0:00:00Hey there. I feel like I just saw you. Well, I feel like I did just see you. I mean, like
0:00:06it was, it's not like one of those euphemisms. Boy, it seems like it was, it was like Monday,
0:00:11Monday afternoon. What a week. Yeah, it's a big week. I was, did you see a baseball
0:00:22prospectus is launching an entire site devoted to the Mets? I had that moment of like, the
0:00:27that. It turns out they've got a bunch of local sites. They already have a Bronx site
0:00:32for the Yankees. They don't have a Giants site, though. I feel slighted there. But it's
0:00:39baseball. It's coming. It's gotta be coming. Giants are too big. It's a big market. And
0:00:45they're a good team. I'm sure it'll happen. But ESPN did that. They launched like ESPN
0:00:48Boston or something. Yeah, exactly. ESPN has a New York. Yeah. But they never did a California
0:00:56even, let alone Bay Area sports sub-site. I don't know what it is. I think it's
0:01:00because people in California don't care about sports. I think that's probably actually
0:01:04the fact per capita. Some of us care about it, but most of us don't.
0:01:10Dave Asprey Have you looked at the MLB app for Apple TV
0:01:15recently, like in the preseason? Tim Cynova
0:01:18No, I haven't. Dave Asprey
0:01:19It has regressed in some very disappointing ways.
0:01:23I think, and this is because people ask, you know, they probably ask you this, they definitely
0:01:28ask me this because I've written about that app a bunch and I went to, I just went to
0:01:32New York and met those guys, which was really cool to go to the MLB Advanced Media offices.
0:01:40And the good guys, they love the Apple platforms, they've got a great team of developers. They
0:01:44were really happy about the new Apple TV because the, did you ever see their PlayStation app?
0:01:50No. Oh, it was amazing. It was better
0:01:53I think maybe the Xbox one app is like this now
0:01:56but there was a period in there where the PlayStation app was the MLB app like it had
0:02:01you could see the metadata that they would drop in of like when there was a hit or when there was a homer or when there
0:02:07Was a run and you could use the you know PlayStation controller to like jump jump to the next scoring play
0:02:12Just incredible amounts of data. It was it was way more complex than anything I've seen on any other platform
0:02:18So, I knew they were going to be excited about the Apple TV because they would be able to
0:02:22build an app instead of just sort of like a list of streams. But the problem with the
0:02:27MLB stuff is they make these press releases for spring training, but in reality, their
0:02:31ship date is like the first day of the season. So, I am reluctant to write about their apps
0:02:37during spring training because they're, you know, first off, the data that's being
0:02:43collected and the video that's being generated is not of, it's like substandard quality
0:02:48because it's not the regular season. So that's a big part of it. And I do think they're busy
0:02:53doing the app version that's going to release on opening day. And that's the one to write about
0:02:58because I bet that it's, yeah, what they've got on the Apple TV right now, what they've got on
0:03:03the iPad right now. It's like, yeah, it's okay. But it's like spring training mode. I feel like
0:03:07there's always a better version that drops at the end of March. I think so. I hope so. I think,
0:03:13though that in this particular case I think that they might be sort of, well, I was going
0:03:20to say behind the eight ball, but I might be mixing metaphors. But I feel like the platform
0:03:24changes are so significant that I think they'll get there eventually because like you said,
0:03:29it's a phenomenal team and they really do care. But at the moment, it's really kind
0:03:34of weird how it's like worse than the old Apple TV app.
0:03:37Yeah, that's not good. That's not good.
0:03:40The big one is that you can't decide, like if you,
0:03:43let's say you start to watch a game after it started,
0:03:45but it's on, like the game started at seven
0:03:48and you start watching at eight.
0:03:49You don't even get the choice anymore
0:03:50of whether you want to start from the beginning
0:03:52or watch live.
0:03:53It just sort of streams and puts you like, you know,
0:03:5630 seconds behind live.
0:03:57- Oh, that's not good.
0:03:58No, they mean to-
0:03:59- But I'm sure they'll get to the bottom of it.
0:04:00- Yeah, I'm sure they will.
0:04:01So you're a Yankee fan in Philly, so-
0:04:05- Right.
0:04:06- You're out of market. - So I'm very lucky, right.
0:04:08there was this big class action lawsuit about a lot of things involving sports leagues and
0:04:15video and in in out of market video and stuff like that and it's it's uh things are are changing
0:04:21starting this year and one of the things that they changed is that they're offering like a
0:04:25one team in market streaming package would you buy that instead of the everything it's like you could
0:04:30say 40 bucks or 30 bucks and and just get yankees games or would you do you want the whole spread or
0:04:36Do you buy the package? Do you buy the... I do buy the package. No, I definitely buy it.
0:04:40And it's lucky. And for those of you who aren't sports fans, you know,
0:04:43well, you got to listen to some sports talk on this show. But the gist of the in-market thing is,
0:04:48and it sounds crazy, but if you're not a sports fan, you might think it's super crazy, is that
0:04:54if you live in the home market of a team, so let's say for me, that would be the Philadelphia
0:05:01Phillies. You can't stream their games home or away because the idea is you're
0:05:09supposed to pay for cable to get the channel on cable that pays to carry
0:05:13their games locally. But you can pay MLB, what is it, like 120 a year? Well, so part
0:05:18of the settlement of the lawsuit, it's 100 this year. So for 100 bucks, you
0:05:24can get the MLB thing and you can watch every game except for the ones that are
0:05:30local to you. But they definitely, you know, and I'm sure that there's ways around it with
0:05:34VPNs and stuff like that, but... It's tough on iOS, though, because iOS has location services, so
0:05:41if you've got location services turned on, it's easier on a Mac to fake where you are in the world,
0:05:47but it's harder on an iPhone or an iPad. Right, like the one time I was out, I remember it was like two years ago,
0:05:52I think it was two years ago, the Yankees were playing the Oakland Athletics, and I was out for WWDC,
0:05:57DC and I wanted to pop the game on my iPhone and they were like, "You can't watch it."
0:06:00And I'm like, "Oh, you must have the wrong location for me." And I'm like, "Oh, wait.
0:06:06You have the right location for me. It's an A's game."
0:06:09It's one of those—I mean, this is not just a sports conversation because it's about how
0:06:12technology is totally swamping the entertainment industry. This is like a TV industry problem
0:06:20and how do you protect—I mean, it's very easy to say, "Well, people are cutting the
0:06:23cord. You just have to deal with it. It's stupid that they're not offering it." But
0:06:26If you look at the deal the Dodgers signed, their cable deal in LA is worth like $30 billion
0:06:32or something like that. It's insane. It is an amazing amount of money. Why is it that
0:06:38much money? The answer is because the cable company figures that if they control the Dodgers'
0:06:42TV rights, Dodger fans in LA can't cut the cord. That's why it's worth as much as
0:06:48it is, is because of that, which, you know, but at some point, I don't know what happens.
0:06:55At some point, cable goes down to the point where they're going to have to try to find
0:06:58another way to make money. One of the things about this shift that's happening with that
0:07:05class action settlement is in parallel, they're making deals with local cable companies. So,
0:07:14What's interesting about that is it means that if you have a cable login, so this is
0:07:18not for cord cutters, but like, I used to work in downtown San Francisco two blocks
0:07:22from the Giants ballpark, and I pay for cable.
0:07:26And yet I couldn't sit in my office and watch the Giants game that was happening, because
0:07:31I was in the local market, even though I could watch it at home or I could use like a Slingbox
0:07:35to watch it, and that's changing.
0:07:37They made a deal with most, but not all, it's like 22 teams now, where if you've got a cable
0:07:42log in, you can watch the game. Even if it's a local game, you can watch it. And that seems
0:07:48to be the next frontier for streaming is going to be everything is unlocked if you're paying
0:07:52for cable in some form.
0:07:54Yeah, the weird thing, one of the weird things is that you don't see the commercials, or
0:07:58at least not the standard. Sometimes they sell other commercials, but usually the space
0:08:03between innings is just dead air, and they're like, you know, in between innings or something
0:08:07like that, you know, standby, the game will come back. And I had the idea years ago, and
0:08:12you know, every time this has ever come up on the podcast, people write in and they say,
0:08:15"Why don't they just show the commercials? If the way they make money is to sell commercials,
0:08:20just show the same commercials to the people watching live." But it's what you said, which
0:08:24is that the cable companies see it as a reason to get cable. It's more than just the commercials.
0:08:29Yeah, they make their money on cable subscriptions. The commercials are a bonus. It's just like,
0:08:33you know, you pay for a magazine subscription back in the day, but it still had ads in the
0:08:37magazine. You get money from both streams come in and that's how you fund whatever
0:08:43you're doing. And so I do wonder if part of the deal of showing local channels to people
0:08:49who are local cable subscribers is that they have to set up like a feed where you're seeing
0:08:54the local ads because that's probably one of the sticking points of the deal, right?
0:09:00They've guaranteed their advertisers this coverage. So that might be—that's a technical
0:09:06thing where, you know, the Fox Sports Southwest has to feed the Diamondbacks games to MLB
0:09:15Advanced Media. It's probably, I mean, they're doing it anyway, but they probably feed a
0:09:18version with commercials to them or something. It's technical, probably, more than anything
0:09:21else, but that's why this is all complicated for all this stuff. There are contracts, and
0:09:26there's big money, and there's technical limitations, and as tech people, we think, "Well, we can
0:09:32solve this. We can solve this technologically." And then you realize, "Oh, tech is not the
0:09:37problem." MLB Advanced Media is one of the most advanced streaming media organizations
0:09:43in the world, maybe the most. They do so much for other people that people don't know about.
0:09:48They're streaming the HBO Now service. They've done CBS's sports stuff. I think they do ESPN's
0:09:53stuff. I mean, they are very good at what they do. Technical is not the problem. The
0:09:58The problem is contracts that still exist and money where, you know, if a cable company
0:10:04in LA is going to pay $30 billion for 30 years or 20 years or whatever of rights to the Dodgers,
0:10:12then it's kind of hard to walk away from that if you're, you know, if you're Major
0:10:16League Baseball, even if it does shut out cord cutters, because that's a lot of money.
0:10:19Yeah, and remember that two years ago when HBO tried to do their own thing with HBO Go,
0:10:26When the Game of Thrones premiere came out, it completely collapsed and they were literally
0:10:31reduced to asking people, "Hey, why don't you wait a day?"
0:10:36They got rid of the guy, too.
0:10:37That's the most shocking thing.
0:10:39The story is that their CTO was building this streaming infrastructure on the inside of
0:10:44HBO.
0:10:45They were like, "Well, yeah, but we're talking to Major League Baseball if we could use them."
0:10:50He's like, "No, no, no, no, no.
0:10:51We're going to do it."
0:10:52Then there was that one day where they announced they were going to go with Major League Baseball
0:10:56and that guy was leaving the company.
0:10:57It was like, "Wow."
0:10:58And then last year, when they had the MLB advanced media backed streaming system, it
0:11:04was apparently seamless.
0:11:06Rock solid, yeah.
0:11:07I mean, I guess it's never perfect for everybody, but even cable's not perfect for everybody.
0:11:14The other weird thing on this, well, weird for me, because as a Yankees fan, but it's
0:11:18a lot of the pre-season coverage is the fact that Comcast still doesn't have...
0:11:23they dropped the Yes Network, which is the Yankees entertainment and sports network that
0:11:27carries at least 150 out of the 162 games a year. There's like 12 that are on Fox,
0:11:34maybe a couple more than that because there's some on ESPN, but 140-some games at least
0:11:38a year. Comcast dropped them in November and still hasn't picked them back up. At least
0:11:46as of this recording, Friday, March 25th, the Yankees aren't going to be on TV if
0:11:50if you're in New York, if you have cable.
0:11:52Oh, so that's actually a very similar situation
0:11:55to what's happened in LA for people who don't know.
0:11:57LA, Time Warner Cable, has had this Dodgers deal,
0:12:01and they have not been able to come to agreement
0:12:04with the other cable company or satellite providers that
0:12:07serve people in LA.
0:12:08So there's a tiny percentage of people
0:12:10in LA who are able to see the bulk of the Dodger
0:12:12games on TV.
0:12:13And I think that's still not worked out,
0:12:14although I read somewhere that that was going to be worked out.
0:12:17But it's kind of awful.
0:12:20But this is, you know, it's like I talk about this.
0:12:23So I do every week I do a podcast with Tim Goodman
0:12:25from The Hollywood Reporter.
0:12:26And we talk about this same thing a lot
0:12:28'cause it's transforming all entertainment.
0:12:30All TV is doing this and it's like a death spiral.
0:12:33I mean, they don't know where this is going.
0:12:35They are desperately paying money to try and hold on
0:12:37or mitigate how far the fall is, how fast it is.
0:12:42I mean, and so you end up in these situations
0:12:45where it makes no sense that the people of Los Angeles
0:12:48New York can't see these baseball teams on their TV set and yet this is where we
0:12:54are because there are bigger issues like the entire future of
0:12:58their industry that they feel are at play.
0:13:00Yeah, and it seems like it would only be fair if Comcast doesn't have the
0:13:05Yankees and you're a Comcast customer that you should be able to get the MLB
0:13:09app package, but it doesn't work that way. I think you're just blocked out,
0:13:15which would drive me nuts. I don't know. And it's like a lot of negotiations when there
0:13:23really is a hard deadline, which is opening day, which is a week away. I wouldn't be surprised
0:13:27if a deal gets hammered out in the next week, but it just seems, I don't know. But like
0:13:33I said, it's dominating the preseason talk about the Yankees because everybody's panicked
0:13:37that they're not going to be able to watch the games.
0:13:40Some of the problems with this, I mean, this goes to business models like on the web and
0:13:44everywhere else, which is getting people to pay for a premium service is great, but it's
0:13:47not the same as having everybody have it, right? You lose this whole layer of casual
0:13:52fans in the case of baseball who are going to flip on a game and watch it from time to
0:13:56time, but they're not going to ever pay $100 a year to do that, right? And so, and that's
0:14:02why they don't, that's why, you know, Time Warner Cable in LA is not going to create
0:14:07a Dodger fan package for everybody who isn't a Time Warner Cable customer to pay them $10
0:14:13or $20 a month to watch the Dodgers because that's not their endgame. They want to cut
0:14:17a deal with Comcast or whoever who will pay them a few dollars off of the bill of every
0:14:24single subscriber and then it goes everywhere. I have a friend who's a cricket fan and
0:14:30he's in Canada and he watches all these Indian cricket league matches and I was like,
0:14:36"Oh, well that's interesting. I can check that out. You can't get it in the US."
0:14:39Well you can, but it's priced for the hardcore fan. They've gone the other way where it's
0:14:43like you can't be a casual fan of that thing in America, of cricket, because there is a
0:14:49small group of people who love it and will pay like $100 to see one cricket tournament
0:14:54or whatever they call them, and that's what they're going for. And you know, baseball
0:14:59doesn't want to do that. They want to be, these are mainstream sports, they want to
0:15:03make the deal where they get a huge amount of money and it's available to everybody,
0:15:08And it makes me wonder about the future of broad appeal stuff if everything is a la carte,
0:15:15because there's a lot of stuff that you're willing to watch if it's on, but are you willing
0:15:19to pay for it?
0:15:21That's very true.
0:15:23All right, as good a time as any to take a break and thank our first sponsor, it's our
0:15:29old friends at Backblaze.
0:15:31You guys know Backblaze, online backup for your Mac.
0:15:35It also works on a PC.
0:15:37I haven't tried it on a PC because I don't have one, but on a Mac.
0:15:40This is what I would recommend, even if they don't, we're sponsoring a show.
0:15:44If you say, what should I do to back up my computer?
0:15:46I would tell you to have a system where you back up locally, back up, you know, use time
0:15:50machine, maybe use, I use super duper, make a, keep a clone of my startup drive.
0:15:55But have something that is outside your office, out of your house, something offsite, just
0:16:00in case disaster strikes.
0:16:04breaks in, steals your computer, water damage, like something leaks over your
0:16:08desk, gets all over your computer, ruins everything. Who knows? Anything like that
0:16:12could happen. If you have an off-site backup, you don't lose all of your data.
0:16:17These guys are great. They're former. The Mac version is written by
0:16:22former Apple engineers. It runs natively on your Mac. You'll never notice it. You
0:16:26don't have to put Java on your computer or anything like that. It's just native
0:16:29Mac OS X code. You'll never even notice that it's running. You just install it.
0:16:33you get a free trial at backblaze.com/daringfireball. You can start with a free trial. No credit card, no risk. Just try and see how easy it is, how seamless it is.
0:16:44And then when you're ready to go, it's an amazing deal. It's just five bucks a month per computer. And it's unlimited. There's no limit to how much data.
0:16:54The only limit on the data is how long it takes for you to do your first backup before it goes incremental after that.
0:16:59that. You don't pay more if you have a lot of data. It's just five bucks per
0:17:03Mac for unlimited backup. I said it before, I'll say it again. Someday I hope
0:17:08that these guys stop sponsoring the show because everybody who listens to the
0:17:12show is signed up for it and has got their family members signed up for it too,
0:17:16and everything backed up to backblaze. And I'll just reiterate, you can restore
0:17:23one file at a time. Go to the website, find the file you want, get it. If you
0:17:27want to get everything back you can order a USB hard drive they'll put
0:17:30everything onto a hard drive and FedEx FedEx it to you so whether you need
0:17:35everything or whether you just need one file back please work so go to back
0:17:38blaze comm slash daring fireball and sign up now if you haven't I guess we
0:17:45should start with the with the event right we get to start with the event
0:17:49then talk about the actual devices yeah I mean that seems like a good place to
0:17:53to start.
0:17:54Everybody, so many people, I say everybody, but so many complaints that it was, "Oh, this
0:17:58is a boring event.
0:17:59Why did they have an event?"
0:18:00I kind of, the more I think about it, I think an event like this week's is actually more
0:18:03interesting if you're like an Apple nerd than the bigger ones because I feel like it's a
0:18:09little bit more revealing.
0:18:15For example, just for example, like Jaws is a segment.
0:18:18do you introduce a phone that has nothing new about it? It's a...
0:18:25well, think about it though. It's a design that we've seen before. Okay, so
0:18:29rose gold is new, but we have seen rose gold before. And all of the stuff that's
0:18:36in the phone, the A9 processor, the camera from the iPhone 6s, being able to do
0:18:45Apple Pay with the Touch ID sensor. We've seen it all before. So how do you
0:18:49spend 10 or 15 minutes on stage talking about a phone that
0:18:54everything I just said about is true? And we saw it. Literally nothing
0:18:58new about that product other than the mixture of it. But you're right. The
0:19:04the broad mainstream wants to see something like totally new blowing you
0:19:08away from Apple every single time, which is unrealistic, but that's why you always
0:19:12get the disappointing event every time. Every time there's an Apple event, people say it's
0:19:16disappointing because that's just, unless it's the new iPhone, like the original iPhone or the
0:19:20original iPad, it's just not going to be exciting. But for us, you're right. It becomes about like,
0:19:26how does Apple communicate something like the iPhone SE and what is their positioning? Like,
0:19:32why would you do that? Why would you do something? Because although there's no parts in it that are
0:19:36new, it is the first time they've ever done a product like this. So it is new strategy-wise.
0:19:44So if we care about strategy, then it's actually really interesting.
0:19:47Right. And I feel like that's a little bit, in a way, it's more interesting for us as the,
0:19:53you know, like I always say, "cremelanologist," to sort of parse out what they're doing with this.
0:19:57Whereas if they had something altogether new, like a totally top-secret thing to make the iPhone
0:20:04only two millimeters thick, like ridiculously thin. It's really just like a piece of glass.
0:20:08It looks like the phone from Looper. Well, that sells itself, right? It's like that's not hard to
0:20:16pitch because you've got this thing that's like, "Oh my god, just look at it. I can't believe they
0:20:19made that." Whereas this is a lot more strategic. And it is. It is. This, like, for example, this is
0:20:25the first time they've made a third phone from an industrial design, right? There was the iPhone 5,
0:20:31then the 5S, and now the new one, the SE, is the first time they've reused a design for the third
0:20:37time. A physical design. Yeah, I mean, I guess you could argue the 5C is close to the design of the
0:20:45others, right? It's just the back plate is kind of different. But yeah, I guess it's a classic now.
0:20:51I mean, if you think about it, yeah, the 4 is... 5 is just an elongated 4 in a lot of ways. So
0:20:57So that's a design that has been with us for a very long time.
0:21:01Well, but similar, but not as similar as this, where you could...
0:21:05If you took the white one... I mean, that space black is different because they changed
0:21:10the color with the 5 and 5S, but I think if you took the white one with the regular aluminum
0:21:14back, you would really have to get close to be able to tell a 5S SE apart.
0:21:19They're dead ringers. I mean, I brought a 5S with me to the event, thinking this would
0:21:26be like this. I took some pictures and I mean they're dead ringers. They fit in the same
0:21:29cases. The chamfer is matte instead of shiny, okay. The printing on the back is different
0:21:35and the Apple on the back is different because it's I think screen printed in some way on
0:21:39the 5S and it's like a stainless steel cutout like the modern phones on the new one, on
0:21:45the SE. But otherwise, I mean, it's the same phone. It's not a rethink of what that phone
0:21:52should be like. It is the old design with new insides.
0:21:57Yeah, I sort of, I think, in a sense, it to me makes it the, it's like the all-time best
0:22:03iPhone design, because it's the only one that got a third, a third go-around.
0:22:07Yeah, I think, I think maybe you're right. I have a soft spot for the original iPhone
0:22:10design. I was saying to somebody the other day that I feel like the original iPhone is
0:22:13both my favorite design and also has some of the worst design elements in it of any
0:22:18but I do I kind of like how how rounded the that original iPhone is but but the
0:22:25five design is great and I like it a lot I saw somebody on Twitter was asking for
0:22:30an iPhone SE case that is as close as possible to the original iPhone like it
0:22:36would have to be longer obviously because the screens longer but that was
0:22:39a good design too it was it was although I laugh at it now because I've got one
0:22:43here and I look at it every now and then when a new iPhone comes out it's like
0:22:45like, some of it is really beautiful, and then there's like the chrome, because it's
0:22:49got like that soft, like the brushed aluminum back, but the front has got the shiny chrome
0:22:54frame, and I'm like, wow, that's not, I mean, they would not have ever done that after that,
0:23:00but that was what they did. You could see, they were just getting their feet wet. They
0:23:04were learning at that point.
0:23:05I feel like they've come so far in terms of how they fit pieces together, across all of
0:23:11their devices really. Like if you look back and think to like the the titanium
0:23:16power book which was sort of the forebearer of all modern power books and
0:23:22Mac books. I mean it was even made of a different material. They
0:23:27didn't get to aluminum yet and there were a lot of problems with titanium
0:23:30with the flaking off of the coating. But the big difference to me was that
0:23:35there were little plastic pieces across all of the seams. Like they couldn't just
0:23:39make a corner out of titanium, it all needed to be sealed up with a plastic corner. And
0:23:44the original iPhone was sort of like that too, where they needed like a piece of—like
0:23:49literally, it was like a piece of chrome around the display, between the display and the aluminum.
0:23:53And they had the black cut out at the bottom that was—
0:23:56Right.
0:23:57I mean, it was just—that was what they needed to do to assemble the thing. And then the
0:24:01next generation phones were the, "Well, what if we just have a big polycarbonate back?"
0:24:06And then with the 4 was like, all right, we figured out how to do this. And everything
0:24:10comes from that. Just like you're right, the titanium power book, every MacBook has looked
0:24:14like that since then. I mean, within, they've all essentially, you could tell they're all
0:24:20of a kind. That was the moment where they went from being like black and brown plastic
0:24:24to being that silver laptop that we know now.
0:24:27Right. I mean, and just in little ways, I mean, if you compare it, if we're going to
0:24:32go down memory lane and compare it to the original iPhone, you could just see how the
0:24:35The whole industry, not just Apple, has come so far in 15 years or so of wireless, where
0:24:41wireless stuff used to always have an actual antenna.
0:24:44I remember seeing palm trios where there'd be an actual antenna up in the upper right
0:24:49corner.
0:24:50I had one of those.
0:24:51Yeah, I absolutely did.
0:24:53Everybody just accepted it because it was amazing.
0:24:55I'm talking on the phone and I'm not connected to any wires.
0:24:58Of course, there's got to be an antenna.
0:25:00go to come so far where like in 2007 we complained about the black plastic on the back of the
0:25:06iPhone because it needed to be plastic to get the antenna signals through and it's we
0:25:12complained about that just because it didn't look great.
0:25:15Yeah, it's well, it's it's kind of hard to think that it's been less than 10 years and
0:25:21the whole industry, I mean, this has been talked about a lot that it's not just how
0:25:25much better people have gotten at phones, which is absolutely true. Everybody has gotten
0:25:29better at phones. But the drive to make smartphones and the miniaturization of all this tech has
0:25:35led to all of these other spinoff devices because once you build these tiny computers,
0:25:42you could do all sorts of other stuff with them too. And it's less than 10 years. I was
0:25:46on some podcast where I said that I thought that in the end the smartphone, the computer
0:25:52era would be seen as a footnote to the smartphone era. That that was like, remember when we
0:25:57first made computers, you couldn't put them in your pocket, as opposed to how we
0:26:01think of it now, which is, "Oh, now you can put a computer in your pocket." It's like,
0:26:04I don't think in terms of history that's how we're gonna think about it.
0:26:08It's like, it's already in less than 10 years changed so much about how people
0:26:11interact all around the world that, you know, that's, and has driven so
0:26:16much new technology. Yeah, totally. All right, back to the event. So here's
0:26:23a question. Let's go through it. I have my notes now. Let's go through it
0:26:27order. So Tim Cook comes out and starts with, well there's the 40 years
0:26:33and 40 seconds thing, which was delightful. Included a Newton joke.
0:26:37People forget that, I mean, people don't know that crossing out the Newton
0:26:42wasn't just malicious. That was the actual pen stroke you used to
0:26:46erase a word. I didn't notice that they actually went to that detail. I did not
0:26:51notice that. Oh yeah, it's that little up and down zigzag across the
0:26:54word, and then what they didn't, they didn't have time to have the little
0:26:56puff of smoke. But that was the Newton gesture for that. So that was deep knowledge by whoever
0:27:03made that video.
0:27:05With a little bit of love. And then he came out and he addressed, as we say, the elephant
0:27:12in the room, which was at the time on Monday Apple's pending court case against the FBI
0:27:17the next day. And I thought he spoke very well on it. He's spoken well on it ever since
0:27:25this issue started in early February, but I feel like he's gotten it down to a much
0:27:33more compelling argument.
0:27:37For example, earlier, a few weeks ago, he was comparing the creation of Government OS
0:27:43to, he analogized it to cancer.
0:27:47I think I know where he was going with that, but he's dropped that analogy, and I think
0:27:50it's for the best that he did, because it doesn't hold up as well.
0:27:54And the main reason I think is because cancer isn't man-made.
0:27:57It's, you know, it's a, this, I mean there's man-made causes that can lead you to get it,
0:28:02but it's, you know, the fact that it exists is an unfortunate aspect of nature in our
0:28:08biology.
0:28:12I think it's, if you're going to go that route, it's a little bit more like asking a company
0:28:16to, you know, requiring a company to manufacture chemical weapons.
0:28:20But that's an analogy that I don't think he wants to use.
0:28:23I think it's a better analogy, but I don't think you want to use it because it's too
0:28:26unpleasant.
0:28:29I thought that the thing that he said that really was the way that I think that this
0:28:32should go is when he said that we even see our phones as an extension of ourselves.
0:28:38That to me is the angle that the discussion...
0:28:42I know that this particular case has been dropped, but the issue is definitely not going
0:28:46to go away.
0:28:47that's the angle to go toward in terms of yes we are actually building warrant
0:28:53resistant phones. Yeah you you did a you had a post and a link that I thought was
0:28:58really great that was calling somebody on this argument like do we dare create
0:29:05a warrant proof space do we dare do that a place where warrants can't reach and
0:29:10the point the point that you linked to is that somebody said was our minds are
0:29:16are a warrant-proof place. The concept of a place that is, and historically, there have been other places that are essentially warrant-proof, but certainly our minds are ours, and the information in them is not subject to a warrant.
0:29:31And I think that I thought the same thing when he said that, that this is the, one of the key parts of Apple's argument is our phones are extensions of ourselves. There are, there are not even backup brains, they're part of our brains.
0:29:45are where we keep information so we don't have to store it in our brains. It makes life
0:29:50better that way. This is how people live in the 21st century, and therefore protecting
0:29:56that is an extension of the protection that we've got essentially against self-incrimination.
0:30:02This is part of our mind, and if the math means that the technology exists to lock something
0:30:09up and nobody can get to it, then perhaps we're all best off considering it that, considering
0:30:18it the extension of a warrant-proof space that already exists on our mind. So I definitely,
0:30:23you know, he didn't go into it beyond just saying it's an extension of ourselves, but
0:30:28you and I had the same thought, which is you read between the lines there and that is what
0:30:31Apple is saying, is you can't pry it out of our head, and my phone is part of my head.
0:30:35It is who I am, and if I can make it so that you can't see what's in there, then that's
0:30:43okay.
0:30:44That's part of the deal.
0:30:46Yeah.
0:30:48And then the FBI called a "Never mind."
0:30:53Never mind.
0:30:55Well, you saw the legal analysis—again, we're not lawyers—but you saw the legal
0:30:59analysis over the weekend and the past week, which was sort of like, "This isn't looking
0:31:03good for the FBI."
0:31:04There's so many reasons that this is, that Apple seems to have the advantage here.
0:31:10The tide seemed to turn.
0:31:11I think even publicly, I think the FBI thought this was a slam dunk.
0:31:16I think they thought that they were going to be able to do this and Apple was going
0:31:19to roll over and the people were going to be on their side because they're talking
0:31:22about terrorism and protecting a terrorist's phone and all of these things.
0:31:26And then the tide starts to turn.
0:31:27Their legal footing is kind of not as solid as they thought it would be.
0:31:32And then so all of a sudden they say, well, we found another way, so never mind, which
0:31:36even that excuse is terrible because they basically said, no, no, no, there is no other
0:31:40way. We've searched everywhere. And everybody went, really? And then they're like, never
0:31:44mind. It's hard not to look at that and say that the political calculation, either
0:31:49they made it that this wasn't a good time to do this or somebody else in the executive
0:31:55branch was like, "Don't, don't, just, just don't," right? Or, or, "Go talk to the NSA," or
0:32:02whatever it was, but something happened. Figure out as graceful a way as possible
0:32:08to get out of this, even if it's actually not graceful at all. Yeah, and I
0:32:13think that it backfired on the FBI in two ways. I kind of, I kind of get
0:32:18the feeling that they maybe never thought that this would go to actual
0:32:22trial, but they thought it would be the other way, that the public opinion would go against
0:32:29Apple so overwhelmingly that, okay, Apple thinks they want to fight this, but we'll turn up the
0:32:34temperature on the terrorism dial, and they'll find out otherwise. And that didn't happen.
0:32:40It certainly is not the case that the public was overwhelmingly in Apple's favor, but it was close
0:32:47to 50/50 and from the polls that I did see, you know, it seemed like it was slowly moving
0:32:53in Apple's favor. It certainly wasn't backfiring on Apple and I think that the FBI wasn't prepared
0:32:58for that. And then the FBI looked at what their legal arguments were and were like,
0:33:02"Shit, if we go to trial, this does not look good." And the other thing that they did that
0:33:07was sort of like just dancing around and, you know, changing their mind, it was like
0:33:13like Friday or Thursday or Friday,
0:33:16but three or four days before it was supposed to go to trial,
0:33:18they changed, they said,
0:33:20"We would like this to be an evidentiary hearing
0:33:22"where we call witnesses."
0:33:23Which, you know, it's not like that's unusual
0:33:28in and of itself, but it's unusual to do, you know,
0:33:30request it at the last minute.
0:33:31And my theory, and again, I'm just making this up,
0:33:34I don't have any information to back it up,
0:33:36but my guess is that they looked at the legal argument,
0:33:38said, "We're kinda screwed.
0:33:40"Maybe if we call some witnesses,
0:33:41"we can make this a little bit less
0:33:43about the facts and a little bit more like an emotional appeal, you know, a gut appeal to,
0:33:50you know, we're trying to fight terrorism here. And then I think they realized over the weekend
0:33:57that that really, you know, when they thought about it, that really wasn't going to work either.
0:34:00Yeah, I think it is a combination of the law and the optics that happened to them. The optics,
0:34:07you're exactly right. I think they expected that the people would be mixed on this, and
0:34:14then when they heard about the details of Apple withholding information from a terrorist,
0:34:18that the public would swing to their side, and it didn't do that. It was the reverse
0:34:21of that, that people learned more about this issue and started to understand why Apple
0:34:26was fighting it, so I think they miscalculated. And then yeah, Apple brings in Ted Olson,
0:34:30Right? I mean, Apple like lawyered up to, to fight this as far as possible.
0:34:36And, you know, I, I think you put those two together and, and there's a, and,
0:34:41and they always had to have the knowledge that there was, even if they didn't know
0:34:44there were zero day exploits that they could probably use, um, I'm sure they,
0:34:49I'm sure they knew that they could find one if they wanted, it was like in their
0:34:53back pocket a little bit.
0:34:54And so that was the, the escape hatches.
0:34:57Oh, Oh, we think let's put this on hold.
0:35:00Because it's not dismissed.
0:35:00It's just on hold for now.
0:35:02Um, but I, I, yeah, it seems like it's, it seems like it's over.
0:35:06I, and the one thing I noticed and it's, it really, I don't think you can overstate
0:35:12how much Apple is truly standing on principle here in that it's, you know,
0:35:18whether you think it's good marketing or not, and I think that Apple really
0:35:21bristled at that accusation from the FBI, that they were doing this for marketing
0:35:24purposes because so it, whether it helps them in marketing or not as beside the
0:35:29point they truly, and obviously I think from starting at the very top with Tim Cook right
0:35:35on down, really see it as a matter of principle. The reason it's a little unusual to see a
0:35:41company do something like that is that you could see it in the polling that their negatives,
0:35:46as they say in politics, have gone way up. It was like before this, the last time the
0:35:53same polling group had it, it was like, "How many people have an unfavorable opinion of
0:35:57Apple and it was like 8% and it's probably just a bunch of people who hate the Mac.
0:36:02The people who get into Mac versus PC flame wars on the internet. But as of last week,
0:36:11it was up to 21% or something like that. So the number of people in the United States with an
0:36:16unfavorable opinion of Apple more than doubled, almost tripled just because of this issue,
0:36:23just because of the very, you know, and thinking about it in very broad terms,
0:36:27Apple is spitefully not helping the FBI unlock a phone that belongs to terrorists.
0:36:32And that's just like this, that's the sort of PR that companies, you know, for good reason,
0:36:38don't want. Yeah, that's the worst, the worst PR, right? The easiest thing to do is go along like
0:36:44all the phone companies did and like a lot of tech companies have done, which is just go along,
0:36:48keep it quiet, don't talk about the tap that you put in for the government, don't talk about this
0:36:52you know, this work you do or this loophole that you've got, that's
0:36:58certainly the best, right? Because then it's like nobody talks about it. You risk
0:37:01having something like what happened with AT&T blow up where it's revealed that
0:37:06there's this warrantless wiretapping going on in your telecom center.
0:37:10There are risks there, but still, yeah, Apple's putting itself out there
0:37:15and they know they're going to get portrayed by the United States
0:37:17government of all places. The law and order wing of the United States
0:37:21government as being on the side of terrorism, essentially. I mean, there's a senator who
0:37:28stood in the Senate and declared that Apple was on the side of ISIS, right? I mean, this
0:37:33is bad PR. But I do think that they're principled. And when we talk about this whole section
0:37:39of the keynote, or the media event, not just Tim Cook, but when we went on to talk about
0:37:45the health stuff and about the environment stuff, too, you know, it is a PR calculation.
0:37:50media event, it is always going to be a PR calculation, but I do believe that
0:37:54it's also a cultural thing at Apple. I don't believe they just do
0:38:00this for good PR. This is part of who they are and the philosophy they have
0:38:04about their products and how they're used.
0:38:07Yeah, I think that the environment thing is a perfect example of that because
0:38:12however many people care about it, I really think that the number of
0:38:16of iPhones and iPads that they sell
0:38:20because Apple has a good stance toward the environment
0:38:23is like, you know, one person could carry them upstairs.
0:38:27You know what I mean?
0:38:29There are not very many people who are making their decision
0:38:32on what to buy based on the environmental policies
0:38:35of the company.
0:38:35I think Lisa Jackson even said it,
0:38:38that you can feel good about Apple's environment.
0:38:41It's a way to make you feel good about it,
0:38:43but it's not gonna sell it.
0:38:45and you can't help but think that it's costing them
0:38:48a significant amount of money.
0:38:50- Yeah, yeah, I think so.
0:38:53But they've been, this is one of those funny cases
0:38:55where I feel like they turn the corner too,
0:38:57that they got rebuked by Greenpeace like 10 years ago.
0:39:01And within a year or two, they started putting up
0:39:05that slide that is on every product launch now,
0:39:07which is the green checklist.
0:39:08Which, you know, they don't have to do that.
0:39:11They really don't have to do it now
0:39:12when they always just check all the boxes.
0:39:14But they have done a lot to make their products more recyclable
0:39:18and less toxic.
0:39:19And now they're doing things where they're buying
0:39:22electricity.
0:39:23It's not as if they've got solar panels on all their buildings
0:39:26and all their buildings.
0:39:28Some of it is like there's a huge solar farm in central
0:39:31California that they basically bought and said,
0:39:34we want all the power from this.
0:39:36But they want to say that, and they want to talk about that.
0:39:39And that is--
0:39:41Again, I think it's good PR because it says we care, but I also think that they do actually
0:39:46care.
0:39:47Yeah.
0:39:48And the other thing worth noting, I mean, it's, but Lisa Jackson being on stage is noteworthy
0:39:55because A, she's never been on stage at an event before and B, you know, in the last
0:40:02few years, there's been a growing awareness that most of the people Apple puts up on stage
0:40:08are white men.
0:40:10Yep.
0:40:11anything, anybody who's, you know, can broaden the diversity of the people who are on stage,
0:40:21it's a good thing in multiple ways. But it's, you know, I brought it up with Phil Schiller
0:40:24when he was on the show at WWDC and he made the point, which is exactly what I suspected
0:40:29is true, is that it's not like they pick people to do, you know, like, here's who's going
0:40:37to do this. It's people who are responsible for the thing that they're pitching who do
0:40:40it. So when JAWS comes up to do the iPhone SE, JAWS is not just a person who does product
0:40:48marketing, he's product marketing for iPhone. And so the fact that Lisa Jackson was on stage,
0:40:54she wasn't going to come out on stage to talk about the iPhone SE. It's because she's literally
0:40:58in charge of Apple's environmental policy.
0:41:03Yeah, I do think they're definitely making an attempt. It seems to me that they're asking
0:41:08the question, like, how can we better, you know, reflect diversity on stage and in videos
0:41:17and all those things. And they are not close to being sort of what you see from a Google
0:41:22event or even a Microsoft event, but you can see that they're working on getting better.
0:41:29I noticed not just Lisa Jackson, but in the videos, there were two videos featuring Apple
0:41:37Apple employees, and one of them, a video was narrated by an Apple product manager who
0:41:43is Asian, and there was one that featured, one of the health videos featured an Apple
0:41:50employee who is an Indian woman. And so I did notice, like, the people in, the people,
0:41:55and not just like the kids in the health study and all that, but the representatives of Apple
0:41:59in those videos were people we hadn't seen before, voices we hadn't heard before, and
0:42:04who do show some more of the diversity that is in existence at Apple. And, you know, what
0:42:09I read that is that they're making an effort. And it's not like, I mean, it's not like there's
0:42:15an incredibly diverse group on stage and that Apple's totally turned the corner. I guess
0:42:20what I would say is that I think they're aware of the perception of it and are trying to
0:42:24take some steps. But, you know, they got more work to do. But it's good to see new people
0:42:30from Apple on stage. This is, it's not just about Apple's diversity. It's also like, Apple
0:42:35used to be the least diverse company in the world because there was literally like a guy
0:42:40who did almost everything publicly, right? Steve Jobs wanted to be the face of everything
0:42:45Apple did. And you're saying they were the least diverse in terms of their public, in
0:42:49terms of their public persona, because it was one guy. It was Steve Jobs was Apple,
0:42:53right? And I think he cultivated that and he was, he was good at it. So why not do it?
0:42:58I feel like Apple's corporate culture still continues to unwind with Katie Cotton leaving
0:43:03and Steve Dowling taking over in PR. I feel like there's still unwinding out to be like,
0:43:10lots of people work at Apple and let's get those voices on stage. It started with a small
0:43:16group of people who we already knew who would pop up during Steve Jobs' keynotes and now
0:43:20it keeps widening. I expect it to keep doing that, but it's kind of funny that I really
0:43:27think they have they they are trying to change but they have to change from a model where
0:43:33like nobody gets on stage except Steve and maybe a couple of lieutenants and they don't
0:43:38I think they I think they know they need to not do that anymore yeah and I don't think
0:43:42they're ever going to go the route of Google who like in a Google I/O keynote there might
0:43:46be 20 people who come on stage I mean maybe I'm exaggerating a little but it's it's a
0:43:50lot it's a lot of people coming out for a brief you know almost like individual
0:43:56features you know here's somebody else to do this an Apple style of presentation
0:44:02is isn't going to change because I think that they you know I think it works you
0:44:06know and I think they believe it works there's a certain style to an Apple show
0:44:10you know and it's it's fewer speakers coming out for longer segments you know
0:44:18And then maybe somebody, you know, like at WWDC, there's a couple of things where they'll have somebody come out to do the demo, right?
0:44:23and and there's you know, but
0:44:25It's just it's just inherently a little different
0:44:28The one thing with the Lisa Jackson thing. I didn't comment on it
0:44:32I in my write-up on my thoughts and observations
0:44:36but one of the things that a couple of readers called me on and I have to say correctly so is
0:44:40It's a little disingenuous to
0:44:45What I call her segment out on is that they pitched it as sort of like Apple is helping to save the climate
0:44:51And I think that's a little it's a little
0:44:54self-centered
0:44:56Because I don't really think Apple's
0:44:59Footprint as big as a company as they are is single-handedly really gonna move the dial on the overall climate of the planet
0:45:05I think that they should pitch it more
0:45:07I really do because I think and I think this is where it could help is pitch it more as
0:45:11We're setting an example that we want all of our other fellow companies in the fortune 500 to follow
0:45:16We're showing that it's possible to be
0:45:18100% renewable
0:45:21Why is why aren't other companies doing the same
0:45:24and I still believe that but the other thing I didn't mention and I did think about it was that they
0:45:31They're they're very
0:45:35carefully omitting their supply chain from their measurements, right? And I don't know,
0:45:40it would be interesting. I mean, because that's one thing, like, Tim Cook is a numbers guy.
0:45:45So I bet that he, you know, has those numbers coming from Lisa Jackson's team, which is,
0:45:50what's the environmental footprint of our supply chain? And I would be interested to know how big
0:45:56that is compared to the rest of Apple's operations. One of the interesting things, and I've seen Ben
0:46:02Thompson write about this at Stratechery a little bit, and Guy Ramez-Nam, who is a science
0:46:07fiction writer, but he also writes about the future of renewable energies. He's written
0:46:11about it a lot that China is really changing to the point where China's path to renewable
0:46:18energy from coal, basically, is it's rapid. It's happening rapidly, because, partially
0:46:27because their pollution is horrible. But it's interesting. I wonder if there's something
0:46:35behind the scenes where they talk to their supply chain and are leaning on them to do
0:46:39this, because I think there's opportunity in the grid in China, knowing nothing about
0:46:45the details of Chinese energy systems. But the country as a whole is adding huge amounts
0:46:50of renewables and is going to keep doing that for a long time to come. So I do wonder if
0:46:55that's happening in the background too, that maybe there's even a thought like, "Look,
0:46:59these guys are all going to be switching to, you know, or investing in, you know, solar
0:47:06in China."
0:47:07And...
0:47:08Well, there are advantages to running an authoritarian government. I mean, you can, you know, you
0:47:13can make the trains run on time a little easier.
0:47:15Yeah, well, and I just don't know how to handle their grid and whether you can say like, "We're
0:47:19going to buy power here and we want the credit for that being our power, that wind farm that
0:47:23you built. Let's say that that's the Hanhai wind farm. And that's the truth of a grid
0:47:29in general is that you're essentially buying offsets. I mean, when Apple puts that solar
0:47:37farm that's south of Monterey to work, it's not like there's an Apple campus right there
0:47:42that's wired to it. It goes into…
0:47:44Or a big cable, one big thick power cord, like the John Fogerty video.
0:47:50Yeah, yeah, you just plug it in and then you got it. No, it goes into the grid and then
0:47:54the electrons are in the grid and then they take, but they get the credit for that generation.
0:47:59So you know, electricity is weird, but they're trying and I would imagine that the supply
0:48:04chain is probably going to get better just because I get the impression that the energy
0:48:08mix in China is going to get better. But you know, who knows? You're right, I'm sure Tim
0:48:12Cook knows.
0:48:14Well, they conspicuously avoided mentioning it. And you know, I don't know, I don't really
0:48:19blame them? I think if I was on their team, I probably would have said, "Yeah, we don't
0:48:23want to." This does not mention it.
0:48:25Tim Cynova I think you're right, though. I think it
0:48:27would be great if Apple was just more an example of like, "Look, this is how a big company
0:48:31can do this." And if you want to be a big company that can say, "Look, we're standing
0:48:34up and we're going to be 100% renewables by this date," you can do it because Apple did
0:48:39it. And even say, "Here's what it cost us," and it's realistic about how much it costs.
0:48:45Because that's one of the arguments always. It's like, "Well, we don't know. It's a mystery,
0:48:49Apple could say, "No, we know, and you can follow our lead. This is how much it'll
0:48:52cost you to do this."
0:48:54So then the last part of the Lisa Jackson's part of the show was the
0:48:58introduction of Liam, the iPhone deconstructing robot, which was kind of a
0:49:04surprise. I mean, because Apple doesn't really show you much behind the, you know,
0:49:10behind the stage, ever. And it's sort of an interesting thing. And I wrote
0:49:17about it, like my thing is I can't help but wonder if they're the same people working
0:49:21on Liam, the deconstructing robot, or also working on a sibling robot who puts phones
0:49:28together. Because before we ever got a look at the, you know, and Apple started publishing
0:49:36photos of, you know, like the inside of the Foxconn factories, or assembly lines, I guess
0:49:42is a better way to put it, you know, like when Tim Cook started going there, and there
0:49:45photo ops and you could see it. I shouldn't have been surprised, but like
0:49:50my gut feeling was that I thought it would be a lot more automated. And
0:49:54because there are things, you know, like when you see like a car factory,
0:49:57an auto factory, a lot of it is roboticized. Whereas putting these
0:50:01electronics together is largely a, at least today, is largely a manual job.
0:50:08Yeah, I wonder, and I don't know whether that's something that, does Apple do that
0:50:12or does Apple talk to their manufacturers about doing that? Does Apple work with them and say,
0:50:18"We want to reinvent how this goes on so that the people working in the factories are supervising
0:50:24the robots rather than doing all the work themselves?" That would certainly reduce the
0:50:28number of people working in the factories, which is certainly how the auto industry in the United
0:50:31States had problems because you lost a lot of jobs that way. But I don't know, it's fascinating
0:50:40to me because this is like, this is a thing people have talked about the problems of recycling
0:50:44electronics for a long time, but I felt like there was never a drumbeat on it like there
0:50:47was about some other stuff. But this is definitely, you know, this seems to be almost in the same
0:50:52class as some of the other tech that we know exists back in the back of the Apple store,
0:50:57where it's like it's in Apple's benefit to have a recycling program and they refurbish
0:51:00phones and they didn't disassemble the parts and reuse them. And how much of this is about
0:51:07being friendly to the earth and how much of this is about, uh, like it's good business sense to why
0:51:12not? Why don't we reclaim all of these things and, and put them back to use? I don't know. It would
0:51:17be an interesting, who, who builds that? Who builds Liam? Do you get a job as a, an engineer at Apple
0:51:22and then discover that rather than building like the new iPhone, you're building a device to take
0:51:27apart iPhone fives? Yeah, maybe. I guess so. I can't help but think that it was that it's an Apple
0:51:33design machine. Yeah, well they said it's in California, so I assume so. Yeah, pretty cool
0:51:40stuff. And then they gave Mashable a nice behind the scenes look at it, which is another sign of
0:51:45the modern new Apple. I also, I guess before we move on, the other thing too, and Tim Cook,
0:51:55I guess he mentioned it at the end, but that it's, you know, if everything goes according to
0:51:59schedule, this will be, that will be, that was the last event they're gonna hold on campus.
0:52:03Right. Well, on that campus.
0:52:05On that campus, right. And a couple of people, and I guess it's just, I overlook how some of the
0:52:14things that I find obvious, but other people don't, but a couple of readers were like,
0:52:17"Did he just say that they're not going to release anything new this year?" And the answer is no, no,
0:52:23no, no, no. That's not the point. It's the schedule that Apple's been on, the pattern that they've
0:52:27kind of centered on is really sort of a three public event a year schedule. Something in
0:52:33March, which is what we just had, of varying importance depending on whether they have
0:52:39something majorly new to announce or not. WWDC in middle of June, which is probably
0:52:47mostly software based, but maybe that's what they'll hold the new MacBooks for? I don't
0:52:50know. They'll either release these new MacBooks with a press release between now and WWDC
0:52:56hold them until WWDC. But that's my guess is that a bunch of us will get a call saying,
0:53:00"Would you like to come for a briefing?" And they'll say, "We have new Macbooks, and here's
0:53:03the embargo," and the press release will go out, and that'll be it. Like at the end of
0:53:06April or something like that. Something like that, yeah. And then in September, there will
0:53:10certainly be a major event, but they don't—because it's a major event, they're not going to hold
0:53:14it in their tiny little town hall. They're going to hold it, like, last year at the Bill
0:53:18Graham Auditorium. Right, or the Flint Center the year before that, or, you know, or Yerba
0:53:23Bueno or Moscone West sometimes, but they'll find a big venue somewhere for
0:53:27that huge club. I don't think they've ever done Moscone West other than for Macworld or
0:53:31WWDC. Have they not? I think they did. I think, I'm sure somebody out there is
0:53:35screaming at their car right now that they did, but my memory is that they have
0:53:39done a single freestanding Moscone West event, but it's probably that is booked
0:53:45up. I think it maybe it was just luck that there was some week where it wasn't
0:53:48booked where they could just drop in and do it, but and they also can't just do it
0:53:51for a day, right? Because we know Apple, they have days of prep to get the space exactly
0:53:55the way they want it, so they can't just rent it for a day.
0:53:59I think I have my gut feeling is that Yerba Buena is a thing of the past, again because
0:54:04of size.
0:54:05Yeah, it's 750. It's not that much bigger than Town Hall.
0:54:09Yeah, and it's a lot of custom prep work to get the hands-on area.
0:54:16Yeah, they built that whole—they built a whole new hands-on thing the last time they were at Yerba Buena.
0:54:22The last time they did the Yerba Buena, they actually cut a hole in the wall. They actually took a wall out.
0:54:26Mm-hmm.
0:54:27I remember asking—
0:54:29That's Apple.
0:54:30Yeah, I think—
0:54:31Well, they built buildings, essentially, at Bill Graham and at the Flint Center.
0:54:37I think Katie Cotton was still there at the time, and I spoke to somebody there, like, towards the end,
0:54:42as they were getting ready to kick us out of the hands-on area. And I was like,
0:54:45"This is like insanely expensive because you guys have to like rebuild the wall." And she was like,
0:54:48"Yeah, we don't care." Yeah, that's about right.
0:54:51Let me take another break here before we move on into the next segment of Apple's event. And thank
0:54:57our good friends, another longtime sponsor of the show, you guys know them, Squarespace.
0:55:02Squarespace is it's the all in one place to host design, customize and build your own website.
0:55:12Any kind of website, almost any website you can even imagine that you might want to start,
0:55:19you really ought to look at Squarespace. First, go to squarespace.com. And
0:55:27You just cannot emphasize enough.
0:55:30Stuff like podcasts, you can host a podcast at Squarespace.
0:55:32They even have a custom audio player.
0:55:34They know what a podcast is.
0:55:35They can help you with that.
0:55:36You can post a blog.
0:55:37You have a store.
0:55:39You can build your own store there.
0:55:41And they have all of the shopping stuff,
0:55:43all the SSL stuff, all the credit card taking stuff.
0:55:47All of it is built in, and you just do it.
0:55:50When you're customizing it, it is like using a design app.
0:55:54It is not like sitting there and doing code
0:55:57you know, moving little snippets of code around. Although you can get into the
0:56:00code if you want to, but you literally just drag stuff around and it's exactly
0:56:06how web design should be. You just sit there and you're actually
0:56:09manipulating the actual website itself that you're logged into. It's not like
0:56:13there's an editing interface and a regular interface. When you're signed in
0:56:16and you it's your Squarespace account, you just sit there and you manipulate it
0:56:21and true what you see is what you get style because it's actually what you're
0:56:25moving is the actual website really just can't emphasize enough how easy that is
0:56:31so my thanks to Squarespace go to Squarespace.com and use the code
0:56:37Gruber my last name Gruber and you will save 10% off your first order
0:56:44Squarespace.com offer code Gruber so use that code and you'll they'll know you
0:56:51came from from the show my thanks to Squarespace if you have any kind of
0:56:54website that you may want to build, go there first and try it and you'll
0:56:58probably not even move on to anything else. My thanks to Squarespace. So then
0:57:05Jeff Williams comes out and like I was sitting next to Matthew Panzorino in
0:57:09the audience and when Jeff Williams was done and he was like let me hand this
0:57:13off you know hand it back to Tim I was like I just whispered to Matthew I was
0:57:17like let me hand things off to my brother Tim. It's uncanny how similar
0:57:22Jeff Williams and Tim Cook's on stage demeanor is it I can't believe more
0:57:29people don't don't comment on it yeah they they they seem similar they're
0:57:34they're Tim is more polished but Tim's had more time to be more polished yeah
0:57:38but Jeff Williams is sort of like where where Tim Cook was when Tim was the CEO
0:57:43for Steve Jobs and would occasionally come out on stage to talk about like how
0:57:47well the Mac is doing or something like that yeah you know one of the things we
0:57:50did. So, you know, going into the town hall event, I had that realization like Friday
0:57:54that it's probably the last one, and I went to Stephen Hackett and I said, "Would you
0:57:58be interested in working with me on a piece like 'Looking Back at Town Hall'?" And we
0:58:01— and we — and he replied with a list of YouTube videos of every town hall event since
0:58:062001. That's Stephen Hackett in a nutshell.
0:58:09That's crazy.
0:58:10And I was looking at him, and it was a fun story to put together. We sort of split the
0:58:14work. I've been to all of them, so I had like little tidbits, like when they took us
0:58:17upstairs to the dorm room, the fake dorm room for the iPod HiFi.
0:58:20I wasn't there for that. Oh no, that was so weird.
0:58:24And there were some others like that, where I remember, and the original iPod event, I remember
0:58:29going for that. But one of the funny things is that the X-Serve event, which was in May 2002,
0:58:36has like super early Tim Cook. And it's interesting to see how far we've come since early Tim Cook,
0:58:44who was explaining the sales strategy of the ex-serve. He's come a long way in the intervening
0:58:5014 years. Yeah, the comparison to Jeff Williams is interesting because it's just funny to
0:58:58me how similar they are. It would be so easy to believe that they were brothers. But it's
0:59:04also an interesting contrast in terms, like you said, how much more polished Tim Cook
0:59:07has gotten and how really good he's gotten on stage.
0:59:12- I think he's relaxed a little bit.
0:59:13I think he realizes he doesn't need to be Steve Jobs, right?
0:59:16Which is like, and I don't mean that in a,
0:59:18oh, you gotta fill his shoes,
0:59:19but more like Steve set the template.
0:59:21Like you said, these Apple events,
0:59:22Apple knows what it's doing.
0:59:24I wrote a piece on Macworld a couple of weeks ago
0:59:26about how everybody does an Apple event now.
0:59:27Like Apple defined this corporate tech media event thing.
0:59:32But if Steve's the template, then even if Steve's gone,
0:59:36there is a moment where you struggle of like,
0:59:38how do I do this?
0:59:39What's my way of doing it?
0:59:40instead of just reading Steve's lines for him.
0:59:44And I feel like Tim Cook has gotten there now, where
0:59:47it's an Apple event, and it's always
0:59:49going to have the echoes of the Steve Jobs events.
0:59:52But he just seems more comfortable in his own skin
0:59:54on stage.
0:59:55He smiles a lot more.
0:59:57That's the thing.
0:59:57I kept taking pictures because I do that at these Apple events.
1:00:00And he used to be kind of serious,
1:00:05and he would occasionally have a super awkward grin
1:00:08that he'd be like, smile for the camera.
1:00:10And he just seems to--
1:00:11I mean, whether he's not--
1:00:13he could be completely torn up inside and terrified,
1:00:16for all I know.
1:00:17But on stage, he is projecting what
1:00:20seems like completely legitimate happiness about being up there.
1:00:23And so I do feel like he's kind of completely embraced
1:00:27his role now and knows who he is on stage
1:00:30and what his public persona is and has come to terms with it.
1:00:34Because yeah, I think he's come-- he's
1:00:37going to be Tim Cook.
1:00:37He's never going to be anything but that.
1:00:39but he does feel like he's genuinely Tim Cook now.
1:00:41- Yeah, and I couldn't say it better myself.
1:00:44And I think that it doesn't matter
1:00:47how naturally talented you are at anything,
1:00:49you kinda have to do it for a little
1:00:50before you settle into it.
1:00:52- Sure. - Right?
1:00:53It's like, I knew how to write
1:00:56when I started "Daring Fireball,"
1:00:57but if you read the first few entries,
1:00:59first year or two of "Daring Fireball,"
1:01:01there's a certain tone that's not,
1:01:02it's not poorly written, but it's not right.
1:01:06Or when you look at the first few years of any of your favorite comic strips,
1:01:12like Peanuts or even Calvin and Hobbes,
1:01:15it's like the characters aren't quite drawn right.
1:01:17- Yeah, oh yeah, sure, they're all off model.
1:01:20I remember when I was a kid reading the Garfield books,
1:01:22and you start with book one, and you're like,
1:01:23"What the hell is this? This is not Garfield."
1:01:25- Right, it looks like a parody of Garfield or something.
1:01:28That's it, and then it settles in, you know?
1:01:31And then the natural, you know,
1:01:33and I feel like Tim Cook's onstage persona
1:01:36is exactly like that, and he has settled in.
1:01:38Saying that he's more comfortable,
1:01:39or he's just more himself is exactly it.
1:01:42And I used to say, before when Steve Jobs was still around,
1:01:48but for obvious reasons, we were all speculating
1:01:53about what would happen post Steve Jobs.
1:01:55And I used to say, and I guess it's still true in theory,
1:01:58that it's not necessarily, it doesn't have to be the case
1:02:02the CEO of Apple is the the spokesman for the company. And that, you know, Tim Cook could just
1:02:09be the CEO and Phil Schiller could run the events. And in a way I was, I think I was right in a way
1:02:16I was wrong. Where I was right in so far is that Tim Cook almost never sells the new products.
1:02:23He always hands off to somebody to actually pitch the products, which is obviously the what, you
1:02:28you know, Steve Jobs just did it all himself.
1:02:30But I do kind of feel like it's important
1:02:32that he's sort of the host of the show.
1:02:34There is a certain, look, the buck stops here.
1:02:38- Right, this is my company,
1:02:40this is why we're doing what we're doing.
1:02:42I thought there would be less of him, honestly.
1:02:44I thought he would do that thing
1:02:45where he'd come up at the beginning
1:02:46and give the retail update,
1:02:49all that stuff that they didn't even do in this,
1:02:51but that's like the company's business.
1:02:53And then hand it off, and he did this for,
1:02:54I think at least one event, hand it off,
1:02:56essentially not come back until the end and come back on stage and say, "See, this is
1:03:00why we do what we do. Only Apple can do this. Thanks for being here. Goodbye." And that
1:03:04would be it. But his presence is, he's much more like the glue that holds the thing together
1:03:09than I thought he had. And I don't think he needed, he could have had Phil Schiller do
1:03:13that, right? But he hasn't and he's done a good job at it.
1:03:16Yeah, he's a little bit more like the host of the Oscars.
1:03:18Exactly.
1:03:19Where there certainly are, you know, a lot of the Oscar show is you're some, you know,
1:03:24famous actor comes out to give the award for whatever. So it's not like the host does it
1:03:28all, but the host does glue every segment together. And I feel exactly like you did.
1:03:33I did not think we'd see as much of Tim Cook at events like this as we do, but it's all
1:03:38good. Jeff Williams, Care Kit. Sounds like a big
1:03:43deal. I don't know what to make of it, though. I'm not quite sure how that's going to work.
1:03:51I mean, it's just so far outside of the mainstream. I think the answer is going to be that in a year,
1:03:57we're going to hear, like we did about some of the health stuff, in a year and the research kit
1:04:01stuff, we'll hear, "Oh, well, this is how Care Kit is being used to help patients." But beyond that,
1:04:07I mean, unless you're—what I hope is that we'll see something from somebody who covers, like,
1:04:14healthcare and research and medical stuff, write a story or write stories about what's
1:04:22going on here with this because it's their area of expertise way more than it is ours.
1:04:27I mean, I know some doctors and I've talked to them about Apple stuff and they say, "Well,
1:04:32it looks cool." But unless you know somebody who's actually doing a research project that
1:04:36is using this tech, it's harder to get a sense of what's going on. I think it's great that
1:04:42they're doing it. I think this comes back to those corporate values again where Apple
1:04:46looks at these devices and says, "We're making these devices and putting them in people's
1:04:49pockets and it can change their lives. Who's going to make the tools that make the medical
1:04:56industry capable of doing this? It should be us. We're the platform owner. We should
1:05:00do this." And I think it's good that they're doing that, but I don't know how to judge
1:05:05it.
1:05:06Dave Asprey I thought it was pretty interesting because
1:05:08just have a little bit of first-hand experience
1:05:10in the last few years with surgery.
1:05:14That the thing he said, like you're in the hospital
1:05:17and you have the best people possible
1:05:20who do this all day every day
1:05:21and have up to the minute knowledge
1:05:24dealing with every aspect of you.
1:05:25Everything you're hooked up to,
1:05:26every way you're monitored, the timing of everything
1:05:29is all taken care of by truly expert professionals.
1:05:32And then when they're discharged, they give you this.
1:05:34And it's just like a sheet of paper.
1:05:36And it's so funny, it was like not an exaggeration.
1:05:39Like when my finger, my eye, every little surgery I've had
1:05:42in the last few years, that's how they discharge you.
1:05:45They give you like a piece of paper.
1:05:47And I do read them and I follow the instructions
1:05:50like religiously because I want these,
1:05:54I wanted my finger to actually work again.
1:05:56I was hoping that I would be able to see
1:05:58out of my left eye again.
1:06:00But I can totally understand though
1:06:01how like a lot of people don't for whatever reason,
1:06:05that they just don't think it's important or whatever.
1:06:08I wonder how much better putting it in,
1:06:12getting it into your phone will be.
1:06:13I can see how it might be a lot better
1:06:15if you can get like, if you can automate the,
1:06:18hey, just like getting a text message,
1:06:20you get an alert,
1:06:21like without you having to manually set the alarm,
1:06:23if you could just get the alert that says
1:06:25it's time to take one of your pills.
1:06:29- Yeah, or check your blood pressure or your,
1:06:33anything like that, your blood oxygen count
1:06:35or whatever it is that they're looking for.
1:06:38Yeah, and I mean, that's the,
1:06:40it's a little bit like all the fitness stuff, right?
1:06:42It is the flip side of the fitness stuff.
1:06:43- Yes, I think that's exactly the model, yeah.
1:06:46- 'Cause it's still logging in motivation of personal data,
1:06:50and the difference here is that somebody
1:06:52is monitoring it for you because they're concerned
1:06:54about your specific health issues
1:06:57rather than it just being sort of you saying,
1:06:59how many steps did I do, how much did I run today?
1:07:02right or you know, but now if it's, you know, like a surgery,
1:07:04like I had on my finger or somebody else might have on their knee or hip or
1:07:07something like that, you know, not just stand up,
1:07:09but it's time to do these stretching exercises.
1:07:12Oh, I would totally, I did some physical therapy and I totally, um,
1:07:16this is the podcast where old men talk about injuries. Um,
1:07:19I did some physical therapy on my shoulder and it was, um,
1:07:22always a challenge for me when I came back because they had a whole regimen down
1:07:27and they gave me like the sheet of paper with some exercises circled in this
1:07:30like really bad illustrations.
1:07:32And I had done the exercises and I was like,
1:07:34how do I do that again?
1:07:35And it sort of fell apart very quickly.
1:07:37And I did have that thought of like,
1:07:39would it have been better if I had sat down with some app
1:07:44and put in like a series of reminders or calendar events
1:07:49or something to get me to do this?
1:07:52And the answer is probably yes,
1:07:54but, and that was my failure is that I just sort of like
1:07:56took the piece of paper and figured I'd get to it.
1:07:58And I never did.
1:07:59- Yeah, I also think, and I think it's,
1:08:02we mentioned this earlier on the show,
1:08:03this whole endeavor by Apple with ResearchKit and CareKit
1:08:07isn't really selling phones.
1:08:11It really is a, and as much as we can bitch about Apple
1:08:17jealously guarding its margins
1:08:23by still selling 16 gigabyte devices
1:08:25instead of starting everything at 32,
1:08:27Here's an area, these areas like the environment
1:08:30and health kit and, well maybe not health kit,
1:08:33but research kit and care kit for sure,
1:08:36aren't really about selling, you know, devices.
1:08:39I really do think it is an institutional,
1:08:42this is the right thing to do.
1:08:43We're in a position to do this and we should do it.
1:08:45We're making the world a better place.
1:08:47- Right, I think it's almost like it's incumbent on us
1:08:49because we've got a popular platform.
1:08:51I don't know if Google has similar initiatives.
1:08:53I kind of hope they do because it's,
1:08:55as a platform owner, you kind of need to be the one to say,
1:08:57yeah, we're gonna make this easier for these industries to work on our platform.
1:09:00I think, and I think that it's the exact sort of thing that Google would do too.
1:09:03Yeah.
1:09:04It does seem like the sort of, you know, that without any sort of cynicism at all, that
1:09:09it's, you know, it is the sort of thing that Google would want to do.
1:09:12I mean, you're responsible for this, these devices that are on everybody's bodies. They
1:09:18can make a huge impact, but they probably need a push because the industry is not monolithic
1:09:23enough probably to create an initiative to do it, but you're the platform owner.
1:09:27You could do it and then you could help them.
1:09:29And there, there are eventual benefits, I think, from in terms of sales.
1:09:33Like if you've got a healthcare professionals and the healthcare
1:09:37industry really happy about how Apple listens to them and does all of this,
1:09:41maybe in the end, they are more inclined to buy iPads or whatever, but it's super
1:09:46indirect, it's not like research kit is going to, you know, sell thousands of
1:09:52iPhones.
1:09:52I think you're right about that.
1:09:53Yeah. So then Tim Cook came back on stage and talked about Apple Watch. And this is a perfect
1:10:02example of the sort of thing that years ago I would not have expected Tim Cook to handle.
1:10:07It was Tim Cook who introduced the new, and again it's not blockbuster news, but new watch straps
1:10:14across the line. Our, what did he say? Our spring colors. Yeah. Well, I think, you know,
1:10:23I it's it's not just gently tweaked I definitely see this as some kind of
1:10:29strategic move on Apple's part that they really are like every six months going
1:10:32to you know I fully expect in September to
1:10:35you know probably new watch hardware in September we can talk about that in a
1:10:38moment too but you know new bands too
1:10:42um
1:10:45a couple of things one thing is that they reduce the price the starting price
1:10:48for this the sport models drop 50 bucks um
1:10:52So now it's a $2.99 starting price for the 38 millimeter sport.
1:10:56I didn't check even.
1:10:57Does, did the, did the bigger sport model also drop 50 bucks?
1:11:00Oh, I didn't check either.
1:11:02I think so.
1:11:02I think the sport sport dropped 50.
1:11:04Yeah.
1:11:05I think that was the story is sport dropped 50.
1:11:07The, the other side, I saw somebody on Twitter said, why didn't they drop the
1:11:10addition 50 so that I think they were joking.
1:11:12I was like, oh, that's good.
1:11:13Yeah.
1:11:13Um, but you know, you want to lower entry cost.
1:11:16Uh, And you know, I got into it on a post, a brief post on during
1:11:22Fireball the other day, where somebody otherwise...an article about something else just offhandedly
1:11:27mentioned that it seems like it's a sign that the watch is selling lower than expected because
1:11:32they dropped the price. And I don't think that that's necessarily true at all. I think
1:11:36that the watch is...it could be, but I don't think you should draw that conclusion. I think
1:11:41because it's been out for a year, but it was announced 18 months ago, that in 18 months,
1:11:48idea that they could cut the price by 50 bucks and keep the margin around the same is a very
1:11:54Apple-like thing to do. And then on Twitter, some people called me out and said, "Well,
1:11:58Apple never drops the price of anything. Look, Macbooks are all still $8.99 and $9.99."
1:12:05And it's true for certain products. They kind of try to keep a price and keep it there.
1:12:10But on others, like, and I would compare that, especially the sport watch, I would compare
1:12:15to the iPod in terms of what kind of product it is to Apple,
1:12:20and the price points are similar.
1:12:22And the iPods regularly dropped in price,
1:12:24or at least the starting price of an iPod,
1:12:26dropped by like 50 bucks or so pretty steadily
1:12:29year after year after year until they got it down to
1:12:32$50 ones that you attach to your jacket.
1:12:38So I see that as something that I think
1:12:44that we'll see, you know, eventually, you know, maybe a year or two from now that the
1:12:48starting price will go to $199. And I don't know, I don't know what the bottom is, but
1:12:52it's probably like $149 or something like that.
1:12:54I think you're right. I think if you look at the price, if you look at the price when
1:12:58it came out, you would have to say, is it Apple's intent that the Apple watch to get
1:13:02into an Apple watch will always be $349 or $400 or something like that? Is that, is it
1:13:08really their long-term plan that this will always be a $400 product? No, absolutely not.
1:13:14Absolutely not. That's too expensive. It's a first-generation product. That's what they have
1:13:19to sell it at. But in the long run, it's got to be cheaper than that, right? To start, at least.
1:13:23It has to be. So I think that's part of it. I think, yeah, it's a product that's been out
1:13:28there a long time. They want more people in the Apple Watch world, right? So you lower the price
1:13:33a little bit. You've got margin to give now. I think it's fine. I do think that if they were
1:13:38selling every single one that they could make and were supply-constrained, they wouldn't lower the
1:13:42price. But you know, obviously not at that part of the cycle. Right. But I think you're right.
1:13:47If Apple could make an Apple Watch, ultimately make an Apple Watch with good margins for 150
1:13:53bucks, they would prefer to do that because this is an iPhone accessory. I think they would rather
1:13:58have the volume go up. And then again, keeping in mind, even if you sold it at 150 bucks,
1:14:03you got watch bands and then you've got your fancier models that are always going to be there
1:14:07and always going to be enticing people to spend more money. I was talking to Mike Hurley on
1:14:13our podcast, and he listed off all the watch bands that he's bought. He has spent as much on
1:14:20watch bands for the Apple Watch as he spent on the Apple Watch.
1:14:23>> That was an interesting number from Tim on stage. It was something that,
1:14:27to my knowledge, had never revealed before. He said one-third of their Apple Watch customers
1:14:32regularly change bands. >> Yeah, and I'm in there. I've got
1:14:36three and I definitely cycle between them and it's kind of fun to not it
1:14:41makes it a little bit different for a few weeks and I switch back yeah I got
1:14:46Apple gave me a the the new space black one with Milanese as oh yeah to review
1:14:54which is nice I'd I like it more than I I've wanted a couple days this week I
1:15:02kind of don't like it though it for exactly the reason that I thought which
1:15:05is that I kind of wear my watch out at the hinge of my wrist.
1:15:10And so it's sort of like when I flex my wrist, it puts a little stress on the band and the
1:15:15Milanese slips a little tiny bit as the way I wear it.
1:15:19I feel like I would need to wear it a little bit higher on my wrist to keep it snug.
1:15:24But I also got the nylon band and I like that a lot, the new nylon strap.
1:15:29Yeah, there was a rumor that they were going to do like full on like NATO straps.
1:15:33It's very, I was struck by something that Marco Arment said
1:15:37on ATP the other week, which is,
1:15:39and he's kind of like abandoned the Apple Watch
1:15:41and has gone to mechanical watches and all that.
1:15:43- Oh, he's off the deep end.
1:15:44He's- - Yeah, oh, he, it's Marco.
1:15:46He doesn't do anything halfway, right?
1:15:49But what struck me about somebody
1:15:51who's not into the Apple Watch anymore,
1:15:53has moved on, said, and has done like real watches,
1:15:56said Apple's bands are like second to none.
1:15:59Apple really, really owns the watch band game.
1:16:02And I agree with that.
1:16:02I think their bands are really great.
1:16:03I bought this Kickstarter thing that get lets you use any watch band with a,
1:16:07it's got just a couple of lugs for the Apple watch.
1:16:10And I put this black leather band that I had on them and it's terrible.
1:16:13Like in, in context compared to the Apple leather band, it's just not even close.
1:16:17And so that, that NATO strap rumor was interesting.
1:16:21And it is, is it surprising at all that in, in the end, what Apple did is say,
1:16:25we've got something that's kind of like that, but it's way better.
1:16:27And then that's what the, this woven stuff is.
1:16:31It's like Apple's take on the genre of NATO strap, but not the same.
1:16:36Yeah, and it's funny too, because the one thing with the NATO strap is the real NATO straps go underneath the watch.
1:16:44It's like one continuous piece of nylon that goes through the lug under the back so that the actual back of the watch doesn't touch your wrist.
1:16:52it sits on top of the strap.
1:16:54And I listened to the ATPX episode
1:16:58and Syracuse was confused as to why that is.
1:17:02There actually is like a tactical reason
1:17:04for the design of the strap.
1:17:05The idea is that if one of the bars of your watch
1:17:09that holds a strap, if one of them breaks
1:17:11while you're like in combat,
1:17:13because it's just one strap that goes through,
1:17:16if one of the bars breaks,
1:17:17the watch won't come off your wrist.
1:17:19It'll be flopping around because there's one bar broken,
1:17:22but the rest of the strap will be going through the other bar.
1:17:27Right, because you've essentially tied a strap to your wrist.
1:17:30Right. They're super, super valuable.
1:17:34I think that they regularly sell for like $50,000 or more,
1:17:39but there's some vintage Rolexes that they made for the British military in the
1:17:45late sixties and early seventies,
1:17:49and that they only could use a NATO strap
1:17:53because by the specs of the British military,
1:17:56the crossbars in the watch,
1:17:58the thing that you need, like, you know,
1:18:00in a normal watch, you need like a special tool to like,
1:18:03you know, it's called a spring bar,
1:18:04so you compress it a little bit so it pops out
1:18:07so you can change the strap.
1:18:08Those bars were like welded or whatever you would call it.
1:18:13You know, they weren't springy.
1:18:14They were like part of the actual watch
1:18:17so that they'd be leaving less likely to break.
1:18:19So there is a tactical reason for that.
1:18:21But that design wouldn't work at all with the Apple Watch
1:18:23because the strap would actually cover the sensors.
1:18:25- Exactly.
1:18:26- So they had to do their own thing.
1:18:28- Their little appley spin on it.
1:18:30- Right.
1:18:31I find it to be a very comfortable material though.
1:18:32I have a strap like that on an old regular watch
1:18:36that I have.
1:18:36It's similar, it's not really a NATO style actually
1:18:38'cause I don't like the way that it sits on your wrist
1:18:41when it goes through like that.
1:18:43But it's NATO style and it just attaches to spring bars
1:18:47a regular watch. But I find that nylon is actually a super comfortable material, especially
1:18:51like in hot weather.
1:18:52Yeah, and they look better. Some people say that they thought they looked kind of ugly
1:18:57on the Apple website. They look way better in person.
1:19:00Yeah, they're actually very hard to photograph, I think.
1:19:03Yeah, well, it's almost like you get a little moire pattern on them. They are these super
1:19:07patterned woven, multiple color woven fabrics, so they're hard to picture.
1:19:13Yeah, I'm looking at it right now on Apple's website, and by putting them at any kind of angle,
1:19:18even on a retina, my retina display here, it's not a good pattern on it.
1:19:24Yeah, it looks weird.
1:19:25It looks weird.
1:19:26But in person, they look nice.
1:19:28But no major earth-shaking news on Apple Watch, which is exactly what we expected.
1:19:33Right.
1:19:34So do you think—we talked about this in person after the event—you think that they have to do—
1:19:41I kind of think they do have to do Apple Watch 2.0 in September.
1:19:45I think, I think they need to do a refresh.
1:19:47September will be two years since it was announced, uh, if not shipped.
1:19:50Um, and so it's hard to say that the hardware is two years old because the
1:19:54hardware didn't exist when it was announced, right?
1:19:56It was, they were still working on it and then they got it out six months later.
1:19:59But I feel like they do need to do a refresh at the same time.
1:20:03I wonder what is an Apple Watch refresh look like and is it, you know, they've
1:20:07got so much work I think to do on the software side still too, that is it,
1:20:11it is it like I would like to see it be subtle I'd like it to see it be like yes
1:20:16there's a new model but it looks like the old model more or less and all the
1:20:19bands work with it it behaves more or less the same maybe it's more energy
1:20:23efficient it lasts longer it's it's it's more it's faster whatever but it's sort
1:20:28of like still Apple watch almost not like a stealth replacement Apple watch
1:20:322 is completely new but more like now you know here's the new model of Apple
1:20:36it's a little bit better and leave it at that because I feel like what they really don't want to do is give the impression that every two years there's going to be a completely different Apple Watch and all of your old stuff is going to be gone.
1:20:53I think they almost want to make it feel timeless.
1:20:57Like this is our design.
1:20:58It's going to look like this for a while.
1:21:00You can get used to it, feel good about buying one,
1:21:04but we'll see.
1:21:07That's my hope is that it's not
1:21:09like a major phone announcement,
1:21:12but it's more like, yeah,
1:21:13the Apple Watch is a little bit better now,
1:21:15but it's still the Apple Watch.
1:21:16And especially on the hardware side,
1:21:19because I think the hardware is,
1:21:22it can always be improved, but it's not the problem with the Apple Watch. If I've got problems with
1:21:26the Apple Watch, and we talked about this too when we were in Cupertino, you know, I think it's more
1:21:30on the software. Like, after two years of use or in a year and a half where the public is using it,
1:21:36they should have some better ideas about, like, assumptions they made two years ago that maybe
1:21:41aren't right, that they need to fix in software. I think the hardware needs improvement too. I think
1:21:45the thing is just too damn slow. Yeah, well, it's hard to tell, right? Because is that the software
1:21:51the hardware, it's got to be the hardware that's just... the fact that it takes forever for apps to
1:21:55launch and sometimes they don't. Well, and just for example, like, I just went through it again
1:21:59because they let me have a review unit of the the Milanese thing, so I paired it with the...
1:22:04and it's the whole hassle. It's such a... it's the worst thing in the world to complain about,
1:22:10because what a great job I have. This is great. I mean, I... so I don't want to complain, and then
1:22:16I, you know, Apple gives me these things to review and I get to play with this, all this stuff,
1:22:20without having to buy it. It's great fun. But it's a pain in the ass, like with the way that
1:22:29Apple Watch is paired to a phone, it's a pain in the ass to test a new phone because then you can't
1:22:34really fully test it unless you're also pairing it with your watch, if that's how you normally,
1:22:39if you actually wear an Apple Watch. And it's such a pain in the ass to pair and un-pair a watch.
1:22:45But just pairing the new watch that they gave me to review, I paired it with the iPhone SE. So I'm
1:22:50I'm leaving my watch, the one I actually bought and owned,
1:22:53paired with the iPhone 6S that I bought and owned,
1:22:56and I'm using their review unit watch
1:22:58with the review unit phone.
1:23:00What a pain in the ass it is to set up a new Apple Watch.
1:23:03It is, it takes forever.
1:23:05- Yeah, and that's not just a reviewer's problem.
1:23:09My wife had her, she had her iPhone screen break
1:23:14and got a replacement and the replacement digitizer was bad,
1:23:17So she took it back and they replaced the whole unit.
1:23:21And you know what that means.
1:23:22She had to then re repair her Apple Watch
1:23:25and restore it from the backup and it took forever.
1:23:27And then it wasn't working right.
1:23:29And they said, wipe it and don't restore your backup
1:23:34and see if it's something weird involving your backup.
1:23:38So we wiped it and then we had to repair the Apple Watch
1:23:41again and it's another like hour to set that up.
1:23:44So there are real world scenarios
1:23:46Where it's like anytime you change anything about your phone, you have to go through that
1:23:49Apple Watch process again.
1:23:51Right.
1:23:52And I don't, and I think in the long run, they have to be aware of this because inside
1:23:56Apple they have to be, you know, they probably pair and unpair Apple Watches more than anybody,
1:24:01you know, while they're testing betas and testing, you know, prototype new devices and
1:24:05stuff like that.
1:24:06So they have to be aware of that.
1:24:07But it's when you've gone through it and it's no longer novel, like when you've, when it
1:24:11first came out and sure it took a long time, but you could like, you know, I was, you know,
1:24:16just studying what it does and watching the little spinner go around and it's
1:24:20like, "Oh, that's a clever thing," but now it's like, "Oh my god, this is ridiculous."
1:24:24It really can take like an hour.
1:24:27So yeah, I mean, the hardware... I would imagine
1:24:31that a new Apple Watch would not look that different. There's a rumor
1:24:36about putting a camera on it. I don't even know about that because it's just
1:24:39going to take pictures up your nose. It seems ridiculous. But making the
1:24:44processor faster and more energy efficient so that the battery lasts longer. These are things
1:24:51that I could see, right? To me, it feels like that's what the new Apple Watch should be,
1:24:58is like the old Apple Watch, except faster and last longer.
1:25:02I can, the only thing I could think of using the camera for would not be FaceTime, because again,
1:25:08the angle would be terrible and your arm would get tired within like 15 seconds.
1:25:13Yeah. Um, I, I could see it though, if they can do it, it would almost be to me, the only
1:25:19time I would imagine using it. And I've, I've been in this situation, like when I'm out
1:25:22jogging and, and don't want to take my phone out of the pocket I have in or whatever. If
1:25:28it's already in my, if I see something interesting, it would be interesting to just point my wrist
1:25:32at it and take a picture. But there'd be no, there's problems with that too, right? Because
1:25:38you don't, you wouldn't be able to look at the screen to, to do it. If you're pointing,
1:25:43pointing your watch at something, if you can launch a camera app and it turns the bottom
1:25:48button into a shutter for a picture, you could get a picture, but you're almost like shooting
1:25:54it blind.
1:25:55Yeah, I took some pictures of the Apple event without looking through the viewfinder of
1:25:58low angles of Apple products in the hands-on area afterward, and they were all terrible
1:26:04because I couldn't frame them right.
1:26:07That's not going to be...
1:26:08Yeah, I get the appeal of the Dick Tracy video watch kind of thing, but boy, that would not
1:26:12be where I would put my... that's not the thing that's crying out on the Apple Watch.
1:26:16Exactly.
1:26:17Right?
1:26:18Boy, if only it had a camera in there, man, then we would really have something.
1:26:21That is not what I think is going on with the Apple Watch.
1:26:24Exactly.
1:26:25So, yeah, I do think, though, that the big news for the Watch, and hardware and software,
1:26:31will all be in September.
1:26:32I think it will be a huge part of the September event.
1:26:34Yeah.
1:26:35if there was a, if they talk about watchOS 3 a lot at WWDC,
1:26:40if we get, maybe get a sense of that there, right?
1:26:46And I'm hoping, I'm really hoping
1:26:48that they rethink the whole thing,
1:26:50because it feels like, and developers feel this way too,
1:26:53I think, which is, you know,
1:26:55the app model doesn't really work right,
1:26:58and it's confusing and people aren't using apps
1:27:01in large part on the watch.
1:27:03When I talk to developers who have watch apps,
1:27:05Their apps don't get used very much.
1:27:07And that would be a good time for them to communicate with developers.
1:27:10It's like, all right, we're going to make some changes to the watch.
1:27:13Oh, we're going to make it simpler.
1:27:14You know, this is how you're going to, your software is going to interact with it.
1:27:17It's going to be a little bit different.
1:27:18I would love to hear that at WWDC.
1:27:22Uh, we'll see if they, cause I feel like after two years, they got to look at it
1:27:26and go, oh yeah, we, we probably.
1:27:28This whole complications and glances and apps from the app launcher screen.
1:27:33and what we use the buttons for, it's like, we kind of got it wrong.
1:27:37Let's, let's clean this up and do a take two on it. Um, and I hope they do.
1:27:41I hope they don't, I hope they, uh, I think it would be hard for them not to
1:27:45notice that. I hope they're like pride doesn't get in the way. I'm like, no, no,
1:27:48no, no, no. It's going to be fine. It's going to be fine. Uh, because I think
1:27:51this product could be way better, even if all they did was change some of the
1:27:55things about the software.
1:27:56Yeah, I very much agree with that. I, we ever, my bottom line is that I think
1:28:02they made a big mistake by offering apps in the first place.
1:28:05That maybe eventually they should have done it,
1:28:07but I think they should have bit the bullet
1:28:08and done what they did with the iPhone
1:28:10and wait at least a year before they opened it up to apps.
1:28:14Just because the app experience is so poor,
1:28:19it really would have been better to ship without it,
1:28:21even though it would have inevitably led to people screaming
1:28:23that they want apps only in theory,
1:28:27but I still think it just the actual experience of it
1:28:31and the way it's played out, I think bears that out.
1:28:33Like you said, like developers even say,
1:28:35we made the app, but nobody uses it.
1:28:38- Yeah, and having your apps on your phone,
1:28:41it is phone accessory, having your apps on your phone
1:28:44do things on the watch that are interesting,
1:28:46I like that idea.
1:28:47I think the complications thing
1:28:48is actually way more interesting.
1:28:50I think glances are actually a little bit more interesting.
1:28:52I'd almost rather glances be more powerful
1:28:55and not have apps.
1:28:56- Yep.
1:28:58Yeah, I never want to go,
1:29:00I can't remember the last time that I wanted to
1:29:02and needed to go to the app screen.
1:29:04So the pressing one of the primary buttons on the thing,
1:29:07one press on the crown,
1:29:09takes me to a place where I never wanna go.
1:29:11Yep.
1:29:12So anyway, I'm with you.
1:29:15I knew hardware and I hope like a interesting
1:29:18conceptual rethink of the software.
1:29:20I didn't really think about the fact
1:29:21that they might do that at WWDC.
1:29:24I kind of bet that they don't
1:29:26because I think that if they're going to do that,
1:29:29Now that you mention it, I kind of think it could be a big tell as to whether they're
1:29:33going to rethink it or not.
1:29:35And I feel like if they talk about it at WWDC, it probably won't involve a major conceptual
1:29:41rethink of how the watchOS works.
1:29:43And if they are going to do it, I think they're going to save it for September so that they
1:29:47can add to the surprise of the event.
1:29:49Or it'll be one of those half-measures things where, you know, here are some new things
1:29:52you can do with watch apps, and leaving aside that, oh well, we're actually going to change
1:29:57how you get to them and how it works.
1:29:59but only tell the developers what they need to know
1:30:02to get their apps.
1:30:04I don't know, I feel like they need to evangelize
1:30:06with developers about watch apps,
1:30:08because I feel like that was,
1:30:10not only did the customers sort of get let down by the apps,
1:30:15but the developers got let down by the apps.
1:30:16It was their, they had to change midstream,
1:30:20the watchOS 2 apps were different rules
1:30:22than the original watch apps.
1:30:24And so I feel like, yeah,
1:30:25if they want active app developers on the watch,
1:30:29they're gonna have to tell them a story of some kind at WWDC.
1:30:33- Yeah, and I think that the truth is
1:30:36that they burned a little bit of trust, right?
1:30:39- Yeah, oh yeah.
1:30:40- The message from Apple, both publicly and privately,
1:30:43by talking to developer relations people was,
1:30:46seriously, you should do this,
1:30:48you need a story to get on the watch, get on the watch.
1:30:53And a lot of people listened to it
1:30:55and a lot of people did it,
1:30:56and I think a lot of people see it
1:30:57as effectively wasted effort,
1:30:59or at least effort that might have been better allocated
1:31:01to something else.
1:31:02Not that it was completely wasted,
1:31:03but that maybe the time would have been better spent,
1:31:06making your iPad version of your app better,
1:31:08as opposed to--
1:31:10- And not just because of like how many people,
1:31:12it's not how many people have Apple watches.
1:31:14That's not the issue.
1:31:15The issue is people who have the Apple watches
1:31:17aren't using their watch apps
1:31:18because the app experience on the watch is bad.
1:31:21- Right, right.
1:31:22That brings us to the iPhone SE.
1:31:28and Jaws did it on stage.
1:31:29I guess we can just mix talking about the actual device
1:31:32with the event.
1:31:34I thought he did a good job.
1:31:36I thought, you know, we haven't seen Jaws on stage
1:31:38in a while and yeah, I think he's really,
1:31:41he's a great presenter.
1:31:42- I think so too.
1:31:43I ran into him before the event
1:31:45and I walked over from building one
1:31:49where we all came in over to building four with him
1:31:52and we were chatting 'cause he saw the town hall story
1:31:55that we did and thought that was great
1:31:57it turns out they had a slide about it at the end of the presentation. So we, we, people
1:32:00were like, "Ah, see, it's not just us." Which was cool. And I've known that guy for a long
1:32:06time because he used to be like the PowerBook product manager. I mean, he goes back a long
1:32:12way at Apple and he is very good on stage. And one of those town hall events that we
1:32:19found, he like was the person who introed the event. He like got up on stage and said,
1:32:24morning everybody welcome to this Apple event. I'm like wow. I remember that one I think it was like
1:32:30the iOS 2 or iOS 3. Yeah and it was like a March event where they were like announcing I think
1:32:37maybe like iOS 3 and I think it was the iPhone software 3.0 I think is what they called it.
1:32:42Right and it was at a time one of the times when Steve Jobs was on a medical leave. Right and it
1:32:48was a year after they had they had launched the app store. Right. Yeah yeah so he's good and it
1:32:53And it was great to see him on stage because I like him.
1:32:56I think he's a good guy.
1:32:59And I think he does a good job on stage.
1:33:01He's always been sort of, you know,
1:33:04he works for Phil Schiller.
1:33:06So he doesn't get necessarily as many opportunities to shine
1:33:10'cause Phil could have done that demo, right?
1:33:11But instead, Jaws did it.
1:33:13And I thought he did a good job.
1:33:15- Yeah, and it's a tough pitch.
1:33:18Like I said at the beginning of the show,
1:33:20here's a phone that everything about it
1:33:22is familiar in some way.
1:33:23It's just a new combination.
1:33:24And you know, I thought he did a good job.
1:33:26And as somebody who's been looking forward
1:33:28to the idea of a four inch phone that please, please, please
1:33:31still has top of the line specs,
1:33:33I was really happy with the announcement.
1:33:36Tons of speculation before the event
1:33:38that it was gonna have like a underclocked A9
1:33:43if it does have an A9,
1:33:44that the camera would be some sort of lesser image quality
1:33:48compared to the 6S.
1:33:50And both of those things turned out not to be true.
1:33:53Yeah, it's funny. It makes sense to me, right? The rumors that, like, "Oh, it's going to be a redesigned thing."
1:34:03And, you know, it's, uh... And, well, I mean, what you said about the idea of it being underclocked.
1:34:13I was pondering that, because on one level, doesn't that make sense? It's like, well, it's going to be the cheapest phone.
1:34:17It should be kind of lesser, right? And then, as I was listening, I thought, "Okay, I see what they're doing here.
1:34:22doing a lot of what they did when they did the iPad Air 2, which is, "Let's max it
1:34:26out now." And then we're going to just leave it there for a while. Because are they
1:34:29really going to do a new iPhone SE every year? No, they're not. So pack it with the 6S
1:34:36stuff for the most part right now. Pack that in. And I would call that this year's technology,
1:34:41but it's not this year's technology, right? It's last year's technology. It's in
1:34:45the current models, but there will be new models in a few months. So pack it with last
1:34:51technology, but that will give you a couple, you know, two, three years where
1:34:55you don't have to update it. And then in two or three years, you turn it around
1:34:59again maybe and have it look perhaps even exactly the same as it does now
1:35:02again, but at that point you'll put in the specs from the iPhone 7s or
1:35:07whatever. Yeah, that's the... it's like I've been hoping for an iPhone 4 with
1:35:14these specs for so long, and now that I've got it, I'm instantly worried about
1:35:17about the future.
1:35:18- Sure, right, because you may not be able to,
1:35:20whatever amazing thing they announce this fall,
1:35:22or even next fall, you know, may not come to that phone
1:35:26for two years or three years.
1:35:28- That's very true.
1:35:31Now, so my thinking strategically is that
1:35:35they're definitely not going to do a four-inch phone
1:35:38in September, another one.
1:35:39- No, certainly not.
1:35:41- Right. - Certainly not.
1:35:42I don't even think it'll be once a year.
1:35:44- I don't think so either.
1:35:46And I know, and that's a couple of people I've spoken to privately who are 4-inch fans.
1:35:53I think it's too much to ask that they were going to do an iPhone 7 that comes in three sizes.
1:35:594, 4.7, and 5.5.
1:36:02Because it's only six months after this event, right?
1:36:04So they'll go off cycle with events, but they almost never.
1:36:08The only example I can think of is when they replaced the iPad 3 six months after it came out.
1:36:15right? That was like the first retina iPad.
1:36:19So underpowered for that. They're like, "Nope, forget it."
1:36:22It was like the one iOS
1:36:26clunker device that they've shipped. And it was nice in some ways because it was
1:36:30retina, and retina in and of itself
1:36:32is—I think that's why they did it, is that retina in and of itself is so
1:36:35compelling.
1:36:36We bought one, my wife used that for
1:36:39several years, yeah. But it, you know, was replaced just six months after it came
1:36:44out, which is unusual. But that was because it was, you know, there were problems with
1:36:48the iPad 3. It was too heavy, it was underpowered, and there's no problems with the iPhone SE
1:36:54like that.
1:36:55No, and, you know, Apple has shown in the last few years that they're willing to take
1:36:59these products and put them on something other than a one-year cycle. It's like, how do we
1:37:03do more products? One way we do more products as Apple is not update all our products every
1:37:10year, right? So, so they, the iPad Air is a great example. iPad Air 2, the iPad Mini
1:37:15had a year where they didn't do a new version of it, right? And then you come
1:37:20out with one and it's top of the line. Like the iPad Air 2 blew us away with
1:37:24how much stuff was in it. And that's good because it was so far ahead that it had
1:37:29a lot of like room to fall, a lot of time where it could kind of decay as other
1:37:34products advanced and it would still be pretty good. And that's still, I mean,
1:37:38cutting the price on it, that's still a pretty great product with a pretty great price even now.
1:37:43But that I feel is what the SE story is. It's the same thing. It's like, let's max it out now,
1:37:48because then it's just going to sit there for a couple years.
1:37:50- Yeah, I kind of feel like it's the iPhone 5C done right.
1:37:55- Yeah, yeah. I mean, the 5C, it was literally the old phone with color in it. And I think people
1:38:05felt like they were getting, I think one of the reasons it didn't sell so well is
1:38:10that they felt like they were getting kind of last year's tech, and it
1:38:13was not really a new phone, it was just a new wrapper, and the iPhone SE is a new
1:38:18phone, in an old wrapper. Well, and I know that there are definitely, you know, and
1:38:21we say no, you know, we're always speaking, I always speak in extremes
1:38:25because it's easier, you say nobody wanted to buy last year's phone, or nobody
1:38:29wanted to buy a phone that didn't look like a premium iPhone, and of course
1:38:32that's not true. Plenty of people bought the iPhone 5C. I'm sure there's lots of
1:38:36people who are still using it. I've been on Apple's campus, and not
1:38:40recently, but when it was fresher, I saw people, Apple employees,
1:38:44who obviously are well-informed about the specs and could have any iPhone
1:38:50that they want, who chose the 5C because they wanted the color.
1:38:54It definitely appealed to some people. San Bernardino County loved it, too.
1:38:58I think as friend of the show Ben Thompson has pointed out, I think in the aggregate
1:39:04though it proved to be a mistake to make a phone that didn't look like a premium iPhone.
1:39:09The iPhone brand is too, it hinges upon looking like a premium device and therefore it needs
1:39:15to be made out of Apple's premium materials which at the moment are, you know, anodized
1:39:19aluminum.
1:39:20Yeah, it's almost like a, it's psychology that it can be cheaper, that's fine, but it
1:39:26still needs to look like it's premium, like it's expensive. That's an important part of
1:39:31the brand identity, I guess.
1:39:33So my guess is, strategically, they're not going to do a new one next year. Maybe. I
1:39:39wouldn't be surprised if they never make a four-inch iPhone again. And I know that that
1:39:43kind of is a little contrary to JAWS's pitch on stage, which is that we've realized that
1:39:48some people prefer a four-inch phone. I wouldn't be surprised if they never do again. But it
1:39:54might be completely based on how well the iPhone SE sells. If it does sell well enough
1:40:00that they're like, "Yeah, we should definitely keep this in the line, you know, something
1:40:03at this size in the lineup," I wouldn't be surprised if we don't hear, get another one
1:40:07for two years.
1:40:08Yeah, I would be shocked if it wasn't on a two or three year cycle. And that's okay.
1:40:14Not every Apple product needs to get updated every year. Because we just got trained that
1:40:18there would always be a new one. And their bandwidth, I mean, like I said, the idea that
1:40:22you've got now three different current iPhone models plus two of last year's that are still
1:40:29being made and sold. So there's five new iPhones, right? You can't, and three current models,
1:40:35you can't turn them all over every year. They just, they can't. They, they, Apple, I don't
1:40:40think between its designers and engineers and all that, even Apple doesn't have the
1:40:43bandwidth to do that and all the iPads that they've got now and all the Macs they've got
1:40:48So you pull some things that are less vital and you put them on a two-year cycle. There's
1:40:53nothing wrong with that. Until Monday, the four-inch iPhone that they were selling was
1:40:59from 2013. It was two and a half years old. So I wouldn't be surprised at all. And in fact,
1:41:06if you follow the Apple as a company of patterns, I think I wouldn't be surprised if maybe we get
1:41:11another one two and a half years from now. Maybe they'll do a four-inch phone that premieres at the
1:41:16September event. Yeah, could be, could be, or it'll be another thing like this where
1:41:20in two years there'll be a spring event and it'll be the best tech from the iPhone 7S
1:41:26inside the new iPhone SE. Right. One thing they mentioned multiple times, Jaws mentioned
1:41:34at least twice, was that the chamfered edge is now matte instead of polished, which is
1:41:40is true. It is you can if you look at it side by side with an iPhone five or five five or
1:41:47five s you will see the difference. I thought it was a curious thing that they mentioned
1:41:50multiple times though.
1:41:52Well, I mean, it's like literally the only thing that's different about the phone. I
1:41:57wonder I wonder whether that is a decision I would love to know if that is a decision
1:42:03made for aesthetic reasons or financial reasons. Because is it is it that Johnny I've said
1:42:08"You know, if I ever get a chance,"
1:42:11I'm not gonna do a Johnny I voice,
1:42:12"If I ever get a chance to revisit the 5S,
1:42:14the thing that bothers me about it is
1:42:16I really regret the shiny chamfered edge,
1:42:18given that the rest of the edges are all matte,
1:42:21it was a mistake, or whether it's more like,
1:42:25"Hey, Johnny, it's gonna save us like $2 a phone
1:42:28not to have the chamfered edge be shiny.
1:42:30Do you care?"
1:42:31And have him say, "Nah, it's fine."
1:42:32- And he cared when the phone was new,
1:42:36and he was like, "No, goddammit,
1:42:37we're paying the 50 cents to do it.
1:42:39And now it's sort of like he doesn't really care
1:42:42about the SE now.
1:42:43- I'd love to know whether it was that.
1:42:45Like is it a financial decision
1:42:46or is it like a revisitation of,
1:42:49oh, I've changed my mind about the Chamfered edges now.
1:42:51- I could see it either way.
1:42:52I could see it that maybe it was actually difficult
1:42:54to do the matte finish and they couldn't do it before.
1:42:56And now they figured out a way to do it.
1:42:58And now that's why they mentioned it twice
1:43:00because it's a hard thing to do.
1:43:01- They're proud of it.
1:43:02I don't know either.
1:43:03It certainly, I think it certainly makes the design
1:43:06the phone more consistent to have it be not shiny on the on the chamfers because
1:43:11nothing else is shiny. But I don't know from a from a aesthetic like a as a
1:43:18hardware designer what what somebody like Johnny I would say about it I I'm a
1:43:22little baffled but like literally that's it for the 5S because the 5S has the
1:43:26has the double flash on the back so the the camera the flash everything other
1:43:31than the Apple itself and the and the the printing on the back the only other
1:43:35physical characteristic that is different is that chamfer. So I guess if
1:43:41we talk about it because what else are we gonna say? Right, I guess. What do you
1:43:48what are your thoughts on 4-inch phones? Are you a 4-inch? Are you tempted?
1:43:52I'm a little bit tempted. I go back and forth on it. I mean the big
1:43:58screens are nice. The thing I love about the about the 4-inch size and the
1:44:03the iPhone 5 design is it's, um, it feels great in the hand. It's easier to hold.
1:44:08The, the sixes do feel slippery and like, like they're like a polished rock. Um,
1:44:13I've never felt comfortable. It's the first, I always wore my, uh, wore my iPhone
1:44:18naked. Um, and I put a case on the, on the six and I moved that case to the
1:44:21success, the Apple leather case, because it just, I needed it to be grippier. I
1:44:25felt like it was going to slip out of my hands. I never feel that way with a, with
1:44:28the fives. I've always, I've always felt that they were, they were super solid.
1:44:32But, you know, the trade-off there is that the, yeah, the screen's a lot smaller.
1:44:36And as somebody who is not a commuter anymore, um, I, you know, I don't rely
1:44:44on my iPhone as much as I used to.
1:44:46I use it when I'm out and I use it, like if I'm walking the dog or taking
1:44:50a run or something like that, I'm listening to podcasts on it or something
1:44:52like that, but I, I used to use it all the time when I was riding the bus and things
1:44:57like that, and I don't, I don't do that anymore.
1:44:59So, um, so for me, it's less of a productivity device than it used to be.
1:45:03And so the smaller screen probably wouldn't make much of a difference to me.
1:45:07Um, and it's, and it's easier to hold.
1:45:09So I'm, I'm kind of on the fence about it.
1:45:11I, I I'm tempted.
1:45:12I totally am tempted.
1:45:14Um, I'm also a little reluctant to embrace it because of what we said before, which
1:45:19is it's, it's state of the art for six months, and then it probably will be not
1:45:24state of the art for the next 18.
1:45:26- Exactly, and then, it's like,
1:45:29however much I prefer the size,
1:45:30and I definitely prefer the size,
1:45:32I'm not going to not have the top of the line phone.
1:45:35So come September when the iPhone 7 comes out,
1:45:38I'm gonna switch to that anyway.
1:45:40- Which is why this is a phone for people who
1:45:43aren't desperate to always be on the cutting edge,
1:45:47like some of us, or for somebody for whom
1:45:50the larger size is just a deal breaker.
1:45:52And I've heard from, I know a bunch of people
1:45:54who have held onto those five S's because they're like,
1:45:57I don't want a bigger phone, it's too big for me.
1:45:59And some of them, I mean, there was a conversation
1:46:01on Twitter that I thought was pretty good about like,
1:46:04you can overstate saying, well, women with small hands
1:46:08prefer a small phone because I know a lot of women
1:46:10who love huge phones because they just put their phone
1:46:13in their purse and it doesn't matter.
1:46:15But I do know people, men and women,
1:46:17who find holding that big phone uncomfortable
1:46:20and the little phone a lot more comfortable.
1:46:22And so for those people, you know, I think, or uncomfortable in their pocket,
1:46:26or they have small pockets and they can't fit a phone in their pocket.
1:46:29Those are the people who are gonna, who are gonna love it as well as all the
1:46:32people who want the, to buy an iPhone.
1:46:34And this is going to be by far the cheapest iPhone they can buy.
1:46:37Yeah, I do miss, I, there's so much of this design that I miss.
1:46:40I love that it stands up on any side.
1:46:43You can put it sideways to watch video.
1:46:45You can stand it up to take pictures.
1:46:47Uh, there's no camera bump, no camera bump.
1:46:49Oh, and I'll say this too.
1:46:52it's got a headphone jack on it so if the future of the iPhone and being on
1:46:55the cutting edge is losing the headphone jack maybe I'm okay with having the the
1:46:59retro phone that's that's not on the cutting edge I don't know it does feel a
1:47:05little retro it does it's funny to talk about something that what the design
1:47:09premiered in 2012 to talk about it being retro but it's it does it's from earlier
1:47:15in the decade well anyway I like it and yeah my only the only reason I wouldn't
1:47:22switch from my 4s or not 4s Jesus the 6s back and switch to this size is only
1:47:30because I I think it's a you know a six why get used to it for six months only
1:47:34to go back in September because you're gonna want that iPhone 7 whatever it is
1:47:39right you're gonna want it yeah well I honestly it's the camera quality and I
1:47:43say that knowing that II could I get slightly better optical that you know I
1:47:47I get the optical image stabilization in the 6, in the plus,
1:47:52but I'm not switching to a plus size phone.
1:47:54- But okay, so what happens if there's that rumor
1:47:58that there's gonna be a super fancy camera
1:48:00that's only gonna be on a plus model?
1:48:02Would that be enough?
1:48:03Like a really good, maybe almost like SLR quality camera
1:48:08on an iPhone, but you had to get the big iPhone.
1:48:10Would you get the big iPhone for the camera?
1:48:12- That is, I've been thinking about that
1:48:14ever since the rumor.
1:48:15I don't know what I'd do.
1:48:17I don't know.
1:48:19That would be a very hard question
1:48:20because the camera is seriously so important to me.
1:48:23I mean, I know I've said this before,
1:48:25but I know it's called the iPhone,
1:48:27but if I had to pick one component to break
1:48:29and the option was you can, you know,
1:48:31for the rest of the week,
1:48:32you can either use this phone that doesn't make phone calls
1:48:35or you can use this one that doesn't take pictures.
1:48:37Almost all the time, I'd want the one
1:48:40that has the broken phone but takes pictures.
1:48:42It's more of an eye camera to me than an iPhone.
1:48:45just too early. - Yeah, I'd agree.
1:48:46I mean, for me, if all it did was take pictures
1:48:50and play podcasts, I'd probably be okay
1:48:52with not having it make phone calls.
1:48:55- Right, so I don't know.
1:48:57I really hope that the idea that the dual camera
1:49:00is only in a plus, I hope that's not true.
1:49:03- Yeah, me too, but I could see them doing that, right?
1:49:06I mean, and I do think that cameras is one of these,
1:49:09like, we've come so far with the smartphones
1:49:12like we were talking about earlier,
1:49:13but camera technology is like,
1:49:15that's one of the frontiers of smartphones.
1:49:17Cameras and then imperviousness to damage
1:49:20seems to me like the big areas here.
1:49:22And I can maybe throw in glare.
1:49:23Like I'm glad that they've talked about glare
1:49:25in the new iPad, which we'll get to,
1:49:26because that's also an issue,
1:49:28but it's not like it's gotta be faster.
1:49:31All that is, sure, yeah, it's gotta have more battery life,
1:49:33but great cameras in a smartphone is a,
1:49:38that's a huge area of interest for anybody who's got it,
1:49:42'cause those are our cameras now.
1:49:44So keep making them better.
1:49:45- You talked about your love of the original iPhone feel,
1:49:50and I feel the same way about it.
1:49:51I love the outside design,
1:49:52but it's always mind-blowing to me.
1:49:55I mean, we're nine years into it,
1:49:56but I still feel like it's the new thing, the iPhone,
1:49:59but the original iPhone camera was a total piece of crap.
1:50:02- It's terrible.
1:50:02- It was just like a stock phone camera part from Japan.
1:50:07I mean, I'm glad they put it in,
1:50:09but it was almost useless.
1:50:13It was no better than the type of pictures
1:50:16you took with your dumb phone, really.
1:50:18And it didn't even take video.
1:50:19You couldn't even shoot bad video.
1:50:21It just didn't do video.
1:50:23- It reminded me of the bad cam,
1:50:24or really, I was gonna say the bad camcorders
1:50:27in the early days of VHS,
1:50:28but no, it reminded me of the really bad
1:50:29early digital cameras, where it's just,
1:50:31it's streaky, it can't do low light at all.
1:50:34It's a miracle that it's there at all,
1:50:35but it's really like, why not put,
1:50:38sure we should put a camera on it. It's not any good and you would never want to
1:50:41use it unless you were desperate, but at least we have it. And it's come a long way.
1:50:44And now we've got people, you know, we've got kids, you know, in the intervening
1:50:48nine years, we've got kids who their entire, all of the video that's been
1:50:54taken of them as little babies and growing up has all been shot on iPhones.
1:50:58And it's great quality. Yeah, I mean, 4K video, it's just mind-blowing.
1:51:04It's on my TV.
1:51:06My TV, I actually do have a 4K TV.
1:51:07I could figure out a way to put it on there.
1:51:09I could watch that 4K video on there,
1:51:11but it's just, yeah, it's come a long way.
1:51:14And yet, I take pictures with my SLR, my five-year-old SLR,
1:51:19and ooh, they're way better, right?
1:51:23So there's plenty more work to be done.
1:51:25- Oh, tons of room, especially in lower light.
1:51:29- Yeah, and in the beauty of having these,
1:51:33the smartphones having the processors they do, right,
1:51:36is that the image processing is part of the equation too.
1:51:38So software and chip design can help too.
1:51:42So I mean, I don't know, did you see that?
1:51:45There's like a thing that looks like a smartphone,
1:51:47but it's not a smartphone, it's a camera,
1:51:48and it's got like nine lenses on it.
1:51:50- Yes, I know exactly what you're talking about.
1:51:52I forget the name.
1:51:53- And I know it's really weird, but you do,
1:51:56I think we're entering that era now
1:51:58where people are rethinking how you do photography
1:52:01in a given that you have to have a flat device. And the answer is, well, I can't
1:52:06have a long lens, but I could have a lot of lenses and use software because I've
1:52:09got this super powerful processor here. And so I think things are gonna get
1:52:13really interesting for phone photography in the next few years. Yeah, totally. I
1:52:16don't think we're anywhere close to. And I think that the fact that the ad
1:52:19campaign that they've really, really been pounding for close to two years, I
1:52:24think now is shot with iPhone six. Yeah, you know, I just realized if it if the
1:52:30the ad campaign is shot with iPhone 6S or whatever that,
1:52:34I think that's what that is now, shot with iPhone 6S.
1:52:37Will they allow pictures shot with the iPhone SEs?
1:52:41Like, is that like, is there like a certain truth
1:52:46in advertising that a phone, you know,
1:52:48you can't use a picture shot with iPhone SE
1:52:51if the campaign is shot with iPhone 6S?
1:52:53- Maybe it'll just be shot with iPhone.
1:52:56- Yeah, that's what I think the campaign
1:52:57should be, shot with iPhone.
1:52:59I don't think they should say success,
1:53:01although maybe there's some sort of
1:53:04trying to tempt people to upgrade aspect to it.
1:53:07I guess the last thing, and here's another thing
1:53:10that I did not write about on Monday,
1:53:12and I think I should've, and I feel like
1:53:15in reading other people's coverage,
1:53:17so many excellent pieces that were written.
1:53:19You had a good take.
1:53:21Ben Thompson had a great take.
1:53:23But the one thing I missed was the price.
1:53:27And I feel like in large part in recent years,
1:53:30I've really gotten away from talking about prices.
1:53:33I just accept them for what they are.
1:53:34And I think that it's, I'm doing a disservice
1:53:38to my analysis by not taking it into an equation.
1:53:42I think somebody called it out, like in one of my reviews,
1:53:44recent big reviews, like maybe for the iPhone 6s,
1:53:46I didn't even talk about like what the prices were
1:53:48or whether people should buy it or not.
1:53:51I just talk about what it does.
1:53:54A 399 starting point for a top of the line iPhone
1:53:58is a huge difference.
1:54:00I think that the starting price for an iPhone 6S,
1:54:03or I think it was like 649 to buy one
1:54:07without a contract or anything.
1:54:09So it's groundbreaking territory,
1:54:13399/499 for the 16 and 64 gig configurations.
1:54:18- Yeah, I was talking to people about it
1:54:22in terms of the, you know, with two year contract price,
1:54:24which is not a thing anymore in most cases.
1:54:27And, and it totally, it totally isn't.
1:54:30But we all understand the context of that.
1:54:32And in that context, the iPhone SE is free.
1:54:35- Yeah. - Right?
1:54:36Right, that's where it's fitting in the line
1:54:38is it's a hundred below the, what is it?
1:54:43The 6S base? - Yeah, yeah.
1:54:45- That's where it fits.
1:54:46It fits in the, exactly in the same slot as the 5S.
1:54:51And that's just remarkable for something that's not two and a half year old technology.
1:54:55That's six month old technology.
1:54:57And Ben Thompson's, it really is.
1:54:59And Ben Thompson's piece that you're talking about was really great because a lot of the criticism was
1:55:05people were looking at what its price was going to be in India.
1:55:08It's like retail price.
1:55:09And he's so good with some of this international stuff especially.
1:55:13He pointed out that the stores in India don't sell at the retail price.
1:55:19and he did a calculation of like what,
1:55:22considering the street prices of existing phones in India,
1:55:26what the street price of this would be,
1:55:27and it basically goes back to,
1:55:29they priced it the way they did
1:55:30to get it to be the price they want it to be,
1:55:32which is essentially the same price as it is in the US
1:55:36for India.
1:55:36So he deflated some of the criticism
1:55:39of like the exchange rate ruining the idea
1:55:43that it might be a lower cost iPhone.
1:55:45- Yeah, I don't know.
1:55:48I don't have much to say about the price,
1:55:50but I do think that it's noteworthy
1:55:52and it signals a strategic change.
1:55:55- The lowest cost iPhone right now,
1:55:58for the first time in a while,
1:55:59has almost all the features of the expensive iPhones, right?
1:56:04It's not a low cost because it's two-year-old tech
1:56:10right at the moment.
1:56:11And that's good.
1:56:11It's a good deal right now.
1:56:12It's a great deal.
1:56:13- Right, and I think that the way that we'll see this is,
1:56:17and you know it they don't break out the models that much they did say on stage
1:56:23jaws said that they sold 30 million four inch phones in 2015 it was actually your
1:56:30piece that opened my eyes to it because you mentioned that they sell and you're
1:56:33right up that they sell 230 million total so it's still only like 11% because
1:56:38I wrote down in my notes 30 million four inch phones and I circled it like hey
1:56:41it's still a popular size like I'm not I'm not a weirdo for wanting a four inch
1:56:45phone but then I realized it's only it's only like 10%. Yeah well it's like 13 I did I mean
1:56:51the the years are probably wrong but I looked at what they sold last year and um and it's 13% or
1:56:58something like that but keep in mind that's 13% of a one to two one and a half to two and a half
1:57:02year old phone right so they're going to sell more than that so I think it's totally reasonable that
1:57:08the iPhone SE could be 15 to 20 percent of total iPhone sales which is you know if you're asking
1:57:15me a question, is it worth updating the four-inch phone? Is it worth having this as part of
1:57:19your product lineup, which is actually five phones wide? Yeah, I mean, if you're going
1:57:25to sell 20% of your line is going to be this phone, it's totally worth it.
1:57:29But I think if it proves as popular as I suspect it will be, which is a little bit more, you
1:57:34know, maybe it'll creep up to like 15% to 20% of iPhones sold now that it has as good
1:57:41a camera and it's just as fast. Because I feel like that's the two things that even casual people,
1:57:45if you tell them this phone is just as fast and it takes just as good a pictures and video as the 6S,
1:57:51then anybody who's tempted by the size will say, well, I don't, you know, I'm fine with the first
1:57:55generation touch ID sensor and I'm fine without having 3D touch and the other little things that
1:57:59are missing. It's going to affect the average selling price of iPhone, right? This is a move
1:58:05where I think strategically Apple is now willing to have the average selling price of iPhone drop
1:58:11in order to sell more phones throughout the world. Yeah, I agree, although I think
1:58:16it'll be less dramatic than we might think because of the fact that they
1:58:21already were selling a phone at this price. It's just gonna be a more for—and
1:58:25again, it's gonna be that curve where it's gonna be the current phone for six
1:58:28months, and then it's gonna be a step behind the high-end phones for a
1:58:32year after that, and then for another unknown period after that, it'll
1:58:36presumably be two years behind. So it'll have a, you know, it'll have a sales
1:58:40curve that'll go back down. But for the first six months or year, it'll eat into the
1:58:45ASPs a little bit, right? Just because it's a better phone at that price point. But it's
1:58:50not like they didn't have one there before that wasn't, you know, they sold whatever
1:58:53it was, 20 million of them at that price in the last year. So, you know, the ASP change
1:58:59is only going to be in sort of the difference between the boost that they get because it's
1:59:04a much better phone. But they are willing to do that. There's no doubt about it.
1:59:08Anything else on the iPhone before we move on?
1:59:12I don't know. I think we got
1:59:16on the phone that it's all entirely things that have already existed.
1:59:19Well then let me, before we move on to the iPad Pro,
1:59:23the new iPad Pro, I will take a moment here to thank
1:59:26our last sponsor.
1:59:29And it's a new sponsor. I love these
1:59:33people. I've tried this and it is terrific. It's HelloFresh.
1:59:37H-E-L-L-O-F-R-E-S-H.
1:59:41They are a meal kit delivery service,
1:59:43and they make cooking fun, easy, and convenient.
1:59:45So you sign up, and you can get like three meals a week,
1:59:50or four meals a week, you can get five meals a week,
1:59:52and they're designed for either two or four people.
1:59:55So you say, we're a family of four,
1:59:57we want three meals a week.
1:59:59They have new recipes and meals every week.
2:00:02You pick the ones that appeal to you that you want,
2:00:05and then the food just shows up at your door in a box
2:00:09and they use like dry ice to keep the stuff cold
2:00:13and stuff like that.
2:00:14Everything shows up and it's all the exact right amount
2:00:18of quantities, so there's nothing to waste.
2:00:20So it really does work out well.
2:00:22We've done this and the food is great.
2:00:24It comes and it's super, super attractive.
2:00:27I was always worried with a meal delivery thing.
2:00:29It's like I'm kind of picky when I'm in the supermarket,
2:00:31like when I pick the produce, like I want, you know,
2:00:33I don't want like a green pepper that's squishy.
2:00:35I want a good one.
2:00:36Everything that they sent us was absolutely perfect.
2:00:39I mean, just super, super great stuff,
2:00:41really fresh ingredients.
2:00:43And the recipes are all designed
2:00:45to be done in 30 minutes or less.
2:00:48And the recipes are terrifically well-explained.
2:00:52I mean, even an idiot like me who can't cook could do it.
2:00:55It is, I can't say enough good stuff.
2:00:59Good food, good recipes, great instructions,
2:01:03incredibly convenient.
2:01:05It's amazing to me that this works.
2:01:10It feels like I'm living in the future
2:01:12and it saves you from going to the grocery store.
2:01:14Can't say enough good things about it.
2:01:17Give it a try.
2:01:18You get 35 bucks off your first week of deliveries
2:01:22by using this code.
2:01:24You just use the code TALKSHOW
2:01:26and you go to hellofresh.com.
2:01:28So you go to hellofresh.com, take a look at it, pick out the ones you want and you'll
2:01:34save $35 just by using the code "talk show".
2:01:39T-A-L-K-S-H-O-W.
2:01:42Can't say enough good stuff about it.
2:01:43Highly recommend it.
2:01:45Go give them a try.
2:01:46Hello Fresh.
2:01:48Groceries just delivered right to your door.
2:01:51Crazy.
2:01:52It's what a world we live in.
2:01:54So then we got, now we have the iPad Pro, which I guess we could start by just talking
2:01:58about the name, which was as rumored that there is nothing, you know, it's not the
2:02:02iPad Air 3, it is just called iPad Pro. And I guess that's not unprecedented, right,
2:02:08because the name of the 13-inch MacBook Pro is MacBook Pro, and the name of the 15-inch
2:02:13MacBook Pro is MacBook Pro, so it's just, you know, specified by size.
2:02:17It kills me, the decimals, though. It makes me sad. I really like to refer to these as
2:02:21the 10- and 13-inch iPads. They're a little bit, they come up a little short, so there
2:02:27There is nothing, you talk about having problems as a product reviewer, boo-hoo, but I have
2:02:33to set up like a keyboard shortcut or something for 9.7-inch iPad Pro every time I type that
2:02:40now.
2:02:42It's like the little one, or the 10-inch, I call it the 10-inch, but it's not 10 inches
2:02:46diagonal, it's 9.7 inches.
2:02:48So I'm already sick of typing it out.
2:02:51Yeah, me too.
2:02:53I mean, maybe we can come up with a nickname for it, but that was the advantage of saying
2:02:5611" MacBook Air. It's like 11" is better than 9.7". That's not fun to write. But it does
2:03:03make sense. I mean, this is the laptopification of the iPad line, where it's like, instead
2:03:11of saying, "We're going to count by one every time we release one, and we're going to keep
2:03:16the old ones around," instead it strikes me that this is a little bit more like, "Nope,
2:03:20these are the slots. We've got a big one and a little one, and those are our iPad Pros,
2:03:25next year if we if we update them they're just gonna fit in these slots
2:03:29the old ones will go away and the new ones will be here and that's just like
2:03:33like we do with laptops and desktops right there's no other than like the
2:03:37ones that keep around for education like the non retina MacBook Pro I mean
2:03:40generally when the retina MacBook Pro gets updated they don't keep the old one
2:03:44around - it's like these are they replaced them with with new ones and
2:03:49these are the new ones I feel like that's what they're doing with the iPads
2:03:51Yeah, I feel like it's a sign of, at least from Apple's perspective, that they see this as it,
2:04:00once it's gotten, this year is the year that the iPad became like an established product.
2:04:07Maybe that's the wrong word, but that it's kind of grown up to the point where it's,
2:04:11and they're, you know, they're, the whole push that Schiller gave on stage for it is that this
2:04:16is a credible alternative to somebody upgrading from an older PC. This can be your primary
2:04:22big screen computer other than the phone. And I feel like by calling a pro, this is
2:04:28finally the point where they could say that that's true.
2:04:31Yeah. I think so. It's a moment. It's a moment in the life of the iPad.
2:04:37Right. There was a controversy might be the wrong word, but people definitely wrote about
2:04:43it. That Shiller, when he mentioned it, he said that there's 600 million PCs in use
2:04:49that are five-plus years old. And we think that's really sad, and everybody
2:04:53laughed. And the controversy, I guess, or the complaint about it, is that
2:04:58it's sort of tone-deaf to the economic, the perfectly logical and sensible
2:05:06economic reasons why people might be using six or seven year old PCs.
2:05:11- Yeah, I feel like, yeah, I had that thought at the time
2:05:14of like, well, this is in the category of making some jokes
2:05:19at the expense of PCs and making some jokes
2:05:24from the perspective of being a computer manufacturer
2:05:27who wants you to buy new things,
2:05:29but not like, but like missing the point,
2:05:32especially since legendarily Apple's computers
2:05:36have been the ones that have lasted a long time.
2:05:39And so to say a five-year-old PC is sad,
2:05:42does that make a five-year-old Mac sad?
2:05:44Does that make an eight-year-old Mac sad?
2:05:45Does it make John Syracuse's Mac Pro sad?
2:05:47(laughing)
2:05:48- His 20-year-old Mac Pro.
2:05:49- Yeah, but it's still kicking.
2:05:50So I don't know.
2:05:52I get what he was trying to say.
2:05:54I get what he was trying to say.
2:05:55It's like, these old PCs are hanging on
2:05:58and they weren't that great to begin with.
2:06:01And I mean, if I could channel him,
2:06:04what I'd say is the people who are using those old PCs,
2:06:08A lot of them are people who don't need a PC.
2:06:10Five years ago, this was the only thing
2:06:13they could get to get on the internet.
2:06:15Like, you buy a computer to get on the internet.
2:06:19And a lot of that stuff, if all you're doing--
2:06:20my mom was like, my mom had a MacBook Pro for a long time.
2:06:23And now she has an iPad.
2:06:25She is very happy with her iPad Air
2:06:27and not having a MacBook Pro anymore.
2:06:29Because it was-- her laptops, for years,
2:06:32her Mac laptops were her gateway to the internet, her gateway
2:06:35to do especially email.
2:06:37And there are other devices that do that now
2:06:39that are way better for that purpose.
2:06:41And the iPad is that device for her.
2:06:44And so I think that's what Schiller was kind of getting at
2:06:47is this idea that these old PCs,
2:06:50you bought them because you needed to do things with them
2:06:53that you don't need to use a PC for anymore.
2:06:55And you can just dump them, get an iPad and you'll be happy.
2:06:58But I had that thought of like, is it sad?
2:07:03I mean, other than that PCs are sad in general,
2:07:06which I think was part embedded in his statement.
2:07:08- Yeah, exactly.
2:07:09And you have to realize that when Apple talks about PCs,
2:07:13PC is Apple lingo for Windows PC.
2:07:16Like the Mac is a personal computer,
2:07:18but the Mac is not an Apple lingo, a PC,
2:07:21even though logically it is.
2:07:23And that's sort of, you know,
2:07:25a lot of what Schiller was saying
2:07:27is just as much an argument
2:07:28about why somebody doesn't need a Mac
2:07:30instead of just using an iPad.
2:07:33And it's a little bit, you know,
2:07:35it's like Windows PCs become the whipping boy
2:07:37for the iPad marketing,
2:07:41but it's a little,
2:07:43not uncomfortable, but it's a little bit like,
2:07:48I knew with the direction Schiller was going
2:07:50and how hard he was pushing it,
2:07:51I knew there wasn't gonna be any surprise MacBooks
2:07:53at that event, 'cause there's no way
2:07:55you could bring MacBooks on stage after everything he said
2:07:57about how you don't need a traditional PC.
2:08:00- Yeah, I had that thought of like,
2:08:03going to be hard to introduce Macs now.
2:08:05I mean, just cause it's like laptops are unnecessary.
2:08:08Also we have laptops.
2:08:10Right.
2:08:10Like, well, like imagine, you know, it's the same way that like, imagine
2:08:14if instead of unveiling a smaller iPhone, if they had unveiled, if the
2:08:18iPhone se was bigger iPhone, like it was 5.7 inches, the biggest phone
2:08:22we've ever had, you don't even need a tablet anymore, then you can't
2:08:25have iPads come out after that.
2:08:27Right.
2:08:27You know, this can replace a tablet for, for a lot of people.
2:08:31If that was the selling of the iPhone,
2:08:33then you can't come out afterwards with iPad.
2:08:35So I kind of knew that.
2:08:37And I guess the other thing is that I think it's just innate
2:08:41to somebody who's a long time Apple person like Schiller
2:08:46to kind of want to crack jokes at Windows expense.
2:08:48That's to me, it was clearly what Schiller intended.
2:08:51It was sort of a joke at Windows being crappy
2:08:54and older Windows even worse, right?
2:08:57A six or seven year old Windows machine is even worse
2:08:59than at least a modern, faster one, and that's kind of sad.
2:09:02But it definitely played wrong.
2:09:04I mean, it was way more than one person emailed me about it.
2:09:07And I think it was an unusual misstep for Apple.
2:09:12- Yeah, I mean, it must be end of the world.
2:09:13- But I think it's, I can see how they made it though,
2:09:14because internally it made all the sense in the world.
2:09:17I wouldn't be surprised if he said the exact same thing
2:09:19word for word in rehearsals,
2:09:21and nobody, it didn't even occur to anybody.
2:09:23Everybody just saw it as a joke at Windows expense.
2:09:25- Any of us who know what the Apple lexicon is
2:09:28can look at what was said and be like,
2:09:29I get what he was saying there.
2:09:30- Right.
2:09:31- But yes, it seems like they maybe didn't have
2:09:34that second thought, which is,
2:09:35but this is not how it will necessarily be perceived.
2:09:38And you know, the usual suspects,
2:09:41like I was waiting for Kyle Wiens at iFixit to chime in,
2:09:44which he did about it, 'cause it's like,
2:09:47that's been his thing for a long time,
2:09:48that Apple, you know,
2:09:49Apple wants you to have your computer be disposable
2:09:52and you get rid of it and replace it with a new one
2:09:54rather than fixing it yourself.
2:09:56And here's somebody who fixed their MacBook.
2:09:58I just referred my mom's old MacBook Pro. I put an SSD in it and I maxed the RAM out
2:10:02and I sold it. I was going to give it to a friend and then they didn't, they bought a
2:10:06new computer so I sold it on Craigslist to a college student. But it was pretty great
2:10:10after I got the spinning hard drive out of it and put in an SSD and maxed out the RAM.
2:10:15It was a 2009 or something and it was still fine.
2:10:19I saw a guy at Starbucks like a week or two ago using the black MacBook and he obviously
2:10:26kept it in tremendous shape because it was all, it just looked great, looked like near
2:10:31mint. And it was one of those moments where I was like, "Whoa, what kind of computers
2:10:37that guy using? That looks cool." And then I realized what it was, that it was an old
2:10:41black MacBook. And I was like, "Wow, hats off to that guy, man. He really takes care
2:10:44of that thing." But also hats off to Apple for making a design that 10 years later still
2:10:49made me think, "Whoa, what is that cool thing?"
2:10:51You can get to the hard drive right from the battery bay for that one. So you could pull
2:10:54that out and put in an SSD really easily.
2:10:56And it's amazing how many of the old computers,
2:10:58the big problem with them is just that the drives
2:10:59are really slow.
2:11:00So that's like number one tip is, you know,
2:11:03but I get what, yeah, I get what Phil Schiller was saying.
2:11:06And it just, it made it difficult to,
2:11:09to talk about Macs at the event.
2:11:10And I certainly had opened to him
2:11:12to a little bit of criticism.
2:11:13I get what they were saying, right?
2:11:14- Here's what I would like, I would be interested to know
2:11:17is not how many, how many five-year-old PCs are in use,
2:11:23but how many three, four year old iPads are in this?
2:11:28'Cause I still think, I firmly believe
2:11:30that the quote unquote problem with iPads
2:11:33with the way that sales have actually declined
2:11:35and sort of steadily gone down,
2:11:37but are still pretty, compared to the PCs,
2:11:41it's still, they still sell like 10 million of them a quarter.
2:11:44It's not going away.
2:11:47I still think though that the fundamental problem
2:11:49is that people get, problem from Apple's perspective,
2:11:51is if people get an iPad and if they like it,
2:11:54what they like about it,
2:11:55they still like three, four years later.
2:11:57They don't see the need to upgrade until the thing breaks.
2:12:02- Yeah, I agree.
2:12:04I think this is the, you know, there's that,
2:12:07like I forget exactly the details,
2:12:09but it's the legend of like you make a product so great
2:12:11that nobody ever needs a replacement
2:12:13and you go out of business because you can't,
2:12:15you know, you can't do that.
2:12:17Although that story is actually
2:12:19the story of every app developer, right?
2:12:21you sell it once and then you can't ever sell it again because it's free updates
2:12:24for everyone and sales of us in in mind and if I'm right then the reason sales
2:12:29were so much higher in the early years up like around 20 million a quarter is
2:12:33because there was the iPad there was nothing like it and so it was an
2:12:37unfulfilled desire on the marketplace like when people were realizing wow I
2:12:44think I could really use one of those things because they didn't have anything
2:12:47like it. And so it was on that the sales were unnaturally high compared to where
2:12:52they quote-unquote should be. Yeah. And I would love to know that because that's
2:12:58clearly you know the idea is look if you have an old creaky this is what the
2:13:01Apple's saying if you have an old slow PC and you're looking to buy a new thing
2:13:05you should look at this look at this iPad Pro this is you know it it's the
2:13:10future of computing it has everything you need and it does these other it's
2:13:14better in so many ways. And I think that that kind of might apply to iPads. It might be
2:13:22like, look, you think your iPad is still good enough, but the new ones, we've done so much
2:13:26in the last four years, and this is so much lighter, and it's got stereo sound and a better
2:13:32display. I think that they've got to start marketing it towards people who have old iPads.
2:13:40I feel like they're going to sell a lot of the, of the little iPad pro,
2:13:44because that is the mainstream size. Um,
2:13:47and maybe not to people who already have an iPad air too,
2:13:51although probably to some of them too, but to older iPads, you know,
2:13:55it's newer and lighter, it's got the pencil support.
2:13:57I think the pencil on that size is going to be big for a lot of people. And so,
2:14:02so I feel like that that is the product that we've been sort of waiting for,
2:14:06for the last year of, you know,
2:14:07what's the next 10 inch iPad and what features is it going to have?
2:14:12And it's pretty impressive set of features that it's got.
2:14:16So I feel like they are going to,
2:14:18whether it's going to make a difference in terms of the iPads overall,
2:14:21like sales decline, who knows?
2:14:24But I do feel like it will be enough to motivate a bunch of people to, uh,
2:14:28to upgrade their old iPads.
2:14:30And they haven't had any motivation for a year and a half.
2:14:32Uh,
2:14:33so one of the things that really interested me about it was it wasn't just a
2:14:37shrunk down 12 inch or 12.9 inch iPad Pro. It actually it it gained a little in
2:14:47terms of the display and the camera it has a superior camera and a better
2:14:50display and it lost a little and that it doesn't have the the new super fancy
2:14:54USB 3.0 lightning port and I don't think there's anything else that's missing I
2:14:59could be wrong but I thought you know so it's on the plus side it's a superior
2:15:04iPad in terms of the display and having the True Tone technology and the camera, which
2:15:09is again like the iPhone SE, it's the success camera assembly or camera system, including
2:15:16the bump. And on the lightning, it doesn't have USB 3. So that's interesting to me because
2:15:23I'm not even quite sure how that came about. It's like you would think it would have it
2:15:29would. I can see how it's better in some ways, but I'm surprised it doesn't have USB 3.
2:15:32Yeah, I was talking to Christina Warren about this the other day, and I gave her this scenario
2:15:39of like, if I'm Mr. Moneybags and I walk into an Apple store and I say, "Provide to me your
2:15:44finest iPad with all of the greatest features," they can't. Because some of them are on the iPad
2:15:52Pro, or some of them are on, sorry, the big iPad Pro, and some of them are on the small iPad Pro.
2:15:59And it's just a weird combination of them.
2:16:01That, you know, true tone,
2:16:02you want the true tone, get the small one.
2:16:04You want USB 3 transfer speeds, get the big one.
2:16:08- Yeah, that's an interesting--
2:16:09- You want a good camera, get the small one.
2:16:12- Right, hmm.
2:16:13- You want the, and it's got the color,
2:16:15you want the same color gamut as the modern,
2:16:18like the 2015 model iMacs, Retina iMacs.
2:16:22That's on the small one, not the big one.
2:16:24- Right.
2:16:24- I don't know.
2:16:27I'm assuming it'll work itself out eventually,
2:16:31six months from now or a year from now,
2:16:33but it's an interesting state of affairs.
2:16:35I can't help but think it probably just comes down
2:16:38to component pricing, I'm guessing.
2:16:40- Yeah, that would be my guess.
2:16:43- Right, so the big iPad Pro starts at a much higher price,
2:16:48and this one starts at 599.
2:16:49And I guess because the display is smaller,
2:16:51they can afford to make it better.
2:16:53I don't know, I'm just guessing that
2:16:55whatever complicated math goes into figuring out, you know, how do we make it so we can
2:16:59sell this at $5.99 with the margins we want that USB 3.0 didn't make the cut.
2:17:04Yeah, yeah, it's it's a it's a divided guess. It's a weird combination of what price, what
2:17:11what features do we omit from the smaller model because we just don't have the margins
2:17:15for it. And what new innovations do we have that we can put in a brand new product that
2:17:20wasn't available six months ago. And this is what you get is you get their product,
2:17:24features removed because you want to hold the line on margins, but we came up
2:17:29with this True Tone thing and it wasn't ready for the the big iPad Pro, but it's
2:17:33ready now, so let's ship it in there and get and get something new in there. This
2:17:37is why ideally you don't ship your product line in alternating cycles like
2:17:44this, right? Ideally you say here are all the new iPad Pros, like here are all the
2:17:47new Retina MacBook Pros, and you do it at once, and then you can explain, well the
2:17:5115 has some things that 13 doesn't.
2:17:54Like when I had an 11 inch Air, right?
2:17:55And the 11 inch Air doesn't have the card reader,
2:17:57for example, it's like, all right, it just, it doesn't.
2:17:59But that's okay.
2:18:00But if the 11 inch Air was out of sync with the 13 inch Air
2:18:03and got the new features first,
2:18:04but also lacked some old features
2:18:06because the small one doesn't get those,
2:18:09you'd be where we are with the iPad Pro,
2:18:10where they're just kind of out of step.
2:18:12And that's a question about, you know,
2:18:14are they gonna be in step now?
2:18:16Is every spring are we gonna get new iPad Pro models?
2:18:18Is that how it's gonna work?
2:18:19I don't know.
2:18:20- Yeah, I wonder.
2:18:21Maybe because now it's a mature, like I said,
2:18:23like mature like in the way that the MacBook Pros are mature.
2:18:26Maybe they come out on a, iPads come out on a,
2:18:30when they're ready we will release some schedule.
2:18:32You know, that there is no, like there's no real pattern
2:18:35to when we expect new MacBooks.
2:18:37They, you know, we get rumors of when they're coming out
2:18:40and people who pay attention to Intel's, you know,
2:18:43chip pipeline can estimate, you know,
2:18:47well, you know, this chipset is coming out soon
2:18:49this one's delayed so new MacBooks are probably delayed but it's there's no
2:18:53like it's not like with the iPhone where you know that it's gonna be like a
2:18:57Tuesday in September in the middle of September right here's the here's a
2:19:02fascinating fact and I cannot explain it so the camera bump I hate camera bumps
2:19:06or really do I know I to an irrational degree really hate the camera bump on
2:19:13the iPhone 6 and success really really hate it I just every time I and I my
2:19:18thumb just goes to it like like rubbing like a pimple on your on your other hand
2:19:24or like playing with a wart or something. The other advantage of sticking it in a
2:19:28case is that I don't have that. I really it's the closest that's the main reason
2:19:34that I almost carried my success and I even spent like a month with it in a
2:19:39case is for exactly that reason because it alleviated the bump. So the iPad has
2:19:43the bump. The iPad, new iPad Pro, but when you put it on a tabletop it does not
2:19:48wiggle. It doesn't wobble. I don't understand how this is possible. I don't. I know. And Matthew
2:19:54Panzareno tweeted about it and people saying that he's full of shit and, you know, saying you're
2:19:59lying. That's impossible. And he like shot a video and it's like you lay it on a flat table and it
2:20:04doesn't wobble. I don't, I guess it's, I don't understand. I'm sure it has something to do with
2:20:08the curvature of the earth. My guess is that there's something, you know, you've got, it's
2:20:15it's a much larger item than the,
2:20:17the much larger surface than the iPhone.
2:20:19So it probably has something to do with the angle
2:20:21of the lift of it being reduced by that amount of distance.
2:20:25So that it's imperceptible compared to
2:20:30something that's very,
2:20:31'cause if you had something that was really small
2:20:33and there was like a bump on one side,
2:20:35the angle would be greater.
2:20:38- Maybe my dining room table isn't perfectly flat.
2:20:41I don't know.
2:20:42- It could be.
2:20:44And so somebody out there might have--
2:20:45- Perch of the earth, I'm telling you.
2:20:46- Somebody out there-- - It's physics, man.
2:20:48- It might wobble on somebody's table.
2:20:50And I'd be interested to hear from anybody
2:20:51if they get it and it does wobble.
2:20:53But if your concern about the camera bump
2:20:55is that when you lay it flat on a table, it's gonna wobble.
2:20:57I'm telling you, it doesn't.
2:20:58So it's got that going for it.
2:21:01- Well, that's good, 'cause that would be a disaster
2:21:03if that was the case.
2:21:04Like, hey, it's got the Apple Pencil, you can draw on it.
2:21:06Now lay it on a table.
2:21:07Nope. (laughs)
2:21:09That would be awful.
2:21:12Otherwise, I don't know what else to say about it.
2:21:15It's the iPad Pro.
2:21:17It's got the pencil.
2:21:18- Well, so when they announced the True Tone feature,
2:21:23somebody in the audience went, "Ah!"
2:21:26And Phil Schiller went, "Ah, somebody knows
2:21:28"what I'm talking about." - That was me.
2:21:29- And afterward you said it was you, yeah.
2:21:31- I swear to God, it was me. - I'm not surprised.
2:21:33I'm so not surprised.
2:21:34- I don't think that's quite the noise I made,
2:21:36but I did grumble something. - You audibly reacted.
2:21:40audibly reacted because to me it's like the next step up from retina like and I
2:21:45wanted retina screens you know my entire life so I can no longer see the pixels
2:21:49because clearly that's the way it should be but to to adjust for color
2:21:53temperature is the next you know it something I've thought of for as long as
2:21:58I've been using computers because I've noticed that boy wait at nighttime when
2:22:02you have incandescent lights on boy the white doesn't look like white anymore or
2:22:07or it looks too white or something, you know,
2:22:09that it's not like paper.
2:22:11- Right, well, it's not white balancing,
2:22:14like, you know, our eyes white balance
2:22:16to match the temperature of the light,
2:22:18but the device doesn't know, right?
2:22:22It's just set to whatever color temperature it's set to,
2:22:25and that's what you get.
2:22:26- Right.
2:22:27- It's a great idea.
2:22:28I wanna see it in practice, right?
2:22:30I wanna go through that and see whether this is something
2:22:32that I really, you know, I really noticed or not,
2:22:34but I like, I really like the idea of it,
2:22:36And like Craig Hockenberry was saying,
2:22:39there's a lot of color management business
2:22:41that's happening on the iPad these days.
2:22:44And for any of us from the old sort of desktop publishing
2:22:48days, the idea that you've got really interesting things
2:22:52happening with color on these devices is really great.
2:22:55I was talking to, when I talked to Glenn Fleischman,
2:22:58I was on the Macworld Podcast 500,
2:23:00and we were talking about this.
2:23:01And he mentioned that this is one of those moments
2:23:05where you kind of wish Bruce Fraser was still around
2:23:07'cause he would love this.
2:23:09He passed away a few years ago,
2:23:11but he was a color management, like God, basically.
2:23:15I learned so much from that guy about how human,
2:23:17the brain perceives color and all of this stuff.
2:23:20And it's really interesting to see Apple go down this path
2:23:23where it's like, we all just took for granted
2:23:26that the white point of your display was what it was.
2:23:29- Remember when you used to have to calibrate it manually?
2:23:31Oh yeah, like cross your eyes and adjust this thing
2:23:34until you get the right gamma, yeah.
2:23:36Oh yeah, and then they make things with suction cups
2:23:40that you'd stick on your screen
2:23:42and then it would put something on it
2:23:43and it would read what the light was off of it
2:23:44and it would know how to calibrate the display
2:23:47so that it would get the color
2:23:49that would be the same as the color that you would print
2:23:50and the same as the color that would come out
2:23:52on the offset press when you printed your catalog.
2:23:55All of that, just so much goes into that.
2:23:59And it's a little bit like, there's like memory color,
2:24:02this idea that it's almost like an optical illusion.
2:24:05It's your brain, your brain knows what colors things are.
2:24:07So it will actually adjust what you see
2:24:09to be the color that it isn't.
2:24:11Like if you see an apple and it's red,
2:24:13but it's the wrong red, your brain like corrects it
2:24:16and makes it the right red.
2:24:17And that's not what you're seeing,
2:24:19but it's what you think you're seeing.
2:24:21So there's so much in here.
2:24:22And so for Apple to like dip their toe in and be like,
2:24:25yeah, we're gonna work on color now,
2:24:27or this is the next frontier for us,
2:24:29is it's really interesting beyond just the True Tone feature.
2:24:33- Yeah, I haven't spent, I have the iPad Pro,
2:24:37I have a review unit of it.
2:24:39I haven't spent, so far, I spent most of my time
2:24:42with the iPhone, not the iPad, so I've tinkered with it.
2:24:45But I haven't really spent that much more time
2:24:49of really looking at the night shift,
2:24:51or not night shift, the True Tone,
2:24:53than you did at the event, really.
2:24:56But it is nice.
2:24:58It definitely is, and it's not a gimmick.
2:25:00It's, and I totally believe Schiller
2:25:02that once you get used to it,
2:25:04you want it on all your devices.
2:25:06- I think it's gonna have a better effect
2:25:07than the night shift thing.
2:25:09- I think night shift is a gimmick.
2:25:12I mean, and if there's people out there, listen,
2:25:13who really do feel like they get a better night's sleep
2:25:15or they think good, I wish everybody a good night's sleep.
2:25:19But to me, it seems like a gimmick.
2:25:21- Yeah, I think it's fine.
2:25:24But when I think about True Tone, I think what,
2:25:28the best benefit of Night Shift is solved by True Tone.
2:25:33That Night Shift, I use Night Shift,
2:25:37I've been using the 9.3 Beta for a while on my iPad Pro
2:25:40because the big iPad Pro had,
2:25:45the 9.2 was quirky on the big iPad Pro.
2:25:49So I've been using the Beta for a while.
2:25:50And so I've had Night Shift.
2:25:51And I find myself using it a lot at night
2:25:54and in the early morning when I've got incandescent lights
2:25:57and the super blue white color temperature of the display
2:26:02is like totally out of whack with my surroundings.
2:26:06Well, a nice shift can do that, but True Tone does that.
2:26:09True Tone does that, solves that same problem
2:26:11where the white that you're seeing on your screen
2:26:14is in context with the rest of your environment.
2:26:17And when you do that, I feel like you've got
2:26:21most of the problem solved.
2:26:22That for me, like I don't even need night shift
2:26:25if I've got a device that will just make my iPad screen warm
2:26:29when I'm in the warm dark light of my living room
2:26:32at 10 at night.
2:26:33- It could just be, yeah.
2:26:35To me, it's just making it look better.
2:26:37It's not about magically get, you know,
2:26:39that this solves the problem of getting a good night's sleep.
2:26:43And again, I could be wrong, I don't know.
2:26:45But I thought even the way Apple spoke about night shift
2:26:47on stage was sort of like acknowledging
2:26:49that this is junk science that,
2:26:51or at least that the science is,
2:26:53the quote unquote science behind it is a little questionable.
2:26:54They were like, some people say
2:26:56they get a better night's sleep.
2:26:58I think that the problem,
2:27:00and I totally believe that there is a problem there.
2:27:02I just think the problem is staring
2:27:03at glowing screens, period,
2:27:05and that color shifting it isn't solving the problem.
2:27:08- Did you see Glenn's piece on Macworld?
2:27:10- No, I don't think I did.
2:27:11- It's new as we record this.
2:27:12I think it was today that it comes out.
2:27:13- Well, then I definitely didn't see it.
2:27:15Definitely didn't see it.
2:27:15- He actually talked to some people
2:27:17who are researchers in this field,
2:27:18and I'm sure people are gonna be skeptical
2:27:20and they're gonna try to debate him on this.
2:27:22But what Glenn basically said is,
2:27:24if it helps you, if you feel it helps you, great,
2:27:29but there's not a lot of science to suggest that.
2:27:31At the levels where Apple is doing this,
2:27:34where they're still keeping some blue in there,
2:27:36so it's just less, it's an issue of brightness
2:27:40and the fact that they're not cutting all the blue out,
2:27:42because if you cut all the blue out,
2:27:44it would look really bad.
2:27:45Like you wouldn't wanna use it.
2:27:47And so they're keeping some of it in there.
2:27:49I think it looks bad with as much blue as they're taking out.
2:27:51I bet.
2:27:52That's the reason I don't like it.
2:27:53So, so that's the, so what his point is, you know, yeah, it's your brightness is a
2:27:57big factor in it too.
2:27:58And, and how much does this affect the melatonin in your brain?
2:28:01And I think everybody would say that, yeah, not having bright glowing screens is
2:28:06going to help you sleep better, but having a slightly less bright, slightly less blue
2:28:11glowing screen that you're looking at, it may, it may not help enough to override
2:28:16the fact that you're watching that screen.
2:28:17Right.
2:28:18I think you're kind of kidding yourself.
2:28:21Maybe the answer is read a book.
2:28:23- Yeah, turn off the TV and give yourself an hour
2:28:25where you're just reading a book or something like that.
2:28:27- Right, get a subscription to the paper edition
2:28:29of your favorite magazine.
2:28:30All right, I wanna talk a little bit about Gary Shandling.
2:28:35I'm just assuming that you were a Shandling fan.
2:28:38- Yeah, I didn't see as much.
2:28:39I never had premium cable, so I came to a lot of it late.
2:28:42I watched the It's Gary Shandling show on Fox
2:28:46when they cut it up and put it on Fox.
2:28:48Cause I never had, when I was a kid, we didn't even have cable.
2:28:51So I certainly didn't have showtime.
2:28:52And then Larry Sanders also, it was like a sporadic thing where they were getting,
2:28:57um, did they get rerun somewhere else?
2:28:59I saw them, but I saw them like late.
2:29:01I was never right, like in on it.
2:29:03But also as, I mean, we talked about as a, as a late on talk show person, I just
2:29:08remember him from all of his great guest bits and guest host bits on the
2:29:11tonight show and on a Letterman.
2:29:13All right.
2:29:13Well, before we talk about channeling, I want to thank our fourth and final sponsor, and
2:29:17it's our good friends at MailRoute.
2:29:19M-A-I-L-R-O-U-T-E.
2:29:20IT departments are expected to do more in 2016, but of course you're getting less money.
2:29:27And that includes really important stuff like stopping spam and virus attacks going through
2:29:32the email that you are responsible for.
2:29:35You being those of you listeners of the show who are in the IT department who are responsible
2:29:40for email.
2:29:41If, like me, you're just one person who owns a domain name that you get email through.
2:29:48If you're in charge of the email for a domain, mail route is something you really ought to
2:29:52look at.
2:29:53Who can you trust to do the job and stick around?
2:29:55Mail route.
2:29:56These guys at mail route, this is all they do, is email.
2:30:00They protect your email and your hardware or your server against spam, viruses, and
2:30:05other attacks.
2:30:06They don't host your email for you.
2:30:08Mail route isn't a company that hosts email for you.
2:30:10So you keep the mail server you already have.
2:30:12What you do is you change your MX records
2:30:14for your domain name to point through mail route first.
2:30:17And it's just like a screen.
2:30:20Email goes to them and then from mail route,
2:30:22it goes on to your existing regular mail server,
2:30:26except without any of the spam, without any of the junk.
2:30:29You can set it up and just have it go through
2:30:32and as soon as the MX records update, it just works.
2:30:35And that's it, you're done, you don't even have to touch it.
2:30:38But if you want to, if you want to nerd out
2:30:40customize it. They have an API that can, you can program it, you can do all sorts
2:30:44of super nerdy stuff. I mean, if you're an email nerd, you're gonna love this. The
2:30:49spam filtering that they do is as good as any that I've seen. You know, some of
2:30:55my domains go through Google, and Google has great spam filtering. I think
2:31:01Apple's spam filtering has gotten a lot better with Mac.com over the years.
2:31:04Mail route spam filtering is just as as good as it can get. Almost no false
2:31:09positives and almost all the junk goes through. It's like the old days of email before spam was
2:31:15invented. It's amazing. They've also got, and I think this is key, they've got great interface
2:31:21for going through and checking if you need to check to see if something was erroneously flagged
2:31:26to spam or something like that. You can still get it. It's not like the spam, what they call spam,
2:31:30just gets flushed away. Could not be better. They have price matching for McAfee and MX Logic
2:31:37customers. I don't even know what MX logic is, but if you do, then you ought to talk to mail route
2:31:42because they've got price matching. You can stop spam today for free. You get a 30-day free trial.
2:31:48Try it for 30 days. Totally free. And if you don't like it, just change your MX records back.
2:31:52You have to move all your email around. It couldn't be easier to switch it off if you don't want to
2:31:57to use it. So here's where you go. Mailroute.net/TTS. Mailroute.net/TTS. Or you can even email
2:32:08them at sales@mailroute.net and just ask questions and see if it's for you. And use that Mailroute.net/TTS.
2:32:16You get 10% off for the lifetime of your account. Lifetime. So if you're using them 10 years
2:32:22from now you'll save you'll still be saving 10 10 percent so my thanks to them the shandling thing oh
2:32:28jason it's it i feel like this is i feel like this is maybe like the rest of my life is all of a
2:32:33sudden people who start dying are like people who i cannot believe that they've died and like a heart
2:32:40attack at 66 isn't exactly old age but it is sort of you know it's the sort of thing that when i was
2:32:44a kid and they'd say some famous person died of a heart attack at 66 as a kid i thought well that's
2:32:50you know, that's what happens when you get old. Sometimes people have heart attacks and die.
2:32:53I don't know if it's like, Shannen is too close in age to me, though. It's like,
2:32:59it just seems like I'm at the age now where 66 is like tragically young.
2:33:03- Yeah, well, I mean, that was what he and Jerry Seinfeld talked about in that comedians
2:33:08and cards getting coffee, right? It's like the only time they ever referred to being in your
2:33:1360s as so young is when you die in your 60s. But it's true, like, and some of it is the older you
2:33:19get, the more you push off old age. It's like, "No, 40 isn't old. No, 50 isn't old. 60 isn't old."
2:33:26But also, just human lifespans are increasing, and our working lives are increasing. And so,
2:33:34what was a retiree maybe when we were kids is now a more active age today. So, you look at
2:33:41him being 66, and yeah, I guess this is how life is going to be. As you get older, all these people
2:33:48that you love are dying, but yeah, just too young.
2:33:53I was-- I didn't have Showtime either. I did have cable though, so I
2:33:58was exposed to the "It's Gary Shanling" show on Fox,
2:34:02which was slightly edited, I guess there were, you know--
2:34:05Commercials and some whatever, like, if there were words or
2:34:09nudity or whatever, but yeah, me too. I-- but I just--
2:34:12it spoke to me in a way that the only other person, you know, you and I have
2:34:16spoken at length about our mutual love for David Letterman. It spoke to me in a way that
2:34:22Oney Letterman did, in a way that he was playing with the form of TV. And a couple of the obituaries
2:34:30mentioned it, that he was just a master of television, and in a way that like, I don't
2:34:35know if he ever considered, you know, like having a film career, although he did have,
2:34:39he was the senator in the Iron Man 2. In a way that like the basic gist of show business
2:34:48was always, at least in our lifetimes, you know, in the late 20th century, was TV was the B team
2:34:54and the feature films were the A team, you know, that's what you aspired to do.
2:34:59And Shandling is a guy who clearly, I mean in Letterman too, because remember they used to
2:35:06used to be talking about Letterman doing movies and Disney wanted to, who was the CEO of Disney?
2:35:11Michael Eisner. Michael Eisner really wanted to sign Letterman to a movie deal and Letterman
2:35:18was like, "Have you ever seen, you know, I'm a terrible actor, you don't want to do this."
2:35:21And he's like, "Just let us give you the money, we'll just let us." And then they dug up Letterman's
2:35:26audition for Airplane and Eisner was like, "Holy shit, you're right, you're terrible.
2:35:32absolutely terrible. Yep. Shanling is a guy who clearly did it's like his genius was specific to
2:35:39TV. It would it wouldn't have had any relevance to movies. It was TV as TV, not TV, as movies on a
2:35:47small screen, that the nature of television was such that he just, he mastered it in a way that
2:35:54it it just blew me away as a kid. I was like, this is a guy who totally gets it. Well, like,
2:35:59Like Letterman, he was present in this medium while he was poking at all the edges of it.
2:36:07It's Gary Shandling's show broke my brain because it was a show that knew it was a TV
2:36:12show.
2:36:13The characters knew they were characters on a TV show.
2:36:15It's just, what am I seeing here as a kid, as a 15, 16-year-old kid?
2:36:21It's just baffling and brilliant.
2:36:23In the same way that Letterman was taking all of the, as we've talked about before,
2:36:27conventions of talk shows and questioning why any of them existed.
2:36:31Right. So it also really just blows my mind that he did it twice in quick
2:36:39succession where he had the It's Gary Shanling Show which was this
2:36:43sitcom, sitcom, you know, the sitcom-iest sitcom that's ever existed. Wacky
2:36:49Neighbor, the platonic friendship with a woman, all of these tropes of the modern
2:36:57and sitcom and they just blew them all away by opening up the fourth wall and talking
2:37:01to the camera and talking to the audience and having the audience throw things at the
2:37:05characters.
2:37:07And then two years later, coming back with another like meta, I mean, that's the thing
2:37:14he was the master of like this meta aspect of TV and doing meta in a totally opposite
2:37:20way where there's no breaking down to the fourth wall, but there was this weird fake
2:37:26talk show within the show that looked as it looked more like the Tonight Show
2:37:30than the Tonight Show did. Well, he hosted the Tonight Show. He was like
2:37:34before Jay Leno became the guest host, he was for years, he was like
2:37:40the permanent guest host of the Tonight Show. He would fill in for Johnny a
2:37:43lot, and I remember seeing him fill in for Johnny a lot, and so he knew that
2:37:48was the fascinating thing about the Larry Sanders show is that the people
2:37:52who did that, especially Gary Shandling, he knew exactly how those shows worked
2:37:56He knew the hosts. He had been in consideration for the jobs, right? I
2:38:05believe he was considered for to be David Letterman's replacement at one
2:38:09point. Yeah, he had the offer. He was offered it and turned it down. I'm not
2:38:14quite sure if he was ever... I think that he had actually sort of stepped away from
2:38:18wanting to host, you know, do it full-time so that he was never really like in the
2:38:23consideration, like at the point where they needed to replace Johnny, he was
2:38:27already like, "I'm out of it." But I think you're exactly right though that in the
2:38:31late 80s, you know, he was absolutely in consideration. Yeah, and so he had all of
2:38:38that knowledge, right? He was an insider. This was not, this is not
2:38:41somebody like Aaron Sorkin doing Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip, where he had sort
2:38:47of like a glancing blow at this industry, but really was
2:38:53kind of imagining a fantasy version of it. This, Larry Sanders was people who understood how the
2:39:00TV industry worked and how the talk shows worked, making a show that was insidery on one level,
2:39:06but also kind of like at times just a scabrous commentary and satire of the, not just the show,
2:39:13but the guests, right? And, and it was, it, you see the roots of so many things. It's the,
2:39:19the cringe comedy of things like The Office come from this.
2:39:22- Herb your enthusiasm.
2:39:24- Absolutely.
2:39:25Well, I mean, very,
2:39:26Gary Shandling and Jerry Seinfeld really did.
2:39:28They did their shows across the lot from each other.
2:39:30They went and visited in that
2:39:31Comedians with Cars Getting Coffee episode.
2:39:33And so, I think they influenced each other for Seinfeld.
2:39:37Definitely Ricky Gervais said that all of his stuff
2:39:39is just super influenced by Gary Shandling.
2:39:41And then something like 30 Rock is another good example
2:39:43where 30 Rock is absolutely, you know,
2:39:45would not exist if it weren't for Larry Sanders.
2:39:48Right, and took it, you know, and it totally in her own way and went like super fast-paced
2:39:53and joke joke joke joke joke, which is, you know, the density of jokes on 30 Rock just blows me away.
2:39:59Yeah.
2:40:00But you're right though, it's, you know, it all sort of owes itself back to Larry Sanders.
2:40:09And it's amazing to me that he did those two shows like almost back to back.
2:40:15Yeah, it's the Hall of Fame kind of thing where it's like those are...
2:40:20Larry Sanders' show is like in the Hall of Fame and you could make the argument for
2:40:24the It's Gary Shandling show too before that. The idea
2:40:27that when The It's Gary Shandling show was going off the air that that would be
2:40:32a footnote would seem impossible and yet the next project was the thing that just
2:40:37kind of blew everybody away. I just remember him as a... he was a really great
2:40:40stand-up. I mean, I just remember how good he was as a stand-up
2:40:43on the Letterman show especially that and you could tell
2:40:47you could tell when Letterman when it was somebody who he liked
2:40:51like you could tell they would you bring them over afterward and they would talk
2:40:53and they would do more comedy and they they and and chandling was definitely in
2:40:57that list like he was he was i've read a few obituaries that said
2:41:00that he was definitely like a comedian's comedian like they all
2:41:03they all just were in awe of how good he was as a comedian
2:41:07and he never really did anything after the Larry Sanders show
2:41:11I mean, other than guest appearances here and there, but he never had a major project.
2:41:17But by all accounts that I've read, I've read it before, but now that he's dead and it's all coming out,
2:41:22but it's just almost universal that he was very generous in giving to any of the up-and-comers,
2:41:30like the Judd Apatow's and the people who are in their prime right now in comedy,
2:41:34that they could come to him with like, "Hey, here's my script and I'm stuck here.
2:41:39or do you have any ideas and would help them out?
2:41:42In an industry that's notorious for being filled
2:41:45with personalities that are, let's say, less than generous.
2:41:49- Yeah, exactly.
2:41:50People actually liked him and thought he was a good guy.
2:41:54- I think it's very telling
2:41:55that you never hear that about Jay Leno.
2:41:57Nobody ever says, "Boy, Jay Leno really knows
2:41:59"how to help out an up-and-comer."
2:42:02- Chevy Chase, everybody loves Chevy Chase.
2:42:04- Right, nobody ever says that.
2:42:06Nobody ever says, "Boy, it's a real shame
2:42:09that something seems to be wrong with Chevy Chase
2:42:11these days.
2:42:12- I get, yeah, I don't know.
2:42:14I think about that sometimes.
2:42:16Like if you're one of these TV stars who has a huge hit,
2:42:21and I think in the case of Larry Sanders,
2:42:25he owned a big piece of it too.
2:42:26Like this was before HBO made the deal.
2:42:29Like it's not on HBO.
2:42:30They're actually bringing it back
2:42:31to the HBO streaming service. - Yeah, I saw that.
2:42:33- But it went off because back in those days,
2:42:36HBO didn't buy like all rights to everything in perpetuity like they do now. But, um, so
2:42:42you make all this money, just insane TV money for being on a show for seven years. And then
2:42:46he had another six year show before that. And I always wondered like, what do you do?
2:42:51Some people, big stars and big successes, they react in different ways. Some people
2:42:55try to recapture it. Other people just kind of do passion projects. Other people just
2:42:59were like, I don't, I don't care. I'm gonna, I mean, I think Bill Murray is sort of in
2:43:03this catalog category too, where like he wants to work when he's moved to work.
2:43:08Like when he finds something that for whatever reason interests him and, uh, he
2:43:14doesn't need to work right.
2:43:15And, and obviously for him, he's not, he's not so obsessed with, with keeping busy
2:43:21that he always has to have a project.
2:43:22He's kind of okay.
2:43:23And I think Gary Shandling was kind of like that, where he would pop in on the
2:43:27occasional thing, like, and he's like, I would love to know the story of, of why
2:43:31he chose to do the Marvel movies, those the Captain America and Iron Man movies.
2:43:36Like he was in a couple, he's a senator, he's kind of a rotten
2:43:39senator villain character. Right, well I know, I mean it's a bit of a spoiler but
2:43:44he ends up he's a... Hale Hydra! Yeah. He's a he's a bad guy. I
2:43:48mean he's a he's a he's a corrupt senator. How why did he decide
2:43:52that? It was probably something like he knew somebody who was involved
2:43:55and thought it would be fun. If I had to guess, I don't know the story,
2:43:59but if I had to guess I'll bet he was friends with Jon Favreau. That could be.
2:44:02That could be. Because I think Jon Favreau is, I mean he's more of a film, he's a filmmaker,
2:44:06not really a comic, but I think he's in with, you know, I wouldn't be surprised if he's in the same
2:44:10pack of guys, you know, like, like Judd Apatow who are pals. I'll bet it's through Jon Favreau.
2:44:16Yeah, and so it looks to me like after he finished, Larry Sanders, he was pretty much happy to just
2:44:21kind of mess around when he wanted to and not worry about it otherwise. And, you know, when
2:44:26when you've got, I think that's a question
2:44:29that most of us will never have to deal with in our life,
2:44:31but it is that question of like, if you won the lottery
2:44:34or something you created became a wild success
2:44:36and you literally didn't have to work again,
2:44:39what would you do?
2:44:40And would you just go to an island
2:44:42and sit out in the sun all day?
2:44:43Or would you work because you wanna work
2:44:45and pretend that you don't have that money?
2:44:47Or would you kind of find a way to compromise
2:44:49where you weren't gonna work too hard,
2:44:51but you'd be, you wanna kind of keep in the game
2:44:53a little bit?
2:44:54- Yeah.
2:44:55- I don't know.
2:44:56Yeah, you know, and just to touch on one other thing that you've, with the HBO deal, it's
2:45:00in addition to the fact that the Larry Sanders show in and of itself stands up as a tremendous
2:45:06body of work. I've watched the whole thing through at least three times, at least three.
2:45:09And now that he's dead, I think I'm itching to do it again.
2:45:13I'm going to do it once it's on HBO.
2:45:15Yeah, I'm going to wait for it to be on HBO. I say three times, but I think a lot of the
2:45:21time I've done it, especially when it was original, you couldn't stream it. So it's
2:45:25like you either caught it or you didn't. And so, you know, I may not have hit, I was like watching
2:45:29it when I was home when it was on, but I, you know, I might have missed episodes. And at least once
2:45:34those in the digital era, I've watched the whole thing. But it's the fact that it even, that there
2:45:39even are shows that we think of HBO as a network that has shows, is in large part driven by or
2:45:45originated by the Larry Sanders show. Like, that's what we think of HBO now, primarily, but at the
2:45:50time HBO was where you went to watch movies. And then sometimes they'd have shows. But
2:45:55a lot of their shows were things like Bryant Gumbel's sports thing. They weren't like
2:45:59original fiction, you know? Yeah, their strategy has changed pretty dramatically. And then
2:46:07as part of that, they locked up all the rights. They produce all their own shows, they own
2:46:11the rights to them. That's why The Wire is on HBO. It will always be on HBO. And The
2:46:17Sopranos and six exactly exactly so Larry Sanders was predates that time
2:46:22But they it's cool like before he died
2:46:25They were Gary Shandling had made a deal with HBO to bring Larry Sanders back onto HBO and onto HBO streaming
2:46:31So it will get there eventually and then I it's a shame that they can't I hope they're right like rushing to get it on because
2:46:37I think we would all love to
2:46:40Go back and watch that stuff again. Yeah feel better about it
2:46:43well
2:46:43Well, the other part, you know, and the other genius aspect to it was that he had the foresight
2:46:47at a time when stand-up comedians, the goal was to get a network sitcom.
2:46:52He saw like past that and he was like, "If I can do something on Showtime or HBO that
2:46:57you can't do on the networks."
2:46:59You know, like I think it was less about the money and the fame and a little bit more about,
2:47:05not to be pretentious, but the artistic integrity, you know, of doing something that you couldn't
2:47:09get on network TV and avoiding the annoyance of the commercial interruptions.
2:47:17I mean, even though he did have it, he let the one show be on Fox, which was, I don't
2:47:23know what the backstory is on that, but especially with Larry Sanders, that he saw that it wasn't
2:47:29like, "Well, I can't get a network show, but I'll do an HBO show."
2:47:33It's like, clearly he saw HBO as a way to do something that he couldn't do on a network.
2:47:37Yeah, yeah, it's sad, and for the people who know him, it's really tragic. For the rest of us, the good thing to come out of something terrible like this is I do really, I like that so many people have come out to appreciate his talent and his work, because, you know, I think that's all that any of us could ask for is when we go that somebody says, "Wow, I like that person. They did a great job. They were brilliant."
2:48:06they were brilliant. I'm going to miss them. And I definitely feel that way about about Shandling,
2:48:11and also celebrating his work. I mean, that's why I want that stuff back on HBO Go, is that I want to
2:48:16go back and appreciate his work. I did watch that Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee again
2:48:22yesterday for the same thing. It's like, let me, now that he's gone, you know, it's worth
2:48:29reminding ourselves how great he was when he was here. All right, Jason, thank you so much
2:48:35for generous use of your time. Happy to as always.
2:48:39Always enjoy having you on the show. Always enjoy your insights.
2:48:42I won't see you again until probably WWDC.
2:48:47Yeah, I know we always run into each other at these weird
2:48:50weird events. One of these days I'll actually just sort of be in Philadelphia
2:48:53for no reason. I'll say, "Hey, John!" But yeah, it was good to see you this
2:48:57week, too. Yeah, thanks to all the sponsors and you
2:49:00You can get as much Jason Snow as you would ever want on sixcolors.com.
2:49:09Six colors dot, you could even put a U in it if you're in Canada or the UK.
2:49:18Do you do any other podcasts?
2:49:19No, not really.
2:49:22Podcasting is a, you can find many podcasts by me at the incomparable.com and at relay.fm.
2:49:28I did the math the other day and I don't even want to tell you what I realized how many
2:49:31podcasts I do in a week on average.
2:49:33It's too many is the answer, too many.
2:49:36But I'll tell you, you've gotten good at it though.
2:49:39Well this week we got, The Atlantic did this big feature about what a robot is and it quotes
2:49:44from John Siracusa's and my podcast Robot or Not at length and I just thought, you know,
2:49:50I'm going to be really mad if the thing that I'm remembered for is robot or not.
2:49:54It's like not my life's work.
2:49:56So, hey, let me ask you, Liam, is Liam a robot?
2:49:59- You gotta ask Syracuse, I would say he's probably not,
2:50:04because it's more like, Syracuse's definition of robot
2:50:07is very narrow, which is that it needs to sort of have some,
2:50:11it's gotta sort of do some self-evaluation itself.
2:50:13So like a Roomba, you just press the button
2:50:15and it kind of figures out what to do.
2:50:18But he doesn't think like an automotive assembly line robot
2:50:21is really a robot, he thinks it's just programmed equipment.
2:50:24And so he would say, he would say no,
2:50:26but he is a very strict robot definer.
2:50:31(laughing)
2:50:32(upbeat music)
2:51:00♪♪
2:51:08you
2:51:10[ Silence ]