Podcast Search

The Talk Show

190: ‘Anything Luxury’ With Ben Thompson

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Lots to talk about. What do you want to start with? Do you want to start with this Microsoft Build keynote?

0:00:05Yeah, it was interesting. Did you watch it?

0:00:10No, I didn't watch it.

0:00:13I was going to, but I ran out of time.

0:00:15Yeah, sorry. I failed to bell you out there.

0:00:18It was good. It was funny. I really liked it as I was listening to it.

0:00:21There was very much a coherent vision that took the idea of, "What's going on?

0:00:28took the idea of Microsoft, by necessity, has to

0:00:33leap over the mobile area.

0:00:36And to an extent they certainly have in the cloud, but painting a vision beyond that.

0:00:41And from a big picture, what I liked best is that at previous builds, there's always two keynotes.

0:00:46And the first day is usually the Windows keynote, and

0:00:51the second day is the Azure keynote, and this year it's the opposite. Azure is the first day and Windows is the second day.

0:00:56and I think that's appropriate because that's realistically where Microsoft's growth and opportunities are.

0:01:01So from that perspective, I enjoyed it.

0:01:05I think the problem though is all that stuff on the edge, Microsoft talked about building a sort of thing from the cloud away the edge,

0:01:13like they don't have very many edge endpoints and that continues to be a problem.

0:01:17Edge being the devices that people use. Is that what you mean?

0:01:22Yeah, yeah, exactly. I mean, even on not just mobile devices, but also sort of on computers.

0:01:28I mean, the big computer, the big criticism I've always had for Microsoft, and even under Satya Daddala,

0:01:34is they've done a great job of sort of locking in the folks that they've always had.

0:01:40But if you're a new company starting today, which piece of Microsoft software are you going to buy and why?

0:01:46And Microsoft doesn't have a very good answer for that question.

0:01:49Yeah, that's a very good point. I would buy none. You would probably buy Excel, right?

0:01:58Yeah, I have Office 365. I actually use that for my email, in part because I vastly prefer using

0:02:06email on an offline client, even if it's Outlook, as opposed to... The problem with Gmail is I have

0:02:11an assistant, so I have some shared mailboxes, and it only supports shared mailboxes through the

0:02:15through the online interface.

0:02:16So that's honestly the reason why I use Office 365.

0:02:19But yeah, but I mean, beyond that,

0:02:23I used Google Docs for a year,

0:02:25or Google Apps, I should say, or whatever it's called,

0:02:27for the first several years,

0:02:29and there's times I miss it, times I don't.

0:02:32But realistically, it's not really,

0:02:34if it wasn't for my own personal,

0:02:36I can choose software based on my own personal foibles.

0:02:38If I were an administrator,

0:02:40if Chuckery was a larger company,

0:02:42I'm sure I would be on Google.

0:02:45I mean, I'm obviously an edge case in that I've lived a Windows-free life my entire life.

0:02:52But off the top of my head, the only Microsoft software I can think that I use regularly

0:02:56is right now Skype.

0:02:58I don't think I use anything else.

0:03:00I haven't had Microsoft Office in, oh my god, at least 10 years.

0:03:06I don't even remember.

0:03:08I don't know if I ever even used it on Mac OS X.

0:03:13you're probably better off for that case.

0:03:16But I mean, if you use Excel, like for real,

0:03:19which I rarely do, but the occasional times I do,

0:03:23it's like there's numbers is not really competitive.

0:03:26If you want to just display stuff,

0:03:27like make a little chart,

0:03:29numbers is actually arguably better and easier.

0:03:32And certainly, you know,

0:03:33Excel makes some really ugly charts.

0:03:35But there are some things I occasionally do on Excel that,

0:03:39I mean, numbers just, it's not,

0:03:42Numbers is what it is.

0:03:44It serves its role well.

0:03:45It's not an Excel competitor, though.

0:03:46I don't know.

0:03:47I have nothing to do with Excel.

0:03:48I haven't used Excel in a long time, but I was never a serious spreadsheet person.

0:03:51But when I've seen serious spreadsheets, it's a very impressive piece of software.

0:03:56Yeah, it's kind of like the ... People have made this point before, but it's very true.

0:04:01It really is sort of the programming language for normal people.

0:04:05Yes.

0:04:06If you think about it, people bend it to do all kinds of crazy things, in part because

0:04:11it's offering in-place computation in a way that is accessible for normal people who don't

0:04:18know how to code it. Obviously there's VB, there's basic or whatever it's called, virtual

0:04:21VB, I can't even remember what it's called. VB script or whatever.

0:04:25VB basic. Yeah, whatever the scripting language is. So you can do actual programming, which

0:04:29again is still different than, still pretty basic, but even just using a cell equals this

0:04:37cell plus that cell divided by that cell. That's programming. In that respect, it's

0:04:42even more impressive when you think of it in that light.

0:04:45Even back in 1991, when I was a freshman in college, as a freshman, I ended up switching

0:04:53to computer science the next year, but as a freshman, I was an engineering major. There

0:04:58was a mandatory intro to programming course, but not—again, this wasn't the computer

0:05:06sciences was, you know, and it was all, it was ridiculous for me. I mean, I was like a,

0:05:11in like the, on the, on the computer programming team in high school. I was, I was, it was great

0:05:18for me. I was the type of student you're, I don't know if you were the same, but when I got a course

0:05:21like that, I didn't try to place out of it. I was just like, oh, this is great. I don't have to do

0:05:25any work. But we ended up, I think, like second half of the thing was like an intro to Pascal,

0:05:32which dates me, and we were still learning Pascal.

0:05:36But I think the first month of the course

0:05:38was all spent in Excel.

0:05:40It was sort of like Excel was the,

0:05:42this is how you learn to program.

0:05:44And I think--

0:05:45- Oh, that's interesting, 'cause it's trying

0:05:47to build the mindset, not necessarily build.

0:05:48- Exactly. - Yeah,

0:05:49that makes a ton of sense, yeah.

0:05:51- And honestly, going through life,

0:05:53I bet more engineers do programming in Excel

0:05:56than writing source code, I mean, at least in some ways.

0:06:01I think the other thing that Excel has, and all spreadsheets,

0:06:04but the thing that they have that really makes them

0:06:07is so much more approachable for people

0:06:09who think they can't program but are actually

0:06:11creating their own custom programmatic things,

0:06:13is it makes data structures completely visual.

0:06:18So there's this entire layer of abstraction

0:06:21of creating a data structure that is completely removed.

0:06:24You just see it.

0:06:25and so much data actually fits conceptually in a grid,

0:06:30and you don't even know it, you don't realize

0:06:33that as you're setting up this two-dimensional,

0:06:35and I know you can do three-dimensional stuff too,

0:06:37but even if it's just a simple little

0:06:39two-dimensional spreadsheet,

0:06:41you're creating a data structure,

0:06:42but you're not really thinking about it that way.

0:06:45- Yeah, I think that's exactly it,

0:06:46and you can visualize, you can literally visualize

0:06:50how the numbers are moving around

0:06:52and moving through equations.

0:06:55you're debugging, you don't even realize you are,

0:06:57but that's exactly what's going on.

0:06:59- Anyway, nothing but good things to say about Excel.

0:07:01So what else happened at this keynote?

0:07:02What are they talking about?

0:07:03What's the big, what do people need to know

0:07:07about where Microsoft wants people to go?

0:07:09And build it, for those who don't know,

0:07:11it's their developer conference,

0:07:12so it's not necessarily consumer-focused,

0:07:15but it's what they want people, developers, to do.

0:07:18- Yeah, well, I think that's part of the point,

0:07:21is there really wasn't anything for consumers

0:07:24in this at all.

0:07:25I mean, there was, they had the sort of Cortana skills kit,

0:07:28you know, which it would be, you know,

0:07:30analogous to sort of the Amazon Echo skills,

0:07:33things like that.

0:07:34They have a new database service for Azure

0:07:38called Cosmos DB, which is very interesting.

0:07:40But again, speaking of data structure is not really

0:07:43something that people, you know,

0:07:45most people would think about or care about.

0:07:48And whereas tomorrow or what time is it?

0:07:51Yeah, tomorrow.

0:07:52I always try to speak in terms of US time,

0:07:54even when it's not, but tonight my time.

0:07:57Tomorrow they will have, I think,

0:07:59more consumer-facing stuff, but again,

0:08:01I think it's really emblematic of the shift

0:08:04in the company that that is on day two.

0:08:06And to me, that's kind of the biggest high-level takeaway.

0:08:09- Yeah, it's, they're sort of doing,

0:08:14on their own, volition under Satya Nadella,

0:08:18what some people 10 years ago had,

0:08:21I guess more than 10 years ago at this point,

0:08:24had argued that should be done by law,

0:08:26which is break the Windows division off

0:08:28into its own subsidiary or separate company

0:08:31or something like that.

0:08:32- Yep.

0:08:33- You know, let Microsoft stay focused on the future

0:08:37and let Windows sort of ride out the, you know,

0:08:41the role that it has to play

0:08:42as sort of legacy infrastructure.

0:08:43- Yeah, I think that's exactly right.

0:08:46And I didn't think they were capable of it.

0:08:50Windows was so long, had so much gravitational pull

0:08:55in the company.

0:08:58I mean, to the extent that at one of these keynotes

0:09:00a while ago, Azure was renamed Windows Azure,

0:09:02even though it wasn't really Windows.

0:09:05But yeah, that's a great point.

0:09:07One of my favorite little details here is they announced

0:09:08that you could access the command line in your Azure dashboard

0:09:11or whatever it is, through a web browser or on a mobile app.

0:09:15and it supports Bash today and PowerShell is coming.

0:09:20PowerShell is the command line program for Windows.

0:09:24And to me, that really shows it, right?

0:09:28Which one do they support first?

0:09:30They support Bash because what actually matters

0:09:32for most cloud applications is,

0:09:34what most developers are used to is, you know,

0:09:36Winix and the Winix shell,

0:09:38and so that's what they're serving first.

0:09:41And the Windows part is coming, but it will come soon.

0:09:44- Yeah, it isn't PowerShell in a nutshell.

0:09:46Like, there was the DOS prompt,

0:09:49and PowerShell was sort of the,

0:09:51okay, you want a command line terminal type thing,

0:09:53but DOS is a piece of crap.

0:09:56So here's something modern,

0:09:58and at least maybe not modeled after Unix shells,

0:10:03but at least is as powerful as a Unix shell.

0:10:05- Yeah, I mean, it's a whole thing.

0:10:08I mean, it's a shell and a whole,

0:10:11its own scripting language,

0:10:12and it's now actually open source, but it was released

0:10:16in 2006, I believe, I'm just looking it up.

0:10:19So, I mean, it's very far removed from the sort of DOS days.

0:10:23I mean, it's a proper shell, like it's used very heavily

0:10:27by system administrators and folks that are managing

0:10:30computers and things like that, and it's used on the server.

0:10:32So, I mean, it's a proper shell, but it's not,

0:10:35you know, it's different than, as one would expect,

0:10:38it's different than Bash.

0:10:41Can I just, as an aside, it's so funny,

0:10:42'cause I didn't think we'd be talking about shells,

0:10:44but I, do you ever use, do you use the command line

0:10:48on Mac OS X, you use it sometimes, right?

0:10:50- Yeah, rarely, I have a couple servers that,

0:10:53not my, not the Stryker server that's managed,

0:10:55but I have a few other servers that I do stuff on,

0:10:59and I use it for that, but I rarely,

0:11:01I don't do much scripting on my main computer.

0:11:05- Do you care what shell you use?

0:11:07- No, I don't care at all.

0:11:08I use it very rarely.

0:11:10I've used the Unix shell since at least 1992.

0:11:16That's when I switched to computer science at Drexel.

0:11:20And I know enough to get whatever I need to do done,

0:11:28but I've never enjoyed it.

0:11:30Never really.

0:11:30And I never really liked writing shell scripts.

0:11:33And so if I ever had anything that most people would write a shell script,

0:11:36once I found out about Perl, I just wrote everything in Perl

0:11:39and just treated Perl, if I needed to,

0:11:40as my shell scripting language.

0:11:43So I never really got deep roots.

0:11:45And I know-- I think Mac OS X used to, when it first shipped,

0:11:49was using TCSH as the shell or something.

0:11:53I don't know.

0:11:53And at some point, it switched to Bash,

0:11:55because Bash is the most popular modern scripting language,

0:12:00because Linux uses it, I think.

0:12:03But I never had deep roots.

0:12:06people get tied up and they have like these shelf or files,

0:12:10you know, the, what do you call it, your profile,

0:12:12where you've got all these aliases

0:12:14and all this stuff set up so that you can't really

0:12:16switch shells very easily 'cause you'd have to

0:12:17rewrite it all.

0:12:18So anyway, recently, I switched my shell,

0:12:22or my max, to fish.

0:12:24Have you heard about this shell?

0:12:26- I've heard you chatting about it, but no.

0:12:30- It's fascinating, and I think anybody who has deep roots

0:12:33into a Unix shell is not gonna switch,

0:12:35But it's like a new shell.

0:12:38It's something that this guy, Peter Ammann, made.

0:12:42He's an engineer at Apple.

0:12:44This isn't an Apple project.

0:12:45It's something he did on the side.

0:12:47But it's amazing.

0:12:47And the thing I like about it is it's completely logical

0:12:51in terms of how you do stuff.

0:12:53And it doesn't have any kind of-- by separating itself

0:12:58from the history of Unix shells, it breaks a bunch of things

0:13:04that other Unix shells all do.

0:13:06But just for one thing, one thing that's so nice,

0:13:08is that instead of spewing a whole bunch of dot files,

0:13:12the Unix way of making a file quote, unquote invisible

0:13:15is to start the name with a dot, which is so gross

0:13:18that we're still using that.

0:13:19But you end up with six of these files in your home folder

0:13:26for each shell that you use.

0:13:28'Cause then they're on, they don't have names

0:13:30that make any sense.

0:13:31- No, they drag me up the wall.

0:13:32I know exactly what you're talking about.

0:13:33Right.

0:13:34It doesn't make any sense at all.

0:13:36With Fish, you still have a dot file, but it's a folder.

0:13:43What is it called?

0:13:45It's called-- boy, I'm really exciting tonight, aren't I?

0:13:49I should do this late at night all the time.

0:13:53It's called-- I think it's called like dot config or something

0:13:55like that.

0:13:56And it makes a folder instead of a file.

0:13:59And it's just one folder called dot config.

0:14:02And inside there is where everything else goes.

0:14:11So there's like a folder in .config that says fish.

0:14:15And then inside that folder is all of fish's stuff.

0:14:17So if other utilities use this convention,

0:14:21everything could go nice and neatly into one folder called .config.

0:14:25Anyway, it's really neat.

0:14:26I'll put a link in the show notes to fish.

0:14:28I think it's really neat.

0:14:31So, oh, it reminds me, when was the last time I was on?

0:14:34Um, 2000, January 2017 looks like.

0:14:38And we talked about the Mac a little bit then.

0:14:41And I do have to say, I think pretty much that episode

0:14:44holds up, I think, pretty well after the news

0:14:47that's come out about the Mac Pro and things like that.

0:14:52Like I think our general presumption was that

0:14:55there was a screw up, they wound up being a bakunt

0:14:57and they're not abandoning the platform.

0:15:00And it was just a screw up.

0:15:01And I think that's basically what ended up happening.

0:15:04So I'm glad we got that one right.

0:15:08Yeah, I think so too.

0:15:09Anyway, before I leave Phish, I'll just say this.

0:15:11If you're a nerd and nerdy enough to use the terminal,

0:15:13but you've somehow never gotten attached

0:15:15to Bash or C-Shell or Z-Shell or any of those things,

0:15:20you should give Phish a try.

0:15:21It's really easy to install through Homebrew.

0:15:23And I like it so much more than any shell I've ever tried,

0:15:27because it just somehow makes sense.

0:15:28It makes sense that it comes from somebody who works at Apple, because it sort of makes sense in the way Apple software does.

0:15:33Right. That's what made me think of it, is the idea of one even having access to a shell,

0:15:38and being able to change it, and all the things you can do through a shell.

0:15:43It's a thing you do on computers. I was trying to remember why I went back to that last episode.

0:15:48But yeah, that's why. It's a great example.

0:15:51It does things like it has like if you want to change the color the syntax coloring for the shell like for which?

0:15:56Like a command is this color the arguments are this color the outputs this color an error is this color?

0:16:02You when you config you don't have to just type in a file you can do something and it opens a little web

0:16:06Local web browser window and so you can visually pick the colors and see actually see the colors as you edit them

0:16:12It's it. Oh nice amazing stuff. It's

0:16:15Anyway, it's really cool

0:16:19So anyway, PowerShell is coming soon.

0:16:23And Bash is already the default and first available thing.

0:16:28That's amazing.

0:16:28For this dashboard sort of interface for--

0:16:31The other thing I saw was announced was--

0:16:34I forget what they call it, but whatever Microsoft's version

0:16:36of Xcode is.

0:16:37What's it called?

0:16:39Virtual Studio?

0:16:40Visual Studio, whatever they call it.

0:16:41Oh, Visual Studio, yeah, not Visual Studio.

0:16:42Visual Studio.

0:16:43Is now-- I know it wasn't a surprise,

0:16:44but there's a version of it for Mac now, which is crazy.

0:16:49Yep, and they did a demo and it was more like oh we're doing a demo on a Mac

0:16:54It wasn't like a we're demoing this program

0:16:56Actually when they were doing the I think was when they're demoing the shell and it was on a Mac. Yeah

0:17:02And that it you know, it's of a piece. It's the exact same, you know two sides of the same coin with the windows

0:17:10keynote being on day two

0:17:13the entire idea that

0:17:16if you're developing on Windows server-side technologies,

0:17:20the assumption that you're developing with a Windows client

0:17:23with your hands on the keyboard is no longer there.

0:17:26Like they're completely committed and realized that,

0:17:29I don't know if it's a majority of developers,

0:17:33but certainly an enormous chunk of them

0:17:35are using Macs as their client,

0:17:38whether they're writing Mac software or not,

0:17:40even if they're just doing like web development

0:17:41or Windows development or something like that,

0:17:43or anything server-side, I think.

0:17:46there's an enormous chunk of them who are using Macbooks.

0:17:50Yep, and the platforms that they're developing

0:17:54for, yes on PC it's still

0:17:58Windows still has a more than dominant share

0:18:02but PCs aren't

0:18:06the past in a very real way, or

0:18:10to a topic I'm sure we'll get to, they were never even a thing.

0:18:14And that's a reality that Microsoft has to deal with for,

0:18:18and I think they by and large are,

0:18:20again, that doesn't mean that they're out of the woods

0:18:22because they still have,

0:18:24they still have to actually reach consumers,

0:18:25actually get in front of them,

0:18:27both in terms, both, and that applies to business

0:18:29just as much as it applies to end users.

0:18:32But at least they're not stuck focused on the past.

0:18:37- Yeah.

0:18:40- Yeah, so now we're in an unusual,

0:18:43how things change situation,

0:18:47where Microsoft is the company that's flexible

0:18:49about what machines people are using

0:18:52to develop against their technologies,

0:18:53and Apple's the company that makes you develop on a Mac

0:18:57to write for their phone OS.

0:18:59- Right, exactly, exactly.

0:19:01- Not that I blame Apple for it.

0:19:02That might have come out as me blaming them.

0:19:05It makes perfect sense. - No, they can't.

0:19:07but it's just a funny situation.

0:19:12Apple's the company with an operating system

0:19:18with such overwhelming market share

0:19:20that they can compel developers to buy a machine

0:19:23that they otherwise wouldn't buy

0:19:25just to do development for it.

0:19:26- Yeah, it's hard to, especially if you were following Apple,

0:19:31I'm sure it's harder for you than for me.

0:19:34I mean, back in, I was following Apple in the '90s,

0:19:36I wasn't using one, and to really appreciate the extent to which they are not the underdog

0:19:45at all.

0:19:46It's easier for the situation to change on the ground before it changes your mental

0:19:52state.

0:19:53I think that's a problem for Apple.

0:19:55That was a problem for Apple internally, too.

0:19:57The way you act and behave changes when you're dominant as opposed to when you're the sort

0:20:04of scrappy underdog.

0:20:06Yeah, totally.

0:20:10So what else is going on at Surface, or not Surface, at Build?

0:20:14You know, that's the conference I was at the one time.

0:20:16I was in a video.

0:20:17Yes, that's right.

0:20:18It feels like a long time ago.

0:20:21Well, it's crazy.

0:20:24It was a while ago.

0:20:25It has to have been what?

0:20:26Four, five years ago?

0:20:29Three years ago, I think.

0:20:30I think it was three.

0:20:31Was that all?

0:20:32I think so.

0:20:33I thought I was still in the States when that happened.

0:20:35Yeah, I think it was three years ago, but I could be wrong.

0:20:37But long story short, for those who don't remember, this was when I was working with

0:20:40Brent Simmons and Dave Whisk. We called ourselves Q branch, and we had our app Vesper.

0:20:44And we did the syncing, our own syncing backend,

0:20:49for various reasons. But we built it on, I guess,

0:20:53I think we were there, we were doing it at the time when they called it Windows Azure.

0:20:58And they made us one of the examples in a little video that they showed in the keynote.

0:21:06It flew us out there and everything. It was kind of nice. Kind of weird though.

0:21:10They have a real-time translator for Microsoft PowerPoint that's kind of nifty.

0:21:16So when you can be presenting and it will show real-time translation of the...

0:21:24Yeah, so that's kind of interesting.

0:21:29But again, it was mostly all back end stuff, which is fine.

0:21:32I think as far as consumer-facing stuff, the one today

0:21:39is probably going to be more interesting.

0:21:44But then again, they just announced the Windows S

0:21:46and the new laptops a couple weeks ago.

0:21:49So I think there supposedly might be a Cortana speaker,

0:21:50like an Echo-type device, which, but again,

0:21:55actually getting customers' hands

0:21:58is gonna be the challenge.

0:22:01- I guess the reason I was gonna say,

0:22:03as somebody who observes Apple, it's weird,

0:22:05because I have muscle memory,

0:22:10and it's weird to see a company that's so un-Apple-like.

0:22:15Like, it's baffling to me that they would hold an event

0:22:18a week before their big developer conference

0:22:21where they would talk about a new operating system

0:22:23and unveil these new products.

0:22:25Like why wouldn't you do that in a keynote?

0:22:27But I'm guessing that the keynote this morning ran long

0:22:30and then the Windows one tomorrow,

0:22:31their keynotes already run long.

0:22:34- Right, I mean, and today was really,

0:22:36I mean, it was much more of, yeah,

0:22:39it was pretty hardcore, like back-end development

0:22:42or line of business application sort of stuff.

0:22:44I mean, it wasn't a really consumer-facing thing at all.

0:22:48Not in the slightest.

0:22:53And yeah, maybe they could have announced

0:22:55the things tomorrow, but I think, yeah,

0:22:56there's a very clear sort of bifurcation,

0:22:59and I think you nailed it before,

0:23:02like Windows is sort of its own thing,

0:23:03particularly the consumer-facing side of Windows.

0:23:06And I think there's relatively free rein

0:23:09to do what they can to support and earn customers,

0:23:11but that doesn't necessarily really have much impact,

0:23:14particularly from a strategic perspective

0:23:16on the rest of Microsoft,

0:23:18which is really the future of the company.

0:23:20And this is probably a good example of that.

0:23:24- It was weird.

0:23:26I know today's build, they move it around,

0:23:28I think they often move it around,

0:23:31but this year's was in Seattle.

0:23:32When I went two or three years ago,

0:23:34three, four years ago, whenever it was,

0:23:35it was in San Francisco, in Moscone,

0:23:37which only added to this sort of--

0:23:39- Weird feeling.

0:23:42Bizarro, like I was in a Bizarro developer, Bizarro WWDC,

0:23:47because they even had the keynote third floor,

0:23:50where Apple always calls the room presidio.

0:23:52Those big convention spaces are sort of modular.

0:23:59There's walls that can be moved around to change the shape

0:24:02and make rooms slightly bigger or smaller.

0:24:07But the thing that Microsoft did--

0:24:09and I've seen so many keynotes in that room,

0:24:11because Mac World Expo used to have keynotes in the same room,

0:24:15WWDC every year.

0:24:18Well, I guess those are the two things, but they're Mac World

0:24:20Expo and WWDC keynotes in that room.

0:24:23And Apple's configuration of the room is almost always the same.

0:24:26You'd almost think that the room always looks like that,

0:24:29but it's actually like an Apple setup.

0:24:32When WWDC is done, everything in there is out.

0:24:36And the thing that Microsoft did was

0:24:38they had their stage along what,

0:24:41in Apple's configuration, is the side.

0:24:44Like, Apple sets the room with the stage in the front,

0:24:46and the room goes back long.

0:24:48Microsoft set it up so that the stage was wide,

0:24:53and the room wasn't as deep.

0:24:55And they set-- - Right.

0:24:56- And the way that that made sense,

0:24:58even though it made more people,

0:24:59everybody was closer to the stage

0:25:01in Microsoft's configuration,

0:25:02but people were further from the center

0:25:05if you didn't have a center seat.

0:25:06and they made up for that by having huge screens

0:25:09that were just showed the same,

0:25:11instead of having one big screen that shows something,

0:25:13they had like a wall of screens

0:25:15that all showed the same thing over and over again.

0:25:18And it just weirded me out.

0:25:21It was just, it's like coming home

0:25:24and somebody has moved all of the furniture,

0:25:26like everything is the same except they've rotated

0:25:29every room in your house by 90 degrees.

0:25:31- That would be weird.

0:25:34But yeah, no Moscone keynote again this year.

0:25:37I mean, they've been in the, what is it,

0:25:40the Billy Graham Auditorium, is that what it's called?

0:25:44- I have something like that.

0:25:46I don't think they might, they might never do,

0:25:48Apple might never do a Moscone keynote again.

0:25:49- Right, that's what I was gonna say, yeah.

0:25:51It might be, which is fine, it wasn't the greatest.

0:25:55I didn't like the, I'm not a big fan

0:25:57of the Apple setup in Moscone.

0:25:59- I'm not either, really.

0:26:01I don't have anything against it,

0:26:02but I thought the Microsoft setup was actually very nice.

0:26:05It worked very well.

0:26:06And I felt like everybody got to,

0:26:10you couldn't really see,

0:26:11may not be able to see the actual people,

0:26:12but if, you know, I feel like if you were seated

0:26:15along the side, you had a much bigger screen in front of you

0:26:17than you get seated in the back in Moscone in Apple setup.

0:26:21- Right, exactly.

0:26:22- Yeah, I don't think Apple,

0:26:24Apple might never have an event in San Francisco again.

0:26:26You never say never, I mean, who knows?

0:26:28But I, 'cause I feel like for their smaller events,

0:26:32are going to have them at their headquarters in the Steve Jobs

0:26:34Theater.

0:26:34Right.

0:26:35I don't think you named the theater Steve Jobs Theater

0:26:38unless you intend to use it quite a bit.

0:26:41To unveil new products.

0:26:41Right.

0:26:42Like, I'm sure there--

0:26:45Have you been to the new campus yet?

0:26:46No, I've never.

0:26:47I don't even know where it is.

0:26:48I was asking about it when I was out there for the MacPro Summit,

0:26:53whatever you want, a roundtable discussion.

0:26:57It was a-- I guess it just isn't close.

0:26:59I don't know.

0:27:00To be--

0:27:00Yeah, I used to work there.

0:27:01So in one of the buildings that was torn down.

0:27:04So I definitely know where it is.

0:27:06But yeah, it's like another exit down the freeway

0:27:09from where the current campus is.

0:27:12And you could drive there through city roads.

0:27:15But yeah, it's a little bit of a hike.

0:27:17It's on the other side of the freeway.

0:27:20So it just wasn't convenient.

0:27:21And I didn't have a car.

0:27:22So it wasn't like I was going to take an Uber to go

0:27:25look at a construction site.

0:27:27I mean, the flyovers that people publish from those drones

0:27:29are probably better than what you'd get looking at the ground from the outside.

0:27:33Yep, yeah, I think so.

0:27:37I mean, maybe, you gotta imagine

0:27:41the, well I guess we'll see with the iPhone, with the

0:27:45iPhone announcement, but they did that in San Jose

0:27:49also, not last year, but for the, when they did the watch,

0:27:53the watch unveiling was in San Jose.

0:27:57Yeah, where was that? I forget where it was. I don't think it was San Jose. No, it was

0:28:02at the watch unveiling was at the college in Cupertino.

0:28:09Oh, was that in Cupertino? I thought that was San Jose.

0:28:14It's like some, I forget the name of the college, but De Anza or something, I forget what the

0:28:18hell it is, but it was not. No, the one that was in San Jose was an iPad event in 2011,

0:28:23I think, or 2012, I don't know.

0:28:26It was right before Scott Forstall got fired.

0:28:29- How was the De Anza auditorium or whatever it was?

0:28:34- It was all right.

0:28:36It wasn't anything to write home about.

0:28:40That was the one where Apple built

0:28:41a big mysterious white box out front.

0:28:43- Right, right, right.

0:28:44And that was De Anza College.

0:28:46- Is that what it is, De Anza College?

0:28:48- Yep.

0:28:49- It was okay.

0:28:51I'm not surprised that they haven't been back since.

0:28:54I don't think it was great.

0:28:55I think the one thing people don't seem to understand

0:28:58is that the Steve Jobs Theater is not that big either.

0:29:00Like there's no way they can't have

0:29:02like a WWDC keynote there.

0:29:07Some people have speculated that maybe this year

0:29:10they'll secretly bus everybody to the new campus

0:29:12to have the keynote there or something.

0:29:14It's like that's, you can't bus 5,000 people there.

0:29:19but B, it's not a 5,000 person auditorium.

0:29:21I don't know what the seating capacity is.

0:29:22- And C, they don't want 5,000 people

0:29:24running around on campus.

0:29:26- Right, I don't think they want people on their campus.

0:29:29- Well, I mean, the old one, Town, what's it called?

0:29:33- Town Hall.

0:29:34- Yeah, Town Hall, I mean, that was tiny.

0:29:36- It is tiny.

0:29:36- But I'm sure, yeah, that makes sense though.

0:29:42I suppose the, I bet WWSU will end up

0:29:45back in San Francisco.

0:29:46We'll see, they'll probably see how it goes this year.

0:29:49And then, because the reason it's in San Jose this year

0:29:51is 'cause Moscone Center's under construction.

0:29:53- I don't believe that.

0:29:54I don't believe that.

0:29:55I really don't.

0:29:56- Well, basically all of the,

0:29:58but everyone is not in Moscone by and large.

0:30:01Like have there been any big events there?

0:30:03I mean, I know only part of Moscone's under construction,

0:30:05but I don't think Apple's the only one to--

0:30:08- Well, there's stuff on their schedule if you look.

0:30:10So North and South, Moscone North and South,

0:30:12the big, like the expo hall ones, are closed

0:30:15and they're ripping up the street.

0:30:17If there's an argument for it,

0:30:18the fact that they've got the street ripped up. I guess that's Howard Street is all ripped

0:30:21up for the north and south expansion. But Moscone West is still open and is not being

0:30:27renovated. Before Apple made this announcement, you could look on the schedule and there was

0:30:33like one open week in June. But otherwise, there's stuff in Moscone West all the time.

0:30:41I could be wrong.

0:30:42Yeah. No, you're right. I don't know.

0:30:44I mean, who cares if the street's ripped up? I've seen people say, "Well, the street's

0:30:48all ripped up, but who gives a crap?

0:30:50I don't know, nobody's, it's not like everybody's driving

0:30:52down Howard Street to get to WWDC.

0:30:54I think if Apple wanted to have it at Moscone West this year

0:30:57they would've.

0:30:57I think there's other reasons, you know,

0:31:01whether they got a better deal, whether they really,

0:31:04you know, I do think, I think Apple is,

0:31:07if you can put a personality on a company,

0:31:09they're a homebody company.

0:31:11They don't, they're not a San Francisco company.

0:31:14I know they have a couple of offices there,

0:31:16but they really are, as a company,

0:31:19they're at home on their campus in Cupertino.

0:31:22And I feel like being closer to home is better for them.

0:31:26- Yeah, no question.

0:31:27I mean, just being in the Valley,

0:31:30I mean, they're not its own insular sort of culture.

0:31:34Like, it's much less sort of interspersed.

0:31:37I mean, obviously at an employee level,

0:31:38that's not necessarily the case.

0:31:39But especially once you get more into senior management,

0:31:42I mean, it's its own world.

0:31:44Like it's in the same geographic area,

0:31:47but the rest of the valley I think is much more

0:31:50intertwined with Google and there's much more

0:31:53of a sort of back and forth in that perspective

0:31:55when it comes to sort of big valley companies

0:31:57and San Francisco.

0:31:59But yeah, Apple has always been its own sort of universe.

0:32:04And you see it all over the place,

0:32:05not just in the valley, you see it sort of online,

0:32:07you see it when it comes to Apple fans.

0:32:09There's a lot of people who are Apple fans

0:32:11that are not necessarily tech fans.

0:32:14I certainly see that when it comes to readers.

0:32:16And you see it in popular culture where it's interesting.

0:32:22It really is its own sort of entity for better or worse.

0:32:27And I think at a practical level, it's absolutely the case.

0:32:30I mean, there's no argument, no spin.

0:32:32It's just a fact that San Jose is so much closer to Apple's

0:32:37campus or campuses in Cupertino that for engineers at Apple who have things to do that week that

0:32:46they need to be at the office, they can swing by.

0:32:48They might be able to do a couple of hours' work in their office and then go to WWDC in

0:32:53the afternoon for labs or something like that.

0:32:56And people might get, you know, attendees might get interaction with significantly more

0:33:01engineers from Apple who couldn't take an entire day to go up to San Francisco because

0:33:06it's night and day. I mean, San Francisco can be over an hour away, depending on traffic.

0:33:13And San Jose, it's probably like a 10, 15 minute drive.

0:33:16Yep, exactly. You found a good spot for the talk show?

0:33:21Yeah, yeah. I'm in the California theater where that iPad event was, the one that was

0:33:27in San Jose.

0:33:29So is it a lot bigger than the old place?

0:33:32The place where I had my show?

0:33:33Yeah.

0:33:34- My God, it's so much bigger.

0:33:35It's, I think it has like an 1100 seat capacity.

0:33:38And I think-- - Oh, wow.

0:33:39- When we had it at Mezzanine in San Francisco,

0:33:43which I love, which I still, if, you know,

0:33:45I love that facility, I love doing the show there,

0:33:47but I think we capped it at 500.

0:33:50I think you could, Mezzanine's attendance cap

0:33:54is significantly higher than that, but 500 seems to,

0:33:58you know, and judging from people's reactions

0:34:00over the years, it keeps it from getting too crowded.

0:34:03Like I don't want to pack the most number of people in there.

0:34:05I feel bad when people, like I think tickets sold out

0:34:08in like 10 minutes last year.

0:34:10So I feel bad that people who want to go can't come,

0:34:13but I'd rather have everybody,

0:34:16I'd rather have fewer people come

0:34:17and more people excluded,

0:34:18but have everybody be comfortable.

0:34:20- Yeah, are there gonna be drinks?

0:34:22I think that's probably the more pressing question.

0:34:24- There will be drinks,

0:34:25and I don't know how that's gonna work,

0:34:27because it's a real theater theater,

0:34:30and I don't know how easy--

0:34:31- Yeah, I'm looking at the pictures right now.

0:34:32- Right, I don't know how easy it'll be

0:34:33for people who are sitting in the middle of a row

0:34:35to go get drinks, so I don't know,

0:34:36it might have to be sort of a,

0:34:38you know, get your load on,

0:34:41get your load on before the show starts.

0:34:42- That was the great thing about "Mezzanine,"

0:34:44is you could like, I mean, obviously there was the seating,

0:34:46and if you were in a seat, well,

0:34:47the interviewer or the show was going on,

0:34:50you wouldn't get up and go,

0:34:51but you could also just sort of be in the back

0:34:53and be, you know, mingling a little bit

0:34:56and getting a drink, and so yeah,

0:34:58it kind of served a, you could watch the show

0:35:01- In multiple ways, which is nice.

0:35:04- Well, we'll see, I don't know.

0:35:06But 1,100 people, Jesus, that's gonna be nerve-wracking.

0:35:08There's a balcony and everything.

0:35:11- It does, oh, it's very beautiful.

0:35:13I'm looking at the pictures right now.

0:35:15- Tickets still aren't on sale, but they will be soon.

0:35:19- Oh, that's right, okay, I forgot that you hadn't.

0:35:24Maybe you can get them on sale

0:35:27by the time you post this podcast.

0:35:27- I am, I'm not waiting until the last minute,

0:35:29but there's lots of little, it's not too much work.

0:35:32I don't have to, it's not like I'm sitting there

0:35:34hooking microphones up and stuff,

0:35:35but there's a lot of details to be worked out yet.

0:35:39Anyway.

0:35:40- Well, hopefully I didn't give anything away.

0:35:41- No, no, no, no, none of that's a secret.

0:35:43Even the venue is, it's right there on Apple's website

0:35:46and stuff like that, so I'm not keeping it secret.

0:35:48Anyway, let's take a break.

0:35:50I'll thank our first sponsor,

0:35:51it's our good friends at Fracture.

0:35:53Fracture is the photo decor company that's out to rescue

0:35:57your favorite images from the digital ether.

0:35:59That's their words, not mine.

0:36:00Here's what they do.

0:36:01They take your photos and they print them directly on glass.

0:36:03Right there, on the glass.

0:36:05On the glass.

0:36:06Not a piece of paper glued to glass.

0:36:08I don't know what they have.

0:36:08They have custom proprietary stuff.

0:36:10They just put glass into the printer.

0:36:13The printer puts your photo right on the glass

0:36:16and then they mail it to you and it looks amazing.

0:36:19It's got that retina effect where it just looks like,

0:36:22it doesn't look, it looks,

0:36:24there's just such a different effect

0:36:25than a piece of paper behind a piece of glass in a frame.

0:36:29And it takes all the pain in the ass stuff

0:36:31out of hanging pictures up.

0:36:32Because this happens to me every time.

0:36:35Every time I used to get like IKEA frames

0:36:38or something like that, you put a photo in there

0:36:39and then you have to get those little things on the back

0:36:42that secure the cardboard, you flip them up

0:36:45and then you put the picture in

0:36:46and you put the cardboard back in

0:36:47and you flip them back down.

0:36:48And inevitably the picture goes like two degrees off

0:36:52and you gotta open it up, start all over again.

0:36:53What a pain in the ass.

0:36:55With the pictures from Fractured,

0:36:57there's nothing like that can happen.

0:36:58It's just a piece of glass,

0:36:59so it's always perfectly aligned.

0:37:01And they ship you everything you need

0:37:03to hang it on a wall in the box.

0:37:05They even include the wall anchor.

0:37:07Just upload your digital photo on their website,

0:37:09pick the size, and just wait for it to show up in the mail.

0:37:12That's it, could not be easier.

0:37:14Where do you go to find out more?

0:37:17fractureme.com/podcast.

0:37:21Every time I read it, I feel like I'm making a mistake

0:37:24and that that's some kind of placeholder,

0:37:25but that's really the URL, fractureme.com/podcast.

0:37:29And then I guess they use the same URL for all podcasts.

0:37:33But then at the end when you buy it, they'll say,

0:37:35"Hey, where'd you find out about Fracture?"

0:37:36And you can say, "The talk show."

0:37:38"Hey, go buy some for Father's Day.

0:37:40"It's a great, great gift."

0:37:41"Too late for Mother's Day."

0:37:42"Mother's Day is like two days from now,

0:37:43"but Father's Day is coming up next month.

0:37:47"What an amazing gift.

0:37:48"Go buy a fracture for your father, your husband,

0:37:52"anything like that.

0:37:53What a great gift.

0:37:54- Well, FractureMe is memorable.

0:37:59- Yeah.

0:37:59- And so, URLs are hard.

0:38:01Someone was making fun of,

0:38:04there's a tweet on the effect of,

0:38:06tech people are so uncreative that they have a site

0:38:09about strategy and tech culture techery.

0:38:11And I'm like, it's true, I have no excuse.

0:38:14I mean, Derry Firewall is always,

0:38:16I've always like, damn it, I should've hired you

0:38:19to get a name, to find me a name before I started.

0:38:22but now it's too late.

0:38:27But the other thing too is getting a URL is hard.

0:38:29One of the things when I started, I had no money.

0:38:31I was in debt.

0:38:34And the idea of going out and spending money

0:38:36to get a URL or whatever, or Twitter handle,

0:38:40all that stuff, one of the advantages of Stereocory

0:38:43is it was available.

0:38:45I would, like I said, I probably wouldn't use it again

0:38:46if I was starting over because it's hard to say,

0:38:49hard to spell, which is not a good combo.

0:38:50But yeah, it's hard.

0:38:53The whole URL Twitter handle thing is tough.

0:38:57I remember fracturing me,

0:39:00especially now after you sort of made that little joke.

0:39:04- You know that I have during fireball.com, right?

0:39:07- Yeah, but it redirects to .net.

0:39:09- Right, and some people don't ask about that anymore.

0:39:11In the early years, people would be like,

0:39:12"Why do you redirect to .net?

0:39:16"Wouldn't most people, if they have both, redirect to .com?"

0:39:19And I think it's like to me it's like I started using the internet so early

0:39:26When most domains weren't dot-coms, you know

0:39:30like dot orgs and dot ed use that use were probably the most popular that I used and

0:39:35net - but to me

0:39:39Dot-com was sort of crass in the early years and I know that in the you know

0:39:43after the doc, you know even called the bubble the dot-com bubble like dot-com sort of became the the

0:39:49the neutral one, right?

0:39:51It's like ground zero of all the top level domains.

0:39:54Like, by default, you want a .com.

0:39:57But like, when I was, in my mind,

0:40:00it's still sort of crass, I don't know.

0:40:02Like in the early years, all the .com sites were garbage.

0:40:07- Right, well, it was supposed to be like commercial, right?

0:40:09I think that's what it stands for.

0:40:11Then, yeah, I like, I agree, I like .net better.

0:40:15But yes, I give in to the prevailing,

0:40:18I own Surtakri.net also, but it redirects

0:40:20in the opposite direction.

0:40:21- Right, and like Kotki, I think a lot of early types,

0:40:26you know, like me and Kotki--

0:40:27- I always did like Kotki.org.

0:40:28- Yeah, and it wouldn't work, like, neither,

0:40:32it somehow is part of the domain,

0:40:33like Kotki.net wouldn't be right,

0:40:35and Kotki.com would be awful.

0:40:37Like, it just, it wouldn't be the same,

0:40:39like Kotki.org is exactly right.

0:40:41And for whatever reason in my mind,

0:40:44it's just, like when you rewrite a sentence

0:40:46and just use the same words, but you put a clause

0:40:50in the middle of the sentence as opposed to at the end

0:40:52or something like that, and one way it reads great

0:40:54and one way it doesn't, to me, daringfireball.net

0:40:57reads better than daringfireball.com.

0:40:59I remember-- - Yeah, well, the great thing--

0:41:01Well, sorry. - Go ahead, go ahead, Ben.

0:41:03- Oh, no, I was just gonna say,

0:41:05the great thing about Daring Fireball is

0:41:06it's so distinct that you can, one,

0:41:10if you type, if you type in a URL,

0:41:12and the thing is that no one actually types,

0:41:14us nerds do, but the vast majority of people

0:41:17don't even type URLs.

0:41:19Like the, Google has the whole, you know,

0:41:22like a huge number, back in the day,

0:41:25like they could track how popular Facebook was

0:41:27because of people typing Facebook into Google

0:41:30to go to Facebook.

0:41:31So for normal people it doesn't really register,

0:41:33but that's the great thing about doing Fireball,

0:41:35even if you do a URL or you do a Google search,

0:41:36whatever, it's going to, it's memorable

0:41:38and it's gonna come up right away.

0:41:40- Wasn't there a thing where,

0:41:43Off the top of my head, I'm not remembering it right,

0:41:45but there was a thing where the number one result

0:41:47for Facebook login was no longer the Facebook login page

0:41:51and the poor bugger who had,

0:41:54it was just some guy's site or something

0:41:55and the guy was just inundated with thousands of people

0:41:59saying, "What have you done to Facebook?

0:42:01"This doesn't look like Facebook."

0:42:03Do you remember this?

0:42:05- I don't, but that would be brutal.

0:42:06- Right, it was pretty big,

0:42:08'cause that's how people get to the Facebook login sign.

0:42:10They go to Google and then type Facebook login

0:42:13and hit return, y'all expect to be taken there.

0:42:15Funny stuff.

0:42:19That's how my son gets around the internet,

0:42:21he just types stuff into Google.

0:42:22- Yeah, that's pretty normal.

0:42:26I mean, that's pretty normal behavior.

0:42:28I mean, if people, you know,

0:42:30to the extent people are still using the internet,

0:42:32I mean, it really shows the extent to which Google

0:42:37is the sort of winch pin for the internet.

0:42:41I mean, yes, you can type URLs, go to places,

0:42:43but the reality is, and the way that people

0:42:45actually experience online is through Google.

0:42:48It's not just about like typing Facebook

0:42:50into the Google search page, but there's just so much stuff.

0:42:54There's so many things that it's incomprehensible

0:42:58to anyone, even the smartest person on earth.

0:43:03And Google, what makes Google so brilliant

0:43:06and such a brilliant sort of invention

0:43:08is that the old search engines,

0:43:12the more stuff there was, the more they bogged down.

0:43:14'Cause they were, I mean,

0:43:15the original Yahoo was literally a directory.

0:43:17I mean, obviously the future search engines

0:43:19were much more sophisticated,

0:43:21but Google by sort of building on top of the link

0:43:23instead of building on top of the pages themselves,

0:43:26well, it turned out when you got more links,

0:43:29Google got smarter and understood it better.

0:43:31And when the web got larger, everyone else got worse,

0:43:35except for Google, which actually got even better.

0:43:37And that's sort of the core piece of the company's dominance

0:43:42and why they're the winchpin for the entire internet.

0:43:48- Which brings us to Windows 10 S and the way that,

0:43:54on Windows 10 S you can't change your default search engine.

0:43:59You get Bing and you like it.

0:44:01- Yeah, and I think that's,

0:44:03I believe they're giving away 10 S to the OES.

0:44:07So that's the primary way that they're going to,

0:44:10I mean obviously there's app sales as well.

0:44:12But app sales and Bing searches and stuff like that.

0:44:16I think Bing is actually profitable now,

0:44:19or very close to it.

0:44:21It has been for a little bit actually.

0:44:23- It should be, don't you think?

0:44:24I mean it doesn't make sense that they'd keep

0:44:27losing money on it.

0:44:28'Cause I mean, how much could it cost other than labor?

0:44:32- Yeah, it's one of those things where

0:44:36It's not like a winnier sort of thing

0:44:39where they make a little more money, a little more money,

0:44:42and that now they're profitable and they're growing.

0:44:43It's like you're either losing a lot

0:44:45or you're making a good amount

0:44:47once you get the sort of scale effects that are kicking in.

0:44:50But yeah, it's still actually growing pretty decently.

0:44:55I think 5.3 billion in revenue the last fiscal year.

0:44:58- I should try it again.

0:44:59I haven't tried Bing in a while.

0:45:01I've done different Macs or different devices

0:45:04at any given time.

0:45:05I sometimes switch to DuckDuckGo,

0:45:07which I admire as the plucky little startup,

0:45:10and they're local to Philly too,

0:45:13it gives me a little affection for them.

0:45:15But I have to admit that there's a lot of times

0:45:18with DuckDuckGo where it's semi free,

0:45:22yeah, if you're gonna do it,

0:45:24at some point in the week, you're gonna be typing,

0:45:27there's a trick they have,

0:45:28you can even type like G exclamation mark

0:45:30and it redoes the same query but redirects you to Google.

0:45:33because there's just sometimes it's not as good

0:45:36as Google search.

0:45:37I mean, they do some really cool stuff

0:45:39and I like the privacy aspect of it, but it's not as good.

0:45:41But the thing that surprises me is I thought Microsoft

0:45:45might catch up to Google search with Bing

0:45:46'cause it seems like the sort of problem

0:45:49that Microsoft would be able to solve.

0:45:53Like it never surprises me that Microsoft software

0:45:56never has as nice of a UI as Apple software

0:45:59because it's institutionally they just don't have

0:46:01the people who have the taste for that.

0:46:04But web search is really just,

0:46:07you don't have to have taste for that.

0:46:08It's a purely algorithmic challenge to get that right.

0:46:13- Well, not quite, you need data.

0:46:14I mean, the thing with Google is,

0:46:17the algorithm itself is far beyond

0:46:22any one person could,

0:46:26it was designed by a person to start,

0:46:28but at this point it's so complex and convoluted,

0:46:30And a lot of it is just constant iterative feedback.

0:46:32So when people are doing searches,

0:46:34and I'm not talking about the individualized searches,

0:46:37just as a whole, like which results are the quick,

0:46:40like Google wants the first,

0:46:41the proper result to be the first result.

0:46:43So they are tracking which result you actually click on,

0:46:45where, how far down you go.

0:46:47And plus websites are optimizing themselves for Google.

0:46:50And so Microsoft has to, you know, attach onto that.

0:46:54But it's one of those situations

0:46:55where thanks to the feedback loop

0:46:58that comes from having the most data

0:46:59and the most users and the most searches,

0:47:02if two identical search engines,

0:47:04if one starts at 51% market share

0:47:07and one starts at 49% market share,

0:47:09absent sort of any exterior force,

0:47:12the one with 50% market share is going to get better

0:47:15over time relative to the other one,

0:47:17which means, and then when it gets better,

0:47:19that lets it get more users

0:47:20because it's a better search engine.

0:47:22And then it gets even more data relative to the competition,

0:47:25so it even has a bigger advantage.

0:47:27So the reality is even Microsoft can have the smartest

0:47:30sort of search folks in the world,

0:47:32but because it's a problem that's not just

0:47:34about algorithm design, it's about the entire

0:47:37sort of system and having iterative feedback loop,

0:47:40they will, it's very difficult to ever catch up

0:47:45absent some sort of like incredible breakthrough.

0:47:49- You can't buy your way out of it.

0:47:50There's no way to throw any money at it.

0:47:52Doesn't get you there.

0:47:53That's interesting.

0:47:54I think that to me has to be the explanation

0:47:57because I just don't think the problem is that

0:48:01Microsoft doesn't have the intelligence

0:48:03and the engineering to do it.

0:48:04And they obviously had no problem spending money on it.

0:48:09For years, famously, they were losing billions on Bing.

0:48:12I think that's just it, though, that Google's so popular

0:48:15that their popularity feeds upon their accuracy.

0:48:20- Right, and this is where-- - Or their accuracy

0:48:22feeds upon their popularity.

0:48:24- And this is where Google is, in some respects,

0:48:26It's like a Facebook effect, but it's like there is a sort of network effect, but it's

0:48:30not necessarily about people per se, it's the interaction between people and the sort

0:48:34of data they generate.

0:48:36But you get the same sort of idea where the larger service, like because I think I always

0:48:41write a lot about user experience.

0:48:43And the point I always have to, I sometimes forget to make this, and when I forget to

0:48:47make this point, I always regret it because I get a bunch of people asking me, you know,

0:48:50pointing, asking questions.

0:48:51User experience does not mean user interface.

0:48:54The user interface is an important part of the user experience and is critical for something

0:48:58like a phone, for example, that's in your hand, you're interacting with.

0:49:02And actually, we can talk about WeChat stuff in a little bit, but the user experience is

0:49:08the totality of the experience, which means having better search results means it's

0:49:13a better experience.

0:49:14Having more friends on Facebook, more family on Facebook, not having to try to recruit

0:49:19people to get on there means it's a better experience that has nothing to do with the

0:49:23interface per se.

0:49:28And these aspects of the experience,

0:49:29they build on themselves.

0:49:32And this is why you have these companies that are so dominant.

0:49:33And what makes it so tricky, and I've been writing a lot about

0:49:36this over the last year or so, these companies are so powerful

0:49:39because of these sort of data effects and these network effects.

0:49:43And they're powerful in a way that's actually better for the

0:49:46consumer.

0:49:49Google is popular because it's better, which means it gets more

0:49:50users.

0:49:49and when it gets more users, it actually becomes even better,

0:49:52which means it's positive on the user perspective.

0:49:56And same thing with Facebook.

0:49:57It has the most users, so more people join it

0:50:00because it's there, and the more people join it,

0:50:02now it has more users, and you get the same sort of

0:50:04feedback loop where people choose it because it's better.

0:50:08And that sort of makes, from an antitrust perspective,

0:50:12that makes US antitrust law fall completely apart

0:50:15because it's based on consumer benefit,

0:50:18and actually they're providing a ton of consumer benefit.

0:50:20That's why they're winning.

0:50:21- Right.

0:50:22- Sorry, that was a summary of like 15

0:50:26Chicago articles that I've been writing about.

0:50:29- Did you see the story that, I think The Verge had it,

0:50:33that the Surface laptop, now the most unique thing

0:50:37about these Surface laptops that they announced

0:50:39is that other than the keyboard and the trackpad,

0:50:42what you touch on the front face is

0:50:46like a soft touch leather, like fake leather type thing,

0:50:50but it's like a, it's called--

0:50:52- Which looks awful to me, but--

0:50:53- Alcantara, apparently a lot of car makers

0:50:56use it, high-end car makers.

0:50:58Well, I don't wanna judge it on photos,

0:51:01but from the photos, to me it looks terrible.

0:51:03I would not want that.

0:51:04I wouldn't, if I had the choice when buying a laptop,

0:51:08whether I just have the bare aluminum surface

0:51:11or like, no pun intended, surface,

0:51:14or have it covered with this stuff,

0:51:15without having seen it in person,

0:51:17I would, zero hesitation, I would just say,

0:51:19"Just give me the aluminum, this seems like a disaster."

0:51:23- Yeah.

0:51:24- But I saw people excoriating Microsoft

0:51:27for having told the Verge that you need to

0:51:31treat it like a luxury purse or something like that,

0:51:37or a luxury handbag.

0:51:39And I think people took that as meaning

0:51:44that it's like dainty and that it's,

0:51:46you're like, you have to treat it preciously.

0:51:49I think that's how people reacted to this.

0:51:51Like the headline, I think.

0:51:52Microsoft says the fabric on the Surface laptop

0:51:54should be cared for like a luxury handbag.

0:51:57And I think The Verge did a disservice with that headline

0:52:01'cause it's not really, that's not a quote.

0:52:04The only quote in that headline is the word luxury.

0:52:07Here's the actual statement from Microsoft.

0:52:11I hate this use of the word luxury.

0:52:14Just like anything luxury that you buy,

0:52:16like that should be luxurious or something,

0:52:19or any luxury product that you buy.

0:52:21But it still, it seems self-serving for them

0:52:23to describe it as luxury.

0:52:25But anyway, just like anything luxury that you buy,

0:52:28like great handbags or a pair of shoes

0:52:30or even expensive cars,

0:52:32there is a care that's needed for the device.

0:52:34So I think there has to be some care for it.

0:52:40But I think the thing that people aren't,

0:52:42Maybe you and I understand it with our spouses,

0:52:46but you can get, like, there are handbags

0:52:50that are, might be, you know, from a luxury brand,

0:52:54and they're not really dainty.

0:52:55They're actually the opposite.

0:52:56They're actually very, they're built to last for decades,

0:53:01you know, and you do have to treat leather,

0:53:04and if you get it wet, you have to take care of it

0:53:06right away and stuff like that.

0:53:07But they actually hold up surprisingly well.

0:53:10They're not dainty little Fabergé eggs.

0:53:12They're actually much more rugged in some ways

0:53:15than typical lower cost bags.

0:53:19So that's-- - Right, sometimes you buy

0:53:22a nice bag or a nice pair of shoes that are luxury,

0:53:26but you buy them because they last way longer

0:53:29and hold up much better and age much more attractively

0:53:33than something that's lower cost.

0:53:35- Right, there was a weird Twitter account

0:53:39I was into for a while.

0:53:41It was one of those ones that was interesting,

0:53:42only when it was anonymous, and then when somebody figured out

0:53:45who the guy was, it was no fun anymore.

0:53:47GS Elevator, remember that?

0:53:50Oh, yeah.

0:53:50It was written from the perspective of stuff overheard

0:53:54in the elevators at Goldman Sachs.

0:53:58And it was often hilarious, often very rude,

0:54:01sort of from that--

0:54:02Very lewd.

0:54:03that bro, alpha male banker mentality.

0:54:08But I remember the guy who wrote it had like,

0:54:12it was like a, he also had like articles

0:54:15and it was just like, all right,

0:54:16so you got a job in an investment bank,

0:54:18here's what, you're a kid out of college,

0:54:20here's the clothes that you need to buy.

0:54:22And one of his things was that you should get like,

0:54:25I forget if he recommended Gucci or what,

0:54:29but you know, something like,

0:54:30get like a nice pair of Gucci shoes.

0:54:31Yes, there's $800 or $700, but they will last you way longer

0:54:36than 10 pairs of $200 shoes if you take care of them.

0:54:41- Right, yep.

0:54:42- There's obviously some things that are luxury priced

0:54:45that are not, that you're just throwing, like a sports car.

0:54:49Like if you buy a Lamborghini,

0:54:50you're just pissing money away.

0:54:51(laughs)

0:54:52It's not really, you're not really buying it

0:54:55for the value of, I mean, the car is valuable,

0:54:59but it's not like you're not going to sink

0:55:01tens of thousands of dollars in it maintenance as you go.

0:55:03Like nobody buys a Lamborghini because it's worth it.

0:55:06- It's a good investment.

0:55:07- Reliability wise compared to a Honda.

0:55:09(laughs)

0:55:11- Yup.

0:55:13- But there are some things like a nice shoe

0:55:14or a nice belt or something like that

0:55:16where you actually, yes, you're paying a lot of money,

0:55:18but it's actually, you might be paying five times more

0:55:21than what you're used to,

0:55:21but you're actually getting like 10 times better product.

0:55:24I don't think that the Surface laptop is like that though.

0:55:28I don't know.

0:55:28- Yeah, yeah, I went to use that word choice.

0:55:33And yeah, now that I'm looking at that

0:55:35just like anything luxury, that's dried me up the wall.

0:55:37That's terrible.

0:55:38- They have to, they have to have tested this.

0:55:41I know, like last week on the show,

0:55:43Renee and I were joking about that the iPad,

0:55:46or iPod that came, I think it was like an iPod Nano

0:55:50that was super easily scratched.

0:55:52Do you remember that one?

0:55:53- It was the original, the original Nano.

0:55:54- Yeah, it was almost in a, you know,

0:55:58- I would love, it's one of those like

0:55:59behind the scenes things,

0:56:00I would love to someday get that story out of Apple

0:56:03as to how in the hell did they make tens of thousands

0:56:07of these things or half a million of these things

0:56:09out of a plastic that you scratch with your fingernail.

0:56:13Like what the hell were they thinking?

0:56:14How did that not get caught in testing?

0:56:17- I know, 'cause if you saw one, like they,

0:56:19within not long, I mean they would be

0:56:22just completely destroyed, like to the point

0:56:24where you could barely even read the screen.

0:56:26- We-- - In the whole,

0:56:27It was the whole front, not just the screen.

0:56:28The entire surface would be just completely all shredded up.

0:56:33- It's hard to remember compared to iPhones

0:56:36where everything is so much closer to the surface now.

0:56:39But with the iPods, even with the Nano,

0:56:42there was sort of a thick layer of screen,

0:56:44or not even screen, but just plastic

0:56:47on the whole front of all these models, or a bunch of them.

0:56:50I remember we got them when I was working at Joyent.

0:56:55I forget, we hit some kind of milestone or something.

0:56:57And so everybody in the company got one as a gift.

0:57:00In our company, like chat,

0:57:06I forget what we even used for chat.

0:57:07It wasn't Slack, obviously it wasn't around,

0:57:09but the equivalent of Slack's.

0:57:10- IRC.

0:57:11- It wasn't IRC though, I forget what we were using.

0:57:14- Hip, hip, hip chat.

0:57:15And that was a long time ago too.

0:57:17- Yeah, I don't remember.

0:57:18I don't know why I'm drawing a blank on that,

0:57:20but we had like a company-wide chat

0:57:21and when everybody got these and we're like,

0:57:23everybody was having fun with their new iPod

0:57:25and it took like an hour for people to be like,

0:57:28holy shit, mine's all scratched up.

0:57:30- Yep.

0:57:31- Anyway. - 2005, man,

0:57:34that's already been 12 years.

0:57:35- I can't help but think that Microsoft had to have

0:57:38stress tested these things with actual sweaty palms

0:57:42and warm, use this for a while with,

0:57:46maybe have us in a warm room with somebody

0:57:49who sweats through their palms or something.

0:57:52These things can't just pick up ugly palm sweat stains.

0:57:56- Yeah, I mean, I'm not sure I want to admit to this,

0:58:00but even my MacBook is always the keyboard

0:58:03and that all ends up just totally filthy.

0:58:05It's pretty disgusting, actually.

0:58:07I should probably clean it.

0:58:08- Yeah, you probably should.

0:58:09That's gross, Ben.

0:58:10- I don't know, it just doesn't seem like,

0:58:14the more I think about it,

0:58:14this just doesn't seem like a good idea.

0:58:16I don't know, it just seems,

0:58:18too many laptops get too grungy, as is,

0:58:21as easy to clean a surface as aluminum is.

0:58:25I mean, it's pretty hard to think of something

0:58:27that's easier to clean than that.

0:58:29- Everyone just wants them to make a nice laptop.

0:58:31That's all they want, just a regular,

0:58:34so they did the Surface Book thing,

0:58:35or first they did the Surface and the Surface Book thing,

0:58:37and now there's a laptop, but yeah, it has,

0:58:40but I mean, I know there's lots of politics

0:58:43and competing with OEMs, all that sort of stuff, but yeah.

0:58:49I'd rather get a ThinkPad with the nub anyway.

0:58:53I'd-- a nub.

0:58:56I mean, I think it's so different.

0:58:58I don't know.

0:58:58Didn't they use it in the old days?

0:58:59It was like the nub was the only thing, right?

0:59:01They didn't even have a trackpad.

0:59:02Yep, it used to be just the nub.

0:59:05But yeah, they have both now.

0:59:06That's almost like an Apple devotion,

0:59:08like Apple's devotion to the single button mouse.

0:59:11In a world where everybody went the other way,

0:59:14the old IBM ThinkPad's devotion to the little red nub.

0:59:18Well, I mean, there's lots of people that,

0:59:23I mean, relatively speaking, not a ton,

0:59:26but there are people like it.

0:59:28I mean, if you're used to it, it's one of those things

0:59:31where if you really like it, why would you,

0:59:33you're going to just keep buying ThinkPad,

0:59:38you're not even going to think about it.

0:59:40And I think part of the problem, too, is this,

0:59:41touchpads have always been so terrible on Windows.

0:59:43Right.

0:59:45So terrible.

0:59:46That was the big reason.

0:59:47Yeah, that was one of the big reasons

0:59:44that when I was at Microsoft, I used a ThinkPad.

0:59:48And that was the biggest reason I started using the nub

0:59:52in the first place, that the trackpad was atrocious.

0:59:54But then you use it and you actually grow

0:59:56to really, really like it.

0:59:57I mean, not having to, I mean, you're absolutely used to it

1:00:02moving, you don't move your hand much on a computer,

1:00:07but on a MacBook.

1:00:08But just having it right there.

1:00:10Once you're used to it, it's nice.

1:00:11- Yeah, it's great.

1:00:12- I mean, I'm an actual differentiation.

1:00:14It's in a world, like the big problem that PC OEMs have

1:00:18is that what's to keep, let's say you sell somebody

1:00:21an HP laptop, what's to keep them from buying

1:00:24a different brand the next time they buy one?

1:00:26Nothing, really.

1:00:28And the little red nubbin is actually a little bit

1:00:30of a differentiator, if they have the muscle memory for it.

1:00:35Yep, I always thought they were weird.

1:00:40Anyway, what else do you want to talk about before we get to the WeChat thing?

1:00:52Yeah.

1:00:53Well, I actually think we've, through talking about various things, have set the stage nicely.

1:01:01So, what do you think about the two new echoes?

1:01:05There's the camera one, and then there's the one with the screen.

1:01:09Well, let's talk about that after I thank another one of our friends.

1:01:12It's our good friend, a new sponsor, first time.

1:01:15I really like this company though.

1:01:17Pingdom, P-I-N-G-D-O-M.

1:01:20It's a service for monitoring websites and servers.

1:01:25You can go to www.pingdom.com/lp/talkshow.

1:01:30Pingdom.com/lp/talkshow.

1:01:36And they have a nice little landing page there

1:01:37for listeners of the show, addressed just to you.

1:01:41You get a 14-day free trial.

1:01:42And when you enter the code, the talk show at checkout,

1:01:46you get 20% off your first invoice.

1:01:49That's a big deal, 20%.

1:01:51Pingda makes the web faster and more reliable for everyone

1:01:54by offering powerful, easy to use monitoring tools

1:01:56and services for anyone on the website.

1:01:58You can do anything with these guys.

1:02:00It's really great.

1:02:01So you've got a web server.

1:02:02You can just point something to it

1:02:03and they can like simulate visits.

1:02:06It's not just like a ping to the server,

1:02:08even though that's their name,

1:02:08but they can actually simulate an actual visit

1:02:10to the website and you can write tests

1:02:12to make sure certain components,

1:02:14and modern websites have so many things

1:02:16where you're drawing things from multiple services

1:02:19to make your website,

1:02:21where it's not just one server that can go down.

1:02:25There's all sorts of fail points along the way,

1:02:27and you can write these tests with Pingdom

1:02:29to test if everything that you expect to be working

1:02:31is working, and when it's not,

1:02:33they'll notify you instantly.

1:02:36Pingdom detects more than 13 million outages,

1:02:40more than 400,000 outages every day.

1:02:43Wow.

1:02:44And if you've ever noticed,

1:02:46stuff actually breaks on the internet all the time.

1:02:48Here's a way to find out if your stuff broke.

1:02:51Really great service used by a whole bunch of big names.

1:02:55If you go to their website, I told you,

1:02:57pingdom.com/lp/talkshow, and just look at the big names

1:03:02that use Pingdom for monitoring their service,

1:03:05servers and websites.

1:03:07It's amazing.

1:03:08So go there and check them out

1:03:09and they will know you came from the show

1:03:11and remember that code, the talk show,

1:03:13and you'll save 20% on your first invoice.

1:03:17My thanks to Pingdom.

1:03:18Great, great service.

1:03:19Yeah, so Amazon, they have two new,

1:03:25what do they call them, Echo products?

1:03:27They both--

1:03:28- Yeah, there's the Echo Look, which is just a camera,

1:03:31and then there's the,

1:03:33and they're pitching it for putting in your closet

1:03:37or wardrobe, and then the Echo,

1:03:40the bigger, probably the one they made a bigger splash about

1:03:43was the Echo Show, which is a, has a screen,

1:03:46has a screen that says, now Echo can show you things,

1:03:49I believe is the tagline.

1:03:50- Right, and obviously also has a camera,

1:03:52since it does like photo, video calls.

1:03:57- Right, which I actually think is the most,

1:04:01the most interesting part of it,

1:04:02and it really featured very heavily

1:04:05in the introductory video.

1:04:08- Yeah, I have to watch that again,

1:04:10but it did seem like it's almost more like,

1:04:13the bigger announcement is that they're doing their own,

1:04:17they don't have a name for it though, right?

1:04:19There's no, they don't have a name like FaceTime.

1:04:22- Right, no, it's just,

1:04:23it's not just the Echo Show,

1:04:26'cause they updated the Alexa app,

1:04:30And so you can go between phones and the Echo Show

1:04:35or Echo Show to Echo Show.

1:04:37I don't know for sure if you can go phone to phone,

1:04:41but I presume you can.

1:04:43- Yeah, I think so. - I think I wrote about

1:04:44yesterday I wrote that, I presume you can,

1:04:45and I was gonna look it up,

1:04:46and then I don't remember if I actually looked it up.

1:04:49But yeah, it is basically a FaceTime competitor

1:04:52without being called a FaceTime competitor,

1:04:55but that's certainly what it is.

1:04:56- Well, it's, 'cause it, yeah,

1:04:58So the trick to the whole thing is that they've updated the phone app for, I guess, Android

1:05:05and iOS.

1:05:06I know the iOS one's updated.

1:05:07Where both for you to have one of these calls with somebody who doesn't own an Echo or who

1:05:17would want to use this if you had to be in the room where your Echo is to get the call?

1:05:23It's like all of a sudden you're back to landline days where you've got a quick run to the kitchen

1:05:28to take a phone call.

1:05:31That's not going to fly.

1:05:32Well, yeah, but I remember when the Echo first came along,

1:05:39it was the original introductory video, which unfortunately

1:05:44has been taken down.

1:05:45But it was super corny.

1:05:48And I remember a lot of people made fun of it.

1:05:50But actually, I kind of liked it because it was--

1:05:53and you can see the same thing in the new Echo Show video,

1:05:56which is it's very sort of, there's no like fancy,

1:06:00like marketing commercial stuff going on here.

1:06:03It's very straightforward,

1:06:04like showing people explicit use cases for this product

1:06:07and people going through these use cases.

1:06:09Like the dad is changing the baby's diaper

1:06:11and he's ordering new diapers.

1:06:12Like it's not subtle at all, but I kind of liked that.

1:06:14Like it's, you're not limited to a 30 second grab.

1:06:18You're not trying to instill sort of,

1:06:20I think there's a mistake a lot of marketers in tech

1:06:23have traditionally made is they've,

1:06:25they hire these branding agencies,

1:06:26especially in the early days of tech,

1:06:27these branding agencies that were used to doing

1:06:29like consumer goods, consumer packaged goods,

1:06:31and there it's all about building sort of brand affinity

1:06:34because the goal is when someone's in a store

1:06:36and they're faced with like 15 options for crackers,

1:06:40that they choose one or the owner or whatever it might be,

1:06:43they choose one and they don't really know

1:06:45why they chose it, they just do,

1:06:47and that's the payoff of all that advertising

1:06:49and branding and all that sort of stuff.

1:06:52With tech products, it's much more of a deliberate choice.

1:06:56So to use sort of brand-type marketing,

1:06:59I think is much inferior to just showing it,

1:07:04showing how it works.

1:07:05I mean, this is something,

1:07:06some of my favorite Apple ads actually

1:07:08were the original iPhone ads.

1:07:10Not the first one, like the "Hello, hello"

1:07:12at the Academy Awards, but all the ads after that

1:07:14for the first year, they were just showing people

1:07:16using the phone.

1:07:18- The ones with Bob Bircher, I think his name was, right?

1:07:21Yeah, and at the very end, the phone would ring.

1:07:24So they'd show them reading the New York Times.

1:07:26They'd show them scrolling, playing a game,

1:07:29or not playing a game, but doing stuff on the phone

1:07:30that you could do on the phone.

1:07:32And then at the very end of the commercial,

1:07:34and it's the same one every time,

1:07:35the phone would ring, say, "Oh, and it's a phone."

1:07:37And it was so effective both in explaining

1:07:40what the iPhone is,

1:07:41they were also teaching people how to use it.

1:07:43One of some of my favorite commercials,

1:07:45just because I think the way they really,

1:07:49It was a new way of doing commercials

1:07:51that I think was much better for a tech product

1:07:54and something that I was always very frustrated by

1:07:58when I was at Microsoft

1:07:59'cause I thought so many of the commercials

1:08:02were in this CPG branding mindset

1:08:05when you're selling a very different kind of product.

1:08:07- Yeah, those iPhone commercials were brilliant

1:08:11'cause they were fast, I mean, they were 30-second spots,

1:08:13but they showed things and they, you know--

1:08:17- They showed it, they showed the product.

1:08:18But it was like real things, and they're like,

1:08:20look, maybe you don't believe it.

1:08:22Maybe you hear somebody saying,

1:08:23you know, you can get maps on your phone now,

1:08:25on these iPhones, you can get a usable map.

1:08:28But they'd show it, they'd say,

1:08:29here, look, type Starbucks, and hit one button.

1:08:33Very easy, just says, you know, like search or whatever,

1:08:36and then a map shows up showing how far you are

1:08:38from Starbucks, or whatever the example was

1:08:40in the commercial.

1:08:41- Yep, yep, exactly, yeah.

1:08:42The map one was a big one, and that was,

1:08:44and it was so immediately became apparent

1:08:46the value was to people, right?

1:08:48Right.

1:08:49Yeah.

1:08:50Yeah.

1:08:51This is something you can understand.

1:08:54Apple understood that-- it sounds funny,

1:08:58but it's the thing that I think a lot of tech people, even

1:09:00tech marketers overlook, is that you tell a lot of people, OK,

1:09:05you've got a cell phone.

1:09:06We know that.

1:09:07We know you're frustrated by it.

1:09:09We know that you probably can't figure

1:09:11out how to do anything on it other than make the phone calls.

1:09:15We're trying to sell you a phone that does,

1:09:17it browses the web, gets your email,

1:09:20has maps, lets you watch YouTube videos.

1:09:24But trust us, none of this is more complicated

1:09:27and making phone calls is even easier

1:09:28than it was on your old phone.

1:09:30- Yep, yeah, it's exactly right.

1:09:33So I mean, these Amazon Echo spots are not like that

1:09:38and they're not nearly as highly produced

1:09:40and they're still pretty corny.

1:09:42But if you're showing a product, a $200 product,

1:09:46and in the original echo I think was the same,

1:09:48I think it was $99 for Prime members,

1:09:49but people are on your, you're on the web,

1:09:52you have infinite space, you can show as short

1:09:54or long a video as you want,

1:09:55you're not limited to 30 seconds,

1:09:57and people are being deliberate about their choice,

1:10:00why not take advantage of that and actually show

1:10:04how this product might be useful?

1:10:05And I think that's something they've done

1:10:07pretty consistently with these,

1:10:08and I think it's smart, I think it's a much better way

1:10:12to think about marketing your product,

1:10:16'cause you're marketing a different kind of product

1:10:17in a different context, particularly for Amazon,

1:10:20because it's on their, they have a big website

1:10:22that they can use.

1:10:24- Yeah, I know that the, I'm gonna get the name wrong,

1:10:27I can't remember these right, 'cause there's weird,

1:10:29like the Echo Show and Echo Look, but it's like, to me--

1:10:32- Echo Dot is the little one.

1:10:33- Well, Echo Show is the one with the TV set,

1:10:38and Echo Look is the one that's like for your dressing room.

1:10:41Right. But you could call it like it's one of those things where, all right, Echo Look

1:10:50is the one that is a camera and you show it, you get dressed and you get like a selfie

1:10:54and you can get like some kind of analysis as to whether your shoes match your belt or

1:11:00whatever. But it just the name Echo Look, it could also mean the thing that you look

1:11:05at, the thing with the screen, right? And Echo Show, which is the one with the screen,

1:11:10That could be the name of the one that's the camera.

1:11:12Like here, Echo, let me show you what I'm wearing.

1:11:14Right?

1:11:15Yeah, I would call the other one, this is just called Echo Camera.

1:11:18I think so too, because then it's clear.

1:11:20That's what it is.

1:11:21Right.

1:11:22And I think the whole gives you tips on what you wear.

1:11:26I always feel like they put that in for the tech geeks.

1:11:29The reality is this whole taking pictures of your outfit is a huge thing, a massive

1:11:35thing and people do it every day.

1:11:37They mostly do it by holding out their arm

1:11:42and taking a selfie, or staying in front of a mirror

1:11:43and snapping a picture.

1:11:45It's a massive, massive, massive thing.

1:11:49So I think that's clearly what this product is focused on,

1:11:51then that's the point of it.

1:11:55And maybe in the long run it will be useful

1:11:56to do the sort of AI stuff,

1:11:59but I almost feel like that was throwing a bone

1:12:02to all the techies saying, "Oh, and there's this thing too."

1:12:03It's a selfie camera, like that's what it is.

1:12:05And that's not to belittle it

1:12:08because that is a massive market.

1:12:10And it's a massive market that's really interesting.

1:12:12There's lots of stuff about retail and retail changing.

1:12:14And one of the big drivers of this is social media.

1:12:17And on social media, it used to be back in the day,

1:12:20like what drove fashion was it was all a status thing, right?

1:12:23You want to go and you go to the mall

1:12:24and you buy the high status items

1:12:26and then you would wear them to school or whatever.

1:12:29Now it's much more about standing out,

1:12:31popping out on social media.

1:12:32and variety and having something interesting and different

1:12:35is much more important.

1:12:37And I think, and just playing into that.

1:12:40- I laugh because you said you wear it to school

1:12:42or whatever and I know exactly why you said that.

1:12:45And I think I even know why you hesitated after saying it.

1:12:48I think you had the same thought that I had did

1:12:49as you said it is you're talking from the perspective

1:12:52of me and you two guys in our 40s.

1:12:54- I know, I know.

1:12:55- Because when retail was the only way to buy clothes,

1:13:00that's when you and I were in school.

1:13:02And by the time we got out of school,

1:13:06that was when the internet was a thing.

1:13:08And I had the same thought.

1:13:09It's like, well, yeah, back in the days,

1:13:10back in the days when you used to have to buy

1:13:12all your clothes at the mall, you'd wear them to school.

1:13:15Everybody wore them to school.

1:13:16But of course there were generations of adults ahead of us

1:13:20who wore them to other places.

1:13:23- Yeah, but it is funny.

1:13:25Like it's always hard to, or you have to be like super,

1:13:29You're right, because the hesitation was the snap of self-awareness, like I'm probably

1:13:33over-personalizing this experience.

1:13:35But you do see this sort of traditional brands that dominated malls, and they're all struggling

1:13:44mightily.

1:13:48You see other things, like there's this other websites and services that are much

1:13:53more inexpensive and it's much more about having something unique and different as opposed

1:14:00to having the same branded t-shirt as everybody else.

1:14:03I saw a thing that, I think the New York Times just had a story that the J. Crew is in financial

1:14:08distress.

1:14:09I think Gap is too.

1:14:11There's companies that would like--

1:14:13Yeah, Abercrombie and Fitch, all of them are struggling.

1:14:17Right.

1:14:18thought, well Abercrombie & Fitch was always a little bit more niche, you know, because

1:14:25they had the, you know, it smells weird and it purposefully made an unwelcoming front

1:14:31to, it's actually kind of an interesting retail strategy where they, they kind of made the

1:14:34front of their stores sort of hard to get into. Like I said, having a big wide opening,

1:14:39they would just have a door and it was sort of, you know, um, like they wanted, you know,

1:14:45It's totally contrary to most retailers,

1:14:49but it was sort of like they only wanted

1:14:50the right people to come in, you know,

1:14:52young people who were shopping for Abercrombie clothes.

1:14:55But anyway, the gap to me is more of the universal,

1:14:59my God, everybody can go in the gap

1:15:00and find something that they would consider wearing.

1:15:03It's weird that they're having, not weird,

1:15:06but it's just, it's obviously like

1:15:09a foundation of American retail is crumbling

1:15:12if stores like that aren't doing well.

1:15:14- Here's a question for you.

1:15:16Do you ever, like when you need,

1:15:19like you feel like you need some new shirts,

1:15:21do you go out and buy shirts in a retail store

1:15:24or do you buy everything online?

1:15:25- I usually, every summer, I go and just buy a ton of stuff.

1:15:31Actually, we always, it's a thing,

1:15:35'cause my brother lives in Minneapolis,

1:15:37and so we always go there and see my brother,

1:15:40and then one day we go to the Mall of America

1:15:42and there's no sales tax on clothing there,

1:15:44and everything's there, and we just spend one day buying,

1:15:47or at least I do, try to buy all the clothes

1:15:49I need for the entire year.

1:15:51Would I do need things otherwise?

1:15:54Yeah, I go to department stores here.

1:15:55I don't buy online.

1:15:58But everything online here is mostly in Chinese

1:16:01and whatnot, and it's obviously a little more difficult.

1:16:02But my wife buys a ton of stuff online.

1:16:04She buys stuff online all the time.

1:16:05- My wife buys everything online, almost everything.

1:16:08I can't recall the last time she went out

1:16:11shopping for clothes.

1:16:12She just buys everything online.

1:16:14Unlike me, she's not afraid to send stuff back.

1:16:16Like that's my problem.

1:16:18I don't, I hate, I just don't like packing stuff up

1:16:21to send back. - Yep.

1:16:22- It's irrational, it's completely irrational.

1:16:25And it's not like I've amassed all these,

1:16:28like a big pile of clothes that I don't like

1:16:31or that don't fit, that I just suck the,

1:16:35just eat the cost of it because I don't send it.

1:16:38But it's why I don't buy stuff like shirts.

1:16:40Like if I was gonna buy like a dress shirt,

1:16:42I don't buy it online.

1:16:43Unless I know-- - I'm the same way.

1:16:45- If I know that there's like a shirt

1:16:48from Banana Republic, that I already have one,

1:16:52and I know the exact size, and I can judge from the picture

1:16:54exactly what this one looks like, I would buy that online.

1:16:57But that's because I've actually tried it on.

1:16:59- Yeah, I'm the same way.

1:17:01That sort of, like, yes it's a hassle to get in the car

1:17:05and like go to the store, or however you get you

1:17:09to the store, but for me, that sort of hassle

1:17:12doesn't register, whereas having a bunch of boxes

1:17:14and having to pack stuff up and put it out,

1:17:17and oh, that just sounds like absolute torture to me.

1:17:20Even if you were to actually go through

1:17:22and add up the number of minutes that it takes, it's less,

1:17:24the feeling of it is much worse.

1:17:28So I'm completely with you.

1:17:29- But for stuff like underwear and socks

1:17:31and stuff like that, I don't think I've bought anything

1:17:33like that in a retail store in 10 years.

1:17:36I mean, why would you?

1:17:38It's crazy.

1:17:39You feel like you need some new underwear.

1:17:41Boom.

1:17:42Just click a couple of buttons and it's at your house.

1:17:45The Amazon apparel thing is very interesting because they've not announced any numbers

1:17:49about it, but there's hints that it's actually doing much better than you think and they're

1:17:54growing really rapidly.

1:17:56I suspect a lot of it is probably things like you just said, basics and whatnot.

1:18:04At a minimum, they're for sure making massive investments in it.

1:18:07huge, not just the Amazon book, although I think that is interesting in that regard,

1:18:13but they have all kinds of interesting projects going on.

1:18:15They've launched multiple brands, their brands, for different categories.

1:18:24They own Zappos.

1:18:25Yeah, but this is all in Amazon itself.

1:18:29I think it's not, the Zappos thing was, I think they bought them because they were

1:18:36doing well and they're an e-commerce site,

1:18:37and so they wanted to take them out.

1:18:41I mean, they just closed down,

1:18:42or they're on the verge of closing down.

1:18:43What's the other one they bought?

1:18:44Oh, diapers.com.

1:18:46Same thing.

1:18:47I think in the long run, I would be surprised

1:18:51if Zappos remains an ongoing concern,

1:18:52but I mean, people like it, people go there,

1:18:54so maybe they'll keep it around.

1:18:56But the long run for sure is all Amazon.

1:18:59They want, because, and this is the other thing,

1:19:01oh, this is the topic we should talk about.

1:19:02I haven't written about this yet,

1:19:03but the Amazon Prime video being on Apple TV.

1:19:08- Oh yeah, well that's, I'm making a note,

1:19:10we'll talk about that in a minute.

1:19:11- Yeah, well because I think Amazon is really trying

1:19:14to own every aspect of, they want to be the facilitator

1:19:19of basically everything in your life,

1:19:20particularly everything in the home,

1:19:22and this is what makes the whole Echo line

1:19:24so brilliant for Amazon.

1:19:26I mean, the opportunity, the reason the opportunity is there

1:19:29is because the home is the one place

1:19:31you don't necessarily have your phone with you, right?

1:19:32If you're out and about, you always have your phone with you.

1:19:35If you're at home, it's plugged in and charging.

1:19:40The other thing is, if you're out and about to just suddenly talk at random, it's getting

1:19:44perhaps more and more socially acceptable, but still a little weird.

1:19:47Whereas at home, to shout at an Echo is totally fine.

1:19:52It's your house.

1:19:53You can do what you want.

1:19:54Also, it fits with the long-term Amazon model of basically being the infrastructure for

1:20:03your home.

1:20:04It's how the things in your home get there.

1:20:05It's how you resupply.

1:20:07It's how you do everything.

1:20:09The focus on clothes and Echo and all that sort of stuff fits into that.

1:20:16Having another brand that's not Amazon, I think, doesn't fit into that in the long one,

1:20:21especially with Prime, 'cause they want to be,

1:20:23it's all Amazon, it's all Prime,

1:20:25and so I, we'll see how long Zappos is for this world,

1:20:30but I doubt it'll be a focus

1:20:31of their sort of apparel efforts.

1:20:33- Oh, I think Zappos is doing well.

1:20:35Maybe it just continues to run as a sort of independent,

1:20:39you know, I think you could easily be a,

1:20:42well, maybe not, maybe they make you sign in with Amazon.

1:20:44I don't know, but I was gonna say

1:20:45that I think you can shop at Zappos

1:20:47and not even know that they're a subsidiary, but.

1:20:50- Yeah, but right, and I think that's fine for Amazon,

1:20:54I mean, as long as it's not someone else,

1:20:57as long as they own it.

1:20:59- Here's the thing that, it doesn't surprise me,

1:21:01but it's, it's still, I still found it striking,

1:21:06was how much of the reaction to the Amazon,

1:21:09or the Echo Look, the one that's a camera

1:21:11for you getting dressed, was a sort of knee-jerk,

1:21:15you think I'm putting a camera connected to the cloud

1:21:18in my dressing room, you gotta be kidding me.

1:21:21Like a sort of knee jerk, I am not putting

1:21:24a computerized camera that uploads pictures to the web

1:21:29that you don't trust it or whatever.

1:21:31And I understand it and it certainly is,

1:21:34it's a reasonable concern that you'd want it to be private

1:21:39and you'd want it to come from a company that you trust

1:21:41and it's common sense that you'd think,

1:21:44at least think twice before you bought it and installed it.

1:21:47But I think it's almost silly to take the point that you don't think that we're

1:21:53going to have cameras all over our houses soon.

1:21:57It's clearly, that's where it's the only way to go.

1:22:00Yeah, and the other thing too is, is a camera really much worse than the Echo itself?

1:22:09The entire category is very problematic.

1:22:12But that's how people reacted to that a couple years ago.

1:22:14They did.

1:22:15It just dies down.

1:22:17I'm not saying that we should...

1:22:20I think anybody who knows me at all through the show or

1:22:25Daring Fireball would guess that I'm...

1:22:27it's not like I rush headlong into new things without

1:22:31thinking about them.

1:22:33In some ways I'm a lowercase c conservative.

1:22:36A lot of the...

1:22:38I don't...

1:22:40I find out what I like and then I stick with it.

1:22:42So I'm not drawn to new and shiny all the time.

1:22:47But I feel like everybody's a little bit too,

1:22:50in some ways, it's good that there's a lot of people

1:22:52whose first concern is privacy,

1:22:54as opposed to thinking about the cool things

1:22:56you could do with something like this.

1:22:57But I'm reminded of, God, it must probably be like '99

1:23:02or something like that, but way back,

1:23:04you know, around the millennium,

1:23:07when like Mac apps, indie Mac apps

1:23:10first started adding features

1:23:11where they would phone home and just say,

1:23:15you couldn't even upgrade,

1:23:17sparkle the technology where you can hit a button

1:23:20and have, you're using version 3.1,

1:23:23version 3.2 is out, would you like to upgrade?

1:23:25And you just hit a button and it downloads

1:23:27and upgrades and quits and relaunches,

1:23:28and there you go, you're running a new one.

1:23:30But there were apps that would just put a dialogue up

1:23:32and say, hey, there's a new version,

1:23:34do you wanna go to the website and download it?

1:23:36And people freaked the fuck out

1:23:38because they were like, what the hell?

1:23:40and sniffing the network traffic.

1:23:43It's not like they were revealing anything,

1:23:46but the fact that the app was phoning home with anything,

1:23:49even just to check the version, was too much for people.

1:23:53And there were people who would do, like, Nday meant it.

1:23:56I'm deleting this app, I'm switching to a competitor,

1:23:58because there's no way that any software of mine

1:24:01is going to phone home to the developer server,

1:24:04even if it's just to check the version.

1:24:07And I don't want to make fun of it too bad,

1:24:10but I mean, that's, you know,

1:24:12is there an app that you use today

1:24:15that doesn't notify you when there's a new version?

1:24:18And I feel like we're going that way

1:24:21with microphones and cameras.

1:24:23- We are.

1:24:24I think there's two sort of points to make.

1:24:27One is your broader point,

1:24:29and this is the most important point,

1:24:30is this is sort of inevitable.

1:24:33Like we're going down this direction,

1:24:34and the fact of the matter is that

1:24:36most people just don't care.

1:24:38And this applies to their online privacy,

1:24:41it applies to, and this is the big problem

1:24:44with sort of fighting for privacy

1:24:49when it comes to technology products

1:24:50is that unfortunately people don't care.

1:24:53And maybe at some point there'll be some scandal

1:24:56that's so bad and so big that it will actually become

1:25:00something that people care about,

1:25:01but to date there's no evidence that that's going to happen.

1:25:04People value convenience, they just do.

1:25:07And related to that though, it actually is really concerning, like the whole echo thing.

1:25:15I have echoes over my house, but the actual, it's not really clear.

1:25:22Amazon says that they're secure and all this sort of stuff, but there's no really

1:25:27recourse for people if they were used badly.

1:25:32It really is just kind of trusting this massive corporation is going to do the right thing.

1:25:41Obviously people can and will track their network and make sure that it's only sending

1:25:45when Alexa is triggered or whatever it might be.

1:25:48But then once it gets on the servers, you don't really know what's happening to it.

1:25:51It really is a massive, massive problem.

1:25:53Unfortunately, it's a problem that absent some sort of popular will, it's hard to

1:26:00to see anything being done about it.

1:26:03- Right, once you're Yodingas,

1:26:07turn out the lights in the kitchen, command goes there,

1:26:11you have no idea where that audio goes

1:26:13and how long it lasts and what they do with it.

1:26:16It is a black box.

1:26:17So I'm not discounting the privacy concerns,

1:26:19but I think, and it's just like,

1:26:21it's such a small example,

1:26:22but just like how apps that can run a version check

1:26:26and notify you of a new version,

1:26:28It is a trade-off of privacy where there is some information

1:26:33of yours that is going to the developer and they can

1:26:35maybe a lot of times send other things too,

1:26:39like what model Macintosh you're on

1:26:41and how much RAM you have or something like that.

1:26:43You are trading some privacy

1:26:45by allowing the software to do it,

1:26:46but in return you're getting something of such convenience.

1:26:50It is so much, the days when you used to have to manually

1:26:53like follow, there used to be a website like Mac Update

1:26:56where you'd, like, part of my morning was go to Mac update

1:27:00and what was the other one?

1:27:01Version tracker.

1:27:03You'd go to version tracker and just see

1:27:05if any of the software I use has a new version out

1:27:08and if so, go and update it.

1:27:10I mean, that was actually part of my daily routine.

1:27:13It seems like madness at this point.

1:27:17And there's so much of the convenience of these

1:27:19AI assistants and we're just, just touching our toes in it.

1:27:26like, I don't know, the more I think about it,

1:27:29and I know I've been talking about it

1:27:30a lot more on the show,

1:27:31like if I were to go to a company like Apple

1:27:35or Microsoft or something or Google,

1:27:37like what would I wanna be working on?

1:27:39I mean, until now, almost unquestionably,

1:27:43what I would wanna be working on

1:27:44is visual user interface stuff for the GUI.

1:27:47I think if I were there now,

1:27:51I think the AI stuff would be what I would wanna work on,

1:27:54'cause I feel like there's so much potential there.

1:27:57- One thing that's interesting about the Echo

1:27:59and with the Echo Show is I think in some respects

1:28:02it was good for Amazon to launch with just the speaker

1:28:05because it sort of, it was like the original Mac

1:28:08launching without arrow keys.

1:28:10So you had to use the mouse and the foundation

1:28:14of it being a voice interface is baked in very, very deeply

1:28:19and so now the show comes out and it has a screen,

1:28:21but it's not a touchscreen.

1:28:23It's still all voice controlled.

1:28:25But it's weird because if it came out originally,

1:28:27we'd say, "Wow, there's a screen.

1:28:28"It's not a touchscreen.

1:28:29"This is so weird."

1:28:30And people wouldn't really get how to interact with it.

1:28:32Now it's like, "Oh, wow, it's so much so convenient.

1:28:36"It's an echo with a screen."

1:28:38The whole framing and the way you think about the product

1:28:40is actually totally different

1:28:42because it was a more limited product to start out with.

1:28:46- I did not realize it was not a touchscreen.

1:28:48I find that shocking.

1:28:49It's not a touchscreen?

1:28:51- No.

1:28:52- Wow, that's shocking to me.

1:28:54I find that crazy, I think that's a huge mistake.

1:28:57I think there's all sorts of things that you'd want to do

1:28:59that you'd want to be able to touch to confirm

1:29:01or something like that.

1:29:02- Wait, yeah, no, I'm totally wrong, it is a touchscreen.

1:29:05- Oh, geez. (laughs)

1:29:07I thought maybe someone at Amazon had a stroke or something.

1:29:12- Yeah, no, that's funny, I don't know,

1:29:16I knew it was a touchscreen and it suddenly got stuck

1:29:18in my head that it was not a touchscreen.

1:29:19The point I was meaning to make,

1:29:22tell Cable to, or tell Cable to--

1:29:26- No way, man, we're leaving it in.

1:29:28- The point I was trying to make, though,

1:29:29is the primary means of interacting with it is voice.

1:29:34Had it been a touchscreen to start out with,

1:29:35that's what I'm trying to say,

1:29:36it would have been much more limited than it is,

1:29:40because every, you know, developers, all the skills,

1:29:42would have all been biased towards touch.

1:29:45Now they're all biased towards voice,

1:29:46and you can add on touch.

1:29:48That was weird, I just completely hallucinated

1:29:50for like five minutes there.

1:29:51I just wrote about it yesterday,

1:29:52I wrote about it being a touch screen.

1:29:54- I do see your point though, I see your point though,

1:29:56that it is voice first and it matters what's first.

1:30:00That the Mac being mouse first influenced the design

1:30:04of the GUI in a way that if you could have treated it

1:30:07as keyboard first, that's how the software

1:30:10would have been written, because that's how

1:30:11all the other software on all the other platforms

1:30:13was written.

1:30:13- Right, exactly, exactly.

1:30:15That was so weird.

1:30:16- You could use an original Macintosh,

1:30:19like if you had two of the original Macintosh side by side,

1:30:22and one of them only had the mouse hooked up,

1:30:24and the other one only had the keyboard hooked up,

1:30:27you could get more done on the one

1:30:28that had the mouse hooked up.

1:30:30And there might have been things

1:30:31that you couldn't even do on the keyboard.

1:30:32Yeah, you couldn't even get to the menu bar.

1:30:35The only thing you could do in the menu bar

1:30:36was have the keyboard shortcuts memorized.

1:30:39- Right, and I mean, in the long run,

1:30:42they brought them back, and it's better to have

1:30:44all the arrow keys there and whatnot.

1:30:46But yeah, as far as like getting the paradigm watch,

1:30:49and you know, if had it been a touchscreen to start,

1:30:54it would have, you know, that's just kind of like,

1:30:57it was just a phone, but worse,

1:31:00'cause it's locked in one spot,

1:31:01and the, to really drive home that it is a voice interface,

1:31:06yeah, I think they're better off starting there.

1:31:09But that said, the other thing though with the screen is,

1:31:12I think this calling thing,

1:31:16We mentioned, we talked more with the phone

1:31:17and stuff like that, but I think there really is value

1:31:20to being able to just initiate a conversation.

1:31:24And probably the most interesting thing here,

1:31:25and here Amazon totally sort of ripped off

1:31:28one of their companies.

1:31:30They have a venture fund for companies that,

1:31:33and they have Alexa built in.

1:31:34There's a company that built a voice communication device

1:31:38that has Echo built in, and it's basically,

1:31:41Amazon just completely Sherlock them,

1:31:43which is bad enough when it's software

1:31:45and it's probably far more painful when it's hardware.

1:31:48But once you have trusted people, you can drop in,

1:31:52which basically means you can initiate a call

1:31:54without their having to go to the,

1:31:56like actually answer it or do whatever.

1:31:57You could just be like sort of instant sort of thing.

1:31:59Now that sounds terrible in a lot of situations,

1:32:01but for me, I'm in a different, a separate office

1:32:04from down the street from the house

1:32:07to be able to just like turn up,

1:32:09be able to literally drop in.

1:32:11It's someone, if I was working from home,

1:32:13they have some ability to come in the,

1:32:15stop at the door and stick their head in.

1:32:16It's the same sort of idea.

1:32:18Obviously you're not gonna use it all the time,

1:32:20but the possibility I think is compelling and interesting

1:32:23and fundamentally different from FaceTime.

1:32:25Fundamentally different from having to get your phone

1:32:27and pull it out.

1:32:28For the kids to call grandma, something like this,

1:32:31is really, is more convenient than having to use FaceTime.

1:32:35- I forget what it was in the context of one of these things

1:32:41I was like, you know, just how crude all of these things, whatever your favorite is, you

1:32:47know, the Alexa platform or Siri or Google or whatever. It's so early days on all of

1:32:53them that we will look back and, you know, this is like to the, you know, personal computer

1:32:58like what the Apple II was in 1981, you know, it's, we're just at the tip of the iceberg,

1:33:04but that you can see where we're going. And I wrote that, you know, really what I want

1:33:08is I want like a C-3PO. But I thought about it a couple days later, I realized I was totally wrong.

1:33:14That's too much because having the actual robot who can walk around is an entirely different set

1:33:19of problems. For these AI assistants, what I want is HAL from 2001. And I wrote that, and I feel

1:33:25like every time you bring up HAL, everybody just goes immediately to, "Yeah, but he killed a bunch

1:33:30of astronauts and tried to kill the last one too and had to be put down." All right, put aside the

1:33:37the fact that he killed people.

1:33:38(laughing)

1:33:39But he did kill people for a very logical reason.

1:33:43I don't want to spoil the movie, but it's...

1:33:45- If you haven't watched "2001,"

1:33:48you need to go watch "2001."

1:33:49- But if you just, if you think about the stuff

1:33:51that Hal does in the movie,

1:33:53and how the astronauts interact with him,

1:33:57it's exactly where we're going.

1:33:59It is exactly the...

1:34:01There could not be a better,

1:34:05everybody is racing towards HAL, where it's not just a voice and a speaker where you can ask HAL,

1:34:11you know, what's the square root of 256 or something like that and get an answer.

1:34:16It's that it's the home automation integration where you can say things like tell your dingus to,

1:34:24you know, close all the blinds if you have blinds that are hooked up to the smart house or something

1:34:29like that or change the color of your lights or something like that. Like that's how they ran the

1:34:34spaceship is they would tell Hal to, you know, open the pod bay doors or something like that.

1:34:39Like, that's exactly where we're going with all these things. And it's, you know, and you watch,

1:34:44and one of the things that, you know, Kubrick got so well in that movie is that they're,

1:34:49you know, from the perspective of somebody watching it in 1968, it was like whiz-bang,

1:34:54futuristic stuff, like, wow, you can tell Hal to open the door and the door opens. But the

1:34:58astronauts acted like it was the most normal thing in the world because they were used to it.

1:35:03Right. Anyway, I think everybody needs to watch Hal and realize that that's exactly where we're

1:35:08going. And the other thing too about Hal was that—and it would have been so easy from 1968's

1:35:16perspective to imagine Hal as a big refrigerator computing device that's located in the bridge of

1:35:25the spaceship. And to think of—because that's what computers were. But Hal was everywhere,

1:35:31Right? They were just little red cameras all around the ship. He was a system that was running throughout the whole ship.

1:35:39Right. And that's exactly the model of like, I mean, the Amazon to a T, where you sprinkle these dots throughout your house,

1:35:48so that, you know, if you're upstairs or downstairs, you can access the exact same system.

1:35:55The other the other I completely agree. I think it is a great example of of the

1:36:03What what everyone is going for the other point I would make I was just thinking about this in terms of FaceTime is Google

1:36:09launched a

1:36:11FaceTime competitor. I can't remember what it's called. Um

1:36:14Well, I was it aloe. No, hello is the chat app. Yeah weirdly they launched two apps

1:36:20separately Google Duo, yeah, I mean

1:36:24And the problem with that is it's a separate app,

1:36:29you have to go download it, et cetera,

1:36:31and it's work beyond, like FaceTime is built in.

1:36:36Now obviously the advantage is you can theoretically

1:36:38go across the platform, then you're competing

1:36:40against Skype though, which has similar capability.

1:36:44And it's just a hard, Google's problem is always

1:36:47sort of the go-to-market, how they actually get

1:36:49their products and technology into people's hands.

1:36:52And obviously Android is one way to do that,

1:36:55but then you have to get people on iPhones to download it.

1:37:00Anyhow, it's hard.

1:37:01- My impression of Google from the outside,

1:37:03and the Allo Duo thing is a perfect example of it,

1:37:06is that their company culture is so resistant

1:37:09to product people that in and of itself,

1:37:14there's nothing unproduct-like about Allo or Duo,

1:37:19but there's clearly no overarching strategy

1:37:21connecting the two or otherwise they wouldn't exist

1:37:23as separate products, but there's nobody,

1:37:25I don't feel there's anybody in a position of authority

1:37:27to sort of crack that whip and guide it.

1:37:31It's just a thousand individual cats

1:37:35wandering around Mountain View

1:37:36doing whatever the hell they want.

1:37:37(laughing)

1:37:40- Yeah, I don't know, it certainly does not seem ideal.

1:37:44But the difference here with Alexa and this voice calling

1:37:48is because of this show device,

1:37:52there is actually a reason to download the app

1:37:57and to use it because there is capability that is,

1:38:00like it's not just a rip off,

1:38:02it's actually doing something new and unique

1:38:05that is worth going to the trouble

1:38:06of downloading the app for.

1:38:08And so it's actually, I would argue,

1:38:09much more of a threat in the long run to FaceTime

1:38:13than Google or Skype, whatever,

1:38:15Even though those have the advantage of being cross-platform,

1:38:18Aloe is not only cross-platform,

1:38:21but also has this third dimension

1:38:23that makes you want to use it.

1:38:26- Yeah, I can sort of see that.

1:38:30I wonder how many people use Aloe.

1:38:35I never really hear about it anymore.

1:38:38It seems like one of those things that, you know,

1:38:40is anybody using it?

1:38:43- Well, I mean, this is a, it's created for Google's benefit

1:38:46because they felt like they needed a chat app.

1:38:48- Right.

1:38:49- Yeah, like there's no market need for it.

1:38:51Like there are plenty of chat apps and this is the,

1:38:55and you can't, they added some features,

1:38:59like you can't just tack on some features.

1:39:01Like you have to create a fun,

1:39:04like the Echo Show creates a fundamentally new use case

1:39:08for video calling because it's like this omnipresent object

1:39:12in a specific location, like in a place where it actually makes sense.

1:39:17Yes, it's kind of a landline, blah, blah, blah, but you know,

1:39:21you can't, when you're wandering around your house,

1:39:23you have your phone with you to be able to just shout out, call whoever.

1:39:25And you can call other echoes. It's not just a show.

1:39:29So you can call from echo to phone.

1:39:32Like it's a fundamentally new use case,

1:39:34whereas these Google products had some new features,

1:39:37but the actual use case was well served by plenty of other apps that were there early.

1:39:39And it's even more difficult because it's a network product

1:39:43and the single most important feature,

1:39:45the single most important feature of any chat app

1:39:47is do your friends and family use it?

1:39:49Like nothing else matters beyond that.

1:39:51- Yep, because it's like the old argument about, you know,

1:39:55who bought the first fax machine?

1:39:57- Right.

1:39:59- Who the hell are you getting faxes from?

1:40:01You just bought the first one.

1:40:02But all of a sudden, if one guy across town

1:40:05buys the second one, all of a sudden,

1:40:07you've got something that's valuable.

1:40:09I mean, it has more value than it did when you,

1:40:10yours was the only fax machine on the phone network.

1:40:14- And this is why, one thing that was really interesting

1:40:16was when the whole messaging app revolution went on,

1:40:21it was very brief, it was like two or three years.

1:40:23And what happened was, it was really one sort of

1:40:26country by country.

1:40:28And countries would basically settle on one service

1:40:31and that was it, and it was over.

1:40:32Like the fight was, it was done.

1:40:34There was no more of a fight to be had.

1:40:37and you had companies like WeChat and Line spending all kinds of money trying to break

1:40:42into other countries, but once you're already established, absent some massive leap in functionality.

1:40:52The reason why messaging was such a big deal is that in nearly every country in the world,

1:40:56except for the US, you have to pay for SMS.

1:40:59I think this is why the US thing is more fragmented and is much further, much more behind as opposed

1:41:07like message app penetration.

1:41:09I mean, and why iMessage is probably the strongest,

1:41:13the strongest network because it's piggyback on SMS,

1:41:15but it's different, it was different

1:41:16in almost every other country in the world,

1:41:18where not having to pay is a really powerful way

1:41:22to drive adoption, right?

1:41:24But once that was done, once everyone is already using

1:41:28a chat app that lets them chat for free,

1:41:31to get them to switch and not just switch one person,

1:41:34because you have to switch everyone simultaneously

1:41:37at the same time is basically, is extremely difficult.

1:41:42- Right, the lack of foresight that the carriers had

1:41:46by trying to milk the SMS revenue at the expense of,

1:41:50well, if we just give everybody free,

1:41:53at the very least they're attached to the phone, right?

1:41:57Then their phone number.

1:41:59And we've got, we've got like a,

1:42:00at least got a sticky platform.

1:42:02Like in the way that iMessage has been very,

1:42:04very good to Apple,

1:42:06even though they've never once charged to send.

1:42:08- It's one of Apple's, yep.

1:42:09Yeah, I mean, it's one of Apple's,

1:42:13I've probably complained on the talk show before,

1:42:16for sure I've complained on exponents,

1:42:18but people often ask, or I get emails

1:42:21whenever I write about messaging apps,

1:42:23and people are like, oh, Apple,

1:42:26why isn't iMessage in the stock price?

1:42:2810 cent is worth x amount, Facebook's worth x amount.

1:42:32Apple's stock should be higher

1:42:33because they have iMessage.

1:42:35And like, no, iMessage is absolutely accounted for.

1:42:39It's accounted for in the phone.

1:42:41Like it is a reason why Apple can maintain,

1:42:45charge such high margins on the phone,

1:42:46can maintain its share, can be so dominant.

1:42:49And iMessage is not the reason,

1:42:52but it is a significant reason why people on iPhones

1:42:56continue to buy iPhones.

1:42:58And so it's super valuable and it is accounted for.

1:43:02It's just embedded in the iPhone.

1:43:05- Yeah, I do think it might be discounted in some ways,

1:43:07but it's different than the independent messaging platforms.

1:43:11- Well, no, it may, yeah, but if you broke it out,

1:43:14if iMessage was actually available on Android,

1:43:16and, well, I guess that's the only one that matters,

1:43:19yes, maybe the iMessage category

1:43:23or whatever division would be worth a lot,

1:43:26but the iPhone, I think the cost

1:43:28that would be borne by the iPhone

1:43:31would actually be even greater than that.

1:43:33- Right, right.

1:43:34- That's why when there was that rumor last year

1:43:36that Apple was going to ship iMessage for Android,

1:43:41I do believe, in fact, I heard from people

1:43:45that there absolutely positively were mocks

1:43:47that were floated within Apple,

1:43:49but that doesn't mean that there was ever

1:43:50any serious intention to do it.

1:43:52It's almost more like, well, why wouldn't there be?

1:43:54Why wouldn't they at least sketch out how it would work,

1:43:58whether they have any intention of doing it or not?

1:44:00But it just seemed to me so unlikely,

1:44:02because it seemed to me like whatever they would get from it, they would lose in the stickiness that iMessage gives to the phone.

1:44:11In terms of any kind of temptation you have, if you have tons and tons of blue bubbles in your text with your friends and family,

1:44:18any temptation you might have to switch to an Android phone when it dawns on you that you lose all those iMessages and everything goes green, it's like, "Ehh, maybe not."

1:44:28Right, and that's why they, that's a motivation for making iMessages more and more, have more

1:44:34and more features and things like that.

1:44:36I mean, I think they've done a pretty poor job of it, but the motivation is to differentiate

1:44:41it from SMS even further so that, yeah, to switch something else doesn't, you know, feels

1:44:48like a terrible idea.

1:44:49Yeah, I mean, I, you know, I'm not a big fan of, I don't like using Android in part, I'm

1:44:56I'm not used to it, but there's little things

1:44:58that I don't like that kind of drag me off the wall.

1:45:01But without question, the,

1:45:04but I still, I mean, I have a Pixel now.

1:45:07I've used Android phones occasionally,

1:45:09but iMessage is, without question,

1:45:11the most straight-up, frustrating aspect

1:45:15of using a Android phone for any period of time.

1:45:19And there's little stuff, but I mean,

1:45:20little stuff, whatever, you can get used to,

1:45:22you can get over it.

1:45:23You can't really get past there not being iMessage.

1:45:25But it's interesting to think of my message as a wholly owned proprietary to iOS and Mac OS to a lesser degree

1:45:31Messaging platform that Apple owns and think about this tell me if you think this is interesting hypothetical, but what if

1:45:40When Instagram was on the market what if Apple had bought Instagram instead of Facebook and kept it

1:45:49iOS only

1:45:52Is that interesting to think of? I think it kind of is, like in a way that people use,

1:45:57you know, that

1:45:59the blue bubbles are seen as having more status than green bubbles. Like imagine if there were

1:46:04tens of millions of people sharing photos on Instagram, you know, and you the only way you couldn't even look at it

1:46:11unless you had an iPhone.

1:46:12It is really interesting. I mean, because it's value-destructive,

1:46:18according to like theoretically it's value destructive

1:46:21to buy a sort of like horizontal service

1:46:26and limit it to where platform

1:46:28in the context of the service itself.

1:46:29So like Instagram is worth what?

1:46:32However, a huge amount of money,

1:46:35vastly more than Facebook paid for it.

1:46:37- They paid $1 billion. - $50 billion,

1:46:39I don't know, whatever.

1:46:40- They paid $1 billion, but I wouldn't be surprised

1:46:42if they tried to sell it now.

1:46:43I mean, I would think like $50 billion, I don't know.

1:46:46I mean, it's almost, it's worth so much

1:46:48it's almost, you know, you have to,

1:46:52it's like whatever somebody would be willing to pay for it.

1:46:54It's kind of hard to get the value on it.

1:46:56- And they'd be willing to pay a lot.

1:46:58So it would not be worth that by itself.

1:47:03But to your point, by the time Android came out,

1:47:07which was like three days before Facebook bought it,

1:47:10the momentum and sort of place that Instagram had

1:47:14in sort of like popular culture,

1:47:16even with only having however many users it had,

1:47:19it was a thing.

1:47:21It was very much a thing just being on iOS.

1:47:23And yeah, would it still be a thing?

1:47:26I think that's sort of the longer run question.

1:47:28Like, would it be able to maintain that

1:47:29or would a cross-platform service really, you know,

1:47:34whether, I mean, Snapchat would probably be

1:47:37in much better shape today if Apple had done that,

1:47:40being something that's more broadly accessible.

1:47:46It's a really interesting point.

1:47:49Well, clearly Facebook would have--

1:47:52if Apple had bought Instagram, Facebook

1:47:54would have done their best.

1:47:56We see what they do with Snapchat.

1:47:57They would have tried seven different ways

1:48:00to copy Instagram, whether it was with their own new app

1:48:04or whether putting it in your regular Facebook feed,

1:48:06just like they've copied Snapchat's stories gimmick

1:48:10like seven different ways.

1:48:11So maybe it would have been Facebook somehow

1:48:13would have done it.

1:48:14But I still think there's something interesting there.

1:48:16And the idea would be that it wouldn't necessarily--

1:48:18like, Instagram itself, as an Apple subsidiary,

1:48:21wouldn't be worth anywhere near what Instagram is worth today

1:48:24as a Facebook subsidiary with so many more users.

1:48:28But it might--

1:48:29Would the iPhone be worth that much more?

1:48:31Right.

1:48:31The iPhone might be worth more because people

1:48:33would be terrified of getting a different phone because they

1:48:36wouldn't be able to share their stuff to Instagram anymore.

1:48:38And they've got 4,000 followers or whatever on Instagram.

1:48:42And the only way they can keep that going

1:48:44as if they keep buying iPhones.

1:48:46And I can't help but think that that was--

1:48:48I have never heard this from anybody.

1:48:51So this is just complete speculation on my part.

1:48:53No, not single birdie has ever said anything to me.

1:48:55But I thought it was so conspicuous.

1:48:56I thought it right at the time that Instagram for Android

1:49:00shipped coincident with their acquisition from Facebook.

1:49:04It was only after the Facebook acquisition was made official.

1:49:08I forget if all the eyes were dotted.

1:49:10Yeah, it was like the same week.

1:49:13I cannot help but think that Apple might have at least been at the table.

1:49:18And the fact, it would be a lot easier to never have had an Android version than to sell to Apple

1:49:25and cancel the Android version.

1:49:27And I think the only part of it that was even interesting to Apple was that it was iOS exclusive.

1:49:32And famously...

1:49:34Without question, yeah. Instagram as it is today is not valuable.

1:49:37No.

1:49:39And you're not cutting it off.

1:49:42- Right, that's the funny thing is that

1:49:44Instagram is more valuable today,

1:49:47but it wouldn't be more valuable to Apple.

1:49:48It was only valuable to Apple as an iOS exclusive,

1:49:51and it emphasized their product marketing,

1:49:53that the camera is better on the iPhone,

1:49:55that it kind of fit in.

1:50:00- Yeah, I think-- - Obviously, Shiller

1:50:01deleted his Instagram account right after

1:50:03the Android version came out.

1:50:06- The more you mention it, yeah,

1:50:07I think they probably should have done it.

1:50:10Again, Instagram would not be worth what it is today

1:50:13as a part of Apple, and it's very possible,

1:50:15to your point, another network will come along

1:50:17and supplant it, but would it be worth

1:50:21more than $1 billion of value to the iPhone franchise?

1:50:24Without question.

1:50:25You don't have to sell that many marginal iPhones

1:50:29to make up a billion dollars.

1:50:31Yeah, it's a really interesting point.

1:50:35- And even now, today, I mean, I forget what year

1:50:37that was when that happened, but even now today,

1:50:40it plays even more into the camera emphasis

1:50:45of Apple's iPhone product marketing.

1:50:47- Yeah, absolutely, yep, I agree, I agree is a miss.

1:50:50I mean, the real shame is that Instagram sold it all.

1:50:53I mean, I feel like things would be so much healthier if,

1:50:58I mean, Instagram is really the purchase

1:51:00that cemented Facebook's dominance,

1:51:03because it's Instagram that is,

1:51:07it's different enough from Facebook in a way

1:51:10that it really, the market need,

1:51:13market niche that it's filling is,

1:51:15it was really a big hole for Facebook.

1:51:20It'd be nice if it was an independent company.

1:51:24- It's, yeah, yeah, it's a terrific compliment to Facebook

1:51:29and it's a better Twitter than Twitter in some ways.

1:51:32or at least a Twitter, it's a Twitter that knows,

1:51:34and I love Twitter, I do love Twitter,

1:51:36and Instagram is of course completely pointless

1:51:39and useless for something like news.

1:51:41Like as we speak today, 24 hours ago we just found out

1:51:44that Trump fired the head of the FBI.

1:51:48It was, I'm sure, I don't know what you did,

1:51:51if you were up, maybe you were sleeping at the time,

1:51:53but as soon as you found out about it,

1:51:54I bet you went to Twitter, right?

1:51:56- Right.

1:51:57- I mean, politics over the side.

1:51:59When I found out that Trump fired the head of the FBI

1:52:02who's investigating his own campaigns,

1:52:04ties us to Russia, I went to Twitter to see

1:52:07what were the news articles that were coming out,

1:52:10what were people whose opinion I value on such subjects.

1:52:14Instagram has nothing to do with something like that.

1:52:16You don't go to Instagram for breaking news.

1:52:17But the problem that Twitter has--

1:52:18- But that's part of Instagram's value, right?

1:52:21- Right, and that's part why people, you know.

1:52:23But it's Twitter-like in that it's the same basic model

1:52:29that Twitter pioneered, which is you--

1:52:34it's very simple.

1:52:35It's brilliant.

1:52:36It seems so obvious, but nobody did it

1:52:37before Twitter, which is you have a feed of the things

1:52:41you post, and you pick people whose feeds you want to see.

1:52:45And then when you look at the app,

1:52:47you see all of the posts from the people

1:52:49who you've chosen to follow in one stream,

1:52:53and you scroll down.

1:52:54And then when you get bored, you hit one that you've already

1:52:57seen before you stop.

1:52:59It's like they took that basic model

1:53:01and made something that was very self-assured

1:53:03and knew exactly what it was for

1:53:05and what people would do with it.

1:53:07Like people don't look at Instagram and say,

1:53:09"I don't know what to do with this."

1:53:10Like a lot of normal people do when they see Twitter.

1:53:13They're like, "I don't know what I'm looking at."

1:53:16- Right, and photos are such a,

1:53:19and this is something that Facebook knew

1:53:20when they bought Instagram.

1:53:23I mean, Facebook was built on photos, photo sharing.

1:53:25But to take, to be, break that down

1:53:28just through a stream of individual photos.

1:53:30And not only that is it super understandable,

1:53:32super approachable and something people like,

1:53:34but it lends itself very obviously

1:53:36and easily to advertising.

1:53:37And in a way that Twitter, you know,

1:53:39it's advertising on Twitter is hard.

1:53:43Like, yes, you can have the promoted tweet thing,

1:53:45but it's so, like you're scrolling past it so quickly

1:53:48and it's hard to really sort of get immersed in it.

1:53:51And this is part of, you know,

1:53:52Twitter's trying to add more media in part

1:53:53because it makes a better canvas for advertising.

1:53:56But just the way you use Twitter

1:53:58is not really amenable to it,

1:53:59and Twitter's had zero luck

1:54:00getting any sort of direct response

1:54:02where you see something and you take an action.

1:54:04That's just not how people think and operate

1:54:07when they're on Twitter.

1:54:08Whereas Instagram, you've had, there is success.

1:54:11People like products, people have all brands on Instagram

1:54:14because they like looking at products,

1:54:16and sometimes they look at a product

1:54:17and they wanna buy the product,

1:54:18and are they making that possible?

1:54:20- No, I've seen product, just watch stuff.

1:54:24I follow a lot of watch accounts on Instagram,

1:54:27And for obvious reasons, the watch stuff is way,

1:54:31to me at least, it's way more interesting on Instagram

1:54:33than it is on Twitter because it's all visual.

1:54:35It's like, hey, take a look at this picture of a watch.

1:54:37It's, if you're interested in watches, that's interesting,

1:54:41whereas here's some text about a watch

1:54:43is not really interesting.

1:54:45But yeah, there's product shots that have

1:54:47thousands and thousands of likes.

1:54:49It's thousands.

1:54:51It's people definitely,

1:54:54for an advertiser to get likes on their ad,

1:54:57that's a huge deal.

1:54:59- I know, yep.

1:55:01- Like in the rest of the web,

1:55:03they're trying to get people from blocking off their ads,

1:55:07whereas on Instagram they're looking for them.

1:55:11- Yeah, no, it's like no one is, yeah, exactly.

1:55:14No one is, I mean some people do complain about,

1:55:17as the getting the ads in front of people,

1:55:22You can play on Instagram to a degree.

1:55:25But same thing with the sort of Facebook feed.

1:55:29What's so brilliant about these mobile advertisements

1:55:34and why they're actually, it turned out,

1:55:36remember everyone was talking about,

1:55:37oh, mobiles were so much less for advertising,

1:55:38desktops better, blah, blah, blah.

1:55:39Well, it turned out actually, no,

1:55:41mobile was way more valuable.

1:55:42You just had to figure out the format.

1:55:43And what's so brilliant about the format

1:55:45of both Instagram and Facebook

1:55:46is you simultaneously have a much more of a grip

1:55:52on a user's attention, like an ad on Facebook or Instagram

1:55:56literally takes over the entire screen of your device.

1:55:59- Right.

1:56:00- But because it's embedded in this feed

1:56:03that you're going through, it doesn't feel

1:56:04nearly as obtrusive as, I'm looking at this article,

1:56:07I'm looking at a webpage on the browser right now,

1:56:10on the Mac, and there's this big banner ad on the side,

1:56:13it's so annoying, and despite the fact,

1:56:16if you actually think about it,

1:56:17it's not actually obstructing me at all,

1:56:20But it's just weird how the, yeah,

1:56:24the feed is such a perfect advertising vehicle.

1:56:27- Right, it's-- - As you know,

1:56:28as you know, as the inventor.

1:56:30- Right.

1:56:31It just makes intuitive sense to me

1:56:36that it always had, it always did,

1:56:40from the moment the iPhone came out,

1:56:42that of course it eventually is gonna be a terrific place

1:56:45to do advertising in some way.

1:56:47Like the hard part is only figuring out the right way.

1:56:49but to discount it as less valuable,

1:56:52you have to be a moron because it's obviously the device,

1:56:56you only have to spend two minutes in 2007

1:56:59looking at iPhone, original iPhone owners' relationship

1:57:05with their phone and see that it's by far and away

1:57:08the most emotionally attached computing device

1:57:10that they own.

1:57:11It's intimate.

1:57:13And of course that's valuable.

1:57:15It's super valuable.

1:57:15And it's with them all the time.

1:57:17Of course, how could that not be more valuable?

1:57:19Again, I'm not saying it was obvious at all

1:57:22that something like Instagram,

1:57:24I mean, I'd be a very wealthy man

1:57:25if I had come up with the idea for Instagram in 2007,

1:57:28but I just knew though

1:57:30that there was some kind of opportunity there, right?

1:57:33- Right, exactly. - Crazy to discount it,

1:57:36just because you couldn't show the same type of ads

1:57:38that you could show on a desktop.

1:57:40Let me take a break.

1:57:43Let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor,

1:57:45unless you had a good point to make.

1:57:46Do you have a good point?

1:57:47- No, no, I have no good points.

1:57:49point. All right. Our third and final sponsor of the episode is our good

1:57:55friends at Squarespace. Look, next time you have to do something new. You got a

1:58:00new company you're starting, you want to start a podcast, your own podcast, you

1:58:04want to start a blog, and it's May, maybe you're a student, you're

1:58:10graduating, you want to put together a portfolio site of your work, do it in

1:58:14Squarespace. Make your next move on Squarespace. You want to make a website,

1:58:17do it on Squarespace.

1:58:19I'm telling you, do it first.

1:58:20By the time you spend half an hour trying it in Squarespace,

1:58:24you'll be halfway to having your thing done.

1:58:28Whereas if you did it by hand, you'd still be

1:58:30learning PHP or something like that.

1:58:34I'm telling you.

1:58:35You can make your own website with Squarespace

1:58:37with no coding experience, no programming experience,

1:58:40no system administrator experience.

1:58:42All of that stuff is all taken care of.

1:58:44It's an all-in-one platform.

1:58:45This is the thing I think people don't get about Squarespace,

1:58:48is that everything from registering your domain name

1:58:52to keeping the server running to collecting the stats that

1:58:55show you which pages on site people are going to

1:58:57and stuff like that, it's all there.

1:59:00It's all in the platform.

1:59:01So you don't have to do, well, you do this,

1:59:03and then you have it just hosted.

1:59:05But then if you want to get stats,

1:59:06you've got to install some other analytics package

1:59:08or something like that.

1:59:09None of it.

1:59:10All of it is right there in Squarespace platform.

1:59:12And the thing I always keep emphasizing

1:59:15is they have all these templates to choose from,

1:59:16but they have so many templates,

1:59:18and the templates are so easily configured

1:59:21with your own graphics or fonts or something like that,

1:59:24that your site doesn't look like

1:59:25a cookie cutter Squarespace site.

1:59:27I guarantee you, you visit Squarespace sites every day

1:59:30and don't even realize they're Squarespace sites

1:59:32because they look original to the brands

1:59:35of the company of site it is.

1:59:36So next time you need a new website,

1:59:38go to squarespace.com/talkshow

1:59:43and uh... use the code group my last name when you actually for cover the dough

1:59:48and you'll save ten percent off your first order my thanks to square space

1:59:52long-time sponsor the show good friends

1:59:56we gotta get to china

1:59:58that that that that that that that that that that that that that that that

1:59:59that's always in your honor show

2:00:01yeah i i i i this is my busy season uh... by business and i mean it's the

2:00:06n_b_a_ playoffs itself

2:00:08i have a chance to listen to

2:00:11the your episode last week uh...

2:00:14where i i think you discussed this but a little bit but it was it's uh... what i

2:00:18wrote about was more

2:00:20you know if you read my article then you'd

2:00:21you know i stand

2:00:25yet i hope i represented you for a do you feel like i represented you fairly

2:00:29uh... yeah i think so i mean i i i i still think uh... i think the part we

2:00:32disagree with me you're wrong which is fine because we can we can talk about it

2:00:35so it's a we should because i i i would say

2:00:39I would say that more, like, I got more,

2:00:43hey, I usually agree with you,

2:00:44but I think you're wrong on this.

2:00:46I got more of that for that stance

2:00:49than anything in recent memory,

2:00:50which doesn't make me dig in my heels.

2:00:53It makes me think, hmm,

2:00:54there's a good chance I'm wrong about this.

2:00:56- Yeah, and this is one of the great things

2:00:58about writing for the web generally,

2:01:00that like, you've made this comment before

2:01:03and I've stolen it,

2:01:04because I think it's such a great way to put it.

2:01:06The goal, I love being right,

2:01:09But the way you're right is by fixing the parts when you're

2:01:13wrong.

2:01:14And having tons of people giving you feedback

2:01:16is a great way to get right much more quickly than was ever

2:01:20possible before.

2:01:21Right.

2:01:21I like to be right all the time.

2:01:23And the way to be right all the time is to catch the times

2:01:26that you're wrong and correct them.

2:01:28Right.

2:01:29Like I said, I totally stole that from you.

2:01:31But I think it's a great way to think about it.

2:01:32Right.

2:01:32And too many people who want to be right all the time--

2:01:35And let's say they're right most of the time.

2:01:37They're defensive about the times that they're wrong.

2:01:43And when they are wrong, you see it all the time.

2:01:45You see it in politics, you see it in tech,

2:01:47you see it in anything you follow.

2:01:48But when they're wrong, you can see it,

2:01:50that they're digging in and trying to spin away

2:01:53to make it that they're right.

2:01:55Whereas the easiest thing in the world to do

2:01:57is to just publish an update and say, you know what?

2:02:00Totally wrong.

2:02:02Yeah, I write these every now and then.

2:02:04I actually, I like it in some respects when something comes along that I was wrong about.

2:02:09And sometimes I'm factually wrong, and that's fine, that's an easy correction, I just mis-screw

2:02:14something up or whatever, like saying that there was no touchscreen. Sometimes like,

2:02:19predictions are wrong or my analysis is wrong. And in some respects, I actually value that,

2:02:24because as soon as that happens, I will write a big post that I will say what I got wrong,

2:02:30I'll say why I got wrong, I'll explain my thought process that went into it,

2:02:33what part of my thought process in retrospect was incorrect.

2:02:36And then the value that accrues is not just that now I'm right,

2:02:41but also it kind of gives you capital to say other stuff in the future,

2:02:46because people will take you more seriously.

2:02:49Because even if what you're saying is wrong,

2:02:51they will know that, one, you will correct yourself in the future.

2:02:57But two, there's a process that goes into it

2:03:02that it's not just sort of like shooting from the hip sort of thing. So for me, I actually think

2:03:06it's not just a benefit of the web. I don't need an editor, although that is from a very sort of

2:03:12small perspective the case. I think from a big perspective, it's one of the wonderful things

2:03:17about writing for a large audience. Yeah, and it's sort of like a shows, you know, like being happy

2:03:24with every once in a while when you, you know, have to correct a pretty big error or just,

2:03:29you know, like, "Oh, I was convinced that it was all doors should open from the left, but

2:03:34dude, that's idiotic. Sometimes the doors should open from the right." You publish it, you know,

2:03:39you just say it like that. It's sort of proof that the system works. Like, you know, a way of,

2:03:45you know, I like to think that when I'm wrong, I will recognize it instantly and, you know,

2:03:51swallow my pride and do what I can to fix it as unambiguously as possible.

2:03:58But if I don't do it for a while, how do I know that I'm not,

2:04:01even though I think that that's what I'm willing to do,

2:04:03how do I know that I'm not just going into denial every time I'm wrong?

2:04:07Yeah, no, exactly. And this is something that I think about a ton, like this

2:04:11idea of confirmation bias, where you always look for evidence that supports your position.

2:04:16Right.

2:04:16And it takes a lot of discipline to actively look for reasons why you might be wrong,

2:04:23which I absolutely try to do. But then also just having, like I said, the fact you get

2:04:30instant feedback and people pushing back on you forces you to think about that.

2:04:34Yeah, so anyhow, it's just a sort of meta commentary.

2:04:39Yeah.

2:04:41Oh, sorry, go ahead.

2:04:42Well, I think a good example of that, I think probably the product review that I probably did

2:04:49the worst job on was the original Apple Watch. And that's why a month later I wrote a second one,

2:04:53it was more or less the same basic idea of, "Here's this new product from Apple.

2:04:58What is it? And what do I think about it?" The first one was just, I don't know, it wasn't awful,

2:05:05but it wasn't poorly written, but it just never sat right with me and rereading it a month later,

2:05:09I was like just I I don't know I felt like a swing and a miss and I feel like part of the problem

2:05:15Was that it was it was?

2:05:17Too much of a what's good about this product review whereas it should have you know, it wasn't it was written from that perspective

2:05:25Like I don't know if that's quite confirmation bias, but it's it Apple wouldn't do this if they didn't have a good reason to do it

2:05:32So what are those good reasons? Whereas I think the story was more

2:05:36or this is a, especially that 1.0 watch,

2:05:38this is a product that doesn't really know

2:05:40what it's good for yet.

2:05:42- Yeah, no, I mean, it's funny.

2:05:44I was all over the place on the watch.

2:05:47My original take was that, which is like,

2:05:49this is a product that is lacking vision.

2:05:51Like, it doesn't know what it is.

2:05:53- Right. - And I think

2:05:53that's even more accurate.

2:05:55- Right, exactly.

2:05:55Well, then I went back and I actually fell into the,

2:05:58like, I had too much faith in Apple.

2:06:00Like, are they really just launching this beautiful device?

2:06:03And that's really the point.

2:06:05And so I actually went back and changed my mind

2:06:08and had this very notorious contentious episode of X1

2:06:10where me and James were arguing about it.

2:06:12And then eventually I didn't come back.

2:06:15In this case, my fix was actually wrong and worse.

2:06:19So I had to go back and like,

2:06:21no, actually I had it right the first time.

2:06:23And so I hate that, I hate that that happened,

2:06:27especially because I actually had it right the first time.

2:06:30But yeah, I mean, whatever, it happens.

2:06:32If you're giving your analysis or opinion four days a week, you're going to get it

2:06:38wrong, which is fine, as long as you correct it.

2:06:41So you run into this.

2:06:42We've spoken about this, that you don't write—strategery is not—it's the tech

2:06:49in general.

2:06:50I mean, and if you tend to write—

2:06:52Stratechery, yes.

2:06:53Stratechery.

2:06:54Stratechery.

2:06:55Stratechery.

2:06:56Stratechery.

2:06:57Tech, tech, tech.

2:06:58It's about tech.

2:06:59Terrible name.

2:07:00I honestly don't even do it to razz you.

2:07:01I honestly have done it.

2:07:02I made the mispronounce the mispronounce.

2:07:05No, I pronounced it differently at the beginning.

2:07:06So I made it even worse.

2:07:08It was already a bad name and I made it worse.

2:07:09So it's all 100% my fault.

2:07:12But alas, it is what it is.

2:07:14I just tell people, when people ask about my site,

2:07:19I just tell them to search for Ben Thompson on Google.

2:07:21'Cause that's too hard.

2:07:23That's the old Jason Fried thing.

2:07:24Like we were talking about domain names.

2:07:25Like for years and years, Basecamp,

2:07:27they didn't have basecamp.com.

2:07:28They have it now, but they just had basecamphq.com

2:07:32because he didn't, you know, somebody had basecamp.com

2:07:35and he didn't feel like paying their exorbitant price.

2:07:37He did eventually, but he was like, screw it,

2:07:39people just Google for basecamp anyway.

2:07:41(laughing)

2:07:42Right, which is true.

2:07:43Anyway, you've written about this.

2:07:48So you don't, it's certainly not,

2:07:51your writing is not Apple-focused,

2:07:53not even in the way that mine is,

2:07:55but you certainly do write enough about Apple

2:07:56simply because if you write about tech in general,

2:07:58Apple is kind of a big company

2:08:01and they kind of do, a lot of tend to do interesting things.

2:08:04But you've spoken about this,

2:08:05that when you write articles or have like a column

2:08:08that's sort of critical of Apple,

2:08:10you get like unsubscriptions sometimes.

2:08:13It's like people don't want to hear it.

2:08:16- No, that's always been the case.

2:08:17I mean, it was, so when I started, I wrote a lot more,

2:08:20probably even more about Apple,

2:08:21in part because that was the company I knew the best.

2:08:24Like I had been following them closely.

2:08:25I'd written like, I'd written a huge paper

2:08:26about them in school.

2:08:28Like, I spent a lot of time trying to understand

2:08:32and think about what made them successful,

2:08:33and obviously I interned there at Apple University.

2:08:36And came to learn and understand so much

2:08:40about sort of the inner workings,

2:08:42it was a fantastic experience.

2:08:43And especially when I started also,

2:08:45it was when the whole Samsung is disrupting Apple narrative

2:08:50was in place.

2:08:52And so I got tons of articles saying this is dumb,

2:08:55like trying to explain Apple and their differentiation.

2:08:58And back then it was controversial to say that iOS was not going to be swamped by Android

2:09:04and developers weren't going to flee en masse and all this sort of stuff.

2:09:07That was still a thing back then.

2:09:08So I and-

2:09:09And iPhone dead in the water, Henry Blodgett.

2:09:12Right, right.

2:09:14And the biggest, as I've recounted, the biggest event in the early Chitekri days for

2:09:20getting readership was you linking to me and saying, "This is a fantastic new blog and

2:09:24you link to a bunch of articles."

2:09:27as per kind of like this column this week,

2:09:29like, oh, this is a great blog, really good, blah, blah, blah.

2:09:32But for the first time, I disagree with Mr. Thompson,

2:09:34and then he explained where I was wrong.

2:09:36But that was the--

2:09:40- That was an outright disagreement, though.

2:09:41Not this time.

2:09:41This time, like I said,

2:09:42it's a subtle difference of weight, I would say.

2:09:47- Yeah, and I actually think you were right in that case.

2:09:49And so--

2:09:50- Oh, I was definitely right back then.

2:09:51(laughing)

2:09:52I was just waiting.

2:09:54I was just really,

2:09:55I was just waiting for you to make a mistake,

2:09:57and then I knew I could link to you

2:09:58because then instead of just saying how great it was,

2:10:00I could also point out that you made an error

2:10:02in your thinking.

2:10:03I was just waiting for it.

2:10:05- Well, the longest story of it though is sort of my initial

2:10:08and then after that I got linked to by Marco a couple times

2:10:10and so I really started in the sort of Apple blogosphere

2:10:14is where awareness of me started to grow.

2:10:17So a lot of my initial followers were in that arena.

2:10:22So you fast forward like a year or something

2:10:25and I wrote something about Apple and services,

2:10:30and basically, I think it was a good point,

2:10:32it's a point that I brought up again and again,

2:10:34is how companies are sort of shaped by their origin,

2:10:37and that influences the culture,

2:10:42and the way they approach products

2:10:43for the entire life of a company.

2:10:44And I talked about Google, talked about Microsoft,

2:10:46talked about Apple, talked about a bunch of examples,

2:10:48and in this case, I was trying to explain

2:10:51that Apple struggle with services,

2:10:53not because they're dumb,

2:10:55but because they're so great at products.

2:10:57And this is a point, obviously I've returned to this point

2:10:59in the past, to say that Apple strobes the services

2:11:02is not to criticize Apple or say they're dumb people,

2:11:05it's in a recognition that the same things

2:11:08that make Apple the best product company,

2:11:11an amazing product company,

2:11:12work against being a great services company.

2:11:15- Right. - Anyhow.

2:11:17- People didn't wanna hear it.

2:11:18- People did not wanna hear it.

2:11:20So I had just started the daily update then.

2:11:22And so my subscriber numbers were in the,

2:11:25I think at that point I was only a couple months in,

2:11:27so maybe the low hundreds.

2:11:28And I got like 20 or 30 unsubscriptions immediately.

2:11:33And people were mad.

2:11:34And it was shocking.

2:11:36I did not expect that to come at all.

2:11:38It was good.

2:11:39It was a good lesson to learn.

2:11:41People were caring more about Apple than they did about me.

2:11:45And that's fine.

2:11:46I have no problem with that.

2:11:47And over time, certainly I've come to build up a user base.

2:11:52And one of the great things about my model is it's $10 a month, so if you want to quit,

2:11:55it doesn't really affect me, my life in the slightest, which is great.

2:11:58I actually love that about this model.

2:12:01But yeah, it's funny.

2:12:02Whenever I write something that is not purely optimistic about Apple, there is definitely

2:12:08an uptick in people turning off auto renew on their subscriptions.

2:12:12I've seen it on sports, too.

2:12:15I follow some Yankees beat writers on Twitter, and every once in a while, they'll get in

2:12:20argument with people and there's a certain flavor of Yankee fan who just doesn't want

2:12:26to hear it that the Yankees aren't the best team in baseball. Now this year they actually

2:12:29are the best team in baseball, but like last year, last couple of years, the Yankees have

2:12:33been kind of, they haven't been bad, they haven't had a losing season, but clearly we're

2:12:38not going anywhere, we're not going to win a championship. And any kind of sports coverage

2:12:44along the lines of, you know, it's not really a great strategy to be paying $27 million

2:12:49to a 41-year-old Alex Rodriguez with a bad hip.

2:12:53And the Yankees fans are like,

2:12:54"Wow, why do you want to write about the Yankees

2:12:57"if you hate them so much?"

2:12:59- Right. - Like, unfollow.

2:13:01And it's like, actually,

2:13:02he's just sort of an expert on baseball,

2:13:03and he's pointing out something

2:13:04that's actually pretty obvious,

2:13:05which is that having old people on your team

2:13:09is not a good way to win at sports.

2:13:11- Yeah, and it's a great thing for Apple.

2:13:14It's one of Apple's really core strengths

2:13:16is the devotion that Apple has fans, right?

2:13:21Like that's not from a business perspective.

2:13:24I put my business analyst hat on and that's amazing.

2:13:28And it's something that Apple uses as a tool,

2:13:32as a strategic tool again and again.

2:13:33Like that's how the iPhone,

2:13:37they would go into a country and they would dictate terms

2:13:42and the leading carriers would say no.

2:13:44And then they'd go to the second place carrier

2:13:46and often they say no, they go to third place carrier

2:13:48who's desperate to catch up and say,

2:13:51okay, we accept your terms.

2:13:52And then the iPhone is on the carrier,

2:13:54like Japan is probably the classic example of this.

2:13:56SoftBank was well in third place.

2:13:59And the iPhone is on SoftBank

2:14:02and people started switching their carriers,

2:14:05which they never did before, to get the iPhone.

2:14:08And by and large, particularly at the beginning,

2:14:10they were Apple fans who already loved Apple,

2:14:13loved Apple products, desperately wanted an iPhone,

2:14:15and they switched, this happened in the US with AT&T,

2:14:17same thing, and over time, then Apple could eventually,

2:14:21now the iPhone is on all the carriers,

2:14:23and it's on Apple's terms with all of them,

2:14:26and that's all because of the devotion

2:14:28that people have to Apple.

2:14:29It's an amazing tool.

2:14:32- What a weird duck the Verizon iPhone 4 was, right?

2:14:37It's like the only sort of half iPhone that was ever made.

2:14:41It's not just like, and we'll get to this

2:14:43in a minute or two, but not like,

2:14:45okay, we've made the iPhone 7 in red.

2:14:47I mean, that's just the color.

2:14:49- It was available in white, though.

2:14:52'Cause remember, the white phone was super delayed?

2:14:54- Yeah, but when the Verizon one shipped,

2:14:56the white one still wasn't even out.

2:14:57So I think the Verizon one shipped in early February,

2:15:01but it was weird.

2:15:02- Oh, did I?

2:15:03I thought it was the same time, yeah.

2:15:04But regardless, yeah, it was still weird, yeah.

2:15:05- Yeah, it was like eight months later,

2:15:06and it had a different antenna.

2:15:08It had the modern iPhone 4S antenna design,

2:15:12the slightly problematic and tennegate one from the GSM version. Anyway, what a weird thing.

2:15:19So basically the overall premise is that in China, the user interface, WeChat is so dominant

2:15:36that it reduces sort of the software lock-in that an iPhone has, which makes it more viable

2:15:43to switch. At a very sort of high level, that's it. And I would just kind of tap down one

2:15:50level, which means, when I talk about the lock-in, it's not just a lock-in in that

2:15:55there's no iMessage or that apps are available on both platforms, which is the case. I mean,

2:15:59there's no app that's while using China that's not available on Android. Like, it's

2:16:02really an iOS first sort of environment the way it is in the US where even still

2:16:07there will be hot new apps that are that are iOS only to start. So that's not so

2:16:12that's part of it but also it's not just the apps it's the interaction it's

2:16:16the user interface when you're in one app all the time you're using that app

2:16:22and that's the dominant way that you experience your phone whereas in the US

2:16:25Yes, we may use Facebook and Uber and PayPal or Square Cash or whatever it might be that

2:16:34are all analogs for WeChat functions, but every time you switch an app, every time you

2:16:39use the app switcher, every time you go back to the home screen, that's all interactive

2:16:42with the operating system.

2:16:43You're interacting with the operating system constantly outside of China.

2:16:48And in China, you're not really interacting with the operating system at all, so there's

2:16:53even the little niggling things about moving stuff around is reduced.

2:17:00And so the lock-in is not just about an actual, like, on-paper lock-in.

2:17:05It's like in the user experience lock-in is less as well.

2:17:08Right. It almost sounds to me like it's used for so much that it's actually a problem that iOS doesn't let you define, you know, like...

2:17:18like, they don't show the icon anymore, but you know how like from the lock screen you

2:17:22can jump right to the camera by swiping to the side?

2:17:25And when they first introduced that feature, they had a little camera icon in the corner,

2:17:29right?

2:17:30And you could like, I think it used to drag up instead of drag over.

2:17:33Like they've changed the interaction.

2:17:34But the idea is, here's an app that's so important.

2:17:39And obviously camera's a little different than WeChat because camera, it might be a

2:17:42fleeting moment you're trying to capture.

2:17:44So being able to get there, it's not just that you use it a lot, but that getting there

2:17:47quickly from a locked phone can be the difference between getting the shot and not getting the shot.

2:17:52But iOS doesn't let you do things like say, let me put WeChat on my lock screen so I can jump right

2:18:01to WeChat from a locked phone right away. Like none of that's configurable. And it sounds to me

2:18:06like WeChat is so central to the experience in China that the iPhone would be a better OS

2:18:12if you could.

2:18:13Yeah, well it's not, in many respects, all the sort of lock-in things on an iPhone that

2:18:20are occasionally mild irritants, you know, here, but by and large, the iPhone, like the

2:18:25Apple's built-in stuff is usually good enough that it's fine.

2:18:29Like you know, you can't switch the default browser, you can't switch the default email

2:18:31client or all sorts of that little stuff that can be kind of irritating if you care, but

2:18:37at the end of the day, it's not that big a deal.

2:18:38In China, it's much more of an irritant.

2:18:41I mean, because remember Android there is completely, it's not Google Android.

2:18:47They're all like Chinese variants.

2:18:50And a lot of them offer much more sort of flexibility and little, they just use phones

2:18:58kind of differently than we do here.

2:19:00And so in some respects, an iPhone is not just that because you're most using WeChat,

2:19:05the experience is mostly the same.

2:19:07In some respects, it's arguably actually worse

2:19:10in a way that it isn't in other parts of the world.

2:19:13- Yeah, and that is terrible for Apple.

2:19:16And so let's just say this before we get into speculation

2:19:19or our analysts, but it's just a fact,

2:19:22it's the statement of fact that iPhone sales in China

2:19:25are down year over year.

2:19:26I think in the just completed quarter, they were down 14%.

2:19:31- Yeah, in the second year in a row,

2:19:32they were down even more last year.

2:19:35years in a row and until then there was the it was it it was an increase it's a sharp difference

2:19:42it's almost like a v-shaped curve i i think it's fair to say where it was it was rising very quickly

2:19:48year over year and then all of a sudden now it's dropping year over year it wasn't like it had

2:19:52leveled off for a while there's no plateau really i don't think um and so why i mean it's a fact that

2:19:58iphone sales are down it is also we can't say it's a fact but there's at least two market research

2:20:04studies. You found one that was written in Chinese, and then there's another one that

2:20:10Business Insider linked up last year. I forget who, some US analyst firm. But both of them

2:20:15found roughly the same thing, which is that in 2016 in China, iPhone users, people who

2:20:22already owned an iPhone, and if they bought a new smartphone, only about 50 to 55% of

2:20:28them bought another iPhone. And in the rest of the world, that number ranges from around

2:20:34like the mid-70s in Japan to the mid-80s in the US and UK and the high 80s in Germany.

2:20:39And so we can't say it's a fact that 50% of Chinese iPhone users bought an Android phone

2:20:47last year, but we can say it's a fact that two market research studies that seem pretty

2:20:52well rigorously performed to me say so.

2:20:54Brian Miller Right, and it's shown in Apple's numbers,

2:20:57too. I mean, there's several data points to triangulate on here. Right, and that's a,

2:21:03That's a stunning difference.

2:21:05One, it's not small, but two, one of the real points

2:21:10that I talk about going back to those Apple arguments

2:21:14back when I first started with Techery,

2:21:15one of the core things that was critical

2:21:17to understand with the iPhone is that iPhone users

2:21:19bought new iPhones, and Android users often changed.

2:21:23And if you just play that out in the long run,

2:21:26in a saturated market, that's actually the Apple's favor,

2:21:29because they're going to keep their users,

2:21:31and they're just going to slowly keep adding other ones.

2:21:33and that's what is actually happening.

2:21:35What's so interesting about this core, the iPhone 7,

2:21:38both this quarter and last quarter,

2:21:40is that if you exclude China, it's a smashing success.

2:21:44- Yeah. - Like, it is still growing,

2:21:45and it's growing nicely, and it's growing in,

2:21:48quote, unquote, saturated markets,

2:21:50and this is exactly, and this is something

2:21:52that I've been writing since way back when,

2:21:54that actually a saturated market

2:21:56is going to be good for Apple,

2:21:57because of this, if you just play out the math, and--

2:22:01- Tim Cook has made that point,

2:22:03but it's more compelling from you

2:22:05because he's too droll about it.

2:22:06(laughing)

2:22:08You and I were chatting about this

2:22:09and you completely convinced me.

2:22:11You made me rethink my take on Apple's

2:22:14just complete a quarter.

2:22:15That it's actually pretty good

2:22:18except that it's really stinky in China.

2:22:20- Right, and it's good in an understandable,

2:22:25predictable way, right?

2:22:27It's not like these growing numbers,

2:22:29like wow, look at Apple growing.

2:22:31If you actually think through

2:22:32And you've talked about it before,

2:22:34why advertising would be compelling on mobile

2:22:36because mobile's so important to your life.

2:22:38Well, if mobile's so important to your life,

2:22:40that means of all the objects,

2:22:41even if you have to save money or cut costs,

2:22:44what's the one object you're actually going to splurge on?

2:22:47- Right. - Probably the object

2:22:49that's the single most important object in your life, right?

2:22:51And that's the iPhone, that's Apple,

2:22:53and the iMessage thing, and having blue bubbles,

2:22:55and the status that confers to it,

2:22:56and the fact people use it all the time,

2:22:58and like all that stuff,

2:23:00Like, there's just really no reason to,

2:23:03why would you want to switch?

2:23:05And whereas there are reasons to go in the other direction.

2:23:08And this has always been the problem of being an OEM,

2:23:10whether it be a Windows OEM that we talked about before,

2:23:12like HP and ThinkPad, or you know, what's the difference?

2:23:15Same thing with Android.

2:23:16Like at the end of the day, what's really the difference?

2:23:18Yes, Samsung is doing some innovative stuff with hardware,

2:23:21but that's not a sustainable,

2:23:23that's not a sustainable advantage.

2:23:24And whereas Apple has always had the software part,

2:23:28and that's so critical.

2:23:30I think that's worth underlining again,

2:23:35just how interesting that observation is.

2:23:36And I'm convinced that it's true.

2:23:38But if you go back six, seven,

2:23:41the last five, six, seven years,

2:23:43I think that the,

2:23:44and going to the era you were talking about

2:23:48where the narrative was that Samsung

2:23:51is coming to eat Apple's lunch

2:23:53because of some combination of

2:23:56you can't stay differentiated forever

2:23:59And the majority, oh, we saw what happened the last time

2:24:02with Windows and Mac, the majority OS eventually

2:24:05eats the other one.

2:24:07And I think part of that narrative at the time, too,

2:24:10though, was that the Go-Go years were all about

2:24:13expanding the new countries, and then within those countries

2:24:18expanding the new carriers, like being exclusive on AT&T

2:24:22for four years, and now all of a sudden you've got Verizon,

2:24:25and then a year later you had Sprint and T-Mobile.

2:24:27And obviously that was the go-go,

2:24:30the true go-go years of the iPhone were based on that.

2:24:33But the narrative was, well that's over now

2:24:35and the markets are getting saturated

2:24:38and that dooms the iPhone.

2:24:40I think that you have a really compelling case

2:24:41that saturated markets are actually good for the iPhone.

2:24:45- Right, the only real danger that the iPhone faces

2:24:48in most of the world is people

2:24:49holding onto their iPhones longer.

2:24:51Like no one, again, outside of China,

2:24:54is really switching away.

2:24:56the phones are so good now that you can use a phone

2:24:59for two, three years, whereas maybe before,

2:25:03like the difference in year to year,

2:25:04the difference every two years was so huge.

2:25:06I mean, I remember going from like,

2:25:08I actually, you know, 'cause I was young,

2:25:10I was, back when I was poor and a student,

2:25:13I only got a phone every two years,

2:25:15so I got the 3G and then I got the,

2:25:19no, I got the 3GS, 'cause that's when I came back over

2:25:21from the States, and then iPod touch before then.

2:25:25And then I skipped the 4 and I got the 4S.

2:25:28I mean, going from the 3GS to the 4S

2:25:31was such an unbelievable leap

2:25:33in every single aspect of the phone.

2:25:35The form factor was so superior.

2:25:38You had the retina screen.

2:25:39It was a million times faster.

2:25:40Like just, it was amazing.

2:25:42Whereas going from a 6 to a 7, it's definitely faster.

2:25:47You feel that?

2:25:49And going back and the button feels weird

2:25:51and stuff like that.

2:25:52But at the end of the day, could I,

2:25:54Just the Delta, from the way it's experienced,

2:25:58is much smaller than it is.

2:25:59And this is the case for technology.

2:26:00It's always the case that you get decreasing returns.

2:26:03But I'm not gonna switch away.

2:26:06- Yeah, I think that the 4S was right around the time, too,

2:26:09where the iPhone was arguably a reasonable

2:26:14point-and-shoot camera in and of itself,

2:26:17whereas the 3GS, it was still a cellphone camera.

2:26:20- Yep, yep.

2:26:21- It's been so long now, and people take so many pictures

2:26:24on their phones, that it's hard to imagine

2:26:26that in the early years of the iPhone,

2:26:27cell phone cameras took like a second,

2:26:30a totally, it was almost like a different medium

2:26:33than a camera photo.

2:26:35It was a photo. - Well, that's part

2:26:36of how Instagram got off the ground

2:26:38because your 3GS, I think it came out with a 3GS

2:26:41or right around that, and your photos were so bad

2:26:43that the filters weren't just a cool effect.

2:26:45They actually made them like passable.

2:26:47- Right, they disguised the lack of optical quality

2:26:50in the originals.

2:26:52- Right, right.

2:26:53(laughs)

2:26:55It was true, it was also true too,

2:26:59like in the early years of Instagram,

2:27:00like when people were shooting on 3GS or iPhone 4

2:27:03or something where people would say like #nofilter

2:27:06because it was hard to believe

2:27:07if you got a good photo off it.

2:27:10Like seriously, I did not use a photo

2:27:12and people would be like, "Oh, you know, I filtered."

2:27:13And they'd be like, "Yes, you did.

2:27:14"This looks too good now, I swear to God.

2:27:17"The light was nice."

2:27:19So anyway, bottom line, something is different

2:27:21the iPhone in China and it is not good for Apple and especially if I'm I accept it I

2:27:28accept that the what's the what's it called the rate that people rebuy the same product

2:27:34I found buying a new iPhone what's it called retention yeah the retention rate retention

2:27:41rate is significantly lower and again it's not catastrophic it's you know 50 to 55 percent

2:27:47- It's still the best of any OEM in general.

2:27:50By a pretty significant margin.

2:27:52- Most OEMs would kill for that rate,

2:27:54but that's not good for Apple.

2:27:56So something is different.

2:27:58And you and I are in complete agreement

2:28:00that WeChat is obviously the biggest part of that.

2:28:03I think that you can't prove it,

2:28:07but it just seems, I can't imagine what else it would be.

2:28:12- Yeah, and what I think it's hard to really understand

2:28:15is, you know, 'cause the analogy would be like Facebook.

2:28:17Well, Facebook, you know, people spend tons of time

2:28:20on that, blah, blah, blah.

2:28:21But the extent to which, you know,

2:28:23Facebook and apps like that are dominant

2:28:25in kind of leisure time and downtime.

2:28:28And what, WeChat is dominant in all times.

2:28:32And it's not just, and the big thing,

2:28:34it's not just on device times.

2:28:36So yes, they're dominant in your social interaction.

2:28:39They're dominant in news.

2:28:40They're dominant in, you know, watching all sorts of things.

2:28:43The NBA is on Tencent.

2:28:44So they're dominant as far as on-device things,

2:28:49but the degree to which you use your phone

2:28:51for the real world is far more extensive in China

2:28:54than it is in the US.

2:28:55I mean, China is way ahead in this sort of,

2:28:57they call it O2O, online to offline.

2:28:59This whole arena is much bigger,

2:29:01much more well-developed in China.

2:29:02So you're using your phone constantly throughout the day

2:29:06to interact with us, and it's all via WeChat.

2:29:07So you're really living this app.

2:29:09I mean, government interactions are through this.

2:29:12Like not just getting cars, paying for food, paying for goods.

2:29:16You see there's QR codes everywhere.

2:29:18The whole thing runs on QR codes.

2:29:20And what's the problem with QR codes?

2:29:22You don't know what app should you use to snap the QR code.

2:29:24Well, there's no question about which app to use there.

2:29:27And so the pervasiveness of WeChat in just your interaction is there's no app.

2:29:34There really is nothing outside of China that is comparable.

2:29:39And that's why, that's good for Apple,

2:29:41because Facebook really isn't the same.

2:29:44- Right, like you said, it's like you go out to lunch

2:29:48with your colleagues and go to a counter service place

2:29:51and get something.

2:29:52And if you're paying with cash, instead of taking

2:29:55out your phone to pay with WeChat, you look like

2:29:57you're trying to be a hipster or something.

2:30:00- Right, yeah, I don't want to overstate it,

2:30:02'cause it's still, that's more the case in specific areas

2:30:05like Beijing and Shanghai, and some of the,

2:30:08Whereas, there's lots of parts of China where you still use cash a lot, in the big

2:30:11cities as well.

2:30:13But the trend is super strong.

2:30:16It's in surprising places.

2:30:17You can go to markets and the little old lady will have a phone.

2:30:20There's no square sort of thing.

2:30:22It's all via Tencent.

2:30:24And this gets into a point I made earlier.

2:30:27The user experience is not just about the user interface.

2:30:29The user interface of Apple Pay is superior.

2:30:32To make an Apple Pay purchase is so elegant.

2:30:34You just hold it up and put your thumb on it.

2:30:36It's amazing.

2:30:37But if when you consider the totality of it, where you have to figure out, "Oh, do you

2:30:42accept Apple Pay?" and you have to be awkward and ask and look around and they have to bring

2:30:45it up.

2:30:46The user, whereas, yeah, maybe more clumsy, you have to open an app and get a QR code

2:30:52to show.

2:30:54But if that's the expectation and everyone does it and everyone is equipped for it, then

2:30:59yeah, that specific aspect of the UI is inferior, but the totality of the user experience is

2:31:05is far, far superior than another solution.

2:31:10- I was at the liquor store today,

2:31:11and I pay with Apple Pay there usually

2:31:15because they have a chip reader,

2:31:16and it's so much, it's worse than it used to be

2:31:19with a credit card.

2:31:20So they made credit cards worse and slower,

2:31:21and Apple Pay is fast.

2:31:23And it's my neighborhood liquor store,

2:31:25and I know that Apple Pay works there,

2:31:27and the guy was like a crotchety old guy.

2:31:29I won't go into the long rant

2:31:31about Pennsylvania liquor stores

2:31:32being government-owned and operated,

2:31:35but he was a total government employee.

2:31:38And he said, "How are you gonna pay cash or credit?"

2:31:40And I said, "I'll pay Apple Pay."

2:31:42And he goes, "Oh, you can't do that."

2:31:43And I thought he meant like the terminal was broken?

2:31:46And I looked at it and didn't say anything.

2:31:47He goes, "We don't accept that."

2:31:48And I said, "Yes, you do, actually you do."

2:31:50I was like, "I pay with it here in this store all the time."

2:31:52And he goes, "No, you don't."

2:31:53(laughing)

2:31:54And he goes, "The state won't."

2:31:57And I was like, "I'm telling you,

2:31:58"I was just in here yesterday and bought something."

2:32:01And...

2:32:04(laughing)

2:32:06And I just thought, you know what,

2:32:08I am not gonna, why am I arguing this?

2:32:10I was like, I'll pay credit.

2:32:11- That's funny.

2:32:14You should just want to pay credit

2:32:15and then hold up your phone and then stealthily pay anyway,

2:32:17'cause that will actually happen.

2:32:19But, oh, the other thing, the other point to make

2:32:23about this, oh, sorry, the analogy,

2:32:25we talked a little bit about Microsoft and--

2:32:27- I also enjoyed that I just told a story

2:32:29that makes it sound as though I run out of liquor in a day.

2:32:32- I know, I noted that, but I was just gonna

2:32:34but I totally noticed what you said,

2:32:36I was there yesterday.

2:32:37- It actually is true that I was there the day before,

2:32:39but it wasn't so much that I had drank myself

2:32:42out of liquor in a day,

2:32:43but that I'm a very poor planner

2:32:45in terms of knowing what else I might be running low on.

2:32:48But anyway.

2:32:49- Yeah.

2:32:50(laughing)

2:32:52Oh, the point to make about this,

2:32:54about how WeChat does so many things,

2:32:56whereas Facebook only does some things,

2:32:58is what happened back in the day

2:33:01when Microsoft was dominant.

2:33:03like we used lots of apps and those apps were actually what we use the computer for,

2:33:08but the reason why Microsoft got all the value and was the most valuable of them all is they

2:33:13were sort of the commonality, right? They all ran on Windows. And so it was sort of by having lots

2:33:19of disparate apps that Windows itself got all the value. And the same thing with the iPhone.

2:33:24We actually use apps. We don't use the iPhone. We spend most of our time inside Facebook, inside

2:33:30whatever it might be, but they're all running on the iPhone and we use enough different ones

2:33:35that where's the winch pin, where's the sort of, you know, the squeeze is at the OS level.

2:33:41Right.

2:33:42What made, what ended Microsoft's dominance was, and why Google became dominant,

2:33:49because the web, there was so many websites and what became the common, what became the

2:33:55winch point. It was Google. It was the search box, right? And when everything, when you

2:34:02have sort of a one-to-one relationship where all between Google and the computer it ran

2:34:08on, the value in sort of the value chain kind of went up the stack, where to the new platform

2:34:14where all the sites sort of sat on top of it, right? So it went up. The analogy of the

2:34:19phone is, as long as you're using multiple apps, multiple apps are important to your

2:34:23then the actual value, the point of leverage is the OS.

2:34:28But once everything consolidates into one app,

2:34:31then that point of leverage skips up a level.

2:34:34And that is the case in China,

2:34:36and it's not the case in other places, if that makes sense.

2:34:39You have to have an app that does everything.

2:34:41If it only did some things,

2:34:42it's not gonna steal leverage in a similar way.

2:34:47- In the Apple's decades old, almost foundational,

2:34:52Literally, I mean, software wasn't quite as important

2:34:57in the Apple two days or Apple one days even,

2:35:02as it is today, but it was the marriage of hardware

2:35:06and software that made Apple products different

2:35:10right from the get-go.

2:35:11I mean, and again, like I mentioned in my thing,

2:35:13writing about your thing, that Steve Wozniak

2:35:16has venerated and mostly thought of as an engineer,

2:35:20hardware engineer, 'cause that's what he was,

2:35:21electrical engineer, but he was a software genius too.

2:35:24I mean, he never written a compiler in his life

2:35:27and he made the Apple basic.

2:35:29He put the Apple base,

2:35:31he completely created Apple basic from scratch.

2:35:34- It's incredible.

2:35:34- Put it in a ROM.

2:35:35Like he didn't, he like borrowed somebody's,

2:35:40like his neighbor's neighbor at HP in a cubicle,

2:35:43borrowed like a compiler book

2:35:46and taught himself to write a compiler in a ROM.

2:35:50I mean, he was a software genius.

2:35:52It was a great basic.

2:35:53It was a great version of basic.

2:35:54And it was right there as soon as you turned the machine on.

2:35:59In that formula of hardware differentiated

2:36:02by proprietary software, the software side

2:36:05is way more important to Apple in the long term

2:36:08than the hardware side.

2:36:10Right, the hardware is how they monetize it.

2:36:12It's a money vehicle.

2:36:14Right.

2:36:14And people focus on it because that's the actual thing you buy.

2:36:18and certainly finance people,

2:36:20tech people concentrate on it

2:36:22because it's easier to do a review of new hardware

2:36:25than it is slowly,

2:36:27than it is to review slowly

2:36:29evolving software. - Evolving software.

2:36:33- Evolving software over time.

2:36:35But the software's way more important than the hardware.

2:36:39I mean, you can have something like the Mac Pro

2:36:41that doesn't get updated for four years

2:36:43and it's not gonna kill the Mac,

2:36:44but if the software was as stagnant

2:36:48as the Mac Pro hardware, it would be a disaster.

2:36:51- Well, and that almost did kill Apple, right?

2:36:53- Right.

2:36:54- Back in the '90s.

2:36:55And yeah, this was going back to why all those people

2:36:58were so wrong about the iPhone.

2:37:00This is exactly why.

2:37:02They didn't properly value software,

2:37:04and they didn't properly value software

2:37:06because that's not, Apple didn't charge for it.

2:37:08But that was to, that's what people always fail

2:37:11to not understand about Apple,

2:37:13is that the entire reason why they can charge

2:37:16for much for the hardware is because the software

2:37:18is different, I mean, you'd always read reviews, right?

2:37:20There'd be like a review way back in the day,

2:37:22like PC Magazine, like the new Mac Pro.

2:37:24It would compare it to, or Mac,

2:37:25or whatever they were called back then.

2:37:26And they would compare it to the PC, blah, blah, blah.

2:37:28- Power Mac. - And it was such,

2:37:30yeah, it was, and it was dumb, it was a farce.

2:37:33Because the reality is, if you're in the market for a Mac,

2:37:38there is no competition, like that,

2:37:40and how do you make a lot of money?

2:37:42They call it only by having a monopoly.

2:37:43Apple has a monopoly.

2:37:45They have a monopoly on their software.

2:37:46The only way to get their software

2:37:48is by buying their hardware,

2:37:50which lets them charge way more for their hardware

2:37:53than anyone else can charge for theirs.

2:37:54I mean, that's why they're the most

2:37:56viable company in the world.

2:37:58- Yep.

2:37:59And again, like a perfect point,

2:38:01the only time Apple was ever actually in real trouble

2:38:04in circa 1996 or so

2:38:08was when their software stack had been exposed

2:38:13as being antiquated and had serious technical problems.

2:38:17And there were really, you could make

2:38:20a really compelling case that,

2:38:22in some cases for some people, not for everybody,

2:38:24but for some people it was decidedly

2:38:28a worse platform than the competition.

2:38:30That's-- - Oh, I mean,

2:38:32Apple had been slower than PCs

2:38:34for multiple years at that point.

2:38:36But when you were getting a situation where,

2:38:39like just the, I mean, no protective memory,

2:38:41and it was, like honestly,

2:38:44if you actually cared about the work you were doing

2:38:47at any given time on your computer,

2:38:49you were kind of nuts to not use a,

2:38:51to not use, once Windows got protective memory,

2:38:54like to not use Windows.

2:38:55Yeah, it might have sucked, but like,

2:38:56what, no, your computer's crashing all the time.

2:38:59- Mine was not crashing all the time.

2:39:01But the reason mine wasn't crashing all the time

2:39:03was that I was sufficiently--

2:39:05- You were careful about it.

2:39:06Right, sufficiently expert at using a Macintosh that I knew not to install.

2:39:09I knew what type of stuff not to install.

2:39:11I knew exactly.

2:39:12And if I did crash and I had MaxBug installed,

2:39:16I wasn't like an expert at MaxBug, but I could at least see what it was that crashed.

2:39:22I could figure out what it was that was causing the problem.

2:39:24Right.

2:39:25That's a problem.

2:39:26The fact that you had to be an expert Mac user to have that ability, though,

2:39:31is a problem because it's fine.

2:39:35Where the Mac is today is a terrific position in that regard, where if you want to be an expert and are an expert, you can do amazing things that other people can't, but that the casual user...

2:39:46It's not a necessity though.

2:39:47Right.

2:39:48Right.

2:39:49It's absolutely not a necessity just to use the web and check your email and find out what's going on on Facebook.

2:39:56- Right, and what really shows how dumb

2:39:59the argument about hardware is,

2:40:01is that the Mac became more valuable as a product line

2:40:05once its hardware became the same as everybody else.

2:40:07- Yeah, exactly.

2:40:08- Like once they started using all standard stuff,

2:40:13it was a more valuable product and they sold more.

2:40:15And yet people couldn't get,

2:40:18went back to the iPhone and said,

2:40:19"Oh, because the hardware," blah, blah, blah.

2:40:21Yeah, it's so funny how people just don't,

2:40:25Even today, I think it's mostly the war has been won,

2:40:30but even today, there's some, like,

2:40:32that people don't get the,

2:40:33the software is not sold for a dollar,

2:40:37and it's the most valuable thing they make.

2:40:39- There was a plan in the '90s before the next,

2:40:42they settled on the, you know, acquiring Next

2:40:45and using Next Step as their operating system of the future,

2:40:48but at the point where they were evaluating their options

2:40:50and they were thinking about buying the BOS,

2:40:55that one of the options--

2:40:56I think it was Ellen Hancock who was then

2:40:58the chief technical officer, which

2:41:00is a position that I don't think anybody even

2:41:03held after her at Apple.

2:41:04But I think it was her who endorsed it.

2:41:07And if not, I apologize to Ellen Hancock.

2:41:09But somebody at Apple seriously investigated

2:41:13using Windows NT as the foundation

2:41:16and just building a touchwiz, like a Macintosh touchwiz

2:41:21interface on top of NT.

2:41:24what TouchWiz is to Android, that Apple--

2:41:26yeah, you just paint a little Apple-like magic on top of it,

2:41:30but you can outsource the actual operating system

2:41:33to Windows NT.

2:41:34It would have completely sunk the company.

2:41:36The company would have been gone in three years.

2:41:39It had it exactly upside down, the way--

2:41:41But they can do--

2:41:42doing the exact same thing on the hardware side

2:41:44by switching the internals to bog standard Intel PCs that

2:41:48could literally dual boot into Windows if you wanted them to,

2:41:51or still can today, was the best thing

2:41:54that ever happened to Mac hardware.

2:41:56- Right, and so the reason this matters is,

2:41:59if you're, and why the iPhone 7 will sell well,

2:42:01is if you need a new phone, you're gonna buy an iPhone 7,

2:42:05right, and it's faster and it's better,

2:42:06and yes, the camera's better, and yeah,

2:42:08it may be it looks the same as iPhone 6,

2:42:10but like, when that's your only choice,

2:42:13it's not really that big of a deal, right?

2:42:15And the problem, whereas Android,

2:42:19It's like the what lock-in,

2:42:21there's not really any lock-in at all.

2:42:23Samsung's been trying to create some sort of lock-in

2:42:25for years and they fail

2:42:26because that's not what they're good at.

2:42:28- So here's where we disagree, where we disagree.

2:42:30We agree that it's a big problem for Apple

2:42:32that WeChat's dominance is more important,

2:42:36more central than iOS to the experience,

2:42:39would then lend you believe that more iPhone users

2:42:41would be willing to switch to Android

2:42:42and we're seeing proof of that, that it's happening.

2:42:44- Right.

2:42:46- Where we subtly disagree is that you also think

2:42:48it's a factor in these declining sales,

2:42:50is the fact that the iPhone 7

2:42:52looks so much like a 6 and 6S.

2:42:54- Yeah, and the reason is 'cause--

2:42:57- I agree, and this is the point,

2:42:58that's the exact point where my sort of,

2:43:03it's definitely contrarian to most people,

2:43:05'cause I think that most people who opine professionally

2:43:08about the design of phones took that,

2:43:13emphasized the wow, it's the same form factor

2:43:15as the last two years.

2:43:17and that's an inherently negative thing.

2:43:20I agree in the basics though,

2:43:25I'm not arguing the extreme point

2:43:28that the iPhone is now in a perfect shape

2:43:30and should never change in any dimension

2:43:34or something like that.

2:43:35I just think it's less of a factor than you do.

2:43:39In fact, almost irrelevant in the China case.

2:43:42- Well, see, so I agree with you

2:43:44in most of the rest of the world

2:43:46because at the end of the day,

2:43:47to buy an iPhone is to buy an iOS delivery device, right?

2:43:52At the end of the day, the hardware is a vehicle

2:43:56to get the software that you want.

2:43:58And this is what Apple is and always has been.

2:44:00But just set aside Apple for a while

2:44:04and think about what drives high-end Samsung sales,

2:44:07what drives other high-end vendors in China, Huawei and Apple.

2:44:11Like, why would you choose one or the other?

2:44:15Well, you're gonna choose based on hardware.

2:44:18You're gonna choose in what goes into hardware.

2:44:20Well, some aspect of it is features like the camera

2:44:22and which is better or not.

2:44:24Some aspect of it is the way it looks.

2:44:25We're talking about a device that's with you all the time.

2:44:28Your most personal device.

2:44:29It's all you pull out, you put it on the table.

2:44:31It's something that says who you are.

2:44:34And part of that is if it's something that looks the same.

2:44:39Here's the analogy I would take.

2:44:41Think about buying a Mercedes or buying a BMW

2:44:45or an Audi or whatever, or whatever you want.

2:44:47Are there differences in how they drive

2:44:50and their performance?

2:44:51Yes, of course there are.

2:44:51And some people will always only buy a Mercedes,

2:44:54they'll always only buy a BMW.

2:44:56And that's the same thing with using,

2:44:58say, WeChat on a phone or using on Android.

2:45:00Some people will only ever buy one of them

2:45:02because it's still different.

2:45:03It's still, there's some aspect of the experience

2:45:05that it's still about iOS.

2:45:07And those, it's not to say that that's not a factor in China.

2:45:10It still is.

2:45:11It just, it's not as big.

2:45:13The number of people that actually care about that

2:45:15are fewer. But the way some people will choose to buy which car to buy is, well, BMW just

2:45:22came out with the new 5 Series, but before then the sales were really bad the previous

2:45:25year. Why? Because they'd been the same design for five years. And now this year the

2:45:28sales are really good. Why? Because they just came out with a new model. And it's the

2:45:33same sort of thing. If it's the old model, maybe you'll buy it because you just actually

2:45:38like an iPhone that much, but maybe you'll buy something else. And the implication is,

2:45:43I'm actually a bit of an optimist in the short term

2:45:45because a new iPhone's gonna come out.

2:45:46I think lots of people are gonna wanna buy it.

2:45:48- My point that it's not relevant though is that

2:45:53even if there is a spike,

2:45:56let's just say that the rumors are true

2:45:58and Apple ships in September at least one iPhone

2:46:02that's a very distinctly new design.

2:46:05And maybe all three of them,

2:46:07somebody came out with a report this week

2:46:10that the 7 and 7S, or 7S Plus and 7S

2:46:14are also going to have glass backs.

2:46:17It would, I don't want to get down this rattle,

2:46:19but it's nonsense.

2:46:20If it's true that the second tier new phones,

2:46:24not the super phone, not the iPhone Pro

2:46:26that might be, you know, $1200 or $1400,

2:46:29but like the ones that are replacing the 7 and 7 Plus,

2:46:33if they have glass backs, they're not gonna call them

2:46:34the 7S and 7S Plus because the S thing only applies

2:46:38looks exactly the same as the last year's,

2:46:41but with new technology.

2:46:43If they do that, all three phones would have new names.

2:46:46But anyway, that's a different point.

2:46:48Let's just say, Apple comes out with exciting new phone,

2:46:53and low and behold, Chinese sales spike again.

2:46:57And there's pretty strong correlation that,

2:47:00hey, new design equals Apple's back in China.

2:47:04I'll apologize to you, I'll admit that you were right.

2:47:07if it's a noticeable spike.

2:47:08'Cause it would almost have to be,

2:47:13it's not just that they'd have to be a spike,

2:47:15but it would have to, to prove it,

2:47:16I think it would have to mean that Chinese growth

2:47:18would be even greater than the growth everywhere else

2:47:20from the sale of this new iPhone, right?

2:47:22That the argument here is that the Chinese market

2:47:25is more sensitive both ways

2:47:28to the hardware design of a phone.

2:47:30That when it is new and wow, you've got the best new iPhone,

2:47:33they're even more willing to buy it

2:47:35than the rest of the world.

2:47:36and when they feel like it's stale,

2:47:38they're more willing to abandon it.

2:47:39Do you feel like that's a fair assessment?

2:47:43- I do think so.

2:47:43I thought you were going to say

2:47:45that they'd have to sell even more than the iPhone 6,

2:47:47'cause I'm not sure--

2:47:48- Oh, I don't know about that.

2:47:49- I don't think that's true.

2:47:50- Right.

2:47:51- Yeah, 'cause there's two parts.

2:47:52So one, yes, I do believe that's the case,

2:47:54and I do think that iPhone growth in China

2:47:57will be greater than in other regions of the world

2:47:59when a new design comes out.

2:48:01I do wonder, though, something that I've been thinking

2:48:05lot about. And this is the real bear case for Apple in China. The iPhone 6, it wasn't just that

2:48:12it was the big phone. That's also the first phone that came out on China Mobile, which is the

2:48:18largest carrier in China. And at the same time, you have the continued emergence of a middle class

2:48:25that can stretch for a luxury good that in the grand scheme of things isn't that expensive.

2:48:31I just talked about cars, right?

2:48:33- Right.

2:48:33- To buy a phone is a fraction of the cost,

2:48:35even if you're buying the very best phone in the world.

2:48:37- Right.

2:48:38- So my big question though,

2:48:41and this is the bare bull case,

2:48:44the best news for Apple would be exactly what I say,

2:48:47where there's, I think regardless,

2:48:49there's gonna be a big jump.

2:48:50The question is, was the iPhone 6 a fad?

2:48:52You know what I mean?

2:48:53Where it was the thing to get,

2:48:55and now, luxury goods go through this, right?

2:49:00At one point it's Louis Vuitton, then it's Chanel,

2:49:03then it's like Hermes, then it's Balenciaga,

2:49:05or whatever it might be.

2:49:06Like, is that, was the iPhone 6 a fad

2:49:09where it was just the thing to get?

2:49:11Or, I don't think that's the case, it may be a little bit,

2:49:15or is the iPhone and Apple a luxury good

2:49:20and an aspirational good, which I do think it is.

2:49:22And this matters, it matters in China,

2:49:24it matters way more in China than the US.

2:49:26And like, the level of conspicuous consumption in China

2:49:30is kind of jarring when you go.

2:49:32Like you can be in like some rundown part of town

2:49:37or messy and dirty and there's stuff flying around

2:49:40and there's people walking down the road

2:49:42with like Chanel bags.

2:49:43Like it's very different and matters

2:49:46and you pull out your phone,

2:49:47you put it on the table at the coffee shop

2:49:49and yeah, even if it's in a case,

2:49:51you can see what kind of phone it is

2:49:53and it really matters and Apple still has a great brand

2:49:57and it still means something that it's an Apple

2:49:59And I think that's why they're still maintaining cells

2:50:03to the degree that they are.

2:50:05And so I'm still relatively bullish.

2:50:09If you wanna be bearish though, it'd be that,

2:50:11oh, it was just a fad.

2:50:12Which I don't think is true, but it's possible.

2:50:14- But here's my point is,

2:50:16going back to the software being

2:50:20more important than the hardware,

2:50:21what has you attached to the Apple brand

2:50:24has to be the software too.

2:50:25It's not just that Apple as a company

2:50:27needs to be more focused on the software platform.

2:50:30But if the software platform isn't what's primarily

2:50:34keeping you buying iPhones, then you're so much less sticky.

2:50:38Like if you really are just concerned, somebody else can.

2:50:42I would argue that the competition is way closer

2:50:45to iPhone quality hardware than they are,

2:50:48than Android is to being iOS quality software.

2:50:51- Right, no, that's absolutely true.

2:50:55But I really do think it's right.

2:50:56And this isn't like a Johnny completely observation.

2:50:58I've made this point like three, four years ago

2:51:01that the big differentiation for Apple in China

2:51:05has always been the brand.

2:51:07Like that matters more.

2:51:08And that's one of Apple's actually advantages

2:51:12and something they learned with the whole 5C thing

2:51:14is having only a high-end brand or a high-end phone

2:51:19is a good thing because there is no watering down

2:51:22of the brand, right?

2:51:23Yes, you can have a high-end Samsung.

2:51:24There's also low-end crappy ones floating around.

2:51:26Same thing with all the other Chinese brands.

2:51:29The fact that an iPhone is always an expensive device

2:51:33is something that actually helps preserve that brand value.

2:51:37- It's always an expensive device or an old device.

2:51:40- Right. - Right?

2:51:41And so the only way-- - But it was expensive

2:51:42at some point. - Right.

2:51:43Okay, so what about the red iPhone?

2:51:46I didn't mention that in my article.

2:51:48I got a whole bunch of, well, what about the red one?

2:51:49'Cause the red one is obviously new.

2:51:51Like, people can quibble about

2:51:52whether the jet black iPhone looks new,

2:51:55but the red one is unmistakably new.

2:51:57Do you think the red iPhone 7 will make a difference

2:52:00in the second half of this financial year?

2:52:03- It might.

2:52:04I think that, you know, I think Cook was totally right

2:52:08to say that there's anticipation for a new device,

2:52:11which, again, I think that was about China, that comment,

2:52:15that people are waiting for the new device.

2:52:16So it might have an impact, but I think it will be muted,

2:52:21that at this point, people are waiting.

2:52:23And people are super, super up to date on this stuff.

2:52:27I don't live in China,

2:52:31but I will just say being here in Taiwan,

2:52:34iPhone rumors are on the nightly news.

2:52:36- That's amazing. - What was that?

2:52:38- Well, I'm laughing 'cause I realize that in some circles

2:52:41that's a politically charged sentence,

2:52:43but I'm also laughing at the fact that the iPhone rumors

2:52:48are on the nightly news.

2:52:50Yeah, the pervasiveness of just mobile devices is,

2:52:55I mean, the US is really behind.

2:52:58I mean, they're behind in that everyone,

2:53:01because everyone in the US had a PC,

2:53:03what mobile means in the US is all the times

2:53:08between, in between when you're using your PC.

2:53:11And what happened in China is for the vast majority

2:53:16of people, their first computing device

2:53:19is the phone.

2:53:20And so the reason why WeChat is what it is,

2:53:25it's not just that it gobbled up all these services.

2:53:29I'm not even going to gobble up, they created them.

2:53:31But also--

2:53:32- Can you use WeChat from a browser?

2:53:35- No.

2:53:36- Right, so is it mobile only?

2:53:37- They have an app for Mac and Windows.

2:53:42This is, actually it's worth downloading

2:53:45'cause I think it's really interesting.

2:53:47People, it drives people to the wall.

2:53:48people who are used to using PCs,

2:53:49this app dries up the wall.

2:53:51But I think if you can understand how the Mac app works,

2:53:54you'll start to kind of grok this.

2:53:56So what you do is,

2:53:58well, you can download the WeChat app

2:53:59from like the Mac Apple Store or Mac Apple Store,

2:54:02the Mac App Store.

2:54:04And when you launch the app,

2:54:06what it does is it brings up a,

2:54:10let me watch right now,

2:54:10I've launched a mouse, I should get it.

2:54:11So you bring it up and it has your picture

2:54:13and you quick log in.

2:54:15When you quick log in,

2:54:16you don't actually type a username or password.

2:54:19It brings up a QR code.

2:54:21And what you have to do is you have to open the WeChat app

2:54:23on your phone, scan the QR code, which I'll do it now,

2:54:27and then boom, you're logged in on the desktop.

2:54:30'Cause it sends it up to the WeChat servers that,

2:54:32yes, this is the right device, and then you're logged in.

2:54:36It's honestly worth downloading just to experience this,

2:54:40because if you're a regular PC user,

2:54:42and I heard from people like,

2:54:43oh man, have you tried using it on the PC?

2:54:45It's terrible.

2:54:46"I think they have a good user experience, blah blah blah."

2:54:48Well, mainly that app is there for old fogies

2:54:51like you and I who still want to use a PC,

2:54:54but it really gets the centrality of mobile.

2:54:59Like, you have to use your phone to log in on the PC.

2:55:03And once you grok that, I think you can kind of start

2:55:06to understand what it means to have mobile

2:55:08actually be the center of everything, not to be a peripheral.

2:55:11- All right, here's my other thing I want to get

2:55:14before we wrap this up.

2:55:15I think we're hitting the one hour mark here.

2:55:18(laughing)

2:55:20No, two hours.

2:55:21Nope, three. - Three.

2:55:22- Three hours, all right.

2:55:24Well, we can't go over for four.

2:55:25- I got it right.

2:55:28- How do you square this obsession

2:55:30with the appearance of, the external appearance

2:55:33of the phones with the fact that all around the world,

2:55:38majority of users put their phones in cases,

2:55:41but in China, it's by all accounts,

2:55:43is probably the highest rate of people putting their phones

2:55:47in cases because the resale protecting the--

2:55:50it's the whole thing with the people not wanting

2:55:53to use the Home button and using the accessibility feature

2:55:56to put a virtual Home button on the screen

2:55:58because they don't want to wear out the button so that it

2:56:00protects the resale value of the phone.

2:56:03So if everybody puts their phone in a case,

2:56:05how do you even--

2:56:07like the red phone is a perfect example.

2:56:10You put the red iPhone in a case, the button isn't even red,

2:56:12So there's no way to tell that it's a red iPhone.

2:56:14Yeah, which is one of the reasons why it might be dampened.

2:56:19I think, so there's two aspects of Apple.

2:56:23It's not just it being a new device, it's also the fact that it's an Apple.

2:56:27Like, Apple is a meaningful brand.

2:56:29It is a status-conferring brand.

2:56:32So, and that remains the case and will remain the case.

2:56:35Even if you have a case, it's not like you're worried,

2:56:39worried, yes, it's not like a purse or something where you can see across the road that someone

2:56:44has a purse. You're conveying status not to strangers, you're conveying status to the

2:56:48people you're with and around you. So when you sit down at the office and you pull out

2:56:52your phone, you put on your desk, or you're in a coffee shop, like I said, and you pull

2:56:55it out, you can see by, you can just, even if it's in a case, you can tell if it's a

2:57:01new phone or not. Interestingly, you can't really tell if it's a six or if it's a seven,

2:57:08you can definitely tell if it's a 5S or a 6.

2:57:12And you could tell the difference between a--

2:57:14Or an Android and--

2:57:18Right, right.

2:57:18So you still get the Apple status,

2:57:20because you can see that it's an iPhone.

2:57:22But there's no status conferring for newness in the fact

2:57:26that I can afford to buy the newest phone,

2:57:29and I have the best phone.

2:57:32And why buy-- yes, if you're rich and you can afford it,

2:57:38And yes, by all means buy a new iPhone every year.

2:57:41But if you're buying an iPhone,

2:57:43not just because it's an iPhone,

2:57:45but you want the status that it confers on you,

2:57:48well, why not keep the iPhone 6

2:57:50that looks the exact same as the iPhone 7

2:57:52and spend your, what little cash you have.

2:57:54I mean, China is rich, relatively speaking,

2:57:58especially in the big cities,

2:57:59but on an absolute dollar basis, much, much less money,

2:58:04why not spend that money on buying a new wallet

2:58:06or something like that?

2:58:07And I've been thinking about it.

2:58:09I actually think that the prominence of cases that the--

2:58:15what's the word I'm looking for?

2:58:17But the fact that cases are so ubiquitous

2:58:19actually plays against the ways that the iPhone 7 is new,

2:58:25because you can't see the jet black.

2:58:27You can't see that it's a red iPhone.

2:58:31The color alone--

2:58:32You can see the dual camera.

2:58:34Yeah, but that's it.

2:58:36So there are some changes, but it's nowhere near as much.

2:58:39I happen to think, and I feel like one

2:58:42of the most fascinating things about the-- there's

2:58:45so much rumor and so much speculation

2:58:47about this year's new iPhones.

2:58:48It's clearly a higher pitch than usual years,

2:58:52because all the rumors are saying

2:58:54that it's going to be something new,

2:58:56and new is more exciting than something that's not new.

2:59:00And like you said, they're on the nightly news in Taiwan.

2:59:04But despite the fever pitch of these rumors that there's something new and we hear that it's an edge-to-edge screen and stuff

2:59:10There's no actual leaks of what it's going to look like like that to me

2:59:14Like you said you didn't listen, but renee richie and I talked about it last week like it's almost excruciating reading mark german's stuff

2:59:21uh

2:59:23At bloomberg because it's entirely written around

2:59:26The central point which is that mark german has no fucking idea what the next iphone looks like

2:59:31none

2:59:33And it's really kind of hard to write the story where the gist of the story is,

2:59:39I have no idea what the next iPhone looks like.

2:59:42And so it's--

2:59:44There is a little bit.

2:59:45I mean, recently, isn't there some blueprints that got out,

2:59:48like the vertical camera and stuff like that?

2:59:50Supposedly, right?

2:59:51But they're not consistent.

2:59:53So the vertically aligned camera.

2:59:55But I think Germin did have something about that.

2:59:59But he wasn't first, though.

3:00:01I don't think any of that--

3:00:02I don't think that vertically aligned cameras came from him first.

3:00:05I think that plans leaked and then he just wrote about him.

3:00:07But then he wrote that it would, it would help the iPhone moving the,

3:00:11the dual camera from horizontal to vertically aligned would help the iPhone

3:00:15take better pictures. Oh, it wouldn't still do lenses,

3:00:19the same distance from each other. It just,

3:00:22it's just changes where they are on the body. But anyway, uh,

3:00:27anyway, here's what I think. Here's my point. My point is this,

3:00:31I think Apple is very much aware of how many people put their phones in cases, and I think

3:00:39they're very much aware.

3:00:40And I think that part of the design of whatever the next form factor for iPhone is, is very

3:00:45much designed in mind with the fact that it's going to be in a case.

3:00:49And I think they started this with the iPhone 6, because I think it's the only way that

3:00:53they justified to themselves the camera bump, which is that for most users, the camera bump

3:00:57is irrelevant because they never notice because it's in a case and the case even

3:01:01the thinnest case is thicker than the camera bump the camera bump is actually

3:01:05a penalty for people like me who don't use a case yeah I think that's a great

3:01:11point and the other the other thing I think it's really interesting is this

3:01:15idea of this iPhone like Plus or pro or pro or whatever it is that's gonna be

3:01:19much more expensive to me this is a very easy it's interesting in a lot of

3:01:25I think it's a pretty optimal path actually I think for Apple to grow revenue because

3:01:32Like there's

3:01:36There like right now. There is no

3:01:38We haven't they haven't tested how high they can go like they know they can sell a lot at this price point

3:01:43But but the iPhone Plus pushed it up $100 and they sold ton of them

3:01:46They're selling more even more than they expected and this is the third year in a row

3:01:50They've had the plus and for three years in a row

3:01:52They've under produced the plus size like the the plus share of the iPhone is actually is actually becoming more and more and

3:01:59I'm really interested about this sort of new even higher tier sort of sort of model and I think it is a

3:02:07Something that will play very well in the China market. I mean

3:02:10not just I think

3:02:13it's a balance right so you don't want to ruin the brand value of the

3:02:17seven six hundred seven hundred

3:02:20$700 phone, I mean in once you you are getting pretty darn expensive once you're going beyond that

3:02:26but the implication of being going beyond that is the sort of status and

3:02:31visibility that comes from having that is even greater and where do you strike the balance between being accessible to enough people

3:02:39versus getting in a iPhone 5c situation where it's kind of like the the there was a a

3:02:46Gulf between or in perception because you're clearly buying the cheap iPhone, right?

3:02:51That's gonna be very very interesting to see how that plays out and how far they try to push it

3:02:55Yeah, I think that if it's true and Renee was talking about this last week Renee seems pretty

3:03:01sold on the idea that the

3:03:04successors to the 7s and 7s or 7 and 7 and 7 plus

3:03:09It's I get the S's wrong

3:03:13Whether they call it the 7s or they call it the iPhone 8 or something

3:03:17Maybe if it's even newer

3:03:19But that there will be at this, you know

3:03:20The same price points as the 7 and 7 plus today that this iPhone Pro or whatever you want to call

3:03:26It is gonna be significantly more expensive

3:03:28I think that's the only way to do it

3:03:31it's the only way that makes sense and I feel like a lot of times you can kind of answer like

3:03:35the the the

3:03:38Philonology of Apple is is it gonna cause people to lose their shit the moment it's announced and like let's say

3:03:44let's say they come out with let's say they come out with a

3:03:47Replacement for the 7 and the 7 plus

3:03:51Call it the 7s and 7s plus just for the sake of this discussion at the same price points and it has reasonably

3:03:57You know what you expect from Apple year-over-year

3:03:59Technology wise the GPU graph keeps going up on the hockey stick

3:04:03The camera has X Y & Z that it does better and you can take a side-by-side picture with the year-old camera

3:04:09And you can see things that are better in the new one

3:04:11Better battery life maybe you know just typical things like that and they have this phone

3:04:18That is a jaw-dropping physical form factor and let's say the starting price is

3:04:22$1,500 like people would lose their freaking shit if all of a sudden in this market of Apple and these

3:04:30Samsung and all these super phones that are in the 700 $800 range and Apple just doubles the price for this new top tier and

3:04:37Sells a 15 or 1600 dollar starting point iPhone

3:04:40Would people lose their shit absolutely now the other tricky Apple thing that they could be doing is seeding this idea of a

3:04:49higher than thousand dollar starting point and then just making the new design at the

3:04:55at the existing starting points that the whole thing is some kind of ruse and that everybody thinks fears that this new phone is going

3:05:01To be super expensive and it turns out to be you know

3:05:04The same price as the current ones because remember like that famously the iPad yes

3:05:09Leaked to the journal's a thousand dollars and it started like $4.99

3:05:13That was amazing because it works so well like people were blown away at how inexpensive this device

3:05:20right

3:05:22They'd set the expectations.

3:05:24- Right, Jobs had talked it up,

3:05:25sufficiently talked it up during the keynote,

3:05:28lounging in his nice little chair,

3:05:30that it easily sounded like he was gonna say,

3:05:33"This thing is so freaking great,

3:05:34"you're gonna love spending $1,000 on this."

3:05:37And it was half the price.

3:05:38But anyway, I could see them doing it both ways.

3:05:40I would have to say that in the post-Steve Jobs world,

3:05:43it's more likely that they're gonna sell it for $1,500.

3:05:45- Yeah, people would definitely lose their minds on that.

3:05:50The other thing that's interesting,

3:05:52I wonder if the high end is there's gonna be,

3:05:54do you think there'll be like a pencil sort of thing,

3:05:56like the Samsung Note?

3:05:58I mean, that would be a way to differentiate it

3:06:01and call it Pro.

3:06:02It'd kind of match the iPad Pro naming.

3:06:04- I don't know.

3:06:05I don't know.

3:06:06I can't see them doing a pencil for it,

3:06:07or if they did, it would just be the regular pencil, right?

3:06:11I don't know.

3:06:12- Yeah, where it has pencil support,

3:06:13as opposed to having something built in.

3:06:15- Yeah, it could be.

3:06:17Could be the pencil.

3:06:17I don't know.

3:06:18I mean, it obviously, the pencil support in the device

3:06:21obviously costs enough money that they didn't put it in the quote unquote new iPad 9.7 inch

3:06:28You know that it's also it's a very strong differentiator to and it's a very clear thing that

3:06:33This more expensive device does this this cheaper device does not I could see them tossing if they started like 14 15 16

3:06:41$100 I could see them putting air pods in the box

3:06:43Yeah, that's I mean I that would blow it it would blow my mind it was $1,500

3:06:49I was thinking maybe like a thousand or something like that.

3:06:54Maybe you're right, maybe they'll go all out.

3:06:56- I think it makes a lot more sense.

3:06:58In fact, I think it has--

3:06:59- You're gonna go for it, go for it.

3:07:00- Well, here's my argument.

3:07:01I've been thinking about this an awful lot,

3:07:03is if it's only $100 more expensive,

3:07:05like going from the seven to the seven plus,

3:07:07like getting plus-sized with the otherwise same components

3:07:10is a $100 upgrade, right?

3:07:12Or is it a little more than $100, like 120 or something?

3:07:14- Yeah, they did raise the price.

3:07:16And I think that was a lesson for Apple, too.

3:07:18They raised the price and it didn't matter.

3:07:20They actually sold even more pluses this year

3:07:22than last year, relatively speaking.

3:07:25- I think it has to be so much more expensive

3:07:27that it keeps people from buying it.

3:07:29That people say, "There's no way I'm buying it.

3:07:31"I love it, it looks amazing,

3:07:32"but I'm not spending $1600 on an iPhone."

3:07:35And therefore, it can ship in much lower quantities.

3:07:40- Yeah.

3:07:41- Because if it's only $100 more, everybody would buy it.

3:07:43Everybody, or not everybody, but an enormous number

3:07:47people who would have otherwise bought the second level,

3:07:51the one that's the new phones that are a level down,

3:07:53they're all just gonna get the one that's more expensive.

3:07:56It can't just be $100 more expensive

3:07:58if they're really doing three new phones.

3:08:02- Yeah, the whole Apple pricing curve is really fascinating

3:08:07because, again, it's a monopoly, right?

3:08:10If you want iOS, you only have one choice.

3:08:13So the optimal, where does Apple find the right line

3:08:18between maximizing profit, which by the way,

3:08:23like the maximizing profit price is always gonna be higher

3:08:27than what it would be in a more competitive, or obviously.

3:08:32You're gonna sell fewer devices,

3:08:34but your total profit's gonna be more.

3:08:37Yeah, but they've never, I said before,

3:08:40they've never really pushed the high end,

3:08:41but you're right, with the Plus,

3:08:43they already did push it up 100,

3:08:44and they pushed up another $30,

3:08:46and it has not only, in its increased sales,

3:08:50it hasn't decreased them,

3:08:51which is, like, how much more headroom might they have?

3:08:54- It might be a lot, and I think it makes a lot of,

3:08:56the more I think about it,

3:08:57the more I think it's gonna be, you know, who knows?

3:08:59Or maybe it'll be $2,000, I don't know.

3:09:01Maybe it'll be crazy expensive, you know,

3:09:03because they're going to put stuff into it

3:09:05that they cannot, they can't put in a $700 phone,

3:09:09and/or, you know, cost-wise,

3:09:11and/or they simply cannot make in sufficient quantity.

3:09:15They sold, I think, 77 million phones in the holiday quarter

3:09:19last year, something like that, 70-some million.

3:09:23What if there's some kind of cool new technology,

3:09:25but they can only reasonably expect

3:09:27to get maybe 5 million of them in the first quarter?

3:09:31Then they'd have to-- they can either not make the device

3:09:34and stick to what they can make in quantities like 70 million,

3:09:39or they could price the device at a point where five million would be closer to where supply and

3:09:46demand meet. Yeah, or it could just be that they want to make more money. I mean, well,

3:09:52remember too, this is the company that sold $20,000 gold Apple watches. I mean, it's,

3:09:57you know, and they still, you know, they have the edition now. I mean, and, you know,

3:10:01if they called it the iPhone edition and they maybe they'll charge $2,500 for it. I don't know.

3:10:07- And maybe it will be ceramic.

3:10:08I mean, I can't remember what his name is.

3:10:11The guy who writes those brilliant--

3:10:12- Greg Kone. - Machining articles.

3:10:14Yeah, he kind of shot down the whole ceramic iPhone thing.

3:10:17And a big part of his point was about volume.

3:10:21Like there's no way, if they were actually gonna do this

3:10:23at volume, one, it'd be almost impossible,

3:10:25but two, like we would definitely know about it.

3:10:28But if it's a limited edition $1,500 phone,

3:10:33well, Apple could probably pull that off much more easily

3:10:36they're already making the watch.

3:10:39- Right, it's not even, it could be something

3:10:41that sells in so few quantities, 'cause it has to,

3:10:43because like maybe it's ceramics,

3:10:45maybe it's these OLED screens,

3:10:46whatever else the thing may have.

3:10:48I don't know, what if it costs $3,000?

3:10:51- And this, the Apple II edition,

3:10:53so my wife actually has it.

3:10:55It looks good, I think it looks better than the,

3:10:59the gold ones just looked wrong, right?

3:11:00- Yes, I agree.

3:11:02- But the white ceramic, it looks really, really good.

3:11:06and it pairs with all the straps and it looks fantastic.

3:11:10A phone that looked like that would be hot.

3:11:14- Yeah, it looks somehow to me,

3:11:15I've always been a fan of the black phones.

3:11:18And to me, I just don't like the way

3:11:21that the black rectangle of the screen

3:11:24looks surrounded by a white bezel.

3:11:25I don't like it on an iPad, I just don't.

3:11:27It's a personal thing.

3:11:28Whereas on the addition watch,

3:11:30the way that the black and the white integrate,

3:11:33because it's not really a black rectangle

3:11:35surrounded by white, it's that black sapphire piece on top

3:11:38with the black screen.

3:11:39It looks really good.

3:11:41- Yeah, it may just, a watch usually kind of has

3:11:45an offset color for the watch face anyway,

3:11:47so it maybe fits your sort of expectations for the wrist.

3:11:50Anyway.

3:11:52- So watch this become like Business Insider,

3:11:54the headline tomorrow, John Gruber says iPhone edition

3:11:58is gonna cost $3,000.

3:12:00No, right?

3:12:02I'm literally, nobody has ever,

3:12:04I have no source on this whatsoever.

3:12:06I'm just speculating.

3:12:07I'm just saying it wouldn't shock me.

3:12:09And I would relish the,

3:12:12I would just love the post keynote reaction.

3:12:16- Yeah, and I mean, I'm talking myself

3:12:18into my own self-created rumor.

3:12:20But this idea of it being ceramic,

3:12:23it being a different material,

3:12:25I think would really help them pull it off.

3:12:28- Is anybody talking about the material of the phone?

3:12:30I don't think that they are.

3:12:31They're talking about glass backs,

3:12:33but the glass back rumor seems to be about the,

3:12:36the, you know, regular level new iPhones.

3:12:39- Right, and it's a way to get away with selling,

3:12:41again, I think, like, I think this high-end phone

3:12:43is gonna like be, would be a huge hit in China,

3:12:45like for all these status sort of conferring reasons

3:12:47I just, I just discussed.

3:12:49And this is a way to get away with that without,

3:12:53'cause I was thinking about the whole pencil thing, right?

3:12:55And I don't think Apple wants to do that on the phone either.

3:12:57I was trying to think about the, what is gonna be the,

3:13:00what's going to be the sell to justify it being so much more expensive?

3:13:04Whereas if it's a completely different material, uh, in the case, you know,

3:13:08I think that's, you could,

3:13:11especially since they already set the precedent with the watch, right?

3:13:13How much is the edition cost like 1200 or something? So it's, it's,

3:13:16it's four times as much as the,

3:13:18as the base watch and much more a much more reasonable spread in price,

3:13:23I would say than the, the original edition to say the least.

3:13:26And you could see a similar thing.

3:13:28I think that it would be a, they could pull that off.

3:13:31People would be less, they would lose their shit,

3:13:33they would lose, I can't even square properly,

3:13:36they would lose their shit because the price is so high,

3:13:39but it wouldn't be like a how on earth are they,

3:13:41can they even contemplate just like this?

3:13:43Like wow, they actually went there,

3:13:46as opposed to I don't understand,

3:13:47this doesn't make any sense.

3:13:48- Right, and then I guarantee you that the thing,

3:13:50I've cited it too, I think it's such a lovely,

3:13:53lovely little quote, but the Andy Warhol quote

3:13:57about Coke being the greatest American product

3:14:00because there's just one type of Coke and it's the best.

3:14:03It's the best soda and that the bum on the street

3:14:07drinks the exact same Coke that the president drinks,

3:14:10that Liz Taylor drinks.

3:14:11Nobody else, nobody can get a better Coke.

3:14:13And with the Apple Watch, I got so much stuff from readers

3:14:19who are like, this is a complete violation

3:14:20of Apple's principles because Apple's always been like Coke

3:14:23in that regard where you can get the best phone in the world

3:14:28and you pay the same that people buy for other phones.

3:14:31President of the United States can't get a better cell phone

3:14:33than you can, but if you're gonna sell it

3:14:36for three or four thousand dollars,

3:14:37then all of a sudden you're cutting people off

3:14:40from the best, but trust me, Apple's already crossed that.

3:14:45- Well, no, but they didn't though,

3:14:47because the low-end watch was still the same.

3:14:49You could get the exact same functionality,

3:14:51because Apple at the end of the day is a software company.

3:14:54And, but this was so interesting is,

3:14:57what if maybe this high-end phone,

3:15:00there are no other differences?

3:15:02Like maybe the hardware is completely the same,

3:15:04it's just material.

3:15:05'Cause the problem is Apple's market in China

3:15:09is just different than the rest of the world.

3:15:11So again, I think if they do this,

3:15:13I really think it's a China thing

3:15:14because in China they are competing on brand and status.

3:15:18So in that case, you don't wanna be Andy Warhol,

3:15:21You don't want to be Andy Warhol's Coke.

3:15:23You want to be able to create a special Coke

3:15:26that people will pay lots of money to get.

3:15:29- And like I said to people, I've tossed it out

3:15:33where defending, even, obviously it was a mistake.

3:15:36I don't think it was wrong to try though

3:15:38with the solid gold edition.

3:15:40And I think the ceramic is a terrific second stab

3:15:45at the same idea.

3:15:46But to me, it's not that you're getting a better Coke.

3:15:49it's exactly like you said, because of the software

3:15:52and because the CPU is the same and everything,

3:15:55it's more like drinking your Coke

3:15:56out of a very fancy goblet, as opposed to--

3:15:58- Right, exactly. - The bum on the street

3:15:59who's drinking it out of the can.

3:16:01It's just both getting the same Coke,

3:16:03but the person drinking it out of the gold rimmed goblet

3:16:07is paid for the wrapper.

3:16:10One thing that would be different would be the display,

3:16:12'cause all the rumors point to the two regular new iPhones

3:16:17having the same size 4.7 and 5.5 inch displays

3:16:21and the 5.8 inch super fancy edge to edge display

3:16:26would be on the new one.

3:16:27But I wouldn't be surprised if it has the exact same system

3:16:29on a chip and same RAM and same storage and stuff like that.

3:16:33- Well, I, yeah, I've always-- - Maybe even the same camera.

3:16:35- I don't know, see, I've always been skeptical

3:16:38of the 7S and 7S Plus having the same four factor

3:16:42as the 7 and there being a new form factor

3:16:44at the very high end.

3:16:45because we already saw how that plays out with the 5C.

3:16:49It's like, it's--

3:16:50- Well, I didn't say same form factor,

3:16:52and the rumors don't say same form factor.

3:16:54The rumors just say same screen sizes.

3:16:56- Got it.

3:16:57Oh, yeah, yeah.

3:16:59We'll see.

3:17:00I mean, this is pure speculation,

3:17:02as I think we said at the beginning,

3:17:04but we can say it again.

3:17:04Like, completely making this stuff up.

3:17:07But I, yeah, it seems,

3:17:09just seems to make much more sense to me

3:17:10that the only differentiation being materials.

3:17:13But maybe you're right.

3:17:14Maybe it's bigger, and bigger is better in China,

3:17:17as also we'll note.

3:17:18People, you can care about getting a small form factor

3:17:24like the SE phone if you're not using your phone

3:17:27for everything, right?

3:17:28That almost comes with the presumption

3:17:30that you're using a PC regularly,

3:17:33or an iPad or whatever, if you want a smaller phone.

3:17:36If the phone is actually what you use all the time

3:17:39and it's the key to your life and everything that you do,

3:17:41both inside the house and outside the house,

3:17:44you want a bigger screen.

3:17:46There's no ifs, ands, or buts about it.

3:17:48- All right, Ben Thompson.

3:17:51Todd Visserie is gonna be very happy.

3:17:53Todd Visserie is the talk show listener

3:17:55who periodically charts episode lengths over time.

3:17:58Usually, whenever I post a long episode,

3:18:03he usually DMs me, just a thumbs up.

3:18:06No context, no reference,

3:18:08I just get a thumbs up from Todd Visserie.

3:18:11- That's funny.

3:18:12- I predict this will be a thumbs up episode.

3:18:15Everybody can read you and your fine work at Stratechery.

3:18:20- Just search for Ben Thompson on Google.

3:18:22- Search for Ben Thompson on Google.

3:18:24- I think one of the first times I was on,

3:18:25I misspelled Stratechery.

3:18:27And I think I went and bought the misspelled domain

3:18:30'cause I spelled it wrong and then I directed it to my site.

3:18:34Yeah, just search for Ben Thompson on Google.

3:18:34- And you can't go wrong.

3:18:35And we've got @BenThompson on Twitter,

3:18:38a fine Twitter account.

3:18:39And then there's also your No Tech Ben Twitter account

3:18:42where you tweet about the NBA.

3:18:45Who's your pick?

3:18:46Who do you think is gonna win the NBA this year?

3:18:48- Oh, Warriors.

3:18:49I think they're the very heavy favorites.

3:18:51I mean, it would be amazing and phenomenal

3:18:54if the Cavs were able to knock them off,

3:18:56but I mean, I think they have to be the, oops,

3:18:58they have to be the very heavy favorites.

3:19:00- Yeah, what's going on with the Spurs?

3:19:01Why are the Spurs struggling?

3:19:02- Well, the problem with the Spurs at a very high level

3:19:07is they don't have very dynamic guard play

3:19:09'cause their guards got old and now Tony Parker's injured,

3:19:12which is very sad.

3:19:13But I think another problem is the Spurs system is so,

3:19:17their system is so amazing and everyone plays well

3:19:20and they always have amazing bench units.

3:19:22And I think a lot of the reason in the regular season,

3:19:24they're just better prepared and deeper

3:19:26than all the other teams.

3:19:27So they just win lots of games because of the system.

3:19:31The problem is when you get to the playoffs,

3:19:33the rotations become shorter, you play fewer players.

3:19:35Sometimes you play too few.

3:19:37Like I think the Spurs won last night

3:19:39because the Rockets just got too tired.

3:19:41They only played seven people, seven players.

3:19:43But once you get the playoffs,

3:19:45it's not the median versus the median,

3:19:48whereas the regular season, it's kind of like the system.

3:19:50In the playoffs, it's the best versus the best.

3:19:52You're playing your best guys.

3:19:53They're playing more minutes.

3:19:54You're expressly game planning for your opponent

3:19:57and attacking their weaknesses

3:19:58and picking on them again and again and again.

3:20:00And so the playoffs are just so very different

3:20:02than the regular season that I think

3:20:03they have a hard time going up to another level

3:20:06'cause they're already at such a high level.

3:20:08- Yeah, the intensity is so much higher

3:20:10that it tends to keep the games closer

3:20:12and then you get in the fourth quarter

3:20:14and it really just comes down to your best five or six

3:20:16against the other best five or six.

3:20:18- Yeah, well, even just the whole game,

3:20:20'cause a lot of Spurs in the regular season,

3:20:21in like that second and fourth quarter

3:20:23when the bench units are in,

3:20:24they'll often blow the game open.

3:20:26But in the playoffs, those time periods

3:20:29are very, very short.

3:20:32So I mean, the Spurs are amazing.

3:20:34They've won four or five titles.

3:20:36People think five titles in the last,

3:20:38you know, whatever number of years.

3:20:40The NBA, it's unbelievably difficult to win a title.

3:20:43Like four teams account for like 70% of all the titles

3:20:46because it's so dependent on having the best player

3:20:51that a best player or a collection of best players

3:20:54just dominates for a long time.

3:20:57But the Spurs have also, in that time period,

3:20:59they've won a lot, they've also lost a lot,

3:21:01even when they're the higher seed.

3:21:03And I think it's because of this,

3:21:06they're great, they perform at such a high level

3:21:09with such consistency that they dominate

3:21:11the regular season again and again,

3:21:13but that is less meaningful in a playoff context.

3:21:17- Do you think the Warriors lose a game before the finals?

3:21:20- I don't.

3:21:24- Yeah, I don't think so either.

3:21:27I think it would take an injury or something.

3:21:29Somebody would have to get,

3:21:30I think the way they're playing now,

3:21:31there's no one in the West who's gonna win a game from it.

3:21:34- Yeah, probably the best bet is Houston gets there

3:21:38and they just make like 33s in a game.

3:21:40- Right, right.

3:21:41- And just through sheer shooting.

3:21:45So I think that'd be a reasonable bet.

3:21:48But yeah, there was that game a few months ago,

3:21:51again, the regular season,

3:21:52so it can't take too much from it,

3:21:53but where the Spurs jumped out

3:21:55to like a 25 to three lead on the Warriors,

3:21:57and the Warriors ended up winning by like 15.

3:22:00- That's crazy.

3:22:01It was like, it was just demoralizing.

3:22:03It had to be demoralizing for the Spurs.

3:22:04It was demoralizing as a basketball fan.

3:22:06It's like, yeah, it's over.

3:22:08- All right, I look forward to seeing you

3:22:11next month in person.

3:22:12- Yes, I will see you soon.