0:00:00the dulcet tones of your sweet voice, Glenn.
0:00:02Glenn
0:00:07I have a poem. I wrote a poem, by the way.
0:00:08Oh, well, let's hear it. I'm trying to guess what it's about.
0:00:09I was moved by the ending of the Apple filing, and I've been listening to Hamilton way too much.
0:00:14Are you a fan of Hamilton, and you've been listening to it?
0:00:16I have not. I am aware that it exists, and I'm aware that it's a sensation.
0:00:20And I agree that the premise sounds, it sounds fascinating,
0:00:25but I've actually not watched or listened to any of it yet.
0:00:28It's kind of a brain virus.
0:00:29Like I'd heard about it.
0:00:30I sort of was like, well, maybe I'll wait.
0:00:32I'll see it some, I don't want to.
0:00:33And then I was like, well, listen to a song and then you just spiral down.
0:00:36So this is, this is my poem inspired by the end of the Apple brief
0:00:40with apologies to Hamilton.
0:00:42Uh, your honor, we must have, in reading Brandeis government, zeal's a danger,
0:00:46not understanding the scope of their pleading, the danger to Liberty lies
0:00:50within mistreating American's rights.
0:00:52We posit they're exceedingly well meeting, but insidious encroaching.
0:00:56There we go.
0:00:57Pete: Very well said.
0:00:58Pete: Nipsey Russell for the ages.
0:00:59[Laughter]
0:01:00I've also been reading Aaron Burr papers because, you know how the government cited-
0:01:09Pete; Yes, yes I do.
0:01:10Pete; I've been actually going back and reading some of the historical documents,
0:01:13including some books from the 1800s and some later books written about it.
0:01:17Found an interesting article from 1982, have been looking at the original ciphers that,
0:01:23the codes and ciphers they used.
0:01:24It's a very fascinating thing to see what the state of cryptography was in the late
0:01:281700s, early 1800s.
0:01:29It all comes back to Hamilton.
0:01:31It kind of does.
0:01:33It's really kind of funny.
0:01:39This is a tweet from my pal Buzz Anderson last night.
0:01:41Who would have thought Aaron Burr would get so much attention in 2016?
0:01:47Is a little weird.
0:01:48And then they did a Hamilton performance at the White House, like not long after the FBI
0:01:53citing the Aaron Burr. Aaron Burr ostensibly wanted to become the Emperor of Mexico. He had a plan.
0:01:59American history is kind of awesome and strange, let me tell you.
0:02:02Pete: The Emperor of Mexico.
0:02:05Pete and Jono.
0:02:05Jono.
0:02:05The Emperor of Mexico! He was going down the Mississippi to try to schedule some kind of
0:02:11event and a general who didn't want to get caught up with it, who had been corresponding with him
0:02:14for years, turned over the ciphered letter and there's a trial and he was found innocent of
0:02:21treason because the justice in the case, I'm blanking, his name is famous justice.
0:02:27Pete: Marshall.
0:02:28Ben, Jr. Marshall, thank you, said that no actual, like, event had occurred. So it wasn't
0:02:33treasonous to discuss this, even if that's what was discussed. So he was-
0:02:36Pete; Well, how would it have been treason to become the Emperor of Mexico since it's
0:02:39not, it wasn't trying to become the Emperor of the United States?
0:02:41Ben, Jr. He was trying to raise armed forces to fight against a separate, another nation
0:02:47without the support and authority of America. So there was some like, I'm losing the detail
0:02:54there, but it was treason because he was acting against the interest and stated policy of
0:02:59America and waging war, or that was the intent, but without actually doing it. So, yeah, Burr
0:03:04wound up living for decades after that and never quite got back to the same position
0:03:08he had when he was vice president, between the duel and then treason trial and then just
0:03:15kind of people not really wanting to be...
0:03:17is the story of the duel? That's just one of those things that it's like you file it under your head
0:03:21that the revolutionary times were crazy and that they were, you know, like the remnants of the
0:03:26medieval era was still, you know, floating around. Well, it's complicated. Most things, dueling was
0:03:32mostly banned. It was, and it was, you know, I believe it had gone out of practice in England.
0:03:36I think it was practiced in the barbarous colonies, right? And I am reading the Chernow
0:03:41biography of Hamilton now, so I haven't gotten to the intricacies there. I recall from my past
0:03:45reading some things after the play sort of become popular, I
0:03:48went back and reread, and they had to go to New Jersey, and
0:03:51there's a line in the in the musical, you can do anything in
0:03:54New Jersey, right? Everything's legal in New Jersey, it's a
0:03:57joke. And they had to go to New Jersey because it was still
0:03:59ostensibly legal, but you know, manslaughter was and murder
0:04:02still illegal. So you could extensively in some states, you
0:04:06could duel and if no one was injured or killed, you might
0:04:09just walk away from it. But not much, not much of a duel though,
0:04:13a duel though if nobody's injured or hurt.
0:04:15Pete: Well, it's to satisfy honor. I mean, that's the thing. It's funny, ritualized
0:04:21violence. There's a really great essay in the New York Times from a few days ago, these
0:04:25philosophers talking about what violence is, and they argue that violence isn't an act
0:04:30in itself, it's a, violence has a cycle. You know, there's an attack. You attack
0:04:34someone that's not per se violence in their definition, it's that you're dealing with
0:04:38a cycle that perpetuates itself. That is violence. And it's a great discussion that deals with
0:04:43sports as a representation of force and violence in a controlled fashion and violence at the
0:04:49Trump rallies. And it's, I was blown away by it. But dueling is part of that tradition
0:04:54is, yes, it's overt violence, but it is also under very specific constraints. And a lot
0:04:59of the time, duels didn't result in anyone being hit. And that was the point. But everyone
0:05:04got to satisfy the fact that they expressed a form of ritualized violence without actually
0:05:07killing someone. But you could also kill somebody.
0:05:10So why did Burr and Hamilton get in a duel?
0:05:13Burr was, well let's see, this is, well you have to watch the musical, there we go, got
0:05:19a good ticket somehow, spent $5,000 to get tickets.
0:05:23The subject of the duel was that basically Hamilton was talking smack about Burr and
0:05:28probably rightly so, Burr really shifted to whatever he needed to do, he had done a lot
0:05:32of double dealing, Hamilton was not a pure character either necessarily, but he had been
0:05:39speaking publicly and privately and I believe there was a specific dinner that
0:05:43Some comments came through so Burr wanted him to apologize and Hamilton said I'm not saying anything. That's not true and
0:05:50Even though his son Hamilton's son had been killed in a duel not many years before
0:05:55And both he and Burr had seconded
0:05:58This is part of the musical to had seconded another duel when they were younger. They were the seconds and
0:06:05In a case that involved, I think it was George Washington being insulted.
0:06:09George Washington wasn't one of the parties of the duel.
0:06:11Even with that, they went out there and there's this long-running debate.
0:06:14The musical is part of the channel biography is whether Hamilton intended to shoot Burr
0:06:18or not.
0:06:19Whether Burr was reacting with intent or thought he was about to be shot and fired directly,
0:06:26but never quite known.
0:06:29And we're talking about it 200 plus years later.
0:06:31It's amazing.
0:06:32(laughs)
0:06:34- The takeaway I took from school when I learned about it
0:06:37was that, and again, who knows how accurate it is,
0:06:41but it seems as though most of the Founding Fathers
0:06:45were genuine statesmen, and then a couple of them
0:06:48were real hotheads.
0:06:51- Oh yeah, yeah.
0:06:52Well, and they were all, I just watched the musical 1776
0:06:56with my kids, so my kids are all head up about Hamilton now,
0:06:58and we're on the other coast and tickets are a fortune,
0:07:01So we will hopefully see it when it tours,
0:07:03you know, in a touring company to Seattle,
0:07:05we'll probably be a B company in like four years
0:07:08or three years and we'll go pay too much to see it here.
0:07:11But so I'm like, hey, look,
0:07:12there is a musical about the founding fathers.
0:07:13Like really, really let's watch 1776.
0:07:15So we did that.
0:07:16I'd watched it for the incomparable.
0:07:18We did an old movie club a couple of years ago
0:07:21and watched it then.
0:07:22So I rewatch it with them.
0:07:22They loved it.
0:07:23It's all sort of focused on John Adams,
0:07:25primarily also Jefferson and Franklin.
0:07:27And that I always, whenever I see these things,
0:07:30"Oh yeah, I could go read some more stuff about Adams."
0:07:33They're really interesting people.
0:07:35They had rich lives.
0:07:36They were involved in all kinds of stuff.
0:07:39And they weren't, they, you know,
0:07:42they were all people who had their own lives
0:07:44and Congress was another thing.
0:07:45Wasn't, you know, it was one period in their life,
0:07:49the Continental Congress particularly,
0:07:50but I don't know, it's a fascinating,
0:07:52I mean, you know, Franklin, of course,
0:07:53is the fascinating one.
0:07:54He lived a long life and liked sex workers and mistresses
0:07:58all kinds of people and lived in France and came back and anyway it's a great
0:08:02they're a great bunch that's the musical John Adams apparently late in life wrote
0:08:07about how he was obnoxious and disliked and late in life he lived quite a long
0:08:11time he and Jefferson died on the same day they're bitter enemies and they died
0:08:15many miles apart in the same day which is one of those little and the day was
0:08:19July 4th yes that's right I forgot you're right
0:08:22it's a while but Adams criticized his own personality late in life and the
0:08:26takes it up there's this recurring line "you're obnoxious and disliked" you know
0:08:30that sir and but apparently Adams was actually quite well liked and he was
0:08:35viewing himself too harshly late in life so he wasn't as obnoxious as the musical.
0:08:40Also brings to mind from a comment you had a couple minutes ago at the Dylan
0:08:44song from the Traveling Woolberries "In Jersey everything's legal as long as you
0:08:49don't get caught." See Hamilton is great it actually pulls from musical theater
0:08:54modern musical, rap and hip hop.
0:08:57I heard like echoes of poems where like all of you,
0:09:00there's a, if you go to Genius, they annotate it
0:09:03and people have found it's not a pastiche, but he pulls.
0:09:06So Lin-Manuel Miranda is an excellent,
0:09:09in terms of taking your ear and letting you hear an echo
0:09:13of something if you're tuned in.
0:09:14If you're not, it sounds good.
0:09:15But if you're a big hip hop fan, you will hear, you know,
0:09:18rhythms, patterns, lines, the kind of characterization.
0:09:22If you're a musical theater fan like I am, you
0:09:24hear all kinds of things throughout.
0:09:26You're like, wait, oh, you know, there's that
0:09:28reference to 1776.
0:09:29There's that reference to South Pacific, this
0:09:31Rogers and Hammerstein and Sondheim references
0:09:34throughout Sondheim loves it apparently, which
0:09:36is great.
0:09:36He loves to play.
0:09:37Um, it's funny we're talking about the 1700s,
0:09:40but it's not right.
0:09:411800s because so is Apple and the FBI.
0:09:43This is what's cracking me up.
0:09:44Like, what is the deal that this musical is
0:09:47sweeping the nation and then suddenly FBI is
0:09:50like, well, they all ritz act.
0:09:51Act hasn't been modified for 250 years but anyway it's just the way it always
0:09:55works out you know these things these things happen it's it's Gilead eyes the
0:09:59millenists it's all right serendipity is a real it's like almost like a force it
0:10:04is pretty amazing now the details of it though it's kind of interesting we'll
0:10:07get into it again but so last week the federal government filed a their final
0:10:14brief which Apple initially took I think it's fair to say took um bridge to
0:10:21(laughing)
0:10:23to several of the angles that the government took in it.
0:10:27I thought this was interesting,
0:10:28'cause I was invited to the conference calls
0:10:31that reporters were on, both last week and this week.
0:10:34And it was a real interesting difference, like last week,
0:10:40and they do them very fast, and it's obviously,
0:10:43and I enjoy thinking about this strategically,
0:10:46because I don't work fast, right?
0:10:50"The Ring Fireball" is not a source of breaking news.
0:10:54The talk show certainly is not a source of breaking news.
0:10:57I tend to take my time, and not because I want to,
0:11:02but because I have to.
0:11:03My brain just doesn't work quickly.
0:11:05But it's fascinating to me to look at the meta angle on it,
0:11:12which is that when these briefs drop,
0:11:15Apple reacts very quickly.
0:11:17So last week's call, I think that it was on Friday,
0:11:20maybe it was Thursday, Thursday or Friday last week
0:11:22when the government put their proof out.
0:11:25And Apple held the call with the reporters an hour later.
0:11:30So I certainly hadn't gotten through the brief.
0:11:36I guess Apple had, you know, Apple's attorneys
0:11:39had the full hour before they started the call.
0:11:42- Wow.
0:11:45And I guess the strategy there is that they know
0:11:49that once the brief is out, the news media is,
0:11:51some of them in the news media are gonna
0:11:53start writing takes and Apple wants to get their spin on it
0:11:58out as quickly as possible, otherwise it's too late.
0:12:01That they have to have, if they have to do something
0:12:03press relations-wise quickly.
0:12:07But I thought the difference between their,
0:12:11their, what would you call it, a hot take last week
0:12:14this week is so different. Like it's, I detect a very cool confidence in their current argument.
0:12:22But anyway, one of the things the government put in their brief last week was a reference to,
0:12:26and this is again, this is back to what's the year seven 1807 Chief Justice Marshall that the
0:12:34government claims once ordered a third party to, quote, provide decryption services. I've,
0:12:39I went and read the original transcripts of that trial, by the way.
0:12:42Okay. That's, I cannot, I did not, so I want to hear about it. But the government said that
0:12:48here's some precedent for compelling somebody to decrypt something that we can't decrypt,
0:12:54is that Chief Justice Marshall had Aaron Burr's secretary decrypt a ciphered note. And Apple,
0:13:00in its response, was it yesterday or was it Monday? Monday?
0:13:04Uh, yeah.
0:13:05Monday.
0:13:06No, yesterday.
0:13:08Was it yesterday?
0:13:09It's all a blur. It's all a blur. Says that they got, the government got it wrong, that Marshall
0:13:21did nothing of the sort, and that the All Writs Act had nothing to do, was not even an issue in
0:13:26Burr. And what actually happened, according to Apple's brief, is that Aaron Burr's secretary
0:13:30declined to state whether he, quote, "understood the contents of a certain letter written in cipher
0:13:36on the ground that he might incriminate himself. So in other words he was invoking the Fifth
0:13:39Amendment to decline to say whether he understood a ciphered message. And what the court decided was
0:13:46that he could answer that because simply answering whether he understood the cipher would not
0:13:51incriminate him. Which is fascinating if you're, you know, sort of a, you know, like I am,
0:14:00just sort of like at broad strokes, like interested in civil liberties and cases like this. Like edge
0:14:05cases around the Fifth Amendment can be fascinating and that's an interesting
0:14:09one here's you know and it's again what over 200 years ago it's a sophisticated
0:14:14question yeah I mean this is what's I love living in 2016 and being able to
0:14:18pull up instantly transcripts of trials that happened over 200 years ago but the
0:14:23court anyway the bottom line this is from Apple's brief in a footnote the
0:14:26court did not require the clerk to decipher the letter that's correct
0:14:31That's correct. It was, it was, it was the, there are two questions being put. One was,
0:14:36do you understand the cipher of that paper? Did the paper come from Colonel Burr? Was it written
0:14:41by him or by his direction? The last question, this is me reading it, last question ought to
0:14:45have been first stated. The witness does not say why the answer to the question will the tendency
0:14:49to incriminate him. And so it goes back and forth because the judge, ultimately the issue is if,
0:14:57He didn't have to decipher it.
0:14:58They're asking him if he knew the contents of the letter
0:15:01not to provide the cipher key.
0:15:03And in fact, just to be pedantic here,
0:15:05it was both a code and a cipher.
0:15:07They had a code book, actually two,
0:15:09that Wilkinson and Burr and others had been using.
0:15:12Well, the first one since the 1790s, I think.
0:15:15And then the later one they'd modified
0:15:16that had codes for like president and vice president
0:15:18in France and so forth.
0:15:19And then there was also a simple replacement cipher
0:15:22that used a rotating letter scheme.
0:15:23So you'd have letters at the top like Cuba or France,
0:15:26You'd take the letters, following them down, assign them numbers, and then you
0:15:29could read across the row to pick the numbers corresponding.
0:15:33So, um, you know, complicated for the day, uh, because you could work out simple
0:15:37site substitution ciphers are relatively easy to work out easier with computers,
0:15:41but definitely doable, uh, in the day.
0:15:43And, um, that's not that protected, but codes are very difficult.
0:15:46So with that knowledge of the code, uh, you can determine it from
0:15:49frequency of appearance and other characteristics.
0:15:52You can sometimes, uh, retrieve those, but he wasn't asked, you know, the
0:15:55He wasn't asked, "Do you know the cipher?"
0:15:57It was, "Do you," or it wasn't for the cipher.
0:16:01He was asked, "Do you know what it said?
0:16:02Do you understand the contents?"
0:16:04And he was concerned that any statement would allow him to,
0:16:09it would provide,
0:16:10it would put him in a position of incrimination.
0:16:12- Right, fascinating.
0:16:13But I have to say, it sounds to me like Apple
0:16:17is exactly right that it's no precedent whatsoever
0:16:19for compelling somebody to decode and encrypt it.
0:16:24pretty clearly, pretty clearly.
0:16:26Anyway, so one of the interesting side effects of all this and of invoking things like these, this Burr case, is this, I
0:16:33did not know that the Founding Fathers took, were so commonly in use of codes and ciphers and stuff like that, and apparently
0:16:40one of the things I read was like the first
0:16:42Postmaster General was like a political enemy of a
0:16:47couple of them. I forget which one, I forget, you know, there's the way that their political
0:16:53things are, I get it mixed up. But long story short, that they really felt, some of them really felt like they needed to because they knew that this Postmaster General was reading their mail.
0:17:02Oh yeah, that was a con—right, mail was often open. It's an interesting thing that our current mail system—I've forgotten how far back the law goes, it might be the 18th and 19th century—that it's illegal for any party to open the mail. Like, including the post office, except with like specific warrant or subpoena.
0:17:19Another Hamilton musical reference, by the way, is Hercules Mulligan, best name in the world.
0:17:23He was transporting messages. He was not a loyalist, but he was sort of a spy, going back and forth to New York.
0:17:30He was a textile importer, ran a clothing shop with Taylor, and he and his slave, whose name was Cato,
0:17:36were sending messages back and forth, often in code or in other, you know, trying to hide the meaning of it, eventually became too dangerous.
0:17:45dangerous but he's one of the reason that they were able to, to, Hamilton was able to assist
0:17:50General Washington in some of the battles around Manhattan. It's amazing, it is an amazing name.
0:17:56Hercules Mulligan. Hercules Mulligan, it's awesome, it's a great part in the play. But yeah,
0:18:00I mean, code's been an important part. I think I forget what the earliest cryptographic stuff is,
0:18:04there's the, there's a thing of wrapping a strip of paper around a cylinder of a certain dimension,
0:18:10like a pencil sized thing that was used so you could write across it and then unfurl it
0:18:14unless you knew the dimensions,
0:18:15you wouldn't be able to figure it out.
0:18:16- Oh yeah, I've seen that, I've seen that.
0:18:17- Yeah, and that's, I think,
0:18:19one of the earliest uses of crypto,
0:18:21and simple cipher substitution,
0:18:23if you don't know what it is.
0:18:24And it's only become more complicated over time,
0:18:26but code has a, code an interception of code,
0:18:29and people being executed for possession
0:18:33of what was seen as code, that was never deciphered.
0:18:35All big issues for thousands of years.
0:18:38- When I was a kid, I spent a couple,
0:18:40I mean, it's been a long time,
0:18:41I was truly like grade school age,
0:18:42but I spent like, you know,
0:18:44at one point one of my obsessions became codes
0:18:46and stuff like that.
0:18:47And I very, I specifically remember that one
0:18:50where you wrap the paper around like a ruler type thing
0:18:53of a certain known width.
0:18:56And then when you unwrap it, it just looks like gibberish.
0:19:01And again, like you said, that's not the most secure.
0:19:05- Nobody else knows it though.
0:19:06You don't have sophistication on the other side.
0:19:08It's people are like, why does someone write gibberish?
0:19:11I have a very vivid memory.
0:19:14I'm almost certain I was in first grade,
0:19:17but it was certainly like first or second,
0:19:20that Kellogg's had a campaign and that three or four
0:19:26of their flagship kiddie cereals had little plastic things
0:19:34in them.
0:19:35So like the Toucan Sam one might be blue,
0:19:38and the Frosted Flakes, Tony the Tiger one was yellow
0:19:42and maybe the Sugar Smacks one was red,
0:19:45with the Ribbit Rabbit or whatever his name was.
0:19:48Ribbit the Frog, you know what I mean?
0:19:50But there'd be, so there'd be different colors
0:19:52and then you would, they were all just a different
0:19:55like 26 character cipher,
0:19:59where it would just be a different rotation,
0:20:02sort of like rot, it was like a rot 13,
0:20:04but Tony the Tigers was rot 17
0:20:07and the frog one was rot 11 or something like that.
0:20:10But I was fascinated, like A, as a first grader,
0:20:13I felt pretty clever that I figured out
0:20:15the differences between them.
0:20:16But then it was cool because then it was,
0:20:20like with friends at school,
0:20:21we could send coded messages to each other
0:20:23and it took so long spinning the disc,
0:20:25it would just be like.
0:20:27- Then ultimately, drink your Ovaltine.
0:20:30- Yeah, exactly, exactly.
0:20:33- God damn it.
0:20:33I found, it's called the scriptali,
0:20:36It's the Greek rod that was used for encryption
0:20:39with a substitution stifer.
0:20:41I knew there was something, that's not the earliest.
0:20:43Egyptians were maybe a thousand years before for that.
0:20:47There's also a famous story of the word shibboleth.
0:20:50You know, it was a great story.
0:20:51It's not about code per se, but it's spies
0:20:53in a camp, some might camp, and the leader says,
0:20:58say you now shibboleth, and the spies were unable
0:21:01to pronounce the sh sound, and they said,
0:21:03shibboleth and were put to death.
0:21:05So a shibboleth is like that passphrase,
0:21:07like a thing you say to be shown
0:21:09that you're a member of a tribe, always like that.
0:21:11- Hmm.
0:21:12- These divisions go back thousands of years,
0:21:14so from probably the origin of being able
0:21:16to put words on paper, people were figuring out ways
0:21:19to make other people not be able to read those.
0:21:21- Right, well, to communicate at length, right?
0:21:23- Yeah.
0:21:24- Because you could always communicate in private.
0:21:26Well, I mean, obviously, if your room is bugged or whatever,
0:21:28there's ways around, but if you're reasonably secure
0:21:32that the room you're in is not being bugged,
0:21:35you can have a private conversation with somebody.
0:21:38The trick is how do you have a private conversation
0:21:40with somebody at a distance?
0:21:41And it's like you said,
0:21:43it's long as we've been communicating at a distance,
0:21:45even if it's like just by dispatching a messenger,
0:21:49there have been codes.
0:21:51- Yeah, I mean, you're saying there might be
0:21:52warrant proof spaces is--
0:21:55- Exactly.
0:21:56- Possibly in our minds.
0:21:57My grandparents, my family was furniture,
0:22:00ran furniture stores for many, many years,
0:22:02and my grandfather developed a code,
0:22:04a number code, 10-letter code,
0:22:05based on our last name and his mother's initial,
0:22:08so they could put the retail,
0:22:09or the wholesale price of things in the tags
0:22:11without customers knowing.
0:22:12So when they negotiated,
0:22:13they knew exactly how low they could go.
0:22:15- Ha, see?
0:22:16- Clever fella, my grandpa.
0:22:18- Very, very clever.
0:22:19Boy, that's the type of thing that nowadays,
0:22:22people, you know, it's eventually some consumer website
0:22:27would come out with the--
0:22:28- Oh yeah.
0:22:29- Yeah, go into this mattress store
0:22:30and here's how you decode the thing.
0:22:31Exactly. You know, they can go. Yeah. All right.
0:22:34Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor.
0:22:35It's our good friends at Casper. You guys know Casper.
0:22:39They sell mattresses online,
0:22:41obsessively engineered mattresses at shockingly fair prices. Um,
0:22:45there's one of the, here's my favorite thing about, uh, Casper mattresses.
0:22:49They don't make you choose between like two, three, four, five, six,
0:22:53seven different types of mattresses or the technologies in them. No,
0:22:56they figured it out for you. Just the right sink, just the right bounce.
0:22:59They've taken two commonly used mattress technologies, latex foam and memory foam, and they've made
0:23:05their own custom cocktail between the two for better nights and better days, good sleep.
0:23:12So all you do is pick what size you want.
0:23:14So you know what size bed you have, so you just go there, you need a new mattress, get
0:23:19the right size.
0:23:21And as crazy as it sounds, I know I've said this every time they sponsor this show, it
0:23:24sounds crazy to buy a mattress without like trying it out, but what kind of a tryout do
0:23:28you actually get in a retail store anyway. It's actually kind of gross because other
0:23:31people have slept on it. And just like being there with all of your clothes on and laying
0:23:36on a bed for two or three minutes isn't going to tell you how you sleep on it. So actually,
0:23:41the way that Casper does it, if you think about it, it's a traditional but it makes
0:23:44a lot more sense. They have a risk free trial and return policy. You try sleeping on a Casper
0:23:49for 100 days. And if you don't like it, up to 100 days, they'll just call them up, go
0:23:57website and they'll take care of free. They'll just take it
0:23:59right back. No, no questions asked. I've even heard from a
0:24:03listener of the show, sent me an email and said that, that they
0:24:08did it and that they bought it because it was on the show. And
0:24:11it was like for whatever reason wasn't wasn't to their liking.
0:24:14And it and and said it just wanted to say, I know you keep
0:24:19saying that they take them back, but it literally was as easy as
0:24:21could possibly be to take a mattress back. Here's the some
0:24:25of their prices. Retail, you go retail for mattresses, you're probably going to pay like
0:24:29$1,500 or more for a premium mattress. Casper's start at 500 for a twin 750 for full 850 for
0:24:36Queen and just 950 bucks for a king size mattress. So you just can't lose. Here's where you go.
0:24:42For more information, go to casper.com caspr.com slash the talk show and use that code the
0:24:52the talk show and you'll save 50 bucks off.
0:24:54They're already excellent prices.
0:24:56Free shipping to you, free shipping back
0:24:58if you wanna send it back and great prices.
0:25:01Casper.com/thetalkshow.
0:25:04So I guess we should talk in detail
0:25:09about the Apple FBI case.
0:25:12- Yeah, you're gonna jump into that.
0:25:13- And then we can speculate.
0:25:14'Cause I feel like this is the one thing.
0:25:15This is the thing, I mean, we can talk about
0:25:17next week's event and what our last minute speculation is,
0:25:19whatever, but that's,
0:25:21know it's interesting but it's of the moment whereas that this Apple FBI thing
0:25:25is is truly I don't think it's hyperbole I think it's genuinely important to the
0:25:30future of the Republic. I am absolutely I think it's actually one of the most
0:25:35fundamental issues of privacy we could possibly be facing now and we have the
0:25:39best advocate on our side and the government is and extremely disappointed
0:25:45the Obama administration's stance I feel like we're we're being sold out because
0:25:51He says, it's not on my watch is the, is what
0:25:54is driving it.
0:25:55He says he's worked with law enforcement a lot.
0:25:57He has a lot of good takes on this subject.
0:25:59And he said, nobody wants to be the guy when
0:26:02the event happens and you could have done
0:26:04something else and you didn't do everything.
0:26:06So the FBI is doing this scorched earth policy
0:26:08to break apart this thing.
0:26:10They try to find a test case because James
0:26:12Comey and a few other people are saying, this
0:26:14is not going to be the thing where we lose.
0:26:16Not, I am not going to be the person responsible
0:26:18for this thing, but I am not going to be the
0:26:20I'm going to do everything, even if potentially it threatens liberty, that's not my concern.
0:26:24My concern is preventing this attack.
0:26:26And I think it's true, too.
0:26:27I think they're being such bulldogs about it.
0:26:29But I agree with you.
0:26:30I think this is a -- you've been writing about this, I think, in a wonderful way.
0:26:35The warrant-proof spaces is a big issue.
0:26:37And Comey said that.
0:26:39And then Jonathan Zdravierski has been writing about this, too.
0:26:42He just wrote recently about how there are many warrant-proof spaces in America, American law and the Constitution.
0:26:48Uh, state laws carve out lots of places in which
0:26:51warrants aren't allowed.
0:26:52Great post.
0:26:53But, uh, are we allowed only the privacy of our
0:26:57own mind?
0:26:57What, here's the thing, you know, you and I were
0:26:59talking about this on Twitter is there's all
0:27:01these natural extensions.
0:27:02Should ISPs preserve every email you ever sent?
0:27:04Like, can we delete email permanently?
0:27:06Um, what if there were brain scanners?
0:27:08What if brain scans existed tomorrow?
0:27:09There's technology starting to be able to pull
0:27:11images out of people's heads.
0:27:12Right.
0:27:13Is that, I mean, would they be allowed to
0:27:16Is that private?
0:27:17Would they be allowed to use that on a suspect in custody?
0:27:21Like if you're arrested?
0:27:22Yeah, it's not science fiction.
0:27:23It's not science fiction.
0:27:24We're seeing, I mean, people are showing, they're actually like having some glimmerings
0:27:26of this where it's real.
0:27:27It's something that's not telepathy.
0:27:28It's science in a lab that they can show.
0:27:30And so, holy cow, you know, this isn't impractical, theoretical.
0:27:34Could they compel a criminal suspect to have like a brain scan and ask them questions,
0:27:41sort of like where today it's a lie detector test, but just imagine like, what is the pass
0:27:46code to your phone? What's the passcode to your phone? And if they read a number out
0:27:50of the guy's head and try it and it works, is that admit? No, but I mean, I don't think
0:27:55that that's it. I know they, I don't think they can do that today. To my knowledge, there's
0:27:58no such device today, but that does not seem like it's unreasonable, even within the scope
0:28:03of your, my lifetimes. I mean, in terms of the way that, that, that we're starting to
0:28:08understand the brain. And I've said this before, I said this on the show and I really, it,
0:28:12To me it really, it's interesting.
0:28:15What if, what if some future computing device
0:28:20that provides capabilities like what we use today
0:28:23with an iPhone, what if it's embedded in your body?
0:28:27What if it's something that you place in your wrist?
0:28:30What if it's something you do put in your head, right?
0:28:33What if it's, and again, I'm not an expert on Alzheimer's
0:28:38and I know that there are some biological,
0:28:41you know, the solutions or improvements to Alzheimer's research going on. But what if,
0:28:47you know, somebody 10, 15, 20 years from now invents some kind of very small system on a chip
0:28:53that can be embedded in somebody's brain to help with the cognitive decline and the dementia that's
0:29:03caused by Alzheimer's. Would that device then be susceptible to the government reading the
0:29:12contents of it? To me, it's not preposterous to pose hypotheticals like that. And my answer
0:29:21would be no. There's not that much difference and there's going to be less as time goes
0:29:27on between artificial digital devices and our capability of reading the, you
0:29:36know, the mechanic, you know, treating our brains as the mechanical devices they
0:29:40are at a certain level. It's also, I think the warrant proof space is a great
0:29:45metaphor because in fact every place we have in our brains and in reality that
0:29:50we own are all warrant proof spaces until a warrant is produced and I think
0:29:54there's this interesting thing where the view of the FBI,
0:29:57as they've expressed at the Department of Justice,
0:29:59is that all spaces are open to the government on demand.
0:30:02And that is simply not, I mean, it's both true and not true.
0:30:05People can also express civil disobedience
0:30:07and be jailed for contempt or for violating court orders
0:30:09or other charges.
0:30:10They can go to jail for refusing.
0:30:12You have a lot of people who have nobly in the past,
0:30:15sometimes nobly, gone to jail,
0:30:18rather than give up information
0:30:20or access or locations of things.
0:30:22I think by default we should assume that all places are private.
0:30:27I think this notion, I think Zdravinsky wrote about this also, is that the Bill of Rights
0:30:31is not instructions on what the government can do.
0:30:35It's instructions on what citizens' rights are, and it prescribes the government from
0:30:40doing so much.
0:30:41So it's not a plan to use to circumvent rights.
0:30:45It's a giant wall to prohibit the government from excess.
0:30:49And so the idea that every space we own is really owned by the government is terrifying.
0:30:53I mean, that's really, you know, it's a very much a conservative and far right view that
0:30:57the government, you know, any Democrat elected government would be, have that in place.
0:31:03So the government owns all spaces.
0:31:04So they're playing into the hands at some point of that.
0:31:06And I think people who are on the left of the spectrum would say also that even if they
0:31:11believe in a bigger role for government or different nature of government regulation
0:31:14and control, that the government having sort of a de facto right to all of our private
0:31:19our homes, our computers, and by extension our minds.
0:31:22That that also is not in keeping with the nature
0:31:26of what civil human rights are and it would be
0:31:30in the nature of our country.
0:31:32So, I mean, you come down to this,
0:31:35it's like what percentage of iPhones are used for crime?
0:31:38It's .00 whatever percent.
0:31:41And the idea that all iPhones have to be open to inspection
0:31:44at any time, like bags going through an X-ray machine
0:31:47machine or the TSA with their locks that have now been duplicated because they allowed photos
0:31:51to be taken of the master keys. Like that's what the FBI is proposing is we'll have a way for,
0:31:57you know, the TSA style investigators to get in, which means everyone can get in.
0:32:01Right. And there's a, um, the part that to me is the most disappointing,
0:32:06single most disappointing in, in, in the Obama administration. And, you know, I'll just admit it.
0:32:14and Hillary Clinton has espoused the same opinion,
0:32:17is a belief in this magical thinking
0:32:19that if we just put smart enough people
0:32:21into a room together, that they can come up with a way
0:32:24that this backdoor solution would only be available
0:32:28to law enforcement.
0:32:29That we're not asking you to make a backdoor
0:32:31that anybody could get into,
0:32:32we just want a backdoor that law enforcement can get into
0:32:36when we have a warrant.
0:32:37Which sounds reasonable,
0:32:39and in some fictional other universe
0:32:43where that's mathematically possible, that might be great.
0:32:46I actually, I think that there's good reasons
0:32:48why a civil libertarian would be opposed even to that.
0:32:52I'd like, like, let me just put this out there
0:32:54that and I tend to lean that way.
0:32:57I would listen to the argument,
0:32:59but I tend to lean towards even if that were possible,
0:33:02I don't think it's a good idea.
0:33:03And I think it's contrary to the values
0:33:05that are already in our Bill of Rights, but it is an idea.
0:33:09But the simple truth is that it's math, all experts agree.
0:33:12everybody who understands encryption. I mean, this is it. I don't think that you it's more than even
0:33:18like, I mean, it's, it's, like, provably incorrect, you know, like, as opposed to, let's say, climate
0:33:25change, where you can say, you can argue that only 98 or 99% of expert climate scientists agree that
0:33:32the, you know, what we're seeing is manmade. I mean, with with cryptography and backdoors, it's 100%
0:33:38agreement, because
0:33:40You're totally right. I just realized I haven't seen any, um,
0:33:42any crypto deniers out there saying this is possible.
0:33:44I've only seen politicians and law enforcement. Right. It's, well,
0:33:49that's part of the beauty of trying to convince my 12 year on son of it.
0:33:53I'm trying to convince when I talked to my 12 year old son,
0:33:56it does not have the enthusiasm for mathematics that I did,
0:33:58that that's the beauty of mathematics. It's, it's, you know, and,
0:34:03and in a,
0:34:04in a way that computer science sort of falls out of mathematics,
0:34:08I could go on a long run here.
0:34:09Like when I went to Drexel and got my degree
0:34:12in computer science, it was from the department
0:34:13of math and computer science.
0:34:17It was one department for mathematics and computer science.
0:34:19And well, they've since broken it out
0:34:21and now computer science is often,
0:34:24I don't know what they did, but it's--
0:34:25- An expensive new building probably.
0:34:27- Yeah, I think that what happened is that politically
0:34:31the computer science department grew to,
0:34:34used to be like, it was the math department
0:34:36a little kooky computer science group of professors and then computer science got so popular and
0:34:43so important to our society that it grew off. But anyway, I just thought, and it's not just
0:34:48because I went to Drexel where they put them together. It just made sense to me though,
0:34:51that when you type a computer program and it either works or doesn't work, there's a
0:34:56certain beauty to that. And I think a lot of the people who listen to the show are probably
0:35:00nodding their heads like that's why they got into this racket because there's a statistics
0:35:05statistics lie, math doesn't. Right, correct. And it's, you know, it's just disappointing to me that
0:35:13they keep, you know, pushing back on that. There was a, there's a line that Apple's attorneys used,
0:35:19it was in the sort of off the record. You can paraphrase, you know, the rules were from the
0:35:25call that you can paraphrase it, not quote it directly, but the gist of it was that, that they
0:35:31talk to US law enforcement frequently and they are happy to do so and happy to
0:35:37work with the government and that they are of course you know opposed to
0:35:43terrorism and crime and all this stuff and that they are also happy to you know
0:35:47willing and happy to comply with warrants and provide information that
0:35:51they have but that every time they meet with law enforcement about this issue
0:35:57law enforcement, US law enforcement, comes at the discussion with the angle
0:36:03of how can you let us into the iPhone and never wants to discuss the question
0:36:09of should we be able to get into the iPhone. It's just not it they're
0:36:16intransigent and transigent on the point of how do we get into the iPhone.
0:36:21Oh here let me give you a good thought experiment because I think there's this
0:36:25issue where people, I want to say that I keep stating on the Macworld podcast
0:36:30everywhere, I keep saying look I absolutely support the right of a legal
0:36:33warrant. I don't like extrajudicial stuff, I don't like the FISA Court, I don't like
0:36:36extra constitutional things, illegal rendition, all that stuff. I like the
0:36:41legality the constitutionally created warrants, right? And I think the FBI
0:36:46should be seeking every available reasonable means and sometimes even
0:36:50almost unreasonable with a court holding them in check so they don't violate the
0:36:54I am absolutely a, I want to trust the government.
0:36:57The government isn't always trustworthy, but I believe it's the best system we have to
0:37:00ensure justice.
0:37:01We need to improve the quality of justice as opposed to constraining them from being
0:37:04able to use tools that are legal and courts oversee in a public way that is fair and whatever.
0:37:09So here's the thought experiment.
0:37:11I was reading a paper, a academic paper a year or so ago.
0:37:15You know that cameras and cell phones and DSLRs are so good now that they can extract
0:37:21that they can extract a face from the reflection
0:37:25in an object in the subject.
0:37:27So you're taking a picture, you're behind the camera,
0:37:30a reflection, even minute in anything
0:37:32you're taking a picture of, can be reconstructed
0:37:35to provide a decent facial match against you.
0:37:38And this is today, right?
0:37:39This is a couple of years ago, actually.
0:37:40So when we have 20 megapixel or 50 megapixel
0:37:43or photographic, computational photographic equipment
0:37:46in everything, our iPhones will have seven cameras on them,
0:37:48whatever, right?
0:37:49So, here's the picture, here's the scenario, and this is where I think we would agree on, but let's find out.
0:37:53Is that FBI, or law enforcement says, ah, we know there were several people in the vicinity of this event and they were taking pictures.
0:38:02We believe we could recover the face from a reflection of the actual criminal and they subpoena the phones or they, you know, they demand them.
0:38:08They want the abuse of mis-evidence.
0:38:10In my view, I think that's totally legitimate.
0:38:13Now, could those people be compelled under All Rights Act to provide it?
0:38:16Maybe not. Maybe they would say yes, maybe they'd say no.
0:38:19that request to want those photos
0:38:21and people handing over those photos
0:38:23thinking they were legally obliged to aid in this,
0:38:26that seems reasonable to me,
0:38:27where the line would be crossed as if,
0:38:29like in this case, they said,
0:38:30"Oh, we need to use the All Writs Act
0:38:32"to break the encryption,
0:38:33"'cause some of the witnesses
0:38:34"refuse to turn over their phones
0:38:35"where we think there's a picture
0:38:37"of the killer in that scene."
0:38:38What do you think? - No, I agree.
0:38:40That's exactly what a warrant is, in my opinion.
0:38:43You ask for permission to search whatever,
0:38:48a room, a house, a filing cabinet, a digital device,
0:38:53and what they can get off it, they can get off it.
0:38:57But if all they get off it is a strongly encrypted jumble
0:39:02of ones and zeros, that's tough.
0:39:06- Yeah, I mean that's, and I, yeah, so that's the thing.
0:39:09I mean this is a different, it's a sort of parallel case,
0:39:11you know, where it's, but I think we're gonna see,
0:39:13I think based on this, we're gonna see a lot more use
0:39:16of the All Rights Act, and I think they're gonna be
0:39:17And I think a lot of citizens or small companies
0:39:20or even bigger companies are gonna feel compelled
0:39:22to do it to obey.
0:39:24And I think the precedent set here
0:39:25will affect things like that.
0:39:27There'll be, you know what it is,
0:39:27is I think there's gonna be a massively increasing number
0:39:30of cases in which people who are innocent bystanders
0:39:34will have evidence that will be useful
0:39:36because of digital data collection,
0:39:38audio or video images or anything else.
0:39:41- But that's also a very different thing
0:39:42than compelling innocent bystanders to take action,
0:39:47to say, to, for example, say this,
0:39:51we have reason to believe that some sort of crime
0:39:55is gonna be committed in this area,
0:39:57therefore we, you know,
0:39:59and I'm telling you, this is exactly the path
0:40:03that this sort of precedent can go down.
0:40:06We want the right to turn on the camera and recording
0:40:09of every iPhone in range of this cell tower.
0:40:14- Panopticon OS.
0:40:17- Right, and only here, we're not saying anywhere
0:40:21and everywhere, we're saying right here in the vicinity
0:40:23of whatever street and whatever street in whatever city.
0:40:27But we have good reason for it,
0:40:30and therefore we require the ability to do this.
0:40:34- That is very much within the realm
0:40:36of what people would ask.
0:40:37I mean, look, that's already happening with cars.
0:40:38We know that law enforcement wants to get
0:40:41information on their cars.
0:40:42Look, I was talking to car makers last year about,
0:40:44you know, car robots, self-driving cars.
0:40:47And the deal is, like this is the thing
0:40:49you keep coming back to.
0:40:50What we are seeing today is the tip of the iceberg
0:40:53of data collection, both us watching the watchmen
0:40:55and the watchmen watching us.
0:40:57And it seems like it's already ridiculous, right?
0:40:59In the future, our clothing is gonna be covered
0:41:01with cameras.
0:41:02I mean, I'm exaggerating, but like everything,
0:41:03cars are gonna be festooned.
0:41:05But one of the limitations, there's a point at which
0:41:07you can have too many cameras on a car,
0:41:09you're collecting too much information.
0:41:10That point has not been hit yet.
0:41:12I think because of computational photography
0:41:15where you can combine images from many cameras
0:41:17or different kinds of imagery from cameras
0:41:19to obtain more information.
0:41:21Like, you know, we talk about 3D cameras on cars,
0:41:23they're really 2D stereoscopic cameras.
0:41:25They're RGB plus depth,
0:41:28and they use infrared or laser for ranging.
0:41:30That kind of information you can also obtain,
0:41:32in some cases, if you have more cameras.
0:41:33You don't need the ranging part.
0:41:35There's all these things that are gonna happen.
0:41:36So at some point our camera, our car's gonna have--
0:41:37- Yeah, you can triangulate the three-dimensional aspects
0:41:39of it from the two different angles.
0:41:41- Yeah, and I've seen some really,
0:41:42some really interesting papers.
0:41:43So at some point, we are gonna,
0:41:45our phones are gonna be recording 100% of the time.
0:41:47We're gonna be having wearable devices,
0:41:48if they're watch or watches or whatever,
0:41:50they're constantly ready and on recording video and audio
0:41:53unless we disable them.
0:41:54And everything is gonna be constantly recording
0:41:56and streaming terabytes of data
0:41:58that's actually gonna be processed to pull out information.
0:42:01So we are going into a future
0:42:02and with what you're describing as reality,
0:42:04There could be a continuous 3D-like coverage
0:42:07in any area of any minimal population density
0:42:10between Nest Cam-style things
0:42:12and our phones and watches and cars.
0:42:15So what if the government wants to compel that?
0:42:16We need like 10 minutes in an hour.
0:42:18Hit this button and every camera records that
0:42:21for the next 10 minutes and they get, you know,
0:42:23terabyte of information or petabyte from that.
0:42:25- Yeah.
0:42:26Could skip over, you know, skipping around a little bit,
0:42:29but I think it applies.
0:42:30But one of the highlights I have in Apple's brief yesterday
0:42:34was from talking about this CALEA law, C-A-L-E-A.
0:42:39- Yeah, that was really fascinating.
0:42:41- And the government is sort of arguing
0:42:44that CALEA doesn't apply to Apple in this case.
0:42:47And Apple is arguing, yes, it exactly applies to us.
0:42:52- Yeah.
0:42:53- It's, and one of them, here's the passage I highlighted.
0:42:57CALEA's legislative history makes clear
0:42:59the sound policy reasons behind its specific limitations
0:43:02on when decryption services can be required.
0:43:05During congressional hearings on CALEA,
0:43:08then FBI Director Louis Freeh assured Senator Leahy,
0:43:13that's Pat Leahy from Vermont,
0:43:15that CALEA would not impede the growth of new technologies.
0:43:18When Senator Leahy asked whether CALEA
0:43:21would inhibit the growth of encryption,
0:43:23Freeh responded, quote,
0:43:26"This legislation does not ask companies to decrypt.
0:43:30It just tells them to give us the bits as they have them.
0:43:33If they are encrypted, that is my problem.
0:43:37Which is what I'm saying, is that yes, I
0:43:39think that the FBI should have the rights
0:43:41to get the contents of this suspect's phone.
0:43:43But if the contents of the phone are scrambled
0:43:45and the FBI is technically incapable of decrypting them,
0:43:50that's their problem.
0:43:51And I don't say that to be callous in terms of, wow,
0:43:56what if in some other hypothetical case
0:43:58the information would actually prove useful to getting a conviction of someone who actually
0:44:02did something, or what if it was some sort of information on a phone that they can't
0:44:07access would have information that could prevent something in the future. I mean, those things
0:44:11will happen, but there is no perfect solution.
0:44:15Yeah, I want to circle back about this too, is when we talk about the political spectrum,
0:44:20it applies directly here too, is that it's hilarious to see people all the way on the
0:44:24anarchist to, um, you know, right wing
0:44:28fundamentalists who are all like absolute
0:44:31libertarian.
0:44:32I, um, I love that aspect of this.
0:44:34But the cryptographer, cause the cryptographic
0:44:35community has people across a larger political
0:44:38spectrum than I think almost who are prominent
0:44:40in it, let's say, than almost any other field of
0:44:42endeavor I can imagine.
0:44:44So you've got Whitfield Diffie, you've got
0:44:46Moxie, uh, uh, Marlon's, uh, you've got, uh,
0:44:49David, uh, uh, what's his face, uh, Robert, um,
0:44:52um, uh, from a rat, a gram from a rat of security.
0:44:55Uh, you've got people across, um, huge spectrum,
0:44:59right?
0:44:59And some people have come from dictatorship, uh,
0:45:02based societies and escape them.
0:45:04Some are living in societies that are
0:45:05becoming repressive.
0:45:06Some are in democracies or extensible democracies
0:45:09and they're all like, yeah, okay.
0:45:11I mean, there's different reasons to argue
0:45:12about this.
0:45:12Some people may or may not be in favor of a
0:45:14backdoor, none of them disagree over what you're
0:45:17saying, there is no way to create that.
0:45:19And so if you're an anarchist or a, you know,
0:45:22raging libertarian, you've got the same view like, "Nah, can't be done."
0:45:25I really enjoyed—I keep pondering it over my head—Rich Mogul's description of it,
0:45:30that it's sort of a cover-your-ass mentality, or like, you're seeing his words are not on my watch,
0:45:34but it's cover your own ass. Because that's the only way it really makes sense. And it's very
0:45:41disappointing though, because the implications are so severe. I have a feeling—and again,
0:45:46and I could be wrong.
0:45:48And that's why it's nervous watching this go down.
0:45:51I have a feeling that Apple might do well in this.
0:45:56I think Apple, I think they should.
0:45:58It's not just because I'm hoping
0:45:59and that my personal preference
0:46:02is that Apple wins this case.
0:46:03I actually think that on the fact
0:46:05and based on the law, I feel like that they should win.
0:46:10- Well, there's, if they, it's so bizarre.
0:46:13It's like, there's so many different bases
0:46:16And this brief spells out a lot of them.
0:46:18Why what the FBI and Department of Justice
0:46:20are requesting is unprecedented or a misreading.
0:46:23And I've been following this closely,
0:46:24never read this brief and some others in depth.
0:46:26This one I read very much in depth
0:46:28because it's kind of one of the crux right now.
0:46:31And because the FBI went into sort of name calling.
0:46:33The DOJ isn't saying things that are just kind of,
0:46:35it's like, it feels like watching someone
0:46:36spin out of control.
0:46:37You're like, look, we need an intervention here.
0:46:39And Obama is not your interventionist apparently.
0:46:40He's like being your codependent enabler here.
0:46:44But you read this and you're like, look,
0:46:46All rights act has never encompassed this.
0:46:47And there's plenty of evidence like, and what
0:46:49they're studying is speechless, the CALEA, the
0:46:51legislative history, the previous, whatever.
0:46:53Then you have like basically every person who
0:46:56used to be in intelligence or law enforcement,
0:46:58who was at a high level, who is no longer in
0:47:00that office saying, yeah, like, well, what would
0:47:02you have done when you're in office?
0:47:02Well, I might've supported Comey because I had to
0:47:05like, well, what about now?
0:47:06Like, no, no, no, no.
0:47:06I mean, the, the interview is with Richard
0:47:08Clark with Michael Hayden with, you know, like
0:47:11Clark's NPR interview is astonishing.
0:47:14What do you say?
0:47:14He's like, it was called the NSA.
0:47:16we could, they could do it right. Well that, that's interesting to me. Now,
0:47:19number one, I've found that post nine 11,
0:47:21Richard Clark was fine at one of the most thoughtful and a truly impressive
0:47:26individuals, you know, in the U S government in terms of,
0:47:31yeah, I agree. I've been a huge fan of his,
0:47:35I can't even think of a single point that I've ever really disagreed with him
0:47:38on. I get really sad and he's, you know,
0:47:40opened my mind to all sorts of things that I had never thought of.
0:47:43Like he's exactly the sort of person who I would want to be
0:47:46the, you know, who he was and who I wish we had more of
0:47:50in national security positions.
0:47:53So when I say, my gut feeling would be that
0:47:59if the FBI gave this phone to the NSA,
0:48:01I bet the NSA could crack this phone
0:48:04and knows some, you know, knows a way to get in.
0:48:07But that's just based on, you know, me, my hunch
0:48:10as to what I think the NSA can do.
0:48:12pretty much completely uninformed, but just sort of,
0:48:15you know, it just seems to make sense to me.
0:48:17When Richard Clark says, I'm pretty sure
0:48:20that if you gave this phone to the NSA, they could get in.
0:48:23It's like, go to the cashier
0:48:25and put your money on that horse.
0:48:28- Oh yeah, well, yeah, anything,
0:48:30I think anything that Apple could do
0:48:31to their own operating system, the NSA could do,
0:48:33plus the NSA can disassemble it
0:48:36to like a submolecular level.
0:48:37- Right.
0:48:38- I mean, they're not magicians,
0:48:39But they have the best people who are not working
0:48:42in cryptography in public and private enterprise,
0:48:45I mean, I shouldn't say private enterprise, rather,
0:48:47and in public sector open jobs.
0:48:49They're working at the NSA.
0:48:50I mean, this is the thing, like,
0:48:51I don't love how our government is using the NSA
0:48:55and the FBI to gather information.
0:48:57I do respect that the people, the FBI, CIA, and NSA,
0:49:00are some, there's some people in there,
0:49:02maybe many people based on some things you hear,
0:49:05who are some of the smartest people on the planet,
0:49:06and they're going there because they're told,
0:49:08do you want to work with the most interesting thing?
0:49:10You can never talk about it,
0:49:11maybe for decades or ever,
0:49:13but you're going to work with the most interesting,
0:49:15cutting edge technology, ideas and hardware and theory
0:49:20that no one else in the world can work with.
0:49:22You're going to go there.
0:49:23There are people who will go there
0:49:24and they may have moral qualms about it or not,
0:49:25or they doesn't enter into it
0:49:26or they support the missions,
0:49:28but it's kind of an interesting pull, right?
0:49:31So I'm sure that,
0:49:33so I want to talk about employment issues
0:49:37just for a second too,
0:49:38'cause this comes back to this Apple brief.
0:49:40So let's say Apple loses and is compelled.
0:49:44- All right, hold that thought, hold that thought.
0:49:45I know where you're going and it's too long of a segment.
0:49:47I wanna do it.
0:49:48- I'm gonna hold my breath.
0:49:49- Yeah.
0:49:50Let me just say this before I do the sponsor.
0:49:52I just wanna go back.
0:49:53These are two quotes that Apple pulled out.
0:49:55You referenced them both,
0:49:56but this is people who've come out
0:50:00and it's almost to a surprising degree
0:50:02and I'm impressed at some of the people
0:50:04who've come out in favor of encryption on this.
0:50:06But one of them is former NSA and CIA Director Michael Hayden.
0:50:12That's who Michael Hayden is.
0:50:13His quote is, "America is more secure, America is more safe, with unbreakable end-to-end encryption."
0:50:22That's a... I mean, you can't get more clear than that.
0:50:25And here's Defense Secretary Ashton Carter.
0:50:28So that's crossing the line over to the Department of Defense.
0:50:32Data security, including encryption, is absolutely essential to us.
0:50:36I'm not a believer in backdoors.
0:50:38And to me, the angle there is that it gets to that...
0:50:42the Rich Mogul thing, where why is the Department of Justice doing this?
0:50:50And it doesn't make any sense from a national security perspective.
0:50:55And that point blank is what these other guys are saying,
0:50:58is that from a national security perspective,
0:51:00backdoors are a disaster. And so, and Apple in their brief is saying that the
0:51:08government is saying you can't take that into consideration and Apple in their
0:51:10brief is saying I don't know about the legality of the argument of whether the
0:51:13court should take it into consideration but Apple is certainly emphasizing that
0:51:17angle. All right, let's take a break and we'll talk about that employment issue.
0:51:22Okay, I am going to tell you about our good friends at igloo. You guys know
0:51:29igloo we all struggle with productivity we're constantly under pressure to
0:51:34accomplish more do it faster and there's no one definitive way to accomplish that
0:51:40when you're on a small team or a small company or or or something like that so
0:51:44we all have our own methods to make things work and we combine you know this
0:51:48sort of chat with this file sharing and other technologies igloo can help you
0:51:54and your team keep doing things your way only better. Collaboration should not be
0:52:01painful. What igloo is, pure and simple, is an intranet that you'll actually like.
0:52:05They have all sorts of ways to customize it and get just the features that you
0:52:13and your team need to fill in the gaps in the system you already use. But it's
0:52:16not like when you sign up for igloo you have to suddenly drop everything you're
0:52:19already using and do things the quote igloo way. It's not like that at all.
0:52:23igloo is just a toolkit to let you and your team keep working the way that you already do just
0:52:31better. You can sign up free of charge, no credit card required, at igloosoftware.com/tts. So just
0:52:43go there. If you have a team and you're struggling in any way to collaborate, just go to igloosoftware.com/tts.
0:52:49sign up for free, check it out and see how good it could be. So my thanks to Igloo.
0:52:56All right, let's talk about the employment issue now.
0:52:58>> Yeah, so we were talking about this on Twitter because I had this horrible,
0:53:01okay, so this gets into like, I feel like we're in Orwell territory at all levels. Like,
0:53:05okay, Snow Crash, did you ever read Neal Stephenson's Snow Crash?
0:53:08>> I'm embarrassed to say no.
0:53:11>> As a programmer, you would love it. And it's sort of about hacking the brain. But one of the
0:53:15themes in it without giving spoilers to like a 20-year-old book is this notion that it
0:53:19wanted to retain the ownership of programming code
0:53:22in their programmers' minds.
0:53:23So when they left, they couldn't use it elsewhere.
0:53:26I mean, that's, I'm paraphrasing.
0:53:28I had this thought, I'm reading this.
0:53:30So Apple loses this case.
0:53:31The court says, it compels them to write
0:53:33what they're calling, you know, gov'd, G-O-V-T-O-S.
0:53:38I'm picturing this meeting, Tim Cook in a room
0:53:41with like 200 people.
0:53:43And it's everybody at Apple capable of working on this.
0:53:45And he says, all right, you know what's happened.
0:53:48The order has been given.
0:53:49We are going to, we always, you know, we're going to try to appeal it, but right now we haven't been able to stay.
0:53:54Um, we need you to do this.
0:53:56Um, and we can't order anyone to do it.
0:53:58We can, we've been ordered, uh, but you are all individuals and this needs to happen.
0:54:02Like what, what are those people do?
0:54:04What are those people do?
0:54:04And what does the court do if all 200 of them suddenly quit?
0:54:09And what does Tim do for those people if they suddenly quit?
0:54:13I mean, I just think you can't, you can order Apple to do something, but employees are at work.
0:54:17None of the executives can do this.
0:54:20They need specific employees at the engineering level.
0:54:23What happens?
0:54:25I also wonder just how many engineers at Apple
0:54:30would be capable of doing this.
0:54:33Now, capable-- you can obviously hire somebody new
0:54:36and provide them with the source code
0:54:38and let them study it and study the way the entire system works
0:54:42long enough.
0:54:43And somebody who's obviously not even employed by Apple today
0:54:46Apple today could eventually become capable of doing it.
0:54:49So it's, you know, I'm not saying it's impossible,
0:54:53but I wonder how many people within Apple would be
0:54:56on the team that would be commissioned to undertake this.
0:55:01I don't know that it's 200.
0:55:04I think it's probably a significantly lower number
0:55:06of people who work in the area
0:55:08of system level device security.
0:55:11- So is it Daniel Jalka who used to work at Apple,
0:55:13I mean, years ago working at Apple,
0:55:14he say something in response to this?
0:55:16Was it like he said there might be 100 people
0:55:17in the world, maybe I'm exaggerating the number.
0:55:20Something like that.
0:55:20That's too small, but it was, it's right.
0:55:22It's not that other people could, it's not that
0:55:25other people can't get up to speed, but in order
0:55:29to, then they'd have to hire other people.
0:55:31And it's not even an issue of morals.
0:55:32Like I have to wonder, what is your career
0:55:34like inside Apple?
0:55:35If you're the gal or guy who says, yeah, sure,
0:55:39whatever the government wants.
0:55:40Like you do the government OS and it's
0:55:43and it's delivered and it's Tim say,
0:55:45"Thanks for helping us obey the court order
0:55:47and you have no future with us."
0:55:48Could you be fired for being a good employee?
0:55:51Could you be put on in Siberia
0:55:53and sent to an Alaskan outpost of Apple
0:55:56to work on projects there?
0:55:57I don't know.
0:55:58- It's easy to outside, to just abstract it.
0:56:03Somebody within Apple could do it.
0:56:07Apple has got a lot of money
0:56:08and a lot of smart people they can do it.
0:56:10But at some level it will, if it ever,
0:56:12if this came to pass, it would come down to individuals.
0:56:16And I think--
0:56:17- They'd have to make a decision.
0:56:18- And for security purposes, it would be better
0:56:20to have it be as few people as possible.
0:56:22I've often thought about this.
0:56:25I wonder what Apple's security policies are
0:56:28for hiring people to work on stuff like this.
0:56:30Like, how do, think about it.
0:56:33I mean, how do they make sure that a secret agent
0:56:36for China isn't applying to be a security agent
0:56:41to be an engineer on iOS who would place a backdoor.
0:56:45I mean, and it sounds like it start thinking
0:56:48it sounds like something out of a James Bond movie
0:56:50or something like that, but stuff like that has happened.
0:56:52There've been backdoors placed in,
0:56:54remember the open SSL one?
0:56:58- Oh yeah, the Heartbleed, well, Heartbleed,
0:57:02was that the, there's so many.
0:57:03- And I don't even wanna just blame China.
0:57:05I think that there's a strong suspicion
0:57:07that it was the US government who surreptitiously
0:57:11placed a backdoor in like an SSL library that was--
0:57:15- Oh yeah, there's some purposely,
0:57:16what seems to be purposely weakened encryption
0:57:18that NIST seemed to have some interaction with
0:57:22in some VPN software libraries.
0:57:27No, it's not implausible.
0:57:28I mean, this is the thing, like what really drives
0:57:29the world is not spy craft in the terms
0:57:31of state-run espionage, it's industrial espionage
0:57:34is a huge thing.
0:57:35It's huge, it happens continuously.
0:57:38This is not like a movie thing.
0:57:39There are people working inside companies
0:57:42constantly selling secrets to competitors
0:57:44because they can get money from them.
0:57:46- What do you do when somebody,
0:57:47a very talented programmer with a security background,
0:57:52who without lying about their employing history at all,
0:57:57but has spent like eight years working for the NSA,
0:58:00applies to work on a security job at App,
0:58:04you laugh, but if they're being honest,
0:58:07it could be a tremendous hire.
0:58:09I tell you this story already. I once met guys from the CIA print shop and they said we gave them business cards
0:58:14And they said we have business cards. We can't give them to you and we said you're serious
0:58:18They said yeah, we can only hand them out inside the building
0:58:19So like how do you get a reference from the NSA for your job at Apple - I?
0:58:23Don't know but you know
0:58:26but what you know it I it must occur to them, you know, and it's
0:58:31Anyway, it's we're getting off the point though of what happens if everybody who works at Apple refuses to do this and and I or even
0:58:38Like you need, I mean, I said 200, partly because
0:58:41it's like project managers and what like, there's
0:58:42people who have the expertise and there's the
0:58:45people who support those people and people, I
0:58:47mean, who has the key, who has the codes that give
0:58:50them access to like the root certificates that
0:58:52are used, all this stuff involves a very small
0:58:55number of people.
0:58:56Uh, but what if they all, I mean, look, if you
0:58:59and I were in that position, I think we know
0:59:00what we'd do.
0:59:01We'd quit, right?
0:59:02We'd quit.
0:59:02And then can the government compel us?
0:59:04Could the government court say, you're not
0:59:06allowed to quit?
0:59:07to quit. I can't imagine, but could they? I don't know the legality of that.
0:59:11And it's even easier in today's, the current job market in Silicon Valley. No, it is!
0:59:19Yeah, no, it is like, "Oh!"
0:59:20I just wanna be out there and say that I'm not even trying to say that it's an act of
0:59:24nobility. It would be, I would like to think, and I would like to think that I would act
0:59:29on principle. But if you just wanna get down to the cold hard facts of, "Well, you've
0:59:35got a mortgage to pay and kids to put through college or whatever.
0:59:38It's like somebody who has extensive experience on Apple's security team is
0:59:42not going to have a hard time getting another job.
0:59:44No, absolutely not. Right.
0:59:46They probably get like million dollar bonuses that are still being handled,
0:59:48handed out when they go to work for one of the unicorns.
0:59:50Right. And it might break their heart cause maybe they'd prefer to work at
0:59:53Apple, but you know,
0:59:54rather do good work for Google than do destructive work for Apple. I mean,
0:59:58it's, it's, it, it, to me is not, uh,
1:00:01an outlandish scenario at all. And I do think, I do think,
1:00:05I think that people who work in encryption, it's like you said that it spans the political gamut
1:00:10That's one of the things that I really like about this is that in in what I you know in my sideline as a amateur
1:00:16Twitter political columnist
1:00:18One of the things that depresses me about the current state of decades-long discourse in the United States is the polarization of
1:00:27politics and that so many issues are so clearly polarized and that we've we've
1:00:35Sorted on these various lines into the two parties and that there's no interchange between them
1:00:42I I it does my heart it warms my heart that on this particular issue
1:00:46It it doesn't fall on on one line or the other and if anything
1:00:52Because the DOJ is part of the executive branch
1:00:55You know, I would have to say that the you know
1:00:57The Democrats have more responsibility in this case with Apple than the Republicans
1:01:02I mean, there certainly are Republicans who I've seen call for Apple should just open the iPhone.
1:01:06Oh yeah.
1:01:07But do you, I'm sure you watched the John Oliver.
1:01:09Yes.
1:01:09Brilliant.
1:01:10The Lindsey Graham thing.
1:01:12I didn't realize Lindsey Graham had recanted his position to watch Lindsey Graham say,
1:01:15Oh, I was wrong.
1:01:16I've been better informed now.
1:01:18You're like coming to Jesus moment.
1:01:20If he can be convinced, then wow.
1:01:23I mean, I know he's got the easy side also of, you know, they want to support law and order, which is a fundamental GOP stance, but he also has
1:01:31but he also can be opposing the Obama administration
1:01:34by doing so.
1:01:34Even with that, I was just like, oh my God.
1:01:38Well, they got to him, they explained it to him,
1:01:40and he accepted the logic of what was explained.
1:01:42- Right.
1:01:43I think Daryl Issa, who I generally disagree with--
1:01:46- Oh God, I retweeted him today,
1:01:48because he's so right in some places.
1:01:51- And he understands it to a certain degree.
1:01:53I mean, and I know he had a background in technology
1:01:55before he got into politics,
1:01:57but at least at the layman's understanding
1:01:59that you would hope that our legislators would have.
1:02:02He's got it.
1:02:03He's been really good.
1:02:06- Here's an interesting, just a side note,
1:02:10get back to 1776, 'cause this is a musical podcast.
1:02:13I know there's a bit.
1:02:15So imagine you're the engineer at Apple,
1:02:16or a set of engineers, and you're the people
1:02:19who write the code that's been compelled by the government
1:02:22to essentially betray humanity.
1:02:24I mean, it comes down, I'm not even exaggerating the case.
1:02:271776 the musical it draws on there no apparent records that just that are came
1:02:32from the Continental Congress because they were worried about being
1:02:35intercepted all kinds of stuff so there's 1776 is a recreation from later
1:02:39remembrances of people and other sources there's a judge judge Wilson is from the
1:02:43Pennsylvania delegation so it's you've got Dickinson on one side is opposed to
1:02:47voting for independence you have Franklin on the other who's for it this
1:02:50is a key vote Wilson who had supported Dickinson sort of out of moderation
1:02:55changes essentially last minute declares himself.
1:02:58And it's a dramatic moment in the musical,
1:03:00but it's also essentially what happened in reality.
1:03:03Here's the thing, he didn't want to be,
1:03:04this is the motivation given to him.
1:03:06He didn't want to be the person who killed Liberty.
1:03:08He wanted to be kind of, you know, under the radar.
1:03:11And it's like, everyone will remember Judge Wilson
1:03:14as the person who killed American Liberty, you know?
1:03:18And you think about that as the programmers,
1:03:19you've like maybe 20 people or 15 people
1:03:21on a team that do it.
1:03:22and you're the people who kill encryption for everybody.
1:03:26How do you do that?
1:03:27That's a traumatic thing you'd be put through
1:03:30if you have that kind of conscience.
1:03:32- Right.
1:03:33There's a personal security angle here,
1:03:35and Apple has mentioned this in their,
1:03:38I think in a brief, but if not in a brief,
1:03:40certainly in one of the supplements,
1:03:44you know, there's the testimony from Craig Federighi.
1:03:47- Yeah.
1:03:49- I forget the guy's name.
1:03:50It's got a big long name that starts with an N.
1:03:52Sorry, if you listen to the talk show.
1:03:57- It's Erich Neunschwander, how do you pronounce?
1:04:00- Yeah. - I'm pronouncing it German-ly.
1:04:02- It's a big long Germanic name.
1:04:05But part of it is that there's a personal security angle
1:04:08to this where right now nobody knows how to create,
1:04:13as Apple calls it, government OS,
1:04:16a version of OS that you can install
1:04:18on top of an existing iPhone without destroying
1:04:20its encryption keys and then bypass
1:04:24the protections against the touchpad,
1:04:28which once you get rid of those protections, it's easy.
1:04:31Obviously using a long alpha numeric password
1:04:37or passphrase, I guess I should say,
1:04:39would actually, you know, would significantly help increase
1:04:43the security of your phone.
1:04:44But even the six digit passcode,
1:04:47it would take longer to brute force,
1:04:49but once you bypass the protections,
1:04:52you know, you're talking about like days or weeks,
1:04:54not, you know, years.
1:04:57There are jailbreaks for the phone,
1:05:02zero day, you know, what are they?
1:05:03Zero day exploits that have been sold on the open market.
1:05:07And there was one that sold for like over a million dollars
1:05:10last year, like a way to, you know,
1:05:13like a security form put out like a bounty
1:05:16and said, if you can get us into a jailbreaker on an iPhone
1:05:21that under the following conditions,
1:05:25like let's say like just by sending a text message
1:05:27or just by opening this URL in Safari,
1:05:31sold for like a million dollars.
1:05:35Can you even imagine what the black market value
1:05:38of Government OS would be?
1:05:40It's, and again, it's not,
1:05:42it sounds like we're talking about cloak and dagger,
1:05:44James Bond, Jason Bourne movie stuff, but it's not,
1:05:47it's real, right?
1:05:49But imagine if the identities of the engineers at Apple
1:05:53who knew how to make it and knew how to, you know,
1:05:58knew the details of it, it would put them in some measure
1:06:02of personal risk.
1:06:04It really, I mean Apple made this--
1:06:05- Oh God, yeah, I mean I think right now they must be too.
1:06:07Imagine if you have some of the secrets,
1:06:08I'm sure those people are already,
1:06:10Apple security must already have eyes on them,
1:06:14both from the perspective and the danger side,
1:06:16like are these people going off to do stuff?
1:06:18They're probably being watched.
1:06:19But also, is someone trying to kidnap?
1:06:21I mean, imagine if your family's kidnapped
1:06:22and you know how to do whatever,
1:06:24and it's kept quiet, and you're like, yeah, here's the key.
1:06:26I mean, and that's just now before government OS is built.
1:06:29- Apple has made the analogy,
1:06:34and I think this comes to the way that the Bill of Rights,
1:06:39to me, protects acts of your conscience.
1:06:43You know, I mean, that's a big part of what the first amendment is about.
1:06:48Apple has made the analogy to, uh, like, uh,
1:06:54what could a pharmaceutical company be forced to produce, uh,
1:06:58the serum for a lethal injection,
1:07:00which is a real world world political problem right now.
1:07:03That is not hypothetical either, right?
1:07:05Where the States in the United States that still have the death penalty,
1:07:11because it's been banned in the rest of the civilized world.
1:07:15And there's only, you know,
1:07:18it was really only practiced in the first world in the United States and only
1:07:21then in certain States, um, the company, you know,
1:07:25whatever they used to use to give people a lethal injection,
1:07:27there's no more of the serum.
1:07:29If you want to be really interesting coverage about that,
1:07:33Buzzfeed has had some really amazing coverage about this,
1:07:36the people selling drugs from India and so forth fascinating.
1:07:40and the state's refusing to disclose information
1:07:43that they should be about
1:07:43where they're obtaining the drugs from.
1:07:45- Right, all right, I will look that up, Buzzfeed.
1:07:47- It's very interesting. - On lethal injections.
1:07:50Right, 'cause can a state,
1:07:53this is getting off into the weeds on the death penalty,
1:07:56but can a state use a substance to put a prisoner to death
1:08:01that isn't like FDA approved?
1:08:03And why in the world, it gets down to the question
1:08:05of why in the world would the FDA approve a substance
1:08:07that kills people.
1:08:10But well, so could the, but Apple's question stands,
1:08:13could the All Rits Act be used for,
1:08:17could the government say, okay,
1:08:18we don't have any more of this stuff,
1:08:19let's go to, let's go to Pfizer and compel Pfizer
1:08:24to come up with a serum that would have
1:08:28the following qualities, you know,
1:08:29that it's painless and puts you to death.
1:08:32- Yeah, this is, I think one of the great arguments,
1:08:36I think it's very directly related
1:08:37to what you're talking about here,
1:08:38is Apple trying to show what I think is,
1:08:42they'd like to say a settled law that code is speech,
1:08:45and other people may be less secure in that.
1:08:47I think it's pretty settled.
1:08:48I think the Supreme Court has really made that clear,
1:08:52and the FBI and DOJ would like to say
1:08:54that code is not speech when it's functional code.
1:08:56There's a thing where Apple is sort of
1:08:57ridiculing the FBI's phrase in the brief.
1:08:59There's no such thing as functional code.
1:09:01All code is the same thing.
1:09:02So you cannot, it's unconstitutional to compel speech.
1:09:07That is practically, I'm pretty sure
1:09:10that is an overriding principle.
1:09:11I'm not a constitutional lawyer, I'm not sure,
1:09:13but I'm pretty sure I keep reading about it.
1:09:15You cannot compel speech.
1:09:16No court can compel speech.
1:09:17It can compel you to testify, or it can penalize you
1:09:20for not testifying, for not providing information,
1:09:23but you cannot compel someone to speech.
1:09:25And you cannot compel a programmer to program.
1:09:28Few of wise Twitterers were saying,
1:09:30"Wait a minute, if corporations are people,
1:09:32can you compel corporations to speech given that they are now, you know, under Citizens United
1:09:37and other rulings should have ostensibly the same rights. So, can you compel Apple to speech if that
1:09:42involves code? That's the thing about this brief is Apple is hacking away at many, many, many
1:09:47different, you know, trees with poison fruit. And I think the code is speech when it's very
1:09:52compelling, even if the all-rits one, which is also compelling, falls down.
1:09:55Pete: Yeah. Yes, I agree on both of those parts, that to me, that's the main thrust of Apple's
1:10:01two-fold argument is that they can't be compelled to do this because it's speech
1:10:06and it's deeply offensive to to Apple and the employees who would be you know
1:10:11subject to carry it out and that the all-rits Act cannot be used to compel
1:10:16extraordinary action and to me that's when you read the government thing and I
1:10:21feel almost feel bad for the lawyers who wrote the government's brief because
1:10:25it's I don't think it was their decision to it's not like James Comey had to
1:10:28write the brief. It's not like Loretta Lynch, the Attorney General, wrote the
1:10:33brief. It's like it got assigned to these, you know, the two lawyers who wrote it.
1:10:38And I almost feel bad for them because I feel like it's like when you're, you know,
1:10:42that's what it's like to be a lawyer. You don't necessarily, you don't get to pick
1:10:44the side, you know what I mean? Like, they might know they're, they might well
1:10:49know that their argument stands on nothing but thin air, but they've still
1:10:52got to write the brief. They're left arguing, the government is left trying to
1:10:58argue because they know that they all rich act is supposed to fill in the gaps of statutory law so
1:11:05they're left trying to argue that the use of the all rich act here isn't compelling apple to do
1:11:10something extraordinary but it's it's really really hard to do that you know and and the
1:11:16gist of it is that the already i've you know for people who are you know aren't paying attention
1:11:20that the all rich act is supposed to fill in the gaps that isn't covered by existing law so if
1:11:26if there's a law that says this and a law that says that,
1:11:28but there's a minor issue that's in between there,
1:11:31the All Rights Act fills it in.
1:11:33And I think one of the examples the government gave
1:11:34is that somebody can be compelled
1:11:38to give testimony in court, like you said.
1:11:40What if their testimony will take three days?
1:11:45What, where do they go at?
1:11:47Right?
1:11:47And so maybe there's no law that says that.
1:11:48The All Rights Act would fill it in
1:11:50and that the government can just do what's reasonable
1:11:52and put the guy up in a hotel.
1:11:54the government will put you up in a hotel for three days.
1:11:56So you still have to testify for the full three days.
1:11:59But even if there's no law that says that when a,
1:12:02you know, that says when a witness has to testify
1:12:04for more than one day,
1:12:05the government will put them up in a hotel.
1:12:06It's just that the All Writs Act can fill in
1:12:08and fill in the gap in a situation like that.
1:12:11Apple's argument, and I think it's extremely compelling,
1:12:15is that if the government wants to compel a company
1:12:20to do what they're saying they want Apple to do,
1:12:21It has to be passed through legislation.
1:12:24You have to pass a law that says, yes, in this case,
1:12:27you would have to do this.
1:12:28Because otherwise you're at, you know,
1:12:31'cause it's an extraordinary thing.
1:12:33And the other analogies I thought about,
1:12:35and I wanna see what you think about this,
1:12:37but so for example, famously, I think it's the '60s,
1:12:41I might be getting the time wrong,
1:12:42but when Ralph Nader wrote the, what was the book,
1:12:46"Unsafe at Any Speed?" - Speed, yeah.
1:12:50about the horrible state of car crash safety,
1:12:55and wanted to legislate that,
1:13:02to get car companies to mandate
1:13:03that they put seat belts in cars.
1:13:05And the car industry pushed back against mandatory seat belts
1:13:10under the argument that putting seat belts in cars
1:13:15made cars look unsafe.
1:13:17That if you got--
1:13:18- Oh, right.
1:13:19- No, this is true, I'm not making this up.
1:13:21- No, it's true, I forgot the other way.
1:13:21- Right, so they said, no, this is not a good idea
1:13:24because people love driving cars
1:13:27and they feel safe and happy driving cars,
1:13:29but if you go in there and there's these safety harnesses,
1:13:32safety belts, it's gonna make people think
1:13:34that they're dangerous.
1:13:35That's not, it sounds silly in hindsight,
1:13:40and we now have a lot of statistics that back up
1:13:42that it obviously hasn't stopped Americans from driving
1:13:45and we have statistics that prove that safety advances
1:13:49that have been mandated have been tremendous boons
1:13:51to public safety.
1:13:52But it's not a ridiculous argument.
1:13:54It's not ridiculous that the logic
1:13:58of the car manufacturers, it was provably wrong.
1:14:01But that didn't, it didn't happen through the All Rights Act.
1:14:05It happened through, you know, real legislation
1:14:07passed through Congress that mandated things like this.
1:14:12And that's the way it should be.
1:14:13And the other analogy I can think of,
1:14:15this isn't national, it's all gone local,
1:14:17like state by state and city by city.
1:14:20But one of the great things of my lifetime
1:14:24as someone who really, really has always been bothered
1:14:27by cigarette smoke is the passing of laws
1:14:31that get cigarettes out of bars and restaurants
1:14:33and workplaces and stuff like that.
1:14:35Now, it was a common, common and oft-repeated refrain,
1:14:40especially from bar owners,
1:14:42that if you made smoking illegal in bars,
1:14:44it would, business would dry up
1:14:46because people who smoked would go to private establishments
1:14:50instead of public ones,
1:14:51because they're not gonna stop smoking while they drink.
1:14:54And the common sense that says that,
1:14:57that argument might hold water, right?
1:14:59It might, there's some logic to that.
1:15:02And again, this wasn't done through the All Writs Act.
1:15:08It was, you have to pass an actual law and fight
1:15:11and make that argument and listen to the people,
1:15:14the bar owners arguing.
1:15:15Now, I pick both of those examples, the seatbelt, the mandatory seatbelts and the getting cigarettes
1:15:21out of bars and restaurants. I pick those specifically because I know that those arguments
1:15:27are on the wrong side, right? That it's, in my opinion, it's correct that seatbelts and,
1:15:33you know, other safety devices and, you know, very high standards for, you know, crash survivability
1:15:40are a good idea, and that I think it's a very good idea for public health that cigarettes are not,
1:15:46are banned in most restaurants and bars now. But I still think that it was right that they had to
1:15:51pass legislation to do it. So in this case, to me, with Apple being on the right side, it's even more
1:15:58important that if you want to force them to do this terrible thing, that you have to fight it
1:16:02out in the legislature. Yeah, I think you're absolutely right. I think those are great examples.
1:16:07And we could also get to like gun control as part of this issue too is like what can be done under regulations
1:16:14existing regulations and enforce and what requires laws to be passed and whatever side you are about the you know
1:16:21How many guns should be out there guns should be out there at all in private hands, whatever the side you are
1:16:25I think I would argue I would rather have a legislative solution
1:16:28Than a regulatory one even if a regulatory one might be better whether that's for allowing broader gun ownership or narrower gun ownership
1:16:36Because without the legislative solution, an executive making a decision, it doesn't lack that consensus.
1:16:42So we have the same situation here. It's like, do you want the government to use a 240-something-year-old law
1:16:49with, uh, constrained logic to upset the future of privacy and communication protection
1:16:56when the CALEA more recently addressed it or didn't address it in specific ways?
1:17:01Or do you want legislators, um, you know, regardless again of who, which political party is in charge.
1:17:05It's not actually a political issue in that sense.
1:17:08It's a political issue of how this would be addressed in a comprehensive way through a
1:17:12process that has various, you know, three branches of government and the checks and
1:17:17balances.
1:17:18I don't really want an executive agency to push through something like this.
1:17:21And you know, despite having, I'll admit it, I voted for Obama, yes, twice.
1:17:24And but I don't really like the extensive use of presidential orders, executive orders,
1:17:29and regulatory moves that he's using.
1:17:31I understand why he's doing it.
1:17:33I don't think there is long-lasting, and I don't think there, I mean, I know we're in
1:17:36the middle of intransigence, and you, with gridlock, you have to try things and so forth.
1:17:41So I understand why they're being done, but they won't have the lasting effect, they
1:17:44don't indicate a change of policy, where something like the Affordable Care Act, they
1:17:48were able to actually get that passed.
1:17:50It became law, and you see how implacable it is to resistance.
1:17:53I mean, look at, you know, the Supreme Court Chief Justice voting in favor, surprising
1:18:00of ACA under the Commerce Clause and, you know, all these decisions that have come through
1:18:05where the ACI, ACA has had some, you know, fallback, but mostly been upheld because it
1:18:11was law as opposed to regulatory interpretation or strained regulatory interpretation or presidential
1:18:17order. So, and a lot of presidential orders recently have been thrown down by the courts
1:18:21at various levels and some have not been upheld so far.
1:18:25You went to guns, so I'll go to...
1:18:27- I know guns, like yeah, we should bring it.
1:18:29- But I thought you did, hopefully,
1:18:30I think we've done so in a way that is amenable
1:18:33to anybody on either side of the issue.
1:18:34I'm gonna go to abortion, and Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
1:18:38Ruth Bader Ginsburg--
1:18:39- That's the game we're playing, guns, abortion,
1:18:40and all rights act.
1:18:41(laughing)
1:18:43- Ruth Bader Ginsburg has argued,
1:18:46and I think surprising many people, long argued,
1:18:48I think from before she was on the Supreme Court,
1:18:50I think it was a paper she wrote
1:18:52that kind of got her to the Supreme Court ruling.
1:18:54that that Roe v. Wade was actually a setback in the long run for abortion
1:19:01rights because it was a sweeping change by the Supreme Court and rather than
1:19:09letting it work its way through the legislative branch which would have
1:19:13given it a lot more that things work out better and are more broadly accepted
1:19:20when they go through the legislature than when the judiciary passes, takes matters into
1:19:26its own hands.
1:19:27And again, I don't even want to touch on the side of which way it should go.
1:19:35Pretty clear my views on it are known, but it doesn't matter though.
1:19:38I think that the basic argument though that Roe v. Wade has remained controversial in
1:19:43a way that a legislative solution, which the US was probably heading to at the time in
1:19:48the '70s, would have had more staying power. It's almost remarkable to the extent that
1:19:53Roe v. Wade remains so radioactively controversial 40-some years later, 44 years later, that
1:20:06a 44-year-old Supreme Court decision is still considered contentious, shows the logic of
1:20:15Ginsburg's argument.
1:20:17- I have to agree with that too, is right,
1:20:19it does not matter what your stance is on abortion,
1:20:21a legislative decision that was made
1:20:24and carried out at a national level
1:20:26and then enforced and refined by Supreme Court rulings
1:20:29that narrowed or broadened them on more limited grounds,
1:20:33people would be arguing about it in a different way
1:20:36because they would have felt like the,
1:20:38they would be looking to overturn the law
1:20:40as opposed to trying to figure out
1:20:41how to change a constitutional precedent
1:20:43it would have become enshrined as a constitutional precedent.
1:20:45You would have had, you know, a Roe law and the law having passed, I think in the seventies,
1:20:51I think the GOP and the Democratic Party at the time, I think would easily have passed a law that,
1:20:57uh, I think I actually think it would have not been that difficult to produce consensus then.
1:21:04Um, so let's say that happened.
1:21:06So, you had a Roe law and then some Roe based decisions later that refined it.
1:21:10that refined it.
1:21:11You know, people would still be debating about it, would still be active, but there wouldn't
1:21:14be this notion that it could be just a small tweak in the composition of the court would
1:21:19change this for everyone because you would have to get the law returned or you'd have
1:21:22to have a radically different Supreme Court interpretation.
1:21:25And that's an ongoing issue in the court.
1:21:27And it's one of the critiques of Scalia as an originalist is that he was, as an originalist,
1:21:32he didn't care about precedent as much as proceeding courts did.
1:21:35You can see the liberal and some conservative justices going off on rejecting on the fact that decisions
1:21:42overturned sometimes relatively recent precedents, which is not historically
1:21:46The case it's usually long periods of time before precedents are overturned by one from one court to another right so so yeah
1:21:54I think you're I mean so in this case
1:21:55Let's say it's I think Congress addressing it and interestingly giving Congress's approach this I wouldn't be surprised if Congress could reach consensus
1:22:03maybe not in this one, but the next one about the direction it should take that would not be as extreme as the
1:22:09administration's position and would not require this level of
1:22:13action, even if it did then you might have a constitutional issue if they try to enshrine what the FBI is trying to do as
1:22:20regulatory action. The big difference here, like we just mentioned a few minutes ago though, is that on
1:22:26abortion it's clearly polarized between the two parties.
1:22:30The Roe v. Wade only exacerbated that this issue this issue of encryption it
1:22:36Splendidly, so is crosses the political spectrum and I almost wonder whether if if the DOJ wins this case
1:22:44against Apple
1:22:46Whether that actually polarizes Congress to
1:22:52pass a law to
1:22:55Enshrined the right to strong encryption
1:23:00be interesting. Left and right could join hands around the side. That's always a good thing.
1:23:04That it might, but it might be that like losing in court might inspire Congress to do that in a way
1:23:09that not having picked this fight at all, the FBI might have been better off, you know, from their
1:23:16desire, wrongheaded desire to keep these devices as accessible as possible. Because the other thing
1:23:22too, the thing that's cross-platform, the other thing that is definitely cross-platform, and it's
1:23:27just common sense but it's easy to overlook is that branches of government
1:23:35that are three branches of government don't take well to the usurpation of
1:23:41their powers by another branch so like you said President Obama has taken and
1:23:48Bush did too but both of them in the face of opposition in Congress have
1:23:54taken to executive orders. And Congress, whatever the order is, regardless of it, does not take
1:24:01poorly, does not take well to that. And I think that when the judicial branch, when
1:24:08a judge passes or makes an order that Congress sees as that should be something that we decide,
1:24:15it doesn't matter what the issue is, it just stiffens their spine. They bristle. And I
1:24:19think rightly so. That's sort of the way the system is designed to work.
1:24:23- Yeah, and yeah, it's true.
1:24:25And I think, I mean, you can take this too
1:24:27from the legislature to the people, right?
1:24:29We keep reading these things, polls show that, you know,
1:24:32the support for Apple, the FBI are evenly split.
1:24:34And I'm like, all right, let's see what questions you ask.
1:24:36And the questions are too vague.
1:24:38I would like to see this question asked in like AB testing.
1:24:40So in one case you say, should Apple give the FBI
1:24:43the contents of the phone or whatever the questions are
1:24:45that ask yes, no, and how are they phrased, right?
1:24:47The other is, should the FBI be allowed
1:24:50with legal warrant from a judge to access your phone
1:24:54at any time they deem there's a legal necessity for it
1:24:58and obtain all the contents absolutely in plain text,
1:25:01you know, in some form of that.
1:25:03I think he'd get a different response if he said,
1:25:05you know, should a judge allow the FBI to examine
1:25:09the contents of your phone at any time?
1:25:11- Well, and it's-- - Not at any time,
1:25:11but in a criminal action with a warrant.
1:25:15- It's really hard to pull, too, because it's--
1:25:18because it's easy for a lay person to believe in the magic solution of a way
1:25:25for the F for the government to get in but nobody else that only the government
1:25:28you know which you kind of have to be gently informed of the basic way that
1:25:36encryption works to understand just how dang you know how dangerous and
1:25:40impossible it is to say the only people who can get in are the US federal
1:25:45It just doesn't work that way once you create,
1:25:47you know, once you create a backdoor.
1:25:49I know it's right.
1:25:51So there's like, you could actually ask, I mean,
1:25:53basically we're saying is, uh, for this poll,
1:25:55we need to get 10,000 people.
1:25:56We can give a two day class on cryptography and
1:25:59operating systems too.
1:26:00And after that, we're going to ask you a few
1:26:02questions like, yeah.
1:26:03Yeah.
1:26:03And what if, what if you just proceed the
1:26:05question with, remember like, uh, 20 minutes ago,
1:26:0830 minutes ago when I read the two quotes from,
1:26:10uh, the, the, uh, uh, the, uh, uh, the, uh,
1:26:15the Department of Defense, the, what do you call it?
1:26:18The who's in charge of the Department of Defense?
1:26:20The Secretary of Defense, US Secretary of Defense.
1:26:25And the former head of the NSA and CIA.
1:26:28And just read those two short, clear statements.
1:26:31And then say, do you think Apple should be forced
1:26:34to comply with this?
1:26:34And then see if the poll results change.
1:26:36And it's almost certain it would change to some degree,
1:26:38whether it would change dramatically or mildly,
1:26:40but it would have to have some effect.
1:26:43So, you know, I don't go,
1:26:45That is why we don't have, this is, you know, it's exactly why we don't just vote on everything,
1:26:50you know, California style, just have voter initiatives on all this stuff.
1:26:53But it's why we have a representative democracy.
1:26:55Yeah.
1:26:56And that's, I mean, this is the problem sometimes or often with jury trials, right?
1:27:00We've seen this with civil trials specifically, but you'd have them with criminal too.
1:27:02It's like, how do you get average people who should be able to solve, I mean, in many kinds of cases of
1:27:08or civil liability, uh, an ordinary people with
1:27:12reasonable intelligence should be able to spend
1:27:14a few days in a courtroom, learn enough and be
1:27:17able to make an adjudication that's, that's
1:27:19ostensibly fair or reasonable, right?
1:27:21Right.
1:27:21With a judge overseeing it.
1:27:22But how do you do that with encryption?
1:27:24How do you do that with most of these technical
1:27:25topics or user interface design?
1:27:27Like you can't, and every outcome is going to be
1:27:29arbitrary when placed in front of a jury.
1:27:31It's the same thing with polls.
1:27:33The polls are a reflection of how a jury would
1:27:35probably deal with it, which would be, you
1:27:37would be, you know.
1:27:39- So one of the things, so Tim Cook a while back,
1:27:42at some point, you know, not a while,
1:27:45but it's all been within the last month,
1:27:46but at one point had compared it to the creation
1:27:49of this governmentalist to cancer.
1:27:51And I think a better analogy, I've been thinking about it,
1:27:56this bothered me ever since, and a better analogy to me,
1:27:58it's close, but to me it's a better analogy,
1:28:00is chemical weapons or biological weapons.
1:28:02And I've seen other people make this comparison
1:28:05that creation of this is like creating a biological weapon.
1:28:08And you can say, oh, we're gonna let you keep it
1:28:11in a secure place and we'll treat it,
1:28:14and we're gonna devise a very precise,
1:28:17carefully planned procedure for the application of it
1:28:22so that it's only applied in this one specific thing.
1:28:25But that there is a very good argument
1:28:30that the best way to avoid the dangers
1:28:32of biological weapons getting out of your control
1:28:34is to never create them in the first place.
1:28:37And that to me is where the cancer analogy falls down
1:28:39is that nobody's created cancer.
1:28:40Cancer is not a, no, but I think it really matters though.
1:28:44- No, no, I think you're true.
1:28:45It's not an intent, it's a byproduct
1:28:47of biological processes and maybe pesticides
1:28:50and genetics and so forth.
1:28:52Right, yeah, absolutely.
1:28:53I never thought of that analogy though.
1:28:54That's very funny.
1:28:55- And I think it's a little,
1:28:57I think, I haven't seen Apple repeat that analogy
1:28:59and I think they realize that it's not a good enough analogy
1:29:03Right?
1:29:04'Cause there's this, the part of the argument,
1:29:07or the entirety of the government's argument
1:29:09is that this could be controlled.
1:29:11And it would never get out, given the right precautions,
1:29:14it would never get out of control.
1:29:16And that's-- - I don't know,
1:29:18I keep thinking about this, like, what if, you know,
1:29:20okay, government says, you, hospital X,
1:29:24we need you, Sisters of Charitable Mercy,
1:29:27we need you to do open-heart surgery on this individual
1:29:31who has a micro SD card implanted in his heart.
1:29:35And we need that data.
1:29:36And so the hospital tries to oppose it,
1:29:40they're ordered to do so,
1:29:40court orders them to do what surgeon goes in
1:29:43and does the open heart surgery to do that.
1:29:46I mean, that's a one-off thing too,
1:29:47it's not even as bad.
1:29:48And it's like, okay, well, this is possible.
1:29:50Well, we have a thousand open heart surgeries,
1:29:52we need to schedule tomorrow.
1:29:54And we'll have surgeons trained in this now too,
1:29:56so it's very easy to do.
1:29:57Like, oh no, no, no, no.
1:29:59Not everybody has a chip in their heart. Um, all right,
1:30:03let me just take a break here and thank our next sponsor and it's our good
1:30:06friends at audible audible.com has more than 180,000 audio books and spoken word
1:30:11audio products and you can get a 30 day free trial at audible.com/talk show.
1:30:19Um, if you want to listen to it, audible has it. You mean you could literally,
1:30:25I think with $180,000, 180,000 audio books,
1:30:28You could probably spend every waking minute of the rest of your life and not finish listening
1:30:33to the Audible library.
1:30:36They have audiobooks from every genre you can imagine, anytime, anywhere, and you can
1:30:42play Audible's audiobooks on phones, tablets, computers, most Kindles, all the modern Kindles,
1:30:48and even iPods.
1:30:52Audiobooks are great for flights.
1:30:54They're great for road trips.
1:30:57They are great to fill up your daily commute.
1:31:00I think it's a great solution for everybody who wishes that I did the talk show more frequently.
1:31:05Fill in the gaps with books from audio, from Audible.
1:31:10It's just a tremendous resource for anybody who has the time to listen to stuff like that.
1:31:14I like to go when I walk or run through the city, take a jog or whatever.
1:31:19I want to have something to listen to.
1:31:21So it drives me nuts if I don't have something to listen to.
1:31:25audible.com you'll never ever run out of stuff to listen to 180,000 books free free trial just go
1:31:35to audible.com slash talk show my thanks to audible for sponsoring the show once again
1:31:41unbelievable library at audible all right what else should we talk about glenn tiny phones
1:31:49Tiny phones for tiny hands.
1:31:50Vulgarian handed phones.
1:31:53Tiny, tiny hands.
1:31:55I love the idea that Donald Trump is bothered by it.
1:31:58He keeps sending, he sends the photocopies of his hands to, uh, what's his name?
1:32:05The guy from Green Carter.
1:32:06Right.
1:32:07Got them a few years.
1:32:08It's not like he did it once.
1:32:10Like it's Green Carter's every couple of years, I guess.
1:32:12The story, for those of you who haven't, the story, I'll paraphrase it.
1:32:17I'll put it in the show links.
1:32:18It's such a funny story, and it's so telling as to Donald Trump's personality.
1:32:21But the story is—I think it might have even predated the Vanity Fair.
1:32:24Was it for Spy Magazine?
1:32:25Pete: Oh, it was for, I think it was Spy, that's right.
1:32:28Jim: Right, well, but Graydon Carter, who's long been the editor at Vanity Fair,
1:32:35and before that was the editor at the late beloved Spy Magazine, which was just fantastic,
1:32:40wrote a profile of Trump in the 80s, and I think he called him a small-handed Bulgarian.
1:32:47small, small, wait, small fingered, small fingered, small fingered, something like that.
1:32:53And in the decade since Graydon Carter has said recently that every, you know, once a year,
1:33:00maybe two years go by, but then he gets another one. Every couple of years, he gets a letter from
1:33:06Trump with like a picture from a magazine pulled out and in gold Sharpie, a circle around the hands,
1:33:15and it's just like a handwritten note that says, "Look at those hands."
1:33:18Not small. So, you know, there's a PAC, a political action committee was registered by
1:33:26a Portland, Oregon man called Trump Has Tiny Hands. And the Federal Election Commission on
1:33:31Monday, so the FEC has been deadlocked with two members, Republican appointed, two Democratic
1:33:36appointed members, destroying the ability for the FEC to enforce election law. And it's been going
1:33:41on for years because Congress won't approve the third appointee who would give the balance of
1:33:44power of the Democrats under Obama. Many, one of the many intransigent points here, right?
1:33:48FEC acts against this guy on Monday. FEC can't do anything. They act against this guy,
1:33:55requiring that he changes Trump has tiny hands pack. So he's changed his name.
1:33:59It's now the Americans against insecure billionaires with tiny hands. That's his
1:34:04political action. Oh my God.
1:34:07(laughing)
1:34:10Trump famously was, however large or small his hands are,
1:34:16a few years ago I remember he tweeted something
1:34:22to the effect of that, this is before the iPhone 6 came out,
1:34:25that Apple needs to put out a big iPhone,
1:34:27you know, get with the times or something like that.
1:34:29- Oh, that's funny, yeah.
1:34:31- So Trump, however small his hands are,
1:34:33is a fan of large phones.
1:34:35- That's true.
1:34:36Well, I'm curious, my wife likes small phones,
1:34:38and when I use her, she has an iPhone 5 that is failing.
1:34:41And when I use it, when she hands it to me,
1:34:42and she makes a type large, little vision issue,
1:34:45so she makes a type large, and I use it,
1:34:47and I feel like I'm using a fairy phone.
1:34:48I'm like, little tiny fairies use this phone.
1:34:50And I'm like, how many years did I use a phone
1:34:52that was that size or smaller, and it seemed fine.
1:34:55I have an iPhone 6S, and now the iPhone 5S size
1:34:59seems ridiculous, but she's waiting, her phone is failing.
1:35:02If the SE ships or is announced on Monday as expected,
1:35:05then she's a customer.
1:35:07John Woltz is a customer.
1:35:08- I would argue that in a certain sense,
1:35:11I don't know what the volume is,
1:35:12but in a hand feel sense,
1:35:14I would argue that the iPhone 5 and 5S
1:35:16are the smallest iPhone Apple ever made.
1:35:18And I know that the screen got bigger.
1:35:20It went from three and a half to four,
1:35:21but it's so much thinner that to me it feels smaller.
1:35:25And I have my little museum here of old iPhones,
1:35:29that because of the thinness,
1:35:32it feels smaller in the hand,
1:35:33that it feels like the smallest iPhone they ever had.
1:35:36- That is probably it, you're right,
1:35:37by volume and like screen edge dimensions, yes.
1:35:41- Maybe by volume it's not because of the extra length
1:35:44to accommodate the four inch screen as opposed to 3.5,
1:35:47but because you hold it sideways typically,
1:35:51you don't really hold it end to end,
1:35:53that the volume that matters is sort of like the,
1:35:57you know, like the bottom half of the phone.
1:35:59- Yeah, that's true.
1:36:00- Or like the bottom, you know, two, three inches
1:36:02is really the volume that matters
1:36:04and that whatever sticks up off the top
1:36:06doesn't really count.
1:36:07- I think it's gonna be a big seller.
1:36:10I hope it actually is a real thing.
1:36:11It seems very reliably so that it's a real thing.
1:36:13And it's fun to watch.
1:36:15I mean, Apple has that matrix.
1:36:17Who did that a few years ago
1:36:18before something came out, the iPad mini,
1:36:20something came out where someone built this fan
1:36:24of all the devices and sizes and prices
1:36:26and they said, "Here are the holes,"
1:36:27then Apple released devices that fit in those holes.
1:36:29I feel like the SE is absolutely
1:36:32in one of those holes right now.
1:36:34- I think it's fascinating that here we are,
1:36:36we're recording on Wednesday, March 16th,
1:36:38and I think the show's gonna air on Thursday.
1:36:40I don't know when people will listen.
1:36:43Hopefully they'll listen before the event on Monday,
1:36:45but who knows what will leak at the last possible minute,
1:36:48but it's fascinating to me that the phone hasn't leaked.
1:36:51And I know that there was like a CAD drawing
1:36:53that one of the rumor sites,
1:36:55I don't know if it was 9to5Mac or MacRumors,
1:36:58probably 9to5 Mac, but they had like a CAD rendering
1:37:01that they then interpreted as a, you know,
1:37:04made like a rendering out of.
1:37:07But we don't really know, like the parts didn't leak.
1:37:09There's nobody who's held up a part that says,
1:37:12here's the, you know, here's the casing for the iPhone SE.
1:37:15And I-- - It makes me wonder
1:37:17if it's shipping like a month,
1:37:19but I can't imagine they're gonna do the event and say,
1:37:21and you can order this for shipping on May 1st.
1:37:23- I don't think so. - It's gonna be available
1:37:24day and date, I have to believe.
1:37:25- Germin, Germin? - Like, on Friday, rather.
1:37:27I think Germin says by Friday, which is actually kind of interesting, my, you know, just my own
1:37:31selfish interest that it's, I'm going to the event, I'll be at the event. I guess since I'm going that
1:37:38I'll probably get one to review, but if they're shipping it on Friday, I don't, I'm not quite sure
1:37:43how, how I write a review before it actually ships. Yeah, that's, it, it seems, yeah, I'm doing a
1:37:50Monday event, yeah. Although on the other hand, maybe it's a very easy device to review. It's,
1:37:55It's back to the old size and it's got the new specs
1:38:00and figure out how good the camera is.
1:38:03I think I'm gonna like it.
1:38:04I think I'm going to,
1:38:05I don't know that I'll switch from the 4.7
1:38:07but I might be very tempted to.
1:38:09It's gonna be a close call for me.
1:38:13- I love that they're,
1:38:15I mean if this happens, it seems so likely,
1:38:17I love that they're doing it because,
1:38:19I've talked to some other folks about the notion
1:38:21that we're getting to post numbering,
1:38:23that maybe this is, or maybe this model never gets numbered.
1:38:27I think you've written about that too.
1:38:28It's that like, at some point, you know, the iPad 3,
1:38:32was it called the iPad 2 and the iPad 3,
1:38:34then it became the iPad.
1:38:35And numbers are bad for Apple,
1:38:39except if they're trying to create demand,
1:38:41like a pull of demand for the newer thing.
1:38:43And I think sales figures and growth may show
1:38:46that they just need to be shipping out devices,
1:38:49maybe not creating the expectation
1:38:51in the same way and the new plans.
1:38:53I mean, the thing is with a lot of people
1:38:55shifting to, shifting to installment plans
1:38:56that allow an upgrade after either 12 or 18
1:38:58months, I think we're going to see, seems like
1:39:01the majority of people in the U S will wind up
1:39:03on a plan with either a 12 or 18 month refresh
1:39:05and some with like a, you know, 20 or 24 month
1:39:08where, um, they don't pay any extra for that.
1:39:10That's going to flood the market with older
1:39:12phones in some fashion, there'll be resold
1:39:14or there'll be, uh, you know, uh, refurbished
1:39:17and available.
1:39:18And then, um, you have all these people
1:39:20I mean, Hey, look, I'm on an installment plan.
1:39:22Am I going to get an iPhone seven or whatever it's called?
1:39:24Probably because I feel like that's my Apple fee is now I'm paying, I don't
1:39:28know what is 56 bucks a month.
1:39:29I'll just pay that forever for my phone and I'll just always have the freshest
1:39:33phone like that does not seem like a penalty to me, um, the way they're
1:39:37marketing it.
1:39:37Yeah.
1:39:38To me, I think it'll probably personally come down to image quality.
1:39:43I think that, or, you know, for the camera that if you want your 12 megapixel
1:39:48- Well, I don't care about the megapixel camera.
1:39:50- I'm sorry, but like a better, right.
1:39:52That's a field, I want depth of field.
1:39:54- Well, you're not gonna get that in this camera.
1:39:56- I know.
1:39:57- It's not gonna move forward,
1:40:00but if to me it looks like I can take the same quality
1:40:03pictures in the same lighting conditions as my iPhone 6S.
1:40:07- Oh, I'm sorry, I see, yes.
1:40:08- More or less that it, at least to my eyes,
1:40:11it looks like I'm getting the same image quality.
1:40:13I think I would prefer the smaller phone.
1:40:15the smaller phone. I like the way it feels in my hand. I like the way it is smaller in my pocket.
1:40:21And to be honest, the majority of what I read on the phone is Twitter. And tweets,
1:40:31because they're so small, it doesn't matter that I can see more of them at a time on a larger screen
1:40:37phone. And I do read a lot of articles on Mobile Safari, but I never minded it that much.
1:40:45You know, like to me, both screens are small and constrained for reading articles
1:40:49and you just reflow them with, you know, reader view or something like that. So
1:40:54Big screen to me isn't all that appealing. I see, you know, it is certainly a trade-off
1:41:00But in terms of the smaller device size, I don't know. I think I'm on the fence. Me and Moltz.
1:41:04Yeah, I like having the smaller phone. I mean this comes back to hey, apparently we're both guys
1:41:09So there's an issue there
1:41:10which is that we don't have the tiny unusable pockets
1:41:13or no pockets that a lot of women have in their clothing.
1:41:16My friend, Erin McKean, who's at Wordnik,
1:41:18the head of that great site that's collecting
1:41:20like open source-ish definitions of words,
1:41:23the nonprofit project, she likes to make her own dresses,
1:41:26makes wonderful stuff, wrote about it
1:41:27for the magazine years ago, and she puts pockets in stuff
1:41:30and she has people stopping her all the time.
1:41:32Wait, you have pockets in your clothing, how that happens?
1:41:34Like I made the dress, so there's pockets in it.
1:41:36A wife encounters this all the time
1:41:38stylish, but not like, um, like a fashion,
1:41:41absurdly stylish, unusable clothing.
1:41:43And, um, got to think like that was the thing
1:41:45with the iPhone six or if I own a six plus
1:41:48when it came out, I thought I don't want to
1:41:50phone that big, but I'm not going to prejudge
1:41:52it because Apple knows the market better.
1:41:53And I am like one tiny segment now of the market.
1:41:56I don't want a gold phone.
1:41:57I don't want a gold watch.
1:41:58I don't want whatever.
1:41:59Uh, and I, a lot of women I know, uh, liked
1:42:02the six plus cause they already keeping a phone
1:42:04in their purse.
1:42:05And this was like, this is great.
1:42:06I can read it and it's, it's great.
1:42:08and it doubles as a Kindle and it serves many purposes.
1:42:11So in a lot of women and some men, I know,
1:42:13but I would say more of the women I know got it than men.
1:42:15Although several men we know like Mike Hurley and so forth
1:42:18are big fans of it.
1:42:19I feel like the SE is definitely ties more into that,
1:42:22like the small pocket thing or small,
1:42:24for like not having a lot of room or stuff to carry,
1:42:27it's gonna be for an audience
1:42:28that I think has been underserved
1:42:29and the 5S has filled that gap.
1:42:31- I'm so, I'm excited to go out for this event
1:42:35because I so don't know,
1:42:37I have a good guess what they're going to show us,
1:42:40but I have no idea how they're gonna sell it to us,
1:42:43which to me is interesting.
1:42:44Because there's two main things that they've got.
1:42:46They've got the smaller phone,
1:42:47and they got the new iPad Pro that's only 9.7 inches,
1:42:52which is effectively just a smaller iPad Pro.
1:42:55So how do they get on stage and sell two devices
1:42:59that are, it's exactly like the thing
1:43:00we announced in September, but smaller.
1:43:02(laughing)
1:43:04Right, that neither of them are gonna do anything
1:43:06than the ones that are already on the market.
1:43:09- I wonder if they'll talk about it as a family of devices.
1:43:11We know people have different needs, different demands,
1:43:13and the 5S has been a, I won't mention the 5S,
1:43:15they never talk backwards, right?
1:43:16But like, we've, you know,
1:43:17we filled this category in the past,
1:43:19and now we felt we could do something unique and new,
1:43:22and this is what we're doing to fill out our product line,
1:43:25to fit a family of needs, right?
1:43:27Something like that?
1:43:28- I don't know.
1:43:29- They have to say something new though.
1:43:31There's always a new thing.
1:43:32This is the reason why we waited till now to do this.
1:43:34What is it? We don't know.
1:43:35- I don't know, yeah, I don't know how it's just like
1:43:37the last thing but smaller,
1:43:38how they get something new out of it.
1:43:39There must be, but that's why I'm--
1:43:41- That's the tagline, the campaign is,
1:43:43last thing but smaller, think different.
1:43:45It's pretty good.
1:43:47- Do you think, here's a question I've had.
1:43:48I keep meaning to ask this on Twitter, but I'll ask you.
1:43:52Do you think they will come out with the smart battery pack
1:43:57for the iPhone SE?
1:43:58- That's a great question.
1:44:01I just, I was working for Wirecutter for a while,
1:44:03I worked on this USB battery guide, not the battery, we didn't do the battery pack that was Dan Frakes, my old friend Dan Frakes,
1:44:08worked on the battery pack
1:44:11up front when that came out, but looking at a lot of batteries that are out there and what's capable and
1:44:17what the capacity of this thing will likely be, I have a hard time believing it because I think the whole idea
1:44:24this one is going to be that sort of like a very specific form, right?
1:44:28So if you come out with it and a battery pack, you're underselling what this phone is about,
1:44:34uh, because they are so much more efficient with power than with the F the five S I would bet they
1:44:40could eat 30 or 40% more power out of the same form factor than they can out of the F S with a similar
1:44:47using the same battery capacity.
1:44:49And so extensively, you'll have a slightly bigger battery because they're better at that or slightly
1:44:54slightly denser perhaps, and everything will be so much more efficient.
1:44:58And because the screen is so much smaller by area and by pixel count, it, and that,
1:45:03you know,
1:45:04They perfected that. It would be hard to believe that they would want to, I mean, would you
1:45:08want to, like, I understand the 6S, it makes a lot of sense because it's kind of in the
1:45:13middle there and people, I mean, USB battery packs of all kinds, not just the ones that
1:45:18are cases have sold so well.
1:45:20I think if they do, it will roll out on the same schedule
1:45:24that the battery pack for the 6S did,
1:45:26which is, you know, six weeks after the phone comes out.
1:45:29- Oh, don't steal a thunder.
1:45:31- Yeah. - Extra thing.
1:45:32Here's something, hey.
1:45:33- And don't risk the PR backlash of Apple releases a phone
1:45:38that needs an external battery pack.
1:45:41- Yeah. - Right?
1:45:41I mean, they got that anyway
1:45:42when they released their own battery pack,
1:45:44but by the time November rolled around,
1:45:46it was a lot quieter than if they had done it on stage.
1:45:49Can I talk batteries for a second?
1:45:50'Cause I can't tell you how many batteries I've tested in.
1:45:52I did this thing at the Wirecutter.
1:45:55We did a USB battery pack guide
1:45:56with a great writer there, Mark Smerniotis,
1:45:59who did a fantastic job, used a battery testing lab,
1:46:02K-DEX up in Vancouver, BC.
1:46:04It was fascinating.
1:46:05And then I did a bunch of reviews for Mac World
1:46:08just a few weeks ago of USB-C equipped batteries.
1:46:11And oh my God, if you haven't touched a battery,
1:46:14like a USB battery, if you, like a few years ago,
1:46:16were like, ah, these are sort of terrible and expensive
1:46:18and they don't last long.
1:46:19the next generation is out and like across all
1:46:22these different manufacturers and you can
1:46:24get, you can charge the one that I liked best in
1:46:27the Mac world round up was the Anker has a 20,100
1:46:31milliamp year hour battery with USB-C and USB
1:46:35regular USB.
1:46:3520,000?
1:46:3620,000 and it costs 50 bucks.
1:46:38So it's like.
1:46:39You can charge your MacBook about 110% from it.
1:46:42Wow.
1:46:43A 12 inch MacBook.
1:46:44Wow.
1:46:44That's, I know what I was like, you know, I was
1:46:47kind of watching batteries a little bit.
1:46:48I hadn't got into it.
1:46:49And the circuitry is so much better.
1:46:50They hold a charge for the new, like the new
1:46:52lithium ion cells that are being used, hold a
1:46:55charge better.
1:46:56They're so much better at conversion.
1:46:58They don't heat up as much.
1:46:59Um, it's really extraordinary.
1:47:01So if you've been holding back on a USB, I
1:47:03sound like an ad for the industry, but it's
1:47:05like, it is complicated though.
1:47:06I actually looked into it a couple of weeks ago
1:47:08and I was going to do a wire cutter style thing
1:47:10where I actually bought like three or four,
1:47:13just for the phone.
1:47:14It was right after I did the battery case
1:47:16review and I thought, you know what, I should
1:47:17review these little portable things because I've long had one it's a couple
1:47:21of year or two old a mophie that has like mofie my problem with mophie is
1:47:27mophie alone has too many they have too many they also charge four times what
1:47:32you to pay it makes it so hard to figure out what to buy just anybody at mophie
1:47:37who listens to the show please for the love of God just get rid of three
1:47:40quarters of your product lineup and just keep you know just tell me what's the
1:47:43best one to get because they have like different even just form factors of them
1:47:47But anyway, they've got one that I really like that has built in a built in USB cable
1:47:52and a built not like a and it does pass through charging.
1:47:57Does it do is it now that pastor is interesting thing, but does it do so it's got a type A
1:48:01connector you can plug into a DC adapter.
1:48:04Yeah, like a standard adapter doesn't have lightning though, right?
1:48:08No it does have lightning as a built in.
1:48:09It does lightning and type A. Oh, see, that's great.
1:48:11And you can get that there's a travel card.
1:48:14if you want a really tiny one has a lightning
1:48:16and type A thing that they--
1:48:18- What's type A?
1:48:19Type A means you plug it into the charger, right?
1:48:21- Yeah, type A is like the standard rectangular one.
1:48:24And that's what you mostly see.
1:48:26That's the computer side one.
1:48:27It's either USB-C or type A
1:48:30is what you're gonna see on computers.
1:48:31And all the AC adapters are type A,
1:48:34those rectangular plugs.
1:48:36But travel card is really neat
1:48:37'cause it has the integral lightning MFA,
1:48:39MFI approved or licensed certified, whatever.
1:48:43and the one, so you only, you don't have to carry
1:48:45any extra cable with a travel card.
1:48:47I think it's like 40 bucks, so it's expensive, or 35.
1:48:50And it only charged your phone like, I don't know,
1:48:52like two thirds the way or something,
1:48:54but like an iPhone 6.
1:48:55But if that's what you need, if you're like,
1:48:56the question, the thing we did with the wire cutters,
1:48:58we divided it up into, do you need it to top off
1:49:01at the end, your full day at work or away,
1:49:02and you need to get through the night,
1:49:04or to the end of an evening?
1:49:05Or do you wanna be able to charge like for another
1:49:07full day of usage, or on the road for like a week,
1:49:11and you got an iPad?
1:49:12So you can get things, there are now a differentiation.
1:49:14You get anything from like, oh, Amazon,
1:49:17Amazon Basics, it doesn't have a lightning cable,
1:49:19but it will take a regular plug,
1:49:22you can plug your cable into it, your regular adapter.
1:49:262000 milliampere hour battery from Amazon,
1:49:29it'll charge a phone, I think the resulting charge
1:49:31is at least half or two thirds.
1:49:33It's five or six bucks as an Amazon Basics add-on.
1:49:36So you can go all the way from that
1:49:37up to like 25,000 milliampere hour,
1:49:40like RavPower and some others
1:49:42it'll charge an iPad like six times or something.
1:49:45- That's really, it's really interesting though
1:49:46to think about, I mean, I've always used them
1:49:48in the context of charging a phone,
1:49:49but it's interesting to think about charging
1:49:51like a MacBook that way with, and getting like,
1:49:54you know, like a hundred, like you said,
1:49:55what, 110% charge out of a portable phone?
1:49:57- Yeah, the Anker is amazing.
1:49:59Anker is a fascinating company.
1:50:00It's like a Google engineer and his wife started this up
1:50:02and she started the business, I think,
1:50:04and then he eventually quit Google.
1:50:06They moved back to China.
1:50:07I think they were from China originally,
1:50:08'cause they moved back there, I think is what he said.
1:50:10And now they're shipping like, I don't know,
1:50:12a month or something like they came from,
1:50:14I love anchor quality.
1:50:15It's like, it's really great.
1:50:16They have a whole lineup of stuff.
1:50:18Uh, and, um, and they're making, they're
1:50:21kind of pushing it so that what, what happened
1:50:23really is that a lot of companies, Panasonic,
1:50:25LG, and a bunch of other firms started to make
1:50:27really good standardized, you know, essentially
1:50:29lithium ion cells.
1:50:30They they're varying sizes.
1:50:32They're cylinders like a double a battery,
1:50:34but can be bigger or smaller.
1:50:35And these standardized components mean that
1:50:37nobody in the chain has to build that part.
1:50:40has to build that part and they're all such high quality or blah they're very high quality now
1:50:44that it's so affordable they can stick three or six or eight into a thing with you know some
1:50:50circuitry to handle charging and USB conversion and get you know so it's really all about like
1:50:55packaging and engineering of taking this commodity item and making it something better it's cool it's
1:51:01the new it's the future I I the gist of my experimentation with these mophie ones and I
1:51:06I bought two of the other ones that don't have built-in cables and you instead have to supply your own lightning cable to charge your
1:51:12Phone from it, but the other ones are more like almost like basically like iPhone size batteries
1:51:18They're you know, yeah, they're thin like an iPhone and a varying sizes depending on their capacity
1:51:24But you have to supply your own cable the thing that really makes them work
1:51:27well for me is when you buy like from Amazon basics, or I actually bought a couple from I
1:51:34- I forget the name of the company.
1:51:35What's the name of the company you buy
1:51:36real cheap cables at?
1:51:38- Oh, Monoprice.
1:51:39- Monoprice.
1:51:40- Monoprice, I'm sorry.
1:51:41- I bought a bunch of these little
1:51:43like three inch lightning cables,
1:51:45which in a lot of contexts make no sense at all,
1:51:48but like for just putting a battery in your pocket
1:51:50while it charges the phone, it's absolutely perfect
1:51:53because then you don't have, like to me,
1:51:55before I bought one of these little cables to go with it,
1:51:57the whole thing that was such a pain
1:52:00and it looked ridiculous is what do you do
1:52:02with a three foot cable when you're charging it
1:52:04in a device that's in your pocket.
1:52:06These little like two or three inch lightning cables
1:52:09are perfect for that.
1:52:10So, and to me it's a better solution
1:52:13than the Apple battery pack or any battery pack
1:52:15for that matter, because unless you really wanna use
1:52:17the battery pack every single day.
1:52:19At which point, at which point I really question
1:52:22whether you shouldn't just get the iPhone plus size.
1:52:26If that's, you know, if you really want it all the time,
1:52:28every day, why don't you just buy the iPhone plus?
1:52:31Well, this is the thing that's interesting, too, having gone through all this battery stuff, is USB is a huge bottleneck, including lightning.
1:52:38There's only a maximum amount of power you can push into an iPhone or iPad battery, or even recharge it.
1:52:45So I'm testing 20,000 milliampere-hour batteries. It takes hours to drain these things.
1:52:50I got this thing, I had to order it from Japan. It's this beautiful little device, cannot get it in America, that's a load generator.
1:52:56two amps of load or up to like three, I think
1:52:59off a USB port and dissipates it as heat.
1:53:01So I could drain the damn thing.
1:53:03So I could test to see how fast they charge.
1:53:04There's a new quick charge, uh, two and
1:53:07three of these standards from Qualcomm that are
1:53:09being built into Android phones and some other
1:53:11phones that can charge at higher voltages.
1:53:13So they can, they charge at a relatively low
1:53:16amperage high voltage and they can recharge
1:53:18battery like two or three times faster than at
1:53:21USB voltages, even at high amperages.
1:53:23So USB C is interesting because it's
1:53:26'cause USB-C boosts the overall like wattage
1:53:30that you can put into something.
1:53:31So if an iPad Pro would actually really good with USB-C
1:53:35because it could safely charge its battery
1:53:38like four or five times faster than the limits
1:53:41that USB puts on it.
1:53:42It's why, I mean, iPad Pro,
1:53:43I'd love to talk to some people about that.
1:53:44- What if, well-- - Recharge time.
1:53:46- Is lightning definitely a limiting factor?
1:53:49What if the lightning cable started with USB-C
1:53:52to get the power and then was lightning into the device?
1:53:55- That's a good question.
1:53:56I believe that Lightning has a wattage limit
1:53:59that is below what you could do with USB-C by a large factor.
1:54:04So, oh man, of course, I don't know what the limit is.
1:54:07I think it's only 15 watts you can put over Lightning
1:54:12and you can do, you know, the MacBook charges,
1:54:14has a 29 watt charger
1:54:16and USB-C can have up to a hundred watts on a cable.
1:54:19You wouldn't want to do that with an iPad Pro,
1:54:20but even like a 30, a 29 watt or 30 watt charger
1:54:24for the iPad Pro, I think would, like I say,
1:54:27at least double or maybe even be 60 or 70% more
1:54:30than you can do with lightning's limits.
1:54:32- One of the basic rules of computer technology in general
1:54:35is that anything that's slow will eventually be faster.
1:54:40Right?
1:54:40It's true.
1:54:41And you just accept it.
1:54:43We used to just accept that it took 90 seconds
1:54:46to copy a 1.4 megabyte floppy disk.
1:54:48We just accepted that.
1:54:49I mean, 'cause what are you gonna do?
1:54:50You gotta wait.
1:54:53And now, the idea that you wait a noticeable period of time
1:54:58to copy one megabyte of data, it's laughable.
1:55:02So what's slow today?
1:55:04Charging, listening to you talk about this,
1:55:06charging is slow.
1:55:07And it's like, we develop habits to avoid
1:55:12having to worry about it, charging overnight,
1:55:14charging while we're at our desk.
1:55:16But like, my son is not good with remembering to do it.
1:55:20And it's like, if you're going on a road trip
1:55:21and it's, or you're heading to the airport
1:55:23and its phone is already in the red,
1:55:24it's like, oh God, what are you thinking?
1:55:27But it's, and that's when you really notice,
1:55:29boy, a phone does not take a charge very quickly
1:55:32when you're in a hurry.
1:55:34- No, that's a big, I think that's a big thing.
1:55:35And that's why, I mean, Qualcomm,
1:55:37this is where they're trying to innovate
1:55:38on the opposite side,
1:55:39and I'm sure they would love Apple to adopt this,
1:55:41and Apple's not gonna adopt Quick Charge, I don't think,
1:55:43'cause it's doesn't, it's not like a lightning-based thing.
1:55:45- Right.
1:55:46- But I've got a couple of Quick Charge 3 chargers here
1:55:49that had a--
1:55:49- They can't afford to be left behind though.
1:55:51You know what I mean?
1:55:52Like they-- - Yeah.
1:55:53That's what USB-C though, they can go to USB-C
1:55:55and then they don't have to do quick charge.
1:55:56They can push more amperage
1:55:57or I think it's a combination of amperage and wattage
1:55:59through amperage and voltage.
1:56:01- I wonder if they could do a lightning too
1:56:03that would increase the amperage
1:56:05but would be physically compatible.
1:56:09- I think USB-C is the direction
1:56:12and I'm just wondering if lightning,
1:56:13I mean, I know this has been a battle.
1:56:15We've been talking about this since USB-C.
1:56:17It became a thing that Apple wanted to do
1:56:19It's like, it's really tricky to put a USB.
1:56:21It's only slightly larger than lightning, but it's tricky to put it in my phone.
1:56:24But I think it's probably the right approach.
1:56:27I don't, I don't think the Apple's ever going to put USBC on the devices.
1:56:30I know.
1:56:30I know.
1:56:31They, I wonder if they would add this as they were never going to add a second
1:56:33port on an iPad, right?
1:56:34But they should have a USB-C port on an iPad pro and it's not going to happen.
1:56:37I think lightning is becoming inadequate to the task.
1:56:40And I think that they're going to have to cope with that eventually.
1:56:43Yeah.
1:56:44I wonder, I wonder how much of this they've foresaw and how much now they're
1:56:48like painted ourselves in a corner.
1:56:50- You're totally right though.
1:56:51They could have, no, Lightning II could actually be,
1:56:53Lightning II could have USB-C on one end
1:56:56and Lightning II on the other,
1:56:57and the same cable thing, and it's backwards compatible,
1:57:00but if you've got Lightning II circuitry
1:57:02and a Lightning II cable, you get to charge that.
1:57:04You totally, I mean, that is totally feasible,
1:57:06and I forget that.
1:57:07So that could be where they're going,
1:57:08and then they're gonna take advantage
1:57:10of the USB-C infrastructure for having chargers
1:57:12and other stuff, and they really push it that way.
1:57:14But yeah, I mean, you don't wanna take like seven hours
1:57:17pro battery.
1:57:18That doesn't make sense, right?
1:57:19You want it to take like three or two.
1:57:22That's the thing.
1:57:25But on the other hand, you know, this anchor,
1:57:26this one I was talking about that I like it's,
1:57:28it weighs like a pound or something.
1:57:30It's a pound, 20 amp hours and 50 bucks.
1:57:35So you're sort of like, all right, well, if I
1:57:36need to carry something extra, I can get one
1:57:39of these things and then I'm sort of set.
1:57:40And, uh, anyway, it's such an, it's such a like
1:57:44wonky little area, but it's battery life is
1:57:46Battery life is the thing that affects us more.
1:57:48I mean, you know, network speed hasn't been solved,
1:57:50but you can get LTE in most places pretty good.
1:57:53And so battery is the next frontier to kind of resolve.
1:57:57- No, I definitely, I mean, there's no doubt about it
1:57:59that battery life is the biggest,
1:58:01it's the lagging technology at the moment.
1:58:05- It's fun too.
1:58:05I learned so much about watt hours and C, like the top number.
1:58:09There's a thing about like how much colums
1:58:11you can stick into a battery fast enough without damaging it
1:58:14and it's wild, like you get into that
1:58:17and it's like people spend a lot of time
1:58:18doing a lot of little formulas
1:58:20to make sure everything matches up correctly.
1:58:23- My sixth grade battery, or not battery,
1:58:25my sixth grade science fair project was on batteries.
1:58:27- That's really your time.
1:58:30- I did a poor job on it, I think I got like a B.
1:58:34I don't even think I got a B plus.
1:58:35- Look, my son's in sixth grade,
1:58:38one of his comrades did a hovercraft
1:58:40using a modified electric leaf blower
1:58:43and it actually hovers and carries 75 pounds.
1:58:45This is the science fairs today.
1:58:46- I really have asked my sixth grade science fair project.
1:58:50The test was not whether alkaline batteries lasted longer,
1:58:56that was self-evident, than regular.
1:59:00Remember at the time,
1:59:01all you can buy now are alkaline batteries.
1:59:03We're talking about like AA or C, those type of batteries.
1:59:06There were regular, there were heavy duty, quote unquote,
1:59:12and alkaline, like the Doracil and Energizer.
1:59:16And so my test wasn't whether they actually lasted longer,
1:59:18of course they did, it was whether you,
1:59:21at consumer prices, whether you were getting
1:59:23more bang for your buck with them.
1:59:25- Oh, clever.
1:59:26- And, well, it sounds clever, and it got,
1:59:28it was like good enough to get the thing approved,
1:59:30but it really turned out to be not a very exciting test.
1:59:34And it was actually devilishly hard,
1:59:35because of the way the test I devised
1:59:37was to use the same flashlight,
1:59:42and then turn the flashlight on, note the time,
1:59:44and then note the time it went off.
1:59:45But finding out what time a flashlight burned out is--
1:59:48- Oh my God, this is hilarious.
1:59:50This was a wire cutter's battery guy.
1:59:52He did a review with this exact same problem.
1:59:54They put a flashlight, and they were videotaping
1:59:56a flashlight pointing into a box,
1:59:58was how he ultimately did it, I think.
2:00:00- See, I didn't have a video camera, though.
2:00:02That is actually very clever.
2:00:03- You wouldn't have had a 12-hour videotape, either.
2:00:04- Right, I wouldn't have had a 12-hour videotape.
2:00:06And it got to the point where my parents got a little mad.
2:00:08I mean, this was not the--
2:00:09(laughing)
2:00:10I mean, this was not the this was not the most expensive scientific test that was ever performed
2:00:15But it did seem like I kept saying I need more better. Oh my god
2:00:18and so I kind of had to
2:00:21Triangulate like based on when it seemed it was going off in the middle of the night
2:00:26Okay, so if I started it at 5 p.m. And it went off in the middle of the night
2:00:29How about I start the next one at 9 in the morning before I go or at 8 in the morning before the school?
2:00:33And it was like petitioning my sister and my parents like every time you go buy this flashlight see if it's on
2:00:40One more thing to talk about batteries, batteries are so exciting. I know the listeners are delighted about it. There's a new kind of AA battery, a new kind of lithium battery you can get. It's not a lithium, it's called, what is it? Oh, I'm blanking on the name here. It's a nickel metal hydride. Oh, it's not lithium. What is it? There's new batteries you can get now that perform rechargeables that perform so much better than the old ones because they've changed the fundamental chemistry of them.
2:01:06So in the past you would get really terrible
2:01:09recharging performance and now you get,
2:01:13there's so much better because of this thing.
2:01:16So you get this, it cycles like 500 to 1,000 times.
2:01:20It'll maintain a charge longer,
2:01:24like all the things that used to drive you nuts
2:01:25about rechargeable batteries,
2:01:27the new generation now is avoiding that.
2:01:30- When Jonas was younger and he had a lot of kids toys,
2:01:33I did the right thing.
2:01:34I volunteered, I took this,
2:01:35I took this undertook this myself and I did the right thing and bought like 40
2:01:39double-a rechargeables and 40 triple-a for the toys that took the whole just a whole slew of these I think I got him from a
2:01:47Company call like green battery or something like that. That was oh, yeah
2:01:50I live it and a charger that would charge a bunch of them at once and then for all of his toys
2:01:54We used them but it's it quickly became clear that
2:01:57Boy, they ran out faster than like like it was so tempting to just buy the big pack of door ourselves and put put them
2:02:05in there.
2:02:06That's what we went from rechargeables to Costco alkalines and I always felt terrible.
2:02:09I'm like, "I'm destroying the earth because," instead of being able to use a few seconds
2:02:13of electricity because they weren't reliable.
2:02:16But over time, almost everything I have is lithium ion battery powered now anyway.
2:02:20It all has an internal battery.
2:02:21So I have very, very few things that require one.
2:02:24They seem to do really poorly in remote controls too for some reason.
2:02:27Because replacing the batteries in a remote seems like something that you should only
2:02:32have to do like, you know, like, I don't know, more than a year, right? I don't know. I haven't
2:02:38changed the battery in our remotes in a long time. Whereas when we were using those rechargeables,
2:02:43it seemed like it was like all the time.
2:02:45Yeah, this new generation, what are they called? They are their nickel metal hydride, nickel
2:02:51metal hydride, NIMH, low self discharge, LSD. I don't know where you'd heard LSD before.
2:03:00It doesn't seem like a problematic abbreviation
2:03:02to use at all.
2:03:03No.
2:03:03They last for sometimes, I think now it's
2:03:07they have months or even years where they'll
2:03:09maintain their charge.
2:03:11And they can do, like I say, hundreds to thousands
2:03:14plus cycles.
2:03:17And these are relatively new.
2:03:18So if you were buying batteries like three to five years ago,
2:03:21you'd be frustrated.
2:03:22And if you buy this generation and you have to carefully--
2:03:25Wirecutter is a good review of them.
2:03:27And you have to look for brands and types,
2:03:29because some of them vary even among capacities. They can be
2:03:31better or worse, but much better experience.
2:03:34All right, let me take one last break here and thank our final
2:03:36sponsor of the show. It's our good friends at fracture. You
2:03:38guys know fracture. They're the company that prints photos
2:03:40directly onto glass, you can go to fracture me.com. And if you
2:03:48use the code talk show 10, just talk show 10, you'll get 10% off
2:03:54your first order. The code is easy to remember talk show 10 10
2:03:58is the 10% you'll save off your order. Now here's the thing. The fracture pictures look
2:04:04great. They make awesome gifts. They make a great way to take the photos that you have
2:04:10on your phone in your iCloud account that you've never actually printed and put them
2:04:17into the analog world. It's the best way to do it because they print them right on glass.
2:04:21They ship in these amazing packages that have everything you need to hang them up on the
2:04:24wall, all included, so you don't need to frame them. They are a frame. It's just an edge-to-edge
2:04:29piece of glass that's ready to pop on the wall, prop up on your desk, put it on a mantle.
2:04:34Could not be easier, and you never have to worry about all the stupid little fiddly things
2:04:37you do when you get a regular printed photo on paper into a frame where it has to be perfectly
2:04:42aligned and then you seal the frame back up and it tilts off 2% and you have to open up
2:04:47the frame again and redirect it and try to get it to stick so it's perfectly aligned.
2:04:50forget it. You don't have to do any of that. You'll get a better looking image and a better
2:04:55quality and a much more impressive display from fracture and it's so it's better quality
2:05:03and it's easier. So you can't lose each fractures hand assembled and check for quality by their
2:05:10small team in Gainesville, Florida. They're great people, a great company and they really
2:05:14do in addition to having a great product, they really do offer great service. So just
2:05:17Go to fracture me calm and remember the code talk show 10 when you check out and you will save 10%
2:05:23Well, we should wrap up. We've been talking for a while anything else. What else is on the agenda?
2:05:28Anything else you think that they're gonna do at the event next week?
2:05:31Got that
2:05:32I wonder if they're gonna slipstream in maybe some kind of Wi-Fi update or cellular or something because I feel like the wire
2:05:37Wi-Fi quotes being pretty old. I think they sell a lot of it and
2:05:40Somebody's written about Wi-Fi a ton
2:05:44I'm like, they're kind of like two or three years behind some of the features in the marketplace. So I wonder I wonder what they'll do
2:05:50Did you see the new thing Walt Mossberg had a review of it
2:05:53It's called the e something and it's like a bunch of little pods that you put around your house to sort of create a network
2:05:58Eero I'm like not so hip on it because I feel like it's it's expensive
2:06:04I saw a review it with like this is great. I had a $200 Airport
2:06:08Eero Eero
2:06:12Eero Saarinen, I guess the great Finnish architect.
2:06:16Eero Saarinen, a great answer if you're doing
2:06:18either a trivial pursuit or crossword puzzles, E-E-R-O,
2:06:22Saarinen, he designed the dorm I lived in in college,
2:06:26which had no right angles.
2:06:27We hated it so much, so much.
2:06:28You couldn't put anything up against the wall.
2:06:30God damn it, Eero Saarinen.
2:06:31And it's beautiful.
2:06:32He designed the Dulles Airport.
2:06:34Oh, okay.
2:06:35I believe that's right.
2:06:36I'm saying that now, I don't know.
2:06:37But I think he's a famous architect.
2:06:40This has nothing to do with him.
2:06:41I hope they licensed the name.
2:06:42Uh, yes, he designed it anyway.
2:06:45So Euro.
2:06:45Yeah.
2:06:46So there, so I remember if you were, someone
2:06:47said, well, I had a $200 or $180, uh, Apple
2:06:50airport extreme and it didn't reach everywhere.
2:06:52So I bought three of these things and it was
2:06:53great on their $200 each.
2:06:55I'm thinking that doesn't actually
2:06:57prove that they're better.
2:06:58Like you need to do this side by side.
2:06:59So I don't know.
2:07:01I think their notion is they're trying to make,
2:07:02uh, it's, you know, it's simpler, they're
2:07:04small, they're intrusive and they think they
2:07:07automatically pair over wifi.
2:07:09So that's a nice idea compared to having to go into
2:07:12Configure, Crap, and Airport Utility.
2:07:15I mean, I've been writing about Airport Utility for like 12,
2:07:1815, I don't know, since it came out in 2001.
2:07:20And it's never been a great piece of software.
2:07:22It's gotten better, but it's not comprehensible.
2:07:24It's always done well compared to the competition, but it's--
2:07:27Correct, yes.
2:07:29I have a TP-Link Archer C7, which is one of the top-rated routers from,
2:07:34you know, not from Google or Apple.
2:07:36And it's like 90 bucks and has 802.11c and it's
2:07:39great and their interface is dogs lunch.
2:07:41Like I love them, but there's like 40,000
2:07:44options and it's, and it's like, there's no
2:07:46streamlined, like I want to do this thing.
2:07:49It's like, no, here, we're going to give you,
2:07:50we're going to throw every single thing we could
2:07:51put in the firmware at you.
2:07:52It's not great.
2:07:53That's not what people want.
2:07:54Right.
2:07:54A lot of them, it's almost like you're just
2:07:56opening a dot com file.
2:07:57Exactly.
2:07:58Vomiting dot com.
2:08:01Yeah.
2:08:01Uh, so there's, I mean, but I love the idea.
2:08:04So the Eero is, they're trying to get a
2:08:05they're trying to get a very high profit margin
2:08:08in order to take all the pain away,
2:08:10and there's market for that.
2:08:12You look at something like Nest Cam,
2:08:14Nest Cam is interesting because it's not,
2:08:16it's premium in the market,
2:08:17it's not actually that much more expensive
2:08:20than many competitors that offer similar features.
2:08:23It's a lot more competitive than the cheapo IP cameras
2:08:26that you have to do a ton of configuration for
2:08:28and don't have a cloud service.
2:08:29But Nest Cams was sold in, I think,
2:08:31the millions at this point because you plug it in
2:08:34and you're done, right?
2:08:35That's nice. I like that.
2:08:37I can't help but wonder. You've put the idea in my head.
2:08:41The Wi-Fi idea, I haven't heard anything like that, but it does seem like it might be overdue.
2:08:45And it's a technology that's constantly marched forward ever since introduction.
2:08:50And so therefore it seems like maybe it might be due.
2:08:54And it would tie into maybe just the basic home kit.
2:09:00Who knows? Maybe they have something.
2:09:02I'm not trying to get anybody's hopes up,
2:09:04but maybe they have some other kind of home kit,
2:09:06you know, stuff you plug into your house,
2:09:09stuff to announce.
2:09:10Just because it would be a good event to do it,
2:09:14because it's not going to be, you know,
2:09:16it doesn't seem like, clearly it's on campus,
2:09:19it's in their little town hall,
2:09:21so it's not gonna be a flagship event.
2:09:22There's no Blockbuster that's gonna be coming,
2:09:25otherwise they'd held it in a bigger venue.
2:09:27- Well, the fourth generation Apple TV,
2:09:29as I recollect, it has home kit hub features, right?
2:09:31it's got Bluetooth in it and whatever.
2:09:33And they haven't rolled that into the wifi devices.
2:09:37So I could see them doing,
2:09:39the other thing they could do
2:09:40is do some kind of simple setup like you do
2:09:42when the Apple TV works right,
2:09:43when that's worked, like hold your thing,
2:09:45hold your phone near the device,
2:09:46now you can set it up.
2:09:47That's really cool.
2:09:48And when that worked for me with the Apple TV,
2:09:50I really liked it.
2:09:51I could see them adding Bluetooth.
2:09:53- When it worked for you.
2:09:54- When it worked, I know.
2:09:55I got it to work once.
2:09:57I like my Apple TV a lot more
2:09:58now that I can use the remote app.
2:09:59Like I use it a lot more since they updated to support that.
2:10:04But Wi-Fi stuff is often slipstreamed in,
2:10:06like they'll put in a press release and not announce it
2:10:09in a March or April event.
2:10:10I think the last few generations of real improvements.
2:10:13- Yeah, and it might make for something
2:10:16that they could demo.
2:10:17'Cause that's what I kind of feel like they might be hit up
2:10:21is just something that they can demo on stage
2:10:24to fill an hour.
2:10:25- Yeah, and HomeKit has, I feel like HomeKit
2:10:28Like I think they expected to have more a year ago
2:10:31to offer and I don't know what the deal is.
2:10:34Like I mean, it's harder to corral a lot of third parties
2:10:37together and Apple didn't want to take center stage
2:10:39in making an ecosystem.
2:10:41They want to make the hubs, which makes sense,
2:10:43but it feels, I mean, USB-C is only right now
2:10:46starting to hit the mainstream and Apple in that case too
2:10:48did not take the center stage in building an ecosystem.
2:10:51They built stuff you could plug in or plug into
2:10:54and I'm just already only now reviewing the whole thing
2:10:57I'm only now reviewing some USB-C docs for Macworld
2:11:01that do pass-through power,
2:11:03and this is the first generation of those
2:11:04that have done those,
2:11:05are just coming out now a year later.
2:11:07So I think Apple, I don't think it's ill-advised.
2:11:10They shouldn't be focused,
2:11:11they shouldn't be building a USB-C extra devices
2:11:14and adapters and crap.
2:11:15They should be focused on the core thing.
2:11:17They shouldn't be building home sensors,
2:11:19'cause that's not,
2:11:19they should be putting the value in the right place.
2:11:21But I think they're seeing the penalty of the market
2:11:23not leaping to their needs.
2:11:26- Yeah, I think it's the penalty of when they don't do it
2:11:30all themselves, sometimes nothing happens.
2:11:32'Cause it seems like, it just seems like HomeKit
2:11:34is one of those things that is now,
2:11:36I think all of us have kind of loosely filed it under,
2:11:39or we've at least started shifting it
2:11:40towards the whatever happened to pile, right?
2:11:44- Yes. - Yeah, whatever happened
2:11:45to HomeKit. - I remember.
2:11:47- You got these little bits and pieces that comes out,
2:11:49but there's nothing comprehensive.
2:11:50And after bugs and nest cams and nest thermostats
2:11:55and other things like IA and some of the security things
2:11:58that are coming out, the FTC putting action,
2:12:01you know, they didn't order against a company
2:12:03that didn't properly secure its equipment.
2:12:05Strange how the FTC is giving penalties
2:12:08for not securing your devices against intrusion.
2:12:11- Which brings us full circle.
2:12:13- Exactly, odd thing there.
2:12:15- That's a pretty good guess.
2:12:18And I guess the other wild card would be
2:12:20if they come out with new MacBooks of some sort.
2:12:23- Yeah, it's been a year since the 12-inch MacBook,
2:12:25so it would be timed, but I have one, I don't know.
2:12:27I love mine, I think I'm, I don't know if I'm one of the few
2:12:30but it's my favorite computer since my Duo 210.
2:12:33I don't love the keyboard, I cope with the keyboard,
2:12:36but I love my Duo 210 and I think I love this one
2:12:38as much as that.
2:12:39In between, I had a lot of bigger laptops
2:12:41I didn't love quite as much.
2:12:43Titanium I liked a lot, but.
2:12:44- Well, I don't know, it just seems to me like,
2:12:47and I know that, I'm just not cued into Intel's roadmap
2:12:50like a lot of people are,
2:12:51and I know that a lot of it hangs on that,
2:12:53but it just seems like a device
2:12:55that you can kind of knock for being too slow.
2:12:59Whatever improvements Intel has gotten in a year
2:13:04would be worth putting out a new revision of the product.
2:13:07- It's true, although I've laid out like a 1200 page book
2:13:11in InDesign on my MacBook.
2:13:13I've edit audio in Audition, Adobe Audition
2:13:16with multiple tracks.
2:13:17It can't do real-time effects,
2:13:18but it lets me edit at least and play back in real time
2:13:21without applying all the effects.
2:13:22And I like the dense screen.
2:13:23I wanted to replace my air, which was underpowered
2:13:26and didn't have a retina.
2:13:27And this is the closest thing I could get
2:13:29that was like affordable and met it.
2:13:30And a year later, I'm still pretty delighted with it.
2:13:33- Yeah.
2:13:34Well, we'll know.
2:13:36We'll be at the show.
2:13:38I don't know who knows the famous last words,
2:13:40but I might try to do like a mini episode of the show,
2:13:45not live from the event,
2:13:47but maybe record something ad hoc
2:13:49with any anybody else who's going to be there who will give me five or 10
2:13:53minutes of their time,
2:13:53sort of a do my thoughts and observations on the event right afterwards Monday
2:13:57afternoon.
2:13:58There'll be a lot of people, you know, there I've been seeing, uh, uh, I'm not,
2:14:02I'm not going, I'm Seattle. I'll be covering it remotely for Mac world, but, uh,
2:14:05Susie Oaks will be there and okay. Mr. Jason style, I'm sure.
2:14:09And Serenity Caldwell, I understand. So it'll be the old gang.
2:14:12We'll be there in different guises.
2:14:13People who are readily volunteer will readily volunteer to be on a podcast.
2:14:17- Exactly, yeah, they don't know anything about podcasts.
2:14:19- This is a real stretch for you, Jason.
2:14:21- Exactly.
2:14:22- But would you consider being on a podcast?
2:14:25- He only records, I think, 15 a week now, the poor guy.
2:14:28- Yeah.
2:14:28(laughing)
2:14:30- I don't know if I'm exaggerating.
2:14:31- I'm looking forward to it.
2:14:32I know it's not a blockbuster event,
2:14:34but I almost feel like these are the ones that are a little,
2:14:36they're more interesting strategically to me,
2:14:38because the bigger ones are a little bit
2:14:40more obvious strategically.
2:14:42- Yeah, this will be fun.
2:14:43I think I love that we don't know for sure as much,
2:14:46despite the leaks, the fact that there's just not as much,
2:14:49I mean, there's a lot of stuff known, but not seen.
2:14:52It's kind of interesting.
2:14:53- Yeah, totally.
2:14:54Glenn Fleischmann, anybody who wants to see your work,
2:14:58I mean, you're everywhere.
2:15:00You're at Macworld now?
2:15:02- I've been, yeah, I read a lot for them.
2:15:03I got a book on Slack that's coming out soon.
2:15:06We're syndicating it at Tidbits.
2:15:08They have a neat model where the first two chapters
2:15:10are up there now for free, if you go to tidbits.com,
2:15:12about using Slack, because a lot of people,
2:15:14a lot of people your age and mine, John,
2:15:16They've been told they have to use Slack.
2:15:18Now Slack's fun to use, but I keep coming across
2:15:20people like, okay, I got to use this new tool.
2:15:23How does it work?
2:15:23And like, all right.
2:15:24So first book is about that.
2:15:26It could be the first two chapters.
2:15:27It'll be out in a few weeks, the full book.
2:15:29And then also a smaller compendium.
2:15:31Uh, you know, I got name checked, uh, at S South
2:15:33by Southwest, I wasn't there.
2:15:35People start telling me Stuart Butterfield's
2:15:37mentioning your name on stage.
2:15:38I'm like, what did I do?
2:15:39What did I know?
2:15:41Like, what did I know?
2:15:42I've known Stuart in passing for like 15 years.
2:15:44I'm like, what did I do?
2:15:46Just full circle, very briefly, I'd mentioned in
2:15:48passing Roman Mars, the host of 99% invisible,
2:15:51great podcast.
2:15:51He says something about the future of articles
2:15:54reporting on business will be, um, people posting
2:15:56Slack screen captures, right.
2:15:58And I respond, oh, well, you know, they'll just
2:16:01put steganographic, um, pixel identifiers,
2:16:03Slack will, so when you take a screen capture,
2:16:05it'll be able to identify it.
2:16:06So Stuart on stage says something like, Glenn
2:16:10Fleishman mentioned this, that we're not going to
2:16:11do this.
2:16:12It's like, oh, thank God.
2:16:13But it was very funny.
2:16:13I was like, why am I being taught?
2:16:15What did I say?
2:16:16It's like, it's just saying that they will not be
2:16:18inserting a security identifier.
2:16:20- I did not know you were writing a book on Slack.
2:16:22That is fantastic.
2:16:23It is a great idea.
2:16:25- It's fun.
2:16:26I love, it's really great.
2:16:28And I'm in well-timed. - I think it's well-timed.
2:16:29- Five Slack teams, yeah.
2:16:30So that's, but people can read two chapters now,
2:16:32and then there's more.
2:16:33We'll have the book out in a few weeks.
2:16:34But yes, find me at Macworld, find me at tidbits.com,
2:16:38and more to come.
2:16:40- And of course at Twitter,
2:16:43the very quiet, seldomly updated @Glenn_ account.
2:16:48- I took two weeks off, it was a good break.
2:16:53I did, I had no tweeting for two weeks, it was really good.
2:16:55- Was it, did it hurt?
2:16:57- No, it was actually, it was good, it was good.
2:16:59It's interesting, being on Twitter during the political
2:17:02season is very entertaining, but I kind of, you know,
2:17:04backed off a little from it, now coming back,
2:17:06I'm enjoying it again.
2:17:07- Glenn has, Glenn has over 401,000 followers.
2:17:12431 tweets. You took the break right at the 400,000 mark, right?
2:17:16I did. I essentially auctioned off the tweet to raise money for Planned Parenthood. And I raised,
2:17:20I think people contributed almost $3,000 and someone got my 400,000th tweet as a result. So
2:17:25that was, that was my little taking a break fundraiser.
2:17:28I just know that right now there's a lot of people, we've been going a long time,
2:17:31it's a long show. People can tell it's over. They're like, oh, come on, 400,000 tweets. This
2:17:34is when, you know, these guys are starved for oxygen and now Gruber's getting goofy
2:17:38and he's making shit up. And I'm telling you right now, if you go to Glenn Strutt,
2:17:42That count is 401,000.
2:17:46I will leave the math of dividing the number of hours in a day and the number of years
2:17:51that Twitter has existed.
2:17:53I will leave that up to you.
2:17:54I'll leave it as an exercise to you.
2:17:55Fire up Peacock on your iPhone and get Glenn's tweets per day output.
2:18:01He's probably tweeted.
2:18:02I'll bet you've tweeted during the show.
2:18:03I'll bet if I look right now that you've tweeted while we recorded this show.
2:18:06I'm withheld.
2:18:07But you know, Snark actually drains...
2:18:09I'm respectful of your time, John.
2:18:12(laughs)
2:18:13I'm listening intently.
2:18:15Slack has taken some of my tweeting away
2:18:17because some of the people I used to communicate
2:18:19with a lot on Twitter, we now have are in Slack rooms,
2:18:22so the incomparable network.
2:18:23- It is absolutely.
2:18:24- I understand the Relay FM has a big chat room.
2:18:27There's a lot of the podcast networks
2:18:29'cause hosts on podcast networks all over the place.
2:18:32One thing I like about Slack,
2:18:33just for those listening too,
2:18:34it's the fact that you can use it free
2:18:36with like up to 10,000 people and get most of the features
2:18:39is a really amazing freemium model.
2:18:41I think they have like 1.8 million of their users,
2:18:45our daily users are in that mode,
2:18:46and like 600,000 are paying for service.
2:18:49So most of the Slack teams are free,
2:18:51and it's just nice to have a forum that's private
2:18:54where you can have these discussions.
2:18:55- Well, I will make sure to get the link to the book
2:18:59in the show notes.
2:19:00But Glenn, thank you for your time.
2:19:01This was a great discussion. - Great, it's been
2:19:03a great pleasure, John, thank you very much.
2:19:04- Talk to you soon.
2:19:05[ Silence ]