0:00:00Ah Horace did you welcome I think this is definitely the first time right unless I'm misremembered. Yeah, definitely, you know
0:00:07Now that you had you know
0:00:10Not that yet Phil on I guess it's you know, you're legitimate
0:00:16It's worth doing
0:00:19You know, there was something I was supposed to say last week
0:00:21I should have and I forgot it's a little bit of follow-up from that live episode of the show with with
0:00:27Phil Schiller so at the end of the live episode right towards the end as I thanked him
0:00:32I thanked everybody and then I asked the audience if the live video stream had stayed up because we we had tried something new
0:00:39We actually had that set up before I knew that that Phil Schiller was gonna be the guest
0:00:45We were gonna try to live stream it anyway, so I asked the audience
0:00:48Hey, did the live stream stay up because my thought was hey once word gets out on Twitter that Phil Schiller is on the show
0:00:54So it might overwhelm it.
0:00:56And some knucklehead down in front yelled, no.
0:01:00And then Phil made a very funny joke.
0:01:02He said, hey, these things are hard.
0:01:06But I felt bad.
0:01:06I thought, ah, the live stream is down.
0:01:08And then as soon as we got off stage,
0:01:09my phone started going off.
0:01:11And people were texting me.
0:01:13And they were like, I'm watching right now
0:01:15live on the video stream.
0:01:17I'm watching right now live on the video stream.
0:01:18Did not go down.
0:01:19So I don't know who the knucklehead is in the audience
0:01:22who said that the live stream went down.
0:01:24And maybe there were problems for a few people here and there,
0:01:27but it apparently did not go down.
0:01:30And there were an awful lot of people who did watch it live
0:01:32on the stream.
0:01:33And I wanted-- so the reason I want to call that out, though,
0:01:35is that the company that did it is a company called Hybrid
0:01:38Events Group.
0:01:39And I'll put a link to their Twitter in the show notes.
0:01:45Their Twitter is @hybrideventsgrp,
0:01:49because I guess they ran up against the limit in Twitter usernames.
0:01:53But anyway, they did a great job.
0:01:54I couldn't be happier with them.
0:01:56I feel terrible that at the end of this live stream that they worked their asses off to
0:02:00keep up and do a good job on.
0:02:03It looked like it did not stay up and it went down, but it didn't.
0:02:06So I just wanted to clear that out.
0:02:08You know if you have knuckleheads, I mean that the thing is there's always someone you know, who's not happy so
0:02:14There's always an Apple people are just as likely maybe more so to complain, right? So
0:02:21Yeah, I guess so
0:02:23I just don't know what would have driven somebody to shout out know that the stream didn't stay up when in fact it did and
0:02:28And if there were any problems they were minor and sporadic. Yeah, but anyway, it was a lot of fun
0:02:33So you were out at WWDC
0:02:38I was, I was there and I was sitting, I was actually fortunate to sit in a pretty good
0:02:46spot I would actually they managed, I came in late, I had gone to the bathroom because
0:02:50they always tell you go to the bathroom you know because it could run long and by the
0:02:54time I came back out you know they had let everybody in so I was like almost the last
0:02:59person to get in and I'm like wandering around near the front trying to find a place because
0:03:04Sometimes people in the front don't fill up completely and I was actually kindly taken
0:03:13by hand by an Apple person and sat next to, actually sat behind Ben Baharan and his father.
0:03:24So I was like the fifth row and it was really the best seat I ever had and that's what I
0:03:32got for being late.
0:03:34So it was for me, it was a thrill to be in that great spot.
0:03:40And in previous shows, I remember sitting behind you.
0:03:44That was funny sandwiched between you and like Renee, for example.
0:03:51And so there's always these great people you meet there.
0:03:53And that's almost more exciting than the show itself, just getting to meet these people.
0:03:59Yeah.
0:04:00I have been to enough of these now.
0:04:02It's funny because it's dawned on me that now I've been to enough of these keynotes
0:04:06where I'm sort of a veteran rather than a rookie.
0:04:11But I still think of myself.
0:04:12I still think every time I go to one of these things, like, "Wow, I can't believe that
0:04:14I'm invited to attend one of these Apple keynotes."
0:04:17I know.
0:04:18It's a little bit thrilling every time.
0:04:20I've probably been three or four.
0:04:23It's still, you feel a little bit of a tingle every time and it's kind of, I feel privileged
0:04:29to be there.
0:04:30I've had the same experience though where sometimes if you want a good seat, it's
0:04:35actually advantageous to not wander in with friends or colleagues.
0:04:41Because what happens is you mingle before they open the doors and you see people who
0:04:44you know.
0:04:45Remember, I think it was you who took the picture of me and Ben Thompson wearing seemingly
0:04:48identical shirts this year.
0:04:50Eric Lander Seemingly?
0:04:51I thought they were identical.
0:04:52Dave Asprey They were in fact different brands, but it
0:04:55would be very hard for anybody.
0:04:56I think you'd have to look at the label to see the difference.
0:04:59Thompson and I showed up at the keynote dressed like twins and
0:05:02You were kind enough to document that for posterity
0:05:06But anyway, you've run into people who you know like that and then you go in the keynote together
0:05:11But then if it's like a group of five or six of you you look for five or six seats and it limits where you
0:05:16Go sometimes going in just by yourself or going to
0:05:19Like you like you go into the restroom one time. I think it was last year for WWDC it
0:05:25At the keynote it used to be for years and years
0:05:28There's always been a 10 10 o'clock start and it used to be that they let press in
0:05:33Very close to the end
0:05:34I mean sometimes to the point where people would start like getting nervous and be like are they forgotten us are they gonna start without?
0:05:41Us like there was one year where we you know
0:05:43The members of the media didn't get in until I don't know five or ten minutes before 10 o'clock
0:05:49But it's part of the new Apple with Tim Cook is that stuff runs a lot more regularly and stuff
0:05:55Starts exactly on time. I mean if you've noticed with Tim Cook the keynote start at 10 Oh, oh, oh, oh, I mean like
0:06:02To the second but you know, I noticed a couple other details
0:06:06Maybe you already went over this with your audience
0:06:08but I a couple of details one they when they let the the press in they
0:06:12They segregate the photographers from everybody else. Oh, no, they've always done that
0:06:17Yeah, they've always done that but the purpose is that you know, they've got their own little
0:06:21They've got their own little bleachers or whatever wing and then the other thing that's interesting
0:06:27Is that then there's kind of like this time when the executives who usually sit in the middle section and the front middle
0:06:34So the executives begin to cut, you know
0:06:36come in and take their seats and they're basically they're mingling a little bit with each other and
0:06:43And it's like you see the camera guys just going nuts taking all these shots of the executives
0:06:48mingling and I wonder how much of that is planned so that they have this photo op for
0:06:55this kind of casual interaction that happens with some of the superstars of Apple, if you
0:07:04will.
0:07:05You know, you see people would just like in the audience stand up and you would say, "Hey,
0:07:09I see Johnny or I see Angela or I see so and so.
0:07:14And it was funny to see how it seems so natural,
0:07:18but I wonder how much of it is actually on purpose
0:07:22done that way to create the opportunity
0:07:24for the photographers to take their shots
0:07:26and have something.
0:07:27I don't know, that's my take.
0:07:29- It's definitely strategic.
0:07:30I'm not quite sure what the strategy is though
0:07:33and about which sight lines they're looking
0:07:35to give the photographers.
0:07:36It seems to me like what they want
0:07:38is they want the photographers not close,
0:07:41and so if you're serious about taking the photography
0:07:45at the event, you really wanna bring a long lens
0:07:48and assume that you're gonna be zoomed in from a distance
0:07:51and that you're not gonna get close.
0:07:54But anyway, last year, I think it was last year,
0:07:57I was walking to the Moscone from my hotel
0:08:02and it was around 9.30, so it was about a half hour before,
0:08:07but I got a text from a couple people that, hey, they've already let us in.
0:08:10And I was like, oh, crap.
0:08:11So I was like, you were this year.
0:08:12I was like one of the last ones in.
0:08:14And had a similar type thing where I wound up--
0:08:17somebody from Apple PR spotted me looking for a seat and was like, here,
0:08:19come on up here.
0:08:20And I sat, I don't know, fifth or sixth row or something.
0:08:22But it's weird sitting up there because when you're up there with all the Apple
0:08:25employees, they're the people who sort of applaud at strategic points
0:08:31and sort of try to get the applause rolling at applause points, which,
0:08:34you know, to me as a member of the media is not really appropriate.
0:08:38It feels a little bit like you're sitting in the home team crowd when you're up there.
0:08:42>> Really?
0:08:43I didn't sense that, but I did sense in other events that there were some cheerleading going
0:08:47on, but I didn't see here this one.
0:08:49But it is kind of an interesting experience.
0:08:55I guess we're very privileged that we have that access to the event the way we do and
0:09:03each other and it's wonderful. In fact, that's where I asked you. I said, "Hey, how about
0:09:09we get together and do this?"
0:09:11Dave: Yeah. That was exactly where this got set up. Now, we're a couple of weeks out and
0:09:17I feel like we're about to enter what's more or less the summer doldrums news-wise. I don't
0:09:22think we're going to get… Other than the launch, the imminent launch of Apple Music,
0:09:29There's not much going on and never really is in July or August.
0:09:34So I'm just curious what you think overall with a couple of weeks behind us, what you
0:09:38think in hindsight of the WWDC keynote.
0:09:42Well, so the, you know, it's, I'm not a good analyst of events that way because I
0:09:50tend to look for the understated and the, is there a
0:10:01deeper thing and I don't dwell on the feature set so much, I'm not making a
0:10:05list of the big ideas, I'm trying to find where the small ideas and the
0:10:12To me, the big thing this whole year has been around what I call humanism of Apple.
0:10:22The idea that Apple is presenting a new face, a new definition of its principal operating
0:10:33strategy, which is really about not the algorithm.
0:10:38It's hard to put a word on it because the dominant logic of Silicon Valley is that power
0:10:46of the algorithm is power of business and all that flows from it.
0:10:57And somehow what I see is this shift where Apple is saying, "You know, we don't necessarily
0:11:02believe in the power of the algorithm.
0:11:05In fact, we may actually believe in the anti-algorithm.
0:11:08And the anti-algorithm is the human being.
0:11:11And the word I came up with is humanism.
0:11:13Although humanism is a word that was used
0:11:16to counter the notion of a world based around faith.
0:11:21And so this was a sort of a,
0:11:24maybe I got the timing wrong,
0:11:26but maybe a Renaissance or a period of time
0:11:29when people began looking at humans
0:11:32at the center of the universe
0:11:34or the center of thought.
0:11:35And that idea of putting man in the center
0:11:40was a big deal back then,
0:11:42because the church was the dominant leader.
0:11:44And so my way of thinking is that
0:11:47I'm not trying to position against faith,
0:11:49but rather position against the notion
0:11:51of the all powerful algorithm
0:11:54as the counterparty to this idea.
0:11:58And so what's the evidence?
0:12:00The evidence is number one,
0:12:02that they believe in curation,
0:12:04they believe in actual people making decisions
0:12:08when we've seen this already for years and years
0:12:10on the App Store, that there would be someone making,
0:12:14now that means they're fallible,
0:12:15that means they're gonna make mistakes,
0:12:17that means they're gonna make,
0:12:18all, you know, upset people and offend people.
0:12:22But with it comes also the benefit of judgment
0:12:24that comes from the mind of an individual.
0:12:28Second piece of evidence, Johnny Ive,
0:12:30in all his visions of what people want,
0:12:35he's making a judgment, he's making a call,
0:12:38he's calling the, he's curating essentially
0:12:42what it is that we want.
0:12:44And rather than offering every possible option,
0:12:47they'll tell you, no, these are the best options,
0:12:50we believe that.
0:12:51So these are old stories, the new stories,
0:12:53which I think bring it even more to the surface,
0:12:56are, well, we're actually gonna decide how to surface
0:13:00the music that people should listen to or we're going to surface the generally speaking
0:13:07media and so trust us with our judgment, with our taste and that idea is so opposite to
0:13:18the algorithmic ideas that exist as the norm that I feel like somehow this is the beginning.
0:13:25And also, by the way, the idea that trust us comes down to privacy.
0:13:29Trust us comes down to being able to put together the integrated packages that we think are
0:13:38the features that you really need and no more than that.
0:13:42And so this whole idea has been around sort of latent, but suddenly it's springing up
0:13:47and going head to head with algorithm-based business models.
0:13:51I think that's a great observation and that's exactly the sort of insight that I honestly I'm looking for you from from the keynote
0:13:58Like whereas it's not about point-by-point
0:14:00critiquing the the
0:14:03performances on stage but rather trying to suss out what the actual meaning was because I and I think you'll agree with me here that I
0:14:09Think one of the more interesting things of today's Apple
0:14:14Let's call it Tim Cook's Apple because I think that's roughly, you know
0:14:17I think it does correspond roughly to when he took over as CEO and I think it's it's deliberate and I think it is his
0:14:24Personality coming to the surface. I
0:14:26think Apple
0:14:28Wants to be better understood by people outside the company
0:14:33Whereas before I don't think it was so much that they they wanted to be misunderstood
0:14:37But that they just didn't care if you didn't get it
0:14:39They they want they reveled in the in the mystique of Apple. I think the mystique of Apple was
0:14:46There's value in being mysterious
0:14:48There's value in being misunderstood even because at some point you're gonna get the aha moment that you were wrong
0:14:55And then those who become aware of it through their own discovery own that fact even more deeply
0:15:01and I think you're right that is the sort of the jobs in ethos of
0:15:05public relations
0:15:08preserve a
0:15:09distance
0:15:10And you're right. I think there's the sensitivity more towards well, you know
0:15:14Well, maybe we don't need to be so mysterious after all, but here's where I feel that there's
0:15:21still the mystique, which is that they speak actually plainly of what their intentions
0:15:27are.
0:15:28And when you see this in Tim Cook's statements like, "The product is our North Star," that
0:15:36we are concerned about doing good work rather than being profitable or having a rate of
0:15:43return when he sometimes very pointedly attacks some Wall Street punditry.
0:15:50Other times, you see this language from Johnny Ive about, "Does the product deserve to exist?"
0:15:59And so you see these framed very carefully articulated statements which I would say 99.9%
0:16:07of listeners throw away, you know, in one ear and out the other, and it's just as if
0:16:14these guys are just using some kind of poetry to bamboozle us.
0:16:20But what I think perhaps my favorite thing to do in Apple analysis is take literal word
0:16:28out of the horse's mouth analysis of the framing of the phrases, every little detail when they
0:16:34say something and deconstructing it and saying, you know, there's a code in here, there's
0:16:40actually meaningful communication going on.
0:16:43So my take on it is, yes, there is a more, there's more articulation using coded phrases.
0:16:54And Steve Jobs didn't need to, he would speak from the heart.
0:16:58And so what came out of his mouth was deconstructed, but he was the spokesperson.
0:17:03And now we have simply a lot of other spokespeople who are doing these types of very interesting
0:17:08phrasings and I take them and I see from that to me that is what guides my thinking, that
0:17:15guides my analysis.
0:17:17Rather than saying what the numbers say and what the profit logic might be, I always ask
0:17:27given their language, what are they going to do next?
0:17:30So to give you the example of like, you know, people were asking a few months ago, what
0:17:33about the car, what about the car?
0:17:35And I said, well, here's how I would work that out.
0:17:37And I would say, what did Johnny Ives say about product?
0:17:40What does Tim Cook say about product?
0:17:43Therefore, the product that has to emerge has to comply to these rules.
0:17:47They have to have a meaningful contribution.
0:17:49It has to be better in ways that are in which Apple can contribute, etc.
0:17:59And so what I would do is simply take those verbatim communication from Apple and use
0:18:04those as my lenses to analyze the questions at hand.
0:18:08So in that sense, that's how Apple is different in my way of thinking because if you did that
0:18:15with Steve Jobs' comments, he would flip-flop and a lot of them were simply like, "Today
0:18:20I feel this way."
0:18:22And they couldn't really rely on those statements as guiding principles.
0:18:25And I think Apple remember once it reminds me what Tim Cook was acting CEO
0:18:31He went on a conference call and he almost like stated a poem in a poetic way
0:18:38What we believe in and he was like one of these like
0:18:42Speeches buried in the in a conference call with analysts. Yeah, that usually introduced it and I wrote it up
0:18:49And I said I called it the Tim Cook doctrine and this was before he was full-time CEO or I should say permanent CEO
0:18:55And he, you know, I wrote those down and I broke the lines up in a way that almost looked
0:19:01like a poem.
0:19:02And I said, you know, there it is.
0:19:05There's an algorithm right there about how this business works.
0:19:08We're going to cross-pollinate.
0:19:09I remember he used that phrase.
0:19:13You know, I don't remember a lot of it, but I can go back and dig it up.
0:19:17It's the doctrine and it's still searchable in the blog.
0:19:21So anyway, that's the kind of guy he is, I think.
0:19:24And that was way back in what, 2000, probably eight or nine.
0:19:30So it's very much a reflection of what you think of as Tim Cook's apple.
0:19:37Yeah.
0:19:38And so I think part of what went wrong in that keynote was the way that-- and I don't
0:19:44know if you thought this too.
0:19:45I know most people who I've spoken to agree that the music segment at the end was too
0:19:50long and disorganized.
0:19:52But in hindsight, as we get closer to the launch of Apple Music, and I read more and
0:19:58more about it, I see that as the picture becomes more clear to me, it was there.
0:20:04It just wasn't... the information was there.
0:20:07What I think we should understand about it was there, but it was too disorganized for
0:20:12it to be clear.
0:20:14And so part of it is what you said about the humanism and not trusting in the algorithm.
0:20:19And I know it was there and I know that they mentioned it a few times with the Beats 1
0:20:24radio how it's going to be human selected.
0:20:30There was a New York Times profile yesterday, earlier this week, of Zane Lowe who's coming
0:20:38from BBC One in the UK.
0:20:42Super highly regarded DJ.
0:20:46And I know this was mentioned in the keynote, but it just kind of, I lost it because I was
0:20:50just losing focus.
0:20:52But they mentioned that their intention with this is not so much that you're going to pick
0:20:58your favorite genre and go to station.
0:21:01It's sort of like the anti-XM radio.
0:21:03We've got XM radio in our car and I think there's like 200 stations or 300 stations,
0:21:07I don't know, unbelievable number.
0:21:09But you can dial into, I mean they have an entire station that's just Frank Sinatra and
0:21:15there's like a station just for Elvis Presley.
0:21:18With this Beats 1, their intention, I mean obviously you're going to be able to stream
0:21:22music based on your preference if that's what you want, but if you listen to Beats 1, it's
0:21:27any new music that they think is interesting, which is to me a really interesting way to
0:21:32go and it is absolutely not algorithmically generated.
0:21:36Absolutely. And that's exactly the thinking that I think this new apple is about.
0:21:40And I think with Johnny... Sorry, Jimmy Iovine was the one who probably sold him on the idea that you can do this to music.
0:21:49And let me guess here, I have no evidence, but let me guess that he probably remembered back in the days when there were influential DJs in the United States who pretty much drove musical taste.
0:22:02who could influence a generation by selecting the right music and playing it.
0:22:11And over time that became corrupted by scandalous type of bribing and so on.
0:22:18But the job of radio was for a generation to discover the music that spoke for them.
0:22:28And what we're seeing now with an abundance and overabundance of choice is that there
0:22:37isn't, you assume, here's the assumption I think of the internet is that you can select
0:22:44it for yourself and I think that's not the case for most people.
0:22:48Secondly, you can use your friends as a selection criteria which is somewhat what Twitter does.
0:22:55use your feed as a way to select what to read.
0:22:59And so there's that notion that you select good friends and your friends are going to
0:23:03select good things for you.
0:23:05But that has its pitfalls as well.
0:23:07What if you select the wrong friends?
0:23:10And finally there's the algorithm, which is the idea that let's sample what you like and
0:23:15then we'll give you selections.
0:23:19And all of these are the modern version of discovery.
0:23:26What Apple is saying is let's go back to this idea that no, it's an individual that we trust,
0:23:33an individual who has supreme ability of taste, supreme ability at judgment about things.
0:23:42And that's again, this is a reflection of the logic of Johnny Ive and even the logic
0:23:48of Steve Jobs which said, you know, at the end of the day, we're going to decide what
0:23:54products are the ones we're going to dedicate so much energy to and we're not going to do
0:23:58a portfolio strategy, we're not going to hedge our bets and we're not going to do all these
0:24:02things, we're going to hit a home run every time.
0:24:08And by the way, you know, if I were to say, well, that's crazy, it's only those two guys
0:24:12who can do it, it's not something that anybody else can do, but look at Hollywood, look at
0:24:17the way companies like Pixar are able to hit home runs every time because they have a brain
0:24:22trust because they selected people who know how to make great stories and gave them the
0:24:27authority to say yes spend three four hundred million dollars on this project and three
0:24:33four years to get it done and yet they do it every time and it you know we love them
0:24:40for it in contrast to a company that you know the old Disney who just you know put out a
0:24:46portfolio and say essentially they're playing with a spreadsheet in order to decide what
0:24:52to make and that's that's a difference instinct versus spreadsheets or the human versus the
0:24:58algorithm and this is what surfaced I think through this through this event is how much
0:25:03more music is going to turn into that as far as Apple's concerned and that is a very very
0:25:09different thing than what we've heard in the past from everyone else.
0:25:12Yeah, Pixar is a good example too because I think that they've been so open about
0:25:17so much of their process. It's not really a mystery according to them, you know,
0:25:21how they've been so successful and yet nobody else can bring themselves to do
0:25:26it. To do it, yeah. It's like hiding in plain sight or here's the
0:25:30formula, but no one has the courage to do that because it
0:25:35It requires saying no to things which are nearly proven to work.
0:25:40You have to say that portfolio theory is the foundation of finance and who would, wildest
0:25:48mind, it's like if I were an investor and I would say, "Forget about buying a basket
0:25:53of securities, just buy one company and own it all your life."
0:25:57That would be the strategy that Apple is suggesting they do as far as their investments or that
0:26:02Pixar does in terms of their investments.
0:26:05You have to have so much faith in that decision that you're throwing away the hedge opportunity.
0:26:13You're throwing away the what if it doesn't go right.
0:26:19So remember what Steve Jobs said, "Focus is about saying no."
0:26:24And focus is literally about saying no to everything else but the one thing.
0:26:29And so that's what's so hard.
0:26:32And here, when we think about it, so this is very deep in the psyche of Apple in many
0:26:37ways, but when we're looking at it now through this question of products that they're launching
0:26:41as services, they're essentially telling, I think, that we're asking you to trust us,
0:26:48to act, to make those choices for you when it comes to services and things we're going
0:26:54to give you.
0:26:57And that means saying no to a lot of things, and many people will just huff and puff and
0:27:02how dare you but but those who you know go ahead you don't have to buy this
0:27:07isn't like you know that you're not obligated but it's it's it's the way
0:27:13that I think that you're gonna appeal to the the type of audiences that are
0:27:18probably the the best audiences to have yeah all right let me take a break I
0:27:22want to keep talking about music afterwards but let me take a break and
0:27:27and thank the first of our three sponsors for the episode.
0:27:30And it's our good friends, I'm so happy to have them back.
0:27:33I love this company.
0:27:35It's our good friends at Backblaze.
0:27:38You guys remember Backblaze?
0:27:40Online, unlimited backup for your Mac.
0:27:44What do you do?
0:27:47You go to backblaze.com, you download their software,
0:27:50you install it on your Mac, and you get 30 days free trial.
0:27:54It backs up everything on your Mac, everything.
0:27:57just backs the whole thing up to the cloud, their cloud-based server.
0:28:00And after the 30 days
0:28:04you pay five bucks a month, that's it. And
0:28:08it just backs up your whole everything. You have an external hard drive in addition to
0:28:11your internal hard drive, it backs that up to
0:28:13everything. They have over 150
0:28:18petabytes of data backed up so far. And they have restored
0:28:23over 10 billion files for their customers. You can access all of your data from your
0:28:30Mac or from multiple Macs. If you have two Macs, sign up for two accounts, five bucks
0:28:35per machine per month. That's it. Everything's online, but you can access it anywhere. You
0:28:40can use their iPhone app, iPad app, and get just one file when you're out and about. If
0:28:45you need to send a file to somebody and you just log into back plays from their app on
0:28:50on your phone, go through all of your files that are backed up,
0:28:54find the file you want, and do whatever you want with it.
0:28:57So you can download one file at a time.
0:28:59If you have a catastrophe, if a disaster actually strikes,
0:29:03you just go to your account.
0:29:04You can just pay, and they'll just
0:29:06put everything from your account,
0:29:08load it up on a USB drive, and have it overnighted to you.
0:29:12So you can restore one file at a time from anywhere you want.
0:29:15Get all of your files, put on a USB hard drive,
0:29:19whatever you need. 25% of all of their restores though are just one file at a time. Once you
0:29:25have the ability to get any of your files anywhere, you realize it's more than just
0:29:29like backup or recovery from catastrophe. It's really about convenience. Really great
0:29:35software. I recommend it so wholeheartedly. I've got it on every Mac in the house here
0:29:40at the during Fireball headquarters. And like I said, it's a risk free, no credit card required
0:29:47trial so you have nothing to lose just by trying it if you haven't yet don't
0:29:51put it off putting off getting a backup system in place worst thing you can do
0:29:55because that's when Murphy's law will hit so just go here go to back blaze dot
0:30:00com slash daring fireball and you'll they'll they'll know you came from here
0:30:05and sign up today if you haven't signed up so far you're nuts it's it's a great
0:30:09service backblaze.com daring fireball so music part of the news of the last week
0:30:20was this crazy to me it the Taylor Swift story right so we're recording here on
0:30:29Friday June 26 and it was last Sunday where Taylor Swift wrote a blog post
0:30:36post on her tumblr account more or less calling taking Apple to task for the fact that in the in the free trial
0:30:43for Apple music
0:30:46The three-month free trial Apple wasn't going to pay artists for the music that got streamed. They were only gonna pay
0:30:53a percentage based on you know, the paid accounts once the free trial period is over and Taylor Swift's argument was
0:31:02This isn't right, you know, the free trial is a promotion for your service
0:31:05we should get you know, we the artist should get paid no matter what and and
0:31:09It not only worked it worked by the end of the day by the end of the day at EQ
0:31:15You know this Apple senior vice president in charge of music among other things was tweeting that
0:31:22Okay, I've called Taylor Swift. We've worked it out and and we'll be paying artists even during the free trial period
0:31:30I'm kind of blown away by that just by the speed at which it happened and how it kind of
0:31:35In terms of being a longtime Apple observer that it it like the public aspect of it that it took place
0:31:41You know from one Apple executives Twitter account
0:31:45Yeah, I was yeah, I was watching it and I was I was I was bemused. I I personally I
0:31:53Didn't have an opinion on it on one way that I think this is just business
0:31:59You know terms terms and conditions that are in contracts are often negotiable and sometimes you use boilerplate
0:32:06That might not you know be appropriate for everybody and you know
0:32:11Then you change it and and that's that's what we call negotiation and it wasn't to me
0:32:18This is just a matter of business
0:32:20But the I think the noteworthy thing was your you know
0:32:23your observation that they were so responsive to it in such a public way.
0:32:28And in fact that negotiation took place in public on Twitter.
0:32:36That amuses me greatly.
0:32:37I'm not outraged, in fact I refuse to be outraged anymore about anything.
0:32:43So I'm a little bit just reflecting on the age we live in that this is happening.
0:32:53In the end, it turns out very well for everybody.
0:32:55I don't think this was a big deal for Apple
0:32:58to even do it initially, but they just probably,
0:33:01it wasn't something that they thought of.
0:33:02They said, "Well, it's just standard practice."
0:33:04Yes, it's our service, but it's, in the end,
0:33:09they're gonna grow your business as well.
0:33:10So we think of it as a partnership, so we both take a hit.
0:33:14But at the end, they said, "All right,
0:33:17"we'll absorb that cost upfront and pass it on."
0:33:22because you're right, we're probably very well off.
0:33:25It's money we don't need as much as you do.
0:33:27But it's just the way it happened,
0:33:31I guess that's what's interesting.
0:33:32- Same to me, and I feel like it's also further sign,
0:33:36and I think Apple accepts this.
0:33:38I don't think there's any other way,
0:33:39but with the success that they've had
0:33:41and the size that they've grown to,
0:33:43a lot of the times when something like this happens,
0:33:45there's no way that they can truly win.
0:33:49'Cause I saw people saying the next day, like on Monday,
0:33:52that this is sort of makes Apple look weak.
0:33:55It makes them, you know, that they capitulated,
0:33:57that they gave in, you know,
0:34:00and it doesn't make Apple look good
0:34:02that they scrambled to do this.
0:34:05Whereas my guess is that inside Apple,
0:34:09that their take on this is why not make it look
0:34:13like we're paying attention?
0:34:14Because we are paying attention, right?
0:34:17I mean, it's, you know, we saw the tailors.
0:34:19Why put it off?
0:34:20Why make it look, why wait a week or two
0:34:23and make it look like we're a black box
0:34:26who doesn't respond to stuff like this?
0:34:28- Or like we called our lawyers
0:34:29and we called our, you know, consultants or something.
0:34:31- Yeah. - It's clear.
0:34:34- I think it's as simple as what Eddie Q said,
0:34:36that he and Tim Cook talked on the phone Sunday
0:34:39and said, all right, we'll just, you know,
0:34:40we'll pay him during the trial period.
0:34:42- Yeah, exactly.
0:34:44So, and by the way, I think the reason Apple is in the business of music anyway is because
0:34:48they love music, as they say many times over and over again.
0:34:52Again one of these statements that people just, you know, just goes right over consciousness
0:34:58because they say it all the time, you know, "We love music."
0:35:00And by saying we love music, they're not just saying, "Yeah, we love being," you know, remember
0:35:06the dancing of Eddie Key on stage.
0:35:10The point is that they do love music because actually they think that that's a cornerstone
0:35:15of the business.
0:35:16That is, they want to be seen as a brand associated with music musicians and artists and creative
0:35:23people.
0:35:25Going back to Think Different, who did they put up on the Think Different campaign?
0:35:28They're all people who are creative people, fundamentally, whether they were scientific,
0:35:33artistic, cultural, social creative people.
0:35:37And so the idea is that that's what the brand rests on.
0:35:41And so I don't know anybody who would think that Apple benefits by being a tough guy with
0:35:48artists.
0:35:49They come to the story, they're coming to the table with music.
0:35:52In fact, spending all that money on a music... the acquisition of Beats was spending a ton
0:35:59of billions of dollars on a company founded by musicians or music executive, you know,
0:36:06a partner with a musician.
0:36:08And the whole company is like saying,
0:36:11trying to tell the world, we want creativity to flourish
0:36:16and we want our tools to be used by creative peoples.
0:36:20We're on their side, we're on your side
0:36:23to addressing their customer in a way.
0:36:26And so that is why if they quote cave into them,
0:36:31they're just saying, look, we're just being overly,
0:36:33The fault is that we're being actually overly generous
0:36:38when maybe a cynical view would be that we ought to be
0:36:41much more tight with money
0:36:46and that's not a good thing to come across
0:36:49as being restrictive with your terms.
0:36:54You can be restrictive when you're dealing
0:36:56with another company and I'm sure they drive a hard bargain
0:36:59but when it comes to artists, the way you want to project
0:37:01is that you're being very generous.
0:37:04And that therefore reflects also on developers,
0:37:07ultimately who are part of the ecosystem.
0:37:10And so I think it turns out well,
0:37:12the only people who are gonna be critical of that decision,
0:37:17I think are cynics because I don't think Apple's brand
0:37:21is about being confrontational with those who use it
0:37:26confrontational with those who use its tools.
0:37:32Yeah, I agree with that and I think I saw some of that cynicism in the aftermath of
0:37:38this, you know, "Okay, we'll pay you during the free trial thing if that's such a sticking
0:37:43point."
0:37:44And I think the truth of it is that it's so little money to Apple.
0:37:47I mean, the terms have leaked and apparently this is fairly standard across the industry.
0:37:53you know Spotify is paying somewhere around the same amount where it's about
0:37:58two tenths of one cent per play for for streaming so in other words five
0:38:06streams to get one penny in payment which is so little money no matter how
0:38:12popular this thing gets I mean just a little back-of-the-envelope math but if
0:38:16you know, like a hundred billion plays is...
0:38:23it times... wait let me think, I gotta make sure I get this right...
0:38:26hundred... is this right? 100 billion, all right, times 0.002
0:38:36is only 200 million dollars, which is a long, you know...
0:38:41Yeah, I don't even know. They paid three billion for beats,
0:38:46And it would be a long time before they paid $3 billion in fees.
0:38:52And this is just talking about the free trial period, right?
0:38:55Once people pay for the $10 a month thing, the payments will all come out of--
0:39:00there's no charity involved.
0:39:02There's no-- Apple's not eating the cost of anything.
0:39:05Everything will come out of a percentage of what people are actually paying.
0:39:09So it doesn't matter how popular Apple Music is,
0:39:13how many people sign up for this free trial and how many songs they play on it. It just
0:39:19can't add up to an overall meaningful number for Apple in terms of what they would be paying.
0:39:26So I think the idea that and the idea that they were trying to squeeze that miniscule
0:39:31amount of millions of dollars because that ultimately it's going to be in the millions
0:39:35not billions no matter where it falls. The idea that they were trying to screw artists
0:39:39out of that and take advantage of them in the free period, I think is too cynical. I mean,
0:39:44it's certainly possible, but it just doesn't sound right to me. I think that it's exactly what they
0:39:48said, which is that they're hoping that they're going to get so many people onto paid accounts,
0:39:55and therefore have a real sustainable model for artists to get paid for digital streaming.
0:40:05They just saw that free trial as a way for everybody to sort of benefit from the long
0:40:10term of having people signed up for actual paid accounts.
0:40:13Dave Asprey Sure.
0:40:14And that's the way it works.
0:40:15I mean when you're – the point of free trials is that everybody who's – you're
0:40:21doing it because you want to gain people's business and you want to gain people's attentions
0:40:28and it makes a lot of sense to – in this case because also there isn't a cost in
0:40:34giving it away.
0:40:35Remember, this is digital media, so if they listen to those streams, maybe those streams
0:40:41would have never gotten listened to.
0:40:42It's not that they're going to stop listening and somewhere where they are paying and then
0:40:46start listening on this service.
0:40:49Maybe they will, but they'll shut off Spotify and some artists might see a decrease in revenue
0:40:55for this trial period.
0:40:56But generally, again, these are very small amounts and I think this is one of those things
0:41:03that I felt that I wasn't motivated by it enough to even make a comment about it. So
0:41:08I thought, to me, the news is in the way it happened, not what the outcome was.
0:41:16Dave Asprey Yeah, I think so too. I'm definitely curious
0:41:19to see how popular album music becomes, but it's sort of outside my purview. I'm just
0:41:25not into popular music. So I don't know.
0:41:27Nor am I. That's something I'm embarrassed about. But then again, you get to a certain
0:41:32age. One thing I have as a theory about the human condition, it's that when music discovery
0:41:42is a young man or young woman's problem, when you get to a certain age, you know what you
0:41:50like and you've already probably got it. And so very few people get... are
0:41:57interested in new music at a certain age. And so that's why the genres break
0:42:02into nostalgia and you know you can get a radio station for every decade because
0:42:08people want to go back to that time when they were young and that was the
0:42:11formative years where that music speaks to them. And by the way the
0:42:17The interesting thing is that there wasn't such a thing in the 1960s because the industry
0:42:23was so new and there wasn't the idea of popular music was just recently created so the nostalgia
0:42:30would have been for jazz or for that sort of music that the 1920s, I forget the names
0:42:38of some of those types of music then, but it wasn't recorded and so people weren't going
0:42:45to go back to try to relive that time through music.
0:42:50So it's very much a phenomenon of the 20th century.
0:42:53I love one thing about the music event or the music part of the event that I think didn't
0:43:00maybe rise high enough in consciousness was that video they showed where they narrated
0:43:05through imagery how music changed over the years.
0:43:09And I think they missed a little bit with that video because it wasn't narrated, they
0:43:13They just had images only, but the way you could read that narration is like if you go
0:43:18back in history, ever since music became a recorded product, it's changed not just in
0:43:25the form of the medium or the media that was used to capture it from vinyl to tape to CD,
0:43:33but also because at that time the music, in my language, was hired for different things.
0:43:43the first record players were hired to play music in the living room to the whole family
0:43:50and you probably have a very few records and maybe you would actually dance to them in
0:43:55a formal way.
0:43:57And so over time you see how music became a different thing and when it became concentrated
0:44:04enough and portable enough so that you could carry 500 or 1,000 songs in your pocket, then
0:44:11Then it became yet another thing.
0:44:13And when it became something you could get on the internet through a stream, it became
0:44:19yet another thing.
0:44:20So nobody would have thought in the 1960s I would have these wearable headphones and
0:44:26I would go running with them and use music as a way to motivate myself through my workout.
0:44:35or I would use these at work to isolate myself from the noise in the background, or I would
0:44:43wear these on a commute.
0:44:45That use case, those types of uses for music emerged only because of the technology that
0:44:50was available at that time.
0:44:53And so in some ways what they're saying is that we as Apple, we made one of those eras
0:44:58happen and now we're going to move to another era and we're going to make this happen for
0:45:03not just the consumer, but also for the musicians.
0:45:05And so this whole story, I think, is wonderful
0:45:08because it's about the evolution of music,
0:45:11the evolution of how music was consumed
0:45:13and what purpose it had and meaning it had in people's lives.
0:45:16And to the chagrin of many people in the industry,
0:45:20it seems as if music has been devalued over time.
0:45:24Once we've had so much of it and it's so easy to obtain
0:45:27and that we can carry so much of it in our pockets
0:45:30that we've traded analog dollars for digital pennies,
0:45:34or digital dimes, and then streaming pennies.
0:45:39But, so that's the sort of the negative spin on it.
0:45:44But the positive spin is actually
0:45:47we consume more music than ever.
0:45:49We're surrounded by it, we have access to it,
0:45:51we can sample, we can try new things.
0:45:54And so if you were to take the positive spin on it,
0:45:56and Apple will say, the conversation to the artist,
0:46:00is that, hey, let us help you surface this,
0:46:04let us help you actually take advantage of technology
0:46:07that helps you continue in your craft.
0:46:11And for the consumer, the same thing is like,
0:46:14let's find music that you wouldn't have ever found before,
0:46:17that is so inspiring or delightful
0:46:20and that really doesn't improve your life.
0:46:22So that's why Apple's in the music business.
0:46:26They come in and say, we're not here to figure out
0:46:28a new monetization strategy.
0:46:30We're here to actually make sure that music survives,
0:46:33that music is continuing to be an important part of life.
0:46:37Again, I sound like a pitchman for beats,
0:46:40but the idea is that I've thought about this
0:46:43for years and years when I was thinking about
0:46:45where's music gonna end up being?
0:46:47What is the job to be done, music is hard to do?
0:46:51And looking through history,
0:46:52you realize that that job changes,
0:46:54and that you've got to change along with that.
0:46:57Yeah, I think that the idea that Apple should have...
0:47:01I've seen some people speculate, you know, that,
0:47:04"Hey, why is Apple even bothering with this at all?
0:47:06"They don't need to do music.
0:47:09"They don't need to be this involved, right?"
0:47:11Why not just let Spotify and Pandora handle it all?
0:47:17They've got great iOS apps.
0:47:19You can play them from any of your Apple devices.
0:47:21Why does Apple even need to do this?
0:47:22And I think it's because, I think it's what you said,
0:47:25I think it's because they want to,
0:47:26because they really think music is part of what they want their company to be.
0:47:31Alex Tsakiris Yeah, it reminds me of a conversation once
0:47:33I had with someone at Pixar and I said, "Why don't you guys go into doing TV because you've
0:47:41got these great storytelling techniques and tools and things like that.
0:47:47They make shorts and movies and nothing in between."
0:47:50And they were like, the answer was because we love movies.
0:47:54And I had no way to – I was taken aback.
0:47:58I was like, oh yeah, of course.
0:48:02Here I am thinking like a technician or I'm trying to segment the world by what is possible.
0:48:09And at the end the decision is like no, we just love stuff.
0:48:13And that's why we do things.
0:48:14And if we did things that we didn't love, then we wouldn't be good at all.
0:48:17And so the formula of Pixar isn't just like we know how to turn the crank, it's like we
0:48:21really are passionate and the passion is key.
0:48:24And so in this case, I think it's the same thing.
0:48:27Why is Apple in anything?
0:48:29Why shouldn't they just leave payments to someone else?
0:48:32Why should they be trying to make better photographs?
0:48:35Why should they be trying to make better, you know, even movies with iMovie, even though
0:48:40nobody's using it?
0:48:42Or why isn't, you know, why are they doing iWork at all?
0:48:44Isn't that stupid?
0:48:46Why get into that and kill it kill it every time I hear is like shut it down shut down Apple TV
0:48:52It's a failure shut down this and that and I always think that look they didn't get into it
0:48:56Just for that purpose to sort of make money or to become a success by your your definition of it
0:49:03They probably do it because they think it's far part of their fiber and it's it's something that they feel that that
0:49:09will complete them or or the you know, just and I don't want to make it seem like
0:49:14like there's some kind of an artistic entity.
0:49:17But when you ask artists this question,
0:49:19it's like why did you paint this thing
0:49:21and not show it to anybody?
0:49:22He said, well, I had to get it out.
0:49:23I had to get it out and I don't care if anybody sees it.
0:49:27In some ways, you ought to think about business this way
0:49:30because this is the sort of antithesis
0:49:35of an analytic approach is actually one
0:49:38of being entirely empathy based.
0:49:42But that empathy allows you to create greatness.
0:49:46And it may lead you to that one great business as well,
0:49:51but it doesn't happen through a deliberate act.
0:49:53It happens through a discovery act.
0:49:55And so this is why when they make choices
0:49:59that are based on these instincts,
0:50:03and people say, well, it's not economical,
0:50:06or it doesn't make sense,
0:50:07or they're stepping on toes and things like that.
0:50:10On one hand on Apple, that's the narrative.
0:50:12On the other hand, on Google, nobody complains that they get into all kinds of crazy moonshots.
0:50:18And they all applaud.
0:50:20If Apple however, even slightly veers off of what is thought to be the well trodden
0:50:25path, then people jump up with criticism and, "Oh, this is the end of Apple.
0:50:32Obviously this is not their forte.
0:50:34There should not be in this," etc., etc.
0:50:37It's some people do R&D, some people do moonshots, and Apple just wants to indulge some ideas
0:50:47about what they think is important.
0:50:50Or education, for example.
0:50:51Why are they in education?
0:50:53Why are they getting into healthcare?
0:50:54Why are they getting into fitness tracking?
0:50:57Are these all money-making opportunities?
0:50:59Someday, but I don't see a way I can put that on the spreadsheet, and I don't care either.
0:51:05It's about really doing things which they think stitch together into a fiber that holds
0:51:10up the whole thing.
0:51:12That's the business of Apple.
0:51:13I think that's not...
0:51:15Maybe that is a new business of Apple because in Steve Jobs' time, there would have been
0:51:19a little bit less diversification.
0:51:23But it's still...
0:51:25To me, this is because the fiber is so much broader and there needs to be so much more
0:51:31to support billions of or potential billions of users.
0:51:35I think fundamental to the culture of Apple, the corporate culture, and it definitely started
0:51:40with Steve Jobs without question and it was deliberate and continues to have unforeseen
0:51:48consequences and allows Apple to do things you may not, you know, 10 years from now that
0:51:53we wouldn't have predicted today, is the fact that they don't do a P&L for each product
0:52:01or division or however you want to talk about it. They don't have divisions within the company.
0:52:09They're completely functionally organized. In fact, they're more functionally organized
0:52:13than even before with Steve Jobs where Johnny Ive's team took over design of everything,
0:52:22not just hardware design, but with the Forstall Ouster and taking over all of software design.
0:52:29There wasn't one team doing iOS design.
0:52:32- They created a new function with design
0:52:34that's really deep and exactly right.
0:52:36And this is something I've been,
0:52:38I'm glad you brought it up because I think it's one
0:52:40of the most under understood aspects
0:52:44of the Apple algorithm, which is that they essentially
0:52:49said no to a divisional organization,
0:52:53which, here's the narrative I have on it,
0:52:56which is that, that's fine for small companies.
0:52:59In fact, if you're a startup,
0:53:01you are by default a functional organization.
0:53:03It makes sense that you're gonna have somebody,
0:53:05you're usually a person is a function and that's it.
0:53:09There's not that many of you.
0:53:10But as you grow, it makes sense.
0:53:12People think it's logical.
0:53:14Now, okay, now we have to divide
0:53:15according to where the money comes from.
0:53:17So if we've got a product,
0:53:20okay, I'm gonna put somebody in charge of that product.
0:53:22I'm gonna put somebody in, if it's in fact geographical
0:53:25because your sales structure is that way,
0:53:26then you do geographical segments or something like that
0:53:30and then you organize according to whatever means
0:53:33you decide the money comes in.
0:53:35And that's the thing is that the money starts
0:53:37to lead your thinking and optimization becomes
0:53:42the rule of the day.
0:53:43It's like how can I hold that person responsible
0:53:46to do the best thing for that particular flow of money
0:53:50that's coming in to optimize it.
0:53:53And so that's how divisional organizations evolve.
0:53:58And in fact, General Motors was probably the pioneer
0:54:01in that area back 100 years ago or so.
0:54:05So this idea of divisional logic
0:54:10is pervasive in the world.
0:54:12And it also makes sense when you're managing people
0:54:16and thousands and thousands of people,
0:54:17you wanna be able to create the incentives for them
0:54:20to align according to certain goals.
0:54:23And so the pyramid of that division is set up
0:54:28so that everybody knows what the target is,
0:54:30and therefore their paycheck is tied to that in some way.
0:54:35And so people then know what they're,
0:54:37you don't need to tell them every day what to do,
0:54:40they'll have that in their incentives built in.
0:54:42But, and that doesn't work for an organization
0:54:46which is like Apple, which is functional,
0:54:47because you're not attached to a product.
0:54:50might be one day but not the other. And then you're sort of, you're never even, part of
0:54:56the P&L logic is that you report some of that data and people know how things are going
0:55:03and so there's a communication that happens through the knowledge of what's happening,
0:55:10right? And so bottom line is that Apple's lack of a P&L structure means that people
0:55:18within the organization, you'll have hard time motivating them, you'll have a hard time
0:55:23figuring out what their responsibilities are, figuring out how they can navigate their own
0:55:29personal careers so that they can maybe optimize their own career because the signal of pricing
0:55:36and the signal of profit was used to guide you and or would guide you if you were in
0:55:42in a divisional organization.
0:55:44So what we have to be impressed by is how actually difficult it is to do what Apple
0:55:51is doing because it actually makes running that business really, really hard.
0:55:56And in fact it may cause some people to just say, "I quit.
0:56:00I can't make sense of it.
0:56:01I can't progress in my career because of this."
0:56:05And so there's a lot of heartache that comes with it.
0:56:08And there's a lot of chaos that comes with it.
0:56:11And so this is why every company that grows up beyond the certain stage abandons this
0:56:15logic and here's Apple which is now, I don't know how many, 50,000 or more people is still
0:56:21able to continue in that way.
0:56:23It's hard to put a head count on Apple unless you separate the retail out from it.
0:56:29I think you might be right that it's probably 50 or 60 now.
0:56:33It's explosively grown.
0:56:36Non-retail has grown tremendously in the last five years.
0:56:40I think it was Don Melton that pointed this out to me.
0:56:42He said, you know, Apple is the largest functional organization outside of the US Army, and maybe
0:56:47other foreign armies.
0:56:48But the idea is that, and then you ask, oh, and that, when he said that, my head went
0:56:53like pop because I said, holy cow, that's exactly why armies are the way they are.
0:56:58I mean, the armies are the way they are.
0:57:00They're actually organized the way they are because they need to be, you know, thrown
0:57:05at a target.
0:57:07thrown at a mission and they have to execute on that mission.
0:57:10But they're very inefficient in terms of trying to do a blend of things.
0:57:15And often even when you go into that mission, it's like it's chaos.
0:57:19It's like crazy, you know, incompetencies emerge.
0:57:22And then you realize that, well, okay, that's why we have war games to simulate them and
0:57:26sort of make sure that things run effectively and so on.
0:57:28And so I got into this whole train of thought about what would happen if the U.S. Army was
0:57:35divisional.
0:57:36then you would have the head of certain types of missions.
0:57:39So you would say, "We're not going to have air force, Marines, and an army.
0:57:43We're going to have a guy in charge of attacks in the Middle East, and we're going to have
0:57:50a guy in charge of maybe, we'll do it geographically, Latin America."
0:57:55And the head of Latin America would have under him, you know, army, air force, and Marines.
0:58:00But the problem is that that person would gain so much power, then they would start
0:58:03the Joint Chiefs of Staff would kind of have these debates around the big table and say,
0:58:07you know, you know, Middle East is much more important, I ought to get more resources.
0:58:13So why don't you, you know, put 80 percent of the budget in the Middle East this year,
0:58:17Mr. President, and, you know, nobody cares about that in America, all they're doing is
0:58:23busting drug gangs, you know, I got a real fight here to fight, so give me more money.
0:58:28So then they would get into that, and then so one general who ran that region would suddenly
0:58:32have so much more power than the other generals, he could actually probably run, you know,
0:58:38run his own empire, run his own, make so many decisions that he would become like the king
0:58:45of the Middle East.
0:58:46In fact, MacArthur was like that in Japan.
0:58:48He had so much authority in Japan after the war that he wrote their constitution for them
0:58:53practically and he was a general.
0:58:55And so that was a special situation.
0:58:58But when you think about it that way,
0:58:59that this is this idea of people who have
0:59:03under them an empire.
0:59:05This is the politics, this is the type of politics
0:59:08that drives organizations into all this paralysis,
0:59:12all of this mismanagement and all of this running off a cliff
0:59:16and stupidity that we observe.
0:59:18And so because someone has that power structure in them,
0:59:20you can imagine this in Microsoft's world,
0:59:23well, the Windows guys are really powerful
0:59:24and the Office guys are really powerful
0:59:26and they need all the resources
0:59:28because they've earned them.
0:59:29And so and so it goes.
0:59:30But when you take that away,
0:59:32you depoliticize an organization.
0:59:34So you, especially with the military,
0:59:36you've got to be depoliticized.
0:59:37A politicized military turns into an object of coup.
0:59:42And this is why you have Republican guards
0:59:47and things like that, which are politicized militaries,
0:59:49which often end up really controlling the state.
0:59:52And in a democracy that's unacceptable.
0:59:55And for that reason,
0:59:56militaries and democracies are the way they are and and this is you know that's a long narrative but
1:00:01i i i'm sorry well and not and not to go too deep down the history historical uh rabbit hole but
1:00:06that's why harry truman fired general mccarthur exactly i mean which harry truman that's one of
1:00:12those things where i grew up and i heard the story and i thought well i guess that's the sort of
1:00:15thing that happens but then like the older i get and the more perspective i get on it it was sort
1:00:20of a bombshell you know to the U.S. public who viewed him as a you know as a hero.
1:00:28He was a wartime hero he not only had beaten Japan but he also he had beaten Korea and so or
1:00:35North Korea and he getting fired I mean so many people were upset but he became too political
1:00:41and that was unacceptable in a democracy and that to me was a great story to tell and
1:00:48And I think that's where you got to watch out.
1:00:51This is the day-to-day fears and worries that a guy like Tim Cook has to deal with.
1:00:56He's got to worry about – the Forstall story I think had a lot to do with whether that
1:01:02general became too political and didn't stick to his functional role.
1:01:07In that case, he had to be sacrificed even though everybody loved him.
1:01:12So it's the same story.
1:01:14I think of him as the Truman of Apple.
1:01:17Yeah, then as the more time is gained from that the less oh not Truman sorry MacArthur
1:01:22I'm sorry exactly, but I thought you meant cook as the Truman which is true
1:01:26Yeah, cook is the Truman and and forest all was it was McCarthy right now. That's it the more I see it though
1:01:32it's it's not just I at first I viewed it as sort of a
1:01:36Petty more of a petty disagreement between a few individuals and I think that there's something to that angle
1:01:44but I feel like long-term strategically it was about
1:01:47Making sure that the institution of the whole company was was truly more functional
1:01:55Whereas I feel like under Steve Jobs a lot of the functional nature of Apple came down to jobs
1:02:01singular role in the company not not to say that the company depended on him and couldn't you know that he was a
1:02:08Cornerstone that the company couldn't do with that
1:02:11I think we're seeing that that's not true. But I think that the functional nature of the company flew through him
1:02:17Yeah, and you know, you're you're right. There's subtle differences
1:02:21Um, we generalize then we use metaphor and we use we use allegory
1:02:26but the truth is is far more complex and so I don't want to be I
1:02:30Don't want to make it seem like it's so clear-cut that that you know, this is this tells the story
1:02:36but it's only illustrative.
1:02:38For example, just as an anomaly, as a counterpoint
1:02:41to the functional thing, there's the EdiQ's organization
1:02:45because EdiQ, I see it as an empire
1:02:50because he's got under him services now called,
1:02:53and includes all the stores, it includes iWork,
1:02:57it includes the new, it includes Apple TV,
1:03:03It includes products that are hardware,
1:03:07software and services.
1:03:08And that is, it could, you know,
1:03:10if you could spin off to ediQ, you know,
1:03:12it would be a huge business.
1:03:14It would be a business bigger than Amazon, in my opinion.
1:03:18I can probably dig up some numbers that would show
1:03:20that ediQ's organization by itself, you know,
1:03:25would be valued by the market far,
1:03:28with a good chunk of multiple would be far in excess
1:03:32than what it is inside Apple.
1:03:33But of course, that's not going to happen.
1:03:35The point is, though, that is an exception to rule.
1:03:37And there is a good reason for that,
1:03:39because there is this kind of like, what do you
1:03:41do with these pieces problem.
1:03:43And so in some ways, they're put under him.
1:03:48So if it happens, there's a reorg.
1:03:51I would be surprised, because something may just
1:03:54get out of control there.
1:03:55I don't know.
1:03:55I'm not prejudicing, hopefully.
1:03:58I think what's so funny with Apple today,
1:04:00it would be it would be almost impossible to reorganize the company. I think what they
1:04:04could do is is there could be like, departures, individuals could depart maybe just simply
1:04:11to enjoy their retirement, enjoy the you know, the wealth that they've accumulated. Or it
1:04:18could be another dispute arises where there's a personality conflict between two senior
1:04:23vice presidents who need to be working together and can't get along. But I, to me, it would
1:04:29just be it's almost more like running like sports you know like pick any sport you know
1:04:37like you if you want to talk about soccer like well we're gonna have to change goalkeepers
1:04:41yeah it's but it's still right position you're not really you know I think you're you're
1:04:48absolutely you're saying it right I I just I literally I on the spot thought of the rear
1:04:55your idea and I don't, on reflection I think you're right.
1:04:58It's not gonna be what we think of as a reorg.
1:05:01It might just be that maybe they'll carve,
1:05:04maybe they could do something with services
1:05:07that's gonna grow to such an extent that they may create
1:05:12that as a separate thing.
1:05:15I don't know, I don't know.
1:05:16I'm just being completely speculative.
1:05:18- Let me take another break here.
1:05:20I'll take a deep breath and I'll thank our second sponsor.
1:05:23and it's another long time friend of the show,
1:05:25our good friends at Fracture.
1:05:29It is sad, sad, I honestly think it is,
1:05:32that so many of our photos that we take today,
1:05:35people, everybody, almost everybody I know
1:05:38takes more photographs today
1:05:40than they ever have before in their lives.
1:05:43And it's only becoming more prevalent.
1:05:45And it's easy to see why.
1:05:46It's because we all have really good cameras
1:05:50with us all the time.
1:05:52like two or three seconds away from being ready to snap a photo.
1:05:55Um, and yet so many of the photos that we take,
1:06:01uh, never really leave the devices that, that we view them on.
1:06:06They're just digital things that we see on digital devices when we look for them.
1:06:10Uh, and I think it's actually true.
1:06:13I think it's even true for me personally as somebody who uses fracture and has
1:06:16fracture prints and, and, and, you know,
1:06:19talks about them all the time here, that I've actually got fewer printed photos now when
1:06:24I take more photos than I did 10, 11, 12 years ago when I used to shoot on film and I had
1:06:30to have prints of everything made. There's something magical about a printed photograph
1:06:35when it's something that means something to you. That's where Fracture steps in. Fracture
1:06:40prints your photos directly on pure glass. You pick your favorite photos that you've
1:06:46taken. You send them to fracture and the prints come back to you, printed directly on glass,
1:06:52not a piece of paper attached to glass. They just print right on the glass. I don't know
1:06:55what kind of voodoo they used to do it, but it looks great. The prints come back to you.
1:07:00They've got a foam back right on the glass that's ready to mount on the wall or ready
1:07:06to be used. It's this ingenious, ingenious packaging that you can use to mount it on
1:07:11the wall or to prop it up on a shelf or your desk or the mantle or wherever you
1:07:16want to put it up right out of the box so you don't need to put them in a frame
1:07:20you don't need to buy a separate frame the picture itself is all you need to
1:07:26mount it on the wall hang it up really looks great and it gives your photos the
1:07:30analog beauty that they deserve so go check them out take some photos or take
1:07:36some of your recent photos, pick a few that are your favorites, go to fractureme.com.
1:07:44fractureme.com. That's their website. And use the code daring fireball. Use that code
1:07:50and you'll get 15% off your first order from fracture. The prices are already great, but
1:07:56you can say 15% using the code during fireball. So my thanks to fracture. So
1:08:03So speaking about not putting everything off in its own P&L, profit and loss, and looking
1:08:12at things functionally, you wrote a recent piece on Asymptco about maps and the sort
1:08:19of – well, more like one factor.
1:08:23How much does it cost to run a top-notch mapping service per year?
1:08:27You came to the conclusion that it costs about $2 billion a year?
1:08:31Yeah, I think it used to be one but it's closer to two now and I think that and I
1:08:38got that figure by looking the financials that Nokia was reporting
1:08:42for its HERE product or HERE division which was an acquisition back in 2007
1:08:50actually the year the iPhone launched Nokia spent a seven billion dollars or
1:08:55viewers I forget, on the acquisition of MavTek, which was at the time probably the best map
1:09:02service in the world.
1:09:04And I mean that because I was using maps in 2005 and 2006 on a mobile device, on a phone,
1:09:13back in the pre-iPhone dark ages.
1:09:16And I remember using Google Maps back then.
1:09:20And it was horrifically bad.
1:09:22I think Google Maps was laughably bad compared to paid services or things you could purchase.
1:09:34You could download the entire maps.
1:09:36Like, remember Tom Tom and those, Garmin, those guys had a down or they had an embedded
1:09:44map in their hardware.
1:09:47if you had an in-car system like you would have with a high-end car back in the day,
1:09:53you'd pay three, four thousand dollars for the onboard navigation, which was a DVD usually.
1:09:59That was, you know, that was upgradeable if you paid.
1:10:02That's exactly what I, we bought the car that we have, we bought in 2006, still driving it,
1:10:07and I think we turned down, it was a four thousand dollar upgrade to get inboard navigation.
1:10:14which in hindsight, there were a couple of years there
1:10:17where my wife gave me a hard time about that
1:10:19and in hindsight really looks like a very good decision.
1:10:23- And at the time you could get a handheld navigator
1:10:27or you could get like very rarely,
1:10:29and these were only on some Nokia devices
1:10:31that you could get, usually was an SD card
1:10:34that had maps data for the region you were in
1:10:36and you could pop that in.
1:10:38Very few, actually none I think were directly over the air.
1:10:42Google started offering over the air
1:10:44but again it was horrible.
1:10:45And I remember using it in those years.
1:10:47I was in Boston, I was actually working at Nokia's offices
1:10:51over by 128, and I remember using it
1:10:55every afternoon going home.
1:10:57I would open it up on a Nokia sort of Blackberry style phone
1:11:02and I would have this tiny square screen
1:11:04and I would pop in through the online,
1:11:08through, sorry, through the network at the time,
1:11:12which would have been probably 2G or 2.5G,
1:11:15and I would get to see my route home,
1:11:17and I would look for the traffic data,
1:11:19'cause that was really the only value for me,
1:11:22is like how bad was the traffic when I would drive home?
1:11:26But that was it, that was no really discovering
1:11:29where to go eat or anything like that,
1:11:31that was maps-based.
1:11:33So at that time, at that time,
1:11:35Noki thought we've gotta spend
1:11:417 billion dollars on maps.
1:11:43The thing about Nokia throughout the years I was there is that they're really, really
1:11:48forward thinking.
1:11:49They thought about smartphones 10 years before anybody else did.
1:11:53They thought about maps 10 years before they got good enough and if anything, they just
1:11:58were too early on everything and didn't focus on the things that needed to be improved,
1:12:04rather they said, "Okay, we buy the assets or we commit to the strategy," and they thought
1:12:10that was enough. They didn't have the ability to really, really get this thing sorted out.
1:12:18So long story short, they buy Naftech for billions of dollars, and then they would report
1:12:25their revenues and they would report their costs, so from that we could work out just
1:12:30how much they were spending to maintain that $7 billion asset, to maintain the data in
1:12:36And of course, nowadays people would say that here maps is not as good.
1:12:41By the way, here the maps business did have revenues for them because they were selling these data sets to the car makers.
1:12:47So they were selling them to Mercedes and Porsche and whoever to put on those DVDs in their cars
1:12:53and put in the SD cards if you were willing to buy that service.
1:12:58So, NaftX business was a real business.
1:13:01It wasn't an ad-driven business.
1:13:03It wasn't based on selling devices.
1:13:06it was based on selling the actually hard-earned data.
1:13:10And they had 400 people who every day got into cars
1:13:14to go collect data by driving around.
1:13:17And they would also source data from satellites,
1:13:20they would source data from, I mean, satellite companies,
1:13:22they would source data from geo position.
1:13:25And there was these huge data sets
1:13:28that mostly were not consumer-based, right?
1:13:30These were for companies.
1:13:32And so this was an amazingly valuable idea
1:13:35that maps are going to be someday very important in mobile,
1:13:39and that maps, therefore, the Nokia thought
1:13:41by owning that asset, and there weren't very many others.
1:13:44In fact, they were coming with the baggage of hardware,
1:13:48like Garmin and TomTom.
1:13:50And so instead they said, "No, it's a pure asset.
1:13:53"We're gonna buy it,
1:13:54"and we're gonna be the best map service in the world."
1:13:56And at that time, I would argue, yes, they were.
1:13:58Google was a joke.
1:13:59And the funny thing to me was a few years later,
1:14:03when finally Apple gets into the maps business,
1:14:06people say that their maps are a joke.
1:14:08And I just remembered Google.
1:14:10I didn't think that that was a relevant argument
1:14:14because I remembered that Google got better.
1:14:16So the only question in my mind was not,
1:14:18are they any good at the launch?
1:14:20Of course they're not good at the launch.
1:14:22They're just getting started on something
1:14:23that people have been doing for 20 years
1:14:26and Google itself had been doing for seven years
1:14:28or six years.
1:14:29And of course, Google had a six year lead
1:14:31and of course they're gonna be better.
1:14:32so let's look at it six years from now.
1:14:34And I knew that they would have to spend the kind of money
1:14:39that just to maintain the here maps service
1:14:44or NAFTA cost a billion dollars a year.
1:14:46So in order to obtain the depth of knowledge to catch up,
1:14:50you'd have to be spending more than that.
1:14:52Now, no one's confirmed or denied the two billion figure,
1:14:55but I would say that's credible.
1:14:59The amount of effort going in is at that level.
1:15:02And so that's how I got that number.
1:15:05- I will put a link to the piece in the show notes.
1:15:08I know I often say that and I forget to,
1:15:09but I've already got it in my notes, so it'll be there.
1:15:12But you make a good case for why it's,
1:15:14I think in the ballpark it's gotta be pretty close.
1:15:16And there is a lot, there's just a lot of ongoing legwork
1:15:20to run a modern mapping service.
1:15:22I mean, you need those drivers out on the streets
1:15:26taking the pictures of the stores and--
1:15:28I'll give you another example.
1:15:30And this is from a friend of mine who I met at,
1:15:33actually, last I met was at ULL,
1:15:36Paul Campbell's show in Ireland.
1:15:40And he ran a service in Prague, he was American,
1:15:44he ran a service in Prague, Germany,
1:15:46oh, so Prague, Czech Republic, sorry,
1:15:48where he would pay college students
1:15:53to walk around the city and make notes
1:15:58about the opening times of every restaurant,
1:16:01every place you could walk, bar,
1:16:03everything you could walk into.
1:16:05So the address and the details about,
1:16:09what was on the door that gave you information
1:16:13that was about that establishment.
1:16:15And so he would aggregate that data
1:16:17and overlay it on public open source maps
1:16:20and provide that as a tourist atlas.
1:16:25So he would let you download,
1:16:27So you would download this and not pay roaming charges.
1:16:30So imagine you're visiting from Italy to Prague
1:16:33and you're in Italian and you get the map of Prague
1:16:36from him and the law gives you this level of detail.
1:16:39Now, the reason he was in business is because Google Maps
1:16:41would have cost you a lot in roaming fees.
1:16:44So in Europe, it made sense that you could do
1:16:46every city this way.
1:16:47But then the real amazing story he told me was that
1:16:50Google came to him and said,
1:16:51"Why don't you just license all this data to us?"
1:16:55They didn't have it, Google didn't have this data.
1:16:58So he did a deal with Google where he's,
1:17:00and he felt he had been wronged in it
1:17:03because they offered him, like,
1:17:04we'll just put your name down at the bottom of each page.
1:17:06We won't pay you anything,
1:17:07we'll put your name down at the bottom.
1:17:09And so that'll be a link.
1:17:11So you're gonna get a lot of business
1:17:13from being exposed via Google Maps.
1:17:16And it turned out that that wasn't worth very much.
1:17:19So he felt that that was a bad deal
1:17:21and he got out of it later.
1:17:22But the idea is that Google itself,
1:17:27in order to get this information,
1:17:30does all kinds of deals, right?
1:17:33Either sends people on its own,
1:17:34or in this case, through another person
1:17:36who did all this work, has college students doing,
1:17:40because college students are fairly cheap,
1:17:42and they're going around by foot anyway,
1:17:43walking around the city,
1:17:44thinking they're discovering the world.
1:17:47And by the way, here you're gonna be paid
1:17:49a couple of dollars if you jot down this data
1:17:52every time you pass a doorway.
1:17:54And so this model of really low level crowdsourcing data
1:17:59is truly labor intensive,
1:18:02and it ends up costing a lot of money.
1:18:04And then cleaning it up and sending it all to India
1:18:06to have it rationalized and fixed and all that stuff.
1:18:11So there's a huge amount of effort there as well.
1:18:14And then they go off and do 3D,
1:18:17then they go off and do underground and internal maps.
1:18:20And then, you know, on and on it goes,
1:18:22the demands of these maps are suddenly,
1:18:24we wanna have every single thing,
1:18:26we want flyovers, we want vector maps,
1:18:29we're not happy with bitmaps, right?
1:18:35So all of that adds a huge amount of cost.
1:18:37And so if this is the game,
1:18:40you wonder then why are they doing it?
1:18:43Because you've gotta make the money back somehow.
1:18:46And it gets tough to understand the logic
1:18:50that exist besides the ones we see now,
1:18:54which are basically Google Maps advertising-based
1:18:58and Apple essentially saying that our devices are worth it.
1:19:01And so I asked the question,
1:19:04what else can we expect for business models
1:19:07as far as maps are concerned into the future?
1:19:09And I lead to thinking about transportation
1:19:12and autonomous vehicles.
1:19:14- Yeah, well, it's part of your analysis and I love this.
1:19:17I never really thought about it,
1:19:18But if you know starting with the idea that it takes about two billion dollars per year to maintain a modern mapping service
1:19:25That you can work out rough estimates of how many users
1:19:29The major mapping services have and then you can divide and figure out what does it cost per user per year and your your estimates?
1:19:37You come out with so Google Maps is the leading map service in in the world
1:19:43Costs about cost them about two dollars per user per year. So to be profitable now
1:19:48I'm reading right from your post Google would need to find ad revenues of two dollars per user per year
1:19:54With Apple with fewer users, but with a majority of iOS users
1:20:00By all accounts there Apple is spending about
1:20:04Six seven dollars a year per user per year and to make to justify that they really just need to you know
1:20:13Find six or seven dollars of value in the iPads and iPhones that people are buying which I you know
1:20:19as you said certainly seems reasonable and then you get to Nokia here and
1:20:24It's costing them
1:20:28$66 per year per user because they've only got 30 million users at this point and you can if you were to bundle it with
1:20:36With the old Nokia, I mean Microsoft Nokia because actually
1:20:40Now they exist without any users, so they are having what they're doing is they licensed it to Microsoft
1:20:45So Microsoft is a probably only paying Nokia, you know a couple of dollars like they would let's say for for for
1:20:52Let's say a blend between Apple and Google like some let's say five bucks a year for per user
1:20:58And that just doesn't cover their cost so they'd have to find other revenue. They do like I said they always been selling to car makers
1:21:05But that makes it you know, that's why the car in that that's why the car guys are so, you know asking four thousand dollars
1:21:13That you know, they're probably paying
1:21:15The the data vendor like three four hundred dollars per you know, their markups are huge and they're very inefficient
1:21:21But but that that's the that's per vehicle pricing. It's probably in the hundreds of dollars
1:21:26But again long now it's up for sale and it's still losing money as it is right and and the question I you know
1:21:34But this is why, people would ask me, why doesn't Apple buy Nokia here?
1:21:40And I would say, well look, it's up for sale for $3 billion and there's no deal yet, but
1:21:47somebody supposedly is bidding $3 billion on something that a few years ago cost $7
1:21:51billion and suddenly we're saying is absolutely a hygiene factor as far as platforms are concerned.
1:21:56If you don't have this, you're a non-player and Apple is desperate and so on and so on.
1:22:02All of these things make no sense when you look at the, when you follow the money and
1:22:05you say here's, somebody could just buy the third best mapping system and probably, you
1:22:12know, having the longest legacy actually.
1:22:16And no one wants it.
1:22:17Why is that?
1:22:18Why these things don't make sense to, you know, when you reconcile the dollars and you
1:22:22against the supposed value and in that,
1:22:27what is it, the invaluable nature of maps
1:22:31as a strategic asset.
1:22:33And so I point out that, well, the guys who are in it
1:22:37already have already decided and committed to this strategy
1:22:40and they're putting their own people to work on it
1:22:42and this would not help them very much.
1:22:44So the only question is, would there be a third party
1:22:46that wants to get into this business,
1:22:48but they have to discover a business model.
1:22:50That's the question.
1:22:52If Uber, and Uber is one of the candidates
1:22:54that's being put forward, maybe it's not true,
1:22:57but the rumors say that Uber's interested,
1:22:59or the car makers as a group would go and buy
1:23:03this mapping thing that's up for grabs,
1:23:05but they would have to come up with
1:23:07how do we make sure we're profitable
1:23:09to burning up to $2 billion a year
1:23:12to keep the service competitive?
1:23:17And the answer would have to be that
1:23:20They have to get into some way of monetizing autonomous vehicles, and I both have an interest
1:23:26in that.
1:23:27Yeah, because it can kill a bunch of birds, maybe more than two birds with one stone,
1:23:32where the autonomous vehicles...
1:23:34And you see, it's no secret that Uber is getting into package delivery and stuff like that.
1:23:42And that Amazon...
1:23:44A whole bunch of different companies are converging on the same idea, and that Amazon is investigating
1:23:49new ways to deliver packages to people that without going through UPS or something like
1:23:56that actually had an uncomfortable conversation with my UPS guy the other day where there
1:24:02was a package from Amazon that was left at our door and then the UPS guy came and rang
1:24:07the doorbell and had another one and that's very unlike UPS. UPS is usually very, very
1:24:12efficient at bundling two things. If you have two different orders coming that they come
1:24:17at one time. And he mentioned that he said he thought I wasn't home because that Amazon
1:24:25package had already been left there by somebody else at my front door. Clearly not delivered
1:24:31by UPS. But anyway, all these things, people getting driven around and not owning cars,
1:24:36this whole idea that if you live in an urban environment, you can use Uber instead of owning
1:24:41a car and you actually save money. You can save a lot of money compared to the monthly
1:24:47cost of owning a car and combine that with the fact that these cars could do the work
1:24:54of taking the pictures and stuff like that as they drive around the area.
1:24:58Alexi Oh yeah, and that's the thing.
1:25:01In fact, this professor at NYU Galloway, Scott Galloway, great guy and you should probably
1:25:08interview him.
1:25:09He's found to the knowledge.
1:25:13He points out that Uber is potentially disruptive to Amazon
1:25:17because when you break Amazon down,
1:25:19besides having a discovery engine for, you know,
1:25:21through the website, it's really a massive operations
1:25:24and distribution center.
1:25:27In fact, that's where a lot of their money goes.
1:25:29There are a lot of their capex or capital expenses
1:25:32are in setting up distribution centers globally,
1:25:35and they're very expensive,
1:25:37and they're somewhat even robotic.
1:25:39They have robots and stuff in them.
1:25:42And so that's a high cost thing and they're doing it
1:25:46because really that's how they get the growth thing.
1:25:49They have to get these packages
1:25:51from a lot of points to a lot of points.
1:25:56And the thing is that that's exactly what Uber does.
1:25:59Now it doesn't have the storefront,
1:26:00but it's actually probably easier for them
1:26:02to do a storefront than it would be
1:26:07to build the infrastructure that they're disrupting.
1:26:10So it's fascinating.
1:26:12I think Uber is one of the most disruptive ideas ever.
1:26:16And so that's why they would come to the maps question
1:26:20with a different set of priorities,
1:26:21not so much about monetizing them
1:26:23the way the other two are doing it,
1:26:25but rather than saying,
1:26:25"Hey, this is actually exactly in the direction
1:26:28we wanna go, we wanna be a logistics company,
1:26:30we wanna be a transportation company,
1:26:32we wanna be a potential even a vehicle company."
1:26:36And so all of that, the maps enables that.
1:26:40And of course the car makers are in it
1:26:42for the same obvious reasons that they've always been.
1:26:46- Yeah, it makes a lot of sense to me intuitively
1:26:49that if somebody else were gonna start,
1:26:52like let's just say Uber to be a third major maps company,
1:26:56that they would have a third different revenue model.
1:27:02So there's Google that's doing it with advertising
1:27:05and just sort of, we'll put our maps anywhere
1:27:08and everywhere we can and get the most people
1:27:11we possibly can and we're gonna make that money back
1:27:13by advertising and we really only need to sell a few dollars
1:27:16in ads per user per year to make this work.
1:27:19There's the Apple model which is we're gonna use this
1:27:22as a value add to our premium products
1:27:26and I don't feel like anybody is gonna catch Google
1:27:29or Apple in either of those ways soon.
1:27:32And so it makes sense to me that if somebody's gonna be
1:27:35a strong number three, that it would be with an entirely
1:27:38different model like Uber.
1:27:39Yeah.
1:27:40And that's where I'm saying by the title,
1:27:42it's like where maps are going, is
1:27:44where in the sense of obtaining value from transportation.
1:27:49By the way, it's possible that both Apple and Google also
1:27:52have that in mind, because they're going to potentially
1:27:54enable vehicles either of their own design
1:27:56or licensing it for that.
1:27:59And the other thing that I found fascinating,
1:28:02and I don't remember where I read it,
1:28:03But it was a wonderful expose which said that really the key to the autonomous vehicle,
1:28:10the self-driving cars that Google is now field testing is not that they have this amazing
1:28:16algorithm that it recognizes the world and is able to act as if we do in terms of avoiding
1:28:23an accident, but rather that they compare what they see with what they stored. And what
1:28:30is stored is essentially hyper high resolution
1:28:35map of the street.
1:28:36So imagine that the vehicles drive over the same spot
1:28:39many times, they always take a picture
1:28:42and then they upload it.
1:28:43And that is what's stored as the,
1:28:45this is the world the way it looks.
1:28:47Now compare the way the world looks
1:28:50with what you are seeing at this moment.
1:28:52If they don't match, then there's an obstacle.
1:28:55So that's the way they determine
1:28:56whether there's an obstacle in the way,
1:28:58because there is this kind of comparison being done.
1:29:02Rather than saying, oh, I see this blob,
1:29:04I'm gonna use my artificial intelligence
1:29:06to determine if the blob is a person or an animal
1:29:09or a boulder.
1:29:12It's really about this kind of differential
1:29:15they're able to do.
1:29:16So it's really much more brute force than we think.
1:29:20And probably more effective by the way,
1:29:23and less error prone than this idea
1:29:28of really machine learning about driving.
1:29:31And so it's very data driven and that boils down
1:29:35to therefore really having super hyper accurate maps
1:29:38like down to the centimeter in terms of resolution
1:29:41rather than what we see now which is down to the meter.
1:29:44And also not just street view, imagine street view
1:29:49with the ability to see every square centimeter
1:29:54of the world as you're moving along at 60 frames a second.
1:29:57And so you're doing that comparison continuously
1:30:00and therefore you're able to really have
1:30:03that autonomous machine.
1:30:05And this is why also it's very difficult to,
1:30:08one of the side effects is that they,
1:30:10unless you have a map of the inside of a,
1:30:13let's say an inside of a parking garage,
1:30:15the car cannot go there.
1:30:17The car can only go in places that have been pre-mapped
1:30:20and pre-visualized.
1:30:21And so that's why maps are so important
1:30:24to autonomous vehicles.
1:30:25It's because the algorithms depend on having
1:30:28a very hyper accurate view of the world.
1:30:30And so if either three of these three contenders, right,
1:30:35Google, Apple and Uber who want to become potentially,
1:30:40again, there's a lot of hypothesis here,
1:30:42potentially suppliers of transportation services,
1:30:47then you get into this whole question,
1:30:49how good are your maps?
1:30:50They have to control the maps.
1:30:52And in fact, maps are not good enough,
1:30:54so they can't just go, oh, we'll just get somebody
1:30:57to do it for us.
1:30:58No, we've gotta have to figure this out.
1:31:00So that's why I think part of these vans
1:31:03you see that Apple drives around
1:31:05and we think of them as being,
1:31:06well, they're just doing Street View.
1:31:08Well, Street View is the baby version
1:31:10of what's gonna be necessary
1:31:11if you're gonna have autonomous vehicle.
1:31:13- That's a great point.
1:31:14Let's keep going on this, but before we do,
1:31:15I wanna thank our third and final sponsor
1:31:17and it's our good friends at Casper.
1:31:21Casper makes obsessively engineered mattresses at shockingly fair prices
1:31:27Just the right sink just the right bounce they combine two technologies
1:31:34To make one mattress. You don't have to go there and pick like oh
1:31:37Do you want mattress a or mattress B mattress C?
1:31:40You just pick a size and all their mattresses have the same exact feel to them using two technologies latex foam and memory foam
1:31:49Put together with just the right mix of how much of each style to make a perfect mattress
1:31:55now again
1:31:58Buying a mattress all this stuff you can buy online sounds crazy
1:32:01Well, how why in the world would you buy a mattress online if you can't feel it? I
1:32:04Can't try it
1:32:06Here's the thing. They have a risk-free
1:32:08Trial and return policy you try sleeping on a Casper for a hundred days
1:32:14and that's with free delivery and
1:32:17Painless free return so 99 days into it. You don't like it
1:32:20You think this is this is not a this was not a good mattress
1:32:23You just go to their website and say, you know set up a thing. They'll come pick up the mattress take it out of there
1:32:29That's how confident though they are in the mattress that now when they first started sponsoring a show
1:32:36I forget what the free trial period was
1:32:38but it was less than a hundred days and they extended it to a hundred days because that they've
1:32:44Had so few returns because people buy these mattresses and love them
1:32:47their mattresses are made in America and
1:32:51The prices if you've ever if you shop for a mattress recently, you'll see just how low these prices are
1:32:57500 for a twin size mattress
1:33:00up to
1:33:02950 for a king-size mattress so under a thousand dollars for a king-size mattress unheard of for a premium mattress
1:33:08Compare that to the industry averages and it's just outstanding
1:33:13How do they deliver them? This is part of the amazing part of this, is that by using these foam technologies,
1:33:20latex foam and memory foam, they can vacuum seal these mattresses into a shockingly small box.
1:33:26It's a big box to get delivered. It's probably the biggest package you'll get, you know, if you order one of these.
1:33:31It's probably the biggest package you'll get all year, but it's way smaller than the size of a mattress.
1:33:35And so they have instructions on the box. They tell you, take it to the room where you want to have it,
1:33:41take it to your bedroom and open the box there. You definitely don't want to open it downstairs
1:33:46and then carry it upstairs because then you're stuck lugging a mattress size thing. You open
1:33:50it up and it makes a cool sound as it soaks in the air and next thing you know you've
1:33:54got a full-size mattress. Really, really good stuff. I've got one. It's really nice. It's
1:34:00a great mattress. Could not be more convenient. I just found out I did not know this. I don't
1:34:05live in New York. They've got a thing where if you live in New York City, you can get
1:34:09one same day, I believe, and they actually deliver them. This is how small the boxes
1:34:14are. They get delivered by people on bicycles. It's a big thing to lug on your back on a
1:34:20bike but it actually is that convenient to ship around.
1:34:24Here's the thing. You can't lose. You don't have to go to six different mattress stores
1:34:30and try six different mattresses and figure out which ones are equivalent between the
1:34:35the two in price shop, just go to casper.com/the talk show,
1:34:39casper, C-A-S-P-E-R, .com/the talk show.
1:34:44Figure out what size mattress you want and order it.
1:34:48That's it.
1:34:49Now use that code, the talk show.
1:34:52I think it kicks in as long as you just use the URL,
1:34:54but if you need the code, it's the talk show.
1:34:57And you save an additional 50 bucks
1:35:00off the price of any mattress.
1:35:03So save 50 bucks, they'll know you came from the show,
1:35:06and you'll get a great mattress
1:35:08at a truly unbeatable price, casper.com/thetalkshow.
1:35:13So we were talking about maps.
1:35:15I'm not sure if we have more to go on maps,
1:35:18but it has occurred to me.
1:35:21One thing I've looked at,
1:35:22as I've been thinking about it more and more,
1:35:24is that I'm slow to the uptake sometimes
1:35:28on revolutionary companies.
1:35:30And Uber is one of them.
1:35:32where Uber is a company where I've been using them for a while, especially since they came
1:35:36to Philadelphia, but they've always been—they started in San Francisco and San Francisco
1:35:41has—well, it's gotten better and it's because of Uber, but San Francisco to me has
1:35:47always had some of the worst taxi cab service of any city that I visit. It's simply appalling
1:35:53compared to what I'm used to on the East Coast. I was a big fan of Uber in San Francisco
1:35:59right from the get-go. But I just I thought of them simply as a newfangled
1:36:06taxi company and that's it and I didn't look past that and it occurred to me
1:36:10that that's exactly how I used to see Amazon. I was a very early adopter of
1:36:14Amazon for buying books but I saw them as a bookstore and then people would say
1:36:19"Oh Amazon has ambitions to do a lot more than just books" and I would just roll my
1:36:24eyes and think whatever but it's a pretty it is a pretty cool bookstore I
1:36:28thought the same thing about uber until recently but I see now that I think that
1:36:33they they sort of are like the inverse of Amazon indeed and you know what
1:36:40what's interesting when you think about trying to do this type of analysis of
1:36:45where thing you know I always use some kind of you know biological metaphor
1:36:50Like I say, you know, it's like looking at a baby and saying, "That's a pretty useless
1:36:56human being."
1:36:57You know, it's just like, can't do anything.
1:37:01It's like, this is a lot of the criticisms we get when, not just when new companies are
1:37:06born, but even when new products are born from established companies.
1:37:09And we're just like, "Eh, it's useless."
1:37:13You know, like the Apple Watch or the first iPhone or the first whatever.
1:37:17I mean, yeah, some things Apple does
1:37:19were much more meaningful, but it's like,
1:37:21the logic of it is that,
1:37:23or rather to say the magic of it is being able
1:37:27to look in the child's eyes and say,
1:37:30there lies a human being that's gonna live 90 years,
1:37:34that's gonna have an amazing life,
1:37:36that's gonna change the world
1:37:38and contribute so much to others.
1:37:40And yet, that's not what comes in the mind
1:37:46even of the parent, the stranger may just be ambivalent.
1:37:50Or a lot of young people who haven't, you remember,
1:37:54when you were a teenager, you didn't think babies
1:37:57were all that great.
1:37:58But when you're parent age, you kind of really get
1:38:01a soft spot, and then when it's your kid,
1:38:04you're completely irrational about children.
1:38:07But the point I'm making is that we don't love children
1:38:12because of what they're gonna be necessarily.
1:38:15We don't love our children because they're gonna grow up
1:38:18to be lawyers and doctors,
1:38:20nor that they're gonna help us in our old age.
1:38:23We love them 'cause it's just we love them.
1:38:25And the thing is that there's this,
1:38:29I'd like to propose that we treat startups
1:38:34and young things in general with the same
1:38:39the contemplation of their potential,
1:38:44but also sort of saying, well, they're valuable just because they exist.
1:38:48You know, they're just valuable because somebody took the effort of making it.
1:38:53And, you know, that's worth a lot.
1:38:58And, you know, it's coming back to Pixar again, remember, in Ratatouille and that speech
1:39:05of what was the name of the critic at the end.
1:39:11He said, "Nothing we do as critics is worth the crummiest product we've ever visited or
1:39:20the crummiest restaurant we've ever eaten at because these people work to make it happen
1:39:26and all we do is consume the result and mock it.
1:39:33So they deserve a lot more than we do."
1:39:37he said, you know the value of the critic he continues is in discovering the new and
1:39:42that's that that was in a beautiful speech and
1:39:46I wish I would remember who wrote it but it was almost as if they were speaking to the characters name was Anton you go
1:39:54Portrayed that's Peter. Oh, I remember that hitting home for me too, because I
1:40:01clearly was self-aware enough to recognize that that's more or less that the career that I've carved out for myself is
1:40:08you know effectively I'm a critic a
1:40:11Pundit on these things and that I do a lot more
1:40:15Telling tell you know thinking about whether the work of other people is good or bad or how it could be improved
1:40:23Then I do creating it myself and that you know, I should remember that and keep that perspective and not
1:40:30never lose sight of the fact that what I say is not more important than the
1:40:34actual work itself. Having said that, so I you know I want to make sure that we
1:40:42give we give a lot of credit to those who stick their necks out but it's it's
1:40:47also important that when you when you look at something and you ask yourself
1:40:51what can it become that there are helpful hints. One thing you can study
1:40:57with a baby is the kid study its parents.
1:40:59Often that's a great indicator of what they're going to end up doing or how well.
1:41:03Not always.
1:41:04I mean maybe even if you have 20% chance, it's better than zero though.
1:41:10So there's that.
1:41:11And also sometimes you study the child and you see whether they struggled through life.
1:41:16And that usually tells you that they will do better than average because they actually
1:41:21are learning through experience.
1:41:26And so when you see something like an Uber, you know, you measure things like are they
1:41:31flexible, are they driven, are they, do they have an ambition.
1:41:38And fundamentally, I think the disruptive theory that I'm a big fan of and I'm a big
1:41:46supporter and advocate of is that it gives you these hints about where things can go
1:41:52And the thinking around the analysis
1:41:56around an object like Uber is that, you know,
1:41:59they're solving a job,
1:42:00and that is to get people from point to point.
1:42:03And that job today has an alternative called a car.
1:42:07And it's really about understanding the substitution power
1:42:11that they have versus something that doesn't necessarily,
1:42:15is not seen in the same category.
1:42:18And this is when you start to jump across markets
1:42:22and you have to cross categories and say,
1:42:24you know, actually this thing has the potential
1:42:26to be a threat to something that's completely unrelated.
1:42:29And that skill of understanding what it's really,
1:42:34what it's really trying to do and what the customer,
1:42:38we use the phrase, what the customer hires the product to do
1:42:42and this is in a way of saying,
1:42:44this is the jobs to be done methodologies,
1:42:48like saying, well, you don't buy a drill,
1:42:50you buy a hole in the wall.
1:42:51And so if, and this has been an observation
1:42:55for many, many decades ago,
1:42:56that that which companies sell isn't what their buyers
1:43:00or their customers are buying.
1:43:02So this distinction is important
1:43:05because those are the capabilities that the seller have,
1:43:10that has the capability that they say,
1:43:13well, we can make this,
1:43:14but then the other person on the other side
1:43:16who receives the product is saying,
1:43:18well, what I really need is something else,
1:43:19but thanks, I'll take this and I'll make it work.
1:43:22That's where the combination of those two things,
1:43:25plus the opportunity to shake hands and change money,
1:43:29that's how we make business.
1:43:30And so often these are separate things.
1:43:33Too many times we end up in a situation
1:43:35where we buy a product, not exactly what we want.
1:43:38But then you ask yourself,
1:43:42but that product can evolve and get better
1:43:44because it's getting information from the buyer
1:43:46about what's wrong with it.
1:43:48And then they get pricing signals.
1:43:52Sounds very, very much like a buzzword.
1:43:55But the idea is simply that,
1:43:56look, I can't charge much for this thing.
1:43:59Like today, I can't charge $400 for Office anymore.
1:44:04And that's a signal to Microsoft to say,
1:44:06go do something else.
1:44:08And if you don't have that signal, you just keep doing it.
1:44:11So if you sell to enterprises who are like,
1:44:13or whatever, I'll keep paying, then you get dumber.
1:44:18You get dumber and not move on.
1:44:20And so if you have consumer as a customer,
1:44:22then they're gonna eventually say,
1:44:24oh, I'm not gonna pay that anymore.
1:44:26I'm gonna go off and buy a tablet
1:44:27that does good enough work instead of a PC,
1:44:29et cetera, et cetera.
1:44:30And so this is why the conversation happens
1:44:34with the customer.
1:44:35So anyway, there's a lot of these things we can talk about.
1:44:38But bottom line is that when I think about an Uber,
1:44:42I always think about, well, what are they really hired to do?
1:44:44And I think what they're hired to do is saying,
1:44:46I want a car outside my door whenever I'm ready to go.
1:44:49And if I have that option every time, every day,
1:44:54everywhere, then I don't need a car anymore.
1:44:59And that means I can get rid of my car.
1:45:01And if I can do a deal with Uber and say,
1:45:04hey guys, I don't wanna pay for this trip
1:45:06every time I get in the car,
1:45:08but can I just pay upfront $300
1:45:10and you guys always show up.
1:45:11And Uber works it out and says, okay,
1:45:15they probably will have some customers
1:45:17that will use it less and some customers
1:45:19that will use it more, but on average,
1:45:20maybe $300 a month is a good price
1:45:23to offer it as a all you can eat Uber.
1:45:28Then suddenly you'll have like Amazon Prime.
1:45:33And so you'll be saying, I want Uber Prime.
1:45:36So Uber Prime is $350 a month.
1:45:38Maybe in the beginning they're gonna charge $500 a month
1:45:41'cause some people will pay that
1:45:42and probably they'll have fewer sparse users,
1:45:47et cetera, et cetera.
1:45:48So over time that's gonna change.
1:45:49But anyway, they'll do that and someday,
1:45:51and then what?
1:45:52And then, so Uber is pulling in all this money, $500,
1:45:56and they're saying, and then they have to turn around
1:45:58and hire people to serve as chauffeurs or whatever.
1:46:02And they'll say, maybe we oughta finance
1:46:06their car prop buying.
1:46:07Maybe we ought to put them on the payroll.
1:46:10Maybe we're gonna get some autonomous vehicles.
1:46:13We'll have better algorithms for dispatch
1:46:16because we'll know where these people live,
1:46:17et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
1:46:19So a lot of these things are gonna be information driven.
1:46:21And at that point though, the machine just takes over
1:46:25and it just goes, goes, and goes rolling and rolling.
1:46:27And as far as the entrepreneur is concerned,
1:46:30at every stage of that journey,
1:46:32they're just following in their instincts.
1:46:33They're saying, well, obviously we gotta do this, right?
1:46:36people are asking for it.
1:46:37Or hey, I just, some guy, you know,
1:46:40an intern runs in the room and say,
1:46:41"Hey, have we thought of doing this?
1:46:43"This makes a lot of sense.
1:46:44"I just ran these numbers, look at this."
1:46:46And so they'll do it without any kind of great strategy
1:46:49or any kind of big vision or any McKinsey consultant
1:46:52telling them that's what the future's gonna be.
1:46:54So they'll do it intuitively, and lo and behold,
1:46:5810 years later, they'll have millions of customers
1:47:03paying them billions of dollars a year
1:47:06to provide transportation services
1:47:08and all those millions of customers
1:47:09will have abandoned owning a car
1:47:12and Uber will be commissioning more Priuses
1:47:14than anybody else on the planet,
1:47:16probably enough to fill a factory with production.
1:47:20So in that case, why shouldn't Uber just make its own cars?
1:47:24And maybe it will, maybe it won't.
1:47:25Maybe it'll just simply do a great deal with Toyota
1:47:28and Toyota will essentially be having one giant customer
1:47:32versus millions of small ones.
1:47:35And so maybe that deal will work for both of them,
1:47:38but maybe not, maybe Uber will say,
1:47:41price isn't the best configuration,
1:47:43we could do a lot better if we made our own design.
1:47:46And then they'll hire the best designer out of GM
1:47:49or Toyota or BMW and they'll say, we go to it.
1:47:51And by the way, we've got manufacturing guys
1:47:54who can help as well.
1:47:55And on it goes, right?
1:47:56So this is why you go from a baby to a mature adult
1:48:00that suddenly is changing the world.
1:48:02- But that's the thing that's occurred to me.
1:48:03And I realized that it's very different
1:48:05if you live in a relatively, or like I live in a real urban environment. I live in Center
1:48:09City, Philadelphia. I go to New York a lot. I go to San Francisco a lot. But if you live
1:48:13anywhere, it's even relatively Uber where Uber can be a practical service. I mean, obviously,
1:48:18there's, especially in the United States, there's many people who live in rural areas
1:48:21where Uber isn't going to make sense or at least isn't going to make sense for a long
1:48:25time. But just take a look at a typical city. Where are most of the cars? By far and away,
1:48:32of the cars at any moment in any city are parked, right, which is incredibly inefficient.
1:48:38And it's an enormous part of the pain in the ass of owning a car or even visiting a city
1:48:44with a car is the pain of parking.
1:48:49So I can, but that's actually good for the auto industry where there's a lot more cars
1:48:54being sold than there are cars being driven at any moment.
1:48:59the disruption of Uber is let's keep these cars moving. And it's almost like the airline metaphor,
1:49:06you know, and you hear that like, one of the reasons that Southwest is is more successful
1:49:11than most other airlines is that the employees buy into the mantra. You can't make money with
1:49:16planes that aren't in the air. And that's why they their Southwest has, you know, significantly,
1:49:23like, like, it contributes to their profitability that they
1:49:29there take that takes them less time to deep disembark and
1:49:33embark on a flight and they keep most of their planes in the air.
1:49:36Well, an Uber car that isn't being driven isn't making money.
1:49:40And but that if people stop buying cars and just leaving
1:49:43them in their garage parked all night. I don't know that that
1:49:47could to me be terribly disruptive to the auto industry
1:49:50in terms of the number of cars being bought.
1:49:52Oh yes, oh yes, oh yes indeed.
1:49:54And that's, see, the dream that you have
1:49:57of better utilization of cars
1:50:00is exactly also Google's dream when it came to,
1:50:03you know, to their motivation for driverless cars,
1:50:08because they, but here's the interesting thing,
1:50:10this is where the theory comes into play again,
1:50:12is that let's say you follow the logic of Google
1:50:16and their algorithmic approach to autonomy,
1:50:20and then you follow Uber's logic and you ask,
1:50:23here's a good question.
1:50:24Let's say you see both of them pointing in the direction
1:50:27of depopulating cities with automobiles
1:50:34and increasing utilization of automobiles.
1:50:38And so who wins?
1:50:39Because this is where you have to have another way
1:50:42of thinking and theorizing about it
1:50:44because the problem I think is that in the case of Google,
1:50:49they're just saying we understand where we were going,
1:50:52we're gonna get there through a process of research
1:50:56and we're gonna ship the product when it's ready.
1:51:01And that's where I think that's kind of a deliberate
1:51:04approach where Uber is just gonna follow its nose
1:51:06and go down that path and maybe it'll get there,
1:51:08maybe it won't, but all the time it does it,
1:51:10it learns and all the time it does it, it's profitable.
1:51:13And so if that's the, my bet would be that Uber
1:51:16will get there faster.
1:51:17So that's how I would analyze that.
1:51:19But it's a great story.
1:51:21It's a wonderful analysis.
1:51:22Dave Asprey Do you think, here's my question about Uber,
1:51:24is how does Uber protect their lead?
1:51:29What keeps other companies from saying, "Oh, I see what they're doing.
1:51:33Let's all do that too."
1:51:34And then all of a sudden, the whole idea of anything you could use Uber for is commoditized?
1:51:41Some of it is just plain running as fast as you can.
1:51:47So one thing obviously is that they're recruiting drivers as quickly as possible, they're recruiting
1:51:54users as quickly as possible, establishing as many cities as possible.
1:51:59So they're running essentially in the land grab scenario where you identify the resources
1:52:04that you need, drivers, cars, passengers and regulation.
1:52:09you just like sweeping the land with that and then you assume there's a first mover
1:52:14advantage of course others can come in but you realize it's heavy lifting.
1:52:18Similarly you could have said well why you know when Google stumbled upon search as the
1:52:22answer why didn't everybody else I mean yes their algorithms were better but there were
1:52:26other search engines and partly was like Google doubled and tripled and quadrupled down on
1:52:30servers and on infrastructure and that was basically that was their secret sauce.
1:52:36It was brute force, it was just running really fast.
1:52:38And so in the early years, that's what you do.
1:52:40- And they were obsessively focused on response times.
1:52:44Like to a degree, like where other search engines
1:52:47were measuring response times in seconds,
1:52:50and Google was already measuring in tenths of a second.
1:52:53- And so experience was important,
1:52:57but ultimately it was like, they did the heavy,
1:53:00they designed their own data centers,
1:53:01they designed their own servers,
1:53:03at a time when all of those things you could buy
1:53:05and even rent, and so why did they need to go
1:53:08so deep in the guts of their operations?
1:53:11Because they realized that the thing that they needed
1:53:13to tweak the most was that performance metric
1:53:16and the scaling metric, and so that let them essentially
1:53:19run like wildfire and capture share.
1:53:21And again, same thing with Microsoft, by the way,
1:53:24and others who came before.
1:53:25It's this driving force that you're just gonna go
1:53:29as fast as you can because you know where you're going,
1:53:31you know what you're doing.
1:53:33And the other guys are just not sure if that's worth committing how many billions, you know,
1:53:38and especially the big guys are like, I don't get this.
1:53:40Yeah, I had the thought I had about it was sort of the way that as long as they as long
1:53:47you know, the first mover advantage is, is real, but you have to kind of stay focused
1:53:53on still being the best, even if it's in small ways.
1:53:57And the thing that made me think about it was a tweet from our friend, the guy who stole
1:54:02my shirt Ben Thompson this week where he he mentioned that he was in San Francisco obviously
1:54:08for WWDC to and had a couple of coupons or codes or something to get free rides in Lyft
1:54:18and he had been meaning to try it he'd never tried the service and here he'd gone back
1:54:22home to Taipei and forgot to use them and had taken an Uber every time he got in a car
1:54:27in San Francisco simply out of habit and that the habits matter that without even thinking
1:54:32about it he'd forgotten to try Lyft even though he was going to be able to try it for free.
1:54:38To me that just speaks to the power of the first mover advantage.
1:54:41Alex Petros Yeah, power of first mover, power of defaults,
1:54:45power of being the go-to thing that people hire right away.
1:54:50There is something, but that's again, that's earned.
1:54:52It's not something that you can get to before you actually do great work.
1:54:59It comes as a byproduct of building the brand and building the experience and all those
1:55:05other things.
1:55:06So knowing to focus on the right thing at the right time, knowing to put all the chips
1:55:10on the table when you know you have a good hand, that's really, at first of course you
1:55:15got to get the chips but that's the thing is that the magic of the entrepreneur is the
1:55:19one that is able to parlay every advantage into another one and then bet again and again
1:55:26and again, doubling down every time and shifting their strategy all along the way and pivoting
1:55:32as they call it these days.
1:55:34That's the magic of it.
1:55:35I could not agree more.
1:55:37So let's wrap it up.
1:55:38We're nearing the two-hour mark.
1:55:40Horace Tedu, thank you extraordinarily for your time.
1:55:44What a fascinating conversation.
1:55:45Here's where people can find out more at first your website, asymco, A-S-Y-M-C-O dot com.
1:55:54You've got your own podcast, The Critical Path, over with the 5x5.
1:55:59Go to 5x5.tv and find your podcast, The Critical Path.
1:56:05And what else?
1:56:06Where are you on Twitter?
1:56:07A.J.
1:56:08ZWICKI A Twitter, it's just @ASymco.
1:56:09A.J.
1:56:10ZWICKI @ASymco, a very good Twitter account.
1:56:13Anything else before we go?
1:56:15A.J.
1:56:16ZWICKI No.
1:56:17Thank you very much for this opportunity.
1:56:19It's been a long time.
1:56:21A.J.
1:56:22ZWICKI Likewise.
1:56:23Fascinating stuff.
1:56:24and we'll talk to you soon.