0:00:00Where do we even start, Ben?
0:00:03Yeah, I was actually kind of optimistic we could just avoid watch discussion.
0:00:09Possibly. I don't know.
0:00:11Well, then that article dropped today.
0:00:13But it's almost like at this point, it's like I just want to come out and then let's talk about it.
0:00:20But no, Apple via wired had to drop a sack of turd on the front porch.
0:00:28So we're recording on Thursday, April 2nd.
0:00:31Show's probably gonna come out tomorrow, Friday.
0:00:33So we're still in this void between,
0:00:39three weeks ago was this event.
0:00:43Three weeks from now is when real people
0:00:47will start getting to watch.
0:00:49We're still a full week away from the watch being
0:00:51in stores for people to look at with their own eyes.
0:00:55Right, like right now, 99.9999% of people
0:01:00who are interested in Apple Watch
0:01:02have not seen one in person.
0:01:04- Right. - Right?
0:01:05I mean, you go out a lot of nines on that.
0:01:08I got it. - No, totally.
0:01:09It's only been at the two events.
0:01:12- Right. - Well, I guess no,
0:01:13'cause people are wearing them in public, I guess.
0:01:15- Combined with employees, but I'm sure though,
0:01:17and even people who glanced it on employees
0:01:20with testing units out in the wild, you can do that,
0:01:24I'm sure that if you say hey is that an Apple watch that they'll say yes, but then I'm sure that this
0:01:28They've got like a standard reply. That's more or less, but I can't show it to you and said they're not allowed to like
0:01:33That's exactly right. They're not allowed to let people examine it
0:01:35But it's
0:01:40Interesting like to me
0:01:41I've and I've been talking about it the last few weeks is why in the world would Apple schedule things this way and I think
0:01:45That the article today is part why I think that they wanted
0:01:51They didn't want the cycle like with a regular revision where it's event
0:01:55next week reviews
0:01:58Two days later go buy it right like this 10-day cycle of most of their you know
0:02:05Which called flagship products, you know new iPhones come out on an event on a?
0:02:10Usually a Monday or Tuesday
0:02:13Then the reviews come out a week later and
0:02:19Then like on a Wednesday, I think usually usually Tuesday or Wednesday
0:02:24And then Fridays are always the day where people who've pre-ordered will get theirs delivered and stores will have them and people can line up
0:02:31It's like a you know
0:02:3310 day cycle 11 day cycle
0:02:35The watch is way off of that and I can only guess that it's because they want to fill that space between last month's event and
0:02:41this month's release with a
0:02:44Drumbeat a steady drumbeat of stuff
0:02:48Promotional stuff, you know, good morning America TV now this and wired
0:02:53So today what tell me what's the article we're talking about?
0:02:58So wired dropped this article
0:03:01entitled iPhone killer the secret history of the Apple watch
0:03:04and
0:03:07David Pierce
0:03:09Wrote an article
0:03:11Where he clearly got clearly, you know blessed by Apple PR. He talked talked to people at Apple. He spent a lot of time
0:03:17with the Human interface designers day.
0:03:21His name is... I can't find his name right.
0:03:23Alan Dye.
0:03:24Alan Dye.
0:03:25And with any of these pieces, and this is kind of the trouble with posting them, is
0:03:36you don't know like to what extent what is coming from Apple, what's coming from the
0:03:41spin that PR is giving him, and then what if it's coming from Pierce.
0:03:46But the kind of overarching theme of the article is that the real goal of the watch is to make you not need your iPhone so much.
0:03:56And it's focused on the notifications and the idea that it will free you from your phone.
0:04:00I would say, I'm going to interrupt and I'm going to subtly tweak that and say that it's not so much that you don't need your iPhone, but that it...
0:04:09it because it's all coming from the phone right it all only works if you're
0:04:15in Bluetooth range of the phone so it's more like a dashboard to your phone
0:04:23well I think it's it's it's more like because they talked about like like
0:04:28winch talked about in the article you talked Kevin Lynch um the idea of like
0:04:32you can be playing with your kids and you can get a notification and you can
0:04:36glance at it realize it's not that important you can keep doing what you're
0:04:38You're not actually pulling out of your pocket and filling with it and all that sort of stuff,
0:04:42which is hardly a new thesis.
0:04:44It's interesting that this seems to be the story that Apple is choosing to tell.
0:04:50But I mean frankly I think that – oh, and by the way, I think that they said at the
0:04:55event that the watch will work on your home Wi-Fi network.
0:05:00But I'm not 100% sure on that.
0:05:04I think that that's only, but it's only, again, I cannot, I'm 100% sure, but I'm 99% sure
0:05:11that all that means though is, I think you're correcting me, that as long as your phone
0:05:15and your watch are on the same Wi-Fi network, even if Bluetooth is out of range.
0:05:22That's correct.
0:05:23So you can set your phone down like on the front door, next to the front door or next
0:05:27to your bed and you can go around the house and your watch will still have full functionality.
0:05:32And the idea there, and it sounds great, is that you can, you know, if you need to charge
0:05:36your phone or whatever, you can do it and, you know, go watch TV two floors away from
0:05:41where it's charging and you're not going to be out of touch from notifications you're
0:05:45expecting.
0:05:46Right, exactly.
0:05:47That's why I just looked it up.
0:05:48That's exactly what it is.
0:05:49So yeah, so I think you're probably right.
0:05:53And if you think about the other, you know, because you have to think of this not in terms
0:05:57of the normal Apple watch but an Apple new product launch and it was the case with particularly
0:06:06the iPhone but also the iPad that there was a big break between the introduction and the
0:06:12actual unveiling of the device.
0:06:14In the case of the iPhone, there was a second event as well.
0:06:16There was …
0:06:17Exactly, exactly. Which was a good three weeks before the phone as well. So, yeah, so I think
0:06:27big picture you're probably right. Frankly, I think this article is a PR disaster.
0:06:35I would not go that far, but I don't think it was good.
0:06:40Yeah, well, I mean the killer line which is already all over Twitter and stuff is this
0:06:46idea that Apple decided they wanted to do a watch and they had to figure out what it
0:06:51was for which kind of confirms the worst suspicions that people had about the watch in a very
0:07:03sort of not subtle way, a very blunt sort of way.
0:07:08And of course, like I said, you don't know what the balance is between Apple PR and what
0:07:12Apple employees said and what Pierce came up with.
0:07:19Where is that line?
0:07:21It sounds bad.
0:07:22Where is that line?
0:07:23I can't find it.
0:07:24Let me find it.
0:07:25It's pretty close to the top.
0:07:28Maybe I don't have the phone.
0:07:29Apple decided to make a watch and only then set out to discover what it might be good
0:07:33for, besides displaying the time.
0:07:36some of these terrible web pages that has like the pictures and the text growing on
0:07:39top of it, which like theoretically looks good, but drives me up the wall.
0:07:43Yeah, it's, you know what? I read it on my phone and it was actually really good. Like
0:07:48the phone is much better on the phone. Yeah. I just say beer and now I'm looking at it
0:07:51in a desktop browser and it's a disaster for reading in my opinion. Yeah. So there's, there's
0:07:56two parts. The first one is that first one, there's a big at the top apple side and make
0:07:59a watch and let itself discover to discover what it might be good for. Um, and then there's
0:08:03There's another line about Johnny Ive.
0:08:05I began dreaming about an Apple Watch just after CEO Steve Jobs death in October 2011
0:08:11and that is basically like insinuating that I've, yeah, I've began a deep investigative
0:08:20horology studying how reading the edition of the sonnet horology became an obsession
0:08:23and the obsession became a product.
0:08:25Along the way the Apple team landed upon the watch's reason to talk.
0:08:28It came down to this and then they get the phone is ruining your life which I definitely
0:08:33presume is is Pierce's kind of summary of it but like it doesn't matter this is
0:08:37on Apple and they're the one that's orchestrated this and like I said the
0:08:43problem is it's really feeding into all the worst or the most pessimistic kind
0:08:48of conceptions about the watch yeah the line is Pierce's it's not a quote yeah
0:08:56here's that this is just prose from Pierce Apple decided to make a watch and
0:09:00only then set out to discover what it might be good for,
0:09:02parentheses, besides, you know, displaying the time.
0:09:05Which is a weird thing to put in parentheses,
0:09:11because who says that it has to,
0:09:16that telling the time has to be a primary function?
0:09:20- Right, and the thing is, is like, what's funny is,
0:09:26The next sentence actually very much fits my feeling about the watch.
0:09:32I don't remember if it says on the podcast, I think I said it to you before.
0:09:37The quote is, "There was a sense that technology was going to move onto the body," says Alan
0:09:42Dye who runs Apple's human interface group.
0:09:45"We felt like the natural place, the place that had historical relevance and significance
0:09:48was the wrist."
0:09:52That's my whole thesis for the watch as well.
0:09:55It's the natural progression of technology.
0:09:59It keeps getting smaller and keeps getting more personal and where do you go from the
0:10:03phone?
0:10:04The watch just seems the obvious place to go and I think the history of technology shows
0:10:11that personal and convenience trumps anything and that actually is the reason to be bullish.
0:10:19The problem is it's a subtle point that requires putting in kind of historical context
0:10:27of technology and the way things move and the way things will go over time like what
0:10:34happens when the watch has cellular radios for example.
0:10:37And either Apple didn't do a good job of setting up that framing for Pierce or he ignored
0:10:45it but read but the fact the matter is I actually think that's exactly right but
0:10:50like but it doesn't sound good that's why it's a PR disaster I have to go meta
0:10:58on the story before we talk about I think there is a lot to talk about here
0:11:03with this feature story but I'd have to go meta first about the story as opposed
0:11:09to the watch and the team and the decisions you know and I'm gonna get
0:11:12this out of the way I feel like I have to clear the decks is that it's
0:11:17complaining about the the way that it's written is petty and catty but that's
0:11:24how we writers are and there's a part of this where I think holy shit I could
0:11:28have done what's better job if they would have given me a full day with
0:11:31Lynch and die and let me talk to them on the record extensively I could have done
0:11:37a much better job and I honest that's that is that's what I as I'm reading
0:11:42the story that's what I thought and I got to the bottom and I thought wow this
0:11:48they picked the wrong guy to give this access to like to me this was very this
0:11:53is a very lightweight article did you ever get one of those there's a
0:11:56steakhouse in Philly that has these great when you get the bread before your
0:12:02meal they're really big and it looks like holy show I could never eat that
0:12:05that's this like muffin type bread thing and then you open it open it up and
0:12:09there's nothing in the inside right you know it's like it's actually not a
0:12:12a lot of bread. It's like some kind of thing that puffs up and like a, you know,
0:12:16like more like a pastry than bread. That's what this article is like to me.
0:12:20It's very empty. Part of it though, here's the thing that I think is part of it, is
0:12:25look at the timing of it. It came out today. It looks like, you know, it's pretty,
0:12:29I don't know how many, how long it is, but it sounds to me like he got this access
0:12:35to to Lynch and Dye sometime after the event last month, but probably a couple
0:12:41weeks ago yeah it wasn't it wasn't yesterday or at least 3500 word yeah so
0:12:47at least or at least a week ago I mean I think it would be at least a week maybe
0:12:51more but some you know but anyway I and who knows maybe he did but it certainly
0:12:56doesn't sound and and and Pierce never said here's the thing Pierce never says
0:12:59in here that he's had the watch that he himself is you know got access to one
0:13:05and it doesn't read like a review in any way. So I'm guessing he didn't. I mean, I'm sure
0:13:12that they had, you know, you know that he got to see demos from the watches that Lynch
0:13:17and Dye and others were wearing and that they had demo units similar to the ones that were
0:13:21at the event, etc. But he didn't get to he doesn't have firsthand experience of what
0:13:25it's like to use the watch. So how do you write this story? Like, so on the one hand,
0:13:29I think I could have done this better. But on the other hand, even if they had offered
0:13:32it to me. I don't see how I could have accepted it unless they let me use the watch for a
0:13:36week first so that I'd have a frame of reference. How do you talk to the two people? Maybe they're
0:13:46the only two sources he has on the record, but Dai is the user interface point person
0:13:51for the watch, or they say for all of Apple's human interface group, but led the team that
0:13:58did the watch interface and Lynch was in charge of the software team that implemented the
0:14:03designs.
0:14:05So I don't understand how you have the best possible interview with those two unless you
0:14:13are familiar with the product that they're talking about.
0:14:18So I understand why Apple might want an article coming out before the pre-orders to keep the
0:14:25hype level up but it's to me a waste of time.
0:14:28So on the one hand, I wish that they'd pick me to write it or ask me to write it but on
0:14:32the other hand, there's no way I would have accepted it unless I had firsthand experience
0:14:34with the watch because I feel like I'm going in blind.
0:14:37>> Yeah, well, that's why and you're right.
0:14:40Saying a PR disaster is a little strong but because who knows how much it's going to break
0:14:44through but this is why I place -- that's one of the many reasons why I place -- I think
0:14:51this article reflects poorly on Apple's communications team.
0:14:56And the reason is a few things.
0:14:59One, the reason you just articulated, right?
0:15:01Like if it is an empty, like one,
0:15:03maybe they did pick the wrong guy.
0:15:04I don't know, I don't know, I don't know David Pierce.
0:15:06He has a great reputation.
0:15:07So, you know, but you're right.
0:15:10He was put in a difficult position
0:15:12by having to write about something that he,
0:15:14you're right, I agree.
0:15:15It seems like he hasn't used.
0:15:17to like, there's a certain art to messaging something and origin stories and things like
0:15:30that and it might be true that Apple decided to do a watch and then figure it out but I
0:15:39would also bet that Apple decided to do a phone and then figure out what it would do
0:15:43as well.
0:15:44The thing about this thing that everyone's latching onto is if you actually think about
0:15:52it, it's not really that controversial.
0:15:57That's how products like this are developed.
0:16:02But that's not how you necessarily tell the story.
0:16:05The way you told the phone story was we all hated our phones so we wanted to do something
0:16:09better.
0:16:10And that was the line and everyone remembers that.
0:16:13remembers Steve Jobs saying that at the keynote.
0:16:16And that line,
0:16:19like there's no line like that about the watch.
0:16:25And now the line that is, especially with this article,
0:16:30gonna kind of become cemented,
0:16:33particularly on the tech press,
0:16:34is that Apple wanted to make a watch.
0:16:37- Yeah, I think I am in complete agreement with you.
0:16:39I don't think it's damning,
0:16:40And I don't think it's, I don't know, whatever the app is,
0:16:44what's the opposite of damning?
0:16:46I don't think it's anything, it's nothing.
0:16:47Because I think you're right, all products start like that.
0:16:50Like, okay, let's try to make a phone
0:16:51and see if it comes out.
0:16:53Or really like the way Apple did it was,
0:16:55let's try to make a phone and they made two phones, right?
0:16:57There was the Fidel team working on the iPod OS version
0:17:02of the phone and there was the four stall Bertrand Cerlet
0:17:08Bertrand Serlet side trying to do the "we can seriously we can strip down OS X to something
0:17:15that will run on this trust us" side and then it was like okay this is the one.
0:17:21Well the thing is with the phone is the phone had a reason to exist and that was that it
0:17:26was a phone and what's funny about the line that we're talking about is like everyone
0:17:33pretends like I don't know why it's in parentheses you're right like the watch does have a
0:17:38reason to exist. It's a watch. Like it tells the time. And now admittedly this is less
0:17:46compelling because everyone needs a phone but clearly over the last several years more
0:17:51and more people have decided they don't need watches. So I appreciate that there's more
0:17:57of a need to create value outside of that to get people who have never worn a watch
0:18:06to start wearing one. That said, it's not like this is Google Glass, for example, where
0:18:14there was no pre-existing kind of thing for it to fit into. There was no framing for it
0:18:22to fit into. It was a completely new-to-the-world thing, whereas the phone was a phone, but
0:18:28more. And this is a watch, but more. And I think this is why Apple -- and this is almost
0:18:33where Apple kind of got it but not quite. That's why Tim Cook, the first thing he said
0:18:37about the phone, it keeps super accurate time, which was kind of weird. But I think that
0:18:42was the idea, was establishing that this is a watch first and foremost. And that's why
0:18:46it's called Apple Watch. It's not called a smartwatch. All that sort of stuff. And I
0:18:51think you see that in here. There is a lot of the imaging about the watch faces and there's
0:18:59about the Mickey Mouse thing in here and the SORR thing.
0:19:03I think Apple was going for that, but there's a lack of clarity in their messaging.
0:19:17I think Apple, the company, is doing very well, but I think this is an area they've
0:19:20struggled with consistently since Steve Jobs passed away.
0:19:26If you think about it, this is the one area that he really did micromanage.
0:19:30He looked over everything and approved everything when it came to messaging and the fear about
0:19:35micromanaging is what happens when the micromanager goes away.
0:19:38Do the people that are left have the skills and ability to come up with stuff of their
0:19:43own or are they just people who implement it?
0:19:46I haven't seen super compelling evidence quite frankly in the last several years, I've written
0:19:50about this several times that Apple really has their,
0:19:54their messaging muscle fully developed.
0:19:56Hold that thought. Cause I, I want to come back to that exact point. Hold that.
0:20:01I want to go back. What's in your hands. Okay.
0:20:06Cause I'm really bad at holding a thought.
0:20:08Cause that's another meta point that I want to make,
0:20:15but to go back to my admitted
0:20:19pettiness complaining about the article and professional jealousy. I'm also, I
0:20:24don't do that all the time. I certainly like the Ian Parker profile of
0:20:28Johnny Ive in The New Yorker from a few, I guess it's a few months ago now, yeah
0:20:32February 23rd, was fantastic. Absolutely tremendous, a piece for the ages. I don't
0:20:40even know that I have a niggle about it. I guess my only niggle was that when he
0:20:43quoted me that he didn't quote the better part of the line.
0:20:48So I will get to your quote soon in this article. I'm not Yeah,
0:20:53exactly. I'm not above you know, I don't every single time
0:20:57somebody gets, you know, access to Apple. I'm not I don't think
0:21:00wow, that should have been me this Ian Parker story for the New
0:21:02Yorker. Fantastic. Also, I've been endless in my praise for
0:21:08the new becoming Steve Jobs book, which I think is
0:21:11fantastic and I recommend to everybody and I think it's I'm not gonna say it's perfect but I think it
0:21:17is excellent truly excellent and a great complement to everything that's especially as a complement to
0:21:23all the other books that have been written about jobs and Apple in you know last few decades so
0:21:29it's not like I always complain about people who write about Apple you know it's not like I'm
0:21:33constantly saying I could have done that better I could have done that better but I just think in
0:21:38case a lot of people could have done this better. Yeah but I mean at the end
0:21:45of the day like I mean I think the the fault for the Isaacson book falls on
0:21:52Jobs. Yeah I do too. Well both I'd say both. Well I mean yes it does but I think
0:21:57but like you know one one can suspect that you know why didn't Jobs pick
0:22:03someone that knew him well and knew Apple well and new technology well. Well
0:22:07And there's a great story in becoming Steve Jobs that Bruce Schlander tells of when he was at the Wall Street Journal
0:22:13One and this was like in this was before he I think it was
0:22:18Before he met Jobs the first time and why he was nervous meeting him the first time in the 80s
0:22:23Was that he had a colleague at the Wall Street Journal who got an interview with Jobs
0:22:28I think while he was still at Apple and he was like Jobs just interrupted the interview and said something to the effect of
0:22:34Do you understand anything at all about this fucking stuff that we're talking about? Do you understand any of this?
0:22:39Just called him out on it, you know
0:22:41And a guy probably didn't and I kind of feel like if you know, I think jobs is probably a really good
0:22:47Judge of whether people understood the stuff that they were talking about. I think it was really hard to bullshit that man
0:22:54I think he had to know that Isaacson just didn't know what the fuck he was talking about with his work
0:22:59Which I you know, I agree the buck stops with jobs
0:23:03Well, that's the same thing here. I mean like
0:23:06this is like I
0:23:08Don't think I don't think this article
0:23:11accomplished what Apple wanted it to accomplish and
0:23:15And I think the buck stops stops with Apple. Yeah, so let's think back so this idea
0:23:21Hey, let's make a watch and we don't know what it's gonna do
0:23:24but let's just set out to do it and that like you said a lot of people are latching on to this as proof that it's
0:23:29the whole thing was doomed in a folly.
0:23:32That's exactly, I think that's exactly what they do with everything.
0:23:34The key is to go back to that line from a year or two ago that "thousand no's for every yes," right?
0:23:41Do well, do a thousand crazy things and the
0:23:44the trick isn't in coming up with the brilliant idea from the outset, right?
0:23:51That's, that is, that's death. If you only, if you just sit there and wait at
0:23:57The idea stage until you have a perfect idea and it's all comes together and then go build it. That's death
0:24:03That's the way you make crap products
0:24:06you have to get your hands dirty get the clay and start molding the clay and start making things and
0:24:12try it and
0:24:14Look at it and think is this anything and then if you think it's something keep going and then even after you've spent a lot
0:24:20Of time on it eventually you've got to say
0:24:22Well, it was worth it. But no, we're not gonna do this and then you know you abandon it
0:24:28Paul Paul throughout posted it posted to like a bunch of like old old
0:24:33stuff that he had
0:24:36today and he posted this amazing kind of like like
0:24:40statue type thing that was like a a a
0:24:44Concept case for Longhorn. It was like these three CDs and a glass case and it was way overdone and out of there
0:24:52But it's funny that you mention that because that was like the classic case of pre-planning.
0:24:58Like Microsoft, "Oh, we're going to do all this stuff.
0:25:00We're going to redo the file system.
0:25:01We're going to redo all user relational databases."
0:25:04All this crazy stuff and they got so focused on this is the idea and now we're going
0:25:09to make it happen that they spun themselves into the ground and took years to recover
0:25:16from that.
0:25:17No, I think you're exactly right.
0:25:20You don't start with an idea.
0:25:21start with a ton of ideas and whittled down.
0:25:24So it's a three year project. And the the idea you know, the
0:25:28people are latching on to the idea that the that the mistake
0:25:31was made back on day one when they said let's make a watch and
0:25:34figure out what what it could be good for. No, if if the watch is
0:25:38a bad product, if it's if this is, you know, or even not, not
0:25:44bad, even if it's just not great. The problem wasn't on day
0:25:47The problem was on day 800, 700, somewhere around there,
0:25:52maybe even 900 when they didn't just say, you know what?
0:25:55No, this isn't good enough.
0:25:57It's not at the beginning stage.
0:25:59It's at that end stage.
0:26:02It's having the discipline of, what do they say, killing your babies.
0:26:06And even though you've invested two years in this,
0:26:08you may have to backtrack a year.
0:26:10And there is some of that in here.
0:26:12There's some of that in the Wired story where they say that they've
0:26:15you know, had to rebuild some of the software
0:26:17from scratch three times.
0:26:18- Yeah, I thought it was interesting.
0:26:21They actually had the same interface as the Pebble Time.
0:26:25- Yes, yes.
0:26:26- Which is really interesting.
0:26:27- That was one of the things I called out.
0:26:29I actually called that out.
0:26:30Let me see here.
0:26:31Here's the quote.
0:26:32"An early version of the software served you information
0:26:36"in a timeline, flowing chronologically
0:26:37"from top to bottom.
0:26:39"That idea never made it off campus.
0:26:41"The ideas that will ship on April 24
0:26:43are focused on streamlining the time it takes a user to figure out whether something is worth
0:26:47paying attention to. So yeah, it sounds, which is, and again, that drove me nuts though that
0:26:52Pierce didn't delve more into that, into their idea, if they told him about that idea, I would
0:26:57have loved to have heard more about it and see just how much it was like the Pebble 2.0 interface.
0:27:02Because that's, that's the Pebble 2.0 is, what is it, up is old and down is,
0:27:09Up is old, the middle is now, and down is the future.
0:27:13Right.
0:27:13And it sounds like the criticism is.
0:27:15And now we're reading into an article that
0:27:18was reading into whatever.
0:27:19But was that-- that leaves everything
0:27:23the same level of priority.
0:27:25And so now you're just scrolling through stuff
0:27:27that may be important, stuff that may not be.
0:27:29And the situation here is, I think,
0:27:33that Apple redid the interface to more surface things in the moment and then either have
0:27:40them go away or have them or have it be more immediate and more reactive.
0:27:47Yeah.
0:27:48Alan Dye is actually an interesting guy.
0:27:50I don't know him personally, but he's active and I knew of him and even though his name
0:27:58probably isn't that well known, is somewhat controversial if you consider the whole, you
0:28:05know, you change in UI direction from iOS 7 and Yosemite to be controversial, because
0:28:12he led that work, you know, working directly under Ive. And it's the fact that his background
0:28:17is graphic design.
0:28:20Yep. I was I was thinking the exact same thing.
0:28:24he came into Apple and Schiller's product marketing group and did things like the packaging,
0:28:31you know, like boxes and stuff like that, and then moved to take a leadership role in
0:28:38user interface design.
0:28:40And the, like I said, I would call it controversy.
0:28:44And people inside Apple, I know, you know, there are people who strongly disagree with
0:28:48the direction.
0:28:50I think that is the criticism of the iOS 7 aesthetic is that it looks fantastic, but
0:28:55there's a difference between looking good in a screenshot and actually being something
0:29:00that you interact with.
0:29:02I think all the criticism is about the affordances, like how do you know what to do, what to press.
0:29:08That's something that I do think is lacking and is still lacking.
0:29:13Even though, no question, iOS 7, I would say it looked a million times better than the
0:29:17previous version, it is harder to use.
0:29:20Yeah, and you know, it's inside the company, like HR wise,
0:29:27there's been turnover, like where there are. And again, I
0:29:34don't think it's complete. It's not like all of the old human
0:29:38interface team was let go, forced out, and they're all, you
0:29:42know, have new jobs elsewhere. And a whole new team came in.
0:29:46But in some ways it's, you know,
0:29:49you know, some of the old people are still there and, you know,
0:29:52it wasn't a complete reshuffling, but it was definitely
0:29:56somewhat of a reshuffling, right?
0:30:00Yup. No, I've heard the same thing.
0:30:02You know that. And, and there's definitely some, you know, uh,
0:30:06user interface people from the other side,
0:30:08the old school people who have left Apple and are at, you know,
0:30:11Google and other places now in, in the Valley, uh,
0:30:15And Di is sort of, I forget the other name.
0:30:19I know there's another person
0:30:20who came from product marketing.
0:30:21You know, and there's some resentment
0:30:25from the people who don't think,
0:30:26who don't agree with the direction.
0:30:28Just as an aside.
0:30:32Let me take a break and then we'll come back
0:30:35to that point that I told you to keep in your hands.
0:30:37Is that all right?
0:30:38I think it's a good time.
0:30:39- It was slipping through my fingers,
0:30:40but with a reminder, I just re-grabbed it.
0:30:42- All right, hold on.
0:30:42Let's take a break and let's thank
0:30:44our first sponsor. It's our good friends at Fracture. You guys know Fracture. I talk about
0:30:51them. They've been sponsoring the show all year long. Great, great service. They print
0:30:58photographs directly on glass. You take pictures with your iPhone, any camera you want. You've
0:31:05got them. They're all on your computer, right? In the old days, all your pictures were analog
0:31:11And it was easy.
0:31:12You could just buy a frame.
0:31:13You put the best ones up.
0:31:14We've got everything digital now.
0:31:16It's great to print your photos.
0:31:19It really is your best photos.
0:31:21You put them up.
0:31:22You get some pictures of your kids or your family and stuff like that.
0:31:25You put them up on the wall.
0:31:28And then all of a sudden, you look at them and my God, everybody's older, right?
0:31:31We've got a picture.
0:31:32I just saw it the other day.
0:31:33It was from my wife's and my wedding.
0:31:37And God, it was a long time ago.
0:31:38and one of her cousins was just a tiny little girl,
0:31:41like preschool age, and now she's like a senior
0:31:44in high school, and it's like, holy shit, look at her.
0:31:47What a great reminder.
0:31:48Printing photos, I can't recommend it enough.
0:31:51Well, Fracture is a great way to do it.
0:31:54You send them your photos, they print them directly on glass,
0:31:58not a piece of paper stuck to glass.
0:32:00I don't even know how they do it,
0:32:01some kind of proprietary secret sauce.
0:32:04They print them right on the glass,
0:32:05just like the way that our iPhones are laminated,
0:32:09the pixels are laminated to the glass.
0:32:11It's a fantastic effect.
0:32:13It really looks great.
0:32:16And it lets you mount them in these amazingly minimal ways,
0:32:20because there's no reason--
0:32:22you don't need to have a border around the frame,
0:32:24because there's no piece of paper that's secured to the glass.
0:32:27So you can get these amazing edge-to-edge--
0:32:29just the glass, just the picture, just the picture,
0:32:32just sitting there.
0:32:34Really, really amazing stuff.
0:32:36Great prices, all sorts of sizes,
0:32:39from really small stuff you can put on your desk
0:32:41to really big, like 23 by 23 square,
0:32:46I forget how big the big rectangle one,
0:32:47something 28 inches, 27 inches, really, really big.
0:32:51And the amazing thing about that too,
0:32:55is it ties into, I think, Apple's campaign
0:32:57with the iPhone 6 camera, the shot with iPhone,
0:33:00with just how good iPhone pictures look blown up big.
0:33:05We know that the iPhone has a good camera,
0:33:08but it's like you still think, well, it's a phone camera,
0:33:10so you can't blow it up real big.
0:33:11It's like, actually you can, there's plenty of pixels.
0:33:13You can go to 20 some inches with photos taken
0:33:16with your iPhone and they look amazing.
0:33:18I mean, some of the ones in the Apple store,
0:33:19they've got blown up to like six feet and they look great.
0:33:22So where do you go to find out more?
0:33:26go to fractureme.com and you can sign up. Is there a code? I think there's a code but
0:33:36I forget it. Well, I'll tell you later about the code. Go there. Go to fractureme.com and
0:33:47get some pictures printed and my thanks to fracture. All right. What was the thought
0:33:55that I had told you to hold in your hands.
0:33:57So the idea is that Apple's messaging
0:34:03hasn't been as crisp as it once was.
0:34:06And I always hate to dip into the since Steve Jobs
0:34:14sort of narrative.
0:34:15But I think this is the one area where Apple does miss him.
0:34:20And I think a reason they miss him
0:34:21is in part because he was so deeply involved in the messaging, approving everything.
0:34:31You cannot overstate how involved he was more than product design.
0:34:38The problem with that is the danger of having a micromanager is while the micromanager is
0:34:43there, presuming he's brilliant as Jobs obviously was particularly when it came to messaging,
0:34:49get great work but once the micromanager is gone everyone underneath the micromanager has just been
0:34:55in pure execution roles. I just got a message from headquarters. Headquarters says the code
0:35:00for fracture it's a daring fireball all one word and when you use that you save 15 percent. So let's
0:35:06screw it let's not fix it in editing let's let it go this will stick in your head because it came
0:35:10mid conversation daring fireball use that code when you buy your fracture and you save 15 percent
0:35:14their prices are already really good. Yes, and here's the big difference. It's another meta angle
0:35:20on this story is in the jobs era. It wasn't just that he controlled the messaging from behind the
0:35:25scenes. It was a strategy of truly severe limited access to any and all Apple employees, including
0:35:36Jobs himself. Yep. And that's one of the things that really sticks out to me reading "Becoming
0:35:43Steve Jobs was just how much more accessible he was personally right up
0:35:52through coming back to Apple in 1997. That it really was a and even maybe even
0:36:02in those first two years you know the first few years there at Apple he was
0:36:06still a lot more accessible to again not any and all not any you know
0:36:12Joe or Jane Charlie reporter from anybody but with hand-picked reporters
0:36:16from you know big-name publications like the Wall Street Journal and Fortune and
0:36:21etc he was pretty accessible and then that that got shut down really and
0:36:27nobody they nobody got to talk to Apple executives and you certainly didn't see
0:36:31this it is clearly a huge strategic change at Apple in terms of just how
0:36:39many people they've made accessible to the press in the run-up to the watch.
0:36:43Huge profile of Johnny Ive in The New Yorker which was clearly months in the
0:36:48making. I mean maybe the better part of 2014 you know with a series of
0:36:53interviews and trips to California. Enormous access that was granted to Ian
0:36:59Parker and the Financial Times had a you know clearly not as detailed and as
0:37:06lengthy as Ian Parker, but pretty pretty good interview with Johnny Ive on the record. There
0:37:11was a Tim Cook profile by Adam Leschinsky in oh boy.
0:37:18Fortune. I don't know.
0:37:20I, I, I've, because they, I swear to God, by the way my brain works, it's like a hashing
0:37:27algorithm and because they both start with F O R and their business publications, I always
0:37:31confuse fortune.
0:37:32It's fortune. It's fortune.
0:37:35That was last week and I think I'm forgetting some.
0:37:40Well, and then after the event last year, there was a bunch too.
0:37:43He was in the Bloomberg Businessweek with that crazy cover.
0:37:48But yeah, it's interesting.
0:37:49I'm actually going back.
0:37:51It's not perfect but I'm searching in Google for the time period up to the actual launch
0:37:57of the watch or the phone, sorry, back in 2007.
0:38:01You would think that any sort of article like this sort of wire article would be somewhere
0:38:05at the top and I can't find anything like it.
0:38:08The only thing I can find are the reviews that dropped a week before.
0:38:12I don't recall, and I think I would have, I don't recall every hearing about who designed
0:38:18the interface for the iPhone.
0:38:21And I don't recall, I mean we knew Johnny Ive.
0:38:24You know in in the jobs era the best that you got outside Apple was just public
0:38:31recognition of who did what
0:38:34Yep, Johnny
0:38:35I would like give a speech like once a year like usually somewhere in Great Britain and like that that that was that was about
0:38:40It and he was already talking in the the videos
0:38:44You know, I think I think I've I've was already, you know, either being interviewed
0:38:49It wasn't really like now he narrates them
0:38:51But then it was like he was the you know, the talking head with the white background, you know talking about what you know
0:38:57The you know meticulous design and you know dropping all those
0:39:00excellently
0:39:02impeccably pronounced adjectives
0:39:04You know, we always know who Schiller is because Schiller is on stage
0:39:08But you just never got behind this, you know, there's never any kind of access like this like talking them to people who designed
0:39:17You know the look and feel of the buttons for iOS one and stuff like that
0:39:21Right.
0:39:22It's all you got was the story that Jobs presented on stage.
0:39:26Right.
0:39:27Yeah.
0:39:28So I think there's a couple of things here.
0:39:29So one, it was super tightly controlled which means like you're not getting a story like
0:39:36this that I think that I suspect it came out with a spin that Apple probably wouldn't
0:39:46prefer.
0:39:48So that's kind of part one.
0:39:51This is kind of the risk of being open.
0:39:53But part two is even the people who are talking don't have a crispness in what they're saying.
0:40:01And I know like, again, the narrative for skeptics in particular is that why does this
0:40:07exist?
0:40:08Again, I actually think this is what's hard about messaging.
0:40:11I actually think what they're saying in this article is exactly right.
0:40:18I don't believe that advancement in technology and computing happens because great people
0:40:24force it into being.
0:40:26I think that there's an ongoing march forward progress of technology and the great companies
0:40:35and the great visionaries like Steve Jobs, their skill is not in birthing things per
0:40:42se.
0:40:43where the wave is going and catching it and being on the cutting edge of it.
0:40:49And that's why you see again and again like there's all these examples of history of like
0:40:53stuff being invented by multiple people at about the same time, right?
0:40:57It's because like it's the time for something and this is my philosophy with technology.
0:41:01My very first post is just actually like stated this and I think it's the time and exactly
0:41:07what he said, the next place is the watch.
0:41:11The problem is that that's not how the press writes stories. The press doesn't write
0:41:15about the big picture contextual place in technology for this advice. That's why I
0:41:20have a job because that's what I write about. But I write to a limited niche audience. What
0:41:25press wants, they want the hero and they want the open and shut story and case. That's
0:41:31why you had Steve Jobs with the iPhone being like, "We all hated our phones so we made
0:41:35a better one. That you can latch onto that. That's not here. It consistently hasn't been
0:41:42here. You think you first saw the iPad. Now you're seeing it now.
0:41:46Dave Asprey I think one of the most interesting things
0:41:48that's come out of this barrage of behind this access and quotes from Apple's leaders,
0:41:56design leaders, I thought one of the most interesting was the Ive quote in the Financial
0:42:00Times article, which overall wasn't a great article, wasn't really, you know, but this line
0:42:05was great, which isn't surprising, but more, you know, I've said exactly what you're saying, but it
0:42:10was great to hear from. We approached the phone with, from this perspective, that we all hated the
0:42:16phones that we had, hated them, and we're approaching the watch as that we love watches. We love the
0:42:24traditional world of mechanical watches, and we're approaching the watch with reverence for what's
0:42:29come before us and that is a totally different approach and it's informed everything we did
0:42:33and it's fascinating to hear that right nothing no kind of trash talk at all about
0:42:39the traditional world of of watches yeah it is interesting but then this article doesn't go into
0:42:46that at all it just says you know johnny i've took a deep dive into horology and i think that
0:42:51was even a mistake because from what i understand it wasn't just that johnny i've went and had like
0:42:55a I'm gonna go become a huge watch expert everybody who worked on the watch like they brought in
0:43:02horological experts and it wasn't just Johnny Ive who studied up on it it was everybody who was
0:43:09involved like the whole team more or less became world-class experts in in the history and you know
0:43:18everything you'd want to know to be a serious you know watch expert yeah and I don't think that
0:43:24that comes across in the story.
0:43:28I do think, and in terms of it being outside Apple's control, I can't help but think
0:43:32that Katie Cotton, wherever she is this morning, is enjoying her morning cup of tea or coffee
0:43:39or whatever she drinks and is just shaking her head.
0:43:42>> I was under the impression she started out with scotch first thing.
0:43:46>> I don't think so.
0:43:48>> No, yeah.
0:43:51I think I agree.
0:43:53And like there and the people got people.
0:43:58People obviously especially journalists, you know, very much disliked that era of Apple
0:44:05from a PR perspective and disliked Katie Cotton by and large.
0:44:10But the fact the matter is Apple didn't Apple's message always got across.
0:44:17Apple wasn't out to me because there was there was nothing else to write about.
0:44:19The only thing they let out was exactly what they wanted to let out.
0:44:24And again, like I said, it's almost like the problem here and the problem with this
0:44:28article and with all these articles is they're too honest.
0:44:32And I appreciate that and you appreciate that.
0:44:36But kind of unfiltered honesty, and this is kind of maybe we can lead into your BOSA remark
0:44:43Like, unfiltered honesty without... it's not a soundbite.
0:44:50It doesn't spread.
0:44:54Or it leaves itself open to all kinds of interpretations.
0:44:59And you kind of see that happening in the hands of someone like Ian Parker,
0:45:06who, remember, took 17,000 words to do it.
0:45:10Like what was it about the link that mattered too?
0:45:13It was all the context that was put around it, right?
0:45:15When you put context around honesty, then it's so fulfilling and it's like you read
0:45:22that article like eating a steak dinner or something, right?
0:45:25But when you have honesty but without deep understanding or context, it leaves itself
0:45:34open to interpretation which I think happened here and so you had Pierce's interpretation
0:45:38on top of it. Two, you get unintended sound bites. I think that's exactly what happened.
0:45:45The sound bite is Apple didn't have a plan for the watch. Again, I think if you look
0:45:49at big picture, a watch is the natural thing to do next and it does tell time.
0:45:54Dave Asprey And I honestly think that that's the better
0:45:56way to approach it is, okay, let's approach it with an empty mind and anything and everything
0:46:00goes. As opposed to, I'm telling you, the worst way to design anything is to have the
0:46:05the whole thing in your head and then go make the thing in your head without
0:46:09constant iteration and revisiting and feeling it as it becomes realer and
0:46:14realer and realer. It's, it's to me,
0:46:16one of the secrets of Apple's success in the last, um, geez,
0:46:20what are we even up to now? 20, 20 years, 15 years. What the hell?
0:46:25How long has it been?
0:46:25Well, the, well, the iPod was 18 years, 14 years.
0:46:29I'm going to say 18 years since 97.
0:46:31That's fair. Uh,
0:46:34is that they don't, you know, it's not like somebody goes off with a notebook, sketches a thing,
0:46:41and draws it all up, and then somebody goes and makes it, which is I think how a lot of technology has been made ever since the outset of technology.
0:46:49Oh, totally. I mean, I think people have this idea that Apple has this grand vision.
0:46:53And one thing that I got a chance to really dig deep into when I was at Apple was looking
0:47:01at how iTunes came about.
0:47:06And what people forget about this, I might have told this story, I don't know if it
0:47:09was to you before, but you remember in 2000 Apple had a big event where they were like,
0:47:16what made Mac the first time around?
0:47:19It was desktop publishing.
0:47:21we think we know what's next and it's going to be movies and iMovie and it was the iMac and it was
0:47:27like we are gonna like you can make home movies and this is what we're gonna be all about.
0:47:32Yeah. And then like nine months later or nine months later or somewhat absurdly short amount
0:47:37of time Steve Jobs gets on stage and gives a completely different vision like could not be
0:47:42more different and that was the digital hub speech so we think the Mac's gonna be a digital hub for
0:47:46all these devices. Yeah and I think he almost admitted that it was a mistake right because
0:47:50it also coincided with with making CD-R drives standard because part of the
0:47:57problem with the the prior max was that you couldn't make music discs right no
0:48:04no I mean they implicitly admitted it was a problem I don't I mean see jobs
0:48:09never want to stand up and say we we screw this up but I mean it was yeah he
0:48:14had a good way of doing he had a good way of doing it without saying you know
0:48:18He was I would say one of his greatest gifts was his way of
0:48:21Backtracking even publicly and somehow making it not look like an admission of error, right?
0:48:28No exactly and you hear this but you hear this is what cook always praised about jobs is how you change his mind all the
0:48:33Time like I mean to think that Apple has a master plan and just executes it is is
0:48:39Not just on misunderstand Apple, but it's to misunderstand how progress happens
0:48:44Yeah, I mean again, this is back to my kind of big meta thesis like you figure out what's next you don't make what's next
0:48:51yeah, and
0:48:53I'm sorry go well and you have to look at what people are doing and and that era you're talking about it
0:48:57It was a it was a dividing point between Mac and PC users
0:49:02Not just in terms of any kind of political affiliation or tribal affiliation, whatever you want to call it
0:49:09But just in terms of what real people were really doing and on the PC side
0:49:14what people were doing was downloading a lot of music from Napster and
0:49:17And then burning CDs, you know, 10 11 12 13 songs, whatever you could fit
0:49:23Or I guess you could fit more
0:49:25I guess you could with mp3s you could if you had an mp3 player that could read them off CD
0:49:29but anyway, people were burning CDs with music whether it was to play them as
0:49:32regular CDs or to play them in
0:49:36MP3 players that could read MP3s off CDs people were doing it and Mac users weren't because they didn't have CDR drives. Yeah
0:49:43My favorite actually one of my favorite jobs quotes comes around this time. I it's it's actually really hard to find
0:49:50I think it's you have to either an archive off. I'll try to find it, you know in a bit
0:49:54But basically he says like I thought we've missed it
0:49:57Like I thought I screwed up like and it was like the most like stark admission of like jobs thing
0:50:03admitting that he thought that he totally blew it.
0:50:06He said they thought they were too late.
0:50:07They thought they were too late to music.
0:50:09They made the wrong focus.
0:50:10They made the wrong bet by focusing on movies.
0:50:12And what's amazing is, I mean, the company internally,
0:50:16in that year or nine months, however long it was,
0:50:19completely transformed.
0:50:20Like, the iMovie guys were like top of the heap, right?
0:50:22Within a matter of weeks, like, completely reorganized,
0:50:26completely deprioritized.
0:50:28iTunes was gonna be, they went out and bought SoundJam
0:50:31And turned around and you think about Apple has this reputation, they do stuff for years
0:50:37and stuff like that.
0:50:38I do believe they do that today but they delivered iTunes and these new Macs in something like
0:50:44nine months and then they hadn't even conceived of the iPod yet.
0:50:50A month later was when Rubenstein went to Japan and visited Toshiba.
0:50:55He was like, "Oh, we have this little hard drive.
0:50:56We don't know what to do with it."
0:50:57He's like, "Oh, I know what we could do with that."
0:50:59And that was in February and they watched the iPod in September.
0:51:03So the iPod was conceived, designed, all that in six months.
0:51:09In 2001.
0:51:10In 2001.
0:51:12And that's not like…
0:51:19Starting with a breakthrough from Toshiba.
0:51:21It is a crazy story.
0:51:23The basic idea there was that standard laptop hard drives were 2.5 inches and Toshiba came
0:51:28up with a 1.8 inch hard drive. And none of the PC makers wanted it because well, and
0:51:36it the 2.5 inch size was fine because the the laptops even the smallest one had to at
0:51:43least the minimum size for the laptop with the keyboard and with a reasonable screen.
0:51:48That inch didn't matter. There was nothing to do with the space saving the space saving
0:51:53made no difference to the design of laptops and laptops were the only devices these other
0:51:58companies had that needed smaller drives, right? You had to go to something as radically smaller
0:52:04as like the first iPods to make to say, here's where you need something that here's where 2.5
0:52:10inches is too too big. You needed it. And nobody else had a device in mind that that needed that.
0:52:17No, it's a it's a wonderful example of how, you know, particularly technology like and this is why
0:52:23This is why technology companies generally, even though you want people that have a wide
0:52:31range of experiences and wearable arts, that sort of stuff, but that's why the technological
0:52:37background is valued because at the end of the day, what is possible and what isn't
0:52:43is governed by the technology.
0:52:45That's a big part of why the iPhone succeeded whereas something like the Newton didn't.
0:52:50The technology just wasn't there whereas the iPhone was on the edge of possible.
0:52:55The processor was just barely fast enough.
0:52:56They did do all kinds of tricks to make it responsive like they did.
0:53:02The touchscreen technology was just getting cheap enough and it's understanding that
0:53:10intersection and having the patience to watch something when it's ready.
0:53:14Quite frankly, if you want to criticize the watch for anything, first of all, I was just
0:53:19Just wait until it actually comes out and you can use it.
0:53:22But two, I think if you look at the arc of personal technology, of course the next thing
0:53:32is going to be the risk.
0:53:33That's my opinion but I think it's pretty clear.
0:53:35The question is when is the right time and the right time will be governed by the available
0:53:40technology.
0:53:43And so the criticism of the watch, if it ends up deserving criticism, is not that it shouldn't
0:53:48exist.
0:53:49Should it exist now or should it exist later?
0:53:52Yeah, and I would say a great example of that is the Newton.
0:53:56And, you know, the Newton was a great product.
0:54:02I really, really appreciated the OS.
0:54:05I thought it was a great design.
0:54:07I think you could quibble about some of the details.
0:54:10I think that the way that they made some of the apps blessed,
0:54:14you know, the way that at the bottom of the screen,
0:54:16there were certain apps that had a permanent location there and you couldn't change them,
0:54:20was questionable. But it was also fixable. They could go forward in a new way. But to me,
0:54:25though, I have talked, I talked about this a long time ago, but to me, the fundamental
0:54:29failure of the Newton was that it came too soon, insofar as there was no wireless networking at
0:54:37the time. And any device of that basic gist form factor needed wireless networking. And I know
0:54:44palm had some success with palm pilots in that era. And there
0:54:48wasn't Wi Fi or cellular networking at the time. But I
0:54:51think if you look at palm success with the palm pilot, and
0:54:54how many they sold it was it was a hit among us, right? I had
0:54:59one I had a hand. I carried around for years and loved it.
0:55:03But there was no way like, my parents were going to get one or
0:55:08my sister, my sister was would never get one. It's, you know,
0:55:11normal people weren't going to get one, right. And it's because
0:55:14it didn't have wireless and because it didn't have wireless it couldn't
0:55:16communicate and you know what people do they communicate that's the fundamental
0:55:20gist of why the internet got popular in the 90s was people communicated with
0:55:26each other until people could communicate with each other they had no
0:55:28interest in in you know PCs the mass market it was only for us nerds yeah and
0:55:35same thing with handhelds and you know that's what doomed the Newton the Newton
0:55:41needed anything that's that you carried around in your hand and each wireless
0:55:45networking because it needs to be a communications device now I think that
0:55:49that it is it is the perfect example and and this is you know this gets to why
0:55:55why Apple has focused on the communication aspect of the watch and
0:56:00you know the drawing and the heart be on sort of stuff I mean what obviously
0:56:03again left to wait and see how it actually works out in real life but
0:56:08But that's why it's a tentpole feature because that's what matters to normal people.
0:56:19I want to talk about the headline for this article.
0:56:23It drives me crazy.
0:56:26This is the Wired article.
0:56:28The headline is "iPhone Killer colon the secret history of the Apple Watch."
0:56:35None of that is true.
0:56:38It is not an iPhone killer.
0:56:43To me, a bad headline is like a bad first impression.
0:56:49Everything has to recover from that.
0:56:52So the article, the headline sets up such a false impression.
0:57:02The watch is useless without your iPhone.
0:57:04Literally.
0:57:05not literally I guess there's certain functionality still works outside the
0:57:09range of your phone but it is fundamentally designed to work as a it
0:57:16is a companion it is supposed to make your life with your phone better that's
0:57:21the gist of it it's not a killer and maybe someday it will be right maybe
0:57:25someday there will be it certainly seems possible with the march of technology
0:57:30that that within a few years whether that's three years four years five years
0:57:34years, six years, that you know, the watch will have its own Wi Fi first, probably
0:57:38a watch could have its own cellular and be the main device and then you would buy something
0:57:45like an iPod touch just to be your four inch five inch screen that connects to the watch.
0:57:52It must have Wi Fi because of the whole it works in your house even when you Yeah, but
0:57:56it doesn't use but like you can't set it up. Let's say it's a like you never log into your
0:58:01home Wi-Fi. It's that whole Wi-Fi back channel thing. You don't type a password into your
0:58:08watch so that when your phone isn't there, it's on the internet and getting notifications.
0:58:14It's only that back channel, I forget what the technical term for it is, but it's that
0:58:17way that Wi-Fi can now have--
0:58:18>>Steve Paulson Wi-Fi Direct, I think.
0:58:19>>Steve Paulson Yeah, something like that. I'm saying that
0:58:23in the future, clearly, it's a natural progression that the watch would have its own Wi-Fi and
0:58:28and then you could leave house without your phone.
0:58:30And if it knows the Starbucks network,
0:58:33it can, when you get there, it'll get notifications
0:58:36and email and stuff like that right there.
0:58:38And then you can send text messages or iMessage,
0:58:40at least not SMS, but you could send messages and emails
0:58:43right from your watch without your phone present.
0:58:46That's coming in the future, surely,
0:58:48unless the product is so unpopular that they stop making it.
0:58:52- Right, well, I mean, LG just watched a watch with LTE.
0:58:55I mean, so it's like it's in the realm of possibility.
0:58:58- Yeah, I think Samsung had,
0:59:00didn't Samsung have one with LTE?
0:59:01- Yeah, they launched it last year.
0:59:02- Yeah, clearly it's possible.
0:59:03It's just a question of when it'll be ready
0:59:05for an Apple caliber product.
0:59:07- Right.
0:59:08- That headline is so bad.
0:59:09It's not an iPhone killer, absolutely not.
0:59:12And then the secret history of the Apple Watch,
0:59:14boy, that is really overstating the hacks tests
0:59:17that he got, right?
0:59:18I mean, how much does,
0:59:21this is not the secret history of the Apple Watch, right?
0:59:24Like if there's a problem with the article,
0:59:26it's that it's so incomplete about the creation story
0:59:28of the Apple Watch.
0:59:29There are very few details about what paths they went down
0:59:35and backtracked on in the three years
0:59:37that they were working on it.
0:59:38- Yeah, no, even the one that was in here
0:59:42that was kind of interesting about the timeline
0:59:44wasn't really fleshed out.
0:59:46- No, it wasn't fleshed out in any degree.
0:59:49So, you know, who has on the, to me,
0:59:51click baby headline from Wired.
0:59:54Compare that to the New Yorker, which the headline is,
0:59:58"The Shape of Things to Come--
1:00:00How an Industrial Designer Became Apple's Greatest Product."
1:00:03And then their title tag for the article,
1:00:05which is a little different, is "Jonathan Ive
1:00:08and the Future of Apple."
1:00:10Totally fair.
1:00:11Not clickbaity at all.
1:00:12And the article got tons of attention.
1:00:14It got all the attention it deserves.
1:00:15Well, welcome to the reality of today's World Wide Web.
1:00:22Yeah.
1:00:23Let's take a break and then the last thing we can do
1:00:25on the article is talk about the quote they have for me.
1:00:30There's another area where I'll complain.
1:00:33- We'll get to the real area while you're grumpy.
1:00:35- Yeah.
1:00:36Let me tell you about a new sponsor, Dash.
1:00:42Dash is really cool.
1:00:44It's a website that lets you quickly create
1:00:47real time dashboards, like a status display.
1:00:53you create a dashboard.
1:00:54It's on the web.
1:00:55You can put it anywhere you can put a website.
1:00:57So you can hook like a computer up to a big TV set
1:01:01or something like that, hang it on your office for your team.
1:01:04And there are dozens of pre-built widgets
1:01:07for services like Google Analytics, GitHub, Twitter.
1:01:12So you can get stuff from Twitter
1:01:14for your company's Twitter account,
1:01:16display it on a big dashboard on a TV
1:01:19or something like that for your team to see.
1:01:20I also hook up with AppFigures.
1:01:23AppFigures is a really cool company that does app analytics.
1:01:27So you can see things like how many reviews your app got,
1:01:32how many sales you had yesterday or this week
1:01:35or month to date and stuff like that.
1:01:37So if you just wanna put up a dashboard
1:01:39that graphs things like your app sales for the last month
1:01:44or last week or whatever,
1:01:45dash and you use app figures already.
1:01:48Well, number one, if you don't use app figures,
1:01:50you should look into it.
1:01:51But then if you use Dash, you can hook up to app figures
1:01:53and get that graphed in a really, really cool way.
1:01:57And you're not limited to their pre-built widgets.
1:02:02They have an API, so you can do custom data.
1:02:04The API you can use to push real-time data
1:02:08or pull it from sources like Google Drive, Dropbox,
1:02:13or pretty much anywhere on the web.
1:02:15So if you can build something that can put data
1:02:18into Dropbox, which is pretty easy.
1:02:21It's pretty much just like writing a file.
1:02:23You can then set up a custom dash widget
1:02:26that'll just log in your Dropbox account
1:02:29and pull the data from there.
1:02:30The pricing model is fairly simple.
1:02:33Free accounts get unlimited public dashboards
1:02:37so that people can share live data with the world,
1:02:40with the community.
1:02:42If you upgrade to Pro,
1:02:43you can get unlimited private dashboards
1:02:47and you can get themes and access to the real-time push
1:02:50API.
1:02:51The real-time push API is only for pro accounts.
1:02:55$10 a month, that's it.
1:02:56Just $10 a month and you can get a pro account.
1:02:59Really cool.
1:03:00So the free account, you can use it just to see how cool it is.
1:03:03Use the free account, see how cool it is.
1:03:06But they're also running a limited time promotion.
1:03:08If you sign up for a free account today at their website--
1:03:12now their website is thedash.com, thedash.com--
1:03:17you'll get one private dashboard in addition
1:03:21to your free accounts unlimited public dashboards.
1:03:24So you can even try the private dashboards for free
1:03:28with the limited time promotion just to see how cool it is.
1:03:31No credit card required
1:03:33and they will keep your private dashboard.
1:03:36You'll keep it forever.
1:03:38So it's not like during the limited time promotion
1:03:40once it's over your private dashboard disappears,
1:03:43you get to keep it.
1:03:45Really cool stuff. So go check them out at the dash dot com. Thanks to them.
1:03:51Do you want to read the part of the first paragraph? It's the first paragraph of
1:03:59David Pierce's story. Sorry about that. I stepped out for a second. Oh, that's all right.
1:04:06Oh, I found the quote, by the way. Fortunately, Isaacson, which the thing about the essence
1:04:13books like half of it was just like rewriting other people's stuff. But he told Fortune
1:04:19and as soon as it in here, "I felt like a dope," he told Fortune. "I thought we
1:04:23had missed it. We had to work hard to catch up." Speaking about music and the fact that
1:04:29they kind of rejiggered everything.
1:04:35I know you share my frustration with this, like the whole mythology about Apple creating
1:04:40these new products. Apple really hasn't created new products. They've created new
1:04:46user interfaces but the idea of a WIMP interface was famously initially came up at Xerox. The
1:04:57idea of an MP3 player wasn't new. The idea of a smartphone wasn't new. The idea of
1:05:01a tablet wasn't really new. What they do though is they do it really well and part
1:05:10of doing it really well is they do it at the right time with the right technology. Again,
1:05:17it goes back to this fundamental myth-making nature of the press. I know this is the case
1:05:23in all arenas. This is the case in politics, this is the case in sports. More and more
1:05:28with sports, I'm a huge sports fan, there's more and more writing about the intricacies
1:05:33of the game and game planning and how people run plays like that, which I love, I dig into.
1:05:39But the sports writing that we had for years and what you still get in places like ESPN
1:05:43and stuff like that, at least on the front page, is the mythological great man or great
1:05:48woman overcoming adversity to win the day when that's actually a story and it's
1:05:57not how products are made.
1:05:59But again, like I said, it's on Apple to create the myth and it's the myth making
1:06:06that is gone.
1:06:07Do you want to read the first paragraph of this iPhone killer story?
1:06:13I guess it's the second paragraph.
1:06:15There is a paragraph marker.
1:06:16No, it's the first.
1:06:18Oh yeah, you're right.
1:06:19Oh, because it's a terrible layout.
1:06:20Yeah.
1:06:21Yeah.
1:06:22Kevin Lynch, I'll skip around a little bit.
1:06:25I'll read the other parts.
1:06:27In early 2013, Kevin Lynch accepted a job offer from Apple.
1:06:30Funny thing about the offer, it didn't say what he would be doing.
1:06:34It was odd that Apple even offered him a job.
1:06:36During his eight years at Adobe, most recently as chief technology officer, he was best known
1:06:40as the only person dumb enough to publicly fight Steve Jobs with the iPhone's lack of
1:06:43support for flash videos, which of course he wasn't the only one, but whatever.
1:06:47When Lynch announced his move, the reaction was immediate.
1:06:50They want this guy?
1:06:51Apple blogger John Gruber called Lynch, "A bozo, a bad hire."
1:06:58New paragraph.
1:07:00I didn't though.
1:07:01I know it's nuanced and it's harsh but when he was hired this was actually
1:07:06exactly two years ago Tuesday 19th of March 21 T 13 this is all in the
1:07:13headline I'll put this in the show notes don't forget exhibit a in the case that
1:07:21newly hired Apple VP of Technology Kevin Lynch is a bozo a bad hire the nuance
1:07:30there is I didn't say he is a bozo a bad hire. I said there is a case to be made
1:07:36that he is and the case to me was you know not that it was good or that it was
1:07:42convincing but you know and I quote from the blog post that he had written at
1:07:48Adobe three years ago talking about flash player and and so here's this is
1:07:54these are words from Kevin Lynch so three years before so 2010 we are now in
1:07:59a verge of delivering Flash Player 10.1 for smartphones with all but one of the top manufacturers.
1:08:05This includes Google's Android, RIMS Blackberry, Nokia, Palm Pre, and many others across form
1:08:13factors including not only smartphones but also tablets, netbooks, and internet connected
1:08:17TVs. Flash in the browser provides a competitive advantage to these devices because it will
1:08:23enable their customers to browse the whole web. So those are Lynch's words, right? That's, you know,
1:08:29he wrote that, or at least he put his name on it. And I wrote, well, how'd that work out? Those
1:08:35companies and platforms are now either a this is and this was two years ago, a out of business,
1:08:41be on the verge of going out of business or C have abandoned flash player entirely.
1:08:47And even include D that the web is kind of on on deathwatch as it is.
1:08:52Yeah, well, at least on mobile and the watch, right?
1:08:55So I stand by it. I'm not, you know, I, but I didn't say he was, I said there was a case to
1:09:05be made that he was. And I know that I'm asking for nuance that the press typically doesn't give,
1:09:13but to me, it's important. Like, it's, you know, clearly, we're going to judge Kevin Lynch on the
1:09:18quality of Apple Watch software and you know he might prove himself that you
1:09:24know okay you know he was dealt a bad hand at Adobe and the argument would be
1:09:29then that he was the loyal company man and that he knew he knew damn well when
1:09:34he wrote it that it was a bad hand and he was loyal to the company
1:09:39but I just I don't like that I don't like having it quoted that I said he was
1:09:43a bozo because I didn't say that and I wouldn't have because I don't feel like
1:09:46you know, to me the nuance is important. It could be that he knew damn well that it was a pile of
1:09:54shit and that he was just, you know, being the right, you know, doing right by the company as
1:09:59he saw fit. I don't know if I've ever... Yes, reading it, I have to be honest. Reading it,
1:10:09yes, you clearly said it is a case. You didn't say he was a bozo. I will say that I very much
1:10:15remembered your post about Kevin Lynch and when I saw the quote in the article
1:10:21a I knew you'd be annoyed but B I thought it was totally fair that's what
1:10:25I remembered you saying so well it's not unfair I wouldn't say unfair but I feel
1:10:29like it misses the nuance and then there's another line from his what he
1:10:34wrote he wrote for example the recent Nexus one from Google will rock with a
1:10:38great experience in the browser with flash player 10.1 and then I said yeah
1:10:43it rocked so hard Google dropped Flash Player support from Android last year
1:10:48with a link to where Google dropped Flash Player support from Android.
1:10:53No, the interesting thing though, I completely shared your skepticism. I mean,
1:10:59I was and remain very critical of the initial watch unveiling, again for the exact same reason,
1:11:07because I just felt the messaging was so poor.
1:11:11And I called out the fact that, boy, the Kevin Lynch part really bothered me.
1:11:15I was bothered when he was hired.
1:11:17Other people were bothered when he was hired and I linked to this post, by the way.
1:11:21And then I said, "For me, at least, his seeming inability to focus or prioritize his
1:11:25software demo confirmed many of those misgivings."
1:11:29So no, I mean, there's no question that he had a ton of skepticism.
1:11:32I will say I thought he crushed the watch event.
1:11:39I thought his was by far the strongest part of the second watch event.
1:11:42I thought he captured the way the watch can transform your life.
1:11:49My case for the watch has always been – again, I take less of the Apple Watch in particular
1:11:56and more of a where is technology going view.
1:11:59One, I think that's the natural next place.
1:12:01Two, I think what's interesting is the phone gave us the ability to interact with anyone
1:12:08and anything anywhere in the world, but what the watch will give us is the chance to interact
1:12:12with everything in our physical environment.
1:12:15That's what Winch demoed.
1:12:16That's more of a longer range vision because a lot of the stuff for that isn't in place
1:12:21yet.
1:12:22That's what he did.
1:12:25That's why I'm bullish because I think that the watch makes sense, like a watch makes
1:12:31sense one and two, Apple deserves the benefit of the doubt.
1:12:36They're three for three right now and if anyone's going to nail it until they prove otherwise,
1:12:41I'll presume they will and that's at the core.
1:12:44That's why I'm bullish and I think Apple and Lynch in particular demonstrated that at the
1:12:49last event but that's not coming across in these articles.
1:12:53One thing I heard when I wrote that, and I don't think I wrote about it, I don't remember if I said
1:13:01it on the show, but after I wrote that, this was back when he was first hired, one thing I heard
1:13:06from, let's say, a well-placed birdie in Cupertino, who would know, a birdie with a position who would
1:13:15know if it were true said to me that in fact Steve Jobs had personally
1:13:21recruited now obviously he was hired if he was hired in 2013 13 two years ago
1:13:28Steve Jobs was already dead but what I heard from one source who would know was
1:13:34that Jobs tried to recruit him years prior I don't know exactly when probably
1:13:402010 or 2011. Probably 2010 thinking about it. And he turned him down specifically because he
1:13:52thought it he owed it to Adobe to stick with them and that it would he he thought it would look that
1:13:58Lynch thought it would really make Adobe look bad if he left for Apple in the middle of the flash
1:14:03in the middle of this flash player stuff. And that he stuck with them out of loyalty with Adobe out
1:14:09out of loyalty. Now I did, you know, I would if Lynch told me
1:14:13that I would take it as fact I heard it from a secondhand
1:14:16source. So take it with a grain of salt. I don't know if that's
1:14:19true, or if it's been, I don't know. But I heard that.
1:14:21I've been thinking he was with my macro media. So presumably,
1:14:25I mean, you've solar. Um, that might have been maybe that was
1:14:29the connection. I don't know.
1:14:29I wonder though, because solar was there so long ago. That's
1:14:33true. That's we're talking mid 90s. So I don't know about
1:14:36that.
1:14:39Here's the thing though about the loyalty angle. To me, the best thing you can say about Lynch is
1:14:42if he believed all that stuff about Flash Player for mobile being a great thing that's going to
1:14:50help everybody but Apple and that Apple should get on it. If he really thought in 2011, or was it
1:15:002010, he wrote that in 2010. If he really thought that Flash Player for mobile was a winner for
1:15:07everybody but Apple and that Apple should get on board and do it. To me that's a
1:15:10damming because it's it was just bad technology and it was really bad for
1:15:15mobile you know. You know I'm I agree and you get to the like the Johnny Ive
1:15:21article and talking about the idea that you know you're not being honest if
1:15:26you're not like being critical. At the same time before I went to Microsoft
1:15:32and when they first unveiled Windows 8 at all things D. This would be 2011. I thought
1:15:39it was awful. I trashed it. I posted myself on Twitter, which unfortunately is no longer
1:15:47there because one of my classmates was like, "Dude, you know you're going to work there,
1:15:50right? Someone might be reading that." People who follow me through will be shocked to hear
1:15:54this. I already got in trouble with my Twitter account previously due to Apple actually.
1:16:00It's a long convoluted story.
1:16:02Not when I was at Apple.
1:16:03It was a school thing.
1:16:07But then I went to Microsoft and I worked on Windows 8.
1:16:13And one of the things is when you're working on it and you're recruiting and I was in charge
1:16:17of – or not in charge – I was one of the people on the team getting developers to build
1:16:21for Windows 8.
1:16:23And you're kind of selling it, right?
1:16:26And there's a certain sense of like, "I can't.
1:16:33Maybe I should just quit if I don't believe in it."
1:16:35But if you're fresh out of school, it's a big opportunity.
1:16:41The team's got reorganized.
1:16:42I was doing a job several levels above me.
1:16:44Ton of responsibility.
1:16:45Had a ton of impact.
1:16:46And there's a kind of subconscious thing like, "Well, maybe I have my doubts, but
1:16:53I'm going to put those in a cover for now and I'm going to work my ass off and do the
1:16:57best I can," which I did.
1:16:59I told close friends.
1:17:01I told them about my misgivings and the issues with it, but boy, as far as it impacted my
1:17:06day-to-day life, my professional life, I was giving it my all.
1:17:10Sure enough, when it came out, all my initial misgivings ended up being totally spot on,
1:17:17But I kind of look back at both humbled for sure and a little ashamed but also appreciative
1:17:25for how you can lose sight of what is true.
1:17:31And yeah, if you're someone like Johnny Iver, arguably Kevin Lynch in his position,
1:17:35you have the luxury of you can step off.
1:17:38But there are so many things in history where people kind of like just go down the wrong
1:17:42path and man I join you in judging him but I also empathize and can sympathize
1:17:50because I I feel bad about it I feel bad that I sucked in at the same time I can
1:17:56appreciate why that happened to me right because and who knows what he was saying
1:18:00inside the Adobe right I mean that's you know what he said publicly I I would not
1:18:06want to put my name on something public that to go that all in on if I was the
1:18:12CTO of Adobe in 2010. There's no way I would have put my name on that publicly,
1:18:17even no matter how loyal I wanted to be to the company. And I realized that as,
1:18:20you know, the CTO of Adobe, he couldn't say anything bad about it at the time publicly,
1:18:26and that Adobe as a whole was going to market it and try to do it. But he had to know it was a bad
1:18:34technology and a really bad fit for mobile devices and processors in terms of performance and just
1:18:41where everything was going.
1:18:43I mean, I took so much flak at the time from certain people
1:18:47with my adamant, my absolute adamant
1:18:49that Flash was terrible for mobile.
1:18:53I've always thought Flash was terrible even for desktop,
1:18:55but it was horrible.
1:18:57And that the best thing that ever happened to the web,
1:19:00the open web, was Apple's refusal
1:19:03to put Flash on these devices.
1:19:05And it single-handedly, in my opinion,
1:19:09got video out of the proprietary
1:19:12and terribly performing Flash Player
1:19:14and into, you know, just, you know,
1:19:19you know, HTML5 compatible, what, H.264 and et cetera,
1:19:24that can be played more efficiently and openly
1:19:28and doesn't require any sort of lock-in
1:19:31to one particular plugin architecture.
1:19:34It's funny, I actually kind of stumbled across this personal website via Wikipedia and it
1:19:40has his kind of, you know, it's in paragraph form but kind of what he's done and there
1:19:45is no mention of the word Flash.
1:19:47Surprisingly, I talked about Adobe as at CTO at Adobe helped define Creative Cloud and
1:19:54Adobe Marketing Cloud.
1:19:57No Flash.
1:19:58Earlier, this is Kevin Lynch from his website. I will put this in the show notes on if I write it down on paper
1:20:03It'll get in
1:20:05Earlier I was a Mac software developer
1:20:07I helped develop the first Mac release of frame maker and then led their core technology team frame technology was also acquired
1:20:13By Adobe prior to this I helped establish one of the first Mac software startups in 1984
1:20:18Framemaker you ever use framemaker. Nope. Ooh great rate software really great software
1:20:25And the fact that it, like Adobe sort of,
1:20:28I guess it's gone now, I guess it's dead.
1:20:29I don't think it ever made the transition to OS X.
1:20:31I think it was, I don't think there was ever
1:20:34a native OS X version of it.
1:20:36And it was strategically subsumed by InDesign.
1:20:40And InDesign was way more, the thing with Framemaker,
1:20:42we used to, I used it at Barebones, where we had the--
1:20:44- It was super focused, right?
1:20:46- Yeah, it wasn't quite as designer-y as I would like.
1:20:50And I used to live and breathe in QuarkXPress.
1:20:54And so, I mean--
1:20:55- Yeah, that's what I knew.
1:20:56I used QuarkXPress.
1:20:57- I would get frustrated by some of the ways
1:21:00that Frame wasn't as designed.
1:21:03Like, Quark, I could make a thing print out
1:21:06with the exact design I wanted, down to,
1:21:09I'm gonna say hundredth of an inch,
1:21:11but it might've even been thousandths of an inch.
1:21:13I mean, and it was spot on accurate.
1:21:15And then it would just, you know,
1:21:16it would come out of the printer exactly everything,
1:21:19positioned exactly where I wanted it.
1:21:21And Framemaker didn't let you position things
1:21:24quite as precisely as Quark.
1:21:26But the thing that Frame had was these book making features
1:21:29where you could select, like for making,
1:21:32here's the canonical example,
1:21:34is to make an index for the book.
1:21:36Is you could select text and say,
1:21:38"I wanna make an index entry right here."
1:21:40And you got precise control over what the entry
1:21:45and the index would be called, where it pointed to.
1:21:48And then as you edited the document and moved things around,
1:21:51it just worked. - Update.
1:21:53Right, you just did not have to worry
1:21:55about your index connections breaking or working.
1:21:58It was brilliant and it really, really,
1:22:00and it's a tricky, tricky problem to solve.
1:22:03Really, I mean, doing a good index for a book
1:22:06is infamously difficult and expensive
1:22:09to get someone to do it.
1:22:11And at the time, the BB edits manual was thick.
1:22:15I mean, it was, I don't know,
1:22:16I was saying it was like 300 pages.
1:22:17And had a great index.
1:22:20And it was so easy, Framemaker made it so easy
1:22:23to keep that index up to date as you went
1:22:26and added new features and stuff.
1:22:28Great, great, great app.
1:22:30So that's a feather in his cap.
1:22:31- Well, we all have our ups and downs.
1:22:40Anyhow, like I said, I was hoping we were not gonna
1:22:44have an Apple Watch an hour, an hour and a half in, so.
1:22:48- I do, it's funny that you brought it up though,
1:22:49'cause that's exactly where I was going
1:22:51with the whole, you know, like with his role
1:22:55with Flash and Mobile is on the one side,
1:22:58he really believed that it was the, you know,
1:23:00could be the future of Mobile,
1:23:02which would indicate that he's a bozo.
1:23:05I don't believe that.
1:23:07I think that my guess is that he knew
1:23:09exactly what the score was,
1:23:11and he was just being loyal to Adobe.
1:23:13That though, like you said, in and of itself is maybe not,
1:23:17loyalty as a general thing is great,
1:23:19But maybe in that case, it's like,
1:23:22I was gonna go there with the Johnny Ive story
1:23:24about Steve Jobs saying,
1:23:26don't just say good things about it, you gotta be honest.
1:23:28If you're not being honest,
1:23:29you're doing a disservice to the people you're talking to.
1:23:33And that it was a disservice to Adobe
1:23:35to let them keep pushing Flash Forward.
1:23:38Because it was--
1:23:40- It's so rare though.
1:23:42I mean, it's, especially in big companies.
1:23:45- Right, and Adobe is doing pretty good.
1:23:47Their last quarter, their results were pretty good.
1:23:50And I'm happy to see that.
1:23:52I think the industry is better with a healthy,
1:23:55strong, successful Adobe as an independent company.
1:23:58- Oh no, I completely agree.
1:23:59And the way they've transitioned their products
1:24:02to being a service basically has been really impressive.
1:24:07No, I completely agree.
1:24:11Actually, they just released a new app a couple hours ago.
1:24:14I don't know if you've seen it yet.
1:24:15Adobe Slate, a visual storytelling app for the iPad where you can basically use photos
1:24:21and text to create a story.
1:24:26It feels so Adobe-esque in the best possible way.
1:24:31It's like letting you weigh stuff out, create something that looks really, really great,
1:24:36to create your own product in a sense.
1:24:38Adobe lets you create products in the best possible sense or when they're at their
1:24:45best. And what's what's fascinating about this is, like,
1:24:50who is arguably if you think about it, who is who if anyone
1:24:54is pushing the envelope in the iPad right now? Like, there
1:24:58there aren't many and wouldn't it be fascinating if kind of
1:25:00like the the the two companies that arguably are producing some
1:25:05of the most compelling iPad apps right now are Adobe and
1:25:07Microsoft. Yeah. Like it's well, and that would like a replay.
1:25:10All right. Yeah, it is a replay to the Mac. Right? Yep. Because
1:25:14let's just say that 84 84 was you know the original Mac was a severely limited machine 85 86
1:25:2287 or so is when I would say the Mac really kind of got up off the ground in terms of the performance of
1:25:30The I don't know if they were up to this 68 0 20 yet, but it was getting close
1:25:37You know the 68 of 20s and the 60
1:25:398 Oh 30s eventually
1:25:43But other and and with other form factors where you could get bigger displays and stuff like that
1:25:49And more RAM and then famously, you know the desktop publishing industry
1:25:54Which was built on the Mac that didn't come from Apple Apple never had a desktop publishing app
1:25:59I mean Apple came out with the laser rider which certainly helped but
1:26:02you know, it was software from Adobe and Quark and
1:26:06Who did page maker Aldis yep
1:26:11that really made that an industry and
1:26:13Again, Microsoft it was apps like Excel Excel started on the Mac right or at least became a hit on up started started on the Mac
1:26:20Microsoft Word
1:26:23was a huge Mac app
1:26:25you know lots of great software from Microsoft for the app for for the Mac in the 80s and
1:26:32Absolutely helped make the Mac for and obviously never got entrenched as a widespread, you know business computer
1:26:38But in places that did have Macs, it was Microsoft software that made it plausible.
1:26:43Yeah, that would be interesting.
1:26:46I know this is a little controversial, but I kind of feel like Apple, to some extent,
1:26:56the way that I feel they've limited the App Store and limited the ability to build sustainable apps,
1:27:01in my estimation, without not having things like trials, not having things like easy upgrades,
1:27:06grades. I kind of feel like that one there's the whole you know
1:27:13commoditize your compliments like cheap apps is good for the platform within
1:27:16within a certain limit. But on the other hand I think they they remembered you
1:27:22know being in that position where it got to the point where the Microsoft and
1:27:26Adobe apps were more important than the Mac. Right. And like Steve Jobs had to
1:27:30like prostrate it prostrate himself said we might have to edit that out.
1:27:37No way.
1:27:38No way are we editing that out.
1:27:40But it's really morbid considering the person talking about it.
1:27:45You know like almost like literally with this massive visage of Bill Gates up on his screen
1:27:52you know Microsoft riding into the rescue and then Adobe when they went to OS X Adobe
1:27:58wouldn't even come over right?
1:27:59they refuse them. Our customers aren't really there. Apple never wanted to be able to hostage
1:28:07to app makers again. It turns out though because no one has really been able to build, especially
1:28:16in the productivity space, a meaningful business on the iPad in particular, it turns out it's
1:28:22the same guys that are there. It's Microsoft and it's Adobe. I just find it fascinating
1:28:27and kind of like the history of this relationship.
1:28:31- Yeah, they were definitely,
1:28:33I think that with,
1:28:36and again, I don't wanna go on a huge digression
1:28:37about circa 1997 industry politics,
1:28:42but it is interesting though.
1:28:45I do think so that, you know,
1:28:46that Adobe and Microsoft, at least especially combined,
1:28:50held far more sway over Apple's future
1:28:53than Apple itself did.
1:28:55- Yep.
1:28:56Maybe they could have gotten by with one and on board and not the other. Either way, but not both.
1:29:02And, you know, and it certainly, you know, exemplified with the original Rhapsody
1:29:08introduction, like with the first in, you know, the first plan that was announced post
1:29:11next reunification, which was a very, it was much, it was more or less
1:29:18the next step operating system without carbon. It was you're going to have to rewrite for cocoa.
1:29:26I don't even know if they'd called it Coco yet, but more or less, you know, it was more or less
1:29:29We're gonna you know, we're gonna do it
1:29:31Put a new Apple style UI on the next step operating system, right? And there was no there's no carbon no carbon and
1:29:39That went over like a lead balloon and more or less like Microsoft said we're not doing that
1:29:45Because it would be a rewrite right and everybody knows, you know going from these existing code bases on the Mac
1:29:53To pure next step would have been it's a complete rewrite
1:29:57It's a all new platform and they were gonna know we're not gonna do it Adobe was like nope
1:30:01Does that's that does not its starter and they Apple announced it, right?
1:30:05I mean and then they had to backtrack and that's for stalls decision
1:30:08It was for Scott for stall who really was the champion of carbon within Apple
1:30:12which I still think is one of the most telling stories that that paints for stall is as a
1:30:21Complex figure, you know, it's there's no way to just say I was a he was a jerk and so they fired him
1:30:27Because if that was true, I mean and he was a guy who you know
1:30:31I think he went to work at next right out of college
1:30:33I mean he'd been in I mean, I think all he'd ever done in professional life was work
1:30:36For for next and it was only platforming new and yet he was the guy spearheading
1:30:41We need to support we need to create this carbon thing to support this legacy stuff, you know
1:30:47Whereas the public the perception from outside Apple was that the next people came in and had no respect for the Mac stuff
1:30:53That was already there and it couldn't be further
1:30:54I mean there might be some people who are like that but forced all exemplifies that it you know
1:30:58There were there was a guy who couldn't have been more pureblood next who was pushing for carbon
1:31:04Which was what got them on board?
1:31:07And I think it was the right decision
1:31:09But I think jobs always resented that they had to do that right that does absolutely right
1:31:13It's the fact that they didn't control their own destiny
1:31:16Yeah, and that is so core to Apple now and the way they think about all their business.
1:31:28Yeah. Let me take a break here and thank our next sponsor of the show, Casper. Have you
1:31:35heard about Casper?
1:31:36I have.
1:31:37Casper is amazing. It sounds amazing. It sounds like something I'm making up. It sounds like
1:31:42Sounds like an April Fool's joke. They're an online retailer of premium mattresses for a fraction of the price
1:31:48Sounds like an April Fool's joke you go online and buy a mattress. No, seriously. This is what you do you go there
1:31:54They've it's truly it's revolution. It's a complete different approach than the standard mattress industry. None of this confusing
1:32:00Product names the regular mattress makers. It's all it's it's seriously it is
1:32:06I don't think it's any exaggeration to call it a cartel. They they they keep prices high they
1:32:11They use all these confusing product names for their mattresses to make it as difficult
1:32:17as possible to comparison shop because when you go to one store and try the Sealy, whatever,
1:32:23whatever, and then you go to another store and try a Sealy, that product isn't even there.
1:32:28That's all got different names, even though it's the exact same mattress and therefore
1:32:31it makes it really, really hard to tell which one is which.
1:32:35Forget about all that nonsense.
1:32:36You go to Casper website and they have one mattress technology.
1:32:40is one-of-a-kind thing it is a hybrid mattress that combines premium latex
1:32:46foam with memory foam I've had one sent to me I've tried it it's really good I
1:32:52don't like pure memory foam mattresses it is not like that at all it's not some
1:32:55kind of thing where you get up off the bed and there's like a corpse shape
1:32:59bedded in the mattress which I I don't like that at all it's not like that at
1:33:03all they use just enough of the memory foam style stuff that it just makes it
1:33:06comfortable while you're laying there. Great mattress, really great. Shows up at your door
1:33:13in a box. It's a big box, but it is not a mattress sized box. This to me is the most
1:33:19amazing part of it. It shows up in a little dorm room refrigerator box. You think there's
1:33:25a queen size mattress in there, a king size mattress? Well, take it up to the room where
1:33:29you want it. Again, they tell you this in the instructions. Do not open the box in another
1:33:33of go to the room, go to your bedroom, you open a box and all of a sudden there's a mattress.
1:33:39It's amazing. Prices are fantastic. Regular mattresses, premium mattresses usually sell
1:33:46for over 1500 bucks, 2000 or more. Casper mattresses are way lower than that. 500 for
1:33:53a twin size mattress, 750 for full, 850 for queen size and just 950 bucks for a king size
1:34:00truly truly great prices here's the thing they totally understand Casper
1:34:06understands that buying a mattress online without ever feeling it without
1:34:10trying it out laying down on it seems weird seems like you know even 950 bucks
1:34:15even though it's a great price who wants to spend a thousand bucks on a mattress
1:34:17that you never even tried so here's the deal it's completely risk-free you don't
1:34:23like it up to a hundred days they'll just if you don't like it just call them
1:34:27up say I don't want it up to a hundred days they'll come and get it from you
1:34:30and take it back and give you your money back it's that simple. Statistically
1:34:33here's the thing they have lying on a bed for four minutes in a showroom has
1:34:36no correlation with your eventual satisfaction to the mattress so the fact
1:34:41that you can try them in retail stores doesn't even matter in terms of finding
1:34:44when you're actually gonna like to sleep and Casper they I forget what their old
1:34:50demo period was but it was less than a hundred days and so few people were
1:34:55sending back their mattresses that they extended it to a hundred days because
1:34:58they were so confident once they had data that people really really love
1:35:01their Casper mattresses so that's everything you need to know oh one more
1:35:07thing they're made in America which I think is pretty cool made right here in
1:35:11the USA so here's what you do go to Casper sleep calm slash talk show Casper
1:35:18caspersleep.com/talkshow and you'll save some bucks and they'll know you came from the show.
1:35:27My thanks to them.
1:35:28If you need a mattress, go check them out at caspersleep.com/talkshow.
1:35:33What else do you want to talk about?
1:35:37What else do I want to talk about?
1:35:41It's been a pretty busy week.
1:35:45I thought the title thing was interesting, the music thing.
1:35:48wrote about that. The Jay-Z streaming service. There's been
1:35:52the Amazon button, which I love you. You were you were debating
1:35:56if it's either if it's genius or stupid. I think it's I think
1:35:59it's absolutely genius.
1:36:00All right, that we've already that's a good lesson. That's
1:36:04let's see if we can tackle some of these quickly. The Jay-Z
1:36:08music service. I think it here's my take. I haven't read in
1:36:12detail. It's a right it's been busy week, my high level take on
1:36:16What's it called?
1:36:18Title T I D a L like like the ocean tide right number one bad name because it's
1:36:24indistinguishable audibly from title
1:36:27Like you're you know, TI TLE bad product name this to me reeks of
1:36:33Everybody well, I don't know that we know
1:36:39But we're pretty close to knowing that beats audio apples beats audio is relaunching soon
1:36:45Under I don't know if it's gonna keep the name
1:36:48Or if it's gonna be rebranded under iTunes or Apple or something like that, you know Apple music who knows
1:36:53But it's coming. I
1:36:56think
1:36:58probably at WWDC
1:37:00And if not soon thereafter, but I think they would love to announce it at WWDC
1:37:07Everybody knows it's coming and it just this title thing from Jay Z sounds like well, let's hurry up and announce something
1:37:15thing beforehand.
1:37:16Mike Santos I mean it is shipping.
1:37:20You can sign up for it right now.
1:37:24But I think it's just pretty much a rebrand of the service that they bought.
1:37:28The thing that I found interesting in relation to the Apple thing was there was, well first
1:37:32off there was some reports at the end of last year, I think originally the New York Post
1:37:35about Jimmy Iovine and Apple trying to sign up exclusives for their service and after
1:37:41After the title launch, there was an interview with Jay Z in Billboard where they asked him
1:37:46specifically about competing with Iovine.
1:37:50He said he's speaking with Billboard about bidding competitively with Iovine behind the
1:37:54scenes of title and beach respective launches.
1:37:57Jay Z said, "Listen, Jimmy, you're Jimmy Iovine.
1:38:01You're an Apple, truthfully you're great.
1:38:03You don't have to do this.
1:38:05I don't have to lose in order for you guys to win.
1:38:06Let's just remember that.
1:38:07Sorry, Jay Z."
1:38:09As long as Iovine is with Apple, Apple will absolutely be out to win and they're not
1:38:17going to play nicely for the good of music.
1:38:19And it's just very convenient that the good of music according to this group happens to
1:38:25be very good for them personally and actually it happens to be good for their labels too.
1:38:32Yeah, I'm skeptical.
1:38:34It doesn't really change anything.
1:38:36it doesn't change anything and if there's not going to be any meaningful
1:38:40exclusives in particular then they're competing on the merits of the product.
1:38:44Presumably they'll have some exclusives from Jay-Z.
1:38:47I don't know if there's going to be others.
1:38:49But they don't. The only exclusive they have at launch that is meaningful is Rihanna's latest single.
1:38:55They don't really have anything else. People have reported they have Taylor Swift's back-head log,
1:39:00but Taylor Swift's back-head log is on Beats right now. It's on RDO. It's on any service
1:39:03that doesn't have a free tier. Her objection was always to the free tier. So no, they don't
1:39:09have any exclusives and they won't have exclusives because to put from a label perspective and
1:39:15frankly from an artist perspective to have an exclusive is dumb. The cost in making music
1:39:21is upfront. It's actually recording the music. Once it's recorded, you want to get it in
1:39:26as many channels as possible because your marginal cost is zero. So you want to sell
1:39:31as many as possible, which means having it everywhere.
1:39:34And so the idea of exclusive, like it just doesn't, like all the, you're having like
1:39:39a mixture of business models and stuff like that, which means that all the left is competing
1:39:43with on the product.
1:39:44Well, you've got to get something in exchange.
1:39:47Look at when Apple landed the Beatles catalog.
1:39:50It clearly, that was in exchange for an enormous marketing campaign.
1:39:56Yep.
1:39:57Right?
1:39:58I mean, Apple was running Beatles ads.
1:39:59Apple was paying for them.
1:40:01It was an enormous campaign to promote it.
1:40:03You have to get something.
1:40:04You can't just say, okay, it's an exclusive
1:40:05and it's only on this thing.
1:40:06You've gotta be getting, to do that,
1:40:08you've gotta be getting something either promotional
1:40:10or cash to make it worthwhile.
1:40:13- Right, and the ones that control it,
1:40:16or especially anything in the back catalog,
1:40:19it's mostly the labels.
1:40:20And the labels' interest is having,
1:40:24they're fine to have a bunch of these guys
1:40:27competing with each other.
1:40:30I mean, that's why I'm long-term bearish on Spotify.
1:40:33I don't like subscription services in general.
1:40:36I think they're a great value for the consumer,
1:40:39but I think they're a bad idea for most artists.
1:40:44But as long as they exist,
1:40:50I don't know, I lost my train of thought.
1:40:52I was getting a little worked up.
1:40:54- Well, here's my thing on Jay-Z's attitude.
1:40:56- That's the 1/3 AM, lost the train of thought.
1:40:58You don't have to win or we don't have to lose for you to win, blah, blah, blah.
1:41:04Compare and contrast to video.
1:41:05With video, Apple doesn't have their own custom content.
1:41:10Apple doesn't have Apple-produced shows.
1:41:13So Apple can treat Netflix and HBO Go and HBO—what's the new one?
1:41:20HBO Now?
1:41:21You know, and Apple doesn't have to—there is no competition with Apple.
1:41:27guess what Apple does sell music and Apple's view on how much of the music
1:41:32out there they should be selling is all of it. Well not just that but this if you
1:41:37know if and when Apple launches a streaming service that's a zero-sum game
1:41:40no one is going to be subscribed to multiple streaming services. Right yeah
1:41:43that's another good example right because people yeah and that's another
1:41:46difference of video where you might in fact I am both a Netflix subscriber and
1:41:51an HBO subscriber because I want to watch both shows that are on exclusive
1:41:56to Netflix and exclusive to HBO.
1:41:58Right, but those are like their vertical business models.
1:42:01They're Apple-like in a way, right?
1:42:03They're using their exclusive content to get you to sign up for their service because you
1:42:07can only get House of Cards on Netflix.
1:42:10You can only get Game of Thrones on HBO.
1:42:13Whereas when it comes to music because it's controlled by the labels and they want to
1:42:18be everywhere, that means all the services end up having pretty much the same stuff.
1:42:25What else was going on this week?
1:42:26Well, along those lines actually, I thought I loved this story because it was so classic
1:42:33Apple.
1:42:34It's funny, I thought we were going to talk about Apple at all.
1:42:36That's the way it goes.
1:42:38There's a story yesterday in Recode about how Apple is going to get for their TV service,
1:42:44they want to get the networks to pay for the streaming.
1:42:49So basically, Apple will sign up all the networks on there and instead of the networks delivering
1:42:55bring their content to Apple and then Apple streams to the Apple TV, they'll stream
1:43:00individually to the Apple TV.
1:43:02The quote here is great.
1:43:03"Eddie Q, who has the company's media efforts and leading negotiations for the
1:43:06streaming service, has told them that Apple feels it should concentrate on what it's
1:43:09best at, creating consumer hardware and software, and leave other tasks like streaming infrastructure
1:43:13for people who specialize in it."
1:43:16This is so great on multiple levels.
1:43:19It's great because one, it's true.
1:43:21Honestly, I don't want Apple focusing on the streaming.
1:43:24I don't want Chinese dubbing.
1:43:27Two, you missed that because you were actually at the first Apple event.
1:43:29Yeah, and the one where I couldn't make it last month was great.
1:43:33The stream was perfect for me.
1:43:35The only complaint I saw of others was that other people seemed to get on one that was
1:43:38a minute or two behind.
1:43:40Yeah, that's the case with streaming always.
1:43:43I watch the NBA a lot, a week past, and I'm always slightly behind Twitter, which sucks
1:43:47because something big will happen and I'll see it first.
1:43:53But anyhow, so this Apple thing…
1:43:54Mad Fientist Wouldn't that be a cool Twitter client feature
1:43:56if you could tell your Twitter client to put you five minutes behind?
1:44:00Dave Asprey It would be fantastic.
1:44:02Oh, yeah, Twitter, we were going to talk about that I think.
1:44:06But the other thing that's great about this is this is what Apple does again and again
1:44:14in industry after industry is because Apple has such a dominant hold on the consumer and
1:44:20the customer relationship, what they end up doing is they get other people to do the really
1:44:26expensive undifferentiated commodity work for them.
1:44:31And then Apple gets to blame them when anything goes wrong.
1:44:33So like with the iPhone, right, what's the actual expensive part of an iPhone?
1:44:38It's the carrier service.
1:44:40Like the amount of money it costs to build up a network is massive.
1:44:47But Apple doesn't do any of that.
1:44:48They get the carriers to do it for them and when the call goes bad and you can't get
1:44:54online, do you blame Apple?
1:44:55No, you blame AT&T.
1:44:56And then they leverage that into getting Verizon to take it because Verizon is losing customers
1:45:00to AT&T.
1:45:03And you see Apple do this again and again.
1:45:06The banks are paying Apple for the privilege of Apple Pay.
1:45:09Why?
1:45:10Because the banks are fearful that people will switch banks just to get access to Apple
1:45:14Pay.
1:45:16Now they're going to do this with this network thing that the networks like are looking for alternative revenue streams
1:45:20they want to get they want to be a part of the Apple thing and
1:45:23Apple you can you can see it like Apple has them reeled in and then I was like, oh by the way
1:45:28We're not so good at this streaming thing. Why don't you take care of that?
1:45:30Guess what? That's that is really expensive and there's no value add
1:45:34It's a pure commodity and Apple is gonna somehow get out of paying it. I think any interesting conversation
1:45:40Email conversation yesterday with our friend Darth of you know
1:45:44the greatest guy on the internet.
1:45:47- Yes, with the greatest avatar.
1:45:50- Yeah.
1:45:51And he was surprised by it because his take was Apple,
1:45:57he was surprised that Apple wouldn't wanna control that.
1:45:59Because, and his take, and I think he's right here,
1:46:01is that if the stream, for somebody's stream
1:46:04on this new Apple TV is shitty,
1:46:06people are gonna blame Apple.
1:46:08Because we may know as insiders that Apple,
1:46:10the way that they've architected this
1:46:11is that you bring your own streaming technology, you know,
1:46:14you know, you bring your own servers and streaming stuff.
1:46:18The consumer isn't going to know that the consumer is going to know.
1:46:21I bought the new Apple TV and I went to whatever it is.
1:46:25I wanted to watch the NBA thing and the stream sucked. Apple TV sucks.
1:46:29But what if every stream works except for that one?
1:46:32Like, well, CBS is patchy, but every other stream works fine.
1:46:36Like, right. Then who is going to get blamed? Right.
1:46:39Maybe then even a consumer would figure out, you know, oh, I guess I should blame the NBA.
1:46:44I mean, we had this we had this conversation on Twitter last night about about this topic.
1:46:51And someone pointed out that if you want to take a cynical view of things, Steve Jobs managed to
1:46:58successfully blame the iPhone 4 on people holding it wrong. So never don't. You can always ask just
1:47:05is how far Apple can get people to admit.
1:47:09Actually, it was our fault.
1:47:10- Yeah.
1:47:11Well, and the other fact, I think it's complicated.
1:47:13The other factor is some of these companies
1:47:15really do do streaming well.
1:47:16Netflix streaming is pretty excellent.
1:47:19MLB has fantastic streaming,
1:47:22and they're so good at it
1:47:24that they're actually white labeling it for a whole bunch.
1:47:28I forget, yeah, I guess they're gonna do HBO, right?
1:47:31- Yeah, they're doing HBO.
1:47:32Yeah, they're doing a whole bunch of folks.
1:47:33Yeah, they've built up some-- - My prediction.
1:47:34I'll make a prediction right here, which is that,
1:47:37and I know that HBO's like go crapped out
1:47:41with Game of Thrones last year.
1:47:43Now that they're backed by MLB,
1:47:45I'm gonna make a prediction that it's gonna go well
1:47:49because I think the MLB stuff is really, really good.
1:47:53The only times I ever have problems
1:47:54are when I'm pretty sure that it's my Comcast connection
1:47:57and everything in the house seems to be pretty slow.
1:48:01MLB, the MLB Technologies Group
1:48:04does streaming amazingly well.
1:48:06It's a really great group.
1:48:08So I think they're going to do well.
1:48:10And I think the problem for some of those, like MLB,
1:48:13I think Apple would have a very difficult time getting MLB
1:48:16on board with a new Apple TV if they couldn't
1:48:19use their own streaming.
1:48:21No, that's interesting.
1:48:21Yeah.
1:48:22I don't see how they would do it.
1:48:24I think they've put such an investment into it,
1:48:26and they trust it so completely that I
1:48:30think they'd have a hard time getting people to do it.
1:48:32And I think it's in the interest of these companies,
1:48:35like Netflix and MLB, to control their own streaming
1:48:37so that they're not tied to Apple's device.
1:48:40That, to me, is the difference, that they're not
1:48:42looking to lock people in.
1:48:45The thing that struck me--
1:48:45Another great point.
1:48:46The other thing that struck me about it,
1:48:47though, is that if this is it and Apple has no--
1:48:50like, I guess what I would kind of hope to see Apple do
1:48:53is if you want to bring your own streaming,
1:48:54bring your own streaming.
1:48:55If you don't, there's a different tier.
1:48:58And maybe Apple would obviously have
1:48:59to take a bigger cut of the revenue
1:49:01because they'd be providing it.
1:49:02But it would be interesting and neat to me
1:49:04if Apple had an option where a channel could
1:49:07use relay on Apple, rely on Apple to provide
1:49:11all the backend infrastructure.
1:49:13So that truly small indie channels could exist
1:49:18for Apple TV, right?
1:49:19Like the App Store.
1:49:20So that three guys could start a, you know,
1:49:25Apple TV channel and without paying, you know,
1:49:28an arm and a leg for a massive backend for streaming the video
1:49:32that all you need is the camera and the production stuff and you
1:49:34send the video to Apple and Apple takes care of everything
1:49:38else.
1:49:38Yeah, I don't think so. And I, I mean, that's, that's, I think a
1:49:44harder job than it than it sounds like, because I mean, how
1:49:48many three guys in a camera are you gonna allow? Yeah, well, I
1:49:51don't know, is it gonna be an app store? But if it's an app
1:49:53store, right, I don't think they've built them all in, I
1:49:56I don't think it's going to be like you turn on the app,
1:50:00like it is now, where you turn on the new Apple TV today,
1:50:04you get all the channels.
1:50:05And I think there's a way you can hide the ones
1:50:07you don't want to see, but they're all there.
1:50:09I'm thinking of more like an app store type thing,
1:50:13where if you wanted to get a channel, you know, like...
1:50:15You ever seen these YouTube videos?
1:50:19You probably have, 'cause I know you're into stuff like this.
1:50:22There's crazy successful YouTubers who do things like,
1:50:26There's a woman who makes a huge amount of money.
1:50:28Nobody even knows what her name is.
1:50:31Unboxing Disney toys.
1:50:33All she does is unbox Disney toys.
1:50:37- I am aware and no, I do not watch.
1:50:40- But no, I don't think you're,
1:50:41I wasn't saying that I think you're a subscriber
1:50:43to her channel.
1:50:44I'm saying it seems to me that you'd be aware
1:50:46that she exists, that she's making a terrific living,
1:50:50doing nothing but unboxing Disney toys.
1:50:53- Yup, and kids love it.
1:50:54kids love it so I'm just saying that
1:50:59why wouldn't Apple maybe want to disrupt Google and have let her make an Apple TV
1:51:07channel and it wouldn't show up by default everybody wouldn't get the woman
1:51:11who unboxes Disney toys channel on their Apple TV but if you wanted it you'd go
1:51:15to the App Store for Apple TV and get it and you could put it on your home page
1:51:19and it wouldn't go through YouTube it would just go through Apple like it is
1:51:24It's always interesting to think about what will the user interface look like.
1:51:27Will you be able to – will it stay kind of like it is and if you get the bundle that
1:51:35people are talking about Apple getting, will you be able to only have the channels/apps
1:51:40that you want to have on there or will there be a specific TV app where – and then it
1:51:46operates more like a traditional TV.
1:51:50If you think about it, why would Apple want to just recreate a broken paradigm?
1:51:55That's interesting.
1:51:56Well, and it also ties back to something you mentioned an hour ago, which was with every
1:52:03major platform, Apple's unveiled a new input device.
1:52:09The remote.
1:52:10Right.
1:52:11Again, they didn't invent the mouse, but they made the mouse mass market.
1:52:16They didn't invent...
1:52:17Well, I guess that's the thing.
1:52:20People get so hung up on the actual invention and by all means, invention is fantastic.
1:52:29But it is just as innovative to bring something to market in a meaningful way.
1:52:34And that's what Apple does.
1:52:35Apple makes markets.
1:52:37They made a market for the mouse.
1:52:39They made a market for all these other devices.
1:52:42Dave Asprey The click wheel, right?
1:52:43Spinning device.
1:52:44Jeff
1:52:44they made the market for MP3 players and they made the market for smartphones.
1:52:47It doesn't mean they made the smartphone, but making the market is more meaningful,
1:52:51it's more profitable, and frankly, it's much more difficult.
1:52:55And they made the market for touch screens.
1:52:57I mean, and again, touch screens have existed for a long, long time, but they made the market
1:53:01to make it a mass market technology.
1:53:03No other product had a mass market touch screen before the iPhone.
1:53:06And that's where everyone benefits because then the cost comes down because it gets scale.
1:53:13So my question is do they have something like that for a new Apple TV?
1:53:16Because the whole up down left right thing is not innovative.
1:53:20I wouldn't be surprised if we're still stuck with up down left right select play.
1:53:23Hopefully, God almighty, please God, not infrared, please Bluetooth, for God's sake.
1:53:30Honestly, if it comes out with a new Apple TV and it's an infrared remote,
1:53:35I don't know. I don't know what I would do. I was going to say I'd sell all my Apple stuff,
1:53:42but I don't own any Apple stock. I'm gonna buy I would buy Apple stock just so I could sell it.
1:53:47I think you're gonna sell your Apple stuff. I'm like that seems a little extreme.
1:53:53No, I wish I owned Apple. It would make me wish I owned Apple stock so I could sell it.
1:53:57It would it would be very upsetting, but I wouldn't be surprised if it's
1:54:02Bluetooth remote and just up down left right select and play. But I would love it if they've
1:54:08got something right. I'd love it if they have something that makes it better. So I don't
1:54:13know.
1:54:14I mean do so I mean the job is out scene and he's now at BuzzFeed you know said reported
1:54:22that there's a new device and actually has an eight chip it has a meaningful amount of
1:54:26storage for apps and an app store. And he pointed out that the Apple TV it says starting
1:54:33at $69, which it also ends at $69 currently.
1:54:38So you're buying the... there's going to be multiple Apple TVs, one of which has an app
1:54:46store and...
1:54:47I don't know.
1:54:48Maybe that's starting it.
1:54:49Maybe we're all reading way too much into the starting at $69 because I don't understand
1:54:52if they come out with a new one, why wouldn't the world when they just get rid of the old
1:54:55one?
1:54:56Why would they even want to make it available if it's running an entire, you know, entirely
1:55:00different platform?
1:55:01Because the $69 point I think is important.
1:55:03And this is a huge mistake that Microsoft made.
1:55:07Microsoft wanted, like the whole reason for the Xbox, the big picture strategic reason
1:55:13was that they wanted to own the living room.
1:55:16And the idea was we'll start with a console and then we'll expand into all these functions
1:55:22so that we own that screen.
1:55:24That was the whole three screens in a cloud sort of thing.
1:55:26The problem with that is they started in the wrong place.
1:55:28They started in a place that meant it had to be expensive.
1:55:31And as long as the Xbox was several hundred dollars, they were never going to crack the
1:55:37mass market.
1:55:39And I think that's a cautionary tale and I think Apple and all the other folks, Google
1:55:48and Amazon and Roku, they're taking the better approach which is delivering kind of a minimum
1:55:54viable product for a device and keeping the price low.
1:55:58then when and if Apple brings this out,
1:56:02and maybe Apple does wanna go up against the consoles,
1:56:05maybe they do want to really dominate that space.
1:56:10To do that, you're gonna have to spend some money,
1:56:15but you don't wanna lose the accessibility
1:56:19in having the core function of the TV
1:56:21accessible to lots of people.
1:56:23So I think the multiple model approach
1:56:25actually makes a ton of sense.
1:56:27maybe maybe I do think there's a chance that they're going there might be some
1:56:32classic Christiansen style disruption potential there again and I know I'm not
1:56:39a gaming expert but I think the a8 is good enough and it's you know it's not
1:56:44gonna render as many you know polygons per frame as you know the ps4 or the
1:56:50Xbox One. But if it's only $99, it might and it might be good enough because it
1:56:58you know in terms of how many pixels are on a 1080 HD screen it's fewer.
1:57:05It's not that many. Right, it's fewer than iOS devices the A8 already handles.
1:57:10So I've actually argued both sides of this. Like I was all about the Apple TV and
1:57:15and its potential previously.
1:57:19And I don't, I, this is why the biggest question to me
1:57:23about the new Apple TV is you were kind of hinting at it.
1:57:26It's the input method.
1:57:28- Right.
1:57:29- I think as long as if the Apple TV
1:57:33does not have a controller, like a proper controller,
1:57:37the traditional consoles are going to be safe.
1:57:41Now their growth might be capped.
1:57:43like they're going to have trouble finding new customers, but they will, the current
1:57:49kind of hardcore gamers will be there and it's a large enough market that the publishers
1:57:56will stay and it will still continue to be a profitable industry.
1:58:00What gets really interesting is if there is this mythical higher level Apple TV and it
1:58:08has a proper controller and I think we're talking more like 199 or 179 maybe, that
1:58:13is where like meaningful disruption becomes a possibility.
1:58:18I don't know, the whole disruption thing, I've written about this a few times, I think
1:58:29the core theory is really compelling and explains a lot of stuff but I've picked nuts with
1:58:36whole modular integrated sort of stuff.
1:58:43One thing that bothers me about that is it's kind of assumed with once a company is disrupted
1:58:50that they're done, like they're doomed, they're going to go out of business.
1:58:53That's actually what Christophson said.
1:58:55I think the way it turns out though and we've seen this play out is that a company -- and
1:59:02And this is partly because the market is just so huge now because the way it has disruption
1:59:06is the lower guy comes in and he's capturing customers that the incumbent doesn't care
1:59:11about and then he expands, captures more of the customers and the incumbent retreats to
1:59:14the high end.
1:59:16And the problem is the high end becomes so small relative to the mass market that everyone,
1:59:20all the supporting players flee the high market and they serve the mass market and then the
1:59:25big incumbent is doomed.
1:59:28The problem is the market is just so huge.
1:59:31Like you need – and we've talked this with Apple, you need to not think about things
1:59:34in relative terms.
1:59:36Apple has X percent of the market.
1:59:38You need to look at absolute numbers.
1:59:39Apple has hundreds of millions of customers, right?
1:59:42It doesn't matter if they have 10 percent of the market or 15 percent of the market
1:59:45if 10 percent of the market is hundreds of millions of people because hundreds of millions
1:59:48of people is plenty to support developers and keep them on board, all that sort of stuff.
1:59:54And this is the fundamental thing people like Henry Blodgett get wrong consistently about
1:59:58their thesis about why the iPhone is doomed.
2:00:02I think this is the case with, this is my thing about consoles is that as long as they're
2:00:08dedicated, there's so many people, even in a percentage basis that's small, there's so
2:00:12many people that play these games, it will remain a space where you can build a nice
2:00:17business and have a nice business.
2:00:19The problem is you're just not going to grow.
2:00:22And I think I'm repeating myself a bit now, but I think that I'm super excited about the
2:00:29Apple TV in particular, mainly because it could go in so many directions.
2:00:34I'll keep you focused until we land this ship.
2:00:37Let me do one last sponsor and then we'll wrap up the show, but it's our good friends
2:00:41at Igloo.
2:00:42Now you guys know Igloo.
2:00:44They're the intranet that you will actually like.
2:00:47You can share news, organize files, coordinate calendars, manage projects, anything you'd
2:00:54want to do with a team, with a company, you can do on the igloo platform.
2:01:00Their latest upgrade, they call it Viking, revolves around documents and how you interact
2:01:05with them, gather feedback and make changes.
2:01:09They've even added the ability to track who has read critical information to keep everyone
2:01:13on the same page.
2:01:14a type of organization where sometimes there's a document that everybody, somebody absolutely
2:01:19needs to see and sign off on and get approval, you can do that and get proof of it like more
2:01:24or less like a red receipt for an iMessage or an email. You can get that for a document
2:01:29now in igloo. Very important for some organizations. If you've been holding off on igloo for that,
2:01:36now they've got it. Just like red receipts for email really, but less annoying because
2:01:40have a good interface for it. If your company has a legacy Internet that looks
2:01:45like it was built in the 90s and it probably was built in the 90s, you should
2:01:50give igloo a try. They've got all this all sorts of other cool stuff like
2:01:56Twitter like micro blogs imagine having a private Twitter like service just for
2:02:00your team totally private their stuff their their service everything works on
2:02:06any kind of device it's all web-based so you can use it on big desktop machines
2:02:10machine works great on phones, tablets, anything like that, and really customizable.
2:02:18Free to use for up to 10 people, so you can try it out, find out everything you want to
2:02:23know about it before you start paying for more than 10 people to use it.
2:02:27You can sign up at – here's the website igloosoftware.com/tts, the initials for this
2:02:35show, the talk show, igloosoftware.com/tts.
2:02:38sign up there you get the free trial use that URL with / TTS and they'll know you came from
2:02:45the show really great give it a try it's worth going to the website if you've never done
2:02:51it just to check out the sandwich videos that they have to promote the site they're really
2:02:56funny from our good friend Adam Lisa gores company so go there just to watch the sandwich
2:03:02videos if you haven't done it but sign up if you have any kind of need for an internet
2:03:05for your team. Really great stuff. And I thank igloo for their continued support of Daring
2:03:11Fireball. What else you want to talk about, Ben? Want to talk about basketball? Or should
2:03:17we talk about maybe we should Wisconsin man final final final for I'm rooting for him.
2:03:22That's my team in the final four. But that's that's not we better not get into that. We've
2:03:26got real stuff to talk about. What about me? You want to do meerkat and periscope? Sure.
2:03:30I've I told my my members that I was gonna be writing about it like three weeks ago
2:03:36And I still haven't written. I wrote a couple of pieces about basically I said that you know
2:03:39Meerkat is almost certainly doomed
2:03:43Would you would you call this the the coincidental rise of the two another one of those things like you mentioned before like just in
2:03:49the history of science, you know like going all the way back to Newton and Leibniz with calculus being you know
2:03:55developed pretty much simultaneously separately by the two geniuses
2:04:00Is this another one of those things where like Meerkat and Periscope more or less arrived
2:04:03at the same time? It's just like
2:04:07everything was in the right, everything got to the right place at the right time?
2:04:10No, absolutely. I mean the idea of live streaming is in a new one and there's, there are services that are out there that I've
2:04:17had some success. Like YouNow, I think is actually has, is a lot bigger than people realize. Um, but
2:04:22the idea, having the connectivity everywhere, having LTE everywhere, like it gets really dodgy on 3G.
2:04:28So you need LTE you need the quality cameras you need the App Store you need the Twitter, you know the Twitter graph
2:04:36You also need I think you need data
2:04:39packages that with sufficient
2:04:42Gigabytes per month that people feel comfortable. Yeah, it's consuming and sharing
2:04:47Video streaming video content like this, which is it it's it's part of your LTE
2:04:54LTE in itself isn't enough if it's not affordable enough that people feel like they can just
2:05:00sit there and watch people making these videos.
2:05:03Dave Asprey Right. Exactly. Exactly. I think it's a
2:05:06great example of the time was right for this product to emerge and it just so happened
2:05:13to emerge within two weeks of each other.
2:05:15Dave I described it as a science fiction scenario.
2:05:19There's some pushback from people like that. They're like, "Oh, come on. Live streaming
2:05:22isn't new. It's not new. So, you know, what is science fiction about this? To me, the
2:05:26part that science fiction is the universality, the way that anybody can do it. It's all free.
2:05:36You don't have to pay for anything other than what you've already paid for, which is your
2:05:39iPhone and your data plan.
2:05:41plan. To me it's the size. It's this 4.5 inch device that is doing this. The sort of equipment
2:05:52that was needed to do just video much less. You could live stream 20 years ago. You needed
2:05:59a big ass camera. You needed a microwave connection. You needed a van with a massive satellite
2:06:04dish on top of it. You're doing exactly that with a piece of glass in your hand.
2:06:10I think the thing, and I think the thing that is the most science fictiony in terms of if
2:06:14you went back 20 years and described periscoping to somebody 20 years ago, or let alone longer,
2:06:22but the most amazing aspect of it to me is that the device for producing and the device
2:06:30for consuming is exact and the app, it's the same app and device for being a producer as
2:06:37a consumer. You use your iPhone with Periscope or Meerkat to create a stream or to consume it.
2:06:46And that to me is the magic. And it's so easy to overlook because it seems so obvious once you see
2:06:51it in action. But that's revolutionary that the right like your TV set is not a TV studio.
2:06:58Yeah, it is anything but it doesn't even have it. You know, it's just unrelated, right? Because
2:07:03This gives much more of the sense of it being like a portal, right?
2:07:06It's like you're in one side and out the other.
2:07:10Whereas, whereas previous last streaming, it's unidirectional.
2:07:14Like it's coming from the studio to your TV.
2:07:17There wasn't the sense, even if, even if a mirror camera scope is one way,
2:07:21the container is such that it's a bi-directional relationship.
2:07:26It is crazy to me.
2:07:28I think it's so exciting and funny that it's the same device for somebody, you know, like somebody with
2:07:3510,000 followers, you know 10 20 30 thousand followers who gets hundreds and hundreds
2:07:41Maybe a thousand people watching their streams
2:07:42They're using an iPhone with
2:07:45Periscope to send that and all the people watching it are using an iPhone with Periscope to watch it
2:07:50It's exact same device in the exact same app
2:07:54Yeah, I mean it's it real like I I haven't like I'm with you. I mean the first so I really
2:07:59III was at the Apple the the watch event
2:08:03The second one that you missed and tonight
2:08:07I yeah
2:08:07And I started and that was when I really started using it was I was using it in line saying outside like before the event side
2:08:13I was saying I saw you I saw you on the stream. I saw you standing up you had a seat
2:08:18I think you're in like the third row and I saw you standing up on your phone and I text you guys like you're on
2:08:23the stream and you're on your phone and you're like, "I'm meerkatting."
2:08:26Yeah.
2:08:27It was mind-blowing.
2:08:29You look up there and you see you had 350 people watching you.
2:08:33There are 350 people all over the world.
2:08:37You write a website.
2:08:38It's already amazing.
2:08:39You can look at your analytics and you see someone logging on from Brazil or Russia or
2:08:44wherever it may be.
2:08:46That's already mind-blowing enough, but the immediacy of knowing someone is sitting somewhere
2:08:52are 6,000 miles away from me and they are seeing exactly what I'm seeing because I am
2:08:59holding up this device. It's an incredible experience.
2:09:04Dave Asprey The truth is though, I'm with you, I think
2:09:07Meerkat is fucked. I think it was obvious even before Periscope came out. I'm not an
2:09:13expert on social media. I'm a nerd and I follow this stuff. Meerkat caught my attention. I
2:09:20I was like, oh, this is something and I see this.
2:09:22But then Twitter immediately got word out
2:09:25that they had purchased,
2:09:26'cause here too, before Meerkat came out,
2:09:28the fact that Twitter had bought Periscope
2:09:30was not public knowledge.
2:09:32- Right.
2:09:33- They bought Periscope,
2:09:35and I don't know if it's on the record
2:09:36or if it's just rumored, but for $100 million,
2:09:38which if it's true, I think was rivals,
2:09:42I think it's gonna end up rivaling
2:09:45Facebook's purchase of Instagram for $1 billion
2:09:48as one of the great acquisitions of this decade.
2:09:51I really do. - No, absolutely.
2:09:53- I think if they got Periscope for 100 million,
2:09:55it's gonna go down as a great acquisition
2:09:59and exhibit A in the case that Dick Costello
2:10:02is actually a pretty good CEO, I think.
2:10:05- No, I agree.
2:10:07The reason why Meerkat is screwed is because
2:10:10what is so power, like what,
2:10:13the thing about Twitter is,
2:10:16Twitter is so many things to so many different people in so many different scenarios, right?
2:10:21That's what makes it so great and that's what makes it so hard to use for a new user in
2:10:26particular.
2:10:27But for sure, one of the core values of Twitter is real time, right?
2:10:32When something happens, you go to Twitter, you can search, you can get the reaction.
2:10:35We talked about it just a second ago with watching a game and how annoying it is when
2:10:38Twitter is like five seconds ahead.
2:10:40That's how real time it is.
2:10:41Twitter is faster than my stream of the game and it's frustrating.
2:10:48And so both Meerkat and Twitter are - and the reason why Meerkat was a threat to Twitter
2:10:53and why it's a good thing they had acquired Periscope was that it was unbundling one of
2:10:59the core features of Twitter because real time in text is one thing but real time in
2:11:05video is another thing entirely in a dramatically more powerful way.
2:11:10So you have someone tweeting about like a fire going on or the plane crash.
2:11:15Like I was tweeting when the plane crash happened in Taiwan a few weeks ago.
2:11:18Built the gas explosion in New York last week.
2:11:22Right. Yeah, no, exactly.
2:11:24Which happened to be like the day Periscope came out.
2:11:26So, so, so helpful.
2:11:27That has a that that is like
2:11:32that has to be Twitter because Twitter has Twitter has to has to own that.
2:11:37Yeah. And yeah, that's why America had a screwed
2:11:40because they're so fundamentally tied to what Twitter is.
2:11:43Like Twitter already owns the real time space,
2:11:47which means all the people that you wanna find
2:11:49or follow in real time are already on Twitter,
2:11:52which means you have to have access to the Twitter graph
2:11:54to, and they now don't.
2:11:57- So for anybody, and I know Periscope,
2:11:59and there's, it just seems like the writing's already on,
2:12:01we don't even need to analyze it
2:12:03because Meerkat has really dropped precipitously
2:12:06in the App Store rankings, and Periscope is at the top,
2:12:10Apple is promoting it heavily
2:12:12and I think
2:12:14You can't beat the first party integration with Twitter, right?
2:12:19no matter even if meerkat had been allowed to keep the
2:12:22The access to the social graph that they had and that Twitter pulled a couple weeks ago
2:12:27Even if they kept that they wouldn't have helped them because it's not
2:12:31Being a third party thing built on top of Twitter is never going to be as integrated as a first party thing within Twitter
2:12:37Second of all, the technology is clearly better on Periscope side just technologically it is much closer to live
2:12:43And for anybody out there who hasn't used either of these apps
2:12:46The basic just you should get Periscope. I in my opinion
2:12:51I think you could probably skip meerkat at this point, but get Periscope get your username. I think it's really interesting
2:12:56I'm about to I've still got notifications on I'm probably gonna turn that off soon because it's
2:13:00Starting to they just announced they did a post yesterday saying that oops. Sorry
2:13:05We overly which in this annoys me like you could tell from meerkat the way notifications needed to be and they still shipped it wrong
2:13:13That worries me. But like yeah, because the problem is notifications are essential though
2:13:18Yeah, it's like that's how you like following it on Twitter. You're always late
2:13:22You have to get the notification and that's how you catch the live stream. Yeah, obviously periscope has has
2:13:28It keeps the streams around for a period of time
2:13:31But if you want to be the live it so you don't turn it off at the same time the way it's implemented now
2:13:36It's it's overwhelming. I'm gonna I'm gonna start periscoping me talking to you right now. So it'll be very metal. Haha. That'd be great
2:13:42That would be great
2:13:47I've thought about people keep asking me am I gonna start periscoping while I broadcast the the show
2:13:52I don't think so because I don't see how I could get the audio from both sides through and also I don't
2:13:58You know, I don't know that I want to be on camera, but I maybe do it briefly
2:14:02I'm doing talking about I'm probably I'm like wearing like whatever I was I'm here
2:14:08I was actually temporarily like number four number five on the meerkat leaderboard. I saw that I um
2:14:13but but then I saw while talking about periscope on the talk show with
2:14:20Gruber so
2:14:24meta and I'm gonna post it to Twitter if you haven't used it starting the broadcast the gist of it is is that you
2:14:30You know
2:14:31You get a one-way the producers video is there and you hear them you see them you see either see them or you see what?
2:14:37They're seeing if they have the camera pointed around the other way here
2:14:39It goes 20 20 26 people 28 people 29 people 32 people and they can come by people and then you can see their comments
2:14:47Now they can't you know, it's obviously not audio because that would be a mess
2:14:50Oh man, John, the hearts are flowing in. People are pleased with our stream.
2:14:57But the latency on Meerkat was at least 30 seconds on the comments, in my experience.
2:15:06I'm not, as somebody broadcasting, but watching. And it really made for a slightly awkward
2:15:10experience where if the person who was on, if it was like a Q&A type thing, like, "Hey, ask me
2:15:14anything about what you, you know.
2:15:16- Yep, I did that.
2:15:18I didn't realize that the lag was so bad,
2:15:21and they're like, "Oh, no one's asking questions."
2:15:22- Right. - It's gonna block off.
2:15:23And then like, I'd go on Twitter,
2:15:24and there was like five gazillion questions there.
2:15:26- Right, and it's way behind.
2:15:28Whereas Periscope, it seems like it's really minimal.
2:15:30It's seconds behind.
2:15:32And you see a question, and if it's a good question,
2:15:34you see the person who's hosting the video.
2:15:36- We'll test it right now.
2:15:38Can someone type in the comments, type John.
2:15:42Someone's asking how's oh yeah everyone okay stop stop that's enough.
2:15:53People want to know how your eye is.
2:15:55It's you know as steady as she goes I mean it's not.
2:15:57This is very awkward when people listen to the podcast it's gonna be it's gonna be totally
2:16:01out of place.
2:16:02Yeah.
2:16:03I'm enough.
2:16:04People do want to know you know.
2:16:08You know according to the doctors. It's as good as could be hoped at this point
2:16:12My vision is not good out of the eye, but it's you know better than being blind
2:16:17Long story short, but I it's not I'm not expected. There's no expectation that that my vision will be
2:16:24That it's as good as it will be yet. It's you know should take months before
2:16:30It settles in and I still have the gas still have the gas bubble in there. So it's still relatively
2:16:36It's you know impossible to judge. Are you gonna be able to go to WDC or oh, yeah, definitely. Well, I
2:16:42Can't say definitely but it's supposed to be
2:16:45Six to ten weeks for the gas bubble to fully dissolve and it was February
2:16:5124 so four weeks was March 24. So now it's five weeks
2:16:56So it should be sometime within the month of April. I don't think I can't book travel
2:17:02There's no way I would book a flight in April
2:17:04I think by May I should be good and by the end of May for sure because that's way past ten weeks and it's definitely
2:17:10Shrinking so that's you know
2:17:13But I have to I need to go there and they need to look in my eye and verify that the gas bubble is completely
2:17:19Gone before I can get on an airplane. I can't just think that's the wise that's a wise course of action
2:17:23Yeah
2:17:24Although I think that if it was there but truly tiny like the last day or two I could do it because you know
2:17:29The whole thing is that you go on if you if I went on an airplane and the air pressure changed the gas bubble
2:17:34would greatly increase in size. But if it was tiny, even if it greatly increased in size,
2:17:38it would make a difference. The issue is if it's of any reasonable size, it would increase
2:17:43big enough that it would, you know, be... Did I say this on the show? I read a book about it. I
2:17:48read like an actual... I found like through Google, an actual textbook for retinal surgeons. It was,
2:17:54you know, like a medical textbook that Google had indexed. So I read about this procedure that I had.
2:17:58And it goes into great detail about this restriction that things you need to do after this is you need to emphasize to your patient that you cannot get on an airplane until you have permission until it's gone.
2:18:10And it goes into all this detail about how it would be excruciatingly painful if you did this. And it's all this stuff about how much pain you would be in.
2:18:17And then just one sentence at the end is that it would also likely render them blind.
2:18:21Permanently blind.
2:18:23And I'm like, the pain would be bad.
2:18:25It would be terrible to be in pain for a flight,
2:18:27but it's the permanent blindness that to me
2:18:30is a better selling point on, hey, take this serious.
2:18:33- Right, exactly.
2:18:35I mean, I fortunately haven't had anything in my eye,
2:18:38although I was warned the last time I saw the eye doctor.
2:18:40They told me all the symptoms of a retinol tear
2:18:45'cause I'm apparently at risk.
2:18:47So now you have me super paranoid.
2:18:49But I once took a flight where I didn't even know
2:18:52before I got in the flight apparently had something in my sinuses.
2:18:55Oh.
2:18:56Yeah.
2:18:57And it was excruciating.
2:19:00Like I was like, at one point, the flight attendants finally let me lay on the floor
2:19:05in the back of the plane.
2:19:06Like I was, it was unbelievable.
2:19:10And then the plane descended, I was totally fine.
2:19:12Yeah.
2:19:13Oh man.
2:19:14So I can imagine that being in my eye.
2:19:16It sounds pretty crappy.
2:19:18So the interesting thing about Periscope and Meerkat is we got totally sidestreamed by
2:19:25me filming.
2:19:26Sorry about that.
2:19:27This is a good example to not live stream your show.
2:19:33But I think it really highlights what is valuable about Twitter the company.
2:19:41And what's interesting is I'm not sure that the most valuable part of Twitter is
2:19:45like the Twitter app, like the actual looking comments and stuff like that.
2:19:49What's valuable about Twitter, what makes Twitter unique and what makes Twitter potentially
2:19:54super valuable when it comes to advertising is it's the Twitter graph and because the
2:19:59Twitter graph is what I'm interested in, right?
2:20:02Facebook, it's who I know.
2:20:04Google, it's what I'm searching for.
2:20:06Pinterest is interesting.
2:20:07It's kind of like what I aspire to but Twitter, like it's what I'm interested in.
2:20:11The people that I follow, the things that I search for, the folks that I interact with,
2:20:14You can really, if an advertiser wants to understand Ben Thompson, he just needs to
2:20:19understand my Twitter account and he will know me better than any other service will
2:20:24know me.
2:20:25And what's interesting about that is the key then for Twitter is getting people to have
2:20:32a Twitter account and to kind of build up that profile.
2:20:36And what's funny is they belatedly have the pieces.
2:20:42So the Twitter app is interesting in a way that helps understand me.
2:20:46I'm not sure it's the best place to monetize.
2:20:48It monetizes pretty well, but I think that's where they acquired a company that lets them
2:20:54put ads in other apps and stuff like that.
2:20:58Crap, it's escaping me.
2:21:01But I think it's really compelling to imagine a Twitter ad network that is fueled by knowing
2:21:11what I'm interested in. And then the ideally you would have lots of apps that the key to
2:21:17Twitter is not Twitter the app but it's Twitter the login. And so imagine a world where you
2:21:22had lots of apps that use the Twitter credential, use the Twitter login. So you could have both
2:21:27Meerkat and Periscope and they would not be a part of Twitter. They would fight it out.
2:21:30They would both log in with Twitter and they would necessarily like it with Twitter because
2:21:33if you that's the graph that matters for a live app. And then Twitter can monetize through
2:21:39their ad network. It's this alternative vision for Twitter that they kind of went
2:21:45away from back in the day when they shut off all the third-party clients and they decided
2:21:50no, we're going to own our platform and we're going to be an ad displaying platform.
2:21:55It's like a what if. Twitter back in 2012 when they walked out all the Twitter clients,
2:22:03they made the decision that we're going to monetize by showing ads on the Twitter
2:22:07app. And I think in retrospect that might have been or it was probably a suboptimal
2:22:14decision because what was valuable was not the app, it was the identity. And in some
2:22:20respects Twitter the app is like a minimum viable product of what you can do with someone's
2:22:25identity. But if you know what someone's interested in like you can build stuff like
2:22:29Periscope, you can build stuff like MiraK, you can build stuff like the Twitter app,
2:22:33can build all kinds of interesting stuff and it's too bad that didn't happen.
2:22:38And like Twitter now kind of had to buy Periscope.
2:22:41Yeah, I started a Periscope here.
2:22:44I just saw it on Twitter, yeah.
2:22:46Yeah and everybody wanted me to talk but I couldn't because you were calling.
2:22:51Ben was going on, that's why I wasn't talking.
2:22:55How many people are we up to here?
2:22:57394.
2:22:58Holy shit.
2:22:59I don't know about these hearts.
2:23:00I think the hearts thing is...
2:23:02I don't know.
2:23:03it but I think it's I don't know I think it's weird and I don't understand how the hell you
2:23:06how do you know when you're sending hearts it's like you hold your finger down and no you just
2:23:09touch the screen you touch the screen well how do you know which ones are yours though you don't
2:23:14yeah and what's the I don't understand the point of it I don't understand it
2:23:17you don't feel you don't feel loved and appreciated no I don't I don't know I feel like I feel like
2:23:28seeing 495 people on makes me feel appreciated or something but I don't
2:23:34know the hearts I don't get yeah and that's the other thing that's the other
2:23:38thing that's interesting is um is the is people are saying that everybody gets a
2:23:43color but I've got 563 people here there are not 563 colors right and how do I
2:23:50know who's who I don't know well the other thing the other thing the the one
2:23:55I think that's like the reservoir dogs.
2:23:57It's like the reservoir dogs thing with Quentin Tarantino didn't want to be Mr. Brown.
2:24:01That's like Mr. Shit.
2:24:03There is an aspect of Paris.
2:24:05It's the main issue you see how it plays out because right now it certainly benefits.
2:24:08I mean you and I, you have what, you know, hundreds of, 200,000 followers, 300,000 followers.
2:24:14I have 20,000 or something like that.
2:24:16And so we immediately have like an audience that's like, "Oh, I'm going to be a big fan of Paris."
2:24:22So, we immediately have an audience when we launch Periscope.
2:24:26I ended up getting like 350 when I was just doing it.
2:24:31What will be interesting, and you can see with the disaster thing or celebrities using
2:24:35it for sure, what's interesting about that is I think the most interesting part is getting
2:24:41the people to log on to watch that.
2:24:43I'm very interested to see what use this ends up having for normal people, like people who
2:24:50have 50 followers or 100 followers, like what ends up being compelling for them?
2:24:55If anything, or maybe it's just going to be there's going to be observers and watchers for the most
2:25:00part. So this is so meta. So the people who are watching on Periscope, don't hear your side. And
2:25:09you're the whole point that Ben just made that only I can hear here in my headphones, is that
2:25:13it's going to be interesting to see what the what the use case for this really is. Is that fair?
2:25:19That's a fair summary. And I do think... Especially for normal people without a lot of followers.
2:25:24Even though there's 1... There's 1,300 people watching right now, I do think that
2:25:28the answer to that is not going to be watching one side of a podcast. I think if I could somehow
2:25:36patch through your audio, this would be interesting. You know, 'cause some people do like listening
2:25:44along to live episodes of shows but yeah one side is definitely not enough so hello to everybody out
2:25:51there but I'm gonna I'm gonna end this because I don't think this is very compelling all right
2:25:57swipe down to stop all right adios everybody thank you maybe I'll do more of these later
2:26:02what's what's unfortunate is it was probably it's rough to watch these on your one side it's gonna
2:26:07be really rough to listen to because we're gonna just be kind of stumbling all over the place I
2:26:12I probably have to delete this.
2:26:13It's probably, 'cause it probably has,
2:26:16what do you call it?
2:26:21Isn't there some kind of thing
2:26:22where the location is on by default?
2:26:24- Yeah.
2:26:26- I think I probably, yeah.
2:26:27- Oh, I don't know.
2:26:29I think I have mine disabled.
2:26:30- I don't know if I did or not.
2:26:31How do I know?
2:26:32- I have no idea.
2:26:34Let me see, or let me look at my periscope
2:26:37and see if your stream's there.
2:26:39Did you?
2:26:42Well, maybe not though because it seems like--
2:26:45no, it seems like location sharing was off.
2:26:47I just-- yeah, I think it was off.
2:26:49I heard some-- maybe that was Meerkat, I don't know.
2:26:51Or maybe they changed it in an update to the app.
2:26:55But I didn't do anything.
2:26:56I forgot to even check.
2:26:58But now that I try to do a new broadcast,
2:26:59the location indicator defaults to off.
2:27:02So I think it's actually pretty good.
2:27:05I wouldn't mind if there was a setting that let you do it
2:27:07and it was just broad.
2:27:11It just told you what city I was in.
2:27:13I don't want my--
2:27:14- Yeah, that was another update that they're gonna do,
2:27:16is they're making the location less exact.
2:27:18- Yeah, maybe, I don't know.
2:27:19But anyway, I don't know.
2:27:20Do you see my thing?
2:27:21I don't see where it even went.
2:27:22How do I access my videos?
2:27:24Well, anyway, this doesn't make for a good show.
2:27:28But I'll check it out after the show.
2:27:32What else?
2:27:33Anything else you wanna talk about?
2:27:35- No, we're two and a half hours in,
2:27:37and I think the last 30 minutes got pretty choppy, so.
2:27:41No, that's probably pretty, that's a good way to end it.
2:27:43All right, who do you like in the NCAA tournament?
2:27:46- Well, with my heart or with my head?
2:27:48- Well, give me both picks.
2:27:50- Well, obviously Wisconsin for both.
2:27:51- All right.
2:27:52- No, I mean, Kentucky, it's obviously--
2:27:54- Did you go to University of Wisconsin?
2:27:56- Yes, I did.
2:27:57- Wow, so it's not just that you're,
2:27:58I knew you were there, I didn't know if you were,
2:28:00if you were just local or if you actually went to the school.
2:28:02Well, that's terribly exciting.
2:28:04- Yes, and so--
2:28:05- Do you like their chances?
2:28:07- I think we have a decent chance.
2:28:09I mean, I think the great thing about this team
2:28:11is one that they made it last year. So I mean they watched Kentucky on a last second shot.
2:28:17So like this team doesn't get frazzled like they just like Arizona like punched him in
2:28:24the mouth in the first half of that game last week and it looked really bad. But it's one
2:28:29of those teams you watch them and you're never worried because you know they're going to
2:28:32like get it together and they're going to respond. And I think that's that's a good
2:28:38thing going against this undefeated juggernaut super team that they're not going to be intimidated
2:28:44and they have a couple guys that are real matchup problems. I think I think Kaminsky
2:28:48the player of the year, the biggest player of the year, probably national player of the
2:28:51year. I think he's going to struggle frankly. The Collie Stein on Kentucky is is probably
2:28:58a perfect matchup for him. But I think you know Decker at the small forward spot definitely
2:29:05has the potential to be a matchup issue.
2:29:07And yeah, I think if any team can beat Kentucky,
2:29:09it's Wisconsin.
2:29:10I think Kentucky should be favored, but I like their chances.
2:29:12- Yeah, what's the spread?
2:29:13Have you looked at the spread?
2:29:15- I haven't.
2:29:16- I thought last week's weekend was an absolutely great
2:29:20weekend of college basketball.
2:29:22And there were so many crazy tight games,
2:29:24but almost every one came down to which, to me,
2:29:26which team kept their shit together down the stretch.
2:29:30- Yep.
2:29:31- I mean, poor Gonzaga, I was rooting for him.
2:29:34I hate Duke, so I was rooting for Gonzaga, but they didn't score a point in the last six and a half minutes
2:29:38Which is atrocious, you know, I mean that's I mean, how can you win a basketball game a tight basketball game?
2:29:43Well, you don't score in the last six minutes
2:29:45I mean, you know Duke plays good defense, but man that was bad and they took some bad shots
2:29:49And I thought with Louisville who played
2:29:53Wait who to lose you can stay yeah, Michigan State. Oh my god
2:29:58the guys on the foul line look like they were ready to die and and they're
2:30:03It was like the clang of the ball hitting the hoop. It was like ear splitting
2:30:07I mean it was right horrible and then for Notre Dame then - yeah another one
2:30:11I mean just like slicing them apart and then the last the last two minutes just like
2:30:16Degenerating into pounding the ball at the top of the key. Um, there was a guy I forget is I don't remember their names
2:30:21but there was a guy with like
2:30:23In the last minute and Louisville was still in it and a guard came down and they had all the time in the world
2:30:29Down by one and a guard forced up a bad shot and I thought Rick Pitino was I thought he was gonna have an aneurysm
2:30:36It was like he he put up a shot
2:30:39That was like you've only if you've only got six seconds to go, you know coast to coast
2:30:43All right, you know wasn't maybe he could have gotten a better shot, but you can't blame him
2:30:47You only had six shot six seconds. This was like 40 seconds to go and
2:30:51Or maybe a minute or so, you know, but it was it was outside the you know
2:30:55You couldn't run the shot clock all the way down
2:30:57But you had all the time you needed to get a good shot and run and play and this guy came down and just forced
2:31:02Up a shot and it you know, which to me is like a telltale sign of a team that cracked under pressure
2:31:06Yeah, no, I'm sure so I don't know I think I think you're right I like Wisconsin's chances
2:31:13I mean, let's face it Kentucky's the best team and I think that you know
2:31:15They're gonna be tough to beat but I think Wisconsin can do it because they've got the size
2:31:20My hope is that we either see and I hate to say this because God Almighty I hate Duke
2:31:25But I feel like the two most interesting final matchups would be the all Big Ten matchup of Michigan State versus Wisconsin
2:31:31Or one of the most underrated like rivalries in the country like it right
2:31:36It's pretty intense and has been for 10 15 years now and and you know, what a what a feather in the cap to the Big Ten
2:31:43or
2:31:45Kentucky versus Duke and I hate I don't like either Kentucky or Duke, but I mean, let's face it
2:31:49They're probably you know, they're they're too, you know top tier, you know, that would be the killer
2:31:54Those would be the two killer championships to me
2:31:56But anyway, I'm Wisconsin Duke and Wisconsin Duke did play this year actually Duke won, but it was a great game
2:32:02So it wouldn't be a bad consolation prize
2:32:04By the way, the Kentucky opened as a six-point favorite, but it's moved to five. Hmm. So they are five-point favorites
2:32:10Yeah, right. Well anyway, I'll be rooting for Wisconsin. I love the underdog and
2:32:13Either was yeah, I could I would root for either of Wisconsin or Michigan State anybody but Duke or Kentucky for God's sake
2:32:21Ben Thompson, thank you for your time for anybody who doesn't know Ben is over in Taipei and he's on exactly 12 hours difference from
2:32:28The East Coast us so it is to 2 20 in the morning in Taipei and Ben is a very busy man
2:32:33running strip strip tech array
2:32:36Very good
2:32:39strip tech array calm
2:32:41Which is a fantastic site and he's killing it on a daily basis with his newsletter for members
2:32:47It is some of the best and smartest money you could ever spend to stay informed about all the stuff
2:32:54We're talking about and more on a daily basis. I mean, I don't know how many words you're putting out a week, but it is impressive
2:33:01Really really? I mean, I mean do you have secretly have somebody working for you?
2:33:05No, it's it's all me. I have my my secret ability is to write
2:33:10Really fast and hopefully mostly cogently. So yeah, it's about 10 to 11 thousand words a week
2:33:15It's I see it's one of those things that I appreciate that's a lot. Wow, that is great though
2:33:19I mean, I appreciate it on two levels is on one level. I appreciate just reading it and then the
2:33:24Professional level I'm like, holy shit. He's putting out a lot of words. I better start writing more. So anyway, thanks
2:33:31Go check go check your stuff out at strategic calm and your Twitter account is
2:33:35Monk bent MLN KB ENT and that's definitely worth a follow as well. So my thanks to you anything else you want to plug
2:33:44Exponent.fm. That's the podcast I do with James Olen.
2:33:49Yes, of course. Duh. So check that out. That is also worth listening to. So if you enjoyed Ben's--
2:33:55what's the word for your voice? I'll call it sultry. Your sultry tones, dulcet tones. The dulcet tones
2:34:03of Ben's voice and his insight. Definitely check that out too. So my thanks to you. Go to sleep.
2:34:10Get some sleep. Sounds good. Thanks, Ben.
2:34:14them.