Podcast Search

The Talk Show

153: ‘Chock Full of Whimsy’ With Ben Thompson

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I have a good I told you I've told you before we started the show. I have a SodaStream story. This is out of nowhere

0:00:04I hear so it it psychoanalyzed me. I'm on your couch Ben. You're you're the the psychoanalyst

0:00:10So

0:00:14The context is I was looking for drink recommendations for the podcast and I decided to go with

0:00:19SodaStream and scotch in two separate glasses

0:00:22I drank my scotch straight to be clear

0:00:24Longtime listeners of the show know that I'm a firm believer that all you need to be successful in today's world

0:00:30You need three things you need

0:00:32Well, actually I may be my three things have changed but I forget but right now

0:00:37I would say the three things you need is you need

0:00:39You need good coffee fussy way to make coffee. You've got to be real fussy about it make real good coffee

0:00:45You need

0:00:49Highly carbonated water and the only way to get it

0:00:52It's in my opinion is to own your own soda stream machine

0:00:55So you can you can carbonate your own water and you need a clicky keyboard

0:00:59That's those are my three keys to success that if you ask me why daring fireball and and this podcast are doing well

0:01:06It's that I have a fussy way to make

0:01:08Good coffee. I have a soda stream and a super carbonated water and I have a very clicky keyboard

0:01:15I have an Apple extended keyboard -

0:01:18Here's the problem. The problem is about a week ago

0:01:21My current

0:01:25Carbonation canister in my soda stream ran out of

0:01:28Co2 and

0:01:32So it's always so demoralizing that happens. It's just like the little the little piffed into the water

0:01:37Well, here's my in my my strategy for years

0:01:41I mean years now has been that I have four canisters of co2 and when three get empty

0:01:48I go to, there's a Williams-Sonoma across town, right in Center City, Philadelphia.

0:01:55I take the three empty ones to the Williams-Sonoma. I exchange them. You get like a discount when you

0:02:02give them the empties and you can buy new ones. So I always buy three at a time. But then I have

0:02:08my fourth that's in the canister so I don't have to, you know, it's not gonna come out. Well,

0:02:12here's the thing. My thing ran out last week and I've had this thing for years and I went down to

0:02:17where I keep the empties down in our bottom floor.

0:02:20But it's not really a basement, it's sort of a bottom floor.

0:02:23And they weren't there.

0:02:24I don't know where the hell my other ones are.

0:02:27And I spent all day and I asked Amy.

0:02:30We looked, I looked everywhere.

0:02:33I don't know where the hell I put my,

0:02:35I don't know what happened at some point

0:02:37in the last few weeks or months.

0:02:38Either me or I suspect, quite frankly, my wife moved

0:02:46my refill canisters and I don't know where the hell they are.

0:02:53So I couldn't make fizzy water.

0:02:55And so I was stuck buying, what I did is I started buying Pellegrino and some Perrier

0:03:02because I even forget, I'm so used to making my own I forget which I like better.

0:03:08That's what I do.

0:03:09I have the 24-pack Perrier at Costco that I keep for like car rides and and in case I run out

0:03:16Yeah, I think I like Perrier better than pellet green

0:03:18I think Perrier is a little bit more bite to it

0:03:21But either way I but then I'd run out and I couldn't make more and I was dehydrated. I

0:03:25Mean I was dehydrated because I cannot drink flat water. It's just awful and

0:03:31Here the days are going by and I'm dehydrated and I'm miserable and

0:03:38And even when I have the stuff in the house, even when I have like the Perrier or whatever,

0:03:42I'm unhappy with it because it's nowhere near carbonated enough for my taste.

0:03:47And then I realized, this is literally yesterday, I realized, you know what?

0:03:50I could just go to the goddamn Williams Sonoma and buy a couple more canisters of this stuff.

0:03:56And if and when I find the ones that are somewhere in my house, I'll use them eventually too,

0:04:03I can still take, even though I'll have more empty canisters than I need, I'll just take

0:04:09them all back. It doesn't matter. Why did it take me a week? This is my question. Why

0:04:13did it take me a week to realize I can just go there and buy the goddamn refills that

0:04:19I need? Why did I make myself miserable for a week then?

0:04:24I laugh because I have done the exact same thing. So here you'll usually buy them at

0:04:29a department store. I'll get to the department store. I'm like, "Oh, shoot! I wanted to get

0:04:33more canisters, but I forgot to bring it. And then I don't buy it. And then I don't have

0:04:38any eating canisters. It's totally illogical and I do the exact same thing.

0:04:43I somehow convinced myself that I need the one for one exchange to get the refills. When

0:04:51I don't, I don't. I didn't need that. I just went there with the one refill that I had

0:04:56because of the one that was, you know, that I just emptied and did it. I will say...

0:05:01Did you find the canisters?

0:05:02No, no and my wife said you know as soon as you come home

0:05:06You're going to find that those canisters and and I said yeah, she was waiting

0:05:09She was waiting for you to leave and then she was gonna smuggle them back to the shelf where they were so you would show

0:05:14Off and find them right well that seems like the Murphy's law way that it would roll, but it did not actually happen

0:05:19I'd I still have no idea where the hell the the canisters are if anybody knows where my extra canisters are please please

0:05:25Tweet at me or send me an email

0:05:28It occurs to me, it does occur to me, because it's like having a superpower, having as many Twitter followers as I have.

0:05:40And you know, I think you're in the same boat. It can be a superpower. Like on the last episode with Guy English, when I was wondering what the hell, you probably don't remember this, because I don't think you were a Mac user back then.

0:05:53back then but I was wondering about there was this chooser extension for the

0:05:58classic Mac OS that if you had a local talk network if you if other people had

0:06:02this chooser extension you could effectively show you could like chat to

0:06:08them you could it if we both had it I could look your machine if I knew and I

0:06:14knew your Mac's name I could send you a message so it was effectively like

0:06:19instant messaging over the local talk network back in the very early 90s and I

0:06:25could not remember the name of the chooser extension and googling for

0:06:30anything like pre-google is very difficult very difficult and and

0:06:35googling for this particular problem really unless there's some better way to

0:06:39phrase it so there's a common word involved yeah yeah it doesn't give you

0:06:43the answer and so I asked on Twitter and within like five minutes somebody

0:06:49was, you know, had the answer. It was called "Broadcast." And as soon as they said

0:06:52"Broadcast," I was like, "That's it!" And then somebody even posted screenshots of

0:06:56it, which is amazing, because if you type "Broadcast chooser extension classic Mac OS"

0:07:01into Google, you still don't get the screenshots in the, like, image search.

0:07:05It's literally un-Googleable, even if you know the name of it. But asking on

0:07:10Twitter got me the answer. And I have to say, it does occur—it often occurs to me

0:07:16in situations like when I'm looking for the SodaStream in my house, like I should ask

0:07:20on Twitter. And then I realized, no, nobody on Twitter is going to be able to help me

0:07:24on this. It has spoiled me.

0:07:29Yeah, it's funny, I realized I just kind of did that today. I thought about the mini-Microsoft.

0:07:36Do you remember that guy?

0:07:38Oh yeah, he was great. Well, it's great that he's kind of stopped, right?

0:07:43Yeah, no, that's why I asked. He's just telling me, I don't know why, the guy just suddenly

0:07:47occurred to me. So I just threw it on Twitter, "What happened to Mini Microsoft?" And I heard

0:07:51from someone actually kind of off the record that said that he left Microsoft.

0:07:54Oh really?

0:07:55He didn't tell me who it was. But, and then of course the joke is, you know, because he

0:07:59left, you know, he piped down around the time Steven Sinofsky was. There's always a joke

0:08:03that Steven Sinofsky was actually Mini Microsoft, especially he was very complimentary of Sinofsky

0:08:10in general and very anti-balmer.

0:08:14So actually, Sanasi jumped in on the thread.

0:08:17He's like, oh, you got me.

0:08:18But no, it was funny.

0:08:19Actually, the funniest answer, though,

0:08:21was Contra, Counter Notions, our anonymous friend,

0:08:26where he said he's now known as Mini Amazon, which

0:08:28is probably true, given that he was at Microsoft.

0:08:31But yeah, that's like the most inside of both the Seattle

0:08:37and tech jokes as you can get.

0:08:41Many of you--

0:08:41He was great.

0:08:42Yeah, he used to-- and it looked so beautiful, too,

0:08:49because he'd spell Microsoft with the stock quote MSFT.

0:08:53So it was M-I-N-I-M-S-F-T. And somehow,

0:08:58that eight-character name, it looked very balanced to me.

0:09:03And he was a guy for years who ran a blog where

0:09:06He, and I think, I don't think anybody disputes that he actually worked there.

0:09:11I mean, you can't, he was anonymous, obviously, or pseudonymous would be a

0:09:14better way, but he was like a pseudonymous Apple or not Apple, a Microsoft, um,

0:09:20longtime Microsoft employee who was a critic of the late Balmer era.

0:09:27Um, but he was a critic who loved Microsoft, right?

0:09:31Like that's a, and that's what made it so compelling and saw,

0:09:34saw tremendous potential there.

0:09:36And I think in hindsight was largely proven correct that what he saw as

0:09:42Folly, you know, and I think folly is a good way to put it

0:09:46Turned out to be correct

0:09:49Yeah, no, absolutely

0:09:53And and the other thing that was amazing about it too was he had these

0:09:58Unbelievable comment threads and all his posts because everyone at Microsoft read it

0:10:01Yeah

0:10:01And so he would have these thousand comment long posts that like debating stuff going back and forth

0:10:08Like it was I mean, he slowed down a lot. The site's still there. It's it's mini MSFT blogspot.com

0:10:15but but I mean at the time especially when he was posting regularly like it was like the outlet for for like Microsoft inks and

0:10:22Complaints and all that sort of stuff. It was really something else. Yeah

0:10:25Imagine if we had that imagine we had someone at Apple doing that like how how

0:10:31How many black ops would they bring in to find out who the guy was or who the gal was or whatever it might be?

0:10:37I don't think I you know, that's interesting. I know that some people

0:10:41Think that I wonder if they would I mean my understanding I know that that that off the cuff that a lot of people seem to

0:10:50think that Apple

0:10:52does

0:10:54What would you call it counter espionage

0:11:00you know, but they don't that Apple does not

0:11:03Really my understanding I mean I can't prove it but my understanding is that Apple doesn't really have like

0:11:12Anybody inside who like investigates leaks or anything like that that they don't and specifically they don't because

0:11:22They think that if it ever leaked that they have a team that investigates leaks

0:11:27it would be so bad PR wise that it would be worse than the actual leaks.

0:11:32And that the only reason that so little tends to leak from Apple is really, even as their headcount grows,

0:11:40it's literally just the internal culture of people who work here don't leak.

0:11:45Yeah, well, and I'll tell you too, on the first day on the orientation,

0:11:50like, this orientation is very upbeat and all these great things about Apple and history and blah, blah, blah.

0:11:56And then this very stern looking security woman came in, and I'm telling you, we were a bunch of interns when I was there, so we're all kind of young and impressionable anyway.

0:12:06But she put the holy fear of God in you. It was incredible. It was delightful looking at it from the outside.

0:12:14Even as sitting there, you're like, "Holy crap, I will never leak anything ever again."

0:12:17[Laughter]

0:12:18It was awesome.

0:12:20uh... it

0:12:21river her big example was i have for apple store i think like the old the old

0:12:26the old dog that that tracked apple stores

0:12:28and she was like

0:12:30yet back and remember what the context was a member that blog

0:12:34was one of the examples she had

0:12:36uh... but yeah it was something else but you know i agree obviously a harsh

0:12:40presentation i could last that long it's it's absolutely a cultural cultural

0:12:43thing

0:12:44and

0:12:45uh...

0:12:46yeah it's it like their remember going into an office

0:12:49and like my first couple days and someone like,

0:12:52and I was kind of jarred that they didn't hold the door open for me.

0:12:55But like that would, that's just the way that just, you don't,

0:12:59you don't do that. Right. Because you don't know that I have to badge in. Right.

0:13:02Right. You don't know that. So it is, it's totally a thing. Yeah. Yeah.

0:13:06All right.

0:13:07Do you don't know that the guy behind you actually has the credentials to come

0:13:10in? Right. You know that the guy who, right. Especially,

0:13:12especially because the different, uh,

0:13:14different parts of the apple will be like specified by the badge.

0:13:19even though you have an Apple badge, you can't necessarily get into all parts of Apple.

0:13:22Right.

0:13:22So...

0:13:22The guy who wrote IFO Apple Store, you know, he died recently.

0:13:28Yeah, it's very sad. I was just thinking about that when I...

0:13:30His name was Gary Allen. I'll put a link in the show notes, but it was a good site. And

0:13:36it's funny because a lot of people I noticed, I mean, it wasn't like, you know,

0:13:41first thing I do in the morning is check IFO Apple Store. But, you know, in the racket that I'm in,

0:13:46I obviously you know would come across it and it occurred to me at one point that boy

0:13:50IFO Apple store has really died down

0:13:52I wonder if the guy is sort of just lost his interest in it or it you know now that the stores have rolled out

0:13:57Worldwide is it just not interesting and then it turned out it was you know, he was he was ill and

0:14:03I

0:14:05Think he died

0:14:07Last fall I just look yeah, you know what's in the sights down. It's like it's a bummer. It's just yeah

0:14:15I suddenly feel very mortal, both because, one, we're both getting older, two, we're

0:14:21talking about death, and three, making my living on the web and going to this guy's

0:14:25website that he poured his life into and there's nothing there.

0:14:28Now I'm really bummed out.

0:14:29I think he's written about it publicly, but my pal and longtime blogger at waxy.org,

0:14:35Andy Baio, has thought about this for a long time, maybe even years ago, that there should

0:14:42be some sort of, you know, his idea is to somehow set up some kind of a trust where

0:14:48people with websites can, you know, pay for them. Yeah, you'd somehow somehow set up a

0:14:54trust where and some sort of and like a trusted organization where you would put, you know,

0:15:00trust them with the credentials for your website. And so that you can, you know, with some sort

0:15:08of modicum of financial backing that to keep websites up in perpetuity after, you know,

0:15:16because obviously, you know, let's face it, we're all going to die eventually.

0:15:20No, it's awesome. It's something like that that WordPress or whoever should think about,

0:15:25like there should be a button to like export as HTML and like, actually, WordPress to do

0:15:31this. I'll talk to Matt about it. Like, imagine being able to have it in a will, whatever

0:15:36you can export the site so it's just HTML, they're not rendering every time so it's not taking any

0:15:40compute resources, it's super lightweight. And yeah, you put down, it wouldn't be that much,

0:15:45honestly, to be able to serve a static web page for a very long time.

0:15:50>> I think in the long run, the biggest expense honestly would be the keeping the domain name

0:15:55registered. >> Yeah, I think that's exactly right.

0:15:58>> And even if it's only six, seven bucks a year, in the long run for a statically rendered version

0:16:04of during Fireball, and especially as time goes on, let's face it, let's just say 100 years from now,

0:16:09there's not going to be a lot of traffic on this site.

0:16:13Right.

0:16:14And even if there were.

0:16:15This kind of sounds a little narcissistic when you put it that way. Who's going to be reading

0:16:20the year 2100? Let me see what SirTekkari.com had to say about this.

0:16:23Right, but at least, but I would like to think that it'll still be there for people to refer to,

0:16:29and that somebody who wants to refer to it,

0:16:34that they can still point to the URL and it'll still respond.

0:16:37This is why I'll put the...

0:16:40I think I said this last time I was on your podcast too.

0:16:42I have a recurring donation set up for the Internet Archive

0:16:45and it's something I would counsel everyone to do

0:16:48because that is such an unbelievable resource.

0:16:50It's the closest that we have.

0:16:51It is and they do really important work

0:16:56And I use it a lot for researching stuff because stuff disappears all the time.

0:17:02Like you'll, especially when you talk about the pre-Google stuff, you're trying to find stuff back in the day and you find a link and you know at the end of the link is what you need and then crap, it's gone.

0:17:10And then you go to Internet Archive and it's there.

0:17:12So yeah, I set it up just an automatic donation every single month.

0:17:15Um, because I mean, one, it's awesome.

0:17:18Two, it's important.

0:17:19And three, it's like super important to my work.

0:17:20So, yeah.

0:17:22I've said this to people multiple times and it's one of those things I'll get to someday,

0:17:28but it's one of those things where if I had an intern or an employee or something, but

0:17:33it is astoundingly depressing how if you go back to 2004, which was the first year where

0:17:42I had the link list feature on Daring Fireball, where I'd link to things on a daily basis.

0:17:50absolutely astounding how many of those links are 404s at this point. And

0:17:54Kottke and I have talked about this, like, because Kottke has been doing his thing

0:17:57since like 1998. If you go back to the earlier, I mean, the longer you go back,

0:18:02it's like almost exponential. If you go back to the earlier year, the earliest

0:18:06years of Kottke, it's even worse. It's like the even just every year you go

0:18:11back, it's worse and worse and worse. It makes a difference if it's like 2005

0:18:16versus 2003 versus 2001.

0:18:19It's absolutely astounding how many links are 404s.

0:18:22Really, it's depressing.

0:18:23So my idea would be to hire somebody

0:18:27to go back and, for every dead link,

0:18:31see if it's available at archive.org.

0:18:33And if it is, change the link to the archive.org version.

0:18:36It makes sense.

0:18:41And also then it comes back to, well, how many people

0:18:45We're gonna actually click these links. Yeah, but it's I just want it to be right

0:18:48You know what? I mean? It has nothing to do with me. No, I

0:18:51totally get it's just that it just bothers me in a I don't know it isn't you know in the way that

0:18:59My obsessions, you know

0:19:01It's I know that it's the right thing to do and it doesn't matter what right in a bother

0:19:06It bothers you to know that there's a bunch of bad links and I'm you know in your stream

0:19:11All right, and I don't want any blink on during fireball to ever go bad. I really do

0:19:15I mean it. I mean, I want everything that I've ever posted it during Firewall to be a, you know,

0:19:21a valid URL in perpetuity, long past, you know, when I'm dead.

0:19:27I was going to say in the ground that I doubt, I really doubt that I'm ever going to be put in

0:19:35the ground. So I wasn't sure what to say. We have taken such a morbid turn. I know.

0:19:41I think we started with sparkling water and now we're in the ground.

0:19:45Well, I was gonna say until I'm in the ground. This is why I hesitated there. I was gonna say

0:19:49in the ground and then I realized I don't want to be buried. I think that's antiquated and a waste of

0:19:55real estate. And so I was gonna say burned up, but then I realized if I said burned up, it's as

0:20:00though I'm predicting that I'm gonna die in some kind of terrible fire, which is, you know, I

0:20:06hopefully will not be the way that I go. Hopefully you'll be already dead before you enter the

0:20:11the charitable fire.

0:20:12Exactly.

0:20:13Well, what better segue into my first thanking my first sponsor.

0:20:19Hey, you're lucky because you launched right into it.

0:20:23So I had to do the panic hit record.

0:20:25So I was going to break up.

0:20:28You should always be recording.

0:20:30No, I did.

0:20:31I did.

0:20:32I was only five seconds late.

0:20:33Don't worry.

0:20:34You missed the what's up, the very enthusiastic what's up.

0:20:37Our first sponsor is our good friends at Wealthfront. Wealthfront is an automated investment service.

0:20:44They have over $3 billion in client assets under management. They manage a diversified,

0:20:51continually rebalanced portfolio of index funds on behalf of their clients in a low

0:20:57cost and tax efficient manner. So what you do is you give Wealthfront your money and

0:21:04it is effectively set it and forget it. You don't go there and it's not like this is where you go to

0:21:10day trade and something like that and pick individual companies and things like that.

0:21:16This is the complete opposite of this. This is not short-term active market timing trading.

0:21:22This is put it in there and this is an algorithm. They have algorithms that are really measured for

0:21:30for the long term.

0:21:32And research shows that when individuals attempt

0:21:35to time the markets, attempt to day trade,

0:21:37attempt to pick individual stocks, overwhelmingly, they

0:21:42underperform index funds.

0:21:46And in large part because of the higher costs, higher taxes,

0:21:50and just the fact that it's really hard to beat the index

0:21:54funds.

0:21:56So here's a big advantage to Wealth Fund.

0:21:59They charge no trading commissions, and they charge an advisory fee of 0.25% per year.

0:22:09That's one-fourth of 1%, and that's only on assets above $10,000.

0:22:14So if you only put less than $10,000 into your Wealthfront account, which is how people

0:22:19– they know this is what people do, and it makes total sense.

0:22:22People who get started with Wealthfront put, like, play money in there just to see if it

0:22:27works.

0:22:28that it works and they give trust then they put quote unquote real money into

0:22:32to Wealthfront and only when you're over $10,000 do they start charging fees and

0:22:37even then the fee is only one fourth of 1% and you can get an additional $5,000

0:22:44free for each friend you recommend to Wealthfront and those people who you

0:22:49recommend your friends who you say hey man I'm putting all my money in

0:22:52Wealthfront and and you can get into they get the $5,000 extra too so

0:22:58So there's no limit to the amount you can get managed free.

0:23:01So put a whole bunch of friends in there and you can keep getting more and more that has

0:23:05no fees at all.

0:23:08It's really, really low fee, really optimized for the long term.

0:23:16There's so much more and there are experts on this.

0:23:19I'm not an expert on investing or anything like that other than the fact that I'm a true

0:23:24believer in putting your long-term investments into index funds as a basic idea.

0:23:31So go there and find out more.

0:23:34And the URL, this is where you go, wealthfront.com/the-talk-show.

0:23:44Really it's just a great way to invest your money and it's super easy.

0:23:48You just go there, it's no work.

0:23:50no work and your money is in, in my opinion, the safest sort of

0:23:56investment that you can in the long run, which is index funds.

0:23:59And they take care of all the details. And they really do it

0:24:02in a way that minimizes your taxes and maximizes the long

0:24:06term after tax returns that you'll get on your investment.

0:24:11So go to wealthfront.com slash the talk show. We have a lot to

0:24:17talk about. It's a good thing we wasted the first half hour.

0:24:20on sparkling water.

0:24:22On sparkling water, nonsense.

0:24:25We do.

0:24:26Multiple topics, and I think all Apple related, but...

0:24:30Well, I want to talk to you about this stupid Amazon Echo that you talked me into buying.

0:24:36Oh, that's right.

0:24:38But we should talk about Apple first.

0:24:43And we should get to both the Apple iPhone and to you and Guy's discussion on the services,

0:24:49I thought was actually really good. I enjoyed it. I had one addition to make.

0:24:54Well, make it now. Let's do that first. Let's do that. So last week's show, Guy and I spent

0:24:58a long time talking about your recent piece on Apple and services and their organizational

0:25:06structure. So tell me what you quibble with. The only thing I would say is when I say Apple

0:25:11services, I'm talking about much more than just iCloud. And I think that that was a...

0:25:18I did say that in an article, but I probably could have made the point more forcefully

0:25:22because people hear Apple services and they think iCloud.

0:25:25Like iCloud as it is, I actually agree with you, it's mostly fine.

0:25:29I think they prompt your password way too much for one.

0:25:32But when I talk about services, that includes things like the App Store.

0:25:37Like that is a service and I don't think it's run optimally.

0:25:42Like and I think it's actually to Apple's detriment.

0:25:45uh... it's things like apple pay it's things like homekit it's all these

0:25:50ancillary things and i think where they actually struggle the most in many cases

0:25:54is placed with a foster ecosystems like that to get merchants to adopt apple pay

0:25:59they did they did get device makers to to integrate with

0:26:03with home kit

0:26:05make it so's developers can build sustainable businesses on the app store

0:26:08like all those go into the services bucket and i think in general apple is

0:26:14not good at those and it's not just the timing issue, it's the control issue.

0:26:19A big reason why Apple sucks at that stuff is they have a very hard time of letting go

0:26:24of control.

0:26:26And so that was the one thing.

0:26:28You guys didn't talk about that part and I actually think that's the more important part

0:26:32because that's the potential part.

0:26:34That's what Apple...

0:26:35It's so easy to look at stuff that companies do poorly, but often the bigger, the greater

0:26:42damage is the stuff that's not done, the advantages that aren't taken advantage of, or the opportunities

0:26:47that aren't taken advantage of. And so that was just the one kind of missing piece.

0:26:50Don't you think Apple Pay is a good example of Apple getting it right? Where they've built

0:26:58this thing on top of, they're not requiring people to have an Apple, retailers to have

0:27:03a Apple Pay proprietary sensor. It's this thing that works with anybody. It works with

0:27:11Android phones, it was already there. Like some retailers on day one could just say,

0:27:17"Okay, we're in." And I think that the growth in Apple Pay is actually pretty impressive.

0:27:23I think Apple Pay is actually a really interesting example to talk about. And the reason is,

0:27:31because first off, because there's multiple components that go into Apple Pay. So first

0:27:37First off, there's the actual hardware aspect of it, which is brilliantly done.

0:27:41It works really well.

0:27:43There is one downside, which is I personally trigger Apple Pay too often, just in general

0:27:47day-to-day use, which is kind of annoying, especially since I have it in Taiwan and it's

0:27:50not really available here.

0:27:52That part's awesome, which makes sense.

0:27:56It's a beautiful example of Apple integrating all the different pieces that go into making

0:28:01that experience work flawlessly.

0:28:02So the hardware aspect is amazing.

0:28:06this secure enclave in all all that sort of stuff

0:28:09uh... apple brought the banks to heal very effectively and in in general if

0:28:13you look at apple in any cues division in all that sort of stuff from a

0:28:16business development perspective they're actually usually pretty good at working

0:28:20with big established players they understand negotiate understand how

0:28:24where leverage is and how how to use it and things like that

0:28:26you know we've seen that with the label we've seen that with with himself the

0:28:29banks and so apple but again

0:28:32i think when you get a bunch of apple

0:28:34executives and other companies in a room Apple feels like they can control that

0:28:38situation they do it well

0:28:39where I think Apple has really dropped the ball

0:28:43is in coming up with an effective means to

0:28:46get retailers on board. Yes they've gone to the big retailers and work with them

0:28:51again directly

0:28:52but where's the incentive program for

0:28:55small merchants to sign up? Where's the program to go and get information about

0:28:58Apple Pay and supporting it in your store?

0:29:00Where's the program to get stickers for your door that says Apple Pay supported

0:29:03here?

0:29:04all that stuff is not existent actually wrote about this in the update actually

0:29:07heard from multiple

0:29:09people who wanted to support apple pay because of the what you there was the

0:29:13liability shift last fall which is a huge opportunity for apple to take

0:29:16advantage of

0:29:17and and they're like we

0:29:19we'd like we could get over apple there's nothing to say about what to do

0:29:23that we bought a new we bought a new pair processor none of them said if they

0:29:26supported apple parent out so we didn't know so apples not working with the

0:29:29manufacturers of these things

0:29:31and that's where apple falls down because

0:29:33there it's a you can't an apple representative can't go out and talk to

0:29:37every small medium-sized business they can't talk to every merchant

0:29:40they probably should talk to every manufacturer payment terminals but they

0:29:43didn't apparently

0:29:44but but what you have to do is you have to create incentives you have to do to

0:29:48have a bonus programs you have to

0:29:50figure out ways we can sign up seamlessly to integrate the rewards

0:29:53program or coupons or whatever might be and that sort of stuff where it's

0:29:57itself serve

0:29:59apple doesn't do a good job with that stuff and i again you can see that with

0:30:03the App Store. The people that Apple deals with directly, they do a good job and they

0:30:08partner well, but when it comes to creating the conditions for success for people broadly

0:30:14that aren't necessarily going to ever talk to Apple one-on-one, the company doesn't do

0:30:18a good job. And I think that's why Apple Pay, like there was this huge opportunity last

0:30:23year with this liability shift where basically what happened was if you didn't have a chip

0:30:29readable terminal

0:30:31and someone had a chip card you were liable for any fraud

0:30:34and vice versa if you didn't have a chip card and they had a chip terminal then you were

0:30:37liable for fraud so it was a great example of how incentives

0:30:42drive change they couldn't force people to upgrade their terminals but they could say

0:30:46if you don't you're going to be held liable and so people would would pay themselves to

0:30:50to upgrade and Apple should that was the huge example for Apple Pay to be all over that

0:30:54and be advertising and say these chips suck they take a long time to use it take like

0:30:5860 seconds or 30 seconds or whatever to process. This is the chance everyone's

0:31:02gonna buy new ones. Apple should have had a huge blitz. They should have had

0:31:04marketing targeted at business owners and none of that happened. Absolutely none of it.

0:31:08So you're saying even though the growth is great that it could have been

0:31:13it could be accelerated if Apple were doing everything? Hugely accelerated, right?

0:31:18Right? Because Apple Pay is not never going to reach its potential unless

0:31:21people have confidence that it will mostly be okay. Actually this is a

0:31:26tie into the echo thing right the reason one reasons i like

0:31:28alexa much better than siri is i'm shocked when alexa doesn't work and i'm

0:31:33pleasantly

0:31:34pleased when when siri does like that there's a

0:31:37there's a line that that is like where you assume it's going to work and

0:31:41mhm apple pay is a long ways away from that line

0:31:43like in with the what happens is even if you know mcdonald's accepted or

0:31:47walgreens accepted or whatever the places may be you're not in the habit at

0:31:50all of using it because no one wants to walk up and look like an emily bonus

0:31:54geeks will. "Do you support Apple Pay?" But normal people don't want to be in that

0:32:00awkward situation and so it's just frustrating because it's such a great product. It has

0:32:05so much potential. Imagine Apple owning your wallet. What opportunities are out there if

0:32:15they really establish this and make it a very real thing? And again, that's my services

0:32:21It's not that the stuff they do isn't as great as it could be.

0:32:23It's not, frankly, but it's not that big a deal.

0:32:25It's probably mostly fine.

0:32:27It's the opportunities that I believe they're missing.

0:32:30I don't know about that, but it's an interesting argument.

0:32:36I don't know.

0:32:37I don't know.

0:32:39Hey, I was appreciative that you didn't dismiss my proposal outright, so I'll take

0:32:44what I can get.

0:32:47What do you think... who just said this? There was something I linked to this week

0:32:55where somebody held up iMessage as a... it might have been the kook I linked to

0:33:06who said Tim Cook should be fired which is cropped up again.

0:33:13He's a character to say the least.

0:33:17Wait, who was it? Oh, Lefsitz. Yeah, that's it. Bob Lefsitz.

0:33:21Held up iMessage as

0:33:25like Apple dropping the ball because they're keeping it proprietary.

0:33:29And Lefsitz is a kook and he's not the only person who's said it.

0:33:33But to me, iMessage is a

0:33:37very

0:33:41under-appreciated aspect of modern Apple,

0:33:46because they don't, and it is to me,

0:33:51almost a pure Apple service,

0:33:55because nobody else would ever do anything like this,

0:33:58'cause it wouldn't make sense for anybody else to do it.

0:34:01Is they-- - Well, except for Blackberry.

0:34:03- Yeah, I guess so, I guess so, I guess you're right.

0:34:06I guess it is sort of a copy of BBM.

0:34:10That's fair, you know.

0:34:12- But that's a testament to the point.

0:34:16And that's like the tension here, right?

0:34:18Because iMessage is a beautiful example

0:34:20of Apple having a vertical sort of model

0:34:24where their services differentiate their hardware.

0:34:26Like iMessage is a reason to have and use an iPhone.

0:34:30Like I tried to switch to Android when my arm was broken

0:34:32because the speech recognition is so much better.

0:34:34And one of the things that made it very difficult

0:34:38was the lack of iMessage.

0:34:39Like it's a super great lock and it really is.

0:34:44And yeah, so that's why this whole services thing

0:34:49is so fraught because to date it has been about

0:34:53differentiating Apple's services.

0:34:56And the question is in the long run, like,

0:34:59is that enough?

0:35:02- Right, the thing that to me is underappreciated

0:35:05is that if you and I started a messaging service

0:35:09that had only and exactly the features that iMessage has.

0:35:13End-to-end encryption, you can put,

0:35:17you can send text and you can embed images and that's it.

0:35:22And we got as many users as iMessage has.

0:35:26It would be a tremendously valuable company.

0:35:30It's on the scale of like WhatsApp and what's the other one?

0:35:38You know them all.

0:35:40Line, we just could call it.

0:35:42Right.

0:35:42It's--

0:35:43Or--

0:35:44Yeah.

0:35:44It-- the number of--

0:35:46and whatever buzzword metric you want to use,

0:35:50like daily active users, it's huge.

0:35:53iMessage is huge in terms of how many people send or receive

0:35:57an iMessage every day.

0:35:59It would be tremendously valuable.

0:36:02And it goes completely, to me, unrecognized

0:36:05in people evaluating Apple.

0:36:09And maybe it should. - I don't think so, though.

0:36:09- Maybe it shouldn't.

0:36:10Maybe it shouldn't because the other ways

0:36:14that people value Apple are intrinsically tied to iMessage.

0:36:18- Exactly, 'cause people value Apple

0:36:20based on how many iPhones they sell.

0:36:21And the way iMessage is leveraged by Apple right now

0:36:26is as a tool to sell more iPhones.

0:36:28And so it is properly valued.

0:36:30Like the only way it should be valued separately

0:36:34is if apple explicitly starts to think about it as as a service in his own

0:36:39right in maybe you could do that was well retaining it being only on on

0:36:44iphones you may have

0:36:46we maybe have less potential then but but no i i don't think it is under

0:36:50valid to think all week they look at what's up to a fifteen billion i will

0:36:54how much is i miss is worth to that read up as well on the stocks on fair bowl

0:36:57blah blah it's not because

0:36:58apple has

0:37:00strategy is such that

0:37:02it is eight part of the iphone and the iphone is value very highly i mean

0:37:06apple is still the most valuable company in the world

0:37:10and it it leads me to what apple has invented as and to me a fairly

0:37:16as its own metric

0:37:17uh...

0:37:18and i think it's only going back to a three quarters where they've started

0:37:21citing this

0:37:23number of uh...

0:37:26i don't know if they're calling it daily but actively use devices

0:37:31They're saying that they, I think it's a billion, right?

0:37:34- A billion, yep.

0:37:35- That there's a billion Apple devices in active use,

0:37:40which is, no other company, maybe other than Samsung.

0:37:44Samsung, I guess, would be an interesting,

0:37:47I guess Samsung could use that figure,

0:37:51and it would be interesting too,

0:37:52especially considering that Samsung has things

0:37:55like refrigerators and washing machines

0:37:57and microwave ovens. (laughing)

0:37:59No, seriously!

0:38:00No, I'm laughing because first, sorry,

0:38:04it's just a side note, but it's not even about Samsung,

0:38:09so I probably shouldn't even tell this story,

0:38:10but now I feel like I've gotten myself too far in.

0:38:13During the NCAA tournament,

0:38:14you know you see the same commercial a million times?

0:38:16- Yeah.

0:38:17- And I think it was a couple of years ago,

0:38:18there was a commercial for the LG smartphone,

0:38:21like the Optimus or Prime or whatever it's called.

0:38:23That's not the right name, but it's something like that.

0:38:25And the commercial would be all about the phone.

0:38:29At the very end, I think Kenny Smith was the guy that was doing it.

0:38:32No, it was Greg Anthony.

0:38:33They would show him in front of the lineup of like washers and dryers and

0:38:37refrigerators, which the whole commercial was not about at all, but they felt like

0:38:41that they felt the need to squeeze that into this ad they were paying a lot of

0:38:44money for and it cracked me off every single time I saw it.

0:38:47I mean, it's like been three years.

0:38:49I'm still laughing about it.

0:38:50Anyhow, sorry.

0:38:50That was totally, totally off track.

0:38:52Well, now that I think about it though, I realized that there's a lot of companies,

0:38:57you know, Sony and LG, any of those companies that I guess could cite a lot of quote-unquote

0:39:03devices. I guess what makes Apple's metric more interesting is that Apple's devices are

0:39:08actually things that you pay attention to. You know, they're real computers is what they're

0:39:15talking about.

0:39:16It is, and honestly, Apple talking about services and that they're a services company is totally

0:39:21legitimate because it is a it is a real one they make real money the vast majority of

0:39:27it is from the App Store and most from pay to play games because you know that's all

0:39:31that Apple has enabled from a business model perspective which I'm happy to rant and rave

0:39:35about but it is real money and and they're right and it is also real potential like if

0:39:42they actually did get serious about it like a you can do a lot with a billion devices

0:39:49and and that's the this is the other thing with the i called thing the reason

0:39:52why i don't like folks you know i called is because the implication of folks and

0:39:55i called it it should be on all devices you know like apple music is on android

0:39:58and stuff what what i think is the huge potential for apple is device specific

0:40:02services it is

0:40:04it is the things like apple pay it is the things like home kit it is the

0:40:07things like the watch like

0:40:09the watch the huge potential for the watch from my perspective is being the

0:40:13key to your life

0:40:14like literally the key your watch to open your door your watch it

0:40:17should start your car, your watch should be your badge at work.

0:40:21Like your watch should be this movable piece of identification

0:40:25that oper-- Apple Pay. Like the watch with Apple Pay is

0:40:29amazing, you just have to find a place that has Apple Pay.

0:40:32You know I've thought about that

0:40:36too, that the watch as your sort of

0:40:39key to your life and I've written about it too little, way too little, maybe

0:40:44even borderline not at all, in terms

0:40:47of... the big picture question of, which I've sort of been writing about recently, is why

0:40:56did they do the watch, you know, why did they do the watch, why did they release the watch

0:40:59when they did with the features that it has?

0:41:02You know, should they have released a...

0:41:06Obviously the watch is significantly flawed.

0:41:08It's the most flawed device Apple has released in modern history, in my opinion.

0:41:15And recently I've been writing either, you know, I've posited that either…

0:41:18And with that, with that Gruber just, just, just spawned a hundred articles, but continue.

0:41:25I've posited though that Apple should have either waited longer to release the watch

0:41:30so that it would have been faster and that some of the features that don't work well

0:41:34would have worked better or cut those features that don't work well on the watch as we

0:41:39know it and released when they did.

0:41:43But I do think, lost in there is that one of the reasons that I think they wanted to

0:41:46get the watch out sooner rather than later, flaws though it had, is that idea though of

0:41:54the watch in the long run being a sort of key to your life.

0:42:00I do think there's tremendous potential there.

0:42:02And I've thought about things like, you know, Touch ID is such an eye-opener on iOS devices,

0:42:10But it's conspicuously absent on the Mac.

0:42:14And every time I have to type my password to unlock,

0:42:17you know, wake up my Mac,

0:42:18I think what a pain in the ass this is every single time.

0:42:21And why, you know--

0:42:22- If you have your--

0:42:24- Well, people-- - If you have a watch on,

0:42:25it should be unlocked.

0:42:26- Yeah, exactly.

0:42:27And people, a lot of,

0:42:28it's like a frequently emailed question to me is,

0:42:31you know, like, just with the recent update

0:42:34to the MacBook One,

0:42:35that, you know, hey,

0:42:38come they don't put a touch ID sensor on the MacBook because I'm so used to it on

0:42:42this and I tend to think that the answer isn't touch ID for the Mac I tend to

0:42:46think that the answer is like some sort of way of if you if you've got the watch

0:42:53on and you're within a very very close distance you know like like three inches

0:42:59of the Mac that it just unlocks there are actually apps you can get that do

0:43:05this and they do that with the phone as well but they're a little clunky as

0:43:08anything kind of third party is yeah it has to be has to be first party yeah I

0:43:12know absolutely and no the other thing with with the MacBook is the touch ID is

0:43:19is intimately integrated with the secure enclave on the on the a series chips so

0:43:25as long as there isn't an arm based Mac I don't think there's going to be touch

0:43:29ID yeah that's it's probably true and I just I just tend to think that it's the

0:43:35wrong form factor and the fact that it it kind of makes sense from it has to it

0:43:43should be to be due to be done right it has to be platform wide that any Mac or

0:43:49at least new Mac could do it but touch ID to do it the exact same way would

0:43:54only work on Mac books because there's there's just no feasible way that that

0:44:00it well I guess not no feasible way but you'd have to have you know to have it

0:44:03work on the iMacs and Mac Pros. Remember the Mac Pro?

0:44:07Do they still make that? You would have to build it into the

0:44:11keyboard and it's, you know, and the

0:44:15idea that you could do it from the watch, I guess if you could do it from the watch you could do it from the keyboard

0:44:19you know, that it would be some kind of secure way to do it wirelessly, but

0:44:23it just makes more sense to me that it would be the thing, you know,

0:44:27and like you said, like it should start your car, it could let you into your house

0:44:31if you have a smart door, you know, it's there's so many ways that it could be done for that and it would be a

0:44:36Tremendous like it would really like start to remove so many questions about why are they building?

0:44:42We know why did they make a device that you can wear, you know on your wrist?

0:44:46No, I could I completely agree and I mean this has been my vision for the watch kind of from the beginning

0:44:50I actually thought it might not even have a screen at the beginning because I was so like to me this idea of being the

0:44:55Key to your life and then notifications

0:44:57I mean the best feature of the watch is the taptic engine unless it fails

0:45:00But I mean, it's like that's what makes it really great. I was aware regularly

0:45:05I would argue though that the Taptic Engine is the best in theory. It's the best feature but in practice

0:45:12it's not and and I think part of that is me being biased because I have my watch is a stainless steel one and

0:45:19I've yep, I hear and I've worn the aluminum ones enough and it's you know

0:45:25it's just the privilege of getting review units and

0:45:29and being able to try both because I realize most people why in the world would a normal

0:45:33person be able to wear both but I have an aluminum model here that I don't own it's

0:45:37you know it's a review unit from Apple but it's eye opening after a while how much better

0:45:41the taptic engine is on the aluminum models than the steel ones and I've even worn I've

0:45:47tried it I've tried my son has the aluminum you know the sport model too and I've worn

0:45:51his just for you know like an hour or so and just said like hey just send me a text every

0:45:58couple minutes, you know, or send yourself a text, you know, because it was synced to

0:46:02his phone, but so I would feel it on my wrist, and it feels so much better. And it's, you

0:46:07know, it's just...

0:46:08How does it feel on the Edition, John?

0:46:10I don't know. I actually, I've never even tried an Edition, honestly. Even reviewers

0:46:15don't even get to try them. You know, I have noticed, though, that Apple Store here in

0:46:20Center City, Philadelphia, used to be one of the stores that had the Edition models

0:46:25in the display and you could buy the edition model here.

0:46:28And just last week, Amy and I were running errands

0:46:36in center stadium.

0:46:37We stopped into the Apple store, and the edition models

0:46:41are gone in the Philadelphia store.

0:46:44Interesting.

0:46:45That is interesting.

0:46:46Yeah, I noted a while ago that there

0:46:50seemed to quietly be emphasizing the edition less and less

0:46:55uh...

0:46:56and there is some pushback from a few people on twitter who are saying no

0:46:59they're not you know and it's still there it's just they're just putting in

0:47:02it you know

0:47:02they've just rearrange it is not really less emphasis but there's no doubt my

0:47:06mind that there

0:47:08just quietly you know

0:47:10uh... i know that quietly is often overused like finally when talking about

0:47:14apple you know apple quietly you know

0:47:16blah blah blah and it's you know not really any less

0:47:19or more quiet than anything else

0:47:22it's just that they're not trumpeting it

0:47:23but the... It's nowhere on... I'm on the front page of the watch page and there is not an

0:47:27edition on here. No. And there's like 15 watches on here. No, it's just there... but to me the way

0:47:33that they're backing away from the edition model watches really is sort of a quiet like,

0:47:39you know, let's start pretending like this doesn't exist. And to me the new... the new edition is the

0:47:48Hermes models of the watch. That's the, and you know like the stainless steel link bracelets,

0:47:58you know, that the luxury version of the watch are the ones that cost a thousand to two thousand,

0:48:04not five to twenty thousand. Yeah, it'll be interesting to, if we look back on that edition

0:48:13sort of series. We had so much fun speculating about that, how much they would cost.

0:48:17I'm pretty sure we did all five. Yeah, I'm looking at the whole

0:48:21kind of nature. There's nothing about him at all. Yep, and if we look back at it,

0:48:29it's sort of a kind of hubristic moment to be honest. I mean we're going to sell a

0:48:34a $20,000 watch because we can and we're gonna show it at these

0:48:40fashion boutiques and all this sort of stuff. And you know, and to lots

0:48:44of people's credit. There was a significant sector of the sort of Apple world that felt

0:48:53very uncomfortable with that, more so than I did, to be frank. And maybe there was something

0:48:59really to that.

0:49:00Yeah, it's fascinating.

0:49:01Getting away from your... We had this discussion, I think, the whole Andy Warhol Coke thing,

0:49:07right? And yes, the function of an addition was the same as the function of a sport, but

0:49:12just the idea and because what makes the iPhone so powerful as a consumer product, there's

0:49:18lots of things about it that make it powerful, but the best phone in the world has an entry

0:49:23price of $650 and while that is massively more expensive than the cheapest Android you

0:49:29can get for like 50 bucks, on an absolute basis it's just not that much money. And

0:49:35whereas cars, you say, "Oh, the iPhone is the BMW of cars." Well, sure, but on an

0:49:39absolute basis a BMW is what minimum 35,000 if you want something you know if you want

0:49:43a real BMW it's a lot more than that like just absolute numbers matter and on an absolute

0:49:51basis the iPhone has never been that expensive on a percentage on a relative basis yes it

0:49:55is absolutely expensive but and that is something that's core to Apple you can have the best

0:50:01phone in the world for relatively to the grand scheme of luxury goods not that much money.

0:50:07I forget what year it was, but it was probably the last year I went to South by Southwest.

0:50:12And so that's probably like 2010 or maybe it was even 2011, but somewhere around there.

0:50:19The last year I went to South by Southwest in Austin.

0:50:23And me and Jim Kudall and Michael Lop and a few other people went to dinner at a steakhouse.

0:50:35And as we were leaving, we were like waiting in the entry area, you know, like the sort

0:50:41of foyer of the restaurant to leave.

0:50:45And we saw by him standing by himself waiting, I guess, to go in.

0:50:49It seemed it very soon seemed like he was waiting to meet his party.

0:50:53We saw Michael Dell.

0:50:54And it was like, Holy shit, that's Michael Dell.

0:50:56You know, there's a billionaire.

0:50:58And he was on his phone.

0:50:59And I don't know what kind of phone he was using.

0:51:02But the thought just popped into my head.

0:51:04He's a billionaire.

0:51:05I have a better phone than he does.

0:51:09It was such a weird thought.

0:51:10It was like, holy shit, there's Michael Dell.

0:51:13Wow.

0:51:14And then because he was on his phone

0:51:16and it was clearly some sort of-- I don't know if it was--

0:51:21Not an iPhone.

0:51:22Yeah, it was not an iPhone.

0:51:24And I realized because it was not an iPhone, whatever it was,

0:51:26he's a billionaire, but I have a better phone than he does.

0:51:30And it was such a weird thought.

0:51:32And it is that sort of egalitarian thing.

0:51:35If you take the edition out of the Apple Watch lineup

0:51:38and just look at what they have without the edition,

0:51:41it makes total sense to me as an Apple product,

0:51:44where it ranges from $299 to-- I think the most expensive

0:51:49is the Hermes cuff, which is-- I'm looking-- $1,500.

0:51:55And take the cuff out, and I think

0:51:57it's like $1,250 for one of the Hermes models.

0:52:01And that makes total sense.

0:52:02The cheapest stainless steel is like 450 or something. Yeah, and

0:52:05Apple has always had kind of two levels in their lineups, right?

0:52:07They have the low end and the high end like and yeah, it does

0:52:10make much more sense.

0:52:11But I really do think one of the fascinating you know that the

0:52:14whole like hand some of the hand wringing. I think the idea that

0:52:18the addition is folly and it's a sign that the company is

0:52:22distracted has merit. I think that the hand wringing over the

0:52:26difference between the sport aluminum sport models and the

0:52:30stainless steel models though is misguided because to me the range is

0:52:37reasonable but it's also fascinating to me that to me at a at a at a functional

0:52:43level the sport models are actually better because the taptic engine works

0:52:47better the one thing that the stainless steel models have that the sport don't

0:52:51that is functionally better is that the the sapphire cover for the display truly

0:52:59is scratch proof. Like mine.

0:53:02I think and I think that I still think they look better too.

0:53:04They do look better. I think so too. I do. But at a every other

0:53:09functional level, because the the Taptic engine works better

0:53:12that the sport models is actually a you know, it's

0:53:15superior. And and so in terms of like the speed of the CPU and

0:53:20the resolution of the display, etc, etc. It's all the same. It's

0:53:23exactly the same. You don't get you spend the extra money and

0:53:27all you're getting is the what you can touch that the materials are better.

0:53:31So two observations. One,

0:53:35it's interesting that all the Hermes models are always stainless steel.

0:53:40There's no edition. And two, I've been clicking around this site for the last five

0:53:43minutes. I cannot find the edition anywhere.

0:53:45I honestly cannot find it on the website. Yeah, it's down the memory hole.

0:53:49It's actually,

0:53:49since I brought it up, it's actually been emphasized even less.

0:53:54No, I... oh there it is, watch edition. You could only find it in the buy tab.

0:53:59In all the product marketing tabs, it's non-existent. It's completely not really gone.

0:54:04Right, and that makes me think, I would place a bet here today, May 5th,

0:54:11that when we see Apple Watch 2.0, there is no edition model.

0:54:15That it's sport, and I don't know, maybe they'll come up with a new name, but it's stainless steel and aluminum.

0:54:21I think the addition thing is gone. And I know for a fact, I have heard from

0:54:27numerous, at least several, I wouldn't say numerous, but several people within Apple

0:54:31that there was significant debate within the company

0:54:35at high levels as to whether addition should be a thing or not.

0:54:40And that it was Johnny Ive and

0:54:43you know, anybody who's under him, maybe, you know,

0:54:46almost certainly Mark Newsome who pushed for it and that there were others within

0:54:53the company who were like this is you know this is not a good idea you know

0:54:56but it was more or less a Johnny Ive idea and that I think that oh I mean

0:55:02obviously ultimately it came down to Tim Cook and I think ultimately and I don't

0:55:07know this this isn't you know that the people who I've talked to don't you know

0:55:11aren't the sort of people who would know what Tim Cook was thinking but my

0:55:16My guess is that it wasn't so much that Tim Cook thought it was a good idea in and of itself,

0:55:22but that Tim Cook wanted to make Johnny happy.

0:55:25And that making Johnny happy was doing this addition thing.

0:55:29And there's something so telling about that, and whether or not it may be right,

0:55:35but is this idea that Apple is, at the very top of the company, still ruled by consensus.

0:55:44And the power of Apple's organizational structure, which I wrote about, is the way it kind of forces collaboration.

0:55:50And groups have to depend on each other, and there is no dictator.

0:55:54But that worked in part.

0:55:55A lot of Apple's organization was Steve Jobs wanting to make an Apple that could be his instrument that he could play, right?

0:56:04Like, that would do his bidding.

0:56:06And like, there's the counterweight of the dictator at the top.

0:56:09That's...

0:56:10The way I framed it is editor.

0:56:12And actually, I think they still use it at Apple University.

0:56:16Like I came up with it back then.

0:56:18Like the best way to think about what Jobs does at Apple is he's the editor,

0:56:21or what did at Apple was he's the editor in chief.

0:56:24Like he didn't write the copy.

0:56:27He didn't do the things.

0:56:29He may have tweaked a headline to make it that much more gripping.

0:56:33And he said, no, and he cut stuff and he pushed stuff forward and he said,

0:56:38oh, well, you should go work on this sort of thing.

0:56:41And for all the good things that Tim Cook has done

0:56:46and all the things that he's good at,

0:56:48and to his credit, he knows he's not that person.

0:56:51He's not a product person.

0:56:52So I think he's empowered Johnny for sure.

0:56:55But Johnny has a distinct set of skills that are not,

0:57:00I don't think, as broad as jobs were.

0:57:02And I don't know that he has the connection to

0:57:08and the empathy for the kind of common man,

0:57:12and you see this, I think,

0:57:13in some of the design decisions as well,

0:57:14particularly when it comes to the user interface,

0:57:17that that job is it either.

0:57:18And you always hate to break out the,

0:57:22they miss Steve sort of thing,

0:57:25but when it comes to the watch

0:57:27and it comes to having the addition,

0:57:28it comes to having these apps that were underpowered

0:57:31and this watch kit idea, which was a disaster.

0:57:33Like the watch should have,

0:57:35if the watch was nothing but the display

0:57:37and notifications, like one, it would be a great experience. Two, what's the criticism?

0:57:43Oh, it doesn't have apps. Let's do that. Let's do that. But implicit in that criticism is,

0:57:47oh, but of course they're coming soon, right? Oh, the iPhone watch has all the apps too,

0:57:51right? And it's such a different framing about the watch. It's a framing of it's not what it

0:57:57is now, but it has the potential to be like, it's great now, but it's going to be even better

0:58:02as opposed to it kind of sucks now and it might be better in the future. Like just the tone of

0:58:07that is so fundamentally different?

0:58:10We've, you know, this is, it's not just me, you know, but I feel like

0:58:16there's been a research, I think it's sort of the roughly one,

0:58:20you know, the watch's one year old has sort of brought out a lot of,

0:58:25you know, big picture, hey, let's take a, let's re-look at

0:58:29Apple Watch commentary. And, you know, I've certainly written a lot

0:58:35more about it recently than I had for a while.

0:58:39And I'm with you.

0:58:42I really do think at a fundamental level

0:58:45that shipping with an SDK in an app store was a mistake.

0:58:49Or maybe not an SDK, but that the SDK

0:58:51should not have been about quote unquote apps.

0:58:53It should have been an SDK

0:58:54for empowering smart notifications, right?

0:58:58- Or the key stuff, right?

0:59:00- The what?

0:59:02- The key stuff, like being the key to your wife.

0:59:04- Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

0:59:06I see what you mean.

0:59:07I somehow thought you were talking about

0:59:08like a keyboard or something.

0:59:10Yeah.

0:59:11(laughing)

0:59:12But yeah, like the way that there are apps,

0:59:14like I have this great app.

0:59:17I use it, I've long used this great app

0:59:19on the iPhone called Do, D-U-E.

0:59:21That is a, to me it's way better than,

0:59:26it's a way to set reminders,

0:59:30either one-time reminders like,

0:59:32go pick up the dry cleaning on Friday at five o'clock.

0:59:36Or repeating reminders, like every Wednesday at 10 o'clock,

0:59:40I have a do reminder that tells me to take the trash out.

0:59:43That works better for me than either putting them

0:59:48on my calendar or using the clock app or something like that

0:59:53'cause they're out of the way.

0:59:54I don't want these things, I don't want my calendar

0:59:57to say take out the trash every day at 10 o'clock.

0:59:59I want my calendar to just tell me things

1:00:01that are actually novel.

1:00:03So Do is a great app for that.

1:00:05And the watch integration with Do is great,

1:00:08but 'cause it lets me do things like you can,

1:00:11Do lets you snooze things,

1:00:15and so you can snooze by like one hour,

1:00:19three hours, or a whole day.

1:00:22And they're just buttons,

1:00:23so you just scroll down on the Apple Watch

1:00:25and it'll be like, you know,

1:00:26mark it as done because you've done it,

1:00:28snooze for an hour, three hours a day. Great. And it's a total like

1:00:33notification. It's not really an app. It doesn't launch an app. It's just that the

1:00:37notification is smart in that way. So that sort of SDK, definitely the Apple

1:00:41Watch. It's integral for what the Apple Watch is actually good for. So I

1:00:47don't want to say no SDK, but definitely it should not. I really feel firmly that

1:00:51it should not have apps because the apps are such a bad experience. Every

1:00:54aspect of it from the beginning to the end. From actually just launching the app on that

1:01:00Honeycomb screen all the way to the end of using the app is a bad experience and I really

1:01:06think it shouldn't have had it.

1:01:08And in a way to take this kind of full circle, the problem with Do is you can't integrate

1:01:15it with Siri. Right?

1:01:16Yeah. Yeah.

1:01:17Like, which is, Siri, one of the things I do use Siri for regularly is to do reminder

1:01:22things, particularly when I'm driving. I always think of it as when I'm driving,

1:01:25and I find it very helpful then. But we're what, five years on now? Yeah, five years

1:01:31on and there is no SDK for Siri. And meanwhile, you have Amazon, to go the Echo thing, where

1:01:39the SDK is spreading like wildfire. And in some respects, it gets this whole tension.

1:01:47Is the Amazon kind of vernacular more limited? Yes, you have to kind of train yourself and

1:01:52you have to use the right language, right?

1:01:53But that also imparts a degree of flexibility

1:01:58and experimentation and easy to plug into-ness

1:02:02that really works to its credit.

1:02:04And you know, Apple's trying to perfect

1:02:06this natural language interface

1:02:07and have an assistant that makes jokes to you

1:02:11that make you want to throw your phone in the ocean

1:02:14when it makes a joke because it just misinterpreted

1:02:16what you said four times in a row.

1:02:18And it's just like--

1:02:20- Hold that, you know, let's stop, stop.

1:02:22I want to get on the recycle stop stop. I was getting worked up

1:02:27All right, okay, I'm gonna scotch do it do an ad I need to go

1:02:32I need to go get another floor

1:02:33Let's unwork you up and talk about one of my favorite longtime sponsors of the show is automatic

1:02:40Automatic is the connected car company that improves your driving and integrates your car into your digital life

1:02:48You want to go to automatic comm slash the talk show and use the code the talk show you'll get a 20% off your purchase

1:02:54What is it? It's it's this little dingus that it's like almost like a USB stick and

1:03:00Every car made since I think like 1996 1997

1:03:06it goes back a while has this same standard diagnostic port and

1:03:10automatic comm they'll help you find it on your car, but in other words, it's like when your car says like

1:03:18service get service code a4 or something like that and you don't know what that

1:03:23means well it when you go to the the mechanic you go to the the car service

1:03:30place they plug into this diagnostic port and that's where they figure out

1:03:34what it is that the car actually needs automatic you can plug you plug

1:03:37automatic into this exact same port and it reads all that stuff and it gets

1:03:43it's every single car it's really this it's I had no idea until they started sponsoring

1:03:48the show that this port existed and that it was cross platform across all makes and models

1:03:53of cars. It tells you everything it needs to know it knows it can it can tell you things

1:03:58about your fuel economy. It can tell you exactly when there is an error or some sort of services

1:04:04do exactly what service that means. So you can know like, hey, this is actually important.

1:04:09You better go get service right away. Or this is the sort of thing like, yeah, I better

1:04:13get this looked at soon but I can wait a week or two if I need to. But it tells you all

1:04:19sorts of things. It tells you whether the way that you're driving is maximizing your

1:04:22fuel efficiency or not. And they have what they call an app store and it lets you integrate

1:04:32your car and your driving with all sorts of things. It really is the internet of things

1:04:40that Connected Life brought real because you can integrate with things like Nest,

1:04:44your mechanic, FreshBooks and more. So you could do things like you can set it up. I mean this

1:04:52really is like the future made real. You can have things like once you're within x miles of your

1:04:59house have your Nest thermostat change the temperature in your house. You know in this

1:05:06right now it's May so we're heading more towards air conditioning. So you turn on the

1:05:10the air conditioning and lower the temperature in the winter you can have it turn on the

1:05:13heat and raise the temperature.

1:05:16Really it works, it is amazing and it even works with IFTTT, if this then that, which

1:05:24literally makes almost unlimited possibilities of the ways that you can integrate this with

1:05:29your life.

1:05:33It is useful and it is, trust me, it is actually fun.

1:05:37is really cool to have a car that can do stuff like this.

1:05:40And just to get that information,

1:05:42even if it didn't integrate with other devices

1:05:45or something like that, it's actually really cool

1:05:48just to get the information.

1:05:49It's totally private, automatic, doesn't sell your data.

1:05:54All they want you to do is just buy the gadget.

1:05:57And there's no monthly fees, no subscription.

1:06:00So normally, the automatic dingus is $99.

1:06:05But with you go through this URL, go to automatic.com slash

1:06:10the talk show and remember the code, the talk show and you'll

1:06:13save 20% that's 20 bucks. So for just 80 bucks, you can get this

1:06:18thing that makes your car the car you already have. way cooler.

1:06:23So go to automatic comm slash the talk show and buy this

1:06:26thing. Trust me. I don't think there's ever been anybody who's

1:06:30done this who's bought this automatic and who regrets it.

1:06:32It's totally cool.

1:06:34One of my favorite sponsors, so my thanks to them.

1:06:37- So you got your license back?

1:06:40- Yeah, well, I drive without a license.

1:06:43I've been lucky.

1:06:44- You know the vast majority of your listeners, I think,

1:06:47still don't think you have a license.

1:06:48(both laughing)

1:06:51Sorry, that's an ancient joke at this point, I think.

1:06:55- Well, the longtime listeners will enjoy it.

1:07:01What happened is I lost my license a few years ago for driving too fast.

1:07:08Allegedly.

1:07:13It adds to the myth.

1:07:14Let's talk about Apple's quarter before we get too far.

1:07:20So Apple ten days ago or so announced their January to March quarter, which is for them

1:07:29in their calendar year, Q2.

1:07:33And it was bad for Apple because insofar

1:07:38as it was the first time in 13 years

1:07:41that they had a year-over-year decline in revenue and profit,

1:07:47which is an extraordinary streak.

1:07:50But obviously, even if you subscribe to the--

1:07:55had to happen eventually, which I think is totally true.

1:07:58impossible for a streak like that to go in forever. It's extraordinary. It's an

1:08:05extraordinary run, but you know, it obviously, even if it was inevitable, it

1:08:10can't be seen as anything other than bad news. Well, it's okay. So it was expected

1:08:20in some respects, and actually last quarter, in the first quarter,

1:08:25where people were kind of banging them, I was still pretty optimistic and I thought it was a pretty good quarter.

1:08:30And my contention was actually the same thing that you just wrote last week,

1:08:36was that, well, if you, I charted out, if you took their results from 2008 to 2014,

1:08:42and you took it on an annual basis because, you know, they shifted when the iPhone was sold,

1:08:47was launched and they, like there's lots of, you couldn't do it on a quarter by quarter basis because stuff has changed.

1:08:54But if you put that on a graph and then forecasted forward what the expectations would have been

1:09:01for 2015 and 2016, they were actually right on track.

1:09:07And they were growing nicely.

1:09:08It just happened they picked up like a free 50 million users in 2015.

1:09:15Let's take a step back though and just emphasize that what we're talking about here is that

1:09:20two-thirds of Apple's revenue comes from the iPhone. Fundamentally, right now, and

1:09:25for the foreseeable future, as the iPhone goes, so goes Apple as a whole. And what I

1:09:32was… the graph you're talking about was specifically… it wasn't about Apple as

1:09:34a whole, it was specifically iPhone sales.

1:09:36Right, exactly. Yeah, no, you're right. I'm talking about iPhone sales. And just

1:09:40to be clear…

1:09:41It's two-thirds. It's two-thirds. It's just… it's just an enormous… as big

1:09:46as iPad and Mac and services and watch and everything else Apple does, which would still

1:09:52leave them as an enormous and arguably, it might even still be the most, what's one third,

1:10:00yeah, they'd still be close to the most profitable company in tech, or at least they'd be in

1:10:05the ballpark. Without the iPhone.

1:10:07Without the profits, because the iPhone is also, the iPhone has significantly higher

1:10:10margins in other products as well. So it's a two thirds of revenue, but it's like three

1:10:15quarters of profit. So it's, yeah, absolutely.

1:10:18But so fundamentally though, as goes the iPhone, so goes Apple. And it's the decline in iPhone

1:10:24sales correlates directly to the decline in everything else.

1:10:27Right, right. And so I came out of the first quarter pretty optimistic. And then this quarter

1:10:34came along and I frankly completely changed my view. Like I think that we got a lot more

1:10:41information this quarter about lots of things that frankly discredited a lot of the things

1:10:48that Apple itself told us in previous quarters and cast a lot of doubt on the iPhone. And

1:10:56I actually think that the situation is worse than you wrote last week, for example. I think

1:11:03there is genuine reason for concern. And just to be super duper clear, the iPhone's not

1:11:08going anywhere. Like this is a discussion about like the growth prospects of the iPhone,

1:11:14which to your point are about the growth prospects of Apple, which by extension are about the

1:11:19stock. The stock is about the future growth opportunities. The stock is not, it's not

1:11:22a scorecard. It's not, it's not a scoreboard, but we've done in the past. And I now have

1:11:29very serious, like I wrote a thing this week in the daily update, like I kind of went through

1:11:33Like one, there's a data point that is different than I thought it was and there are three assumptions that I had about the iPhone business

1:11:41Before that I have now changed my assumptions about and that makes and as a whole it makes me much more bearish

1:11:47There's an interesting point and you're the one who pointed it out to me not not publicly

1:11:51I don't think until now on this show

1:11:52but and when I wrote I took the the the stands last week in my the written piece that

1:11:58on daring fireball that

1:12:02What Apple announced for q2 was exactly what they had forecast in q1 and therefore

1:12:08whether you think this is

1:12:10However bad or okay you think this is it shouldn't have resulted in a jolt in the stock

1:12:17But the stock jolted badly downward

1:12:20Six or seven percent which was for Apple is about like it was something like forty billion dollars in market cap just poof and

1:12:30And you pointed out that that's not true. Like for Q2, yes, they were what they announced was exactly within the guidance from three months ago, but you pointed out and I completely missed this, that the the part that was the surprise or was unexpected, or quite frankly, contrary to what Apple had said before, was what they're now guiding for Q3, which is that Q3, this current quarter, April

1:12:59to June is actually going to be the worst of it. And where that's contrary, and people,

1:13:05you know, and I've, I think I tweeted about it, I didn't write about it on During Fire

1:13:09Bulbs, people are like, no, they'd never guide more than one quarter in advance. So they,

1:13:14you know, that's not true that they that they misguided on Q3. But they did indirectly because

1:13:20they said, in January, and their quarterly results, we think that this upcoming Q2 will

1:13:26be the worst. And now they're saying, actually Q3 is going to be the worst. And that's a

1:13:34huge thing. That is significant and it's worrisome.

1:13:42It's worse in two ways. So the next Q core is going to be worse. The first reason is

1:13:47going to be worse is they're basically saying they're going to run down inventory to the

1:13:52tune of two billion dollars. And what that means, and they're contrary to what people,

1:13:58there's kind of a thing a few years ago about ship versus sold. Apple and every other manufacturer

1:14:02calculates based on ships, not on sold, because it's just impossible for them to know, except

1:14:08for Apple stores, which only sell actually a relatively small fraction of iPhones. There's

1:14:12no way for them to know when it's sold. And so it is calculated on ship versus sold. And

1:14:16if you look at their financial reports, you can see like their inventory and what's in

1:14:20the channel, that sort of stuff. And basically over the last two quarters, they've been significantly

1:14:26increasing inventory. The only reason they were up in the first quarter was because they

1:14:32ran up inventory. And the only reason they met their guidance in the second quarter was

1:14:37because of the inventory thing as well. And so and so now they're saying, oh, a third

1:14:41quarter, we're gonna have to run this inventory down. So we're there, they guided way lower,

1:14:45the advantages, they're going to meet their guidance again, right. But had they played

1:14:49the inventory game fairly, for lack of a better word, they would have missed last quarter,

1:14:56and they would have missed in the first quarter as well. So one, if they were running their

1:15:03business as they've traditionally run it, this would actually be the second miss in

1:15:08a row, instead of being the second barely making guidance. So that's one.

1:15:13But then two, and so you can say--

1:15:14- And it's easy, I would just back up,

1:15:16keep your number two, but I would just back up

1:15:18and say that Apple, in the Tim Cook era,

1:15:21and that's not just Tim Cook as CEO, but COO,

1:15:25they're so operationally efficient

1:15:27that the ship versus sold thing was easy

1:15:30for us Apple people to mock other makers for,

1:15:33because with Apple, for any device,

1:15:37has largely been irrelevant,

1:15:39because they're so operationally efficient

1:15:41that what they ship is what they sell.

1:15:43- Exactly, so it was actually a fair criticism,

1:15:45even if like on a technical basis it wasn't quite right.

1:15:49Like the implication of the criticism

1:15:50was actually totally fair, you're exactly right.

1:15:52- They tend to keep inventory so low

1:15:54in that they really do, you know,

1:15:56whatever they make is what they're selling.

1:15:58You know, and they make what they sell

1:15:59and they sell what they make.

1:16:00But in this case, they've obviously made,

1:16:04you know, they got ahead of themselves in manufacturing.

1:16:07- They did, and so one, the Q3 is gonna be worse

1:16:12because of the two billion.

1:16:13But here's what's really concerning.

1:16:16Even if you take out that two billion,

1:16:18the Q3 is still going to be worse.

1:16:22Which means like when they said that,

1:16:23and they said that at the end of January,

1:16:26which means they're a month into the current quarter,

1:16:29they said that, "Oh, we think the next quarter

1:16:30"is gonna be the worst quarter."

1:16:32And it turns out like they were wrong.

1:16:35Like they don't know what's happening

1:16:39with the iPhone, frankly.

1:16:40right you haven't seen apple bid be this

1:16:44on accurate

1:16:46and

1:16:47uh...

1:16:47ended that's just this quarter i mean that will buy a pool

1:16:51we can get to their earnings calls last year which are actually

1:16:54for me personally are even more

1:16:56concerning some respects

1:16:58yeah you wrote about that recently

1:17:00i did it in the in that

1:17:03like so i'd

1:17:04so i'd i'd like to know if i face let me paraphrase maybe i can do a better job

1:17:08paraphrasing then

1:17:09you can because you wrote the piece but paraphrasing and you can correct me or

1:17:14clarify but basically zoom out big picture what we're seeing is that the

1:17:21iphone 6 last year was a not an anomaly in terms of its popularity it was off

1:17:28the curve and I think I think that the reason was twofold I think it was that

1:17:36that that was when they hit, what's the carrier in China?

1:17:40- China Mobile.

1:17:41- China Mobile.

1:17:42And it was pent up demand for larger iPhones.

1:17:48And with the long rumors, you know, the year long rumor

1:17:53that hey, Apple's next iPhone is actually gonna be have,

1:17:55they're gonna have a bigger screen version.

1:17:57And anybody who was maybe leaning towards upgrading

1:18:01or getting an iPhone was like, well,

1:18:03I'll wait for that bigger screen one

1:18:05I want a bigger screen and that there was so much pent-up demand for that that it that it

1:18:09was an anomalously

1:18:12Popular

1:18:15But if you look back a year at what Tim Cook said on quarterly these quarterly and analyst calls

1:18:23He downplayed that it was you know

1:18:26He more or less made it sound as though this is what he expected and that this was the growth that they you know

1:18:31This was organic growth. It wasn't anomalous growth

1:18:35Exactly. He was pressed on every single... So on the first two earnings call, he volunteered that,

1:18:41"Oh, there's tons of people that haven't upgraded yet. We have tons of greenfield." And by the Q3

1:18:46and Q4, the analysts were getting a little skeptical of this, especially Tony Sacc and

1:18:50Agua, who asked really good questions every call, and he's been a great skeptic all along.

1:18:55And he was pressing Cook on this, like, "Look, are you sure that you're not just the delayed 5S

1:19:04upgrades but also pulling forward upgrades where people were upgrading early just because

1:19:07they wanted to get the big screen phone. He's like, "Are you sure that..." Tim Cook, four

1:19:13times in a row, and I quoted all four times in my update, he said, "Oh no, we think there's

1:19:18tons of opportunity here. Only this fraction is upgraded, blah, blah, blah, blah." And

1:19:25the reason, I'm personally frustrated. I know we've talked to this one-on-one. The only

1:19:32thing worse than being wrong is letting something that you said that was wrong like persist

1:19:35out there. And so like you want to correct it and make clear what it is. And I wrote

1:19:38a piece last fall like saying stop doubting the iPhone. And one of my core things was

1:19:43that this upgrade point because I believed Cook. I believed him when he said that we're

1:19:49not seeing an upgrade rate out of the ordinary and there's a ton of opportunity. And for

1:19:53him to come back on this call and to say, "Oh, well, there was a massive upgrade cycle

1:19:57last year and obviously as you would expect to be slower this year it was i

1:20:01mean

1:20:02i don't know the right word for it because

1:20:05it's in the record he'd he's changed his tune and in tony

1:20:11call them out on the call and cook actually got a little annoyed had it

1:20:14which was in really interesting because tony had him dead to rights because he

1:20:18was the same when i was asking the questions last year uh... and

1:20:22i i i don't think cook was reading on purpose i i i because that would be

1:20:25stupid. It'd be stupid for fusions. One, because you get in trouble. Two, because

1:20:30if Cook did it on purpose, he was setting Apple up for a fall. Like,

1:20:34Apple's... no one... people in the investment community don't believe Tim Cook right

1:20:40now. Like, because he's changed exactly what he's saying, and so he's hurt his

1:20:46credibility. I just kind of think that Apple didn't know. Like, they

1:20:52They didn't really do the research on upgrades,

1:20:55and I suspect before this quarter's called,

1:20:58like, how do we explain this?

1:20:59And they sent some intern to figure out

1:21:01what are the upgrade rates in previous cycles,

1:21:03how does that compare to this cycle?

1:21:05And they're like, oh crap,

1:21:06we were saying the wrong thing last year.

1:21:08Actually, we're wildly out of the ordinary,

1:21:10and we have much slower upgrade rates as a result this year.

1:21:13And that's how that kind of played out.

1:21:16- Yeah.

1:21:20I think you called it out in one of your daily updates

1:21:23was that it was, how do you pronounce his name?

1:21:27Tony Sacanale or something.

1:21:31I was so annoyed because I was listening to the call

1:21:33because I sleep through it during the night here.

1:21:37And so I woke up and as soon as Cook said that,

1:21:39like my radar went up because I remembered him saying that.

1:21:41- Cook said was I don't recall saying anything.

1:21:43- No, before that, no, 'cause Cook,

1:21:45in Cook's opening remarks, he said,

1:21:48"Oh, this upgrade cycle, blah, blah, blah."

1:21:49in a meal like that's the key my daily update i'm gonna nail him on his point

1:21:53because

1:21:53uh... that's wrong and it totally asked the question like damn you tony you just

1:21:58all night under

1:21:59right so

1:22:01twofold

1:22:02basically and again if i'm summarizing this wrong

1:22:07tell me but

1:22:08twofold

1:22:08one

1:22:09it seems like apple misinterpreted a year ago apple misinterpreted the

1:22:14successes success or six is success the iphone the original iphone six and six

1:22:18plus. It misinterpreted their success as being part of the growth of iPhone in general, as

1:22:30opposed to being exceptional, out of line with the expected growth. They thought, "Hey,

1:22:36this is part of the growth curve," but the truth was it was outside the growth curve.

1:22:42missed that and then this year they're clearly overestimated the success I

1:22:48think basically for the same reasons that because they thought the six was

1:22:53normal they thought the success was going to continue on that path and it

1:22:56did not well I think they knew the six was out of whack but I think they

1:23:02attributed it mostly to being them acquiring new customers as opposed to

1:23:05pulled for do as opposed to pull forward upgrades one thing that's really

1:23:10interesting and this is this is if you want to have a bull case for Apple today

1:23:14this is probably the one to take is if you invert 2015 and 2016 that linear

1:23:22line I talked about actually continues why because right now Apple's probably

1:23:26going to come in with about 200 million iPhones but 210 million or so for

1:23:31fiscal year 2016 and and this is another thing that that that changed Apple

1:23:36People didn't say, but they hinted that 2016 would be about the same as 2015.

1:23:412015 was 230 million.

1:23:42And so it seemed like, oh, they have this nice boost along the way.

1:23:45But that's clearly not happening, one.

1:23:47But two, if you invert that and you pretend that 2015 was 205 million and 2016 was 230

1:23:55million, that actual, that line is almost perfectly linear, like it's an R squared

1:24:00of 0.98, like it's incredibly straight on.

1:24:03And you could say, "Oh, they just got all the 216 buyers, just all bought a year early,

1:24:10and 2017 is going to revert back to normal."

1:24:12Like if that is, I think, the bull case to make for 2017 and the iPhone 7, I don't buy

1:24:22it, but that is the bull case.

1:24:24And I can tell you why I don't buy it if you don't want it.

1:24:29Well tell me, tell me why you don't buy it.

1:24:31I don't think so either.

1:24:32- The reason, the reason why I don't buy it.

1:24:34- Let me, let me, let me--

1:24:35- Oh, you go first, you go first.

1:24:36- I think that the extraordinary growth of the iPhone

1:24:40was fueled by adding new carriers around the world.

1:24:45And they've already added most of the carriers.

1:24:50There's no big pickings left.

1:24:53And then-- - Yep, that's 100 it.

1:24:56That's 100% it.

1:24:57Like, they, they, they, like,

1:24:59I actually tried to research this and I spent,

1:25:01I remember I spent days on this,

1:25:03and it was so hard to figure out.

1:25:04I need to hire an intern too to try to figure this out

1:25:06and try to measure when they went into new carriers

1:25:10in new countries and how that contributed iPhone growth.

1:25:13But one thing that was always so striking about Apple

1:25:15for years is how accurate their forecasts were, right?

1:25:18They would miss on the high side,

1:25:19but they'd miss on the high side

1:25:20by the exact same percentage every single time, right?

1:25:22It was uncanny.

1:25:23And then they said, "Oh, from now on,

1:25:25"we're actually gonna make sure we're more concerned,

1:25:27"or we're gonna make our guidance actually accurate."

1:25:29and then they were accurate by the exact same amount every time and i wonder how

1:25:33much of that was they knew which carriers were coming online in new which

1:25:36countries are coming online and they knew because they've done this bunch of

1:25:39times we're gonna get this carrier has has has the certain number of customers

1:25:43we get a certain percent of those customers we know that's gonna happen

1:25:46and actually built this in the contract right cares had to had to guarantee a

1:25:50certain number of subscribers

1:25:53and so they

1:25:54it's a huge factor in i phone growth was just increasing the available market of

1:25:58the iPhone and once you got the last one the left like that in there was Verizon

1:26:04there's NT Docomo been a bunch of small ones in general but the last the big one

1:26:08was China Mobile and China Mobile came on in 2014 and then the iPhone 6 launched

1:26:13and and that was the last one and now that is gone and the question for growth

1:26:21for the iPhone 7 is not just getting people to upgrade because there's lots

1:26:25of evidence that that's extending and we talked about that as well but where is

1:26:28the new users going to come from right yes people are switching i i do think

1:26:32they're switching and i think the iphone will get growth from switchers

1:26:35but that's countered by

1:26:38upgrade cycle being allen gated for two reasons one

1:26:41iphones are just getting better and better

1:26:44and to

1:26:45the bigger apple gets the more they get away

1:26:49they more they get into like the mainstream people that just aren't that

1:26:51concerned with performance like us geeks are gonna upgrade all the time but but

1:26:56the farther away they get from us

1:26:59the less likely it is that they're going to upgrade

1:27:02and you combine that with with carriers moving to these these plans where

1:27:05once your phone's paid off your bill actually goes down

1:27:08like there's

1:27:09i'm skeptical where the news is going to come from

1:27:13it's

1:27:14it's crazy if you think about it i mean it was only january twenty eleven

1:27:18i mean that's four years into the iphone

1:27:21that it was available on a second carrier in the u_s_ switches verizon

1:27:25I mean, it took a long time to spread.

1:27:28You know, there was so much potential.

1:27:33And if you look at the absolutely explosive growth,

1:27:37I mean, I forget which iPhone,

1:27:39but it was well into the iPhone 4 era,

1:27:41maybe even the 4S, where--

1:27:43- It was the 4S that was like, blew everyone's mind.

1:27:45- But it wasn't just that each iPhone

1:27:48outsold its predecessor,

1:27:50it was that each iPhone outsold

1:27:52all of its predecessors combined.

1:27:54- Right, right.

1:27:55Well into like the fourth, fifth, maybe even the sixth iPhone generation

1:28:01outsold all of the previous iPhones combined and the one before it outsold all of its previous ones combined.

1:28:09The slope on the growth curve, it's just phenomenal. It's almost incomprehensible, but it was fueled largely by

1:28:18Yes, lots and lots of people wanted iPhones

1:28:21once they, you know, a year or two in and they understood what it was,

1:28:25but they couldn't get it, or thought they couldn't get it because they didn't want to switch carriers.

1:28:29Or it wasn't, or it literally wasn't even available in their country yet.

1:28:32On any carrier, even if they were willing to switch.

1:28:35And

1:28:38this is such a danger zone for companies where you kinda

1:28:42mis-

1:28:42attribute your success, and the iPhone just grew for so long,

1:28:46and it's easy for even someone as smart as Tim Cook and his executive team

1:28:51team to just assume that's going to go on forever and to discount like structural changes

1:28:57in the market where you're changing, like if the iPhone will always have X percent of

1:29:02the market, there's two functions, like you can either increase the percentage of the

1:29:07market or you can change the market size. And for years, Apple was changing the market

1:29:13size slowly and steadily. And in some respects, that's why you could argue that's why the

1:29:18growth went on for so long unlike someone like Samsung. Samsung's great

1:29:21strength has always been they're on every single carrier in every single

1:29:25market and they have this massive distribution network and that's

1:29:30why they just came out of nowhere to dominate Android because they had this

1:29:33network built in. Right and if like they come and they're like they come to

1:29:36Verizon and they're like we want you to carry this and Verizon says something

1:29:40like okay we'll do it but we want to put our own custom skin on the UI Samsung

1:29:45Sam's like, "Go ahead."

1:29:46Sam's like, "You got it, chief."

1:29:50It's like they just stick out their hand for the handshake.

1:29:52You got it.

1:29:55People diss them, especially in Apple world, but there's something admirable about that.

1:29:59It's a totally valid strategy.

1:30:01And people, of course, kind of came crashing down to earth, which was predictable, but

1:30:08don't discount the fact they made billions and billions and billions of dollars along

1:30:12the way.

1:30:13Right.

1:30:14I agree.

1:30:16I do.

1:30:17And to me, there is something-- there's obviously

1:30:20something different about Samsung compared

1:30:23to all the other Android handset makers in the way

1:30:25that in a normal market, all those very--

1:30:35or let's just take Samsung out.

1:30:37Take Samsung out, and all of a sudden,

1:30:38the entire Android market is more or less indistinguishable.

1:30:42I mean there's, you know, obviously some sell more than others, but there's really no standout

1:30:46manufacturer. Samsung is a standout manufacturer though. And it's, you know, there's something

1:30:55there. And it's not so much that their devices are, the devices don't speak for themselves.

1:31:02It's something that they do strategically.

1:31:06Right because there's ways to compete other than the product. Apple has chosen to compete

1:31:10on the product. So I think people in the Apple world kind of trigger on that, but you can

1:31:17compete through distribution, you can compete through marketing, there's lots of places

1:31:21to compete. And Amazon, yeah, they were available to everyone. And particularly when everyone

1:31:27like, the classic example is actually Motorola with the Droid phone, but that's an example

1:31:33of what Samsung did worldwide, where Verizon was like, "We're bleeding customers because

1:31:39"We don't have the iPhone.

1:31:40"Like, we need an alternative."

1:31:42And like, and some of Motorola's best years were like,

1:31:46was like that year when the Droid,

1:31:49and there's the commercials everywhere,

1:31:50because they just needed an alternative.

1:31:52And Samsung filled that role all over the world.

1:31:55- Right.

1:31:56Before we leave the topic of iPhone,

1:32:00let's talk about the S strategy.

1:32:04And I don't wanna put words in your mouth,

1:32:07but I think you're questioning whether the S strategy

1:32:10can continue, which is, to put it another way,

1:32:13the TikTok strategy of, here's a new form factor,

1:32:18the iPhone, let's just call it the iPhone 7,

1:32:21and a year later, here's the same form factor,

1:32:25but with a whole bunch of new stuff inside the iPhone 7S.

1:32:29Then the iPhone 8, then the iPhone 8S,

1:32:31then the iPhone 9, iPhone 9S.

1:32:34And that's put aside whether any of us think

1:32:37that Apple is gonna keep numbering the iPhones,

1:32:41but this whole one year is a new form factor,

1:32:44the next year is the same form factor with an S.

1:32:47You question whether they should continue with that, correct?

1:32:52- Absolutely, yeah, no, absolutely.

1:32:55And I think one of the challenges with technology in general,

1:32:58we've seen this with PCs, we've seen this with iPads,

1:33:00is that at some point it just gets,

1:33:03it's good enough for the majority of people.

1:33:05and whatever, like the 6S is a big jump over the 6

1:33:10in many respects, but it's a big jump

1:33:12that doesn't really make a big difference

1:33:13in the way people use their phones day to day,

1:33:15at least the majority of people.

1:33:17But something that's so powerful about the iPhone

1:33:21and has made it such an iconic device,

1:33:23has made it such a profitable device,

1:33:24and in the U.S. to a degree,

1:33:26but particularly in places like China,

1:33:28is the status of it.

1:33:30Like it is the, we talked about the beginning,

1:33:32it's the best phone, and it means something

1:33:34that you carry it. And there is no way this is why I think they've they've introduced

1:33:40the new colors on the S models, because that can show you have the newest model. But I

1:33:46think they like if they want to push growth in we should talk about China because I think

1:33:51that that's the other real worry point for me. I question whether you can stick with

1:33:57this same form factor for two years because the thing about the phone, it's a personal

1:34:01device, you carry it with you, you pull it out when you sit on the cafe, you put it on

1:34:04the table. Like, it is like a car in that respect, where it matters like what car you

1:34:09get out of. And I question how long they can stick with this strategy where you don't know

1:34:15if you're using last year's phone or this year's phone. And it sounds super shallow,

1:34:19but it's a reality.

1:34:20I don't necessarily question that going forward in terms of where Apple goes in the future.

1:34:30But I want to take a moment just to point out, and I suspect a lot of people listening

1:34:35might succumb to this fallacious thinking, because I've definitely seen it on Twitter

1:34:41and commentary on what Apple needs to or ought to do with the iPhone going forward.

1:34:48And I've noticed it for years, is that people who are the more closely attuned you are to

1:34:55this, if you're the less less casual you are of an iPhone

1:34:59user, if you're, you know, an obsessive and you know, quite

1:35:01frankly, if you're listening to this podcast, you're probably

1:35:04right, pretty seriously. And the tech gadget, journalism racket

1:35:12in general, has long, I mean, forever, right from the three

1:35:17GS, the four s, the five s has always under appreciated the

1:35:23success of those S models. And there's, I think, a conventional wisdom that people

1:35:29are only, the general public, the world is only interested in the new form

1:35:35factors and that they see because the S ones look the same, they're not as

1:35:41interested in them. And that's not true at all because this is, the 6s is the

1:35:46first iPhone that hasn't outsold its predecessor. The 4s outsold the 4, the

1:35:513GS outsold the 3G and the 5S outsold the 5. I have no idea why I went in that order, 435.

1:35:59But up until now, no S model has failed to outsell its predecessor. And like I said,

1:36:08at least up until the 4S, the 4S outsold all previous iPhones combined. So now part of that,

1:36:15as we've just said, you know, 10-15 minutes ago, was about the worldwide expansion to more countries

1:36:21and carriers. But it's really just the obsessives who say, "I'm bored by the form factor." But now

1:36:31that we are... but I do agree too though that it's so old. I mean, we're almost, you know, next year's

1:36:37going to be the 10-year anniversary. I mean, we're a decade into the iPhone era. It's amazing. The

1:36:43world has changed. What was true in the early years is not going to be true going forward.

1:36:51Like everything in technology, there's no way to expect what happened before to continue

1:36:58happening. So I don't know.

1:37:00Well, that leads to the big engine for China, or sorry, the big engine for Apple has been

1:37:09China and that's been the promise that it's this massive market that we're

1:37:13growing in and it's going to be awesome and I'm exceptionally worried about

1:37:18China now and for a few reasons. So first off, Apple was up in China in the

1:37:24first quarter but people forget and I actually forgot originally in October or

1:37:29in 2014 when the iPhone 6 launched, the Chinese government actually held up the

1:37:34approval of the iPhone 6 and even though Apple intended to launch it in September

1:37:39with everyone else, they didn't watch it until October 17th. So on a year-over-year comparison,

1:37:45you were comparing two and a half months versus three months. And had you done a straight-up

1:37:50comparison, actually in Q1, it would have been down in China. Two, in Q2, it was massively down

1:37:56in China, in Greater China. And Tim Cook tried to take care to say, "Oh, in China itself, it was

1:38:02only down 7% or 11% or whatever it was. All the drop was in Hong Kong." The problem with that is,

1:38:08is a lot of those Hong Kong sells were gray market imports into China and as

1:38:15availability increased in China it was it's natural if the Hong Kong market

1:38:19would decrease and I think that's a red herring because I suspect the vast

1:38:23majority of the Hong Kong which was just demolished was people who used to buy in

1:38:29Hong Kong and smuggle into China and sell in China no longer did so because

1:38:33people just bought it in China now that is widely available and so I think you

1:38:37do have to look at it as a whole and it was down like 27% or something like a huge amount

1:38:42and this is really really concerning because this is supposed to be the the the engine

1:38:47up because you again you don't one it's not just that you need up graders you who are

1:38:53arguably not upgrading as frequently you need to find new customers and the new customer

1:38:59engine was supposed to be China and and the problem is that Tim Cook saying oh we sold

1:39:05a ton with the six, so of course it was down this year. Well, yeah, that's an upgrade story.

1:39:10Where are the new customers? And they're not materializing. And you say, "Oh, well, China's

1:39:14macroeconomic environment is challenging." It is. It is a problem. But if you're in a

1:39:21greenfield environment where you have so many new people to sell to, the macroeconomics

1:39:27don't affect you. Like Apple in 2008 was not affected by the Great Recession, right? Because

1:39:33was so many people to sell iPhones to, it didn't slow the company hardly at all.

1:39:37Yeah, I wouldn't say they weren't affected, but it was that they were in such a period of growth

1:39:42that their growth exceeded, the positive aspects of their ability to grow exceeded the negative

1:39:51aspects of the Great Recession. You can't say they weren't affected.

1:39:55No, that's fair. But the degree to which you are affected by macroeconomic conditions

1:40:00is a function of how mature your market is.

1:40:03Like the more mature your market is,

1:40:05the more you're gonna be effective

1:40:06at macroeconomic conditions.

1:40:07If you're in a new market

1:40:10where there's tons of growth opportunities,

1:40:12like the macroeconomics don't affect you nearly as much.

1:40:15And like I listen to all these earnings call every,

1:40:18like this is earnings call season for checkery.

1:40:20Like almost all my data updates are about earnings.

1:40:22And I actually love earnings call.

1:40:23I feel it's the time you can learn more about a company

1:40:25than almost any other time.

1:40:27But the degree to which Apple for the last two quarters has focused on macroeconomic

1:40:32conditions, it's kind of striking how it's far exceeded any other tech company.

1:40:36Like they're really concerned about the world economy growing into the ditch and

1:40:40like Facebook's not worried about it.

1:40:42Like they're doing fine.

1:40:43Like it's, it's, it's a testament to how mature your market is, how much that affects

1:40:48you.

1:40:48Uh, isn't it also sort of, uh, that Apple more than any of the other

1:40:57companies you might compare it to is shipping atoms, not bits, and that therefore they're

1:41:03more affected by currency exchange rates?

1:41:12Well, I mean, currency is just where you sell it. Facebook has a great Asia-Pacific business,

1:41:17so they were affected, for example. And advertising for sure is impacted by recessions. I think

1:41:24But the Adams versus I actually thought you were going to talk about China because a reason

1:41:29why Apple's been so successful in China is because they're shipping Adams, not bits,

1:41:34because bits can either be a copied or be blocked.

1:41:36Yeah, that's true.

1:41:37Right.

1:41:38And the fact that they ship Adams that are differentiated by the software has made them

1:41:43to a massive degree more successful than any other company in China.

1:41:47And frankly, Carl Lacan getting out of the stock last week and blaming China, I thought

1:41:52it was totally reasonable to be honest.

1:41:54the iTunes store being blocked. Yeah, I mean like it's not, it didn't cause a problem for Apple

1:41:59financially, but it's a worrisome sign. And like it's very, like Apple's China prospects,

1:42:07irregardless of whether they're saturated the market, which is, which is, which is something

1:42:11that can be, I mean, Tim Cook talks about the upper middle class in China. The upper middle

1:42:15class in China as it's defined in this McKinsey report he cites, which I actually cited first on

1:42:19this trajectory, I'd like to think he got it from that, but I don't know. But the upper middle class

1:42:22is defined by an income of $27,000 to $60,000, or sorry, $16,000 to $35,000 US dollars. And

1:42:31that's not very much money. Like in purchase power parity, it's much more because stuff

1:42:36in China is cheaper, but iPhones aren't cheaper in China. Like they're actually more expensive

1:42:40in China than in the US. Like you have to wonder, like, I'm concerned about this narrative

1:42:48in China, like how big actually is the iPhone market in China? And if, and again, it just

1:42:53goes back into this, like one, Apple doesn't seem to know what's going on with the iPhone.

1:42:58Two, there's evidence that upgrade rates are extending, particularly as the iPhone pushes

1:43:03into the marginal customer that's not a geek and upgrades every year. But then three, and

1:43:09three, they're not adding new carriers. And then four, the inch in China, like maybe it's

1:43:13not nearly as big as we all thought it was. Like, there's genuine reason to be concerned.

1:43:21And again, the iPhone's not going anywhere, no one's replacing it with Android, it's going

1:43:25to be super successful. But where's the growth going to come from? And if the growth's not

1:43:30going to be there, then we're almost back at the services discussion, if that makes

1:43:33sense. Like, everything's connected.

1:43:35Well, and the other thing Tim Cook mentioned, and again, this is maybe a little worrisome,

1:43:40that Tim Cook spoke optimistically about growth in India and sort of comparing it to China.

1:43:49And I linked to a, I thought it was a really good piece by Rupesh Shander, I hope I'm pronouncing

1:43:58it right, who lives in India and is a long time daring fireball reader and has written

1:44:03to me many times over the past.

1:44:05But he wrote about the differences between India and China and I, it's almost summarized

1:44:08by his footnote in his post, which is, I'll just read it entirely, "According to Pew Research,

1:44:15less than 2% of Indians earn more than $20 a day, which is about $7,000 a year, as of

1:44:222011."

1:44:24And that's an increase of about 0.5% over 10 years.

1:44:29In China, the number of people who earn more than $20 a day increased by 5% in the same

1:44:38period. So China's, there's, you know, the similarity between

1:44:41India and China is that there's a billion plus people in a lot

1:44:46of a lot of people, a lot of people. And so even if a

1:44:49relatively small number of people earn, I can buy an iPhone

1:44:53amounts of money. A small percentage of a billion people

1:45:00is an awful lot of potential iPhone buyers, but that it

1:45:03India's economy is not doing as well as China's in terms of

1:45:07raising the number of people who earn, you know, $7,000 or more a year. And again, if

1:45:13you only earn $7,000 a year, buying an iPhone is, you know, enormous, right? Because an

1:45:21iPhone is, even if you get the SE, it's $400.

1:45:28He cited an observation in his article, which I was grateful for. iPhone and China are very

1:45:34different in two respects. One is that China is just much richer than India. Like it's

1:45:40eight or nine times on a GDP basis, like per capita basis, richer, one. But then two, inequality

1:45:48in China is much greater than inequality in India. And the implication of high inequality

1:45:53with a ton of people is that there's a lot of rich people. And so China has this huge

1:45:59number of people that are like living on Western standards and incomes and India and you like

1:46:08arguably to its credit, I mean there's a lot of sociology that goes into this, but it's

1:46:12a relatively equal country. So even the rich people in India, one, there's not that many

1:46:18of them and two, they're not that rich relatively speaking. So the market, like even though

1:46:24it's a billion people, the people who can afford an iPhone is structurally much smaller

1:46:30than it is in China.

1:46:32Yeah. So anybody looking for a China-style explosion in India, I don't think it's

1:46:36going to happen. And Apple added setback after results where they'd been petitioning the

1:46:43government in India to allow them to sell refurbished iPhones and it got rejected, which

1:46:49Which is weird.

1:46:50The whole idea of not being allowed to sell refurbished phones is weird, but it seems

1:46:56like some kind of political issue in India.

1:46:58But that was a big path for potential sales for Apple in India because it would allow

1:47:04them to sell the iPhones at prices that Indians could more likely afford.

1:47:10And without being able to know what Apple's doing...

1:47:12Yeah, I don't know what Apple's doing.

1:47:13It's sort of...

1:47:14Well, it's just sort of like the way that you can...

1:47:18is BMW's strategy for reaching people who can't afford a new BMW? It's the certified

1:47:23BMW, certified pre-owned, they don't call them used, they're not used cars, they're

1:47:28pre-owned. Certified pre-owned BMW. And all the premium car makers have these certified

1:47:34pre-owned things. And that's the way that premium car companies like BMW and Mercedes,

1:47:41Porsche, whoever you want to talk about, they have these certified pre-owned sales things.

1:47:46It's exactly what Apple's strategy is with the iPhone, and it's two orders of magnitude

1:47:53different in price between, say, a new Mercedes and a new iPhone, but Apple's brand is exactly

1:48:00the same.

1:48:01They're a premium phone maker, and the way that they expand to the lower price points

1:48:05is with refurbished models.

1:48:09I also thought, I'm confused about what Apple's doing in India, because they did something

1:48:14really interesting in India, which they haven't done in any other country, which is they allowed

1:48:18for massive discounts of their phones. So the 6s and the 6 were hugely discounted in

1:48:24India and you could get them for, like you could get the 6s for something like $500 in

1:48:28India, which is massively less than in the US. And so when the SE launched, I actually

1:48:36thought it was targeted in India. And I presumed that even though it launched in India for

1:48:41like five hundred dollars like what more expensive than the US I presumed in a

1:48:45matter of weeks or months it would be discounted twice three hundred dollars

1:48:48and I I thought they were gonna make a big push India with the SE and it what

1:48:54they actually did was they cut off the discounts for the success so wouldn't

1:48:58compete with the SE and they raised it back up like $800 right because they

1:49:02felt it was suppressing SE cells and like I don't know one I don't know what

1:49:09are doing. Two, I feel silly because I presume their discounting was a strategy or an extend.

1:49:15But three, if that is their strategy where their entry level phone is going to be super

1:49:20expensive in India, the SE, it's not going to be China at all. And again, where are new

1:49:28customers going to come from?

1:49:30I don't know. Before we leave, with this idea that Apple might need to abandon the S strategy,

1:49:38I see a few problems with that.

1:49:42One of them is that, and I haven't done it, I should have maybe, but anecdotally, and

1:49:48I could be just as wrong as the people who I know are wrong that the S models generate

1:49:54less consumer interest, or have in the past generated less consumer interest than the

1:49:59new model ones.

1:50:01But I think that the new ones tend to be supply constrained when they're new in ways that

1:50:07the S model ones aren't for the very obvious reason that Apple is good at making, like

1:50:15for example, last year the iPhone 6 was supply constrained when it first came out.

1:50:20And that was one of the reasons that the January to March quarter did so well.

1:50:26One of the reasons was that it was delayed in China and then it was available in China.

1:50:30And one of the reasons, simple reasons that Q2 last year was so good for the iPhone 6

1:50:35that there were people who wanted to buy in Q1 and had to wait. And that to me is

1:50:40one of the very obvious reasons that Apple goes with this S strategy is that

1:50:45operationally it's a huge advantage because they get very very very

1:50:49efficient and good at making this form factor and all they have to do is put in

1:50:54like a new touch ID sensor which is very different than making an entirely new

1:50:59aluminum case and an entirely new screen size and stuff like that. So I just wonder,

1:51:06I don't know that it's even feasible for Apple to make a new form factor every

1:51:09year. I just don't think, I think that's too much too fast. I don't think that, I

1:51:13think it actually takes two years for them to get, you know, to get in place to

1:51:17make a new form factor. It's a fair point, but I guess the counter to that would be

1:51:23is that when they did that with the 3G, with 3G, 3GS and 4, 4S,

1:51:28the volumes were so much less.

1:51:30Like, there's a very real factor where

1:51:33the more you can spread out the fixed costs

1:51:36of your tooling and your factory over a number of phones,

1:51:39like the better margin you get, it's called leverage,

1:51:41and there certainly is an aspect to that,

1:51:44but at this point, they're selling every year,

1:51:47even in a down year, they're selling so many more 6S,

1:51:51they're selling more 6Ss than they sold 4s

1:51:52and 4Ss combined, or certainly 3G and 3GS combined.

1:51:56I think they have the scale at this point that they could justify the investment in

1:52:04tooling and setting up lines even if it was only over one year.

1:52:09But it is a very... it's a fair question.

1:52:12I think you're exactly right.

1:52:15It's work to Apple's benefits.

1:52:16I mean, certainly they've changed the phone, so I'm actually very curious to know how much

1:52:21benefit they do get, because the 6S is a different phone than the 6.

1:52:24It is.

1:52:25I'm curious how much benefit they do get year by year.

1:52:29Like do they really get to reuse that much tooling

1:52:31'cause they use different aluminum,

1:52:33they use all this sort of stuff.

1:52:35If they do get a lot of benefit,

1:52:36then the question is probably closer than I'm thinking about

1:52:38'cause there's a cost component to it as well.

1:52:41But I don't know, it just--

1:52:44- Even if they could, and there's another factor

1:52:47which is that even if they could, manufacturing-wise,

1:52:49literally just snap their fingers

1:52:50and Johnny Ive's team says,

1:52:53"Here's what this year's iPhone looks like."

1:52:55If they could just snap their fingers and within a day have the supply chain turning

1:53:00them out in the quantity that they need to meet demand, even if it was that magical,

1:53:05I don't know that I really doubt that Apple's, you know, that Johnny Ive's team would come

1:53:11up with a new design every year that was noticeably different because they're getting paid enough

1:53:17thing into it.

1:53:18Well, they could, but their philosophy though, their ethos is that they don't, they're

1:53:24The idea of changing, making something look new,

1:53:28just to have something that looks new,

1:53:30is antithetical to their philosophy,

1:53:32which is that they are only going to make something look new

1:53:36if they are convinced that it's better.

1:53:39And if not, then they won't do it.

1:53:41- I will tell you, I couldn't go back to the size.

1:53:44I have it sitting here though, but this iPhone 5,

1:53:47I'm, 5S, I'm holding my hand,

1:53:48is a vastly more beautiful phone than my 6S.

1:53:52Well, I find, you know, in terms of, you know, things I'm worried about with Apple in the

1:53:57long run, it's, you know, the fact that I prefer the, I've been doing, I do it every

1:54:03time I keep my SE review unit here. I don't use it day to day anymore, but I much prefer

1:54:10the way, I just sit here and worry stone it in my hands over and over again. I find that

1:54:14they...

1:54:15Oh, it's, it's, it's, like the 5, to me the 5 and 5S were the pinnacle of, because the

1:54:20was brilliant it was so auto left field but the five like perfected the four

1:54:25right like it's it really is like the perfect the perfect form factor in my

1:54:29opinion yeah I find that the four was you know well the fact that the back

1:54:34could crack was right that was the problem deficiency but in the fact that

1:54:37you couldn't tell in your hand which side was which was sort of an

1:54:40inefficiency as well I find it worrisome that Apple clearly in at least Johnny

1:54:45Ives team thinks that the 6 6s form factor is superior to the 5 5s SE and size aside I would

1:54:55I would prefer I think a a 4.7 inch phone that was had the flat sides you know and sharp I think the

1:55:04seven will be better because I think what they were concerned about was like the round I think

1:55:10Apple was so worried about making a big phone that I think the 6, like they did a lot of affordances

1:55:15in the 6 for a larger phone, like having the rounded edges and stuff like that. And now that

1:55:20people are more comfortable with it, I think they'll be a little more exploratory with the 7.

1:55:26The other thing too is actually the supply chain rumors, which credit to the supply chain,

1:55:32the supply chain nailed the 6s being low. It was widespread in Taiwan for sure. And it got out in

1:55:39out in the western media as well that the Apple was tamping down inventory. Oh, here's

1:55:43a factoid, John. I just posted this today because I did some calculations. So Sony in

1:55:48their earnings, and they actually did a warning, wait in April, where they said that their

1:55:54devices division, where they make the camera sensors, was going to have a big miss. And

1:56:01it was a real surprise because that's been a real strength for Sony for the last couple

1:56:04of years. And kudos to Sony, by the way. The company is doing really, really well and I

1:56:08I couldn't be more pleased.

1:56:10I think for us children of the 80s,

1:56:11like it's a company that will always hold

1:56:12a special place in our hearts.

1:56:14- Oh, definitely.

1:56:15- But their devices had a big loss

1:56:17and they had to do a write down.

1:56:19And the write down was of $560 million worth of sensors

1:56:23that basically they didn't sell.

1:56:26And there was some speculation that it was a customer,

1:56:29what happened, what went on.

1:56:30It turns out if you go to the estimates of the success cost,

1:56:35which obviously who knows if they're true or not,

1:56:37But the estimate for the camera on the 6S is $22.50, $22.50.

1:56:42That may or may not include the lens assembly,

1:56:45but if you presume that's the sensor, that is--

1:56:49that sensor that costs $22.50, if you take $560 million divided

1:56:54by $22.50, it comes out to 25 million sensors

1:56:57that Sony apparently made and one of their customers

1:57:01ended up declining to accept shipment of.

1:57:04It turns out $25 million is about what most analysts think

1:57:07Apple over forecasted the iPhone 6s.

1:57:11Which is, it's interesting on a few levels.

1:57:13One, like I already had in my head,

1:57:17in my Excel spreadsheet,

1:57:19that Apple had lowered their forecast by 25 million

1:57:23and it actually matched almost perfectly.

1:57:26Two, it goes to show the leverage and power Apple still has

1:57:30that Sony had to eat it,

1:57:33even though Apple's the one that screwed up.

1:57:36But yeah, that was just a factoid. That was pretty interesting.

1:57:43You know what? You know those sensors? You know what? No.

1:57:46We're not gonna pay for them. We're actually not gonna pay for them.

1:57:51That is interesting. Where did you post that? I didn't see it and I thought that...

1:57:53I just did today. You might not have seen it yet. It was in my "Today's" update.

1:57:57Oh, I thought I... But I really thought before we started recording that I had caught up.

1:58:01I was like... Oh, it was in a... It was a section about Nintendo versus Sony, so it might...

1:58:05Oh, I skipped it. I skipped the Nintendo part. I did see it, but then I skipped it.

1:58:10Yeah, it was just stuck at the very end.

1:58:13I don't... yeah.

1:58:16It's interesting. I enjoy the fixed typo too.

1:58:19This is why I don't think I could ever do...

1:58:23I don't think I could ever do a newsletter. It's awful. It's awful. Yeah, because

1:58:26once it's out, it's out. So there's always a balance, do you fix it or not?

1:58:29And so I did about Tesla, and I said that they had had a

1:58:32cash out full in operations of $560 billion or $525 billion.

1:58:36And $525 billion is the market cap of Apple approximately.

1:58:40Like, of course it's not billion, it's million. And in the next sentence

1:58:43I added up the stuff and it was clearly I meant million.

1:58:46One of the... It's one of the great flaws

1:58:50in the English language that million and billion and

1:58:54even trillion and whatever go on. But especially in terms of what numbers we

1:58:58actually use.

1:58:59And in terms of talking about money, million and billion are the only ones that really matter.

1:59:03It's very, you know, there's very few discussions that go into trillions.

1:59:06And they're only one letter. Like, a trillion is two different letters, right? So it's, like, significantly different.

1:59:12Yeah, but they should be... it's helpful and proper and, I think, actually helps you understand how different a thousand from a million is.

1:59:23because the word sounds so different and a hundred sounds so different from a

1:59:28thousand even though it's only a tenfold difference it's only a tenfold

1:59:31difference from a hundred to a thousand a thousand to a million is a thousand

1:59:35fold difference and it sounds totally different but a million to a billion is

1:59:39a thousand fold difference and it sounds so similar and our brains just so many

1:59:44people's brains just naturally file them together and I totally understand the

1:59:49difference but in writing it is the easiest and anybody who writes only that

1:59:56mistake one way or the other. So the worst thing with an email is because it's out

1:59:59there right and so I was just gonna leave it I saw it actually right away

2:00:03and I'm like crap but I was gonna leave it but I got like double digit like

2:00:09tweets and emails yeah cuz I feel like if you actually think about it like

2:00:13obviously I meant million but I got more than usual like did you mean million or

2:00:17billion. And like, and so I had to issue the follow up email saying fixing this

2:00:22typo, which I hate doing because like, to me, a really powerful aspect of the

2:00:28check remodel is I insert myself into a place that people always look at with

2:00:32their email blocks. And I take that, like very seriously, right. And so to send a

2:00:36second email, I really hate doing, but if I'm getting so many responses, like,

2:00:42what did you mean? I feel like I have to correct it and like, Oh, yeah, right. It

2:00:46depresses me. So before we move on to the final segment of the show, but just hit the rumor mill.

2:00:54The rumor mill though is that the iPhone 7 or whatever they're going to call it this fall,

2:00:58the new iPhone this fall, is going to be very very similar to the... it seems as though the S cycle is

2:01:03coming to an end, but it seems as though the way it's coming to an end is not by coming up with

2:01:08new form factors every year, but by extending existing form factors for additional years. So

2:01:13first example proof of it we have is the iPhone SE which is the first time that

2:01:17the same form factor has been used three times and the rumor mill is very strong

2:01:24that the iPhone that this year's iPhone I don't even I I'm really starting to

2:01:29think they're not gonna call it the iPhone 7 just on a gut level so I don't

2:01:33want to call it that but for lack of a better term the iPhone 7 is going to be

2:01:36in large part in this physically indistinguishable from the iPhone 6 and

2:01:40and success except that the antenna lines are moving.

2:01:44That's a bummer. Yeah, that's a bummer. I'm not a huge fan.

2:01:49Well, I was going to go the other direction. The other rumor is that the iPhone, the 2018

2:01:57iPhone, which would theoretically be the 7S, is going to be markedly different from--

2:02:01No, no, 2017. That'll be 2017. This year is 2017.

2:02:05Yeah, you're right. Sorry, you're right. 2017, you're right. Fiscal year 2018, that's

2:02:08- That's why I get confused, 'cause Apple starts in October.

2:02:11But that that phone is also gonna be markedly different

2:02:14from the 2016 iPhone, which, so either one,

2:02:19they're gonna like extend the six to like three years,

2:02:23which you just kinda said, or on the flip side,

2:02:26they're gonna move into an annual refresh cycle.

2:02:30I hope for, I think it needs to be a refresh cycle,

2:02:32but if they ship a phone with the same form factor,

2:02:36I would be, that would be amazing.

2:02:38Here is what I would not wager heavily on any aspect of this,

2:02:43but if you wanted me to wager at all,

2:02:45I think that they are getting away from the tic-tac S cycle.

2:02:50But the way that they're doing it is not with significant--

2:02:53it's different.

2:02:54Here's what I think is going to happen.

2:02:56I think that this year's iPhone, new iPhones,

2:02:59will only be in the 4.7 and 5.5 sizes.

2:03:03There's not-- the SE-- if you like 4-inch iPhones,

2:03:05you might as well buy the SE now.

2:03:07I really don't think that they're gonna come out

2:03:08with a new four-inch iPhone six months from now.

2:03:11I think it's gonna be 4.7 and 5.5.

2:03:14I think it'll largely look like the iPhone 6 and 6S.

2:03:19I think that, this is the biggest question I have

2:03:23is whether both phones get the dual camera module

2:03:26or whether only the 5.5 Plus does.

2:03:29The rumor mill says that only the Plus will.

2:03:33I, my gut feeling, my spidey sense says

2:03:36that doesn't sound like Apple.

2:03:37And I think that maybe the reason the rumor mill has that

2:03:40is that the schematics,

2:03:41the only schematics that have leaked are for the 5.5

2:03:44and that the schematics for the 4.7 didn't leak.

2:03:47But I don't wanna bet against it

2:03:50because so much of the rumor mill says

2:03:52only the plus is getting the dual camera module.

2:03:54That just seems out of character to me

2:03:58because the 4.7 inch is the best selling model.

2:04:01So I don't know.

2:04:02Because it's the best selling model, it just seems unusual.

2:04:04But I just think whether they both get the dual camera or not,

2:04:09it's largely going to--

2:04:10I think the rumor is probably right that this year's phone

2:04:13will largely look like the 6 and 6S,

2:04:15except that the antenna lines move.

2:04:18And I think--

2:04:19I haven't seen that, actually.

2:04:20That only the Plus is going to get the dual camera?

2:04:24Or no, that the--

2:04:24No, I hadn't seen that.

2:04:25That was going to look the same.

2:04:27I'll put it in the show notes, and I'll send you a link

2:04:29privately.

2:04:29But I will put it in the show notes.

2:04:34And then I think next year's phone, the 2017 model,

2:04:38the one that will come out in September 2017,

2:04:41what I have heard-- now this is not really from the rumor

2:04:44mill, this is more just scuttlebutt that I've heard--

2:04:46is that it will be an all new form factor.

2:04:50And there have been some rumors, I guess, that say this.

2:04:53But what I'm saying is I've heard this independently,

2:04:55that it is getting rid of the-- that it'll completely

2:04:59get rid of the chin and forehead on the phone.

2:05:01and the entire front face will be the display.

2:05:04- Interesting.

2:05:06- And that the touch ID sensor

2:05:08will be somehow embedded in the display.

2:05:09The front facing camera

2:05:11will somehow be embedded in the display.

2:05:13The speaker, everything,

2:05:15all the sensors will be somehow behind the display.

2:05:17And what I don't know, I have no idea,

2:05:21but whether that means that they're going to shrink

2:05:23the actual thing in your hand

2:05:26to fit the screen sizes we already have,

2:05:28or whether they're going to grow the screens

2:05:30to fit the devices we're already used to holding, I don't know.

2:05:35But that's what I think is going to happen.

2:05:37I think 2017 is going to be the jaw-dropping, wow,

2:05:41that's an astounding industrial design iPhone,

2:05:44and that this year's is not.

2:05:45But it's not going to be the-- you really

2:05:49have to look at very, very, very, very fine details

2:05:52to tell the difference between the 6 and 6S.

2:05:55I think that the iPhone 7 or whatever you want to call it

2:05:57this year will be-- it'll largely look the same,

2:06:00but that the antenna lines being different will make it pretty easy to tell that it's

2:06:05new. That's what I've heard.

2:06:06Well, I feel good about my prediction that they're not going to turn to growth then.

2:06:13I don't think that that's what drives it. I really don't. I don't think that normal

2:06:17people really care too much about that.

2:06:20I disagree, at least on this side of the world. It matters that you can show off that you

2:06:28have the latest iPhone. It's a much more materialistic, displaying your status world

2:06:35than the United States is. It's a different culture.

2:06:37Well, can't they solve that? I think they could solve that with...

2:06:39That's why all the luxury goods are sold here.

2:06:40I think they could solve that, though, with different anodization and colors.

2:06:44Absolutely. Like I said, that's why I think they've launched the additional colors with

2:06:49the S models recently. But yeah, I don't know. It's interesting.

2:06:54Yeah, like the whole rose gold thing seems like this sort of fashion oriented thing that

2:07:01it's not like a long term trend, it's a short term fad.

2:07:08And that maybe, who knows what they'll do. But obviously they have a lot of opportunities,

2:07:12they could color them any way they want, they could go like the way the iPods used to be

2:07:17and go colorful. I mean, and totally throw a loop in all of Samsung's rose gold production,

2:07:24or whatever they call their rose gold.

2:07:26But what we learned with the 5C is it has to be the high-end iPhone that does it. You

2:07:30can't come in on the middle level because an iPhone is high-end. It has to retain that.

2:07:36Yeah, yeah. It has to be premium.

2:07:39I don't, it's fast.

2:07:41I mean, we're in a really fascinating time with Apple.

2:07:44I mean,

2:07:45can they, I guess here's what concerns me.

2:07:52Here's what makes me really worried

2:07:53about the last little bit.

2:07:56It's that, one, it doesn't seem that Apple

2:08:01knows what's going on.

2:08:02And that concerns me.

2:08:03Because we talked about like the changing forecast

2:08:06and what they said last year and stuff.

2:08:07And that's very worrisome in general.

2:08:09one and then two it feels like Cook has defaulted to the short-term expedient answer to questions

2:08:21that will prop up Apple stock as opposed to laying the groundwork for the what is best for Apple in

2:08:28the long term. Apple would be in better shape today if Apple if Tim Cook had been much more

2:08:33conservative last year and said this growth has vastly ceded our expectations which was true

2:08:39and said we next year we might be down

2:08:43like if he had like

2:08:44it would it he could have adopted a conservative approach

2:08:49and apple could have beaten it

2:08:51and they're like wow look at that it turns out we're beating it

2:08:54or if they could have been like they are today like yeah as i told you last year like the

2:08:57six was amazing like we really crushed it we got super like we just everything came

2:09:02to we had china mobile with the big screen all at the same time everything was a perfect

2:09:06year, but like I told you last year, like that was probably going to make 2016 tough.

2:09:12Apple would be in better shape today. They really would be. And it concerns me that Cook

2:09:17did not take that approach. Because it's counter to...

2:09:20It's like the old Seinfeld skit about nighttime Jerry screwing daytime Jerry. And nighttime

2:09:25Jerry will stay up and watch the end of the movie knowing that morning Jerry has to get

2:09:30up for a night.

2:09:30I love that analogy.

2:09:31Right?

2:09:32Yes.

2:09:32And 2015 Tim Cook hung 2016 Tim Cook out to dry.

2:09:37- Yep. - Or didn't,

2:09:40knowingly or unknowingly.

2:09:42But 2016, today's Tim Cook has to, you know,

2:09:46wanna kick 2015 Tim Cook in the ass.

2:09:49- But what worries me is, Tim Cook,

2:09:52did you watch the Jim Cramer interview with Tim Cook?

2:09:54- Yes, yeah.

2:09:55- Like, it worries me because it feels like 2016 Tim Cook

2:10:00is now hanging 2017 typical cut to dry. Yeah, and it's like you know what you think you know,

2:10:07that Tim Cook really has Apple's long-term interests at heart, that he is not a short-term

2:10:14quarter-to-quarter thinker. He's not trying to maximize Apple. But he has lots of stuff that

2:10:20looks like it's quarter-to-quarter. Yeah, exactly. Right. You think you know that, and it's like you

2:10:25said that you, you know, it lends a lot of you're willing to, or at least have been in the past,

2:10:30been willing to take Tim Cook at his word because you think that, but now you start to start, you

2:10:35have to start wondering about that. Like how much is Tim Cook?

2:10:38I will tell you as an analyst, like, I really want to be right. Like, it's super important to me.

2:10:43Not because like, and I don't do stock picks and stuff like that, but like, I just try to be right.

2:10:48I work really hard at my job and do what I do. And it bugs me that I was wrong because I believe

2:10:55Tim Cook. And again, that's my personal problem. Tim Cook doesn't need to worry about me, but

2:11:05I think that Apple and the Apple stock and all the stuff that Tim Cook is worried about

2:11:09would be in better shape if Tim Cook had... I don't know. It worries me. I wrote about

2:11:17this last year with Apple Music. We were sitting next to each other at the Apple Music keynote.

2:11:21we're just baffled. And we should talk about your article.

2:11:24Like, we're just baffled at this Apple Music presentation. It was so bad.

2:11:28And I went back to my hotel room and I wrote about that day, and I said,

2:11:33and I talked about, Tim Cook talks about focus.

2:11:36And he says about how Apple's so focused, all sort of stuff.

2:11:39And I'm like, I'm not seeing that from Apple.

2:11:42I'm not seeing, the rhetoric is not matching what's coming out of the company,

2:11:47and that concerns me.

2:11:48And frankly, what I wrote in that article, my concern has only deepened since then.

2:11:53Well, let's take a break. Alright, we're going on. We gotta wrap up soon.

2:11:57But I want to thank our...

2:11:58I've got super worked up. The Scotch has done its job. I'm very worked up. Very worked up.

2:12:02I want to thank our final sponsor of the show, our good friends at Audible.

2:12:07Audible.com has more than 250,000 audio books and spoken word audio products.

2:12:16You can get a 30 day trial free at audible.com/talkshow.

2:12:21Now if you want to listen to it, Audible has it.

2:12:26They have audio books from every genre

2:12:30and you can download them, start listening,

2:12:32or start listening to them anytime, anywhere.

2:12:36You can play their audio books on your phone,

2:12:39your tablet, your computer, Kindle Fire, even iPods.

2:12:44Audiobooks are great. If you're listening to me right now, it means you like spoken content, by definition.

2:12:53And if you have more time in your life or you wish there were more podcasts you want to listen to or more episodes of the talk show, audiobooks are terrific for that.

2:13:02They're great for flights. They're great for road trips. They're great for a daily commute.

2:13:07commute. You might think you don't have time to read books,

2:13:10but you'd be surprised by how many audio books you can hear

2:13:13each year, even if you only listen to them going back and

2:13:16forth to work. Find out more, get a free 30 day trial, go to

2:13:21audible.com slash talk show. And there's no stress or obligation,

2:13:27you can cancel your membership at any time. And they even have

2:13:30what they call the great listen guarantee. If you start an audio

2:13:34book and you don't like it you can exchange it and get another one for free

2:13:38so it's almost like a can't-lose offer go there find out more they keep

2:13:43sponsoring a show because I think people keep going because people who listen to

2:13:46this show and other podcasts are the exact audience for audiobooks so go

2:13:51check them out at audible.com slash talk show yeah I just wrote last night about

2:13:57Apple music because there was a leak or I don't know whether it was planned or

2:14:02not, but Bloomberg had a story that there's a major revamping of the Apple

2:14:10Music user interface, I guess is one way to put it, that it's going to, you know, to

2:14:15at least, and according to Bloomberg, an acknowledgement that what they

2:14:18shipped last year was confusing or convoluted or just not just not well

2:14:23designed and that it will be coming again like last year at WWDC. Which I'm

2:14:29sure all the devs are thrilled about.

2:14:31I don't know though, how much is the WWDC keynote even about developers anymore?

2:14:36No, I know, I know. It was a watermelon, it was right there, I had to take a swing at it.

2:14:42Right, I don't know. I think that's a little... I mean there's some truth to it.

2:14:49No, I agree. It is a public event now, it's just like any other Apple keynote.

2:14:54And the reason why I'm really not moved by the argument that the WWDC morning keynote

2:15:02ought to necessarily needs to be developer related even tangentially is that it's followed

2:15:09by in the afternoon that what the Apple calls the state of the union, which in in plain

2:15:15English is the technical keynote.

2:15:18Like WWDC every single year has two keynotes, a morning keynote, which is the one that everybody

2:15:23and the general everybody knows about. And then there's a lunch break and then you come

2:15:28back in and there's a technical keynote. And the technical keynote, the State of the Union,

2:15:33could not possibly be more nerdy. I mean, it's talk about frameworks, it is, you know,

2:15:37source code.

2:15:38Let me show you coding on screen.

2:15:39Right. They show you source code. I mean, it couldn't be more. So if that's what you

2:15:42want, if you're like, "I'm a developer and I paid $1600. I want a technical keynote,"

2:15:47you're going to get it anyway. You know, so I say, you know, if you don't, and if you

2:15:52don't want a non-technical keynote, sleep in and skip the morning keynote. I don't

2:15:57have any sympathy for that argument.

2:15:58But definitely go to the bathroom in the women's bathroom, right?

2:16:01No. No. What are you talking about? No, it wasn't the women's bathroom. You're

2:16:09totally, you're confusing these North Carolinians. I would not endorse, excuse me,

2:16:15you're conflating it with last year you and I sat in the WWDC keynote together

2:16:20and we both we got in early because they they used to in the old days only let

2:16:25the press in like five minutes before the keynote started they let us in early

2:16:29and we had plenty of time but we both thought maybe we should maybe we should

2:16:34take a bathroom break before this and it was good that we did because the

2:16:37goddamn keynote went on so long and you go out now this will be all different

2:16:42this year because it's gonna be at the Bill Graham Civic Auditorium instead of

2:16:46upstairs, top floor of Moscone. But top floor of Moscone, the men's room line was, I mean,

2:16:51seriously, no exaggeration, 50, 60, 75 people out the door in the men's room.

2:16:56It was ridiculous.

2:16:57And of course there's no line.

2:16:58And for the record, the women's, yeah, exactly.

2:17:00There's never a line in the women's bathroom. We did not go into the women's bathroom though.

2:17:04What we did is we took the elevator down to the first floor and went to the first floor

2:17:09men's room, which had no line.

2:17:10Where there was no one.

2:17:11And then we came back up to the third floor and we saw the line and I was just going to

2:17:18go back and retake my seat, but you acted like a good Samaritan and started trying to

2:17:23tell people in the line, "Hey, you know, you can go downstairs.

2:17:27If you go downstairs, there's no line."

2:17:28And no one listened to me.

2:17:29And nobody listened to you.

2:17:30No one listened.

2:17:31That's why I didn't bother.

2:17:32It doesn't pay to be a good Samaritan, Ben.

2:17:36Doesn't pay.

2:17:37This is what happens.

2:17:38See, I still have this small number of Twitter followers.

2:17:40I don't have the superpowers quite that you do. So I still have empathy for my fellow man.

2:17:44What can I say? Literally men. Literally empathy for my fellow man.

2:17:49I can't believe that you misremembered it as us sneaking into the women's bathroom.

2:17:52I don't know where that—it's totally true that the women's bathroom definitely had no light.

2:17:57I mean, yes, that's a commentary on the problem with the technology. I don't know why, though,

2:18:02I remembered us going to the women's bathroom. It does occur to me, though, that we will—I

2:18:07I don't know what, you know, that's a minor hiccup in the Bill Graham civic auditorium

2:18:11plan where there won't, I don't think there will be such a thing as a...

2:18:15Well, fortunately, if you walk there, you go to the Tenderloin first, so you can just

2:18:19go to the bathroom on the street before you get there.

2:18:25I didn't know how to phrase that.

2:18:26I wrote, when I wrote that, that's interesting because it's a bit of a—on Daring Fireball,

2:18:32I wrote, it's a bit of a hike from the Moscone area hotels,

2:18:37and Moscone is surrounded by hotels,

2:18:40to the Bill Graham Civic Auditorium.

2:18:42And somebody, a few people wrote to me,

2:18:44and they like, either cited Google Maps or Apple Maps,

2:18:46and they're like, it's like a mile.

2:18:49And they're like, are you seriously so lazy

2:18:52that you think that's a hike?

2:18:54And really what I meant by a bit of a hike

2:18:56is that it's not so much that it's far,

2:18:58but that it's not,

2:19:02A, it's definitely unpleasant, and B, it's questionably unsafe to walk there.

2:19:08It's a little better, to be fair.

2:19:10But yeah, if you're walking in the morning, argue with everyone that's going to bother you is asleep.

2:19:15Right.

2:19:15But yeah, it's probably better to just take a taxi or grab a burger.

2:19:19Or the muni goes right down Market Street.

2:19:21Yeah.

2:19:22Anyway, well, but how does the muni accommodate thousands of people?

2:19:27You know what I mean?

2:19:28Yeah, it's not that people.

2:19:29It's not that people.

2:19:29And you know what I mean? And like Uber and stuff like that, it's like, it's, it's, if lots and lots of people's not that many.

2:19:35Yeah, that's fine.

2:19:36Right. I don't know. I don't know. I think it'll be all right. But anyway, Bloomberg says, Apple Music, big revamp, an acknowledgement and whether or not that they're going to acknowledge it, but that the revamp is an acknowledgement that it was it people were confused by what they had last year, and they're going to announce it at WWDC again.

2:19:55So one thing you talked about is you felt like the best thing would be to break apart Apple Music from iTunes.

2:20:02And like from a product design perspective, I can 100% agree with you.

2:20:07But one thing that's interesting is, has become more apparent over the last year,

2:20:13is that Apple's integration of iTunes and Apple Music is arguably a strength.

2:20:17In some scenarios, like for example, when you have like all the stars now are adopting this

2:20:23windowing strategy where they first make their stuff available for purchase.

2:20:28So they're super smart, right?

2:20:30If Adele makes her a CD available for only for purchase, not for streaming,

2:20:35all her best fans give her $10 or $15 or whatever it is.

2:20:39Beyonce's album was like $18.

2:20:41And then a year or two later, they open up to streaming and get all the

2:20:46marginal fans that went to have paid for it.

2:20:48So it's super smart for them.

2:20:49and only apple has a solution where

2:20:53those are

2:20:54connected like you you have one out that has your purchased adele tracks

2:20:59and you're streaming other tracks whereas if they were separate apps

2:21:04you would have to preemptively choose the right apt to get your music that's a

2:21:07fantastic point and i'm probably wrong

2:21:10and you know that

2:21:12that the right way to do it is to break it into a separate app

2:21:15but i think

2:21:17whatever they come up with has to have that level of clarity between

2:21:22what is yours and what is

2:21:26and just think about what i want

2:21:27jim dow rumple's complaints throughout the year of the way that his library got

2:21:32screwed up

2:21:33you know like

2:21:37that doesn't happen about the music is a standalone you know

2:21:41i'll tell you what the problem is with apple music i think it's actually

2:21:44pretty straightforward if you open apple music there's five towns in the bottom

2:21:47I'll read from left to right. Number one for you, number two new, number three radio, number four connect, number five my music.

2:21:53The reality is I spend 98% of my time in my music and that's smushed into one tab.

2:22:00And that includes not just my music that I bought on iTunes but also like Apple Music.

2:22:04If I want to search for something on Apple Music I have to go to my music and search.

2:22:07Like they've broken out these four tabs that are just... I don't use and I suspect most people don't use.

2:22:16And I think that's where the mistake came in. Like they need to, like, at the end of the day, people... what makes music such a great business, and what reason why Jobs was so focused on owning the music is that people tend to, they just want to listen to the same stuff again and again, right? And Apple Music over index on this discovering new music, like I don't like for you and new, why are those different things? Like, and then connect? I mean, I'm sorry.

2:22:46Apple, I will, if Apple ever births a successful social sort of network, I will eat a literal hat.

2:22:55Like, that needs to go. Like, radio, maybe that should be a different app, I don't know.

2:23:004U and U should be combined. And if you break out, like, my music that I've collected, either

2:23:06I bought it in iTunes or I saved it from the Apple Music, from Apple Music to be in my collection.

2:23:11And then you have a separate search tab. Like, where is the search tab? It should be its own

2:23:14tab. I actually think there is a solution to make this app significantly more manageable.

2:23:21My idea for a standalone Apple Music app, which again, I haven't, it's not like I've sat and

2:23:28designed the whole thing, but when people object to, "Hey, but I just want one place to listen to

2:23:33whatever I've got." My idea is predicated on the idea that in a way that other apps have always

2:23:40had apps access to your music library like when you're in iMovie you can import a song from your

2:23:45music right that this Apple Music app would have like let's say if there's a band that's or an

2:23:53album like a new Adele album that's not in Apple Music streaming yet if you have it in your personal

2:23:58music collection then you could still play it from there it would just magically you know it would it

2:24:02would appear there with some sort of visual indication that it's there because you own it

2:24:07So I'm not arguing against it. I'm just saying that the visual design, it should just treat,

2:24:12basically the way I would propose it would be that it would treat any track you have in your

2:24:18personal library, whether it's like not available, like the new Adele album, or whether it's like

2:24:23Prince, like an artist who just didn't sell streaming rights to Apple Music, or whether

2:24:29it is something like a live recording of an album that's, you know, like passed around by fans, like

2:24:36Marco's band, Fish. You know, but if it's in your personal library, it would appear in Apple Music

2:24:45in the same way that your music appears in iMovie and whatever else. So I'm not saying you shouldn't

2:24:51be able to, that you'd have to go to a different app to listen to this stuff in your stuff. I'm

2:24:56just saying, like, I think you're arguing that it just shouldn't be segregated so much down at the

2:25:00the bottom and in tabs. Yeah. Well, I mean, the problem is like, yeah, well, no,

2:25:05I, yeah, the problem is Apple music isn't really about my music, right?

2:25:09It's about what Apple, like Apple thinks you should ought to listen to.

2:25:13And literally I,

2:25:14there are five tabs in Apple music and I don't touch four of them.

2:25:18And the only reason I, I subscribe to help music,

2:25:20and this is actually to take this full circle to the, the services thing,

2:25:24I'm still subscribed to Apple music.

2:25:26And the reason I am is because when I drive my kids around, like we always listen to songs and, and I use Siri to like, they request songs and I use Siri to want to watch the song.

2:25:38And of course, Siri doesn't have an API, so it doesn't support like Spotify or other things.

2:25:44And it's, it's, it's interesting because it gets into this tension.

2:25:47Like what is Apple's strategy?

2:25:49Where are they trying to make money?

2:25:50like in this case siri is actually

2:25:54forcing me to give more money to apple

2:25:57as opposed to spotify just because it works there and also my daughter was

2:26:01here so that's the other reason

2:26:03uh... and you don't have you don't own any tailors with you just listen to it

2:26:07there are problems

2:26:08side i i think i i got nineteen ninety

2:26:11i think i actually got nineteen nine when taylor swift did her breakup with

2:26:15uh... spotify i wrote about the update those as i was really interesting

2:26:19So now I've adopted a Twitter persona of being a Taylor Swift fan, which I enjoy.

2:26:27It's kind of an ongoing gag on exponents about me and Taylor Swift.

2:26:33Is this a good segue to talk about the Amazon Echo that you've tricked me into buying?

2:26:42You have said and written, I think, that Amazon Echo—and a lot of people have good words

2:26:49about Amazon Echo. No, for the record, I want to get this on the record, when the Echo launched,

2:26:54almost everyone dumped on it. And as far as I read, I was the only person that was enthusiastic

2:26:59about it. And people were dumping on it because it was when the phone, they had Amazon just

2:27:03written off the Fire phone, which was obvious from day one was a mess. And the Echo though,

2:27:11so there's two things. One, this gets at Amazon is such a unique company in that they're built

2:27:16to run experiments and to fail or succeed.

2:27:19And the phone failed.

2:27:21And the admirable thing about the phone is even though Bezos was clearly--

2:27:25one, it probably shouldn't have launched in the first place.

2:27:27It was obviously a bad idea.

2:27:29But two, even though Bezos was so cool--

2:27:30It should have been identified internally as, wow, this is--

2:27:33It should have been.

2:27:34This is incredible.

2:27:35But the way they ruthlessly killed it was very impressive, right?

2:27:42Even though it was Bezos' baby, would it failed utterly?

2:27:46Like he cold bloodedly killed it late like way up again.

2:27:50I'm not glorifying weighing off people.

2:27:52It's a tragedy that people lost their jobs, although they were engineers in

2:27:55Silicon Valley, I'm sure they, they survived, but like they weighed off people.

2:27:59They shut the whole thing down.

2:28:00It was over.

2:28:01Like they realize we.

2:28:02And Bezos probably realized personally, I got wrapped up in this.

2:28:06I made a mistake.

2:28:08And in some respects being able to recognize and own your mistake, especially

2:28:13when you're someone who's succeeded so wildly

2:28:15as someone like Jeff Bezos is super impressive.

2:28:18And kudos to them.

2:28:21But then the Echo comes out and the Echo,

2:28:23the thing with Echo, it was so different than the Fire Phone

2:28:26because the Echo was all, the Echo was a conduit.

2:28:30It's a conduit to Amazon services.

2:28:32And you could see the connection to like buying stuff

2:28:35and leveraging app Amazon's cloud power.

2:28:38It was totally different than the Fire Phone was.

2:28:42But I think it was kind of dumped on at the beginning

2:28:44because people were locked into the Fire Phone was--

2:28:46- You can't actually buy stuff through it.

2:28:49Or can you?

2:28:50I guess what you can do is add stuff to your shopping list.

2:28:52'Cause you can tell--

2:28:53- I think you can buy stuff now.

2:28:55When it launched, you could only add stuff

2:28:57to your shopping list.

2:28:58But I believe they've added buy stuff now.

2:29:00- Oh, and we were playing with it.

2:29:02And Jonas and Amy--

2:29:04- I'm not certain on that.

2:29:05- Jokingly did something like that.

2:29:07And then Alexa said she was adding it to John Gruber's

2:29:12Gruber shopping list and they panicked and they're like no cancel cancel I'm

2:29:18ragging on a little it's an interesting device I don't regret the money I spent

2:29:22on it but it's I'm not as impressed by it as I think you are but maybe I don't

2:29:26have enough of these add-ons that add new services I mean this is so one of

2:29:31the fundamental differences between Alexa and Siri and and let's just

2:29:39imagine that Apple has a Siri device that's the same as Alexa so we're not

2:29:45comparing phones and tablets to the stand this is because it very be very

2:29:49easy for Apple to do the same thing just make a speaker with a microphone that

2:29:52you can say the I'm not gonna say it cuz I know it'll trigger people's phones the

2:29:58hay and then the Siri and then you talk to it hey theory it's very easy don't

2:30:04screw with people Ben. It's very easy to imagine a similar Apple product and it

2:30:10would be very different because the way that Siri works is very different from

2:30:15the way Alexa works in terms of the structure that is expected. Alexa is is

2:30:22far more expects far more structure in what you tell I'm gonna say her tell her

2:30:30to do than Siri does. For better and for worse, in my opinion. I think some of it is significantly

2:30:37worse and it's kind of disappointing. But your argument is that because once you know

2:30:42what you can tell her to do, it works way more reliably?

2:30:47Well, so I think we talked about like, like Siri is definitely trying to focus on like

2:30:52pure natural language processing, where it will figure out what you say, whereas Alexa

2:30:57is much more like you have to say it the right way to get it to work. And so there's multiple

2:31:03factors going on here. So one, and there's a great, I think it was Business Insider,

2:31:07there's a great profile of how like the story of Alexa and how like they were, they presented

2:31:13Bezos and they're like, we're going to have two milliseconds of like latency. And he's

2:31:18like, no, it has to be one. And sorry, but Alexa is unbelievably fast, like in the speed

2:31:25in which it processes kind of like what you say.

2:31:28So the one that's already a plus, I think, over Siri.

2:31:33But two, it's interesting.

2:31:35It's like, it's hard to know, including Google,

2:31:40I think Google is actually still the best.

2:31:43I think it's still better than Alexa, although Alexa is close.

2:31:46No voice recognition is yet at the level

2:31:51where it can interpret everything.

2:31:53And I kind of feel, I feel this both kind of intellectually and also having used different devices,

2:32:00that it's better to fail predictably than it is to fail unpredictably, if that makes sense.

2:32:06Yeah, but--

2:32:07And I feel like Alexa--

2:32:08Mm.

2:32:09I think you're right.

2:32:10I-- you might be right, but I feel like the only proper solution is AI that is so accurate that you almost never get--

2:32:22errors. You know that it, it almost doesn't matter which way

2:32:26you start now, whether you start on the side of failing

2:32:29predictably, like Alexa or failing unpredictably, like

2:32:32Siri, because ultimately, both of them still have are like 1%

2:32:37solutions that are 99% unfulfilled.

2:32:39I agree, but it's weird, because when I feel like when

2:32:44whatever Alexa doesn't understand me, I feel like I

2:32:46did it wrong. And I would say 90% of the time, that's a bad

2:32:51thing for technology. Like technology should have empathy

2:32:54towards the user. And to blame the user is a bad thing. Like

2:32:58there's this article spreading around on Twitter today about

2:33:00like someone losing their Apple Music and there's like counter

2:33:02articles like, "Oh, no, you set it up that way." Like, no,

2:33:04that's Apple Music's fault. Like you should not make a use- you

2:33:07should not enable the circumstances in which a user

2:33:10does the wrong thing, right? But in this particular area, when

2:33:14Alexa, when I say the wrong words, and Alexa doesn't get it,

2:33:18I try to figure out the right words. Like I feel like it's that like I feel like Alexa

2:33:23is really good. So I want to make sure I get it right. Whereas with Siri, I get frustrated

2:33:29and I in part of it is the Siri. I feel like the Siri joking stuff and being jocular is

2:33:36actually really bad for it because it it imparts a degree of accuracy and realism that is on

2:33:48that is just not true it's like over promising and under delivering

2:33:51per point before and oh I don't get that from when Alexa doesn't understand what you're saying

2:33:55it's like sorry I don't understand what you said

2:33:57like it's very straightforward right and I

2:34:00just it's different approaches and I think the Alexa one is better

2:34:04but she says something like I don't understand the question I think you

2:34:08said

2:34:09it right it's like I understand

2:34:12I understand you joke about it it's like I understand your words but I don't know what you're

2:34:16talking about. No, I, the way that what she says, I wish I knew it exactly, but the way

2:34:21the way that she'll say, "I don't understand the question I heard from you,"

2:34:26indicates both that either, either she heard you word for word exactly and

2:34:32doesn't know how to answer that, or maybe she didn't hear you correctly, but either

2:34:36way she can't answer you. And it, you know what I mean? It's kind of an interesting

2:34:39way to phrase the error. I see what you mean, and I have mixed feelings about

2:34:43series jocularity. And it does seem a little un-Apple-like because Apple's

2:34:50actually taken, in large part, especially on iOS, has taken the whimsy out of the

2:34:56visual UI. You know, that one way of looking at the iOS 6 to iOS 7

2:35:03transition, you know, everybody uses the word skeuomorphism, but one way

2:35:08of looking at it, another way of looking at a different word would be that they

2:35:11took a lot of the whimsy out of the UI. That, you know, having wood paneling around Game Center, or a leather, you know, rich Corinthian leather around your calendar, or your find your friends or whatever it was that had the the Corinthian leather is whimsical. And that they took that out. But Siri is chock full of whimsy.

2:35:35Yeah, it's weird because Apple has this brand about perfection. And there is an aspect where,

2:35:44like, it's weird, it's hard, it's really weird to say that, to the extent that Alexa makes it feel

2:35:53like it's my mistake is a good thing. Because, again, that goes against my instincts about

2:35:57product design in general, and that you should strive to make things obvious for the user.

2:36:03but I think it works to its benefit, like, and I think it would serve Apple and the Apple brand better.

2:36:08When Siri screws up, I blame Siri, because Siri has, it's over-promised and under-delivered, frankly.

2:36:15And, and, so this is just at a very high level from the, so one,

2:36:19Alexa's voice recognition is much better than Siri, like, vastly better.

2:36:24One. Two, it's much faster than Siri. - I don't know about that.

2:36:27- Eh, well, for, okay, well, here's my test example.

2:36:30For me, so one, for me, Alexa's much better than Siri.

2:36:34Two, my daughter can trigger Alexa without fail.

2:36:38She's eight years old, and she can rarely trigger Siri, maybe 10% of the time.

2:36:43Three, my four-year-old son can command Alexa maybe 30% of the time,

2:36:50but he definitely can never, ever trigger Siri.

2:36:54And like the degree to which Alexa can handle poor, I mean, immature...

2:37:00>> Pronunciation.

2:37:01>> Yeah, yeah.

2:37:02It's super impressive in my estimation.

2:37:04>> All right.

2:37:05Maybe it is better.

2:37:06I don't know.

2:37:07I told you this.

2:37:09I said the thing.

2:37:10So I'm five days into owning Alexa and I haven't added any significant number of the third

2:37:15party editions, which we should talk to because I know that this having an API period is a

2:37:19huge difference.

2:37:21And I know it's one of the reasons that you're on the Alexa side of the argument.

2:37:25But I set it up and when this query failed, I immediately texted you to complain.

2:37:32You're my tech support for the Echo.

2:37:34But I asked Alexa, "When's the next Golden State Warriors game?"

2:37:41And she said, "I don't understand the question."

2:37:44And then I said, "When is the next Warriors NBA game?"

2:37:47Or something like that.

2:37:48the Golden State and maybe like added NBA and then she got the answer. But I can't believe that,

2:37:53you know, and again I'm not saying that Siri doesn't have the exact same sort of

2:37:57ask the same thing one way and ask it a different way where a human would undeniably interpret the

2:38:04questions the exact same way. No human being would, you know, think that that was a different

2:38:09question even though you phrased it differently and it works one way and doesn't the other. But

2:38:13But to me, Alexa has this exact same shortcoming, where I say "Golden State Warriors" and she

2:38:18doesn't know, and I say "Warriors" and she does, and in fact, that's even counterintuitive

2:38:23to me, and I remember it, because it would seem to me that saying "Golden State Warriors"

2:38:26is more specific.

2:38:29I would go so far as to say that you just say "Golden State" and everybody knows.

2:38:34I would say 99% of the use of the phrase "Golden State" these days is specifically about the

2:38:38Warriors' NBA team.

2:38:40No, I agree, and arguably Alexa should be better, and I'm not going to argue with that.

2:38:46I do think, though, I'm going to shift the debate to my court.

2:38:53Part of where this pays off, though, is the API aspect.

2:38:56So the API works out in two ways.

2:38:59One, there's lots of services you can add, like MBA scores or weather or sources of stuff,

2:39:04and it's all through the Echo app.

2:39:06In a moment, you can bitch about the Echo app.

2:39:08But two, the way like the really exciting thing about Echo is all the household stuff

2:39:13like like like light bulbs and and air conditioning and calling an Uber and all this sort of stuff

2:39:21that is the fact that there is an API in this respect that the relative simplicity of Alexa

2:39:29and that it expects a certain order of words works to its advantage because yes, that puts

2:39:36more of a burden on the user, but it also makes it more viable to add on lots of extra

2:39:42services, right? What's the problem with Siri adding on extra apps? It's that, what's the

2:39:46nomenclature? How do you know that you're asking Spotify as opposed to asking Apple

2:39:49Music, right? I can say Siri, play Taylor Swift, and it will play, but if Spotify's

2:39:55on there, I have to have, what's the trigger for that? And Alexa being simpler makes it

2:40:01more extendable and I'll tell you we're actually building a new house and I'm

2:40:07gonna buy everything to work with Alexa because there there's lots of products

2:40:11and - I'm confident it'll work yeah but Alexa can't can't Alexa can't connect to

2:40:19Spotify can can it it can yes Spotify is on Alexa it is this is interesting where

2:40:26- Where do you have to have Spotify on?

2:40:28- You have to add it through the extras menu,

2:40:32so just make it like an option on Alexa,

2:40:34and you also have to say like play X on Spotify.

2:40:37If you say like play Uptown Funk,

2:40:40it will try to play it on Amazon Prime Music

2:40:43without any modifier,

2:40:44you say play Uptown Funk on Spotify,

2:40:46then it will play it via your Spotify account.

2:40:48But it's only Spotify premium,

2:40:49the Spotify free account does not work.

2:40:51- Huh, that's interesting, I didn't know that.

2:40:53But I don't have Spotify,

2:40:54so it doesn't do me much different.

2:40:55tell you what the one thing my family has been very very nonplussed by by the Echo and Alexa

2:41:03until last night when we started playing music and then it actually that was the first thing that

2:41:10uh that really clicked where we could and it seemed you know I don't know that we stumped

2:41:17Amazon Prime Music. Amazon Prime Music seems to have an awful lot of music. We everything we were

2:41:23looking for, I guess the one thing we there was a live song. We

2:41:28wanted to play. It's a family favorite, one of my favorites,

2:41:32Asia's Heat of the Moment. And when you ask Alexa to play it,

2:41:36all she'll play is a live recording. And there was, we

2:41:40couldn't figure out a way to force her to play the studio

2:41:44recording.

2:41:44Yeah, she probably doesn't have it.

2:41:46Yeah, it might be.

2:41:48It's fascinating, though, like, like, when Mike, like, my kids

2:41:51will walk in the door and immediately issue a command to Alexa. Like it's remarkable. And I

2:42:00don't know, I think this extendability and again, this just take this full circle, like all this

2:42:06podcast is actually integrated. And if the iPhone is slowing growth, like the biggest opportunity

2:42:14for Apple to grow is services. If they want to grow in services, I would argue they have to think

2:42:19about their organization and how they, you know, whether that, like, they should kind

2:42:23of bifurcate it. And by extension, if they, to be effective in services, it entails enabling

2:42:33ecosystems and enabling these sort of plug and play sort of things. And it's gonna, it's

2:42:39a challenge for Apple. And this gets to like real existential questions about companies

2:42:43and how you build them. And how do you balance culture versus what your opportunities are

2:42:49and it's fascinating. This is honestly going to be, I think, the next five years

2:42:54or next two years are going to be some of those absolutely fascinating years

2:42:57when it comes to thinking about Apple and their place in the world going forward.

2:43:01So for us it's going to be great. It's interesting thinking about Siri and APIs

2:43:07because Siri is no longer new. I mean, Siri debuted in 2011.

2:43:12I know it's five years almost. Almost five years, at least four and a half.

2:43:16half. And you know I think a lot of us, I thought, you know an API was inevitable.

2:43:23It's just of course you know and much like the way that the iPhone shipped

2:43:27without third-party apps and then it came you know that Siri is obviously

2:43:31rougher around the edges than the iPhone was but give it some time and there will

2:43:35be an API but now here we are in 2016 and still no API. I would love it. I know

2:43:40know a lot of developers would too. But at this point, if this WWDC in six weeks comes

2:43:48and passes without any mention of a Siri API, I really have to start thinking that Apple's

2:43:53strategy with Siri is that it's proprietary and first party only.

2:43:58Yeah, it's interesting. I mean, that makes sense, I guess, if you want to. I mean, if

2:44:06want to put like like I said it keeps me subscribed Apple music a Siri is the

2:44:10reason I'm still subscribed Apple music yeah interesting so anything else you

2:44:14want to talk about Ben we got a wrap up and going forever well I what's the

2:44:18record I think the Syracuse have the record right now we're at we're at two

2:44:21minutes and 51 seconds so or two hours if you're doing I don't think anybody's

2:44:25gonna break Syracuse this record Syracuse and I think the episode was

2:44:28Syracuse it was let me look here six hours 47 minutes no it was a six it was

2:44:34not six hours we had a hard limit hard limit at seven so we've wrapped up at

2:44:39six six hours 47 minutes we could go NBA court according you want to talk to your

2:44:44podcast last week I always love to talk NBA yeah I mean how did you watch that

2:44:52that the San Antonio OKC ending that last 13 seconds?

2:44:57- I did.

2:44:59So San Antonio was...

2:45:01Wait, how well was this?

2:45:05- The one where Dion Waiters shoved Manu Janovali.

2:45:08- Right.

2:45:09- From an out of bounds position.

2:45:10In which no one has ever, the refs at the end,

2:45:13the best part was the end of the game,

2:45:14the refs issued an end of game report

2:45:16or they interviewed them.

2:45:17They're like, one, we missed the call.

2:45:19It should have been offensive foul.

2:45:20Two, we've never seen that before.

2:45:23So like, it was just totally understandable, right?

2:45:26A reffing is almost, a lot of it's about anticipating stuff

2:45:30and when something happens you've never seen before

2:45:32and you're in the heat of the moment

2:45:33and there's so much going on,

2:45:35like you can't, you don't even think to blow your whistle

2:45:37'cause you're like, what the hell was that?

2:45:38- I mean, you're a bit, you're a diehard NBA fan.

2:45:41I used to be more of a basketball fan.

2:45:43I've really gotten into it.

2:45:43I feel like, just because I feel like the league

2:45:46is having a resurgence in that there's a lot

2:45:50interesting stuff going on. And I've said this on the show many times before, a lot

2:45:53of times in the context of baseball, which is still my favorite sport, but that my friend

2:45:58Matt Wang, if Matt's listening, I know he listens to the show, but he'll appreciate

2:46:03that I call him out. But his basic idea is that there's two types of sports fans, fundamentally.

2:46:08Story people and stats people. And that story people can still appreciate stats and stats

2:46:13people can still get into the stories, but there's, you know, fundamentally there's one

2:46:18One of the other is the reason you love sports.

2:46:20And I'm a story person.

2:46:21And to me, the stories in the NBA right now are as good as they've ever been.

2:46:26It's like almost back to the heyday in the 80s and Jordan era, 90s.

2:46:31And part of it is just the way that the personalities of the superstars are so different.

2:46:37LeBron and Steph Curry are such different players that it makes for a compelling narrative.

2:46:43And you've got Tim Duncan wrapping up his career, etc.

2:46:46But anyway, one of my observations, I just want to see if you agree, is that the refereeing

2:46:51in the playoffs so far has aired almost game to game on the side of no calls.

2:46:58Like you can, at the end of a game, you could just shoot a guy with a gun and you're not

2:47:02going to get called for a foul.

2:47:04So one of my guilty pleasures is the Dan LeBertard show, which is like this ridiculous sports

2:47:10talk show from Miami.

2:47:12But as I follow him on Twitter, he tweeted during that OKC San Antonio thing, he's like,

2:47:17"I think I saw a machete under the basket."

2:47:21Which was ridiculous, but it captured that last play.

2:47:24There was so much malfeasance happening on the court in a span of 13 seconds.

2:47:29Yeah, it looked like a playground game.

2:47:33It really looked like a playground game that had gotten out of hand.

2:47:35And it was like, "There's gotta be a foul somewhere.

2:47:38If you miss a call, you miss a call, but how can you miss all of them?"

2:47:41I know. But it was so great because, like, one, there was aspects of that play that captured

2:47:50everything about both teams. Like OKC ran a miserable inbounds play and turned the ball over,

2:47:57and yet they, yet they, their defense was incredible on that play. The fact was Steven Adams

2:48:02blocked or contested like three different Spurs shot opportunities and they, and like,

2:48:09And that's OKC, right? They suck at organized basketball, but they're so overwhelming

2:48:14athletically that they make up for it. And it was great. And then there's all the debate on Twitter,

2:48:20and there's all the vines. The way the NBA has been like, "Post what you want on YouTube,

2:48:25post what you want on Twitter," and all that sort of stuff, it's so forward thinking.

2:48:29NBA Twitter is like the perfect manifestation of what Twitter could be.

2:48:33Like, when you follow the right—you get into NBA Twitter, and you follow the right folks,

2:48:38and like all the debate and all the jokes and all the memes, it's incredible. To watch an NBA game

2:48:45with NBA Twitter, and shamefully the NBA app doesn't handle the split screen on the iPad,

2:48:51which is a bummer, but the iPad is awesome because you can watch the game and have the Twitter on the

2:48:56side. It really is a revolutionary sort of experience and it really is like the best

2:49:02manifestation of Twitter and kind of sports going forward. Yeah, for anybody who's like me,

2:49:08like my favorite US pro support is baseball. My second favorite now is probably the NBA, definitely the NBA.

2:49:13And I've long resented this popularity of the NFL, but the overwhelming popularity of the NFL,

2:49:20to me, the advantage is it makes the other leagues a little bit more, I think, liberal with their,

2:49:26or forward-thinking with the social media. You know, like I know the MLB was, you know, like when

2:49:32Meerkat and Periscope came out, they were like, "Yeah, sure, you know, do it."

2:49:37You know, like if any, you know, there's no way that they just say recognize the truth

2:49:41Which is that there's no way that anybody watching the periscope of a baseball game from

2:49:45However, good your seat is is ever gonna be better than watching the actual broadcast

2:49:49So just do it and if you catch something cool, you know share it. I

2:49:53Definitely think that it's an advantage to be a fan of the not preeminent league because that the NFL is way more

2:50:02Stick up the butt about stuff like that

2:50:07So big picture let's not get specific big picture. How do you see the NBA playoffs to turn it out?

2:50:11You think what do you think they're gonna do with Steph Curry? I

2:50:13Think they're gonna sell I think they're gonna sit them until

2:50:17Until they have two losses in this series and I don't think they're gonna have two losses in this series

2:50:23So I don't think we're gonna see Steph Curry play until the next series

2:50:26Yeah, I will tell you I love what this kind of period is doing for the reputation of Draymond Green like he

2:50:33That game like he's an incredible player. He really is that said there's an argument

2:50:40He said if curry is ready like better for him to knock. He's gonna be rusty

2:50:45You saw him in the game against the Rockets better for him to knock the rust off against the Blazers

2:50:48And knock the rust off against against the Spurs because you lose one game in Oracle and like your backs against the wall

2:50:55and so I

2:50:57Don't know like there was a great article by Tim Grover

2:51:00Michael Jordan's trainer talking about the fact that he actually believes that

2:51:04Curry's knee injury was caused by his ankle. Yeah, I saw that article. He was

2:51:09probably wearing a very, a brace which transferred the kind of kinetic injury

2:51:13up, kinetic energy of the slip up to his knee. Yep. Which makes makes a ton of

2:51:19sense. At the same time, like, you know, you got to knock off the rust at some

2:51:23point and and if they can handle the Blazers arguably it's better to do it

2:51:27Yeah, then maybe he should yeah, I could see that but even so I don't I still don't think he's gonna play Saturday

2:51:32No matter what I'd say

2:51:34And so maybe they'll let him knock the rust off in game four if you know win or lose

2:51:39But you know, I really don't think they're gonna let him play

2:51:43Play on Saturday

2:51:46yeah, no, I think and in

2:51:48Ideally, they bring him back and he can come in like maybe against bench units

2:51:52I was that you don't want him covering Willard right?

2:51:54And Miller's a great player and he's gonna force you into these really harsh lateral movements and

2:51:59Hopefully they can ease it back in if he's healthy. I think Golden State's the overall in favor

2:52:04I think they're a bad match for San Antonio like they just San Antonio. I

2:52:09Think it's gonna have a time with those two great shooting guards and they put in the pick and roll

2:52:14If he's not healthy though

2:52:17The thing with San Antonio is Danny Green

2:52:19He's shot the three terribly all year and he's been good the last couple games if he is knocking down that three

2:52:26They're they're they're a tough team

2:52:29so I

2:52:31Hope because I'm a story guy. Here's how I hope it plays out

2:52:34I hope it's Golden State versus San Antonio in the West and

2:52:37Just like you know, you've got a new podcast with a friend of the show Manton Reese

2:52:41Dedicated to basketball technical foul put a link to it in the show notes good podcast

2:52:48And you guys have mentioned this that it what an amazing is he be a better story in the east if it is

2:52:55LeBron James and the Cavs against the Miami Heat

2:52:57It would be awesome. Like it'd be awesome. I'm sorry if you're like a Toronto fan, you know

2:53:03I mean, I know you're not gonna root for Miami. But I mean you got to realize that everybody else is

2:53:07rooting for Miami versus the Cavaliers because man that it's playoff game

2:53:14LeBron on the road playing in Miami in a playoff game for the Eastern finals?

2:53:19Especially because like there's still like there's still questions about LeBron's kind of mental

2:53:24strength, right? Right. I mean like he's had two playoff series against Boston and against Dallas

2:53:31where he kind of melted down mentally and if he's going up against his old teammates and they're

2:53:36getting in his head like you Cleveland's the better team but you can envision a possibility

2:53:43where Miami wins games they shouldn't. And Dwayne Wade has been amazing these playoffs.

2:53:49Yeah, he's got that look of the elder statesman who's in the last gasp of his preeminence

2:53:56athletically, but his smarts compensate for it. It's sort of like late era Jordan on the

2:54:05Bulls. You could tell he's half a step, but he makes up for the half step mentally.

2:54:12Like the I mean the greatest example is the time Jordan stole the ball from

2:54:16Malone Malone

2:54:20He just knew he just see he knew exactly what Malone was gonna do and his hand was there

2:54:24We got a wrap-up, but the other thing too is you because you don't watch baseball

2:54:28Did you I'll put this in the show notes, but you know, clay Thompson speaking of the Warriors, you know

2:54:32His brother's a baseball player, right?

2:54:34Yeah, why the reason I know about it is because I think he says something to his press conference after a recent game about his

2:54:39brother just crushed them all. Well, his brother is a Trace Thompson, plays for

2:54:43the Dodgers and the Dodgers were playing the Tampa Bay Rays, which is interesting

2:54:49because it's interleague baseball. Interleague, you don't play American in

2:54:53the National League and other than the rivals that are in the same town, you

2:54:56don't play every year. So the Dodgers hadn't been to Tampa Bay since like 2007.

2:55:00So it's a rare thing for the Dodgers to be playing in Tampa Bay and Tampa Bay

2:55:03has the worst baseball stadium ever in Major League Baseball. It's this horrible dome called

2:55:12Tropicana Field. Paul Kefasis and I went there last year just to see it because they've got to

2:55:18close it soon. It's horrible. It's a dome. It is ugly. It smells bad. It smells like you're in a

2:55:25Sam's Club or something like that. And it's actually physically, it should be illegal. It's

2:55:31like the dome isn't high enough, so balls get caught up in the rafters all the time.

2:55:35And there's all sorts of rules. There's like different tiers. The field rules are so...

2:55:46There's like this whole book of rules of if a ball hits this rafter, it's in play. So

2:55:50you can hit it, and then if a guy catches it, it's an out. And if it hits these rafters,

2:55:55this, this, or this, it's a home run. And so his brother hit a ball that disappeared.

2:56:00It just went up into the rafters and never came down.

2:56:03But it was the rule the whole properly because it would have been over the fence in any other

2:56:07stadium.

2:56:08But it just disappeared.

2:56:11Which is, even in their crap field, it almost never happens that the ball just doesn't come

2:56:16down.

2:56:17And the next day, he wanted to go up and find it.

2:56:19He wanted to see if he could go up and find it in the rafters and he wasn't allowed to

2:56:22because he was told that they're not safe.

2:56:27The field is so janky that they thought that if he went up there, maybe the rafters will

2:56:32collapse.

2:56:33I thought that was a funny story and a nice crossover between baseball and basketball.

2:56:38All right, let's wrap it up.

2:56:41Ben Thompson, we crossed the three-hour mark.

2:56:43I feel, I think this is the first time we've crossed the three-hour mark, so I feel accomplished.

2:56:46Let's see what comes out in the editing, but yeah, probably.

2:56:50Your excellent daily update at Stratechery is, what's the website?

2:56:56Yeah, so sashakri.com has one free article a week and then I will mail you something

2:57:03an additional three days a week.

2:57:05Well worth it.

2:57:06It is.

2:57:07Your cash?

2:57:08Honestly, anybody who enjoys Ben on the show, it is enormously worth the money.

2:57:13It's a great value.

2:57:16You can find him on Twitter.

2:57:17He's, what are you now, Ben Thompson?

2:57:20Yep, @BenThompson.

2:57:21@BenThompson.

2:57:22You used to have a goofy name, right?

2:57:24I did, @monkbent, M-O-F-K-B-N-T, which is now,

2:57:28I still, unfortunately still on the account.

2:57:30It's funny, when you change your Twitter name,

2:57:32Twitter doesn't like reserve your old name.

2:57:34- Right.

2:57:35- That was my Twitter name for a long time,

2:57:37which I now still control,

2:57:39but I don't tweet from it anymore.

2:57:41- And the new, well, you got the Exponent FM,

2:57:44which is a podcast which is more in line with the talk show,

2:57:48you know, talking about tech and stuff like that

2:57:50at exponent.fm.

2:57:51But more importantly for this playoff stretch,

2:57:53You've got the technical foul podcast with Manton and that's at what'd you say technical foul dot FM?

2:58:00Yep, technical foul dot FM get it technical foul because they're they're like two tech guys

2:58:06And if in case you couldn't get it we capitalize T eck which you harshly criticize us for probably rightly on our back channel slack

2:58:15Yeah, terrible that did stop that

2:58:19And our my thanks to I think we just passed we just passed the stuff the stuff line my thanks to our sponsors

2:58:27Automatic the connected car dingus

2:58:30Wealthfront put all your investment in there make make lots of money and audible.com the audiobook company

2:58:37My thanks to view. Thanks

2:58:40[ Silence ]