Podcast Search

The Talk Show

187: ‘Forget About Frodo and Sam’ With MG Siegler

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00In the old days if if I were gonna have a show it would we would have to be together

0:00:04you'd have to be like in a studio with me and

0:00:06You would think I would I would supply comfortable chairs for my guests and you you know

0:00:12I feel like forcing guests to use Skype is like you get like a folding chair that was that was outside and as like

0:00:19Rain scum on it, you know

0:00:22Yeah

0:00:24Yeah, it's nice to be on again

0:00:28There's a couple of things we have to talk about, I guess.

0:00:32There's always stuff to talk about, but there's a couple of recent posts that you've

0:00:36had on your 500-ish word site.

0:00:39Is that what it's called?

0:00:40I know that's the domain.

0:00:41Yep, 500-ish words.

0:00:43But you wrote about the end of Virgin America.

0:00:51Can you summarize this?

0:00:53And again, it's a perfect piece, I will put it in the show loads.

0:00:57But it is perfect insofar as you admit that Virgin America only flew between a very small

0:01:03number of cities.

0:01:04Right.

0:01:05So there's a large number of people who, if you don't live in San Francisco, LA, or New

0:01:07York, you probably haven't flown Virgin.

0:01:09Right.

0:01:10And so, yeah.

0:01:11So basically, I'm assuming by this point, because it's been a month or so, everyone

0:01:16knows that Alaska Airlines bought Virgin America.

0:01:21And as a part of that, they sort of did this whole big branding thing, certainly around

0:01:25in San Francisco and I assume other cities

0:01:27in which Virgin operates where it's sort of like

0:01:29the Alaska plus Virgin equals love type marketing campaign.

0:01:34'Cause obviously people were worried

0:01:37when someone else bought Virgin America

0:01:39that there would be the end of Virgin America.

0:01:42And they were trying to sort of play it up,

0:01:44no, this is just gonna make both sides even better.

0:01:46And then whenever it was a few weeks ago,

0:01:49they of course announced that they're going to be

0:01:51shutting down the Virgin America brand entirely.

0:01:55and basically merging the planes

0:01:59and sort of merging all into one entity,

0:02:02which of course I'm sure makes sense for the bottom line.

0:02:04That's the reason why they're doing it

0:02:07for cost efficiencies.

0:02:08But yeah, I mean, so people who don't live

0:02:12in one of the cities that Virgin America services,

0:02:14which is, I'm not even sure what the current number is,

0:02:16but let's say it's 10, maybe 12 or something like that.

0:02:19It's not very many still.

0:02:21Started in San Francisco.

0:02:22The company was headquarters here.

0:02:24Obviously, it was famously started out of Richard Branson's Virgin Group.

0:02:28People who don't live in one of those 10 to 15, whatever it is now, cities,

0:02:35don't really understand why people who do live in one of those cities

0:02:40and take Virgin regularly are upset about this.

0:02:43The best pushback that I found most amusing was on Twitter,

0:02:48basically saying, "But Alaska Airlines is such a great airline too."

0:02:52And you know, I've been on Alaska, certainly any flight that goes to sort of the Pacific

0:02:56Northwest, you know, that's sort of one of the common carriers, and it's fine.

0:03:00It's a nice airline.

0:03:01You know, it's not United.

0:03:02I'm sure we can talk about that in a second, but it's fine.

0:03:07But it's not Virgin America.

0:03:08You have to be on a Virgin America plane to know what that's like.

0:03:11I mean, if you think back to when it started, whenever that was, several years back, you

0:03:17know, the fact that they were all sort of new planes.

0:03:21The basic thing that I highlighted in that post is,

0:03:24I think people don't understand,

0:03:26you got a level of consistency flying Virgin America

0:03:29that you don't get with any other airline,

0:03:30'cause it's a total crap shoot,

0:03:32whether you're gonna get an old rickety plane,

0:03:34whether you're gonna get one with like,

0:03:36still cigarette ashtrays.

0:03:37(laughing)

0:03:38- Yeah, ashtrays.

0:03:39- Yeah.

0:03:40- And a sticker that says, "Do not use under federal law."

0:03:42- Yes, and with Virgin,

0:03:45sort of because it was a newer airline,

0:03:47they had all the same,

0:03:48I think it was A380 planes,

0:03:50No, the A380 is the big one, whatever the Airbus is.

0:03:53I think they're A321s.

0:03:55It might be that, yeah.

0:03:56Maybe--

0:03:57It's one of the sort of standard, smaller Airbus planes.

0:04:02And so they were all that.

0:04:03They all had Wi-Fi, which at the time was a novelty, certainly.

0:04:08They all had those televisions and the screenbacks,

0:04:10not just in first class or anything.

0:04:11All the screens-- all the seats, sorry--

0:04:14had that.

0:04:14And you had a very consistent experience.

0:04:16You knew if you were getting on a Virgin America flight,

0:04:18more likely to be a good flight. I mean, I'm sure that, you know, everyone will have a

0:04:22horror story about every airline, but it's not like you hear about United and Delta and some

0:04:28of the other ones that are just, you know, constantly a crummy experience. This was

0:04:32a definitely a notch above. We had them in Philly until about two years ago, and we lost them. We

0:04:42lost Virgin during the aftermath of the American--

0:04:46Oh, the merger?

0:04:47--US Air merger.

0:04:48I've told this story before.

0:04:50But long story short, it's very simple.

0:04:53When US Air and American proposed merging,

0:04:57one of the problem areas was that it

0:04:59gave the combined airline too many gates at JFK in New York,

0:05:05or the federal aviation.

0:05:06There's some kind of limit to the percentage of gates

0:05:09that any one airline can have at any airport.

0:05:11And US Air and American both had a big presence at JFK

0:05:15and it was too many gates.

0:05:16So they had to get rid of some of the gates

0:05:18and Virgin decided they would rather take more gates at JFK

0:05:22but leave Philly entirely.

0:05:24And they couldn't keep both because one of the problems

0:05:26of being an airline is it's really hard to get more planes.

0:05:29I mean, it sounds silly 'cause you think like,

0:05:31oh, you just call Boeing up and buy a plane.

0:05:34- Right. - You know what I mean?

0:05:35Like if you and I bought or started a moving company

0:05:38and it took off and we needed more trucks,

0:05:40we could just go buy more trucks.

0:05:42That's not a problem.

0:05:43But in aviation, you gotta order an airplane

0:05:46like a couple years in advance.

0:05:47So there's nothing-- - Right, such a long

0:05:48lead time.

0:05:50- So I've been off Virgin for a while.

0:05:51But I still get the emails.

0:05:52Like I got the email the other day from Alaska

0:05:54telling me not to worry, my points are okay.

0:05:56- Right, yeah, I mean, we'll see.

0:06:00Of course, Alaska's trying to say all the right things

0:06:04in their sort of press statement about it.

0:06:06They said, "We're going to be sort of bringing

0:06:08the Virgin experience to Alaska flights.

0:06:11And so, including the humorous bit about there being

0:06:15mood lighting, that's one of the,

0:06:17that's like the thing they decided to focus on,

0:06:18'cause Virgin America sort of famously has this

0:06:21purple-hued mood lighting.

0:06:22And so, Alaska's gonna do that,

0:06:24but they're gonna have blue mood lighting.

0:06:25So it'll be not the exact same,

0:06:27but it will be almost as good.

0:06:29And we'll see, I mean, they said that basically

0:06:32nothing was going to change, and then of course

0:06:34everything's changing, so don't have a lot of

0:06:38hope for it remaining as it was.

0:06:41The good news, if there is slight good news,

0:06:44it's going to take them a long time to sort of phase

0:06:47in and out those changes.

0:06:49And so Virgin will remain operating

0:06:50for I think at least a year, maybe a couple of years,

0:06:54something like that.

0:06:55But yeah, it'll be a big change.

0:06:58And as we're seeing this week with the airline industry,

0:07:01this is sort of par for the course,

0:07:03just doing anything to screw over customers.

0:07:05I think they only had two or three gates at Philly.

0:07:08So it wasn't a lot of flights.

0:07:10It wasn't a big presence.

0:07:11And it was a small desk for check-in.

0:07:13You know, it was usually like two people.

0:07:16So it's not a fair comparison to like American,

0:07:19which dominates Philly.

0:07:21But every time I could fly Virgin, I did.

0:07:26And I, you know, they had a great nonstop service

0:07:30between Philly and San Francisco, which was, you know,

0:07:33Duh is a very common flight for me for work.

0:07:36Every time I could, I did.

0:07:39And I never once had to wait.

0:07:41It's just little things like that the people at the desk

0:07:44were super efficient and nice, and you'd get up there

0:07:48and they would be like, hey, and then you'd give 'em your ID

0:07:52and then they'd take your bag if you had a bag to check

0:07:55or give you a, and you were gone, and that was it.

0:07:57And you only had no lines, never.

0:07:59And good service on the plane.

0:08:01My favorite story about Virgin was one time,

0:08:04also I used to get,

0:08:06I got the cheapest upgrades to first class.

0:08:08I don't understand, they only had the way,

0:08:10every plane, they're probably all the same.

0:08:12They only had like eight first class seats.

0:08:14It was like two rows of two.

0:08:15- Yeah.

0:08:16- Or they still do, I guess.

0:08:17And every, almost every time I flew,

0:08:19I could get an upgrade from coach to first class

0:08:21for like a hundred bucks.

0:08:23And I'd be like, yeah.

0:08:24- In general, the first class seats,

0:08:26I mean, weren't super expensive when you compare it

0:08:28to what they are on other airlines.

0:08:31So yeah.

0:08:32- I flew first class on Virgin as a percentage

0:08:35higher than anywhere else,

0:08:36and it wasn't 'cause I had the points,

0:08:37it was because it was so cheap to upgrade.

0:08:38And the service was super terrific,

0:08:40the seats were super comfortable.

0:08:41But one time I was up in first class,

0:08:43and we actually pulled away from the gate a little bit.

0:08:47And then all of a sudden there was some kind of,

0:08:49not a unpleasant commotion,

0:08:51but some kind of thing with the phone,

0:08:53and they were like, hey, hey, let's go back.

0:08:55And they went back to the gate,

0:08:56and some poor sap who had a connecting flight that was late,

0:08:59They went back to the gate.

0:09:01I'd say it set us back about three minutes.

0:09:04They went back to the gate and let this guy on the plane.

0:09:06And this guy looked like he won the lottery because--

0:09:09- Yeah, you never hear about that, never.

0:09:12- I've never seen it before.

0:09:13I mean, maybe I've never seen it before

0:09:14because I wasn't in first class,

0:09:16but I mean, I think even in coaching,

0:09:17you kind of tell if they-- - No, yeah, I've never seen

0:09:19that. - If the plane stops

0:09:20backing up and goes forward again.

0:09:22And it was a nice thing, and I was happy for it,

0:09:25'cause the three minutes, what's the difference

0:09:26to the three minutes?

0:09:27coming out of it was coming back from SFO to Philly and so you're probably going to wait that

0:09:31time waiting to take off anyway but for that poor guy who almost missed his flight uh they just it

0:09:38was you know thousands of dollars in happiness for that guy and i was i mean i've seen i've seen much

0:09:43more of the sort of the opposite version of the story where the plane isn't even pushed back from

0:09:47the gate but they just closed the door and they will not open it even though the person's there

0:09:51the plane is still there and the door is closed and so it's just they will not reopen it for

0:09:55for those people, not with Virgin,

0:09:56but with countless other airlines have seen that.

0:09:59- Yeah, and they were like,

0:10:01the flight attendants were so nice.

0:10:02They were like, "Hey, hey, you're here.

0:10:04"You're on, you don't have to run anymore.

0:10:05"Take your time, go find your seat.

0:10:07"Do you want us to bring you a drink?"

0:10:08And they were like, he was like, "This is amazing.

0:10:11"Okay, sure, yes, I'll take a Coke."

0:10:14And it was--

0:10:15- But to your point, that was sort of like,

0:10:17that's also definitely a part of sort of

0:10:19the overall experience with Virgin,

0:10:21and I don't know what it is.

0:10:22I don't know if they just, if they hired

0:10:24from a different crop of people in the industry or whatnot,

0:10:27but people generally didn't seem to hate their jobs

0:10:30and hate their lives when they were working at Virgin,

0:10:32whereas they do very often, it seems like,

0:10:36on many other airlines.

0:10:37- Yeah, the big ones.

0:10:38And I think Alaska, and it's like, to your point,

0:10:41I would compare Alaska to Southwest.

0:10:43I haven't flown Alaska a lot.

0:10:44I've flown it, I think, at least twice to

0:10:47when there was the XOXO Conference in Portland,

0:10:50it coincided with XOXO at least for three years coincided with the tail end

0:11:00of the iPhone introduction events in September where just by somewhat

0:11:05coincidence or I guess not quite total coincidence but Apple targeting like the

0:11:09second week of September for iPhone events and XOXO targeting the end of the

0:11:13second week for XOXO at least twice for me to go to XOXO it made more

0:11:20sense to fly out to San Francisco at the beginning of the week, wait, and then fly San Francisco

0:11:25to Portland instead of flying all the way back to Philadelphia and then to Portland.

0:11:29And Alaska was like, you know, was the best airline, you know, had the most flights for

0:11:32that. So I've flown Alaska at least twice and I would compare it to Southwest. It's

0:11:36fine. It's fine. I mean, Southwest, I've flown it a lot actually. And I like it. It's sort

0:11:44of like, you know, it's like a nice commuter bus in the sky, right? Because they don't

0:11:49have assigned seats, but you get sort of these numbers

0:11:51and you stand and then you get on the plane,

0:11:53you can just pick whatever seat you want,

0:11:54and it's very simple.

0:11:56I think you always get the same type of plane,

0:11:59so that's sort of a similar experience.

0:12:01But again, it's nice, but it cannot compare

0:12:06to what Virgin America like.

0:12:08The one that does, supposedly,

0:12:11which I have not been on yet, I wonder if you have,

0:12:14is the JetBlue Mint experience.

0:12:16- Nope, 'cause we don't have JetBlue.

0:12:17- I've not been on that.

0:12:18Or maybe we do.

0:12:19We have JetBlue, but they don't fly anywhere I go out of Philly,

0:12:21I think.

0:12:22Yeah, and I think San Francisco has JetBlue as well,

0:12:25but I don't think the Mint thing is currently in play.

0:12:29Or at least it's not like-- if I would take JetBlue,

0:12:31I think I've taken it once before,

0:12:32and I've taken it to New York, because obviously most

0:12:35of the time I would take Virgin.

0:12:37But I don't think the Mint service operates

0:12:40between San Francisco and New York.

0:12:41Hopefully they change that maybe with the Virgin news.

0:12:43But it's like LA to New York, I think, has it.

0:12:45And people rave about it when they take that.

0:12:47They say it's at least as good as Virgin, if not better.

0:12:50I don't really know all the perks and everything,

0:12:54having not taken it before,

0:12:55but I guess it's one to look forward to potentially.

0:12:58- And it's just an industry.

0:13:01You've made it, in your column,

0:13:05you made it a sort of comparison to Apple and Dell

0:13:08or something like that.

0:13:09And maybe Alaska is maybe more like Lenovo,

0:13:11where a ThinkPad is a nice laptop,

0:13:14but it's not a Mac.

0:13:16You know, it's what happens if somebody really tries to make something really good in an

0:13:23industry where that was fine is generally considered good.

0:13:28Wow, you got really lucky.

0:13:32You know, my fight was fine.

0:13:34It was more or less on time.

0:13:35We landed more or less on time and none of my luggage got lost.

0:13:39Right?

0:13:40Yeah, it was funny.

0:13:41were I was chatting actually with a in our internal work slack with some people

0:13:46about the news and of course everyone sort of outraged right when it hits and

0:13:49so like there's this long thread going on and that was the thing that I quoted

0:13:52a co-worker mine Ken was like you know comparing it to yeah sort of the the PC

0:13:58versus Mac thing which I thought would be fun because of course that always you

0:14:02know draws such heated debate on both sides for that and whenever you compare

0:14:07anything to that situation. But I mean I think it does feel fairly apt, you

0:14:14know, having been myself, you know, a longtime PC user when I was growing up

0:14:18and then switching to the Mac and just like I was PC user and it was fine and

0:14:22like yeah I would get a faster PC and sometimes you know Windows would break

0:14:27down and and that would suck but when it worked it was fine and then you know

0:14:32it's uh it was a totally different experience once I switched over.

0:14:36Yeah, it's, I mean, do you have AirPods? I'll bet you do.

0:14:39Oh yeah, I love the AirPods.

0:14:40Alright, so I do too. It's my favorite, my favorite thing in the last few years,

0:14:44I think. Seriously, I love them so much. But that's, it epitomizes what Apple stands for,

0:14:49to me, which is, let's try to make this as nice as possible, even if it's such a simple thing as just

0:14:56putting two AirPods in your ear and having them just work when you hit play on your phone.

0:15:01Yep.

0:15:02and just taking it to like,

0:15:04just keep going into tenths of a decimal,

0:15:0899.999% nice, 99.999% nice,

0:15:12and sweating detail after detail.

0:15:14That's the Apple way, and it's not like Apple's perfect.

0:15:17My favorite example from recent years

0:15:19of Apple totally falling short on this

0:15:21is the remote control for the new Apple TV.

0:15:23- Oh yeah, yeah, totally, right.

0:15:24- Which is like, how did this ever come out of Apple as okay

0:15:28because this is so, it is fine,

0:15:31And it's not, you know what I mean?

0:15:33And it's not like a Comcast remote with 127 buttons, right?

0:15:38It is Apple-like in certain ways,

0:15:42but it's totally un-Apple-like in other ways.

0:15:44- It's Apple-like in certain ways,

0:15:45although I feel like everyone who has one

0:15:49has the exact same complaint,

0:15:50and that complaint is that you never know

0:15:52if you're holding it right side up or upside down.

0:15:53And how did just user testing,

0:15:57even amongst Apple employees, how did that not come up?

0:16:00I mean, that's like the first thing that comes up for everyone.

0:16:02Right.

0:16:03But to me, Virgin was shooting for the AirPods like experience from check-in to,

0:16:11you know, getting off the plane.

0:16:13That's what Virgin still stands for while they, while they exist.

0:16:16But, and something like Alaska or Southwest, which I'm, I'm a fan of, I'm a big fan of,

0:16:22so I've flown tons of miles on Southwest.

0:16:24I don't anymore just because they've sort of dropped nonstop routes between the cities

0:16:28I go to and I'm as the longer and more I fly the more resistant I am to taking anything other than a non-stop

0:16:36But I really I do like them and I know that they're not luxurious

0:16:41But the main reason I like them is that that they do seem to hire really nice people and the planes are very consistent

0:16:48The Southwest plane is always clean and always exactly the same, but it's nothing like virgin which was trying to say

0:16:55Let's make this really nice

0:16:56Let's make being in a coach seat like a decent humane experience

0:16:59And the thing that's really a bummer about it is you know, so when Virgin launched

0:17:06I remember it very well in San Francisco. There was a lot of pomp and circumstances there is with many sort of Richard Branson affiliated things

0:17:14But you know deservedly so and the whole criticism at the time though was like, yeah, it's a great experience

0:17:20But they'll never be able to keep this going. They're not going to be able to run it profitably and

0:17:25This is just not the way the airline industry works,

0:17:28you know, in this day and age.

0:17:30And, you know, I think they were running unprofitably

0:17:33for a long time.

0:17:34I do think that they eventually turned a profit

0:17:36or they were very close to it.

0:17:37And so there was some hope, you know, that like,

0:17:39look, you can actually build an airline

0:17:41with a great experience that actually makes business sense

0:17:43as well.

0:17:45And then of course, that just got thrown out the window

0:17:47and they merged, I mean, and all airlines continue

0:17:50to constantly merge and continue to constantly charge

0:17:54for more things, for overhead storage,

0:17:56just adding on fee after fee after fee.

0:17:59And that's just the, you know,

0:18:00that's the state of the industry,

0:18:02and Virgin, it seemed like, was trying to buck that trend,

0:18:04and it ultimately, you know, just didn't end up doing it.

0:18:09We'll see how Alaska sort of takes the mantle,

0:18:14but that's what's the real bummer about it.

0:18:17It just, it sort of showcases that I think

0:18:19it just probably can't ever work.

0:18:22- It seems like a lot of people I know,

0:18:24- And it does make some sense, but it's, to me,

0:18:26key to the continuing, I don't even know

0:18:31if I wanna say success, 'cause I'm not quite sure

0:18:34how profitable they are, but the continuing dominance

0:18:36of the major mediocre carriers, your Americans,

0:18:41Deltas, Uniteds, et cetera, is that they,

0:18:46for obvious reasons, they largely depend

0:18:49on regular frequent flyers, and people who,

0:18:53once you start racking up points on a certain airline,

0:18:57so many people-- - You're locked in, yeah.

0:18:58- So I don't feel that way.

0:19:00I've got platinum status-- - I don't either.

0:19:02- On American, which is pretty nice,

0:19:05and it gets me a couple of perks,

0:19:06and I've got miles I can cash in, whatever.

0:19:10But every time I book a flight,

0:19:12I still search for other airlines just to look.

0:19:15And if I found something better or cheaper

0:19:18on a different airline, like I still check

0:19:21to see if Southwest has restored a couple of non-stops

0:19:24to San Francisco every day.

0:19:25I look every once in a while.

0:19:27Like I would think about going back to Southwest

0:19:29on certain flights, especially if I could,

0:19:31or if I could get a better time of day

0:19:33or something like that.

0:19:35- Yeah, I'm in the same boat as you.

0:19:37I am not sort of beholden to any sort of point system.

0:19:40I have the virgin points, of course,

0:19:41but as we just talked about,

0:19:42like they didn't go all that many places,

0:19:44so obviously you would have to take out their airlines

0:19:45all the time.

0:19:46And so I think I have rewards programs at all of them.

0:19:49And I don't have huge status,

0:19:51but I have status at some of them, I would say.

0:19:52I fly quite a bit.

0:19:53But I'm not one of those people who is so adamant

0:19:57about maintaining that

0:19:59versus just maintaining a good experience.

0:20:01That said, I do know people who are the exact opposite.

0:20:03I know people who take flights to and from New York City

0:20:07just to maintain their status level.

0:20:09Like they don't actually stay overnight in the city.

0:20:13They just do a round trip flight on one day

0:20:16just to be able to maintain their status,

0:20:18- Which sounds absolutely insane.

0:20:20- It's just not that important to me.

0:20:25And I just don't get that much for it.

0:20:27Even as a platinum status person on American,

0:20:30I still don't get, I still would have to pay

0:20:32to join their quote unquote admirals club

0:20:34to get into the lounges.

0:20:37And I tend not to need lounges

0:20:42because I tend to just fly nonstop

0:20:44from home to my destination, my destination to home.

0:20:48And the only time I ever really need or wish I had access to a lounge is when my flight's

0:20:53delayed. If I get to the airport on time and the flight is significantly delayed and I've

0:20:58got two or three hours to burn, well then it would be nice to be in a lounge. In some

0:21:02places I can get in the Amex lounge, but other airports don't have one. But it's not...

0:21:08I don't even get it. I have platinum status and I still don't get it. So it doesn't make

0:21:11any sense to me why people are so loyal like that. But it really does seem to screw the

0:21:15upstart airlines. Like they can't, like one of the reasons they can't get

0:21:19traction is people are like, I've heard Virgin is nice but I've got points on

0:21:22United so here I go. Yep, yeah it's uh it's it's quite a racket that they that

0:21:28they run and like you know I think you know there's certain other airlines that

0:21:32go internationally that are that are obviously very nice. I'm actually getting

0:21:36ready to go to London and I'm gonna be on Virgin Atlantic, it's sort of sister

0:21:41thing. It was like the sister thing but they weren't exactly you know affiliated

0:21:44for a long time their points didn't even transfer. I think they do now.

0:21:47I think they set it up that way to make it easier to have happen what actually happened,

0:21:51which was to sell one or the other without selling the other.

0:21:56Yeah, and Branson wrote a post-mortem or whatever and sort of made some reference to it, like

0:22:05losing a child. But there was all sorts of issues with his ownership of it and whether

0:22:14or not he could have actually blocked anything. It seems like no, and so that's what happened.

0:22:18I've never flown Virgin Atlantic, but I would love to. And my favorite story about that,

0:22:22and it relates to the show, is way back in the day when Dan Benjamin and I were reviewing

0:22:28all the James Bond movies, we were talking about Quantum of Solace.

0:22:32Yes, I was just going to bring that up.

0:22:34Bond is on route from England to, where was he going?

0:22:39Somewhere in South America or the Caribbean, right?

0:22:44- Yeah, 'cause he's with the elder gentleman.

0:22:47- Yeah. - And they're having a drink.

0:22:49- Yeah, and he's bereft and he's getting tanked.

0:22:54There's a bar in the plane with a bartender

0:22:58and he's sitting at the bar drinking Vesper Martini.

0:23:00I don't know, like 18 of them or something.

0:23:04And it's a beautiful looking bar.

0:23:05And Dan and I were like, it was a cool scene,

0:23:07you know, and it's kind of unusual to see Bond

0:23:11actually get tanky.

0:23:13He's always drinking, but he never seems to be drunk.

0:23:15And here he is, you know, drinking himself into a stupor.

0:23:18But we were like, how unrealistic is it

0:23:20that there is a nice bar on a commercial air flight?

0:23:22And then all these people wrote to me,

0:23:24and they're like, oh no, no.

0:23:24- They have it, yeah.

0:23:25That's there, that's real. - Yeah, they were like,

0:23:26that was actually shot on a real Virgin Atlantic plane.

0:23:29It's like, oh my God, I've gotta get on that plane.

0:23:32- I mean, yeah, I've been on them.

0:23:33that's 100% legitimate, they have those bar areas,

0:23:37and it's amazing.

0:23:38It's not usually as quiet as it was, I would say,

0:23:41in that scene.

0:23:42There's usually much more people or activity around it,

0:23:45but yeah, that's legitimate.

0:23:47It's pretty amazing.

0:23:48- That was some of my favorite feedback ever.

0:23:52We were both like, totally preposterous.

0:23:54Who would ever have a commercial airplane

0:23:56with something like that?

0:23:57It's like something out of the 1960s,

0:23:59and all these people wrote to us,

0:24:01and they're like, oh yeah, it is real, and it is nice.

0:24:03It's fantastic.

0:24:05Yeah, and the thing with Virgin is-- so I rarely--

0:24:07Virgin Atlantic, I rarely take it because it's for--

0:24:10for some reason, it ends up being usually far more

0:24:12expensive than British Airways.

0:24:16And we just so happened to find a ticket that

0:24:18was roughly the same price.

0:24:20And so we decided to book that because you haven't taken

0:24:23Virgin, but if you ever go to London at Heathrow,

0:24:26they have an amazing lounge, too.

0:24:29It's probably the best lounge I've ever been in,

0:24:32including you can get a haircut, you can shower.

0:24:34You can-- (laughing)

0:24:36- That's pretty nice.

0:24:37- They have a spa, they have all this amazing stuff there.

0:24:39- The shower mode would be nice,

0:24:40'cause sometimes, for whatever reason,

0:24:42when you fly cross-country, especially for you,

0:24:44'cause you're coming from the West Coast,

0:24:45I always feel like it's been like three days

0:24:48since when I get off the plane in Europe,

0:24:51I always feel like, man, that felt like it was 72 hours.

0:24:54- Yeah, yes.

0:24:55So yeah, I highly recommend that if you're ever

0:25:00going overseas.

0:25:01All right, let me take a break here

0:25:02and thank our first friend of the show,

0:25:04our good friends at Squarespace.

0:25:07You guys know Squarespace.

0:25:08It's the best place to go to make a website,

0:25:10register, domain, anything like that.

0:25:12When you make your next move, you're gonna need a website.

0:25:16Why not start it at Squarespace?

0:25:19They've got beautiful templates.

0:25:20They've got beautiful types of sites

0:25:23to choose from to start.

0:25:25So if you're making an online store,

0:25:27you can start with a store

0:25:28and then choose a template from there.

0:25:30if you're making a podcast.

0:25:31You can start with something like a podcast

0:25:34and boom, you've got a podcast site.

0:25:36You didn't do any work.

0:25:37You can host your podcast right there from Squarespace.

0:25:40You name the type of site,

0:25:42you can build it with Squarespace.

0:25:43And I say this, this is what I think is

0:25:45the resistance people might have to Squarespace

0:25:47is you say, well, everybody signs up for Squarespace

0:25:50and you choose from a handful of templates

0:25:52and then my site's gonna look like a Squarespace site

0:25:54'cause it's not like that.

0:25:56They've got so many templates to choose from

0:25:58and so many ways to customize them

0:26:00that you don't even know

0:26:01when you're looking at a Squarespace site.

0:26:03I was just looking at a,

0:26:06I mentioned this on Daring Fireball last week.

0:26:08There's a new cheesesteak place

0:26:09pretty near our place here in Philadelphia called Cleaver's.

0:26:12Really great new sandwich shop here.

0:26:15I was looking at their website to place the takeout order.

0:26:18And one of the things you click on to see the menu loaded,

0:26:22instead of as a page, loaded as a standalone image,

0:26:25and I could see the URL,

0:26:26and I could see it was hosted at Squarespace.

0:26:27I was like, whoa, and all of a sudden I view source

0:26:29and look, and their whole site,

0:26:31which is a really nice site,

0:26:32but doesn't look anything like any other site

0:26:34I've ever seen, it's very much strongly branded

0:26:36like the restaurant built with Squarespace.

0:26:38But that makes total sense.

0:26:39Why would they waste time doing something

0:26:43outside their expertise, like building a website,

0:26:45when they could just do it at Squarespace

0:26:47and stick to building a great restaurant?

0:26:49So keep them in mind, next time you need a website

0:26:51for anything, check out Squarespace.

0:26:54Go to squarespace.com, you get a free demo,

0:26:57And once you sign up, remember this code, Gruber, just my last name, G-R-U-B-E-R, and

0:27:03you will get 10% off your purchase.

0:27:07My thanks to them for their continued support of this podcast.

0:27:10All right, next item on my list at least is your reaction to the new MacBook Pros.

0:27:18Yeah, so, and I know you have thoughts on this as well, and you, sir, the one thing

0:27:26that you linked to which I thought was interesting was a few weeks ago sort of a

0:27:31poll right of people how they feel about it and so my general take is pretty

0:27:37straightforward I just I don't hate the touch bar I just think it's totally

0:27:42useless I have a few apps you know that are sort of tailored for it including

0:27:48things like pixelmator handful of other things a bunch but a bunch more that

0:27:54aren't of course but I honestly just switched the sort of the fluid setting

0:28:02to be back to just the standard sort of F and or no I didn't sorry I didn't use

0:28:07the the F keys I used the function is I use the actual brightness and all that

0:28:12stuff because I like I just found myself going to that like way way more than I

0:28:17would use any of the sort of dynamic options that the touch bar would off

0:28:20offer and I just I don't I have a hard time I know it's early but I have a hard

0:28:26time ever seeing that it becomes like this great feature of the MacBook Pro do

0:28:32you disagree with that no I don't disagree I feel like it exists I feel

0:28:39like the touch bar as we have it right now exists in a sort of no-man's land

0:28:44where you cannot I don't think it's fair to trash it I don't think it's fair to

0:28:48say this is great I feel like it's it's nuanced now that said I don't own one so

0:28:56I've got I spent about two or three weeks when they first came out playing

0:29:00with the review units I had multiple of them but mostly spent the time with the

0:29:0413-inch because that's the size I like and I love touch ID yes I don't use the

0:29:12I don't use the escape key as much as some people do,

0:29:16but I do use it, and I do still even now,

0:29:19even as somebody who doesn't use the escape key

0:29:21all the time, I question whether they should not have

0:29:25left a hardware traditional escape key

0:29:28and made the touch bar just run from escape,

0:29:32have an escape key in the upper left corner,

0:29:35the touch ID in the upper right,

0:29:37and have the touch bar exist between the two.

0:29:40I think that would have solved an awful lot of problems.

0:29:42it more symmetry as well because it's you know they have one button on one

0:29:45side why not have the escape button even if they change the size of it and made

0:29:48it square sort of like the right touch ideas but make it something you can

0:29:52actually click and I think that would have I I do feel like just reading

0:29:57Twitter reading feedback from readers and stuff like that I feel like an an

0:30:01awful lot of the criticism of the touch bar relates to the escape key as for the

0:30:07utility of the touch part itself it's hard to say I do I find I do I remember

0:30:12thinking it was really nice to adjust the brightness with the touch bar.

0:30:15I find that so much more tedious honestly to do it that way.

0:30:21So here's before I switched it back to being sort of the brightness as

0:30:27sort of default buttons so it has like you know brightness and things like

0:30:30bring up expose and stuff like that you can there's a setting that you can you

0:30:33know move it to rather than being the dynamic touch bar it's it's sort of your

0:30:38old standard buttons and I did that because I was actually using I think

0:30:42it's when you hit the function the FN key I think that would bring up the old

0:30:46ones and I was just using that all the time because even though there are what

0:30:49there is a brightness button on the dynamic version of the touch bar when

0:30:54you hit it then you yeah then you have to scroll sort of up or down and so

0:30:59often I just want like you know one little knit more of brightness not like

0:31:03I don't need the sort of scrubbing, you know,

0:31:06to see all the way down and all the way up

0:31:08what the difference is.

0:31:09It's like one of those features that just seems like

0:31:11a cool option on paper, but when you actually use it,

0:31:14it's much less useful.

0:31:15- Yeah.

0:31:16So I don't know.

0:31:17I can see the mixed feelings about it.

0:31:19I feel like the biggest thing that it needs

0:31:23is haptic feedback.

0:31:25I feel like, and I was reminded of it just recently

0:31:29because I haven't used it a lot

0:31:33'cause I don't personally have a need,

0:31:34but I'm fascinated by the new Clips app,

0:31:36and I think it's really well done,

0:31:38even though I realize some of the initial complaints

0:31:40from other people are that they're a little confused by it.

0:31:42But I think it's only confusing at first

0:31:45because it's ambitious and tries to do a lot,

0:31:47and so there's a lot in there,

0:31:49but I feel like everything that they've done,

0:31:51once you get it, it's pretty logical.

0:31:53But the thing that made me think of the Touch Bar

0:31:56is when you've got multiple clips in a project,

0:32:01clips in a project in a row.

0:32:04And if you want to rearrange them,

0:32:05you can force touch on one,

0:32:08and you get like a little,

0:32:09you get the haptic feedback as you drag it along

0:32:12to rearrange clips in the timeline.

0:32:14And it feels like,

0:32:16so you want to move the one that's in the fourth spot

0:32:18to the second spot.

0:32:19As you drag it between second and third,

0:32:21you get a little--

0:32:22- It rumbles and you can feel it, right?

0:32:23- Yeah, you can feel like,

0:32:24it's like you're dragging it over physical slots.

0:32:27And it's so nice.

0:32:28And I just thought,

0:32:29boy, the touch bar would feel so much better

0:32:30if it had a little bit of feedback like that.

0:32:33- And that speaks to, I think it was Michael Lop, right,

0:32:37who wrote a post about the usability factor

0:32:41of the touch bar, because it's almost impossible to use

0:32:43without looking at it, which is also very odd, right?

0:32:46Like, because that's not what that row of buttons has been

0:32:49for the entire life of a MacBook.

0:32:52And so to your point, like, if they had some sort

0:32:54of haptic feedback where you could actually tell

0:32:56what you were doing while still keying on the screen,

0:32:59like for scrubbing or doing some other action,

0:33:02that would be significantly better

0:33:04than having to look down

0:33:06because you don't know where you are.

0:33:08- Yeah, and I do feel like that's part of it.

0:33:10Some of the ones in the middle, I almost never use.

0:33:16On a traditional F key row,

0:33:18I don't really, I almost never adjust

0:33:21the brightness of my keyboard.

0:33:22- Keyboard, yeah, same.

0:33:23- Sometimes it's like I'll be on a dark flight,

0:33:29all right, yeah, I'll adjust the brightness of my keyboard.

0:33:32But I'll just do it once,

0:33:33and it's fine for me to be looking at it.

0:33:35But for like, micro-adjustments

0:33:37to the brightness of the screen,

0:33:39I can do it without looking,

0:33:41just by going up with my left hand to the top left.

0:33:45I know where the escape key is,

0:33:46and the next two are brightness.

0:33:48And even if I'm wrong,

0:33:49even if I go up and I hit brightness up,

0:33:51even though I wanted brightness down,

0:33:53I can see what happened right away,

0:33:54and I know I'm right next door,

0:33:56and just slide my finger,

0:33:58and do that without looking.

0:34:00- And I'm with you with that,

0:34:02and I'm the exact same way with volume,

0:34:03and both of those are now problematic on the touch bar.

0:34:07You know, they look nice, like that nice, you know,

0:34:10little scrubber and everything, but it just,

0:34:12I do not like it at all.

0:34:15I mean, I don't hate it, but I just don't see,

0:34:19like I said, I switch back to sort of the old standards,

0:34:22and like you said, they're not physical buttons,

0:34:25and there's no haptic feedback, so they're harder to use,

0:34:27So I have to actually pay attention to what I'm doing.

0:34:29And then I also, I do think, I agree that Touch ID

0:34:32is by far the best part of it.

0:34:34But the weird thing there is that I almost never get

0:34:38to use it because I do have an Apple Watch

0:34:40and I'm always wearing the Apple Watch

0:34:41and that unlocks faster than the Touch ID does.

0:34:45So before you can even reach up to the Touch ID, it's done.

0:34:48So there's no point.

0:34:49- Yeah, well, it's good for purchases or whatever.

0:34:51- Yeah, for purchases.

0:34:52- But logging in is the big, is the one that you do.

0:34:56I log in and out or open it from sleep

0:34:58and log in way more frequently than I buy stuff.

0:35:01- Yeah.

0:35:02And so why do you think that they did the touch bar?

0:35:08Because like so part of the thing that I wrote

0:35:10was sort of the title of it.

0:35:12It was a great laptop stagnation.

0:35:15The notion being that we've sort of reached

0:35:19peak form factor of the laptop.

0:35:21And I know that's dangerous to say

0:35:22for sort of any technology that we've reached peak

0:35:24because there's always going to be some level of innovation.

0:35:26And I think I made the quip that maybe we'll

0:35:28have Phil Schiller on stage saying,

0:35:30can't innovate anymore my ass when they do something

0:35:34new with the MacBook.

0:35:35But my only line of thinking is either they're

0:35:38going to one day try to make it a bigger screen

0:35:43area, like the keyboard tray being more maybe

0:35:46like haptic digital keys, something like that,

0:35:51or not even replacing the entire keyboard,

0:35:54but just making that a bigger area, you know,

0:35:57for different things that they can dynamically do.

0:35:59I mean, that has to be some line of thinking, right?

0:36:03It can't just be this touch bar,

0:36:04which isn't that interesting.

0:36:06- I guess, I don't know, but I find it worrisome

0:36:09if their goal is to replace hardware keyboard

0:36:12with a virtual keyboard,

0:36:14because I can't see how that would,

0:36:16like whatever my,

0:36:18I kind of still prefer my older MacBook keyboard

0:36:22to the new one.

0:36:24shallow keys yeah it's in New York but it's deeper keys but after two or three

0:36:28weeks my feelings went from I like the old one better - oh I have mixed

0:36:33feelings because I also feel though that my old one they feel loose and jank

0:36:37jank right and resin the new ones even though they have shallower feel so

0:36:41clicking them feels worse because it's shallow but just resting my fingers on

0:36:46them feels better because they don't wiggle around they feel more premium

0:36:49Yep. And I had a problem at first. I had a really weird problem and I can't explain why, but the new keyboards in the Macbook and the Mac, the just plain Macbook and the Macbook Pro have bigger keys and less space between the keys.

0:37:07The keyboard takes up the exact same amount of area.

0:37:10And so the distance between just pick two keys,

0:37:13like the center of the A key and the center of the F key

0:37:17is exactly the same.

0:37:19So your fingers resting on the home row

0:37:22are exactly in the same position.

0:37:23But for some reason, because the keys are bigger,

0:37:27I felt for a while like my fingers were spread out more.

0:37:32- Yeah, I get that.

0:37:35I think that's something I needed to get used to.

0:37:37- I especially notice it because I use the iPad keyboard

0:37:41all the time and those are smaller keys, right?

0:37:44And so that's when I really notice it.

0:37:46And I honestly, I think I prefer the iPad keyboard,

0:37:49as weird as that sounds.

0:37:50It's not a perfect keyboard, but maybe it is,

0:37:55like you're talking about, sort of the size of the keys,

0:37:57just something about it feels more familiar

0:37:59than typing on the newer keyboards.

0:38:01- Yeah, I can kind of see that.

0:38:03Like you're talking about like the smart keypad.

0:38:05Yeah, yeah, the one that Apple made.

0:38:06It's almost like on the smart keyboard cover,

0:38:09it celebrates the shallowness of the movement.

0:38:13Whereas on the MacBook, it's like, man,

0:38:16I still wish that these keys went in further a little bit.

0:38:19But I can live with that.

0:38:21The difference between my feelings

0:38:25about the new MacBook Pro keyboard

0:38:27and the previous generation MacBook Pro keyboard,

0:38:30I have thoughts, but the thoughts are much narrower

0:38:35than the thoughts between what we have now

0:38:38and a hypothetical virtual touch bar

0:38:40that was the whole keyboard.

0:38:42- Yeah, well, what do you think about this?

0:38:44So the other thing that I've chatted with some folks about

0:38:48is the notion of one way that I think

0:38:51they could have alleviated some of the touch bar criticism

0:38:55is also just putting it at the bottom of the keyboard.

0:38:59So in other words, keeping the function row as it was and just adding a new row because

0:39:03like, and especially on the MacBook.

0:39:05So here's the thought here.

0:39:08Right now they made the touch pad itself, right?

0:39:12Massive.

0:39:13It's pretty big now.

0:39:14I think it's bigger than it needs to be for anything.

0:39:16And so you could shave that down a little bit.

0:39:19And I think if you wanted to do some sort of touch bar type thing, put it just above

0:39:23the touch pad and sort of make that the whole touch area, especially because Apple's whole

0:39:28as we all know, is that they're not going to do a touchscreen Macbook or iMac, Macbook Pro, anything.

0:39:34And the weirdness of this whole dynamic right now is that they made a touch area that's so close to

0:39:41the screen but isn't the screen and you know they make they have the the famous sort of picture of

0:39:46like you know with a crossed out arm or like pointing at the screen because it's just not

0:39:51ergonomic right and it's not that much different in my book to sort of have to go up to this top

0:39:57row and have to sort of manipulate touch that way, I would have been much more happy if

0:40:03where my hands already rest, sort of at the bottom, you tried to do something with the

0:40:06touch bar.

0:40:07I don't know.

0:40:09Just looking down at my MacBook as you say this, my problem with that is that my hands

0:40:12would cover it most of the time.

0:40:14I think the advantage of having it at the top is that you can see it, your hands don't

0:40:17cover it, whereas this way your hands cover it until you go to look at it.

0:40:21But maybe that's okay.

0:40:22I don't know.

0:40:23I don't know if they've tinkered with that idea or not, but maybe that's okay because

0:40:27It doesn't matter if you see it or not because by the time you go to do something on it

0:40:30You were already moving your hands

0:40:31I don't know right especially if you have to I mean if they acknowledge that you have to be looking at it to use it

0:40:36already

0:40:37And I just I feel like I don't know I could see I think some people push back in that like with an ocean of

0:40:44Well what your palms could rest on and it could mess it up or something obviously

0:40:47Apple has all the palm detection stuff for the iPad already. I'm sure they could figure that out but

0:40:52I just think like for certain types of things, certainly some of the things that they were showing off like the DJing and all that kind of, you know, fun stuff,

0:41:00you might not be, you know, really needing to use the keyboard as much as sort of the touch area to toggle controls and stuff.

0:41:07And so in that situation, it might make a little bit more sense.

0:41:10But I don't know. I mean, I assume, like you said, they maybe tried something or thought about it at least, and they determined that that wasn't the way to go.

0:41:17Man, I don't know. What do you think about the weight and the size?

0:41:22The weight and the size are great. I mean it's not, so I have, right now I have a bunch of machines.

0:41:28I have an older MacBook Pro for, that's my work machine that sort of was given to me by the

0:41:37people who dish out computers at work. And so that's I think like a two and a half or three

0:41:42year old MacBook, so an older style MacBook Pro. Then I have the MacBook, the small 13 inch one,

0:41:49and then I got the Touch Bar MacBook Pro. And so my other issue there is that while it is obviously

0:41:59more svelte and lighter than the older MacBook Pro I have, it's not anywhere near as light and

0:42:07and is felt as the MacBook itself.

0:42:09And so if I'm going somewhere where

0:42:12I would want sort of the most portability--

0:42:15obviously, I know that most people don't have three options,

0:42:18of course.

0:42:18But when people would ask, like, well, I

0:42:19just want the most portability, I would say,

0:42:22go with the MacBook.

0:42:23I mean, it's still--

0:42:24the main problem there now is the one USB-C port.

0:42:30And honestly, I carry around the dongle, of course,

0:42:34and it's mildly annoying from time to time.

0:42:37But I'm not sure it would even be that much better

0:42:38if it had four USB-C ports,

0:42:40because USB-C is still not,

0:42:42doesn't seem quite as ubiquitous,

0:42:44certainly for the things like,

0:42:45I have to loop in things for work all the time

0:42:48and sort of hook up different USB-C stuff,

0:42:50and I almost always need a converter still.

0:42:53So I'm just not sure that that would even

0:42:54sort of alleviate the pain.

0:42:55So my biggest problem with the older MacBook,

0:42:58and I have the one that came out a couple years ago,

0:42:59so it's fairly slow, but I think a lot of people said

0:43:02that this sort of newer version that came out

0:43:06several months ago is significantly faster. So I would go with that one.

0:43:11The thing I like the most about it, and I think it speaks to your point that we're

0:43:15sort of approaching peak form factor, is—and it was to me the part that made my personal

0:43:242014, I think—I get mixed up at how old a two-year-old—I think I got it in 2014.

0:43:31Anyway, yeah, that makes sense. My 2014 13-inch MacBook Pro, the biggest difference to me

0:43:35and it's petty and it has nothing to do with actual computing, but it's the ease with which

0:43:42I can open the display. The display just lifts up perfectly and if I want to adjust it slightly,

0:43:50I just put one finger on it, on the new ones that is. It's just absolute, the perfect amount

0:43:56of resistance where it never moves if I don't want it to and when I do want to move it,

0:44:00it's the least amount of energy possible. It makes my old one feel like it's way too

0:44:04hard and heavy to lift. And to me, that's the ideal that the new MacBooks have ever

0:44:12more closely approached to. I don't know about the regular MacBook. Like, when you

0:44:17lift a MacBook, is it so light that the whole thing lifts up, or can you do it with one

0:44:20hand?

0:44:21Yeah, it's a—right. I would say it's a little bit too light for that. I still feel

0:44:25the need to sort of, yeah, like, you know, weigh it down a little bit while I'm lifting

0:44:29it up.

0:44:30Whereas the new MacBook Pros, you don't have to do that. The new MacBook Pros, even

0:44:32- [Peter] No, in theory, it's worse to be heavier,

0:44:35all things considered.

0:44:37- Right. - If they could make one

0:44:38that was every bit as fast and powerful as the MacBook,

0:44:41yes, they would do it.

0:44:42They're not gonna make it heavier.

0:44:44Just, the Apple is not gonna make MacBooks heavier

0:44:46just to make it easier to open them in the future.

0:44:50But right now, I feel like the MacBook Pros

0:44:52are at this wonderful ideal between the weight of the base,

0:44:57where the keyboard and the battery and everything are,

0:44:59and the lightness of the display,

0:45:01and the ability to lift it up.

0:45:04- I agree, and so, right, so the form factor is great, right?

0:45:07It's so great that it's like, it's been whittled down

0:45:10to sort of this, you know, that level of sort of perfection

0:45:15for exactly what you're talking about.

0:45:17What else would they possibly do to it,

0:45:19beyond like, you know, expanding Touch Bar

0:45:21and doing other things to it,

0:45:22but it's like, that's the form factor.

0:45:24What else are you gonna do to that?

0:45:26You can't really change that now.

0:45:28- No, other than, and again,

0:45:32it's not really a change of the form factor,

0:45:33but in theory, at some point,

0:45:35I presume that they're gonna,

0:45:37it won't be aluminum forever.

0:45:39I mean, I feel like the MacBook still has a decade

0:45:43maybe more ahead of it.

0:45:45Is it gonna really be aluminum for 20 or 30 years?

0:45:49I don't know.

0:45:50So new materials, you know?

0:45:52But basically, I do think the form factor,

0:45:57And for certain tasks, it is a wonderful,

0:46:00wonderful form factor.

0:46:01And I just feel like, don't mess with it.

0:46:02And I do wonder, there's a part of me that wonders

0:46:05if the touch bar is basically a mess with it

0:46:08for the sake of messing with it change.

0:46:11- Right, that's exactly what I was basically

0:46:13alluding to in that post.

0:46:15You know, they felt like, look, we're sort of

0:46:18at the perfect storm of two things right now, right?

0:46:21So what we were just talking about,

0:46:22sort of the form factor is, we've whittled it down

0:46:25to near perfection, right?

0:46:27And then on the flip side, we have sort of the CPUs

0:46:31and the internals are basically not getting

0:46:33that much faster now because as Moore's Law has slowed down,

0:46:38we're sort of at the point where it's very hard

0:46:44to rationalize a year-to-year upgrade.

0:46:47It's hard to rationalize a two year-to-year upgrade, right,

0:46:50for a MacBook Pro because it's just not that much faster

0:46:54than what the state of the art was two years ago.

0:46:57And so we have those two things coming into play.

0:47:00And so when Apple's trying to think about,

0:47:02well, what do we do this year to get people excited

0:47:05about potentially buying the new machine?

0:47:07You can change the colors of it.

0:47:11They've done that a little bit, of course,

0:47:12with some gold and rose gold options.

0:47:15And I don't think that that really moves the needle, though,

0:47:17on making someone purchase a new one.

0:47:19And so this Touch Bar thing,

0:47:21it feels like to me that was some idea,

0:47:24like let's try this, you know,

0:47:26let's see if this is interesting.

0:47:28And that's a dangerous game for Apple to play, I think.

0:47:31- I totally agree.

0:47:33And I wonder about it.

0:47:35And it is clearly to me their most important product.

0:47:37I know we just had the whole thing with the Mac Pro

0:47:39and that there's iMacs coming out and stuff like that,

0:47:41but the MacBooks are clearly the bread and butter

0:47:44of the Mac lineup.

0:47:46You know, if they had to cut back for some reason,

0:47:49you know, that's the last Macs to go

0:47:51are gonna be the MacBooks.

0:47:53And I wonder, you and I have talked about this before,

0:47:56and I know a lot of people obviously

0:47:57have differing thoughts on this.

0:47:58But like, so the other part, I think,

0:48:00towards the end of that post I wrote was basically,

0:48:04I'm very much in the camp of,

0:48:07I would love to just do everything on an iPad.

0:48:09I'm like 90, I'm 95, let's say, percent of the way there.

0:48:13The problem is that other 5% matters,

0:48:15and so I just can't do it yet.

0:48:17I would love to be in that camp, though.

0:48:19Are you, and I know you're definitely, you know,

0:48:22still in the MacBook camp,

0:48:23but if they could do, if they had full sort of parity,

0:48:27maybe not quite as easy to do certain things and vice versa,

0:48:32but if they had sort of full parity

0:48:34in terms of functionality,

0:48:36would you want to use an iPad more than you use the MacBook?

0:48:42- No, I don't think so.

0:48:43I think the longer time goes on,

0:48:45the less likely I am to even want to use an iPad.

0:48:50I feel like I have the clarity now,

0:48:52And it might, I feel like, but I don't feel like

0:48:54I speak to the mass market.

0:48:57It's, I have so many little things,

0:49:00little custom nerd scripts and things that I have

0:49:04set to keyboard shortcuts on my Mac

0:49:06that I can't do on the iPad.

0:49:08And that even if I wanted to do through Workflow

0:49:11or something like that.

0:49:12And I'm super, super happy that Apple bought Workflow

0:49:14and seems to want to keep it around

0:49:16and maybe they'll integrate it in the OS.

0:49:19But like, I have a shortcut that is a system wide service

0:49:24that I made so that I can convert the selected text

0:49:28in any app from Markdown to HTML.

0:49:31And the key command I made for it is command shift K.

0:49:35I don't know why, I forget why.

0:49:40'Cause M, 'cause command shift M is like minimize Windows.

0:49:42And so I went to K, Mark.

0:49:45I don't know, but I don't even have to think about it.

0:49:46I had to pause to remember it

0:49:47my fingers just know it and I've had it for years. Yeah, but you know, so the iPad Pros,

0:49:53like we were just talking about, they, you know, you can get the the keyboard that's with it and

0:49:57they, you know, they have Command and Shift and K still. I guess that in theory they could add,

0:50:03that they could add stuff to the system software that would enable something like that in theory.

0:50:08But the form factor doesn't speak to me either. Like, last week when I was flying home from

0:50:17from San Francisco after the shindig at Cupertino.

0:50:22I was at the gate at the terminal

0:50:27and I had just a couple of minutes

0:50:28before they started boarding.

0:50:30And somebody DM'd me that I had a typo in a DF post.

0:50:35And instead of fixing it on my phone,

0:50:38I just, I knew I had like a couple minutes.

0:50:41I just quick took out my MacBook from my backpack,

0:50:46opened it and just without even sitting down,

0:50:48just held it in the palm of my hand and opened it,

0:50:51logged in, fixed it, shut it, put it back in my backpack.

0:50:56Like I don't see how you could do that on an iPad.

0:50:59You could do it, but you wouldn't have the hardware keyboard.

0:51:01There's no way you can just sit there and stand

0:51:02and connect the hardware keyboard and--

0:51:05- Yeah, I get that.

0:51:06And I'm sort of the same way.

0:51:08That's one of the sort of 5% thing

0:51:09is definitely on the writing side of things.

0:51:11So I actually do a lot of writing on the iPad,

0:51:14but I'll sort of write in the app Ulysses

0:51:16and then I basically export it to Medium

0:51:20or wherever I'm gonna publish.

0:51:21And I don't publish though from there

0:51:24'cause I wait to do some of the formatting stuff

0:51:26that I feel like I can just have a much better handle on

0:51:29using on a MacBook.

0:51:30And so I wait to publish until after there.

0:51:33But that's sort of one of the larger parts of the 5%

0:51:38that is still holding me back.

0:51:39But in my book, I'm quite different, I guess,

0:51:43from you in that regard

0:51:44because I, like my ideal computing experience would be

0:51:48where I could go on a trip,

0:51:50not have to take any MacBook with me,

0:51:53just take the iPad Pro with the keyboard cover.

0:51:58And you know, I do it right now for short little trips

0:52:01or you know, just on a daily basis,

0:52:02like if I'm going to just do email

0:52:04and then do some reading,

0:52:06and I go to a sort of local cafe,

0:52:08I just love grabbing that thing and walking out the door,

0:52:10don't have to bring a bag.

0:52:11It's so, it just feels like this is the way

0:52:15I want to be doing computing in my life.

0:52:18And I don't wanna have, you know,

0:52:20even as we were just talking about,

0:52:22even as felt as the MacBooks are now.

0:52:24I just, there's too much going on.

0:52:26I like the simplicity of doing everything through the iPad.

0:52:29- I totally see the appeal of it,

0:52:30but it doesn't, it just doesn't speak to me.

0:52:33I, you know, and I like iPad.

0:52:35But for me, and again, I'm a big proponent,

0:52:38I have been for years, fighting against the argument

0:52:41that it's fundamentally only good for consumption

0:52:43and not for creation.

0:52:44I've argued it, but for me personally,

0:52:46that actually is very true, that I tend to use it.

0:52:49I actually have left the cover of mine for a while now,

0:52:52and I just have it with no cover, and I read tons on it,

0:52:55and I read lots of Twitter, and I bookmark things

0:52:59to post it during Fireball later

0:53:01from a different machine from it,

0:53:02but I tend not to do any actual typing on it.

0:53:05But I can see the appeal.

0:53:06I totally see the appeal.

0:53:08And I would totally see the appeal

0:53:09for long form writing too.

0:53:11I feel like the longer the thing you're writing,

0:53:13the more pleasant it is.

0:53:15And like when I wrote, like I did,

0:53:16I enjoyed writing my review of the iPad Pro

0:53:18on the iPad Pro because it was a long review.

0:53:21And I do kind of like that it is naturally distraction free.

0:53:26I find I never use the distraction free full screen modes

0:53:30on the Mac for any app ever,

0:53:32because I find that it's just,

0:53:34just gets in the way when I wanna get out of it.

0:53:35Whereas on the iPad, it's totally natural.

0:53:38It's, you know, and I'm a big believer in that in general.

0:53:40I feel anything you tack on to a system afterwards

0:53:44is never as good as if it was there from the beginning.

0:53:46So full screen mode on the Mac, to me,

0:53:49I use it for video and that's about it.

0:53:51But otherwise, to me, it feels tacked on

0:53:53because the Mac wasn't designed at the start,

0:53:55it was designed to have everything in Windows

0:53:58that are overlapping, you can drag around.

0:54:00Whereas the iPad was designed from the ground up

0:54:02to have full screen apps.

0:54:04- Yeah, and I mean, I, so I do a lot of, you know,

0:54:07anything that I write basically, like you said,

0:54:09sort of that's longer than just a blurb

0:54:10or something like that.

0:54:11I try to do on the iPad.

0:54:13And I just, it's something about it reminds me

0:54:14of like when I was a kid growing up,

0:54:16going to my father's office and like they had typewriters

0:54:18and just using the typewriter, right?

0:54:21I mean, I know it's obviously very different,

0:54:22but something about this focus thing

0:54:25and it's almost like, you know,

0:54:26there's a blank sheet of paper in front of you

0:54:28and the words are magically appearing on it.

0:54:30- Yeah, and most things in my life,

0:54:33most things in my life are,

0:54:35that I'm in control of are a complete mess.

0:54:37Like my desk is usually just a complete

0:54:39Andy Rooney-style mess of papers and odd objects

0:54:44and boxes and all sorts of stuff.

0:54:46So lots of things I have are a complete mess.

0:54:50Other things though, I try to keep obsessively neat.

0:54:53And like the Daring Fireball homepage

0:54:55would be a fine example.

0:54:56There's no clutter, you know, I aspire to that.

0:54:59I wish that I had the organizational ability

0:55:02and the wherewithal to have everything in my life

0:55:05be like that.

0:55:06When I see pictures of people who have these minimal

0:55:09offices, I covet them.

0:55:11I do, I see the appeal.

0:55:13And I do, I look at my Mac with all of these windows,

0:55:18like if I go to Exposé or whatever and see how many apps

0:55:20I have running and how many windows are actually

0:55:22overlapping, sometimes my Mac looks like a mess.

0:55:26And I do, I like the way that the iPad,

0:55:29even if you open a second app, I love how neat it is

0:55:32that if you have like the Messages app on the right

0:55:36in a narrow iPhone width column,

0:55:39and your other thing, whether it's Safari

0:55:41or your writing app in a square to the left of it,

0:55:44I love how neatly that's organized,

0:55:46where there's no overlap, there's no shadows

0:55:48from windows showing depth,

0:55:50it's just two rectangles perfectly aligned.

0:55:55I love that, and I can see how that is soothing,

0:55:59mentally soothing to people and appealing.

0:56:02Since it's sort of the perfect segue and there may not be much to talk about but

0:56:08I'm just curious like so obviously Apple released the sort of you know the

0:56:13cheaper iPad version but they didn't do anything you know as was rumored by many

0:56:18various sites for actual new iPad hardware and so I presume now that

0:56:25we're at the end of April we're not going to see any sort of event before

0:56:27WWDC. Do they do that at WWDC? Do they wait for the fall?

0:56:32I don't know. It's very intriguing to me that the supply chain rumor mill seemed to

0:56:37think it was going to happen either last month or the first week of April or something like

0:56:44that. I agree with you. I don't hear any rumblings to the ground that there's anything

0:56:48coming before WWDC. I almost feel like it's something that maybe they've successfully

0:56:55kept under wraps. So it could happen at WWDC, but if they wait until the fall, I almost

0:57:03feel like they've got to wait until October because it sounds like...

0:57:06So after iPhone. Right, because I don't think they'd want to

0:57:09share the stage with iPhone because it sounds like they've got a very exciting iPhone to

0:57:13unveil. And if it's on schedule, it'll be like the second week of September, as I said

0:57:18before. I mean, they've been pretty consistent on that for three or four years. And I don't

0:57:23think they'd want to share the stage but they could in theory you know it may not

0:57:28be it may come naturally if there's you know like a shared design language of a

0:57:33more edge to edge display it could make sense to unveil them side by side I

0:57:39don't know but it would make more sense to me if they did iPhones in September

0:57:42and iPads in October and you but you don't think that they would do it at

0:57:47WWDC?

0:57:48I guess they could,

0:57:51but it depends how much these new iPads,

0:57:55which at least some of the, you know,

0:57:57one of them is rumored to be a more edge to edge display

0:57:59where the, you know,

0:58:00that the 9.7 inch iPad is still going to be 9.7 inches

0:58:04as a device,

0:58:06but that the screen will be 10 point something inches

0:58:09instead of 9.7 inches,

0:58:10because it's going to take up more of the front face.

0:58:13But that sounds to me like what the rumor is

0:58:15for the iPhone.

0:58:16And if they don't want to spoil it, right?

0:58:19That they want the iPhone to come out first.

0:58:22But is that, am I overthinking it?

0:58:28Am I overthinking their willingness

0:58:32to just let the product that's ready to ship first

0:58:34ship first, whether it's the iPhone or not?

0:58:36I don't know.

0:58:38- Yeah, and if there was some sort of marquee feature

0:58:41in iOS 11, you know, that was sort of iPad,

0:58:46more iPad focused maybe.

0:58:48But yeah, there hadn't been much rumors about iOS 11 at all.

0:58:53- No.

0:58:54- Even though we're fairly close, which is interesting.

0:58:58- Well, other than the fact that there, for a while,

0:59:01I don't know if you've noticed this,

0:59:02but I've heard rumors for a while that months ago,

0:59:06I guess more or less when iOS 10 came out last WWDC,

0:59:10there after the event was over there were rumors beforehand that that Apple

0:59:15might unveil some iPad specific iPad Pro specific features you know and that the

0:59:24keynote came and went and there were none and then in the aftermath the word

0:59:27was well that got punted from 10.0 but it's gonna come in like 10.2 or

0:59:31something 10.2 or 10.3 but we've gotten to 10.3 and it didn't happen and

0:59:36and there's not going to be a 10.4 between now and June,

0:59:40because all hands are working on iOS 11.

0:59:44- Right.

0:59:45- So whether that ships in iOS 11.0 or not,

0:59:49or gets punted once again to the first big update

0:59:53in December or January of 11.2, I don't know.

0:59:56But that's the rumor.

0:59:57But there have been rumors since this time last year

0:59:59that they have iPad Pro-specific improvements to the OS

1:00:04for multitasking and stuff like that.

1:00:07And if that is the case, then we may have just answered our riddle, right, that they

1:00:11would launch that and presumably they would want to have new iPad Pro hardware to show

1:00:16whatever that functionality is off, since the iPad Pro would be relatively old at that

1:00:22point, right, over a year between iterations.

1:00:26Right.

1:00:27Well, and the 12-inch one, the 13-inch one, would be a year and a half old.

1:00:32at this point. I don't know, but I mean both of them launched with, I feel, a lot

1:00:38of headroom to wait for the next version because they really are pretty fast for

1:00:42iPads. I mean, you know, they're both, you know, faster than—I don't know if

1:00:45they're faster than the current MacBook, but I think they are, and they're

1:00:48certainly faster than the MacBook that you're talking about, the original MacBook

1:00:52with one port. I mean, that's how fast they are. Yep, I'm using the big iPad Pro

1:00:57right now, which I almost never use. Again, speaking to, obviously, as we all do, we

1:01:02just buy a bunch of devices, probably more than we need, but it is nice when you're sort of sitting

1:01:08at a desk. It's a nice sort of second screen. Yeah, I don't know. So I feel like they need

1:01:12to though, and I feel like selling points on changes to the OS to make it a little bit more,

1:01:21you know, bring the iPad, especially the iPad Pro, a little bit more towards the Mac in terms

1:01:28of capabilities, not necessarily copying things from the Mac and how you do it,

1:01:31but just making it easier. I mean the thing I would like to see them do, let me

1:01:37take a break actually, I mean hold this thought and I'll take a break because

1:01:40it's a good way to keep people in suspense. I want to talk to you about our

1:01:46next sponsor. I love this company. I love their products and I this is a company

1:01:51that I hate to say it but they shouldn't even be paying me to promote their

1:01:56products because I would sing their praises even if they weren't and that

1:01:59company is Eero. E-E-R-O. Eero makes Wi-Fi routers for your house. You don't have to

1:02:08choose which one. They just have one model right now. You go, you buy like a

1:02:12three-pack. You plug one of them. They're little white boxes roughly the size of

1:02:16like an Apple TV or something like that. It almost looks like an Apple design

1:02:19product. They ship with Apple style really supple even like the Ethernet

1:02:23cables they give you in the box are nice. It's like a nice ethernet cable. It's not

1:02:28like a piece of junk thing that you got from Joe's cables on the corner. Nice cable, nice

1:02:33power cable. You plug it into your router and now you've got, there's your primary ERO

1:02:37base station. Then you take like the other two and you're like, maybe your router is

1:02:42on the first floor. You put another one on the second floor and another one on the third

1:02:45floor. Keep them near the steps. Try to minimize how many walls has to go through. And it creates

1:02:49It's what's called a mesh network through your house.

1:02:53And it is a huge difference.

1:02:56Now I don't know what, maybe if you live in a studio

1:02:59apartment, guess what, you don't really need an Eero.

1:03:01It's a nice base station, but you really only need one.

1:03:03And it'd be a nice base station for that.

1:03:05But the mesh network thing isn't gonna help you out.

1:03:08But if you live in a city like I do, we have four floors.

1:03:11There's really no way to set up one router

1:03:17that I've ever tried that gets a good Wi-Fi signal

1:03:21everywhere in the house.

1:03:23Personally, I just recently upgraded my Comcast service,

1:03:27had Comcast come in, got new internet.

1:03:30Comcast's new router, they gave me a router with the thing.

1:03:34In the room where I have it set up in my home office,

1:03:37I get like 150, 200 megabits per second over Wi-Fi.

1:03:42It's amazing, that's an amazing performance.

1:03:43It's like 10 times faster than what I had before.

1:03:46One floor up, it's still pretty good.

1:03:48It's like 50 megabits per second, something like that.

1:03:51But in my master bedroom, this is no shit.

1:03:53I swear to God, this is true.

1:03:55I tested this with the speed test app.

1:03:57I get 0.2 megabits per second WiFi from that router.

1:04:02So it goes from 200 megabits per second

1:04:04to 0.2 megabits per second.

1:04:07So once the Comcast guy was gone

1:04:09and I knew I had good internet, I'd reset up my Eros.

1:04:12I put my Ero in there and I only have three.

1:04:16Now I still get 200 or so megabits per second

1:04:19in my office from Euro, but my master bedroom

1:04:22is getting 60 megabits per second WiFi.

1:04:25That's how great it is.

1:04:26I cannot be, and I didn't have to configure anything.

1:04:29You just follow the instructions in their little app,

1:04:32and it just configures everything,

1:04:35and they even tell you that they talk to each other,

1:04:38and they fix it up, and after you've set it up,

1:04:42like 24 hours later, the service is usually even better,

1:04:45because the Eros have communicated with each other

1:04:48about where they should hand off to each other.

1:04:50Cannot tell you how happy I am with this product.

1:04:53I recommend it highly.

1:04:55I don't know what else to tell you.

1:04:57If you need Wi-Fi, if you're unhappy with your Wi-Fi,

1:05:00if you need new Wi-Fi, you'd be silly not to check it out.

1:05:04Then what they do is they recommend one Ero

1:05:06for every thousand square feet of your home.

1:05:08Three packs of good starting point.

1:05:10You can always buy more,

1:05:11and you can hook up 10 in total if you need to.

1:05:15So here's what you do.

1:05:16Go to ero.com and use the code.

1:05:21Actually, you know what?

1:05:24Forget the code.

1:05:25Screw it.

1:05:26Here's what they've done.

1:05:28They've gotten rid of these codes,

1:05:29and to celebrate their first birthday,

1:05:31what they've done is they've just

1:05:32dropped their prices permanently.

1:05:34So instead of using a code, you just go to ero.com,

1:05:36and now you can get a three-pack for just $399.

1:05:40used to be $4.99 and you can get a two-pack for $2.99. That used to be $50 more. So to

1:05:47get Eero at this new price, just go to Eero.com and you can get them at Best Buy or even Amazon

1:05:52if you want. They don't care. They don't even care if you buy them direct. So if you need

1:05:56Wi-Fi, get an Eero. Love this product.

1:06:01I feel like you and I talked about Eero before they were a sponsor of your podcast, which

1:06:05is nice.

1:06:06I remember the first time I read, you know what, I'll get back to my, the point I wanted

1:06:11to make about iPad. I've got my finger in the air. This is my reminder. I know the point

1:06:14I want to make. But we could go on a digression right now. I remember the first time I heard

1:06:19about Eero was I read it in Walt Mossberg's column. And I read his description of it.

1:06:26And I knew that I was suffering from the problem that he was talking about. For years, I had

1:06:31an Apple airport whatever the best the best Apple I think it's the most still

1:06:37the most recent one because they haven't updated it in years yeah the one that's

1:06:40for extreme yeah the one is a real tall yeah I have the same one and I had the

1:06:44same one now I have zero same thing I had it on the second floor our living

1:06:48room of a four floor residence and it was okay and it my office was one floor

1:06:55up and it got pretty good Wi-Fi our master bedroom on the fourth floor yeah

1:07:00it wasn't bad wasn't like it is it like it was with this Comcast router but it

1:07:06wasn't great and and for whatever reason our garage on the first floor one floor

1:07:13down got no signal whatsoever I don't know if it's because the garage had

1:07:16insulation I don't know what the heck it was I read Walt's column and I was like

1:07:23This sounds amazing because A, it solves a problem I have,

1:07:26but B, he's telling me that I don't have to configure,

1:07:29there's no, you don't go into an admin interface

1:07:31and start typing in IP numbers,

1:07:34you don't start picking channels,

1:07:36you don't have to set one of them in bridge mode

1:07:39and one of them in something mode.

1:07:41You just hook 'em up and tap buttons in the app

1:07:43as you hook 'em up around your house

1:07:45and follow their general advice of where best to put them,

1:07:48and then all of a sudden you've got a network

1:07:51every room in your house has good internet. I was like, that sounds so

1:07:54amazing. And it was the literal truth. It's the exact experience of

1:07:59using it. And it's anyway the digression would be Walt's announcement that he's

1:08:04retiring. Yeah, obviously significant news within the world in which in which we

1:08:13inhabit. Yeah, you know, like it's funny when I moved to go... So I was working as

1:08:21as a web developer down in San Diego

1:08:24and sort of writing on the side just for fun.

1:08:27And at some point, you know, VentureBeat

1:08:31at the time came calling and wanted me to sort of come up

1:08:35and consider sort of writing full time.

1:08:36And I just like sort of laughed to myself,

1:08:40like thinking like no one can make a living

1:08:43sort of doing that, right?

1:08:44Like, I mean, you know, it's almost like too good to be true.

1:08:47And you know, around, you know, the same time

1:08:50I think there had been a profile,

1:08:53or maybe I was even just Googling it,

1:08:55but just the story of the rise of Walt Mossberg

1:08:58sort of getting into,

1:09:00obviously it wasn't blogging at the time,

1:09:01it was for the Wall Street Journal,

1:09:03but sort of making his way

1:09:06into this thing that hadn't existed before, right?

1:09:09He was covering politics,

1:09:11and then all of a sudden he decided

1:09:12he was going to cover personal technology,

1:09:14and again, not blogging exactly,

1:09:16but not too dissimilar from,

1:09:20I think what sort of the ideal state for a lot of us,

1:09:24certainly for me at the time,

1:09:26that's what I aspired to do something like that, right?

1:09:31- I just read, I will, I swear to God,

1:09:34put it in the show notes.

1:09:35There's an interview, I think it just came out today,

1:09:38but if not, it came out last night,

1:09:40an interview with Walt in the Columbia Journalism Review.

1:09:44- Right, I haven't read it yet, but I saved it as well.

1:09:46- Yeah, he was, in 1991,

1:09:48He was the lead national security correspondent

1:09:52for the Wall Street Journal,

1:09:53which is the Columbia Journalism Review says

1:09:56is literally one of the most coveted spots

1:09:58in all of newspaper journalism.

1:10:02I mean, it's probably, you could count it on one hand

1:10:05as one of the most prestigious gigs.

1:10:09The Journal, the New York Times, Wall Street,

1:10:12or Washington Post, and a handful of the top jobs there

1:10:15would be something like that,

1:10:16because national security is of utmost importance.

1:10:19And when something breaks, it becomes,

1:10:23you own the top right corner

1:10:26of the front page of the newspaper.

1:10:28And there's no breaking news that's more important

1:10:30than national security news.

1:10:32So he had the job.

1:10:34He obviously had decades ahead of him in his career,

1:10:37and he gave it up to create what was then unheard of,

1:10:40which was in a national major newspaper,

1:10:45a personal technology column.

1:10:47Everybody, you know, like the CGR said

1:10:49that most people in the industry, you know,

1:10:51news people were like, what did he do?

1:10:53Why did he get this terrible demotion?

1:10:55(laughing)

1:10:56- Right.

1:10:57Yeah, I'm trying to think of like

1:10:59what the equivalent thing would be today.

1:11:02And it's hard to come up with something

1:11:03because honestly it's hard to envision something

1:11:06that would sort of become as pervasive

1:11:09as just technology in general, right?

1:11:11Like you could say like, oh, I'm going to

1:11:14stop the Apple beat because I want to write about Bitcoin.

1:11:18And people would be like,

1:11:21but you're covering the most valuable company in the world,

1:11:24why do you want to write about

1:11:26sort of this nascent technology thing?

1:11:28And it was one hell of a leap of faith that he did.

1:11:33And obviously, like I said,

1:11:35he sort of was the pinnacle of doing that.

1:11:41And I think the whole generations of Engadgets, Gizmodos,

1:11:46all the people who were doing gadget reviews,

1:11:51certainly that was the pinnacle.

1:11:54And then just in general,

1:11:56sort of writing a technology column.

1:11:58- I can't say it better than him.

1:11:59Here's Walt's exact words in this interview.

1:12:02There were a bunch of computer columns

1:12:03in a lot of other newspapers,

1:12:04and certainly there were computer magazines,

1:12:07but these were all written by geeks for geeks.

1:12:09My pitch to the journal was that I wanted to write a column

1:12:12that didn't use a lot of jargon,

1:12:14that treated people with respect for their intelligence.

1:12:17And I think that can not be understated,

1:12:20that that was the gist of Walt's,

1:12:22it still is the gist of Walt's writing,

1:12:25that it was never computers for dummies.

1:12:27It was, it was, his angle was that the problem

1:12:31was with the complicated stuff,

1:12:33not with the people who can't understand

1:12:34the complicated stuff.

1:12:38and that it did two things.

1:12:40One, help people figure out how to make this journey

1:12:42into technology by telling them what was good

1:12:44and what was bad on the market,

1:12:45explaining when some new development happened,

1:12:47what it meant, what it was, who it might be for.

1:12:50That was one of my goals.

1:12:51And the other one was to use the power of the platform

1:12:54and the voice that I would have in this column,

1:12:56because it was an opinion column in a way,

1:12:59to push the industry to stop ignoring normal people

1:13:01and stop treating them like they were stupid.

1:13:04That was it, that was my idea and it worked.

1:13:06And I can't say it better-- - Yeah, I mean--

1:13:07I cannot say about that.

1:13:08- No, that's absolutely perfect,

1:13:09because he basically, whether you could argue,

1:13:14he certainly helped usher that era in,

1:13:17but he also just, he foresaw the fact that

1:13:19it would move from the enthusiasts and geeky people

1:13:24just being really into technology

1:13:27and reading things like PC World and things like that

1:13:30to actually going into a mainstream thing.

1:13:31And I mean, it is, one of the most mainstream things

1:13:35right now is technology, right?

1:13:37There's every single person in the world in some capacity uses some sort of technology

1:13:42and

1:13:44We could you imagine sort of if you know if the PC worlds

1:13:47Were still sort of the the norm and sort of writing about that it would seem insane right now

1:13:52Because no one would have sort of a guide to to figure out how to use any of this stuff

1:13:58And the timing is just amazing that he did it and he'd made this decision in 1991 because in my opinion

1:14:03What made computers mainstream?

1:14:07Arguably twofold, but I think it's singlefold.

1:14:11I think Windows 95 obviously had some part of it

1:14:13where the mass market, lower cost PCs

1:14:16jumped from having a really janky operating system

1:14:20like Windows 3.1 to having something that looked pretty nice

1:14:23and was a little, certainly a lot better organized.

1:14:26But the bigger thing is just the internet itself,

1:14:29which is that, and people who love computers,

1:14:32I certainly didn't foresee it.

1:14:33I was of the opinion as somebody,

1:14:36a kid who grew up loving computers.

1:14:37I couldn't understand why everybody else

1:14:38didn't love computers and want to spend

1:14:40as many hours a day as they possibly could on computers.

1:14:42But for normal people, what made computers something

1:14:45that they didn't care about,

1:14:46something they cared about deeply,

1:14:48was that they got turned into communication devices.

1:14:51It's communication.

1:14:52Everything, humans are creatures

1:14:56we're born to want to communicate with each other.

1:14:59And the technologies that allow us to do so

1:15:02are the ones that rocket off.

1:15:04I mean, you could even talk about the automobile

1:15:08from the Henry Ford era a century ago

1:15:10as ultimately as a communications device.

1:15:13You know, that yes, you could use it to bring things

1:15:15from one place to another faster than you could,

1:15:17but the fact that you could go visit people

1:15:19who you otherwise couldn't visit

1:15:21because you wouldn't have time to get there

1:15:23is a huge part of it, right?

1:15:24And computers, before they were communication devices,

1:15:27or in like the dial-up modem era,

1:15:30when you had to dial in an telnet into a bulletin board

1:15:33and use, you know, cryptic command line things

1:15:35and nobody would understand it.

1:15:37Geeks got it early.

1:15:38We spent time on bulletin boards

1:15:40communicating with each other,

1:15:41but when simple, easy to understand

1:15:44communication technology became available on the internet,

1:15:47that's when it exploded.

1:15:48But Walt had his column from 1991, five years before that.

1:15:52And so he was already established as this voice of authority

1:15:56when the explosion already happened.

1:15:58- Yeah, and I mean, the most obvious thing in the world

1:16:01is that the iPhone was the ultimate extrapolation of that,

1:16:04right? - Right.

1:16:05- Because then you had the,

1:16:06not only was it a physical communication device,

1:16:09it blended everything together

1:16:11and you had it with you all the time.

1:16:12Right.

1:16:15One thing that I was curious to your take

1:16:17about this topic on with, you know,

1:16:20with Walt moving on was,

1:16:23who do you think takes up the mantle then

1:16:25as sort of the, I guess that go to

1:16:28either technology columnist or reviewer?

1:16:29We know the names who are sort of at the bigger places,

1:16:33Farhad Manjoo at the New York Times.

1:16:37Wall Street Journal is still doing the combo, right?

1:16:42Of-- - Right, with Joanna and--

1:16:45- With Joanna, right.

1:16:46- And the other guy.

1:16:48(laughing)

1:16:51- But so, and then David Pogue is still at Yahoo, I guess?

1:16:58Yahoo, I guess, or is he not?

1:17:00I don't even know, like what's going to happen?

1:17:02Is he going to be at a--

1:17:03- I think so, but I feel like I don't know

1:17:04because Yahoo's future is so uncertain.

1:17:08- Right, is he gonna be at Ethos

1:17:10or whatever the hell that company's gonna be called?

1:17:12So, oh, Jeffrey Fowler.

1:17:16- Yes, Jeffrey Fowler, sorry Jeffrey.

1:17:18- Sorry Jeffrey.

1:17:19But so like, so how do you think that that plays out?

1:17:22Or is it not one of the giant, you know,

1:17:24sort of old school publications?

1:17:26Is it some other, is it so Mark Gurman,

1:17:29you know, was announced this morning

1:17:30that Bloomberg's launching a,

1:17:32like a gadget show with Gurman.

1:17:35- Oh, I didn't see that.

1:17:37- Yeah, it was on like, I saw Axios.

1:17:40So Axios, you know, the new newsletter thing

1:17:43from Mike Allen and that group.

1:17:45Yeah, they broke the story about,

1:17:47it looks like it's going,

1:17:50I don't know exactly what it's gonna be called.

1:17:51Hold on, I actually had the link here,

1:17:53so I can pull it up, but. - I got it.

1:17:56I was just talking about Axios because Ina Fried took over and is running the technology

1:18:01beat for them, and she was at the Appleschindig last week, and I was talking to her about it.

1:18:05It's an interesting format, and I said to her, I said, "I'm not just saying this because you're

1:18:09here, but I have to say that, especially politics-wise, I'm more keenly attuned ever

1:18:16since November, and in the last few months, it's surprising how many of the links that have bubbled

1:18:22up to the surface politically have been Axios sites. It didn't take very long after Axios

1:18:26launched before I noticed it, and I was like, "How long has this been around?" Because all

1:18:31of a sudden, it's popping up every day, and then I checked, and I was like, "Oh, it's

1:18:35only two weeks old." It's not like I missed it. It's right from the get-go, though, Axios

1:18:41has-

1:18:42They're doing great. And not to do too much of an aside on the aside, but yeah, so in

1:18:47my world, in my current world, in VC, obviously everyone was reading Dan Primack when he was

1:18:52at Fortune, his newsletter, and he moved over to Axios sort of around the time of their

1:18:56launch.

1:18:57And then they have the Mike Allen guy who famously sort of wrote the Politico newsletter

1:19:03for a long time.

1:19:04And it's insane because he literally writes it every single day and just fills it with

1:19:07a ton of content every single day and seems to get legitimate inside the White House scoops.

1:19:12And obviously Primack gets his scoops, Eno will get hers, and it's just like on down

1:19:16the line.

1:19:17They have a pretty killer product and team.

1:19:19Yeah.

1:19:20Yeah.

1:19:21did a very keen job of focusing on just getting great talent.

1:19:26Just, you know, they have a great format and I like, you know, it's a good,

1:19:30it looks good, there's not, I don't see any clutter on screen that is

1:19:33annoying me. It's, they've got this focus on writing really short articles that

1:19:39just get to the point which I think goes over really well.

1:19:42Like, there's no padding in the articles,

1:19:45but they've got great talent on all these beats which

1:19:49which is, to me, a great combination.

1:19:51It's a good format with a good focus.

1:19:54It's user-friendly, and they've assembled

1:19:57a really good team of talented people with deep sources.

1:20:01So anyway.

1:20:02- And they do a great job with brevity, too.

1:20:05They don't just, they don't drag on.

1:20:07- Right, that's what I'm saying.

1:20:08- These long-winded things. - There's so much on the web

1:20:09that drags on because it's like they want now.

1:20:11It's like, I feel like in the old days,

1:20:14the problem eight, nine years ago was that the sites,

1:20:18because they were counting pages,

1:20:19they would break up articles,

1:20:22click here for next page, next page.

1:20:24But now I feel like articles are padded

1:20:28for the sake of being able to algorithmically interrupt

1:20:33between paragraphs to insert either ads

1:20:37or promotions for other thing on the site.

1:20:39And so I noticed mostly reading on the phone is,

1:20:42there was this, oh my God, I forget who it was.

1:20:45I don't even want to mention it

1:20:46because I don't want to give them any attention,

1:20:48but there was an article I was reading last night

1:20:50where they had three interruptions in the same article

1:20:52to promote a new podcast that they were launching.

1:20:56For the same podcast, three times in the article

1:20:58between paragraphs, and on the phone,

1:21:00it's a huge interruption between where your eyes

1:21:04find the next paragraph.

1:21:06Anyway, Axios does a good job on that.

1:21:09- So Gurman's thing is called Gadgets with Gurman.

1:21:11- Huh, that's a great idea.

1:21:13- Bloomberg show, so it's gonna be a digital video series

1:21:16that they're going to launch across all the Bloomberg stuff, including the terminal, it sounds like.

1:21:20But then they're going to package it together and eventually sort of put it on Bloomberg television as well.

1:21:25I know he's been very interesting. I know that's, you know, I can't say I'm close friends with him, but I certainly am friendly with him.

1:21:31He's been on the show and whenever, you know, I like, and now that he's, you know, really gone pro, he's getting invited to Apple events,

1:21:39and I always try to make a point of saying hi.

1:21:41I know from talking to him that a big reason

1:21:44he went to Bloomberg instead of anywhere else

1:21:45was the promise of video and TV stuff.

1:21:49He's super interested in that.

1:21:51So I'm not surprised at all that he's getting his own thing.

1:21:55- But so, amongst those people or someone else,

1:21:58is there someone who takes up that mantle,

1:21:59or are we just in an era now where it's such the norm

1:22:03that there's going to be sort of the five to 10 go-tos

1:22:06for sort of everything? - Yeah, I don't think

1:22:07there's anybody who takes the mantle from Mossberg.

1:22:09really don't and and I just don't I just don't see how it happens because I don't

1:22:14see it's not like the New York Times on Wall Street Journal aren't still

1:22:20important but they're differently important now where I don't feel like

1:22:25they have singular voice maybe like on the New York Times op-ed page you know

1:22:29like a Paul Krugman and Maureen Dowd still have that influence but I don't

1:22:36in technology, I just don't see it. I think the fact that Walt was there so early and

1:22:44was so established that it combined with the incredible power of the Wall Street Journal,

1:22:50even today, I mean, Wall Street Journal is still super popular, but the fact that he

1:22:53was doing it at the Journal, I just don't see how anybody's going to take that position.

1:22:56It's almost like Michael Jordan retires. Who takes over as Michael Jordan? Maybe there

1:23:01will be a LeBron who comes along, but I think whoever that is isn't here yet.

1:23:05- Yeah, and it's gonna have to be sort of different thing,

1:23:08maybe even a different format, you know?

1:23:10And you know, maybe this German thing becomes interesting.

1:23:13I do think like, you know, some of the other folks

1:23:18who have great history, like Steven Levy,

1:23:20who's a good friend of mine,

1:23:21obviously he's still getting, you know,

1:23:23some amazing stories for his back channel stuff,

1:23:26which is underwired now.

1:23:28And you know, so there's gonna be sort of,

1:23:31there's still the group of folks

1:23:33who have so much prestige around them

1:23:37and the bigger companies are still comfortable

1:23:39sort of talking to them versus just some random person,

1:23:44like you said, when Mark Gurman was at 9to5Mac,

1:23:49he didn't get invited to any of the Apple things, right?

1:23:52Even though he's breaking every single story.

1:23:54- Well, it was already too late to come to the events.

1:23:57- Yeah, right.

1:23:57- What he was doing that was adding to

1:24:02the overall quantity of the information in the world.

1:24:05It had nothing to do with what was at the events.

1:24:07It was five months before the events.

1:24:09- Right.

1:24:11- I feel like the closest would be, and I wonder,

1:24:14I think he did the right thing,

1:24:16'cause I think part of being prescient with Walt was that

1:24:20I think he was smart to go to create the all things D brand

1:24:25while at the Wall Street Journal.

1:24:28And again, the Columbia Journalism Review mentions

1:24:31that they did that, he and Kara Swisher did that,

1:24:33when the consensus among print journalists

1:24:37was still to treat the web as an ugly stepchild, right?

1:24:41- Right. - That you're writing

1:24:42primarily for print, and then there's some B team

1:24:45that takes the print stuff after it's gone

1:24:48through the print process, and I don't know,

1:24:50put it on the web thing or whatever,

1:24:51treat it as an ugly stepchild.

1:24:53I mean, here in Philadelphia,

1:24:55I don't wanna go on a super long aside,

1:24:57but in Philadelphia, the two newspapers

1:24:59the Inquirer and the Daily News. And they made a decision in the late 90s that rather

1:25:05than focus on having like an Inquirer.com and PhillyDailyNews.com or whatever you want

1:25:10to call the domains be a quality things, they made like a joint thing called Philly.com

1:25:16and they had content from both newspapers, but they just sort of, it was never really

1:25:20clear which articles were from which paper, even though they independently as print operations,

1:25:25They were completely separate and rivals,

1:25:27completely separate rivals,

1:25:28even though they were under the same parent obligation,

1:25:31our organization.

1:25:33But the philly.com, and it was an ugly website.

1:25:35It was slow to load.

1:25:36They always, they were at the forefront of using paywalls.

1:25:40(laughing)

1:25:42And it almost bankrupted the company,

1:25:44it did bankrupt the company.

1:25:45The company is, they ended up having to sell

1:25:47their magnificent headquarters

1:25:49and move into janky office space.

1:25:53and not treating the web seriously

1:25:56really almost ran them into the ground.

1:25:58I would say Walt was at the opposite,

1:25:59where Walt was, with All Things D,

1:26:01they were like, we'll write for the web first.

1:26:05- Yep. - And we'll make

1:26:06web-only content.

1:26:07- That plus the conference business.

1:26:10- Right, right. - I mean, they--

1:26:12- Which came first. - They were ahead

1:26:13of the curve on that, yeah. - Right, that was 2003,

1:26:15and I think they started the All Things D website in 2007.

1:26:18I also think that leaving the journal

1:26:20the last five, six years of his career to start Recode, which they then merged with Vox and The

1:26:28Verge, et cetera, was probably the right thing to do. I really do think so, and I think it had

1:26:33an eye on the future. But I wonder how much it lessened his influence. I think for Kara,

1:26:43and what she does best with breaking scoops, it's fine. I think in fact, it was all win.

1:26:50And the fact that she's got equity in the thing

1:26:53and the scoops go out to everybody who cares about scoops

1:26:57when they come out.

1:26:58But for Mossberg's thing of being a sort of

1:27:01spokesperson for the everyman,

1:27:04as a product reviewer, I do wonder whether

1:27:07his voice was lessened by leaving the journal.

1:27:12- Right, and I mean that's the hard,

1:27:15the hard sort of gap to close because the everyman

1:27:19He may not read the Wall Street Journal only,

1:27:23but they know of the Wall Street Journal.

1:27:24The other man knows the Wall Street Journal.

1:27:26They'll know Walt Mossberg at the Wall Street Journal.

1:27:30Certainly, he had a big enough name for when he

1:27:32leaves the Wall Street Journal to take some of that audience with him,

1:27:35but it will never be the full audience of a nationwide distributed paper.

1:27:41So it was almost like was recode more of a,

1:27:48you know, sort of back to the tech enthusiast crowd

1:27:50versus the everyman crowd.

1:27:52- Right, like Walt's writing didn't change.

1:27:54Like, you know, I don't think that you could Pepsi challenge

1:27:57the difference between Walt's columns

1:27:59under the Recode or Verge banner

1:28:01and his, you know, columns under the Journal banner.

1:28:04He had the same style and the same approach

1:28:05and the same attitude.

1:28:07If you just look at the words,

1:28:08but I think it reached fewer people.

1:28:09I think it was almost like a magnifier

1:28:11where he built the Walt Mossberg brand,

1:28:13where if you put a quote up in a keynote

1:28:15and just had a quote from Walt Mossberg.

1:28:19That says a lot right there.

1:28:20But Walt Mossberg, comma, The Wall Street Journal,

1:28:23it's like a multiplier, because now you've got both

1:28:25the power of the Wall Street Journal brand combined,

1:28:28multiplied by the power of Walt's personal brand.

1:28:32- Yeah, and so, I mean, that speaks to why

1:28:34it was probably the smart move to then do the,

1:28:36sort of, the Vox sale and merge, basically,

1:28:39you know, with the Verge, because it is,

1:28:42while we can argue about whether it's been successful yet in doing so, it is trying to

1:28:47reach a more mainstream audience rather than what ReCode was doing itself, which was much

1:28:53more targeted.

1:28:54Right.

1:28:55And obviously, I'm a big proponent of writers and independent journalists going off on their

1:29:03own and building their own brands.

1:29:07But I'm also keenly aware of the brand equity of things like the Journal and the New York

1:29:11Times. I feel like Pogue is in the same boat where career rise, it might have been exactly

1:29:16the right thing. I'm not criticizing him in the least. It might have been exactly the

1:29:18right thing to go to Yahoo and it might be great for his career and his family and his

1:29:24personal finances. But I can't help but think that if Pogue were still at the New York Times,

1:29:29he might be in that position to sort of take over as the de facto. Like David Pogue at

1:29:33the New York Times is a much more powerful voice and brand than David Pogue at Yahoo

1:29:39tech or whatever the umbrella is. Yeah, it's sort of interesting. I know it's not a direct analogy,

1:29:45and it's in some ways probably unfair, but it's like, you know, it reminds me of sort of like

1:29:49the Siskel and Ebert thing, right? When they were at sort of the pinnacle of doing film reviews and

1:29:56of course the getting the television show and everything, doing that, and then, you know,

1:30:03know both unfortunately passed away and like who then takes up that mantle and

1:30:08they're really you know there's some people like a o scott at the New York

1:30:12Times who I think is great and and there's a handful of other people but no

1:30:14one has that same influence a perfect example that I think because there is no

1:30:19there's no no more Cisco on ebert and even after gene Cisco died I think

1:30:23ebert ebert was enough of a voice where he was still yes he was still up there

1:30:28- Right, but after he died, nobody really took that.

1:30:33I can't think of who I would think, you know.

1:30:35I personally do like A.O. Scott.

1:30:37I personally, I love to hate read,

1:30:40what's his name, Anthony Lane in The New Yorker.

1:30:46- Oh, right, yep, yep.

1:30:48I read those too, yep.

1:30:50(laughing)

1:30:52- I get to the end of every issue of The New Yorker

1:30:55and I either, if I've,

1:30:57I don't read them unless I've seen the movie.

1:30:59But sometimes I keep old ones and I bookmark them.

1:31:01And then when I do see the movie, I go back and read--

1:31:03- I do the same exact thing.

1:31:04- I go back and read Anthony Lane's review.

1:31:06And then I rip it up.

1:31:07- And I do the exact same thing for the same reason.

1:31:09- I rip it up and I wanna just throw these

1:31:11ripped up reviews in his face and say, "You joyless."

1:31:14(laughing)

1:31:16Don't you realize that sometimes a movie

1:31:21is just meant to be fun?

1:31:22But he's very good at writing those reviews,

1:31:25so I still read them.

1:31:27But I can't say that anybody's like Ebert.

1:31:30I would say that Walt is sort of the Ebert

1:31:32and Cisco combined, maybe.

1:31:35Anyway.

1:31:36- Yeah.

1:31:36- Anyway, good luck to him.

1:31:37It's gonna be weird.

1:31:38It's gonna be weird not seeing him around, I tell you that.

1:31:41- Yeah, I'll be at the code conference for, I guess,

1:31:45that's where he's saying the actual goodbyes.

1:31:47So that'll be an interesting--

1:31:48- I've never gone.

1:31:49I should see if I can wrangle an invitation.

1:31:53- You should, it is.

1:31:54not to promote, not to be a promotion here,

1:31:58but it is a very good conference.

1:31:59They do a very good job with it.

1:32:00- I think the reason I never have even thought about

1:32:02seeing if I could go is that it seems so close to WWDC

1:32:05and I'm sort of a homebody and I don't wanna go away

1:32:08two times in short succession.

1:32:10- Yeah, and it's in Southern California, not up here, so.

1:32:13- Right, well I don't really care.

1:32:14It's just, all that matters to me is that I'm

1:32:17a gazillion thousand miles away from home, but.

1:32:19- Can't be away from that U-Haul desk, if yours.

1:32:22(laughing)

1:32:24So do you wanna go back to your iPad point?

1:32:27- Let me finish that.

1:32:28I have one more sponsor to thank,

1:32:30and then I'll go back to my iPad point,

1:32:31which is really perfect.

1:32:32And it's our good friends, one of our best sponsors,

1:32:35Fracture.

1:32:36Fracture is a photo decor company.

1:32:38Here's what they do.

1:32:39You send them your personal photos,

1:32:40you pick a size, and they have all sorts of sizes

1:32:42to pick from, and then they print your photos

1:32:45directly on glass.

1:32:46You've probably heard about them before.

1:32:47You've probably heard me talk about them.

1:32:48They've been a longtime sponsor.

1:32:50I cannot emphasize what a great gift this item is.

1:32:53Now as we record, it's the middle of April.

1:32:56Mother's Day is coming up.

1:32:58I don't know if there's time left.

1:32:59Maybe as you hear me listen to the words

1:33:02that are coming out of my mouth,

1:33:03you can hurry up and order some fractures for Mother's Day.

1:33:07If not, order them for Father's Day.

1:33:10These are the greatest gifts of all time

1:33:13that I've given them out to members

1:33:16on both sides of our family.

1:33:17And every single time, even to people

1:33:19We've given them to before.

1:33:20It's, do you ever give a gift and then you're like,

1:33:24wow, and it was great, it was like well received.

1:33:26And you're like, wow, I wish I could give them

1:33:28the same gift again next year.

1:33:29Guess what, with Fracture, you can.

1:33:31You can just pick new photos of kids who are growing up

1:33:34or trips that you've been on or anything that's happened

1:33:37in the last year, it's a great gift.

1:33:39And you can give it to them again and again and again.

1:33:42And it goes over well each time.

1:33:43And they don't think, their reaction is never,

1:33:46oh, one of these again.

1:33:47The reaction is always, "Oh my God, that's beautiful.

1:33:49Thank you so much."

1:33:50Great photos printed directly on glass.

1:33:53They do it right down in Gainesville, Florida.

1:33:55They're made in the USA.

1:33:56And if you've never seen one in person,

1:33:58I just can't say how cool it is

1:33:59to have an edge-to-edge photo, no bezel.

1:34:01It just goes right from one edge to another,

1:34:03and it comes with all the stuff you need

1:34:05to mount it on a wall.

1:34:07And it just looks so striking

1:34:09to have a really high-quality photo

1:34:12that looks like it's printed directly on glass,

1:34:14on the wall, with no frame, no bezel,

1:34:16just edge-to-edge glass that is pure photo.

1:34:20It's a great, great gift.

1:34:22It's a great product for your own home

1:34:23if you've got walls to fill and decorate.

1:34:25Where do you go?

1:34:29Go to

1:34:30fractureme.com/podcast.

1:34:35Now that sounds like a fill-in URL that I'm botching,

1:34:37like it's supposed to be my own code, but it's not.

1:34:39It's just fractureme.com/podcast.

1:34:42All they do is keep track of all the people

1:34:44who come from any podcast.

1:34:46And at the end, when you buy something, they will ask you a one question survey, which

1:34:50is where did you hear a fracture from?

1:34:52That's where you can say the talk show or Darren Fireball or whatever you want to say

1:34:54and they'll know you came from here.

1:34:56So my thanks to that.

1:34:57Go ahead and buy them.

1:34:58They're the greatest gift you'll ever have.

1:35:00Fractureme.com.

1:35:03Fractureme.com.

1:35:04Fracture.

1:35:05All right.

1:35:06Back to the iPad.

1:35:07Here's the thing I would like to see them do.

1:35:08My biggest request would be to have a multitasking mode similar to the one they have now where

1:35:14you arrange multiple apps in full height columns. But I would like to be able

1:35:20to make them—I don't know exactly—I haven't envisioned or invented an

1:35:25interface to make this—to figure out exactly how they would do it. But I would

1:35:29like to have it be more arbitrary. So if you want to have three, you could have

1:35:35three. If you want to drag one from the middle to the left, you could somehow

1:35:41drag the you know put your finger in like the nav bar or something or do a

1:35:45long press on it and drag it over rearrange them and I would like them to

1:35:52do away with it bothers me somehow and I can't quite put my finger on it but it

1:35:56just feels like the whole thing it still makes the whole field thing feel tacked

1:36:00on to me that the left one is always main and the right one is like the junior

1:36:07app. Right. And it doesn't feel right to me. It doesn't feel... it's like on the Mac, there's

1:36:12never... there's a frontmost window and then there's all other windows and they're all

1:36:16equal, and if you click on one, it becomes frontmost and it's every bit as legit as the

1:36:21other ones. So if I have three apps on my iPad in columns side by side, when I'm in

1:36:28the middle one, I feel like it should be every bit the real, the main app as it would be

1:36:33if it were the left one. And secondarily, I would like them to figure out a way to

1:36:38more visually clarify which one currently has the focus. Right, right.

1:36:43But so with that three, the notion of three, does that work ratio-wise for sort

1:36:50of the, you know, how big? Yeah, because I think that if you do the size classes

1:36:54right, it could be it your app should rearrange themselves, you know, should use

1:37:00using auto layout etc to any arbitrary width you shouldn't be worried about

1:37:04exact whether it's exactly you know 767 pixels or I got that wrong but you know

1:37:11that did you should be worried about hitting this short list of exact pixel

1:37:16widths you should be in more like a Mac app you should be able to rearrange to

1:37:20any arbitrary width I'm not saying that the that the iPad should let you drag

1:37:24the little divider and change it from 750 pixels to 748 pixels I feel like

1:37:29like the fact that the iPad isn't so fussy

1:37:32and has these set sizes that the apps clip to

1:37:36is actually nice.

1:37:38- Yeah. - Right?

1:37:39Like it's always bothered me a little

1:37:41that when you resize a Mac app window

1:37:44that it's never really perfect.

1:37:46It's always just wherever you left off the mouse.

1:37:50- Right, so you want a combination of those things,

1:37:53like it being strict in sort of formatting

1:37:58but just being more options for how you can format that screen.

1:38:01Right, and I don't want infinite options.

1:38:03I feel like a 9.7-inch iPad, maybe the maximum is 3.

1:38:07Maybe on the 12.9, the maximum's 4.

1:38:10You know, I trust Apple to work that out.

1:38:13But if I want to go 50/50, and I want

1:38:16to have two that are exactly 50/50,

1:38:18or if I want to go like 2/3, 1/3,

1:38:21I could do that very easily.

1:38:22And if I want to go 1/3, 1/3, 1/3 for 3, I could do that easily.

1:38:28And do you think now, I assume the iPad,

1:38:32certainly the iPad Pro's at the point

1:38:33where it could run three apps simultaneously

1:38:36without an issue?

1:38:37- Oh, I think so, without question.

1:38:39And especially with the way that,

1:38:42yeah, I think so, I think it has enough RAM to do that.

1:38:46- Yeah, I would love to see something like that.

1:38:49I think one of the biggest drawbacks,

1:38:53it's not huge, but one that I have,

1:38:55'cause I use the iPad a ton,

1:38:57is just there's still a little cutesy

1:39:00with sort of switching between the apps.

1:39:01They still have sort of these,

1:39:03the animations that go on to sort of flip it around

1:39:05and whatnot, and it just makes it a little bit longer

1:39:08than it needs to be, right?

1:39:10And so if you're really into using two apps,

1:39:13yeah, and I know you could do the side-by-side things,

1:39:15and I do that for certain apps,

1:39:16it makes sense to do that for,

1:39:18but I would even just make it as fast as possible

1:39:21to switch between two.

1:39:22- Yeah, they tweaked that in iOS 10.3.

1:39:26Yeah, I think it's a little bit faster.

1:39:27Yeah, they shorten some of the animation times.

1:39:29Yeah, like I'm using it right now. Yeah, I mean it is faster because it slides right in now,

1:39:34but they still, you know, they're still cute, a little cutesy with the animations.

1:39:37Yeah, and the longer you use a computer, like the more that you use an iPad as like your main

1:39:44writing computer, the more those animations grate on you because the more sensitive you are to

1:39:50knowing that you're waiting for the animation and not really waiting for the computer.

1:39:55And I feel like in the classic days like in the original Mac like the 84 85 86 when the first max first came out and

1:40:01You know that in hindsight they were desperately desperately slow and desperately starved for

1:40:07Every resource you can imagine disk space and RAM and video RAM and everything

1:40:14When you double-click something and you've got those resume rectangles that showed it coming up

1:40:20Part of it was to help you understand

1:40:22Okay, you've opened this folder and it's opening into a window and the animation would help you do that

1:40:28But the other reason the animations were there was to give you something to look at while you were waiting for the computer to actually

1:40:33Do it because it wasn't going to happen instantaneously anyway

1:40:36All right, sort of solving two birds with one stone

1:40:38Which was it was giving you this visual clue of telling you what was happening like oh this

1:40:44Folder is opened into a window now and when I close the window it

1:40:49closes into the icon from which it opened. I see the folder is a window and the window is a folder

1:40:55and the folder, if I go back to that window, has a different visual state when the window,

1:40:58its corresponding window is open. But the animations never felt like they were slowing

1:41:05you down because you were waiting for the computer anyway. And as the computers got faster,

1:41:09I feel like those visual clues, like I still like in some ways, like on the iPad or iPhone,

1:41:14when you tap an icon and the app animates as it opens up, I still feel like it's...

1:41:19I don't feel like it should... I don't feel like the screen should flash instantly,

1:41:23but I feel like that animation should be very fast.

1:41:25Right. And just playing around with it now, like... So I think Apple did a good job,

1:41:31sort of, if you use Command-Tab, which you can use if you have the keyboard, you know,

1:41:34hooked up to the iPad, it's actually very fast. It's pretty good. But if you just do the double

1:41:41click of the home button, it's still sort of like a slowish zoom out and then you click

1:41:46on the one you want and then it's a slowish zoom in.

1:41:48And then the worst of all maybe, and I don't know, I assume very few people actually use

1:41:53this but you know you can do the four finger sort of swipe thing and go from sort of app

1:41:58to app that way and it's just like unnecessarily slow.

1:42:03So yeah, I almost never use that as a result of that but that's currently I guess the state

1:42:08of the art.

1:42:09The only other thing I was going to add to the iPad discussion since we were talking

1:42:12about sort of newer ones.

1:42:14So the Pro that I'm using now still feels super fast.

1:42:17The newer 9.7 Pro, super fast.

1:42:20But I will say the iPad mini is a little slow these days.

1:42:25I still use it for, you know, for certain times reading, take it out with me since it's

1:42:30nice and small.

1:42:31But that's pretty slow.

1:42:33And I know that there was some debate back and forth whether or not they would actually

1:42:37just sort of get rid of that product and I hope they don't but anyway I wonder

1:42:41because it does stick out now because it's actually at an entry level it's

1:42:45more expensive than the 9.7 the new one yeah it does have more storage so it's

1:42:54not completely inexplicable why it's more expensive but it does seem weird

1:42:58because up until this most recent introduction of the quote new 9.7 inch

1:43:02iPad there was a correlation in cost between okay the small one is the cheap

1:43:07the mid-sized one is mid-priced and the new big one is the most expensive.

1:43:10And now all of a sudden there's the weird situation where if your budget

1:43:14counts, you're gonna get the 9.7 inch, not the, you know, you're seemingly

1:43:18getting more more of a device than you are, you know, for $329 than you would at

1:43:22$399 for the mini. And it's also, it's been over two years, right, since it's

1:43:28been updated at this point. Yeah, I don't know if it's done though. I don't know. I

1:43:32mean, it's hard to say. I don't know. I guess it really comes down to how

1:43:36many people are buying it. I mean, Apple knows that and isn't going to tell us. But I wouldn't

1:43:41be surprised either way. I wouldn't be surprised if it gets a very quiet update, more or less

1:43:45like with the specs of the "new 9.7-inch iPad" just in a smaller size and it just sits there.

1:43:53I don't know. Who knows if they could lower the price, but maybe. And I wouldn't be surprised

1:43:59if it just never gets updated and two years from now it just goes away, that it sort of

1:44:05got killed by the plus-sized iPhones. Right, and yeah, especially if, you know,

1:44:11when the if and when this new top-of-the-line iPhone comes out, if

1:44:15that even makes it even more of sort of a glaring discrepancy between them. Yeah,

1:44:20and I wonder, I can't help but think that the the Pro uses, like I don't think

1:44:25there's ever gonna be an iPad Mini Pro. I just don't, I don't think they're gonna

1:44:28make a keyboard that small. I think it would be, would really take child. I did

1:44:32get one of those keyboards that was like the Logitech one that you could use with it. It

1:44:36was so ridiculously small. Not very useful. It is good though as a like a reader, you

1:44:44know, like it because it is roughly kindle size and so if you really do just read but

1:44:48maybe their thinking is that for the people who do use it they mostly just read and it

1:44:51doesn't matter if it's long in the tooth and a little slow at this point. I don't know.

1:44:55Yeah.

1:44:56But I can't see I'm adding a smart connector and having a keyboard for it.

1:45:03Yeah, it's too small of a screen size to actually make an ergonomic keyboard, and all you have

1:45:10to do is play with Logitech One for five seconds to know that.

1:45:15I talked about this before.

1:45:16I still think it's interesting that Apple, when they had me, they had a briefing for

1:45:21for the new iPad and the Clips app and stuff,

1:45:24and I went up to New York and saw it.

1:45:26They don't have a special keyboard

1:45:30for the new 9.7-inch iPad,

1:45:31but in collaboration with Logitech,

1:45:33they're supporting this Logitech case/keyboard,

1:45:38which is sort of, it's very thick, it's like rugged,

1:45:42but it's, you know, you can totally see,

1:45:44if you think about it in the context of like a K-12 school,

1:45:46you think, oh yeah, I can see why they would love that,

1:45:48because it looks like something

1:45:49that would easily survive like a drop.

1:45:51But one of the reasons it's important

1:45:54is that you put it into this case,

1:45:56you put the iPad in this case that's totally surrounded,

1:45:58and it has a lightning port inside.

1:46:01And I don't know if it has a battery or not,

1:46:03but that means that it's not a Bluetooth connection

1:46:05to the keyboard, it's a hardware connection

1:46:07to the keyboard through lightning.

1:46:09And that's essential for K-12

1:46:12because all of the standardized tests

1:46:15that take place on a computer,

1:46:17it's mandated that there's no wireless connectivity.

1:46:22And you can understand, you know, I see, I get it.

1:46:25No wireless whatsoever.

1:46:27It's like complete airplane mode.

1:46:28Otherwise the software does, you know,

1:46:30detects that you're not in airplane mode and won't run.

1:46:33And I could totally see why Apple did that.

1:46:36- I feel like if a kid can cheat via Bluetooth,

1:46:39that would be pretty impressive.

1:46:40But yeah, I understand.

1:46:43- From what I mentioned this the other week on the show

1:46:45Dan Fromer, he said that he and his friends used to, I forget if he said Palm Pilots, I forget what

1:46:50they had, but when he was in high school, they had something and they were IRing their cheats

1:46:55to each other. They're just- Oh, I wonder if they, I remember like, you know, they remember

1:46:59like the TI calculus, the Texas Instruments sort of scientific calculators. We used to have all

1:47:05sorts of fun things on that. I think you could run Doom, like an emulator to run Doom on it and

1:47:09some other fun stuff. Yeah. You're too young. You're, you're, you're too young for me. I didn't

1:47:14have anything of that capability. But we had calculators that had, they just had the

1:47:19numeric display, but you could type letters in them too. But it was a one row, and it had

1:47:27like memory functions. And so our cheat, our way of cheating was to put the briefest possible cheat

1:47:32notes in those memory functions. And then you would bring them up and instead of just being

1:47:37numbers, it would, you know, be some sort of like 32 character. Oh yeah, that's how you, you know,

1:47:41That's how you do it.

1:47:43Yep.

1:47:44Yeah.

1:47:45Children find a way, no matter the technology.

1:47:48Anything else that you want to talk about?

1:47:52The only other thing, and we can sort of briefly talk about it, just because I did think it

1:47:56was interesting, you had sort of a shortest rant in linking to something, and it does

1:48:00relate directly maybe to some of the iPad stuff we were just talking about, is the app

1:48:03bundle size thing.

1:48:06Because there was also, like, you and I had a, not really back and forth, I responded

1:48:10to you and they both got a ton of yours and mine both got a ton of likes because

1:48:13I think this resonates with people you were talking about in that tweet the

1:48:17Dropbox app like why is it 260 megabytes or whatever and then in your linked

1:48:21posts you were talking about the someone wrote a breakdown of why the Facebook

1:48:25app is so bad now right I so I noticed this because I was without Wi-Fi service

1:48:31for a week or so and so I was living entirely off LTE and I have I upgraded

1:48:38our Verizon plan to quote unquote unlimited but I've read the fine print

1:48:42when we did it like our family plan and unlimited is not really unlimited

1:48:46there's I forget what point but there's a point where they reserve the right

1:48:50where in your month if you go over like 20 gigabytes or something they reserve

1:48:53the right to throttle you something like that it's not really unlimited and so

1:48:58one of the things I did in the week or so I was without Wi-Fi is I didn't

1:49:02update any of my apps with the update all I would just go through and look for

1:49:07ones that I either thought were essential or like small and it's amazing

1:49:11how many apps so more or less I didn't update any app over a hundred megabytes

1:49:15and by the end of the week I had like 26 app updates it's amazing and it's

1:49:19amazing how many of them are over 200 megabytes I know and I mean that's

1:49:23without question that's creeping up across all apps over time it was it was

1:49:27sort of one app maybe it was the clips app or something like that it was one of

1:49:31Apple's apps I noticed the other day you know I think it was clips maybe and it

1:49:36was like six megabytes and I was like oh my god I don't even remember the last

1:49:40time I saw an app update that was that tiny because they're all now at least

1:49:4450 and then many are over 100 some over 200 like you were talking about and it's

1:49:49insane and so I like that the thing you linked to like sort of breaking down

1:49:52looking unpacking the the you know the Facebook's bundle for that and they just

1:49:58have so much cruft in there that's that's obviously duplicate duplicate

1:50:03copies of the same framework, duplicate copies of the same image assets, and even that, even

1:50:08if you got rid of all the duplicates, it still seems like it would be big, but it's crazy.

1:50:13I know from somewhat—I know one of the things is that it's these analytics packages that

1:50:20the apps are all using and that they come as binary blobs where you just—they give

1:50:25you this framework to toss into your Xcode project and the whole thing is in there and

1:50:30it's you know and then somebody else says from the SEO team on your company

1:50:35is like well we want this analytics product too and then all of a sudden

1:50:37you've got two of them and they add up to 100 megabytes and it's not it not

1:50:41even your app right Apple isn't innocent either because the iWorks apps are

1:50:47humongous Oh huge and Microsoft those are some of the worst that I works all

1:50:51the productivity stuff whenever I have Microsoft Word one of them and it was

1:50:56like it was like 600 megabytes like what in an app update what are they doing

1:51:01zoom it's all templates and and the image assets to go with the templates I

1:51:05can't imagine what else it would be in languages and I I don't even know um one

1:51:10of the things I know obviously Facebook does one of the reasons for the bloat is

1:51:15they're always including various a/b tests in their app and so they will

1:51:21trigger things based on country, I think based on other things as well to try to

1:51:27you know a/b test various functionality. Back in the TechCrunch days you know I

1:51:31used to sort of know where to look and and who to ask about sort of

1:51:37unpacking some of that because you could always find stuff. I think I found the

1:51:40iPad version of the Facebook app when it was still bundled in before there was an

1:51:44official iPad version because it was baked into the you know the the standard

1:51:49iOS version and so it was right there and I'm sure they're they're always

1:51:53doing stuff like that. I feel like it's getting out of control though and

1:51:58part of it is that I noticed it with this I've noticed it before that but I

1:52:01noticed it with this week where I didn't have Wi-Fi but I've noticed it before

1:52:05and it just seems preposterous to me I mean like I'm not saying I mean we you

1:52:10know we were finicky and fussy but Vesper I'd looked it was the the last

1:52:14version of Vespers, which is still in the App Store, is 5.5 megabytes.

1:52:19Wow. Yeah, that's impressive.

1:52:23And a huge chunk of that is that we embedded a custom font.

1:52:25If we had used a system font, it would have been even significantly smaller.

1:52:28There's no reason for it.

1:52:34And it's really wasteful.

1:52:37And Facebook, after I mentioned that, somebody wrote to me, and I forgot to even mention this, but it's a good point,

1:52:38is Facebook updates their app all the time.

1:52:41So multiply the size of the update versus how frequently they have new versions.

1:52:46And it's...

1:52:47Yeah, I mean, they famously say in their update notes, "We update the app every two weeks."

1:52:50That's all they say in the update notes, right?

1:52:52So they do it every two weeks.

1:52:53And the same with Messenger.

1:52:54Messenger is almost as big, I feel like, in that, you know, the Facebook Messenger product.

1:52:58And then Facebook has several other apps that are all sort of roughly in the same situation.

1:53:04And then that...

1:53:06An offshoot of all of that reminds me of, this was several weeks ago, Twitter actually

1:53:12added something in their settings to basically clear the cache.

1:53:17And when I did that, I had like a gigabyte worth of information in there.

1:53:22Like what on earth?

1:53:24They were caching, I guess, images and GIFs or something from like years and years ago.

1:53:30It was a gigabyte worth of data.

1:53:32Twitter, 140 characters.

1:53:35140 characters. So in a world where all but the newest devices were still sold

1:53:40in 16 gigabyte configurations you could you can have a gigabyte of old tweets

1:53:44stored there. I don't know, but I feel like it's it's getting out of control

1:53:50and I know that in the early years at the App Store it was a pretty big deal I

1:53:54think the limit was a hundred where you could raise like a hundred

1:53:57bytes it was the limit where it had to be on Wi-Fi and otherwise you could be

1:54:01on cellular and it was a big deal for developers to stay under a hundred

1:54:04because they wanted users to be able to update as soon as they could. And if they were on cellular

1:54:08for an extended stretch, they wanted them to get the updates. But it seems like they've just blown

1:54:13past that. But it's a serious, it adds up to serious bandwidth. So like, I checked, like,

1:54:19I think I pay $50 a month for an AT&T cellular service on my iPad. And I'm thinking about giving

1:54:29I'm not giving this up when I next get an iPad,

1:54:32but my strategy when I bought, it's an iPad mini,

1:54:35and I got it, I don't know, two or three years ago,

1:54:37probably like three years ago, but that's my personal iPad.

1:54:40And my strategy was, I'm gonna have Verizon service

1:54:43on the whole family's iPhones,

1:54:45and I'm gonna get AT&T on my iPad

1:54:48so that if I'm ever somewhere where Verizon,

1:54:50you know, I got on vacation or something,

1:54:51and there's no good Verizon service,

1:54:53I'll have AT&T service.

1:54:54And I pay 50 bucks for seven gigabytes a month,

1:54:58And I think Amy pays like 30 bucks for four gigabytes,

1:55:03or five, I don't know.

1:55:04But it's single digit gigabytes of bandwidth a month.

1:55:07And if you've only got four gigabytes of bandwidth

1:55:09in a month, and app updates are 200 megabytes each,

1:55:12like five app updates use up a quarter of your bandwidth.

1:55:18You could easily chew through the four gigabytes.

1:55:21And I don't feel like people know that.

1:55:22I think people realize that, hey,

1:55:24if I'm going to stream video,

1:55:27that's gonna chew up my bandwidth.

1:55:28Like if I'm gonna watch YouTube for an hour or two,

1:55:31that's obviously on cellular, I'm using my bandwidth.

1:55:34If I watch a Major League Baseball game in the MLB app,

1:55:38I know that I'm using a significant chunk of my bandwidth.

1:55:42Like updating my apps doesn't feel like

1:55:44that should be squandering a huge percentage

1:55:46of my monthly bandwidth, but it is,

1:55:48because people have, a lot of people have

1:55:51a pretty low single digit number of gigabytes

1:55:54a month of bandwidth to use.

1:55:56- Yeah, I mean, I had the exact same situation

1:55:57when I was last moving.

1:55:59Same thing, we were using sort of a tethered device.

1:56:01I think it was a Mifi unit that I had just gotten

1:56:04and hooked up to our AT&T account.

1:56:06And not even explicitly, but I just either forgot

1:56:09or I have too many devices to even remember

1:56:12every single one of them, but I would just leave it on.

1:56:14If I left it on at night, we would always have to turn it off

1:56:16because if I left it on, they would auto update

1:56:19because it considers it to be WiFi

1:56:21'cause I'm connected to a Mifi unit, right?

1:56:23And so it would auto update,

1:56:25and then I'd look at the bill,

1:56:27and we would blow past our, what happened,

1:56:29like 20 gigs in like four days.

1:56:31Almost all from app updates.

1:56:33We weren't watching video.

1:56:34It was like, it was crazy.

1:56:36- Marco Orman has a funny story about that.

1:56:38From years ago, he was at WWDC, and he was tethering,

1:56:41in the era of relatively low gigabytes per month,

1:56:45and he was tethering, and he wanted to,

1:56:47had it set up so he could publish a podcast

1:56:49that they recorded, and he left,

1:56:51he left his, he went to bed, and he left his MacBook open,

1:56:54it downloaded and iTunes downloaded a new episode of Mad Men in HD and it cost

1:56:59him like $70. He got like a single episode of his show you subscribe to it

1:57:04it was like a $70 overage fee or something. Because your Mac doesn't know that.

1:57:09Anyway, no that's a good topic. I don't know what's going on but I feel like

1:57:12Apple's got to get on top of this because I don't feel like we're just

1:57:14crazy old men who are, you know, get off my lawn with your big-ass apps. There's

1:57:19no reason for these apps to be so big. There's absolutely no reason for it.

1:57:22- It reminds me, well two things it reminds me of.

1:57:25'Cause one, it reminds me of back when they tried

1:57:28to launch magazines on the iPad, right?

1:57:30And they were massive, because they were just pictures

1:57:34of pages, right?

1:57:36They would scan in a picture of Wired magazine,

1:57:39and that would be the app.

1:57:40And so they were each individual, episode,

1:57:45each individual issue was 700 to 800 megabytes.

1:57:49and it was just so ridiculous and so tedious to download.

1:57:52They seem to have streamlined that a little bit.

1:57:54Obviously there's less of an emphasis on it these days,

1:57:57but I noticed they're downloading faster,

1:58:00so I assume that they're smaller.

1:58:02The one other thing is,

1:58:04this actually came out a couple weeks ago, I think.

1:58:07So Twitter now, one of the things Twitter launched recently

1:58:10was Twitter Lite, L-I-T-E.

1:58:12It's like the lite version of their service

1:58:14because of this problem, right?

1:58:16Like in developing countries,

1:58:19they can't possibly download 250 megabyte apps

1:58:23or have your Twitter app store a gigabyte worth of data.

1:58:28And so they ended up launching, it's just on the web,

1:58:31and it's the same thing Facebook did back in the day.

1:58:35This was several years ago, they launched a Facebook Lite.

1:58:37And when they launched these things,

1:58:40everyone seems to praise them for it

1:58:42because it's like, wow, it's so great, it's so fast.

1:58:45I remember I would try to use Facebook Lite

1:58:47as my main thing, even though it was meant for

1:58:49sort of third world countries.

1:58:51So they're all like, they have these funny ways around it

1:58:54because they know that that situation

1:58:56is just completely untenable,

1:58:58certainly outside of the United States.

1:58:59And so they have like whole teams now

1:59:01devoted to launching light versions of their product.

1:59:04- It's, I don't know what the solution is,

1:59:06but something's gotta be done

1:59:07because it's getting out of hand

1:59:09and it's only getting worse.

1:59:10I just can't help but feel too

1:59:13that when I read that technical analysis

1:59:14of the Facebook app bundle

1:59:16and how many duplicate resources and frameworks they have.

1:59:20The project, the Xcode project to build it

1:59:23must be like a total mess of spaghetti logic.

1:59:26There's just no way that you get in that situation.

1:59:31There's no good explanation behind that.

1:59:34- Well, and the problem also, I assume,

1:59:36unlike sort of like you with Vesper

1:59:39where you have a very small team working on it,

1:59:41Facebook presumably has hundreds, if not more,

1:59:44people working on all of these things.

1:59:45So you can say like just you know streamline some of it but it's like whose job is that you need like an overseer of the code?

1:59:51I guess I mean, I guess I can see how it happened

1:59:54but it's still not a good explanation where if the people who are working on their

1:59:57snapchat clone

2:00:00Need they need to depend to build it. They need a copy of the the Facebook

2:00:05You know

2:00:07framework the the

2:00:08Everybody uses this framework with our core shared code, but the other teams need the same thing

2:00:14but they can't depend on where that is.

2:00:16And that's all of a sudden how you have three copies

2:00:18of the same framework, because team A needed it,

2:00:21team B needed it, and all of a sudden--

2:00:24- I also really liked his note about finding the strings

2:00:28that were like, you will be fired if you turn this on.

2:00:31- Right, or if you use this API.

2:00:33That was funny too.

2:00:34- And my joke back to you about the Dropbox one was like,

2:00:39well, yeah, of course, 'cause they're including

2:00:40the Dropbox stories into it.

2:00:42But I think someone else had an even funnier one, I thought,

2:00:45which is like for the Facebook ones, where it's like,

2:00:47well, yeah, of course they're that big.

2:00:48I mean, they had to shove all of Snapchat into the app,

2:00:51so what else are you gonna do?

2:00:52(laughing)

2:00:54- I'm looking here.

2:00:58Do you wanna talk about clips a little bit?

2:01:00Or?

2:01:01- Yeah, we can.

2:01:02I don't have, I've played with it a little bit.

2:01:05I found it confusing when I was first using it,

2:01:07but I only have played with it for a few minutes.

2:01:09It sounds like you did the sit-down,

2:01:11sort of a walkthrough with Apple about it.

2:01:13From your view, what's their mentality?

2:01:18I know you said something like, you know,

2:01:20obviously they didn't launch a social network,

2:01:22it's just meant for other networks, right?

2:01:24But why do it?

2:01:27Is it a reason to buy the iPhone?

2:01:28Like, what's the rationale?

2:01:30- I think the rationale is that they see these things as,

2:01:34I don't think we collectively have a name for it yet,

2:01:38but that it's a new medium.

2:01:40It's not quite a video, it's not quite an animated GIF.

2:01:43It's sort of, but it's got all these ideas

2:01:47where you can use text to annotate,

2:01:49you can include multiple clips,

2:01:52so it's not just one shot of video.

2:01:54You can include stills.

2:01:55It's meant to be viewed on a phone,

2:01:59and you can do it with minimal fuss,

2:02:02and that it's right up their alley to make,

2:02:04it's like the social networks

2:02:06are how they get distributed, right?

2:02:08Instagram and Snapchat and Facebook, of course.

2:02:11But that the tools to actually make

2:02:14the best possible version of this

2:02:15is exactly in Apple's wheelhouse

2:02:18of the sort of things that they do well.

2:02:20And I still stand by, I'm very proud of it,

2:02:22as a tweet-length review that it's like iMovie

2:02:25and Keynote had a baby and the baby got the best genes

2:02:28from both parents, like I really do believe that.

2:02:31I have a couple of small complaints about it,

2:02:34but one thing that they do that's very smart,

2:02:36and I think it's why the bundle size is so small,

2:02:39is that they have all these titles

2:02:42and certainly the music soundtracks,

2:02:46they're not included in the download.

2:02:48And so when you start using the AppFresh,

2:02:50if you wanna get these soundtracks,

2:02:51you have to download them.

2:02:53- Oh, okay, that's good.

2:02:54Maybe that's what Facebook and others should learn from.

2:02:56- I think it's a great idea.

2:02:57I think it's so you can start using the app

2:03:00with a minimal download and just download.

2:03:02And so if you are on cellular or a slow network,

2:03:05you can just download the ones you really want.

2:03:07My only beef about it is I do wish

2:03:09there was a Download All button.

2:03:11Like, in iTunes you can do that.

2:03:13So like, if you're using the iTunes Music Library,

2:03:16you can have a music album that's in the cloud,

2:03:18and if you just want one song, you can download it.

2:03:20But if you want to download the whole album,

2:03:22you can download the whole album

2:03:23without clicking 11 times to download.

2:03:26I feel like Eclipse should have that for the title styles

2:03:29and for the music soundtrack.

2:03:32- Why do you think, though,

2:03:33that they launched it when they did?

2:03:34Why not make it a feature of iOS 11?

2:03:36Why do it as a fully standalone thing?

2:03:39- That's a good question.

2:03:41I guess because it's ready and they feel like why not?

2:03:45That's my guess and that maybe that they,

2:03:49they see this as an exploding form,

2:03:52these sort of stories-based meme-style mini-videos.

2:03:57One of the other things too that I think is central to it

2:04:03is that being silent is part of,

2:04:06you can include sound,

2:04:08you can include and include in those music soundtracks,

2:04:10but the fact that a lot of people

2:04:11are gonna listen to them in silence

2:04:13is part of the idea,

2:04:16and it's part of why they spent so much effort

2:04:18on this annotated text that gets the text

2:04:20as you dictate it.

2:04:24I feel like that they see this as,

2:04:29this is my guess,

2:04:30is that they see this art form as exploding

2:04:32and that it makes sense to get it out sooner rather than later,

2:04:35because iOS 11 isn't going to ship until September,

2:04:38if they're on schedule.

2:04:40And so if they're ready to go now in early April--

2:04:43and I think it is.

2:04:44I think the app is certainly in 1.0 shape.

2:04:47It's in very good 1.0 shape.

2:04:49I feel like they don't want to wait.

2:04:51Maybe do less as big monolithic OS updates

2:04:55and keep doing more as individual app updates.

2:04:58Do you buy anything into the notion

2:05:01of this being sort of a toe dip into augmented reality.

2:05:05'Cause obviously we see that,

2:05:06we see both Microsoft, Google, and a handful of others

2:05:09sort of launch some of these things.

2:05:10Microsoft just launched one,

2:05:11they call it like Sprinkles the other day,

2:05:12which is effectively using some of their

2:05:16machine learning technology to sort of alter images.

2:05:18Google just launched that thing where you can doodle

2:05:20and it will look up, try to match it to a picture.

2:05:24So all of these guys are clearly doing that

2:05:26as both experimentation, but also to sort of train data,

2:05:29right, to be better at that.

2:05:30Do you buy Apple trying to do that?

2:05:34Anything with it for augmented reality?

2:05:36- A little bit, because I feel like you have to call

2:05:38the face recognition as augmented reality, right?

2:05:41I mean, maybe it's not augmenting it,

2:05:43but it certainly is, it's reality aware.

2:05:47Is that a better way to say it?

2:05:48You know, where if you shoot a clip

2:05:50and it has three of your friends in it,

2:05:51and the facial recognition is able to identify them,

2:05:55and the fact that when you go to share it,

2:05:56they're the first three people it suggests sharing it to,

2:05:59It's not quite augmented reality in the sense of,

2:06:02okay, here's goggles that show you the real world

2:06:05and overlay things.

2:06:08- But it is machine learning, for sure.

2:06:09- It is, and it is, the device in your hand

2:06:13is making, is aware of the real world.

2:06:16It is saying, I know that I'm shooting,

2:06:18that's a picture of your son, I know that.

2:06:21I almost feel like augmented reality

2:06:27is a term that's not gonna pan out.

2:06:30I feel like it's more just devices being reality aware.

2:06:35- Yeah, and I think like, I don't disagree with that

2:06:42because I do think, you know, sort of,

2:06:45everyone assumed augmented reality would be

2:06:48sort of like what the Magic Leap videos are, right?

2:06:50Where it's like, you're looking out

2:06:52and you have glasses on or something

2:06:54and then a whale jumps out of the street.

2:06:56But what we're seeing is like the mainstream usage,

2:06:59at least right now of course,

2:07:00of what you would call quote unquote augmented reality

2:07:03is more along lines of Snapchat filters and Pokemon Go,

2:07:07where they're just different,

2:07:09there's nuance to how they're not quite like that.

2:07:14Pokemon Go's a little bit more like that,

2:07:18but Snapchat's more just what you were talking about,

2:07:21sort of being able to recognize a face

2:07:24and do manipulation of that.

2:07:26And if you think about it with a little bit of battery,

2:07:31you could, like why can't your iPhone be as aware

2:07:36of where it is as you are?

2:07:39I don't think we're very far from this at all.

2:07:43And I mean this in the sense of beyond GPS.

2:07:47Like GPS is certainly one aspect of knowing where it is.

2:07:50But like when I'm walking down Broad Street in Philadelphia,

2:07:55Broad Street in Philadelphia.

2:07:57Like, if you had me blindfolded until the moment

2:07:59and then you opened my eyes,

2:08:01it's only gonna take me an instant or two

2:08:03to realize where I am on Broad Street in Philadelphia,

2:08:07'cause I'm very familiar with it.

2:08:09Well, if I have my phone in my hand,

2:08:10why can't the phone use the camera very briefly

2:08:12and just take a quick look, a quick peek,

2:08:15and instantly realize, oh, I know exactly where I am.

2:08:18I'm at Broad and Spruce in Philadelphia,

2:08:21'cause I recognize this instantly,

2:08:24way that a human can't and and Merlin Mann and I talked about this recently on

2:08:28this show but and we can't go in depth on these voice assistants but like

2:08:32things like the I mean it's very good in a lot of ways but why can't devices like

2:08:38said recognize every voice in the family it seems to me like we're very gonna be

2:08:43very close to that because a human being certainly could if we had a human being

2:08:46in our kitchen the human being would know instantly whether it was me or my

2:08:52wife or my son who is asking for the weather and now it doesn't matter maybe

2:08:57if the question is what's the weather like it doesn't matter who it is but if

2:09:00it's what's on my agenda they should certainly not oh yeah we will that will

2:09:05absolutely happen I would say that happens in short order and you start

2:09:09thinking about these things and I said I think about like oh how would you

2:09:11program something how would you think about making a computer that does this

2:09:14and you think about what our ears can do and it's like when you're familiar with

2:09:17your with like your house or whatever it's not just that you know who's

2:09:20talking to you, but you can basically tell where they're talking to you from.

2:09:23Like if somebody's upstairs from you and they're yelling, "MG, you know, can

2:09:28you blah blah blah," you know that they're upstairs. You can hear it. Your

2:09:32ears pick up that location, and like, why can't these devices know that?

2:09:37Context awareness. And yeah, I mean, but look at, like, Apple still does the thing

2:09:43right where you have to sort of "train" Siri when you start, right?

2:09:47you have to say like hey and so it'll only illuminate with your voice that's

2:09:52still right right yeah well it's supposedly but it's it's not it's not

2:09:58very accurate in my opinion in terms of locking people out like in fact I think

2:10:02my wife just used on my phone I'm not sure if she pressed the button or not

2:10:07though and if that's the case that's sort of weird that they even make you do

2:10:09that if it's just not you know cuz obviously like you don't sort of voice

2:10:14train and I don't think the Google won either right now I just triggered love

2:10:24to beep it yeah it's so hard to talk about these things on a podcast you saw

2:10:31that thing that just like that news broke I didn't read the full story about

2:10:34it but I saw that somewhat Burger King's trying to do a commercial that triggers

2:10:39the Google Home. Oh, really? I did not see that. And I think I saw that Google is already

2:10:45going to block that because that's a whole can of worms, obviously.

2:10:53That's a bad idea. But anyway, I feel like there's a lot to go in that direction. I still

2:10:59feel like one of the main areas where Apple is—I think it's just that they just didn't

2:11:03have it ready, but the way that they don't share the facial recognition data between

2:11:07your different devices is a huge hole,

2:11:09and I think that they will,

2:11:10and I think that their whole explanation last year

2:11:13that it was about privacy was just,

2:11:15it wasn't that, it wasn't like,

2:11:17we believe so much in privacy

2:11:18that we're not gonna share this between your devices.

2:11:21I think that the reading between the lines,

2:11:23the answer is, we believe in privacy,

2:11:25and we don't have a private way

2:11:27to share it between your devices yet,

2:11:28and so we're not gonna do it.

2:11:29We're not gonna do it in a way

2:11:31that we're not satisfied with the privacy

2:11:33until we have it ready,

2:11:33but I think it's inevitable that they will.

2:11:36- Right, and they made a bunch,

2:11:38I can't remember the exact name or wording

2:11:41of the technology. - Differential privacy.

2:11:43- Differential privacy, right, yeah.

2:11:44- Well, that's different though

2:11:45than sharing personal information.

2:11:46Differential privacy is about--

2:11:48- Is fully anonymized. - Yes.

2:11:50But like, real private, you know,

2:11:52like they do share stuff between their devices,

2:11:55like in the same way that you can get

2:11:56end-to-end encrypted iMessages on multiple devices.

2:12:00It's not like they don't believe

2:12:02in non-duplicating private information between your devices.

2:12:05It's just that for whatever reason,

2:12:07the photo face ID stuff wasn't technically ready.

2:12:11That's my belief.

2:12:12It's not that they're never not going to do it.

2:12:15But for something like Clips, it would really help.

2:12:16- Yeah.

2:12:17And we'll see, I mean, my guess is that their stance

2:12:22just maybe doesn't fully change over time.

2:12:26'Cause they've obviously, they've taken the privacy stance

2:12:29like you mentioned, but the implications of that

2:12:31were that they were gonna try to do

2:12:32as much on the device as possible.

2:12:34And I think that's fine.

2:12:35and good and we'll see what they can do with that.

2:12:37But I would imagine that if they really need to get

2:12:41in the game for all of these things that we're talking about

2:12:43in a big way, they are gonna have to start doing a lot

2:12:46in the cloud and so then yeah, it becomes like a question

2:12:48of how they do it, whether it's a differential privacy

2:12:53or if they come up with other new technologies

2:12:56so that they feel okay with the privacy sort of trade-offs.

2:12:59But there's always going to be trade-offs.

2:13:01>> All right, we've gone on pretty long.

2:13:02Do you want to spend five minutes on Netflix and Amazon

2:13:05or do you wanna wrap it up?

2:13:06- The problem is, I think that that's just such a long--

2:13:10- I say we save it for the next time you're on the show.

2:13:12- Okay, let's save it.

2:13:13- 'Cause I feel like doing it quick wouldn't do it justice,

2:13:17and I feel-- - Yes.

2:13:18- And both of them are so active in this regard

2:13:21that there's gonna be new stuff to talk about soon.

2:13:23But anyway, I'm with you that I feel like

2:13:25they're both super fascinating.

2:13:27- Yes.

2:13:28- What's your favorite Netflix show?

2:13:31- We really liked "The Queen."

2:13:34- I didn't see that.

2:13:36- You should see it, it's good.

2:13:36It was the one that's the most expensive one.

2:13:38I think they said it's more expensive

2:13:40than Game of Thrones to make.

2:13:41- Wow.

2:13:43- Yeah, because of the costumes,

2:13:45and it's obviously a full period piece.

2:13:47And yeah, so it's supposedly the most expensive,

2:13:51I don't know if it's the most expensive show ever,

2:13:53but it's ahead of Game of Thrones,

2:13:55so it's gotta be up there.

2:13:57And that was really well done.

2:13:59On Amazon right now we're watching

2:14:02The Man in the High Castle, which I like.

2:14:03It was a little slow to get into.

2:14:04I'm starting to really like it.

2:14:05- Oh, I almost gave up on it.

2:14:06I almost gave up.

2:14:07- Yeah, same, same.

2:14:09- My favorite thing that either of them are doing

2:14:11is Netflix's incredible all-in focus on comedy specials.

2:14:16The Dave Chappelle ones are two of the best

2:14:21comedy specials I've seen in memory.

2:14:24And they released them both at the same time.

2:14:27They were both amazing.

2:14:28And it's, I like comedy specials in general,

2:14:32but my wife does too.

2:14:33And so it's like this perfect sweet spot of,

2:14:35oh my god, every single time one of these comes out,

2:14:37we've got something we're both looking forward

2:14:39to watching together.

2:14:41And they just keep coming out.

2:14:44It's Dave Chappelle and Amy Schumer.

2:14:45And now I just saw that there's a Louis C.K. one.

2:14:47It's almost like they're coming out with them

2:14:49faster than we can watch, which is amazing.

2:14:53- And so I'm surprised that like,

2:14:55'cause this is like what HBO used to do back in the day,

2:14:57right, HBO would have all the comedy specials,

2:15:01I guess in the 90s.

2:15:02And I'm sort of surprised, because it

2:15:04is such a relatively cheap versus doing

2:15:09a full production of a television show or something.

2:15:11Yeah, it's super cheap.

2:15:11Like Avenue to Go Down.

2:15:13They just give a ton of money to the comedian, like $20 million.

2:15:16I think Chappelle got $20 million.

2:15:18I forget.

2:15:19Something like that.

2:15:21I know that Will Seinfeld got, I think

2:15:23it's $100 million for his show, the comedians--

2:15:26getting coffee with comedians or whatever in cars,

2:15:28whatever's called.

2:15:29Well, is that moving networks?

2:15:30Is that moving?

2:15:31- Yes, it's moving over to Netflix,

2:15:32and so they bid up the rights.

2:15:35Yeah.

2:15:36- Oh man, oh man, that's just brilliant.

2:15:39That's absolutely brilliant,

2:15:40because I feel like he would be doing the same thing,

2:15:43whether it was televised or not.

2:15:44So he's getting a hundred million dollars to--

2:15:46- Oh yeah, I mean, he says that.

2:15:48I mean, 'cause it was on like Crackle or whatever,

2:15:50and he was just like, "Yeah, I just had this crazy idea,"

2:15:52and someone said, "We'll put up the cost."

2:15:54Okay, cool, great.

2:15:55- But here's the thing, and again,

2:15:58we won't go too deep on it,

2:15:59But I remember as a kid growing up,

2:16:01all the great comedy specials were on HBO,

2:16:03and I didn't really think about it,

2:16:05but I assumed it was, I only thought about it

2:16:07from the perspective of commercial interruptions

2:16:11would wreck it.

2:16:12You can't interrupt, you know,

2:16:13the whole point of a great stand-up routine

2:16:15is that it builds continuously,

2:16:18and there's never a good point for a commercial break.

2:16:21And B, almost all of them have material

2:16:25that would be inappropriate for major networks.

2:16:29And so of course HBO's the natural home

2:16:31because they can put R-rated content up

2:16:33and they have no commercial breaks

2:16:35and so that's why it's on HBO.

2:16:36What never occurred to me until Netflix

2:16:40has suddenly become the dominant force

2:16:42in stand-up comedy specials is that they're evergreen.

2:16:46That they can show, like the Dave Chappelle 2017

2:16:49comedy special is something that people

2:16:50were gonna watch five, six years from now.

2:16:53Like six, seven years from now,

2:16:54some kid is gonna all of a sudden discover Dave Chappelle

2:16:57and the Dave Chappelle comedy specials

2:17:00that are exclusive to Netflix,

2:17:02they're gonna watch 'em back to back to back to back.

2:17:05It's evergreen content.

2:17:06- And it's, right, exactly.

2:17:07It's the perfect type of content

2:17:09for what Netflix and Amazon are doing,

2:17:11because in the HBO days, like we were talking about,

2:17:13there was no concept of on-demand.

2:17:15You had to watch it when it was on.

2:17:17Now we live in an on-demand world,

2:17:19and if you want to have some sort of differentiation

2:17:23of content, it's hard to beat that.

2:17:26But I can see now how, in hindsight, that was part of HBO's strategy back in the day,

2:17:29is that HBO could show their Eddie Murphy comedy special a year later.

2:17:33They could just put it on at five in the morning, and somebody would be up and be like, "Oh,

2:17:37Eddie Murphy, I'll watch that," that it would fill up space and that it would never really

2:17:43that it was as close to evergreen as you could get for exclusive content.

2:17:47Yeah.

2:17:48The one things that aren't doing that well, it seems like, are—and maybe you have a

2:17:54better example but like so the talk shows that have moved over like the

2:17:57actual like sort of late night things like there was the Chelsea Chelsea

2:18:00Hanlon right which I don't think was doing I don't even know if it's so on it

2:18:05might be but I don't think that's like a weird format for Netflix right do you

2:18:09agree like it's um yeah I I watched it a few times and I as a talk show

2:18:15aficionado I do I liked it and I thought you know and then there's this whole you

2:18:20know, meta discussion for years now of, you know, how come there aren't any women

2:18:25with late night comedy shows, you know, and even in this era when Jay Leno

2:18:29and Letterman were retiring and there was time for turnover, the show still

2:18:33went to two guys. And so I was interested in Chelsea Handler's show and I

2:18:38liked it and I watched quite a few episodes but it never ever grooved on me

2:18:43and I don't know why. And there is something to a talk show, a late night

2:18:46talk show, where it feels like it's supposed to be on at a certain time. Even

2:18:49if I watch it, there's a ritual to it. Yes, totally. Even if I watch it on TiVo, which

2:18:53I usually did, it feels like this was the show from Tuesday and it was on at 1130. And

2:19:00you know that it was on at Tuesday at 1130. And the Netflix style of, "Here it is, and

2:19:05you can watch it whenever," it somehow doesn't seem right. But on the other hand, she definitely,

2:19:09Chelsea Handler's show, it definitely felt like a late-night talk show. It didn't feel

2:19:13like Ellen DeGeneres' show, which very clearly is a daytime talk show. And I, you know, we

2:19:19could spend it you could teach a whole class on what are this lighting and

2:19:24differences yeah but I you can tell you know I don't know you know it's I don't

2:19:29know how to explain it but I know it when I see it there's late night shows

2:19:32and daytime talk shows and Chelsea handlers was a late night talk show and

2:19:36that reminds me of I wrote about this a while ago I guess when stranger things

2:19:41was on so you know the Netflix show I love stranger things that was great but

2:19:45I kept thinking to myself while we're watching it like yeah, it's cool that we can binge watch it

2:19:51But it almost feels like the type of show where it would have been

2:19:54Better suited for sort of a weekly cadence type thing and there's like, you know release watches

2:20:00You know sort of like what we do that what people do for Game of Thrones now

2:20:04Yeah, especially with the cliffhanger endings, you know it did. Yeah, I don't know right do fee

2:20:08I if there's anything I think Netflix should rethink is I think it's they should they should rethink there

2:20:13We're just gonna drop the whole season at once for all of our shows. I don't think that they should do that

2:20:17I think that for some shows it works and for some shows it right. It's actually robbing us of some fun

2:20:22Yeah, and I think there's stance on the matter is we have this very

2:20:26This very regimented worldview of that and this is we want people to know that

2:20:31All of our content is always going to be available when they sign up

2:20:35but I do think I would bet that over time they do get more nuanced with that and they do have some shows that

2:20:40that launch like that and some that don't.

2:20:42And they're starting to get more into movies now,

2:20:44and there's obviously all this sort of back and forth

2:20:46between theater owners, like some of them want to make sure

2:20:49that the movie is still screened in a theater

2:20:51for Oscar contention and whatnot.

2:20:53And Amazon has been more amenable to that, I guess,

2:20:56and Netflix still has been very strict in saying,

2:20:58nope has to go on Netflix, the exact moment

2:21:00that sort of it launches.

2:21:02And I would imagine that they have to sort of give and take

2:21:05a little bit on some of those things.

2:21:07- So much for not spending five minutes

2:21:08talking about Netflix and Amazon.

2:21:10I would say this, I think Game of Thrones, I enjoy it.

2:21:13I enjoy it very much.

2:21:14I look forward to it coming back.

2:21:17I watch it every week.

2:21:18I would rank it as one of my favorite shows of all time.

2:21:22Is it top 10?

2:21:24I don't know, it's close.

2:21:25It's certainly in the top 20,

2:21:26but it may not be in the top 10.

2:21:27I'm not a huge superfan.

2:21:29But I would say this, I think it's the best show ever

2:21:34in the history of these modern super shows

2:21:38at making that weekly cliffhanger add to the show.

2:21:43- Yeah. - Like, I feel like

2:21:45it's the best.

2:21:46There's a bunch of shows that I've enjoyed more,

2:21:48but Game of Thrones, and I think it's partly just

2:21:52that they're very self-aware of their,

2:21:54we're on Sunday night, and we're gonna make you talk

2:21:57about us Monday, and combined with the fact

2:22:00that there's like a thousand characters.

2:22:02(laughing)

2:22:03So, right, like a show like Mad--

2:22:06- So it's not repetition over and over again.

2:22:07- A show like Mad Men, which I would possibly argue

2:22:10is my all-time favorite show,

2:22:11it's certainly in my top two or three,

2:22:13it had a somewhat smaller number of characters

2:22:17and had one character who was clearly the protagonist

2:22:21of the story that it was, it would have been artificial

2:22:23to have a cliffhanger every week.

2:22:26It just wasn't, some weeks it was,

2:22:29most weeks, more weeks often than not,

2:22:31it didn't leave you dying for the next episode.

2:22:34And that was just the way the show was written

2:22:35and it was very natural to it.

2:22:37But Game of Thrones is really, really good at that.

2:22:39I feel like Game of Thrones that was dumped

2:22:4110 episodes at once would be, it would lose so much.

2:22:44- Yes, totally.

2:22:46And the notion used to be that you would save

2:22:49sort of the cliffhanger for the season end

2:22:51because it's just so hard to do them week after week

2:22:54and Game of Thrones pulls it off better.

2:22:56I can't, like Breaking Bad was pretty good about it.

2:22:59Then there's a handful of other shows

2:23:01that I think were good at it.

2:23:02But yeah, it's pretty incredible.

2:23:06And the fact that they do it,

2:23:08and they had to translate it from books, right?

2:23:11I mean, so it's not like the books are,

2:23:14obviously they follow them to a certain extent,

2:23:16but the cliffhanger thing is just a page turn away,

2:23:19so it's different.

2:23:20- Well, one of the books I remember having that feeling with

2:23:23was when I first read The Lord of the Rings,

2:23:25'cause I remember with The Lord of the Rings,

2:23:26where the chapters would, you'd leave Sam--

2:23:30- Yeah, one location.

2:23:31You'd leave Frodo and Sam and you'd go back to somebody

2:23:34and you'd be like, oh my god, why are we going back to them?

2:23:36I wanna find out what happened to Frodo and Sam.

2:23:37Jeez, that's terrible.

2:23:39And then all of a sudden, three pages later,

2:23:40you're all, forget about Frodo and Sam,

2:23:42you're with these other guys.

2:23:44And then you get to the--

2:23:44- And that is what the Game of Thrones books do as well.

2:23:46They focus on one individual storyline.

2:23:49- And I love those books, you know,

2:23:52who doesn't love those books?

2:23:53But part of the brilliance of the structure

2:23:56was the way that every single chapter,

2:23:58I was like desperate to keep going with who I was with

2:24:01and was very upset to go back to these other characters,

2:24:03but then three pages later, I'm all totally into them.

2:24:06And I feel like Game of Thrones has that in TV.

2:24:09- I can't believe, I know they're going to pull it off,

2:24:14but I really can't believe that they're going to pull off

2:24:16like finishing the whole series before even the next book,

2:24:19you know, there's still two more books to come.

2:24:22And I think they're gonna finish the series

2:24:24before even the next book comes.

2:24:26And it's just incredible.

2:24:28Like you would have thought like this would have been

2:24:30the ultimate logistical nightmare when you're sort of pitching the show, right?

2:24:35Like, what's the worst that could happen?

2:24:37Well, we could not have, sort of, know what the ending is going to be

2:24:40because the other books haven't come out yet.

2:24:42Oh, come on, that's, you know, a decade away.

2:24:44Of course we're going to have those, and nope, we're not going to have them.

2:24:47I don't know how that's going to, does it make any sense to me?

2:24:50I haven't read the books, though, so I don't really care.

2:24:53It's just insanely impressive of the showrunners of that show

2:24:57that they're able to sort of land the ship without having the infrastructure you would think to do so.

2:25:03Yeah, I wonder if that's going to really hurt the show. I wonder how much they depend on that.

2:25:06I don't know. It is actually unprecedented to know what will end up happening with that.

2:25:15Like, do they... Because they say the show's only going to... So this coming season,

2:25:18which I think starts in July, is going to be slightly truncated, right? It's going to be,

2:25:22I think, seven, six or seven episodes, not ten. And then they're going to split that into the next

2:25:27season which will also be a truncated season and that's the end really but do

2:25:32that's that's what the word is right now I don't know if they're gonna change

2:25:35that at all do they end up doing something like you know ending it with a

2:25:39with a movie in a few years something like that but as of right now I think

2:25:45the plan is just two more seasons two more shortened seasons oh I don't know

2:25:48I don't know how they're gonna do it I look forward to it them all right mg

2:25:52thank you so much for your time it's always good to have you on the show yes

2:25:56Thank you. I will see you soon and everybody can catch you on Twitter. What's your Twitter handle?

2:26:01at mg c glad mg siegler and your

2:26:05The place where they can catch the writing is it all your writing or just most your writing?

2:26:11most of it is

2:26:12100 yes words five five hundred ish dot-com hundred ish dot-com

2:26:16Yes, and good stuff. So still good columns coming out of you

2:26:23Thanks when I get a free moment in between everything else that I do now these days.

2:26:28All right. Thank you very much.

2:26:30Thank you, John.