this conceptually

1:32:41simpler direct manipulation operating system

1:32:44at the expense of performance,

1:32:46because obviously a real Intel PC is gonna be faster,

1:32:50to this point where it's like,

1:32:51actually, the only reason to use a Mac is if,

1:32:56the Mac is the one that has to make the excuse

1:32:58for the software, right?

1:32:59It's like you have to really prefer

1:33:01the full PC operating system because the performance

1:33:06is not the reason to use that device.

1:33:09It's crazy. - But I think that's,

1:33:10that's the best thing.

1:33:12I mean, it's a long time coming,

1:33:14but that's the position Apple wants to be in

1:33:16because then they get to actually go back

1:33:18to the philosophy from a few years ago,

1:33:20which is the right device for the right task.

1:33:24And it's like some tasks make more sense with the Mac,

1:33:27and that's okay, and some tasks make more sense

1:33:29with an iPad, and that's okay too.

1:33:31There can be room for both devices.

1:33:33It's just pick the one that makes more sense

1:33:35for your work.

1:33:36- Absolutely.

1:33:37All right, let me take a break here

1:33:38and thank our third sponsor.

1:33:39It's our good friends at Squarespace.

1:33:41Look, you guys know Squarespace.

1:33:42It's where you go to make a website.

1:33:44You can pick your domain name.

1:33:46You can host your website there.

1:33:48They have templates to choose from.

1:33:50Long story short, I'm not gonna,

1:33:52I don't know what else to tell you about Squarespace,

1:33:53but next time you need a website,

1:33:55Just go there and try to build it at Squarespace first.

1:33:59Just spend 30 minutes at Squarespace building a new website.

1:34:03And I can almost guarantee you that you'll just parlay that

1:34:08into, oh, this is great, this is exactly what I wanted,

1:34:12and boom, you just roll that in and sign up,

1:34:17and there you go, you've got a website already.

1:34:19Stop, don't start by making a new HTML document

1:34:22and doing it that way.

1:34:24Go to Squarespace and do it that way.

1:34:26I told you a couple weeks or months ago

1:34:29about a local restaurant here in Philly that,

1:34:31just curiously, I went and viewed Source,

1:34:35and lo and behold, their website was a Squarespace size.

1:34:38Another one, just around the corner from me here,

1:34:41there's a new pizza place that opened up,

1:34:42and they have wonderful pizza.

1:34:44It's called Rione, R-I-O-N-E.

1:34:46So if you're here local in Philly, go to this place.

1:34:49They have the most amazing pizza.

1:34:51They also have an adorable website.

1:34:53It's super cool.

1:34:54And I thought, I wonder, and I went and viewed Source,

1:34:57and guess what?

1:34:58It's a Squarespace site.

1:35:00So rather than wasting their time

1:35:02paying somebody to build a fancy website or whatever,

1:35:08all they do, they're just making the pizza,

1:35:10and then they have a very cool, very stylish,

1:35:13totally branded for the restaurant website,

1:35:16built with Squarespace.

1:35:20Don't waste your time building it on your own.

1:35:23just go to Squarespace and all you have to do is design it.

1:35:26It's so great.

1:35:27So my thanks to Squarespace, go to squarespace.com.

1:35:31And when you sign up, remember the code GRUBER,

1:35:35my last name, you gotta remember that.

1:35:37And when you actually sign up to pay,

1:35:39you'll save 10% on your first order.

1:35:42So go to squarespace.com/talkshow

1:35:44and remember that code GRUBER and you'll save 10%.

1:35:51I got two other things I wanted to talk about, Serenity.

1:35:53I wanted to talk about this book that's coming out,

1:35:57Brian Merchant's The One Device,

1:35:59and the excerpt that ran in The Verge.

1:36:02And then I wanna talk about WWDC being in San Jose

1:36:07and what we think about that.

1:36:08So let's talk about the book first.

1:36:10- All right.

1:36:11- It's not coming out till next week,

1:36:13so this podcast will come out before the book comes out.

1:36:16But The Verge ran an excerpt a couple of days ago,

1:36:19and it made some waves.

1:36:23- Just a few.

1:36:23- Particularly, and it was funny,

1:36:26so I'm reading this excerpt the day that it came out,

1:36:31and I'm reading it and I'm into it,

1:36:33and it's like, wow, there's some stuff in here

1:36:35that I didn't know before, this is great,

1:36:38and I knew I was gonna link to it from during Fireball,

1:36:41and there was this great little story from Greg Christie,

1:36:44who's, I think he left Apple about two or three years ago.

1:36:48He used to head up their human interface design team,

1:36:52and his team came up with, more or less came up

1:36:55with the original iPhone, the entire UI design.

1:37:00And he had a great story about how they had

1:37:03what he called tapas, little things.

1:37:08There was like, oh, well, here's how you would,

1:37:10we think on a little three and a half inch touchscreen,

1:37:13here's how you would do contacts.

1:37:17and an idea for, you know, here's how we think, you know,

1:37:21we would do like a web view for the web browser or whatever,

1:37:25but they didn't really have the whole start to finish,

1:37:28here's exactly what you'll see when the phone turns on,

1:37:31here's what happens when you tap this, here's what, you know,

1:37:34and more or less Steve Jobs came to him,

1:37:36it's like, these ideas are fine,

1:37:38but I want the whole story.

1:37:40You have two weeks, give me the whole story,

1:37:43or I'm putting another team on this.

1:37:44and they went into this, as Greg Christie calls it,

1:37:48death march, but his team spent two weeks

1:37:50living in this lab, and the place got all smelly,

1:37:54and he had people sleeping at his house

1:37:56'cause he didn't want them driving home

1:37:58'cause they were so exhausted.

1:37:59But in two weeks, they more or less came up with,

1:38:02Greg Christie said, "If I could reproduce the demo

1:38:05"we had at the end of that two weeks,

1:38:06"you would recognize it today as an iPhone."

1:38:09And I had this ready to go as my Daring Fireball post.

1:38:13I'm going to block quote this little section of this

1:38:15and say, go read this.

1:38:17And then I went down a little further

1:38:18and read the bit about Schiller.

1:38:21And I was like, delete, delete, delete, select all, delete.

1:38:24It was like, this is why I read the whole story

1:38:29before I post.

1:38:30- Yeah.

1:38:31Yeah.

1:38:35- So the bit that got all the publicity was Tony Fidell,

1:38:40former Apple executive who was in charge of the iPod hardware

1:38:44and was in charge of iPhone hardware

1:38:49in the original iPhone, was quoted extensively saying

1:38:55that Phil Schiller was the lone person at the executive level

1:38:59who was insistent that the original iPhone should

1:39:02have a hardware keyboard like a BlackBerry,

1:39:06and that it got to the point where there was a screaming

1:39:10match and that Steve Jobs said something to the effect of,

1:39:14"I'm sick of this shit. Get on board or get the fuck out,"

1:39:18and kicked him out of a meeting. And then it was immediately followed by a

1:39:23story by a guy named Brett Bilbray, who

1:39:28wasn't quoted extensively. He was quoted in little snippets

1:39:33saying something to the effect of that Phil Schiller

1:39:36isn't a tech guy and understands things like a grandma and grandpa from middle America.

1:39:43I think, so I think here's what I think happened. I think Tony Fidele shot his mouth off

1:39:53and regrets it because it's since come out. The author of the book, Brian Merchant,

1:40:01was on the Verge catch with Neelai Patel and says he has the entire interview with Fadel on tape

1:40:08and went back and double-checked and everything he quoted him saying was on tape.

1:40:14So the whole, what Schiller did though, I think it's kind of genius, is Schiller just said, "Not

1:40:21true. Don't believe everything you read" in response to some random person saying, "Hey,

1:40:25"Hey, Phil, is it true that you pushed this hard

1:40:29"for a hardware keyboard?"

1:40:31And in response to that tweet, Fidel tweeted,

1:40:34"Hey, this whole story isn't true.

1:40:37"I really value my friendship with Phil Schiller

1:40:40"and my time working with him."

1:40:43And this merchant has said, responded to that

1:40:46and was like, "Well, I have you on tape saying this."

1:40:51I feel like it's pretty clear what happened.

1:40:55I think Tony Fidell was quoted accurately.

1:40:58He said what he's quoted as saying,

1:41:00whether it's actually true what he said is up for debate.

1:41:04Debatable. Yeah.

1:41:06Right? Long story short,

1:41:08that's where we stand.

1:41:12Is it true or not that this happened?

1:41:15Who knows? Tony Fidell says one thing.

1:41:17But I think it's so funny that Phil Schiller baited, you know, he...

1:41:22Fidel tells this story that seemingly tries to make Phil Schiller look a little foolish, in hindsight at least.

1:41:30And in just 44, in a 144 character tweet, Phil Schiller baited him into publicly making a shit out of himself.

1:41:37[laughter]

1:41:40Well, what is it?

1:41:43Dish, grandma and grandpa, my ass.

1:41:47I mean, Phil Schiller is many things.

1:41:54Not intelligent is not one of them.

1:41:57Or technically savvy is absolutely positively not true.

1:42:00And I realize I'm coming at it from the perspective of somebody

1:42:04who just had him on my show last week.

1:42:06And so you can say, well, of course,

1:42:08going to defend him because he's a friend of the show and he comes on your show, you know,

1:42:13last three years. Put that aside, I'm telling you that I don't know anybody in the press. I mean,

1:42:21Walt Mossberg came out. I mean, Walt's got no fucks left to give because he's retired.

1:42:26He's retired.

1:42:28Right. And Walt is like, if you, you know, I've talked to, he's probably talked to

1:42:32Phil Schiller more times than anybody in the press combined. In fact, I would bet on it because I

1:42:36I don't see how anybody else could have talked with Phil Schiller more times

1:42:41than Walt Mossberg. And Walt is like, if you don't think Phil Schiller knows his

1:42:45stuff, you're an idiot. Yeah, there's no question. I mean, you don't get

1:42:50to where you are by being an empty head or an empty suit. So I know it's, you know,

1:42:56I don't want to go too far in this book because it's not out yet, so I haven't

1:42:59read it. I'm greatly looking forward to it. But in particular, this anecdote about

1:43:04the hardware keyboard to me and I really do mean this like Phil Schiller doesn't

1:43:10mean need me to defend him but I'm just saying even if it is true particularly

1:43:16depending on the timeline of when this argument happened I don't really think

1:43:20it was even so much about whether you needed a hardware keyboard but more

1:43:26about whether the iPhone needed a software it needed a keyboard period

1:43:31Like yeah, because because it's clear that at this point they were kicking around the notion and Steve Jobs himself

1:43:37Even you know was clearly of half a mind that it should be more like an iPod like a consumer electronics thing

1:43:46that

1:43:47Ran they even called them widgets, right?

1:43:51But and they even had the guy who invented dashboard for Mac OS X port like the calculator and the stocks widget

1:43:58to

1:43:59a

1:44:00a non-Mac OS X based iPhone prototype, right?

1:44:05That it would be like the sort of thing where there'd be an iPod so you could play music.

1:44:10There'd be a phone where you could dial numbers and select people,

1:44:14and maybe like a calculator and a stock widget and, you know,

1:44:18something for text messaging and that's it.

1:44:20But even like the text messaging thing wouldn't necessarily have like a keyboard.

1:44:24Maybe it would have like a, you know, like the way we texted before,

1:44:28where you'd type them on a number pad or something.

1:44:30T9.

1:44:31Right.

1:44:31Like, I think it's entirely possible,

1:44:35even if this anecdote is true,

1:44:37that what Schiller was saying was,

1:44:39we need to, we've got the ability to make this

1:44:42a little tiny personal computer,

1:44:44and therefore it needs the ability

1:44:45to actually type on a real keyboard.

1:44:48Whereas there might have been other people

1:44:50who were like, nah, we don't need that.

1:44:51Which should be more like a simple phone

1:44:53that just happens to have some things

1:44:55like a stock widget and a calculator widget.

1:44:59- Yeah, I mean, I can see it as,

1:45:02I think more likely the conversation comes on the heels of,

1:45:07well, can we even make a software keyboard work

1:45:11to the extent where it's actually functional?

1:45:14'Cause I could very much see Shiller putting his foot down

1:45:17if it's been six months and the software keyboard

1:45:20still looks shitty, looks terrible, right?

1:45:24Can't, the button response is not right,

1:45:26or you're constantly button mashing, or you just like,

1:45:29There are many reasons why a software keyboard would not have been successful at that point,

1:45:34and I can see making that point. But the way that the story is structured, it just makes it sound

1:45:40like, I don't know, I feel like it is bad narration on Merchant's part, because I just,

1:45:47it feels like there's more to the story, whether the quote is complete fabrication or not.

1:45:53But if the quote is true, like the fact that it's just like, oh yeah, Schiller was against it,

1:45:59Like, not when Schiller was against it, not why Schiller was against it, just Schiller

1:46:03was against it.

1:46:04Right.

1:46:05And, you know, when this argument took place, in what state was the software keyboard that

1:46:13we know for the iPhone?

1:46:15Did it even exist?

1:46:16Because if it didn't even exist yet, it's actually the most logical argument to make.

1:46:22It's actually, you know, correct in hindsight that we gotta have a keyboard.

1:46:27It's kind of funny how it blew out of control.

1:46:31And again, I've never met the guy, and I would love to because he seems like he's a lot of

1:46:37fun, but it seems to me like Tony Fidell needs a better press handler.

1:46:44Yeah, maybe gone off as a...

1:46:49One interesting thing...

1:46:51I just want to reiterate that Tony Fidell, as we record this, his public stances, this

1:46:58thing that I was quoted accurately saying is not true.

1:47:05He hasn't walked it back yet?

1:47:07No, all he said is that it's not true, but he hasn't denied that the quote is accurate,

1:47:12which is...

1:47:13Oh boy.

1:47:14And Merchant says he has tape, so it must be accurate.

1:47:17In other words, Tony Fidell is saying, "The story that I've told is not accurate."

1:47:21And on the Vergecast, Merchant says that he—Fidell emailed him and said,

1:47:27"Some of the stories I told you I didn't mean for you to take literally."

1:47:30Oh my god.

1:47:31And what is extra funny to me is that, of course, what, two days after this story comes out,

1:47:42the Computer History Museum announces that they're gonna, you know, have a bunch of the iPhone

1:47:48engineers for a roundtable, including Scott Forstall, who did not get interviewed for this

1:47:54book and who no one has really talked to about creating the iPhone, period, up to this point,

1:47:59because he's been under NDA. Well, we don't know that. We don't know that that's why.

1:48:04That's true. That's true. It couldn't, it could be that he just didn't feel like talking about it.

1:48:08Right. I-

1:48:09It sure was fair. He put a lot of his life into it.

1:48:11I honestly have no idea.

1:48:14I mean, the last time I talked to Scott Forstall,

1:48:18he was an Apple employee.

1:48:19So it's been a long time since I've talked to Scott Forstall.

1:48:23I don't-- I would highly doubt that his nondisclosure agreement

1:48:28for the termination package he got,

1:48:31I would highly doubt that it lasted five years.

1:48:33I would guess it was probably like two or three years.

1:48:37And I think that his continuing silence is simply

1:48:41the fact that he was,

1:48:46whatever else you want to say about the guy,

1:48:48he's an Apple employee and Apple employees don't talk.

1:48:51You know what I mean? - It's true.

1:48:53That's true. - So I can't wait for that.

1:48:55It's John Markoff, formerly of the New York Times,

1:48:57who's hosting it.

1:48:58And there is going to be video.

1:49:00It's gonna be like live cast on Facebook

1:49:03or whatever they call the thing for the clips.

1:49:05But there's gonna be video, so it's great.

1:49:07I hope it's interesting.

1:49:08I hope he opens up,

1:49:09'cause that's a guy whose story we haven't heard

1:49:13since the whole shit went down

1:49:15where he got forced out of the company.

1:49:17- Yeah.

1:49:19- And I do kind of feel like this merchant's book,

1:49:22whatever it is, it seems like there's a lot of good stuff

1:49:24in it, but the fact that it doesn't have on the record stuff

1:49:27from Forstall or anybody on Forstall's team

1:49:29means at least half the story is not in the book.

1:49:31- Yeah.

1:49:33And quite a large portion of the story, really.

1:49:36- Right, because getting Greg Christie and Boz Orting

1:49:41and a couple of other people from the design side,

1:49:44that's fantastic.

1:49:45It really is, it's a huge score for him.

1:49:47I can't wait to read that part of the book.

1:49:50But saying here's the design for the iPhone is one thing.

1:49:55Actually getting it to run, like I said,

1:49:58on 2007 ARM hardware is an entirely other thing,

1:50:02and arguably the greater accomplishment.

1:50:06- Yeah.

1:50:06- I remember talking to somebody at the Macworld Expo

1:50:12in January 2007 when it was announced.

1:50:15I knew somebody who, I didn't know beforehand,

1:50:23but afterwards I knew he worked at Apple

1:50:25and I knew that he had disappeared

1:50:28and it ends up he was working on the original iPhone

1:50:31on the software.

1:50:33And I was like, this is where you've been.

1:50:35He was like, "Yeah."

1:50:36And he still couldn't tell me anything, really.

1:50:39He could at least say, "Yes, this is what

1:50:40I've been working on."

1:50:42And I remember saying to him,

1:50:43"Okay, so it's running a stripped-down version

1:50:46of Mac OS X.

1:50:46I don't care how stripped down it is,

1:50:48it's gonna take forever to turn on.

1:50:50Like, how is that gonna work?"

1:50:52'Cause my current cell phone at the time,

1:50:54you could totally have it powered off,

1:50:56powered on, and it would be on in five seconds.

1:50:58And he just said, "You're thinking about it wrong.

1:51:02You're not going to turn it on and off.

1:51:04you're going to put it to sleep.

1:51:06And I was like, oh.

1:51:09But it's funny because here we are in 2017,

1:51:11and it actually doesn't take that long for an iPhone

1:51:14to turn on anymore.

1:51:15But the original one did take--

1:51:17I was correct.

1:51:18It did take forever to turn on.

1:51:21Something like 56 seconds, if I remember correctly.

1:51:23I think it took longer.

1:51:24I think it took over a minute.

1:51:25I think it was more than a minute.

1:51:27Well, you can still get that experience

1:51:29if you reboot your Apple Watch.

1:51:33- So true.

1:51:33Oh my God, upgrading your Apple Watch.

1:51:37It's still, is there anything worse

1:51:40in the entire Apple ecosystem

1:51:41than like a minor point upgrade to watchOS?

1:51:44'Cause you're not even gonna get like a major upgrade,

1:51:47you're really just getting like security fixes

1:51:49and bug fixes. - Bug fixes, yep.

1:51:50- And it takes forever.

1:51:54- So my fun story on that is I have iOS 11

1:52:00running on pretty much all of my iOS devices.

1:52:02I have High Sierra running in a partition on my Mac because I'm not stupid enough to install it wholesale, but I still do not have watchOS 4 because every time I go to install it, it either doesn't work or it's like, will take four and a half hours to download and install.

1:52:22Oh, the watch.

1:52:24That's that's that's something Apple could, you know, future future updates.

1:52:28Yeah, the watch easier to update.

1:52:30No, you know they will because it used to be so hard to update the phone.

1:52:33It'll be the same way because you used to have to plug it into your Mac and download it on your Mac

1:52:38and install it over. You couldn't do it right on the phone itself. It'll happen for the watch.

1:52:43And we'll all look back at these watch 1.0 and watch 2.0 days and laugh, but we're not there.

1:52:49We'll get stories. Yeah, we'll get stories from the creators of the

1:52:51watch at the Computer History Museum. It'll be great.

1:52:54Anyway, last but not least, I wanted to talk to you about just the overall experience,

1:53:00the experience of being at WWDC last week. I thought you had a great piece. I will,

1:53:04I promise, I swear to God, it's going into show notes. You had a good piece that you wrote,

1:53:09I think Friday? It was at the end of the week.

1:53:12Yeah, Friday as I was coming home, I was on the plane and I was just kind of, you know,

1:53:18free form thinking. There were a couple people who wrote some really nice ones, including

1:53:24Steve, Steven Hackett of Relay and a couple other folks.

1:53:28But it's, it was a really different conference than in many years.

1:53:33And it, I, you know, I go to WWDC and it's nice to, to see these people, you know, to see you and to see the other folks in the media, but also to see all of these developers and podcasters and friends that I've made through over the years at various events and throughout this community.

1:53:52But it's always one of those things where like it's always a rush right where you maybe see you see people at like 2 in the morning

1:53:58for drinks

1:54:01But the rest of the the rest of the week, it's just kind of like maybe you'll see them, you know in and out really quickly

1:54:06Whereas this year it felt like I got to spend a even being probably having it be one of the craziest

1:54:15WWDCs for me as a writer in recent memory. I feel like I was constantly

1:54:21amidst everybody.

1:54:23And part of it is just this,

1:54:25San Jose is not what I would call a crazy bustling city

1:54:30in the way that San Francisco is.

1:54:33San Jose almost reminds me a little more,

1:54:35I mean, it's a sleepy California town in a way,

1:54:39while still being a major American city.

1:54:41It just has this relaxed sort of atmosphere,

1:54:45or at least it did throughout the entire week,

1:54:48where almost, you know, there were restaurants,

1:54:51but there weren't so many that like you could go

1:54:54to a coffee shop and never run into anybody.

1:54:57Instead, I feel like everybody was

1:54:58at the same two coffee shops.

1:55:00So you would constantly be running into people

1:55:02that you knew, you'd constantly be getting

1:55:04these great conversations and not just, you know,

1:55:07not just people who, you know, you might end up

1:55:10for drinks with, but people who could never make it

1:55:12to the 2 a.m. drinks crowd, right?

1:55:14Or you've run into Apple engineers on their way

1:55:17from getting lunch and I don't know,

1:55:19it's the, one of the things that I always heard people say

1:55:22about the WWDC ticket was the sessions are great,

1:55:25but the reason why you buy the ticket

1:55:27is not for the sessions.

1:55:28You buy the ticket for the labs

1:55:30and you buy the ticket for the random chance encounters

1:55:32and the meetings and the waiting for the restroom line

1:55:36and joking there.

1:55:37And this year, it felt like the entirety of San Jose

1:55:43was the WWDC keynote hall or conference hall

1:55:47It's just like you were constantly running into people

1:55:49and making those amazing connections

1:55:51and having interesting discussions,

1:55:53whether you were at WWDC or outside or at Layers

1:55:57or at social policy, the coffee shop, it was great.

1:56:02- Yeah, social policy turned into

1:56:03like the second keynote hall.

1:56:07It was like-- - Oh, yeah.

1:56:09- But you wrote, when you originally booked your ticket,

1:56:12you were only staying until Tuesday

1:56:14because you were like, I don't know, maybe half these people are going to end up back

1:56:19in San Francisco by Tuesday afternoon.

1:56:21Yeah.

1:56:22Like, are people going to stay there?

1:56:23And it wasn't the case at all.

1:56:25No.

1:56:26And you're exactly right, too, to the point where I question how San Jose functions without

1:56:34WWDC.

1:56:36Because in that downtown area, it's a very nice layout, but it reminds me of a college

1:56:42campus.

1:56:43Yeah.

1:56:44It's more like a college campus and there's that park and there's you know

1:56:49The the Convention Center is at one end and there's the at least two of the hotels. There's a Marriott

1:56:56I forget the other one at Hilton, but they're right next to the Convention Center

1:56:59there's the park and all around that park is almost everything that you went to that the

1:57:04You know a couple of hotels

1:57:07The the Sunday night screening of the app the human story documentary was like just one block off from there

1:57:14You know like nothing was more than like one block away from that that park

1:57:18But every single person I saw everywhere was there for?

1:57:23WWDC or one of the ancillary things like layers or old conf or something like that

1:57:28So I don't even understand how that entire area functions when there's not a conference. I

1:57:33Mean I know there are

1:57:37there are tech companies that work just up the way, you know, there's Viv and there are a couple

1:57:42others sort of on that, on Mission Street, on San Jose's Mission Street.

1:57:45And Adobe's headquarters is very, very nearby.

1:57:47Yeah. Yeah, so it's, I mean, there are people and there are colleges nearby. But yeah, I don't know,

1:57:55maybe there are just a lot of conferences and that's how they run that area. Or maybe it just

1:58:01just happens to be a quiet spot for the folks

1:58:06who work on market to go get their lunch,

1:58:08and then this week it just turned into insanity.

1:58:12But it wasn't even, but that's a funny thing, right?

1:58:14It wasn't really even insanity.

1:58:16It was just the right amount of people

1:58:19to make that entire downtown area function.

1:58:21- And it seems like the conference,

1:58:26I forget what it's called, McHenry, whatever it's called.

1:58:29- The McHenry, yeah. - The McHenry Center

1:58:31has more square footage than Moscone West.

1:58:34I mean, I don't even think there's a question about it.

1:58:36- No.

1:58:37- And Apple really took advantage of that.

1:58:41I was on Jim Dalrymple's podcast

1:58:43and we recorded it in the,

1:58:46did you make it to the podcast?

1:58:47- I didn't, but Rene did.

1:58:49And he had a--

1:58:51- Gorgeous, absolutely.

1:58:52I figured it would just be like a little black box

1:58:56in the corner because that's all you need.

1:58:57You know what I mean?

1:58:58You don't need, it doesn't need to look good.

1:58:59But it was amazing because it overlooked this lounge

1:59:06that they had set up that was several thousand square foot.

1:59:09And while we were recording Wednesday afternoon

1:59:11or Thursday afternoon, whenever the hell it was,

1:59:16there must have been 1,100 to 1,500 WWDC attendees

1:59:20in this lounge one floor down that we were overlooking,

1:59:23just downloading betas and chilling.

1:59:26and just it was a type of space that there was nothing like that, no ability to create

1:59:32a space like that in Moscone West.

1:59:35I think, I mean Apple obviously doesn't say stuff like this.

1:59:40They don't say like, "We'll be back here next year.

1:59:42We'll find out when the WWDC is announced in April next year," or whenever the hell

1:59:46they announce it.

1:59:48But I would bet heavily that it's forever going to be in San Jose henceforth because

1:59:54it just-

1:59:55- It just feels way more Apple-y.

1:59:57Apple, it feels more natural to Apple.

2:00:01Apple got to control more of the experience

2:00:03within the convention hall,

2:00:05and they got to control way more of the experience

2:00:07in the surrounding neighborhood.

2:00:09That's the biggest difference.

2:00:11- Oh yeah.

2:00:12Being able to have all the WWDC banners on the signposts,

2:00:16I think, went around for at least a square mile

2:00:19was very, very impressive.

2:00:21- That said, I do feel, if I have a suggestion to Apple,

2:00:25it would be that they should reach out to local restaurants and bars.

2:00:30Yes.

2:00:31[laughter]

2:00:32And tell them to treat this whole week like a weekend.

2:00:36Yep. More staff, later hours.

2:00:40After... So my live show was on Tuesday.

2:00:43And my event horizon for that show is

2:00:48be ready to go and all I can think is

2:00:53be ready to go by 7 p.m. to actually step on stage

2:00:56and have questions ready,

2:00:58and don't make a fool of yourself

2:01:01for the next hour or 90 minutes, and then that's it.

2:01:05Once that show is over,

2:01:06I have no idea what the hell is going on.

2:01:08It was over, it seemed like it was a success.

2:01:12I felt like it was a really good show.

2:01:14I really liked it.

2:01:15Phil and Craig hung around for a little bit,

2:01:18and we talked backstage, and it was all very fun.

2:01:21And next thing you know, they leave.

2:01:25And I wrapped up.

2:01:27I dot the i's, crossed the t's with the event staff

2:01:32in the theater.

2:01:34And there was about six of us.

2:01:35It was like me and Amy and Paul Kefastis,

2:01:38who did a great job announcing the show,

2:01:41and a couple of other people.

2:01:43But we needed dinner.

2:01:44And all of a sudden-- and I'm famished all of a sudden.

2:01:46Because I had lunch like eight hours before.

2:01:49And--

2:01:49Yeah, you're on stage time.

2:01:51Yeah.

2:01:51and I only pecked at it.

2:01:53So we needed to go eat.

2:01:54And Paul found a place, and it looked good,

2:01:57and it was, I don't know, a quarter mile away,

2:02:00a third of a mile away, not too far, nothing down there.

2:02:03But they're open 'til midnight,

2:02:04and it was like, so we could make it easily.

2:02:07And so we get there at 10.25.

2:02:09I remember this very specifically.

2:02:11It was 95 minutes before their closing time.

2:02:14We get there, and the woman is putting the chairs

2:02:18up on the tables, and she goes, "Oh, we're closed."

2:02:21and Paul says, "But you're open till midnight."

2:02:24And she goes, "That's what the last guy said."

2:02:26(laughing)

2:02:28And clearly meaning somebody who was just there

2:02:30like a minute or two before.

2:02:31- Yeah.

2:02:32- And who thought that maybe they would be open

2:02:35until their stated closing time

2:02:37or even close to their stated closing time.

2:02:41- God forbid.

2:02:42- We just close our kitchen whenever it gets slow.

2:02:45And it's like, that's not how hours work.

2:02:48(laughing)

2:02:50Well, there's your answer about how the town survives when WWDC is not in town.

2:02:54Right, they just closed.

2:02:55[Laughter]

2:02:58Yeah, yeah. Thankfully, I did not have as many late hours as I did this year as I have in previous years.

2:03:06But we definitely ran into that once or twice, you know, going to some place for dinner and having it be like,

2:03:12"Oh, out of the office for a few hours, had to go," you know, as I said, it feels like very small town California in some ways.

2:03:20So maybe if the city can just be like,

2:03:23"Hey, local businesses, we'll make it

2:03:26"so that you make more money than you probably will

2:03:28"all year otherwise."

2:03:29- Yeah, just treat Sunday, Monday, and Tuesday of that week

2:03:33like a weekend and you'll be fine.

2:03:36- Yeah, exactly.

2:03:37- Don't treat it like a typical Monday,

2:03:38'cause it's not going to be a typical Monday.

2:03:41- No, if you're closed on Monday, maybe stay open.

2:03:44- No, anyway, but I do think it was great,

2:03:46I really, really enjoyed just the fact that it seemed like everybody who you ran into

2:03:53was there for WWDC.

2:03:57It was really great.

2:04:00Or if they weren't, they soon became part of WWDC.

2:04:04Yeah, and I would bet.

2:04:08Again, I have no inside knowledge.

2:04:10Nobody...

2:04:11It wasn't like I asked Phil Schiller backstage, "Hey, are we coming back here next year?"

2:04:15because I knew he wouldn't answer.

2:04:17So nobody said anything to me,

2:04:18but I would be shocked almost if it wasn't in San Jose

2:04:23going forward, because it just seems to me

2:04:25like it was a rousing success.

2:04:27- I hope it is.

2:04:28And on a personal fun note,

2:04:31one of the really cool things about San Jose is it's flat

2:04:36and relatively easy to get around, as you said,

2:04:40like all of the venues are kind of

2:04:42within half a mile of each other.

2:04:44I had my roller skates for some demos,

2:04:47and I ended up spending the last two days of the conference

2:04:50just going from place to place on my skates,

2:04:54and that is the best time, hands down,

2:04:57that I've ever had going from building to building

2:05:00at a conference, and if they do it in San Jose again,

2:05:02I'm like, "I'm bringing my skates."

2:05:04- And if they bring it back to San Francisco,

2:05:06you'd kill yourself.

2:05:08- Yeah, oh yeah.

2:05:09I have skated in San Francisco precisely once,

2:05:13and it was awful. - You'd achieve

2:05:14Escape velocity.

2:05:15Right?

2:05:16Yeah, you don't, there are certain hills, certain streets, you're just like, "No,

2:05:20that's not going to work."

2:05:22Very, very, nobody has ever described San Francisco as a very flat city.

2:05:25No, not so much.

2:05:30Thank you so much, Serenity.

2:05:31I always appreciate having you on the show.

2:05:33Everybody can read your fine writing at iMore.

2:05:36You did a terrific, is the transcript up?

2:05:39Do we have the transcript?

2:05:40The transcript is up, yes.

2:05:42it will be, it is 90% finished,

2:05:46it will be fully finished by the time that this show is live.

2:05:48- So Serenity was kind enough over at iMore.

2:05:51I will have a link to it in the show notes.

2:05:53There's a full transcript of the live show from last week.

2:05:56And people can follow you on Twitter at,

2:06:00what's your Twitter handle?

2:06:02- Saturn, S-E-T-T-E-R-N.

2:06:04- There we go.

2:06:06Thank you so much for your time.

2:06:07Always good to have you on the show.