0:00:00What an amazing technology indoor plumbing is.
0:00:03You're a Stephen Johnson fan, right?
0:00:05Yes.
0:00:06Yeah, so you know his book Ghost Map from several years ago, like a decade ago, 2006.
0:00:12It was about the fellow who basically invented epidemiology.
0:00:16Yes.
0:00:17And, but it also has a really long discussion about how before, I mean, there was indoor
0:00:24plumbing then.
0:00:25This is actually when we had generally had indoor plumbing in cities.
0:00:28how, what happened to all the effluvia? Where did it go? There were all these specialized
0:00:33professions to deal with, like, night soil and other kinds. So, there were various products
0:00:39and various people whose professions were to handle the products of society. And it's
0:00:46really incredible, like, the book is great because it's about sort of how empirical
0:00:51science becomes a thing that we then start to rely on and it changes the nature of medicine
0:00:54and health, but it's also like, wow, there were a lot of people employed dealing with
0:00:58shit in London. I mean, you had to. You had to be.
0:01:01Well, it's—if you think about it, it's not just—I first thought it often just seems
0:01:07like, wow, that would be inconvenient.
0:01:09[laughter]
0:01:10But the volume!
0:01:12Right, that it's—
0:01:13Oh, man.
0:01:14And the smells, right? Like, it's like once a year or so, I end up having to go in like
0:01:20a porta potty for some reason or another, you know, I'm at some sort of event where
0:01:25you've got to go in a porta potty. And porta potty technology, I think has advanced to
0:01:30a significant degree where where there's that blue stuff that's in the hole that I think
0:01:36does take care of an awful lot of the unpleasant odors of just releasing your your waste into
0:01:45all, literally just a big bucket.
0:01:47[Laughter]
0:01:48Pete: A little cabin, camping recently, and experienced more sort of "feel the tree"
0:01:56style.
0:01:57It's very different.
0:01:58Jared: It always occurs to me, though, that that was what going to the bathroom was like
0:02:01every single time you went to the bathroom.
0:02:03Pete; Oh yeah, I try to think, like, when we think about the past, we think about inconveniences
0:02:07and we think about horses and muddy streets and all that.
0:02:11Like, were you watching Westworld just finish up?
0:02:14I have watched Westworld.
0:02:16The series is extraordinary, I think. The finale is great. I really liked it. We have
0:02:22an episode coming out on the incomparable about the whole, with all full spoilers. But,
0:02:27you know, that's the vision of the West where it's really neat and clean. So, the
0:02:29people are shooting each other and there's fornication and so forth, but there is no
0:02:34horse manure on the streets of Westworld because it's cleaned up. And I've often thought
0:02:37the thing that we can't replicate when we think about the past is the smell and the
0:02:43constant mess. Like, everything was dirty and everything smelled until like 1910 or 1890 or
0:02:49something like that. And then it started to improve gradually. And then by the 1930s, cities
0:02:56smelled a lot less and by the 50s, it was sort of like if things smelled, something was terribly,
0:03:00terribly wrong.
0:03:00Pete: Right. I've heard, maybe it was even in the Steven Johnson book. But, you know, and it makes
0:03:07sense. But like, in like the late at the turn of the last century, the streets of major cities like
0:03:14New York and Philadelphia and London were just it ever just curb to curb horseshit. It was just the
0:03:22streets were just paved with a layer of horseshit because there was no way to keep up with.
0:03:26Pete: Yeah. Sean, is this a metaphor for this year?
0:03:29Pete: It could be.
0:03:30Pete; I sort of feel like that's what we're, we're talking about one thing, but we need another.
0:03:33But I did think that Westworld I I thought that it was weird that they never addressed the the sort of
0:03:40The roughing it aspects of I mean this is not a spoiler
0:03:46The basic concept of the show is not a spoiler that it's at some point in the future
0:03:50there's like a theme park where people go and
0:03:52For a lot of money you get to pretend to live in the Old West for a couple of days
0:03:57And there's action and adventure that you can take part in
0:04:02But, yeah, nobody mentions that, you know, you gotta go shit in an outhouse.
0:04:07Pete: Yeah, it's pretty, it's a very, it's clean. I mean, there's a lot of, there's
0:04:12some, a lot of certain bodily fluids, mostly blood, but there's no other kinds of bodily
0:04:16fluids. You know, there's a sensibility thing, like, there's things you can't, there's
0:04:20things you can't do and talk about, even on HBO, apparently, which is good. But yeah,
0:04:25it was kind of, it was supposed to be a theme park, so for all we know, Hidden in the Bushes
0:04:29were like, you know, little potties that broke the spirit. But I think, yeah, I think that's
0:04:36the thing that people don't get—people who camp know about this, of course, because
0:04:39they deal with it. You go out in the woods, you're a hunter, or you like to go out and
0:04:42camp, and you're in areas that have no facilities at all, you know. But most of us do not have
0:04:47to deal with the basic human realities that people did for billions of years, or hundreds
0:04:51of millions of years, I should say.
0:04:52Right. And I mean, it's getting cold in Philadelphia. It's very cold today. I mean,
0:04:59I'm not quite sure how cold, but it certainly felt cold when I was outside. And it's like,
0:05:03imagine, I had to go outside every time to take a leak.
0:05:06Oh, man. We had an inch or two of snow in Seattle, which is a snowpocalypse for us.
0:05:11So, they shut down—no, I'm kidding. It mostly melted, but they started the schools two hours
0:05:16late because the bus routes were very steep hills. So, whenever it snows, they can't
0:05:22really send the buses up, they run snow routes, and it's sort of a safety for that rather than,
0:05:27like, you know, the streets are impassable. So, they don't want to have—I think bus
0:05:31plunge is not a headline you want to see. It's really bad.
0:05:35Pete: Did you ever watch Deadwood?
0:05:38Pete; I didn't! I heard it was fantastic. I think it came out when I had Small Children,
0:05:43so I never really got, oh, and you had to have, that was on HBO, wasn't it?
0:05:46Pete; Yeah, it was on HBO. From 2004 to 2006.
0:05:48I missed it. I bought HBO Now where I'm subscribing specifically to watch
0:05:52Westworld. So in those days I would have had to pay the cable thing.
0:05:56You can probably get Deadwood then, right? I think that the HBO has—keeps most of their old shows in
0:06:01there. You have to know this going—I thought it was a marvelous show. I really loved it. I was a
0:06:09big fan. It was created by a guy named David Milch who was, I guess—it was like before people called
0:06:15called Showrunner Showrunners, but he was the guy behind NYPD Blue, which was back in
0:06:21the 90s, probably the first serious TV show that I ever really fell in love with. And
0:06:27it was weird because it was a network show and I guess it was fairly cheap to produce
0:06:31and it went on forever and ever, long past when it was, and I kept watching because I
0:06:35liked it enough, but it sort of, NYPD Blue sort of ended with a whisper because it just
0:06:41Oh, yeah, that was the worst thing.
0:06:43I mean, it was on for like ten years or something like that, but it was a great show.
0:06:48And still had, you know, there was enough good in the characters to, you know, make...
0:06:53There were a couple of episodes a season that were always good, but it was kind of hard.
0:06:58And it was on ABC, and those ABC shows had to do like 22 shows a year, which is too much.
0:07:04Like, part of the secret of the modern resonance or renaissance in, like, movie-quality TV
0:07:11shows is that they only do, like, 10 episodes at a time, and sometimes not even once a year.
0:07:17It might take 18 months to get the next 10 episodes out.
0:07:20There's a sort of quality instead of quantity aspect to these HBOs and Netflix.
0:07:25Pete: Oh yeah, season two of Westworld is coming out in 2018.
0:07:29But, although I think, isn't there a little sequential thing?
0:07:32Like, they sort of, they play it a little by ear.
0:07:34I don't know when they got the renewal request, but I believe Westworld has been, I think,
0:07:38one of the most popular shows. I mean, I'm sure Games of Thrones swamps it, but they,
0:07:43I think they are okay at HBO. They're very good about funding things with no strings
0:07:48attached, I've heard. I keep reading about how they're such a, they're an amazing organization
0:07:52by just saying, they don't throw money at something, but they trust, they trust people,
0:07:57right? But they, I don't think they gave them the dollars for season two or really
0:08:02fully committed until it was underway and the showrunners, Nolan and Joy, are saying,
0:08:06"We need time to do this right." They had to stop production twice to do some retooling. I think
0:08:11once was kind of tool up and the other was to sort of rejigger because they realized they'd gotten
0:08:15some mechanics wrong and they wanted to fix those, which is admirable. And they had the freedom to do
0:08:20that, which is incredible. And then it rolled out.
0:08:22Pete: Narrative mechanics?
0:08:23Pete; That's right.
0:08:24Pete; What did you mean by mechanics?
0:08:25Pete; Oh, oh, I think, oh, world mechanics. Apparently they built, they built the world. I
0:08:29I mean, it's really clear watching the whole season that they really understood what it
0:08:34was about.
0:08:35They had an arc, they had a circle, they had, there are time bombs in episode one that pay
0:08:40off in ten and aren't referred to in the interim.
0:08:42So, I trust them having watched it, but I think they had the freedom to go back and
0:08:46say, you know, we thought the world was going to work.
0:08:48I mean, this is what they said, it's something along the lines of, we thought this is how
0:08:51the world worked and then we realized that changed, but in episodes, I think it was one
0:08:56to three, maybe it was a little even more, they had elements that were now wrong inside
0:09:01their ecosystem. So, they reshot and fixed them, so they were consistent. And I'm thinking,
0:09:06how wonderful they did that, had the time to do it, that that's the conscientiousness
0:09:10they had. What an incredible thing. And I'm sure the show benefited from it, because otherwise,
0:09:14especially with the level of attention it got. Can you imagine by episode five, people
0:09:18were like, "No, well, excuse me, but in episode three, they bled from the left." And
0:09:22we know that's not true in Westworld.
0:09:23Yeah. I'm actually... anyway, Wes, the thing about Deadwood, to go back one digression,
0:09:31was that Deadwood wound up getting cancelled before, and they didn't even have time to
0:09:38give it a proper final episode.
0:09:39Oh no!
0:09:40So it just sort of ends. So I want to warn anybody before they get into it that it's
0:09:47a very dissatisfying ending. It's like you don't go into it looking for any kind of complete
0:09:53loop on any of the characters or anything. You just kind of have to take it for what it is.
0:09:57But anyway, Deadwood was a Western, took place based on real people, actually,
0:10:02in Deadwood, South Dakota. And it was probably the grittiest Western I've ever seen,
0:10:09where there was some shit on the streets, you know? And they showed people, you know,
0:10:16urinating out in the middle of the street and stuff like that.
0:10:18And a Baroque swearing, I heard. I heard just endless, incredible, eloquent, obscenity.
0:10:24Yeah. It's probably the greatest Al Swearengen. He's based on a real character,
0:10:32a real person. But it was—
0:10:34That's great.
0:10:35It was the filthiest mouth I've ever heard. It was poetry.
0:10:38Oh, man.
0:10:45So, I guess—I don't want to spoil Westwood, you can't really talk details about it.
0:10:50But—
0:10:50Pete: Generally, I think.
0:10:52John: I thought it was, I really enjoyed it a lot, and I'm actually up to episode,
0:10:57there's 10 episodes in a season, I'm actually up to episode three rewatching it.
0:11:02Pete; Oh, that's good. I haven't gone back, I've watched some episodes twice when they came out,
0:11:07and I haven't rewatched the whole thing. Kelly Guimont and Don Melton have a podcast, actually,
0:11:15called, was it Hello from the Uncanny Valley? It's now on the Incomparable Network. But they've done,
0:11:20they did episodes, they started a little late, they did a bunch of episodes about the show,
0:11:24and now they're going to rewatch and do more episodes about it, because we've got a whole
0:11:28year to kill, so they'll be doing more. But—
0:11:30It's one of those things like the usual suspects, where when you rewatch it and you know
0:11:35future plot twists, and then you watch, and you're like, "Oh, they totally set that up!"
0:11:42There's so many moments like that in the first few episodes that play completely differently.
0:11:46Just throw away lines and it's all of a sudden—the first time watching it, you didn't even notice
0:11:52the line of dialogue, but then the second time, it gives you chills.
0:11:56It's like, "Whoa, that's creepy," because you know things that you didn't know then.
0:12:00It's that layering.
0:12:01It's like, I think you can tell when something—this is always my thing.
0:12:05I actually feel this way about software, too—is you can tell when stuff is rich and deep,
0:12:09when people go back.
0:12:10I mean, it works in literature, it works in filmed entertainment, it works in software.
0:12:16There's the discovery and there's the richness.
0:12:18So, you go and you look at something and you find out that what you thought was a certain
0:12:21depth is deeper and deeper because they went, they layered, they went back around and around
0:12:25and around.
0:12:26And you know, you could overwork stuff too, like a bad, you know, a bad dough when you're
0:12:30baking, but if it's done right, the richness kind of like, comes up from the bottom and
0:12:35the more you pay attention, the richer it becomes.
0:12:38Pete: Do you think you would like to, like, if you were in that future, would you like to go
0:12:42on vacation to Westworld?
0:12:44Pete: That's a great question because, right, this is the, you know, are you William or are you,
0:12:48I don't want to give any spoilers away, are you another character in the show? Other characters,
0:12:53like, I don't know that I would because I think this is the, I think people have different amounts
0:12:58of dopamine in their brain, right? There's different ways of expressing dopamine and
0:13:01other chemicals that give us happiness and there's people who get great joy in their life
0:13:07out of, like, doing ice cliff climbing, right? And I don't need that. I have this kind of natural brain chemistry
0:13:14I'm very fortunate to have where I think I am not far off the—when I have a success in my life
0:13:20or I'm doing something that I really enjoy doing and I'm feeling very good about my performance doing it,
0:13:24I think I achieved maybe 90% of ice cliff climbing. I don't really need that extra 10%.
0:13:30Excuse me. And some people—it's not even thrill-seekers.
0:13:33It's more like a way to achieve a certain state of like, advanced happiness requires
0:13:38doing something extreme.
0:13:39And I think Westworld is that, it's a great representation of that, because, you know,
0:13:44right now, that used to be something like, you know, just to say, it's like people
0:13:47go to Thailand, or they go to other places where there was a, you know, Demimonde, or
0:13:52really off-the-grid kind of quality, and they can pay for anything they want.
0:13:55They can do things, they might be able to harm other people, like go do bare-knuckle
0:14:00fighting and worse.
0:14:02Westworld is kind of an encapsulation. It's like a cleaned up version of it where, you
0:14:06know, it's not giving anything away to say that there are robots called hosts who look
0:14:10very, very human. They're Android, they're indistinguishable, essentially, and you can
0:14:14do stuff to Android, so it doesn't count, right? You're in this other place, it's,
0:14:17you know, what happens in Westworld stays in Westworld, and I don't think I have that
0:14:21desire to—I like the idea of being able to step outside myself into a different time.
0:14:25If I was going to explore, like, something like Colonial Williamsburg that was Westworld
0:14:30quality and are part of the story, that sounds interesting, but I don't really have the
0:14:34desire to leap into a less controlled environment. There's actually a series of books called,
0:14:40it starts with The Many Colored Land by Mary, or was it LeMay? I'm blanking on the name,
0:14:47I'll see if I'm wrong. But it's a future where, again, this isn't a spoiler because
0:14:52it's explained in the first few pages, it's a future beyond ours in which things are much
0:14:58more advanced and totally civilized, and there's a small galactic community of different species
0:15:03that interact very well, and it's very boring and there's no risk, and people are definitely
0:15:09boring. And someone discovers a tiny portal to the past. It's a one-way portal, takes
0:15:13you six million years into the Pliocene, I think, and the idea is that when you walk
0:15:17through it, you'll never come back. There's no way to return. So, a lot of people, they
0:15:20actually, governments try to repress it, then they set it up as kind of an exile thing.
0:15:24who really want a totally uncontrolled experience, they're not allowed to take technology back,
0:15:29just their own knowledge, and they go there, and it's actually a really beautiful exploration
0:15:33of that same kind of thing. Like, Westworld is that. Like, all right, I want to go some
0:15:36place where the normal rules don't apply, but there are no consequences. Oh, Julian
0:15:42May, I'm sorry, is her name. Would you go to Westworld is my question. Do you want a
0:15:48Westworld experience?
0:15:49I it's a very close call for me. I
0:15:52Would note no joking I
0:15:57I have no desire to have a sexual intercourse with an Android no matter how
0:16:05Realistic for the same reason that
0:16:10Because if they're not super realistic, it's gross and if they're indistinguishable from humans
0:16:15it's indistinguishable from cheating on your wife.
0:16:18- Exactly, right. - I don't, I, you know.
0:16:21So, going back to sex with robot hookers,
0:16:25no, I probably-- - Robot hooker, coming through.
0:16:27- Right, but they're very nice,
0:16:29so I might chat them up at the bar,
0:16:31because they're all very good talkers.
0:16:34I would enjoy having a drink with Maeve.
0:16:36But that part, now--
0:16:39- You know, here's a secret I've read
0:16:41by reading accounts of sex workers.
0:16:43Sex workers say they spend a lot of time
0:16:45talk to their clients. There are some sex workers that say most of the regulars, they
0:16:50don't actually have any form of sexual contact with them. They just need somebody they can
0:16:54pay to talk to and they don't want to go to a therapist and they have a long-term relationship
0:16:57where that's the case. So, that would be totally within the scope, I think, of the
0:17:02Westworld design.
0:17:03So, I just want to go and talk to an intelligent robot about whatever with no holds barred.
0:17:06Pete: Right. And I, would I like to go back and have like an adventure where I go out
0:17:14with a crew and try to catch a bandit and shoot him dead,
0:17:18knowing that if I get shot, it's more like getting
0:17:20hit by a paintball type thing.
0:17:24Maybe.
0:17:25I think when I was younger, definitely.
0:17:27Because I was never serious about it,
0:17:30but I've played paintball a couple of times
0:17:31and had fun doing it.
0:17:34I don't know that at age 43.
0:17:37I don't know.
0:17:39My time for stuff like that is maybe over.
0:17:42Skylighting and Westworld.
0:17:44But it also seems like there's other people there who are just sort of exploring, right?
0:17:49Remember the family that—there was a black family with a small child who met Dolores down by the
0:17:57river one time. So it seems like there are people who go there not for any kind of debauchery,
0:18:03but just, you know, like a family vacation, like, "Let's go," right? I do think—I think that it's
0:18:08It's a very thoughtful show.
0:18:11There were-- I regretted it to some degree,
0:18:15where I started reading the wrap-up shows that go into detail
0:18:20and people taking screen captures.
0:18:23There was one point where they have these iPad-like devices, which
0:18:26I think were pretty well done.
0:18:28They're very thin, but not quite see-through.
0:18:31But they also are like tri-folds, like a tri-fold wallet.
0:18:35So they kind of fold up.
0:18:37they fold up to be like a, maybe like an iPhone Plus type thing,
0:18:42and then you can unfold it twice and get more of an iPad style thing.
0:18:47And somebody took a screen capture at one point of one of them
0:18:50that seemed to say that the show takes place in the 2150s or 2015
0:18:57or something.
0:18:58Oh, I wasn't paying attention to that.
0:18:59Interesting.
0:19:00Or 2050?
0:19:01I don't know.
0:19:022050 sounds more reasonable because--
0:19:05well, I don't know.
0:19:06- No, no, no, but it's 2050.
0:19:07'Cause you're looking at what the culture is
0:19:09of the employees, but the employees are really sequestered
0:19:12at the park, they seemingly all live there,
0:19:14or that's where they, you know,
0:19:15they don't seem to go anywhere else.
0:19:17- Right, I think that, I don't know
0:19:18if the screenshot really indicates, I don't know.
0:19:21I think they do pay attention to details,
0:19:22who knows if that's right.
0:19:23But I think gut feeling-wise, that's when the show,
0:19:25it clearly isn't like super far in the future,
0:19:28but it's clearly significantly beyond where we are.
0:19:33- Yeah, I like the computers.
0:19:35I like the presentation of technology in it, and oh, you know, the thing that I think is
0:19:39the best telling detail they got right is the way Anthony Hopkins controls Androids.
0:19:46Did you love that? That it's subtle? That he does one finger or he just says, "That's
0:19:52enough now." And he just say it in a normal tone of voice. It's like a Siri thing. He
0:19:55doesn't have to say, "Android 75, halt action and proceed to program 5B," which
0:20:00is what I feel like everything in the 1970s would have been.
0:20:03I saw a funny cartoon on Twitter the other day where somebody was talking to somebody
0:20:09else and they didn't like where the person was going and they just said, "analysis."
0:20:13[Laughter]
0:20:14Oh, man. Shannon Woodward, who is one of the cast members of the show, who I follow on
0:20:19Twitter, and without giving any spoilers, one of the interesting things in the show
0:20:25is, you get to the end of season one and you're like, "Whatever happened to—did they really?"
0:20:30So there's people we don't know who has contracts for season two, but there are clearly things
0:20:34planted that make it clear. And if you go, there's a Westworld, a site for Delos, the
0:20:38company that apparently owns Westworld. And there's details being revealed. Like, they
0:20:42must have a one-year-plus social media, like, marketing plan, because they are already,
0:20:48like, leaking stuff, and you have to go through. It's like a little online adventure stuff.
0:20:52So Shannon Woodward posted this very funny thing. She plays Elsie in the show. She's
0:20:56one of the behavioral technicians, works directly for—
0:20:59One of my favorite characters.
0:21:01Yeah, she's great. She's great. And, you know, again, no spoilers. I loved her early in the
0:21:05season, and she's also a very righteous person on Twitter, so great to follow, because she's very
0:21:10active in promoting for, you know, things like justice and equality. But she tweeted
0:21:14something last night. She said, "My dad, who was a real programmer, was excited to see how
0:21:18Siri had been updated. He said to Siri, 'analysis,' and Siri dumped out a bunch of hacks." And her
0:21:26father, I think her father recognized it, or what do you say, he went to Reddit? It's
0:21:30Unicode text, and if you look it up, it's a bunch of emoji that relate to the show.
0:21:35Pete: Really?
0:21:36Pete; Yeah. If you, if you said to Siri, if you say, you can ask Siri questions that are sort of
0:21:41Westworldish related and she will respond and say things like, "That doesn't look like anything to
0:21:45me." So, they updated it right away, I think. I don't know what happened earlier, but people
0:21:50weren't reporting on it. And then after the finale, Don Melton was saying, "Probably a Westworld fan."
0:21:55you know, super fan, somewhere in the Siri team,
0:21:59adding more responses, but the hexadecimal
0:22:02emoji code was pretty good.
0:22:04I only looked up one of them.
0:22:05- Who says Siri isn't getting better?
0:22:08- It's great.
0:22:09One of them was just like a cactus.
0:22:10I didn't look up all of them, but I looked up one.
0:22:12- Let me take a break and thank our first sponsor.
0:22:18It is our good friends at MailChimp.
0:22:2012 million people use MailChimp to connect
0:22:24with their customers, market their products,
0:22:25and grow their e-commerce business every day.
0:22:29Personalize your marketing.
0:22:30You can sell more stuff.
0:22:31When you connect your store to one of MailChimp's hundreds
0:22:35of e-commerce integrations, you can create targeted campaigns,
0:22:39automate helpful product follow-ups,
0:22:41and send back in stock messaging.
0:22:44This is a huge thing.
0:22:45MailChimp has grown so far beyond just email newsletters.
0:22:50The store stuff is amazing.
0:22:51I can't get into the details in the sponsor read here,
0:22:53but it's so much stuff.
0:22:54and they really hook up to a lot of the main e-commerce platforms that are out there.
0:23:00So if you do have some kind of store, what they can do is help you, for people who opt
0:23:04in to an email thing from you, is based on what the people have bought and opted into,
0:23:11not like a creepy type thing, but send them emails that they might actually want to get
0:23:15with stuff they might actually want to buy.
0:23:18It is super...
0:23:21There's like a renaissance in email newsletters.
0:23:24Because I think, you know, back in the day, people signed up for everything was going through email
0:23:29because that was like the first way people got on the internet and then all of a sudden everybody
0:23:32realized I'm getting way too many emails for stuff that I don't want and it kind of got a bad rap.
0:23:37But then it's like water seeks its own level and I feel like there is a right amount and there are
0:23:43a lot of newsletters, a fair amount that I sign up for that I love and I'm happy every time I see
0:23:47them in my inbox. MailChimp is a way that you can create your own. So the store stuff, that's great.
0:23:54if you have a store. All sorts of other great reasons. It integrates with
0:24:00WordPress, you can integrate with Facebook, Shopify, there's one that
0:24:05integrates with an online store. All sorts of ways that you can hook MailChimp
0:24:10up to whatever platforms you're already using for whatever kind of thing that
0:24:15you want to send people to. Pricing. You can send 12,000 emails a month to a list
0:24:20up to 2,000 subscribers with MailChimp's forever free plan, though a few features are only available
0:24:27to paying users. So you could send an awful lot of email to a lot of people for free with MailChimp.
0:24:31As a paying customer, you can send more than 12,000 emails a month, you can access additional
0:24:39features, and you can remove MailChimp's badge from your campaign footers. So where do you go
0:24:45to find out more. Just go to MailChimp.com. No secret code, no slash or anything like that. Just
0:24:51go to MailChimp.com and you can get started. Great service, long-time sponsor of the show.
0:24:56They always sponsor the bar at the live talk show. So, my thanks to MailChimp for, once again,
0:25:02sponsoring the show. Wow, they're brave. That's a very brave thing to do. Sponsoring the bar.
0:25:08Well, the first time, I've often said this, and I do the intro at the show,
0:25:14I have such very nice-- the Daring Fireball audience is very good people.
0:25:20And the first time I did the live talk show-- well, it was the second time, I guess,
0:25:28because it was the first time at the place where we always have it now in San Francisco,
0:25:33a place called Mezzanine. And we had a minimum, and it seemed easily hit.
0:25:41the first year we did it, though, we didn't hit the minimum for the bar. Because people—and
0:25:46I think what happened was that—I said that it's an open bar and it's free, but I didn't emphasize
0:25:53enough that, seriously, drink as much as you want. Go have a second or a third.
0:25:57Oh, that's sort of sweet. People were so reserved.
0:25:59Right. People were like, "Well, I'll have one, but I don't want to stick Gruber with a big tab."
0:26:04But it was—we actually didn't reach the minimum. So ever since I always tell that story to the
0:26:09audience, you know, that like, seriously, drink, you know, we've, we've never had problems
0:26:12hitting the minimum.
0:26:13That's, that's pretty, that's adorable. That is a very lovely audience when you have to
0:26:17encourage them to spend, you know, to use the money that sponsors.
0:26:21And they have different tiers of booze. Like you could just do beer, beer and wine. You
0:26:27can, you know, um, you know, you could, but I get the top shelf booze, you know, like
0:26:32the name brand, you know, vodka and stuff like that. Like instead of, you know, uncle
0:26:36Joe's, you know, Uncle Joe's Russian special, you know. I gotta say, you know, whatever
0:26:42you want. If it's back there, it's supposed to be there. Have as much of it as you want,
0:26:46and MailChimp will just pick it up. It's very easy for me to be generous, too.
0:26:51"Uncle Joe's booze. I like it. The fire's bathtub gin. Money will buy."
0:26:55Right. Well, it's funny, though. It's gotten the other way around now. Like, there's—it's
0:27:02like I think when we were kids, like if the gin was made locally, it's like, "Watch out!"
0:27:07You know? It's like, "Better schedule a trip to the eye doctor because you might go blind."
0:27:13Whereas now there are so many craft distilleries. I can't even tell you, I was just looking the
0:27:18other day, there's a section in the liquor store here where it's like made in Pennsylvania,
0:27:22and there's so many gins being made in Pennsylvania now, and they all have like these
0:27:27amazingly exquisite, designed labels, you know, they all look excellent. It's not,
0:27:33you know, like, the local stuff is expensive now. It's not, it's not…
0:27:36[Laughter]
0:27:36Pete: Oh man, I had a friend who wanted to start years ago, like, I think it was almost
0:27:4020 years ago, he wanted to start a local craft distillery as a distill pub. No such thing
0:27:46existed in Washington state. He'd been a brewer, had run, you know, brew pubs and worked
0:27:50in breweries, had, you know, done the craft thing. He was totally capable of it and the
0:27:54the state didn't know how to license it. But he was trying to buy this bar in the Georgetown
0:27:59area in Seattle, which is this little weird spot that bars operated during prohibition.
0:28:04There was this very weird exception or exclusion or scam or something. So, it was like the
0:28:09longest operating bar in North, continuously operating bar in North America. He was almost,
0:28:14he was going to try to buy it with investors to turn it into the state's first distill
0:28:18pub and one of the first ones in the country, I think, maybe at the time. And they couldn't
0:28:22pull it off because no one knew how to license it. But now it's like, I don't know if you
0:28:25have, no, there are distill pubs. I've seen places, I don't know what they call it, sorry,
0:28:29distill pub is not the right word.
0:28:30But uh,
0:28:31Pete: I know what you mean though.
0:28:32Pete; Place of eunuch's command, distill pub.
0:28:33[Laughter]
0:28:34But yeah, but any places that are doing like, certain kinds of liquor on site, which is,
0:28:39which is, I think that's really cool. It's like, you know, this is, we're trying, we
0:28:43sort of, Westworld's indicative of this, right? There are things about the 19th century
0:28:46that we idealize and we'd like the neat, clean, cool component of it because it seems
0:28:52more real to us.
0:28:53Yeah.
0:28:54It's just another one of those little things, though, that makes me feel like I was born
0:29:00at the right time.
0:29:01I don't know.
0:29:04Maybe it's my personality where whenever I had been born, whether it was the future
0:29:08or further in the past, I would have—I have a personality type or I would think I was
0:29:14born at the right time.
0:29:15But just little things like the fact that I was around as a kid when computers were
0:29:19were super simple and you could totally understand
0:29:22the entirety of how the computer worked
0:29:24as like a 12 year old.
0:29:25I love that.
0:29:28There's a part of me that is a little jealous
0:29:30that my son is growing up in a world where
0:29:34at the age of 12 he's got a MacBook Pro.
0:29:36I mean, it would have been very impressive
0:29:38to 12 year old John Gruber,
0:29:40but I feel like it was right for me
0:29:42that I was clacking away on an Apple IIe at school.
0:29:48my 12-year-old is programming in JavaScript and other stuff, and I'm like, "You know,
0:29:51at 12 I was soldering RS-232 C ports on my 8K computer, so I feel bad. I mean, I'll open up
0:29:58a computer to change something out," and the kids freak out slightly, like, "Can you really do that?"
0:30:02Not like it's illegal, but more like, "Won't that break it?" I'm like, "No, no, you can actually
0:30:06fix things." It's sort of a sad—
0:30:09But in terms of consumable beverages, I like to drink coffee, but I like really, really,
0:30:15really good coffee, and a generation ago, there was no such thing. I mean, I realize
0:30:21there were some people who kept the art of it alive, but as a mass-market product, you
0:30:26know, like, people went into the supermarket and bought a can of Maxwell.
0:30:32I think this is the best time in history to be alive for coffee, because for most of coffee's
0:30:36history it was not made well, except in limited places, if you could get the beans and it
0:30:42was all there, like you had to be in just the right spot at the right time.
0:30:45But when we were kids, the coffee that our parents drank wasn't even made out of Arabica
0:30:50beans.
0:30:51It was made out of—it wasn't even really coffee.
0:30:54It was made out of some other, like, weird cheap bean.
0:30:57Were they chicory-based or is that something else?
0:30:59I don't know.
0:31:00There's some difference.
0:31:01I could ask Marco.
0:31:02I'm sure he could.
0:31:03It was a brown—I thought they melted brown crayons in water.
0:31:07The basic story is that good coffee from Arabica beans needs a certain kind of climate and
0:31:14certain type of atmosphere, and that's why it tends to grow at the top of mountains and certain,
0:31:19you know, regions of the world where the temperature's right. It's very particular about
0:31:24where it will grow well. And then there's another type of coffee bean that'll grow anywhere. And
0:31:30that's like what the coffee of like the late 20th, you know, this post-World War II 20th century
0:31:37America was made out of, because it was super cheap.
0:31:40The coffee cycle is so funny too, is our mutual friend Tonks, as Tony connects me, he, I met him
0:31:47first, I think we talked about this in some episode before, but in 2004, I met him when he
0:31:52was the head roaster at a local coffee shop that had started up that was trying to be more of a
0:31:57community coffee shop again. They were trying to reclaim from Wi-Fi already, and I went to my first
0:32:01cupping in the back of that store when I was reporting the story, and then Tony left and,
0:32:05you know, kind of traveled a bunch, and he started his own brand. That got sold to Blue Bottle.
0:32:09And then, you know, and he's, you know, he's kicking around doing stuff, but I'm like, now
0:32:15cupping is like such a standard thing.
0:32:18Like, it's a thing people expect.
0:32:20Like the sophistication, even of 2004, now seems almost quaint.
0:32:25And when Howard Schultz just announced that he was stepping down to see Starbucks, he
0:32:29did it at the 15th Avenue, I think it was the 15th Avenue, roasting place, which is
0:32:33Starbucks' new model for a place that is like a roasting center with cuppings and high-end
0:32:38coffees and the whole bit. Like, it's now a thing they are commercializing and pushing out as a,
0:32:43you know, high-end experience, as a, you know, repeatable deal. And that's, you know,
0:32:48that's already where we're at. So what's the next refinement? Like, there's got to be, like,
0:32:5010 years from now we're going to be looking at that as course and quaint, I'm sure.
0:32:54Pete: And, you know, in the evening hours, I enjoy the occasional adult beverage,
0:32:59and it's, there's never been a better time. I mean, it's, if you like beer, like, when my
0:33:06My dad was my age. The only beer that there was was the mass-market Pilsners, you know,
0:33:13they all tasted the same.
0:33:14Yeah, unless you lived in a small town someplace or people did, you know, the home brewing
0:33:18thing was starting up, but those were usually, they were, you know, they're quirky. No,
0:33:24there's never been a better time to have a sophisticated palate, probably in the history
0:33:29of the world, in terms of—this ties into technology. So you know how Mark and Dries
0:33:32and other people have pushed these charts that shows how everyone has the kind of stuff
0:33:37that previous generations would have dreamed of. Everyone has a TV, everyone has a DVD,
0:33:41a lot of people have phones, even if they're like living below the poverty line, they have
0:33:44a cell phone on a pay-as-you-go-pant—like, all of these certain signs of material success.
0:33:49But this is the point that people made about the Apple phone, you have made this point
0:33:53over and over again, is the iPhone is the same price no matter how rich or poor you
0:33:58And I think the beverage thing falls in the same thing.
0:34:01You can get, I mean, obviously you can spend a lot of money on beverages, but you can spend a few dollars for a drink,
0:34:07let's say $5 to $10 for a drink and get one of the finest drinks ever made in human history.
0:34:12Now, you can go up from there, you can spend $15 for civet poop coffee or whatever for a cup of it and a million dollars for champagne,
0:34:20But this lower tier, generally accessible, even if it's a special occasion price, is achievable by like most of humanity in the developed world.
0:34:29Yeah, it's amazing. And you know, I think that there was a… I don't know, you know, I think there was sort of a pride in post-World War II America at the sort of homogenization of culture.
0:34:44Mm. Mm hmm.
0:34:45It seemed right, like when my grandfather was a young man,
0:34:49all the beer came from local breweries.
0:34:51Every town of a certain,
0:34:53every town with 10 to 15,000 people had a brewery
0:34:56that made the beer for the town.
0:34:58And then in my dad's generation,
0:35:00the Anheuser-Busch's and the Coors became such a thing,
0:35:06and TV rammed this home that,
0:35:11you didn't drink like Philadelphia beer,
0:35:14drank the same Budweiser that everybody drank. You drank American beer. But it was all bland,
0:35:21all watered down for the--
0:35:22- I hate that taste.
0:35:23- Right.
0:35:24- Metallic taste.
0:35:26- And the craft brewing revolution certainly started-- I was in college in the late '90s. It
0:35:33had already started, but it was still obscure. And so when you'd go to parties, if they had beer,
0:35:38it was just cheap bland stuff. So I just thought, "Well, I don't like beer."
0:35:43Which is crazy in hindsight, because I love beer.
0:35:47But I love very particular kinds of beer.
0:35:50And I just also think that it's such a wonderful world right
0:35:55now for somebody who truly is obsessive about something
0:35:58like that, like Tonks, and that he can just go and start
0:36:01his own coffee company.
0:36:03Whereas in the 1960s, that's not how it worked.
0:36:06It was infeasible.
0:36:07You had to be like Procter and Gamble.
0:36:09It was like a billion dollar thing.
0:36:12there was no way for somebody, you know, like two people, you know, to start a business
0:36:16where we're going to send coffee around the world by mail order.
0:36:20There's a great book by an editor I've worked with for years at The Economist, who's now
0:36:24the deputy editor, Tom Standage, called History of the World in Six Glasses. It's maybe like
0:36:29a decade old now, and he looks at it's beer, spirits, coffee, tea, what's the other one?
0:36:39like, "I forgot all six." It's tea and coffee, beer and spirits, and I forget the two. But it's
0:36:45basically a history of how civilization advanced through the perpetuation of certain kinds of
0:36:51drinks because of how—
0:36:52Pete: What was the name of this book?
0:36:53Pete; A History of the World in Six Glasses.
0:36:55Pete; Huh.
0:36:55Pete; And it's six different things, but like, tea is an amazing thing because it's got antibacterial
0:37:02properties, you boil the water to drink it, it replaced the small beer, which is like a very
0:37:07low-alcohol beer that was drunk, that was given out to factory workers in England and
0:37:11other places. They were given a certain quantity of beer to drink every day and it was very
0:37:14low alcohol, but they were always mildly, you know, inebriated. Tea was a healthful
0:37:19beverage.
0:37:20And it revolutionized factories because people were—
0:37:22Pete: It focuses the mind.
0:37:23[Laughter]
0:37:24David: Exactly. But people were living in places with bad water supplies, you know,
0:37:27whatever, so it improved health, so it was healthy, it was anti-bacterial, and it didn't
0:37:31get you drunk. And so, it became the beverage of temperance and so forth. And anyway, it's
0:37:35a lovely book because he argues, and very persuasively, that certain, like, the advancement
0:37:42of society isn't, it's not that we got tea because we're at a certain point in civilization
0:37:47where it's possible to have like a global supply chain, it's more like tea actually
0:37:50influenced the industrial revolution significantly.
0:37:53Which is cool.
0:37:55Pete: Fascinating.
0:37:59I have long, I, it's one of those things where I've never really done the deep dive, but
0:38:04I will at some point find a couple of good books on it and really go deep on it.
0:38:12But I have a fascination with the Prohibition in the United States.
0:38:20Because it's another one of those things where it happened—I knew the basic years of when
0:38:26it happened, around 1920 or so, and it only lasted about 12 years, and it led to the rise
0:38:34of gangsters who'd run booze into the cities and Al Capone, blah, blah, blah. But as a kid,
0:38:39it just seemed like, "Well, that was a long time ago, and it's over." But then when you become an
0:38:47adult and you realize just how 100 years ago really isn't that long, right, in some ways.
0:38:54Pete: No.
0:38:55Michael, in the world did making alcohol illegal ever gain popular support?
0:39:03that they'd pass a constitutional amendment. Like, to pass a constitutional amendment,
0:39:08something has to be overwhelmingly popular.
0:39:10Pete: You know what it was? It was fake news, John. It was fake news.
0:39:14It was, like, mothers spread these, you know, the lies about drinking were spread and believed.
0:39:21John "Slick" Baum: In light of our recent election here in the United States and how the
0:39:26fuck did this happen? It's soothing to me mentally to think back to other times where,
0:39:33you know, there were what the fuck were we thinking moments in U.S. politics.
0:39:39And—
0:39:39We have cycles. Hey, we're about to have our first tea-totaling president,
0:39:43and I don't know how long.
0:39:44That's an interesting thought.
0:39:45I—that's—
0:39:46He doesn't drink, and I, you know, I reflect—like,
0:39:48Trump has no vices except lying, and he's lying about that, right?
0:39:53Right.
0:39:53But he said he didn't drink, so I assumed it was a lie. It turns out he's absolutely sincere. People
0:39:59have said they've seen him drink in the past, but it may have been decades ago and there have been
0:40:03confirmation people have been with him, you know, enemies and friends and people who are former
0:40:07friends. Like, he doesn't drink alcohol. He doesn't seem to have any alcohol, which is,
0:40:11and it's not a, it doesn't seem to be a moralistic thing. His brother, I mean, he has a family history.
0:40:15Pete: He had an older brother who, you know, literally a long time ago, I guess,
0:40:21It's a drunk himself.
0:40:22Jared: In early '80s?
0:40:23It died, but he, you know, pretty much drank himself.
0:40:25Pete: Yeah, drunk himself to death, right, yeah.
0:40:26And I'm, so I mean, you know, you can see that, like, there are signs of Trump, like
0:40:29things like that, that I think maybe the man has some empathy, compassion, or at least
0:40:34insight, self-corrective capability, but it is fasting.
0:40:38It is fasting to have a president who, I don't know how much Obama drank, I think he liked
0:40:43the beverage.
0:40:44We know he indulged in some cigarettes before he was elected and then, maybe he didn't
0:40:48Jared; No, he smoked, he didn't quit until after he was elected.
0:40:49Pete; Oh, that's right.
0:40:50And then occasionally, there's reports, maybe he sneaked a cigarette here and there,
0:40:53right, at sight. But he's mostly quit, stuffed thing. But it's Trump being a teetotal. I don't
0:41:00think it'll have any impact. I don't think he's going to go out. He's never been a temperance
0:41:03advocate. But I think when I've read things, here's the weird thing about this guy, right?
0:41:09There are times that I read things he says and I go, "But this is very reasonable." And I've read
0:41:13things he said in some middle of long interviews about his brother. And sometimes he's a little
0:41:18harsh about it, but often he is very sympathetic to what the brother went through and very
0:41:22sympathetic to the effect it had on the whole family and how sad it was he died young. And
0:41:26I'm like, "All right, well, you know, I like to know there is a human being under
0:41:30there somewhere."
0:41:31Pete: He is a bit of a cipher. It is one of the weird, I mean, whether you, you know,
0:41:34again, whether you like him, don't like him, or somehow are indifferent.
0:41:39[Laughter]
0:41:40Pete: A very small percentage of Trump voters are actually celebrating, from what I can
0:41:45tell. They're all concerned what's coming next too because they don't know if he's
0:41:48going to do what they promised him either.
0:41:49One of the odd-- well, he's not.
0:41:53One of the odd things about him, though, is that he does--
0:41:56his personality seems to be a bit of a cipher.
0:42:01Whereas Obama, I think, wears his personality
0:42:04on his shirt sleeve, much like Bill Clinton and, I think,
0:42:08too, George W. Bush.
0:42:10I think Elsa, yeah.
0:42:11That's right.
0:42:12I think Hillary is guarded, famously.
0:42:15But there are widespread reports, though,
0:42:17from the people who are close to her that in person she's very warm, funny, and empathetic.
0:42:24But on the campaign trail, for reasons that we won't get into, because it's, you know...
0:42:30But she publicly put up sort of a more serious, guarded personality.
0:42:41But—
0:42:42Pete: Yeah, I'm wondering if we'll see, we'll probably see the Hillary in the Woods
0:42:45photos "Give Me Life" because she looks like a great weightless drop-offer despite
0:42:51what's coming next.
0:42:52But isn't—
0:42:53Jared: But you never hear stories about like, the real Trump from the people close to him.
0:42:56Like there doesn't seem to be one.
0:42:57Pete; There's no real Trump.
0:42:59Jared; But talking about his older brother really does, I do believe, I'm with you,
0:43:03where 99% of the stuff out of his mouth I don't believe, but when he talks about his
0:43:07brother it seems sincere that he, you know, and that it really did, you know, he saw what
0:43:11happened and he decided, "I'm not going to drink." And the other thing that's very self-aware about
0:43:15it that I saw, the New York Times had a good story about this way earlier in the campaign,
0:43:20was the other thing that he said about it was, it wasn't just, "Well, I saw what happened to
0:43:24my brother and decided not to drink." He also, very self-aware, said, "I also know that I'm not
0:43:31much for moderation, personally." You know?
0:43:34Pete: It's amazing from him. Wow!
0:43:35[Laughter]
0:43:36Jon Hayser, Ph.D. You know, and looking, like, look at the way he decorated at his home!
0:43:40Pete: Yeah, well, and he also occasionally, like, the unguarded Trump is fascinating because he's,
0:43:44he's, you know, a bully and a fascist in certain ways. And then he says things like,
0:43:48when it came up about transgender bathroom bills, like in North Carolina and elsewhere,
0:43:53his first reaction, someone asked about it, he said, "Well, people should go to whatever
0:43:57bathroom they're comfortable with." And I was like, "Well, that's cool! Like, I'm good with
0:44:00that." And then his campaign walked it back and wrapped it and put it into Republican phraseology
0:44:04and, you know, whatever. But his first reaction, you know, is people should just make whatever
0:44:09choice they want for themselves, it doesn't really affect other people, which you could
0:44:12argue is a little bit of a narcissist choice too. But it was a more, that was his honest
0:44:16reaction. I'm like, I'm curious how much of that kind of blunt honesty we're going to see versus
0:44:22the, you know, tendencies towards much worse behavior. I'm not optimistic per se, but I'm
0:44:27trying to be curious because we will see things that are going to be totally unexpected
0:44:32from a Republican elected president. They're going to not conform with any of my, my wife says,
0:44:37she said this a number of times, the reason that we're feeling anxiety, and I think this goes for
0:44:41Trump voters as well. I think there are a number of Trump voters who feel exactly the same way.
0:44:45I mean, some are elated, but I think that's a small percentage compared to the largest number
0:44:50of people who voted for him, is she said he defeats our ability to predict the future. We
0:44:54all have a little internal prediction capability, and he breaks that and you feel anxious. And
0:44:59that's also what people talk about with fascism, not necessarily directly for him, is that fascists
0:45:04and abusive domestic partners and people in those categories, they try to unsettle you so you never
0:45:09know what's coming next, so you live in a constant state of anxiety. I don't think that's his plan,
0:45:13but I think that's how we feel, that's how I feel, that's how my wife feels.
0:45:16Pete: Right.
0:45:17[Laughter]
0:45:19Pete; How about that technology? How about that new power dual-charter?
0:45:27[Laughter]
0:45:28Pete; Let's talk about something that we know works.
0:45:30Pete; Who says I'm not good at segues?
0:45:33That's great. So you had a story at Macworld. I think it just came out yesterday. Wait, wait, I would interrupt you. All right
0:45:38segue
0:45:40Magic loop. Did you see about the ostensibly faked magic magic leap demonstration? No, tell me about it
0:45:46You may want to talk about it. I own all the details
0:45:48But you know, it's a it's one of these new VR things and Kevin Kelly wrote a really breathless piece earlier this year for Wired
0:45:54He got a demo. He got to see it and it's a bunch of super intelligent people involved in it
0:45:59They're running the lab in Florida away from Silicon Valley. Oh
0:46:02Like next level like whatever everyone's working on now that's being released in demo. This is the thing beyond it is how it's being hyped
0:46:09Well, they put out a demonstration video and then it came out that it was actually like a Hollywood produced Hollywood style produced video
0:46:16That does not actually reflect any hardware they have already
0:46:18So I was just thinking this when you said segue I was thinking like yes
0:46:22Remember how the segue changed the world magic leap is right up there with it. Sorry. That's my segue
0:46:27They there's a some sort of tour here in Philadelphia where you can I don't know if it's I guess it's history historic sites
0:46:35But oh, yeah historic sites are all very close to each other frankly
0:46:40But I see them occasionally where there's obvious tourists with helmets on on segues on a tour
0:46:46You know like usually somewhere around eight to ten of them
0:46:49There's somebody in the front who's clearly the tour leader
0:46:54And it just seems like the dumbest way to get around.
0:46:57(laughing)
0:46:59Like I do, I love the idea, I'm fascinated by the idea
0:47:04that the thing self-balances on two wheels,
0:47:08but the segues themselves are so stupid.
0:47:11- Oh yeah, I mean, I just remember the whole,
0:47:13the breathless, it's gonna change the world,
0:47:15the patent filings are amazing,
0:47:16they think the people investing, like Jeff Bezos,
0:47:19think this will be, change the way cities are built.
0:47:22- Right.
0:47:23Steve Jobs trashed it.
0:47:25- Yeah, I'm not surprised.
0:47:26It's like, eh, and it's a really cool scooter
0:47:28that has certain applications, it's done pretty well.
0:47:31Anyway, I'm sorry to interrupt,
0:47:32but Magic Leap just got me with that.
0:47:35Like they thought no one was gonna figure out
0:47:36it was a faked or produced demonstration.
0:47:39- Do you know what I got?
0:47:41I have the Google Pixel.
0:47:45- Yeah, oh yeah, yeah. - Pixel phone.
0:47:47And I got the VR headset, I forget what the,
0:47:51I forget what the, I can't remember what the name of it.
0:47:53They have a Daydream.
0:47:55I haven't used it a lot yet, but it's pretty neat.
0:48:00I mean, I forget how much I paid for the headset,
0:48:02but it wasn't too much.
0:48:04I mean, once you've bought the phone for $800
0:48:06or whatever it costs, the $75 headset is a neat add-on.
0:48:11It's really pretty good.
0:48:13Although it does, Jonas was really into it,
0:48:17but it does get hot.
0:48:19It eventually tells you that it couches.
0:48:24It's sort of like, remember when the Wii would tell you
0:48:27to take a break, the Nintendo Wii?
0:48:29- Yeah, oh yeah, yeah.
0:48:31- It told Jonas to take a break,
0:48:33but it wasn't really for his well-being.
0:48:35It was because the phone had overheated
0:48:38and needed to cool down.
0:48:40But it's actually pretty good.
0:48:41The latency is really, really good.
0:48:43Like, I was, what I thought was wondering
0:48:44if it would pick up.
0:48:46But I can also completely see why Apple
0:48:49hasn't built such a thing.
0:48:51That's not ready yet.
0:48:52They want the thing.
0:48:53They want the thing whatever magically intends to make,
0:48:56which they may not be able to achieve.
0:48:59That's what Apple would prefer.
0:49:00Right.
0:49:02I don't-- it baffles me that people don't see this in Apple.
0:49:06So one of the things when people complain about the new MacBook
0:49:09Pros, that they're not pro enough,
0:49:12that they're not performance heavy enough.
0:49:14Like, they're like, other companies are making laptops
0:49:17that you can drive high-end VR helmets from.
0:49:21And it's like, well, that's, of course they are,
0:49:26'cause that's what the PC industry always does,
0:49:30is build whatever, you know.
0:49:32That's why gaming PCs exist, that the PC,
0:49:36for some people, it's just a generic box
0:49:38that you can use it to drive any computing task you want.
0:49:41That is not what Apple does.
0:49:44Apple doesn't make generic boxes that you can make other things from.
0:49:47If Apple's going to make a VR helmet, the VR helmet itself will be the computer,
0:49:52and it will have the graphics and screen that it needs to be--
0:49:56Oh, yes.
0:49:57That makes a lot of sense.
0:49:58Right.
0:50:00They're not going to work on making the phone into a jerry-rigged VR screen,
0:50:06even though it's possible.
0:50:07And the Pixel thing is good enough that it's neat.
0:50:10But it's, you know, you can also, it's also, it's not retina resolution. I mean, you can totally see the pixels of the things that you're, that you're seeing.
0:50:18And it's, you know, it's just clunky to stick your phone into a helmet. And same way that it's clunky to have a helmet that's literally tethered to a laptop computer.
0:50:29Like, maybe if you hold your watch up really close to your face, it'll simulate, no, I'm sorry. But no, I think you're right. I think it's unlikely.
0:50:37Apple makes an operating system that is capable of being adapted to a lot of different circumstances,
0:50:45but they don't make hardware that has general purpose. I mean, I think that's the MacBook
0:50:49Pro is really more of a niche computer now. It doesn't have the same general appeal.
0:50:55I've been saying that about the 12-inch MacBook since it was released. It's not like the MacBook
0:50:59Air, which was for a lot of people. The 12-inch MacBook is more particular because it makes
0:51:04you make choices and if it doesn't fit your needs then it's not the laptop for you and
0:51:07the MacBook Pro is much more restrained or restricted than the previous models of MacBook
0:51:13Pro.
0:51:16But speaking of those…
0:51:17So you wrote a review this week of this Nuertech NuPower, N-U-P-O-W-E-R. I've already got
0:51:24a link in the show notes. NuPower, it's a 60 watt power adapter that has two outputs.
0:51:31One of them is a USB-A, the old school USB, and then the other one is USB-C. And you can
0:51:36use them at the same time.
0:51:38So you could plug this into the wall and then take your existing cable you charge your phone
0:51:45with, the rectangular USB-A, plug that in, plug your phone in, and then with a new 13
0:51:53inch MacBook Pro or the just plain MacBook, you could charge that from the USB-C at the
0:51:58same time.
0:51:59Yeah, it's pretty slick and it comes with a six foot AC cable. So you're using your six foot
0:52:04USB-C charging cable that came with the MacBook or MacBook Pro you have you know 12 feet suddenly if you want that from Apple you
0:52:11Have to pay a the adapter is I think more ungainly
0:52:14B you have to pay if you don't have one around you got to pay I think it's $20 or $90 to get the six foot
0:52:21Extension for the power adapter that comes with your with your Apple laptop, so I like that
0:52:26I mean, so right, so it's like a cable, it's kind of like an offset.
0:52:30So if you've got a 12-inch MacBook, it's sort of ideal because you plug this in to one port
0:52:34and you plug in your, you know, iPad or iPhone to charge the new power thing, and you also
0:52:40have six foot of cable beyond that, so you can have your cable, you know, your Type-A
0:52:45to whatever cable, and your laptop cable, and a long AC cable, and it's 50 bucks for
0:52:51the whole thing.
0:52:52I think it's a great replacement or traveling alternative because it seems to fit all these
0:52:57bases.
0:52:58And 60 watts is an interesting number because it's clear they design it more around, they're
0:53:02like 45 watt PCs that this also works with.
0:53:07It works with anything with USB-C charging, power delivery 2.0 is the spec, which is a
0:53:12lot of devices.
0:53:13And so the, you know, the MacBook, 12 inch MacBook is 29 watts.
0:53:16There's some 45 watt laptops and so forth.
0:53:19The MacBook Pro 13-inch models are 61 watts.
0:53:23- Yeah, which is crazy, right?
0:53:25Where, what? - Yeah.
0:53:26- I don't understand that.
0:53:27- Apple's very specific about how they like
0:53:29to map batteries to charging,
0:53:30and they just do exactly what they want.
0:53:32It's weird.
0:53:33- Well, it's the first one I can think of, though,
0:53:34that's such an odd number.
0:53:36Like, the-- - Well, no, the MacBook
0:53:37is a 29-watt charger.
0:53:38- Oh, I guess you're right.
0:53:39- And the MacBook Pro is 87 watts,
0:53:41and somebody told me, I didn't look this up,
0:53:43that the previous MacBook Pro, the 15-inch one, I'm sorry,
0:53:45was also 87 watts.
0:53:47So they have a very specific power profile.
0:53:51They don't like to make a generic charging thing.
0:53:53So the new power is probably not appropriate
0:53:57for a 15-inch MacBook Pro because it will be hard
0:53:59for it to keep up if you're doing anything
0:54:00that's pulling power down.
0:54:01For the 13-inch, it'll keep up almost as quickly.
0:54:05I mean, it's 3% off.
0:54:07So it will charge while you're using it,
0:54:09and it might charge a tiny bit slower.
0:54:11If you plug in a USB Type-A device to charge,
0:54:15it'll take away from the charging
0:54:16going to the USB-C port.
0:54:19So if you're charging an iPad at 2.4 amps,
0:54:22that's 12 watts at five volts.
0:54:24And that, so that'll be, you know,
0:54:2512 watts would be subtracted from the 60
0:54:28if you're doing that and you have a 13-inch MacBook.
0:54:30But I think in a lot of cases,
0:54:31it's a really nice alternative.
0:54:32And it's got, you know, it's not a square little thing.
0:54:35It's like longer, it looks more like a traditional one,
0:54:38but it's very lightweight and it's got rounded edges.
0:54:40- Only thing I think I don't like about it though
0:54:41is I don't like that to plug this into the wall,
0:54:44you have to use a cable.
0:54:46It has, you know, it's one of the,
0:54:48so this is the brick, but it's,
0:54:50you plug a power cable into the back,
0:54:52and then it's a six-foot cable that goes to the wall.
0:54:54So like, there are some cases,
0:54:56some situations where you do want that,
0:54:58but there's others, like when you're,
0:54:59like when I'm in a hotel,
0:55:01usually most hotels now have like a desk
0:55:04where there is like a power on the desk.
0:55:07And it's not, you know, like I don't need it.
0:55:09The six-foot cable is just gonna be in the way there.
0:55:11Like I kind of-- - No, it's true.
0:55:12- I wish that I could just plug it right in, you know,
0:55:15like it had the prongs on the thing.
0:55:18- That's true, I think that's the drawback,
0:55:19is if that's what you want,
0:55:21then you can always carry the original one.
0:55:23But no, I think that is the drawback,
0:55:26'cause you get extra cable that way with that option.
0:55:28But I think, and I have that same issue,
0:55:31although I'll get to a hotel,
0:55:32and by the time I got stuff plugged in,
0:55:33or if you're gonna wanna work,
0:55:34I'm often hunting around for an AC outlet.
0:55:37And some of them have power strips,
0:55:38I bet in some newer, or not newer hotels,
0:55:39but retrograde ones, power strips.
0:55:41- Right, or maybe it would be nice if it,
0:55:43again, this would obviously make it a lot physically bigger.
0:55:46So maybe I'm not thinking it through,
0:55:49but it might be nice if it had one of those cables
0:55:51that you could like, it would retract,
0:55:53you know, like the way like most vacuum cleaners work now,
0:55:56you can retract the cable.
0:55:58- Oh yeah, we're gonna see a lot more USB-C chargers too.
0:56:01I mean, it's taken the power delivery spec.
0:56:04So I actually interviewed for an article
0:56:05that's gonna come out in Fast Company about USB-C,
0:56:08like why it's so hard to figure out what cables are good.
0:56:11Like why isn't there some group?
0:56:13I mean, my conclusion, spoiler, is that the death of magazine test labs is basically why
0:56:18we're having problems with USB-C. Like, it's not – so, I talked to the head of the USB
0:56:21implementers forum, the USB-IF and the chief operating officer, and had a great talk about
0:56:26like where does Type-C fit into the ecosystem and what are you guys responsible for? Like,
0:56:30where does your point end? And one of the things the president told me is he said really
0:56:36frankly, this isn't your grandma and grandpa's USB 2.0. He said it's much more complicated,
0:56:42and we're seeing more problems because it's a
0:56:45much more complicated and difficult spec.
0:56:46It does so much more.
0:56:47And so, they're not surprised, but it's what
0:56:49manufacturers want.
0:56:50It's not like the USBIF invented a difficult spec
0:56:54and it's being inflicted on customers.
0:56:56It's like all of the major computer and mobile
0:56:58makers are all involved with USBIF or they're on
0:57:01the board or they're deeply involved in the
0:57:03standards process.
0:57:04They wanted this to happen.
0:57:05Ultimately, in a couple years, maybe a year,
0:57:07we're all going to be delighted that we have,
0:57:10maybe we still have lightning, but we're
0:57:11of lightning, that seems like it's going to happen, but we have one cable and one thing
0:57:15that works every goddamn place, and then new displays will all have USB-C support, and
0:57:20new everything will have it, and we'll say, "Why do we make such a big deal about this?"
0:57:25Because the pain of transition and finding the adapters that don't exist and legacy support
0:57:30is a pain, but I think it's really a net positive for it.
0:57:35And so the power part is particularly difficult.
0:57:36There's something called Power Delivery 2.0, which is, as far as I can tell, is the first
0:57:41widespread implementation in products of a non-proprietary,
0:57:45standards-based, but trade group-owned,
0:57:47but non-proprietary spec for doing power
0:57:50that's above like 15 to 30 watts.
0:57:52It can go up to 100 watts.
0:57:54There are previous USB specs that allowed this,
0:57:56but from what I can tell,
0:57:57I don't know that many devices use them.
0:57:59They're very specific and you need a specific adapter.
0:58:02This is the first generic way that's already in millions
0:58:05or maybe even tens of millions of shipping products
0:58:07that supports above 12 or 15 watts.
0:58:10a standard way and interoperable, interchangeable adapters. So, the ecosystem I think is about
0:58:15to sort of like, the chipset issue is a big deal. Every, John, you know this, right, like
0:58:21lightning, every lightning and Thunderbolt 2 cable had a computer in the tip of every
0:58:26cable, right?
0:58:27Pete: Right.
0:58:28I did know that.
0:58:29Pete: And so, the same thing is true with USB-C and that makes it more complicated.
0:58:30It's all, USB-C is like, you're plugging a computer that looks like a cable into your
0:58:35computer's port that has a controller and they have to talk to each other. And so, like,
0:58:39that right means the controller chipsets and the USB-C cable chipsets all have to
0:58:45be in this incredibly perfect alignment and that is I think what's been taking
0:58:49so long and we're starting to finally see the benefits of it you know already
0:58:52like a almost two years into the rollout and next year will be very different.
0:58:57I think one of the underestimated easily overlooked but fascinating to me the
0:59:03things that's going on in hardware everywhere today.
0:59:08Whether you're in the consumer electronics business in the car
0:59:14business, everything is that every individual component is
0:59:21slowly but surely turning into its own to being a computer. I
0:59:25know, right? Oh, you're totally right. And I know Joanna Stern
0:59:27and I talked about this on about the Mac, but about the touch
0:59:30But it's fascinating to me.
0:59:32It just is.
0:59:33Every time I look at this review unit and I just think about it,
0:59:36it just pleases me to no end that the Touch Bar is an iOS
0:59:40computer in my Mac computer.
0:59:44I find it just makes me smile.
0:59:47It just cracks me up.
0:59:48Because just like we were talking about half an hour ago,
0:59:51like when we were kids, a computer was super expensive.
0:59:57And you'd get like 64 kilobytes of memory, and it was enough money.
1:00:02Luxury!
1:00:03Right!
1:00:04And it was a lot of money, and you had to be very careful, and it was quite large.
1:00:10And now there's a much better computer than that in the tip of your Lightning cable.
1:00:15The analog-to-Lightning adapter has a GSP in it.
1:00:19I mean, it's a $9 cable, and that computer is probably more powerful than my first personal
1:00:24maybe even my second person.
1:00:26I mean, could it do, is it as powerful as a Commodore 64?
1:00:29Maybe not, I'm not sure, but it's certainly
1:00:32as powerful as my first computer.
1:00:33- In some ways, it surely is.
1:00:35There are certain, some aspects of it
1:00:37that are surely faster than a Commodore 64.
1:00:39It's crazy.
1:00:40- Well, this is like storage.
1:00:41How many terabytes of storage do you own now, personally?
1:00:43Like 10?
1:00:44- I don't even know.
1:00:45- You don't even know.
1:00:46I have at least, I don't know, I've got seven or eight
1:00:47lying around, maybe more, and I probably got
1:00:49two or three terabytes in the cloud,
1:00:51and we are gonna laugh at how small it is,
1:00:53that is, like the way that 50 gigabytes seems ridiculously tiny. Like, I backed up 80 gigs,
1:01:00I added more, I use Backblaze for my desktop machine backup, and I'm like, "Oh, you know,
1:01:05I didn't have this part of this drive backed up." So, I add it, it says, "Oh, that's 80 gigs,
1:01:09I got gigabit internet." It added it in like an hour or something. And it just seems so laughably
1:01:14small, even though it's enormous. And so, you know, in five years, we'll have like 50 terabytes
1:01:18of storage and we won't be thinking about it much either.
1:01:21(laughing)
1:01:22Gets bigger, everything gets bigger, faster, better.
1:01:25- Let me take a break and we'll come back to that
1:01:30because one of the computers in our computers now
1:01:34are the computer that's inside AirPods,
1:01:37which still haven't shipped and I'd like to talk about that.
1:01:40- Oh yeah, yeah.
1:01:41- I'm gonna take a break here and thank our next sponsor
1:01:44and it's our good friends at Fracture.
1:01:47You know Fracture, it's the photo company
1:01:48that you send them your photos,
1:01:50they print your photos directly on class.
1:01:51They sponsored the show two episodes ago
1:01:54and I told you then, I told you,
1:01:56order now for the holidays
1:01:58because they're gonna get backed up.
1:02:00Well guess what, they're already backed up.
1:02:02Orders placed today are shipped after Christmas.
1:02:05We are recording, you're hearing us record
1:02:07on Friday, December 9th.
1:02:10I'll bet the show comes out on Saturday, December 10th.
1:02:13So whatever point you're listening to me tell you this, if you were going to get people
1:02:18fracture gifts for Christmas, you had a great idea.
1:02:21And if you didn't order them already, I'm really sorry to tell you that you're too late.
1:02:24But what you can do, what you can do is you can order gift cards from fracture.
1:02:32You can give them, you can give out a gift card so that people can print their own fractures.
1:02:37And you could do that all the way up to December 19th and still get Christmas delivery.
1:02:42So you could still do it.
1:02:43You're not totally shit out of luck.
1:02:47These are great, great products.
1:02:49So again, if you're thinking about it for Christmas, too late, hope you listened to
1:02:52me last time.
1:02:53Some of you probably did.
1:02:55But it's such a great product.
1:02:56Holiday aside, Fracture is just the best way, really is.
1:03:02I would say this even if they weren't a long-time sponsor of the show, but if you want to print
1:03:07your photos, it's the best way to do it because there's no fuss and they look great.
1:03:13looks better than putting it on paper and then putting it into a traditional frame.
1:03:17It looks better and it's easier to deal with because if you've ever done the thing where
1:03:21you go to Ikea and get a picture frame and then you have a picture printed out and you
1:03:26put it in and then you secure the back and then you look at the front and the picture's
1:03:29off by like two degrees and you've got to undo the whole thing and put it back in. What
1:03:34a pain in the ass.
1:03:36Fractures are just printed right on the glass and they ship in this super clever little
1:03:40cardboard thing that comes with everything you need to hang it on a wall or to prop it
1:03:45up on your desk or on a mantle or wherever you want to put it. And it looks so cool because
1:03:50it's just this edge to edge design. There is no frame that's necessary. It's just a
1:03:54piece of glass with the picture edge to edge. Looks so great. So go check them out. Get
1:04:03your own pictures printed. Pick up some gift cards if you want to for the holidays and
1:04:08haven't ordered already, and go to fractureme.com/podcast. That's the name, that's the URL. They don't
1:04:17care which podcast. Everybody's podcast gets the same URL. But then, when you order, they
1:04:23ask a one-question survey, which is, "Where did you hear a fracture from?" And you can
1:04:26tell them you heard about it right here on the talk show. My thanks to Fracture. Told
1:04:31you it was going to be—they're going to get backed up. Listen to me next time.
1:04:35Love their stuff. I need to order some but I didn't need them for presents. I got a I'm gonna remember that so airbrite
1:04:40You know air pods still haven't shipped as I said, we are recording on Friday December 9th
1:04:45And so it's like HBO and Westworld. They had a stock production. They had a reengineer the world to Apple and Apple's and they're getting
1:04:52Very close to being to missing the holidays. I have heard just in the last 24 hours
1:04:59I have heard not from like a very well-placed little birdie, but from a birdie
1:05:04that there's a possibility that there are whispers in Apple,
1:05:09among people who work in Apple retail,
1:05:11that they might actually come in quote unquote
1:05:13the next few days.
1:05:15- Oh my God. - But nobody has,
1:05:16but I asked and I was like, well, is it like a token amount?
1:05:20Like, well, some of them are coming
1:05:22and we're gonna sell them to some people,
1:05:24but you've got no chance of actually getting one
1:05:26because they're gonna be instantly back ordered
1:05:28six to eight weeks.
1:05:29Is it that type of shipping?
1:05:31Or is it like you have a reasonable chance of getting them,
1:05:36walking into an Apple store and walking out with AirPods?
1:05:41And the answer was no idea.
1:05:44This is, in my opinion, the biggest Apple
1:05:51screw up in recent memory.
1:05:54- I gotta agree, 'cause, so, let me,
1:05:58I'm gonna bump up one level. - The only thing I can
1:05:59- I'll compare it to one other thing,
1:06:02and I think that this is worse,
1:06:03is the, I think it was the white iPhone 4.
1:06:08- Oh yes.
1:06:12- So when the iPhone 4 came out,
1:06:14that was the one with the glass front and back,
1:06:17and I think that was the one that didn't ship, right?
1:06:22And it kind of got lost, I think,
1:06:25in the shuffle of Antennagate,
1:06:27because that was the phone that had Antennagate.
1:06:29- That's right.
1:06:31- It was supposed to, there were black ones and white ones,
1:06:33and the white ones, the black ones came out in June
1:06:38on schedule, and then Apple said something to the effect
1:06:41of we're having a little problem with the white production,
1:06:43we expect them in July, like one month late.
1:06:46And July came and went, and then Antennagate hit,
1:06:50and everybody remembered that.
1:06:51But the white iPhones didn't ship until May,
1:06:56the next year, April or May, like almost a full year.
1:06:59And I remember it vividly because my wife wanted
1:07:03to get the white one and she waited.
1:07:07And then by the time it got to April or May,
1:07:09she was like, well, I'm not stupid,
1:07:11I'm not gonna buy a new iPhone now,
1:07:12the new one's come out.
1:07:13Even though the 4S, that was when they first moved
1:07:16the schedule back from June to like September.
1:07:20So she ended up with her, I think she was using her 3GS
1:07:23or whatever for two years.
1:07:25But I would say this is a worse mistake because at least with the iPhone 4, if you wanted an iPhone 4 you could get it, you just didn't get it in the color you wanted.
1:07:35Whereas if you want AirPods, you can't get them.
1:07:40Yeah, this is, it seems bad to introduce something that is a fundamental part of a major change
1:07:49you're making and then not have the engineering and production in place to release it. Seems
1:07:54like a big F up. I was gonna say, I want to bump up one level, not to avoid the topic,
1:08:01but I mean, there's always this metaphor. Like, you know, Apple is Hillary Clinton,
1:08:06Samsung is Trump, right? You know, without even a political discussion, it's kind of
1:08:09And so, Apple removes headphones and you have think pieces and whatever.
1:08:13You posted something about this other day.
1:08:15Samsung says, "We're not going to have a headphone jack."
1:08:18I'm sorry, headphone jack, rather.
1:08:19Samsung says, "We're not going to have a headphone jack on our next flagship phone."
1:08:22Everyone's like, "Well, it's just Samsung, right?
1:08:24Of course."
1:08:25You're like, "But wait, but you're so angry!
1:08:27Why were you so angry?
1:08:28Like, it's a technology company.
1:08:29It's a decision.
1:08:30There's all these trade-offs.
1:08:31Why were you so, like, furious?
1:08:33Like, there was white-hot fury about it."
1:08:35And you could argue it's because there's more of an emotional connection with the iPhone
1:08:38with the iPhone and there are fewer models
1:08:41and there is not that emotional connection with Samsung,
1:08:44but it is sort of hilarious.
1:08:45But if you're gonna take the headphone jack out
1:08:47and you're gonna deal with the repercussion
1:08:49'cause you know people have been keyed up
1:08:51to be angry for weeks and months
1:08:52as the rumors are out there,
1:08:54there is something desperately wrong with that.
1:08:56Something very bad happened to reach this point.
1:08:58I mean, 'cause--
1:08:59- There's no doubt in my mind.
1:09:00I've talked to several people, you know,
1:09:04I can't say with 100% certainty,
1:09:05but I'm as certain as I could be
1:09:07that there was absolutely zero coincidence to the fact
1:09:11that the iPhone 7 is the first iPhone
1:09:14without the headphone jack
1:09:16and was introduced alongside AirPods and W1 chip.
1:09:21That was completely in coordination.
1:09:22AirPods-- - They wanted
1:09:23to ship simultaneously.
1:09:24- AirPods were in development for three years.
1:09:27Engineering and design started three years ago
1:09:31and it was a year ago when they felt like they were
1:09:34at the point where they can say,
1:09:35yes, these will be ready in September 2016.
1:09:39Therefore, we can go ahead with this design of the iPhone that
1:09:44doesn't have the headphone jack and this, that,
1:09:47and the other thing, or now we can make the camera bigger
1:09:50and move the battery down.
1:09:51And all the other side effects of being
1:09:54able to remove the headphone jack
1:09:57was completely in coordination.
1:09:59And yes, they did not.
1:10:00And they knew then--
1:10:01Apple knew.
1:10:02I didn't know.
1:10:03But Apple knew that they were relatively expensive
1:10:06and therefore were not going to be included in the box.
1:10:10So even though they're not in the box and cost $150,
1:10:18and therefore-- which is a lot to pay for headphones
1:10:22by most people's standards.
1:10:23And therefore, they knew it's not
1:10:25going to be like everybody with an iPhone 7
1:10:27is going to spend $150 for AirPods.
1:10:30it was absolutely in lockstep with each other,
1:10:34that they weren't going to ship a phone without a headphone
1:10:36jack without the new wireless AirPods,
1:10:40and they weren't going to ship the AirPods
1:10:42with a flagship phone that still has the headphone jack.
1:10:47And so I think if Apple knew--
1:10:49I really do think so.
1:10:53I think if they knew that they were
1:10:54going to be as late as they are, I
1:10:56don't think that they would have removed the headphone jack
1:10:58this year.
1:10:59Well, remember, if you look at the design of the phone, am I wrong? My recollection
1:11:03is after the teardowns came out that both phones have technically have room for a headphone
1:11:09jack, so they must have given themselves—and there's a space where it could have gone,
1:11:13so they must have given themselves wiggle room at some point.
1:11:16I thought there was room for it.
1:11:18No, well, I guess—
1:11:19There's a space where—well, maybe I'm wrong. I was wondering how much wiggle room
1:11:23they gave them, because they have to lock in the circuit board design and everything
1:11:26else, you know.
1:11:27in very far in advance. Like, whatever they're coming out with next year is already completely locked in.
1:11:32I feel terrible for whoever on the team, whichever people on the team at whichever levels from top to bottom,
1:11:39either made an error in judgment or just were ahead of—I mean, this is the thing. So, this will seem
1:11:47like a sidebar. I'll be brief with it. But, you know, I wrote a piece in March, I think, for Macworld about
1:11:52why you should probably not become a backer of Kickstarter and other
1:11:56crowdfunding projects
1:11:58involved mass manufacture items that aren't totally interchangeable and known
1:12:02like a book like everyone knows how to print a book
1:12:05public in a brick book printer could be late but they don't suddenly say we
1:12:08don't know how to put ink on pages we try to put the ink on the pages and the
1:12:12ink fell off and we have to work with you to develop a new way
1:12:16to put ink on paper because the one you propose doesn't work
1:12:19So, that typically doesn't happen.
1:12:21It happens constantly in the production of,
1:12:26especially electronics, but a lot of things where,
1:12:29if you follow the folks at Studio Neat,
1:12:30they have a great podcast that Mike Hurley is hosting,
1:12:33where the two guys, Dan Provost and,
1:12:35my black hair's name, and Tom Gerhart,
1:12:40the two of them, these wonderful guys.
1:12:42I've met them so many times,
1:12:43I'd be embarrassed to make them their names.
1:12:45Oh, geez.
1:12:46Well, they're lovely people, they do really good products,
1:12:48really interesting stuff they make, and they have a podcast about making their latest thing and
1:12:52talking about it, and it's really fascinating because you get the insight into people who do
1:12:56have a, you know, a moderate-sized company but not a very big one, and what the constraints are when
1:13:01you're doing all of these manufacturing things. So, I'm just sort of backing it out into the like,
1:13:08like, so I understand from talking to people at sort of Dan and Tom's level, and some folks in
1:13:13bigger corporations when they'll talk more frankly about like, just what happens when you get from
1:13:17there's a stage between, I think you've written about it too,
1:13:20there's been people that have written articles
1:13:22about this, of course, between like prototype
1:13:23and production, there's this thing where you deliver stuff,
1:13:26you work to get something that's closer and closer
1:13:27to what's actually going on in a production line,
1:13:29then there's a point in which you make units
1:13:31on the production line and they work,
1:13:33and then you go into this full scale thing
1:13:34in which there's QA and QC for,
1:13:37or QC for the products coming off the line, right?
1:13:39And it's horrible, and the fact that any consumer
1:13:43electronics company can produce things routinely
1:13:45on any schedule is always amazing.
1:13:47So Apple's track record is really good.
1:13:49So is Note 7 excluded, but sort of part of it.
1:13:53So is Samsung.
1:13:54So are a lot of other companies
1:13:56that just produce huge numbers of new models of things
1:13:59and they're super complicated.
1:14:00- Even with the Note 7, the problem wasn't with production.
1:14:04The problem was with the design.
1:14:05I mean, that's--
1:14:06- Right, they made a bad choice.
1:14:07- Right, I mean, I've read enough articles from people
1:14:10who've taken it apart. - No, you're totally right.
1:14:12- Everybody's in near unanimous agreement
1:14:15about what's wrong.
1:14:16put too big of a battery in too small of a space and therefore led to the positive and
1:14:21negative sides touching it under physical strain.
1:14:25And they, you know, the post-mortem's going to be they should have realized this in the
1:14:29prototyping stage well in advance of going to production and done something about it.
1:14:32But so when I—so, you know, you know all those things. There's this mystery, though.
1:14:36This is what I think Dan and Tom get at well in their podcasts, and you can read stories
1:14:39about this all over. Like, there's this incredible thing about—we know, and I think
1:14:43It's one thing that Johnny Ives does really well.
1:14:45It's something that I think Tim Cook, as coming from that deep knowledge of the supply chain,
1:14:50and you know, it kind of got him onto the CEO path, understanding how you bring different
1:14:55things together and what is feasible.
1:14:58Kazanami used to consult on this for high-tech companies, where he would look at what they
1:15:01had in the lab, he would look at what their customers actually wanted, and he would help
1:15:05them match those things together, what was feasible and what people wanted, to turn it
1:15:10into something that was manufacturable or producible.
1:15:12It is an incredible art because you're modeling machines in your head that make things on
1:15:20these massive scales.
1:15:21So, it's not surprising this happens from time to time, it's just Apple is so good at,
1:15:26in general, executing it that something went deeply wrong when they thought they could
1:15:30make some part of this and it would work 100% of the time, and they got to it and they're
1:15:34like, "This works 98% of the time."
1:15:35I mean, it could be as, it's probably as little as that, too, based on what the reports were.
1:15:39Yeah, secondhand talking to a friend who has a friend who works on the AirPods team, it is,
1:15:45these things are a bitch to manufacture. And they knew it was going to be, but there's something,
1:15:50you know, some part of, "Hey, we've got a, you know, I'm holding a pair right here in my hands,
1:15:58and I'm not trying to brag, you know, but it's very surprising to me that I, here we are on
1:16:04December 9th, and I've got AirPods and nobody else does."
1:16:07It's that late in the process that—
1:16:09that a problem occurred.
1:16:10- You know, I've got right here in my hands proof
1:16:13that there's somewhere there, there was, you know,
1:16:16by September there was a factory in China
1:16:19that was pushing out very good high quality AirPods.
1:16:24And somehow though, being able to spool that up
1:16:29to punch out the millions of them
1:16:32that they need to punch out, they've run into something.
1:16:35Now again, I've heard that,
1:16:38and this is from a different source, but I've heard that it's possible that by the time you
1:16:42even listen to this, they might be out if you're listening like next week. But I wouldn't be
1:16:46surprised if, you know, they get pushed out to January. Something has gone terribly wrong.
1:16:53Pete: My suspicion, based on the fact that they're able to ship units to you and other reviewers
1:16:57that, from generally reported, you know, I think Matthew Panzareno wrote about this and I think,
1:17:02I think you, I forget what your experience has been. They're reliable in your experience, right?
1:17:06They work pretty much the way you do.
1:17:07if this, they don't work perfectly. Uh, they glitch occasionally, but,
1:17:12but if, if,
1:17:14if this is as good as the AirPods 1.0 are going to get, if it's, if,
1:17:19if the exact experience that I've had and continue to have with these is exactly
1:17:23what everybody would experience, I would still recommend it wholeheartedly.
1:17:27And I, I would describe these AirPods as is occasional problems included as my
1:17:32favorite new Apple product.
1:17:37I love them.
1:17:38And my suspicion is this is a QC or quality control problem that they turned on the volume,
1:17:43they got production units out, they had some yield issues, but they said we can fix the
1:17:47yields and production.
1:17:50They pulled out the best of them, sent them through viewers, and then they started turning
1:17:53the dial up, and when they turned the dial up, the yield was so poor on which I don't
1:17:58know what their number is.
1:17:59Yeah, I think it's like that.
1:18:00That's what I think it is.
1:18:01Yeah, because they're that far along.
1:18:02If they're making something they can send to you that is not a one-off item, it is something
1:18:05came out of production line, it has to be, it's not a software issue, or yours would
1:18:09be failing all the time too, and so would all the other reviewers.
1:18:11Every once in a while, the problems I've seen, and they're very similar to what Matthew's
1:18:15seen, every once in a while, but it's actually, I use them all the time. They're the only
1:18:20headphones I've used since September, period. Every once in a while, the audio, it just
1:18:29gets a little stuttery. It's like there's some kind of Bluetooth, you know, somehow
1:18:34the wireless signal gets jacked and you know usually you can just take them out put them
1:18:39back in and you know wait a little bit and it fixes itself. Every once in a while one
1:18:47of them drops out and I've got both in but it somehow mistakenly puts itself into oh
1:18:54you just want to use one mode because you can do that you can just put one in and it'll
1:18:58just play through the month even though I have both in like the audio will stop playing
1:19:02to the right one for a little, and then the way to fix it,
1:19:05or at least I've fixed it, is take them both out,
1:19:07put them in the little Tic Tac case, and start over.
1:19:10But it's only happened to me like twice, period.
1:19:14And I think that's it.
1:19:17I mean, that's pretty much the only problems
1:19:19I've had with it.
1:19:20Every once in a while, you know,
1:19:21oh, and the other problem is every once in a while,
1:19:23switching from one device to another,
1:19:26it doesn't go seamlessly.
1:19:28It's not as magic as it should be.
1:19:31That, I think, though, is more of an iOS problem
1:19:34than a problem with the AirPods, I think.
1:19:36I suspect that software, and I've seen that less,
1:19:39so I wouldn't even be surprised
1:19:41if that's actually been fixed in one of the recent,
1:19:44I'm actually running the betas on all my devices.
1:19:49Like, my phone is still running
1:19:51whatever the current developer beta of iOS is.
1:19:53- Oh, yeah, yeah.
1:19:54- So I wouldn't even be surprised.
1:19:55- The 10.2.2, I think, just came out.
1:19:56- I haven't seen that in a few weeks,
1:19:59Although I pretty much just use them with my iPhone too.
1:20:02- This makes me think, you know,
1:20:02actually as I think about it,
1:20:03I realize because they can push so much
1:20:05to software and firmware,
1:20:06my suspicion is even further
1:20:09that it's not a quality control issue.
1:20:10I just realized it's the next level thing,
1:20:12which is they got a bunch of units off,
1:20:14they went through quality control
1:20:15and went through automated testing,
1:20:17they started to pull samples to test,
1:20:19and they found with samples
1:20:21that the defect rate wasn't being determined
1:20:24through automatic testing.
1:20:25And then they started to test more
1:20:26they realized that the defect rate was, whatever the defect was, was wider and more complicated,
1:20:32and that whatever QC process they're using would not be adequate.
1:20:36Because otherwise, excuse me, if they could make some that are good and some that aren't,
1:20:42they would have perhaps made a bunch and shipped out a quantity and said, "Look, we're
1:20:45getting an early amount out.
1:20:46We have manufacturing problems.
1:20:48We're going to catch up.
1:20:49We want to get the people who committed to this earliest.
1:20:51We're going to send the first 100,000 out," right?
1:20:53Because even if they lost 100,000, 100,000 units were bad and 100,000 were good, they
1:20:58might do it because they do like to delight their customers.
1:21:02That's one thing they do.
1:21:03So my thinking is they couldn't even get a yield or reliability high enough that made
1:21:08them confident they could ship out any numbers in quantity until this.
1:21:12And they also tend to know when they're going to catch up.
1:21:21So for example, with Apple Watch,
1:21:23Apple Watch, the original one,
1:21:26launched and couldn't meet demand.
1:21:30Not even close.
1:21:31But their estimates were, if anything,
1:21:35under-promising and over-delivering.
1:21:37So like if you ordered an Apple Watch
1:21:41right when they first started taking orders
1:21:43and your preferred model said six to eight weeks,
1:21:47you probably got it in like five weeks.
1:21:51It seemed, you know, and there were people--
1:21:53- Oh yeah, and the other thing where they pushed
1:21:54the unpopular model that developers could get the blue,
1:21:57whatever the parameters were, which was nice.
1:21:59It was like we have some that aren't committed,
1:22:01so we're gonna make them available to, you know,
1:22:03and that's how a lot of developers made a lot of friends
1:22:06buying those and selling them off.
1:22:07- And it's also been true, for example,
1:22:08with the iPhone 7, you know, where there were
1:22:10certain models, you know, the Jet Black
1:22:14and the plus size ones that, you know,
1:22:17If you didn't get your order in right at midnight Pacific,
1:22:21you were given a, you weren't gonna get it on day one,
1:22:24but whenever they were promising, that's when you got it.
1:22:28You did get it before, and I ordered a couple of them,
1:22:32and one of them, I don't know,
1:22:33six to eight weeks or something like that,
1:22:34and I got it in four weeks.
1:22:36- Oh, wow, great.
1:22:38- So whatever's going on with the AirPods isn't like that.
1:22:41It seems to me like they aren't willing to commit.
1:22:44Obviously, if they could, if they felt like,
1:22:46well, we can't meet demand right now,
1:22:48but within two months we will.
1:22:50They'd start taking orders
1:22:52and say six to eight weeks delivery.
1:22:54- Exactly.
1:22:55- And the other thing too is that whatever it is,
1:22:57it was obviously a surprise
1:22:59and it's sort of like an unknown known.
1:23:02You know what I mean?
1:23:03Like they don't quite have a handle on the problem
1:23:05because I expected, it seemed like Apple expected,
1:23:10when the invitations went out
1:23:11for the MacBook Pro event in October,
1:23:15it seemed as though they were expecting to launch
1:23:17the AirPods at that event and say they're now available.
1:23:21And I think those invitations, as per Apple's usual want,
1:23:25only went out like a week before the event.
1:23:28So up to like a week before that event,
1:23:30they still thought that they were gonna launch
1:23:32in late October.
1:23:33- I also think, so the narrative about Apple always gets
1:23:37spun, they're doomed because of X, and we don't do that here
1:23:40because we know they've got $200 billion in the bank,
1:23:43I've said, I think under a Trump administration, Apple could do very well because they will
1:23:48have a deal to repatriate their money and they'll pay some different tax rate and that's
1:23:53probably going to get solved, right?
1:23:54So Apple will have even more money to spend in the U.S. that's repatriated.
1:23:58Like, you know, they're not going anywhere.
1:24:00But I actually think this is a story that one could argue is the difference between
1:24:04them and Samsung, perhaps, or a sign that Apple is still on the right track even if
1:24:08maybe they have too much on their plate that's not executing all in concert, you know, or
1:24:13not anticipating the USB-C adapter negative response, then they lowered prices.
1:24:18So Apple didn't ship the AirPods and then say, "Oops, some of them are bad, and take
1:24:23them into a store and we'll send you a box to return it."
1:24:26They said, "We can't ship these in good conscience because whatever reason."
1:24:31Maybe they couldn't even get them off the assembly line, which seems unlikely since
1:24:34they had review units.
1:24:35I'm sure they are ramped up to a point to be able to produce them in the quantities
1:24:38that they needed to ramp up towards.
1:24:40But this tells me they're more willing to take the hit of customers who are unhappy
1:24:44to get a thing that they want to delight them by just delaying indefinitely until they know
1:24:49they can deliver something that's functional.
1:24:51That is a good sign to me, even because you can't always hit on all cylinders on manufacturing.
1:24:56And you know, they're losing sales, but are there things that are direct competitors that
1:25:01someone is saying, "I'm canceling my AirPod order to buy this other thing"?
1:25:05I think you just have a delay for most people who are going to be a buyer of it.
1:25:09Right, right. Apple is really screwed because some people who really want wireless headphones
1:25:13are buying Beats.
1:25:15Or they're waiting, Apple is sitting on waiting for a few million dollars relative to their
1:25:22multi-billion dollar earnings.
1:25:24So I can see the possibilities would be... The best case scenario is that sometime in
1:25:31the next week, Apple starts shipping them in significant quantity. And I feel like if
1:25:38If that happens, it'll mostly be all's forgiven.
1:25:42Although I seriously think that they've shut,
1:25:45one way they shut themself in the foot
1:25:46is that the most likely time for someone to buy one
1:25:48is while they're buying their iPhone 7.
1:25:50And so there's an awful lot of people who would have said,
1:25:52well, what the hell, I'll tack on $150,
1:25:55who now that their iPhone 7 doesn't even feel that new,
1:25:58it's like, well, that's just my iPhone,
1:26:00they're not gonna spend $150 on it.
1:26:02But if they can do it in the next week
1:26:04in sufficient quantity, it's also very clearly,
1:26:07a stocking stuffer, right? I mean, like, quite—
1:26:10Pete: Yeah, yeah.
1:26:11Pete: In every aspect of the word, you know, it's something—
1:26:13Pete; It's an expensive gift you get for, I mean, this is, you know, 100 and, what is it,
1:26:16200 bucks? I forgot.
1:26:17Pete; 149. Or 159.
1:26:19Pete; So, it's, you know, it's out of the scale of a lot. It's, you know,
1:26:22I don't know what families have different limits and whatever, but it's like, you know, we got one
1:26:25of my kids, one of my, it's a secret, my son doesn't listen, neither of my kids listen to this
1:26:29podcast. But my older son has a—
1:26:33Pete; You better hope so!
1:26:34Pete; I hope so. They, I don't think they listen to, well, they get older, they will. They listen
1:26:37to the game show episodes of The Incomparable where some of the hosts will say, "Oh no, Glenn's
1:26:41kids are listening, you know, clean it up." But, so, my older son has a great proclivity towards
1:26:47music. He is, thank God, not a prodigy because we know happy lives and prodigies do not go together.
1:26:53But he has a gift. He's a musical talent. It's really neat and he's been learning a bunch of
1:26:57instruments and his flute is his primary one, but he suddenly got interested in the trombone.
1:27:01And I'm like, "Okay, I guess we have a small house, but you know, I love hearing him play."
1:27:06okay, you know, we got a mute for it. So, his mother-in-law, or my mother-in-law,
1:27:09father-in-law got that as a gift, which is, you know, got a modest model on sale and whatever,
1:27:14but it's a pricey gift and he'll appreciate it. So, that's kind of, you know, that's out of our
1:27:18usual scale, but the grandparents are allowed to do that and they asked.
1:27:21Well, if you look at—
1:27:23But like, you know, AirPods, we didn't get them AirPods, let me just tell you that.
1:27:26Right. If you look—oh no, nobody's getting AirPods for good, at least not yet.
1:27:31I'm getting earplugs, though, that's gonna be my gift.
1:27:34- If you look at the iPod's sales history,
1:27:37I mean there's a lot of reasons for the reasons
1:27:39it ramped up, that the first few years
1:27:41it was a Mac only product and et cetera.
1:27:44But it's when they found good models
1:27:47that could hit that 199 price point
1:27:49is really when it exploded.
1:27:51There's something magical about sub $200
1:27:54in terms of, okay, this isn't something we'll,
1:27:57it's not a lark, but it's a gift.
1:28:02So 159 would be great.
1:28:03If they can do it this week, in quantity,
1:28:07that would be great.
1:28:07That's the best case scenario,
1:28:08and I think it's mostly all's forgiven.
1:28:10If they ship in the next week or so,
1:28:14but it's not in sufficient quantity,
1:28:16and it's six to eight weeks back ordered past the holidays
1:28:20for just about it for all practical effects, that sucks.
1:28:23And that's obviously a huge miss for them.
1:28:26Because it was, you know, the holiday,
1:28:30getting these things out in time
1:28:31the ship for the holiday is huge.
1:28:33There's just no doubt about it.
1:28:35It's one of those items that's gonna sell
1:28:38in that spiky, whoa, look at the fourth quarter
1:28:42sells double what it does in the other three quarters
1:28:44of the year type product.
1:28:46And then the third--
1:28:48- I think it was a poll though,
1:28:50oh, it was a poll though too,
1:28:51when people bought AirPods,
1:28:52they thought AirPod plus the new phones,
1:28:54so some people delayed getting a new phone
1:28:56until they could get AirPods.
1:28:57- Third case scenario would be it doesn't even ship
1:29:00for in low quantity this month.
1:29:02- Oh my God, yeah.
1:29:03- And there was, MacRumors had a story,
1:29:06you know, somehow sourced to the supply chain
1:29:08that it's been pushed back to January.
1:29:10And then the next day they had a counter story
1:29:12that said, no, no, it's shipping soon.
1:29:14That's really embarrassing.
1:29:17And then I guess as terms of what's actually possible,
1:29:21you can't say it's impossible
1:29:23that they never even ship them.
1:29:24- Oh man, that would be very bad for confidence.
1:29:29- Not on the financial side, a bit, very small,
1:29:32but the confidence of it would be--
1:29:35- I guess never seems impos--
1:29:36But what if it doesn't ship until like July?
1:29:39Like the white iPhone, right?
1:29:41- It would just become a, you know,
1:29:42becomes an albatross, right?
1:29:44It's like, it's a very beautiful bird when it's flying,
1:29:46not so much when it's hanging around your neck.
1:29:48- Again, does not doom the company, but this is--
1:29:51- No, just--
1:29:52- At this point, I feel like, you know,
1:29:54December 9th, I mean, it's probably too close.
1:29:58I mean, it's, you know, we're talking 15, 16 days till Christmas.
1:30:02There could be a bunch of people in a factory in China very, you know,
1:30:05delicately opening up things and fixing a tiny thing or testing them one at a
1:30:09time.
1:30:10I don't know this, but I certainly would,
1:30:12I would bet heavily that there are some normally Cupertino
1:30:17residents who are spending on all, you know.
1:30:20Do you remember that story about Tim Cook? It was a great story.
1:30:24I think it was the thing. Yeah, it's the, um, they're having that meeting.
1:30:27I can't remember the specific problem. Something was going on in China that was problematic.
1:30:31He's sitting there as CEO. The person at the table explains it, and they go in the meeting,
1:30:36and at some point Tim looks at him and says, "Why are you still here?" And the guy walked out and
1:30:41literally got on a plane to China to take care of the problem. I'm telling you, right? It's close to
1:30:45that.
1:30:45Pete: Yeah, it's somebody, you know, Tim said, "Okay, well, you're responsible for fixing it.
1:30:48You'll have to go there to fix it." And then the meeting keeps going and the guy didn't get up,
1:30:54up, and Tim Cook says, "Why are you still here?" And so the guy realized that that's
1:30:59how quickly he wanted him to go, and he drove—he didn't go home and pack, he just drove to
1:31:04the airport and figured he'd get clothes once he gets to Beijing.
1:31:07Pete: You can buy clothes in China, I've heard, very easily.
1:31:10So, I like that it also wasn't that Tim was screaming and red-faced at him, he's
1:31:16just like, "Why are you still here?" I thought that, to me, set a tone for the Tim
1:31:21Cook administration, and I think it's followed through pretty well that we expect that he
1:31:27holds people responsible without it, you know, for the right reason. When things aren't
1:31:32working, it's going to get fixed, and that's what this feels like from the outside. There's
1:31:35a bunch of people who are, you know, like, "We've got to get this fixed so I can
1:31:39be with my family at the holidays at the end of the year."
1:31:42Pete: Yeah. All right, let me take a break here and thank our third and final sponsor.
1:31:45longtime sponsor of the show with a just a fantastic service mail route you know
1:31:51who should handle your email security and delivery people who only do that
1:31:55that's mail route this is what mail route does all they do is they don't
1:31:59host email they don't host your email all they do is filter it for you take
1:32:05all the junk out so what the way it works is pretty simple if you control a
1:32:08domain where you get email whether you're a big company okay they do stuff
1:32:13for huge companies or whether you're like me and I've got like the only person who has
1:32:19at daring fireball.net email. It doesn't matter big or small, you just point your MX records for
1:32:27the domain to go to mail route first. Your mail goes to them first, they filter out all the junk
1:32:33and then they immediately, you know, we're talking like a hundredth of a second later,
1:32:36it forwards on to your actual mail server. So from the outside, the MX records point to mail route,
1:32:43then it goes to mail route and it's just a filter, literally, it's just the filter.
1:32:46And then the actual good email just goes right to your server. So it doesn't even take any longer
1:32:52that, you know, other than like fraction of a second. But all of a sudden, your email has no
1:32:58junk, no garbage, it just works. And that's all they do. This is all they do. It's a fantastic
1:33:04service. And it really works great. And all sorts of other companies are getting out of the email
1:33:10protection business because it's such hard work. Postini went away, McAfee's thing went away,
1:33:15MX Logic went away. This is a tremendous service. There's no hardware or software to install. It's
1:33:21not like you install new software. You just point your domain at them. So it doesn't matter what
1:33:28you're using for your email. It doesn't matter if you're using Microsoft stuff in a corporate
1:33:33environment or even if you're hosting on Google Apps or something like that. So whether you're
1:33:40a small home business or a huge ISP, MailRoute handles customers of all sizes and provides the
1:33:46same level of outstanding tech support to everyone. They send you anything you'd think you'd want with
1:33:52a service like this. Like, do you want to get a report every day with the mail that got filtered
1:33:58so you can eyeball it and make sure that good stuff isn't getting caught? You can do that.
1:34:02it's so great and it's just completely focused on this one thing which is
1:34:06filtering the junk out of your email. I don't know what else to say about them.
1:34:14If you control the email for one or more domains, I really really recommend that
1:34:19you look at it. They even give you a 30-day free trial so you can go there and
1:34:27and just in the time it takes to change the MX records for your domain, there you
1:34:31go, you're set up and you can go and try it out and see that it actually works before
1:34:36you even give them a nickel. And then once you do start paying, go to mailroute.net/tts,
1:34:42the initials for the talk show, mailroute.net/tts. And if you've used that URL to get started,
1:34:49you get 10% off for the lifetime of your account. So like, if you're using for like the next
1:34:5615 years, every single month when you pay them, you save 10% because you started by
1:35:01go into mailroute.net/tts.
1:35:03So my thanks to them.
1:35:04Go check them out.
1:35:06Highly, highly, highly recommend them.
1:35:07What else is going on?
1:35:12You see this thing where Apple launched
1:35:15their TV single sign-on?
1:35:17- Yes, yeah, they sorta, they launched,
1:35:21yeah, they launched it.
1:35:22All right, I'll give them that.
1:35:22They did launch it.
1:35:23- So John Pachkowski put it in a tweet.
1:35:25So just the other day, Apple launched the single,
1:35:27this is the thing where you can use
1:35:29your cable service username and password to sign in.
1:35:34And then all of the apps on your Apple TV
1:35:40that require a cable service thing to get,
1:35:45you don't have to log into each one of them individually
1:35:48and type the four digits from your phone
1:35:50and blah, blah, blah for each app over and over again.
1:35:53You sign in once at a system level
1:35:56and then the apps just pick it up and then they just work.
1:35:59The problem is that they launched it and they don't have Comcast, they don't have Time Warner Cable,
1:36:05they don't have Fios, they don't have on the content side, they don't have ABC, CBS or ESPN,
1:36:11they don't have HBO Go. So it's launched, but and I guess, you know, there's the big ones that I can
1:36:19see in the list. And maybe I'm underestimating some of the ones, you know, like I've never heard
1:36:24of some of these like Hawaiian telecom. Well, I guess it's probably local to Hawaii. The ones I've
1:36:31heard of are DirecTV and Dish. So if you have satellite TV through DirecTV or Dish, you're in.
1:36:37But without Comcast and Time Warner and Fios, boy, that's, it's, I mean, and hopefully this is
1:36:45one of those things that it just takes time to get these people on board. And maybe it's not even
1:36:52so much that they're reluctant to sign up but that they just need time to get it integrated
1:36:57on their back ends. But this doesn't look good either because this was announced at WWDC
1:37:03I think, right? And it was emphasized and reiterated in the iPhone event in September
1:37:10that later this year we're going to roll this out. This is when they announced that the
1:37:15video app is renamed to TV on iOS. It was announced and I don't, you know, if this is
1:37:24all they're going to have by the end of the year, boy, that's, it's nowhere near what they were
1:37:28promising in September. So this is another one where I feel like Apple is really falling short.
1:37:32I wouldn't have thought they would have announced it when they did unless they had
1:37:37the biggest services signed on, especially HBO. They have a partnership with, although,
1:37:42I mean, I guess it's HBO via these providers.
1:37:45So the provider is still the issue.
1:37:47But HBO's app is not listed.
1:37:50So conceivably, even if HBO and the providers couldn't get a deal, then, you know, maybe
1:37:55HBO has contracts that prohibit them unless providers agree.
1:37:58Some of the apps are iOS only and some are TVS only.
1:38:03Most of those are, that are one platform only, TVOS as well.
1:38:09It is weird because it seemed, I mean, if you didn't have Comcast and Time Warner,
1:38:15why wouldn't you have, why would you have launched, why would you have announced this
1:38:18like for pressure?
1:38:19Like, well, we'll get some of the big ones, you know, they have some of them.
1:38:24I mean, DirecTV makes sense because the AT&T connection and all that, but it just, it's
1:38:28uh...
1:38:29It seems to me to go hand in hand with the AirPods in terms of that it seems like they
1:38:35were taken by surprise.
1:38:36Like, they thought that they had this, and it ends up they don't.
1:38:41Whether it's a negotiation thing that wasn't finalized, or if it's a technical thing,
1:38:45or a little bit of column A and a little bit of column B, it seems to me that in September
1:38:48they thought they were going to have this by, you know, around now, end of November,
1:38:54very early December, and they don't.
1:38:56Well, we've heard, you know, about AnyQ showing up with an untucked shirt and pissing
1:39:00off famous detail, and pissing off TV or, you know, executives, whatever.
1:39:04Right.
1:39:05I think it was Time Warner, right.
1:39:06was a time where, yeah, yeah, and it's like, I mean, there is a little, I'm not going to
1:39:10credit that with being, how real a thing that was, because that came from the cable side,
1:39:15not from the Apple side or whatever. But it may be that they were just, you know, they've,
1:39:20Apple has been able to bowl through a lot of deals on the advantage of bringing a ton
1:39:25of users along and it being a net benefit for subscriptions. There's this related discussion
1:39:30that on, was it just on tvOS that Apple may drop the fee for subscriptions from 30 percent
1:39:36to 15 percent. So which would be, it's a nice big carrot to give to any of the cable networks.
1:39:45And I'm always confused about exactly, I don't follow this closely enough, which premium
1:39:50channels are owned by which cable or media company. And because the cable companies now
1:39:55own sort of chains of media companies, it's all slightly interrelated there too. So in
1:40:01In some cases you're like, all right, well, Comcast is, all the different providers are
1:40:09going to move.
1:40:10I mean, everyone knows that eventually it's going to be unbundled, right?
1:40:13Everything's going to be unbundled.
1:40:15They're all fighting against it as hard as they can, but we've seen all the cracks.
1:40:18And AT&T's new DirecTV Now deal is a part of it.
1:40:22It's not necessarily even financially fantastic unless you do the early signup deal, the $35
1:40:29hundred channels, like, you know, lock-in, like that's a good deal, I think, but we're
1:40:34going to come to a world in which bandwidth is one thing.
1:40:36I've got my gigabit internet as long as it lasts from CenturyLink, which is a, you know,
1:40:41bottom tier telco that has a lot of copper installed, so they're trying to switch to
1:40:48fiber, but I have to hope they actually survive and this is viable.
1:40:51But you know, even Comcast is delivering higher speeds, they're delivering higher caps, there's
1:40:56these zero rating issues that are coming up with AT&T in terms of how they'll count direct
1:41:01TV streaming over wireless. Like, there's a whole swirling miasma of things. And I would
1:41:05have thought in the middle of this that Apple would have been a great tool for the cable
1:41:08operators to extend value and for the cable channels they own, which are many of them,
1:41:15to have more people signed up in various ways. So it's baffling to me as a result.
1:41:20- The single sign-on thing seems to me like, why not?
1:41:24Like if you were at Comcast, like if you've,
1:41:26all of a sudden you're an executive at Comcast.
1:41:28I can see where they're wary of things
1:41:31that enable cord cutting, right?
1:41:34'Cause they don't, they, you know,
1:41:35they wanna fight that and they wanna milk the,
1:41:38we have these customers paying us
1:41:41a hundred and some dollars a month every month
1:41:43for cable TV and that's a really nice deal
1:41:46and we wanna keep that going as long as we can.
1:41:49the single sign-on is based on that, right? It's based on the idea that you're still paying
1:41:53for a monthly thing, right? It's not a cord-cutting thing, so why not get on board with it? I don't
1:42:00quite get it. Unless it's just technical problems. Unless it's like—
1:42:04Pete: Because I can do it now, right? Comcast, I can use a Comcast sign-in for
1:42:07all sorts of things already. They're not preventing me from doing it. This just makes it harder,
1:42:12right? It's not a—
1:42:12- Right, it's exactly it.
1:42:14It's just making something easier for the person,
1:42:18for the user, that you can already do.
1:42:21I already have on my, I have Comcast service,
1:42:23and I have an Apple TV, and I have at least a handful
1:42:26of apps from cable channels like HBO, the main one,
1:42:31where I have to sign in with my Comcast credentials
1:42:34to prove that I have cable.
1:42:36This would just make it easier.
1:42:37And so it's a little frustrating to me.
1:42:40- I have to believe that Comcast
1:42:42the other big ones think they're going to lose some kind of audience presence to Apple by allowing
1:42:47Apple to overbrand it. There's also the melding of it, right? The TV app is going to –
1:42:52Pete: Well, that's different though. Again, I can see why they're not participating.
1:42:56Pete: Right. Oh, you're right. Yeah, okay.
1:42:57Pete; Netflix in particular is a holdout on that. And speaking of Netflix…
1:43:01Pete; But you're right, these other things will though, right? I mean, the TV app will include
1:43:04a lot of stuff drawn from all these other apps, so it's not necessarily a perfect overlap that
1:43:09they're not allowing this. It just seems inconvenient instead of a strategy. So,
1:43:14I have to believe there's something we don't understand. Let's not just peak,
1:43:17or there's some money that should be changing hands that Apple doesn't want to pay, or
1:43:21Comcast, et cetera, thinks they're losing out somehow.
1:43:24Pete: I saw the other day that Netflix became the top-grossing iOS app, and now I just looked as
1:43:29we were talking and it slipped to number two behind Clash Royale.
1:43:34Pete; Interesting.
1:43:35- But it's, you know, now that they,
1:43:38'cause it used to be that they didn't take signups,
1:43:40'cause I guess they didn't want to split the money
1:43:42with Apple, you had to sign up for Netflix
1:43:44outside of iOS in a web browser,
1:43:47and then you could sign in with your credentials.
1:43:49But now that they're taking the in-app purchases,
1:43:53they're the number two grossing app,
1:43:55and that's only counting the people
1:43:57who are paying through iOS, not all of us
1:44:00who've been signed up for Netflix for years
1:44:03aren't even in there.
1:44:03So in terms of like, hey, is Netflix doing well?
1:44:06That looks like they are.
1:44:08But I'm curious, this is one of those things
1:44:10that I've sort of lost track of,
1:44:12is that whole, okay, we're gonna give some of you guys,
1:44:15your big name TV channels an 85/15 split instead of 70/30.
1:44:19Like, did Netflix get in on that, or were they too soon?
1:44:22Like, is this based on an 85/15 split or 70/30?
1:44:26I don't know if anybody knows that
1:44:28other than Apple and Netflix.
1:44:30- I don't think I've seen anything that's even hinted
1:44:33that someone knew which ones were involved.
1:44:35And I have to believe, see,
1:44:36for Netflix has an interesting situation.
1:44:38Like Apple doing that second year subscription price,
1:44:41you know, they're only paying a 15% commission now.
1:44:44Like that's part of, that's a change
1:44:46that I think a lot of people found significant
1:44:47and worthwhile, especially in the,
1:44:49for smaller companies or some of the bigger ones
1:44:51that sell subscription stuff
1:44:52and really rely on the, on in-app purchases
1:44:55or in-app based purchase system.
1:44:57But the Netflix may have reached a point
1:45:01saturated its ability to acquire a market from,
1:45:05or to acquire customers in a way that they know
1:45:10the cost is going to be lower than 30%.
1:45:12So, if they're not getting 15%, they may have said,
1:45:14"All right, we now need to sweep in people
1:45:16that we're not getting. Our numbers, our spreadsheet
1:45:18shows that giving up an extra 15% here is worthwhile
1:45:21for the first year because pencils out good for us
1:45:24and we get the money in the second year."
1:45:25And some of these people may unsubscribe
1:45:27and resubscribe through the website because
1:45:29where they're now our customers and, you know, all works.
1:45:32It's all good now because we're in the last
1:45:33X percentage people we can reach.
1:45:35- Yeah, and they seem to have done pretty well
1:45:38with a fairly liberal policy of shared accounts.
1:45:43You know, that they're not real,
1:45:44doesn't seem like they're big on trying to lock down,
1:45:48like, you know, three or four people sharing an account.
1:45:51- Right.
1:45:52- Across a bunch of, 'cause it seems like they're,
1:45:54you know, they have the right idea, which is, look,
1:45:56somebody's paying us 10 bucks a month or whatever it is,
1:45:59and multiply it by the number of X millions
1:46:03of other people who are paying us 10 bucks a month,
1:46:05if there's some leakage here of shared accounts, who cares?
1:46:10The money coming in is great and growing,
1:46:13and the content, what we're paying for the content
1:46:15is here, so we're, you know.
1:46:17It seems like they've always had a good balance
1:46:22on that front.
1:46:24- Yeah, I agree, I agree.
1:46:25last topic I can think of is you want to talk about Farhad Manchu's column this week in the
1:46:30New York Times, which was The Death of Gadgets.
1:46:33Pete: Yeah, I kind of like this piece because I realized, it seemed like, I'm trying to think
1:46:38how many years ago, it's encouraging me. I think when Gizmodo said that they were going to sort of
1:46:43change how they approached what they were doing with reporting and structure, was that like three
1:46:47years ago now? I'm thinking. There was a point at which it seemed like Gadgets started to go away.
1:46:53Like the obsessive focus on gadgets, there was something Gizmodo was the first and then there was Engadget, then there was Gadgets,
1:46:59and then there were, you know, a thousand thousand blogs that were devoted to obsessive coverage with as much leaked information and
1:47:06unboxing and everything as possible of every little doodad that came out. And I'll tell you like even on my now dead,
1:47:11I mean still archive, Wi-Fi networking news site, one of the most popular things I ever posted there
1:47:16was a tiny, it was a post, a tiny video about this thing called Canary
1:47:21something, and it was like a tiny standalone device that would show you what Wi-Fi networks
1:47:25were around you. It was like a handheld Wi-Fi detector, and it would list off the networks
1:47:29on an LED display, or an LCD display. And people, I mean, that still gets traffic, which
1:47:34is weird to me now, but people were obsessed with gadgets for the longest time, and it
1:47:41really did, you know, it was a proven way to get traffic, and it was a proven way to
1:47:46proven way to get advertising, the whole ecosystem worked, and some of these sites became super
1:47:51highly trafficked. And then I felt like it shifted, I felt like people were less obsessed
1:47:56with it. And I was like, well, what really happened? Do people have enough gadgets? Like,
1:48:00as that run out, are we replacing single-purpose things with multi-purpose things? And it slowly
1:48:06kind of ebbed away. And I think, I feel like Farhad put a really good cap on it. The gadget
1:48:10apocalypse is upon us, is his head, right? And it starts out, "Remember gadgets." And
1:48:15I thought, you know, this is a good concept.
1:48:17He's like, we had decades in which,
1:48:19like, there were transistor radios.
1:48:21Oh, do you remember, the big thing to me was,
1:48:23do you remember the flip, how quickly the flip died?
1:48:26It was this giant thing, right?
1:48:27And then everyone, I'd never heard of it.
1:48:29Suddenly everyone has one.
1:48:31Suddenly they flame out.
1:48:32It was incredible.
1:48:33- Well, here's what I don't,
1:48:35I think that part of this is that the smartphone
1:48:39is the Uber gadget, right?
1:48:43And, you know, for example,
1:48:44That's exactly what happened to flip is it got killed by,
1:48:47it got killed by the phone.
1:48:50And I think a lot of other things have too.
1:48:52Transistor radio, I mean, it's everything, right?
1:48:54It's our camera, it's our Walkman, it's our iPod,
1:48:56it's our newspaper, it's, you know.
1:49:00- HD radio, satellite radio.
1:49:02I mean, satellite radio I think is doing okay.
1:49:03I mean, it's not small, but it's not as,
1:49:05I think it had a bigger arc.
1:49:06- Yeah, but you can get,
1:49:07my wife listens to XM on her iPhone.
1:49:09- Right, it was just smart for, you know, smart for them.
1:49:11You know how much the satellites cost to launch,
1:49:13made a failure with some of their satellites
1:49:14with a Boeing issue.
1:49:15I mean, satellites are not a great way to run a business.
1:49:19But like Pebble, this was precipitated by Pebble
1:49:21getting bought by Fitbit and then saying,
1:49:24well, we don't know how long,
1:49:26we're not gonna make or ship any more watches.
1:49:28- Yeah, they didn't really,
1:49:29it's not like they sold it as a platform.
1:49:31It's more or less an aqua hire
1:49:33where Fitbit bought their engineering and whatever.
1:49:38- It had no future between smart watches
1:49:42major vendors like Apple and iPhones and smartphones that have more capabilities,
1:49:48like what's going to happen with Fitbit, what's going to happen with, you know,
1:49:52then Nest. There's a lot of discussion about what happens to Nest. Does it have a future exactly?
1:49:59You see, there's a story, I had missed this and I felt sort of terrible. 3D Robotics was founded
1:50:06by a drone company, personal drone company founded by Chris Anderson and a partner. And Chris used
1:50:11to be the editor-in-chief of Wire. And a few years ago he left Wire to take over full-time.
1:50:15They raised $100 million in venture. They tried to produce a super premium drone that
1:50:22would be like a—they kind of moved from kits and other stuff to a super premium drone.
1:50:26They had a lot of problems in production. By the time they got to kind of a point where
1:50:29things were okay, China had basically caught up. Like, cheap production in China had overtaken
1:50:36their ability to make something that was competitively priced. And that's part of the story.
1:50:41So, that is part of the issue is anything you can make, like, you look at Nest, you're like,
1:50:45"Well, I could pay $200," I think it's still for the first unit. You can get IP cameras that don't
1:50:50have the same cloud functionality or different and have horrible security problems, but they cost
1:50:54like 30 bucks, you know, and they're slightly worse. It's the not quite good enough but not so
1:51:00horrible that people just completely abandon it kind of thing. And that's, you know, we've got,
1:51:06got the far-hard list off a bunch of stuff, but it's a good tie together, like MakerBot,
1:51:11not really getting to the level that, and it's sort of sad because gadgets kind of drove
1:51:17the entire electronics and technology industry. We've always loved them. But yeah, you know,
1:51:22we saw this happen with snapshot cameras. Snapshot digital cameras are not dead as category,
1:51:28but they might as well be. And even DLSRs have been eaten away. It's not necessarily
1:51:33So you don't choose between a $5,000 DLSR and a smartphone,
1:51:38but mirrorless cameras, which are much less expensive,
1:51:41or can be much less expensive.
1:51:42I think I've eaten away there too.
1:51:43- I think another thing with cameras is,
1:51:45in addition to being eaten by the phone
1:51:47at the consumer end, at the high end,
1:51:49they've also reached a point where the rapid increases
1:51:52in the digital quality have slowed,
1:51:54where you're, it's more like the film days, right?
1:51:58Like in the film era, you could get,
1:52:01You could be like a serious, even a professional photographer
1:52:04and not buy new equipment for long stretches of time, right?
1:52:08You'd, until they break, 'cause number one,
1:52:10the high-end stuff is usually built to last,
1:52:12really great build quality.
1:52:13And the technology stopped changing.
1:52:15It was the same 35 millimeter film.
1:52:17A good lens was a good lens, you know.
1:52:20And I think the digital has sort of gotten to that point too
1:52:23where even the pros don't need to buy cameras as frequently
1:52:25because they're not getting as much bang for the buck
1:52:28by upgrading after two or three years.
1:52:31You can't, I mean, the megapixel myth is a megapixel myth, right?
1:52:35There's a point at which, beyond which a better sensor, a bigger, better sensor doesn't
1:52:40buy you enough more to be worth upgrading, even if it is better.
1:52:43That's where Lightro was trying to introduce computational photography as a gimmick.
1:52:47There's a camera called the Light L16 that hasn't shipped yet that has 16 lenses on
1:52:52it and will let you create like this 52 megapixel image with a tiny format camera using computational
1:52:59photography.
1:53:00curious approach is not going to be a mass market thing but it's very
1:53:03interesting you know so but that's I think that's the truth with everything
1:53:06a GoPro just stumbled they try to expand a different market and GoPro is
1:53:10just the new flip I've been saying this for it feels like but they had a great I
1:53:13mean they had a great run I hope people made money because they had a great run
1:53:16they had a niche product and you know so I don't know I'm a little sad because I
1:53:21grew up with gadgets and I feel like I wasn't like a gadget you know maybe and
1:53:26I never really got into the gadget blogging side of things I do review
1:53:29products and things like that. But he was also pointing out the Kindle, the Echo,
1:53:34like these kinds of—the Echo is a gadget killer at some level because you don't need other stuff.
1:53:38Yeah, but it is a gadget.
1:53:40See, that's why I—
1:53:40It is a gadget, but it's one monolithic gadget from one giant company.
1:53:44Right. That's sort of—that and that is sort of the smartphone as the gadget killer is that
1:53:49the computers have gotten so good that meta-gadgets are killing—
1:53:55Yes, that's it.
1:53:55You know, like a handful of really good smart computers, like an Echo and a Mac and an iPhone,
1:54:03and all of a sudden, they combined obviate an entire drawer full of gadgets.
1:54:08Right, like what else do you need? You don't need a music player, you don't need a camera,
1:54:10you don't need a snapshot GoPro-style camera.
1:54:12You don't need a voice recorder, you know.
1:54:14Yeah, right, you get a case for your camera is now your GoPro, right? Like, I've seen a lot of that.
1:54:21And, you know, I was testing some add-on lenses for iPhone 6s's that'll work with a different
1:54:25case with the iPhone 7. iPhone 7 Plus is just ridiculously good, too. Like, the two lens—
1:54:32Pete: It really is.
1:54:33Pete: Do you have one still? I forgot.
1:54:34Pete; I still have, I have my review unit here.
1:54:36Pete; I just took pictures in the dark outdoor snow. It's night, it's cloudy, I'm in Seattle.
1:54:44Pete; Right.
1:54:45Pete; And I took pictures that I think are absolutely beautiful with the 1x lens. I'm like,
1:54:51Like, I'm like, I can't get a, you know, I'd have to, I pulled out my, I have a mirrorless
1:54:54camera with a, you know, it's like a, when I bought it, it was like a thousand dollar
1:54:57system.
1:54:58I have a pancake lens for it that's an affordable pancake.
1:55:00I went out and took some pictures with that, and you know, the difference is not in that
1:55:04kind of lighting.
1:55:05I, in the, the mirrorless I have, I can push it to, oh, 25,600 ASA, where it's super
1:55:11grainy.
1:55:12So I have to bump it down.
1:55:13The quality of the image from the iPhone 7 Plus and the thousand dollar mirrorless, I'm
1:55:18like, uh, you know, the mirrorless has other attributes that are great, but for that kind
1:55:22of shot, I'm like, I don't think it's not really.
1:55:24So I don't think it's the death of gadgets, but I think it's the death of the drawer full
1:55:29of gadgets.
1:55:30Right.
1:55:31So yeah, that's a good point.
1:55:32That's a good, it is a good column.
1:55:33I'll put a link in the notes.
1:55:34His point too, is I think that like Amazon, Google, Apple, and a handful of other companies
1:55:38essentially now dominate.
1:55:40So this place for innovative startup, interesting niche things is not dead, but like at the
1:55:45moment, what those are going to be, I think, seems pretty thin.
1:55:49Yeah, I think it's true too. I've long thought this about, and Pebble's a perfect example, where
1:55:55the small team, or maybe even the one-person show, can still make an enormous effect with software,
1:56:05but with hardware, at least electronic hardware, no. And I really think that Pebble,
1:56:12Their first one was good enough to be their first one,
1:56:16but their improvements, their subsequent improvements
1:56:19were way too little, too late, at way too slow a pace.
1:56:23They needed much better screens and much better everything,
1:56:27much quicker.
1:56:28And I think, I don't even know that it was a failure.
1:56:30I think, you know, in terms of,
1:56:32I don't know that a team that small could have done better.
1:56:34Like you'd almost have to be Apple's or Amazon's
1:56:37or Google's size to do stuff like that.
1:56:39- I think you're right.
1:56:40Pebble hit us point when the thing it did best, I think you said, was notifications.
1:56:44That's what I heard from a lot of people. But it couldn't integrate well enough with
1:56:48everything and that didn't change because iOS didn't change.
1:56:52And my personal take on their notifications, the thing that killed it for me, above and
1:56:55beyond the display, was that I found their vibrating engine for the notifications to
1:57:00be physically unpleasant.
1:57:02Oh my gosh.
1:57:03And obviously other people disagree because I have friends, like Jason Snell and my friend
1:57:08Paul Kofasas, who wore their Pebble watches, or maybe even still wear them, I don't know,
1:57:11but wore them for a long time. But I found it to be unpleasant. It was way too much of
1:57:15a... It just wasn't a very pleasing haptic feedback. And it was the best feature the
1:57:20watch had. And so it made me dread taking advantage of the best... I didn't want any
1:57:25notifications because I found it to be unpleasant. So...
1:57:28No.
1:57:29I don't know. Anyway. I have got to go... We got to wrap it up. This just hit the two
1:57:36hour mark. So that's a great show. Glenn F. G-L-E-N-N, two N's, you get the second N for
1:57:44free. Glenn F. on Twitter. Where else can people find your work?
1:57:49I write a lot at Macworld. Some days, the poor folks at Macworld, some days because
1:57:54of all the help questions I write and all that, you may see too much of me at macworld.com.
1:58:00And I think that's probably the best places right now to find me. I'd point out to, by
1:58:05way, we didn't cover this very briefly, I do have a story up today. If you have an Apple
1:58:09Cinema Display with DisplayPort, not an Apple Thunderbolt display, looks like there may
1:58:13be some solutions coming. One person found this amazing three-cable solution to use with
1:58:19a MacBook Pro. It's like an adapter, a cable, and an inline coupler, and it works! Then
1:58:25it costs like 30 bucks, but there are some adapters coming. I know tons of people keep
1:58:29asking about that. There's a column up at Macworld about it, and if you have one of
1:58:33those displays and your USB-C Thunderbolt 3 concern is real, then look for that.
1:58:37With that, it's a show. Thank you, Glenn. Thank you so much.