0:00:00We probably should have recorded last week, but I had stuff to do.
0:00:04And so here we are one week later after you and I saw each other in Cupertino
0:00:07for a mysterious-- I think it was billed to me as a Mac roundtable.
0:00:12How was it billed to you in advance of our meeting last week?
0:00:16Yeah, about the future of the Mac or whatever.
0:00:22So I went into it with thinking 50/50 in my head
0:00:29whether this was going to be--
0:00:31that's all I knew.
0:00:32It was going to be about the Mac,
0:00:33and it was going to be a roundtable discussion
0:00:35with a couple of executives and a handful of members
0:00:39of the media.
0:00:42And I went into it thinking, well, this
0:00:44has got to be about the Mac Pro, because it's not an event.
0:00:50It's the opposite of events, very small.
0:00:52How can they have something about the Mac and not address
0:00:58the elephant in a room that was the thousand and some day old Mac Pro.
0:01:03So I went into it thinking 50/50 this is either going to be good news about the Mac Pro or bad news about the Mac Pro.
0:01:08Like we're done with the Mac Pro or we're not done with the Mac Pro
0:01:13but we can't show it yet and here's why. What were you thinking?
0:01:18Yeah, you're probably smarter than me. I don't know.
0:01:23And it really connected directly to the Mac Pro, although in hindsight it seems fairly reasonable to do that.
0:01:31I mean, I guess I did a little bit. Obviously, the Mac Pro is sort of the elephant in the room in a lot of ways for Apple and the Mac, in the sweep of the Mac universe.
0:01:41But I think it's definitely, it was definitely an opportunity to say, you know, "Hey, here's some things we're thinking about about the Mac."
0:01:51But I mean, it all, as you probably picked up on it, it was very odd because, you know,
0:01:55very rarely, as everybody knows, does Apple actually say, "Hey, we're going to talk about
0:02:00future things."
0:02:01You know?
0:02:02So that aspect of it was confusing to me, and my only inkling about that was like, "Oh,
0:02:07they need to set something up."
0:02:09You know?
0:02:10Right.
0:02:11Well, my thinking was that it could be that that would be very similar to how they would
0:02:17announce the end of life of the Mac Pro if that had been their decision.
0:02:21They're not going to hold a product announcement event for a product that's end of life.
0:02:27Right.
0:02:29And I feel like even if the answer was, "Let's just make pro quality iMacs," when they unveil
0:02:37them on stage, they're not going to want to sully that on stage by saying, "Oh, and remember the
0:02:43Mac Pro, we don't need that anymore."
0:02:46Right.
0:02:47that they would want to break it in a non-keynote type
0:02:52scenario, whether it's somebody in particular gets
0:02:57an exclusive or a handful of people get an exclusive
0:03:00and get a chance to ask questions about it.
0:03:02I think it would have been very similar if that
0:03:03had been their decision.
0:03:05And I think that obviously the reason why they--
0:03:09that wasn't the news.
0:03:09The news, in fact, is that they are hard at work
0:03:12on an all new Mac Pro.
0:03:14But because they're so far away from shipping it,
0:03:18which we can get into next, that they felt
0:03:25like they had to say something.
0:03:27They could not just wait.
0:03:28And they wanted to, I think combined with the fact
0:03:30that they wanted to release speed bumps or price drops,
0:03:35whatever you want to call what it is they've
0:03:37done with the current Mac Pro last week, where
0:03:40they, at the same price levels, they've
0:03:43gone from, you know, the entry level is no longer four core, it's six core, and the
0:03:47mid-level one is no longer six core, it's eight core or something like that.
0:03:51If that's all they did is just update the store and not say anything about the
0:03:56future,
0:03:57people would have lost their damn minds. Rightly so. People would have
0:04:01lost their minds,
0:04:02rightly so, because it wouldn't have made any sense that Apple was
0:04:06pretending that this was normal.
0:04:09- Right, it's one of those scenarios where context-free
0:04:12update would have caused many, many more problems
0:04:17than it solved, I guess is the word, right?
0:04:20And I think that that's an unusual position for them
0:04:26to be in to feel strongly enough about
0:04:29the future of a particular category
0:04:32for them to set it up or tee it up in that way.
0:04:35'Cause a lot of times they just sort of take their lumps.
0:04:38they'll just do it and people will misconstrue it or whatever, and then they'll come out
0:04:43with the thing that they were teeing up and then either people will like it or they won't,
0:04:47you know? But in this case, I guess they felt strongly enough about how long it had been
0:04:52or how, you know, how much culpability they felt, I guess, you know, in how the thing
0:04:58played out, that they felt that they needed to contextualize it.
0:05:03I feel like a week later, I feel like there is no simple answer.
0:05:12I feel like part of it, in terms of, you know, I think you asked the question and you prefaced it with,
0:05:22"I don't want to get too personal."
0:05:24[laughter]
0:05:26But the gist of the question was, "When the hell..."
0:05:28Which always means that somebody's about to get personal.
0:05:30Right. When did you guys realize you've done fucked up?
0:05:33I mean, that's not what you said, but we had,
0:05:37so for everybody who doesn't have it in top of their minds, it was,
0:05:41it was nine of us at the table. It was, it was representing Apple was, uh,
0:05:45Phil Schiller, uh, Craig Federighi talking software, uh,
0:05:50and John Ternus, T E R N U S,
0:05:53who was a vice president of hardware and,
0:05:55and as it was described to us at the beginning of the meeting on his plate,
0:05:59our iPad pro and Mac pro,
0:06:03And maybe MacBook Pro?
0:06:05I forget what they said.
0:06:07But I know iPad Pro and a couple of others.
0:06:10And I think-- and honestly, he had very good things
0:06:14to say at the roundtable.
0:06:16But just talking to a couple of other people
0:06:18at Apple in the last week after this came out,
0:06:21it sounds to me like Ternus is a real up and comer at the company.
0:06:24Like, I don't think it's the last time that we're
0:06:26going to hear from him in some sort of publicity facing event.
0:06:32It seems to me like he's a real up and comer.
0:06:35And the fact that he's been tasked with, all right,
0:06:38you're going to run point on hardware on this new Mac Pro
0:06:40is a sign of that.
0:06:41And I think a good sign.
0:06:42I think people who are hoping that this Mac Pro is everything
0:06:46Mac Pro users have been hoping for,
0:06:48I think the fact that John Turnus is in charge of it
0:06:50is a very good sign.
0:06:53And then on the press side, it was me and you,
0:06:59Ina Fried, who was recently of ReCode, but is now at a new site called Axios, for those
0:07:04of you who don't follow the comings and goings of the press very closely.
0:07:10John Pachkowski, also recently of ReCode, but now at Buzzfeed.
0:07:16And last but not least, Lance Ullenoff, who was there from Mashable.
0:07:21So former ReCode writers were well represented.
0:07:25Nobody from ReCode was there at the moment.
0:07:27was a large category, percentage-wise.
0:07:31Yes.
0:07:3340%.
0:07:3440% of the press attendees were formerly of Recode.
0:07:37And then last but not least, or maybe possibly least,
0:07:40was Bill Evans from Apple PR, who was at the table.
0:07:43But as Apple PR's wont, he was more or less
0:07:45there to play defense and pretty much just run the clock
0:07:48and didn't really.
0:07:55So I thought that the--
0:08:02we all tried to ask.
0:08:03I would say everybody except Patch Kowski, who only
0:08:06piped in at the end with a very well-timed question
0:08:08about the Mac Mini.
0:08:11Everybody tried to ask, A, when did you guys figure out
0:08:14that you had a real problem on your hands
0:08:15with the design of the 2013 trash can Mac?
0:08:19And B, when did you guys start on this project
0:08:24of a new Mac, a rethought from the ground up Mac Pro.
0:08:28And Apple does not like to talk about timelines.
0:08:32I mean, they don't like to talk about future stuff.
0:08:34They don't like to talk about all sorts of things,
0:08:36but they do not like to talk about when in the past
0:08:39they made decisions and how long things took.
0:08:42It is more than, almost more than anything else,
0:08:46they don't like to.
0:08:47Like once a design of a new product comes out,
0:08:49they will talk, Johnny Ive will talk at length,
0:08:52openly and honestly in his little narrated videos about why something is the way it is.
0:08:59They won't tell you in advance, but once it's out, they'll say, "Here's why
0:09:01we have these gently sloped corners here," or whatever. But in terms of how long they've
0:09:07been working on blank, they just—it is—it's like the holiest of holies, the secretists
0:09:14of secrets. And they stonewall us.
0:09:16And I think they view that as part of their IP almost, because it's part of their process.
0:09:22And so, they view that those timelines and how long it takes things to get things right
0:09:27or what abortive attempts they had at a particular thing or whatever before they settled on the
0:09:33right path, they view that all as like a protected category of information that's about their
0:09:37process that's part of their secret, their special sauce.
0:09:41Right.
0:09:43And so-- but there were little dribs and drabs
0:09:46that you-- going over it, especially after the--
0:09:51writing my piece all night long and then reading everybody
0:09:56else's the next day and then having a day to sort of breathe
0:09:58and then rethink it all and look at the transcript again.
0:10:01I think that the most telling remark
0:10:07was Federighi's saying that they had painted themselves
0:10:11into a thermal corner.
0:10:13And combined with his saying that they went through the stage--
0:10:18it said in a jovial fashion, and it did get a laugh,
0:10:20that they went through the stages of grief or something like that.
0:10:25Which to me, reading between the lines
0:10:26says that they did try to update the Mac Pro at least several times
0:10:32in between 2013 and the point where they said, OK, we've
0:10:38got to give up on this.
0:10:39And it seemed like by trying to answer customers' requests
0:10:45for what they wanted from a newer Mac Pro,
0:10:48it was mostly about more powerful GPUs.
0:10:52But more powerful GPUs threw off the thermal balance
0:10:55of the Mac Pro, as we know it.
0:10:57And so who knows?
0:11:01I'm guessing at least two years was spent on, at some degree,
0:11:08trying to update and get more powerful GPUs into that configuration, and at some point
0:11:14they gave up. What was your take on that?
0:11:17Yeah, I mean, that's two different questions, right? The timeline is one question. How long
0:11:26do you think it took them? And then the other question is, did they actually make attempts
0:11:31at it? Or did they go, "Hey, there's nothing really we can do here," because they just
0:11:36new from all of the, from the building of the thing in the first place, they built it
0:11:40specifically to take advantage of this split or balanced GPU scenario and, you know, shoving
0:11:48one hot GPU and it was never going to work. I don't know, you know, I don't know how
0:11:52much modeling or prototyping or theory, you know, work they did on saying, "What if
0:11:58we jammed an NVIDIA 1080i in here, TI in here, and said, "Can we get this to run in here,
0:12:07in this shell with proper thermal properties or whatever?" I don't know how far along
0:12:11that road they went, or did they just say, "Well, this is not the purpose we built
0:12:15it for at all, so can we get two GPUs in here that will work together in such a way where
0:12:21it would provide a significant value to our customers?" And then they said, "No, all
0:12:27all we can do is give it a bump so that people on this current gen can just roll with it until we get out what's due.
0:12:34I don't know. I think it's harder for me to say that they went and built whole new units in this case than if they were working on a new product,
0:12:48which they would undoubtedly do,
0:12:51they'll build fully, full tilt, all produced devices
0:12:55if they feel that they need to,
0:12:57to figure out whether it works or not
0:12:59when they're creating a new product.
0:13:00On something like this, I guess maybe,
0:13:03I guess maybe they would, you know?
0:13:05I have no information, I'm just trying to like divine
0:13:07from what I know about the process that they go through.
0:13:10But it seems like it's a possibility.
0:13:13- One thing we don't have to speculate on,
0:13:15I mean, this is just a fact,
0:13:16obvious just by studying the device and it's also obvious just listening to the
0:13:21way Apple described it in 2013 when it when it was announced is that the
0:13:27trashcan Mac Pro from 2013 was a bet on multi-threaded GPUs as the future of GPU
0:13:36power and and they had a software story to tell about it I think you know
0:13:41without getting too complicated I think it was mostly sort of an open CL type
0:13:45thing but in the meantime in the years since Apple has sort of stepped away from open CL and
0:13:51I think the bigger story isn't even really
0:13:55Apple's own decisions on software but more just where did the industry go and in the pro market?
0:14:02It's not so dependent on
0:14:05Or defined by Apple in terms of how should you make software for the Mac Pro?
0:14:10But more, this is how industry standard powerful GPU hogging
0:14:16apps are written.
0:14:19Things like video editing in 3D, which a lot of it
0:14:23is cross-platform.
0:14:24Probably most of it is cross-platform.
0:14:28And the way that that's gone in the four years
0:14:32since we first saw this Mac Pro, it's
0:14:35gotten ever more dependent on super powerful single GPUs, which is the opposite of where
0:14:43the Mac Pro went.
0:14:44I think in theory, the Mac Pro could have been the future of pro computing, throwing
0:14:52lots of GPU cores and having software written to take advantage of that, but that's just
0:14:58not where the industry went.
0:15:00the software that is ever more dependent on just single-threaded GPU performance, the
0:15:06Mac Pro is just, it just wasn't apt at all.
0:15:13You know what I keep going back to is this. So I, you know, I grew up building computers,
0:15:18so I guess a lot of folks who are probably listening to this did, you know, or grew up
0:15:22at least very interested in how they were put together. And I think my, you know, my
0:15:28first computer was like an Amiga that I pieced together out of, you know, rando parts from
0:15:35a friend's stores of garbage because his dad worked for Pacific Bell. And then so on
0:15:40and so forth spiraled outwards from there to PCs and, you know, x86 machines and, you
0:15:46know, on through the Windows train or DOS train and then Windows train and all that,
0:15:51simply because I, it was the thing that I could afford and I could put together myself.
0:15:56along the line there, I developed this parallel track starting with the Performa line and
0:16:03going up through there where I always had a Mac in the house as well. And then my mom
0:16:08would use it, I would use it for graphic design and eventually Photoshop stuff once they became
0:16:13more powerful and a variety of other things. But I always had this parallel track of computing.
0:16:20But I spent the majority of my time on PCs simply because they were great for gaming
0:16:25I was just a massive gamer, and still am to a degree, but the platform itself was obviously
0:16:32very much pushed forward by gamers. There were other industries that were responsible
0:16:39for pushing certain components of the computer, of the CPU or the GPU or whatever, forward
0:16:46depending on their needs, their specific needs. Obviously, data storage is very much like
0:16:51an enterprise thing and so on and so forth. But the GPU and CPU were pushed very hard
0:16:58for a lot of years by gaming, and still are. Obviously, GPUs are where they are because
0:17:04of gamers. They're not there because of--sure, academics at some stage do need those, but
0:17:11only because it was there. It was sort of like a chicken-egg thing. And the academics
0:17:16use heavily GPU-centric computing platforms and things now because they can, but the GPUs
0:17:25are there because the gamers wanted them and the game companies pushed them hard. I remember
0:17:30playing games that they said, "Hey, this game looks this good this year, but it'll
0:17:34look even better next year." We've already programmed in the higher resolution textures
0:17:42and so on and so forth that we in better physics engines that we know will only
0:17:46your computer will only support next year i was it was a constant thing i was never much
0:17:51of a forward i was never much of a gamer but i when i was you know 20 years ago i was much
0:17:55closer to a gamer than i am now and i i remember even on the mac that was true that uh you know
0:18:02marathon was the big game that's right the right yeah bungee the per you know bungees wasn't their
0:18:07first game but it was the first real smash hit and sort of a predecessor to
0:18:12what's the game on Xbox? Halo. Halo. Marathon was huge and and it was
0:18:18networked so we could play it against each other. Yeah, love that game. You had
0:18:22to be on a local talk network though you couldn't... This is... No. You could play over the
0:18:26internet. No, no, of course not. So yeah, we played that and then we played Doom locally and Duke of 3D, all
0:18:35all this stuff.
0:18:36- Yeah, me-- - But yeah, I mean, you get that
0:18:37and that's what drove it.
0:18:39You know, that's what the theme broke.
0:18:40- What was amazing, what was amazing though
0:18:42is that we'd get a new computer at the student newspaper.
0:18:44We'd get a new Quadra or something
0:18:47and all of a sudden, Marathon ran way better
0:18:49and it was like, whoa.
0:18:51I remember too, a lot of times too, it was frame rate, right?
0:18:54Like you could, and you know,
0:18:56and certain games had settings where you could optimize
0:18:58for frame rate or optimize for graphics,
0:18:59but you could get the good graphics,
0:19:02but you wouldn't get a great frame rate.
0:19:03And then all of a sudden you get a new computer
0:19:05and you get it all.
0:19:06And it would be night and day.
0:19:07- Sure, you could run dark forces
0:19:08and everything was all smooth all of a sudden.
0:19:10- Right, right.
0:19:11- Yeah.
0:19:12- No, it's true.
0:19:13I think you're right.
0:19:14- That's what I look at.
0:19:15That's the allegory.
0:19:17- The money comes from gamers.
0:19:18That's what's driving the industry
0:19:20to keep pumping the billions of dollars
0:19:23into research into ever more powerful GPUs.
0:19:25And then like you said, things like academics
0:19:27who are really just running math,
0:19:29just math or data analysis,
0:19:32it really aren't even pushing pixels to a screen.
0:19:34literally just chewing through mounds and mounds of quote-unquote big data, but you
0:19:40can do it where the algorithms run faster on a GPU than a CPU, and they're taking
0:19:45advantage of technology that was developed for games. And the Mac Pro just was not where
0:19:52the industry was headed.
0:19:53No, I mean, no gamer ever looked at the Mac Pro and thought, "Oh, this is interesting."
0:19:57And heck, they barely looked at the previous generation of Mac Pros that way, because they
0:20:02they knew that they would be upgrading their GPU within six to nine months to 12 months,
0:20:06right? And that they would be pushing, you know, looking for that. And they didn't have
0:20:10the confidence that AMD or Nvidia would consistently release that highest, you know, highest performance
0:20:17graphics card for the Mac Pro in that original configuration, much less the new one, obviously,
0:20:24where Apple's the one who controls that.
0:20:26Yeah. So what occurs to me in looking at this scenario, and I mean, it's not just in the
0:20:31last week, but I think having learned now what we now know, I think it's almost certain
0:20:37is that there's at least a little bit of hubris here in the design of the 2013 Mac Pro that
0:20:43I think is fueled by the iPhone and iPad, where with the iPhone, Apple, the iPhone market
0:20:51in and of itself is so big and so lucrative and that Apple can define the computer architecture
0:21:00of the iPhone and can define the APIs for creating software
0:21:06for it and runs the App Store and can not really
0:21:14adhere to define which APIs you use,
0:21:16but sort of make sure that your software is
0:21:21within the lines of how they want software written.
0:21:24But primarily, just by being able to define the hardware,
0:21:28They can define-- if you want your software to run well,
0:21:32you're going to have to do it the way we envision
0:21:34you doing it.
0:21:35It's not even so much the App Store.
0:21:37Forget the App Store part.
0:21:38It's just you've got to take advantage of the way
0:21:41the iPhone is architected.
0:21:43And the iPhone is so big that developers will do it.
0:21:48I mean, literally, they even-- and this
0:21:50is less of a big deal today or more easily overlooked
0:21:53because it's always been the case.
0:21:55But in the early years of the iPhone,
0:21:56a big deal, where an awful lot of developers who were like,
0:21:59well, we want our software on the iPhone,
0:22:01were buying their first Macs ever because you
0:22:04had to run Xcode to write-- you still
0:22:06have to run Xcode to write iPhone software,
0:22:09and Xcode only runs on a Mac.
0:22:10And so it was literally developers
0:22:12were buying an all new machine just to do it.
0:22:15Whereas in the pro high performance computing industry,
0:22:22Apple doesn't have that sort of dominant role.
0:22:24they can't redefine or not you it maybe not redefine is too strong a word but
0:22:29they can't steer
0:22:30they couldn't and push the industry to switch to a multi-threaded GPU
0:22:35model when everybody else you know more or less what Apple needed to do was be
0:22:40humble about it and go with the flow the industry which
0:22:43is big honking single GPUs
0:22:46mhm yeah I mean there's to the so
0:22:49twice he was twice and don't don't at me or whatever but
0:22:53I think twice during the interview, they said something about, you know, we want to make
0:22:57sure that whatever we do is new and innovative.
0:23:00And I looked at, I thought about that, and I was thinking about that during, you know,
0:23:04when they said it, because they said it again, and when they said it again, I kind of, my
0:23:08ears kind of perked up, you know.
0:23:10Because I think that that is, there's two ways to take that statement.
0:23:14You could take that statement and say, hey, I'm doing something new and innovative, and
0:23:18you can, you could just take it at face value and go, you know what, great.
0:23:21I'm glad someone is, right?
0:23:23I'm glad somebody cares enough to really push
0:23:27and make sure that they're not obeying accepted norms
0:23:32without questioning them,
0:23:34that they are truly pushing boundaries
0:23:37and questioning all of the underpinnings of computing
0:23:40and making sure that the way things are done
0:23:43is actually the right way and the way they should be done.
0:23:46All of that, right?
0:23:47And you can extrapolate.
0:23:48You can keep going from there.
0:23:50All of the things that you would like to say to interpret that in the best light possible.
0:23:55And then there's another way to take it, which is we are so interested in doing something new and innovative that we overlook the obvious hurdles because we are so addicted to the slash and burn of, you know, obeying our own recognizance, right?
0:24:15Or relying on our own recognizance to chart the course of computing.
0:24:19Because if you go, "Hey, every phone..."
0:24:22Let's apply this to existing, you know, let's apply this to existing framework of the iPhone.
0:24:29You look at the iPhone, you go, "Hey, if you just said, 'Look guys, you can do every other thing, but keyboards are great.'"
0:24:35You know, keyboards are fantastic. They work fine.
0:24:38You know, thumbs press keys makes total sense, right?
0:24:41Since we were cavemen, we've been manipulating things with our opposable thumbs.
0:24:46Why stop now?
0:24:47I mean, there's plenty of really great arguments that a lot of people made to themselves and
0:24:51really convinced themselves were right, and that's why there was a lot of blowback against
0:24:55the no physical keyboard thing.
0:24:57So Apple in that moment, you know, maybe this is Steve's genius of saying, "No, this
0:25:01is the right way," or maybe this is a collective genius, which is more likely, where Steve
0:25:05acts as the editor for a lot of people's flurry of ideas, "Yeah, I think we can make
0:25:08this work," and, you know, "It's so much simpler, less moving parts," and blah,
0:25:11blah, blah.
0:25:12Tons of arguments on the other side, right?
0:25:14And they made a decision to slice out a very well-established, charted course of having
0:25:22that physical keyboard that was not necessarily evil, right?
0:25:26There's nothing bad about it.
0:25:28It's just they saw pathways that opened up for themselves if they got rid of it.
0:25:33They're like, "Man, then we can manipulate the whole screen.
0:25:35The keyboard can go away when you don't need it," you know, blah, blah, blah, right?
0:25:38You know, all of the arguments that we all know so well.
0:25:40But you look at that, and it worked out incredibly well for them.
0:25:44And in fact, not only did it work out well for them, it was the right thing to do.
0:25:48That's why all our phones look the same now, right?
0:25:52But in this case, I think they looked at the problem and said, "Hey, this is the way
0:25:57it could go.
0:25:58This parallel GPU that splits tasks, it can run lower power when it needs to.
0:26:05It's very power conscious, which is great for the environment, et cetera, et cetera.
0:26:10And there's really no reason that needs to be blowing all this air all over the place
0:26:13all the time and collecting all this unseemly dust and why has nobody ever thought of this?
0:26:19And they got so excited about the fact that they could do this thing that they didn't
0:26:23stop and ask themselves, "Well, is the simpler, straighter, more common path, is it a common
0:26:32path for a reason? Like, do we use metal because metal is good, you know? Or do we use a strong,
0:26:38powerful GPU because the industry that we have traditionally not served, gaming industry,
0:26:45uses it and that pushes everything forward and we can ride that wave. Why paddle out
0:26:51of the current and generate all of the force on your own when you can use additive force
0:26:58on the existing current and go, "You know what? This is fine. This is our limitation
0:27:05that we have to accommodate this graphics card,
0:27:07now what does that look like?
0:27:08Maybe it's a flat slab with almost nothing else to it
0:27:12that's essentially a GPU,
0:27:14or maybe it's external GPUs or whatever.
0:27:16But I just think that the questions got asked
0:27:19and they applied roughly the same frameworks to it
0:27:21that they did with the iPhone
0:27:23and ended up with just the wrong answer.
0:27:25And I don't know why that is.
0:27:26I don't presuppose I'm dumb compared to all these guys
0:27:28they have and girls they have working on these problems.
0:27:31So I don't presuppose to know,
0:27:33That's just my supposition as to how the argument went down.
0:27:36You know, um, and a one factor, I guess I knew this,
0:27:41but it got reiterated a few times is that the,
0:27:45the Mac pro had a sort of triangular shape in the tube, in the middle,
0:27:50the hollow center, two GPS and a GP, a CPU.
0:27:53And it's not just that it was three things in that air flow through the center
0:27:58to cool them,
0:27:59but that it was specifically designed
0:28:01that all three sides of that triangle
0:28:03would remain roughly on par with each other in terms
0:28:08of the heat that needed to be dissipated.
0:28:10And it wasn't a design that would accommodate
0:28:12one of the three sides getting hotter than the others.
0:28:16And that's, again, with software that more so now
0:28:20than before this Mac Pro was distributed,
0:28:23that graphics-intensive software today
0:28:28is about overloading a single GPU with as much performance
0:28:33as you can get.
0:28:35And it just, you know, so even using this configuration
0:28:38to run software that's meant to run single threaded
0:28:40on a GPU, it's just not conducive to that,
0:28:44because you can't let one of the GPUs
0:28:45get hotter than another.
0:28:47And it probably plays into the fact that the Mac Pro,
0:28:52as we know it, is sort of notorious for almost like,
0:28:57like a European sports car, that they're not
0:29:01the most rugged machines or durable machines in terms
0:29:04of reliability over the years, that people who've
0:29:08been pushing these machines, there's a lot of people who,
0:29:11they seemingly, anecdotally at least,
0:29:13have to go in to get GPUs replaced pretty frequently,
0:29:15primarily from overheating.
0:29:18I mean, that's the only way really a computer part
0:29:20wears out or it's part like a GPU could wear out.
0:29:22All right, let me take a break,
0:29:25and we'll come back to this.
0:29:27But let me first thank our first sponsor of this show, Circle from Disney.
0:29:34What is Circle?
0:29:35Circle from Disney is a beautiful little device designed for families to manage content and
0:29:41time online for all the devices in your home.
0:29:44It pairs with just about any Wi-Fi router and it recognizes every device connected to
0:29:49it, tablets, PCs, smartphones, even Chromebooks, anything that connects to the Wi-Fi in your
0:29:54house, it'll recognize it.
0:29:56And parents can set profiles for each member of the family
0:29:59and tailor the individual preferences for each one.
0:30:01It's very easy to set up.
0:30:03It is exactly what you would think
0:30:04of from something from Disney.
0:30:06It is not like setting up something from Cisco
0:30:11where you need a network engineering degree.
0:30:13It is very much what you would think
0:30:14Disney would design for non-network engineering moms
0:30:18and dads.
0:30:20You just download the app, choose your network.
0:30:22It's that simple.
0:30:22from there and just tap things on the app.
0:30:26What kind of things does it let you do?
0:30:28It lets you filter content, customize what's available,
0:30:30and you can set time limits.
0:30:32And you can set the time limits on specific things
0:30:34like YouTube, Minecraft, Facebook, Netflix, and even
0:30:38Snapchat.
0:30:40Kids staying up late on their tablet,
0:30:42you can set a bedtime for each kid and their devices.
0:30:47Families can also see how they spend their time online
0:30:49with their Insights feature.
0:30:51really great. Disney super stoked about this. They've just
0:30:54a couple of new things. They just launched a new thing about a month ago.
0:30:59It's called Circle Connections. It lets you connect app services and devices
0:31:03like friend of the show, Automatic, you know, the car dingus. Well, now you can
0:31:07hook that up and the family can share stuff like that through the
0:31:11Circle. Alexa, IFTTT, Chore Monster
0:31:17and others. You can all hook up to your Circle. It's sort of turning into a
0:31:20platform. Disney is very excited about this. Recently, Apple's CFO Luca Maestri
0:31:28was held a meeting with the Italian press at the Italian Consulate in New
0:31:35York City and he was talking about how his family uses Apple products and
0:31:38devices and he specifically mentioned Circle with Disney, something that his
0:31:42family uses to manage his family's devices. I will put a link to this in the
0:31:47show notes. I think you're going to need to translate it from Italian, but that's
0:31:51okay. I'm sure most people who listen to the show speak fluent Italian, but that's
0:31:55a pretty cool story and a pretty... you don't really hear Disney or Apple
0:31:59C-level executives talking up products from other companies all that often. So
0:32:03anyway, it's very exciting stuff. Where do you go to find out more? Easy. Go to
0:32:08meetcircle.com and remember this code, the talk show, and you will get
0:32:16free shipping and $10 off your Circle with Disney device.
0:32:24It's a $99 product, 89 bucks with the talk show code, and CircleGo, which is
0:32:32their service for mobile, like a phone like cellular service, is $9.95
0:32:38a month for up to 10 devices. iOS only, but that's probably not a problem for
0:32:43listeners of the talk show so my thanks to Disney meet circle comm code the talk
0:32:48show great product so timeline wise more spec is here's my take my take is that
0:32:56in the 20 I mean because one thing a couple people have observed is it's not
0:33:04like this is the first Mac Pro that went a long time between updates the Mac Pro
0:33:08had sort of been on a longer than one year update schedule for a while. So the fact that
0:33:14there wasn't an update in 2014, I don't think struck, I don't think it really surprised
0:33:18anybody. Right. My guess is sometime around 2015, 2016 is when an update, certainly by
0:33:252016, it was everybody was talking about it and certainly Apple was aware of it. I think,
0:33:30I don't know this, I don't have any sort of, you know, super sources inside, but I think,
0:33:37I don't think anybody's surprised by this.
0:33:39I think that as the--
0:33:43around 2015, 2016, as it became more obvious
0:33:47that the design of the Mac Pro was problematic,
0:33:50I think there was a sense within Apple that maybe that's OK.
0:33:54And maybe MacBook Pros combined with ever more powerful iMacs
0:34:02might be the way future to satisfy the pro
0:34:04users of the Mac market.
0:34:07And I think this came up at our interview last week.
0:34:12And I think that they sort of emphasized just what a--
0:34:17- But we need more, so to speak.
0:34:19- What, just what a large percentage of what they define
0:34:23as pro users are using MacBook Pros and iMacs.
0:34:26And they even mentioned this, and if anything,
0:34:31this might have been the most surprising part
0:34:33of the meeting is where they mentioned specifically
0:34:36that they have new iMacs in the pipeline that
0:34:38are coming slated for sometime this year that are including
0:34:42configurations that are geared towards pro customers.
0:34:47I think that what happened is that probably
0:34:50at a very high level-- I mean, I'm not naming names.
0:34:52I don't know.
0:34:52But I think at a pretty high level within the company,
0:34:55they talked themselves into believing
0:35:00that the iMac, including the ever better iMacs combined
0:35:04with the MacBook Pros could cover everything
0:35:06they needed to cover.
0:35:07And I think at some point recently,
0:35:11let's say within the last six months or so,
0:35:15maybe a little more, they realized no,
0:35:18that the 1% of Mac users who can't be satisfied
0:35:23by an iMac need a real pro computer.
0:35:27That's my guess.
0:35:31- Yeah.
0:35:33I think you're probably right. That sounds reasonable. I definitely think there was that moment which they alluded to because they said, "But we realized we needed more."
0:35:43that they did feel that a larger and larger segment of the pro market was being served by a 5K screen and a computer slept on the back.
0:35:55And I certainly, it's what I've been using for a long time, I haven't had a Mac Pro in years.
0:36:00And I only had one briefly, and honestly, a lot of the times that I ran Mac Pro level machines with OS X running on them, I ran Hackintoshes for the GPU reason.
0:36:11You know, and Hackintoshes are becoming a much more, I don't doubt that Apple sees this.
0:36:16You know, the diagnostics probably tell them, you know, general opt-in diagnostics probably tell them, if not, pulling the community.
0:36:24But there are an increasing number of people running Hackintoshes, which are, you know, PC components that have OS X driver support,
0:36:34driver support or have some sort of cribbed together,
0:36:38driver support, and that are being put together
0:36:41and then you boot OS X on them,
0:36:44either with the use of a bootloader,
0:36:46piece of software or piece of hardware
0:36:48that allows you to boot OS X, fool OS X
0:36:50into thinking that you're running a Mac.
0:36:53And the advantage that offers is, of course,
0:36:54you can build according to your precise power needs,
0:36:58perhaps even more powerful than is currently on the market,
0:37:00which is a situation we're in right now with the Mac Pro.
0:37:03And then of course you can run Windows on a Mac,
0:37:06but now you can run Windows on a more powerful Mac
0:37:09that can then run very high performance games
0:37:12or other applications.
0:37:14And so you'll see people like,
0:37:16who was it that recently wrote a fairly solid,
0:37:22kind of what it's like to build a Hackintosh right now
0:37:24just recently, it was--
0:37:25- Was it Mike Rundle?
0:37:26Is that who you're thinking of?
0:37:29- I think Mike was mentioning,
0:37:30was talking about running a Hackintosh,
0:37:31but somebody else just wrote a piece that was traded around a lot. I mean, many folks have over the years.
0:37:36They build graphics software for the Mac.
0:37:41And it's not...
0:37:46My brain's blanking. I'll try and get back to it if I can.
0:37:49But the gist of it is, it's like, best of both worlds scenario.
0:37:54Where they love OS X, and they just shutter using Windows.
0:37:59need to to make it through, you know, or to run software that only runs on Windows, aka,
0:38:06you know, Class A games that just don't ship on multiple platforms, although Steam is making
0:38:12that better to a degree. But the OS X is just, you know, the beautiful experience and all
0:38:17that, and they can build this really custom experience underneath it. And I think that
0:38:23more people being willing to consider a Hackintosh and that the community really looking to those
0:38:29builders to try and tell them exactly what parts to buy
0:38:34and exactly how to build it and all of that.
0:38:38I think that really speaks to this desire to have OS X
0:38:42but with a more customizable hardware platform
0:38:45underneath it.
0:38:45Not just more powerful with a capital P,
0:38:49but also more customizable, truly modular, right?
0:38:52The truly modular experience that people haven't had
0:38:55in many years.
0:38:56So even though they appreciate the design
0:38:58and the thoughtfulness that went into the Mac Pro as it currently exists, I think many
0:39:02people feel that those choices being made for them stands out as an even more irritating
0:39:11decision because of the segment that they're going after.
0:39:15How many iMac users—I mean, well, scratch that. There are plenty. Apple users love to
0:39:21complain because they're so attuned to detail. The company has taught them to be picky about
0:39:27their stuff. That's the base reason that the Mac community, the Apple community is
0:39:32so picky about stuff, because they've been trained to care by a company that ostensibly
0:39:38cares. But, scratching that, setting that aside, the average Mac user, the 80%, let's
0:39:45call it, of the Mac users out there who are like, "Hey, I just want a big computer for
0:39:49my desk and I love Apple stuff. What do I get that's not a portable?" Well, we buy
0:39:54by an iMac, right?
0:39:55The vast majority of those are not going crazy about like,
0:39:58oh, I can't change this particular chipset, right?
0:40:02Or whatever.
0:40:03Like, I can't get this network card
0:40:05instead of this network card or whatever.
0:40:06But the segment that they did it to
0:40:09was the one that was gonna be the most allergic to it
0:40:13in the long run.
0:40:15And like, that is another thing that was kinda weird to me.
0:40:18I wonder if there was, I mean, I'm sure there was,
0:40:21advocate inside saying, "This is great, but it actually..." Something like the Mac Pro,
0:40:27imagine if that was the iMac. Now these days, I think the iMac is the right choice. People
0:40:31just buy one thing and they're done. Nobody wants to buy separate monitors. They do it
0:40:35because they have to, right? Like the average person. So I think the iMac is the right configuration.
0:40:40I'm not trying to say that the Mac Pro is right for the normal person, but that segment
0:40:45of the market would have been much more receptive and welcoming, I think, of a thing where it's
0:40:50"Don't worry about it, we thought it all out."
0:40:53- Right. - Right?
0:40:54We've got the perfect, sweet capsule for you
0:40:57that's gonna do amazing things, performance-wise,
0:40:59totally enough for you.
0:41:01Plop this on your desk and plug it in and enjoy.
0:41:05And that segment, I think, is much more receptive
0:41:07and welcoming of that,
0:41:08whereas the pro segment is the opposite.
0:41:10The first thing they do is refresh the iFixit page
0:41:13so they see how things tear down
0:41:14and they wanna know what's in there and all of that
0:41:17and they wanna be informed consumers.
0:41:20And I think that that leads itself to the desire
0:41:23to have choice and all that stuff.
0:41:25I don't know, it's just the way I see that.
0:41:27They just sort of pitched it to the wrong people.
0:41:28- Yeah, I think that there's a continuum of everything,
0:41:32but there's a continuum of people's price sensitivity.
0:41:35But I think that at a certain end,
0:41:40if you talk about college-age students
0:41:44who want a Mac for gaming,
0:41:48and what type, or want a computer that can dual boot,
0:41:51but use a Mac, but have a powerful GPU for gaming,
0:41:55are gonna, are more willing to spend the time
0:41:59to do the Hackintosh and to put up with
0:42:01the incompatibilities and the worries
0:42:03about applying software updates and, you know,
0:42:06maybe wait until somebody else decides
0:42:08whether this graphics card is gonna work
0:42:09with the latest version of Sierra and all of that,
0:42:14versus the professional market
0:42:16where price isn't really the issue.
0:42:18It's they're begging Apple to charge them a lot of money
0:42:21for a computer.
0:42:22And part of what they're willing to spend money for
0:42:25is the it just works factor of getting a real Mac.
0:42:29And the hackintosh-- like I can see why the hackintosh
0:42:34route is more popular than growing in popularity,
0:42:36given the Mac pro stagnation.
0:42:38But I think it's a large part of that.
0:42:40I mean, and clearly, like I said, it's a continuum.
0:42:42And there's obvious exceptions.
0:42:43There might be real professional users.
0:42:45There certainly are some who are doing it.
0:42:47But I think for the most part, a real professional user who
0:42:50might be willing to spend $10,000 or $15,000
0:42:54on a workstation isn't going to do it
0:42:57with unsupported drivers and an unsupported configuration.
0:43:00They're the type of people who are like,
0:43:02if I can't get hardware from Apple that meets my needs,
0:43:06I'd rather switch to Windows and get a supported configuration.
0:43:11Whereas the hobbyist community--
0:43:12Yeah, I think that's totally right.
0:43:13The hobbyist community has always, by definition,
0:43:15been self-supporting.
0:43:16They don't need support because they are their own support.
0:43:19- Yeah, and whatever configuration they're coming up with,
0:43:22they're getting live, essentially live tech support on it
0:43:26from the community that they're in,
0:43:28of those similar people that build those things.
0:43:30Hey, has anybody ever come across this problem?
0:43:32You know, I did it a bunch of times
0:43:33when I was building Hackintoshes where it's like,
0:43:35you know, 'cause I was just too poor
0:43:37to own a really powerful Mac,
0:43:39and so I would just build out of PC parts
0:43:42and then run OS X on it.
0:43:43And you know, I'm sure Apple's cringing and whatever,
0:43:46but it's what I could afford.
0:43:47And I think a lot of people start out that way.
0:43:49Those price-sensitive people,
0:43:51but that are also sort of hacker-friendly
0:43:54or whatever you wanna call it,
0:43:55who don't mind instability and thinking around
0:43:58because they just lust after the OS X experience
0:44:01and the Apple ecosystem and all of that.
0:44:03But I think that there's like,
0:44:07it's sort of like an entry point
0:44:13for eventual Mac Pro owners, right?
0:44:16And so either, I know there are other entry points, right?
0:44:19You go to a company and you become a designer
0:44:22and all this and the company has a corporate budget
0:44:24and what are you gonna buy, right?
0:44:25You're gonna get your Mac Pro,
0:44:26you're gonna be a designer capital D
0:44:29and do all your design work and that's great.
0:44:32But I think there's a long tail of people out there
0:44:34that are, that have become pros
0:44:38through alternative pathways.
0:44:40Don't have a lot of money to spend,
0:44:42want to get into the ecosystem because they, once again,
0:44:45they love the fact that the company prioritizes design
0:44:50and prioritizes care and all of that in their software.
0:44:54And they know in the end, underneath it,
0:44:57the hardware that it runs isn't perhaps
0:44:59as carefully picked and chosen as something Apple would do,
0:45:02but they can get it to run, right?
0:45:04It's just a mishmash of junk, but it sort of runs,
0:45:07and you get it running and you feel good about it,
0:45:10and you get hooked on the ecosystem,
0:45:13which is why I always thought that once in a while,
0:45:15Apple will take a stab at trying to shut down
0:45:17Hackintosh projects and things like that.
0:45:19And I was always just like, let it ride.
0:45:21I mean, if it becomes a major component
0:45:23of your business being stolen,
0:45:27I guess you gotta take some legal,
0:45:28and there's also some legal things you have to plant
0:45:31because of trademarks and all that,
0:45:32so that you can have a future court case against Samsung
0:45:36and say, oh yeah, we tried to protect it back then,
0:45:38even with little people.
0:45:39So I get the legal precedent thing.
0:45:41But it's also just like, let it ride,
0:45:43'cause it's like the low simmering entry point
0:45:46to somebody who eventually, once they have the means,
0:45:48is like, yes, build me an amazing Mac, please, Apple,
0:45:52and I, you know, powerful Mac Pro, and I will buy it.
0:45:55You know, now I have the means, I'm addicted,
0:45:57I want the power, but I also want OS X, and so on, you know?
0:46:01So that's the way, that's the way, oh,
0:46:03I found that, the Hackintosh article, by the way,
0:46:04it was by Dan Council.
0:46:06- Pasted it, pasted it in the chat here.
0:46:08I'll send you the link. Yeah, it's Dan Council of RealMac. RealMac Software makes lots of
0:46:14great apps. This is not an ad, etc. But he wrote an article called "Building a Hackintosh
0:46:22Pro" a little earlier back in March. But his reasoning was essentially, "They haven't
0:46:31updated the Mac Pro. I need a full-size graphics card for the stuff that I want to do." And
0:46:36So it's not complicated.
0:46:38It's not like anybody's angry.
0:46:40Well, I mean, I'm sure some people are angry,
0:46:41but it's not like anybody's really thinking Apple
0:46:45is doing things that are consumer hostile on purpose.
0:46:50It's just that there's certain needs and wants they have,
0:46:53and Apple didn't glom onto those needs and wants
0:46:55or assign enough importance to them soon enough
0:46:58to catch themselves, so they didn't have this big gap now.
0:47:02- Yeah.
0:47:04I think, bottom line, I don't really see how this,
0:47:08well, I'm sure someone at Apple could deny it,
0:47:12but I think it seems pretty clear now
0:47:15that at some point in the last three years or so,
0:47:20or maybe starting around three years ago,
0:47:21that Apple sort of took its collective eye
0:47:24off the ball on the Mac, at least on the hardware.
0:47:27I think the software is going fine.
0:47:30I think they're hitting their annual release dates.
0:47:33I think that they're solid.
0:47:34I think they're doing enough cool new things
0:47:37that are very useful, like the continuity stuff
0:47:40I use every day and I just think like,
0:47:42how the hell did I ever go from,
0:47:45have these links on my iPhone and then switch
0:47:47to another computer to look at them there
0:47:49before this stuff worked?
0:47:52Some great features.
0:47:53I don't think that they should be radically,
0:47:57I think that the complaint some people have about the Mac
0:47:59is that they haven't done anything that's like,
0:48:01here's the radical new way to use a Mac.
0:48:03I don't want that.
0:48:04I mean, obviously, if they came up with something
0:48:05that I liked, I guess I'd like it,
0:48:06but I kind of feel like they've, you know,
0:48:10that's what new products are for, right?
0:48:13That's why the iPad is a different product.
0:48:16Like, here's a radical new way to do personal computing
0:48:18on a portable device.
0:48:19I still want to do the stuff
0:48:21that the Mac is great at on the Mac.
0:48:23Hardware-wise, though, I think it's hard to deny
0:48:26that they kind of took their eye off the ball.
0:48:28And I think part of this sort of let's hit the reset button
0:48:33mindset is that reaction to the MacBook Pros last fall
0:48:38I think was mixed.
0:48:40I don't think it's fair to say it was a poor reaction,
0:48:43but I do think it was a mixed reaction,
0:48:45and I think that took Apple by surprise.
0:48:47I think Apple internally thought they had a smash hit
0:48:50on their hands and was sort of taken aback
0:48:53by the number of people who expressed displeasure.
0:48:58at the decisions they made with the MacBook Pro.
0:49:01And during our discussion, Schiller had,
0:49:04during his opening remarks, addressed it
0:49:07in his usual way where it wasn't quite head on,
0:49:09but it was clear what he mentioned him
0:49:11and said that they're hard at work
0:49:13on a next group of MacBook Pros that would address,
0:49:17specifically address some of the complaints
0:49:19professional users had about the current ones.
0:49:22Although he didn't say any of things of what those are.
0:49:26but I would presume, or maybe he mentioned RAM.
0:49:28Did he mention RAM?
0:49:30I mean, one of the complaints people have
0:49:31about the current MacBook Pros is that there's still,
0:49:34the maximum amount of RAM you can put in them
0:49:35is 16 gigabytes.
0:49:37And the reason it's not 32 gigabytes
0:49:39is because Apple is using,
0:49:42I don't have to write me to tell me,
0:49:44but they're using DDR whatever low energy RAM.
0:49:49And on the current Intel chip sets,
0:49:51if you're using the kind of low energy
0:49:54battery-saving RAM that Apple wants to use
0:49:57to keep battery life good, the maximum you can get is 16.
0:50:00So they could, in theory, have MacBook Pros
0:50:03that have 32 gigabytes, but it would involve
0:50:05a complete re-architecture of which Intel chipset
0:50:08they're using, and to ship them last year,
0:50:11they would have not been able to use the low-energy RAM.
0:50:14And we went through this when the MacBook Pros came out,
0:50:18and the answer from the people who are RAM-starved
0:50:21in their professional work who really need more than 16
0:50:25or at least want if not needs more than 16 gigabytes of RAM
0:50:29is I don't care about the low energy,
0:50:31I'll plug the goddamn thing in,
0:50:33I just want 32 gigabytes of RAM,
0:50:35which is a completely reasonable trade off.
0:50:39It is completely reasonable for a Mac user
0:50:44who gets the Mac and loves the Mac.
0:50:46It's not like, oh, if you were a real Mac user,
0:50:48you'd see the genius of Apple's decision in this regard.
0:50:51I could totally see how there are totally long time
0:50:55die hard Mac users who get and love the Mac
0:50:58who are willing to say, I would rather get
0:51:00eight hours of battery life instead of 10
0:51:03if I could get 32 gigabytes of RAM in this machine
0:51:06instead of 16.
0:51:08Totally reasonable.
0:51:09I think the number of people who took that stance though
0:51:12took Apple by surprise.
0:51:13I mean, and it's not that RAM is the only issue,
0:51:16the complaint that people have about the MacBook Pros.
0:51:20But it...
0:51:22Yeah, well, then...
0:51:26So there's two things that I think that are important to touch on. I think the touch thing we should talk about, because I think that's very interesting.
0:51:32You mentioned iPad, but the other branch of that discussion is, you mentioned how many people...
0:51:37It took them by surprise, you know, how many people did that. So it sort of begs the question, like, why did it take them by surprise?
0:51:44You know? Like, why did it sneak up on them, so to speak?
0:51:49speak well like I said best phrase I can come up with is that they took their eye
0:51:53off the ball a bit and yeah and sort of got a little too insular I mean I think
0:51:58it's often the biggest risk to Apple is that they're so insular as a culture
0:52:05that they they can lose sight even if they think they're keeping track of the
0:52:09community and and they certainly I think they certainly try to but I think that
0:52:13they could talk themselves into just taking their eye off the ball
0:52:18specifically taking their eye off the ball of the needs of larger chunks of their users.
0:52:24That's what I think they took their eye off the ball on.
0:52:27And I think that there are so many things to really love about the new MacBook Pro
0:52:30that I think that they somehow got caught up loving the things there are to love about them
0:52:37and lost sight of the ways that it was falling short of some of their professionals' needs.
0:52:44What were you going to say about touch in that regard?
0:52:47So the thing that they mentioned essentially was if you want touch, buy an iPad and use it together.
0:52:54And we're going to work on ways to make those work better, or think about ways to make those work better together, or whatever.
0:52:59Which says to me that they want, they not want, this is not the primary purpose of it, but that an iPad Pro,
0:53:07you know, they want it to act like a Cintiq tablet of sorts that connects to a Mac Pro or iMac or whatever in a more seamless fashion.
0:53:16Which makes a hell of a ton of sense. Because the pen tracking and things like that, Apple feels is superior to things like the Surface Studio and the Cintiq.
0:53:31It's quite obvious. The Cintiq tablets, which are made by Wacom, are sort of like the de facto industry standard.
0:53:37and a designer that earns enough money to spend
0:53:411500, 2000 dollars on it,
0:53:43is basically they're buying a PC with a touch screen
0:53:46glued to the front of it, and they lay it flat.
0:53:49If you're not a designer, they lay it flat,
0:53:52then use a stylus directly on it,
0:53:54therefore directly drawing a line on the screen.
0:53:56It was like an iPad Pro before an iPad Pro, I guess.
0:53:59I don't know.
0:54:00Just to analogize it through a backwards lens.
0:54:03But the Cintiqs for many years ruled the roost
0:54:06with designers.
0:54:07And now I have this, I'm sure you do too,
0:54:10but just because I do happen to do a lot in Apple stuff,
0:54:14when I'm looking at pictures,
0:54:18even in completely unrelated articles or media,
0:54:23looking at desks, I always look at desks, right?
0:54:26And workspaces, I'm fascinated with workspaces,
0:54:29from machinists to designers to anything else.
0:54:33I think there's a lot of fascination with,
0:54:35a lot of fascinating things to learn about a person by the way that they handle their
0:54:39workspace, how messy it is or how clean it is, neither of which are bad necessarily.
0:54:42It's just the person, right? It's how they move through life.
0:54:46You made a keen observation last week, because our meeting was held in what they call the
0:54:53machine shop, but it's their design realization lab where they take designs that I guess are
0:55:00or CAD or just prototypes.
0:55:03And it's a machine shop where they take ideas for designs
0:55:09and try to turn them into as realistic an approximation of what
0:55:14it would actually be like as a real Apple project as possible.
0:55:17And I got the feeling that a lot of that stuff
0:55:22was just so that they could wing it around and hold it and open
0:55:25and close, open and close, open and close it, and see how a human--
0:55:28like, oh, this feels really awkward now that I hold it.
0:55:31- Make it as real as possible.
0:55:33But you made the keen observation that,
0:55:35looking around, and they had some stuff covered
0:55:38with black drapes, and they obviously had shut down
0:55:40for the day, they said ordinarily this is a very noisy
0:55:42facility for obvious reasons.
0:55:44- Right.
0:55:45- But you made the keen observation, I thought,
0:55:47that you could kind of see that there were,
0:55:50that some of the benches and stuff, and the machines,
0:55:53were from different people who worked there
0:55:56because they were set up in very different ways.
0:55:58that there's somebody who works at this spot
0:56:00and that the person who works right across this aisle
0:56:04from them is a different person
0:56:06because their tools were laid out in a different way.
0:56:08And I thought that was pretty interesting.
0:56:11- Yeah, I mean, I'm hypersensitive to that.
0:56:13I came from, my grandfather was a machinist
0:56:15and my dad is a craftsman.
0:56:18He's a painter, fine art painter now,
0:56:20but he for many years was, and still does,
0:56:23works on cars and all kinds of other stuff.
0:56:25Got the same inclination, obviously, from his dad.
0:56:27I mean, I'm a dummy when it comes to that stuff.
0:56:29I just, I can get my way around,
0:56:31but their workspace is always fascinated with me with,
0:56:35like my grandfather had a, you know,
0:56:38I don't know what you call it, a cabinet or whatever,
0:56:42which was, he built himself, 'cause he's a machinist,
0:56:45so he worked in wood as well,
0:56:47and wood was like butter to him
0:56:48after working on aircraft parts all day.
0:56:51And so we built like this cabinet with these wooden drawers,
0:56:54and there was maybe, I don't know, 50 or 60 wooden drawers,
0:56:58and each one had a different kind of thing in it.
0:57:01Like, you know, you go like, oh, I need a washer,
0:57:04like a split lock washer, and he's like, oh, right here.
0:57:07Right, and you look in, and there's a bunch
0:57:09of split lock washers, and they're not new.
0:57:12They're reclaimed, right?
0:57:13They're like, they got a little bit of oil
0:57:15and grit on them, but they're fine, right?
0:57:16They're fine, and you know, he puts them back there,
0:57:18and that way you know, like, hey, I gotta fix this thing
0:57:21under the sink or whatever.
0:57:22He came from that generation where it's like,
0:57:23I'm gonna fix this thing.
0:57:24I'm gonna go out, pull out a drawer,
0:57:26grab this thing and put it in.
0:57:27I'm not gonna go to the store and buy a whole new faucet.
0:57:29You know, or whatever.
0:57:30- And he's also not going to jury rig it
0:57:32with an ill-fitting part and just sort of--
0:57:35- No, no, no, no. - Strap it together
0:57:37with a rag to stop the dripping.
0:57:38He's gonna have the exact washer that you need
0:57:42to make a complete, you know, make the right fit right there.
0:57:46- Right, exactly, and the same thing with the tools.
0:57:48You know, all of the, like a punch or a pair of pliers
0:57:52or a clamp or anything like that.
0:57:54all laid out, all kind of had its own place. Used, worn, grimy, whatever, but there, right?
0:58:01And organized in some way too, according to his brain. And I just saw that reflected on the
0:58:06workspaces. And I'm not like, you know, this is the same in machine shops around the world. So,
0:58:10I'm not trying to say that Apple is some sort of, you know, crazy special place. I just found it
0:58:15really nice to see because it says, "Hey, these are craftsmen." A lot of people think about this,
0:58:21like Johnny designs it and some thing prints it out overseas and that's it. But I think it is very
0:58:29important for us to remember that, as Steve said, the world is made up of people who are no smarter
0:58:37than you, then they made all these things. All it is is they applied themselves, they put the
0:58:42effort into learning how to do this. And so you see those wooden work boxes there with their
0:58:49measuring tools and punches and filing tools and those things all laid out in different bits
0:58:55for their CNC machines, for the cutting machines, and all of that stuff laid out.
0:58:59And you could tell, like, a man or woman works here, you know? And they live in this space.
0:59:06- Their personality is on the bench, yeah.
0:59:06- Yeah, exactly. And so while the machines themselves may have the overall personality
0:59:11of somebody, you know, a lot of man-hours and woman-hours, whatever you want to call it,
0:59:16I hate that term man-hours, but they went into it and then it definitely
0:59:20Was reflected in the workspaces, you know, which I found compelling
0:59:24But any I digress but like from the workspaces thing I'm seeing more and more more and more designers workspaces
0:59:31They'll have whatever computer a Mac or a PC or whatever
0:59:35Invariably though iPad Pro and a pencil. Hmm like everywhere
0:59:40like I was reading an article about Nike the other day designing some shoe because I'm a shoe fanatic and
0:59:45on the table in the background, iPad Pro and a pencil, right?
0:59:49And I think it's sort of gaining a lot of traction in that industry
0:59:53and in that field, and Apple sees this as an opening for them to go,
0:59:57"Hey, we can serve these customers who have traditionally been very
1:00:01Apple-centric, and we can hopefully not lose them,
1:00:05but at the same time hold to our beliefs," which
1:00:09from their discussion during our talk there, they still very strongly
1:00:13believe that touch does not belong
1:00:15on that huge vertical monitor.
1:00:17- Right. - You know?
1:00:18And so this is a way that they can
1:00:20sort of serve both of those.
1:00:22And as Craig joked, you know,
1:00:23also allows them to sell more products.
1:00:25- Yeah. (laughs)
1:00:26They do, and they're very upfront about that,
1:00:29that they like it when people buy lots of Apple products.
1:00:32The person who is a recent iPad convert
1:00:36because of the iPad Pro and Pencil,
1:00:38who I found fascinating, and it was exactly
1:00:40what I suspected, is Jonathan Heffler
1:00:43of Heffler and Company, the typographers.
1:00:45And a friend of the show, icon designer, icon artist,
1:00:51and graphic designer, illustrator,
1:00:54extraordinaire, Louis Mancha, is getting
1:00:57into creating his own typefaces.
1:01:01And just like any super artistic person, it's not like--
1:01:07he's so talented.
1:01:08I mean, he can draw illustrations.
1:01:09He can make icons.
1:01:10can do logos, and he's drawing typefaces.
1:01:13And put one up, like an A through Z specimen up,
1:01:18and asked Heffler for his thoughts.
1:01:19And Heffler, rather than just tweet his response,
1:01:23took it and marked it up with just a slew of thoughts,
1:01:29and just little details, and parts of a B that maybe should
1:01:33be the mirror image of the D, like a B in a lowercase b and d.
1:01:38and other areas where you think, like as a kid,
1:01:41you grow up thinking, oh, a B and a D are just mirror images.
1:01:44Well, sometimes you want them to be, and sometimes you don't.
1:01:46And with explanations of why maybe you'd
1:01:49want to take a bigger chunk out of this,
1:01:50or you want to have this be curved or this be--
1:01:53I found it as a fan of typography
1:01:57who does not have the artistic ability
1:01:59to create typography in any way, shape, or form.
1:02:03There's no chance that I could make a good looking typeface.
1:02:06None.
1:02:07but I can appreciate a good typeface.
1:02:10And I'd like to think at least that I can appreciate
1:02:13the difference between a good typeface
1:02:14and a great typeface.
1:02:16And I found his markup to be fascinating
1:02:19from a typographic level, but then I was also interested
1:02:22in how did he make this mockup?
1:02:24And he was like, of course you would ask.
1:02:26And he said that, on Twitter, Heffler said that
1:02:29he switched, he got an iPad Pro like a year ago
1:02:33and took to it, and I forget which app he's using,
1:02:35but I think it's like PDF Pro, PDF Expert,
1:02:39I wanted the third party PDF markup apps.
1:02:42And that it was so good for him that
1:02:45he got iPad Pros for the entire company
1:02:49and they switched their entire critique process
1:02:54for typefaces from paper to PDFs
1:02:57and it was all specifically,
1:02:58it never could have happened before the iPad Pro and Pencil
1:03:01and that they're A, loving it, they're way more efficient
1:03:04and B, they're saving like 8,000 sheets of paper a day.
1:03:08- Right, right.
1:03:09- Like an unbelievable, I don't know what exactly he said,
1:03:12but it was, you can imagine how many,
1:03:15a company full of type designers who do lots of critiques
1:03:18and lots of iterations over and over and over again
1:03:20on every letter that they're saving an awful lot of paper.
1:03:24And they've got, now they've got a paper trail
1:03:25of the evolution of a typeface that is electronically
1:03:29searchable and doesn't need to be archived
1:03:31in filing cabinets or something like that.
1:03:33Anyway, I thought that was interesting.
1:03:36- Yeah, I mean, as a long time,
1:03:38I come from a family of artists
1:03:41and I never fully went down that path.
1:03:43There was a brief period where I thought
1:03:44I was gonna be a fine artist.
1:03:46And I went more into the photographic side of things,
1:03:49but I did take all of the required drawing classes,
1:03:53life drawing, et cetera.
1:03:57So I could still sketch you a reclining nude
1:03:59if you want one.
1:04:00But that process of pencil to paper, the way everybody holds a pencil, every artist holds
1:04:07one slightly differently, different angle, different inflection, and it feels organic
1:04:11and natural to them.
1:04:13And a typical stylist requires that you have a fairly precise, specific angle on it to
1:04:19make it react to the surface in a certain way.
1:04:22And the pencil doesn't.
1:04:23I mean, within certain bounds, you can't go as extreme as you can with a pencil, but
1:04:28But you can go a lot more extreme because of the way that they built it and the way,
1:04:32of course, that they built the screen to match it.
1:04:35Whereas most people are working with a fairly standard touchscreen and then mating whatever
1:04:41swizzle they can get in a stylus to it to try and make it feel more organic.
1:04:45You've seen the ones with the little disks at the tip so that you could see what's under
1:04:48the stylus and all that.
1:04:50But it's really the hold of the pencil that is the most important thing.
1:04:53And I find it amazing that you can do a four-finger hold on a pencil and shade, and then you can
1:04:59flip it and do a standard stylus-type hold, and so on and so forth.
1:05:04And I think that that organic way that those work, coupled with the very incredibly low
1:05:10latency on the screen, are just selling people on it the moment that they try it or can figure
1:05:17out a way to work it into their workflow.
1:05:20And I think that if Apple can leverage that and use that as a way to say, "You don't
1:05:24need touch because you've already got all the touch you need here," I think that
1:05:27it could work. It could work for the Mac Pro.
1:05:30Yeah. All right. I've looked it up. I've got it in the show notes, but I've got the
1:05:34whole thread on Twitter of this typeface critique. And the app that Heffler and his company are
1:05:41using specifically is Notability, Notability, or is it Notability Pro? Notability app, which
1:05:48he describes as the only app that he's ever felt feels like a real pen to him.
1:05:54So anyway, it's a great app. I do have it. I don't really have a need for it like he
1:05:57does, but boy that's great. And I agree with what you said. I really do. It did
1:06:03come up though. It came up at the meeting as to whether they're over working on
1:06:07touchscreen Macs. I feel like it's it's the question that will never go away.
1:06:13Until one day they find out a way to do it and everybody says "See?" and they're
1:06:16like, well, you know, we were just waiting or whatever.
1:06:19- I don't think they will, I really don't.
1:06:21I think that they could do it and shut people up,
1:06:24but I feel like it's a bad idea.
1:06:26Let's hold that thought and I'll explain why I think it.
1:06:29It really is a bad idea.
1:06:31And I don't think, I think some people suspect that it's,
1:06:33oh, they know touch is the future
1:06:36and they just want people to,
1:06:38it's all hinges on this theory that they quote unquote
1:06:41want everybody to use a MacBook Pro or an iPad Pro,
1:06:44use an iPad Pro.
1:06:45And so they're starving the Mac of touch screens
1:06:50out of spite to encourage people to buy iPad Pros,
1:06:53which I think is nonsense,
1:06:55but I think that's the working theory of the,
1:07:00otherwise it makes no sense why the Mac has no touch screen.
1:07:02Whereas I think that there are,
1:07:04I think what Apple is saying about the Mac and touch screen
1:07:06is the literal truth, that it's a bad combination
1:07:10of form factor and UI design.
1:07:15Anyway, let me take a break though
1:07:16and thank our next sponsor.
1:07:19It is HULO, H-U-L-L-O, HULO Pillow.
1:07:24Have you ever tried a buckwheat pillow?
1:07:26They are totally different than the fluffy soft pillows
1:07:29most of us are used to.
1:07:30It's similar to a bean bag,
1:07:32which allows you to adjust its shape and thickness.
1:07:35I've been using a HULO pillow.
1:07:37We actually have two of them, one on each side of the bed.
1:07:41I like mine and I like it a lot.
1:07:44My wife actually comes back,
1:07:46when we come back from vacation,
1:07:48she actually complains that she actually misses,
1:07:51that's how much she misses her hollow pillow.
1:07:53We go away for a week and she's like,
1:07:55"Oh my God, she's totally,
1:07:58no longer likes sleeping even on a really nice bed
1:08:03without a hollow pillow."
1:08:05We've had it, it's gotta be at least a year, maybe longer.
1:08:09And I can't imagine what it was like without it.
1:08:13We really like 'em.
1:08:14Here's what it's like. It's like a bean bag. It's very heavy for a pillow. Heavy for a pillow, at least.
1:08:19It supports your head and neck how you want it.
1:08:22And unlike traditional squishy soft pillows, which collapse under the weight of your head,
1:08:27pillow pillows hold their form.
1:08:29It also stays cool and dry compared to pillows fed with feathers or foam.
1:08:36Because there's air between these little buckwheat husks that are sort of,
1:08:42or the quote unquote beans in the bean bag.
1:08:45No matter what happens, there remains air in there
1:08:47and it keeps stuff flowing, and so it doesn't get hot.
1:08:50It's really great.
1:08:52Ours have been, like I said,
1:08:54we've had them for at least a year.
1:08:55They last great.
1:08:56It doesn't seem like it's any different
1:08:57than it was when it was brand new.
1:08:59It's really great.
1:09:01Do you use two pillows or fold your pillow
1:09:04in an attempt for proper support?
1:09:05Well, that's a sign that your pillow
1:09:06isn't firm or thick enough.
1:09:08Hello Pillow support allows you
1:09:09to keep your head up with just one pillow.
1:09:11It's very true. It's very different than a regular pillow. You're going to open a box,
1:09:16you're going to say, "It really is like a beanbag," and you're going to think,
1:09:19"There is no way that this thing is actually going to be a good pillow because it is so unlike a
1:09:24traditional fluffy pillow." Here's the deal though. They're so confident on it. They're
1:09:29going to give you a 60-night guarantee. So go ahead and try it. That's it. Hello,
1:09:34H-U-L-L-O, pillow.com/talkshow.
1:09:38Just hello pillow.com/talkshow.
1:09:42And you'll get 60 nights.
1:09:43And you could just send it back if you don't like it.
1:09:45But you probably won't, because you're probably
1:09:47going to like it.
1:09:47Here's what you get with that deal.
1:09:51You get a discount of up to $20 per pillow,
1:09:54depending on the size.
1:09:55You'll find out when you go pick out your size.
1:09:57And you get fast, free shipping on every order.
1:10:01And they even contribute 1% of all their profits
1:10:04to The Nature Conservancy.
1:10:07So there you go, next time you need a pillow,
1:10:08check out hellopillow.com/talkshow.
1:10:12My thanks to them for sponsoring the show.
1:10:14Great product.
1:10:15What were we talking about?
1:10:18I always forget.
1:10:19(laughing)
1:10:22Oh, touchscreen max.
1:10:23- Yeah, touchscreen max.
1:10:24- I get into it, I get into it.
1:10:25That's the secret.
1:10:26I get hypnotized by my own sponsor.
1:10:27- Buckwheat Pillows, yeah.
1:10:29So think about the one that-- and I'm not
1:10:36saying it's a bad design, but I feel like the trade-offs are
1:10:38too much.
1:10:39So people are talking about the Windows Surface-style tablets,
1:10:46where you can dock it to a keyboard part,
1:10:51and then you can undock it somehow.
1:10:54And then the screen is a standalone tablet
1:10:57with a separate processor and its own little battery.
1:11:03It is, to me, it's a worse tablet than an iPad,
1:11:06because it doesn't have a full strength processor.
1:11:12The full strength processor is in the base.
1:11:15But so it's worse as a tablet, but it's also worse as a laptop,
1:11:22because then the screen of the laptop when it's in laptop mode
1:11:25is thicker, especially compared to the new MacBooks
1:11:28and MacBook Pros.
1:11:30One of the best little things--
1:11:33and I can write about it, but I don't
1:11:35feel like it's ever convincing to someone until they actually
1:11:37try it for a while--
1:11:39is how much nicer the screen opens on the latest MacBook
1:11:43Pros.
1:11:44I'm still using, as my daily driver,
1:11:46I still have a 2 and 1/2 year old 13 inch MacBook
1:11:50Pro from the previous design.
1:11:52And it still suits my needs, because on a day-to-day basis,
1:11:56the iMac is my main computer.
1:11:58And what I tend to do with my Macs is when I do buy a new one,
1:12:02I just max it out.
1:12:03I get the fastest, and I get the most RAM,
1:12:05and I get the biggest SSD, and then use it for years
1:12:09until I feel like I really need a new computer,
1:12:11and then max one out again, rather than upgrade
1:12:14like every year or so to a mid-range computer
1:12:16or something like that.
1:12:19I think of everything else on the new--
1:12:22after getting those review units of the new MacBook Pros.
1:12:24The thing that I miss the most isn't the touch bar and it isn't touch ID,
1:12:29although touch ID is close. It's the,
1:12:33the way that it opens and closes. That's, it's so light.
1:12:37The screen is so light and thin and the hinge is so much better that it's just
1:12:42effortless. It always goes, it just lifts.
1:12:45The base never comes up when you lift it. The base never shifts.
1:12:48- The floppy base thing, the floppy base syndrome was like,
1:12:51it was always a huge issue for me on, well, Airs,
1:12:54you know, and the little MacBooks.
1:12:56- I just got used to it.
1:12:57I used an 11-inch MacBook Air for years
1:12:59and liked it in so many ways.
1:13:01And I just had it out recently to do a battery test on it.
1:13:06And I still love the form factor when it's closed,
1:13:10but opening and closing it is sort of a two-hand operation
1:13:13or a pinched finger operation because it's just,
1:13:16like you said, a floppy base.
1:13:18The new MacBook Pros have the best feel of a laptop opening
1:13:22and closing of any device I've ever seen in my life.
1:13:25But part of that though is that the screen part,
1:13:30the part that you move up and down,
1:13:32if you could magically detach that,
1:13:35it's way too thin to be a tablet.
1:13:36It wouldn't have any room for a battery.
1:13:38It's way too thin and light.
1:13:39There's no way that that could be a tablet.
1:13:41And if you wanted to turn it into a tablet,
1:13:43you'd end up with a device with a totally different balance
1:13:46weight and etc.
1:13:48Almost inverted really because the keyboard would be on the bottom and that's it.
1:13:52Well and that has struck me with the iPad Pro with a smart keyboard.
1:13:57Like I get it if you, to me that configuration of using an iPad with a smart keyboard or even
1:14:04a third party like a Logitech keyboard with a click click keys is so top heavy.
1:14:10I can see it if your goal is, I love my iPad so much that I want to use it for more stuff,
1:14:17and I want to use it for writing, and so for writing I want to have a real hardware keyboard.
1:14:22Therefore, being able to do it and do it with a smart connector for the ease of hooking it up
1:14:29and unhooking it up, that's great. But it's so inferior just as a laptop compared to a real
1:14:36real MacBook Pro.
1:14:37Like putting the software aside and your preference
1:14:39for iOS over Mac OS or vice versa,
1:14:42just the art, the action of opening and closing it
1:14:45and putting it away, you can't beat the MacBook Pro
1:14:48with a tablet that docks to a keyboard, right?
1:14:52It's like you could have your MacBook Pro open,
1:14:56close it, realize you forgot to do one last thing,
1:15:00reopen it, and especially if you're using the Apple Watch
1:15:04unlock it or use touch ID be logged back in before somebody else could close up
1:15:11an iPad Pro and get the smart keyboard folded up. It's, you know, again I'm not
1:15:16saying that that means iPad Pro with a smart keyboard or a logitech keyboard is
1:15:20a bad design but it certainly is a huge trade-off in terms of just just the art
1:15:26of opening and closing the laptop. And so I just don't see it. I'm curious to see, so
1:15:33like me, I've had a couple of the Surfaces. I've had the Surface Pro 3 and the Surface
1:15:37Pro 4, and I found them to be, you know, interesting devices that just really got schizophrenic
1:15:44in the software. So like the hardware wasn't, you know, the Surface Pro 3 was okay, the
1:15:484 was better hardware-wise, not too bad. The software was just super schizophrenic because
1:15:54it was trying to be two things at once. You know, it was trying to be touch and mouse
1:15:57and all of that, and it mashed into one, which is Apple's constant refrain that they don't
1:16:02want to run into that problem. And I agree, having used Windows 10 on a Surface Pro 4,
1:16:09it still felt really schizophrenic to me. And I don't think that it's unusable, right?
1:16:15So I think there are plenty of people out there that can get used to it. I am very curious,
1:16:19though, people are saying, "Hey, Surface are selling more devices." Obviously, their
1:16:23quarterly reports show that they have something there, right? There's something there that
1:16:28that people like and maybe that is the pitch
1:16:30of having the all-in-one so they don't have to buy
1:16:32a tablet and a computer, you know,
1:16:34that marketing is working and then people get the devices
1:16:37and they like 'em enough to keep them
1:16:39and so that's working.
1:16:40But I'm very curious to see what will happen
1:16:42one generation out when people go,
1:16:45man, how exhausting was using that?
1:16:47You know, how exhausting was this constant,
1:16:50being caught in between two worlds?
1:16:52And so I think Microsoft has an opportunity right now,
1:16:54this sort of gap of time where they've got a little traction
1:16:57and it's going well, and so the positive word of mouth
1:17:00is causing more and more people to try that paradigm out,
1:17:03where they have a chance to figure it out,
1:17:04and maybe they can, right?
1:17:05Maybe they can suss something out, and they figure it out,
1:17:07and it's like, oh wow, this really hits the mark.
1:17:10And the Surface Book obviously is a nod to that.
1:17:13Trying to, they're trying to swizzle,
1:17:15trying to find their niche to put that claw in.
1:17:18And that's great, but I think that Apple looks at that
1:17:21and goes, why would we do that
1:17:23when we have these two more pure devices
1:17:26that we feel service just different needs completely,
1:17:30and that's our philosophy.
1:17:31Like, hit these nails straight,
1:17:33rather than trying to hit the nailing at an angle
1:17:35to try and catch both boards or whatever.
1:17:37- Yeah, and I think it fits with Apple's philosophy
1:17:40of we're not going to create enough devices
1:17:43to cover every possible desire.
1:17:45We're going to have a fewer number of devices
1:17:49and hopefully have them meet almost everybody's needs.
1:17:54And it almost comes back to the fact
1:17:56that I suspect that there might have been an inkling
1:17:59two years ago to a year ago where maybe they thought
1:18:03they could even get rid of the Mac Pro
1:18:05and just have iMacs and MacBook Pros.
1:18:08That they were, if anything, I think that they were leaning
1:18:10towards having fewer configurations of Macs
1:18:13than adding more by adding something like a Surface Studio.
1:18:18And that gets us, I've said this before many times,
1:18:22but it's, there's all sorts of things on screen on a Mac
1:18:26that are just are not conducive to touch
1:18:29just in terms of how big they are.
1:18:31And I've done it, and I know people feel,
1:18:35I get a lot of email about this,
1:18:37but I've done it myself.
1:18:40I am an anti-screen-toucher.
1:18:42I like to, I generally, I will sometimes buy a new MacBook
1:18:46and it might go hopefully many, many months
1:18:51before any human being ever touches the display.
1:18:55(laughing)
1:18:56- Right, yeah, I'm a hover-hander myself.
1:18:58I don't like to stab my screen.
1:19:00- It makes me very nervous, like people might get nervous.
1:19:03There was a scene in The Walking Dead this week
1:19:06where, you know, without revealing anything, any spoilers,
1:19:09but there was a character threatening another character
1:19:11by holding a knife very, very close
1:19:13to this character's eyeball for a very long time.
1:19:17And if it's, I can only, they had to have done it
1:19:20with computer graphics, 'cause there's no way they could,
1:19:23It looked too convincing that this but it was very nerve-wracking to see a character with a knife
1:19:27Held right in front of his open eyeball during a threatening situation for a long period of time
1:19:32That's how I feel when I see somebody reach towards a non touch display with the right to try and point at a document
1:19:38Yeah, I get nervous when they as soon as they start point
1:19:44Would rather and the thing is I might touch phobia with screens goes even further
1:19:48I would rather not clean it than touch it.
1:19:52Is that weird?
1:19:53Like my screens, like I often have like,
1:19:56I open it, my MacBook can go wow.
1:19:58This has like, maybe it's sneeze residue,
1:20:01maybe it's dust, I don't know.
1:20:02Like eventually it gets bad enough
1:20:04to where you have to clean it,
1:20:05but I'd almost rather not touch it,
1:20:07'cause then I'm afraid I'm gonna clean it
1:20:08and it's gonna be spongy at the corners.
1:20:10(laughing)
1:20:11It's just like a no-win scenario.
1:20:13- In my days as a graphic designer,
1:20:15I remember I would work with people
1:20:17who were screen-touchers themselves.
1:20:19This is back in the CRT era.
1:20:21And they would, you know, we'd be like,
1:20:23hey, let me show you this.
1:20:24What do you think about this?
1:20:25And they'd start pointing to the screen and touching it.
1:20:27And I'd be like, what are you doing?
1:20:30It's your screen, why are you touching your screen?
1:20:33- I think big smeary snail trails across it.
1:20:37- All right, all that said,
1:20:39back when the first iPad Pro came out
1:20:44and I had a review unit
1:20:45And I did what I tried to always do,
1:20:47is immerse myself in it by doing as much of my computing
1:20:50on it as possible during the review period,
1:20:53including writing the review itself, using it.
1:20:57And then when I was done, like a day later or so,
1:20:59I was using my MacBook Pro.
1:21:01And I went over and I tried to scroll.
1:21:04I remember exactly which app it was.
1:21:05It was Tweetbot.
1:21:06And I think the fact that Tweetbot sort of shares
1:21:09aesthetic with the iOS version helped put me in.
1:21:13I touched my MacBook Pro screen and tried to scroll it.
1:21:16So I get it.
1:21:17If it happened to me, I could see how it could happen
1:21:19to more people where they just want to scroll
1:21:22by touching the screen or whatever.
1:21:25But you can't, it's, and I get it.
1:21:28- It's not pretty though.
1:21:29It's just not pretty.
1:21:30Like, I mean, in terms of the physical interaction,
1:21:33it's not pretty.
1:21:34I've seen it happen.
1:21:35Like, I've even been like at events and stuff
1:21:37and I've seen people with touchscreen, you know,
1:21:39Macs or whatever, and they're hurrying to file,
1:21:42like a reporter, you know, and they're hurrying to follow their story and they're bashing away and maybe they go to close up or whatever and
1:21:49they're trying to do a couple last things or even if they're like reading news while they're doing it and they're scrolling they reach up
1:21:54and they do this sort of thing where they they're pulling the laptop in and half closing it and using the screen with their thumbs
1:22:00Like stuff like that, which I look at it and go, you know, I get it
1:22:05It's kind of nice to be able to
1:22:07have this dual mode thing where you're like clickety-clackety-clickety-clack and then if there's a big touch target and you want to just
1:22:12touch it really quick or perhaps like some some interactions might make sense
1:22:17like swiping on the screen to move an entire desktop space right like that
1:22:21makes a ton of sense to me logically you know philosophically but just going like
1:22:25hunt I've seen them also hunting to try and click buttons that they really
1:22:29should have clicked with the mouse but the touch pads are so shitty on those on
1:22:33those particular computers or the they don't have a mouse right that they're
1:22:37just like right and then you know you hit the target wrong because the thumb
1:22:42isn't really calculated to hit it right and all of this stuff. You know, they don't do what Apple
1:22:46does to offset the target, you know, all of that. And remember, there's not a predictable angle that
1:22:52they're hitting it from. You know, because it's a laptop screen with your phone, Apple has offset
1:22:57the key targets, so where they're not over the keys, they're actually slightly above the keys
1:23:01because of the parallax, the way you look at it and the way you type on it. And so, when people
1:23:05go whack it, they don't realize they're hitting above the key, but it's still hitting the key.
1:23:08and like that kind of thing they can't do because it's unpredictable how people
1:23:12are gonna
1:23:12touch them so I think there's a lot of hurdles that manifest themselves in the
1:23:16weird gymnastics people do when they start actually interacting with those
1:23:19kinds of screens
1:23:20you know especially laptops you whack it and it tilts backwards and flops back down
1:23:24and all this stuff you know
1:23:25right you'd almost want to build one that probably has more resistance than
1:23:28the current
1:23:29macbook pros resistance in terms of resistance to
1:23:33to whether it moves down on not in the electrical sense
1:23:36Yeah, yeah.
1:23:37There's also a kind of a fundamental difference between tapping and clicking.
1:23:42Like when you just, if you had a touchscreen Mac and you just touch the screen and then
1:23:47start dragging, did that touch count as a click and then a drag or is it just, that's
1:23:53just where you start dragging?
1:23:54And if you think about that, it's totally different both ways, but you would want, sometimes
1:24:00you'd want one and sometimes you'd want the other.
1:24:02Like how do you differentiate between scrolling in a finder window full of icons and by touching
1:24:11and moving your finger and dragging an icon so you can drag and drop by touching and dragging?
1:24:18It's the exact same gesture.
1:24:19You put your finger on the screen and it happens to be on top of an icon and you move it.
1:24:24Does it start dragging or does it start scrolling the view of icons?
1:24:30There's two things that you want the same gesture to do.
1:24:33And with the mouse pointer, it's easily solved
1:24:36because it only does the drag if you click before you move.
1:24:39You know, there's all sorts of problems
1:24:43that open up like that, and it all gets very messy.
1:24:45And I feel like most of the people
1:24:47who are kind of hoping that Apple would do this
1:24:50haven't really thought through any of those issues
1:24:52and would be, at least in some ways,
1:24:55would be dissatisfied with the result
1:24:56because they would see it as sloppy,
1:24:59Whereas it's really not, there is no easy solution to it.
1:25:04There's no way to make putting your finger on the screen
1:25:07and dragging it do both scroll the view
1:25:10and drag and drop the item.
1:25:11And iOS gets away with it by not having drag and drop.
1:25:16(laughing)
1:25:17- Yeah, it's just like, we'll just gonna not do that.
1:25:19Yeah, and that's the thing they could do
1:25:21by burning it down, so to speak, right?
1:25:22The interface, the layer.
1:25:24- And there's things like on iOS
1:25:26where maybe they're gonna do drag and drop
1:25:28because now they're adding the haptic engine
1:25:30and you can get a touch and drag
1:25:33and a click and drag on the iOS.
1:25:35But even if you thought, well,
1:25:37then there's your solution for macOS for a touchscreen.
1:25:41But now you're making the top of the MacBook
1:25:43even thicker than it was already.
1:25:45Again, another layer of thickness you're adding,
1:25:47which is all problematic.
1:25:49And if you wanna be able to press it hard enough
1:25:51to get a 3D touch, you've gotta make the,
1:25:53the hinge has to be even firmer,
1:25:57et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
1:25:58I don't wanna go down this route any further,
1:26:00but I think it's a bad idea.
1:26:02- Well, it's a rabbit hole, right?
1:26:04It really is.
1:26:05And once you start going down it,
1:26:07you find yourself mixing metaphors.
1:26:10And I think that's something that Apple's super allergic to.
1:26:13Like if you have a touch metaphor that works on the iPad,
1:26:17why would you introduce a completely separate metaphor
1:26:20for the same exact action on a desktop machine?
1:26:23And the answer, of course, the easy answer is,
1:26:25oh, because the desktop's different.
1:26:26But I don't think Apple views it that way.
1:26:28I think they view it, well, if it's different,
1:26:30then why are you trying to shoehorn
1:26:32this interaction methodology onto it?
1:26:35And I think that's where they,
1:26:37they don't want two different answers
1:26:39for what happens when I touch things, you know?
1:26:42They just want one answer.
1:26:44And I think that's the kind of the key there.
1:26:47- Right, and I feel like the way,
1:26:49like part of the brilliance of the original iPhone design
1:26:55was that they had, I'm sure,
1:27:00entire whiteboards full of these issues to resolve
1:27:02over what happens when you just touch,
1:27:05what happens when you drag, what happens, you know,
1:27:08and came up with, okay, this is what'll happen
1:27:11when you do this, this is what'll happen when you do that,
1:27:13and came up with an overall design
1:27:16that when you presented it to a normal person,
1:27:18they didn't realize any of those things had been designed,
1:27:21that it all felt natural, that yes, this is just,
1:27:25You just put your finger on the screen and swipe it
1:27:27and it starts dragging the view and et cetera, et cetera.
1:27:31You just touch the button and let go
1:27:33and the button is activated.
1:27:35- Right.
1:27:36Yeah, I think they're gonna walk into a world of hurt
1:27:43if they start saying different things happen
1:27:45when you touch different things
1:27:46simply because they have come so far instructing people
1:27:51on the one to one.
1:27:54and the one-to-one is like their mantra, you know?
1:27:57And it was, it's something that they didn't invent,
1:28:00but they did perfect and popularize.
1:28:03And I think that that is,
1:28:05you don't wanna give up ownership of that by going,
1:28:07oh, just kidding, that's not actually what we believe.
1:28:10Yeah, you're walking into a problem there.
1:28:13- Right, I don't believe, fundamentally,
1:28:15I do not believe that all computers should be touch screens.
1:28:18I think most should be,
1:28:21and I think most clearly already are,
1:28:23because I think you should count phones as touch screens
1:28:26or as computers and overwhelm,
1:28:28if you combine iPhones and Android phones,
1:28:30they overwhelm all the other personal computers
1:28:34in use in the world today,
1:28:35let alone tablets and anything else
1:28:38that might have a touch screen.
1:28:39But I don't think all should.
1:28:41I think there's a place for a non-touch screen
1:28:43mouse and keyboard interface.
1:28:47Anyway.
1:28:48- Yeah, yeah, no, I agree.
1:28:50I mean, it intersects with a whole lot of discussion
1:28:51about voice, but that's literally a whole other,
1:28:53that's a whole other thing.
1:28:55- Let me take one last break here
1:28:58and thank our third and final sponsor.
1:29:00Long time friends of the show, Backblaze.
1:29:04Backblaze offers unlimited native backup
1:29:07for your Mac or PC.
1:29:09No credit card required to get started, no risk.
1:29:12You get a 15 day free trial at backblaze.com/daringfireball.
1:29:17All data is backed up.
1:29:20all data on your computer's backed up.
1:29:22That's how much data is backed up.
1:29:23What do you say?
1:29:24Well, not mine.
1:29:25I have a four terabyte external drive.
1:29:27Nope, they'll back it all up.
1:29:28Only hitch is it, however much data you have to back up
1:29:31on your computer, however long it takes to upload
1:29:35through your home internet or your office internet,
1:29:39it just takes longer to get the initial backup up there.
1:29:42That's it.
1:29:43That's the only hit.
1:29:44There is no catch.
1:29:45You pay $5 per Mac per month,
1:29:49unlimited data.
1:29:52The software is terrific.
1:29:54The Mac version is written by former Apple engineers.
1:29:56And it feels like it's seamless in the background.
1:29:59You never notice it running.
1:30:01You just set it up and forget it.
1:30:03And it's there.
1:30:04And you get the peace of mind, the wonderful, wonderful--
1:30:08you'll sleep an extra hour a night
1:30:10with the peace of mind of knowing that everything
1:30:12on your Mac that's important is backed up to the cloud.
1:30:15Should that be the only way you back up?
1:30:17No.
1:30:17Backblaze will be the first to tell you that.
1:30:18There's a great place in your backup solution
1:30:22for something like Time Machine, something like Super Duper
1:30:25to clone your startup disks so that you
1:30:27have a second external drive with a complete clone
1:30:30of your startup disk that you could just switch to and boot
1:30:33from and go back to.
1:30:35Local stuff is great.
1:30:36It's always going to be faster.
1:30:39But for when disaster strikes, like if somebody
1:30:42breaks into your house and steals your stuff,
1:30:44or if a pipe bursts in a roof over your office
1:30:48and drips water over all your computing equipment.
1:30:51Anything that could go wrong that might go wrong locally,
1:30:54having an offsite backup is just a tremendous piece of mind
1:30:58and it can be a lifesaver.
1:31:01So where do you go to find out more?
1:31:03I've been using Backblaze for years.
1:31:04I recommend it.
1:31:05I would recommend it if they stopped sponsoring the show,
1:31:07if they stopped sponsoring Daring Fireball.
1:31:09I would still recommend it.
1:31:10Five bucks a month per machine.
1:31:13Go to backblaze.com/daringfireball
1:31:18and they will know that you came here from the show
1:31:20and you'll get a 15-day free trial.
1:31:22My thanks to them.
1:31:23- I like that back place.
1:31:26I've been using that for a long time.
1:31:28- Yeah, it's a great service.
1:31:29I always forget that I have it running.
1:31:31I really do.
1:31:32- Yeah, yeah, only time I remember is when I restart
1:31:35and I see the little flame icon.
1:31:36- Every once in a while, I have an external drive
1:31:39on my desktop that I don't always keep plugged in.
1:31:41It's just, I just call it storage,
1:31:43and it's where I keep all sorts of big-ass stuff,
1:31:45like video and stuff,
1:31:46that I don't necessarily want to fill up my SSD with.
1:31:51And every once in a while,
1:31:51I don't have it plugged in for a while,
1:31:53and they send you a nice little email that says,
1:31:54"Hey, that device hasn't been backed up in 21 days,"
1:31:58or something like that.
1:31:59- Right.
1:32:00- And I'm like, "Oh yeah, Backblaze is still running."
1:32:02- Yeah, exactly.
1:32:03- But I don't really need to plug it back in,
1:32:05because part of the reason it hasn't been backed up
1:32:07in 21 days is I obviously haven't changed anything.
1:32:09- Exactly, yeah.
1:32:11- But anyway, great choice.
1:32:11- I use Carbon Copy Cloner for local,
1:32:13and then back place for, yep, for external,
1:32:17in case my house burns down.
1:32:18- Yep, yep, and then you think, wow, this is good news,
1:32:21my house burned down, but I've--
1:32:22(laughing)
1:32:24- I get to reset up my computer, it's awesome.
1:32:27It's any nerds will take any excuse to reset up a computer.
1:32:30(laughing)
1:32:33- So all right, one of the points,
1:32:35I wouldn't say of contention, but one of the,
1:32:41the things that we didn't really think about last week during that meeting in Cupertino
1:32:46was what Schiller had said was, "Hey, all right, we're working on a new Mac Pro, thought
1:32:52from the ground up. We're working on new Apple branded displays to go along with them. You're
1:33:00not going to see these products this year." I think every single other person at the table
1:33:07heard that and thought, "Okay, these things are coming next year."
1:33:13And sort of in the context of, "Wow, Apple is telling us about a product that's a year
1:33:18out," which is sort of unprecedented.
1:33:21I guess it's the longest ever.
1:33:23They've done things like they unveiled the iPhone at Macworld in January and it didn't
1:33:26ship until June.
1:33:27That's a six-month lead.
1:33:29A year is pretty unusual, if not unprecedented.
1:33:34But I had that in my story at at least one point where I used the phrase "next year"
1:33:40and I got pinged the next morning from someone at Apple PR just to clarify that Apple didn't
1:33:46say "next year."
1:33:47They did not say "next year" either.
1:33:49They just said "not this year."
1:33:51And that there's obviously a subtle difference between "not this year" and "next year,"
1:33:57which is that in theory, it might not come until 2019.
1:34:01- Mm-hmm, yeah, nobody from Apple reached out to me
1:34:04like proactively like that, but I did look at my,
1:34:07when I was looking at the, through my transcript,
1:34:09just to kind of make sure I got everything right
1:34:12and all that, I realized that nobody did.
1:34:15I think it was Lance kind of mentioned twice,
1:34:18hey, these things that are coming next year,
1:34:20blah, blah, blah, you know, just doesn't lead in
1:34:22to another question.
1:34:23And there was no pushback, so I think that's kind of
1:34:26where my brain clicked over, okay, fine,
1:34:28they didn't push back against these,
1:34:29but it was a conversation.
1:34:31So, I didn't expect them to necessarily push back
1:34:33against every little thing,
1:34:35or maybe they were just waiting
1:34:36for the point of the question, right?
1:34:37And they didn't, you know,
1:34:38they slipped their mind or whatever.
1:34:41But yeah, nowhere in that did they specify next year.
1:34:44So, that makes sense.
1:34:46And I don't think that it means
1:34:47that it won't come next year.
1:34:49Maybe it will.
1:34:50But I also think that they wanna leave themselves
1:34:53wiggle room in case they can't get it done.
1:34:54And it's first quarter the year after,
1:34:56or second quarter the year after, you know what I mean?
1:34:58I can't fathom to see it being three years from now,
1:35:01but I definitely think that they did not want to commit
1:35:05to exactly 18 months from now, no longer kind of thing.
1:35:10- At first I was a little alarmed by it,
1:35:15but then I thought, you know what,
1:35:16I think it's just, it's just not,
1:35:20it's their institutional resistance
1:35:21to talking about stuff in the future
1:35:23and making any promises at all,
1:35:25and their sort of desire to under-promise and over-deliver.
1:35:28I can't help but suspect that internally
1:35:31they certainly are shooting for next year,
1:35:33if not early next year.
1:35:35I can't help but think that,
1:35:36but that they know that Murphy's Law can hit
1:35:39and that they might spend six months pursuing path X
1:35:42and decide, nope, we need to backtrack
1:35:44and go down path Y instead,
1:35:45and now we've lost six months,
1:35:47that that can happen with the product.
1:35:49But given the fact that they're hitting this reset button
1:35:54on a what's now four-year-old computer,
1:35:58well, almost four, coming out four,
1:36:00but let's call it three,
1:36:01I guess 'cause it shipped at the end of 2013.
1:36:04Let's be generous and call it
1:36:06a three-and-a-half-year-old computer.
1:36:08That they're doing this now
1:36:14and saying it's still gonna take at least a year,
1:36:17that's a pretty long time for the world's most,
1:36:22most successful, profitable company that specializes
1:36:25in making computers, to make a computer that
1:36:30should be at a basic level fundamentally
1:36:34similar to high-end Intel-based workstations,
1:36:41that part of this isn't--
1:36:43it's not like they're designing their own.
1:36:45At least we think they're not designing their own CPU
1:36:48to go with this.
1:36:48[LAUGHTER]
1:36:49Right.
1:36:51And on the flip side of that,
1:36:53and this is what I want to hear your thoughts about,
1:36:54is part of the pushback I got from my article
1:36:58was specifically about this, it's not coming this year.
1:37:01And the pushback I heard was from people,
1:37:05readers and listeners of the show,
1:37:06who are obviously frustrated at the Mac Pro,
1:37:09who didn't take this announcement as the good news
1:37:12that I took it as, because my biggest fear,
1:37:14like I said, going in, was that they were gonna say,
1:37:16we're not gonna make a Mac Pro anymore.
1:37:18- Right, like nothing at all, right?
1:37:19- Right, that was my bad news,
1:37:21and my good news scenario is the Mac Pro is coming,
1:37:25but it's not coming for a while.
1:37:27And I thought that that was the good news,
1:37:28because if the, in theory, good news would be,
1:37:32we have a new Mac Pro and here it is,
1:37:34or we have a new Mac Pro and it's coming at WWDC,
1:37:39they wouldn't have had the meeting.
1:37:40They would have just either shown,
1:37:41had an event and shown it,
1:37:43or they would have waited until June.
1:37:45They could have at least waited that long,
1:37:46and then had shown it.
1:37:48I think the fact that it couldn't even be shown in June
1:37:52meant that they needed to do something like this.
1:37:54And so I knew that going into the meeting,
1:37:55that there's no way they're going to show it to us.
1:37:58It can't be coming soon.
1:37:59So the best possible case would be that they say to us,
1:38:02it's coming at the end of the year,
1:38:04I thought would maybe be the ideal case.
1:38:07But what I heard from people was, god damn it,
1:38:11why can't Apple just take a motherboard from Intel
1:38:16and some high-end Nvidia graphics cards
1:38:19and put them in a goddamn box and sell it to me.
1:38:22How long can it take to make a nice new--
1:38:26Two 1080is, aluminum case, done.
1:38:28Right.
1:38:29Give Johnny Ives team a month to make a nice-looking box
1:38:32and ship the goddamn thing.
1:38:35And I wonder what you think about that.
1:38:38What is it that they're doing that's going to take them
1:38:41at least a year added to however long they've already
1:38:46been working on on this, which seems to be at least six months, probably a little more,
1:38:51but at least six months since I think they flipped the switch and said full speed ahead.
1:38:56Jay Haynes Yeah. I don't know. I mean, I keep going back.
1:39:01It's almost like haunting me now when they're saying, "If we're going to do anything, we
1:39:05want to make sure that it's innovative and that it's not the same old thing." And I think
1:39:10it's fine. Like the best case scenario of that is iPhone. I don't know what that could
1:39:17be. There's two things that stick in my mind completely unrelated to Apple. Well, not completely,
1:39:22but sort of unrelated to Apple that sound intriguing. One of the reasons I asked, "What's
1:39:29your feeling on external GPUs?" was that was my assumption of what the Mac Pro was. Because
1:39:36Because I had heard a little bit before the Mac Pro was announced, these things start
1:39:40to come up in conversation as you have them. Nothing I could put together really solidly,
1:39:44but I'd heard it's a little blob of a machine and they're going to focus on peripherals,
1:39:49which is essentially what they were trying to do, but the peripherals never really materialized
1:39:54because of Thunderbolt issues and all that stuff, in terms of the vast array of them
1:39:58they thought were going to accompany this thing. But the peripheral that I was really
1:40:02focused on in my mind was an external GPU. So it's saying, "Hey, like this is what we
1:40:06launched today. We think it's going to be great for most people's computing needs, blah,
1:40:09blah, blah. And then, you know, in six months we're going to have a partner like Nvidia
1:40:14or AMD, obviously who they work very closely with, who has an external GPU you can plug
1:40:20in and it'll handle your rendering tasks and run your games and you can just pick which
1:40:25GPU you're going to use and boom, right? And you can just do that. And this--that way,
1:40:30this little blob of a machine lives on your desk for five years, eight years, ten years,
1:40:36and you get the newest GPU and plug it in, and as long as the I/O doesn't change, you
1:40:40know, we don't have some massive change shift in I/O, which will happen every five, eight
1:40:44years, whatever, then you're good, you're golden, and you're going to be able to keep
1:40:48using this for the GPU-intensive tasks that you have. And that was my thought originally
1:40:54for it. I was obviously too aggressive in the way I was thinking about it. I guess one
1:41:00way to put it.
1:41:01I think Apple was too though. I do.
1:41:03Well, yeah, yeah, yeah. I guess so. But not in that way, right? In a different way. In
1:41:07a different direction completely. So my thinking is like, maybe that's the answer. Maybe that
1:41:13they figured out like, hey, maybe external GPUs are the thing. And they can go to NVIDIA
1:41:17and say, "Hey, build us a GPU or an accessory that people plug their GPUs into, and then
1:41:25we don't have to worry about it." But it doesn't seem right to me, right? Because then they
1:41:30would be doubling down on their current shape and form factor, and I don't think that they
1:41:34would be doing that if they brought us in to have this whole discussion.
1:41:38- Yeah, but the answer was unambiguous though.
1:41:42You asked, do you guys see a future for external GPUs?
1:41:47And I think it was Federighi who answered unambiguously yes.
1:41:51We see a place for external GPUs.
1:41:53It was very short, very sweet.
1:41:54There was no preamble. - They're interesting.
1:41:55And then Turnus, I think, said,
1:41:57for some applications, absolutely.
1:41:58For others, no.
1:41:59Which is another way of saying,
1:42:01yeah, it doesn't work always, but it does work sometimes.
1:42:04- Right. - But not, no.
1:42:05Those are terrible.
1:42:06terrible idea like touch, right?
1:42:08- Right, right, and that was like a long discussion
1:42:11about why they're no, why they're not, you know.
1:42:14Of all the, you know, a lot of the questions
1:42:16they wouldn't give a yes or no to,
1:42:17but they gave a no to touch, and it wasn't just no,
1:42:20it was no and it was a long discussion,
1:42:22but the external GPU was yes for some cases.
1:42:25I think the other thing that they were pretty unambiguous
1:42:27about is that the new Mac Pro has to be able
1:42:30to support a big honking internal GPU.
1:42:32that whatever you might do as a niche within a niche
1:42:37that would require external GPUs,
1:42:40fundamentally this machine has to accommodate
1:42:42a big honking GPU that's there all the time
1:42:45and can do things that'll make it hot
1:42:48and have the heat dissipate.
1:42:49I thought that was pretty unambiguous too.
1:42:53- So the other trend besides the external GPUs,
1:42:59I'll just interject this.
1:43:01I don't know why this is tickling my brain,
1:43:06but there are types of computers,
1:43:08obviously the people that build PCs are very familiar,
1:43:10you know that you have like the full size ATX case, right?
1:43:15Which is your big case, and then you have mini ATX,
1:43:19a micro ATX, so on and so forth, right?
1:43:21Basically smaller and smaller cases,
1:43:23and at some point you have to get like a smaller motherboard,
1:43:26a motherboard that's meant specifically to conserve space
1:43:28and maybe it doesn't have as many RAM slots,
1:43:31or maybe it doesn't have as many creature comforts
1:43:35or whatever, and it shrinks and shrinks and shrinks.
1:43:38But there are miniature prebued computers called nukes
1:43:42or nucks that are, Microsoft has a very popular one
1:43:46where if it's like you need somebody who needs a computer
1:43:49but they don't really need anything special,
1:43:50they just buy a nuck, right?
1:43:51It's like 250 bucks and boom, you get yourself a computer,
1:43:54plug a monitor in and you're good.
1:43:55And then there's other ones that are about,
1:43:59really about fitting really robust graphics cards into tiny cases, like really small cases.
1:44:09And some of these PC, and I'll have to look it up once again, I don't have it up to my
1:44:13fingertips, but some of these cases are essentially an excuse for a graphics card, right? They
1:44:18wrap around the graphics card, the motherboard is specifically designed to fit inside the
1:44:22case as small as possible, and the thing looks like a bread loaf, right? And it's all about
1:44:28the GPU. And it's for gamers who want the power but don't want to sacrifice the space.
1:44:34And I think VR and to a lesser extent AR are driving this, this sort of category, where
1:44:42you've got a person who wants to do VR and maybe they want to port it around and go to
1:44:46groups to, you know, go to their friend's house and bring it or whatever. Like these
1:44:50evangelists, VR evangelists pushing the thing forward and gamers who want the latest bleeding
1:44:55edge thing, like 100,000 VR headsets or so have been sold so far. So you figure 100,000
1:45:01users, that's enough for some case manufacturer to go, "Hey, let me build this specialty
1:45:05case," right? And I think for me, it makes a ton of sense. I love it. I love the idea
1:45:11because if I travel between cities, which I do often, and I want to bring my VR kit,
1:45:16I can pack my headset and my cords into a relatively small bag, but then I got this
1:45:20this big old tower computer that runs this thing.
1:45:23And that sucks, right?
1:45:24And a laptop sort of runs it,
1:45:27but it won't run it really well.
1:45:29It won't run it like an Nvidia high-end 1080
1:45:32or high-end AMD Cardwell.
1:45:34And so there's something about that.
1:45:36It's like maybe that you're thinking like,
1:45:38well heck, if this is the future, let's lean into it.
1:45:41Let's honor the shape and the power
1:45:46and the desire to slot these things in here
1:45:49and just build a case that accommodates two full-size graphics cards
1:45:53and up to four SSDs and that's it. You know what I mean?
1:45:57I don't know. It's like the same kind of ideas
1:46:00but leaning in a different direction. I just don't know if they do that or if they go
1:46:04full-on like bunch of space.
1:46:06I think VR is an interesting topic
1:46:09combined with this discussion of the Mac Pro and
1:46:12the most powerful possible graphics you can get running on an Apple device
1:46:16today, but not in the obvious first level scenario of, hey,
1:46:25in the current world, Mac users can't run VR in a mass market
1:46:29way or can't do it well, and that things like the Oculus
1:46:33don't even support it because there's no graphics card that's
1:46:35up to their specs, et cetera, et cetera.
1:46:37I think from Apple's perspective,
1:46:38that's not really relevant.
1:46:40And I think that they're correct that it's not relevant,
1:46:43that the ultimate mass market way for Apple to do VR or AR
1:46:48is to create a standalone device with a,
1:46:52this is what Apple does,
1:46:53is when they go to a new form factor,
1:46:55they create an entirely new interface
1:46:57that is meant to be optimal for that form factor.
1:47:01And so from Apple's perspective,
1:47:03the right way to do VR is to bide your time
1:47:06and wait until the technology can be put
1:47:09into a desirable product that you just put over your eyes
1:47:13and you're using their new VR product,
1:47:15and it's running a VR OS.
1:47:17But in the meantime, pro users have a need to do VR now.
1:47:25Not consumer users for playing games and stuff like that.
1:47:28That's not really Apple's purview.
1:47:30But I can totally see why Sony has-- we have one in the house.
1:47:35The kid has a VR headset that runs right now,
1:47:38and people can play games, and it's kind of cool and immersive.
1:47:42But at a professional level, somebody's got to make the VR stuff and somebody's got to do the work.
1:47:47And if you assume that Apple, just think about Apple's own needs internally.
1:47:50It's widely rumored that Apple has teams working on VR and especially AR.
1:47:56Apple's even said publicly that they're interested in augmented reality.
1:48:00What are Apple's engineers inside the company using to do these things that is so super?
1:48:09Right, right, exactly.
1:48:11Like if they're gonna I mean, I know for a fact obviously that they're working on AR and VR
1:48:15Who would you know, they'd be dumb not to and they have these teams of people, you know
1:48:20Poking and prodding at it from different varying angles trying to figure out. Is this the right way to go?
1:48:25Is that the right way to go? Do we build glasses? Do we build this thing?
1:48:28Do we build the other thing like what the hell are they using? Right? I can tosses probably I have heard
1:48:33I don't know, you know in recent weeks both both after from a couple people after last week's news broke and and you know
1:48:41our stories hit. But even in the weeks leading up to this, after I linked to a thing about
1:48:47a video editor, a long-time Mac user who's reluctantly moving to Windows, just because
1:48:54the GPU situation didn't meet his needs on Mac, I heard from people within Apple, Little
1:49:00Birdies, just saying, "Yeah, in some ways it's a shit show." And that there have been
1:49:05people in Apple who are like, "I don't even know what to do. Should I try to requisition
1:49:07in the Linux box?
1:49:09'Cause it's like Apple's not even set up
1:49:13for things like that to go through,
1:49:15like for an engineer to ask for non-Apple hardware.
1:49:18But that, you know,
1:49:20just different needs within the company.
1:49:24I mean, but AR, I didn't hear from anybody working on AR,
1:49:27but I heard from somebody who's working at Apple
1:49:29with large data sets, let's say,
1:49:31and that there is no Apple computer
1:49:36that actually is state of the art
1:49:37for the needs of their work.
1:49:39Which is a really weird situation for Apple to be in.
1:49:43- No, it really is.
1:49:44Like, I'd love to see the POs.
1:49:46- All right, it goes back to--
1:49:47- Like, what are they ordering?
1:49:48- What it reminds me of is,
1:49:49I forget the exact details of the story,
1:49:52but in the early days, like 1983 or '84 or so,
1:49:56like when the original Mac was getting
1:49:57on the cusp of launching, they bought a Cray
1:50:00to do certain supercomputing needs
1:50:03for the development of the Mac.
1:50:05Which made total sense because supercomputers were totally different things from personal computers,
1:50:10where supercomputers were, at least by the standards of the day, the fastest possible computers money could buy,
1:50:15and they would cost like a million dollars or something like that.
1:50:18And a personal computer was supposed to cost $2,000 or $2,500 or whatever.
1:50:23And obviously it was only a fraction of the power.
1:50:28But in recent years, at least certainly for the entirety of the Mac OS X era,
1:50:33where it was a Unix workstation.
1:50:38You didn't need to go outside the company
1:50:40to buy a Unix workstation.
1:50:43And they run into all sorts of problems where it doesn't--
1:50:46you'd really have to go down the--
1:50:47like you said, the Hackintosh route,
1:50:49because just buying a Linux box to do this
1:50:51doesn't let you run Xcode.
1:50:53And your stuff might require Xcode in particular, not just
1:50:56any C compiler or whatever.
1:51:00And then just think of anybody outside the company who's
1:51:02working on VR and AR and stuff for the future where it becomes a much more mass
1:51:07product market product well the the work is being done today that's laying the
1:51:12groundwork for the future where AR and VR are mass market technologies that
1:51:17everybody just sort of takes for granted like we take for granted touchscreens
1:51:20and and everything else down the chain huh that work is going on today and it
1:51:25really is not suited to the Mac Pro yeah and it is I mean the people that are it's
1:51:32At some point you have to think to yourself, "Okay, the people that are shaping the future
1:51:36of computing, what tools are they using?"
1:51:39The shovels are incredibly important.
1:51:42In the startup community, you always have this...
1:51:45I mean, it's tech in general, but startups especially, you have this philosophy that
1:51:52you'll hear VCs or entrepreneurs talk about where they say, "Build the shovels," or "Invest
1:51:56in the shovels," because in the end, everybody needs a shovel.
1:52:00You got to dig the hole, you got to pour the foundation and build your thing on top of it.
1:52:03But if you're the shovel maker, everybody needs a shovel.
1:52:06Right?
1:52:07And at some point, either the shovel gets acquired by somebody who's like, "I really need this
1:52:10particular shovel," or it gets widely used.
1:52:13In either case is a major, minor success scenario for a startup.
1:52:18And it just goes to, you know, it leads in this line of thinking.
1:52:22Apple for many years, they built the shovels.
1:52:25Right?
1:52:26They built what you would use, what you would launch your thing on and build your thing
1:52:30on top of, but they also built the shovels.
1:52:33And they still are a shovel builder to a degree, but with Xcode and with the MacBook Pros and
1:52:39IMAX, as they said, more and more people are using that for things like software development
1:52:43and whatnot.
1:52:44But if they want to maintain this hold on being the shovel builder, so people buy the
1:52:51shovels and they build on top of your platform with your shovels and all of that, which has
1:52:55which has been a major component of Apple's success
1:52:58with the iPhone and everything else,
1:53:01then you gotta go, okay, well, what's the next big platform
1:53:04and what are the shovels for that platform?
1:53:07If AR and VR are, in fact, a big component
1:53:11of the next era of computing and it's not something else,
1:53:15then where are your shovels for those people?
1:53:19And right now, they don't have any.
1:53:21Or they have some that sort of work
1:53:23but are not really the ideal shovels,
1:53:25So no major swath of those people
1:53:27are really going to consider it right now.
1:53:32Totally agree with that.
1:53:33And I think that's sort of what they tacitly
1:53:35acknowledged last week, which was
1:53:37it was sort of a dual emphasis.
1:53:39It was conflicting, maybe not conflicting.
1:53:43But they strongly emphasized that the needs of most
1:53:46of their pro users are met by the current MacBook
1:53:48Pros and iMacs.
1:53:50and even more so in the near future as the new MacBook Pro
1:53:55form factor gets improved, and with the iMacs
1:53:59that they emphasized include, quote, "pro configs."
1:54:05But they realized that for--
1:54:08what was the phrase--
1:54:09a small single digit of their users, which I think means 1%,
1:54:16but they didn't want to give an exact number.
1:54:18- Yeah, it's gotta be close to that.
1:54:20- If it's not one, it's close to one,
1:54:22but it's, let's say a small single digit of their users,
1:54:25they need something else,
1:54:28and they're committed to building that for them.
1:54:31They get it, you know, and that they clearly,
1:54:34obviously had their eye off the ball in recent years
1:54:37on that segment of the market.
1:54:38- Yeah, I don't know.
1:54:44I don't know if it's like,
1:54:48Everything is so much more open and rapid now.
1:54:51I mean, I'm casting about a little bit here for why,
1:54:55but I think that software development
1:54:57is a completely different ballgame now.
1:54:59Where it used to be, you had pipelines that were being built
1:55:02and legacy pipelines that sort of evolved
1:55:06into newer pipelines, right?
1:55:07And now you have sort of pipelines having to be created
1:55:10out of whole cloth within years, a couple of years,
1:55:13versus pipelines that evolved over decades.
1:55:16And I think that there's something there too,
1:55:19where it's so quick, you have to readjust
1:55:21your frame of reference, you know,
1:55:24and how fast you gotta move on these things
1:55:26and provide those tools for people.
1:55:29I don't know, maybe it's that.
1:55:31- On a meta level, I don't know if you had anything
1:55:32else you wanna talk about, but the other thing
1:55:34I wanted to talk about was the meta level
1:55:36of our afternoon in Cupertino,
1:55:40was the campus itself.
1:55:42One thing, it was at the old campus,
1:55:45It was in a really old building across the street from One
1:55:47Infinite Loop across De Anza Boulevard
1:55:51in this sort of nondescript, old California-style single-story
1:55:55office building.
1:55:57They did treat us to lunch at the new Cafe Max, which
1:56:01I didn't even know existed, which is sort of--
1:56:06Cafe Alves, they call it.
1:56:07Cafe Alves, which is a beautiful new building.
1:56:11I mean, it's a really impressive architecture.
1:56:16So what struck me about the fact that the Cafe Alves
1:56:20is so nice, it's all brand new, it's got, I don't know,
1:56:24quadruple height ceilings, I mean, it's truly a huge space.
1:56:28Really nice fit and finish, but also looks very new.
1:56:30It looks like new Apple.
1:56:32A lot of Apple's campus is obviously very old
1:56:34and sort of still predates, I mean,
1:56:37the whole One Infinite Loop campus really predates
1:56:39the return of Steve Jobs and the architecture really kind of looks like it.
1:56:43Yeah. But that they've made this very modern new current Apple cafeteria on the old campus,
1:56:51which just emphasizes what we've been hearing, which is that yes, they're opening
1:56:55this massive new Spaceship Campus this year, but that they're not abandoning any of their
1:57:03previous office space. They're just bursting at the seams right now headcount wise.
1:57:07Yeah, they're going to fill the new headquarters and still be full at both, which is some sort
1:57:12of bigger on the inside thing happening there.
1:57:14Yeah, well, they still saw the need to build this massive new cafeteria.
1:57:17I mean, cafeteria is the wrong word, but café, I guess.
1:57:20But I thought that was pretty interesting.
1:57:22And then somebody asked during the event about whether people on their teams had moved into
1:57:30the new campus yet.
1:57:31And another one of those topics were, for whatever reason, Apple does not want to talk
1:57:35about it.
1:57:36do not want to talk about who has moved into the new campus, who hasn't, and when anybody
1:57:41is moving in. Did you get that sense that they're just like...
1:57:44**Beserat Debebe:** Yeah. Yeah. There's, oh, I mean, a couple
1:57:47of times they were like, "Hey, we don't mind asking, but we really want to talk about the
1:57:50Mac, blah, blah, blah." And that was one of them. And yeah, they definitely are not interested
1:57:55at all in talking about how many people have moved, which departments have moved, which
1:58:00departments are moving, all of that.
1:58:03Yeah, I don't know what state it's in. I really don't I mean
1:58:06I've watched those flyover videos every once in a while and you can see you know that it certainly is ever closer to completion
1:58:12and that you know like
1:58:14landscaping is probably the last thing to be done and it's probably the biggest thing remaining but
1:58:17You know for whatever reason it was clearly not it never never on the table that that
1:58:24Last week's meeting was going to be held on the new campus
1:58:26even though if you would have told me a year ago that we'd be having a
1:58:30interesting roundtable discussion
1:58:33At the very end of March was it the very yeah, it was the very end of or was it the beginning of April?
1:58:38I guess it was the beginning of April. Yeah, it was April. Yeah in April 2017. I would have thought oh, I bet that's on the new campus
1:58:45Yeah
1:58:47No, I think they're still trying to get everybody's
1:58:49Work table set up. Yeah
1:58:52Hide the LG logos under under five displays trying to move the routers further away from the LG monitor
1:59:01(laughing)
1:59:03Sorry.
1:59:05- Was there anything else that you wanted to talk about
1:59:07before we wrap up?
1:59:08- No, I mean, I think that covers it.
1:59:10I think it was an interesting discussion.
1:59:12I think it was very interesting to hear them say,
1:59:15"We're sorry," twice to the community, which,
1:59:18honestly, there's one aspect of this where people are like,
1:59:24"Yeah, well, Apple's arrogant."
1:59:25They never say they're sorry, which is not totally true.
1:59:27They have apologized for things.
1:59:29But there's also an enormous amount of responsibility
1:59:32that a corporation,
1:59:34you have to think about it this way, strategically,
1:59:37there's an enormous amount of responsibility
1:59:39that a corporation takes on when they say, "I'm sorry."
1:59:42Because they're admitting some sort of culpability.
1:59:44Now, this is not like a consumer harm scenario, really.
1:59:47I mean, I'm sure somebody will try to make an issue of it,
1:59:49right, at some point.
1:59:50But that's not for me to determine.
1:59:52I'm no legal analyst in that regard.
1:59:54But it's a big statement for the biggest company on earth to say we're sorry twice
2:00:02in an on-the-record discussion like that and not try to crib it or beyond contextualizing
2:00:12it.
2:00:13Of course, I'm trying to paint a picture about why it happened.
2:00:15And that's a pretty ballsy thing to do, I think.
2:00:19For a product that is not a disaster, it's a disappointment.
2:00:23It is something that they were rightfully proud of
2:00:25when it came out.
2:00:27This is not a situation where heads should roll
2:00:30or something like that.
2:00:31And we can laugh about Schiller's
2:00:34can't innovate anymore, my ass.
2:00:36Maybe a whole different discussion,
2:00:38but I don't think we need to argue it,
2:00:40is that it was innovative.
2:00:41It just was the wrong direction for innovation.
2:00:44But it was truly an innovative design.
2:00:46And to apologize for disappointing people for that,
2:00:51I think is different.
2:00:52as I say, compare and contrast with this week's
2:00:56United Airlines fiasco, where it took them 36 hours
2:01:00to apologize for what was literally a disaster.
2:01:04Where-- - Yeah, yeah.
2:01:06- Where they issued it.
2:01:08Right before we started recording,
2:01:09they issued a press release that was pretty good, I think.
2:01:12But should have been the press release
2:01:14they issued 36 hours ago.
2:01:16- It's pretty good, but right now,
2:01:17it's like it has no impact whatsoever.
2:01:20- Right. - Too late.
2:01:2136 hours like shooting somebody and then like offering them a band-aid and being like, oh man, sorry about that
2:01:26I like I already have a bottle in me
2:01:29PR is the analogy to fires is often used with PR's that it's a you know
2:01:36It's put out the put out the fire as the job PR does but it's a really I think it's a really good analogy
2:01:41and at at
2:01:43when the story first leaked that this poor fellow on the flight had been bloodied while they forcibly removed him and
2:01:50oriented and had a really bad experience.
2:01:53It was bad, it was a fire, but it was like a trash can fire.
2:01:58And they let it turn from a trash can fire
2:02:01into a house that had been burned down fire, which
2:02:05can, like real fires, happens very quickly.
2:02:09This is why you need-- PR professionals need
2:02:12to be quick thinking and ready to go.
2:02:13And United certainly blew that.
2:02:16But anyway, it just comes to mind when it comes to apologies.
2:02:19that there's a big difference between apologizing
2:02:21for a man who's been beaten to a bloody pulp
2:02:24and apologizing for a rather subtly disappointing
2:02:29years long,
2:02:32dawdled down the wrong path of the future
2:02:36of pro hardware engineering.
2:02:38And I thought it was pretty telling.
2:02:39- Something that was ultimately well executed
2:02:41but served the wrong needs.
2:02:42- Right, I thought that was pretty interesting.
2:02:44And I thought it was, it filled me with,
2:02:47I think that they've got this.
2:02:48I think they've, I think they lost a handle on this
2:02:51and didn't quite realize they had,
2:02:53but now they've got a firm handle on it again.
2:02:55- Yeah, yeah.
2:02:59- All right, Matthew Panzorino,
2:03:00we can read your fine writing and that of your staff at,
2:03:04what's the name of the site?
2:03:08- TechCrunch.
2:03:09- TechCrunch, TechCrunch.
2:03:11It's a new up and coming site on the internet.
2:03:14- Yeah, fresh.
2:03:16And on Twitter, you are @panzer.
2:03:19Did I get it right?
2:03:20P-A-N-Z-E-R.
2:03:22- That's it, that's it.
2:03:23- It's a fine Twitter account
2:03:25where you have very good commentary on the day's events.
2:03:30My thanks to you.