Podcast Search

The Talk Show

162: ‘Special Bullying Venue’ With Glenn Fleishman

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Every Mac user is the smugest bastard in the world.

0:00:03A virus is never going to affect us, we're immune, whatever.

0:00:06And the reality of course is some people feel that way.

0:00:08Most people who've looked at the situation at all know that, um, we're not immune.

0:00:14We're just really lucky.

0:00:15It's just the target's been small.

0:00:16Apple does a good job upgrading, um, in pushing people to upgrade.

0:00:19They support systems back many years.

0:00:21The target is so small that it's usually not worthwhile for

0:00:25malware makers to target us.

0:00:27So that's been our immunity is because we're insignificant as a target, not necessarily in absolute numbers.

0:00:33So this new thing is this group at Cisco, Talos, um, or Talos, they, uh, are one of many security firms.

0:00:40It's constantly researching for weaknesses, usually to help clients.

0:00:43They are trying to make sure their clients are protected.

0:00:46They find something, this fellow who, um, had some communication with Tyler Bowen, uh, found five previously undiscovered,

0:00:55fairly severe flaws in the way that image format files get parsed.

0:01:01And the trouble was like three or four of them were reasonably severe, but you had to kind of open a file and whatever.

0:01:06But there's one related to TIFF. John, you've been using TIFF for your whole life, right?

0:01:10Since you were born.

0:01:12That's right.

0:01:12Ancient format. So there's a part of the something in the parser,

0:01:16if you use a tiled TIFF file and it's formatted in this very specific malicious fashion,

0:01:21the iOS and ostensibly OS 10.

0:01:25And probably I think the other two OSes

0:01:27are also patched tvOS and watchOS.

0:01:30If it's rendered, it will actually think in that case,

0:01:33it's a memory, it's a buffer overflow,

0:01:35usual typical old thing.

0:01:36And it can allow the potential for malicious code to execute

0:01:40and take control of the machine and do whatever.

0:01:42- Just by displaying the image.

0:01:44- Yeah, and here's the reason it's considered

0:01:46particularly insidious.

0:01:47You could load it with a webpage in Safari,

0:01:49You could have iMessages open and somebody could text,

0:01:53you know, send you a text message with a TIFF in it.

0:01:55There's a few other vectors.

0:01:57Merely by rendering the preview,

0:01:59it would have to parse the file enough

0:02:01that this condition could be exploited.

0:02:03That sounds pretty horrific, right?

0:02:05And that's why it was considered,

0:02:07it's considered very severe.

0:02:10And some discussion about how severe in Apple's patch,

0:02:14did they use responsible disclosure?

0:02:16It's not a zero day.

0:02:17there aren't exploits in the wild.

0:02:19And if you update to all the current OSs,

0:02:23if you just update to the latest micro release,

0:02:25you are protected against that particular TIFF exploit

0:02:28as well as the other four image format related exploits.

0:02:32- I have so many follow up points already.

0:02:35- By the way, BMP format, BMP is actually also affected,

0:02:38which is kind of hilarious.

0:02:39Like TIFF and BMP, nobody's looking at them

0:02:41and I think they're just old implementations.

0:02:43- Let me see if I can keep them on my head.

0:02:46One of them is, yes, I used to use, as you know,

0:02:49and I know you have the ink-stained hands as well,

0:02:52I came from a world of print design,

0:02:54and in the world of print design in the '90s,

0:02:57TIFF was the de facto format, at least for line art,

0:03:02for any kind of bitmap.

0:03:06Everything went through Photoshop into TIFF

0:03:09before it went into production.

0:03:11But it's sort of a notorious file format,

0:03:14'Cause I seem to recall vaguely that over the years,

0:03:16there have been an awful lot of security issues like this

0:03:21that have to do with TIFF parsing.

0:03:24- That is my recollection as well.

0:03:25I didn't go back and look it up,

0:03:26but I think it's that old code thing.

0:03:28Like people wrote TIFF parsers in 1980 something,

0:03:32no, sorry, early 1990s, or late 1980s maybe,

0:03:34probably late 1980s.

0:03:35And the parsers, the basic code is probably mostly unchanged

0:03:39in a lot of ways for 30 years.

0:03:41- And it's probably a very difficult format.

0:03:43It's probably a poor format spec, that's my guess.

0:03:46That therefore it makes it hard to write the,

0:03:48easy to write, not easy to write,

0:03:51hard to write a parser and easy to make mistakes

0:03:56with memory management in the handling of the parser.

0:03:59So anyway, all right, here's another point.

0:04:00Because it's such a weird old format

0:04:02and it was never really part of the web in any way,

0:04:06I'm very surprised that iOS and watchOS

0:04:10even have to parse some code.

0:04:13I know this is part of the, um, like the quick

0:04:15look thing though, like everything in, um, all

0:04:18the different OSs support quick look for, you

0:04:21know, every major file type and include some

0:04:23weird image formats and other things that you,

0:04:26you know, might never be previewing, but you

0:04:28can preview a raw images in some cases, PNGs,

0:04:31are they DNG files, one of the digital formats,

0:04:34um, all these things, PNG, by the way, when

0:04:37that specification portable network graphics,

0:04:40that's kind of TIFFs replacement because it

0:04:41has all the different kinds of things need lossless

0:04:44and lossy and different alpha whatever.

0:04:46In the specifications, I met one of the people

0:04:49who wrote the spec years ago, 1990s.

0:04:51It says ping is pronounced ping in the spec.

0:04:54So there's no question.

0:04:55(laughing)

0:04:57- How else could you pronounce it?

0:05:00P-N-G, I guess.

0:05:02- I don't know.

0:05:02- The only other way you, yeah,

0:05:03the only other way I could think you could pronounce it

0:05:05would be P-N, or just saying the initials, P-N-G.

0:05:09- I pronounce it pang, I don't know.

0:05:10so she knows someone would find a way.

0:05:13- Ping is a-- - Pinge, ping it.

0:05:15- Ping is an odd historical success

0:05:18because a lot of times when people get together in the open

0:05:22and say, you know, there's even like an XKCD comic about it

0:05:27where it's like, we have way too many specs

0:05:28and they all stink.

0:05:29You know what the solution is?

0:05:31A new spec.

0:05:32You just add to the pile, usually,

0:05:35even if it's a noble goal.

0:05:36Whereas Ping had the noble goal of saying,

0:05:39We've got a couple of bitmap image files,

0:05:43formats that are out there being used

0:05:45and they are all terrible for one reason or another.

0:05:49On the web we had GIF files

0:05:51and don't even tell me that you're a GIF person.

0:05:53- Oh my God. - Are you a GIF person?

0:05:55- I'm choosey programmers choose Jeff.

0:05:57That's the--

0:05:58- It's a graphic image change, interchange format.

0:06:01Anyway, it's a GIF file.

0:06:07Just, I mean, horrendous format.

0:06:10I mean, you can only have 256 colors at a time.

0:06:12I mean, it's goofy.

0:06:14- It was great.

0:06:16It was great for CompuServe.

0:06:18- It's juicy.

0:06:19- It was great for CompuServe

0:06:21because I was a CompuServe user.

0:06:23Were you, I can't remember.

0:06:24Were you a CompuServe user?

0:06:24- No, I was never on CompuServe.

0:06:26- Okay, so I can't, for a long time,

0:06:28I can remember my five comma four digit address.

0:06:31It begins with seven.

0:06:32I've totally lost.

0:06:33That's one of the problems with aging.

0:06:34I cannot remember my 1979 CompuServe login.

0:06:37It makes me sad, but on copy serve, it was great.

0:06:39We dial up.

0:06:40We had like, I don't know, 1200 bod modems or 1200 BPS modems, something like that.

0:06:44It was a great compact format when you had, and it was rendered, you know, rendered

0:06:49in a way that made sense, like line at a time or interlacing was, you know, all

0:06:53these things, just most computers, most computers only had 16 color displays.

0:06:57So yeah, it was perfect for the day and it's astonishing that it still is great,

0:07:02but yeah, ping and you remember the most boring thing in the world, the

0:07:06The LZW algorithm was patented and Unisys tried to enforce it and Ping is an outcome

0:07:12of efforts to patent.

0:07:14The patent expired in, I had to look it up 2003 because I'm already gone off.

0:07:18Um, but that was part of the issue.

0:07:19Like TIFF used LZW, which meant how to be licensed.

0:07:22Uh, GIF was being attacked or potentially Unisys wanted to license it.

0:07:27Uh, I believe LZW may have been one of the early attempts to, uh, one of the issues

0:07:31like business, not business method patents, but it was a software-ish patent

0:07:34algorithm patents.

0:07:35There were some issues there anyway.

0:07:37Yeah. And it came out of that and historically we're getting sidetracked

0:07:39here, but it's all good stuff.

0:07:40The, the, it was, uh, it was a big story locally because

0:07:45Unisys is a Philadelphia area company, at least they were, I don't know if they

0:07:48still are. Um, so it was a big story locally. Um, but the gist of it is that

0:07:53they own the patents behind or patents that were part of fundamental part of

0:07:58the GIF GIF format.

0:08:01Uh,

0:08:02son of a bitch.

0:08:05uh...

0:08:06and they never enforced it and it you know people there were

0:08:11gift

0:08:12sping displayed and parsed and created

0:08:16you know and every image editing tool and i was all over the place and then

0:08:20netscape added you know put support in to render them in

0:08:26mosaic or whatever that you know whatever the first one of their browsers

0:08:29that images which was a big deal

0:08:32It was actually a big deal when they added image tags

0:08:35to the web browser.

0:08:37- Oh my God.

0:08:37- And they waited until like, all of a sudden,

0:08:42like when the internet exploded

0:08:43and everybody was buying, you know,

0:08:47like Adam Eng's internet book and everybody is like,

0:08:49I'm gonna get on the internet

0:08:50and Bill Gates is writing a memo that we're gonna,

0:08:52you know, turn the whole, you know,

0:08:54Microsoft around at the internet, internet, internet.

0:08:57And then all of a sudden, somebody at Unisys was like,

0:08:59hey, we own a patent for this.

0:09:00(laughing)

0:09:02And the open community responded and said,

0:09:05"We've gotta create a new format."

0:09:07And they did it, they did it quickly.

0:09:09They got support into all the tools quickly.

0:09:12And Ping took over the world as it was supposed to,

0:09:17very quickly, and that almost never happens.

0:09:20- It's where Ping is such a great format in a lot of ways.

0:09:22I mean, I think it's funny that it didn't actually

0:09:24ultimately replace everything except JPEG,

0:09:28but it's just, it's great.

0:09:29as all the different kinds, you know, two modes, you can do 24 bit with alpha transparency.

0:09:35And it's just, it's not quite as compact, I think as GIF for the same thing.

0:09:41But yeah, patents, patents are issued, almost came up, you remember with the, the committee

0:09:48that runs the, it was H.264, whatever the underlying patents are there, there's a patent

0:09:53pool.

0:09:54But I think there was at one point, there was a question about whether if you used,

0:09:58If you displayed H.264 video on your site without going through a third party package

0:10:03like Adobe flash, for instance, which wraps it, that you might actually owe separate licensing

0:10:08fees and using flash.

0:10:10One of the reasons that flash was successful, uh, is because Adobe handled the licensing

0:10:16for video patents, or at least they said they did.

0:10:18I think that fact was overlooked because the, you know, flash is so terrible, but it meant

0:10:22there was no, if you were a, you know, CBS or something, if you put it in flash, your

0:10:26your lawyers must have assured you it's cool.

0:10:28We don't have any fees.

0:10:30If you'd use HTML5 as if it existed to show,

0:10:34you know, to directly stream that kind of format,

0:10:37I think there might've been a patent issue.

0:10:38And that's been resolved since the patent holders changed it

0:10:41so they wouldn't, you know, poop in the pool.

0:10:42- I seem to remember that.

0:10:43You know, it's always a good sign

0:10:45when the lawyers are making engineering decisions

0:10:48(laughing)

0:10:49for your web technologies.

0:10:51- It's great, I like that.

0:10:52- Now what could go wrong?

0:10:55All right, back to the security issue.

0:10:56So all of Apple's operating systems

0:11:01were vulnerable to this threat.

0:11:04So it's- - Yeah, all the current ones

0:11:06and also two previous version of OS X were tested.

0:11:09It's possible that older versions are also vulnerable

0:11:12and they just didn't test them.

0:11:14I don't have the clarity on that

0:11:15because the particular library

0:11:17may go back a bazillion years,

0:11:19could be back to 10.6 or 10.0 for all we know.

0:11:25But there are no actual exploits in the wild, right?

0:11:29Or at least none that are known.

0:11:31- None that are known.

0:11:32It's possible, so I talked to the folks

0:11:34at the Cisco division directly,

0:11:37'cause I could not find, I saw this coverage.

0:11:39So you know how this works.

0:11:40Something happens related to Apple,

0:11:42and the news story is Apple computers burst into flames.

0:11:45That's like the next day.

0:11:46It's like, well, it was one computer in a lab.

0:11:48It was under controlled circumstance.

0:11:49No, no, Apple computers burst into flames.

0:11:51So Apple releases these updates,

0:11:54then the engineer at Cisco, or I sorry, Talos

0:11:56is the division.

0:11:57He writes up a, uh, the guy is in charge of

0:11:59this team who's credited with the discovery

0:12:01by Apple.

0:12:02So it meant he used responsible disclosure

0:12:04reported months ago, Apple patch at all,

0:12:06everything's cool.

0:12:06He writes up a very detailed blog post that

0:12:08explains the severity and then has some details

0:12:11about exactly what gets dumped.

0:12:12He puts some, you know, core dump information

0:12:15in or traces and things.

0:12:16And, um, people like, you know, the register

0:12:19and Forbes and whatever, right?

0:12:20These it's stage fright for Apple, you know,

0:12:23which is Android still is wrestling with stage fright,

0:12:26which was an MMS deliverable, among other factors,

0:12:29a way to send a maliciously formatted message

0:12:33for Android 2.2 and every subsequent system,

0:12:37and the problem with upgrading older Android systems

0:12:39and on and on, right?

0:12:40So stage fright remains, it's possible

0:12:42there's a couple hundred million Android devices

0:12:44that remain susceptible to stage fright, it's a big deal.

0:12:47And there were viruses that were discovered in the wild

0:12:50within I think weeks of the first stage fright release and then months later some more for

0:12:55devices that couldn't be patched. This touches on one of my very most precious pet themes in what I

0:13:06write about like in media criticism which is false equivalence. Yeah, yeah. And it's a huge

0:13:11issue in politics and it's definitely an issue in the tech world too and it's this idea that to be

0:13:17fair or cynic more cynically to sensationalize the story because I think everybody knows

0:13:26that putting Apple into headlines gets more clicks.

0:13:34So Android had stage fright or has stage fright, you know, and has this issue that is actually

0:13:39being exploited in the world.

0:13:41And there are lots, not most, you know, I'm not, nobody is saying that every Android phone

0:13:47out there is hacked or even most of them are, but that there are many people with Android

0:13:51devices that have malware, perhaps even unbeknownst to the user because of this exploit.

0:13:58Then Apple has this, you know, Cisco discovers this security problem in Apple's operating

0:14:04systems and it's presented as though it's, you know, like you just said, they're actually

0:14:08calling it Apple's version of stage fright, even though there aren't any known exploits.

0:14:12Right.

0:14:12The right, the right, it's great narrative.

0:14:13And there are similarities except sandboxing and code signing and so forth.

0:14:20There's a lot of spaces that are different in terms of how Android deals with incoming

0:14:25everything or, you know, malicious software that's trying to execute on a system.

0:14:28There's other protections, even if you manage to deliver a payload, you may just crash a process.

0:14:33Right.

0:14:33So the, you know, I talked to the engineer, I went back and forth through email.

0:14:37I had to go through the PR folks and, um, you know, it's like, is there a proof of concept?

0:14:40Because with Stagefright, the researchers who did that

0:14:43delivered an effective proof of concept

0:14:45showing not just that they could crash a process

0:14:47or overwrite a buffer,

0:14:48but that they could actually commit acts and gain root.

0:14:50If I recall, some Android systems you could get root

0:14:53and some behalf you could take control of the microphone

0:14:57and things like that.

0:14:58So there were ways to get access to system resources,

0:15:01even if you couldn't potentially gain root.

0:15:03And the Talos researcher said,

0:15:05in effect, we have a provable exploit

0:15:08that allows us to do nasty stuff with Safari and OS 10.

0:15:13And the reporting had been about MMS,

0:15:16but they have no exploit for that.

0:15:18They think there are some major hurdles in the way

0:15:20that might be able to be overcome.

0:15:22They weren't focusing on that

0:15:23because they knew it was gonna be patched.

0:15:24They focused on something

0:15:25where they had a path already to do it.

0:15:27They suspect that the Safari plus OS 10 pathway

0:15:30would also let them exploit iOS and Safari, mobile Safari.

0:15:35They haven't tested it, but everything seems the same.

0:15:37They think there may be a few more bars in the way there too, that can be overcome.

0:15:40This is all with the unpatched version.

0:15:42So, you know, the truth is, this is that it's going back to the

0:15:45beginning is it's a severe bug.

0:15:47You know, a few years ago, Apple had some wifi bugs where you could drive by and do

0:15:52terrible things to someone's wifi network and gain access and, you know, do all kinds

0:15:56of stuff to an airport base station or Mac, or sorry, Macintosh's, if you could

0:15:59just gain X, you know, just have physical proximity.

0:16:02And it's terror, that's especially terrifying because you don't

0:16:04actually have to be in their house.

0:16:05in their house, you just have to be within range of their wifi, which could

0:16:08be, you know, in a car in front of their house.

0:16:10Yeah.

0:16:12Just put a high gain antenna out the window and you can do it.

0:16:14And those, they were patched and people have the same argument then.

0:16:17And this happened since I think in a lot of times is how severe

0:16:21is it if the threat is over?

0:16:22It's like, well, this is very severe.

0:16:23We don't know the it's.

0:16:25It's severe as an exploit.

0:16:26You know, these things really are doing something really terribly

0:16:29wrong they shouldn't do and shouldn't be in the code.

0:16:31That's true.

0:16:32And conceivably it's a pathway.

0:16:34the next steps are in the lab or, you know, malware could be developed that

0:16:38would then take advantage of it.

0:16:40And we could find out how severe in practice it is.

0:16:42In theory, it's very severe, but because of responsible disclosure and Apple

0:16:47being able to patch it in a timely manner, there's no evidence anything is in the

0:16:50wild that said, this is the kind of thing when the, um, was it, uh, I'm blanking on

0:16:55the group in Italy that had all its files, hacking, hacking team hacking

0:17:00team or something like that.

0:17:01Yeah.

0:17:01Those guys.

0:17:02And it's true of some other outfits that have had leaked information.

0:17:05These, you know, there's all these companies, it's individual researchers and companies that exist to find zero days and sell them to governments, right?

0:17:11And governments are also working on similar things.

0:17:13It's possible things like this are already completely known, maybe even to multiple parties, and they're being deployed against some Iranian official or American official or Chinese official or a company for, you know, for industrial espionage.

0:17:28and it's being specifically deployed in a very quiet way

0:17:31in which it allows them to exfiltrate information

0:17:34or tap communications, but the idea, it's not,

0:17:39if that's the case, that hasn't been found yet,

0:17:41maybe it will now the bug is known,

0:17:43virus signatures will get updated, people will find it,

0:17:45but so it's not in the wild.

0:17:46- Yeah, there's, the most obvious source of malware,

0:17:51the one that we see and hear about most often

0:17:56is the one that's sort of stuff that's sort of out in the open,

0:17:59where it's just almost like-- you almost

0:18:03want to say more like common criminals who either find

0:18:07exploits like this that you can go through a web page

0:18:10or certainly email, click link, click this link in an email.

0:18:14And if you're using a certain type of computer that

0:18:16has a known exploit, just by clicking the link,

0:18:23you've got malware on your computer.

0:18:25And what does the malware do?

0:18:26A lot of times it sets up like a botnet

0:18:28or something like that.

0:18:29And it's like a shotgun approach to the crime

0:18:33where they're trying to just get hundreds and thousands

0:18:35of random people, they don't even care who you are,

0:18:38to run this and steal your Bitcoins

0:18:41or whatever they wanna do.

0:18:42That's the stuff that we see.

0:18:47The part that, the paranoid part of my mind is the,

0:18:51well, what about the Chinese government?

0:18:53The Chinese government would be, you know,

0:18:55are they employing people to find exploits like this?

0:18:59Of course they are, right?

0:19:00I mean, who, does anybody believe they're not?

0:19:03Does anybody think the NSA doesn't have

0:19:05really, really smart people doing this exact same thing?

0:19:10You know, and then there's the companies,

0:19:14not just governments, but companies like the hacking team

0:19:16that you mentioned that sell their services,

0:19:19you know, to governments and stuff like that.

0:19:20But find these zero days and then hold,

0:19:25instead of letting them loose,

0:19:26they're like a precious commodity.

0:19:28I mean, I think last year somebody was actually

0:19:30like in the public was saying,

0:19:32we're gonna pay a million dollars

0:19:35if you can find an exploit for iOS 9 or something like that.

0:19:38- Yeah, yeah.

0:19:39- I mean, a legitimate, I mean, sort of legitimate.

0:19:42I mean, it's sort of a scummy underside of the world,

0:19:44but a serious offer, a legitimate offer for a million dollars

0:19:48if you could deliver them an exploit that would let them do

0:19:52it.

0:19:52Well, it was just jailbreaking often falls that right.

0:19:55As there's companies that make a lot of money off, um, third

0:19:57party app stores for jailbroken, uh, uh, iPhones, I think.

0:20:02And so there's money to be made if you get the, the, uh, the

0:20:05exploit first, uh, the jailbreak, uh, um, pathways first, some of

0:20:09them sell jailbreaking is funny.

0:20:11Jailbreaking went from a very innocent enterprise in the early

0:20:13days to something that is now all enmeshed in viruses and criminal

0:20:16enterprise and so forth.

0:20:18There's still, I'm sure, legitimate people out there doing jailbreaking,

0:20:20but everything I read about it makes it sound like you don't know when you

0:20:24download the jailbreak tools what they're going to do.

0:20:26I was talking to a friend of the show, Craig Hockenberry at WWDC,

0:20:31and we were laughing,

0:20:34thinking like reminiscing to 10 years ago when the iPhone was new about how we

0:20:39all jail broke our phones.

0:20:40We all jail broke our phones at before the first C4 conference,

0:20:47because somebody had created the Lights Out game.

0:20:54And it was a really nice game.

0:20:56Like, it was just like a-- there was no Xcode for iOS yet.

0:21:01I mean, these were some really smart people.

0:21:03And there were no public tools at all to create iOS software.

0:21:10And somehow--

0:21:10Oh my god.

0:21:11And Craig, eventually, during the jailbreak era,

0:21:15I got Twitterrific working.

0:21:18So like, I don't know, of course,

0:21:19so of course I jail broke my phone

0:21:20'cause then I had an iPhone with Twitterrific on it.

0:21:22And this is before you could have apps.

0:21:24I mean, of course I jail broke.

0:21:26But it was, it just seemed, it was a lot easier too.

0:21:31- Innocent days back when it was just us kids

0:21:34playing around with the phone.

0:21:36Sidebar counselor, EFF has just filed a lawsuit

0:21:41about section 1201 of the DMCA,

0:21:44which I'm sure you're aware of.

0:21:45I saw the announcement.

0:21:46Yeah.

0:21:46Uh, it's the, so, you know, DMCA digital money and copyright act, which I think

0:21:50is a largely unconstitutional piece of legislation that has never been fully

0:21:54tested if the Supreme court ever got his hands on it, I got to say there's so many

0:21:58things in there that, that, uh, give the privileged commercial speech at the, in

0:22:03the face of free speech and whenever I've seen anything like it, that's been decided

0:22:07by high courts, you know, either appeals or up the Supreme court, it's usually,

0:22:11even if I don't agree with the decision entirely,

0:22:13it usually opens up the way for more speech,

0:22:16meaning more, encode is speech.

0:22:17It's sort of now been encoded at a certain level

0:22:20of the court systems, even if it's not totally understood.

0:22:23So one provision of the DMCA is this reverse engineering

0:22:26thing related to digital rights management.

0:22:28And if you put DRM on something as a manufacturer,

0:22:31it's illegal and you can be sent to jail for years,

0:22:34for, I'm sorry, four years, not for four years,

0:22:36I forget, see if it's like five years, I think.

0:22:39reverse engineer it, even for yourself, like in the privacy of your own home, FBI

0:22:42breaks in, you've been breaking DRM and not distributing it, you go to jail.

0:22:46And, uh, there's a provision called section 1201, which is the most hilarious thing

0:22:51in the world every three years, more or less, uh, the librarian of Congress

0:22:56holds hearings, not them personally.

0:22:58And the last, you know, we just got a new one.

0:23:00Isn't this awesome?

0:23:00The Senate actually approved the confirmation, uh, new librarian of

0:23:04Congress understands technology has run a library system.

0:23:07She's the voice of the future.

0:23:09This is going to be great.

0:23:10The guy who's been in charge for decades has been kind of a know nothing,

0:23:13Luddite, just terrible in terms of the technology side, great in terms of books.

0:23:17Anyway, so the section 1201 hearings, it's a circus.

0:23:21You have the process described in the law is terrible.

0:23:24So the librarian of Congress created a process that basically people who object

0:23:30to limitations and want to get them removed temporarily only for a three

0:23:36only for a three-year period have to essentially file something like a legal

0:23:39brief, although it can be in more plain language explaining why there's a

0:23:42legitimate public interest to be served in providing exemption. And then the

0:23:47librarian, so they have this circus, they have hearings and people parade through

0:23:50and they testify and there last time I think there were 47 different subgroup

0:23:55items being presented and it's just and it's you know farming, it's companies

0:24:00like John Deere who have DRM on their tractors, automakers, video game makers,

0:24:05printer companies, as well as the software and, you know, like iPhone

0:24:10locking and the rest of it.

0:24:11And, and then there's people who, you know, file these objections and there's

0:24:14back and forth, and then the Library of Congress issues a set of rules about

0:24:18what's going to be exempted, if anything, in the next three year period.

0:24:21It's a ridiculous process.

0:24:22So the EFF is suing, basically on the unconstitutionality of the, of this

0:24:28provision, and if it were struck down or even minimized, it would dramatically

0:24:33enhance the ability of people to do self-repair, which is, you know, Kyle

0:24:37Wiens at iFixit, he's been a huge proponent and deeply active in this process.

0:24:41And, um, you can read a lot of stuff about right to repair that

0:24:44relates a lot to DRM these days.

0:24:46Uh, I did a specific provision in the D digital D M C a not DCM.

0:24:54D D yeah.

0:24:55Digital cause it was a millennium copyright was sunny.

0:24:58I can't remember if Sonny Bono was involved in that one, but maybe

0:25:01- Maybe. (laughs)

0:25:02- We might have. - The Sonny Bono law also,

0:25:04but that's a different one.

0:25:05- It's specifically, it more or less outlaws backwards

0:25:08reverse engineering how DRM works.

0:25:11And reverse engineering is, you know,

0:25:13here, you've got this thing, you own it.

0:25:16Are you allowed to try to figure out how it works?

0:25:18And that's, you know, I think that's been considered

0:25:21part of, you know, I guess free speech,

0:25:25but certainly seems like something that, you know,

0:25:28I don't know, the engineer in me objects to,

0:25:31We've got this magic thing called copyright

0:25:35for our movies and music,

0:25:37and it gets a special exemption for this

0:25:40that nothing else has.

0:25:41- Yeah, and I just learned something,

0:25:44and that's terrible because it keeps innovation.

0:25:46How did everything interesting happen that's going on?

0:25:49Some people point to giant corporate research labs.

0:25:52So many interesting things we're doing in technology

0:25:54came from people tinkering at little stuff

0:25:57that they took apart, right?

0:25:58I saw Kate McKinnon, who I love,

0:25:59We're going to talk about Ghostbusters later, right?

0:26:01We'll talk about Ghostbusters.

0:26:02I have not seen the movie yet though.

0:26:03We'll talk about the movie.

0:26:04We'll talk, we're gonna talk about Twitter or whatever.

0:26:05Okay.

0:26:06Yeah.

0:26:06Yeah.

0:26:06I am one of the, my, one of the few people who still watches SNL.

0:26:09I watch it and Lynn and I, my wife, we fast forward, we tape it.

0:26:12We watch it like a few days later.

0:26:14We fast forward through the bad stuff.

0:26:15There are a bunch of really great performers.

0:26:18A lot of people our age have given up an SNL longer.

0:26:21Like it's, you know, we're big SNL fans here.

0:26:24Oh, good.

0:26:24Yeah.

0:26:24And it's hit or miss as you know, sometimes you're watching an entire

0:26:27episode, you're like, where I don't even know what happened.

0:26:29And then another time you're crying for--

0:26:31- It's always been like that.

0:26:33It's always been like that.

0:26:34- You're totally right.

0:26:35I have this, I have the same memory of,

0:26:36no, wasn't it always, no it wasn't.

0:26:38So Kate McKinnon, you love her then 'cause you watch it.

0:26:40She's an incredible mimic and she's great in "Ghostbusters."

0:26:43She is such a, I've seen her interviewed.

0:26:45I just think she is so great.

0:26:47And we're at the beginning of her breakout part

0:26:49of her career, like Kristen Wiig already had, right?

0:26:52This is it.

0:26:52So Kate McKinnon, I see this interview.

0:26:54She's on the red carpet for "Ghostbusters."

0:26:55And this tiny little girl,

0:26:57It's supposed to be like eight or nine is doing interviews.

0:27:00And she asked Kate McKinnon question and Kate

0:27:02McKinnon looks so touched and in love and then

0:27:04looks at her very seriously and gives you this

0:27:06answer.

0:27:07And the girl said, what was it like to work

0:27:09around all this cool technology in the movie?

0:27:11And Kate McKinnon said, when I was a kid, I

0:27:13used to love to take things apart, radios,

0:27:15things that look at the circuit boards and

0:27:16whatever, and this whole movie, I walk in

0:27:17everything is circuit boards.

0:27:19And it's just, it was a dream.

0:27:21It was like my childhood again, something like

0:27:23that.

0:27:23And I'm thinking that is the kind of thing

0:27:26that kids today, they don't know,

0:27:28they're not encouraged to take things apart.

0:27:30They could actually be violating the law

0:27:32if they were to know, on the software side,

0:27:34to circumvent things.

0:27:35Literally, these kids could be violating federal law

0:27:38for doing the stuff that you and I did,

0:27:40and all, you know, millions and millions of other children.

0:27:41- It is certainly the case

0:27:43that the overwhelming majority of all people

0:27:45have almost no curiosity about how things work.

0:27:47- Which is fine, which is fine.

0:27:48- Right, but for the minority of people

0:27:51who are curious about how things work,

0:27:54those also tend to be the sort of people

0:27:56who create new things, you know?

0:27:58And I mean, I think you could find that

0:28:00with creative people and, like you said, entertainers.

0:28:03Even entertainers, it's just like a mindset of,

0:28:06I would like to take that apart.

0:28:08(laughs)

0:28:10It is a very-- - I saw her at StuffMiner

0:28:11saying about refinishing tables too.

0:28:12She's got a crafty aspect to her, she does.

0:28:15- So my take on it is that I think it's,

0:28:20I object philosophically to the idea

0:28:22that you should outlaw being able to take things apart

0:28:24and figure out how they work,

0:28:26But on the flip side, I also think that the people

0:28:28who make things have every right to make them

0:28:30as difficult to take apart or as, you know,

0:28:33like in the case with Apple and cell phone encryption,

0:28:38that if Apple can figure out a way to mathematically

0:28:40make the contents of a phone effectively unbreakable,

0:28:45encryption wise, they have the right to do that.

0:28:48And the NSA has a right to try to find the holes

0:28:51in their logic.

0:28:52- Oh, yeah, I don't think manufacturers should be obliged

0:28:55to make it easy.

0:28:56And some do that.

0:28:57I was talking to a company that I can't reveal

0:28:58that said, because of various regulations,

0:29:01they're not allowed to promote the fact that

0:29:03their product is modifiable because it would

0:29:05actually put them in violation and put them in

0:29:07a new regulatory framework.

0:29:08However, they can make their product

0:29:11viable, a modifiable, including the firmware,

0:29:13and they just can't say anything about it.

0:29:15So they are actually doing everything they can.

0:29:17A great example is that I can talk about is

0:29:20Chumby, which is Bunny Huang, who's one of the

0:29:22plaintiffs in the EFF suit that's coming out

0:29:24Uh, suit that's coming up, uh, bunny, uh, lives in Singapore.

0:29:28I think still lives in Singapore.

0:29:29It goes to Shenzhen all the time.

0:29:31He's a hands-on designer.

0:29:33He's been designing an open laptop.

0:29:34This is too fascinating.

0:29:35It's not, there's a little ideology in it, but it's also an

0:29:38incredible technical exercise.

0:29:39He was one of the people behind Chumby, which was, uh, it was originally

0:29:42this kind of soft alarm clock that you could make apps for like many years ago.

0:29:47Yeah.

0:29:47And it went through a lot of revisions.

0:29:48It's still out there at company.

0:29:50So they left everything in such a state that when the product didn't succeed,

0:29:54People could keep it alive and then a new company

0:29:57came in to support it.

0:29:58And then that company is now making new chumby

0:29:59stuff and running the servers.

0:30:01Um, because enough was open and available.

0:30:04I don't think the whole thing was open source

0:30:06and forgetting all the details, but they had

0:30:07left everything open enough.

0:30:09And then I think when it was shutting down,

0:30:10they opened it even further.

0:30:12And I'm like, that was a wonderful thing.

0:30:14So as a company, you could choose to do that,

0:30:15but you can also choose to be, you know, rat

0:30:18bastards or pursue security, let's say

0:30:20it, whichever you want and, uh, not make it easy.

0:30:23That's totally, I mean, I don't, I don't think being, there's a difference there.

0:30:26Like should Apple allow third-party apps that are not sold from its store?

0:30:30I should say non app source apps.

0:30:31That's a whole interesting debate.

0:30:32And there's an argument to be made that they should be required, even if they have

0:30:36to put hurdles in and switches, and you have to agree, you're going to

0:30:39avoid your warranty or whatever.

0:30:41That's separate from should Apple let its firmware be hackable.

0:30:45That's a very different situation.

0:30:46They, they shouldn't pursue people who have broken into it.

0:30:51That's where the DRM issue lies rather than they should make it easy, which is a sort of philosophical,

0:30:56ideological situation.

0:30:58Um, all right.

0:31:00And that's where I disagree with the, what's his name?

0:31:03Wines from, uh, the, uh, Mac fix it.

0:31:06What's the point?

0:31:07Yeah.

0:31:07I fix it.

0:31:08I fix it.

0:31:08Like the pentalobe screw thing was a big, that was an inflection point, right?

0:31:11Is Apple switched to pentalobe screws.

0:31:14It was hard to get such a screwdriver then iFixit made it, which is great, but Kyle maintained, I think that, uh,

0:31:20- Yeah, from your right.

0:31:21Yeah, he said Apple is doing this to make it hard to repair.

0:31:25Some people said maybe it's because it's easier

0:31:27to do machine creation, but that was machine assembly.

0:31:31That's, who knows?

0:31:32But it definitely made it harder to repair.

0:31:34And then, you know, Tana Lobe screwdrivers got made

0:31:36and now it's possible.

0:31:37But I agree that Apple probably does some things

0:31:40to make it harder for third,

0:31:41for consumers and third parties to make changes.

0:31:44And other things, I think it's, they don't care.

0:31:47They just engineer it

0:31:48because they know they're gonna repair it

0:31:49so they don't give a damn if it's hard,

0:31:50'cause they'll take care of it.

0:31:51- Right, I think that there's,

0:31:54it's funny, 'cause that's a perfect example,

0:31:56and I try to be like this as much as I can.

0:31:59So I disagree with Kyle on his take on this,

0:32:03but I'm intrigued by his argument,

0:32:05and I don't, you know, I don't think that,

0:32:07I don't say this guy's an idiot.

0:32:09I disagree with him.

0:32:11I do believe that he's wrong,

0:32:13but I always do enjoy reading his pieces, arguing about it.

0:32:16He's pushing and he pushes the, the, he pushes the envelope in a way that's good for everybody.

0:32:20Even if you disagree with them, there's nothing wrong with the idea that Apple could roll back to

0:32:26Phillips head screws.

0:32:27Like that doesn't make things worse for anyone.

0:32:28Even if you disagree with why they switched to Pentelome.

0:32:31Um, I want to point that since we're in a sidebar, we're sort of side barring a sidebar, there's a great piece

0:32:35about warranties and motherboard last month.

0:32:38I don't know if you saw this house Sony, Microsoft and other gadget makers violate federal warranty law.

0:32:42I am going to send you a URL.

0:32:45This is a great piece. I never knew this.

0:32:48Most, all the things that say,

0:32:51break the seal and you violate warranty

0:32:53are actually either illegal or unenforceable.

0:32:56I had no idea.

0:32:57- I did not know that either.

0:32:58- 1970 law called the Magnuson Moss Warranty Act.

0:33:01Federal law says you can open your electronics

0:33:03without voiding the warranty,

0:33:04regardless of what the language of that warranty says.

0:33:06People should read this 'cause I had my mind blown.

0:33:09- Every single hard drive I've ever purchased

0:33:10has a sticker like that somewhere on it.

0:33:14But I always thought that it was kind of reasonable

0:33:16for like a hard drive because,

0:33:18especially in the spinning disk era,

0:33:20if you get to the point where you open up

0:33:22and expose the disk and it picks up dust

0:33:25and then doesn't work right,

0:33:27well, why shouldn't your warranty be blocked?

0:33:28- Oh yeah, it's not that, but the thing is,

0:33:31the warranty isn't de facto violated by breaking the seal,

0:33:35and that's the thing.

0:33:36Or even doing a repair, the article notes,

0:33:39and they got some great liability lawyers,

0:33:42that lemon law lawyers talk about is the manufacturer

0:33:45has to prove that your, whatever you did caused the failure.

0:33:48- Ah, gotcha, that's fair.

0:33:49- So they can do that.

0:33:50They can say there's dust on the drive,

0:33:52there wasn't dust originally,

0:33:53it worked when you got it, so screw you.

0:33:55- I see that, going back to Kyle Wines,

0:33:58I think his argument would be bolstered

0:34:01if he stopped attributing malice to Apple

0:34:04and simply stated why he thinks

0:34:07these would be better devices with standard screws.

0:34:10And I know one of his other bugaboos

0:34:12is the use of glue.

0:34:13- Oh yeah.

0:34:14- Just make the argument that this would be a better device

0:34:19for everybody if they stopped using glue

0:34:23and stuff like that.

0:34:25- Oh yeah. - Instead of saying

0:34:26that they're doing this to make it hard to repair.

0:34:29Apple does not care about the repair shops.

0:34:31They don't.

0:34:32They give no shits.

0:34:33- It's tiny, yeah.

0:34:35It's also, this is a case,

0:34:38this is not a sidebar, I swear to God.

0:34:39parentheses Nestor as you know.

0:34:40Um, but Walt Hickey wrote this great piece that I

0:34:43think he's at 538, I think that's right about,

0:34:46um, he's, I love his writing and he wrote this

0:34:48thing about how IMDb, uh, movies, uh, movie scores

0:34:52are, um, are sunk by male trolls because he did

0:34:57the analysis and you can see that men more highly,

0:35:01uh, downvote or give poor ratings to movies that

0:35:04women like better than, and women do not do the

0:35:07same thing to male films.

0:35:08films that men like better.

0:35:10So, you can look at films that more men have seen,

0:35:12there's gender split, you know, and so forth.

0:35:13And you can do that analysis and figure it out.

0:35:15And the article is really interesting, but the one

0:35:17thing I disagree with him on is he was attributing malice.

0:35:20He said effectively that men are trolling as

0:35:23opposed to internalizing their own toxic masculinity

0:35:26and voting stuff down because they thought no one

0:35:28should see it, sort of the Ghostbusters thing.

0:35:29Again, like, well, if you haven't seen the movie and

0:35:31you're voting to three, you're kind of a troll, but

0:35:34some people may have, may have seen it.

0:35:36You don't know how many haven't seen it.

0:35:38haven't seen it, how, have, and whatever.

0:35:40I feel like the same thing a bit with people

0:35:41who attribute things to Apple.

0:35:43If you know, if you could pull it out and say,

0:35:47I talked to, or an Apple engineer goes public and says,

0:35:50I worked at Apple for 20 years,

0:35:52and the things we did to screw repair firms,

0:35:55then you could say, malice.

0:35:56- My job was to make it difficult or impossible

0:35:59to replace your screen at a third-party facility,

0:36:02because Apple wants the $100 replacement fee.

0:36:06I was the extra glue engineer at Apple,

0:36:08continuing glue engineer.

0:36:09- Before, this is good.

0:36:12I think I can unwind.

0:36:13I wanna go back to the security bug.

0:36:17So all the way back to this responsible,

0:36:24what is it called, responsible?

0:36:26- Is it like, I don't know, I may know if this is right,

0:36:27it's like responsible disclosure policy

0:36:29is what I'd label it.

0:36:30- So in some aspect though, it's not responsible

0:36:33because the only things that are updated

0:36:36are the very latest update to the OS.

0:36:38I'm talking to you right now through an iMac

0:36:42that has not been updated,

0:36:43because I didn't feel like restarting my Mac

0:36:45before we started the show.

0:36:46- Right, right.

0:36:47- So the Mac I'm talking to you on right now is not updated.

0:36:51My iPhone is.

0:36:53I thoroughly doubt that my son's or wife's iPhones are.

0:36:58I'm pretty sure my iPad is not because I haven't,

0:37:01oh no, it might because I'm running iOS 10 beta,

0:37:04so I don't know.

0:37:05But I have devices, I'm technically adept

0:37:08and I'm in tune to the news.

0:37:10And I have devices that aren't updated yet.

0:37:13And let alone anybody who hasn't updated to El Capitan yet.

0:37:18If you're running, you know, what was the one before?

0:37:26- Yosemite, I don't have to keep looking it up.

0:37:29- You know, you're still vulnerable.

0:37:34And I don't know if Apple, you know,

0:37:35nobody knows 'cause Apple won't say it,

0:37:36but whether Apple's gonna do a security update

0:37:38for those things either.

0:37:39So in some sense, I often wonder

0:37:41about disclosing these things, you know,

0:37:43whether it's good or bad.

0:37:46- Well, yeah, there's a couple of different aspects to it.

0:37:49If there's a zero day, you know,

0:37:52which just for the benefit of listeners who don't know,

0:37:53zero day is an exploit that is known as something is patched.

0:37:57So the patch comes out and it's known

0:37:59that it's in malware that's being used, right?

0:38:03So it has to be patched immediately

0:38:05because you have to protect people who are in active danger.

0:38:07So this is not a zero day.

0:38:09There's no known attacks in the wild.

0:38:11I haven't seen anything in the last couple of days

0:38:12that suggested anyone had managed to exploit this

0:38:15in any broad way.

0:38:15And we'd know that 'cause Mac users and iOS users,

0:38:18if it had been sent out as general malware,

0:38:20would have been reporting,

0:38:21I've been hijacked or whatever,

0:38:23because malware distributors are not subtle, typically.

0:38:26There'd be ransomware.

0:38:27I mean, the big thing right now is ransomware,

0:38:28as you know, I've been writing about that recently.

0:38:30I got a couple articles on it.

0:38:31And anyway, so this isn't a zero day,

0:38:35but this is the tricky part.

0:38:37Like if you don't think that it's in the wild,

0:38:39like you're working for a security company,

0:38:40there's no reports of this coming out,

0:38:42that you've been analyzing,

0:38:43you've found it proactively in advance or prospectively.

0:38:47And the patch has been made and distributed

0:38:50so anyone can get it has it.

0:38:52That removes the financial incentive

0:38:53for any criminal organization to try to find an exploit

0:38:57because the window is closing so fast.

0:38:59Like, you know, 25% of it's closed in the first few hours

0:39:03and Apple pushes updates so heavily

0:39:06and makes it hard to ignore them,

0:39:07especially in iOS and other platforms

0:39:10that the odds of having a target are very small.

0:39:12So you spend weeks or months developing the payload

0:39:15of the exploit technology to deliver the correct payload.

0:39:18And by then 93% of people have updated

0:39:21and you have, you know, a couple hundred thousand people

0:39:22you have to reach and even spam and phishing

0:39:25doesn't make it worthwhile to send out the messages

0:39:27to reach a fraction of them.

0:39:29So the economics of it are bad when it's not a zero day.

0:39:31When it's a zero day, you disclose because it's so dangerous

0:39:34and you want everyone to patch right away.

0:39:36And the economics there change instantly too,

0:39:38but there's exploits out there that will be tried

0:39:40to be put out as fast as they can before people patch.

0:39:44- Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor.

0:39:46I love, this is a brand new sponsor and it is a great app.

0:39:51It's called Boom.

0:39:52It's a Mac app from Global Delight.

0:39:54Have you ever wished that the audio playing

0:39:56your Mac could be richer, crisper, and just better. If you like listening to music, movies, videos

0:40:02through your Mac or any other audio, then you may have searched for ways to boost the volume on your

0:40:08Mac but haven't found anything yet. Well, that's what Boom does. It's an amazing audio enhancer for

0:40:12the Mac. It is simple. It's gorgeous. It has great looking UI. These guys at Global Delight have always

0:40:19always done really, really high-end, you know, classic indie Mac developer attention to detail,

0:40:26and all the icons look great and everything like that. So it's just a volume booster. That's it.

0:40:33Just it works on a system-wide level, so you don't have to install it like inside apps. It's not a

0:40:39plug-in or anything like that. And anything you play on your Mac suddenly sounds amplified.

0:40:45It works with headphones, it works with speakers,

0:40:48and the best part, it's a MacWorld Best of Show winner.

0:40:52This is an app that has been renowned.

0:40:54It really, it sounds almost like snake oil,

0:40:57but it really does work.

0:40:58It's won the MacWorld Best of Show

0:41:00back when MacWorld was a show.

0:41:02And here's the best part.

0:41:04Anyway, I keep talking in circles here,

0:41:06but the best part is right now, for a very limited period,

0:41:09I don't quite know how limited the period is,

0:41:11so if you hear it, you better go get it now,

0:41:12It is 33% off in their store.

0:41:15It's just $9.99.

0:41:17It's usually $15.

0:41:19Where do you go?

0:41:20Here's their URL.

0:41:21It's a Bitly URL.

0:41:22So go to bit.ly/boom2mac.

0:41:28That's the digit 2.

0:41:30Bitly/boom2mac.

0:41:34And you will get more info.

0:41:36They have a seven-day free trial.

0:41:37Can you believe that?

0:41:38Seven-day free trial.

0:41:39What a-- it's like in the world of the App Store,

0:41:42it's like you forget about free trials.

0:41:43Well, guess what?

0:41:44That's why the Mac is awesome.

0:41:46Seven day free trial.

0:41:47Try it, listen to it, see that you like it,

0:41:51and then you can get it for 33% off.

0:41:53That's boom two, that's the reason the two is in the URL.

0:41:57This is version two of the app.

0:41:58Boom two, 33% off.

0:42:00Bitly/boom2mac.

0:42:02It's a great app.

0:42:03We were talking before about the sort of,

0:42:12I don't know what you'd call it,

0:42:13but the idea that Mac users are insufferably smug

0:42:17on security issues.

0:42:18- So true.

0:42:20- And that's another one that's sort of like

0:42:21a pet issue of mine, is the incessant,

0:42:26inevitable need to boil everything down to a binary.

0:42:32It's either this or that.

0:42:35Either the Mac is completely invulnerable

0:42:38to malware and security exploits,

0:42:42or the Mac is every bit as vulnerable and exploitable

0:42:47as every other system that's out there,

0:42:50when the truth is in between.

0:42:53It is nuanced.

0:42:54You know, and it was a lot, you still see it,

0:42:57and part of it is that iOS is so spectacularly popular

0:43:02and such a lucrative target.

0:43:05But in the old days, pre-iPhone,

0:43:08it was always, almost always boiled down to an argument

0:43:13that the Mac, you know, Windows has all this malware

0:43:16problems, all these issues and all this, you know,

0:43:20and I don't even think it was snake oil.

0:43:22I think it was a reasonable thing that, you know,

0:43:24informed users would agree with,

0:43:26was that it was considered a standard practice

0:43:31to install antivirus on your Windows PC.

0:43:35That if you didn't, you were a fool

0:43:37and you were probably gonna get exploited.

0:43:38- Oh yeah, remember when you'd install

0:43:40a virtual Windows machine on your Mac in Parallels

0:43:42and then you'd launch it and it would get infected

0:43:44before you could install the antivirus software?

0:43:46That happened to me.

0:43:47- It's no exaggeration.

0:43:50And then Mac users, informed Mac users like myself

0:43:55would say, "Well, I don't run any antivirus on my Mac."

0:44:00And in fact, I don't recommend, my family members do,

0:44:04and I don't think you should either.

0:44:05And I don't think you need to.

0:44:08And then they would say, well, you're an idiot,

0:44:09because the only reason the Mac doesn't get exploited

0:44:12is that it's every bit as vulnerable as Windows,

0:44:14but it's too small for the malware people to care about.

0:44:18And it's like, you can't disprove that.

0:44:20That's one of those, it's like,

0:44:21I don't know what the rhetorical description of that is,

0:44:24but it's sort of like a straw man argument.

0:44:26You can't knock it down.

0:44:27You can't disprove a hypothetical like that, right?

0:44:32There's no way to prove it otherwise,

0:44:33except if the Mac got as popular as Windows.

0:44:37And that sort of happened with iOS, right?

0:44:42iOS has hundreds of millions,

0:44:45or I guess a billion active devices.

0:44:47There might be, now that I think about it,

0:44:50there might be more iOS devices in use than Windows devices.

0:44:53I don't know, that might be ridiculous.

0:44:55- I think there's more Windows,

0:44:55because Windows things are never,

0:44:57there's like people running Windows 95 stuff someplace.

0:45:00- It's in the ballpark though.

0:45:01probably running air traffic control or something.

0:45:04- It is in the ballpark.

0:45:05- Yeah, oh yeah.

0:45:07- And it didn't happen.

0:45:09I mean, now there is malware for Mac.

0:45:11There is malware that attacks iOS,

0:45:13but it's never been as rampant a problem

0:45:15as it has been on other platforms.

0:45:18- Yeah, it's, I've always said,

0:45:21shouldn't say always, but I've said increasingly,

0:45:23let's say this time is going by,

0:45:24I said increasingly like Apple was a weird target

0:45:26and we had, we were the first viruses

0:45:28come to the computers, the first widespread worms and things

0:45:31was through Macs, right?

0:45:32We had the one that you stuck a disc in,

0:45:34it would write it to the floppy disk, I think.

0:45:35- Yes, I have in my notes here,

0:45:38do you remember what, do you remember?

0:45:40There was a time. - It's not gonna be.

0:45:41- There was a time when I did run antivirus on my Mac

0:45:45and I did recommend everybody do it.

0:45:47It was called Disinfectant.

0:45:48- Yeah, oh, I love that.

0:45:49Yeah, those guys, yes. - Awesome.

0:45:51Oh no, it was one guy.

0:45:52It was like a guy up in Seattle, right?

0:45:54- Oh, you're so right, 'cause did he charge for it?

0:45:57- No, it was free. - It was free.

0:45:58- What was his name? - It was great.

0:45:59It was as good as the commercial solutions for a long time.

0:46:01- John Norstead.

0:46:04- Oh, wow, that's good memory.

0:46:05I think that's right.

0:46:06A very nice guy, if I recall, too.

0:46:08- Really nice guy.

0:46:09I mean, like, just amazing that it was just,

0:46:14and it was this free utility you did,

0:46:17like an init, you would, Norstead, John Norstead.

0:46:21- I miss inits, sort of.

0:46:23- Here's his homepage, John Norstead's homepage.

0:46:26There he is.

0:46:27- Yay.

0:46:27- I will put this in the show notes.

0:46:29John Norstead's homepage.

0:46:30It was amazing.

0:46:31It was an init, you ran it,

0:46:34it seemingly didn't slow your Mac down at all.

0:46:38It had no adverse effects,

0:46:40and it was updated on a regular basis

0:46:43with all the new viruses that were spread around,

0:46:47and it would identify them and block them.

0:46:49But yeah, that was like an insidious one.

0:46:50I remember Drexel was absolutely hit by it.

0:46:53It was so insidious.

0:46:57it was a virus that would spread just by inserting a floppy disk into an already infected machine.

0:47:01Great piece of engineering for the day.

0:47:03Yeah.

0:47:04But yeah, so here's my thing.

0:47:05So Apple didn't necessarily, they're not a,

0:47:08Apple was never necessarily ahead on any innovation like address space layout randomization, ALSR,

0:47:13which is a great technique used so that you can't predictably as a malware developer

0:47:18know where part of the system is going to be located in memory necessarily.

0:47:22And the more ASLR you do across everything,

0:47:25target a memory location and have something happen.

0:47:27And so that, you know, that Windows, I want to say

0:47:30Microsoft introduced that years before and they

0:47:32needed to before OS X.

0:47:34It was much more necessary.

0:47:35But Apple wasn't necessarily an innovator in that.

0:47:37What they were an innovator in was accidental things

0:47:40that worked, right?

0:47:41So, Apple going to free updates for its operating

0:47:45system, you know, first super cheap and then

0:47:48completely free and all the free incremental ones.

0:47:50And the way in which you could do an incremental

0:47:52You could do an incremental update in OS X without typically destroying your system.

0:47:56I know there were some bad releases and I had problems over the years,

0:47:59but they created an environment in which people were expected to run updates and typically stay up to date.

0:48:04You might have been, you know, using 10.6.8, not 10.7 for a while, but then you'd switch over.

0:48:09And when you looked at over the years, as you looked at the adoption curve,

0:48:13it's ridiculous compared to any other operating system.

0:48:16These people move up so fast, and software developers, of course, have the issue of compatibility and all that.

0:48:21So there are, uh, the, the long tail of older versions by number of people, uh,

0:48:27running, uh, a number of computers rather of older versions of OS X is very small

0:48:31compared to most other things.

0:48:33You look at Android, too, Android, and there's this incredible distribution

0:48:36because Android devices, when they were sold originally, the first

0:48:40generations, as opposed to iOS, uh, it was very difficult or impossible

0:48:45to get beyond the version, even the subversion, like 2.2 that you had

0:48:49that you had installed.

0:48:50That gives you a great target,

0:48:52'cause you know there's going to be 100 million devices

0:48:54out there running Android 2.2

0:48:56for as long as the devices work.

0:48:58So you have that target to attack forever.

0:49:01Android, as opposed to OS X or iOS,

0:49:04didn't have a good pathway directly to users.

0:49:06I mean, Windows has this, of course,

0:49:08as a direct pathway,

0:49:09and eventually it helped to provide security updates.

0:49:11So Android users are sort of abandoned,

0:49:14and Google's been working on this for years

0:49:15to create an effective way to have a rapid turnaround

0:49:18for certain kinds of security issues.

0:49:20Switching to apps is one way.

0:49:22One of my colleagues over at Greenbot

0:49:24in the IDG family there, Flo I was telling the other day

0:49:27that like Google having a messaging app,

0:49:30Hangouts and messenger, I forgot they call it messenger.

0:49:33They can update the app.

0:49:34If there's a security problem in the app,

0:49:35the app can take care of it,

0:49:37but they can't update the entire system

0:49:38'cause someone's running an outdated or unpatchable phone.

0:49:41So Apple, I think the upgrade cycle

0:49:44can always reduces the target of potential infections,

0:49:47whether it's with iOS, which is a monolithic,

0:49:49you know, ecosystem as opposed to Android,

0:49:52or it's with OS 10 where they push stuff out.

0:49:55And I think it seems like a pretty fast way

0:49:58and get people up to the next version.

0:49:59So there's never a lot of people

0:50:01that you can easily target.

0:50:02And with Windows, you have people running,

0:50:04hundreds of millions of people

0:50:05running pre Windows 10 versions.

0:50:07You have hundreds of millions of Android users,

0:50:09maybe several hundred million

0:50:11running pre Marshmallow six point X versions, right?

0:50:14So those targets are so lovely that as a,

0:50:17If you're a malware developer and you're a criminal and you're trying to hit the biggest target, why would you do it for iOS or OS 10?

0:50:24If it's going to be hard or there aren't enough people, it's, it's again,

0:50:28if you're doing that shotgun approach of I want to do the least, I want to do the least amount of work and get my scummy little piece of malware on as many devices as possible.

0:50:38I'm going to send it a billion phishing messages. And I know that I'm going to catch of that, like a hundred million Android 2.2 users.

0:50:44users, it's their owners.

0:50:45It's easy, relatively easy.

0:50:46Whereas if you want it, if you're in the business of targeting specific

0:50:51individuals at the behest of a government agency, you

0:50:54totally different.

0:50:54Yeah.

0:50:55I mean, look at the threat, you know, the hacking team that revealed how many

0:50:57different kinds of attacks that were against, uh, max and iOS.

0:51:00So, and it's a different category.

0:51:02It's something to be concerned about, but it's also things like Apple, uh,

0:51:05didn't have a native mail program for the longest time.

0:51:07Remember, and then they come out with mail and mail's kind of crappy, but it

0:51:10Apple came out with own mail program for OS 10.

0:51:12Um, there was already diversity, so you

0:51:14couldn't as a malware author, target a

0:51:16specific popular mail programs problems.

0:51:20The mail programs weren't deeply integrated,

0:51:22like they were in windows.

0:51:23So you couldn't cause like JavaScript to run

0:51:25an attached message without someone clicking

0:51:27on it in Eudora or whatever.

0:51:29Right.

0:51:29And then when mail came out, Apple already

0:51:31knew this was a problem.

0:51:32So they engineered something that was less

0:51:34embedded in more separate.

0:51:36So you could still have stuff that would go

0:51:37wrong, but it was, it was a problem.

0:51:40a more limited set of activities that happened

0:51:42with Outlook and integration.

0:51:44I mean, Microsoft's basically spent the last 20 years

0:51:46pulling out the hooks it built deeply into its systems

0:51:49that allowed things to happen

0:51:50when they should have been sandboxed.

0:51:52- We're so old that I specifically, you say that

0:51:55and it sounds so old.

0:51:58- That's right, you remember when they did.

0:51:59- Max shipped without an email app.

0:52:02And I had to double check.

0:52:04I knew that Apple didn't make one, but I was like, wait,

0:52:06Did they maybe ship like Netscape's weirdo email

0:52:10or something?

0:52:11I was like, no, they didn't ship any of them.

0:52:12I didn't even ship the one.

0:52:13I was a Eudora user.

0:52:16- What came after that?

0:52:17I mean, it was Outlook.

0:52:18I think I used Outlook for a while in the Office Suite.

0:52:21I don't know if that was part of, was that part of the deal?

0:52:23Did Jobs and Gates agree as part of the Microsoft investment

0:52:28that Apple wasn't going to release its own mail software?

0:52:31- No, no.

0:52:32- Okay, because Outlook existed.

0:52:34So we put Office or they didn't install Eudora

0:52:35And there were a bunch of other mail programs.

0:52:37There's still a remarkable number of email programs

0:52:40available and new ones being developed all the time.

0:52:42- I don't wanna resort to Google here.

0:52:45I want either me or you to remember it.

0:52:47What was the one Jed Spencer's team created?

0:52:51And they went on to Microsoft

0:52:53and created the good version of Outlook.

0:52:56- And it wasn't Note, what was it called?

0:52:58I don't think I ever used that.

0:53:01- Guy Kawasaki was a big--

0:53:03- Mail mate?

0:53:04- No, no.

0:53:05It was beloved by some people.

0:53:09- I don't, I don't know.

0:53:10- Was it a Claris product at one point even?

0:53:12- Claris had an email product, didn't it?

0:53:14I don't, you know, I'll tell you, I use Mailsmith today.

0:53:18I actually wrote a--

0:53:19- You still do?

0:53:20- I wrote a pro, I wrote an article for Macworld

0:53:22recently called Old Software That We All Still Use,

0:53:24and I got so many lovely comments from people

0:53:26chipping in with these.

0:53:27I used Quicken 2007.

0:53:29I used Mailsmith, which is updated for compatibility.

0:53:32I use CSS Edit from Mac Rabbit,

0:53:34which doesn't develop anymore

0:53:35for doing CSS tweaking on live sites.

0:53:38I have this whole set of old software

0:53:40that's still either getting tiny compatibility updates

0:53:44or manages to work under the current environment,

0:53:46and I'll cry when it stops.

0:53:48And people chimed in with all this software that they use

0:53:50that's sometimes like 10 plus years old

0:53:53that they've just been, you know, a level later.

0:53:55Level later, they upgraded it very nice

0:53:58to the people involved and to be compatible with El Capitan.

0:54:02but Levelator I don't think was really changed

0:54:04for several years.

0:54:05It's a vital piece of podcast,

0:54:07audio normalization, equalization software.

0:54:10- All right, we hold the thought.

0:54:12I did cheat, I Googled

0:54:14and I went to Judge Benser's LinkedIn page.

0:54:18It was Fog City Software.

0:54:20- Fog, yes.

0:54:21- And the product was called E-mailer.

0:54:24And then it was purchased by Apple in March, 1996

0:54:27and became Claris E-mailer.

0:54:29So Apple owned it 'cause Apple owns,

0:54:31or I guess Claris doesn't exist anymore.

0:54:33And I guess it's FileMaker.

0:54:34- It was like spun out and Summit was spun in.

0:54:37- Apple owned an email client,

0:54:38but didn't pre-install it on Mac.

0:54:40- Oh my God.

0:54:41- Because, and the whole point was that until the,

0:54:46again, I've long said that to me,

0:54:50there's really only two eras at Apple.

0:54:53There was the original era up

0:54:56and then starting with the next reunification,

0:54:59that's like modern Apple.

0:55:00Modern Apple started with the next reunification

0:55:04and jobs coming back.

0:55:06And there's so many things that were different,

0:55:08but in the original Apple, it was explicit.

0:55:12It wasn't even implicit.

0:55:14I think Apple was explicit about it at times

0:55:17that they didn't want to compete with third party developers.

0:55:22And so the Mac, it would have,

0:55:26it had like, what was it called back then?

0:55:28Simple Text, Teach Text, which was the--

0:55:31- Ah, I can't remember now.

0:55:33I think it's, I remember Simple Text,

0:55:34but I think that was later, I think you're right.

0:55:36- Teach Text was like the built-in read me reader,

0:55:39but super minimal.

0:55:41I mean, way less, way more minimal,

0:55:44minimally featured even than TextEdit today.

0:55:46- I'm sorry, just think about TextEdit,

0:55:48'cause TextEdit actually has its roots, right, in Next.

0:55:51- Yes, oh, deeply, yeah. - I mean, that is basically,

0:55:53and TextEdit is a great piece of software no one uses,

0:55:55and I wrote a Macworld piece about how great

0:55:58There's some features in it that are invaluable

0:56:00that you can basically cannot easily get

0:56:01in any other piece of software.

0:56:02- People do use it.

0:56:04There are, it's sort of like a secret cult of people

0:56:06who love, and rightly so,

0:56:07text edit, including people at Apple.

0:56:11I remember I had a meeting at Apple over a decade ago

0:56:14when I was at Joyent.

0:56:15It had nothing to do with during Fireball.

0:56:16It was, you know, Apple wanted to meet with us

0:56:19and talk about Joyent's technology and blah, blah, blah.

0:56:22And I noticed that it was the first time, actually,

0:56:26I met Michael Lop in person.

0:56:28- Oh yeah, yeah. - At Ranson Repose.

0:56:29He was there, he was an Apple software manager at the time.

0:56:33And so we didn't know each other, we weren't friends yet,

0:56:36but we were online, had a little bit of back and forth

0:56:39simply as he knew Darren Fireball, I knew Ranson Repose.

0:56:43He comes into the meeting and of course,

0:56:45he's a very, he's such a minimalist.

0:56:48He opens up his, I don't know if it was,

0:56:50it might even have been a PowerBook at the time,

0:56:51but whatever, MacBook, PowerBook.

0:56:53Of course there's nothing on screen,

0:56:55It's just a beautiful desktop picture.

0:56:57He launches TextEdit and he's got one window on screen

0:57:00and it's TextEdit and that's the app he used

0:57:02to take notes for the meeting.

0:57:03And I was like kind of blown away,

0:57:05but also not surprised at all.

0:57:07And he was like, oh, of course.

0:57:08'Cause he said, you know why I use this app?

0:57:10I use this app because it is super simple

0:57:12and it has never once crashed on me.

0:57:14I've never lost a single letter of anything I've ever typed

0:57:18in TextEdit.

0:57:19But anyway, Apple--

0:57:21- I think this is still the case in Japan, I don't know.

0:57:23But in Japan, it used to be the less on your business card,

0:57:25the more important you were.

0:57:26And then, at least in the '80s,

0:57:27I remember seeing a cartoon about this

0:57:28and reading about this, and you know,

0:57:30when you hand someone a business card to Japan,

0:57:31you hold it with two hands, and you hand it to them.

0:57:33It's just, you know, it's got a little bit

0:57:34of a ceremony about it, used to.

0:57:35I have no idea what people do today.

0:57:37And there was a comic strip at the time

0:57:38by an alt cartoonist who was about these two people

0:57:41competing for a job in Japan and striving to be whatever,

0:57:44and one of them has a dream, he says,

0:57:45"I dreamt I met God, and he handed me his business card,

0:57:48"and it was completely blank."

0:57:49That's what I'm thinking about

0:57:50when you're talking about Michael Law on the street.

0:57:53- So Apple had an email product,

0:57:54and they didn't even pre-install it, I don't think.

0:57:56Maybe they did at some point.

0:57:58- Yeah, so nothing bundled.

0:58:00They kept their hands off.

0:58:01And Microsoft integration, bundling,

0:58:03tying monopoly-ish tendencies,

0:58:06always keeping this market locked in for themselves,

0:58:09whether it's business software, productivity issues,

0:58:12email, browser, that was their security downfall.

0:58:15And I think they spent a lot of time backing away from that.

0:58:18And okay, oh, so I just did this story.

0:58:20I don't know if this is a sidebar.

0:58:21We're still talking viruses.

0:58:22I just did a piece that should be out

0:58:24by the time this airs, for MIT Technology Review

0:58:26about some new research, it's been public for months,

0:58:29a couple research teams at different universities

0:58:32came up with strategies for fighting ransomware on Windows.

0:58:34And it was very interesting, and I talked to a bunch,

0:58:36I talked to McAfee and other folks, and the researchers,

0:58:40and the thing that's hilarious,

0:58:41they say, "Well, how do you stop ransomware?

0:58:42"What do you do?"

0:58:43And they're like, "Well, you keep your software up to date,

0:58:45"you install, you run the latest patches,

0:58:47"you don't run Java, you don't run Flash."

0:58:49I'm like, "Wait, what about virus software?"

0:58:50They're like, "That's sort of the last stage.

0:58:52Like ransomware and most malware now just targets this incredibly low hanging fruit

0:58:57of which there still remains so much.

0:58:59Like, so one of the people I spoke to said something like 50% of machines you can

0:59:03just get into because they're just not protected in any way.

0:59:07Forget antivirus software.

0:59:09Um, what the ransomware, what's interesting is the developers of these, uh, these

0:59:13academics, rather the two different groups took different approaches, but the fact

0:59:16is ransomware, it works on user space files.

0:59:19So it's actually insidious.

0:59:21You don't have to gain deep permissions.

0:59:22Once the payload is dropped and it runs, you know, a lot of ransomware is like scripts,

0:59:26like PHP or JavaScript, and you double click a Trojan horse that's delivered via email,

0:59:32and it just starts encrypting files because it doesn't need extra permission.

0:59:35It can, it's, they're your files, so they're only doing documents, but there's a lot of

0:59:39tell tales, there's entropy and all kinds of other stuff that can monitor.

0:59:42So the approaches are really cool, but I was like, oh, that's one reason ransomware has

0:59:46a money thing at the end, which is very straightforward.

0:59:50And there's like 6 million unique variants of ransomware out there now,

0:59:54because the modifications of a bunch of like base families of ransomware,

0:59:58so many different people are doing it because the money is so easy.

1:00:01But fundamentally, it has that great advantage.

1:00:04It's not trying to get into your kernel and do something.

1:00:06It's not trying to hijack your networking.

1:00:08It's just trying to take your Word documents and make them unreadable.

1:00:11Right. It's not really fighting the system.

1:00:13It's actually going with the flow of the system.

1:00:15Oh, you're something the user double-click,

1:00:17you have access to all of the user's files.

1:00:19Yeah, exactly. It's in your doc, you know, my documents, boom, you're done.

1:00:21Well, and it's exactly the sort of thing, it's exactly the sort of reason that Apple is, you know,

1:00:26sandboxed iOS from the start and is so, for all the technical problems it causes for honest apps,

1:00:35why they're so bent towards sandboxing on Mac as well.

1:00:41Yeah, yeah. And I hear that. There's a technique I learned that I didn't know about. There's a

1:00:45micro virtualization is coming. It's a step beyond sandboxing.

1:00:48Every app runs essentially in its own tiny virtual machine,

1:00:52which sounds crazy, but bromium,

1:00:54a B R O M I E M is one of the companies in the space. I think, uh, was it, uh,

1:00:59F secure may has a product. Um,

1:01:01it's the new thing because a lot of business users are basically only running a

1:01:05handful of apps.

1:01:06So running them in the virtual environments are transparent to you as a user,

1:01:09but essentially it's like super sandboxing. Right. It's wild.

1:01:15Did you see the story I linked to it?

1:01:17I guess I'll put it in the show notes.

1:01:19I linked to it earlier this week, or maybe last week,

1:01:21where there was a variant of ransomware that doesn't actually--

1:01:29after you pay them, it doesn't give you your file.

1:01:32So for anybody who doesn't know, the way ransomware works,

1:01:35your machine gets hit by ransomware.

1:01:37The ransomware malware starts running,

1:01:39and it starts encrypting your files.

1:01:41And then all of a sudden, you notice it

1:01:43when you go to open one of your documents and it gives you a dialogue and it says you've been,

1:01:49you know, you've been hit by ransomware, all of your files are encrypted and they really are

1:01:54encrypted. And so like if you like go try to open it and you know a text editor or something,

1:01:59it's just going to be, you know, garbled binary stuff because it's encrypted. Right. And the key

1:02:04is sent via command and control system. That's the one. It does need a little network access. So

1:02:07the key is not stored on the device. So you can't just extract the keys. Yeah.

1:02:11So there's some clever use of encryption there.

1:02:15And then if you give them money by following steps X, Y, and Z,

1:02:19who knows, maybe they want Bitcoin.

1:02:21You have to go buy Bitcoin and then give them the Bitcoin,

1:02:23or they just want your credit card number or whatever.

1:02:27Somehow you've got to get the money.

1:02:28And then you give them money, and then they really do decrypt.

1:02:31They give you the key and you get your files back.

1:02:34And there have been cases, high profile cases.

1:02:36I remember there was a hospital, I think in Los Angeles,

1:02:39a hospital that got hit by a ransomware.

1:02:40they spent 17 000 i think yeah unencrypted they had to but you know that you know and and there's

1:02:47sort of a uh you know it's it's like an old almost like a political thing that you know like the

1:02:52united states government doesn't negotiate with terrorists and if that's your poll if you just

1:02:56state that as your policy up front we don't negotiate with with terrorists it hopefully acts

1:03:01as a deterrent to terrorists who would you know uh take people take us you know take people hostage

1:03:08because now it's not really true that we don't negotiate with them, but it's the policy. And you

1:03:12can see the logic of that. And you can see the logic of, "Well, you should never pay these people

1:03:16for this." But at a certain point, it might have been worth it for if it was critical enough

1:03:20information, it might be worth it for you to pay whatever the price that the price they're asking,

1:03:25however distasteful it is to actually give in and give these literal criminals money, it might be

1:03:31more valuable to you than the actual data that's been encrypted is more valuable.

1:03:37Now, the funny thing is that there's a group,

1:03:42there's a group that you give them the money

1:03:46and I'm laughing, but it's terrible

1:03:48because it's even worse, obviously.

1:03:50But the thing that makes me laugh about it

1:03:54is that all of the honest ransomware,

1:03:58and it's so funny to say that, the honest crooks,

1:04:02have gotta be furious about this

1:04:04because if word spreads that even if you pay,

1:04:07don't get your files back, it's going to make people less likely to pay.

1:04:09I have so many things to say about this.

1:04:11Can I say a few things?

1:04:12I have so many, I spent several days working on this recently.

1:04:15So, okay.

1:04:16So you know how ship ransoming works like piracy, Somali pirates, right?

1:04:20Money, Planet Money did a great piece about this that talked to one of the

1:04:23people who does negotiation with pirates to pay their ransom, right?

1:04:28If you start killing the hostages, piracy stops working.

1:04:32So it's actually typically not dangerous to be taken captive by pirates, Somalian or whomever,

1:04:40because it is entirely in the interest of the economic system to negotiate a reasonable fee,

1:04:46make sure all the hostages are unharmed. They will even sometimes release people for medical

1:04:49or compassionate reasons. Like it's handled like a business. Then you have the situation where,

1:04:54I can't remember how long ago this was now, a couple years, where some pirates started killing

1:04:57people. And then it was like, okay, and all the navies in the world went, screw this. And they

1:05:01They start steaming Navy ships in and sort of clean up the problem, which has been a

1:05:05commercial problem and is now, you know, a human rights one, right?

1:05:09And I'm thinking the idiots who think it's funny to delete the files or they're too incompetent,

1:05:15whatever it is, they have so many, I mean, there are so many angry organized criminals

1:05:19in the world.

1:05:20They're, these guys could get killed, honestly, if they're tracked down.

1:05:23That's for sure.

1:05:24So that's not funny, but it's also like, it actually does exactly that.

1:05:27almost like a disruptive technique that would,

1:05:29that destroys the value of ransomware.

1:05:31So in researching this story, I came across

1:05:35just a few days ago, F-Secure released this

1:05:37hilarious white paper.

1:05:38They tested the customer service of major

1:05:41ransomware packages.

1:05:42They're like, it has a customer service burden.

1:05:46I talked to this guy named Sean Sullivan at

1:05:48F-Secure labs about some background stuff

1:05:50about ransomware.

1:05:51And he said, the reason it's gotten so popular

1:05:53is it's Tor, you know, the routing network that

1:05:56That's how the ransomware people post websites,

1:05:59basically, and Bitcoin is all Bitcoin.

1:06:01There's no credit card anymore.

1:06:02That's the big change.

1:06:03The ransomware dates back literally decades,

1:06:05but this is the Bitcoin just makes it, it

1:06:08facilitates it so much.

1:06:09The average ransomware demand now has gone up

1:06:13from a few hundred dollars worth of Bitcoin to

1:06:14like 600 something dollars, but F-Secure

1:06:17found you could negotiate with some of them.

1:06:18They'll, you'll, they'll run the fee down.

1:06:20They created like a naive user who then she,

1:06:23they hired somebody who was not technically

1:06:24They hired somebody who was not technical to do the communication so they wouldn't give anything

1:06:28away about, you know, what they ate about more sophisticated details. And they tested all these,

1:06:33you can extend the deadlines, customer service people, the ransomware companies are very

1:06:36sensitive. In one case, they're like, this was as good as like real customer service. It's like

1:06:40what you'd get from a software company. They talked you through it. They'll often teach you

1:06:44how to buy Bitcoin so that you can pay. They treat it like a real customer service burden,

1:06:48like it's a business and we're here to help you get your files back. So

1:06:51- Yeah, well, if you think about it,

1:06:53when do you typically get the best customer service?

1:06:57Typically, you get better customer service

1:07:00before you've given them your money.

1:07:02- Yeah, yeah. - Right?

1:07:03You get, you know, it's easier and you wait less time

1:07:08to talk to a salesperson before you've bought something

1:07:10than when you come back with a problem.

1:07:13- Yeah, it's just, the whole thing is hilarious.

1:07:15I mean, it's hilarious and awful.

1:07:16So Mac users, you know,

1:07:17there's been a couple ransomware attempt,

1:07:18software attempts against Mac users.

1:07:20And again, because the user space file issue,

1:07:24it's possible we will see,

1:07:25phishing style ransomware

1:07:28or things that will be minimally capable

1:07:30because OS X will execute certain kinds of things.

1:07:34The question is your network access

1:07:36and some privilege it may need would be harder.

1:07:38There might need to be an exploit pathway

1:07:39for a little bit of it,

1:07:40but it is so much less of a burden

1:07:42to get to have some effect.

1:07:45So we'll see.

1:07:46So hopefully it won't affect most of us,

1:07:48but it is, and again,

1:07:50everything they're saying, it's like,

1:07:51update your software, use patches, make backups,

1:07:53having good backups.

1:07:55You know, I use Backblaze and CrashPlan and local clones.

1:07:59And I have a deep archive.

1:08:01So if all my files were encrypted today,

1:08:04I have 100% of those on,

1:08:06most of them on Dropbox also,

1:08:08and in two other, like at least one other place,

1:08:10I should say, where I have a deep archive

1:08:12and I could go back to a pre-encrypted release.

1:08:14- Let me take a break here.

1:08:16Thank our next sponsor.

1:08:18This is a long time friend of the show,

1:08:20long time sponsor, Fracture.

1:08:23Fracture is a photo decor company

1:08:25that is out to rescue your favorite images

1:08:27from the digital ether.

1:08:29They print your photos directly onto glass

1:08:32and add a laser cut rigid backing

1:08:35so they are ready to display right out of the box.

1:08:38It's not like a piece of paper glued to a piece of glass.

1:08:41They print the photo right on the glass.

1:08:44They've been a sponsor for years.

1:08:45I still haven't seen anybody else that does this.

1:08:47Maybe it's somebody else.

1:08:48I think the Fracture's got all this

1:08:49proprietary stuff down there.

1:08:50It is an amazing display.

1:08:53I've always said it is very much like

1:08:55the way that the retina displays.

1:08:58Once Apple started fusing the screens to the glass

1:09:01where it looks like the pixels are on the glass

1:09:02instead of behind a layer of glass,

1:09:04that's what Fracture photos look like

1:09:06except they're completely analog.

1:09:08It is a great thing to do with your digital photos.

1:09:11I have thousands, I shoot thousands of photos every year.

1:09:14The ones that I like best I get get them printed on these fractures hang them up around the house

1:09:18That's what people used to do because your photos were printed you'd go you'd shoot photos

1:09:23You'd get them back from the photo lab

1:09:25You'd take the ones you like out, you know

1:09:27The real keepers you'd instead of just putting them back in the envelope you'd put them in a frame hang them up

1:09:32We don't do that anymore

1:09:34Because there's like this extra step where you got to get them from your digital archive to being on

1:09:38This is the way to do it. If you're gonna print your photos take the keepers and send them to fracture

1:09:42They're so good. They have so many sizes, amazing sizes. They have a 60-day happiness guarantee

1:09:50so that you're sure to love your order. Each fracture is handmade in Gainesville, Florida,

1:09:55from U.S.-sourced materials in their carbon-neutral factory. All happens in the U.S.

1:10:01So for more information and 10% off your first order, visit fractureme.com/podcast.

1:10:10There's even a special note in here that says, "Note, the URL really ends in 'podcast,' not the name of your podcast."

1:10:18Because I'll tell you, if they did put that note in here, I would have said,

1:10:21"FractureMe.com/TheTalkShow," but that's not it. Remember this. It's "FractureMe.com/Podcast."

1:10:27And then what they want you to do when you place your order, they're going to say, "Where did you

1:10:31hear about this?" Just mention that you heard it from the talk show, and they'll know that you came from here.

1:10:35It's literally, it is a one question survey.

1:10:40Where did you hear about Fracture?

1:10:42So it is the easiest survey you will ever take.

1:10:44Just remember to tell them.

1:10:45That helps support the show and it's fractureme.com/podcast.

1:10:50- Can I talk about-- - You can do whatever you want.

1:10:56- Well, a brief another, this is like, this isn't a sidebar.

1:10:59You were writing recently about Amazon

1:11:01and its inventory of the Birkenstock story.

1:11:03- That's on my list of topics.

1:11:05Oh, good. Well, I have something to say about that,

1:11:06but we can go take your direction.

1:11:08- I think we were done with security,

1:11:10so we can totally go on to Amazon fraud.

1:11:12I've linked just to a couple of recent stories about-

1:11:15- Oh my God, it's so terrible.

1:11:17- So there's a couple of aspects to it.

1:11:19One is the main one that I've been reading,

1:11:23'cause it seems like it's a little bit new,

1:11:25is big brands being ripped off

1:11:30by mostly Chinese counterfeiters,

1:11:33and then they sell these things through Amazon.

1:11:36Well, the first one I heard,

1:11:38this is maybe two years ago,

1:11:39is that Mophie products, Mophie the battery maker,

1:11:43they make a whole bunch of battery,

1:11:46external battery packs and battery cases for phones.

1:11:49Really interesting company.

1:11:52I have a couple of their things

1:11:53and I really, I have to say I like them a lot.

1:11:57I have a battery, I like them instead of a case,

1:12:00I like to just have the battery pack

1:12:02and they make one that has built-in lightning and USB cables,

1:12:06so you don't need to take cables.

1:12:08You don't need to have an extra cable.

1:12:09I really like that product a lot.

1:12:11It's my favorite external battery thing ever.

1:12:13But I heard years ago, just like at least two years ago,

1:12:16don't buy Mophie stuff on Amazon

1:12:18because there's so much Chinese knockoff crap

1:12:21that looks like a Mophie product,

1:12:23but it's really substandard electronics.

1:12:25The batteries are no good.

1:12:26They're just crummy products.

1:12:29If you Google like Mophie Amazon,

1:12:31you'll find lots of hits about it.

1:12:32So now just recently this week,

1:12:34Birkenstock, the sandals, what else do they make?

1:12:37Just sandals and flip-flops, I guess.

1:12:39- Yeah, a bunch of stuff.

1:12:39I was called, by the way,

1:12:40I was called socks and sandals in college

1:12:42'cause of my Birkenstock habits, just so you know.

1:12:45I went to school in the East, grew up in the West,

1:12:47that's how it goes. (laughs)

1:12:50- Is pulling out of Amazon on January,

1:12:52I guess they can't do it immediately

1:12:53'cause they might have contracts or inventory or something,

1:12:56but they're so overrun by counterfeiters on Amazon

1:12:59that they're pulling out.

1:13:00- Oh yeah, and you love them.

1:13:01They're like, Amazon basically told them,

1:13:03if you wanna be, sell every single thing you sell,

1:13:06then we will fight counterfeiting.

1:13:07I mean, I'm paraphrasing.

1:13:09And if you wanna just sell the way you're doing,

1:13:10then screw you.

1:13:11I mean, they didn't say it that way, but that's the effect.

1:13:13That's, you know, that's what Birkenstock claims at least.

1:13:15- I think I could be wrong on this.

1:13:18I wrote that, it's sort of like when you search for stuff

1:13:22on Amazon, it tells you who you're buying it from.

1:13:25And you know, with a lot of the smaller things,

1:13:28like when you just go there and buy copy paper,

1:13:33printer paper, you know, it's like full,

1:13:35you know, it's just, you're not really buying it

1:13:37from Amazon, you're buying it from some vendor

1:13:39that sells through Amazon.

1:13:41But I was under the impression that even if you wanted

1:13:44to buy like a Mophie battery pack,

1:13:46if you buy it directly from Amazon and you're not buying it

1:13:49from, you know, Joe's battery shop,

1:13:52that you're, you know, you could be, you know,

1:13:55you could feel safe that you're getting

1:13:57the actual Mophie product, but you kind of have to be--

1:14:00- Oh my God.

1:14:01- You have to be like a close reader.

1:14:03How many people who shop at Amazon actually look at

1:14:05who it's, who's this fulfillment is?

1:14:09I don't think most people, most reasonable,

1:14:11most regular people even know that that's how Amazon works.

1:14:14I think they just think you're buying it from Amazon

1:14:17and they don't even look, they just look at prices

1:14:19and they might be curious about the fact

1:14:21that the same product is available

1:14:23at three different prices from Amazon

1:14:25because it's from three different, you know,

1:14:29whatever you wanna call them, fulfillment partners.

1:14:32- Yeah, or maybe through Marketplace

1:14:36or maybe through their, they've,

1:14:36Fulfillment by Amazon also,

1:14:38you can send your stuff to Amazon

1:14:40and they will sell it to their own customers.

1:14:43- Right.

1:14:44- So, you know, I think you mentioned this

1:14:45in one of the pieces that you linked to, the commingling.

1:14:48So there's like two kinds of,

1:14:49there's actually like four kinds of fraud.

1:14:51There are two kinds of major fraud.

1:14:52One is, oh God, there's so many kinds of fraud.

1:14:55So co-mingling is company X ships a product to Amazon and they say, this is exactly the same.

1:15:02Here's the skew number.

1:15:03This is product Y that you already sell like a Cuisinart electric kettle, which I'll explain why I bring that up.

1:15:08Right.

1:15:08Amazon does co-mingling where they take this inventory.

1:15:12I don't even know how many inspected or whatever, and they put it on their shelves as, and they don't care.

1:15:17Uh, they treat it as a fungible thing.

1:15:20This thing that came from company X that claims its product Y we're putting on the shelves in our warehouse.

1:15:25house next to this thing that came from the manufacturer that claims its product Y right

1:15:29I have heard stories from multiple places and you can read them publicly to in a lot of these articles about

1:15:34Companies like Birkenstock and Birkenstock has a different problem which I get to but that you buy a product you go to Amazon you order product

1:15:41Y and it comes and you're like this is not product Y you complain to Amazon and they're like, oh send it back

1:15:46We'll ship you a new one or you complain the company. I bought product Y from Amazon

1:15:50They like we didn't make that does it have this and this? No, that's a counterfeit

1:15:53fit that was put into Amazon stream and we cannot prevent them from

1:15:56selling them basically, that's the commingling problem.

1:15:58Birkenstock has the undercutting problem where people are listing things

1:16:02basically as the same kind of thing.

1:16:04They're undercutting Birkenstocks prices and they may or may not

1:16:07be shipping a Birkenstock.

1:16:08They're probably shipping that thing as it could be there buying

1:16:11them from some other source, or it could be they are manufacturing

1:16:13something that is completely counterfeit and selling it.

1:16:16And, um, when they're both huge problems, because in the one case

1:16:20you have this thing where people are buying, I mean, actually

1:16:21Birkenstock has the same problem, whether it's a commingled problem or counterfeit

1:16:24and cheaper, someone buys it says Birkenstock screwed me.

1:16:28They're ready.

1:16:28The company said we didn't make that.

1:16:29What'd you buy from Amazon?

1:16:30That's not ours.

1:16:31You bought the $80 one, not the a hundred dollar one.

1:16:34We don't sell it for $80.

1:16:35You bought the sucky one.

1:16:36Right.

1:16:37So this just happened to me last night.

1:16:39Really?

1:16:40Yeah.

1:16:40So what was the product?

1:16:42So, uh, uh, electric kettle love electric kettle.

1:16:45I've had two, uh, Brown model ones or Braun, I guess we say in America.

1:16:48Uh, my wife got one for a birthday, like 15 years ago.

1:16:51It worked fine for several years and then it just died.

1:16:54So we bought the identical thing.

1:16:56It's like a $20 one.

1:16:57It's worked great.

1:16:58It just dies of the day.

1:16:59Same thing.

1:16:59Some kind of, you know, it's got all these contacts breaks.

1:17:02So I'm like, okay, I will find out what Wirecutter recommends.

1:17:05My old friends at Wirecutter and Sweet Home was a contractor there for a bit.

1:17:08I love the people there.

1:17:09I love the process.

1:17:10I'm like, all right, well, what one do they recommend?

1:17:11I'm like, oh God, it's $80.

1:17:13Am I going to spend $80 on an electric?

1:17:14I'm like, ah, I don't know.

1:17:15I'm not made of money.

1:17:16Uh, Jason Snell has a Breville T robot.

1:17:20which is $250, which I've been eyeing for a year now.

1:17:25I'm not, I can't get it.

1:17:27Can't get it. - Robot that makes tea?

1:17:29- It has a basket that lowers robotically and raises.

1:17:32So it steeps it for the right amount of time.

1:17:35- I just wanted to clarify that it was tea, the beverage,

1:17:38and not like some kind of, you know, like a t-shirt,

1:17:41like the letter, something I wasn't familiar with.

1:17:44I just wanted to clarify.

1:17:45- It's a tea brewing robot pot.

1:17:47It's awesome.

1:17:48And people love the Breville.

1:17:49but I'm not ready to spend, I'd love to be able,

1:17:51if I ever got some great contract or something,

1:17:53I might say, this is my treat to myself.

1:17:55I will get a robot that makes tea for me.

1:17:58You still have to put stuff in the basket,

1:17:59but it moves it, lose it up and down, doesn't oversteep.

1:18:01So anyway, 80 bucks, I'm like, that seems, I don't know.

1:18:03So I start doing research and I go to Amazon,

1:18:05'cause it's usually my first stop.

1:18:07And there are like 700 electric pedals now.

1:18:10And many of them have one review,

1:18:11which makes no sense, right?

1:18:13Like, what's something with one review and a brand name

1:18:16I've never heard of in my 48 years on this planet.

1:18:19And then a bunch of others, I find one, I'm like, this is like 300 reviews.

1:18:22I've never heard of this thing.

1:18:23And 97% of them are five stars.

1:18:26You know how the app store works, same thing on Amazon.

1:18:29So I'm reading the reviews and it's like, Marty says, this is a great kettle.

1:18:32This kettle does everything I want it to.

1:18:33It's great.

1:18:34Jill says, this kettle is great.

1:18:36It does everything I want it to.

1:18:37This kettle is great.

1:18:38It goes on and on.

1:18:39And there's a few real five star reviews and then a distribution of other ones.

1:18:43I'm like, I'm not going to buy that because that's some piece of crap

1:18:46manufacturer, God knows where that they're, you know, for a finite amount of time,

1:18:50they're going to push through Amazon and make some hundreds of thousands of

1:18:52dollars. So I'm like, where are the 20 or $30 good kettles? I can't find Browns anymore.

1:18:57Everyone's gone upscale kettles now costs 50, 60, $80 just to do basic stuff.

1:19:01So I'm like, all right, I'm going to bite the bullet. I,

1:19:03I use the kettle two, three times a day. My wife uses it two times a day.

1:19:07This is a high use thing. I can, I'm going to, I'm going to spend $80. I'm,

1:19:10I hate it, but I'm going to spend $80. I go to Amazon site and I'm like, all right,

1:19:14Well, it's 80 bucks.

1:19:15Okay.

1:19:15I'm looking through reviews, but this looks pretty good.

1:19:17And then I look at the seller, it's a Cuisinart, but it doesn't say sold by

1:19:21Cuisinart says sold by, uh, everything lucky, not making this up, everything

1:19:29lucky to selling the Cuisinart.

1:19:31And I thinking this, this isn't right.

1:19:33So I search an Amazon site for the model number.

1:19:35It's like CPK 12, 112 or something.

1:19:38And I'm like, all right, so where is this?

1:19:41And then I find another listing for a hundred dollars with, okay.

1:19:44So the $80 unit, everyday lucky, which I find

1:19:47out later, so he points out to me, it says

1:19:48ever day lucky, it's not even spelled right.

1:19:51Whatever the make, you know, they're mostly

1:19:52said an everyday lucky is mostly selling iPhone

1:19:55cases and this Cuisinart alleged Cuisinart.

1:19:57So the $80 everyday lucky listing has 2,500

1:20:03clearly legitimate reviews.

1:20:04They have managed somehow to

1:20:06hijack the main listing.

1:20:08There's a hundred dollar version.

1:20:10And if you look at all the other people selling

1:20:12Walmart, Best Buy, they're all selling this model for a hundred dollars.

1:20:15So I'm like, that's the list price clearly.

1:20:17And the hundred dollar one on Amazon says, buy sold by, you know, buy Cuisinart.

1:20:21It's being fulfilled by a third party, but it's clearly the legitimate product,

1:20:24but it has like seven reviews.

1:20:25So I asked my friends at Sweet Home, like what's going on here?

1:20:28They're like, Oh, what happened is I got a response this morning

1:20:31from Tony over there.

1:20:31Who's great.

1:20:32You know, they have all these deals, people and everything.

1:20:33It says, what happened is, um, the, uh, Amazon ran out of a

1:20:39stock that it sells directly.

1:20:40And so they pulled a listing for someone selling it new, not, you know, used or new refurbished, whatever, and they drop that in so they don't drop the listing off.

1:20:50And so in this case, Everday Lucky was the backup provider in their listing of third-party sellers for this particular model.

1:20:57It's, it's, I'm looking at it as we speak, it's Everthing Lucky.

1:21:01Oh, Everthing Lucky, sorry.

1:21:03Everthing Lucky.

1:21:04I know, isn't that, and so that, that is my story.

1:21:06So, I'm like,

1:21:07It's still there!

1:21:08Yeah, so well, no, so I wake up this morning and Tony has responded at

1:21:11Sweet Home via Twitter because great God, he's like, oh, here's, what's going on.

1:21:13Check it's back.

1:21:14And I go, I'm like, oh, there's the Amazon listing at $67.

1:21:17Now.

1:21:17Now I feel justified.

1:21:19I've waited, right?

1:21:19Do you think that this is the real product though?

1:21:21Well, well, so here's, so, uh, it may be, but there's no way to know.

1:21:26Like I'm buying it from a third party seller who has clearly done some magic.

1:21:30So this morning I placed an order, I paid $67.

1:21:33Everyone can criticize me for my profligate spending.

1:21:36And, uh, if you like, please feel free anyway.

1:21:39So I buy it and I write back to Tony.

1:21:42I'm like, Hey, the thing you're right.

1:21:43Swapped back.

1:21:43And he's like, I just went back and it's there.

1:21:45Apparently I bought the one model Amazon had in a warehouse that it fulfilled

1:21:49itself and it's back to everything lucky.

1:21:50So anyway, that's the problem they have.

1:21:52So I don't know.

1:21:53So everything lucky could be selling me a legitimate object and still $20 less than

1:21:58the retail price at target, Walmart, et cetera.

1:22:00However, um, they're getting the advantage of 2,500 positive reviews

1:22:05And Amazon doesn't vet that that product is actually a new from Cuisinart item.

1:22:10Yeah. So part of the, part of the problem, the way that, I mean,

1:22:15this is so insidious, but part of this problem now is if, if it starts to,

1:22:19if awareness starts to spread that you can't trust stuff through third party

1:22:24resellers on Amazon,

1:22:25it hurts all of the honest ones that the system was set up for in the first

1:22:29place.

1:22:29Exactly. It's terrible all around. There's also like even yet another variant on

1:22:34is that, um, so those are like the almost legitimate cases, right?

1:22:38Like this could absolutely be a fell off the truck or, you know, bought like, you

1:22:43know, one of the things in China is that, and I've heard this, I hope, I don't mean

1:22:46to tell lies about China.

1:22:47So let's say this isn't, I don't know if this is true, but I've read it in

1:22:50other number of accounts.

1:22:51I've talked to people that admit stuff made in China.

1:22:53It's a complaint made by a number of companies about things with China is

1:22:57come.

1:22:58Some factories will gear up products for a given maker.

1:23:01And during the day they're being supervised or being made for Maker, you know, whatever company is, you know Reebok or whatever. It could be shoes, it could be

1:23:08Cuisinart kettles. At night they fire up the lines, they make stuff and they sell that themselves. And they're essentially identical.

1:23:15Sometimes there's labeling changes. So they're the identical unit with it not labeled so they avoid some intellectual property issues.

1:23:20So the Birkenstock thing, when you're go to try to buy a Birkenstock thing and their list price is $100 for whatever and

1:23:27and there's people selling it for $80, you might be getting the legitimate thing.

1:23:30It might be made as a factory nighttime job or who knows what, or they're just

1:23:34doing deeper discounts because however they're acquiring it, they're not

1:23:37honoring the list price.

1:23:38The same thing that a Cuisinart kettle bought from everything lucky could have

1:23:43been absolutely the same as anything purchased directly from an Amazon

1:23:46warehouse or from a third party, you know, uh, authorized Cuisinart thing.

1:23:51But you don't know the, the other problem though, like the other thing is that,

1:23:54Uh, what you were saying before is it's the, um, the counterfeit stuff.

1:23:58That's just knockoffs that are crap and they appear to be listed the same.

1:24:02So it's, I see this all the time for, you know, all these different products.

1:24:05I'm looking for, for reviews and things.

1:24:07You find stuff that is clearly the pictures are something off.

1:24:11You buy it, something's not right.

1:24:13And you're not, you know, sometimes it's listed under a slightly different name.

1:24:16Sometimes it's listed as exactly the same thing and it's trying

1:24:18to take advantage of the reputation.

1:24:19But all of these problems persist because Amazon wants to sell more.

1:24:24it doesn't want to do tighter inventory control

1:24:26'cause it costs a lot of money.

1:24:27It shaves the margins off.

1:24:28- So I just sent you a link.

1:24:29This is the 1.8 quart cordless electric tea cuddle.

1:24:33I think this is the product you're talking about.

1:24:36- Yes, that's right.

1:24:37- I kind of hate the interface to tell you.

1:24:39- I know, it's the best, cheapest thing.

1:24:42Like if you want something better,

1:24:44you have to spend more.

1:24:45I know it looks horrible.

1:24:46The queries are like, "CPK 17 sold by Everything Lucky."

1:24:51- Now, if you look, I think it's the same product.

1:24:53there's a thing that says size seven cup.

1:24:56And the two sizes that are offered is seven cup,

1:25:00which is $100.

1:25:02And then the other one, instead of measuring in cups,

1:25:04it just gives you the dimensions of the box,

1:25:069.7 inches by six inches by eight.

1:25:10And so it- - Oh, they may have managed

1:25:12to sneak, oh, interesting.

1:25:14- They've made it look like there's two options

1:25:16of the same product, but one is measuring by the cup

1:25:20capacity of how much water you can put in,

1:25:22and the other one is measured in inches.

1:25:24- Yeah, and the one-point-eight-quart one,

1:25:25the seven-cup one, is sold by Card Machine Outlet, Inc.

1:25:29- Oh, the one, you know, mine says,

1:25:31oh, it says, mine says it's by Cuisinart.

1:25:34- Yeah, you scroll down under in stock,

1:25:36it says, "Sips and Sold By." - Oh, I see.

1:25:39- I know, isn't it, but so--

1:25:40- No, mine is sold by Kitchen Capers.

1:25:42- Oh my God, what happens when I reload?

1:25:43That's hilarious.

1:25:44- Mine is from Kitchen Capers.

1:25:46- Every time I reload,

1:25:47I'm getting a different answer, I think.

1:25:48- Oh.

1:25:49So this one is $100 and Prime is available,

1:25:53but that $80 one, to me, is suspicious.

1:25:56The $80 one, and I guess Amazon defaults to it

1:25:58'cause it's cheapest.

1:26:00- Yeah, that's exactly it.

1:26:01- The fact that that's the one by everything lucky,

1:26:03the fact that it's cheaper makes me think

1:26:05that it might be fake.

1:26:06I would actually, if I were gonna buy this right now,

1:26:08I would actually spend the extra $20

1:26:10to get the one that says it's by Cuisinart.

1:26:13- Yeah, except here's the funny thing.

1:26:14So when I logged in this morning,

1:26:15Amazon apparently had gotten one on their shelves

1:26:17that they fulfilled directly,

1:26:18so it's supposed to be sold by Amazon, 67 bucks.

1:26:21So I got the deal, I guess I got the one that was $67.

1:26:25I'm very happy about that.

1:26:25I'm gonna be able to boil my tea

1:26:26at all kinds of temperatures.

1:26:27It's gonna be great. - Now there's another,

1:26:28there's another type of fraud going on on Amazon,

1:26:31and this is just comical. - Oh my God, no, come on.

1:26:33- I linked to somebody on Twitter yesterday

1:26:38who bought, wanted to get a floor mat,

1:26:41and they got like a, almost like a mouse pad type mat

1:26:46with printed on the mouse pad like it is it is floor mat size but printed on the

1:26:51piece of foam is a screen print of the sort of texture of the full,

1:26:57I was crying. I was explaining that to my wife this morning cause I was saying,

1:27:02okay, I bought a tea kettle. Here's my story. And she's laughing at it.

1:27:05I told her about the other one, the cup,

1:27:07the changing temperature pattern cup one. Right. So the other one,

1:27:12I guess I'll put a link to my Daring Fireball link piece

1:27:15in the show notes.

1:27:16- That was so funny. - And you guys can look

1:27:17it up there.

1:27:18But somebody bought, there was a listing on Amazon,

1:27:20and it showed a picture, two pictures of the same mug.

1:27:24One was like when it's empty, and it just looks black,

1:27:28and if you fill it with a hot beverage,

1:27:30the color will, it's printed with some kind of

1:27:34temperature-sensitive ink, and it changes and gives you

1:27:37like a snowy Christmas scene.

1:27:39And so somebody bought this on Amazon,

1:27:42And what they got was a mug where somebody had printed that photo of two mugs onto the mug.

1:27:49So it was a mug, a mug with a, with a photo of two mugs on it.

1:27:57It's kind of, I actually think it would be a great, now that, now that has become a meme,

1:28:00that'd be a great gift. I would love to buy a mug with a picture of two mugs on it. I think that sounds great.

1:28:05Uh, and I guess that the idea with that type of scam is that it is so, I mean, I'm guessing

1:28:13that this was not a very expensive mug that if it's only like four bucks or six bucks

1:28:18that people wouldn't even bother to send it back because it's like, what's the, you know,

1:28:23what's the point?

1:28:24You know what I mean?

1:28:25Like you feel like you're ripped off, but at a certain point, it's more of a hassle

1:28:28to send it back than it is the money's worth.

1:28:30Can I tell you my perfect Walmart experience, which is a Walmart pay just came out.

1:28:35nationwide, they rolled it out.

1:28:36And this is, so I've been laughing about currency,

1:28:39which was the, you know, the big retailer system

1:28:41that was supposed to use 2D codes

1:28:43and checking accounts and crap.

1:28:45Been laughing about that for years.

1:28:46Susie Oakes and I on the Macworld podcast,

1:28:48every time a currency story comes out,

1:28:49we make sure to highlight it so we can laugh at it.

1:28:52Because it sort of, if it had come out before Apple Pay

1:28:55and then Android Pay,

1:28:56maybe it would have gotten a little bit of traction,

1:28:58I don't know, but it didn't, right?

1:28:59It was like ridiculous.

1:29:01It's finally been a basically shut down.

1:29:02they're focusing on the MCX consortium,

1:29:05that's a bunch of these big retailers,

1:29:06is now focusing on backend stuff, which is great.

1:29:08So Walmart had been working on its own system,

1:29:11it's a member of the MCX consortium,

1:29:13but it had been working on its own variant.

1:29:14And I saw an announcement about it,

1:29:15I'm like, you know, this doesn't look as awful.

1:29:18They don't accept checking account linkages,

1:29:20so there's less risk of your stuff being hijacked, right?

1:29:23Where your checking account can be drained

1:29:25and it's always a pain to get anything fixed.

1:29:26I just talked to someone the other day,

1:29:28they had $160,000 taken out of their checking account

1:29:31after they sold a house.

1:29:33Took them six months to get it back,

1:29:35even though they had not authorized anything,

1:29:36they weren't even scammed, the bank was scammed.

1:29:38So checking accounts are a pain in the ass.

1:29:41Credit cards, debit cards, we have protections.

1:29:43Even gift cards, state-

1:29:45- That's terrifying.

1:29:46- Yeah.

1:29:46- That's positively terrifying.

1:29:48- There are no protections on accounts.

1:29:49Let's go all, go back to Bitcoin and gold.

1:29:52So state attorney generals have a lot of control

1:29:55over gift cards.

1:29:56There's this, those are state regulated.

1:29:58And so there's control even there.

1:30:00So Walmart pay will let you use,

1:30:01a Walmart gift card, a debit card, credit card,

1:30:03and prepaid card, something like that.

1:30:06And I'm like, well, this is kind of cool.

1:30:07You still have to use a barcode.

1:30:09You're scanning a 2D code, but it all looked sensible.

1:30:13So I pitched to Mac, well, let me go right about this.

1:30:15Is it? Sure.

1:30:16So I find a Walmart, it's about 20 minutes away.

1:30:17I've been to, they opened it actually a store

1:30:20they shut down, which is rare for them.

1:30:22And I go there and first thing in the morning,

1:30:23the place is totally empty.

1:30:25No one's even trailing me around to make sure I don't steal.

1:30:27There's no greeter, nobody checked my receipt when I left.

1:30:29The place is empty.

1:30:30We need to buy a cheap clock with a face for our dining room

1:30:34so that my younger son does not spend an hour and a half

1:30:37eating at the table, the same piece of toast.

1:30:39So he can get through things in the day.

1:30:41So some children dawdle, some eat fast.

1:30:44Anyway, so I find a clock, it costs $6.50.

1:30:46I'm like, this is great, it's battery operated,

1:30:48it looks cool, I like the face, whatever.

1:30:49Do the checkout process.

1:30:50I actually quite like it.

1:30:51I'd already set up Walmart Pay.

1:30:53The app is actually very well designed.

1:30:56Point of sale system displays a code.

1:30:58You just open your app, you tap it and you're done.

1:31:00and it's electronic, I'm like, this is great.

1:31:02I get home, I unpack it, the clock doesn't work.

1:31:04(laughing)

1:31:06So that's the Walmart story.

1:31:09- I have noticed that it seems like,

1:31:11I don't know if this was predicted or not,

1:31:15I actually wanted to talk about Apple Pay.

1:31:18- Oh yeah.

1:31:18- It seems to me, and Apple is an interesting,

1:31:22Apple's usually late to most things,

1:31:24but every once in a while, they're early on things.

1:31:27Like for example, Wi-Fi.

1:31:29Apple, you know, like when Apple introduced the iBook

1:31:33that had Wi-Fi, they actually had to explain what Wi-Fi was.

1:31:36And that was the event where Phil Schiller did like a stunt,

1:31:40like he like jumped off, climbed up a ladder

1:31:43and jumped 10 feet onto a padded mat

1:31:47while holding the iBook to prove that it was, you know,

1:31:50getting the internet over the air.

1:31:51Like they actually, it was almost like, you know,

1:31:55the idea that you're getting internet over the air

1:31:56was such a novelty that they actually felt like

1:31:59to prove it. And it seems to me like Apple Pay is another one of those things where Apple Pay came

1:32:03out at the right time, like, because it's just maybe it's a local thing here in Philly, but maybe

1:32:09it's something else, but a whole bunch of chains around here have suddenly started getting the chip

1:32:13and pin registers. And they, they all seem to work with Apple Pay, even though they don't have Apple

1:32:19Pay logos yet. Like, so we have a supermarket chain here called Acme. They don't have, there's

1:32:24There's no Apple Pay logo, but it just says tap or pay or something.

1:32:29I forget what they all say,

1:32:31but there's like a little logo that suggests that maybe there's some kind of NFC

1:32:35thing. And so I've, I tried Apple Pay and it just works.

1:32:38And Starbucks are local, at least the,

1:32:42the one I go to now has chip and pin, but a lot of these ones too,

1:32:46they get the chip and pin. Um,

1:32:48and then they have a piece of tape there and it says chip chip doesn't work yet.

1:32:54- Yep.

1:32:55- But at Starbucks, Apple Pay worked and I paid.

1:32:58- Oh.

1:32:59- I paid with Apple Pay at Starbucks.

1:33:01And-- - I think that's new, right?

1:33:03- It is totally new.

1:33:04I mean like--

1:33:05- You may have an early rollout.

1:33:06- It's like maybe like within the last 10 days,

1:33:08at least here.

1:33:09And that the none of, you know,

1:33:12and it's funny because it like Whole Foods, where I go,

1:33:15they've had Apple Pay for a while.

1:33:16They were like a debut partner

1:33:18and like listed on the slide on the stage.

1:33:22And I've been using it at Whole Foods for years,

1:33:26ever since it came out.

1:33:27So it's not a novelty there, but at Starbucks,

1:33:29I've gotten like two or three of the clerks

1:33:31have been like, whoa, what did you just do there?

1:33:33That was amazing.

1:33:34But then I went today and it didn't work.

1:33:38It worked in so far as when I got my iPhone

1:33:41near the terminal, my credit card came up on the screen

1:33:45and it read my fingerprint and went, "ching,"

1:33:50and said done, and then the little hand terminal

1:33:54said processing, but then the processing never went through

1:33:58and I forget what it said.

1:33:59It just like, processing was up way too long,

1:34:01'cause Apple Pay is very fast usually.

1:34:04It was processing way too long and then it said like,

1:34:07payment could not be completed.

1:34:09And so I had to pay with an actual credit card

1:34:12like a 20th century person.

1:34:14- I think my recollection is that NFC is typically like,

1:34:18It's a protocol.

1:34:18The payment is a over FCS protocol.

1:34:21So even if it isn't supposed to take Apple pay, if NFC is enabled at all, it will try to do it, but the back end part may not work.

1:34:29Cause I think that was the deal.

1:34:31Was that, um, Oh, I forget CVS or something.

1:34:33One of the MCX partners.

1:34:34Yes.

1:34:35Yeah.

1:34:35At launch, it was like people were paying with Apple pay and they're like, oh, it's not supposed to work.

1:34:38It's like, they literally, they literally did stay nationwide.

1:34:43CVS disconnected their entire, the ability to pay with any NFC at all, just so that it

1:34:50wouldn't use Apple pay, even though they were actually getting the money from Apple pay.

1:34:54It wasn't like they were getting ripped off. It was, they didn't want to put, well, they

1:34:57all had a deal and it was, I just, I just got emailed from a company. I don't want to

1:35:01mention its name yet because I haven't tested it, but I'm so full of secrets. I'm so full.

1:35:05No, it's not that they're secret. I don't want to promote them until I see what they

1:35:08actually do. Uh, they're in beta testing it like public beta. You have to sign up. Our

1:35:12So that's how credible they are.

1:35:13Okay.

1:35:13They're great.

1:35:14Um, and it's a very funny video, of course.

1:35:16Uh, so, and very informative.

1:35:18So this, uh, do you remember several years ago, there were some credit cards, uh, that

1:35:23would let you create an individual card number for every transaction?

1:35:27Yes.

1:35:27Yes.

1:35:27I love that.

1:35:28I use that and you could set things like this can charge no more than a hundred

1:35:32dollars a month.

1:35:33This is a one-time use and should only work until such like all these things.

1:35:35And the interface was terrible.

1:35:37It was premobile.

1:35:37It was awesome.

1:35:38It was awesome.

1:35:39And the interface was terrible.

1:35:40It's pre-mobile.

1:35:40It was awful.

1:35:41And online payment was terrible anyway.

1:35:43So this is an outfit that is doing the same thing with an app.

1:35:46You sign up, you get a credit card through their partner, which I forget which bank it

1:35:50is, a major bank and a 18% credit, you know, interest, APR.

1:35:55So it's, you know, it's the kind of card you better pay off because it's not reasonable

1:35:58otherwise and 1% cash back.

1:36:00So it's, they got all these parameters on it, but the fact is like for online

1:36:03transactions, like you're, they have a physical card you can use.

1:36:06You can use that's got an EMF or MV chip in it.

1:36:10Um, so you could use that, but when you're paying online, uh, you know,

1:36:14any kind of transaction you run the app, it generates a unique number with

1:36:17whatever parameters you want, like one time or whatever, and you use that

1:36:20one time number and so it gets stolen.

1:36:22You know, who stole it.

1:36:23So I'm going to try.

1:36:24They gave me an invitation.

1:36:25I signed up.

1:36:26I'm going to test my credit rating, but, um, I had three card

1:36:29numbers stolen this year so far.

1:36:30It's amazing.

1:36:32It's been so long for me.

1:36:33And numbers.

1:36:33I had a visa and then an Amex and then another visa, three different

1:36:36car issuers and in every case, I got to tell you the fraud people have got, I

1:36:41mean, they used to be good.

1:36:42I dealt with this in the past a bit, but every call was with someone who is so

1:36:45crackerjack and like, they're obviously paying people well, they're training them

1:36:48well.

1:36:49These people were amusing and fun.

1:36:50Nobody's like fun to talk to while we're going through all the crap you have to go

1:36:54through.

1:36:54And they took care of it in every case they caught it in one case, like a 38 cent

1:36:59transaction to a charity went through and, but everything else didn't.

1:37:02So the pilot,

1:37:03yeah, yeah.

1:37:05That's what the, that's what they do.

1:37:06I forget it wasn't me. It was my wife. I think it was Amy gas station charge or an online charge

1:37:12Uh, like in a bodega somebody bought like coke they see if it's been canceled. Yeah, so they got it

1:37:18they they bought a coke and

1:37:20Then they went to buy like, you know, I don't know TV. Yeah

1:37:24So in each of these three cases their fraud

1:37:26pattern got it and they're like in two cases nothing in one case 38 cents, which was refunded and

1:37:31Poor charity that got 38 cents. They didn't know they were gonna get and then it's taken back

1:37:35But so I'm very interested and you know you think so I am so excited for Apple pay and Safari not because I am

1:37:41So excited about Apple pay

1:37:43But I'm like Apple pay and safaris can be the beginning of a transition because Android pay in

1:37:48whatever browsers is coming like they're gonna be all these mobile pay options will now be available through desktop and

1:37:54mobile web transactions

1:37:57The minute any of my cards is enabled. I'm like never gonna buy anything from a site that doesn't do Apple pay in Safari again

1:38:04I'm dreading my Amex getting ripped off again.

1:38:08It was a couple years ago and somebody, some nitwit tried to buy jet skis in Arizona or New Mexico.

1:38:16Either Arizona or New Mexico.

1:38:17That's very funny.

1:38:18But you know, the guy from Amex called me and said, you know,

1:38:23"You're not trying to buy jet skis in Arizona, are you?"

1:38:26And I was like, "No, definitely not."

1:38:27And he goes, "All right, well somebody is sorry."

1:38:29You know, and like you said, totally on the ball.

1:38:32Just don't worry about it, but your card is now canceled.

1:38:35I'm FedExing you a replacement.

1:38:37It should be there tomorrow.

1:38:39Really sorry, you know, you know, but you know, and you know, and take a look,

1:38:44take a look at your next, you know, statement.

1:38:47And I guess he read some of my recent transactions that were me.

1:38:51And I was like, yeah, those are all good.

1:38:54But I'm dreading my the one I've had now for a couple of years getting ripped off

1:38:58because it's my new couple of my new card came my last three digits are double

1:39:03o seven oh my god yeah I love this card custom card numbers why don't they sell

1:39:07them I think if you're a very high like you're a whale of a card user or an

1:39:12investment I think you can get a number you want get some lucky numbers on there

1:39:15double I can you believe it I got double so oh my god that's so it's so good and

1:39:19I always read it when I have to read it over the phone I always say it that way

1:39:21like you know whatever the whatever whatever whatever whatever whatever and

1:39:25and then double it.

1:39:26(laughs)

1:39:28- Yeah, I think, I mean, the pain of the thing,

1:39:32the fact that we're still using unsecured numbers

1:39:34to do this is sort of hilarious.

1:39:35Like I've wondered, why can't the credit card companies

1:39:37be set up to do two factor authentication?

1:39:40Like I'd be delighted if I went to Amazon,

1:39:42I punched in my cart, or not Amazon,

1:39:43'cause they have their own whatever.

1:39:45But I go to a random site X,

1:39:46and before the transaction goes through,

1:39:48it texts me a code and I have to enter it.

1:39:50Like I know the backend systems are ancient and weird

1:39:53and whatever, but you'd think after this many years,

1:39:55they could just tack that on and you'd enable it

1:39:58in your card and if you went to a site

1:39:59that couldn't do it, they'd say,

1:40:01you have to try this transaction again

1:40:02after clicking a link that's being sent to you,

1:40:04email or some kind of bypass,

1:40:05but apparently the frictionless nature of e-commerce

1:40:09has to be emphasized over the amount of fraud.

1:40:11Fraud at some point becomes so high

1:40:14that they have to then invent new ways

1:40:15to prevent against it, but there's some balance there.

1:40:18- So what do we think?

1:40:21circle back to Amazon.

1:40:24I think Amazon's gotta clean this mess up.

1:40:26I think Amazon needs to,

1:40:29I know that they're operating at a massive scale

1:40:33and there's sort of an app store-like problem there

1:40:37where if you've got all of these hundreds of thousands

1:40:39of products from all these partners

1:40:40that maybe they can't ever achieve perfection.

1:40:44But at this point, it seems like nobody's even

1:40:46watching the door, you know what I mean?

1:40:50- Yeah, well, they could say there's like,

1:40:51they could say there's a thousand major brands or 10,000 major brands,

1:40:54or they could even partner with major brands who want to do this and say,

1:40:57if you're company,

1:40:58if you're some no name supplier who ships us a Cuisinart electric kettle,

1:41:02we're not going to list it as if we're not going to commingle the inventory

1:41:05because you're nobody, right? Or you have to prove your relationship,

1:41:07or you have to do some Providence, or you have to prove yourself over time.

1:41:10They give you a, you know, they give you some kind of, um, uh,

1:41:13long payments to sort of do something to vet you before you're allowed to ship

1:41:17product that would be commingled. They don't, as far as I can tell,

1:41:20They do a little bit of something.

1:41:22I know there's issues with how they hold payment

1:41:23and so forth, but I don't think they have

1:41:25any real processes in place because it hasn't hit them yet.

1:41:29But if you have companies like Birkenstock

1:41:31saying we're more willing to back out

1:41:35of these relationships, like Birkenstock,

1:41:38I don't know how many tens of millions of products

1:41:40they sell online, dollars of products they sell online,

1:41:42but it's gotta be something.

1:41:43So them saying basically, they're gonna tell,

1:41:45I mean, this was a leaked memo, so we don't know,

1:41:47this is internal stuff,

1:41:48it wasn't a Birkenstock announcement.

1:41:50So if you have companies saying,

1:41:51if you buy a product with our name on it from Amazon,

1:41:56it is not authorized and it is likely counterfeit,

1:42:00if it's being sold new, that is, I mean, that's--

1:42:03- That is serious damage to Amazon's brand, right?

1:42:05Because-- - Who wants that?

1:42:06- Retail is largely about trust, in my opinion.

1:42:10I mean, I guess for some people,

1:42:11and maybe this is the way Amazon sees it,

1:42:13maybe, I guess for some people,

1:42:14retail is largely about price,

1:42:16and it's all just cheap, cheap price.

1:42:18And Walmart is sort of built on that.

1:42:20But I think Walmart has, for people who like Walmart,

1:42:25there's a certain trust, right?

1:42:29I think part of it is that people trust

1:42:31that the prices are gonna be low.

1:42:32There's no, you know, we don't have,

1:42:34don't even bother going around town and pricing--

1:42:37- Exactly. - Pricing your dog food

1:42:39at the supermarket too.

1:42:41Just get it at Walmart.

1:42:42You know it's gonna be as cheap or cheaper.

1:42:44And I think people know that when you buy

1:42:48whatever brand dog food at Walmart,

1:42:50it really is whatever brand dog food.

1:42:53You know, it's the, you know,

1:42:54the Cuisinart thing you buy at Walmart is a Cuisinart.

1:42:57I think it's serious, serious, serious damage

1:43:01to Amazon's trust that it's turning its reputation.

1:43:04It's starting to be like eBay,

1:43:06where it's like, who the hell knows what you're gonna get?

1:43:08- It's true.

1:43:09I remember, by the way, Jeff Bezos said this.

1:43:11I worked for Amazon briefly for like six months in '96, '97.

1:43:15Was hired by Jeff who I knew

1:43:16when the company was starting out.

1:43:17So it was a little bit of a, you know, it wasn't nepotism per se.

1:43:19I did a great job.

1:43:20I did a great job.

1:43:21Did a bunch of stuff.

1:43:22There's still like, I understood a bunch of programs.

1:43:24I feel very happy with my time there.

1:43:25Like what I got done.

1:43:26But, uh, Jeff said at some meeting and I, I, 20 years ago, I remember it very distinctly.

1:43:30He said, um, we're eventually going to become authoritative for price.

1:43:33And what I mean by authoritative is not that we always had the best price that people don't think they need to go anywhere else.

1:43:38They just assume we do.

1:43:39Right.

1:43:39And I was like, and that was, I was like, I thought it was like, huh, I wonder how that'll work out.

1:43:43It's like, that's what's happening.

1:43:45So, you know, I run this book price comparison

1:43:46site called isbn.nu.

1:43:48It's my ongoing programming experiment and

1:43:50running a large, like a high traffic site.

1:43:52It's millions of queries a day.

1:43:53People just punch an ISBN or you search on a book

1:43:56and it gives you price results from a dozen,

1:43:5815 bookstores.

1:43:59And what's fascinating to me is over time, the

1:44:01revenue has gone down because people don't

1:44:02price compare that much.

1:44:04And most of the revenue used to be Amazon was,

1:44:06I don't know, like 25% of the revenue.

1:44:08Now it's like 75% because people come and

1:44:11they search like, ah, let's get it at Amazon.

1:44:12I mean, that's kind of the result.

1:44:14And there was a point at which like most, I

1:44:17think the majority of my money comes from people

1:44:19doing textbook searches because then you have

1:44:21more variety and I mean, there's textbooks that

1:44:24sell, there's people about textbooks that cost

1:44:26$1,200 and I get four to 8% of that.

1:44:28I'm like, hooray, but holy crap.

1:44:30So, uh, so I get a lot of sales in, uh, you

1:44:33know, in July, August and January, basically

1:44:35it's kind of a funny pattern I have.

1:44:37Um, but it's been interesting to watch it

1:44:39because it's been this gradual change as, as

1:44:41Amazon has just assumed to have the best price

1:44:43as other stores like why would you buy I bought a bunch of DVDs and blu-rays from Barnes and Noble

1:44:48a few weeks ago because they had a ridiculous sale they were doing 40 to 50 percent off everything

1:44:53already then they had a 30 percent off coupon you could add with it and they had free shipping so I

1:44:58bought stuff some things for 70 to 80 percent off list price or yeah off list price but I never buy

1:45:04from bn.com um let me take one final break here thank our third and final sponsor of the show it

1:45:10is our old friends at Casper, a company that makes obsessively engineered mattresses at

1:45:15shockingly fair prices. I have recently been on vacation. We stayed in two different hotels,

1:45:21split a little trip, and one hotel had, in my opinion, a terrible mattress. I woke up

1:45:27every day and I was a little miserable, and then we immediately spent the second half

1:45:31of the trip in a different hotel, which had a terrific mattress. I thought of Casper and

1:45:37And I thought, you know, this,

1:45:38'cause a lot of times if you don't think about it,

1:45:40you don't get to compare one day after another

1:45:42what a difference a great mattress can make.

1:45:44I am one of those people who says,

1:45:46"Hey, you really do sleep a third of your life.

1:45:48"It's worth getting a great mattress and a good bed."

1:45:52You spend so much time in bed,

1:45:53you probably spend more time in bed

1:45:55than you do anywhere else.

1:45:57Why not get a great one?

1:45:58Well, Casper has created terrific mattress.

1:46:01They have an engineering team in-house

1:46:03that spent thousands of hours

1:46:04developing their Casper mattress.

1:46:06It combines springy latex and supportive memory foam

1:46:09for a sleep surface with just the right sink

1:46:12and just the right bounce.

1:46:13I love the fact that Casper just has one type of mattress.

1:46:18All you do is pick your size.

1:46:19You just pick a size and that's the mattress.

1:46:21Because how the hell would you pick?

1:46:22Like if they had like seven different types of mattresses,

1:46:25how would you pick?

1:46:26I don't know how to pick.

1:46:28I just, I trust that somebody who becomes a mattress

1:46:31engineer is gonna do the job for me, right?

1:46:34It's sort of like Apple in that regard,

1:46:35where they're going to just do that's what design is design is making choices

1:46:39well Casper has figured out what they think is the best way to make a mattress

1:46:43now maybe you disagree maybe you get it you don't like it well guess what they

1:46:47have a hundred night home trial so if you buy the thing take it up the steps

1:46:52and that they vacuum seal these things into the most ridiculously little you

1:46:56cannot believe that there is like a queen or king size mattress in one of

1:46:59these boxes it you take it up in a room follow the directions it sucks all the

1:47:04out of the room to fill it up and all of a sudden you've got this little box now

1:47:07you've got a queen or king-size mattress whatever you need if you don't like it

1:47:11you have a hundred nights and if you don't you just go to the website and say

1:47:15I'd take my mattress back they give you all your money back and they take care

1:47:19of the hassle of getting the mattress out of your house that's how confident

1:47:24they are and how few people actually take them up on it so if you have any

1:47:27reluctance to buy a mattress online because you haven't actually sat there

1:47:31in a gross showroom where other people have laid on the same mattress and poked at it

1:47:36before. You don't have to worry about it. You can't lose. I have heard from readers,

1:47:41a lot of readers. It's the craziest thing in the world to me that I have become like

1:47:45a spokesperson for a mattress company. Among the many things I never thought I would ever

1:47:49do in life is sell mattresses. But it's so funny to me, but readers write to me and say,

1:47:55"You know, I just moved. I had to get a new mattress and I got one of the Casper things

1:47:59I you know and expected that they would send it back or whatever. They're like, this is great

1:48:02This is like staying in like a best hotel. It is a great mattress

1:48:06So get yours today go to Casper comm slash the talk show Casper

1:48:11Casper ER slash the talk show use the code the talk show with the the and you save 50 bucks on your mattress and the

1:48:19Prices are great. It's 750 for full 850 for Queen 950 for a king a king-size mattress for 950 you save 50

1:48:26It's only 900 bucks.

1:48:27Most stores, that's like two grand.

1:48:29Really is.

1:48:30That's how expensive mattresses are.

1:48:32So go to casper.com/thetalkshow

1:48:34the next time you need a mattress.

1:48:36And maybe consider the fact

1:48:38that maybe you do need a mattress.

1:48:40- I want someone to do that experiment

1:48:41like with Amentos and Pepsi's

1:48:42where they open a bunch of Casper mattresses in a room

1:48:45and see if all the air is sucked out of the windows pop in.

1:48:47Like now I wanna see that.

1:48:48- Or if people can't breathe.

1:48:51- Can't breathe, Casper.

1:48:54Last thing on my agenda for this show was this issue where, uh,

1:48:58this guy, Milo, uh, I don't know how to pronounce his name.

1:49:02Yiannopoulos. I believe it is.

1:49:05The Annapolis, um, sort of a, uh, uh,

1:49:08conservative agitator slash political columnist. Uh,

1:49:12I'm not quite sure how to describe him for people who aren't familiar with them.

1:49:15He's the very six, very, very successful troll.

1:49:21very successful, charming in a way that only people with an English accent can ever get away

1:49:26with while being—he's a younger Boris Johnson for people into politics. Younger, nastier Boris Johnson.

1:49:34Brian And this relates to what you were talking about before, where there is some subset of—he's

1:49:40a participant in this new subculture called the alt-right, which is, you know, I don't want to

1:49:48want to get too much into politics of it, but there is a subset of this movement and

1:49:54of the internet at large that is, of all the things in the world to be upset about, very

1:50:02downright angry that the Ghostbusters reboot features an all-women cast of Ghostbusters.

1:50:10the people actually busting ghosts are for women. When in the original movie, there were four men,

1:50:19and they are very upset about this. And I don't really know why. It seems very strange to me.

1:50:25To me, this is a sign that these people have some very...

1:50:31I think if you're upset that Ghostbusters is now all women, it is a very good sign that you have

1:50:37some very significant issues with women. Well, this guy, I think I'm being fair here. Somehow,

1:50:47a week ago, Leslie Jones, also speaking of very talented current SNL cast members.

1:50:53I have to interrupt you. I love, more than Kate McKinnon, I love Leslie Jones so much, so much,

1:51:00because she is the kind of comedian you do not see on television. Not just that she's black,

1:51:04But she's like a statuesque, she's like, I don't know, she's six something.

1:51:08She's six feet tall.

1:51:09But she is not a traditional, you know, figure.

1:51:12She is, she is this large, beautiful, totally outspoken woman with spiky hair who has this

1:51:19like incredible voice and she has this like intensity that like John Cleese at his best,

1:51:25when he was like angry John Cleese in the early Imani pythons and could go red face.

1:51:28Like she has this incredible energy and I love her and I love that she is on SNL.

1:51:34now. I love that she's in this film. Yeah, I think she's really, I like, she's really great on SNL too.

1:51:40I love, again, like you said, she's definitely not the sort of comedian that you typically see.

1:51:44I can't think of anybody else to even compare her to. No, there's no, I mean, she's, yeah,

1:51:48she's kind of her own. I mean, I don't go to clubs, but she seems to be like her own,

1:51:52like, unforg, un, like, um, she does not change herself for anybody else. And she got her place

1:51:58in this show and is doing her thing. Absolutely. Uh, she's a good writer too. She's not just a

1:52:03a good performer because I, you know, she writes like her own bits when she, my favorites are when

1:52:07she's on the weekend update desk. And that's really just, you know, those are her bits.

1:52:13Well, anyway, she's in the Ghostbusters, she's busting ghosts and was on Twitter engaging,

1:52:19you know, with the fans and somehow just started getting a just a steaming, ceaseless barrage of

1:52:30at replies and mentions, racist, misogynist, I don't even know, I mean there's got to be even

1:52:37more things, more offenses, but really some just sick, sick stuff from these gamergate troll types.

1:52:45And she, you know, engaged with them. She started retreating some of them, and this Milo guy jumped

1:52:54in on it, and including, and to me the one I think probably put him over the top, was the one where

1:53:00where he posted a fake screenshot that made it look as though Leslie Jones herself called

1:53:06somebody a kike.

1:53:09And she didn't.

1:53:10She I think there's one where she, the manufactured screenshot, which had more than 140 characters

1:53:16by the way, but it was part of the tell, but who's counting was accusing him was like calling

1:53:21you know, he's he's openly gay.

1:53:22He makes a big point of being conservative and very far right and gay and he's just at

1:53:26the Republican National Convention hosting a party.

1:53:29very into that, right? So he, the screen capture had something that was essentially making fun of

1:53:34him for being gay. I forget the exact detail. Uh, so that was part of it too. Like he was saying,

1:53:38look, I'm being attacked by her. Right. When in fact she's not. And these fake screenshots

1:53:44were not, uh, there's no way that you could, they're not parody. It's not like when our pal

1:53:50Darth, you know, posts a picture that makes Trump's hand seem like a Barbie doll size.

1:53:55You know what I mean? Like, you know, like that's parody. And nobody is, you know,

1:54:01it's nobody's fool. This is a deliberate attempt to turn his followers, to get them

1:54:07to actually believe that she was committing, you know, these acts of hateful tweets as well,

1:54:13which would encourage them to, "Well, hey, if she's going to do that, let's take the gloves off,

1:54:17you know, now fair is fair. Now we can, you know, go racist and misogynist on her."

1:54:24And so what happened is this guy, and this guy's been in trouble with Twitter before,

1:54:28where people have reported him for this sort of abuse and harassment, leading a caterer of

1:54:34harassers. Before, at one point he was verified. You know, I think it was part of the whole thing.

1:54:40He is a journalist. He works, you know, he's worked for legitimate publications before. I think he's

1:54:44the tech correspondent for Breitbart now. If you don't know Breitbart, it's a, well, I think it'll

1:54:52say everything you need to know is it's a conservative leaning website that was very

1:54:59early on the pro-Trump. Well, yeah, it's the current state. It's also, if you haven't looked

1:55:04at Breitbart in a while, I'm not sure you should, but it was founded by Andrew Breitbart, who's like,

1:55:08was our age and then died. And I know people who liked him, actually like, like friend to friend

1:55:12to friend liked him very much personally. His site was, oh, he tried to, he'd helped co-start

1:55:17Huffington Post and then left and started this far right thing. And, but it wasn't, didn't involve

1:55:22of like white supremacy and whatever.

1:55:24It was pretty far right.

1:55:26And he's the one who found Elliot Spitzer's,

1:55:28who's picked, Anthony Weiner's Weiner,

1:55:30didn't he have the shot of that, I think, revealed?

1:55:32- Maybe, I don't know.

1:55:33- Anyway, so Breitbart now, if you remember

1:55:36what the site was like when Andrew Breitbart

1:55:38were live and ran it, this is like something

1:55:40even so far beyond that, it makes me look back fondly

1:55:43at the time that Andrew Breitbart ran the site.

1:55:46- Yeah, when Breitbart ran it,

1:55:48I was not a regular reader of it,

1:55:49but I was familiar with it.

1:55:52It was like something I didn't agree with, but not something that I found offensive,

1:55:57whereas now, to me, it is borderline offensive.

1:56:00To me, it comes about as close as you possibly can in today's...

1:56:05Even if you're anti-quote-unquote "anti-politically correct,"

1:56:10there are still modicums of discourse that we all agree to.

1:56:16It comes about as close as you can in the guidelines of modern discourse

1:56:20to being like white supremacist in my opinion.

1:56:23Yeah, it crosses into, it almost, I mean, this is, because this is Milo's stick without

1:56:29even getting into the political aspect of it, because there are left, left-side extremists

1:56:34who do the same thing. And we saw a lot of times the left does not get the same criticism

1:56:37as the right. The right seems to get a lot more coverage when they say extreme things

1:56:41and they verge into, you know, nativism and white supremacy and things, and you know,

1:56:46anti-Semitism and so forth. The left has, unfortunately, the far left has an anti-Semitism

1:56:50and other kinds of extremism and the whole, uh,

1:56:54Bernie period revealed, unfortunately, that a

1:56:56subset, not all, not all Bernie Bros, not all

1:56:59Bernie supporters, but a subset of, uh, Sanders,

1:57:02the people who alleged to be, may have been good

1:57:05trolls, may have been deep supporters also

1:57:07engaged in some pretty severe activity.

1:57:09And it's they, but they always try, especially,

1:57:12I mean, Breitbart does a great job of this.

1:57:13Milo, especially they're trying to come up to the

1:57:15line of hate speech without crossing to it,

1:57:18where they get into something that's, that's

1:57:19actionable, where they could get sued and lose,

1:57:22not just get sued, but sued and clearly lose,

1:57:24or in which they would cross some line in which

1:57:27some aspect of decency would involve the maybe

1:57:30a criminal statute, like hate speech is not

1:57:33protected in a line.

1:57:34You know, all speech is not absolutely protected

1:57:35in the United States.

1:57:36There's been a lot of trials about it, but

1:57:38certain kinds of hate speech used for incitement,

1:57:40especially if you're publishing a website in

1:57:42multiple countries.

1:57:43Uh, I don't know if I can't remember if Milo

1:57:45lives in the U S UK or he's back and forth, but

1:57:47like, you know, he's a, he's a, he's a, he's a

1:57:49Like he could wind up being, you know, prosecuted

1:57:52if he crossed certain lines outside the US than here.

1:57:56Anyway, so like they, but they are knowingly skating up

1:57:59to the precipice and skating back,

1:58:01where they will get as far as they can

1:58:02with the skates hanging over the cliff,

1:58:04you know, before they skate back.

1:58:07- Yeah, and I don't think it's any coincidence.

1:58:11I mean, part of it is that Leslie Jones

1:58:13was engaging on Twitter,

1:58:15but I don't think it's any coincidence

1:58:17that of the four Ghostbusters, they went after the one who's not just a woman, but is also

1:58:23black. This guy's been in trouble with Twitter before. At one point he was verified. That's

1:58:29why I mentioned he's a journalist. They removed his verified badge, which is very odd thing.

1:58:34I thought that was very unusual. Like I could see why Twitter wants to deal with this guy,

1:58:38but removing his verified badge was a very strange move to me because I didn't like it.

1:58:42I didn't like it either because it, it, it plays into this whole notion that having the

1:58:46verified badge is this mark of prestige, which to me is like nonsense. I don't know. I mean,

1:58:52I got verified. I didn't ask for it. It was like, somehow what happened is when remember

1:58:57when Matt Honan got hacked? Oh, yeah, yeah. So Matt Honan, who's now at BuzzFeed got hacked

1:59:05like two years ago, and he wrote a great story about it. And it was somehow that was like,

1:59:09you know, it was sort of social engineering where his attacker called Apple and said,

1:59:15you know, claim to be him and somehow got through a couple of the questions and got

1:59:19his, you know, Mac.com, his iCloud account, uh, uh, reset. And then once they had his

1:59:27email account, that was the email account used by his Twitter account. And so his at

1:59:31MAT, you know, it seemed like the target of it was that the, because he has this very

1:59:36short, uh, Twitter handle at MAT, uh, isn't that his Twitter handle? I think it used to

1:59:41be.

1:59:42Yes, that's right. It's super short. They really wanted that. And I have a friend who

1:59:45who has a very short handle that apparently it's part of her name,

1:59:49but it's four letters and it relates to some programming thing.

1:59:51So she is being regularly harassed by script kiddies and how to get someone

1:59:55permanently suspended because of their, uh, doxing attempts.

1:59:58Yeah. Uh, or yeah,

2:00:00it's a weird thing where like certain handles are so in demand.

2:00:04Jesse char is at Jesse on Instagram. Every, every photo she posts,

2:00:09there's some girl named Jesse, you know, not the same person, but every time it's,

2:00:12can I have your Twitter handle?

2:00:14There's, you know, Dave Rutledge works at MEH, our friends at MEH, which is I've been

2:00:19running for MEH, by the way, which is a fun place to write for.

2:00:21He's at, he's @_.

2:00:22Yeah, and his wife is @__, and their child is @___.

2:00:26Well, his wife's @__ got ripped off, got hijacked somehow, and he eventually, he kind of was

2:00:32trying to, they were trying to go through channels, they eventually kind of bumped up

2:00:35like, "Anybody help us?"

2:00:36And somebody at Twitter was like, "Got your back," and took care of it, but she almost

2:00:39lost @__.

2:00:40Ugh.

2:00:41Well, anyway.

2:00:42It was terrible.

2:00:43which is weird because to me, it's almost like to me that isn't like we're punishing you. It's like,

2:00:48to me that would be like, we're no longer certain that this account is who you, is you.

2:00:52But they knew it was him. There's no question that it was him. So removing the verified badge

2:00:56is very strange. It's like,

2:00:58Well, you know, but the reason they do it though, I think the reason they did it and I, and I have

2:01:02the same reaction you do too. It's like Twitter shouldn't be anointing people. They originally

2:01:06started the verified program to help celebrities in some news outlets prevent to have a legitimate

2:01:12account that showed it wasn't being impersonated, that they'd vetted it, right?

2:01:15And they used to have requirements that you had to have two-factor authentication or some

2:01:19other protection on your email, or they would ask, and so they vetted entire newsrooms where

2:01:23the newsroom had shown them or discussed their techniques to prevent email from being hijacked

2:01:28so that they wouldn't be overtaken.

2:01:30Especially if they're like AP hijacks and a bunch of news outlets got hijacked a few

2:01:33years ago.

2:01:34So, but the thing that, the reason I think they did it is if you're verified, I'm not

2:01:39You know, there's, they have the tools that you

2:01:41see only verified accounts.

2:01:42So if you're looking at replies, so I think this

2:01:44was to get him to not show up in the replies to

2:01:48other people are verified, like celebrities and

2:01:50whoever, whoever they, yeah, I know.

2:01:52Cause I, you know, I tweeted, so, um, Chrissy

2:01:54Teigen, uh, the supermodel, I think she is also

2:01:58awesome.

2:01:59Like I don't even know her super modeling career.

2:02:00Like I've seen pictures of her.

2:02:01She's I like most supermodels, one of the most

2:02:04beautiful women on the planet.

2:02:05Great.

2:02:05Right.

2:02:05But I don't, it's fine.

2:02:07It's beautiful.

2:02:07Um, sports illustrated model, right?

2:02:10Cover model.

2:02:10So, but that I didn't follow her because of that.

2:02:12At some point I noticed people retweeting these

2:02:15incredibly funny, really direct stuff she's saying

2:02:17about, you know, not just like feminism or politics,

2:02:20whatever, but the way that, which she has to defend

2:02:22yourself, she's married to John Legend about people

2:02:25telling her she doesn't deserve him and he's been

2:02:26duped and whatever.

2:02:27She is awesome.

2:02:28She is so forthright and so great.

2:02:30She has a cookbook out.

2:02:31So I, she tweets something last night.

2:02:34I wrote something back to her.

2:02:35I can't read just some little thing in my

2:02:36just some little thing in passing. I don't think she's going to read it. She favorited it." And I'm

2:02:40like, "Good God, just, this thing has 4,000 favorites on it. Why would she do that?" I'm

2:02:44like, "Oh, she's using this filtering. I have a verified tag." So, there is a little bit of a

2:02:49superpower that is associated with it, is you have more visibility to people who are verified.

2:02:53So, I'm, you know, some random journalist who works in a daylit basement. And I can,

2:02:58but because of that, it's like, that I think is the power of that blue checkmark.

2:03:04Yeah, well what happened for people like me and you is after Honan got hacked and I think he got hacked

2:03:09I think I might be misremembering the details. I think he got hacked those. I think it was very clear

2:03:13It was about his his MAT Twitter. I think you're totally right, but it was early but Twitter

2:03:19I think as a precaution thought well

2:03:21Maybe it's because he's a tech

2:03:23reporter and that all of a sudden in a very short period of time like I think me and you probably got verified right around the

2:03:28Same time a lot of people at Macworld did

2:03:31I had to wait a bit. I had to ask them for actually a few years because I did. Well, the thing was,

2:03:35I felt there was this developing thing where a lot of journalists were getting marked and I'm like, look, I'm a freelancer.

2:03:40Not having a blue check mark makes me look like I'm not legitimate on Twitter. And I'm like, I don't care or not.

2:03:46But if you're going to have a system, I want to be in it so that then, and likewise, like I can direct message people who don't have DMs open and they can DM me even if I have DMs off because we're verified.

2:03:57verified like that's a funny thing. There's a couple little things that are useful.

2:04:01It's a very strange club.

2:04:03Yeah, it's a weird club and it's like it's got supermodels,

2:04:06the President of the United States and you and me. It's great. I love being in this club.

2:04:08I've told this before and it is incredibly embarrassing, but it's,

2:04:13uh, my son told his friends at school that I'm verified and all the girls in the class thought it was the coolest thing that they did.

2:04:20Oh my God. That's awesome.

2:04:24They were like, no way. They didn't believe him. They didn't believe him.

2:04:26So like they, they opened up a Chromebook and loaded my Twitter page and they were like,

2:04:32that's so cool.

2:04:33Oh my gosh, that is awesome.

2:04:35That is terrible.

2:04:36I think it's just dreadful.

2:04:38But anyway, Milo Yiannopoulos, they took away his badge.

2:04:43They had suspended him temporarily for similar incidents in the past and he'd always come

2:04:48back.

2:04:49And after this one, right before he was supposed to go into some kind of event in Cleveland

2:04:54for the Republican National Convention, he received an email that said, "This is it.

2:05:00Your account is permanently suspended."

2:05:03One of the weird things about that—I think they did the right thing.

2:05:06I think this guy was abusing Twitter, and I don't think Twitter should tolerate it.

2:05:11But it is weird.

2:05:14There's a weird down-the-memory-hole aspect to it, where once his account is suspended,

2:05:18all of his tweets are gone.

2:05:19- Yeah, I know, that's, you know,

2:05:21so when they do temporary suspensions,

2:05:23they will often make people agree to delete specific tweets

2:05:27through an automated process

2:05:28before they're allowed to the count back.

2:05:30So only those tweets are deleted?

2:05:32Like, however odious something is,

2:05:33I'm like, well, this is deleting history.

2:05:35Now no one knows that he said

2:05:37these hundred thousand terrible things.

2:05:39- Yeah, and that was part of it.

2:05:40And there were, you know,

2:05:41I wrote briefly about this on "Daring Fireball,"

2:05:43I support this.

2:05:44And my take is that his supporters say,

2:05:47and I've seen this argument with other people,

2:05:49this is not the only time, but when something like this happens and after instigating this

2:05:54sort of abuse, they say, well now that they've suspended his account, they're obviously,

2:06:01Twitter is a company that censors conservatives and suppresses free speech.

2:06:07As though the right to harass people on Twitter, and I don't think there can be any argument

2:06:13that what was done to Leslie Jones was outright harassment.

2:06:16She seemed genuinely emotionally distressed at what she was seeing and dealing with.

2:06:24The argument that that should be protected free speech is just nonsense, and it just

2:06:28shows that these people are, in my opinion, not just racist and misogynist, but that they're

2:06:36like sociopaths, that they're so emotionally stunted, that

2:06:44it's very hard. You really can't rationalize with these

2:06:49people. And there were other readers. I got some feedback from people

2:06:53who read Daring Fireball. Very thoughtful. And some people I

2:06:57know, just random readers, who said, "I'm very

2:07:01uncomfortable with this. I'm not racist or misogynist.

2:07:04These weren't people who were Milo Yiannopoulos fans, but they were like, "I'm just very

2:07:08uncomfortable with Twitter saying that somebody, you know, this is allowed and this isn't.

2:07:16There should be a free-for-all."

2:07:17But you can't have a free-for-all.

2:07:18You just—well, you could.

2:07:20You could run a service that's a free-for-all, but it's not going to be a pleasant place.

2:07:24Alan Corey Yeah, among other things.

2:07:25Twitter has rules of engagement, has terms of service, and he was violating them.

2:07:31like the reason they got criticism about this is

2:07:34famous persons attacked, famous prominent person

2:07:36who's already under attack has part of like a

2:07:38cultural war against, you know, people who may

2:07:41align with Trump and people who may align with

2:07:43other progressive movements.

2:07:44Uh, so, and I actually saw Leslie Jones

2:07:47interviewed by her friend Seth Meyers and his

2:07:49show, and it was lovely.

2:07:51And she was talking about this whole situation.

2:07:53Oh really?

2:07:53I didn't see that.

2:07:54Yeah, it was like four or five minute clip.

2:07:56And one of the things they showed was a bunch of

2:07:57people who'd sent into Seth Meyers, like these

2:07:59these little videos of just how, you know,

2:08:02you're awesome, Leslie, you're so inspirational.

2:08:03It's like this like little girl and an adult

2:08:05couple and just like all kinds of people.

2:08:07It was great.

2:08:07And she was practically crying cause it was just,

2:08:09you know, so you'll be so nice about it.

2:08:11But, um, she said, um, he said, you know, should

2:08:14it rise, Seth asked a very good question.

2:08:16He was like, should this rise the level?

2:08:18Like you and I are kind of well known, like we

2:08:20have a lot of, you know, whatever, a lot of

2:08:21followers and she's like, this should be, and

2:08:23she said, you know, this is for, it should be

2:08:25for everybody.

2:08:25No one should go.

2:08:26Like he said, she said, if I never spoke up

2:08:28spoke up about this. No one would ever have known it happened to me. But I made a fuss,

2:08:33right? And if she'd never talked back to people, it still would have affected her,

2:08:38because it's asymmetric. And I think that's, that's the issue. The question I would say

2:08:42too, when you look at Milo, like, he's a provocateur. That's his stock and trade.

2:08:46He talks about being a provocateur. He wants to get a reaction, and he's very good at

2:08:50it. Now, it's unfortunate that what he wants, that he's not, you know, in my mind, funny

2:08:54or interesting or decent or whatever. I think he's off the charts in terms of, you know,

2:08:59being practically a sociopath in the way that he acts. He acts consistently in his self-interest

2:09:03without regard for any standards of morality or decency. And that's, you know, it doesn't matter,

2:09:07I don't care if he's left or right. I'm not even talking about any political view he has,

2:09:11it's his behavior. And it's not political correctness when you're specifically trying

2:09:16to say things that you know will cause, like, political correctness is when you are

2:09:21told not say something that is a reasonable statement that is not designed specifically

2:09:26to harm someone and is actually part of social discourse that needs to occur to improve the

2:09:31social good. That is political correctness I've encountered. There's a lot of things as somebody

2:09:35who's, you know, left the center, maybe a liberal, lifelong democratic voter. There are things that

2:09:40I do not feel comfortable discussing in public because I know I can't discuss in a way without

2:09:45having a blowback that would be pretty severe, even though I have no bad intent and I want to

2:09:50through an issue as opposed to make statements,

2:09:52right? So there is, there is a chilling effect

2:09:55in certain areas that I would call that because

2:09:56you can't even bring up, this happens like easy

2:09:59case, which I can talk about. It's like, look

2:10:00at Israel, supportive Israel. I'm a Jew. My

2:10:03whole family, I'm married to someone who's not

2:10:05Jewish, but my whole family back to whatever

2:10:08is Jewish. I'm very uncomfortable with Israel.

2:10:10I think they're engaged. I don't, I'm not going

2:10:12to get into the political stuff, but like I'm

2:10:13very uncomfortable with Israel. Let's leave it

2:10:14there, right? It is very difficult to have any

2:10:17sane and sensible conversation about

2:10:18about Palestinians, Arabs, and Israel with any combination of people, other Jews, non-Jews,

2:10:24Muslims, whatever, no two people can get together and talk without somebody chiding you for some

2:10:30opinion about it no matter what your stance is. And there is, that's sort of a problem with race

2:10:35in America too. It's very difficult to have a discussion because no two people can agree how

2:10:39to talk about it without essentially accusing each other of engaging in something. That is a form of

2:10:44Going out of your way to specifically knowingly inflict emotional harm or inspire threats

2:10:50against somebody, even when you do it with a way that's plausibly deniable, that is not convincing

2:10:55at all, there's no question what that is. So, if Milo were super left-wing and thought it was funny

2:11:01to go after anti-Semitic things against Jewish actress or something, and I'm saying that not

2:11:08that the left is all anti-Semitic, but it's the closest, you're not going to have left-wing people

2:11:11go after black people typically, but you know,

2:11:13that happens too.

2:11:13You have issues with intersectional

2:11:14feminism, blah, blah, blah.

2:11:16I won't go into that.

2:11:16But anyway, so it doesn't, I don't think it's a

2:11:18political thing.

2:11:18He's not raising a conservative point

2:11:20against Leslie.

2:11:22He's not raising an issue even about the movie.

2:11:24Like he has a cultural, the whole gamer gate

2:11:26movement, alt-right merged together with it.

2:11:29And even the Ghostbusters thing has to do with

2:11:31people who feel like that people who were in a,

2:11:34what they thought was a majority situation,

2:11:35never felt the benefits of privilege and now reject

2:11:38entirely the notion that they have a

2:11:40that they have any privilege.

2:11:42But so there's a structural cultural argument there

2:11:45that he, that the basis of which is at Ghostbusters

2:11:48is a terrible thing because of,

2:11:49but that is not a conservative viewpoint.

2:11:51- But he's parlaying off the, his followers,

2:11:56actually, I think is the point you're trying to make,

2:11:58actually well-founded concern at political correctness,

2:12:01the dial right now is set too far,

2:12:04and that things that we should be able to have discussion

2:12:07about we feel like you can't.

2:12:09It's funny, but whatever political correctness is raised, it's always about issues where I'm like,

2:12:12that's not political correctness. That's someone wanting to say something offensive

2:12:15and not liking the consequences as opposed to a valid, when I say valid, everyone will have

2:12:20valid differently. This is the thing I want to get at with speech too is I wrote this long

2:12:23screen a few days ago. I wrote like 40 tweets in a tweet storm. I thought I was going to write two.

2:12:27Pete: You? Really?

2:12:28I know, it's crazy, right? And I got a remarkable amount of response,

2:12:32but I thought people wouldn't listen. I just had to say it because it's after Leslie-Jen's thing.

2:12:35And it's like, I think there's a clear difference. I don't study the First Amendment,

2:12:38so I can't tell you where this sits in law. There's probably people who have this more to find.

2:12:42There's offensive speech, and then there's like abusive, hate-threatening speech, right? And

2:12:47hate speech is a difficult thing under the First Amendment because the First Amendment is so broad.

2:12:51But I think Twitter should not encourage offensive speech, but I think it should allow it. And when I

2:12:56say offensive, it's things you don't want to hear are offensive. And sometimes those things are very

2:13:00offensive. If somebody wants to, on their own account, not adding me, say, and not talking about

2:13:06Let's say the best case.

2:13:07They say, there are Nazis who want to say,

2:13:09Jews are terrible.

2:13:10I think they should all go to a gas oven.

2:13:12I wish this would happen.

2:13:13I hate the fact that the world is run by Jews.

2:13:15If somebody wants to say that, well,

2:13:17that's very general.

2:13:18It's awful.

2:13:18It's offensive.

2:13:19I don't want to hear it.

2:13:20I don't have to follow them.

2:13:21If rather they're using their account to

2:13:24exchange information, to create, you know, to

2:13:26organize around notions of hate, to create,

2:13:28um, not even to create policies, but to, uh, to

2:13:32threaten other people, to gain strength that

2:13:34allows them to then practice hate speech

2:13:36against other people.

2:13:37Um, or if they're using their Twitter accounts,

2:13:39even as like coded ways to organize or promote

2:13:42things that they link to on websites or everyone

2:13:45knows on a website.

2:13:46And there's some question with Milo about like what

2:13:48he's posting on Breitbart versus what he's doing

2:13:49on Twitter.

2:13:50And he may even more careful on Twitter to not

2:13:52be as, uh, you know, provocative in some ways

2:13:55as he was on Breitbart even like that's a

2:13:57different thing.

2:13:58So like, I don't, so even if nothing Milo said

2:14:01specifically individually, if it weren't sent to

2:14:05to Leslie was offensive, like vile,

2:14:10but not actually abusive,

2:14:12that maybe there's a case made that that person,

2:14:14and there's some gray area there

2:14:16about saying things you don't wanna hear.

2:14:18'Cause John, there's tons of things that people say

2:14:19that you don't wanna hear

2:14:20that are valid political opinions

2:14:22that you wouldn't say that person should be banned

2:14:24unless you actually wanted to decrease free speech.

2:14:27- Right. - It's a very

2:14:28different thing.

2:14:29- And you know, it's a funny thing.

2:14:30It just isn't, a subset of these people

2:14:34seem to really think that free speech is,

2:14:37that it's absolute, that they should be able

2:14:42to do whatever they want.

2:14:43Say whatever they want to whatever they want

2:14:45and if they wanna @ reply Glenn

2:14:47that you should be put in an oven,

2:14:49they should be allowed to.

2:14:50And you should figure out how to filter it

2:14:53if you don't wanna see it.

2:14:53- Right. - That it's your problem.

2:14:55And I say that's hogwash.

2:14:56That's absolute nonsense.

2:14:59And I know that these analogies

2:15:02from between the online world and the real world

2:15:04always break down.

2:15:05There's always, 'cause you know,

2:15:07online is so totally different.

2:15:09But like my analogy was that nobody would ever

2:15:12tolerate a restaurant, no sane restaurant

2:15:15would ever tolerate allowing a person to come in

2:15:18and harass fellow patrons and just go up and

2:15:21make disparaging remarks about the color of their skin

2:15:27or that they seem to be same sex couple

2:15:32or whatever, for anything.

2:15:35Why would you allow that?

2:15:36It would be toxic.

2:15:38And that's exactly what these storms of people

2:15:42harassing people on Twitter are all about.

2:15:44- No, that's why Leslie Jones, he said,

2:15:46if I'm in a restaurant, she said exactly the same thing.

2:15:48- Maybe she read my-- - I'm in a restaurant,

2:15:51and a couple people are shot in front of me.

2:15:54That's the restaurant's problem.

2:15:55That's not my problem.

2:15:56I wanna eat in the restaurant.

2:15:57I like the restaurant, I wanna come back.

2:15:59But if people are gonna be shot there,

2:16:00I'm not going to go there.

2:16:02I think there's also this—free speech is not the right to be heard. It's the right to talk.

2:16:06Ted

2:16:09that it is actually hard to behave antisocially

2:16:14in the real world, especially after you get out

2:16:19of the older you get.

2:16:21It's, you know, kindergarten,

2:16:23there's a lot of antisocial behavior.

2:16:25And as you work your way through high school,

2:16:27it decreases, but there's, you know,

2:16:29a lot of people have memories

2:16:30of a lot of antisocial tormentors in, you know,

2:16:33middle school and high school.

2:16:35And then all of a sudden it just magically goes away

2:16:38when you go to college.

2:16:39and in the real world, in most venues,

2:16:41it is extremely difficult to behave antisocially.

2:16:44There's all sorts of social pressure

2:16:48and there's physical pressure.

2:16:50Like if you behave the way some of these people

2:16:51behave on Twitter in the real world,

2:16:53there's a very good chance that you'd get punched.

2:16:55I mean it.

2:16:56- Oh yeah, yeah. - You would actually

2:16:57get punched.

2:16:58So for example, here's an example.

2:17:01You and I both know an awful lot of,

2:17:04we've seen it in the last year or two.

2:17:06We've seen women who get, you know,

2:17:09stand up and speak out on something that upsets these people

2:17:14and then they get literally told,

2:17:17literally threatened with rape or death in a tweet.

2:17:20At, at, insert, you know, the username.

2:17:23You know, I know where you live, you're gonna get raped.

2:17:27If you did that to somebody in real life,

2:17:30there's a very good chance,

2:17:31well, you should be like arrested,

2:17:34But if somebody did that to my wife,

2:17:37I would be prepared to punch the guy.

2:17:40Because that's a dangerous situation.

2:17:42People don't do that.

2:17:43I mean, it just doesn't happen.

2:17:45So for these people who, for whatever reason,

2:17:48in their minds, want to behave antisocially,

2:17:51the online world, and we've known this,

2:17:54like you said, you've been on CompuServe since 1968.

2:17:57I mean, the online world has seen this

2:17:58from the beginning days, that there's antisocial behavior

2:18:01that you just don't encounter in the real world

2:18:03because there are no repercussions.

2:18:07You can get away with it.

2:18:08You can do it.

2:18:09So people have gotten into these hordes

2:18:13that harass people, and they seem to enjoy doing it.

2:18:17And what they're being told now,

2:18:19like with this Milo getting kicked off Twitter,

2:18:21is no, you can't do it.

2:18:22Well, if they can't do it, then all of a sudden

2:18:25they don't have an outlet for this antisocial behavior.

2:18:29And part of it, too, is that you can go off into,

2:18:33what's the 4chan or whatever, and just hang out,

2:18:35hang out with your fellow, you know, sickos,

2:18:39and do this.

2:18:41The beauty of Twitter from these weirdos' perspective

2:18:45is that they can at reply these women and minorities

2:18:49and get their jollies by knowing that the people

2:18:54who check their replies are gonna see it.

2:18:56And then when they engage, it's like they just go bananas

2:19:00because it's like they know, then it's confirmation.

2:19:02Like once they knew that Leslie Jones was actually seeing this stuff and reacting to it,

2:19:06it just made it worse because this is exactly what they want to do.

2:19:09They want to behave in an extremely, almost sociopathic way,

2:19:14and they can, and there's no other outlet for it in the world.

2:19:17And so now that Twitter is standing, you know, so they're standing behind free speech,

2:19:20but what they really want is they want their special bullying venue

2:19:25to remain available.

2:19:26Special bullying venue is probably not what Twitter wants as its motto.

2:19:31Definitely should, but that's the way these guys see Twitter.

2:19:34That is exactly the way they see Twitter.

2:19:36There's a high degree of asymmetricality in Twitter that could be changed.

2:19:39And, uh, Randy Harper knows I've been working on tools. I use her, uh, good, uh,

2:19:44what's called a good game block list. I forget. GG auto blocker, um,

2:19:48with a block together as the tool. And so you subscribe block together.

2:19:51There's a web app with a Twitter API integration.

2:19:54You log into it and then you can add shared lists of other people you and other

2:19:58people maintain, and you can set a few throttles and things.

2:20:00So, block together exists, it's a third party thing,

2:20:02Twitter allows it, and there are like 12,000 people

2:20:05on Randy's list that are auto-generated

2:20:07from people who follow a few major accounts,

2:20:09which will change, 'cause one of those few major accounts

2:20:11was Milo's, which was @Nero.

2:20:14And oh, Twitter, by the way, when it block,

2:20:16permanently suspends an account,

2:20:17that account is dead forever.

2:20:19@Nero will never be used again.

2:20:20- Right. - You know,

2:20:21'til the sun burns out, potentially.

2:20:23So, anyway, so, Randy Harper wrote this thing,

2:20:26just someone asked me that the other day,

2:20:28in February, it's a Medium piece,

2:20:29You can search for Randy Harper, medium Twitter ideas and, uh, finding the show notes.

2:20:33If you put it in, I don't know whatever, but she had like 23 ideas for Twitter.

2:20:36She's a developer.

2:20:37She's been working at three API.

2:20:39She's met with them.

2:20:40She's knows how everything works on the, you know, the outside of the black box.

2:20:44She knows it as well as anybody trying to develop anti-abusive tools, the stuff she mentioned, some of it's trivial.

2:20:50Some of it's harder.

2:20:51She's not sure the severity of work required for all of it, but those things are still out there.

2:20:57And so the issue with Twitter isn't so much that people can gang together and abuse, it's that you as a party receiving it, it is bad at asymmetrical warfare, where someone can get 100, someone can either create 1000 accounts and tweet at you, or get 100,000 people like the the the twitch twitchy, there's a conservative site, and they will often say basically, that person is bad. And then all the people who follow twitchy or go to the website will go off, I get I say I'll say respond to something Sally Cohen says, you know, I have a little back and forth her about something.

2:21:27or whatever, I think I'm being funny.

2:21:28And I will suddenly get all these people who hate

2:21:30follow Sally Cohen.

2:21:31I've never been targeted by Twitchy yet for as

2:21:33far as I know.

2:21:33Uh, and, uh, I get like, you know, a hundred or

2:21:36200 tweets from people who don't spell and have

2:21:39flags in their bios and just like, you're

2:21:40before, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

2:21:42You know, it's like, it's not even intelligible.

2:21:44It's just like random anger.

2:21:46There's nothing I can do to stop it except

2:21:48blocking what her time, even the auto block

2:21:50lists don't help me.

2:21:51So if there were tools, like if you started

2:21:53getting a lot of tweets, you could like, if there

2:21:55were dials and tools, you could just, you know,

2:21:57There are things that could happen that would,

2:21:58that would either temporarily or as a permanent

2:22:01block, you could prevent.

2:22:02The course tool that Twitter is going towards

2:22:04is that thing I was talking about.

2:22:05They have an app, I forgot what it's called.

2:22:07They could at least a separate app that's

2:22:09basically, it's good if you have a verified

2:22:11account, works fine otherwise, but it's a

2:22:13little tailored towards being a verified person

2:22:15with a large number of followers and mostly

2:22:19posting rather than doing a ton of interaction

2:22:21with everybody.

2:22:21Um, I've forgotten the name of it, but, uh, so

2:22:25So Twitter just the other day said they're going to open a verification to everybody with a

2:22:29opaque process that I think involves sending a picture ID to them.

2:22:33So you're going to give them your OD.

2:22:34So conceivably, this is one step on the road to more people being verified.

2:22:39And what if there are the hundred thousand most prolific, engaged Twitter people are all verified.

2:22:44Well, that can be removed as well.

2:22:46So maybe Twitter is moving towards a more asymmetrical model where we're only following, we give up following random people.

2:22:51If you can't be bothered to verify.

2:22:54I've thought for a long time, Twitter should

2:22:55offer a basic level of verification where you

2:22:58had to use a phone number to confirm, even

2:23:00though phone numbers can be disposable and

2:23:01whatever, it's a high enough bar that if you're

2:23:04re taking, getting a text from a phone number,

2:23:06you're, you know, it's a hassle if that account

2:23:09gets banned or blocked, it's a hassle to get

2:23:11their phone number and you can only get so

2:23:13many, you can't get a 10,000, a hundred

2:23:15thousand phone numbers, but they could have

2:23:16some basic level that doesn't involve sending

2:23:18a photo ID.

2:23:19And I could say, look, I don't want to deal

2:23:20with people who are completely anonymous.

2:23:22I only want to see people my time.

2:23:23And I think that's true in general, people don't follow Brianna

2:23:25Wu and then spew hate or they're not following.

2:23:28Typically some people do, some people follow you because they think it

2:23:31gives them a little extra whatever.

2:23:32So I only want to see things in my timeline will follow me because I can

2:23:35block them or I could change them.

2:23:37I mean, there's a checkbox and from people or for people who don't follow me.

2:23:41Cause I don't want to see things in my timeline, I don't want to see

2:23:44things in my timeline because I don't want to see things in my timeline.

2:23:46I don't want to see things in my timeline because I don't want to see

2:23:48things in my timeline because I don't want to see things in my timeline.

2:23:50Or for people who don't follow me, who, if they're not retweets from somebody else, that's cool.

2:23:56I'll see people who I follow as retweets, but people who have gone through a very basic level of verification

2:24:01that doesn't cost money. Like I don't want this to be a first world, developing world thing or whatever.

2:24:06But there's only things they could do. They could put lots of throttles in, they could be monitoring behavior.

2:24:10Jon, you know there's a setting called filter low quality tweets in your account, right?

2:24:15No, I did not know that.

2:24:16It's only available to verified people so far. It's been available for like two years.

2:24:19And if you check that, they use their machine learning, I think it's using machine learning,

2:24:23to filter out tweets that look like they aren't very good.

2:24:26(laughs)

2:24:27I don't know. I don't know. I don't know what it is. I think part of it, obviously, is that I am a white man.

2:24:35I can do things like write about Milo Yiannopoulos in a very critical way, and at least knock on wood, to date.

2:24:44I don't get, I get very, I got responses in Twitter, but it wasn't any, I wouldn't call it abuse.

2:24:49I mean, and there were people who disagreed and there were obviously, you know, people who staunchly disagreed.

2:24:53And a little bit of it was ugly, but I don't get any kind of mob, it never happens.

2:24:58Whereas if I think if I was, you know, Joan Gruber, I think there's a very good chance that I, I really do.

2:25:07I thought about A/B testing, like creating a fake account that was under the name of a woman with a woman's face,

2:25:14with someone's permission. Some people have tried this on like, OKCupid, they've gotten a friend's

2:25:17permission to use their image and just been like, you know, but then it becomes, I mean,

2:25:21it becomes a stunt. I don't want to be a stunt. Left women live through this, people of color,

2:25:24people with, who are not, you know, cis male, straight, white. It's like, they already have

2:25:30enough problems that I don't need to pretend to do like racism tourism or something like that.

2:25:35gender tourism. I should try it though because it would be interesting. I actually just by

2:25:39coincidence last night I crafted what I think I don't know how else you'd measure it I should go

2:25:45to fab star I think I wrote my two most popular tweets of all time last night no no really yeah

2:25:52and it the beating my old one which was my original all-time best tweet was like from 2009

2:26:00and I said, let me see if I can get it right.

2:26:02I said-- - I'm looking it up here.

2:26:03- I don't drink, I don't gamble.

2:26:06- Oh yeah, I found it.

2:26:10My one vice, I'm reading your own tweet to you.

2:26:12- Yeah, read it.

2:26:12- Okay, I don't drink, sorry, I don't gamble,

2:26:15I don't drink, my one vice is buying a new iPhone

2:26:18every summer, well that and lying about drinking and gambling.

2:26:21I remember that one, that was great.

2:26:22That was 2590 days ago.

2:26:24- Yes, that was previously my all-time favorite tweet.

2:26:28But last night after--

2:26:29- Oh my God, I'm looking at your numbers.

2:26:30This is hilarious.

2:26:31What are you using to look at them?

2:26:32I'm using-- I like Fafstar.

2:26:34Yeah, how do I do that?

2:26:35I'm just vain enough.

2:26:36I'm looking at-- oh, Nick Kristof and my friend Susan Orlean

2:26:40both retweeted it.

2:26:41And Chris Hayes from MSNBC retweeted it.

2:26:44Wait, he did?

2:26:44Yeah.

2:26:45Oh, I'm looking at one of them.

2:26:46Oh, yes, Nick Kristof and Susan--

2:26:47Nick Kristof, the columnist for The New York Times.

2:26:50Susan Orlean, staff writer for The New Yorker.

2:26:52Oh, yeah, Baratunde.

2:26:54Yeah, it's unbelievable.

2:26:56Somehow it got into the cycle of top political reporters,

2:26:59and they all retweeted it.

2:27:00Well, you're followed by—you have an interesting group of followers that overlaps, and so people who—this is what happened, I've had some breakouts.

2:27:06I have like 6,000 retweets, which is like 50 times more than anything I've ever said before, because I made a comment about Brexit.

2:27:14Because the morning after, I'm like, I'm listening to everything, and I'm like, this isn't going to happen.

2:27:19Like, there is a plan here.

2:27:21And I wrote something about basically like Brexit, you know, this could be such political suicide that Brexit's not going to happen.

2:27:29and it got retweeted like 6,000 times.

2:27:31Oh my God, did I get interesting responses?

2:27:33Those were actually interesting.

2:27:34I got hundreds and hundreds of replies from people.

2:27:37Some of them thought I was an idiot

2:27:38and some people thought I, you know,

2:27:39I'm like, I don't vote in the UK.

2:27:41I don't have an opinion on this, but I love the UK.

2:27:43I want it to succeed.

2:27:44But I also got very informed things by people

2:27:46who were torn about it or had voted for Remain anyway.

2:27:50But yeah, yours was-

2:27:51- This blew away.

2:27:52So I have two tweets, one after another,

2:27:54and I connected them with Tweetbots, whatever they call it.

2:27:57Let's play what if.

2:27:59What if Barack Obama had five children

2:28:02with three different women?

2:28:04Immediately followed by what if Hillary Clinton

2:28:06had five children with three different fathers?

2:28:08- I thought those were pretty brilliant.

2:28:11You know what's funny?

2:28:11And this is not to not credit you with originality and wit,

2:28:14'cause you have a lot of it, I'm gonna butter you up.

2:28:17But when I saw that, I was like,

2:28:18oh my God, has no one tweeted that before?

2:28:21'Cause the minute you say it, it's absolutely obvious,

2:28:24'cause they're all, you know, they're on stage,

2:28:25the five kids are on stage, and you're like,

2:28:27Holy crap, but like nobody had said it as succinctly and with the perfect timing as you had and so I did my

2:28:34At reply, you know, so the one tweet the one mentioned the first one with Barack Obama has

2:28:403100 retweets and Hillary Clinton one has 3,800 and 34 retweets

2:28:45So I even though I have an unusual Twitter account in a large number of followers. I had two tweets that were obviously a little

2:28:56provocative, presented to an awful lot more people

2:29:00than who usually read my tweets.

2:29:01And so my current @ reply stream is,

2:29:04I can't get to the bot, I can't keep up with it right now.

2:29:07- It must be out of control.

2:29:07I'm looking at, yeah, when I look at the people

2:29:09who've retweeted it, there's a bunch of people in there

2:29:11that I know like Mike Montero and John Siracusa

2:29:13and people are definitely the tech side of things.

2:29:16And then, you know, so it's a lot of the,

2:29:18lot of the, and then like, I mean,

2:29:20looking at the top retweets,

2:29:21and then it's a lot of just really interesting people

2:29:23who obviously found this through another thing,

2:29:24some of them have 50,000, 60,000.

2:29:26Yeah.

2:29:27Excuse me.

2:29:28There's an incredible, I mean, this is what's

2:29:30interesting about Twitter is like, it makes

2:29:31everyone have the ability to be a pundit or to be

2:29:34a standup comedian and reach an audience they

2:29:36don't otherwise.

2:29:37And it's like, sometimes you feel like you're

2:29:39shouting into the void.

2:29:39Like there's times, Max Temkin asked me, you

2:29:41know, from Cards Against Humanity, he asked

2:29:43me, I don't know, a while ago, he's like, you

2:29:45know, everybody who follows you agrees with

2:29:46what you're saying.

2:29:46Do you feel compelled to say it?

2:29:48And he wasn't, he was mildly castigating me

2:29:50because I had gone on about something.

2:29:51And, and I was like, ah, you know, I did go on

2:29:53And I'm like, you know, I don't think everyone

2:29:56who follows me actually, like, I don't know how

2:29:57many people who follow me read every tweet.

2:29:59It's a percentage.

2:30:00I look at Twitter.

2:30:01Nobody.

2:30:01I'm sorry.

2:30:02That's, I didn't mean to be such a traitor.

2:30:03I meant more like you can use Twitter analytics

2:30:05and anyone can log in and you actually get to

2:30:07see the impressions, like what percentage of

2:30:09your audience sees it.

2:30:11And it's fascinating.

2:30:11It's good.

2:30:12It's good and bad for the ego too.

2:30:13Yeah.

2:30:13Um, we got to wrap up.

2:30:15Okay.

2:30:15There's there's things that I say where I'm glad

2:30:19at times to be able to say, I just need to say

2:30:21this because I want other people to know that

2:30:23to know that other people feel it?

2:30:24- At the bottom line, Twitter has got to get a handle

2:30:30on this, it cannot just be something that they address

2:30:33when it's somebody of Leslie Jones' stature.

2:30:36This needs to be something that everybody feels

2:30:39like they're not going to be abused.

2:30:40Not, and I agree, there is a fine line

2:30:42and it is worrisome and Twitter, it's difficult

2:30:44and I trust that it can be done, which is,

2:30:47there should not try to prevent offensive speech

2:30:52or ideas that some people find offensive

2:30:54for being expressed on Twitter,

2:30:56but they should absolutely make it seem

2:30:58as though people are not going to be attacked.

2:31:01And they're the different human being,

2:31:03I don't know if you could do it all algorithmically,

2:31:04I really don't.

2:31:05I think you can use some algorithms to help,

2:31:08but I think when somebody reports abuse,

2:31:10I think somebody at Twitter who has any bit of empathy

2:31:12can easily discern this is just an offensive idea

2:31:16versus this is a personal attack on this other user.

2:31:21- Some of it's nuanced, but when a thousand accounts

2:31:24with fewer than a hundred followers all tweet

2:31:26within a few minutes of each other at one account,

2:31:29I think machines can learn what that means.

2:31:31- And I would even be in favor of,

2:31:32in terms of the nuance of, if there's any doubt,

2:31:35don't suspend the account.

2:31:39But it's so many cases where it's easily

2:31:41should be recognized.

2:31:42And the other thing that Twitter cannot,

2:31:44you can say, well, there's a scaling problem there.

2:31:45Twitter has an enormous headcount.

2:31:47I don't know how sustainable that is.

2:31:49I think it's, we could do a whole segment

2:31:52on the show about it, is why in the world

2:31:53does Twitter have so many employees?

2:31:54Because it doesn't seem like there's much new stuff going on.

2:31:58They certainly have the resources to hire a staff

2:32:00that can look into this abuse.

2:32:02And I think it absolutely needs to be done,

2:32:04and it ties into the Amazon thing,

2:32:05where it really is hurting Twitter's reputation,

2:32:08where Twitter is more and more getting a reputation

2:32:10as a place where if you participate,

2:32:11you, especially as a woman,

2:32:13you have a very good chance of being abused.

2:32:18Twitter spends literally hundreds of millions of dollars a year, literally hundreds of millions of dollars a year on R&D.

2:32:23It's astonishing. I don't know what exactly they count as R&D, but it's a big part of their expense.

2:32:28So they're working on it. But yep.

2:32:31Bottom line. Anyway, Glenn, thanks for being here. You've got a new book, new books to promote?

2:32:36I have, I have a thing to be, yeah, I got deep into the Slack well.

2:32:40Do you use Slack? I know that you work for Waddellun.

2:32:43I am a regular participant on one Slack.

2:32:46That's yeah, and it's slack you can get I have six slacks. I'm part of and some of them thankfully

2:32:51They're not very loud, but I like them all but it can get out of control

2:32:53So yeah, they're friends at uh, the take control books adam and tanya

2:32:56angst long time mac folks, um

2:32:58We were talking about like we started using it and it's like, uh, it's it's not quite like pokemon go

2:33:03That's not that addictive but boy it went from zero to you know millions really quickly

2:33:08And we were complaining amongst ourselves. Like how do we do this? What's this thing?

2:33:12we're like, oh, if we can't figure this out and we've used a thousand software packages in our

2:33:16life, perhaps it would be useful to do a book. So I did a book that's Take Control of Slack Basics,

2:33:22that is for people who are users who want to be able to master it because the online documentation,

2:33:27it's good. Our friend Matt Howey, he's, you know, involved in documentation, some aspect,

2:33:31the Metafilters founder, great guy. And now Slack's head of documentation or something.

2:33:36Is it head of documentation? Yeah. I don't know what he is. They're working on their side,

2:33:39but like they have a different— He writes for Slack.

2:33:41Yeah, they do a different thing.

2:33:43Like, online documentation is not what a take control book is about.

2:33:47They're experientially different things, as you know.

2:33:49You've worked on manuals, you've worked on other stuff.

2:33:51And so, I wrote a book that's divided into subjects using channels and messages

2:33:55and even how to do emoji and so forth.

2:33:57And the idea is you wake up one morning,

2:33:59so many people I know this happened to,

2:34:01you're 30 years old, 40, 50, and everyone says,

2:34:04"You get a message from the office,

2:34:06we're using Slack starting today."

2:34:07You're like, "Oh, God, not another piece of software."

2:34:09So the book is partly for people who had sort of Slack thrown at them and other,

2:34:13you know, also for people who want to master it without having to go through

2:34:17and sort of discover everything.

2:34:18There's a lot of stuff in there.

2:34:20And then I wrote a complimentary book.

2:34:21That's how to set up a Slack team, which is pretty straightforward in some ways.

2:34:25There's a lot of detail.

2:34:26Um, and so if you don't have an IT organization behind you, but you want to

2:34:29set it up, you want to run it well, you want to make sure people, uh, stay civil.

2:34:33And how do you keep things correct and keep people from doing, you know, stupid

2:34:37but also just set it up so it's as secure

2:34:40and sensible as you want.

2:34:41So I have this great URL.

2:34:43You can go to takecontrol.com, of course,

2:34:45takecontrolbooks, rather, .com, of course.

2:34:47But I have slackhelp.me.

2:34:49I got this URL and I'm very happy about it.

2:34:51- Slackhelp.me.

2:34:52I will absolutely put it in the show notes.

2:34:54I love, just by the way, I know it's probably not,

2:34:56maybe you did, I don't know, I know you know Adam,

2:34:59but I love the new cover design for the Take Control books.

2:35:02- Oh, it's so great.

2:35:03Took a lot of years to figure out what we didn't,

2:35:05like to this illustrative approach.

2:35:07And then the minute I saw the new designs

2:35:09when they were in progress, I'm like, oh, this is it.

2:35:11It's like a discovering, like you're cutting away

2:35:14at a block of marble and there's the sculpture inside.

2:35:16- I think it's probably no surprise

2:35:18that you can guess that you know my taste in graphic design.

2:35:21But well, one of the things that I really love

2:35:23about the new cover design is that putting

2:35:26where the author title is.

2:35:28The author title is in relatively small print,

2:35:30but the topic is a big print, which is right,

2:35:33because that's what take control books are about.

2:35:35They're very topical.

2:35:37They're just like, this is about Slack admin.

2:35:39So that's nice and big, real nice font,

2:35:42all caps, which I, of course, like.

2:35:44Then the author name is down below, real small,

2:35:46but because it's surrounded by white space,

2:35:48it is so prominent.

2:35:50And I love prominence in an author's name.

2:35:54Like, it's, 'cause that's, to me,

2:35:55is the whole point of the take control series,

2:35:57is that they're not just churned out.

2:35:58These are like the best writers in our racket

2:36:01who do these things.

2:36:02- It's fun too.

2:36:03eBooks after, I mean, I kind of misprint, but, uh, you know, faster turnaround.

2:36:07Yeah.

2:36:07Um, yeah.

2:36:08So Slack Slack's fun.

2:36:09It's it's fun.

2:36:10I know people that Jeff Carlson knows long-time Mac writer.

2:36:13He and his wife have a two person slot because it's free.

2:36:15You can use it free, you know, with some limits, but not, you know, 10,000 people.

2:36:19We have a Slack group.

2:36:20We set up, um, if people go to slack help that me, there's a link.

2:36:23Uh, it's a public Slack team that anyone can join who just wants to understand what

2:36:27Slack is like without having to set one up.

2:36:29So it's four, it's called Slack bits.

2:36:31and we're having discussions about Mac stuff, but also Slack help.

2:36:34And it's great, we got several hundred people joined who just, they wanted a place to go with no overhead.

2:36:38And, um, because it takes five minutes to set up a Slack team, but you have to set one up and you're dealing with it.

2:36:43So, um, I like, there's a lot more, so my very last point, a lot more public Slack teams starting,

2:36:49like this one for Mac admins, there's a bunch of them, I keep hearing about private ones that have hundreds or thousands of people.

2:36:54If Twitter isn't careful, some of the conversation is going to get drained off to private Slack groups where everything is controlled.

2:37:00That's a very interesting tie-in. And on the Slack that I'm on, that point has been made before,

2:37:04too. There's an awful lot of people. I've heard this from other people, but on the board I'm on,

2:37:08you probably know everybody who's there. It's a bunch of mutual friends. But it's a relatively

2:37:12small group, maybe like 15 of us. And a whole bunch of them have admitted that they personally

2:37:19use Twitter a lot less because of this Slack. I'd rather just communicate with this handful of good

2:37:26friends, people who I would like to go and have dinner and a drink with, then interact with the

2:37:31world at large on Twitter, just because of, you know, a couple of knuckleheads who make it unpleasant.

2:37:35It's safe, you know, you know, everybody's part of the group. And even if it's a public group,

2:37:40there's still an administrator who can kick anybody off. And Incomparable Podcast Network,

2:37:44we have an incomparable Slack with, I don't know, 50 or 60 people who are involved in the many,

2:37:47many, many podcasts. Jason Snell has now got up at the site. And that's where a lot of my

2:37:53conversation that I don't trust to do publicly anymore because there's too

2:37:57many jerks on Twitter who will respond to it I have those conversations with

2:38:00many the same people who I would have on Twitter I have not privately so sad but

2:38:04all right my thanks to you Glenn you've been so generous with your time what a

2:38:07great conversation this is a good episode I really liked it remember that

2:38:11URL if you do slack you got any interest in it go check out the books they're

2:38:14really worth it and slack definitely has a lot of power user stuff that you're

2:38:17gonna be like I didn't know I could do that at slack help dot me and you'll find

2:38:22links to both books. My thanks to our sponsors. We've got Casper where you can

2:38:26go to buy a mattress and we've got Fracture where you can print out your

2:38:29photos and Global Delights Boom which will make the audio on your Mac sound a

2:38:36lot better. So my thanks to them.