0:00:00You know, I can't believe I missed the holiday party again.
0:00:03[laughter]
0:00:04It was a different kind of holiday party.
0:00:07Anything interesting happen in the last few weeks?
0:00:10Nope. It's quiet. Peaceful.
0:00:13Without a tumbleweed roll-by.
0:00:15You know. Not much.
0:00:17Apple doesn't really do much in the fall.
0:00:20[sigh]
0:00:23[sigh]
0:00:25[sigh]
0:00:27[laughter]
0:00:29You have to laugh a little.
0:00:32I was talking to my wife the other day about, we were on a walk, and I said, "You know,
0:00:37I feel like it's been going nonstop for a long time."
0:00:40And then I realized it totally had been going nonstop for a long time.
0:00:43We went to Ireland for Ool, and I realized, literally, I went to the Apple event, and
0:00:50the next day I got on a plane and went to this event in Southern California, this festival
0:00:55over the weekend, and then from there I went basically straight to Ool.
0:00:58And in the middle there, I got the one review unit
0:01:01of the MacBook Pro, and then the day after I came back
0:01:05from Ireland, I got the Touch Bar review unit
0:01:08with the MacBook Pro, and it is nonstop.
0:01:11It's just like one thing after another, all fall.
0:01:14- You know what I mean, and it's, you know,
0:01:16tough life for us, you know what I mean, reviewing--
0:01:20- Yeah, no, it's good. - Amazing new computers
0:01:22before anybody gets them while jetting around the globe
0:01:25to meet interesting people, but it has been hectic.
0:01:29- Yeah, I mean, I'm not complaining.
0:01:32It is a privilege to do this, but this is the high season.
0:01:35I mean, that's the way I keep telling people
0:01:37it's high season.
0:01:38This is when everything is happening for Apple.
0:01:40It's like this time period and like WWDC
0:01:43are the two craziest times of the year.
0:01:44- I think this is crazier, honestly, for us.
0:01:48'Cause just, I don't know, somehow to me,
0:01:52even that several weeks long period between the iPhone 7 coming out and the
0:01:58MacBook event, I don't know. That somehow seemed jam-packed with stuff too.
0:02:03Yeah, rules in Apple Watch, you know, two rules in there.
0:02:08And yeah, I mean, there's a lot going on. A lot of stuff going on.
0:02:13Anyway, long story short, just wasn't a good time for an election that I had a,
0:02:17like 110% obsessive interest into.
0:02:21No.
0:02:24So yeah, there's stuff, lots of stuff going on. It was a, it was a busy fall. I do feel like we've
0:02:28reached, you know, it's all subsiding a little bit now. And I feel like that mentally I'm starting to
0:02:34shift gears. I still got some stuff that I put off that I need to pick back up again, but it's like
0:02:37mentally shifting gears into, you know, holidays, end of year people, you know, if you want to make
0:02:43holiday stories and gift guides and best of the year lists and stuff like that. It's
0:02:49starting to feel more like that at last. Which is good because it's like Thanksgiving
0:02:53next week. So, I mean, here it is.
0:02:55It was a little... The MacBook Pro review... I got all... I got three of them. I got
0:03:02the button one. What are they called? We're calling it the MacBook
0:03:06Escape.
0:03:07I guess we are. Makes me think of a Journey album, but, you know, whatever.
0:03:11I know I got that the same time you did.
0:03:12We got that the day of the event.
0:03:14Yeah, they had those.
0:03:17I got the 13-inch with the Touch Bar, I don't know,
0:03:20a week later, about at least a week later.
0:03:22I don't know if it was six days or eight days.
0:03:24It was the week I was in Ireland, which
0:03:26was the week after the event, because I got an email from
0:03:27Apple on a Wednesday in Ireland saying,
0:03:29can you come buy Cupertino on Thursday
0:03:31to pick up your 13-inch MacBook with Touch Bar?
0:03:34And I was like, uh, no.
0:03:37And so I didn't get that one.
0:03:39And then I got the 15-inch, I don't know.
0:03:41But that was late.
0:03:42The 15-inch was really only just a few days
0:03:45before the embargo deadline.
0:03:47So I opened it, and I turned it on and looked at it.
0:03:50But I spent much less time with the 15-inch,
0:03:53simply because I already had the 13-inch with the touch bar set up
0:03:57with my stuff.
0:03:59I've got BB Edit on it.
0:04:00It's just there.
0:04:04And the thing I do to wrap block quotes,
0:04:07So they all look like nice markdown block quotes
0:04:09that's already there.
0:04:10- Right, and again, not that we're complaining
0:04:12about getting review units,
0:04:13but onboarding to a new Mac is a lot of work.
0:04:16And when you have to do it three times in three weeks,
0:04:18it's like, oh, here we go again.
0:04:21Like what files, what do I install?
0:04:23Can I migrate?
0:04:23No, I don't really want to migrate,
0:04:25but then I have to install everything.
0:04:26I have to hook it up with Dropbox.
0:04:29And I don't know about you,
0:04:31I also have to juggle,
0:04:33like there are these hard breaks
0:04:35like five authorized iTunes computers and like 10 authorized Apple music devices.
0:04:40And so I'm always juggling like logging out of different iPads and phones and stuff in
0:04:45order to get slots back to put other computers in there.
0:04:49And it's a yeah, so it's again, not complaining.
0:04:51It's great that we get to do this for our job.
0:04:53But you know, like that all of this stuff is not meant to be done as frequently as we
0:04:57do them.
0:04:58So yeah.
0:04:59- Yeah.
0:05:00- What I, I mean even little things.
0:05:01I've run into a little thing where
0:05:03my Amex card has a maximum limit on how many
0:05:08Apple Pay devices it can be hooked up to.
0:05:10- Oh. (laughs)
0:05:11- And-- - Oh yeah.
0:05:13- And you know, and it's, it's magnified
0:05:16because it's like two, now you get two phones
0:05:18when they give you review phones,
0:05:19they give you one of each size,
0:05:20and it's like, I got iPads and stuff,
0:05:23and it's like, I don't even know, you know,
0:05:25and some of them I've foolishly left named John's iPad.
0:05:29So it's like, right?
0:05:31It's like, what, which one is it?
0:05:34I don't know.
0:05:35I mean, what?
0:05:36And I just started-
0:05:37- And occasionally, there are updates that reset the name.
0:05:39So I realized the other day
0:05:41that my iPad is called iPad again.
0:05:42And it's like, well, I don't know when that happened,
0:05:44but it's like, no wonder I went on my device list
0:05:47and I saw three things named iPad
0:05:49and had no idea which was which.
0:05:51It's, yeah.
0:05:52It's, I haven't been able to do Apple Pay.
0:05:55I've been testing the Apple Watch too.
0:05:56And I actually haven't written about that yet,
0:05:58but it can't do Apple Pay because it's just,
0:06:00I think my financial institutions have given up on me
0:06:04and they're like, no, mm-mm, no more devices for you.
0:06:06Every time I try to pair it, it's just like,
0:06:07I can't even forget it, you know?
0:06:10- Oh, and my bank, sometimes what I've done is,
0:06:13I generally, if I use a charge card,
0:06:15I use my Amex, I just use it everywhere.
0:06:18And the only times I ever don't use it
0:06:20is if I'm in a place that doesn't take Amex.
0:06:22But to get around this Amex limit,
0:06:26If I have a device that I'm testing from Apple that I don't really want to spend--
0:06:32I know I'm not going to spend a ton of time on.
0:06:35For example, at WWDC, they gave me an Apple Watch with the beta of watchOS 3.
0:06:42Wow.
0:06:43Which I think that's when they gave it to me.
0:06:46I don't know.
0:06:47But at some point, they gave it to me.
0:06:48It wasn't new hardware.
0:06:49It was just, here, you could try this thing out with the watchOS 3.
0:06:52And I thought, well, that's interesting.
0:06:53but it's like, I'll just put the watchos 3 beta on my own Apple watch, you know what I mean?
0:06:57And so I didn't want to put this Amex limit on it, so I used my other card.
0:07:02My bank sends me a letter in the mail every time I set up Apple Pay that it's like, "Congratulations."
0:07:08It's so totally written from the perspective of like, you're going to have one device that you do this with,
0:07:14and we'll tell you everything, how it works, and I just keep...
0:07:17I should have kept all the letters, because I'll bet I've got 15 of them by now.
0:07:22I think the advantage of this is it's so easy in so many different ways that you do,
0:07:28you review tech products, to lose perspective if you're not careful. And this is like
0:07:34the reverse of that, which is there's nobody, I think, more aware of the pain of basically
0:07:42upgrading to a new device than reviewers, because we have to do it like with every device.
0:07:48Like for a while there, I could tell you everything you need to do to migrate from a MacBook to
0:07:53another MacBook or from a PowerBook to another PowerBook because I was reviewing all the
0:07:58laptops at Macworld.
0:08:00And so like I would go through, I would migrate everything a couple times a year.
0:08:06And so, I mean, that's good because we get to experience that.
0:08:08And I think Apple's got some issues with the migration assistant on the Mac and with some
0:08:13of the stuff they're getting better, but like, you know, they've got some issues there.
0:08:16And those really come out when you're migrating multiple times a year.
0:08:20Because regular people only might do it once a year for a phone and once every several
0:08:23years for an iPad or a Mac.
0:08:25I have spoken—I still think it's too hard on a Mac.
0:08:30And I think part of it is because I don't—I think part of it really is a technical challenge
0:08:36and not just a disinterest.
0:08:37I think because you can—you still have so much freedom of what to put where in the file
0:08:44system on a Mac, and it's, you know, really, it's just technically not, it's not, you can't
0:08:51just say clone the disk and open it, you know, it's because there's all sorts of stuff that's
0:08:55a different because it's different hardware.
0:08:57You know, I think it's the number one motivator why they do, why they did desktop and documents
0:09:01syncing the way they did it, was that that was sort of like their, if you keep everything,
0:09:06if you buy everything through the App Store, which, you know, some people do, and you're
0:09:11not a superpower user, but you keep everything in documents and on the desktop, and then
0:09:15you log into a new Mac. Like, it'll just sync your stuff and you're ready to go. It's for
0:09:21the rest of us who've got, you know, legacy apps, non-Mac App Store apps, all sorts of
0:09:26stuff like that, and then you turn to Migration Assistant. I'm not convinced Migration Assistant
0:09:31is doing so hot. I've tried it twice with these two MacBook Pros that I've got, and
0:09:37it failed both times.
0:09:38- You know what's interesting?
0:09:39I've given up on migration assistant, to be honest.
0:09:41I haven't used it in a few years.
0:09:43I mean, and maybe I should give it another shot,
0:09:46one of these, although what you just said,
0:09:47it's really not. - I don't think you should.
0:09:49- What I've got-- - I don't recommend it.
0:09:51- What I have is an Apple Notes document.
0:09:55I started this two or three years ago,
0:09:57setting up a new Mac.
0:09:58And so it's, the first thing I do is I go through
0:10:02the first run, I put my iCloud,
0:10:04I go through and put my iCloud credentials in.
0:10:07So because I put my iCloud credentials in, my note sinks.
0:10:10And then the note has a checklist of, you know,
0:10:14do this, do this, do this.
0:10:16It's, you know, and some of it-
0:10:18- It's like an onboarding script for yourself.
0:10:20- Yeah, more or less.
0:10:21And then some of the stuff I'll just skip.
0:10:22- Like a pre-flight checklist, right?
0:10:23Like do this, then do this, then do this,
0:10:25and I'm like, all right, got it.
0:10:25So you don't miss a step.
0:10:27You know, it kills me, BB Edit will sync all of its,
0:10:30let's nerd out.
0:10:33It's you and me.
0:10:34We talked about baseball, we'll talk about BB Edit.
0:10:36BBEdit will let you put all of its support stuff in Dropbox, which is great, and I use
0:10:42that, but its preferences file does not go in Dropbox, and so every time I move to a
0:10:47new Mac, I either have to manually reset all of the preferences, or I have to go to a home
0:10:54folder, library application support, no, library preferences, com.barebones, BBEdit preferences,
0:11:01and copy that file over so that my editor
0:11:04is the way I like it.
0:11:05And I do that every single time I move Macs.
0:11:07It's like one of those things on the checklist
0:11:09is I gotta move my BBEdit preferences
0:11:11'cause they don't cloud sync.
0:11:13I can't fish them out of Dropbox.
0:11:14- Yeah, I've been meaning for,
0:11:15I've used that ever since BBEdit added that feature.
0:11:18I mean, it's a couple of years ago at least.
0:11:20And at first I really liked it,
0:11:22but it's grown to annoy me
0:11:24because I end up with like the same documents open
0:11:27'cause I also have the preference set
0:11:29to restore open documents.
0:11:31and almost everything I write in BB Edit
0:11:34is stored in Dropbox.
0:11:36So when I go to a different machine
0:11:39and use BB Edit there, Dropbox has the same document.
0:11:43And so it's open in two.
0:11:44And I have found that I don't want that
0:11:48because I leave too many documents open.
0:11:52- Yeah, and oftentimes I'll leave one place
0:11:55and finish in the other, and then I go back
0:11:57and it's like, oh, I don't want that.
0:11:58It's opening documents that I'm done with
0:12:00because it lost state, because I'm not keeping them open
0:12:03and in sync myself.
0:12:05And I agree, I've noticed that.
0:12:07But I like the fact that all my scripts and clippings
0:12:10and things like that are just sort of there everywhere.
0:12:12That's nice.
0:12:13- I do too, and I know it's gonna annoy me
0:12:16to go back to the old way, where if I write a new script,
0:12:19or just one of my scripts, just tweak one of my scripts,
0:12:22that to get that script to percolate everywhere,
0:12:25I'd have to do it manually.
0:12:30you know, zip up the, I don't know. Maybe what I should do is just turn off the preference
0:12:35to reopen documents and see. I don't know. I've had a—but it's a mild annoyance that
0:12:39I've had. I've been thinking for like a year I should like dig into this and redo it, but
0:12:43I don't.
0:12:44I know there's so many things that we do with our computers that are like, it's annoying,
0:12:49but it doesn't—you gotta clear the bar of, "I'm gonna sit down for an hour and figure
0:12:53out what the hell is going on," and so that you're just like, "Nah, I'm not gonna leave
0:12:56and probably do you have more than an hour of misery?
0:13:00Maybe, maybe not, but it's just enough.
0:13:03I do that all the time with like automation stuff
0:13:05where automation's great,
0:13:06but you gotta clear the time to like do it.
0:13:10And then once you do it, you're like, yay,
0:13:11I've got this automation thing.
0:13:13But so often it's just like, eh, I'm not gonna bother.
0:13:16It's close enough and it's not enough annoyance
0:13:19for me to break out an hour to try and figure it out.
0:13:22So you just leave it.
0:13:23- I actually, you know, it's funny you would say that.
0:13:24I actually did a couple of those things last week as a sort of get my mind off of other
0:13:32things, you know, get my mind off the internet.
0:13:35And I found it very difficult to write, honestly.
0:13:41I'll tell you what, I read a thing—let's just keep going meta here, and I know Merlin
0:13:47and I talked about this last week extensively, you know, blah blah blah, the election and
0:13:52and hard feelings.
0:13:53But I saw a couple of other people with sight.
0:13:55Steven Levy had a good thing on his back channel.
0:13:59He had, I think it was just a day after the election.
0:14:00But half of me says I should just charge ahead
0:14:05and write some typically daring fireball topic stuff
0:14:10because other people who read Daring Fireball, I'm sure,
0:14:14would more than even usual love to have their mind
0:14:16occupied by this, to get it off thoughts of the election.
0:14:22and President Donald Trump.
0:14:25But then there's another half of me that says,
0:14:27that is, it's so, it's inappropriate, right?
0:14:32That something this, you know, of its seismic level happens.
0:14:38It's just foolish to write something that is so off topic.
0:14:45And so I found myself unusually jammed last week
0:14:50in terms of actually getting anything written.
0:14:52So what I did is I occupied myself
0:14:54by doing a couple like AppleScript things
0:14:56that I'd been meaning to write for myself.
0:14:58And it really, it helped.
0:15:00It's the sort of thing where once I start
0:15:01like writing an AppleScript and I'm,
0:15:03'cause half of it for me always with AppleScript is,
0:15:08what the hell is the syntax for blank?
0:15:10I find myself like an hour can go by
0:15:14and I haven't had any thoughts of the election
0:15:17and it's like the best hour of my day was writing.
0:15:19What is it here?
0:15:21I've got it, just opened it.
0:15:22It's a Apple script that creates a new text file
0:15:25at the current, right in the current finder window.
0:15:28- That's nice.
0:15:30I mean, I've, it's funny that we're talking about this
0:15:34'cause as we record this,
0:15:36I think that the news kind of broke today
0:15:38that Sal Segoian, who was the automation
0:15:42in Apple script product manager at Apple for years,
0:15:44is no longer employed by Apple.
0:15:47- I did not know that.
0:15:48- Oh yeah, yeah, he just mentioned that he did a presentation
0:15:52at the Mac Tech Conference today.
0:15:54I have to say I'm sad, but I'm not really surprised
0:15:58'cause I'm not sure Apple's eye has been
0:15:59on that particular ball for a long time,
0:16:01but you know, and it's not for everybody.
0:16:03And when I talk, people know that I do automation stuff
0:16:06and they're like, "Oh, you know, it's hard to get into."
0:16:09And that's all true, but then, you know, every,
0:16:13And again, I do leave things for a long time, and sometimes, and it's like, oh, well, you
0:16:16know, I should automate that.
0:16:18But every time I do one of those, I finally put in that work.
0:16:21Not only is it kind of a pleasure to solve the problem, and I think to myself, this must
0:16:24be what computer programmers feel all the time, but, you know, once it's done, I can
0:16:31hand it to other people sometimes if they want it.
0:16:33I've done that a little bit.
0:16:34And, you know, things get passed around, and it can make, it just can make your life better.
0:16:38I have a bunch of things now that are,
0:16:41they're not even Apple scripts,
0:16:43they're shell scripts that run inside a service.
0:16:48So basically, you basically make an automator thing
0:16:52that says, do the shell scripts.
0:16:54And then you wire that to--
0:16:56- Take the current selection as input
0:16:58and pass it to the script.
0:16:59- Yeah, and so I do that for like,
0:17:01I've got all these scripts that either I'm clicking on
0:17:05something in the finder and doing a keyboard shortcut
0:17:08or I'm choosing it from the contextual menu
0:17:11to do all sorts of like audio processing
0:17:14and stuff for podcasts.
0:17:15And I just do it in,
0:17:16it's all scripts running in the background.
0:17:18And I got a lot of these scripts from Marco Arment
0:17:20who is very comfortable with the command line
0:17:22and just issues all this things from the command line.
0:17:24I'm like, I'm not gonna do that.
0:17:25I'm gonna put it in a little,
0:17:27I'm gonna wrap it in an automator
0:17:28and just hit a keyboard shortcut and do it.
0:17:30And it's great.
0:17:31And every time I do one of those things,
0:17:32I think to myself, I can't believe I went months
0:17:35where I was bringing up the terminal
0:17:37and dragging in folders to get the path names
0:17:39and then issuing the shell scripting commands
0:17:42and all of that.
0:17:43Now all I do is point and click.
0:17:44I mean, that's the great thing about Mac automation stuff
0:17:47and iOS too really is once it's done,
0:17:50it's out of the way, all you do is go boop
0:17:52and magic things happen.
0:17:53And that's the abstracted computer user interface
0:17:58in a nutshell right there
0:17:59is you shouldn't know what the steps are.
0:18:01You should be able to build the steps
0:18:02and then put it aside and just keep doing your work.
0:18:05- Yeah, and some of the utilities that are along those lines
0:18:09like TextExpander and Keyboard Maestro,
0:18:12I think Keyboard Maestro does this.
0:18:13I'm almost certain TextExpander does this.
0:18:15There's a way if you go to the About box or something,
0:18:17it shows you how much time you've saved
0:18:19since you've been using it.
0:18:21And if you've been using,
0:18:22I've got some of these utilities where I somehow,
0:18:24it's like I look and it tells me I've saved
0:18:27like 10 hours of time over so many years.
0:18:31But that's like at each little step.
0:18:34One of them for me, I've published this somewhere,
0:18:36I don't know, I think it's on Gist or something like that,
0:18:39I've written about it on Daring Fireball,
0:18:40but I have a very particular style of title casing
0:18:43I use on Daring Fireball.
0:18:44Where there's, every big word gets an uppercase letter
0:18:50and then there's a specific set of little words
0:18:52that are not, like of, a, an.
0:18:55And it can be tricky though to do it, to automate it,
0:19:02because you can be fooled by things like quotes
0:19:05in the text that's being selected
0:19:10because then the should be capitalized
0:19:13if it's the first word in the quote
0:19:14because it's like the title of the thing.
0:19:16So I've hacked together a script years ago
0:19:18that gets it right 99.9% of the time.
0:19:22And I have it exactly like you said,
0:19:24it's an automator script or a service
0:19:28with that shell script running in it.
0:19:30and I have it mapped to shift command T for title case.
0:19:34And there are some, I think about how much time
0:19:37that has saved me over the years.
0:19:39And it's just unbelievable.
0:19:41And, but before I wrote it,
0:19:42even though I've been using it for years,
0:19:43I think, well, all those years,
0:19:44I was like arrow, arrow, arrow, shift,
0:19:46retype the letter, arrow, arrow.
0:19:49It's crazy.
0:19:50- Yeah, it's, well, I mean, that's,
0:19:53KeyboardMeister tells me I've saved seven hours,
0:19:55by the way, I just looked.
0:19:57It goes back to regular expressions, right?
0:20:01Did you write the chapter in the BB Edit manual
0:20:03about regular expressions?
0:20:04Was that you?
0:20:05- No, no, but the second half of it is.
0:20:09So I think this is fair to say,
0:20:11I don't wanna take too much credit.
0:20:13The regular expression chapter in BB Edit
0:20:15was there when I started.
0:20:17But BB Edit was using
0:20:19a very old regular expression library.
0:20:22It was really a derivative of the original Unix one.
0:20:26a guy named Henry, somebody wrote it.
0:20:30And it only had the basic regular expression syntax.
0:20:34It was almost more like glorified wildcards.
0:20:38And all the fancy stuff that you can do
0:20:42when you read that chapter and you're like, holy crap,
0:20:45was added when I was there.
0:20:47And so I wrote the, you know,
0:20:49they added onto the chapter to write all the--
0:20:51- So all the PCRE stuff. - Yes.
0:20:54- All right.
0:20:55Yeah, that's, anyway, that's, I tell people about grep, about regular expressions, and
0:21:00they have that same look as when I talk about Automator or if you talk about shell scripting,
0:21:03which is like, I don't want to learn it, I don't understand it, I don't know, and it's
0:21:06like, I get that.
0:21:07But like, especially when I would talk to writers and editors about grep, I'd be like,
0:21:13you don't understand.
0:21:14Text is what you do for a living.
0:21:16I am telling you, if you buy, like, buy Jeff Friedl's book, you know, or read the BB Edit
0:21:21chapter. There are things in there that, you know, if you learn it, all of a sudden you'll
0:21:27be sitting there thinking, "Oh man, I can't believe I need to do this. This is going to
0:21:30take me an hour." And if you know the language of grep, if you know those symbols, you can
0:21:35do it in two minutes. And it only needs to happen once, and you realize that it is a
0:21:43life skill that you need to have.
0:21:45I'll tell you the truth. This is a true story. I didn't learn regular expressions
0:21:50while I was in college, even though I was a BB Edit nerd, comp sci major. I mean, I
0:21:56think the furthest I ever got was like dot plus and dot star, which is, you know, just
0:22:01more or less like old DOS wildcards. And I just never saw the need for it. And like a year or so
0:22:10after college, I got a temp job at the Philadelphia Inquirer in the advertising department,
0:22:19where they had a bunch of Excel spreadsheets with all of the ad rates for everything.
0:22:24Each department had their own thing, and each one had like seven pages or 12 pages of ads in a matrix.
0:22:37Keeping them in Excel as where the business people set them made total sense. Then there'd
0:22:42be graphic designers who'd turn them into a book that they could send out to people.
0:22:47So I got hired to do these books,
0:22:48'cause I could do graphic design.
0:22:50And so I did the first one,
0:22:51and this is how everybody did it,
0:22:52but there was all sorts of gibberish
0:22:56in columns that wasn't public.
0:22:58And it must have made sense for the business people
0:23:01who'd use the Excel spreadsheet,
0:23:03but it didn't need to go in there.
0:23:05And so the way that it was done before,
0:23:08and the way I did the first book,
0:23:10was I just went in and edited each column by hand,
0:23:12and it was just tab, delete, tab, delete.
0:23:15and just pages and pages and pages and pages.
0:23:18And a couple of days work easily, or maybe a week's work
0:23:21for the whole book, mostly just deleting the crap.
0:23:26And I thought, there's got to be a better way.
0:23:28And I thought about it.
0:23:28I thought, I think this is the sort of stuff
0:23:30regular expressions are supposed to solve.
0:23:32And so I just spent a day writing just a couple
0:23:36of regular expressions in BB Edit.
0:23:38And then so I went from Excel to text,
0:23:41BB Edit to just run a couple of saved grep patterns,
0:23:46imported it into the document, and I was done.
0:23:49And I literally turned a week's work of work for each book
0:23:54into about two hours.
0:23:57And so I just--
0:23:59but I acted as though I didn't write the script
0:24:01and just sat there and browse the web.
0:24:04That's actually-- going out of Excel,
0:24:09that's like a pro tip for all this stuff too.
0:24:12It's like, I can't tell you how many times
0:24:14I've had something in Excel that's been a disaster
0:24:16and I just select it and paste it into BB edit.
0:24:18It comes in as tab delimited
0:24:20and or you save it out as a tab delimited file
0:24:22and you do all of the crazy tech stuff
0:24:24and you just make sure that there are tabs
0:24:26between the fields and you bring it back into Excel
0:24:28and you're like, look, it was in Excel all along
0:24:31but it wasn't, you know, you completely take it out.
0:24:34You know, times where I've taken multiple columns in Excel
0:24:36and I pulled them out and then kind of like mixed them
0:24:39and match them and reassembled them in the right way,
0:24:42and then you paste them back in.
0:24:44And it's like, you know, it's like they never left Excel,
0:24:47but they totally came out of Excel.
0:24:48And it's not like you can't do some wildcard stuff
0:24:50in Excel, but, and you probably can write
0:24:52Visual Basic scripts that do things too.
0:24:54But for me, it was just like, can I get this back to text?
0:24:56And can I write a couple of pattern matching
0:25:00search and replaces that solve this problem?
0:25:02And usually the answer is, yeah,
0:25:04and you can take an hour of work
0:25:05and do it in 10 minutes, five minutes.
0:25:07- I mean, it literally turned-
0:25:08turn literally turn weeks weeks of work into hours of work and I just got paid for weeks of work
0:25:16I felt like I deserved it um yeah I will just say this one last thing it was a long time ago
0:25:23it must have been 2001 or so when I wrote that the the second half of the bbedit grep chapter
0:25:29I would still say is one of the pieces of writing that I am most proud of in my entire life because
0:25:34I've people have told me many times when they find out that I wrote it they're like oh my god that
0:25:38That was the first time regular expressions
0:25:40ever made sense to me.
0:25:41And I can't take credit for the whole chapter.
0:25:43But I did take a pass through the early part,
0:25:45'cause that was my goal, is I do feel like
0:25:48I have a knack for regular expressions.
0:25:50It's the one area of programming
0:25:52where I'm better than almost anybody.
0:25:54I really am good at figuring out how to create the syntax
0:26:00to match what I wanna match.
0:26:01And it ends up creating these things
0:26:04that most people look at and they're like,
0:26:05"What the hell?"
0:26:07- Yeah, I think that's the big problem
0:26:09with regular expressions is readability.
0:26:12Like, people see them and they think,
0:26:13it's nonsense, I can't do it.
0:26:14And it's like, no, no, no.
0:26:15If you learn it, it's actually fairly straightforward.
0:26:18Not all of them, but most of them.
0:26:19But they look like nonsense.
0:26:22- Well, I just thought, you know, but this is something,
0:26:24this is like a perfect combination for me
0:26:26because I have a knack for explaining things
0:26:28and I have a knack for regular expressions.
0:26:30And in hindsight, I still feel, you know, what is it?
0:26:3314, 15 years later, I still feel
0:26:36one of the best things I've ever written. Yeah, I love that chapter. I mentioned Jeff
0:26:42Friedl's O'Reilly book about this. It's great, but it's from the possession of a
0:26:46long-time Unix guy, and he talks about scripting a lot in that like shell and Perl scripting. And
0:26:53for me, the most direct application was BBEdit. So the BBEdit chapter is a much more distilled,
0:26:59clear approach to this than—I love that Friedl book, and I reference it all the time, but
0:27:05the BBA chapter is just a much more simple, gentle introduction.
0:27:09Yeah, I love it. I love the "FREEDLE" book, too, and I've read both editions—maybe three
0:27:13editions. I think there might be a third—I don't know. Every time there's a new edition, I buy it.
0:27:16There is a third.
0:27:17And I have all three copies, and I've read them all cover to cover.
0:27:20It is. But it's a—I would definitely say it is—this "FREEDLE" book is so comprehensive and so
0:27:32well done. I don't know that I've ever read any book on any subject where you could say,
0:27:37"Well, there's no need for anybody else to ever write a book on this again." But I would honestly
0:27:41say that that's the case with Friedel's book on regular expressions. I just can't see how
0:27:45anybody else would say, "Well, I'll take the time to write a technical book," which is really hard
0:27:52on this subject when there's a book that covers it both perfectly and extensively.
0:27:58All right, maybe I'll take a break. How about I take a break here and thank the first
0:28:02friend of the show. It's our good friends.
0:28:05- Sounds good.
0:28:07- Good friends at Casper.
0:28:08Casper, they make obsessively engineered mattresses
0:28:11at shockingly fair prices.
0:28:12Go to casper.com/thetalkshow and use code thetalkshow
0:28:17and you'll save 50 bucks towards your mattress
0:28:20with one exception.
0:28:21Hold on, I'll tell you what that is.
0:28:23So here's the deal.
0:28:24I've told you this before, I'll say it again.
0:28:26Casper has created one perfect type of mattress.
0:28:30It's a combination of memory foam and some other stuff
0:28:35that's just the right blend of types of things.
0:28:39So you don't have to pick between six different types
0:28:42of mattresses.
0:28:43How do you know what the difference is?
0:28:46These guys, it really is sort of like the Apple attitude
0:28:49taken to mattresses.
0:28:50Trust us, we'll do all the work.
0:28:52We'll make one type of mattress,
0:28:54and then all you have to do is pick the size.
0:28:56That's it.
0:28:57That is, it just sings to me.
0:29:00This is how a mattress company should do it.
0:29:03Now, in addition to that, because they sell,
0:29:05they make 'em, right here in the United States, in fact,
0:29:08and they sell them directly to you, you just go there,
0:29:12they cut out the middleman and it enables them
0:29:15to keep their prices incredibly lower
0:29:18than the mainstream big brand mattresses you find
0:29:22in traditional mattress stores.
0:29:24Premium mattresses often start at well over 1500.
0:29:29Casper mattresses cost just 500 for twin
0:29:32750 for full 850 for Queen and just
0:29:36950 for a king so you can get a king from them for less than like a twin from a lot of the other big brands
0:29:43crazy
0:29:45And like I said, they're made right here in America now
0:29:48biggest thing you think how am I gonna buy a thousand dollar mattress and
0:29:52Not even try it. You don't have to worry about it
0:29:56They have a 100-night home trial.
0:29:58If you don't love it, they will pick it up at your house,
0:30:00give you a full refund.
0:30:02No hard sell.
0:30:03It's not like trying to cancel your cable.
0:30:05It's something like that.
0:30:06You just say, I want to send it back.
0:30:08And they say, OK, when?
0:30:09And then somebody shows up, and they take the mattress away.
0:30:12And you get your money back.
0:30:13And that's it.
0:30:13I've had readers.
0:30:14Casper's been a sponsor long enough.
0:30:16I've gotten emails from readers who've done that.
0:30:18And they said, I couldn't believe how easy it was
0:30:21to actually just send it back.
0:30:23Because they actually didn't believe
0:30:25that it was going to be easy because that just
0:30:27sounds too good to be true.
0:30:29But that's how confident Casper is in their mattress.
0:30:31Get yours today, 100 nights in your own home.
0:30:37They have a dog mattress even.
0:30:40That's a new product.
0:30:41And that's the one that you don't get $50 on
0:30:43because it's a lower price.
0:30:45But if you have a dog, get him a good mattress.
0:30:47Go check it out.
0:30:48I've had readers tell me-- this is the thing.
0:30:51When I first did this read, I didn't
0:30:52know that the discount didn't apply to the dog one.
0:30:56So I had a couple of readers who said,
0:30:57"Hey, I bought my dog the mattress,
0:30:58"but I didn't get 50 bucks off,
0:31:00"but I don't care because my dog loves the mattress."
0:31:02So that's the exception.
0:31:06Go to casper.com/thetalkshow
0:31:07and remember that code, thetalkshow,
0:31:09to save 50 bucks on any human-sized mattress.
0:31:13- Maybe that would get my dog off my couch.
0:31:17- I love doing sponsor reads.
0:31:21I've gone from having it be the part of this job that I hate to a part that I love.
0:31:27I think that makes the—not to get podcasty inside baseball, but I think that makes the
0:31:32reads better once.
0:31:34When you can't—there are a couple of podcasts I listen to where, you know, the ads are part
0:31:40of the entertainment and you just can't, you know, you can't not listen to them.
0:31:43You can't tune out, you can't skip.
0:31:45You really got to pay attention because they put their personality into them and, you know,
0:31:50And I think that makes the difference.
0:31:52If it's like a hostage video or something,
0:31:55it's a lot less entertaining.
0:31:56But if it's part of the fun, then it's a lot better.
0:31:59- I can't even tell you how many emails I got from people
0:32:02about last week's show with Merlin.
0:32:03Were there, A, just thanking us like,
0:32:05oh my God, I needed that for the election week.
0:32:08And they were like, oh my God,
0:32:09the sponsor reads so good.
0:32:11I will just take a meta break here and just say,
0:32:15I don't have time to respond to all of my email,
0:32:19but I got so much email,
0:32:21the most email I've gotten about an episode of the show
0:32:24in as long as I can remember from people last week.
0:32:28And all of it, I honestly didn't see one that was,
0:32:32I honestly thought there'd be some from Trump people
0:32:34or people who just don't wanna hear about people
0:32:37who are upset about the way the election turned out.
0:32:41Go back to tech, dummy.
0:32:42I didn't get any of that, which was sort of our goal.
0:32:45It was the way that we approached it
0:32:46and what we talked about.
0:32:48but I got so much email from people thanking us for that.
0:32:52So I just wanna say to all of you who listen,
0:32:54thank you for listening and thank you for the good words.
0:32:58I have a podcast question for you, Jason.
0:33:00You don't, I mean, do you do any other podcasts regularly?
0:33:04- Occasionally.
0:33:07- So you occasionally-- - I hear and there.
0:33:08- Occasionally podcast. (laughs)
0:33:10- Yeah, yeah, just from time to,
0:33:12you mean like per day?
0:33:14Some days I don't podcast.
0:33:16I got a bug up my butt recently about something that I had never thought about before.
0:33:25This is the sort of thing that I tend to think about.
0:33:27I can't believe I didn't really think that much about it when I set up the talk show
0:33:30to be on Daring Fireball, which is the fact that I've been doing it.
0:33:39I've always done it.
0:33:40And in most of the podcasts, almost all the podcasts I see do it.
0:33:44putting the episode number in the title and making the episode number a major part, you know, like the
0:33:49the main anchor on the URL that the like dead on on our websites on six colors and during fireball
0:33:57we don't have post number you know for 23123. Right, oh that was a good one. Yeah, good old
0:34:06good old 23,323. Why why do we do this and and you know uh tv shows don't do it i mean they
0:34:14sort of do now, like when you watch digitally, you know, you're going through season one,
0:34:20episode seven of American Horror Story or whatever. So there is, there's sort of that on TV, but...
0:34:28I don't know. It's a good question. Like, why? Why do we number podcasts? And you,
0:34:36I can always tell what number it is, because you actually do number them in the, like, the slug
0:34:39of the talk show, but not like in what people see, just like the written descriptions.
0:34:46Right. Well, but I have them in the metadata for the show, so like when you're looking at it in
0:34:52your podcast player, it will say 173 colon. Well, I switched recently. I did switch just a couple
0:35:00weeks ago from putting EP period space, the digital, you know, representation of the number
0:35:08colon, I took out the EP.
0:35:11Because I thought, you know what?
0:35:13It's cruft like that that I don't like.
0:35:16I like clean URLs.
0:35:18I don't like seeing dot PHP at the end of a URL.
0:35:21I don't like seeing all the gibberish and the medium URLs.
0:35:26I don't like tracking any URL.
0:35:28I like the URL to have every single bit of it be meaningful.
0:35:33And that same way with the titles.
0:35:35It seems to me--
0:35:37I don't know.
0:35:38There seemed it part of me thinks that part of it is that you want to know which one's the newest episode in your podcast
0:35:43player and that maybe it actually is useful because you
0:35:46It's it's a more confident way of making sure that your podcast player whatever software it is
0:35:52Whichever sort order it's using top to bottom or bottom to top, you know, which one's the newest one
0:35:57Mm-hmm. So I'm keeping it. I like when I made the change to get rid of the EP period I
0:36:02Was on the verge of just getting rid of them period and maybe just putting them in the URL
0:36:07But then I thought you know what? I think there's a reason everybody does it
0:36:10And I'm curious what you think. I don't know if it's a reason that is
0:36:15I don't know if it's a good reason or if it's more just sort of continuity. I mean some of it is
0:36:20reference wise to be able to say it's this one like saying like um
0:36:25like a Mac world we had volumes and
0:36:29numbers like
0:36:31Internally we would have like you turn in a story and it would be 24-04 and that was
0:36:38Literally 24-04 was like the to the April
0:36:432008 issue or something. It was like volume 24 number 4
0:36:48And and that was partially because in a file in the file system like it would sort right
0:36:53That all the 24-04 s would go together and then there you'd have 24-05 and it would just kind of keep going like that
0:37:00So I think some of it is just sort of like finding an internal structure and for podcasts you could do it by date
0:37:04You could literally say, you know, this is the one for
0:37:08You know this day in November of 2016 and the metadata certainly supplies that so you could just you could just do that
0:37:16You could have nothing
0:37:18I don't know as a kid growing up
0:37:21I really loved reading comic books and the comic books always had that like this is Amazing Spider-Man number
0:37:271983 and and they would have footnotes and they would say Oh spider-man face the scorpion before in Amazing Spider-Man number
0:37:3483 and sent him to prison and you'd be like, oh number 83
0:37:37Yes
0:37:37if only I had that issue I could read that now and I
0:37:40Part of what appeals to me about the podcast numbering scheme is that which is just it lets you hang a number on it and say
0:37:47For reference sake this is what it is rather than saying season one number three
0:37:52Or just giving you a date
0:37:56But I don't know if that's a great reason to do it
0:37:58Probably also the the other thought I had is since the incomparable is now at three hundred and twenty six episodes
0:38:07think maybe it was a
0:38:09It made sense when you did ten episodes of a podcast in the early days of podcasting and now there are these podcasts that have
0:38:17Hundreds and hundreds of episodes were pretty soon. If not already there will very soon be many
0:38:23podcasts with with
0:38:25a thousand plus episodes. It's sort of crazy. Marco was saying on ATP a couple an episode or two ago
0:38:32because he knows because he runs the radio ones. Yeah, he said that the radio they're already there.
0:38:39Yeah, and they do because there's radio stations that will publish five or six podcasts a day like
0:38:44meaning like the 15 hour one hour two hour three hour four of the you know the sports fans podcast
0:38:52in the morning. And so you'll have episode 1500. It's crazy. The comic book analogy is pretty good.
0:39:00Yeah, that's the best for me is it gives you something to hang it on sequentially and say,
0:39:06"Look, we've done a lot of these." And then I have that with Incomparable. I mean, even though
0:39:11we built an index, one of the reasons that we did end up using use Moveable Type, which you
0:39:15you use on Daring Fireball for the incomparable CMS is because I wanted an index of topics.
0:39:24And so, I've got an index of topics. So, if somebody wants to see what's that episode
0:39:27where John Gruber and John Syracuse are talking about the Godfather, you can look up the Godfather
0:39:32and it'll be like, it's this number, right? But still, people will email me, tweet me,
0:39:37post on Facebook, whatever they'll say. When was that episode about whatever? And there
0:39:42is something nice about being able to say that was number 32 and just kind of point
0:39:46them and be like, it's that one, that number. I don't know. It's like a little handle for
0:39:51an episode.
0:39:52Yeah. The alternative would be to just look at the dates and somehow, but that doesn't
0:39:57show up. That's not going to show up in the list in your podcast player.
0:40:01Well, but that's maybe a self-fulfilling prophecy, right?
0:40:04Right.
0:40:05I mean, I think maybe podcast player UI is in part based on the idea that a lot of podcasts
0:40:11organize themselves by numbers, but like Overcast has a date field, and there are dates for
0:40:17every episode in Overcast, and I would imagine most podcast players are kind of like that.
0:40:22And certainly if podcasts weren't numbered, I'm sure they would all be like that.
0:40:26Yeah, but if I made mine not numbered, or didn't put the numbers into titles, it's not
0:40:32going to change it, you know what I mean? It's the collective decision that the podcast
0:40:38industry as a whole has made to do that.
0:40:40Yeah, it's more fun for me to say we talked about Raiders of the Lost Ark and the Incomparable
0:40:46Number Eight than it is to say October 17, 2010 episode.
0:40:55Was that the gap in my appearances on the Incomparable? Because we laughed about it.
0:40:59I was just on recently, like you just said, to talk about the Godfather with John Sirkusa
0:41:03and a few other… I forget their names. I'm sorry.
0:41:08There was a bunch.
0:41:09It was great.
0:41:11I had a great time.
0:41:13I can't count the number of people who made the crack on Twitter that they can't believe
0:41:17that all of us long-winded podcasters made a podcast about the Godfather that was shorter
0:41:22than the Godfather.
0:41:23I know.
0:41:26But was that it?
0:41:27That I hadn't been on since Raiders, which was episode 8?
0:41:29Yeah, that was basically six years, October 10 to October 16.
0:41:34Other than that day—you were in—I interviewed my Dave Letterman episode, which was last
0:41:38year. But in terms of being on the panel, yeah, we went from 8 to 323. It's fine. It's fine. I tried
0:41:44a couple of times to get you on, and it's like you're busy, and I want to, like with Merlin,
0:41:48I kind of want to deploy you guys tactically. I don't want to be like, I want to ask you when
0:41:52there's something I got that's really good. And it was like, for like a couple years I've been
0:41:55thinking, we're going to do the Godfather, I'm going to get Syracuse, I'm going to ask John
0:41:58Gruber, we're going to make it happen. And we finally made it happen. It was great. We got to
0:42:02talk about Abe Vigoda. Any chance to talk about Abe Vigoda is worth it.
0:42:06Although we didn't make it happen until Abe Vagoda was actually dead.
0:42:10Yeah, well, that's true. Maybe that was what I was waiting for.
0:42:13I wanted Abe to pass on before we talked about him.
0:42:16This is so amazing. I literally, just five seconds ago, got a DM from Rich Segal, creator of BBEdit,
0:42:28asking if I'd heard that Sal had left Apple.
0:42:31(laughing)
0:42:34- I was spooked, I was like, is he listening?
0:42:35Do we have a live broadcast that I don't know about?
0:42:38- I should have turned off the live stream
0:42:40for being comfortable.
0:42:42- But then I realized that--
0:42:43- He knows we're talking about him.
0:42:43- Well, then I realized that asking have I heard
0:42:47means he's not spooking me, but that was kind of spooky
0:42:50given that we spent a good chunk of the last 45 minutes
0:42:53talking about BB Edit and automation and Sal.
0:42:56- Yeah.
0:42:57(laughing)
0:43:01- New MacBook Pros.
0:43:02- Yeah.
0:43:04- I read, I really enjoyed your review.
0:43:07I often think, when I write these reviews,
0:43:11I don't know if you feel the same way,
0:43:12but I write them and sometimes I feel like
0:43:16I know that I've got this.
0:43:18Like, I don't care if other people agree with me or not,
0:43:22but I know that what I'm saying about this, I'm certain of.
0:43:25Other times, I feel like I haven't had enough time
0:43:27Or it's-- a lot of times it's just
0:43:32that I feel like I haven't had enough time.
0:43:34But other times it's like, I'm not sure
0:43:36that what I care about is representative
0:43:39of enough people.
0:43:41And I kind of had that worry with the review
0:43:44I wrote of these MacBook Pros.
0:43:46Because I know that there's a lot of people
0:43:50who are disappointed in just the basic idea of the direction
0:43:55Apple is taking them.
0:43:56But I read a whole bunch of the reviews from people
0:43:59who I really respect, like you and Joanna Stern.
0:44:01It goes on.
0:44:05I read a whole bunch of them after my review.
0:44:08And it really seemed to me like a very large consensus
0:44:12of that these are pretty good machines.
0:44:14- Yeah, I tried to,
0:44:18I mean, because of the way it got kind of strung out,
0:44:20I got to write a piece after the Apple event
0:44:25that was basically quick hands-on with that 13-inch MacBook escape. And then I got to use it for a week
0:44:31and travel and then write another piece about it. So by the time I got to the Touch Bar one,
0:44:35I felt like I'd kind of addressed the issues about people's disappointment. I wrote, I think,
0:44:40a Macworld column about people's disappointment and what that meant for why Apple let everything
0:44:46build up and people kind of—this was a thing they could focus some of their disappointment and let
0:44:51it out. And so I felt like by the time I got to the Touch Bar review, it was great because
0:44:56I could just write about the Touch Bar. I wrote a couple sections about the rest of
0:45:00the computer, but really it was an essay about the Touch Bar and Touch ID, because that was
0:45:04the thing that was left and frankly was the thing I found most interesting.
0:45:09And it's really why I—honestly, I'm not just saying it because you're on the show
0:45:14and you're a pal—it's really why, of all the reviews, I really think I liked yours
0:45:18best because I spent a relatively little amount on Touch Bar just because I had so much else
0:45:24to say about sort of the bigger picture.
0:45:29And the other thing I thought was that your video, which focused almost entirely on the
0:45:35Touch Bar, was super instructive in the difference between the way Apple would do a promotional
0:45:42video about the Touch Bar, or in fact did, and they showed it during the event.
0:45:47was focused on, look, when you're doing real stuff,
0:45:49like here's just stupid little things,
0:45:52like the fact that you can--
0:45:55when you adjust the brightness or the volume,
0:45:57you can just put your finger on it
0:45:59and slide without tapping on the actual thing that shows up.
0:46:03It illustrated in a way that I feel like 10,000 words
0:46:07wouldn't have conveyed.
0:46:09It's a visual-- it's clearly a very visual input device.
0:46:13And so I feel like the video really helped.
0:46:14Have you done video reviews before?
0:46:17- I've done a handful of them.
0:46:18I mean, I did some at Macworld.
0:46:20And then since I've been doing Six Colors,
0:46:21I've done a few, you know, they take time.
0:46:24And the challenge is always,
0:46:25am I doing this because everybody agrees
0:46:27that video is the future and we need to do video?
0:46:29Or am I doing it because video will be able
0:46:31to impart something that's worth imparting?
0:46:34And for me, it really is like,
0:46:36I will put in the time if I feel like
0:46:38this is gonna be the best way to communicate something.
0:46:39And with the touch bar, it was very clear.
0:46:41This was the way to,
0:46:43I needed to communicate what was going on with the touch bar.
0:46:46And I had the time.
0:46:47I finished that review basically on Friday afternoon,
0:46:50and the embargo was Monday morning.
0:46:52And so on the weekend, on the Sunday morning,
0:46:53I basically sat down and said, all right,
0:46:55let's figure out if I can make a video here.
0:46:57And I ended up with an iPhone 7 in a glyph attached
0:47:02to a little tripod and then a bigger tripod.
0:47:06And I tried to figure out, could I
0:47:08get an angle where I can see the touch bar
0:47:10and it's not blown out?
0:47:11and then I can capture the screen
0:47:14and kind of put them together.
0:47:15And in the end, it did work, which is good.
0:47:17'Cause that's what I wanted is like,
0:47:19I wanted people to be able to see like,
0:47:21what happens on screen?
0:47:22What happens on the touch bar?
0:47:23Where do your fingers go?
0:47:24What's the result?
0:47:25Can you see the animations?
0:47:26Can you see how some of the apps
0:47:30have these totally wild like slider interfaces
0:47:33and others just have keys?
0:47:34Some of them color the keys,
0:47:35some of them don't color the keys.
0:47:37And until, you know, there will be,
0:47:40It's a little harder because you can't do a screen capture of it, so it's harder to make those videos.
0:47:44And I had the advantage of having some time to shoot the video, and I figured out of the gate,
0:47:48there aren't going to be that many videos that explain this feature.
0:47:51And Apple's videos are probably not what people want to see because they're going to be really slick,
0:47:56but they're not necessarily—I mean, they're marketing videos.
0:47:58They're not going to be necessarily slowed down enough for people to see what's going on.
0:48:03And in the end, it was about five minutes long, which, you know, I kind of feel like could be too long,
0:48:08but at the same time I felt like I really packed it in
0:48:10with stuff, so, but it was worth doing because of that,
0:48:13because it was, how much, how many words, like you said,
0:48:16how many words would I have had to try to write
0:48:18to convey what I could just show in a video?
0:48:21- Yeah, I honestly feel like that's the sort of thing
0:48:25that just can't be done verbally.
0:48:27And you know, even just little things like,
0:48:33look, here's what it looks like in this app,
0:48:34here's what it looks like in this app,
0:48:36and they're all sort of monochromatic,
0:48:38And you can go through a bunch of stuff in the touch bar apps,
0:48:42switching from app to app and doing things
0:48:45and using the control strip.
0:48:46And it almost feels like a monochrome screen.
0:48:51And then all of a sudden, you're in something like Maps.
0:48:54And it is all lit up like Times Square.
0:48:58And I'm not saying that's wrong yet.
0:49:00But it is such a different thing, though.
0:49:03And all of a sudden, when your keyboard--
0:49:06Maps is probably the best example,
0:49:08but when your keyboard lights up with all those colors,
0:49:12it is a weird different thing because I've
0:49:15been using laptops for, I don't know, a long time, at least 15,
0:49:2316, 17 years since I first bought one.
0:49:27And I had one at the school paper before that,
0:49:29so probably 20 years.
0:49:31My keyboards never lit up in color before.
0:49:35It was surprisingly weird to me.
0:49:37It really was, when you get the burst of color,
0:49:41it really was surprisingly interesting to me.
0:49:44- Yeah, the calculator is the other one that struck me
0:49:46because there are a few of those keys are like in orange,
0:49:48they're like super bright.
0:49:50And they're still keys, but they're super bright.
0:49:53That maps, it's basically putting up the same icons
0:49:56that are in iOS and they're very colorful.
0:49:57That is by far the most colorful implementation
0:49:59of sort of standard buttons.
0:50:01But like, the calculator,
0:50:03I thought calculator was really instructive,
0:50:04not only in the use of color, but both Calculator and James
0:50:07Thompson's PCALC app.
0:50:09Those were both instructive to me
0:50:12in realizing that what I think is the right way to handle
0:50:16the touch bar is as an extension of the keyboard and not--
0:50:20I mean, when all the questions of like, why would you
0:50:23need a touch bar?
0:50:24Why wouldn't you just want to use the Mac interface?
0:50:26It was that idea of, I don't know
0:50:28how to do this with the keyboard, which
0:50:31means that I'm going to get to a certain point
0:50:33where I have to take my hands off the keyboard,
0:50:35move down to the track pad,
0:50:36and click on some UI on the screen.
0:50:38And so the calculator was that moment where I realized,
0:50:40oh, I can put like square root and cube root
0:50:43and log and sine and cosine on the touch bar.
0:50:46And I can do numbers and then immediately
0:50:49just move my hands slightly up and go tap.
0:50:51And now I've got a result or conversion,
0:50:54you know, Fahrenheit to Celsius or something.
0:50:55And my hands stay, I was already up on the number row,
0:50:58right, and my hands just move up.
0:51:00And that was that moment where I thought, oh yeah,
0:51:02this is why this is, this is where this shines,
0:51:05is I just stay on the keyboard.
0:51:07And the touch bar kind of just is an extension
0:51:09of the keyboard that,
0:51:11and is that how everybody's going to use it?
0:51:13I don't know.
0:51:14It's so early, we don't really know,
0:51:15but it felt to me like that was the moment that unlocked,
0:51:18like, I see why you would use this.
0:51:21And when I, James sent me a beta of PCALC,
0:51:25where when you tap the function keys,
0:51:27it brought up a palette of all his functions in the UI.
0:51:30And what that meant was I tapped the touch bar
0:51:33and then I had to take my hands off the keyboard,
0:51:36move to the track pad, and then move the cursor up
0:51:38and then click on which one I wanted.
0:51:40And I sent him an email back and I said,
0:51:41"You know, I think this is wrong.
0:51:43I think what you need is to put your functions
0:51:46in the touch bar because it feels like a defeat.
0:51:50If I touch the touch bar and then I have to take my hands
0:51:52off of it and move around with the cursor."
0:51:54And so he changed it and now it's like your most recent
0:51:58functions and conversions appear in the touch bar.
0:52:00and it's like night and day because now I type in 32 and I tap conversion Fahrenheit to Celsius and
0:52:06That and it all happens on the touch bar and I never have to sort of switch modes to mousing around
0:52:12yeah, and I think that
0:52:15Calculator is the apples calculators an interesting example in a couple of ways I I
0:52:22My gut feeling is that that's one of the apps that got it most, right?
0:52:28Yeah, me too and one thing too and I know Apple said this is true
0:52:31but my experience testing the device is that it is clear that
0:52:35Apple's Mac app
0:52:39engineering teams spent a lot of time working on touch bar support for their apps because there are
0:52:44Obviously some of the oddball apps like the ones that are in applications slash utilities, you know
0:52:49Those got updated. Did you really go through everyone? I did I did
0:52:54You want you want to hear the list?
0:52:58- It's like, so, so, you, activity monitor,
0:53:03that's the one that gets me.
0:53:04Activity monitor and terminal are the two utilities
0:53:07that got updated. - Oh, I knew about terminal.
0:53:09I forgot about that.
0:53:10I forgot that terminal was that,
0:53:11was buried away in utilities.
0:53:13I use it so much. - Yeah, but,
0:53:14but they also updated, and this is some of their stock,
0:53:16and some of them are their sort of app store apps,
0:53:18but calculator, calendar, contacts,
0:53:20finder, Final Cut Pro, GarageBand, iMovie, iTunes,
0:53:23keynote, mail, maps, messages, numbers, pages, photos,
0:53:26Preview, QuickTime Player, Safari system preferences.
0:53:30And then there are a bunch of apps that use the sort of standard text editing interface,
0:53:33and they pick up a text editor touch bar interface, so like TextEdit and Notes get that text editing
0:53:41interface too.
0:53:42So there's like more than a dozen.
0:53:43They did a lot.
0:53:44I mean, for people who say Apple doesn't care about the Mac, it's like they built this whole
0:53:48new bit of hardware, and then they updated all of these Mac apps to support it.
0:53:53That was a lot of work.
0:53:54Right.
0:53:55there's a lot of work in,
0:53:58I might be missing something actually,
0:54:01but there's the hardware engineering work
0:54:05of actually putting an embedded iOS device
0:54:08into the keyboard with the system on a chip
0:54:11and having a way that it can interface with the Intel side.
0:54:15You've got like this little arm computer
0:54:18running on your keyboard,
0:54:19and it communicates with the Intel side.
0:54:22And the Intel side even does the,
0:54:23because one of the things that the iOS device
0:54:26on the touch bar doesn't have is a GPU.
0:54:28So the Intel side does the GPU rendering
0:54:32and it has to go back, but it's all done securely.
0:54:34And there's a whole bunch of electrical engineering
0:54:37going on there that's, and it just,
0:54:39you'd never know it, right?
0:54:40It's 60 frames per second, just like iOS.
0:54:45It's instantaneous touch.
0:54:48It's just like you'd expect
0:54:50from any Apple iOS touch device.
0:54:52So there's the physical hardware engineering of that.
0:54:55And then the second level is the Mac programming side,
0:55:04where all of these apps were updated with--
0:55:08whether they got it right or wrong, none of them
0:55:10seemed half-assed.
0:55:11They all seemed like a lot of thought went into it.
0:55:13All of these apps got updated with touch bar support,
0:55:17which is a lot of work.
0:55:19But then in between those two, there's the Xcode side,
0:55:23where the people who work on the APIs and Xcode itself
0:55:28had to do all the work to make it so that Mac developers have
0:55:33APIs and simulators so they can test it
0:55:36on machines that don't actually have a touch bar
0:55:38and all of that stuff.
0:55:39So an awful lot of work went into this.
0:55:42And I completely agree.
0:55:43It's, to me, example number one, that whatever else is going on
0:55:47with the Mac and some of the machines that have gone way too long without getting updated,
0:55:52it's clear that Apple is invested in the Mac. I really think the touch bar is proof of it.
0:55:58Yeah, and we can debate, and I've been trying to make this distinction for the last couple
0:56:03of weeks. It's like, part of what I think a lot of us do is try to understand why Apple
0:56:07is doing what Apple's motivation is, why Apple made the choices it made, and I want to separate
0:56:12that from the judgments about whether these are good decisions or not. Because I think
0:56:17we could debate whether doing the touch bar is a good decision or not. And we can debate
0:56:22the price of these systems, and we can debate, you know, there's so many aspects of this
0:56:28that we can talk about, but I think you can't debate the fact that Apple made a major investment
0:56:34in the Mac platform in this particular computer, because we're seeing a huge bit of hardware
0:56:42engineering happening here, and a whole lot of software engineering happening here. So
0:56:46We can debate whether we think this was the right approach,
0:56:49whether this was a waste of time,
0:56:51whether having a laptop-focused input device method
0:56:55is good or bad, if it's gonna be a gimmick.
0:56:57There's all those things, but you can't debate.
0:57:00It was a huge investment on Apple's part to do this,
0:57:02and if they really didn't care about the Mac,
0:57:04why would they do it?
0:57:05- Right, exactly.
0:57:07I--
0:57:08- Just do another laptop with the latest Intel chips
0:57:10and move on, right?
0:57:11I mean, they could do that.
0:57:12- Yeah.
0:57:13Here's why I think calculators is a great example.
0:57:15Apple calculator app is a great example because the buttons, so Apple it at least I don't know
0:57:21ever since like iOS 7 or so and then when you know the the Yosemite whenever the Mac version was that
0:57:29got the sort of iOS style visual refresh, Apple has a very consistent calculator look and it's
0:57:35you know mostly based on the color orange. Yeah. They you know orange buttons so when those buttons
0:57:43are on the keyboard, it makes the keyboard look calculator-branded, right?
0:57:48Like, and so if you use Apple's calculator, you know what it looks like.
0:57:51It's got this sort of just orange calculator look. You see these buttons
0:57:55that are orange, and it's, it to me is a very cool way of making the touch bar
0:58:00feel like it's part of the app. It's, it's a really cool move. And all of the, all
0:58:06of the functions that are in orange on the UI are orange on the touch bar, and
0:58:13And so it's like, yeah, you immediately get it.
0:58:15You're like, oh yeah, right, of course they are.
0:58:17Of course the equals button is orange.
0:58:19- So when I was at the event,
0:58:23and I got to talk to people at Apple,
0:58:27and they showed me the calculator,
0:58:27and they said, and a couple of the people I spoke to,
0:58:31said this is one of my favorite examples,
0:58:32and I know it sounds silly, but they showed me calculator.
0:58:34And then at first, like in the default calculator mode,
0:58:37the only buttons you have up there
0:58:38are divide times minus plus equals.
0:58:40And they said, no, that seems silly,
0:58:43because those buttons are there.
0:58:44You can hit Shift on the equals key to get plus.
0:58:47And it's not like you can't type that.
0:58:52But they said, in our testing with the team that
0:58:57was using it, we found that we loved this.
0:58:59And surprising how many people inside Apple
0:59:03who had access to this and were working on it
0:59:06loved the calculator thing.
0:59:07Because all of a sudden, you don't have to--
0:59:10it makes your laptop keyboard feel more
0:59:14like having that extended keyboard that
0:59:16has the thing on the right side where
0:59:18you have number pads and dedicated buttons
0:59:21for those features.
0:59:22There's a reason why some people who enter numbers a lot
0:59:25like having an extended keyboard that
0:59:27has that keypad over there.
0:59:29It gives you sort of the--
0:59:30now, the number layout maybe isn't
0:59:32quite as convenient having a horizontal row of numbers,
0:59:34but not having to worry about ever hitting Shift
0:59:37or the fact that they're not consecutive,
0:59:41that minus is right there,
0:59:43but plus you have to hit shift to get,
0:59:45I mean, it's all sort of weird typing those operators
0:59:48on the keyboard, on a regular keyboard,
0:59:51with you don't have a numpad.
0:59:52With the touch bar, it really is natural.
0:59:55- Yeah, I mean, you could argue that calculator
1:00:00is the best example,
1:00:02and that they really do run the gamut.
1:00:05I do think that this is gonna be an interface playground
1:00:08where we're gonna learn a lot in the next year or two,
1:00:11where Apple and third-party developers try a bunch of stuff
1:00:14and find out what the right approach is,
1:00:16because it's all over the map now.
1:00:17Like calculator is a good example
1:00:19because there are buttons you wanna press
1:00:22that aren't on keys.
1:00:24Like there is no, I mean, there's an equals key
1:00:27and there's a plus and minus,
1:00:28and, you know, but like multiplication is the asterisk
1:00:32and division is the slash.
1:00:33And it's like, no, no, we're just gonna put
1:00:35the symbols on these virtual keys at the top.
1:00:38It's like, that is the like almost purest example
1:00:41where there are things you want to type
1:00:42that you don't know what keys to press.
1:00:45So we're gonna just draw those keys on the touch bar
1:00:48and now you know how to press them.
1:00:50And you go all the way down to something like Final Cut,
1:00:54which is this incredibly intricate context-based set of,
1:00:59sometimes it's buttons,
1:01:00sometimes it's got like sliders and scrubbers and things.
1:01:03And then there's a bunch of stuff that's in between,
1:01:06where some of them you look at it and you go,
1:01:08I don't know if this is very useful.
1:01:10And then others you look at and like maps
1:01:13and you're like, whoa, what am I seeing now?
1:01:15I can tap the gas station button now
1:01:19and it'll show me all the gas stations around me.
1:01:21And I think over time, we'll figure out what,
1:01:25philosophically, like what's the right approach?
1:01:27What do people, what looks good
1:01:29and what do people actually wanna use?
1:01:32I found Safaris to be useless.
1:01:34And I have to admit that I didn't spend a lot of time
1:01:38configuring the touch bar in a lot of apps,
1:01:40just because I ran out of time.
1:01:41And I feel like I will, once I'm using a touch bar equipped
1:01:46MacBook Pro as my main laptop, I will get in to do that.
1:01:51But I found Safaris default implementation to be useless,
1:01:55which is that it shows thumbnails of your tabs
1:01:57in your current window.
1:01:59And I mean, maybe daring fireball is identifiable
1:02:03'cause it looks like a gray button,
1:02:05but they just look like a bunch of,
1:02:07almost every webpage just shrunk to that size
1:02:11is indistinguishable.
1:02:13They're just little white with things,
1:02:17little white with gray, it's just too small.
1:02:21I couldn't possibly use that.
1:02:24- I also am a little bit baffled.
1:02:26And I say this also, this is a larger complaint
1:02:29have is they added these tabs, Safari tabs in El Capitan, and I like them and I use them,
1:02:36but they're not on iOS to this day, and they're not in the touch bar, which also kind of baffles
1:02:41me. Like, I've told you I want these sites and they've got these nice little icons and
1:02:47they're important enough that I want you to keep them tabbed all the time.
1:02:50Oh, the pin tabs you mean?
1:02:52Yeah, the pin tabs. They're not accessible either. So it's a little bit... And yeah,
1:02:56graphic that's a great example of like
1:02:59what we can do graphic previews of what
1:03:00of all the pages that you've gotten your
1:03:02tabs and make it a slider it's like well
1:03:04that sounds great that's a really cool
1:03:05way of showing that this is a feature
1:03:09that has more than just buttons in it
1:03:10but in practice I don't think it makes
1:03:13any sense I don't think it works at all
1:03:14I think that that's the there are a
1:03:16bunch of things like that like you know
1:03:17I get why you did it but I honestly got
1:03:20I feel embarrassed that I didn't even
1:03:22look because it maybe I actually you
1:03:24maybe you can actually go in and
1:03:26configure it to do this. But so if it's already there, I'm going
1:03:29to go after we're done recording, I'm going to go set
1:03:32up my my review unit to do this. But I think it should be the
1:03:35default. I in my gut is I think that Safari should just default
1:03:40to putting next tab previous tab buttons up in the don't show me
1:03:45a one just say next tab previous tab and make them nice and big
1:03:48and have them say next tab previous tab. Oh, yeah.
1:03:50No, it's got backward and forward.
1:03:54Yeah, I don't want back one forward. I want next tab, previous tab, because I feel that the
1:03:58shortcuts for that is kind of convoluted. It's like control tab and control shift tab, which is
1:04:04really a fingerful. So you get that with those visual previews. I do wonder, and I suspect that
1:04:11there's a guideline somewhere that I haven't seen because I'm not a developer. I do wonder about
1:04:15the touch bar being used for informational purposes if somebody laid down an edict that,
1:04:20like information that isn't permanent, that's like temporary text, should not go in the touch bar.
1:04:27Because like I'm baffled why the now playing in the control strip brings up a scrubber for iTunes,
1:04:33which is like I'm never going to scrub for music, but it might be kind of fun to if I pop that open
1:04:38to see the name of the song I'm listening to. It's not there. And it won't, it'll show you in Safari,
1:04:43it'll show you little tiny thumbnails of part of the page of the web page that you're, you've got
1:04:47got loaded in your tabs, but what it won't do is put up like the name of that tab of
1:04:53that page, which would be more, way more useful. And I wonder if they've decided like, no,
1:04:59ephemeral kind of like text labels of what's in a page is not something you should do in
1:05:04the touch bar. I'm not sure I agree with that, but it seems like there's a rule at work here
1:05:10that they don't want to put like a text readout. It's only for controls, not for information.
1:05:16even then I would say, but a sliver of, a horizontal sliver of a web page as a
1:05:22preview is useless to me too. I am reminded, and I skimmed the user interface
1:05:33guidelines for the touch bar. I should go back to that and reread them, read them
1:05:37thoroughly. But I can't help but think that no matter how well-written that
1:05:41document is just the evidence of using all of Apple's apps is that it's still
1:05:47sort of a Wild West and they're feeling and now the third-party developers can
1:05:52get in on it we collectively are feeling our way to how we should use it and what
1:05:56I'm reminded of is how in the very early years of the original Mac let's say
1:06:02somewhere around 1984 to 89 or so I would say it took four or five years the
1:06:11The Mac was famous for its human interface guidelines
1:06:14right from the beginning, and that there was consistency
1:06:16and a toolbox that developers could use
1:06:18so everybody's alert would look the same.
1:06:20But you go back and look at screenshots
1:06:22from almost close to the '90s.
1:06:26I'd say right around System 6 is where things
1:06:28got very definitively, oh, that's Mac-like,
1:06:32or this app was clearly written by a developer
1:06:35who does not know the Mac.
1:06:36You just see stupid things.
1:06:38like somebody who spelled OKAY in a button, right?
1:06:43Like to a Mac user's eyes,
1:06:46it just jumps right out as, that's a mistake, right?
1:06:51You do not spell OKAY.
1:06:53But if you look back at like 84, 85, 86, like Mac dialogues,
1:06:57you'd see that all the time.
1:07:00And you are just weird layout,
1:07:02like not having a default button in a dialogue, right?
1:07:06things that you are putting the default button,
1:07:09not in the bottom right corner.
1:07:11Just things that eventually became like,
1:07:13what's the word idiomatic, right?
1:07:18Idiomatic Mac UI design.
1:07:20We don't have that yet.
1:07:21That's the what's an idiomatic design
1:07:24for the touch bar of an app,
1:07:25the touch bar interface for an app.
1:07:27What type of features are, should go in there by default?
1:07:30We don't have it yet.
1:07:31- Yeah, and I'm excited by the fact,
1:07:35I mean, you could argue like maybe Apple's app
1:07:38should show a little more unification than they have,
1:07:41but I'm okay with it the way it is,
1:07:43which is everybody, it looks like,
1:07:45with some rules and restrictions,
1:07:47everybody has tried to develop the right approach
1:07:51for their app and their content and their users
1:07:55and sort of let the chips fall where they may.
1:07:58And I think that's great because I, I mean, right now,
1:08:01I think I could say with certainty that there are apps
1:08:04do it wrong and that do it right. And we can argue about which is which, but like there
1:08:07is such a variation. And maybe it'll turn out that something like what Final Cut does
1:08:15is totally the right way to do it, which is you got sliders and you're intensively using
1:08:20it like the DJ app on stage, right? And maybe, you know, if I had to choose, I would guess
1:08:28that maybe we're going to back off of that and say actually what we saw with DJ in Photoshop,
1:08:33we see with Final Cut Pro is maybe too far, too intense, too much of a UI instead of a
1:08:40set of shortcuts. And maybe we'll back off of it. Maybe not. Maybe it'll turn out that
1:08:45that UI is what people love and having that surface there is the best thing in the world.
1:08:50But my gut feeling is that it's like, that's a big step to go and I'm not sure that it's
1:08:56the right approach. But I'm sure people at Apple were debating it too. And it doesn't
1:08:59have to be one or the other. I mean, right now it isn't. In fact, my biggest criticism of Final
1:09:03Cut is more that it's so complicated that it seems to be not customizable in any way.
1:09:07And that's, for me, the fact that they went back to this classic, like, from 10.0 customized
1:09:14toolbar interface to let people customize the touch bar, I really like that because
1:09:19it should be personal. You should be putting the stuff on it that you care about the most.
1:09:24And I don't know how many people do that, but I'm glad that that's there and that it is customizable.
1:09:28I worried that it wasn't. I mean, the next step should probably be to make the
1:09:32let third parties have access to the control strip, but one thing at a time.
1:09:35Yeah, and I really like it just feels so Mac-like
1:09:39in terms of the way that the customization feels exactly like
1:09:46customizing the toolbar in a window in a cocoa app. It's,
1:09:50you know, and that's, you know, it's by design and it's no surprise, but it
1:09:53really just goes to show that the people who wrote these
1:09:56APIs are, you know, knew what they were doing and they did it the right way.
1:10:01Yeah, and I, you know, I always say when they show these things on stage and people ask afterward,
1:10:07I'm sure they do the same to you, like, "Well, what did you think?" A lot of it's like, "Well,
1:10:11it looked good. Let's see what the details are." And when I first customized the toolbar,
1:10:15I was like, "Oh, wow. Okay, good." Like, they did a really good job. Like, I had this whole
1:10:20worry about how do you use like you move the cursor to the bottom of the screen and it like
1:10:27disappears and suddenly you get a selection in a toolbar but you in the touch bar but you don't
1:10:32see your cursor anymore but it's still sort of there as a ghost and you can move it around and
1:10:37then if you move it back up it pops back out on the bottom of your display i'm like that's weird
1:10:42how are they going to do that and when i used it i was like oh it makes perfect sense like they
1:10:45nailed it. They really did figure out a way to do it where you never feel like suddenly your pointing
1:10:51device has gone into a different parallel universe and nothing makes sense anymore. Like it all held
1:10:57together and I'm impressed by the kind of care that they took with that stuff. It's a little thing
1:11:03but I appreciate, so when you go into editing mode the buttons that are there jiggle. It's a little
1:11:10similar to, you know, very similar and clearly drawn from the home screen
1:11:16customization in iOS, where if you want to move your apps around in iOS, you know,
1:11:21you hold the home button and you go into the mode and all your apps jiggle. It's a
1:11:27good way of playing off something people are familiar with. I feel like that
1:11:33idea, that if you're gonna put them in reorder mode, make them, you know, jiggle
1:11:37around. But what I really like is that to me, I think it feels just slightly more of
1:11:44a serious jiggle than the iOS jiggle. Like the iOS one is a move more or less in a goofy
1:11:51way.
1:11:52They kind of twist.
1:11:53Yeah, they twist. And the Mac ones just kind of go back and forth. And now maybe part of
1:11:58that is that it's just horizontal. But I think they could have made them twist if they wanted
1:12:02to even if it made the corners go off the top.
1:12:06It just feels more appropriate to the Mac
1:12:09in a way that the Mac is a more serious platform than iOS.
1:12:14- I do like the personality.
1:12:16I mean, that's one of the things I said in my review
1:12:18that you quoted.
1:12:19I always had the moment of like,
1:12:21if Jon links to me, what part will he quote?
1:12:24And that one was, it's just reporting a true feeling I had,
1:12:29which is this has more personality than I thought it would.
1:12:32Like, it has a lot of animations.
1:12:34I think if you just read about this feature,
1:12:37you would not imagine that everything animates.
1:12:41And like the touch ID sensor, when it comes on,
1:12:44there is this arrow, and the arrow like stretches
1:12:47like it's made of rubber as it points at the touch ID sensor
1:12:51and it is, I mean, it's not wacky, but it is whimsical
1:12:56in a way that it totally didn't need to be.
1:12:59And there's just little stuff like that,
1:13:01that I think, you know, there is personality here.
1:13:04It isn't just this kind of gray,
1:13:06we gave you a toolbar, enjoy.
1:13:08It's like a little bit more enthusiastic
1:13:11and I like that it's got personality.
1:13:13- It's a Mac-like whimsicalness though,
1:13:16that touch here to log in with touch ID
1:13:20and the arrow stretching,
1:13:23that to me feels right for the Mac
1:13:26and it should be if they did something similar on iOS,
1:13:30it would be more whimsical and appropriately so.
1:13:32- Mm-hmm.
1:13:33Yeah, I think that's right.
1:13:35- Horace, I quoted this thing that Horace did you wrote
1:13:38a week or two ago, where he wrote a piece about,
1:13:43let's see if I can find it here.
1:13:45- I love that piece.
1:13:48- I did too, but where's Apple going with the Macintosh?
1:13:51And an analogy about why isn't the Mac a touchscreen?
1:13:56And I'll put the link again in the show notes
1:14:00anybody who hasn't read it can do it. Wherefore art thou, Macintosh? But he wrote, let's see
1:14:07if I can find the quote.
1:14:10"It cannot take on the role of being the future." He's talking about the Mac. That
1:14:18belongs to the touchscreen devices. "It will not morph into a touchscreen device
1:14:22any more than a tech, a teen's parent will become cool by putting on skinny
1:14:27genes. What it will do is become better at what it is hired to do. I'll put a link in the show notes.
1:14:34It says I promise I'm doing it right now. I'm copying and pasting. I'm so infamous for saying
1:14:38I'll put something in the show notes and not doing it. Here it is. Copy, paste. There it is.
1:14:43- Very well done. It's great. I mean, I wrote a piece about the same time called like parallel
1:14:49or perpendicular philosophies. And it's the same thing. It's like, why does Microsoft
1:14:54insist on doing these touch screen things and everybody's like, "Oh God, I can't believe
1:14:57Apple's not doing them." It's like, well, number one reason is Apple already has a touch screen OS,
1:15:01so what Apple's doing is differentiating. They're saying, and this can be hard for Mac users to hear,
1:15:05although I don't mind it, it's like the Mac is like the classic computing metaphor that Apple
1:15:11makes, and you can't push it too far because it becomes an iPad or an iPhone then, and they've
1:15:16already got that. Like, they don't need to do a touch screen tablet, like they have a touch screen
1:15:21tablet already. So the Mac has to be defined by some fundamental premises and
1:15:29Apple and again you could debate it and say no no no Microsoft's doing the right
1:15:34thing but what Apple has decided and they've done this again again they've
1:15:37set it publicly repeatedly is the Mac is for traditional computing with a
1:15:42pointing device and in the case of a laptop it's very clear it's two
1:15:46perpendicular surfaces but it's even true on the desktop. You've got your
1:15:49keyboard tray or the bottom of your laptop and that's the control surface
1:15:53and it's got the keys and it's got the touch bar maybe and it's got the track
1:15:56pad and then you got the screen and this stuff happens on the screen and you
1:16:00control it from the from the perpendicular surface that's in front of
1:16:04you and if you would rather directly manipulate with your hands that's fine
1:16:07that's not what a Mac is Mac's aren't for that yeah I this adult with you know
1:16:13becoming it cool by putting on skinny jeans is the best it's the best metaphor
1:16:19I've seen, because I didn't think of it. He did, but I love it. And to me, the way that
1:16:28Apple has adopted some of these things, like the animation for that arrow, is exactly the same way,
1:16:33where it's not trying to be iOS. It's not trying to be, you know, it's doing it in a Macintosh way.
1:16:39And I have to say, personally, on the flip side, I got to spend, I spent like half an hour in a
1:16:44Microsoft store when I was in San Francisco last month for the Apple event, and they had
1:16:48the new Surface, I don't know what they call it, Surface Studio? Yeah, Surface Studio.
1:16:54Had a couple of them set up and a whole bunch of apps like Photoshop and stuff and there wasn't,
1:17:01you know, it wasn't that crowded. They're actually, I'm not making fun of them for
1:17:07having stores that aren't crowded. There was actually a line for people to try out the VR
1:17:11thing they had set up. So there was a thing there that was drawing a crowd of, it seemed to me like
1:17:17like at least 10 people at a time,
1:17:18constantly waiting to try the VR thing.
1:17:21So there is something there that is drawing people
1:17:22in the store, but the surface wasn't.
1:17:26So I got to play with it.
1:17:27And old person trying to dress like a teenager
1:17:31is exactly, it's better than anything I could say.
1:17:34I had other complaints about the latency
1:17:36compared to the Apple Pencil on iPad.
1:17:39It was low latency.
1:17:39I mean, Microsoft definitely did some work on that,
1:17:42but it was not like Apple Pencil.
1:17:45But the weirdest part was the way that just exactly what you would think, like having
1:17:50a mouse-based interface but then using touch and a pencil to do things was weird, like
1:17:55where all of a sudden as your pencil gets near, you see a cursor on screen right beneath
1:17:58it and it's like, "Ugh, weird."
1:18:00I feel like I'm using—it's not that much better than one of those airport terminals
1:18:06where you get your boarding pass and every time you touch the screen, the Windows mouse
1:18:09cursor moves to where you touch it.
1:18:13It just feels like old person dressing like a teenager.
1:18:16Is exact, I can't think of anything better than that.
1:18:19And it would just break my heart
1:18:21to see Apple do that to the Mac.
1:18:24- I guess the one thing that,
1:18:26if I extended to Horace's metaphor a little bit is,
1:18:30it is possible for something theoretically,
1:18:33for something like Windows to have a,
1:18:35like a chrysalis and like turn into a teenager, right?
1:18:38I mean, they could evolve Windows
1:18:40to the point where it is a touch interface.
1:18:42The problem is, they've got everybody who's using Windows PCs, and they don't want to,
1:18:47you know, they don't have a, they tried it, right?
1:18:49They tried it with Metro and with their ARM-based stuff, and in the end, they retreated back
1:18:57to the power of their successful Windows platform, and they've made it better, but like, they
1:19:01have one operating system, and they can change the context, but it's one operating system,
1:19:05and there are challenges with that.
1:19:07I don't, you know, it's not that they're not unsolvable, they may be solvable, but it's like,
1:19:13I'm not saying that fundamentally Microsoft is right or wrong or Apple is right or wrong,
1:19:20but if you look at what the assets of both companies are, Microsoft has this incredibly
1:19:25successful desktop operating system, traditional computer operating system, and they haven't done
1:19:30anything in mobile. So what do you do to get to approach sort of like the mobile world and the
1:19:36the touch-based world. You gotta take Windows and you gotta jam it in there. And if you're
1:19:40Apple, you got the Mac, you got iOS, they're fine. You don't need to do that. So they're
1:19:44not gonna do that. And so when people say, you know, one of them is right and one of
1:19:48them is wrong, that may well be, I'm not quite sure it's that clear. I think it may
1:19:53be a much more kind of shades of gray situation, depends on your use cases, and who knows where
1:19:57we'll be in five or 10 years. But I would argue both companies are doing what makes
1:20:02sense for them because you know Microsoft has the assets it has and
1:20:06Apple is very, Apple is extremely fortunate. In fact they're basically the
1:20:11only company in the world who has a very successful touch-based operating system
1:20:16and a traditional computer operating system and so they don't need to jam
1:20:19them together. They can just keep them apart and everybody like us who's like I
1:20:22love the Mac I want to keep using the Mac, they're not gonna make a Mac that's
1:20:25totally unrecognizable because at that point why wouldn't you just use a PC or
1:20:29or switch and use an iPad.
1:20:31So Apple has the luxury of doing that,
1:20:34and it makes perfect sense that that's what they're doing.
1:20:37- Yeah, I also will say that I found Windows 10
1:20:39running on the Surface, what's it called again?
1:20:42- The Studio. - Studio, Surface Studio.
1:20:45I was very lost and confused,
1:20:49just going between apps and navigating the system,
1:20:52and I honestly found it confusing.
1:20:56And part of it is just that I haven't used Windows regularly
1:20:59in over a decade.
1:21:00- Yeah. - But--
1:21:02- And it's very, all my Windows skills
1:21:04were really good up to a point,
1:21:05and then they, Windows has evolved enough now,
1:21:07'cause I've got Windows 10 on my iMac and Bootcamp,
1:21:09and Windows has evolved to the point
1:21:12where all my old Windows skills, which were pretty good,
1:21:15are just useless now.
1:21:16I have no idea what I'm looking at.
1:21:18So that doesn't help matters.
1:21:20- But I will say that I've spent time a few years ago
1:21:23with like Windows original surfaces,
1:21:24and I didn't find those confusing at all.
1:21:27Now, I didn't really love the whole idea
1:21:28where you can go into traditional Windows mouse pointer
1:21:31mode and run your traditional Windows software,
1:21:34and you go into this other mode, the Metro mode,
1:21:38and it's all touch-based.
1:21:39But I got it, because the Metro thing was clear,
1:21:42like, oh, these are big, chunky touch targets.
1:21:45And instead of tiled windows, they're
1:21:48going on more of a 2D thing, and you swipe side to side.
1:21:53And this is all new, and everything is big.
1:21:56and big thumb-sizable touch targets.
1:21:59Oh, and if I want to run my Microsoft Excel,
1:22:02I switch to this other mode,
1:22:03and it looks exactly like Excel.
1:22:05I know exactly where I am.
1:22:06- Yeah, plug in a mouse.
1:22:07- Right.
1:22:08I guess I can see why they went away from that
1:22:10and why people rejected it,
1:22:12but it made way more sense to me to go that way.
1:22:16And I think part of it was, under Stanofsky,
1:22:19they clearly wanted to,
1:22:21'cause they had the ARM-based Surface tablets
1:22:24that only had the Metro mode.
1:22:26And I really feel like that's where some of them,
1:22:29the ones who have good taste in Microsoft wanted to go,
1:22:32like good taste in the Apple sense.
1:22:34And it was a much, to me, a much more compelling device.
1:22:37And I think it only failed
1:22:38because it didn't get developer support.
1:22:40That developers kept writing the old classic,
1:22:43Windows Win 32 API apps.
1:22:46- So I was at the D conference when they did that demo
1:22:49for the first time.
1:22:50And I remember seeing all the Metro stuff and thinking,
1:22:53with the original Surface and thinking,
1:22:55"Damn, that is really good.
1:22:57"Here comes Microsoft.
1:22:58"Everybody watch out."
1:22:59And then they did that moment where they're like,
1:23:01"And if you wanna run Office,"
1:23:02instead of showing what I expected to see,
1:23:04which was like a demo of a touch-based Office,
1:23:07like Office or iPad is today.
1:23:09And they were like, "Boom, now you're in the Windows desktop
1:23:13"and you plug in a mouse and a keyboard and you have a PC."
1:23:17And I thought, "No, no, no, no, no, no."
1:23:18I remember, you know what?
1:23:19I wrote a piece, you wrote a piece about it.
1:23:21We were talking about it.
1:23:22And it was like, "No, no, you're so close."
1:23:24And I still believe like the right thing to do
1:23:27was for Microsoft to say,
1:23:29we have taken all our knowledge of Windows
1:23:31and we have built a touch-based operating system
1:23:33that will, you know, it's related.
1:23:35And if Steve Ballmer wants to call it Windows something,
1:23:37we'll call it that, but it's different.
1:23:39And the Windows RT was like that,
1:23:41but it was like already compromised and half-hearted.
1:23:44Like they'd already kind of sold it out.
1:23:46That all said, given the strength of Apple and Google
1:23:50in mobile operating systems,
1:23:52and what has happened with all of Microsoft's attempts to make just a mobile operating system,
1:23:56I'm not really convinced now that even if they had done what I think would have been
1:24:01the best product, that anybody would have bought it. Because they would have been selling,
1:24:05they couldn't have leveraged any of their, or much of their strength, which was Windows,
1:24:10to get people on board. So they'd be starting from scratch like they did with Windows Phone.
1:24:15And so, you know, I think it would have been a way better product, but I feel like by the
1:24:20the time they got to Metro and making that demo,
1:24:23the ship had kind of sailed already.
1:24:26- I think it was the right thing--
1:24:27- Which is too bad, 'cause it was cool.
1:24:28- Yeah, I think it was the right thing to do
1:24:30from a design perspective, but it was not going to work
1:24:35from a market perspective.
1:24:37It just wasn't going to gain traction.
1:24:39I don't know that there's anything they could have done
1:24:41to make Metro better, just better in terms of
1:24:44if we had done a better job designing it,
1:24:46if we'd done a better job making the initial set of apps,
1:24:49it would have succeeded.
1:24:50I don't think it failed because it wasn't good enough.
1:24:54I think it failed for other reasons.
1:24:56- Yeah, yeah, and it's tough
1:24:59'cause you look at Microsoft and, you know,
1:25:01Microsoft's ambition was that
1:25:04of a dominant operating system vendor,
1:25:06but their position was that of a newcomer, essentially,
1:25:10because, you know, Android and iOS gobbled that market up
1:25:15very quickly and they were left kind of with
1:25:18not a whole lot.
1:25:19like they were there in the in the Blackberry camp down and also receiving
1:25:23votes were these people with 5% of the market and that's tough that's a tough
1:25:26position to be in I don't you know I love a lot of what Microsoft's doing now
1:25:31but it's a it's still a tough position to be in because they do need to be
1:25:34Windows and try to innovate and you know I know a lot of people especially
1:25:39creative people people who use pen input all the time on their Mac with a with a
1:25:45tablet and all that people who really kind of going ape over the over the
1:25:49surface studio and I'm not one of those people so it didn't really thrill me and
1:25:56in fact when I looked at it I thought I would much I think I would much rather
1:25:59have a desktop iPad yeah but I will say this I that I if you draw for a living I
1:26:09don't know if you draw comics if you are an architect or something like that I
1:26:13I can totally see how the Surface tablet is a device for you, but I don't see any reason
1:26:18to like that device if you're not someone who makes a living with a pen in your hand.
1:26:24The funny thing, and this is part of the people coming back to people being grumpy with Apple
1:26:29about various things, it's like one of the things I've seen, it's like, yeah, if you're
1:26:32a cartoonist or a comic book artist or anybody who is using these certain kind of inputs,
1:26:38is going to be a class of user for whom the Surface Studio is the perfect computer. And
1:26:43you know what? A lot of those people are going to be loyal Mac users, and they're going to
1:26:47feel torn, and they're going to feel like Apple has let them down a little bit because
1:26:51Apple isn't providing them with that same kind of product. And all of those feelings
1:26:56are valid, but I would also say it's also valid for Apple to say, "We're never going
1:27:00to make a product like that." Like that is not... How big a market is that? How many
1:27:05surface studios are going to sell right i mean it's a cool product that will be
1:27:09perfect for a very specific group of people
1:27:11and they should love it because you know because it's it's made for them and
1:27:15it's brilliant for them but i'm not sure that i can see the logic
1:27:18of apple like making their next iMac like a surface studio it just doesn't
1:27:22make sense to me. I could see not in the very near future not within the next
1:27:26handful of years but i could see within 10 years i could see apple having
1:27:31a 30-inch iOS device.
1:27:33Oh, I agree. I mean, that's the… at some point, I was talking to somebody about it,
1:27:39and that's what I said, is it's way more likely that Apple makes a giant iPad than
1:27:43they make a touchscreen Mac on your desk. Like, way more likely.
1:27:46Way more likely. So much more likely that, you know… says the guy… says the guy who
1:27:53thought Hillary Clinton was locked to win.
1:27:56Yeah, that's right.
1:27:57But it just--
1:27:58I do think it's--
1:27:59Are you the guy from Princeton who said it was a 99%?
1:28:02Or are you Nate Silver who said it was two to one odds?
1:28:05Because that makes the difference there.
1:28:07Oh, I woke up loving that guy from Princeton.
1:28:10And I woke up the next day wanting to have a talk with him.
1:28:16He wrote a blog post.
1:28:17And it's just kind of hilarious.
1:28:18Because it's like, dude, you said greater than 99%
1:28:20probability.
1:28:20I don't think you know how probability works.
1:28:23And that was Nate Silver.
1:28:24People were really ragging on Nate Silver about it.
1:28:25not to get too much into the election,
1:28:27but it's like Nate Silver all along,
1:28:28he got crap from so many people
1:28:30saying Donald Trump had a chance.
1:28:32And he's like, "Look, if we miss our numbers up,
1:28:34"then she's gonna have a sweep.
1:28:37"But if the polls are all off 2% down,"
1:28:40which by less than they were off for Obama-Romney,
1:28:43which was off by 3%,
1:28:45if they're off in Trump's favor by 2%,
1:28:48he's gonna win in the electoral college.
1:28:50He said that days before the election,
1:28:52and that's what happened. - And they were off by 2%.
1:28:55Yeah, so it was totally within that cone of probability.
1:28:59The final polls nationwide had her up 3%,
1:29:01and she wound up winning the popular vote by 1%, which--
1:29:04By 1%.
1:29:05And it was not, please don't email me.
1:29:07I know, I'm not arguing.
1:29:08That means she should be president.
1:29:09I know the rules.
1:29:10The idea, though, is that if a candidate, especially
1:29:13a Democrat, only wins--
1:29:14because of the electoral college--
1:29:16only wins the popular vote by 1%,
1:29:18that there is a very high probability
1:29:20that the Republican candidate will
1:29:22win the electoral college.
1:29:23And that is exactly what will happen.
1:29:25Yes, and it--
1:29:26This year.
1:29:26In 2012, Silver said that it was actually in Obama's favor.
1:29:31The way the states were stacking up,
1:29:32he could have lost the popular vote by half a percent
1:29:34or something, and he would have won the electoral college.
1:29:36But for this election, the way it stacked up--
1:29:40and they factored in.
1:29:41For weeks before, you can go back and look,
1:29:43they had an 8%, 10%, 12% chance that Trump
1:29:46would lose the popular vote and win the electoral college.
1:29:49And so probabilities are hard.
1:29:52It's hard for people to understand them.
1:29:53The New York Times had that field goal the whole time.
1:29:56That was one of my thoughts on election night was like,
1:29:58I guess she missed the field goal.
1:30:00(laughing)
1:30:01It's a 30, any NFL fan when they say her chances
1:30:04are like making a 38 yard field goal in the NFL.
1:30:08It's like, you know what?
1:30:08People miss it 38 yard field goals all the time.
1:30:10- Ask Buffalo Bills fans.
1:30:11- Yeah, yeah, it happens.
1:30:15- Let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor.
1:30:16It is one of our best friends of the show.
1:30:19It's Harry's.
1:30:20Harry's makes shaving products.
1:30:24They make them themselves.
1:30:25They're terrific.
1:30:27Big razor companies-- I'm not going to name names.
1:30:29I'm not going to name the--
1:30:30Gillette, Schick.
1:30:32They have this annoying habit of putting out new models,
1:30:35you know, Mach 7, whatever the hell they call the new thing.
1:30:38And what they do every time they put out a new model
1:30:40is they raise their already high prices.
1:30:43Unlike those guys, Harry's doesn't want to upcharge.
1:30:46They're going for low prices.
1:30:48That's why they made their razors even better.
1:30:50They have just upgraded their whole line of razors
1:30:53and handles, and they're keeping the prices exactly the same.
1:30:58They're not just putting in a new line
1:30:59to make you feel like, well, now I
1:31:00have to spend more to get more.
1:31:01No, you pay the same prices that they already
1:31:03had, which were already lower than the national big brands,
1:31:09and they've improved everything.
1:31:10Their five blade razors now include softer flex hinge
1:31:14for a more comfortable glide.
1:31:16They now include a trimmer blade for hard to reach places,
1:31:20which I think for most men at least
1:31:21is like that little area right under your nose.
1:31:24A lubricating strip and a textured handle
1:31:28for more control when it's wet.
1:31:30They sent me one and I have to say I love my old one.
1:31:32I've had it for years.
1:31:33I mean, I've had it since Harry started sponsoring my show,
1:31:36which was like, I think around 20 years ago it feels like.
1:31:39And when I put the old one away, here's the thing,
1:31:41it still looks brand new, which is bizarre.
1:31:45Their stuff is built to last.
1:31:46But the new one, the textured handle, it's clearly better.
1:31:49Instant upgrade, no problem.
1:31:51And it's still just $2 per blade compared to $4 or more
1:31:56that you'll pay at the drugstore for brands like Gillette.
1:32:00They own their own factory in Germany where they make blades.
1:32:02They don't just buy like cut rate blades
1:32:05on some kind of open market and then just slap
1:32:07a Harry's label on them.
1:32:08They have their own razor blade factory in Germany
1:32:11where they make these blades.
1:32:13And then they can keep the prices low
1:32:14because they sell them direct to you.
1:32:18Harry's is so confident in the quality of their blades.
1:32:22They'll send you their popular free trial set,
1:32:25which comes with a razor, five blade cartridge, and shaving
1:32:29gel.
1:32:31It's free when you sign up for a shave plan.
1:32:33All you do is pay shipping.
1:32:34Plus, there's a special offer for fans of the talk show.
1:32:41Get a bottle of Harry's Post Shave Bomb added to your order for free when you visit harrys.com
1:32:49and use the code "talk show".
1:32:51No "the", just "talk show" at checkout.
1:32:54You will get a free bottle of their Post Shave Bomb.
1:32:56It's good stuff, smells good, feels good.
1:32:58I've got it.
1:32:59It's really, really nice stuff.
1:33:01So go to harrys.com right now and use "talk show" at checkout to claim your free trial
1:33:07set and post-shave bomb, which is better than the deal you get from most other podcasts.
1:33:11So remember that. That's harrys.com/code/talkshow.
1:33:18You talked about the control strip before we move on to other things. But do you remember—I
1:33:22mean, this is the stupidest question I'm ever going to ask. Do you remember the control
1:33:26strip classic Mac OS?
1:33:29Do I remember the control strip? Yeah, I actually booted up an emulator the other day to look
1:33:36at it to just remind myself. But God, I had that on my PowerBook. I don't know if you
1:33:41remember like CPU, Connectix, PowerBook utilities, which like added items to the control strip.
1:33:45Oh, I loved it. Yes. Yeah, totally loved it.
1:33:48Right? I mean, that was like the dock of its day to put in context to people who are modern
1:33:53Mac users. Yeah.
1:33:54It was better.
1:33:55But to me, it was one of the things, I mean, famously, or maybe not famously because I
1:33:59was maybe more obscure, but the first like three, four years at Daring Fireball is mostly
1:34:02me bitching about Mac OS X in the ways that the interface is not as good as the classic
1:34:07Mac OS.
1:34:08And Control Strip is one of those things where it was so perfectly Mac-like.
1:34:13Every pixel of it was perfectly of the way that things were supposed to look in that
1:34:19OS.
1:34:20And just everything, the close button, the little zipper thing that you would just tap
1:34:26to make it expand and contract.
1:34:30Just everything about it was so nice.
1:34:32And it was so elegant.
1:34:34And it felt so right for the Mac system-wide
1:34:36that you just have this little thing.
1:34:38And then eventually you could drag it around to any corner.
1:34:41Did it have to be in a corner?
1:34:42I think it had to be in a corner, right?
1:34:44No, it could be anywhere along either side.
1:34:47Anywhere along the left or right.
1:34:48And you'd zip it open, and you'd get all these little icons.
1:34:51And they opened it up to third parties.
1:34:53And third parties did some really useful stuff.
1:34:57And the Mac OS X equivalent of it
1:35:01is all these little turd icons in the top right of our menu
1:35:04bars.
1:35:05The toolbar or the menu bar.
1:35:06Yeah, the menu bar.
1:35:07We've still got them.
1:35:08All those little icons up there.
1:35:09In the old Mac OS, those would all be Control Strip items.
1:35:13And your menu bar would only have menus.
1:35:16And then anything else would be in a Control Strip,
1:35:18which was really nice.
1:35:21It bothers me to no end. 15 years later that we don't we don't we had something so elegant as the
1:35:29control strip and now we've put all these turds in our menu bars. I wonder if bartender
1:35:36does bartender let you put their bar anywhere? I wonder about that like because bartender is
1:35:43kind of like that where you can actually pull things out of the menu bar and put them in the
1:35:45little bartender bar and I wonder if you can you can yeah you can I think you can move it around
1:35:51Hmm. I should look at that. I looked at Bartender, I remember looking at it years ago, and for some reason
1:35:56rejected it, but maybe I should take another look.
1:35:59Yeah, I don't know. It's not, I mean, it's kind of hacky, although it's got some things going for it.
1:36:06I use it to clean up my menu bar because there's some items that I don't need to see most of the time,
1:36:09but I occasionally need to get to it. But it's in the ballpark, right? And the idea there is, could you imagine
1:36:14pulling all of the stuff off the menu bar and putting it in this little bar that you dock somewhere else,
1:36:20or you pop up somewhere else.
1:36:22And yeah, we just, I think the answer is screen real estate
1:36:25is that in the control strip was designed
1:36:28to be very small when collapsed,
1:36:30and then you'd pop it open to get to the UI
1:36:33and it floated above everything.
1:36:35And then you'd turn off Apple Talk
1:36:36or do whatever you need to do,
1:36:37or connect via PPP to the internet,
1:36:41or dial in with your modem.
1:36:43And then you snap it closed
1:36:45and it just is this little tiny thing in the corner,
1:36:48and then you're done.
1:36:49And now we've got these huge monitors and they're just littered with menu bar items
1:36:52at the top. But yeah, Control Strip was great. It was an unsung hero of the sort of latter-day
1:36:58classic Mac OS. Yeah, it really was. And I'm so... I think it started on laptops too,
1:37:02and then it was so popular they brought it to the desktop, to every computer,
1:37:07even though it started on PowerBooks. I haven't... I wish that I'd asked while I was talking to
1:37:11people from Apple, but I can't help but think that they named the new thing the Control Strip,
1:37:15That it's not a coincidence that it's you know
1:37:17Built by people who remember the old one because it's so similar in concept the way it zips open from the side
1:37:23uh
1:37:25I mentioned it to them. I was like, oh that's a familiar name and they're like, yeah, we knew we knew uh,
1:37:29You know some of you guys would notice that we reused the name. Um, and you know, it's it's uh,
1:37:34It's a cute reference. Like I think that's what they were going for was those in the know
1:37:38You know apple's aware of all these things that it has the intellectual, you know property in the trademark four
1:37:44and that was a name that they had and it was doing a similar job and so they used it.
1:37:48Yeah and it just has similar character you know just the way that it animates
1:37:51soup soup oh it's so nice. Yep.
1:37:56Anything else on the MacBook Pros? I have one I guess broad topic about it
1:38:02but anything you want to talk about with the new MacBook Pros?
1:38:06I don't know I mean it's the other big thing about them well I mean we
1:38:12We mentioned TouchBar, we mentioned Touch ID.
1:38:14The other big thing about them is the ports.
1:38:16And I feel sort of talked out about it
1:38:19'cause we've been talking about it
1:38:20since the MacBook came out a year ago
1:38:22and almost two years ago now.
1:38:24And certainly in the last month since the Apple event.
1:38:29And I'm kind of over it.
1:38:30Like it's a port transition.
1:38:32It stinks, everybody knows it stinks.
1:38:34Everybody buys adapters.
1:38:36There's a period where everybody's got the adapters
1:38:38and has old hardware and then eventually it goes away.
1:38:41And I think USB-C and Thunderbolt 3 is like a good direction to go.
1:38:45And the only way you get there is by going through a transition.
1:38:47So here we are.
1:38:48And, you know, I, I don't know if.
1:38:51I I'm, I, I'm kind of drained of outrage for something like that, because I do
1:38:57think it's superior in almost every way.
1:38:59Every time I try to plug something into the back of my iMac and get the USB
1:39:03orientation wrong and have to flip it over and peer into the port to make sure
1:39:07that I'm doing it right, I think, well,
1:39:09USB-C and Thunderbolt 3 solve this, this is dumb.
1:39:13And so, you know, I get people complaining about it
1:39:18and they're right to complain about it,
1:39:19but at the same time, I feel like in the long run,
1:39:22it's gonna be great and I'm gonna miss MagSafe, I will,
1:39:27but at the same time, I think it's also cool that you can,
1:39:31on the touch bar models,
1:39:32you can plug in your Mac on either side.
1:39:34- That is great, that is so great.
1:39:36It's so many-- there are so many times where it's--
1:39:41the worst is when you're far enough away from the power
1:39:44where it would fit to the right but not the left.
1:39:47It's just at the--
1:39:48but then there's just other times
1:39:49where you just don't want to have to drape it
1:39:51around the outside, where it just is inelegant.
1:39:55I mean, one case for me as an East Coaster
1:39:59is sometimes if you're on the Acela on the East Coast
1:40:03train, the Amtrak Acela, you can get, there's some really cool seats that have a table in between
1:40:09them, but you're facing people on the other side. And the tables are relatively, as you might expect,
1:40:14they're, it's not a very wide table. You know, you're pretty close, but you have enough space
1:40:19where two people back to back can, you know, put their laptops, you know, fair, you know, easily.
1:40:26But if you want to stretch the power around the other side, it's, you know, you can do it, but it,
1:40:31it would be so much easier if you could always just plug it in on the side closest to the wall.
1:40:36Yeah, yeah, so it's, again, I get people's complaints about it. Maybe I'm just a little
1:40:43jaded because I've seen it all before. It's like, yes, everybody will complain, yes, it will be a
1:40:48pain, yes, we will need adapters, then we'll get over it, and then in a few years we'll look back
1:40:52and think, wow, I can't believe that we used that stuff. This stuff is so much better. I linked to
1:40:57a couple of examples from like the four years ago MacBook Pros and they it was so uncanny how the
1:41:04almost word for word you didn't even have to like edit out like you know one you know the name of
1:41:09the port they would just be like you know not enough ports too thin you know they're exactly
1:41:15word for word what people are saying about these I also believe I've written about this too but I
1:41:20And I believe firmly that Apple's aggressive traditional,
1:41:25not just in this case with the going all USB-C Thunderbolt 3,
1:41:30but that they've done this so many times in the past
1:41:33that it brings about the future where being all USB-C is fine
1:41:40sooner than if they had stuck a couple of legacy ports
1:41:43on the devices.
1:41:45If they'd put an old school USB and one old Thunderbolt
1:41:50or something like that.
1:41:52And I firmly-- I can't prove it.
1:41:54There is no way to prove it without the ability
1:41:57to fork the universe.
1:42:00But in the alternate universe, where these new MacBook Pros
1:42:03have a USB port and a Thunderbolt port--
1:42:06I don't know what other ports people still wish they had,
1:42:09but--
1:42:10or a SD card reader or something like that.
1:42:14I really believe that two or three years ago,
1:42:17it's less of a USB-C everywhere world.
1:42:21- Oh, sure.
1:42:23I mean, I think it's only a matter of degrees
1:42:26because I think you made this point on "Daring Fireball,"
1:42:29which is if you have legacy ports,
1:42:31you have no motivation to switch
1:42:34because you can just keep using your legacy ports.
1:42:35But once you've switched
1:42:36and you have no more of the old ports,
1:42:39then there's no longer any point
1:42:41in buying anything using the old ports
1:42:43and you move to the new ports and then you move on.
1:42:45And the longer you leave the bridge,
1:42:48and Apple's done that in the past
1:42:49where they've left the bridges
1:42:50and they've done it where they've ripped the bandaid off.
1:42:52And this time they decided to rip the bandaid off
1:42:56and I'm okay with it.
1:42:58In fact, the people that I have the most sympathy for
1:43:01are probably like the photographers and videographers
1:43:04who use that SD card slot.
1:43:06And I totally get why it is a pain to have to go
1:43:09from having no reader to having a reader.
1:43:12somebody who used an 11-inch air, I didn't have a slot. I already felt that pain, but I get it.
1:43:20I totally get it. Yeah, I get that one too. I do get it, and it speaks to how useful the built-in
1:43:26SD slot is to serious photographers that Apple did it ever in the first place, because it's the
1:43:33least Apple-y thing that they've done in a long time. It is. Yeah, it's like since they put S
1:43:41video on the Macintosh TV. It's like, why is this port here?
1:43:44Right. It has to be if it's so unred... Really, the SD card slot on Macs is the return of the
1:43:52floppy drive. I mean, it's way, you know, thousands of times faster and thousands of
1:43:57times more storage, but it's, you know, it's the floppy drive. It is the least Apple-y thing.
1:44:05I know. So the fact that it's so useful is the reason they did it in the first place.
1:44:09But the fact that they removed it is the reason why, you know, Apple was the first company to remove the floppy drive.
1:44:16Right. Although, I mean, I just bought, um, for experimenting for like podcasting stuff, I bought
1:44:22an SD card that does wi-fi. It's not the iFi. It's a Toshiba, I think, one. And it's pretty good.
1:44:30You know, it's again not perfect, but I can see Apple's philosophy here, too, of saying, you know,
1:44:36you can get a card reader, and then there are also new wireless technologies in the SD cards,
1:44:41in the cameras. There are other ways to transfer this stuff. Or you bring a cable and attach your
1:44:48camera direct. But I get it. I get why that's a major inconvenience, because that was their
1:44:56storage medium of choice, and it had a reader built in, and now it's gone. I totally get it.
1:45:03That said though, there's still a fair number. I realize SD is the most popular size, but there's
1:45:07still a fair number of people shooting on cannons that shoot the CF card. And there's other cameras
1:45:15that use the super micro, almost like sim card size SD card. Right, the super tiny one. Yeah.
1:45:21And then with them, you have to bring and adapt. Usually, I think most people probably use, there's
1:45:26SD, standard SD card size adapters that you slide it in and then you put in. So you're still,
1:45:31You know, it wasn't an ideal world, and I feel like the world where
1:45:35everything just works wirelessly and you can very, very quickly
1:45:39airdrop things, equivalent of airdrop, whether it's actually official airdrop or
1:45:43not, but just, you know, plop a thing from your standalone
1:45:46camera to your MacBook. It's going to come quicker
1:45:48now that the SD card is not in Macintosh's.
1:45:53Yeah, I think that's true, but I think maybe there'll be a little longer
1:45:58of a pain. The pain transition will be a little different there than for like USB stuff, but
1:46:03I just think back to like, you know, the iMac throwout, serial ADB and SCSI all in one throw
1:46:09for USB, and this is a little bit like that. I guess the last thing I want to talk about is
1:46:16the people arguing that these aren't pro devices, that okay, it's nice enough, but it's not a pro
1:46:24device because it's not the fastest Intel mobile chipset. It's not the one that, I don't
1:46:34want to get into the details, but Apple wants to use the low energy RAM and by wanting to
1:46:40use the low energy RAM, they're limited to 16 gigabytes right now. That's going to change
1:46:46soon enough. I would bet in 2017 there will be an update to the MacBook Pros that support
1:46:51at least 32 gigabytes of RAM.
1:46:53I don't know if it could go to 64, but it would be at least 32.
1:46:58But there's people who would want-- just to name one thing--
1:47:00that they would rather have Apple build, at least
1:47:04as an option, another level of MacBook Pro that, say,
1:47:10has a better graphics card, higher energy,
1:47:16that RAM that would support up to 32 or more gigabytes of RAM,
1:47:20even if it takes more energy, and would rather have a significant hit on battery life, but
1:47:26a performance improvement, and they'll just plug it in or get less battery life, why won't
1:47:32Apple build that machine and let them buy it?
1:47:35Yeah, and I get that, although I think if you're Apple, you know what the sweet spot
1:47:41of your market is, and you know who's buying these things, and again, it sucks if you are
1:47:48the person who's in the corner of the market that is small, but you're in it, so it's super important
1:47:55to you. And Apple looks at it and goes, "Are we really going to solve, are we going to build one
1:48:00reference sort of design for the MacBook Pro and it's going to cater to 2% of our market or 4% of
1:48:06our market? Are we really going to do that?" And, you know, the customer, not everybody needs to be
1:48:12targeted. The customer is not always right. Not everybody needs to be targeted. And that stinks
1:48:16if you're in that area where Apple's like,
1:48:19"Look, you're just gonna have to suffer
1:48:21"'cause we're not gonna build this product.
1:48:22"We would have to make major changes
1:48:24"in order to build this product
1:48:25"so that it would also overlap your needs."
1:48:28So I get that.
1:48:28I also think, though, Apple knows about the march of time
1:48:31and the march of technology.
1:48:32And as in so many of these Apple product designs,
1:48:35they're kinda looking ahead.
1:48:37And maybe some of that is that they expected more
1:48:39from Intel than they got.
1:48:40Maybe that's true. - I can't help
1:48:41but think that's true a little.
1:48:42I do. - Yeah, yeah.
1:48:44Yeah, and I have this,
1:48:46you talk about next year, it's like, yeah,
1:48:48you'd think Apple would use its influence with Intel maybe
1:48:50to say, how about a 32 gig ceiling next time, right?
1:48:55Can you work on that?
1:48:56'Cause we really could use that.
1:48:57But in this same enclosure,
1:49:00with this same power profile and all of that,
1:49:02next year stuff is gonna be able to do way more
1:49:05than this year stuff.
1:49:06And the year after that,
1:49:07'cause this model will probably be the same one
1:49:11that we see in terms of the shape of it
1:49:13and the touch bar and all of that.
1:49:15This is probably also the 2018 MacBook Pro and the 2019 MacBook Pro, honestly.
1:49:19And every year they're going to have more capabilities fitting in this small case.
1:49:23So this is the year where it's kind of a tough ask and next year it'll be better.
1:49:28And, and that's again, stinks if you're not in there now and you need a laptop.
1:49:32Now I have no arguments for you.
1:49:35Yeah, that's terrible.
1:49:36I get it.
1:49:36Right.
1:49:37I think, you know, you have to think, I keep thinking about it from like a marketing
1:49:41perspective, product marketing perspective, is that Apple has three slots for Mac books,
1:49:48for families of Mac books. And they, you know, they have their gradients that blend between
1:49:53them at price points, you know, where there's like $100, every $100 from like $999 up to,
1:50:00you know, $4,000 almost, you know, there's configurations that you can buy. But fundamentally,
1:50:06the MacBook cheap. In other words, price is your biggest concern, and that is the MacBook Air,
1:50:12and it has been for the last few years. The entire reason the MacBook Air is still being sold
1:50:18is to hit the $999 starting price point. Right. It's like the old plastic MacBook was back in
1:50:23the day before it got eclipsed by the MacBook Air. You know what? I forgot about this. The last time
1:50:27you were on the show, the last time you were on the show back in August, we were talking about
1:50:30MacBooks speculating about what we're now talking about in hindsight. And you had said something
1:50:35about the MacBook Pro being the best-selling Mac.
1:50:38And yeah, and that was everybody said no no no it's the air.
1:50:42I heard from because the price is so good. Right and we're
1:50:45we're me and you are thinking too much about people like us.
1:50:49And really I heard from a couple people who work in Apple retail stores and
1:50:53they're like you just cannot even believe how many people when they
1:50:58come in to get a new Mac it's and you can you know and they can
1:51:02you could you know and they say because dealing with them and you know these
1:51:04Apple, the people who work in those sorts of areas, it's very clear that these people
1:51:07just, you know, they want to get a Mac, they're definitely, you know, you can tell they're
1:51:10going to buy one, but they're not definitely, there's no doubt they're going to get the
1:51:14Air. It's just a question of which one because, you know, about $100 is the most more they're
1:51:18going to spend. And it's all about price. And I'm a Mac, I'm a MacBook Air user, right?
1:51:22I haven't used a MacBook Pro in years. For me, I think I got, I was too busy focusing
1:51:27on like the flagship and the one that's got the, probably the biggest profit margin. Right.
1:51:33that's not the same as, I mean, and that's why that $999 13-inch non-retina
1:51:37air is still there, right? Because that is that is priced to move and that's the
1:51:42price that gets you into a Mac laptop and it's a pretty, you know what, it's a
1:51:45pretty good system. It's pretty, it's a pretty good mix of power and price. It
1:51:48really is, even to this day. People who are thinking of the old PC industry in
1:51:52a way that everything, every like six to eight months, you'd, you know, just put new
1:51:55chips and, you know, everything would get faster and you'd always be, you know,
1:51:58swapping out. In a way that the MacBook Air is effectively unchanged and the
1:52:02The price is unchanged, the price isn't going down.
1:52:04They're keeping it at 999.
1:52:06It's because people keep buying them.
1:52:08It is a best-selling device, and they don't mind.
1:52:11The people don't mind, it's fast enough for them.
1:52:13So you could say that Apple is under
1:52:16some kind of moral obligation to cut the price,
1:52:20but it's business-wise, that doesn't make any sense.
1:52:25It's a very popular device,
1:52:27and it exists just to hit that price point.
1:52:29Then there's the MacBook Pro,
1:52:30which is, right now it's the same size.
1:52:34There's no argument in size or weight
1:52:35between a 13-inch MacBook Pro and a MacBook Air.
1:52:38It is just the, if you wanna say Pro,
1:52:41it's really, I emphasize the word nice in my review.
1:52:44It's the MacBook nice, or the MacBook Premium,
1:52:47if you wanna call it.
1:52:49It is, in every single regard, it is nicer.
1:52:53It's faster, has the retina screen,
1:52:56and now it has this super bright retina screen.
1:52:58And then in between is the MacBook Thin and Light,
1:53:02which, you know, that's what now is called the MacBook.
1:53:0610 years ago or eight years ago, it was the MacBook Air.
1:53:08And you still pay a premium for the thinness and lightness
1:53:13and the niceness, and it has a retina screen.
1:53:16And it just, it's just sexy, right?
1:53:18I mean, there's just,
1:53:19it is like the little convertible sports car, right?
1:53:23It is really, really, I was in a meeting,
1:53:26I'm on this panel at Drexel University
1:53:28that meets like once a year,
1:53:30like alumni advisors in this thing.
1:53:33And we had a meeting, I don't go to meetings very often.
1:53:36We just had a meeting and there was a guy
1:53:38who had the current MacBook.
1:53:42And all I could think is,
1:53:43God damn that is a nice looking laptop.
1:53:46It's not really for me, right?
1:53:48But it's like, and I think he's just typing emails on it.
1:53:51And it's like, wow, that is a nice thing to carry around.
1:53:56is there room for something else like that would be—this isn't my proposed marketing
1:54:01name, but the MacBook Max or the MacBook—the Power MacBook Pro, or whatever you want to
1:54:09call it. Something that trades battery life and maybe some thinness in weight for sheer
1:54:17computing power.
1:54:19Well, it's the equivalent—I mean, it's a slot that they haven't had for a little
1:54:23while because if you think about the yeah the air is like the plastic MacBook and the MacBook is
1:54:28where the air used to be MacBook Pro is still sort of where it was and in terms of 13 and 15
1:54:35and then there's this lot that used to be like the the lunch tray right the cafeteria
1:54:39for the 17-inch MacBook Pro and they just don't make that computer anymore but you know and and
1:54:46I think this is a lot of the pro fear about Apple is that laptop doesn't exist and the Mac Pro
1:54:56basically doesn't exist because it's been abandoned since it was released three years ago.
1:55:00And so here we are, like what does this all mean? Does Apple care about that market enough to make
1:55:09a product for it or do pros have to kind of eke out their livelihood on computers that were not
1:55:15really made for them because that's the best that Apple wants, not can offer, wants to offer,
1:55:20is willing to offer. And I don't know, I mean, they totally could. I'm a little surprised that
1:55:25they didn't take the old MacBook Pro and stuff something even more powerful in there in the
1:55:31old enclosure and just say, "Look, and we've got this thing that's got old ports and it's got the
1:55:35latest Intel processors and the latest GPU and no touch bar and just, it's also available, you can
1:55:42can max it out, you can load it up with stuff,
1:55:45and if you really need it, you can take it away.
1:55:47- I sympathize, and I'm hearing from readers and listeners,
1:55:50and I see it, and I believe them.
1:55:52I don't think it's like an idle threat,
1:55:54but I'm hearing from people saying,
1:55:55I think I have to switch back to Windows,
1:55:58because I need to be able to buy something,
1:56:00and it's clear Apple isn't gonna make it for me.
1:56:02And that is the advantage of,
1:56:03it's always been the advantage of the PC marketplace,
1:56:05is that you, well, Apple has holes in its lineup,
1:56:10and right now, its hole is a notebook
1:56:12that is optimized for, let's just say,
1:56:15well, I was gonna say power,
1:56:16but that sounds like it might be energy.
1:56:17Performance, sheer performance.
1:56:19The most RAM and the fastest chips and the fastest graphics.
1:56:23They don't have that, they don't sell it.
1:56:24And there are PC laptops that have the fastest Intel CPUs
1:56:29and incredibly fast, hot GPUs,
1:56:32and they just sacrifice battery life and wait for that.
1:56:36Apple doesn't fill that.
1:56:37The hole in the PC market is, in my opinion, niceness.
1:56:41there's nothing you can buy on the PC market that's
1:56:43as nice as a MacBook Pro.
1:56:47Obviously, that's subjective.
1:56:48Obviously, the difference in that--
1:56:49and it drives some people nuts--
1:56:51is you can measure performance.
1:56:52You can run a benchmark and come up with a number.
1:56:55There's no benchmark for how nice the machine is
1:56:58and how much I appreciate the new hinge when
1:57:00I lift open the thing.
1:57:02But I feel it in my gut, and I believe it.
1:57:05That's what you give up.
1:57:06It's a shame that there are people who love Mac OS X, love
1:57:10Mac, but have that their personal needs are such that they want that machine, because
1:57:16I don't think Apple's going to make it.
1:57:18Right.
1:57:19And I think, yeah, and it's so easy to come across as not having sympathy for them or
1:57:26not caring about them, and that's not how I feel at all.
1:57:30But if you're Apple, you have to make a calculation about, you know, first off, there's all the
1:57:37things about what's the product.
1:57:39If they went down this path and then realized that it was going to limit them to 16 gigs
1:57:43of RAM, and they're like, "Well, we thought Intel would come through with something different,
1:57:47but they didn't. Maybe that happened, or maybe they decided 16 was good enough for almost
1:57:51all cases." What is the number of people for whom the highest end Mac laptop is simply
1:57:59not sufficient? What is that number? What's the size of that market? And who are those
1:58:03people? And are they influential and all that?
1:58:06And can they wait here?
1:58:08Yeah, and so you ask that, and yeah,
1:58:10do they have to buy something right now,
1:58:11or can they wait a year for something that will be,
1:58:14you know, better, more efficient,
1:58:16more powerful in the same space?
1:58:18And that's, for me, that's the question.
1:58:20Like, if Apple, I'm sure Apple has done that calculation.
1:58:24We know that Apple has very smart product marketing
1:58:28and research people, and they look at this stuff,
1:58:31and they've got access to data that we don't,
1:58:32because they are Apple.
1:58:34And my guess is, because these are the decisions they made,
1:58:38that they looked at that and said,
1:58:40that market is not sufficiently large enough,
1:58:44the market we're cutting off by making these decisions
1:58:46is not sufficiently large enough
1:58:47for us to not make these decisions.
1:58:49So we're gonna do it.
1:58:50And maybe they're right, and maybe they're wrong, right?
1:58:54Maybe they're wrong.
1:58:55But if they're right, it doesn't change the fact
1:58:57that there are lots of people, potentially,
1:59:00just not enough in that space
1:59:02who are gonna feel like Apple has abandoned them.
1:59:05And you know what?
1:59:06Apple has abandoned them.
1:59:07Apple has said, "Look, if you need 32 gigs of RAM
1:59:10in your laptop and this kind of..."
1:59:12You know, like, I'm in the Relay FM Slack
1:59:15and Shahid Kamal Ahmad is in there
1:59:18and he's a game developer.
1:59:19And I think he's gonna buy one of these
1:59:21'cause he's also a Mac fan.
1:59:22But like he's doing Windows development now.
1:59:24And he looks at this and Brianna Wu is like this too.
1:59:28She knows about game development stuff.
1:59:29And they're like, "You know, for 3D and VR
1:59:34and stuff like that, this hardware is kinda
1:59:37not good enough?"
1:59:38And it's like, and for gaming,
1:59:40it's certainly not good enough.
1:59:41But Apple has made that decision for years now.
1:59:43If like, we don't care, if it's not good enough for gaming,
1:59:45we don't optimize for gaming.
1:59:47So I guess what I'm saying is,
1:59:49it could be that Apple's miscalculated here,
1:59:52but it could also be that what we're hearing
1:59:54is the people who are basically being told by Apple,
1:59:58"We're not gonna make a computer that will satisfy you."
2:00:01And Apple's not wrong to make that decision necessarily,
2:00:04and they're definitely not wrong to be angry about it.
2:00:07But it's not a sign that this was a misfire,
2:00:09that some people are going to buy a PC
2:00:13because Apple can't satisfy them.
2:00:14- I think that it's also the case that Apple designs,
2:00:19to eliminate, makes choices for their customers
2:00:23because they truly believe that they know better
2:00:26and they want to keep customers from making a mistake.
2:00:30By which I mean, let's say you go into the Apple Store
2:00:33and you've got the money to spend
2:00:35and you want to buy the best MacBook Pro that you can get,
2:00:40or the best MacBook, let's say,
2:00:42in case they had a different name
2:00:43like the MacBook Plus or whatever.
2:00:45Obviously, there are some truly expert users,
2:00:49game developers, like you said,
2:00:50people who really do know exactly,
2:00:52yes, I don't care if I only get five hours of battery life
2:00:55instead of 10, I want the machine that has this power.
2:00:57I think Apple knows, though, that there's other people
2:00:59who would come in and say, well, if this machine is $2,500
2:01:03and this other machine is $2,500 and thicker and heavier,
2:01:07but look at the specs, it's got more gigahertz,
2:01:10it's got more RAM, that's clearly the better machine,
2:01:12I'll buy the one that's better.
2:01:14Or maybe it's more expensive, right?
2:01:16I don't know.
2:01:17But whatever, if it can be mistaken as being better
2:01:20in their mind, but it isn't for them.
2:01:23It's gigahertz, extra gigahertz they don't need.
2:01:26It's extra graphics that they don't need.
2:01:28It's battery life that they would appreciate if they had it,
2:01:31that it would be a mistake for them to walk out of that store.
2:01:35Obviously, these MacBook Pros are not
2:01:37the best hypothetical MacBook Pros from November 2016
2:01:41for every single person.
2:01:43But I think what Apple is--
2:01:46I think it's restating what you said.
2:01:48What Apple has tried to do is make the best machines
2:01:51for the most people.
2:01:52And that keeps some of those people
2:01:55from buying the wrong, going the wrong way.
2:01:59- Yeah, and it's not to come back to like
2:02:03when the customer, like myths we have
2:02:05about companies succeeding or failing
2:02:07based on keeping their customers happy.
2:02:10The truth is that it's not a you choose
2:02:14to make everybody happy
2:02:15or you choose to make some people unhappy.
2:02:17The truth is the choices you make
2:02:19going to make somebody unhappy in most cases, and you get to choose who you make unhappy.
2:02:25And Apple makes their choices, and now we'll have to live with them, and we'll see quite
2:02:30what happens.
2:02:31But if Apple views the decisions about battery and about weight and about size and says that
2:02:4090% of our users care about that stuff and 1% of our users care about this other thing,
2:02:47then I can see why they make that decision, right?
2:02:50And it doesn't make it any more bitter
2:02:54if you're somebody who's kind of on the outside looking in
2:02:57saying, "I'd really like more than 16 gigs of RAM
2:02:58in my laptop, please, or a better GPU."
2:03:02But it's an open question.
2:03:05Pro, like you said, it means nice.
2:03:08That's probably true.
2:03:12And the Mac Pro, it's the same question of like,
2:03:14Does Apple, Apple as a company right now,
2:03:19is making decisions about what their audience is
2:03:22for these various products, who are their customers?
2:03:25And it may be that the Apple of five years ago
2:03:28would be like, oh man, we gotta give a high end,
2:03:30super high end developers and content creators
2:03:32and people who used to use Linux and now use a Mac
2:03:35because they get the command line.
2:03:36We gotta get those people
2:03:37'cause we gotta use them in the Mac.
2:03:39You know, maybe the Apple of today is like,
2:03:40we're not interested in those people.
2:03:42We want a mass market of people.
2:03:45The MacBook Pro is nice,
2:03:46but it's not gonna be for everyone.
2:03:48And that's their decision to make.
2:03:51And if they wanna turn their back on certain markets,
2:03:52it might be a good business decision.
2:03:54And if I was in those markets, I would be pissed off.
2:03:56I think all these things are true.
2:03:58I don't think if people in a certain market
2:04:01switch to Windows or Linux,
2:04:03it means the MacBook Pro was a bad decision necessarily.
2:04:05Because Apple will not be surprised if that happens, right?
2:04:11not like these came out and Apple was like, what?
2:04:12They only have 16 gigs of RAM.
2:04:14We're shocked, right?
2:04:15They made that decision.
2:04:16They knew what the ramifications were gonna be.
2:04:19And it's interesting if that's the case
2:04:23that a bunch of people maybe that they've kind of wooed
2:04:25over to the Mac over the last 15 years with OS X
2:04:29are now not in their target anymore.
2:04:33And yeah.
2:04:34- I will say, I just think though that,
2:04:36again, things could change.
2:04:37The past does not always predict the future,
2:04:39but if you look at the last 10 years of MacBook sales,
2:04:43it has gone down a little bit in the last year,
2:04:45but I think that's mostly been people waiting.
2:04:48But it's Apple's priorities,
2:04:52prioritizing thinness to an almost obsessive degree,
2:04:57prioritizing battery life to an almost obsessive degree.
2:05:01I come back to this many, many times,
2:05:04that the order of your priorities matters tremendously,
2:05:07Even if you have like two, you know,
2:05:09the customer and the Apple have like
2:05:11the same top four priorities, you know,
2:05:14but they're in slightly different order.
2:05:16It makes a tremendous difference in the resulting product.
2:05:19And Apple's list order of priorities
2:05:22has shown to be very successful.
2:05:24- Yeah, and that's the thing is,
2:05:27Apple could be making a bad decision here.
2:05:34It's entirely possible
2:05:35that they're making a bad decision here.
2:05:36and we'll find out what the market says about it.
2:05:38But they have their priorities and a lot of it is something
2:05:41that is just sort of like quintessentially Apple.
2:05:43And when we say they prioritize the battery,
2:05:46I mean, I think the right thing to say there is really like,
2:05:49they prioritize the weight and the thinness
2:05:54and the battery comes third,
2:05:56where the battery has to hit some kind of a metric,
2:05:59but really no more than that because every inch,
2:06:04every minute, every hour of battery life
2:06:07above what they think is optimal
2:06:10is added weight and thickness that you don't get.
2:06:14You get enough battery to hit,
2:06:16like with the iPad, it's whatever, 10 hours, and that's it.
2:06:19You don't get any more battery.
2:06:21And with the MacBook, it's a little more complicated
2:06:24because it's battery life and power saving
2:06:27in the operating system and all of those things,
2:06:29but that's their priority.
2:06:32So they're gonna put thinness and lightness
2:06:35and battery life and power in maybe that sequence
2:06:39where somebody else would put power first.
2:06:41- I'm generalizing. - Go from there.
2:06:44- To my gut feeling, in the early years
2:06:47of that inflection point where most,
2:06:49the most Macs sold were laptops and notebooks, I should say.
2:06:53Apple calls them notebooks instead of laptops,
2:06:55but notebooks instead of desktops, right?
2:06:57There was that, and it used to be
2:06:59because notebook computers were so phenomenally expensive
2:07:02that it was really a luxury item,
2:07:05just to have like the lowest end power.
2:07:08At the inflection point
2:07:12where they became the most popular max,
2:07:17I felt for years it was very consistent
2:07:20where Apple would say you could get six hours of battery life
2:07:22and in the real world, you always got,
2:07:24you seemed to get about three and a half or four hours.
2:07:27But Apple would say six.
2:07:28And it was always, it seemed to me,
2:07:32for me flying coast to coast, five, six hour flights,
2:07:36it never seemed to be enough to go on a full charge coast
2:07:39to coast.
2:07:40It was right in real use.
2:07:42And that's before they had Wi-Fi.
2:07:45And then there was--
2:07:47at some point when they hit--
2:07:48I think the Intel transition definitely
2:07:50had something to do with it.
2:07:52All of a sudden, the battery life did start creeping up.
2:07:55And it seemed like that was a higher priority for Apple
2:07:59on an annual basis, where it really was suddenly getting
2:08:02six hours of battery life.
2:08:03And you really could get seven hours, eight hours, 10.
2:08:07It seems like once they hit 10, they were like, we're done.
2:08:10And now, we'll hold that point steady.
2:08:14And I know that the 10 isn't necessarily 10 for all tasks,
2:08:18but 10 under their testing conditions.
2:08:21- Yeah, they're light use 10 hours, right.
2:08:24Because if you really are doing editing audio or video
2:08:27or something like that, it will bleed that thing dry
2:08:31way faster than that.
2:08:32And that's just how it is.
2:08:34That's not what they're shooting for.
2:08:36- All right, let me take a break here
2:08:37and thank our third and final sponsor.
2:08:39Another long, this is like a greatest hits
2:08:40of talk show sponsors, Backblaze.
2:08:44Backblaze is unlimited native backup for Mac and PC.
2:08:49Here's what you do.
2:08:51You go to backblaze.com/daringfireball.
2:08:55You download Backblaze to your Mac.
2:08:58Install it on your Mac.
2:08:59It's a simple little-- it goes in your system preferences.
2:09:01It's just a system preferences thing.
2:09:04And then it just starts--
2:09:06you sign up.
2:09:07Again, no credit card.
2:09:08And then it just starts backing up everything on your Mac
2:09:11to their secure cloud-based servers.
2:09:13Everything.
2:09:14Do you have an external drive that's
2:09:15maybe like three terabytes or something like that?
2:09:17It'll back it up.
2:09:18Do you have two external drives?
2:09:19It'll back them both up.
2:09:21It might take a while, depending on how much you have,
2:09:23but you don't pay more for more space.
2:09:27It's just $5 a month for unlimited, un-throttled,
2:09:30off-site backup per Mac.
2:09:32$5 a month, that's it.
2:09:36I've been using them for years, I've recommended them for years.
2:09:40They have so many features that everything you might want them
2:09:43to do, they can do.
2:09:45Let's say you need a restoration of everything you've got.
2:09:48Well, if you want to, though, they can restore by mail.
2:09:50You can purchase a hard drive with all your data on it,
2:09:54and they'll overnight it to you on FedEx.
2:09:56Because let's face it, downloading
2:09:58three terabytes of stuff or however much stuff
2:10:00could take forever.
2:10:01Maybe in some kind of emergency situation
2:10:04where you need it all, you can get it overnighted.
2:10:07You can use their iOS app and log in
2:10:13and just get one file and email it to somebody.
2:10:17You can just access all the files on your Mac,
2:10:19backed up through Backblaze.
2:10:22So anything from one file to getting everything on your Mac
2:10:28overnighted to you on a hard drive, they can do.
2:10:31They have over 200 petabytes of data
2:10:34that has been stored by Backblaze.
2:10:36Over 10 billion files have been restored to their customers.
2:10:41It is a great addition to local backups,
2:10:44like having an external drive running Time Machine
2:10:47or I use SuperDuper to clone my startup drive every day or two, a great utility.
2:10:56Having an offsite backup that runs automatically, just silently and visibly in the background,
2:11:02just software that never gets in the way. It's not like all of a sudden when Backblaze
2:11:05starts backing up your stuff, your fans spin up. You don't even notice. I never notice.
2:11:09It just happens. I can't say what a relief it is to know that if somebody came in and
2:11:15rob my house or if the house burned down or something like that, I don't lose my data.
2:11:22For years and years and years, that's how I lived and it was always a nagging fear in
2:11:26the back of my head that, hey, if something really bad happened, I could lose everything
2:11:31and that would be heartbreaking. What a relief it is. It's a great service. I use it myself.
2:11:36Go to backblaze.com/daringfireball so they know where you came from. Really, it's a great
2:11:44deal. Last thing on my agenda, we've been going long, it's just this, speaking of books from Apple.
2:11:52Yes, the lowest priced MacBook. The lowest priced MacBook from Apple is a coffee table book that
2:12:03they announced yesterday, I think it was yesterday, but called Designed by Apple in California, and it
2:12:10is it comes in two sizes, small and large.
2:12:13They cost $200 and $300, respectively.
2:12:16And it's almost entirely photographs
2:12:22of 20 years of Apple products.
2:12:24I don't know.
2:12:31I have mixed feelings about it.
2:12:32I'm not as outraged as some people seem to be.
2:12:35I don't think it's as much of a boondoggle
2:12:37as some people think it should be.
2:12:39I do think though that the optics of it are a little self-indulgent.
2:12:43Mm-hmm. No doubt. I mean, it's self-published, right?
2:12:47Right.
2:12:48You made the point on Daring Fireball, like, they could have used—expensive art books
2:12:54are a thing, right? I mean, people who are used to thinking books cost $10 or $20 do
2:12:59not know about expensive art books. You mentioned you bought some very expensive art books.
2:13:04Stanley Kubrick, lots of books like that.
2:13:07And there are even, there's a book called "Iconic"
2:13:10about Mac industrial, Apple industrial design.
2:13:12It's a hundred bucks,
2:13:13but they've got a $250 special edition.
2:13:15So, I mean, it's sort of a thing, but you're right.
2:13:17It's a little surprising.
2:13:19They published it themselves.
2:13:20They didn't work with a partner.
2:13:22I still feel like this is the ultimate Rorschach test
2:13:25for people's view of where Apple is today.
2:13:28Like, I'm not quite sure commenting on this
2:13:31tells us anything about actually,
2:13:33especially since they claim that they've been working on this for eight years
2:13:36and they decided to build an archive and had to buy some of their products on eBay
2:13:41in order to get them back because they literally didn't have them in the office.
2:13:45So I'm not sure this says a lot about where Apple is today
2:13:48versus a progression of their design group for the last eight years,
2:13:53but I think it is a vessel into which everybody can pour all of their fears
2:13:58about where Apple is going and use this as an example if they want.
2:14:02I had a part from my write-up on it that I wrote,
2:14:06and then I thought about, and I deleted it.
2:14:09It's the sort of thing that I just--
2:14:11because I can explain it on the podcast why I deleted it.
2:14:15I feel like I can say it on a podcast with no reservations,
2:14:17but I felt extremely uncomfortable publishing it,
2:14:19which was something to the effect of I
2:14:21don't have the exact words in front of me,
2:14:22I guess because I deleted them.
2:14:25I'll come out and say it.
2:14:27I don't think this would have happened if Steve Jobs were
2:14:29still in charge of Apple.
2:14:31But I don't know Steve Jobs at all.
2:14:36And Johnny Ive was, by all accounts, his closest colleague
2:14:40and one of his dearest friends.
2:14:43And so I feel like a fool saying that,
2:14:48because I didn't know the guy and Johnny Ive knew him
2:14:51as well probably better than anybody who worked with him.
2:14:55And so for all I know, I've and Jobs kicked around the idea,
2:14:59while Jobs was still alive, and I'm an idiot.
2:15:02But it feels to me like something
2:15:05they wouldn't have done with Steve Jobs,
2:15:07that Apple has made a book that Steve Jobs
2:15:10never would have published dedicated to Steve Jobs.
2:15:12- Yeah, I mean, one of the problems with the head geography
2:15:18of somebody like Steve Jobs,
2:15:19where we turn him into this figure,
2:15:22this amazing kind of icon,
2:15:26is that he was a person and his life was a continuum, right?
2:15:31And so I think I saw somebody make the comment
2:15:34that I thought was really smart that said,
2:15:36it's undoubtedly true that Steve Jobs of 1997 through 2002,
2:15:41whatever, 2005, would not approve of this, right?
2:15:47Like I feel like there was a pathological,
2:15:51almost dislike of the past when Apple was trying to give up
2:15:56get on its feet again. And I think some of that might have been innate in Steve Jobs.
2:16:01I think some of that was also a management technique, that he felt like Apple was so
2:16:06navel-gazing and so focused on congratulating itself on its great achievements of the past
2:16:11that it had completely lost its way. And when he came back, he wanted to right the ship.
2:16:16So I think it's entirely possible that in the last five years that Steve Jobs was at
2:16:22that his feelings were different.
2:16:24And that in talking to Johnny Ive about the idea
2:16:28that they didn't even have an archive
2:16:29and that that was a mistake
2:16:31and they didn't even have some of the products they designed
2:16:34and that when they set up,
2:16:36I mean, you could make the same argument
2:16:37for something like Apple University,
2:16:38like is that too inward facing
2:16:40or is the argument there that you want to be able
2:16:43to document and teach your company's successes
2:16:45and thought processes so that the culture
2:16:48can pervade all of your employees
2:16:51that other parts of the company can learn from what these parts of the company had to
2:16:56experience themselves instead of having to learn it again. I mean, you could make the
2:17:00argument that that's all of a whole and that that's as much what this is about as anything
2:17:05else. Or you could just look at it and say, this is self-congratulatory nonsense and it's
2:17:13a project where Johnny Ive got to hire a famous, fabulous photographer to take beauty shots
2:17:19of all the things that he made so that he has got a souvenir when he leaves Apple. Also,
2:17:25you made the point on during follow-up that I thought was really good, like, in another
2:17:29time, this would either be like an Apple employee only thing, or I was thinking, or they'd
2:17:33print a thousand copies and make them available only at the Infinite Loop company store. And
2:17:39today's Apple's like, "Yeah, we might as well sell them everywhere." So...
2:17:44I didn't, it didn't occur to me, I actually cheated a little bit when I put that hypothetical
2:17:47out there, I actually heard about this from somebody
2:17:52a while back, not super recently,
2:17:54which is why I didn't think of it early in the morning
2:17:55yesterday.
2:17:56It only occurred to me at night.
2:17:57I heard something about this project a while ago
2:18:01from someone at Apple.
2:18:03And what I heard then was that it was
2:18:06being made for Apple employees.
2:18:09That my hypothetical was at one point maybe the plan.
2:18:13And I think in that world where Apple made this exact book
2:18:17and made it or maybe since it's Apple,
2:18:21sold it to Apple employees.
2:18:23In that world, I think these books
2:18:25would be going for over $1,000, maybe $1,500 on eBay.
2:18:32Yep.
2:18:33And I think I would strongly--
2:18:36Adam for Adam, Ink for Ink, Paper for Paper,
2:18:39the exact same book.
2:18:40I think that if Apple made them exclusive to Apple employees,
2:18:44they would be selling for maybe $2,000 on eBay until the market calmed down.
2:18:48Well, sure. I think that's the argument for why you sell it,
2:18:51why you sell it to anyone is, is why create a scarcity?
2:18:56That means that somebody else makes an $800 profit on this thing that you made.
2:19:01That's like selling a world series ticket for $250 face value,
2:19:06knowing that it will immediately be resold on eBay for a thousand dollars.
2:19:09It's like, why would you let somebody else take that money?
2:19:12with printing books they can not print as many as they want but they can probably because of the
2:19:17price print as many as it needs to meet demand and you know in a way that like with hamilton tickets
2:19:24they can't make the theater bigger and even if they could make it bigger the seats wouldn't be
2:19:29good right you can't have hamilton in uh uh mba-sized arena it's not the same experience so
2:19:37Right, and those actors can only do seven shows a week.
2:19:40Exactly.
2:19:40That's all they can do.
2:19:41Right.
2:19:42Or eight shows a week, how much it is.
2:19:43That's all they can do.
2:19:44Two matinees, six-night performances,
2:19:47and they're deep in their sleep.
2:19:48The scale is limited very quickly.
2:19:50And so the fact that the tickets on the secondhand market
2:19:54are selling at exorbitant prices,
2:19:57well, that's the way supply and demand works
2:19:59when supply has a hard upper limit.
2:20:02Right.
2:20:04So the alternative is, if you're Hamilton,
2:20:06and the alternative is you either build in a "no resellers" you know you can return to the
2:20:12theater for your money back but you don't get to resell it or you raise the price or you just accept
2:20:18that somebody else is going to make twice as much as you make on your product and you know apple
2:20:25apple's so big and there's so many people who are interested in it that it totally makes sense for
2:20:30them to say why would we make this and not let anybody who wants one get one why would we do that
2:20:36And so the more I think about it, the more okay I am with it.
2:20:39I still think the optics are bad because there's a lot of people who complain,
2:20:41but I think it's better than anything else they could have done,
2:20:45including not make the book.
2:20:47Like, I mean, I'm going to buy one.
2:20:49Sure.
2:20:50Are you?
2:20:52I don't know.
2:20:53I don't know.
2:20:53I might get the small one.
2:20:55But I want one.
2:20:57But I'm a sucker for coffee table books.
2:20:59I am.
2:20:59I have a weak spot for them.
2:21:01I know.
2:21:01I own iconic--
2:21:03I have all those Taschen ones about Kubrick that were absolutely gut-wrenchingly expensive.
2:21:09Yeah.
2:21:10I'm a sucker for them.
2:21:12It's a thing.
2:21:13Yeah, and I think there's, yeah, I think when you put it in that context of the big
2:21:19oversized expensive art book, it's not nearly as ridiculous unless you want to use it as
2:21:25an example of sort of a cultural change or a systemic failure at Apple, which gets us
2:21:29back to the Inglot test, right?
2:21:33You can absolutely use it as a vehicle for that
2:21:35if you want to, but I'm kind of with you.
2:21:37I'm okay with it.
2:21:40I think it's definitely not what Steve Jobs of 2004
2:21:45would do, but he's gone and Johnny is there
2:21:51and it might've been the Steve Jobs of 2009.
2:21:54- The eight year thing is an interesting thing.
2:21:56That came in Johnny Ive's interview with wallpaper
2:21:59and I put it in the show notes already.
2:22:02The eight-year quote, though, is ambiguous because what—people are taking it as evidence
2:22:07that Jobs approved of the book, but it's not.
2:22:09What he said started eight years ago was their collection of all old Apple equipment, right?
2:22:15That they found, you know, like they wanted to look at some of the—I don't know, maybe,
2:22:18who knows what it is, like maybe some of the old candy-colored IMAX, and they didn't
2:22:22have them all.
2:22:23So they had to—
2:22:25But still, that goes to a point where Jobs was still around, and they were reversing
2:22:30his policy which was don't think about the past. I mean like can you imagine that Apple didn't have
2:22:35a Bondi Blue iMac in their possession? But for that era? Sure. It is proof that Jobs changed
2:22:40because when Jobs first came back to Apple in 96, 97, I guess it was 97, one of the first things
2:22:45he did is he found that they had a whole collection of all this old uh yeah and he's just like let's
2:22:51get rid of it you know and they didn't throw it in a dumpster they gave it to it they gave it to a
2:22:55Museum. That's my favorite Jobs quote ever. It was, "I said get it away and we sent that shit to
2:23:03Stanford." I just love the whole thing. I love the swearing, I love the "get it away!" Like,
2:23:10it's got cooties. It's just like, it was repellent to him that this company that was going into the
2:23:17dumps had this whole thing that was like a monument to its greatness and so that was his reflexive
2:23:25you know get it away and they sent it to stanford and that was it uh which brings me to and to me
2:23:32this is the roar shark test is a sentiment i've seen several people supported on twitter uh
2:23:39best put by genius, like, jailbreak sort of developer,
2:23:48Stephen Troughton Smith.
2:23:49Steve Troughton Smith.
2:23:50Troughton Smith, yeah.
2:23:51His quote or his take on Twitter was that it's only the last 20
2:23:55years says a lot.
2:23:56This is Ive's portfolio, not Apple's.
2:23:59My impression is that his career is drawing to a close.
2:24:01And a lot of people--
2:24:02this isn't just because of the book.
2:24:04I've seen people say that ever since the promotion
2:24:07to chief design officer and naming Alan Dye and I forget the other guy's name as the hardware
2:24:16and software design chief under Ive. Is Johnny Ive checking out and slowly fading away or
2:24:24is he, you know, and I could see it two different ways. I honestly can see it and I don't know.
2:24:30This is something that is sometimes knowledgeable about internal workings at Apple as I am.
2:24:39I don't know anybody who has insight to it, and I think part of it is because Johnny
2:24:44Ive operates in such an isolated way within the company that he doesn't really interact
2:24:49directly with a large number of people and never did.
2:24:52He's in a secure enclave.
2:24:54thing I've heard, I have heard that he has lately been checked out of, not
2:25:00checked out I guess, but not as directly involved with product design and that he
2:25:04has been largely focused on architecture, meaning mostly the obviously the
2:25:12Spaceship Campus and the new stores. And then maybe the other top-level executive
2:25:21who's been working the most with Ive is Angela Arndt.
2:25:29Right. I also wonder about the car, right? You know, for a while there the talk was
2:25:33that they were going to make a car and they and they recalibrated that to
2:25:36making bits of a car and I have to wonder if that was a little
2:25:39bit of a hit for Johnny Ive because he is a car
2:25:43guy, we know that, and perhaps one of the reasons they went
2:25:48down the path of making their own car is that Johnny Ive was excited about
2:25:51doing card design and it sounds like they've made the decision to back away from that too. I think the idea that i've has has um,
2:25:59conquered all
2:26:01All mountains there are no more lands for him to conquer and that
2:26:05he
2:26:07You know is easing his way out of apple is
2:26:10It certainly seems like a a legitimate scenario. I don't like you. I don't really have any evidence
2:26:16I've heard people say that the that people inside Apple have that impression too
2:26:20But it's not necessarily that they've got more information than we do about this too, but it certainly feels that way like he's
2:26:26He's either eased into a very different role or he's just sort of fading away it absolutely
2:26:32This book does feel like the Johnny Ive era
2:26:34Dissertation, right? No kind of thing of like here here it is. Here's the work that I did and
2:26:42And and then you step away from that the other side of it though could be that he is
2:26:47the
2:26:50most influential person in the company. Mm-hmm and that
2:26:54Not he had decreed that there would be a book and so there's a book exactly like in the way that Steve Jobs could decree
2:27:02You know a lot of things
2:27:05You know, we're gonna open source FaceTime, you know the night before FaceTime
2:27:09Came out sure
2:27:11That Johnny Ive can say we're gonna make a book and that means they're gonna make a book whether there are other people object
2:27:16Oh, and I here's my a number one example. Can't believe it took me 30 seconds to think of it. I
2:27:21Clearly this is what happened. I don't know this
2:27:24Nobody has ever told me this who knows but I would bet my bottom dollar on it
2:27:28Johnny I've said I want to make $20,000 gold Apple watch. Oh
2:27:33Yeah, yeah
2:27:35And I know for I do know for a fact that there were some high-level
2:27:39executives with an Apple who thought that was nutty.
2:27:43I never heard for a fact that it was
2:27:45Johnny Ive himself who wanted it.
2:27:47But I know what I think.
2:27:49And I think it's Johnny Ive said,
2:27:51I've always wanted to make a watch.
2:27:54One of the great materials that watches are made out
2:27:56of is gold, so I want to make a gold Apple watch.
2:27:58We got to make a gold watch.
2:28:00It's the least Apple-like product
2:28:01that has ever been made.
2:28:03Or at least-- I shouldn't say Apple-like,
2:28:05but least like any other Apple product that's ever been made.
2:28:08Right.
2:28:09- Right, it breaks your Coca-Cola analogy.
2:28:11- Exactly, and it is indulgent.
2:28:13I don't know, but it makes me think,
2:28:16I don't know that he,
2:28:17I think that maybe what's happened, possibly.
2:28:20I'm not saying that this is any, you know.
2:28:22Johnny Ive might be there for the next 15, 20 years,
2:28:25but that he has assumed a jobs-like role of,
2:28:30gets to do whatever he wants
2:28:31and has final say over all products,
2:28:33but that his personality is such,
2:28:36and it's so different than Steve Jobs'
2:28:38that he's almost a a a
2:28:44howard hughes like figure you know a recluse
2:28:48and other other than appearing as a narrator
2:28:51in the product videos i don't get well i don't get
2:28:54you know i don't know whether that's true or whether it really is just that he
2:28:57has stage fright and so he wants to be on video but
2:29:00he does seem to have fallen into this role as
2:29:04their credibility right i mean he's there
2:29:07Those Johnny Ive videos went from,
2:29:10we want Johnny to explain things,
2:29:12but he's terrible on stage,
2:29:13or he doesn't want to be on stage,
2:29:15something like that, right?
2:29:16And so we're gonna make these videos
2:29:18and he's gonna narrate them.
2:29:19But at some point that seems to,
2:29:22especially since Steve has been gone,
2:29:24that seems to have become instead
2:29:26like Johnny brings the credibility.
2:29:28Let us explain to you why what Apple does
2:29:31is we're making all the right decisions
2:29:33and all the steps we had to go through
2:29:35and all the incredible processes that we now use
2:29:37in order to make this product, right?
2:29:39I feel like that's now his role is as this,
2:29:43in some ways almost like an icon or a totem
2:29:46of like the apple everybody believes is there,
2:29:50where they have their, you know,
2:29:52where they do their amazing design
2:29:53and they make all these incredible decisions
2:29:55to bring the future out of his white room into reality.
2:29:59And he may not, I mean,
2:30:01he may only be spiritual leadership at this point.
2:30:04I don't know. - I firmly believe,
2:30:06I really do like that when it comes to an aesthetic decision,
2:30:12like, hey, should we ship Jet Black in addition
2:30:16to regular black on these iPhone 7s?
2:30:19Should we do-- we can do-- here's two blacks we can do.
2:30:23The Jet Black 1 is more expensive and time consuming.
2:30:26And if we sell it at the same price as the same memory
2:30:30storage and the same thing, we are
2:30:32going to take a hit on margins.
2:30:33But look at it.
2:30:34It's fricking beautiful.
2:30:36Yes or no, do we do this?
2:30:38I think the final decision on stuff like that
2:30:40is Johnny Ives and not Tim Cook's.
2:30:42And I'm not saying that Tim Cook is powerless in that way.
2:30:47I think it's because Tim Cook, in his gut,
2:30:50knows to defer to Johnny Ive.
2:30:52- Well, I mean, this is--
2:30:56- Technically, ultimately, it would be Tim Cook's decision
2:30:58as the CEO, that the power resides in the CEO.
2:31:00But that, I think, within Apple's culture,
2:31:03Johnny Ive gets to make the product decisions in a similar way that Steve Jobs did, even
2:31:07though his title is not CEO.
2:31:10Like Johnny Ive wasn't going to be named CEO in a legal way and actually make it his title,
2:31:16because it's absolutely positively, there are aspects of being CEO that he simply doesn't
2:31:22want to do.
2:31:23And in fact, some of those aspects like of managing people and direct...
2:31:29actually him being promoted as chief design officer and having two lieutenants directly
2:31:34below him actually made him less like the CEO of just the design group, that he's more
2:31:41like chairman of the design group.
2:31:44Yeah, he's kind of like, yeah, and you could say he's kind of the head of product in a
2:31:48really grand scale. I'll give you an example from my life is for whatever, you know, decade
2:31:54plus I was the editor-in-chief of Macworld. That means that if I want the cover to say
2:31:58something and look a certain way, I get to decree that right, like Tim Cook being the
2:32:03CEO. But, you know, I had a really good art director named Rob Schultz for many, many
2:32:09years, and he and I would work on these cover designs, and you know, I would come up with
2:32:14lots of wacky ideas, and some of them, he would be like, "No, that's not…" or
2:32:17we'd get, we'd have nine sample covers, and I'd say I kind of like number three,
2:32:22and then he and my executive editor would be like, "No, number three is not so good,
2:32:26five is the one." I'd be like, "All right, well, you know, I'm gonna go with you." And again,
2:32:29I could say, "Nope, damn it, it's gonna be number three," but I feel like Tim Cook maybe is that way
2:32:35with product and design, right? That he's got people to lean on, he's got Phil Schiller to
2:32:39work with on product and marketing, but he's got Johnny. And if Johnny says, "Gotta do the
2:32:44jet black," like, you could say no, but are you gonna say no to Johnny Ive? Like, I wouldn't--
2:32:49it would take a lot for me to say no to my art director, and I'm sure it would take way more
2:32:55than that for Tim Cook to say no to Johnny Ive. And that's not that Tim Cook's powerless, and it's not
2:32:59that Johnny Ive always makes the right decisions, but he's much more likely to be right than Tim
2:33:08Cook, and Tim knows it about some decisions. And so that's perfectly reasonable.
2:33:12Because he's not forward-facing, and because he's not on stage, and because he's clearly not as
2:33:18hands-on involved with the day-to-day design of the actual products as as he used to be
2:33:24or if he is there are these products that we that that even the typical the apple employee
2:33:30he's maybe have a sense that he's fading away wouldn't even know because all he's doing is
2:33:34working on the architecture of the retail stores which you know someone who works in the you know
2:33:40you know the the hardware design group for the max you know feels like johnny is putting less
2:33:48input into it, well, you'd have no idea because he's off somewhere else, you know, designing tables
2:33:53for Apple stores. I'm not sure. I'm not saying I'm betting on that. I wouldn't be surprised if a year
2:33:58from now they say, you know, you know, Johnny Ive is retiring and moving to England, you know, or,
2:34:04and taking an, you know, chief design officer emeritus title with him, you know, like that,
2:34:09you know, still technically some part of Apple, but, you know, he's emeritus and he's not involved
2:34:15on a day-to-day, and I wouldn't be surprised if I would the other way, if he's as engaged as ever,
2:34:22but on other things, moving, you know, forward, like architecture now, maybe a car five, six years
2:34:29from now, etc. Yeah, it'll be interesting to see what happens with him. I don't think anyone would,
2:34:38I don't know, I mean, I feel like we've reached the point with Johnny Ive where, if he wants to
2:34:43to go do other things, nobody would say that he's wrong to do so. He really, it does feel
2:34:48like he's sort of done everything he can. On one level, he's conquered everything. And
2:34:53also, I don't think I would feel like he's been there so long, I mean, he's been there
2:35:00since the E-Mate, for god's sake, right? He's been there so long that I'm not sure I would
2:35:05be like, "Oh no, what will Apple do without Johnny Ive at this point?" I'm sure some people
2:35:10would. Apple is doomed because Johnny Ive is leaving stories, but I feel like
2:35:14not only has he built a culture, like Steve Jobs built a culture, but
2:35:18new people have new ideas. We've had Johnny's ideas for 20 years now.
2:35:24It would be a big one and probably the second biggest that there ever was, but
2:35:27it's not going to be the biggest. Apple's not going to be the same without
2:35:31blank. So we've been through one that is so much bigger than the next
2:35:37three combined. And again, maybe they're not the same, and they
2:35:40be the same because if they were the same, you know, what's the Dylan lighting? That's not busy
2:35:44changing, it's busy dying. And Steve, you know, that is, I think part of this era is the continuity
2:35:51with Steve, like with Steve leaving, with Steve dying, I mean, he left and then he passed away,
2:35:58but with that whole period, Apple needed to show that it was still in business and still knew what
2:36:04it was doing. And so like presence of Johnny Ive, super important. Steady hand of Tim Cook,
2:36:09super important. It's been a few years now, right? I mean, we're passing through that phase of
2:36:14"reassure us that Apple's not going to totally crash and burn without Steve there." And we can
2:36:20debate, and people will still argue that Apple completely lost it after Steve left. Fair enough,
2:36:24whatever, we can debate that. But I feel like, on a very large scale, Johnny Ive leaving today
2:36:30would not be the freakout that it would have been six months after Steve Jobs died.
2:36:36Yes, I think that's exactly true. And, you know, I think this book is a very possible sign that it might happen.
2:36:42I think the next canary in a coal mine would be an Apple event without a Johnny Ive narrated video.
2:36:50Like if the--
2:36:51I don't know, I feel-- sometimes I feel like that's his minimum involvement, is he may be off driving cars at a test track somewhere in the world.
2:36:59The videos?
2:37:00But he comes back for the videos.
2:37:01- I'm telling you, if you and I are sitting there
2:37:03next to each other in one of these events next year,
2:37:05maybe next year, maybe next time we see each other
2:37:07we'll be on the new campus.
2:37:09All right. - New Apple Campus.
2:37:10- And we're there in March,
2:37:11and you're there typing away
2:37:14and I'm scribbling in my notebook,
2:37:15and a video comes up and it's narrated by somebody else.
2:37:19I'm gonna look at you and you're gonna go, hmm.
2:37:23I also have a correction to make,
2:37:27the Dylan line, I can't believe I botched it,
2:37:29It's he not busy being born is busy dying.
2:37:33And you can't have a misquoted Bob Dylan lyric stand.
2:37:38- Not within two minutes of mentioning Steve Jobs.
2:37:41- No, if there's ever any way to haunt me,
2:37:44if he's gonna spook me from beyond the grave,
2:37:47it would be botching a Dylan line.
2:37:51All right, let me thank our sponsors for the show today.
2:37:54Backblaze, go to backblaze.com/daringfireball.
2:37:57Harry's, go to harrys.com and remember the code talk show
2:38:02and you'll get a really cool free trial set.
2:38:05And Casper, the place where you go to buy mattresses,
2:38:09casper.com/thetalkshow.
2:38:11Jason Snell, I thank you for your time.
2:38:12Where can people hear more Jason Snell?
2:38:14- All right, you can get my podcast
2:38:18about tech stuff at relay.fm.
2:38:21I host Upgrade and Clockwise
2:38:22and I've got a couple other podcasts over there
2:38:25that are a little less techie, but they're over there.
2:38:26And then my pop culture stuff is at the incomparable.com.
2:38:30And all my writing is at Six Colors.com.
2:38:32And I'm going to say something that you probably wouldn't do,
2:38:35but I want to bring it up, is that SixColors.com
2:38:38has a newfangled--
2:38:41I don't forget when you launch it,
2:38:42but there's a membership at a very--
2:38:45One year ago last week.
2:38:46And you get some nice extra stuff that I really like.
2:38:50I don't even know how you find the time
2:38:51to do it because you get this weekly newsletter that--
2:38:54I don't know how you do it.
2:38:55It's monthly newsletter.
2:38:58Monthly.
2:38:59I just figured I don't see some of them in my inbox.
2:39:03So there's a monthly newsletter, and there's
2:39:05something we started a little bit later.
2:39:06There's a weekly podcast that's like--
2:39:08so Dan Morin does the site with me.
2:39:10We used to work together at Macworld.
2:39:11And we talk for about half an hour about what's going on.
2:39:14And that's a subscriber podcast.
2:39:16And people seem to really like the podcast too.
2:39:18So it sounds a little different, a little more conversational.
2:39:20So yeah, there's some bonuses.
2:39:22Plus, it helps support us doing the site because, you know, as you know better than anyone else,
2:39:28making a living as an independent writer on the web these days is challenging.
2:39:32We didn't touch on it.
2:39:33We don't have time.
2:39:34Everybody listening to us surely has heard and read an enormous amount of stuff this
2:39:40week post-election about advertising and Facebook and Google and the pressures on advertisers
2:39:48and media sites and fake news and just the way that advertising, even when the money is there,
2:39:53can be a problematic influence. If you're bothered by that, things like direct membership support at
2:40:01Six Colors is the way to act and to actually just do a little thing that can actually help make
2:40:08quality. As far as I know, you don't publish fake news.
2:40:17I try not to. I try very hard.
2:40:19- It's a great way to do it.
2:40:20- Although, you know, that's, yeah, I mean, let's see.
2:40:23Let's see, maybe fake news is my future, but I hope not.
2:40:26- And, you know, my friend Jason Kotke
2:40:28just started a similar thing at kotke.org.
2:40:31I signed up like five minutes after he launched it,
2:40:33like sight unseen.
2:40:34- He emailed me and asked me how mine went
2:40:38and how it worked and stuff like that.
2:40:41It was pretty funny.
2:40:41So when he launched, I was like, oh yes,
2:40:43because, you know, he asked,
2:40:44'cause he's using very much the same system.
2:40:46- And I was like, hell yeah, I'm in.
2:40:48So anybody who likes independent media,
2:40:51like the work that Jason's doing and that Kaki's doing,
2:40:54and you know, go sign up.
2:40:56Anyway, thank you so much, Jason.
2:40:58I really appreciate it.
2:40:59Talk to you next time. - Thanks, John.