Podcast Search

The Talk Show

188: ‘Apple VP Lisa Jackson’

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Hey there, it's me, John Gruber, host of the talk show.

0:00:04And I'm here to do a little introduction

0:00:06for what is a very special episode.

0:00:09I have an interview with Lisa Jackson,

0:00:12Vice President at Apple of Environment Policy.

0:00:16Pretty much everything Apple does

0:00:17with regard to the environment.

0:00:18I think it went great.

0:00:20I think it was a fascinating interview.

0:00:21She's super smart, super funny.

0:00:23We talked for about an hour.

0:00:25And it is interruption free.

0:00:26Once I get going with Lisa,

0:00:29It's just going to go straight through.

0:00:30It's just under an hour.

0:00:32And how is that possible?

0:00:33It's made possible because we've made a deal

0:00:34to have an exclusive sponsor for this episode.

0:00:38I'm going to tell you about them right now.

0:00:40Give me a minute of your time to tell you

0:00:41about Circle with Disney.

0:00:44Circle with Disney is a beautiful little device

0:00:47designed for families to manage content and time online

0:00:51for the kids and the whole family.

0:00:53It lets you, it's not about controlling everything

0:00:56your kid does on the internet,

0:00:58But it's about giving you, the parent, some sort of say

0:01:01in what they do online, how long they spend,

0:01:03and when they do it.

0:01:05What can it do?

0:01:05It lets parents filter content, customizing what's available

0:01:08and what's filtered by app, platform, and category.

0:01:11You can set time limits for things like YouTube, Minecraft,

0:01:14Facebook, Netflix, and even Snapchat.

0:01:16If your kids are staying up too late on the internet,

0:01:19you can set bedtime for each kid and their devices.

0:01:22And they have something called Insights,

0:01:24which is sort of an analysis of what everybody in your family

0:01:27is doing online when they do it, sort of an accounting.

0:01:32So you can see just how much time your family

0:01:34is spending on the internet.

0:01:36What about 4G?

0:01:37What about LTE?

0:01:38They have a separate product called Circle Go,

0:01:41which you can install on your kid's smartphone.

0:01:43And it gives you the same sort of control over their access

0:01:46when they're on the cellular network or any other Wi-Fi

0:01:48network other than your own.

0:01:50So here's the deal.

0:01:51You buy the Circle with Disney.

0:01:52It's this little device that plugs right in to your router.

0:01:55works with just about any modern Wi-Fi router in your house.

0:01:58Could not be easier to set up, and it could not

0:02:00be easier to manage.

0:02:02This is not something that turns you, as a parent,

0:02:04into a system administrator setting up some kind

0:02:06of complicated network.

0:02:07No, it's meant for non-technical parents.

0:02:09It's total Disney style interface.

0:02:12Really great product.

0:02:13You can get it at Amazon, Best Buy, Target.

0:02:18And online, you can go to their website, meetcircle.com.

0:02:21Now, that's not like beef.

0:02:23It's not M-E-A-T. It's M-E-E-T.

0:02:24like you're meeting them meet circle calm use the code the talk show at meet

0:02:31circle calm and you'll get free shipping and $10 off your circle with Disney

0:02:36device they're a proud sponsor of the talk show they sponsored before and

0:02:39they're very much excited to be the sponsor of this show because Disney is

0:02:44very encouraged by Lisa Jackson's efforts at Apple around environmental

0:02:47policy and her work on Apple's connect ed program so they're very excited to be

0:02:53the sponsor of the show, exclusive. So my thanks to them. And then here we go, away

0:02:59with the show. So we met briefly a few weeks ago when I was on campus for the

0:03:06Mac Pro thing, and the first words out of your mouth were...

0:03:11We talked about Jekyll and baseball. You said, "How can a guy from Philly be a

0:03:17Yankees fan. That's true. That's true. I don't understand that at all. But all right, you

0:03:24can be if you want to. A Mets fan. Mets for life. Are there any Yankees fans at Apple?

0:03:29I get it from Schiller. He's a Red Sox fan. Steve Dowling, Red Sox fan. And now I found

0:03:35out you're a Mets fan. Yeah, I married into the Mets and I can't ever be without them.

0:03:40But yeah, I don't know. If they're around, maybe they're just not holding their head

0:03:44up too high these days. I'm sure they're all gonna come and find me after this airs, but they're here.

0:03:51Well, if there are any Yankees fans at Apple, you should go after Lisa Jackson. Thanks. That's all I

0:03:58need. There aren't any people in the world going after Lisa Jackson, so let's just add them to the

0:04:02list. We won't talk baseball, but so far so good for both the Yankees and Mets. They're both off

0:04:08to a good start.

0:04:09So neither of us really has anything

0:04:12to rib the other about.

0:04:14Always about the bullpen, right?

0:04:16But we'll see.

0:04:17OK.

0:04:17Well, we'll keep our fingers crossed.

0:04:19And hopefully I won't talk to you later

0:04:21if things go the wrong way.

0:04:23We are talking because this episode will

0:04:26air right before Earth Day.

0:04:29And Earth Day is big.

0:04:31Starting to do an annual celebration for Apple.

0:04:33You guys have announcements that coincide with Earth Day

0:04:37every year now.

0:04:38Yeah, that's right. It's something we started back in 2014.

0:04:44This year, I have notes here. Let me make sure I don't miss anything. By the time this

0:04:52episode airs, your 2017 Environmental Responsibility Report will be out, and you have a big announcement

0:04:59there, which is that you guys are setting a new goal, which is a closed-loop supply

0:05:05chain. Can you tell me what that means?

0:05:07- That sounds so technical.

0:05:09You know, what we've said is that,

0:05:12for years now we've said that one of our three priorities

0:05:15is to really recognize the fact that the resources

0:05:19that we use to make our products are finite,

0:05:22just by definition.

0:05:23And the world has been looking for a while at this idea

0:05:27of trying to close the loop on supply chains.

0:05:29So if you think about most supply chains,

0:05:31and ours is very complex, I'm gonna oversimplify you,

0:05:35you mine something out of the earth,

0:05:36you source it, usually it comes from the earth somehow, it's a finite resource.

0:05:41And then you manufacture, you produce it, obviously there are many, many people involved

0:05:45in the manufacture of our products.

0:05:47People use them, they buy them, they use them, that's great, hopefully they use them for

0:05:50a very long time, they get all their software upgrades, everything's wonderful, but at some

0:05:55point you have to discard it.

0:05:57And Apple spent a lot of time and effort over the years, for many years, on the recycling

0:06:03you know, being able to try to bring used electronics in and recycle them.

0:06:09But the frustrating part of that has been, you know, that's still a line.

0:06:13When it's time to make more products, many of our suppliers still go back to the mines,

0:06:18if you will, go back to the earth.

0:06:20So one of the things we've set our sights on, and I have to start by saying this is

0:06:24a very long-term goal, and it's not like us to announce goals way out into the future,

0:06:29but it's sort of a north star for us, is to start to close that loop, to say, "Can we

0:06:34use recycled material, maybe our recycled material, but recycled material in general,

0:06:40to be more of the feedstocks for our suppliers, for the components that make up our products?"

0:06:45So if you think about that for a second, it requires all of us working together.

0:06:50It's kind of a systems problem, everything from design to engineering to manufacturing

0:06:55to procurement, all those relationships with suppliers.

0:07:00But it's really something kind of cool for us.

0:07:02We've sort of worked with a lot of the folks who

0:07:05do the work here.

0:07:06And I think all of us think it's just

0:07:07a fun and really important time to focus on resources.

0:07:12What are-- you said you have-- there's

0:07:14three priorities, three main priorities at Apple

0:07:16in this regard.

0:07:17What are those three priorities?

0:07:19So they haven't changed, and I don't think they will.

0:07:21The first is to address climate change.

0:07:24And I say it really broadly that way

0:07:27because it's not to zero out our carbon footprint

0:07:31or to become carbon neutral,

0:07:33but really to look at climate change

0:07:35as a problem that the world is facing,

0:07:37really the largest environmental

0:07:38and environmental health problem

0:07:40and economic problem in many places.

0:07:42We now see it's another big systems problem.

0:07:46And so to address it,

0:07:49obviously the way to address it is energy efficiency,

0:07:52more renewable energy, cleaner energy on the grid,

0:07:55moving to a low carbon world.

0:07:58And so we take really seriously our responsibility

0:08:01to first start at home.

0:08:03Apple is 100% renewably powered in 24 countries,

0:08:08including our own, I'm sorry, is 96% renewably powered.

0:08:12I'm about to get in trouble here.

0:08:14In 24 countries, we're 100%.

0:08:17So in the US, we're 100% and 23 other countries.

0:08:21but when you average it out around the world, we're at 96%.

0:08:24And that includes our data centers, those are at 100%.

0:08:28So all of our data centers, every time you send a message

0:08:32or send a FaceTime video, you're using a data center

0:08:36that's not contributing to climate change.

0:08:39And it includes our offices, our new office, Apple Park,

0:08:42of course, being one of those.

0:08:44So 96%, we're really proud of.

0:08:48So climate change is number one.

0:08:50We talked a little bit about resources, number two.

0:08:54And our third one kind of goes back to something

0:08:57that's been in our history for a long time,

0:08:59and that's to use greener materials to remove toxic materials

0:09:04usually well ahead of the game.

0:09:07Apple removed halogenated compounds

0:09:10from our products years ago.

0:09:12And so we wanted to sort of honor this history

0:09:15that Apple has had of pioneering the use of greener,

0:09:18safer, better materials, and then keep that as one of our priorities. Because

0:09:24there's a lot of people here very proud of the work they do to accomplish, for

0:09:28example, PVC free power cords. Yes, and that's become, you can bank on it,

0:09:37a hallmark of every product introduction event is at some point

0:09:43there's going to be that green checklist, and it's not something that gets rushed

0:09:47through. It is, let's pause for a second. We want to tell you how awesome this product is,

0:09:52but we want to pause right now and just say, look at this. It's PVC free, this free, that free.

0:09:59That's become a, you can bank on it for every product.

0:10:02Yeah, I'm almost hoping it gets to the point where everyone says it along with us. And, you know,

0:10:08because Phil Schiller is usually the one who does it. The secretary explaining things, I call him.

0:10:17But, you know, he usually takes the time to really explain, you know, the products and

0:10:22all they do.

0:10:23And it makes me really proud that he always insists that one of the things he wants to

0:10:26explain is the time that it takes.

0:10:29I mean, are the materials that aren't in there.

0:10:32And I think it's partially because he realizes how much deep innovation and engineering it

0:10:37takes to make those decisions, to take those materials out.

0:10:41And a lot of times with pollution, it's, you know, you're talking about the stuff that

0:10:45didn't happen.

0:10:46So that can be a hard thing for most people to appreciate or understand, but it's always

0:10:51really cool that Apple takes the time to do that.

0:10:55And part of what makes it difficult for Apple in particular is that Apple has very high

0:11:02standards.

0:11:03What the company is known for in consumers' minds, part of the brand, is that their stuff

0:11:07is very nice.

0:11:09It is nice in terms of, it just looks nice, it feels nice.

0:11:14And sometimes, I think in the past, some of the reason that some of these substances and

0:11:20materials that were used that are not environmentally friendly were used, it was because such and

0:11:26such thing makes the glass shinier or something like that.

0:11:29And so it's for Apple, it's not, we can't just get rid of, it's like you can't just

0:11:32get rid of it.

0:11:35You have to get rid of it and still keep the standards for the devices and the quality

0:11:39of the materials as high as possible.

0:11:42And I think that's true.

0:11:43True. I mean, I wasn't in the labs when work was being done.

0:11:47I think there's also an element of sort of that's the way it's always been done.

0:11:51So power cords is a great example.

0:11:55You know, do you need polyvinyl chloride in the power cord in order to

0:11:59make it strong enough and safe enough? Well, pretty much around the world,

0:12:03Apple has worked to get certified power cords that don't have them.

0:12:07They do feel different. They are softer. But there's a really important reason

0:12:11why, which is that those materials are never introduced anywhere in the supply,

0:12:15which is really sort of a prevention of pollution for our workers and for the

0:12:20communities where manufacturing happens. I think it's also a bit of a nod

0:12:26to the folks in the environmental testing and technologies group. You know,

0:12:31we have an environmental testing lab here and it's grown over the years. I was

0:12:36actually there yesterday, day before, can't even remember, the week is going by fast.

0:12:42But you know, we also have to test the parts that we get, and one of the things we've been

0:12:47doing is testing, so far I think it's over 20,000 individual parts, because a lot of

0:12:52things end up in a part. We might specify how we want the part to behave and what we

0:12:57want in it, but a lot of times there is material that are in there that maybe you don't need,

0:13:02or maybe you don't realize, or maybe we want to make sure

0:13:05it is substituted out.

0:13:06And so we're also spending a lot of time,

0:13:08it's almost like our own little DNA project,

0:13:11you know, learning and understanding intimately

0:13:14what are in the parts that we get from our suppliers.

0:13:17- One of the things, I don't want to skip around too much,

0:13:21but-- - Okay.

0:13:22(laughing)

0:13:23I tend to do that, so.

0:13:24- Part, I do too, I do too.

0:13:26But a lot of this stuff is interrelated.

0:13:28It's like all of a sudden we're talking about

0:13:31the materials that are used in these devices,

0:13:35and it leads you immediately to talking about aspects

0:13:38of the supply chain.

0:13:41But part of the news this week is a series

0:13:44of four short videos, animated videos, by James Blagdon.

0:13:49And I got a sneak look at them ahead of this so I can see it.

0:13:52But by the time the show airs, they'll be out.

0:13:54And they're really kind of interesting,

0:13:56but they cover different aspects of it.

0:13:59One of them covers the goal of having no--

0:14:07correct me if I'm wrong, but the goal

0:14:08is to have no waste going to landfills from the supply

0:14:12chain?

0:14:13Yeah, right now the video covers our final assembly facilities.

0:14:17So that's why you'll see in the video an emphasis on material

0:14:23coming in, which is what happens at those facilities.

0:14:26A lot of material and parts come in,

0:14:28and then they're assembled and a product goes out the door.

0:14:31But yeah, so the emphasis is on this idea.

0:14:34And it's not a new idea, but I think Apple is really

0:14:37embracing it.

0:14:38We have facilities now, all of our final assembly facilities

0:14:43in--

0:14:45we have a facility in Cork.

0:14:46We have facilities in China.

0:14:48We have a facility in Brazil.

0:14:50And our facility here in California

0:14:52are now certified by UL as zero waste.

0:14:57And it was, you know, this classic environment versus, you know, economy argument that's so false.

0:15:06And it was so evident because the reason this started was looking at a problem and thinking,

0:15:11oh, we just got all this material in its waste and thinking, oh, the answer is recycling.

0:15:16But really, the answer is to think smart about why are so many things coming in but leaving empty?

0:15:22And can they go back?

0:15:23Can you take a pallet or can you take a tray that contains material and send it back so

0:15:28it can be used over and over again?

0:15:31And that saves money.

0:15:32Some people really embraced it.

0:15:35It's not always easy to see that path towards saving money, but everybody feels really good

0:15:41about the idea of not having to send waste to a landfill in order to produce our products.

0:15:48In other words, it's sort of, in the common sense

0:15:52of the word, it's kind of like a simpler form of recycling,

0:15:55where instead of having, and again,

0:15:58you think about the magnitude of it,

0:16:00and sometimes it just boggles the mind

0:16:03where they're talking about assembly facility

0:16:06that is turning out 150,000 iPhones a day, which is crazy.

0:16:10And you just think, well, every single one of those iPhones

0:16:13has a touch ID sensor, and it comes in a tray.

0:16:17And if you can just have those trays that were used to deliver the touch ID sensors

0:16:23in the morning go back out and the same tray is being used to deliver the touch ID sensor

0:16:29in the afternoon, it's sort of like recycling without actually having to go through all

0:16:33the process of actually remulching the material and turning it into a new tray.

0:16:41Why turn a tray that was used once into another tray when you could just reuse the tray?

0:16:45Yeah, exactly.

0:16:46I mean, it's that old adage of reduce, reuse, and recycle is part of it, but it shouldn't

0:16:52be the first place we go.

0:16:55And I kind of like the way you're explaining it, because part of our thought of these videos

0:17:00was, you know, not everyone at home has a final assembly facility, but they do have

0:17:05the opportunity to think the same way about the waste that they might produce.

0:17:12And we really wanted to connect our customers first to what we do, but also maybe to spark

0:17:19in them the thoughts of, "Hey, that's a really interesting way of thinking about life in

0:17:24general, and maybe it applies a little to me.

0:17:27Maybe they won't make that connection."

0:17:28But really just sort of make it simple, maybe thought-provoking, and to reach people where

0:17:34they are.

0:17:35But also it gave us a chance, the video you're talking about gave John a chance to tell his

0:17:41story.

0:17:42cool stories at Apple of people who don't have to, but want to do the right thing and

0:17:47figure out through maybe a little bit of trial and error.

0:17:51John has a little bit of a trial and error moment in that short video, but they figure

0:17:56out what to do.

0:17:57And then the beauty of Apple, of course, is once we figure out what to do, we learn how

0:18:02to do it at scale pretty quickly.

0:18:04Yeah, I've noticed it.

0:18:06My son is in seventh grade, and it's not like a rule.

0:18:10It's not like they're told everybody has to come in with it, but as far as I can tell,

0:18:13every kid comes into school every day with a thermos or an aluminum water bottle.

0:18:21And so for drinking water, nobody brings in the retail bottles of water.

0:18:27Every kid comes in with a little thermos that they just fill with cold water at the beginning

0:18:31of the day.

0:18:32Yeah, and they don't see it, right?

0:18:34I'm guessing your son doesn't see it as a pain or anything weird.

0:18:39actually just thinks of it as the way to drink water.

0:18:41Yeah, exactly.

0:18:42No, it doesn't.

0:18:43My son is considerably older than yours, but I was talking to him yesterday, and I said,

0:18:49"What did you have for lunch?"

0:18:50I didn't eat.

0:18:51I said, "Oh."

0:18:52So then as a mom, I'm upset.

0:18:53But then I'm like, "What did you do?"

0:18:54He's like, "I drank water all day."

0:18:56I was like, "How do you do that?"

0:18:57He said, "I brought a water bottle from home, Ma.

0:18:59Just like, leave me alone."

0:19:01But it's not a big deal, and it's not seen as like you don't need to buy this bottled

0:19:08It's right there. It's for us. It's actually one of the blessings we have in this country is a

0:19:13Mostly secure supply a clean drinking water. Yeah, but it's it that's exactly it though

0:19:18It just seems it just comes naturally to two kids today

0:19:21It doesn't it doesn't seem like they they don't even see it as like oh, I'm doing my good deed for the environment

0:19:26It's just this just makes sense

0:19:28Absolutely, and I sometimes wonder like what things what other things will be that way. I know climate change will be that way

0:19:37So but you know you just you wonder what other things will sort of be baked in with an ethic

0:19:42That's a lot more thoughtful about the planet and sort of your role in the planet

0:19:46One of the other videos

0:19:50Again, skipping around a little bit, but it's okay. It's all in your purview

0:19:54one of them focused on the new

0:19:58Apple Park and how the the building is

0:20:05I don't think it's a stretch to say that it's an innovative design to cooling, that it's

0:20:13a combination of cold water running through pipes and sort of a breathable, let the wind

0:20:19blow through the building to circulate.

0:20:24Can you tell me more about that?

0:20:25Yeah.

0:20:26You know, so these will be out and hopefully everybody will see them.

0:20:29But if you haven't seen the building with Dan Wisenhunt, who's done a lot of the work

0:20:35overseeing the construction of Apple Park, Dan talks about the way the building was designed

0:20:45by Foster and Partners to be a breathing building.

0:20:48And he does a lovely job, and Blagdon does a great job of sort of illustrating the idea

0:20:53of here's the typical building, and here's how this one works.

0:20:57Now, you know, we have kind of a, we have an advantage.

0:21:01First off, we're in, you know, Silicon Valley in Cupertino,

0:21:06and the climate here is mild,

0:21:09although it can get pretty warm in the summer.

0:21:11It's not New Orleans hot, like what I'm used to,

0:21:13but it's hot, you get warm, but 75% of--

0:21:17- I was gonna mention Philadelphia humidity,

0:21:19but you trumped me with New Orleans.

0:21:21- You know, I think they're almost the same.

0:21:23It's the same as DC.

0:21:24People say, "Oh, New Orleans is so hot,"

0:21:26And I'm like, no, it's not as hot in the summer

0:21:28when it's humid.

0:21:29There's just nothing like it.

0:21:31But you know, 75% of the time at Apple Park,

0:21:35we're estimating that there won't be a need

0:21:37for additional air conditioning.

0:21:39And you're right, the building sort of is designed

0:21:41to have this flow of air.

0:21:43It would be sort of convection into the building

0:21:47through these louvers and then past concrete

0:21:50that has cool water circulating in it.

0:21:53And that should be enough.

0:21:54And it is also designed to have a lot of air do that.

0:21:57And so, you know, there's lots of studies that show

0:22:01that sort of outside air, sun,

0:22:04sort of is actually the environment we humans

0:22:07are meant to be in,

0:22:07not these artificially conditioned environment.

0:22:11And the building is on track to be certified

0:22:15by the US Green Building Council as LEED Platinum.

0:22:18That's their highest certification for environment

0:22:22and energy efficiency and smartness.

0:22:25And so we're really proud of that

0:22:26'cause it includes the R&D facilities.

0:22:28It's really a R&D park as much as it's an office building.

0:22:32So it's gonna be exciting.

0:22:34I'm thrilled for the day we actually move in,

0:22:38although I know it's gonna be a little bit of madness,

0:22:40but it'd be awful fun.

0:22:42- Moving is always madness.

0:22:44Moving the world's largest corporation across town

0:22:48is really, I don't know.

0:22:50- What could go wrong, really?

0:22:52All right, here's a question that I have.

0:22:57And I would like, explain it to me like I'm an idiot.

0:23:02What it means, what renewable energy means in the sense of 96% of your operations are

0:23:10running on renewable energy and in 24 countries, 100%.

0:23:14Explain to me what that means and why I should care.

0:23:18So, you know, we set a goal to run on 100% renewable

0:23:23for all of our operations.

0:23:24And I just want to say, notably, we set a goal

0:23:27from the beginning to run data centers on renewable energy.

0:23:30You should care because climate change is real,

0:23:33it's happening, and any responsible company

0:23:36ought to be thinking about its role in solving that problem.

0:23:41It's just that simple to me.

0:23:43I mean, you know, Tim talks a lot about companies

0:23:45are made of people and companies have values

0:23:48they should stand for things.

0:23:49And this company has said very clearly that one of the things we stand for is taking care

0:23:54of our environment.

0:23:57I don't think that's in any way partisan either.

0:24:00I think most people would say less pollution is good, more pollution is bad, but also the

0:24:06idea that having the planet and having the resources of the planet around for future

0:24:11generations is really important.

0:24:14And then you're a parent, but I think many of us think about our obligation to future

0:24:19generations not to leave a place that's heading to the point where the only option is to recolonize

0:24:26or colonize another planet.

0:24:28It just doesn't seem like a parental thing to do.

0:24:33And so there's all kinds of reasons, and I could wax all day about climate change.

0:24:38But what we said is, look, ideally, we are not a power company.

0:24:42We are not a utility.

0:24:44If the world was where we want it to be today, there'd be a utility saying, "Hey, what kind

0:24:49of power do you want to buy?"

0:24:50"Okay, sure, here, I'll sell it to you.

0:24:52That would be awesome."

0:24:53We don't have that choice everywhere.

0:24:55So Apple has the ability to do a little bit more.

0:24:58So in general, we know how much energy we use in a particular country, in a particular

0:25:03region, and our goal is to put that much or more clean energy onto the grid where we use

0:25:10it.

0:25:11So a couple of things, the idea has to be new clean energy.

0:25:15So we don't want to just come in and buy all the available clean energy, because then there's

0:25:19nothing left for somebody else to buy.

0:25:21That doesn't seem very fair.

0:25:23And wherever possible, to displace dirtier energy.

0:25:27So because we're there, there's this new clean energy, and maybe it means you don't need

0:25:32as much of the more polluting forms of energy.

0:25:37And then we try to be very fastidious about quantifying that, so we true up at the end

0:25:43of every year.

0:25:44So when people ask me, "Well, that means you're not always using the exact clean energy

0:25:51electron that you generate," because we have solar powers on top of Apple Park, we have

0:25:56solar farm at our data centers, we have wind power that we purchase here in California,

0:26:02We even have like micro-hydro projects in Oregon.

0:26:07We don't always have that connection.

0:26:08It has to go through the grid, and the grid plays an important role, but it's like an

0:26:13ATM.

0:26:14We make sure we're putting enough clean energy, new clean energy in to cover what we have

0:26:19to take out.

0:26:20And although that's not the absolute optimum, to us it feels like if every company did that,

0:26:25we'd have a lot more clean energy on the grid and demanded on the grid, and that would displace

0:26:31brown power. Is it a source of frustration for you, either in

0:26:40your current role, specifically at one company, Apple, or looking even broader

0:26:47at your career and previously, for anybody who doesn't know, for the first

0:26:52four years of the Obama administration, you were the head of the EPA. Is it a

0:26:57source of frustration for you that more companies don't seem to have as high a priority on using

0:27:05renewable energy?

0:27:08You know, I think companies are moving in that direction.

0:27:11You know, what we always knew at EPA was really clear to me here is, you know, a business

0:27:17needs certainty and has to make decisions based on where policy is going, where it thinks

0:27:25the world is going.

0:27:26And it has been really clear to most big, you know, multinational companies, I think,

0:27:31for some time that we're going to be living in a carbon-constrained future.

0:27:37It's not clear how it's going to be constrained.

0:27:38I mean, there's the Paris Climate Accords.

0:27:41There are all kinds of policy discussions going on around the world about how to get

0:27:45to lower carbon.

0:27:47And some countries are in the middle of that transformation in a very big way.

0:27:52So I think a lot of companies over the last eight to ten years had to decide what to do

0:27:58and have made the decision to incorporate energy efficiency, of course, because that's

0:28:03cheaper and cleaner, but also renewable energy.

0:28:08And that's true in states like Texas, certainly in states like California, but we have a big

0:28:13data center in Nevada.

0:28:15It's true there.

0:28:17We have a big data center in North Carolina, which is on its third solar farm now.

0:28:23So you know, I don't...

0:28:27When I left EPA, the one thing I thought was, because I'm an engineer, a chemical engineer

0:28:31by training actually, around all these computer science and electrical engineers, so go figure.

0:28:37But you know, I wanted to go back to my roots and sort of say, I believe, I've always believed

0:28:44that business has not just a role, but a responsibility.

0:28:48Part of the reason I became an engineer, or an environmental sort of engineer, is that

0:28:54I remember being in school and thinking, as a chemical engineer, we make all this hazardous

0:28:59waste.

0:29:00Chemical engineers should be responsible as a profession for stopping this problem.

0:29:05And so I think that's sort of how we think of it here.

0:29:08And I think more companies are seeing it that way.

0:29:11It is a little depressing that there's some old thinking out there still, which is you

0:29:15can either have economic growth or you can have a clean environment, but that's old-fashioned

0:29:21thinking.

0:29:22We really need people to sort of look beyond that and really think about the problem and

0:29:27innovate around it.

0:29:29That's something, and again, I'm very much a layperson in the expertise on this, but

0:29:35At a common-sense level, it frustrates me to hear that argument of economic growth being

0:29:44tied to "we can't spend money on... we have to do things the cheapest way possible right

0:29:50now," which would be to continue using fossil fuels and just spewing carbon into the air,

0:29:57versus "it's like an idealism that we can't afford to go to cleaner and renewable sources."

0:30:04What frustrates me with that argument is that,

0:30:07isn't that where all this opportunity is,

0:30:10where new companies, or even existing companies could,

0:30:13like existing energy companies,

0:30:16could stand to make a fortune

0:30:18if they make major breakthroughs in renewable energy?

0:30:21- Well, sound like an environmental and energy expert

0:30:25to me, John.

0:30:26I mean, it's not surprising you see it,

0:30:28because you're also used to the thinking in the valley,

0:30:33And it's not only in the valley, but this idea that,

0:30:36we need to apply the same level of innovation

0:30:41to the environment and our work to protect the planet

0:30:44as we do to the other work that we do,

0:30:46in Apple's case to our products.

0:30:47And as soon as you start to see innovation

0:30:51as the way forward, then you realize

0:30:54that the only limitation is our imagination,

0:30:58our creativity and our persistence,

0:31:01the sweat you put into something.

0:31:02So when we talk about wanting to use more recycled materials in our products,

0:31:07it's about looking at a supply chain that right now is just not going to be sustainable over time.

0:31:12There won't be enough, or some country might decide to, you know, control the supply of materials needed,

0:31:19and the price just goes up. So how can we get ahead of that?

0:31:23It's all about innovation and not looking--

0:31:27I also like to say, because I am a little bit of a nerd, that the thing about an engineer

0:31:33is that engineers wake up, and at Apple it's absolutely true, we wake up when you give

0:31:37us a hard problem, and we look at it as a challenge.

0:31:41And if I have one complaint about my profession, it's that we need to continue to include

0:31:48the idea of ethics.

0:31:49Like, you know, solving the problem, part of the elegant solution has to be thinking

0:31:54about whether it's truly a sustainable one.

0:31:57Economically sustainable, yes,

0:31:59but who's being harmed in this solution?

0:32:02And I think good companies are there,

0:32:03and I hope that customers start to expect

0:32:07and demand that of companies,

0:32:08because right now I really believe

0:32:11that a lot of the leadership that we're gonna see

0:32:13on these issues has to come from businesses

0:32:15who stand up and dispute this idea

0:32:18that they need to pollute in order to profit.

0:32:22- Yeah, I hope at least that it sort of changes

0:32:27from consumers, maybe like environmentally conscious

0:32:32consumers, a smaller niche of them if you will,

0:32:36keeping a white list of a handful of good companies

0:32:40who are environmentally conscious to more of a broader,

0:32:44here's a black list of companies who are clearly

0:32:47disregarding the environment in their actions

0:32:49and operations, I'm not going to do business with them

0:32:52because I find that offensive.

0:32:55- Yeah, it's like a gray-green list, you know, khaki.

0:32:58I think, but yeah, absolutely.

0:32:59You know, I just, I agree with you.

0:33:01And I also don't think, I think consumers are, you know,

0:33:06sort of confused too, because you have companies

0:33:09of all stripes standing up and claiming,

0:33:11especially this week, you know, as we roll into Earth Day,

0:33:15how, you know, sort of putting forth their green credentials

0:33:18and Apple's no different.

0:33:20So I think it tends to make people a bit cynical.

0:33:23So part of the videos was also opening up a little and showing that all these claims

0:33:29you make take work and effort.

0:33:31And all these promises that we make, we try not to make them if we don't know how we're

0:33:37going to get there, but in some cases, they require a lot of persistence.

0:33:43And so one of the frustrations I've had also is, frankly, there's a lot of people out there

0:33:48claim to say, you know, they make lists, everybody makes lists. But what I want people to know

0:33:53is that for me, this company, Apple, is thinking, you know, years, decades ahead about how to

0:34:01influence our sector, the tech sector, the consumer products sector, and make it better.

0:34:11And leave the world, as Tim would say, leave the world better than we found it.

0:34:15One of the other announcements you guys have this week is that in a partnership with the

0:34:21WWF, which when I see it, I still think of the wrestling.

0:34:25I do.

0:34:26Well, they would not like to hear that.

0:34:28I know.

0:34:29I know.

0:34:30Props to WWF.

0:34:31But it's not the wrestling organization.

0:34:33No, it's the World Wildlife.

0:34:35Right.

0:34:36And you guys, in partnership with them, have gotten over 300,000 acres of working forest

0:34:43in China to be recommended for what's called the Forest Stewardship Council certification.

0:34:49That means that Apple is now protecting and creating sustainable working forests as much

0:34:56as is needed to cover your paper needs for the packaging that you guys make.

0:35:04In plain English, does that mean that as much paper as you guys are using for packaging,

0:35:09There's trees that are being regrown at the same rate that they're being used to turn

0:35:13into paper.

0:35:14Yeah, I like that.

0:35:16You see, you should be in the videos because you're explaining stuff really well too.

0:35:21Yeah, that's exactly it.

0:35:23A while ago, actually I just started at Apple and the woman who runs packaging amongst other

0:35:29things, Kate Bergeron, we were all at dinner having a glass of wine and she was like, "You

0:35:34know, I've been thinking for a long time we should buy a forest."

0:35:38And it was sort of my introduction to, you know, think different at Apple, this idea

0:35:42that somebody who does packaging would go that far deep in her thinking, you know, really

0:35:48analyzing the problem.

0:35:49And of course, she was trying to get at that very problem, which is packaging is made out

0:35:54of paper.

0:35:55By the way, our packaging is increasingly almost entirely paper.

0:35:59We've tried to phase out plastics, because we think paper can be a renewable resource.

0:36:05And what if we controlled how that paper was, you know, how the wood was harvested and the

0:36:09pulp was made?

0:36:12And so we didn't buy the forest ourselves, but we found great partners.

0:36:17In the U.S., we found a group called the Conservation Fund.

0:36:20So we have 36,000 acres in Maine and North Carolina that they've worked to preserve and

0:36:25ensure remain in sustainable forestry.

0:36:28So working forest, yes, trees are chopped, but trees are also planted.

0:36:32And then we found WWF in China, and there it's not a land ownership issue, it was a

0:36:38management issue.

0:36:39We have these big, basically paper, they call them plantations, and making sure that they

0:36:45were being managed sustainably, which has been a goal of China's as well.

0:36:50So we found the right partner.

0:36:51They have some great people on the ground in China, Chinese folks who are really deeply

0:36:59involved in working with these Chinese businesses.

0:37:02And we're really proud of the fact that based on

0:37:05the work they've done in just, I think about two years,

0:37:08we've gotten to the point where those forests,

0:37:11the three of them are producing enough sustainably

0:37:16and responsibly managed wood to cover our needs.

0:37:19Now we've also done something on the other end,

0:37:21which is back to that old reduce, reuse, recycle.

0:37:24We wanted to reduce how much virgin paper

0:37:27we need for packaging.

0:37:29So we've really upped our work on using recycled paper,

0:37:32and we've also upped our work to make packaging smaller

0:37:36and lighter whenever we can.

0:37:38So we still have work to do.

0:37:40You know, this is a long road,

0:37:42and so I don't want it to sound like we're there,

0:37:44but we're really proud of the fact

0:37:46that this year we hit that milestone.

0:37:48- And again, this is another one of those things

0:37:50where the stakes are very high for Apple

0:37:52because Apple products are known

0:37:55for having beautiful packaging.

0:37:57And so it's not enough to just say,

0:37:59well, we'll take out the plastic

0:38:00and we'll use cardboard or some kind of paper.

0:38:03It has to be nice.

0:38:04- Yeah, it has to be more than nice, right?

0:38:06I mean, I think that's maybe the thing

0:38:09I didn't emphasize enough.

0:38:10I don't, I didn't want to come here and do this

0:38:13in a way where people felt they were giving something up

0:38:16in order to do something good.

0:38:18And I don't mean that to sound, you know,

0:38:20it's sort of like, again, back to your son.

0:38:22You know, he doesn't, he's doing something good,

0:38:24but it doesn't change his experience.

0:38:26he still feels really good, he's getting the water he needs.

0:38:29I mean, for us here at Apple, we understand that, you know,

0:38:33our customers love our products.

0:38:35They feel emotionally attached to the experience,

0:38:37all the way from taking it home to unboxing it,

0:38:41to turning it on the first time, to seeing the hello,

0:38:44all the way through use and upgrades.

0:38:47So none of that is what we're trying to impact.

0:38:49And in fact, we won't allow it to happen that way.

0:38:52I don't think anybody here would allow us to impact that.

0:38:57What we're trying to do is make sure people understand

0:38:59that all these really smart people here

0:39:02are thinking about ways to make it green and better

0:39:05and produce without harming the planet.

0:39:09So you don't have to.

0:39:10So you can feel really good about the purchase

0:39:13that you make so that you know that part

0:39:16of making the best products in the world

0:39:19is making the best products for the world.

0:39:21- I would like to talk, this is an area

0:39:26where I just don't know much about, about transportation.

0:39:29Because just going back to that basic idea

0:39:31of like an assembly plant in China

0:39:35that's manufacturing 150,000 iPhones a day.

0:39:40And let's say it's September and there's a new iPhone.

0:39:44And the day that it comes out,

0:39:47There are millions of UPS drivers around North America

0:39:52ringing doorbells, dropping off pre-ordered iPhones.

0:39:56To get all those iPhones from China to North America,

0:40:01and then once they get to North America,

0:40:03to distribute them to everybody who purchased it,

0:40:05there's an awful lot of fossil fuel

0:40:08being burned on that, right?

0:40:10- Yeah, you know, transportation as a sector,

0:40:13for our carbon footprint,

0:40:15It's actually a very small percentage

0:40:17of our carbon footprint.

0:40:19I'll get you the number, I'm looking as I speak.

0:40:22But we do a comprehensive carbon footprint for Apple.

0:40:26This year, for 2016, for the year just past,

0:40:29it's 29.5 million metric tons.

0:40:33And transportation of our product is 4% of that.

0:40:37So do the math really quickly.

0:40:40Included in that carbon footprint is,

0:40:44Some people say cradle to grave.

0:40:45We're trying to get rid of the grave

0:40:47and make a closed loop system.

0:40:49But right now, all the way from the mine,

0:40:51even though we don't own mines,

0:40:53we don't have relationship with mining companies,

0:40:56but we estimate the extraction and processing

0:41:00of let's say the alumina or to make aluminum enclosures.

0:41:05All the way through a product use,

0:41:09we actually include in our carbon footprint

0:41:12the electricity you use as an Apple customer,

0:41:19because you wouldn't use that electricity if it wasn't for Apple.

0:41:21So all the way to recycling.

0:41:24So it's not a huge part of our carbon footprint,

0:41:28but 4% is nothing to sneeze at.

0:41:31The biggest part of our carbon footprint is actually in the manufacturing,

0:41:34all those suppliers that are in our supply chain.

0:41:37And so one of the other things we're doing is spending time with them,

0:41:41Now that we're at 96% renewable, we've learned a lot.

0:41:45And so now we're trying to bring them along.

0:41:47And this year, we're announcing three new suppliers who've committed to go 100% renewable

0:41:54for all their operations, Compel, Sunwoda, and Beale.

0:42:00And that brings us to seven suppliers.

0:42:02And I think that number is going to keep going up.

0:42:05I don't want to act like all of them are doing it just because of Apple, but those seven

0:42:09have made an Apple-specific commitment, and there are others who are doing it on their

0:42:13own.

0:42:14So, you know, yes, transportation is a problem that we need to think about, and we can do

0:42:20that.

0:42:21You know, when you make a lighter product in a smaller package, it helps with transportation

0:42:26emissions.

0:42:29And when we think about marine, so taking it by ship versus air, that helps with transportation.

0:42:38And so every little bit will help, but we are tackling the biggest places first, the

0:42:42hardest.

0:42:43But in other words, you guys aren't sweeping any aspect of it under the rug by saying,

0:42:48"Well, that's not us."

0:42:50Right?

0:42:52This is what actual Apple employees are doing in Apple-owned buildings.

0:42:59And anything that happens from the mine until it gets there, we're not taking that into

0:43:05account.

0:43:06to account for everything. Yeah, because you can't change the world if you stop at your theoretical

0:43:14borders. You have to change yourself first. You have to lead by example and not demand

0:43:19of others what you're not willing to do. But I think we're one of the few companies, I won't say

0:43:26the only companies in the world, who take this very comprehensive look at our carbon footprint

0:43:31and look to, we'd love to get it to zero,

0:43:35which would mean that all those suppliers

0:43:37would be at zero carbon footprint.

0:43:40And we're trying to do it right now,

0:43:43not using offsets or credits.

0:43:46You know, there might be some places in the world

0:43:48that it's just not possible to do that right now,

0:43:51but that's why we're at 96%, not saying 100,

0:43:56'cause we could get to 100 if we just bought some credits.

0:43:59And so we're still working hard on that.

0:44:02And yeah, it feels really good to be that expansive.

0:44:05Because then you can inspire the energy folks, the product power

0:44:11folks, to make the most efficient products in the world.

0:44:14Because every time you save a wad of energy on a MacBook,

0:44:21you're saving a tremendous amount,

0:44:22because we sell so many of them.

0:44:24So the more expansive you are, the more, I guess,

0:44:28playing field you have to play with,

0:44:30to go back to the sports analogy.

0:44:32- Yeah, there's an old story from the '80s

0:44:36of the creation of the original Macintosh,

0:44:39where, I forget, somebody had a stopwatch

0:44:42and timed how long it took the prototype to start up.

0:44:46And Steve Jobs said, "You gotta get that,

0:44:47"you gotta cut 30 seconds off of that."

0:44:49And they're like, "Why?"

0:44:50And he was like, "Well, we're gonna sell

0:44:51"millions of these things, multiply that by 30 seconds."

0:44:55And you get like, you know, it came out to like,

0:44:57I don't know, 87 years.

0:44:58He goes, there you go, you saved a life.

0:45:00Yeah, yeah, I read that story.

0:45:01And it's like that with energy, right?

0:45:03You take 70 million iPhones in a quarter,

0:45:08and if you can make them a little bit more energy

0:45:12efficient, every little bit you multiply by the 70 million

0:45:15that were just sold, and it adds up.

0:45:18I think the number is something like since 2008, on average,

0:45:21our products are 70% more efficient, more energy

0:45:24efficient.

0:45:25And there's been some great big technology innovations in there.

0:45:30And I also want to be really clear, back to that idea

0:45:33that you don't have to sacrifice.

0:45:34Those are all things that make the experience better.

0:45:37Energy efficiency, the flip side of that is battery life.

0:45:41If something doesn't use a lot of energy,

0:45:43you need a smaller battery, or your battery of whatever size

0:45:48goes longer.

0:45:49It goes longer on a charge.

0:45:50So all these things tend to have sort of compounding reasons.

0:45:55And sometimes they're even based on the customer experience,

0:45:59but there's a happy sort of carbon benefit

0:46:02at the same time, or environmental benefit too.

0:46:05- You said earlier that this sort of thinking

0:46:09shouldn't be seen as partisan.

0:46:11And I think that the cynic's take on that would be

0:46:15that Apple, as the most profitable company in the world,

0:46:20can afford to be,

0:46:22can afford to spend on this idealism.

0:46:28But I think your argument would be that no,

0:46:32it's Apple as the most profitable country in the world

0:46:35can show that having a focus on this sort of stuff

0:46:38is not at odds with being profitable.

0:46:40- Yeah, I mean, it's the right thing to do.

0:46:45I don't think, I think if you go back to sort of,

0:46:47you know, core human values, you know, protecting the planet where we live, where our children,

0:46:54you know, grow up, where we work, the places that we, you know, used to fish or swim as

0:47:00a kid, the drinking water that we all honestly take for granted because we've, most of us,

0:47:07haven't had the experience of, say, people in Flint where you literally have to, you

0:47:11know, shower and wash your face with bottled water.

0:47:13I mean, all those things are just goods.

0:47:16And so, you know, when we think about the environment, it shouldn't, you know, our position

0:47:23is we're not taken aside in terms of whether any political approach is right.

0:47:30We're just saying this is something that is definitely a good.

0:47:34It's good to have, to be efficient, to be thoughtful and careful.

0:47:39Kind of the, you know, what my grandmother said, you know, waste not, want not.

0:47:43idea that, you know, in a world where we have been incredibly fortunate as a country or

0:47:50as a people to think of that as our responsibility.

0:47:55I think, you know, for me it's sort of almost a moral thing, but yeah, it's not about having

0:48:04the money to do it.

0:48:05It's about figuring out the innovations that would then, you know, hopefully spread out

0:48:11like ripples and allow others to do it too.

0:48:13I think if you went to someone who right now has a utility bill and there was a way that

0:48:19they could have cleaner energy that would also reduce their utility bill, they would

0:48:25be for it.

0:48:26And so that's a policy question.

0:48:28I don't think it depends on what party you're in.

0:48:31If you ask somebody, "Would you rather have solar power?"

0:48:34I think it's kind of a cool thing.

0:48:36Where do you see the role between the government and something in the U.S. like the EPA and

0:48:45a business like Apple taking initiative on its own to do these things?

0:48:51Yeah, you know, from the EPA perspective, there wasn't a ton of places where EPA and

0:48:59Apple intersected.

0:49:01is a regulatory agency and there are regulations that definitely affect

0:49:07the technology sector but

0:49:10you know regulations in many cases not all cases are meant to set

0:49:15the floor. There's definitely, they just can't set the ceiling and in fact if they

0:49:21set a ceiling

0:49:22they're not doing the right thing. They should be there to help

0:49:26innovation go forward and

0:49:29you know, I'm not for every single piece of regulation, especially those that seem

0:49:35to be

0:49:35picking, you know, which innovations

0:49:39should or shouldn't go forward. I think that requires real thoughtfulness.

0:49:43But, you know, I think for companies like ours

0:49:49it's not to say we don't have times when we have regulations that affect us.

0:49:52It's not to say, you know, I don't want anybody to walk away from this thinking we

0:49:56figured out how to do it right all the time. We will have problems

0:49:59like any other company will, but our general orientation is to trying to do

0:50:05the best we can to meet the goals we've set for ourselves around climate change,

0:50:10around

0:50:11greener materials, and around conserving

0:50:14and being really smart and not wasteful about resources.

0:50:19Alright, one last question I have for you.

0:50:22Where do you think Apple is

0:50:25least up to snuff.

0:50:27Like where is the, where can you guys improve,

0:50:30where do you guys have the most opportunity for improvement?

0:50:34- Oh man, that's like the interview question

0:50:36when they ask you for your one flaw.

0:50:39You know, you don't answer that, but I mean,

0:50:41there are tons of things that I wish I could snap my fingers

0:50:45and would be done, you know.

0:50:47I wish we could make a better connection with our customers

0:50:54So we got more of our products back at end of life.

0:50:58I think we have a ton of work to do.

0:51:00I mean, we had just outlined this big hairy goal around starting to close loops for different

0:51:07materials.

0:51:08And so I think that's going to be a big area of focus for us.

0:51:15I mean, it has to be done in a way that maintains all the things that Apple is.

0:51:22- Apple is. - That's a great point.

0:51:25Somebody buys, let's say, a MacBook Pro,

0:51:29and they use it for the next four or five years,

0:51:31and they get a great time out of it,

0:51:33and they upgrade, and they take that old one,

0:51:35and they just put it in a closet,

0:51:37and they think, well, this old MacBook Pro,

0:51:39it's still good, but I'm gonna get a new one.

0:51:41They put it in a closet, and then a couple more years go by,

0:51:43and they're like, why do I still have

0:51:44this old MacBook Pro, right?

0:51:46And at that point, at least that's the way my closet works.

0:51:50At that point, you don't want them to just put it in the trash.

0:51:54You want them to do-- like the fact that this complicated, fancy laptop is made out of recyclable

0:52:01materials, it's not-- you can't just put it in the blue recycling bin where your aluminum

0:52:06cans go to get it properly recycled.

0:52:09Right.

0:52:10What we'd love to have happen is that it comes back either to an Apple store or that you

0:52:16go online and ask for a mailing box or envelope, we'll take back at the stores

0:52:23any product, any Apple product you bring in. That's our Apple Renew program.

0:52:29We, you know, we are also emphasizing in the stores the programs that we have

0:52:34that allow you to upgrade. So if you're a tech person who does like the latest

0:52:41technology, we want that, you know, we want last year's or the year before's model

0:52:48back because it still has value first off. You know, a lot of the reason people

0:52:51love Apple is that if you if you want to sell your product yourself or trade it

0:52:57in, it has a great value. But at the end of life, and that could be, you know, a

0:53:03long time away, I mean we have people still rocking fours and I think threes

0:53:09out there, but you know, when the time comes, we'd still like to have it back. It is a bit of a

0:53:14challenge, by the way, to then make sure all that material gets back in the recycling chain, because

0:53:19it's, you know, it's very different and very diverse. We're starting to have quite a bit of

0:53:23a catalog back behind us. But that's part of the challenge.

0:53:27Well, that was the video that was shown when you were on stage a few events ago with the robot who

0:53:34disassembles iPhones?

0:53:36Yeah, Liam. Liam is actually a twin now here in California and actually over in Europe.

0:53:43Yeah, and the idea was to think about that disassembly step and understand,

0:53:49if you think of this thing as a chain or a big circle, every step influences the one before and

0:53:55against. So how do you disassemble this product and do it in a way where you maximize the ability

0:54:02to maybe get tin back, or get aluminum back,

0:54:07or as we're starting to look at with batteries,

0:54:11get cobalt back.

0:54:12And so when you start to think about this challenge,

0:54:16not to scare myself, which I can do,

0:54:21it's material by material, component by component,

0:54:24product by product.

0:54:26Because the camera is different in the iPhone 6

0:54:31than it is in the iPhone 7.

0:54:33So those are all challenges we're willing to take on.

0:54:39But the customer's role in that is to, wherever possible--

0:54:43I'm not asking anybody to give up their first iPhone--

0:54:46but wherever possible, to get those products back to Apple.

0:54:50And the other thing that's online that's really important

0:54:53is a lot of people have security concerns.

0:54:55Your life is on your device.

0:54:58And so to make sure you wipe it, we'll

0:55:00be looking out to do that as well.

0:55:03But a lot of people don't want to part with them

0:55:05because of the data that's on it.

0:55:06So there's instructions on how to do that as well.

0:55:09Yeah, that's a good point.

0:55:11Anything else that you wanted to talk about today?

0:55:15No, I guess we covered it.

0:55:16We got to give a shout out to Drexel, right?

0:55:19Can I say hi to my son Brian, who's a dragon?

0:55:21Hey, Drexel.

0:55:23Go dragons.

0:55:25Now that's an amazing connection between the two of us.

0:55:28Your son is doing game design, game development at Drexel.

0:55:33- Yes, yes.

0:55:34I'm hoping that is an actual major, but--

0:55:37- No, it is.

0:55:38(laughing)

0:55:39It wasn't when I was there.

0:55:41But I actually know the program.

0:55:44I am familiar with it.

0:55:45And I just keep hearing.

0:55:46- I am teasing.

0:55:47It is an amazing program, and I am a huge fan of the school.

0:55:51So shout out to Brian and his friends

0:55:53and the amazing group over there in Westfall

0:55:56and the engineering school.

0:55:57- It would be pretty funny to imagine some college student

0:56:00just sitting around playing PlayStation all day

0:56:03and tells his mom, "I'm studying game design."

0:56:06- And like, "Your son is young,

0:56:07"but let me just tell you, beware."

0:56:10They get real smart real fast, real, real fast.

0:56:14- Lisa Jackson, thank you so much for your time.

0:56:16It has been an absolute pleasure talking to you.

0:56:19- Right back at you.

0:56:20- Have a good Earth Day, and I hope to see you soon.

0:56:23Thanks, happy Earth Day!