Podcast Search

The Talk Show

180: ‘Yay or Nay to Their POV’ With Matthew Panzarino

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Matthew Panzareno welcome welcome back to the show. Thank you sir. Thanks for having me. Wow. It's a tough week to have a show. There's no news

0:00:07Yeah, we might as well just shut it down go on vacation

0:00:14Man yeah, it's been like that every day so

0:00:20We are recording on Tuesday the 31st. So we are literally talking like two hours after Apple posted

0:00:28Quarterly results so we can actually do like a news show. It's like we're like on on CNN or something talking about breaking news

0:00:35Right this week's news today or whatever. Yeah, so that yesterday

0:00:40Summarizing the quarterly results, I think it's my summary is more or less

0:00:50iPhone went back to growth which was contrary to

0:00:55Some predictions that that that last year's dip was was the sign that that we'd reached a peak iPhone

0:01:03People say they sold more iPhones last quarter than they've ever sold in any quarter including the two year ago one when the sales went

0:01:10bananas because of the

0:01:12iPhone 6 and 6 plus

0:01:14iPad sales are down a little bit year over year, but they're

0:01:20reasonably saying, well, last year they came out

0:01:23with the brand new iPad Pro.

0:01:24This year there were no new iPads in the holiday quarter,

0:01:26and they're still a respectable 13 million.

0:01:29Mac sales were up a little, rebounding,

0:01:33I think showing good signs of probably

0:01:36the new MacBook Pro sales being pretty good.

0:01:39Apple Watch, they don't break those out,

0:01:42but on the conference call, it sounded to me,

0:01:45reading the summary, that they said

0:01:47it was a record-breaking quarter.

0:01:50And that makes sense because it's the holiday quarter

0:01:52and I think that it's,

0:01:54if they did break those watch sales out,

0:01:56I think the holiday quarter is gonna be a huge spike,

0:01:59just like in the old days, the way iPods were.

0:02:02And then last but not least, services,

0:02:04Apple's favorite word of the last two years is up.

0:02:07Is that a fair summary?

0:02:10- Yeah, I think so.

0:02:12I mean, I think there's some question

0:02:13about that other category,

0:02:15in like the overall other category.

0:02:18There was a dip in growth, but the general consensus

0:02:22is the watch did fine in the quarter.

0:02:24- Right.

0:02:26- I mean, it's pretty much the only watch

0:02:27that's doing anywhere near decent right now,

0:02:29so it's not too hard to say that.

0:02:33- Yeah, and it seems to me like, I mean, there's a lot of,

0:02:37I mean, this is a little off topic of Apple's quarter,

0:02:39but it's on point with the watch that I'm starting to see

0:02:43some serious repeated pessimism about Fitbit,

0:02:48that Fitbit, I think, might be,

0:02:51as a company, might be in trouble.

0:02:53- Yes, yeah, I think that's pretty clear

0:02:55from what we've been hearing so far.

0:02:58I think that there's a significant change in direction,

0:03:01what we refer to here in Silicon Valley as pivot,

0:03:05coming for them, but yeah, there's,

0:03:08they are definitely, and I don't think anybody

0:03:10really thinks that it's completely about the products.

0:03:14I mean, I think there's plenty of quality issues

0:03:15they've had over the years,

0:03:16and they've never been super highly rated

0:03:21as far as durability and longevity and quality.

0:03:24And they've had a couple of actual real problems

0:03:26with quality, but I think it's just a tough category

0:03:29and they just didn't quite figure it out.

0:03:32- Yeah, it's like they stand alone

0:03:37as the only independent company

0:03:41that's making fitness trackers

0:03:43that is worth even talking about,

0:03:45but it doesn't seem like they've got it over the hump.

0:03:48And it's, I think in particular, Apple Watch is doing them in

0:03:52that in this casual market, in this casual market

0:03:56of people who wanna spend like, let's say,

0:03:58somewhere around two, $300 to track their fitness,

0:04:02it seems to me like Apple Watch is starting to get

0:04:05real traction outside the early adopters market,

0:04:09and I think it's at Fitbit's expense.

0:04:13yeah and it's sort of the

0:04:16you know you bought a phone

0:04:18may used to be a main made for four five years ago you bought a phone make phone

0:04:21calls and maybe you write text messages

0:04:24and you got all these apps with it

0:04:25you know i know it's not a stop and then you come to love that and

0:04:28pretty soon you're not making phone calls at all you texting everybody with

0:04:31you know messenger or whatever

0:04:33but i think it's the same kind of concept you know so people are saying

0:04:35hey you know now the price is getting to where

0:04:39i don't mind spending two hundred box

0:04:41getting this thing and getting all these other things with it but it's a great

0:04:44you know so solid fitness tracker that they can do all these things so

0:04:48as a category and union as you mentioned it

0:04:51you knows treading alone on the backs of that

0:04:54one p_m_l_ right

0:04:55right so if you break out the apple watch is a business especially that

0:04:58first launch quarter when it launched

0:05:01i mean that stuff takes ramp time

0:05:04and when it's you're relying on yourself in your own revenues and whatever you

0:05:07know venture capital obviously you have

0:05:09you don't have

0:05:10infinite runway, you know?

0:05:13- Yeah, and I think, we'll come back to this

0:05:16on another topic in a bit, but I'm as guilty of it,

0:05:21maybe not as anybody, but I know I'm guilty of it,

0:05:26and I think others who write about technology

0:05:28are seriously guilty of being too focused on the short term

0:05:33and not realizing how long some things need

0:05:40to really get mainstream acceptance.

0:05:42Like just smartphones, period.

0:05:45It was like, remember the, what was the initial goal?

0:05:48It was like 10 million iPhones in the first year of sales,

0:05:52something like that.

0:05:53And they made it, but it's like if you think about that now,

0:05:59they sold 78 million phones in three months

0:06:03this last quarter.

0:06:04And whereas back when it first came out 10 years ago,

0:06:08It was, we're hoping for 10 million in 12 months.

0:06:12It takes a long time.

0:06:14And a part of it is just the simple common sense,

0:06:16and I mean, other people have written about it,

0:06:18but just, there are people like me

0:06:21who will go and buy an iPhone on the day it comes out.

0:06:24But most people, even if they were curious,

0:06:26and I still remember it with the original iPhone,

0:06:28where people on the street would see me using it,

0:06:30and they would say, without knowing who I am,

0:06:33they would just say, "Is that an iPhone?"

0:06:35Right?

0:06:36And they were obviously aware of it.

0:06:38They probably have one now,

0:06:39but it took years for them to be comfortable to say,

0:06:42"Okay, I'll get one."

0:06:43'Cause there's like a comfort factor of knowing it.

0:06:46And I think the watch is on that trajectory.

0:06:49- Yeah, I think so.

0:06:53I mean, I think I've definitely had,

0:06:54right now it's exited that phase for me.

0:06:59It's not like people see it on my wrist and go,

0:07:02oh my God, is that an Apple Watch?

0:07:03But what they do say is,

0:07:05"Oh, you know, I'm thinking about getting it. Are you still using it?"

0:07:08Which is an interesting way to phrase it, right? And I think that that's

0:07:11partially from the narrative, you know,

0:07:15I guess you could call it media narrative or whatever,

0:07:19that the watch isn't all that useful long-term, that there's an initial

0:07:23wave of like, "Oh hey, I'm poking around," and then eventually you get tired of it and put it away.

0:07:27And I definitely know that

0:07:29there are plenty of people that don't wear those anymore or whatever, right? There's

0:07:32going to be that with any gadget. It doesn't fit

0:07:34either what the company tried to sell you it was, or whatever their success or failure

0:07:41in communicating what it was was, or your own vision of how it would fit into your life

0:07:45didn't quite match up with how it actually did.

0:07:49So I think that we've exited that phase, and now we're in a phase where the people that

0:07:54are still wearing it are advocating in ways that are more specific.

0:07:57They're like, "Yes, I love it because X, Y."

0:08:00It's not like, "Oh yeah, I love it."

0:08:03And then like, "What do you like about it?"

0:08:04"Oh, I look at all these things and this thing and that thing."

0:08:06I don't think we're out of that.

0:08:09These are the practical benefits it offers me.

0:08:11"Oh yeah, I have all my calendar stuff on there."

0:08:14That's enough for most people.

0:08:15Or it's a great fitness tracker.

0:08:17I go to the gym every day or I cycle or I swim, etc.

0:08:22People are figuring out the things that work for them.

0:08:25And so it's more about the precise benefits on an individual basis versus the entire bolus

0:08:34of benefits that could theoretically apply to you.

0:08:38And I think that that could be where the sustained growth

0:08:42is coming from versus the initial wave of who knows.

0:08:44- Yeah, it's also true that, I mean, we knew this.

0:08:47This isn't something we needed to hear from Tim Cook

0:08:50on the conference call today.

0:08:51You could tell just by going to the Apple store

0:08:53and trying to buy an Apple Watch that they were backordered

0:08:57for most of the last quarter, or still are, I think,

0:09:01that they couldn't make them fast enough,

0:09:03Which is a good sign, I guess.

0:09:05- Yeah, I mean, I think initially, you know,

0:09:09you never know whether they just didn't know

0:09:11how many to make or what, or whether they didn't know

0:09:13what the right mix was.

0:09:15- Right.

0:09:16- I think initially there was a lot more people

0:09:17buying steel than maybe they thought.

0:09:20And so there was, you know, it's incredibly hard

0:09:21to get steel ones for a long time.

0:09:23But now I think they're getting the mix figured out.

0:09:25So if they have the mix figured out, that eliminates that.

0:09:28And now you are looking at, yeah,

0:09:31they're just having a hard time keeping up with it,

0:09:33which theoretically should be a good thing.

0:09:36On the flip side, they aren't keeping up with it,

0:09:38so they're not selling as many as they could,

0:09:39which is not great for your shareholders

0:09:42or whatever you wanna call it.

0:09:43- With iPhone sales rebounding

0:09:47and actually growing and breaking a record,

0:09:49even with that, even saying it's a record,

0:09:54it's clear, it's a few fractions of a percentage.

0:09:59I think at 78 million they sold into one two years ago

0:10:02that was the previous record was like 74 million phones

0:10:05or something like that.

0:10:06So the years of rah-rah 50% growth year over year are over.

0:10:11And I think that common sense would tell you why.

0:10:15It's because the smartphone is sort of a saturated product.

0:10:19I mean, not that there's no room for growth

0:10:22in certain markets, but for the most part,

0:10:24over the last 10 years, we've reached the point

0:10:26where almost everybody who might get a smartphone

0:10:30has a smartphone.

0:10:31- Right.

0:10:34Well, I mean, I think,

0:10:35it looks like there was some declines in China,

0:10:39but every other market grew,

0:10:41which is, that's pretty solid.

0:10:45I mean, China is its own beast.

0:10:47You know, it's incredibly difficult to do business there,

0:10:49as Apple has found over the years, you know,

0:10:51and we only know the public stuff.

0:10:53We don't know the many challenges they've come up,

0:10:56against with the government and everything else that don't quite make it to the page.

0:11:01But outside of that, every other region was growing. And I think that people think of

0:11:06saturation and replacement cycles and things like that. The people that do think of those

0:11:12things are not, they're not communicating it well or I should say that they communicate

0:11:17it fine in their vein. But it's hard to characterize those things and turn them into very human,

0:11:26you know, sentences or ideas or concepts for people that can help them understand where

0:11:32the growth is coming from and where the sustained growth will come from.

0:11:35Because it's like you could say, "Hey, every X years, people are going to replace their

0:11:40iPhone and that changes based on major design changes, right?"

0:11:44So in a major design change year, the replacement cycle may be lowered by 30%.

0:11:49And then you can also go to like, you know, there's new people being born, so people are

0:11:53are turning what, 12 or 13 or 14 now,

0:11:57that were just born when the iPhone came out

0:12:02and they're getting phones.

0:12:03So we're getting into the first wave of,

0:12:06I don't know, new iPhone consumers,

0:12:09first generation of new iPhone consumers.

0:12:11So there are lots of factors.

0:12:12It's a very liquid thing.

0:12:14And everybody treats it like,

0:12:15oh yeah, everybody that has a phone,

0:12:18has one, wants one, and that's it.

0:12:20But I think Apple is looking at growth

0:12:21in terms of all of these variables,

0:12:24and the projections show, revenue projection,

0:12:27guidance-wise, it's like 51, I guess,

0:12:30to 53 billion, something like that,

0:12:32that they're projecting, which is not crazy high,

0:12:35but not light by any means, and so I think that,

0:12:39I think that they feel that they've got the growth

0:12:41out there, in those pockets.

0:12:43- And I think that, I think a lot of people saw,

0:12:50Long story short, last year for the calendar year,

0:12:54iPhone sales were down year over year.

0:12:56The 6S seemingly didn't sell as,

0:12:59or didn't sell as well as the 6.

0:13:02And I say that, my only hesitation in saying that

0:13:05is my presumption that most iPhones sold are the new,

0:13:09the top of the line new model.

0:13:12'Cause you don't know, they don't break that down

0:13:14for competitive reasons.

0:13:15So in theory, they could've sold,

0:13:17the iPhone SE could secretly be the best selling iPhone.

0:13:20But anecdotally, it certainly seems

0:13:23that that doesn't seem the way,

0:13:25most people buy the best one.

0:13:28I think some people saw last year's slight dip

0:13:32and thought whether it was just to be dramatic

0:13:36and make clickbait predictions,

0:13:39but saw it as the beginning of a trend

0:13:42as opposed to the counter argument was just that

0:13:46it looked like a dip because the six was such an outlier

0:13:50in terms of there having been so much pent up demand

0:13:53for a quote unquote bigger iPhone.

0:13:55And I think the numbers they just announced

0:14:01for the iPhone 7 certainly back that up.

0:14:03That it was just an outlier.

0:14:06- Yeah, I think so.

0:14:07I mean, I think the plus, I guess Tim said on the call

0:14:10that the iPhone 7 Plus was the highest portion,

0:14:14was a higher portion of the mix than in the past.

0:14:17So that, you know, people are getting acclimated

0:14:20to the larger phones, that increases their profit margins,

0:14:23obviously, 'cause the larger phones don't cost them,

0:14:26you know, whatever percent larger, whatever percent more

0:14:29to make, and increases their ASP, their average selling

0:14:32price, which is always a guidance point that like,

0:14:35analysts love to look at, because it means that for every,

0:14:39every amount of, ounce of effort they put into marketing,

0:14:41or whatever the case may be, the return is higher,

0:14:45'cause you've got that individual unit

0:14:46that's a higher price, and it really costs you

0:14:49roughly the same amount to sell that

0:14:51as it does anything else.

0:14:53It's like growing a tall tree versus a short tree.

0:14:55I mean, they're both trees, right?

0:14:57So there's a definite positivity around that

0:15:02that I've been seeing, that the bigger phones,

0:15:05people are loving them, they're taking them up,

0:15:07and they're buying more of them than ever.

0:15:10It is interesting and I think Apple is pretty good at this stuff, but it's always interesting

0:15:17to see them admit that their estimates were off.

0:15:21And it's like you said, that they've admitted that the mix of the Plus to the non-Plus 7,

0:15:27even though the regular iPhone 7, they said, was the best-selling model, the Plus sold

0:15:32better this year than it has, I guess, in the previous two years.

0:15:35And that's the highest mix of them, you know, then versus the other right?

0:15:40Makes me wonder in particular if the the the camera in particular

0:15:46I mean, it's gotta be right

0:15:49I mean, yeah sure part of it is just getting used to bigger size

0:15:52But the camera has to drive like X percent of it. Like I'm not I'm not pulling out a number

0:15:56Let's say 30% of the decisions to buy that phone where oh, it's got the better camera. So let's get that one, right?

0:16:03- Yeah, and it seems like something that

0:16:06you can see it when you're in the store.

0:16:10Like if you go in the store and you're on the fence

0:16:12over whether to get an iPhone 7 or 7 Plus,

0:16:15starting this year, you can tell just by looking,

0:16:18without even trying the camera, it looks different, right?

0:16:21It's double the size.

0:16:22It looks like, you know, you can see that it has,

0:16:26like the previous years, the Plus models

0:16:28had the optical image stabilization.

0:16:30Starting with the 6, it was for stills,

0:16:33and then the success added it for video.

0:16:37That's a great feature, especially for video.

0:16:41I mean, it's almost unbelievable how good

0:16:45some of my little home family videos come out now

0:16:48because of image stabilization on video.

0:16:51But you can't see it in the store,

0:16:56so it's just a bullet point, and everybody is, I think,

0:17:01you build up an immunity to bullet points

0:17:04because every time you buy anything,

0:17:05whether it's a car or a toaster oven,

0:17:09everything has bullet points.

0:17:11Here's the features that your coffee maker has.

0:17:1412 cups has an alarm.

0:17:17- Makes coffee. - Right, makes coffee.

0:17:19Whereas you just look at the back of the 7 Plus

0:17:25and the idea that the camera is better on this one

0:17:29than the smaller one, it seems visceral

0:17:31because you just look at it.

0:17:32I can't help but think that that actually successfully

0:17:35bumped sales of this, which in turn makes me think

0:17:39that if, you know, they may not be done,

0:17:43this might just be the start of the bigger,

0:17:46more expensive iPhone having tangibly better

0:17:49camera technology, just because it seems like it's proof

0:17:53that it can drive sales.

0:17:54- I think you're right.

0:17:56There are two things that I think are really driving this.

0:18:00I'm 100% agree that the difference could actually,

0:18:03the physical difference, the way it looks,

0:18:05could definitely make a big difference.

0:18:08You're right on there.

0:18:09I know there will be people that listen to this

0:18:12and they'll laugh, they'll be like, oh yeah,

0:18:14people are just looking at the back of it

0:18:15and going, oh yeah, this one's bigger,

0:18:17got a bigger camera thingy on it and I'm gonna buy that.

0:18:20But I think people would be shocked,

0:18:23especially people that listen to this show,

0:18:24which the subset of people that are in the world

0:18:27listed to the show. You know, how much higher technical savvy than average, probably do

0:18:33a lot more research on products than average. You know, if you were doing a demographic

0:18:37survey, I think that none of these things would be surprising, right? But I think people

0:18:41underestimate very heavily how little research people do when they go to buy stuff in a store.

0:18:46Like they'll go to the store to get a phone, not having looked at a single thing online

0:18:50or asked anybody or whatever, and they'll just go and they'll just like, "I want the

0:18:55the best along X or Y personal axis, you know?

0:19:00Best camera or most storage or whatever, honestly,

0:19:03whatever most recent problem they had

0:19:05is probably how they pick.

0:19:07And I've seen this myself, I used to work in big box retail

0:19:10and I've sold a lot of different things over the years

0:19:13but one of the times I was selling digital cameras,

0:19:17especially, this was like early,

0:19:19in the early digital camera days, very early.

0:19:21And somebody comes in and is looking like a Mavica,

0:19:24like a Sony Mavica, which is one of the ones that took the floppy disks. You would throw

0:19:28those in there. And you know, they, honestly, nine times out of ten all they want is which

0:19:34one has the biggest number on the box. They would literally look at the boxes and they

0:19:38go, "Oh, this one has ten, that one has eight." And you're like, "Well, yes, but the one that's

0:19:42-- I mean, if you're an honest person, you go, "The one that's eight that's slightly

0:19:46less is actually better for you because, I don't know, it has this swivel thing and you

0:19:50really need that for whatever you're doing. But if you don't have that person there, that

0:19:55decision is getting made based on the number on the box, right? Hey, that's 10. This one's

0:19:598. I'll get the 10, right? I have the money. That's fine. Let's go. And I think that people

0:20:04make those decisions that way a lot more than most people think. And even though Apple store

0:20:10employees are theoretically better informed than your average big box retailer, they don't

0:20:15have the time. Apple stores are more crowded than ever. People are making decisions without

0:20:19intervention by an employee and just asking the employee to set it up for them.

0:20:23And hopefully the employee maybe intervenes at some point if they feel

0:20:26it's the wrong product for them and tries to switch them to something that

0:20:29is, but there's no guarantees. So I think that literally the physical difference

0:20:34in the camera could make a real big difference for people because of those

0:20:38reasons. And it seems silly or obvious or whatever, but people are silly

0:20:45and obvious when they buy.

0:20:46You know, that's just,

0:20:48the vast majority of consumers are that way.

0:20:51- And I think it's also telling how long

0:20:53Apple has stuck with the shot on iPhone ad campaign.

0:20:58You know, and Schiller said it when he was on my show,

0:21:02I forget if it was last year or the first time,

0:21:05two years ago, where I think it was--

0:21:07- It's a name drop, I like it.

0:21:09- But I asked him, like, I think it was two years ago,

0:21:12'cause I think last year it was so obvious

0:21:14it was too late to ask, but I just said,

0:21:16do you consider Apple one of the leading camera companies

0:21:21in the world, and his answer was the leading camera company

0:21:24in the world.

0:21:25I mean, it's totally how he sees the importance

0:21:28of the camera on the phone.

0:21:31And I really, there's no other explanation I can think of

0:21:33for why the mix of plus to non-plus would grow up this year.

0:21:38'Cause one of the big complaints about the iPhone 7

0:21:40is that it quote-unquote looks just like the iPhone 6

0:21:43and success that it's otherwise,

0:21:44I just, it just seems like obvious.

0:21:49- Yeah, and it's a great lever to get people

0:21:55to buy that bigger phone even though they don't want

0:21:58the bigger screen, you know, because people are often

0:22:00just shocked by how large it is physically

0:22:03when they hold it.

0:22:04You know, if I hand somebody, I have a seven now,

0:22:06but like I often use a seven plus,

0:22:09especially when I'm traveling,

0:22:10and so if I hand it to somebody, they're,

0:22:11oh man, this is big.

0:22:12if they've never used one or held one.

0:22:14But it's a testament to how driven by camera people are

0:22:20when they'll put up with that, so to speak.

0:22:23And knowing how hard the camera team at Apple

0:22:28had to push to make this thing even work,

0:22:32the dual camera thing,

0:22:34which is fairly, it's a really significant

0:22:36technical achievement.

0:22:38And if some other company had done this,

0:22:41I mean Apple, they toot their own horn a lot, right?

0:22:44But if some other company had done this,

0:22:46they would have tooted it 10 times as much.

0:22:49'Cause it's actually a very, very, very, very difficult

0:22:51technical problem that they achieved here.

0:22:53And out of everything in the camera,

0:22:55or excuse me, out of everything in the phone,

0:23:01the camera is really the only thing

0:23:03that's pushing the processor to its limits,

0:23:07to its absolute peak limits right now.

0:23:10You know, I mean, a game or whatever the case may be, they know what the limits are and

0:23:14they work within those. But most games on average that people play aren't really pushing

0:23:19that hard. Games is probably the number two category. But above that and far above anything

0:23:25else that most people do on their phones or most of the capabilities of the phone, which

0:23:29are pretty well known by now, the camera in that 7 Plus with its dual lens and twin capture

0:23:37and blending of the pair of photos and all of the stuff that it does, it really is pushing

0:23:43very, very hard that A-Series chip. So it's like a leading driver of the power, the chip

0:23:50power that's in the phone because that chip does and has done everything it needs to do

0:23:56for most people for a very long time, you know, for several generations. And so it's

0:24:01driving forward the processing capability and power of the phone and I think it's,

0:24:06you know, driving sales along with it.

0:24:08- And it was clearly instrumental in the portrait mode,

0:24:13or is, you know, like why, you know,

0:24:16why did portrait mode and the dual mode thing

0:24:19ship this year?

0:24:20I mean, part of it was, I think,

0:24:22that the camera engineering, just the camera itself,

0:24:24it took a long time.

0:24:26I think it's complicated, and just the algorithm

0:24:30of how are you going to use these two lenses

0:24:33for zooming and et cetera, et cetera.

0:24:36But I think another part of it too

0:24:38was that it was coincident with the A-series chip

0:24:41getting fast enough that you can do this on the fly.

0:24:43- From what I know about how long it took them

0:24:46to build this, and obviously everybody knows

0:24:49that it didn't ship with the phone, right?

0:24:51It shipped several weeks later.

0:24:53I don't think that was strategic.

0:24:55I think it was necessary.

0:24:57It was absolutely necessary for them

0:24:59to actually make it work, like finish it,

0:25:02and get it to work.

0:25:03And that doesn't happen if you've been able to do it

0:25:05for a processor generation.

0:25:07- Right. - Like that was it.

0:25:08- You literally, Matthew Banserino,

0:25:10were the first person I knew who had access to it

0:25:12'cause you got a pre-release version of it

0:25:15at least a couple of days ahead of the beta coming out.

0:25:18And you had like a nice little exclusive on TechCrunch

0:25:23with adorable pictures of your daughter.

0:25:25But they were really, well, they chose well

0:25:29because you've got a background in photography,

0:25:32so you're not just sitting there

0:25:33shooting pictures of your, I don't know,

0:25:36your desk or whatever.

0:25:38- Yeah. - But I think you could,

0:25:40even when it first came out and they let us use the beta,

0:25:43there were performance problems with it

0:25:46that have since been ironed out,

0:25:47and now it just, there is a sort of, it just works.

0:25:50You put it in portrait mode, the preview is live,

0:25:52the phone doesn't get hot, and it just works.

0:25:55- Yeah, that stuff is being iterated on as we speak.

0:25:58Like, you and I are talking right now, it's four o'clock.

0:26:01I'm sure the camera team is still working on updates to that thing, right?

0:26:05Because it's a living document, you know, in terms of the way that it performs.

0:26:11The edge detection gets better every iteration, and the blur effect gets more organic and more natural.

0:26:17You know, they're able to push that processor via optimization, because obviously the hardware hasn't changed, right?

0:26:22So they are able to optimize the processes further, so they're able to do more and more complex calculations on that.

0:26:27that. But it really is bleeding edge stuff. Like there, nobody else is pushing this hard.

0:26:32And people were very quick, you know, when I published that preview and then eventually

0:26:36when we did the review of the phone and stuff like that, people were very quick to say,

0:26:41"Oh, you know, well this model or that model from some other brand has been doing this

0:26:44for years, yada, yada." It's true that other brands have done this faux blur thing, but

0:26:53not in this way and not to this level of sophistication.

0:26:56And to be honest, even though some of the results

0:26:58were kind of hinky up front,

0:27:00you know it's gonna get better

0:27:01because they're dedicated to making it better

0:27:03and they know this is a primary driver of purchases.

0:27:07Whereas a lot of these other phones,

0:27:09it was a one-off gimmick to try and sell phones that quarter

0:27:13and really is gonna get no significant updates

0:27:15in the future, you know?

0:27:17And it's a shame, but nobody else is really driving

0:27:19like that.

0:27:20works sort of backwards, right? From like, "Oh, you know, what do we think the market

0:27:25wants this quarter? Let's try to produce that." And then, you know, they're--I'm not saying

0:27:30that their products are not, you know, solid or, you know, decent or whatever if they don't

0:27:35explode. But there is a drive there to get that kind of stuff right because they know

0:27:44that this is the thing that people want. It's not what they say they want which is more

0:27:50megapixels or sharper images or these crude terms that they use to describe it. It's actually

0:27:56they want their pictures to look more like pictures. And that's a really nebulous thing

0:28:00until you sort of figure out how to define that. I think they spend a lot of time trying

0:28:04to define that for people.

0:28:06Yeah, I also think it is the clearest path that I can think of, because I fail in certain

0:28:14and other forms of imagination of how can the iPhone

0:28:18continue to get better?

0:28:19There are some little things like the True Tone color

0:28:26that the iPad Pro has, that would be great

0:28:29to eventually have it on the iPhone too.

0:28:32But I can't see the display quality-wise

0:28:38getting radically better, so much so that it would,

0:28:40that's why you'd get a new phone.

0:28:42everybody is, there's rumors that are rampant

0:28:44that the industrial design is gonna change

0:28:46and they're gonna get rid of the head and forehead

0:28:48and just sort of go from a top to bottom,

0:28:50left to right, edge to edge display.

0:28:53And visually that would be very striking.

0:28:56If it looks super cool, then I could see that driving sales.

0:29:00But how many, after you do that, how does it keep going?

0:29:03Whereas the camera can continue to get better

0:29:06every 12 months, maybe not in a radical way

0:29:09because you run up into limits of physics,

0:29:11but, you know, and lens optics.

0:29:14But in a tangible way, and that if you're only,

0:29:17if you're on like a two or three year upgrade cycle,

0:29:19you can get a radically better camera

0:29:21every time you upgrade to a new phone.

0:29:22That, to me, could continue to drive sales

0:29:26about where we are right now for the iPhone

0:29:28for years to come.

0:29:29- Yeah, yeah.

0:29:33There's not much else for them to chip away at.

0:29:36And I think there will be new opportunities

0:29:40in other categories that may even involve the camera,

0:29:43AR, augmented reality, or VR, whatever the case.

0:29:47But as far as the on-device components,

0:29:51they're pretty well along towards diminishing returns.

0:29:56So yeah, I agree, camera's a primary driver there.

0:30:01- All right, let me take a break here

0:30:02and thank our first sponsor.

0:30:03It's a new sponsor, I'm very excited about this company.

0:30:05It's a company called Ministry of Supply.

0:30:08Ministry of Supply makes performance dress clothes.

0:30:13What does that mean?

0:30:14Well, it was launched by a bunch of,

0:30:16a group of former engineering students from MIT.

0:30:21And they make fabrics, performance fabrics,

0:30:25the type of things that are on like gym clothes.

0:30:27But they use them to make dress clothes,

0:30:31like stuff that you'd wear to work.

0:30:33They are breathable, they are flexible,

0:30:36they are way more comfortable.

0:30:38totally feel different, even less resist,

0:30:42they're even more resistant to wrinkles,

0:30:43shouldn't say less resistant, more resistant.

0:30:46They sent me some samples, they sent me a jacket,

0:30:48really nice jacket and a very nice dress shirt.

0:30:50The dress shirt is really, really nice.

0:30:54Feels great, looks great.

0:30:56And even when I took it out of the box,

0:30:59my wife even commented on the shirt,

0:31:01she was like, whoa, what is that?

0:31:03Because it just looks a little different,

0:31:04not like in terms of weird, but just sort of like

0:31:07like a nice sheen to it. It was very, very nice. They also sent me some socks, just socks,

0:31:11and they're very comfortable socks. So here's what—one of the examples. Men's Future Forward

0:31:19Dress Shirt. I think that's the one they sent me. It regulates your body temperature based on

0:31:24your surroundings, keeps you warmer when it's cold, keeps you cooler when it's warm. Their

0:31:29dress shots are made out of coffee fibers that whisk, sweat, and absorb odor. They provide

0:31:35extreme cushion and are shockingly comfortable. I can vouch for that. The socks are super

0:31:39comfortable. No risk. They offer free shipping, free returns, and a 100-day no questions asked

0:31:46return policy. So you can buy your clothes, get your shirt, find out it's the slightly wrong size.

0:31:52Maybe you should have gotten one a little smaller, a little bigger. Send it back totally free, up to

0:31:56up to 100 days, couldn't be better.

0:31:59Go to their website, is ministryofsupply.com/thetalkshow.

0:32:04Ministryofsupply.com/thetalkshow.

0:32:11And what they'll do if you go there

0:32:14is they will send you a free pair

0:32:17of their moisture-wicking dress socks

0:32:19for free, a $15 value with your first purchase.

0:32:23And they also have seven retail stores,

0:32:25including Bethesda, Maryland, Chicago, and Atlanta,

0:32:29and you can go into their retail stores

0:32:30if there's one near you,

0:32:31and just mention the talk show when you check out

0:32:35and you'll get that same free pair of socks.

0:32:37So my thanks to Ministry of Supply.

0:32:39Great, great sponsor, love it.

0:32:42Really, really cool stuff.

0:32:44What next on the results front?

0:32:47iPad, maybe.

0:32:49iPad sales were 16 million last year the same quarter

0:32:53and down to 13 million this quarter.

0:32:55I don't know what to make of that.

0:32:59- I don't know.

0:33:01I mean, I think that,

0:33:02I think we're still trying to find the replacement cycle,

0:33:10and the bottom of it, you know, the, what do you call it?

0:33:16The bottom of the pendulum arc.

0:33:18- Yeah.

0:33:19- But where it starts to swing back up

0:33:20that people repurchase or stabilizes anyway.

0:33:23Yeah, I don't know.

0:33:26I mean, I think that there's two schools of thought on this.

0:33:28I think you could argue that iPads are built really well

0:33:32and they handle single tasks.

0:33:35And it's sort of like you got a,

0:33:37Apple sold a framing hammer to someone to hang pictures.

0:33:42Right?

0:33:47So like, you go to the hardware store,

0:33:49There's five kinds of hammer there.

0:33:51There's a picture hanging hammer,

0:33:54which comes in a little plastic bubble pack,

0:33:59and it's got a few finish nails and the hammer.

0:34:02And it's like if you hammer anything bigger

0:34:04than a teeny-tiny nail into plaster or whatever,

0:34:08it just, the head falls off, right?

0:34:10And you go all the way up the scale

0:34:12through all the different hammers to a framing hammer.

0:34:13And a framing hammer is a hammer that slams in

0:34:1710-pinning nails to 2x4s or 2x6s on a construction lot, right? The framing hammer is reinforced.

0:34:24It's got like a long tang that's really thoroughly embedded in the head. And when you swing that

0:34:30thing, bang, it's got a waffle head so you know the nail got nice and trunk down and

0:34:36you can see that you got your imprint on that board so you know the nail's driven all the

0:34:39way home. And you could just wail away on that for 10 years and that hammer will last

0:34:43right? So Apple sold people framing hammers and they're, they're hammering in picture

0:34:50frames. So you've got, you know, a ten-year-old or five-year-old or heck even a teenager or

0:34:59an adult who uses it to browse the web and for a variety of different apps that don't

0:35:04really push the capabilities of the iPad in any significant way. And they're like, "This

0:35:08this is fine, why can't I just keep using this?

0:35:11Because that framing hammer is nowhere near its limits.

0:35:15And so I think that there's, that's one school of thought

0:35:18that the iPad is significantly overbuilt

0:35:21for the tasks that most people use it for.

0:35:24And then the other school, I think, the other side of it,

0:35:27is Apple has not done as good of a job as it could

0:35:32explaining to people how much they can do

0:35:34with that framing hammer.

0:35:35Like they haven't sold it as a framing hammer.

0:35:37And so I think that there's definitely some interesting

0:35:40debates to be had there.

0:35:41I don't even know where I fall on that scale yet.

0:35:43I'm of two minds about it,

0:35:45but I think those are the kind of arguments

0:35:47that people are having about where the iPad is currently.

0:35:50And then on top of that, you have this,

0:35:52hey, we don't know how long it's gonna be

0:35:56before people need to or want to replace an iPad

0:35:58that they don't break.

0:35:59Ever since the iPad 2 or 3 or whatever,

0:36:03iPad AR I guess you'd say, it's been pretty capable.

0:36:07- Yeah. - So why replace it?

0:36:10- Yeah, I think it starts with the iPad Air.

0:36:13I feel like up until then, it was still improving rapidly.

0:36:18I mean, the first one is the first one.

0:36:19I mean, you know, it was, you know, wow,

0:36:22it's a tablet that people might actually buy,

0:36:24but it was super thick, it didn't have retina.

0:36:26And then it got thinner, and then it got retina,

0:36:29but the iPad 3 that had retina actually got thicker

0:36:32than the iPad 2 that was before it,

0:36:34and it was replaced by Apple six months after it came out,

0:36:37which is sort of ridiculous in hindsight.

0:36:40It just shows how far they were pushing themselves

0:36:42to get that Retina iPad 3 out.

0:36:45And then I really feel like it found itself

0:36:49with the iPad Air, where they shrank the sides on the sides.

0:36:53And the A series chips had gotten,

0:36:57I'm sorry about that, that launched Siri again on my phone

0:37:01by saying A series. (laughing)

0:37:05- I'm sorry, I apologize to anybody out there who's--

0:37:07- Hey, Siri.

0:37:09- Hey, Dingus was activated.

0:37:11But, and I just feel, like my working hypothesis

0:37:17on the weird trajectory of iPad sales,

0:37:20weird meaning it, you know, at one point

0:37:22was like 20 million a quarter, and it was faster,

0:37:26it was never above the iPhone,

0:37:28but it was above the iPhone at that date since launch.

0:37:33like the first iPad outsold the first iPhone,

0:37:36the second iPad, iPad 2, outsold the iPhone 3G.

0:37:40And then it came down to earth.

0:37:43And my working theory on this is simply

0:37:46pretty much what you said,

0:37:47that there was this great unfilled need.

0:37:50Steve Jobs was right, that there was this middle territory

0:37:53for something like an iPad in people's lives,

0:37:57and there was nothing like it, right?

0:37:58The phones were too small,

0:38:01And laptops are, you know, they are great for certain things, but they're impersonal

0:38:08enough and the form factor is such that it, you know, it creates this void that the iPad

0:38:15actually does fill.

0:38:16But then once people got one, especially of the Air Vintage or later, that's it.

0:38:21They don't need another one until they, you know, break the other one.

0:38:24- Mm-hmm.

0:38:25Yeah, I mean, if you look at it from the terms of like, hey, Steve introduces the iPad and

0:38:30and says, "We think people are gonna love this,

0:38:32"people need this."

0:38:33And that was, if you ascribe to the histories of it,

0:38:38the iPad was the goal, and the iPhone was an ancillary thing

0:38:42that they hit on.

0:38:44But if you go back to that, and you say,

0:38:48you have them walk on stage and say,

0:38:50"We think that this is going to be, you know,

0:38:53"in 10 years or whatever," what is it now, 2010,

0:38:57so seven years.

0:38:59in seven years this is going to be a total of $300 million business for Apple which is

0:39:05about what iPads are, maybe a little more now, right? People would have been like overjoyed,

0:39:10right? $300 million, you know, there's 300 million units, excuse me, $300 million, significantly

0:39:17more dollars. But you know, you look at the amount total that you sold and these billions

0:39:23of dollars of, you know, business that the iPad created, you would go, "Hey, that's an

0:39:27an entire company, more than an entire company's worth of value that you're going to create

0:39:32for Apple and shareholders and whatever else. That is more than great. And it is only because

0:39:38the iPhone has been so, you know, outsized popular and now we know continues to grow

0:39:47that the iPad looks paltry in comparison. Like you're judging it--

0:39:49And because it had those go-go early years.

0:39:51Yeah, yeah. Exactly. Exactly.

0:39:52Where it was--

0:39:53- Exactly, a real ramp up, fastest selling computer,

0:39:57or fastest selling consumer electronics device.

0:40:00I think maybe they connect beat it for a time

0:40:02and then it, I don't know, don't quote me.

0:40:04But one of the fastest anyway,

0:40:06selling consumer electronics devices of all time.

0:40:09And it just, yeah, you look at those boom years

0:40:12and you go, oh man, now it's going down or whatever.

0:40:16But iPads, they still sold 13 million of those

0:40:21in the last quarter, which is crazy.

0:40:22- And if you had-- - It's still

0:40:23an enormous business.

0:40:24- And it is Apple's answer

0:40:28to the sub-thousand dollar computer market, right?

0:40:32Like, let's just admit that the phone is a phone,

0:40:34and even Apple, you know, smartphone is the most important

0:40:38device in the computer industry it's ever come up with.

0:40:41And even Apple, I think even as much as Apple knew

0:40:44with the 10 year ago introduction of the iPhone

0:40:46that they had something special on their hands,

0:40:48I think that even Apple itself was surprised at

0:40:51just how useful a smartphone could be

0:40:53and how much we would depend on it as our primary device.

0:40:57If you just think of the iPad,

0:41:00if they called it the MacPad instead of iPad

0:41:03and you discounted it with Mac sales as PC,

0:41:07I don't think that's a ridiculous comparison to make,

0:41:10that there are people who are going to go drop $500

0:41:14on a portable computer.

0:41:15Well, they're not gonna buy a MacBook

0:41:17because there is no system that's a $500 MacBook,

0:41:19but they might get an iPad Pro or an iPad Air or whatever.

0:41:24If you add up those 13 million iPad sales

0:41:31to the Mac's five million sales,

0:41:33that's 18 million personal computers that Apple sold

0:41:36in the whatever price range from iPad

0:41:39to most expensive Mac, it's pretty impressive.

0:41:44But I do think that it's sort of gonna,

0:41:47think it's already settled into sort of a Mac-like static number of how many million

0:41:52they can sell a quarter.

0:41:53Steve: You know, so the analogy, the cars and trucks analogy, where a car's a, you know,

0:42:02lightweight computer and a truck is a desktop or whatever. I mean, people often view the

0:42:09iPad as the car and, you know, that's--and then set the iPhone aside. But I think it's

0:42:14It's interesting to rejigger that a little bit

0:42:16and view the iPhone as the car.

0:42:18The iPhone's your daily driver.

0:42:22You name me a day, you don't touch your iPhone.

0:42:25It's possible.

0:42:26If you lost it, you broke it, you don't touch it.

0:42:29Other than that, you touch it every day.

0:42:31So that's your car.

0:42:32The desktop stays the truck.

0:42:34The question then is, is the iPad your utility vehicle?

0:42:40your utility vehicle or is it your sports car? In other words, do you like take it out

0:42:48on the weekends to get work done or do you take it out on the weekends for fun? And I

0:42:52think that there's whatever the case, whatever side of that you come down on, I think there's

0:42:56definitely a case to be made for the iPad as like a purpose-driven device that, I mean,

0:43:02you know, there are whole companies built up around like Revel Systems and other things

0:43:05that are built up around using the iPads to serve functions.

0:43:10And a large portion of its business

0:43:14is driven by institutional sales, right?

0:43:17Like schools and other things that use the iPads

0:43:20in very specific ways.

0:43:22And I think that there's the netbook arena or whatever,

0:43:27when you remember the netbook era in schools

0:43:29when everybody was like,

0:43:29"Oh, we'll just buy netbooks for the kids."

0:43:31And those things were just so bad, like so bad.

0:43:35- Garbage. - Yeah, garbage.

0:43:38- Garbage.

0:43:39It was very funny to me because,

0:43:43I mean, my son is now in seventh grade,

0:43:45but as a 13-year-old, he's sort of,

0:43:47like an interesting age technology-wise

0:43:51because when he first started going to school,

0:43:55it was, it wasn't quite 10 years ago,

0:43:58but 2008, nine, whatever,

0:44:02his school had a lot of,

0:44:04I don't know if they were called netbooks,

0:44:05but effectively they were.

0:44:07That's what a lot of the devices they had.

0:44:08And all the kids knew they were junk.

0:44:11Like, 'cause it's so funny to me

0:44:13because I remember when I was a kid,

0:44:15getting access to any computer in school was,

0:44:18it was like, all of a sudden I'm pumped,

0:44:22just pumped full of dopamine and I'm on, yes.

0:44:25And yes, there were ones that were better than others

0:44:27and newer than others and there were even some of the,

0:44:31some of the classes, I mean it was so ad hoc

0:44:33at the elementary school I went to,

0:44:35There were, some teachers had like a TI-99-4A

0:44:38or whatever it was called, which was a total piece of junk.

0:44:40I mean, it ran off a literal cassette tape drive,

0:44:43but I loved it.

0:44:44It was just so funny to me to see first graders

0:44:47who thought that, didn't even wanna use the netbooks

0:44:49because they were such a piece of junk.

0:44:51- Right, and they can, it's like they can tell.

0:44:56They can tell, everybody can tell.

0:44:58And if you look at the iPad that way,

0:45:01and you look at it like, hey,

0:45:03no matter what your, I mean, you know,

0:45:06there are some people that can't afford any computer at all

0:45:08and that's, you know, to be, that's a different problem

0:45:13or different discussion to be had, right?

0:45:15But if you can afford a computer,

0:45:18almost nearly the first computer you could afford

0:45:20is either a subsidized iPhone or an unsubsidized iPad, right?

0:45:24And I think that if you, you could look at like Chromebooks

0:45:28and a lot of those other things as sort of

0:45:30those companies' efforts to do that,

0:45:33lower the barrier to get somebody to using their computer/using the web in Google's case

0:45:39using their services and using their connected, you know, their connected services that carry

0:45:44advertising and whatever the case may be. In Apple's case, it's the same thing. It's

0:45:49like we want people to be into the Apple ecosystem so we can teach them about how good Apple

0:45:54could be for them and what, you know, what an Apple computer feels like versus another

0:45:58computer and I think the iPad is a good ambassador that way. And so if it always exists, if it

0:46:04levels out at some point, because we haven't seen any leveling out, I think that's the

0:46:09big question marks that everybody is seeing right now. Because once the true replacement

0:46:14cycle starts to kick in and/or Apple finds a way to revitalize it in some significant

0:46:19way where we get a new spike that resets the bar and then it slopes downwards from there

0:46:25as everybody adopts the new thing. Whatever the case may be, I think there will be a point

0:46:30where it eventually levels out and we see what kind of business the iPad business actually

0:46:35is and will be long term. And I think that business will always be characterized by its

0:46:41ability to give people expanded computing capabilities at far less price than in a MacBook.

0:46:49And that's what it will always be for Apple. And Apple could preach about what it could

0:46:54be for artists and what it could be for creatives and all this other stuff and that's great.

0:46:59Now hopefully they continue to serve those people by pushing the capabilities of the

0:47:02device, but the vast majority of sales in the category are not that. There's not 13

0:47:08million artists buying it for pencils. That's not the way it works.

0:47:14Dave Asprey The number I pointed out, well one of the

0:47:16numbers I pointed out was that just looking at revenue, last year iPad was above Mac and

0:47:24services by like a little bit for Mac and about a billion dollars in revenue for the

0:47:29same quarter last year. And as of this year, the numbers announced today, the Mac did $7.2

0:47:38billion in revenue and iPad was down to $5.5 billion and services were up from $6 billion

0:47:44to $7.2 billion. Again, I'm not a doom and gloom on iPad, but I think it just goes to

0:47:51show how the mix of the price points that are selling at iPad are low. I think that

0:47:58the, you know, and I think iPad Pro is a successful product, but I think it's going to be most

0:48:03successful in years to come as it trickles down, you know, the original iPad Pros trickle

0:48:08down to the lower price points. And I think it's clear since the Macs, like unit sales

0:48:14are just about dead even, but the revenue was up quite a bit that the MacBook Pros,

0:48:20new ones sold pretty well for the first quarter. And I don't even think that that, they weren't

0:48:24even out for the whole quarter.

0:48:25- Right. Yeah, they weren't. And when you look at that trickle-down effect, I mean,

0:48:31you look at the iPad Pro, especially the larger one, and how much capability, I mean, easily

0:48:38at, on par, utility-wise, at least in the specific utilities, with Cintiq, you know,

0:48:49from Wacom that were several thousand dollars more

0:48:54and frankly worse.

0:48:56You know, the pencil tracking was not nearly

0:48:59what it is on the iPad and the screen does not have

0:49:02the color rendition and accuracy of the iPad Pro.

0:49:05And you look at all that and you look at,

0:49:06as that trickles down, you're gonna see those

0:49:09pro devices being, giving people access,

0:49:15artists and other creatives access to those capabilities

0:49:18in ways that just were not even heard of.

0:49:21And I think Apple doesn't get credit for that stuff

0:49:23because people wanna see,

0:49:26in the business and tech writing world,

0:49:28people wanna see those results in the numbers.

0:49:31And it's like, oh, everybody must buy that iPad Pro

0:49:35and really drive up the sales and price

0:49:37and stuff every quarter.

0:49:38Whereas if you look at it in the arc of the game

0:49:41where it's like, hey, we're shipping this now in a year,

0:49:46it's gonna be really affordable

0:49:47and we're gonna sell a lot more of them,

0:49:49or a lot more of devices that have their capability,

0:49:52whatever they're gonna call them.

0:49:54And that arc, I think, is a very interesting one,

0:49:57and it's hard to message, right?

0:49:59'Cause people don't wanna hear,

0:50:02we're putting this thing out

0:50:03that not a lot of people are gonna buy,

0:50:05but more people will buy later when it's affordable.

0:50:07They wanna hear, oh, we're putting this thing out

0:50:09that people must buy now.

0:50:10- Yeah, yeah. - And, you know.

0:50:12- Right. - That's it.

0:50:13- Like anything short of an iPad

0:50:15that makes everybody just throw their old iPad in the garbage

0:50:18and go get in line to buy the new one is somehow a failure.

0:50:22But it doesn't really work that way.

0:50:24The only other thing I have from the results

0:50:27and from the notes of the conference call that I read

0:50:30was that Tim Cook pointed out that Apple Pay users

0:50:33are up three X year over year.

0:50:36So that's a really, that's a very good year for Apple Pay,

0:50:41especially since it's what, two years old now?

0:50:43Two and a half years old?

0:50:44And again, that's the other thing I had in my notes that is sort of like, hey, let's

0:50:50all remember that getting people to do something to like 2013 years, hey, you're going to

0:50:58pay for stuff by putting your fingerprint on a phone at the register on your cell phone.

0:51:05Sounds weird, right?

0:51:06It's like different and it's like, I don't know.

0:51:08I mean, I know enough about how it works.

0:51:11'cause I understand it, that it's,

0:51:12I actually understand that it's actually more secure

0:51:15than using a credit card, a lot more secure,

0:51:17if you're doing a magnetic swipe.

0:51:20But people always have the heebie-jeebies

0:51:25about putting their credit card into their phone

0:51:26or something like that.

0:51:27I mean, there are an awful lot of people

0:51:29who spent years not buying anything at all on the web

0:51:32because they didn't feel like they could trust it

0:51:34because it was new and different,

0:51:36and that's just the way humans are hooked up,

0:51:38for the most part, that new and different is scary,

0:51:41and therefore you wait.

0:51:42So 3X growth in Apple Pay, I guess,

0:51:46I didn't see the details on where exactly that is,

0:51:48like how much of that is in the US,

0:51:50how much of it is worldwide expansion.

0:51:52But I feel it's one of those stories that,

0:51:55in terms of hey, Apple hasn't done a goddamn thing

0:51:57under Tim Cook, that that crowd conveniently overlooks.

0:52:02That it's a really solid Tim Cook, Apple era success story.

0:52:07>> Yeah, I mean changing user behavior on something that has to do with their wallet,

0:52:13you know, their bank account or whatever, that's insanely hard. It's insanely hard.

0:52:18And so it is, it is encouraging to see things like that, that theoretically, you know, could

0:52:23be big bets. I mean, you know, when people had the inkling that they were going to get

0:52:27into payments, you know, people saw that as a, as a very big business for them. And I

0:52:32think it's still, you know, it already is somewhat of a business, another services category,

0:52:36and could be a much larger business in the future, especially if Apple's able to sell

0:52:42Apple Pay through and keep up this kind of growth. But the hurdles you have to overcome

0:52:50when you're switching over to something like Apple Pay are crazy. You come to the counter

0:52:56and you're going to pay with your phone and you're not quite sure where to put it and

0:53:01you're not how far away and what part of this credit card. So I put it where the credit

0:53:06card goes? Do I put it over the keypad? Do I put it over some weird symbol that I'm not

0:53:09familiar with? Do I put it on this clear plastic part? And people are embarrassed. They don't

0:53:14want to do that. First of all, there are people behind them.

0:53:17You don't like that. I hate it.

0:53:19It's still so early days that usually, like when I go to a place that, like I notice that

0:53:24they've upgraded their point of sale systems and I either see the Apple Pay logo or I see

0:53:29that little Wi-Fi looking logo that means it usually works. Apple Pay usually works

0:53:34even if they're not officially Apple Pay yet,

0:53:37that it just has contactless NFC payments.

0:53:42The clerk usually has no idea.

0:53:43They'll be like, "How are you gonna pay?"

0:53:45And I'll say, "I'm gonna try Apple Pay."

0:53:46And they'll say, "What's that?"

0:53:48I mean, I've had that happen,

0:53:49and I'm not afraid to do it because I know,

0:53:52A, I'm not embarrassed even if it doesn't work,

0:53:56and B, I'm not embarrassed that I might know more

0:54:00about how this works than the clerk,

0:54:01but somebody has to go first,

0:54:02and people are resistant to stuff like that.

0:54:05Here's a funny thing, this is true.

0:54:07I forget if I've mentioned this on the show before or not,

0:54:09but one of the places I go that just added

0:54:12a new point of sale system that supports Apple Pay

0:54:15are the state-run liquor stores here in Pennsylvania.

0:54:20And theirs very consistently

0:54:24doesn't work on the first try.

0:54:30Every single time, I put my phone there,

0:54:32I have my thumb on the sensor and it says,

0:54:35"Card not valid," or something's not valid,

0:54:38"Use card instead."

0:54:40But if I just sit there and lift my thumb

0:54:42and press it again, it goes ding,

0:54:44and then I get the payment.

0:54:46But how many people would even think to try that?

0:54:48Like, did, and every time, every single time I do it--

0:54:51- You. - Right.

0:54:52I just looked at the error message and I thought,

0:54:56well, that error message makes no sense,

0:54:57so I'm just going to try again.

0:54:59And I didn't ask the clerk for help or anything,

0:55:01I just sat there, I just moved the phone away,

0:55:03moved it back, and now every time I do it,

0:55:05it gets, it's the same thing.

0:55:06Anything else on earnings?

0:55:09- Yeah, that kind of finicky-ness doesn't translate well.

0:55:12- Yeah.

0:55:13Anything else on earnings before we move on?

0:55:15- Nothing ahead.

0:55:16- All right.

0:55:17Let me take a break then,

0:55:19and thank our next sponsor, it's our good friends,

0:55:22longtime sponsor of the show, Audible.

0:55:26Audible is the unmatched selection of audio content.

0:55:31Everybody thinks of them, I always do, I do.

0:55:36I think of them as the place you go for audio books.

0:55:40And they are the number one source

0:55:42in the world for audio books.

0:55:44But they really have expanded to just audio in general.

0:55:48They have their own audio shows, news, comedy,

0:55:52all sorts of stuff.

0:55:55You get a membership, number one,

0:55:57if you go to audible.com/talkshow,

0:55:59you'll get a 30-day free trial.

0:56:01So there you go, 30 days you can listen

0:56:02to everything you want at audible.com/talkshow.

0:56:06But it's just amazing how much stuff they have.

0:56:09And their stuff works on just about any device

0:56:11that you have that can play audio,

0:56:13you can play audible stuff.

0:56:15So even if you have an old iPod

0:56:18that you used to work out at the gym or something like that,

0:56:21it doesn't have to be a smartphone,

0:56:23you don't need a special app,

0:56:24You can just download the stuff to your Mac and sync it over to an old iPod or Kindle

0:56:30or anything like that that can play audio, and it'll work.

0:56:34Audio content is so great.

0:56:36If you're listening to me to sell you on Audible right now, you obviously listen to audio content.

0:56:43You obviously listen to really long podcasts.

0:56:45You probably have more time on your commute or wherever it is that you listen.

0:56:50You want to fill it with more good stuff, go to audible.com/talkshow.

0:56:54will find it. So, my thanks to Audible for sponsoring the show. Remember that URL,

0:56:57audible.com/talkshow, and you will get a 30-day free trial if you haven't got one yet.

0:57:03Here's some news, and it's interesting. It's a follow-up from last week's show. I had Ben

0:57:11Thompson on, and I mentioned an anecdote from a reader of the show, and I was a little nervous

0:57:15bringing it up because it was like one reader who wrote me this email. But he convinced me—it

0:57:24It really seemed like he knew what he was talking about.

0:57:27He wasn't just spitting in the wind.

0:57:29But he bought the new LG Ultrafine 5K display, the one

0:57:32that Apple co-developed.

0:57:35And it's the only retina standalone display

0:57:38you can get from Apple right now, these LG models.

0:57:42And he was having all sorts of problems with it.

0:57:45And for some reason, it occurred to him to try moving it.

0:57:48And he did.

0:57:49And it turns out that moving it away from his Wi-Fi router

0:57:52solved the problems.

0:57:53And I mentioned this on the show with Ben Thompson.

0:57:55Well, it seems like this is an actual thing.

0:57:59Zach Hall wrote a story at 9to5Mac, first-hand story,

0:58:04where the exact same thing happened with him,

0:58:07where he, and the problem was so bad,

0:58:10it was like actually crashing his MacBook.

0:58:12He had his MacBook hooked up to the 5K display,

0:58:15and it was like freezing his MacBook.

0:58:19He Googled a little bit, saw some,

0:58:22speculating about this, hey, it's near a WiFi router.

0:58:26His was near his WiFi router, so he moved it to a different,

0:58:29moved it away from his desk, and the problems all went away,

0:58:33and then he contacted LG, and LG said, yeah,

0:58:35just don't use it near a WiFi router.

0:58:37This is crazy.

0:58:40(laughing)

0:58:42- Well, I mean, why would a computer

0:58:44ever be near a WiFi router?

0:58:45- Right, right, it's, I can't help but think,

0:58:49especially in a home office, it's gotta be a frequent,

0:58:52a common scenario, you know, and anybody, you know, like--

0:58:56- Yeah, probably.

0:58:57- Anybody who's, like, lives in, like,

0:58:59a studio apartment or something like that,

0:59:01I mean, you may not even be able to move it that far away.

0:59:03You know, it's kinda crazy.

0:59:05And it just-- - Yeah, it's insane.

0:59:09Yeah.

0:59:11- I mean, the gist of-- - I guess we know how,

0:59:13exactly how closely co-developed it was now.

0:59:16- Yeah. (laughs)

0:59:18The gist of this display, I do not have one.

0:59:21I have a iMac here, so I'm not, a 5K iMac,

0:59:25so I'm not in the market for a standalone display.

0:59:27But I saw, I've seen them in the Apple stores,

0:59:28I saw them at the Apple event that you and I were at

0:59:31a couple months ago.

0:59:32And my impression, my firsthand impression

0:59:36of just looking at it from a kick the tires perspective

0:59:39was it's a gorgeous display in a really chintzy,

0:59:44but at least plain looking case.

0:59:47It doesn't, it's not an ugly, I don't think they're ugly,

0:59:50but they're not really, it's not sexy.

0:59:52Yeah, it's not sexy like an Apple product is.

0:59:55So like you're like, wow, that is, I want that.

0:59:57That is gorgeous even before you see it.

0:59:59But the display quality is excellent.

1:00:01And the convenience of just being able to plug in

1:00:05USB-C, Thunderbolt, and just have it work

1:00:07seems really great.

1:00:08But like you said, it seems pretty clear

1:00:11that the collaboration with Apple was not on the enclosure.

1:00:16So the chintzy-- - No, no, yeah, exactly.

1:00:20none of the shielding. (laughs)

1:00:21- The chintzy feeling and looking enclosure

1:00:24is also chintzelly shielded.

1:00:26I'm not an expert on shielding, but it seems to me

1:00:31like this is just emblematic of why

1:00:34there's a practical reason beyond just wanting

1:00:37to spend more money that a lot of us wish Apple

1:00:41were making its own Apple-branded 5K displays.

1:00:47- Yeah, I mean, the answers that I got with this stuff

1:00:51when I poked around, you know, like why the heck not,

1:00:53you know, is it's pretty much as hard as designing

1:00:58an entire system, so why do it?

1:01:01And it's, you know, or not why do it,

1:01:03it's not that attitude that I got, like who cares,

1:01:06it was more we have so many hours in the day

1:01:09and this is like designing a new iMac,

1:01:11so maybe we shouldn't do it this time, you know,

1:01:15and maybe we should put our efforts elsewhere.

1:01:17And I mean you could disagree or agree.

1:01:19I'm not saying yea or nay to their POV,

1:01:22but that's the input that I got.

1:01:25And that's not through official channels or anything,

1:01:27so this is not like a PR message.

1:01:29It's just a matter of like, it's really hard to build that,

1:01:33especially because of the throughput

1:01:36that you have to have to connect it to external displays.

1:01:39And if they wanted to do it the way

1:01:40that they wanted to do it normally,

1:01:42which probably would have worked close to a WiFi router,

1:01:44it would have taken them a lot of time and money

1:01:47and manpower to achieve.

1:01:49I guess the money's not really the problem,

1:01:51it's more the time and manpower.

1:01:53Taking somebody off of Macs or off of another department

1:01:58to work on that or hiring people in

1:02:00and then training them up through Apple University

1:02:03and blah, blah, blah to get to a point

1:02:05where they are able to work on those hardware products.

1:02:08They just felt they couldn't devote the time to it, I guess.

1:02:12I don't know, it's a hard one.

1:02:16Whether you want to fault them or not, I don't know.

1:02:21And obviously some people do, but for this,

1:02:24for which is that they have so much money,

1:02:27how can they possibly be stretched thin on resources?

1:02:31Now, whether that's an actual emblematic

1:02:34of a problem in their mindset,

1:02:36that they're still at an executive level,

1:02:38think too much like the small company,

1:02:39smaller company they used to be pre-iPhone,

1:02:42or whether it's actually bad management, I don't know.

1:02:46But it's obvious though that they are.

1:02:49Whether that's reasonable and that's a sign

1:02:52that for Apple to be Apple,

1:02:55that maybe the pro argument would be for Apple to be Apple,

1:02:59they have to continue to be like a small company

1:03:02that focuses on a few things

1:03:04because that's just how it works.

1:03:07The con argument would be it's just ridiculous

1:03:10they can't afford to put an engineering team together to do a display.

1:03:15But it's the proof, you know, whether it should be this way or not, they are.

1:03:20They're stretched thin.

1:03:21And I think that the decision not to do this, it's exactly along those lines.

1:03:26That if it's going to take us that much effort to do this, we put that effort somewhere else.

1:03:31Right.

1:03:32Yes.

1:03:33And you could hammer all day on the argument that, well, they should be able to afford

1:03:38the man hours or whatever the case. But yeah, that's the way it came down and that's why

1:03:43these decisions were made the way they are. As far as I know, I don't know. Maybe I'm

1:03:46wrong. But I think you reach a point where saying no becomes less about, "Oh, we're

1:03:55not going to pursue this new fun thing." And sometimes it comes down to, "We're not

1:04:02going to splinter ourselves in ways that make a lot of logical sense. Like it's much harder

1:04:11to say no to the things that makes--make a ton of sense than it is to say no to the things

1:04:16that have very obvious faults and flaws and whatever. You know, I mean, so many unknowns

1:04:22in a project can lead you to say no. So many things that say, "Hey, you know, we're down

1:04:28this pathway, we've spent a lot of money and whatever, those could be hard to say no to.

1:04:33But the ones that make total sense like, "Why wouldn't Apple make an external display?"

1:04:37Those are the ones that you're going to take the most heat over. Those are the ones that you're

1:04:42going to hopefully have to really come to, have a come to Jesus moment on and say, "We're not making

1:04:49them for these reasons that make a lot of sense to us and that we can't even message or, you know,

1:04:56don't want a message externally for whatever reason.

1:05:00If it is simply that they don't have enough people

1:05:04to work on it, man, it's hard.

1:05:08That's a hard thing to defend,

1:05:09but if they don't have them, they don't have them, right?

1:05:12What are you gonna do?

1:05:14You can't just hire a whole new random team

1:05:16full of random people to work on a high-profile

1:05:19hardware release because you're gonna have the same problem

1:05:22as the LG thing has.

1:05:23It's gonna have some weird dumb issue.

1:05:25I mean, as hard as Apple works on their stuff,

1:05:27there's always some weird dumb issue

1:05:28when they launch something, right?

1:05:29Because this stuff is difficult, and it's very complex.

1:05:33So if you're not gonna own that,

1:05:35and own whatever problems you come,

1:05:37you can't say, oh, we put our B team on this, right?

1:05:40Or we put the noobs on it.

1:05:41You just gotta say no.

1:05:42- I wouldn't be surprised if Apple

1:05:46doesn't do a standalone display, or to, you know, 4K and 5K.

1:05:51I don't know.

1:05:54I don't have any kind of like little birdie info

1:05:56that yes, they're coming.

1:05:58I have had little birdie info and other people have too

1:06:01that there were Apple branded displays

1:06:03in the works within Apple.

1:06:05Whether they're still moving forward,

1:06:07I have not heard anything, I don't know.

1:06:09So I don't have, I can't even whisper a secret on the show

1:06:13and say I've heard it.

1:06:14But I know that there were and I wouldn't be surprised

1:06:19if the story is, I mean, the one everybody seems to believe

1:06:23right now is Apple is out of the standalone display game,

1:06:26period, and we're never gonna have another one.

1:06:28Possible, I would not be surprised if there never

1:06:31is another standalone display.

1:06:32Other than treating the iMac, buying an iMac

1:06:37just to use as a standalone display with target display mode

1:06:40which is kind of ridiculous, the idea that you'd buy

1:06:42a computer you wouldn't use, but it does work.

1:06:47- I just also beg the question, how expensive is the display

1:06:52versus the other components in the device.

1:06:54So if your 5K display had to be 60% as expensive

1:06:59as a regular iMac, that's on the bubble.

1:07:02If it's 70% as expensive, who the hell's gonna buy it?

1:07:05So there's also that component cost angle

1:07:11that you gotta think about.

1:07:12- I wouldn't be surprised though if the story is simply,

1:07:15and again, on this theme of Apple can only do so much

1:07:18at a time and there's only so many resources for testing

1:07:21and for even just stuff like sales

1:07:24and training the entire retail staff

1:07:27on product design and stuff like that.

1:07:29I wouldn't be surprised if they're still in the works,

1:07:33but it was so clear that it wasn't gonna be done

1:07:36in time for October 2016,

1:07:39when they needed to have something to sell

1:07:41with the new MacBook Pros.

1:07:42They needed some sort of retina display

1:07:47that would work with USB-C and Thunderbolt 3.

1:07:51They couldn't get that done in time.

1:07:55LG could slap something together.

1:07:59And so that's what they did.

1:08:00And that maybe, but it won't,

1:08:03I think maybe it won't come out till like a year,

1:08:05like next year, like next October, October 2017,

1:08:09a year later, here's the new Apple,

1:08:11whatever they're gonna call it, 5K display.

1:08:14- Right. - And it doesn't--

1:08:15- It'll be hard to think that this would be

1:08:17their ambassador forever.

1:08:18- Right, it's really hard.

1:08:20I know that,

1:08:21it sounds funny, but I know John Siracusa

1:08:29has made this point on ATP several times.

1:08:31They're gonna make this brand new campus.

1:08:32It's gonna be, it's all Johnny Ive approved hallways

1:08:36and curved glass and lighting fixtures and desks.

1:08:41They're designing their own tables and all of this.

1:08:44And what are they gonna do?

1:08:45with LG displays on the engineer's desk.

1:08:48(laughing)

1:08:49It just seems ridiculous.

1:08:51I mean, for everybody that doesn't have an iMac.

1:08:53- That's such a John Sirk, he's a thing.

1:08:54- Right. - That's really funny.

1:08:55I like it. - But it does.

1:08:57So, other than Nellie Patel, Nellie is the one

1:09:00who based on, like, is off the record briefing

1:09:03at the event, said Apple said they're out of the game.

1:09:07I was told a little bit more like what you heard,

1:09:09which is what I asked.

1:09:12I was like, hey, does this, I just,

1:09:14I asked in a briefing, like, hey, is this LG display?

1:09:16Does that mean you're not gonna make a standalone display?

1:09:18And of course, I did not get an answer.

1:09:20(laughs)

1:09:21A masterful, completely prepared,

1:09:23they were obviously rehearsed on the point.

1:09:26Did not get a yes or no, but I got,

1:09:28this is the display we have to show you,

1:09:30you know, what we're selling now.

1:09:31This is the display that will be in our stores,

1:09:34that we'll have, you know, hooked up in a prominent space

1:09:38in all of our retail stores, so make of that what you will.

1:09:40And that making a standalone display today

1:09:43with all this stuff is as complicated as making

1:09:45a new iMac or something like that.

1:09:48That to me doesn't say never, but it does say to me,

1:09:52yes, you can buy the LG display now

1:09:55if you need a new display, and we're not going to

1:09:58come out with one in a couple of weeks

1:10:00or a couple of months.

1:10:01- I think it honestly, what it comes down to is

1:10:02if it makes sense, then they will.

1:10:05And it makes a lot of sense to me, that's all I know,

1:10:08that they would do it one day, but that that day wasn't now,

1:10:13and that they needed something to ship.

1:10:14I think you're totally right on that.

1:10:15- Yeah, it also seems to me,

1:10:16like in terms of allocating engineering and testing

1:10:19and all the other stuff for it,

1:10:20it seems to me like the sort of thing

1:10:22that they could get a lot of years out of,

1:10:23because they have in the past

1:10:24where they've come out with new,

1:10:26when they called them cinema displays

1:10:27or whatever the other product names were,

1:10:29they sold them, they'd come out with a new one

1:10:32and it would be great and maybe price competitive

1:10:34with other companies based on the technology of the day.

1:10:36And then Apple just keeps selling them at 9.99

1:10:39as the years go on and monitors from Dell

1:10:42and other companies improve or drop in price.

1:10:45And Apple can keep selling it 'cause it's Apple

1:10:48and people like to buy the Apple branded one

1:10:50and they'll pay a premium for it

1:10:52even if it's a couple of years old.

1:10:54It just seems to me that they're at a place

1:10:56with these displays where you don't need

1:11:00more pixels per inch, they're super bright,

1:11:03they've got amazing color, they've gotten

1:11:06to the wide color gamut.

1:11:10if Apple came out with it, I think I could see that they come out with one and sell it

1:11:14unchanged for three, four, five years. I mean, three is probably, I mean, three for sure.

1:11:20- Absolutely. I mean, the 5K is like, yeah, 5K is, it's getting close to paper resolution.

1:11:25I mean, you know, or even above if you count color rendition. And so it's just, there's

1:11:29not really a, there's not a lot of places to go from there. So if they make something,

1:11:36they could squeeze many, many years out of it. And really what would change would be,

1:11:40if there's another major change in input or output.

1:11:43- Yeah, I think that-- - Or throughput of a connector

1:11:45or whatever. - Yeah, I think that

1:11:46the display itself is least likely to be the,

1:11:49we need something to replace it,

1:11:52it's more likely to be the connector.

1:11:54- Yeah, it's like, oh, I can't believe this display

1:11:58doesn't have USB 8, you know, that kind of thing.

1:12:01(laughing)

1:12:03- Let me take one final break here

1:12:07and thank our third and final sponsor,

1:12:09long time friend of the show,

1:12:11maybe the longest running sponsor, Squarespace.

1:12:14Squarespace is the best place to go to build a new website.

1:12:19It's just an amazing product.

1:12:22I can't say enough good things about it.

1:12:25I mentioned Syracuse, I'll steal a talking point

1:12:28from Marco Arment, I love this idea,

1:12:30which is, hey, you're a nerd,

1:12:32you're listening to the talk show.

1:12:33You might need a website yourself,

1:12:34and if so, you should definitely look at Squarespace.

1:12:36You really should, it is amazing.

1:12:38But here's the bigger thing, it's such a great idea.

1:12:40You probably know someone.

1:12:41At some point this year, somebody you know

1:12:43is gonna come to you and say that they need a website.

1:12:46Maybe it's like a school group at your kid's school,

1:12:50or like some kind of community group,

1:12:53or a church, or something that you're involved with,

1:12:55and you're like, everybody knows you're the tech person.

1:12:58You're the nerd, and they're gonna come to you

1:13:00with help on this.

1:13:02Set 'em up with Squarespace.

1:13:03Go to Squarespace to get their site going,

1:13:05because A, it is a great service

1:13:06that you might consider using anyway.

1:13:09But B, because it's so easy to use

1:13:11and because Squarespace offers award-winning tech support

1:13:15that you can get right on the phone,

1:13:16if they do have a problem,

1:13:17they're gonna go to Squarespace and not go to you.

1:13:19So you can wash your hands of the problem.

1:13:21You'll give 'em a great website, they'll get a great price,

1:13:25and you'll be done.

1:13:26You won't be on the hook for when they need to add something

1:13:29or change it or whatever.

1:13:30They can just do it themselves.

1:13:31It is a great idea and a great point, I think,

1:13:34for the audience of a show like this.

1:13:36So make your next move with Squarespace.

1:13:39Go to squarespace.com and enter the code TALKSHOW,

1:13:43know the, just TALKSHOW, and you will get 10% off

1:13:46at checkout, it's a great, great service.

1:13:50Keep in mind next time you need a website,

1:13:51or next time anybody you know needs a website.

1:13:54Remember that code too, TALKSHOW.

1:13:56Here we go, deep breath.

1:14:00Wish I had a stiff drink,

1:14:02but instead I've just got fizzy water.

1:14:03(laughing)

1:14:05- I can't, we can't, I can't keep going,

1:14:08I can't do this without mentioning Trump's immigration order

1:14:11that came down last week and Silicon Valley's responses.

1:14:14And even if you wanna play the,

1:14:16let's not talk about politics,

1:14:18it's way too essential to the racket that we cover.

1:14:23It really, it hits home.

1:14:24I mean, it's a huge deal and I don't,

1:14:30I think it's hard to overstate how much of a reaction

1:14:35it's already gotten from companies like Apple

1:14:37and Google and et cetera.

1:14:40I saw Google had a big rally.

1:14:44- That's right, employees did.

1:14:47I've gotten so much hate mail over this, Jon.

1:14:55We cover politics and we cover the policies

1:15:00that affect tech, and we always have,

1:15:02we have for many years.

1:15:03But we've been covering so much more of it lately

1:15:06because so much more has been happening

1:15:08that's related to our industry that we cover

1:15:12and the companies that look to us for whatever reactions

1:15:17or whatever context that they want to have.

1:15:24And we've been writing about a significant amount

1:15:27of these things as they relate to individual companies

1:15:29And then also tech leaders speaking out and taking stances one way or another, pro and

1:15:35con and well very little pro, but how far con is a good question about how many of them

1:15:41have responded.

1:15:43And I just get, I mean I've gotten hate mail, I mean I always get hate mail, but I've gotten

1:15:49a lot over this.

1:15:50And people are like, "Why are you talking about politics?

1:15:52I don't come to you for that."

1:15:54People accusing us of being partisan in one direction or another depending on what article

1:15:58gets published and all this stuff. And, you know, I just ignore most of it. I may end

1:16:04up saying something about it at some point, but the long and short of it is that this

1:16:08is not a tech issue, it's not a politics issue, it's like a human issue. Like if you're a

1:16:15human, you should be interested in this stuff. And to be fair to our readers, like, I'm not

1:16:21instructing our writers and our writers are not doing it. They're not writing about stuff

1:16:25from a pure politics standpoint. We're not politico. Like, we're not just going like,

1:16:29"Hey, politics happened and look at politics." You know, we're definitely relating it to

1:16:33our industry, but the tech--I mean, the stuff that he's--that he's talking about with immigration

1:16:39and, you know, possible reduction or clamping down on H-1B visas which allow highly skilled

1:16:47tech workers to come over here, those are incredibly germane to the tech industry. From

1:16:51everybody from Apple to Google to Facebook and everybody else uses an enormous amount

1:16:56of H1B workers because there are a lot of highly skilled programmers that come from

1:17:02India, elsewhere in Asia and, you know, a wide variety of other countries that aren't

1:17:08here because our education system has a lot of flaws. So it's an incredibly germane issue

1:17:14and they're, you know, they're up in arms about it or, you know, up in some kind of

1:17:18arms, depending on how closely they're colluding with the current administration.

1:17:21Yeah, and they're doing the right thing where they've, all these big companies, the Googles,

1:17:28Apples, Microsofts, it's inevitable with the head counts that they have that they have hundreds of

1:17:34employees who are affected by this, that somewhere along the chain of their passport that they

1:17:40were born in or were once or still are a citizen of one of these seven countries.

1:17:47and might literally be out of the country right now

1:17:52in the way that this was implemented with.

1:17:54I just signed it and even if you're in the air right now,

1:17:57your band is, it's great that the companies

1:18:01have their employees' backs and are helping them,

1:18:02but it's interesting.

1:18:05I don't know, I don't, and I thought it was,

1:18:08I thought Tim Cook's statement

1:18:12could have been a little stronger.

1:18:13Like, I'm not expecting him to lash out.

1:18:17And I'm obviously, it's no secret that I am

1:18:20violently, virulently against Trump,

1:18:24and I see him as a danger and a menace, personally.

1:18:27But even so, I totally get that Tim Cook,

1:18:30or the CEO, anybody in a position like that, can't be.

1:18:34Even though I would certainly suspect privately

1:18:36that he is, based on everything we know about him,

1:18:39and who his personal heroes are.

1:18:40I get it.

1:18:43And I see people on Twitter who are,

1:18:46you know, who want him to be, you know, like a completely outspoken critic. I see how he can't,

1:18:52but I still think his statement could have been a little bit stronger. And in terms of,

1:18:56it's like the old adage that like when you're, you know, collaborating with people that you work

1:19:02with, or you're in school and you're doing a crit, you criticize the work, not the person.

1:19:05So I don't expect him to come out strongly against Trump personally, but I think he could have come

1:19:11out a little stronger against the executive order on immigration.

1:19:18Yeah, and you've got a variety of people. It was interesting, one thing here, here's

1:19:25like a little inside, not super inside baseball, but inside baseball in a way. If you look

1:19:30at the statements that were released, there was like, especially early on, there was only

1:19:35a couple of people that went on the record and just said stuff. Said, "Hey, this is

1:19:40and here's what I have to say about it.

1:19:42And there were a lot of leaked memos.

1:19:44Even Tim Cook's was not a public statement.

1:19:47It was a quote unquote leaked memo, right?

1:19:49Couple of publications got it.

1:19:52We ended up getting it.

1:19:53The origin of those memos is often debated

1:19:59among various journalists.

1:20:00Hey, did you get this?

1:20:01Where did you get this?

1:20:02And people are like, sawed off.

1:20:04I'm not gonna tell you.

1:20:05But where those come from is an interesting thing

1:20:09Because a leaked memo is essentially,

1:20:11we wanna say this, but we don't wanna make

1:20:13a public statement about it because we're a public company

1:20:15and this has a lot of ramifications.

1:20:17And a statement, an on the record statement,

1:20:20is a I feel very strongly personally about this,

1:20:23come at me bro, right?

1:20:25And that is a, there's a difference, right,

1:20:28in impact, I feel.

1:20:30And eventually, a lot of the CEOs,

1:20:32a lot of the tech companies ended up having a,

1:20:36some sort of public personal statement about it.

1:20:39Satya Nadella posted on LinkedIn,

1:20:41Mark Zuckerberg posted on Facebook, so on and so forth.

1:20:48And those statements, I mean,

1:20:50Sergey Brin showed up at the protest at SFO.

1:20:53And he said, this is not a company thing,

1:20:55I'm here as an immigrant, as a person.

1:20:57But then of course the employee rally

1:20:59and then Google was supportive of that,

1:21:02about the ban or whatever you wanna call the order.

1:21:07- Right.

1:21:09- Semantics are being debated as we speak.

1:21:12But that was interesting to me,

1:21:15to view the spectrum of people who were at least,

1:21:19I don't know if you wanna call it comfortable,

1:21:20but felt passionately enough about it

1:21:23to put it on the record in their own voice

1:21:25and go out there versus the people who weren't.

1:21:27And it could spell caution, it could spell calculation.

1:21:31There are a lot of ways to take it.

1:21:33It just depends on how you look at it.

1:21:34- Yeah.

1:21:37- One weekend.

1:21:38- I know, it is honestly, you know, yeah.

1:21:44I mean, there's a lot here that doesn't really feel,

1:21:47there's a lot of it here that seems to very clearly

1:21:51to be coming from Steve Bannon.

1:21:53Bannon's tenure at Breitbart and the publications bent,

1:21:59it's very clear that these are all things

1:22:02that he feels very strongly personally about.

1:22:05How much of those feelings that Trump shares

1:22:07will be a very interesting historical account to read.

1:22:10- Right.

1:22:11- If we ever figure that out,

1:22:13how closely their views are aligned,

1:22:15or if Bannon is able to just push forth his views

1:22:19and make them Trump's views.

1:22:22But it seems very clear that these attitudes

1:22:25towards immigration and towards a variety

1:22:27of other government institutions

1:22:29very strongly held by Bannon,

1:22:31and this rapid application of the exact

1:22:36the executive order, which Republicans were so angry

1:22:40that Obama utilized, even though he utilized them

1:22:42far less than say Reagan or someone else.

1:22:46It is very interesting to see what the ramifications

1:22:51of this very fast and loose application of these orders

1:22:55that obviously had far less, let's put it this way,

1:22:59it's very clear they had far less vetting

1:23:02from the appropriate agencies

1:23:04previous executive orders.

1:23:06- Right.

1:23:07- You know, from the agents, affected agencies,

1:23:08or agencies responsible for their execution.

1:23:11So, and this is not a politics thing,

1:23:13this is like a logistics thing,

1:23:15or if you're looking at the government as a business,

1:23:18which Trump has said he does,

1:23:20it's very interesting to see this kind of business

1:23:22being conducted, and what the ramifications of it will be.

1:23:26Given that we are a weekend, and we're already exhausted,

1:23:29it is definitely going to be interesting to see

1:23:32how people maintain their vigilance that these things are handled according to the rule of

1:23:37law and according to appropriate procedure and process. Because fugue is a real thing,

1:23:44you know, I mean, or fatigue is a real thing, you know, you just, at some point you can't

1:23:48keep up.

1:23:49It's so fatiguing that you've mispronounced it. I thought one of the most telling, we're

1:23:54in Nunday and there's so much good writing that's going on, it's hard to keep up with

1:23:57all of it, but one of the most telling things, I did, I actually noted this back in the campaign,

1:24:02remember this but there were a couple you know when it was clear that the Steve Bannon was going

1:24:05to be so or was so influential in his campaign and then after the election when he we found out that

1:24:11the this guy won that he was going to be a top advisor um uh Trump had been a guest on Bannon's

1:24:18radio show uh I guess it's not a podcast I think it's on some kind of actual radio network but

1:24:24Bannon had a show uh and one of the times that Trump was on they talked about uh they were

1:24:31talking about immigration. And Trump was, this is where they differed, where Trump was arguing more

1:24:36or less that he wanted to make it easier for when immigrants come and go to our universities and

1:24:44become experts in science or whatever other fields they are, that it would be better for the country

1:24:49to figure out a way to keep them here with their newly found US expertise than to have them leave

1:24:55again. And Bannon, you know, he was like, you agree with that, right? And Bannon's argument

1:24:59was that there's something to the,

1:25:01it didn't quite say it was a problem,

1:25:03but you could tell that's where he was going,

1:25:04that when 2/3 or 3/4 of the CEOs in Silicon Valley

1:25:07are from Asia or South Asia, that's a problem.

1:25:12And you know, (laughs)

1:25:14there's no way to avoid it.

1:25:16I mean, either you look at something and you see like

1:25:19Sundar Pichai, who was born in India,

1:25:23is the CEO of one of the most successful companies

1:25:27in the history of the United States.

1:25:29You either see that as a great success,

1:25:32I mean, I just, there's no common ground.

1:25:34I see this as that Sundar Pichai is proof

1:25:37that the system works and that our country can be great.

1:25:40And Steve Bannon holds it up as a problem

1:25:43to be, that needs a solution.

1:25:45And I don't know, I don't see how--

1:25:47- Yeah, I think you referred to it as a cultural,

1:25:49that it refers to our culture,

1:25:52that we have to maintain a certain culture.

1:25:54And then the question then becomes,

1:25:55you mean white culture, right?

1:25:57like do you mean, you mean that the European people who came over and killed off the natives,

1:26:03like those are the folks that are the best. Excuse me. Those are the folks that are the

1:26:07best and those, that's the culture we need to maintain. And you know, I mean I think

1:26:13that you have to take that stuff at face value. And I think that was, I think you wrote something

1:26:19about this but, you know, everybody that was saying, even Peter Thiel said this, nobody

1:26:24really believed him at the time, but it really looks pretty gross in retrospect, you know,

1:26:30in terms of a gross miscalculation or gross dissembling of the truth. And that is that,

1:26:38you know, you don't take him literally. Right? Don't take Trump literally. Take him at his

1:26:45intent, not his word or whatever the, you know, saying was. But it's become very clear that you

1:26:50have to take this stuff literally. So if you look at statements like that, you go, okay,

1:26:54well, you know, if this person's, you know, policies or whatever are enacted, then, you

1:27:01know, their goal is to create a safe space for white people in America and then to, you

1:27:08know, destroy as much of the current government establishment as possible because they view

1:27:16it as corrupt or unnecessary. Because he says he views himself as a Leninist or whatever.

1:27:22And he'd like to, this is Bannon, like to tear down as much of the existing government as possible.

1:27:29So you look at things like that and you can look at them, hey, you know, oh, I'm intellectually

1:27:33curious about what this person's views are and, you know, where this gentleman is coming from.

1:27:37And then you can look at the stuff that's happened in the last week and you can go,

1:27:42"Oh, maybe I should take this as a statement of fact,

1:27:45"and not a statement of philosophy or game theory."

1:27:50And I think that that is a very scary proposition.

1:27:54- I have a theory on that front.

1:27:57And it is as much a hope as a,

1:28:01well, I can't prove it, but it's certainly what I hope

1:28:05in terms of the sustainability of this administration.

1:28:10It's a fact that according to polls,

1:28:12he is the least popular incoming president

1:28:15in modern history, meaning in the history

1:28:18of the Gallup poll and modern polling technology.

1:28:20And with just about every previous,

1:28:24or in fact, not just about,

1:28:25with every previous elected new president,

1:28:28there is this grace period after the election

1:28:32where as soon as the election's over, here's the winner,

1:28:36congratulations, and the campaigning stops,

1:28:39there is a groundswell of support

1:28:41and their popularity grows.

1:28:43They enter office with an approval rating that is higher.

1:28:46This was true for Reagan, this was true for Carter,

1:28:50Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, George H.W. Bush.

1:28:55It's always been true and it's not true with Trump.

1:28:58Trump's popularity and approvals went down

1:29:00between the election and starting.

1:29:02And amazingly, his Gallup approval rating went down

1:29:07eight points in his first week as president,

1:29:09which just doesn't happen.

1:29:11And again, I don't know, but I've probably lost everybody,

1:29:15anybody who was listening who was a Trump supporter,

1:29:19but I think I lost 'em a while ago.

1:29:22But here's the hope for someone who's opposed to Trump,

1:29:24is my theory is that Trump had a coalition of voters

1:29:29who half of them, let's say roughly,

1:29:33loved every literal word he said.

1:29:36They wanted to lock her up, they wanted to build a wall,

1:29:38they wanted to make Mexico pay for the wall

1:29:41that they didn't want.

1:29:42They wanted to ban Muslims from the country.

1:29:46And then the other half were the Peter Thiel type,

1:29:49and which is why I wrote about it, which is the,

1:29:52you can't take this guy literally.

1:29:54He says these things 'cause they sound good,

1:29:56he's a showman, he's not gonna do any of this stuff.

1:29:59Just think of the vague intent, you know,

1:30:02Thiel's description, and it's so funny

1:30:04that he picked up on the ban the Muslims was that,

1:30:09oh yeah, he just says that, but what he really means

1:30:11is they're gonna have a sane,

1:30:13they're just gonna have a saner, smarter immigration policy.

1:30:15Well, this immigration policy is insane,

1:30:18and it's not smarter.

1:30:19It's poorly written, it's hard to execute.

1:30:22I think what's happening with Trump's approval

1:30:24is that the people, the only people he's gonna be left with

1:30:27are the group that wanted him to be taken literally,

1:30:29and that the group who didn't wanna take him literally

1:30:32and just assumed that he wouldn't are a jumping ship,

1:30:35because now they see that he actually is doing these things.

1:30:38And I don't think that there's widespread support for them.

1:30:41- Yeah, yeah, it is, I mean, there's like a couple of,

1:30:49there's a couple of accounts on Twitter

1:30:51sort of collating regretful Trump voters,

1:30:55who, you know, are expressing their,

1:30:58there's one today that's, you know, hundreds of tweets long,

1:31:02sort of before and after tweets. The first it's like clipping the, I'm afraid I don't

1:31:07remember the account right now, but they're clipping the before tweet, you know, when

1:31:11they're like, "Oh, Trump is going to X and Y and, you know, trust him." And then the

1:31:16after where it's like, "He's not going to do this at all. I'm not, now I'm not going

1:31:19to have healthcare or whatever." And I think that there is, there's a schadenfreude in

1:31:23that but there's also like, when people say you have to see the other side and or, you

1:31:31know, cross borders to make that. It always seems like it's always one side having to

1:31:35cross those borders. But I honestly think there's opportunity there to not be like Nelson

1:31:41Haha and be like, "Look, you were fooled. Now let's fix it." Right? And unfortunately,

1:31:50you know, for many people, unfortunately for especially for people who are very solidly

1:31:54were very solidly Hillary Clinton supporters or whatever, fixing it is going to end up

1:32:00with Pence in power. I mean the worst case scenario is that, you know, for those folks

1:32:04is definitely Bannon stays in power and implements his true strategy, which he laid out very

1:32:10explicitly and you have to believe he wants those things because he's, you know, written

1:32:16and influenced all of the other stuff so far that's matched up one for one. And so that's

1:32:22your worst case scenario. But your best case scenario is Pence, which, you know, Pence

1:32:27does not share liberal values at all, right? I mean, he's very far right. You would consider

1:32:33him one of the farthest right if it wasn't for the Bannon-Trump conglomerate, right?

1:32:41So yeah, it's gonna be a rough four years, I think, for anybody. Well, rough two, maybe,

1:32:46if this groundswell of disapproval and/or, you know, activity or activism is able to

1:32:56to carry for two years, you get into the midterm elections

1:33:01and maybe the checks and balances are back in place

1:33:05where some sort of middle ground is found

1:33:07between the two halves of the country.

1:33:09Literally almost two halves of the voting public, right?

1:33:12So it's definitely, it's at times like this

1:33:17where you realize just how important

1:33:20to the balance of the force, so to speak,

1:33:24those checks and balances are.

1:33:25when they're not there anymore,

1:33:27it's a very sudden cold bath.

1:33:29- Yep, and I don't think we're at the end of it

1:33:33and in terms of issues that'll just pop up,

1:33:35unexpectedly, that draw the industry

1:33:41that we cover into it directly.

1:33:44I mean, there's gonna be something.

1:33:45I mean, for example, I mean, Trump was harping about it

1:33:48a year ago with the San Bernardino case

1:33:50and Apple's studied refusal to give the FBI,

1:33:55not to go down that whole story again,

1:33:58but they didn't wanna give them an OS to unlock the phone,

1:34:02and it's gonna be a little different

1:34:04when Trump is the president instead of just the candidate,

1:34:07and he's fighting back against it.

1:34:09So I'm sure we'll go down that path again.

1:34:11- Yeah, I mean, cybersecurity is the next big thing,

1:34:15so we'll see.

1:34:16- All right, briefly, 'cause I know we've gone for a while.

1:34:18- Oh, but Giuliani's in charge, so we're fine.

1:34:19- One last thing I just wanted to touch on.

1:34:22I don't know how many years now you've been going,

1:34:25but last week you were at Sundance in Utah.

1:34:27- Yeah, mm-hmm.

1:34:29- And so tell me about it.

1:34:33Tell me, it seems like you really

1:34:35have a good time out there.

1:34:37- Yeah, so I haven't been going as long as some folks.

1:34:40I mean, obviously it's been going on for decades,

1:34:42but I started going in 2013,

1:34:492012, 2013, somewhere in there. So for a few years now I've been going every year and I

1:34:54like it a lot. I mean it's, you know, I like everything about it. There's, you go to this

1:34:59town in Utah, Park City, which is, this, uh, it covers Salt Lake City, Park City, and a

1:35:06couple of other small venues like Robert Redford's house and personal screening room and some

1:35:11other things. He's got a whole conclave up there. The dude basically just owns this whole

1:35:18town. It's really funny. But it's a, you go, it's in the snow. There's nothing else to

1:35:26do but watch movies and eat. You're kind of locked in. I mean, you could ski and stuff.

1:35:32I never do. I always tell myself, "Oh, I'm going to take an afternoon or whatever." But

1:35:36there always seems to be something to see or something to do. But you go and you're

1:35:41snow locked in this little town. Everybody there is there to see movies. There are like

1:35:4860, 70 movies that play every day across all the venues. You can only see three or four

1:35:53of them a day. I mean, that's if you pack them in.

1:35:54Right?

1:35:55How do you decide? How do you, I mean, what do you do? Do you get like a, is there just

1:35:58like a, here you get like a pass and here's a list of all the movies and you just go through

1:36:03and pick them?

1:36:04Yeah, it's different for pass holders. So if you're a pass holder, you buy a package

1:36:09which gives you access to certain kinds of tickets and so many tickets a day or whatever

1:36:13the case, right? And you know, those past holders get some nice perks like they get

1:36:17to go in and get seated first in the theater and whatnot. But I go as press because I do

1:36:21cover a variety of things. Like last year, for instance, the documentary that Werner

1:36:27Herzog, documentary on the Internet, you know, and the kind of impact of the Internet was

1:36:33showing there. So I got to interview him and wrote about that for TechCrunch. And so, when

1:36:38I can, they've more and more stuff there is interactive with VR and AR versus just films.

1:36:44So when I go, I always find something to write about for TechCrunch and it's fun to go as

1:36:50press because you get, you sign up, you get your press pass. Your press pass allows you

1:36:55to see any press screening. They have essentially one for theater multiplex where it runs press

1:37:01PNI screenings all day. So press in industry. So you can go to any of those, just get in

1:37:05line and go in and watch those. And then you can also wait list for any movie throughout

1:37:11the day. Wait listing is essentially they have a little app and when the waitlist thing

1:37:16turns on, you hit go and it assigns you a number. And so the overflow seating which

1:37:20they have between 40 and 100 to 200 seats on every theater assigned to the waitlist,

1:37:25you could possibly get in if you don't have a ticket. You buy your ticket for $20, each

1:37:30movie ticket is $20 and then you go in and see this movie that nobody's ever seen. So

1:37:34So it's kind of a good deal for like local residents and folks that don't have ticket

1:37:38packages.

1:37:39But for the press, you sign up, you get your press pass which allows you to do all that.

1:37:43Then you get 10 free complimentary tickets over the course of the show and then you can

1:37:47request between one and two tickets every day via the press office in the morning.

1:37:52So everybody rushes down and says, "Oh, I'm trying to see this or that."

1:37:55And they sell out of those tickets once they sell out and that's it.

1:37:58So in general, like this last time, I don't have my stubs in front of me to count, but

1:38:02but I think I saw, I got there Thursday

1:38:05and left Tuesday morning, it was a short trip for me,

1:38:08and I saw I think 20 movies in that space of time,

1:38:11and then a bunch of VR exhibits.

1:38:13So, I mean, you pack it in, you're there,

1:38:15you might as well, I mean, I do anyway.

1:38:18Different people handle it differently.

1:38:19The film journalists usually stay there

1:38:21for a week or even two, because it runs two weeks,

1:38:26and that second week is, or second weekend/week is great,

1:38:30because nobody's there.

1:38:31I've gone in the second week some years and it's purely about the movies. The stars have

1:38:38all left to go back to their lives or wherever. The first week, every show you go to, the

1:38:44director or the actors or everybody involved is there. You get to see it essentially with

1:38:50the people that made the movie, including down to the grips and camera guys or whoever

1:38:54else came. And then there's Q&As after every movie. So you get to talk to the filmmakers

1:39:00about their motivations and all that stuff,

1:39:03person to person right there.

1:39:04So it's pretty fun.

1:39:05- What was the best movie that you saw?

1:39:08Can you pick one?

1:39:09Do you have a handful?

1:39:11- Yeah, I'm gonna write about it too.

1:39:13Yeah, yeah, there's a couple that I found really good.

1:39:15I mean, there's a couple that are non-tech related

1:39:17that I saw while I was there.

1:39:19The Big Sick, which is Kumail Nanjiani.

1:39:22He wrote that with his wife about their experiences.

1:39:26Kumail's one of the guys from Silicon Valley.

1:39:30he plays one of the programmers. Very good. And you'll hear about this. I think Netflix

1:39:35bought them, actually. So you should be able to watch it on Netflix. I don't know if they're

1:39:38going to release it theatrically or directly on Netflix. But Netflix and Amazon were big,

1:39:44enormous presences there. They bought a ton of movies. This is like, for 2013, there was

1:39:52just like rumblings that Netflix is like poking around, like there are people here. And then

1:39:57year after year, they got to be more and more of a presence until this year. It was like,

1:40:01you know, they were some of the biggest purchasers at the show and they were on everybody's lips. And

1:40:07many of the movies that premiered there had already been pre-purchased by Netflix and things

1:40:10like that. So it's, you know, my world was colliding with Sundance's world at a rapid

1:40:17pace over the last several years. And it's got to be, it has to be from their perspective,

1:40:21a lower risk way because these are movies that are already made, you know, that and it, you know,

1:40:26that you could say, look, and there's some subjectiveness

1:40:29to it where obviously whoever it is from Netflix

1:40:32is watching the movie and saying, yeah, this is good,

1:40:34and making a subjective judgment that this is a good movie

1:40:38or good enough that we should think about buying it.

1:40:40But then once they do, the risk is so much lower

1:40:42than backing something when it's just a screenplay,

1:40:46and there's so much uncertainty, who are you gonna get,

1:40:49who can you cast, is it gonna come together?

1:40:51So it doesn't surprise me at all.

1:40:54- Yeah, you have a sort of fixed price.

1:40:55- Right.

1:40:56- Right.

1:40:57And like last, every time I go,

1:40:58one of my favorite things to do is when I'm in line,

1:41:01I just talk to people.

1:41:02Because in general, these are film industry people

1:41:05that are there.

1:41:05I mean, they're fans too, right?

1:41:07Just folks that wanna see movies.

1:41:09But like I talked to Academy Award winning producers

1:41:12that are just standing in line

1:41:13and we just have a discussion, right?

1:41:15Because they're waiting to see some new thing

1:41:17and they're like, "Oh yeah, I hear it's great," or whatever.

1:41:19And I talked to them about their next project

1:41:22and about the industry and blah, blah, blah.

1:41:24And I talked to buyers and producers,

1:41:28and when they're talking about Netflix and Amazon,

1:41:31they're talking about, I asked them,

1:41:33"Hey, is this a challenge to you?

1:41:35"Do you view it as an invasion or whatever?"

1:41:37In general, the response has been very positive.

1:41:41I mean, they're like, "Hell no.

1:41:42"For us, it's a way to tell a filmmaker,

1:41:44"look, you can use these people to make your next movie.

1:41:47"In other words, sell this movie.

1:41:49"You're not gonna be rich off of it or whatever.

1:41:52"You're gonna make a decent deal."

1:41:54neither Amazon and Netflix are overpaying right now for movies simply because A) they

1:41:59have the money and B) they're sort of trying to build momentum. But they're also enabling

1:42:05filmmakers to just boom, like sell that and then make another movie. You move on to your

1:42:12next project and then it allows them to build a body of work. And it's just like a new plug

1:42:16and play distributor that they're able to just go and say Netflix comes with their corpus

1:42:23of data that says this is what we know works.

1:42:26Amazon comes with their deep pockets and says,

1:42:28hey, we're gonna release you theatrically.

1:42:29Like they're different playbooks.

1:42:30They're not just like bland entities

1:42:33that handle things the same way.

1:42:34They definitely distribute them very differently.

1:42:37But new opportunities for filmmakers.

1:42:40- Any other movies you wanna give a shout out to

1:42:42other than The Big Sick?

1:42:43- Yeah, Marjorie Prime.

1:42:44I really, really liked it.

1:42:46Marjorie Prime is a movie that stars

1:42:51John Hamm, Gina Davis, who else?

1:42:56Tim Robbins is in it as well.

1:43:04So I mean like, you know, all star cast.

1:43:07I mean it's directed by this guy named Michael Amareja,

1:43:12I think, Amareja, I might mispronounce it.

1:43:15He directed Hamlet, I don't remember, with Ethan Hawke.

1:43:19- Yes, I do remember that.

1:43:20But the movie stars Lois Smith, and Lois Smith is a very venerable actress. You have

1:43:26seen her. You listeners out there, you have seen her in something, trust me. I don't

1:43:32know if you remember East of Eden. She was in that. She's been in the biz a long time.

1:43:40I think she's 85, 86 now. But she's been in tons of stuff that people have seen like

1:43:46fried green tomatoes and Twister and, you know, True Blood and all kinds of stuff, right?

1:43:51Pete: Yeah.

1:43:51J

1:44:03by the guy who they adapted the screenplay off of.

1:44:06And she's played that character twice

1:44:08in two runs of that play,

1:44:10and then this director directed her

1:44:12in this movie version of that play.

1:44:15And she's an older woman who's losing her cognitive ability,

1:44:19and her family purchases her an AI called the Prime.

1:44:23And that Prime is there to talk with her

1:44:27and to help her to keep those memory pathways active, right?

1:44:32to help her relive her life and talk about her memories. So Jon Hamm plays her husband

1:44:40in his younger state because that's the way she wanted to remember him. And the Prime

1:44:45is set up to engage with her and ask her about her life and to learn. So when she talks to

1:44:50it, it learns about her life, essentially learning to be more human and more like him.

1:44:55But the themes, obviously the AI, you know, component of it is a huge portion of the theme.

1:45:02themes I found absolutely just spellbinding. I mean, I was barely breathing by the end

1:45:08of it. And it's not a very--it's not a thriller by any means. You know, it's an extremely

1:45:12calm meditative movie that I found to be extremely well-acted, full of nuance, and addressed

1:45:19some really, really interesting topics about AI, the way it will affect us, the way that

1:45:27humans can sort of impart their being to AI in the future or may impart them if it ever

1:45:32gets to that point. You know, it's very, very interesting. I highly recommend checking it

1:45:37out when it comes out. I think maybe Netflix bought it.

1:45:39It sounds right up my alley. I feel like we're entering a golden age as Hollywood devolves

1:45:45into nothing but sequels to franchises and $300 million budgets and the expectation that

1:45:53the last two-thirds of the movie is gonna be blowing up

1:45:56a city every single time.

1:45:58We're entering like a golden age of smaller budget,

1:46:03what used to be called indie movies,

1:46:05I don't know what you wanna call 'em now,

1:46:06but outside Hollywood and outside the blockbuster mindset

1:46:10of science fiction, and a lot of 'em,

1:46:13I mean, and it's no surprise that people are thinking

1:46:15about AI because it's starting to get real.

1:46:19And it's so great, it is so refreshing to see movies

1:46:22about AI that have gotten away from AI that goes bad

1:46:26and takes over the planet, right?

1:46:28- Exactly, yeah, that's what you normally see.

1:46:30And I mean, the one thing, one thing I will say,

1:46:33this might be an interesting to people listening,

1:46:36is that the mood at Sundance this year,

1:46:39I mean, like I said, I'm not claiming to be

1:46:41some historian of Sundance, but the mood this year

1:46:44compared to years past, because remember,

1:46:47the inauguration was happening on that Friday

1:46:50of the beginning of the festival.

1:46:52And all this stuff started happening.

1:46:54The first executive actions and stuff started being passed

1:46:59and all this and people were realizing just how much

1:47:02Trump was going to be the Trump he promised to be.

1:47:05And the mood at Sundance was insane.

1:47:08I mean, it was somber and meditative and defiant.

1:47:10And it was artists being artists, just saying like,

1:47:15we're not gonna give up the light, we're gonna push

1:47:17and we're gonna tell stories and we're going to help

1:47:20unify via those stories.

1:47:22Redford and various programmers made comments

1:47:25as I was sitting in screenings and things like that

1:47:28about telling challenging and difficult stories

1:47:32and not letting up on that.

1:47:34It just seemed very, very interesting,

1:47:36very unified in its emotion.

1:47:41And then years passed, it was all over the place.

1:47:43People have different thoughts and feelings,

1:47:45but it seemed very, very interesting to me.

1:47:47So it'll be interesting to see how artists and filmmakers

1:47:50and people like that react over the next several years.

1:47:53- Well, it's nice to talk about something

1:47:54a little bit nicer than Trump,

1:47:57but it inevitably came back to Trump.

1:48:00(laughing)

1:48:02My thanks to you for your time.

1:48:05This was a great discussion.

1:48:07Everybody can find you on Twitter.

1:48:10What's your Twitter handle?

1:48:11- Panzer.

1:48:13- P-A-N-Z-E-R.

1:48:16And of course, your good work as the editor at TechCrunch.

1:48:20Keep up, keep up the good work.

1:48:21My thanks to our sponsors this week.

1:48:23We had Squarespace and we had Audible

1:48:27and our new sponsor, Ministry of Supply.

1:48:33So my thanks to them and my thanks to you.

1:48:37Adios.

1:48:38[ Silence ]