Podcast Search

The Talk Show

121: ‘He Was Sort of Anti-Golf’ With Guest Rene Ritchie

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00I don't even know where to start. What do you want to start with?

0:00:02Johnny Ive.

0:00:03Johnny Ive. I guess that's probably historically the biggest news of the week. So we just talk about our new black watches

0:00:10So Monday Memorial Day US holiday I

0:00:20Was just I

0:00:25I so did not know what to make sense of this when it hit.

0:00:27A story came out in the Telegraph in the United Kingdom,

0:00:32written by Stephen Fry, who, though I don't,

0:00:37I have some complaints about the article,

0:00:39is a wonderful, you know,

0:00:41one of the world's most beloved figures.

0:00:46I mean, he's a comedian, actor, writer,

0:00:48long-time Apple fan, wrote a profile,

0:00:52and I guess you'd call it a profile?

0:00:54I don't know, even the headline is weird.

0:00:56The headline is when Stephen Fry met Johnny Ive,

0:00:59the self-confessed tech geek,

0:01:01talks to Apple's newly promoted chief design officer.

0:01:05In an exclusive interview in which Ive's promotion

0:01:09is revealed for the first time,

0:01:11Stephen Fry meets Johnny Ive and his boss,

0:01:13Apple chief executive Tim Cook,

0:01:15to talk spaceships, design, and Steve Jobs.

0:01:17And so, you know.

0:01:23So part of the news, it's sort of a first person account of hanging out with Johnny

0:01:27Ive and Tim Cook, which in and of itself is interesting, but to me, and the part that's

0:01:31just odd to me is that this is how Apple chose to unveil the, what would you call it, the

0:01:40executive change, which is that Johnny Ive has been promoted from senior vice president

0:01:44of design to chief design officer and two of his lieutenants, Richard Haworth and Alan

0:01:53and

0:02:15time in the industrial design department there. They're a very close-knit team, very involved

0:02:21team and Alan Dye came over with iOS 7 which is just a couple of years and it's I mean it's a

0:02:27super fascinating topic to talk about because the dynamic of ID is that they all did work together

0:02:31for so long and were so used to collaborating but with HI Johnny Ive was new to it and he needed

0:02:37someone who was a strong collaborator in UI but he didn't go with any of the traditional like Greg

0:02:42Christie team, he went with Alan Dye for marketing and then had to collaborate because he doesn't

0:02:49draw pixels as far as I know. Yeah, Greg Christie is an interesting, you know, I don't, and that's

0:02:54one of the reasons I wanted to have you on talk about this because I feel like you're a little

0:02:57juiced in your, at least your mental Rolodex is a little bit more up to date than mine on some of

0:03:03the names and stuff like that, but Greg Christie is a great example like where, I mean, I don't

0:03:08I don't even remember what his title was, but I remember, certainly, they don't tell

0:03:13you, one of the weird things about WWDC is that they don't tell you who's presenting

0:03:19until you go to the session or until you start playing the session. And there is a credit

0:03:24that tells you who it is who's talking to you, but in advance they don't tell you.

0:03:28And sometimes who is giving the presentation is actually more of an indication as to what

0:03:33the subject is going to be than the title of the session.

0:03:36Absolutely. I think I last saw Greg Christie. I don't know if he did anything last year,

0:03:39but I saw him do the big presentation on how they designed photos for iOS a couple years

0:03:43ago. Yes, I remember that one. Right. And it just

0:03:45because it just so happened that, you know, the user interface stuff was always more interesting

0:03:49to me and always a little bit more, you know, up my, in my wheelhouse as one might say.

0:03:57I almost said in my wheelbarrow. In my wheelhouse, as one would say. I wound up in Greg Christie-led

0:04:05many times over the years. I think I seem to recall a long time ago there was even

0:04:09like one that was more like a panel discussion, like stuff that they don't

0:04:14really do at WWDC anymore. But yeah, Greg Christie was from back in the

0:04:18day when there was like a general HI team that was sort of, I guess, really

0:04:24just reported its jobs. It wasn't really part of any kind of

0:04:31chain.

0:04:32Yeah, as far as I know, I mean, HI was always sort of elevated at Apple beyond where they

0:04:36would have been, like maybe another company that would have been slotted in under some

0:04:38VP of some software product division somewhere.

0:04:43Right.

0:04:44But, you know, and as I've sort of written out, just dipping my toes in, part of this

0:04:50is that one of the reasons Johnny Ive wanted to bring user interface design under his design

0:04:57team's umbrella is that he wasn't exactly happy with all of the direction that interface

0:05:04design had gone at Apple in recent years or in the years prior. I mean, because obviously

0:05:09it was a change. I mean, whether you love the iOS 7 and Yosemite looks or whether you

0:05:14don't like them or whether you're ambivalent about them, nobody can deny that there was

0:05:18a shift in aesthetics.

0:05:20Absolutely. And that, I mean, I think it feels like Scott Forestall gets blamed for a lot

0:05:24of that but you know it was Steve Jobs airplane that had the famous stitch leather texture

0:05:29that he wanted. He was a big proponent of that sort of affordance and Greg Christie

0:05:33and I'm blanking on the gentleman's last name Baz who testified on all the Samsung

0:05:37lawsuits and then subsequently left Apple. They were intimately involved in the early

0:05:41years of the iPhone design that whole team and that whole focus and he really did feel

0:05:45like he wanted something new when he came in.

0:05:48Right. And Alan Dye came from, in Apple terms, MarCom. Does that widespread the industry?

0:05:57I always thought that was sort of an Appleism.

0:05:59No, I used to work in MarCom. So for me, it's always been normal in an enterprise. And I

0:06:04think you and I both worked in print design for a while. And I always found that sort

0:06:10of background. And I know Mark Edwards did that too. And I always found that sort of

0:06:13background really educational when you started moving into digital design.

0:06:17Yeah.

0:06:18And anyway, Greg Christie left Apple.

0:06:21Not immediately, but he left in their Panzareno story

0:06:27from April 9th, 2014,

0:06:29veteran designer Greg Christie departs.

0:06:31And I don't know that it's as simple,

0:06:33I don't know the story there,

0:06:34but I don't, you know, whether it was, you know,

0:06:38just, well, you picked him instead of me, then I'm out.

0:06:40You know, I don't know.

0:06:41Or if it was just, you know,

0:06:42but Christie had been there for a long time,

0:06:43and it's, you know, maybe, you know,

0:06:46He could just put his finger in the wind until it was time to go. But yes, and there was definitely it was not exactly universally

0:06:52Seen as the right decision within Apple. Well, I think that's absolutely true

0:06:57I think you said that really well and there was a joke around the time that you know

0:06:59We mentioned was gonna hate the direction. Yes

0:07:02Yeah

0:07:02but there's a lot of people who fell into that camp of liking rich textures and rich designs and

0:07:08They they they had to be on board at my understanding is there was a really big meeting where this whole direction was

0:07:13announced and not everybody was happy with it, but at the same time you have people like

0:07:17Greg Christine you have people like army Lamora who?

0:07:20Literally did forced marathons marathons of sprints for years and years and years and I think that comes to a point where you just you need

0:07:27to stop

0:07:28Especially if you're at that intense level of doing iOS and a yearly grind schedule. Yeah

0:07:37Yeah, so I think bottom line is because a whole worth is you know industrial design has been under Johnny's group

0:07:44I mean that was in fact that was Johnny's group. I think yes in the old days Johnny's group really was just industrial design

0:07:50and

0:07:52Holworth has been part of that and clearly, you know

0:07:55Johnny trusts him and they've gotten along and that whole group has by all accounts that I've ever read has always been very tight-knit

0:08:02And has gotten along

0:08:04Extremely well that there's it's not just that they do good work, but that there's a true camaraderie

0:08:09I think that's been part of the secret of keeping because a lot of creative people

0:08:13They don't go very long term bill Watterson famously retired from Calvin and Hobbes and some people like George Lucas

0:08:19They end up making prequels which is not the best of their work. And I think the relationship that ID group had

0:08:24when Steve Jobs came back to Apple

0:08:26They were off somewhere in the boonies and he brought them to IL to and set them up and made them so important

0:08:31but that group seems to have sort of kept them all fed

0:08:33and energized and alive for many, many years.

0:08:36- Right.

0:08:37It's the holiest of holies, the inner sanctum.

0:08:40I mean, that is the center of Infinite Loop,

0:08:45is their design lab.

0:08:47I mean, maybe not, it's not the physical center, obviously,

0:08:49but it's the place that the least,

0:08:52fewest number of people have ever seen.

0:08:54- Yeah, very few key cards grant access therein.

0:08:56- Right.

0:08:59But prior to this shakeup where Forstall was ousted

0:09:04and UI design was placed under Johnny Ive in that group,

0:09:10prior to that, there were HI,

0:09:13there were people who, there was like an HI group,

0:09:15but then there were also like,

0:09:16it was spread about where somebody might go off on a team

0:09:20and then they were, like I, for example,

0:09:22like with, I think with the original iPhone

0:09:24and you correct me if I'm wrong,

0:09:25'cause I could very much be wrong on this

0:09:28as a basic story, but the basic gist was

0:09:31when they committed to doing the iPhone,

0:09:33Forstall was placed in charge of the software

0:09:38and Forstall went around the company

0:09:40cherry picking designers who he wanted

0:09:44and would say, and this part is true,

0:09:47I don't know if he did it to everybody,

0:09:49but at least for some people it was,

0:09:50I'm putting together a team to do something

0:09:53and it's gonna be the greatest thing in your career

0:09:56and I cannot tell you what it is,

0:09:57but if you wanna join, you know,

0:09:59you'll work harder than you ever have,

0:10:01but it's gonna be great.

0:10:03Are you in or out?

0:10:03And if they said they're in, then they were on the team.

0:10:05But then it wasn't like there was this one interface group

0:10:10that part of what they did is put together an iPhone team.

0:10:13The iPhone team had its own interface group,

0:10:15cherry picked from around the company.

0:10:18And that it was like that with other projects too,

0:10:20maybe to a lesser degree because the iPhone was,

0:10:23you know, a major, major endeavor.

0:10:26- Yeah, no, I think that's absolutely true.

0:10:27I think Nitin Ganatra on debug was talking about how they had to all be disclosed by

0:10:32Steve Jobs and when he wasn't around he would have to go into one room, look at the

0:10:36designs and then walk out to the undisclosed designers and sort of describe to them what

0:10:39they had to do.

0:10:42Which is, it makes sense, I can see how it makes sense to Steve Jobs and it makes, you

0:10:47know, and it obviously worked for Apple to some degree but obviously it was not a very,

0:10:53There was an ad hoc nature to user interface design, to software design.

0:10:57Yeah, absolutely.

0:10:58They had limited design resources, and they had to be shared and pooled.

0:11:02It sounds like a really grueling project to get out.

0:11:04Right.

0:11:05On the one side, I think you could argue, maybe it's one of those things where it

0:11:09doesn't have to be either/or.

0:11:10They're not necessarily mutually exclusive.

0:11:12On the one side, you could say that what Jonny Ive orchestrated in 2011 with Forrestal going

0:11:17out and all of UI design being placed under him and picking new people to run it and setting

0:11:25a new style.

0:11:26You could say that it was a power grab, that it was an expansion of just ego and an expansion

0:11:32of his power.

0:11:33But I think in a very reasonable sense, you could say it was a growing up.

0:11:40It made the process of UI design much more orderly within Apple because it wasn't spread

0:11:46about where each individual project might peel off its own team.

0:11:50Yeah, I think that's absolutely true.

0:11:52And the thing that's interesting to me is Scott Forsloh was widely known as, I don't

0:11:55know how widely known, but it was known that if Steve Jobs said, "I want leather for

0:11:59this," if Scott Forsloh wasn't around, the designer would almost lose his mind because

0:12:03it would just be no, no, no, no, no.

0:12:04And he'd burn through 40, 50, 100 different designs.

0:12:07But if Scott was there, he could say, "Steve will pick one of these three," and Steve

0:12:10would pick one of those three.

0:12:11And that saved everyone a tremendous amount of work.

0:12:14But in an Apple where there's no Steve Jobs, the value of that for HI's or the combination,

0:12:19the alchemy of that is very different.

0:12:22And then you have at the same time someone like Johnny Ives sitting in the wings who

0:12:25was on the record.

0:12:26He'd said before he didn't like the skeuomorphic design.

0:12:29One of the arguably the best designer in the world who's not allowed to take control or

0:12:32to influence, to put his tastes on the software that runs on his hardware.

0:12:37And then Tim Cook comes in and it always reminded me of what Steve Jobs did when he returned

0:12:41to Apple when he said desktop, laptop, professional consumer. And he came in and he just said

0:12:46design services, hardware, and software. And he made Apple very clean that way.

0:12:52In a way that it didn't need to be under jobs. And again, I think that emphasizes that

0:12:57part of what made Forrestal talented and essential and so important to the history of, you know,

0:13:03Especially iOS, you know, you know the iPhone and iPad

0:13:06Wasn't just that he was good manager and by all accounts

0:13:11He was that he shipped OS is on time and there, you know, some people would argue they were more reliable

0:13:17etc

0:13:20But and an uncanny ability he seemed to have is that he seemed it

0:13:26Wasn't just that he had good taste. It was that he knew Steve's taste and that his you know

0:13:32And one of the profiles, something that was written, one of the pieces that was written

0:13:36about Forstall was, it might have been an unnamed person who was complaining that like, you know,

0:13:42they'd present stuff to Forstall and Forstall would say, "Steve wouldn't like that." And then

0:13:46that was, all he had to do was say, "Steve wouldn't like it and that's enough to bounce you back to

0:13:49the drawing board." And that it got tiresome over the time. But I think the fact that he

0:13:55lasted so long as a direct report to Steve Jobs in that role shows that he was right. That he knew

0:14:02knew what he would like and what he wouldn't like.

0:14:06In a company where you have something like Steve Jobs, that's an essential skill to get

0:14:09anything done.

0:14:11And we've both heard the story is like, make that blue more beautiful.

0:14:14That can burn hours and weeks from a designer.

0:14:17If you can shortcut that process with someone like Scott Forest in the middle, that's immensely

0:14:20valuable.

0:14:21Right.

0:14:22Because you couldn't just, it wasn't like you were going to get a chance at 10 a.m.

0:14:27a Tuesday when he says you know no that's not good enough you don't get a

0:14:33chance at 10 a.m. the next day to also present to him you've got to wait you

0:14:38might be stuck waiting a week or longer before you get your next chance to get

0:14:42your project in front of him yeah or if there's something that's worth fighting

0:14:45for and there's been stories you know like like iTunes on Windows was a great

0:14:48example but there's a lot of smaller examples Scott was somebody who could go

0:14:50back to Steve and say look I really think we should take another look at

0:14:52this and then projects that might have otherwise been derailed in a few minutes

0:14:56Sometimes we gradually get back on track.

0:14:59- Right, so rather than just merely

0:15:01and being an arbiter of good taste,

0:15:03being an arbiter of Steve Jobs' good taste was essential.

0:15:08And I think, you know, in hindsight,

0:15:14clearly not very valuable to Apple

0:15:16after Steve Jobs wasn't there.

0:15:18- No, 'cause Tim Cook doesn't,

0:15:19Tim Cook's not, he's not Steve Jobs,

0:15:21so he doesn't need that service,

0:15:22and Johnny Ive is, he has peerless taste of his own,

0:15:25so he doesn't need that service as well.

0:15:27- Right, different days.

0:15:28And it does make you wonder in hindsight what some of,

0:15:30'cause Ivan and Steve Jobs famously

0:15:34were actually friends, more than just collaborators,

0:15:37and ate lunch together all the time.

0:15:39And it makes you wonder how much feedback Johnny had given

0:15:43him over the years that was obviously rejected

0:15:46in terms of trying to steer the user interface

0:15:50in a direction more palatable to himself

0:15:52without actually having any kind of actual role in it.

0:15:56- I think something you said a couple of years ago

0:15:58was really astute there because the age before retina,

0:16:00and especially when mobile devices were really new,

0:16:03swipe to unlock, nobody knew what that was.

0:16:05So making a giant groove in there

0:16:06and making a very elaborate button,

0:16:08it gave you that affordance,

0:16:09that visual clue of how you had to use that.

0:16:12And, or Steve would say, you know, this is a database app.

0:16:15No one cares about that, give it a texture.

0:16:17And it sounds dumb, but if you're stumbling home,

0:16:19tired or drunk, and you open up an app

0:16:21and you're in contacts and there's nothing to tell you which contacts it is, maybe you're

0:16:25trying to call a cab in Game Center and you just don't know. So there were a lot of usability

0:16:29reasons and just philosophical reasons why I think that started off, but then as you

0:16:34transition to retina, that sort of texture doesn't hold up anymore.

0:16:37Yeah, I think it's a combination. I emphasize that. Years ago, my thought was a lot more

0:16:42about the retina, non-retina, and that you needed… The other thing was in addition

0:16:47to just the affordances of knowing what to do and having that slide to unlock, which

0:16:51is, you know, to me, like, just put that design itself, not even the whole iPhone, but just

0:16:57put that slide to unlock itself, put that in a museum, because that is—it made people

0:17:07wow. People wanted to buy the phone just from slide to unlock.

0:17:10And it taught you how to use it.

0:17:12Right.

0:17:15My thought a couple of years ago was simply about the fact that even at 163 pixels per

0:17:20inch, which was pretty high for the time in 2007, it still wasn't that high.

0:17:26It was only high compared to the 120 to 130-ish pixels per inch we had on our Macs at the

0:17:32time, that you needed to use those sort of Photoshop-style user interface designs just

0:17:40to make it look good so that as soon as you looked at it you thought, "Ooh, that looks

0:17:43cool," because something like iOS 7 just doesn't look that great on non-retina. There's nothing

0:17:51about it that makes you go, "Wow."

0:17:54I think that the affordance stuff was important too, because I think the basic idea with the

0:17:58original iPhone was that – Steve Jobs used the analogy when he introduced it that, "Here's

0:18:09these other phones of the time and look what they've got. They've got all these buttons.

0:18:13Here's the thing about all these hardware buttons. It reduces the amount of space you

0:18:16have. Now the screen's only this big. Then number two, a year from now if we come up

0:18:21with this great idea for a new feature, we're stuck with the buttons we had already come

0:18:25up with a year ago. We've solved this problem years and years ago. It's called bitmap screen.

0:18:30Then you can make all the buttons you want whenever you want and only have the buttons

0:18:34that you need right now on screen. So we'll do the whole thing will just be a screen and

0:18:40we'll make the buttons in software. But I think that the basic idea was make the buttons

0:18:45look like fake hardware and that in every single app it's like a dedicated device

0:18:52simulating a dedicated hardware device for that feature.

0:18:55Yeah and the Braun calculator is maybe a famous example of that. It's people the thought

0:19:01was that people wouldn't know how to approach just a blank piece of glass and if you made

0:19:03it look like something they were familiar with, at least they'd start tapping around

0:19:07and then discover how it worked.

0:19:08Right, or the call recorder.

0:19:11Yes.

0:19:12I know, that wasn't in the first OS, but certainly was in one of the early ones.

0:19:20The compass is another one.

0:19:22Reel to reel in the podcast app was probably the last big example of that.

0:19:26Right, and even the ones that didn't have an, something like mail, which didn't really

0:19:31have like a brown style gadget that you could compare it to.

0:19:37Just the fact that there were these little 3D effects between the keyboard and the content

0:19:44area, it just ever so gently suggested that this is what it would look like if you had

0:19:49a hardware device that was just for email.

0:19:52And the original, at least the first versions, they didn't composite anywhere nearly as well

0:19:55as later versions, which is why we didn't get wallpaper until I think iOS 3 or I think

0:19:58iOS 4 actually.

0:19:59So they had a lot fewer things they could do visually.

0:20:03- Right, well, the basic idea,

0:20:06I always thought with the original home screen

0:20:09was to make it look like at the home screen level,

0:20:13by having just a black wallpaper,

0:20:15the idea was you've got this device

0:20:17that is sort of like a calculator

0:20:19where each icon is a button, right?

0:20:21It's like a dial pad where instead of having numbers,

0:20:26right, like an old phone,

0:20:28the phones that they were replacing, the basic interface was a 123, 456, 789, and a zero

0:20:39dial pad.

0:20:40The dial pad on the iPhone was these 11 apps.

0:20:44Yeah, that's a really good insight.

0:20:46Absolutely.

0:20:47It was also different than some competitive products when, not initially, but when, for

0:20:52example, Android would later put widgets on the home screen.

0:20:54It always felt like Apple never wanted the home screen to be a destination just a gateway, right?

0:20:59It was just a dial pad where you dial up whichever app you needed the device to transform itself into. Yes, absolutely

0:21:05So I kind of you know

0:21:10We go back dialing all the way back to this news about Johnny I've and Greg Christie are not great

0:21:15Christie, you know, well and I on die and Richard Holworth well and you know guys like Christie leaving

0:21:23It turned UI design into something that works exactly like industrial design had always worked at Apple

0:21:32Like and in theory they could have done the same thing by not putting it under Johnny I've but just by picking somebody else like Greg

0:21:38Christie and setting up

0:21:40UI design as a separate peer to

0:21:44Industrial design right they could have named instead of putting it all under Johnny I they could have said Johnny you're still in charge of

0:21:52Industrial design you design all the hardware and now we've named this guy

0:21:56could have been great Chrissy could have been anybody else you are like the Johnny I've of

0:22:01UI design and you'll set up your own lab and you guys will design all the user interfaces

0:22:07Didn't have to be in one but it you know

0:22:10But I do think that either way it was the right way to go moving forward without jobs at the helm

0:22:15As CEO as somebody has to be in charge of the taste

0:22:20Yes, some you know it had to be done

0:22:22Yeah, no

0:22:24I think that's very astute and I think the you could see clearly that it right away the big the first big project that came

0:22:30Out was iOS 7 and when they did the advertising for the iPhone 5c

0:22:34They had better together as their slogan

0:22:37They wanted to show that the pallets matched over that the hardware and the software being together was an important thing for them

0:22:42And that's probably the only reason obviously that had to have been driven by Johnny I but that that was the benefit of putting all that

0:22:49stuff together.

0:22:50Yeah.

0:22:51And I think the watch is the culmination of that because say what you want about the watch

0:22:55and what you know whether you like the you know where you think the watch stands in terms

0:23:00of you know is it better than the original iPhone is it better than the original iPad

0:23:04whatever I don't think to me there's no doubt that the hardware and software integration

0:23:10are tighter with the watch than any any other device and talking about UI design in particular

0:23:16that the UI just doesn't make any sense

0:23:20except in the context of this watch.

0:23:22- Yeah, and it is something brand new,

0:23:25and it's also a category where traditionally

0:23:26Apple had 10 years of smartphones to look at,

0:23:28or 10 years of tablets, of Windows tablet PC to look at.

0:23:32Watches were still very new.

0:23:32You had the Pebble, you had a couple Samsung watches,

0:23:35but those came later, probably after Apple had to do

0:23:37a lot of their original concepts for the watch.

0:23:39So it's a project where Apple had to

0:23:41not just identify problems and see like this,

0:23:44We hate this because, and they already loved watches,

0:23:48but they had to sort of figure out how to make the watch

0:23:49a computer and not just a digital mechanism anymore.

0:23:53- Yeah, famously, well, maybe not famously,

0:23:56maybe people don't know this,

0:23:57but in the development of the original iPhone,

0:24:02the Forstall's software team didn't see the prototypes

0:24:06of the hardware.

0:24:07They were developing, they knew the size of the screen,

0:24:11and they obviously knew it was gonna be a touchscreen,

0:24:13but they didn't get to see what the prototypes look like.

0:24:16Which is a little bit less important.

0:24:18I feel like the software team just knowing,

0:24:20okay, it's a touchscreen that is 320 by 480,

0:24:24and it's gonna be a piece of glass, touch it.

0:24:26Them working blind on the hardware

0:24:30is a little bit less meaningful

0:24:32than the fact that the hardware team

0:24:34didn't get to see the software.

0:24:36I know you know this.

0:24:38Maybe it was even on eBay where a prototype got out.

0:24:41There was this super janky looking stand-in OS.

0:24:46- Yes.

0:24:48- It was so ugly.

0:24:50- 'Cause the iPhone was originally purple

0:24:53and I think that was Skank was the stand-in one.

0:24:56- We should try to find the link after this.

0:25:00Skank was like the code name for the stand-in OS?

0:25:03- I think, I don't know if it's just a stand-in OS

0:25:05or it's the sort of the development,

0:25:07stuff that runs all the technical information

0:25:09that you need to grab from the electronics

0:25:10to do a lot of things.

0:25:11- Right, it was sort of like a diagnostic OS,

0:25:15I guess you could say.

0:25:17And purposefully did not look good at all.

0:25:20It was made to look bad so that it wasn't like

0:25:24they lied to them and said,

0:25:25"Hey, this is the OS we're making."

0:25:26They're like, "You guys don't get to see the OS.

0:25:28"Make the hardware and here's this ugly diagnostic OS

0:25:31"where you can test to make sure that the WiFi antenna

0:25:35"is doing what the WiFi antenna is supposed to do,"

0:25:38et cetera and so forth.

0:25:39- Yeah, and I think even some of the earlier prototypes

0:25:41were just components, and I think this has been true

0:25:42for years, even with iPads, they're just components

0:25:45literally bolted down on boards.

0:25:47- Yes, yeah, definitely.

0:25:50Did you ever see like the early iPod prototype?

0:25:56- No.

0:25:57- It's, yeah, it's really big, and it, you know,

0:25:59clearly was never supposed to fool anybody

0:26:01into thinking it was the product, but it's, yeah,

0:26:04it's just like a bunch of things on a board,

0:26:08there's a dial that you know that was the click wheel but it just looked like a knob you know off

0:26:12to the side that you would spin around well it's smart because if you have to wait for i mean you

0:26:16can't you can't have one follow the other you have to be doing both at the same time so you have to

0:26:19use them in some sort of development state right but i it's it seems very clear to me and i i would

0:26:27be shocked to find out otherwise because it's with it you know was all one you know johnny i've design

0:26:31lab but it's it seems very clear to me that the watch was developed with the software and the

0:26:36the hardware at the same time.

0:26:40And it seems even beyond that because there is some siloing like you have Kevin Lynch

0:26:43in charge of the software not Craig Federighi but it also seems like the people who do messaging

0:26:48for iOS are in touch with the people who are doing it for the watch and there's not sort

0:26:52of that strict divide that there used to be and that results in all the stuff working

0:26:55together maybe not perfectly but very well.

0:26:59Right I do think I think Lynch reports to Federighi though but the idea was that you

0:27:04know, rather than spread federally thinner than he is that, you know, they needed somebody

0:27:08who is just going to be, you know, you know, what would they I don't know if he was I don't

0:27:14know how there's the Apple term, the DRI directly responsible individual, but at least he you

0:27:20know, somebody has to be the DRI for the OS itself, if not the design of the OS, and the

0:27:25actual like, it's all coded up, you know, here's the build and the build is written,

0:27:30know this is the 1.0 for Apple watch and that was Kevin Lynch yeah I think

0:27:35someone also and this was definitely Scott for so many ways someone has to

0:27:38have that single act of will to birth something new and it's arguable whether

0:27:41the same person should mature that product but you you really have to have

0:27:44that person whose only job it is to make that product launch right so with the

0:27:50I've stored I I have to admit I'm guilty as charged where I my first read through

0:27:54of the article was I took a deep breath and thought who does is this the first

0:27:59step to him going out the door. And it was just like I wrote. And it was like, I read

0:28:06too much into it, I think. But that whole thing that he was going to travel more, I

0:28:10really did read at first, my first take, and as I, you know, when I linked to it on Daring

0:28:14Fireball, I thought that meant he might move back to England. And a lot of that was based

0:28:20on my recollection of that, of a 2011 story in the London Times that said that while negotiating

0:28:28a new contract with Apple, I've wanted to be authorized to work from London or wherever

0:28:36he would live in England, and that Tim Cook and whoever else at Apple was like, "No,

0:28:40you've got to stay here," and that there was a source of conflict, which in hindsight

0:28:44was the only one report of it. And then it's one of those things where it seems like there

0:28:48were a whole bunch of stories about it, but every other story you can find about it is

0:28:53the London Times is reporting that blah, blah, blah, Johnny, I've wanted to move to England,

0:28:58there wasn't anybody else who said it. Their source for this was completely anonymous.

0:29:02It certainly wasn't Johnny Ive. And asking around over, you know, in the last week, it

0:29:08seems to me like that story was bullshit and was sort of a source of consternation at Apple

0:29:14at the time because they knew it was bullshit. It was bullshit, but they didn't want to say

0:29:19that it was bullshit just because they're Apple and they don't talk about such things.

0:29:23Well, I had the same thought as you initially, just because it was a British paper, it was

0:29:27Stephen Fry. I think that may have influenced me, but yeah, and not moving back necessarily,

0:29:32but like if you were to spend the summers there, which is a couple months or three months,

0:29:35that seemed perfectly logical to me given his new role.

0:29:38Pete: Yeah, that's another factor in it. The fact that it wasn't a UK paper,

0:29:43the fact that it was, you know, wasn't announced in a press release.

0:29:48Jared; It was the day the market closed.

0:29:50I forgot about, and I've since linked to it, I linked to it yesterday on Daring Fireball,

0:29:57but I forgot that in 2003 Avi Tamanian took a promotion, whether you want to put quotes

0:30:03around it or not, to a title, "Chief Software Technology Officer," I think, CSTO. I forgot

0:30:17about that, even though I just reread the story of it in the Becoming Steve Jobs, which—but

0:30:24the thing that I had forgotten was that the title started with "Chief." I just—because somehow,

0:30:28like, the four-letter CSTO—like, if they had promoted him to chief technology officer,

0:30:35just CTO, I would have remembered that in a way that I didn't with chief software technology

0:30:41officer. Somehow that sounded ceremonial to me right away, and then even the description

0:30:47of it in the press release where Apple announced it sounded a little bit—it just really—it

0:30:52almost seemed almost definite that it was sort of a stepping aside.

0:30:55It was like inventing a title for him.

0:30:57Yeah. So I kind of—I should have remembered it, but I think in the back of my mind, subconsciously,

0:31:04I did and that it also fueled my, because it was, you know, that was 2003 and that was

0:31:11when Bertrand Cerlet, Cerlet, Cerlet?

0:31:13Jared Ranerelle Yep, Bertrand Cerlet.

0:31:15Steven

0:31:15Well, I say Sirlet, Sirlet, Sirlet, Sirlet, and you go yep.

0:31:19I'm a Quebecer, so I'm doing it wrong.

0:31:21Alright, Sirlet, Bertrand. I just know him as Bertrand. Everybody called him Bertrand.

0:31:24So Bertrand got promoted to Senior Vice President of Software Engineering and reported directly to Steve Jobs.

0:31:31Which I really do think is sort of a key to the difference between Tevainian going to CSTO and Johnny Ive going to Chief Design Officer.

0:31:41that people who are getting promoted underneath him to take more

0:31:44responsibility still report directly to I've not to Tim Cook or to somebody else

0:31:50with the veiny and he was essentially non-essential at that point Steve Jobs

0:31:53had a direct line of communication through a software stack and it made

0:31:56Tivani and superfluous and that was not a position that Steve Jobs suffered

0:32:00lightly right and it's actually kind of an interesting let me see if I can fish

0:32:05this up here. I have this saved somewhere, I hope. No, maybe not. The gist of it is as told in the

0:32:15Becoming Steve Jobs that it wasn't necessarily that at the time that he immediately, that

0:32:23Tevainian really wanted to like, "Hey, ease my way out the door." He really just wanted to get

0:32:27away from the day-to-day stuff and kind of work on blue sky stuff. But that it just did not work

0:32:34with the way Steve Jobs worked at the company. So here's the passage from

0:32:40becoming Steve Jobs. "It was unquestionably a promotion but it turned

0:32:44out to be a job without much of a portfolio. Tevainian found himself with

0:32:48little concrete responsibility. He felt out of the loop and realized that his

0:32:52new role would not work." "Being a pseudo individual staff person working for

0:32:58Steve doesn't work because he already has all the answers. He didn't like it

0:33:02when I would be in a meeting where he was reviewing a product and I would have an opinion.

0:33:06He just didn't like it. And he grew to not like that I could be a senior person like

0:33:10that without having day-to-day responsibilities to deliver something," he says. Tim Cook,

0:33:16now Apple CEO, says that he worried about Tevainian leaving and urged Steve in 2004

0:33:21to figure out another challenge to keep the brilliant software engineer at Apple. "Steve

0:33:25looked at me," Cook remembers, and goes, "I agree he's really smart. But he's decided

0:33:30he doesn't want to work. I've never found in my whole life that you could convince someone

0:33:35who doesn't want to work hard to work hard. Another time, this is my favorite part of it,

0:33:40another time, shortly after Steve had learned that Tevainian had taken up golf, Steve karped

0:33:47to cook that something was really amiss. Golf, he thundered incredulously. Who has time for golf?

0:33:52Golf. He famously wouldn't even let people join boards of directors.

0:33:58They should be too busy with Apple to do that

0:34:00Well, I've also heard that they used to when they used to have their off-sites

0:34:04He wouldn't let them have it anywhere where there was a golf course. Yeah

0:34:07He was sort of anti golf which is

0:34:10Which is super interesting because in the article as strangely staged as it was they made sure to mention that Johnny I've still had had

0:34:18Things on his plate to do like the store redesigns like campus - and other products

0:34:24yeah, which is a huge difference right and it's

0:34:27You know, just an enormous, still, I still think even with this and with these

0:34:35lieutenants taking over sort of direct day-to-day responsibility for UI design

0:34:39and industrial design, he still is spread pretty thin. But I think he's spread a

0:34:42little bit less than by administrative stuff. I think that's a key

0:34:46thing we've seen recently too, is that Apple, if you look at what EdiQ is

0:34:50responsible for, that's almost an entire, that is an entire company. It's

0:34:53got its own marketing, it's got its own software development, it's got it, and

0:34:56And they're bringing in people to sort of help him do that.

0:35:00Marketing has always been stretched really thin, but they've got more people in there

0:35:03lately and it just seems like it's a little more sane than it used to be.

0:35:07And the responsibilities as they've grown, the company didn't scale to account for that.

0:35:11And the amount of work that the people at the top of those organizations had to do was

0:35:15just becoming ludicrous.

0:35:17Yeah.

0:35:19So I think, I have since concluded, you know, I mean who knows?

0:35:22We'll see.

0:35:23A couple years will let us know.

0:35:24this actually is another one of those cases where, as weird as the story was where it

0:35:30came out and it's, my guess is this weirdness was sort of, this is the way Johnny wanted

0:35:35to do it and so okay, this is how they did it. That it really is what they say it is.

0:35:41It's a promotion. It's a recognition maybe, it may be almost like a belated promotion

0:35:46where it's recognizing the authority he already wielded within the company and that he's

0:35:51not going anywhere.

0:35:52Well, that was the interesting thing because there was, I think at least three discrete

0:35:55reactions to the news when it first came out.

0:35:57One was that this was Johnny Ive putting one foot out the door, you know, getting ready

0:36:00to wind down.

0:36:02The other was that this was Johnny Ive consolidating power because there was that old quote from

0:36:05Steve Jobs where he said no one had more operational power at Apple besides himself than Johnny

0:36:10Ive, even though they had a chief operating officer, which is, you know, just it shows

0:36:14sort of his position in the company.

0:36:16And then the sort of the third one was like the Wall Street take where they're still upset

0:36:20that Apple doesn't disclose Johnny Ive because he was a senior vice president with direct

0:36:23reports and certainly one of the top 10 paid people at Apple and his salary is not disclosed.

0:36:28But now as a chief design officer with very few direct reports, you could argue that it

0:36:32no longer needs to be.

0:36:33Yeah, I don't think so. I don't know. I mean, who knows about that? I know that I've—I

0:36:38think I only tweeted about it, but maybe I blogged about it. But it has struck me as

0:36:43weird over the years when they disclose executive payments, who's on the list and who's

0:36:48Like, Arents had to be last year because her, like, I guess you just call it, loop it under

0:36:54a signing bonus.

0:36:55But she got an enormous amount up front.

0:36:57Like, it's not her annual salary, but she was paid so much in her first year as a signing

0:37:02bonus for taking the job that her compensation had to be disclosed.

0:37:07It sounds complicated.

0:37:09I read a Fortune article, I forget who wrote it, but they were saying that it's the top

0:37:1110 compensations on the team, but if they don't have policymaking positions, then they're

0:37:17not included because they don't affect what Wall Street cares about with the company.

0:37:21It just seems like a mess.

0:37:23Yeah, it really does.

0:37:27My conclusion is really—I'm not trying to be cute, but more or less, if you just

0:37:35listen to Tim Cook's words in the internal memo, we're announcing the deal describing

0:37:39what Johnny's responsible for, that he was responsible for hardware design and now he's

0:37:43is responsible for UI design and packaging and he's supervising the design of the headquarters and

0:37:49The retail in that New Yorker profile said he was doing the ads too. I mean it really is Steve Jobs level of breath

0:37:58yeah, I don't quite think ads like marketing like TV spots and

0:38:03Like magazine ads but like those videos that he does right like the videos for the keynote. Yeah

0:38:10So even though he's not on stage in the keynote because he did I really do and I think it's as simple as that

0:38:16He is just is not keen as to be a public speaker, even though the few times he has done it

0:38:21He's done fine

0:38:22I think it's like he just enjoys it so little and there's so much prep that's involved that he'd rather not

0:38:27but instead his involvement in the presentation is

0:38:30Literally supervising and if not editing, you know with his own hand the videos. Yeah

0:38:37And this seems to suit everyone's best interest because it gets a little bit of the stuff

0:38:42that Johnny Ive doesn't seem that happy to be doing which is the day-to-day managerial

0:38:45stuff but it also recognizes, it almost like Apple's recognizing the job he was already

0:38:49doing and that sort of assures his future in the company because you don't want him

0:38:53to either get bored or to feel like he's finished or to want something different.

0:38:56You want to keep him energized and engaged but at the same time it puts these two pillars

0:39:00underneath him so if anything does happen or he decides to leave you have a stable functional

0:39:06organization that can keep going underneath them. And that's really important Apple.

0:39:09Yeah, that's exactly, I do think that it makes a more sustainable organization. Now,

0:39:15would that mean that they would have to appoint a new chief design officer afterwards? I don't know.

0:39:20I don't even have a new COO yet. Right, exactly. Although I think that's coming.

0:39:26We can maybe just hold that thought and I'll do a sponsor break here and then we can talk about

0:39:33that. But bottom line is I don't think Johnny Ive is going anywhere. I think this is sort of a,

0:39:39you know, this is sort of a, like making it official that Johnny Ive and Tim Cook have

0:39:48a relationship like Tim Cook and Steve Jobs did. Like where there are two leaders in this company

0:39:54and it's a little different this time because the other way the guy with the, you know, the CEO.

0:40:01Right, like it's a little different, but somebody has to be a CEO.

0:40:07But exactly, I think in a way though that makes Ive different from Jobs is I don't think

0:40:12Johnny Ive would ever want to be CEO.

0:40:14I think part of this is that he's getting away from some of the stuff that a CEO would

0:40:19have to do, some of this administrative stuff.

0:40:23You know, Johnny Ive has no interest in negotiating with CBS television to get them on Apple TV,

0:40:30right?

0:40:31So it just comes down to the personalities and the individual talent that they have,

0:40:37but that he is as important to Cook as Cook was important to Steve Jobs.

0:40:42Yeah, it's like you need those two sides of the coin.

0:40:44It doesn't really matter which side is on top at any given time, but you need those

0:40:46two sides.

0:40:47And the other thing that I thought was really good is the projects that Apple has coming

0:40:50up like Campus 2 and like Project Titan, those are things that Jonny Ive seems really interested

0:40:54in, which makes it seem further unlikely that it's anything other than a better positioning

0:40:58of all the talent they have in place.

0:41:00What's Project Titan?

0:41:01the automotive stuff.

0:41:03Oh, well we can talk about that.

0:41:06Let me take a break though and thank our first sponsor and it is our good friends at Fracture.

0:41:13You guys know Fracture, long time sponsor of the show.

0:41:17You guys keep buying their pictures so they keep coming back to sponsor it more so keep

0:41:21doing it.

0:41:22But if you haven't heard of it, you need to be reminded.

0:41:25Fracture is a service.

0:41:26You go to their website and you send them your photos from any camera that you've whatever

0:41:31you've taken them with.

0:41:33You pick a size, could be small.

0:41:34They've got real small ones fit on your desk, could be big.

0:41:37They've got big 23 by 29 inch things you can mount on your wall.

0:41:42You decide whether you want it rectangular or square.

0:41:44It's up to you.

0:41:45They've got all the sizes, all the aspect ratios you could want.

0:41:48They take your photos and they print them directly on glass, right on the glass, right

0:41:53on the surface and they look amazing. They look like no other thing that I've ever

0:41:58seen. They look so good that no matter what the content of the photo is, when you hang

0:42:03them up in your wall and you have friends over or family over, people, they see them

0:42:07out of the corner eye and they say, "How did you do that?" There's like a "How

0:42:10did you do that?" aspect to it where at first they might think it's a regular photo,

0:42:14but then they realize it's edge to edge and there is no frame around it. And then

0:42:18they might think, "Well, maybe it's like an LCD type thing." And then they realize

0:42:22is that it's not, it's not glowing, it's a real picture,

0:42:25like just an artifact.

0:42:27It's stunning.

0:42:29And so it's one of those things that it's like,

0:42:31I can tell you this 'cause I have them

0:42:33hanging around my house and I've had people say,

0:42:35wow, how did you get that?

0:42:36And then I go into this same spiel

0:42:38that I tell you about on a podcast telling them in person,

0:42:40you should go there and buy them yourself.

0:42:43It really, you have to see it to believe it

0:42:47and it's one of the hardest things I think for them

0:42:49to get across because when you go to their website,

0:42:51You don't get that.

0:42:52There's no way to show you on a website a picture of a thing to show you what it really

0:42:56looks like when you're looking at it.

0:42:58A picture of a picture isn't the same thing as actually looking at the picture.

0:43:02Really really impressive and you can get started at a really low price.

0:43:05Their prices are fantastic considering the quality of what you get.

0:43:10Take your pictures.

0:43:11Father's Day is coming up.

0:43:12I keep saying it.

0:43:13It's a great great gift for people in your family.

0:43:17Right now as you listen to this you've got plenty of time to get stuff done for Father's

0:43:20Day.

0:43:21note as soon as you're done listening to show, go to fractureme.com. F-R-A-C-T-U-R-E-ME.com.

0:43:30And remember this code, daringfireball. All one word, daringfireball. Use that code and you will

0:43:37save 15% off your order. So, my thanks to Fracture. Go there, get your dad, your grandfather, your

0:43:45husband some pictures for Father's Day. My thanks to them. All right, so the car. That's

0:43:58an interesting thing thinking about in the context of Johnny Ive being promoted to chief

0:44:04design officer. Because it's, you think, well, that's just all industrial design. But there's,

0:44:13You know, I think that if Apple is going to do a car, it is absolutely going to be completely,

0:44:23you know, the computerification of car design.

0:44:28Like there's no way that it's not going to involve both UI design and industrial design.

0:44:33No, I would not be surprised if, you know, the same kinds of engineers who worked on

0:44:38iPhones and other products are working on that now.

0:44:41It's no guarantee that it's ever going to ship because I do think, and you know, that

0:44:45thousand no's for every yes mantra, some of those no's come late.

0:44:50Jared: We talked about this a couple weeks ago, that that TV just didn't ship for year

0:44:55after year after year.

0:44:56No one was interested in shipping it.

0:44:58They didn't think it was a great product.

0:44:59So it just sits in the lab.

0:45:00Pete: Right.

0:45:01But there was there.

0:45:03There were TVs.

0:45:04And I think, in hindsight, poor Gene Munster, but I do think that that's one of the reasons

0:45:10Munster was so convinced and one of the things that analysts Wall Street analysts like him do is

0:45:16develop sources in the supply chain and

0:45:20ones who are most accurate like Ming

0:45:23Ming key what's it mean?

0:45:27Ming Chi Kuo

0:45:30You know and and some of the stunningly accurate things that he's had in recent years

0:45:35I think clearly come from the supply chain, you know that that he's talking to

0:45:40to, like he, for example, nailed it on the screen sizes of the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus, and

0:45:47I think it was because he had sources at Sharp and whoever else was making the displays for

0:45:51those things.

0:45:54I think Munster figured out through supply chain that Apple was making TV prototypes,

0:46:01and then just extr—you know, which is pretty, you know, that they weren't just things that

0:46:06Apple had made in the Johnny Ive lab, which never comes – nothing ever leaks out of

0:46:11there.

0:46:12But they were in discussions with manufacturers and wheels were starting to turn over there

0:46:18just to get things set up.

0:46:20He just took that to mean, "Well, then that's a sure thing."

0:46:22Because I think with most companies, once you get to that point, it's going to come

0:46:26out and they're going to see how it does.

0:46:28Yeah.

0:46:29Apple is really different.

0:46:30Apple prototypes almost everything.

0:46:32If people like you or I can think about it or talk out loud about it on a website, Apple

0:46:37has thought about it and investigated it, whether it's like touch screen max or arm

0:46:40max or television.

0:46:42All of that stuff, when they don't ship something, it's because they've made an informed decision

0:46:45based on actual experience with prototype products that they don't want to ship it.

0:46:50Right.

0:46:51So, you know, there's no guarantee that a car is ever going to ship.

0:46:54But I definitely – oh, God, this is going to be a terrible pun.

0:46:57But I definitely think the wheels are turning.

0:46:59Well, if you look at it now.

0:47:01I was looking at cars the other day,

0:47:03and even within the same brand,

0:47:04the interfaces are completely different

0:47:06from one model to the other.

0:47:08And that just, to me, says there's no vision

0:47:10for how this stuff should be done.

0:47:12- Oh, I definitely think so.

0:47:13I've seen that.

0:47:15I've had my car since late 2006,

0:47:17so it's been a while since I've shopped for a car,

0:47:19but I remember the last time I did,

0:47:21and driving two cars from the same brand,

0:47:23and being just in the,

0:47:27not that it was driving my decision as to what to buy,

0:47:29but just absolutely rolling my eyes at the inconsistencies.

0:47:34- I bought my last car right before the advent

0:47:37of the infotainment system, the connected stuff

0:47:38where you could just plug your iPhone

0:47:40or Android phone into it.

0:47:41So I went to my dealer and I said,

0:47:42"Can I just upgrade to the next year's radio center?"

0:47:45And they said, "No."

0:47:46And I said, "Well, what do I have to do?"

0:47:47They said, "Buy another car."

0:47:48And that to me is probably one of those things

0:47:50that Apple just thinks is ludicrous.

0:47:51Like it should be as easy to update what runs on your car

0:47:54as it is to what runs on your phone.

0:47:56- Right, I mean, and not that you would be able to,

0:47:59you know like that you should be able to get like a software update yes

0:48:03right that that's what you should be able to get for your

0:48:06car not that you should be able to take the actual computer out and they're at a

0:48:09certain level apple is a hey you have to buy you just have to

0:48:12buy a new phone yeah uh company but on another level you know

0:48:17there are significant features that you get

0:48:19you know two years after buying your phone by upgrading it

0:48:23yeah i think that the same industry is just so far behind

0:48:27And similarly, CarPlay, Scott Forslop was working on that years ago and it just took

0:48:32forever to get to market.

0:48:34And that shows, I think, the slowness of that sort of a process.

0:48:37And if Apple's going to do that the way Tesla, for example, had to build up their car process,

0:48:43we're talking years and years of experimentation, never mind a release schedule.

0:48:47Yeah.

0:48:48It's on a much longer time scale.

0:48:52But I've heard, it's not my original analogy, I don't know who I'm stealing from, but that

0:48:56carplay is to Apple's car what the rocker was to the iPhone. Even though the rocker

0:49:02was like one year before the iPhone.

0:49:05Carplay to me is really interesting because it's part of this huge transition that Apple's

0:49:09undergoing where before we had all this pull interface where you'd have to go to some

0:49:13other place to, well if we could just transition to apps for a second. An app was this discrete

0:49:18bundle, this little binary you downloaded on your phone and you would tap it and all

0:49:21functionality would be inside that. And the same way WebKit is now HTTP apps everywhere,

0:49:26it's not all Bundling Safari anymore. With iOS 8, all the UI kit stuff is sort of an

0:49:31extensibility means that all an app functionality is now everywhere. You can share to Pinterest

0:49:36from a share extension, you can use one password from an action extension. So the idea of those

0:49:41apps has sort of been torn apart. And not only that, not only can I just pull the notification

0:49:46center down and use PCALC there without going to the app, I can now shoot that app to my

0:49:50my Apple watch or shoot that app to my car.

0:49:52It's like Marco's Overcast is running on cars now.

0:49:55And I think that fundamentally changes

0:49:56what it's gonna mean to be software.

0:49:58And I think CarPlay was sort of one of the things

0:50:01Apple was doing to experiment with what that's gonna be

0:50:03going forward.

0:50:05- Yeah.

0:50:05No, but I'm just trying to decide what to go to next.

0:50:11We could go to, I'll give you a pick

0:50:13and then we'll do the other one.

0:50:14We could go to Google I/O, which is past tense,

0:50:19sort of, I guess it's technically like wrapping up

0:50:21its second day right now, or we could go to WWDC.

0:50:25I say we do the past first, we'll do Google I/O.

0:50:27- Yes.

0:50:28- And we'll do WWDC expectations afterwards.

0:50:33So Google I/O, keynote yesterday,

0:50:36seemed to run about seven hours.

0:50:39- All of this, they were good this year.

0:50:40I mean, I think last year just went on forever this year,

0:50:43it was just long.

0:50:44- Announced a lot.

0:50:47And some of it, you know, pretty interesting to me. I guess maybe it was a little more

0:50:53focused than usual.

0:50:54It was restrained. I mean, I remember some years where it would just almost seem like

0:50:57every five minutes it'd be an entirely new initiative or API or something being dropped,

0:51:02and you'd never hear about them again. And this year it seemed like they stuck to bigger,

0:51:05more important things.

0:51:06Yeah, and stuff that they truly expect to ship.

0:51:08Yeah.

0:51:09I feel, you know, and not that Apple invented only talking about stuff that's really going

0:51:14the ship but I think it's a little more appley direction. The whole thing was the

0:51:19whole thing had a much more and people get really upset when we talk about this

0:51:23stuff but it had a much more Apple sort of sensibility to it especially with the

0:51:27new Android features and you could see this over time where originally to get

0:51:31market share Google had to make everything open and marketed as open as

0:51:35possible but now from Google Play services to store reviews to a lot of

0:51:39the programs that they're doing they need to exert a certain amount of

0:51:43control just to just to improve the experience and it looked like they're

0:51:46doing that again with this keynote yeah I mean and and there's a lot of little

0:51:52things but one of those things that I noticed is when they talked about where

0:51:57it's a program that to me is very interesting but to me I to my knowledge

0:52:00hasn't taken off yet but I think has a good chance to is Android one yes which

0:52:06which is their version of Android that is meant for "developing countries," but it's

0:52:15for people who cannot afford $500 or $600 phones. And so what if they can only afford

0:52:22a $100 phone or a $125 phone? How good can you make that today in 2015? And the thing

0:52:32that struck me about that is being Apple-like. Not that Apple is going after that market,

0:52:36has any product that they don't. There is no iPhone that's targeted at that market.

0:52:39But the way that it's Apple-like to me is that it's not a, "Here's a version of Android

0:52:44that runs on lower powered devices." It's a whole thing like a device certification

0:52:49program and the only way you get it is if you go along with them. And if you do, Google

0:52:55has Apple-style control over the OS where you get the latest, you know, you're getting

0:52:59Android lollipop and then you'll get the Android M update when it comes out because the only

0:53:07way to participate in this as an OEM is to go along with what Google is saying.

0:53:14There's a lot to unpack for me and one thing that maybe everyone knew this but me going

0:53:18into this but Apple's been starting their keynotes by reaffirming their corporate mantras

0:53:24and Tim Cook does that job.

0:53:25He's like the moral compass of Apple and he talks about Apple's North Star being making

0:53:29great products. And Google, they used to be, don't be evil, but more and more often now

0:53:33they're saying Google's purpose is to organize the world's data and make it easily accessible

0:53:38to everybody. And once I said that, I started watching the entire keynote through that lens.

0:53:43And the thing like, the optimist in me is like, wow, Google's using all this money that

0:53:47they make to bring technology, whether it's internet in balloons or low cost phones to

0:53:51everybody. But then the cynic in me was saying that if they really want to collect all the

0:53:55world data, they need to have everybody in the world giving them their data.

0:53:59And then when you look at everything they announced, all these services, especially

0:54:02the ones that are really cool, are sort of what you feed, the drugs you give somebody

0:54:07so they'll go and feed the beast for you.

0:54:10And there's a profound difference between Apple wanting to make great products so that

0:54:14they can sell them at a high margin and make a good experience so you'll buy the next product,

0:54:19where Google has to make these services that are so good that you'll be willing to give

0:54:22them your data on an ongoing basis.

0:54:25It's sort of a similar strategy.

0:54:28You can argue how successful each one is, but they're both phenomenally successful,

0:54:32but so different from each other.

0:54:34Yeah.

0:54:35And it's, you know, the cynic in me always asks, and you know, with any company, but

0:54:40you know, how are they going to make money on this?

0:54:42How do they think they're going to make money on this?

0:54:44And with a lot of their stuff, it's very dubious to me, like with the whole internet balloons

0:54:49thing.

0:54:50it to me, the honest way to make money on it would be to somehow take a share of what

0:54:57they're charging the people, even if it's, you know, compared to like us carriers, even

0:55:01if people there are only paying a few dollars a month for self service, you know, by taking

0:55:07a share of that, then they're making money. The cynical way to do it would be if part

0:55:11of the terms of service for getting internet service through the Google balloons is that

0:55:15Google gets to see an index all of the traffic going through.

0:55:19The thing that reminded me of a part of this is I remember a few years ago there was a

0:55:22Google ad about a father setting up some kind of Google account, might have been a Gmail

0:55:26account for his baby and starting to document the baby's life.

0:55:30And there was pushback on that saying how can you try to encourage people to put their

0:55:33children's data in there.

0:55:34But now we live in a time where they just give Google accounts to schools and people

0:55:37say thank you.

0:55:39And they say they're not going to use that data and I take them at their word.

0:55:43But I used to work in advanced analytics and the actual data is not always that important.

0:55:48you get vast quantities of data, there's all sorts of patterns and behaviors and market

0:55:52basket analysis and just trends and things that you can find in that data. That's immensely

0:55:59valuable and Google showed that with things like the machine learning and the neural networks

0:56:03on how their driverless cars can now start picking out other cars and pedestrians because

0:56:08they're committing enough data and enough patterns and enough behaviors to understand

0:56:12that and that that's going to be immensely valuable to them. So even if there's no direct

0:56:16return on a business unit nature for things like the balloons.

0:56:21All that stuff will feed their core business which is collecting and making use of all

0:56:25that data.

0:56:27Well the question though is where do you, you know, the thing about web search is that

0:56:33there is a place, a very obvious place to show the ad which is right there at the top

0:56:39of the results.

0:56:40and it's you know

0:56:43i think they say web search you know search advertising

0:56:47is ninety percent of google's remains ninety percent of google's revenue

0:56:51i think they really had it all comes down to that top spot in the results

0:56:57and

0:56:59in some sense okay simply giving internet to people around the world

0:57:03through the balloons they don't need to make any money from the balloons because

0:57:06those people are going to search on google and they're going to see those

0:57:09ads and the results. I see that though as such diminishing returns and just for the

0:57:15cynical reason that if you're in an impoverished country, those ad views just cannot be that

0:57:22valuable and that you're chasing, instead of chasing pennies, you're chasing fractions

0:57:26of a penny. Not that it means that Google's going anywhere, but it means that it's not.

0:57:32I just don't see how that's a serious source of any kind of growth.

0:57:34Yeah, I think that's a lot to do with why you see them branching out and again like when I my old job was doing

0:57:39This analytic stuff and it wasn't it wasn't really about search

0:57:42But there were other ways of making huge amounts of money

0:57:44So for example, if you go into a quickie Mart and you buy coke the quickie

0:57:49The coke has no idea that you bought it

0:57:50But the quickie Mart does and if you have a company that can go in and take that information

0:57:54You can sell that back to coke and then you can sell it to Pepsi and if they bought Doritos with it

0:57:59You can then sell that information to Doritos and those companies use it when they decide where they're gonna put their products on shelves

0:58:04or what combinations or what sales or all this stuff is immensely valuable to companies

0:58:08who want to get into these emerging markets and Apple and a lot of companies have talked

0:58:13about the value of the BRIC countries but especially China is growing now, Russia is

0:58:16growing now, Brazil is growing now and they're going to have huge economies and I think having

0:58:20actionable intelligence on those economies will be valuable and if Google is the one

0:58:24brokering all that then that makes Google as opposed to Facebook who's also doing these

0:58:28emerging market internet initiatives.

0:58:30It gives them a better position.

0:58:32My understanding is that at Quickie Mart in particular Buzz Cola has an exclusive.

0:58:38I think that's true.

0:58:39They don't even need to do any analytics.

0:58:42I don't mean to sound like I'm down on goal.

0:58:43I just think that like everybody, some people think that you're not paying for this stuff

0:58:47and whether you're paying with money or with time or with attention or with data, you're

0:58:52always paying and you just have to be to understand the cost that your data is valuable, like

0:58:57money is valuable and whether it's worth it for you to make that exchange.

0:59:00Right.

0:59:01of paying for stuff that leads me directly to one of the top products that

0:59:07they announced that I owe this week that really caught my attention was Google

0:59:10Photos. So Google Photos is pretty much Google's version of iCloud photo library

0:59:17and I don't mean that I wrote that and I don't mean it in the sense that I think

0:59:21they copied it I think it was inevitable for both companies to do this the basic

0:59:24idea was so obvious that of course they were both going to do it and it just so

0:59:29happened that you know Apple beat them to it. It feels like the right solution.

0:59:35Yeah which is basically you sign up and you have all of your devices where you

0:59:41deal with photos signed in and then all of your photos go to through one cloud

0:59:49library and are therefore available on all your devices and to save space that

0:59:54you don't have once you have that and if the truth is in the cloud meaning your

0:59:58true library is the one that's in your cloud account, then your devices don't have to have

1:00:03all of your photos. And if you have 32 gigabytes of photos and videos in your personal library,

1:00:11you only need a fraction of them on your device at any time. And the rest can all be represented

1:00:15by truly tiny thumbnails and then drawn down from the cloud on demand when you want to

1:00:22open them.

1:00:23You know, super smart.

1:00:26And we used to call that you used to do that in storage a long time ago.

1:00:28It was called nearline where you had all the frequently high value data, frequently accessed high value data right on the on the device, because you needed to access it all the time.

1:00:36And it had to be fast.

1:00:37But everything else was stored just a step away on much cheaper storage and in much bigger capacity.

1:00:43And you would just get it when you needed it.

1:00:45And it was very infrequent that you would actually need it.

1:00:48And this is the same.

1:00:49So all the photos you've taken recently, all the ones that are your favorites, all the

1:00:52ones that you access all the time are just right there on your device.

1:00:55So you tap them and they're there.

1:00:57The ones that you maybe haven't looked at in three years, you know, and you probably

1:00:59won't look at very often.

1:01:01If you have to tap that and it takes a second to download, nobody really cares.

1:01:05So they have two, but the big difference to me, the fundamental difference is that they're

1:01:10saying unlimited storage for all of as many photos and videos as you want with the asterisk

1:01:19on unlimited being that they recompress your photos in a hot you know in other words and

1:01:25then they're not quite I don't maybe somewhere there's a technical but in other words they're

1:01:29they're using Jake jpeg recompression to store good enough versions of your photos up to

1:01:3516 megabytes you can pay for something which they call original which gives

1:01:40you the original the access to the original uncompressed photograph but I

1:01:43think even then it's limited to 16 megabytes I could be wrong I wasn't sure

1:01:48it sounded like if you're willing to pay for the storage you just got your photos

1:01:51but they didn't say anything about raw either which I know Apple stressed yes

1:01:54which you know kind of me is one of those like you know difference between

1:01:59Apple customers and Google customers and I'm sure yes I'm absolutely sure that

1:02:04there are some pro photographers who shoot everything in raw using some of

1:02:08best cameras on earth who also are Android users no doubt about it but I

1:02:13think the truth is that most professional photographers are probably

1:02:17Apple customers and probably have iPhones and care about things like that

1:02:20in a way that Android users don't or is it something that they will announce in

1:02:25the course of the product roll out right and of course all of this stuff can go

1:02:28on but the pricing difference is definitely different where you know it's

1:02:32it's pretty easy and in fact depending you know on how long you've been

1:02:36shooting digital photographs, it might be likely for most people that their complete

1:02:42collection of digital photographs, not just from their phone, but everything they've

1:02:48taken for the last 10 years or so, is already bigger than the free storage tier that Apple

1:02:53offers. Whereas Google's is it's free for however many you want with that caveat that

1:02:57they're going to recompress them, but to what they claim to be still a very high level.

1:03:02I know David Mark on Loop Insight pointed this out, but again, this is fine if you're

1:03:07happy paying with data because the terms of service are kind of nebulous as to what they

1:03:10can do with it.

1:03:11I don't think they're going to do anything wrong with it.

1:03:13A lot of it is always just covering your ass if you have to move servers or do something

1:03:16else and you don't want to be sued when you do the normal course of your business.

1:03:20But with Apple, you know no one's going to show you an ad next to that photo.

1:03:23Your photo is never going to be used as an ad.

1:03:25At least Apple is currently being run.

1:03:27They're not going to take, when you do facial scans, they're not going to say, "Oh, this

1:03:31a photo of John Gruber, now I know what John Gruber looks like and propagate that across

1:03:34their system. Where with Google you might not care about that, but again you should

1:03:37– and I'm not saying that Apple couldn't reduce prices, it's just Google is subsidizing

1:03:41it based on their business model where Apple's business model is not being used to subsidize

1:03:46photo – cost of storage.

1:03:48One of the reasons I don't use Gmail is I don't like the idea of ads next to my email

1:03:52and I really don't like the idea of context-sensitive ads next to my email. And maybe that's just

1:03:57because I'm a funny fuddy duddy who's been using email since the terminal days,

1:04:01but it's like email to me is very personal and it just bothers me.

1:04:08So Bradley Horowitz, who's in Google's vice president for photos streaming

1:04:16and something else-- pretty interesting title, very specific--

1:04:20but who's more or less in charge of Google Photos.

1:04:23had an interesting interview with Steven Levy yesterday at Steven's back channel. And

1:04:30his analogy, which I found pretty compelling, was that Google Photos is Gmail for your photos.

1:04:35But then the flip side of that is what you just said. Well, wait, your Gmail has ads

1:04:40next to your photos. If you have photos of your family at Disney World, are you going

1:04:47to get ads for Universal Orlando next to those photos? I would find that extremely bothersome.

1:04:56With Apple's photos, you can click to identify people's faces. Google looks like they're

1:04:59doing that automatically and that's again to feed their machine learning system. I don't

1:05:03know if that bothers me or not. There's a lot of things along this path that – I got

1:05:07the Nexus 5 last year. I try to get the new Nexus phone every year and I turned it on

1:05:11and I said, "Do you want to use Google now?" I said, "Yeah, hell yeah," because it

1:05:13reminds me of Jarvis from the Iron Man movies. I want to use that. The first thing it said

1:05:17is can we access your full web history? And I said no. And I said well then you can't

1:05:21use Google Now. And that's technically not true. There's a lot they could do for me without

1:05:25having to have access to my web history. And they might have changed that since then I

1:05:29haven't looked again. But that to me the cost the price of that service was too high. And

1:05:35again I consider paying with data the same thing as paying with money. So I don't get

1:05:39that service now. And I understand why people would be reticent. And by all means if you

1:05:43think it's a fantastic service, it looks terrific, if you're not bothered by this at all, great,

1:05:49but I think it's worth at least considering the cost of what these services are.

1:05:53So here's the storage pricing for iCloud, and this is as of May 29th, who knows, we

1:05:58might get some new storage pricing in two weeks, I don't know. And delightfully so,

1:06:05the dollar amounts are identical in US and Canadian dollars. So no matter which of me

1:06:12and Renee you're thinking of here's what we pay 20 gigabytes you pay a dollar a

1:06:16month 200 gigabytes four bucks a month 500 is 10 bucks a month and a terabyte

1:06:21of storage is 20 bucks a month so to me that's a you know it's not bad 20

1:06:29gigabytes is very possibly too small for an awful lot of people 200 gigabytes is

1:06:35probably enough for just about everybody and it's four dollars a month which is

1:06:39is not that bad but it's you know oh you know let's round up it's 50 bucks a year and so

1:06:45Apple is saying 50 bucks a year and Google is saying nothing that's a difference I'm

1:06:51not saying that's going to draw people to it but it's you know it's.

1:06:56I pay for the half terabyte plan right now and it's absolutely different and also it's

1:07:02if you're on that free five gigabyte plan it's not just photos all your backups are

1:07:05in there as well and a lot of your other data takes up that space as well.

1:07:09And if you look at what pure Amazon S3 stores because Apple is using Amazon and Azure I

1:07:14believe to actually store this stuff.

1:07:17You pay for the storage that you use so it's not an unheard of model.

1:07:21But I think you know Apple selling these devices they make a lot of money off these devices.

1:07:25It would probably be a compelling value add to customers if you said you bought a 64 gigabyte

1:07:29device you're starting off at 64 gigabytes.

1:07:31If you want more, you can pay for it.

1:07:33But at least you have enough to back up

1:07:35pretty much the content of that device.

1:07:37- Yeah, I wonder, you know, presumably Apple

1:07:42isn't paying like with a standard S3 plan.

1:07:45- No, I hope not.

1:07:47- Wouldn't that be hilarious if Eddy Cue

1:07:49just had set up like a, just like signed into S3

1:07:52and he just pays like a regular bill every month.

1:07:56- There's a pile of paper bills in the Ferrari's

1:07:59seat next to him.

1:08:00for every single iCloud bite of data.

1:08:03Presumably Apple has a very special deal with Amazon

1:08:09for their use of S3.

1:08:11So who knows what they're paying and how close,

1:08:16but it would be curious to know how close Apple,

1:08:21as a company that is saying this is not our core competency

1:08:24so we're gonna go out for storage

1:08:25and some of these services to Amazon

1:08:29with S3 and Microsoft with Azure.

1:08:32And even given our clout and the size of the offer

1:08:37we can make and our, you know,

1:08:38Apple's famous negotiating acumen.

1:08:42Even so, so let's just presume that they've gotten

1:08:46very good favorable rates from both Amazon and Microsoft.

1:08:49It would be interesting to know how that compares

1:08:53to Google's ability to do it completely internally

1:08:57in terms of cost.

1:08:59And at what point is it valuable enough for Apple

1:09:01where like maps, they start to want to make that

1:09:03of their own core competency?

1:09:04- Right, like how much does it,

1:09:06is there a significant difference

1:09:09in the cost per typical user who says,

1:09:12okay, yes, go ahead and store my entire photo library

1:09:15on your service.

1:09:16What does that average out to for a typical user

1:09:19for Apple using S3 and who knows what else,

1:09:24and Google doing it completely internally?

1:09:27I think that would be interesting.

1:09:28That would be extraordinarily difficult to figure this out because I think it's obviously

1:09:33secret information for both companies.

1:09:35I think it would benefit Apple in the long run.

1:09:37iCloud Photo Library I think is a tremendous product.

1:09:39I think it solves a problem in a really good way.

1:09:42Cameras we know are incredibly important, especially in iPhone upgrade cycles.

1:09:45New cameras drive significant upgrades.

1:09:47But if you always have friction, if people feel either they don't use it or they feel

1:09:51it's too expensive, they're often going to hit that wall where they can't take a photo,

1:09:55they want to take it, they have to delete something else.

1:09:57reduces the experience and it's just one more piece of friction that they could probably

1:10:02use their resources to overcome.

1:10:04Yeah. Let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor and it's our good friends at

1:10:10Warby Parker. Warby Parker is a new concept in eyewear. They were founded with a simple

1:10:17but lofty objective to create boutique quality classically crafted eyewear at revolutionary

1:10:24price points. New pair of prescription glasses is typically pretty expensive, hundreds of

1:10:29dollars. Their idea is they could do it and get them to start at 95 bucks. So what do

1:10:38you do? You go to their website. You go to warbyparker.com and they have a whole bunch

1:10:43of eyeglasses right there to look from and you can filter the view. You can look at all

1:10:46the ones. If you're just looking at women's prescription eyewear, you can just look at

1:10:52If you're just looking at men's sunglasses, you can just look at those you can filter it the way you want

1:10:57You can search for certain shapes. Like if you know, you really want to look for rectangular frames you can filter on that

1:11:02And but here's what you do anything

1:11:05Here's I say this like with the mattresses and the pillows and all the stuff is like well

1:11:09How can you buy this stuff online?

1:11:10I mean glasses are so personal and your face and you never know you think I hey I like these glasses those glasses look cool

1:11:15And then you try them on in the store and you're looking like oh this looks terrible on me

1:11:20Well, here's what you do you sign up and for free?

1:11:24They you pick the five that you like the best and they just send them to you for free, you know

1:11:29Not with prescription lenses. They just send them to you with you know, clear lenses you take them out

1:11:34You try them on you look in the mirror take a selfie you ask your you know, your friends your significant other you ask them

1:11:41Hey, how do I look which one do you like?

1:11:43and

1:11:44Whichever ones you like if you just one you like if there's two you like whichever ones you like you send them all back

1:11:48Two or three days later and then you go back to the website and say well

1:11:51Here's I know because I tried these on I want these frames and you give them your prescription from your you know

1:11:57your eye doctor and

1:11:59Like a couple of days later. Boom. You've got a brand new set of prescription glasses 95 bucks

1:12:04they don't upsell you on stuff like

1:12:07Anti-reflective coating or using high index lenses high index lenses just is a fancy way of saying hey if your eyes are kind of bad

1:12:16The high index lenses lets the lenses still be relatively thin as opposed to you know

1:12:20Like coke bottle thick you want high index lenses if your eyes are bad because otherwise your glasses are gonna be thick

1:12:26They just get you just get all that it's included

1:12:29Stuff you do have to pay more for would be progressives. That's if you know, you need a

1:12:35Reader reading lens if you're older and you need, you know, regular lenses like near-sighted lenses at the top and

1:12:43Bifocals at the bottom so they start at two hundred ninety-five dollars, which is a lot more than the regular ones

1:12:48But it's way less than you pay for good progressives at most I wear shops

1:12:53I just bought a new pair. I'd say seriously. I mean this is just coincidence that the podcast timing is such

1:12:59I just bought a new pair a week ago

1:13:01Because with all this nonsense I'm going through with you know with my eye

1:13:08I needed a new prescription for my old glasses.

1:13:11The prescription in the left eye was no longer relevant.

1:13:14So I got a new pair, I bought them from Orbeez Parker.

1:13:17Showed up way in advance of what they promised.

1:13:19I think they said, "Hey, you'll get them in 10 days."

1:13:21And like four days later, boom, there they were.

1:13:25And they looked pretty cool, and you know, $95 bucks.

1:13:28And one of the reasons I was excited about it is that there's a good chance with the

1:13:32stuff I'm going through with my eye that even within a few months I might need a new prescription.

1:13:37So I'm not even out that much money.

1:13:39If these glasses only last me three or four months before I need a different prescription

1:13:44in my left eye, I'm only out 95 bucks, which is absolutely great.

1:13:49Really, really cool stuff.

1:13:50Now here's one last thing I want to tell you about them, is that they do a thing that I

1:13:54think is amazing.

1:13:55So there's people all around the world who cannot afford prescription glasses.

1:14:00I cannot even imagine what that's like to need prescription glasses and not be able

1:14:05to have them.

1:14:07And so what they do is every time you place an order for prescription glasses, they make

1:14:14available to people around the world who can't afford them a pair of prescription glasses.

1:14:19So in addition to the fact that you're only paying 95 bucks for cool glasses that come

1:14:24quickly and have a wide variety of styles, you're also doing something good for somebody

1:14:29else in the world who needs a pair of prescription glasses.

1:14:31So it's really hard to beat that.

1:14:33So if you're in the market for glasses, prescription or sunglasses, or prescription sunglasses,

1:14:40go check them out.

1:14:41Really can't recommend them enough.

1:14:43WarbyParker.com/TheTalkShow and they'll know you came from the show.

1:14:49So my thanks to them.

1:14:52What else from I/O?

1:14:53Anything else?

1:14:54Yeah, the Google Now improvements and the, I mean the Android stuff was interesting but

1:14:58a lot of them I thought was very similar, some of them at least was very similar to

1:15:01to what Apple have been doing with iOS for a while, like with permissions and with battery

1:15:04usage. But the Google Now and the OnTap stuff, which sadly doesn't mean beer is going to

1:15:08pour from your lightning port, I thought that at first. But the, I guess they don't have

1:15:12lightning ports, they're USB port. But the stuff about that is what makes me so interested

1:15:16in Google is that they're trying to make these better contextual engines where they can present

1:15:20you already like they know that if you have a flight coming because they read it off your

1:15:23email they can present you with the boarding pass for that flight. But now they want to

1:15:27start doing it when you're in locations and in areas that they haven't explored so far.

1:15:32And this is an area that Apple hasn't wanted to go into with Siri and Apple gets a lot

1:15:35of data from Siri and for a while they just did not want to mingle or act on your data

1:15:42on their servers.

1:15:43It was one of their privacy lines.

1:15:45But now with the proactive stuff that Mark Gurman was reporting on last week, it sounds

1:15:49like maybe that's changing at Apple and it makes me wonder what a service like Google

1:15:54now or like on tap would be through Apple's strong privacy and security stance or filtering.

1:15:59Yeah, can we do that? We'll just take a time out here and say young Mark Gurman over at

1:16:049to5Mac has been on a run like no one else. Hats off to young Mark Gurman, but he seems

1:16:11to have uncovered about 90 to 95% of what has publicly been revealed about WWDC and

1:16:20coming out. I do think that's an interesting direction for Apple and I feel like with Apple

1:16:28and Google in particular that they each, depending on the nature of their companies, get ahead

1:16:36of each other in certain ways and then the other catches up. And sometimes we can say,

1:16:43"Well, the one is copying the other." But on the other hand, it's not even about copying.

1:16:48It's really just like, it's inevitable that they're both going to go in that direction.

1:16:52And it can go from little things like the copy and paste pop-up.

1:16:57You know, how to select text and how to copy and paste it, which, you know, iOS didn't

1:17:03have in the first few revs, famously.

1:17:07You couldn't copy and paste, but then when they got it, they nailed it.

1:17:10And it's like, oh yeah, this is the way to copy and paste on a touchscreen.

1:17:14And Android experimented with a whole bunch of things, and all of them, quite frankly,

1:17:19in my opinion, just really, really stunk.

1:17:21It was one of the areas where Android was just, it's just one of those things that drove

1:17:25me nuts about it every time I tried it.

1:17:27And then coming up in Android M, they've got what's effectively the iOS style of copy and

1:17:31paste.

1:17:32Other things, though, you know, same thing.

1:17:34Android had it first, where you'd swipe down from the top of the screen and you'd see a

1:17:37list of your notifications.

1:17:39And they had that for like two years before iOS had a notification center.

1:17:44And guess what?

1:17:45You swipe down from the top of your screen and there's a list of your notifications.

1:17:48So it's not like it's a one-way street.

1:17:50I think that this sort of contextually aware, the phone knows some stuff about where you

1:17:58are, what you do, where you are on a daily basis, and can do smart things about it.

1:18:05I think it's like it does every time I hear them say neural network or machine learning

1:18:11I do think of the Terminator because you know it's one of those things where you are where

1:18:15those movies sent to us as warnings and I'm saying that it sounds paranoid but you never

1:18:20know how far this stuff is going to get and how much I want them to know about me which

1:18:23goes back to the same privacy discussion about Google Now previously so I would love to have

1:18:29Jarvis in my house but when I start thinking about it it's just as scary as it is attractive

1:18:33So I'm conflicted about this technology.

1:18:37But I think it does have absolute value.

1:18:39And if you don't like it, I would hope that a company like

1:18:42Apple and eventually Google would let you just use the

1:18:44functionality that Siri provides today where it has

1:18:47minimal knowledge of you.

1:18:48And the knowledge that it does have is on-device knowledge.

1:18:50And it's not doing any big data gathering or operations.

1:18:53But for people who do want that, who think that

1:18:55providing that data to get that service is a tremendous

1:18:57deal for them, that I think Apple providing it makes all

1:19:01of iOS more valuable to them?

1:19:03I find some of the stuff in Germin's report on it to be a little confusing because one

1:19:14of the things he says is that to begin with, Proactive will become a new layer within the

1:19:18iOS operating system, replacing the pull-down spotlight menu currently found on the iOS

1:19:23home screen.

1:19:24Again, I don't know what his sources are.

1:19:26I don't know anything about this.

1:19:28I'm completely in the dark.

1:19:30heard anything about it. But that doesn't make any sense to me because that screen is

1:19:33not part of the OS. The two layers of the OS that go from top or bottom is control center

1:19:40from the bottom and notification center from the top. And the reason I call them layers

1:19:45of the OS is you can get them from anywhere. Whereas to me, what he's talking about is

1:19:49just part of the, to use the internal lingo, it's part of springboard. It's only when you're

1:19:54on the home screen. And it doesn't make any sense to me that this feature wouldn't be

1:20:03available everywhere. To me, it would only make sense in the hold down the home button

1:20:07layer where Siri takes over the whole screen. But I don't know.

1:20:10I think one of the things that I don't know if this is what he's describing or not, but

1:20:15previously Apple was doing a lot of really cool things and part of those were surfaced

1:20:18in Siri. Like Siri could do a lot of interesting search. You could say like compare Apple or

1:20:22Google stock or get me these sports results.

1:20:25And you could do a lot of interesting searches in Spotlight, especially recently they made

1:20:29major changes to both Siri and Spotlight recently.

1:20:32And Spotlight could get you a bunch of interesting information including Wikipedia and maps and

1:20:35ports of interest.

1:20:36But even App Store search, they were all different like some did nearest neighbor and some didn't

1:20:41and some didn't care if you misspelled words and some didn't.

1:20:45And so in spite of having all these great technologies, they weren't merged together.

1:20:48They weren't better than the sum of the parts.

1:20:50I think part of what this is is taking the engine that's being built into spotlight and

1:20:54the engine that's in Siri and sort of making something that is better than each of those

1:20:57individually and Siri is sort of an ancillary interface layer.

1:21:02It doesn't replace the multi-touch interface but it's there whenever you need it.

1:21:08That makes sense.

1:21:11What do you think about – this bothers me but maybe I'm just not aware of the lingo

1:21:15But it bothers that this whole trend towards calling it machine learning

1:21:19bothers me because to me it's just AI we already have a term for it and my

1:21:23my hunch is that

1:21:26Computer science the world had talked about AI for so long and for so many decades and you know famously, you know, we

1:21:36Kubrick thought that by 2001 we'd have a computer you could just you know how that you could just talk to you. So

1:21:42famously

1:21:44computer scientists as a whole were vastly over-optimistic in terms of when we would get to

1:21:51like talk to a computer and hold a conversation with them, AI. And that it burned out the term.

1:21:59And so we come up with this new thing called machine learning that is, it doesn't,

1:22:06you know, it's two different words, but it's just, you know, a different branch of AI.

1:22:09I remember in Dune, which was one of my favorite books and movies growing up, where they had

1:22:14that Butlerian Jihad and they made a new commandment saying, "Thou shalt make no machine that thinks

1:22:18like a man."

1:22:19So it's been all part of our culture growing up and I by no means have any specific knowledge

1:22:24of AI, but it does seem like there's this recognition that's coming out that we're getting

1:22:30smart objects but they're not smart the way AI is.

1:22:33Touch ID makes the home button smart, the way Siri makes the microphone smart, the way

1:22:39makes the camera smart but it's not smart in a Terminator or Matrix way. It's

1:22:43just it's useful and I wonder if if this is sort of like what Jeff Hawkins was

1:22:48doing at Numenta where there was a realization that we can't make them

1:22:51think like us so we've got to go sort of part of the way there and this is

1:22:54using machine learning as distinct from AI because it's not artificially

1:22:58intelligent in the way we always imagined it. It's just a machine learning

1:23:01to recognize context and other specific areas. Hmm yeah one of the examples that

1:23:06Google gave and it does seem and this is one of those areas where it seems like

1:23:09Google is not just ahead of Apple but ahead of everybody but definitely ahead of Apple is in the

1:23:15aforementioned Google Photos project. They're doing more. So Apple's been doing face recognition

1:23:22for years and you know but they're doing a lot more. They're doing like recognizing when a

1:23:28picture was of a snowfall and saying I mean who now does this work I don't know but that they're

1:23:33saying that you know you can say I remember that snowfall back in 2010 and you could search for

1:23:38for snow in 2010 and come up with the photos you took

1:23:41of the snow piled on your car or whatever,

1:23:45which is really pretty cool, but it also seems believable.

1:23:50It seems like, wow, I bet that's really complex

1:23:52and really interesting how they got there,

1:23:53but I kind of believe it.

1:23:55If they can do face recognition, why can't they do,

1:23:58this is a snowy scene.

1:24:00- It's sort of like when they told us

1:24:02that Siri would get better when the more people use it.

1:24:03It's all of these technologies require ungodly amounts

1:24:07of data. It's part of why I think Google really wants to get

1:24:10us to give it more data because it who knows how much it needs

1:24:13to consume of snow before it starts to understand and

1:24:15recognize snow, that movie Ex Machina that just came out, they

1:24:20have a guy there who sort of it's sort of like the Google

1:24:22company in that universe. And in order to make his AI, he hacked

1:24:26every phone in the world to read every facial feature feature in

1:24:29the world. So he'd have enough data to reproduce them. And that

1:24:31was the volume that he needed. And it always seemed to me like

1:24:34when you start doing facial recognition or snow or when you

1:24:36have driverless cars, the amount of raw data you need to get to what the car needs or the

1:24:42photo needs to make the machine understand it is just immense.

1:24:47Yeah I can totally see that.

1:24:52Anything else on IO?

1:24:53I think that was all the really, I mean there was the cardboard stuff where they have VR.

1:24:58And VR is fascinating to me.

1:24:59It's like when Facebook bought Oculus because it's always been interesting to me that on

1:25:04On a computer I can have Facebook or Google open in one little window but then switch

1:25:07quickly or on a phone it's in one little app but I can switch quickly.

1:25:11But once it's VR and on your face I mean I don't know how to quit out of Oculus when

1:25:14it's strapped to my head or quit out of cardboard when it's strapped to my face.

1:25:18It seems like that's sort of the complete all-encompassing presence that they've always

1:25:22wanted.

1:25:23Yeah, have you ever used cardboard?

1:25:26I haven't.

1:25:27I've used Oculus a couple times and I've used Google Glass but I haven't used cardboard.

1:25:32I am worried that I'm not going to be able to use it.

1:25:36I'm worried that my eye situation, that maybe at the time where I can see 3D is over.

1:25:41But we'll see.

1:25:42But it definitely seems interesting.

1:25:44And I had to say, like, I was watching the keynote, or at least I watched some of the

1:25:47Google I/O keynote, and I was watching on the TV and my son had gotten home from school,

1:25:53and he was like, "Man, this stuff, these guys are boring."

1:25:56And then when that part kicked in, he was like, "Wait, this is pretty cool."

1:26:01So I don't know.

1:26:02you know, when they first came out with it last year, I thought it was kind of janky.

1:26:06But just because the only one they had was this seriously simple, stupid cardboard thing.

1:26:12But I don't know, it seems pretty interesting to be able to do it. I don't know. But

1:26:18you raise a good point, because this is one of the first interfaces where I mean, there's always

1:26:21going to be accessibility issues. But this is one of these first interfaces where there's a

1:26:25tremendous amount of the population who can't watch 3d movies, because they're just not

1:26:28comfortable with their eyes converging and focusing on different planes and they get vertigo where they get seasick and

1:26:33They're trying to fix these but there will always be a large amount of

1:26:36People who will not be able to use this as an interface and that to me

1:26:40Investing in it that heavily is interesting despite that even before I had this retina issue and had vision problems

1:26:46Even before that even when I saw 20/20 out of both eyes at distance

1:26:50I've never enjoyed a 3d movie

1:26:53Other than like a short one at like Disney like where you go in and you're in and out in five minutes and it's like wow

1:27:00That was pretty cool

1:27:01And I'll tell you what it is for me is I go and see a 3d movie and I could I can see the 3d

1:27:07and it's like I don't have any problems with the

1:27:09What do you call it? Like where some people have trouble seeing the 3d? Yeah

1:27:14But I would come out of the movie and and I will realize I don't remember the second half of it

1:27:21Like I'll be like I honest to God don't remember what the hell happened there. Like I remember I saw

1:27:26Perfect example is up

1:27:30I saw Pixar's up in 3d for the first time and I came out thinking hey that was pretty good

1:27:36And then I realized I really

1:27:38The whole thing once once the kid was in the house. I really didn't remember it

1:27:42I was like there was some kind of old, you know, I remembered vaguely

1:27:44There was the old guy who had the dogs

1:27:46But it was like I really could not summarize the plot

1:27:49Like I I have to spend so much time concentrating on the 3d that I I cannot just sit back and watch the movie

1:27:55and then when I watched up the second time in 2d, I

1:27:58Was so much more impressed with the movie. I was like wow, this is so clever

1:28:03This is a typical Pixar movie where every single scene is good

1:28:06Every line is worth, you know, every line of dialogue is worth it

1:28:10It's like and I just didn't have that impression watching it in 3d

1:28:13I had the same problem with I got accidentally I bought 3d tickets to Avengers Age of Ultron and the the fight scenes were just

1:28:20Undigestible to me. There was so much visual information. I had very little idea what was happening

1:28:24Yeah, and I went back and saw it in 2d and I was fine. Yeah, I haven't seen it

1:28:28Yeah, my son has and tells me that it's that I'm an idiot for not having seen it already. That's all Tron. It's AI

1:28:33Let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor and these guys

1:28:42I've been longtime friends of the show haven't been with us for a while happy to have him back and it's mail route

1:28:48I don't know. How would you pronounce it Renee? Are you?

1:28:52Te-meh, I do the same thing mail route, but some people might call it mail route. Well, either way ma I'll

1:28:59rout e

1:29:02You know who you want protecting your email

1:29:04Email nerds who do nothing but email that's what mail route is

1:29:10These guys created the first cloud-based email filtering solution and they sold it to Microsoft

1:29:16and now they're back with their own company and it is a really innovative and effective

1:29:23spam and virus filtering for your email, mail route.

1:29:27So imagine a world without spam, viruses, bounced email.

1:29:31Imagine the joy of opening your email and seeing only legit email that you need and

1:29:36And imagine that with a mail server that you control, your own mail server on your domain

1:29:42for your organization, something like that.

1:29:44Mail route wants you to feel this joy.

1:29:47There's no hardware or software to install or maintain.

1:29:50You don't go on your server and hook up mail route.

1:29:53Mail route simply receives your mail, sorts it, and then delivers only clean email to

1:29:58your mailbox.

1:29:59So what you do is you go in, it's sort of like a DNS type thing.

1:30:02You go in and change your DNS records, your MX records for mail so that the mail for your

1:30:07server that you control goes through mail route first.

1:30:11They don't host your email.

1:30:12They're not an email hosting thing.

1:30:14All they do is the mail from the outside world comes through them first.

1:30:19They filter it and then it goes on from mail route to your server.

1:30:23You're not giving up control of your server if you're an email admin or an IT pro.

1:30:27They're not asking you to let them host your email server.

1:30:30just saying filter your mail through them first this is all they do these guys they're like like

1:30:36the world's you know like preeminent like email experts all they do is email uh and it really

1:30:44works a charm it just removes all the cruft from your life and then your server uh only has to deal

1:30:51with the good email uh they have tons of features apis anything you want you know they're nerds you

1:30:58You can set it up very simply and just have to say,

1:31:01just hey, just filter my spam and the crap

1:31:03and give me the rest.

1:31:04You wanna customize it,

1:31:05they've got everything you'd wanna do to customize it

1:31:07if you are in charge of IT at your company

1:31:10and stuff like that.

1:31:11Really, really, really encourage you to check them out.

1:31:14It is a great service.

1:31:16I know a whole bunch of people who have signed up for this

1:31:19and I haven't heard a single bad word about MailRoute.

1:31:22So here's what you do.

1:31:23Go to mailroute.net.

1:31:27mail route dot net slash the talk show and you'll get a you get a free trial so

1:31:34you can try it out and if you don't like it then you just change your your MX

1:31:38records back to pointing it directly at your mail server easy to change back you

1:31:43don't have to like copy all your email you're not copying your email there you

1:31:45just change the MX record and all of a sudden you're back to where you were so

1:31:48you can undo the free trial at any time if you don't like it but set it up set

1:31:52up the free trial start filtering your mail through them and use that that

1:31:56Slash the talk show and you'll get 10% off not for the first month, but forever for the lifetime of your account. You'll save 10%

1:32:03just for being smart enough to try mail route and smart enough to

1:32:07Listen to the talk show. So my thanks to them check out mail route

1:32:12Anything else at IO I

1:32:18Think that was the main stuff. Yeah, so

1:32:20WWDC what do you think is coming up? I

1:32:25I think Apple's going to stick with iOS 9 and OS 10.11. I think we'll see the new Apple TV.

1:32:32We'll get some more word on HomeKit. Apple TV might come with a game store or an app store.

1:32:37I think those will probably be the least of the big stuff.

1:32:41Yeah, I am surprised to hear this. But so at the code conference this week,

1:32:50Jeff Williams was, you know, and this is a conference that Steve, this is the Walt Mossberg

1:32:54Karas Swisher hosted conference that for years was like the All Things D conference while

1:33:00they were at the Wall Street Journal and now it's the code conference now that they're

1:33:04on their own at Recode/Comcast.

1:33:08Zing!

1:33:10And for years, I don't know if there's, maybe there's a year where nobody from Apple showed

1:33:19I don't know but for years somebody from Apple has shown up jobs was there many times and some of his most famous sort of

1:33:26Off-the-cuff interviews in the last, you know, 10-15 years came with that conference

1:33:29Obviously, he's pretty hard get he was a pretty hard get Tim Cook has spoken there a few years ago. That's the conference where Tim Cook

1:33:37Said that the wrist is interesting. This was that was two years ago

1:33:41and

1:33:44This year speaking from Apple was Jeff Williams

1:33:49So I thought that was, as an Apple nerd,

1:33:51that was something that caught my eye.

1:33:52'Cause to me, being an Apple exec

1:33:55who is authorized within Apple to go there and speak,

1:34:00not necessarily opened by the standards of open,

1:34:02but instead wasn't just a bunch of no comments.

1:34:05And in fact, he said some interesting things.

1:34:08But it's also sort of another sign

1:34:10of Jeff Williams' leveling up within the executive hierarchy.

1:34:15- Yeah, we saw him do the research kit presentation

1:34:17the last event and I thought he did an excellent job for his first time yeah

1:34:21and you know and in addition to the fact that he did a great job on stage it was

1:34:28to me an important an interesting thing that he announced and something that was

1:34:34dropped like a you know a true surprise something that had not been leaked in

1:34:39any way I think the stuff that like if you look at the stuff that's in

1:34:42Federighi's work that traditionally doesn't leak that we don't start

1:34:45hearing about stuff until it starts leaving the core group of engineers.

1:34:49Yeah, I agree. So, you know, first sign of Jeff Williams's leveling up was a

1:34:55significant on-stage presence at one of their public events and then another

1:34:59sign here is his appearance at the code conference and so my conjecture is that

1:35:07I don't know if it's imminent but I would think sooner rather than later

1:35:11later Jeff Williams is going to get a promotion to chief operating officer as

1:35:16he was sort of it would Tim Cook was chief operating officer Jeff Williams

1:35:18was right underneath them and then he became senior vice president of

1:35:22operations which is not exactly the same thing as chief operating officer it's

1:35:25not a c-level position so that makes that makes a lot of sense especially if

1:35:28operations continues on one hand I can see it because Tim Cook is an operations

1:35:33guy so you might think you don't need a CEO when the CEO is in fact that good at

1:35:37operations but I think it just makes sense as as Jeff Williams continues to

1:35:41do these impressive projects that that title gets to him yeah I think so and

1:35:46well and quite frankly I honestly think I think it's a lot harder to guess than

1:35:51it was with Steve Jobs and Tim Cook but my guess is that the current succession

1:35:56plan if something happened to Tim Cook would be for Jeff Williams to be named

1:36:01CEO yeah I thought the same thing and that it's it's and again it's funny how

1:36:07things change where when when Steve Jobs you know was sick and it was I mean a

1:36:14responsible company would have a succession plan even with a perfectly

1:36:17healthy CEO like they have to I it well it's a responsibility of the board if

1:36:23they don't then the board I think can be you know is liable to shareholder suits

1:36:28etc I Tim Cook seems to me like the type of guy who you know always has insurance

1:36:35(laughs)

1:36:37Right, like you don't have to remind him

1:36:39that you have to, you know, you should, you know,

1:36:41make sure you get renter's insurance on that,

1:36:44you know, rental property.

1:36:45It's like he's already got it.

1:36:46- It's a line item.

1:36:47- But my guess is that the current succession plan,

1:36:50if it needed to come in, would be for Jeff Williams.

1:36:52And the funny difference would be that when Steve Jobs,

1:36:55they needed a succession plan,

1:36:56their idea was the last thing we're gonna try to do

1:36:59is replace Steve Jobs with another Steve Jobs,

1:37:02because there is no other Steve Jobs.

1:37:04Whereas my guess with Tim Cook is

1:37:07we would replace him with the closest thing we have

1:37:10to another Tim Cook, which is Jeff Williams.

1:37:13A guy with the exact same background.

1:37:15They just seem like two peas in a pod, really.

1:37:21And I'm sure if you got to know them personally,

1:37:24I'm sure that they're individuals.

1:37:25But at least from the outside,

1:37:26they are extremely similar individuals.

1:37:29Operations background, even they're both from the US South,

1:37:33They seem to have similar demeanors even, you know, and similar reputations within the

1:37:39company for getting shit done.

1:37:42Absolutely.

1:37:43And Steve Jobs was unique, but he did have some of the skills that are really important

1:37:47for a CEO, including the ability to make those deals and the ability to rally shareholders.

1:37:52But a lot of the other things – it's not typical.

1:37:55Like you said earlier, Johnny Ive probably has no aspirations to be CEO because that's

1:37:59not the kind of job you'd enjoy doing.

1:38:01And I think that's true of a lot of them, whether it's marketing or services or something

1:38:05else.

1:38:06Like Craig Federighi, a CEO, makes no sense.

1:38:08Even though he's phenomenal, Jeff Williams just seems like the best fit for that job.

1:38:13Right.

1:38:14Like what it really means to be a pure CEO, it really, to me, comes out of operations.

1:38:19And combined with a deep understanding of what it is that makes Apple, Apple, right?

1:38:25you know, that I don't think, you know, I again, I really do not think that in the near future,

1:38:33that they would ever consider looking outside the company for replacement, you know, CEO, it would,

1:38:39it would have to take a significant and I think, years long drought of, you know, of, you know,

1:38:47declines in revenue and problems with products, you know, for them to even think about that it

1:38:51It would have to be a situation where something was clearly going wrong.

1:38:55Whereas as long as things are going right or in my opinion even just like okay, they're

1:39:01only going to look inside.

1:39:03I agree completely.

1:39:04I don't think there's, it's such a unique culture and getting someone at that level

1:39:07acclimatized to that culture.

1:39:09We've heard about having some of the problems with the vast amount of engineers but getting

1:39:12an executive in there at that level.

1:39:15I can understand bringing in Angela Ahrens but we saw what happened when he brought in

1:39:19John Browett before that.

1:39:20It's just not an easy thing to do.

1:39:22You know, years from now, who knows?

1:39:24You know, Angela Arnn's could be on that list too, but it wouldn't be like a near term, if something happened near term.

1:39:31And I don't think that's going to happen. I think Tim Cook is, you know, he's made Apple his life.

1:39:36I think it would be like an emergency situation. But they have to have a plan for it.

1:39:40So another way to look at it to me is, you know, there are places, you hear about places where they only like to hire software engineers from Stanford, MIT,

1:39:48and you know Caltech and Carnegie Mellon like if you're not in the top five comp

1:39:53side programs they don't want it they don't want to look at you I think Apple

1:39:57for like a chief executive is only looking at graduates of Apple University

1:40:03yeah like if you haven't gone through app years long program through Apple

1:40:08University and learned the Apple way from the last 15 to 20 years they're not

1:40:14looking at you and the only the only way to go through Apple University is to

1:40:18to be a long time executive at Apple.

1:40:21- Yeah, absolutely.

1:40:22I think Angela again, running Apple retail and stores

1:40:25is one of the closest jobs to being president

1:40:27of a division of Apple.

1:40:28Maybe only iTunes is similar

1:40:29because of the scope of that operation.

1:40:31So those are two people who could,

1:40:33and Angela Aarons did run her own business for a long time.

1:40:35But like you said, that the length of time in the company

1:40:37is what makes it Apple.

1:40:39- Yeah, yeah, it is sort of her own division.

1:40:41And in a sense, for example, she gets her own marketing.

1:40:46Again, maybe the posters gum through Schiller's group or whatever, but just the general sense

1:40:51that when you walk into the Apple store, the experience of walking in, and literally, I

1:40:56mean this totally literally, how it smells.

1:40:59Every sense that is engaged when you're in that store is a reflection of Apple's brand.

1:41:06That's an enormous brand responsibility.

1:41:08Again, that makes her more like the president of a separate division.

1:41:14Yeah, no, absolutely. I think Q is similar because again they have marketing and they

1:41:18have events and they have developers and they have designers and all those people working

1:41:21and iTunes could easily be its own company as well. But he just seems ideally suited

1:41:26for what he does which is making those sort of entertainment deals.

1:41:28Yeah, Q would be on my short list of guesses though too, definitely.

1:41:32Which is interesting because I've been thinking about this a lot because there are all the

1:41:35rumors of the new Apple TV coming out and the Apple TV unlike the iPhone and the iPad

1:41:39is under the iTunes organization.

1:41:42And it's been so long since it was updated.

1:41:44It was last updated 2012, the spring.

1:41:47What that means for a product when Apple looks at it as not just being a device, but being

1:41:51a device that has to be bundled with services, in this case, media properties or content

1:41:56deals.

1:41:57Because otherwise they could have just been updating this every year the way they've been

1:41:59updating iPhones.

1:42:00Yeah.

1:42:01So that's the thing I'm most excited about for WWDC this year.

1:42:05At least, unless they have, you know,

1:42:06other than the vague idea that they have a complete surprise

1:42:09to pull the, you know, to pull the curtain on.

1:42:13But, you know, so we, blah, blah, blah, new Apple TV.

1:42:17And maybe there's an SDK, et cetera, et cetera.

1:42:21We don't know anything about it.

1:42:22Like, they've kept that, that's been,

1:42:24like, the details of it have been,

1:42:26at least from everything I've seen,

1:42:28is pretty under wraps.

1:42:30But I really do think it's coming this year.

1:42:33I would put money on it.

1:42:34I think we can guess a little bit.

1:42:36Like it's running a single core A5 processor right now and they've almost certainly got

1:42:39to do.

1:42:40They're going to go, it's an iOS device.

1:42:41It runs a version of iOS 8 right now that has just a different versioning number.

1:42:45You mean right now meaning if you go into a store and buy a $69 Apple TV right now.

1:42:50Right.

1:42:51Yeah.

1:42:52Single core A5 processor running iOS 8.3 I think has been updated 8.3.

1:42:55But you know if they put an A788 class processor in there, if they let it run something like

1:43:00metal, if they start incorporating technologies into it like Siri, then I think if you do

1:43:04You just look at it as an iOS device and you bring it up to parity with last year's or

1:43:08this year's iPhone or iPad, then that becomes a very, maybe a more expensive device than

1:43:13we've seen before, but that becomes a really interesting device.

1:43:15And just in terms, it's crazy, and they do these comparisons as they've gone to retina

1:43:19screens where they show what a 1080p TV pixel for pixel looks like on a retina 5K iMac or

1:43:29something like that.

1:43:30you see it my god the 1080p TV is like just a tiny little rectangle in the corner I mean

1:43:38you could do like side-by-side 1080p on a retina 5k my Mac right I pretty sure yeah

1:43:43before you do for them is still have room for your pallets so the ridiculous thing is

1:43:49that a new Apple TV to run a 1080p TV is pushing way fewer pixels than an iPhone 6 or 6 plus

1:43:59I guess it's just not even breaking a sweat in terms of that, in terms of what they could

1:44:04get away with at a cost-efficient level.

1:44:08So I'm really excited to see that, to see what they do, to see what the input methods

1:44:11are and to see what kind of SDK they're giving to us.

1:44:18Well, that's a super interesting thing.

1:44:20And I think the platform technologies group under Johnny Suruji, the other Johnny at Apple,

1:44:25I think never gets the credit they deserve.

1:44:27If you look at something like the Apple, the iPad Air 2, that machine is ludicrously overpowered

1:44:32for what you can do on it.

1:44:33That's got an A8X processor.

1:44:36A lot of companies, companies that make money off selling chips, it's not in their best

1:44:39interest to move too fast because they want to get as much money as they can for every

1:44:42generation of chip.

1:44:43Apple could care less.

1:44:44So they just let these guys run as fast as they can.

1:44:47They don't say, "Oh, the A7 is good enough.

1:44:48We'll use that for two or three years."

1:44:50No, you can fit an extra core, do it.

1:44:52You can fit an extra more GPUs, do it.

1:44:55And there I think for a while iOS the software was perhaps ahead of the hardware but I think

1:45:00we've entered an age now where I don't even know what you do with the power in an iPad

1:45:04too.

1:45:05I don't think anything maybe a high-end game taxes a little bit but I don't think anything

1:45:08on iOS taxes it and if you start putting that sort of power in an Apple TV I don't outside

1:45:14of an SDK you don't need that to run HBO now.

1:45:16So I think what they start doing both with the iPad going forward and with Apple TV is

1:45:21So start answering the questions of,

1:45:23now that you have all this silicon, what do you run on it?

1:45:26- Can I tell you what my dream feature

1:45:28for Apple TV would be?

1:45:29And I'm ripping it right off from my pal John Siracusa.

1:45:32I don't know if you do listen

1:45:33to the Accidental Tech podcast?

1:45:36- Absolutely.

1:45:37- It's got John Siracusa. - Only for Casey.

1:45:39- Who?

1:45:40(laughing)

1:45:42Oh yeah, all right, I got you, I got you, the other guy.

1:45:44- The moderator.

1:45:45- Yeah, the other guy.

1:45:46So Siracusa had a rant a few episodes ago,

1:45:48and I know it's a recurring thing for him,

1:45:50But his thing is you're watching a stream

1:45:53or a video or whatever, and you go to fast forward

1:45:57or you pause for too long, and then when you come back,

1:46:01it's back at the beginning, right?

1:46:03Like you're watching a Netflix stream and you just wanna,

1:46:05like I understand that if it's streaming

1:46:07rather than completely downloading,

1:46:09it's like you just go listen to the episode of ATP

1:46:12where Syracuse ran it, but I just,

1:46:13I'm completely in agreement with him.

1:46:15If I wanna fast forward a stream,

1:46:19Just show me thumbnails as it goes by.

1:46:22But make sure that the time on-- even just

1:46:25if you just move the timeline and the scrubber

1:46:27and the timeline, and don't even show me anything visually.

1:46:29Just let me see the timeline and pick.

1:46:32And if I say, I know I just want to go back two minutes,

1:46:35and I just go back, just show the timeline animating

1:46:38for two minutes.

1:46:38And then when I stop two minutes later and hit play,

1:46:42if you need a second or two to catch up on the stream, fine.

1:46:45But make sure that that's where you start.

1:46:47And the fact that so many streaming things

1:46:50on everything I've ever tried don't work that way

1:46:54drives me nuts.

1:46:55And it's even worse because, like Syracuse,

1:46:59we've been a TiVo house since forever.

1:47:01I think I got a TiVo in year 2000

1:47:05when my wife and I, when I was working

1:47:08at Pear Bone Software, we went over Rich Siegel's house

1:47:11and he had a TiVo.

1:47:12And we immediately went out the next day and bought a TiVo.

1:47:16We were like, this is the craziest thing ever.

1:47:17But the thing with TiVo is when you fast forward,

1:47:19it always just fast forwards.

1:47:21And when you rewind, it always rewinds.

1:47:23And it always just starts where you want to start.

1:47:25And you never have this problem.

1:47:26And I know that's because TiVo has downloaded everything

1:47:29into a hard drive in the box.

1:47:30But the simple fact is that with TiVo,

1:47:32you can fast forward, rewind, skim, scan,

1:47:37whatever you want to call it, backwards, forwards, jump

1:47:39forwards 15 minutes at any time, and it just works.

1:47:42And I swear to God, if Apple TV could just do that for stuff,

1:47:47that enough would sell me on it.

1:47:50- It's sort of like the original iPhone

1:47:51when you scroll Safari, they didn't try to render

1:47:53the interface and slow you down,

1:47:54just let you get where you were going

1:47:56and then filled it in behind you.

1:47:57- Yes, that's what I want.

1:47:58That's exactly what I want with stream scanning.

1:48:01- And not to be a dick about it,

1:48:04but also I know that whatever content deal

1:48:06has been delaying or at least influencing

1:48:08the Apple TV releases, I'm not gonna get that

1:48:09in Canada anyway, so just ship me the hardware.

1:48:12- I never thought about that, it's sad.

1:48:14God, that sucks.

1:48:17- Well, you'll still get the, I still think,

1:48:19I think Apple could do a better job

1:48:20even with their own content, the iTunes content

1:48:22that you do get in Canada.

1:48:24And I'd really like to see them focus on that experience

1:48:28and put the sort of, comparing it to scrolling

1:48:32on the iPhone is exactly right.

1:48:33Like, obviously, right from the get-go,

1:48:35when the software was way more ambitious

1:48:38than the hardware could support,

1:48:40they still focused on making sure

1:48:41the experience was responsive.

1:48:44And that even if you had to wait to catch up,

1:48:46At least you, it wasn't like if you scrolled too far down on the webpage, all of a sudden

1:48:50it snapped you to the top, which would make you mad, but which happens with streaming

1:48:55stuff all the time.

1:48:58There's super smart engineers working on Apple TV and maybe there were some frustrations,

1:49:02maybe there were some false starts, but they've had a long time now and it feels like there's

1:49:06a big technology gap that's going to help with performance and things are smarter now,

1:49:11so hopefully a lot of that will get rectified.

1:49:13Yeah, my, you know, and again, not to put too much on them, because who knows, maybe

1:49:16it'll be an underwhelming announcement, and I'm not going to hold it against them.

1:49:20But I will just say, knowing that there are some really smart people who've been working

1:49:23on it for a while, and that some of the holdup, if not all of it, a lot of it has been content

1:49:28negotiation and figuring out what we're going to do in terms of service-wise, and it was

1:49:32external, that it's possible that the internal team is really kind of, might be, you know,

1:49:38able to do like it's like a 2.0 version of whatever it is that they were going to if

1:49:43they might have shipped two years ago that they would have shipped then you know that

1:49:46they're already at like a next generation version of it.

1:49:50And there's so much in iOS 8 that they're not for example last year we almost had no

1:49:53iTunes announcements I can I don't think I can remember very many at all and the ones

1:49:57we did get like iTunes radio they never propagated because the beats merger effectively changed

1:50:02that whole strategy but we don't have continuity for iTunes or for any form of media yet we

1:50:06just get up with the playlist playing on our Mac, just transfer it to our iPhone and keep

1:50:10walking or if we're watching something on the Apple TV and we want to go to bed, we

1:50:13can't just pick up our iPad.

1:50:15You can go manually and chase after the functionality the way you used to have to do with productivity

1:50:19stuff on iOS, but it's not yet of that age and I think this is a huge opportunity.

1:50:23I don't know how many people can mention about whether they're going to do it now or not,

1:50:26but there's a lot of stuff that they can just do to catch up and bring all this stuff forward

1:50:29that I think would be really interesting.

1:50:30Yeah, I wonder how some of the continuity stuff could work and with like a little bit

1:50:36of proximity awareness, you know, like how much easier could they make, you know, airplay

1:50:44by like I already know you're in the living room and you're watching a video and, you

1:50:50know, maybe the Apple TV could get ready to receive, you know, the video so that the handoff

1:50:57happens much quicker in advance.

1:50:58I don't know if you've played with handoff on the Apple watch very much.

1:51:02No, I actually haven't done handoff on the watch that much.

1:51:06It's interesting because there's some collision right now because I have a Mac and I have

1:51:10an iPhone and I have my Apple watch and you can handoff messages or mail or any of that

1:51:14kind of stuff, but my Mac is broadcasting too, so I'll pick up my iPhone and I'll see

1:51:20the Safari icon from my Mac, but then I'll change Windows, then all of a sudden I'll

1:51:23see the messages icon from my watch.

1:51:26And that sort of thing I think they're going to have to figure out too because now we're

1:51:28We're not going to just have an iPhone or an iPad, but we have the Mac and the watch

1:51:31and maybe the Apple TV.

1:51:33And who gets that slot on the lock screen or in the dock?

1:51:36Yeah.

1:51:37All right, let me take one last break here and thank our final sponsor, and then we'll

1:51:43come back and wrap up the show with our final thoughts.

1:51:46But our last sponsor, and I am positively delighted to have them back, it's our good

1:51:51friends at Harry's.

1:51:54You guys know Harry's.

1:51:55makes premium men's shaving products. Everything from the handles to the razors to the creams,

1:52:02anything you need. Really great stuff, really great focus on quality design, a sort of timeless

1:52:13design that isn't gimmicky, it doesn't look like a droid ad from Verizon, it just looks like a nice

1:52:18classy handle for a razor. A nice beautiful box of razor blades. And here's the thing,

1:52:28by cutting out the middleman, they make them, they package them, and then they sell them

1:52:33direct to you. So you're not going through some kind of distributor, and then the distributor

1:52:38puts them in drugstores, and then the drugstore sells them to you, and it's marked up all

1:52:42along the way. And when you're in the drugstore, because people shoplift this stuff, they've

1:52:48got them behind a glass thing and you've got to hail down a clerk and then they

1:52:51have to unlock the thing and then you pick it out and then they won't even let

1:52:54you take them they like walk you to the counter what a pain in the ass you go to

1:52:59Harry's you sign up you pick the one you want you pick the starting kit you want

1:53:02and a couple of days later boom the thing arrives in the mail and they by

1:53:08cutting out the middleman their prices are just terrific so just for example

1:53:15here's the thing the blades cost like two dollars or less per pack depending

1:53:20on what you do so for 15 bucks you get you get a pack of eight you can't get a

1:53:2615 pack of like Gillette high-end blades I mean an 8 pack for 15 bucks you know

1:53:32they're like $32 or something like that and that's even on Amazon if you go if

1:53:37you buy 16 at a time it's only 25 bucks you're only paying a dollar fifty per

1:53:42blade cartridge and these are the type of cartridges you know there's four

1:53:45blades on the thing and you know a strip at the top to keep it comfortable comes

1:53:50in beautiful packaging makes you feel really good about it really really cool

1:53:56stuff they also have things where you can sign up once you're a happy

1:54:01customer you can tell them how often you shave how often you go through stuff you

1:54:05can sign up get more or less like a subscription and blades just show up on

1:54:09a regular basis so you don't even have to remember to reorder but to get

1:54:14started before you know you're not going to subscribe before you know how good

1:54:17this stuff is all you do is you go there you take a look around and you can get

1:54:20these sets they've got one called the Truman set gives you some shaving cream

1:54:24or gel a handle three blades everything you need to get started 15 bucks that's

1:54:31it they've got the Winston set same type of stuff same three things except the

1:54:36blade is made out of steel instead of plastic really cool stuff and then

1:54:41And here's something else, timing-wise, exactly,

1:54:43it's a great idea.

1:54:45It's called the Father's Day Shave Set.

1:54:48Comes in a beautiful box.

1:54:50You get to pick between foaming gel or shave cream.

1:54:54It gives you everything you need

1:54:57to get started with Harry's.

1:54:58And just the box alone looks like it's worth it.

1:55:03The whole thing is only 40 bucks.

1:55:04Really, really great stuff.

1:55:08Again, a no-brainer.

1:55:10I know it seems like a, you know, like a,

1:55:11it's like getting your dad a tie.

1:55:13It's right out of the central cliche, you know,

1:55:14get your dad a shaving kit.

1:55:15But this is so nice and it's so nicely designed.

1:55:18I say go retro and do it.

1:55:20It is a great idea.

1:55:21How can you go wrong with it?

1:55:22Really, really cool stuff.

1:55:25I encourage you to go and check it out.

1:55:26You just see that just the box alone

1:55:28looks like it's worth 40 bucks.

1:55:29Don't know how these guys do it.

1:55:31Where do you go to find out more?

1:55:35Go to harrys.com.

1:55:37h a r r y s dot com and use the code talk show know the just talk show and on your first

1:55:45order you will save 10 uh so my thanks to harry's go there check them out get your uh

1:55:54dad your husband your father um anybody you want a father's day shaving kit really really

1:55:59great stuff my thanks to them you know what i was wrong it's not 10 you save five bucks

1:56:05But anyway, that's what you save.

1:56:07Five bucks at checkout on your first purchase.

1:56:10But it'll be about 10% depending on what you buy.

1:56:14- It's money in your pocket.

1:56:15- Money in your pocket and a fantastic shaving kit.

1:56:18One last thing on my list of things to talk about.

1:56:22I don't know if you have anything.

1:56:23And maybe it's related to handoff and et cetera.

1:56:27But one of the most curious pieces of news

1:56:29that have come out to me,

1:56:30you know what I'm gonna say, right?

1:56:31- Yep.

1:56:32- All right, you say it.

1:56:33- Discovery D.

1:56:34Discovery D. Explain Discovery D to people who may not be familiar with it.

1:56:41So Apple did a lot of under-the-hood stuff with Yosemite. I think they rewrote Launch

1:56:45D. They rewrote Discovery D. And my original understanding is that this was a key component

1:56:50for things like continuity and for a world where you do have things like the Apple Watch,

1:56:54and you need to be able to move, identify devices and move information, not just information,

1:56:59but actually activity back and forth between them. But it was remarkably error-prone. I

1:57:03I think Rich Segal was my favorite when he posted a screenshot showing Apple TV bracket

1:57:07one all the way to 99 or something on his screen.

1:57:10All right.

1:57:11So for example, if in the last year you've had an experience where anything on your home

1:57:19network has suddenly gotten a new name where it was the old name parenthesis and an integer.

1:57:26Like perfect example that your Apple TV no longer shows up as Apple TV.

1:57:30now called Apple TV one or you know Jones iPhone is now Jones iPhone 2 that's

1:57:37discovery D that's an issue with discovery D or if your other computers

1:57:42on your network no longer show up in the finder like they're just it's not there

1:57:45anymore they're only intermittently there I it does seem like they fixed my

1:57:49problem at some point but we had a problem here I think I talked about it

1:57:53in the show a few months ago with our HP laser jet printer which has

1:57:58Bonjour support and at first when we first got it a couple years ago it was

1:58:04great because we no longer needed it just go and set up a printer and it was

1:58:09listed and then it would figure out what it was it was almost I swear and I know

1:58:14this is retro but in the old days of classic Mac OS with the chooser and we

1:58:18didn't even have network but you plugged a printer in your computer and you went

1:58:21to the chooser and there it was there was the printer and you selected it and

1:58:25And then when you went to whatever app you were using to print, it would print to that

1:58:29printer.

1:58:30And there was no other, no drivers to install, no telling the computer what printer it is.

1:58:36It all identified itself.

1:58:38That's how it worked with our LaserJet until Yosemite.

1:58:42And then all of a sudden, you printed yesterday and then you went to print today and it wouldn't

1:58:48print and then you'd go to see where's the printer and it wouldn't even be listed.

1:58:54One of those fixes was to basically disconnect everything, especially Apple TVs, and then

1:58:58reconnect it.

1:58:59It sounded – I don't have the technical acumen to say whether this is true or not,

1:59:02but it sounded like almost some form of cash poisoning where something would keep a bad

1:59:05list and it would just replicate errors over and over again.

1:59:09Yeah.

1:59:10It would maybe like hang on to old ideas of where something should be.

1:59:17But the weird thing about it is it replaced something called mDNS Responder.

1:59:23weird thing is is people you know again when I was younger I would have been

1:59:26right there with them but they're you know people far braver than me jury-rigged

1:59:31Yosemite to turn off discovery D and replace it with mDNS responder from like

1:59:39I guess what we had before Mavericks yeah like the last stable version of

1:59:46Mavericks which to me that type of stuff I can see why it works I'm not shocked

1:59:50that it works. But to me, that sort of doing surgery on the OS is not for me anymore, right?

1:59:56That's a young man's game. But by every account I've read, if there's like sets of instructions

2:00:02out there, I wouldn't recommend following them if you're, you know, but there are, and by all

2:00:09accounts at work, that you could disable Discovery D, go back to Maverick's version of MDNS Responder,

2:00:15and everything just worked. And the weird thing is before that, before somebody had figured out,

2:00:18out, here's a proven set of instructions to do it. The assumption was, well, they replaced

2:00:24and why did they replace MDNS responder, which didn't have any of these problems, with

2:00:28Discovery D, which has all of these problems. And the consensus was, well, some of these

2:00:33continuity features must depend on it. And if you do this, I'll bet some of the continuity

2:00:38features aren't going to work anymore, and apparently not. And so the weird thing is

2:00:44that in what's still a beta, the latest beta of 10.10.4, that is exactly what Apple has

2:00:52done is that discovery D is no longer there and they've gone back to MDNS responder.

2:00:59It feels like an MDNS responder has been around since Jaguar, but it feels like they needed

2:01:04this rewrite or they felt they needed this rewrite. Oftentimes people at Apple will complain

2:01:08that they're not allowed to refactor old code or they just don't have the time to refactor

2:01:12But it sounds like this went forward and they were given opportunities to fix it and there

2:01:16were fixes that were in almost every point release and it just got to a point where a

2:01:19decision was made that it's not being fixed right enough or fast enough and we're cutting

2:01:24baits.

2:01:25And I don't know if this is just for now and they're testing it because what's weird is

2:01:30this is a beta so unless it's in the shipping version it's not going to hit everybody.

2:01:35So if the shipping version comes out with Discovery D back in it then I don't know what

2:01:38this means that comes back with MS DNS responder in it then at least we know

2:01:42that that's been officially changed everywhere now MD nest or discovery D

2:01:46is also on iOS 8 right I believe so yeah I believe so too and I had a friend who

2:01:51said that he was with - this is a friend who does not work at Apple but I was out

2:01:56with a few Apple folks and joked I'll bet they replaced discovery D on iOS -

2:02:01and and they they just went silent and the one the one Apple guy had to like

2:02:05stifle a laugh. I don't know. Read that as you may, but I mean, you know, and they wouldn't

2:02:11know further words for explained exchange on the subject, but there might be something

2:02:16there.

2:02:17I think if you started asking, you'll just get a clear saying too soon.

2:02:20My guess is there's somebody within Apple who's the DRI, again, directly responsible

2:02:25individual for Discovery D, who is having trouble sleeping at night and when he wakes

2:02:32up in the morning is covered in sweat.

2:02:34Yes.

2:02:35because this sort of thing does not happen like they Apple stubbornly fixes

2:02:42these things rather than go back to right like a rollback like this just is

2:02:50you know and it's not the hugest deal in the world but it's just out of character

2:02:54for Apple and and another thing I have heard is just loosely that in term in

2:03:03in the aftermath of this coming out and just like asking around like, "What the hell,

2:03:07man? This is just crazy," is that Discovery D became like the whipping boy for anything

2:03:17and everything wrong with Yosemite, even if it had nothing to do with networking. Like,

2:03:23just loose terms from the top. It's this whole basic idea, you know, and to go back even

2:03:29into Marco's functional high ground thing.

2:03:33This whole basic idea that Apple software

2:03:35has become a little less reliable with Yosemite,

2:03:40really rank, really rankled people within Apple,

2:03:45all the way up to the top.

2:03:47And that, you know, I've talked about this,

2:03:51but that, you know, there were people who,

2:03:53not who went in denial about it, but who said,

2:03:55"Wait, our open bug count is lower than it's been in years.

2:03:58We've been fixing bugs at this incredible rate.

2:04:01It doesn't make sense that people think

2:04:03we've been getting less reliable,

2:04:04and we're getting fewer crash reports than ever.

2:04:07Things are crashing less.

2:04:08All these ways they have internally

2:04:11of analytically measuring reliability

2:04:14were saying Yosemite was one of their best releases ever,

2:04:17and the conventional wisdom out in user land

2:04:20was that it was one of the worst,

2:04:22and the whole thing came down to its discovery deets fault.

2:04:27They were using the wrong metrics to qualify their success,

2:04:30but DiscoveryD became the poster child.

2:04:31- Right.

2:04:32- And you could just see in a pre-Steve Jobs world,

2:04:34he'd be sitting there with Apple TV 99

2:04:36and wanna throw the controller at somebody's head.

2:04:38- You know what?

2:04:39It actually, doesn't it seem like a Steve Jobs decision?

2:04:42That at some point there was like, it obviously wasn't,

2:04:45but at some point, somebody got started

2:04:48about all these bugs with DiscoveryD

2:04:50and there's this frustration and pride

2:04:53that Yosemite's supposed to get,

2:04:54and he's just like, fuck it,

2:04:56We're going back to MDNS Responder.

2:04:58And everybody in the room is like, well, we don't do that.

2:05:00And then he leaves, and it's like,

2:05:02he just said we're going back to MDNS Responder,

2:05:04and so it's like, okay.

2:05:06- And in the old days, to bring the show full circle,

2:05:09Scott would have said, don't worry about it,

2:05:10give me two weeks, I'll turn them around.

2:05:12(laughing)

2:05:13- Maybe, and there's nobody there for that.

2:05:15So that is a curious story, but in another way, though,

2:05:20it's actually sort of makes me feel good.

2:05:23It's like, let's not be stubborn.

2:05:26Let's not be too prideful with the new thing.

2:05:28Let's just go with what works.

2:05:30- It's not all, doing something

2:05:31that's no longer off the table.

2:05:33- Right.

2:05:34- Which I think is huge.

2:05:35And it makes me, 'cause the other thing Jeff Williams said

2:05:37at Recode was confirming that the native SDK

2:05:40is coming for the watch.

2:05:41And a lot of, at least I thought that DiscoveryD

2:05:44was inter-mental to all that kind of stuff

2:05:45that they're doing now with extensions.

2:05:47And you never know, it's brand new what's gonna happen,

2:05:50but this kind of culture, I think,

2:05:51is a better environment for it.

2:05:53I skipped around a little bit, but I did want to say that about the code conference.

2:05:56I thought that was such an interesting thing for him to reveal two weeks before WWDC that

2:06:00they're going to have the native SDK, which I really wasn't sure about.

2:06:06I know a lot of people thought it was a no-brainer, but I thought watch kit itself is still relatively

2:06:12new.

2:06:14I know that they said – on the one hand, I'm a little surprised, and on the other

2:06:19hand, I'm not shocked because they did say it was coming later this year.

2:06:23If it is coming later this year, why not unveil it at WWDC?

2:06:27I think some people think they're going to actually get the SDK, but it wasn't clear

2:06:29to me whether it was just a preview or they're actually be dropping the SDK at the show.

2:06:33Yeah, I don't know.

2:06:34Then it raises all sorts of questions like how do you install developer releases of the

2:06:38OS on your watch and stuff like that.

2:06:41Special developer version of the Apple Watch app for iPhone.

2:06:45That's what I would guess, right?

2:06:46That's what I would think.

2:06:47Well, the whole thing is brand new.

2:06:49They just had the first Apple Watch update very recently, the update to iOS 8.3, which

2:06:54I guess they're calling Apple Watch 1.0.1.

2:06:57And they had instructions for how to do it because it's very different than updating

2:07:00another Apple device.

2:07:01Yeah.

2:07:02Yeah, because it's all, you can't do it on the device itself.

2:07:05It's all through the Watch app on the phone.

2:07:07So you have to put it, you have to make sure it's on the charger, has more than 50% because

2:07:11they're going to turn Wi-Fi on full blast to get the data over.

2:07:14And then you have to, you know, you basically watch it on the phone, then it switches over

2:07:17to the watch and reboot.

2:07:18Interesting procedure. Yeah. Yeah went very well for me and seemingly for everybody me too. Absolutely

2:07:24You have to think that I thought while that happened in the day that it happened that that has to be like such a gigantic

2:07:30Collective held breath for like Kevin Lynch's team. We're like no matter how well they've tested it and how confident they are

2:07:37It's like putting it out in a real world

2:07:40There could be you know, even like that 1% you know, like if 1% of the watches got pricked. It's like that is

2:07:47That's a failure and it's gonna be a PR disaster

2:07:51Especially because of the Iowa the iOS update it goes eight point one point one that only affected

2:07:56iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 plus if you use the Delta file update over the air the full install was fine

2:08:01I'm but that you know for a first generation product the first time that happens. It's not

2:08:06Even though that was terrible

2:08:08It would be even worse if that happened to the watch with the first update

2:08:11Right because the first one is the one where the press would you know be able to jump on it and say you know?

2:08:16First up first watch update bricks watches and yeah, it's like that's that's not a good headline

2:08:21Yeah, especially because you don't have as much access to the watch even that you have to an iPhone

2:08:25I don't know what people would do to start troubleshooting that I think they would I think it's I think a bricked OS on the

2:08:31Phone on a watch has to go to store. I don't think there's any way around it

2:08:36I really don't because with iOS with my iPhone 6 plus

2:08:40I just plugged it into iTunes and restored to the previous version and ended up full upgrade and it was fine

2:08:43But I can't do that with an Apple watch right because I don't see how if it gets bricked and during an OS update

2:08:50How they otherwise they would still have to have some kind of working Bluetooth

2:08:54Or Wi-Fi, I don't know one or the other that the that the phone app could still detect it and do it over the air

2:09:01But I don't know that that's possible

2:09:03The Apple TV it's look like the micro USB port you can plug it into iTunes if you really have to but the port

2:09:08On the Apple watch is sealed away. Yeah the port on the Apple and it's definitely yeah

2:09:12That's a seal that is you know, technically if you want to and there's videos out there of how you can do it

2:09:17But there's no way that that's ever a troubleshooting step for the customers

2:09:20It might be what they do at the store, but it's definitely not ever user-exposable

2:09:25Right

2:09:29And even now they can't and people can't get their hands on them close enough

2:09:34It's amazing. Our watches just ship but I think like you still can't just order a modern buckle for example off Apple.com

2:09:40It still says not available.

2:09:41Right.

2:09:42No, I still keep hearing July.

2:09:44Yeah.

2:09:45Yeah.

2:09:46So, last thing I have on my list is that you and I, the watches that you and I both ordered

2:09:49for our personal watches, both arrived right around the same time about a week and a half

2:09:54ago.

2:09:55Yeah.

2:09:56The space black link bracelet.

2:09:58I love it.

2:09:59I do.

2:10:00I'm very happy with it.

2:10:01I was torn between this one and the stainless, the regular stainless, and that's the one

2:10:07I got for my review unit.

2:10:09So having won both, I am definitely glad that I got this one.

2:10:12I had the stainless steel with Milanese from my review unit, but it was just something

2:10:16about the black and the way that Apple does manufacturing.

2:10:19And I understand why some people would think that the gold might be the height of whatever

2:10:22the Johnny Ive, Mark Newsome powers are with the watch.

2:10:25But for me, this was always the most attractive version just because it's stainless steel,

2:10:29it's DLC.

2:10:30There's so many things going on with it.

2:10:32And the look, I think you're the one who said that it changed slightly between September

2:10:35and March.

2:10:37I'm convinced it did.

2:10:38cannot prove it. I also felt I was in the store yesterday or the day before with my

2:10:44son. He had a hardware problem with his Macbook. And so while we were there, we were looking

2:10:52at the watches. To my eyes, now the one in the store is lower. It's under glass and

2:10:58so lighting could be different. But to me, the demo unit that they have in the store

2:11:02under the glass display looked slightly lighter than mine. Theirs looked more like dark,

2:11:08gray and mine looks more like black but I thought the ones in September

2:11:11definitely looked more like darker gray metal and not black but I could be a

2:11:17mystery remembering I think I have a photo and now looking at it I can't tell

2:11:20if it's the silver or the black one because and I was sure it was a black

2:11:24one but it looks so light compared to this one

2:11:26Sammy that you have it on is that from I'm or I just took an Instagram back when

2:11:32we went to the September event and I went back to look at it and it just

2:11:35looked so light compared to what I have now and it made me doubt whether it was actually

2:11:39the black wash I took a photo of.

2:11:41Yeah, that's what I remember thinking and again I could be wrong and maybe I was just

2:11:46looking at two stainless steel ones but I remember in September looking in the press

2:11:51area and thinking I don't understand why they made both of these because they look almost

2:11:57indistinguishable. They're calling this one stainless and this one space black stainless

2:12:01and they look like the same thing to me. Whereas the one that's wearing, is on my wrist, is

2:12:08truly black. It's as black as the display.

2:12:11It's like what you call blacked out, I think, in a watch.

2:12:14Right.

2:12:15And the DLC to me, the diamond-like coating that they use, is just terrific. I've been

2:12:18wearing it nonstop for a week and a half. It still looks like I took it out of the box.

2:12:22Yeah, that's actually true for me too. Whereas the regular stainless definitely develops

2:12:26scratches on the bracelet within a day or two, which is normal, I should say, for a

2:12:30stainless steel like my you know my own stainless steel watch you know you just

2:12:35get scratches it's you know if you look closely at it you know and whereas this

2:12:39DLC coating really does seem to be keeping it in in like out-of-the-box

2:12:43condition it really is a weird thing to talk about like we talked to you and I

2:12:53talked about this just personally but it to the touch it has it feels hard like

2:12:58metal but it has like almost a rubbery texture like a non-porous texture yeah

2:13:05it's like kryptonian or something I don't have a definition for it yeah I

2:13:08have to say I really like it but I ordered it first thing first thing the

2:13:14seconds after the store went live and it didn't show up until a week and a half

2:13:18ago so that was a long time yeah I think this was one of the last models to

2:13:24actually ship.

2:13:26- Yeah. - Additions I think

2:13:27shipped last week. - Yeah.

2:13:28Do you know anybody who got an addition?

2:13:31Have you seen it?

2:13:32- There was that guy, that kid in China

2:13:34who put two of them on his dog.

2:13:35(laughing)

2:13:37- I saw that Jonathan Geller--

2:13:39- Yeah, Don Geller-- - The Boy Genius Report

2:13:42got one.

2:13:43- Yeah, it looks really nice.

2:13:45(laughing)

2:13:47- I don't know if it's out of turn,

2:13:49but on last week's show, Dan Fromer and I

2:13:50were talking about how we hadn't

2:13:52how he hadn't seen any in the wild.

2:13:57And then after we published the show

2:14:00is when it seemed like they first started shipping.

2:14:03- I don't think you'll see many in the wild.

2:14:10- Dan alerted me to it.

2:14:13That was the first I'd seen that Jonathan Geller

2:14:15had gotten his gold Apple Watch.

2:14:17And his DM to me, Dan Frommer, said,

2:14:20The boy genius wins the golden turd award.

2:14:26I don't blame the kid.

2:14:27If you got the money, go ahead and get it.

2:14:29Have fun with it.

2:14:30I don't blame anybody who wants to spend the money on it.

2:14:31Yeah, I think he just got married last week or the week before, and I think both he and

2:14:35his new bride got them.

2:14:36Well, good for them.

2:14:37Yeah.

2:14:38That's good.

2:14:40Somebody, a listener also texted me that they saw somebody in Grand Central with the rose

2:14:48gold – I forget what band.

2:14:50have been a sport band but a rose gold one with a sport band so you know

2:14:55they're definitely starting to ship and I think you know obviously places like

2:14:58New York City and stuff like that or where you're gonna see him when I was at

2:15:02the I went to the try-ons at the store in Palo Alto and I went for lunch

2:15:06afterwards and there was just a group of people sitting around at one of the

2:15:10tables and they were talking about which version of the edition they were going

2:15:12to get it wasn't a question about which watch it was like the rose gold no the

2:15:16yellow gold with this buckle and that was just their version of the

2:15:18conversation huh interesting I'm sure for some people again, it's like you know people who get

2:15:24$25,000 plane tickets to Singapore or who get $20,000 open to addresses or right?

2:15:29Six or seven star hotel rooms. It's just that's the option that they're gonna choose. Yeah

2:15:34No, I guess not

2:15:39Anything else that you wanted to talk about before we wrap up the show. I think you did a good job

2:15:43All right. It's been a busy week. I will see you soon, right?

2:15:47All right, cuz I guess I should say because the questions about my I am free to fly

2:15:53I've been free to fly for over a month. So I'm

2:15:55Invited to and we'll be at

2:15:58WWDC

2:16:00Likewise be fun. Did they do they didn't do invitations this year like that? No, I just got a phone call

2:16:06Yeah, I think some some people on Twitter tried to say they did but then when I tracked it down

2:16:11I didn't I couldn't find anybody that actually gotten the traditional invitation, right?

2:16:14because I and to my knowledge so nobody has like no we don't get to do the the

2:16:20Kremlin ology of trying to read into the invitation design what the topics are

2:16:25going to be yeah but I think they would have probably just used that logo that

2:16:27they made for WWDC anyway right did that right so it doesn't I just go to

2:16:31Dalrymple site and if he doesn't have a picture there I see him there's no yeah

2:16:34I just figured nobody got one all right Renee everybody can find out more about

2:16:39about Renee Ritchie's work, certainly at iMore.com and on Twitter at @ReneeRitchie,

2:16:49right? @ReneeRitchie?

2:16:50Yep.

2:16:51R-E-N-E-R-I-T-C-H-I-E. The podcast that you're on. If everybody, if you enjoy Renee Ritchie

2:16:59on a podcast, you're in luck because Renee is on 37 podcasts. I'll let you pick up

2:17:04to five of them.

2:17:07We just put debug live a few minutes ago and it's with a guy and Paul kafasas and they

2:17:12have nothing to talk about for about three hours.

2:17:14Where was that from?

2:17:15That's on debug and it's.

2:17:17No but where was it recorded live?

2:17:18Oh we just recorded on Skype.

2:17:20Oh I got you got you got you.

2:17:22It's funny because we did the podcast at all and after an hour it felt like forever and

2:17:27they talked to Horace D'Edea and Steve Trotton Smith and it just an hour felt like an eternity.

2:17:31Three hours with Paul on Skype felt like half an hour.

2:17:34Yeah no that's always the case.

2:17:36When you're on stage, you feel it in a sense that you don't live.

2:17:40So Paul Kefas has never heard of him.

2:17:42Sounds like an interesting –

2:17:43No, Eager Young Go-Getter.

2:17:44Yeah.

2:17:47And anything else?

2:17:48So you got debug.

2:17:49What else?

2:17:50We got Vector, which was on hiatus, but it's coming back right after WWDC.

2:17:53Excellent.

2:17:54And that's – I do the iMore show as well.

2:17:57Probably heard enough Apple stuff for now.

2:17:59Goes without saying.

2:18:00Yeah.

2:18:01All right.

2:18:02And thanks to you.

2:18:03And talk to you soon.

2:18:04Talk to you soon.

2:18:05Talk to you soon.

2:18:06All right.

2:18:07Call that a show.