Podcast Search

The Talk Show

159: ‘Phil Z’ With Marco Arment

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Here's what I got for us to talk about.

0:00:01WWDC.

0:00:03(laughs)

0:00:04The live talk show at WWDC.

0:00:07Mac OS, or what's it called?

0:00:09Mac OS.

0:00:10Mac OS 10.12.

0:00:11- I've lost track.

0:00:12- iOS 10.

0:00:13Watch OS 3.

0:00:15Taking the headphone jack off the iPhone.

0:00:17Covering your laptop cameras with tape.

0:00:21Podcast ads, the future of podcasting and mid-roll.

0:00:24Buying Stitcher.

0:00:25And then at the end we can talk about cars

0:00:28talk about the shitty Shifter design that led to the guy from Star Trek stuff. So let's

0:00:37get started. WWDC. We don't have to talk about the actual announcements.

0:00:40Nah, everyone's heard about those already. I want to talk about your show.

0:00:45Alright.

0:00:46Because, you know, I have some to say about it and you probably won't be saying all

0:00:51this so I will say it because you won't. So, number one is, you know, first of all,

0:00:57I greatly enjoyed it.

0:00:58You began the show by posing the question of like,

0:01:03you know, you had Phil on last year, how do you top that?

0:01:05You know, there's only so far you can go up the chain

0:01:08to top having Phil on the show.

0:01:10And you ended up having Phil and Craig on the show this year

0:01:16and I put forth now this theory that that is the top,

0:01:19that is the best you can do for that show in that week.

0:01:23- I agree with that.

0:01:24I think that's actually probably true.

0:01:26because, and this is, I know that it,

0:01:29I think I successfully kept it secret, number one.

0:01:31I don't know what the people were whispering

0:01:33out in the audience.

0:01:34- I was guessing Tim, but I had no idea.

0:01:36- Yeah, Tim, that was by far the most common guess,

0:01:39that like, and people were,

0:01:41and people were bugging me like that they,

0:01:42not bugging me, I shouldn't say that.

0:01:43Everybody who come up and said hi to me at WWDC,

0:01:45I always enjoy it, and sometimes I see people on Twitter

0:01:48who say, "Hey, I saw you somewhere,

0:01:49"and I thought, ah, I won't bother you."

0:01:51No, just come say hi, I like to say hi to people,

0:01:53it's great, it's one of my favorite parts of WWDC.

0:01:55And it was really weird for me in the early years because it does not come naturally to

0:02:00me.

0:02:01But I've learned over the years how to make those things go pretty well.

0:02:08Pretty much what I did was the one year at South by Southwest I was hanging out.

0:02:10It was the year Merlin and I spoke together at South by.

0:02:13And I just noticed that when people would come up to us, whether they knew Merlin, Merlin

0:02:19is amazing.

0:02:20He's absolutely amazing when someone comes up and says, "Hey, are you Merlin, man?"

0:02:24obviously never met them. They're a fan. He's so good at it. And I just suddenly

0:02:27went into like, "I'm just gonna copy his moves and just do what he does." And it's

0:02:35gotten a lot better. So anyway, people would come up to you. They'd say blah blah blah.

0:02:37But then they'd say, "Who's gonna be on your show?" And I would just say, I started

0:02:40saying to them, "You don't really want me to tell you, right? I mean, you want to be

0:02:43surprised." Yeah, and like you and you know, I don't know what the listeners think,

0:02:47but like, you know, so you and I are friends. I didn't know either last year

0:02:50or this year. Like, you don't even tell your friends. Like, you don't, as far as I

0:02:53know the only people you tell are like Amy and Paul who are working the event

0:02:56with you like you don't tell anybody I didn't tell Paul Amy did and Caleb

0:03:04Sexton knew as of like three or four in the afternoon of the day and I did tell

0:03:10Caleb that you know to prepare three lav mics so he knew there would be two to

0:03:15two guests but no I did not tell anybody because that's how you keep a secret how

0:03:19How do you keep a secret? It's easy. Don't tell anybody. I swear to God, it is the...

0:03:25It sounds stupid, but most people don't do that.

0:03:31Amy tells me a great story. I'm going to butcher this in some way. But when she was in law

0:03:36school, she had a criminal defense course that was taught by a former FBI agent. And

0:03:45He told them, he said, "You want to know how to get away with a murder?

0:03:48It's actually very easy.

0:03:50Don't leave any evidence.

0:03:53Don't leave any evidence behind.

0:03:55Don't tell anyone what you did, and don't ever do it again, and you'll get away with

0:04:01it."

0:04:02AARON LINDQUIST >> Useful information for law students.

0:04:04JEFF ZELENY >> Most murderers do not get away with it because most murderers either leave

0:04:08something behind or, most commonly, they tell somebody.

0:04:12It's very, very easy.

0:04:14I didn't murder anybody, but I did not tell anybody who was going to be on the show.

0:04:17And I agree with your assessment that the duo of Phil and Craig is, I think, unbeatable.

0:04:23Tim Cook would be a bigger get.

0:04:26Johnny Ive would be a big get.

0:04:28But I don't think that the combination of my interviewing skills combined with their

0:04:34personalities I don't think would be as enjoyable.

0:04:37Well, especially in this setting, too.

0:04:40You are there and you want to talk about what was just said in the keynote.

0:04:43seen interviews of Tim, Tim doesn't really stray from the talking points.

0:04:46He's very well prepared, very well controlled, and he says what he wants to

0:04:50say and nothing more. And what you really want at the BBC is, and in the

0:04:55talk show, is like the live talk show is still your show. It's still the talk show

0:05:00and you know the the mood of it takes on what you set there. So it really it's

0:05:06kind of like you know like you like you say that this is the director's

0:05:09commentary for Daring Fireball. You know when you have these Apple execs on

0:05:12on your show, which I love that now two years in,

0:05:16it just has become like, oh, this is just what you do now.

0:05:18Last year it was like, holy crap,

0:05:19this year it's like, oh yeah, again, okay.

0:05:21But when you have them on the show,

0:05:24it kind of becomes the director's commentary for WWDC.

0:05:29'Cause it is like, mood-wise, it's like the closest

0:05:32that any of us will ever get to sitting down

0:05:35and having a beer with Apple executives.

0:05:37And I think Phil and Craig not only have

0:05:41very good personalities that mesh well with that.

0:05:43But also like topic wise at WWDC,

0:05:47if there's any two Apple execs you can pick

0:05:49to ask questions to that are gonna be interesting

0:05:52and relevant to developers after having heard

0:05:54that keynote that day, it's gonna be those two.

0:05:56Because you have Phil who now runs the entire app store,

0:05:59policy wise at least, he runs the whole app store

0:06:01and then he's also kind of like,

0:06:04I don't know what his role is unofficially

0:06:07but it seems like he is in many ways

0:06:10like heavily involved or possibly the head of a lot of product decisions. Yeah,

0:06:15I've always said, and I mean, just maybe I should have asked. I've always had this

0:06:19on my list. What would you say you do here? Well, I have had that, and I've run

0:06:24out of time. I've both ears, you know, it's better that way, but I have more stuff

0:06:28to talk to them about than I have time to ask them. And I tend to favor,

0:06:34"Hey, let's fill this up with questions from the keynote," because I think it's

0:06:39that's more relevant to now than forever.

0:06:42But I have ideas, I go into it with a couple ideas

0:06:45for things to talk about just in case the keynote

0:06:47doesn't really have a lot of stuff.

0:06:49But I've always said, and from my perspective on the outside,

0:06:52the best way to understand Schiller's role at Apple

0:06:55would be to take the word marketing out of his name

0:06:57and edit title and edit senior vice president of product.

0:07:01'Cause the marketing is in and of itself,

0:07:03it's part of the product, it's not a separate thing,

0:07:06it's not like the products are developed

0:07:07and then Schiller's group figures out how to advertise them or what pictures to take

0:07:11to put on the box. It's all of a piece. That's the type of marketing that gives, especially

0:07:17engineers who are analytical, and they roll their eyes when they think about marketing.

0:07:22Bad marketing is when you start with a bad product and somebody is told, "Here's a kind

0:07:26of crappy product or a thing with a bunch of problems. Figure out a way to sell it."

0:07:29Well, the marketer still has to do their job, but whereas if you have a good product, you

0:07:35just let the product speak for yourself and figure out how do we let the product speak

0:07:38for itself. And I think that's ideally what, you know, at their best, that's how Apple's

0:07:43marketing works.

0:07:44And it seems too like...

0:07:45He is intimately familiar with all of their products.

0:07:48Oh, clearly. And also, and you know, having Craig there too, like, it's amazing because,

0:07:53you know, you think of like, you know, what is an executive? And you think of like, what

0:07:57kind of person is it? What do they know? What kind of involvement do they have? And to have

0:08:00the kind of incredibly deep knowledge that these two executives have about

0:08:05what they apparently oversee with pillar you know and what and what Craig does

0:08:09officially oversee you know like Craig was throwing out deep technical

0:08:13implementation details and and I know from talking to people in the company

0:08:17that that's genuine like Craig is really a genuine like hardcore engineer and

0:08:22he's really he really knows his stuff and he gets deeply involved in it and and

0:08:27is, but at the same time is a really good leader. I mean, I don't think I've met

0:08:31anybody who has worked under Craig or anywhere near Craig and has a single bad thing to say

0:08:36about the experience of working with him. I mean, he seems incredibly good at his job

0:08:42and very well suited to that leadership role, but also, like Phil, having this incredibly

0:08:47deep knowledge of the product and the decisions. And to have that there, this is why I think

0:08:53this is better than having Tim for your show.

0:08:55Because not only, not only like I think you have,

0:08:57you'd have a better personality mesh with these guys,

0:09:01but also I think, you know,

0:09:03Tim doesn't take that kind of deep knowledge

0:09:07of like the little details of how these things

0:09:09are engineered or product decisions like,

0:09:11and 'cause I think Tim kind of knows

0:09:13that he's not like ahead of product the way Steve was,

0:09:16and so he has delegated that to some of the other SVPs,

0:09:20and you know, different combinations.

0:09:22And honestly, I think it's a little bit vague as to what the combination is right now, and that might be a bit of a problem.

0:09:25But overall, you know, it's, you know, Tim is not really a product person, and Phil very clearly is.

0:09:33And honestly, I mean, from just my point of view, I am very happy you had those two people on.

0:09:39And I would say Phil and Craig are my favorite Apple executives.

0:09:43And I think the ones that most closely align with my priorities, it seems.

0:09:50Yeah, I think that's fair to say. So I don't know why I'm screwed for next year.

0:09:54Yeah, well just have them on again or have moles. That's it. Those are your

0:09:57choices.

0:09:57I think Eddie, Eddie Q, uh, when he was on this show with Craig was good and I

0:10:01think he would be good, but his personality wise, uh,

0:10:06but his domain isn't a good fit,

0:10:09especially for the WWDC show.

0:10:11If I had something where I did like a quarterly show or a twice a year show and

0:10:16like maybe if I did a live show after the September, you know,

0:10:20iPhone event or something like that.

0:10:22Eddy Cue might be good then,

0:10:24but I feel like WWDC in particular,

0:10:26when the news is supposed to,

0:10:28and in late, most years recently really is,

0:10:31mostly about software, it's, you know,

0:10:34there's, it wouldn't really make any sense

0:10:37just to have him on because it's not his domain.

0:10:41- Yeah, also, I would also say like,

0:10:44one of the greatest things we saw

0:10:45at the live talk show this year

0:10:47is that we on the outside got to see,

0:10:51in a very, very rare circumstance,

0:10:53we got to see two Apple SVPs interacting with each other.

0:10:58And if you think about it,

0:10:59what other chances do we ever have to see that?

0:11:02And from what I understand,

0:11:04again, talking to some people inside the company,

0:11:06even most people who work in the company

0:11:08rarely see two SVPs in the same room,

0:11:11'cause usually you're presenting to at most one of them.

0:11:14So to see two execs who have clearly worked together

0:11:18for a very long time and know each other really well

0:11:21and clearly respect each other very much,

0:11:23who are also good in all these other ways,

0:11:25it really brought a lot of amazing humanity

0:11:28and just insight into just who these people actually are.

0:11:31And this is something that you're not gonna get

0:11:34in a carefully scripted keynote

0:11:36or any kind of carefully planned event.

0:11:38And this is why I love this show so much,

0:11:40because you get to do this

0:11:41and you get to reveal this to the world,

0:11:44and you do it in a way that, because it's a podcast,

0:11:49I love podcasting because if you write something

0:11:52on a blog or on a news site,

0:11:54that spreads all over the place really quickly

0:11:56if there's anything about it that's controversial

0:11:57or inflammatory or anything else.

0:11:59Believe me, I know that better than a lot of people.

0:12:02And that can often be prohibitive

0:12:04to encouraging people to continue writing.

0:12:07With a podcast, it seems like just because podcasts,

0:12:11they just don't really spread like wildfire

0:12:13the way text spreads.

0:12:15You can quote someone's post or paraphrase someone's post,

0:12:19stick an inflammatory headline on it

0:12:20and it just spreads like wildfire.

0:12:23Podcasts, that just doesn't happen.

0:12:25I thought last year when you had Phil on,

0:12:28which, let's anybody forget,

0:12:29that was remarkable at the time,

0:12:31I thought that was gonna be literally world news.

0:12:35I thought it was gonna be reported on CNN

0:12:38that this happened and everything that was said

0:12:40would have been scrutinized and reported on

0:12:43just as much as an Apple press release would have.

0:12:46And instead, there was one MacRumors article about it.

0:12:49It was almost nothing, almost nothing happened.

0:12:51And then the same thing happened this year,

0:12:53where again, it's like now you have two Apple executives.

0:12:55Now you should have CNN and the New York Times

0:12:57reporting on it, double the coverage.

0:12:59And again, you had one MacRumors article

0:13:01and basically nothing else.

0:13:03- Yeah, I thought the same thing last year.

0:13:05Not necessarily that I was disappointed, I was just curious.

0:13:09And I think one measure of it would be tech meme.

0:13:14And it's like, I write blog posts that get more attention

0:13:17on tech meme than this.

0:13:20The good thing is that I found with my experience,

0:13:23like I've been writing a lot less in part because

0:13:27of this problem of just like any slip up

0:13:30and it spreads like wildfire.

0:13:32And in podcasting, that just doesn't happen.

0:13:34But also because of that effect, the podcasting kind of--

0:13:38and because of the conversational nature of it just being more casual, podcasting is kind

0:13:44of like a safe space. And you can go on a podcast, you can talk off script and answer

0:13:52questions that you didn't get in advance or that were unplanned or whatever. You can accept

0:13:56that gig because it really isn't dangerous. People give you the benefit of the doubt,

0:14:01it doesn't really spread like wildfire if you screw something up in some kind of minor

0:14:05way. It's a conversational context, so it doesn't seem as official or as like, you

0:14:09know, coded in stone. And I feel like, you know, that's, again, that's something that

0:14:13Apple never gets in any kind of public way. So it's, and for the listeners or the attendees

0:14:20of the live show, it's almost like being led into like an exclusive club. Like, you

0:14:25know, it's like, it's a club of obscurity, basically. Like, you know, we get to be here

0:14:30and listen to this and get to know these people

0:14:33and get these great insights into things,

0:14:36but it's not a big problem for them

0:14:39and they don't get in trouble for things they say.

0:14:42It's kind of amazing.

0:14:43- I was thinking about what you said before

0:14:46about how we don't get to see Apple's executives

0:14:49interact with each other in a personal way.

0:14:52And one evidence of proof of that,

0:14:53and again, I often bring up Scott Forstall.

0:14:57And I have met him and I liked him, you know, like backstage after a keynote.

0:15:02And I think he did fantastic work for the company.

0:15:05And so, you know, I bring him up not to dump on him because I really think the

0:15:09guy did a great job. But, famously, I mean, it was, you know,

0:15:15he did not get along well with the rest of the

0:15:17leadership team. I mean, the press release announcing his,

0:15:20I forget what they called it, but, you know, that he was no longer...

0:15:25He was quit fired.

0:15:26Well, his promotion to Tim Cook's assistant or whatever, special advisor.

0:15:33That the title of the press release was something about enabling collaboration or something like

0:15:41that. It was very clear. And my sense since that, but on stage you'd never know it. Shiller to

0:15:50Forrestal handing off in a keynote, and here to tell you all about it is Senior Vice President

0:15:56Scott Forrestal, is exactly the same as his interaction with Federighi now, because they're

0:16:04pros. They're total pros. They're polished. From the outside, you'd never have any idea

0:16:09whether there was a difference, whereas on stage, with those two, you could tell that

0:16:13they like each other.

0:16:14Yeah, totally.

0:16:15The way they razzed each other, especially Phil Razzing, Federighi.

0:16:18Oh, yeah.

0:16:19Yeah, I thought it went pretty well.

0:16:22And you know me, I'm not gonna sit here and say how good my show was, but...

0:16:25Yeah, I will.

0:16:26It was really good.

0:16:27So we did.

0:16:28I love how uncomfortable this makes you.

0:16:30It does.

0:16:31It really does.

0:16:32Let's talk about the problems with the show.

0:16:33We had audio problems.

0:16:34We had this feedback at the beginning.

0:16:37And anybody who's watching the video, watch the video, the recorded one on Vimeo or listen

0:16:42to the podcast.

0:16:43You won't hear it.

0:16:44I don't know.

0:16:45I don't think Caleb had to clean that up.

0:16:48I don't think he had to remove it.

0:16:49I think that the audio, like the mics didn't pick it up.

0:16:52But what happened, and it wasn't Caleb's fault,

0:16:56it was during the, and they definitely did a sound check,

0:17:00but Caleb let the house sound guy at Mezzanine,

0:17:05who was new, he wasn't the same guy as last year,

0:17:07talk him out of a, I don't know what, I don't even know,

0:17:10I didn't wanna know what the details were,

0:17:12but Caleb let the guy talk him out of something

0:17:14against Caleb's better judgment,

0:17:16and then the fix, five or 10 minutes into the show,

0:17:19was exactly what Caleb wanted to do at the outset.

0:17:23It violates the number one rule of sound equipment, which is get it working and then don't touch

0:17:27anything.

0:17:28Yeah, I'm not sure where that went wrong, but it did get straightened out.

0:17:31It wasn't too bad.

0:17:35If anybody watched the video and I look a little bit like I'm looking around, it was

0:17:40because of the feedback.

0:17:43But you won't hear it when you watch on the show.

0:17:47The other thing I think that I wonder how it affects the immediate, "Holy shit, these

0:17:51two guys are on Gruber's show," is that the show doesn't come out right away.

0:17:56This year it didn't come out till Friday, so I feel like on my list for what can I fix

0:18:00for next year is figure out who do I have to pay, what do I have to do to get the video

0:18:04out hopefully like 24 hours.

0:18:06Well, on the other hand though, why?

0:18:09If the show doesn't make national news and they don't get in trouble for anything they

0:18:14then that makes it easier to get them back. The main reason to turn to get the

0:18:20turnaround quicker is just to make people who want to watch it happier. I

0:18:23don't think it would have... I don't think it would really make a big difference in

0:18:27terms of publicity. The main reason is that I know just from my tweets and the

0:18:32emails that people were like chomping at the bit to get it. And I would be too if

0:18:36there were two of me and one who does the show and the other one who just

0:18:38listens to the show and really likes it. I would have been too if I couldn't get

0:18:42to the live show. You know what you should do? You should hire the Apple

0:18:46W2C video team because they get stuff out the next morning. I know, that's

0:18:50amazing. They've really upped that. It's really incredible how quickly

0:18:55they get it out. Yeah. The live stream broke this year. Last year it stayed up,

0:18:59but this year it broke. I would suggest maybe doing an audio only live stream

0:19:03because it's, I mean, unless you go to something like YouTube live, which should

0:19:06also be probably an easier way to do it, but audio is a lot easier to scale up.

0:19:11And we did that two years ago when you and your ATP pals were the guest.

0:19:17That's how I know that.

0:19:19Because we were streaming it off of my iPad in the back on Verizon and it was fine.

0:19:25Absolutely true.

0:19:28The thing I love about that, I don't know if it helped you because then you wouldn't

0:19:32be nervous, it gave you something to do, or if it just made you even more nervous because

0:19:38instead of thinking about the show, you were fiddling with it.

0:19:40But the back story on that was that literally,

0:19:44right up until we opened the doors to let people in,

0:19:47you were back there.

0:19:48And we weren't planning it.

0:19:49You were just like, well, why don't we livestream it?

0:19:50I can do it.

0:19:51And you just took out your iPad and were plugging it

0:19:54into the board.

0:19:56It was worse than that.

0:19:57You said, oh, by the way, we don't

0:19:58have a way to record this.

0:20:00So I was providing the only recording of it

0:20:03and also the livestream.

0:20:04That was a poorly planned show.

0:20:06Poorly planned show.

0:20:08That's funny that we've gone from there to here

0:20:10in two years, I do keep pretty good notes

0:20:12about what to improve for the next year.

0:20:15- No, I'd say you now have a pretty good,

0:20:19you have the Kings worked out,

0:20:20and I would say just repeat this,

0:20:22and maybe change the way you stream the video,

0:20:24and that's about it.

0:20:25- Yeah.

0:20:26Seemed like people had a good time.

0:20:29- Yeah, oh yeah, it was good, it was a good event,

0:20:31and yeah, again, I mean, you won't say it, but I will.

0:20:35It was great, and you should definitely

0:20:38keep doing it if you can.

0:20:39Yeah, I'll see what I can do, hopefully.

0:20:41I thought it went well.

0:20:42How about I take a break right here

0:20:45and I thank our first sponsor.

0:20:48And our first sponsor this week is Wealthfront.

0:20:52Wealthfront is an automated investment service

0:20:55with over $3 billion in client assets under management.

0:20:59In plain English, they make it easy for anybody

0:21:02to get access to a sophisticated,

0:21:03diversified long-term investment portfolio

0:21:07without high fees and in fact with very low fees

0:21:09and without high account minimums.

0:21:13Historically, you needed to invest at least a million bucks

0:21:16to get the attention of a quality financial advisor

0:21:18or wealth management professional.

0:21:20And then you have to pay at least 1% per year

0:21:23in management fees.

0:21:24Wealthfront is nothing like that.

0:21:25They're completely free for accounts under $10,000.

0:21:29You can get started with just like a couple hundred bucks.

0:21:32And in fact, they say that's how most

0:21:33of their customers start.

0:21:34They just put a couple hundred bucks in

0:21:36just to see how it works, sign up, look at the interface,

0:21:40and then once they get to like it and say,

0:21:42"Okay, this is good, I trust this,"

0:21:44then put in the quote unquote real money,

0:21:46which could be anything.

0:21:47They charge an advisory fee of just 0.25% per year,

0:21:53and that's only on the assets above $10,000.

0:21:56And if you use this code, wealthfront.com/thetalkshow,

0:22:00that goes to $15,000, and you get $5,000 free management

0:22:06for every friend you invite.

0:22:07So if you send your code to your brother-in-law

0:22:10and a couple other people, you can get 10, 20, 25,

0:22:15however many extra thousand dollars managed for free.

0:22:20And then even then, you only pay 0.25% above that

0:22:24going forward.

0:22:25They have all sorts of stuff.

0:22:28It's a long-term investment thing.

0:22:30This is the total opposite of day trading.

0:22:33This is a place where you put money in for the long run

0:22:36and they have so many options,

0:22:38so many different types of accounts.

0:22:39I cannot possibly go over them

0:22:41in the length of a podcast ad.

0:22:43Just go to their website and check them out.

0:22:47Really smart way to invest your money

0:22:49for the long run Wealthfront,

0:22:51and the URL is wealthfront.com/thetalkshow.

0:22:56Anything else on the live show?

0:23:01I feel like that covers it.

0:23:02Anyway, I had a good time.

0:23:03I have not watched it.

0:23:04I can't bring myself to watch it yet.

0:23:06I watched last year's at some point,

0:23:07but I didn't watch this year's yet.

0:23:09So maybe I should have watched it

0:23:11before we started talking about it here.

0:23:13- I listened to it again.

0:23:14- macOS, here's my thing about macOS.

0:23:18I can't believe that they changed the name to macOS,

0:23:21but kept the 10.12 version numbering.

0:23:25What is that 10 now?

0:23:26Why, is this 10 forever?

0:23:28- Well, you know, I think it's a lot like,

0:23:30like, you know, like the dumb Windows kernel version thing

0:23:32where Windows 2000 was NT 5.0, I think,

0:23:36and then XP was 5.1, and it stayed at five for a while.

0:23:40Just the numbers doesn't mean anything

0:23:42relative to the marketing name and the marketing sequence.

0:23:47So I think that it just doesn't really matter.

0:23:49I'm kind of surprised, though,

0:23:50that they kept the California names,

0:23:52and I'm kind of surprised they didn't just call this

0:23:54Mac OS 12.

0:23:55It seemed like even though people would have made fun

0:23:57of them, oh, you skipped 11,

0:23:58I think that would have made a lot more sense

0:24:00to just say, all right, this is now Mac OS 12,

0:24:02and then next year Mac OS 13 or whatever.

0:24:03But I guess those numbers don't scale very well.

0:24:06Nobody wants like Mac OS 17, I don't know.

0:24:08- It did seem weird that they give,

0:24:11I think they could have done both though.

0:24:12They could have called it Mac OS 12 Sierra.

0:24:15- Yeah, maybe, that's a lot of tokens.

0:24:17- I don't know why.

0:24:18Why does Mac OS get a code name and iOS doesn't?

0:24:21I don't get that.

0:24:23- Well, and maybe because of the high numbering problem,

0:24:26like once you get into the teens,

0:24:27it kind of is less cool sounding.

0:24:30maybe they're going to transition iOS

0:24:32onto a code name system.

0:24:33And maybe they would unify the code.

0:24:35Maybe they would say, you know,

0:24:36this year we have iOS Sierra and Mac OS Sierra.

0:24:39I don't know.

0:24:40There's a lot of things they could do there,

0:24:41but I do think the numbers are really nice

0:24:43and clean and simple now because they're relatively low.

0:24:46But once you get into the teens and stuff, it's less cool.

0:24:50- Anything else?

0:24:54WatchOS 3.

0:24:55- I love that.

0:24:56I love that it's all we can talk about about Mac OS,

0:24:58the name.

0:25:00Well, have you used it yet?

0:25:01I actually have.

0:25:02I actually have it on a MacBook Pro downstairs.

0:25:05And it's exactly the sort of thing I would like--

0:25:11I'd like to see Apple do, which is it doesn't feel--

0:25:15you could easily convince me that it wasn't even

0:25:17a new version of Mac OS X. And it's like, oh, yeah, yeah,

0:25:20look, that looks a little different.

0:25:21They've changed a little bit here and there.

0:25:23But it is such a minor refinement

0:25:26in terms of everything I'm used to.

0:25:28and then they've just added some nice new features.

0:25:31- Yeah, and I'm happy with that too.

0:25:32I mean, from a developer's point of view,

0:25:34I would love to see some modernization of AppKit

0:25:38and possibly some kind of cross-platform AppKit,

0:25:40UIKit kind of hybrid.

0:25:42So I basically wouldn't have to learn AppKit.

0:25:45(laughs)

0:25:47But I understand also why that's kind of a big job

0:25:50and probably not worth doing necessarily.

0:25:53- Ah, that's a good question. - Or maybe waiting until,

0:25:56presumably in the future,

0:25:57there's gonna be some kind of rewrite or refactoring

0:26:01of a lot of the frameworks to better optimize for Swift.

0:26:04And beyond just renaming.

0:26:07Right now they've basically renamed them

0:26:08when you're using them from Swift and that's about it.

0:26:10But there's more that you could do there

0:26:13to really optimize these things for Swift.

0:26:15So maybe down the road they're planning on

0:26:18a bigger change to the frameworks

0:26:20and maybe they would unify them then.

0:26:21'Cause as you talk about it often,

0:26:23Apple's a very patient company.

0:26:25And when it comes to long-term technical decisions

0:26:27like this, they're willing to wait five, 10 years

0:26:30to do what they need to do if they think

0:26:32it'll be better later to do it then.

0:26:34So I think it would be interesting to see

0:26:37if they ever do tackle this problem

0:26:38or if they just kinda consider, you know,

0:26:40AppKit's the right tool for this job

0:26:41and UIKit's the right tool for that job,

0:26:43which there's some basis for that.

0:26:45Not 100%, but there's some basis for that.

0:26:47And maybe they just kinda consider the Mac

0:26:48to be kind of like a completed platform.

0:26:51We don't need to do much on this anymore.

0:26:53I don't know.

0:26:54- Yeah, sort of like the way I treat Markdown.

0:26:56- Yeah, right.

0:26:57- I mean, no joke.

0:26:58I mean, it's seriously like, you know,

0:27:00it is what it is, you know, move on with the other stuff.

0:27:02Maybe, I don't know.

0:27:03I think you're right though that if they do do it,

0:27:05it would probably coincide

0:27:06with a swiftification of frameworks.

0:27:10- Right, or if all these rumblers I keep hearing about,

0:27:12they're like being like a single unified OS

0:27:14coming down the road with new everything,

0:27:17you know, for the car and God knows what else, you know,

0:27:19then if that is actually true

0:27:22and coming in the next five years,

0:27:25then that would be the time to do it.

0:27:27- Yeah, I don't know.

0:27:29- I don't give that rumor a lot of weight, honestly,

0:27:31because it seems really grand, and I don't know.

0:27:35- It just seems to me, like, when I study it

0:27:37and think about it, and it's like,

0:27:38I'm trying to think about what to write

0:27:40about the Mac OS beta.

0:27:42I keep thinking about something Guy English,

0:27:45friend of the show Guy English, said to me

0:27:47last week when I was asking just friends,

0:27:51I didn't say who, I just said, hey, let's just say if I got to interview somebody, interesting.

0:27:56What are some questions?

0:27:57Do you guys have any questions that you wish I would ask?

0:27:59And Guy had pointed out that when Steve Jobs introduced the Mac OS X 10.0 back in 2001,

0:28:09he framed it as saying, this is the operating system for the next 15 years.

0:28:14Well, that was 15 years ago.

0:28:19And I think it's almost, you know, he was trying to say this is the operating system for the, you know, the long term for Apple.

0:28:25This is something that Apple can really, so what, Apple was, what, they're 40 years old now, so they were a 25 year old company then.

0:28:31This is, you know, it was as far away from the original Mac as we are today.

0:28:38I think, if anything, in hindsight, Jobs clearly undersold the longevity of the platform.

0:28:44that's the thing I look at when I look at Mac OS 10.12 is that this doesn't feel

0:28:47like an operating system on its last legs. This feels like an operating system

0:28:51that is still in its prime and doing it's exactly what it wants to be and

0:28:55really doesn't need anything major. I mean it could and it's someday something

0:29:01like a you know your example about doing a lot of UI kitification to AppKit or

0:29:08bringing UIKit to Mac OS 10 in some way to sit there alongside AppKit or who

0:29:13Who knows?

0:29:14There are major changes someday,

0:29:16but at the moment it's really just fine

0:29:18and does its job very well.

0:29:20And the way I put it a couple years ago,

0:29:21and it's funny too because I said something

0:29:24about the next five years,

0:29:25but it was like five years ago.

0:29:27So I undersold it as much five years ago as Jobs did, 15,

0:29:31was that the heaviness of the Mac, conceptually,

0:29:35that it's so, you can have so many windows open

0:29:38and you can go so deep and you have all these options

0:29:40like services and control, right-clicking

0:29:43and getting these contextual menus,

0:29:45and even just the existence of the menu bar.

0:29:47That heaviness is what lets iOS remain so lightweight.

0:29:52That you couldn't have it like the iPad

0:29:55and make it as simple as it is

0:29:57without having a platform to go with it

0:30:00that is as complicated as the Mac.

0:30:02- I mean, the downside of that logic though,

0:30:06which I think is mostly sound,

0:30:08but the downside of that is that kind of assumes

0:30:11that they will be both maintained over time

0:30:14and will both succeed over time.

0:30:16And I'm not sure that's a safe assumption to make.

0:30:20- I wonder if it doesn't also conversely tie into

0:30:23the fact that there's some productivity tasks

0:30:28that just still aren't that great to do on an iPad.

0:30:31You know, that it works both ways.

0:30:34That it's like, they just haven't been,

0:30:38they haven't felt forced to enable the iPad

0:30:40to be good at X, because yeah, you could just use

0:30:43your MacBook for that.

0:30:45- Well, but also, as they have added more productivity

0:30:49features to iOS, and especially to the iPad,

0:30:52you're kind of seeing them basically try to address

0:30:54the same problems, like basically trying to make it

0:30:56closer to a Mac kind of environment.

0:30:58So now you have things like a basic form of windowing,

0:31:01and multiple windows on screen.

0:31:03You have these document pickers that are a simplified view

0:31:07of a file system that are still files.

0:31:09They're having to solve the same problems

0:31:13and oftentimes the solutions they come up with

0:31:16are actually not substantially better than the solutions

0:31:19that the PC and Mac world figured out years ago.

0:31:22Sometimes they are, but it seems like

0:31:25they're both kind of aiming for the same thing

0:31:28where they try to make Mac OS easier to use

0:31:31and more iOS-like in ways.

0:31:33At the same time, they're trying to make iOS

0:31:36more productive and more suited for pro use.

0:31:39and by doing that they're kind of making iOS

0:31:41a little more Mac-like in these certain areas.

0:31:44And I'm not sure either effort

0:31:47is a huge success necessarily.

0:31:49I think the effort to proify iOS

0:31:54is probably more successful

0:31:55than the effort to iOSify the Mac.

0:31:58- I think that if you think about it,

0:31:59I can't think of anything this year

0:32:00that really was iOSification of the Mac.

0:32:03I feel like maybe they're done with that,

0:32:05and they've done enough of it that they wanted to,

0:32:09and now they're just letting the Mac be the Mac.

0:32:10I mean, maybe I'm overlooking something,

0:32:13but I can't think of anything.

0:32:15- No, you might be right.

0:32:16I mean, maybe it does seem like they've kind of

0:32:19figured out that the Mac doesn't need to be iOS,

0:32:22that it can stand on its own.

0:32:24Maybe they've gained more confidence in it

0:32:26as being its own thing.

0:32:27- Yeah, I can't think of anything.

0:32:30I mean, there are features that are obviously

0:32:31in parallel with iOS,

0:32:34like the fancy new messages, animations,

0:32:37and stuff like that.

0:32:38But that's not really iOS-ifying the Mac,

0:32:40that's just getting the same stuff at the same time.

0:32:43- Yeah, but ultimately, in the long haul,

0:32:47I think having iOS be this juggernaut

0:32:50that is most of the market for Apple,

0:32:53it will hurt the Mac, it will cost the Mac,

0:32:55because you have situations,

0:32:57like Messages apps are a great example of this,

0:32:59where you can now have, until iOS 10,

0:33:04iMessage worked basically the same way

0:33:07on all three platforms, iPad, iPhone, Mac.

0:33:10It worked the same way,

0:33:11it had the same capabilities roughly.

0:33:13With the new version of Messages,

0:33:14now you're gonna have this large amount of functionality,

0:33:17especially if the app thing takes off,

0:33:19which other Messages services have had apps

0:33:22that have taken off, so they probably will.

0:33:24And Apple's pretty good at apps and making apps take off,

0:33:27as long as you weren't talking about the TV.

0:33:29So by having this big app environment

0:33:33that's going to take off on iOS,

0:33:35and having almost none of it available on the Mac,

0:33:38and having no easy technical bridge there

0:33:42because the Mac is not UIKit and is not iOS

0:33:46and is not running all these same frameworks

0:33:47and does not have the same kind of extension system

0:33:49and binary support and everything else,

0:33:51I suspect that the Mac is gonna have some trouble

0:33:54in the next few years if this stuff takes off

0:33:56because it's going to feel even more

0:33:59like a second-class citizen than it does now.

0:34:04I don't know, maybe. I mean, and that does tie in. This is a good, it's a good segue, I think,

0:34:08because it does tie into, I can't believe I almost forgot to bring this up, is I have one major

0:34:14regret from the live show. There was one question from my list. Like I said, there were a bunch that

0:34:19I didn't get to that were fine, that were just sort of like, "Hey, if we have time, I'll get to

0:34:22these, and if not," but there was one on that I had above the line of definitely want to ask

0:34:27that I didn't get to, and it was on the tip of my tongue at one point, but it didn't seem

0:34:34like the right moment and then after that it was like out of my mind and I'd forgotten it.

0:34:38And the question would have been for Phil and it would have been more or less along the lines of

0:34:43the Mac Pro hasn't been updated in over 900 days. I think as of the showtime it was 908 days.

0:34:50And the Mac Mini hasn't been updated in over 600 days. And why do you hate pro customers?

0:35:00And but it you know insert audience laughter there, but the true thing is I know for a fact talking to

0:35:08developer friends and just reading email from from DF the Daring Fireball audience which has

0:35:17in addition to developers I definitely have a lot of readers and listeners who are professionals in

0:35:22video and photography and other things where you they want a new Mac Pro and they the concern is

0:35:28is palpable that they worry that Apple's phenomenal success

0:35:33selling consumer products has left them disinterested

0:35:39in professional products.

0:35:41- Yeah, and I think that concern is warranted

0:35:43based on a lot of the stuff that's happened

0:35:44over the last few years.

0:35:45Like a lot of, yeah, I mean, first of all,

0:35:46losing things like Aperture and then seeing,

0:35:50even the Final Cut transition to Final Cut,

0:35:53now is that one X or 10?

0:35:54I honestly don't know.

0:35:56- I don't know.

0:35:57- I'm gonna say 10, I'm gonna guess 10.

0:36:00That, I know, a lot of pros are still sore about that.

0:36:03And from what I understand, that's mostly been kinda,

0:36:05people now are okay with it.

0:36:07But the software side, Apple has definitely backed away

0:36:10from the pro market to a large degree.

0:36:12The hardware side, I think it's been even more dramatic.

0:36:16And granted, a lot of pros get away just fine with iMacs.

0:36:19A lot of pros use the MacBook Pro,

0:36:21and they're mostly fine with that too,

0:36:22although it's pretty old.

0:36:24I think one of the problems we have now,

0:36:26and which ties into the Thunderbolt display thing also.

0:36:29But one of the problems we have now is that

0:36:33it seems like Apple has,

0:36:34whoever is responsible for deciding these,

0:36:38like, you know, these hardware generations

0:36:40and when to ship things and what makes the cut

0:36:42and what gets pushed to the next release,

0:36:45it seems like their sensibility for,

0:36:49do we ship now with the new stuff we've accumulated so far

0:36:52or do we wait and do a bigger update in X time

0:36:56with this stuff that's imminent, that we're soon,

0:36:59if we wait now, we'll be able to do a bigger update

0:37:02in six months that has X, Y, and Z.

0:37:04And it seems like their sensibility for that

0:37:07is just a little bit off in recent years.

0:37:10'Cause there are new components they could have used

0:37:13for the Mac Pro.

0:37:14And the Mac Pro uses Xeon CPUs, Intel's server line.

0:37:17Xeon's don't get released that often.

0:37:19They get released, I think, roughly every 18 months.

0:37:21There's a new generation of Xeon's that would be suitable

0:37:23to use in the Mac Pro.

0:37:25GPUs get released even more often than that.

0:37:28And for Apple to say that this is a,

0:37:31like they redesigned this entire machine

0:37:33to be entirely like GPU focused,

0:37:36that you can't even buy this with only one GPU anymore.

0:37:40You can only get it with two GPUs

0:37:42and they're gonna be server-ish

0:37:44or workstation-ish grade GPUs.

0:37:46There's some asterisks on that,

0:37:47but basically they're gonna be workstation GPUs.

0:37:49And this is the future of how we see pro computing

0:37:54is these heavy GPU operating machines.

0:37:57Well, the GPU world moves really quickly,

0:38:00way faster than the CPU world ever did,

0:38:02and it's still moving at that speed.

0:38:04You can't say your vision for pro computing

0:38:07is tons of GPU power, and then not update the GPUs

0:38:10that you're selling for three years.

0:38:13Like, it seems like they set on this course of,

0:38:16we're gonna, you know, this is our vision

0:38:17of the future of computing, and then they just

0:38:19didn't follow through at all, and to the point now where,

0:38:23A year in it was kind of like,

0:38:26eh, I wish these GPUs were faster.

0:38:28Two years in it was like, ah, is everything okay?

0:38:30Three years in, people are looking for the exits

0:38:32and looking to switch to Windows for their pro needs.

0:38:35And that's a problem.

0:38:36- It definitely is because,

0:38:37and I think that in an ideal world,

0:38:42well, maybe not ideal, 'cause ideal would be updated very,

0:38:44you know, we'd see lots of updates.

0:38:46I would say in a realistically ideal world,

0:38:49the Mac Pro could still be on a greater than one year cycle.

0:38:54I think, you know, it could, like 18 months though

0:38:57is about the upper limit of some kind of update.

0:39:00- And fortunately, that's about as often

0:39:02as Intel makes new Xeons.

0:39:03So all Apple has to do is stop skipping generations.

0:39:06'Cause right now, like in recent times,

0:39:09the Mac Pro for maybe the last, I don't know,

0:39:11six, seven years, they've released roughly

0:39:15every other Xeon generation.

0:39:17Like they just kind of skip every other one.

0:39:19And I don't, you know, I'm sure there,

0:39:21maybe there's good reasons why,

0:39:22but I'm not aware of what those are.

0:39:24And it appears from the outside

0:39:26like they just don't feel like it.

0:39:27And that's not a good reason if that's the reason.

0:39:29And again, like even if for some reason

0:39:32you have to keep the same CPUs,

0:39:35if this computer's really gonna be a GPU focused machine,

0:39:38release new GPUs for it.

0:39:39And by the way, this is a pro machine,

0:39:41make those GPUs upgradeable.

0:39:44Because that's what pros who need a lot of GPUs need.

0:39:47They need upgradable, powerful, recent GPUs.

0:39:50- Right. - And if that's not

0:39:52the focus of the machine, then make it cheaper

0:39:55by making a single GPU option and give more CPU options.

0:39:59Maybe redesign it so it can support two sockets again.

0:40:01Then you can have then double the amount

0:40:04of very high-speed cores, double the number of RAM slots.

0:40:07It's like they designed this machine to accomplish a goal

0:40:11that they are seemingly unable or unwilling

0:40:14to actually fulfill.

0:40:15(laughing)

0:40:17It's just funny because it's a striking design

0:40:21and obviously it wasn't designed as a second thought.

0:40:26It was designed as let's redefine what it means

0:40:29to make a kick-ass professional high-performance desktop.

0:40:34But then it was, again, it's almost like they figured,

0:40:38well, we're done.

0:40:39We came up with a new Mac Pro and now we're done.

0:40:42Let's work on the iPhone 6s.

0:40:44- Yeah, and it's sad because it does seem like,

0:40:48from the outside, having no answers from Apple on this,

0:40:51it does seem like they just don't care.

0:40:53And the whole Mac lineup kinda looks like that right now,

0:40:57or at least the vast majority of it.

0:40:59And it's, I know they do care,

0:41:01like I know that's not actually the case,

0:41:04but it sure looks bad.

0:41:05- It does, and it definitely doesn't.

0:41:07And maybe it's not even entirely rational.

0:41:09I think people's professionals' concerns

0:41:11about Apple's long-term interest in this,

0:41:13It's just that if your personal livelihood is based on

0:41:17what you do at your computer, and that's probably true,

0:41:20it's certainly true for me and you,

0:41:21and it's true for a lot of people who listen,

0:41:23I think, to this show.

0:41:24It's reasonable to be concerned that the only company

0:41:28that makes the tools that you use

0:41:30may not be interested in serving you anymore.

0:41:32- Right, 'cause like, that's like, you know,

0:41:33one thing pro users hate with very good reason

0:41:36is being forced to change what they use to their job,

0:41:39either their workflow, their hardware,

0:41:40their software, whatever.

0:41:41They hate doing that because it sucks.

0:41:43Because when you're using something to get your work done,

0:41:46you don't want to have to spend a bunch of time and money

0:41:48to change systems, to relearn something else,

0:41:51to update everything and fix everything that breaks

0:41:53and deal with missing functionality for a while

0:41:55or have to buy new hardware, buy new software.

0:41:57It's very disruptive to pros to have their platform

0:42:02and their workflow messed with or be forced to change it.

0:42:05So when you're buying something for pro use,

0:42:07you want to be buying into a system

0:42:08that's going to be stable long term.

0:42:11You don't want to have to be learning an app now

0:42:13that is going to be discontinued next year.

0:42:15And oh, by the way, you have to also switch to Windows

0:42:18if you want to be competitive with your video encoding rig

0:42:20or whatever.

0:42:21Nobody wants that.

0:42:22And it kind of feels like this is

0:42:25going to be like a downward spiral, where Apple will keep

0:42:30really neglecting the pro hardware, which will then

0:42:33make people trust it less, and they won't sell as many.

0:42:36And then Apple can justify discontinuing those,

0:42:39or neglecting them further.

0:42:40and then they can say, well, we just don't sell

0:42:41very many of these, so why should we pay attention to these?

0:42:43- Yeah, it's, you know, I feel like it doesn't take

0:42:46a genius to analyze the situation,

0:42:48where the Mac is the pro platform,

0:42:51and iOS is the consumer platform,

0:42:54and especially with the iPhone, that's where the,

0:42:59you know, there's, what, I don't know,

0:43:0220-fold, 30-fold more of them sold per quarter,

0:43:06all around the world.

0:43:08It's their expansion into all these other countries

0:43:11like India and especially China.

0:43:14So of course, of course it's their most important priority.

0:43:19Of course they're never going to be late on an iPhone.

0:43:22Or if they are, it's a catastrophe,

0:43:24not as a result of, eh, we can wait.

0:43:27Like imagine if the iPhone didn't get updated for 900 days.

0:43:30You can't, I mean, literally,

0:43:32I know people make these jokes that,

0:43:34the stock's down 10%, Tim Cook should be fired.

0:43:36Or I shouldn't even say they make jokes.

0:43:38I know there's jackasses who actually say that.

0:43:40- They're serious. (laughs)

0:43:42- But with no hyperbole, if Apple got even close to that,

0:43:48if Apple went two years without an iPhone update,

0:43:52I think it would be reasonable for the board

0:43:54to maybe call Tim Cook in and say, "It's time, you're out."

0:43:57- Yeah, that would be cause for serious concern.

0:44:00- Right, it's like you can't even,

0:44:01really it's unfathomable.

0:44:04So 900 days for the Mac Pro,

0:44:05you know, it's not gonna get anybody fired,

0:44:08but it certainly looks bad.

0:44:09And I can even see it with the Mac Mini,

0:44:10where the Mac Mini's never been updated quickly.

0:44:12And maybe that's not really a pro machine,

0:44:14although I do know that there are some people

0:44:16who use it in pro sort of ways by like, you know,

0:44:19setting up like build machines and stuff like that.

0:44:22- Yeah, or like servers for offices,

0:44:24or even web servers in some cases.

0:44:25- Right, and you know, my friend Brian Stuckey,

0:44:28formerly of Mac Mini, colo, and now at Mac Stadium,

0:44:33is the new company that he combined with.

0:44:35- Yeah, they bought them, right?

0:44:36- Yeah, well they merged.

0:44:38And he even, I know he sent me like,

0:44:41hey please ask, if you get any,

0:44:43I don't know who you've got on the talk show,

0:44:45but if you get anybody good,

0:44:46can you please ask him about my poor Mac Mini?

0:44:48So there is a pro angle on the Mac Mini.

0:44:52- Yeah, but also it's worth pointing out too,

0:44:53like the current generation Mac Mini

0:44:56and the current generation Mac Pro

0:44:58both do a lot less than their previous hardware designs.

0:45:03So they've taken these products and not only have they made them, in the case of the Mac

0:45:08Pro it's actually more expensive now because now you have to pay for two GPUs, so now it's

0:45:11more expensive and it has less flexibility and less upgradability and fewer configuration

0:45:18options and less stuff you can put into it, less maximum capacity in a lot of areas.

0:45:23And the Mac Mini too, the Mac Mini used to have a quad core option and it was a really

0:45:27great way to get a decent amount of power in this little headless server and occasionally

0:45:33they go up for sale on the Apple refurb store

0:45:36and they just disappear in like a minute.

0:45:39Like there is still incredible demand

0:45:42for I believe it was a 2012 era CPU

0:45:46in these roughly 2012 era Mac minis

0:45:48because they happen to be quad core

0:45:50and that's a lot more processing power in total

0:45:53in parallel than the current model's dual core

0:45:57highest configuration.

0:45:59- Yeah and a lot of what people wanna do

0:46:01is these things that are parallelizable.

0:46:02Right, especially in a server.

0:46:04Or even if you're using it at home,

0:46:06like for a media thing for your TV,

0:46:08or if you're using it as a build server, all those things

0:46:10use all the cores.

0:46:12Almost everything that a pro would want to do with it

0:46:15is parallel.

0:46:16And even for home users, at least make the option.

0:46:19So Apple has these machines now where they're actually

0:46:22making them worse, and in some cases worse and more expensive

0:46:27over time, and updating them almost never.

0:46:31And then so of course sales are gonna go down,

0:46:34which again, it's gonna make that downward spiral start,

0:46:36where then they won't be able to justify updating them.

0:46:39And it's just gonna get worse.

0:46:40And I feel like, you know, and we're gonna get to this,

0:46:43I think if we ever get to the headphone jack,

0:46:44and you probably shouldn't let us get to that,

0:46:47'cause I have a lot to say about that.

0:46:48(laughing)

0:46:49But-- - We're definitely

0:46:50gonna get to that.

0:46:51- It seems like Apple, somewhere in Apple

0:46:53there's like this obsession with getting rid of things,

0:46:56getting rid of options, getting rid of ports,

0:46:57getting rid of hardware, getting rid of something,

0:47:01just getting rid of things.

0:47:02And I can see how you get that way.

0:47:05I've gotten that way before in my software development,

0:47:07where it feels really good to get rid of stuff.

0:47:10And oftentimes there are benefits.

0:47:13But not always.

0:47:14It isn't always worth it.

0:47:15And sometimes the costs outweigh the benefits.

0:47:18And it seems like, similar to how I question

0:47:20the decision making that has led to,

0:47:23oh, we'll just wait until thing in the near future

0:47:26to update this computer, I also question the judgment

0:47:29recently of, oh, we can just take this out,

0:47:31or we can just make this worse,

0:47:33or we can just make this more expensive or whatever,

0:47:35and it'll be worth it in the end

0:47:36because we're moving forward.

0:47:37It's the future, the vision of the future

0:47:39is things can do less and cost more.

0:47:41Like, no, but that's actually what we're seeing

0:47:44in some of these products, and that does concern me.

0:47:48- I think so, too.

0:47:51It would've been interesting to ask,

0:47:52so I regret not asking that question.

0:47:54I don't know how we could've gone that long on stage

0:47:56with it, but probably not.

0:47:57I would've been interested in hearing--

0:47:58that you didn't. There were, prior to WWDC, up until a couple of weeks, there were a lot of

0:48:04expectations that there might be hardware announcements and if there would, you know,

0:48:07Mac. People were thinking maybe new Mac books, maybe a new Mac Pro. I don't really think that

0:48:12new Mac Pro ever really heated up too much, but there were whispers that the supply constraint

0:48:21train of Thunderbolt displays was going down.

0:48:24And it's just one of these like catch-22 chicken

0:48:28and the egg problems, right?

0:48:30Like which comes first, like, well, if they're gonna,

0:48:33you know, they need a, desperately need

0:48:36a retina standalone display.

0:48:38Like at this point, once you're used to retina

0:48:40on all of your devices, from the watch to your phone

0:48:43to your iPad, and the iMac has this beautiful,

0:48:47beautiful display, it just sticks out like a sore thumb

0:48:50that their best display for a Mac Pro is not Retina.

0:48:53And it's like, for me at this point,

0:48:55it's like, I almost can't believe how,

0:48:57I can't believe I lived my whole life

0:48:58before Retina displays.

0:48:59They're so fuzzy.

0:49:02And so it sticks out, but if they make it,

0:49:07what drives it, you know,

0:49:08does, can they, you know,

0:49:09if they came out with a 5K Retina display,

0:49:11I think that the existing Mac Pro

0:49:13wouldn't be able to drive it.

0:49:14- Well, there's like, again,

0:49:15there's like a whole bunch of asterisks on that.

0:49:16it could with dual cables maybe and with certain hacks.

0:49:21Basically, the way that displays are driven

0:49:25over Thunderbolt ports is way more complicated.

0:49:29The more, as time goes on, I learn even more about it

0:49:32and I learn how little I know about it.

0:49:34And basically there's an asterisk on everything

0:49:36and it's not as simple as well,

0:49:39Thunderbolt doesn't have enough bandwidth for this

0:49:40because it isn't technically a Thunderbolt,

0:49:42it's a DisplayPort that runs that.

0:49:43And it's like, there's all these little asterisks

0:49:45and like, well, you can make a bridge chip that did this,

0:49:47you can use this hack over the cable to do this,

0:49:49and it's basically a mess right now,

0:49:52and it will be much cleaner and simpler with Thunderbolt 3.

0:49:56- I remember when the original 5K iMac came out,

0:49:59the first one, which is what I'm using right now.

0:50:02- Me too. - Do you have the new one,

0:50:03or do you have the original one?

0:50:04- I have the same one you do.

0:50:05- Yeah, so I have the exact same one that you do.

0:50:07And I was talking after that was announced,

0:50:11and I got to talk and I had like a product briefing,

0:50:13and they explained to me,

0:50:15like some of the product marketing people explained

0:50:17exactly how they're driving it inside,

0:50:19and it's just amazing.

0:50:20It's such a hack.

0:50:21I mean, not like a bad hack, like a dirty hack,

0:50:23but it's just crazy.

0:50:25But it totally makes sense as to,

0:50:27it's like the embodiment of why Apple likes to make

0:50:30an all-in-one product.

0:50:32Because all of that ugliness,

0:50:33they can just encapsulate it inside the thing,

0:50:36and we'll just take care of it,

0:50:37and we'll write our own,

0:50:39I mean, they mentioned this on the event,

0:50:40what do they call it, the custom--

0:50:42- The T-Con, the timing controller.

0:50:44- Yes, the timing controller,

0:50:45because it's like they have to have these,

0:50:47the reason they have a custom timing controller,

0:50:49I think I have it in lay terms,

0:50:51but because they need like two cables to do it,

0:50:55they need this timing controller

0:50:56so that the two signals coming in

0:50:59look like you're just getting one picture.

0:51:01- Yeah, it's basically it, yeah.

0:51:02- It's two pictures that are being combined in once

0:51:05out of Apple's very high frame rate

0:51:07so that you don't notice anything.

0:51:09They needed to write a custom timing controller.

0:51:12It just perfectly embodies why Apple likes to make devices

0:51:15like the iMac rather than the Mac Pro

0:51:17with a standalone display.

0:51:19So I think what's going on, I think what's going on

0:51:22is that they're going to release a 5K cinema display

0:51:26and they're gonna release new Mac Pros

0:51:28and they're gonna release new MacBook Pros.

0:51:30But it's like they can't release any of them

0:51:34until they're all ready, I think.

0:51:36- Honestly, that's probably just like a choice

0:51:39that they want to release them all together.

0:51:41I mean, they probably could stagger them a little bit

0:51:43if they really felt like it,

0:51:45but the fact is it doesn't really matter.

0:51:46We don't really know.

0:51:48- Yeah, I guess they obviously could, for example,

0:51:49they could release new Mac Pros

0:51:50that are capable of driving this thing

0:51:52and just say, "Just use your old crappy Dell monitor,"

0:51:55or whatever.

0:51:56- Exactly.

0:51:56So that's, you know, probably sometime

0:51:59in the next six months,

0:52:00we're probably getting all of these things.

0:52:01If I would hazard a guess, I'm guessing,

0:52:04well, the Mac Pro is a bit of a problem

0:52:05because the, well, of course,

0:52:08it's always a bit of a problem,

0:52:08but the type of Xeon it would use,

0:52:12if it's being released this fall,

0:52:13would most likely be the Broadwell Xeon.

0:52:16The Skylake Xeon is coming out sometime next year,

0:52:19and it's a really big improvement for the Xeon platform.

0:52:22There's a lot of other stuff that goes along with that.

0:52:25So I'm kind of afraid that Apple's gonna wait for that.

0:52:28- And if they do, or if they don't wait,

0:52:31will Syracuse await? (laughs)

0:52:33- Well, he's always gonna wait. (laughs)

0:52:35- Syracuse's back is to the wall.

0:52:37People who don't listen to ATP,

0:52:38And I bet the overlap here is like 90%.

0:52:40- Yeah, probably.

0:52:41- But the macOS Sierra doesn't officially run on John's.

0:52:46He's using like a 1998 Bondi Blue Power Mac.

0:52:52Doesn't run on it.

0:52:57It's finally been dropped.

0:52:59So now he's in the conundrum

0:53:01where he's been waiting for all of these years,

0:53:0320, 22 years or something like that to upgrade his Mac Pro.

0:53:06and now he either has to,

0:53:10or he won't be able to run macOS Sierra on it.

0:53:12- Or there's one of those hack bootloader programs

0:53:15that will modify Sierra to actually work,

0:53:17'cause it actually does work,

0:53:19they just don't feel like supporting it, basically.

0:53:21So you actually could install it

0:53:23through this unofficially supported hack.

0:53:26So what do you think is more offensive to Syracuse?

0:53:29- No, I think that-- - Running the hack?

0:53:31Or not running it, or buying a new Mac Pro?

0:53:33- That he knows is gonna be obsolete, it's in.

0:53:35- Right, like I, this is a really tough position

0:53:38to put him in.

0:53:39- Boy, it's almost like a perfect,

0:53:41a perfect-- - And it has

0:53:43a new file system. (laughs)

0:53:44- Yeah. (laughs)

0:53:46(bell dings)

0:53:47(laughing)

0:53:49And it's the only way that he could use it.

0:53:51- Yeah, exactly. - No, no, no,

0:53:52they are gonna come out with a file system

0:53:54for El Capitan, right?

0:53:56I think so.

0:53:57- No. - No?

0:53:58- No. (laughs)

0:53:59Why would they do? (laughs)

0:54:01- I thought that they were going to,

0:54:03that you could like plug a disk into LCAP, but maybe by the time the file system actually

0:54:07ships that Sierra will be the old release. I don't know.

0:54:11I don't know. It's very funny though.

0:54:14I mean this really was like a masterful trolling of Syracuse this year.

0:54:18It really was. It really is. But it's his own fault for not buying. He should have bought

0:54:22the Mac Pro as we know it as soon as it came out.

0:54:24Yeah, and I even offered to sell him, when I sold my 2010 era one, which does run this,

0:54:29which is decently better than his 2008,

0:54:32I offered to sell to him for a really good price,

0:54:34like well below market, just 'cause I wanted to get rid of it,

0:54:36I don't wanna deal with selling it.

0:54:37And he was like, "No, I'll just wait.

0:54:40"I'm happy with my 2008.

0:54:41"Okay."

0:54:42- The best time to buy a computer is when it's brand new.

0:54:46And maybe if you're really smart,

0:54:48buy it just a little after it comes out

0:54:51so you can read initial reviews

0:54:52and just make sure there's not something really stinky about.

0:54:55- Right, buy it like a month or two in.

0:54:57Yeah, like six weeks in.

0:54:59Because like Apple doesn't, they don't lower their prices over time as the computers get older.

0:55:02Like you're paying the same price and getting the same computer on day number 900 of the Mac Pro as you were paying on day zero.

0:55:09Like who's, I just can't even imagine who's buying a Mac Pro right now.

0:55:14I mean if you have to, yeah, I just imagine that almost everyone they're selling right now is through gritted teeth.

0:55:19Like somebody who's old one broke or they've made a new hire, you know, we've got a new guy on the staff,

0:55:26"we gotta get him a Mac Pro," or something like that.

0:55:31- Right, I mean, it's like if you drop your iPhone

0:55:33on a toilet in like August.

0:55:35- Yes, exactly. - You're like, "Damn it."

0:55:37But like, you know, that makes people mad.

0:55:39Like, this is yet another reason why Apple needs

0:55:42to really look at this and see if they could do this better

0:55:44and release things more often, because like,

0:55:46right now, if you buy any Mac Pro, and even, you know,

0:55:50yeah, not a lot of people buy the Mac Pro,

0:55:52but you know what a lot of people buy?

0:55:53The MacBook Pro.

0:55:55and that is also really outdated.

0:55:57And to have people knowing that these things

0:56:01are old and outdated, and I think a lot of people,

0:56:03I mean not every buyer knows that,

0:56:05but I think a lot of buyers do,

0:56:07and they're gonna go a whole other summer now

0:56:08of all these back to school sales,

0:56:10or kids going to college,

0:56:12buying a whole bunch of MacBook Pros again,

0:56:14like that everyone kinda knows

0:56:15are basically like three year old hardware.

0:56:18Man, this is making people unhappy

0:56:21about buying Apple products.

0:56:24That is not where you want them to be.

0:56:26- Yeah, because I think Apple's mojo is the fact

0:56:30that people love buying Apple products.

0:56:33- Exactly.

0:56:35- It's like everybody, it's like your Christmas,

0:56:37people who don't even do unboxing videos

0:56:41save the unboxing video.

0:56:43- Yeah, and when I got my cylinder Mac Pro

0:56:47like a couple months after it was released,

0:56:49I don't know, like February or something of that year,

0:56:50when I got that, I was really happy with it.

0:56:52It was amazing.

0:56:53But if I went to buy one today,

0:56:56now that I've already replaced it with an iMac

0:56:59almost two years ago,

0:57:00like it's still the same computer today that I bought,

0:57:06that I ordered in December 2013.

0:57:09- It's really kind of strange, it really is.

0:57:13And you know, it's like I think I was saying before,

0:57:15it's like you can even go down the line

0:57:16and just show that the,

0:57:18even within the MacBook family,

0:57:21the MacBook One has gotten a year over year update,

0:57:25less overdue, like the more consumer friendly device

0:57:30is updated more regularly than the professional one.

0:57:33Even within the MacBook lineup,

0:57:35the Pro end seems to get short shrift.

0:57:38- Yeah, and that's what I'm saying.

0:57:40Like whatever Apple decides, you know what,

0:57:43we need to hold back and wait for X, that needs tweaking.

0:57:46And if for a long time it was just like,

0:57:48oh, we'll just ship whenever Intel gives new laptop CPUs.

0:57:51But in recent years Intel has had a lot of delays

0:57:54and has gotten less reliable.

0:57:55So maybe decouple that or definitely don't skip any

0:58:00or figure out ways to give more frequent updates.

0:58:04Like last year when they brought the Force Touch trackpad

0:58:08to the 15 inch MacBook Pro,

0:58:10so it has technically been updated

0:58:13but notice that almost nothing else about it changed.

0:58:16From what I heard the reason why is that

0:58:18the GPU it was using was so old that Nvidia stopped making it,

0:58:22or ATI, whichever one it was.

0:58:24Like, they just stopped making the part.

0:58:26And Apple was still selling these brand new,

0:58:28in the 15-inch MacBook Pro, their highest end laptop.

0:58:31Oh, man.

0:58:32And if that's true, I mean, that's really embarrassing.

0:58:35Hey, we just crossed the one-hour marker

0:58:37a little bit ago.

0:58:37So I think we're on pace for a two-hour show.

0:58:39We'll see.

0:58:39Yeah, OK.

0:58:40You haven't seen the length of my notes for the headphone

0:58:42jack.

0:58:43I made an outline.

0:58:44You're in trouble.

0:58:45Let me take another break here and thank

0:58:47our very good friends, longtime sponsor of the show, Audible.

0:58:50Audible.com has an unmatched selection of audio books,

0:58:55original audio shows, news, comedy, and more.

0:59:00Get a free 30-day trial at audible.com/talkshow.

0:59:04They've been advertising on podcasts forever,

0:59:06and I always say it's duh because anybody who's listening

0:59:10to me tell you right now about Audible

0:59:11is somebody who enjoys spoken word content,

0:59:13and that's what Audible has.

0:59:15They've got gobs and gobs untold count.

0:59:18You don't have enough hours left in your life probably

0:59:20to listen to everything that Audible has.

0:59:22I used to think, here's one thing about Audible

0:59:25that is eye-opening to me,

0:59:27is that I always thought of them as the audiobooks company,

0:59:31and they do have thousands and thousands of audiobooks.

0:59:35But the other types of content they have,

0:59:38like I just said, the original audio shows,

0:59:41news, the comedy, and stuff like that,

0:59:44tons of stuff like that too. So even if you're not into audio books like hearing a novel read out

0:59:51loud or something like that, there is tons of stuff there if you like spoken word content. And

0:59:55if you don't like spoken word content, I don't understand how you are hearing me talk to you

1:00:00right now. So go there, check them out. You can get a 30-day free trial and you just sign up at

1:00:08at audible.com/talkshow. No "the," just /talkshow. Go there. Thanks to

1:00:13Audible for sponsoring our show. Go there and fill up your phone with

1:00:17audio content. All right, let's talk about the headphone jack.

1:00:23You sure? You wanted a short show. Let's see. I'm fascinated by this. I wanted to write

1:00:29about this a few months ago, and it was one of those things where I'd collected

1:00:33a lot of notes and had some thoughts on it, and just now I think it's one of

1:00:36those ones where having a podcast sort of hurts my column at Daring Fireball

1:00:41because it was like I talked about it with a couple people on this show over a

1:00:44week or two and then it's like I felt like I got it out of my system so I

1:00:47never wrote about it. See this is this is where you're in trouble now because you

1:00:51know a few months ago when the rumor first started started going around we

1:00:53all talked about it like I talked about on ATP. I remember. And so I probably

1:00:57won't get a chance to talk about it on ATP this week so therefore I'm gonna dump

1:01:01this all on you. Okay. Because it's interesting like you know so this kind

1:01:06flamed up again this week because Neelai Patel at The Verge wrote the big thing

1:01:09about it. Well, it goes back one step though. It started with Daisuke Wakabayashi,

1:01:14published his story in the Wall Street Journal Monday, more or less confirming

1:01:18all the stuff that we've heard. That the next iPhone is going to largely look

1:01:24like the iPhone 6 and 6s, and yeah removal of the headphone port would be

1:01:32one of the main features. I will happily rescind that and change it to changes.

1:01:41I forget. But just a whole bunch of things that we've heard rumored for a while coming out of

1:01:48the supply chain. And Wakabayashi had sources familiar with the matter who couldn't speak for

1:01:54whatever reason confirm them. Which is worthwhile. There's nothing in it that I hadn't seen before.

1:02:01But it's always worthwhile when somebody with the stature

1:02:05and the track record of the Wall Street Journal confirms it.

1:02:09But then after that, that's when Neelai published,

1:02:12what was the headline?

1:02:15- I forget, it was something like,

1:02:17Six Reasons Why You Don't Want the Removal of Headphone Jack

1:02:19and he even said in his Twitter link to it--

1:02:22- Taking the headphone jack off iPhones

1:02:24is user hostile and stupid.

1:02:26- And he even kind of like disclaimed

1:02:30in his Twitter link to it, like,

1:02:31"I was really angry when I wrote this,

1:02:33"so it probably sucks."

1:02:33Like, it was something like that.

1:02:35So, you know, I give him the benefit of the doubt on that.

1:02:36And a lot of his points I thought were valid and good.

1:02:41Not all, I didn't agree with all of it,

1:02:43but I think I agree with most of it.

1:02:45And then you wrote this rebuttal piece,

1:02:48mostly rebutting him, I think,

1:02:50that was basically like, you know,

1:02:53it's progress, it's going to happen, why not now?

1:02:55Is that a fair summary?

1:02:56- Yes, it's going to happen eventually.

1:03:00Maybe, why not now?

1:03:01If there's one thing that seems like people misread in it,

1:03:04I think Steve Strese had a piece on Medium,

1:03:07and his assumption is that I was arguing

1:03:10that this is a good change for iPhone users.

1:03:14And I never said that.

1:03:14If you read my thing, I never said that,

1:03:16because I don't know.

1:03:17I have no idea what they're replacing it with.

1:03:19I don't know, and Wakabayashi didn't either.

1:03:22I think people assume that the default earbuds

1:03:26will be lightning.

1:03:28if they're getting rid of the audio port, what do we call it?

1:03:31What is it called?

1:03:31Standard headphone jack?

1:03:32It doesn't even have a name.

1:03:33- It has a few names.

1:03:34Technically, it's one of the family of phone plugs,

1:03:37and it is specifically a 3.5 millimeter TRRS jack.

1:03:42- Well, the TRRS jack.

1:03:44(laughing)

1:03:45- You're welcome.

1:03:46- I think most people assume that the standard earpods

1:03:48are gonna be lightning,

1:03:49because then they don't have to have batteries,

1:03:51and there's no latency.

1:03:54There's all sorts of good reasons why you'd still want

1:03:56a wired set of earphones, earpods,

1:04:00whatever you wanna call 'em.

1:04:02Could be that the defaults will be Bluetooth

1:04:04or some other new proprietary wireless thing.

1:04:07- Bluetooth seems like an upsell.

1:04:09- That does to me too.

1:04:10- Also, if they were gonna have a proprietary wireless thing,

1:04:13that would've been using the Apple Watch,

1:04:15'cause Bluetooth sucks for the Apple Watch.

1:04:17So they definitely would've used it there if they had one.

1:04:19- Well, maybe it wasn't ready yet.

1:04:22It's possible. - Maybe it's up there

1:04:23with the Skylake Xeons.

1:04:24- Right, I don't know, but.

1:04:26Who knows? But I just don't know. I don't know what the story is. And so my argument is more,

1:04:30I think that the removal of this port is inevitable. Will it be there in 50 years? I just,

1:04:38no way. So what is the time frame? Well, it was there 50 years ago. That is true. And I think it's,

1:04:44you know, it has had a remarkable, you know, run. But I feel like the time is up. So just for the

1:04:51sake of argument here, I looked this up before the show. There's a Wikipedia article on the phone

1:04:54plug. The large, like the, have you ever seen like a stereo from like the 70s or

1:05:00if you're a high-end headphone nerd and you've seen like the quarter inch

1:05:03version of the plug, it's basically, it looks just like the regular one but it's

1:05:05about twice as big in both dimensions. Yes. That version was invented in 1878 for

1:05:12use in phone exchanges and the stereo version that we mostly know

1:05:18today that has the two rings halfway through so it has like

1:05:22three total areas of plug and it's smaller,

1:05:25the 3.5 millimeter one.

1:05:26That one appeared roughly in 1964

1:05:30and became popular with the original Sony Walkman in 1979.

1:05:34- So we're talking about at least a good 40 years.

1:05:38- Yeah, yeah.

1:05:39So this thing is old and you know,

1:05:43the reason it has lasted so long is because it is universal,

1:05:49it is very simple electrically,

1:05:51It's very, very simple.

1:05:52There's no smarts to it.

1:05:54It's just like, it's just pure analog signal

1:05:55going over these, you know, two or three wires

1:05:58inside the cable, or in the case of the headphone remote,

1:06:00four wires inside the cable.

1:06:02Very, very simple, electrically.

1:06:04They're very reliable, for the most part.

1:06:07Like, the port can get gunked up with dust,

1:06:09but so can the lightning port, so can any port.

1:06:12So, you know, compared to other ports,

1:06:14it's not particularly bad for reliability.

1:06:16It's very, very durable, and it's very, very cheap.

1:06:20So you have this combination of like standard,

1:06:22universal, cheap, durable, simple,

1:06:24like it's really great for all these things.

1:06:27And by the way, if you think it's too thick,

1:06:29there is also a thinner version.

1:06:31So this version is 3.5 millimeter,

1:06:33there's a 2.5 millimeter version that used to be

1:06:36on like some like answering machines

1:06:38and then like more recently it's often used

1:06:40like on the ear end of removable headphone cables

1:06:44where like you'll have like the end that plugs

1:06:46into the phone and the other end plugs into like

1:06:47your ear cup, sometimes that end will be the skinnier one,

1:06:50and you might have a couple of those.

1:06:51- I've seen that.

1:06:52I used to own something that had that.

1:06:54I don't know what the hell it was though.

1:06:56- Yeah, it doesn't matter.

1:06:57- Well, the other thing about making the devices thinner

1:06:59with the standard headphone jack,

1:07:01I keep pointing this out over and over again,

1:07:02but the iPod touch still has it,

1:07:04and the iPod touch is significantly thinner

1:07:06than the current iPhones.

1:07:08- And the Nano too, I believe it's also thinner,

1:07:10and it also has it.

1:07:10So like, the reason to remove it now

1:07:14isn't a thickness barrier,

1:07:16because there are,

1:07:18we see Apple makes thinner devices with this.

1:07:20So that's not the reason.

1:07:22I would also say, so like in my category of reasons

1:07:25it doesn't have to go yet, assuming it has to go

1:07:28at some time, one of the reasons this might not be the time

1:07:31is like what are we gaining by removing it,

1:07:33'cause there's cost removing it.

1:07:34So I think one thing we're gaining would be

1:07:37a lot of people assume space for the battery, right?

1:07:40Except that if you look at the tear downs

1:07:42of where this port is on the phone,

1:07:45down there at the bottom next to the lightning assembly

1:07:47and everything and then on the other side you have the speaker next to it, you have

1:07:49the microphone and everything. Down there, like that's not where you need space for

1:07:53the battery. I mean, they could go to some kind of crazy system like the MacBook One

1:07:57where they have like different shapes of battery things all over the place, but this is a phone

1:08:02and they have to replace a lot of phone batteries under warranty and people replace them aftermarket

1:08:06and you know when they're old and in different countries and everything. You need the battery

1:08:10to be easily serviceable, replaceable and cheap. And so keeping it as one regular rectangle

1:08:16of a battery is way more practical for them.

1:08:19And also, the total amount of space you would save,

1:08:23or a space you would gain by invading that little

1:08:27rectangle of area at the bottom of the phone,

1:08:29where the headphone jack is,

1:08:30you can just make the battery some minuscule amount thicker

1:08:33and keep it in the same footprint,

1:08:35and it would have that same volume increase

1:08:37and be way cheaper and easier to deal with.

1:08:38So, battery life is probably not the reason either,

1:08:44because of just like where it is in the phone

1:08:46and what else is down there.

1:08:47Like I don't really see a massive internal redesign

1:08:51of the phone layout inside where that space

1:08:54would suddenly become space you could expand

1:08:56the battery into.

1:08:57It might, but I think it's unlikely.

1:08:59- Well, I think it goes far enough in that

1:09:01the space is significant, but I don't think it's huge.

1:09:03I think the biggest space-saving argument

1:09:06or three-dimensional, you know, this thing is just too big

1:09:09or too thick or too long argument,

1:09:11probably have to do with next year's new iPhone, which I believe, and as you know,

1:09:16I mentioned it on the show and I know there's rumors about it too, that if it

1:09:20goes to more of an edge-to-edge display, which would be like the top and bottom

1:09:24of the display go to the edge as close as the sides do now, then I think it's a

1:09:29problem because I don't, I think it's a lot harder to have the, the jack

1:09:33would therefore have to be underneath the display. Yeah, so remove it then. Well,

1:09:38Well, that's what I'm saying.

1:09:39It is a good point.

1:09:40Why now?

1:09:41That doesn't count for why now, unless they just possibly

1:09:46just want to eat the shit sandwich now of putting up

1:09:50with people's complaints about this a year in advance

1:09:53of unveiling that phone so that people don't complain about it

1:09:56when the amazing new industrial design is unveiled.

1:09:59And that might be the reason, but that's a crappy reason.

1:10:02I don't think that's the reason, though.

1:10:03I do think that there is a reason.

1:10:05All I'm saying-- and this is the secondary thrust

1:10:07my argument, which is, "Well, we don't know. How about we just wait and find out what the story is before we complain?"

1:10:14Like, it's to me that it's too soon to say this is user hostile and stupid.

1:10:20Right, although it's also too late to change it.

1:10:22Right. But we don't have proof that it's not user hostile and stupid. It might be.

1:10:25I guess that, if there's anything that I wish I would have emphasized more, it's like, "Okay, maybe it is."

1:10:30But we certainly don't know that yet, and it may well not be.

1:10:33I'm wondering and you know you definitely know more about headphones than I do is I'm wondering about

1:10:38If it switches to lightning something digital

1:10:43How much better could the input be not just the output right right now you think of a headphones

1:10:49Output you put them in and you listen right but like the whole input stuff like voice

1:10:55You know through the microphone and the little clicks like when you you know what there's like play/pause and fast forward and stuff like that

1:11:01I mean, you know, you write a podcast player.

1:11:04That stuff is all, that's just like a serious hack.

1:11:07- It is a hack, but it also works.

1:11:10- Yeah, but maybe-- - And it is,

1:11:11the main thing that you can say from that point of view

1:11:13is that it's limiting.

1:11:14Like, for example, you can only have mono input right now,

1:11:17'cause there's only one pin for the microphone return.

1:11:20So like, you can only have one channel.

1:11:22So if you wanted to have like a nicer microphone setup,

1:11:25maybe if you wanted to podcast or record something

1:11:27from your device, you can, if you're using that port,

1:11:30you can only record in mono.

1:11:32And lightning adapter, you know,

1:11:33lightning devices can add much more than that.

1:11:36They can have all sorts of inputs and outputs,

1:11:38and especially if they have custom apps to deal with them,

1:11:41then they can do a lot, and most of them do.

1:11:43But that also isn't a good argument,

1:11:44because like, well, we already have that now.

1:11:46Like, you don't have to remove the headphone port

1:11:49to have lightning audio.

1:11:50We have lightning audio already,

1:11:52and we also have the headphone port.

1:11:53- Yeah, but, uh. (laughs)

1:11:58- You know?

1:11:59And there's also, by the way, while we're on this topic,

1:12:01there's a huge argument going around

1:12:05with the pro side of this,

1:12:06that this could enable better audio quality.

1:12:10And let me tell you, as an audio file,

1:12:12that is complete garbage.

1:12:14First of all, you have the same problem of like,

1:12:18well, if lightning headphones can be better,

1:12:20great, we can have that now.

1:12:22We don't need to remove the headphone jack

1:12:23to make that happen.

1:12:24And the way iOS handles audio devices,

1:12:27if any other device is connected via Lightning or USB

1:12:30or whatever, that device just takes over

1:12:33from the built-in microphone and speakers

1:12:35and headphones and everything else.

1:12:36So you don't even have to,

1:12:38the software doesn't have to do anything

1:12:39to take advantage of Lightning connected audio devices.

1:12:41It just works.

1:12:42So there's basically no downside from that point of view

1:12:45to keeping the headphone jack around.

1:12:48And the idea that some people have

1:12:50that a Lightning connected headphone

1:12:52would have better audio quality

1:12:53because you could have a really nice DAC and amp

1:12:56that DAC is the DAC digital audio converter

1:12:59that converts, literally converts the digital signal

1:13:01to the sound that you hear, and then of course

1:13:03the amp amplifies that to different volumes for you.

1:13:06- At some point it has to go to analog.

1:13:08There's no-- - Right.

1:13:09- 'Cause it's actually going to put sound waves

1:13:12into your ear.

1:13:13- Right, and so I wouldn't worry about the DRM angle

1:13:15like Nilay did, because it would be trivial to,

1:13:18if you're actually relying on analog output

1:13:21to capture, to re-record, to pirate something,

1:13:24it would be trivial to just take apart the headphones

1:13:26and connect a couple things to the wires

1:13:28that go to the drivers and that'd be it.

1:13:30So that part of the DRM is not a concern.

1:13:32Licensing the connector is, but I'll get to that.

1:13:36But the idea that you get better audio quality

1:13:38out of having separate premium headphones

1:13:42that have premium DACs and amps in them, that is possible.

1:13:46However, it's extremely unlikely in reality.

1:13:49Because in reality, it is very difficult

1:13:52to distinguish differences between DACs and amps,

1:13:56especially once you've crossed a minimum threshold.

1:13:58And people who make this argument are often talking

1:14:01about how DACs and computers are always crappy.

1:14:03And the fact is they were really crappy in the 90s.

1:14:07That's when they were crappy.

1:14:08And most built-in headphone jacks and sound cards

1:14:12that are in computers and our phones and tablets today

1:14:16are pretty decent, they're fine.

1:14:17And the limiting factor to how good they can sound

1:14:21is not the quality of the DAC and the amp in the phone.

1:14:24it's almost always limiting factor is the headphones

1:14:28that you're using and the environment you're listening in.

1:14:30Like that's it, like when you're listening on your phone,

1:14:33like you might be commuting, you might be outside,

1:14:35you might be in a loud shared office,

1:14:37and you're probably listening on headphones

1:14:38that are like, you know, at best decent,

1:14:42probably not amazing, probably not like the big,

1:14:44full-sized, open-backed ones that audio files

1:14:47like to listen critically with.

1:14:49And those headphones you're listening on,

1:14:52Like there's so much room for improvement in the sound,

1:14:55just by better headphones, better drivers,

1:14:57better tuning of the sound to make it, you know,

1:15:00less trying to imitate beats badly

1:15:02and more just trying to sound good.

1:15:04You know, like that is where improvement comes from.

1:15:07It does not come from in the portable realm,

1:15:09but does not usually come from different DACs and amps.

1:15:12DACs and amps are just a really nice way

1:15:14to sell overpriced stuff to people who want better sound,

1:15:17but never consider the fact

1:15:19that they should just buy better headphones.

1:15:21I saw somebody today and I don't remember who.

1:15:24No, that's okay, this is good.

1:15:25Somebody today was speculating that maybe they will switch,

1:15:30they'll do like a noise canceling thing

1:15:32and they'll have the stuff on the phone doing it.

1:15:36Like right now when you buy noise canceling headphones,

1:15:38you have to put batteries in the actual headphones,

1:15:40like when you buy them from Bose or whatever,

1:15:41'cause it takes power to actually do the noise canceling.

1:15:46So the phone could do it.

1:15:48But I find that unlikely.

1:15:51Like it sounds good when you think, oh, noise canceling.

1:15:53Some people like noise canceling headphones.

1:15:55And in certain scenarios, like being on an airplane,

1:15:57it really is very useful.

1:16:00But that sounds very unlikely to me

1:16:02that anybody is gonna find it a good idea

1:16:05to have headphones that draw power from your iPhone.

1:16:08Like when you're using the headphones,

1:16:11you'll get worse battery life.

1:16:12Like that doesn't sound like something

1:16:15people are gonna sign up for.

1:16:16like there is a like one of Eli's things was...

1:16:21Yeah, I mean in reality like it isn't that much power but it's still you know it's

1:16:26still not trivial but the reality is like the high-end headphones like noise

1:16:31cancelling and everything those are all moving to Bluetooth now and I believe I

1:16:35have things to say about Bluetooth as well but I think like a whole other side of this

1:16:39argument is like oh well lightning headphones would be great but you know

1:16:42what lightning headphones are very expensive like their premium price right

1:16:45Right now there's very few of them,

1:16:47and the few of these are very expensive.

1:16:48They will always be more expensive than other headphones

1:16:51because they're gonna have the Apple licensing,

1:16:53the MFI stuff, and then they're gonna wanna be sold

1:16:56on Apple retail stores.

1:16:57They're gonna have these, you know,

1:16:58I'm guessing most lighting headphones

1:17:00are gonna be above $300 in all likelihood.

1:17:03And so you're gonna have this stuff,

1:17:05but the problem is if you look at the headphone market,

1:17:07everyone's kinda freaking out

1:17:08and trying to rush out Bluetooth models

1:17:10in the last couple years

1:17:10because everybody wants noise canceling and Bluetooth

1:17:15the high end. Like if you're looking at high end headphones like headphones that cost more

1:17:19than 200 bucks that are for iPhones or for portable use like everybody wants Bluetooth

1:17:26and noise canceling. And so that is, you know, in many ways that's an argument for the headphone

1:17:33jack removal because you can say well, you know, if everyone's going Bluetooth then,

1:17:37you know, we don't need this, right? And this is why I think like, you know, Bluetooth is

1:17:44In many ways it is worse than wired headphones.

1:17:48In many ways it's a lot worse than wired headphones.

1:17:50Like the sound quality is usually pretty rough.

1:17:54By the way, the reason the sound quality is pretty rough

1:17:56is not usually because of lossy compression over Bluetooth.

1:18:00It is usually because the headphones

1:18:03are kind of mediocre or garbagey.

1:18:06And they have, guess what?

1:18:08They have a built in DAC and amp

1:18:10in every Bluetooth headphone because it has to,

1:18:12because it is not powered by your phone,

1:18:14and the signal's transmitted digitally from your phone.

1:18:16So we already have a world full of aftermarket

1:18:19DACs and amps in headphones, and they're all garbage.

1:18:24And the most sophisticated things they do

1:18:27are they tweak the audio, they tweak the EQ curve

1:18:31of the audio coming out of the headphones

1:18:32to make up for crappy headphone drivers.

1:18:35So if you have headphones that say,

1:18:37suppose they have really weak bass,

1:18:40and they know that everybody wants strong bass,

1:18:43they'll just use the DAC amp chip in the Bluetooth headphone.

1:18:48They will tweak the sound before they send it out

1:18:50to the driver to just artificially boost the bass.

1:18:54And these are like cheap components doing things

1:18:57in a very basic way.

1:19:01And it sounds pretty rough.

1:19:02And you can hear this yourself.

1:19:04If you have like noise canceling headphones,

1:19:06like any Bose headphones that also can operate

1:19:09with a wire passively, if you can turn off

1:19:12the noise canceling and use them with the wire,

1:19:15turn it off and listen to how much worse everything sounds.

1:19:18That, what you're hearing when it's off,

1:19:20that's what the headphones in an app actually sound like.

1:19:23And when you turn it on, they're applying this big EQ curve

1:19:26to try to boost it and make it sound better artificially,

1:19:28but it's never quite right,

1:19:30it never sounds great or natural.

1:19:33That's the world we're going towards.

1:19:34If we're going towards more Bluetooth, more lightning,

1:19:39headphones that are not just passive analog devices

1:19:41but actually have active circuitry in them,

1:19:43it's not going towards a world of like amazing dacs and amps

1:19:46in portable headphones,

1:19:47it's going towards a world of mediocre headphones

1:19:49that have their flaws papered over

1:19:51by kind of these DSP hacks.

1:19:55- So what are they gonna do?

1:19:55I feel like if they switch,

1:19:57if Apple's story is, okay, buy this new iPhone

1:20:00and when you open it up,

1:20:01you get a pair of our new Bluetooth AirPods

1:20:05or whatever they're gonna call them.

1:20:07somebody had a there was like a trademark filing on the word AirPod oh

1:20:10there's no way that's that's in the package you know I'm thinking in the

1:20:14package you get like you get the the cable adapted version of them just like

1:20:18today and then they will tell you with a lightning port in some form you know

1:20:23whether it's like a dongle and then head no headphones there's no way there's

1:20:27probably not go no way probably they'll definitely sell you one but they might

1:20:31put one in the box I don't know no probably not well not either way they

1:20:35They might give you a dongle so that you can use your existing headphones if you'd prefer

1:20:40not to, but the headphones they give in the box have to just plug right in.

1:20:43And that means it has to be plugged in.

1:20:44Yeah, that's probably right.

1:20:45Yeah.

1:20:46So I'm guessing that they will gladly sell you a set of AirPods, if that's going to be

1:20:51a real product name, they will sell you a Bluetooth version of those headphones for,

1:20:54I don't know, $150, $100 maybe.

1:20:57That's going to be an add-on.

1:20:58That's not going to be in the box.

1:21:00Because let's not forget that Apple's really good at making you spend a little bit more

1:21:04money at the point of sale and get all those attachment sales like they've

1:21:07mastered this now I think both of these both of these ideas qualify as of course

1:21:12that's what they're going to do their Apple of course Apple isn't gonna make

1:21:15you use a dongle their Apple there's no way they're gonna make you use a dongle

1:21:19and of course of course the air wireless ones are gonna be a expensive upsell

1:21:25because they're out exactly so that's sold and and the idea of like moving

1:21:31towards the world of Bluetooth,

1:21:33'cause let's be honest, it's gonna be mostly Bluetooth.

1:21:35It's not gonna be mostly lightning headphones,

1:21:37except for the ones that come in the box.

1:21:38Those will be very popular,

1:21:39but aftermarket headphones, I think,

1:21:42are gonna be way more often Bluetooth than not

1:21:45in the near future.

1:21:47We're almost there now.

1:21:49- If the story is go with Bluetooth,

1:21:53it solves some of the problems

1:21:55in terms of why would they get rid of the headphone jack?

1:21:58Well, we got rid of it because the future's wireless.

1:22:01And it also solves the how do I listen to music

1:22:04while I charge my phone problem, which is a real problem.

1:22:08I mean, and I--

1:22:09- The solution is you discharge the other device

1:22:11that you're wearing on your head at the same time.

1:22:13- Well, how would you do that?

1:22:15- No, you're right.

1:22:16I mean, the solution is either they ship

1:22:17and kind of pass through adapter,

1:22:19which would be pretty clunky.

1:22:21- Right.

1:22:22- Or you just use Bluetooth.

1:22:24And when you're using Bluetooth,

1:22:26the iPhone is not concerned with the battery level

1:22:29of your headphones.

1:22:30problem.

1:22:31Yeah, and it does seem it seems weird to me.

1:22:35I have to admit, I mean, this is one of these things ever since the thing started.

1:22:38I don't see how they're going to sell this.

1:22:41And you know, what's the story going to be?

1:22:43Because I totally acknowledge like I see Jonas doing it all the time where he's got like

1:22:47an iPad at 3% and he's charging it while he's still listening to the YouTube stuff that

1:22:53is on it while he plays the PlayStation.

1:22:56I totally recognize that.

1:22:58I know lots and lots of people, they do it on airplanes.

1:23:00If you're lucky enough to fly on an airline that has USB or power adapters,

1:23:04people charge their phone while they listen to music on the flight.

1:23:08I know people do it at their desks.

1:23:09People will charge their phone while they're listening to music on it.

1:23:13I understand it and if there's just one lightning port,

1:23:19and of course they're not going to put two lightning ports on the thing,

1:23:22how do you listen with lightning headphones?

1:23:24I mean, and that's the one idea that people were

1:23:27kicking around when the rumors were that the new iPhones were going to have the

1:23:30smart connector type thing on the back that maybe there'd be like a Apple watch

1:23:35style magnetic charger but I don't know it doesn't seem right

1:23:40especially like you know we already got like you know the as they as they ship

1:23:45more and more other things that charge via lightning it's pretty clear like we

1:23:50have now a world where lightning is like the universal Apple charger for all

1:23:55Apple products except the watch annoyingly but everything else it's like

1:23:59everything charges by lightning and I don't I don't see them throwing that

1:24:03away so soon yeah like the pencil charges by it the

1:24:07rumored that I forget if somebody just pulled this out of their ass or if it

1:24:12was a real leak that the air pods would have like a little some kind of little

1:24:15lightning thing that comes out or goes I don't know Bluetooth I'm lucky that I

1:24:20don't I don't actually use earbuds or in-ear monitors that I just can't wear

1:24:24them like pain-wise I can't wear them Bluetooth is you know it's annoying for

1:24:30full-size headphones but it's not that bad Bluetooth for earbuds has a whole

1:24:35bunch of challenges like well where do you put the battery and how do they

1:24:39connect to each other and like there's all sorts of like weird hacks that

1:24:42people have devised like well you have this like thing behind your neck or

1:24:45something you know like there there's always some some kind of trick but it's

1:24:48tricky to get Bluetooth into you into earbuds in a way that doesn't suck but

1:24:53But overall, moving towards the world of Bluetooth headphones,

1:24:58in so many ways, it's worse.

1:25:01Number one problem is, of course, this

1:25:03is one more thing you have to charge.

1:25:05And if you're traveling, that might mean one more cable

1:25:07to bring or something, and one more battery that could just

1:25:09die at inopportune times.

1:25:11And it's just kind of annoying.

1:25:13They tend to be substantially more expensive

1:25:15than other headphones of similar quality and attributes.

1:25:19And Bluetooth is slightly unreliable.

1:25:22Like it works most of the time,

1:25:24but like every time I'm walking with my Bluetooth,

1:25:28you know, little portable headphones

1:25:29for walking and listening to podcasts,

1:25:31every time I have like a little clip out of the audio

1:25:33during some part of the walk,

1:25:34if I like turn, if I like put my hand in the wrong spot,

1:25:37like in my pocket or something,

1:25:39like it like blocks the signal just enough

1:25:41that oh, can't quite make it, I get a little static

1:25:43and I gotta move my hand.

1:25:43Like, and I've tested so many pairs of Bluetooth headphones,

1:25:46they all have that problem.

1:25:47It's always, some of them are better than others,

1:25:49but they all have that problem to some degree.

1:25:51And then there's the big problem of using

1:25:53whatever headphones you come up with,

1:25:54Bluetooth and lightning,

1:25:56this would actually be substantially worse,

1:25:58using the same headphones for multiple devices.

1:26:01So suppose, like when I'm on a plane,

1:26:04I'm always switching my headphones

1:26:06to whatever device I'm using.

1:26:07So if we're like, you know, taking off or whatever,

1:26:09I'm just gonna try to sleep,

1:26:10I'll have my iPhone in my pocket.

1:26:12But then if I'm gonna like take out my laptop or an iPad

1:26:15to try to get something done on the tray,

1:26:16I'm gonna switch the headphones to that.

1:26:18And a lot of people, they use the same headphones

1:26:22between work and home at their work computer

1:26:24or either work and iPod, like, excuse me,

1:26:27iPhone, iPods are ancient.

1:26:29So with Bluetooth, because of Bluetooth pairing

1:26:33and everything, it's just such a pain

1:26:36to share Bluetooth headphones between multiple devices

1:26:40that in practice, nobody really does it.

1:26:42You can't, some of them have a multiple pairing memory,

1:26:46but they're always weird and hard to use.

1:26:48Effectively, Bluetooth headphones, in practice,

1:26:51they just kinda get locked to their primary device.

1:26:53So nobody ever really changes it.

1:26:54So that sucks.

1:26:56Lightning would be even worse,

1:26:57because yes, you could swap Lightning

1:26:59between your iPhone and your iPad,

1:27:01but then what are you gonna do when you go to your Mac?

1:27:03Like, you can't plug your Lightning headphones

1:27:05into your Mac.

1:27:06- And that seems crazy.

1:27:08I mean, I threw it out there as a spitball this week

1:27:11that what if that's the reason the MacBook Pros

1:27:13are being delayed, 'cause they're gonna put

1:27:15lightning port on them just so that you can plug your headphones in but it

1:27:20doesn't you know in every other way other than the idea that I would like to

1:27:24be able to use the headphones the same headphones with my iPhone and my Mac

1:27:29which is a very reasonable desire other than that it doesn't make any sense to

1:27:33put a lightning port on a Mac but I'd you know I I don't know maybe I don't I

1:27:39mean it doesn't seem I wouldn't I wouldn't faint if that was announced but

1:27:43but it doesn't seem right.

1:27:45Again, the only thing that really makes sense is Bluetooth,

1:27:48but like you said, Bluetooth sharing between devices

1:27:50is really weird, you gotta like,

1:27:52I mean it's just like click, click, click,

1:27:54or tap, tap, you know, settings, Bluetooth,

1:27:56unpair, pair, type this code.

1:27:57- Yeah, it's just, yeah, it's crappy.

1:28:00And like, on the Android side,

1:28:02they have this whole NFC system

1:28:03to make pairing faster and easier.

1:28:06It's possible Apple could add that to the next iPhone,

1:28:08they already have the NFC antenna for Apple Pay.

1:28:10I don't know much about NFC,

1:28:11but it's probably the same antenna.

1:28:13so it's possible they could do something like that,

1:28:14but honestly, I don't see that.

1:28:17- It's hard to beat the pairing process

1:28:21of headphones as we know them.

1:28:23- Yeah, you plug 'em in.

1:28:24- And when it clicks, you're done.

1:28:26- Yeah, and then if you wanna all of a sudden

1:28:29have the headphones be playing output

1:28:31from a different device, you know what you do?

1:28:32You just unplug it and you plug it into the other device

1:28:35and because they all have the same port.

1:28:37Even the MacBook One has no other ports

1:28:40except it has a headphone port.

1:28:41- Right.

1:28:42- Besides the USB-C, that's like the one other port

1:28:46they deemed worthy of including on that computer

1:28:48was a headphone port.

1:28:49That just kind of shows how ubiquitous and important

1:28:53and how compelling it is for this port to continue to exist.

1:28:56Ultimately though, if this thing about the iPhone is true,

1:29:01I think the world of lightning headphones

1:29:05is generally a terrible idea

1:29:08and is probably not gonna be very healthy.

1:29:11- Yeah, but maybe-- - It's probably gonna be

1:29:12mostly adapters to regular headphones or Bluetooth.

1:29:15- Maybe though it'll kickstart it,

1:29:17because it hasn't taken off to date, because why?

1:29:20Why would you bother getting Lightning headphones

1:29:22when you can get regular headphone jack headphones

1:29:25that have the same audio quality and they're cheaper?

1:29:29- Right, by the way, I should point out too,

1:29:30I love this so much, the headphones that are pictured

1:29:33in every article about Lightning headphones on the Verge

1:29:36are the Audizay EL8 Titanium or Platinum or something.

1:29:41They're $800 and they sound terrible.

1:29:43(laughing)

1:29:45Just putting that out there.

1:29:47They look really cool.

1:29:48We're gonna have lots of Lightning headphones

1:29:50that look really cool and cost a lot of money,

1:29:53but hopefully they'll sound better than the EL8.

1:29:55Sorry, Audizay, there goes one sponsor

1:29:57I'm never gonna get.

1:29:58- Let's dispel the notion that maybe,

1:30:02I've seen this kicked around,

1:30:03and I think it is total nonsense, never gonna happen,

1:30:06is that the solution, 'cause one of the problems

1:30:08people have with Lightning,

1:30:10The idea of using Lightning as the port for wired headphones

1:30:13is that now you're stuck with an Apple proprietary solution

1:30:15that has to get a licensing fee,

1:30:17has to meet Apple's approval,

1:30:18and therefore has to be more expensive

1:30:20than it would be otherwise

1:30:21because whatever the licensing fee is,

1:30:23it's, if it's even a penny,

1:30:25that means the thing's gonna cost a penny more.

1:30:27And it's not gonna be a penny. (laughs)

1:30:30- Right.

1:30:31- Well, but-- - So the idea that people

1:30:32are, I've seen kicking about is,

1:30:33well, okay, well, if a headphone port is should be open

1:30:36and everybody likes having an open standard,

1:30:39why not USB-C?

1:30:41Maybe that's the idea, is that the iPhone will switch to USB-C.

1:30:43And guess what?

1:30:44Headphone port aside, the iPhone is not going to switch to USB-C.

1:30:47No, there's no chance of that.

1:30:49No chance.

1:30:49First of all, it's thicker than lightning.

1:30:51Right.

1:30:51Then that alone is a deal breaker.

1:30:53And I'll put it in the show notes, hopefully.

1:30:55But I got a good link.

1:30:56Somebody did a really nice, precise diagram showing just

1:31:01how much thicker it is.

1:31:02And it actually would be pretty close to a gating factor

1:31:05already on the iPhone 6.

1:31:07and everybody knows Apple likes to make devices

1:31:10thinner over time.

1:31:11So like when you just eyeball them side by side,

1:31:13you can say, oh yeah, they're like more or less the same.

1:31:15But when you get right down to it

1:31:17and start measuring the tenths of a millimeter,

1:31:21it's too big of a difference.

1:31:23- Yeah, definitely.

1:31:23- And strategically, Apple is not gonna give up

1:31:26their proprietary port that they've had

1:31:28on the iPhone all along for a non-proprietary port

1:31:31just so that they can have quote unquote open headphones.

1:31:35yeah they i mean they couldn't possibly care less

1:31:37uh... so yeah i mean

1:31:38and andy the could be cost increase i mean

1:31:41headphones already especially you know especially headphones that are targeted

1:31:46at

1:31:46smartphone use

1:31:48and enough would be to cut the result in apple store like

1:31:51the price of the headphone

1:31:53has so little to do with the cost of its components in this market

1:31:57uh... that that would not like

1:31:59the cost of an apply certification

1:32:01would probably not be the reason why the headphones cost a lot

1:32:04These headphones cost a lot because they know they're selling into a premium market that's

1:32:08based mostly on brand recognition and being sold in a high-end retail store.

1:32:12That is why these headphones cost what they do.

1:32:16Lightning headphones will be expensive, but it won't be because of the raw component

1:32:20cost increase.

1:32:21It'll be because of everything else about them.

1:32:23So that's that.

1:32:24Ultimately, though, I really do believe that we are heading towards a world of Apple pushing

1:32:31you know, assuming this is true,

1:32:34the real push is gonna be towards Bluetooth.

1:32:36It's not gonna be towards the new cabling standard.

1:32:39It's going to be Bluetooth because that,

1:32:41again, we're already moving there so much

1:32:42because the reality is, like, as a user,

1:32:45like, look, I have a whole closet and a couple of drawers

1:32:48full of way better headphones

1:32:51than my little Bluetooth walking pair.

1:32:53And yet, the little Bluetooth walking pair

1:32:55is the one I am using most often with my iPhone

1:32:58because even though it is worse in so many different ways,

1:33:03it's more complicated, it's more expensive,

1:33:06it needs to be charged, it's a little bit flaky

1:33:08with that connection when I move my hand worse.

1:33:10It sounds worse, like the sound quality is worse.

1:33:13So much about it is worse.

1:33:15However, it is more compelling.

1:33:18And if you look at, like, you know,

1:33:20worse but more compelling is like the theme

1:33:23of modern computing advances.

1:33:24Like so many things we have, you know,

1:33:27we have given up reliability, simplicity, openness, cost,

1:33:32so many good attributes, we've given those up

1:33:35for a new thing that is just nicer in some way,

1:33:40or I want it more, or it's just more compelling

1:33:43for some reason, and that's how Bluetooth is,

1:33:45that's why I don't know anybody who has started

1:33:50using Bluetooth headphones and then ever wanted

1:33:52to use wired headphones again.

1:33:54- Well, it's like WiFi versus ethernet,

1:33:55worse but more compelling.

1:33:57Especially in the early years of WiFi.

1:34:00- Yeah, I mean, WiFi now is pretty decent.

1:34:02It was really not so in the early years, but again--

1:34:05- And the speed difference was really, really dramatic

1:34:07in the early years.

1:34:09You didn't even need to have

1:34:10a terrific internet connection,

1:34:11and you could easily saturate your WiFi connection,

1:34:13and the ethernet would be the other way around.

1:34:16Like, you couldn't buy an internet connection

1:34:19that would saturate even 100 base T.

1:34:22- Yeah.

1:34:24Bluetooth will, whatever argument we can have

1:34:26about the headphone jack now,

1:34:28it will be worse not having it.

1:34:31It will suck not having it sometimes.

1:34:34For some people, it'll be more than sometimes,

1:34:36but in general, we are better off if we can keep it,

1:34:39but in general, the market is moving

1:34:42towards Bluetooth headphones,

1:34:44and it is worse, and that's okay.

1:34:47- What about latency?

1:34:48That's one thing that bothers me,

1:34:49and I'm one of those weirdos.

1:34:50I realize, it's like I tell people this,

1:34:52and they look at me, and they think I'm joking,

1:34:54but I generally run with key clicks on.

1:34:57Like when I'm typing on the iPhone keyboard,

1:34:59I like to hear the clicks.

1:35:01But I can't, I mean, it's like just the cognitive,

1:35:04trying to make sense of the lag

1:35:07when I have Bluetooth headphones on, it's like impossible.

1:35:10I can't because-- - Well also, I mean,

1:35:11it's hard to also ignore the fact

1:35:13that some pretty common tasks for people to do on phones

1:35:16include watching videos and playing games,

1:35:18and both of those really suck

1:35:20if there's noticeable audio latency.

1:35:22Yeah, the video problem, they seem to have solved.

1:35:25I don't notice any kind of lip sync problem.

1:35:28That's really when you can tell with audio

1:35:30is off if it looks like lips aren't moving in sync.

1:35:33And they've done something where I think that they--

1:35:35sort of like what Federighi was saying with the speed of light

1:35:42calculations with the--

1:35:45on stage last week, he said, where

1:35:46they can tell just how close the watch is

1:35:49to the MacBook that's being unlocked with that new feature.

1:35:52They do something where the video is lags

1:35:57by the exact same amount that the audio has to lag

1:35:59because of Bluetooth and it's in sync.

1:36:01But games are like the keyboard,

1:36:03like all the beeps and boops and blops

1:36:06are a half second behind.

1:36:07- You know, but ultimately I think what's going to happen

1:36:10is we're just gonna deal with that.

1:36:12'Cause like, I mean, one thing is like,

1:36:13I learned this when I tried to buy

1:36:14wireless digital microphones for our recording this year

1:36:18at WBC and that failed miserably.

1:36:20If you're transmitting audio wirelessly,

1:36:23if you're doing it in like a pure analog sense,

1:36:27like the way old cordless mics worked

1:36:29and a lot of old cordless phones worked,

1:36:31analog sucks in a lot of ways.

1:36:32You pick up static and everything,

1:36:33but analog is basically latency free.

1:36:37If you're doing it digitally,

1:36:38which is what Bluetooth is doing,

1:36:40transmitting audio digitally wirelessly

1:36:43from some device in your hand to headphones on your head

1:36:46and then having those headphones then convert that audio

1:36:48digitally into the analog sounds,

1:36:51just because of the nature of digital transmission,

1:36:53there's like buffers in different places and everything,

1:36:55there's always going to be some degree of latency.

1:36:58And even the best latency,

1:37:00like even the lowest we've managed to get it as an industry

1:37:04is still noticeable for things like lip syncing lining up

1:37:07and for things like that.

1:37:09And that's like the best stuff.

1:37:10Most of what you're getting in Bluetooth headphones

1:37:12is not top notch equipment.

1:37:14You know, it's not like the best of the best,

1:37:16It's consumer grade cheapo stuff.

1:37:19And so you're never gonna get digital transmission of sound

1:37:23from a phone to your headphones that is latency free.

1:37:27I don't think we know how to do that as a science.

1:37:30So I think this is gonna be one of those things

1:37:32where it's just always going to be worse

1:37:35and we will just, as a society, we will just move to,

1:37:39well, I guess we just won't play games with headphones on

1:37:42or I guess we'll turn off our keyboard sounds or something.

1:37:46Because again, the advantage is once you get used

1:37:48to using Bluetooth headphones,

1:37:50using a wire feels barbaric.

1:37:52'Cause I know whenever I travel on a plane,

1:37:57my Bluetooth ones suck on a plane

1:37:58'cause they're small and they don't isolate.

1:38:00So I usually bring a nicer pair of wired headphones

1:38:04for planes and it just feels so weird

1:38:06to have this wire going down my side into my pocket.

1:38:09Once you're not used to that, getting it again is crazy.

1:38:13Once I got used to having the track forward,

1:38:16track back volume controls on the ear cup as buttons

1:38:20on my Bluetooth pair, rather than having the clicker

1:38:23and have, all right, click twice for four,

1:38:25click three times for back, and try to do,

1:38:28again, once you get used to the convenience of it,

1:38:29it really is so much better that you tolerate

1:38:32all the crap about Bluetooth.

1:38:34- Yeah, I got them for running, for listening to podcasts,

1:38:38and well, really just listening to podcasts while I run.

1:38:41And the tethered, being tethered to the headphones

1:38:46always bothered me.

1:38:47It never once figured out.

1:38:49I tried all sorts of stuff.

1:38:50Holding the phone, an armband, putting it in a pocket.

1:38:55I tried everything and no matter what,

1:38:57that the wire gets in your way.

1:38:59That's why I bought it.

1:39:00But then I, this was like, I don't know, nine months ago,

1:39:04something like that when I got these, the Beats ones.

1:39:06But the thing I noticed was over the winter,

1:39:08how nice it was in the East Coast winter

1:39:11when I could wear them all bundled up with a coat

1:39:13and still have my phone in the pocket.

1:39:16Because with a winter coat on and a hat and stuff like that,

1:39:19it was just another type of mess, having a cable.

1:39:22- Try to like sneak it through different layers.

1:39:24- Yeah, exactly, like sneak it through the button.

1:39:26It's almost like when you wire yourself up with a lav mic.

1:39:29- Exactly.

1:39:30- And then trying to get it out, it's even worse.

1:39:34All right, here's one last topic on the headphone thing

1:39:36and the headphone port being gone that I have in my notes

1:39:39is the waterproofing angle.

1:39:42- See, that's kind of a bad one,

1:39:43because there are already phones out there

1:39:45that other people make that have headphone ports

1:39:47and are waterproof.

1:39:49- And that's, I,

1:39:51that's true.

1:39:55I wonder if it would be just part of the story, though.

1:39:59And then there's an angle where maybe

1:40:02it's a little bit of BS, because hey, well,

1:40:05okay, you're saying that the phone is water-resistant now,

1:40:07And one of the reasons is you got rid of this ancient headphone port, but there's these

1:40:14other phones that are water resistant and they have it.

1:40:17Do the other phones that have it, do they make you plug it up with a little rubber cover?

1:40:22Or are they just like, "Nope, you can just..."

1:40:24Oh, I don't know.

1:40:25I think that the...

1:40:26You assume I've ever seen an Android phone.

1:40:28Well, there's a funny commercial.

1:40:30It's obnoxious, but there's a funny commercial or a series of commercials for Samsung where

1:40:36There's a guy who's, I think I'm supposed to know who he is.

1:40:38I think he's like a rap star, but I don't know who he is.

1:40:41And he's got a new Samsung, whatever, top of the line,

1:40:45Galaxy Edge or whatever, and he's just pouring champagne

1:40:48on it, and he comes into a convenience store

1:40:50and he asks the guy, and he's pouring champagne

1:40:52on his phone while he comes into the store,

1:40:55and he says, "Where's your champagne?"

1:40:56And the guy points back there, and the bottle's empty,

1:41:00and he throws it away, and he goes by a Nuba bottle

1:41:02of champagne, pops the cork, and then just starts

1:41:04pouring it on his phone again,

1:41:06and that's the end of the commercial.

1:41:08I laugh--

1:41:09- What a bizarre company that is.

1:41:10- It is, but it is such an obnoxious commercial.

1:41:13- They're very good at that.

1:41:16- Like can you even imagine if Apple had a commercial

1:41:18that just showed somebody wasting two bottles of champagne

1:41:23to pour on their phone?

1:41:25But I can only presume that the Samsung one

1:41:26must be waterproof with a headphone jack.

1:41:28- I think it is, yeah, from what I've heard.

1:41:30I don't know the details,

1:41:31but all I know is that these phones exist, right?

1:41:32So there are reasons that Apple could say on stage

1:41:37to why they did this, but if you look down

1:41:40the list of reasons why they might do this,

1:41:42the better audio, the thickness, the waterproofing,

1:41:47all of these are not strong reasons,

1:41:49because either they are totally unnecessary

1:41:51or there's enough ways around that or enough asterisks

1:41:55on it that it's not really that valid.

1:41:57So if you look at, there are some cynical reasons

1:42:00why Apple would want to do this.

1:42:02I mean, they would stand to make more money.

1:42:04They would save on component costs.

1:42:05They would save on warranty repair stuff

1:42:07when they have to pull lint out of people's headphone jacks

1:42:08and fix the ones that jam up.

1:42:10Which, by the way, again,

1:42:12is also a problem with Lightning ports.

1:42:14So, like, you know, there are lots of reasons

1:42:16why Apple wanted to do this.

1:42:17I mean, it would cause a wave of headphone upgrades

1:42:22and Apple sells a lot of their own headphones

1:42:25with their name and Beats's name on them.

1:42:27In addition, many of those headphone upgrades

1:42:29would apply at the point of sale when you buy your iPhone.

1:42:33Hey, why not also treat yourself to this $200 pair of Beats

1:42:37because you're gonna need to do headphones with this phone.

1:42:39So that would help their attachment sale rate

1:42:41with sale of new iPhones.

1:42:42It's like Apple would tend to make quite a lot

1:42:45of additional money by doing this.

1:42:47I hope that's not the reason.

1:42:48That probably isn't the reason, but I bet that's a reason.

1:42:52- What if they do ship a pair of white in-ear just pods

1:42:59with the phone, you just get them with the phone.

1:43:01Wireless Bluetooth things that come with the phone.

1:43:04But then they also have a whole lineup

1:43:08of new Beats stuff ready to go.

1:43:10Like the upsell is for Beats.

1:43:12- That's possible, but I think it's very unlikely.

1:43:14I think it's way more likely what we said earlier

1:43:16that what you get in the box is either nothing,

1:43:19like maybe they will just decide, you know what,

1:43:21we don't need to ship headphones in the box anymore,

1:43:22you can buy any of the things.

1:43:24We're doing you a favor, we're offering you the choice.

1:43:26So maybe that's the angle.

1:43:27Or more likely, they ship wired lightning headphones

1:43:31in the box, and it's just a wired lightning version

1:43:33of the ones they ship now.

1:43:34That's way more likely, I think.

1:43:36And it's possible that the way that,

1:43:40what's that Japanese rumor site?

1:43:42Like, Okator, I don't know, I don't know how to pronounce

1:43:46Japanese words, I will just embarrass myself, unfortunately.

1:43:48But they reported months ago when we first started

1:43:51talking about this that the next iPhone would have

1:43:53a special, some extra pins on the lightning port

1:43:57and special secretary inside of it,

1:43:58would actually send analog audio out over the port

1:44:01to be able to power passive devices

1:44:03that don't have a built-in DAC and AMP,

1:44:06and that would be how the next cheap Apple earbuds

1:44:09would receive the audio.

1:44:10So it's physically over the Lightning port,

1:44:12but they're receiving analog audio.

1:44:14That seems very plausible to me.

1:44:16I said it even back then,

1:44:17that sounds extremely likely to be

1:44:19how they solve this problem for their own earbuds.

1:44:22And if they wanted to offer a dongle,

1:44:24they could do one very cheaply

1:44:26and it could be a very simple device

1:44:28if they have that kind of setup.

1:44:29- Yes, that sounds possible.

1:44:31And that's one of the reasons I've seen people toss out,

1:44:33hey, maybe they'll switch the iPhone to USB-C

1:44:35because I think part of the official USB-C

1:44:38SPAC is analog audio pass through on one of the pins

1:44:43or something like that, I could be wrong.

1:44:46- Probably. - And Lightning

1:44:47doesn't have that.

1:44:48But the difference is that Apple can change Lightning

1:44:50whenever it wants to.

1:44:51- Exactly. - It doesn't have to.

1:44:53- And they can so easily say like,

1:44:55well, you know, we didn't need this part

1:44:57of the Lightning port on any previous phone

1:44:58because they all had headphone jacks.

1:44:59Now this one, we've helped everyone out.

1:45:02So I think to me, I guess my final for now comment

1:45:05on the headphone jack thing is like,

1:45:08is there any reason I can come up with

1:45:11why this would be a positive thing for customers?

1:45:13It's obviously good for Apple.

1:45:14Why is it good for customers?

1:45:16And I can come up with one reason.

1:45:17And that would be if they replace the space

1:45:21used by the headphone jack with another speaker.

1:45:24and if by doing this they can dramatically improve

1:45:28the quality of the built-in speaker output of the iPhone.

1:45:31Because as I learn more about how people use iPhones,

1:45:36so I do my own analytics in Overcast

1:45:39of what is the current output device type?

1:45:42And the audio API is pretty coarse-grained on that,

1:45:46but it can tell you whether it's internal speaker

1:45:48or wired headphones or Bluetooth or AirPlay.

1:45:50And that helps me to figure out,

1:45:52hey, what kind of features do I work on next?

1:45:54That's one of the reasons why I did the speaker optimized voice boost in a recent version

1:45:58because I learned that tons of people use the iPhone built-in speaker and I always have

1:46:05but I thought I was just like a weird freak who worked at home.

1:46:08I didn't know anyone else did but it turns out tons of people use the iPhone speaker

1:46:12all the time even though it slaughters your battery but it doesn't matter.

1:46:16Everyone does it anyway and a lot of people do it like in cars.

1:46:19They play music from their phone in their car that they don't have a better connection

1:46:22to.

1:46:23we'll do it around the house.

1:46:24I mean, it's so common.

1:46:27So, and that's one of the reasons why I ended up buying

1:46:30the new Baby Pro, the new 9.7 inch iPad, because--

1:46:33- It sounds so much better.

1:46:34- Oh my god, it's night and day.

1:46:36I mean-- - It's unbelievable.

1:46:37- And like, I use it as a kitchen speaker most of the time,

1:46:39plus like a couch iPad, and oh my god,

1:46:41it's massively different.

1:46:42So what if they were able to do a large improvement

1:46:46to the internal speaker of the iPhone

1:46:48by replacing the headphone jack with a second speaker?

1:46:51- I like your thinking.

1:46:53That sounds compelling to me.

1:46:55- The only, my only hesitation on that

1:46:58is that the reason they're able to do it with the iPad

1:47:00is when you look at how you're allocating space

1:47:04inside of a computer device these days,

1:47:06these mobile, modern, ultra-thin, awesome devices,

1:47:09you like to think, oh, well, figure out

1:47:12what components you need and then fill

1:47:13the rest of the space with battery.

1:47:15The problem is batteries are really heavy.

1:47:17So my theory is that, you know, we talk about Apple

1:47:21pushing everything to be super thin and everything,

1:47:23and in some ways that goes too far,

1:47:24like the MacBook One keyboard.

1:47:26But I think what they really are doing

1:47:28is they're trying to target a weight goal.

1:47:31And the weight goal is limited by how much battery

1:47:34you're willing to carry, like how much battery

1:47:37are you willing to devote weight to.

1:47:39And then you can just kind of shrink the enclosure

1:47:41around that and be like, what's the smallest enclosure

1:47:43we can make that fits only this amount of battery

1:47:46and nothing else, you know?

1:47:48And with the iPad, they've kind of reached this point

1:47:51where, well, the enclosure is this thin, flat thing,

1:47:54and they basically can't make it a lot thinner

1:47:58and keeping the same amount of battery

1:48:01and still have it be a flat back.

1:48:03Like they'd have to like kind of make it like a bulge

1:48:04where the battery sticks out,

1:48:05kind of like their battery case for the phone,

1:48:07or you know, something like that.

1:48:08That would look dumb.

1:48:09So basically with the iPad,

1:48:11because of this like battery weight trade off,

1:48:14they end up having a lot of extra space in the case.

1:48:17So they spent that extra space on big speaker cavities

1:48:20to like tunnel the sound and make it sound better

1:48:23and everything.

1:48:24On the phone, they don't have that kind of volume to spare.

1:48:28So they might get some of it with the headphone jack

1:48:30removal and that might be enough to just basically

1:48:33like double the speaker we have now, which would help,

1:48:35that would be nice.

1:48:36But in order to make a really big improvement,

1:48:39I feel like they would have to do like one of those

1:48:41four speaker arrangements like they have on the iPad

1:48:43or like have any phones on that?

1:48:44Probably some Android phones on that.

1:48:46Like to have like a speaker on every corner basically

1:48:48instead of just the bottom half.

1:48:49- I don't think they would have to do that.

1:48:51'Cause I think everybody holds the phone.

1:48:53Although I guess when you watch video,

1:48:55it's always, it is a little weird

1:48:56that the sound's only coming out of one side.

1:48:58- I mean if they did that it would be great.

1:49:00But I just don't think they have enough space.

1:49:02I don't think they have enough free volume

1:49:04inside the phone to do that.

1:49:06- It also raises the question of the idea of the notion of

1:49:09hey let's make the speakers bottom,

1:49:11let's use the space on the bottom for the speakers,

1:49:13do it on both sides, you could have stereo.

1:49:15Well then why not put the headphone back at the top

1:49:18where it used to be for years?

1:49:20- Right.

1:49:21Yeah, I mean, that's the thing.

1:49:24My most plausible, most optimistic version of this,

1:49:28well, first of all, my most optimistic version

1:49:29is that the headphone jack doesn't go away.

1:49:31But if it's gonna go away,

1:49:32my most optimistic version of this that is plausible

1:49:36is that they're just gonna put a second speaker there

1:49:38that's roughly as good as the one we have now

1:49:39or maybe a little bit better,

1:49:41And that will still be a big improvement to the speaker,

1:49:43but not as big of an improvement as we have on the iPad.

1:49:46- I enjoy that there's 300,000 people

1:49:48who've signed a petition not to do this.

1:49:51- Really?

1:49:52- Yeah.

1:49:53- That's amazing.

1:49:54That'll help.

1:49:55- Well, it's already done.

1:49:57If it's true--

1:49:57- I know, that's the thing, it's too late.

1:49:59- It's already done.

1:50:00It's getting to the point where I think it's too late

1:50:01to change next year's iPhone, let alone this year's.

1:50:03Like, that's the thing.

1:50:04- Yeah, it might be.

1:50:05- People do not understand, like,

1:50:07this is how Apple ships 70 million iPhones

1:50:10in the first quarter, it's because the production ramp up

1:50:13is months in advance.

1:50:14- Yeah, I mean, they're probably already

1:50:15being manufactured right now.

1:50:18- It is. - This year's model.

1:50:19- All this speculation, it is still,

1:50:20I'm damn curious to hear them tell me why.

1:50:24I can't wait.

1:50:25But I do know that, and again, they could make mistakes,

1:50:28Apple does make big mistakes sometimes,

1:50:30and this could be one, but in general,

1:50:32the company has a very strong,

1:50:39I don't know what you would call it, like a rule,

1:50:41but just a policy, it's just the way they work,

1:50:43is they don't make changes for changes' sake.

1:50:45They only make changes if the change is for the better.

1:50:48Now the question is, better for whom?

1:50:50I mean, and sometimes changes are what's better for Apple.

1:50:54- I would maybe argue the ForceTux trackpad

1:50:57on all the computers that aren't the MacBook One,

1:50:59where the thinness isn't necessary is,

1:51:01maybe on the wrong side of that, but that's just me.

1:51:03- Can I just tell you, we disagree on that,

1:51:04because I have my regular 13 inch MacBook Pro

1:51:09has the old physically clicky one.

1:51:13I love the Force Touch one.

1:51:15I like it so much that I would almost,

1:51:17it would be such a waste of money,

1:51:19but I almost wanna get a new MacBook Pro

1:51:21just to get the Force Touch Pro.

1:51:23I like it that much better.

1:51:24I really do. - Well, I will say though

1:51:25that the one on the 13 inch MacBook Pro,

1:51:28which would be I guess the one you'd probably be getting.

1:51:31- Without question, that's the one I would be getting.

1:51:32Yeah, that one is the best one that I've felt.

1:51:36Like, a lot of people don't realize

1:51:38that every Force Talks trackpad feels a little bit different

1:51:40because they're all like different sizes,

1:51:42slightly different components, I think.

1:51:43The one in the MacBook One is the worst.

1:51:45It is, I mean, just like everything else

1:51:47but the MacBook One, it's like, you know,

1:51:49horrible for input, but really great for portability.

1:51:51Right, so it's fine.

1:51:53The desktop one, which I actually have one,

1:51:56I use it as my left hand pointing thing

1:51:57for like when I'm scrubbing through logic projects

1:51:59when editing podcasts.

1:52:01The desktop one is decent.

1:52:03The 15 inch one is decent.

1:52:05The 13 inch MacBook Pro one is actually pretty good.

1:52:07None of them I would call great,

1:52:10but the 13 inch MacBook Pro I would say feels the best.

1:52:13But honestly, I dislike the Force Touch so much

1:52:18that I'm just converting myself to be a tap to click person,

1:52:20which I hate, but I hate it less.

1:52:22- Anything else on the headphone port?

1:52:28- I think that's it.

1:52:29we're not gonna make this to our mark because we just crossed we just crossed

1:52:32it yeah I have another speaker to thank it is our new speaker sponsor a new our

1:52:38sponsor sorry I'd love to get a new speaker this we get a new speaker - I've

1:52:41got speakers on the mind our new sponsor is Ministry of Supply as humans we sweat

1:52:48right everybody does nobody talks about it but you sweat well here's the thing

1:52:52very rarely does sweating take place at convenient times gym clothes can handle

1:52:57but the clothes we wear to work, or at least that most people wear to work, aka a majority of the day,

1:53:03every day, do nothing to help. They're stiff and restricting and they only add to the problem.

1:53:08They make you sweat even more. Ministry Supply has set out to fix this. Their brand combines

1:53:15performance technology and tailored design to make men's work wear that's actually comfortable

1:53:20and capable. So it's like they're taking the fabrics and technology of modern gym

1:53:26wear and applying it to work wear. They have something, for example, they have

1:53:32something called the Aviator 2 suit, whole suit. It's so stretchy and

1:53:36breathable that people have actually run marathons in it. That sounds goofy

1:53:41to me, but it's an example of just how stretchable, comfortable

1:53:46their clothes are. Their co-founder set the Guinness Book of World Records for

1:53:53the fastest half marathon run in a suit that was wearing the Aviator II. Here's

1:53:59another example. The Apollo dress shirt. It has NASA invented fibers that

1:54:04regulate body temperature based on your surroundings. It'll keep you warm when

1:54:08it's cool. It'll keep you cool when it's warm. Really, really great stuff. Very, very

1:54:13stylish. I've checked out the website. This is all sorts of great stuff. Very,

1:54:17very cool clothes. And it's all machine washable. You're no longer a slave to the

1:54:22dry cleaner. You don't have to take everything to get dry cleaned in iron or

1:54:24whatever. You could just throw it right in the washing machine like regular

1:54:26clothes. So where do you go to find out more? Advanced technology, great fibers,

1:54:31great comfort, combined with really, really great stylish, very cool clothes.

1:54:38go to MinistryOfSupply.com/TalkShow.

1:54:43MinistryOfSupply.com/TalkShow.

1:54:47And remember that, use that URL,

1:54:49or just remember the code, talk show,

1:54:51and you will save 15% off your first purchase.

1:54:55They even have retail stores in Boston and San Francisco,

1:54:57and coming soon, Washington, D.C.

1:54:59So if you're in Boston or San Francisco,

1:55:01or soon, Washington, D.C.,

1:55:03you can just go to the retail store and check 'em out.

1:55:05And if you mention the podcast code there,

1:55:07just mention the code talk show,

1:55:08you'll save 15% off right in the store.

1:55:10So my thanks to Ministry of Supply, brand new sponsor.

1:55:14Go check them out, get some new clothes.

1:55:16What else is on our agenda before we sign off?

1:55:18We're almost done, right?

1:55:20- Yeah, I mean, there were only four or five more topics

1:55:22that you had that were giant, like the entire conference

1:55:24or whole platforms like iOS and watchOS and tvOS.

1:55:28- You know what, the watchOS thing is so fascinating to me

1:55:32because I just linked to a thing today where David Sparks,

1:55:35So the hiccup with upgrading to watchOS 3,

1:55:39if I could just upgrade my watch to watchOS 3,

1:55:41I would do it in a heartbeat.

1:55:42Because I don't really,

1:55:45I have so many issues with watchOS 2

1:55:47that watchOS 3 exactly tackles.

1:55:50I would, betas and all,

1:55:52and if my watch gets stuck, it gets stuck or whatever.

1:55:56That's fine, I could totally live with that.

1:55:57But the problem is you can't upgrade to watchOS 3

1:56:00unless the paired iPhone you have it with

1:56:01is upgraded to iOS 10.

1:56:03And I understand why that is.

1:56:04It makes a lot of sense, but I am definitely not ready

1:56:07to upgrade my daily iPhone to iOS 10,

1:56:09and probably won't be until later in the summer.

1:56:12- Yeah, I mean, like typically, like I think

1:56:13for regular people, the best advice is

1:56:17just don't use the betas, but if you insist

1:56:19on using the betas, you know, wait until at least

1:56:22like public beta two or so, and for like people

1:56:25who wanna write about it and talk about it,

1:56:27or developers, I think a good rule of thumb

1:56:30is roughly beta three of the developer side,

1:56:33which roughly correlates to beta one of the public side usually.

1:56:35Right, and summer just is like the worst time of year for me to like take risks with my phone

1:56:40because we're traveling, we're going on vacations and just going away for weekends to see family

1:56:46and stuff, we just are out more and so I rely on my phone more in the summer than any other time.

1:56:51Like if it was like time shifted by six months and we got like the betas in September,

1:56:56I'd probably put it on my phone. Still wouldn't put the first one on, but I definitely would

1:57:01wait and listen to what everybody says about developer beta 2 and probably go from there.

1:57:05But I can't do it in the summer. But anyway, David Sparks bravely did. And really just had nothing,

1:57:13you know, it's true. I mean, effectively, what Apple said in the keynote, because I

1:57:18was really skeptical, honestly, watching the keynote.

1:57:21**Matt Stauffer:** Oh, I think we all were.

1:57:22**Ezra Klein:** I mean, like super skeptical to the point where I was sitting with Ben Thompson,

1:57:27and I was like

1:57:28If he's full of shit, this is gonna be so much worse like

1:57:31but you know

1:57:33I got to play with them in hands-on and they were is

1:57:35Every bit as fast as promised and now that people brave people in the real world are trying it there

1:57:40They can vouch that what Apple said is true that it has enough RAM to keep you know

1:57:46Half a dozen apps suspended in memory, which makes them

1:57:49Instant, you know when you switch back to them they they're right there instantly and the background updates

1:57:55this is why it requires iOS 10 on your paired iPhone.

1:57:58The background updates really do update in the background.

1:58:02- Yeah, and there's a lot of things that you still can't do

1:58:05in real time, or there's still a lot of limits

1:58:09to conserve power and stuff, but it's substantially

1:58:13different and way better than how it was before.

1:58:16And by the way, to help people not feel too bad

1:58:20they can't run this yet, or they shouldn't run this yet

1:58:22on their main phone and watch, keep in mind

1:58:24that a lot of these benefits, you're not really gonna see

1:58:27as a user until the apps can be updated for it,

1:58:29which can't happen until the release.

1:58:31- Yeah.

1:58:32- So like, you know, you could have like your dock

1:58:33full of like Apple's apps, but you're not gonna have

1:58:36any of those benefits for third party apps

1:58:37unless you're like on their beta maybe,

1:58:39but I don't even know if we can send out

1:58:41test flight builds for iOS 10 yet, I don't even know.

1:58:43- Yeah, I don't know either.

1:58:44- But it's gonna be a while if we can,

1:58:46like it's gonna be probably later in the summer

1:58:47if that when that happens, and then you know,

1:58:49any app you're not in the beta for,

1:58:50you literally can't use the watchOS 3,

1:58:53enhancements to that app until like October or whenever,

1:58:56you know, whenever it's released.

1:58:57- It's, at a zoom out and at a high level,

1:59:00it's interesting to me in a couple of ways.

1:59:01And one is that, especially with iOS,

1:59:04and watchOS is a variant of iOS, so I think it qualifies.

1:59:07Apple has, for years, had the knock against it

1:59:11that older devices upgraded to the new OS

1:59:15instantly gets lower, to the point where, you know,

1:59:17there was the Catherine Ramble article

1:59:20in the New York Times of all places

1:59:21that was accusing them of doing it deliberately to spur upgrade sales. I mean, that's something

1:59:26people believe. And there is...

1:59:27Your times really come downhill recently, huh?

1:59:29For some, for some people, you know, there are, you know, and some of that is actually true. I

1:59:33don't think it was ever deliberate. I really don't. It's antithetical to Apple. And most of the people

1:59:38I know at Apple who are engineers, if they were told to do something like that, they would quit.

1:59:42They would actually quit their jobs rather than purposefully make an upgrade run slower on a

1:59:47a certain device. The problem is more that they didn't spend enough time

1:59:51optimizing it because everybody was working on the new version of iOS, was

1:59:55using the latest and greatest hardware. And then like at the end it's like, well

1:59:58quick try to make this run fast on an iPad mini too. And it's like... Turn off some

2:00:05stuff, it'll be fine. Yeah, I don't know, dial down the animation. Well, it's time to ship. Here it is.

2:00:11I don't think it was purposeful, I really don't, but it was true that there have

2:00:15been versions of iOS that come out for older devices and it does make them slow.

2:00:19And it's so funny that with this one it is going to make your year-old watch

2:00:25faster. And way faster. Right. Like noticeably faster. Like I did I haven't

2:00:33spent a day using it because I don't have you know yeah but in the hands-on

2:00:37area for the press that I got to play with it you know it really feels like a

2:00:42at new hardware.

2:00:44It's really kind of hard to believe

2:00:45that this is the same hardware as the old one.

2:00:48- Yeah, I got to, at WBC, I got to play with it

2:00:52with underscore David Smith's watch,

2:00:53a friend of the show, my friend underscore David Smith.

2:00:55And, 'cause he's a big watchOS developer.

2:00:59He has a bunch of watch apps, and so he had, of course,

2:01:02because he's incredibly productive

2:01:04and embarrasses all of us, he had already built

2:01:07like two of his apps for the watch,

2:01:08and like already had the complications installed,

2:01:10and had him like, so he was showing me,

2:01:12This was on Tuesday or Wednesday of WDC,

2:01:15an amazing time.

2:01:16- It blows me away.

2:01:18- Yeah, and I got to play with it.

2:01:21He was showing me on his, of course he had two watches.

2:01:23He had a second one to run the beta on

2:01:24because he's amazing.

2:01:26And it really is real.

2:01:31It wasn't just PR, it wasn't just a presentation.

2:01:34The gains are real.

2:01:36I too was just as skeptical.

2:01:39I was like, oh come on, there's no way

2:01:41it's gonna be that fast in reality.

2:01:42And it really is that fast in reality.

2:01:43It's not perfect, some of the animations still

2:01:46skip a little bit here and there.

2:01:48It's still very slow hardware,

2:01:50but it just seems like it was being used very poorly

2:01:54in watchOS 1 and 2.

2:01:56The hardware that's there, it's not as bad as it seemed.

2:01:59It's still very slow and very rudimentary hardware,

2:02:02but the software was seemingly making

2:02:05a lot of bad life choices before,

2:02:07and now they've really had a lot of time.

2:02:09And I mean, you know, I've been kind of cool on the watch

2:02:13in recent months and I don't really wear it anymore.

2:02:17But this, like, this is a huge update.

2:02:20This is a way bigger update and I'm way more impressed

2:02:24by it than I thought I would be with, you know,

2:02:26whatever watchOS 3 turned out to be this summer.

2:02:28I was not expecting this big of an update

2:02:30and this big of a change.

2:02:31And, you know, for them to reconsider and rethink

2:02:35some of the design of the watch software environment.

2:02:38and to get rid of the stupid friend circle,

2:02:39or at least move it somewhere else,

2:02:40and to get rid of glances,

2:02:42and to unify apps with glances,

2:02:44and to make, you know, all that stuff,

2:02:46you know, I've been thinking for a while,

2:02:47like, some of these things would be nice to do,

2:02:50but they're not gonna do it,

2:02:51because they already built this whole thing,

2:02:52and it's too late.

2:02:53And it turns out, it wasn't too late,

2:02:55and they changed their mind,

2:02:56'cause they saw how things were actually used,

2:02:58and they saw ways to make it better,

2:02:59and that's great.

2:03:01And as a developer of, you know,

2:03:03like I'm gonna make Overcast for the watch,

2:03:05you know, at some point soon,

2:03:06I don't know if I'll make it in time for day one,

2:03:08but I'm gonna try.

2:03:09'Cause my old watch app, based on WatchKit 1,

2:03:13it was just terrible.

2:03:14It was just too slow, too unreliable.

2:03:16And I didn't upgrade it to watchOS 2

2:03:18because it was gonna be a ton of work.

2:03:20'Cause watchOS 2 was not too different for users,

2:03:23but it was very different for developers.

2:03:25So it was gonna be a ton of work to do,

2:03:28and the gains just were not really there.

2:03:30So I decided not to do it,

2:03:32and to just wait and see what OS 3 brought.

2:03:34And I'm sure that I did because--

2:03:36- Yeah.

2:03:36- OS 3 is a major, major upgrade for users and developers,

2:03:40and now it's possible to actually make decent apps.

2:03:43Like before, even the best app you could make

2:03:45for watchOS 1 and 2, it was pretty mediocre to actually use.

2:03:49Now it's actually possible to make good, compelling apps

2:03:53for the watch, and it's still not easy,

2:03:54and there's still plenty of limitations,

2:03:56but it's at least possible,

2:03:58and there's good stuff to be done there.

2:04:00- I can't think of anything else to compare it to,

2:04:02except maybe when Mac OS X first came out,

2:04:04I know this predates you as a Mac user,

2:04:06but Mac OS 10.0 was so dreadfully slow.

2:04:11It was everything.

2:04:13I mean, just clicking on a menu

2:04:15and having the menu drop down was slow

2:04:17because it just, what Aqua was doing,

2:04:21what the user interface was doing

2:04:22was so far ahead of the hardware that it was just slow.

2:04:27And it was, what made that so painful was one thing

2:04:32that was not a problem with the classic Mac OS was,

2:04:35for lack of a better word, snappiness.

2:04:38The UI, there were lots of technical problems

2:04:40with the old Mac OS, but it was very snappy,

2:04:43because, and part of that was simply because

2:04:45it was so far behind the hardware,

2:04:47because it was this OS, the problems with the OS

2:04:50was that it had low-level parts that dated to the '80s,

2:04:54and here we are running it on 2000, 2001

2:04:58Power Mac G3 hardware.

2:05:00the hardware was way more powerful than what the software was originally designed for,

2:05:05and it made it real fast.

2:05:06And so, you know, most of us at the time were either dual-booting between the two for different

2:05:10tasks or we had, like, I used to run Mac OS 9 on my desktop and I'd have Mac OS 10 on

2:05:17my PowerBook.

2:05:19And it was so painful to switch.

2:05:21And 10.1 came out, like, five months later, six months later, something like that, like,

2:05:27way less than a year later, and was a pretty big improvement.

2:05:30It was still slow, but it had obviously gotten a lot of low-hanging fruit out of the what's

2:05:34making this feel so slow.

2:05:37But it was nowhere near as dramatic as this watchOS 2 to 3.

2:05:41It was a nice improvement, but it was really like a series of iterative improvements over

2:05:46like four years.

2:05:47As I recall, sometime around like 10.4 was when Mac OS X finally felt like, "Okay, this

2:05:53is...

2:05:54It may not be fast yet, but it's at least not slow."

2:05:57I'm trying to figure out what is going on with watchOS 3.

2:06:00How is this possible?

2:06:01- Well, I mean, I think Federighi's explanation

2:06:03last week on the talk show was great,

2:06:05which is basically many of the things

2:06:09that were making watchOS so slow before

2:06:12were just extreme conservatism

2:06:15about how things are kept in memory,

2:06:18what apps can do, what they can't do,

2:06:21what kind of background operations they can and can't do.

2:06:23That's one of the reasons why,

2:06:24basically with watchOS 1 and 2,

2:06:26every time you launch an app,

2:06:27it was basically launching from scratch.

2:06:29And it was not really able to do much, if anything,

2:06:33in the background in the meantime.

2:06:34So you'd have to launch it,

2:06:35then you'd have to wait for it to get new data

2:06:37'cause the data it had was out of date.

2:06:38And it was just slow and it was a pain.

2:06:41And then you'd go and you'd try to launch it again,

2:06:43like a few minutes later,

2:06:44after the watch turned off to save power,

2:06:46you'd go to launch it again like a few minutes later

2:06:48or a few seconds later,

2:06:49and you'd be back to the clock face or the home screen.

2:06:51You have to go back to the app again,

2:06:52or double click on the button

2:06:54to get the last used app or whatever.

2:06:56And it was just, it was way too aggressive

2:06:59about kicking apps out of memory

2:07:00and about researching what they could do in the background.

2:07:03And so, and Federighi explained it very well.

2:07:05It's basically like, the explanation was basically like,

2:07:08oh, we had extra RAM.

2:07:09Like we overshot our budget on RAM and power

2:07:11and it turns out, you know,

2:07:12the way people use the watch is different

2:07:13and it works better than we thought it would

2:07:15for RAM and power.

2:07:17So we spent some of it.

2:07:18So, you know, the watch now, like with OS 3,

2:07:22if you use any of these new features

2:07:24of having these apps in the dock

2:07:25and having them be updated more often,

2:07:27or especially if you put them in complications,

2:07:28then they can update a lot more often.

2:07:30You are going to get less battery life,

2:07:32but I think it can,

2:07:35when I wear the watch every day,

2:07:37most days I'd go to bed and the battery would be at 50%.

2:07:40So I'd be willing to spare a little bit of battery life

2:07:43to make the thing more useful to me.

2:07:45- I think that's all true,

2:07:48and again, I think Federighi's explanation was interesting,

2:07:51and I think very honest.

2:07:52I think that being stingy with RAM was probably very much true.

2:07:58But strategically, here's my theory.

2:08:00I think what we're seeing is that Apple released the watch too early and that this is what

2:08:08they should have launched with.

2:08:09And that the process that they went through of having what we know as watchOS 1 and then

2:08:17and watchOS 2 was what they should have

2:08:20and in the past usually went through internally

2:08:23before they got to, okay, this is good enough.

2:08:26That they were probably like a version of the iPhone

2:08:29that was every bit as crappy as the user experience

2:08:33of watchOS 1 and maybe not even crappiness,

2:08:37but maybe like the confusing nature of the UI paradigm

2:08:40and the convolutedness and like there's like,

2:08:44there were like some yada, yada, yada parts of it

2:08:46where there's no real spatial thing.

2:08:48It's like, well, you drag, you know,

2:08:49these glances are down there and you drag them up

2:08:51and the apps are, you know, like behind the watch face,

2:08:54you click this button and you get to the apps

2:08:56and then they pop forward.

2:08:57And the apps, the glances are sort of like an app,

2:08:59except they're limited, but they're always there.

2:09:01And it's like, well, why are they down?

2:09:03What's, why is this other thing underneath?

2:09:05I feel like everything probably goes through that.

2:09:08And again, I always hate to bring out the,

2:09:13you know, Steve Jobs card,

2:09:15but that one of his gifts was,

2:09:18of course he was great at motivating people

2:09:20to work really hard and ship things ahead of their time,

2:09:22but I also think that he had an uncanny ability

2:09:25to keep saying not good enough, not good enough,

2:09:29even if it meant shipping years after he wanted to ship.

2:09:33- Yeah, and as we talked about earlier,

2:09:37with Tim versus Phil and everybody else

2:09:39for product direction,

2:09:40Steve was the head of product direction.

2:09:44He was the chief editor,

2:09:45and I think he played large roles

2:09:48in product choices and direction.

2:09:51And you can't have somebody like that

2:09:55just removed and gone forever and have things not change.

2:09:59Things are going to change,

2:10:00and not all of it's gonna be for the better.

2:10:02A lot of it's gonna be better,

2:10:03a lot of it's gonna be worse,

2:10:04a lot of it's just gonna be different.

2:10:05One of the things that changed is the role

2:10:07of that product editing and the head of product direction

2:10:11has now apparently, from what we can tell,

2:10:13kind of split up between these people.

2:10:15And the watch, from what I understand,

2:10:17the watch was kind of like a satellite project,

2:10:20and it seemed, there was a lot about the watch

2:10:22that was kind of bizarre, like some of the weird,

2:10:25creepy stretchy face emoji, and the whole Friends,

2:10:28the ring of Friends, you're supposed to digitally touch,

2:10:30I mean, the whole thing was weird.

2:10:32And again, some of the spatial things

2:10:36and why Watch Kit 1 was just so incredibly bad

2:10:39and why they decided to ship that,

2:10:40it does seem like that might have been partially because

2:10:44of this kind of split product responsibility.

2:10:47This was kind of relegated as a satellite project

2:10:50or a skunkworks kind of thing.

2:10:52Maybe not because it was considered low priority,

2:10:55but just because it was something new

2:10:56and everyone else was busy.

2:10:57I don't know, I don't know the reason,

2:10:58but it was clearly something

2:11:01from a side project division of Apple.

2:11:03It suffered in a number of ways because of that,

2:11:07and it seems like they've maybe realized

2:11:10this was not as good as we wanted it to be at first,

2:11:12so let's fix it, let's put some more into it,

2:11:14and let's actually fix it.

2:11:16- I think that they would have gotten

2:11:17to this point inevitably.

2:11:18I just think that it's almost like we've gotten

2:11:20an amazing behind-the-scenes look

2:11:21at how Apple goes through designs and iterates.

2:11:26And this makes so much more sense,

2:11:30just a basic fundamental level,

2:11:31and it works so much better.

2:11:33You have to remember, too, that two years ago,

2:11:35so two years ago at this point,

2:11:36The watch hadn't been announced yet.

2:11:39It was announced in September two years ago.

2:11:42But it was rumored.

2:11:43And at the time Apple was under inordinate scrutiny

2:11:47for Apple can't innovate anymore

2:11:51because Steve Jobs isn't there.

2:11:53And they haven't had a new product since the iPod,

2:11:56or iPad in 2010, and now it's been forever,

2:11:59and they're overdue for a product.

2:12:01So they were under tremendous scrutiny for,

2:12:05hey, how about you release something new

2:12:06and show us that you can still amaze us.

2:12:09And I think part of that was pressure on Tim Cook, the CEO,

2:12:12and I think part of that was definitely pressure on Johnny

2:12:14Ive as, well, let's see what Johnny Ive can do now

2:12:17that he doesn't have Steve Jobs.

2:12:18And ultimately, we don't know who it is who got to say,

2:12:23OK, let's ship the watch this year.

2:12:25We'll announce it in September and ship it sometime later,

2:12:29probably next year.

2:12:31I don't know who made that decision that this is

2:12:33good enough to ship, but I think in hindsight,

2:12:35especially now that we've seen watchOS 3,

2:12:37it was clearly too soon.

2:12:38I think that the watch should have been announced this year.

2:12:41And maybe I'm wrong because two more years of where's,

2:12:46you know, how about a new product?

2:12:47How about a new product?

2:12:48How about a new product?

2:12:49Maybe that would have been too much to bear.

2:12:51But I just feel like this really feels to me

2:12:54like what watch 1.0 should have been.

2:12:56- Yeah, oh, and no question.

2:12:58I mean, it's, it's still not perfect.

2:13:02I mean, nothing ever is really.

2:13:03But it is such an improvement,

2:13:06and to have such an improvement after,

2:13:10what is a relatively short time, really,

2:13:12I mean, heck, the hardware is feeling pretty old

2:13:15at this point, I wish they'd update that,

2:13:16but to have the software go from where it was last year

2:13:20to this in one year is very impressive.

2:13:23But on the other side of that,

2:13:25do you think they actually would have reached

2:13:27this conclusion internally?

2:13:28'Cause one of the things they can't do really internally

2:13:30is learn what people will do and what developers will do

2:13:35with like, how many apps will you use?

2:13:37What will apps want to do?

2:13:39What apps will end up being compelling

2:13:40and which apps won't?

2:13:42They kind of can't do that very well

2:13:44without just releasing it and seeing what the app market

2:13:46and what the users actually do with it.

2:13:47But there is a lot of stuff about like the initial release

2:13:50of the watch that you look at and you're like,

2:13:53did they test this much internally?

2:13:55Like, did they really think this was gonna be good?

2:13:59I don't know.

2:14:00- Yeah, some of the stuff that is in watchOS 3

2:14:02definitely wouldn't have been there

2:14:04if they hadn't launched and observed

2:14:06what people really use it for.

2:14:08And a big one is fitness tracking,

2:14:10that an awful lot of Apple Watch purchasers,

2:14:14I think maybe they told me in a briefing

2:14:17what the percentage is, but it's big.

2:14:19I don't know if it's public or not,

2:14:20but a big percentage that they have found

2:14:22if people buy it primarily as a fitness tracking device,

2:14:25that it is just a one-to-one competitor

2:14:28with like a Fitbit or something like that.

2:14:30And therefore, they really, really focused

2:14:33on the fitness and activity tracking in watchOS 3.

2:14:38I think that the new default watch face

2:14:40is the one that shows the circles as the dial.

2:14:44I think that's how big of a deal fitness tracking is,

2:14:46that it's now the default watch face.

2:14:49- It was, I mean, when I used it,

2:14:53I was all about the fitness rings.

2:14:55And if I cared less about watch face design,

2:14:59I would gladly say that as my home screen.

2:15:02Right now I'm just too much of a picky jerk

2:15:04to wanna use that, but--

2:15:05- So that's there too.

2:15:08I mean, there is, in some ways, Apple is benefiting

2:15:10from the release early and often.

2:15:13And especially in the way,

2:15:15I think the other thing we're seeing,

2:15:17and I think it makes sense to me,

2:15:19that software takes longer than hardware in some ways.

2:15:24Oh yeah, easy.

2:15:25Especially like to design, because it's too nebulous.

2:15:30There's too many infinite possibilities.

2:15:34It's the constraints of hardware.

2:15:36Like, well, look, it has to look good.

2:15:39Johnny's made this design.

2:15:40It can't be any bigger than this.

2:15:42It has to be this small so that there's like a model that people

2:15:45with smaller wrists and like women and children

2:15:47can wear without looking ridiculous.

2:15:50And the most energy efficient screen we have

2:15:55is gonna consume this much power

2:15:57and take all these constraints

2:15:58and figure out what the best thing is,

2:16:00is almost, it makes it faster to come up with the design

2:16:03than the infinite possibilities of software.

2:16:06- Yeah, although to be fair, I mean,

2:16:08I think as we're seeing the Apple Watch hardware

2:16:12get somewhat long in the tooth now,

2:16:15if you look around the smartwatch landscape,

2:16:17when the Apple Watch first came out,

2:16:18the smartwatch landscape looked pretty miserable.

2:16:20There was almost nothing else of value.

2:16:23There was, like, on the low end you had Pebble,

2:16:26and Pebble watches are basically the modern day

2:16:29geeks quartz watch.

2:16:30So it's like, you know, it's not like that,

2:16:35like, you know, high fashion, it's not particularly

2:16:38glamorous or even graceful or even, you know,

2:16:42necessarily even nice, but it served a very useful purpose

2:16:45and it was like a great utility.

2:16:48and it looked like it, but it was priced like it too,

2:16:50and it was fine.

2:16:51Then you had like--

2:16:52- I still, I root for them.

2:16:53I don't like Pebble.

2:16:54I bought one and I did not like it,

2:16:56but I still root for them as a company

2:16:57because I really enjoy the fact

2:16:59that they have a very different set of priorities

2:17:01than anybody else.

2:17:02They're definitely appealing to nerds.

2:17:04They're definitely appealing to people

2:17:07who wanna get notifications from apps and stuff,

2:17:08but they value practicality above anything else

2:17:12to a ridiculous degree,

2:17:14and that's very different than Apple.

2:17:16- And also, again,

2:17:17I gotta give them credit, their pricing is really low

2:17:19for what you're getting, it's a very good value.

2:17:21And then, so we had that and then we had like

2:17:23the initial batch of Android Wear watches

2:17:26which were just horrible, like they were just the worst.

2:17:29But that was now, what, almost two years ago.

2:17:33They've moved on, Pebble has gotten better,

2:17:36they're still not my style but I greatly respect

2:17:40the progress they've made in that time.

2:17:41And the Android Wear watches, like I'm now seeing

2:17:44Android Wear watches in person, in the world, like around.

2:17:48And occasionally, I'll be somewhere,

2:17:49like I was getting my windshield replaced,

2:17:52thanks Highway Rocks, and the service guy I was talking to

2:17:56had an Android Wear, I'm like, what is that watch?

2:17:58And I asked him about it, and it was,

2:18:00I forget which one he said it was,

2:18:01it was, is the LG Urbane a thing, is that a watch?

2:18:06It might have been that one

2:18:07that's sticking out my head for some reason.

2:18:08But I've seen now a number of Android Wear smartwatches

2:18:12in person that look decent.

2:18:15They're all pretty big for me,

2:18:17but they look decent.

2:18:19And I think they might even look more modern

2:18:24than the Apple Watch, possibly,

2:18:25just because it's a fresher look.

2:18:28Again, just like with the Mac Pro,

2:18:30Apple set the bar for this is gonna be the future

2:18:34and it's gonna be all this GPU power,

2:18:35then they just didn't follow through.

2:18:37With the Apple Watch, they set a big bar on fashion.

2:18:40and to have this object that is supposed to be

2:18:43like this fashionable accessory that you wear

2:18:47and then to not update the hardware for a long time

2:18:51is, I don't know, I worry about that with the Apple Watch,

2:18:54but I think it'll be all right in the long term.

2:18:57Anyway.

2:18:58- I think we're seeing a pattern that repeated

2:18:59that started with the original iPhone where,

2:19:02so the iPhone 3G did come out a year

2:19:05after the original iPhone, but it was barely an upgrade.

2:19:09I mean, it was really just the 3G.

2:19:11And I always forget, there's something else.

2:19:13Maybe it was like GPS.

2:19:14- It had a GPS, yeah.

2:19:15- Yeah, so it wasn't just the 3G,

2:19:18but the 3G is the one that affected me on a daily basis.

2:19:20Like, I just remember thinking like,

2:19:22"Wow, I really hate the way this phone feels

2:19:25"compared to my old one, but oh my God,

2:19:26"3G is so much better than Edge."

2:19:29But otherwise, they really didn't get

2:19:31like a performance upgrade until the 3GS two years later.

2:19:34And so it's looking like the performance,

2:19:36the serious performance upgrade for the watch

2:19:38come two years after the announcement, a year and a half after it was released.

2:19:44I think ultimately what the Apple Watch needed from the beginning, and we're seeing some

2:19:50of that now with OS 3, and we'll see what happens on the hardware side, what it needed

2:19:54from the beginning was just like focus and editing.

2:19:56You know, like at the beginning it was like, "Oh, I can do all these different things,

2:19:59and we have this crazy gold version."

2:20:01You know, the number of like rough edges that got sanded off, you know, as the product found

2:20:05its place in the market. I think though like I don't know I mean you know you

2:20:12and I are both watch nerds also and I I'm not sure that the right formula for

2:20:19something that's supposed to be a mass-market watch is to have everybody

2:20:24wearing the same shape the same looking rectangle with different bands like

2:20:29physically I think there needs to be more variety in the physical attributes

2:20:35of the watch itself, for that to succeed in that way,

2:20:37if they want to, and they might not have a chance.

2:20:41Like, fashion and watch nerds might just move too quickly

2:20:44or be too picky, or, you know,

2:20:46it just might not work for them,

2:20:48but if they're gonna go for that, like,

2:20:51high-end or even mid-range fashionable angle for this,

2:20:55it needs more variety in the actual watch body.

2:20:59- I don't know about that. - And that requires

2:21:00a different kind of software focus that they're not taking,

2:21:03so I'm guessing they're not going in that direction,

2:21:04- Yeah, there doesn't seem to be anything in watchOS 3

2:21:06that would hint at a circular face, for example.

2:21:09- Yeah, or even just like, you know, maybe have,

2:21:11maybe have like a passive mode, or some,

2:21:14or where you're always showing something on screen,

2:21:16or maybe have, maybe have some that are, maybe not round,

2:21:19but like, maybe have like a thin model

2:21:21that maybe doesn't have the heart rate tracker on the back.

2:21:23If for people who don't want that, but want, you know,

2:21:25a dressier version or something, like,

2:21:28just having more hardware variety,

2:21:29'cause like bands are nice, and they do make amazing bands.

2:21:33Overall, Apple's watch bands are excellent.

2:21:35And some of them, like the Link bracelet,

2:21:37I think I've never seen anything better than that

2:21:39in the rest of the watch world.

2:21:40But, but like, there's still like,

2:21:44you're still basically everyone's wearing the same watch.

2:21:47And when it comes to fashion, the one thing,

2:21:49I don't know a lot about fashion,

2:21:51but the one thing I do know is that you don't wanna be

2:21:53wearing literally the exact same thing

2:21:54everybody else is wearing.

2:21:56- Yeah.

2:21:57- You want some kind of variety there,

2:21:58some kind of individuality,

2:22:00and putting on a different band is not enough.

2:22:02That helps, it's better than nothing, but it's not enough.

2:22:04- While at WWDC, I had a very enjoyable afternoon

2:22:09with CGP Grey, a good friend of yours.

2:22:14- That guy's an enigma.

2:22:16- It was, it was funny.

2:22:17I was gonna bring up coffee, but we met,

2:22:20we started with coffee, and we met at Blue Bottle,

2:22:23and it was very, very funny,

2:22:25'cause I didn't know what he looked like.

2:22:27It was like, "Oh, what about Blue Bottle?

2:22:29"I'll meet you there, I need coffee."

2:22:30And he's like, "I need coffee too."

2:22:31So I got there and as right as I got to the line,

2:22:36and the line was very long,

2:22:38I mean like long even by blue bottle standards,

2:22:41I got a DM from Gray that just said,

2:22:43"No man should stand on the line this long."

2:22:45And I turned around and there he was.

2:22:48And it was exquisitely pulled in.

2:22:49It was an amazing introduction 'cause he timed the text

2:22:53and as soon as I turned around, there he was.

2:22:55And I just said, "Yeah, this sucks, let's go to Pete's."

2:22:58And he was like, "Fine."

2:22:59And we just walked over to the,

2:23:01I can't even tell you during WWDC how often that happens.

2:23:04I like Blue Bottle, but I don't like Blue Bottle,

2:23:06wait half an hour in line,

2:23:08and then wait another 10 minutes for the drip.

2:23:11- No, it is good coffee, but it's not that good.

2:23:13It isn't good enough to wait on that line.

2:23:15- So we got, you knew were there with me

2:23:17the day of the keynote.

2:23:19We went to Phil's, or Phil's E,

2:23:21I don't know how you pronounce it.

2:23:21- I think it's just Phil's.

2:23:22I liked it, honestly.

2:23:23I had a good cup of coffee there.

2:23:26I would say that was the best cup of coffee

2:23:27I had that week.

2:23:28- Well, I also liked their system,

2:23:30where you don't just order and then it goes in a queue.

2:23:33It's like you wait for a barista to become available

2:23:36and then you place your order and then they make your,

2:23:40I always get drip coffee,

2:23:41and then they make your drip coffee

2:23:43and it takes like two or three minutes.

2:23:44I got worried 'cause I skipped out of the keynote

2:23:47about 20 minutes before it started

2:23:49because they ran out of, they didn't have--

2:23:50- It was like 10 minutes.

2:23:52You were late, weren't you?

2:23:53- No, I was there with plenty,

2:23:55I was there with a couple minutes to spare.

2:23:56So what happened is I got to the Bill Graham Center

2:23:59at like 9.05 in the morning.

2:24:01And I think they let people in before nine o'clock,

2:24:04the press people at least.

2:24:05And I got there at like 9.05, 9.10, I said hello,

2:24:08I saw some people I knew and some Apple PR people

2:24:11and said hello, hello, went over to the coffee

2:24:13and it was all gone.

2:24:14It was all gone at like 9.10.

2:24:17And I was like, what the hell's going on?

2:24:19And I went in and I found a seat and--

2:24:21- I mean, granted, if that was the same coffee

2:24:24they were serving outside on the line,

2:24:25they were doing you a favor.

2:24:27I guess, because it probably was the same coffee.

2:24:31It just threw me off, because my normal way

2:24:34is to go to Blue Bottle.

2:24:36And then I go with my Blue Bottle,

2:24:38and then go to Moscow-- when I used to be at Moscone--

2:24:40and then go say hi to all my friends who

2:24:43are waiting in line for the keynote while I've done it

2:24:46to you.

2:24:47Yes, every year.

2:24:49You're waiting in line, and you've been up

2:24:51since like 5 in the morning.

2:24:53And I just woke up, and I have delicious coffee,

2:24:55and I'm gonna use my magic press pass

2:24:57to go right to the front of the line and get in.

2:24:59- And get a front row seat.

2:25:00- And I've always enjoyed that.

2:25:02Well, I didn't know what to do this time.

2:25:03I had to get a cab to get to the build,

2:25:06I didn't have to get a cab,

2:25:07but to get there as soon as I could, I wanted to get there.

2:25:10So anyway, 20 of or so I told Ben, I was like,

2:25:12"Screw this, I'm gonna go find coffee."

2:25:14So I ran out of the building

2:25:15and found the Phil Z about two blocks away.

2:25:18And I didn't know anything about Phil Z

2:25:22except I'd heard good things,

2:25:23but I just wanted to drip coffee.

2:25:24And Ben wanted one too.

2:25:26So Ben didn't have the guts to go.

2:25:27He just said, "Get me one."

2:25:29And I saw that they were gonna make it pour over

2:25:32and that they didn't have pre-made coffee

2:25:34that they could just pour into a cup for me.

2:25:36And I thought, oh, this, at Blue Bottle,

2:25:39this would take too long.

2:25:40I'd missed the opening of the keynote.

2:25:41I said, "How long is this gonna take?"

2:25:42And she goes, "Oh, just two or three minutes."

2:25:44And two minutes later, I had my two coffees

2:25:46and I was out the door.

2:25:48Excellent.

2:25:51I was so sad because I had just met Federico Vatici

2:25:55late the night before.

2:25:57And he's really into, he's Italian for one,

2:26:00and he's really into coffee.

2:26:01And so I had to have my first coffee with Federico Vatici

2:26:06as the crappy coffee in the line at Bill Graham.

2:26:11And I was like, I'm so sorry, I'm like,

2:26:13we shouldn't really drink this, like please.

2:26:15And to have that be the first coffee that I have

2:26:19with Federico Vatici is just heartbreaking.

2:26:20- Criminal.

2:26:21- And so fortunately, we went with you after the keynote,

2:26:24we met you outside and we went with you

2:26:26and we went back to Pete's and got better coffee there.

2:26:28- Phil Z we went to.

2:26:29- Yeah, right, yeah, sorry, Phil Z, yeah.

2:26:32And that was so much better, I feel like that made up for it

2:26:34like I'm just gonna forget about the urn coffee

2:26:38that we had in the line and just hope nobody

2:26:42got a picture of it and, oh man, it was such a shame.

2:26:45But you know, the Phil's or Phil Z actually made up for it

2:26:49that was really good coffee and I had that for the line going back into the

2:26:52State of the Union and that was like I feel like that was like the forgiveness

2:26:55for the morning. I kind of can't believe how honest their system is like you go

2:27:00to a barista you wait you wait till a barista calls you and it's sort of like

2:27:04a barbershop system where you wait in line until a barista says okay I'm ready

2:27:08next and then you go to the barista they make whatever you ordered then they call

2:27:12your name when it's ready and they give you the drink you haven't paid for

2:27:15anything yet. They just give you the drink and then you are—it's just on you to go

2:27:19over to where the register is, which is separate, and then just tell them what's in the cup,

2:27:23and then you pay what you owe them. I'm glad, because it seems like it makes it very efficient,

2:27:29but it seems to rely on the honor policy to a degree that you don't really see in retail

2:27:35places.

2:27:36I'm also curious to hear if you get any flack about us talking up fills on this episode,

2:27:42when I tweeted a few days back that Phil's was the best

2:27:46cup of coffee I had in San Francisco that week,

2:27:49I got a lot of responses that seemed to indicate

2:27:52this is not a widespread opinion.

2:27:54And that apparently Phil's is looked down upon

2:27:58by a lot of coffee snobs in San Francisco.

2:28:00And I gotta say, I only had one cup of coffee there

2:28:03'cause it was only near Bill Graham.

2:28:06I don't think there was one closer to where we were.

2:28:08- Yeah, I don't think so either.

2:28:09- I only had the one cup there,

2:28:11But that one cup was definitely way better

2:28:14than what I had at Blue Bottle,

2:28:16what I had at other places, like way better.

2:28:18- I'm not, I don't have the fine palette that you do,

2:28:21but I had one, I think I only had one Blue Bottle this week

2:28:24and it was good, but the combined experience was worse

2:28:27because even in the best case scenario,

2:28:29you have to wait so much longer.

2:28:30- Right, I have never gone to Blue Bottle in San Francisco

2:28:33and decided, you know what, that was worth it.

2:28:34Because it's like, I always, you know, I try to go,

2:28:37I try to go like before going to the first session

2:28:40Moscone. And so I'm in kind of a rush and I never leave enough time when I wake up in

2:28:46the morning because who wants to wake up earlier than you have to. So you know, it's certainly

2:28:49not us.

2:28:50So like, you know, I go down the blue bottle, there's this huge line, I'm like, "Oh, you

2:28:53got to be kidding me." I wait in the line, I wait, I wait, I wait. Eventually I get the

2:28:57coffee after way too long and I'm sitting there and then I had like, you know, something

2:29:00cost fallacy halfway through the line like, "God, I really, this is, I'm going to be late

2:29:04to the session, I'm going to miss the first 20 minutes of it if I wait in this line, but

2:29:07I've already weighed on this line for the last 15 minutes. It seems like I'm getting close to the beginning, you know

2:29:11So all the all those fallacies and stresses finally get the coffee and then I have a problem on my hands because now I have this

2:29:19Huge full cup of very very hot liquid. They don't double cup there the best you could

2:29:25They don't have those little jackets

2:29:27The best you can do is wrap a napkin around to try to insulate your hand from this scorching hot cup of coffee that

2:29:33Like I saw then I have to walk from there to Moscone which is you know a medium walk a few blocks

2:29:39Trying to spill this coffee on my hand or anywhere else as I'm walking with it

2:29:43But it's way too hot to begin drinking

2:29:45then I finally get to Moscone and I have again this

2:29:48giant cup of hot liquid that I have to just like still be carrying with me and doing something with

2:29:52Until I finally go into a session at which point there's nowhere to put it in the session

2:29:56You know, you can put it on the floor

2:29:58But that's a big risk getting kicked over and you don't want to be that guy who spills hot coffee on the on the rug

2:30:03in Moscone. So like you're basically left like holding this thing for like the

2:30:07next half hour as it cools down to a drinkable temperature and then you have

2:30:11this giant cup of coffee that you basically have to finish and usually

2:30:14that's too much caffeine for me even at even their small size usually I only

2:30:17drink like two-thirds of it but I feel kind of pressured to finish the whole

2:30:20thing is like well I have nowhere to put this then I'm like buzzed over the whole

2:30:23person it's just every time I say you know what that wasn't worth it next time

2:30:28I should just either like you know grab an espresso somewhere you know anywhere

2:30:32anywhere can serve a reasonable espresso in that area. So like, just grab a quick espresso,

2:30:37or just tolerate the Moscone coffee, or just drink tea. Every time I think that, and every

2:30:42time I forget to do it the next time.

2:30:44John Greenewald They need those things that Gray and Brady

2:30:47are always talking about, the hot stoppers. Isn't that what they call them?

2:30:49Ben de la Torre Yeah, that would solve one of those problems.

2:30:51John Greenewald It would solve the travel problem.

2:30:52Ben de la Torre Yes, but that's it.

2:30:53John Greenewald Philz gives out hot stoppers because there

2:30:55was, I actually kind of jogged back from Philz to the keynote with two coffees. And so without

2:31:01hot stoppers I would have two mangled scarred hands anyway but you would have

2:31:07good coffee though the whole reason I brought or was reminded to mention gray

2:31:11was I know one of his pet bugaboos with the watch as he wants third-party watch

2:31:17faces yeah I love that I broke it to him and I'm gonna break it to you that that

2:31:21is never gonna happen it is not gonna happen and this is gonna make sense to

2:31:26you and it made sense to Gray but it's this weird crevice that Apple and only

2:31:31Apple is in in the smartwatch world where they do fancying themselves to be

2:31:37a real watch company and as a real watch company they have there's certain things

2:31:44that everything anything that you can see is always going to be San Francisco

2:31:47now they could maybe enforce that for third parties possibly any analog dial

2:31:53is going to use those hands. That's the Apple style of watch hands.

2:31:58The big ovals. I don't know what you call them, but those big ovals, the

2:32:02capsule-shaped hands. I guess they're... are they? Yeah, they are ovals. Yeah.

2:32:06Yeah. And, you know, in the real world, high-end watch companies

2:32:12typically have things like that, like the hands on a Rolex. They're not all

2:32:16identical. There might be like two or three different styles of Rolex hands,

2:32:19but they're all Rolexes are have hands that are instantly recognizable as Rolex hands.

2:32:25Yeah, they're kind of all like in a family.

2:32:27Yeah, in a family. And the dials are all unmistakably Rolex style dials. And insert

2:32:35name of your favorite high-end watch company here. And those things are true for all of them,

2:32:41because anybody if it wasn't true for them, they wouldn't be a high-end watch company.

2:32:44And Apple fancies itself a high-end watch company and therefore,

2:32:47And if you look at all of their dials, other than the Mickey one, which is sort of an exception,

2:32:52the Mickey ones are a little different.

2:32:57They're unmistakably Apple watchy.

2:32:59There's an Apple watchiness to all of their analog ones and the digital ones too.

2:33:05So therefore there's no way they're going to open that up to third parties and have

2:33:08people making watches that look like, I don't know, Omegas or something like that.

2:33:14It's never going to happen.

2:33:15- There's so many, yeah, I mean,

2:33:17there's the intellectual property infringement problem.

2:33:20And if you look at other smartwatch platforms,

2:33:22you know, Pebble, Android, like, they do have this problem

2:33:24where there are tons of, like, knockoff faces

2:33:28of, like, popular watch brands.

2:33:29Like, there's just copyright and trademark infringement

2:33:32all over the place.

2:33:32Like, it's a mess.

2:33:34And so, of course, Apple wouldn't want that,

2:33:35and certainly wouldn't want the liability

2:33:37of dealing with that, nor the kind of, like,

2:33:38you know, lowbrow nature of that.

2:33:40But also, you know, technically speaking,

2:33:42I think there's a lot of technical reasons

2:33:44why Apple would want to control the face app.

2:33:47And they could overcome these barriers

2:33:50if they really wanted to.

2:33:50They could make like, basically like a watch face kit

2:33:54and have you kind of like supply certain custom behaviors

2:33:58or certain graphics or whatever else

2:34:00but have them kind of still run the code.

2:34:02They could do a system like that if they wanted to.

2:34:05But I think they don't want to for these reasons.

2:34:07And I think you're right

2:34:08that we're probably never gonna get that.

2:34:09And honestly, the reason I want it is completely selfish.

2:34:13The reason I want it is because I want to design my own watch face is because I'm a huge like watch face design critic nerd.

2:34:20Like, I nitpick every watch face I see and there are very few that I'm happy with.

2:34:25And even the ones I'm happy with I'm usually like only mostly happy with because I'm that kind of nerd.

2:34:30And I think you are probably similar in that regard. Is that safe?

2:34:34Yeah, there's watches that I like except I find if I find that the hour hand is just too close to the size of the minute hand, it's out.

2:34:42(laughing)

2:34:43- Yeah, I mean like, yeah, 'cause that's legitimate.

2:34:46That impacts legibility of telling the time quickly.

2:34:48- Yeah, and, or vice versa.

2:34:50Maybe the hour hand strikes me as too small.

2:34:52Now there's, it's, there's no confusion,

2:34:55but to me it just looks ungainly.

2:34:58- Right. - Has to be in proportion.

2:34:59- And I'm in trouble with watch faces

2:35:01because I've been affected by,

2:35:03I've been bitten by the like,

2:35:05getting annoyed by poor placement of date windows bug.

2:35:09- Yeah. - Where like,

2:35:10There's like this design virus

2:35:13destroying the watch industry right now

2:35:14'cause everyone's putting date windows all over the place

2:35:16'cause it turns out most people who buy a watch

2:35:18want to have the date on it somewhere.

2:35:20And so you have to kind of like shove it somewhere

2:35:22on the dial and there's lots of easy

2:35:25but bad places to do it.

2:35:26Like oh, we'll just cut the three in half

2:35:28and kind of stick it there.

2:35:30Or we're gonna stick it diagonally

2:35:31between the four and the five and it's like,

2:35:33oh, it just looks so bad.

2:35:35- I'm picky about things like that,

2:35:37But the date complication in particular,

2:35:41you opened my eyes to the fact

2:35:43that there's a lot of watches coming out

2:35:44where it's in a bad place.

2:35:45And then once you start looking for it, you see it.

2:35:47And I think one of the reasons why is the,

2:35:50so many watches don't make their own movements.

2:35:54And so they're using like an ETA movement

2:35:57or the Japanese company now that ETA isn't really

2:36:01selling their movements on the open market.

2:36:04But if you're limited by what you can do

2:36:07to the standard movement, you're limited in certain ways

2:36:10as to where the date can go,

2:36:11and all of a sudden it just sticks out like,

2:36:13well, they didn't wanna put the date there,

2:36:15but they had to, and you can just see it.

2:36:17- Yeah.

2:36:19- It bothers me.

2:36:21- So many otherwise great watch face designs

2:36:23are ruined by a bad date window.

2:36:25- Yeah.

2:36:26Anything else you wanted to talk about this week?

2:36:27What else do you have on the list?

2:36:29- I mean, we've definitely lost all the listeners

2:36:31talking about watch design, so don't worry.

2:36:33Everyone's gone. - No, I don't think so.

2:36:34I think it ties in with watchOS 3.

2:36:36I really do.

2:36:37- I bet you have just lost more listeners

2:36:39during the last five minutes than you lose

2:36:40when you talk about baseball.

2:36:42(laughing)

2:36:44- I don't wanna talk about the podcast thing

2:36:46with the midroll.

2:36:47- Nah, it's too late.

2:36:48- Too late.

2:36:48I don't wanna talk about it.

2:36:51What about this car shifter thing?

2:36:52Do you see that?

2:36:53- I know the story, I know the whole recall thing.

2:36:56I have not actually seen the shifter,

2:36:58but I saw all the anecdotes of the complaints

2:37:01people had filed about like you know this this exact model of car or you know

2:37:05something with the same shit like this it started rolling backwards when I got

2:37:09out because I thought it was in park and I guess it shifts itself into neutral or

2:37:12something. I've never seen a car like this before I don't I guess I don't find

2:37:15myself in new cars all that often but it so the the car so the terrible traffic

2:37:20a picture of it this Anton Yelchin the guy who played Chekhov in the new Star

2:37:24Trek movies died in a terrible freak accident where is his Jeep Cherokee he

2:37:30got out of it, he thought he had it in park, apparently got out of it and it was in either

2:37:35in neutral or reverse and ran down the hill and pinned him against his own gate and he

2:37:40got killed. The design of this shifter is so bad. It just goes up and down. It's like

2:37:44a paddle. Think of it like a paddle shifter. So like if you're like in different mode,

2:37:49just kind of like, you know, up, up, up, down, down, that kind of thing. Yeah, it's exactly,

2:37:52it's like thinking of like it's so it's like you just hit up three times to put it in park,

2:37:57but if you hit up two times, you're in neutral.

2:37:59Or maybe it's like how hard you press it or something.

2:38:01But you're not actually moving it and clicking it

2:38:04into these positions like you do on a traditional one.

2:38:06And so it's so easy, I just cannot believe

2:38:09that this design shipped because I think I would see

2:38:14what a problem this design is, even without having

2:38:17the benefit of this tragic news story to put it in context.

2:38:20Because it just seems to me like this is a design

2:38:23where you have to be paying very close attention

2:38:25to the indicator light of what gear you're on.

2:38:27Whereas with the traditional one, I don't even look.

2:38:31I just hit the brake, push all the way up,

2:38:34and I know I'm in park.

2:38:35I can absolutely, with 100% certainty,

2:38:38put my car into park every single time blindfolded.

2:38:42- Right, I mean, this is, I think,

2:38:45I've seen in a lot of cars recently,

2:38:47especially higher-end cars and newer cars,

2:38:49a lot of the makers are kind of playing

2:38:51with the shifter lever and redesigning them

2:38:53different ways to make them electronically control

2:38:55instead of a direct linkage.

2:38:58And I apologize in advance to John Siracusa

2:39:01for getting any of this wrong

2:39:02'cause he's way more of a car nerd than I am.

2:39:04But basically everyone is messing with the shifter design

2:39:07and the parking brake designs.

2:39:10And there's so many of them are electronic now

2:39:11and so they have these weird controls

2:39:13that are of poor design.

2:39:16The good ones I've seen, it's weird at first to get used to,

2:39:20but it's actually better long-term,

2:39:22which is like the BMW ones,

2:39:25park is a button on top of the shifter.

2:39:28So the shifter moving up and down

2:39:29switches you between reverse neutral drive,

2:39:31but if you wanna put it in park,

2:39:32it's actually a button on top.

2:39:33So you can't, it's very clear

2:39:36which one of those things you're doing.

2:39:37Tesla's the same way, where Tesla, it's a column shifter,

2:39:40which this is the first time I've ever had a column shifter,

2:39:43but I got used to it pretty quick

2:39:45because it's like down is drive,

2:39:47and then there's a button on the end to hit it for park,

2:39:49and you have to hit that button every time.

2:39:50and the physical action of pushing that button in

2:39:55is nothing like any other operation on that lever.

2:39:57So you're very unlikely to accidentally do it.

2:40:00- Right, whereas on this Jeep design,

2:40:03putting it in park is just pushing a little bit long,

2:40:06either, I'm not quite sure if it's how long you press up

2:40:08or how many times you press up,

2:40:10but it's only ever so slightly different

2:40:12than putting it into neutral.

2:40:13And I'm laughing, and it's terrible that this guy died

2:40:16and that other people have obviously been hurt too

2:40:18because there's a product recall.

2:40:20But it's just mind-boggling that you would make

2:40:23putting it in park something that's hard to distinguish.

2:40:26- Yeah, I mean, it's, the bad design that goes into

2:40:31car interiors and that actually ships in car interiors

2:40:35boggles my mind.

2:40:36Like, there's so, and this is like way worse

2:40:39than date windows on watches.

2:40:40There is so much horrible design in car interiors

2:40:44and the controls in car interiors these days.

2:40:46- I don't think anybody's ever been killed

2:40:48by a poor placement of a date window on a watch dial?

2:40:50- Probably not.

2:40:52It's horrible, 'cause you know, as we see with this,

2:40:57design flaws in cars, that can cause

2:41:01actually fatal consequences.

2:41:03That can actually get people killed,

2:41:04and often they do actually get people killed.

2:41:07And it's, they gotta take design seriously,

2:41:10and when you have something like this,

2:41:11it's like, does anybody actually think about this?

2:41:14Do they do any testing?

2:41:15I mean, like, ah, it's just a tragedy.

2:41:18- Yeah, I do see the origins of why they would ship

2:41:23this horrible design was just the basic idea of,

2:41:25we wanna switch to an electronic system

2:41:28instead of a analog system of where this is.

2:41:32But, so okay, there's the why,

2:41:34but this was not the answer.

2:41:36This is terrible.

2:41:38Anything else?

2:41:41- No, I think that's it.

2:41:41we've definitely put most of the audience to sleep

2:41:45or lost them in the watch discussion.

2:41:47- I don't think so.

2:41:48I think people are gonna love the watch discussion.

2:41:50All right, well, we are under three hours,

2:41:52so that's exactly as predicted.

2:41:54I wanna thank our sponsors in reverse order,

2:41:56Ministry of Supply, Audible, and Wealthfront.

2:42:01And I wanna thank you, Marco Arment,

2:42:04your podcast, Accidental Tech Podcast, is at ATP.fm.

2:42:09You've also got, what else do you got?

2:42:11I got more podcasts now.

2:42:12- I got Under the Radar with _DavidSmith,

2:42:14relay.fm/radar, Top Four with my wife,

2:42:17relay.fm/topfour.

2:42:19- The wonderful Tiff Arment.

2:42:21- Yeah, she's the best.

2:42:23- Do you feel bad with the developer one

2:42:26where _ was totally up to date and knew all the APIs

2:42:29by Tuesday of WWDC week?

2:42:31Or do you just feel like, no, this is great,

2:42:35_ will fill me in on what I need to know?

2:42:38- Basically the latter.

2:42:39When you first become friends with Underscore,

2:42:42if you're a developer, you just feel incredibly lazy

2:42:45and inadequate by comparison.

2:42:46You're like, my God, what I did during this time

2:42:49was have a steak and edit a few photos and go to sleep.

2:42:54And what he did during this time was make four new apps

2:42:57and learn everything about all the APIs.

2:42:59And yeah, you definitely feel like, wow,

2:43:02I waste a lot of time compared to this guy.

2:43:03- He runs at a higher metabolism, clearly.

2:43:05We ran into him on Sunday, the first day we were out

2:43:08for WWDC and me and Amy and Paul,

2:43:12friend of the show Paul Kufasos,

2:43:16walked over to the Bill Graham Center

2:43:18so I could get my credentials and stuff.

2:43:20And we ran into Underscore on the way.

2:43:22We ran into a bunch, it was amazing,

2:43:23we ran into so many people on the way.

2:43:25Underscore is there, we're all freezing.

2:43:27It is like 61 degrees and windy

2:43:29and everybody is just frozen to bone.

2:43:31Underscore is wearing shorts and a t-shirt

2:43:32and looks totally comfortable.

2:43:35- Yeah, I mean, no, he's,

2:43:36The frustrating thing about Underscore is that he's just a really great person and there's

2:43:41basically no downsides.

2:43:45When somebody's super together in life, it's tempting to think, "Man, at least they're

2:43:51a jerk or something."

2:43:52You try to find something that makes you feel less bad about how you are less productive

2:43:57than them or something.

2:43:58With him, you just can't find that because he is just a really good guy.

2:44:02He's also very productive and it's very frustrating.

2:44:05The other thing that killed me is he was wearing a really big backpack.

2:44:07And so it looked like it was, you know, it was like,

2:44:10why are you wearing a big backpack? And it turns out that that was,

2:44:12it actually wasn't a really big backpack. It was a really small, uh,

2:44:16this is everything he had for the entire week. Like he is,

2:44:20he was just getting at, he hadn't checked into his hotel yet.

2:44:23So like everything he brought for an entire week in San Francisco was in the,

2:44:28you know, when I was thinking of just walking around for the afternoon,

2:44:32look like a very big backpack. When it realized that it was everything he had for the week,

2:44:36it's like, "I cannot believe how efficient he is. He's got to know one of those secret

2:44:40techniques for folding t-shirts or something."

2:44:42Marc Thiessen Yeah, we all have a lot to learn from him.

2:44:45Dave Asprey All right, thank you, Marco.

2:44:47Marc Thiessen Thanks.

2:44:47[