Podcast Search

The Talk Show

192: ‘The Original Sin Is XML’ With Special Guests Manton Reece and Brent Simmons

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Alright, we've got a super special episode of the show.

0:00:04We've got two guests.

0:00:05Double your pleasure, double your fun.

0:00:08What was that chewing gum called?

0:00:10Doublemint?

0:00:12Remember Doublemint? - Doublemint, maybe, yeah.

0:00:14- It was always-- - Remember the ads?

0:00:16- Yeah, it was always like you'd get like,

0:00:18it was like two twin teenagers, boys or girls,

0:00:21would get double the pleasure out of,

0:00:24I guess like a shared piece of gum or something.

0:00:26(laughing)

0:00:28Brent Simmons, longtime friend of the show,

0:00:31and Manton Reese, who's a longtime friend of me,

0:00:33but I don't think has ever been on the show before.

0:00:36- No, thanks for having me.

0:00:37- And I got both of you on,

0:00:40because you guys both have new stuff that's come out,

0:00:43some of it you've collaborated on,

0:00:45and it's all sort of interrelated.

0:00:48It makes, I think it makes a lot more sense

0:00:50to have you guys on together than separately.

0:00:52- Yeah, I think so too.

0:00:54I've described Manton and me in a way as litter mates.

0:00:58You know, we kind of came up around the same time

0:01:00and we have a lot of the same values and, you know,

0:01:0290s scripting and web and Mac and all that good stuff.

0:01:07So it's not surprised that we're still, you know,

0:01:10collaborating on stuff so many years later.

0:01:14- So one of the things,

0:01:15it's not even one of the major announcements, I mean,

0:01:16but I'll just list them up front.

0:01:18We've got a JSON feed,

0:01:20which is a new format for syndication of content in JSON format.

0:01:25We've got micro.blog, which is a microblogging platform

0:01:30that Manton just launched about a month ago.

0:01:35We've got other cool stuff related to feeds, Brent.

0:01:39But then one of the other things you're working on right now, Brent,

0:01:41is you are working on a modernization or just getting Frontier to run again.

0:01:48Well, it really is pretty much a ground up rewrite.

0:01:52You know, I have the old source code that, you know, with me and I can

0:01:56do a build on a 10.6.8 virtual machine, but otherwise I'm rewriting it

0:02:01almost entirely in Swift.

0:02:03So it's, you know, it's going to be all new code or almost all new code.

0:02:08And man, you were a big Frontier user back in the day, right?

0:02:11I was absolutely.

0:02:13I built a bunch of web related things in Frontier and

0:02:18gosh, it's so long ago now, but yeah, I was a big fan of the design,

0:02:21how it thought about scripting integrated with the database.

0:02:26It's just a great platform. I'm glad to see it's getting some new life.

0:02:30Maybe some new people will discover it.

0:02:32So one of you guys take this. At a high level, can you explain to somebody

0:02:36who doesn't know what Frontier was? And I think it's fair at this point

0:02:39to talk about it in the past tense, because it doesn't, right now, today,

0:02:42it doesn't really run on a modern platform, even though there's...

0:02:46It's complicated, right?

0:02:48- It is.

0:02:49- Old code never dies completely,

0:02:50but can somebody take a high level overview

0:02:53of just what Frontier was?

0:02:54- I can give that a try.

0:02:58I'm so close to it though,

0:02:59that I don't know if I've ever been good at this.

0:03:02At a high level, it's a scripting system

0:03:05with a database and a user interface.

0:03:08So it makes persistence really, really easy.

0:03:12'Cause the database is tables

0:03:14which can contain objects and other tables,

0:03:17and it's schema-less.

0:03:19So storing stuff forever is just as easy as using key paths,

0:03:24which then map to locations in the database.

0:03:28So foo.bar.x equals, you know, whatever you want it to be,

0:03:32a string or a number or an outline

0:03:34or any number of different things.

0:03:37And for some reason, that just makes development

0:03:41really, really rapid and really fun, really easy.

0:03:45There's more to it than that, but that's a high level.

0:03:48- So one of the things, it sounds so trivial,

0:03:51and for people out there, and again,

0:03:53I don't wanna bore anybody,

0:03:54I'm not gonna turn it into a programming podcast,

0:03:55but the persistence of data was literally non-trivial,

0:04:00I mean, trivial in Frontier.

0:04:06It was as easy to store something permanently to disk

0:04:09by writing it to the object database as it was to write it to a temporary variable that

0:04:14it dies when the script stops running.

0:04:17Yeah, absolutely right. Yeah. As you're typing, there's no difference between a local variable

0:04:23and a persistent location.

0:04:28Even a programming language like Perl, which is the language I'm personally most familiar

0:04:33with and which is famous or infamous depending on your perspective for making it possible to be a

0:04:41very very terse and write minimal lines of code to do the most things. Just to write something to

0:04:48a file at a minimum is still three or four lines of code where you get a file handle to a path in

0:04:54the file system and then you open the file and test to make sure that it worked and then you can

0:05:00print to the file handle and whatever you print to the file handle be written to the file. Whereas in

0:05:05Frontier, you literally would just pick a name for your object, you know, whatever dot whatever dot

0:05:12whatever equals foo and then later on whatever dot whatever dot whatever you can read from it and it

0:05:17says foo. Yeah, yeah, it's literally no harder than just, you know, assigning a value to a local

0:05:24variable. Just as easy as that. And it came out—originally, Frontier came out, as I recall,

0:05:31around 1992 or so? '92? I guess I could have done some research here. But it seems very strange to

0:05:41me, and sad in some ways, that here we are 25 years later, and there's nothing that easy. There are

0:05:48certain things that Frontier made easy, that 25 years later, there's nothing that fills that void.

0:05:54Yeah, that's right. I like to think of it as an artifact from an alternate universe. If programming

0:06:00and scripting had gone another way, you know, Frontier might be, you know, one of the most

0:06:07important apps on the platform, and there might be a lot of imitators. But we kind of stuck with the,

0:06:13you know, here's your text file on disk, and we're reading and writing to files kind of way.

0:06:21where our frontier is, you know,

0:06:23I think the technical term might be image-based

0:06:26because you're actually in an environment with a database

0:06:29rather than separate files on disc for everything.

0:06:32- Yeah, exactly.

0:06:34- There was something about,

0:06:34I don't think I even appreciated at the time,

0:06:37you know, the thing about the language being integrated

0:06:40with the database until years later,

0:06:42like you said, it's been like 20 years

0:06:44and we still don't really have that.

0:06:46If you want to build a web app today, for example,

0:06:49You pick a language, Ruby, whatever, Python, Perl,

0:06:52and then you pick like, oh, I need to get the MySQL library

0:06:56in or some other database framework.

0:06:58They're all still very separated.

0:07:00Even on other platforms, you have core data

0:07:02or something was like the official way,

0:07:04love it or hate it.

0:07:05That's like the official way to do database work

0:07:08on the Mac or iOS, but it's still very separate.

0:07:11There's no, I mean, it's not tightly integrated

0:07:13in the way that Frontier was.

0:07:16Right, it's like every language, I mean,

0:07:20I'm sure you can go back 50, 60 years

0:07:22and there's some weird language where you had to,

0:07:24but every language has built in arithmetic operators.

0:07:28So if you've got two integers, you

0:07:31can just use the integer name variable plus the other one,

0:07:35and you get the sum of the two numbers.

0:07:37It would be an enormous pain in the ass

0:07:39if you had to write three or four lines of code

0:07:41to import arithmetic library and call

0:07:45like a PLUS plus function just to add two integers.

0:07:50But that's still sort of the way

0:07:51that we kind of have to do file IO with everything.

0:07:54And I love the Unix scripting system.

0:07:57I write stuff in Perl all the time.

0:07:59And there's lots of ways where that's great,

0:08:02but the fact that that's kind of all we're left with today

0:08:04is sort of sad.

0:08:05- Yeah. - Yeah.

0:08:07Especially since every modern app,

0:08:09especially web apps,

0:08:10needs some kind of database persistence.

0:08:12I mean, it's very rare that you have an app

0:08:14that's so lightweight that it doesn't need any database or file, I/O at all.

0:08:20The other thing historically that was interesting about the timing of Frontier, so Frontier

0:08:24comes out in 1992 or so, early 90s, and that's before the web, and was mostly about automating

0:08:30stuff on the Mac. Originally it was Mac only, eventually there was a Windows version. But

0:08:35obviously the big story of the 90s was the web, and Frontier quickly shifted to becoming

0:08:44a place where people would generate,

0:08:48create their own, it wasn't necessarily a content management system,

0:08:52but you could use it to make content management systems. And that's probably

0:08:56Manton, where you really got involved with it.

0:09:00It kind of, I don't think I used it before it kind of

0:09:04pivoted a little bit toward the web. Because like Frontier used

0:09:08to be a commercial, you know, buy the box in the store

0:09:12software package and at the source there's difficulties with that because now you're

0:09:16competing with AppleScript and other things as Apple, you know, HyperCard, all those kind

0:09:21of scripting environments at the time.

0:09:22And at some point, and Brent maybe remembers the details, but it switched to now it's open

0:09:28source and there's a lot more web frameworks and kind of embracing that and trying to find,

0:09:33you know, just a new set of people that can be using Frontier for web apps and for websites.

0:09:41So,

0:09:45we've got so many things to talk about. Let's talk about

0:09:49I'll let you guys pick. Do you want to talk about micro.blog

0:09:53first or do you want to talk about JSON feed first? Which one do you think makes sense to talk about first before

0:09:57we talk about the other? I like JSON feed. I mean that's

0:10:01we've been focused on that the last couple weeks. Let's talk about that.

0:10:05Alright, so Brent, tell me what JSON feed is.

0:10:09JSON feed is like RSS or Atom, but it's in JSON, and it has a few more features that

0:10:19are needed these days that didn't exist in RSS and Atom.

0:10:23But the main point of it, I think, is still the JSON-ness of it.

0:10:27XML is something that people hate working with.

0:10:30They do a lousy job of generating feeds, and everybody just prefers JSON.

0:10:35So hey, let's do this in JSON.

0:10:38JSON is, what's it called?

0:10:41What's it stand for?

0:10:42JavaScript object notation, I think.

0:10:45Yeah.

0:10:46But basically, it's just a way of very simply defining either--

0:10:53I think that the JavaScript term is dictionary.

0:10:56Other languages would call it a hash,

0:10:57but where you have these key value pairs, where

0:11:00there's a name of the thing and then the value of the thing.

0:11:03And you can have a whole list of them in an object.

0:11:07and you can have arrays.

0:11:08And you don't have to be a programming expert

0:11:11to know what an array is.

0:11:11It's just if you have an array of 10 items,

0:11:14it's just a list of 10 items, and the order matters.

0:11:16And it's, you can have,

0:11:20what makes it a little bit more complicated than that

0:11:23is that you can have a dictionary

0:11:24where one of the objects of the dictionary

0:11:26is another dictionary or an array,

0:11:28and so it can get hierarchical and go deeper

0:11:32to have nested data structures.

0:11:34But basically, at a high level, that's it,

0:11:37and it's very simple and you can look at it as a human

0:11:41and kind of get the gist of exactly what it is

0:11:45and what it means.

0:11:46- Yeah, it's not difficult to read.

0:11:49And at a programming level,

0:11:50it's super easy to read and write too,

0:11:53which kind of covers all bases.

0:11:55- Right, and one of the things that I feel like

0:11:58is essential to it is that even though

0:12:00it's based on JavaScript syntax

0:12:02and a JavaScript implementation that reads or writes JSON

0:12:06can literally just read the JSON file.

0:12:09And if it's a valid JSON file, just

0:12:11interpret it right through the JavaScript interpreter.

0:12:13You don't have to process it in any way.

0:12:16It's not specific to JavaScript.

0:12:18It has been quickly adopted by every single programming

0:12:22platform that is in use today.

0:12:24It has built-in JSON parsers and generators.

0:12:29It is, again, trivial is often a dangerous word

0:12:34use in programming, but it's generally trivial in any modern programming environment to generate

0:12:41or consume JSON.

0:12:44Often just one line of code for either.

0:12:47Yep.

0:12:48Very simple.

0:12:49That's not true for XML.

0:12:52And obviously there are many, many very well-known and well-done XML libraries, but it is definitely

0:13:04not as one line away as JSON is.

0:13:10And it's proven in the-- well, when did XML first

0:13:15come into being?

0:13:16Probably the late '90s, right?

0:13:18Yeah.

0:13:19It's roughly 20 years old.

0:13:20So I mean, with 20 years of experience under a belt,

0:13:23we can safely say, even 20 years in,

0:13:28there's an awful lot of broken XML out there.

0:13:31And Brent, you can speak to that in your history

0:13:34as somebody who's written a very popular feed reader,

0:13:39NetNewswire, for those of you who don't remember,

0:13:41was originally Brent's product,

0:13:44and reads RSS feeds and Atom feeds.

0:13:47And what percentage of feeds out there do you think

0:13:50had some sort of XML error?

0:13:53- No, I haven't thought in that terms, but it's a lot.

0:13:57I mean, character encoding errors

0:14:00are especially pernicious.

0:14:01They appear all the time.

0:14:03people are building their RSS using a template or whatever, not an actual XML writer which would

0:14:10handle all of this stuff for them. And so feeds are just screwed up a thousand different ways.

0:14:16It's super common. And so yeah, I was always working around those kinds of bugs.

0:14:21So the chase on feed launch, you guys, the spec for it is bylined by both of you.

0:14:32It's, I think, Manton Reese and Brent Simmons.

0:14:35I have a cheat code, because the three of us

0:14:42are on a Slack group together.

0:14:45This was hashed over in advance.

0:14:47So I've been aware of JSON feed far months before it was

0:14:51actually announced, and I've read the spec

0:14:53and gave you guys some feedback on typos and stuff like that.

0:14:59But Manton, tell me, what got you interested?

0:15:01because I think it was Brent's idea first, if I recall my history from this, like it was originally Brent's idea,

0:15:07but Manton, you obviously jumped in far enough that you became a full on, you know, 50/50 collaborator on the spec.

0:15:14Yeah, I was actually thinking about this and I looked back on some of the emails and actually Brent and I exchanged a couple emails about this as far back as 2015.

0:15:25There was a couple emails kind of loosely related to this.

0:15:30And I thought about it because I think a lot of people

0:15:33when they look at JSON feed, especially at an example JSON,

0:15:37which is just so much more clear and readable and simple

0:15:40than XML and RSS feeds, like you said,

0:15:45I think that some people are kind of fooled into thinking

0:15:47it was just like whipped together really quickly,

0:15:48the spec and put out there.

0:15:51And so I was kind of curious

0:15:52how long we've been talking about it.

0:15:53And we just briefly exchanged email way, way back.

0:15:56But then in earnest at the beginning of this year,

0:15:58Brent said, you know what?

0:16:00The time is right.

0:16:01This is a good time.

0:16:03Let's talk about this.

0:16:04Let's think through a spec, see what it would look like

0:16:08and see if it has a place in the open web.

0:16:11And I'm so glad he did because it's,

0:16:15I really do think the time is right.

0:16:16And a lot of the feedback we get from people is,

0:16:20wow, I got an, actually I got an email yesterday

0:16:23from someone said, oh, we wanted this at our company 10 years ago.

0:16:26We were hoping someone would do this.

0:16:28And now finally, you know, it's here.

0:16:30Hmm.

0:16:30Uh, I kept expecting someone to do it too.

0:16:34I, you know, yeah, for 10 years at least I thought, wow, surely

0:16:38this will happen at some point.

0:16:39And then we realized, well, I guess we're the people to make it happen.

0:16:44Well, okay, fine.

0:16:45There's a, uh, of infinite, I mean, a whole bunch of XKCD comics are very

0:16:51but there's one in particular and we've seen it pop up probably once a day every day since

0:16:56JSON Feed comes up where somebody first sees JSON Feed and there's an XKCD comic. I will

0:17:01put it in the show notes, I swear. But the gist of it is that somebody says, "Hey, there's

0:17:0514 competing standards in this space. That's a mess. This is a terrible idea. Let's come

0:17:10up with a brand new universal format, a spec that'll be the one true spec." And then the

0:17:16third panel is, "Now we have 15 competing specs in this space." And people think they're

0:17:21being very clever when they mention this in the context of JSON feed but my

0:17:25objection to it it's a funny comic I get it but my objection to it in the context

0:17:30of JSON feed is that JSON feed is in no way in in if you read the spec itself if

0:17:36you read what you both of you have written about it and and your interest

0:17:39in it it is not meant as the let's stop using RSS and Adam and whatever else

0:17:47might be obvious. It is meant to be the 15th thing in this field that addresses

0:17:52new issues or does things better that the other ones can't do but isn't meant

0:17:58to replace them. Is that fair? Yeah, that is fair. In fact, the spec itself has

0:18:03some wording to the effect of, you know, if you can only do one kind of feed, pick

0:18:07RSS because it's been around a long time, because it's good, because it's, you know,

0:18:12well-tested, supported all over the place.

0:18:16So we're not saying that any other format should go away

0:18:19and we're not trying to be the one universal format.

0:18:21It is what it is, which is a pragmatic JSON-based format.

0:18:26- Yeah, and I think that's important

0:18:30because some of the feedback, the negative feedback

0:18:34we've heard is that it doesn't try to solve all problems.

0:18:37And some people would like it to solve more problems

0:18:40and be an even more flexible and kind of advanced format.

0:18:43But then that introduces complexity and other issues.

0:18:46And then you're kind of back where you started in some way.

0:18:48And it doesn't try to do that.

0:18:50It really clear prioritizes, like I said, clarity,

0:18:54just making it really simple to implement.

0:18:56It doesn't try to solve everything.

0:18:58So yeah, that comic is funny.

0:18:59I laugh, I laugh the first few times I saw that.

0:19:02I don't laugh quite as much the 10th or 15th time

0:19:07I've seen someone post it,

0:19:07but it's not quite accurate

0:19:10and then JSON feed doesn't attempt to do everything.

0:19:14It just tries to solve a few problems

0:19:16and make it really clear.

0:19:18And the whole idea, I mean, if we're glossing over it is,

0:19:21now things are kind of stuck.

0:19:23We could use kind of just a little kickstart

0:19:28in the open web standards, new feed readers,

0:19:32just people even just thinking and kind of talking

0:19:35about web standards and feeds and feed readers,

0:19:39I think is a win.

0:19:40- Yeah. - Yeah, for sure.

0:19:42- I totally agree with that.

0:19:44And I think in the handful of weeks

0:19:47since JSON feed was announced, the uptake,

0:19:50I was very optimistic about JSON feed.

0:19:53There was something about it that just looking at it,

0:19:55I thought I just smelled a winner.

0:19:58I think when I linked to it on during Fireball,

0:19:59I said something to the effect of,

0:20:01I had the same feeling about it,

0:20:04even though it's not my creation,

0:20:05but I had that same feeling about it

0:20:06that I did about Markdown back in 2002 or 2003,

0:20:10whenever it was that I first released Markdown.

0:20:13I just thought when you guys finished it

0:20:17and it was very close to the end,

0:20:18I looked at it and I'm like,

0:20:19this smells like a winner to me,

0:20:21because I think that if I hadn't been behind the scenes

0:20:24reading this back for months beforehand,

0:20:26if it had just popped into my news as a new thing,

0:20:30I thought I would look at this and I would think,

0:20:32oh, that's cool.

0:20:33I should quick add that to Daring Fireball.

0:20:35That wouldn't take much work.

0:20:36And that's exactly what happened with a bunch of people

0:20:38we know, like Jason Snell at Six Colors.

0:20:42The day that it was announced-- he didn't know it was coming.

0:20:45The day that it's announced, he's

0:20:46working on adding it to Six Colors, which

0:20:50still runs on movable type.

0:20:51And he ran into a very small problem with JSON encoding

0:20:56his strings for values.

0:20:58And so I quick put together-- it's the first movable type

0:21:01I've written in, I think, 15 years.

0:21:03But it was very-- it's super, super small.

0:21:06It is literally like-- it's way more comments than code.

0:21:09It's just three or four lines of code to get--

0:21:12and JSON string encoding is super simple.

0:21:15There's not a lot of rules.

0:21:16It's not like XML.

0:21:17It's very simple.

0:21:18You pretty much just need to backslash escape

0:21:21your actual double quotes, because the string is

0:21:25enclosed by double quotes.

0:21:27So every actual double quote in your string

0:21:29string needs to be encoded, and you take out

0:21:32all your white space.

0:21:33So if you have a tab in your character,

0:21:35you just put a backslash T in, and a return is a backslash N.

0:21:40And so literally, Jason Snell had a JSON feed.

0:21:43He'd never heard of it.

0:21:44And within two hours of hearing about it,

0:21:46and a little bit of work for me, he had a working JSON feed

0:21:50on his site.

0:21:52Manton, you helped create a WordPress plugin

0:21:56that was there on day one.

0:21:57And all, I mean, I lost count,

0:21:59I very quickly lost count of how many sites had JSON feeds

0:22:03within 24 hours of the announcement.

0:22:05And I thought that was pretty cool.

0:22:07- Yeah, this response has been incredible.

0:22:10And you're right about the like the encoding issues

0:22:13and just the simplicity.

0:22:14I mean, one of the problems with XML is that

0:22:17it's hard to put HTML inside XML

0:22:19because they're the same, right?

0:22:21And so you have to escape everything

0:22:24and that's really easy to get wrong.

0:22:26And if you just pull up a default RSS feed from a website,

0:22:31it's a little bit of a disaster.

0:22:33I mean, it's a mix of a lot of things.

0:22:35There's some RSS, there's some Adam in there sometimes,

0:22:38and there's at least two or three ways

0:22:40to put HTML in a feed.

0:22:43And with JSON, it's just way simpler.

0:22:46We have content_html field,

0:22:50you put HTML in it and everything's good.

0:22:54- So I think the original sin is XML itself.

0:22:59I think XML, and this is, in some ways,

0:23:03it's gonna be controversial, maybe,

0:23:05but I think it was a disaster for our entire industry.

0:23:09I think basically, this is my theory of what happened,

0:23:12is that the web became such a sensational,

0:23:17explosive success where like 1994, nobody had heard of it.

0:23:231995 technical people had heard of it,

0:23:26and by 1996 everybody was on the web.

0:23:29And it's crazy.

0:23:31Microsoft famously, Bill Gates wrote this memo

0:23:35that was like, we're currently at mid-90s,

0:23:39the most successful company in the history of the world,

0:23:41and we're completely shifting our entire,

0:23:43everything we do is entirely focused on the internet

0:23:45all of a sudden.

0:23:46We totally missed this and we're shifting

0:23:48the biggest company in the world to be internet focused.

0:23:50And it worked for them, right?

0:23:51It was the right move.

0:23:54And I feel like everybody was so obsessed with the web, and the web is all based on

0:23:59HTML, and they were like, "Well, now let's do everything like HTML, and let's make a

0:24:06data serialization format that is like HTML, where you've got these tags that are set by

0:24:11angle brackets that enclose whatever it is they represent, and then you end them with

0:24:18the same type of tag."

0:24:19And like you said, Ben, XML and HTML pretty much are the same basic idea.

0:24:24There was the whole disaster that we went through where they literally—we spent like

0:24:2810 years of standards process trying to get HTML to become XHTML, which was the bastard

0:24:36baby of XML and HTML.

0:24:39And which eventually—

0:24:40And that failed, thank goodness.

0:24:42Right, it failed.

0:24:46And HTML5, which is what we have wound up with,

0:24:49which is much better, pretty much went completely

0:24:52around that XHTML standards process.

0:24:56But it's exactly like you said.

0:24:58In some ways, it's such a bad idea,

0:24:59because it's like you've got XML,

0:25:02and it's got the same rules as HTML.

0:25:04But a lot of what you want to encode,

0:25:06whether it's in feeds or any other use of XML,

0:25:11if you're using an XML data format,

0:25:13if your content is HTML, it's a disaster.

0:25:18It really is.

0:25:19And it looks, it's almost impossible for a human

0:25:21to look at it and see if it looks right.

0:25:25- Yep, and even writing software for it.

0:25:29I mean, I think my code works properly

0:25:32for all those different kinds of feeds,

0:25:34but there's so many like decode this and then decode this,

0:25:37and it's just much more complicated than it needs to be.

0:25:40There's so many places you can get it wrong.

0:25:42Yeah, and then, you know, you may have it right in your code, but there's going to be feeds or

0:25:48documents, whatever they're, that are going to have it wrong on their end. And then your users

0:25:54are going to notice and report it as a bug. And pretty soon you're writing, you know, workarounds

0:25:58to handle buggy, you know, documents and feeds and so on. And it gets messy. I think, I think

0:26:07the central theme of a lot of this is idealism versus practicality. Is that the opposite of

0:26:15idealism? What's a good word for that, Brent? Pragmatism. Pragmatism is a good word.

0:26:22And so XML is a very idealistic format, in my opinion, because it is literally, it stands for

0:26:34for extensible markup language, I believe,

0:26:37but it is extensible.

0:26:40It can and is, in the real world,

0:26:42being used for just about anything you could imagine.

0:26:46But it's so complicated because it's so ambitious

0:26:50and because it aimed to be able to represent or to model just

0:26:53about anything you could throw at it.

0:26:57And so people say, like in your announcement--

0:26:59and I read the whole Hacker News thread on it.

0:27:02I know you guys--

0:27:03Wow.

0:27:04You guys did not.

0:27:05Thanks for doing that, Fred.

0:27:07If it was my thing, I would not have been able to do it.

0:27:10Like, if it was my baby, if JSON feed were my baby,

0:27:13I would not have read the Hacker News feed.

0:27:15Or I would have read the first two lines

0:27:17and then closed the tab.

0:27:18I imagine 100 links to that same XKCD comic.

0:27:22I think it came up at least three times.

0:27:24And it was one of the deeper threads,

0:27:26because the first one who did it, I swear,

0:27:28it's a really deep thread with all the people who are like,

0:27:31Damn it, I was just about to post that.

0:27:33(laughing)

0:27:35But one of the bits of pushback on this would be,

0:27:41and I've seen this repeated several times, I'll paraphrase,

0:27:44which is you guys are presenting JSON feed as easier

0:27:49and less error prone to generate and parse than XML.

0:27:54And people are saying, the response is,

0:27:56if you're having problems parsing and generating XML,

0:28:01the solution isn't to create another format in a different language. How about you fix your XML

0:28:05generators and parsers? So XML, you know, it was early enough when XML came out that

0:28:12people didn't really know how developers would behave in as a giant mass. And the fact is,

0:28:21they're just not going to always behave all that well because people are, you know, they have

0:28:25budgets, they have deadlines, they have different skill levels. So people aren't necessarily going

0:28:32to do the right thing. So it's important to keep that in mind and use formats that are

0:28:40a whole lot easier so that the burden isn't on each individual developer.

0:28:44Right. And that the fact is, this isn't going to like that question, like, why don't you just fix,

0:28:52X, it's not gonna change.

0:28:54I mean, even if you think back,

0:28:56like we were talking about Brent working on that newswire,

0:28:58it's been a number of years

0:28:59since Brent worked on that newswire.

0:29:01Guess how much has changed since then with RSS feeds?

0:29:04Nothing, nothing's changed.

0:29:06Nothing has changed with feed parsing and tools.

0:29:10It's basically same thing.

0:29:12And so I think that would continue.

0:29:14Nothing would change without someone

0:29:17kind of putting something new out there

0:29:19and getting people to talk about it.

0:29:21- XML is old enough.

0:29:24In fact, I think it's long past old enough,

0:29:26and I think it speaks to you guys saying

0:29:27that you kind of expected something like JSON feed

0:29:29to appear 10 years ago.

0:29:31And in hindsight, it does.

0:29:33It feels like a real head scratcher that it didn't.

0:29:35I would say by 10 years ago, XML was settled enough

0:29:40that we can see how it's used in the real world,

0:29:42and in the real world, it's often broken.

0:29:45And that's just a statement of fact.

0:29:47And you can say it shouldn't be.

0:29:50You can say that all these people generating malformed XML

0:29:54or subtly malformed or questionable XML,

0:29:56that they should fix their tool chain.

0:29:59I guess that's correct.

0:30:02There's all sorts of things the world should do though.

0:30:03We should all exercise every day.

0:30:05We should stop drinking beer.

0:30:09There's all sorts of things that we could do

0:30:10that should be better,

0:30:12but that don't reflect the way people actually behave.

0:30:15- In fact, it's because of XML

0:30:18that I don't exercise enough and drink too much beer.

0:30:20(laughing)

0:30:22- Here's my favorite anecdote.

0:30:25I keep, maybe, but hopefully, in fact, I guarantee it,

0:30:28by the time this podcast airs,

0:30:30this will be a post on Daring Fireball,

0:30:32is, in terms of it being easier to generate.

0:30:37And again, I think that there are people who,

0:30:42if you're already comfortable with your RSS

0:30:47an atom parsing.

0:30:49You're responsible for some product or service

0:30:51that consumes RSS feeds.

0:30:53And you have a working system that consumes these feeds.

0:30:56And you look at JSON feed.

0:30:58I'm not saying you YouTube,

0:30:59but you, this hypothetical person who wishes there weren't

0:31:02another new standard.

0:31:03You say, well, now you've just given me more work to do

0:31:05because I have to add support for this new thing

0:31:07and I already had this thing working.

0:31:09And it's not that hard to consume XML,

0:31:14that you should be able to do it.

0:31:16I disagree, and I think it depends on which platform you're using, but the real eye-opener

0:31:21for me was Workflow, which is the iOS automation system.

0:31:27It's sort of like Automator for iOS, and it was actually recently acquired by Apple with

0:31:34a lot of publicity.

0:31:36It's a totally different discussion as to whether Apple's going to keep it going as

0:31:39an actively developed product or integrate it into iOS somehow or what they're going

0:31:43to do.

0:31:44I don't know.

0:31:45now, it's still in the App Store. It was not like, "Hey, we got acquired by Apple and

0:31:50now it's left out to die." They've actually had a couple of updates since the acquisition.

0:31:55And basically what you can do with Workflow is you create these—they call them workflows—and

0:32:02you drag actions. It's a visual way of programming. And maybe there's Workflow users who don't

0:32:06think of it as programming, but it is. It's a visual way, though. And you drag these things

0:32:10like an action would be get URL, and you give it a URL,

0:32:16and when it runs, it'll go out on the web

0:32:19and get the content of whatever that URL is.

0:32:23And then you drag an action beneath it,

0:32:25and it can do something with it.

0:32:28So here, like a stupid example would be you could get a URL,

0:32:32and it, say, returns text.

0:32:35And it's just plain text.

0:32:36And then you could have an action underneath it

0:32:38that says reverse the text.

0:32:40And it would turn Brent into-- how do you reverse Brent?

0:32:44I'm terrible at this.

0:32:45This is a terrible example.

0:32:46T--

0:32:47Tnerb.

0:32:47T-N-E-R-B, Tnerb.

0:32:50And maybe there's an action to speak the text.

0:32:52So you could have three things in a row, get a URL,

0:32:54and it returns a string, reverse the string,

0:32:57and then speak it aloud through your iPhone or iPad speakers.

0:33:01And you haven't written a line of code.

0:33:03You've dragged these three things out.

0:33:06You string them in order.

0:33:07and the results of each one get passed down the chain.

0:33:12And there's other systems.

0:33:14Automator works the same way.

0:33:16But workflow has proved to be quite popular with the iOS

0:33:21enthusiasts set.

0:33:23And it works around certain shortcomings, in my opinion,

0:33:26on the platform, like the fact that there is no scripting

0:33:29system on iOS like there is on Mac OS.

0:33:33And anyway, where this ties into JSON feed

0:33:36is Federico Vitici of MacStories,

0:33:40and arguably the most well-known workflow user in the world.

0:33:45He's a serious iOS productivity enthusiast.

0:33:47He writes all sorts of very interesting stuff in workflow

0:33:52to aid his productivity.

0:33:54He showed an example with JSON feed on Twitter,

0:33:57and it blew my mind how simple it was, because more or less,

0:34:00he just passed in the URL to Daring Fireball's JSON feed.

0:34:03And then the next step in JSON was

0:34:06turn that feed into a dictionary, which

0:34:09is a workflow data structure, which is named values with--

0:34:15or keys that have the title of the feed, the date of the item,

0:34:21and then a value for each thing.

0:34:24And then all of a sudden, in the next step,

0:34:25he can just extract the value from the dictionary value.

0:34:31So give it a JSON feed, turn it into a workflow dictionary,

0:34:34which is something he's familiar with

0:34:36and is intrinsic to workflow.

0:34:38And then he can do things.

0:34:39Like all of a sudden, he could show

0:34:41a list of all 25 items in the Daring Fireball JSON feed.

0:34:46So workflow wasn't updated to support JSON feed.

0:34:50It just naturally works with JSON, period,

0:34:54and maps JSON to what workflow calls a dictionary.

0:34:58And so Federico wrote a thing,

0:35:01like within a day or two of JSON feed being announced,

0:35:04where he could do something

0:35:05that was actually useful from workflow.

0:35:09And then I looked into it.

0:35:10Now I'm not a heavy workflow user,

0:35:11but I looked into it, I opened workflow,

0:35:13and I replicated what he did.

0:35:15And I built a little workflow for me,

0:35:16which I actually might use.

0:35:18It's a little thing I can launch

0:35:19from my iPhone home screen now.

0:35:21It shows a list of all my recent articles

0:35:22at Daring Fireball, and I can copy the URL for one.

0:35:25So if I'm texting somebody,

0:35:26And I know I want to text them a recent article I wrote.

0:35:29I can do this now with like three taps on my iPhone.

0:35:33But the thing I looked into is, well,

0:35:34could I do this with RSS or Atom in workflow?

0:35:38And the answer is no.

0:35:39There's no way to do it.

0:35:41So it's not just is it easier or harder

0:35:45to parse JSON versus RSS.

0:35:48For workflow users, it's literally

0:35:50the difference between it's possible and not possible.

0:35:55Yeah, that's a great example of like new tools, right, that we hope will happen because of this.

0:36:00It wasn't possible to do that before.

0:36:01And maybe you could have some custom workflow RSS thing that was built in that the workflow team worked on.

0:36:09But you can't just have a generic XML action that would work this way.

0:36:15And it gets back to the point earlier about like, in a lot of cases, parsing JSON is just one line of code.

0:36:22it can't be one line of code for XML because XML is more complicated. You don't have just one, you know, key.

0:36:27If you're working on a dictionary, you have attributes. It's just, it's a different type of format.

0:36:32You can't have the same simplicity with XML. It's just, it's literally not possible to do the same thing and just make a dictionary out of it.

0:36:40I just think that there are people who think, if you think XML is simple enough that there's not a need for this,

0:36:45I really think that you're overlooking just how dramatically simpler JSON is for a lot

0:36:53of modern programming platforms.

0:36:57I think of it as being more democratic, right?

0:36:59So JSON is just usable everywhere and usable by people at massively varying skill levels.

0:37:08That it makes things like working with feeds something amateurs of all kinds can totally

0:37:13do and get some value out of. And I think that it sounds small, it sounds small in the way I talked

0:37:20about Frontier, you know, persistence is so easy. You might think, oh, well, whatever, that's a solved

0:37:25problem for me. But it really does make a huge difference when you get to use the thing.

0:37:29Pete: It is literally why I started by talking about Frontier, that I see a path from there to

0:37:37here that is similar. And democratization of this is exactly—it's something that

0:37:45I get fired up about. I really do think that when you make stuff like this easier for more

0:37:49people to do—like, there was an idea in the early days of personal computing where

0:37:55maybe everybody would be a programmer. And I think HyperCard was sort of designed in

0:38:00that vein of, this is the sort of thing that everybody could do. And because those of us

0:38:06who can program at some level, you know, like if you can write some kind of script at some

0:38:11level versus, whether you, maybe you can't write a full-fledged, you know, CoCo application

0:38:16that is too far beyond your capabilities as a programmer. But if you can program at all,

0:38:22you could see that, and you can see how exciting it was in the '80s and '90s when we were

0:38:25writing little scripts in HyperCard. You wanted that enthusiasm to spread to everybody. But

0:38:30the truth is, everybody isn't a programmer. In the same way that, in theory, everybody

0:38:35could write novels, but most people don't write novels. And everybody could sing, but

0:38:41not everybody sings or plays a musical instrument. I think programming is very much like any

0:38:46of those things, where some people have a knack for it and an interest and some people

0:38:50don't. But I still think that there's a huge—I feel like we gave up as an industry

0:38:55on making things approachable to more people at a simpler level. And JSON Feed is—

0:39:04Right. JSON feed is exactly like that. And one of the things too is it's not just about making

0:39:09feed readers, right? There's all sorts of things that you can do with a feed and the data from a

0:39:14feed that just might not occur to you until all of a sudden you're like, "Whoa, I wish I could

0:39:18just pick a list of recent articles from during Fireball and just copy the URL."

0:39:22Sure. I think if this, then that is an example. Yes.

0:39:30They have like a feed actions, things you can do, and people use that.

0:39:34And it would be nice to make that kind of ease of use available in more different places,

0:39:41many more places.

0:39:42Right. Right. And I think as JSON feed takes root and blossoms, we'll see things like that,

0:39:49where people who might be IFTTT—I don't know how you pronounce it. Do you say IFTTT or—

0:39:54If—I don't know.

0:39:56- No, if it's just, people might make their own feed

0:40:01for things that you don't think of.

0:40:04Something to do with your home

0:40:07and just the smart home automation stuff

0:40:10and maybe you start making a feed

0:40:11of times your refrigerator's opened or whatever.

0:40:15I don't know, but there's all sorts of things

0:40:17that you could do with it

0:40:18and with an easy to generate format,

0:40:21it just opens the door to things

0:40:24that you haven't thought of yet.

0:40:25Yeah.

0:40:27All right, let me take a break and thank our first sponsor.

0:40:30I want to tell you about our good friends at Fracture.

0:40:34Fracture is out to rescue your favorite photos

0:40:38from the digital ether.

0:40:39Here's what they do.

0:40:40They print your photos directly onto glass,

0:40:42and they add a laser cut rigid backing.

0:40:46You pick your favorite photos, you send them to Fracture,

0:40:49you upload them, you pick the sizes

0:40:51that you want them printed at.

0:40:53fracture, prints them directly on glass in their carbon neutral factory down in

0:40:58Gainesville Florida. Handmade. They ship them to you in a beautiful clever little

0:41:04box. You take them out of the box and they're literally ready to hang on the

0:41:08wall or prop up on your desk or wherever you're going to put them depending on

0:41:11the size. Everything you need is right there in the box ready to go and they

0:41:15look amazing. It's not just an easy way to get your photos printed it's also the

0:41:20the best way to get your photos printed.

0:41:23And let me tell you, as somebody who,

0:41:26I tell you about them all the time, and I underuse them.

0:41:28I have fractures all over the house,

0:41:30but I should have more, because every time I look at one,

0:41:32it makes me happy.

0:41:34Looking at pictures, the nice pictures that I've taken

0:41:37of places I've been, and my wife and my son,

0:41:41other people in our family, psychologically,

0:41:44it makes you feel good.

0:41:46Fracture is a company that makes people happy,

0:41:49because pictures of loved ones and places you've been

0:41:53that you want to remember will make you happy.

0:41:56I don't want to oversell it, but literally,

0:41:59in a way, Fracture is selling happiness.

0:42:01It's a great company, a great service.

0:42:04You will never, ever regret getting a Fracture.

0:42:07Where do you go to find out more?

0:42:08Their website is fractureme.com, fractureme.com/podcast.

0:42:13They use the same URL for all their podcast ads,

0:42:17And then when you buy your pictures from Fracture,

0:42:21they will ask you a one question survey,

0:42:23which is where did you hear of Fracture?

0:42:25And you can tell them you heard it from me, the talk show.

0:42:28My thanks to Fracture.

0:42:30Go get some pictures printed.

0:42:31They are terrific.

0:42:32All right, JSON Feed.

0:42:34Anything else we want to talk about on JSON Feed?

0:42:37Where do we think it's going?

0:42:39Do you think it's, is the success about where you expected,

0:42:45about what you hoped, more or less?

0:42:47Jared: It's more than I thought, actually. Yeah. It almost seemed to me like people had been

0:42:53sitting around not knowing if anybody else cared about this stuff, and then when we came out with

0:42:58this, a whole bunch of people were like, "Oh, a lot of people care about this stuff." This stuff

0:43:03being, you know, the open web and feeds and things like that. In a weird way, it's kind of like a

0:43:08group is finding each other, which is really cool. Pete: Yeah. I kind of see that too. And

0:43:15And it would be interesting--

0:43:21we can parlay this into our next conversation

0:43:23about feed reading.

0:43:24And I'm curious, as feed readers now start to adopt JSON feed,

0:43:29I'm curious what they will do when--

0:43:33let's say somebody is using a feed reader

0:43:35and they want to subscribe to Daring Fireball.

0:43:37And they just-- they say-- it says new feed.

0:43:39And you type in daringfireball.net.

0:43:42And on the back end, both of my feeds are discoverable.

0:43:46There's an RSS feed, is that technically an Atom feed,

0:43:49but for the sake of, we'll just call it RSS for clarity.

0:43:53There's an RSS feed and there's a JSON feed.

0:43:55At what point do you think feed readers

0:43:57might start preferring the JSON feed?

0:44:00- I think many will, yeah, it's hard to know,

0:44:05but I think some might soon because there's,

0:44:09It kind of switches the code path in your app to something that's simpler,

0:44:13maybe even faster in some cases.

0:44:17It's hard to know. And the other thing to think about is it's not, we don't

0:44:21expect everything to change overnight, but you have to start somewhere.

0:44:25And so I agree with Brent, I think this is more than I thought

0:44:29we'd see in the first week or two. And it gives me a lot of hope that

0:44:33you fast forward not just weeks or months, but like

0:44:37five years, 10 years, I mean, things change over years.

0:44:41And starting now, which we didn't start earlier,

0:44:44but starting now works too.

0:44:46- Brent, what do you think?

0:44:50- You know, it looks like Feedbin, for instance,

0:44:54may already be preferring JSON feed

0:44:56or certainly seems to be leaning that direction,

0:45:00where others like Feedly aren't even sure yet

0:45:02that they want to support it.

0:45:04So I don't really know how long it's gonna take

0:45:08feed readers in general to prefer that or, you know,

0:45:12we'll see, a lot, yeah, a lot can happen in five years.

0:45:16You know, and it may be that there's some other

0:45:18syndication format in five years that just blows

0:45:20all this away and whatever, you know, who knows?

0:45:25Hard to predict, but I think, you know,

0:45:27JSON feed will do well and will make the ecosystem better.

0:45:32- It just loaded the feed bin.

0:45:33Feedbin is an online feed reader.

0:45:38And it's so funny.

0:45:41I don't use it, so I don't have any feeds in mind.

0:45:43But it's a very nice little iCloud.com style web app

0:45:49that looks sort of like a little bit like a native app.

0:45:52And because I have nothing there in the content column,

0:45:55they just show an outline of a hamburger.

0:45:58Like a real hamburger, not a hamburger menu.

0:46:00(laughing)

0:46:02- Making me happy.

0:46:03All right, we'll speak--

0:46:04- And the nice thing about some of those,

0:46:05like Feedbin is also like a RSS syncing,

0:46:08- Right.

0:46:09- You know, feed syncing thing.

0:46:10So there's lots of native apps that support Feedbin

0:46:14that don't even really need to add direct support

0:46:17to JSON feed necessarily, and they'll get,

0:46:20they'll be, you know, quote unquote compatible.

0:46:22And I think the other unknown is how much innovation

0:46:26this will spark.

0:46:27You know, we have like extensions in JSON feed,

0:46:29people coming up with new ideas, things they want feeds to do.

0:46:32And I'm hopeful about that because we haven't, I mean, when Google Reader shut down, that

0:46:37was kind of like good news, bad news.

0:46:39And the good news was that it did spark kind of some innovation and like more feed syncing

0:46:44engines and services.

0:46:46And we haven't seen much like that, but I'm hopeful that we might see something else like

0:46:50that.

0:46:51Like some feed reader will take a leap and say, "I'm going to add a new feature."

0:46:54Imagine that.

0:46:55and I'm gonna add a new feature to a feed reader

0:46:58that no one has seen before.

0:46:59And so we'll see.

0:47:00- It sometimes seems to me like things now

0:47:04are a little calcified,

0:47:06like the bones of the web have hardened.

0:47:09And in order to do something new, like JSON feed

0:47:14or add new features to a feed reader, whatever,

0:47:17like you have to go through a bunch of hurdles

0:47:19and pass gatekeepers and have all these people explaining

0:47:23why you're doing it wrong.

0:47:24And, you know, years ago, we would just make things and people would like them or not.

0:47:30And it was fun. And so, part of the message here is like, look, we can have fun and we don't actually

0:47:37have to, we don't have to listen to all the gatekeepers, all the people who would stop us

0:47:42from doing things. Now, it could be that what we're doing isn't the right thing or has a bunch

0:47:47of flaws, you know, maybe, maybe not. But the point is, you know, let's get back to the place

0:47:53where we actually do make new things and have a good time doing it.

0:47:57It is fun, and I've written that too, that to me this whole thing with JSON feed is fun.

0:48:02And of course that hopelessly brands me as a nerd that I think that a new JSON-based syndication feed

0:48:08is fun. But it is, I have to admit, I've had a bit of a thrill just watching this thing take off over

0:48:16the last week or two. And it is fun. It was fun for me to write the little script that makes the

0:48:23JSON feed for Daring Fireball. It was a fun programming project for me in the way that I enjoy

0:48:32little things that you can complete in the afternoon programming projects. It was very fun.

0:48:40I think Dr. Drang wrote a post about creating one for his website at Lean Crew.

0:48:47He more or less said the same thing. As a little scratch and itch,

0:48:53do it in an afternoon programming project. It was as-built on the tin, this is an easy thing to do.

0:49:06Ironically, I think of all of us who worked on the spec, I was the last one to actually

0:49:10write code to generate a feed, like the day before we published. I remember it would be easy, so,

0:49:17you know, whatever. Yeah. It's funny though, because that is true. I can vouch for that.

0:49:23And I remember it was like, we were like, you were like, here's a checklist of things that need to be

0:49:28done before we announced this publicly. And one of them was have an actual JSON feed for Inessential.

0:49:34- Yeah, and for the JSON feed site itself,

0:49:37which both use the same content management system,

0:49:40which is really one big, hairy Ruby script.

0:49:43- Right.

0:49:44I don't want to keep hammering on XML,

0:49:46but I will say, though, that,

0:49:48not that it's hard to make an RSS feed for a site

0:49:51if you're writing your own, doing it on your own

0:49:54as opposed to using WordPress or something,

0:49:56but I can verify firsthand that with the weird system

0:50:00I have behind the scenes at Daring Fireball,

0:50:01where I take, long story short,

0:50:04the system at Daring Fireball,

0:50:07my short entries are a different blog behind the scenes

0:50:10than my longer entries.

0:50:11And then to just have one feed,

0:50:13I have a script that takes two separate feeds,

0:50:16one from my link list entries, one from my articles,

0:50:18and blends them together into one feed.

0:50:21And I wrote that myself.

0:50:23And I have had times in the past 10, 15 years

0:50:28where that's broken, like when I've upgraded

0:50:30of the server and move to a new server where text starts getting encoded differently because there's

0:50:35different modules. It's not trivial. You wouldn't want to save generating an XML feed for the last

0:50:42minute. Whereas JSON feed, I could see why you weren't worried about it. And you're a big believer

0:50:49in Murphy's Law, right, Brent? Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, absolutely. Well, because it's true.

0:50:55But Murphy's Law often involves XML. All right, speaking of feed readers, Brent, you have an

0:51:03announcement to make. Yeah, I've actually been working on a new feed reader for quite some time

0:51:09as one of my nights and weekends project. And I thought for quite a long time, you know, what I

0:51:15wanted to do with it. And for a long time, I thought, I'll make it, you know, a for-pay

0:51:19commercial thing, you know, make some money. I've decided against that. So the name of the reader is

0:51:24Evergreen. And it is up on GitHub, there's a repository, github.com/brentsimmons/evergreen.

0:51:34And it's not quite usable yet, except by extreme masochists. But it's coming along. And eventually,

0:51:41we will have a modern nice cool Mac, RSS reader, and Adam reader and JSON feed reader.

0:51:49I was gonna say is it going to support JSON feed?

0:51:52Of course, yeah. But tellingly, I haven't actually written the JSON feed support for it yet, so

0:51:57at the moment it's only running on my machine and it only works with RSS and Atom.

0:52:03But you know, maybe I have 15 minutes later today and I'll fix that.

0:52:06So it's Mac only?

0:52:10Open source.

0:52:12Open source.

0:52:13And tell me why it's Mac only.

0:52:19It's Mac only, mainly because my two big passions in my career have been the open web and the

0:52:29Macintosh desktop, Mac apps. iOS apps were kind of fun, but also so massively heartbreaking that

0:52:35I can't love that the way I love the Mac. And so for me, the intersection of the open web and the

0:52:42Mac desktop is my favorite place to work. And that's why I work on things like Frontier,

0:52:46and that's why I've worked on RSS readers. That's why I started Mars Edit a long, long time ago.

0:52:52So that's my favorite place. And so I'm writing another feed reader because I,

0:52:58you know, that's me. That's what I do.

0:53:00So right now, your day job, though, for the last what, like, how long have you been at OmniGroup?

0:53:05Two years?

0:53:06Two and a half years.

0:53:07Two and a half years. What do you work on at OmniGroup?

0:53:09For the past year and a half, maybe I've been on OmniOutliner. And I also love Outliners.

0:53:16and this is my favorite Omni app,

0:53:19so it's been great working on that.

0:53:21And I've been solely on the Mac version this whole time,

0:53:24at least so far.

0:53:26Before that, I worked on OmniFocus for Mac.

0:53:28- Right, but Mac apps in particular.

0:53:31- Absolutely, yeah.

0:53:32- And we've had this discussion now,

0:53:34obviously, long-time listeners of the show know

0:53:36that you and I, along with Dave Whiskus,

0:53:38collaborated on an iOS app,

0:53:43ultimately it was only an iOS app,

0:53:45although we had plans for a Mac app,

0:53:46we can go over that some other day,

0:53:48Vesper from a couple of years ago.

0:53:51And in our postmortems of Vesper,

0:53:57one of our big regrets was that we strategically,

0:54:01I think I'm speaking for both of us,

0:54:02but we wished that we had done the Mac version first,

0:54:06both for business reasons and it just seems

0:54:11like it was a strategic error.

0:54:14I think we kind of got blindsided, or blinded by the--

0:54:19sort of like what I said about how the web was--

0:54:24everybody was blinded by HTML and the web in the mid '90s.

0:54:27Five, six years ago, iPhone apps were such the thing.

0:54:32And I don't think you ever enjoyed writing an iPhone app

0:54:36as much as you enjoyed making a Mac app.

0:54:39Yeah, it's really-- it's no comparison.

0:54:42even in the early days of iOS.

0:54:43And I had NetNewswire for iOS,

0:54:46well, for iPhone was up on day one of the app store.

0:54:49And that was cool initially

0:54:52'cause the iPhones were so new and exciting,

0:54:54but they kind of wore off for me.

0:54:57I've been a long, long time Mac user

0:54:59and I love writing Mac apps, just way much more.

0:55:04- It's a different, you often hear the,

0:55:08I think there's more people out there,

0:55:10like let's say WWDC in a few weeks,

0:55:13there will be more people attending WWDC

0:55:17who would raise their hand and say that they prefer iOS,

0:55:20writing iOS apps to writing Mac apps.

0:55:23And again, not to go out in the weeds

0:55:25on programming differences,

0:55:26but that people find iOS's UI kit more,

0:55:31they just like it better than they like the equivalent

0:55:37on Mac, which is called AppKit,

0:55:39which dates back to the next days.

0:55:41And so what you're saying is really the opposite though,

0:55:44that you prefer the Mac to iOS,

0:55:46but it's not really, from your perspective,

0:55:48I don't think it's really an AppKit versus UIKit thing,

0:55:50it's more of a, the freedom of a Mac app,

0:55:55especially one that's not sandboxed, you know,

0:55:59it's liberating in some very literal ways.

0:56:05- It really is.

0:56:06The personal computer revolution changed the world dramatically.

0:56:11It brought, going back to democratization, right, it brought power to anybody who could

0:56:17manage to get a computer in their life.

0:56:20And that's huge, really, really huge, and it remains huge.

0:56:24And iOS still isn't liberating in quite that same way.

0:56:29Maybe it's liberating in other ways, for sure.

0:56:31You know, you have it in your pocket wherever you go.

0:56:35But the kind of deeper things that you can do on a Mac are still difficult to impossible

0:56:40on iOS.

0:56:42And I like that.

0:56:43I like being able to do those deeper things and to enable users to do deeper things.

0:56:49And I sense a certain frustration from you personally about the—again, not like your

0:56:57anti-app store, but that distributing your software through the app store has pluses

0:57:03and minuses, but that the minuses weigh you down. It makes it less likely that you're going to do

0:57:08something for iOS as a nights and weekends type thing. Yeah, that's right. It adds a bunch of

0:57:16housekeeping. It adds a bunch of stuff I'd just rather not spend time doing, and it separates

0:57:23me from my users. And I don't like that at all. The fact that Apple provides a download space for

0:57:32your apps. It's kind of nice, but I wasn't really asking for that. I can just use S3

0:57:37or whatever. I mean, who cares?

0:57:38It's sort of a solved problem, right? Nobody—there was a point where it really was, as an indie

0:57:43developer, it was actually an expense to like, "Well, where am I going to host the actual

0:57:47like, I guess it was like a .sit file at the time. Where's my stuff at archive with my

0:57:54app going to be?" Because the bandwidth—but I haven't heard the last time that somebody

0:58:00ran up a bandwidth bill on downloads.

0:58:03- Right, and just being on the App Store doesn't, you know,

0:58:06replace the fact that you need to do marketing.

0:58:08So whether there's an App Store or not,

0:58:09you still have to do marketing.

0:58:11It really just doesn't help that much.

0:58:16Having something on the App Store,

0:58:17people aren't just gonna magically find your app.

0:58:19You still have to do all the stuff you would have done

0:58:21without an App Store.

0:58:23- So why another feed reader?

0:58:28just out of love because I love it.

0:58:30Another big reason is, you know, I love these technologies.

0:58:34I love the open web, I love feeds,

0:58:37and I'd like to see more people use it.

0:58:40And so that goes to why I'm making it free.

0:58:43Yeah, I could not, in other words,

0:58:49like one day, a few years ago,

0:58:52I just found myself writing an RSS parser,

0:58:54and I'm like, yep, I'm doing this,

0:58:56Because obviously my fingers want me to do this and I have no choice.

0:58:59The name Evergreen is so great too. I wonder, like, how much did that lock you into the idea of,

0:59:08you know, you have a great name, you almost have to finish writing it out.

0:59:11That was a relatively recent change, actually. It's had a few different names. The first name was

0:59:16Seneca, which I love. It's a beautiful name. And, you know, it's the old Roman senator.

0:59:23It was also the name of the company that made page mill, though they spelled it with a C instead of

0:59:27an S. And I've wanted to use that name since that time. But the problem is there's also the Seneca

0:59:35brand apple juice, and I just couldn't get away from that association. I didn't want people coming

0:59:40to my site thinking that they're going to learn about apple juice. It just didn't work.

0:59:45Mad Fientist The book, I can't say they're well read enough to have read more than one,

0:59:52But the one book from the Roman senator Seneca that I think he's best known for is on the

0:59:56Shortness of Life, which is a great—and a lot of really old books is actually almost

1:00:02more like an extended essay than a book.

1:00:05But I will put a link in the show notes to it because it's really a wonderful essay,

1:00:10something that was written, what, like 2,000 years ago that seems as applicable today as

1:00:15ever.

1:00:16Yeah.

1:00:17And it kind of went to my motivations for writing the app.

1:00:21It's like, you know, apparently this is what I love doing,

1:00:23so why not just do it?

1:00:25- I can tell that you're happy

1:00:32with the set of projects on your plate.

1:00:35You and I have been friends for a very long time,

1:00:37and I can just tell you,

1:00:39it almost sounds like you do have a lot on your plate.

1:00:41You've got a very juicy day job.

1:00:44I mean,

1:00:47we said, you're retooling Frontier to run on a modern Mac. JSON feed, in some sense,

1:00:56it's kind of, you know, at least that's in the past tense. Like, maybe there will be

1:01:00an update or something, but if there is, it'll be minor. So you don't have to do a lot of

1:01:03work on JSON feed, and now you've got—

1:01:05Yeah, that was a side project of a side project.

1:01:08Right. But it is related, though, where I feel like if—I think we're heading to a

1:01:15path where when Evergreen is at a place where it's usable, where it's more of a closer to

1:01:22being—yeah, I would call this a complete feed reader. By that time, I'll bet a decent

1:01:28chunk of the stuff that people are putting into it are JSON feeds. And one of the things—are

1:01:34you going to have local feeds?

1:01:37At some point, possibly not in 1.0, but yeah. Yeah, scripted local feeds.

1:01:41Right, so NetNewswire supported local feeds.

1:01:44And what you could do, and what that means

1:01:46is if you're a scripter, you could write your own feeds

1:01:51locally on your Mac and subscribe to them.

1:01:54And it could be something like-- if you have a shared Dropbox

1:01:59folder with people at work, you could generate your own feed

1:02:04of when items appear in there.

1:02:06And then if you want to, that would be your notification.

1:02:09If you're in Newswire all the time, you could see,

1:02:11oh, there's new items in my shared Dropbox folder,

1:02:14and that's the thing that you wrote yourself.

1:02:17I think that it will, in Evergreen,

1:02:21I think most scripted feeds will be JSON feeds

1:02:24because they're so much easier to write.

1:02:25If you're writing a feed,

1:02:27if you're starting right now to write your own custom feed,

1:02:29why in the world would you choose

1:02:31anything other than JSON feed?

1:02:33- Yep, yeah, 'cause it's as simple as

1:02:35you build the data structure in code

1:02:38and say, "All right, JSONify this," and there, we're done.

1:02:43- So it's 2017, and Brent Simmons is working

1:02:48on Frontier, an outliner. (laughs)

1:02:52- Yeah, I know, I know.

1:02:54- A feed reader.

1:02:55- I have like three passions, and I do all three of them,

1:02:58and that's that.

1:02:59Which means I'm super lucky, and I had to get

1:03:04to the age of 49 to be this lucky,

1:03:07but you know, I've worked my way there.

1:03:10- All right, let me take another break here

1:03:11and thank our next sponsor.

1:03:13It is our good friends at Squarespace.

1:03:18You've heard of Squarespace.

1:03:20They sponsor the show all the time.

1:03:21But listen to me, listen to me.

1:03:23I'm gonna make it short

1:03:24because you know what they are already.

1:03:26Squarespace, you go there,

1:03:28type squarespace.com in your browser.

1:03:30You go there, you can say start a free trial

1:03:32and you start a free trial.

1:03:33And you're already, at that moment,

1:03:35you're already building your website.

1:03:36You've got templates to choose from that

1:03:39are both stylistic templates in terms of what

1:03:41do you think it's going to look like and functional templates

1:03:44in terms of what is it that you're making.

1:03:46Are you starting a new podcast?

1:03:48Well, then you can start a blog type thing in Squarespace

1:03:51where you'll have entries and that sort of thing.

1:03:56Or are you building a store because you're selling stuff?

1:03:58Maybe you're making t-shirts or something like that

1:04:01and you want to sell them.

1:04:02The next thing you know, half an hour later,

1:04:04your website is finished and it's there.

1:04:06and it's a real website, the thing that you make in Squarespace, it is the thing.

1:04:11There is no separate mode for like, well, here's what it would look like,

1:04:15and now you have to build it in generator or something like that.

1:04:17Like as you make these choices and drag these things out,

1:04:21and move them around on screen and change the names, you have a website.

1:04:25It's that easy.

1:04:26So next time you have an idea that needs a website, I'm telling you right now,

1:04:30go to squarespace.com and use this code, Gruber.

1:04:35That's my last name.

1:04:36But you don't need to use that code until you buy.

1:04:38So go there and just spend 30 minutes trying

1:04:41to build it in Squarespace.

1:04:42And you're probably just-- you're

1:04:44going to realize that there's no reason to do it anywhere else.

1:04:46They handle everything-- hosting, domain name,

1:04:48registration, everything you need.

1:04:51There's web stats, all of your stats

1:04:53that you need for who's coming to your site, where

1:04:55are they coming from, how many hits a day you're getting.

1:04:57Squarespace has all that covered, all of it.

1:04:59Just remember my last name, Gruber, when you pay,

1:05:02and you'll get 10% off your first order.

1:05:04My thanks to Squarespace for their continued sponsorship of the talk show.

1:05:10Anything else you want to talk about on Evergreen?

1:05:12Oh, just the meaning of the name.

1:05:16I think the obvious thing is the idea that the open web and feeds and syndication are

1:05:21Evergreen things.

1:05:24They haven't gone away.

1:05:25There's still a lot of people that like this stuff, and still a lot of people who will

1:05:28like this stuff.

1:05:30But it's also, I live in Washington state, which is the Evergreen state.

1:05:34I went to Evergreen State College.

1:05:37So it has both some public and some personal meaning.

1:05:41I just love the name.

1:05:43I do love the name.

1:05:44Manton.

1:05:45I know Manton loves it.

1:05:46I think Manton loves it more than you do.

1:05:49And I didn't know all the backstory there.

1:05:50I just knew part of that.

1:05:52So I love it even more now.

1:05:53I have a question for you, Brennan.

1:05:55mentioned the first thing you said about Evergreen was the GitHub URL and you've

1:06:01open-sourced some stuff but in the past I think most of the things you open

1:06:06source are later in a project when it's done or you know or it's you know mature

1:06:12or whatever and this is the first thing I can think of in a while that you've

1:06:15open-sourced at the very beginning have you thought about like what that means

1:06:20like what is that going to change any way you approach this and how the app will evolve or,

1:06:26you know, be forked into other apps and you know, who knows, you know, it's kind of

1:06:29just a different process than you've used before.

1:06:33Yeah, that's a good question. So this is open source, as is the work I'm doing on Frontier.

1:06:38And for me, it's exciting because I feel in a way like I'm performing in public.

1:06:46I get the right blog posts about it.

1:06:48People who want to follow the commits can look at it

1:06:51and just see how something like this is made.

1:06:55And maybe for people who aren't developers,

1:06:58but know enough to be able to understand what's going on,

1:07:01maybe it'll be interesting to them.

1:07:03And maybe for newer developers,

1:07:05it'll be a way to learn from my mistakes

1:07:10as well as the things that I do well.

1:07:14So I almost feel like I'm inventing a new literary form,

1:07:19not as high art, but the form of, you know,

1:07:25here's a bunch of code,

1:07:26here's a bunch of writing about that code.

1:07:29Not that nobody's ever done that before,

1:07:30of course they have,

1:07:31but I'm just really into that aspect of it.

1:07:36Of all my things I've made,

1:07:38my blog is my longest running, started in 1999.

1:07:42And it's also the thing I'm most proud of.

1:07:44So sometimes I think I'm doing all this

1:07:46just so I have something to write about.

1:07:48(laughing)

1:07:50- I'm keenly aware of blogs that predate Daring Fireball

1:07:55because it's, when I had the idea to do Daring Fireball,

1:08:00it was, the motivation was like a ball rolling downhill

1:08:05where every day it went by before I launched it,

1:08:08I wished more I already had it.

1:08:10and I had it, you know. And it was the blogs that other people were writing that was making

1:08:18me want to do it, right? It's, you know, Kotke and Inessential and Andy Bayo's waxy.org

1:08:26launched I think about six months before Daring Fireball. And the ones that are still going,

1:08:30I'm so happy about. I'm so happy that Inessential is still going. Every once in a while, I'm

1:08:35reading Kotke. I read it every day, but every once in a while, I'm like, "You know what?

1:08:39I fucking love that Jason Kottke is still killing it with Kottke.

1:08:42Yeah, he's amazing.

1:08:44Yeah.

1:08:45It just makes me so happy that it's just all these years gone by, and I could totally

1:08:51see that.

1:08:52And the original blog, Scripting News, still going strong.

1:08:55Of course.

1:08:56Of course.

1:08:57Absolutely.

1:08:58Yeah, definitely.

1:08:59And it ties into the creation of RSS and podcasting and everything with Dave Weiner, and absolutely

1:09:01a huge, huge motivating force.

1:09:04One of the things about Dave that was a huge inspiration for me, beyond his technical contributions

1:09:10and the creation of all these things that my entire career hangs on, but one of the

1:09:16things about Dave that I was so super inspired by was that Dave had a column for Wired magazine.

1:09:32I forget if it was just on the web

1:09:33or if he was in the actual paper,

1:09:35but I know he was on Hotwired.

1:09:36And he had his blog.

1:09:41And the thing about Dave that was very clear

1:09:43is that I could tell that he liked writing for his blog

1:09:45better than he did writing for somebody else.

1:09:47And it wasn't like he started the blog

1:09:49so that he could get a column at Wired.

1:09:51It was like he wrote the column at Wired

1:09:53so that more people would read his stuff,

1:09:54but it was, you know,

1:09:56his own thing was the more important thing.

1:09:58And that's the thing that he's, you know,

1:10:0025 years later still doing.

1:10:01And it was a huge inspiration for me,

1:10:03which was that I wanted to do Daring Fireball

1:10:05and make it, make Daring Fireball my career,

1:10:07not write Daring Fireball, get well-known

1:10:10and then go write for Macworld or something.

1:10:12So anyway, there's a nice shout out to Dave.

1:10:16- I remember-- - And it's funny at that,

1:10:19at that time, I mean, I remember feeling like,

1:10:22gosh, there's so many blogs, like, do we need another blog?

1:10:25Do I need to start one?

1:10:26I know some people today are probably feeling that way.

1:10:28Like maybe they want to start a blog,

1:10:29but there's so many.

1:10:31But of course, like 10, 15 years ago,

1:10:36it was certainly not too late to start a blog.

1:10:38Now, if you started a blog that long ago,

1:10:39you were one of the oldest blogs on the web.

1:10:42And so, I don't know, I hope people kind of can help

1:10:46put that in perspective for people.

1:10:47Like it's never too late.

1:10:50And a lot of these blogs, I mean, we talk about Twitter,

1:10:53we talk about Facebook and how long

1:10:54these services might be around.

1:10:56They're all younger than like our blogs.

1:10:59And so, you know, it's a, when you stretch it out five, 10, 15 years, where do you want your writing to be?

1:11:07Like where, if you're passionate about writing on the web, obviously Dave is, obviously you all are, where do you want that content to live?

1:11:13And it's, you know, I think blogs obviously are a great solution.

1:11:18Hold that thought, man.

1:11:26I was going to tell the story of how I got into Frontier in the first place.

1:11:29I don't know if I've ever said before. Well, hold that thought. I'm going to tell you about another

1:11:37friend of the show. And we'll do that, and then we're going to talk about man and blogging.

1:11:42But it's our good friends at Away. Away is a company, another one of these podcast,

1:11:50prototypical podcast sponsors that sell stuff direct to you. What do they make? They make

1:11:55luggage. They make really nice suitcases, and they have a carry-on. The carry-on is sort of their

1:12:01prime example. That's the one that you want to look at. I've got one. I've been using it for,

1:12:08I forget how many months now, but it's now my go-to carry-on for everywhere I go. Hard case,

1:12:14really nicely made. Mine still looks brand new. I mean, the carry-ons, you get a lot less wear and

1:12:19and tear on because they don't go underneath the airplane.

1:12:22Really nice size.

1:12:23Wonderful wheels.

1:12:25The wheels-- oh my god.

1:12:26I had a carry-on suitcase.

1:12:27Maybe it was just because it was old.

1:12:28But I had one that was like-- as I'd go through the airport,

1:12:31it was like squeaking and made terrible noise.

1:12:34The way it rolls so nice, it's like you don't even

1:12:37have to put any energy into it.

1:12:38It almost goes too fast.

1:12:40But here's the thing that they've got that is so brilliant

1:12:43is they've built into the carry-on suitcase

1:12:46a battery charger.

1:12:48It's like, by the standards of something

1:12:51you would carry in your pocket, it's huge.

1:12:54It's got two USB ports, so two phones or two iPads.

1:12:57You can charge them at once.

1:12:58Anything that charges by USB, you can charge from this thing.

1:13:01And so when you're at the airport

1:13:03and you're waiting for your flight to go off,

1:13:05you don't have to hunt around for one of the two

1:13:07seats in the whole terminal that has a charger

1:13:10or electrical outlet nearby.

1:13:12And they never put them near seats anyway.

1:13:14Everybody, if you go to the airport,

1:13:15you see people sitting on the floor

1:13:17so that they can be near the port

1:13:18and there's probably somebody already sitting there.

1:13:21You just take any seat you can

1:13:22and if you need to charge your phone,

1:13:23you just plug it right in your suitcase.

1:13:25It is brilliant.

1:13:26This is such a great idea.

1:13:27And it's a really great suitcase.

1:13:30They've got all sorts of nice stuff inside

1:13:31to help you organize your stuff,

1:13:33keep your shirts separate and not get 'em wrinkled,

1:13:36stuff like that.

1:13:38So what do you do to find out more?

1:13:41Go to their website.

1:13:42It's awaytravel.com.

1:13:44awaytravel.com/talkshow

1:13:48and use the promo code talkshow during checkout

1:13:51and you will save 20 bucks on your suitcase.

1:13:54I've got one, I recommend it super thoroughly.

1:13:57Go there and check it out, awaytravel.com/talkshow.

1:14:02All right, back to the show.

1:14:04And Brent, you were gonna tell a story

1:14:05about how you got involved with Frontier in the first place.

1:14:08- Yeah, it's not a huge story, but so it was 1995

1:14:11I was literally, I had a job as a secretary. I didn't have a CS degree. And the office had four

1:14:17people in it, including me, but we all had Macs, so I was a secretary. And one night, I was bored

1:14:23at home and I typed into the search engine in my browser, which I think was Lycos at the time,

1:14:32before Google even existed, "free Mac software" was my search term. And what that brought up was

1:14:39an article of Dave Weiner's on Hotwired, I'd never heard of him before, where he was talking about

1:14:44the release of Aretha, which was a free version of Frontier, technically a Frontier 4.0 beta.

1:14:52And I'm like, "Oh, something for programming. Cool. I want to get back into programming."

1:14:56I was thinking to myself, I downloaded it and I loved it. And like, that,

1:15:00the entire rest of my career comes from like that one search on that one day.

1:15:06[laughter]

1:15:11That's kind of amazing, right?

1:15:13Yeah.

1:15:14And everything falls out of that.

1:15:17Syndication formats, outliners.

1:15:20I mean, that is the one thing, too, that maybe we didn't mention before about Frontier,

1:15:24is that the source code editor for Frontier was an outliner,

1:15:29not just a simple text editor.

1:15:31editor.

1:15:32And people tend to write almost all modern programming

1:15:36languages in an outline-like format, where you say--

1:15:41if you say if this, then do these things,

1:15:45the do these things block, people

1:15:47tend to tab them in one more level of hierarchy

1:15:51to the right.

1:15:52And then when you're done with that block of only do this

1:15:55if this if statement is true, you

1:15:58go back out to the next level.

1:15:59but Frontier took it to the level where it was literally

1:16:03like on the outliner, like enforced as an outliner.

1:16:08- Right.

1:16:09And if you have a good outliner, it makes restructuring,

1:16:12indenting, unindenting, et cetera,

1:16:14really, really easy and really, really fast.

1:16:17And it also makes it nice, you can collapse stuff

1:16:20so you can see your code at a higher level and so on.

1:16:23I know we have code folding

1:16:25in a lot of text editors these days,

1:16:27but an outliner is, that's like the cheap version

1:16:30of what a good outliner gets you.

1:16:32- Right, and it gets rid of any arguments

1:16:34over tabs versus spaces.

1:16:36- Yeah, that's right, 'cause who cares?

1:16:38- My favorite story about working with you,

1:16:41I think I've said this before on the show,

1:16:43but with Vesper, you handled all of the programming.

1:16:46And there's one line of code

1:16:50that was like a regular expression that I wrote.

1:16:53I wrote one line of code for Vesper,

1:16:54and of course it was a regular expression.

1:16:56But at one point, I did have Vesper checked out so I could do my own builds, because it's

1:17:03just what you're doing, you're developing.

1:17:05I could update changes.

1:17:07And there were things I would commit, like language, like if there was stuff to write,

1:17:11I might contribute stuff like that.

1:17:13But one time I started just—I was like, "You know what?

1:17:15I wonder how the hell this works."

1:17:16And I just started going through the source code to Vesper, and I realized that you were

1:17:21all over the map on tabs versus spaces.

1:17:24Right, yeah.

1:17:25So, I was, all these people were like, "You should use spaces."

1:17:29So, I'm like, started best for them, I'm like, "Okay, I'm going to switch to spaces."

1:17:33And a little while in, I'm like, "God, I hate spaces.

1:17:35I'm going to go back to using tabs."

1:17:37But I didn't go through and reformat everything.

1:17:39And so, on my machine, everything was indented and lined up perfectly.

1:17:43But if your settings were different from mine, I think you said at one point I indented like

1:17:49a drunken sailor.

1:17:50That's exactly what it looked like.

1:17:52But on my machine, it was all perfect.

1:17:54So yeah.

1:17:55And I've stuck with tabs ever since. It's at that Omni where spaces are the rule.

1:17:59For those who don't know, it's a long-standing and never-ending debate in the programming world,

1:18:05where some programmers, when they indent code, they use spaces, and some use tabs.

1:18:10And it gets very, very—sometimes these arguments can get very emotional, because the stakes are so low, right?

1:18:22It's just like anything in life. Because it seems like such a trivial issue, people

1:18:29get very worked up about it. But usually, an institution like a group, a company, or

1:18:34something like the Omni Group is going to just have a, "Here's our coding standards.

1:18:37Everybody uses spaces. Then there's no debate." I was appalled by the state of Vesper's

1:18:44indentation.

1:18:45I'm a little surprised.

1:18:46I would have been too if I had seen that. But again, on my machine, everything was perfect.

1:18:51So yeah, I don't know what to say.

1:18:53- Omni use the spaces is fascinating to me

1:18:55because I'm certainly tabs and I'm not gonna start

1:18:58or finish that debate on this.

1:18:59But traditionally I feel like Mac programmers,

1:19:02especially classic Mac,

1:19:04like I remember when I started programming the Mac

1:19:06in the classic days, like no one used spaces.

1:19:09I mean, I literally, I can't remember any

1:19:11ever encountering code with spaces instead of tabs.

1:19:14And slowly over the years and decades,

1:19:17especially as people come from other programming communities,

1:19:20spaces become more and more dominant,

1:19:22so I would be surprised now if spaces aren't more common.

1:19:25But I'm kind of surprised to hear about Omni.

1:19:27That's fascinating.

1:19:27- Oh, maybe they're old Next developers.

1:19:29- Yeah, exactly.

1:19:29That's kind of a wrinkle in things.

1:19:32- My basic, I'm with you, man,

1:19:35and I think Mac users tend to be tabs people,

1:19:38and my thought was, always was,

1:19:40I mean, this is back to the '90s,

1:19:41is why in the world would I want four spaces

1:19:44when I have to backspace, backspace, backspace, backspace

1:19:46to get rid of one when I can just hit backspace once

1:19:49to get rid of a tab?

1:19:50And yes, I know that everybody who codes with spaces now,

1:19:53that modern code editors will smartly delete

1:19:57all four spaces when you hit it,

1:19:58so it treats it the same way.

1:20:00But why create the need for a special case?

1:20:03Like, it's exactly what the tab key is for.

1:20:06- Right, that's why the tab key exists.

1:20:09And like, I might want my indentation to look much wider

1:20:12than, you know, I might want it to look like eight

1:20:14or something, and you can't do that with spaces.

1:20:17I think, to your point about editors kind of hide this,

1:20:20I bet a lot of people don't even know what they're setting.

1:20:24Xcode might default to spaces now, I'm not sure,

1:20:27but I bet most people don't even know

1:20:29if they're using tabs or spaces.

1:20:32- Kids today don't even know if they should be upset

1:20:34about tabs versus spaces.

1:20:35(laughing)

1:20:38God damn kids.

1:20:39- Yeah.

1:20:40- All right, so Manton, I mentioned it before.

1:20:46Micro.blog, that's your new platform for microblogging.

1:20:51Tell me about it.

1:20:54- Sure, so the idea is with microblogging,

1:20:58and is, you know, Twitter, you know,

1:21:00people like Twitter, right?

1:21:02Posts are short, they're easy, kind of effortless.

1:21:05You should put that on your own site too,

1:21:06is the basic premise.

1:21:07Like you should have a blog,

1:21:08and you can have short posts on there, and it's fine.

1:21:11And short posts, you know, a lot of people,

1:21:14they don't wanna start a blog, or they have a blog,

1:21:16they don't know what to write because it's kind of daunting.

1:21:18They have to have a title and write multiple paragraphs

1:21:21and have to sound really intelligent.

1:21:22And with short microblogging, it removes all of that, right?

1:21:27It's okay to just post something that's a couple sentences.

1:21:30And that's the basic premise.

1:21:32It's a blog publishing platform,

1:21:34but it's also kind of a social network.

1:21:35So you can follow people like you can on Twitter.

1:21:38You can cross post to Twitter.

1:21:40And going kind of back to JSON-FE2,

1:21:43I mean, it shares some similar themes

1:21:46and just like helping get the message out, kind of like encouraging

1:21:51people to think about blogs and feed readers again.

1:21:53That's the, that's the most important goal, I think, of microdot blog.

1:21:57Now you launched this as a Kickstarter campaign.

1:22:00Um, and I know I, as somebody who contributed to the Kickstarter campaign,

1:22:07that's where I got my microdot blog account from.

1:22:10Where does it stand now on like signups?

1:22:12I haven't even looked like can people who didn't

1:22:15warn in on a Kickstarter get an account at micro.blog?

1:22:20- Not yet, it's still for Kickstarter backers.

1:22:23So I opened it up to Kickstarter backers

1:22:27about a month ago now.

1:22:28And I guess we're kind of on track

1:22:31for where we thought it would be,

1:22:33but you kind of using that early period

1:22:36with Kickstarter backers to get feedback, make it better.

1:22:40The iPhone app is not in the app store yet, right?

1:22:42So it's all via test flights, so it's kind of still a beta.

1:22:45And then we'll slowly start opening it up to more people

1:22:49and eventually everybody, yeah, pretty soon,

1:22:51but don't have an exact date yet.

1:22:53- But it's also the sort of thing where it's federated,

1:22:56where somebody else can create their own hosted service

1:23:00that is completely compatible.

1:23:03It's not like, I think it's worth clarifying

1:23:06that your micro.blog is not an attempt

1:23:08to make like a quote unquote open Twitter.

1:23:12It's not a unified centralized social network type thing.

1:23:17It's really just a hosting service for short posts.

1:23:21- Right, and it's a little confusing

1:23:23'cause it's kind of a mix of things.

1:23:24And it's not right now completely federated.

1:23:27Like if people have heard of Mastodon,

1:23:30which has got some popularity over the last month or so,

1:23:34which is more federated,

1:23:36where you have more kind of instances

1:23:38of a Twitter-like service running.

1:23:41It's a little different than that in that instead of like,

1:23:45just installing the micro.blog software yourself,

1:23:47you just use blog software, right?

1:23:50So you just use WordPress.

1:23:51Like if you wanna run your own site,

1:23:52you just use WordPress or Jekyll

1:23:55or some other blog publishing platform that you like.

1:23:59And then it hooks together into micro.blog

1:24:01so you can follow people.

1:24:03And if you don't, if WordPress is too much

1:24:05and you just want something simple,

1:24:06then we can host a microblog for you

1:24:08and just make it really easy.

1:24:09And that's part of it, just like making this easier.

1:24:11I think blog feed readers, publishing platforms,

1:24:16they're not as easy as they should be.

1:24:19And that's why Twitter and Facebook are so popular in part

1:24:22because it just makes it a lot easier.

1:24:25I was thinking back to,

1:24:28when you wrote, John, about Twitter apps

1:24:32are like a UI playground years ago,

1:24:34it's like there's all this excitement in Twitter apps.

1:24:38And of course, Twitter started discouraging

1:24:41third-party apps and that kind of faded away. But there was a time where people were having

1:24:45a lot of fun building these apps because you could do so much in the UI with such a simple

1:24:52idea. And I think that simple idea can be for other blogs, not just Twitter. It should be that

1:24:59easy to post to your own site, basically. That's a good way to put it. You should write that down.

1:25:05It should be micro.blog. It should be that easy to post to your own site.

1:25:11- That's good. - And you support things.

1:25:12You've got support for things like photos.

1:25:15So you could, if you wanted to,

1:25:17somebody's micro.blog feed might just be like a sort of,

1:25:22I follow you there, and you often post updates

1:25:25about your work on micro.blog itself.

1:25:28It's sort of like your public record of,

1:25:31here's the progress I'm making on this thing

1:25:33that I know that people are following along with.

1:25:36But somebody else could do it

1:25:38and effectively use their micro.blog

1:25:40like their own personal self-hosted Instagram, where they just post like a, you know, take one

1:25:46nice photo every day and post it. Yep. Yeah. And I'm seeing a lot of that. I'm really happy to see

1:25:51it. And that the official microdubler app tries to kind of encourage that by having, you know,

1:25:56it's not as full feature as Instagram, but it has the filters and it has square photos, which

1:26:02actually turns out they work really well in timelines like that. And it just make it really

1:26:07easy to post photos.

1:26:10And I think that's really important.

1:26:11I think like photo blogging is like a really important kind of variation on microblogging.

1:26:17You don't have to write a lot.

1:26:19You can, everyone takes photos.

1:26:21Sometimes they're really good and worth sharing.

1:26:23And Instagram is an interesting point now too as being part of Facebook.

1:26:28I'm not going to say there's going to be a pushback against Instagram.

1:26:31Like Instagram is probably not going anywhere.

1:26:33I still love Instagram.

1:26:35But I think there are a lot of people that are aware of the trade-offs with using Instagram

1:26:41and Facebook, and they love the idea of having those photos on their own blog as kind of

1:26:46like the first they go to my blog, and the next they optionally go to Twitter or Instagram.

1:26:53Making money is often in conflict with simplicity.

1:26:59That's a broad statement, but I think it's often true.

1:27:03And I think Instagram is an example of that, where I still like Instagram a lot, but I

1:27:08don't like it as much as I used to when Instagram was just square photos with filters, and there

1:27:15was nothing else.

1:27:17I get the stories thing now.

1:27:19I don't really—I posted like—I went through a car wash a couple weeks ago, and I love

1:27:25being in it.

1:27:26Ever since I was a kid, I like driving my car through a car wash.

1:27:29It's just like neat sounds.

1:27:31I don't know, and it looks cool.

1:27:32so I posted an Instagram story from the car wash.

1:27:35But for the most part, I don't really get the idea

1:27:38of posting something that's gonna disappear.

1:27:40It just doesn't fit me personality-wise.

1:27:45There's all sorts of stuff that I would never post

1:27:47to the internet just because,

1:27:49obviously I'm a public person in terms of my writing

1:27:54and stuff, but I'm in large part pretty private.

1:27:57So I don't do things, like I don't check,

1:28:00when I go to a restaurant, I don't check in.

1:28:01I've never done that.

1:28:02I don't understand it.

1:28:03I don't know why I would want to.

1:28:05I don't know why I'd want other people

1:28:07to know what restaurant I'm at, et cetera.

1:28:09But I just feel, I can kind of ignore it in Instagram,

1:28:14but it just, I don't know.

1:28:16It just seems to me like two different things,

1:28:19whereas I look at, like I'm looking at micro.blog right now

1:28:23and I'm scrolling down and it's like,

1:28:24well, this is just nice.

1:28:25It's just like a list of things I signed up to see

1:28:27and then the only things that are there

1:28:29the date that they were posted, a reply button, and a favorite button. And that's it. I like that.

1:28:35Brent Durand (01h00m 11s): Yeah. The idea is kind of back to basics in a way. And of course,

1:28:40no ads and things like that because the business is just helping people post their blog or help

1:28:46make it easier. The business is not to grow to billions of users and put ads in their face.

1:28:51Jim Collins (01h00m 28s): And again, all this stuff that the three of us are talking about today,

1:28:53they all sort of interrelate. And Brent, I think that there's an angle with that with making

1:28:57Evergreen just a free open source Mac app where you've got a day job at Omni Group,

1:29:03which is a company that knows how to make money on software, but that frees you up.

1:29:08Like Evergreen is, it must be liberating in some ways that you don't have to worry about

1:29:12Evergreen selling for $19 a copy or whatever the price would be.

1:29:17It very much is. Yeah. I kept thinking, well, at some point I'll have to deal with licenses

1:29:22and demo version? Do I make a lite version available? And what about when people lose

1:29:27their serial number?" And I'm like, "Ugh, don't make me." And it's just like, "You know, I don't

1:29:33have to do it. All right, so I won't make that money, but whatever, I'm fine."

1:29:37So it's a lot easier to have fun when there's no need to make money.

1:29:46Matt, you've got a complicated relationship with Twitter in history.

1:29:49And so one of the things that you've done in the past is you—I think it's correct to talk about

1:29:57it in a past sense—but you had Tweet Library, which was an iPhone app, right?

1:30:04Matt

1:30:04Yeah, it started as an iPad app and then it became a universal app for both iPhone and iPad.

1:30:09And it's, again, it's the same, it's just like with Brent, it's your same obsessions coming back over. Tell us about, what was Tweet Library?

1:30:17Yeah, so and then Tweet Library kind of came out of that same period that I referenced too, of like lots of innovation in Twitter apps.

1:30:23And my take on it was, it actually kind of fits in with your Instagram comment too, is like, why would I want to post something that disappears?

1:30:32And I feel the same way. I kind of experimented with Instagram stories, but I don't have a Snapchat account.

1:30:38To me, if I'm taking a picture or I'm writing something, if I'm bothering to write it down, it kind of matters to me.

1:30:44And so I want it to last forever as long as possible. I want it to be in my domain name, and I want to be able to find it later.

1:30:51And so Tweet Library was along those lines of, "How can I download all my tweets, search them, filter them by keywords or date, maybe export them or collect tweets together?"

1:31:01And back then, Twitter was, I mean, Twitter has some,

1:31:06it has better search now, at least in the website,

1:31:09has better like collecting tweets together.

1:31:12But back then it was much more difficult

1:31:14to find old tweets.

1:31:15And so I wanted an app that could do that.

1:31:18You're right in the past tense, I don't sell it anymore.

1:31:22It was hard to let that app go,

1:31:24but I went through a phase of being very frustrated

1:31:28Twitter and it didn't make much sense to keep working on that app for that reason

1:31:34and also just because there were other apps that started to do the same thing.

1:31:37Yeah and it's a semi-recent thing but they now, Twitter does now have a thing

1:31:43where you can say send me an archive of all of my tweets from history and then

1:31:47like two days later you get an email with like a download link. Yeah and I

1:31:51actually added a feature to tweet library where you could, yeah you get a

1:31:54download link that's like a zip file and I you could import that directly into

1:31:57which was really great because the first version of Tweet Library couldn't do that.

1:32:01You basically had to run the app every once in a while, make sure it downloaded everything for you.

1:32:05But you yourself

1:32:09don't really use Twitter anymore?

1:32:13Not really. I got frustrated

1:32:17when Twitter was just becoming

1:32:21developer hostile. We're talking about

1:32:25about feeds a lot, they removed their RSS feeds is one example of something they did,

1:32:30locked down their API a little more, you know, put limits on how big a

1:32:35Twitter app could get in terms of popularity compared to the official app, the whole famous

1:32:40kind of app tokens that they limited and various other shutting down other Twitter apps.

1:32:47And so I kind of left, I kind of threw a fin, left Twitter for a number of years.

1:32:53And in fact, my original Twitter account, which is over 10 years ago now, I do not post to it and don't log in as it ever anymore.

1:33:03As kind of a, I left Twitter, it was actually one year after Steve Jobs died and I collected a bunch of stuff about Steve, a lot of tweets and stuff.

1:33:12And I wanted to mark the occasion of leaving.

1:33:16It's like this is something that I think was great about Twitter, like something that made Twitter really special.

1:33:21And so I just haven't touched it.

1:33:22I just let it be what it is.

1:33:24And I feel like if I went back to that account,

1:33:26it would kind of, you know, it would like cheapen

1:33:30like what I was trying to capture.

1:33:33And that was like five years ago now, I guess,

1:33:35four or five years ago.

1:33:36And so what I have done though,

1:33:37is I created a separate Twitter account,

1:33:40Manton2 where I cross post stuff.

1:33:42So if I post something in my blog,

1:33:43automatically cross posts to Twitter.

1:33:45And I started as an experiment and I thought I would stop,

1:33:48but I just kind of kept doing it anyway

1:33:51for people who don't have feed readers and they want to kind of keep up with my blog,

1:33:55they can follow that account.

1:33:56Or if they want to effectively use Twitter as a sort of poor man's feed reader.

1:34:01Exactly.

1:34:02And I know a lot of people do that.

1:34:03I personally, I mean, if that works for you, I guess that's great.

1:34:06But I mean, I love traditional feed readers and hope to see more activity, obviously,

1:34:11in feed readers with JSON feed and whatnot.

1:34:13So that doesn't work for me, but if it works for you, you know, you can follow Twitter

1:34:17accounts that way.

1:34:20So where do you see, how do you think the launch of Microdublog has gone so far?

1:34:26I think overall good.

1:34:28It's very limited, of course, with Kickstarter backers.

1:34:32It wasn't, honestly, it wasn't really ready when I opened it up to Kickstarter backers.

1:34:37Like, it needed probably a few more weeks, at least, of baking.

1:34:41And there were bugs and there were issues.

1:34:45And so I'm obviously really glad that it was limited to a smaller audience.

1:34:49But I feel like we've worked through a bunch of those.

1:34:51I feel like it still has,

1:34:53there's still a bunch of things to improve.

1:34:55And, you know, there's a bunch for me to work on

1:34:59before the public launch.

1:35:00But overall, I think it's good.

1:35:02And I think it's resonating with certain people.

1:35:04You know, some people don't get it and that's okay.

1:35:06But some people are excited about it

1:35:08and kind of get the potential

1:35:10for what it's trying to do with blogs.

1:35:12- Now, one of the things you were able to do

1:35:14through the Kickstarter, I think it was like a extra level,

1:35:17but you made enough through the Kickstarter where you said,

1:35:20if we hit this level, I'll hire a community,

1:35:23what's Jean's title?

1:35:27- Yeah, community manager was--

1:35:29- You hired the great Jean McDonald of,

1:35:32formerly at Smile Software, AppCamp for Girls co-founder,

1:35:37and all-around amazing person.

1:35:39She's, what's, community coordinator?

1:35:43- I guess, so when I wrote the Kickstarter update

1:35:46about halfway through talking about like a stretch goal

1:35:49for the project community manager was the term I used.

1:35:53Now, Jean, I mean, I didn't think I'd be so lucky

1:35:56to get someone as great as her

1:35:58with so much experience that she has.

1:35:59So I don't know if that term is perfect anymore

1:36:03for everything that I think she's gonna be able to help

1:36:06with the project, but yeah, I couldn't be happier.

1:36:09I mean, she's got great experience, Smile and AppCamp.

1:36:13And I wanted to, I didn't want to wait to address issues

1:36:18of potential just kind of hate and harassment

1:36:22and the kind of problems that we see

1:36:25almost kind of run unchecked sometimes on Twitter.

1:36:27I mean, I don't completely blame Twitter for some of that,

1:36:31but I do kind of blame them for not trying to work

1:36:35on that stuff earlier.

1:36:36And so my thought is start earlier,

1:36:40try to get out in front of those kinds of issues.

1:36:42and then it won't blow up into a huge problem

1:36:44because it's very difficult after it becomes a problem.

1:36:47And like I said, I don't completely blame Twitter

1:36:49because it's hard for them to solve now.

1:36:51If they had started earlier,

1:36:53maybe it wouldn't be quite as bad.

1:36:55- It's like any kind of infestation.

1:36:58The earlier you can address it, the better.

1:37:01Or even if you're redoing your patio or your deck,

1:37:10If you make sure that the door closes with a good seal

1:37:13to keep ants out, it's better to do it now

1:37:16than to wait 'til you've got an ant infestation

1:37:19in your house.

1:37:20And I don't know, I think Twitter sort of,

1:37:23I know people there, and I know that there's,

1:37:26I don't think there's a single person at the company

1:37:27who's happy about the abuse that takes place

1:37:30on the platform, but I think that they've chalked it up

1:37:33to, ah, we'll fix it eventually.

1:37:35But once it takes root, it's a lot harder to take care of.

1:37:39So I think it was very smart for you to treat this as a,

1:37:44hey, here's something that's on my plate

1:37:46while it's still a Kickstarter.

1:37:48And it's an idea in my head,

1:37:50as opposed to waiting until it might be too late.

1:37:53- Yeah, and because some of these things

1:37:55need to be addressed through design and features,

1:37:59not just hiring more people to police tweets, right?

1:38:03So there's some things inherent in how Twitter works

1:38:07with reposting, with hashtags and search and trending.

1:38:11There's a lot of areas where people

1:38:16will get attention that they don't want,

1:38:19is I guess a simplified way to put it.

1:38:21And so it's almost impossible to change some of those.

1:38:23There's like fundamental ways that Twitter works.

1:38:26And sometimes those are great things.

1:38:28Like I said, I tried to highlight when I left Twitter,

1:38:32like some of the great things that Twitter enables,

1:38:34but sometimes not good things happen

1:38:37because of the way features work.

1:38:38So with Micro.bo, I didn't wanna just copy

1:38:42every Twitter feature.

1:38:43I wanted to think about every single feature,

1:38:47every part of the UI, the design of the app,

1:38:50just to see if it would be one of those things

1:38:54where people could be harassed, for example.

1:38:57And so it is, again, back to basics, it's limited

1:39:01and we'll be adding more features,

1:39:02but there's some things we won't add

1:39:04because I feel like they encourage bad behavior.

1:39:07- So one of the things that's interesting about it

1:39:09is that it's like Twitter,

1:39:12a micro.blog post has just one text field.

1:39:15You just type in it and then you hit post

1:39:17and it's posted so you don't have to come up with a title.

1:39:19In fact, you can't, there are no titles.

1:39:22- Right.

1:39:23- I think you're exactly right,

1:39:26you mentioned this a couple minutes ago,

1:39:27where I think that that's so freeing in some ways,

1:39:32And I often think about it with email, where I don't like to half-ass my subjects, but

1:39:38there's a lot of times where I'll sit there and stare at the subject and I think,

1:39:42"You know what?

1:39:43Screw it.

1:39:44I'll just hit them up on iMessage instead," because then I don't have to come up with

1:39:46the subject.

1:39:48It's a weird psychological barrier.

1:39:52I would never think to do a site like Daring Fireball without titles, because that's

1:39:57my job, and it's something I take very carefully.

1:40:02So I don't mind the formality of always having a title.

1:40:06And I don't really expose them.

1:40:08But all 17 years worth of-- or however long,

1:40:1415 years of daring fireball posts--

1:40:16have tags with categories and stuff like that.

1:40:19I don't mind that because I feel like, hey, this is my job.

1:40:23I should straighten up, smooth out the wrinkles in my shirt,

1:40:26make sure I don't have crumbs on my face.

1:40:28Whereas when I'm just shooting off at the hip on Twitter,

1:40:30Who gives a shit?

1:40:31- Yeah, and different kind of workflows

1:40:36work for different people.

1:40:38And I think that for some people that's totally fine,

1:40:42just like throw out whatever thing on Twitter.

1:40:45But there's a lot of people that I think would benefit

1:40:48from maybe a little thinking about it a little bit

1:40:51before they post something.

1:40:55- Maybe like our president?

1:40:56(laughing)

1:40:57Just say him.

1:40:58- Maybe, maybe just a little.

1:41:00But anyway, blogging should be easier, it should be as easy as Twitter.

1:41:05You should still think about what you're posting.

1:41:07But for some people they don't care if it lasts, they don't care if it's searchable or they can find it again.

1:41:13But for other people the idea that even if I'm just like this quick comment or joke on Twitter, even that is worth keeping.

1:41:21It's worth having my own domain name, it's worth being able to find later and link to.

1:41:26And so it just depends. That's what you want to get out of it.

1:41:29want to get out of it. So differences between micro dot blog and twitter, one of them

1:41:34and again full circle comes to one of our creations. You support markdown for

1:41:38text formatting, which I've seen people suggest that twitter should

1:41:43do. And I kind of think that they can't now. There's no way that they can like

1:41:48there's a sort of expectation in twitter that if you type an asterisk and then a word

1:41:53and then another asterisk that you're going to see the asterisks, you know, uh yeah,

1:41:57- Yeah, it might be too late.

1:41:59- But you also have--

1:42:00- And the idea there is just like,

1:42:01tweets are fine, I guess.

1:42:03But like, if you look at a short tweet-like post,

1:42:08and instead of having like a bunch of URLs

1:42:11at the end of it or something,

1:42:12if it has inline links and maybe something's in bold,

1:42:16like look at both of those side to side

1:42:19and it looks really great.

1:42:21- Yeah.

1:42:22- Like it just really looks nice

1:42:24when you use like just simple markdown

1:42:26And it just, when you're scrolling through your timeline and something's in bold and then there's an

1:42:31inline link or something, it just looks really nice.

1:42:33And you don't have to, you know, do a microblog post that way, but you can.

1:42:37I think it just adds something, a kind of a clarity to the

1:42:42timeline.

1:42:43There's an underappreciated aspect to writing for the web.

1:42:46And I maybe somebody has written about it in a way, but I've never seen it, but

1:42:52it's like just implicit rather than explicitly talked about.

1:42:56And I certainly don't think anybody learns about it

1:42:58in school, even though I think it should be taught

1:43:00the same way other forms of grammar are,

1:43:01which is where do you put a link?

1:43:04What words do you use for the link

1:43:06when you're linking to something?

1:43:07I think very carefully about it every time

1:43:09I put a link in my writing, like which words.

1:43:12And it bothers me sometimes, and I often notice it

1:43:15in like articles at like a old,

1:43:18long-standing print publication, like a newspaper,

1:43:21where if the New York Times is writing about something

1:43:25Washington Post reported it first. They'll say this was first reported in an article by the

1:43:29Washington Post, and they'll make the link just the word article. And I think, no, it should be

1:43:33like article by the Washington Post. Like add a couple more words to that link.

1:43:37Yeah. I wonder if they're almost trying to hide the link.

1:43:42That's what I think. No, that's exactly what I read into that, though. I read at this meta level

1:43:48when I see the links, and I think, oh, they're, you know, they're, that's exactly what I think.

1:43:52I think that's sort of like, you know, they're throwing shade on them by making the link as

1:43:57short as possible. Like, all right, we'll give you credit for this, but we're going to make it

1:44:00as inconspicuous as possible. And I do think that I think that we've, in some ways, we've gone

1:44:08backwards with these posting formats like Twitter and Facebook, where if you want to have a URL,

1:44:14you have to show the whole URL.

1:44:16It's not that-- there were some people who've

1:44:22pushed for URLs being completely hidden,

1:44:25and the way that browsers have sort of-- they still

1:44:28haven't done away with them entirely.

1:44:30But Safari typically just shows your domain name

1:44:36in the location field until you click in the location field,

1:44:38and then it shows the whole URL.

1:44:40They've slowly but surely made them,

1:44:42tried to make them less of a user-facing thing.

1:44:47But we've ended up in this world where

1:44:49when you share URLs on Twitter and stuff like that,

1:44:52you have to see the whole ugly thing.

1:44:53And so many people have CMS systems

1:44:56that generate these ugly URLs.

1:44:58And even if you don't have ugly URLs, all of these people

1:45:01now post these UTM turds for SEO tracking

1:45:06or whatever the hell they're for.

1:45:07And so the URLs have gotten uglier over time,

1:45:11and we're stuck looking at them.

1:45:13- Yeah, and Twitter tries to clean them up a little bit,

1:45:17like truncate's part of them, but yeah,

1:45:20it can get really, a lot of clutter.

1:45:23- Very clutter, and just being able to do square bracket,

1:45:27end square bracket, put the URL in parentheses afterwards,

1:45:30and then have it render just as a nice word.

1:45:34Like, who would have thought in 1996 that in 2017

1:45:38we'd be saying, you know what's nice?

1:45:39It's a blocking system where you can make links.

1:45:42(laughing)

1:45:44It doesn't seem like something that we would be praising

1:45:48a new blocking platform for in 2017, but there it is.

1:45:53And that's the thing.

1:45:53- It's the basis for the entire web.

1:45:55- Right.

1:45:56- I mean.

1:45:58- And like, if there's one theme that underscores

1:46:00a lot of what we've talked about today,

1:46:02it's like, things should be better.

1:46:03Like we deserve a better web by now, right?

1:46:06And like, I think Twitter should have evolved

1:46:09more quickly, they ran into issues and leadership changes

1:46:13and whatnot and that happens, but it should be better.

1:46:17Feed readers should, I mean feed readers should

1:46:19in some cases work, should embrace ideas

1:46:22from social networks.

1:46:23And yeah, so there's progress to be made

1:46:26and I'm excited for that because what Brent said

1:46:30about these themes in his life of working on an outliner,

1:46:34writing on his blog, these things that last

1:46:38and he's still happy doing 20 years later.

1:46:41I feel the same way about blogging.

1:46:42I can't believe actually it took me this long

1:46:44to build a blogging platform.

1:46:45I probably should have built one a long time ago.

1:46:48But I'm glad that there's still unsolved problems.

1:46:50There's still room for improvement.

1:46:52- I think that I don't wanna be too melodramatic,

1:46:55but I feel like Google Reader was a catastrophe

1:46:59in the sense of the meteor that killed all the dinosaurs

1:47:04a couple hundred million years ago.

1:47:06Google Reader became so popular and so central.

1:47:10And it was even-- because it was central and it had APIs,

1:47:13it was-- even for people who didn't look at Google Reader,

1:47:16like NetNewswire had to support it as the syncing engine.

1:47:20I'm looking at NetNewswire, but it's

1:47:22using Google Reader behind the scenes

1:47:24to do the syncing so that an app on my iPhone

1:47:27can see the same read on read status

1:47:29and have the same subscription feeds.

1:47:31And when Google Reader went away,

1:47:33it did so much damage to the open web.

1:47:36And it's our own fault for letting the open web become

1:47:39so dependent on one centralized proprietary thing

1:47:43from a company.

1:47:44Like the open web thrives when there's multiplicity.

1:47:49But it is funny, though.

1:47:50I feel like in hindsight, it was bad for the web

1:47:54that Google Reader went away.

1:47:55And I've said it before, traffic during Fireball plummeted.

1:47:58I mean, I lost 25% of my page views per month just like that,

1:48:03just gone.

1:48:03And it never returned.

1:48:05Luckily, I don't think readership is down.

1:48:07I just think the number of times a day

1:48:09that people came to the site went down

1:48:11because Google Reader was their way

1:48:12to get notified when something new was posted.

1:48:16Thankfully, I never monetized the site by page views.

1:48:20It was always based on how many people

1:48:22and what I could charge sponsors per week.

1:48:23But other sites that had page view-based things

1:48:26lost 25% of their revenue just like that.

1:48:31But much like the catastrophe of the meteor,

1:48:34There has been an awful lot,

1:48:37like there's so many more feed syncing services now

1:48:40than there were when Google Reader went away.

1:48:42Just quietly, the feed, I don't want to say industry

1:48:47because that's the wrong word,

1:48:48but the community surrounding feeds

1:48:50has sort of routed around that,

1:48:52and it's good that there's so many options now

1:48:54for things like syncing feeds.

1:48:56I don't know if you guys agree. - Yeah, definitely.

1:49:00Yeah, and it's kind of like,

1:49:02well, maybe these small mammals will take over now that the dinosaurs are dead, and

1:49:07something good will come of that.

1:49:09Dave: People definitely still read Daring Fireball through feed readers. I just looked

1:49:13at it the other day and how many hits there are to the feed, and they come from a wide

1:49:18variety of sources. Wait, there's no one dominant feed reader anymore, which I think is a good

1:49:23thing.

1:49:24Tim Cynova Yeah, I think so, too.

1:49:25Dave: All right, I got one more sponsor to thank, and it's our good friends at MailRout.

1:49:30and then I want to talk to you guys a little bit about WWDC

1:49:32and then we'll wrap it up.

1:49:33But our sponsor right now, it's Good Friends at MailRoute.

1:49:37MailRoute is a company, it's the group behind MailRoute

1:49:41has been working together for 20 years.

1:49:44They started in 1997, they were at Microsoft for a while,

1:49:47and now they have their own company, MailRoute.

1:49:50And all they do, this is it,

1:49:52all they do is handle email filtering.

1:49:56You point, if you have a domain name for your company,

1:49:59your personal site, anything like that.

1:50:01You point your MX records for your domain name to mail route.

1:50:04And your mail goes to them first.

1:50:06And then they forward it on to your existing mail server.

1:50:09So they're not hosting your email.

1:50:11Your hosting service stays exactly the same.

1:50:14You don't have to change your clients at all,

1:50:16because they all just talk to the same server.

1:50:18It's just that all incoming email

1:50:19goes through mail route first.

1:50:21And guess what gets filtered out?

1:50:22All of the junk.

1:50:24All the viruses and the scammy, spammy attachments,

1:50:28All that stuff just goes away.

1:50:31And MailRout has APIs, so if you're an expert,

1:50:34if you're a professional system administrator,

1:50:35you can write, integrate it with your software.

1:50:37They have APIs that you can connect to.

1:50:39They have great user-facing stuff,

1:50:42so the users can go there and get a report

1:50:46of which emails got filtered and stuff like that,

1:50:48see a list of the ones that are maybe in the gray area

1:50:52just to double-check it with your eyeballs if you want to.

1:50:55Everybody's getting out of this business.

1:50:57Even Google has come out recently and said that they encourage people who use Google

1:51:00Apps for email, for their company email, to use a gateway service like MailRoute first

1:51:05so that they don't have to be the front line of filtering out your email.

1:51:08It's a terrific, terrific service.

1:51:10I personally know a bunch of people who use MailRoute on their domains now, and I don't

1:51:14know a single person who's started using MailRoute who's stopped.

1:51:19It's so good.

1:51:20It does one thing.

1:51:21They do one thing really well.

1:51:24And I don't even know who's second place is in the business.

1:51:27It's so great.

1:51:29And I think they have one of the best offers

1:51:31you're ever, ever gonna hear from a sponsor.

1:51:33You go to mailroute.net/tts.

1:51:36That's like the initials, the talk show, mailroute.net/tts.

1:51:39You get a 30-day free trial.

1:51:41And then when you sign up through that link,

1:51:43you get 10% off for the lifetime of your account.

1:51:47So like I said a couple weeks ago,

1:51:49you could be using them for 20 years

1:51:51and you'll still be saving 10%.

1:51:53It's an amazing deal.

1:51:53you'll save tons of money.

1:51:55So go to mailroute.net/tts.

1:51:58So WWDC's coming up.

1:52:01You guys are going, right?

1:52:03- Oh yeah.

1:52:04- Man, are you coming?

1:52:05- Well, not actually going to the conference,

1:52:06but everything else.

1:52:09- The same here.

1:52:10I'm not going to the conference, but I'll be there.

1:52:11I'll be there for a few days.

1:52:13- I think it's gonna be so weird.

1:52:15The three of us have been in WWDC for a long time now,

1:52:21at least the last 10 years or so.

1:52:22I think we've been, I've been to everyone,

1:52:24I think you guys have too, or at least most of them,

1:52:27and we hang out together and we go to the same restaurants

1:52:30and we drink beer at the same places and it's,

1:52:33I'm ready for a shakeup, but I think it's gonna be

1:52:36so bizarre because it's, I am sort of a creature of habit

1:52:39and it's gonna be weird not being able to go

1:52:42to the House of Shields.

1:52:43- That's exactly my thought too.

1:52:45It's like we always know we'll end up

1:52:47at the House of Shields at the end of the night.

1:52:49Everything else may be up in the air,

1:52:50but we have that one habit especially.

1:52:54- If we had to do it this time,

1:52:55that's gonna be a story.

1:52:57- Yeah, that's probably a mistake.

1:53:00I know, yeah, we'll work it out.

1:53:02I mean, you know, somehow it'll be different.

1:53:05- All right, one of the events that is going on at WWDC

1:53:08is there's gonna be a screening of App the Human Story.

1:53:12That's a documentary movie.

1:53:13It's been in the work for a couple of years now,

1:53:15but it's finally coming out as a real deal.

1:53:20a terrific documentary that I was interviewed for it, Brent, I know you are. I'm looking

1:53:27at the website right now, and it's actually a picture of you, Brent, at your computer,

1:53:30footage from the movie. So there's going to be a—

1:53:33It's me at Omni, actually, right there.

1:53:35Is it really?

1:53:36Mm-hmm.

1:53:37Boy, that's a nice desk. There's a screening. I don't know. As we speak right now, it looks

1:53:42like there's a lot of open tickets available. By the time this episode airs, I don't know

1:53:45if that's true or not, but if it is, you can go to the show notes, and I will have

1:53:48a link to where you can sign up for this. But they are selling tickets to a screening

1:53:54June 4th, that's Sunday, the day before the WWDC keynote, right there in San Jose.

1:54:01So if you're going to be in the area, either if you live there or if you're going to

1:54:05be in the area for WWDC, you can go. And then afterwards, there's going to be a panel

1:54:08discussion that—I think I'm actually leading the panel discussion. Brent, I know you're

1:54:13on the panel talking about the movie. So this is going to be great. And the best thing about

1:54:18Is this screening, all the proceeds for it are going to AppCamp for girls, which is a terrific program.

1:54:26So there's that. I don't know what else you guys want to talk about.

1:54:30If you have one wish for WWDC for Apple to announce, what would it be?

1:54:34Bug fixes for Mac OS.

1:54:38Matt?

1:54:40I think Siri improvements for Siri for developers.

1:54:44I think I'm a big fan of the Echo

1:54:47and I think Amazon in some ways is way ahead.

1:54:50So I don't know if there'll be any hardware or anything,

1:54:53but I think there needs to be more

1:54:56with the developer SDK for Siri.

1:55:01With the Echo you can do like,

1:55:03there's thousands of skills and stuff you can add

1:55:05to the Echo and the Apple needs, I think more here.

1:55:09I think they can do more.

1:55:10- They've effectively taken the opposite approach,

1:55:12where last year when they announced SiriKit,

1:55:14they were like, and SiriKit works for the following

1:55:17like three or four things.

1:55:19So like, and some of them are useful,

1:55:21like ride hailing services, right?

1:55:23So you can like tell Siri to get you an Uber,

1:55:26and because ride hailing service is one of like

1:55:29the three or four hard-coded things that it does,

1:55:33the Uber app has APIs to say, okay,

1:55:36when somebody asks for a ride,

1:55:37you know, do call these things and then all of a sudden you're in the uber app and it's getting you an uber or a lift or whichever one you want.

1:55:44Um, but like hard coding the ideas for what you're going to do is not the way that software platforms take off because the thing that's popular is never predicted in advance.

1:55:57Well, yeah, it's so limiting and I understand why they did it that way.

1:56:00And there are some advantages like for localization is a big one.

1:56:04Apple can handle some of the details about the phrasing in different languages.

1:56:08That's important.

1:56:10But I want to be able to do more.

1:56:13I mean, we've been talking about blogging a lot.

1:56:15I mean, I should be able to ask Siri to post to my blog.

1:56:17And right now, I guess I could maybe overload the messaging part of Siri,

1:56:22but that sounds like a hack.

1:56:24And so I think at the very least, Apple needs to, let's say, add 30 or 40 new types of things that Siri can do

1:56:32and maybe even have another one that's like, oh, and anything.

1:56:38Some more flexible way to extend it.

1:56:40I think that they know that.

1:56:42I'm not putting out the idea that Apple thought

1:56:45that having three or four things that Siri could do

1:56:47was the be all end all.

1:56:48I think that they shipped what was ready to ship,

1:56:51and it was better to ship it in a limited form

1:56:53than not ship it at all.

1:56:55And I agree with that.

1:56:57It's better that you can at least send messages

1:57:00through this than if you couldn't do anything.

1:57:02But I really hope that this has been a productive year

1:57:05for the Siri kit team.

1:57:07I think that's a good wish.

1:57:09And I almost feel like if it's not,

1:57:13it's a warning sign about this current state of Apple

1:57:16as a company and are they able to keep moving fast

1:57:20and in new directions because it feels like something

1:57:23they really should be doing.

1:57:25I'm also with you Brent.

1:57:26I hope that the Mac announcements are relatively quiet

1:57:30that it's not really about, wow, lots of new stuff in macOS. I really hope that it's sort of a quiet,

1:57:35snow leopard style. We're actually just making stuff more reliable.

1:57:41Jared: Yeah, that'd be great. macOS, it's mature. They don't need to force themselves to find new

1:57:47features for it. Just, you know, make it faster and fix bugs. Yep.

1:57:53Anything else you guys wanted to talk about?

1:57:56Or did I hit everything?

1:57:58Anything about Evergreen or JSON feed or micro.blog

1:58:02that I didn't ask about but you wanted to talk about?

1:58:05- That would be covered a lot.

1:58:09- I'll take it as a no.

1:58:11(laughing)

1:58:13- You know, I like all this stuff fits together.

1:58:17- It really does.

1:58:18- It just does, yeah.

1:58:19And I like that a lot.

1:58:20- I even like how it fits together with Markdown

1:58:22where people will be writing their blog posts

1:58:24in markdown format and posting them to their micro.blog,

1:58:28and then people will read those things in Evergreen.

1:58:32Pretty nice.

1:58:35Anyway, the other thing that I just love,

1:58:37and I just had a podcast with Jim Dalrymple

1:58:39and signed off the same way,

1:58:40I love being able to say right now,

1:58:42I will see you too soon, and I look forward to it.

1:58:45- Yeah, cool, right on.

1:58:48- See you in San Jose.

1:58:49[BLANK_AUDIO]