0:00:00So, how are you? It's been a while.
0:00:03I'm very well, thank you.
0:00:04I have a lot to cover because my last episode was the Lisa Jackson episode, so it wasn't
0:00:08really news-related. There's a lot on the agenda. I'm trying to think of even where
0:00:14to start. I guess we could start with quarterly results. I don't know. I just wrote a big
0:00:22piece about iPhone sales in China. I don't know. I don't think it's major. I don't
0:00:28I don't think the quarterly results this time were all that bad or good.
0:00:35I think long story short, my take on them is that it was a pretty good quarter everywhere
0:00:39except China.
0:00:40And it was iPhone sales continuing to slide in China turned a pretty good quarter into
0:00:45an eh, okay quarter, where it was flat.
0:00:48Overall.
0:00:49Yeah, flat I think is a great word to describe it.
0:00:51And there were two things that Tim Cook said that really stood out to me.
0:00:54One was when they're talking about new customer acquisition,
0:00:57that the rate of switchers from Android to iPhone
0:01:00was up everywhere when you discounted China,
0:01:03which is a different story than they used to tell.
0:01:05- But that's a big but, because part of what I wrote
0:01:09about today based on a very good column
0:01:13by a friend of the show, Ben Thompson,
0:01:16with some market research, at least two pieces
0:01:20of market research, one from China and another
0:01:24from UBS analysts that came out last year,
0:01:27show that in China, there's a lot lower retention rate,
0:01:33meaning when somebody who already owns an iPhone
0:01:37goes to buy a new phone, do they buy another iPhone
0:01:39or do they switch to another brand?
0:01:41That's retention rate.
0:01:42And it's really pretty, in the West,
0:01:44it's pretty consistently in the mid to high 80s.
0:01:47In the US, in the UK, in Germany,
0:01:50for two or three years now,
0:01:52very consistently 80-45. Germany's even a little higher 88-89. Japan is a little lower
0:01:59like mid 70s but pretty flat year to year. But in China it went from like Western levels
0:02:05in the 80s like in a couple years ago to around 50% now which is not good from Apple's perspective.
0:02:12No, it's a very different narrative than what they spoke about previously. If you flash
0:02:16back a couple years when they were talking about the lack of low entry level pricing
0:02:20on iPhones, one of the things that Apple said
0:02:22is they didn't need to be your first phone
0:02:24if all you wanted was the cheapest phone.
0:02:25If cheapness was your primary feature, that was great,
0:02:29but it wasn't a feature they were competing on.
0:02:30And they would count on the fact
0:02:31that you would get into smartphones
0:02:33and then if you wanted a better phone experience,
0:02:35you'd upgrade to an iPhone.
0:02:36And a lot of people did that either for status
0:02:38or for iOS for iOS apps,
0:02:40but that's no longer the case in China.
0:02:42There is still the status symbol implement,
0:02:44but as Ben pointed out, the platform layer has shifted
0:02:47from base operating system to messaging.
0:02:50Yeah, and especially, it's particularly this app, WeChat,
0:02:52which is, I think, only in China.
0:02:55I don't know.
0:02:56Or at least it's really only a sensation in China.
0:02:58But it's truly staggering numbers.
0:03:00It's a four-year-old app from another company.
0:03:03But it's, I don't know, 900 million monthly active users,
0:03:07something like that.
0:03:09And I don't want to go too-- I'll put a link,
0:03:12I swear to God, in the show notes, at least in my article,
0:03:18which has a link to the post from a woman named Connie Chen
0:03:23at Anderson Horowitz, explaining more or less for what is WeChat
0:03:30and why is it a sensation in China.
0:03:33And long story short, it's sort of like an OS in an app
0:03:36where it's a messaging app, but you can do so much stuff.
0:03:42You can pay for-- it's like an Apple Pay type competitor
0:03:45where you can go into a store and use
0:03:46WeChat to pay for the lunch while you're in line.
0:03:51And like Ben has said, that in China, it
0:03:54makes you look like a rube if you pay with cash.
0:03:56Everybody else is paying with WeChat.
0:03:59Just all sorts of stuff.
0:04:00You can buy stuff.
0:04:01It's a shopping app.
0:04:03That all sorts of companies that would
0:04:05like to be on the WeChat platform
0:04:07set up their own authorized accounts,
0:04:11like a special account status that opens up a bunch of APIs
0:04:15So you can have a programmatic backend
0:04:17so other WeChat users can, when they're chatting with,
0:04:21you know, Renee and John Incorporated,
0:04:25we can sell them t-shirts or sneakers or whatever
0:04:27right in the WeChat app.
0:04:28- Yeah, and messaging is fragmented,
0:04:32so it doesn't really,
0:04:33like you don't have to own messaging everywhere.
0:04:35As long as you own the China market with WeChat,
0:04:36you're fine, the Japanese market with Lion.
0:04:38It's almost like people who are such casual computer users
0:04:41that all they ever use is Facebook.
0:04:43It makes no difference to them
0:04:44they're on a Mac or a Windows PC or a library terminal
0:04:46or anything, their entire computing experience is Facebook
0:04:49and it makes it easy to migrate.
0:04:50- Right, my argument, and I've said this,
0:04:52I've always thought this and I still believe
0:04:54it's always been true and always will be true,
0:04:56is that in the basic Apple's model is selling nice hardware
0:05:01differentiated by proprietary software that's also nice.
0:05:06But the software part is more important
0:05:08than the hardware part because that's what makes people
0:05:13people sticky to the platform.
0:05:16And so like a Mac user, and I've put this forth before,
0:05:20I think you would agree with me,
0:05:21I just love it as a thought experiment,
0:05:23but would you rather use Apple's OS on competing hard,
0:05:27on some other hardware, or would you rather use
0:05:32some other hardware platform that's running,
0:05:39wait, some other hardware platform running Apple's OS,
0:05:41would you rather use Apple's hardware running the other OS?
0:05:44So for example, would you rather have,
0:05:46like I would rather have a Google Pixel that runs iOS,
0:05:49hypothetically since that's not really possible,
0:05:52instead of say an iPhone 7 that's running Android?
0:05:56- Totally, and I think it's easy to see
0:05:57because there are other companies
0:05:58that can manufacture beautiful hardware
0:06:00and they're in fact the suppliers
0:06:01of a lot of Apple's components,
0:06:03so we know they can make really good components,
0:06:04but no one else has proven
0:06:05they can make really good software yet.
0:06:06That's a much more rarer skill.
0:06:09- Right, and with the iOS example,
0:06:11It's a real hypothetical, because I don't even
0:06:13think it's possible.
0:06:14I really think that there's technical aspects
0:06:16of the secure enclave and stuff like that that
0:06:20would keep something from iMessage from working.
0:06:22In my hypothetical example, I'd have everything.
0:06:25My iMessage would work.
0:06:26My iCloud ID would work on this Pixel running iOS.
0:06:30But I would rather have that, even though I do,
0:06:32in any abstract, prefer an iPhone 7 over the Google
0:06:36Pixel, which is the latest Android phone that I'm
0:06:38most familiar with.
0:06:39which I have to say is actually the nicest Android phone I ever saw, versus the other
0:06:46way around. It would drive me nuts to—
0:06:47You'd have to use Qualcomm's crappy processors instead of the A-series, but you could live
0:06:51with it. Yeah, I could live with it. It's fast enough.
0:06:55If you look at the specs, they're somewhere around 18 months to 24 months behind. I would
0:07:01rather use a two-year-old iPhone 6 than use a cutting-edge Android, because the platform
0:07:08is most important to me.
0:07:09It's just my mind is warped around it.
0:07:11It's part of the way I think about how
0:07:13to do stuff on the phone.
0:07:16And whenever I pose that question, with computers,
0:07:19it actually is possible.
0:07:20Because you could create-- you can create a hackintosh
0:07:23that works, although there still is things like iMessage still
0:07:26has problems and stuff like that because there's security.
0:07:29It's not perfect.
0:07:30Hackintoshes don't work perfectly, but they do work.
0:07:34I'd rather have a hackintosh on a ThinkPad running Mac OS X
0:07:38than anything, Windows, you name it, Chrome or whatever else desktop PC operating system
0:07:46I could have running on a MacBook.
0:07:47Steve McLaughlin Yeah, absolutely the same.
0:07:49Dave Asprey But I've heard, I know there are people
0:07:51that are probably listening to the show right now. I've heard from them whenever I bring
0:07:54this up, because I do think it's an interesting hypothetical question. There are definitely
0:07:58people who I hear from who read my stuff or listen to the show and say, "No, I used
0:08:04used Windows forever, but switched to a MacBook
0:08:08just because of the hardware.
0:08:09And a lot of times, they'll say--
0:08:11and not just the way it looks, but I just
0:08:13got sick of the fact--
0:08:14I wanted a laptop that just, when I opened it up,
0:08:16it turns on.
0:08:17When I close it, it shuts.
0:08:18It's never had--
0:08:19Trackpad works.
0:08:19Trackpad works.
0:08:20Trackpad working is a huge thing.
0:08:23And I know Joanna Stern, friend of the show, is often--
0:08:25she's like the absolute queen of trackpad judgments.
0:08:31She's got the ranking in her head
0:08:33of every single trackpad quality in the whole market.
0:08:36And I totally trust her judgment on trackpad quality.
0:08:41That's a huge one.
0:08:42But the people who say that they switch like that, a lot of times
0:08:45say, but that's the only reason.
0:08:46And that they're-- for example, very common scenario
0:08:49among my audience, at least, are web developers
0:08:51whose entire life revolves around Chrome, a text
0:08:56editor, and a terminal window.
0:08:58So somebody like that, if that's your life,
0:09:00If your life is just Google Chrome, a text editor, and a terminal, you can easily switch
0:09:07to some other brand of laptop running another operating system, because those things are
0:09:11available on every platform.
0:09:13Yeah, absolutely.
0:09:14Same as the Facebook example.
0:09:16It's just your entire environment is abstracted away from your computer.
0:09:19Right.
0:09:20Well, that's why I think Facebook is such a—not really a threat to Apple, but like
0:09:25a direct threat, but certainly looms large as an indirect threat.
0:09:37Facebook is far more threatening to Apple than, to me at least, than say Samsung, even
0:09:42though you would think Samsung would be the one who's the threat because they do the same
0:09:47thing.
0:09:48They make $700 cell phones that when somebody goes into a store to decide what to buy, they're
0:09:54they're only gonna buy one.
0:09:55Whereas I feel like Apple has,
0:09:59it successfully has always been,
0:10:03or at least has been for 20 years,
0:10:05in a position where the quality of their products
0:10:08are enough that they don't really have to worry
0:10:10about somebody else who also sells nice things
0:10:12because they've got the software platform
0:10:14to differentiate themselves.
0:10:16The problem with something like Facebook
0:10:18is that Facebook, in a way, is sort of like
0:10:20the WeChat of the West,
0:10:22where if it's the most used app, and from a lot of people
0:10:27it is, and it does all the same things in mostly the same ways
0:10:32on iOS and Android, it's a lot easier for somebody
0:10:37to switch from an iPhone to Android
0:10:39if their most important app just works exactly the same way
0:10:43and lets them do all the same things.
0:10:45And it's interesting because the web arguably
0:10:46helped Apple at a time when they were very far behind in terms
0:10:50of just market share and mind share with PC,
0:10:53but the web let them compete.
0:10:55You could just have a web browser
0:10:56and you have access to all these things
0:10:58and it did ease the transition back to Mac,
0:11:01but that door goes both ways
0:11:03and it can let people leave as quickly as it let them in.
0:11:05- Right, it was, that sort of cross-platform parity
0:11:10that the web created was helpful to Apple
0:11:14when Apple was struggling,
0:11:17but it's detrimental to Apple
0:11:19now that Apple's in a position of strength.
0:11:22- And it's interesting because there's different layers
0:11:23of abstraction where Facebook abstracts away
0:11:25a lot of the operating system and you're just interfacing.
0:11:27'Cause for a normal person, the interface is the app
0:11:29and the interface is the hardware.
0:11:30It's the face that they, literally the face that they see
0:11:32and they work with.
0:11:33And you can change all the plumbing behind it
0:11:35and they may not notice.
0:11:36But if you change one button on an interface,
0:11:38you'll get complaints or, you know,
0:11:40people will tell you about it.
0:11:42And there's voice analysis too,
0:11:43where you use Siri, for example,
0:11:45which totally disintermediates Google
0:11:46and all they see is queries coming from Apple.
0:11:49and Apple could switch the plumbing for that,
0:11:51and then Alexa intermediates things.
0:11:53And it's almost like this battle
0:11:55for who can be the final point of the user interface,
0:11:57and that's the experience that becomes sticky.
0:11:59- Right, and Facebook is doing WeChat similar things
0:12:02with Messenger and stuff,
0:12:03where there's apps within apps,
0:12:06and it's the sort of thing that Apple, in its way,
0:12:11has tried to discourage in the App Store all along.
0:12:17They were never going to allow, say,
0:12:20it's part of the whole Flash thing in the early years
0:12:22when that was contentious and when Adobe first had
0:12:25a sort of Flash to native iOS development chain
0:12:30and Apple like put the kibosh on it.
0:12:33It was sort of, you know, I'm sure there,
0:12:37strategically there were multiple reasons,
0:12:39but one of them was they were never going to allow
0:12:41something like an Adobe app that when you open the app
0:12:44gives you a secondary homepage of Flash-based games
0:12:47that you can play, right?
0:12:49You can't have an app store within the app store.
0:12:52Except that if you already have a certain momentum
0:12:57and size and importance like Facebook
0:12:59and like WeChat has in China,
0:13:02you can kind of get away from it,
0:13:04get away with it because Apple can't really afford,
0:13:06they can't say we're not gonna allow WeChat
0:13:08on the iPhone in China and they can't say
0:13:11we're not gonna allow Facebook on the iPhone.
0:13:14- Yeah, people would just buy something else at that point.
0:13:16- Right, but so, you know, they even talk about apps.
0:13:19Like, you know, Facebook has things they call apps
0:13:21that you can have within Messenger.
0:13:23And like if you and I started a new chat app
0:13:27and came out with it and we said that there were apps
0:13:30you could have within the app,
0:13:31it would not make it through app approval
0:13:35in the iOS app store, or probably wouldn't.
0:13:40It's just something that a company like Facebook
0:13:43that has that sort of, what would you call it, stature?
0:13:47- Yeah, well it also blurs the web services line
0:13:49because like Apple wouldn't blink with,
0:13:50just like you go to Google.com and there's your Gmail
0:13:52and your Google Calendar, those are just
0:13:53normal web experiences, and they've done that,
0:13:56but they've packaged those things up inside chat clients
0:13:59or inside social networks instead of having them
0:14:01as a bunch of standalone URLs,
0:14:03and that gives a very different experience
0:14:04and probably a lot more compelling experience.
0:14:06- Right, and you know, one of the ways that Facebook
0:14:09is sort of threatening to Apple is in theory,
0:14:12like I don't think this would happen.
0:14:13I think it's, you know, so far it's actually
0:14:16more likely the other way around where something like,
0:14:19you know, Facebook's subsidiary Instagram
0:14:21was iOS only for years before it came out for Android.
0:14:25But if in theory Facebook somehow got better,
0:14:31it was a better experience on Android
0:14:33than it is on the iPhone, that's a threat to Apple
0:14:36if people's favorite app and most used app is Facebook
0:14:39and word spreads around that, oh, but you can't do
0:14:42the cool new X, Y, and Z that all your friends
0:14:44who have Android phones are doing on Facebook
0:14:46unless you get an Android phone.
0:14:48Facebook is so big and so popular
0:14:50that if something like that happened hypothetically,
0:14:52that's a problem for Apple.
0:14:54- Yeah, I don't wanna relitigate the whole App Store thing,
0:14:56but when you look at it, if you look at the App Store
0:14:57and you look at Google Play, for example,
0:14:59Google Play offers freedoms and features
0:15:01that a lot of App Store developers
0:15:02have been wanting for years,
0:15:04but you can't really point to things on Google Play
0:15:06and say those are apps that aren't,
0:15:08those are transformative apps
0:15:09that are simply not possible on iPhone.
0:15:11You can get Snapchat on iPhone, you can get Uber on iPhone.
0:15:14But if there was ever a case where an app
0:15:15could only exist on Android because the policies
0:15:17or capabilities of Google Play and the Android ecosystem
0:15:21were such to make it so, that would I think be the only thing
0:15:24that could really change Apple's outlook on how all that thing
0:15:26on how iOS and the App Store works.
0:15:28- Right, if you really think about it, it's Apple's...
0:15:31They have control over the app store that software vendors haven't had previously over
0:15:43their platforms, right?
0:15:45That they didn't have over the Mac because you can install any app you want on the Mac.
0:15:53And so technically, yes, they could ban anything.
0:15:54But practically speaking, they have lots of control, but they don't really have total
0:15:59control.
0:16:00only so far that they can push Facebook on,
0:16:04if Facebook is doing shady stuff behind the scenes
0:16:06like they have in the past, like when they use--
0:16:08- Of used audio APIs or bloatware, yeah.
0:16:11- You know, like, that was one of them,
0:16:13like where over the years when you look and say,
0:16:16well, why in the world is Facebook doing so much
0:16:18in the background and how are they doing it
0:16:19where there's rules of, you know,
0:16:22that apps get killed in the background?
0:16:24And Facebook at one point, one of the things they did
0:16:27is they were playing, there was an API
0:16:31so that an app that's playing audio
0:16:33can keep playing it in the background indefinitely
0:16:35and it won't get killed.
0:16:36Because if you, let's say you're playing a podcast
0:16:38and you're not, you're doing other things on your phone,
0:16:41like you're going through email and browsing the web
0:16:43while you're listening to the podcast,
0:16:45you don't want your podcast player to get killed by iOS
0:16:47because it's quote unquote in the background
0:16:49because you're getting something from it, it's playing audio.
0:16:52So Facebook used that API to play completely silent audio
0:16:57track so that they keep going in the background while they do other things like waiting for
0:17:03notifications and whatever else they're doing.
0:17:07It's almost as egregious as when they had two hamburger buttons on both sides of the
0:17:09app.
0:17:10Right.
0:17:11I'd say that this was worse.
0:17:12Two hamburger buttons don't run your battery down.
0:17:15And this problem still exists.
0:17:17I think it was a month ago people started complaining about the same issue with Pokemon
0:17:19Go and I started investigating and if you go it says with two or three hours on the
0:17:23background audio, which is not something that any app besides a streaming client should
0:17:27ever present. It should get Jetson'd immediately.
0:17:30Right. And so Facebook can get away with stuff like that in a way that other companies can't.
0:17:37The other good example of that—I mean, I don't want to tie too many stories together,
0:17:40but while we're on it—is the story that came out a few weeks ago about Uber getting
0:17:49caught by Apple.
0:17:50We could save that though.
0:17:53Maybe we should save that for after the break.
0:17:55So anyway, iPhone in China,
0:17:56what else do we have to say about that?
0:17:58- Well, I think just beyond China
0:18:01is that Tim Cook used the same sort of wording
0:18:03when he spoke about iPad and said that
0:18:05large screen iPads were up.
0:18:08Sales of all large screen iPads were up
0:18:10when overall iPad sales were down again.
0:18:12And that sort of was pointing the finger
0:18:14right at the iPad Mini.
0:18:15- Yeah, I think so.
0:18:16I think the reading between the lines on that,
0:18:19that is a good, that did strike me too.
0:18:21Reading between the lines on that
0:18:23and also looking at the revenue number,
0:18:26which wasn't really up either.
0:18:29Like for example, for the Mac, unit sales were up 4%.
0:18:36Good, year over year from the same three months last year.
0:18:40But revenue was up 14%.
0:18:42So 4% units, 14% revenue, that tells me
0:18:47that the new MacBook Pros are selling pretty well.
0:18:51Because that's the only thing that's new in the lineup.
0:18:55- And the ASPs are higher on those models.
0:18:56- And the ASPs are higher on those models.
0:18:58And so, you know, if there's any concern out there
0:19:03that the sort of mixed reviews those MacBook Pros got,
0:19:06it doesn't seem like it's had an adverse effect on sales.
0:19:08It seems like the opposite,
0:19:09that they're actually proving to be pretty popular,
0:19:11because they've driven the revenue per unit up.
0:19:17But with the iPad, with them saying--
0:19:18and again, those analyst calls, they can't lie on them
0:19:24or else they're committing securities fraud.
0:19:28They're very, very careful.
0:19:29I mean, you know because you read the transcript
0:19:31and read every word.
0:19:32I mean, it's not loosey-goosey talk.
0:19:35No, and they are well-prepared.
0:19:36They have every fact in front of them
0:19:37before they get on that microphone.
0:19:39Right.
0:19:40So if they say-- I mean, again, in the actual PDF data
0:19:46document for the quarterly numbers,
0:19:48they give you units per product line,
0:19:52like just for iPad, and the revenue for the product line.
0:19:55And that's it.
0:19:56And so they don't break down.
0:19:58In the old days, like 10 years ago, they used to break down,
0:20:00for example, Mac sales by desktop and notebook.
0:20:04But they don't have any breakdown like that for iPads,
0:20:06like between big and small.
0:20:07But if they stay on the call, the big ones are up.
0:20:10But they must be up.
0:20:12Like, either that or they're committing securities fraud.
0:20:15But given that everything was still down,
0:20:17that must mean that iPad Mini sales have just dropped off
0:20:20the face of the earth.
0:20:22Which makes sense given the advent of the larger phones
0:20:24and the lack of updates to the iPad Mini platform.
0:20:27Yeah, it's sort of a chicken and egg question for me,
0:20:29is are they not even updating the iPad Mini because people
0:20:35aren't buying the iPad Mini?
0:20:36or are people not buying the iPad Mini
0:20:37because they haven't updated the iPad Mini in a while?
0:20:40- Well, this is a bit of a tangent,
0:20:41but I went to, a mutual friend of ours
0:20:43sort of prodded us about macOS Server the other day.
0:20:46So I went to pick up a Mac Mini
0:20:48so that we could write a series of articles on iMore
0:20:50about the benefits of macOS Server.
0:20:51And I went to the Apple Store, I bought it,
0:20:54took it home, and it was running LCAP.
0:20:56Which, I mean, that to me shows
0:20:59there's not a huge turnover rate on Mac Minis.
0:21:01And we talked about how Mac Mini is a languishing product,
0:21:04and it's the same chicken and the egg problem,
0:21:05That's what I gave me an indicator about how few magnities might actually be moving
0:21:08It's pretty telling
0:21:12Be funny if it opened it up and it was running like tiger or something. Oh, that'd be great, right?
0:21:26Yeah, the old awkward stripes
0:21:28Say how old is this?
0:21:31Power PC apps
0:21:34I'm trying to think of anything else from the quarterly results.
0:21:40Services are way up, which is as predicted.
0:21:42I mean, they've been saying this for a while that, "Hey, we're hell-bent on services,"
0:21:50and it's showing in the results.
0:21:52And it's repeatable revenue from the same customer base, so it's sort of the revenue
0:21:55that Wall Street likes.
0:21:56Because like we saw in China, you can't guarantee someone's going to buy the next iPhone, but
0:22:00if they're paying you subscription revenue, you have a certain amount of period you can
0:22:02look forward to that revenue.
0:22:04Well, and I think the other thing that--
0:22:07and it ties into my argument on the software being
0:22:10more important than the hardware in terms of not
0:22:13in any particular quarter, but in the long run of having
0:22:17a loyal customer base that when they go to replace their blank,
0:22:22whether it's their watch or whether it's their phone
0:22:24or whether it's their laptop, if they've already
0:22:26got an Apple one, they're going to buy another Apple one.
0:22:31And to have the services revenue is a sign
0:22:35that they're creating new ways
0:22:36that make more stickiness in that regard.
0:22:39- Yeah, I mean, it's good in both directions too.
0:22:41And I think they've even said this on the call
0:22:42is that you, not in these terms though,
0:22:45is that you can either double your amount of customers
0:22:47or you can double the amount of revenue
0:22:48you get from your customers.
0:22:49And both of them result in substantial increases.
0:22:51And as Apple starts to reach those big numbers
0:22:53where it's really hard to start opening up
0:22:55new iPhone markets, you've got Verizon,
0:22:57you've got international carriers, you've got China Mobile,
0:22:59getting people onto higher revenue streams
0:23:01with things like subscription services
0:23:02just creates more value from each customer.
0:23:04- Right, and I think it's important too
0:23:06because if Apple is Apple, they're never going to,
0:23:10they're never gonna have market share,
0:23:13like monopoly market share of these products
0:23:16because they're just, it's just not what Apple does
0:23:19is make products that are so low priced
0:23:22as to take over the commodity level market.
0:23:26I mean, it just wouldn't,
0:23:28An Apple that tried to do that would no longer be recognizable
0:23:31as the Apple we know.
0:23:32There are certain markets they just choose not to compete in.
0:23:34Right.
0:23:35And whatever percentage of the PC market they have--
0:23:394%, 5%, 6%, 10%, whatever you want to call it--
0:23:43their market of the phone is significantly higher than that.
0:23:47But it still is a minority and not even close to 50%.
0:23:52Even in the most popular iPhone countries,
0:23:55it's 20%, something like that.
0:23:57is where we see the differential between their market share
0:23:59and their profit share.
0:24:00- Right.
0:24:01And being able to get more money out of the existing
0:24:04customers is a path to growth that lets them still be Apple.
0:24:09- And there was one other thing that I thought
0:24:11was really interesting and that's when he was talking
0:24:12about Apple Watch and they still won't give numbers.
0:24:14They did the Amazon-like thing where they said we had
0:24:16almost twice the amount of sales as last year.
0:24:18So X was last year, this was 2X.
0:24:21But then Tim Cook said that if you take Apple Watch
0:24:22and you combine it with AirPods and with Beats,
0:24:25although he wasn't specific which Beats products,
0:24:26just the W1 or all of them,
0:24:28that makes a Fortune 500 company.
0:24:30Yeah, my guess is there's a large amount
0:24:31of Beats money in there.
0:24:32It makes a Fortune 500 company.
0:24:34- Yeah.
0:24:35Well, let's take a break and we'll come back to that
0:24:40'cause I have some comments on the watch.
0:24:44But let me take a break and thank our first sponsor.
0:24:48It's a good friend of ours, you know him, Squarespace.
0:24:52Squarespace is the place to go
0:24:55if you need to make a new website.
0:24:57I say this all the time.
0:24:58They sponsored the show for a long time.
0:25:01I'm telling you right now, next time you have an idea
0:25:02for a website, any kind of website,
0:25:05any project that needs a website, a podcast, a store,
0:25:08try it at Squarespace first.
0:25:11You will be, if you haven't recently or never have,
0:25:14you will be surprised at how easy and flexible
0:25:17Squarespace is to create a website,
0:25:19how totally non-technical you have to be.
0:25:23You just do it right there in the website.
0:25:25You see the website.
0:25:27You pick from a template.
0:25:28It looks like it.
0:25:29You see it right there on your screen.
0:25:31And then if you want to move elements around,
0:25:33you just drag them around.
0:25:34If you are technically savvy enough
0:25:36to want to put your own JavaScript in or modify
0:25:40the CSS or something like that, you can do it.
0:25:43You would be surprised.
0:25:44Here's the other thing, too.
0:25:45Because part of the easiness of using Squarespace
0:25:47is this ability to pick templates.
0:25:49And they have so many of them from different types of sites
0:25:51and have a professionally looking website.
0:25:53But I hear that.
0:25:54If I hear that, if I'm listening to this show and I hear that,
0:25:57my thought turns to, well, I don't
0:25:58want to have a cookie cutter site that
0:26:00looks like everybody else's.
0:26:01Like, say, back in the day when you'd get a Blogspot blog,
0:26:06and you'd know it was a Blogspot blog because there
0:26:08were two or three templates to choose from,
0:26:10and everybody had one of those.
0:26:12Squarespace has so many templates to choose from.
0:26:14And the templates they have, you can modify them so easily
0:26:16to customize them to your own brand
0:26:19that you don't even know when you're on a Squarespace site.
0:26:21It's unbelievable to me how many sites,
0:26:23when you start poking around and looking in the source code
0:26:25and you see that it's Squarespace site,
0:26:26you're like, wow, I never would have guessed that
0:26:29because it looks so uniquely branded to this restaurant
0:26:33or clothing company or whatever it is you're trying to make.
0:26:37So next time you make a website, build it with Squarespace
0:26:42and use the code GRUBER, my last name,
0:26:45and when you pay, you will save 10% off your first order.
0:26:49Remember that next time you need to make a website.
0:26:53So sometimes I worry that I repeat myself too often,
0:26:56Rene, that I've got like three or four columns,
0:26:59and I just keep writing them all over and over and over again.
0:27:02But the one I just wrote a couple of weeks ago was--
0:27:06I forget the guy's name, but somebody wrote a column that
0:27:08the Apple Watch hasn't changed Apple,
0:27:10hasn't done anything for Apple at all.
0:27:14And I think if you read between the lines of his arguments,
0:27:17It's more or less that the Apple Watch is nowhere near
0:27:21an iPhone-sized product and probably never will be,
0:27:25and therefore it's meaningless to Apple
0:27:28or close to meaningless.
0:27:29And I just think that's such a wrong way to look at it.
0:27:33It's like there might never be another iPhone-sized product
0:27:38in any industry, let alone Apple.
0:27:40Like Apple may not ever have an iPhone-sized hit.
0:27:43it may well be that no other company has an iPhone size hit
0:27:47in terms of just how much money
0:27:49and how many people around the world the market size is.
0:27:52And so I think judged by that,
0:27:56nothing Apple ever does will succeed by that merit.
0:28:00And I think if Apple internally took that mindset,
0:28:02it would paralyze the company.
0:28:04- Yeah.
0:28:04Yeah, I mean, iPhone creates more profit than companies
0:28:08that have oligopoly control
0:28:09over scarce fossil fuel resources.
0:28:12and people forget that perspective,
0:28:13and they create this false equivalency
0:28:15where everything for Apple has to be measured
0:28:17by the success of iPhone,
0:28:18and then everything is seemed to be lacking.
0:28:20Where for other companies,
0:28:21you could sell three Surface Books,
0:28:22and it's a rousing success,
0:28:24and you'll get 19 articles out of that.
0:28:26When we saw that, I think,
0:28:27I forget if it was Neil Seibert or Benedict Evans
0:28:30who tweeted that, based on their metrics,
0:28:33Apple Watch vastly outsold,
0:28:35by, it was a factor of two or three,
0:28:38Amazon's Alexa, sorry, Echo product,
0:28:40And yet people were touting how great and transformative
0:28:43Echo was and what a dismal failure Apple Watch was.
0:28:45And it was completely out of whack with anything resembling,
0:28:48any resemblance to facts.
0:28:49Right.
0:28:50It's graded on such a bizarre curve.
0:28:53And it's a perfect example because Alexa,
0:28:57like every other Amazon product, the Echo
0:29:00doesn't get numbers reported.
0:29:01And Apple Watch gets a Bezos curve of twice as much as ever.
0:29:07Yeah, and it's true.
0:29:08It's really important technology.
0:29:10You can kind of, at least with Apple Watch, it's in that other category, and there is
0:29:14a revenue number for the headphones and beats and Apple TV and Apple Watch.
0:29:29And given Apple TV is almost certainly pretty static.
0:29:35There hasn't been an update.
0:29:36There hasn't been a big promotional push.
0:29:37There hasn't been a big change since the fall 2015 when the current Apple TV came out.
0:29:44So it's pretty reasonable to assume Apple TV is flat at best.
0:29:50Aeropods is a little hard to gauge for this quarter because they're obviously popular
0:29:53enough that they're backordered, but it's hard to tell just how constrained they are.
0:30:01I think you pointed out that they're not sold at a huge margin.
0:30:04They're sold as cheaply as possible.
0:30:06Well, the revenue number, though, might be big, because they're not going to break that
0:30:10down by profit.
0:30:11But I have reason to believe that they're not a big moneymaker at this point.
0:30:16And it makes sense that they must be hard to make, because it's four months in, and
0:30:20they're still six weeks out if you go to order them.
0:30:24As an aside on that, for anybody looking to buy AirPods, I wrote about that on Daring
0:30:28Fireball a couple times recently.
0:30:30And a couple of people have written to me and said
0:30:32that they scored AirPods on the fly recently from AT&T stores,
0:30:41or Verizon stores.
0:30:44They're showing up.
0:30:45If you really want them and you don't want to wait six weeks,
0:30:48try stores like AT&T and Best Buy and stuff like that.
0:30:52And you might just get lucky and get them
0:30:53before you would if you place an order at Apple.com.
0:30:55So that's my tip for anybody out there looking for AirPods.
0:31:00But the numbers from those that Apple reported another
0:31:03back up the idea that Apple Watch is selling pretty well.
0:31:08And personally, I mean, this is obviously very unscientific,
0:31:11but personally, I see more and more Apple Watches
0:31:16on real people out in the streets than ever before.
0:31:19I see an awful lot of them.
0:31:21- I went to the deli the other day
0:31:23just to order a Montreal smoked meat sandwich,
0:31:25and the waiter was wearing an Apple Watch,
0:31:26and I asked him how he liked it,
0:31:27and he said, "Best thing in the world.
0:31:28not allowed to have our phones with us when we work,
0:31:30but I can still check my text messages on my Apple Watch.
0:31:33- Yeah, there's a big construction project
0:31:35across the street from my house.
0:31:37And I just, I noticed the other day
0:31:39that the guy who controls the crane
0:31:44is wearing an Apple Watch.
0:31:45And I thought that, you know, it might be the same,
0:31:47that might be the exact reason for that,
0:31:49is, you know, that he, you know, while he's doing this,
0:31:52he can't have his phone out, but if he glances at his wrist,
0:31:55he can see, you know, text notifications.
0:31:57I don't know, but just seems, you know,
0:31:59I see 'em all the time.
0:32:00I see an awful lot of 'em.
0:32:01It backs up the idea, again,
0:32:02not like it's as popular as the iPhone,
0:32:05but nothing is, really, literally.
0:32:07But I sure see 'em a lot, I really do.
0:32:11- It does a subset of important brief tasks for you
0:32:13in a way that saves you having to go to your iPhone,
0:32:15the same way your iPhone does a subset
0:32:17of really important tasks
0:32:17that saves you having to go to your Mac.
0:32:19- Yeah.
0:32:20- So it just depends how important those are to you.
0:32:21- While we're talking about Apple Watch,
0:32:22we can tie in the other story from this week
0:32:24where Apple Insider discovered that a couple of big-name apps, iPhone apps, have dropped
0:32:32their Apple Watch counterparts.
0:32:35Was it Amazon, eBay?
0:32:37And the one that, to me, was most telling was Google Maps.
0:32:39Yeah, I have to admit, when I first heard this story, my guess—and I checked into
0:32:44it, but I couldn't get an answer—was that it happened at the same time they launched
0:32:47their iMessage app, and I just thought they screwed up something in their bundle and enabled
0:32:50the iMessage app and disabled the Apple Watch app by accident.
0:32:52And I don't know if that's true or they're going to be updating it for our watch OS 4 or whatever
0:32:57But their state their subsequent statement made it sound like it was it was returning. It was not a deliberate removal
0:33:02Well the but the telling part is that it seemingly happened weeks ago and nobody really noticed
0:33:07It's very notice right away. She's like what's happening here and sort of looking into it, but it wasn't a huge story now
0:33:13I just think though I really do I think and I think it's you know
0:33:18I think the emphasis that Apple I think Apple is fully aware of this based on
0:33:22What they worked on for iOS 3 and what how they build it that
0:33:26Even with the iPhone it was true that they'd you know, they certainly obviously at the be outset didn't see how much
0:33:35How big a deal it would be to be an app platform?
0:33:38They might have had the inkling but it certainly you know, and I think it's played out in ways that
0:33:44That even they couldn't foresee. I don't think Apple would have predicted in 2007
0:33:50That the iPhone would become the most important and popular camera in the world
0:33:54you know, it's you don't know, you know, and I feel like they rolled out the Apple watch and
0:34:00Obviously, I think initially thought that apps were going to be a bigger part of what might make it
0:34:06Popular and in real use in even their own use like not just surveying users, but I think you know
0:34:13Apple people using the watch themselves that the health tracking and
0:34:19and that using it as a notifications input and output device
0:34:24are far more important than the app story.
0:34:30- I think that's absolutely true.
0:34:31It's almost like they overcompensated
0:34:33for the lack of an app store at launch for iPhone
0:34:35by making sure no matter what happens
0:34:36or how poorly it performed,
0:34:38they had one available for Apple Watch.
0:34:40And almost the heartbreaking part about that is
0:34:43they launched it at the same time that Extensibility
0:34:45was launched and Extensibility was one of the technologies
0:34:47allowed them to have apps on the Apple Watch.
0:34:49But at the same time, you've written this really well,
0:34:53what HTTPS, what web services were to websites,
0:34:57where they basically, you didn't need a website anymore,
0:34:58you could just provide an API.
0:35:00Extensions were like that to apps.
0:35:01You didn't necessarily need a binary blob
0:35:03on the same device.
0:35:03You could have features and functionality
0:35:05that could be on the same device,
0:35:07but could be projected or surfaced
0:35:09in many different places in many different ways.
0:35:12And they had that with Apple Watch,
0:35:13but instead they sort of took this mentality
0:35:15of binary blobs, where you had to have an app
0:35:17on a carousel screen that you could tap with your finger
0:35:19to launch.
0:35:20And we've seen them move away from that.
0:35:21But I think in hindsight, we're going
0:35:23to see that the watch has to be a feature device and not
0:35:28an app device.
0:35:30Yeah, and I think-- and I played around.
0:35:35He's a friend, and I appreciate the feature.
0:35:37But Marco Arment has worked on a much improved watch
0:35:41app for Overcast.
0:35:43and I know that he spent an awful lot of time
0:35:47in the last few months on it.
0:35:49And it shipped recently, and then over the weekend
0:35:52I thought, well, I was gonna go for a run,
0:35:55and I thought, in theory, I would love to go
0:35:58with just my watch and AirPods,
0:36:00and not have to figure out a way to carry my phone,
0:36:07because there's just no great way.
0:36:08I've got some kind of like belt-like thing
0:36:10that I put underneath my shirt where I can strap it in,
0:36:13but I don't want to run with it in my pockets.
0:36:15I don't like using an armband.
0:36:17There's no good way to go with a phone.
0:36:20So I thought, well, this is perfect.
0:36:21I'm not just trying this watch app of Overcast out.
0:36:27I actually want this feature.
0:36:29I would love to do this.
0:36:30And it was absolutely horrible.
0:36:32It was just terrible.
0:36:33It was hard to get it installed on the watch
0:36:35in the first place, which shouldn't be the case.
0:36:38It was like from the watch app on the phone,
0:36:41it said installing, and it just said installing dot, dot, dot,
0:36:44forever.
0:36:46And then once it was installed, getting audio--
0:36:49it's like getting audio from the phone to the watch
0:36:51takes forever.
0:36:52And even once it did, and I got a podcast over there
0:36:57to listen to, and I went to play,
0:36:58I got my AirPod synced to it, the audio was whisper quiet.
0:37:02And I mentioned this to Marco, and it's obviously not always
0:37:05the case.
0:37:06And other people are saying it happens sometimes,
0:37:08but he has no idea why.
0:37:11And I wasted like 45 minutes, and I was just like,
0:37:14you know what, screw it, I'm just going with my phone
0:37:16like I always do.
0:37:17(laughing)
0:37:18It was so much better.
0:37:19I mean, it's just too finicky.
0:37:22It's way too finicky.
0:37:23Whereas there are other things like,
0:37:26did you ever use this app,
0:37:28did you ever use this service Nuzzle and use ZZEL?
0:37:31- I've seen it, yeah, I've used it on the iPhone.
0:37:32- It's really great.
0:37:33It's a service you sign in with your Twitter account.
0:37:36And what it does is it's really, really great
0:37:40if anybody out there wants to try it.
0:37:41I find tons of stuff that I link to on Daring Fireball from it.
0:37:44But what it does is it follows your own-- the people you
0:37:46follow on Twitter.
0:37:48And when a certain threshold of the people you follow
0:37:51have all tweeted the same link or a link to the same article,
0:37:53it gives you a notification about it on the assumption
0:37:56that if like five people you follow
0:37:57have all tweeted the same link to blank,
0:38:00you want to know about blank.
0:38:02And it gives you a notification for that.
0:38:04And when I first heard about it, I
0:38:07thought that this is going to be something
0:38:08that I'm going to try and quickly get rid of,
0:38:10because I'm sort of sensitive to getting--
0:38:12I don't want too many notifications from anything.
0:38:15I find that whatever algorithm Nuzzle uses to do this--
0:38:18I mean, maybe it's super simple.
0:38:19Maybe it's just-- I don't--
0:38:21but just the idea that if five of the people I follow
0:38:25on Twitter link the same thing I want to know about it,
0:38:27the ratio of interesting links to the times they notify me
0:38:33is so high that I have no interest in turning it off.
0:38:38but they don't even have a watch app,
0:38:39but the notifications go to my watch just automatically.
0:38:42Like you don't, you know,
0:38:42like the only thing I would want from them on my watch,
0:38:45they don't even need a watch app for
0:38:46because the notifications, if my phone is in my pocket,
0:38:49automatically go to my watch.
0:38:51It's so great. - I remember Brad Ellis
0:38:53was saying that when, I forget when, right,
0:38:54when watch was introduced that, in his opinion,
0:38:57developers should spend more time making
0:38:58a really awesome notification experience
0:39:00and not worry about an app at all,
0:39:01and I think that turns out to be canny advice.
0:39:03- Right, so like Nuzzle doesn't even have a watch app,
0:39:06And to me, the watch app that I get is exactly what I want.
0:39:10And poor Marco spent months working on an advanced watch
0:39:15app that maybe someday will turn into something that's
0:39:17actually good and useful, like a future version of the watch.
0:39:21Maybe the foundation will be there
0:39:22so that when the watch actually gets its own LTE or something
0:39:25like that, it actually will be useful.
0:39:28But he spent all this time on it,
0:39:29and I don't want to use it at all,
0:39:31even though I use Overcast almost every day.
0:39:34Yeah, I've tried it.
0:39:35I like it.
0:39:35It has the issues that you mentioned,
0:39:36and I always have my iPhone with me even if I'm out,
0:39:38so I haven't been forced to use it.
0:39:40But it's a problem that people want solved,
0:39:43but it is not something
0:39:44that is technically solvable right now.
0:39:45- Right, like in all honesty,
0:39:47if Overcast didn't have a watch app,
0:39:49it wouldn't matter to me at all
0:39:50because the only thing I ever really do,
0:39:52I can do through the now playing anyway.
0:39:54- Yeah.
0:39:55- So I don't know.
0:39:58I feel like there's something that Apple,
0:40:00I think they're well aware of it, that's what I think.
0:40:03And I think we'll see more,
0:40:04I think we'll see it go that way.
0:40:05- Yeah, I think it's a classic example of,
0:40:07they saw everything as a nail.
0:40:09They had an App Store hammer,
0:40:10and then everything looked like an app nail to them.
0:40:12And in hindsight, you can look back and say,
0:40:14we needed a different approach for this.
0:40:15- Yeah.
0:40:16- And I think they've known that for over a year and a half,
0:40:18which is why we saw watchOS 3
0:40:20and we'll see watchOS 4 be different.
0:40:22- Yeah.
0:40:23Yeah, it'd be interesting to see what they do with that.
0:40:28Anything else on quarterly results before we move on?
0:40:32- No, I mean, I saw at the same time
0:40:35Tim Cook was on Jim Cramer
0:40:37and said that he used Apple Watch to lose 30 pounds.
0:40:39- Right.
0:40:39- Which, I don't know where that was from.
0:40:41- Right.
0:40:43Like, and again, and Tim Cook does not strike me
0:40:45as a bullshitter, right?
0:40:46- No.
0:40:47- Like, he's, if he says he lost 30 pounds,
0:40:50I think he probably lost 30 pounds,
0:40:51but I mean, I've seen him on stage every six months
0:40:56for five, six years, and there was never any point
0:41:00where it looked like he put on, you know,
0:41:03or put on or lost 30 pounds.
0:41:05- Yeah. - I mean, that's,
0:41:06but anyway. - And more power to him,
0:41:08it just, it was amazing. - Right.
0:41:10What did the, it was a pretty good interview.
0:41:12I mean, for, you know,
0:41:13I give Jim Cramer credit for a guy
0:41:18who's not really an Apple person,
0:41:20but rather a finance person.
0:41:22I thought it was a pretty informative interview.
0:41:25I think that this announcement of a billion,
0:41:27a $1 billion fund to promote advanced manufacturing jobs
0:41:32in the US is pretty interesting.
0:41:34That's cooking out.
0:41:36So details aren't out yet.
0:41:37I think he said to come in at the end of May.
0:41:39- Yeah, I think so.
0:41:42It was entirely, I mean, it was super interesting
0:41:47when you started to decompose the interest,
0:41:48the relationship that Apple has with the administration
0:41:50who is heavily pro US jobs and US manufacturing
0:41:54and all these elements where Apple has
0:41:56massive manufacturing capacity outside the US, but also a massive amount of money, which
0:42:00we heard about on the call as well, that they want to repatriate.
0:42:03And the last time that happened was under the Bush administration, and this administration
0:42:06might be more amenable.
0:42:07So I think it's a very careful balancing act.
0:42:10Right.
0:42:12And it's—yeah, because one thing that has happened in recent years is Apple's had
0:42:22large cash poured for a long time now, although the definition of large keeps growing.
0:42:30Yeah, letting out the waste band.
0:42:33But it has changed, even though they've sort of capped it off now where it's not
0:42:37really growing so much, and rather, however much it would be growing, they just keep giving
0:42:42to the shareholder, whatever they call it.
0:42:45It's growing despite the biggest giveback, one of the biggest givebacks in corporate
0:42:48history.
0:42:49One shift that has happened, though, is that their US holdings have shrunk, and it's almost
0:42:55entirely overseas. What they have now is almost entirely overseas. And so for this billion-dollar
0:43:00fund in the US, they're going to borrow to get the money rather than use it because they don't
0:43:06really have a billion. They have a billion, but it's—
0:43:11I don't have it on me.
0:43:12Right. It's in my wallet over in Ireland.
0:43:17No, very true.
0:43:20But it'll be interesting to see what comes of that.
0:43:22And I don't think Apple is a--
0:43:27and they've been thinking about this for a while.
0:43:29I mean, with the Mac Pro, that was
0:43:332013 where they announced that it
0:43:35would be assembled in the US.
0:43:36I mean, so it's not like they haven't--
0:43:38like all of a sudden, just with Trump in office,
0:43:41they're now looking to toe the line on bringing manufacturing
0:43:45jobs back to the US.
0:43:48But I don't think-- and I think if there's
0:43:50a Trumpian aspect to it, I don't think
0:43:53it's so much about toeing the line
0:43:55or wanting to please the Trump administration,
0:44:00but more a pragmatic, let's make sure we don't get caught
0:44:06flat-footed if they start a trade war with China
0:44:10or impose some other tariff or something like that.
0:44:14like let's be ready for anything that might happen now that somebody with his temperament
0:44:19and his stated policies toward overseas manufacturing jobs is in office.
0:44:25It's almost like preemptive positioning when they bought Steak and Didi in China because
0:44:30there's certain volatility in that leadership as well.
0:44:34And it's true.
0:44:35I think that was back when they were doing the iFactory series in New York Times and
0:44:39and that was a big story, and Apple making Macs,
0:44:43MacBook Pros, sorry, Mac Pros in the US
0:44:45was a very good story for that too.
0:44:47It'll be interesting to see where this goes.
0:44:49- Yeah, it will be.
0:44:51I mean, you know, again, you can say,
0:44:53like I saw it on CNBC after the Kramer thing had aired,
0:44:58where somebody was like, you know,
0:45:01given Apple's $250 billion cash holdings
0:45:07and their quarterly revenue.
0:45:11It's easy to say a billion dollars isn't that much to Apple,
0:45:13but still, a billion dollars is a billion dollars,
0:45:15and saying you're gonna commit a billion dollars
0:45:17to assembling, to advanced assembly
0:45:19and manufacturing jobs in the US is significant.
0:45:22- Yeah, if you have $250, you gotta give a dollar away.
0:45:25It's still a dollar you gotta give away.
0:45:26- Right, and it's, a billion is a little different
0:45:29than one dollar.
0:45:29- And any problem is easy to solve
0:45:32provided you're not the one in charge of solving it.
0:45:35That's what the media keeps forgetting, I think.
0:45:37(laughing)
0:45:39- Let me take another break here
0:45:42and thank our next sponsor.
0:45:43It's our good friends at Casper.
0:45:45You guys know Casper.
0:45:46They make an obsessively engineered mattress
0:45:48at a shockingly fair price.
0:45:49We just bought a new Casper mattress
0:45:51here at the Gruber family home.
0:45:54Our son needed a new bed.
0:45:55Got him a Casper.
0:45:56He loves it.
0:45:57Absolutely loves it.
0:45:58He literally, honest to God, he was mad at me
0:46:01that I didn't get him one sooner.
0:46:02(laughing)
0:46:04(laughs)
0:46:06It was that, we were that happy with it.
0:46:07He's that happy with it.
0:46:08It's a great mattress.
0:46:11So here's the deal.
0:46:12This is my favorite thing about them.
0:46:13They don't make you choose a type of mattress.
0:46:16When you need a mattress, you go there,
0:46:17you pick a size, and that's all.
0:46:20And then it comes to you, and you open it up,
0:46:22and you've got a mattress.
0:46:23How do you ship a mattress to somebody?
0:46:25Guess what?
0:46:26It's the fact that they make it out of like this,
0:46:29their own custom blend of like foams.
0:46:34It comes in a little box, little box meaning like
0:46:37it might be the biggest package that you're gonna get
0:46:40this year delivered to your house,
0:46:42but for a mattress it's a surprisingly small box.
0:46:45And then they have nice instructions on the outside,
0:46:48they tell you to bring it up to the room
0:46:49where you want it first, don't open it up downstairs.
0:46:53Go to the bedroom, follow their instructions,
0:46:56you open it up, it sucks all the air out of the room
0:46:58to fill the mattress, so be careful, be careful.
0:47:02Make sure you take a deep breath before you open it up.
0:47:04And there you go, you got a mattress.
0:47:05And it's comfortable and it's nice.
0:47:07It's just a nice mattress.
0:47:09And the prices, because they sell directly,
0:47:11they make 'em right here in the US, by the way.
0:47:13They make 'em here in the US.
0:47:14They sell 'em to you directly.
0:47:16There's no middleman, there's no markup
0:47:17for a retail store or anything like that.
0:47:19Their prices blow away the prices for premium mattresses
0:47:24from the big name mattress companies.
0:47:26There's just no comparison.
0:47:27Where do you go?
0:47:30Get yours today, you try it for 100 nights in your own home
0:47:35with free delivery.
0:47:36So you don't have to take my word for it, that's comfortable.
0:47:38Go buy one, have it delivered, try it out.
0:47:41You've got over three months, 100 nights,
0:47:43and if you're not happy with it, no questions asked,
0:47:45they will just arrange for someone to come
0:47:47and get it out of your house.
0:47:49No questions asked.
0:47:51Go to casper.com/thetalkshow and use that code, thetalkshow,
0:47:56and you will save 50 bucks towards any mattress.
0:47:59Put an asterisk right here.
0:48:02You can't save 50 bucks on their dog mattresses.
0:48:04I'm sorry, because the dog mattresses are only like a couple hundred bucks.
0:48:07But if you have a dog and you want to get your dog a bed, get them a Casper.
0:48:11They have an amazing, amazing dog mattress.
0:48:13And I keep mentioning it and readers keep saying that they bought it for their dog and
0:48:17their dog won't get up off the mattress.
0:48:19So there you go.
0:48:20My thanks to Casper, makers of fine mattresses.
0:48:25What else happened recently?
0:48:26I guess this week, Microsoft had their education event, and they unveiled two things. They
0:48:30unveiled on the hardware side, their own—this is their first true laptop, something that's
0:48:36not like a detachable tablet type thing that they call the Surface laptop. And they unveiled
0:48:44a new operating system called Windows 10 S. Which do you want to talk about first?
0:48:50I was going to say Joe Belfiore's new blonde haircut.
0:48:52Wow.
0:48:53(laughs)
0:48:55He famously Windows phoned Joe Belfiore,
0:48:57who went away for a year and decided to focus on education
0:48:59and then came back and is now leading this initiative.
0:49:02- I didn't see that part of the show.
0:49:03- Yeah, I don't think they put him on stage,
0:49:05which was interesting.
0:49:06- Oh, that's why I didn't understand.
0:49:07- They had Meyerson on stage, yeah.
0:49:08He was out front beforehand.
0:49:10I think maybe the hardware first, because--
0:49:12- Were you there?
0:49:13- No, we had Daniel Rubino, one of my colleagues was there.
0:49:16- I watched the video, but I really only watched the video
0:49:18for the 10S part, I didn't watch the hardware part.
0:49:23So what do you want to talk about first?
0:49:25The hardware?
0:49:26Alright, let's talk about the hardware.
0:49:27It's so interesting, and I'm going to start off with this because why not, it's
0:49:31the talk show.
0:49:33If this laptop had an Apple logo on it, I think the coverage would have been very different
0:49:37than what we saw.
0:49:39How so?
0:49:40Because there was a lot of things about this laptop that were very Apple-esque.
0:49:44The design looks almost identical to a MacBook Air.
0:49:46The price was almost identical to a MacBook Air.
0:49:49You know a lot of the video and the language that they used for it was very similar to
0:49:54Apple.
0:49:55It's got one port on it, USB-A port instead of a USB-C port, but just one port on it and
0:49:59it does have the Surface dock, you know, so you can do other things with it.
0:50:02But I think a lot of people who were highly critical of Apple for doing things like a
0:50:06single port MacBook or any of a dozen decisions they've made recently were strangely silent
0:50:12when it came to Microsoft making very similar moves with this laptop.
0:50:15Yeah, one port it's USB a which seems outdated and then they have a proprietary
0:50:19Displayport right? Yeah, and the surface talked that to me that the proprietary
0:50:24Displayport seems like the weird the part that like whoa if Apple did that that would be that would seem to generate a lot of criticism
0:50:31I don't get you you are true. I wasn't even gonna bring that aspect up, but there's
0:50:36How can Apple release a laptop with one port and get like in a month of criticism?
0:50:42or years of criticism. People still complain about the MacBook, you know, people call it the MacBook One, and then
0:50:48Microsoft releases one with one port. It happens to be outdated. The only other port is a proprietary one, which is an Apple move, and
0:50:56it gets headlines like
0:50:59here's the laptop, the Apple's, Apple's, or Microsoft's
0:51:03MacBook killer that Apple can't ignore. And it gets, it gets funnier after that because it is running Kaby Lake,
0:51:09which is a generation beyond what Apple ran, and there's reasons for that.
0:51:12that the quad-core version of Kaby Lake wasn't ready when Apple needed it.
0:51:15The graphics that Apple wanted, the more powerful graphics, were not available when Apple wanted
0:51:18to put them into the MacBook Pro.
0:51:20And this, in fact, doesn't have those sorts of graphics options.
0:51:22So Microsoft made a different choice.
0:51:24They went with a better CPU, but arguably a much worse GPU.
0:51:27But at the same time, there's 8 gigabytes and 16 gigabytes of RAM, but the 16 gigabyte
0:51:31version doesn't ship for months.
0:51:32And can you imagine if Apple announced the new MacBook Pros that we went to in October
0:51:36and said, "Oh, by the way, the 16 gigabyte version is not going to ship for a few months"?
0:51:41And I also think I went through the configuration on it because there was also some initial
0:51:45Twitter feedback that I saw where it was that it shows how overpriced the MacBook Pros are.
0:51:52And I found the exact opposite where I configured one with a Core i7, 16 gigs of RAM, and a
0:52:01512 megabyte SSD.
0:52:03the price was $2,199 and a MacBook with Core i7 and 16 gigs of RAM and a 512
0:52:11gigabyte SSD was $2,199. The exact same price. $2,199 for both. And Apple offers a
0:52:20one terabyte SSD. Microsoft doesn't. And Apple will let you get a 16 gigabytes of
0:52:26RAM configuration in the Core i5 variant of the MacBook Pro and Microsoft doesn't.
0:52:33If you want to get 16 gigs of RAM,
0:52:35you've got to also upgrade to the Core i7.
0:52:38And I'm personally, me personally,
0:52:41I've actually totally changed my personal take on
0:52:44laptops where for me, I think,
0:52:50I'm podcasting from it right now.
0:52:53I have a 2015, or is it 2014?
0:52:57Jeez, I don't even remember.
0:52:58MacBook Pro, 13-inch MacBook Pro.
0:53:00Let's see what they say in here.
0:53:02I don't even remember.
0:53:03That's a...
0:53:04Um...
0:53:05I...
0:53:06My...
0:53:07My take for years...
0:53:09Oh, mid-2014.
0:53:10So, yeah.
0:53:11It's a late 2014 MacBook Pro.
0:53:1313-inch.
0:53:14It's one of the best computers I've ever owned.
0:53:16Um...
0:53:17I maxed out everything when I bought it.
0:53:19I got three...
0:53:20Like what?
0:53:21Three gigahertz Intel Core i7.
0:53:22I got the 16 gigs of RAM, which is the most I could get.
0:53:25And I got the one terabyte SSD.
0:53:28And I'm happy with all those decisions, because I've got a couple hundred gigabytes
0:53:33left but way more than 512.
0:53:35I'm like 700 or something like that.
0:53:37So I need the one terabyte was useful to me.
0:53:41RAM is the biggest thing I need, because I'm lazy and I always keep all the Safari tabs
0:53:46open and Slack takes, Slack itself, even if you run it as an app, takes like a gigabyte
0:53:52of RAM.
0:53:55I don't think I need a Core i7.
0:53:57I think-- and I thought this when I was testing.
0:54:00I had a couple of the review units of the new MacBook Pros
0:54:04from October.
0:54:08There's nothing I do on a day-to-day basis
0:54:11where having a Core i7 instead of a Core i5
0:54:13really makes a difference.
0:54:14I don't use Xcode.
0:54:16Or if I do, I do it rarely enough
0:54:19that the difference in build times.
0:54:21I'm not doing it all day long where
0:54:23shaving some time off the build and run cycle
0:54:26would really make a difference.
0:54:30Other things I do that might be like batch processing,
0:54:32it doesn't matter to me because it's running in the background.
0:54:36The difference between a Core i5 and Core i7, performance wise,
0:54:39isn't meaningful to me personally.
0:54:40And the Core i5 is going to get better battery life.
0:54:43And that actually is-- that's more important to me.
0:54:45So I think the next time I get a MacBook Pro,
0:54:47I'd get a Core i5 that would get better battery life.
0:54:50And it's way more than fast enough.
0:54:53And then just max out the SSD and the RAM.
0:54:56Microsoft won't let you do that and I find that to be a very useful configuration
0:54:59I have the exact same MacBook Pro that you have from before the exact same
0:55:03Configuration and I came to the exact same conclusion about this one
0:55:05And in fact, I can't mention any names, but someone who knows those chipsets inside and out just told me point blank
0:55:10Don't give and tell the extra money. I
0:55:12Really I
0:55:16I believe that I really do and it's not so much that there's anything wrong with the core i7
0:55:20But that the core i5 is just good enough and I really do on that curve
0:55:25And I think that's why Apple has wisely made it the default,
0:55:28even on the Pros.
0:55:31It's not just that it's more expensive,
0:55:33but that it's really a good--
0:55:35even for someone who needs a hyper--
0:55:37relatively on the scale of all of Apple's MacBooks,
0:55:40higher performance model, the MacBook Pro, the Core i5
0:55:43is a good one.
0:55:44So anyway--
0:55:44And for that money, you get an extra port.
0:55:45I mean, you're actually getting one port from MacBook Pros.
0:55:48So anyway, I do find that interesting on the surface.
0:55:51I'll give them kudos.
0:55:52I don't think it looks like a MacBook Air.
0:55:54I think Apple has largely defined the modern laptop in a way that there are some basic
0:56:02fundamental similarities to the MacBook Air.
0:56:06The wedgey design.
0:56:07Yeah, the wedge design is certainly one.
0:56:10But I don't think that's the sort of thing that even me, as somebody who's relatively
0:56:13sensitive to people ripping off MacBooks, I don't think that's something that they could
0:56:17lay ownership to.
0:56:21sort of like, Tim Cook mentioned this, I think, at the event last year when they introduced
0:56:28the MacBook Pros, when they went through all of Apple's portables from the beginning,
0:56:33at least from the first PowerBook. I think they skipped the Mac portable. But all the
0:56:38ones that you would identify as a laptop, like the Mac portable was portable but wasn't
0:56:42a laptop. It seems crazy now, but Apple was the first one who put the keyboard back so
0:56:50so that you have palm rests in front.
0:56:53All previous laptops had the keys
0:56:55right up to the front of the device.
0:56:57I just think that's just something that when you see it,
0:57:01you're like, oh, that's an obvious way to do it.
0:57:03I think that the wedge-- - Optimized design, yeah.
0:57:05- Right, I think the wedge shape of the MacBook Air
0:57:06is an obvious way to shave weight off a device,
0:57:10where only some of the components
0:57:12need the full thickness at the back,
0:57:15and if you can make it thinner in the front,
0:57:17you might as well.
0:57:18So I don't hold that against them.
0:57:19And at a glance, you don't look at it,
0:57:21and you wouldn't look at that
0:57:22and think that's a MacBook Air.
0:57:23- I did, but I'm willing to concede the point.
0:57:26I watched the video, 'cause the video, again,
0:57:28is very similar to Apple Design Language,
0:57:30and you see that computer opening up,
0:57:31and if you squint a little bit,
0:57:32you can't tell the difference.
0:57:33- All right, and they obviously took a lot of pride
0:57:36in the video, and it is an Apple-style video,
0:57:39but there's a lot of pride in the internals, too.
0:57:41They show the, what would you call it, the...
0:57:47It's obviously done in CGI, but the computer--
0:57:50The renders.
0:57:51Yeah, coming apart.
0:57:53The different parts of it are in the little screws
0:57:56and everything going in.
0:57:57The federalists, too, they've gotten much--
0:57:59I mean, for a software company, they've
0:58:00gotten remarkable hardware chops over the last few years.
0:58:03Well, it's funny, though.
0:58:04They've always had a good reputation
0:58:06for making mice and keyboards, right?
0:58:09Microsoft mice and keyboards have,
0:58:10ever since they got into the business,
0:58:12have had reputation as world class.
0:58:15But the Xbox line, not so much.
0:58:18No.
0:58:20Red rings and squeaky boxes.
0:58:23But yeah, they-- and I even like the way that the--
0:58:27I think-- is it the Windows logo or the Microsoft logo,
0:58:30the four rectangles thing?
0:58:31The Windows logo, yeah.
0:58:32Is that what it is?
0:58:34It looks good.
0:58:35They've finally gotten it to a point where it's reduced to a real icon.
0:58:40It was probably the de facto Microsoft logo by now,
0:58:43because I think they use it everywhere.
0:58:45They're using a different material.
0:58:46They've got a soft touch, I forget the name of it.
0:58:51There's a brand name that I wasn't familiar with.
0:58:53- Yeah, acetyl something.
0:58:55- Yeah, it's some kind of fake leather type,
0:58:58artificial synthetic leather.
0:59:00- It's still leather, what AstroTurf is to grass
0:59:01or something.
0:59:02- Yeah, but that it's used by premium luxury automakers
0:59:06for components and the dashboards of cards
0:59:09or stuff like that.
0:59:10So it's supposedly a great material.
0:59:13It will be interesting to see how it wears.
0:59:16And you might think, hey, well, duh, of course
0:59:18it's going to wear well.
0:59:19Why would they use it if it doesn't wear well?
0:59:21But then you think about the-- remember the iPod Touch that--
0:59:24Yep.
0:59:25Yes, sir.
0:59:26Well, not an iPod Touch.
0:59:27It was an iPod Nano or something that was like-- you could
0:59:31scratch it with your fingernail.
0:59:33Yeah, no, totally.
0:59:33You can't-- it's hard to-- there's no amount of Q&A that
0:59:36can prepare you for a million customers hitting your product.
0:59:38So we'll see.
0:59:38But that's new.
0:59:39I don't recall ever seeing a premium laptop that
0:59:42was something other than aluminum or plastic as the surface.
0:59:47- Yeah, they said they wanted it to be less sterile,
0:59:52to be less cold, to be more like a warmer feeling.
0:59:54I just thought, ah, that's gonna pick up a lot of stains
0:59:56and a lot of dirt.
0:59:57- At least the lighter colors would, I would think.
0:59:59I don't know.
1:00:01- But the argument, I guess, is that it's gonna patina
1:00:03like a good leather.
1:00:04- I don't know, but it's--
1:00:05- Which is a fancy way of saying a stain.
1:00:07- Yeah, but it's weird, though.
1:00:08I think things that patina by touch are different
1:00:10things like if you have like a leather watch strap or a leather belt it will get a patina over time
1:00:21but it doesn't look like too sweaty palm print. Yes. Right? No, yeah, exactly. You know, it's
1:00:29coming from use as opposed to coming from just sweat on two spots, right? Right on the palm rest.
1:00:35And those are heavily used. I mean, that's heavy traffic there. Yeah, so we'll see, you know,
1:00:38but give them credit for something original.
1:00:40- Yeah.
1:00:42- And it looks pretty good.
1:00:42But I don't think the price is all that compelling.
1:00:45I mean, I don't think it's bad,
1:00:46but I don't get the argument
1:00:48that it makes Apple's MacBook pricing look out of line.
1:00:51- No, the one thing you could criticize Apple for
1:00:53is that at $99, $999, they do not have a retina computer.
1:00:57The MacBook Air is still a non-retina machine,
1:00:59although it does have a wider variety of ports
1:01:02than this machine does.
1:01:03- Right.
1:01:04- But for people who always wanted a retina MacBook Air,
1:01:07the MacBook Pro Escape is not quite that,
1:01:10and this is closer.
1:01:11- Right, and that is the take,
1:01:13there are a couple of tweets along the lines of,
1:01:15this is the MacBook Air, the Retina MacBook Air
1:01:18that Apple never made.
1:01:20And you can kinda see that and squint your eyes,
1:01:23and that's sort of basically what it is.
1:01:25It's the wedge shape, it's 13 inches display,
1:01:28it has a Retina display, it's got the Core i5
1:01:31and Core i7 chipsets, as opposed to the Intel M3, M5,
1:01:35seven chips that the MacBook has.
1:01:37Yeah, which I still don't like.
1:01:40Whenever those chips see my iPad Pro, they just cry.
1:01:45That's the truth.
1:01:46For people who don't pay attention to those specs, and I know some of you people listening
1:01:49obviously do, but I think a lot of you probably don't.
1:01:53But the MacBook, the one-port MacBook that we have today is very, very, very similar
1:02:00conceptually to the original, when the iPad Air--
1:02:04not iPad Air, MacBook Air first came out,
1:02:07where it was not priced based on performance.
1:02:14And in traditional computer thinking,
1:02:18you spend more to get a faster computer, and you spend less,
1:02:21and you get a slower computer, by some multiple measures,
1:02:26often of speed. I/O, CPU, graphics, you name it. You spend more, you get faster, you
1:02:33spend less, you get slower. And the MacBook Air was a dramatic exception to
1:02:38that, where the MacBook Air was a lot more expensive and a lot slower, but what
1:02:43you got was something remarkably thinner and lighter. You know, famously taken out
1:02:47of a manila envelope by Steve Jobs on stage to announce it. To gasps, outright
1:02:52gasps from the audience.
1:02:54The appeal was immediate.
1:02:56But in terms of how is it priced, it was very different.
1:02:58It was a premium-priced product, even though the performance was
1:03:01far behind a MacBook Pro, like far less expensive computers.
1:03:05The MacBook today is sort of like that.
1:03:07The difference isn't as dramatic.
1:03:08It's not super expensive.
1:03:10I think-- what does it start at, $1,299?
1:03:11And a reasonable config is, I would say, around $1,500, $1,600.
1:03:18But it's slower than a $999 MacBook Air.
1:03:22- Yeah, and I think it's also,
1:03:24if you actually look at that computer,
1:03:25the components that Apple used in it are expensive,
1:03:27and it's a really bad analogy,
1:03:29but they delivered futuristic computer technology
1:03:31in the present, and that's always expensive.
1:03:33And I remember sort of asking why it was this price,
1:03:35and it seemed overpriced,
1:03:36and I got this aghast sort of look,
1:03:38and then I got a very behind-the-scenes rundown
1:03:41of what actually went into making it.
1:03:42That display is incredibly sophisticated,
1:03:45and a lot of technology they had to invent
1:03:46to make that computer the way it is
1:03:48is incredibly expensive and sophisticated.
1:03:50And you could argue that they don't need to do that kind of thing.
1:03:53And I think we'll see that again with the iPhone 8 when it ships, that it's going to
1:03:56be more expensive than the current iPhones, but because the technology they're putting
1:03:59in it would otherwise not come to market for a couple years.
1:04:02And that's the cost of bringing that stuff forward sooner.
1:04:05So you really, we're skipping ahead, but you really think that they're going to ship an
1:04:09iPhone Pro or X or 8 or something that actually raises the prices from the current iPhone
1:04:157 and 7 Plus prices?
1:04:17Yeah.
1:04:18I think they saw that there's price elasticity
1:04:20when they made the iPhone 7 Plus 20 bucks more
1:04:23than the previous iPhone 7, sorry, the previous iPhone Plus
1:04:26and that's gonna carry forward.
1:04:27And when they start introducing things,
1:04:28it's always a balancing act.
1:04:30If we wanna put something like distance charging in,
1:04:31if we wanna put a much better camera system in,
1:04:33if we wanna put much better screen technology,
1:04:35all these things have a cost
1:04:36and they'll come down over time.
1:04:37But if we do it today, it's gonna be this price.
1:04:40If we do it next year or the year after,
1:04:41it's gonna be this price.
1:04:42And once in a while, I think they're gonna gamble
1:04:44and say, we can afford to test the upper limits
1:04:46of iPhone pricing.
1:04:48- Yeah, and the other factor that comes into that
1:04:49is that they can not have to bank on having 70 million
1:04:54of those components in the first three months.
1:04:57- Oh yeah, it controls demand.
1:04:58And the price is higher, less people want it,
1:05:00and then the constrained supplies don't matter as much.
1:05:02- I think if that's going to be their strategy
1:05:04with the iPhone, which I don't think
1:05:07they would call the iPhone 8, I really don't.
1:05:09I think they would call the iPhone Pro,
1:05:11or the iPhone something.
1:05:14Because I think, and then if they also have iPhone 7S
1:05:18and iPhone 7S Plus that stay at these same prices
1:05:20we know today and just do a typical S upgrade,
1:05:23which is often, if not usually, a better upgrade
1:05:27component-wise than the non-S years.
1:05:30I think calling the new one the iPhone 8
1:05:34makes the iPhone 7S look older than it would
1:05:39if they gave it a non-numbered name.
1:05:41Like iPhone Pro. - Or I think iPhone edition
1:05:42was the other-- - Right.
1:05:43- Because Macbook was Macbook stealth originally
1:05:45and then they just went with Macbook.
1:05:46- Right.
1:05:47- So they can play around with those things
1:05:48until they just make a last minute decision.
1:05:50- Right, and those things, the leak the least
1:05:52because they don't print the names on the devices
1:05:56so they don't come out of the,
1:05:57like you look on the back of your iPhone 7,
1:05:59it doesn't say iPhone 7, it just says iPhone.
1:06:01And so it's just a small number of product marketing people
1:06:06who do not leak.
1:06:08- And they back that stuff around for a while.
1:06:11Anyway, back to Surface laptop.
1:06:16The other thing-- so the flip side of the event
1:06:20was the software, which was Windows 10 S, which is--
1:06:24and again, the comparisons were all to Apple.
1:06:27Apple was so-- it's fascinating to me,
1:06:29as somebody who's been following this stuff obsessively for--
1:06:34I was a teenager.
1:06:38It is absolutely fascinating to me how central Apple is
1:06:43to this entire announcement, both software-- everything
1:06:46on the hardware was compared to the MacBook,
1:06:48and everything software was compared to iOS and Mac OS.
1:06:55But the big news-- so Windows 10 S,
1:06:57it's a cut-down version of Windows 10.
1:07:00And it is iOS-style in some ways,
1:07:04where apps can only come from the Windows App Store.
1:07:09And to get out of that, it's not like the Mac
1:07:15where you can click a checkbox and there's
1:07:20a radio button in the Mac in the security thing where you can
1:07:22choose--
1:07:23The Gatekeeper switch.
1:07:23Yeah, the Gatekeeper switch.
1:07:25Allow apps only from the App Store
1:07:26or allow apps from the App Store and from known
1:07:31identified developers.
1:07:33And you can also, even with that checked, you can also use apps from unsigned developers,
1:07:40but you have to be nerdy enough to open them by not just by double clicking them.
1:07:45You have to control click and choose open or use the gear menu in the Finder just to
1:07:51double ensure that you know exactly what you're getting into in terms of using an app from
1:07:55an untrusted developer.
1:07:57So you can do that on the Mac.
1:07:58Windows 10 S is like iOS where there are no options like that.
1:08:03no options to get side load apps from outside the store from known developers, and certainly
1:08:08no options to get unsigned apps.
1:08:12Yeah.
1:08:13You have to pro your way out of it.
1:08:15It's a huge, huge deal.
1:08:16I mean, it's the sort of thing that, like, if Microsoft had tried it 10 years ago, would
1:08:21have had antitrust regulators.
1:08:24Well, that was a suspicion.
1:08:25When the Mac App Store was first announced, there was a whole bunch of people who panicked
1:08:29immediately and said that we're one step away from Apple locking down the Mac the way
1:08:32They locked down iOS.
1:08:33And this is just the first stage.
1:08:35And Apple has thus far not done it at all.
1:08:37And it's interesting that Microsoft got there first.
1:08:39Right.
1:08:40Because that's everybody's fear.
1:08:42And I highlighted a tweet during Fireball
1:08:44from Dieter Bohn of The Verge who said that Apple--
1:08:49Microsoft's the first-- I might be paraphrasing,
1:08:52but Microsoft's the first-- Microsoft
1:08:53ships a completely locked down computer before Apple.
1:08:57Odd.
1:08:58Which I thought was interesting just because it's-- when he's
1:09:01talking about a computer, it's clear that what he means is that he only thinks of Macs
1:09:05as real computers and not iPads, because the iPad's been out since 2011 and has been locked
1:09:10down the exact same way the whole time.
1:09:14Other changes that they've done that are even tighter than Apple's iOS restrictions in some
1:09:18ways are with web browsers. You can download other web browsers, but only from the store,
1:09:26Chrome is not in the store.
1:09:29It was at one point, so it might return.
1:09:31But my understanding-- I've poked your ass around--
1:09:34was more or less that Microsoft went to Google and said,
1:09:38hey, with the version of Chrome in the Windows App Store,
1:09:41you're turning it into Chrome OS.
1:09:42That it had its own app store.
1:09:45It did, again, circling back to our discussion of Apple
1:09:48and apps that have, quote unquote, "apps within apps."
1:09:51They were like, knock it off.
1:09:53And so rather than sort of take out that Chrome OS style
1:09:57integration of, quote, "apps within Chrome,"
1:09:59Google just took their ball and went home.
1:10:04But even if you do get a browser from their app store,
1:10:08you can't set it as your default.
1:10:10So if you get an email with a URL in it and click it,
1:10:13it's always going to open in Edge.
1:10:16And here's the part that would have
1:10:18been so much more interesting if they had done this years ago
1:10:21and if they had done it in Windows itself, is the search feature in Edge is Bing and
1:10:29only Bing, and you have no other options.
1:10:31So unlike, say, even iOS, which is pretty locked down, you get Google Search by default
1:10:37still, but you have the option for Bing, Yahoo, and DuckDuckGo.
1:10:42Yeah, it's hard to take things away from people, and I think the expectations are different.
1:10:48With iOS, the expectation has always been that you've never been able to have third-party
1:10:51rendering engines which means like you know you've never been able to you've always been able to change your
1:10:56Your default browser and with Microsoft in they're calling this windows. It feels like windows
1:11:00It looks like windows those features now feel taken away. You've taken away my ability to get chrome
1:11:05You've taken away my ability to search with Google rather than being a feature of the operating system. Yeah, it's interesting to see
1:11:10I'm intrigued to see how it plays out because I don't know who the market is for this exactly and
1:11:14There is an option last but not least there's an option
1:11:17Where you can get this?
1:11:20You could get if you buy any I guess any of these Windows 10s devices
1:11:24If you pay 50 bucks you can upgrade to Windows 10 Pro
1:11:30But it's clear
1:11:32It's not just like you're paying 50 bucks to toggle a checkbox like you're changing the OS in certain ways
1:11:39Yeah, it's not like a keeper where you can turn it off download the app you want turn it back on
1:11:42It's not like you can download Windows Pro get Chrome turn
1:11:44Then we go to it to Windows s you know, and I don't know enough about Windows to say for sure
1:11:49But it's clear that the difference between Windows 10
1:11:52S and Windows 10 Pro is more like it's
1:11:56two different versions of Windows 10,
1:11:58and there's obviously a lot of shared stuff in there.
1:12:00And it's not like the difference between iOS and Mac OS,
1:12:03where it's two entirely different operating systems.
1:12:08One Windows.
1:12:09But they did advertise repeatedly during the event
1:12:12that Windows 10 S-- I forget what they call it,
1:12:16but they don't call it sandboxing.
1:12:18But there's the equivalent idea of sandboxing,
1:12:20where apps from the Windows Store
1:12:26can't do it like the old days, where you can do it right
1:12:28all over the file system and add DLLs to the system level,
1:12:32blah, blah, blah.
1:12:34They repeatedly said that as you use a Windows 10s device
1:12:38over time, it won't slow down, which is-- again,
1:12:42I haven't used Windows on a regular basis in 10 or 15
1:12:45years.
1:12:46but it was always true and as far as I have heard recently is still true that if you know people
1:12:51can't nobody who's like an expert Windows user gets a Windows machine and four years later is
1:12:56still using it without having reinstalled at some point just to clean out the gunk.
1:13:00Yeah, it's super interesting to me the a lot of the choices that they made with this operating
1:13:07system and are they competing? It's clear they're competing with Apple in some aspects,
1:13:12but they're also competing with Chrome and Chrome OS and the growth of Chrome OS in schools and
1:13:18Chrome OS is the virtue is like the Chromebooks are super super cheap. Chrome OS is essentially free
1:13:23Chrome services Google services are essentially free makes it an incredibly easy to manage environment which education, you know schools
1:13:29everybody loves
1:13:30And is Windows S really an answer to that is a way to get a super cheap free version of Windows onto a bunch of
1:13:36Super cheap really inexpensive laptops. I think the surface laptop aside a lot of the third-party
1:13:42the Surface laptop style machines
1:13:44will be much less expensive.
1:13:46But that brings with it a whole other set of concessions
1:13:50or compromises.
1:13:51- I get the impression that at a practical level
1:13:56and from their business,
1:13:57what they really need to be concentrating on
1:14:01is Chrome and Chromebooks.
1:14:03And they announced that through their,
1:14:06nothing Microsoft branded, but through their partners,
1:14:08OEMs like I think Acer and a couple of others,
1:14:11that they're coming out with $189 notebooks
1:14:15that run Windows 10 S, which is a pretty good price point.
1:14:19And clearly, very specifically,
1:14:21the event was education themed,
1:14:23marked at the education market.
1:14:25The Surface laptop is clearly not aimed
1:14:31at that part of the education market,
1:14:35the tray full of laptops for grade school kids
1:14:40get as they come in the school.
1:14:43There is, though, it's still quote unquote education,
1:14:47but there's the teenagers who are
1:14:50going to own their own computer for high school and college.
1:14:56And that's where Apple thrives.
1:14:59So Apple, because their prices are so much higher,
1:15:02and because Chrome-- for various reasons,
1:15:04Chrome has really, really taken off in the classroom education
1:15:09market.
1:15:09And it's going to be interesting to see if it repeats.
1:15:14Because when I was young, a lot of us had Apple computers.
1:15:17But you'd go to schools, and sometimes they
1:15:19would have PC computing labs because they were cheap.
1:15:22And all you'd hear is kids go, ah, I hate this.
1:15:23My Mac at home is so much nicer.
1:15:25And I wonder if we're going to get to the point where,
1:15:28because schools are regimented the way that they are,
1:15:30there's a bunch of cheap Windows S and probably a lot more
1:15:32Chromebooks.
1:15:33And kids will go in and go, ah, this is not like the iPad
1:15:35I have at home.
1:15:35I hate it.
1:15:36and that sort of builds a whole separate cache
1:15:39where maybe Apple isn't as competitive
1:15:41in the schools anymore,
1:15:42but they're super competitive in the homes
1:15:43with the same sort of population.
1:15:45- Yeah, I think it's definitely true.
1:15:46As the father of a seventh grader,
1:15:49and seventh grade is a little different,
1:15:51but in the lower grades, just in the last few years,
1:15:55at Jonas' school, most of the computers
1:15:58that they had access to were Chromebooks,
1:16:00and the kids hated them.
1:16:03But, well, not hated them,
1:16:04But they didn't really see them as something desirable.
1:16:07Hate's a wrong word.
1:16:08But they more or less were just Google Docs machines, really.
1:16:12That's really all they were.
1:16:13And I guess they do some research on web browsers.
1:16:17But they're just literally just used
1:16:19for searching the web for some amount of research
1:16:22and for writing.
1:16:25If you had a written assignment, you'd do it in Google Docs
1:16:28and it saves to a folder where the teacher can get it.
1:16:31And they're kind of junky, and they're kind of squeaky,
1:16:33and they're kind of mushy.
1:16:34Just like, I've asked, 'cause my co-workers
1:16:36are the same way, they have Chrome at school now,
1:16:38so they went all in on it, but they have iPads at home.
1:16:41And they can tell, like it's not,
1:16:42they don't put it in those terms,
1:16:44but they can tell that it just feel like a sub,
1:16:46like they're not the same experience.
1:16:47- Right, and that's not necessarily a bad thing,
1:16:49and I totally understand it from the school's perspective,
1:16:51'cause I don't, you know, that they don't think,
1:16:54you know, you don't want more expensive, you know.
1:16:58The price is a huge issue, and durability is a huge issue,
1:17:01and if you can combine it and have a device that at least is reasonably rugged and even
1:17:06if it does break, it's only $180 to replace or whatever, I totally get it. But the mind
1:17:13share of the kids and what they actually used and wanted to use in their own time was iPhones,
1:17:19really.
1:17:20I think that's an important part of the discussion in the overall education market.
1:17:25But the Surface laptop clearly is aimed… I feel like from a business sense, Microsoft
1:17:30really needs to stem the growth of Chromebooks.
1:17:34They need that market.
1:17:35They need that, you know, their business is set up
1:17:37on the assumption that all of these low-end machines
1:17:40will be running Windows and we'll figure out a way
1:17:44to make money even if the margins are really low.
1:17:46That that's, you know, that Windows Everywhere strategy
1:17:48is important to them.
1:17:49I feel like it's more of a psychological pride thing
1:17:53that they are, and for years now,
1:17:56it's not just with the Surface laptop,
1:17:58but that they've sort of been, not even sort of,
1:18:00that they've been outright gunning for the MacBook
1:18:03in advertising with their products, right?
1:18:06They had a whole ad campaign based on the,
1:18:09I forget the name of their products,
1:18:12but I think it's the Surface Book?
1:18:14- Surface Pro and the Surface--
1:18:15- Or the Surface Pro?
1:18:16I don't know, but it's one--
1:18:17- Surface Pro was the first one
1:18:18that was the convertible tablet,
1:18:19and then Surface Book was the laptop-y convertible.
1:18:22- Right, so the laptop-y convertible.
1:18:24There's an ad campaign that was pretty big where they ran,
1:18:26And the whole thing was based on,
1:18:28can't do this on a MacBook,
1:18:30and it's usually just drawing or touching the screen.
1:18:32Trying to make that,
1:18:35look, we've made a high quality laptop
1:18:37and it has a touchscreen,
1:18:39trying to make that into a differentiating issue.
1:18:43And they mentioned, in that campaign,
1:18:45they mentioned MacBooks specifically and nothing else.
1:18:48I mean, and they can't really mention anything else
1:18:50because it's not targeted at Chromebooks.
1:18:53It's a very, these are different class machine.
1:18:55or like the thousand dollar range machine, and they can't piss off their OEMs by talking
1:19:00about other Windows laptops.
1:19:02It feels like Microsoft is caught in a hard—it's sort of caught in the middle right now.
1:19:06You have Apple at one side and Google at the other side, and Microsoft is sort of running
1:19:09back and forth between them, not really certain of its own identity, sometimes competing with
1:19:13Google, sometimes with Apple.
1:19:16And I don't want to bring up the toaster fridge thing, but I think it's an apt description
1:19:19of it sort of botches your focus with products because you don't have your own clear destination.
1:19:25You're sort of like what Apple's doing over here, what Google's doing over here, and you're meshing them together
1:19:29And I think that's sort of the disconnect that I see in the Surface Book. Yeah, okay the Surface Laptop
1:19:34well, and the other thing too is that they they
1:19:37Tried to make some hay at the end of last year in the wake of the mixed reviews of the new MacBook Pros
1:19:45And
1:19:48It said you know
1:19:50this is the end of 2016-- that I forget
1:19:54if they said their surface in particular,
1:19:56or that the premium market, which
1:19:59is defined as like $9.99 and up for laptops,
1:20:02that they're taking share away from Apple in that market.
1:20:06And there were a couple of statements that they had.
1:20:08But it was all Bezos numbers, where
1:20:10they didn't give specific numbers or sources
1:20:12and just set it.
1:20:15But the actual numbers that have been released,
1:20:17and were released since then, don't bear that out.
1:20:20Apple's Mac sales have been up.
1:20:22And again, Apple doesn't, in their numbers,
1:20:24release the split between notebooks and desktops.
1:20:27But there's no reason to believe that their desktop
1:20:29sales are up, because their best selling one, the iMac,
1:20:32is over a year old.
1:20:34And there are other ones.
1:20:35The Mac Pro and the Mac Mini are 17 and 23 years old,
1:20:40respectively.
1:20:41And even in the best desktop year, the laptops dwarf.
1:20:45Just dwarf the desktop sales.
1:20:48And so there's absolutely--
1:20:50Apple's Mac sales are up the last two quarters
1:20:53they've reported.
1:20:53So there's absolutely no sign that Mac sales are down.
1:20:58And so if it's true that Windows PCs in the premium market
1:21:02have taken share from Apple, it doesn't make any sense.
1:21:06Because if Apple's sales are up, technically it
1:21:08would be possible if the overall market were growing so fast
1:21:11that they could take share away, even though Apple is still
1:21:14growing by outgrowing it.
1:21:16But absolutely nobody is reporting
1:21:19that premium Windows laptop sales are
1:21:22a growing part of the market.
1:21:24In fact, everybody's reporting that it's
1:21:26a shrinking part of the market.
1:21:27Not collapsing, but like a slowly deflating tire.
1:21:32And there's no sign of that abetting.
1:21:39Yeah, and it's funny that-- again,
1:21:41going back to the Apple Watch thing,
1:21:43The Apple Watch is considered beleaguered, it's considered doomed in a lot of the angles
1:21:47taken in reports, where Surface was by no measure selling—well, we had no idea what
1:21:52it was selling, but it was being ballooned.
1:21:54It was being propped up.
1:21:55There were headlines all over the place saying the resurgence of the Windows laptop.
1:21:59And the coverage of the numbers you talked about that had no backing from Microsoft,
1:22:04as far as I can tell, that was pretty extensive, and the coverage of the Surface not doing
1:22:07well has not been similarly extensive.
1:22:08No.
1:22:09Right.
1:22:10sales are, not again, not collapsing,
1:22:12but the surface sales were down pretty significantly
1:22:14in the last quarter that they reported.
1:22:16So I don't see that happening.
1:22:18All right, let me take a break here
1:22:20and thank our third and final sponsor of the show.
1:22:24To our good friends at Audible.
1:22:27Audible has an unmatched selection of audio books.
1:22:33And, and this is pretty new to them, original audio shows.
1:22:38They've got news, comedy, and more.
1:22:40their own audio shows, you get an account, you sign up,
1:22:44and you get access to all of it.
1:22:45You get a 30-day free trial if you go to audible.com/talkshow.
1:22:49If you want to listen to it, whatever it is for you,
1:22:53Audible has it.
1:22:54They've got audio books from virtually every genre,
1:22:57anytime, anywhere.
1:22:58And you can play their audio books on phones, tablets,
1:23:02computers, most Kindles even, your iPod,
1:23:05you can sync it to your computer.
1:23:08Anything you can listen to digital content on,
1:23:09you can listen into Audible stuff on.
1:23:12It's great for flights, it is great for long road trips,
1:23:14it is great for your daily commute.
1:23:17Anywhere where you listen to podcasts,
1:23:19like wherever you are right now listening to me
1:23:21tell you about this, great spot to listen to Audible content
1:23:24when you run out of episodes of my show
1:23:26and the other shows that you like to listen to.
1:23:27They've even got something that they call
1:23:29the Great Listen Guarantee.
1:23:30If you start an audiobook from Audible
1:23:32and you don't like it, you get bored,
1:23:33it's not what you thought, you can exchange it
1:23:35for another one for free so you can't lose.
1:23:38Check it out and listen for yourself.
1:23:40You don't have an Audible account,
1:23:41but you like listening to podcasts, you're missing out.
1:23:44You're in the market for more Audible content.
1:23:47Begin your 30-day free trial at audible.com/talkshow.
1:23:53No the, just /talkshow.
1:23:56My thanks to Audible.
1:23:58- I should point out when I talk about the coverage,
1:24:04I don't mean that Apple should be given
1:24:05a free ride on these things.
1:24:06I think it's the same thing as like when Touch ID
1:24:08is considered a disaster at launch,
1:24:10but the botched facial recognition is fine.
1:24:12I think everybody should be scrutinized
1:24:13to the level that Apple is.
1:24:15It's not that they should give Apple a break,
1:24:16but they should hold everybody to that same standard
1:24:18because as a consumer, I want to know all that stuff
1:24:20when I make my decision on what I want to buy next.
1:24:22And I feel like I'm being underserved right now
1:24:24because I hear every little, all the hot takes about Apple
1:24:27and everything else sort of just skates by.
1:24:29- Yeah.
1:24:31Well, I think it's worth talking about.
1:24:32The elephant in the room of Apple's MacBook lineup
1:24:36is the MacBook Air because it's,
1:24:39I think I checked today, I think it's 788 days
1:24:42since they updated the specs, so it's two years old.
1:24:46It still costs $999.
1:24:48It doesn't have a retina screen.
1:24:50It's the existence of that product that gives rise to the,
1:24:56hey, Microsoft just put out this thing
1:24:58and it makes the MacBook lineup look overpriced.
1:25:02I don't think that's true if you look at the MacBook, the MacBook One port.
1:25:07Even though I think we're probably due for an update on that because the last one came
1:25:10out a year ago.
1:25:11Yes.
1:25:12But a year is not an unreasonable period of time to wait for an update.
1:25:16So if we get one at WWDC, I would say right on time.
1:25:20MacBook Pros obviously just came out last fall.
1:25:23And I think our … I don't buy the argument that they're overpriced.
1:25:27I think for what they are, they are correctly priced, even though at certain price points
1:25:32that means that getting a "new MacBook Pro" has a higher price.
1:25:36It's the price of a MacBook Pro plus the Apple Watch that's essentially embedded inside
1:25:40it.
1:25:41Right.
1:25:42Exactly.
1:25:43And I think that if you spec things out, like when I did the comparison to the Surface laptop,
1:25:52what I was configuring it against, I don't think I mentioned this, I was configuring
1:25:55it against the new MacBook Pro with the buttons, not the touch bar, because that's, to me,
1:26:02the most apt comparison.
1:26:04To me, that is the MacBook Air with retina that everybody claims that they want Apple
1:26:09to make.
1:26:10The MacBook Air with a retina screen is the new MacBook Pro that doesn't have the touch
1:26:16bar.
1:26:17I think Phil Schiller said as much when he introduced it.
1:26:18Yeah.
1:26:19Well, yeah, it's so much in so many ways.
1:26:22by comparing it to the size and weight and thickness of the MacBook Air, which it compares
1:26:26very favorably. It matches up with and it's way faster and has a beautiful screen, et
1:26:33cetera.
1:26:35But the MacBook Air is old and is sitting there at $999 and doesn't have a retina screen.
1:26:40Not arguing, but just having a very nice debate with people on Twitter about it recently.
1:26:45Marco Arment on Twitter made the point—and it's hard to argue with—that in 2017, Apple
1:26:50should not be selling any device that has a display that's not retina caliber in terms
1:26:55of resolution.
1:26:56And I agree with that.
1:26:57In theory, 2017 is too late to still be selling a brand new product.
1:27:03Brand new meaning that you're buying it out of the box and it's factory sealed.
1:27:06Full price retail, yeah.
1:27:09Right.
1:27:10I think the non-retina MacBook Air is like the new 16 gigabyte iOS device.
1:27:16I can't defend it.
1:27:17I think it's I would recommend against it
1:27:20I would if somebody asked me if they should buy one I would say no and that would be the reason why what you pointed
1:27:24Out so well with the Mac Pro thing is that Apple doesn't have a game plan for this
1:27:28It's like if we don't have something new to announce and we're not canceling it
1:27:30It just stays at exactly the same price in the catalog because they want to keep something at that
1:27:34999 price that is a Mac laptop, but they feel like they can't sell the MacBook
1:27:43One port at that price yet. Yeah and still keep the margins they want
1:27:47You know, I think what they're doing is waiting and and I don't know if it's this year
1:27:53I don't I have no inside information. But my theory is what they will do is eventually they'll have an updated
1:27:59State-of-the-art MacBook just playing MacBook. Yeah and put the year-old
1:28:04Just playing MacBook at a lower price point until it gets to 999 and then at that point the MacBook air goes away
1:28:12Yeah, and I'll be a little sad if they stick to the mint the Intel core M platform for that because it just it's not the
1:28:17same
1:28:18Either analysts its fan list, which is great
1:28:20But it's just I don't know how to get out of that though because I don't you can't use a core
1:28:24I don't know
1:28:25You know
1:28:25I think you're I think you're stuck waiting for the for the the M series to get fast enough that you don't mind
1:28:30I mean and it can happen. I mean, you know the
1:28:33The a10 is a fan list design and you know, it's fast
1:28:38That's the other thing that sort of greats about the MacBook.
1:28:42It's that the iPad Pro, in my opinion, has a faster CPU.
1:28:48I think that the single core Geekbench scores
1:28:51are a reasonable-- I realize that they don't correlate
1:28:54exactly to real world use.
1:28:56No, and they're purpose built. So the two things
1:28:58that you note right off the bat is
1:28:59that Apple can build those cores exactly for what they want.
1:29:01So they can have super fast single threaded operations,
1:29:04because that's what people hit when they do interface
1:29:06and stuff like that.
1:29:07But I remember the initial review unit I had
1:29:09for the second generation MacBook,
1:29:11it could barely handle one stream of 4K.
1:29:13Well, the A9, not even the A10 version of the iPad Pro,
1:29:17there is no A10 version yet.
1:29:18The A9 version of the iPad Pro could handle three streams
1:29:21of 4K because Apple built that chip exactly to do that.
1:29:23And they don't have control over Intel.
1:29:25And Intel will do things like,
1:29:26as far as I can tell, the Core M3
1:29:28is a deliberately hobbled chip
1:29:30that maybe Apple shouldn't use.
1:29:32But Intel just makes it worse than the M5
1:29:34just because they want a lower price point for that chipset.
1:29:36So there's a waiting game involved there.
1:29:40And because part of it, I think, too,
1:29:42is like you just alluded to, a big part of it
1:29:46is out of Apple's hands where they were waiting for Intel.
1:29:49And that opens the door to the whole, well,
1:29:51maybe they'll go put an ARM chip, their own custom
1:29:54ARM chip in a Mac.
1:29:55Or buy AMD.
1:29:56They have all this money.
1:29:57Right, or buy AMD.
1:29:59And who knows?
1:29:59Who knows what they're thinking?
1:30:01But switching to ARM on one model of Mac
1:30:04is a lot more complicated than we have time to discuss.
1:30:08And I don't think it's going to happen.
1:30:09And therefore, there might be something I don't foresee.
1:30:12There might be some way out of this.
1:30:14But basically, they're waiting for Intel on that.
1:30:16So I don't know.
1:30:17I don't know what to say.
1:30:19But I can totally see.
1:30:20I also wouldn't recommend that Apple update the MacBook Air
1:30:24and put it right in the screen in there.
1:30:26Yeah, it feels like there's something--
1:30:28and there were rumors of a device in between that
1:30:29was sort of a larger version.
1:30:30It was a 14-inch MacBook or something.
1:30:32Yeah, it would never happen to that.
1:30:34- It hasn't shipped.
1:30:35- Right.
1:30:37- There's no Kaby Lake version of the MacBook.
1:30:39There's no 14 inch version of the MacBook.
1:30:41There's just, then the updated iMac's not here yet.
1:30:44- Yeah, yeah, the 14 inch MacBook was a weird rumor
1:30:48that some people seem certain of and never shipped.
1:30:51Anyway, let's move on.
1:30:56WWDC stuff.
1:30:58I just quickly want to say, I am having a live show.
1:31:02It's announced.
1:31:03People keep asking about tickets soon.
1:31:05As you listen to this, it will be very soon.
1:31:07We are moving.
1:31:09But I don't have anything to announce yet.
1:31:10So patience.
1:31:15Sorry.
1:31:17There are a couple of other events.
1:31:19I know that they're on the same web page on Apple's WWDC.
1:31:22It's very, very nice of Apple to promote these alternative--
1:31:25or I forget what they call them-- but community events.
1:31:29There is a CocoConf taking place in a hotel right
1:31:32adjacent to the convention center where WWDC is.
1:31:37CocoConf is held a couple times a year.
1:31:39I've never been, but I have friends who have spoken there and have attended and swear up
1:31:44and down that it is an amazing conference, like a $12.99 conference for developers.
1:31:49They have a great speaker lineup.
1:31:51They'll be right there next to WWDC.
1:31:53So I think CocoConf is sort of a great plan B for people who wanted to go to WWDC and
1:32:00It lost the lottery for tickets.
1:32:03So look into that if you're a developer and you want something like that.
1:32:06There's AltConf, which is also in a hotel adjacent to the convention hall.
1:32:12I've never been there, but it seems to me like there's two hotels that are literally
1:32:16connected to the convention center and that those hotels themselves have convention space.
1:32:22And so one of them is a CocoaConf.
1:32:24The other one is AltConf.
1:32:25Alt Conf is free, so that's a great option
1:32:28if you're not looking to spend money.
1:32:30But I think it's also sort of developer oriented.
1:32:33And then last but not least, in fact,
1:32:34last but probably the opposite at least
1:32:37is the Layers Conference, which is a great,
1:32:41great, great conference.
1:32:42It's more design oriented.
1:32:44It's not a developer conference.
1:32:46So for those of you who aren't interested in design,
1:32:50or in development, you're not coders, but you're a designer.
1:32:52It is a great conference.
1:32:54I was, it was two years ago where I got to interview
1:32:58Susan Care, the designer of the original Macintosh icons
1:33:01and all the original Macintosh fonts,
1:33:03which is still maybe the,
1:33:05I can't believe I'm, the most I can't believe
1:33:08I'm doing this moment of my entire career.
1:33:10Like, you know, like having Phil Schiller on the talk show
1:33:12or whatever was a thrill,
1:33:14and meeting Steve Jobs was a thrill.
1:33:16But for me personally, the, not necessarily thrilling,
1:33:20but just like, I can't believe I'm doing this,
1:33:21Interviewing Susan Carrer on stage was just absolutely amazing because she's just one
1:33:27of my favorite designers of all time.
1:33:30Like literally got me, you know, it was as famous to me as Steve Jobs was at a very young
1:33:36age because I knew that she did all of this amazing work almost single-handedly on the
1:33:40original Mac and it was all down to the pixel, just perfect.
1:33:44That was great.
1:33:46But the speakers there, it's great and it's so, so nice.
1:33:48Layers is just one of those conferences where it's like,
1:33:50I cannot believe that once a year,
1:33:53these people put together a conference
1:33:54where everything is so nice, and you get nice coffee,
1:33:56and it's a nice room, and stuff like that.
1:33:58So I have a special deal for people
1:33:59who listen to the talk show.
1:34:00You go to layers.is, that's the website,
1:34:03or you can just Google for Layers Conference,
1:34:05but the website is layers.is.
1:34:07And if you use this code,
1:34:09you'll save 100 bucks on registration.
1:34:12And I know they're doing pretty well,
1:34:13but there's definitely still openings.
1:34:15And if you're gonna go, if you're thinking about
1:34:17an excuse to be in the WWDC area during WWDC. You're going to want to book stuff. Now's
1:34:24the time to book so you're not making arrangements at the last minute. You will save 100 bucks
1:34:30and here's the code you can use. They'll know you came from me. This is not a sponsorship.
1:34:33This is something I'm doing as a friend to Jesse Char who runs the conference. Because
1:34:38I wholeheartedly recommend it. This isn't a sponsorship, but it's just a great conference.
1:34:43You save 100 bucks, here's the code, martini.
1:34:46Use that code.
1:34:48And I worked it out.
1:34:50I added test it.
1:34:51You can also get the same code, same discount,
1:34:56if you type the martini emoji.
1:35:01I dare you to try it.
1:35:02I think it'll work.
1:35:02Perfect.
1:35:03That's perfect.
1:35:04Isn't that perfect?
1:35:05I hope it works.
1:35:06Try that out.
1:35:07Layers.is.
1:35:08It is such a good conference, and it's such a great-- I
1:35:10think it's going to be pretty exciting.
1:35:11I don't know.
1:35:12Who knows? This whole thing could be weird.
1:35:14But if you're thinking about it,
1:35:17if you're hoping to make last minute,
1:35:18I'm just talking to somebody else today
1:35:19who is like on the fence about whether they are gonna be,
1:35:23can they get to San Jose for WWDC week?
1:35:26So I know that there's people out there
1:35:29who are just still thinking maybe they will,
1:35:30maybe they won't.
1:35:31But if you wanna have a good reason to be there,
1:35:33layers is as good as anything.
1:35:36- Yeah.
1:35:37And if you're a designer, it's a perfect compliment
1:35:38to WWDC because I know every year they try more and more
1:35:41more and more design sessions and they have the design review labs but it's really a developer
1:35:44show and layers is such a great complement to it yeah and i forget what else they do
1:35:48there's some integrations with wwc where apple people come and do talk about interface design
1:35:54and stuff like that so check out their website you have all the info also i just love the layers
1:35:59logo this year it is so great because it is so self-referential to the name where it's very
1:36:06design looking but anyway check out their website even if you're not interested in conference just
1:36:10just to see the excellent graphic design.
1:36:12What else do you got?
1:36:17There was the, we didn't talk about it,
1:36:18but the, we mentioned it before,
1:36:21but we didn't go into it though.
1:36:22The whole thing with Uber tagging iPhones.
1:36:25- You can tell it's an interesting week for Uber
1:36:27when they have not one but two controversies on the same day.
1:36:30- What was the other one?
1:36:31- I heard you had them both in your original write-off.
1:36:33- I don't remember.
1:36:34- Yeah, and now he's canceled his recoded.
1:36:37I mean, it's just, it's--
1:36:38- Well, that was, it had to happen.
1:36:39There was no way that he could possibly get up there.
1:36:44I almost wish what they should have done
1:36:47is like Kickstarter, just like, "All right, I'll do it,
1:36:50"but we've got to like Kickstarter a million dollars
1:36:53"for AppCamp for girls," or some good cause like that.
1:36:57Can you imagine how much money you would have raised
1:36:59to get Kara Swisher and Walt Mossberg to skewer him on stage?
1:37:03Oh my God.
1:37:06But anyway, the story came out.
1:37:07Mike Isaac of the New York Times had a story
1:37:09a profile of Kalanick, the CEO, co-founder of Uber,
1:37:15and mentioned that a couple of years ago,
1:37:18he got called in for a meeting with Tim Cook at Apple's
1:37:23campus.
1:37:24And Cook confronted him with the fact
1:37:27that Apple had figured out that they were--
1:37:29and this is where the story was murky initially,
1:37:32where the initial version of the story that
1:37:34was up in the New York Times in the morning
1:37:36said that they were tagging and tracking iPhones,
1:37:39even after the app was deleted or even if the OS was erased
1:37:45from the phone and reset.
1:37:48And then the word "tracking" was taken out
1:37:50in a subsequent edit in the afternoon.
1:37:52But the horses were out of the barn
1:37:56at that point, where people were panicked.
1:37:58And part of it is rightfully fueled by, well,
1:38:00Uber has been caught with so many shady practices
1:38:04that if they could do that, of course they would.
1:38:07It passes the sniff test of--
1:38:09Yes, it's believable.
1:38:11Right.
1:38:11But there was no tracking, meaning
1:38:14you hear tracking phones and you think, well,
1:38:16I had the Uber app.
1:38:17And if I have the Uber app, it can use my location,
1:38:20because that's how the car comes and gets you.
1:38:24And so you hear that.
1:38:25And what people think is, well, I deleted the Uber app,
1:38:27because I don't like the company.
1:38:28I've used Lyft.
1:38:29Or for whatever reason, they deleted the app.
1:38:32And the fear that Uber is still tracking them and doing
1:38:35something like figuring out if they're using Lyft,
1:38:38even if you don't have the app.
1:38:39And if you know iOS, you'd know, well,
1:38:42that sounds like it should be impossible.
1:38:44Because when an app is deleted, you
1:38:46can't do things like you could do on traditional PCs,
1:38:49like sneakily put a background process in a system directory.
1:38:55So even if your app is deleted, you've
1:38:57still got this remnant of you behind.
1:38:59That's the whole point of these containers
1:39:01that AppShip in now is that when you delete the app
1:39:03as a user, just hold the app, make it jiggle, hit the X,
1:39:07anything it could run on your phone is gone.
1:39:10But that's not what they were doing.
1:39:13I think basically, we're still not sure exactly
1:39:15what was going on, but basically they were quote unquote
1:39:17fingerprinting the phone, and they were figuring out a way
1:39:20to get a uniquely identify a phone.
1:39:23Phoning that home to Uber so they could store it.
1:39:26- Yeah, it's not like they were just essentially
1:39:28fingerprinting it and then using that fingerprint
1:39:29as a way to tell when the same device
1:39:31was re-accessing the service.
1:39:32- Right, I lost my train of thought there,
1:39:34but that's exactly right.
1:39:35And it was to counter some sort of fraud
1:39:37that was going on in China,
1:39:38where I think basically the story was
1:39:40that they had a promotion to get people
1:39:42to start using Uber, where you could get a free ride,
1:39:45if you're new to Uber.
1:39:46And if you're a driver and you pick up
1:39:49one of these free rides,
1:39:50you still get the credit as a driver.
1:39:53Uber is, the corporation is eating the free ride,
1:39:57not the drivers, because drivers would rightly revolt.
1:40:01So what drivers are doing is setting up some kind of scam
1:40:03where they would get stolen iPhones
1:40:06and configure them as new and put the Uber app on
1:40:08and get the free ride and pick them up.
1:40:11Like me and you could work as a team
1:40:13and I'll pick you up with the free thing and drop you off.
1:40:16And then you erase the phone and put it on all over
1:40:20and pretend to be somebody new
1:40:22and get another free ride and I pick you up.
1:40:24and somehow bilking them out of free rides like that.
1:40:27And so if they could uniquely identify the phone,
1:40:32I guess it did actually allow them to sort of block
1:40:36that sort of thing where they could tell,
1:40:37"Hey, this phone's collected free rides twice already.
1:40:39Forget it."
1:40:40- And Uber's not the kind of company
1:40:42that lets regulations get in the way
1:40:43of them doing business.
1:40:45- Right.
1:40:45So the basic story, and again,
1:40:49this certainly did not seem to come from Apple's side
1:40:53that seemed to more likely come from somebody on Uber's side.
1:40:58But the gist was that Tim Cook supposedly told them, hey,
1:41:01so knock it off.
1:41:02And they did.
1:41:03Oh, and the other thing that they had
1:41:04was that they somehow knew that Apple might
1:41:06look at this in app review.
1:41:08And they put, at Kalanick's request,
1:41:10put a geofence around Apple's campus
1:41:12so that when the Uber app was running
1:41:15within x distance of Cupertino, it
1:41:18wouldn't do the fingerprinting.
1:41:21- It's remarkable to me that a company
1:41:23that is based on such geolocation technology
1:41:26would not think about Apple having other offices.
1:41:29Like, "Whoa, Sunnyvale, what are they doing?
1:41:31"Oh, San Francisco, what's happening with Uber?
1:41:33"Boston, what's going on here?"
1:41:34I don't know if it's hubris or naivete
1:41:38or some mixture of both.
1:41:40- Well, both, but I think hubris, largely an arrogance.
1:41:43And the outrage on Twitter,
1:41:45and in a moral sense it was correct,
1:41:47was why in the world does Uber,
1:41:50Just Tim Cook give Uber a hey, knock it off,
1:41:53slap on the wrist and give them a chance
1:41:57to just remove this and stay in the app store
1:41:59when other apps, again,
1:42:04if me and you jointly together make an app
1:42:07or put a new version of Vesper out
1:42:10and it tags and identifies phones,
1:42:12they're just gonna kick the app out of the app store.
1:42:15I get it.
1:42:18I see that in a certain moral sense,
1:42:23I see the argument there, or justice sense,
1:42:26that it doesn't seem fair that a small guy would get kicked
1:42:28out and a big company, let alone a big company full of jerks
1:42:32like Uber, gets to stay in.
1:42:35But that's the way the world works, right?
1:42:37Uber has more stature because it's a super popular app
1:42:43that iPhone users use.
1:42:44And in some ways, yes, it's up, you know,
1:42:47Apple's doing the right thing by making,
1:42:49identifying this and making it stop.
1:42:51But our iPhone users as a whole,
1:42:56all, you know, however many, 100 million of them there are,
1:42:59happier or sadder if Uber is literally
1:43:02kicked out of the App Store.
1:43:04- Yeah, and Apple has to be, I mean,
1:43:05it's the same thing, discussion we had with Facebook earlier
1:43:07where Apple has to be pragmatic about these things.
1:43:09They have a certain amount of,
1:43:11you have to weight these things.
1:43:12They can't all be done on a strict black and white scale
1:43:13because that sounds great in the abstract,
1:43:15but doesn't work in life.
1:43:17And we make those decisions all the time.
1:43:18We, as much as we'll be upset
1:43:20that Apple's not doing things fairly or morally,
1:43:22we have the same problem when we're dealing with our client
1:43:24or the same issues when we're dealing
1:43:25with different people in our lives.
1:43:26It's that these companies are all not, they're not equal.
1:43:29They're companies which Apple has beholden.
1:43:31They're companies which Apple has absolutely no interest in.
1:43:33And they're companies where maybe Uber is like this,
1:43:35where they sort of both need each other.
1:43:37And it would be devastating for Uber to be off of the iPhone
1:43:40but it would hurt Apple considerably
1:43:41to have Uber off the iPhone as well.
1:43:43- Yeah, I think, and I don't know,
1:43:46I don't know the backstory on this.
1:43:47I don't even know how much of it is technically,
1:43:49exactly what happened.
1:43:50It's all from this one Mike Isaac story
1:43:52and doesn't seem like anybody's gotten a followup.
1:43:54But what I would have liked to have seen
1:43:56is not for Apple to have kicked Uber out of the store.
1:43:59I really, from a pragmatic standpoint,
1:44:00I understand why that, you know.
1:44:03I mean, I think it might have happened
1:44:05if Kyle and the kid said to Tim Cook,
1:44:07"Screw you, we're gonna keep doing it."
1:44:09I mean, there's a certain, you know,
1:44:10all right, you get called into the principal
1:44:12and maybe the principal gives you another chance,
1:44:14but you can't give the principal the finger, right?
1:44:17- Yeah.
1:44:18- But I think what Apple,
1:44:20what I would have liked to have seen them do,
1:44:21if everything that we know about this,
1:44:23we think we know about this story is true,
1:44:25is I think that they should have made Uber disclose
1:44:28what they'd been doing in exact detail,
1:44:31and say here's the information
1:44:32we were collecting about phones,
1:44:34here's how we did it,
1:44:35and you have our word that we've deleted our database
1:44:39of these identifiers.
1:44:41- Yeah, I mean it's-- - And if they refuse,
1:44:42then I think Apple should have disclosed it.
1:44:45The part that doesn't sit right with me from what Apple did
1:44:49is that Apple knew that they were doing this.
1:44:51They knew that their customers had had their phones
1:44:53fingerprinted by Uber, and Apple was apparently
1:44:58willing to let that go unknown.
1:45:03I mean, there's a chance that maybe Apple did do something,
1:45:06which is that maybe Apple-- somebody at Apple
1:45:08was the source for Mike Isaac for that story,
1:45:11And that by leaking that, that was their way of disclosing
1:45:14that that's what Uber had done.
1:45:16But I would have liked to have seen them do it
1:45:19in a way that's on the record.
1:45:20Even if it was Apple, somebody at Apple
1:45:22who was the anonymous source for that,
1:45:24I still think that there should have been
1:45:26some sort of official acknowledgement that this went on.
1:45:28Even though I don't think it was all that gross
1:45:30of a privacy violation
1:45:32in the grand scheme of privacy violations.
1:45:34- Yeah, so I think if Uber had been
1:45:36literally tracking people,
1:45:38I think it would have forced a much greater response
1:45:41Apple or a much more public response from Apple because there's some offenses that are just so
1:45:45egregious that there's no other alternative. But this to me is, and again, this is a horrible
1:45:49analogy, but if Grenada does something the US doesn't like, they can literally just drop in,
1:45:53take over the airport and do whatever they want. It doesn't work in Moscow.
1:45:56Right. Right. It is- Because there's mutually assured destruction there.
1:45:59Right. Well, and maybe there's other countries that are bigger that wouldn't be mutually assured
1:46:04destruction. Like London. You can't just take the London airport.
1:46:08Right.
1:46:09Well, pick a country without nukes.
1:46:10But Australia, let's say.
1:46:13Yeah, OK, Sydney.
1:46:14I don't know.
1:46:15Because our relations with Sydney,
1:46:17I don't know if you've heard, they're a little rocky.
1:46:21But yeah, it's not a bad analogy.
1:46:24Grenada's a little different than bigger countries.
1:46:30I just feel like they should have figured that out.
1:46:32No, I agree with you.
1:46:32Now, in the old days, the funny part
1:46:34is in the old days, in the innocent days of iOS,
1:46:38It's just funny because I think it's hard for people who work
1:46:44at Apple to even think from the perspective of these ad
1:46:47networks that want to do all this tracking and stuff.
1:46:49But in the old days, there were APIs, official APIs,
1:46:52not like private APIs.
1:46:53But the idea that you might want to uniquely identify a phone
1:46:57was like a feature.
1:46:58And it was only once that started
1:47:00getting abused by ad networks in privacy invasive ways
1:47:03that Apple deprecated and then removed those APIs.
1:47:06Yeah, you could just take the UDID, right, and share it, I think, as you wanted to.
1:47:10Right, like when you plug your phone into iTunes, iTunes can still see it. You see there's
1:47:14a unique device identifier. I think it's printed on the back of the phone still in that small
1:47:19print? I can't read it. It's too small for iOS. But they used to sometimes, on some models,
1:47:24they would print it on. But you can go to the settings screen in iOS and get the UDID.
1:47:31You can get the MAC address. In other words, each Ethernet port in the world has a unique
1:47:35Mac address that can uniquely identify a device. I mean, I remember in the old days when that first
1:47:42started being used and it wasn't all that reliable because people building their own PCs would take
1:47:48the Ethernet, it was a card that you could take out. And so you couldn't necessarily associate
1:47:56the Ethernet ID, the Mac ID with a device, but obviously nobody is changing the Mac ID of an
1:48:01iPhone. There were all sorts of ways to uniquely identify a device that were
1:48:05officially supported, and Apple's one-by-one eliminated them all. But it's,
1:48:11you know, it's obvious to anybody when Apple eliminated those things that
1:48:15figuring out a way around it to still get a unique identifier on an iPhone was
1:48:19contrary to Apple's intentions. Like, this is not a loophole. This was a direct
1:48:25circumvention, you know, of a locked door. You know, I mean, somebody leaves a door
1:48:31unlocked and you go in, you can maybe argue, "I didn't know I wasn't supposed to go in.
1:48:34The door wasn't locked."
1:48:35If you get to a door and it's locked, but you figure out a way to unlock it, you have
1:48:40no excuse.
1:48:41Yeah, no, totally.
1:48:42And again, Uber is famous.
1:48:44Sometimes they've been applauded for their pugnacious combative, "Do what you want to
1:48:50do.
1:48:51Don't ask for permission."
1:48:53And this is the flip side of that.
1:48:57The other thing that rolled out of this story was sort of an aside in this Mike Isaac story
1:49:04about Uber and this collection of data, was that Uber had one of the other things, the
1:49:10greatest hits of all the shady stuff that they've done, but that they paid money to
1:49:14a company called Unroll Me.
1:49:18Or no, I guess it was the parent company of Unroll Me, and they slice analytics.
1:49:23And that's a company that's come up before in iPhone and Apple-related products, where
1:49:27Slice is this company that claims to have, and does have, access to people's inboxes
1:49:33because they offer these services where they let people sign up and get some kind of rewards
1:49:39in exchange for Slice getting to see their incoming email.
1:49:42Which, again, sounds crazy to me, but some people have different...
1:49:52People do not see the value of their data the way they see the value of their cash or
1:49:57their time despite the fact that these companies will spend unlimited amounts of time and money
1:50:01just to get your data.
1:50:02Well, Slice has come up before where they've used this data to come out and make projections
1:50:06about what iPhones people have bought and how it compares you over a year because their
1:50:10customers last year got so many iPhone receipts in their email in the first 72 hours since
1:50:16it went on sale and this year it's this and that.
1:50:19And so my mention of them previously is, I don't really--
1:50:22it's interesting.
1:50:23I don't think it's complete noise,
1:50:25but I don't trust data when it only
1:50:27comes from people who've signed up for a service that lets
1:50:30internet marketing firm read all of your email.
1:50:33But they bought a company called Unroll Me
1:50:37that offers a service that, again, you
1:50:39filter all your email through them,
1:50:40and they make it easy to unsubscribe from things
1:50:45you can unsubscribe to or to put all of your, not spam, but newsletter type things that
1:50:54would have an unsubscribe me link at the bottom.
1:50:56Put them all together in a folder or collapse them or something like that.
1:51:01And these bastards, it turns out, were then selling it.
1:51:04So they sold information to Uber that using their access to these people inboxes gave
1:51:10you know, Uber bought like all of the Lyft receipts from these people. Supposedly anonymized,
1:51:15but like I wrote on Daring Fireball, well supposedly, you know, an iPhone that you do
1:51:20a factory reset on is anonymized too, and Uber was tracking that.
1:51:24Yes. Yeah, you can't trust them.
1:51:28There's all sorts of ways that they could, you know, backwards correlate, you know, even
1:51:32somewhat. Anyway, I think a lot of people, and a lot of people were rightly like, "Whoa,
1:51:36I use this on Romy.
1:51:38There's absolutely no way that I thought that something like my Lyft receipt would be sold
1:51:42to Uber.
1:51:43Ben
1:51:50There's a bunch of apps that you can just give permission.
1:51:52I remember when I signed up for TripIt, I would just forward them an email with my travel
1:51:56information.
1:51:57They said, "Why are you going to this trouble?
1:51:58Just give us access to your Gmail."
1:51:59I said, "No."
1:52:00Eventually, I stopped using Gmail because there's just so many services that want to
1:52:04tie into it.
1:52:05That's not exactly an equivalency, but I just don't want to provide access to that stuff
1:52:09because there's so much information in there.
1:52:11And mine is all just a business email.
1:52:12It's all just a bunch of travel stuff.
1:52:14But that data is incredibly valuable to me, and they're not really making a fair purchase
1:52:20decision there.
1:52:21Dave Asprey So the CEO and founder of this company, Joe
1:52:25Heday, in the day after this came out, he wrote a blog post where he said, "Our users
1:52:33are the heart of our company and service,
1:52:34so it was heartbreaking to see that some of our users
1:52:37were upset to learn about how we monetize our free service.
1:52:40And while we try our best to be open about our business
1:52:43model, recent customer feedback tells me
1:52:45we weren't explicit enough.
1:52:47And it really-- again, if you read their terms of service,
1:52:51yes, it was in there in certain words.
1:52:54But people don't read the terms of service,
1:52:56and everybody knows they don't.
1:52:57And there was certainly no bullet point in the main,
1:52:59like, hey, why you should sign up for this service?
1:53:03Here's how we make money.
1:53:04And I think what it is is that people who haven't--
1:53:08because they don't think like this.
1:53:09Good, honest people who just don't
1:53:11think that someone would do something like this
1:53:13hear about the service.
1:53:14They know that their inbox every day, that 2/3 of it
1:53:17isn't spam, but also isn't the most important stuff.
1:53:21And so something that could help organize that
1:53:23so that the actual email from colleagues or family or friends
1:53:27is all there organized.
1:53:28sounds like a good deal, signs up for it.
1:53:32And even if you say, well, you know,
1:53:33you're giving them access to your email,
1:53:34they might think, ah, you know, I don't really care.
1:53:36There's nothing in there that I care about.
1:53:38But then later on, you tell them, you know,
1:53:40I know exactly what you bought your husband
1:53:42for Father's Day last year.
1:53:44What? - Yeah.
1:53:45- Yeah, you bought him this,
1:53:46and because we have your email.
1:53:48And it's like, all of a sudden,
1:53:49you tell them an example like that,
1:53:51or you tell them, yeah, yeah, they, you know,
1:53:54those four times you got a Lyft,
1:53:56yeah, we sent those to Uber.
1:53:57- Well, they knew when you were out of that.
1:53:58we knew you were traveling, you were out of the house.
1:54:00Nobody was at your home.
1:54:01I mean it's, and this is not new.
1:54:02I remember 10 years ago, 15 years ago,
1:54:06for example, if you go to 7-Eleven and buy a Coke,
1:54:08Coke has no idea you bought it, but 7-Eleven does,
1:54:10and they'll sell that information back to Coke,
1:54:12but they'll also sell it to Pepsi for competitive analysis,
1:54:14and to like Lay's potato chips, so they can say,
1:54:16"We wanna be positioned next to Coke on the shelf,
1:54:19"not next to Pepsi."
1:54:20And you think that it's anonymous, but it's not,
1:54:22because they could figure out,
1:54:23based on one unique identifier, one phone number, one time,
1:54:26or one email address, or something,
1:54:28that you were the person buying the diapers and the beer
1:54:30at that supermarket that day.
1:54:32- Anyway, I wrote about this.
1:54:33Give me a fucking break that they're heartbroken
1:54:35that their user's upset.
1:54:36They're not upset.
1:54:37If they knew their users would be upset,
1:54:38which is why they hid exactly what they're doing
1:54:41in the small print of the terms of service.
1:54:43They're upset because they're suddenly the focus
1:54:46of a massive spotlight of a story
1:54:48that every reasonable person would say,
1:54:50"Wow, that is outrageous and is offensive
1:54:52"and I wouldn't use that service,"
1:54:54which was obviously gonna hurt their brand
1:54:56and make people,
1:54:57I never even heard of this on Roll Me before.
1:54:59So the first time I heard of it was
1:55:01in the context of don't sign up for this thing.
1:55:04Why don't people use it?
1:55:05And they were shocked.
1:55:06Right.
1:55:07Like if you think in the back of your mind
1:55:09that signing up for a free service that
1:55:11can read and index all of your email is a bad idea,
1:55:14guess what?
1:55:15It is.
1:55:16They were heartbroken.
1:55:17They got caught.
1:55:17I think you said that well.
1:55:19Right.
1:55:19And there was somebody on Hacker News
1:55:23who posted that he worked for a company that
1:55:26was thinking about acquiring them,
1:55:27and when they did their due diligence,
1:55:29that Unroll.me was literally keeping an archive
1:55:32of every single email, of every single email
1:55:36that all of their customers ever got
1:55:37since they signed up for the service.
1:55:39- Yeah, calling. - And that they were just
1:55:41sort of served in a scary fashion in Amazon AWS buckets.
1:55:45- Yeah, and that's part of the problem here,
1:55:46is those buckets could be hacked,
1:55:48it could be an employee decides
1:55:49to abuse the information contained in there.
1:55:50When there's extra copies of your stuff hanging around,
1:55:52you no longer have control over that information.
1:55:54- Yeah.
1:55:55What else we have? I got this Hulu Live. They've shipped a new live TV thing, a $40 a month
1:56:01cable cutter package. Did you see this? It just came out today.
1:56:04I did. I'm jealous. There's all these great services in the US I just simply don't have
1:56:07access to.
1:56:08And you guys have none of that in Canada?
1:56:10No. We allow our telcos to own our broadcasters. So we have Bell and Rogers who own those things,
1:56:16and they don't want to give it to us.
1:56:18So I looked into this recently,
1:56:20'cause I had to switch, we moved,
1:56:25so I had to get new cable service
1:56:27and internet service and stuff.
1:56:28And at first, 'cause we're a TiVo family,
1:56:32we've always been a TiVo family,
1:56:33and I couldn't get, and this always happens,
1:56:35this has happened to me for 10 years,
1:56:36every time I've tried changing
1:56:38or getting a new TiVo or something like that.
1:56:40The cable card thing doesn't work.
1:56:42There's like a card, and it's,
1:56:44I guess the idea is that they try
1:56:47make this super secure. It's the way that they can get the security of the cable signal
1:56:51on a device they don't own. Part of it, I think, is just that they want you to buy their
1:56:56stupid box, their box. I don't want their box. I want TiVo. But we had a hassle getting
1:57:02our TiVo working. I looked into these services for the first time seriously, because I don't
1:57:08watch a lot of TV or cable TV, but my wife does.
1:57:15I looked at the PlayStation Vue service, and it looks great.
1:57:19I think it's like $30 a month or $40 a month.
1:57:21I don't know, but it's a reasonable price
1:57:23compared to cable.
1:57:25And I looked at the list of channels they had,
1:57:27and I couldn't find any channels missing that I ever watch.
1:57:31And I asked Amy to look, and as far as she could tell,
1:57:34they had all the channels that she watches.
1:57:37It varies by city here in the US, but in Philadelphia,
1:57:41You get ABC, all the major networks, not just the cable networks.
1:57:45You get the broadcast networks.
1:57:48Apparently in some cities, the PlayStation View misses something.
1:57:51But honestly, just because I don't watch a lot of TV and I'm happy with the TiVo and
1:57:59for what I do watch, and when I watch on my TV, I'm using Apple TV usually, I just hadn't
1:58:06been paying attention.
1:58:07I know the phrase cable cutting.
1:58:08I know what it means.
1:58:09I wasn't aware that when you sign up for something like this, just how much it's equivalent to having
1:58:15cable TV in terms of what you get per month. You know, that it's the same channels and content,
1:58:20it's just delivered in a different fashion.
1:58:22And so Hulu's getting into it now.
1:58:25But it's weird, like Hulu, like one of the networks that they don't get is AMC, and there's a couple of good shows on AMC.
1:58:31And I don't understand, you know, what the, how that, you know, obviously,
1:58:38I guess it's all negotiations, but somehow Hulu doesn't have AMC.
1:58:43My question for you is, where's Apple in this?
1:58:45Because I feel like this PlayStation view thing is so much exactly like what we've
1:58:51been hearing Apple might do.
1:58:55What the heck do you think is going on?
1:58:56Yeah, and it's especially frustrating because one of the reasons that we kept hearing that
1:58:59the Apple TV, who didn't launch earlier, is that they were working on these over-the-top
1:59:03services or originally an Apple video version of what Apple Music was, where you'd pay
1:59:07one price $30 and you have access to all the major channels and then the
1:59:11negotiations broke down and then we heard that again they become like a set
1:59:13top box sort of thing and those broke down and it sort of reminds me of music
1:59:18when it went DRM free they just didn't give it to Apple it was DRM free on
1:59:21Amazon mp3 first and they wanted to break Apple's hold on the music industry
1:59:26and that was one of the levers they tried to pull and then eventually it
1:59:28broke down and Apple got DRM free mp3 music like everybody else and I wonder
1:59:33if there's still this sort of feeling in the entertainment industry that Apple
1:59:37Apple destroyed their music business.
1:59:39And they'll be damned if they let Apple
1:59:40destroy their video business.
1:59:41And it ends up being not an advantage to Apple
1:59:43that they did iTunes, they did Apple Music,
1:59:45but a disadvantage.
1:59:46And now these companies are more reticent
1:59:48to give Apple this product.
1:59:49And they wanna make sure they seed the market
1:59:51with a lot of active competitors
1:59:52before they agree to terms with Apple.
1:59:54- Yeah, I think that that might be it.
1:59:56I really do, that Apple is having a much harder time
1:59:58negotiating just because of exactly what you said.
2:00:01And it has nothing really to do about dollar amounts,
2:00:03but just sort of a vague notion
2:00:05that the entertainment industry feels like Apple
2:00:07picked their pocket last time.
2:00:09Even though I don't think there's any aspect of it
2:00:11that wasn't above the board, I just think that they,
2:00:14I think basically they thought when they first
2:00:16allowed Apple to create the iTunes Store
2:00:19that Apple has had this reputation as a niche player.
2:00:22And the iPod at the time was a Mac only device,
2:00:27and so it limited, even if it was wildly successful
2:00:30among all the people who could get an iPod, got an iPod,
2:00:32it still wasn't that big of a market,
2:00:34because it would only be one to one
2:00:35a number of people who have a Mac, and that they just never foresaw that Apple—and even
2:00:41people who don't pay close attention to the computer industry—had the basic, rough
2:00:46outline of a sketch where Apple was this little, tiny California company that was like a 99-to-1
2:00:53dwarf compared to Microsoft and Windows and PCs.
2:00:57No, I think that's it entirely.
2:00:59And there was that famous quote—and I know you referenced this recently in the Netflix
2:01:01article where Steve Jobs said your competition is free and it's piracy and
2:01:06it's theft and it was Napster and we just saw that's with Netflix where
2:01:09Orange is the New Black was essentially stolen and held for ransom but the the
2:01:13privacy like the piracy rates for Netflix are extremely low because the
2:01:17service is so popular but also so reasonably priced. Right and so
2:01:21reasonably policed in terms of like sharing you know that you're you know
2:01:26your kid goes to college and still has the family Netflix password so what they
2:01:31They don't care.
2:01:32They don't care if your kid's going to University of Michigan and your family lives
2:01:36in Philadelphia and they do the geolocation on IP and they know that.
2:01:42They don't care.
2:01:43I'm sure that there's some kickoff where at a certain X number of people using the
2:01:48same Netflix account, it automatically triggers something.
2:01:52But if that number is reasonable, they don't care.
2:01:54They feel like…
2:01:55And it's so reasonable.
2:01:56I actually had a family member who was using my account when they were staying with me
2:01:58and they went and got their own place.
2:01:59And they used my account for a little while,
2:02:02I think a month, but then they got their own
2:02:03because it was so reasonably priced,
2:02:05they just didn't want to be bound to my,
2:02:06like they didn't want to see the same things
2:02:08that I was watching all the time.
2:02:09Sorry.
2:02:11- I just feel like you cannot overstate
2:02:13how important that is to Netflix's runaway success,
2:02:18their generosity in terms of,
2:02:21or not generosity, but relaxedness of this.
2:02:23- It's almost like a pragmatism.
2:02:25- Right, compare and contrast with the Comcast attitude
2:02:28with these cable cards in the TiVo,
2:02:29where literally an actual service person
2:02:32came to the house twice and failed to get one
2:02:35to actually work and register.
2:02:37- They treat you like a criminal, not like a customer.
2:02:39- Well, they were very nice to me.
2:02:42It's just that they've set up the technology.
2:02:43The service people were super nice,
2:02:45but that the technology is designed from a perspective
2:02:48to be super, super persnickety in terms of this.
2:02:52And the only logic behind it is that they're fearful
2:02:54that I'm gonna pop the cable card out of my TiVo
2:02:57and go to your house and put it in your TiVo
2:02:59and watch Game of Thrones one Sunday night
2:03:02for free at your house.
2:03:03- Or hook it up to a computer
2:03:04and get their high quality stream of Star Wars
2:03:06and put it up on the internet.
2:03:08- Whatever, it's crazy.
2:03:09But the Netflix style has proven,
2:03:11and their runaway success in every regard shows that.
2:03:15- Well, it's like iTunes,
2:03:15and instead of assuming that you're someone
2:03:17who wants to rip them off,
2:03:19they assume that you're a customer who wants to be good
2:03:21and they give you a product that engenders that.
2:03:22- Right, and so it's very interesting to me
2:03:24to see that the BitTorrent rates
2:03:26for all this stuff has actually gone down.
2:03:29- Yeah.
2:03:30- And that a lot of what is left,
2:03:33it seems to be attributable to content
2:03:35that's not available in certain places.
2:03:37So like Game of Thrones in particular is probably,
2:03:41I think, I don't even think there's a question,
2:03:42it's the most pirated content on BitTorrent.
2:03:45But-- - And apparently Travelers,
2:03:47because a lot of the stuff was stream only for a long time
2:03:49and they just wanted to have it with them on a plane or something.
2:03:51- A huge part of that though is the parts around the world
2:03:54where Game of Thrones isn't even legally available.
2:03:56So it's pretty interesting.
2:03:58And I do think that there is a huge convenience
2:04:00factor on that.
2:04:00I mean, part of it for me is that-- I do.
2:04:04I know there's some people who pirate all sorts of stuff
2:04:08and don't think twice about it.
2:04:09But when I was younger, I did.
2:04:11I had pirated copies of Photoshop
2:04:14when I was in college because what was I going to do?
2:04:17Spend $600 for Photoshop?
2:04:18No.
2:04:20But I stopped pirating stuff as soon
2:04:22as I could afford to buy stuff.
2:04:25'cause I knew it was wrong, I just, you know, I don't know.
2:04:29So there is a, honestly, I'm not trying to make anybody
2:04:31feel bad, but I do, I don't know.
2:04:33And I create, you know, partly I'm biased,
2:04:35I create content, I happen to give my stuff away,
2:04:37but in theory, I can imagine selling it,
2:04:42and it would not make me happy if people were
2:04:45bootlegging it.
2:04:49- Well, you still want them to go to Daring Firewall
2:04:50to get it, you don't want someone else
2:04:51that's reproducing your entire website
2:04:52on Google for other websites.
2:04:54Exactly, perfect example.
2:04:55Right.
2:04:56You know, as a content creator, I might be more sympathetic, but it just seems like it's
2:05:01the right thing to do.
2:05:02But also, even just putting the morals of it behind, as a lazy person, the BitTorrent
2:05:07thing just seems like so much work.
2:05:09Oh my god, it's just like, how can you bother?
2:05:12And you can get malware and all sorts of things.
2:05:14Yeah, just, and it's these crazy file formats and part one, part two, part three, and you
2:05:20got to stitch them together and all.
2:05:22What the hell?
2:05:23I honest to God I really and you know, I just want to talk to the microphone and say put the Godfather part 2 on
2:05:29Yes, I really do and yeah spins for a little bit and then I'd hit a button and it starts playing. Yeah
2:05:35No, it's totally
2:05:37So I can't do it. All right
2:05:39Anything else you want to talk about?
2:05:41No, I mean I think we hit on all the major points now
2:05:45That was that that minor flare up again and in Apple's role in App Store and and indie apps
2:05:49But that's what was that a new argument?
2:05:52Well, Apple put out their job creation, and they often tout how many iOS developers they've
2:05:59empowered to this.
2:06:00So Matt Gamble put up a post saying that Apple, you know, and he also mentioned consumers
2:06:04and developers and everything, once again, but the App Store was responsible for devaluing
2:06:08software.
2:06:09Yeah, I saw that, and I was nodding my head the whole time, but I didn't see anything
2:06:16as new, and I don't know.
2:06:17I mean, there is something to be said there, and I sort of agree with it.
2:06:23I don't know, though, that anything has actually changed in that regard.
2:06:26No, I wrote about it earlier today because I talked to a lot of our developer friends
2:06:29and a lot of people who are involved in the industry, and there's sort of this consensus
2:06:33that—and I think this is true—that it sort of hit traditional software developers
2:06:37hard because they thought that they were the new thing, but they turned out to be traditional
2:06:41in every sense of the word, and that's just as open to disruption as any industry.
2:06:44And we no longer live in an age where only a few people
2:06:47have computers and you spend $500 for WordStar
2:06:49and there's a box of software on the shelf
2:06:51and all of those things are true.
2:06:53We now have, almost everyone has access
2:06:54to ubiquitously connected computing devices
2:06:58thanks to the smartphone and what we perceive of as apps
2:07:01is incredibly different.
2:07:02There's millions of apps and no one's gonna spend
2:07:04$30 to $40 for a thousand apps a year.
2:07:06It's just, it's not possible.
2:07:08And the same token, no one's gonna spend $500 on WordStar
2:07:11now that Google Docs is in every browser.
2:07:13So the entire industry is turned upside down.
2:07:15And I think the app store may have hastened that,
2:07:17but I think it's more a reflection
2:07:19of where the industry went,
2:07:20not a single-handed, dastardly villain sort of a thing.
2:07:24- Right, but you know, people,
2:07:27tens and hundreds, maybe thousands of people
2:07:30are spending 10, $15 a week on Clash of Clans
2:07:33and Candy Crush. - Candy Crush, yeah.
2:07:36- End game upgrades, and then somebody like TapBots,
2:07:40puts exquisite, a year-long exquisite work into a Twitter client and wants to charge
2:07:46$4 for the upgrade from the old one, and the same people are outraged. So I get it. I get
2:07:52it.
2:07:53Yeah, I mean, it's traditional. We will pay for ego and instant gratification. That's
2:07:55why tulips were worth our fortune. It made no sense, but we wanted to have more tulips
2:07:58than our friends had.
2:07:59Right. It's like a Twitter client could make—a for-pay Twitter client could make
2:08:04more money by locking you out of features than by just charging up front.
2:08:09Yeah, no, it's absolutely true. It's just I think it's a far bigger
2:08:13Movement than an app store can account for it's just the if the guy English said this really well a couple years ago
2:08:19It's we've gotten to a pop culture for apps. It took longer to get there than it did for other mediums, but it still got there
2:08:25Yeah
2:08:26I know it's just a small thing
2:08:28It's just a small thing but I and it's funny because it actually popped into my head yesterday after you agreed to be on the show
2:08:34but I keep
2:08:37an Apple note, an iCloud note,
2:08:40with the list of all the episodes of the talk show
2:08:42and who's been on them and the episode number
2:08:43just so I have it to reference.
2:08:45And I type, like, you know, this episode
2:08:50that we're doing right now is episode 189.
2:08:52And then I type tab, and then I type berna-richie.
2:08:55And then I might put in parentheses, you know,
2:08:56just like the basic topics, you know, of what we did.
2:08:59And then it's there, and I can look back to it in the past.
2:09:01But I was doing it on my phone, and I can't type a tab.
2:09:05I have to type a space.
2:09:06And then I go on-- later on, I'll open it up on my Mac
2:09:10and replace the space with a tab.
2:09:12And I want to do that because I'm a picky, picky person.
2:09:17But San Francisco, the font that Apple Notes uses now,
2:09:22doesn't have proportionate numbers.
2:09:25So in other words, in a lot of fonts, especially older
2:09:28digital fonts, they would make-- even if the font itself was not
2:09:31a monospace font like Courier, the numbers
2:09:35are so that if you type 111 and then 444 underneath it,
2:09:40the numbers line up.
2:09:41The number one is just as wide as the number four.
2:09:46San Francisco isn't like that.
2:09:47It's a non-proportionate font.
2:09:49So the ones in particular are narrower
2:09:51than the other numbers.
2:09:52And so if I use the space, if I type the episode number
2:09:55and the space and then your name,
2:09:57then the names don't line up.
2:09:58And that bothers me.
2:09:59So I type a tab.
2:10:01But I can't type the tab on my iPhone.
2:10:03And that seems like a bizarre oversight in 2017.
2:10:08And it just hits me with,
2:10:10if it's the ongoing debate over,
2:10:12can you, you know, is there a need for a Mac,
2:10:14can you do all your work on iOS?
2:10:16Well hell, you can't even type a tab on the iPhone.
2:10:18- No, it's very true.
2:10:20I mean, there's just, there doesn't seem to me like
2:10:23there's any reason why the basic actually characters
2:10:25not be available on an iPhone.
2:10:26I mean, especially not in 2017.
2:10:28- I think, here's my suggestion,
2:10:30anybody at Apple who's listening.
2:10:31I would suggest it be a little pop-up on the space bar.
2:10:36Tap and hold on the space bar.
2:10:37Make tab if you're looking for a place to put it.
2:10:40But the Mac, here's the thing.
2:10:44The Mac had a way to type all of these extended characters
2:10:49in, I think, right in 1984.
2:10:51And if it wasn't, it was certainly there by '85 or '86.
2:10:54And they're great.
2:10:55They're so brilliant.
2:10:57One of the little ways that the Mac has always
2:10:59been so much better than DOS and Windows,
2:11:01where if you wanted to type an em dash,
2:11:04not only was it pretty easy to do it,
2:11:07but there's actually a really clever
2:11:09mnemonic to the shortcut.
2:11:11It's option shift hyphen.
2:11:13Well, hyphen is like a dash,
2:11:15and a shift makes it bigger.
2:11:17So option dash would give you like the little mini dash,
2:11:22like the end dash,
2:11:23and option shift dash would give you the bigger one,
2:11:26because shift is bigger and you get the dash.
2:11:30Option eight gives you a bullet character because eight is the character with the asterisk which is sort of the ASCII bullet character
2:11:38Option zero is the degree symbol for temperatures
2:11:41No, is it I thought it's option shift 8 is the degree not sorry the the bullet
2:11:49I think is option shift 8 and then the higher one the degree characters
2:11:51Yeah shift zero, but it's all well considered like the it's where you would assume that the character would be right
2:11:58How do you type the upside down exclamation mark you type option one?
2:12:02Because that's where the exclamation mark is so brilliant whereas in Windows. It was like all to one three six
2:12:08It gives you yes, you know a pound sign or whatever
2:12:11like the British pound
2:12:13Crazy like no logic to it at all. It's just some arbitrary numeric mapping
2:12:19The Mac had it. It's brilliant. It's been there forever. How do you type the pi pi character?
2:12:24You know like three point one four one five nine that I don't know option P. Oh, yeah nice option shift
2:12:31P gives you a capital pie
2:12:33It's an option slash gives you the percentage
2:12:35Yeah, it's there's so many. There's so new there's and there's just so cleverly
2:12:41Assigned and they've been like that for over 30 years and yet on iOS you can't type half of those characters at all and you know
2:12:49And I don't understand why that's not your keyboard team friends and while they're doing that
2:12:53I'm going to say this completely unabashedly.
2:12:55Let me long press on the french fries to get poutine tater tots and hash browns.
2:13:00I support that wholeheartedly.
2:13:04Someone has to do it.
2:13:05I'm just, I mean, I'm going down memory lane here, but I know, I don't even have to think.
2:13:11I typed these without even thinking.
2:13:13So I just had to double check to be sure, but you can type option semicolon and you
2:13:17get an ellipse.
2:13:18It's, I guess that one's not super mnemonic, but anyway.
2:13:22Anyway, that's my complaint.
2:13:24I want someone at Apple to let me type a tab character
2:13:26on my phone.
2:13:27Anything else?
2:13:31- Not that comes to mind.
2:13:34- René, I thank you for your time.
2:13:35Hope you have a good weekend.
2:13:36- Thank you so much. - I will see you soon
2:13:37and I'm looking forward to it.
2:13:38I'll see you a month from now.
2:13:39We'll be palling around at the keynote.
2:13:42- Yeah, I can't wait.
2:13:43It should be a good year.
2:13:44- Yeah, so it's very nice to sign off
2:13:48and say I'll see you soon, but I'll see you soon.
2:13:49My thanks to our sponsors.
2:13:50sponsors this week were, let me see if I can do it off the top of my head, we had Squarespace,
2:13:54that's the place to go to build a website. We had Casper, where you go to get a mattress.
2:14:00Who was our third sponsor? I forget the third sponsor. Third sponsor was, oh of course it
2:14:05was Audible. That's the place with an unmatched selection of audio. Alright, Rene, thank you.