0:00:00this is episode CLVI of the talk show.
0:00:06Oh, we're already up to CLVI.
0:00:08CLVI. I switched to Roman numerals last week.
0:00:10I didn't listen to last week's episode yet, so you and MG Siegel talked about Roman numerals again, huh?
0:00:14Yeah.
0:00:15That's ponderous.
0:00:16I got on it. I got on a rant because of the getting rid of the 10 in Mac OS X.
0:00:21Oh, right.
0:00:22And I've hated it all along. I hated it right from the first version.
0:00:25I don't like it.
0:00:27You have never liked OS X as the name of the operating system?
0:00:32No, I just think that it was X. X is the coolest letter of the alphabet, and it was a way to put the coolest letter of the alphabet in the name.
0:00:40But because it's so cool, half the people pronounce it O-S-X?
0:00:43Oh, I did it for years. I think I made John Sirkius a shart one time when I told him how
0:00:50I'd gone into the PHPMyAdmin and done a universal search to change all of my OS X as one word
0:00:57to OS SpaceX. You don't want to tell a Perl user that's how you fix stuff on the internet.
0:01:02You got it from right inside of MySQL? Yeah, yeah, that's what I did. I felt so bad though.
0:01:10I was like, how do I obliterate this?
0:01:13But isn't the conventional wisdom-- you tell me.
0:01:16You're the Mac blogger.
0:01:17But isn't the conventional wisdom
0:01:18they're going to switch to this kind of standardized way
0:01:21for Mac OS, iOS?
0:01:24I think it's almost certain.
0:01:25Yeah, seems very sensible.
0:01:27The only question is whether they're
0:01:29going to capitalize the M in Mac OS,
0:01:31even though they themselves don't capitalize the I in iOS
0:01:35or the W in watchOS or the T in tvOS.
0:01:40They don't capitalize the T and the V.
0:01:44Right.
0:01:46And that's one--
0:01:47They got to go lowercase.
0:01:48Yeah, but the counterargument-- and there was like a unusual--
0:01:53it seemed like--
0:01:54I don't know if-- it just seems like an unusual mistake
0:01:56for Apple to make.
0:01:57But they had like an environmental--
0:01:58whatever the day is where you celebrate
0:02:04the world's environment. What's that called? Green Day?
0:02:07>> Or Green Day, maybe Earth Day?
0:02:09>> Earth Day. What's the difference?
0:02:11Green Day. On Green Day,
0:02:13they had a promotional page up and they said something blah,
0:02:16blah, blah, and they spelled it Mac OS with a capital M, closed up.
0:02:22I have another friend, my friend Nat,
0:02:24who said that this is going to bug him because he's like us,
0:02:27goes back to the old days of the classic Mac OS where they called the OS Mac OS.
0:02:31But back then, it was capital M-A-C space O-S.
0:02:38And--
0:02:38It said in Garamond.
0:02:41Yeah, but when you'd be writing about it,
0:02:43when you'd see publications that would mention it and spelled
0:02:45it closed up, you were spotting an error, right?
0:02:50So the way that we think they're now going to spell it
0:02:52was a late '90s frequent typo.
0:02:56And now it's going to be apparently the real way.
0:02:59I think the argument that they might capitalize it
0:03:01without capitalizing the other ones is that Mac is a registered trademark and watch TV
0:03:06and I are not.
0:03:10Well you know the other thing is think about it for so long how you know Mac was a you
0:03:17know that was a name that insiders mostly called it but you know it seems like you know
0:03:22it just in the in the popular imagination Macintosh and Apple for a number of years
0:03:27were synonymous which is going to drive lots of people crazy I know I know there were things
0:03:29before the Mac. But Macintosh and Apple, to this day John Roderick still calls the
0:03:33company Macintosh, I think, because that's for a long time those were kind of
0:03:37conflated to be sort of the same thing. So Macintosh means something. Mac means
0:03:41something. But Mac OS, I mean, how much are they even... well, here's a can of worms, but
0:03:48you know, the Mac is not the central pillar in what they're doing anymore.
0:03:51And that reflects its place as part of the ecosystem.
0:03:55Who's the other guy on ATP?
0:03:59Oh, you're talking about the other guy? You're talking about Casey?
0:04:03Yes. On their show last week, they were talking about their excellent new t-shirt designs.
0:04:07They're the worst!
0:04:11That's a great design. I totally believe it.
0:04:15The ATP Apple/BMWM
0:04:19is brilliant for that show.
0:04:23But I saw that design and I was like, "Oh my god, how did that not..."
0:04:27I think they ought to make that the logo of the show.
0:04:30I mean, it's amazing.
0:04:31Because of the whole gimmick where they...
0:04:33The whole reason they even have the ATP show is that they had a car podcast for a while.
0:04:37It's a classic logo in that sense of being very attractive just to look at it.
0:04:41That's kind of cool, that's kind of retro.
0:04:43But if you get the joke, it's kind of perfect.
0:04:45Right.
0:04:46In his explainer, though, Casey described it as a reference to the six-color Macintosh
0:04:52logo.
0:04:53to say that, you know, that, you know, the way that people conflated Apple with
0:04:57Macintosh. It was not the Macintosh logo, it was, it was the Apple logo. I think, I
0:05:03think John Syracuse pointed out that that was an error. This is, you know,
0:05:09now you're getting into this territory where, man, you're gonna get into the, you
0:05:12know, the greater nerd syndrome. There's gonna be always, always gonna be somebody
0:05:16that knows slightly more about this and is slightly less interesting in how they
0:05:18describe it. It just keeps getting worse and worse and worse.
0:05:21So actually the colors of the apple logo to represent the rainbow.
0:05:25Uh, have you ever seen a rainbow?
0:05:27Uh, thanks buddy.
0:05:30Super helpful.
0:05:31I miss it.
0:05:33You know, still how long now has it been that,
0:05:37um, what, you know, just gray or for, I guess,
0:05:41black apple.
0:05:43But I miss it, man.
0:05:44When you used to be, when you bought a Mac, you got the, uh, you got the stickers,
0:05:49but now the stickers are just white.
0:05:50But the Rainbow stickers are so cool and they're so, I mean, they're so like, they're so 80s, but they're also so 70s and they're kind of, I don't know, they're sort of like weirdly timeless and retro.
0:06:00Yeah. I miss it. I miss it.
0:06:02Uh, they still, they've, they've started slightly bringing it back a little bit in retro situations, didn't they, uh, I, I think they brought it back for the, the LGBT Pride Parade in San Francisco?
0:06:17Oh, that's cool.
0:06:18Or else they did something that clearly referenced it, you know, with the connection between
0:06:23the rainbow as a symbol for that community and Apple.
0:06:27And then I think that they stuck it in a commercial.
0:06:30I know they used it in at least one, because they had a commercial where they showed people's beat-up MacBooks with stickers on them.
0:06:38Oh, and they did a super fast montage.
0:06:40Yeah, super fast. And one of them was an old-school Apple logo, which was like, "Whoa!" as like a real geek.
0:06:47it was cool to see Apple put up a computer with the six color Apple logo
0:06:51again even though it was in...
0:06:52They didn't like Trotsky it they didn't like disappear it.
0:06:55It was still in there.
0:06:56And then I could have sworn there was another commercial.
0:06:58This is why I need a live audience.
0:07:00Those, you know, the shows with the live audience somebody would already have the
0:07:03link in there. I think there was one where they ended it. I don't know if it
0:07:06was that one where they went through the Apple 40 years and 40 seconds or what
0:07:09but they had a spot where they showed it.
0:07:12I do miss it.
0:07:13I do too. It's an interesting time.
0:07:15Very interesting time. It's funny, I was watching the Warriors game the other night, and I was like,
0:07:19"Man, that logo is that... those uniforms. Ugh, that's the worst."
0:07:23And Madeline's like, "Well, she's like, 'What the hell are you talking about? That's totally like their throwback, retro logo.'"
0:07:27And I was like, "Oh, that's cool." And I kinda liked it once I knew that it was old.
0:07:31I kinda hate their logo. I kinda hate their logo.
0:07:33It's really bad.
0:07:34'Cause they even used that... what's that goofy font? The, uh...
0:07:38Uh, that... it's like fake, classy, uh...
0:07:42I'll have to look.
0:07:43Oh.
0:07:45Well, anyway, it's not a good logo.
0:07:48I kind of like their colors.
0:07:49I like their colors.
0:07:50I do too.
0:07:51I do too.
0:07:52I like the three pointers.
0:07:53Oh, yeah.
0:07:54It's kind of like a-- is it a copper plate?
0:07:56Maybe a little bit?
0:07:57A little bit copper-- not quite copper plate, but yeah,
0:08:00it's a copper plate.
0:08:03Yeah, copper plate.
0:08:03That's exactly the font I'm thinking of.
0:08:05That's one of those fonts that I used
0:08:07to use when I first started working in design,
0:08:10because I thought, wow, this makes everything look classy.
0:08:12Oh, absolutely.
0:08:13It's like papyrus for men with men's warehouse suits.
0:08:16You know, used to be comic sands and now it's papyrus. It's just, uh,
0:08:23God or, you know, Philip Mistral, Mistral's fun. Like, you know, Mistral's fun.
0:08:27If you're like Guy Fieri at a beach bar, I'll roll with Mistral. You know,
0:08:31that's fun. You know what I mean? The surfy font.
0:08:33Yeah. Yeah, I know exactly.
0:08:35But you know, uh, and you know, even copper plate fine, you know, pick a weight,
0:08:39have some fun with it. But like papyrus, man,
0:08:42Papyrus is the new Comic Sans. If it's like a sign in your spa or it's your menu of the day, it's like it's always Papyrus.
0:08:50So with the Warriors, how amazing is it that that photo of Eddie Hugh with Stephen Stephen Curry that was...
0:08:59It was delightful! So perfect. I thought it was a wonderful image. I would have worn some nicer shoes, but I think it's one of the flip-flops.
0:09:06It's one of those images though where it's like...
0:09:09I mean, I'm not...
0:09:12I haven't been into basketball for a while. I used to be really into basketball, but I like the sport.
0:09:18I happen to find the style that Golden State plays to be delightful.
0:09:22It's a team that really has fun playing basketball, and I used to play basketball.
0:09:27I found the reason I liked playing it is that I found that it is a very fun game to play,
0:09:31especially if it goes right. If you're moving the ball around and everybody's getting the ball and
0:09:36your fast breaks and it's lots of scoring and it's not just, you know, two seven-foot guys slowly but surely backing their way to the basket.
0:09:45It can be a beautiful game and that's how Golden State plays.
0:09:48And it's like watching a video game sometimes with these guys where they're shooting from ten feet past the three-point line and just hit nothing but net.
0:09:55Lots of fun to watch. So I've really been into the playoffs this year.
0:09:58And of course I know who Eddie Q is. I've had him on my show even.
0:10:02And then here's the photo of the game, of one of the most amazing games in recent NBA
0:10:07history.
0:10:08And it's iconic.
0:10:09It will probably become an iconic photo.
0:10:11Yeah, it really will.
0:10:14And he's wearing flip-flops.
0:10:15He's dressed better there than he is at a lot of presentations.
0:10:18It's cool if I crash here for a couple weeks, it's alright Eddie, but you know, you gotta
0:10:23leave at some point.
0:10:24Here's my take.
0:10:25You know, there's still this...
0:10:26My take on the flip-flops is first and foremost that I understand that it's a California thing
0:10:32and I'm not, I'm an East Coast person. We don't really, you know, grown men don't really wear flip flops out,
0:10:37even if it's just to a basketball game. But I understand that California is a little more casual.
0:10:41My take on it, though, is having been to a lot of events, sporting events, rock concerts, etc., at an arena-type atmosphere,
0:10:51that the floor situation isn't all that great. Now, I realize he had courtside seats, and maybe they make an effort to
0:10:58keep the spilled beer and soda to a minimum down there at the courtside. But that's my
0:11:04first thought, is that you kind of want some waterproof footwear when you go to an arena.
0:11:10Oh, God. Where do you begin? Well, first of all, I mean, well, I realized that was, wasn't
0:11:18that, was that in Oklahoma? Yeah. No, no, it was across the river. It was over there
0:11:23in Oklahoma. Okay, so, okay. But, I mean, you know, the Bay Area is not California. It's
0:11:27a different thing and it's not a question of you know I mean it's one
0:11:30thing to like you know live in Pasadena or something like hey look at me I don't
0:11:33have toes on my shoes yeah but like here like man if you're walking around San
0:11:37Francisco dude you do not want to be wearing flip-flops this is just so many
0:11:41when I when my daughter's game we're getting ready to go downtown with my
0:11:44daughter like I want to put her in a Tyvek suit like no I mean she's got a
0:11:47she's got a wear socks and shoes and like you know I wanted to put on some
0:11:51like, you know, medical booties. It's like, it's not good. They're moving the, I think
0:11:58they're talking about moving the arena right near where my wife works, which is very near
0:12:01AT&T Park.
0:12:02Yes, yes.
0:12:03And like, kind of across the street from a children's emergency hospital. So, it'd be
0:12:10real interesting to try and get your kid in during a big game. I don't watch sports, I'm
0:12:14not into sports. I've been enjoying watching you on Slack talking about this. You told
0:12:17fantastic anecdote you probably won't share here, but you had an amazing anecdote about
0:12:22your basketball career that I'd love you to share sometime.
0:12:26I would share it. I'll share the story. I'll share the story.
0:12:28Okay, I'd love to hear that. All I want to share is this. If you're going to be somebody
0:12:32who watches three sports games a year, boy, that was a great one to watch.
0:12:36Because it reminds me a little bit of how I... There was a time when I enjoyed watching
0:12:40tennis. I'm not a tennis fan, but it used to be in the '80s, you could really enjoy
0:12:44that combination of like ace serves plus a lot of just insane volleying and it feels
0:12:50like that got to we might have talked about this before but it feels like tennis eventually
0:12:52just become all about the aces and all about like the hitting super super hard and the
0:12:57beauty of watching those two teams and the way that they complemented the way that the
0:13:01other played is yeah you're gonna get those two guys Steph Curry and the guy who looks
0:13:04like Steph Curry they're gonna be dropping a lot of three-pointers and that's amazing
0:13:08but then it could also be Steph Curry like just he it's almost like he's moving through
0:13:14a party. And he's just going, "Excuse me, excuse me."
0:13:17Like, you're like, he's like, you know, "I just need to get by here for a minute."
0:13:19Boom! Layup! And you're like, "How did he do that? How did he move past all of those
0:13:24people?" It's fast-paced. They got the long game
0:13:27thrown from three points. They're going up for the layups. The teamwork is
0:13:31fantastic on both teams. And you just, you just see these two
0:13:33teams that are so well matched and are both
0:13:36operating at the height of their performance, and it's a complete delight
0:13:39to watch. He moves through the defense while
0:13:43dribbling the basketball in a way that I don't think most athletic people could get through the same defense without the basketball.
0:13:50Just run. Just slip through these guys. Just get through them.
0:13:53If you show somebody that pattern, like with Fred Astaire's feet on the floor dance moves, and said to somebody, "Go repeat what he just did five times,"
0:14:00there's no way somebody could do it.
0:14:01It really, I think it really, and it's always more impressive in slow motion.
0:14:06It really looks like some kind of visual effects shot that, you know, Todd Vizzieri put together, you know, like here.
0:14:12Steph, just run through this crowd and then I'll, you know, we'll make sure we'll put the basketball in afterwards.
0:14:17We'll do it in post.
0:14:19It's composited. Yeah.
0:14:20Yeah.
0:14:21But like, you know, you just see one of those guys. What's the other guy's name? I forget his name. The other...
0:14:24Clay Thompson.
0:14:26Thompson. Yeah, that montage you put up was great. His 11 three-pointers.
0:14:30But the crazy part is, you know, I'm used to watching basketball in the Larry Bird era.
0:14:34And when you see these guys moving so fast, passing so fast, and you see somebody feet
0:14:40beyond the three-point line. They've had the ball for about a quarter of a second.
0:14:43They take a shot, and my immediate thought is, "Oh, that's a shame, throwing away that shot.
0:14:47That's a shame they did that." And you go, "Swish! Doesn't even touch the rim."
0:14:50Like, what has become--what is this game? I don't even recognize this game anymore.
0:14:54It's so much more fun to watch.
0:14:56I think that what's happened is that
0:14:59it's taken until now for--even though the three-pointer--the three-pointer went into
0:15:03the NBA, I think, in 1981
0:15:06or so, and it came to college
0:15:10in the later 80s and high school around the same time too.
0:15:15So when I played high school basketball,
0:15:17we had the three point shot, but it was new.
0:15:19Like the paint on the court in the high school gym
0:15:21was different color than the rest of the court
0:15:23because they had to pay a guy to come in and add it.
0:15:26And coaches in all sports tend to be conservative.
0:15:32They are, you know, they don't want to rock the boat.
0:15:36And so it was always treated as a novelty
0:15:38and you don't want to, you know, they always, coaches were always telling me, you know,
0:15:42you don't want to win and win or lose or die by the three or live or die by the three.
0:15:47When it was yelling, it must have seemed like a risky trick.
0:15:49Yeah, and if you missed two or three in a row, coaches would be like, that's it, you know,
0:15:54you know, stop shooting it because you're, you know, you're not, you're cold tonight.
0:15:57Whereas like, Klay Thompson the other night missed six or seven, his first six or seven
0:16:02three-pointers and just kept firing them up there and eventually they go in because it's actually,
0:16:06that's actually the way statistics work, right? Were you the one who posted that image that was
0:16:10basically the second half in shots? Did you see that graphic and it was like shots taken, shots
0:16:16missed? Oh no, that was our mutual friend Ben Thompson posted that. Okay, that's incredible.
0:16:22Yeah, and just where they took their shots and just two different styles of play where Oklahoma
0:16:26City is not really actually a relatively poor three-point shooting team overall.
0:16:32And the golden stage shot chart, like just little dots on the court of where they took shots,
0:16:37it looked like this is this looks like the time in practice when we practice our three-pointers.
0:16:42Right, right, right. With nobody's arms, you know, waving around.
0:16:46So I think what happened is that it took until now to get coaches who grew up in the three-point
0:16:54era to really embrace it as a "it's okay to shoot it." And just, you know, for your edification,
0:17:01Steve Kerr, the coach of Golden State, was a wonderful three-point shooter. He played college
0:17:07ball at Arizona. I think he graduated. I used to be a sports fanatic. I can even tell you when he
0:17:13graduated. I think he graduated in 1988. And then he had a very nice pro career, including playing
0:17:18with the Michael Jordan Bulls later in the late 90s. And he was more or less the guy who, like,
0:17:23when Michael Jordan would get double-teamed or even triple-teamed, Steve Kerr was the guy whose
0:17:28man probably left him to go double team Jordan and Jordan would just flip him the ball and
0:17:33he would knock down three-pointers. So I think having a coach who grew up in the three-point era
0:17:37really makes the difference in terms of embracing it. I think I saw a stat the other day that,
0:17:42and now Larry Bird in the 80s was, I think, without question the best three-point shooter in the NBA.
0:17:47But even Larry Bird is on the record as saying he doesn't even like the rule. He kind of,
0:17:52he's always thought it was a gimmick and that, you know, he'd shoot it because he can shoot from that
0:17:56far but he always thought two points is good enough for anybody. Or I guess
0:18:01the mantra that a lot of the old-timers had was that you shouldn't be able to
0:18:05lose with a two-point lead and you know that the worst you do is go to overtime
0:18:10and a three-point lead should be a sure thing. That if you have a three-point
0:18:14lead with with seconds to go you could just walk off the court because that's
0:18:18it. That's good enough to win. And it just changes. When you see real changes in sports,
0:18:24this is actually a question, not a statement. When you see rule changes in sports, just as a way outside observer,
0:18:32it seems like they're often in the interest of making it more interesting or speeding things up,
0:18:38or closing some kind of a loophole that makes the game less competitive and interesting given certain conditions.
0:18:45Is that kind of a fair statement? Like with baseball and football, it seems like that's really the case.
0:18:50Yeah, and the three-point line is definitely that sort of idea. That it was an answer to
0:18:56what was seen as an epidemic that the game was being taken over by seven-footers who
0:19:00would just toss the ball into him down low and watch him bang away.
0:19:07Boy, that Khal Drogo guy playing for Oklahoma is pretty amazing, though. That shot that
0:19:15that guy made like he just jumping toward the net he seems like he's about
0:19:19three feet off being able to dunk it and he somehow just gets it in amazing to
0:19:24watch it's good stuff all right let me take a break and thank our our first
0:19:30sponsor and it's a new sponsor for the show good friends at meh calm these guys
0:19:37run a daily daily deal site you go to meh calm and every day they have a new
0:19:41thing that's for sale and sometimes they sell out because they only have a limited number of them
0:19:46sometimes they don't and they're the same guys who years ago had a site called Woot. You could tell
0:19:53they even sort of named their stuff the same way except they were more excited back then they were
0:19:57excited in the early days and they named it Woot and now they've been beaten down by the man and
0:20:02they just call it Meh because what happened is they sold Woot to Amazon. It did not go well
0:20:09And eventually, it got to the point where under Amazon, Woot was selling multiple items a day,
0:20:15and the Woot guys were like, "You know, we're a daily deals site. The whole gimmick is we sell
0:20:18one thing a day." And Amazon was like, "Well, we're Amazon. We sell everything." And so they left,
0:20:25and they started their site up again, and they just called it Meh. And it's great. It's not just
0:20:30about the daily deals, though. The thing is, is you got to read the descriptions they write for it.
0:20:36They're real writers and they put funny videos up.
0:20:38It's really like the daily deal thing is just an excuse for them to create the sort of content that they want to create.
0:20:44That's really what they want. They want people to come in to check out their site every day just to see what they've posted,
0:20:50what they've written, the funny videos they've put together.
0:20:53And then if you happen to like the deal of the day, you can buy it.
0:20:57And if you don't, you can just give it a... they even have a button.
0:21:00You just sign up and you have an account and you give it a "meh" and then they know that you weren't interested.
0:21:05So, really great stuff, very fun, very interesting. These guys are super clever,
0:21:10so go check them out at Meh.com.
0:21:14I got a killer deal today. What's their deal today?
0:21:17This will be too late. Nobody's gonna be able to get it because... No, it's meta too late.
0:21:21Because it's... First of all, as we record this, it is sold out.
0:21:25But also it's a deal day. You know, but again, just going in and reading for the
0:21:29writing is so fun. They got the FoodSaver vacuum sealing system,
0:21:32Albeit refurbished. I paid 80 bucks for this a couple months ago, because I do lots of sous-vide cooking at home.
0:21:42I get this back in 22 bucks, out the door. It's crazy.
0:21:47Here's their description. "You shouldn't use this to seal marijuana that you legally buy in Washington, Oregon, Alaska, or Colorado,
0:21:54so it's easier to conceal when traveling to or through other states, no matter how ridiculous you think it is
0:22:01it is for possession of a plant to be legal in one state but illegal in others no matter
0:22:04how obvious it is that marijuana prohibition is on its last legs worldwide, that would
0:22:09be wrong.
0:22:10So that's the type of stuff you can get from them.
0:22:11All right, you want me to tell my basketball story?
0:22:13I would.
0:22:14I'm not embarrassed to tell this story.
0:22:17So when I was in high school, I played recreational basketball.
0:22:20I was pretty good.
0:22:21My senior year, I scored 14 points a game and we had a pretty good team.
0:22:26And I could shoot.
0:22:27You know, my thing, I didn't like to mix it up.
0:22:28What was your position?
0:22:29You forward?
0:22:30you forward sort of like a small forward or maybe a tall shooting guard it's you know but i know but
0:22:36i was good good at you know passing on a fast break i scored lots of layups on fast breaks
0:22:41and i was good at shooting a three um although i think the most i ever made in the game was
0:22:46five or six um it made me mad because i played in a christmas tournament one time
0:22:52uh and they had had a thing in the the the like a school hosted like a little you know round robin
0:22:59two-team or four-team Christmas tournament. They had a little program and they had like
0:23:03our Christmas tournament records and one of them was for three-pointers
0:23:07for like across the whole tournament and I broke it. And then the next year they didn't put that
0:23:13record in because they only printed it because it was one of their home team players who had it.
0:23:17It made me mad. Anyway, there was a team in our county that we'd play a couple times a year and
0:23:22there was a kid on the team who I'm guessing was born this way but you know could have been an
0:23:27accident, but he only had one hand. And I think it was his left hand. And he was about my size,
0:23:36and he was really, he was actually pretty good at basketball. And so because he was about my size,
0:23:40I often guarded him. And I remember early on, maybe like 10th grade, maybe 11th grade,
0:23:46we were playing a summer league game and I was guarding him and he was posting me up. In other
0:23:50words, he's backing me down on the paint and so my chest is to his back. And it all of a sudden I
0:23:56felt on the the nubbin at where he had like a just was sort of missing the hand and his his
0:24:03wrist ended with like a little nubbony thing and all of a sudden I felt the nubbin in my hand and I
0:24:08instinctively was just a little bit honestly I was a little grossed out I took a step back
0:24:14and his teammate passed him the ball and he turned around and made a layup because I wasn't right on
0:24:18his back anymore and I thought oh man and then like next possession or two you know five two
0:24:24minutes later, the same thing happens, except he's sticking it in my stomach. And I thought,
0:24:29son of a bitch, this guy's doing it on purpose. And I was like, I'm not falling for this.
0:24:35And I had told nothing but… I was like, that is… I had nothing but respect for him.
0:24:39But I figured it out, and I played him for years afterwards, and he did it all the time.
0:24:43And I would tell my teammates, hey, either let me guard him, or if you're going to
0:24:48guard him, know that he's going to do this. And I would watch, and he'd do it all the
0:24:52the time. And I have, I thought it was so genius, it was like a way of like, you know,
0:24:56hey, I have nothing but respect for the guy because he was actually a good shooter. He
0:25:00could, you know, shoot the three-pointer and everything with one hand.
0:25:03But I like you wouldn't think so like anybody who said you wouldn't look at another person
0:25:07and criticize them because oh that guy's no fair he's got long legs or that guy's got
0:25:11big hands or that guy's got long arms or a good eye. He's just he's using what he's got
0:25:16effectively.
0:25:17Yeah, and it's, you know, I'm not, you know, I have nothing but no complaint about it,
0:25:22but I thought it was genius. I thought it was a way of embracing, you know, taking a
0:25:26limitation and embracing it, making the most of it. And I'll tell you, it worked. It absolutely,
0:25:31the first time on me, it worked like a charm. And I remember when other people on my team
0:25:34were guarding him, seeing it work and saying, "I told you he was going to do that."
0:25:41Ah, sports.
0:25:45So we were going to talk about
0:25:49I don't know if there's anything else you want to talk about up front, but we could talk about
0:25:53I want to talk about this AI stuff. Yeah, me too. And I know it's driving people nuts
0:25:57It's driving people nuts to call this
0:26:01AI, and I don't know why. I don't see how anybody could deny
0:26:05that, you know, I know there's some kind of formal
0:26:09computer science PhD level definition of artificial intelligence in that in some
0:26:15ways this doesn't apply. But if you took an Amazon Echo back or took someone, I
0:26:21guess you can't take it back because it wouldn't have the internet, but took
0:26:23someone from 1978 to today and showed them an Amazon Echo and say, "Is this
0:26:30artificial intelligence? Yes or no?" They're gonna say yes. Right? It's
0:26:35almost like every time we solve an AI problem, once we solve it, it no longer is magical
0:26:43and therefore it no longer counts as AI. AI is only—
0:26:46Just because you understand how the effect was pulled off doesn't make it a magic trick.
0:26:50I mean, it's still a magic trick even if you understand the effect. And to bring somebody
0:26:55from 1978 and I yell at my dingus and say, "Hey, when's the next Bartram coming?"
0:26:59That's magic. That feels like AI. Even if that's not what a computer scientist would
0:27:04call it.
0:27:05Yeah, even if, like, once you know how the trick is done, you're like, "Well, it just
0:27:08hooks up to the local API for your public transport."
0:27:13It hooks up to the magic network in the sky that connects all computers.
0:27:16Oh, by the way, did we mention there's a magic network in the sky that connects all computers
0:27:20now?
0:27:21Oh, by the way, did we mention everyone has computers in their pocket now?
0:27:24Right.
0:27:26The device knows the weather because it's got a GPS and, you know, it knows your zip
0:27:30code.
0:27:31Oh, by the way, we can predict weather now.
0:27:32We didn't used to be able to do that.
0:27:33Oh, by the way, your pocket computer makes a beepy noise when it's about to rain in the next two minutes.
0:27:39Devices know where they are to within a house or two.
0:27:43There's a kind of cuisine that isn't even popular yet that you can request in your neighborhood on your pocket computer.
0:27:49Right. Look, this isn't AI. Your phone thinks it's next door.
0:27:57Oh, that's so stupid.
0:27:59Oh, God. Just because you say to your pocket computer, "Tell my wife I'll be running late,
0:28:07and it knows how to send it to her," of course it's a trick. There's a little wizard inside
0:28:11of there.
0:28:12Do you know what I try to—the thing is, you saw in my long discursive notes about
0:28:18this, that I guess I feel like part of it is I'm trying to do two things. One is I'm
0:28:22trying to avoid using what I know to be terms of art. So, I mean, people talk about AI,
0:28:27talking about machine learning, and even getting as specific as saying just, you know, Siri or Echo or
0:28:32what have you. It's just, I'm more interested in what this stuff is doing for a consumer.
0:28:38And I mean, that requires a little bit of extrapolating about what's happening technically
0:28:42behind it, but I don't think it makes it any less fascinating what's happening
0:28:46when we don't call it a science-y name.
0:28:47I completely agree. So I'm just brushing all this under the umbrella of AI,
0:28:55Because I don't know what else to say. I think separating it into voice assistance versus AI
0:29:00is not helpful. Well it doesn't get to all of the constituent parts that, you know, so if we say
0:29:08Siri, you know, to paraphrase Raymond Carver, you know, what we talk about when we talk about
0:29:12Siri, which part of Siri do you mean? Are you talking about dictation? Are you talking about,
0:29:16you know, being able to interact with, are you talking about the button on your phone? Like,
0:29:20that means lots of different things, and I feel like to understand where this stuff is going,
0:29:25It's very helpful. It's not helpful to fixate on what we call it. It's helpful to focus on what it
0:29:32does and what are the potential, as far as we can tell in this, you know, short to medium term,
0:29:37what are the things that are likely to help or hinder the growth of all of these various pieces
0:29:43that we lose in the lights every time we call it AI? That's my feeling.
0:29:47You know, if we just keep calling it AI, we keep calling it AI. Well, what does that mean?
0:29:50It's the kind of thing you do when you're talking to your phone in your car,
0:29:54the same thing as what's happening when IFTT turns your humidifier off, like, those are such
0:29:59different things, and yet they are completely related because they are parts of this ecosystem.
0:30:04Down to the ability, like I said, down to the ability to pick which florist you want to use
0:30:07when you talk into your pocket computer. Those are all part of the same system, and I feel like
0:30:12it gets really confused when people try to just keep throwing it, throwing it under the bus by
0:30:17calling it all this same, like, fruity future world stuff that nobody's ever going to want.
0:30:22Quick aside, I've been struggling. I think a lot of podcasters struggle. I know I have,
0:30:26talking about this stuff, because there's this phrase you can say to address Siri that you don't
0:30:34want to say on a podcast because it can trigger it on listeners' phones and devices if they're not
0:30:40listening with headphones. And a reader suggested I wrote this down, and unfortunately I did not
0:30:45write down his name, and I'm sorry. I'd love to give you credit. Whoever you are, I thank you.
0:30:50his solution is that while we're talking about it on a podcast, we can say, "Hey, comma, Siri."
0:30:56How about, can I suggest, that's very good, can I suggest another one that might be even better?
0:31:01How about "Yo, dingus"? Okay. Because that's not going to trigger nothing. Not right now.
0:31:06Although it might if you and I start a startup with one of these things.
0:31:10Easy. Because I think we would definitely call ours "The Dingus." "Yo, dingus."
0:31:18I can't have dead weight in my incubator.
0:31:20Yodingas.
0:31:22Alright, I like that too.
0:31:24So I'm gonna put that out there. Hey comma Siri if you want to talk about Siri in particular, and then we'll say Yodingas to address these things in general.
0:31:31I do think it's, I think the terminology is interesting though, because Siri is an umbrella term for stuff that is not really AI.
0:31:42it's even we even call it Siri when you're just talking about voice
0:31:46dictation where you just hit the little microphone to to dictate a text that you
0:31:52want typed out you're not even asking a query or anything like that whereas
0:31:57Google doesn't really it it seems like until very recently they didn't even
0:32:02have a name for their thing I used to call it Google now but then I found out
0:32:05Google now isn't really the AI thing now is like their contextual thing where
0:32:12They show you cards based on what they think you want to see at the moment.
0:32:16And now they call it Google assistant, I guess, for the drive and
0:32:22but it benefits their brand to just,
0:32:24to not overly disambiguate that by just getting you used to the idea that
0:32:29Google is this big bunch of functionality that helps you with your life. So,
0:32:33you know, they might have brand names for things,
0:32:35but I would think when you hail it, it's unlike the other ones,
0:32:38it does make sense that you would say, yo, Google.
0:32:40- Yeah, I think that from just a typical user standpoint,
0:32:44it doesn't matter because it don't,
0:32:46and maybe it's less confusing for them
0:32:48to just think of Google as a thing that they can talk to
0:32:52instead of just type at.
0:32:53You just, just give it to us.
0:32:56Just tell us what you want and we'll just figure it out.
0:32:58- It's shockingly fast.
0:32:59I mean, so right there,
0:33:01one of the distinctions you're making there,
0:33:02I mentioned this a couple of weeks going back to work,
0:33:04is there are a lot of folks who understandably
0:33:07gave up on everything Siri a long time ago,
0:33:11which I have to say is somewhat understandable given the basic way most
0:33:14of us deal with this stuff, which is we try it,
0:33:17it works or doesn't work, we try it again, it works or doesn't work, and eventually
0:33:21in a fit of pique you go, "Hmm, this is not for me,
0:33:23this is for nerds." And that was, it was true with Siri for a long time, but then
0:33:26Siri got better, then Siri got way better,
0:33:29but one way in which it's been good for a long time, so what I'm trying to sell
0:33:32people on this idea that
0:33:33not only, well, the only important part is Siri is better than you think.
0:33:37The important part is, Hey, get used to it.
0:33:39Like start using this because this is where stuff is going, pal.
0:33:43So what I would say to people is if you're frustrated with Siri, you know,
0:33:46not understanding your requests, if you're not,
0:33:48if you're not comfortable with the Siri service,
0:33:50getting your voice in functionally working,
0:33:53which can vary a lot depending on your connection and stuff like that. One test,
0:33:56I just said three times in the next week,
0:33:58try using dictation where you would normally type. Don't talk too fast.
0:34:03Don't talk too slow. Don't talk too loud. Don't talk too quiet. Just talk to it.
0:34:07And I think a lot of folks might be a little bit re-interested in it, given that for long-sentence-to-short-paragraph-length things,
0:34:17if you know what it is that you want to say, I can pretty much guarantee, even including time for corrections, it will be faster than typing.
0:34:24Talking about dictation here, as against "Tell me the weather in Bangkok."
0:34:28Yeah, I remember a couple years ago when I had the finger injury and I couldn't type
0:34:36with my left hand for a couple of weeks and I had to use dictation and I ended up getting
0:34:41a lot of work done by installing the Dragon naturally speaking thing on the Mac, but I
0:34:46didn't have anything like that for iPhone.
0:34:48And so I really like, you know, I'm lucky because my finger made a full recovery now.
0:34:55I mean, but there's and there's people like like my aforementioned
0:34:57Opponent in basketball who's you know hand is not gonna come back right so anything that would help
0:35:04I mean, there's people with genuine permanent accessibility needs that dictation can really really be helpful
0:35:11and
0:35:13It really wasn't there. I think that was like 2012
0:35:16And it you know, it was better than nothing but it was better than not having the feature in iOS
0:35:24But boy, I wish it was as good as it is now because I find, you know, like having just come off the winter where
0:35:30it really, you know, when you're all bundled up and you can't really type while you're walking around a cold city, the dictation feature,
0:35:37I think it works amazingly well compared to where it was. It still has much room for improvement, but...
0:35:41Yeah, I agree. And I mean, I've played with, I mean, is it Nuance? Is that the company that makes Strike and Dictate?
0:35:47I mean, they for a long time have been, their engine has been way ahead of everybody else's as far as I know.
0:35:53But I mean, you know, I think well except maybe Google's right
0:35:56But I think it's like getting it working the David Sparks's of the world can work
0:36:01Dragon dictate like Emacs where they understand it and it understands them
0:36:06I found it super frustrating to train and retrain and I never got invested enough in it to like really use it
0:36:12Whereas as you say, I mean it's something Syracuse often talks about just start make a habit
0:36:17sometimes of going to the Google app, hitting the microphone and talking, and it is shocking
0:36:21how fast you can see the transcription happening as you're speaking, the corrections. Now,
0:36:26the way Siri finally does now, you can watch it making contextual corrections. You see
0:36:30this now on Apple TV, where it understands you probably mean the name of an actor rather
0:36:34than a homonym. And you can see that that has come so far even in the last two years.
0:36:40Yeah, really, yeah. And Apple TV, the contextual corrections, as you said, are very evident, because it shows you the words as it comes up.
0:36:51It has trouble with titles, because titles can mean and be many things in many different languages, and there's plenty of room for, you know, as I say, homonym sound-alikes.
0:37:00But if you're looking for an actor, it's amazing, or a music artist, it's amazing how often it gets right on the first try.
0:37:05try. Yeah, and some titles use such common words and that they're relatively short
0:37:11that the context isn't there. And I'll give you a specific example. Jonas had a
0:37:15friend sleep over last weekend and the movie that they decided to watch, and
0:37:21truly they have excellent taste, was John Carpenter's The Thing. Oh man, what a great
0:37:28movie. Oh, I haven't seen it in forever. I watched it last year and it's still
0:37:33terrifying. I'd more or less completely forgotten it. But show me the thing.
0:37:40And I don't blame... Like, essentially TK or Foo. And they, both kids, really love the Siri...
0:37:50well, they don't love the remote, but they love the idea that you can just push
0:37:53the button and say things, you know, like show me, you know, Terminator 2 and
0:37:58that it shows it to you. And they were, you know, going through, making like a
0:38:02list of like here's here's like five or six movies we're thinking about and but show me the thing
0:38:06didn't work and i just remember noting you know file that one away that's a good good example
0:38:11where i you know totally understand why it didn't work but that one's that one's an especially
0:38:17thorny one but if you don't mind getting a little bit bash with it you can sometimes
0:38:21hint it a little bit by saying um find find the tv show doctor who right or say i wouldn't play
0:38:30play the band Band of Horses or whatever. Show me the movie The Thing.
0:38:34Yeah, exactly. Yeah, I think that would probably work. I forget
0:38:38what we... and in fact, I think that's what we did
0:38:41to, you know, get it going.
0:38:45That's amazing though also. I mean, one of our favorite things is,
0:38:49I mean, I still have bitches about the Apple TV that
0:38:52are out of the scope of this show, but you know, as somebody who buys a lot, a
0:38:56lot, a lot of stuff on the iTunes store, one of my biggest frustrations is
0:38:59The bigger a fan you are of a TV show, the more likely you are to find it inscrutable.
0:39:05So like in the case of, yeah, again, Doctor Who, or in the case of Shark Tank, which yes,
0:39:08I bought several seasons of, you, when you bring up that page, you say, find, find Doctor Who.
0:39:15And it says this Doctor Who? And you say, yes, this Doctor Who. And it pulls it up.
0:39:19And now you got to go through in chronological order, like starting from the earliest season
0:39:24that you've bought. Have you dealt with this? You got to do that horizontal scroll?
0:39:27Yes. Yes. So like our latest trick is find the latest episode of shark tank.
0:39:32Boop pops right up. That's, that's a great thing. We're like, you know,
0:39:35you may not think of Syria as being,
0:39:37or voice control as being the fastest way to get to something I can damn near
0:39:40promise you that is the fastest way to get the latest episode of a TV show.
0:39:43But it seems there, there's definitely some frustrations there though, where if,
0:39:49if you do the up, down, left, right, it seems like it should,
0:39:52it should recognize, Hey, you've seen a lot of these shows.
0:39:57you probably want to watch the new one as opposed to starting you at episode or
0:40:00season one episode one. Even HBO which has one of the crummiest apps on Apple TV
0:40:04prettiest bad apps even they have a two-level hierarchy for it's do you want
0:40:08season two season three season four we can at least jump you're still going in
0:40:12in straight chronological but you can jump to a season but but you know it's
0:40:17you know think for a lot of us it is still a case of remembering to use this
0:40:20and you know I guess it helps to bracket it's your show but I mean we have to
0:40:24bracket some of this stuff. We can't talk about every concern about, you know, privacy,
0:40:28although that's certainly an issue. We can't talk about every issue related to commerce.
0:40:31I think there's still the barrier of getting people to remember that this is there and
0:40:36then learning enough to know what it's capable of. And I think outside of our bubble, that's
0:40:40a much smaller group than a lot of people are aware of, especially for people in the
0:40:45bubble. I don't like, how often do you see people using Siri like on the street? Like
0:40:50not a ton in my case. No. No. And I think within the bubble, I think you made a good
0:40:55point a couple minutes ago where I think an awful lot of people tried it, circuit 2011-2012,
0:41:02and got the shits of it and just sort of filed it away as something that's not worth trying.
0:41:08It was a frustrating experiment because it was hard to know which part of it was not
0:41:12working. And even as a non-engineer, I can guess that there are several parts that might
0:41:15not work. It might be that there was a physical occlusion where it did not get to the microphone.
0:41:20Maybe I had my finger there, right? If it did get to the microphone, did it capture
0:41:25what I said? If it captured what I said, was it able to throw it up to the cloud? If it
0:41:29threw it up to the cloud, was it able to understand what I said? If it understood what I said,
0:41:33was it able to follow? Like, I feel like there's probably at least three or four little milestones
0:41:39between coming out of my mouth and doing a thing where it could go wrong. And any problems
0:41:44with connectivity would greatly exacerbate even how well the product worked at best.
0:41:48Yeah, I've had the same experience with Apple Maps where it's like I was on a podcast with
0:41:54Josh Topolsky a couple months ago and he couldn't believe that I use Apple Maps. And I was like,
0:41:58"Well, when's the last time you tried it?" And he was like, "I don't know, never, because
0:42:01it's terrible." And I'm like, "It's so much better than it was. Really, it's actually
0:42:06pretty good." And I know that I say that and I heard from people around the world and there
0:42:10was somebody, you know, somewhere in the middle of Sweden, who's like, well, here's what Apple
0:42:14Maps thinks my neighborhood looks like. And it's like blank, you know, with a with a lake. And so
0:42:18yeah, obviously, right, you know, but here in, you know, it, the places I go, you know, here in
0:42:26Philadelphia, New York City, California, the places I've I tend to go, Apple Maps is actually
0:42:33very good. And it does things like just last week, Amy and I had to go to some store out way outside
0:42:39the city. And the path that we were originally on had traffic and middle of
0:42:46the directions, Siri said, you know, I forget the prompt, but something like, you
0:42:51know, traffic ahead. You can save 10 minutes if you change, you know, and we're
0:42:56like, okay, sure, tell us what to do.
0:42:58See, I use Apple Maps all the time. I didn't know that. Whenever we're traveling, we use Waze.
0:43:01Waze is something I would never use anywhere. It's just too, it's too
0:43:06crufty to use anywhere that I know where I'm going, but when we're traveling it'll
0:43:09frequently say, "Hey, you know, pop off at this exit, drive down this dirt road for
0:43:14two exits on a dirt road and you'll actually get there faster than if you
0:43:17stayed on the interstate." But I didn't know Apple Maps did that. That's new to me.
0:43:21But I just think that there's a general problem where if you start... like the way
0:43:26that I've written many times and the how Apple rolls piece that I have at
0:43:31Macworld from a few years ago, it's still probably the best thing I've ever
0:43:33written about the company. The way Apple makes things is they make a thing and at first it's
0:43:39here's it is a big surprise and then year after year after year they just keep making a little
0:43:43better, a little better, a little better, a little better, you know, in these increments and
0:43:47that's the that's Apple and that's the way you make things better and better and better and it's
0:43:54not about these massive, you know, explosive surprise announcements every single time.
0:44:00But I think the problem is if you launch with something that's so disappointing that it makes
0:44:05people not even check out the iterative improvement, it's a problem. Like there's a certain minimum
0:44:10quality you have to meet. And I know that there were business development reasons why they launched
0:44:15maps when they did, you know, that they were sort of in a negotiating battle with Google. And it
0:44:19wasn't really so much a choice as to, "Okay, this is good enough." It was like, "We've got to launch
0:44:23no matter what right now because, you know, we've either got to launch or renew this deal with
0:44:29Google that we don't want to renew.
0:44:31Well, think about in the age, well, in really any age since Yahoo, but definitely, whether
0:44:40it's AltaVista or Jeeves or Google or Bing or whatever, don't say porn.
0:44:45But what's the first thing everybody looks for when they go and search?
0:44:50You search on your name.
0:44:52So if you search for your name, I mean, let's be honest.
0:44:54And porn.
0:44:55And porn.
0:44:56Yeah.
0:44:57John Gruber porn. 17 million returns. Just to make sure nothing comes up. I don't want
0:45:07to know. But if you went, so like, you know, especially back in the day when there was
0:45:13still the potential of somebody unseating Google as the king of that, and I guess, you
0:45:17know, a lot of people like Bing, whatever. But whenever anything new comes along where
0:45:21there might be information about you about, that's the first thing you do. And then you
0:45:23evaluate you within the period of like what 90 seconds you might make a overarching decision
0:45:31about the quality of that based on how that comports with your own idea of what should
0:45:34be there in what order right so you know if it doesn't find anybody with your name at
0:45:40all you might go wow that's that this is garbage and i think the same is true with siri where
0:45:44like even when you would try the um the stock searches on it and it was you know sometimes
0:45:50Sometimes it would just have trouble and you didn't know why. It would just say whatever
0:45:53Siri is on available right now. You know, whereas, I mean, again, you open up something
0:45:57like Hound and the completely banana stuff you can do with Hound, it's so fast and so
0:46:02good at parsing really complex stuff. But you know what? Guess what? Hound does not
0:46:07have a little button on the device. So it's going to lose it that in the same way that
0:46:11any other device. So, you know, is Siri just recognition? No, Siri is also the fact that
0:46:17There's a button that connects with your contacts that can do functional things.
0:46:20Nothing else can do that in the Apple ecosystem right now.
0:46:23And even more now, it's not just the button, it's the always listening microphone for Jodungas.
0:46:31That's where I am feeling what people felt with Siri.
0:46:34I have a terrible time.
0:46:36We talked about this somewhere.
0:46:37I know, it's on Twitter.
0:46:40My slugging percentage on Jodungas, even when it's plugged in, not great.
0:46:46I still gain percentage for yo dingus on my Apple watch is not stellar. I mean,
0:46:49it's, it's pretty bad and other people seem to have zero problem with it.
0:46:53And I don't know why.
0:46:54I don't know either. I, I've, I, I, I forgot.
0:46:59I honestly forgot that Apple watch had yo dingus. I,
0:47:03cause it was so bad at first.
0:47:04And then when we had that discussion on Twitter recently,
0:47:07I thought let me start trying it again. And it seems better, uh,
0:47:11than it was when I gave up on it. Um,
0:47:16I'm the worst at demos, because every time I want to show something amazing,
0:47:19a little Quicksilver-style thing I want to demo for somebody,
0:47:21the thing that I want to show that's amazing never works.
0:47:24And when I want to-- conversely, when I want to demonstrate how something never
0:47:27works, it always works.
0:47:28So in bitching about this the other day on Back to Work, I invoked Yodingas.
0:47:32And I looked down, and my Apple Watch was recording everything
0:47:34that I was saying.
0:47:37[HUMMING]
0:47:43So machine learning and AI, doesn't it feel a bit like the Google I/O announcements have
0:47:50slightly attenuated and slightly pivoted the way we talk about this stuff?
0:47:57Like I did not hear so many people talking about AI and machine learning two months ago
0:48:01as much as I do now.
0:48:02It feels like they have already had a, I feel like anyway, they've had a role in directing
0:48:06this discussion even though there's a bunch of unreleased stuff to which that refers.
0:48:12I think so. I definitely think so. I could be wrong. I just feel like
0:48:16usually people would say specifically, "Oh, I love my Echo.
0:48:19There's things I like about Siri, etc." But now that Google's in the game,
0:48:24I think people might be taking it a little more seriously.
0:48:28I think so too, and I think that it's
0:48:32just so...couldn't be more in their wheelhouse.
0:48:35And that gets...somewhat gets into Marco's argument that
0:48:39it just does it there's from a certain viewpoint it looks like how could apple ever catch up to
0:48:45google in this regard in the same way that it doesn't i don't think i think you can make the
0:48:49same argument that like in terms of like frame rate of animation and smoothness of the ui android's
0:48:55never going to catch up to ios right um but that you know the question is where do they get to good
0:49:02enough like is android good enough i think for you know some people that obviously it is um and good
0:49:08enough in the AI sense maybe maybe the difference is too too far apart I think
0:49:18it's I think it's a bummer that you know Marco got piled on in that way because I
0:49:22think what are you saying is very smart I mean if I were gonna in the you know
0:49:25as a Monday morning quarterback what I would say right now is the problem with
0:49:28Apple as as Apple exists right now they have a pretty low ceiling we're like if
0:49:35If things get as great as they can get in the current state, they're still not going
0:49:38to be that great.
0:49:39Because on the one hand, you have Google, who has shown how quickly they can do great
0:49:44things with services, and how much they are willing, able, and excited to integrate stuff
0:49:50they know about you, your personal data, to make that into a, you know, say what you will
0:49:54about privacy and your concerns.
0:49:56But there are a lot of folks out there, like me, who use Google products because they feel
0:50:00like the payout is there.
0:50:01Like what I get in return for what they're doing with that data is extremely useful.
0:50:05And then on the other hand, like, you know, right now for now,
0:50:09rumors aside, Siri is still a closed system.
0:50:12Whereas I get an email every Friday from Amazon about new stuff I can do with the Echo.
0:50:16New skills, new stuff. It's not always, you know, earth-shattering stuff,
0:50:19but there's always at least a couple new things a week that it does.
0:50:22And I'm forever discovering new stuff the Echo can do that I didn't know.
0:50:26And for now with Apple, until we learn more about what their plan is,
0:50:30you know, if it, I mean, even if they're, if the reliability, the dependability, all that stuff
0:50:35becomes flawless, even if it works great in a car, even if the mic gets better, you're still going to
0:50:39be kind of stuck at what Siri wants to or can do right now, and that's, it's nowhere, I guess we,
0:50:45I feel like a lot of us thought they'd be further along faster by now. Right, just because they
0:50:50launched first, and it doesn't seem like it's, it seems like, and again, I don't want to slag on it,
0:50:56it because I think on the grand scheme of nerds I'm actually pro-Siri.
0:51:01Oh, I am too, absolutely.
0:51:03Yeah, but I think there's a good argument to be made that what Siri is good at now is the stuff
0:51:10that it was supposed to be good at originally. Like it hasn't really expanded as far outside the
0:51:18original feature set. I mean it definitely has additional data sources that it didn't, and just
0:51:24just to roll back to the beginning of the show,
0:51:26it definitely knows a lot more about sports
0:51:28than it used to.
0:51:30Like I said last week, I think last week or the week before,
0:51:33but it can even do things like,
0:51:34and this is just one of those things that I was like,
0:51:37there's no way-- - Is it over under?
0:51:38Is that what it was? - Yeah, or the point spread.
0:51:39You get point spreads or the over under,
0:51:41you get these Vegas lines, and it's like,
0:51:43I thought there's no way that's gonna work.
0:51:45'Cause A, it's a little seedy.
0:51:48You know, the whole idea of gambling on sports
0:51:50is a little seedy, and it sort of works against the Disney--
0:51:53Would they allow an app that does that?
0:51:55Yeah, I don't know.
0:51:59But it's like in the way that like every single cruise ship in the world has a casino, except for Disney's cruise ships, because
0:52:06it's Disney. And you know, that's not a surprise.
0:52:09But so, you know, I was a little, color me pleasantly surprised that Siri can tell you the point spread of upcoming games.
0:52:16thought that was pretty interesting. But it was the sort of thing that I think people just don't even try anymore.
0:52:22Well, you know, it's always such a joyful feeling as a as an Apple user as a Mac user in particular
0:52:27It's been a peculiar joy of power users for years to have this experience
0:52:31That I haven't seen replicated in that many other places
0:52:33This for example is the kind of thing that's not gonna happen with the on with the dashboard experience of any car
0:52:39With Apple sometimes you'll say hmm. I wonder what'll happen if I do this and you do something
0:52:46You didn't look it up. You didn't try you didn't learn a key command. You didn't read a PDF
0:52:49You just do a thing and it does exactly what you might have prayed that it would do.
0:52:55You ever have this experience with Apple stuff?
0:52:57Yes.
0:52:58What happens if I swipe?
0:52:59Oh my God!
0:53:01This changes everything.
0:53:02And you go like, "How did this not...
0:53:03Why is this something that..."
0:53:04For example, the one I'm always telling people about, option click on the speaker in your
0:53:09menu bar in OS X.
0:53:12You know this.
0:53:13I think so, but what happens?
0:53:14What do you get?
0:53:15Oh yeah, yeah, you get the input sources.
0:53:17A lot of people don't know if you option click, because it's not obvious.
0:53:20If you option click on the speaker, you get options to change your input and output devices,
0:53:24which saves me an hour a week, probably.
0:53:27Not a big deal.
0:53:28You don't get that feeling that many places.
0:53:31This is the thing that I love about the Mac, and I've always loved about the Mac, is that
0:53:36yes, there are...
0:53:38You could say it's not discoverable, but if you were going to guess how do you do it,
0:53:43you know the Mac, you know that it would be the option key.
0:53:47Like if I said to you, there's a way to change the speaker menu up in the menu bar to get
0:53:53a different menu, but you have to hold down a combination of keys while you click.
0:53:58What keys, one or more keys do you have to hold?
0:54:01I would instantly guess you just hold the option key because that's...
0:54:04And it actually makes sense semantically with the word option, right?
0:54:08It wouldn't be command.
0:54:10It wouldn't be control.
0:54:12it would definitely be, it should definitely be option. And in fact,
0:54:14it is option. Have you tried it for other things? No.
0:54:19You click on option, click. I never thought to do this.
0:54:21You option click on wifi. You get the ability to create a diagnostic report.
0:54:25It gives you some nerd information. Do it on, do it on a Bluetooth. Again,
0:54:30lots of nerd options under there. Information that gets displayed. It's clever.
0:54:34Nobody needs to know that that exists unless you need to know that that exists.
0:54:37But anyway, I just meant that in the service of saying like,
0:54:40Apple has a great history of putting stuff in there
0:54:42where, hey, you're gonna learn.
0:54:43If you're on a Macintosh long enough,
0:54:46you're gonna learn there's at least two ways
0:54:47to do almost everything.
0:54:49You don't have to learn one or the other,
0:54:51but you will eventually learn that there's a way
0:54:53that comports with how you wanna roll.
0:54:55And if you don't know, hit Command + Shift,
0:54:56question mark, enter the name of what you think you want,
0:54:59and it will magically appear in the menu bar.
0:55:01- Remember with System 7, there was like,
0:55:04when you first ran it, there was like a little,
0:55:06I don't know if they made it with HyperCard or not,
0:55:08but it was sort of a hypercard type thing that would,
0:55:10it was like the first run experience and there was like a little cartoon guy who,
0:55:14who, uh, would teach you a couple of, uh, shortcuts like that,
0:55:19like, and it was like a, uh, a help menu that you could,
0:55:22you could bring it up again with. And it was sort of like, show me,
0:55:25show me some of the advanced tricks,
0:55:26like being able to use command up and down arrow to go up and down folders in
0:55:31the hierarchy from the keyboard.
0:55:33That's I love that kind of stuff. They were so great at that stuff.
0:55:38Well, you know, so let me ask you a question.
0:55:40I mean, you remember the announcement of HomeKit and it was kind of alongside a
0:55:43lot of other, this kit, that kit, all this stuff has got to come out eventually.
0:55:47The whatever, the medical stuff and the, um, the, um, what's called Apple health.
0:55:52But like, for example, like how many, how many things do you have
0:55:55running on HomeKit right now?
0:55:57Nothing.
0:55:57Zero for me too.
0:55:59I swear to God, I'm not, I'm not trying to be,
0:56:01no, I look through the list.
0:56:03I finally got an app off the store called Home that gives you an easy way to like, if
0:56:10you've got this or that device and it's got this inscrutable list of all these what appear
0:56:14to be like hundreds of, I don't have any of those devices. And I've got like, I've got
0:56:18two kinds of security cameras, three kinds of, I've got, I've got Hue lights. I mean,
0:56:23there's some stuff you can do, but like, you know, when they announced something like HomeKit,
0:56:27you're thinking like, Oh my gosh, I'm maybe three months away from being able to talk
0:56:31to my house. Like who can you know, and you're in the course, you know, you get into the
0:56:35reality distortion field. Now I'm thinking, Oh my gosh, how soon will it be before there's
0:56:39an Apple device that replaces the airport and the time machine that like it's everything
0:56:43you'd want in an airport and time machine. Plus it's a home hub plus it's, you know what
0:56:47I mean? On and on and on. And now we're like twiddling our thumbs going like, okay, what's
0:56:51the next thing I can knock, talk to my phone and do like, what's going to happen with that
0:56:54stuff? Is that going anywhere? We don't have that same confidence that all of these pieces
0:56:58are going to fit together. Hell, when you, when you put on the ATV for you flip it on,
0:57:02you can't even like use Siri for music. What a weird oversight. Like that was so strange.
0:57:06It's like, how do you have all these strands not being sewn together in the system that
0:57:10with all these parts of the ecosystem need really want to be interlocked and like, how
0:57:16is that not happening?
0:57:17Yeah, I don't know if I could see it too as I could see where on the one hand, maybe it's
0:57:23like, "Hey, just wait. We just need another year or two." Or B, the pessimist take would
0:57:31be that Apple's "We control everything. Everything gets authorized through us. You submit your
0:57:37home kit stuff to us, and we say whether it gets the stamp of approval."
0:57:43>> The equivalent of MFI.
0:57:46Yeah, the equivalent of MFI or the App Store even, you know, that sort of mindset versus
0:57:55the Amazon's take, which is more or less, look, you know, we've made Echo work with
0:57:59these things and we have some APIs and it's, you know, if it works, you just build an Echo
0:58:03app and submit it to us and, you know, we'll throw it out in a newsletter on Friday.
0:58:09Right.
0:58:10You know, because right now you could certainly, you know, you know, you can do stuff with
0:58:14the echo. And I know that the people who are the bigger fans of it have stuff like that.
0:58:17I know Marco's got it hooked up to some light bulbs and stuff like that.
0:58:21I do. I use the echo for my office lights. I've got, so I mean, this is one of those,
0:58:26like this was not a terribly complex thing to set up. I have a, I'm saying here's a real,
0:58:30real simple example. I have a motion sensor in my office that, you know, basically connects
0:58:37via wifi. And then I have two, this is a Wemo, W E M O is the company. And then I have two
0:58:42two Wemo plugs that are just simple zero or one. This light is either on or off. I don't
0:58:46use the switch, I only use the Wemo. Could not do this at home, because my daughter does
0:58:50not want to have to use an iPhone to turn lights on and off. That's not going to happen.
0:58:54But in my case, when I walk into my office, the motion sensor turns the lights on. I can
0:58:59also say "Yo dingus" to my echo. I can say "Yo dingus, turn my office lights off." And
0:59:03I've set up a thing where it knows office lights means these two Wemo lights. Further,
0:59:08I have an IFTTT set up such that when I'm away from my office or move out of the radius
0:59:13of my office or 30 minutes pass without movement, it turns the lights off.
0:59:18So that whole thing, all the setup, every bit of that to set up, what, 45 minutes, half
0:59:22hour and now I don't think about it.
0:59:24But there's not that many more things like that that I have right now.
0:59:27I can't use...
0:59:28When you say, "Yo, dingus, turn my lights off," how long does it take for the lights
0:59:32to go off?
0:59:33I would say less than two seconds.
0:59:39Can we test it?
0:59:41No, you don't have to test it. Does it feel as though as responsive as if you
0:59:47had an intern and part of the intern's job was to be ready to turn the lights off at a moment's notice?
0:59:55Not necessarily standing around with their hand on the switch.
1:00:01perm, you know, like, like, like, trigger finger, not like that. But just like, hey, you just hang
1:00:07out in the office and have a, you know, have a button nearby. And if you, you know, if I tell
1:00:11you to turn the lights off, turn the lights off. Like, is it about that responsive?
1:00:14Second, it 100% understands me. I mean, it's very honestly, 100%. That's silly. It, I could count on
1:00:22one hand, the number of times it did not understand something I spoke clearly. The echo just gets that.
1:00:28I would say imagine you're eight feet away from the garbage can, you got two paper towels to throw away.
1:00:34It's about that amount of time. Let me test it, hang on, just cut this out, be ready to cut the marker of this.
1:00:40Alexa, turn my office lights on. On. They're on. Ready? Part two. Alexa, turn my office lights off. Off.
1:00:54So there you go. What is that about? Second, two seconds?
1:00:58Yeah, that sounds that, you know, I think that was actually,
1:01:01you know, not quite instantaneous, but I would say satisfyingly close.
1:01:09Well, it's, for me, it's well within the range of "that's fine."
1:01:13Yeah. Motion detection turns it on. See, to me, turning on,
1:01:18turning on is much more important than turning off. Like, turning on, if I walk
1:01:22into the office, I know with confidence that when I walk into the office, I can either
1:01:25address the echo to turn it on, or I can just walk in like a gentleman, it'll see my motion
1:01:28and turn it on. So, I mean, that's plenty fine for me. I don't need high performance,
1:01:33like, depowering.
1:01:35It's underneath the threshold of impatience.
1:01:37I will, absolutely, and it's also a lot better than a bad day with the Apple TV remote.
1:01:43Right.
1:01:44Where it's just not responding and I don't know why.
1:01:51I didn't mean change the subject.
1:01:53No, but if you're out there in iMessage and you're dictating a text message and instead
1:01:59of words showing up, you get the spinner and it just spins and you're like, "Do I cancel?
1:02:07Is this going to take?
1:02:08Do I just need to wait and my words are going to show up or should I cancel and try it again?"
1:02:13Once you're even thinking about that decision, you've already crossed the impatient threshold
1:02:17because even if the words magically...
1:02:19Your Wi-Fi is bad.
1:02:20posted something to Twitter you think it's like 50% grayed out, meaning it's still posting,
1:02:25and you're like, "What world am I in right now?" I mean, is it posting? Is it not posting?
1:02:29You start to feel a little bit crazy, that kind of feeling?
1:02:32Yeah, I think so. And exactly, the demo you just did live on the show is exactly, to me,
1:02:40at the heart of the praise that Alexa, or I guess the Echo, whatever you want to—I
1:02:48I don't know what to give credit to, but that the Amazon's dingus is getting.
1:02:53Well, I can just yell at it. I can say like, how am I doing with Fitbit?
1:02:57I could say play the latest episode of Fresh Air.
1:03:00There's a, I mean, and you know,
1:03:03the one beef some people will have just in passing is, yeah, I mean,
1:03:06there's more to learn because there's more to do.
1:03:09It's not as simple as just saying to Siri, Hey,
1:03:11do this obvious thing you've been doing for five years. Like with the Echo,
1:03:14it does enough stuff that you have to do a little bit of command line with it,
1:03:17right? You gotta do a little bit of bash to like address the right thing.
1:03:20But it's, uh, it's shockingly good at hearing that even kind of,
1:03:25kind of far away in the house.
1:03:26Like I'm forever yelling at my phone across the room to set a timer and have,
1:03:31I don't mean to bitch. I'm just saying that like,
1:03:33there's just benefits to all of these things. And you know,
1:03:35the echo is the one that got traction surprised everybody. Everybody's like,
1:03:39Oh, this crazy thing, this crazy future too. There's a lady in the tube.
1:03:42Who's going to buy this? Well, people did and they love it. And I own two now.
1:03:46and I don't consider it essential but I consider it in the aggregate more useful
1:03:52than my Apple Watch and I think it has a brighter future.
1:03:55All right let's keep going on this but first I want to thank our second sponsor
1:03:58of the day and it's our good friends at Meh.com again. Again. Again. You get a two-fer.
1:04:08You know they're the daily deal set you go there you get a daily deal
1:04:12the daily deal today again this is too late for you it's already not only is the
1:04:16show gonna be out, you know, a day later, two days later. But just as an example of
1:04:22how good this is, this FoodSaver vacuum sealing system, it is refurbished, but that's, you
1:04:28know, it's still, that's like new. You get it for 22 bucks, they even tell you what it
1:04:31costs at Amazon. It costs 102 bucks at Amazon. So that's, you know, 5x higher, almost. You
1:04:39know, crazy. Some of the deals they have, it really does make me wonder whether they're
1:04:43getting this stuff off the back of the truck like on Goodfellas.
1:04:46I do!
1:04:47And it's weird.
1:04:48This stuff is so delightfully weird.
1:04:50They, um, they're such a strange company.
1:04:53And they'd sponsored Back to Work not too long ago, and their special the day the day
1:04:56we did it was two folding knives.
1:04:59Like two swish-blady-like pocket knives.
1:05:03Like just in case you get a knife fighting you with two knives.
1:05:06Right.
1:05:07Or you get it if they, if you're going into a, if you're going into a bar and they, you
1:05:11know, the bouncer takes your one knife, you've still got a backup knife.
1:05:13Ah, you didn't check the sock, sucker.
1:05:17But they've got other stuff, too.
1:05:19I told you that just their write-ups of the daily deals
1:05:22are worth reading.
1:05:23They've got these videos.
1:05:24But they've also got these community forums.
1:05:27And you type, and it's forming stuff.
1:05:29But on these forums, they're doing interesting stuff,
1:05:32like commissioning articles from real writers.
1:05:35So they commissioned a friend of the show, sometimes
1:05:38guest on the show, Glenn Fleischman,
1:05:40to do a two-part history of all caps being interpreted as shouting in written language.
1:05:50They've got all sorts of great stuff like that.
1:05:54Actual content.
1:05:55Like, you could go to med.com on a regular basis and never want to buy the daily deal,
1:06:00and it's just a site where you go to read cool stuff.
1:06:04So Glenn Fleishman's articles on all caps is...
1:06:08almost like clickbait for me because I love, you know, that type of analysis of how you
1:06:14read in your head. And it goes back to like the 1800s. It's crazy. He's done all this
1:06:18research. So go to med.com, check out their forums and check out their daily deals.
1:06:23Good sponsor.
1:06:25Who do you think the third sponsor is going to be?
1:06:32You guys know Fracture.
1:06:33I'm not gonna guess, I'm not gonna guess, I don't wanna spoil it.
1:06:40Do you think it's a problem...
1:06:43So you hinted at this, and in some ways this voice assistant space is almost the conceptual
1:06:53opposite of iOS insofar as most of iOS, and certainly iOS starting in 2007 and 2008 in
1:07:04the early years, was entirely visual and that anything you could do was represented on screen
1:07:12by some sort of physical, visual object.
1:07:16And to me, it's actually an overlooked aspect
1:07:21of the genius of iOS's design.
1:07:23That they didn't go with some sort of like,
1:07:28what's our fabulous new phone user interface
1:07:31going to be like?
1:07:31And they didn't try to do something
1:07:33that makes regular people say,
1:07:35wow, this is so conceptually clever.
1:07:37Instead, they did like the most obvious thing possible,
1:07:40which was like, hey, just like the old PalmPilots,
1:07:43or here's a bunch of apps,
1:07:44tap on the app and it launches the app,
1:07:46And when the app is launched, it takes over the screen.
1:07:49And here's one button on the front face
1:07:51that you go back to the home screen.
1:07:53So here's a bunch of apps.
1:07:55Tap one to go in the app.
1:07:56And when you're in an app, tap this button,
1:07:58and you go back to the home screen.
1:07:59And once you're in an app, anything you can do in the app
1:08:02is something you can see on the rectangle of pixels
1:08:05that are lit up.
1:08:07And since then, they've added some shortcuts
1:08:10that you kind of have to know about,
1:08:11like when you slide in from the side
1:08:13or slide down from the top to get the notification center,
1:08:16or up from the bottom to get the control center.
1:08:20But those are things that if you don't know about,
1:08:25there's still a way to do it visually, right?
1:08:29Everything you can do, if you're a more simple user of iOS,
1:08:33and you don't even know about control center,
1:08:35anything you can do there,
1:08:36you can just go to the home screen, go to settings,
1:08:38and just read that list and you'll find it.
1:08:41- On settings now,
1:08:42But also to your point though, settings has gotten so long and so complex,
1:08:46I wonder how many people have realized that there's now a search field inside of
1:08:49settings.
1:08:50I don't know how many people, but they should, it's very useful.
1:08:53It's staggering how much stuff is in settings and rather than having to go drill
1:08:57down,
1:08:57it's now there's so much stuff in there that it's actually way faster to do a
1:09:01search.
1:09:01Right.
1:09:02But it's almost like the difference between
1:09:06a visual video game like,
1:09:09you know,
1:09:12Super Mario Brothers, where you could see where Mario can go
1:09:15'cause you're watching Mario move around the screen
1:09:18versus the old school text games like Zork or whatever,
1:09:21where you just have to start typing stuff and guess.
1:09:24It's easier to explore, I think for most people,
1:09:29visually than it is to explore verbally.
1:09:33And it's so much easier to see what an iPhone can do
1:09:37because effectively for the most part,
1:09:39it's you go to the home screen and look at the apps
1:09:41And here's what your iPhone can do.
1:09:43It's these apps.
1:09:45And the ones that come from Apple are fairly obvious.
1:09:49And any other ones are ones that you chose to install.
1:09:53So you should have a basic idea of what they do.
1:09:56Whereas Siri, it's like,
1:09:59what's the total list of things you can do with Siri?
1:10:03- I have never found a comprehensive list
1:10:05that wasn't somebody's guess on a blog post.
1:10:09I have never seen a full list of everything Siri can do.
1:10:13The closest thing I've seen is, like I say, some blog posts people have done, and basically
1:10:17that marketing page where you can scroll really far down and see lots of suggestions.
1:10:22But it's surprisingly under-documented.
1:10:25So you're right.
1:10:27How do you learn?
1:10:28I mean, think about how many people you have to say, like, "Hey, if you want to play with
1:10:31Siri, go to Siri and then go hit that little question mark."
1:10:34And they're like, "What question mark?"
1:10:35I'm like, Oh man, hit that question mark. Is that as in the lower left,
1:10:39I believe. And that's going to tell you so much stuff. You had no idea.
1:10:42You could say to Siri, it's not learnable. Like you're saying,
1:10:45it isn't like you can just look at the pretty glass screen and understand what
1:10:48you're supposed to do.
1:10:48You either need to get educated or you need to explore. You need to try.
1:10:53And that's not intuitively obvious.
1:10:56So to me, the, the, the, uh,
1:11:01not the canonical example,
1:11:03I'm trying to see the epitome of where this is going, the ideal of where these voice-driven
1:11:09assistants are going, is exemplified by HAL 9000 in 2001, where you watch these characters
1:11:19interact with HAL, and you never... it would be shocking if they said something to him
1:11:27and HAL was like, "I'm sorry, I didn't understand the question."
1:11:32You know, it's like you just know that Hal's gonna get it.
1:11:35And if they said something to him--
1:11:37- Right, did you mean white the color or white the race?
1:11:39Well, what a weird question, Hal.
1:11:41Of course you would know that.
1:11:42- Right. - Hal just knows that.
1:11:43Not only that, but Hal also,
1:11:45as I was boning up last night
1:11:46and reading stuff you were suggesting,
1:11:48if you notice, Hal ends up sounding like the calmest
1:11:51and most human person in the movie in some way.
1:11:53- Oh yeah, definitely.
1:11:54Well, that was Pauline-- - I never thought of it
1:11:55that way, but it's true.
1:11:57- That was Pauline Kael's criticism,
1:11:59one of her criticisms of the film was that--
1:12:00- It's only got one character.
1:12:02that the most interesting character is the computer and it's like well so what isn't
1:12:05that actually kind of fascinating that that somebody could make a movie where the most
1:12:08interesting character is is the computer like how is that how is that a failure
1:12:13but if the characters in that movie had said how can dim the lights you know that the lights would
1:12:20dim there's a hundred percent chance you and you know that hal could do that like anything on that
1:12:25ship you know that Hal could do. You know, and everything that they... it's... the
1:12:34ideal is obviously something that's so aware that it can control everything.
1:12:37Like, it's... and we're obviously not there yet, but you know, we're getting there.
1:12:43You're already... you're already turning your lights out with it, but it's like, you
1:12:46know, you know, you probably can't turn your microwave on with Alexa. You got me
1:12:52thinking though, you're bringing up a really good point. We talk about what
1:12:57they came out of the box with in 2007 and like what was it that was in
1:13:00retrospect as we look back, what are the things that we really remember as
1:13:03seeming revolutionary? I think I feel like for myself, the most amazing what
1:13:10trick Steve and team pulled off was calling this thing a phone. So the first
1:13:15amazing part is that they were to put out this they would have brought this
1:13:18thing that... I mean, yeah, it's a phone, but I mean, there's a lot of other things
1:13:23I would want to call it before I called it a phone. It is to use his third, the
1:13:27third piece, it's an internet communicator. That's what made the thing
1:13:30really great. But who's gonna go out and buy internet communicator? I think that
1:13:35for myself, that's one amazing part, is that like they put a computer in your
1:13:38pocket and it did actually work. The other amazing thing in retrospect, and
1:13:41maybe one of the things that is the most revolutionary and influential, was that
1:13:46It's just a big piece of glass on front, right?
1:13:49There's no, there's no, there's one dedicated button that does stuff, but,
1:13:52and there's only limited things the apps can do too, right?
1:13:55Then we've got to remember these are the days when you're running one app at a
1:13:57time. Uh, what you could do with sound was very limited.
1:13:59What you could do with having, you know, you're only,
1:14:02you couldn't copy and paste it to one app at a time, et cetera, et cetera.
1:14:04But what did that do?
1:14:05That worked to the advantage of both the strengths and weaknesses of the phone.
1:14:09It could only do so much,
1:14:10but what you could do was very easy to understand because it was in this
1:14:13paradigm that you're familiar with.
1:14:14If you've ever used a windows, like a GUI system, this is not going to seem crazy.
1:14:19It's just that there's no mouse. Your finger is the mouse. So, right.
1:14:23But the thing is, so, but, so now where are we? Where are we now? Like you say,
1:14:26well, now you can get to stuff by pulling down.
1:14:29You can get to stuff by pulling up. If you're on a recent phone,
1:14:33like if you're on a sixth generation phone pressing hard on the,
1:14:37I wonder how many people know this pressing hard on the left side of the screen,
1:14:39there'll be a little bloop and you can go to the previous app. Right.
1:14:43You could be one of the six people who's using the 3D touch.
1:14:46But so, and then on top of that,
1:14:48let's think about haptics and tactics on the phone and on the watch.
1:14:52There are now so many more ways to communicate.
1:14:55And communication is not just talking.
1:14:57Communication is also listening and hearing.
1:14:59So our ability, I mean, for example, something,
1:15:01I don't know how many people use this on iOS,
1:15:04but you can go into accessibility and flip on the LED.
1:15:07The LED will blink when you get an alert.
1:15:11So I have that turned on.
1:15:11So if I'm not paying attention, I can see across the room that there's like a flash.
1:15:15So there's all these ways that you can talk to the phone, the phone can talk to
1:15:18you, but we're still, I mean, but we still haven't really rethought the whole
1:15:24paradigm of how we interact with the phone.
1:15:25We're finding new ways to expand what this thing can do, make it faster.
1:15:29Touch ID, think about Touch ID, right?
1:15:31But I mean, there hasn't been, there hasn't been a need to completely rethink
1:15:35the phone because these are all improvements on the product we had in 2007.
1:15:40But now, I'm not sure if this is where you're going, but I want to know where you're going.
1:15:44Wow, now that you can do voice, how does that change the way you think about this little
1:15:48glass internet communicator?
1:15:50Is it well suited to doing these kinds of things, and what would need to change about
1:15:55the basic technology and the policies of the company to make this into something more than just
1:16:00another way to interact with the phone?
1:16:03I don't know. I still want to know, like, where do we draw the line between having every single device that we get from Apple understand Yo Dingus?
1:16:18Right now I've got my watch doing it, I've got my phone doing it, my iPad does it, my Mac doesn't, but there's three devices that do.
1:16:28that do, and now there's a rumor that...
1:16:29- Apple TV, also the Apple TV.
1:16:30- And Apple TV, right.
1:16:32And now they're supposedly building a new device
1:16:35that does it.
1:16:36Well then when I address Siri with the Odingas,
1:16:39how many things turn on at once?
1:16:42I mean, and right now it's not very smart at all.
1:16:44Like if my iPad is within same earshot as the phone,
1:16:48they both come on.
1:16:48- Well, I mean, think about iMessages.
1:16:52Think about iMessages.
1:16:53Like, you know, they seem to have gotten better at that,
1:16:56but you know, you don't want every single device in the world going off.
1:16:59If it has a way to determine where you quote unquote are right now,
1:17:03that's where you prefer to hear about.
1:17:05I still miss things because it went to the watch and I didn't realize it.
1:17:08So it's trying to be smart with that,
1:17:10but to have a sense of place about what you're doing. And like I said,
1:17:13in this, these notes here, like context awareness,
1:17:15like when it's most appropriate to do a certain kind of thing, because you know,
1:17:19do we have to choose one tool?
1:17:21Aren't we allowed to have like spoons and knives in our house? It's like, well,
1:17:25you might want all of these things,
1:17:26but you do need a little help from the devices
1:17:29to be contextually intelligent about what you need to know
1:17:31when stuff is likely to be useful
1:17:34and where it is extremely cumbersome and inappropriate.
1:17:37- Do you remember like, this is way back,
1:17:40this is like going back to like 1998, 1999.
1:17:43And on the great,
1:17:45one of the best websites at that time was Macintosh.
1:17:48It's still around, but I don't think it's--
1:17:51- Is that Rick Ford?
1:17:52- Yeah, Rick Ford.
1:17:53- That was a great song.
1:17:54I remember that there was a recurring,
1:17:57like the way that he would do it,
1:18:00is somebody would send something in,
1:18:02it would become a story,
1:18:03and then a couple more people would email,
1:18:05and then he would add to the page
1:18:06with more people's comments.
1:18:08But it wasn't open, it was curated by Rick Ford.
1:18:11And you'd end up with this great discussion.
1:18:12I remember one of the big controversies
1:18:14was when some Mac apps started phoning home on the network,
1:18:18which more or less just to check for a new version,
1:18:22like they would, like maybe like once a week,
1:18:24some little indie app would connect to its parentcompanies.com and just say, "Hey, I'm
1:18:31version 3.7. Is there a new version?" And then if there is, like if 3.8 is out, it could
1:18:37let you know that there's a new version. And people were using certain utilities that would
1:18:43notify them, like super hyper privacy-minded people who use utilities like on Mac OS X,
1:18:50it would be like Little Snitch. I think there were things like that.
1:18:52This was a concern though,
1:18:54if you were stealing your copy of Quark,
1:18:55which I heard some people used to do,
1:18:57because it would be able to run out across the network
1:18:59and see which other serial numbers,
1:19:01like things along those lines,
1:19:02where you would actually be able to get another layer
1:19:05of shareware running that would prevent those things
1:19:08from talking to each other.
1:19:09- Yeah, what it would do, yeah,
1:19:11one of the anti-piracy or anti, you know,
1:19:16using a license on too many machines mechanisms,
1:19:19I know Quark did it, I think Adobe might have.
1:19:21I know for sure Quark did it, yeah.
1:19:23- Where they would look across the local network.
1:19:25Maybe it was the whole internet.
1:19:26Was it the whole internet?
1:19:27I don't know about that.
1:19:28- I think for our case it was our AppleTalk network, yeah.
1:19:31- And it was enough to make it important,
1:19:33but it would look across the local talk network
1:19:34and if it saw the same serial number it was already running,
1:19:37it would refuse to run on the second machine.
1:19:39And people were very upset about it because it was like,
1:19:43"What right does this app have to do anything
1:19:45"on the network without me?"
1:19:47And I remember nodding my head
1:19:48and I wasn't thinking like, "Yeah, outrage."
1:19:51I was just thinking, yeah, this is a little creepy.
1:19:53I wonder where this is going.
1:19:54And to think about how antiquated that is,
1:19:58like privacy-wise, that I'm thinking,
1:20:00what made me think about this was that I'm thinking,
1:20:03I wouldn't mind if my iMac always had the camera on
1:20:09to look to see if I'm sitting in front of it,
1:20:11so that it would, as soon as I get it from my chair,
1:20:15would know to send the iMessage,
1:20:17the conversation I'm having with Merlin, right to my phone.
1:20:20Right? Like, how does my iMac know if I'm sitting in front of it? Like, right now it
1:20:25doesn't really. It just, like, kind of keeps track of, I guess, like, mouse action or keyboard
1:20:30action or something like that.
1:20:31And that seems to be either totally innocuous or really scary, depending on what you think
1:20:35of as being watched. Because what about motion sensors in your home? Does that creep you
1:20:39out? Well, no. It just, I, you know what I mean? Like, it depends on what you want it
1:20:42to do. But there's a zero or one feeling there, because if there's a camera, we assume that
1:20:47it's always recording us and sending it somewhere to do something. It's not simply a censor,
1:20:52right? We assume immediately that it's going to be taking our stuff and throwing it up
1:20:55on the internet somewhere.
1:20:58It just, we've just come so far in terms of where we draw the line on balance.
1:21:05It's ludicrous, but I was trying to actually, I was telling my daughter, I was giving my
1:21:07daughter a bath last night and boring her to tears telling her about how I was going
1:21:11to talk to you about today, and I was asking her about what she thought about the distinction
1:21:14between listening and hearing.
1:21:18And she, she was saying she thinks we were disagreeing a little bit on the
1:21:22distinction, but I think to appreciate what we're talking about with this stuff,
1:21:25you must see a distinction or should see a distinction between listening and
1:21:29hearing.
1:21:29So if you don't believe the companies that say they're not actually setting all
1:21:35your stuff to the NSA, we'll definitely don't have these devices.
1:21:37If you're considering that though,
1:21:38I think it's worth considering the difference between listening and hearing.
1:21:41It's one thing to listen, right?
1:21:43So listening means that it's basically listening for the trigger words,
1:21:47but then after the trigger words is when it's really hearing.
1:21:50And I feel like that's,
1:21:52that's a young distinction that we need to start thinking about for all kinds of
1:21:56reasons, including privacy, right? Do you follow what I'm saying though?
1:21:59No, I do.
1:22:00Like in your case, you want, you want a camera that's,
1:22:04that is monitoring, even if it's not recording, that there's, there's,
1:22:09we should start to see some kind of a distinction. Certainly again,
1:22:12I feel like I always have to say this. Yes, I don't want people spying on us,
1:22:15but like what are we willing to throw out for that notional privacy that we may
1:22:19or may not have anyway, in this instance, I just,
1:22:22I think that a lot of people shut that door really fast without looking too much
1:22:27further beyond what they imagine is the worst case scenario.
1:22:30Would you be okay with your,
1:22:32with your Mac using the camera to see if you're you're in front of it?
1:22:36God, no, no. Even if they see me, you should see what it looked like right now.
1:22:41Well, no, I don't know.
1:22:43And I feel like you could, you know, outsiders could independently verify
1:22:48by looking at network traffic that the video isn't being sent anywhere.
1:22:53No, no, I see what you're saying.
1:22:54But like, for example, like we've got a couple of different cameras at the house.
1:22:57We've got a a nest cam that watches the door
1:23:01and we've got a canary and the canary is a camera with a super
1:23:06familiar with canary.
1:23:08No, canary is pretty cool.
1:23:10it's canary.is. So it's a device that's not too different looking from an
1:23:16Amazon Echo, a little shorter, a little fatter. You basically plug that in and it has a
1:23:23very wide fisheye lens that will cover, not 180 degrees, but a pretty wide
1:23:28spectrum. But the nice thing about it is it has a very sane mode, series of
1:23:36modes. So there's "Armed", which means that nobody is in the house and, you know, go
1:23:42ahead and record, you know, whatever, whatever you're seeing with the camera. If
1:23:46it notices that you're at home, you can set it so that it either keeps running
1:23:50and doesn't, isn't sending you notices, or you can say "Shut it off". So in my case, if
1:23:55the iPhone detects that anybody is at home, you know, that the people who should
1:24:00be there, it just shuts it off altogether. So like, you know, I mean, is that perfect?
1:24:04No, but that works pretty well. So if we're out of town and we see something moving around
1:24:09that's not a cat or a house cleaner, you can have that thing shoot off a siren, you can
1:24:14hit the police number from it, whatever. I mainly want to just be able to see what's
1:24:18-- you know, nothing's on fire. You know that feeling?
1:24:23I will put the link in the show notes. I've already written it down. It looks like a great
1:24:27product. It does. I know exactly what you mean. I get paranoid when we're away from
1:24:31home that yeah that you know how do I know that the house is hasn't burned
1:24:36down how do I know that who would know to contact you know how do I know that
1:24:40squatters haven't broken in and just sort of set up set up home I know somebody
1:24:44draw a penis on your garage door all right exactly
1:24:49but trust me I know from first-hand experience you've got a scrub that as
1:24:55soon as possible before the ink dries.
1:24:58Sorry, I took you off your topic. Well, no, no, no, but the rumor about this upcoming
1:25:05Apple thing is that... I'll put a link to the show notes on that, but did you see
1:25:09this? That after the initial report came out, there's a report that the thing that
1:25:12Apple's doing does include a camera, probably similar to the Canary, like a
1:25:17wide-angle fisheye camera, and that it will attempt to recognize the people
1:25:22talking to it. And again, I don't want to be glib about it, and I know I'm a Kubrick
1:25:29fanatic, but it's the concept of how. And one of the things that makes 2001 such a great
1:25:38movie is the scientific rigor. It really was an honest attempt, and obviously it was very
1:25:44optimistic about all of it. You know, there is no Hilton orbiting the Earth. Pan Am doesn't
1:25:53have flights to the Moon. We don't have a rocket ship that could take astronauts to
1:25:59Jupiter and we don't have…
1:26:01The more cute stewardesses in Velcro shoes.
1:26:03No, and we don't have AI at the level of HAL.
1:26:09So it was optimistic year-wise, but it attempted to be as rigorous as they could, including
1:26:20talking to top artificial intelligence experts of the era as to what do you think would be
1:26:26possible, how could this work.
1:26:30And it's conceptually, that's where we're heading, right?
1:26:32we would have wide angle, I mean, even down to using a wide angle lens to get a big field
1:26:38of view into the AI dingus.
1:26:44When they show you Hal's point of view, it's like a super fisheye.
1:26:47But the idea that the thing you're talking to, and again, it's like this mixture of yes,
1:26:52I've always wanted to have like Hal 9000.
1:26:55And then conversely, the, I don't know if I want, you know, I don't want people, you
1:27:00know, AI systems watching me, you know what I mean? Like, it's a mixture of like
1:27:04dread and desire, but I think it's clearly where we're heading, and the idea
1:27:11that it would help, you know, like help create a shared device, because like
1:27:18isn't one of the limits of like the Echo right now that it it's like two people
1:27:23in the same house can't really set it up with what's on my calendar.
1:27:27Oh, true. Yeah, true. You can have multiple echoes and that's actually, it's kind of cool.
1:27:32But yeah, you're right. And I mean, also, you know, there's a, there's a,
1:27:35something that's got to get dealt with at some point soon is, I mean, it's understandable to
1:27:42say, well, you know, right now we just want to get the technology down. So anybody who talks to
1:27:46it correctly can make this work. But I mean, you know, for example, my echo has access to my
1:27:50calendar. It is my calendar. Anybody who came in and asked it could get my calendar info.
1:27:56that doesn't, I mean, currently there's not a way I know for Echo to be disabled when I personally
1:28:00am not there. There's probably all kinds of creepy stuff you can do, but, you know.
1:28:04And you can buy stuff, like, so, like, if I came over to your house and you,
1:28:07you know, head to the restroom, I could quick order up, uh,
1:28:10I could just say reorder, reorder dildos, and they'd be on your door the next day.
1:28:14That's totally true. I basically just say to your dingus, you just say, like, reorder
1:28:20contractor bags, and they'll say, "Okay, on this date you ordered that."
1:28:24What? It's like Syracuse's concern about the Amazon buttons that his kids...
1:28:29Which my daughter has totally done. Oh, look at some more seventh generation detergent.
1:28:35Um, see, I don't know. This is, I guess, this is the part people always want to talk about. This is
1:28:43the part that you always jump directly to. I think it's unavoidable, but I think it's
1:28:47also complicated, which is when you get into, like, you know, what should this do? Just because we can
1:28:51do it? Should we do it? Well, I think this is where stuff is going. So it's, it does
1:28:56not benefit us to keep talking about how this, how we're never going to use this. It benefits
1:29:01us to talk about what we actually are talking about when we talk about this stuff, what
1:29:05we're willing to tolerate. I think in order to have a sane conversation about this, we
1:29:09have to stop acting like it's a Frankenstein monster and try to have like a more reasoned
1:29:13discussion about, you know, what this stuff is, what this stuff does. And once you get
1:29:17used to a creature comfort, it's psychologically impossible to go back.
1:29:23And just think about cars and the way that cars have improved since we were kids, just
1:29:30creature comfort-wise.
1:29:31When we were kids, if you wanted to move the seat back or front, you had to sit there and
1:29:36hold a physical lever and then slide it using your muscles.
1:29:42And now, I mean, our car's 10 years old, but we have a thing where when I, because we have
1:29:46electronic key fobs, if I unlock the door, the seat automatically starts moving to my preferred
1:29:52location, and if Amy's the one who unlocks the door, the seat moves to her preferred location.
1:29:57That's amazing, but you really shouldn't be driving, right? You lost your license?
1:30:00I, well, and I, and, well, and I wear flip-flops everywhere.
1:30:04You know about topic, yes, this, that is so crazy to me, but a topic for some reason seems to come
1:30:11up every time we talk. ATMs. We always talk about ATMs. But you know, what a terrific example,
1:30:191977, 1978. Guess what? There's this new scary robot at the mall that will give you money.
1:30:25Wait a minute. You're saying anybody can walk up to this machine and they'll have access to my bank
1:30:29account? No, no, no, no, no. You got to have your little card and you got a four digit code. Okay,
1:30:33just let me understand this. You know, I'm a Rockefeller and I have access to all this money.
1:30:38So basically anybody who has this four digit code can just clean me out
1:30:43Because and that's really what everybody said into the 80s. Okay, so I'm not trying to say this is a perfect system
1:30:50But what I'm saying is that in the amount of time that ATMs have been around there's some things
1:30:53Most all of us kind of know at this point
1:30:55I mean said there's always gonna be stuff like skimmers like, you know, go read Krebs on security have just ruined your month, but
1:31:02There are things we know we know first of all that
1:31:05there are limitations on the account. If they do quote-unquote clean you out,
1:31:09they're not going to get more than probably $400 or $500 out of your account.
1:31:12And you know what? If it was fraudulent,
1:31:15there's a pretty good chance you can go to your bank and they're going to cover most of the cost of that.
1:31:18My dad, I don't think, has an ATM card.
1:31:23I still think that maybe they've sent him one without even asking and then he just cuts it up.
1:31:34My dad, my dad, at least, you know, at least through the high school when I lived at home,
1:31:42anytime my dad wanted to get cash, he would go to the bank and go to the waiting line
1:31:46and go to the teller and bring the past book, right? And, uh, and get cash and he would
1:31:53just get enough cash at the time where he wouldn't have to go back frequently.
1:31:56I hate accidentally falling into the role of armchair futurist because it's, it's such
1:32:00a douchey thing to be, but like, here's what I'm trying to say. Like, you know, I have
1:32:04a pretty good feeling and this is an overarching thing for me as I try to grow as a person
1:32:09is to stop making these instant decisions based on emotions about whether something
1:32:13will be terrible and ruin everything, which feels like something a lot of folks do as
1:32:20soon as it does. There's this weird black and white thinking thing where as soon as
1:32:23somebody gets the slightest whiff of something they don't like, it's the worst thing ever.
1:32:27it's a literal Holocaust. I'm trying to avoid doing that.
1:32:29So when I say this example, something like an ATM,
1:32:31what I'm really trying to say is that like, well,
1:32:34there's a certain amount of risk associated with that.
1:32:37There will always be a certain amount of risk.
1:32:39We're still driving cars that can go a hundred miles an hour.
1:32:43There's an acceptable amount of risk with that.
1:32:45You don't find that risky at all when a bus goes by your kid while you're,
1:32:48while you're walking down the street.
1:32:49But like all these things find their level in some way, not for all time,
1:32:53pendulum swing, Hakuna Matata. And like,
1:32:56but the thing is we figured out a way for ATMs to be part of our life in a way
1:33:01that didn't ruin everybody in America.
1:33:03And so I think instead of thinking about this as like some kind of new dioxin
1:33:08that's going to kill the environment, let's think about things like AI and yes,
1:33:11things like VR, the silly things like that. Let's instead ask ourselves,
1:33:15like how that could find a place.
1:33:16If we stop looking at it as this thing we think we understand today,
1:33:20start looking at the components of this as something we might see in our lives.
1:33:23and stop being so wowed by it.
1:33:26'Cause in all the times you're either cowed or wowed by it,
1:33:28somebody else is running away with the legislation
1:33:30on what actually happens with that stuff.
1:33:31You gotta keep your eyes open and be smart,
1:33:33but admit that this is something that is a thing.
1:33:36- Right, there's, you know, the self-driving cars thing
1:33:38is a perfect example where I think most people
1:33:42are looking forward to it,
1:33:43but because it is scary, red letters, new,
1:33:47and it seemingly involves, you know,
1:33:49robots doing things that we used to do,
1:33:52Everybody is worried. I know I'm worried.
1:33:54Everybody knows that eventually it's going to come.
1:33:57We're going to have self-driving cars.
1:33:58And eventually it's just inevitable.
1:34:00There's going to be an accident where somebody gets killed
1:34:02and you can blame the AI.
1:34:05And there's so many millions of people in so many cars
1:34:08and so many things, it's inevitable.
1:34:09And just to put up the hypothetical,
1:34:12like what if the AI locks itself into a situation
1:34:15where it's either, it can make a move that harms you,
1:34:19the passenger, or it kills a pedestrian
1:34:22and it doesn't see, you know,
1:34:23there's no other option that the AI sees
1:34:26and the decision has to be made
1:34:27in the next hundredth of a second, what happens?
1:34:30Either way, it's a scandal.
1:34:32- It's like that ethical problem with the train track
1:34:33and that kind of thing.
1:34:35- Right.
1:34:36- But I mean, ask yourself, you know,
1:34:37I mean, I'm not a statistician,
1:34:38but think about like if we took the net number
1:34:41of miles driven by mature automated vehicles
1:34:45versus the net number of just,
1:34:48allow me a straw man here,
1:34:49the net number of miles driven by drunks.
1:34:52Like let's see who has a better kill ratio.
1:34:55'Cause I got a feeling the automated car
1:34:57might do a little bit better.
1:34:58I bet, you know what, turns out,
1:35:00I bet it might even do a little bit better
1:35:01than all those people who are really good drivers,
1:35:04especially when more and more automated cars
1:35:05can talk to each other and don't need the meat bag
1:35:08behind the pedal to keep it from flying off the road.
1:35:11- Right, I completely agree.
1:35:12I think it's inevitable that self-driving cars
1:35:15are going to happen relatively soon
1:35:17and that they will have wonderful safety records
1:35:21and that the sooner we can get all or nearly all cars
1:35:24self-driven, that the difference in the number of people
1:35:28getting maimed, seriously injured, and killed,
1:35:32we'll look back at it as when we used to let people
1:35:35smoke on airplanes, you know, like, oh my God,
1:35:38what the hell were we thinking?
1:35:39We let people drive 100 miles an hour
1:35:41while they were text messaging.
1:35:43There was not, you know, and people did it.
1:35:45- Oh, I just, we just, we got totally
1:35:47off by a truck the other day, like just completely cut off by a semi. Ten minutes later, we see
1:35:52a woman, you know, cruising down 80 with her kid in the car seat, like texting. And you
1:35:58don't see too many of those to go like, "Really? Do you think it's going to be that much worse
1:36:01to have an automated car that understands the heuristics of the world?"
1:36:04I totally don't. But the problem is that as a society, we collectively are very bad at
1:36:11accepting statistical proof versus anecdotal proof. It's like the Republican senator
1:36:23whose argument against climate change was, I mean this is a true story, I forget the guy's name,
1:36:30but he made his little speech on the senate floor with a snowball he had just made outside the
1:36:36capital at an unseasonable time of year, right? The one example...
1:36:41Well, the climate scientists are just cursing. He's figured us out. He's figured out what's
1:36:46happening with big climate. But for some people, that one example is way
1:36:50more compelling than the statistical evidence of what is actually going on. I think people
1:36:56will get used to it with the self-driving cars. I forget how much I told about this,
1:37:02I know I never wrote about it, but I got this amazing demo at the Mercedes self-driving
1:37:07car thing in Silicon Valley a couple months ago. And I went on a ride in an actual self-driving
1:37:14Mercedes S-Class. It was amazing. I mean, it's real. It actually was like an entire
1:37:19thing like starting in somewhere in Mountain View and getting onto a highway and getting
1:37:23off and the entire thing had no human intervention whatsoever.
1:37:27Wow, really? Yeah people who do that all seem to say a similar thing, which is like they're always amazed at how quickly
1:37:34it's
1:37:36How quickly it stops seeming weird?
1:37:38Like it isn't more than it. Sometimes it isn't more than a few minutes of that before you go like, oh this totally makes sense
1:37:44So Mike one of my questions for them was
1:37:47Do you think right now you you know?
1:37:50Mercedes-Benz makes cars that go well in excess of any speeding limit posted in the United States
1:37:56It's, you know, you, you know, if not,
1:37:58I would guess every single car they make
1:38:00goes at least a hundred miles an hour.
1:38:02In self-driving mode, is it going to be an option
1:38:07to exceed the posted speed limit?
1:38:10And the answer was almost certainly not.
1:38:13That the car, you know, will be programmed
1:38:15so that there is no way that you can exceed the speed limit.
1:38:18And their take is that, no,
1:38:22you couldn't sell a car like that today when people drive,
1:38:25But they think that people will accept that because why do they want to go fast?
1:38:29It's because they're bored and they want to get to where they're going.
1:38:32And if they can sit there and dick around on their phone while they're getting there,
1:38:37who cares if it takes an extra five minutes to get to work because you're driving 55 instead
1:38:43of driving 80?
1:38:47Or maybe you're taking a nap.
1:38:49Yeah, but this is also getting to, I mean, you know, whenever we try to think about change,
1:38:55try to think about the future, we tend, I feel like at least I tend to focus on maybe
1:39:00two axes, but usually one axis. Like the thing that I'm familiar with, the thing that I'm
1:39:03obsessed with, the thing that I think about, but that's the difficulty of thinking about
1:39:07anything more than a year out of the future. And the future is like, how will ideas germinate?
1:39:12How will things suddenly get cheaper and more possible? How does things suddenly become
1:39:17less impossible? And it's difficult to imagine how those kinds of things are going to work.
1:39:23And we all have our own biases about how we would want it to work and what we would accept
1:39:30in terms of risk.
1:39:32Yeah, I don't know.
1:39:34I don't know.
1:39:35Let me take a break and thank our third sponsor.
1:39:38Do you have a guess?
1:39:39Who's your third sponsor this week, Jon?
1:39:41Third sponsor this week is the good folks at Meh.com.
1:39:45Honestly, fuck these guys for making me think of a third thing to say about them.
1:39:53I mean, God bless them for buying out the entire show.
1:39:55They really did.
1:39:56They bought all three.
1:39:57They paid rack rate for all three spots.
1:39:59God bless them for that.
1:40:00I do love the sponsors, but I gotta tell you,
1:40:03there's not that much to say about them.
1:40:04They're a daily deal site,
1:40:06and they've got some really cool videos,
1:40:08and they write really clever copy,
1:40:10and they've got some forums
1:40:11where there's really cool stuff going on.
1:40:13But other than that, fuck 'em.
1:40:16Go to med.com and check 'em out.
1:40:20Fuck 'em.
1:40:22Anything else you want to say about this AI stuff? I think we covered a lot of it.
1:40:24Anything else? I know you had good notes. You did a lot more research. You did good work.
1:40:28Yeah. Fuck those guys. Um, no, but um, let me ask you this. Um,
1:40:33I think the camera thing, I want to stay on the camera thing for a second.
1:40:37Yeah. Go. Cause I think, I think that I don't think that it's gonna,
1:40:40I mean the rumor is that Apple's working on a product now. I think it's imminent.
1:40:44I mean you've got this canary thing in your house. I think,
1:40:46I think the cameras are the next step. I really do.
1:40:49- The people who say, why would I need a device
1:40:53if I've got, you know, the Apple faithful, God love them,
1:40:56who say, why would I ever want a device for these things
1:40:59if I have my watch and my phone?
1:41:01I can almost promise you, as much as I love you all,
1:41:04that you haven't actually tried using a device
1:41:06for this stuff, 'cause you will use it differently.
1:41:09It's funny, it's ironic to me that the same people
1:41:11who are so in love with their iPhone
1:41:13that they learned to love don't understand
1:41:15that there's a similar pattern with trying a device
1:41:17for a while and seeing how you would use it
1:41:19in a different context.
1:41:21And you might use it pretty differently.
1:41:25I could see that becoming a hub for the home
1:41:27in a lot of ways.
1:41:28There's already an Amazon device that's made
1:41:29by a third party that you can put on your refrigerator
1:41:32and treat that way.
1:41:33But you know, and the question I was gonna ask you
1:41:36that we'll come back to though is like,
1:41:38how are our kids gonna use this?
1:41:39That's the thing.
1:41:40Nobody cares how we use it.
1:41:41We've aged out of the demo, nobody cares.
1:41:43- I don't wanna keep banging the HAL 9000 hammer,
1:41:46but I still think that conceptually it's correct
1:41:49that Hal was everywhere on the ship
1:41:52and was built into the ship
1:41:54and he wasn't like a thing that they talked to on a wrist.
1:41:58I'm not saying that talking to the thing on your wrist
1:42:00isn't a thing, but I'm saying that the better way to go
1:42:04is to have a ubiquitous presence built into the ship.
1:42:09The Star Trek is the same way, right?
1:42:11The next generation enterprise computer,
1:42:15best name for one of these things ever.
1:42:17Was the same way though, the computer was just
1:42:22an ever present,
1:42:22presence built into the ship.
1:42:27- Well, yes, totally.
1:42:28And I mean, like think I'm just,
1:42:31think about stuff like water.
1:42:33Water used to be a thing that you went down to the creek
1:42:36and you filled a jug or a bucket and you brought it back
1:42:39and that was the water.
1:42:40But now water comes out of little dinguses
1:42:42all throughout your house.
1:42:43time was, air conditioning was a thing. You bought down at the Montgomery Ward and you
1:42:47stuck in your window. And now, magically, air conditioning comes out of all these vents
1:42:51throughout your house. You can even have smart vents, as I've seen on Shark Tank, that you
1:42:54can adjust how much air conditioning is going into a room at each time.
1:42:58So our first example of how we would use this HAL 9000-like device is I talk into my watch
1:43:05to see what the weather is, even though I could probably just as easily go see. But
1:43:08think about it more like what happens when the devices that you use, I think of it almost
1:43:14like a client-server relationship. What if it gets to where you pick up six or eight
1:43:18or twelve packs of these dinguses that you could magnet or stick to the wall in the shower,
1:43:24they're waterproof, they could go in the car, they can go in the garage, they can go anywhere.
1:43:28What if it becomes just another, in the same way that you would want to extend your Wi-Fi
1:43:31network, you just want to extend the ability to say stuff into the air and have it do things.
1:43:37That gets us away from this idea of having this weird $200 thing you put in your house.
1:43:41Like I would think more in that direction than thinking of talking to your watch and
1:43:44asking for the weather.
1:43:45And eventually, if it gets smart enough and contextual enough, it will learn to, as I
1:43:50said, the thing I'm always looking for is learn to tell me about things I didn't know
1:43:54I needed to know before I realized I need to know it.
1:43:58That's the real brilliance is when the real machine learning starts to see patterns that
1:44:01I didn't and starts telling me about important things, not just things I know I need to know.
1:44:06Tell me the things that are important that I don't know that I need to know.
1:44:09And that's where ubiquity comes into it, in context.
1:44:12Tell me when this is useful.
1:44:13Like, don't be yelling at me and blinking lights all the time.
1:44:16Learn what's important to me, and then help me have the life I want to have.
1:44:21Humans are naturally really, really good at pattern, certain pattern recognitions, like
1:44:25identifying a familiar face, or even like a face that you've only met once, you know,
1:44:30but you know you know them.
1:44:31Or it's like pareidolia, is that what it's called?
1:44:33just like you look at a street curb and you see a face because you're wired to see faces.
1:44:36Yes you are, yeah, yeah, or like the rock up in New Hampshire, the old man on the mountain,
1:44:42whatever it is, you know what I mean? Yeah, we're actually so wired to recognize faces that
1:44:48we see faces where there aren't faces, or Shroud of Turin, right? And voices too, but even as humans,
1:45:00here's just an obvious example. Once I hit puberty, every time I answered the phone,
1:45:05anybody who was calling for my dad would think that I was my dad and just start talking to him
1:45:10like I was him. Because I sounded, I don't think I sound that much like him, to be honest,
1:45:14but I sound enough like him that over, and with the distortion of a landline phone,
1:45:21it sounded enough. So if a human being could confuse me with my dad, I think that it's
1:45:26it's reasonable that even a very good echo-like device
1:45:30might confuse me and my dad.
1:45:33And so I think that adding additional sensors,
1:45:38obviously a camera, to know who the heck
1:45:40is talking to it at the time, is almost necessary.
1:45:44Maybe I'm just talking myself in a corner
1:45:45and everybody's gonna have these camera-like devices
1:45:48in their house within the next 18 months.
1:45:49- I don't think you are.
1:45:51I mean, think about the way triangulation works,
1:45:53where you could, I guess, if you wanted to,
1:45:55you could put your entire R and D budget into creating the world's greatest
1:45:59single antenna for discovering where something is located.
1:46:03But isn't it fair to say that it's better to have hundreds or thousands of much
1:46:08less costly antennas that talk to each other that can triangulate and say, well,
1:46:12you're like,
1:46:13there's a pretty good chance that you're here based on the signal strength of
1:46:16these different things. That's, I think that's kind of what we're talking about,
1:46:18right? I mean, so in this case, like there are,
1:46:21There are existing technologies that make this easy and useful already.
1:46:25So if this iPhone app detects that I'm in the house,
1:46:30cause a certain set of things to happen. If it's a certain time of day,
1:46:34then that's a factor, right? You think about I'm here, but my kid's not here.
1:46:39That can cause things to happen.
1:46:40Knowing what the weather is or what the weather is becoming.
1:46:43These are all like very knowable things right now.
1:46:46It's just that you cannot accomplish that easily with just something like,
1:46:49if this then that. It's a great app, but a very service, but a very dull weapon. But
1:46:55what about these multivariate things where if certain kinds of conditions aren't met
1:46:59over a certain period of time, let me know to do these things. But just even something
1:47:02as simple as what we're describing. When my iPhone is in the house, lots of things should
1:47:07be different, right? That's pretty easy.
1:47:10Yeah. And I know Syracuse had covered this recently on ATP about how he almost feels
1:47:16bad for his kids that they're not gonna they can't get away with like putting
1:47:19their bike up against the car anymore.
1:47:20Where you had the camera looking out.
1:47:23Right, but like imagine like I'm not even at home, but
1:47:26we've got a rule that there's no video games
1:47:30before dinner. Like, you know, right now Jonas is on a, let's just say,
1:47:35no video games and I could say, "Where's Jonas?"
1:47:38And I could be told, "Jonas is playing PlayStation 4
1:47:42in your living room." Right? I mean that is
1:47:45That is... it was science fiction when we were, you know, even...
1:47:50There's nothing about that that is unknowable. You're talking about connecting two pre-existing
1:47:54streams. It's just the connection's not there. The connection could be there.
1:47:57Right. The face recognition is there. The wi-fi is there. The voice-driven stuff is there. I mean,
1:48:05that's a problem that could be solved today. I mean, here's another one that's such a brilliant
1:48:10little thing that it... I don't get that many phone calls, so I'm grateful I don't need this that much,
1:48:15But have you gotten the thing yet? I don't know if it's just in 9, but where your phone says
1:48:19you're getting a call from this number, which appears to be this person.
1:48:23So what's that doing? It's going and looking through your old emails and recognizing
1:48:28that this phone number has been mentioned by this person before.
1:48:31That's what we're talking about. We're not talking about rocket science. We're talking about, like,
1:48:36the most basic kinds of inference, like one little step at a time. You know what I mean?
1:48:40Just build up this little case with these little bits of information.
1:48:43I completely agree. I can talk about this all day. Anything else you want to talk about on this front?
1:48:50No, I don't think so. You know, it's just it's this ongoing obsession of mine where like I
1:48:55really have noticed myself, I don't even mind being across the old man, there's a lot about
1:48:59that's very comforting, there's a lot of things I can dismiss and not feel bad about it, but I
1:49:03am trying to really just keep my mind open about continuing to understand new stuff on its own
1:49:09terms rather than like what I need or expect it to be. So that's why these topics end up
1:49:14really hitting me.
1:49:15I feel like that's that is my perspective exactly. I'm absolutely rocketing towards
1:49:22crotchety old man, but I'm like an open-minded crotchety old man.
1:49:28That's the best kind.
1:49:31It's the best. I think it's the best that we can hope for.
1:49:33Get off my lawn whenever it suits you.
1:49:36I don't know why, but it's been on my mind this week. I'm obsessed with this.
1:49:42I ended my XOXO talk two years ago by referencing the song, but for some reason I've had it.
1:49:50It's like the song that's been popped in my head is Kenny Rogers, "The Gambler," which is sort of like this jokey, upbeat, you know, like, you know, it was just a funny little folksy story about a guy.
1:50:00A lot of wisdom in that song.
1:50:01song a lot of wisdom and except that the the song ends and it goes back to the
1:50:09refrain afterwards but the last actual lyrics before it goes back to the
1:50:13refrain in his final words every hands a winner every hands a winner and every
1:50:21every hands a winner and every hands a loser and the best that you can hope for
1:50:25is to die in your sleep.
1:50:27(laughs)
1:50:29- The best, really?
1:50:31- Yeah, the best that you can hope for
1:50:33is to die in your sleep.
1:50:35It's such a macabre,
1:50:38I mean the whole thing is so folksy and ridiculous,
1:50:41and then that's just tossed out there.
1:50:44And if you think about it, there is an actual,
1:50:46I don't know what got me, something that you just said
1:50:49about the best that we can hope for or something
1:50:51that reminded me of that.
1:50:52Every hand's a winner, every hand's a loser.
1:50:55But the best that you can hope for.
1:50:56In his final words, "I found an ace that I could keep."
1:50:59You know what, John?
1:51:03There aren't enough advice songs.
1:51:04There aren't enough songs that are just filled with folksy advice.
1:51:08Well I think that if you read between the lines, at first you want to say, "Well, that's
1:51:11not the best that you can hope for."
1:51:13There's all sorts of things that you can hope for.
1:51:14It's literally not the best that you can hope for.
1:51:17Not in any conceivable way.
1:51:20Or is it?
1:51:21Well, but if you accept the premise that we're all going to die, then, and I know like our
1:51:32friend Peter Thiel, friend of the good friend of the show Peter Thiel does not accept this
1:51:36premise, then there's a certain logic to it where you gotta die somehow, and at the end
1:51:42we're all gonna be in the dirt, and so the best that you can hope for is to die in your
1:51:45sleep.
1:51:46Because any other way of dying is...
1:51:48Yeah, I saw a song called "Coward of the County".
1:51:50It's a little bit of a cowardly way to jack up your aspirations is to hope, Jesus, I hope
1:51:56I'm not awake when this happens.
1:51:57What did you do?
1:52:01Do you have any thoughts on the whole Peter Thiel Gawker thing?
1:52:06Nope.
1:52:07No.
1:52:08I got enough problems.
1:52:10I got enough problems, Jon.
1:52:13I tossed it out in a reply.
1:52:16So I think that it's, I think that it's, it got lost.
1:52:20I had a little gag I tweeted. This one went out to everybody. I tweeted that
1:52:25"Batman vs Superman 2 Bruce Wayne spends a decade and ten million dollars
1:52:31financing lawsuits to bankrupt the Daily Planet." Pretty good joke.
1:52:37And then somebody tweeted like, "Well, I'm in as long as it's subtitled
1:52:42Electric Boogaloo." And I tweeted back, "No, obviously the subtitle is Man of
1:52:47teal. Right? I had to get that out there. You don't even give him all your good ones.
1:52:54You just pick and choose. You should write an advice song.
1:52:58Uh, meta stuff here at the end of the show. Meta stuff. Stuff that's coming out is, I got the live
1:53:06talk show coming up in, as we speak, I think 13 days, so I got to get the tickets out. I think,
1:53:12fingers crossed that by the time anybody is listening to me tell you this, that
1:53:17the show will probably already be sold out.
1:53:19Good for you. Congratulations, man. That was great.
1:53:22Hoping to launch soon. Hopefully it'll be a good show this year, too.
1:53:25But if you want to, you could go and look at Daring Fireball and see if
1:53:29there's still tickets available. So that's coming up. It is going to be
1:53:34the same venue. It'll be Tuesday, the day after the keynote at
1:53:37Mezzanine. And here's the more important part. So we're limited, I think.
1:53:41I think we're limited to around 500 tickets just with the way we set up the venue and the seats
1:53:47and everything like that. And it's sold out every year so far and I think because last year's show
1:53:53blew up and was so big that it's probably going to be even more in demand this year.
1:53:57High expectations, buddy. High expectations.
1:53:59I wish we could find a bigger venue, but it's really kind of tight combined with all of the...
1:54:08mezzanine is perfect in so many ways other than the fact that if we could fit more, we would love
1:54:12to fit more, but we can't. To my knowledge, it's the best venue we can find, and I'm sorry.
1:54:16But we do plan on having a live video stream again. Last year, I didn't really promote the
1:54:22live video stream because I was so worried that it wasn't going to hold up, but it did hold up.
1:54:27So fingers crossed it'll hold up again. But anybody who wants to follow along live and
1:54:33doesn't get in with a ticket or if you're not even in San Francisco, then a ticket isn't even
1:54:37an option. You should be able to watch live. It'll be Tuesday. I think doors open at 6
1:54:45Pacific, but the show should start sometime around 7 o'clock Pacific, which is 10 Eastern time.
1:54:51And it should be a lot of fun live. That's a great event. Looking forward. Yeah, I've got your
1:54:58ticket reserved already. Boom. That's good. It's a fun one. What a crazy week.
1:55:06It's super crazy. One other meta thing, and I haven't done this in a while, I was saving it for
1:55:10your show, you being the guest on this show, is I joke sometimes that the show is America's
1:55:16favorite three-star podcast, but it actually is still rated three stars in iTunes. It started off
1:55:25with very low ratings when I split with our old friend Dan Benjamin, and there were some people
1:55:30who were not upset about it and left a lot of very, very poor reviews.
1:55:35Got some, uh, they're called activist reviewers.
1:55:37Yeah, activist reviewers. And, you know, that's what the system is there for. That's why I can't
1:55:42delete them. I wouldn't delete them even if I could. Fair is fair, you know, that's the way
1:55:46the system works. But I know...
1:55:48You can hope for us to die in your sleep.
1:55:49A lot of other shows often remind their viewers to leave a review and do that.
1:55:59And apparently, I've been told that this is actually true, that it actually does help in the iTunes.
1:56:05You know, there's like a manual system where iTunes, the people who work there in the podcast, can manually promote shows.
1:56:10But like the automated stuff and getting high in those rankings definitely helps to get good reviews,
1:56:19and that it can grow the audience. And maybe I shouldn't be so... I don't know, what's the word... "coi."
1:56:26and I don't want to ask people to leave reviews.
1:56:30But I'm asking.
1:56:31- I'll say it for you.
1:56:34It's very difficult to know what doesn't,
1:56:37does or doesn't always help when you've got a podcast.
1:56:41There's a lot of black boxes in podcasting.
1:56:43What I'll say is this.
1:56:44If, like me, you enjoy Jon's show,
1:56:47consider going, leave a nice review.
1:56:49Leave a five-star review to offset the activist reviewers.
1:56:52- Oh no, no, leave an honest review.
1:56:53- No, don't do that.
1:56:54Don't ask for that, don't ask for that.
1:56:56You gotta know when to-- here's the thing. You gotta know when to hold them. Okay? You
1:57:01gotta know when to fold them. Number three, you gotta know when to walk away. And finally,
1:57:08fourth, you gotta know when to run. Oh, there's number five. Don't count your money when you're
1:57:11sitting at the table. Oh, and so finally, turns out, the best you can hope for is to
1:57:15die in your sleep.
1:57:17I have always also thought that some of the worst advice you'll ever hear is to not count
1:57:23your money while you're gambling. Anybody listening at Overcast, you could use their
1:57:32little recommendation dingus as well and promote the show. But anyway, if you like the show,
1:57:38do me a favor and say good things about it. Anyway, I'll see some of you guys soon. We
1:57:43should have at least one more show before the live one, but look forward to seeing you
1:57:46guys who will be there at the live show. My thanks to you, Merlin Mann, for your generous
1:57:52use of your time and your thoughts. And my thanks to our sponsors today, mad.com, the
1:57:59Daily Deal site, mad.com, the forum where you can go and read cool articles by Glenn
1:58:07Fleischman and others, and last but not least, mad.com. Fuck those guys.
1:58:15You got to accept every free drink, try not to overthink, trust your dumb luck, don't
1:58:21Don't give a fuck.
1:58:23You gotta blow your fortune before you even realize the best that you could hope for is
1:58:29to lay down and die.
1:58:32Good night everybody.
1:58:33[BLANK_AUDIO]