0:00:00This argument is why we're going to stop being friends.
0:00:02Like one day we're going to get drunk and get really mad about this.
0:00:04I think we have.
0:00:06I think we probably we probably have.
0:00:08Like like in a way that like,
0:00:11you know, maybe other guys would get in a fight over,
0:00:13you know, sports or a girl or something like that, like,
0:00:16you know, getting fights over Celsius versus Fahrenheit.
0:00:20Right. Yeah.
0:00:22You're the only person I know who I can't convince that,
0:00:25OK, at least it makes sense for temperature.
0:00:28Yeah, you can't convince me because it doesn't make sense.
0:00:30It's just anyway, whatever.
0:00:33I don't want to get into it, but it's, it's a, in the nineties, way too hot in
0:00:38the hundreds, dangerously hot in the eighties, nice and warm.
0:00:42Honestly, I kind of believe you.
0:00:45I get it.
0:00:47I really do.
0:00:47Especially as I spend more time in, in the States.
0:00:51I, I really do.
0:00:53And I can't leave this close circle of you, me, and all of you listeners.
0:01:00So I do get it.
0:01:03But the arguments for it make no sense, man.
0:01:07It's all about what you're accustomed to.
0:01:09I totally agree that for anything else, for doctors, you go to the hospital,
0:01:13they should do everything in Celsius.
0:01:16All science, obviously, should be conducted in Celsius or Kelvin
0:01:20or whatever scale makes sense.
0:01:21but for talking about the weather.
0:01:23Fahrenheit's the bomb.
0:01:25So, trying to get away from this a little bit,
0:01:29Apple introduced a whole bunch of new APIs
0:01:33this last cycle for different
0:01:37measurements. And one of them was temperature.
0:01:41What do you think the system they used was?
0:01:45Probably Celsius.
0:01:49Kelvin. Kelvin? Huh? Yeah, because I wanted it to be Celsius because I want it to be like,
0:01:54"Hey, screw you, John." But no, it was Kelvin, which makes sense because zero in Kelvin is like...
0:02:00It's absolute zero, right? It's absolute zero. Yeah, there is. I mean, there's...
0:02:06So it's the... There are no... Nothing moves there. There is no... Like, it is zero-zero. It's not like
0:02:12water gets cold. It's like... Right. Done. Yeah. Yeah, that makes some sense. It's sort of like,
0:02:19you know, the equivalent of keeping time from the epoch.
0:02:23Yes, yeah. Although, yeah, right, like you got to pick an amateur date kind of thing.
0:02:28So, right, yeah. I got some follow-up. I don't know if you
0:02:31listened to my last show with Jason. Jason Snell was on, and we got
0:02:35talking about mechanical keyboards. Yeah. And I expressed my
0:02:43frustration with the fact that there's, you get into mechanical keyboards,
0:02:47I got into them and I like the Apple Extended 2.
0:02:51I don't know what kind of switches. I think they're made by a company called Alps.
0:02:54But you don't have to choose. I just know that I like the Apple Extended 2 keyboard.
0:03:00I used it when I was a kid. I owned one since I was 19 years old.
0:03:06This is one thing where I... I mean, honestly, really only the temperature thing is where I think you're off your rocker.
0:03:12But you were totally right about that keyboard.
0:03:15I think you have a weird obsession with it.
0:03:17Like I move with the times.
0:03:19Right.
0:03:19It is a weird, but I admire, I admire your dedication to that one keyboard.
0:03:24Well, Jason and I, Jason, I've got talking about modern mechanical keyboards and
0:03:28you buy like a new USB one.
0:03:29And when you buy them, you get the choice between different switches.
0:03:33So, and there's other companies too, but the famous company is Cherry.
0:03:36This company Cherry makes mechanical keyboard switches and they make blue
0:03:41ones, red ones, brown ones, clear ones, black ones, and I think green ones. And how
0:03:50do you choose? And there's descriptions of them and they play, you
0:03:52go to the website and they have little sounds and you can listen to them, but
0:03:55that listening to the click of a keyboard is nothing like actually using
0:03:59it. A couple of readers, this is the follow-up, a couple of readers sent in that
0:04:03there's a company called, I don't know how you pronounce it, WASD keyboards. W-A-S-D
0:04:08keyboards. Those are the movement keys for games like Doom or
0:04:15Quake or if it's a Mac. Oh man, it's a classic Mac one. Mac Shooter.
0:04:21It's the Bungie guys from way back in the day and I'm
0:04:27blanking on it right now. You know what's funny? It's been so long since I was
0:04:30in the games I didn't realize that that's where they got the company name
0:04:32from. But that is exactly what I'm guessing. If you look at their logo.
0:04:38It makes no sense. So WASD keyboards. They sell a product that is amazing. It is called the Wads-D
0:04:466-Key Cherry MX Switch Tester. You pay 15 bucks and it's not like an electrical device. It's just
0:04:52like a piece of metal with one of each of the six types of switches on top and the clear key cap.
0:04:58And then they also send you a pack of these O-ring dampeners. They're just like little rubber band
0:05:04type things that you can optionally put into the key to sort of dampen the clickiness, the sound of it.
0:05:09For 15 bucks, it's a great thing. I have no idea if I'm even going to buy one of these keyboards,
0:05:15but I instantly bought this thing for 15 bucks. It came in like two days.
0:05:18Marathon, just before Syracuse gets mad at me. It was Marathon.
0:05:25Yeah, anyway, so sorry, 15 bucks. Marathon was the last time I really got into a 3D game.
0:05:30I was deeply obsessed with Marathon.
0:05:33Cool.
0:05:33And that was before the gaming part of my brain rotted away.
0:05:37Anyway, this sample kit, highly recommend it.
0:05:39I will put it in the show notes.
0:05:41Very fun if you're curious about the different types of key caps.
0:05:45But it's also-- it makes it very fun, in my opinion, desk toy.
0:05:48I like to just have it here.
0:05:49Now I've got a keyboard where I can just sit here and click keys,
0:05:51and I'm not doing anything on screen.
0:05:54That's cool.
0:05:55I think what I like-- if I were going to buy one of these keyboards,
0:05:58I think what I would get is the cherry brown switches, probably with the dampener in there.
0:06:05And it feels to me—
0:06:06Oh, you'd go with the dampener. Interesting.
0:06:07I think so. It's very hard to tell. I almost wish that I didn't have to choose whether I got the dampener.
0:06:12Yeah. You know what I love about this? It's a real nerd connoisseur kind of thing.
0:06:16Like, most people on Earth do not care.
0:06:21No.
0:06:22But the people who care, care a lot.
0:06:24Yeah.
0:06:24Like, you know, like you're going to be pulling your hair out trying to make a decision to go with the damper or not.
0:06:29You know?
0:06:30Well, and the other thing I found out, and this WASD company has a very good FAQ on their website.
0:06:35So the other thing that I found out is that it's not quite the decision between these six key cap or key switch colors isn't quite as complex as you think.
0:06:44There's really only three types.
0:06:46The blue, the brown, and I forget what the other one to the default is.
0:06:54I think it might be the black.
0:06:55But the idea is that the--
0:06:57or the red, I guess.
0:06:58The three main ones are the blue, the brown, and the red.
0:07:02And then the other three, each one of them
0:07:05corresponds to one of the other two
0:07:07and just requires a little bit more force to activate.
0:07:11It has a spring that has more resistance.
0:07:17So it takes a little bit more force to push it.
0:07:19And when you're done pushing it, it
0:07:22will push the key back up faster. Apparently gamers, a lot of gamers, prefer the ones with
0:07:26more resistance because they feel like they can hit the key faster because it springs
0:07:32up a little bit faster. That's interesting. So the black one is the red with more resistance.
0:07:39The clear one is the brown with more resistance and the green one is the blue with more resistance.
0:07:46So there you go. You've learned something every day.
0:07:50So what do you like about the travel? The sound?
0:07:54I mean, it's just satisfying. I feel the sound is like an
0:07:58artifact of you actually liking to type on the thing, right?
0:08:02It's just a tactile satisfaction.
0:08:06There's something satisfying to me about clicking an actual button.
0:08:10Yeah, okay, but more so than like, well, whatever
0:08:14looking at now like the Apple magic. Did they call a magic keyboard?
0:08:17Yeah. You know, the standard Apple keyboard, like, yeah,
0:08:21I think they're called the magic keyboard to now. Okay. Which is not a bad,
0:08:25these guys have like very little travel. They're basically laptop keyboard,
0:08:28right. But you know, with a little bit of extra travel just because they can
0:08:32little bit, yeah. They can afford it in the space. Right. And I, you know,
0:08:37I will offer, you know, when I travel, I don't take a mechanical keyboard with me.
0:08:40I just type on a MacBook for as long as it takes.
0:08:44I mean, it's not like I'm a princess who
0:08:46can't sleep on a mattress if there's a pee underneath.
0:08:51But I do feel the pee.
0:08:54I just still sleep right on top of it.
0:08:56It's like, OK, I'm going to deal with it.
0:08:58Anyway, that's my follow-up.
0:08:59I highly recommend it.
0:09:00Hopefully this company will be overwhelmed with requests
0:09:04from talk show listeners buying these switch testers.
0:09:07And like I said, it's a very fun little desk toy, in my opinion.
0:09:11Yeah, I'm going to probably check one out.
0:09:13That's cool.
0:09:14All right, I wanted to talk-- here's a piece from earlier this month
0:09:17that I specifically wanted to talk to you about, because I feel like your
0:09:19sensibility might be--
0:09:21you might have an interesting take on this.
0:09:23Earlier this month, during--
0:09:25I forget which beta release, but the betas for iOS and Mac, Sierra,
0:09:32macOS Sierra, were updated.
0:09:34And one of the changes-- they made some changes to the emoji,
0:09:37and the one that was controversial, I wrote about it, a lot of people wrote about it,
0:09:41is that Apple changed the, it's called the pistol, I mean a lot, most people maybe call it the gun,
0:09:46but like the official Unicode name is pistol, they changed it from a realistic uh revolver type gun
0:09:53to a uh toy like space gun. Water pistol. Oh no, is it a, it's a water pistol, that's right. It's a
0:09:59water, well it looks like a water pistol to me, I mean whatever, use your own interpretation. No,
0:10:05I think it definitely does. When you make it big, you can definitely see it's a water pistol.
0:10:08It's Microsoft that used to have a ZAP gun, that's right.
0:10:10So they made it a toy water pistol.
0:10:12Oh, Microsoft.
0:10:14So wait, what's the question?
0:10:17Well, what do you think about it?
0:10:19I mean, the controversy is...
0:10:22Let me try to summarize it.
0:10:24I'd say one angle on it is...
0:10:26This is the nanny state.
0:10:29They're coddling us.
0:10:31Whatever problems there are with real guns in the world,
0:10:34The problem is when actual guns are fired and actual bullets rip through actual human flesh.
0:10:41A picture of it, a cartoon picture of a gun that you send as a text message is an abstraction.
0:10:48And it would be, you know, what's the difference between not showing the emoji
0:10:52or not allowing you to type the character string "G-U-N" in it.
0:10:57I think that would be the expression of the opposition to this that I've seen.
0:11:02And then the second opposition, which is less politically charged, it's more of a linguistic
0:11:08argument, is if all other major platforms render this code point as a realistic gun,
0:11:19and I send a string of emoji that includes the gun, it will have a different... it could
0:11:26be interpreted as having a different semantic meaning on iOS and Mac now compared to these
0:11:32other platforms. Yeah. That I might think that everybody sees it as a squirt gun and I send it
0:11:39to you and... Which is harmless and guess what? Right. Everybody else sees an actual gun which is
0:11:45not good. Right. So to the first argument, that's an argument for inaction.
0:11:53Yes, you're right. Okay, stupid emoji is not going to change anything and the gun's actually being
0:12:01fired in real life really do cause harm.
0:12:04But I don't see that as an argument for why you must keep the pistol emoji to be
0:12:10like a gun pistol, like a like a weapon rather than a squirt pistol.
0:12:16You know what I mean? Like it's the that argument is one that you're
0:12:21completing two different things and pistol isn't perfectly fine thing that you may
0:12:26want to represent an emoji.
0:12:28OK, maybe so.
0:12:30Also, a water pistol is something you may want to represent.
0:12:35It's purely a politically-cherished argument, I think, at least.
0:12:42And I think probably because this comes on the heels of the rifle emoji being rejected.
0:12:53Right, there was a proposal in the – like, every year there's some sort of process that the Unicode Consortium goes through
0:12:59where new characters are suggested for emoji.
0:13:03I guess for all of Unicode,
0:13:05you know that there might be some obscure language
0:13:09from a small tribe in Asia or South America
0:13:14or something like that,
0:13:15and they'll add glyphs to support their language or something.
0:13:18You can make all sorts of proposals.
0:13:20Unicode, it grows every year.
0:13:21And one of the proposals that I guess was pretty far along
0:13:26was the rifle.
0:13:27And some point last year, Apple said,
0:13:30we are not going to implement this.
0:13:32Whether it passes or not, we're not going to implement it.
0:13:34And as soon as Apple said that, it was dropped.
0:13:37- Yeah, was it Apple uniquely?
0:13:40Or was it like Apple and Google and Microsoft are like,
0:13:43nah, we're not gonna do it.
0:13:45Maybe Apple said it first and everybody was like,
0:13:47yeah, you know what, we don't need this.
0:13:49- Right.
0:13:50I'll have to look that up.
0:13:53But I think--
0:13:54- I think you're right.
0:13:55Certainly all the articles I read said it was Apple, but I don't know if it was just...
0:13:59Apple might have, at the very least, might have led the way.
0:14:02Yeah, yeah. That was my understanding at least, but that could be biased.
0:14:08I'm okay with that. Do we really need a rifle emoji?
0:14:10And look, I'm not a...
0:14:13You know, just to expose myself, I'm clearly not a gun advocate.
0:14:21But I do understand why you may, you know, there's a lot of really sensible and responsible gun owners out there.
0:14:31I don't think we need an emoji.
0:14:34No.
0:14:34It's kind of where it goes to.
0:14:38Yeah.
0:14:38And one of the things that really bugged me about the pistol was like this smiley face with a pistol next to itself, like for the suicide.
0:14:46Yeah.
0:14:47That's not cool.
0:14:48That's not funny.
0:14:50No.
0:14:51That's like a real... I mean, that happens a lot. There's what, 30,000 guns deaths in the US each year?
0:14:59Something like that? And a lot of those are suicides?
0:15:02I think suicide is the most common. Or at least it's very, very close.
0:15:07Almost certain it's the most common.
0:15:09And I understand that these are goofy little things and you're cracking a joke.
0:15:14And you can do "Die in a fire". Casey List does this all the time.
0:15:18He's got the little skull face and a fire.
0:15:22And I'm like, that's horrible.
0:15:26That is a horrible notion. I understand it's a phrase, and
0:15:30I look the other way, but since we're bringing up the topic, man,
0:15:34that's harsh. The suicide one is interesting, and I'm
0:15:38talking from memory here, so I might be wrong, but I'm very, very
0:15:42close to certain that I am correct here.
0:15:46It is a leading form of suicide, or maybe the, and especially for men.
0:15:52Men overwhelmingly choose to, if they choose to, often choose to use the firearms.
0:15:59And in countries where firearms have—
0:16:02Australia is the great example, because Australia used to have a gun culture very similar to the US
0:16:07in terms of guns per population.
0:16:10Outback, like the cowboy culture, literally, like very much the same kind of thing.
0:16:16And after a mass shooting, terrible mass shooting, I think in 1997,
0:16:22they legislated, they did like a massive gun buyback,
0:16:25where the government just bought back literally millions of guns.
0:16:29I don't know what they did with them, I don't know if they destroyed them or whatever.
0:16:32But it's a great, in terms of actually studying scientifically the effects of gun ownership,
0:16:38It's a tremendous case study because it used to have lots of guns and now they have very few and all sorts of guns are missing.
0:16:45And it's not obviously the suicide rate by firearms did go down, but actually this overall suicide rate went down because guns are a particularly easy way to do it.
0:16:57I mean, I don't want to get too dark here, but...
0:16:59Yeah, but I mean, if you're drunk and having a bad day and you have access to something that you know is going to do the job, you know.
0:17:07It doesn't hold water to say that if you ban guns that suicide will stay the same because people who want to kill themselves will just
0:17:13Find another way. It's actually there is statistical proof that I mean obviously some will but it's there's actually it's it's just too easy
0:17:20And it's the other, you know, terrible problem with it is that they're very effective. They they they work very well
0:17:26So a higher percentage of suicide attempts that are made with a with a firearm
0:17:30right, actually you end up killing yourself as compared to
0:17:36pills, for example, people who try to kill themselves by overdose.
0:17:39There's a tremendous number of them who survive because they just pass out and somebody finds them and they get medical attention.
0:17:46And it's a lot easier to recover from an overdose than it is to a gunshot.
0:17:51Yeah. Well, turns out a device made to kill things is good at killing things.
0:17:55Yeah.
0:17:57Not to be too... Man, you're gonna get some hate now.
0:17:59Well, I don't see how that's... I don't see how what we're saying is...
0:18:04It shouldn't be controversial.
0:18:05Right. I'm not saying that we should ban guns. I'm not either making that, you know, I'm just
0:18:10saying it's the truth though that if you want to accept the gun culture that we have it's going to
0:18:14result in higher suicides and much more effective argument solvers. And frankly, I mean, obviously,
0:18:22yeah, I do advocate for some kind of change, but I'm not like nobody should have any guns.
0:18:29In Canada, we have a lot of guns. We don't have the same kind of crazy gun culture. So,
0:18:34you can do it. The current state of the US gun laws is kind of bananas.
0:18:42I am kind of fascinated by emoji.
0:18:46Thank you for getting us off the topic.
0:18:50Well, when they first became a thing, I was a little skeptical.
0:18:54I think anybody who knows my style can tell I'm a little...
0:18:58I don't go for frivolous things. I was never a fan. I've never really made
0:19:02very extensive use of like ASCII smileys, you know, like colon dash parentheses to make a smiley.
0:19:11And that even in text messages to me, you don't do that.
0:19:15Right, and I used to turn...
0:19:16Maybe in Aubergine every now and then.
0:19:18So I was never big on smileys. And the first... the way that emoji sort of crept up on me was
0:19:24like with iMessage or what iChat I guess it used to be called at the time, was there I think by
0:19:29default it would automatically turn certain character sequences into smileys
0:19:33and this was before we called them emoji and there was a limited set. I think that
0:19:37the set character set came from AIM actually, like it was like an AOL
0:19:41instant messenger thing, but different character sequences would turn into
0:19:44different smileys and I turned that off. But there were, you know, you'd run into
0:19:49them accidentally sometimes. There were certain character sequences that you, like
0:19:53if you were, I don't know, if you were pasting like source code or something
0:19:56that to somebody, you know, the semicolon and a thing would somehow turn into a smiley and it
0:20:01wouldn't make any sense. But once the, you know, the full emoji set, I sort of, you know, I'm sort
0:20:06of fascinated because I feel like people are expressing themselves in a way, like, it must be
0:20:11like a field day to be like a linguistic researcher to study this because people take to them naturally,
0:20:16you know, and you've mentioned Casey Liss, you know, who's, you know, like, an idiot savant.
0:20:23He's a very nice guy.
0:20:25In written English, he's barely literate.
0:20:28I mean, it's very tough to make any heads or tails out of his writing in English prose,
0:20:34but he can express himself fluently in emoji.
0:20:37That's true. That is the most true thing anybody's ever said about poor case limits.
0:20:41And I think it's fascinating, people who are good at it. And I use them.
0:20:45There are certain ones that are very fun.
0:20:51I do think though, I think it's interesting and I think that it is a form of real communication
0:20:57and it conveys emotion much better than prose, especially in very short form.
0:21:03I mean it's no surprise that they get mostly used in text messages.
0:21:06Text messages and Twitter kind of thing.
0:21:09Right. And you can convey things like if somebody says, "Hey, I got the job."
0:21:16They've been trying to get a job at a place and they got it.
0:21:20and you send them the two beers clinking emoji, it's a very, very quick and efficient way of saying,
0:21:27"Hey, congratulations!" And maybe, "Hey, let's meet up and have a beer and celebrate." You can convey
0:21:33that with one character. Yeah, congratulations and celebration, like all in one. Yeah,
0:21:38I totally agree with you. There is, to me, although, even though I do think it's a serious
0:21:43form of expression, to me they are inherently frivolous. And that to me is where, to me,
0:21:50taking out the the realistic pistol is to me okay, because I think that there is an inherent
0:21:56frivolousness to emoji, and that they're best used for... and if you look at them, most of them,
0:22:01overwhelmingly, they're mostly like expressing things that are either completely innocuous,
0:22:09like strawberry or you know it's like surfing right some weird random like the woman dancing
0:22:18or yeah it it's which is a little weird because well they're they're finally expanding their
0:22:23female representation right but yeah it's all happy and good and uh like a rifle and a
0:22:31you know like a pistol it's an ill-suited it's an ill-suited language for expressing
0:22:39negative things, in my opinion.
0:22:43I agree. Now that could just be because culturally
0:22:47I haven't grown up with guns and guns are not a thing in my life.
0:22:51Maybe a goofy pistol is funny.
0:22:55And maybe we're
0:22:59now doing the thing where
0:23:03eventually people look back at Looney Tunes and are like, "Oh man,
0:23:07I know, yeah.
0:23:08We gotta cut a lot of these scenes.
0:23:10Right.
0:23:10Which I hated, by the way.
0:23:12But, I mean, we don't need a pistol pistol.
0:23:16Water pistol's fine.
0:23:17Whatever you want to express as a joke with a pistol,
0:23:21you can express with a water pistol.
0:23:23I loved the Looney Tunes.
0:23:25The Looney Tunes were one of my--
0:23:26Me too! That was some horrible stuff.
0:23:28But they had an entire character.
0:23:30Yosemite Sam.
0:23:31The entire basis of his character was that.
0:23:33Yeah.
0:23:34Yeah, yes.
0:23:35He was so gun crazy that he had two guns.
0:23:38Like one gun wasn't enough for somebody to say, man, I love that guy.
0:23:42Yeah.
0:23:43And while he go to karate died in like every way possible.
0:23:47That was horrible.
0:23:48Who was your favorite?
0:23:50Who's your favorite living?
0:23:51Oh, um, I'm blanking.
0:23:53Uh, uh, the giant chicken, foghorn, leghorn, this is why, this is why
0:23:59we're going like horn is exact.
0:24:01Thank you.
0:24:01I forgot his name.
0:24:02This is why we're friends.
0:24:03He was my absolute favorite.
0:24:05He is, I swear to God, like a year ago, maybe two years ago.
0:24:09I can't remember.
0:24:10I spent an entire night just watching fuck one, like one on YouTube.
0:24:14I was like, this is, he's the best.
0:24:16Why the hell was he so big?
0:24:17I don't know why he's so big.
0:24:19It was like seven feet tall.
0:24:21Yeah.
0:24:22And yeah, I love it.
0:24:24He's like a total asshole to like the dog that's tied up.
0:24:28Like the dog, this basically, I guess mentally you're a guard, everything is
0:24:33tied up and all he does is like he wakes up in the morning and he goes and he
0:24:37stands just outside the line of where the dogs leash, lets him go.
0:24:41And he just baits the dog into charging at him and then laughs.
0:24:45He's such a asshole.
0:24:48I always love a fog horn like going.
0:24:53He was definitely my best.
0:24:54Yeah.
0:24:55And a chicken Hawk who the ad they added later was like teeny tiny.
0:25:01Yeah.
0:25:01Yeah.
0:25:02But he was like this, like, uh, you know, like rough,
0:25:06like he always wanted to get in a scrap kind of guy. So good.
0:25:10The other thing about the dog was that the dog was a worthy adversary.
0:25:14Oh yeah. Yeah. He wasn't a dummy. He was just tied up half the time.
0:25:18Like what are you going to do? Apparently his name,
0:25:20his name was just barnyard dog, but it was spelled D A W G
0:25:25dog. Oh, this gives it the Southern drawl. Barnyard dog.
0:25:31Yeah, that was the other thing. I mean, just Fokker and Leggon's voice was hilarious.
0:25:36And the dog sometimes got him back.
0:25:40Just like his delivery, like, "Oh, God."
0:25:42It was gut--oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
0:25:44Not even sometimes.
0:25:46Like, it seemed like a fair fight to me.
0:25:48Yeah.
0:25:49As opposed to, like, the Roadrunner and Wile E.
0:25:53Coyote.
0:25:54Yeah.
0:25:54Which was good, too.
0:25:55Wile E.
0:25:55Coyote is a bit of a tragic--you know, he's kind of a tragedy, though.
0:25:59Right.
0:26:00But the Roadrunner would never do anything mean to him.
0:26:03No, he did it. He always did it.
0:26:06It would just backfire.
0:26:08Did you ever read the rules?
0:26:10There were the written rules of the Roadrunner.
0:26:14I think I did years ago.
0:26:16I'll have to put it.
0:26:17I'll put it in the show notes, but the rules are brilliant.
0:26:19And it was almost like writing the script for a Roadrunner
0:26:24Coyote short was almost like a logic puzzle because you had to follow this very, very
0:26:32specific list of rules. And one of them, there's things that I never even really thought of,
0:26:37was that one of them is that the Roadrunner never leaves the road. No matter what happens,
0:26:42because he's a Roadrunner. Everything that ever happened in all of those Wile E. Coyote
0:26:49Roadrunner shorts, he never once left the road.
0:26:51I hadn't even noticed that. That's cool. That makes sense.
0:26:55Yeah, that's great. It's like the cartoon version of Asimov's
0:27:00three little robots. You set up a structure and then
0:27:07you debug it, basically, by like... your story is like, "well, see how this went wrong?"
0:27:12Yeah, and I think one of the rules is that every bad thing that happens to the
0:27:15coyote has to be his own doing. I would totally believe that.
0:27:18It seems that, I mean, that's what I took away from it.
0:27:21So because, and he's not even a bad guy, really.
0:27:27Well, I guess he does want to eat the roadrunner, but I think he's just hungry.
0:27:31He's hungry. Yeah. I'm sorry. He's got to eat something.
0:27:34I don't, what is, I don't, yeah.
0:27:37And he falls off cliffs and gets blown up.
0:27:40And it's like horrible. The things that happened to him are the worst.
0:27:44Like he falls off a cliff and then a giant boulder falls on it.
0:27:47It's like as if that wasn't enough.
0:27:50Let me take a break and thank our first sponsors, our good friends at Casper.
0:27:57Casper is an obsessively engineered mattress and they sell them at shockingly
0:28:01fair prices. Go to casper.com/the-talk-show and just, uh,
0:28:06I think you automatically get it by going to that URL,
0:28:08but the code is the talk show and you will save 50 bucks towards your mattress.
0:28:13Casper created one perfect mattress.
0:28:16They don't have to choose what type of foam you want,
0:28:20what type of springs you want.
0:28:21They've got one.
0:28:22They spent years.
0:28:23They spent a lot of money.
0:28:24They really do.
0:28:25They have engineers who just went into
0:28:27what is the perfect default mattress.
0:28:31They ended up with a combination of springy latex
0:28:34and supportive memory foam for a sleep surface
0:28:36with just the right sink, just the right bounce.
0:28:38So you don't have to choose.
0:28:39Who wants to?
0:28:40It's like you don't have to get
0:28:41one of those six keycap testers for six types of mattresses from Casper. They've got one
0:28:46type, exactly what you want. It's not like buying one of these mechanical keyboards.
0:28:50One type of mattress, you just pick the size. And because they make them, and they manufacture
0:28:57them right here in the United States, they make them and sell them directly to you. This
0:29:03is how they get away with charging, in a lot of comparisons, half the price of a premium
0:29:09mattress that you would buy at a mattress store. Most premium mattresses
0:29:14start at over 1,500 bucks. Casper's start at just 500 bucks for twin and they go
0:29:19up to just 950 for a king, 850 for a queen, and they're made right here in
0:29:25America. There's a cool thing too if you live in New York City, I don't know if
0:29:28you've ever seen pictures of this, but if you live in New York City they deliver
0:29:31them to you on a bicycle. There's just, I mean it is a big box to be carrying
0:29:34around on your back on a bicycle, but you can get like same-day delivery in
0:29:38in Manhattan, maybe elsewhere in New York, which is kind of amazing. They show up in your house
0:29:44in these ridiculously small boxes. Big box, like probably the biggest box you'll get all year,
0:29:49delivered to your house, but considering that it contains a mattress, it's remarkably small.
0:29:53Simple instructions on the box. Bring it up to the room, the bedroom where you're going to put it.
0:29:57Open the box the right way and it just sucks all the oxygen out of the room and next thing you know
0:30:02you've got a full-size mattress. They have, and this is the whole key to buying a mattress without
0:30:07trying it in a store or just taking the word from me, John Q.
0:30:12Podcaster, that these are good mattresses.
0:30:14And they are very good mattresses.
0:30:16But they have a 100-night home trial.
0:30:17So you buy it, open it up, sleep on it for three months.
0:30:22And if you don't love it, you just go on the web, go back,
0:30:25and with no questions asked, no hard sell,
0:30:27they don't make you sit there and try to convince you to keep it.
0:30:31They'll just say, OK.
0:30:32And they'll come and pick it up, and you get your money back.
0:30:34So you can't lose.
0:30:36It is the easiest way to buy a mattress and you get a terrific mattress.
0:30:40So go to Casper.com/thetalkshow and remember that code,
0:30:44the talk show, and you will save 50 bucks on their already amazing prices.
0:30:48So this is honestly not part of the pitch, but, uh, they,
0:30:55uh, they started selling dog beds.
0:30:58Is that true? I did not know that.
0:31:00I hope they're not mad at you because I'm muddying the water or something,
0:31:03But yeah, they started selling dog beds.
0:31:06And that seems pretty cool to me.
0:31:07Yeah.
0:31:08Yeah.
0:31:09Well, that's a good idea.
0:31:10Similar kind of technology and a good cover so the dog doesn't just eat the whole thing.
0:31:15[LAUGHTER]
0:31:17But yeah, no, it's pretty cool.
0:31:19Your dog's got to sleep somewhere.
0:31:21Yeah.
0:31:22May as well sleep on the best.
0:31:24Yeah.
0:31:24Anything else on the-- you don't want to go back to the emoji, do you?
0:31:30I think we covered it.
0:31:32Yeah.
0:31:32Oh, the second point was that the inter-OS operability.
0:31:38Yeah, we talked about that before, but we would talk about a smiley face.
0:31:43Like the one with the teeth.
0:31:45Yeah. Apple has a... it's like a grinning face that looks almost exactly like their grimacing face, except the eyes are different.
0:31:56And on other platforms, the grinning face is clearly somebody who is happy,
0:32:01whereas the apple one really looks like somebody who is grimacing for whatever reason.
0:32:06Yeah, like if I pick it out, I pick it out because it looks like it's sucking your teeth.
0:32:10Yeah, like the face you would make if you just
0:32:14talked bad about somebody and you found out they're standing right behind you.
0:32:18Yes, exactly. Yeah. But it's different platforms render them in different ways, so that sucks.
0:32:25So yeah, the water pistol doesn't convey the same notion.
0:32:30But it's fine. I think it'll all get sorted out.
0:32:36The other thing is, man, poor Microsoft. Those guys.
0:32:41They had the right idea. They had a ray gun.
0:32:43And now they changed it to a pistol the day that Apple changed it to a water pistol.
0:32:48I actually think, and the worst part about that, not only did they change it the wrong way, or at least just keep up with Apple.
0:32:54To me, yeah. To our tastes.
0:32:57Well, and not just to our tastes, but it is true that the iPhone is so singularly popular
0:33:05that what Apple does, their user base is arguably the leading,
0:33:13or at least in the Western world, is the leading users of emoji.
0:33:19So it really does matter, disproportionately, what Apple does.
0:33:22Yeah, I'd agree with that.
0:33:26I mean, for as many tens of hundreds of millions of people
0:33:30who are using Windows and sending emoji on them, there's more people using
0:33:34iOS devices. And Android is splintered
0:33:38because Samsung has their own set,
0:33:42different Android makers have their own sets of emoji, they don't all just
0:33:46use the default Google ones. So even though there might be more users
0:33:50of Android in "Android" is so splintered that there's no single base the way that iOS does.
0:34:02Right. And Android splintering is not helping.
0:34:10Pick a metric. Pick some avenue that you want to talk about.
0:34:15like almost always it's like oh yeah but Android is not one thing it's just right
0:34:20it's that that's the best way to think about it though if you stop thinking
0:34:23about it as though it is one thing it's it's you know it makes more sense I do
0:34:28think I also think I personally I think Microsoft had a better idea yeah going
0:34:33with a ray gun than the water gun because I think a water gun I think 90
0:34:38some percent of cases it won't make much difference but a water gun is a little
0:34:41bit more specific where you could combine it with like the splashing water drops.
0:34:48Yeah. Right? And then that will make any sense at all with other platforms.
0:34:54Whereas if you went with the Ray Gun, I don't really think there's any context
0:34:58where you could use it with other emoji where it changes things that much.
0:35:02Just sort of puts a more frivolous spin on the idea of a pistol. Yeah, I agree.
0:35:08And I... you know what, I'm gonna say I do know, but I'm not sure if I know, because I'm pretty sure I saw it.
0:35:17But the water pistol emoji used to be flipped the other way.
0:35:21Yeah, and apparently...
0:35:22Internally. Before they shipped it, it was like going the other way.
0:35:25So... which would have really broken everything.
0:35:29Yeah, because it would matter if you were saying you want to shoot...
0:35:34Shoot to the left or shoot to the right.
0:35:36Right, and you're putting an emoji that's what you want to shoot, you know.
0:35:40Yeah.
0:35:41And I kind of like the fact that they made it the other way,
0:35:46just because it literally breaks any of that.
0:35:50You're shooting at the wrong thing, and that's a very personal, political thing.
0:35:56I think it is smarter that they probably flipped it back to the left at this point.
0:36:00So it at least faces the same way as all the other pistols.
0:36:04And I think Craig Hockenberry pointed this out, is that the Unicode spec specifically mentions that it should be pointing one way.
0:36:20Yeah, I think it does. We could say this a bit. Craig knows more about emoji than we'll ever know, because the Icon Factory has done the emoji sets for a couple of companies.
0:36:33Yeah, big companies. Companies that everybody knows.
0:36:38So they've done a lot of, as you might expect from a company,
0:36:43the entire name is based on drawing icons. They've drawn a lot of emoji.
0:36:48And Craig, while he's not drawing the emoji, is obviously
0:36:53the point person on making sure that all the hexadecimal code points
0:36:58and etc. are. Yeah, well, he made his own internal awesome tool to make those fonts.
0:37:07Of course he did. Because they're fonts, right? Like, it's still a font. So, yeah, so he made an awesome tool for it.
0:37:12All right, moving on. What else can we talk about?
0:37:18How about, did you read the Steven Levy piece for Backchannel with a profile of Apple's AI
0:37:26and "machine learning" work?
0:37:29I did a little bit, yeah. I read it.
0:37:32I haven't read all of the subsequent follow-ups of
0:37:36trying to frame it in different ways.
0:37:39So the gist of it is that Stephen Levy,
0:37:43I think it's Levy, I don't know if it's Levy, Stephen Levy. I know him, I should know.
0:37:47I should know him.
0:37:50Also, seems like a smart guy to me. He's been in the racket forever.
0:37:54forever. So, right. Yeah. Has written some great, great books, including, uh, what was the name of the iPod book? The iPod book was amazing. Oh, yeah. It was like, perfect. Horrible names. But yeah. He's written books. He has written about cryptography. He is, you know, again, he's smart guys been around for, right. As long as I've been following this stuff, he's been a go to, like,
0:38:23A name worth trusting.
0:38:25The iPod book was called "The Perfect Thing."
0:38:27Oh, cool. Man, that's a good name.
0:38:29Yeah, really it was.
0:38:31So he was somehow obtained, whether it was offered to him or whether it was him asking,
0:38:38but it was probably a combination of the two through Apple PR,
0:38:41was granted exclusive access to Apple's executive leadership on AI and machine learning in Siri,
0:38:49Siri, which is Eddie Q and Greg Federighi, of course.
0:38:55And then two other guys who--
0:38:58one of them's name, I do remember, is Tom Gruber, which is, just for the record,
0:39:05no relation.
0:39:07And another guy whose name escapes me, but he's in charge of the voice stuff.
0:39:12Bob English, I think.
0:39:15Alex Sera.
0:39:16Oh, I missed your joke because I'm looking for his name.
0:39:19Yeah, it's too funny. Too funny for anybody to notice.
0:39:22Alex Asiro. He's in charge of voice recognition.
0:39:28I saw people complain that this was a quote-unquote--
0:39:30a lot of people say it's a PR puff piece. I saw the words "PR puff piece"
0:39:35at least, I don't know, 20 times in response to this. And of course
0:39:39there's a certain truth to that in terms of
0:39:43it's not like Steven Levy got free access for a year
0:39:48to just be a fly on the wall and watch the team work.
0:39:52He, you know, he got like one day of access to what Apple had planned as almost, you know,
0:40:00like a presentation of here's what we will reveal to you and talk to you about.
0:40:04And so of course, what Apple revealed and talked to about was meant to, you know, make Apple look good.
0:40:10Right.
0:40:11There's no other way around it.
0:40:12But I mean, the alternative is that Steven Levy declines to do the story,
0:40:19and I feel like the world is a worse place.
0:40:21I'm not saying that this is inaccurate, that it's not a slanted look at it.
0:40:27It's obviously what Apple was willing to reveal.
0:40:29But there's a lot of interesting stuff in the article, I thought.
0:40:33Yeah, I agree with you.
0:40:35There's a difference between being a minion and reporting and letting everybody know the circumstances under which you got the information or you had the conversations.
0:40:49Right.
0:40:49You know what I mean?
0:40:50I think there's a false equivalence between—
0:40:56I'm very carefully trying to pick my words here—
0:41:02between a press that is very politically aligned
0:41:07and a press that gets some kind of access
0:41:13and lets you know they had that kind of access
0:41:16and then tells you what was said.
0:41:19Right. The context of the access is right there in the story, and you can judge it, be a critical reader, and judge it for what you will.
0:41:27Exactly. That's the baseline. Always be a critical leader.
0:41:30But, I don't know. Especially with this current political cycle going on in the US.
0:41:39Gauging the press is like, no, it's not always easy, but you shouldn't just throw everybody in one bucket and be like,
0:41:50"Well, I don't believe anything that anybody says."
0:41:54And he's very upfront and I think he makes it very clear exactly what the context was.
0:42:02And that's what you need as an intelligent, critical reader to make your own decision.
0:42:10Right. And it's not like if you read it—and I read it very thoroughly—but it's not like Steven Levy was trying to make the argument that Siri is perfect or even great or far ahead of the competition.
0:42:25Apple might be making that argument, and he might quote them saying it, but he's not.
0:42:32Again, Steven Levy has been around the block before.
0:42:34I mean, he's very, very well-sourced at Google in particular.
0:42:41Also, Steven Levy is the type of guy who writes stuff that really stands up over time.
0:42:49The value of this article might be better 10, 15,
0:42:5220 years from now than it is today in terms of looking at either where things went wrong for Apple or where, you know, the beginning of where things went right in their AI and, you know, it's written for the long term.
0:43:04Yeah. And you write about it. He wrote In the Plex, like a book about, and if anybody is looking for a book to read on a hot summer day, In the Plex is definitely worth reading.
0:43:18Right. That's his look inside Google.
0:43:20He's looking at Google.
0:43:22With extensive and long-term access that he was paying for.
0:43:24Oh yeah.
0:43:25Like it's, yeah.
0:43:27Like years, years worth of reporting in that.
0:43:30That's hard work.
0:43:31And he did it.
0:43:32So this interview or piece carries all the more weight
0:43:37because he's familiar with both companies.
0:43:40And I think among people who read our stuff, listen to our shows,
0:43:45people who are listening to us talk right now, I feel like,
0:43:48hey, is Siri good, bad, mixed bag, whatever, is probably one of the most contentious--
0:43:53you know, I worry a lot.
0:43:54I do, that me in particular and the type of people I have on the show,
0:44:00that we're all just preaching to the choir,
0:44:02and that we agree on so much of what's going on that--
0:44:06what's the point?
0:44:09I feel like that Siri and Apple's machine learning efforts and stuff
0:44:12like that is a great point where there's--
0:44:14I know that there are people listening right now who
0:44:16I think Syria is a big pile of dog shit.
0:44:18Yeah.
0:44:19And those are, I think, some of the people who are most frustrated with this article
0:44:23and think that it's a "PR puff piece" because how can this article keep going on and on
0:44:27and not say that Syria is garbage?
0:44:29Because they, for whatever reason, they think Syria is garbage.
0:44:32Which I disagree with.
0:44:34Well, there's two things here.
0:44:39I don't think you can just unequivocally say that.
0:44:42That's a value judgment, right? It's up to everybody else.
0:44:46Which, man, that sounds like wishy-washy.
0:44:50Because, yeah, it could be garbage. But it's not.
0:44:54It's in the field. It works. I think people use it all the time.
0:44:58It's in everything from the watch to now the Mac.
0:45:02Soon the Mac, it's in beta. The Apple TV.
0:45:06All the iOS stuff. Working pretty well.
0:45:10Now, does it answer everything perfectly? No.
0:45:13But I think it's more audacious.
0:45:17The aspirational goal is higher than I think something like the Amazon Echo is,
0:45:24which is what it often gets compared to.
0:45:27Or, you know what I don't hear a lot about now?
0:45:30It's Google Now.
0:45:32I just read a story that Google made a change somehow recently,
0:45:36recently and made something that they change in Google Now has a lot of people upset.
0:45:41I don't hear as much about that and I don't know why that is. I don't know if it's because I don't
0:45:46read enough Android stuff or... Maybe. We should talk to Vinay.
0:45:51Well, here's what I think. This goes unsaid
0:45:56in this article, but I do feel that the disadvantage that Google has with Now,
0:46:01And this might change coming up later this year because they pre-announced their echo-like
0:46:06device, the little home speaker system.
0:46:09But this whole AI bot assistant type thing, it makes intuitive sense.
0:46:18This is not a very profound observation, but as we go on and we live with these things,
0:46:24it's shown to be more and more true.
0:46:26It can't be part of an app.
0:46:27It has to be part of the system on the device.
0:46:30Yeah.
0:46:31You have to be able to say, "Hey, dingus," to your thing.
0:46:35It's like going to open the Google app on your iPhone first and then speaking into it.
0:46:42What's the point?
0:46:43The whole point of the voice-driven interface is that you don't have to fish an app out.
0:46:46Yeah, I'm coming to think that maybe apps are...
0:46:53Not a dead end, but it's like...
0:46:56It's not a path for this sort of voice.
0:46:58It's certainly not a path for this kind of thing.
0:47:02And we've had it for, what, 30 years now?
0:47:06Well, we've envisioned it since 1968 with HAL.
0:47:10Yeah. Oh, sorry, I just mean apps.
0:47:14Oh, apps. I'm like, maybe apps are like, maybe that shouldn't be the focus.
0:47:18And not necessarily do the OpenDoc thing.
0:47:22But we are totally right with HAL.
0:47:26Hal doesn't run apps? You don't ask Hal to, like, "Hal, launch the Podbador app."
0:47:32Right. Or launch the Hal app and then talk to Hal. No, he's just there.
0:47:37Right. That stupid Podbador app should have been updated, though.
0:47:44Before they went off to Jupiter, they really should have updated that sucker.
0:47:48I'll just read an example. Here's a tweet in my Twitter replies to me. I won't call the guy out because I think he's not asking to be called out. It's not rude.
0:48:00But there's a guy who sent me a tweet. What's Gruber? What's with Apple doing a press victory lap, I think he meant, about how great they think Syria is?
0:48:09It's laughably poor compared to anything else.
0:48:12I really disagree with that.
0:48:15I think there are clearly areas where, you know, I think what's interesting
0:48:19about this is that the big players in this are all better.
0:48:22They have different strengths and weaknesses.
0:48:26Yeah.
0:48:26Oh, yeah.
0:48:27Yeah.
0:48:27Which makes it cool, right?
0:48:29Right.
0:48:30I keep going back to a couple of examples.
0:48:34I have an Amazon Echo, you know, here in the kitchen, and I barely use it.
0:48:39But I think I'd use it more if we had more of the home automation stuff that you can hook up to it, like turning the lights on and stuff.
0:48:45Did you buy that? Or did you store it somehow?
0:48:47No, I bought it.
0:48:49Sorry, that's a weird question, but I'm trying to gauge your engagement with it, I guess.
0:48:55Yeah, but for example, if you ask the Echo and Alexa anything about the weather, all you get is the exact same canned weather report for where you are.
0:49:06are. So if you say, "What's the weather?" you get a weather report with
0:49:13like the expected highs and lows and whether it's gonna rain. And if you say,
0:49:16"What is the current temperature?" instead of giving you the temperature, you get
0:49:20the exact same weather report. You just can't let temperature go, man.
0:49:24I know. You can't let it go. It's in Celsius or Fahrenheit? It's in Fahrenheit.
0:49:28Oh well, so at least it's on the good side. Although I wonder what would
0:49:32happen if if I just said to you know hey dingus please please give me the
0:49:41temperature in Celsius instead of Fahrenheit from now on I wonder if that
0:49:44would work I'll have to try that but if you ask for the humidity you get the
0:49:50weather report and it the the weather report doesn't even include the
0:49:52humidity yeah so it understands that you asking about the humidity is you asking
0:49:57about the weather but the answer is just the same exact word-for-word canned
0:50:01weather report. If you ask Siri those questions, you get the actual answer. If you ask for the
0:50:07temperature, you just get the temperature. If you ask for the weather, you get a full weather
0:50:10report. And I even tried asking for the humidity, and Siri can tell you the current humidity.
0:50:15So there's an area where I could say unambiguously, Siri is better than Alexa.
0:50:21And on sports is another example where Alexa can tell you some basic stuff about sports,
0:50:26I think like scores and stuff like that. But Siri can tell you things like the Vegas betting odds
0:50:31and who's favored in a game.
0:50:34I mean, is that a big difference?
0:50:37I mean, for me it is, because I'm a gambling junkie.
0:50:39Yeah, no, I think it is.
0:50:40I mean, because I'm a gambling junkie.
0:50:46What's your tweet?
0:50:47I don't drink, I don't gamble.
0:50:50My only vice is buying a new iPhone every year,
0:50:54and that and lying about drinking and gambling.
0:50:59That's still the funniest one.
0:51:01It's a pretty clever little logical one.
0:51:03Yeah, I was like, "Oh, man, I was cracking up on the red dead."
0:51:07Yeah, I know. I think
0:51:11Siri seems to have
0:51:15a broader area that it aspires to cover.
0:51:19And perhaps in some
0:51:23place it doesn't cover it as well as what the more
0:51:27focused things do, which is interesting because Apple typically narrows things down to the solvable problems.
0:51:41Right. But in the case of Siri, it seems like they've gone deep.
0:51:46Like, it's interesting because they also bought the company that made Siri.
0:51:53So there could be a cultural divide a little bit there, which I don't know, but it's possible because
0:52:02you would think that Apple would be shipping something like the Echo, which does way less.
0:52:09But when you ask it to do something, does it?
0:52:11Right.
0:52:12And instead they've got this thing that when you ask it to do something, it will make a best effort to answer
0:52:21any spoken question and give you a good answer.
0:52:30Can you wrap your head around how hard that is?
0:52:33I couldn't do that.
0:52:34Well, I mean, I think--
0:52:35It's me like five of the things that Siri could help you with,
0:52:38and be like, I have no idea.
0:52:39I think all of us who've ever programmed,
0:52:42or at least if you started programming as a kid,
0:52:45have written, tried to write like a choose your own adventure type
0:52:50thing, you know, at least in the days when starting a program, meant you were around like a little command line,
0:52:55and you'd just build up a list of "if/then" statements for what the input was.
0:53:01Right, and that just doesn't work. Like, you'd have to have an exact match for every single input.
0:53:07You can do that, it's tedious, but that's not how Siri works.
0:53:10No.
0:53:12Well, and they're very, very ambitious about it.
0:53:15I mean, and they even have examples of things that work, where in this story, the Steven Levy story,
0:53:19Eddy Cue shows that with integrating with Square Cash,
0:53:23where he says, use Square Cash to send Jane $20.
0:53:27And Siri interprets it and opens Square, the Square Cash app,
0:53:31to send his wife $20.
0:53:34And he says it differently.
0:53:35He says, shoot $20 to my wife.
0:53:38He can call her Jane.
0:53:39He can call her his wife.
0:53:41He can say, send $20.
0:53:42He can say, shoot $20.
0:53:44I mean, shoot $20 is actually, linguistically,
0:53:47pretty advanced if it you know if that yeah you know yeah i would never say that but i could see
0:53:51somebody like i would understand it if somebody told me that i'd be like okay i get it like send
0:53:57them some money i don't even know how many of those things work like i even me as a being
0:54:03generally on the you know i'm on the positive end of the spectrum of where i think siri is i
0:54:07and i know that a lot of people aren't but i am i'm a fan and i think they're doing well even i
0:54:11might be underestimating like i wonder if you can like tell siri like to get my wife on the horn
0:54:16horn. Like would it know that you want to make a function?
0:54:21Yeah, that's like Trappi John in MASH.
0:54:25I would never think to try that with a computer.
0:54:28Oh, well, no. My dad says that all the time. My dad probably says get somebody on the horn more
0:54:33than he even says I talk to him on the phone. I love that expression. I really love that
0:54:38expression. That's old school. You would like my dad. I'm sure, yeah.
0:54:43should come to a family gathering.
0:54:46Exactly.
0:54:47Yeah, that is awesome.
0:54:49Especially because it evokes the old school headsets, right?
0:54:54Where you have to pick it up and there's no buttons on it.
0:54:57It's just a horn that you kind of stick to your head.
0:55:00Alright, here's the big question I have.
0:55:02Why does this article exist?
0:55:04Why did Apple agree to give Levy access to write this article?
0:55:09I don't know, they seem to have been on a PR blitz recently.
0:55:13Yeah, definitely. I mean, it's definitely, you know,
0:55:17big picture answer is this is part of the new, more open Tim Cook's apple.
0:55:21This is part of the apple where Craig Federighi and Phil Schiller
0:55:25go on this show, and Craig Federighi goes
0:55:29deep on stage in front of a live audience on the differential privacy,
0:55:33which is a big part of the same story. Oh yeah, no, no, yeah.
0:55:37The differential privacy is a huge part of this AI learning thing.
0:55:43I don't know.
0:55:44But old Apple not only wouldn't show up on Joe Random podcast and talk about it in front of a live audience,
0:55:51they wouldn't talk about differential privacy period.
0:55:53Well, at this point you're not Joe Random podcast.
0:55:56I know, I know. But they wouldn't have gone on my podcast six, seven, eight years ago and talked about this.
0:56:02And they wouldn't have talked in detail about how it worked.
0:56:05you know, that they didn't talk about how anything worked, really.
0:56:10Right.
0:56:10Right? That would have just been part of the black box.
0:56:13Yes. No, they would never talk about that. That shocked me, actually.
0:56:17Like, you're not in a bad way. I was happy for you.
0:56:21But like, the access that you got was like, "Ooh, that's pretty surprising."
0:56:25It's definitely, but maybe it shouldn't be.
0:56:28And I think that the fact that they're talking to Steven Levy shouldn't be surprising.
0:56:32I think that one of the aspects of Tim Cook's Apple, the new Open
0:56:39Apple, that is different from Steve Jobs' old Apple,
0:56:44isn't just that they're open for the sake of openness.
0:56:47I think it is very specific, and I
0:56:52think it is that they wish to be better understood as a company.
0:56:57And when they perceive that they are being misunderstood
0:57:02or that the conventional wisdom about X within Apple is wrong,
0:57:08they want to do what they can to correct that.
0:57:13Whereas I feel like with Jobs, it was like if-- I really do--
0:57:16I mean, this is a little flippant.
0:57:18But I really think that with-- under Steve Jobs,
0:57:20it was like, well, everybody thinks we're blank,
0:57:23but we're not.
0:57:24And I think Jobs' attitude was, well, screw them.
0:57:27I don't care.
0:57:27Who gives a crap if they understand us or not?
0:57:30Or maybe it's even better if we're misunderstood because, you know...
0:57:34Nobody's going to see us coming.
0:57:35Everybody wants to treat us like the dummy.
0:57:38Well, we'll just take the lunch.
0:57:40We'll show them.
0:57:42Whereas I feel like Tim Cook's Apple is frustrated by being misunderstood
0:57:47and seeks to correct it.
0:57:49And in this case, I believe that they are frustrated with the conventional wisdom
0:57:57that Apple doesn't get AI, may not even care about it,
0:58:01and that they are--
0:58:04while the rest of the industry, led by Facebook and Google
0:58:09and perhaps Microsoft, are racing ahead on this stuff,
0:58:13Apple is going to be left behind with pieces of glass
0:58:16that you touch, whereas everybody else is
0:58:19moving towards these AI bots.
0:58:20And I think Apple is saying, no, we are deadly serious.
0:58:23We are different.
0:58:24We are different in two big regards.
0:58:27which I'll get to, but we are deadly serious about this, and we think we're doing pretty well.
0:58:31Yeah, I agree with that.
0:58:34I feel like they want to color that. So here's a paragraph from this story. I don't want to
0:58:39cut you off, but one of the differences between Apple and other companies—here's a read from
0:58:44Levy. Though Federighi doesn't say that this approach might be a necessity, Apple's penchant
0:58:48for secrecy puts it at a disadvantage against competitors who encourage their star computer
0:58:52scientists to widely share research with the world.
0:58:56Quote, "Our practices tend to--" this is Federighi talking.
0:58:59"Our practices tend to reinforce a natural selection bias.
0:59:03Those who are interested in working as a team
0:59:05to deliver a great product versus those
0:59:08whose primary motivation is publishing."
0:59:11So back to Steven Levy.
0:59:12"If while improving an Apple product,
0:59:16scientists happen to make breakthroughs in the field,
0:59:18that's great," says Eddy Q. "But we
0:59:22driven by a vision of the end result. And I think that what they're getting at
0:59:27here is that the researchers in the larger community who are largely
0:59:32focused on publishing see Apple as out of it because nobody from Apple
0:59:37is publishing. Yeah, I think the security area had this at one point. Yes, yes
0:59:47Yes, definitely. That Apple was outside the mainstream in the security industry.
0:59:54Because they weren't participating in it.
0:59:56Right. And they didn't answer. You'd send in...
1:00:00They were even dinged for not giving credit to people for when they'd fixed the bugs.
1:00:07Yeah. Which probably they should have, and they do now.
1:00:13And that's another example that's changed.
1:00:14The head, Apple's head, chief engineer for security.
1:00:17Yeah, he's had Black Hat recently.
1:00:19Right, and gave a very well-regarded talk.
1:00:22It's been a couple of years since Apple had spoken at Black Hat,
1:00:25and the last time they did, it was sort of panned
1:00:28because it was deemed insufficiently detailed,
1:00:32that it was just sort of painting in broad strokes.
1:00:34Whereas this talk that the guy gave last month at Black Hat
1:00:39was very detailed about some things,
1:00:40and that's where they introduced the new bug bounty program.
1:00:43Mm-hmm.
1:00:44We talked about unencrypted kernel caches.
1:00:48Whatever topic was on the table for Apple security,
1:00:53he was on it.
1:00:55He explained it great.
1:00:57These people are brilliant.
1:00:59They're not dummies.
1:01:01With the proviso that I really do think that serious academic research is best,
1:01:09shared so that it can be checked.
1:01:14Right.
1:01:15Because that's how science works.
1:01:18I kind of agree with the fact that, like, say, well, we're going to build something
1:01:25and then we're going to ship it and then you can judge it by its merits.
1:01:28I appreciate that approach because all of the mistakes and stuff along the way may be interesting,
1:01:35but it's what you actually get to. It's the goal, and it's the thing that everybody should be thinking about, rather than all the mistakes.
1:01:48Levy's article even mentions that Apple is making an exception to it.
1:01:52We don't really publish papers about the work we do, we just use it to make great products.
1:01:57They're making an exception on differential privacy, which they consider to be such a breakthrough
1:02:02and such a big part of what they're doing, that they are having their researchers behind it publish what they're doing,
1:02:09because they want everybody else to get on board with it as well.
1:02:12Yeah, it's not just that. It's the compression thing that they did last year.
1:02:16They've got so much open source stuff going on, like WebKit's open source.
1:02:21Chrome, the OS, did they call it Chrome? What do they call it?
1:02:26There is Chrome OS.
1:02:28Yeah, Chrome OS, Chrome browser, it's all WebKit. It's being hacked a lot.
1:02:33But I mean, that's Apple's stuff. Since '97, Apple has been releasing huge chunks of open source software.
1:02:42Well, Chrome is a perfect example of why some people would argue against open sourcing stuff.
1:02:53stuff because it's, you know, it is it the, you know, quote-unquote worst-case
1:02:59scenario where here's this thing that Apple did, WebKit, and put all this work
1:03:03into and Google used to be an active participant in submitting patches to
1:03:09WebKit and at a certain point Google and Apple had enough differences on the
1:03:13future of WebKit where Google said we're gonna fork this and what do they call
1:03:17the new one, Blink is there. But Blink was, you know, when it Blink started was
1:03:22just a copy and paste of WebKit, and then they went their different ways.
1:03:28Yeah, well, the process models wanted to be different.
1:03:32But a thing that was an Apple-led project, WebKit,
1:03:37now serves as the foundation for an entire competing operating system.
1:03:42And it really does compete against Apple, like in education, where I think
1:03:47Chromebooks are probably the dominant device in education.
1:03:51Which is the argument that somebody would make against participating,
1:03:55a corporation participating in open source, is that, "Hey, our competitors
1:03:59can take our work and use it against us."
1:04:03I think Melton has heard both sides of that.
1:04:07So Don Melton, a mutual friend, he's been on my show a couple of times.
1:04:11He started WebKit.
1:04:15And he's told me that it can go either way.
1:04:18Like one month, they're like, what the fuck, man?
1:04:23Why?
1:04:24These people are just taking our work.
1:04:26And then like another month, it's like, oh, that's brilliant.
1:04:29Good choice.
1:04:30So I really don't know.
1:04:32It's probably somewhere in the middle.
1:04:34But I mean,
1:04:35Avi Tvenian wrote the Mock Colonel.
1:04:43And he came over with Next and Apple has been open sourcing a lot of their OS stuff for years.
1:04:50Like at this point, 20 years.
1:04:54And I think it's kind of the right thing to do.
1:05:00I think they're making the right choice.
1:05:02It's weird because there was a new Apple kind of thing that came in with, you know, like when Next came in,
1:05:11that had a fair amount of academic or academia feeling to it, at least.
1:05:17Certainly they were selling into the academic market.
1:05:20I mean, they shipped the collective works with Shakespeare, for crying out loud.
1:05:27Like, nobody wants that on their home computer, unless you're in academia.
1:05:37But I think that has kind of permeated the culture to a certain extent.
1:05:42But what they don't do is share user-facing work.
1:05:48Like the Windows Server app kit, UI kit,
1:05:54none of that is open to the public. And that's because that's where their value is.
1:05:59And they are right to protect it.
1:06:03And so with Siri, I think that they're putting that in the same bucket.
1:06:08That's where they interface with the user.
1:06:13What's Apple good at? What's their value interfacing with the user?
1:06:17Why are they going to write up all the papers about exactly how they do it?
1:06:22So one of the things that the Levy article mentions, and there's even a quote from somebody,
1:06:27is that the people leading minds in the AI community are like, "Well, who among the top five
1:06:32know, who among the top five brains in AI does Apple have on their staff? And it's,
1:06:37you know, show me, and there's a lot of skepticism. One of the—to me, one of
1:06:42the interesting things was that Federighi said that a lot of their people who are
1:06:48doing this machine learning don't really come from the AI background. Here's the
1:06:51quote, "We hire people who are very smart in fundamental domains of mathematics,
1:06:54statistics, programming languages, cryptography. It turns out a lot of these
1:06:58kinds of core talents translate beautifully to machine learning." So it's
1:07:01people that--
1:07:03and if you're smart and you're a good programmer,
1:07:06you can do all sorts of things.
1:07:10I know a guy who used to do a lot of graphics programming
1:07:14for games.
1:07:15Oh, yeah?
1:07:16Yeah, and then he does other things as well.
1:07:19Seems like a good idea.
1:07:21But I think you would agree with me firsthand
1:07:25that you can enter a new field in programming
1:07:29and be good at it, get up to speed,
1:07:31just because a lot of this stuff doesn't have to be its own domain.
1:07:36Yes, I agree.
1:07:41I actually really do agree with you, but I'm going to do the devil's advocate thing.
1:07:45I think the idea is that the back end knowledge and the way to structure and machine learning from a system,
1:07:58accepting input from billions of sources and then learning from that is not knowledge that is internal to Apple at this point.
1:08:10And I think that's the argument. I don't know if it's true. And I do know that this differential privacy thing is probably going to make it harder.
1:08:20And I like that it's going to make it harder because they're prioritizing privacy.
1:08:28Yeah. I think that secondarily, I think that is one of the reasons Apple participated in this article.
1:08:37Is that they want to push back hard on the notion that the one way to do this machine learning style features
1:08:47that are exposed to end users is by collecting tons of data and doing it all server-side.
1:08:55This is one way that Apple is clearly going against the way that Facebook and Google work.
1:09:02But of course that's the way Facebook and Google work is because they are fundamentally server-side companies.
1:09:09And Apple is fundamentally a device company.
1:09:12But Apple is effectively doing a lot of this stuff in parallel by having each and every individual device do the work.
1:09:20And it's explicit in the article with Levy where a lot of this data is staying on the device,
1:09:27and therefore all of the AI-style analysis of it is doing it on the device.
1:09:34So like the face detection in the photos happens on the device.
1:09:37Yeah, I mean, I think the obvious assumption is that if you had a personal assistant that could do everything that Siri or like the ultimate version of Siri, like the best personal assistant you could ever have, obviously they're going to know everything about you.
1:09:56because they need to in order to do their job.
1:10:00And that's true for a person, but I don't know if that needs to be true for
1:10:07a system or like an artificial intelligence.
1:10:11It seems like the way to go, just because we can rationalize about
1:10:17that. It's like, "Okay, well if I tell this person
1:10:19every little detail, they can try to help me.
1:10:24But I don't know if that's the only way.
1:10:29Honestly, there's probably some hardcore mathematical proof that you could work out this, right?
1:10:37You could throw information at a thing that is obscured in some way,
1:10:45and it could come back with answers that are incredibly accurate, but they still can't reason about you as a whole.
1:10:53Which is where I think Apple is trying to go.
1:10:56Yeah. And skating to where the puck is going.
1:11:00I mean, it's not like Apple is going to stick with the A9 system on a chip and that there's not going to be an A10, an A11, A12, and that these chips aren't going to keep getting faster and faster and faster.
1:11:12I mean, five, six years from now, we're going to have iPhones that make the current iPhones
1:11:16look like a joke in terms of the computational power.
1:11:20And it's just one of those things that the phone is going to have, you know, it's going
1:11:24to be easier and easier, I think, to do advanced computational work.
1:11:28Unless you needed a headphone jack.
1:11:32Anyway, I don't think I have anything else on this Steven Levy article, but I don't think
1:11:39it should be dismissed.
1:11:40Yes, read it with an open mind and understand that this is exactly what Apple presented to
1:11:46Steven Levy, but I think there's a lot of interesting stuff to grok from that.
1:11:50Yes, I totally agree with you.
1:11:52All right, let me take a break and thank our next sponsor. It's our good friends,
1:11:55old time, long-time sponsors of the show. Warby Parker. Warby Parker makes buying glasses online
1:12:00easy and risk-free. Go to warbyparker.com/thetalkshow and order your free home try-ons
1:12:07today. Warby Parker offers contemporary eyeglasses that are extremely affordable
1:12:11and fashion-forward. They believe glasses should not cost as much as an iPhone.
1:12:16They offer prescription eyeglasses. Prescription eyeglasses are just 95 bucks,
1:12:21and that includes the prescription lenses. They don't upsell you on the
1:12:25coatings and stuff like that, the anti-glare and the anti-scratch. You just
1:12:28get them. You get anything you want. There's no upsell. Last time I bought
1:12:31glasses in a glasses store, it's like you end up spending twice the money from the
1:12:35starting point just to get the coatings that you want on the glasses. They also
1:12:39have a titanium collection that starts at just $145 including lenses with
1:12:44premium Japanese titanium and French non-rocking screws. They even sweat the
1:12:50detail down to what type of screws they use. All Warby Parker glasses include the
1:12:54anti-reflective and anti-glare coatings. They also include excellent cases. I
1:12:58really vouch for the case, it's great. A cleaning cloth, no extra charge.
1:13:04So whether your eyesight is pretty good or absolutely abysmal, Orby Parker has you covered.
1:13:08You can get eyeglasses, reading glasses, sunglasses, whatever kind of glasses you need.
1:13:13You just go there, you pick like five of the ones that you that you're interested in out,
1:13:17give them your address. And like in two days, there's a box at your door and you try them on
1:13:23at home. Now they don't have your lenses in yet. They're just you know, like dummy lenses. You have
1:13:28five pairs, you can try them on look in the mirror. You know, get the people in your family to tell
1:13:33which ones look good. Pick the one you like, order it. They'll get it to you within 10
1:13:39business days, usually even faster. And then they have free return label. You just put
1:13:43the samples back in the box, put the return label on and boom, I'll back off to Warby
1:13:47Parker it goes. So it's easy to buy them easy to shop, no pressure and couldn't be easier.
1:13:54So go to warbyparker.com/thetalkshow. I'm reading this, these notes while I'm wearing
1:14:01a pair of Warby Parker eyeglasses as we speak. Very good stuff.
1:14:05You know what? I need glasses, man. I have glasses, but they look me,
1:14:10they make me look like a serial killer from like the 1980s. They're horrible.
1:14:14You've been saying this to me for years, though. We'll be out.
1:14:17I know, I know, I know. But I'm going to do it. I'm going to do it.
1:14:20And I feel like I'm pimping your ads a little bit too much.
1:14:24But like Warby Parker is making me be like, oh yeah,
1:14:27I should just actually go on that website and get some glasses.
1:14:30You know, I would say this about the Warby Parker thing, about them having to load these $95 starting point,
1:14:35is that you can buy without feeling, you know, if you go to like a regular eyeglass store and they're
1:14:40like five or six hundred dollars, you feel like, okay, I'm going to buy a pair of eyeglasses and
1:14:43then these are my glasses for the next few years. With Warby Parker, it is so much easier to buy
1:14:47like two or three pairs and not feel like you're a profligate. And you can either buy two or three
1:14:53pairs and have them so that they are different and you can have like, you know, minimal glasses and
1:14:59thick black glasses, whatever, different looks.
1:15:02Or just to have them laying around so that if they're more like reading glasses,
1:15:07you can keep a pair in the office and keep a pair downstairs.
1:15:10And it's so much better at that price.
1:15:13But it used to be like when I was growing up and I first got glasses,
1:15:15it was like I got one pair of glasses and that was it.
1:15:17And don't break it.
1:15:18That was it.
1:15:19Yeah, me too.
1:15:20I looked like a serial killer.
1:15:22And I picked them myself.
1:15:24And I thought they were like silver and they kind of--
1:15:27they're East St. Laurent, but they kind of like lean in a little bit.
1:15:30Like, I look crazy.
1:15:31I look like I'm going to murder you.
1:15:33More than usual.
1:15:35And I just, I got to let it go.
1:15:38But yeah, so I bought these one pair of glasses and I can do my job fine.
1:15:42But I mean, distance is like, I can barely read my TV at this point.
1:15:47Like I don't.
1:15:48Like I guess what shows are on, like I guess what the names of shows or episodes
1:15:52are based on what's most likely, which is probably not the way most people actually read the world.
1:16:02I'm like, "Eh, this is probably the most likely."
1:16:06You should probably get your eyes checked.
1:16:08Yeah, a little bit.
1:16:09So Tim Cook has been CEO now for five years, as of two days ago.
1:16:14He has been the CEO of Apple for five years.
1:16:16So there's a couple of people commemorating that with, "What are the five years of Tim Cook like?"
1:16:21I think that that was the basis. There was a really long interview with Tim Cook in the Washington Post.
1:16:27I think the date was the 13th, so that was about two weeks ago, actually.
1:16:31I'm not quite sure that that was timed to be with the five-year thing, but it might as well be.
1:16:38I will put a link to that interview.
1:16:40Yeah, I think so. I like that interview. It was really good.
1:16:42Yeah, it's so long, and I was actually on a brief vacation with my folks at the time.
1:16:49So I actually didn't finish reading it until today, actually,
1:16:53which is why I haven't linked to it on Daring Fireball.
1:16:55Yeah.
1:16:56You should.
1:16:57It's worth thinking.
1:16:57I know.
1:16:58But now I'm two weeks late.
1:16:59Yeah, it's OK.
1:17:00You're always late.
1:17:01Yeah, it's typical for me.
1:17:03It was very interesting.
1:17:05And a lot of it is stuff that I already knew about Tim Cook.
1:17:09But some of it was insightful.
1:17:10And one of the questions they asked that I've seen people ask about,
1:17:14but nobody asked him, was whether or not
1:17:18he thinks that growing up gay in the US South in Alabama, did that fuel his focus on privacy?
1:17:30Right.
1:17:31You know, and that he was...
1:17:32What a great question.
1:17:34It is a great question. It was very well worded.
1:17:36And in short, I don't want to... you know, you should read his article.
1:17:38I don't want to read the whole thing, but in short, he says no.
1:17:42That it's two separate things.
1:17:43that obviously his upbringing was, you know, everybody's upbringing informs who they are as an adult,
1:17:49but in this particular case on the issue of privacy, he believes that it is fundamental to the United States,
1:17:58and that it's as much a part of the founding of this country as freedom of speech and freedom of religion,
1:18:04that you have a right to privacy, and that he believes that so strongly that it has, you know...
1:18:08But who knows? Maybe he's, you know...
1:18:11I don't know.
1:18:13But I would agree with that 100%.
1:18:16Yeah.
1:18:16And just to get, oh man, I hate that I'm going to do this, but just to get back to
1:18:21the gun rights thing is like, first you should be concerned about privacy.
1:18:25Then you won't need a gun to protect yourself from whatever the hell you think
1:18:30you're going to protect yourself from.
1:18:32But yeah, no, I totally agree with them.
1:18:37And for a long time, I did.
1:18:40I had my own narrative.
1:18:42I'm like, well, he's like a gay guy growing up in the South.
1:18:45That's got to suck.
1:18:47I've given his age and all that.
1:18:49Things are different now.
1:18:51I hope.
1:18:53Well, they're certainly better.
1:18:55I don't think anybody would deny.
1:18:58Whether it still is problematic or not, I would guess that being--
1:19:02Probably really problematic.
1:19:03And hopefully the worst that's happening
1:19:06is arguing about who's going to make your wedding cake, when it used to be like, "Oh, you just may get murdered."
1:19:14Right.
1:19:15So, hopefully. But, you know, just kind of change takes some kind of time.
1:19:22So, yeah, that would have been what I would have thought.
1:19:27But I like this answer a lot. It's just like, "No, this is a fundamental freedom."
1:19:34It's hard to not get behind that.
1:19:39Right.
1:19:40He's a very careful speaker, as he needs to be.
1:19:46And they even address that.
1:19:48One of the things he's surprised by is he thought he would operate a little under the radar
1:19:54because he thought that the attention Steve Jobs got was because he was Steve Jobs.
1:19:58I love that quote.
1:19:59And that it didn't come with the job, but that he was wrong.
1:20:02that being the CEO of Apple brings an intense scrutiny to everything you say and do,
1:20:07that he didn't quite anticipate, because he really thought it was Steve and not the chair, as he calls it.
1:20:13Yeah. I think he's partially right.
1:20:16Like, a lot of it was just because of Jobs.
1:20:18Like, if Jobs had quit Apple and went somewhere else, which I can't even imagine happening,
1:20:23but if he had, people would still be following Jobs.
1:20:27Right.
1:20:29At this point, yeah.
1:20:30At this point, Apple is huge.
1:20:32Right.
1:20:33Yeah.
1:20:34The hot seat is not just Steve anymore.
1:20:41You won.
1:20:42It worked.
1:20:43Now you're going to have weird pieces written about you that you don't...
1:20:51You are unsure of their sourcing, or you say something and somebody's going to take it
1:20:55the wrong way.
1:20:57I really don't envy that kind of scrutiny.
1:21:01It is weird, though.
1:21:02I mean, I don't write the five-year commemorative piece.
1:21:08I tend not to do those sort of anniversary-type things.
1:21:12But it is still fun to think about.
1:21:15And it is weird to me to think that he's been CEO for five years.
1:21:18Now, just as a point of reference, the thing that made me go, "Whoa," is I've been writing
1:21:24during Fireball since 2002, actually August 2002, so exactly 14 years.
1:21:32So over a third of the time I've been doing during Fireball has been, Apple has been under
1:21:37Tim Cook.
1:21:38That's kind of crazy to me.
1:21:40That is crazy.
1:21:41In my gut, it doesn't feel that way.
1:21:43It doesn't feel like, it still feels like the Tim Cook era is new and that I've spent
1:21:47most, you know, and that's true, I've still spent two-thirds of the time, but, you know,
1:21:52it another five years and it'll be half the time I've been doing this, Tim Cook's been
1:21:56in charge.
1:21:57Yeah, yeah.
1:21:58I feel the same way about, well, first of all, when Tim Cook was there for five years,
1:22:03I realized that like, I've known you way too long and I should spend some time finding
1:22:09better friends.
1:22:11Because like we'd been friends for a long time when Tim Cook took over.
1:22:17It's just, I feel like I'm wasting my life here.
1:22:20The other thing is, his tenure was so questioned at first.
1:22:34But I mean, if you look at, was it Horace that posted the charts recently?
1:22:40Oh, I'm sure he's posted some charts recently.
1:22:42Horace Dejue has always posted some charts recently.
1:22:46Jared. But no, Tim Cook's been killing it for the first five years of that, his tenure as CEO of Apple.
1:22:58And I don't think he's doing it in the same way that Bonner did, because Bonner also had great results.
1:23:08Yes.
1:23:11But it was more like doubling down on what already existed and in a way kind of riding out the wave of success of Microsoft for a while.
1:23:20Yeah.
1:23:21Who I honestly these days, I just do better guys.
1:23:26It might have been.
1:23:28I'm actually like a Microsoft cheerleader at this point.
1:23:32Like, I want them to do well.
1:23:33I really do.
1:23:34Yeah.
1:23:35I think that the biggest mistake under Balmer, I mean, again, we could probably do a whole show about that.
1:23:39But the biggest mistake was missing out on mobile.
1:23:44And again, I've said this many times where--
1:23:47And he laughed about it, which I think is unfair,
1:23:49like that thing where he's laughing off the iPhone.
1:23:51Right.
1:23:53But I--
1:23:53OK, that's what he's doing in an interview,
1:23:55and he's a boisterous, over-the-top kind of guy.
1:23:57I kind of get the feeling, though,
1:23:59that in that video where he laughs about the iPhone,
1:24:02that it doesn't have a keyboard, and it's $600,
1:24:05and how are you ever going to do work without a keyboard?
1:24:08and he laughs. I know it is his personality, and of course he's not going to say very good things
1:24:13about it. But I do feel though that the way he, his attitude in that video, to me, indicates that
1:24:22he didn't, even privately, didn't get it. He didn't look at the iPhone and think, "Oh, fuck. This is
1:24:30amazing and we don't have any that we are what and I do believe that he should
1:24:37that CEO of Microsoft should have been able to look at the iPhone and say that
1:24:41first iPhone and say oh we are screwed but it's true if you read the the great
1:24:49what was Andy the great book by the guy from the original Macintosh team Andy
1:24:56Hertzfeld Andy Hertzfeld I was gonna say Andy and not go I know that that was
1:24:59Andy Hertzfeld's book. Andy and not go is a great guy.
1:25:02Revolution in the Valley and then he's also in most of those stories are also
1:25:06on his great website folklore.org yeah that's a great site oh my god it's
1:25:12amazing but I like it in the book I like the book better but if you want to be a
1:25:15cheapskate you can read it for free he tells the story he was there in the room
1:25:22when Bill Gates first saw a Macintosh. I think it was still a prototype.
1:25:28And what Gates was specifically obsessed about was the way that the mouse pointer moving on screen was so smooth.
1:25:38That the animation was so smooth. Because all other previous attempts at that, there was...
1:25:44I don't know what the details of how Apple did that, what the trick was.
1:25:48was some serious trickery going on that made--
1:25:51These days it's done in hardware.
1:25:54Back then, no, like you'd have to--
1:25:57you'd redraw the thing underneath, like your mouse was there,
1:26:01then you would move it, and then you'd have to redraw it
1:26:04where it was. And that's like--
1:26:07on those kind of computers at that time, that was hard.
1:26:11Like, you know, it's a big deal. If you didn't do something special,
1:26:14the mouse movement on all other systems that had a mouse,
1:26:17The mouse moved very jerkily. It was just real jerky.
1:26:20And on the Macintosh, even though the hardware was, by today's standards,
1:26:24almost laughably, you know, minimal, you know, 100, what was it, 128 kilobytes of RAM?
1:26:30Yes.
1:26:31Or was the 128K one the fat one?
1:26:34I think that might have been the fat one.
1:26:36That might have been the fat one.
1:26:37It's just a laughably slow processor.
1:26:41So the other one would have been like 64K.
1:26:43We could be wrong on that. Syracuse.
1:26:47I think the fat Mac was 512. I think the fat Mac was 512.
1:26:51And I think the original was 128. I don't think they ever shipped a 64K Mac.
1:26:55It was about 128. But it was ridiculous. But Gates saw the mouse movement
1:26:59and accused them of having dedicated hardware to do it because otherwise it would be impossible.
1:27:03And I think as the story goes, the jobs told Andy Hirtzfeld to shut up.
1:27:09Because Hirtzfeld was going to tell Gates exactly how they did it.
1:27:14Of course he would, which goes back to the previous point about scientists, dudes, want to just tell everybody all the stuff all the time.
1:27:21But Gates is the type of guy who could look at the Mac and see something like that and say, "Whoa, this is something."
1:27:29Whereas Balmer, because he's so outside the product development and not really a software guy, really is just a true businessman CEO,
1:27:40didn't look at the iPhone and see, "Whoa, this is not something to laugh at."
1:27:46There was a way to answer that question where he doesn't look so bad in hindsight.
1:27:50And the keyboard thing is a fine answer. I've made hay over that over the years.
1:27:55But at the time, because all people with business phones had BlackBerry-style devices,
1:28:00or the Windows mobile device was BlackBerry-style, where it had these hardware keyboards.
1:28:05That was a fine part of the answer.
1:28:07But Joanna Stern, who's been on the show a lot, she should be more often, because she's hilarious,
1:28:13huge Blackberry physical keyboard fan, you know, she loves it. But, you know,
1:28:21that ship has kind of sailed at this point. Right, but that was a fine answer. But the laughing at
1:28:24it was inappropriate. And you could just see, I could just see that he just didn't have that.
1:28:28I feel like Tim Cook doesn't have that problem. He may not be a product guy, but he is absolutely,
1:28:32to my mind, not focused solely on milking what Apple's got.
1:28:37Okay, so two things.
1:28:39Steve Jobs also crapped on products.
1:28:45Right. Competing products.
1:28:48Yeah, competing products. Like Ballmer did.
1:28:51So why do you think he managed to pull it off and Ballmer didn't?
1:28:57I think because Ballmer was so profoundly wrong on that particular issue.
1:29:01It's not like Steve Jobs saying Blu-ray is a bag of hurt, which it is, and we still don't have Blu-ray on any Mac.
1:29:10Right. It literally became, I mean, this is no exaggeration, no hyperbole.
1:29:14The iPhone is the most successful product in the history of consumer electronics.
1:29:18It's maybe the most successful product, period.
1:29:21Like more successful than the Model T Ford.
1:29:24You know, it's unfathomable how much money Apple has made
1:29:28and makes every day on the iPhone.
1:29:31Would I have predicted that when I first saw it,
1:29:35when I was in that audience at Macworld Expo
1:29:38when he showed, Steve Jobs took the iPhone
1:29:42out of his pocket, would I have predicted
1:29:43that it would be the single most successful product
1:29:46in the world and would propel Apple to become,
1:29:48I think Apple's just, if they only sold the iPhone
1:29:51and they had no other business,
1:29:52they would still be the biggest company
1:29:53world by revenue and profit. Would I have predicted that that would be true? No. But if you told me I'm
1:29:59from the future and that is true, I would have believed it. I would have said, "Yeah, this is so
1:30:03amazing that I can believe that it's going to be that big." Yeah. I mean, I've told you this story
1:30:10before, and I'm sure I've said it before, but I bought an iPhone when I couldn't even use it.
1:30:13All I could do was swipe and call 911. That's all I could do. And I bought it just because of that.
1:30:22I'm like, I want this thing.
1:30:24I think you told this story on the show before.
1:30:25It's just amazing.
1:30:26And the thing that I forgot, you got halfway through the story last time,
1:30:29and I had totally forgotten.
1:30:31I still assume, though, OK, you couldn't make phone calls
1:30:33because you were in Canada, but you could still use notes
1:30:37and get on Safari and do email.
1:30:38But you couldn't, because those original iPhones had to be activated.
1:30:43You take it out of the box, and you had to activate with AT&T before you could get past the--
1:30:49I had the lock screen.
1:30:50That's what I had.
1:30:52And Swype was like, not swipe to unlock, it was like swipe to call 911.
1:30:56That was it.
1:30:57That's the only thing I could do.
1:30:59And I thought about doing it, but I'm a good citizen, so I didn't do it.
1:31:03But like, I still bought that phone and loved it.
1:31:07That was a great phone.
1:31:09Eventually it got unlocked and things worked out okay.
1:31:13I've still got it.
1:31:13It's on my desk here.
1:31:14I'm not giving that thing up.
1:31:15But, yeah, that first iPhone.
1:31:19Whew! A little bit of a ... That's a cultural moment.
1:31:23I don't know if you read it. I linked to it the other day.
1:31:27A guy on Medium. I've heard him before, but never really noticed.
1:31:32A guy named Jan Dawson wrote a big, long Medium post.
1:31:36It was five years of Tim Cook in charts, and he had all sorts of information.
1:31:41I just pasted it. It will be in the show notes, I swear.
1:31:44But I thought it was really interesting.
1:31:48And he makes a very interesting observation.
1:31:50I'm sure Horace has noticed it, and I probably should have.
1:31:53But Dawson points this out in a way that makes it very clear,
1:31:57is that under the five years of Tim Cook,
1:32:01Apple's profit margins have gone down slightly.
1:32:05They're high enough that a 2% drop in profit margins
1:32:08is not that big.
1:32:08But it's kind of gone from-- just dropped 2%.
1:32:16but that their spending on R&D has gone up as a percentage of revenue, has almost doubled,
1:32:21gone from like 2% to 4%. And that extra 2% correlates pretty much exactly with the 2%
1:32:26drop in profit margin, that Apple has taken a little bit of a hit on profit margin to pump
1:32:33into R&D, which again, they can well afford to do because the profit margins have gone from extremely
1:32:40high to very high, or ever so slightly less extremely high.
1:32:46And to me, again, the proof will be in the pudding as to what pans out of this increase
1:32:51in R&D spending.
1:32:56But to me, it's evidence that he's, as a leader, he's not focused on milking the past products.
1:33:04Oh, no.
1:33:05That's-- I don't want to just be like an Apple cheerleader or a Tim Cook cheerleader here,
1:33:13but I think that this is a sign that what Tim Cook is doing is very different than what Bonner
1:33:20was doing at Microsoft. Microsoft doubled down on their existing assets, Windows and Office.
1:33:29I don't think that that was a problem, though. I feel like, like I said before, I think the only
1:33:35big mistake he made was missing out on mobile and that the mobile plan they had was a bad idea.
1:33:41Yeah, but I see that as a symptom of doubling down on Windows.
1:33:47But I think Ben Thompson has made this case. I'm just parroting Ben Thompson, frankly. But
1:33:51the fact that that Ballmer made Windows and Office so much more profitable than they were when he
1:33:57took over from Gates, it really did help strengthen Microsoft as a company. He did such a good job of
1:34:04taking two products that were already incredibly profitable and incredibly, you know,
1:34:09strong in the market and made them even more so. It really strengthened Microsoft so that the fact
1:34:16that they frankly missed out on mobile... Well, so when you say frankly missed out,
1:34:22I say at the expense of missing out. I don't think that they're exclusive though. I think they could
1:34:27have done the same thing and had a better strategy. Oh, they could have, but I mean,
1:34:31Their focus was on deriving revenue from their two key assets.
1:34:36And so I think they got blindsided, frankly.
1:34:44And they had Windows CE and they thought they were good.
1:34:47It was not good.
1:34:53It's literally Wince.
1:34:57It was the joke since they wanted it, they shipped it.
1:35:00And it looked like Windows 95 on a phone.
1:35:03It even had a start menu.
1:35:04It had a start menu.
1:35:05Right.
1:35:06Come on guys.
1:35:07Like bad idea.
1:35:10Yeah.
1:35:10It would be like if the iPhone had in the top, starting at the top left,
1:35:14Apple.
1:35:15Right.
1:35:16Yeah.
1:35:16Remember those rumors that were like,
1:35:18File edit view.
1:35:19Remember like the phone rumors that every time you'd see like a, like a rendering,
1:35:24you'd be like, that is garbage.
1:35:25That's not going to happen.
1:35:26Yeah.
1:35:27And during the iPhone launch, those rumors were so popular that Steve put up a photo of an iPod with a rotary dial and a list of names.
1:35:42They're like, "Make phone calls." Which is hilarious.
1:35:47But yeah, I think Microsoft, at the expense of getting into mobile, focused on getting the most revenue out of their existing assets.
1:35:54out of their existing assets.
1:35:56- I do think, and looking back at Tim Cook's five years
1:36:01and these interviews and the stories and stuff like that,
1:36:03I feel like part of it, and he reiterates it
1:36:05over and over in that Washington Post interview
1:36:07that he's focused on the long term, not the short term.
1:36:09And he said something about,
1:36:10like the question was something to the effect
1:36:12of what do you say to short term investors
1:36:14who are frustrated because like, for example,
1:36:16if you're in Apple's on the short term right now,
1:36:18for this calendar year,
1:36:20they're down year over year for the first time.
1:36:23And his answer is, we welcome investors of all sorts, whether you're in for the short term or long term.
1:36:27But we're very clear that our strategic plans are solely and only focused on the long term.
1:36:32So if you want to ride us for three months and try to make a quick buck, you're welcome to try.
1:36:38But we're not playing that game.
1:36:39Yeah.
1:36:40I love that quote, by the way.
1:36:41Everybody's welcome.
1:36:43We're thinking long term, so you should know about it right now.
1:36:48Come in with your eyes open.
1:36:49Yeah.
1:36:50And that I'm not going to worry about one 90-day blip.
1:36:55Right. So just to be the Denis Lui to your Jon Stewart,
1:37:02you want to talk about Vesper?
1:37:04Yeah. Well, let me take a break. That was the last topic I wanted to talk about.
1:37:07Oh, you did? Okay. I thought I was going to have to twist your arm.
1:37:11No, but I figured let's not be self-indulgent. Let's talk about the real news first.
1:37:15Let me take a break, though, and thank our third and final sponsor of the show.
1:37:18longtime friends of the show, great company, Fracture.
1:37:22Fracture is a photo decor company
1:37:24that is out to rescue your favorite images
1:37:26from the digital ether.
1:37:28You've heard, if you've listened to the show,
1:37:29you know what they do.
1:37:30They take your photo, you send them digital photos,
1:37:31they print them directly on glass.
1:37:33If you haven't, if you're new to the show,
1:37:36if you haven't heard the Fracture thing before,
1:37:39I mean it, I don't know how they do it.
1:37:41I would actually, I almost am tempted to go down there
1:37:43and see the factory and see how they do it,
1:37:45'cause I don't understand it.
1:37:47They don't print photo on paper and then glue it or seal it
1:37:51to glass.
1:37:52Somehow, they actually print directly on glass.
1:37:55I don't know how they do it.
1:37:56I've never seen anything else like it.
1:37:58I never heard of anything else like it.
1:38:00I think it's some kind of proprietary process.
1:38:02I don't know.
1:38:03But it is amazing.
1:38:04It really does make the color and the contrast
1:38:08of your photos really pop.
1:38:10It looks better than printed photos in a glass frame.
1:38:13I don't know why, but it does.
1:38:16And because it's right there on the glass,
1:38:19you could just use the actual piece of glass.
1:38:21And it comes with everything you need to hang it up on a wall.
1:38:24It's got cardboard on the back.
1:38:26But you don't have a frame.
1:38:27It just goes edge to edge.
1:38:28So it ends up looking like the cell phones from--
1:38:34what was that, Ryan Johnson movie with a looper,
1:38:36where it's just like a piece of glass,
1:38:38where it just goes edge to edge and there
1:38:39is no bezel around it or anything, any kind of frame.
1:38:42It looks futuristic.
1:38:43It is amazing.
1:38:44It is a really cool look to not have any border at all.
1:38:47When you get your fracture, you don't have to then
1:38:49put it in a frame or something to hang it up.
1:38:52You just open the little cardboard thing it comes with
1:38:54and it's ready to go right up there, everything you need.
1:38:57It's really, really great.
1:38:58Just fill your house with these things.
1:39:00Take your pictures of your kids, your family,
1:39:01whoever else you got, your dog,
1:39:04sleeping on his new mattress.
1:39:06Take a cool picture of your dog,
1:39:07get a fractured print of it, hang it up on a wall.
1:39:09They do it right in Gainesville, Florida
1:39:12from US Source Materials.
1:39:13Their factory is carbon neutral.
1:39:16Can't say enough good things about this.
1:39:18Take some summer vacation photos, get 'em printed.
1:39:21You won't regret it.
1:39:22So here's where you go for more information
1:39:25and 10% off your first order.
1:39:27You'll save some bucks.
1:39:28Go to fractureme.com/podcast.
1:39:32They're gonna give you a survey.
1:39:34It is a one-question survey.
1:39:36That is, where did you hear about them?
1:39:38And then that's where you just say
1:39:40you heard about it on the talk show.
1:39:42Couldn't be easier.
1:39:43fractureme.com/podcast
1:39:46Alright, Vesper. We shut down Vesper.
1:39:48Wait, one... just because I did it for the other two.
1:39:51I've used Fracture. I like them. It's good.
1:39:54Like, I love the product. I would recommend it.
1:39:59And this is totally unsolicited and kind of just jumping in the middle of your show to say that.
1:40:06Anyway, what's up with Vesper, man?
1:40:10Well...
1:40:14Yeah, okay, so Vespers ran for what? Two, three years?
1:40:20Three years. We shipped in June of 2013.
1:40:24Okay, and you've wrapped it up now. By the end of, I believe, this month,
1:40:30you're shutting off the Sync service.
1:40:34Right. At this point, we really only have two things. We have an iOS app, and we have a Sync service.
1:40:38And for various reasons, we need to shut down the Sync service.
1:40:42there's some changes coming to Azure
1:40:46mobile services. We might, it's possible that after
1:40:50these changes that it would, if we had left it running, would keep running
1:40:54but there's also possible, we just don't know yet until they make the change, it's also possible that it would
1:40:58require engineering to fix the effort that we don't have
1:41:02because Brent is not working on Vesper anymore, so we don't have the engineering to keep
1:41:06them running. So since we can't guarantee it and we're thinking we should shut it down anyway
1:41:10now is a good time to do it.
1:41:12So we're shutting down the sync service.
1:41:13So what we did is we shipped a new version of Vesper
1:41:16that has two changes.
1:41:19One, you can no longer sign up for a sync account
1:41:22because it really doesn't make any sense
1:41:24to allow people to sign up for a sync account
1:41:26that is only gonna last for five days.
1:41:28And two, it adds an export feature,
1:41:33which we probably should have had all along,
1:41:35but didn't for various reasons.
1:41:37But the way that we're doing export is really,
1:41:40To me, it's ideal.
1:41:44Yeah, if it checks it out, you did a good job.
1:41:46There's confusion.
1:41:47And I don't think that if you read what we wrote about it at various places,
1:41:51either in the release notes for this new version of the app,
1:41:54or like Brent's blog, or my blog, I don't think that what we wrote
1:41:58is confusing.
1:42:00But I think because of the way so many other services work,
1:42:03people just come at it with the wrong impression and are confused.
1:42:06The one source of confusion people have is, hey, wait.
1:42:09if you're shutting down the sync service at the end of August, this is like too short of a notice.
1:42:12How am I going to export my notes? Because you're shutting it down. You know, like what if I'm up, what
1:42:17if somebody is on vacation for the last week of August and they don't get it and the sync server is
1:42:21already off and they haven't been able to export their notes. And the confusion is that export doesn't
1:42:26go from the cloud. It's not, we, in fact, we can't like the way that the sync services is worked is
1:42:32I guess we could, but it...
1:42:35The data's on the device. Right. And it's exported through
1:42:40iOS document pickers. Is that what it's called? Document pickers?
1:42:44Close enough. So the one that's there by default for anybody who has iCloud
1:42:48is you can export to iCloud Drive. But if you have any other app
1:42:53that has a document picker extension, Dropbox is an obvious one.
1:42:58Another one that is very cool that I've tried is transmit from our friends at Panic.
1:43:05So if you have transmit on your phone, you can export your Vesper notes from your device
1:43:11to any web server that you have configured in transmit.
1:43:15Yeah, that's really weird that Panic did a great job.
1:43:18Yeah, it's shocking.
1:43:20But anyway, export goes from the device, not from the cloud.
1:43:26So we can shut down the sync server and anything that notes that you already have on your device you can export
1:43:31including the pictures and
1:43:34Then what we're gonna do is we're probably going to take Vesper out of the App Store soon
1:43:38Yeah
1:43:41How do you feel?
1:43:43Well, I wrote about I mean, I'm sad
1:43:45I mean, I really love the app and I liked you know, I liked working with Brent and Dave
1:43:49I really did have a lot of fun. But the truth is that once you know, we just never made enough money
1:43:54I mean, I wrote about it. We never made enough money, so we couldn't really...
1:43:56We needed to make enough money to keep Brent full-time, and we didn't.
1:43:59We never made that much money.
1:44:02So Brent... when was that? 2014? At some point in 2014.
1:44:06He's been in Omni for a while now.
1:44:07Yeah, so it might be like two years.
1:44:0918 months? Maybe two years.
1:44:10Yeah, I think it's like two years. I think two years come September.
1:44:14Brent went to work at the Omni Group, which, you know, again, it's like working for Panic.
1:44:19It's like, kind of like an all-star team.
1:44:22Oh yeah.
1:44:24you know, it's like Kevin Drant going to the already great Golden State Warriors.
1:44:32Like, "Oh yeah, now they just picked up Brent Simmons."
1:44:34[laughter]
1:44:36Yeah, sure, that's great.
1:44:37Brent has an awesome three-pointer shot, by the way.
1:44:40But the truth is that once Brent went to work for Omni full-time,
1:44:43the writing was on the wall that there was no way for us to continue.
1:44:48I mean, in theory, we could have hired somebody else or found somebody else to take over for Brent.
1:44:53Man, if only you knew another programmer.
1:44:57[laughter]
1:45:01But, I guess part of the whole thing
1:45:05wasn't really that we wanted a programmer. The whole point was that I wanted to work with Brent Simmons.
1:45:09That makes me feel a lot better.
1:45:13I'm joking. It's all--whatever.
1:45:17It's for the sake of comedy.
1:45:21I mean, it's not like I asked you if you wanted to do it, but I said, would you think of, you know, we did talk about it a while.
1:45:26Oh, yeah.
1:45:27No.
1:45:27Oh, yeah.
1:45:27That's that's well, I didn't even want to bring that up.
1:45:29But yeah, it's all a joke.
1:45:30Uh, just as a maybe as a what if.
1:45:32Working with Trent is like a life goal.
1:45:35He, that guy is amazing.
1:45:37I would love to have like work conversations with him.
1:45:40He's man.
1:45:43He's good.
1:45:44Really good.
1:45:45He's smart, smart, like one of the smartest guys I know.
1:45:49Yeah.
1:45:51He is. It was great working with him. I really enjoyed it.
1:45:54And I personally feel very-- I feel responsible for the failure of Vesper as a business,
1:46:00because that was really-- that was the part that was--
1:46:02Really?
1:46:03Yeah, I do. I think Brent would disagree, and Dave would disagree, maybe.
1:46:06Yeah, I also disagree.
1:46:08Because I feel like that was my job. Brent's job was to make the app, to do all of the engineering.
1:46:13And Dave's job was to do the design and make it look great and work great and have a logic to it.
1:46:20And I definitely worked, certainly worked a lot on the design with Dave.
1:46:24But I feel like fundamentally, my role as the director, as we called it,
1:46:30was to make sure what we're doing is, you know, if anybody was responsible for
1:46:36coming up with an idea and a business model that makes enough that we would be a success, that was me.
1:46:42Well, it's admirable that you think that, but I think you're an idiot.
1:46:47That's not your fault.
1:46:51I feel-- let me put it this way.
1:46:52I feel responsible for the failure,
1:46:55but I'm not losing sleep over it.
1:46:56[LAUGHTER]
1:46:59Does that make sense?
1:47:00Yeah, that's good.
1:47:01That's good.
1:47:02I'm not trying to be a martyr about it.
1:47:04I'm not trying to say, oh, poor me.
1:47:06You know, feel bad for me that I'm blaming myself.
1:47:08But I do think that I should have known it.
1:47:10I feel like, in hindsight--
1:47:12like I wrote about it.
1:47:13I really feel like what we wanted to do--
1:47:15I mean, number one, there's all sorts of things.
1:47:18One thing we agreed from the outset
1:47:20was that we didn't want to raise money.
1:47:22We did not want to be funded in any way.
1:47:25We wanted to effectively self-fund with, as they call it,
1:47:29sweat equity, where Brent could afford
1:47:33to spend the good part of the first year working on it
1:47:38before we made any money.
1:47:40He was coming from Glassboard and had
1:47:43the luxury of being able to work for a while without making money.
1:47:46And the idea was we would self-fund by doing the iPhone version, selling it,
1:47:51making enough money from the iPhone version
1:47:53to sort of bootstrap the company financially
1:47:56while we worked on the next stuff, which was to do a sync service
1:48:00or figure out a way to--
1:48:01whether it was building our own, which is what we wound up doing,
1:48:04or using iCloud or Dropbox or something, and then doing a Mac version
1:48:09and selling that, and then going forward from there
1:48:11with effectively a system where you could be at your Mac,
1:48:15or you could be on your phone, and maybe, depending on how we did the sync service,
1:48:19you could be just on the web, and you could do it from anywhere.
1:48:23And I really do feel like, in hindsight, I should have known better,
1:48:27and we should have done the Mac version first. I feel like--
1:48:31That's an interesting choice, and it's atypical.
1:48:35It's the word I'll use. Most people don't even think
1:48:39think of doing a Mac app. I tend to agree with you, but I'm kind of a Mac advocate.
1:48:45I really love the Mac. Right. And you're, you know, at Aged and Distilled, you're...
1:48:49We have a Mac app. Yeah. Right. Napkin. Yeah. Thank you. And, you know, and for the same reason
1:48:57that you and Chris, you know, did Napkin as a Mac app first, and so far only, you
1:49:04know, I think we should have done the same thing with Vesper. And I wrote
1:49:07about this. I mean, I'm just repeating it. You can go read the article on "Daring Fireball."
1:49:10But I do think that Dave and I did the right thing, where the schedule that we had was that
1:49:15Dave and I, we, we, we, you know, where we agreed to, to create the company, it was at Singleton.
1:49:19I had heard that actually at the bar. Yeah, so, uh, at Singleton 2012, uh, Brent said he wanted
1:49:30to talk to me and Dave. And I even remember who was speaking at the time. It was a friend of the
1:49:34the show Glenn Fleischmann.
1:49:36So we snuck out on Glenn.
1:49:42Singleton was a conference I used to run for the audience.
1:49:46But yeah, you totally ducked out.
1:49:48So during Glenn Fleischmann's talk, Brent and Dave and I went to the bar,
1:49:54which was right next door. So, I mean, we could vaguely hear Glenn's talk,
1:49:59but it was held in a nice hotel and there was a bar right next door.
1:50:02And we had a couple of beers.
1:50:05And Brent said, here's what I'm thinking.
1:50:07I'm leaving Glassboard soon.
1:50:09I want to go back to doing indie apps.
1:50:12What I would like to do is make an app with you two guys.
1:50:15I think that we would make a good team.
1:50:17I don't even know what the idea is.
1:50:18What do you guys think?
1:50:19And we went from there.
1:50:20But that's where-- Dave and I instantly were like, yeah,
1:50:23I'm in.
1:50:23Let's figure this out.
1:50:24Let's make it happen.
1:50:26But the timeline was that Brent wasn't-- he had months
1:50:30to go at Glassboard yet.
1:50:31He was going to give notice and wind down very gracefully so we had lead time.
1:50:37That guy's a professional.
1:50:38Yeah, and he left on perfectly amicable terms.
1:50:42But there were going to be months in advance where Brent wasn't spending any time on Vesper,
1:50:49which was fine.
1:50:50And in fact, we thought this works out great because once we decided on the idea of this notes app concept,
1:50:57Dave and I spent months going over the design
1:51:01before Brent wrote anything.
1:51:02And I think, in hindsight, I still
1:51:04think we did the exact right thing by designing the iPhone
1:51:07app first.
1:51:08But I think that we should have, as soon
1:51:10as we were done designing the iPhone app,
1:51:12should have designed the Mac app and then
1:51:13had Brent build that first.
1:51:15And the reason I say that is that I really
1:51:17do think that in today's world, if you plan
1:51:21to have an iPhone app or a mobile app in general,
1:51:23if you want to include Android, you should design that first.
1:51:26because that's where all the constraints are going to be.
1:51:28That's where the screen size is most limited.
1:51:30That's where the features are less limited.
1:51:33I mean, we're all plain text guys.
1:51:34One of the things I love about Vesper
1:51:35is that it's a plain text app,
1:51:37meaning there's no italics, no bold.
1:51:39You don't get to change the font.
1:51:40You don't get to make it bigger.
1:51:41Or if you do, it's system-wide, so all your notes.
1:51:44- Right, yeah. - If you make it bigger,
1:51:46all your notes are bigger.
1:51:47And I love plain text.
1:51:50I think plain text has won the war.
1:51:52I think, you know, I have a rant in me about that,
1:51:54but I think the way that Facebook and Twitter don't have fonts,
1:51:58that it's just plain text, is a better system.
1:52:01I feel like email got ruined as soon as email changed from being a plain text medium.
1:52:06I agree. But I'm old, so whatever.
1:52:11But, so we were never, we were always, there was never any question that Vesper was going to be plain text.
1:52:16But, as an example, one of the things that would be easy to do if you went Mac first
1:52:21is there's a fantastic, what is it, NS text field?
1:52:26On Mac.
1:52:31On Mac, yeah.
1:52:33Right. You get a full word processor for free.
1:52:35Yeah.
1:52:37Right? You can make a Hello World app without writing any code.
1:52:41And just in Xcode, you can just use Interface Builder.
1:52:45That was a Steve Jobs demo.
1:52:47Yeah.
1:52:47Like, drag one of those out.
1:52:49It's one of the things next was proudest of, but there's an RTF, Rich Text Format, Text Editor.
1:52:56You know, you can effectively build...
1:52:57Which text document is what RTF stands for?
1:52:59Right. I mean, the actual TextEdit app has a bunch of other features.
1:53:02There's, you know, the auto-save and a whole bunch of nice stuff.
1:53:05But you can effectively build TextEdit for free, or a version that's very close to it, where you get...
1:53:11Also, they give you the code.
1:53:12Yeah, they give you the code.
1:53:14It's like the demo code that you get.
1:53:15I think they still do, at least back in the day they did.
1:53:19If you made a notes app, and there's plenty of them,
1:53:23using that field, which would be very natural to do if you go Mac first,
1:53:27you're up Schitt's Creek trying to make that go to the iPhone, because the iPhone doesn't
1:53:31have an RTF editing field.
1:53:35Right. Yes. I think you can render it now as of iOS 7?
1:53:39Yeah, it's not quite...
1:53:43I believe there's cases that you can't.
1:53:47But you know, because you shipped an app with it.
1:53:51It's just one example, though, of the type of thing where you can do all sorts of more powerful stuff on the Mac
1:53:55than you can do on the iOS.
1:53:59But I think that that serves your point. Get designed for mobile first,
1:54:03and then do a Mac app. Because that's chargeable money for a family.
1:54:07Right. But the only way you can make a Mac app where you're aware of the
1:54:11constraints of the iOS version is to design the iOS version first.
1:54:15Yes, I agree.
1:54:17And I really think we could have done that. I think that we definitely could have sold it for a lot more money
1:54:22because I think we would have sold it for $20 a copy. And the counter, I could be wrong.
1:54:26The counter argument is obviously that there are way more iPhone users than Mac users.
1:54:30But I don't think there are that many more iPhone users who pay for productivity apps
1:54:36like Notep than there are Macs.
1:54:38This is one of the things. At one point, there were so many Windows machines out there that it was crazy.
1:54:49But nobody was buying software on them, which matters a lot.
1:54:58That's all you care about is how many people out of this install base are actually buying software.
1:55:03And if on iOS it's really low, it's less of an appealing target than the Mac, where maybe it's a little bit higher.
1:55:16And people are willing to pay you a little bit more money.
1:55:19So there was a notion in the early years of the App Store that, and certainly a lot of the people in our circle, people we know,
1:55:27indie Mac developers started making indie iOS apps and there was a feeling like maybe
1:55:35that the iOS market would be a lot like the Mac market, which has a long term, you know,
1:55:41for you know, back when we used to call it shareware supported independent software where
1:55:45independent developers could create apps, sell them at a price and a quantity that multiplied
1:55:51by each other would equal enough money to be to do this full time and call it a job.
1:55:57that iOS would work out similarly.
1:56:00And then it was very clear, very quickly,
1:56:02that the prices on iOS were going to be a lot lower.
1:56:05And the thought was, well, maybe the quantity
1:56:07will be so much higher that we multiply the price
1:56:10by the quantity and it'll be equivalent.
1:56:13And it hasn't worked out that way.
1:56:16I mean, that's-- and again, I'm not assigning blame.
1:56:18I'm not saying-- we could maybe make an argument
1:56:21that Apple had some blame.
1:56:22But I'm just stating the fact that the way it's worked out
1:56:25is that with rare exceptions-- and there
1:56:27are exceptions, but it is a lot less of a feasible platform for that idea. The idea
1:56:33of you'll make an app, sell it for X dollars to Y people, and then you'll have X times Y revenue
1:56:39minus 30 percent. And it just didn't work out that way, whereas the Mac is still thriving for stuff
1:56:47like that. And I think ultimately it's better to look at iOS as something more akin to the web,
1:56:52where you can't make daringfireball.net, and then when you load it, you say you have to pay $5 before you can read it.
1:56:59Like, the web just doesn't work that way.
1:57:01I mean, the closest the web comes to that is paywalls, and everybody knows paywalls suck.
1:57:07So I think for application software, I think in general, and again, there are exceptions, and Fantastical is a great example.
1:57:14Tweetbot is a great example where they are iOS apps that sell for a couple of
1:57:21bucks and sell in sufficient quantities that the developers can afford to do it,
1:57:25work on them full-time. But for the most part, iOS doesn't work that way and I
1:57:29think most people should approach it as being more akin to the web where the app
1:57:33is free. And maybe there's an in-app purchase to unlock better features or
1:57:38themes or something like that, but that fundamentally it has to be a free
1:57:42download or else you just get lost. Yeah, I largely agree with that.
1:57:46You know, and the demo thing is the one area where you can complain that Apple doesn't allow you to have iOS app demos.
1:57:53And the Mac you can I mean, even there are even apps like I just tried it because the guys at Ulysses Ulysses is a text
1:57:59editor, great text editor,
1:58:01or project based writing editor, sort of like an Xcode for writing type thing. They released a very nifty tool specific for the
1:58:11VSEPR export format where you can just drag the folder onto this tool that they
1:58:15just released yesterday and it will translate your VSEPR export into a
1:58:21format that is exactly imported into Ulysses. So Ulysses on the Mac, I thought
1:58:27this is really interesting. The only way to buy it is to get it through the App
1:58:30Store. It's one and only way, but they still have a demo version on their
1:58:34website that you can download so that you can try it before you buy it. But the
1:58:38demo, unlike a lot of other developers, the demo, there's no way to do it in-app and circumvent it.
1:58:44They are apparently so happy with the App Store in terms of using that for all the processing and everything.
1:58:50Well, there's a bunch of technical issues for that.
1:58:52Right. There are. And they can do iCloud, and they can count on iCloud.
1:58:57Yeah, because you can't change your entitlements.
1:58:59Entitlements means it's a technical term.
1:59:03Right. But long story short, there still is a demo version that you can try.
1:59:08And that really, to me, is fundamental to getting people to part with $20, $30, $40 for an app.
1:59:14Yeah. I agree. As a guy that sells a $40 app on the way.
1:59:19Right.
1:59:20I think it's a great idea.
1:59:23How many people do you think, for Napkin, how many people do you think try the demo before they buy?
1:59:28I have no demo.
1:59:29Oh, you guys don't have a demo? Are you guys App Store only?
1:59:31Yeah.
1:59:32Wow.
1:59:33Yeah.
1:59:34You guys should have a demo.
1:59:35Yeah, we want to.
1:59:37I didn't know that.
1:59:39Well, you know a guy.
1:59:43I know a guy and he hooked me up with a free copy of Napkin, so I'm not familiar with that purchase.
1:59:47That's good.
1:59:49Did we give you a free one?
1:59:51I don't know. Maybe I bought it.
1:59:53I don't remember.
1:59:55Maybe I owe you a foot of bucks.
1:59:57But yeah, no, we don't have a demo.
2:00:01And the original reason was that one of the key features we had was sharing the graphic that you create on iCloud.
2:00:12And we couldn't do that without selling through the App Store.
2:00:17And it wasn't worth having two versions that were different.
2:00:21Yeah, that's changed.
2:00:26Now that we know the audience a little bit, that's not necessarily the primary use case.
2:00:31It's sort of the opposite of what Rich Segal did with BB Edit, where Rich had BB Edit on both as an independent download and in the Mac App Store.
2:00:39And in fact, gave a terrific talk at Singleton. It was really one of my favorite Singleton talks ever, was Rich Segal.
2:00:46It was great, yeah.
2:00:47About why he was leaving the Mac App Store.
2:00:49And I think to make a very, it was a 40 minute talk and it was great.
2:00:54To boil it down to a nut, it was just a lot less stress to have one version that wasn't in the Mac App Store.
2:01:00Yeah. And Rich Segal of BB Edit and Barebone Software, not a dummy.
2:01:08They've been in business for like a long time.
2:01:13It'll be a surprise when it happens, but I was just talking with Rich. He's going to be a guest on the show very soon.
2:01:18Oh cool. Oh man, that's awesome. He's great.
2:01:21He's pretty good. Anyway, Vesper.
2:01:26So anyway, we didn't make enough money. We went iPhone first. I think it was foolish to go iPhone first
2:01:31and expect to make money from selling a paid app to justify the company.
2:01:36Whereas I think if we had gone Mac first, we would have made at least as much money,
2:01:41and I think we would have made more. And therefore Brent could have worked on it full-time more
2:01:45we would have gotten off the ground.
2:01:48Would you do another app?
2:01:51Oh, absolutely, if the situation were right.
2:01:55I mean, it's not like I'm going to do an app, period, but if the right, you know,
2:01:59Yeah, give me the circumstance.
2:02:01It would depend on who it was, if I wanted, you know, if I like them, I wanted to work with them,
2:02:05and whether the idea appealed to me. I mean, Vesper was a perfect storm
2:02:09for me, because I really have always wanted to work with Brent. Dave and
2:02:13I really did have a fantastic design process. We really did. I mean, and we disagreed in
2:02:24the best possible way. And sometimes he would change my mind and sometimes I would change
2:02:30his mind, but we both would listen to each other and we would be able to sort of say,
2:02:34"I kind of feel like it should be this instead of that." But if I said, or he or I said,
2:02:40I feel incredible. I'm convinced that I'm right.
2:02:43And even if you, you know, and we would pull that card, we would listen to each other.
2:02:46Like even if I disagreed, thought it should be this, and he said that, but he said I'm convinced it should be that,
2:02:52then I would say okay.
2:02:53Because I'm not convinced.
2:02:54It was a great...
2:02:56Working relationship you can have.
2:02:57And I love the app. I really, I still love it.
2:03:00So...
2:03:01Yeah, me too.
2:03:01It was, it was...
2:03:02Good work.
2:03:04It was a perfect storm. It was worth putting a lot of time into.
2:03:09But I don't know what else to say about it.
2:03:11Yeah. Remember when we wanted to do a Fart app?
2:03:14[laughter]
2:03:17This was way back in the first year. We could talk about it in front of you.
2:03:21This was like 2007. Yeah, at this point.
2:03:23No, 2009, right? Or 2008, I guess.
2:03:25Oh, 2008, I guess. Yeah.
2:03:27The idea of--
2:03:29I was just cracking a joke. We don't need to actually show this story.
2:03:31All right. Maybe not, because I still think it's a good enough idea.
2:03:33Yeah. I want to keep that. But...
2:03:37I think I still have the domain name.
2:03:39I love the idea of you renewing that all the time.
2:03:48It's pathological.
2:03:49It's probably going to bankrupt me eventually, but it'll eventually
2:03:51bankrupt me is my annual bill.
2:03:55Let me know.
2:03:56Maybe I'll toss some money away.
2:03:59The annual bill for unused domain names.
2:04:03Oh, the-- yeah.
2:04:05Well, I'm not paying for all the other ones.
2:04:07I have, you know what?
2:04:09I have so many dumb domain names.
2:04:11I think I have common fireball.net.
2:04:15Almond fireball.
2:04:18Something like that just to be a dick.
2:04:21And I can't even remember what the joke was.
2:04:23It's probably had something to do with that common markdown or something.
2:04:26Right?
2:04:26Yes.
2:04:27Yes.
2:04:28Right.
2:04:28Yes.
2:04:31It was like, I think of a joke where I'm going to be a dick to you.
2:04:35And then I just, I don't, it's like, oh, that's work.
2:04:38And I don't care.
2:04:39Anything else?
2:04:43Anything else you wanted to ask me about Vesper?
2:04:45Um,
2:04:46I mean, I think we covered it all.
2:04:50I mean, it's, yeah, you covered a lot.
2:04:52Uh, people, I will say this, let me just say this.
2:04:56I will say that we have received an awful lot of both on Twitter and by email and
2:05:01awful lot of very, very, very, very nice things that people said after we said
2:05:05this about Vesper, and I want to thank everybody who took the time to write. I
2:05:08do appreciate that. Do you have a question? That was going to be my question,
2:05:14is do you feel a responsibility to your users? I do. You've kind of
2:05:19covered a bit with the sync issue. Right. But yeah. I do, but on the other hand, even
2:05:25at its most expensive, it was ten bucks. And I, you know, I feel like... And an app
2:05:30will keep working. If you've bought it and you have it on your phone, it should keep working for a long time.
2:05:37It definitely still works on iOS 10, or at least on the betas. There's nothing in iOS 10 that breaks it.
2:05:42Eventually something in iOS, I guess, will break it. But it might be many years.
2:05:48Yeah, we talked about that privately, but I think you're good for at least two more releases.
2:05:55releases, so that's at least two years, you know? Because you don't do anything crazy.
2:06:00Right, and it would be something like when apps went from 32-bit to 64-bit, and now 32-bit apps launch and you get a warning for various reasons.
2:06:14We don't have to say why, but I think it's presaging the fact that eventually, maybe next year, 32-bit apps are just not going to launch on iOS anymore.
2:06:22I think that's eventually going to happen.
2:06:24Some change like that will eventually happen and Vesper will break, but it might be many, many years away.
2:06:29Because I don't think there's any kind of change that big coming soon.
2:06:32Yeah, who knows? But it doesn't seem like it.
2:06:37Yeah, I think you'll be fine for years.
2:06:39Yeah, and there could be something...
2:06:40I wish there was... Can you take an app off the store and still have people upgrade to it?
2:06:45I don't know. I actually don't know.
2:06:48so that it's there so that if you already I think you've got like an old one you want to upgrade to
2:06:53the one with export right you can get it despite the fact that it's not actually available for
2:06:58purchase well yeah free download on the star yeah the current plan is to take it off the store I
2:07:06think we can do it in a way where if you want to restore you'll still be able to download it'll be
2:07:10there but it will be hidden from new users but since we've made it free I don't know maybe I
2:07:15I'm not quite sure. Maybe we could reconsider that. Maybe, who cares? Just keep it there.
2:07:19You got a bunch of new downloads.
2:07:21More downloads. Since we made it free, more downloads than we had in the entire three-year history of it being a free sale.
2:07:27Which I'm not surprised about. And again, I'm not complaining. I understand how this works.
2:07:32But there were times where we were selling it for as low as like $2.
2:07:36Yeah, you guys messed with the price a bit.
2:07:39Right.
2:07:40Because it was $10 originally?
2:07:42No, $4.99, I think, originally.
2:07:44And that was when it was most, like it was far more successful in the first year.
2:07:48I mean, it corresponds to when it was most actively developed.
2:07:50The first year it was most successful was mostly, for most of that time, $4.99.
2:07:55I think we were in like a Christmas promotion where we lowered the price.
2:07:58And then once we realized we were running out of steam financially,
2:08:05we'd, you know, well, we have nothing to lose.
2:08:07Let's see what happens if we make it cheaper.
2:08:08Let's see what happens if we make it more expensive.
2:08:10And neither really made any difference.
2:08:13Well that's what you get for making a shitty app man.
2:08:19Thanks guy.