Podcast Search

The Talk Show

134: ‘Field Sobriety Test’ With Guy English

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Yeah, we could get right into it.

0:00:01So how long-- when did you--

0:00:02you had the dev kit for Apple TV?

0:00:05Yes.

0:00:08And what's the story?

0:00:09I mean, I guess it doesn't matter.

0:00:11I'm curious, I did not get the dev kit.

0:00:13And I guess I should have signed up for it.

0:00:15I just assumed that I would get a review unit.

0:00:19But they didn't.

0:00:20I didn't get one until yesterday.

0:00:22So we're recording here on Friday, October 30.

0:00:25I got mine from Apple yesterday on the 29th.

0:00:28And I don't think I've touched one.

0:00:30Yeah, no I haven't since the event last month.

0:00:32- Yeah, you got kind of a host bid on that.

0:00:35'Cause a lot of press outlets just signed up and got one.

0:00:40- Yeah, well, is that what happened?

0:00:42But I think a lot of them did get review units too.

0:00:44And I just, you know, it seems haphazard.

0:00:47Doesn't seem like there was any rhyme or reason to it.

0:00:49Like who got one and who didn't?

0:00:51Like TechCrunch didn't get it until yesterday either.

0:00:55- Oh yeah? - Yeah.

0:00:57I don't think I don't know if Renee got one. No, he didn't

0:01:00Serenity did. Oh, really? Well, she had access to one I know that. Ah

0:01:05Yeah, it's such a weird thing. Like it's meta. It's so inside baseball, but I guess that's what the point of podcasts is. Yeah

0:01:13Is that it was the least secretive device?

0:01:18Give once it was unveiled, you know, so there's it was unveiled on stage in September

0:01:24I think they did a pretty good job keeping it under wraps.

0:01:26Everybody knew that a new Apple TV was coming,

0:01:28but nobody had screenshots or anything.

0:01:31Nobody knew what the remote was exactly like.

0:01:35No, it hurt stuff, but nothing.

0:01:38I mean, I know people who'd seen them,

0:01:40but nobody even told me what they look like.

0:01:42Right, but then they started taking the developer requests the next day,

0:01:48and some people started getting them a week later.

0:01:51And I guess you were under an NDA based on your ADC account,

0:01:56and that you weren't supposed to write about it, but it certainly wasn't a well-kept secret.

0:02:01There was an additional NDA that came with the devkit.

0:02:05Like a new NDA.

0:02:08Yeah, that told you not to do anything with this devkit.

0:02:10Right.

0:02:13I'd like to talk about it.

0:02:13My favorite...

0:02:15It just never works.

0:02:16Well, the best example of that would be the iFixit guys

0:02:17who signed up for the devkit, agreed to an NDA,

0:02:20And that as soon as it came, they took it apart and published their take-apart.

0:02:25I was pretty frustrated, actually.

0:02:33Defqits are a very rare thing for Apple to do.

0:02:38Right.

0:02:40And it's like, we don't want to piss them off and make them not do it.

0:02:41I think it's great that they did this.

0:02:45Yeah, I think it's great, too.

0:02:47I think it was a mistake to sell them for a buck.

0:02:47They should have been like double, triple the price of what the actual shipping unit was going to be.

0:02:51Yeah, why do you think they did it that way?

0:02:53Well, I think they wanted everybody to get as frictionless as possible

0:02:58and encourage people to work on their awesome platform.

0:03:02They probably have to charge a dollar for some reason, you know?

0:03:06Yeah, like maybe in a way that Steve Jobs had to take a $1 salary,

0:03:11I think there was some kind of legal requirement.

0:03:14Yeah, accounting or...

0:03:16pay your CEO or something like that. I swear that it was something like that.

0:03:21And maybe it was something like that too where they have to sell it for some amount of money.

0:03:24Just to account for it in some way other than...

0:03:28Anyway, so...

0:03:30Welcome to the talk show, America's favorite accounting...

0:03:33Accounting...

0:03:37talk show.

0:03:39We're sponsored this week by Salesforce.

0:03:42No, so anyway though, they had these out there.

0:03:44Lots of journalists and writers bought them,

0:03:47even though they weren't going to develop apps on them.

0:03:49And I guess they mostly stuck to the NDA,

0:03:50but it wasn't like it was tough to get.

0:03:52But then the reviews all, there was clearly

0:03:56like some number of people,

0:03:57just like with every other Apple device,

0:03:59iPhones and iPads, that they got pre-release access to them,

0:04:04probably about a week before.

0:04:06And then the embargo was clearly,

0:04:11I think it was six o'clock Eastern on Wednesday,

0:04:14'cause all of a sudden--

0:04:15- And what he had to review up.

0:04:17- Right, and I was actually out at having dinner

0:04:20with our friend Whiskus and Brady Harron,

0:04:25you know, the guy from Hello Internet.

0:04:29He's over here in the States.

0:04:30And we were out and it was like all of a sudden,

0:04:33we were talking about the fact that there were no reviews

0:04:35of the Apple TV and then we were at dinner

0:04:38and then all of a sudden it was like,

0:04:40of a sudden there were like 15 reviews of Apple TV. But it was weird like, you know,

0:04:45iMore wasn't on that list, TechCrunch wasn't on the list. It's very strange.

0:04:51I guess the actual was, which makes sense, I think.

0:04:54Yeah.

0:04:55It's like a lot of media stuff that they cover. And Christina's pretty... she's been kicking

0:05:00ass recently.

0:05:01Yeah, I just actually, just before we started recording, I actually just linked to her review.

0:05:04It's the only one I've read completely and just linked to it because I thought she nailed

0:05:09I was like boy, that's every single thing there is about it. Yeah. Yeah, and she's been getting good interviews and stuff recently - yeah

0:05:16Yeah, cuz well who she disinterview Johnny I've

0:05:20Johnny I've and I'm gonna blank on it now. I

0:05:23Don't know should have been a note right well, and she did and she got to she's the one who got access to

0:05:29when Tim Cook did the meet-and-greet with the

0:05:34the teenagers at WWDC

0:05:36Yeah, she went and covered that. And I think that was an impromptu conversation, really.

0:05:44I think it might have been, but I think it was right place, right time.

0:05:49Yeah, yeah, exactly. That's good reporting.

0:05:53So, I know you've only had it a day. I've had mine longer.

0:06:01I guess I can talk about that. But whatever. I have.

0:06:05Well, I am actually mad.

0:06:09Because if they don't do another dev kit, I'm going to be sad.

0:06:13This is my question for you. My question, before we go on to it, is what was your experience like?

0:06:17Have you been able to upgrade from the betas of the OS to the GM?

0:06:22Yeah. It's dead easy.

0:06:26But it didn't require using the diagnostic port, or it did?

0:06:30does if you can't wear by diagnostic port I mean they'd USB port but they

0:06:34even tell you in the instructions they're like USB C port and then they're

0:06:38like this is only used for diagnostics yeah well you know flashing in OS on to

0:06:44your things counts I guess you just go to the website you download the package

0:06:49like the OS package and then you connect iTunes to it and it shows up in iTunes

0:06:56And then you just, what is it, like option click restore,

0:07:01and use the package you've got.

0:07:03- Right, so it's exactly like doing it with a phone.

0:07:06- Yeah, it's identical.

0:07:06- So you connect it to your Mac with USB,

0:07:11like when you connect a phone,

0:07:13and then you can just do it from the iTunes app.

0:07:15- Yeah, and it's a USB-C, which is like,

0:07:18one of the first times I've been super thankful

0:07:20that I've owned a MacBook, 'cause I'm like,

0:07:22"Oh, look, it just works."

0:07:23I don't have to worry about anything.

0:07:26Yeah, so I guess if your computer was a MacBook, the new MacBook One port thing, you would

0:07:33have to have a USB-C to USB-C cable.

0:07:36Yeah, that's what I did.

0:07:38Oh, really?

0:07:39Yeah, yeah.

0:07:40So I've got a...

0:07:42I mean, when I bought the MacBook, I bought two little adapter things, like one for USB-C

0:07:47and one that turns USB-C into...

0:07:49It's the HDMI out, and it has a USB port.

0:07:53So when did the App Store go live?

0:07:58Yesterday.

0:08:02Okay.

0:08:03I couldn't tell you what time, but I think about noon.

0:08:04Because what we had to do was, so we had a GM candidate for the past few days.

0:08:06Then to get the App Store, and this was kind of confusing, we needed to re-download the OS

0:08:14and flash that back onto the device for the App Store to show up.

0:08:20But if I'm not mistaken, I think the version numbers are identical.

0:08:23Huh? I wonder what they flipped one switch or I don't know exactly what they did,

0:08:28but whatever. Like right now, mine is,

0:08:31is if I just got out of a box from a store.

0:08:33Huh? So it's exactly the same.

0:08:39As mine setting is. Yeah.

0:08:41All right. So first run experience. Pretty cool.

0:08:48the way that they do the, if you want to,

0:08:52just unlock your iPhone and get it near the Apple TV.

0:08:57- That is the way computers should work, like all of them.

0:09:02If you can do it with Macs, do it with Macs, just do it.

0:09:06- And it doesn't transfer everything,

0:09:10but it certainly gets you most of the way there.

0:09:13And just getting it so that it's on your WiFi is huge.

0:09:17Yeah.

0:09:17Like you just wave your, it's basically magic.

0:09:21And I know that's way overused when you talk

0:09:22about Apple stuff, but you take your phone, you

0:09:24put it close to your box and the older ones did

0:09:26this too, but it's just cool to have a new thing.

0:09:30Um, and it would just say, yeah, connecting to

0:09:33the network and it logs you in, it's got all

0:09:35the passwords, uh, it's got your iCloud

0:09:38information.

0:09:38So your, uh, your, what are you calling it now?

0:09:43Apple ID.

0:09:44Your Apple ID.

0:09:45Thank you.

0:09:46Yeah.

0:09:46All your Apple ID stuff is over. So you've got all the Game Center stuff set up.

0:09:51You've got your photos. All of that is just done.

0:09:55And it's amazing. Because passwords are a pain in the ass to type.

0:10:00Anyway. Let alone on a crazy keyboard thing.

0:10:04I did have to enter my Apple ID password, though, one time to enable purchases.

0:10:13Yeah, I think I did that too.

0:10:17And I can see why. It's sort of like, I think the same logic

0:10:21the way that when you restart your iPhone, you have to enter the password

0:10:25once before you can go back to just using touch ID.

0:10:29Yeah, I think the notion is that you can unlock the device, but if you're

0:10:33going to do any real monetary damage, it wants to make

0:10:37sure that you are who you say you are.

0:10:41- I wonder, you know, and I, yeah, it's like they,

0:10:44before you can do, yeah, exactly what you said,

0:10:47monetary damage, you've really gotta enter your password.

0:10:51I guess I can see the logic behind that,

0:10:53but entering a password on the goddamn TV is so,

0:10:55it's still such a pain in the ass.

0:10:57I still am tempted to suggest that maybe you should be able

0:11:00to use Touch ID on your phone, but there's, you know,

0:11:04I guess, you know what I mean?

0:11:08Like if it's somehow, if somehow it would,

0:11:11it would send you an alert.

0:11:13Like the way that like with our family sharing,

0:11:15if Jonas wants to get an app,

0:11:18me and Amy get these alerts that say,

0:11:21hey, Jonas, who's a member of, you know,

0:11:23a kid in your family sharing plan wants to get this app,

0:11:26whatever the name of the app is, is this okay?

0:11:28And actually, I guess I think they actually stopped

0:11:33letting you use touch ID for that though,

0:11:34now that I think about it.

0:11:35I think now you have to enter your password on the phone.

0:11:38- Hmm. - Hmm.

0:11:40I guess maybe what I wish you could do with the Apple TV, and maybe you can, is maybe somehow use the...

0:11:45maybe you can... can you still use the old remote app to enter passwords?

0:11:48I think the old remote app is bust.

0:11:52The old remote, physical remote, works, which is interesting.

0:11:55Oh, does it? The IR one?

0:11:57No, I didn't know that.

0:11:58Yeah, I did it by accident and it totally worked. Look at that.

0:12:01Until you start tapping and clicking and dragging your finger around.

0:12:04Exactly.

0:12:05That's actually funny.

0:12:07Yeah, I don't know about that.

0:12:10So, after you enter that password, then they ask you,

0:12:13"Do you want to use this password?"

0:12:15"Do you want me to prompt you for the password?" "Never?"

0:12:19I don't know what it is. I think it's like, yeah, it's like

0:12:24your three options are

0:12:26"Don't ever ask me for my password again. Just let me buy stuff."

0:12:30Which, I don't know about you, but

0:12:32that's what I do. Yeah, well that's what I do too, and I'm lucky. I definitely

0:12:36understand why some parents wouldn't be able to do that, but Jonas is super trustworthy

0:12:39with stuff like that. And even if he decided to risk it, he's only going to get away with

0:12:45it once.

0:12:45Exactly.

0:12:46But it's so much more convenient, and I'm not worried, you know what I mean? Unlike

0:12:53a device that's in your pocket that you might leave in a cab or something like that, your

0:12:56Apple TV is not leaving your home.

0:12:57It's in your living room. It's a safe place.

0:13:00Right. If somebody who I don't trust is operating my Apple TV, I've got bigger problems now.

0:13:05than if they're going to buy movies that I don't want.

0:13:09Wouldn't that be like the ultimate dick move for a burglar?

0:13:13Before he disconnects your Apple TV to rip it off and steal your TV set,

0:13:17before he takes it, he just quick logs in

0:13:21and buys some shitty movies. Like, subscribes you to all the Adam Sandler movies

0:13:25or something like that. And then leaves the house. So not only did you

0:13:29get burgled, you got stuck footing a bill for a bunch of movies you didn't like.

0:13:33That actually sounds like a scene out of an Adam Sandler movie.

0:13:36I think we're onto something here.

0:13:41It buys you a bunch of albums on Apple Music that you don't want to.

0:13:49It signs you up to Apple Music.

0:13:52So anyway, first run experience. I feel like I've already complained too much.

0:14:03I still want it to be better, but it's so good. It is such a better experience than any other first-run experience I've ever seen.

0:14:11So I've done it manually quite a bit, because earlier betas didn't have...

0:14:18Well, I think they had it, but they told you it was pretty flaky, so I didn't use it.

0:14:22And man, it's a pain in the ass when you...

0:14:25Sorry, I shouldn't say it's a pain in the ass. Comparatively, it's night and day.

0:14:29I mean, laboriously entering in all your email addresses

0:14:33and you gotta do it for a few different things.

0:14:36It's a huge pain in the ass.

0:14:38You have a wifi network, that sucks.

0:14:40This was amazing.

0:14:42It was the first time I tried it yesterday.

0:14:45It was the first time I tried the Bluetooth Magic

0:14:47and it was great.

0:14:48- We know some of the people who work on Apple TV

0:14:54and have for a while and I know that a couple of them

0:14:56have been, you know, personally, take it personally

0:14:59that they want this experience to be better for years.

0:15:02'Cause I know one of the features the old Apple TV had,

0:15:03I actually don't know if the new one still supports it,

0:15:05but remember how the old Apple TV

0:15:07would let you pair a Bluetooth keyboard?

0:15:10- Yeah.

0:15:11- And then you could use that to enter passwords

0:15:14and stuff like that the first time, just to,

0:15:15if you wanted to.

0:15:16And I thought that's a great idea,

0:15:19and I'm so glad that they did it,

0:15:21but I never, I've never once actually done it.

0:15:23Because it always seems to me like,

0:15:25If I'm already at the couch and I've got the stupid remote in my hand,

0:15:29where by stupid remote I mean the old remote,

0:15:32and in my mind the pain of just sitting there and pecking away at the on-screen keyboard to enter my password,

0:15:40as much as it annoys me, it doesn't annoy me enough to go up to my office,

0:15:44get a Bluetooth keyboard, come downstairs, pair it, and go through that.

0:15:48Yeah, even if you had one lying around in your living room, I'd find it annoying.

0:15:52Half the time when I watch TV, it's because I want to stop doing my work, which involves typing on a keyboard.

0:15:59You know what I mean? I just don't want a keyboard anywhere near me.

0:16:02I will hunt and peck with that stupid controller if I have to.

0:16:05I never really wanted to pair any Bluetooth stuff up to it. It's cool you could do it, though.

0:16:11Some of the stuff that works automatically really impressed me.

0:16:16Without me having to configure it at all, the volume up, volume down buttons

0:16:21automatically controlled the volume on my TV.

0:16:25- Yeah, interestingly, it does it on your TV too.

0:16:28Not, you know what I mean?

0:16:30Rather than increasing and decreasing the volume

0:16:32coming out of the back of your set top box

0:16:34out of the Apple TV, it's doing it,

0:16:37like you see your TV UI come up when it does it.

0:16:40- Exactly, right.

0:16:41- And I think that those IR things

0:16:45have like a standard set of actions

0:16:47that most equipment takes.

0:16:50So I think that that's how it figured it out.

0:16:54But it was a pleasant surprise.

0:16:56It was, man, I used to hate,

0:16:58I mean, we're complaining about very fresh world problems here,

0:17:00but I used to hate having to find the other one

0:17:01more controlled just to lower the volume.

0:17:03- Yeah, so for me, it actually,

0:17:05I was very impressed that it worked,

0:17:07and it does exactly what you said.

0:17:08It shows my pioneer UI.

0:17:10You know, and so you get this,

0:17:15all of a sudden you have this, it is ugly.

0:17:17- It's ugly, it's ugly.

0:17:18At the event, it was so funny, at the Apple event in September

0:17:21when they were showing this, whenever anybody would--

0:17:23I forget what brand of TVs they were using.

0:17:26They were, of course, all identical.

0:17:28But whatever brand it was-- and maybe it was Panasonic.

0:17:30But it doesn't matter.

0:17:31Somebody liked Panasonic.

0:17:32When you'd hit volume up and volume down,

0:17:34and you'd see the onscreen interface for the volume,

0:17:36the Apple, the product marketing people who was ever there

0:17:39supervising the demo would always and every time say,

0:17:43that's not our UI.

0:17:45That's the TV set.

0:17:46So they'd try to spin it.

0:17:47It was like this-- and of course, it's just like always

0:17:50with the Apple product marketing people.

0:17:52It was a rehearsed line.

0:17:53So I'm not quoting it exactly right.

0:17:55But it amused me because it was perfectly calibrated

0:17:59to do two things.

0:18:01One, it was setting it up as, hey, this is a cool feature.

0:18:05Our remote will talk to your TV.

0:18:07And then two, it was excusing the jankiness

0:18:11of the onscreen graphics.

0:18:12Like, this is-- don't--

0:18:13It's not our fault.

0:18:14Do not think that we designed this little crazy blue bar that shows you what the volume is at right now.

0:18:19Yeah.

0:18:21That's cool. It's a good feature.

0:18:22Also, it makes a lot of sense to do it that way because there's no synchronization problem then between

0:18:29what people are expecting from their television remote control and what the volume of the Apple TV device is.

0:18:34If you hit mute on your old TV remote, it's going to mute.

0:18:41I think it's just good to have one less level of confusion about what the output is actually going to be.

0:18:48So for me, I was impressed that that worked. But it actually is useless because I don't use the volume from my TV.

0:18:55I have this little box from Bose that powers the speakers on our TV.

0:19:01So we have to use this Bose remote control.

0:19:03And the Bose thing is a little... I guess you'd call it a receiver, but it's even smaller than the Apple TV.

0:19:09It's just this tiny little black box that's like a little puck

0:19:13that the speakers are plugged into

0:19:17And so you can you make the TV learn the remote yeah

0:19:22No, yeah, so you go to Apple in the Apple TV

0:19:27you say it's you go to remotes, and it's like do you want to control a different device and

0:19:30The setup for this was I was like oh what am I?

0:19:35Figured that they wouldn't do remember the old way it would be like what brand you have and if it's like

0:19:39Bose, they're like, "Try these codes, 857, 863, and 877."

0:19:44'Cause those are the ones that Bose typically uses.

0:19:49And if those don't work, well, maybe try this one.

0:19:54I knew it wouldn't be like that, but it was so easy.

0:19:56So what they said is they say,

0:19:59"If you wanna control the volume on a different device

0:20:01"using your Apple TV, okay, go get your other remote

0:20:06"from the manufacturer of your other device."

0:20:09and press down and hold volume up until this line is filled.

0:20:14And so you just press and hold the volume up

0:20:16on our other remote and takes about two or three seconds

0:20:19and then like a progress bar fills up.

0:20:21It's sort of like the, it's similar to the equivalent

0:20:25of when you're training touch ID with a new fingerprint.

0:20:28And then they're like, okay, got it.

0:20:30Now do volume down and just keep holding volume down

0:20:33until we tell you to stop.

0:20:34And it takes about two or three seconds

0:20:36and then you're done, that's it.

0:20:38and then all of a sudden your Apple TV,

0:20:40my Apple TV remote instead of controlling my TV's remote,

0:20:43controls my receiver's volume.

0:20:46- That's great.

0:20:46- Yeah, it really is great.

0:20:48- Piece of cake, 'cause these things

0:20:50are such a hassle usually, so.

0:20:52- Yeah, and that's one of those things that I really do,

0:20:55I'd love to hear the war stories

0:20:57from the team that did it, 'cause you just know

0:20:58that getting that to work on, you know,

0:21:0230 or 40 different brands of consumer electronic devices,

0:21:05you just know that it's as screwy

0:21:08as when you talk to people who work on email clients about the different IMAP servers out there and stuff like that.

0:21:13You just know it's probably even worse.

0:21:15Yeah. It's a good way of doing it though. It's cool. Anyway, so that's awesome.

0:21:20So within minutes, you had your whole setup working.

0:21:23Yeah. The other thing I had to do, and it makes sense, and I only noticed it when I first started playing a couple of games.

0:21:30You remember the game Cannibal?

0:21:33Yeah.

0:21:34So that's there and it it plays really good on TV

0:21:38But the one thing I noticed was it was the first game and the only one so far that I noticed that it it goes

0:21:46Corner to corner. So like the score was cut off by overscan

0:21:49hmm, and

0:21:52I

0:21:53Jonas was with me and it was so I it's like it and so I went into settings

0:21:57I thought maybe I could fix on Apple TV and then I realized like the settings

0:22:01There is a section where it talks about something with overscan.

0:22:04But then the settings explains you've got to change it on your TV.

0:22:07Yeah, it's a TV setting that they crop around the edges there.

0:22:10Right, and that made all the sense in the world.

0:22:12Of course the Apple TV isn't sending...

0:22:15- Cropped image. - Right, a cropped image to the TV.

0:22:17It's the TV that's doing it.

0:22:19And then it's like, "Oh, God, now I'm stuck going into the goofy Pioneer image."

0:22:25Or the goofy little computer that's built into my TV set from Pioneer.

0:22:30and it's horrible. It's so confusing. But then Jonas was with me and thankfully reminded me that

0:22:35we had solved the exact same problem with the PS4 when we got it for Christmas last year.

0:22:41Oh cool. It wasn't until like PC mode or something.

0:22:44Exactly. That's exactly it. You put it in PC mode, which is sort of... I understand it,

0:22:48but there's no way a normal person would understand it. I understand what they're

0:22:51saying though. They're saying this is not an analog video device. This is a computer that

0:22:57that is sending a pixel-per-pixel precise image

0:23:01to what it considers more like a PC monitor than a TV.

0:23:06So once we did that, then it was perfect.

0:23:09- That's cool.

0:23:11Did the colors change at all?

0:23:13- No, not by doing that.

0:23:15No, it really just changed--

0:23:18- TV's mannequin.

0:23:19- So crazy.

0:23:21So much old stuff built in there.

0:23:22There's so much, what would you call it, technical debt?

0:23:25- Yeah.

0:23:26the whole reason for over over scanning it made all the sense in the world in

0:23:30the CRT era yeah but it makes no sense at all and when everything's digital and

0:23:36it's crazy that everything always defaults to the under scan over scan I

0:23:41guess yeah did that make sense yeah did you do the same thing did you have to

0:23:48change yours to PC mode I didn't have to but maybe you just haven't noticed

0:23:53Maybe you haven't noticed, but I did play "Cannibalt."

0:23:55Huh.

0:23:57So, but maybe I didn't look at the thing. I'll have to go look.

0:24:00Yeah, you could, it's very obvious. You could just, I mean, "Cannibalt" really puts the score literally in the top right corner.

0:24:06I mean, it's, they're way outside the safe zone.

0:24:09Yeah. Well, that's the other thing. When designing for a TV, they tell you to, there's like a, like the overscan border, they tell you where it is, and you shouldn't go there.

0:24:18and even when filming, they take it into account when they're filming.

0:24:23Which is kind of bananas in that that's how entrenched this thing is.

0:24:28Even the production side is basically just adapting, throwing its hands up and being like,

0:24:34"Okay, well, let's just avoid the edges."

0:24:37Even though now there's no more technical reason for it.

0:24:41That it's a digital image you're shooting on video,

0:24:44video and it's going to be digital all the way through until it gets on the display.

0:24:50But because everybody shoots within the safe zone, you still have to shoot within the safe

0:24:54zone. And the devices still default sometimes to, well, maybe they didn't shoot with the

0:24:59safe zone, so we're going to overscan.

0:25:01Yeah. Too weird. Byzantine little crazy technological nightmare.

0:25:10(laughs)

0:25:12All right, let me take a break.

0:25:14Take a first break here and thank our first sponsor.

0:25:16It is our friends at Hullo, H-U-L-L-O.

0:25:21Here's what these guys sell you.

0:25:24They sell you a buckwheat hole pillow.

0:25:28What the hell is that?

0:25:29Here's the thing.

0:25:30It's been popular for centuries in Asia.

0:25:33This is how they've made pillows

0:25:34for literally hundreds of years.

0:25:36You take these buckwheat holes.

0:25:39They feel, I haven't actually opened it up,

0:25:41but they feel like coffee beans.

0:25:43And they fill a pillow with these holes.

0:25:46Feels like almost like more like a bean bag

0:25:48than like a feather pillow.

0:25:50Air flows freely through these things.

0:25:54So it's like it keeps your head,

0:25:56your head doesn't get sweaty

0:25:57when you're sleeping on this thing.

0:25:58And then you can adjust the thickness

0:26:00to your personal preference.

0:26:01You just open it up, unzip it,

0:26:02and you could just take some of the holes out

0:26:04anytime you want.

0:26:05If the one you get out of the box feels like it's too full.

0:26:09Made in the USA with quality construction,

0:26:14really good materials.

0:26:15So it's pre-shrunken, durable twill cotton for the case.

0:26:20It's even a good zipper and it's sort of hidden,

0:26:25like it tucks away.

0:26:28Sometimes with like a jacket or something like that,

0:26:29you can have a zipper that's easy to get to,

0:26:32but then when it's all closed up, you don't see it.

0:26:34And even the buckwheat, even the actual,

0:26:38the holes that are stuffed in the pillow,

0:26:42they're grown and milled in North Dakota,

0:26:44right here in the US.

0:26:46Very environmentally friendly and organic product.

0:26:51Everything's 100% unbleached cotton.

0:26:54No chemical foams inside, just natural hull.

0:26:58Really, really good.

0:26:59Sounds crazy.

0:27:00Here's the thing, I know that this sounds crazy.

0:27:02It is nothing like any pillow I've ever had before.

0:27:05They sent us two of them months ago,

0:27:08maybe a year ago when they first started sponsoring the show.

0:27:11And Amy and I still have them both on our bed.

0:27:13We both like it a lot.

0:27:14It's really, really nice.

0:27:15Definitely different.

0:27:17If it sounds different to you,

0:27:18the idea of sleeping on more of like a bean bag

0:27:20than a feather pillow, it definitely is,

0:27:23but it's really, really nice.

0:27:25So here's the deal.

0:27:2760 nights for free.

0:27:28Just go there, buy it.

0:27:30And any point in the first 60 nights, if it's not for you,

0:27:33they give you a full refund, no questions asked, no hassle.

0:27:35that you don't have to like call them up

0:27:37and somebody's gonna try to argue with you

0:27:39that you wanna keep this pillow or talk you into it.

0:27:41Just send it back, 60 nights for free.

0:27:45They have four sizes, small, standard, king.

0:27:48I guess that's three sizes.

0:27:49I guess I can't count.

0:27:5149, 79, 129 bucks.

0:27:56Here is where you go.

0:27:57Go to hullo, H-U-L-L-O, pillow.com/talkshow.

0:28:03know the, just slash talk show.

0:28:05And they'll know you came from the show,

0:28:08they'll help with that.

0:28:10And last but not least, 1% of all of their profits

0:28:14are contributed to the Nature Conservancy.

0:28:18So you're doing good things.

0:28:20So my thanks to them.

0:28:22So what else?

0:28:24So when I got my home yesterday,

0:28:27the App Store, like you said,

0:28:31it must have gone live during the day,

0:28:32probably when they started giving them out to people like,

0:28:35you know, monkeys like me in the media.

0:28:37- So you had a briefing, right?

0:28:40- Yeah.

0:28:40- Can we say you had a briefing?

0:28:41- Yeah.

0:28:42- I guess we just did.

0:28:43- Yeah.

0:28:44- Like, what were the talking points?

0:28:48Like, what did they run you through?

0:28:50- Well, officially the briefings are off the record,

0:28:55so I won't quote them.

0:28:56- Okay, okay, okay.

0:28:57- But I don't think it's a secret either.

0:28:58It wasn't really, it's, you know, it was,

0:29:02In my personal experience, I've said this before,

0:29:05I'm not quite sure where to draw the line

0:29:06with what's NDA and what's not,

0:29:08but the basic gist, I have never ever gotten a review unit

0:29:11of an Apple product that didn't include a briefing.

0:29:14And not like with a room full of people,

0:29:17you get like one-on-one time

0:29:18with somebody from product marketing.

0:29:20And it's always, people who are,

0:29:24but people at Apple are like,

0:29:25the product marketing team for Apple TV

0:29:27is intimately familiar with the product,

0:29:29they really know it.

0:29:30So the big parts that they emphasized, the universal search and Siri, absolutely, they went through a couple of demos, let me play with it.

0:29:39But it's clear that that is central to their vision for why are they even in the business of making Apple TV.

0:29:48This universal search is absolutely huge.

0:29:51Yeah, so I phrased that the wrong way.

0:29:56No, it's alright.

0:29:58I'm curious what they want to push.

0:30:01Yeah, I think that's a good question. I think because usually what they want to push really is the most interesting things.

0:30:08It's not like, it's so easy to overthink it. And if they're talking about A, B, and C, then you can overthink it and think,

0:30:14well then D must be the part that's really interesting because they don't want to talk about it.

0:30:18about it and maybe that's a problem or whatever. Now, Universal Search, you know,

0:30:24the basic gist of using the trackpad, which I, you know, we can talk about this

0:30:30more, I think we should. To me it's interesting. Now this is the

0:30:34sort of thing they don't talk about, but the feel of it, the way that you can kind

0:30:38of feel the UI as you slide your thumb around, is really interesting because

0:30:42usually a touchpad has always been a thing where you have a cursor on screen

0:30:48that you move around, right? Just think about like a MacBook like when you or

0:30:52the new Magic Trackpad for you know desktops. You slide your finger around

0:30:56and there's a thing on screen you know the arrow usually but it you know turns

0:31:01into an I beam when you're editing text or whatever it moves around in response.

0:31:05Well there is nothing on screen on Apple TV. It's you're just sort of implicitly

0:31:11moving a selection around and different things pop up and move. I think they did

0:31:16great job of that.

0:31:18- They did an amazing job of that.

0:31:20Like we could talk about that for ages.

0:31:22- Yeah, we can hold it.

0:31:23- They call it focus, but yeah.

0:31:25Get back to it.

0:31:26- What else did they want us to show?

0:31:28Oh, they definitely wanted to show,

0:31:30and I think rightly so.

0:31:31And if anything to me has been underplayed so far

0:31:34in the reviews of it that I've seen,

0:31:36is the video scrubbing.

0:31:39Meaning that when you fast forward video,

0:31:44you get a fantastic, to me the best,

0:31:49it's even better than TiVo.

0:31:51And TiVo to me, I know John Siracusa

0:31:54holds the same opinion on it,

0:31:56is really until now the only fast-forwarding video

0:32:00for anything I've ever connected to my TV

0:32:03that actually is decent.

0:32:06The old Apple TV was complete shit

0:32:08for fast-forward and rewind,

0:32:09especially for streaming content.

0:32:13Because you'd have no visual indication of it.

0:32:15You just have this timeline thing that moves.

0:32:17And every once in a while, it just

0:32:19goes back to the beginning of the whole stream.

0:32:21And the new one, it's so good.

0:32:24It's so fast.

0:32:25The little thumbnail that shows you

0:32:27what you will get if you stop as you fast forward,

0:32:31it updates perfectly.

0:32:34It's almost like I wonder if they had to dial it back

0:32:36and slow it down so it doesn't change too much.

0:32:40It's like it updates exactly as frequently

0:32:42you want it to and whatever it is that you're looking at on that thumbnail when

0:32:45you hit click it again to say all right start playing from here it just starts

0:32:49playing exactly what it showed in the thumbnail is exactly what you will see

0:32:53blown up to the full size of the screen and it sound I think it's it obviously

0:32:58anything you fast-forward should work the way I just said but nothing has

0:33:02worked that way until now and they definitely wanted to show that off and

0:33:07and then mostly just games, I guess.

0:33:10- Oh, interesting, okay.

0:33:13Yeah, that fast forward thing is amazing.

0:33:18Have you tried telling Siri to go back 30 seconds?

0:33:20- Yeah, yeah, and it works great.

0:33:22- Yeah, it's awesome.

0:33:23- I find the only thing that I find so far is

0:33:29it's almost like I forget to use Siri.

0:33:33I've only had it for literally 20 to 30 hours.

0:33:38- Exactly where it's gonna go.

0:33:39I find myself going to the store,

0:33:43navigating around top shows to find a show

0:33:46that I know what I'm looking for.

0:33:47I could just say it.

0:33:48- I forget what I wanted.

0:33:51- I need to break my old habits.

0:33:52- Right, I started doing the type ahead to type something

0:33:55and I was annoyed and I was just like,

0:33:57oh wait, I'm not supposed to type to find it.

0:34:02I think they even offer you reminders. It's like they even show you.

0:34:06They're like, you know, you could, you know, just hit the Siri button.

0:34:09[Laughter]

0:34:11That's cool. I know some people have been frustrated with it, but whatever.

0:34:14It's Siri, so...

0:34:16I think you can have good and bad experiences with it at times.

0:34:22Yeah, it's always like that. It's definitely... but it's getting better across all devices.

0:34:28You know, the watch...

0:34:29Oh yeah, I agree.

0:34:30the phone and with everything. It is getting better at a very rapid... Does this one seem

0:34:34way faster to you? I think so. And it um... Like the words just appear as as I say them.

0:34:41Yeah, I don't, I almost don't even know how it could be faster. Like why, why, and unless it's

0:34:47just that it's, you know, the the team working on Apple TV are such engineering badasses that

0:34:54that they're actually better than the people on the watch

0:34:58and phone teams or something.

0:35:00I really, it almost seems inexplicable

0:35:02how much faster it is than Siri on the phone.

0:35:06- The only thing I could come up with

0:35:07was that it's a smaller problem set,

0:35:09so they've got a lot more stuff cached locally for,

0:35:11like you often say, "Show me."

0:35:14- Yeah.

0:35:15- And then the name of a TV show,

0:35:16and I've already got like a list about the TV show,

0:35:18so they have a pretty confident guess before maybe.

0:35:22- Yeah. - Maybe.

0:35:23- I don't know though.

0:35:25It was like,

0:35:26I was interested, so for example,

0:35:30we were watching a movie as a family last night.

0:35:34Jonas had like an in-service day today,

0:35:38where the teachers are, I don't know,

0:35:40grading papers or something.

0:35:42So he did, yesterday was the beginning of his weekend,

0:35:45so he could stay up late and we watched a movie.

0:35:48But I was interested, and oddly enough,

0:35:50Amy was too in the Thursday night football game,

0:35:53which was the Miami Dolphins against

0:35:56the New England Patriots because Daniel Tosh,

0:36:00you ever see that Tosh?

0:36:02- That guy-- - I bet you hate him.

0:36:04You hate him. (both laughing)

0:36:08'Cause he's not a good person,

0:36:10which is, he's a very funny guy.

0:36:13I think he's hilarious, but Amy really likes his show.

0:36:16She likes him.

0:36:17So I watch with her and I get grossed out

0:36:21by some of this stuff.

0:36:22I really, I'm a little squeamish.

0:36:24And so if you don't know,

0:36:25Daniel Tosh has a show on, a weekly show on Comedy Central

0:36:28where they show clips from YouTube

0:36:30and wherever else they can find them on the internet

0:36:32of people doing stupid things and often getting hurt.

0:36:36And then he makes fun of them.

0:36:37But anyway, he raised $25,000 and he had a,

0:36:42he did this before too.

0:36:47raised like $25,000 for charity with the awesome with the idea but well just

0:36:53with the idea though that once he raised the 25 grand for charity he would go to

0:36:58Vegas and bet it all on one hand a blackjack and then if he won it would

0:37:03all go to the charity and if he lost they would get nothing and he went and

0:37:07played one hand a blackjack and lost and it was true I mean he was there at the

0:37:12Mirage and he had a stack of $25,000 in front of him.

0:37:16And so this year, he raised $25,000.

0:37:21And it's actually for a pal of his who,

0:37:24some other comedian, I hadn't heard him,

0:37:26but the poor guy's got a brain tumor or something.

0:37:29And it's a typical US thing, even with Obamacare,

0:37:34it's like his insurance is gonna bankrupt him or something.

0:37:37So the money's gonna go to help this comedian friend

0:37:39of his, you know, pay off his medical bills

0:37:42from brain tumor.

0:37:44So great cause.

0:37:45But what he did is he bet the whole thing

0:37:48on the first half, this is like the longest tangent

0:37:52in the history of the show.

0:37:53He bet the whole thing on the first half

0:37:56of the Miami Dolphins New England Patriots game.

0:37:59Now the backstory here is that Tash is a lifelong

0:38:03Miami Dolphins fan.

0:38:04Loves the Miami Dolphins.

0:38:06The Miami Dolphins are terrible.

0:38:09They're so bad they've already fired their,

0:38:11you know, like three games into the season

0:38:12they fired their coach.

0:38:13And that, you know, I mean, that's.

0:38:14(laughing)

0:38:15If you can't even wait till the end of the season

0:38:18to fire your coach, you know your team is in bad shape.

0:38:21So the Miami Dolphins are terrible

0:38:23and the New England Patriots are quite possibly,

0:38:25probably the best team in football this year.

0:38:28- Yeah, don't talk about this.

0:38:30- So what he did is he bet on the Patriots

0:38:36for the first half only

0:38:38so that he could, by all accounts,

0:38:41they're almost certainly gonna be ahead at halftime.

0:38:44They had to be ahead by at least three and a half points,

0:38:46and he'd win.

0:38:47But then he could go back and root for the Miami Dolphins

0:38:50to win the game by coming back in the second half.

0:38:53So anyway, long story short,

0:38:54we were interested in the score of the game,

0:38:56and so I did the Siri thing in the middle of a movie.

0:38:58Hey Siri, what's the score of the Dolphins game?

0:39:00And the score was already up.

0:39:03Like it felt like I was gonna wait for like a little spinner

0:39:07while she processes it.

0:39:08And in the meantime, it was like the New England Patriots are up 17-0 in the first half or

0:39:13whatever it was.

0:39:14Anyway, long story short, Tosh did win the bet.

0:39:17The Dolphins got killed.

0:39:18OK, cool.

0:39:19So, I mean, good that he's helping out his brain buddy.

0:39:24He's such a dick.

0:39:26I'm sure that he'd, you know, behind the scenes, and probably gave him money, but at least

0:39:31publicly.

0:39:32And he did have a picture of the ticket you get from the sportsbook.

0:39:35He did bet $25,000 on the Patriots.

0:39:38anyway long story short, anyway, long story short, you got your sports scores pretty quick.

0:39:45instantaneously and that to me is not the sort of question I guess that you can yeah

0:39:51I mean you know I mean how many I guess people ask about weather and ask about

0:39:55sports scores and I don't know it seems to me like it's more than just local

0:39:59caching it's really really good and I just feel like it it has to become

0:40:04habit-forming because it is such a useful way to navigate the Apple TV.

0:40:08Yeah, I just still haven't got there yet. I still do the left-right-up-down thing

0:40:13way too often. Yeah. I'll get there. The other little thing, and I wonder maybe I

0:40:20haven't actually tried this, but I know at the event when I played with it I

0:40:23kept I'd press the button and I would say "H*ck, what's the temperature outside?" and

0:40:28that screwed it all up and they're like "Oh no no you don't have to say don't say

0:40:32just ask what the weather is but it's weird because I've sort of gotten

0:40:37grooved on saying because hmm I guess I should have prefaced that because I

0:40:43know famous that's probably me doing that probably set off serious although

0:40:49strangely it didn't set off mine on my phone right here yeah maybe we'll beep

0:40:55it out if you heard beeps I don't know you may or not have heard beeps 30

0:40:59seconds ago it was because I said a GY Siri the only thing the only thing that

0:41:12ever gets beeped on on my talk show anyway you would think it shouldn't

0:41:20screw it up though like why would that screw yeah I wonder if maybe they've

0:41:24maybe they could just maybe the in I wouldn't be surprised if in the interim

0:41:28maybe they've made it so Siri will just ignore it. Recognize it and ignore it.

0:41:33You don't need to say it but if you do, out of habit, it shouldn't hurt you.

0:41:37Yeah, exactly. Yeah. It seems like you holding the button, which is effectively

0:41:41the same thing as summoning. It seems like the sort of thing that when before

0:41:47it goes out to a wider audience you can see why they didn't do that because the

0:41:51only people who were using it were on the team and they knew exactly how it

0:41:54worked and so they of course never said **** because they knew not to say **** but

0:41:58- Stop doing it.

0:41:59(laughing)

0:42:00- Beep.

0:42:01They knew not to say the thing.

0:42:05But then once it got out into a wider release,

0:42:09maybe it was like, oh yeah, obviously we should

0:42:12just listen for that and just discard it.

0:42:15Sort of like with the live photos,

0:42:17the way that in the, for the first month with the iPhone 6,

0:42:21if you drop your camera, drop it meaning lower it

0:42:25after you snap the picture,

0:42:26your live photo ends up with this blurry picture

0:42:30of somebody's feet every single time.

0:42:31And then starting in iOS 9.1, they detect that

0:42:35and just crop it at the point where you lower the camera.

0:42:38- Yeah, I love live photo client, that's a good idea.

0:42:41- It's so great, but it's so, you can totally see

0:42:44how this seemingly obvious feature

0:42:47of detecting the lowering of the camera,

0:42:49how it slipped through, because the only people using it

0:42:52knew they had gotten in the habit of holding the camera

0:42:56for one and a half seconds after they take the photo.

0:42:59- And it's really like when you're not thinking about it

0:43:01and you're not really,

0:43:03'cause that's part of the beauty of the live photos,

0:43:05you don't have to think about it.

0:43:07You just do it, but then you end up with these weird things.

0:43:10So I wouldn't be surprised if the, you know.

0:43:15- Yeah, something slips through, but don't do it again.

0:43:19What's the Amazon one?

0:43:25Alexa?

0:43:28Huh? I tricked you into saying it.

0:43:30But what do you have to say, though?

0:43:32I don't know.

0:43:34I don't know what the...

0:43:36Anyway, whatever.

0:43:38We can't...

0:43:40I find it a little bit disconcerting that we're worried about saying the Bonk thing,

0:43:44because it's going to upset robots.

0:43:46[laughter]

0:43:48It's not really a feature of one of the living.

0:43:50Shh!

0:43:52[laughter]

0:43:54Shh.

0:43:55Don't--

0:43:56No, no, no.

0:43:56Don't wake up the robot.

0:43:57Let me take another break here.

0:44:03I'm going to thank our next sponsor.

0:44:05And what are you going to do if you're sleeping

0:44:07on one of these hello pillows?

0:44:09Well, what are you laying on?

0:44:10Well, you need a mattress.

0:44:12So here we go.

0:44:13Serendipity, our next sponsor on the show,

0:44:16is Casper, the company that makes the mattresses.

0:44:21and you buy 'em online and they ship 'em to your house,

0:44:25and it's amazing.

0:44:27This is like the future.

0:44:31None of this shit where you go to a mattress store.

0:44:33What a mess that is.

0:44:35Casper makes, they make buying a mattress so much easier.

0:44:41It's not just about skipping the store.

0:44:44They don't, you don't go there and pick between

0:44:47eight different types of foam or styles of mattress.

0:44:50All they do, they just make you pick a size.

0:44:53They're like the apple of mattresses.

0:44:55You don't have to go in there and figure out

0:44:57what type of spring technology is in there.

0:45:01They make one type of foam.

0:45:03They use two different technologies,

0:45:05latex foam and memory foam, and they've blended,

0:45:08they've got their own custom blend that they think,

0:45:10these guys are mattress experts, that's all they do.

0:45:13They've taken care of how much bounce,

0:45:17how much sink should be there, how much of the memory,

0:45:19how much of the latex.

0:45:20They just, they do it.

0:45:23That's it.

0:45:24And it's really, really nice.

0:45:25So, you go there, you pick what size you want.

0:45:31Twin size mattress, king size, queen size, whatever.

0:45:34That's the only decision you have to make.

0:45:36Then, next thing you know,

0:45:37the mattress shows up at your house,

0:45:39packed into an unbelievably small box.

0:45:42It's probably the biggest box if you've got,

0:45:44when you buy one of these things,

0:45:45it's probably the biggest box you'll get this year.

0:45:48but it is way smaller than a mattress.

0:45:51It is ridiculously small.

0:45:53Half the fun of the thing is opening it up

0:45:56and hearing the air suck into it.

0:45:58The whole reason they can ship it so small

0:46:00is that they vacuum seal these things.

0:46:03You put it in your bedroom, you open up the box,

0:46:05you follow the instructions, and it makes this cool noise,

0:46:08which I will not attempt to replicate,

0:46:09and next thing you know, there's a full-size mattress.

0:46:12With all this Back to the Future talk,

0:46:14because the Back to the Future day was last week,

0:46:17It reminds me of the pizza they make in Back to the Future

0:46:19where it's like tiny and then the mom hits a button

0:46:22and two seconds later there's a full-size pizza.

0:46:24That's exactly what it's like,

0:46:26except it's a mattress and not a pizza.

0:46:29Does that make sense?

0:46:30Great prices.

0:46:31Here's the other thing too.

0:46:32So much easier.

0:46:33No hard decisions on what type of technology.

0:46:35No crazy price comparisons

0:46:38and you don't have to worry about shipping it

0:46:40or anything like that.

0:46:41You just go there, pick it out.

0:46:43The mattresses are made in America

0:46:46And if you don't like it, you have 100 days

0:46:51where up to 100 days later, you can just say,

0:46:53you know what, I don't like it,

0:46:54ship it back, free delivery, you know.

0:46:57So if you have any reservations about buying a mattress

0:47:00without actually having tried it in a store,

0:47:02which quite frankly is kind of gross

0:47:04'cause guess what, other people have been laying

0:47:06on those things too.

0:47:08You give 100 days, no risk, money back guarantee.

0:47:10Here's what you do.

0:47:11Go to

0:47:16Casper sleep what is the house that you are a Casper sleep that's it here we go

0:47:21Casper sleep dot com and the code is the talk show with the and if you use that

0:47:28code you'll save an extra 50 bucks so my thanks to Casper go get a mattress

0:47:33what else is going on with that I like the theme though yes all sleepy stuff

0:47:39Yeah, cozy. The winter's coming in.

0:47:42What else?

0:47:45So we got as far as turning the actual thing on.

0:47:48Yeah, let's talk about the input. You're sliding around this trackpad.

0:47:51And what did you say is called Focus?

0:47:54Yeah, it's called... internally the class that takes care of all of that is called the UI Focus Engine.

0:48:00So... I mean...

0:48:03I know we don't have a selection rectangle, but...

0:48:07You know, think of it like that, right? Like as you move down you get the selection rectangle.

0:48:13What actually happens for listeners who haven't seen it is you move from one icon or button to the other

0:48:20and as you move onto one it gets bigger and gets a parallax effect on it too

0:48:28so that as you slightly move your finger around the trackpad, the angle of the icon changes

0:48:35giving it a nice 3D feel.

0:48:39Like you feel like you're manipulating an object.

0:48:42- It definitely has a 3D feel.

0:48:46I feel like for a 1.0 product, it's remarkably polished.

0:48:50And this might just be a factor of how long

0:48:52they've been working on it internally.

0:48:54But it's like, to me, the 3D-ness,

0:48:58the way that the selected item pops towards you a little,

0:49:01and the way that there is this parallax.

0:49:03And there's also, like you said, if you're going to the left and you're selecting items

0:49:10from the left to the right and you're still kind of pressing your thumb, you've stopped,

0:49:15you're hovering on one, but you're still kind of got your thumb going a little to the right,

0:49:20that's the way it tilts a little bit.

0:49:22It's as though you're sort of pressing it to the right.

0:49:25You can idly play with them.

0:49:27I do, just because I'm like, "Oh yeah, do I want to watch this?"

0:49:29I'm looking at the parallax effect.

0:49:32Like often the text will pop from the front to the background,

0:49:35or there'll be a couple layers in there.

0:49:36- It's such a cool thing,

0:49:39but it would be so easy to do too much,

0:49:41to have it too strong.

0:49:43And it's not, I feel like it is delightfully understated.

0:49:48- Yeah, if anything, I think that the white shine

0:49:51that they put on is a little bit too much, but whatever.

0:49:55- It is funny though, because it is absolutely,

0:49:58positively not flat, to use that overused term.

0:50:02It is a very, very visually 3D effect.

0:50:06The things really pop.

0:50:10Yeah, while preserving some of the...

0:50:14I guess it's difficult to explain it, but I mean, the elements are flat, but they're

0:50:18stacked in a way such that it's clearly 3D. You know what I mean?

0:50:22Like the settings icon looks almost

0:50:26identical to the iOS icon, but it is stacked in a way so the gears are

0:50:31like, they descend into space so you can see them move a bit. Yeah, and buttons are

0:50:38definitely buttons. You go back and forth on this, I've kind of

0:50:46gotten used to it with iOS 7, starting with iOS 7, the new look of iOS where a

0:50:51a lot of buttons don't have an actual outline,

0:50:55they're just text.

0:50:56And it's almost like clicking,

0:50:58more like clicking, tapping a hyperlink

0:51:01than tapping a button.

0:51:02And I can kind of see why they did that.

0:51:05It's never quite sat right with me,

0:51:06but I kind of have come to peace with it.

0:51:10But I really like that on this new Apple TV

0:51:12that buttons are buttons again.

0:51:14- Yeah, they have like a pretty distinctive outline

0:51:17and when you move on to one,

0:51:18it makes a different sound.

0:51:20- Yeah.

0:51:21As you navigate around the UI, you get sounds

0:51:23for what you're selecting too, which is nice.

0:51:25- Yeah, and it's really, in my opinion, well done again.

0:51:29I think the old Apple TV sounds were pretty good too,

0:51:32but I think that the tweaks that they've done

0:51:34are all for the better.

0:51:36And it just kind of, again, it's almost not like you're,

0:51:40it's not over the top, it's not like a lot of beeping

0:51:43and buzzing, it's just subtle little feedback

0:51:47that it almost is like it helps you feel it.

0:51:50it makes it feel like your finger can feel these buttons

0:51:52because you're getting some kind of,

0:51:55even though it's not like a force feedback on the remote,

0:51:59you're getting some kind of sensual input.

0:52:03- Yeah.

0:52:04I would love to see some kind of haptic feedback

0:52:08in the remote eventually.

0:52:10- Yeah, I think that's gotta come eventually,

0:52:11especially it just seems like they're doing so much

0:52:15so quickly, you know, the haptic stuff that they're doing is,

0:52:19If you think about it, it's like we're just early days on it, really.

0:52:23I mean, we're still in the first year of having a Force Touch trackpad.

0:52:29They just came out with the first phones with the 3D Touch a month ago, right?

0:52:36Six weeks ago.

0:52:38The Watch only came out in April.

0:52:42So the Watch was one of the first ones they came out with, but the Watch has really sort

0:52:45the simplest implementation where it's really just, you know, is it a force touch or not?

0:52:49It's not like a degree of force. So I think that's inevitable. I think it's got to be, you know,

0:52:54whether it's next year or two years from now that there will be an Apple TV remote that has some kind of...

0:52:59- Haptic, yeah. They don't need it super robust either. It's a smaller device, so you don't need to move it that...

0:53:06You don't mean like the weight of the device is going to matter for the oscillator.

0:53:11- Right, right, and in a way that,

0:53:15the way that you're, like the big,

0:53:18the only real, to me, the only real downside

0:53:20to the Force Touch on the new iPhone 6s is,

0:53:236s sounds so weird.

0:53:28I'll just say 6s, or I'll say it like I write it,

0:53:30iPhone's 6s, is that it made 'em way more,

0:53:35like noticeably more, like about 20 grams more,

0:53:39Apple doesn't really make things typically that get heavier.

0:53:45I think it's worth it. But on the remote, a little bit more might actually make it even feel better.

0:53:50The remote is so lightweight that if they have to add 20 grams to it to get force touch in there, so what?

0:53:57Yeah. Well, also the engine won't have to be as forceful, right? Because it's got less to wiggle.

0:54:04So anyway, I mean, that's a minor...

0:54:07That's how excited I am. Now I'm like, "Oh, wouldn't it be cool if...

0:54:11X." You know what I mean? It's not even a complaint. It's just like...

0:54:15I would just say this. I would just go zoom back, big picture,

0:54:19of the three...

0:54:23I won't count the watch, because the watch to me is not really an OS.

0:54:27It's sort of, you know, it's a watch.

0:54:31Maybe I should, but of iOS, OS X, and Apple TV,

0:54:36and they all have these new, if we start with iOS 7,

0:54:44these new user interfaces, they're all using

0:54:47the San Francisco system font.

0:54:49I think that the Apple TV is the best designed one.

0:54:53I just, and little things like what do the buttons look like,

0:54:59what do the icons look like,

0:55:01To me, it's the best, it's my favorite of them now.

0:55:06- Yeah, I think I've done amazing.

0:55:08- Maybe I'm judging that a little early.

0:55:09Maybe if I, you know, a month from now

0:55:11after I've really gotten used to it,

0:55:13maybe I'll start to see more things to complain about.

0:55:16But I feel like there are the least things in there

0:55:19that I would really wish that they would do differently.

0:55:21I don't really have any complaints like that.

0:55:23I just think it's gorgeous and has such a great feel.

0:55:26- Could also be because there's less to it, right?

0:55:29- Yeah, it's possible too. - There's less to it.

0:55:30But there's less UI. You don't have a complicated app, necessarily.

0:55:35The way this focus engine thing works is that in code, it moves the focus

0:55:44the way that the viewer is seeing the screen.

0:55:51If you were to move right and there's a list to the right,

0:55:59it would jump to where you would expect it to go as viewer, not programmatically, per se.

0:56:04What's a good way of putting this?

0:56:11So you can imagine having a button, like a view button, that was covered up by something else.

0:56:13And if you press down, it would have selected the button logically in the code,

0:56:19but something is covering it. It will instead pick the thing that's covering it.

0:56:24Because that's the foremost on the screen.

0:56:26It doesn't...man, sorry I'm trying to explain to you in a non-technical way,

0:56:34but there's a way that you'd structure the code in all of these views that relate to each other,

0:56:39and there's a hierarchy of views of what gets embedded in what.

0:56:44But that isn't necessarily what gets presented on the screen,

0:56:47because you could have stuff like popups showing up,

0:56:50or things coming in from the side, or a view element is either hidden,

0:56:53or its alpha value has gone to zero, it's become completely transparent.

0:56:59And this focus engine will take all of that into account.

0:57:04So it'll consider what the user is seeing rather than what the developer has written.

0:57:09Yeah, I think that makes sense from a layperson.

0:57:12I think people can kind of know what they mean by that.

0:57:15In the code, or in--do they still call it interface builder?

0:57:21interface builder what would you call yeah they still called IB interface

0:57:25build but it's inside Xcode now right yeah that a lot of times these the the

0:57:32the UI is almost it's like an outline where there are you know views that are

0:57:38sub views and that you can effectively at a higher level you can just collapse

0:57:43the whole thing like a section of an outline and just know that if you move

0:57:47this thing around all of its subviews go with it and when you think of it that

0:57:51way you can think of what would the outline considered to be next you know

0:57:57it isn't that sort of what you're talking about like it would be like a

0:57:59logical thing like you know that this is beneath it because it's the next thing

0:58:03in this outline which has a linear view but it isn't related to this but the

0:58:08visual layout right totally different yeah right and it would be like a

0:58:12picture of a web page with like a three column web page this is a left-hand

0:58:15There's the content and then there's whatever, the ads of stuff on the right.

0:58:20Now imagine navigating with the focus.

0:58:25If you pressed the down button, you'd be going down the left-hand side, the source list.

0:58:28And then if you pressed right, you would jump over to the main content view.

0:58:32Now, if a dialog box popped up, and you were in the left and you pressed right,

0:58:37you would jump into the dialog box instead, because it's foremost.

0:58:41foremost, it's more prominent.

0:58:44- Yeah, it's, in the bottom line,

0:58:49and I feel like it's, again, to overuse the word magic,

0:58:52they have taken an input paradigm, the trackpad,

0:58:57that is so much easier to conceptualize

0:59:02if you're just moving a pointer on screen, right?

0:59:06Just think of the arrow from Mac, that Mac arrow cursor.

0:59:10Conceptually, that's super simple.

0:59:12You move a thing and it moves exactly along with your finger.

0:59:18And then it solves everything because whatever you tap on

0:59:22is what's underneath the arrow.

0:59:23So getting rid of the idea of a pointer is conceptually,

0:59:28I would think, to implement it very, very difficult

0:59:30because they've done it in a way that it has to--

0:59:34normal people are never going to think about this.

0:59:37Yeah, no, and you shouldn't.

0:59:38And there's a fair amount of new stuff that they've added to UIKit

0:59:43to support this notion of focus.

0:59:48And it's unique to the platform.

0:59:53It doesn't exist, doesn't even make sense on a phone or an iPad.

0:59:57So I don't know, it's really cool.

1:00:02Yeah, I really feel like they've knocked themselves out on it.

1:00:05And I don't think they're going to get the recognition.

1:00:05And they know that too, that it's like some of the stuff that works, it really requires

1:00:12amazing engineering.

1:00:14Everybody's just going to take it for granted very, very soon.

1:00:17Yeah, I mean that's kind of the…

1:00:20So we crapped all over the on-screen keyboard just the idea of it.

1:00:26And it still is less than optimal.

1:00:28But when you have to enter a password or something like that, or if you...

1:00:37Like Netflix, like to turn on Netflix I had to enter our Netflix credentials.

1:00:42There's no way around that.

1:00:43Yeah.

1:00:44That app's better too, by the way.

1:00:47The Netflix app?

1:00:48Yeah.

1:00:49Actually, I guess there is a way around it.

1:00:50We can talk about it.

1:00:51Did you see that there's a net news wire for Apple TV?

1:00:55I did.

1:00:56I have not tried it out yet.

1:00:57So it's, in a sense, so BlackPixel,

1:01:00people who have NetNewswire now, did an Apple TV app.

1:01:03I was surprised, I was like, it doesn't seem,

1:01:05RSS does not seem like something I wanna do on my TV.

1:01:08Having played with it, I think I'm right

1:01:11that it's probably not something I wanna do on my TV,

1:01:13but it may not have been that much work for them.

1:01:16I don't know, but it's interesting.

1:01:18But the thing that was the most interesting to me was

1:01:21they have their own sync engine.

1:01:27And so you can enter your email and password

1:01:28in the Apple TV the old-fashioned way.

1:01:30Or you can just launch iOS Net News Wire on your iPhone

1:01:34if you're on the same Wi-Fi network.

1:01:36And they tell you this.

1:01:39Or you can just, the easier way would be to just launch

1:01:42Net News Wire for iOS.

1:01:43So I launched it on my iPhone.

1:01:45And there on my iPhone I got a dialog box

1:01:48with the option to grant the Apple TV app

1:01:53on this, the name of my Apple TV.

1:01:56my NetNewswire Sync, and I hit a button and it was there.

1:02:01- Oh, that's great.

1:02:03- So that's, you know what I mean?

1:02:04Whether I'm actually gonna read RSS on my Apple TV,

1:02:08to get Sync credentials across, that was great.

1:02:10I wish Netflix would have had the same option.

1:02:12Hopefully more and more apps will start doing stuff like that

1:02:16so that you don't have to do it.

1:02:18But anyway, when you do type on the new Apple TV,

1:02:21I do think they've made the keyboard better

1:02:23than the old one.

1:02:24Like the old one that was arranged in a two-dimensional grid,

1:02:29it was like A, B, C, D, E, F, and then next line,

1:02:34whatever letter comes after F.

1:02:37- G, it's G. - Is it?

1:02:41I forget.

1:02:42I often don't remember mid-alphabet.

1:02:46I have to start from the beginning.

1:02:48- I do it every time, yeah.

1:02:50- I have to start from the beginning,

1:02:51and I didn't feel like doing it.

1:02:52- I don't want to admit that, but I do.

1:02:54And sometimes I can always do it from the beginning, but sometimes I'm amazed by things.

1:03:00I'm like, "Wow, S and T are really far back in the alphabet. I never thought of them as

1:03:06being so far back."

1:03:07Yeah, yeah, they were pretty far back. Yeah, they really are.

1:03:12Like those are, to me, those are big boy consonants. Like, you know, S is the most frequently used

1:03:17consonant. T is, you know, super up there in frequency. You just think that they'd have,

1:03:21you know, better seats.

1:03:22Better position. Yeah, exactly.

1:03:24I heard a man's got...

1:03:27This show is just called "The Weeds" at this point.

1:03:29I was watching TV the other night,

1:03:32and they had somebody do a sobriety test.

1:03:34It was like, say the alphabet backwards.

1:03:38And I'm like, "Are you kidding me? I couldn't do that anyway."

1:03:43I would... As we speak right now, I am stone cold sober.

1:03:49I could not do that.

1:03:51Z, Y. I'd have to--

1:03:55I would have to do it, like, in-- think about it as, like,

1:03:57a programming code.

1:03:58It would be like you would--

1:04:01you would flunk the student, because the algorithm

1:04:04I would have to use--

1:04:05I can do Z and Y. All right, X. I was going to say W.

1:04:10X, Y, Z. So you get a--

1:04:11I would, more or less, once I got past X to W,

1:04:14I would have to redo the entire alphabet.

1:04:17A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, K, L, M, N, O, P, Q, R, S, T, U, V.

1:04:21- You would scan the entire thing.

1:04:22Find the last one. - All right, and then I can go B.

1:04:25I would not be able to pass that field sobriety test.

1:04:29- No, yeah, but the actress rattled it off,

1:04:31and I was like, well, okay, well,

1:04:33I guess I've drank too much,

1:04:37or this is just not realistic at all.

1:04:39- In my head, too, honestly,

1:04:43I'm not gonna sing here on the show,

1:04:45but in my head, when I do the alphabet in my head,

1:04:47I do it in the singsong.

1:04:49- Singsong voice, yeah, of course.

1:04:51You have to, yeah.

1:04:52- It's just one of those things that I stopped caring about.

1:04:57Like doing, I could do--

1:04:59- I know, I feel like I got to a functional enough level

1:05:01with it, and I'm like, okay, putting that aside.

1:05:04- I can naturally do.

1:05:05My brain, I do, I can naturally, without having to stress,

1:05:09I can do pretty significant arithmetic in my head.

1:05:15But I only do it because it is easy for me.

1:05:18And I've been talking to Jonas about it.

1:05:20Jonas isn't so good at arithmetic.

1:05:24And I was like, you gotta do what you gotta do

1:05:27to pass these tests.

1:05:27You gotta study and you gotta work on this.

1:05:29I was like, but in the long run in life,

1:05:31this is a problem that computers have solved.

1:05:33You have to understand the concepts to know what to do.

1:05:35But if you can't do 647 minus 87 in your head,

1:05:40don't worry about it.

1:05:41You're gonna have a calculator with you

1:05:42everywhere you go in your life.

1:05:44Yeah.

1:05:44That's good advice.

1:05:46What you don't have is a sign with the alphabet on it.

1:05:51Right.

1:05:52But, so, alphabetization, for me, does not come naturally.

1:05:55I don't do it.

1:05:56But it's a solved problem, right?

1:05:57My computer alphabetizes everything for me that I want alphabetized.

1:06:01Why would I have to worry about it?

1:06:02Well, if you go down and find a list view, do you…

1:06:05You must know.

1:06:07You instinctively know if you're too low or too high.

1:06:09Yeah.

1:06:11You know, if you're looking at the W, and you're like, "Do you go down to find that H?"

1:06:15No, you'll go back up.

1:06:17Yeah.

1:06:17Yeah, as I'm looking at the list, I'm not like...

1:06:23I'm not...

1:06:27A good therapy for alphabets.

1:06:30I'm not like...

1:06:33I'm not bad at alphabetizing. I just can't do it all in my head automatically.

1:06:38I can't quite remember with K before L or L after K unless I look at it in a list.

1:06:45But I kind of know basically where they are.

1:06:47Yeah. The neighborhood.

1:06:49[laughter]

1:06:51Let's go back to talking about accounting.

1:06:53[laughter]

1:06:57No, the UI. UI for Apple TV. It's really, really well done.

1:07:02I think they've done a good job, and I think it's got legs, too. I think this is going to...

1:07:07I don't think it's going to run out of possibilities.

1:07:10So the difference, I was talking about the keyboard, and the old one was a grid, and

1:07:14you'd have to go up, down, left, and right to select letters.

1:07:18And it wouldn't go, you couldn't go right to go down to the next row.

1:07:24You know what I mean?

1:07:25Yeah, it would bump you out into the next few.

1:07:27Right.

1:07:28If you were at the top right of the grid, I would think going right would move you down,

1:07:32move the selection to the next letter in the alphabet.

1:07:35but it wouldn't, it would just sort of like beep at you

1:07:36or something.

1:07:37So the new one is just a straight list

1:07:42across the screen from A to Z.

1:07:45And so all you do is go left, right.

1:07:49But one of the things I noticed is,

1:07:52and I think it's really cool,

1:07:53is as you move the selection for which letter it is,

1:07:56it's not just one, like the rectangle highlighting

1:08:00the selection moves a little bit

1:08:02as you move your finger on the trackpad.

1:08:06You know what I mean?

1:08:06Does that make sense?

1:08:08- Yeah, it's leading a bit.

1:08:09- Yeah.

1:08:10- It's ready to go to the next one.

1:08:11And then when you let go, it'll come back to rest

1:08:13like on the left that you--

1:08:14- Right, so if you're pressing a little bit to the left

1:08:16on the trackpad, the selection range will be a little bit

1:08:19more like leaning towards the next letter of the left,

1:08:22but you still haven't moved your thumb far enough

1:08:24to actually move it to the next letter.

1:08:27- Yeah, it feels very visceral.

1:08:28- Yes, exactly.

1:08:29It has a real visceral feel to it

1:08:31that it makes it, you know, so for all the crapping

1:08:34I've done about on-screen keyboards in general,

1:08:36I feel like the one that they've built for this

1:08:38is a nice, is about as good as it could get.

1:08:41- Yeah, yeah, I mean, I'm not,

1:08:43I don't know what more you could have done.

1:08:44Like you've got basically a D-pad, or like a track pad,

1:08:48and like 24 letters plus all of the 26 letters,

1:08:52however many letters.

1:08:53(laughing)

1:08:55- People are gonna, this is like the episode.

1:08:57- Wow.

1:08:58- The episode where we reveal ourselves

1:09:00the dumbest people ever. The point I wanted to make was, so if you long press or if you hold

1:09:09letter, you get the capital letters and the letters with accents. Oh man, I didn't know that.

1:09:15Yeah, is there another way of doing it? Yeah, they go down to the bottom and you can,

1:09:20it's like more or less switching to all caps. Okay, yeah. There's like a capital A, capital B,

1:09:25capital C, and then there's the next one over is lowercase a, lowercase b, lowercase c. Okay,

1:09:29I just tried the long press first and it worked.

1:09:32I should have tried that. See, that's my failing, not theirs.

1:09:35Because that seems like if I had to guess...

1:09:38This is like the problem of talking about it with only one day of using it.

1:09:43But that exactly makes sense. Brilliant.

1:09:46Yeah. So it works way better and it's nice.

1:09:50And you're still going back and forth through the alphabet, but it's not that big a deal.

1:09:54I got actually pretty quick at doing that grid.

1:09:57Like remember when we were kids and you'd have to type in codes?

1:10:01Yeah.

1:10:02And you'd get really good at it?

1:10:04I got pretty good at like navigating that grid on the Apple TV.

1:10:08You mean like codes like to...

1:10:12Oh yeah, sorry, like a code for like an arcade game, like a Nintendo game.

1:10:15Like, put in your code, your save code.

1:10:18And you'd have to... they would have like a similar grid of letters and numbers.

1:10:23Yeah, or remember when you used to get to enter three initials for a high score?

1:10:27Right.

1:10:28Right.

1:10:29Man, those are the days.

1:10:30What were your three initials?

1:10:31GTE?

1:10:32Uh, I think I would just put guy.

1:10:34That's pretty good, yeah, that's pretty good.

1:10:38I've mentioned this before.

1:10:39Mine was GRU.

1:10:42That's a good one.

1:10:43Yeah, I don't know.

1:10:44It just came to me early on and I thought it's better than the initials.

1:10:49I have to admit, I don't think I got on the high scores that much.

1:10:53I did on Star Wars.

1:10:54Oh, of course you did.

1:10:56Although on Star Wars, the coin-op Star Wars, the first three, every time you reset the machine,

1:11:02the first three were built in, they're in the ROM and they're incredibly high.

1:11:07So if you just bought, had a brand new Star Wars coin-op game,

1:11:12and you played it the first time, the best you could probably do is to be fourth.

1:11:17the top three were, it was like, one of them was like,

1:11:20they were like in-jokes, like one of them was OBI.

1:11:23- Oh, that's cool.

1:11:24- Yeah, but I thought that they were so high

1:11:27that they were impossible, and then one time

1:11:28I was in an arcade and I saw, it was like the first time,

1:11:31like I thought I was the baddest ass at Star Wars

1:11:33who'd ever lived, 'cause there was no internet,

1:11:35so you couldn't, you never found out about the people

1:11:38who were really good at games.

1:11:40And I was just waiting for the machine,

1:11:42and I was like, Christ, how many games

1:11:44is this guy gonna play?

1:11:45And I like, look, and he had like this score

1:11:50that boggled my mind, and he was at a level

1:11:53that I didn't think you'd ever be able to get to.

1:11:55And I was just like, oh, I'm actually not very good

1:12:00at this game at all.

1:12:02- That was a great game, though.

1:12:04- It was a good game.

1:12:06Vector graphics.

1:12:10All right, the keyboard's good, the focus section.

1:12:14Video playback, so this is the part,

1:12:18I mentioned this before, so when you fast forward

1:12:21and rewind and scrub the video, it is so good.

1:12:24It is, to me, everything that they promised on stage.

1:12:27It works great in Apple's app,

1:12:33like when you play the movies and TV shows

1:12:36that you get from iTunes.

1:12:37It's available, this is what I've been told,

1:12:40It is available to developers,

1:12:42and they encourage all developers to do it,

1:12:43but they can't, it's not like every app

1:12:46will do it right automatically.

1:12:48Like somebody could make like a streaming app

1:12:50that doesn't use the best APIs for this,

1:12:54or that maybe the server that's sending the streaming video

1:12:56doesn't do something that they need to have happen.

1:12:58So there might be, I haven't seen any yet,

1:13:00but I haven't played with a lot

1:13:01of the third-party video apps yet.

1:13:03But it seemed as though they were sort of bracing me

1:13:07for the fact that maybe in some third-party apps video,

1:13:10the scrubbing of the video isn't going to be as awesome as it is in Apple's.

1:13:15But it could be. They're not using APIs that aren't available to third-party apps,

1:13:18but developers might have to do some work on that.

1:13:22Yeah, I would imagine that that's a collaboration between the backend server stuff and the app itself.

1:13:25Because you do have to, at some point when you start doing the scrubbing,

1:13:32you need to see where the thumbnail.

1:13:36So it's got to come from somewhere.

1:13:38So it's probably kind of difficult to coordinate.

1:13:42And some apps may just do raw streaming.

1:13:44- Yeah. - I think the Apple TV app

1:13:47reads ahead as much as it can, basically.

1:13:50- Right, but I will say this,

1:13:52'cause we watched a movie last night on Netflix.

1:13:54It was exactly, it was like,

1:13:56we're right out of a commercial for Apple TV,

1:14:01where we wanted, 'cause it's Halloween season,

1:14:04so we wanted to watch a scary movie.

1:14:05So we were gonna watch Scream and ask Siri for,

1:14:10show me the movie Scream.

1:14:14And we'd already entered our Netflix password.

1:14:17And the first thing that came up was Netflix had the movie

1:14:22and they prioritize free.

1:14:24So if there's a way in one of the apps

1:14:27you've configured on Apple TV

1:14:29to watch what you're looking for for free,

1:14:31that will be the first option.

1:14:32So it's not just that they show third party options.

1:14:35They will show them before Apple's own option

1:14:40just because they prioritize free.

1:14:44Like they-- - That's good.

1:14:45That's really good.

1:14:46- I mentioned-- - Some things I like

1:14:47about Apple is that they do actually.

1:14:49- I mentioned it last night when it worked like that.

1:14:52I was like, they told me that it would prioritize free.

1:14:54And Amy, that gave me like,

1:14:57you're actually gonna praise them for doing the obvious,

1:15:01for not trying to charge you four dollars for a movie you could watch for

1:15:04you should be able to watch for free because you have netflix

1:15:08and i was like well she has a point but i mean

1:15:11it's i guess yeah we are so jaded and accustomed to companies but i mean

1:15:18i would not have been surprised at all if they if if they had

1:15:22prioritized itunes you know or at least you know not prioritized but yeah well i

1:15:25guess whoever's first is prioritized if itunes was always first

1:15:29I would not have been shocked at all. In fact, I remember having a similar thing years ago.

1:15:33I invented a movie, I forget which one, and then months later

1:15:37I went to go and watch it again. So I invented it again.

1:15:41And iTunes or the TV came back and told me

1:15:45"You invented this before. Are you sure you want to do it?"

1:15:49I'm like, "Oh, that's super nice of you. Yes, I do. But thank you for

1:15:53not just taking me my money."

1:15:57easily just taking the money and being like, "Well, I guess you want to watch it again."

1:16:00Right. And you know that somewhere inside Apple there's somebody who probably,

1:16:04somebody who works for iTunes who probably was, somebody had to at least advocate for it a little.

1:16:09Like, you know it was probably a debate inside. Yeah. Well, I mean, that doesn't just happen

1:16:13either. Like, they have to go check, "Have I ever rented this movie before?" Like, that's cool.

1:16:19That, you know, like somebody took active measures to make that a feature.

1:16:25Right, because every single alert along the way, you know, they definitely, you know,

1:16:29it's a terrible experience if it's too easy to accidentally rent something. Terrible.

1:16:33And even Apple, nobody's, no company is so greedy that they want people to be angry at

1:16:37them. So, they're, you know, I don't know that any, there's ever been a video on demand

1:16:42platform that makes it too easy to rent something by accident. But yeah, that's an extra nice

1:16:47step. And I feel like on this, on the new Apple TV, by being willing to say, "Hey,

1:16:51You've got HBO Go and this movie is,

1:16:56in HBO's current selection of movies,

1:16:58you could just watch it there for free.

1:17:00By making that the first option,

1:17:02you know that again, there was probably somebody there

1:17:04on the iTunes team who was like,

1:17:05"Aw, come on, naw, let's put iTunes first."

1:17:08And it's, you know, I'm glad they didn't do it.

1:17:10It comes back to the old,

1:17:12the thing we often come back to when talking about Apple,

1:17:14that of the three people that Apple generally

1:17:17has to think about, Apple themselves,

1:17:19and what's in the best interest of the company.

1:17:22They're users, the people who buy the products, and then last, developers.

1:17:27That they do want to do well by all three, but the order tends to be

1:17:31Apple first, user second, developer's third.

1:17:35Here's a case where I think they're putting a user first.

1:17:41Yeah.

1:17:43I guess...

1:17:47Well, yeah, I guess. I mean, they're putting the happiness of the users ahead, because they think that that's a longer term.

1:17:52And art for their own success, right?

1:17:54And arguably developers, too, right? So, like, you know, Netflix is a developer.

1:17:59And the fact that Netflix can get their thing listed before iTunes's version of the same movie is good for them.

1:18:07I think it's, you know, I'm not surprised, you know, it seems obvious, you know, it made my wife roll her eyes,

1:18:14because it seems so obvious that this is the way it should be.

1:18:18But you just know that there's a lot of little decisions

1:18:20that Apple sometimes makes that don't

1:18:23show that sort of priority.

1:18:24Right.

1:18:26So yeah, that was cool.

1:18:28How do you like the Netflix app?

1:18:29I thought it was great.

1:18:32And I always thought that the old Apple TV Netflix app

1:18:35was sort of crap.

1:18:37And what else do we have?

1:18:40Like Netflix, because Netflix is so device agnostic, right?

1:18:44They've got no box of their own.

1:18:46There's no Netflix box.

1:18:47So they just wanna be everywhere, right?

1:18:49They're built into TVs.

1:18:51I was at a family member's house

1:18:53for a kid's birthday party or something a couple months ago.

1:18:58And somebody had Netflix built into their TV.

1:19:01Like it wasn't like a box connected to their TV.

1:19:04Like their TV--

1:19:04- I have that.

1:19:05I have that.

1:19:06I could do Netflix on my TV.

1:19:07I would any, which is bananas.

1:19:10- It doesn't make any sense to me

1:19:11because I don't, I'm just out of touch

1:19:13on how computerized TVs are out of the box.

1:19:16So Netflix is everywhere,

1:19:19and with varying degrees of quality.

1:19:21But I've always thought Apple TV

1:19:22was actually one of the worst ones.

1:19:24It just seemed a little, I don't know, half-assed.

1:19:29- So I'm not sure how much it could have done,

1:19:33because all of the old Apple stuff was basically this,

1:19:36it's like a markdown language.

1:19:39Sort of like HTML, but specifically just for doing

1:19:42those kind of Apple TV apps, which is why they all kind of look the same and

1:19:46we're kind of bland. Well, I always thought though that their streaming

1:19:49wasn't that great either. Yeah. I mean if you just hit play and you wait a couple

1:19:55seconds and then just play it right through it goes but you know you couldn't

1:19:58fast forward or rewind worth a shit. Yeah, I think I just gave up trying to be

1:20:02honest. Well, and I'm trying to remember the last time I was frustrated by that

1:20:06and then I'm actually thinking like you know what I just don't think I bother.

1:20:09Well, and who wonders how long Netflix has been working with Apple on the new Apple TV?

1:20:15Because we know that the Apple TV, this Apple TV, the new one, the good one, has been in the works for a while.

1:20:21And it seems like Apple and Netflix have a pretty good relationship for companies that more or less could be seen as competitors.

1:20:29I'm not aware of any weird animosity stuff.

1:20:35Netflix was there day one. They were on the phone. They were on everywhere.

1:20:39And Netflix was on the old Apple TV very early on as one of the very first third-party partners that got that sort of relationship.

1:20:47Yeah, I have a feeling that Netflix thinks its fight is with HBO.

1:20:51Yeah, definitely.

1:20:53And it doesn't want it, you can't fight a two-front war, right?

1:20:57Like you can't take on all of the technology players and

1:20:59like people like HBO or AMC in that.

1:21:01>> Yeah.

1:21:02Well, I think it's partly with HBO, but then there's a bunch of HBOs now.

1:21:07And I also think that what Netflix sees is that one of their biggest

1:21:13competitors is the fact that there's only so much time in the day.

1:21:19And it's really that they've got a fight to make it worth your time, you know, that for a couple of hours every month, you're going to find something good to watch on Netflix.

1:21:28Yeah, that's huge. And that way of looking at media is super interesting too, because that means video games can gobble up your TV.

1:21:36Right. Just the amount of time, yeah. Just the amount of--there's only so much--everybody's got to go to sleep at some point.

1:21:43finite amount of time and what are they going to do?

1:21:45Well, if it's messing around on Twitter, then guess what?

1:21:47They're not watching whatever it is,

1:21:50your friends' reruns or something.

1:21:51- Yeah.

1:21:53So I don't know, I think that the video playback is great

1:21:55and I know that it's going to be,

1:21:57I'll take it for granted soon enough,

1:21:59but at this point, I'm just,

1:22:00I'm thrilled every time I fast forward and rewind.

1:22:04- Yeah, it is really good.

1:22:05They've done an amazing job with this little device.

1:22:07Oh, did you, this is a weird one

1:22:09that you probably didn't notice.

1:22:11go to the main menu.

1:22:15Okay. Home screen. Just put the remote down for, wait a bit.

1:22:19Everything will dim, except for the icon that you've got focused.

1:22:23It'll have like a spotlight on it. And then as soon

1:22:27as you move the remote, move it, just nudge it,

1:22:31the screen won't go back to normal. And they're using the accelerometer

1:22:35inside the remote. Right. And when you put it down like on a coffee table or

1:22:39or a couch, it is perfectly still.

1:22:41- Yeah, exactly.

1:22:42- So even like the difference between being perfectly still

1:22:47because it's resting on your coffee table

1:22:48versus it's in your hand, but you're not moving your hand,

1:22:52it knows that it's in your hand.

1:22:54- Exactly, it's just really nice.

1:22:57It's a weird little touch, but it's just really cool.

1:22:59Also, I love that they put an accelerometer in that thing.

1:23:03For no apparent reason that we can see from the UI, right?

1:23:08Right?

1:23:09Yeah, well not in their UI, but it's obviously, you know, we can get into games, you know,

1:23:14later as we work towards the end of this.

1:23:17But I wonder though, I wonder though if they would have put an accelerometer in the remote

1:23:22if they hadn't been thinking about games.

1:23:24I don't know.

1:23:26I mean, why do they use it?

1:23:27They don't use it.

1:23:28Except for that nice little touch.

1:23:30So I don't know.

1:23:34I'm super happy that they put it in there.

1:23:36Yeah.

1:23:37What do you think about the screensavers?

1:23:40I love them. I think they're so gorgeous. They're like hypnotic.

1:23:43Yeah, I can't get enough of them.

1:23:45I have a...

1:23:47My old screensaver is a shared thing, but it's just photos of

1:23:53Indy, like Vicky's dog, basically.

1:23:55And he's so cute, so I love watching that.

1:23:57But I feel kind of bad, because now I just leave the standard city screen

1:24:02viewers, screensavers.

1:24:04And they are gorgeous.

1:24:07I don't know how they shot those, but it's amazing.

1:24:09Yeah, there's something.

1:24:11It would be a great-- well, they're Apple,

1:24:14so maybe they won't.

1:24:15But with new Apple, you never know.

1:24:16It would be interesting if they did

1:24:18one of those little behind the scenes things

1:24:20that they sometimes do and just showed how they made them.

1:24:23Because it really caught Jonas's eye, too.

1:24:26He even asked the question, how did they do this?

1:24:28Because it somehow looks different than the footage

1:24:32that you typically see shot out of like a helicopter.

1:24:35- Yeah, I don't know if it's drones or if it's a helicopter,

1:24:40but shot at a super high frame rate.

1:24:42- Right.

1:24:43- But it's not actually, 'cause you can see cars

1:24:44driving down the street at some point.

1:24:45- Yeah, there's definitely some kind of high frame rate,

1:24:50but it definitely is not like a static image.

1:24:54I guess it's drones?

1:24:55The New York Times had a piece this week

1:24:59on the way that Greenland is melting at an alarming rate.

1:25:03Yeah.

1:25:04And the team of researchers from, I

1:25:08think it was like the University of Wisconsin, whoever it was,

1:25:10doing this.

1:25:12It was an amazing story just to hear about what they're doing

1:25:15and the danger, just the danger of going up there

1:25:18and having this water rush by.

1:25:20Like if the ice you're standing on

1:25:22to measure the temperature of the water cracked and went in,

1:25:24you-- like they said, the chance of death is 100%.

1:25:28There's nothing that anybody would be able to do to save you.

1:25:31Kind of terrifying.

1:25:33Certainly has a sense of being at the end of the world.

1:25:36You're up here and all you see is ice and stuff like that.

1:25:40So it's a great story in general, really interesting,

1:25:42fascinating.

1:25:42But the thing that really captivated me

1:25:44was the video footage they had from these drones.

1:25:47And it just occurred to me-- and they

1:25:49were talking about the budget concerns

1:25:50that these scientists have, that they're using taxpayer money.

1:25:55And it's just really, really tight budget.

1:25:58Like, every single dollar had to be accounted for just to get--

1:26:02and some of the stuff is so expensive.

1:26:04It was like $5,000 an hour for the helicopter that drove them to--

1:26:08or flew them to where they were going.

1:26:11It just occurred to me that even just like 10 years ago,

1:26:13there's no way they would have gotten any kind of aerial video footage.

1:26:17Because of-- drones have absolutely fundamentally

1:26:22changed the type of footage we get.

1:26:25it's like video footage that would have cost,

1:26:28that would have been like in the budget

1:26:29of like a $20 million documentary film.

1:26:33Now a team of university researchers

1:26:35can get just as good at footage.

1:26:37- Yeah, it's pretty amazing.

1:26:39- There is a certain smoothness to drone footage

1:26:41that I guess that's what Apple use,

1:26:43but I don't know, these screensavers are--

1:26:45- They look great, yeah.

1:26:47Did you hear, just because we're in the weeds here,

1:26:50researchers were using drones

1:26:54to check out bears hibernating,

1:26:56but the drones would wake them up.

1:26:57- Oh.

1:26:58- So we screwed up a bunch of bears.

1:27:01- It's like some kind of Heisenberg joke insert there.

1:27:08(laughing)

1:27:10And it's funny too to think about,

1:27:13'cause I'll bet the bears were annoyed.

1:27:16- Yeah, it's this buzzing thing hanging around here.

1:27:18Of course you're gonna be like, what is this?

1:27:20This is not natural.

1:27:22- Bears just seem like the type of animal

1:27:24just don't want to annoy.

1:27:26(laughs)

1:27:27- So you send a robot to do it for you.

1:27:29- Right.

1:27:30Like imagine if you were on a hike

1:27:31and you had nothing to do with the drones

1:27:33or the research, you're just in bear country.

1:27:35(laughs)

1:27:36And now there's like a bunch of angry bears

1:27:38that got woken up in the middle of their hibernation.

1:27:42- Oops.

1:27:45- I've always been a little jealous of bears.

1:27:49- Why, 'cause the people they can--

1:27:51- Hibernating sounds like the best thing.

1:27:55Like, doesn't that just seem great?

1:27:57Like, just skip winter.

1:27:59- Yeah.

1:28:00- You just skip it.

1:28:01- Sounds pretty luxurious.

1:28:02- Yeah.

1:28:03- I mean, I'm sure like the realities of it are not great,

1:28:05but...

1:28:06- Oh man, I bet, you know,

1:28:08they've got all that fat in the fur.

1:28:10- Yeah.

1:28:10- They're nice and warm.

1:28:11I think, you know, it's like getting to be like,

1:28:14you know, late November, starting to get cold.

1:28:16You make one good kill, have a good meal.

1:28:20And then you're like, you know what?

1:28:21- You know what, that was it.

1:28:23You're like, that was it, that was a good rabbit

1:28:25I just ate and then you just go and next thing you know,

1:28:27man, you just sleep for four months.

1:28:29That'd be awesome.

1:28:30- That does sound pretty good.

1:28:32- I read, I do remember reading once

1:28:35'cause I'm fascinated by it, by hibernation.

1:28:40I wish I could, I would do it.

1:28:41That'd be great, just shut the daring fireball down

1:28:43for four months just, you know, hibernating.

1:28:46I'll just put up a thing, you know, sleeping.

1:28:49And then just wake up and it's spring, right?

1:28:50You just skip all the no sunshine, skip the sun going down at five at night, skip the cold temperature.

1:28:59It is weird. Do they wake up ever?

1:29:01Yeah, they do. That's the thing I was going to say. They don't actually sleep continuously for four months.

1:29:06They do wake up and take a piss every once in a while.

1:29:10Oh, so they even move?

1:29:12Yeah.

1:29:13Oh, okay. So it means...

1:29:15Well, that makes sense.

1:29:18it's like the equivalent of waking up in the middle of the night though and going

1:29:21to the bathroom. Yeah, and then just going back. Just on a four-month schedule. You

1:29:25just wake up and you know maybe get it. Man, that sounds like the lap of luxury.

1:29:29Get a drink of water. Yeah, that does sound pretty good. I just like sleeping.

1:29:35I don't know, sounds good. Speaking of going to sleep, our next sponsor has nothing to do with

1:29:45sleep whatsoever. It's mail route. These are the guys, these are email nerds and

1:29:50the company does nothing but email. Kind of almost maniacal, single-minded focus.

1:29:58They do services, cloud-based filtering solution for email and that's all that

1:30:04they do. So long story short, if you have a domain that you get your own email

1:30:10from, you have an email server running somewhere like a web host or maybe it's

1:30:14a company and you have your own servers in the building or something like that.

1:30:17It doesn't matter what your back end is, doesn't matter whether you're running Linux or Unix

1:30:22or if you've got like a Microsoft system or something like that.

1:30:27You can use mail route because you don't really, it's not software that you install on your

1:30:31server.

1:30:33It's a DNS type thing.

1:30:34So you go in to your domain and you set your DNS records for mail to point your domain

1:30:41at mail route first.

1:30:43and in your mail route account, you tell your mail route account where your actual email

1:30:47server is. So then it's just simple. Email comes in. Mail route doesn't host your email.

1:30:52They don't run mail servers. They're just a little DNS filtering service. The mail comes

1:30:56in. Mail route takes all the crap out. All the spam, all the junk, anything that has

1:31:02like viruses or fishy attachments and stuff like that. They filter all that out and then

1:31:09the email immediately goes just right to your server.

1:31:13So now your server, you haven't done anything

1:31:14to your server, you haven't changed a damn thing.

1:31:16All you've done is changed your DNS records.

1:31:18But then all of a sudden, the inboxes for all of your users,

1:31:22whether it's like me and you've got one person

1:31:26at daringfireball.net, one email,

1:31:29where it's a big company and you've got thousands of people,

1:31:32all of a sudden the inboxes for every account

1:31:34on your system have all the crap just filtered out.

1:31:38It's amazing and it's super, super accurate,

1:31:40really, really good.

1:31:41This is all this company does.

1:31:43They've got great stuff on our website.

1:31:46You can read about some of the stuff they do

1:31:48to have this incredibly highly tuned spam filtering engine.

1:31:53It's just amazing.

1:31:55And they have really cool features too.

1:31:57They have stuff that can send you, you can configure it.

1:32:00So if you wanna get it once a day, you get it once a day,

1:32:03you can get it like every week,

1:32:04but you can get a report from them

1:32:06that would list all of the maybes.

1:32:10Like here's 10 emails that we filtered out today

1:32:12that we're pretty sure are spam,

1:32:13but maybe these aren't, take a look at 'em,

1:32:15and then if you see one every once in a while,

1:32:17like when you buy something online,

1:32:19like for me sometimes the receipt for whatever you bought

1:32:22often gets hit by a spam filter or something like that.

1:32:24I think mail routes filtering is amazingly accurate.

1:32:27Nothing's perfect, but then you get this report,

1:32:29you've got this peace of mind

1:32:30where you've got this real nice easy thing to scan

1:32:33just to make sure that nothing's getting filtered

1:32:35that you didn't wanna get filtered,

1:32:36And if they do make a mistake, it's like two clicks.

1:32:38And OK, we know that's not spam, and it won't happen again.

1:32:41Really, really good.

1:32:44They've got-- as a typical user, their default,

1:32:47you could just hook it up, let it go, forget it,

1:32:49don't worry about it.

1:32:50You're done.

1:32:50If you are an IT professional, if you're

1:32:53the sort of person out there who runs

1:32:54the email for your company, they've got all sorts of APIs,

1:32:58anything you want.

1:32:59If you really do want to get down and dirty

1:33:01and deal with the code and hook it up and connect it

1:33:04things. They've got all sorts of stuff. Go check them out. Here's where you go. Go to mailroute.net/tts

1:33:15like the talk show, just tts, and you will get a free trial. And if you use that code /tts

1:33:22on the domain, when you do sign up, you save 10% for the lifetime of your account. So you could

1:33:29use this and 10-15 years from now, you'll still be saving money thanks to the talk show. So my thanks

1:33:34thanks to them, go check them out.

1:33:35Really, really great service, I personally recommend it.

1:33:38All right, what else we got on Apple TV?

1:33:42Oh, here's one I noticed, and speaking of games.

1:33:48Here's one I noticed, and I can't believe,

1:33:52this one is maybe the first thing that I encountered

1:33:55that surprised me.

1:33:56So we did the thing like I talked about, where we,

1:34:00okay, you have a new Apple TV, use your iPhone,

1:34:04and it'll send your WiFi password and your Apple ID

1:34:08and stuff like that.

1:34:09All work great, but for Game Center,

1:34:12that means that our Apple TV is me.

1:34:15And when we launch a game that is Game Center integration,

1:34:18it says, "Hello, Gruber."

1:34:19And it doesn't seem like there's any easy way to switch.

1:34:23Like it seems to me like it oughta be like PS4 and Xbox,

1:34:28where you can set up multiple profiles

1:34:31that Jonas can easily, when he's playing a game, easily switch to his Apple ID and not

1:34:37have to log out and log in and type his password, which is ridiculous. It seems like you should

1:34:42be able to have multiple Game Center profiles. I understand why you don't on an iOS device,

1:34:46because they're designed to be personal. And I know that a lot of people wish that the

1:34:51iPad in particular could have multiple user accounts. But that's just not how they're

1:34:56designed. But Apple TV, by definition, is designed to be used by everybody who lives

1:35:00in the same household. I agree. I think it's a big oversight. I'm really surprised. I mean,

1:35:05I can't help but think that they know about it. And even given all the time that they've

1:35:08spent working on it, I just can't help but hope that this is just, "Well, we didn't get

1:35:13to that yet." Yeah. Well, I have to assume it's "we didn't get to that yet." But I'm

1:35:17not entirely sure how closely tied the Game Center account is to your Apple ID. If you

1:35:24switch to the Game Center account, it should be totally separate, right? It is. Yeah. And

1:35:29You can also do the same thing like with the iPhone.

1:35:33You can have a different iTunes store account

1:35:35from your iCloud account.

1:35:38So if you, like I do, like a dummy,

1:35:41I have an Apple ID that I use for iCloud.

1:35:44This is the thing I get email from.

1:35:45It's the address where you can send me iMessages.

1:35:48But I have a different account for my store purchases.

1:35:52I think there's a lot of, like,

1:35:53people who've been using iTunes

1:35:54since the early days of the store,

1:35:55a lot of people might have that type of setup.

1:35:57- It's weird.

1:35:58I started with an iTunes account.

1:36:01Yeah, iTunes. I remember iTunes.

1:36:04Was the domain iTunes back then or did they not even have email?

1:36:09I can't remember.

1:36:13For me it was...

1:36:14I do know that I give everybody, like my Mac.com is what I give everybody,

1:36:18despite the fact that it's...

1:36:20Here's one thing that bugs me.

1:36:22Mac and Me and iCloud and all of their experimental stuff down into one account.

1:36:27They just counted all of the same.

1:36:34But other services don't.

1:36:36So I'll get a Google invite to a Google group and it'll be like my @me account.

1:36:39I can't log in because it's .Mac or I used iCloud.

1:36:44It's frustrating.

1:36:49Yeah, it's the penalty of not having the foresight to pick the right one.

1:36:51not having the foresight to pick the right domain

1:36:54off the start.

1:36:56Compare and contrast with Google, who nailed it, right?

1:36:59It was, it used to be that Google didn't have any way

1:37:02that you could get email from them.

1:37:04And then low one April Fool's Day, they said,

1:37:07"Okay, now we have a thing called Gmail,

1:37:10"and you can sign up for whatever you want at gmail.com."

1:37:13And 10 years later, it's exactly the same,

1:37:17and you've never had to worry about it.

1:37:18They didn't change it to Google Mail,

1:37:19they didn't change it to @Google.

1:37:21Last month, they didn't change it to Alphabet or AML.

1:37:24That's what Amy gets, Amy gets AML.

1:37:29You know, they just got it right the first time

1:37:33and nobody ever has to worry about it.

1:37:35And you know, like I still use the Mac.com too,

1:37:38but every once in a while, for whatever reason,

1:37:40it's like something will come in to me.com and--

1:37:44- Yeah, it gets annoying.

1:37:45- Yeah, and like you said, other services don't see that

1:37:48just being the synonyms for the same email account.

1:37:51Yeah. And I know that they--so they rebranded them.

1:37:55Because they're like, "Okay, that last one sucked." And they've done that three times now.

1:38:00But it's just collateral damage for long-term users. Every time they change it up, it's like, "Ah, man."

1:38:06Yeah. I like sticking with the Mac.com one, just out of nostalgia.

1:38:10But that was the name that was the most short-sighted.

1:38:14known that they were going to use this for more than just the Mac. Yeah. Oops. Well, anyway, you can

1:38:22have a different ID for the store than for your iCloud. So to get like your photos and stuff in

1:38:28through the photo syncing, you can have a different account for that and you can have a different

1:38:32account for Game Center. It defaults to whichever one you use when you first set it up because for

1:38:37most people that's the right thing is they're going to use the same ID for all of those things.

1:38:42But it doesn't seem like there's any way-- unless I miss something-- it doesn't seem like there's any way to switch Game Center accounts.

1:38:47It does fuel it, not in a point of release, but eventually a multi-user system would make a lot of sense for the TV, right?

1:38:56Yeah, it seems like it. Because it really does seem-- and Netflix has a pretty good thing for that,

1:39:02where you can tell Netflix how many people are in your family, and right when you launch the app, who's watching?

1:39:07- Yeah, it even asks me, it says guy or kids,

1:39:10and I don't even have any kids, but I'm like, still me.

1:39:14I think I use kids when I'm babysitting,

1:39:17like my friend's kid or something.

1:39:19- Right, and keep them out of the, you know.

1:39:22- Well, it's not like there's anything crazy on there.

1:39:24- Well, I wasn't even thinking crazy,

1:39:26but with kids, I mean, even like,

1:39:28depending on how young they are, even like PG-13 stuff is--

1:39:31- Yeah, yeah, there can be some pretty scary stuff, yeah.

1:39:33- I mean, you don't wanna have kids

1:39:36watching Indiana Jones eat the monkey brains.

1:39:38- Yeah, exactly.

1:39:39Well, especially when I'm babysitting.

1:39:41- Right.

1:39:42- Which is like, just don't screw this one up.

1:39:45- I was guy, it was great,

1:39:47you made me watch a man eat a monkey's brain.

1:39:50And then all of a sudden you're in trouble.

1:39:52You're like, it's Indiana Jones.

1:39:53- Yeah, so that needs to change at some point.

1:39:58'Cause that would, that affects a lot of stuff, right?

1:40:01'Cause if you can change users,

1:40:03then suggestions can change.

1:40:06Basically system-wide you can start doing more interesting stuff.

1:40:10Like the apps on the home screen can change.

1:40:13Yeah, totally.

1:40:15You don't necessarily want Minecraft or whatever.

1:40:18I can't even think of anything.

1:40:20But a pile of stuff that Jonas wants, you don't necessarily want, right?

1:40:24Right. I think in the long run,

1:40:27almost any and all games that we end up with this thing are going to be for Jonas, not for me.

1:40:31I mean, so in some sense...

1:40:33I mean, he doesn't want to see Wall Street Journal video thing.

1:40:37Like the whole things DE conference is not necessarily going to be tuning into that all the time.

1:40:43I don't know why.

1:40:49It's just me and you, so I'll brag.

1:40:51But I was happy when I installed Cannibalt.

1:40:54And I got Cannibalt from the list of...

1:40:56I guess they've made it... what are they calling it?

1:40:58it a universal, it's not a universal binary, but like a universal download. So like if

1:41:02you already own it, you can just download it for free. So it was like, here's all the

1:41:05apps I've already purchased that have Apple TV apps today. And I went to Cannibal. And

1:41:10the app description for Cannibal starts with a quote from me about how nice a game it is,

1:41:16which is really close. And I look at Jonas and I was like, yeah, and Jonas, he just looked

1:41:22at me and he was like, doesn't even mention you by name, it just says "Daring Fireball."

1:41:29I was like, I was trying to impress you.

1:41:31He was like, wow, that's not impressive.

1:41:34He's got a good head on his shoulders though.

1:41:36I know you're proud and that's awesome, but it's good that he's not like...

1:41:40No, he is not wild at all.

1:41:42He is not impressed.

1:41:43I thought it was pretty cool though.

1:41:46But I also think it's cool because I am obviously not very well known for my game reviews.

1:41:50I don't play many games.

1:41:53And so I think that's what made it so surprising to me.

1:41:57I think if you added up all of the games I've even mentioned

1:42:01in what, 13 years of writing Daring Fireball,

1:42:05you probably still might have some fingers to spare.

1:42:08Certainly wouldn't use up all your fingers and toes.

1:42:11It's gotta be less than 20.

1:42:13- Yeah, yeah, you don't talk about games much at all.

1:42:15- So I thought that was pretty cool.

1:42:16- Yeah, so Cannonball's cool.

1:42:20Adam put in quite a bit of work to get that working.

1:42:23Not quite a bit of work.

1:42:24He spent like a week to get it working,

1:42:25but he had to do this UI focus thing.

1:42:28- Hmm.

1:42:28Yeah, it's actually, there is sort of,

1:42:32'cause it's become a bigger game in some ways

1:42:35than it used to be.

1:42:36Like there's some kind of,

1:42:37I haven't played in a long time.

1:42:38Maybe the iPhone game has it too,

1:42:39but like at the beginning there,

1:42:40you can select like a level or something.

1:42:43I didn't even know.

1:42:43I only played the default again, but it was excellent.

1:42:47So he did have to do work.

1:42:48You know him?

1:42:49- Yeah, yeah.

1:42:50- Oh, I didn't know that.

1:42:51- Yeah, I've worked with him before.

1:42:52- Yeah, it translates very well.

1:42:54And it's, you know--

1:42:55- It does, yeah, it's great.

1:42:57Alto's Adventure is good, you know, try out that one.

1:43:00- All right, I haven't heard of it.

1:43:02I've never heard of this game.

1:43:03- It's a snowboarding one.

1:43:04It's, again, similar kind of idea

1:43:06in that it's like an infinite runner

1:43:08if you're on a snowboard.

1:43:09- Is this the one that Syracuse is always

1:43:11talking about on ATP?

1:43:14- I don't know.

1:43:16- I think it is.

1:43:17And he talks about it in a way where I can just, I can hear him sighing at my ignorance of Alto's adventure.

1:43:24And I can hear him calling me an old man right now.

1:43:28Could be desert golfing, too. I know they talk about that.

1:43:31Oh, I know desert golfing. Son of a bitch, I came as addictive.

1:43:34I don't think that one would work on the TV, though, would it? I guess it could.

1:43:38I don't know. I don't know. Guess what? I haven't tried it.

1:43:42Interestingly, our pal Matt Colby and Nevin have got Space Age.

1:43:52I saw that. It was in my... It's one of the ones that I definitely know of.

1:43:57And it was in my list of, "Hey, you already own this thing."

1:44:03Yeah. So, I tried it for about two minutes last night. It was getting late by the time.

1:44:08It was way too lit, it wasn't making any sense.

1:44:11But it's interesting in that they do with the trackpad

1:44:15what you're suggesting and in that there is,

1:44:18there's a cursor on the screen that you move using

1:44:21and then you click because it's,

1:44:22Space Age works more like a standard,

1:44:27like an RTS game, right?

1:44:28- Right. - You've got units

1:44:29that you select and move them around.

1:44:31- Right. - So they've had to make

1:44:32affordances to get that on the TV.

1:44:35So you can scroll a view by holding down

1:44:36the play/pause button and then the trackpad will move the window around.

1:44:43And then if you're just not holding down the play/pause button, then you're moving effectively

1:44:47the mouse cursor around.

1:44:49Do they have a little first run tutorial where they tell you what to do?

1:44:52Yeah, they do.

1:44:53No, that makes sense.

1:44:54And I think for games, there's nothing wrong with a cursor.

1:44:58And I think for certain games, obviously, like for some of the strategy type games like

1:45:02where it makes all the sense in the world.

1:45:04What else was an interesting game?

1:45:10I was thinking about something else.

1:45:13Oh, forget it.

1:45:13But so, I guess one thing I'm surprised,

1:45:18there are a lot, there's a lot of games available already,

1:45:21day one, I think that's pretty impressive.

1:45:23And I think it's surprising how much some of them,

1:45:25this is where I was going,

1:45:26is I'm surprised at how many of them

1:45:28that were designed for a touchscreen device,

1:45:31like iPhone or iPad, actually seemed to translate pretty well to the trackpad device.

1:45:38Yeah, seems that way so far. Again, I've spent a day with it, so it's kind of hard to tell.

1:45:44But, I mean, so an infinite runner is a little bit easy, right? Because you hit a jump button.

1:45:51So, problem solved. But yeah, a lot of games seemed that they came over pretty well.

1:46:00I do have a, like my working theory is that like games will, it's like water, like they will take

1:46:12the form of whatever the platform best supports. So I think we'll start seeing some pretty

1:46:15interesting games in a while. But they will be tailored to this trackpad and the motion controller

1:46:22and the interaction that the TV has. Rather than being a port from something else, you know?

1:46:27Yeah, one of the games we got I don't know if it must be a port I think because anything that's out already had to

1:46:32Have been a port but we had this game called

1:46:34Manta manta core man TI co re it's a 3d space shooter

1:46:40You're this like the last surviving pilot of the you know

1:46:45The good guys and you're flying a spaceship in outer space and you know

1:46:50killing bad guys

1:46:54Graphically seems pretty good

1:46:56Jonas gave it a thumbs up

1:46:59You know, but this is more of a serious game. This is like a game game

1:47:03Real 3d and the controls I had to let Jonas play because I was so bad

1:47:08It was I hear you play you play and I'll watch but the controls are accelerometer based

1:47:14And so you steer the ship in 3d

1:47:17by the motion of the device and

1:47:22Jonas got the hang of it pretty quickly. He was doing pretty good

1:47:25He had or at least he clearly had control over the ship and then you flick up

1:47:29To do like a speed boost and you flick down on the trackpad to slow

1:47:34and

1:47:36It shoots automatically so you don't have to fire trigger if if there's bad guys in the sights of your gun

1:47:44It just fires

1:47:47Which is to me all told for you know to me. What is a complicated idea a 3d space shooter?

1:47:53a pretty good simplification for a simple remote yeah

1:47:58accelerometer to move

1:48:01Flick up for fast down for slow, and you don't have to worry about a trigger it just shoots

1:48:06Yeah, it seems to make sense. I'm gonna check that one out tonight

1:48:09Yeah, and it's cool to you know

1:48:13just a cool little thing to me is that and it's you know I know it's it's not

1:48:18the only game but it's obviously a trend the the protagonist is a woman oh cool

1:48:25it's you know and it doesn't seem you know they don't really make a big deal

1:48:28out of it it's just you know that this the woman it's you're the woman who's

1:48:31the last star pilot of whatever the good guys are calling it that's good awesome

1:48:35I mean it's arbitrary anyway so yeah why not you know I mean like right whatever

1:48:43It doesn't sound like there's enough story there that any kind of gender is going to make any kind of difference.

1:48:47Me having said that, just the last 40 seconds of the show, I'm not part of gamer gay now, am I?

1:48:54Don't get me started on gamer gay.

1:48:59I don't know. I just don't understand it.

1:49:01I don't know. I don't even understand it.

1:49:03I just worry that it's like, somebody says something like that, like, "Hey, that's pretty cool that the cool pilot is a woman."

1:49:08And then all of a sudden, you're part of a controversy that shouldn't be controversial.

1:49:12So anyway, I thought it was pretty cool.

1:49:14- Yeah, oh, Adam went back and added a female runner

1:49:19to time vault.

1:49:20- Oh yeah, I saw that, we got that,

1:49:21and you just get it randomly.

1:49:23- Yeah. - Yeah, we got that.

1:49:25- Yeah, that's cool.

1:49:28- Yeah, and just like a ninja, too.

1:49:31- Yeah, he had a few of them, yeah.

1:49:32- Yeah, and very nice, very, very nice touch.

1:49:34We got the Beat Sports game, which was pretty fun.

1:49:42I guess my biggest complaint about it is that it's so derivative of Wii Sports in certain

1:49:51ways that I feel like, okay, the basic concept of you having an accelerometer type control

1:49:57in your hand that you actually swing to make the player on screen swing at a ball.

1:50:03Okay, obviously that's the same idea, but I feel like you're allowed to do that without

1:50:09being called a ripoff, but they do little things that to me are like, it's like the

1:50:14crowd noise and the way that the levels start, it really feels like a little too close to

1:50:21"we" in style.

1:50:23The basic idea of the concept, okay, of course, the comparisons are inevitable.

1:50:28But some of the details, some of the sound effects are so Nintendo-like, it just seems

1:50:32a little "mm," makes me kind of grip my teeth.

1:50:36Yeah, it's one thing to do something in the spirit of another game, it's another thing

1:50:41to kind of just rip it off.

1:50:42Right, and even the name, when you say it out loud, Beat Sports sounds so much like

1:50:46Wii Sports that it's, I don't know.

1:50:49But it's a cool game, I have to say.

1:50:52I mean, just based on the name, you know what the pitch was in the room, right?

1:51:00The pitch was Wii Sports without any Nintendo intellectual property.

1:51:05Yeah.

1:51:06But that's another one too and it popped into my head here.

1:51:09I have it written down but it popped into my head because it's, what do they call it?

1:51:15It's like instead of a Wii, it's your beat or something.

1:51:19But anyway, your avatar.

1:51:21And it's, you know, a total range of skin tones and gender and outfits and, you know,

1:51:27another thing to me that's the way games ought to be.

1:51:30That's cool.

1:51:31Yeah, it's good to think of moving into that.

1:51:34your default though the default character is a girl if you don't if just like out of

1:51:39the box it's like she's I don't know what her name is but she must probably have some

1:51:42kind of name she's like their Mario I guess that's cool I mean yeah the problem with that

1:51:52game I'll just say the problem with the beat sports is that you can only have one Apple

1:51:57TV remote or Siri remote I guess they call it right so for one player you know it doesn't

1:52:03matter but when you play two player the way that you play two player is you have

1:52:08to download their free app for the phone and when you play two player it no

1:52:12longer becomes accelerometer based it it's all swipe based huh so one get one

1:52:19person plays on their phone the other person plays on the remote because I was

1:52:22wondering about it I was like I don't know accelerometer with the iPhones

1:52:26seems like a disastrous idea like as much as they're worried and Nintendo you

1:52:30I remember Nintendo had to send out those bracelets that you connect to the Wiimote.

1:52:36Yeah, Wiimote and the TV.

1:52:38Apple has one too.

1:52:39Apple has one for the...

1:52:40It doesn't come with it.

1:52:41You have to pay extra for it, but you can get a bracelet with it.

1:52:46And it connects to the lightning port and has like a little lock, so you have to squeeze

1:52:52it to get it out.

1:52:53Hmm, that's cool.

1:52:54Well, it just seemed to me like a terrible idea to be swinging your iPhone around like

1:52:58a paddle.

1:52:59They don't let you do that. It's all swipe based. But in other words, but then unlike Wii Sports, you're playing like a totally different game.

1:53:06It feels like when you're playing two-player instead of one-player.

1:53:10That's weird.

1:53:11I'm gonna have to give that a try because I mean changing the game mechanic is weird. Like those are just different games.

1:53:18Yeah, it's very different. But you know, like you said, it's just you so

1:53:22I don't have to worry about it. It's just one-player mode. The other thing, and Jonas picked up on this.

1:53:27This is it's been a lot of fun for me as a dad because Jonas is you know

1:53:31Really really into video games video games are his thing

1:53:33and

1:53:35so it was really it's been really fun for me playing with Apple TV with him and playing with the games because

1:53:40He's better at not just better at playing games, but he's a more astute

1:53:46Observer of the cleverness that's going on

1:53:49He picked up on the what beat sports is so the the thing about beat sports that is completely original and that's it

1:53:55And I think that's how they justify the name beat sports is that it's music based

1:54:01Christina Warren wrote about it too in her review of it that she called it like a

1:54:05mashup of Wii Sports and

1:54:08Guitar Hero

1:54:10so it's the timing and the timing is tied to the music of the game and

1:54:15So the moment when you're supposed to like if you're playing their version of tennis the moment you're supposed to hit the ball

1:54:20coincides to like a

1:54:24moment in the music where there's going to be like a sound the sound that it

1:54:28makes as you hit the ball is part of the music and so that's how you get your

1:54:32timing down your timing isn't so much about what you see your timing is more

1:54:37like what you hear yeah I love this kind of games like I wouldn't I wouldn't go

1:54:42so far as to say you could play with your eyes closed but it's the same way

1:54:45though that you definitely can't play with the sound off like if you turn the

1:54:49sound off you're not gonna you're not gonna get it it's not your timing is

1:54:52never gonna be right which is pretty interesting yeah there there's been a

1:54:56few cool games like that rez comes to mind from like 20 years ago but yeah

1:55:02it's like you if you're getting in the groove of the music you start doing way

1:55:06better John August actually had worked on the new

1:55:13karateka for iOS it is also musically rhythm based as you fight John August of

1:55:20screenwriting fame.

1:55:22Screenwriting fame, yeah.

1:55:24With Jordan Meckner, who built the original Kratica.

1:55:27Right, which was awesome.

1:55:29And Adam Lusigler did the ad.

1:55:31Yeah, it was terrific. He's got a great podcast, too.

1:55:34Script Notes?

1:55:36Script Notes is...

1:55:37I can't say enough good things about it. I love it.

1:55:39You know, it's funny, because when Marco was on the other week

1:55:42and we talked about Hello Internet and what a great podcast it was,

1:55:44it seemed... I don't know.

1:55:46Maybe I should do more recommendations like that.

1:55:48I don't listen to a ton of podcasts.

1:55:50But I got so much email from people who are like,

1:55:52"Wow, I never heard of this Hello Internet.

1:55:54No offense to you, this might be my new favorite podcast."

1:55:57And it's like, no offense taken.

1:55:59It's a great podcast. They're really cool.

1:56:01If you want another one, Script Notes, look it up.

1:56:04But with John August talking about the, you know...

1:56:07The screenwriting process, which is fascinating by itself.

1:56:09But if you're in a creative line of work, it's good anyway.

1:56:15Even if you're not in a movie business,

1:56:16in the movie business, even if you're not a writer,

1:56:19it's fascinating if you're just into,

1:56:21if there's any kind of creativity in your work,

1:56:24it's applicable, and great, great podcast.

1:56:28- Yeah, he's co-hosted with Craig Mason.

1:56:32- I will, I promise to forget to put it in the show.

1:56:35- Perfect.

1:56:36So-- - Script notes.

1:56:41- Do you have anything else, like specific?

1:56:44- Uh, I'm trying to think.

1:56:46I guess the thing that I've kind of,

1:56:49the review unit that I have now is,

1:56:53I ordered mine but since I knew I was getting one

1:56:55from Apple Thursday, I didn't pay the extra $17

1:56:59for the, to get another one delivered today

1:57:02'cause it seemed pointless.

1:57:03So the one I ordered I guess won't come

1:57:05'til next week sometime.

1:57:07And I guess what I'm regretting is that I didn't order

1:57:09the game controller.

1:57:10There was this one game controller that Apple was,

1:57:12I guess, sort of suggesting that you buy.

1:57:15forget what it was called.

1:57:17- That's interesting.

1:57:19- And Jonas, this is the thing,

1:57:20talking with Jonas about it,

1:57:21is are we gonna want a game controller for this or not?

1:57:24'Cause we have a PS4, so for anything,

1:57:26the games like Destiny and when Star Wars Battlefront

1:57:30comes out, it's gonna play games like that on the PS4.

1:57:35And so, the question of whether we,

1:57:40or we in particular, the Gruber household,

1:57:42want a game controller or more than one game controller,

1:57:45and whether lots of people are gonna want a game controller.

1:57:48I don't know.

1:57:49'Cause it seems to me like most of the games

1:57:50I've tried so far really seem meant for the Apple TV remote.

1:57:55- So there was a bit of a kerfuffle about that

1:57:57because originally they released the TV design doc

1:58:02saying that you could use third-party game controllers.

1:58:06Then they changed it to say that your game

1:58:09must support the Apple remote.

1:58:11Right. In other words, what they took out was, it definitely said it, and they changed

1:58:18it like 180 degrees. I think what you're trying to say is, it did say you can make a game

1:58:24that has to have a game controller. And maybe, I guess it would be like there'd be a warning

1:58:29in the store. Actually, I guess your Apple TV could know whether you have a controller

1:58:35paired or not. And they could just say, "Hey, this game requires a controller and you don't

1:58:39even have one paired with the game yet. Are you sure you want to buy this?" And then a

1:58:44day later, the language changed to the exact opposite and said, "Your game must be fully

1:58:51playable with the default remote."

1:58:53Yeah, which just destroys so many classes of games. I still think you'll get a lot of

1:59:03of cool games based on the remote,

1:59:05but until they fix that game controller issue,

1:59:10I think you're gonna be stymied.

1:59:12- Yeah.

1:59:13- Like you may have a chicken and egg,

1:59:14like what you're saying is like,

1:59:16I think if Jonas did see a lot of cool games

1:59:18that needed the controller, you'd be like,

1:59:19well, fine, let's get a controller.

1:59:22But I think it'll chicken and egg it in a weird way

1:59:24that nobody will make them 'cause they can't.

1:59:26- Right.

1:59:27- So.

1:59:28- Yeah, I don't know.

1:59:29I just wonder, I don't know, do you have one?

1:59:33controller? No. Yeah. I don't even understand. I'll probably buy one. I might buy one. I'm trying to see where the hell...

1:59:39It's... now that they don't have the Apple Store anymore, I don't even know where you go to

1:59:42find it. I just remember that when I went to buy it, it had like an option. Here, I'll just buy a new one.

1:59:48You know what I did find a bit confusing is it's hard to tell when you're in the iTunes store or

1:59:55when you're just looking at like a show that you own. Right. Here, the SteelSeries Nimbus wireless game

2:00:01controller is the one that Apple has as like a suggested add-on. Where was that?

2:00:12It was from here. Is that Logitech? I don't know. It's weird. It doesn't seem

2:00:21SteelSeries. You know what would be great if they could just support Xbox and PS4 controllers?

2:00:28That's what I was wondering about.

2:00:30Out of the box. It'll just detect them and...

2:00:32Yeah. And it seems like if they just supported those out of the box,

2:00:36it would solve a lot of the problem of X, Y, and Z.

2:00:40They're known commodities.

2:00:42Yeah, SteelSeries...

2:00:46I don't even know how you know which ones work with it,

2:00:51but Apple had one that they were selling and it was like $50.

2:00:57Well, I mean, check it out after some more software comes out.

2:01:01Yeah, so I don't know. I feel like this is one of the things that one day in, it's too early to tell whether everybody wants to get one or not.

2:01:10I don't know what made me get cheap and not get one.

2:01:13It doesn't sound like your usual play.

2:01:18I stare around the office here, my office, and it's just filled with things that I've spent $50 on, on the, on the notion of, well, why the hell not?

2:01:29And yet somehow, in this one particular instance, I didn't do it. And now I regret it.

2:01:35Did you get the 64 meg one?

2:01:37Oh, I got the big one.

2:01:38Yeah.

2:01:38Yeah.

2:01:39Now, you know what?

2:01:40I still am not entirely clear on what the benefit is.

2:01:45I just feel like for 50 bucks I might as well... I don't want to run out of space.

2:01:49Yeah, but they're selling them as two different units, right?

2:01:52Is that so that the lesser one

2:01:56makes you buy the bigger one? Is that it? They didn't want to come out with a $200 thing?

2:02:00I guess. I do wonder though, why not just have one?

2:02:07I guess that the margins are better enough.

2:02:11We talk about this with everything.

2:02:12Obviously, endlessly over the last year or two,

2:02:15about these 16 gigabyte iPhones, and how much

2:02:18does it cost Apple to get the 32 instead of 16?

2:02:22What are their costs?

2:02:24I mean, most people seem to think

2:02:26it only costs like a buck or two bucks or something

2:02:28at their scale to do it.

2:02:31The $50 difference between these two Apple TVs,

2:02:34it can't possibly be anywhere even close to $50 in difference

2:02:38for the memory.

2:02:40I mean, I say that without actually knowing,

2:02:43but it just seems almost impossible.

2:02:46- 50 bucks for any one component seems way, not likely.

2:02:50- Right, or even give them their usual 30 or 40% profit

2:02:54margins and so assume that the cost is $35 or something.

2:02:57It just doesn't seem right.

2:02:58Not when you can go and buy 32 gigs of really good

2:03:01flash memory from Amazon just as a card

2:03:04and it doesn't cost that much.

2:03:06So I don't know.

2:03:09And it just seems like it would be so much simpler.

2:03:11It would take out this whole decision.

2:03:13And the fact that there are people writing articles,

2:03:16which size Apple TV should you get,

2:03:18that shouldn't even be an issue.

2:03:21- Yeah, I agree.

2:03:23- I don't know.

2:03:24I just looked at it.

2:03:25I just pretend as though there's one new Apple TV

2:03:28and it costs $200 and 64 gigs of RAM.

2:03:30- Yeah.

2:03:32I'm curious to know which one is their primary.

2:03:36Not that they don't love all their kids equally, but you know what I mean?

2:03:41Did they set out to make the 32 gig about what they wanted and throw in extra memory?

2:03:46I guess, or maybe they really wanted to hit $150, and whatever the difference in the component

2:03:58cost is at $150, the 64 gig just doesn't make Tim Cook happy financially.

2:04:06So they did it.

2:04:07I don't know.

2:04:08But it just seems like it could have been an easier win.

2:04:11I do kind of understand why they still sell the old Apple TV for 69 bucks.

2:04:19Because I know that there are institutions like schools and stuff like that that use

2:04:23Apple TV just as like a brain dead thing to do airplay to. So you know you don't

2:04:30want you may not want that to spend an extra hundred bucks to get a awesome new

2:04:34computer that does all these things because all you're doing is using it as

2:04:37like an airplay terminal. And the difference is so it's massive right the

2:04:45difference between the old third gen Apple TV and this new one is obvious to

2:04:50anybody who might have any interest in buying one instantly.

2:04:53Whereas the difference between a 32 and 64 gig version

2:04:56of the same thing is not so obvious.

2:04:59- Yeah.

2:05:01- I'm also curious, I'm curious to see how it'll work.

2:05:05Maybe, 'cause one thing that's definitely true,

2:05:07and maybe that's the limit, you might know this,

2:05:08that your initial download, I think,

2:05:10has to be under 200 gigs, or 200 megs?

2:05:13- It's 200 meg, and you get up to two gigs

2:05:16with what they call on-demand resources.

2:05:18app slices, right?

2:05:20- Well, so app slicing is something different.

2:05:22App slicing will get you,

2:05:24app slicing means that you're not gonna be downloading

2:05:27assets for your iPhone onto your TV, basically.

2:05:32On demand resources means that,

2:05:34let's say in a game you can tag levels,

2:05:38and it'll only download the resources for that level.

2:05:42Or you've got four levels on auth,

2:05:44so all of the ice textures come down.

2:05:47And then three levels on Tatooine, so you can get rid of the ice textures and load the sand textures.

2:05:53You have up to two gigs of those available for your app.

2:05:59Yeah, and obviously they're enforcing it. I mean, I guess if you submit a binary that's over 200 megs, it probably doesn't even go through.

2:06:09Oh yeah, I don't know. They've been good about that since day one at the App Store where you couldn't, like,

2:06:17they wouldn't let you download stuff over sale that was over, I think, 10 megs, originally? Something like that?

2:06:23Yeah, I just sent you a link to something about that Manticore game I was talking about. You don't have to click it now.

2:06:27For all I know, it's going to start some kind of autoplay video, but...

2:06:31There we go. Oh, it looks nice.

2:06:35And if you go to Apple TV or apple.com/tv and then go to games and more,

2:06:43that's you know it's like the games and more section of the Apple TV site, they

2:06:49have a big picture of SteelSeries Nimbus wireless controller. I mean it's

2:06:52not you know obviously they're not putting one in the box, you're not

2:06:56giving you one, but they're also not shying away from showing it off. I feel

2:07:02I feel like this is the one thing that I just do not see how this is going to play out.

2:07:06Either game controllers are going to be a big deal for Apple TV or they're going to be non-existent.

2:07:10I don't know.

2:07:12I think they probably just didn't get their act together yet on it.

2:07:14I do think that the language that they originally had,

2:07:18that they want to allow you to have a game controller, is what they wanted.

2:07:22Right.

2:07:24And then somebody panicked and said, "Wow, can we do this? We can't get the store to check for the presence of a controller.

2:07:30the presence of a controller, we're going to get a bunch of people getting mad at us.

2:07:35Well, maybe just sort of the product marketing thing that they don't want to make it seem as though

2:07:42you need this thing that they're not even giving you.

2:07:46Yeah, sure. Even that.

2:07:48But something changed at the last minute.

2:07:51And as progressive as Apple is in a lot of ways, in some ways, they can be a pretty conservative company.

2:07:57in terms of promising something like that

2:07:59or distracting you with a message like that.

2:08:02They don't want to do it.

2:08:03So I guess the thing would be like,

2:08:07okay, take the lumps from the developers

2:08:09for changing the thing at the last minute.

2:08:11But at least we're not holding a time bomb here.

2:08:15- I have one more sponsor to thank

2:08:18now that we're near the end of the show

2:08:19and I want to do this right now and then we'll wrap up.

2:08:23It's our good friends at Harry's.

2:08:25You guys know Harry's.

2:08:26makes awesome shaving products. They make razors, they make the blades, they make

2:08:32shaving lotion that you can use after shave. Anything related to

2:08:36shaving, Harry's does it. They do it and they have great prices. I mean you can

2:08:43compare their prices to Amazon's for like Gillette blades and it really is

2:08:46half the price. And the way that they can do it is it's like as direct as it can

2:08:52They make their own blades in their own factory over in Germany.

2:08:56Like they bought an old like hundred-year-old blade factory.

2:09:01They make their own. They sell them right to you. There's no middleman involved.

2:09:04And right now they want me to tell you that they are an official partner of the Movember Foundation.

2:09:14Movember is a thing where it's like a charity thing to remind people and raise funds for men's health.

2:09:20You know, I guess types of cancer and disease that affect men.

2:09:26And so it's the Movember is for the month of November and guys grow mustaches to raise

2:09:33awareness for men's health issues.

2:09:35So it makes sense for Harry's to partner with that.

2:09:42Really cool stuff.

2:09:43They have got stuff at their website.

2:09:44You can check out more about that.

2:09:47So I really do recommend you check out their site.

2:09:48out the stuff about Movember and it you know everybody wants to cure these

2:09:53diseases so they're gonna give 1% of their sales and 1% of their time back to

2:09:59Movember for the whole month so if you've been putting it off even if you

2:10:02want to and this is another one of those things that is a terrific terrific gift

2:10:06so if you know your father your son any of the men in your life you want to buy

2:10:11shaving stuff to get them gift for Christmas go do it now do it in a month

2:10:15of November, Movember, whatever you want to call it. And some of the money is going to

2:10:19go to a really good cause in addition to the fact that you're going to get a super great

2:10:23quality product.

2:10:25Go to, here's where you go to do this, go to harrys.com, just spell it the way you think

2:10:31it's spelled, and enter the code "THETALKSHOW". That'll let them know you came from the show.

2:10:37It'll also save five bucks off your first order. They've just crossed their million

2:10:44customer mark. So that's amazing. There's already a million people who have tried Harry's

2:10:50and I'll bet most of them stuck with it because it's really a great way to do it. High quality

2:10:56product at half the price and you don't have to leave your house. Can't beat it. So my

2:11:03thanks to Harry's. Go there, check it out. Remember the code there is the talk show and

2:11:07you can get their starter kit for just 10 bucks with that code. Ten bucks and you get

2:11:11everything you need. Three Blades, your choice of shaving cream or shave gel and razor handle

2:11:18right to your door. Shipping is free by the way. So my thanks to Harry's. Anything else?

2:11:25Any other apps that you've seen? How about our friend James Thompson has built the first

2:11:29calculator. I think the slogan is the best calculator for your TV. True, right? And you

2:11:36You know James. James is a great guy. As long term as just about anybody could be.

2:11:43He's been writing. Peacock started like in the mid 90s, maybe even the early 90s for

2:11:48the Mac. It has been around forever. I love that Peacock is there on day one on the Apple

2:11:55TV App Store.

2:11:58He was on the watch day one too.

2:12:02Ways that I would have never foreseen the indie develop community evolving is like the idea that 20 years ago that James Thompson

2:12:10James Thompson would be writing for the TV.

2:12:12This was the first third party one I fired up to. I got a test flight for it and I was like, "Let's do this."

2:12:19I love it. Do I foresee the need to do math on my television? No.

2:12:26But of course I bought it and I'm glad it's there.

2:12:30And it's actually really well done, of course.

2:12:34He did a great job. I told him, "Man, I can't believe he got all those features in it."

2:12:38It was a rough first start. It's a rough stab at it.

2:12:42He was like, "Are you kidding? That is the world's most advanced television computer."

2:12:46Alright, we were talking about typing

2:12:50and you said that you can long press on a lowercase letter to have it pop up

2:12:54be uppercase temporarily and that you could guess that so I made a guess with

2:12:58pcalc that you could use the play button to be the equals key worked of course he

2:13:05thought it was it works of course it works that's awesome

2:13:09super smart what else is charging for it because he was debating on it was a buck

2:13:1499 okay what do you think it should cost I told him nine ninety nine ninety nine

2:13:22Wait, $999?

2:13:24Yeah, just go for it.

2:13:26I am Richard, just why not?

2:13:28But no, that buck and ninety-nine is good.

2:13:32I just want to hire a place to ask, basically, just because it's easier.

2:13:36I mean, not easier, but it's...

2:13:38It takes a lot of work to put these in. I don't know how many people are going to be buying apps.

2:13:44Yeah, I'm curious to see...

2:13:46That's a big question, and you know...

2:13:48Because TV, game consoles have,

2:13:53really it's one of the most well monetized,

2:13:56maybe the best monetized form of media.

2:13:59Whether it's gonna stay, who knows.

2:14:00But flagship games cost 50 or 60 bucks.

2:14:04I mean that's pretty standard.

2:14:06And that's the most expensive media

2:14:08that most people buy, right?

2:14:10Books don't cost 60 bucks.

2:14:11Movies, you never, movies are 15 bucks, or 20 at the most.

2:14:16Games are the only thing that is monetized at levels of like $50 or $60.

2:14:21Is that going to translate to Apple TV? I don't know about $50 or $60.

2:14:26It seems like a lot of them are around $10, though. Beat Sports is $10.

2:14:31That's good. That's what they started out on iOS, too, though.

2:14:36Right. I remember. That's exactly what I thought. I remember when there were a lot of apps that were $9.99 on iOS.

2:14:41iOS. Yeah, so we'll see. I'm super excited about this platform, more so than I was for

2:14:49the watch. Now, that could just be a sign that I don't have the imagination enough to

2:14:55figure out what I want to do with the watch, but as soon as they announced this TV, I had

2:14:59like eight different ideas that I wanted to write for it. Do you share that?

2:15:07I do too. I've never been super excited about the watch. I've been intrigued and I still

2:15:14do wear mine but I don't wear it every day. I foresee a bright future for it but I just

2:15:21don't think that Apple Watch was ever really squarely in the market for it. It's just not

2:15:28the sort of thing that speaks to me overall.

2:15:32- Yeah, fitness really.

2:15:34(laughing)

2:15:36- Right, like, you know, ultimately,

2:15:39once I stop wearing it every day,

2:15:42and there is this weird motivating thing

2:15:43where you wanna keep filling these circles every day

2:15:45and you get the streak going and you keep going

2:15:47and I'm sure people are more fit,

2:15:48but then once you stop wearing it every day

2:15:49and so because you didn't wear it every day,

2:15:51you definitely, by definition,

2:15:53have days where you don't fill the circles.

2:15:55It just means you don't care anymore.

2:15:57(laughing)

2:15:58- Yeah.

2:15:59- I don't know.

2:16:00It doesn't excite me that much.

2:16:01I'd a bigger screen to me is more exciting

2:16:04so yeah I'm super excited about this because it is

2:16:08it's like a little iOS computer

2:16:10hooked up to a giant shared experience

2:16:12yeah there's a lot of stuff you could do with this

2:16:15yeah and I'm really interested to see

2:16:18like with the iPhone and to me it's the most exciting

2:16:22since the iPhone because with the iPhone

2:16:26starting in 2008 the next year when the App Store opened

2:16:29and all of a sudden anybody could write apps.

2:16:32You got apps that Apple never would have thought of.

2:16:36And it took the platform in ways that nobody

2:16:40could have foreseen.

2:16:41And I think that's got to be inevitable with Apple TV.

2:16:46And yes, I know that there's ways that you can develop,

2:16:49and there's other devices that you can hook up to a TV.

2:16:53You can just have a gaming PC hooked up to a TV.

2:16:56and it's even easier or more open than an app store

2:17:01because anybody can, you don't even need an app store

2:17:03to get apps running on a thing.

2:17:05But people don't do it,

2:17:06and so it's not a big enough audience

2:17:09to make it worthwhile.

2:17:10Like I've never really heard of an app that somebody made.

2:17:12The only thing I've ever heard that's worthwhile

2:17:14with a gaming PC hooked up to a TV is playing games,

2:17:16PC games.

2:17:17I've never heard of anybody who did something

2:17:20truly original.

2:17:20Whereas I feel like with Apple TV,

2:17:22now there's this platform where there's gonna be

2:17:24millions of people who have them and who already know what apps are and already

2:17:29have an App Store account and I'm really curious to see what people do with it.

2:17:32Yeah, me too. Storehouse we didn't mention. Oh yeah, I have that and I... That looks

2:17:37great. Yeah, so Storehouse, to me it's... I didn't spend a lot of time with it

2:17:46but it really, it like breathes on TV in a way that,

2:17:51it's a great example of what makes Storehouse, Storehouse.

2:17:57Storehouse is you upload images in movies

2:18:01and you can add text too and make like an article,

2:18:03but it's not really like you're formatting a document.

2:18:06It's more like a way to build like a photo

2:18:10and video based slideshow, sort of?

2:18:14It's hard to describe.

2:18:15It's a story. It's a visual storytelling medium, basically.

2:18:19But I feel like on Apple TV, it really...

2:18:23it's sort of more like... okay, so you're not making

2:18:27a video. It's not like you're just making one video that plays. But it is sort of a way

2:18:31to turn your TV into like a... it's like a presentation.

2:18:35And, you know, if the pictures are good and the video is

2:18:39high quality, it's really, really gorgeous.

2:18:43- Storehouse is popular with a lot of professional photographers, do you?

2:18:46- Yeah. Yeah. So that's another one if you're out there, if you're just jotting down a list

2:18:50of apps to try on your new Apple TV as you listen to it, definitely try out Storehouse.

2:18:55Don't miss it. And it's a really great example to me. I'm so glad you mentioned it. It's

2:19:00somewhere written here in my notes for the show, but I'm glad you mentioned it. Because

2:19:04to me, it just sort of exemplifies the way that Apple TV is more than just a video box.

2:19:10is something different and new and more interactive and it isn't just about video that you hit

2:19:18play and pause. It can be something else.

2:19:20Yeah, and I'm really excited to see what that something else is.

2:19:25Yeah.

2:19:26Man, you could put these in stores. I guess, you know, like when you've got a little sign

2:19:34and you're saying what the, like a kiosk kind of situation.

2:19:39This is awesome for that.

2:19:43There's so many different ways to use this little computer

2:19:47that it's pretty crazy.

2:19:49Cheap too, it's like the cheapest iOS device.

2:19:53- Yeah, it totally is, I don't know.

2:19:55So wrapping up, looking at my notes, here's the other thing.

2:19:58So I asked Jonas what he thought of the graphics

2:19:59and we didn't look at all the games.

2:20:01I mean, but we looked at enough.

2:20:03Jonas's estimation was that to him it looked, it's clearly not as good as PS4, but he thought

2:20:09it was better than PS3.

2:20:11So he pegged it, he pegged the graphic fidelity of the games as in between PS4 and PS3.

2:20:19That's why I wanted to ask you, because that's just Jonas eyeballing it, right?

2:20:23And looking at frame rates and how much texture and how rich it is.

2:20:29What do you think about that as being someone who's sort of actually, you know, like...

2:20:32I think that that's probably a fair estimation. I'd say that they're about equal with the previous generation of consoles.

2:20:37Now, I can't remember all of the exact specs.

2:20:45I don't know, maybe they get outperformed in some way.

2:20:50But what you see on the screen is what counts, right?

2:20:52So he feels good about it.

2:20:55He feels good about it.

2:20:56More interesting, next year, this is going to get faster.

2:20:57There's going to be a better one.

2:20:58- Right.

2:20:58- And the year after that, there's gonna be

2:20:59an even better one.

2:21:01And the year after that, things are gonna start

2:21:04looking bad for consoles.

2:21:05- Yeah, do you think--

2:21:06- 'Cause they have like a five to seven year life cycle.

2:21:09- Do you think that they will, at this point,

2:21:11Apple TV gets on the annual upgrade cycle?

2:21:15- I'd probably guess every two years, if I had to guess.

2:21:19- I do wonder.

2:21:20It's almost because it's like, and right now,

2:21:23it's on the A8 or A8X, but it's definitely

2:21:28So it's last year's top of the line Apple system on a chip.

2:21:33It seems as though one year later,

2:21:36they can make those chips like,

2:21:38they're just like cooking popcorn.

2:21:40I mean, they just, you know, I wouldn't be surprised

2:21:43that they just pop in a year old A series system on a chip

2:21:48every year and that it's not, it's almost,

2:21:52it's so little work for Apple that it,

2:21:54it would be foolish not to.

2:21:57Maybe. To me, it would only just come down to what's the disposition of the team and where they spend their time on.

2:22:06I might be overlooking the financial gains to be had by selling it for two years.

2:22:14However profitable this thing is at 149 right now, a year from now, the exact same device with a two-year-old A8 is even more.

2:22:22But I don't know. Because I just feel like the nerd in me just screams for, "I want the A9 that's in my iPhone 6s. I want it on my Apple TV next year."

2:22:33Yeah, I think it's a gimme. I mean, not necessarily next year, but obviously.

2:22:37Once you've got this baseline architecture now, they can start iterating it pretty quickly.

2:22:44How quickly they iterate is, I think, going to depend on business stuff.

2:22:47Because they may also not want to have a new TV every year.

2:22:54You know what I mean?

2:22:55The stuffs become negative implications.

2:22:57Every year I've got to go out and buy all my new Apple kit again.

2:23:00The iPad, I think, they kind of got trapped into doing it yearly

2:23:08when I think that they could have maybe stretched that out a little bit.

2:23:11Yeah, and they kind of, well, they haven't really, but they've done it sometimes.

2:23:16done it sometimes. Like for example, they didn't come out with a new iPad Air 2 this

2:23:19year. Whether that's just because they're going to wait until early next year or whether

2:23:24we have to wait a full year remains to be seen. And I've heard both ways. Maybe there

2:23:31will be an iPad Air 3 early next year, like on the old iPad schedule with a keyboard case

2:23:38sort of like the iPad Pro. I don't know, maybe not. But anyway, it's clearly a little different

2:23:44there. But on the other hand it would emphasize the differences that Apple has versus the traditional

2:23:53consoles and I know they're not going head-to-head against PS4 and Xbox and people who are really

2:23:58serious about games like as intrigued as Jonas is by the new Apple TV and he's I think he's

2:24:03downstairs playing games on it right now if I told him we're getting rid of our PS4 he'd you know he'd

2:24:08- Yeah, disowned you. - Call a lawyer.

2:24:10- Call a lawyer.

2:24:11(laughing)

2:24:13- I need to get a divorce from my dad.

2:24:15- Ouch.

2:24:16- Like that would not fly.

2:24:19- Yeah.

2:24:20But you know, I have a lot of excitement for the platform

2:24:25and where it's gonna end up going.

2:24:28Because this is a super capable little computer.

2:24:31- Yeah.

2:24:33Well, and the other thing too,

2:24:33you alluded to this a couple minutes ago,

2:24:35where if you project forward three or four years,

2:24:38They are going to surpass.

2:24:39They're going to make a little Apple TV puck that is more powerful than a Sony Playstation.

2:24:44Whether it's still the PS, they're going to catch the consoles.

2:24:47They're going to catch it up.

2:24:49Have you seen the graph?

2:24:50I know you have, but the performance graph is bananas.

2:24:53They're going to catch them pretty soon.

2:24:56So that's bad news for the console guys.

2:24:58Right.

2:24:59There's only one step forward on pixels, and that's going to 4K.

2:25:04And after that, the pixels don't change.

2:25:07So the graphics capabilities that they can do every year after year,

2:25:11they don't have to worry about driving bigger displays. It's, you know,

2:25:14it's all just raw speed. It's just raw speed. Uh,

2:25:18I guess that's the last thing. If there's anything else is,

2:25:20do you think it's a mistake that this, this Apple TV doesn't support 4k?

2:25:24No, I don't think 4k is a gimmick. I think at this point it is.

2:25:29Sorry. Yeah. Unpack that. I mean, no, it's not a gimmick obviously,

2:25:33but right now I think it's a,

2:25:34I think it's one of those high-end features that some people want and clamor for and say

2:25:39that they demand, but the actual market doesn't require it yet.

2:25:44Dave: Yeah.

2:25:46Too few actual 4K TVs in use, way too little video that's encoded in 4K out there.

2:25:54Obviously, it's going to happen eventually.

2:25:57At some point between now and 10 years from now, we're all going to have 4K TVs and everything

2:26:00we stream will be 4K, but I don't think there's any reason for it now.

2:26:04My only thought though is that it kind of makes me think that they might be on an annual schedule than a bi-annual schedule,

2:26:11just because at some point there's going to be one of these that does 4K.

2:26:15But then again, that could just be two years from now.

2:26:17Yeah. Right? I don't know. Because then it would be a big leap.

2:26:22Like, two years worth of development on their chips plus 4K, that's worth another $150, $200.

2:26:32Right. And maybe a Taptic Engine remote. That's our Apple TV from 2017. Now I'm already bored with this Apple TV. Terrible.

2:26:47Well, we should say I think it's because we're excited about it. We're already looking forward to what the future holds.

2:26:53Usually I just let these, you know,

2:26:54we'd go on for another hour,

2:26:56but I'm so excited by it.

2:26:58And I know that there's people out there

2:27:01laughing at me and you with our personalities

2:27:04and our voices talking about how excited we are.

2:27:07Because it's one thing that you and I are very similar with

2:27:11is that when we get excited about something,

2:27:13we don't really show excitement

2:27:17in the way that normal human beings show excitement.

2:27:21Unless I'm on a heater at a blackjack table or something, I really don't get too exuberant.

2:27:27But I really am. I'm actually sitting here thinking, I really want to wrap this up and go downstairs and go back to playing with my Apple TV.

2:27:36Which is actually a really cool feeling.

2:27:40Anything else going on, Guy? Anything you want to promote before we wrap it up?

2:27:45Well, there's a lot of stuff going on, but I mean, they talk to other people about that.

2:27:50Like, the Apple earnings came in, those bananas. Chrome and Android are getting merged together.

2:27:55It's kind of interesting.

2:28:00Is that new? I didn't see that.

2:28:02Yeah, as of yesterday. He was too busy playing your Apple TV to figure that out.

2:28:03I totally missed it.

2:28:07Yeah, they're getting smacked into one thing. But it's whatever. Deal with that some other time.

2:28:10Other than that, no. Go buy my app, Napkin, in the Mac App Store.

2:28:14Napkin. And what's the domain for that?

2:28:17N-A-P-dot-K-N.

2:28:19Oh, man. That's smart. N-A-P-dot-K-N.

2:28:22Great app, Napkin.

2:28:24And your Twitter is @GTE, right?

2:28:29Yeah.

2:28:30Do you get a lot of spam in your ads just because you have a three-letter code?

2:28:34A fair amount, but not that much.

2:28:37Yeah, it seems like the one people have trouble is people who have like a name like a three-letter name like I don't know

2:28:43I don't know who it is

2:28:44But if you had like Sam at Sam like you end up with a lot of junk in there

2:28:48But GTE is sort of random that it wouldn't happen by accident

2:28:52Not that none as often here. All right. Well, thank you guy. I appreciate the time

2:28:57There's a lot of you. It was a blast. All right, I'm gonna go play with my Apple TV