Podcast Search

The Talk Show

157: ‘A Nokia Phone and Some Pills (WWDC Prelude)’ With Dan Frommer

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00How you liking it over there?

0:00:01- It's awesome, it's great.

0:00:03It's fun, I mean, it's hard, but it's been really good.

0:00:10- Well, this is a busy time for you guys

0:00:11because it's like a busy time of the year period

0:00:14because it's like May and June is like

0:00:17when everybody in tech wants to,

0:00:19if they're launching anything, they're doing it now.

0:00:21Like you gotta get it out before July and August.

0:00:25And you guys have a big conference

0:00:26that just got wrapped up, right?

0:00:28Yeah, which was my third time as a, my third time attending it,

0:00:32but my first time working it and a totally different experience.

0:00:37But it's, I mean, it's, it is an amazing conference. It's probably, you know,

0:00:41obviously it's different than something like WWDC or CES,

0:00:45but as far as executive conferences go in tech that the public is

0:00:50invited, well, sort of invited to, um, I think it's the best one.

0:00:55- Well, the history clearly dates to

0:00:59when it was called All Things D.

0:01:01I mean, it's Kara and Walt and the big red chairs.

0:01:05- And it was basically the only conference

0:01:08that Steve Jobs went to besides Macworld

0:01:11and whatever Apple would put on.

0:01:13- Right, and the difference, the big difference

0:01:16is that when Apple puts on a keynote,

0:01:18it's not really a conference, it's,

0:01:19here's everything we have to say and it's prepared.

0:01:22and on stage there, it's Walt and Kara asking the questions.

0:01:27- Right, totally, yeah, the difference in preparedness

0:01:32and who kind of lays out what they talk about and all that.

0:01:36But it was great.

0:01:37Actually, watching the videos now,

0:01:42I kind of wonder, man, what if Jobs were still here?

0:01:47What would he be talking about?

0:01:50It kind of kind of ruins the mood, but, uh, watching Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk,

0:01:56um, just really, really exciting and really interesting.

0:01:59Yeah, it's a great list.

0:02:01I mean, I would, I would say, you know, it's pretty hard to top in today's

0:02:04executive world, Bezos, a one, two punch of Bezos and, and Elon Musk.

0:02:08Yeah, it was, it was great because Bezos kind of has taken the role of the.

0:02:13Elder statesman almost.

0:02:15Um, as far as like CEOs who are still really, really involved in the day to

0:02:20day, um, and you know, would talk not only at length about the products that their

0:02:25companies make, but just kind of the bigger picture in general, which is kind

0:02:28of the role that jobs would, would do.

0:02:30You know, he would talk not only in detail about how Apple thinks, but also just

0:02:34kind of what's going on in, in the world.

0:02:37And, you know, if you, if you haven't had a chance to watch the full videos,

0:02:4280 minutes of Jeff Bezos talking to Walt Mossberg.

0:02:45And then the other one was, I believe over an hour

0:02:49of Kara Swisher and Walt interviewing Elon Musk.

0:02:53They're all available for free on Recode.

0:02:56You should check them out.

0:02:57It's really interesting.

0:02:59And meanwhile, Musk kind of has played this role

0:03:02as like the wacky guy in a space suit, basically,

0:03:06who half of the talk was a physical lesson

0:03:12and the other half was, you know,

0:03:14let's pretend that we're inside of a video game.

0:03:17(laughs)

0:03:19I don't know, it was crazy and it was super fun.

0:03:22And that one came at the end of like,

0:03:24for me, a 16 hour day, so.

0:03:27- Yeah, that might be a little mind blowing

0:03:29to have Elon Musk up there, speculating on weather.

0:03:32I mean, the idea was, you know,

0:03:34it's not like he's the first person.

0:03:35I mean, anybody who ever smoked a little weed in college

0:03:37has had the same, the same,

0:03:42you could go down that rabbit hole pretty easily.

0:03:44But I mean, it's a serious question

0:03:46that actual scientists have pondered is,

0:03:48is the universe as we perceive it?

0:03:50Could it be a computer simulation

0:03:54of some kind of super advanced civilization?

0:03:58- Right, and I think his answer was like,

0:04:01there's a one in billion chance

0:04:03that we're not in a simulation.

0:04:05- Yeah, I have to say, I disagree with that.

0:04:09I kind of feel, I kind of lean towards

0:04:10Occam's razor explanation that, no, this probably is it.

0:04:14I don't want to-- you know, I think people should watch it.

0:04:19Because it's interesting to see a smart guy riff on this.

0:04:21It really is.

0:04:22So I'm not trying to discourage people

0:04:23from actually watching it.

0:04:24I promise to put the links to those two

0:04:26videos in the show notes.

0:04:27They really are worth watching.

0:04:30I think that the argument that there's

0:04:32an infinitesimally small chance that this is the real universe

0:04:36is that if you assume that computers are going

0:04:40going to keep getting faster at the rate that they've gotten faster, you know, and

0:04:44that civilization is going to, you know, we're not going to destroy ourselves.

0:04:48Eventually we're going to have computers that could simulate something as

0:04:52complex as the universe and they're going to have, you know, and there are

0:04:58going to be billions of those simulations. So if any

0:05:01civilization got to this level of technology first, then the odds are that

0:05:07that of all the things that are as complex as the universe,

0:05:10that we're in the one that's actually real is very small.

0:05:13Do you think that's fair paraphrasing?

0:05:15- Yeah, that's basically what he said.

0:05:17Which, you know, I mean, we wouldn't know, would we?

0:05:22But it's interesting.

0:05:25I guess we wouldn't know, would we?

0:05:29- I don't know, they figured it out in the matrix.

0:05:31- That's true.

0:05:32- I don't know.

0:05:33- That's true, we just needed a Nokia phone

0:05:35and some pills, I guess.

0:05:38- I think that one of the things

0:05:39that makes these two guys interesting,

0:05:41and it's one of the things that,

0:05:42I mean, Jobs was just a compelling figure, period.

0:05:45But, and I think there's even like a term for it,

0:05:48but it's not just the fact that they're CEOs,

0:05:50and it's not just the fact that they run interesting

0:05:53companies, and it's not just the fact that they have

0:05:56their interesting minds, and they come up, you know,

0:05:58they say interesting things, but it's that they're

0:06:00the founders of the company.

0:06:02that CEO founder has a certain magic.

0:06:06And maybe there's no real, maybe it shouldn't,

0:06:08maybe that's not quite logical,

0:06:10maybe that's sort of a lizard brain aspect

0:06:13of human perception, but that somehow

0:06:17there's a gravitas to a CEO founder

0:06:22that say Tim Cook is never going to have.

0:06:25- Yeah, and I don't, you know,

0:06:32And I don't know if that's because they're a founder

0:06:34or because they're still CEO,

0:06:37but maybe just because they're the type of person

0:06:39that would be the founder of something

0:06:42truly successful and big.

0:06:44And I think it's kind of interesting

0:06:48in comparison to many of today's CEOs

0:06:51who make cool things and then kind of escape,

0:06:56quit the company or something like that.

0:06:58Not only are they still there,

0:07:00but they're using their power and influence

0:07:03in really interesting and creative and productive ways.

0:07:07In Bezos's case, doing space research

0:07:12and starting new companies and buying one of the nation's

0:07:16most storied newspapers, Musk too, basically creating,

0:07:21now creating free startup ideas for everyone

0:07:25every couple of years, like the Hyperloop,

0:07:27and now, what was he talking about?

0:07:30the mesh that goes in your brain and lets you,

0:07:34I forgot what it is.

0:07:35- He lost me there.

0:07:38- Yeah.

0:07:40- I believe him.

0:07:41- Right.

0:07:42But it's cool, I really liked it.

0:07:46And you could also, so we also had Sundar Pichai,

0:07:50which in the same vein as Cook,

0:07:52like he's the CEO of one of the most powerful companies

0:07:56in the world.

0:07:59He's an interesting guy, but doesn't carry the same weight as a Bezos.

0:08:04And then Bill and Melinda Gates.

0:08:06And you could, you can really tell that bill is no longer thinking as the CEO

0:08:10of Microsoft, but as, you know, as a world leading philanthropist and is really

0:08:16actively much more interested in science and, and medicine than, you know, the nuts

0:08:24and bolts of technology and the internet.

0:08:26Yeah.

0:08:27Something interesting too, and I don't know if it's coincidence or if there's really something

0:08:34to it, to the fact that Bezos and Musk are in fact directly competing in terms of having

0:08:41space rocket ship startups trying to privatize space exploration, something that had previously

0:08:49been entirely a government overseeing endeavor. Elon Musk has SpaceX and what space is it?

0:08:59It's Blue Origin, is that maybe?

0:09:00Yeah, that's it. That's it. Blue Origin. I don't know if that's a coincidence. I don't know if

0:09:07that's just a factor of, you know, a couple of guys born in the 60s when space, you know, as young

0:09:15boys with an interest in technology,

0:09:19how could you not be obsessed with space?

0:09:21And that if you ever got successful enough to be in the position to do it,

0:09:26it's inevitable that they would, or is there something to it?

0:09:29Like, is this really going to be a thing, you know, in the next 10, 15 years?

0:09:32Yeah. That, uh, I think it's some of both. I think, you know,

0:09:37if you have essentially unlimited money, um,

0:09:41what's bigger than trying to, you know, leave the planet, uh,

0:09:45It's hard to imagine bigger things than that,

0:09:49but I do think a lot of it has to do with when they grew up.

0:09:51I don't know if Mark Zuckerberg

0:09:55has much interest in space, for example.

0:09:58He might, I don't know.

0:09:59And I don't know if that is just 'cause of who he is.

0:10:03Our sample set is pretty small here,

0:10:04but it is interesting coincidence

0:10:06that the two of them are so into it,

0:10:09or maybe not a coincidence.

0:10:11It's certainly interesting.

0:10:13I don't know.

0:10:13Do you wanna go to space?

0:10:15(dramatic music)

0:10:17I have late breaking news.

0:10:22I have late breaking news.

0:10:23I have to interrupt the show.

0:10:24This is big news.

0:10:25My wife just came into the office while I'm recording it.

0:10:29I knew that must have been a big deal.

0:10:31She found my missing canisters for the fizzy machine.

0:10:37(laughs)

0:10:39- Where were they?

0:10:40- Amy!

0:10:44We're going to do it. We're going to reveal it on the show. Where were they?

0:10:46It's not funny.

0:10:50Well, where were they?

0:10:51They were in the coat closet. Um,

0:10:55somebody put them like in a milk crate in the back.

0:10:58I don't know who would do such a thing.

0:11:00And one of them fall on the floor and I like ducked for cover.

0:11:06Interesting. Did you put them there?

0:11:11- No, I believe that my wife is the perpetrator.

0:11:15(laughing)

0:11:16And I believe that's why she came in

0:11:18with a very sheepish grin.

0:11:20- That's cool.

0:11:21How many are there?

0:11:22- Three. - Several, right?

0:11:24- Right, well now I've got a lot.

0:11:26See, my system with the SodaStream is

0:11:30I have four in the house at all times.

0:11:32And then as soon as three are empty,

0:11:34I take the three to the local Williams-Sonoma

0:11:37and exchange them for another three.

0:11:39but that way, if I put it off for a couple of days,

0:11:43I've got the fourth one in the machine,

0:11:45keeping me carbonated.

0:11:46So our long national mystery

0:11:49of where my missing three canisters were is over.

0:11:53All right, where were we?

0:11:54What were we talking about?

0:11:55Spaceships.

0:11:55- See, my system is use one up

0:11:58and then not make SodaStream for six months.

0:12:01- No, I wouldn't, I would die of dehydration.

0:12:04- Well, I just have to buy,

0:12:06I buy like the six pack of Whole Foods sparkling water.

0:12:10- Right.

0:12:10Anyway, we were talking about space.

0:12:12Do I wanna go to space?

0:12:13No, I don't think I do.

0:12:14I don't know.

0:12:15I feel like I grew up at the wrong time.

0:12:18Like I was born in 1973, so I've never been alive

0:12:22when there's been a man on the moon.

0:12:24And I loved the space shuttle stuff when I was a kid,

0:12:28but then it's like, it was like,

0:12:30cool, we have a reusable spaceship.

0:12:32It made it seem like there was a coolness to that.

0:12:37Even as a little kid, you could tell

0:12:38that there was something wrong about the idea

0:12:40that they'd build these massive skyscraper-sized rockets that

0:12:44look just amazing and are just filled with jet fuel.

0:12:49And then by the time these guys got into space,

0:12:51they were in these tiny little things

0:12:52that were just at the tip.

0:12:54And then they come back.

0:12:56When they land, all that comes back into the ocean

0:12:59is this tiny little thing that looks like a refrigerator.

0:13:03And you could tell that that's inefficient.

0:13:07So when the space shuttle program started, I was,

0:13:10I don't know, I remember being, I was in school the day

0:13:12the first space shuttle launched and it was so awesome.

0:13:16They let everybody got out of class

0:13:18and we'd crowd around the TV and watch it on the news.

0:13:22And I think they even let us do it again when it landed.

0:13:25I think when it like that space shuttle landed,

0:13:27they pulled us all out of class and let us watch.

0:13:30And it was amazing 'cause here's the ship.

0:13:31It went, you know, there still were rocket,

0:13:33you know, to get it into space,

0:13:34there were disposable rockets,

0:13:36but the main ship itself came back.

0:13:37That seemed like, hey, we're getting somewhere.

0:13:39And then nothing else really happened.

0:13:41Right, I mean, it's like after the space shuttle.

0:13:44And then, you know, in the space shuttle program

0:13:46had a couple of, you know,

0:13:47like with the Challenger disaster,

0:13:48it was all kind of a bummer.

0:13:51- Yeah, yeah, I would say for me that the main problem is

0:13:54I'm just not really a desert guy.

0:13:56So going to Mars, it's like,

0:13:58nah, I don't really,

0:14:00not really interested in going to a giant desert.

0:14:04If it were lush mountains and streams,

0:14:07maybe that would be interesting, but.

0:14:09- Yeah, I could see it.

0:14:11It may be, you know, like the 2001 "Space Odyssey" idea,

0:14:14if they put a Hilton just in orbit around the Earth.

0:14:17- Yeah. (laughs)

0:14:18- Put a Hilton in orbit.

0:14:20I might be convinced to go to that,

0:14:22but I feel like, yeah, going to Mars,

0:14:26It seems like certainly within our lifetime,

0:14:28there's never gonna be a way to go there

0:14:30that's not a incredibly long trip.

0:14:34I feel like it's a long enough trip flying to California.

0:14:40- Right, yeah, I was gonna say.

0:14:41It's enough fun to go to LA for a few days.

0:14:46- I had to help in low orbit though.

0:14:50I withhold the right to go up there.

0:14:54- That could be neat.

0:14:55That's basically like one of those Emirates flights

0:14:57where you have the suite with the bath,

0:15:00with the shower now, just going for a week

0:15:04instead of 12 hours or whatever.

0:15:07- Yeah, and it would be cool to experience

0:15:09weightlessness, I guess.

0:15:10I'm not sure I get the infatuation with it.

0:15:15And I think you're right.

0:15:16I think it is sort of generational, though.

0:15:18And maybe these guys are right.

0:15:20Maybe there was something to the '60s,

0:15:23John F. Kennedy challenge to do something like that.

0:15:26Seems more than coincidental that Bezos and Musk

0:15:31both have that obsession.

0:15:32- Well, maybe next year we need to have them both on

0:15:37at the same time, dueling rockets.

0:15:41- Yeah, it makes me wonder, like did Bezos hang out?

0:15:43Was he there the next day?

0:15:45Like did they spend any time together?

0:15:46I know it was Bezos the first night and Musk the second,

0:15:49and I know Musk was late getting there,

0:15:51so he obviously wasn't there beforehand.

0:15:54- No, to my knowledge, there was no hanging out.

0:15:58Just kind of a bummer, it'd be cool if the kind of

0:16:02VVVIP guests hung out and stayed around for a while,

0:16:06but a lot of times now they just kind of take off,

0:16:11go back to wherever they come from.

0:16:15- Go back to their Bondlairs, Bond villain layers.

0:16:19- Yeah, I heard last year that the Snapchat guy

0:16:23basically showed up, took a brand new T-shirt out of a box,

0:16:28put it on, went on stage, got off stage,

0:16:32and then left basically.

0:16:33(laughing)

0:16:35But--

0:16:36- It's the new T-shirt thing that gets me.

0:16:38- Yeah.

0:16:39- I'm not going on stage with that.

0:16:40- No, it was like a brand new--

0:16:42- Mid condition.

0:16:43- Deep V-neck T-shirt, go on, I forgot the brand.

0:16:46We actually, so we just relaunched the site.

0:16:49I should probably explain why I'm there,

0:16:51but basically, the Vox Media bought ReCode

0:16:56just over a year ago, and in many parts,

0:17:02in many reasons for the code conference itself,

0:17:05but also because the ReCode website is so influential

0:17:09and just a brand that people know and I think trust

0:17:15and they want to do a lot more with it.

0:17:19So they approached me earlier this year

0:17:21with kind of that in mind.

0:17:24And it sounded like a really exciting opportunity for me.

0:17:28So the first thing we did was completely redesign the site

0:17:31and relaunch it on the Vox Media publishing system.

0:17:34And now we're about to open a bunch of jobs

0:17:39and hire new people and expand our coverage

0:17:42and do a lot of that sort of stuff.

0:17:44So Daniel left off the very most important thing that you guys did.

0:17:48Uh, Oh yeah.

0:17:49We, we got rid of the slash, the slash, which I never gave you anyway.

0:17:54No, that was like my first day.

0:17:56I think they were like, what are we going to do with the slash?

0:17:58I'm like, we are getting rid of the slash.

0:18:00If there's ever a question about how to write the name of your site, that is a

0:18:05problem.

0:18:05So it was great.

0:18:08That's, that's why I think they should have instantly, even if it was the first

0:18:12day, they should have given you a raise.

0:18:14- Yeah, I mean, I think I remember,

0:18:16maybe it was even you when they launched,

0:18:18you were like, "I don't know about this slash."

0:18:20- I was, I was immediately questioning the slash.

0:18:24- Yeah, I didn't know what the history of it was,

0:18:28and I asked about it last week,

0:18:31and I found out about it,

0:18:33and let's just say it's not a good,

0:18:35it's not an interesting story, so I won't repeat it,

0:18:37but no one, I don't think anyone was really tied to it, so.

0:18:41- Well-- - I'm all about simplicity,

0:18:43I mean, if you remember my, every time I build a website,

0:18:46it's the simplest layout possible and you know,

0:18:49no, no too much, not too much depth or, or complication.

0:18:54So in my case--

0:18:55- Rekote has had that as part of their brand

0:18:57right from the start though,

0:18:58even when they had the slash in their name,

0:19:00it has been a very reader friendly site.

0:19:02- I disagree.

0:19:04- I think it got better.

0:19:06I think that the redesign is better.

0:19:08- It's better.

0:19:09I mean, before the front page was this very Pinterest

0:19:12looking thing with variable height blocks.

0:19:15And you could say, well,

0:19:18the front page doesn't really matter.

0:19:19People don't really go there.

0:19:21Our front page is actually still very popular.

0:19:23It's often the most popular page on the site

0:19:26and it's much simpler now.

0:19:27It's a standard reverse cron,

0:19:30actually not always reverse cron

0:19:31'cause we have complete control over the order of the post,

0:19:36but it's much simpler.

0:19:37- So I think my impression is it's mostly reverse cron,

0:19:42but you guys can pin like a blockbuster story to the top.

0:19:45- Yeah, we actually do some pinning throughout the river.

0:19:49Like if there's a feature story,

0:19:51we'll keep that in the river up top for a few days,

0:19:54something like that.

0:19:55But before like the headline font was Futura,

0:19:58which is a great for like one word here and there,

0:20:02but not really the kind of font

0:20:04you'd wanna ever read a sentence in, for example.

0:20:06So some of that stuff, I mean, it wasn't bad.

0:20:09It's just, to me, it was an opportunity to really simplify

0:20:14and got to work with the really talented design.

0:20:17Actually, the guy who made our logo designed

0:20:20the Oculus logo for Facebook.

0:20:22He has designed, he designed the logo for Curbed

0:20:26and some of the other Vox Media properties.

0:20:28So I'm really happy with it.

0:20:30- Yeah, and the logo has a little homage to the slash.

0:20:33- Yes, the implied slash.

0:20:34Yeah, and that actually was a little more pronounced

0:20:36in the earlier versions of it.

0:20:38And I kind of had them tweak it a little bit, but it works.

0:20:42I mean, the, the, the whole point is for the design to get out of the way and just

0:20:46break news and do good analysis and we'll do more.

0:20:50Um, we, we did a few really big, ambitious profile features for our relaunch, uh,

0:20:57which was about a month ago, including a, um, a really well reported feature.

0:21:03One of the first really about Evan Spiegel, the founder of Snapchat,

0:21:07and we sent one of our reporters to Kansas City

0:21:11to write about Google Fiber,

0:21:13which had now celebrated,

0:21:15I believe it's fifth birthday there.

0:21:17And both of those stories did so well

0:21:20that we were almost surprised

0:21:22and now we have to figure out how to do more of those

0:21:25'cause they were really outside of our kind of workflow.

0:21:28So we're really happy with that.

0:21:31And it's been fun so far.

0:21:36I guess kind of the back story is that for me,

0:21:41it's a reunion with my first boss, Peter Kafka,

0:21:44who I worked with at Forbes almost 11 years ago.

0:21:48And we left together in 2007 to start

0:21:53Silicon Alley Insider with Henry Blodgett.

0:21:55So we were the first three people at the site

0:21:58that became Business Insider.

0:22:00And then Peter left to join Kara and Walt at All Things D,

0:22:03and I stayed on.

0:22:04And now, you know, basically a decade later,

0:22:09we're reunited and--

0:22:10- That's when you and I first got to know each other

0:22:12was when you were at Business Insider

0:22:14or Silicon Alley Insider at the time.

0:22:16- Alley Insider, I still remember the first time

0:22:19you linked to us and probably said something,

0:22:22probably like, well, this is wrong, but here's the link.

0:22:25I don't remember, but claim chowder or something.

0:22:29- Yeah, I don't know.

0:22:29I'd have to look it up.

0:22:32And what's your title?

0:22:32You're like the editor, right?

0:22:34- I'm the editor in chief.

0:22:34- Editor in chief.

0:22:35So now you're Peter Kafka's boss.

0:22:39- Sort of.

0:22:40No one's really Peter's boss, but no, I mean, he's,

0:22:45you know, we work together.

0:22:46There's, and Kara Swisher obviously is very involved

0:22:50in the site, but basically it's kind of my site

0:22:53to do what I want with.

0:22:55And my perspective is that, you know, having now worked

0:22:59at some really interesting business publications

0:23:02and watch the tech section basically take over,

0:23:05I think all you need is the tech section.

0:23:09So I don't know, I wrote somewhere that like tech,

0:23:13we used to cover tech as a thing,

0:23:15but now tech is everything.

0:23:16So we'll keep adding new coverage areas.

0:23:20We recently hired a really wonderful

0:23:22transportation reporter to cover the rise of,

0:23:26well, it's not the rise anymore,

0:23:27but the continued growth of Uber, Tesla,

0:23:31and those types of companies.

0:23:33And I anticipate that, and by the way,

0:23:36that's a role that even three years ago

0:23:38we would have kind of scratched our heads at.

0:23:41Like, well, why would a tech site

0:23:43need a transportation reporter?

0:23:45But obviously, of course you do.

0:23:47- It is funny though.

0:23:48That's a perfect example of like how this industry changes.

0:23:53Five years is a good distance to go back.

0:23:58Five years ago, that would have been like a head scratcher.

0:24:00And today it's like, you're nuts if you don't.

0:24:02- Totally, I mean, five years ago,

0:24:05I think Uber already existed,

0:24:07but it would have been covered as an app startup

0:24:09or something like that.

0:24:10And now everything is an app startup really.

0:24:13And just every industry is gonna be re-imagined by tech,

0:24:18some faster than others.

0:24:23And transportation is one that we've kind of identified

0:24:27early is something that we should really have a say in covering. I imagine at some point

0:24:33we'll be covering the tech of food or finance or all kinds of stuff. Basically wherever

0:24:43we have personal interest or wherever we find a really great journalist who can own that

0:24:49coverage for us.

0:24:50Have you seen the story that sort of a mini controversy about Tesla yesterday about like

0:24:57some guys Tesla had the suspend the ball joint the suspension sort of rusted out.

0:25:01Did you see this story? I did not. I'll put it in the show notes but there was a guy

0:25:09who I'd never heard of before named Niedermeier.

0:25:16which always makes me think of Animal House.

0:25:19But I've never heard him, but he's a long time

0:25:23car industry, automobile industry writer, Edward Niedermeier.

0:25:30- Okay, I know another Niedermeier.

0:25:32- No, I'll send you a link, but I'm pasting this

0:25:35into the show notes right now, so I won't forget.

0:25:37Here we go, boom, there it is.

0:25:41And the gist of his article and his writing on Tesla--

0:25:46and Tesla responded.

0:25:48And it seems, again, it's sort of like Musk as Jobs,

0:25:52like for sometimes with those--

0:25:54like sometimes he'd sign them with thoughts on music.

0:25:59But remember the one time there was a fact on the App Store?

0:26:02It was like an FAQ.

0:26:03And it was like there was some stuff in there like the App

0:26:06Store doesn't need any more fart apps.

0:26:09Not everything needs to be made.

0:26:10And you could just tell that Steve Jobs,

0:26:12not just stood over it,

0:26:15but that he had his hands on the keyboard for some of that.

0:26:18And the Tesla PR response to this was sort of dismissive,

0:26:23tonally in a way.

0:26:27There's enough people with Teslas out there,

0:26:30they're obviously not all falling apart,

0:26:32but the gist of it was that they really blamed this guy

0:26:35because he lived at, they had a two mile driveway

0:26:37to a remote home that was like a dirt road,

0:26:39and that the car was just covered with dirt,

0:26:41and it's sort of an unexpected use of it, but it's--

0:26:45- You're holding it wrong.

0:26:46- Right, but the gist of this, Niedermeier guides,

0:26:48what made it more interesting than the specific incident

0:26:51of this ball joint in one Tesla at Model S,

0:26:53and whether in general there's a problem,

0:26:56is this guy who's a long-time automobile industry watcher

0:27:00is very pessimistic on Tesla,

0:27:02more so than anybody I've seen,

0:27:04and his argument is that,

0:27:08Again, I'll put it in the show notes.

0:27:09It's an interesting argument.

0:27:11And I'll probably link it from Daring Fireball, actually.

0:27:13I just haven't gotten around to it yet.

0:27:15But his argument is that it's,

0:27:17there's a counterintuitive aspect to pricing cars

0:27:22and that people think, hey,

0:27:23when you spend a lot of money on a car,

0:27:25like let's say like a Model S,

0:27:27you expect a better quality car.

0:27:31And that's actually not true

0:27:32because you go super expensive

0:27:34and get like a Lamborghini or Ferrari

0:27:35and things fall apart all the time

0:27:37and they're always in the shop.

0:27:38And it doesn't matter because if you've got enough money

0:27:39for a Ferrari, you could just have your chauffeur

0:27:42drive you around in your Mercedes

0:27:44until the car's back out of the shop.

0:27:46And that it's the lower you go in prices,

0:27:49the lower the price car, the more the person

0:27:51who's buying it absolutely positively relies on it.

0:27:55And therefore it needs reliability.

0:27:58And that that's the secret to Toyota and Honda's success,

0:28:01you know, starting in the '70s,

0:28:02is that they, from the top down,

0:28:05were focused on quality in a way that a company from Silicon

0:28:11Valley isn't going to get it right,

0:28:12because quality at every step of the process

0:28:15is sort of the antithesis of the Silicon Valley

0:28:18model, which is move fast and we'll fix problems later.

0:28:23Like the revolution that Toyota brought to the assembly line

0:28:26was that the old way was that the car would keep moving down

0:28:29the assembly line.

0:28:30And even if a fault was identified,

0:28:31they'd try to fix the fault after it got off

0:28:33the end of the assembly line.

0:28:34what Toyota is the Toyota way and you know that's actually a thing like the W

0:28:38is capitalized the Toyota way is that as soon as a fault is identified in a car

0:28:42in the assembly line the entire assembly line shuts down and they almost move it

0:28:46in in reverse to identify where the fault happened and fix it right there to

0:28:51make sure that it isn't you know perpetrated in more than one car even if

0:28:58it's expensive to shut down the assembly line and do it that way but then that

0:29:02that sort of expense of that is sort of what motivates everybody along the way

0:29:07to be hyper focused. You don't want to be the guy who shut down, you know, caused

0:29:10the assembly line to shut down. And that Tesla doesn't have that mindset. And as

0:29:14they move down to more affordable cars, what's this the new one called the Model

0:29:193? What's it called? I think so. Whatever the one is called that everybody went

0:29:25nuts for and bought gazillion pre-orders for at this $35,000 price range. People's

0:29:31expectations for reliability are going to be way higher than they were for the

0:29:36hundred thousand dollar model S and he doesn't think that they're suited to do

0:29:39it. Interesting theory. Yeah, I don't know about that. I mean, he seems really, again,

0:29:46I don't know, I've never, I don't own a Tesla, I don't know what their kind of

0:29:51global reliability is, but he did seem to really care about quality when he was

0:29:57talking about it at code where he was saying even the people who bought the

0:30:01base level $35,000 version would get a pretty freaking

0:30:06awesome car.

0:30:07Definitely not like the kind of situation where you need

0:30:12to upgrade to the $50,000 tier or whatever,

0:30:15making that number up to get a great car.

0:30:18So it seems like safety is probably the biggest priority,

0:30:23but also, and also cool features, but I don't know.

0:30:28it seems like, I don't have the perception that Tesla doesn't care about quality.

0:30:34I don't know.

0:30:34I, you know, it might also be the kind of thing where they're not old enough to have

0:30:39a longterm example of, of how their cars hold up over time.

0:30:45Yeah.

0:30:45I don't know.

0:30:46Uh, that seems like, you know, how you were describing this, we'll fix it later.

0:30:53That seems like the attitude for a lot of software companies, uh, especially

0:30:58because the internet has made it so easy to patch software as it goes.

0:31:02And, you know, you could also argue that that's one of Apple's problems,

0:31:06that they don't do that enough.

0:31:07Um, but when it comes to hardware, it seems like the companies that

0:31:10excel at hardware make stuff to last more than the software company.

0:31:17So I don't, I don't know.

0:31:18Uh, and the other part of the controversy is that apparently it's come out that,

0:31:23when you're with certain out of warranty repairs,

0:31:28that if your Tesla is out of warranty,

0:31:30let's say it's like three years old and you take it in,

0:31:32but it's a weird problem, and they run it up the chain,

0:31:36like, "Hey, should we fix it for this guy

0:31:37or at a discount or for free?"

0:31:40That sometimes when they do that,

0:31:41they ask the person or in exchange for it,

0:31:44they have you sign what they call a goodwill agreement,

0:31:47which is effectively an NDA

0:31:48that you're not gonna talk about that you're,

0:31:50well, you know, instead of what's charging you $3,000

0:31:53for this repair will only charge you $1,000,

0:31:55but you need to sign this that says

0:31:57you're not gonna talk about the problem.

0:31:58And some people are spooked about the,

0:32:01in a way that some people just get spooked

0:32:06when anybody's asked to sign an NDA.

0:32:08- Yeah, or how about the guy who,

0:32:10what did he trash them on Twitter so he can't,

0:32:13just literally can't buy a Tesla?

0:32:16- Stuart Alstopp, longtime technology columnist

0:32:19and now a VC, Elon Musk personally canceled his order.

0:32:24- Amazing.

0:32:29- Which is a very Steve Jobs type thing.

0:32:31- I mean, they're very savvy about some of this stuff.

0:32:35I wrote a post a couple of years ago

0:32:38about how they are effectively their own media company too,

0:32:41the way that he handled criticism by the New York Times

0:32:46and in other situations where Tesla essentially published

0:32:50their own media without going to another reporter

0:32:55or something like that.

0:32:56They're certainly ahead of the curve

0:33:00in a lot of those things.

0:33:01- Yeah, I've got these,

0:33:02I've put a couple links in the show notes already.

0:33:04So they'll be there for everybody who wants to read them.

0:33:06Here, I'll paste it for you.

0:33:08You don't have to read it while we talk.

0:33:10Let me take a break, actually.

0:33:12It's a good time to take a break

0:33:13and thank our first sponsor.

0:33:16And it's a new sponsor,

0:33:17could not be happier to have them here.

0:33:20It's Eero, E-E-R-O.

0:33:23Here's what they make.

0:33:26They make a brand new system of WiFi routers.

0:33:30Why would you wanna do that?

0:33:32Well, here's why.

0:33:33WiFi is broken because for most people in most houses,

0:33:36unless you live in like a studio apartment,

0:33:38if you have dead zones in your house

0:33:41where you know you don't get good wifi,

0:33:44because it's just really hard for one wifi router

0:33:48to reach everywhere.

0:33:49It's really just the nature of physics,

0:33:53that the waves just can't pass through walls

0:33:58as easily as they can pass through the air,

0:33:59and most people have walls and floors

0:34:01and multiple floors in their houses,

0:34:03so it really doesn't make sense.

0:34:05And then the old way of trying to extend it,

0:34:07oftentimes you'd end up with multiple networks

0:34:10within your house, it's like you have to be

0:34:12like a system administrator to do it.

0:34:15So the single router model just doesn't work.

0:34:18What you need is a distributed system,

0:34:19and that's what Eero is, and it is amazingly simple.

0:34:24So they sent me, as part of the sponsorship,

0:34:26they sent me a package, I got it, I set it up,

0:34:28they sent me a three-pack.

0:34:29They give you three of these little things.

0:34:31Each one is identical.

0:34:32They're just little pucks, little Apple TV-esque sized pucks,

0:34:36a little bit thinner, a little bit bigger,

0:34:38little square round-wrecked puck. Honestly, it really does look like

0:34:42something Apple would design. It's that sort of visual aesthetic. It's not

0:34:46something you'd want to hide, you know, somewhere in a cabinet or something like

0:34:50that. It's easily something you wouldn't mind having out, you know, on behind your

0:34:55TV or whatever it is. It's got all the security stuff you'd want.

0:35:01State-of-the-art WPA2 encryption. Great customer support. You can call them up on

0:35:07the phone and get a hold of a WiFi expert within 30 seconds. It's just so simple. They

0:35:15recommend one e-row for every thousand square feet of your home. Most houses, two or three

0:35:19e-rows is fine. So the three-pack is a good starting point for just about anybody. And

0:35:23if you want to buy more, you can just buy more. And you just plug it in to your router.

0:35:31Take your old router, throw it away. Plug this into your cable with the Ethernet. Just

0:35:35one of them gets the ethernet, then wherever else you want to put them around your house,

0:35:40just put a couple more and they just configure themselves into a mesh network and just offer

0:35:47one effectively from you as somebody who just wants to hook up your MacBook to the Wi-Fi or

0:35:52your iPhone to the Wi-Fi. It just looks like one network. You put the password in to configure it.

0:35:58You don't have to go to one of those goofy figure, you know, fakey fake websites with the IP address

0:36:03or whatever, they've got a nice app right there in the App Store for iPhone and Android.

0:36:08You just go there on the app and configure it right there. Really nice app for configuration

0:36:12could not be easier. One of the pucks, it's not like a special one, just pick one of them.

0:36:17One of them, plug it into Ethernet, plug a couple more in around the house on different

0:36:21floors and all of a sudden the fact that you can't get Wi-Fi in your bedroom or something

0:36:26like that, it's all over. So I've got one, I can vouch for the ease, I can vouch for

0:36:30the fact that the dead spots that we've had in our house are no longer dead spots.

0:36:35Really, really great. So if you are looking, if you're dissatisfied

0:36:39with your Wi-Fi at your house or looking for a new Wi-Fi router, go check out Eero.

0:36:44Go to Eero, E-E-R-O, dot com and use the code "THETALKSHOW" and you will get free

0:36:54overnight shipping. So use that code, you'll get free overnight shipping, you'll

0:36:59have it tomorrow. My thanks to era. Uh, speaking of breaking news, what do you think about

0:37:06scoop, uh, scoop, Gerben leaving nine to five Mac and, uh, he's heading to Bloomberg. Yeah.

0:37:12Um, it's funny. I'd actually heard about that a few months prior, but I didn't say anything

0:37:17and I'm glad it, uh, I'm kind of amazed it stayed, uh, stay quiet. I heard about it too.

0:37:22I heard about it back at the March Apple event.

0:37:26- Oh, cool.

0:37:27- And I even heard that it was Bloomberg.

0:37:31I thought about being snarky and posting something about it

0:37:33and I thought, nah.

0:37:35'Cause it seemed like it wasn't up

0:37:36and it wasn't clear to me whether Seth Weintraub

0:37:39at 9to5Mac knew.

0:37:41It turns out I think he did, at least by March.

0:37:44But I didn't want him to hear it that way

0:37:47and I thought, ah, screw it.

0:37:48But I just thought it was funny that Mark Gurman,

0:37:52who spoils all these things for Apple and other companies that a couple of people I

0:37:57know knew and nobody leaked it.

0:37:59Yeah, that's restraint. I think it's great. I think it's cool. It's going to be a bummer

0:38:07to compete with him. Hey, Mark, if you find yourself miserable at Bloomberg, give me a

0:38:14call. But I think it's cool. He's going to get to work with Brad Stone, who's a great

0:38:19journalist and have what I would imagine are very nice resources available to him and also

0:38:28a TV network and also an organization that has a very specific mission and a business

0:38:37model that has nothing to do with internet advertising and is being run by a non-web

0:38:46guy who many people thought would not really come back and this is Mike

0:38:52Bloomberg, of course, not really come back and be the boss again and then showed up

0:38:55and was the boss again and, um, you know, is, is a very profitable business that

0:39:02is dominated by the terminal, which is going to face increasing competition.

0:39:08So it's, it's, and it's also kind of, uh, in the business of producing soulless,

0:39:15but extremely accurate, very fast, uh, you know, market moving news.

0:39:21So should be interesting.

0:39:23I mean, I would guess that a lot of the stuff that would be, uh, publishable

0:39:27at nine to five Mac will not be publishable at Bloomberg either because

0:39:31it's too small, you know, like feature store, you know, not, I don't mean

0:39:35long feature stories, I mean, stories about features of products that

0:39:39probably wouldn't, you know, wouldn't really cut it.

0:39:42Uh, we'll see how that goes.

0:39:44I don't know.

0:39:44But it also sounds like he's going to be working on non-Apple stuff too.

0:39:47So if he can use some of his reporting techniques, which, you know, I admire,

0:39:52um, to break news on, on other big companies, I thought I read that he was

0:39:56going to be working on stuff like Google and Amazon as well, um, consumer tech.

0:40:01I think that's great.

0:40:02So it should be really interesting to see how it goes.

0:40:04Um, yeah, it's the scoop aspect.

0:40:07And that's why when I heard Bloomberg months ago, it immediately clicked

0:40:12is, oh, that makes sense because Bloomberg, again, this is, you know, you and I getting a little

0:40:16inside baseball here, but Bloomberg and but it's interesting to you because Recode is definitely a

0:40:21scoop company too, right? Like, you guys definitely pride yourselves on breaking some stories,

0:40:28a lot of stories first. Absolutely. And Bloomberg, it's institutional at Bloomberg too. Like,

0:40:35you know, it's sort of almost the opposite of me, who I almost seldom ever break anything,

0:40:43and don't really care about it, but it's, you know, and it's exemplified by the

0:40:50leaderboard at Techmeme, at which, you know, German is so far out in the top of "It's Ridiculous."

0:40:55Yeah, I think you're right, though. It's going to be interesting to see how his,

0:41:05the faster and looser style or standards of nine to five Mac compared, you know,

0:41:09how that translates to an institution with a more formal, um,

0:41:14set of standards.

0:41:15And I, you know, I would say not having ever worked with Mark that, uh,

0:41:20his,

0:41:21his accuracy rate suggests that his personal standards are quite high,

0:41:25because it's very easy to get sucked into posting what you think is a

0:41:31scoop and then being wrong. Um, whereas, you know,

0:41:35Even when he is somewhat wrong, it's usually, you know, could be easily

0:41:40explained by, well, he was right at the time, but you know, three months past.

0:41:43And it's totally reasonable for Apple to change the name of something or, you

0:41:47know, whether, whether they, I don't think they did it despite him that one time

0:41:52or whatever, but, um, but like he, you know, to my recollection has never really

0:41:57been wrong about something in a way that suggests that his journalism is highly

0:42:01flawed.

0:42:02Uh, I, you know, I don't know who his sources are, but my guess is that he's

0:42:06has pretty high personal standards about that.

0:42:09So, uh, I've actually also never worked for Bloomberg, so I don't know what, how,

0:42:14how the, there's also the Bloomberg way, capital w and, um, and I'm not sure how

0:42:22that will work with, with Mark, but.

0:42:24It certainly is a, is an interesting place to be right now.

0:42:28So it should be fun or at least a learning experience.

0:42:32I mean, the dude is 23, so he can do it.

0:42:35He can kind of do a lot of different stuff and figure out what he likes.

0:42:39Yeah.

0:42:41It's and if, you know, if he doesn't like it, he can always move on.

0:42:43Interesting.

0:42:44Yeah.

0:42:44Um, but to me, it's also interesting that he went that route as opposed to, um,

0:42:52you know, doing his own thing or taking on, um, you know, more independent stuff

0:42:59like nine to five or creating his own company

0:43:03or trying to work somewhere.

0:43:05And I have no idea who else he talked to.

0:43:07He certainly could basically work at a lot of places.

0:43:12I mean, I would obviously have wanted to hire him at Recode

0:43:16if I had gotten to him before Bloomberg did.

0:43:19But yeah, it's cool.

0:43:23I mean, to be open about what I was thinking,

0:43:26this was when I was thinking about

0:43:28doing something new this year,

0:43:29one of the things that jumped back to mind

0:43:31was doing my own thing again,

0:43:33and Splat F 2.0 or something like that.

0:43:36Nowadays there are business models

0:43:39that didn't really exist

0:43:41when I started Splat F five years ago.

0:43:43- What about this new App Store stuff?

0:43:46- I think it's interesting.

0:43:48So you got briefed, so why don't you start off

0:43:51and explain what, briefly, I guess, what happened.

0:43:54- Yeah, so it was very fast moving.

0:43:56It was Monday, and someone at Apple PR asked me

0:44:01if I could be available Tuesday for a half hour or so

0:44:05phone call with Phil Schiller about some developer news

0:44:08that they're putting out ahead of WWDC next week.

0:44:11I said I would try to find some time.

0:44:13Maybe I could squeeze that in.

0:44:17So Tuesday, I was gonna say a conference call,

0:44:22but it was speakerphone and there were a couple

0:44:24of other people on the other end,

0:44:25but it wasn't like other, it was just me on my end.

0:44:30It wasn't like the other report.

0:44:31I think some people, the people in California

0:44:33got to meet with them live, like The Verge.

0:44:36That obviously wasn't gonna work for me.

0:44:39But yeah, and Shiller told me that three things,

0:44:43three of the things that they're doing,

0:44:45or have already done, is the faster review times

0:44:49for the App Store, all the App Stores.

0:44:51We've noticed that because developers

0:44:54who are submitting apps and are used to week-long approval

0:44:58times, getting their app approved same day, it sticks out.

0:45:02But it's not a fluke.

0:45:03It's not some kind of short-term happenstance.

0:45:08It's a deliberate plan that they took.

0:45:11Three parts of-- what did they say?

0:45:14Staffing changes, which I think there

0:45:17are a couple of managers in there who

0:45:21were sort of roadblocks to moving this forward

0:45:23that they're no longer there.

0:45:27But in addition to that, it was very clear, talking to Schiller, that in addition to the

0:45:31staffing changes, I think that there's also just some changes to the way they're applying

0:45:36just the pure manpower of how many people are doing the reviews.

0:45:41Tool changes, and I heard a little bit more about this off the record from other people

0:45:46later in the week, but definitely some really good engineers at Apple.

0:45:52I mean, they're not talking about the details of what these tools are, but that there's

0:45:56been a significant effort expended within Apple to create internal tools to expedite

0:46:02the software, the app review process.

0:46:06They're not revealing details, not even off the record, but it's not minor.

0:46:12That's the thing I've understood, that months of time from really good engineers were applied

0:46:16to this.

0:46:18And then the last one, the mystery one to me, is policy changes.

0:46:22And I asked Schiller if he could expound upon that.

0:46:26And he hesitated and said, I'd rather not talk about it.

0:46:30So I don't know what that means.

0:46:31But he did.

0:46:32And then he stopped, and he did give one example.

0:46:34And he said, well, here's one example.

0:46:37That if a developer has three apps,

0:46:40and they're sort of interrelated,

0:46:42and they update some core component of it,

0:46:45and all three apps get submitted at the same time,

0:46:48Now, when the reviewer pulls the app from the queue,

0:46:52I mean, he didn't use the word inbox,

0:46:54but effectively the inbox of apps waiting for approval,

0:46:59they'll get all three at once,

0:47:01and they can review them together.

0:47:03And if there's any kind of interconnectedness

0:47:05between the apps, it can make it an hour long thing

0:47:10instead of a days long thing, which is interesting.

0:47:13But to me, that's not really a policy change.

0:47:15that sounds like it's more part of the tool changes.

0:47:18I suspect that part of the, this is, nobody told me this.

0:47:22This is just my thinking about what this could be.

0:47:26Nobody told me this on the record or off the record,

0:47:29so I could be way off, but I can't help but think

0:47:31that maybe some of the policy changes

0:47:33are a little bit of almost just granting the reviewers

0:47:38a little bit of common sense latitude.

0:47:42latitude where like if a developer, if they pull up the app and they look at the developer's

0:47:50history and it's Marco Arment and here's all the apps he's had before, here's the app,

0:47:58he's submitting a new version of Overcast, here's the previous updates to Overcast and

0:48:02he says that this is an update that fixes a sinking bug and that maybe that there's

0:48:07a sort of like, well I think we can trust this guy, look at his history, he's got a

0:48:11reputation put it through. You know, run whatever test you want to do, but that an app from a

0:48:18developer with a trusted record is going to get less of a thorough combing over than a brand new

0:48:261.0 app from a developer who doesn't really have a history or whose history isn't really

0:48:30high profile. I can't help but think that there must be something like that. I don't know.

0:48:40Um, I mean, and this seems to make sense.

0:48:44And if anything, it's, it's kind of absurdly late to make changes like this.

0:48:50I mean, if you, if you think of the app store as a nine year old product, pretty

0:48:54much every other product that was launched nine years ago has, has been vastly

0:48:58improved.

0:48:59Uh, and it seems like, you know, whether it was just a low priority for Apple, but

0:49:06the developer app store experience just really didn't change that much over the

0:49:09years.

0:49:10Yeah, the things that they added were so minor. I mean, it's things like bundles, you know,

0:49:14where you could sell to the same developer could sell a bundle of two or three apps

0:49:19as a single purchase. You know, it's, that's, I mean, it was nice. But I mean, it's like,

0:49:24wow, that's not really a major change. And it wasn't something that really addressed

0:49:28some of the fundamental problems that developers had with the App Store, like these lengthy review

0:49:33times. Right. I think it's fair to say, I would guess that if there were any, and this is,

0:49:38it's far-fetched, but the idea that,

0:49:42remember back in the day was,

0:49:43oh, there should be multiple app stores

0:49:44and Apple should have to compete with other app stores.

0:49:47You could bet that if there were other app stores

0:49:50that Apple would have made improvements like this

0:49:52a long time ago and much more quickly.

0:49:54So, yes, it's nice to see stuff like this happen,

0:49:58but I, you know.

0:50:00- So there was a, not really a,

0:50:03not like a major reorg, but a minor reorg

0:50:05and some promotions back in December

0:50:07within Apple. And one of the things that got shuffled around was that the App Store got moved

0:50:13from being under Eddy Cue to being under Phil Schiller. And that Phil Schiller was going to take a much

0:50:19more active role in overseeing it. And this is the result of it. That's why it was Schiller who was

0:50:25giving me and Jim Dalrymple and The Verge, Lauren Good at The Verge. And I think

0:50:31the UK Telegraph, I forget who wrote it, but I think that they might have been the only

0:50:36we might have been the only four who got it a day in advance.

0:50:39And if it was more than that, it wasn't many more.

0:50:42But that's why it was Schiller doing the briefing,

0:50:44'cause this is his baby.

0:50:46I mean, these are the results of his actions.

0:50:49I think it's completely non-hyperbolic to say

0:50:54that the app store's improved more in the six months

0:50:57under Schiller than it did in eight years under EdiQ.

0:51:00I don't think that's-- - Yeah, I'd agree with that.

0:51:03- And why is that?

0:51:04And a couple of, you know, there's been people emailing me,

0:51:06you know, Twitter, you know, what's this, is Eddy Cue,

0:51:10is he incompetent?

0:51:11What's the problem?

0:51:12I don't think that's the case.

0:51:13I think it's, I don't think it's a case

0:51:15that Eddy Cue couldn't get things like this done.

0:51:19I think it's just that he didn't choose to.

0:51:21That it, that his worldview and what he saw as important

0:51:26in the store wasn't as developer focused

0:51:30as it is under Schiller.

0:51:31and I just think it didn't rise to a priority level

0:51:34that it got done.

0:51:36These things might have been on the list under Q,

0:51:38but that they didn't percolate to the top of the list

0:51:41and therefore didn't get done.

0:51:42- Oh, it's also very easy for Apple to feel like

0:51:44the App Store is a huge grand slam hit,

0:51:47I mean, and a huge success.

0:51:49The growth was unprecedented,

0:51:52the numbers were all up and to the right,

0:51:54and how can you argue with the success of this store?

0:51:58And by the way, we've written you checks

0:52:00for billions of dollars,

0:52:01So why aren't you happier?

0:52:02- $40 billion, I think is the number.

0:52:04And I think that's what Schiller told me the other day.

0:52:06And that might be, it might just be that

0:52:09that was the number from January.

0:52:12And it doesn't even include whatever they've paid

0:52:14since from January to now, because of that,

0:52:16that hasn't been either hasn't been tallied

0:52:18or hasn't been authorized to come out.

0:52:20- And to me, what's even more amazing

0:52:22and could be 10 to 100 times more amazing

0:52:25is that's only the money that goes

0:52:28through the iTunes system.

0:52:30that does not include the money that goes,

0:52:33for example, directly to Uber or something like that.

0:52:36Which is, I'm making this up, but it could be

0:52:40five to 100 times more money that actually goes

0:52:44through apps that has nothing to do with that $40 billion.

0:52:48- Yeah, for me, by far and away,

0:52:50the most money I spend is on Uber, without question.

0:52:53Through my phone, the most money I spend

0:52:55has gotta be through Uber.

0:52:57- Or the Apple Store app when I buy a new laptop

0:52:59something like that, but, uh, or Amazon or whatever, but there's so much money

0:53:04that goes through these apps and you really do have to make it a better

0:53:09product for, for developers, for app users, for everyone. So, um, you know,

0:53:15so the, I guess the other changes are more, I guess they're all kind of

0:53:19developer focused. Well, the subscription pricing. So how do they, how do they

0:53:24kind of frame that?

0:53:29It was framed as we've had subscriptions,

0:53:33but for a very limited number of type of apps,

0:53:38mostly content producing apps, like video streaming, audio

0:53:41streaming, like Spotify.

0:53:45It's great.

0:53:45Schiller is such a pro that he's never knocked off.

0:53:48So it's like he never mentions any competitors, even just

0:53:52on a phone call.

0:53:53So he never didn't mention Spotify or Pandora,

0:53:56but he just mentions, you know, uh, streaming audio streaming video. Um,

0:54:01remember the daily, I think was one of the first publications.

0:54:04Yeah. Yeah. Uh, and he said news news obviously qualifies, you know,

0:54:08you can subscribe to, to, uh, paywall publications like, uh, uh,

0:54:13New York times and wall street journal through an app. Um,

0:54:17uh,

0:54:20more or less an app that you have to subscribe to get content in,

0:54:25you know, on a regular basis. And he said, "We want to change that, to open that up to all app categories."

0:54:31And he mentioned, and I didn't quote him on this, but I know that The Verge did too. The Verge quoted him on it,

0:54:40that it would apply to like a productivity app that requires, you know, constant updates to support features and stuff like that.

0:54:50And so I took it initially as meaning that just about any app would be able to use subscription

0:54:57pricing in any way they see fit. So that if you wanted to, like an app like Vesper, the app that

0:55:05me and Brent Simmons and Dave Whiskus made, if we wanted to do subscription pricing,

0:55:10we could just do subscription pricing.

0:55:17And then, when they published their own website, Apple's website, the language on the webpage

0:55:23made it seem as though it was still mostly about getting content. And it was very, very confusing.

0:55:29And then I emailed Apple PR and I got answers, but they were opaque. And long story short,

0:55:40and then I got a phone call. And the answer is, I posted something last night about this, that

0:55:46that they're still thinking about how to clarify this,

0:55:51but that they're absolutely aware

0:55:53of developers' uncertainty about this.

0:55:56Definitely looking forward to talking to developers next week

0:56:01at WWDC about the way that developers have in their head

0:56:04that they'd like to use subscription,

0:56:06and that in the week after WWDC,

0:56:09they anticipate posting, publishing something

0:56:12that clarifies some kind of fact that clarifies

0:56:16what the rules are going to be.

0:56:18- And when does this take effect?

0:56:22Is it part of the iOS 9 SDK and App Store,

0:56:25or is this something that won't really work

0:56:27until iOS 10 anyway?

0:56:29- That's a good question.

0:56:30I think it's iOS 10.

0:56:31I think they're launching a beta--

0:56:32- So they have time.

0:56:33- Yeah, they said that they're launching a beta over summer.

0:56:36- And there are already subscription apps,

0:56:40and they'll get to take advantage

0:56:41of that new pricing system immediately, it sounds like.

0:56:45- Yeah, well, and the new rev share.

0:56:47One of the big, yeah, that might be the biggest thing

0:56:49that they announced was that any app using subscriptions,

0:56:53after a subscription is a year old,

0:56:55this revenue split changes from 70/30,

0:57:00which is what Apple publicly used

0:57:02for everything at all times everywhere.

0:57:04There are longstanding rumors that, like on Apple TV,

0:57:09some of their individual deals made out with companies

0:57:12that are better, probably 85/15, I guess.

0:57:15But that at least for developers in the iOS and Mac app stores, everything is 70/30.

0:57:22In-app purchases, app purchases, subscriptions, everything.

0:57:25After a year it goes to 85/15 until the end of the subscription.

0:57:30And that's terrific news because that's a significant difference.

0:57:34Especially if it's a 3, 4, 5, 6 year subscription.

0:57:37It's a lot of money.

0:57:39It's like a 20% increase.

0:57:41So that's interesting.

0:57:44And it applies, that applies immediately.

0:57:46So if you--

0:57:47- And I believe retroactively, right?

0:57:47- Yes, so if you already have a subscription app,

0:57:50you know, that previously qualified for a subscription

0:57:55with the old rules, all of your subscribers

0:57:58who've been with you for more than a year,

0:58:01starting next week, I think, you know,

0:58:02when the next billing cycle for those subscriptions

0:58:04comes around, it'll be 85.15 for you.

0:58:06That applies immediately.

0:58:08- Which is nice.

0:58:10I mean, you, you could also argue that it really should just be 97%, 3%, because once

0:58:16the marketing is done, Apple's really only facilitating credit card transactions, but,

0:58:24you know, they also are in the position to set the rules.

0:58:27So I think it's interesting to me, one of the most interesting things about this subscription

0:58:32thing is that this is kind of the problem the app store solved for prior mobile apps.

0:58:42If you think back to the days before the iPhone when you had a flip phone or whatever, there

0:58:49were apps and there were games and that kind of stuff and they were all sold on subscriptions

0:58:53and they were comically overpriced subscriptions and the phone companies took most of the money

0:58:59And the developers got hosed on a lot of it, which is one of the reasons that these, uh,

0:59:04so these apps really never took off, but they all got added to your phone though.

0:59:09Yeah.

0:59:09And I think there were even like class action lawsuits about, you know, how you

0:59:14would kind of get suckered into subscribing to one of them and never get, uh, never,

0:59:18it was never easy to get to unsubscribe and that's that kind of stuff.

0:59:22But when the app store came out in 2008 and made it, you know, an ownership model

0:59:27where for a few bucks or, and then, you know, what eventually went down to 99 cents and free,

0:59:32you could actually buy an app and own it. That was a huge difference over the previous model where,

0:59:37you know, you might get Tetris for $5.99 a month or something like that, of which the developer got

0:59:43less than half of it. And so it is a different time. And obviously the devices themselves have

0:59:50changed so much since then and the apps themselves too. Uh, I think the better, the better model now

0:59:57to kind of look at is how profoundly different Adobe's

1:00:02business is now that they've been able to switch

1:00:05to recurring subscription revenue

1:00:07for their Creative Suite products.

1:00:09- And Microsoft as well. - And Microsoft too,

1:00:11for Office.

1:00:12And if Apple's trying to make the iPad Pro

1:00:17a professional device and they want companies

1:00:20like Adobe and Microsoft to make their highest end software

1:00:24for it, they really need to support the business models that, uh, that

1:00:29those companies are using.

1:00:30So I think that I do expect them to clarify what sort of apps could do

1:00:37subscriptions.

1:00:38I mean, we've, you know, you also see on the indie side, you see an app

1:00:43like Marco's podcasting app where he charges an optional subscription just

1:00:48because you want to support him.

1:00:50So he doesn't renew though.

1:00:51I don't think.

1:00:52Yeah.

1:00:53And I don't know how that sort of thing, I wonder if that would hold up under whatever policies they would institute.

1:01:02I think that I'm really optimistic about this. If Apple takes a laissez-faire attitude to it and let developers...

1:01:11To me, Apple's role should be there to serve as the trusted intermediary between you and the developer you're paying for the subscription to.

1:01:22to, meaning that Apple will be there to make sure that you can unsubscribe easily at any

1:01:27time, that you're not going to get the rate changed on you behind your back, any rate

1:01:32change you have to approve explicitly, that sort of thing.

1:01:38And I think that's perfect.

1:01:40And other than that, I think that they should just let developers try whatever pricing they

1:01:46want and see what works.

1:01:48I don't think that they should really get in the way.

1:01:50So like if a developer of something that doesn't get any content at all, like a calculator

1:01:55app, like Peacock from James Thompson wants to switch to a $3 a year subscription so that

1:02:03there's ongoing revenue and that he can keep doing things like updating the app for new

1:02:10OSs and not have to, you know, because there's no upgrades.

1:02:14There's no upgrades in the App Store.

1:02:16I don't think there are going to be.

1:02:19And so apps like Tweetbot and Twitterific have done things over the years where like

1:02:23when Tweetbot comes out with a major new version of Tweetbot, it's a new SKU in the app store.

1:02:29And if you own Tweetbot 3 to get Tweetbot 4, you have to buy Tweetbot 4 and it downloads

1:02:34as a new app next to Tweetbot 3 on your device.

1:02:39And you have to set it up again and make sure your accounts are in there and then probably

1:02:43delete the old version of Tweetbot so you're not getting like duplicate notifications for

1:02:48the DMs and stuff like that. And that whole fiddly, like now I've got two apps

1:02:53on my home screen and I want to delete the old one and use the new one. It's

1:02:59even worse in some ways than old-school managing your applications on a Mac or

1:03:04PC because of the sandbox. Although I guess maybe to app from the same

1:03:09developer, I think maybe when you with Tweetbot because it's the same

1:03:11developer they can look in the sandbox. Yeah I guess that actually now I think

1:03:14about it when I'm confused because I'm a beta tester of Tweetbot so I see all

1:03:18sorts of weird stuff. But I guess maybe they can read the old Tweetbot 3

1:03:21information because they're the same developer and so it's a little bit

1:03:25easier to migrate. But the whole idea of having to manage these apps as two

1:03:28different apps and and keep it straight and delete the one you don't want anymore,

1:03:32that's the sort of system administration nonsense that the App

1:03:37Store is supposed to eliminate. But there's no other way for a developer to

1:03:41put months and months and months, if not years, of development time into a major

1:03:46new version when most of their customers are, you know, they already have most of the customers

1:03:52they're going to get. That they want to make money, you know, they need to make, they need

1:03:56to monetize the users they already have to support the ongoing development. And to me,

1:04:00subscription pricing is the way forward. Yeah, I agree. And I agree with your assessment that

1:04:06they should let the market sort it out. If, you know, if people want to use this model,

1:04:12then they'll pay for it. And if they don't, they just won't, and the app will fail.

1:04:16So...

1:04:16Right. Or it'll change, you know, adapt or die. You know, change to paid upfront,

1:04:20go back to paid upfront or something like that. And I know that there are people listening. I

1:04:25know, I've heard from you on Twitter. I know that there are people who really hate subscription apps

1:04:29and that they like the idea, like just basic idea of, "All right, I'll give you, we'll agree X amount

1:04:35of dollars. I'll give you $5 for this version of your app." And if a year from now you have a

1:04:40a version with new features and you want more money from me, I get to evaluate

1:04:44whether those features are worth it to me and if not I'll just stick with the

1:04:49one that I have and it'll keep working. Whereas if it's a subscription model and

1:04:53a year from now you're not happy with what the app is and you want to stop

1:04:56your subscription before it renews, the app may, you know, depending on how the

1:05:00developer has it configured, is probably going to stop working or go back to a

1:05:03very limited feature set and you're going to lose what you had because you

1:05:06didn't renew the feature.

1:05:08I realize that in some ways that's a step back

1:05:10from the user's perspective.

1:05:13But the truth is that apps tend to stop working

1:05:16after a year or two anyway if you're not

1:05:19upgrading to the latest version just because of OS changes.

1:05:23The subscription model just makes that more instantaneous.

1:05:27And that's the way stuff has worked on the web forever.

1:05:31I think the web has sort of changed people's mindset

1:05:33on stuff like this.

1:05:34If you sign up for a service like Basecamp,

1:05:37if you stop paying for Basecamp, nobody expects.

1:05:42- Right, exactly.

1:05:45- Nobody expects that you could keep using the old Basecamp.

1:05:48- Yep, yeah, the models have changed

1:05:51and don't be a cheap ass, I think is part of it.

1:05:55But if you get value from software

1:05:59and if the model for the developer

1:06:01to build a sustainable business

1:06:04to make it a recurring revenue thing.

1:06:06I also wonder how much of this has to do with this new Apple,

1:06:09like we're a services company thing.

1:06:13That's probably not the number one, number two,

1:06:15or even number three factors,

1:06:17but for Apple to get more recurring revenue

1:06:19through the app store is a great thing as well.

1:06:22- Yeah, well, this is why I think they should take

1:06:24a laissez-faire attitude towards it,

1:06:26and the reason that I'm optimistic.

1:06:28I mean, to me, the biggest hole in the ecosystem,

1:06:31And I think, I don't see how anybody could deny this.

1:06:34The biggest hole in the ecosystem

1:06:36is serious productivity software for the iPad.

1:06:42That there's lots of great iPhone apps

1:06:44that you can do, quote unquote, "work with" about as best

1:06:49as you can expect to on the phone.

1:06:51Ambitious apps for the phone.

1:06:53And the Mac, that's the whole reason the Mac even still

1:06:55exists, is that there are serious applications

1:06:57that people who work on their Macs all day long

1:07:00can get their work done on.

1:07:02And those sort of apps, there are some for iPad,

1:07:06but nowhere near as many as there are on the Mac.

1:07:08And a lot of them are a lot more--

1:07:11- I would say nowhere near as many as are necessary

1:07:15for the iPad to become the future work machine

1:07:18for a lot of people.

1:07:19- Yes, exactly.

1:07:20I mean, an example would be the very, very popular drawing

1:07:25and it's sort of specialized in UI design.

1:07:27tool, Sketch, Sketch app. It's very popular. And they just announced that they have a sort of, it's not a subscription, but they have a sort of annual, you know, I'll put it in the show notes, I make a note, but they're Mac only. And people love this app. Sketch is a big, big part of the UI work, UI design workflow for an awful lot of developers. And they don't have an iPad app.

1:07:57And they've actually come out publicly and said,

1:08:00"We don't really have plans to make an iPad app

1:08:01"because we don't think it'll be worth it financially.

1:08:04"We don't think that the money we could make from it,

1:08:07"given the ecosystem, the prices people expect on iPad,

1:08:12"that it's just not gonna be worth it."

1:08:14I think Sketch is like $100 on the Mac,

1:08:17and there's just no way,

1:08:19it doesn't seem like the iPad supports that.

1:08:22Maybe if they could go to say a $5 a month subscription,

1:08:26they could. Maybe that would work. I don't know. I don't want to say Sketch in

1:08:30particular, but that's just the sort of thing. You don't see people saying,

1:08:34"We're not going to make a Mac professional tool because we don't think

1:08:36we can make money at it." And you do see people saying that on iPad. And I can't

1:08:42help but hope. I wouldn't necessarily bet on it, but it seems to me

1:08:46possible that subscription pricing for apps like Sketch could be the answer for

1:08:51for the iPad.

1:08:54Yeah, we'll see.

1:08:54I mean, it would have been neat to launch it

1:08:58at the same time as saying, and by the way,

1:09:00Sketch is coming to iPad.

1:09:01But easier said than done.

1:09:05The switch from buying stuff to subscribing to stuff

1:09:07is happening elsewhere, too.

1:09:09I mean, that's where music is going.

1:09:10And there's rumors that Apple is in particular--

1:09:14obviously, Apple Music is a big effort in subscription pricing,

1:09:18but that they're strategically de-emphasizing purchasing

1:09:21music from iTunes as time goes on. I mean, there have been a couple of reports about that.

1:09:25And I subscribe to paper towels. An awful lot of people watch an awful lot of video through

1:09:33Netflix, you know, that they're not buying all this stuff. They're paying Netflix eight bucks

1:09:37a month or nine bucks a month or whatever tier they're at and watching it until their

1:09:42subscription isn't there anymore, at which point they watch nothing. You know, you subscribe to

1:09:48to paper towels. Your paper towels don't disappear though if you stop your

1:09:53subscription. True. And I realize there are definitely trade-offs but I think

1:09:59people who want to be knee-jerk, "I'm gonna resist this, you know, I'm not going

1:10:05down this route at all," you're not moving forward with the industry. And again, I

1:10:10acknowledge that there's, it's not perfect but it's, you know, it's the way

1:10:14things are going. There's also the ads. We can talk about the ads, but let me

1:10:19take a break before we do that. I'll come back to that, and I want to thank our

1:10:23next sponsor, it's our good friends at Harry's. Harry's shaving set will make the

1:10:26perfect Father's Day gift, but you gotta order this soon. You gotta order like

1:10:30right now. Like, you're probably listening to this. I think a lot of people are

1:10:34gonna listen to this over the weekend of June 11th and 12th before WWDC.

1:10:39Order now, and you could get this stuff before the following Sunday, which is

1:10:44Father's Day. So listen, don't even, you know, maybe even just, maybe even just stop right now.

1:10:50Just pause the podcast and go to harrys.com and remember the code "talk show," not with the "the,"

1:10:58just "talk show" and you'll save five bucks. Just stop the show and go order something for your dad.

1:11:04They have a Father's Day shave kit with a matte black razor handle, looks great, chrome razor

1:11:10stand. Harry's moisturizing foam shave gel, three of their handcrafted blade cartridges,

1:11:16a travel cover, and it's all for just 40 bucks and it comes in a sleek giftable box with the option

1:11:23to add custom engraving and a personalized card. They have regular shaving kits if you're not

1:11:28looking for a gift, start at just 15 bucks. And here's the deal, they have their own blade factory,

1:11:34they were sourcing them from this razor blade factory in Germany and they were so happy with

1:11:38that they just bought the factory. They just make the blades themselves. They sell stuff to you

1:11:42guaranteed. And they easily beat the price of big name companies like Gillette and Schick and those

1:11:48people because they're not going through middlemen stuff from Gillette. Gillette makes razorblades

1:11:51and then it goes to a middleman and a distributor and then it goes to like your local drugstores

1:11:58distributor and then the drugstores send it to the individual retail place and the retail place

1:12:03has to pay all this stuff for the store that they're in and all the employees who are there.

1:12:07And then you gotta go find a guy to come and unlock the thing, the anti-shoplifting glass thing,

1:12:13to buy these razor blades. You're paying twice the price for the blades and it's a big pain in the

1:12:17ass. Go to Harry's, use that code "TALKSHOW", you save five bucks off your first purchase and you

1:12:22can get a Father's Day gift. You gotta act quick on that. And if it's just for you, you can do

1:12:28things like get a subscription. There we go, tying it in with the show where you can figure out how

1:12:34often you need new blades and you don't have to do anything they'll just show up

1:12:37every every month or three months or whatever you need so go to Harry's calm

1:12:41and remember that code talk show great sponsor so the last thing Apple

1:12:47introduces search ads in the App Store and now that I see what they're doing

1:12:54here I don't think that it's I think it's worth talking about but I don't

1:12:57think it's worth I think anybody who's upset about it is it's a little

1:13:01misplaced. I don't know that Apple needed to do this, but I feel like it's this isn't really

1:13:06detrimental and it might end up helping developers, including smaller ones. I think the fear that

1:13:14people have is that this is going to be a thing where the auctions for these keywords or whatever

1:13:19are all going to be won by bigger developers with big ad budgets and it's just going to further

1:13:25promote the rich getting richer, meaning the most popular apps getting more popular. But talking to

1:13:33Schiller and seeing how they're doing it, I think not. I think this might actually be a good way for

1:13:39small developers, you know, including really small individual ones, to with a minimal ad spend that

1:13:45they're completely in control of, to get their app at the top of the listing for more searches.

1:13:51An interesting statistic that Shiller revealed was that 65% of all app downloads still come,

1:14:00or the path to it is from the search box in the App Store app. So getting your app,

1:14:07being able to pay to get your app at the top of that list actually seems pretty worthwhile.

1:14:12Yeah, I mean these ads work for a reason and they've driven a lot of growth for Facebook's

1:14:19mobile business and Google has them. It seems logical that Apple would have them

1:14:26too. I'm sure they'll make a nice amount of money for it and it may, I don't think

1:14:35it makes up for the fact that the App Store needs to be better organic search

1:14:40and just the App Store browsing and discovery experience needs to be better

1:14:45but it's hard to fault them for building a system like this.

1:14:50And even then, I've talked to developers

1:14:55who buy a lot of downloads on Facebook and Google,

1:15:00and it's still way cheaper than acquiring a customer

1:15:04almost any other way.

1:15:06- Yes, yeah, I've heard that too.

1:15:08In Schiller's parlance, it's quote, unquote,

1:15:13social networks and search engines.

1:15:15But in reality, it's Facebook and Google.

1:15:19And it's really no other social networks are really big.

1:15:22Twitter has a little bit of it.

1:15:24And when they first launched it,

1:15:25I think a lot of people were optimistic about it.

1:15:27But asking a few people,

1:15:29it seems like Twitter is nothing compared to Facebook

1:15:33with regard to being able to pay for placement

1:15:35to get app downloads.

1:15:37- Yeah, I would say it's Facebook and Google.

1:15:38- Facebook and Google.

1:15:40- To me, the question is,

1:15:42will developers get any good data

1:15:46from Apple on their campaigns?

1:15:48Will they be able to see which keywords drove users?

1:15:53Will they be able to tie those users

1:15:55to any other analytics to tell paid user cohorts

1:15:59versus organic?

1:16:01I'm really curious about that.

1:16:03- I think so.

1:16:05I think that the answer is yes,

1:16:09that you'll be able to see if a certain keyword worked

1:16:11how many came from it. They also have an interesting option where you can just

1:16:16say here's what I'm willing to pay and let Apple pick the the terms that that

1:16:23would be relevant to your app and you don't even have to pick the search

1:16:27keywords let Apple pick them and you only pay per so I don't know whether

1:16:34there's a click or tap but since iOS is more popular than Mac OS I'll say tap

1:16:38pay for tap so as a developer you only pay if your ad is shown but the user

1:16:43doesn't tap it you pay nothing you only pay when the user actually taps on it so

1:16:48if you figure out what what you know what conversion rate you think you can

1:16:52get for everybody who actually taps on your app and they even have a calculator

1:16:56for that to help you figure out like what you should be considering your

1:17:03highest bid in the auction to make sure that you'd be profitable it seems like

1:17:07they have tools like that.

1:17:08And I think that the reporting tools are

1:17:10probably pretty good.

1:17:13We'll have to see.

1:17:14- Yeah, I mean, to me, so,

1:17:16and then there's always users who will tap the ad

1:17:19and then not download the app.

1:17:20And then there are people who will download the app

1:17:21and never launch it,

1:17:22and then they'll launch it once and then never again.

1:17:24So what I don't know is will you be able to identify

1:17:28which of your users were acquired

1:17:31through App Store search ads?

1:17:33- Oh, I don't think so. - Will you be able

1:17:35to compare them?

1:17:35- Yeah, I don't think you'll be able to do that

1:17:37because there's so many privacy-related things.

1:17:41Yeah, so I don't--

1:17:42- Will you be able to target users

1:17:45that have a competitor's app or something like that?

1:17:48I remember hearing once that the iAd let you target users

1:17:53based on what, maybe either what apps they had

1:17:57or what songs they had purchased from iTunes

1:17:59or something like that.

1:18:01I don't really remember, though.

1:18:03- Yeah, I don't know either.

1:18:04And you can definitely target by location,

1:18:08and a user can opt out of that.

1:18:09It's part of the use location services,

1:18:11and you can go to the settings and opt out.

1:18:14But that is interesting to me.

1:18:17I'm not quite sure, I'm not sure I can think

1:18:20of a perfect example for where it would apply,

1:18:22but that seems pretty interesting.

1:18:26- But those are the sorts of things that,

1:18:27as a developer, you would wanna have that access,

1:18:30but Apple's privacy focus might prevent you

1:18:34from having that access.

1:18:36- Right, and I'm thinking about something like,

1:18:39I don't know, like if a conference has a conference app

1:18:44that the location thing could help.

1:18:46But on the other hand, that also seems like the sort of thing

1:18:48where you shouldn't have to pay at all

1:18:50because the search terms should absolutely,

1:18:52if you type in recode conference,

1:18:57the recode app, if you guys had an app,

1:18:59I don't know if you did,

1:19:00If you did, why in the world would it not be the number one result anyway?

1:19:03Yeah.

1:19:04I think we had a web app this time that actually was very nice.

1:19:09Actually surprisingly nice for a web app.

1:19:12Yeah.

1:19:13I think, I mean, so kind of zooming out a bit, I think it's interesting that they went

1:19:21for the strategy of announcing these things first.

1:19:26My guess is that none of these would have made the key,

1:19:31maybe the subscription pricing

1:19:32may have made the morning keynote,

1:19:34but probably not the ad stuff.

1:19:39- I think review times would

1:19:41because they could cover it quickly.

1:19:42And I still think that they're gonna,

1:19:43I still think they'll touch upon it.

1:19:45I think they'll say, as you've probably heard last week,

1:19:49we've made some changes to the App Store.

1:19:51It lets them, here's what I think they're gonna do.

1:19:53It's like the typical Apple keynote style

1:19:55where they'll introduce it, and then at the end of the segment,

1:19:58they'll review what it is we just--

1:20:00here's what we're going to tell you,

1:20:01now we're going to tell you, now we're going to review.

1:20:04They can skip all but the review and just say,

1:20:06as you've probably heard last week,

1:20:09we've put new systems and tools in place

1:20:12to get app reviews to 50% within 24 hours and 90% within 48

1:20:16hours.

1:20:17And then the crowd will go nuts and then cheer.

1:20:20We're adding subscription prices to all app categories

1:20:23and 200 price points for subscriptions

1:20:26and territory-based pricing.

1:20:30We didn't mention that, but I've heard,

1:20:32I try not to be US-centric,

1:20:36but I can't help but be sometimes,

1:20:39but I've heard from a couple people

1:20:41that this territory-based pricing for subscriptions

1:20:43could be huge, and the fact that it wasn't allowed before

1:20:46was really problematic, that effectively,

1:20:49the old way was you'd set a price,

1:20:51If you set it in dollars, the price in China

1:20:54would just be the conversion rate between China's currency

1:20:58and US currency.

1:20:59Whereas now, you could set a dramatically lower price

1:21:02in a country like China and India,

1:21:05where your US price was completely out

1:21:09of reach of most people.

1:21:11And apparently, this is something that is a huge deal.

1:21:15And it could make subscription to even content-based services

1:21:19a lot more interesting.

1:21:22- Yeah, that makes sense.

1:21:23I mean, if you imagine Netflix has a smaller library

1:21:26in many countries, maybe would want to charge a locally,

1:21:31whatever the local equivalent to eight bucks a month is,

1:21:34as opposed to the direct conversion of $8 a month.

1:21:38- Yeah, yeah, I don't know.

1:21:40I could see this stuff being in the keynote,

1:21:42but I can see how if the keynote was deemed full,

1:21:44that these were the things that were,

1:21:46let's just announce them a week in advance.

1:21:49Like I could see it both ways.

1:21:50Like if there was room,

1:21:51I could see holding them for the keynote.

1:21:53If there wasn't, none of them are that blockbuster

1:21:56of a thing.

1:21:59That much of a blockbuster.

1:22:02- They'll have enough to go over with the ARM-based Mac OS

1:22:06to, wouldn't that be something?

1:22:11- You're joking, I mentioned that as an example.

1:22:13I mentioned something like, you know,

1:22:16that apps break over time,

1:22:17like PowerPC apps don't run on Intel Macs anymore.

1:22:21And that something like that could happen again

1:22:22in the future with Intel to ARM.

1:22:25And that was not one of my coy little,

1:22:28I know something is coming.

1:22:29I don't know, I have not heard one thing from one person

1:22:32that ARM-based Macs are a real thing.

1:22:34I just, common sense tells you though,

1:22:36that it might be a thing,

1:22:38because I think Apple has good reason

1:22:40to be unhappy with Intel.

1:22:41Intel seems to be late with everything

1:22:44from mobile chips to desktop chips,

1:22:48Apple would surely like to have it under control,

1:22:50under its own control.

1:22:51And the existence proof is there that there

1:22:53are benchmarks that show the iPad Pro outperforming

1:22:57the new MacBook One.

1:22:59And it's at least roughly on par in terms

1:23:01of just pure CPU performance.

1:23:04So the possibility of ARM-based Macs is real.

1:23:07And when they did the Intel thing back in 2006,

1:23:13They announced it at WWDC, not with hardware

1:23:17that you could go buy, but they preannounced it

1:23:19at WWDC so that developers could start thinking,

1:23:22get the tools to recompile their apps to be fat binaries

1:23:26with native ARM and Intel code.

1:23:28So if such a thing were to happen, it wouldn't be--

1:23:33it would actually be--

1:23:35there's precedent that they might announce it at WWDC

1:23:38nine months before the machines actually ship.

1:23:42So who knows?

1:23:43Huh, all right.

1:23:45I'm all for it.

1:23:46I think that'd be great.

1:23:48Let's do it.

1:23:49I do too.

1:23:49I don't know.

1:23:50I think it could be--

1:23:51I think it's got to happen eventually.

1:23:52I don't know.

1:23:53It might just be three, four years from now.

1:23:56And it's like, well, maybe it just took a while for--

1:23:59maybe they really wanted those chips to be super fast

1:24:02before they do it.

1:24:03But I just think it could happen eventually.

1:24:07And it just seems like something Apple would like to have under its own control.

1:24:12So we'll see.

1:24:12I don't know.

1:24:14- What do you think of this week's rumor

1:24:16about iMessage for Android?

1:24:19- It's in my notes.

1:24:19So that's an interesting thing at a meta level

1:24:22because it came from Mac Daily News,

1:24:24who is not really known for breaking rumors.

1:24:27Mac Daily News is sort of a mysterious website to me

1:24:31'cause I don't know who, there's no byline on it,

1:24:33but it's been around forever.

1:24:35- Forever, yeah.

1:24:36- I mean like, longer than Daring Fireball, I'm pretty sure,

1:24:41But I don't know who runs it.

1:24:44It's a weird little site.

1:24:46Apple to deliver iMessage to Android at WWDC.

1:24:49This was yesterday.

1:24:52Apple will announce that iMessage encrypted text

1:24:54messaging is coming to Android users at WWDC next Monday,

1:24:59according to a source familiar with the company's thinking.

1:25:01This will make it possible for Android and iOS users

1:25:04to communicate securely as iMessage features

1:25:06end-to-end encryption.

1:25:08Blah, blah, blah.

1:25:10The source notes that plans are constantly in flux leading up

1:25:12to Apple keynotes, and the timing of the announcement

1:25:14could change, but that the iMessage instant messenger

1:25:17service would, quote, "definitely be coming

1:25:20to Android this year."

1:25:23The other thing he says is that--

1:25:25because there's a separate rumor that Apple is going to allow

1:25:28person-to-person Apple Pay payments via messages.

1:25:32That's been around for a while.

1:25:33And it's just common sense that Apple has a payment service.

1:25:36Apple has a secure messaging service.

1:25:39Why wouldn't they let me send you money through iMessage?

1:25:43The only thing I question about that-- this is a great topic.

1:25:46I definitely want to talk about it with you.

1:25:49The payment thing, though, is what

1:25:51confuses me because I thought that so much of Apple Pay

1:25:56was tied to the hardware in the phones, the secure enclave.

1:26:02Well, and to me, the bigger question

1:26:05is the fact that it's connected to the credit

1:26:09and debit card network, which has a cost to it.

1:26:13So if you look at the free person-to-person payment systems,

1:26:18they mostly go through bank transfers, ACH bank transfers.

1:26:23If you do wanna use credit or debit,

1:26:27you usually have to pay,

1:26:29although I think Square Cash is free,

1:26:30but Square's in the position to lose money to get new users,

1:26:34whereas that's not really an Apple way.

1:26:37- They're eating those transaction fees.

1:26:40- So you wouldn't just be able to,

1:26:42I couldn't just send you 100 bucks

1:26:44and put it on my Chase Visa.

1:26:45That would cost Apple whatever, like three bucks.

1:26:50So they're not gonna do that.

1:26:52I don't know.

1:26:55And one of my colleagues reported earlier,

1:26:58Apple Pay's interesting.

1:26:59I mean, one of my colleagues reported earlier

1:27:00that they would also be working on Apple Pay for mobile web.

1:27:04I don't know how that would work.

1:27:05Would that be, would there, you know,

1:27:07how would that launch and how would,

1:27:09how would Safari access the secure enclave?

1:27:12You know, going back to the iMessage thing,

1:27:16if iMessage is a marketing tool for selling iPhones,

1:27:20and I think that's how you maybe described it

1:27:22in a previous show,

1:27:25it doesn't make sense to launch it on Android.

1:27:27But if iMessage is suddenly a platform for payments,

1:27:32for potentially bots for all sorts of stuff,

1:27:35then yeah, let's get that on as many devices as possible.

1:27:39So, and then maybe even get a few of those Android users,

1:27:44much like Apple Music going,

1:27:46oh, these Apple services are kind of cool.

1:27:48Maybe I should just get an iPhone and log right in.

1:27:51So I've long been curious as to when there would be

1:27:56some sort of iMessage platform,

1:27:59the way that Facebook Messenger is opening up,

1:28:01the way Slack is and you can kind of see, I believe Apple itself uses iMessage

1:28:08through some sort of server because when you buy, uh, if you use, if you buy

1:28:14an Apple product through their Apple to the Apple store online and then pick it

1:28:19up in a store, they send you an iMessage saying that it's ready for pickup.

1:28:23So, and I don't think that's someone sitting at a Mac or an iPhone typing that

1:28:28And so Apple obviously has a backend to send iMessages

1:28:32through some sort of server queue.

1:28:34So the question is, how rich is that?

1:28:39Are those APIs, is that the kind of thing

1:28:40that they would ever open up to third parties,

1:28:43the way that, again, Facebook Messenger, Line,

1:28:47all these other services are becoming WeChat,

1:28:50becoming platforms for bots

1:28:52and for other person to machine communication.

1:28:57I don't know where that sits for iMessage,

1:28:59but I think it could be really interesting.

1:29:01- And I know there's a lot, this broke yesterday,

1:29:06and most people asking me what I thought

1:29:08were very skeptical of why would they,

1:29:10this seems completely opposite of Apple,

1:29:12and maybe iMessage even was this all previously,

1:29:17was a premium messaging service.

1:29:21Just one of the nice things you get as an iPhone

1:29:24and Mac user is you get this nice messaging service that's

1:29:28end-to-end secure.

1:29:31Maybe they're looking past that now.

1:29:32And as you mentioned before, two quarterly conference calls

1:29:37in a row, a main talking point from Apple

1:29:39was that they are a quote, unquote--

1:29:41they're now one aspect of the company that's

1:29:43worth talking about is that they are a services company.

1:29:46And a messaging service would play exactly into that.

1:29:49And bringing it to Android would be a way to emphasize that.

1:29:53I keep thinking when I see like the monthly active users

1:29:56or daily active users for messaging apps like WhatsApp

1:29:59and what are some of the other, WeChat

1:30:02and some of these other ones,

1:30:04that iMessage has to be up there in the same ballpark

1:30:09in terms of active users on a daily basis.

1:30:12It has to be that if they,

1:30:14somehow if it made sense in any way

1:30:16to spin iMessage off as an independent company,

1:30:18it would be one of the biggest messaging services

1:30:20the world and it would have just by the fact that the demographics of Apple's

1:30:27customers are that they tend to be for lack of a better word richer there you

1:30:34know it's it's a it's a it's not just the number of users but the amount of

1:30:38money that they have to spend is is significant that that would be a valuable

1:30:42company yet so many times when I see I just noticed it last week with Mary

1:30:46Mieker's internet trends thing and she talked about the top messaging services

1:30:50in the world and iMessage wasn't listed.

1:30:55Perhaps I'm colored by being mostly Apple-focused in what I write about, but I really do think

1:31:01iMessage deserves to be treated in that caliber, even though it is iOS and Mac only.

1:31:08I think bringing it to Android would open a lot of people's eyes to iMessage's value

1:31:14as an independent service.

1:31:16- Yeah, by the way, credit where due,

1:31:18I'm now hearing those words in Ben Thompson's voice,

1:31:21the iMessage as iPhone marketing tool.

1:31:24So I think that was Ben who said that on your show

1:31:27a few weeks ago. - Yeah, maybe.

1:31:28- I'm hearing the Wisconsin tones.

1:31:31- So how could they make any money at all on this?

1:31:33You know, like what would be the sense of bringing,

1:31:35like bringing Apple Music to Android makes sense

1:31:38because however many Android users are using it

1:31:42are paying for it.

1:31:43So duh, it makes sense to try.

1:31:45What sense would it make to bring iMessage to Android as it stands today?

1:31:51Well, I don't think any, right?

1:31:53Because it would just be that they would just be losing money on whatever it costs to develop the app,

1:31:58which is probably minor, but they'd be losing on the, you know, the ongoing cost of supporting all those additional messages.

1:32:07Right, all the bandwidth of photos and videos and all that.

1:32:11I think from when Eddy Cue was on the show a couple months ago, I think that at peak

1:32:15that iMessage handles 200,000 messages per second, which is really impressive.

1:32:21I mean, it's, you know, I know that, you know, blah, blah, blah, Apple gets services wrong.

1:32:25I feel like it's like they, all we see are the ones they get wrong.

1:32:28And the fact that iMessage does a tremendous volume and does it really well, and in my

1:32:33experience as a heavy iMessage user, better and better all the time in terms of like not

1:32:38not getting duplicate notifications

1:32:40on different machines and stuff like that.

1:32:42There has to be some other way

1:32:46that they're gonna monetize it from Android users,

1:32:48whether that's payments or whether that's bots

1:32:51from other, like say that other stores

1:32:53could do the same thing that the Apple Store does.

1:32:57But there has to be something like that.

1:32:59So I wouldn't be surprised if that rumor is true at all.

1:33:03- Yeah, I think that could be really interesting.

1:33:08- But you also couldn't argue that that would also be

1:33:10the first ticket for a lot of people to get rid

1:33:15of their iPhone and go to Android, maybe.

1:33:18Probably not millions of people,

1:33:19but there's probably some folks out there

1:33:21who would find switching to Android easier

1:33:25if iMessage were there.

1:33:27It really is a good network effect and a good lock-in,

1:33:30but if the idea is to build a really robust

1:33:36messaging platform out of it that's for other,

1:33:40for bots and other services,

1:33:42then why wouldn't you want to access it?

1:33:46And I wonder if like some markets like India,

1:33:49which Apple has now brought up several times

1:33:51as a key growth area,

1:33:54and Tim Cook spent time there earlier this year,

1:33:57I wonder if that's the kind of thing where it's like,

1:33:58well, first get iMessage on your Android phone,

1:34:01see how cool it is,

1:34:02and then buy a refurbished iPhone

1:34:07as your first opportunity.

1:34:08But I don't know.

1:34:09- I think that iMessage as lock-in

1:34:15is more effective than iMessage

1:34:17as a reason to get an iPhone in the first place.

1:34:19And I've heard stories about like,

1:34:21teenagers who it's like totally uncool

1:34:27to be getting green messages from somebody.

1:34:30And there's memes that are out there

1:34:33where people like on Instagram tweet screenshots of, ooh,

1:34:37gross, a green message.

1:34:40But I can't see how that really works for anything

1:34:44other than teenagers.

1:34:46I mean, who else would be--

1:34:48I notice when I get a green message from somebody,

1:34:50and I think, oh, that's surprising that--

1:34:54I wouldn't have expected so-and-so's

1:34:56to have an Android phone.

1:34:59But I don't think lesser of them, right?

1:35:03- So I do.

1:35:06- Well, I do a little bit.

1:35:08I just think they have bad taste.

1:35:09I don't think of them as a bad person.

1:35:11And I don't think they should therefore feel bad

1:35:14and go buy an iPhone.

1:35:15I just think, oh, there's somebody who doesn't have

1:35:18the good taste to buy an iPhone.

1:35:19- Yeah.

1:35:20- I was lying when I said I don't think less of them.

1:35:23(laughs)

1:35:24But--

1:35:26- Okay, my Google reporter, Mark Bergen,

1:35:29I excuse that he has an Android phone.

1:35:32- Oh, yeah, yeah. - He needs to.

1:35:34- Yeah. - In fact, I prefer him to.

1:35:35- Yeah, I know Mark.

1:35:37We rode in the back of a self-driving Mercedes together.

1:35:40- Really? - Yeah.

1:35:41- Oh, that's cool. - Yeah.

1:35:43- Nice.

1:35:44- I talked about it a couple episodes ago,

1:35:47a couple months ago when we were at the Mercedes

1:35:49self-driving outfit out there in the valley,

1:35:52and Mark and I were the two guys

1:35:53that got picked to go together.

1:35:55- Oh, sweet. - So we could have been

1:35:55killed together as well.

1:35:57- Yeah. (laughs)

1:35:59Yikes.

1:36:00- Yeah, if you follow, if you're a Google reporter,

1:36:03you gotta have an Android phone.

1:36:04But anyway, I don't think they sell many phones with it.

1:36:06But I think once you have a phone

1:36:07and you're used to using iMessage,

1:36:08it's definitely, you know, if you're like,

1:36:11hey, maybe one of these Android, you know,

1:36:12maybe there's some stuff in Android that's appealing to me,

1:36:15like not having your iMessage anymore,

1:36:17it seems like, well, maybe I shouldn't switch.

1:36:20But so it would be magnanimous for Apple

1:36:22to offer it on Android in terms of we

1:36:26don't want to use this as a lock-in.

1:36:29We're confident that people will stick

1:36:31with iPhone for other reasons.

1:36:33And if you do want to leave, take your iMessage ID

1:36:36with you.

1:36:39I also really do believe that the hassles--

1:36:41and I think they've fixed some of these problems.

1:36:43But there were problems that people had, maybe still have

1:36:47to some extent, where once your phone number gets associated

1:36:49an iMessage phone number. If you do switch to Android and just pop your SIM into an Android

1:36:54phone, you don't get text messages from people. You don't get SMS. It's like you have to remember

1:37:03before you switch to disassociate your phone number from your Apple ID and then switch.

1:37:09And that even there were people who even did it the right way and it still got lost and they don't

1:37:14they don't get text messages from iPhone users because Apple keeps trying to send them as iMessages

1:37:19and you know it's a pain in the ass so I think now you can after the fact go in and remove an

1:37:26iMessage device from the server somewhere yeah I think that's the solution that they can they've

1:37:32come up with a way to do that they've given it delivered some kind of interface to allow it

1:37:37but it wasn't there before here's a question I have though about it iMessage on Android

1:37:42is part of the appeal to me a huge part