0:00:00Did you watch the Oscars?
0:00:01I watched the end of the Oscars, so I caught right at the end when everything went totally wrong.
0:00:06So you were watching live when it happened?
0:00:09Yeah.
0:00:09We were not. I've kind of given up on award shows. I find that they're just too damn tedious.
0:00:14But I got a news alert from the New York Times, and so we immediately switched over and quickly rewound and watched it.
0:00:22But it's so totally different knowing.
0:00:23You know, like the news alert was like, holy hell, they announced the wrong winner of the
0:00:28best picture.
0:00:29Go watch this fiasco live, you know.
0:00:31Whereas if you're watching live, it's got to be more of a, what the hell is going on?
0:00:35Yeah, it was very unscripted.
0:00:37So the funny thing is, of course, I was driving home from Canada.
0:00:40So when I say watching live, what I really mean was, I had my iPhone open, and I was
0:00:46listening to it.
0:00:49So I didn't see the facial expressions that everybody was talking about.
0:00:52I just heard this long, really awkward pause, and I'm like, well that's like... and some
0:00:59shuffling in the microphone, and I'm like, that doesn't, that's not usually how you build
0:01:03suspense.
0:01:04It's not like, you know, shuffle, shuffle, shuffle, everything's, you know, everything's
0:01:09fine here, we're all fine, how are you?
0:01:12Yeah, it was just, it was odd.
0:01:14And then the resulting commotion, I almost, like, I didn't pull over the car, but I almost
0:01:22wanted to pull over the car and be like, "I actually want to watch this because this seems
0:01:25kind of ridiculous." So I didn't actually get to watch the video of it until I got home
0:01:32in front of, you know, and probably I don't think until the next day, sitting down in
0:01:37front of my computer being like, "Okay, what actually happened during this nonsense?" And
0:01:43And then watching like Warren Beatty just look completely confounded and feel like,
0:01:51"Uh, let's maybe not announce this."
0:01:56And then I forget, who's his co-anchor?
0:01:58Uh, Faye Dunaway.
0:01:59His co-presenter.
0:02:00Faye Dunaway, there we go.
0:02:02For some reason, her name wasn't coming to me, but yeah, Faye Dunaway just being like,
0:02:06"All right, it's Lalo Land!"
0:02:07And everybody, you could just see like his face crystallizing.
0:02:11Right.
0:02:12"Oh my god, we've made a huge mistake!"
0:02:14Right, I don't know that we should have done that, right?
0:02:16Yeah, exactly. Even though it's live TV, but the show must go on, right?
0:02:20It's funny too, because to my memory, and I guess I don't really watch award shows anymore,
0:02:26but it seems to me that in my mind, the Oscars is the one that's only, that's most bragged over the years
0:02:32about the fidelity of the vote counting process and the secrecy and, you know,
0:02:38the very ostentatious mentions of their partnership with Price Waterhouse, or now it's Price Waterhouse
0:02:45Coopers, you know, and giving them a special briefcase. Right, and that the two briefcase
0:02:51carriers have become, became, even before, way before this, now they're much better known, but
0:02:56they were part of the red carpet ceremony, you know, where they're dressed up and they're, they're,
0:03:02they're ostentatiously bringing, you know, they're carrying these briefcases full of the
0:03:07winning envelopes, that they're the show that, you know, like other awards shows, I don't remember
0:03:13that, you know, any kind of exposure to the integrity of the process.
0:03:19No, exactly. I mean, the Golden... it's also the history of the award show, right? Where you look
0:03:26at the Golden Globes and you look at the Emmys, and to a much lesser extent, the Tonys. The Tonys
0:03:31are more on the Oscar levels, but especially if you look at the Golden Globes and the Emmys,
0:03:36They're very much more of a like, "Let's sit down and have a boozy lunch and acknowledge that these are probably, you know, probably win awards that are won by massive marketing campaigns, but also let's feel good about ourselves."
0:03:51Whereas the Oscars, for as long as I've been alive and much more than that, was raised as the like, this is the pinnacle of, you know, achievement as an actor or an actress or a director.
0:04:03and you know, once you're recognized at the Oscars, then you have become a legitimate star.
0:04:09And that was the thing. It's like, if you want to become big, you have to get an Academy Award nomination.
0:04:15Forget the Golden Globes or the Emmys or anything along those lines.
0:04:19Those don't matter as much as the Oscars, because the Oscars are voted on by us.
0:04:24And we, you know, we have this proud tradition.
0:04:27And like you said, PricewaterhouseCoopers, I'm pretty sure that's the only accounting
0:04:32firm I knew by name growing up.
0:04:37When you ask little kids, like 7 year olds, "How many accounting firms can you name?"
0:04:42And I'm pretty sure that, at least growing up in LA, the only thing people would have
0:04:47been able to be like, "Oh yeah, PricewaterhouseCoopers, they do the Oscars!"
0:04:50They're the people who look a little bit nerdy in really fancy suits and dresses, holding
0:04:56giant briefcases that remind you of nuclear football.
0:05:00They take care of us and they make sure that the integrity of the Oscar stays intact, dammit.
0:05:05Nice to remember...
0:05:06Let me take a moment here and do my own Warren Beatty.
0:05:09Just let me double check that we're okay here.
0:05:11Can you double check that you're using the right mic in Skype?
0:05:14Yeah. I absolutely can.
0:05:17Because you sound pretty good, but you sound ever so slightly tinny.
0:05:21Is that good? Can you hear me tapping on that?
0:05:24- Yeah, yes. - Yeah.
0:05:25- All right, you're sorry.
0:05:26- And I'm using the right microphone.
0:05:27- All right, you're good.
0:05:28All right, I just wanted to double check.
0:05:30- But I figured out why, hold on.
0:05:32I'm using the right microphone, but the wrong side of it.
0:05:35- Oh, now you sound much better.
0:05:37- Yeah, okay.
0:05:39Well, now we've proven that podcasting on a afternoon.
0:05:44Yeah, we're done.
0:05:47Show's over, everybody.
0:05:49- It's not La La Land.
0:05:51You do sound better. - I'm just not.
0:05:52That's good. I'm glad. I definitely don't want to sound
0:05:55tinny on the talk show.
0:05:56So funny. I'm so glad I said something now rather than two
0:06:02hours from now. Me too.
0:06:04So I found this so interesting because it really was the worst
0:06:09possible it was the biggest award
0:06:10was the end of the night and they couldn't cut to commercial
0:06:14and it's like no offense, no offense at all to the nominees
0:06:18for best sound editing, because it is it's the biggest award
0:06:21they can win and I understand that these are professional, you know, like in a way that like
0:06:26you and I work in a niche area of journalism, right? Like I understand what that's like and
0:06:33that you're they're obsessed with sound that I'm not trying to diminish the embarrassment that it
0:06:38would have caused if the same mistake had happened two hours earlier when the best sound editing
0:06:43award was given out but it would have been so much less publicity the next day, right?
0:06:49- Yeah, you wouldn't, and also honestly,
0:06:51the winner of best sound editing,
0:06:53chances are they would've gotten up
0:06:55and then before reading their speech,
0:06:57they probably would've looked down at the card
0:06:59and been like, hmm, this has nothing to do
0:07:02with sound editing.
0:07:04Although maybe they wouldn't,
0:07:05because as the article you were sharing with me earlier
0:07:09about typography, once I got a chance to look at
0:07:12the winner cards that they were distributing,
0:07:17Who puts the name of the category in 10 point font
0:07:20at the bottom of a card?
0:07:23Like that--
0:07:24Yeah, because that would have been the other thing.
0:07:25If the same mistake had been made with an earlier award,
0:07:28it's also possible that the person reading it
0:07:31wouldn't have made the mistake of reading it.
0:07:33Because part of what made the series of unfortunate events
0:07:37that made this possible is that the name of the movie
0:07:43of the previous winner-- what happened
0:07:46is for anybody who isn't sure of the details of this,
0:07:48the second to last award was given for best actress,
0:07:50and it was Emma Stone in the movie "La La Land."
0:07:53And they keep two copies of these cards
0:07:55on both sides of the stage, and when they came out,
0:07:57when he was supposed to give them the last card of the night
0:08:00he gave Warren Beatty the second to last,
0:08:02which was the one that was just announced.
0:08:04So the second to last award was for Emma Stone "La La Land,"
0:08:07and he gave Warren Beatty a card
0:08:08that said the exact same thing.
0:08:10But it just so happened that "La La Land"
0:08:11was one of the nominees for best picture
0:08:13and was highly favored to win it, so it was no surprise.
0:08:17And so when Faye Dunaway looked at the card,
0:08:19it said Emma Stone, La La Land,
0:08:20and she just sort of like, well,
0:08:22I don't know why they put Emma Stone there,
0:08:24but I see La La Land, so I'll say La La Land,
0:08:26which was in hindsight a mistake,
0:08:30but it's kind of reasonable.
0:08:33- Yeah, it's not like the card said, I don't know, Zootopia.
0:08:38And you're like, yeah, that makes sense.
0:08:40If the same I gave the guy, the guy got the wrong card
0:08:44from the previous award, was halfway through the show,
0:08:47there's a good chance that none of the movies
0:08:50that are up for the current one
0:08:52were in the one that was previously announced.
0:08:56And then they'd be like, they'd have to say,
0:08:58maybe that would dawn on them,
0:09:00like holy heck, they gave me the wrong card.
0:09:03- Yeah, yeah.
0:09:04- So A, the whole procedure,
0:09:08This whole procedure of having two sets of cards seems like a massive mistake to me.
0:09:13Oh my gosh.
0:09:15So the way I understand it, and I may be totally wrong and things have changed since then,
0:09:20so if there's a listener out there who has inside info on the Academy Awards and wants
0:09:24to correct me if I'm wrong, go for it, but the way I understand it is this is leftover
0:09:29from an older tradition, pre, you know, I don't even know, maybe even pre-backstage
0:09:37handlers with the idea being that in order to make the show run smoothly and
0:09:42To make things interesting because it is after all a stage show and a show that is being produced for television
0:09:48People are going to come in from opposite sides of the stage
0:09:52But because there are you know as as time has gone on there are like big numbers and things have to change at the last minute
0:10:00a presenter may have been originally scheduled to come on from stage left and then
0:10:05abruptly needs to come on from stage right.
0:10:08And rather than having to send a runner in black
0:10:13like zipping around the back of the stage
0:10:15and maybe running into the best actress nominee or something
0:10:18and she's doing a costume change.
0:10:20- And also that would violate the idea,
0:10:22the rule that the only two people who have these envelopes
0:10:25before they're announced are the two representatives
0:10:27of Price Waterhouse.
0:10:29- Exactly, and that also takes away the secrecy.
0:10:31So the thought is, well, we'll just put
0:10:34one briefcase carrier stage left
0:10:36and one briefcase carrier stage right.
0:10:38They each have a copy of all of the awards,
0:10:41so no matter what happens, the presenter,
0:10:43no matter where they end up having to enter from,
0:10:46they will always be right next to the envelope necessary
0:10:50for their entrance, which is a lovely idea in theory.
0:10:53And you know, 80 some odd years until now worked okay.
0:10:59- Yeah, and even if you wanna stick with it,
0:11:03it's clear that the procedure should have been--
0:11:05that it should have been with a very strict double checking.
0:11:11If you're off stage on the other side,
0:11:14and so in other words, your colleague-- like let's say you and I
0:11:16are the two people giving out these awards.
0:11:18If it's your turn to give out best actress in a leading role,
0:11:22I'm going to have my copy of that exact envelope in my hand.
0:11:26And then I'm going to watch the presenters go out on stage--
0:11:30or I guess, who was it?
0:11:32Leo DiCaprio comes out on stage, reads it,
0:11:35and hands Emma Stone the Oscar,
0:11:38and then at that point I'm gonna take my copy of that card
0:11:41and put it in a different pocket, you know?
0:11:45Right?
0:11:46- Put it not in the hand that I'm about to give
0:11:49to the next presenter.
0:11:51- I'm going to systematically do that
0:11:54for each of the awards to at least,
0:11:58it doesn't quite make it impossible that I could do it,
0:12:00because you'd have to destroy it or something.
0:12:04And people want it for memorabilia and the like.
0:12:07But still.
0:12:08They had photos of the guy backstage, this poor fellow
0:12:12who is responsible for this.
0:12:14Taking a photo of Emma Stone moments before--
0:12:18He's goofing around on Twitter with his iPhone,
0:12:21taking pictures of Emma Stone.
0:12:23And then there's photos of him holding two envelopes.
0:12:27He's still got two envelopes in his hand.
0:12:29the best actress one that he should have put into a different pile, and presumably the best picture
0:12:36one that he needed to give to Warren Beatty in a minute, and he just gave him the wrong one,
0:12:40which is insane. But when you look at the envelopes, Andy, it's funny because the tweet
0:12:45that got sent around the world with the most popular tweet showing how hard the envelopes
0:12:52are to read was a freeze frame from his TiVo that Andy Anatko, friend of the show Andy Anatko,
0:12:58posted to Twitter and and yeah it's like a deep red envelope with very small
0:13:05be on gold no gold on burgundy which I think is worse it's oh that's right
0:13:10that's right yeah all right no it is much worse yeah let light text on dark
0:13:15paper in general is a bad idea when you're trying to read especially in
0:13:19bright lights on a stage and there's tons of people or backstage backstage
0:13:25where it's dark and everybody involved is 50 or older.
0:13:30And so I can vouch as a 40, almost 44 year old
0:13:36that yeah, reading in the dark is a real problem
0:13:39after the age of 40.
0:13:40And like small type, it's just incomprehensible
0:13:45that that would be the design,
0:13:48especially given the system, you know,
0:13:51that there are two sets.
0:13:53you would just think that designing to make sure that we always give the right envelope
0:13:57would be there.
0:13:58[Laughter]
0:13:59Maybe it's a little bit clearer on what this envelope is for. And again, I don't
0:14:03understand the need to write it in such tiny text. I mean, if you look at Andy's photo,
0:14:10it can't be bigger than 12 or 14 point font.
0:14:12No.
0:14:13And that and gold, like, and I understand the concept of, "Oh, well, we want to write
0:14:19best actress in a leading role versus best actress in a supporting role. But can't you write
0:14:24best actress or best picture in big honking like 36 point font? Maybe you know in in legible font?
0:14:35That's crazy. You've got it. You've got it. I mean, there's just no excuse for not doing it in
0:14:40dark textile, light background. I know. It's frustrating.
0:14:45And it just-- it's just so funny.
0:14:48Anyway, I had a couple of links this week
0:14:50to the critique of the design.
0:14:52And it's-- I think the other thing--
0:14:56the other angle is the psychology of it,
0:14:58which is that it totally makes sense to me
0:15:02that it didn't even occur to Warren Beatty or Faye Dunaway
0:15:07that we might be given the wrong envelope, right?
0:15:10No, of course not.
0:15:11The Oscars are always right.
0:15:13Like I think that if you're the guy from Price Waterhouse, I would be thinking,
0:15:17I really would, even if this was like my 20th year doing it and it feels familiar or whatever,
0:15:22I'm still thinking, "Oh my God, I cannot screw this up on every single envelope."
0:15:26This is the year. This is the year that terrible things will happen.
0:15:31Somebody said that it is literally, it could not be, there's never been a better example
0:15:38of that phrase, "You had one job." Right?
0:15:42(laughter)
0:15:43- Yup. Oh gosh. Yeah. I do feel kind of sorry for that poor guy.
0:15:50Just, you know, just, I wouldn't want to be the person to be like,
0:15:55"So, what did you do at your last job?" Well, I inadvertently screwed up the Oscars.
0:16:00- Right. Best picture.
0:16:02- Yeah. Oh boy.
0:16:07- All right, let me take a break
0:16:08before we get into the nerdy stuff.
0:16:09And thank our good friends at Squarespace.
0:16:13Next time you make a big move, you need a new website.
0:16:18Make your next move with Squarespace.
0:16:20You can get a beautiful website from Squarespace.
0:16:23Any type of website you need.
0:16:25You need a store, is that your idea?
0:16:26They have templates for stores.
0:16:28Is it a blog?
0:16:29They have templates for blogs.
0:16:31Podcasts, you wanna make a podcast?
0:16:32Guess what, Squarespace can help you with that.
0:16:36And even if you've just got the idea,
0:16:39you can start by getting your own domain name
0:16:44through Squarespace and get it held for you
0:16:46while you work on the idea.
0:16:49Everything you want to do with a website, from the domain name
0:16:52to the hosting to the analytics and stats
0:16:55as you see what people are doing and what they're
0:16:58doing at the website, all of it goes through squarespace.com.
0:17:02Everything you do is set up visually, drag and drop,
0:17:05click and drag, that sort of thing.
0:17:07If you want to-- and listeners to this show,
0:17:10it's very likely-- if you have the capability,
0:17:12if you know what you're doing, if you've
0:17:13got a bit of a web development nerd angle to your abilities,
0:17:17you could drop in and put custom JavaScript in.
0:17:20You can modify the CSS if you want to, stuff like that.
0:17:22So if you want to get nerdy and look at the code,
0:17:24you can do it.
0:17:25But if you don't, you don't have to.
0:17:26And it's really a very app-like experience of the way
0:17:30that you can just drag stuff around and have
0:17:32a professionally designed website.
0:17:35no matter what your skill level is technically.
0:17:39Where do you go to get a free trial?
0:17:40Go to squarespace.com.
0:17:42Just go there.
0:17:43You get a free trial.
0:17:43You don't even need a code or anything like that.
0:17:45The thing you want to remember is when you do sign up,
0:17:49remember this code, Gruber, my last name, G-R-U-B-E-R,
0:17:53and you'll save 10% off your first purchase.
0:17:57Squarespace, make your next move with Squarespace.
0:18:04I thought we'd start, did you see this thing where the Apple shareholder meeting was earlier
0:18:08this week?
0:18:09Yes, good old Apple shareholder meeting.
0:18:13We used to, when I worked at Macworld, we used to send somebody down there to just take
0:18:17notes and it was usually very boring and there was always one person who's like, "Let's
0:18:23divest all the company of all of X and Y."
0:18:27But this year it was a little bit different.
0:18:29This year's a little bit interesting.
0:18:30It's like the bylaws of a public corporation are such that a crackpot with one share of
0:18:35Apple stock can get the microphone if they so choose. I had no idea until this year.
0:18:42I've never been to it. It's never been something that I've thought that saw the need to cover
0:18:48firsthand. I had no idea that they held them at town hall. I thought it was some big thing where
0:18:59a thousand, you know, Apple diehards love to go, you know, like they buy a share and hold onto it
0:19:06forever just so that they can go, you know, like a Macworld keynote or something.
0:19:12Yeah. Oh, we can go and see the, yeah, I just don't think that that many people
0:19:16either realize what the annual shareholder meeting is, or they don't really think that,
0:19:24"Oh yeah, this is my chance to be within 10 feet of Tim Cook! This is gonna be great!"
0:19:30So it's really just like 100 people who show up.
0:19:31Yeah.
0:19:33It's because Town Hall is tiny.
0:19:34Yeah, there's really not a lot of space. And I do think, I can't remember how it goes,
0:19:40but I feel like there's some kind of priority system, but I may be wrong on that.
0:19:46Where you have to RSVP or something like that, and so...
0:19:50Yeah, yeah. So they actually have enough space.
0:19:54So the news that came out of it was somebody asked a question.
0:19:56This is from a report at 9to5Mac.
0:20:00It's not on video or anything like that, so who knows what the greater context is.
0:20:03But the news that came out was that Tim Cook said something
0:20:06about the pro area again.
0:20:09And I'll just read from 9to5Mac's story.
0:20:11And I will put it in the show note, I promise.
0:20:13Cook also hinted at Apple's product pipeline
0:20:15by promising Apple will, quote, "do more in the pro area," end quote.
0:20:21called out the creative field as especially important to Apple while pushing back against the notion that Apple is too consumer focused now.
0:20:27"Don't think
0:20:30that something we've done or something we're
0:20:33doing that isn't visible yet is a signal that our priorities are elsewhere."
0:20:39That's about as
0:20:43little as you can actually say
0:20:46Specifically like I don't expect him to reveal anything specific in a response to a shareholder
0:20:51The question but he literally didn't even mention whether the at least in the quote, I don't know, you know again
0:20:59It's the selective quotes from
0:21:01See who wrote this at nine to five Mac Zach Hall at nine to five Mac
0:21:05But at least from what he quoted it doesn't even mention whether has anything to do with the Mac or not
0:21:10Like yeah, because they have the iPad Pro which is obvious, you know
0:21:14I don't know if you could tell, but given the name,
0:21:16they consider a device for pro.
0:21:18For professionals, yeah.
0:21:22Well, I do think, though, I do think
0:21:24that in Apple marketing speak, pro doesn't necessarily
0:21:28mean professional user.
0:21:30It means something a little more nebulous.
0:21:33It's sort of more like what in other contexts
0:21:38would be like deluxe or premium,
0:21:42just nicer and more expensive,
0:21:45is sort of what they mean by pro.
0:21:47And the iPad Pro in particular exemplifies that
0:21:53in my opinion, because for example,
0:21:55the MacBook Pros definitely look different
0:21:57than the regular MacBooks.
0:21:58They're thicker and heavier.
0:22:00And in a way that's not as nice, right?
0:22:02Like if you just, in terms of like which one's nicer
0:22:04to carry around all day, a MacBook is better
0:22:06MacBook Pro because it's thinner and lighter. It's that trade off of we'll make it thicker so we can
0:22:12put, you know, more faster, faster, heavier components in there and a bigger battery and stuff
0:22:19is in a lot of ways leads towards literally professional use cases, whereas the iPad Pro
0:22:26versus the iPad Air, it's really just a nicer iPad. Yeah, well, but you could also argue the same
0:22:33the same concept, right? Where you have the 12.9 and the 9.7-inch iPad Pro, they're the only iPads
0:22:39that can use Apple Pencils, so that basically limits, like, creative professionals, if you
0:22:44want to use an iPad as a proper sketching tool, you know, the only thing to get is an Apple Pencil
0:22:50and an iPad Pro. Like, there's no, there's not even any point using a third-party stylus anymore,
0:22:55because it's just so much of a better experience on that. And the, you could argue that, again,
0:23:00the processing power on the 12.9 inch iPad Pro,
0:23:03the True Tone screen on the 9.7,
0:23:05like they are nicer features,
0:23:08but specifically for people who spend a lot of time
0:23:11staring at a tablet screen,
0:23:13a True Tone screen is going to be nicer for them,
0:23:15especially doing proofreading or typography correction
0:23:18or any of the above.
0:23:20It's gonna be a better workspace.
0:23:22- Yeah, there's overlap.
0:23:23There's clearly overlap between Apple's definition of Pro
0:23:26and actual lowercase P professional use cases.
0:23:30There's a lot of overlap in some cases, but it does it.
0:23:32It's not like a one-to-one mapping.
0:23:34- No, it's not the way that it used to be, right?
0:23:36Where when Apple said, "This is our pro computer,"
0:23:39what they really meant is,
0:23:40this is the computer that the top 2% of the market
0:23:43is going to buy for professional use cases.
0:23:47- So who knows what he means?
0:23:48We're gonna do more in a pro area.
0:23:50I mean, I'm not saying it's bad.
0:23:53I think it's better that he said something
0:23:55than that he said nothing in terms of,
0:23:58of, let's just say, the broader context of the concern
0:24:00that Apple is losing interest in high performance computing
0:24:07professional Mac uses.
0:24:10Yeah.
0:24:11Which is a--
0:24:11It's funny.
0:24:12--broad area.
0:24:13But I'm talking-- the areas I'm thinking about-- developers
0:24:16who have code that takes a long time to compile,
0:24:20video editors, graphics--
0:24:23people who do computer graphics and areas like that.
0:24:29Like researchers, like people who do AI research
0:24:32and have these huge data sets of--
0:24:36obviously, artificial intelligence,
0:24:39it's never not been an interest, but it's exploding
0:24:41in practical uses where it's really starting
0:24:43to become a consumer thing.
0:24:46There's all sorts of super high performance computing
0:24:50that people who are working on that need to do.
0:24:53And, you know, there's this, you know,
0:24:57the Mac Pro hasn't been updated in 1100 days, so.
0:25:00- Oh, it's, yeah, it is overdue by just a few years,
0:25:07just a, you know, just a while.
0:25:09I don't know, it's funny to me having transcribed
0:25:13many, many things that Tim Cook has said over the years,
0:25:17usually at financial calls,
0:25:19when he's, again, speaking off the cuff.
0:25:21And the sentence phrasing, it may not be an exact transcription, but the "don't think
0:25:27that something we've done or something that we're doing isn't visible yet is a signal
0:25:31that our priorities are elsewhere," that is very classic Tim Cook being like, "What
0:25:36do you mean we're not doing things for prose?"
0:25:41It's him being, at least from, again, my reading, it's him being slightly defensive and slightly
0:25:45confused as the, you know, why aren't you guys patient and just
0:25:50trust that we know what we're doing? Which, you know, you can
0:25:54be that way as the CEO of a major company. But like you say,
0:25:57John, the Mac Pro hasn't been updated in 1100 days. Like,
0:26:01there, it's not like people are throwing their hands up in the
0:26:04air and saying, Oh, pro users, you know, you guys were just
0:26:08catered to six months ago, you never, you know, don't worry
0:26:11about it. Like, there are some valid concerns in this space.
0:26:14It's sort of like the graph of how much anxiety it causes as the Mac Pro goes un-updated.
0:26:25I'm not going to say it's logarithmic, but it increases over time.
0:26:30It's not linear.
0:26:32As time goes on, it gets scarier and scarier because it seems all the more preposterous.
0:26:37So a couple of weeks ago, sometime somewhat recently, I linked to a story about a guy
0:26:48who works from a guy who works in the professional video industry.
0:26:52And it was just talking about how he expects he's going to have to switch from Mac Pros
0:26:56to Windows machines soon because he's dependent on these cutting edge.
0:27:04work he's doing needs GPUs and these NVIDIA boxes are coming out with all these
0:27:11CUDA boxes, yep, parallel GPUs and it really is so much of where Moore's law still applies
0:27:20is in the year-over-year improvements to GPUs and the parallelism and
0:27:25and you know it's just where performance computing is going and you know how about
0:27:32I don't know that anybody was really thinking that the Mac, even when the Mac Pro was brand
0:27:36new 1100 days ago, it wasn't like the world's fastest GPU. And now it's unchanged over 1100 days.
0:27:44So I got some pushback on that from people saying, "Hey, you just linked to this now." But that was
0:27:50from May. That was like May 2016. It's old news. And I actually didn't notice that. It was like,
0:27:55it's like one of the mistakes I make, I don't know, a couple of times a year during Fireball
0:28:00I'll link to something thinking it's new and my comment makes it seem as though it's new and
0:28:05It's not it's you know
0:28:08I don't know however many months or even a year out of date and
0:28:11It's just it's somehow I have a blind spot for double checking the date on a post because sometimes like what happens is I'll see somebody
0:28:17Linked to it on Twitter or something and the link on Twitter is under the guys that it's new so I click on it
0:28:23It's brand new yeah
0:28:24And you know in some templates and on a blog or something like that the date might not be prominent
0:28:31It might be at the bottom or something like that
0:28:33And I don't I just hate when I make that mistake, but in this particular case. I actually feel like the mistake
0:28:39I should you know it lends itself to your argument, right?
0:28:42I updated the post then to say that he wrote it in May of 2016 so that everybody everybody who subsequently read it would know it
0:28:49But the fact that the Mac hasn't been update Mac Pro hasn't been updated since then just makes his arguments all the more relevant
0:28:54of it.
0:28:55Absolutely.
0:28:56And, you know, he's not shouting in a vacuum.
0:28:59I have friends who work at visual design agencies, who actually a close friend of mine was really
0:29:06sort of wrestling with herself whether or not to get one of the new MacBook Pros this
0:29:10year to replace basically an aging 2009 era MacBook Pro, because she needs, you know,
0:29:19she needs the power and she wants she wants an updated portable workspace.
0:29:23But the MacBook Pro is essentially for her to buy it, she would be compromising on the
0:29:28kind of things that she would need for running Cinema 4D and the like.
0:29:33And it's really like, yes, video editors and graphics professionals are a niche audience,
0:29:39and certainly more niche for Apple than they were a decade or even two decades ago.
0:29:44But they're still, you know, that's still a segment that can move some product.
0:29:50Video professionals don't usually, especially big production houses,
0:29:55they're buying 20, 30, 40 computers for their workforce.
0:30:00And if those computers are all tricked out Mac Pros so that they can process
0:30:05footage, that's not a, yeah, it's a drop in the bucket compared to iPhone sales,
0:30:10but it's still a pretty hefty chunk of Mac sales.
0:30:15And for them to just be like, "Yeah, we're just gonna give up and hand this to Windows
0:30:19because we don't care enough about that market anymore, or that market isn't interesting
0:30:23enough to us anymore."
0:30:25And part of me as a former film person, it really kind of is like a stab in the gut because
0:30:32I don't, you know, like so many of my film friends and myself included, like, we don't
0:30:37enjoy Premiere.
0:30:38We don't enjoy, you know, working with Cinema 4D or Adobe's products.
0:30:43Like the whole, one of the whole excitements about getting into this industry was working
0:30:47with tools like Motion and Final Cut and Shake before it got discontinued.
0:30:53And for Apple to basically be like, "Yeah, this is not an interest to us anymore."
0:30:57Apple can do this, but they're essentially, you know, they're essentially telling people
0:31:02who've based their entire livelihoods on working on a Mac and building up a software platform
0:31:08on the Mac, "Eh, sorry, you're going to have to go learn another platform or go switch
0:31:13to another operating system because your, you know, our bottom line, it does no longer
0:31:19includes this segment of the population.
0:31:21I it would occurred to me in the wake of the cooks, you know, more or less stay tuned. Again,
0:31:32response to this question at the shareholders meeting is that Apple's culture of secrecy about
0:31:38products works fine when the company is functional.
0:31:44There are trade-offs.
0:31:46People have-- this is one of those evergreen topics
0:31:48about Apple is what if they were more open.
0:31:50And in the ways that in the Tim Cook era,
0:31:54they are a little bit more open in some areas.
0:31:57There are trade-offs between secrecy and openness
0:32:00in terms of maintaining a surprise,
0:32:02in terms of not over-promising, being able to over-promise
0:32:07and under-promise and over-deliver,
0:32:10as opposed to the other way around.
0:32:11For example, one of the things a lot of companies adhere to
0:32:15is not talking about release dates of products,
0:32:18because if you never talk about the release date of a product,
0:32:20it won't be late.
0:32:22Whereas if you do, and you're late, then you're late.
0:32:26So the trade-off-- their culture of secrecy
0:32:29has trade-offs when their product development
0:32:32is functional.
0:32:32And those trade-offs, I think Apple has long believed,
0:32:36work in the company's favor. But when they're not functional, the culture of secrecy just
0:32:43completely breaks down. I mean, and clearly the Mac Pro is a dysfunctional product at
0:32:48this point because they haven't, you know, like if they had canceled it a year ago, if
0:32:52they had just said at WWDC that, you know, you know, the time for these Mac Pro is done.
0:32:58And you know, the iMac is our is our pro desktop. Obviously, it would not have gone over well
0:33:05with a certain audience who wants higher, the highest performance they can get. But at least
0:33:11you couldn't say that it's dysfunctional. I mean, that's a rational decision and then people can
0:33:16plan accordingly. Well, and one year later we wouldn't be talking about it still. It just would
0:33:21have happened. Right. I just feel for me, the last year, like from WWDC through today, is the period
0:33:32were for me at least it's gone from the Mac Pro is overdue to the Mac Pro is ridiculous and the
0:33:39fact that Apple isn't is still selling it isn't saying anything is it I don't know if the company
0:33:46is in denial about it or if they're I don't know but it's a to me and again I don't I'm not saying
0:33:54they need to because need is is the wrong word but I they ought to if it's true that they're
0:34:00they're going to have some kind of event this month
0:34:03to announce--
0:34:04the rumors are rampant that they're
0:34:06going to have new iPad Pros.
0:34:07And we can talk about that in a moment.
0:34:09But new iPads, maybe updated iPhone SE, maybe red iPhone 7s,
0:34:18maybe even a new iMac, although there's not as much smoke
0:34:22to that fire.
0:34:24But on the other hand, IMAX often don't get the attention
0:34:29in the supply chain, the Asian supply chain rumor chain
0:34:34that iOS products do.
0:34:36So maybe it's just that.
0:34:37But I haven't heard anything about new Mac Pros.
0:34:40- No, aside from people complaining that they're not here.
0:34:44- Right, but I really think Apple ought to,
0:34:47and it wouldn't be comfortable,
0:34:49but I really think that Apple ought to somehow address
0:34:53that elephant in the room at the event, even if they have nothing to say.
0:34:56And, and I don't know exactly, because I don't know exactly what their plans are.
0:35:01I don't know, you know, but they really ought to say something more than, you
0:35:06know, they should let Mac Pro users know what, what, what the heck is going on.
0:35:11And acknowledge the fact that this is ridiculous.
0:35:14The thing that really frustrates me and I kind of forget about it until, uh, it
0:35:20gets brought up again is the fact that they're still currently selling the very, very out
0:35:25of date Mac Pro.
0:35:28And not at a discount either.
0:35:29It's just full price for a what, four and a half year old computer?
0:35:36Right.
0:35:37And that's another policy that has trade offs, but makes sense from Apple's perspective.
0:35:42This policy of that they don't cut product prices as the life goes on.
0:35:48So if they come out with a Mac book and it doesn't get updated for 15 months, in that
0:35:5414th month, when the old Mac books have only one month but they haven't been replaced yet,
0:35:59they still sell at the same price.
0:36:01Whereas Dell, you go to Dell, the laptops, it's like buying commodities.
0:36:07Every month they go up and down in price based on where the RAM market is and SSD components
0:36:13dropping.
0:36:14they come up with weird prices like you configure your Dell computer and it's $867 or something
0:36:19like that instead of $899.
0:36:22And weird sales too.
0:36:23Right.
0:36:24And Apple picks prices that are the price is part of the marketing where they have nice
0:36:28even you know it's $2499 and it's going to stay $2499 and part of the reason they don't
0:36:33drop it to $2299 14 months after it came out is so that when the next one comes out they
0:36:40can use the same price point.
0:36:41And so clearly that's what they're doing with the Mac Pro, is maintaining these price points
0:36:44so that when the replacements come out, it doesn't look like the prices went up by $2,000.
0:36:48Of course.
0:36:50But it only works when the product development is functional, and it comes out on a regular
0:36:54basis.
0:36:55You can sell an 11-month-old computer at the same price, and you're only asking for a small
0:37:03premium.
0:37:04You can do it on a...
0:37:05Let's say it's an 18-month development cycle.
0:37:07can do it at the 17th month and expect that informed consumers know, "Oh, this is not
0:37:14the time to buy a Mac Pro. It's 17 months old. There's probably a new one coming." But
0:37:18to do it with a three-year-old computer is embarrassing.
0:37:24It's insulting a little bit. And it's, like you said, because there's no new product and
0:37:31they're just parading the fact, you know, "The latest and greatest software." I forget
0:37:35a while back, someone posted to Twitter, you know,
0:37:38the Mac Pro with the latest and greatest software,
0:37:40including Aputure, something that's been sunset.
0:37:44- Right.
0:37:45Did they fix that?
0:37:46Is that still on the website?
0:37:47- I actually don't know.
0:37:49I wouldn't be surprised if it still was,
0:37:52because that's the problem, is that it just doesn't feel
0:37:54like the Mac Pro is a priority.
0:37:56And honestly, even if it was just, I don't know,
0:38:00I would much rather they pull the product off the market
0:38:04and say, "coming soon."
0:38:06And just, you know, you wanna make it nebulous,
0:38:09just say, we have, you know,
0:38:10do the nebulous Apple Store thing.
0:38:13We have something great in store for you.
0:38:15And then just leave it like that.
0:38:16And I'd rather be speculating about,
0:38:19oh, well they have something in the pipeline,
0:38:21and who knows if it'll come out in 2017 or 2019,
0:38:25but they still have something in the pipeline.
0:38:27Whereas right now, they're basically saying that
0:38:30by not discontinuing the Mac Pro,
0:38:33But every year that the old Mac Pro stays on sale,
0:38:38it's just, it's frustrating.
0:38:40And it's also, it's one of those things where,
0:38:43yeah, you can sell an 11-month-old computer,
0:38:45you can even sell an 18-month-old computer,
0:38:47but once you start selling a computer
0:38:50that's been on the market longer
0:38:51than it's covered by AppleCare,
0:38:54or that people would actively use it,
0:38:56that's when I start getting a little bit uncomfortable.
0:39:00- Yeah, and one of the weird things,
0:39:01When I published that piece, the recent piece about the video
0:39:04guy who's getting out of it, I got some amazing emails
0:39:07from some daring firewall readers, most of them
0:39:11in the video industry specifically,
0:39:13although one guy was like an AI researcher, which
0:39:15is where I got that idea earlier before,
0:39:16where his team was going to--
0:39:21I forget what exactly area they're working.
0:39:23But more or less, they just wanted
0:39:24to have massive amounts of computing to throw this at.
0:39:27And in years past, because they work on Mac OS X
0:39:31and prefer the Mac as a development environment,
0:39:34just would have gone to Apple and just bought
0:39:36gobs of Mac Pros and hooked them together
0:39:39for parallel processing, but instead built
0:39:41their own little network out of Linux boxes, which none of them
0:39:44had previous--
0:39:45the reason they would have rather gone with the Mac Pro
0:39:48is they know the Mac Pro.
0:39:49And they wouldn't have had to do a bunch of learning about Linux
0:39:54before they got to the AI work that they really wanted to do.
0:39:57They would have had to do more work upfront
0:40:00to learn how to even set it up.
0:40:01But then they said it was worth it
0:40:02because it was so much faster.
0:40:04And now we can just buy these boxes
0:40:05and just throw them at the thing.
0:40:07But I heard from a bunch of video pros
0:40:10in the movie industry, including somebody
0:40:12who was working on a super, I'm not gonna say the name
0:40:15'cause I just treat emails confidentially,
0:40:17but let's just say a movie with $150 million budget.
0:40:22That's an upcoming summer blockbuster.
0:40:26And that they're still doing editing for dailies on the 2012 Mac Pro.
0:40:34I think it's like the version number is like 5 comma 1.
0:40:37But the last cheese grater Mac Pros, they had like seven of them
0:40:44on location for editing dailies and stuff, which is ridiculous.
0:40:49That's unbelievable that not only is the Mac Pro as they're selling it,
0:40:55three years old, but that there are industry professionals
0:40:57where money is clearly not the problem,
0:41:00who just prefer to work on a five-year-old computer.
0:41:05And they said, and part of it with this movie is,
0:41:09we want to use what we're familiar with,
0:41:12but that the writing's on the wall
0:41:14and that the next big thing might be on Windows.
0:41:19- Yeah. - Which is heartbreaking.
0:41:21- It is, it's very frustrating.
0:41:24As I said, if you've spent 12 years learning your craft,
0:41:28and yes, if you're in the digital video industry,
0:41:31your craft is constantly changing
0:41:33and it's your job to keep abreast of all of those changes.
0:41:36But at the same time,
0:41:38if you put 12 years of work into mastering Final Cut Pro
0:41:42and you're an expert at Final Cut
0:41:43and you're an expert at the compressor
0:41:45and the various workflows,
0:41:47and then they're essentially like,
0:41:48"Yeah, well, but Apple's just given up on it,
0:41:51"so now we have to move away."
0:41:54I don't know if you ever did any graphics
0:41:57illustration, but I remember, you know, back
0:42:00when free, when Macromedia Freehand was a thing.
0:42:02Yeah.
0:42:02Um, back in the nineties, people, uh, like
0:42:06professionals and students clung to Freehand for
0:42:10God knows, like 10 years after it was discontinued.
0:42:14Yeah.
0:42:14Because they had their workflows and they had
0:42:17like the ability to work through it, like work
0:42:19in it, but, but unfortunately illustration,
0:42:21you know, 2d illustration is vastly different
0:42:24than 3D modeling.
0:42:25You have to be using latest and greatest software
0:42:28and hardware in order to be doing that
0:42:30and to have your stuff look like it belongs
0:42:33in a modern film.
0:42:34You can't get away with using, you know,
0:42:36or you can really only get away with using older equipment
0:42:39for so long before it just, it explodes in your face.
0:42:42- No, I remember those days.
0:42:43Well, I never did much illustration,
0:42:45but I, you know, I was more of a layout person.
0:42:47So I was, QuarkXPress was my jam, as they say.
0:42:51- Aw, page maker.
0:42:53But there was the--
0:42:54yeah, if you worked in graphic design and print,
0:42:57you needed a layout program, which is probably either Quark
0:43:01or PageMaker.
0:43:02I was on the Quark side.
0:43:03You needed an image editor, which is probably Photoshop.
0:43:07And you needed a vector illustration app.
0:43:10And that's the one where it was the hardest fought,
0:43:13where there was Freehand and Illustrator.
0:43:15And I always found--
0:43:16I didn't really do much illustration.
0:43:17Usually for me, it would be like editing something,
0:43:21or something as basic as like,
0:43:24let's make, we can't ship this font for some reason,
0:43:28so let's make a little graphic and convert to outlines
0:43:31so we don't have to ship the font.
0:43:33For some context where you couldn't send somebody,
0:43:35you really wanted to-- - The font.
0:43:37- Yeah, you really wanted to just send them just an EPS.
0:43:41I was always, freehand made sense to me,
0:43:45and I think people who like,
0:43:47even though they weren't from the same company,
0:43:49there's a, in my experience, a huge correlation
0:43:52between people who liked Quark Express
0:43:53and people who liked Freehand.
0:43:55That Quark and Freehand,
0:43:56even though they're from different companies,
0:43:58worked in people's brains the same way.
0:44:01And I know people who hung on to Freehand for,
0:44:03oh, you said, like so many years after the war was over.
0:44:07- Mm-hmm.
0:44:08Running it in Rosetta, way past the, yeah.
0:44:12God.
0:44:14Yeah, I think it was, what,
0:44:16did Mountain Lion get rid of Rosetta?
0:44:17- Yeah, I think so. - Or Lion?
0:44:19It was something along those lines where I had a colleague who literally used freehand
0:44:24up until the point that it could no longer be supported on their Mac, at which point
0:44:28they finally grudgingly switched Illustrator.
0:44:33So anyway, I don't know. I feel like this pro question is not going to go away, and
0:44:38at this point I feel like Tim Cook's say nothing answer is no longer... again, I'm not going
0:44:43to say it's not acceptable. It's not like anything bad is going to come of Apple if
0:44:46they keep pretending like this is normal. But I think it makes
0:44:50them look bad. And I just and I think that they I just based on
0:44:54my email anecdotally, they're they've passed the point where
0:44:57they're starting to lose customers.
0:44:59Yeah, I would agree with that. Well, it's, it's hit that point
0:45:04where their customers have to switch. They basically, you
0:45:08know, they have to fish or cut bait at this point. They can't
0:45:11just be waiting around in the water hoping that you know,
0:45:14Apple will deliver them a giant fish on a plate ready to run a
0:45:19CUDA system for their graphics needs and you know, a beautiful
0:45:24you know, the sad thing, the really sad thing is Final Cut
0:45:28Pro 10. A lot of people made a lot of fuss about it when it
0:45:31first switched over. And for good reason, you know, it was a
0:45:35fairly limited program. But the people on the software side for
0:45:39Final Cut have actually been doing some really fantastic and
0:45:42smart work and like the newest version of Final Cut, their latest update, which was
0:45:46released I think a couple months ago, is really like it's a dramatic, a dramatic improvement
0:45:52on on on that workflow. And so it hurts, it hurts my film editor soul a little bit, that
0:46:01Apple wouldn't give its users the technology to really take advantage of this software
0:46:08that they're developed, they're also developing in house. Like you're you're letting down
0:46:12your Final Cut Pro team by not giving people the kind of hardware they need to run it?
0:46:17I guess there's some small chance that in this supposed upcoming event in March that
0:46:24they might answer this. I don't think there's any chance that they're going to answer it
0:46:29by announcing a new Mac Pro, but maybe they'll have a new iMac that they'll say is, whether
0:46:36they call it the iMac Pro or just say that this is a professionally spec'd machine and
0:46:40give strong enough hints that yes, this is our answer.
0:46:43And maybe then take the Mac Pros off the market
0:46:46or lower them in price or hide them on apple.com.
0:46:50(Kelsey laughs)
0:46:51- Take away the aperture mention.
0:46:53- Right.
0:46:54- Yeah.
0:46:55- There's a chance.
0:46:56- Yeah, I mean, honestly, I could see that happening
0:46:59if Apple essentially just said,
0:47:01"Hey, we made a way for you to have
0:47:04"an external graphics card
0:47:06"and have it work properly on the Mac."
0:47:08I think that would actually, that would solve a lot of graphics professionals' problems.
0:47:14Because the main issue right now, and there are a couple of third-party boxes that'll do this,
0:47:20where you can plug an NVIDIA CUDA card and then try and run it off. But there's always going to
0:47:26be latency, right? Because it's not built to the same specs, and it's not built internally to Apple.
0:47:31But the question is really, does Apple care about that? Does Apple care about the small niche of
0:47:38users who are going to want a CUDA card when editing graphics.
0:47:43Yeah, I don't know what to say. We could talk about the other rumors
0:47:47about the upcoming event in a moment. The less depressing
0:47:51rumors. Yeah, it's the ones that'll make us happy. But in the meantime, I'm going
0:47:54to take a break here and thank our next sponsor. It's our good friends at
0:47:57Harry's. Harry's makes terrific shaving products.
0:48:03It was started by two guys, Jeff and Andy, who were fed up with being overcharged
0:48:06for razors. Literally, one day, one of them was in the drugstore buying replacement razor blades
0:48:13and had to wait for someone to come over and unlock the case because they're like frequently
0:48:18shoplifted items and then bought them and then realized that it's like it's a lot of money per
0:48:23blade for a product that's no fun to buy. So they came up with this idea, let's make our own blades,
0:48:28we'll sell them direct and we'll undercut the big name brands on prices. They literally bought
0:48:34their own factory, a hundred year old blade making factory in Germany. They make these blades,
0:48:41they sell them directly online, and they ship them to you for half the price of the leading
0:48:44brand. I did one of my favorite things. They've been sponsoring this show for years.
0:48:49When they first started sponsoring, they sent me a kit with a razor, and it had like a chrome
0:48:53handle. I had it for years, and then a couple months ago they came out with like a new, slightly
0:48:59updated version, and they sent me another one, and it has like a more of a rubbery handle, which I
0:49:03I actually kind of like because to me it's not slippery. But I looked at my
0:49:07Chrome one that was like three or four years old and it still looked brand new.
0:49:11It's absolutely crazy how well, like you couldn't tell which one was the new one
0:49:15and which one was the old one. Their product design is really, really great.
0:49:18Their packaging design is really, really great. I said this before, I'll say it
0:49:23again, I always feel bad when I like finish a pack of blades from Harry's
0:49:26because it doesn't look like the type of box you throw away. It looks like the
0:49:29type of box you keep but that's you know that's that way lights an appearance on
0:49:33the hoarders show so all right I do throw them away but it always there's
0:49:38always a pang of guilt that I'm throwing away such a nice nice box all this for
0:49:44$2 a blade more or less compared to the $4 or more you will pay at the drug
0:49:48store for a big name brand they are so confident in the quality of their blades
0:49:52that they want you to try their most popular trial set for free it comes with
0:49:57razor handle of your choice, five blade cartridge, and shaving gel. It's free when
0:50:02you sign up. You just pay a small fee for shipping. That's it.
0:50:06Redeem your free trial offer. Go to harrys.com/talkshow right now.
0:50:11Harrys, H-A-R-R-Y-S, dot com slash talk show. All right, does this, this rampant
0:50:22rumor that there's going to be three new iPad Pros, 9.7 that I guess is just a
0:50:27faster version of the 9.7 we have now 12.9 it's like a faster better version of the one we have
0:50:33right now and a 10.5 inch diagonal screen that goes edge to edge does this make any sense to you
0:50:40uh i want it to um i don't know i i can see how they've been staggering ipad updates over the last
0:50:5218 months where, you know, they started with the 12.9 and the Pro and put all of their latest and greatest new features into that.
0:51:00And then the next spring they had the 9.7 inch iPad Pro and they had almost all of the features from the 12.9 and some new stuff like True Tone and threw it into that.
0:51:11And I guess I could see them throwing a third option into the mix and saying, "Let's see if this sticks, let's see if this is better."
0:51:20But I just don't understand why they wouldn't update the line at once.
0:51:27Right, like if they're gonna ship a new edge-to-edge design that takes out the chin and forehead or greatly reduces them, why wouldn't you do it in two sizes?
0:51:37Mm-hmm. Exactly. Like, I understand why they launched the 12.9 and then launched the 9.7, because they were still working on trying to put the technology of the 12.9 and the screen into the 9.7.
0:51:48the 9.7. I get that part. But if you're going to launch a 10.5, like the smaller one is
0:51:55the harder one. So presumably, why wouldn't you launch the 10.5 and then also launch that
0:52:01version in the 12.9 and then keep the 9.7 as that's your new iPad Air version, basically.
0:52:10That's the old iPad Pro 9.7 is now just a regular old iPad Air. And these two, the 10.5
0:52:16whatever the 12.9 becomes, these are your, you know, really awesome iPads.
0:52:22Right.
0:52:22To just throw in like one in the middle, it's just, it feels kind of like taking a dartboard out and like being like, maybe they'll like this.
0:52:32The only way it makes any sense to me is if this, the new one with the edge to edge design is also a lot more expensive.
0:52:39Like, it's, I don't know, $1500 or something.
0:52:43You know so that you say oh I get it if I just want to pay what I'm used to paying for an iPad Pro
0:52:48I'll get the new 9.7
0:52:50Which would be you know, like a year better specs, but at the same prices as last year
0:52:55Maybe with more storage or something, you know, but it's typical year over year Apple upgrade of a product
0:53:01but if I'm
0:53:03If I want to spend a lot more money, I can get this one
0:53:08That's amazing because then it's an easy decision
0:53:10But if the price range if the prices are like comparable
0:53:14It doesn't make any sense to me that those products would exist alongside each other
0:53:17I can see switching to a new design
0:53:19But then they would take the old design and keep it unchanged and just lower the price. That's what Apple does
0:53:25Yep, it would be last year's model the I mean I could see them getting rid of the 12 9 2 and just being like
0:53:33Here's our you know
0:53:34Like what they did with the 17 inch MacBook Pro when they switch to the new design of MacBook Pro
0:53:39Where they're like, "Okay, this was a good thing,
0:53:42"like this was a nice idea,
0:53:44"but we wanna go with this design."
0:53:48But that doesn't seem to be happening,
0:53:50according to the rumors.
0:53:51The only other thing that I can think of is,
0:53:55yes, their goal is to eventually position the 9.7
0:53:59as the entry level, and then the 10.5
0:54:02is the first pro machine,
0:54:03and eventually they're going to make a version of the 12.9
0:54:07looks like the 10.5. Pause for dog barking.
0:54:10Sorry, one second.
0:54:15All in!
0:54:15That's all right. I just don't think he likes
0:54:17this iPad rumor.
0:54:17Enough! No. She's like iPads.
0:54:22She, she.
0:54:23Yeah.
0:54:23Sorry.
0:54:24That's okay. She has a, she has a very
0:54:26masculine bark, so I understand the confusion.
0:54:28Yeah, but my thought is, all right, so the only
0:54:35way I can see this making sense is if they've tried to make the 12 9 in this new configuration
0:54:42and either the battery life is not what they want or the heaviness is not what they want.
0:54:47Because if you look at the 12 9 right now, the 12 9 is still a pretty big compromise.
0:54:53Like I switched to the 9 7 almost instantly after it became available and I thought I would hate it
0:54:58because I'd gotten so used to the wide screen of the 12 9, but it was just so much lighter and
0:55:04and more portable even with an art,
0:55:06like with the Logitech Create case,
0:55:09that it just felt like the no brainer option,
0:55:12especially if I still wanted a Mac laptop around,
0:55:14which I need for some tasks.
0:55:18Whereas the 12 nine, you know,
0:55:20it's on the edge of three pounds.
0:55:22Yeah, I know all of it, it's pretty terrible.
0:55:25(laughs)
0:55:26It's not the best portable machine for people.
0:55:31So I could see Apple being like,
0:55:33Well, we don't want to sell it unless it's good,
0:55:37especially with Apple sales lagging.
0:55:39I don't know.
0:55:40There's something about this three iPad product thing
0:55:44that just doesn't make any sense to me.
0:55:46And I can't help but feel that there's a large chunk of it
0:55:51to come that will-- and then we'll say, oh, OK, now I see.
0:55:56It makes sense.
0:55:57Yeah.
0:55:58I'm trying to connect the dots here because I'm sure it exists.
0:56:01I'm sure, as you said, that if this is a real rumor,
0:56:05I'm sure that there's a way to connect it all.
0:56:10Olive is disagreeing with me.
0:56:11- Did you see, in terms of the way that people
0:56:19are doing work on iPads,
0:56:22there was a great thread on Twitter this week
0:56:24where a friend of the show,
0:56:27and I'm known to me more as like an illustrator, Louis Mantea,
0:56:32is working on a typeface design.
0:56:34Yes.
0:56:35And sent it to Jonathan Heffler of Heffler & Company fame on Twitter,
0:56:44and just said, hey, do you have any thoughts?
0:56:45And Jonathan Heffler took it and mocked up--
0:56:50it was a PDF of the whole alphabet that he had drawn--
0:56:53and mark this up with all of these little notes
0:56:57about places where maybe the curves could be different
0:57:00and the radii could be different and letters,
0:57:03like here, take this, you did a great thing here
0:57:05with the lowercase d, but you should do the same thing
0:57:08with the lowercase b, and I'll put links in the show notes.
0:57:12I've got 'em here in the notes already.
0:57:14But I looked at, and as a type nerd,
0:57:17it was super fascinating to see this feedback.
0:57:20And it all made sense to me, and I was like,
0:57:21wow, I can see how that would be better.
0:57:24But then I instantly thought,
0:57:26I wanna know how he did this marking up.
0:57:30And so I asked and it was,
0:57:32it was with an Apple Pencil.
0:57:37In an app called Notability,
0:57:41which I have heard of for the iPad,
0:57:43but it's a PDF, you can import PDFs
0:57:47and then you can draw right on top of them.
0:57:49And it seems like it's really,
0:57:50it's been around for a while,
0:57:50It seems like it's really embraced the pencil.
0:57:52And Heffler said to me that with the 12--
0:57:58here's what his tweet-- with the 12.9 inch iPad and the Apple
0:58:02Pencil and Notability, they moved all of their proofing
0:58:06workflow from paper to screens in the last year.
0:58:10And they're saving 36,000 pages of printed paper a year.
0:58:16And I found that fascinating.
0:58:18And I can totally see.
0:58:19And to me, it's just been an idea.
0:58:22I mean, everybody talks about it, but this whole idea of iPads for work
0:58:26and what's the future of work computing.
0:58:29And that to me, it largely comes down to form factors.
0:58:34And that iPads and iOS have--
0:58:37it's not so much that they're replacing traditional notebooks and Macs,
0:58:42but that they're good for work in areas that Macs never were.
0:58:48I don't think it ever even occurred to Jonathan Heffler to do to to do their their proofing
0:58:55on a Mac before Apple pencil.
0:59:00You could you could take if you had a Cintiq tablet or even on an Intuos from Wacom, you
0:59:06could absolutely hook it up to your Mac and write on the typeface or write on the PDF.
0:59:12But it it's just such a it was a clunkier experience.
0:59:14Cintiq was definitely not a, you know, it's not a portable machine, you're still kind of stuck at
0:59:19your desktop. And I think he would have found it he would have found it unpleasant compared to his
0:59:22existing workflow of just printing 36,000 sheets of paper a year, marking them up with an actual,
0:59:27you know, red pen. Well, the fun thing about critique, right, is that you actually get a
0:59:33chance to step away from your desk. It's I remember back when we were putting together ebooks for Mac
0:59:38World, one of my favorite things was to get our proof, and then to make the final edits to go like
0:59:44sit up on our on the terrace at our at our old space and just,
0:59:47you know, grab a can of coke and my proofs and go through them
0:59:51with an old school red pen. And yeah, I could have like I could
0:59:54have done those on an iPad, probably an iPad Air originally
0:59:58but at the time when we were when we were doing that, but it
1:00:02just wasn't as tactilely sense like satisfying, you couldn't
1:00:06really write with the styluses that were available at that
1:00:09point. And the iPad Air screen just wasn't good enough. Whereas
1:00:14you take the iPad Pro, you take the Retina display
1:00:18combined with the True Tone display,
1:00:19so it's actually easier to work in all spaces.
1:00:23And then the Pencil, which in the right app,
1:00:26feels like writing with pen.
1:00:28It may not have the tactile sensation on the glass,
1:00:31but you're still getting the right approximation
1:00:34of what you wanna draw and how you wanna draw it,
1:00:37and that's really, really important
1:00:39for doing things like that.
1:00:40But it is fascinating to me.
1:00:43I don't know if you saw it, I was doing this iPad Pros experiment where I essentially put
1:00:49a call out on Twitter and via iMore just being like, "Hey, I really want to know what everybody's
1:00:57using their iPad Pro for when it comes to work.
1:01:00Just send me an email, give me the gist of what you're doing, and if it's cool, I'll
1:01:06shoot you an email and we'll do some interviews."
1:01:09And the amount of responses that I got in 24 hours really kind of blew me away.
1:01:16And it wasn't just like, here are the three industries where the iPad Pro is being used.
1:01:21It was across the board, like all kinds of crazy things.
1:01:24Like we, I had a, there's a large number of people in IT who use the iPad for, you know,
1:01:31running around on the go because it's easier to carry with them than like a little Chromebook.
1:01:37The one of the cooler ones that I found out about is there's someone who's getting their
1:01:41PhD at Harvard in ancient writing who uses the iPad to help recreate and scan and analyze
1:01:50this ancient pre-Roman handwriting.
1:01:57There's Kyle Lambert, of course, who drew the poster for Stranger Things almost entirely
1:02:01on his iPad, the one that Netflix used.
1:02:06And that's like that's the traditional thing you think of is like Hoeffler, you know, doing
1:02:11annotation with the pencil or drawing with the pencil.
1:02:15But there are so many other industries and weird use cases that I just don't think people
1:02:21really realize are being filled by the iPad in, like you said, in environments where it
1:02:28just either didn't make sense to have a Mac or a computer or something where maybe a Mac
1:02:33or a computer was filling this gap, but not as well as it could have been.
1:02:37Right. I also think, and there's obviously some legacy aspects to PDFs, and 8.5 by 11 paper,
1:02:44or for our friends on the other side of the pond, A4 dimension paper. And so there's some legacy
1:02:51aspects to that, where if you're in an industry like the law or something like that, where things
1:02:56get published and there are—if you don't deal with it on paper, you are dealing it with a PDF
1:03:02that assumes that it's printed on 8.5 by 11 paper,
1:03:06where the 9.7 inch iPad screen is a little too small.
1:03:09It's readable, but it's just shrunk down enough that it's--
1:03:16there's a reason why that's not the size of the paper we use.
1:03:20For sure.
1:03:20Whereas on the 12.9 it is.
1:03:22But then there's other areas.
1:03:26It's just nicer artistically to have a bigger canvas.
1:03:31And like I think with Heffler, you know, like I don't think there was any reason that they had to stick
1:03:35You know
1:03:35I think he went with the 12.9 not because it was a legacy process if they moved
1:03:39Their whole workflow from from paper to screens they could abandon
1:03:43The size I just think that
1:03:46It's just better to look at him bigger and to be able to zoom up and to have a bigger canvas. Oh
1:03:50Yeah, yeah. No, it's it's one of those things where if I was doing illustration on a regular basis
1:03:59I think the 12.9 would be my daily carry without question because it really is there's something
1:04:06Really wonderful being able to work at that larger screen size, especially when you're sketching
1:04:11I don't know if you've ever taken like a life drawing class or anything where
1:04:15You're being asked to make like big giant strokes with your pencil and taking your entire arm into the process
1:04:23Not just like sketching with your wrist
1:04:25That kind of those kind of big movements
1:04:28traditionally in an illustration class,
1:04:31you really can only get by working on big canvas paper.
1:04:35'Cause if you work on an eight and a half by 11,
1:04:36you're just gonna strike the thing off of the screen.
1:04:40But the 12.9 inch iPad is one of the first
1:04:42where I actually felt like you could do
1:04:45life drawing sketches on it and not feel like
1:04:48you were drawing essentially on a Post-it note.
1:04:51- I feel like we as, there's a part of us, anybody,
1:04:57whether you like Apple stuff or you don't.
1:05:00But where you feel like it's,
1:05:03there seems like there's a rational part of your brain
1:05:07that sees owning an iPad and a MacBook
1:05:10or just a tablet and a notebook,
1:05:14if you have other operating systems, as wasteful,
1:05:17that you've got two things that are basically the same size,
1:05:2210 to 15 inches, and the same thing,
1:05:25computer with an LCD screen in some way to set up a keyboard and maybe touch etc.
1:05:32You just feel like well there should only be one and so that there's a
1:05:35logical argument to the surface book movement right but I can't I've been
1:05:42thinking about this a lot lady I just you know I think it really just depends
1:05:48on the type of work that you do and oh yeah that there are certain tasks and
1:05:54and it's certainly the ones that computers got good, personal computers got good at first in the last few decades,
1:06:00that basically involve you sitting down at a table or a desk with your palms flat on a keyboard that's flat
1:06:10with some sort of pointing device, a mouse or a trackpad right next to it
1:06:16that you use to deal with the screen that is more or less horizontal in front of you.
1:06:22There's a whole bunch of tasks where that form factor is terrific.
1:06:26And if that's the type of work you do, like let's just say you get you have a job where you have
1:06:32just lots of emails that you have to answer every day, so you're typing a lot, not just reading.
1:06:37It's a terrific form factor. And you can see why,
1:06:40like with the new MacBooks and MacBook Pros, where the displays have gotten
1:06:48ever thinner than before, so thin that they can't even light up the Apple anymore.
1:06:52The hinge is so great. It is so much easier to set up a MacBook at a desk in front of you, like in a coffee shop, than to set up an iPad with a keyboard.
1:07:06For sure.
1:07:07And again, what are we talking about? Ten seconds? Is it five, ten seconds to just do the little foldy thing with your keyboard and get it in?
1:07:15It's not long, but it adds up, right?
1:07:17It does.
1:07:18The little things it's just not optimized for it if that's your main point of work and then when you close it
1:07:23It's even more work, right? And
1:07:25Because you have to unfold all of that, right?
1:07:28And I'm not denying that for some people that that there's tons of people who just love writing on their iPads and that's a trade-off
1:07:34They're willing to accept but you I don't see how anybody could deny that an iPad setup in
1:07:39laptop configuration no matter which brand keyboard you're using is
1:07:44Like it's backwards. It's top-heavy
1:07:47The screen is the heavy part with the battery and the keyboard is the light part. Whereas a MacBook is
1:07:54Oriented the right way where there's a heavy base and a super light screen
1:07:59Mm-hmm
1:08:01And I just think more and more but it's just taking a long time to find it. We're finding these other
1:08:06Contexts whether it's the actual task you want to do like illustration like if you actually want to do, you know, you're drawing
1:08:14something on a screen to mark it up. Or if it's just about where you are, that you're not at a
1:08:20desk, you know, like you said, like these sysadmins who are walking around and maybe want to be doing
1:08:25stuff on screen while they're standing, where an iPad is better and has nothing to do with iOS.
1:08:32I guess I think we've all collectively spent too much time worrying about the differences between
1:08:36iOS and macOS, not that they don't matter, but that a large part of it is just the human form
1:08:41factor of where you are? Are you standing? Are you sitting? Are you actually typing?
1:08:46That matter more.
1:08:47Absolutely. Well, I think about, just going back to illustration, I think about how many
1:08:53different sketchbooks I had in college, right? And granted, a sketchbook is a little bit
1:08:58cheaper than a full-size computer. But still, you know, I was spending quite a lot of money
1:09:03on six, seven, eight different sizes of paper because, you know, in some cases a notebook
1:09:12is going to make sense.
1:09:13In other cases a Post-it is going to make sense.
1:09:15In other cases a, you know, 36 inch canvas is going to make sense.
1:09:20It's all about finding the right tool and the right product that works for you.
1:09:27And in the case of the iPad and everything that goes around it, what's really important
1:09:36is how those things all fit together, right?
1:09:38If I'm going to use my iPad, actually, one of the reasons I got my very first iPad back
1:09:44in 2010 was yes, I wanted to sketch with it and I was really excited about that.
1:09:49the time I was doing a job in a online t-shirt manufacturing company and I was indexing what
1:10:00t-shirts we had in stock.
1:10:03Before the iPad, that meant manually going down all of the aisles of the t-shirts with
1:10:09a tiny little out-of-date Windows laptop on a cart where you'd just be pulling it over
1:10:15this factory floor.
1:10:17we went box by box to count how many sizes of smalls, how many sizes of mediums, how
1:10:23many sizes of large. And once we got the iPad, we could very easily enter that into our online
1:10:29inventory just by carrying the iPad around and selecting, you know, "Okay, this has
1:10:35three smalls, great." And we no longer had to use the little cart or the heavy laptop
1:10:41or worry about knocking it over to the ground, which happened, I think, on multiple occasions.
1:10:45Right, so like in things in broad strokes the notebook computer
1:10:50You know the traditional one like that doesn't have a detachable screen that turns into a tablet halfway
1:10:56You know does tries to do both is duplicating the form factor of the typewriter and of the adding machine and of other
1:11:03Things that people have done at desks for a long long time way before their computers
1:11:07So the iPad in some ways it like in your story there is duplicating a clipboard
1:11:12Which again is a long-standing form factor for getting work done.
1:11:17It's just a different kind of work.
1:11:20But it's largely based on the context of where you are, and it's not so much just purely an argument,
1:11:27or even less really purely an argument about operating systems.
1:11:30Yeah. The operating system could be, you know, going back to Steve Jobs' original comment about the iPad,
1:11:37It's a blank slate.
1:11:39All the operating system really needs to do
1:11:41is get out of the way so that you can do your work.
1:11:44Whether or not that operating system
1:11:46lets you run one app at a time or 20 apps at a time,
1:11:50well, the real question should be,
1:11:52is this easier to do my work on than the thing I had before?
1:11:57And if the answer is yes, then you get it.
1:12:01Then it becomes part of your workflow.
1:12:02I mean, obviously, assuming you have the money
1:12:04and all of that, but that's how it fits in.
1:12:07I carry a 9.7 inch iPad Pro and a MacBook Pro,
1:12:12not because, oh, I wanna duplicate the writing functionality
1:12:15on both and oh, that's gonna be so clunky, blah, blah, blah.
1:12:19I carry it on the iPad Pro because there are times
1:12:22when I wanna sketch something out
1:12:23or there are times that I wanna write freehand.
1:12:25And the iPad Pro has essentially replaced my old school,
1:12:28like big Moleskine sketchbook that I used to carry around
1:12:31with my MacBook Pro.
1:12:33I guess I could do that as a convertible tablet
1:12:37if I really wanted to, but that kill,
1:12:39then we get into battery life talks.
1:12:42That's honestly my big thing about multiple
1:12:45convertible devices.
1:12:47If I want to sketch, I'm probably gonna want to sketch
1:12:51for like six, seven hours or have that ability
1:12:56to just kind of pull this iPad out whenever
1:12:58and just sketch on it.
1:13:00Whereas my laptop is the big,
1:13:02that's the thing that you carry around
1:13:04to do your powerhouse work on when you're not at your desk.
1:13:07And if you have a convertible where it's like,
1:13:10oh, well, you turn it into tablet mode,
1:13:12and then you kill most of your battery sketching
1:13:15on the train, for instance,
1:13:16and then you actually get to a point
1:13:18where you wanna use it to do normal work,
1:13:21then you have 5% battery and you have to plug in,
1:13:23at which point it's a desk computer again.
1:13:26- Did you see the, there's a new Windows 10,
1:13:31I forget what they call these things,
1:13:33the dual systems, what do they call them?
1:13:35- The what, convertible laptops?
1:13:37- Convertible, yeah, yeah.
1:13:37So a new one from Porsche Design,
1:13:39which was, it's not out yet,
1:13:43but it was announced at the mobile web conference.
1:13:46- At MWC? - MWC.
1:13:48Which, and it looks nice.
1:13:49It does, I'd like to see one.
1:13:52But,
1:13:53even though it looks nice,
1:13:57and I think the hinge looks much nicer
1:13:59than Microsoft's Surface hinge,
1:14:01which doesn't, you know, like the, it doesn't--
1:14:04- The little, it looks like it belongs
1:14:06in an alien movie or something.
1:14:08- Yeah, and it means that the two pieces don't sit flat.
1:14:11There's like a gap between them.
1:14:13They only, I don't know, that would bother me a little bit.
1:14:17But with the Porsche Design 1, you can see though
1:14:20that both halves of the, when it's in laptop mode,
1:14:23both halves are about the same thickness.
1:14:25The base is about as thick as the display.
1:14:28So it's a really thick tablet.
1:14:30as compared to an iPad.
1:14:33Like to me, that design, and it's never
1:14:38going to be the best laptop design
1:14:40and never going to be the best tablet design.
1:14:43But maybe if they're right and I'm wrong,
1:14:45maybe optimizing for the middle is a good idea.
1:14:52But I can't help but think, though,
1:14:53that I would always much rather have an ideal laptop
1:14:57design, or an ideal tablet design that can be put into a laptop that's maybe not as
1:15:04nice when in laptop mode as the dual design.
1:15:09But at least when I'm using it in one way, it's as good as it can be.
1:15:12Yeah, I would rather carry two devices and have each device be the best it possibly can
1:15:19be at that specific task than try and carry something that does all of those things.
1:15:25I don't need a Swiss Army knife for my electronics.
1:15:28I need smart, you know, dedicated electronics.
1:15:32- Right, and there's just some weird context switching
1:15:35that I don't think I would ever get used to there
1:15:36where you're using a lower powered processor
1:15:40when you're in tablet mode.
1:15:42And like one of the big trade-offs with tablet mode
1:15:45is this Porsche design thing is only advertised
1:15:47as getting three hours of battery life when separated.
1:15:51- Oh yeah, well it's the same problem
1:15:53with the Surface Book as well,
1:15:54where it just doesn't have,
1:15:56the tablet does not have great battery life at all.
1:15:59- Right.
1:16:00It's just so many trade-offs involved.
1:16:02It's so middling product both ways.
1:16:04- Yeah.
1:16:05- I do see them.
1:16:07I mean, and part of this, just a friend made the,
1:16:12I mean, you know, it's one anecdote,
1:16:13but it meshes sort of what I see.
1:16:16But a friend was in a coffee shop recently
1:16:18and counted like, you know, a lot of people doing work.
1:16:24or seemingly doing work.
1:16:25And it was like nine MacBooks of various ages,
1:16:30like one regular Windows notebook and two Surface books.
1:16:37And no iPads, nobody using an iPad at all.
1:16:41And so I can see why some people buy them.
1:16:48And I think that--
1:16:49and who knows what these people are doing.
1:16:51But if it's a university students or something like that,
1:16:53probably a lot of writing. It's like I said, I think if you're doing a lot of writing,
1:16:56it makes sense to be doing it on a MacBook. And that, you know, Macs are more popular for that
1:17:01sort of thing. But I don't know, I can see why Apple isn't going that way.
1:17:06Yeah. And I don't think Apple would go that way unless they found the perfect way to blend it,
1:17:14right? You know, we didn't get the iPhone before it was ready, just because they wanted to cram,
1:17:20well, unless you count the Motorola Rocker, you don't really we didn't get a product that was like,
1:17:26let's turn the iPod and the mobile phone and a breakthrough internet communications device into
1:17:32one thing and have it be half-assed and not great. Like if they're going to do it, they're going to
1:17:37do it well. Otherwise, they're just not going to do it. It's going to sit in some development lab
1:17:41somewhere and never exist. Right. But it just doesn't make sense to me for either device,
1:17:46you know, not that it doesn't make sense. I see why they came to that middling, just, you know,
1:17:51well, we've got a little bit of battery in this top part that you can take off, but most of the
1:17:54batteries in the base and stuff like that. It makes more sense to me to do it the iPad way,
1:18:00where the iPad is the computer and the keyboard is just a dumb keyboard.
1:18:04The keyboard is easy and low power and just works when it needs to work and doesn't work
1:18:10when it doesn't. I feel like there's some kind of win that Apple and/or a third party, but probably
1:18:17Apple because I think it would require something even better, a better smart connector on the iPad.
1:18:22But I feel like there's gotta be some way to make the hinge better, you know, and just make the
1:18:28take it from here it is closed coming out of my backpack to set up in front of me on this
1:18:37table as a laptop, it's got to be a way to make that better, I think.
1:18:40Yeah. The Logitech Create is pretty good, except for the part where it's only one position.
1:18:46And if it was like, if the Logitech Create, if they could find a way to build a smart connector
1:18:51that hinged, and didn't immediately disconnect when you moved a lot moved it like a little bit
1:18:56backwards or a little bit forwards, like they found a way to make a Logitech Create that had
1:19:00a hinged backing, but still connected via the smart connector, that would be the that would be
1:19:06be the ultimate convertible if you really wanted a convertible tablet.
1:19:10Like if you didn't need a laptop to do hardcore writing or multitasking on and
1:19:14you just wanted to switch to iPad, like that's what you'd want.
1:19:17Cause that to me is a perfect example of one of the ways that I,
1:19:21which is why I've for me, for me, obviously, I mean, I'm, you know,
1:19:24when I'm other than the podcast, uh, my work is writing.
1:19:29Uh, and so for me, I, for what I do is work and you know, ignoring email,
1:19:35but if I decide not to ignore my email,
1:19:37I'm writing there too.
1:19:38The laptop form factor is so much more conducive to my,
1:19:45it's so much nicer for me for my work.
1:19:47I'm not denying that it's the other way around
1:19:49for other people, but it is.
1:19:50But one of those things that's so nice,
1:19:51especially if I'm away, not at my regular desk
1:19:54where everything is already set up just so,
1:19:56is that I can adjust the screen infinitely, right?
1:20:00And so if there's a weird light that's giving me a glare
1:20:03or whatever, or I'm sitting with a different posture,
1:20:06or it's a weird height table or chair,
1:20:09you could just sit there and twist it,
1:20:11and get it perfect.
1:20:13And with most iPad solutions, you can't.
1:20:15- No, not unless you wanna keep it flat on the table
1:20:19and work on the virtual keyboard, which sounds terrible.
1:20:23- Well, and again, though, there's no configuration there.
1:20:25Flat on the table is flat on the table.
1:20:27- Yeah, well, I mean, you do flat on the table
1:20:28and then you have an adjustable stand.
1:20:30Like I'm using an adjustable stand right now
1:20:32from Elevation Lab, I think, like a drafting stand that
1:20:35adjusts multiple levels.
1:20:37But that's still not a great configuration,
1:20:39because then you have to fiddle, and it's not
1:20:42as easy as the laptop just like, bam, open, done.
1:20:45Ready to write.
1:20:47So anyway, that's my rant on form factors.
1:20:49All right, let me take a break here
1:20:51and thank our third sponsor, our good friends.
1:20:53What a great company.
1:20:54I love these guys.
1:20:55Backblaze.
1:20:56Backblaze offers unlimited native backup
1:20:59for the Mac and for PC.
1:21:02No credit card required to get started.
1:21:04You get a no risk free 15 day trial
1:21:06at backblaze.com/daringfireball.
1:21:09You just go there, download the software,
1:21:11put it on your Mac.
1:21:13Don't even have to put a credit card in.
1:21:14And just let it start running.
1:21:16And what it'll do is it'll back up everything
1:21:19on your computer to their cloud-based storage.
1:21:22Everything.
1:21:23There's no limit.
1:21:24They don't charge like by the terabyte.
1:21:25Well, you get one terabyte for this and more.
1:21:28No, everything on your Mac, $5 per computer per month.
1:21:33That's it.
1:21:34And you get it unlimited, unthrottled, off-site backup.
1:21:37You have 15 days to try it out, see for yourself.
1:21:39And when it's over, you're going to say, well, this is crazy.
1:21:41This is a great deal.
1:21:42Of course I'm going to pay for it,
1:21:43because now everything I have is backed up.
1:21:46And you'll have the peace of mind
1:21:48of knowing that you have a backup that is not at your desk
1:21:52where any sort of catastrophe that happens in your house
1:21:55could wreck your data.
1:21:57You have water damage, roof leaks, something like that.
1:22:01Ruins your computer, ruins your backup drive.
1:22:03Now your backup isn't worthwhile.
1:22:06What if somebody comes in and steals your stuff?
1:22:08Well, that's terrible.
1:22:09Hope it doesn't happen to you.
1:22:10But if you have an offsite backup,
1:22:12you've got that extra protection.
1:22:14There's no gimmicks, no additional charges.
1:22:17It's just five bucks per computer per month
1:22:20for unlimited, unthrottled, offsite backup.
1:22:23I have used it personally for years.
1:22:24I would recommend it.
1:22:25I would recommend it regardless if they were a sponsor, but they are a sponsor.
1:22:30Here's where you go. backblaze.com/daringfireball
1:22:35and you get a 15-day free trial.
1:22:40Only other thing I had in my notes for the show, well, maybe talk about Uber later a little, but
1:22:46there was a story this week in the Wall Street Journal that came out that got a lot of publicity where
1:22:51City where they wasn't 100% clearly written,
1:22:57but the way it was written could best be interpreted
1:23:01that this year's iPhone, the fancy rumored new iPhone
1:23:09with the curved OLED screen, was going
1:23:12to switch from the lightning adapter to a USB-C port.
1:23:16Not another cable switch?
1:23:18Oh, no.
1:23:19They said Apple-- this is from the story
1:23:21by Takashi Mochizuki for the Wall Street Journal.
1:23:29This is their sources familiar with their plans.
1:23:31They said Apple would introduce other updates, including
1:23:34a USB-C port for the power cord and other peripheral devices,
1:23:37instead of the company's original lightning connector.
1:23:41These models would also do away with the physical home button,
1:23:44they said.
1:23:44These updates would give the iPhone features already
1:23:47available on other smartphones.
1:23:51I would just say with that last sentence that no other smartphone has a lightning connector,
1:23:56so if they kept the lightning connector, they'd have a feature that's not available on other
1:24:00smartphones.
1:24:03This seemed weird to me, and my guess—and again, nobody told me a damn thing.
1:24:08I don't have any little birdies.
1:24:09But my guess is if there's some kind of supply chain thing that this reporter got,
1:24:14it's that they're going to switch to it. I think the iPad Pro works like this already, where
1:24:20it's a USB-C power brick, and you plug USB-C into the power brick, and then it goes to
1:24:26Lightning on the other end for plugging into the device. Yep, and you get what, 29 watts and
1:24:34supercharged. Right, now I don't know if the iPhone's going to ship with the 29 watt charger.
1:24:38Probably not.
1:24:39Probably not.
1:24:40But it could ship with a higher wattage charger
1:24:44that charges more quickly.
1:24:48And does USB 3.0 data speeds, if you need that.
1:24:52Although I kind of feel like data speeds over anything
1:24:56other than the network are sort of--
1:24:59but there's some professional contexts,
1:25:01like for video or film and photography and stuff
1:25:04like that, where you might want to--
1:25:07that extra speed could be useful in an iPhone.
1:25:09I don't know.
1:25:10But the charging speed is the big one.
1:25:14If you can charge faster, that's better.
1:25:17- Charging faster is better.
1:25:19The other reason why it would be good for photographers,
1:25:24especially now that Apple has allowed you
1:25:27to use the USB connector with the iPhone with photos,
1:25:32you can offload your raw images direct
1:25:36to your 128 gig iPhone,
1:25:39rather than having to carry around an iPad Pro
1:25:42if you wanna do some just quick proofing
1:25:46or if you wanna post something to social media
1:25:48very quickly while you're in the midst of something.
1:25:51- Like a live Apple event or something like that.
1:25:53- Yeah, exactly.
1:25:54- Yeah, but it just did not ring true to me
1:26:01'cause I do not think Apple,
1:26:03I just don't think they're ever gonna ship iOS devices
1:26:06with USB-C ports.
1:26:07I know they could.
1:26:08I know there's some people who are sort of hoping
1:26:10that they do because it would simplify the universe
1:26:14in some ways, like where everybody's phone,
1:26:17everybody's phone bought within the last X months or years
1:26:21can now use the same chargers.
1:26:22But I don't think it makes sense from Apple's perspective.
1:26:27And there are plenty of, like the sort of people
1:26:30who are wishing for that are enlarged,
1:26:35I think largely sort of the nerdy type people
1:26:38who have, you know, Android and iOS devices around the house.
1:26:43And I think there's untold tens of millions of people
1:26:47who just already have an iPhone,
1:26:49and other people who they live in the house have iPhones,
1:26:53and when they buy a new iPhone, it would be nice
1:26:55if they could just keep using the same lightning ports
1:26:58that are already around the house.
1:27:00Yep. I don't want to have to switch my port.
1:27:03Right. And from those people's perspectives, the switch from 30-pin to lightning just happened.
1:27:08Yes, exactly. Despite it being, what, four years ago?
1:27:11It was months—it was just a few weeks ago, sorry.
1:27:15It's still so fresh. I still have 30-pin connectors in my home.
1:27:18Right. And I don't think Apple—I don't think Apple was the least bit surprised by the people who were upset by that change.
1:27:26but I also, and I don't think it gave them any pause,
1:27:29but I do think they're fully aware of, you know,
1:27:34it would be worse to do it again.
1:27:37- Yes, the nonsense could potentially be terrible.
1:27:41Yeah, when you sent that you wanted to talk about this,
1:27:47this definitely gave me and Renee pause
1:27:50when we first saw it as well, because it's, you know,
1:27:53We've seen stuff going on in the UK and in Europe where, you know, Apple has to ship
1:27:58adapters in the box to make sure that everything's standardized with the EU Commission on charging
1:28:03devices and making it easy for everybody.
1:28:06But by and large, it just, I don't, it doesn't make sense to me to swap out the Lightning
1:28:14port when the Lightning port still does proprietary things that Apple wants it to.
1:28:19They swap out from Lightning to USB-C.
1:28:22I guess you could still do made for iPhone USB-C devices.
1:28:28But I don't know how that licensing would work if they're
1:28:30on top of that also licensing USB-C for a port.
1:28:34I don't know if that increases their component costs in terms of using
1:28:39a developed port like that or whether they're just paying a flat fee to use USB
1:28:44in general from the consortium.
1:28:47I'm not really sure the behind the scenes aspect in that.
1:28:50What I do know is we're eventually going to have to have
1:28:54USB-C on one end because that is where
1:28:58the computers are going.
1:28:59And from that aspect, the rumor that USB-C will be involved
1:29:05in a capacity like you said, as a charging capacity
1:29:09on the other end of that cord, that makes sense to me
1:29:12as like encourage consumers to hurry it up
1:29:15with the switching.
1:29:16Yeah, there's other things that Apple can do with Lightning that people...
1:29:22I mean, and again, let's just get it out of the way. There is a very selfish...
1:29:26they get the made-for-iPhone licensing thing makes the company money and gives them control
1:29:31and limits what other companies can do with iPhone peripherals.
1:29:35And that's just in Apple's own selfish interest to maintain that.
1:29:40The angle that's good for iPhone users is really just, it's that mass market, look,
1:29:49you've already got these cords all over your house and you can just keep using them for
1:29:53years to come.
1:29:58But there's little things too, like the fact that because Lightning is completely Apple's
1:30:01proprietary thing, they can change it in software.
1:30:05And a big part of Lightning's design is that it's changeable in software.
1:30:09So for example, that's why the lightning headphones
1:30:13that they started shipping last year
1:30:15required you to update to iOS 10.
1:30:17Like if you plugged them into an iOS 9 device,
1:30:19you got an error message that said you have to update
1:30:22this device to iOS 10 to use this peripheral
1:30:24because it was a software change that enabled them to work.
1:30:27And they can't do that
1:30:30if they switch to an industry proprietary.
1:30:32I mean, maybe there's a way to do proprietary stuff
1:30:34over the standard, but I don't think it's as easy.
1:30:38No.
1:30:40So I think that the change-- and it surprised me
1:30:43which people piped up on Twitter and who seemed to think
1:30:47that this was reasonable.
1:30:48And again, it's not the most ridiculous thing in the world.
1:30:52If it turns out that this is true, if I'm wrong,
1:30:56and they're worth like Ming-Chi Kuo of KGI,
1:30:59the famed super well-sourced analyst over there,
1:31:02came out with a report a day or two after the Wall Street
1:31:05Journal report, not calling him out by name, but coming about as close as he could because
1:31:10the entire report was more or less, "No, it's because these new phones are still going to
1:31:13have lightning."
1:31:16But they might have USB-C on the power brick side.
1:31:19And he even talked about fast charging and stuff like that.
1:31:21So if he's wrong, if I'm wrong, and they really do ship a new iPhone in September and it has
1:31:28USB-C, I wouldn't find it shocking.
1:31:30I would just find it mildly surprising.
1:31:34To play devil's advocate here, let's say that Apple decides to go the USB-C route because
1:31:40it makes more sense to them from a, I don't know, consortium perspective.
1:31:44Maybe they're getting pressured in the EU, maybe it just makes more sense as they continue
1:31:49to expand globally to just have one universal port and not have to worry about adapters
1:31:54or donkles or anything like that.
1:31:57I could see them switching and just being like, "Hey guys, this is the new normal, you
1:32:02You know, our MacBook Pros have USB-C now, now your iPhones have USB-C, soon the new
1:32:08iMacs are going to have USB-C, and this is our new standard charging port.
1:32:15However, I just don't think it's good business sense for the company because of all the reasons
1:32:21that we've mentioned before.
1:32:24It makes more sense for them to have control.
1:32:29And also, if you look at the rest of their peripherals, including the Lightning-based
1:32:34headphones that if they change the Lightning port, it'll only be there for a year, they
1:32:38just released brand new, you know, the AirPods and the Beats X have Lightning connectors,
1:32:48and then the older Beats headphones, the Solo and the PowerBeats, both still charge via
1:32:54mini USB or micro USB.
1:32:57it's one of those things where if USB-C standardization was coming down the pipeline as this is going
1:33:03to be our charging port now and forever, you know, so help us God, you'd think that they
1:33:08would start it with the AirPods and the BeatZacks and all of their accessories that start to
1:33:15have these things.
1:33:16And the fact that all of the Apple Pencils would essentially be made useless down the
1:33:21line because they use Lightning as well.
1:33:23And could you charge an Apple Pencil via USB-C?
1:33:26That's a good question.
1:33:28Yeah, the rumor makes my head hurt, honestly.
1:33:37- Yeah, I think that the analogy to the headphone port
1:33:41is exactly right, except that you should ignore the fact
1:33:47that for now, they're shipping the iPhones
1:33:54without a headphone port with lightning headphones.
1:33:58The lightning headphones are a stopgap.
1:34:00And the real transition is to wireless.
1:34:04And it's just the fact that at this point,
1:34:06it costs 150 bucks or so for them to sell
1:34:11the wireless ones that are as good
1:34:14as they think the experience should be.
1:34:16I think we just have to wait a few years
1:34:17for the price of those to come down.
1:34:19But that in hindsight, five, six, seven years ago,
1:34:22we look back and we don't really remember
1:34:24the lightning headphones error so much.
1:34:26We, in our memories, it'll be,
1:34:29we used to plug in headphones
1:34:31via the 100-year-old headphone jack,
1:34:34and now we use wireless headphones.
1:34:37- Yeah, no one's gonna really think about it.
1:34:38- And I think that's exactly what's gonna happen
1:34:40with charging, is that lightning is the charging port
1:34:44for all of these devices, except for Macs,
1:34:48until some sort of no port charging is the standard.
1:34:53Where by which I mean, I have this whole rant
1:34:58that I've been meaning to go on about calling
1:35:00conductive or inductive charging, whatever it is.
1:35:03But when you have to still be in physical contact,
1:35:04calling that wireless charging,
1:35:06'cause that's not wireless.
1:35:08- No, it's just, well, I mean,
1:35:10it's wireless from the phone to the pad,
1:35:14but the pad is still wired.
1:35:15- Right.
1:35:16And Apple is actually pretty careful about it.
1:35:18Apple does not describe the Apple Watch
1:35:20as having wireless charging.
1:35:22Because it doesn't.
1:35:23It's inductive charging.
1:35:24Right.
1:35:26So I don't know where we're going with that.
1:35:28I don't know if the next step is going
1:35:30to be inductive charging for these devices,
1:35:32or if it'll be a true wireless thing where it doesn't actually
1:35:35have to be in physical contact, and you can just
1:35:37have it in general proximity.
1:35:39And it'll magically shoot power over the air
1:35:42and not make us full of cancer.
1:35:45Yeah.
1:35:45- I think that's the big problem there right now.
1:35:48- Right, well, you know, I mean,
1:35:50Wi-Fi hasn't killed us yet, so.
1:35:51- It's true, it's true. - I'm optimistic.
1:35:53It just sounds weird though.
1:35:54- 20 years and counting.
1:35:55- Right, it's like when we first started using Wi-Fi,
1:35:58it really weirded me out.
1:35:59It's like, this seems like it should be impossible.
1:36:01I mean, and then you just think like,
1:36:03these waves are shooting through me right now.
1:36:08My body is full of gigabytes.
1:36:09- And let's not even talk about cell phones.
1:36:12All these memes inside me.
1:36:14- Right, but until we can do that,
1:36:17until they can get,
1:36:18Apple wants to get rid of ports,
1:36:21not replace ports with one from another.
1:36:24- Agreed.
1:36:25- And they don't give two craps about proprietary over,
1:36:29or they give a crap, but they're,
1:36:31they see proprietary as a strength, not as a weakness.
1:36:35- Correct.
1:36:35- And I do think it's super telling
1:36:38that the AirPods have a lightning adapter.
1:36:44They could have had USB-C. They absolutely could have shipped with a USB-C charging brick
1:36:48and they chose not to.
1:36:50Right, and it would have been a big tell, I think.
1:36:57I still think it's weird.
1:36:59It's funny, I understand why the pencil works the way that it does, in terms of having a
1:37:04male lightning instead of a female lightning.
1:37:09so that it's less convenient
1:37:13when if you just wanna plug your pencil
1:37:14into something you already have laying around your house.
1:37:17But it's more importantly, it's,
1:37:19whenever you wanna use a pencil,
1:37:20you must have an iPad Pro nearby to use it on.
1:37:24And if the pencil is out,
1:37:26you can just plug it into the iPad for 30 seconds
1:37:28and get a usable charge out of it.
1:37:30It's not elegant. - But it looks silly.
1:37:32- It looks silly.
1:37:34It's not elegant, but it's a very,
1:37:36it's practicality winning out over elegance,
1:37:41whereas the AirPods in comparison are one of the most,
1:37:45it's just, I can't stop raving about how I love
1:37:49every single aspect of it, including the fact
1:37:51that to charge it, you can just plug it into any iPhone
1:37:54charger you have laying around for a couple of minutes
1:37:56once a week or so.
1:37:57- Exactly, you don't have to worry about it,
1:37:59and if your buds ever go dark,
1:38:00you just pop 'em in the case.
1:38:02And it's very seamless.
1:38:05Honestly, can I tell you my biggest wish
1:38:07for the rumored iPads?
1:38:10- Yes.
1:38:12- I want wireless charging, real wireless charging,
1:38:15area charging for the pencil built into this mythical
1:38:1910.5 inch iPad, right?
1:38:22Where if you're in Bluetooth proximity,
1:38:25you're gonna charge it.
1:38:27Which I just think would be amazing.
1:38:28'Cause then that way the pencil never dies.
1:38:31It just, it charges it whenever it's nearby.
1:38:35And if you have to make contact,
1:38:37then maybe they figure out some way
1:38:39to induct a charge through the display, right?
1:38:44Where whenever you're drawing on it,
1:38:46it's actually sending a tiny charge
1:38:48through the tip into the pencil.
1:38:50I know nothing about engineering,
1:38:52so all this may sound like crazy talk,
1:38:54and it probably is, but that is my dream scenario.
1:38:57- Is it possible for them to announce that
1:39:00right now in March 2017, I don't know either.
1:39:03I don't know.
1:39:04- I don't know, I have no idea.
1:39:05- But if it is, boy, that would be a huge selling point
1:39:07and I can't, I would imagine that that's the sort of thing
1:39:10that would get people who bought a pencil a year ago
1:39:12to buy a new one.
1:39:13- Oh yeah, in a heartbeat and a new iPad
1:39:16because you need the new iPad.
1:39:17- 'Cause it gets rid of the awkward lightning,
1:39:21it gets rid of that, right?
1:39:23So let's presume, and then I think they could get rid
1:39:25of the cap.
1:39:26- Yeah, and then you could add a eraser
1:39:29if you really wanted.
1:39:30The cap is a huge--
1:39:31people complain about the cap because the cap is easily lost.
1:39:35So you get rid of the cap.
1:39:36It's entirely self-contained.
1:39:38So then it's-- that's super Apple-like, right?
1:39:41No input, no output.
1:39:43And it really is--
1:39:44I was just talking with a friend the other day
1:39:46about how his biggest gripe with--
1:39:49well, I'll tell you who it is, Ben Thompson.
1:39:52This mysterious source.
1:39:54But he loves the pencil, but he doesn't use it all the time.
1:39:57But if it's in range of your iPad when your iPad's on,
1:40:03they communicate with each other so that it's ready for you
1:40:06to use.
1:40:07But it's always in range of his iPad
1:40:08when his iPad is on because he's taking it out of the same bag.
1:40:11He's got a bag that he keeps his pencil and his iPad in.
1:40:15And so even when he's not using the pencil and just reading
1:40:19on the iPad, it's slowly draining the pencil
1:40:22because it has a communication.
1:40:23And then when he does go to use the pencil, it's always dead.
1:40:26- Yeah, exactly, the pencil's always at 5%
1:40:29because the pencil doesn't quite understand
1:40:31the difference between I'm sitting in your bag
1:40:33ready to be used and I'm being drawn with actively
1:40:38and need battery life.
1:40:39- Right, and the reason that this is mildly annoying
1:40:41is instead of infuriating is because it doesn't take
1:40:44that long to give the pencil a usable charge,
1:40:46but still it happens every time.
1:40:48And if your idea-- - It's still annoying.
1:40:50- Your idea would solve this problem.
1:40:52- Yeah, well it's a step further from what they already do
1:40:56with the smart connector, right?
1:40:57Where the smart connector, to me,
1:40:59feels like this in-betweener stage.
1:41:02Because it has solved the need for Bluetooth keyboards,
1:41:05at least the Bluetooth keyboards,
1:41:06the keyboards that use the smart connector,
1:41:08it's solved that need for those keyboards
1:41:10to constantly be charged separately.
1:41:12It's just, do I wanna use a keyboard with my iPad today?
1:41:17Cool, I'm just gonna set it up.
1:41:18And because of the way that the smart connector connects,
1:41:21like, hooks into the keyboard, it's good.
1:41:23And if they figured out a way to wirelessly charge devices,
1:41:27then we could have variable stand keyboards too,
1:41:31which would also be really cool.
1:41:32- That would be cool.
1:41:33And it's definitely, I think it's a definite situation,
1:41:36circling back to what I said before,
1:41:37where there's an awful lot of people
1:41:40who only use their iPad with a keyboard sometimes.
1:41:44Because the whole point of why they're using an iPad
1:41:47is they're often using the iPad in these contexts
1:41:50where you either don't want a keyboard
1:41:51or don't need a keyboard, you know,
1:41:54it's just not that important
1:41:55that you have a hardware keyboard.
1:41:56And you do that, do that, do that, do that.
1:41:58And the thing that's great about the smart connector
1:42:01is then when you do need a keyboard,
1:42:02you don't have to worry if it's charged.
1:42:04- Yep, exactly.
1:42:05You just throw it on, use it, and then put it away.
1:42:08And then you can forget about it for another three months.
1:42:10- Yeah.
1:42:12Yeah, that's a great idea.
1:42:13I hope you're right.
1:42:14- I hope I'm right too. (laughs)
1:42:17- You wanna talk about Uber quickly?
1:42:19- Yeah, let's talk about Uber.
1:42:21- Boy, I don't know what to do.
1:42:23I feel like I'm gonna confess something.
1:42:25I'm gonna be honest and straightforward.
1:42:27'Cause I don't feel, I feel like that's the,
1:42:32it's, I feel guilty otherwise.
1:42:34And I feel guilty about what I'm about to say.
1:42:36I'm gonna confess.
1:42:37I have not deleted the Uber app from my phone.
1:42:40- I also have not deleted the Uber app from my phone,
1:42:43despite the fact that I think the company is despicable.
1:42:45- Right.
1:42:46- I haven't used it since then.
1:42:48- I have.
1:42:49- But I also haven't deleted it.
1:42:50I have used, I have used Duper.
1:42:51Because there's the only one that can get a black car
1:42:55in Philadelphia and the black cars have SUVs
1:42:59and sometimes, like I went out to dinner with some friends
1:43:01and we needed to fit five adults in a car.
1:43:05So I still use it and I justify it in my head as,
1:43:12well, I know they're losing money on every ride they give.
1:43:14(laughing)
1:43:17I'm robbing some poor defenseless VC.
1:43:20- Right.
1:43:22But I feel terrible about it.
1:43:23And it's, I don't know.
1:43:26At some point it's, you know, I don't know.
1:43:29What I want is I want Lyft to connect
1:43:31to these black car drivers.
1:43:33Black car drivers I think would jump at it.
1:43:35- Yeah.
1:43:36I mean, I don't think at this point anybody is like,
1:43:39yes, I love working for Uber.
1:43:42I am proud to work, maybe Travis, what's his face?
1:43:46- Well, the drivers aren't. - Yeah.
1:43:48No, but that's what I'm saying.
1:43:50I'm like, I think the drivers are, you know,
1:43:53looking for other options if they can.
1:43:56They still wanna, you know, they wanna drive
1:43:58in the car sharing economy because it's a good way
1:44:00right now to make money, at least until the bottom
1:44:02falls out, but I don't think any of them is like,
1:44:06yes, I feel so loyal to Uber and Uber has stood right by me
1:44:10because Uber has not really stood right by anybody.
1:44:14They've kind of been huge dicks.
1:44:17- There's gotta be a way, and I know that,
1:44:19and I understand that my argument
1:44:22that I know that they're losing money on every ride,
1:44:24that that's actually their plan,
1:44:26and it's, you know, that the basic idea,
1:44:29it's not really a secret,
1:44:30is that they wanna monopolize the market,
1:44:32and then once they have the monopoly on a market,
1:44:34they can raise the rates to where it's profitable.
1:44:36I'm not quite sure how they ever get there,
1:44:42because at the point where they raise the rates,
1:44:44I don't see how new competitors don't pop up.
1:44:47Like, I don't see how they have a real path to a monopoly.
1:44:52'Cause then their whole argument is,
1:44:56they're destroying the existing regulations.
1:44:59It's not like they're gonna get new regulations put in place
1:45:01that say that in the city of Philadelphia,
1:45:03Uber is the only ride sharing app available.
1:45:06- Yeah, they're not gonna benefit Uber,
1:45:08they're gonna benefit all ride sharing companies.
1:45:11- Right.
1:45:1117 might pop up. I can see them getting to monopoly status by taking down the cabs, if the cabs don't form up and create their own rival company, which some have already done.
1:45:22I can see them getting to that point, but like you said, at the issue where they start having to raise rates, then it becomes, okay, well, who has the cheapest service?
1:45:36it's a race to the bottom a little bit.
1:45:38And it honestly depends on whether or not VCs
1:45:41are willing to take that risk and be like,
1:45:44yeah, I'm gonna fund this company
1:45:45because Uber needs to be taken down.
1:45:47It's gotten too big, too big, too violent.
1:45:52Or does it turn into the thing where the VCs
1:45:54are kinda like, well, we're just not gonna fund
1:45:56new transportation startups because no one's figured out
1:45:59how to make them profitable without price gouging consumers?
1:46:02- Right, and I wanna, you know, there's so many,
1:46:05Uber is sort of like Silicon Valley's version of the Trump administration, where there's
1:46:10like a new scandal every day, or even by the hour.
1:46:14You know, it's like, a daily list of the scandals doesn't keep up with the fact, you
1:46:19know what I mean?
1:46:20Like, if you only paid attention once a day, it's like, we're recording this on Friday,
1:46:25March 3rd.
1:46:26Like, on Thursday, March 2nd, if you only paid attention at noon, the news was President
1:46:31Trump says Attorney General Jeff Sessions does not need to recuse himself.
1:46:35But by six o'clock in the night, he recused himself. It's like you have to
1:46:39check every three hours to see what's going on.
1:46:41And it's the same with Uber. But like there was a thing this week where an
1:46:45Uber driver had taped a... he recognized that he had Travis
1:46:49Kalanick as his passenger in a car and he videotaped it. And Kalanick had
1:46:55said some somewhat embarrassing things to the
1:46:57driver somewhat yeah but I I didn't I didn't think it was outrageous it you
1:47:03know I mean and I'm just I'm vaguely uncomfortable with the idea that he
1:47:08taped him in the first place and I don't think what he said was all that
1:47:11outrageous it was a little rude but it I thought the driver was sort of nutty too
1:47:16yeah the problem is that there's already the narrative right there's already the
1:47:21narrative that he's a jerk and a horrible person's yeah get him caught on
1:47:26tape doing anything jerkish. Yeah. And it blows up even further. Right, exactly. I think that's
1:47:32serenity. I think that's exactly what happened where it's like everybody knows that this Travis
1:47:35Kalanick is at least a bit of a jerk and that he's been, him and his company have been caught doing
1:47:41really jerky, exceptionally jerky things lately and you hear and he's secretly taped saying
1:47:47something and what he said is at least somewhere on the jerky spectrum and then you just jump to
1:47:51the worst conclusion. Whereas I think if I actually watched the video and I was like this isn't
1:47:55that big. Yeah, it's not it's not that big. And speaking,
1:48:00speaking of how it just seems like a new Uber story pops up
1:48:04every day, literally while we're recording this. The Verge
1:48:09Dateline 30 minutes ago,
1:48:11the New York Times via the Verge via the New York Times reports
1:48:17that Uber has a secret worldwide program called gray ball to hide
1:48:20from government employees looking to catch Uber cars
1:48:23operating in violation of local regulations.
1:48:26Because this, yeah.
1:48:28I don't even know what to say about this because it's just,
1:48:35it's literally as we're saying, hey, Uber just keeps on getting
1:48:40caught doing really horrible stuff. Now there's another, I
1:48:45don't know, I yeah, like this is the, this sounds like something
1:48:49that a mildly shady company would go for. Be like, yeah, let's run some software to make sure you
1:48:55don't pick up passengers who might be government employees because we're breaking labor practices
1:49:01in certain cities. There's a whole lot to unpack there. So it looks like what they did is when they
1:49:07were in municipalities where Uber was deemed to be contrary to the local regulations, Uber would
1:49:15appoint somebody to figure out where the regulator's offices were and then look for anybody opening
1:49:24the Uber app on a frequent basis from those locations and then I guess not pick them up.
1:49:32Show fake cars. They'd also check the credit card information to see if the card was tied
1:49:37to a police credit union. Wow.
1:49:41unknown to Mr. England and other authorities,
1:49:44I think this was the guy from Portland,
1:49:46some of the digital cars they saw in the app
1:49:49did not represent actual vehicles,
1:49:50and the Uber drivers they were able to hail
1:49:52also quickly canceled.
1:49:54That was because Uber had tagged Mr. England
1:49:56and his colleagues, essentially grayballing them
1:49:58as city officials based on data collected from the app
1:50:00and in other ways.
1:50:01So yeah, not a good company.
1:50:04- No, not having a great week as far as PR goes.
1:50:09- But the thing that I wanted to bring up
1:50:11was that among this avalanche of these things,
1:50:15the one story that, to me, is the sun
1:50:20to the planets of these other scandals or a series of planets,
1:50:24but the one at the center of it is Susan Fowler-Raggetti's story
1:50:28of her year-long employment, which, to me, is different.
1:50:33Because I've reread her entire piece at least three times.
1:50:38It's extraordinarily well-written.
1:50:41And I'm guessing that you've noticed the ways that it's
1:50:44well-written.
1:50:45Because--
1:50:45Oh, absolutely.
1:50:46It's well-written on like three different levels,
1:50:49where she makes her case extremely well.
1:50:52She obviously had her wits about her for the entire year
1:50:55that she worked-- right from the beginning, when she first
1:50:58started to be harassed.
1:51:01She documented it.
1:51:02And she kept emails and screenshots of chats.
1:51:07And it's so clear from her writing
1:51:09that she could back it all up.
1:51:12But also, the tone that she took in the article is--
1:51:17necessary is not the right word.
1:51:23But it was taken from a way that she couldn't be easily dismissed.
1:51:30And it's the sort of tonal tap dancing that a woman has to take that a man
1:51:38doesn't even have to think about.
1:51:39Yeah, it was written, you're absolutely right in terms of the, I'm trying to think of the right
1:51:46word here, it was written in a very level platform where she's basically like, "Here are all these
1:51:54accusations that I'm laying out, but I'm not laying them out in a way that makes me sound
1:51:59especially angry or especially vindictive towards the company." She basically laid it out almost
1:52:06factually, almost like a lawyer would lay out, "Here are the things that happened to me. On this
1:52:12date, this happened. On this date, this happened." But not written so drolly that you can't read
1:52:21between the lines and actually get a good picture of what's happening.
1:52:25The specific nature of the harassment that she experienced is very specific to being a woman in a largely male company where male on female harassment is clearly tolerated at an institutional level.
1:52:46And it's so as you can't just say if the tables returned and it was reversed because there's no such equivalent. There is no
1:52:52There's no company in the world
1:52:54That's like the uber for women where men at a 50 to 1 ratio as engineers get harassed
1:53:01but if a man had suffered the moral equivalent of of this wrongdoing at
1:53:07You know in some other than sexual harassment or some other way
1:53:12just something that everybody would agree was equally wrong on the moral spectrum.
1:53:17A man would document it in a way where I don't think he would have to even think about hiding his anger
1:53:22at what had gone on and what was tolerated.
1:53:25Whereas she did, not hide, but like tap dance between coming across as angry
1:53:33and not crossing the line into acting like it's a joke or it's not serious.
1:53:41- Yeah, she had to pitch it very much, as you said,
1:53:45between the lines because of retribution.
1:53:49I mean, we've all been following the stories
1:53:51and the fact that Uber has gone, you know,
1:53:54potentially sent lawyers after her this week,
1:53:57and I don't know, you know, the fact, how factual that is
1:53:59or where that stands right now beyond her claims.
1:54:03But the mere fact that like, she had to write this
1:54:06in such a way because she was worried about retribution
1:54:09from a company that arguably, she has a pretty darn good lawsuit against to begin with. Whereas,
1:54:16as you said, a man could very easily just write the angriest of angry medium rats and
1:54:23just be, you know, like, "This has happened to me," and "How dare this company," and "This
1:54:27is a disgusting, you know, violation of human rights and my rights as a human, like, my
1:54:33writes in personally and, you know, I can't even write in that tone because it just makes me want
1:54:40to vomit. But it's, yeah. And also, honestly, in comparison, I believe you linked to a Medium
1:54:49article by one other woman who wrote about her Uber experiences. And hers were also very chilling
1:54:55and very bothersome, but she wrote it in a much, in a much vaguer, more, not quite salacious style,
1:55:03but it was definitely written as more of a story and more of a, you know, here's a peek into my
1:55:09life. Whereas Susan Fowlers was very much, you know, removed, emotionally removed. It was written
1:55:17very analytically. Pete: And it, you know, there's, the truth is that an angry woman is going to be
1:55:24dismissed by X percent of people who read her, mostly men, but also some women. You know,
1:55:30there's a woman who's angry in public, gets a very different reaction, and very different adjectives
1:55:38are used to describe her emotional state than a man with the equivalent amount of anger. And I'm,
1:55:46you know, I feel a lot certain about that statement. I also feel like, even though I'm
1:55:53certain of it and I'm incredibly sympathetic to it. I don't even feel, I feel like part of the reason
1:55:59that that's the case is that I'm not in a position to even judge it, right? Like it's,
1:56:05like I can judge what they did to Susan Fowler, but I'm not, I feel like as a man, especially,
1:56:15you know, with every privilege you could possibly, possibly have in this country,
1:56:22I'm not in a position to judge just how widespread that unfairness is in terms of how we see
1:56:32deal with things like angry, people who are rightfully angry in a professional context.
1:56:37But she obviously is very well, very familiar with it.
1:56:42[laughter]
1:56:43Well, you know the verbal gymnastics that you need to thread, especially working in a company
1:56:49like that, you know, she had a year of experience having to dance through clearly the insanity of
1:56:57the HR process and her higher-ups. Coming out of that, you know, you're gonna know, like, the
1:57:04second that you write a piece like that, unfortunately, the second that a woman writes a
1:57:08piece like that, the first thing that a certain subsection of the internet is going to do is try
1:57:13and find ways of proving that she's crazy or she was arrested or that some small aspect of it isn't
1:57:20true and therefore the whole thing is in question the whole thing is null and void exactly oh she
1:57:25cheated on a test when she was in the seventh grade so she's untrustworthy right you know
1:57:29or she claims this one thing happened on you know the first monday of july 2015 but guess what that
1:57:36was a federal holiday it was that was independence day uber was closed yeah exactly it actually
1:57:42happened July 3rd. But she lied, therefore the entire thing is called into question. Yeah,
1:57:48it's unfortunately, there is a certain subsection of the population that delights in trying to poke
1:57:56holes in stories like these. And I don't think that, you know, we should take everything at
1:58:01face value. Obviously, there is value to be had in fact-checking and not believing stories,
1:58:07you know, without doing some digging. But there's a difference between independent verification and,
1:58:13you know, and just going after somebody because they're saying something that you don't want to
1:58:20be true. So you immediately jump into attacking the first possible opportunity.
1:58:25Jim Collison,
1:58:25It would occur to me too, and I just can't say it enough, and it sounds trite, but just how courageous it was for her to publish this.
1:58:35Because she didn't have to...
1:58:36Under her own name.
1:58:37Under her own name, which it gives it, you know, I'm not saying it's necessary.
1:58:41Like the other article that I linked to that you mentioned that was published under a pseudonym, and she admitted it up front.
1:58:47She said, "I'm not comfortable sharing my name. This is a pseudonym, so there's no misdirection there."
1:58:51But, you know, and again, I'm not saying that that wasn't
1:58:54useful and courageous in and of itself,
1:58:56but doing it under her own name is more courageous
1:59:00and it leaves more credence to it.
1:59:01Because she clearly knew to expect a backlash.
1:59:07And I think it's obvious that,
1:59:10you read the story and the part that to me where you just,
1:59:16the part of her story where you just go, whoa,
1:59:18was the part where many months into her employment at Uber,
1:59:23I mean, and the other reason why I should say this
1:59:27is that she now works at Stripe.
1:59:28She hasn't, she's already landed another job.
1:59:30She doesn't have to, you know,
1:59:31she's not like she has to worry about her employability.
1:59:33She's got a great job at a great company.
1:59:35So it'd be easy to just say, you know what?
1:59:36Now I have a great job at a great company.
1:59:38Thank God that's over and let it go.
1:59:41But by coming public and, you know,
1:59:45it's obviously the most well-known she's ever been.
1:59:47you know, she's a published author at O'Reilly, but uh, so I'm not saying that it's not like she hasn't had a
1:59:52You know
1:59:55Stuff in the public eye before but it's a different kind of notoriety, right? Um
1:59:59The whole the part of the story where you really just go I just went whoa was the part where
2:00:08She and some other women engineers at uber months later
2:00:12talking amongst themselves
2:00:14realized they all had problems with the same guy, a manager above them. And several of them
2:00:23had reported their incidents to Uber's HR department. And all of them were told the same
2:00:29thing that, "Well, thank you for reporting it, but we're uncomfortable taking any action against him
2:00:36at this time because it's his first offense and he's a high performer." And it's like, "Whoa."
2:00:44So they just say that and you realize, well, how did they think that they were going to get away with it?
2:00:49How would they you know, how did they think that eventually?
2:00:51Some of these women would
2:00:55Figure this out in a company. No one wants to talk about this stuff. It's all based on the assumption that even if they do
2:01:02They'll get the message that you know
2:01:06Let you know this stuff is okay for high performers and yeah, let's let dogs lie. What are they gonna do?
2:01:14go public, that they seem like at a certain, whether it was, you know, stated or just unconscious
2:01:21between the HR people who made the decision to deal with it this way. HR clearly assumed,
2:01:27at Uber, clearly assumed that these women would, none of these women would go public.
2:01:32Yeah, well because it's too much of a risk. It's a, you know, again, we go back to the,
2:01:39it's the credibility issue. You may never land a job again if you don't have your facts
2:01:43in your story and things to back things up, you know, to back your evidence up.
2:01:47Right. Like there's Susan Fowler Getty by going public under her own name, and with as much
2:01:53scathing detail as she did, was willing to do something that a company valued at $70 billion
2:01:58was willing to bet she wouldn't. Yep. Which is amazing. Yeah. And you talk about courageous.
2:02:08You know, people have been saying under the radar, don't go work for Uber, don't go work for Uber,
2:02:13don't go work for Uber, especially if you're a woman, but just in general, it's just not a
2:02:17good culture. But there really hasn't been somebody standing up on a chair and yelling,
2:02:23"No, don't go work for Uber because you will be sorry," until Fowler. Like, there's just,
2:02:30there wasn't that kind of like, damning public, like, I won't even invent like, "Skatery! New
2:02:39word! But no, it's such a scathing critique of not only the HR department, I don't know how the
2:02:46people who work in that HR department have spines or stomachs at that point. Like, I wonder how many
2:02:52people have quit in that department specifically over the years. And also, I forget from the story,
2:02:57but I wonder the gender of the HR department liaisons too.
2:03:02Because if it's—
2:03:03Pete: I think she said that some of them were women.
2:03:05- Yeah, which just, that's an even bigger gut punch.
2:03:08- Or maybe all, I don't even know.
2:03:08- Yeah.
2:03:09That's, that's, it strikes me just as such a betrayal
2:03:14to have to say to somebody's face,
2:03:17"Sorry, we're not gonna do anything about your,
2:03:20you know, your emotional or physical harassment,"
2:03:24despite the fact that it could happen to anybody.
2:03:27You know, we're just gonna look in your face and say no.
2:03:32Yeah, that's the kind of thing that makes me
2:03:35want to never use their service again.
2:03:36And it's just like, I commend everybody
2:03:40who's deleted the app and burned it.
2:03:42It's, yeah.
2:03:45- All right, I gotta delete the app.
2:03:47It's terrible. - Yeah, you gotta.
2:03:48(laughing)
2:03:49It's gone.
2:03:50- I will say, just in terms of people
2:03:53who've been outspoken critics, I've long followed,
2:03:57I'm sure, I don't know if you know her,
2:03:59but I'm sure you're aware of her,
2:04:00Sara Lacy, founder of Pando.com.
2:04:04And she has been on the,
2:04:07Uber is actually a terrible company beat for years now.
2:04:11- Or a path, yeah. - And so the difference,
2:04:13I would say, is that she's always been from the out,
2:04:17she's been a journalist her whole career.
2:04:19She's been writing about it from the outside
2:04:21as a journalist observing the company, not as an insider.
2:04:25That's the difference between her and Fowler.
2:04:30- Yeah, she can only get anonymous quotes
2:04:33and hopefully people wanting to go on the record,
2:04:35but it's ultimately all the scoops in the world
2:04:39are not going to help you in contrast
2:04:41with someone just coming straight out
2:04:42and telling their story.
2:04:45- So anyway, I feel like we had to talk about it.
2:04:47Glad we did.
2:04:48- Oh yeah, me too.
2:04:49- Anything else you want to mention before we wrap up?
2:04:52- Gosh, I think we kind of ran the gamut.
2:04:55- I know, we caught up.
2:04:56I feel like I kind of caught up to the news,
2:04:57although who knows, God Almighty,
2:04:58there's probably like another Uber scandal.
2:05:01- I know, in the next, the last 30 minutes.
2:05:03- We'll never make it. - In addition to Grayvald.
2:05:05- In the 24 hours it usually takes for shows
2:05:07to get published, we'll never make it.
2:05:09There's gonna be something, something will break.
2:05:11- Undoubtedly, this news cycle,
2:05:13that's what I'd like to talk about.
2:05:14I'd like to talk about a pause button.
2:05:16Could someone make me a HomeKit pause button
2:05:18for the news cycle?
2:05:19- Please, no news.
2:05:20Everybody can read Serenity's fine work
2:05:28at iMore.com and on Twitter, your Twitter name is,
2:05:32I forget, what's your Twitter name?
2:05:33- Cetern.
2:05:34- How do you spell it, S-E-T-T-E-R-N.
2:05:37- Yes.
2:05:38- That's a fine follow on Twitter.
2:05:40Anything else you wanna mention or pitch?
2:05:43- Oh gosh, other than the, we're doing a lot of work
2:05:46on iPad Pros, specifically people who are doing
2:05:49real world iPad examples, so if you have,
2:05:53if you're using your iPad for work,
2:05:54especially if it's something outside the norm
2:05:57that you think is pretty awesome,
2:05:59please hit me up on Twitter or on email
2:06:01at Serenity@imore because I'd love to hear your story.
2:06:04We're collecting some really good ones.
2:06:06- All right, I will definitely put a link into the series,
2:06:08iPad Pros over at IMOR, but I think it's great.
2:06:11I think it's really interesting to think about
2:06:13in terms of context where and what these people are doing,
2:06:17not just, oh, they're doing the same things they used to do.
2:06:21I think our sponsors, Squarespace,
2:06:23that's where you go to make a website.
2:06:24Remember the offer code Gruber,
2:06:26get 10% off your first purchase.
2:06:28Harry's, go to harrys.com/talkshow,
2:06:31get a free shaving kit, pay for shipping.
2:06:33And last but not least, Backblaze.
2:06:36Back up your Mac.
2:06:37If you don't have Backblaze already,
2:06:38just go sign, do it right now.
2:06:40The podcast is over, you're not missing anything.
2:06:42Go to backblaze.com/daringfireball
2:06:45and get a 15-day free trial.
2:06:46Thank you, Serenity.