Podcast Search

The Talk Show

104: ‘2014 Year in Review’ With Guest Rene Ritchie

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00So where to start I say we let's just talk about it Renee Richie. Let's talk year in review. Yes

0:00:04Where better to start than January?

0:00:07It was a quiet beginning of the year

0:00:10It was so quiet that people were again pounding the doom drums that Apple wasn't doing anything anymore

0:00:14Yeah, and maybe even before we get into details like January

0:00:18Maybe just take that and and use it like to me like the year in review as a whole like with zoom out big level

0:00:26What are we gonna look back on this year? I?

0:00:28Would say that this was the year where?

0:00:31that

0:00:33That sense that that Apple can't do it anymore since got rubbed away slowly, but surely over the course of the year I

0:00:40agree, I think it built up to I think it reached a crescendo because you know people kept making a big deal of Tim Cook saying

0:00:46We'd be releasing new product character categories throughout the year and then as the months ticked on they seem to get more and more

0:00:52personally angry with him

0:00:55Yeah, I think so too and I think because it the the naysayers

0:00:59Have been the down on cook overall. Anyway, like that's the root of their naysaying

0:01:06Yeah, we go over the short term at least they wanted him fired. They said he was destroying Apple

0:01:12They kept comparing him to Steve Jobs in a very negative way and looking back at a nine-site. It's absolutely ridiculous

0:01:18Yeah, I was just thinking that

0:01:21Before we started recording. I was thinking that I don't think anybody called for that in 2014

0:01:26But at least in 2013 you can find several instances of

0:01:29ostensibly serious

0:01:31Business writers calling either for Tim Cook to be outright fired or at least calling for Apple's board to like

0:01:39Rain him in and and have him rejigger the company

0:01:42We did have haunted Empire. I think earlier this year which sort of showed that Apple was completely doomed without Steve Jobs

0:01:48Yeah, I think it's I think that's sort of the publication of haunted Empire

0:01:53Her first name her last name is Kane or yeah, you could you could Tori. Yeah, you could Tori Kane

0:02:01not sure I

0:02:03Would say that the publication of her book haunted Empire was sort of the I was gonna say high watermark

0:02:08But I would say maybe the low low watermark of Apple nay saying yeah

0:02:13When did that come in that was probably February?

0:02:17Yeah, it must it was when I was with Jason snow, which means it had to be around Macworld time or something

0:02:22Yeah, which was I think February. Yeah last year

0:02:25Yeah, and I could not help but get the feeling when I read it that it was rushed into publication

0:02:33because I kind of felt like at least if she didn't know at least her the

0:02:39editorial team at her publisher

0:02:41Sort of got the sense that that the time was kicking on that sort of doom and gloom

0:02:46Which was interesting because you could probably make an argument for a haunted empire, but

0:02:52they didn't even make an attempt to make it.

0:02:53It was a bunch of pages strung together and nothing resembling a book.

0:02:57Yeah, and a couple of anecdotes to string it together.

0:03:01I do think, though, like if there is—I think it was a very bad book, and I think it's already

0:03:07showing its age, and I think it's only going to look worse as the years go on.

0:03:12But on the other hand, I'm kind of glad the book exists because it captures that sort

0:03:18of like post Steve Jobs pre-Apple Watch negative Apple perspective.

0:03:28Like in hindsight, you know what I mean?

0:03:30It's like these years, they always blur together and four or five years from now, it's like

0:03:35this whole, you know, period in between where the Apple Watch was announced and when we

0:03:40we actually have it and we have generation two and three

0:03:43by four or five years from now.

0:03:45It'll just be a blink, we'll snap our fingers

0:03:49and think about this interim period.

0:03:51But I feel like her book sort of captures

0:03:53that epitomizes that sort of negative viewpoint.

0:03:56- Yeah, I think that's absolutely true.

0:03:58We do tend to look back sort of the rose colored glasses,

0:04:00the original iPhone, the original iPad,

0:04:02they couldn't do anywhere nearly what they could do now,

0:04:04but we still look at them with fondness.

0:04:06We think of current software updates as being buggy,

0:04:08But you look back at iOS, you know, two point something

0:04:11when everyone was complaining it couldn't attach

0:04:13to a 3G network and Apple was rushing out a fix.

0:04:15We have this weird sort of affection, I think,

0:04:18for the past.

0:04:18- Yeah.

0:04:19So I do, I think that's 2014 in a nutshell,

0:04:24is that the world at large and the conventional wisdom

0:04:28about Apple and about Tim Cook's leadership

0:04:30have caught up to reality, which is that the company was,

0:04:35you know, Steve Jobs left the company in very good shape

0:04:38and in very good hands

0:04:41and it took about

0:04:42two or three years it seems for the mainstream financial media to sort of

0:04:47concede that point

0:04:48i would say that almost a full three years right because he died in twenty

0:04:52eleven

0:04:53i would say it was a full three years

0:04:55and tim cook i mean the company has never been worth more the stock prices

0:04:58through the roof they've introduced not only the apple watch but apple pay

0:05:02they have an A8X processor they have a 5k iMac

0:05:05And you still look at Fortune contributor networks sometimes

0:05:08and you just wanna know how they get published.

0:05:11- Yeah.

0:05:12All right, you're in review, January.

0:05:14Definitely a slow start, I think.

0:05:18- Yeah, again, for some years,

0:05:20one year we got the Verizon iPhone in January,

0:05:22one year we got an education event,

0:05:24previous years we had the introduction of the iPad,

0:05:26we've had Macworld, the introduction of the iPhone.

0:05:28So there was sort of, for a long period of time,

0:05:30there were events that were, there was news in January.

0:05:33And I think last year there was nothing until WBC

0:05:36and this year I think it was almost identical to that.

0:05:39- Yeah, I would say so.

0:05:42I mean there's, you know,

0:05:45now that Apple doesn't make announcements in January

0:05:48or at least they haven't in recent years,

0:05:51I mean who knows this year in theory

0:05:53they might have a watch event,

0:05:55but it's pretty much left to CES,

0:05:58which Apple doesn't take part in,

0:06:02for all of the industry news.

0:06:04I don't recall anything from this year to 2014 CES

0:06:08that ended up mattering a damn bit.

0:06:12- No, I mean, I think this year will be different

0:06:14just because of home kit and health kit and carplay.

0:06:16But last year, CES was a graveyard.

0:06:19It was just almost like matrix shelf after matrix shelf

0:06:22of cases and nothing else.

0:06:24- Yeah, and I don't think they knew

0:06:25what they were going to, you know, going to,

0:06:28the industry as a whole didn't even know

0:06:29what they were trying to make.

0:06:31Yeah, they were making their fitness bands.

0:06:33And I remember one of the worst things I saw at CES

0:06:35was an Android powered car system

0:06:37and it was running gingerbread.

0:06:39And the guy told us with a straight face

0:06:41that you could leave it on for five days

0:06:42but it would drain your car battery.

0:06:44So you had to put it in standby mode.

0:06:46But if you put it, sorry, but if you turned it off,

0:06:47it would take like five minutes to boot again.

0:06:50(laughing)

0:06:51This was something that they actually had as a press event.

0:06:54- Are you going to CES again this year?

0:06:57- Yeah, absolutely.

0:06:58- Yeah, what's it, Dan Fromer who was on the show last week

0:07:00is going for the first time this year.

0:07:02And like I said with him, I always talk about going,

0:07:06but I've never gone.

0:07:07- It's alternatively completely barren or incredibly busy

0:07:10and you never know what's gonna happen year to year.

0:07:12So I don't have high faith for it,

0:07:15but I think this year will be different

0:07:16'cause we will have a watch event,

0:07:18maybe we'll see another Apple television,

0:07:19maybe a bigger iPad.

0:07:20The spring sounds exciting this year,

0:07:22but last year up until June,

0:07:24it really was everyone just saying,

0:07:26where's the new stuff from Apple?

0:07:27Where's the new stuff?

0:07:27Are they capable of innovating still?

0:07:29- Yeah, why do we have to wait?

0:07:31Why do we have to wait for them to be ready for something?

0:07:33- Well, that's the thing that I don't understand is do,

0:07:35would anybody have wanted a 2006 iPhone?

0:07:37No, because it was not a product yet.

0:07:40And the Apple Watch won't be a product

0:07:42until early next year.

0:07:43You don't want them to ship what they have right now.

0:07:45- Yeah, and it, you know, to compare and contrast with,

0:07:50I think the antithesis of Apple's, you know,

0:07:53we'll let you know when we're ready to show you attitude,

0:07:55it's Google, you know, who has been,

0:07:59you know, Google Glass was clearly released ahead of its time.

0:08:03I mean, it still isn't a retail consumer product, but the fact that they sold it at all to,

0:08:08what did they call the people, explorers?

0:08:10Yes.

0:08:11You know, is the antithesis of Apple's strategy.

0:08:14That would be the equivalent of if Apple had let WWDC explorers start wearing and using

0:08:21an Apple Watch, you know, 18 months ago.

0:08:24Running like Skankwatch software or something.

0:08:26Right.

0:08:27And you know the self-driving cars

0:08:29So many things that Google does they show

0:08:33Way early and in some sense I the the the I don't think it's productive and you know

0:08:41Every time I bring it up some people mention that the cars in particular

0:08:45It's impossible to do it without showing your hand because there's no way to road test them

0:08:50You know, you have to road test them in public before you can release them and you know way to keep once

0:08:55it's out in the road you can't keep it secret. So maybe the self-driving cars is a bit of

0:08:59a bad example. But the other products they do, they release and I think ultimately it's

0:09:09counterproductive because I think it saps away excitement from the real things you actually

0:09:15have available to sell to people. But on the other hand, it absolutely works to satisfy

0:09:23the desires of the tech press as an industry because you're giving them something to write

0:09:29about.

0:09:30Yeah, I think that's exactly it.

0:09:31I think for the tech press, perception really is reality.

0:09:34So if we see a demo of the Moto 240 or 360 or whatever it is, even though it's not real,

0:09:39even though leaving a screen like that on, like what they showed in the video is a complete

0:09:43science fiction fantasy, it sets expectations for that and it makes people think that Google's

0:09:47really busy and that product is coming and they're innovating and they're doing all these

0:09:50things.

0:09:51if it comes out in some cases, you know, it's a complete turd, but everyone's already seen the video the excitements already happened

0:09:57And then everything else from then on is it his appointment even things made by Apple or another company?

0:10:01Yeah, it's I think moltz has said it best where he's you know

0:10:05I think it's moltz but one of his lines is that you know Apple's current products continue to

0:10:12Fail when compared to the upcoming products in future years from its competitors

0:10:18It's like the iPhone 5c was a huge disappointment even though it was the third most popular phone in the world and the iPad sales

0:10:24Are lagging even though they're any company in the world would be happy to have that in their product line

0:10:28Yeah, or another example. I just noticed this week and it's funny. I haven't linked it up yet, but

0:10:33The same day or within 24 hours

0:10:37There was a New York Times story about the success of Apple pay and about a whole bunch of nude retailers who've signed up for it

0:10:47Some big supermarket chains like Winn-dixie, which is real big in the south here in the US. I

0:10:52Forget who else but some big big name retailers have signed up

0:10:56and

0:10:59Companies like Whole Foods who've been on board since it started who said that it's you know

0:11:03It accounts for over 1% of their transactions and an enormous percent of you know

0:11:07The digital transactions or what would you call it cardless transactions?

0:11:12And at the same time there were like three or four stories that I saw all based on the same analyst report about what what?

0:11:20What trouble Apple pay is in because they've woken up

0:11:24The MCX partners and really gotten the MCX partners to really want to do a good job

0:11:30And so now Apple pays in trouble because MCX is is still coming

0:11:35It's reminds me that article. I think it was two weeks ago where someone said Apple pay

0:11:39probably another one of the Forbes contributor networks, that Apple Pay was

0:11:43a huge disappointment because it was only responsible for a very small amount of

0:11:47transactions worldwide. Never mind America didn't have a much of equipment

0:11:50for it and it was only available in America which is far behind in

0:11:54terms of NFC. It's amazing what perspective they can bring to it when

0:11:57they try hard enough to put it in a bad light. Right, that there's no other

0:12:01digital, you know, pay with your phone transaction retail thing that's even

0:12:06Close to as popular as Apple pay but somehow it's a failure because it's still only 1% of the market, you know

0:12:12Two months in yeah in one car not even two months, right? It didn't even launch until November. Yeah, I think right

0:12:19October I think came with iOS 8.1. All right. Well still that's a you know, right about two months. Yep, two months

0:12:26And it's crazy to me too that

0:12:35With the MCX that they don't mention the people who you know who want to promote it

0:12:40Which I think I think it's not because they actually believe it. I think it's even though they're analysts rather than press

0:12:45I think it's this this

0:12:47Idea that you want to present everything as a neck-and-neck battle, right?

0:12:52You know and so Apple pay is threatened by MCX because it's gonna be backed by Walmart and whoever else and they have you know

0:13:01huge huge footprint in retail

0:13:04But they just skip over the most obvious aspects of what has made Apple pay

0:13:10successful

0:13:12which is

0:13:14exactly what Tim Cook said on stage when he introduced it, which is

0:13:18You know, it's it's one of like my biggest recurring mantras about Apple is don't underestimate how often

0:13:25They're not giving you any spin any bullshit

0:13:28they're just telling you flat out in plain language exactly why they did what

0:13:33they did and with Apple Bay Tim Cook's explanation was we think everybody else

0:13:38who's tried this to date has failed because they haven't concentrated on the

0:13:41user experience and made that their priority that's what we've done we've

0:13:46made it as easy as possible to use as quick to use and as privacy protecting

0:13:52as we can, all in the name of the user.

0:13:57You know, and if that's all they did, well then who, you know, what retailer would hook up the equipment?

0:14:02But the other things they did secondary to the user focus is use the established

0:14:07infrastructure for NFC payments and make the banks

0:14:12happy by taking a very minimal cut and by promising

0:14:17significantly increase security which gets the banks on board because the

0:14:23banks can do the math and I really do think it works out which is that Apple's

0:14:27little 0.15% cut of the transactions is less than the cost of fraud per

0:14:34transaction that the banks have been used to I think that's absolutely true

0:14:39especially when you look at and the the privacy and the security too when you

0:14:42look at all the data breaches at the targets or the Home Depots but I think

0:14:45You nailed it when you said it,

0:14:46it's aligned with my interests.

0:14:48I've gone to Apple Pay terminals,

0:14:50even the demo ones set up at Apple when we were at the event

0:14:52and they read my Canadian NFC credit card.

0:14:54That technology is not gonna just benefit Apple,

0:14:56it's gonna benefit everybody

0:14:57who uses any sort of NFC transaction.

0:15:01And you compare that to current currency

0:15:02or whatever it's called,

0:15:03and that you have to give the retailer your bank account,

0:15:06you have to have a QR code, you have to scan the QR code.

0:15:09And it is such a horrible experience

0:15:11and it's not done to the benefit of the consumer,

0:15:13done to try to increase the amount of to save money on transactions they pay the credit

0:15:17card companies never mind how long it's gonna how much money is gonna cost them in terms

0:15:21of cashiers fees for the incredibly complicated error prone system that they're establishing

0:15:25right you can't prove yet that Tim Cook's explanation for you know why they thought

0:15:31Apple pay would be successful and why it seems to be successful today are true and that cut

0:15:37you know that a user focused approach is is the way to get it done

0:15:42and who knows maybe something like currency will also become popular

0:15:48i don't i don't know i have my doubts about currency in particular but

0:15:52you know it could be that something that's a lot more retailer friendly as

0:15:56opposed to consumer friendly could work

0:15:58but the evidence today suggests you know that what apple said was exactly right

0:16:04it's also uh...

0:16:05What benefits the retailer is interesting

0:16:08because me getting through the checkout line

0:16:10really quickly benefits the retailer.

0:16:12And I believe it's my understanding that a lot of,

0:16:15they signed multi-year agreements with currency

0:16:17and with MCX when they started,

0:16:19which was a silly thing to do, but they did it.

0:16:20But I believe a lot of those expire pretty early on

0:16:22this year and it'll be interesting, sorry, not this year,

0:16:24but in 2015, and it'll be interesting to see how many

0:16:27of those adopt Apple Pay as soon as they are

0:16:29contractually allowed to.

0:16:30- And the other thing that I keep thinking about

0:16:34as a technical limitation is the way that there's one thing that Apple Pay has that

0:16:39no other payment system that would work on the iPhone at least. I mean obviously like

0:16:44what Google could enable on Android or Microsoft with Windows Phone is different but at least

0:16:49if you want iPhone using customers, the one thing they have that nobody else can do is

0:16:55the way that it works at the system level rather than the app level. Like and I just

0:17:00can't emphasize enough for anybody out there who hasn't used Apple Pay yet because you

0:17:04don't have an iPhone 6 or because you don't shop at one of the places that supports it

0:17:09yet. But I just can't emphasize enough how instead of like feeling like a one step process,

0:17:18it almost feels like a zero step process because you don't have to unlock your phone. You just

0:17:23take the phone, even if it's not on, and just get it within an inch of the terminal, rest

0:17:29your thumb on the reader and that's it.

0:17:32- It's gonna sound like--

0:17:34- Nobody else can do that.

0:17:35Like if a current C app on the iPhone,

0:17:38you would have to unlock your phone, open the app,

0:17:41and go from there, which is, you know,

0:17:46it doesn't sound like a lot,

0:17:48but compared to Apple Pay, it is a lot.

0:17:50- I get upset, most places here,

0:17:52I can just tap my card and go,

0:17:53and when it doesn't work, you feel like an animal

0:17:55having to put it in and put in a pin code or swipe it.

0:17:58I haven't had a swipe or sign something in over a year.

0:18:01But it reminds me of something else

0:18:03and it's a bit of a tangent, but I think it's the same thing.

0:18:06It all goes back to Apple making like the A8 chipset

0:18:09or the 8X chipset in that you take the cameras,

0:18:12for instance, I take out my iPhone,

0:18:13I can just take a picture and nine out of 10 times,

0:18:15it's gonna be a really good everyday picture.

0:18:19And that's because Apple makes

0:18:20their own image signal processor.

0:18:22When you look at Microsoft who buys off the shelf chips,

0:18:24they have to put really big glass on the front

0:18:26and collect as much light as they can

0:18:28because they're using off the shelf chips.

0:18:30There's no advantage to them there.

0:18:32Google has no idea what hardware

0:18:33or what software is running on their phones.

0:18:35They try to suck it up to the server

0:18:36and do all the auto awesome stuff.

0:18:37But Apple is just making sure that

0:18:39they have a good camera on it,

0:18:41they'll process it and almost any shot you take

0:18:43will be useful for a normal person.

0:18:45And that's the same thing.

0:18:47You can't get that advantage unless you own

0:18:48the entire stack the way that they do.

0:18:50And now they're moving that into payments

0:18:51and they're moving that into other areas with the iPhone.

0:18:54- Yeah, no, you can't underestimate the advantage.

0:18:57And I think it totally gets written off

0:19:00by these naysaying analysts,

0:19:03what an advantage Apple has by controlling

0:19:05that level of the stack.

0:19:07- I used to think they were naysaying,

0:19:09and I have a friend who was a sell-side analyst,

0:19:11and he explained it to me,

0:19:11and it's that the press reports analysts

0:19:13as though they're giving comments to readers,

0:19:15and their comments are not meant for their readers,

0:19:17they're meant to manipulate the markets.

0:19:19And what they say has very little to do

0:19:20with what they believe.

0:19:21It's entirely, they probably told their own clients

0:19:23something different two days ago, or three days ago,

0:19:26and now they want to produce results for them.

0:19:28So it's so undependable, I don't know why it gets reported.

0:19:31- Right, like an analyst who comes out with a report

0:19:34that seems to be very pessimistic

0:19:35about Apple Pay's long-term prospects,

0:19:38might in fact, honestly, privately,

0:19:40in terms of where he's putting money

0:19:42and advising his clients to put money,

0:19:43being very bullish on the future of Apple Pay.

0:19:46- It's like that video with Crane from a couple years ago

0:19:48where he says, "You want to make money?

0:19:49You spread a rumor saying the iPhone is gonna be delayed.

0:19:52You call up the news networks

0:19:53and you tell them it's gonna be delayed.

0:19:54Then all of a sudden Apple's down

0:19:55you've shorted all the shares. I think that happens a lot. Yeah. What was that

0:19:58guy's name? Jim Cramer. Yeah, Jim Cramer. That's it. Yeah, it's baffling, but and

0:20:04again this stuff keeps getting reported as though it's factual accounting on

0:20:06what Apple's doing. What else in the first half of the year? I think there was

0:20:14was Angela, I think Angela Ahrens was in early on in the year. Yeah, I do think so.

0:20:20When was she hired?

0:20:22- She was definitely, February, March.

0:20:24- Yeah.

0:20:25- That's a complete turnaround from John Browett

0:20:27from the previous year.

0:20:27- Yeah.

0:20:28- And I think that's super interesting

0:20:29because Apple is really doing well in Apple stores,

0:20:32but some people will say that it's a stale experience

0:20:35that they haven't evolved it.

0:20:36Even though it's working, it's hugely successful.

0:20:38But they gave her not only Apple retail,

0:20:40but Apple Online as well,

0:20:42which used to operate almost as separate businesses.

0:20:44And it's similar to giving Federiki control

0:20:46over both OS X and iOS,

0:20:48and that those sort of artificial walls are falling down

0:20:51and it's providing better service for everybody involved.

0:20:54- So Angela Arnnst, her hiring was announced a year ago

0:20:59in October 2013, but she did not start until,

0:21:03I believe February or March of 2014.

0:21:07I've said this before, and it seems obvious,

0:21:10but it's so clear to me that the reason why they hired her

0:21:13and why she would take the job is because of the watch.

0:21:17- Yes.

0:21:18- Well, she was a CEO of Burberry.

0:21:20That's a huge job and people didn't understand

0:21:21why she'd become a senior vice president at Apple,

0:21:24even though the senior vice president of retail

0:21:25and now online as well is a huge job.

0:21:28It's like being a CEO of another company,

0:21:31but it's still, I think you're exactly right.

0:21:32Apple dangled something in front of her

0:21:35that was a challenge and people like that want a challenge.

0:21:38- Yeah, totally.

0:21:39And it does seem, it seems, you know,

0:21:42it's not like, we haven't really seen the ARNSTs effect

0:21:45on anything in retail yet,

0:21:48but I don't think there's anybody who doesn't think

0:21:50that that's coming.

0:21:51- Yeah.

0:21:52- You know, I think that there's half of it,

0:21:55I think is that changes like that take a lot of time

0:21:58because it, or not a lot of time,

0:22:01but a lot of time compared to our industry, right?

0:22:04Because you can't do it digitally.

0:22:05You can't just, you know, have a new store and, you know,

0:22:10like they do with the online store,

0:22:12put up a sticky note for 15 minutes.

0:22:14And then when you come back, it's an all new store,

0:22:17you know, this brick and mortar stuff takes physical, you know, actual time.

0:22:21And, you know, to take a store down and put it back up is time when you're not

0:22:26making sales, you know? So like in San Francisco,

0:22:29I don't know if the new store is open yet,

0:22:31but they're not putting the new store on the same spot as the old store.

0:22:34They're putting it like on the other corner around, uh,

0:22:37what's the name of that part? Union square. Yep. Um, you know,

0:22:42and you can't do that everywhere where Apple has a retail store. You know,

0:22:46most of the ones that are in shopping malls,

0:22:50you could, I guess, get another spot in the mall,

0:22:53but who knows if there's one, you know,

0:22:55it all depends on availability

0:22:56that's outside the control of Apple.

0:22:58- And they're not like a carrier company

0:23:00who's gonna just put a little kiosk out front

0:23:01while the store is closed behind it.

0:23:03- Right, exactly.

0:23:04- Yeah, I think you're right.

0:23:08I think as the watch starts to deploy into the stores

0:23:11and as the other products start coming online for next year,

0:23:12we're gonna see the stores sort of transform to,

0:23:15I don't know if fashion is the right word.

0:23:17I think Apple's doing something really interesting

0:23:19where technology is meeting fashion,

0:23:20but it's gonna be an Apple store

0:23:22that has to be different than it was in the past.

0:23:24- Yeah, let me see, anything else?

0:23:26I don't really see much else.

0:23:28- Beats, I think, was announced earlier on in the year

0:23:31'cause they had Dre on the stage for WVDC,

0:23:33so it must have been.

0:23:33- May 2014, Apple to acquire music,

0:23:37Beats Music and Beats Electronics.

0:23:39I don't know that that's major news,

0:23:44But it's because it's not a huge it's a it's a much bigger transaction than apple has made

0:23:50You know famously, you know, it's the biggest acquisition since they acquired next

0:23:55Which of course, you know

0:23:57Is the you know turned into like the backbone of the country of the company?

0:24:01But uh, you know a 500 million dollar acquisition in 1997 was like was seriously a bet the company acquisition

0:24:11Whereas a you know three billion or whatever it cost acquisition to get beats is pocket change

0:24:17Absolutely. Yeah, 300 billion three billion dollars

0:24:20You know, I mean you don't want to make a three billion dollar acquisition

0:24:24That doesn't turn out well, but it certainly isn't gonna have any meaningful if it turns out to be a complete bust

0:24:30It's not gonna hurt the company

0:24:31I think more interesting than the beats acquisition was just the reactions to it from it was almost like everyone went through the the five

0:24:37stages of grief with denial and anger and they just couldn't believe it and it

0:24:41turns out it does make some sense there are you know selling headphones at Apple

0:24:45stores makes a lot of sense and sort of a synergy between iTunes radio and Beats

0:24:49music whatever it ends up being labeled makes a lot of sense yeah and I think I

0:24:55don't know I still don't think overall it makes a ton of sense I'm still

0:24:59waiting for the other shoe to drop on it but it's in some sense it does where

0:25:04It's the only other iconic headphone company I can think of I mean it has nothing to do with you know, Marco Arment style

0:25:11Quality analysis but rather you're out on the sidewalk and you see somebody walking while they're listening to their device and you know

0:25:21Those white earbuds that Apple's been making ever since 2001 are truly iconic

0:25:26I mean they even had for years an ad campaign that was kind of based on that right with the silhouettes dancing silhouettes

0:25:33Who you know have white earbuds and a white why?

0:25:37You know connector draped around their body

0:25:40They own that right not that other companies had you know that they have a trademark on it and nobody can make white earbuds

0:25:46But white earbuds people see them

0:25:48They think that's somebody listening to an Apple device and beats is the only other company I can think of that has that sort of

0:25:54Recognition yeah, they have that the other cache that the iPod commercials used to have ten years ago

0:26:00But I think there's also an element to Eddie cues

0:26:02Organization is just so big and there's gonna be a limit at some point to what he can do

0:26:06I mean he's doing Apple pay now as well

0:26:08He does the App Store and the iTunes store and he does all the contract negotiations

0:26:12And if you could have Jimmy Iovine in there doing at least some of that it takes more stuff off of Eddie cues desk

0:26:18Yeah something I've heard and it you know, I don't think this is surprising

0:26:22That's probably what everybody was guessing anyway

0:26:24but what I have heard recently was that at least inside Apple the beats acquisition is

0:26:30Viewed as an Eddie thing that Eddie Eddie Eddie started it and he pushed for it Eddie drove it and not that that Tim

0:26:38Cook wasn't engaged and I'm sure that at the negotiation level he was in fact deeply engaged

0:26:43I mean, I don't think you know, Tim Cook has not like don't worry about the details sort of CEO

0:26:51So not to diminish what Tim Cook's role in the negotiations might have been but in terms of

0:26:56Advocating it and and you know

0:26:59Pushing for it. It was in almost entirely an ediq thing

0:27:03Because we didn't see anything about iTunes this year. We didn't see continuity for iTunes

0:27:08For example, we didn't see a new iTunes music service iTunes radio still hasn't gone past the US and Australia

0:27:14I think and iTunes is an aging platform. It's still based on web objects

0:27:18is still based on their original software they use to manage you know the music store

0:27:22and all of that at some point you know it's gonna be like a John Siracusa thing where

0:27:26a thousand years from now this is gonna have to be fixed so what's the point between now

0:27:29and then that it actually gets fixed and I don't know if beats has better software or

0:27:32better solution but it could also be a catalyst to Apple finally fixing a lot of the infrastructure

0:27:38things that they have to do with the iTunes store yeah I think you know above and beyond

0:27:43whether it's based on web objects behind the scenes and and all of that I think it's ever

0:27:48more clear that it's based on a model that just isn't relevant anymore. Which is, here's

0:27:56a song you want and you give a retailer money for it and now you own a copy of it. That's

0:28:03just not, that's just, that's done. I mean, I'm not done in the sense of they're not selling

0:28:09any songs anymore, but that I can't see any way that that ever comes back.

0:28:16Yes.

0:28:17it's in permanent decline.

0:28:19It's sort of like what standalone iPods are.

0:28:22It's still a decent business,

0:28:26but it's never going to increase quarter over quarter.

0:28:29It's just gonna go into permanent decline.

0:28:32- Yeah, and just like the iPod is being replaced

0:28:34by the iPhone, in some cases, the iPad mini,

0:28:36and now larger iPhones,

0:28:37it makes sense for whatever iTunes was,

0:28:39for Apple to get in early enough

0:28:41to have whatever iTunes will end up being.

0:28:42- Right, and it's, yeah, and in the same way

0:28:45that it, you know, iPods sales decreasing doesn't mean that people are spending less

0:28:49time with gadgets that play music. In the same way, music sales declining doesn't mean

0:28:55people are spending less time listening to music. If anything, they're probably spending

0:29:00more. You know, I wouldn't be surprised if you did a study and found out that people

0:29:03listen to more music today or at least time spent listening to music than ever before.

0:29:09It's just that the model is no longer buying and selling.

0:29:12Yeah, it's not it's not what you had to buy it

0:29:15It's not we had to wait in the radio people can get pretty much what they want when they want and that opens them up

0:29:18To just consuming it almost non-stop if they want to

0:29:21right

0:29:24So, I don't know I'm still not sure what to make of that if is the beats thing an exception to the rule just

0:29:31because it is it it combines two things that Apple wants to continue being a leader at which is

0:29:38music listening hardware and

0:29:41and digital distribution of legal music.

0:29:46Is it just that Beats is like a rare,

0:29:49perfect storm acquisition?

0:29:52Or is it the sign of things to come

0:29:54that Apple is going to loosen up

0:29:56and become a company that does mid-level

0:30:01or to high-level acquisitions with some frequency?

0:30:04- I think, again, to your point about Apple

0:30:05just saying what they really feel,

0:30:06I think when Tim Cook says they're not religiously opposed

0:30:08to big acquisitions,

0:30:10I think he's absolutely sincere about that.

0:30:11They'll do them when they make sense,

0:30:13but it's gotta be something like Beats

0:30:14where it gives them a hardware product.

0:30:16They can sell the compliments and other hardware product,

0:30:18a service they can roll out the compliments

0:30:20and existing service,

0:30:21and has executives that might be able to,

0:30:23you know, a service, sorry,

0:30:24executives and a culture that can integrate into Apple

0:30:27and help them do the things that they wanna do.

0:30:29- Right, and it doesn't really,

0:30:30that's the thing that has me,

0:30:31I'm still curious about it,

0:30:34but it doesn't make me worried about it

0:30:36the way that there's any number of other possible

0:30:40three billion dollar-ish acquisitions

0:30:43that Apple could have made that would raise my Spidey sense,

0:30:47you know, in a way that Beats doesn't.

0:30:49Because the biggest thing is that it doesn't fundamentally

0:30:52change any of the areas of focus in Apple's attention.

0:30:56- Yeah, like you said last week with Frommer,

0:30:58it doesn't make them a conglomerate.

0:30:59- Right, which is exactly what, you know,

0:31:02to me is like the first canary I check in the coal mine

0:31:06Is is Apple losing focus and becoming more of a conglomerate which I you know, we don't know

0:31:11I mean, I don't say that I don't say that Apple becoming a

0:31:14Multifocused conglomerate would be bad. We just have no idea and there's no history for Apple as

0:31:20a you know

0:31:23Whatever their revenue is, you know 50 or 200 billion dollar a year corporation

0:31:28I mean, you know, they're an uncharted territory period there's you know, they're the most valuable company not just in tech but anywhere

0:31:34But it would be so it wouldn't be you know them making seemingly

0:31:41Unfocused acquisitions wouldn't make me sure that they were on the wrong track

0:31:47But it would make me strongly suspect that they were on the wrong track

0:31:51Yeah

0:31:51And it's wonder how the analysts would treat it because it wouldn't be expected behavior

0:31:55Google can compete with everybody they can compete with Amazon with Apple with

0:31:58Microsoft with any tech company in the world and do it all at the same time and that's fine and interesting and wonderful

0:32:03wonderful but you'd probably you probably hear howls all the way across the valley if

0:32:08Apple started doing that yeah well and Google can compete with itself you know you know

0:32:13Chromebooks versus Android tablets is a perfect example and I don't even say that that's a

0:32:19mistake I think it kind of fits with Google's internal culture whereas if Apple had seemingly

0:32:27confusing overlap between low-end Mac books and iPads, I would find that worrisome.

0:32:35Yeah, agreed.

0:32:36Like if Apple had a $399 MacBook, that to me would be very worrisome.

0:32:43I still have in the back of my head this idea that Google bought Android because they were

0:32:46panicked about mobile and then saw WebOS and smacked their head and thought that was a

0:32:50way more Google product than buying Android, but then they were all in on Android and now

0:32:54They're slowly gonna it's fun to get away to get chroma West to a point where that can be their version of web OS

0:32:59That's an interesting. That's an interesting argument too because they ended up hiring

0:33:03Matta Mattias Duarte. Yep

0:33:06Take his name, right? Yeah, absolutely

0:33:09Who was the you know lead designer behind web OS? Yeah

0:33:15And they're slowly giving send our Patai control over the stack and he was you know

0:33:20He's the web guy

0:33:21He's Android always seemed like an odd product from Google because it's a web company and that was very native software

0:33:25Yeah, and I really do think that that it took a long time for Google or for Android. I should say to

0:33:32Not to not at the low end but at the sort of mid to high end to get any sort of foothold is that they

0:33:40Were in such a deep hole design wise, you know

0:33:43compared to the iPhone that any you know

0:33:46even people who were inclined not to buy Apple stuff people who haven't ever bought Apple stuff and sort of want to you know,

0:33:54It's a natural thing, you know people who've been sticking with the PC for years

0:33:57and sort of having

0:34:00Apple is for other people sort of mindset about the company

0:34:03You know in 2011 even through 2012 you go into a store and compare the Android phones to

0:34:11iPhone and it's you know, you don't even have to be a design critic

0:34:15you just see that there's a serious difference in fit and finish in the software.

0:34:20It was a very different priority.

0:34:22Apple famously wanted to get the animation just absolutely nailed even in the first generation

0:34:27iPhone, but they didn't need to have every single feature crammed in there where Android

0:34:31was...

0:34:32It wasn't designed to be a phone for everybody.

0:34:34It was designed to be a phone that would protect Google's share of the web because they rightly

0:34:38believe web was moving mobile.

0:34:40Their priority wasn't that sort of interactivity.

0:34:42They bought Android and they made it work.

0:34:46But I remember even last year at CES, I was sitting there with the Nexus 4 or 5 trying

0:34:51to use Gmail and just cursing out loud.

0:34:53And Brian Klug from formerly of Anantech came over and quickly put it in developer mode

0:34:58and the screen went bright red.

0:34:59And he said that's because they're redrawing every cell four or five times trying to hope

0:35:02that it would stick.

0:35:04And their own graphics engineers couldn't get their own Gmail engineers to properly

0:35:09code all of it.

0:35:10That's why they've really locked things down now with material design and all the new things.

0:35:15But it took them four or five years to fix the massive architectural problems that were

0:35:19causing poor interaction.

0:35:21Right.

0:35:22And the difference with WebOS is that WebOS, right from the get-go, it had performance

0:35:25problems because of the whole architecture of building it on top of like a WebKit rendering

0:35:31engine.

0:35:32combined with the state of mobile hardware in what was it 2009 when when

0:35:40when the pre came out yeah but I you know in terms of an an elegant software

0:35:48interface I mean I mean you could still it to this day I think you could argue

0:35:53that the way that web OS handled notifications is the best design

0:35:56anybody's come up with absolutely there synergies I mean it was almost the

0:36:01fringe universe version of the iPhone if if John Rubenstein had won the keyboard

0:36:05argument or if what's his name it won the the Linux argument or if the people

0:36:10who wanted to use WebKit as the interface instead of creating UI kit had

0:36:13won that argument that could have been an Apple product right Tony said Tony

0:36:17Fidel yeah but instead they all ended up at palm making except for Fidel Rubenstein

0:36:21and and the web the WebKit engineers ended up at palm making their version of

0:36:25the iPhone yeah absolutely I I if you would have shown if you would have taken

0:36:30of a palm pre back in time to you know 1998 1997 and shown it to my then self

0:36:38and said what come you know this is a product from 2009 what company made it

0:36:42you know scrub the logos off I would have guessed Apple yeah without question

0:36:46especially if you just showed me the software and not the hardware the

0:36:50hardware was a lot less appley but the software was extremely appley in my

0:36:56opinion everything from the font choice to you know the roundness you know the

0:37:01rounded corners of the screen the rounded corners of the cards on the

0:37:06screen I think it was a very Apple DNA product software wise I've never seen

0:37:12the p1 phone this fidel's group was working on but in I've always suspected

0:37:16that if that had been the phone that had got the gone ahead of some reason p2

0:37:19hadn't worked out and forest all's group hadn't been able to make the iPhone that

0:37:23could have ended up being very similar to what the Pom Pre was. Yeah, and so it's interesting to think

0:37:27hypothetically what would have happened if Google had purchased, had somehow obtained, webOS instead of Android and pushed for it because in

0:37:35some sense the problems that webOS had were, I think,

0:37:39not solvable by throwing money at them, but more easily solved by throwing money at it than Android.

0:37:46Because with Android it was to me,

0:37:49Fundamentally the fact that it was designed at the outset as a sort of blackberry

0:37:53Style you know that it was going to you know a blackberry style mobile interface keyboard up down left right select

0:38:01and

0:38:03therefore had no

0:38:05No, no at a foundation level aspect of a rich graphical interface with playful animations and high frame

0:38:13Rates and stuff like that. I've told the story before but when I reviewed the g1 the very first Android phone that came out

0:38:18I turned on the snake game and it said press up to start and I tried you know swiping up on the screen

0:38:23Then I tried pressing the up arrow key

0:38:24Then I tried pressing the up joypad and then I tried pressing up on whatever the other thing was on the other side

0:38:29I tried eight different ways of signaling up and I couldn't get it to work

0:38:32But there were eight different ways of signaling up right and that to me to find the very early years of Android

0:38:37Might I remember too that it was the only way to select text was to use the up down left, right?

0:38:42There was no way to touch on the screen to select text you had to

0:38:46You know more or less use like arrow keys

0:38:48And the original one you'd close the keyboard and there'd be the juke the Google search box just blinking at you wanting you to put

0:38:54Text but there was no virtual keyboard so you couldn't input text

0:38:57remember that

0:39:00And that's one of the problems they were facing and and palm was a tiny team and they they coded circles around Google when it

0:39:06came to phones in 2009

0:39:08So anyway, that's an interesting what-if it's and to me it's of the last

0:39:15of the post PC era, you know, from mid 2007 on,

0:39:20the great tragedy of the whole thing is that

0:39:24WebOS never, you know, didn't get a long enough time

0:39:27to try to gain a foothold.

0:39:29- Agreed.

0:39:30- You know, I mean, I think it was a more elegant design

0:39:34than Windows Phone.

0:39:36And so just imagine if they had had somebody

0:39:39with the wherewithal that Microsoft has shown

0:39:42with Windows Phone to stick behind WebOS, you know?

0:39:46And, you know, push the software forward,

0:39:49break some of the performance bottlenecks,

0:39:52but also just let Moore's Law help you out year after year.

0:39:56You know, two, three years later,

0:39:58WebOS I think would have been a lot more,

0:40:01without even any software optimizations,

0:40:04would have been a lot more tenable performance-wise.

0:40:08- Absolutely, I mean, they had no secondary source of income.

0:40:10Apple had Mac money originally,

0:40:11Google had search money, even Samsung had appliance money.

0:40:14Palm and now Blackberry, they have no additional sources

0:40:16of income and so everything becomes,

0:40:18everything becomes Bet the Company.

0:40:20Every phone you put out becomes Bet the Company.

0:40:22- Yeah.

0:40:23All right, let me take a break and thank our first sponsor

0:40:25this week and it is our very good friends at Backblaze.

0:40:30You guys know Backblaze, unlimited,

0:40:32un-throttled backup for Mac.

0:40:35They have over 100 petabytes of total data backed up.

0:40:40They just crossed the six billion files restored mark.

0:40:43That means users of Backblaze have used them to restore

0:40:47or download or get on another device over six billion files.

0:40:52They have an iPhone app that lets you access

0:40:55and share any of your files.

0:40:57So when your Mac's backed up to Backblaze,

0:40:59you're out and about, all you have with you is your phone

0:41:02and you wanna get a file from your Mac.

0:41:04Just log into, just open the Backblaze app

0:41:06and there's all your files, get it.

0:41:08You can email it to someone right from there.

0:41:10No need to do anything more complicated than that.

0:41:12Couldn't be easier.

0:41:14You can restore one file or all your files easily with their web restore.

0:41:2125% of all Backblaze restores are for just one file.

0:41:26So it's not just for computer disasters.

0:41:28But if you do have a computer disaster, somebody steals your Mac, somebody breaks in your house,

0:41:35takes your Mac, takes your backup drive, your roof leaks, water leaks all over your computer,

0:41:40ruins your hard drive, ruins your time machine. You need to, you know, true total disaster.

0:41:47You can just, you don't have to wait and download all of your stuff from Backblaze over the

0:41:51internet. You can just go there, say put it all on a USB hard drive and boom, they'll

0:41:56FedEx it to you and you know, like a day or two later, there's a USB hard drive with all

0:42:01of your files on it ready for you to restore to a new computer.

0:42:06Software's written by the company's founded by Apple X engineers.

0:42:12The software runs totally native on your Mac, runs great on Yosemite, runs great on Mavericks,

0:42:19couldn't be installed more easily, couldn't be more invisible in the background while

0:42:23it's running.

0:42:26Just great, great service for an amazing price.

0:42:29Five bucks a month per Mac, unlimited, no limits on how much data you can upload.

0:42:36Five bucks a month.

0:42:37So you can get a risk-free, no credit card required trial by going here, backblaze.com/daringfireball.

0:42:47You're nuts if you haven't done it.

0:42:48And if you're listening to this over the holidays, sign your parents up for it.

0:42:53Just go when you're at your parents' house for Christmas or whatever, just sign them

0:42:57up for backblaze and give it to them. It's a great little gift. They won't thank you

0:43:02for it until they need it, but then when they need it, they'll think you're a superhero.

0:43:05So put all your relatives on backblaze. My thanks to them.

0:43:10So the first big Apple news of the year, 2014, really didn't come until WWDC.

0:43:14>> Yeah. But what an event. >> Yeah. I think it was certainly -- it still

0:43:20seems like -- it doesn't seem like as long ago as it is. It doesn't feel like six months

0:43:25ago. No, it was amazing because I was sitting with you and Jason Snell and

0:43:30John Siracusa and different people were just lighting up at different parts of

0:43:35that event. It was just such a palpable reaction for them. Siracusa and Swift, right?

0:43:41Well, he turned to Snell and he goes, "Am I dreaming? Because if I'm... you should tell me

0:43:44because I might be in a fugue state. I don't know if this is real or not. Please

0:43:47tell me that I'm actually listening to what I'm listening to." That was certainly

0:43:51big news. You know, iOS 8 and Yosemite. It was the first time we got a look at Yosemite.

0:44:01And I think, you know, certain, how should we say it? Not like a specific, you know,

0:44:11like here's three lines of code, copy these exactly, this is how you do X, the recommended

0:44:17But more in terms of like broad strokes philosophy

0:44:20I think Apple started pushing a couple of new things not necessarily for the first time

0:44:25But two examples I can think of was the heavy focus on

0:44:29Dynamic user interface layout. Yeah

0:44:32clearly

0:44:35Preshadowing, you know pre, you know in in the run-up to the iPhone 6 and 6 plus

0:44:43But I think in the long run more

0:44:45Envisioning a world of iOS devices where there's a continuum of screen sizes, you know

0:44:53And who knows maybe eventually something smaller than four inches

0:44:56and

0:44:59You know by all accounts maybe one of the things you know

0:45:02That we'll be hearing about in 20 for early parts of 2015 would be a bigger screen some kind of iPad

0:45:08that's bigger than 9.7 inches and

0:45:11and not having to code a custom user interface for each size in that continuum.

0:45:19It's a definite, it's a huge change from the way iOS development was until recently.

0:45:23And it wasn't just about supporting the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus.

0:45:28>> The way I look at it, there was the integration theme, which we'll probably get to.

0:45:34But the other big theme was this transition from pull to push,

0:45:37where previously the interface was locked to the device.

0:45:40and then slowly but surely with things like AirPlay and CarPlay and now WatchKit, the

0:45:46interface is actually decoupled so you have the logic on one device and the interface

0:45:49going somewhere else.

0:45:51Or you have the logic for the app of the interface being able to be flexible between the 4-inch

0:45:55screen size, 4.7, 6-inch.

0:45:57Now that you have split view controllers on the iPhone 6 Plus, it's sort of like a mini

0:46:01iPad.

0:46:02So like you said, it can scale across those things, but it's all sort of one central part

0:46:07of logic.

0:46:08And then you add extensibility to it where previously you had to hunt around your iPhone

0:46:12for anything.

0:46:13You had to go between six different photo apps just to get the effects you wanted.

0:46:17You had to leave to reply to a message.

0:46:19You had to leave if you wanted to share to Tumblr.

0:46:21You couldn't do that from where you were.

0:46:22You had to go to the Tumblr app and do it.

0:46:24And now all of that functionality has come to one place.

0:46:27All of that is now independent.

0:46:28You have these remote views.

0:46:30And to me that's made, that sort of severing of that one unit into these more modular parts

0:46:34has really made a huge difference not just in my workflow but where I think Apple could

0:46:38take all these. I think it's the first big hint of much larger plans they have moving

0:46:42forward with these devices.

0:46:44Right and you mentioned both CarPlay which is that's how CarPlay works where CarPlay

0:46:48is a dumb terminal effectively and you know take your iPhone out of Bluetooth range and

0:46:56the only thing the screen is going to show you in your car is the stuff from the manufacturer.

0:47:01You're not going to get any of the Apple play stuff or car play stuff.

0:47:05No iOS at all.

0:47:09It's only a it's really just effectively a projector.

0:47:12Your iPhone is doing all of the computation.

0:47:14Your iPhone is all of the storage.

0:47:16Your iPhone is doing the networking for anything that's coming over cellular.

0:47:21And the only thing that the screen in your car does is show you what the iPhone is showing

0:47:27and report back to the phone where you're stabbing your fingers at it.

0:47:34And the watch, you know, as we now know and as, you know, countless people have, you know,

0:47:40the initial watch kit SDK shows, the first round of third party apps pretty much works

0:47:47the same way.

0:47:48You don't get to run any code.

0:47:49There's no part of watch, this initial watch kit where your app runs code on the watch.

0:47:56just a projected display of what your phone app, your iPhone app is showing it

0:48:02and then the watch just reports back what you tapped on. I would like that

0:48:07everywhere I mean I like the idea of CarPlay I bought the Toyota car before

0:48:11they had any integration at all and my only option is to buy a new car if I

0:48:15want anything but with CarPlay every time I upgrade iOS or upgrade my phone I

0:48:19get a better experience I'd like that on my camera I'd like CameraPlay so that my

0:48:23the Canon interface is replaced with iOS.

0:48:25I don't wanna have Android appliances at home,

0:48:27I wanna have them running iOS.

0:48:28Just anytime there's a screen,

0:48:29I would eventually like to be able to just put,

0:48:31like project iOS right onto it.

0:48:34- Ooh, doing that with a camera, like a Canon,

0:48:37or like a serious, serious camera would be fascinating.

0:48:41I mean, there is a move afoot in the camera world

0:48:44to build in Wi-Fi, but it's,

0:48:47and I don't have a camera that does it yet.

0:48:49my Fuji X100S is a year off.

0:48:54Like the brand new X100T,

0:48:56which just came out a few weeks ago

0:48:58and I linked to a review of it a couple of days ago,

0:49:01now has WiFi, but it's clunky.

0:49:03Like the only way to get it to work,

0:49:05I haven't seen it,

0:49:05but it's like you have to get a Fuji app from the app store

0:49:08and then open the Fuji app on your phone

0:49:11and then you can do something between your phone

0:49:14and the camera.

0:49:17Whereas having it be like CarPlay,

0:49:19man, that would be fantastic.

0:49:21- And it's great for Apple

0:49:21because they're never gonna get into,

0:49:23never is a long time,

0:49:24but they're not gonna get into making appliances.

0:49:25They're not gonna become a giant manufacturing conglomerate

0:49:27like Samsung.

0:49:28And they're not gonna license iOS

0:49:30the way that Android is easily able to be put on any device.

0:49:33But just projecting the interface,

0:49:34it means they can still control it.

0:49:36They in essence just take it over.

0:49:37And the customer will have a great experience

0:49:39and they don't have to relinquish any of the control

0:49:41that they need for products.

0:49:42- Yeah, it almost to me takes cameras

0:49:44back to where they were pre-digital, right?

0:49:46where when you load it, we had a 35 millimeter film camera.

0:49:50The only things the camera did was let you take pictures.

0:49:54You would look through a viewfinder and see,

0:49:57and the camera would have things like a light set.

0:49:59In the latter years, obviously in the early years,

0:50:01you had to set all that stuff manually.

0:50:03But by the latter years of the tail end of the film world,

0:50:08it would do the exposure.

0:50:10If you set things to auto, it would set the aperture,

0:50:13set the exposure time.

0:50:15And then, but it was all just about letting you take the next photo.

0:50:22Then you'd push the button and the photo would be taken.

0:50:24It would be stored on the film and that was it, right?

0:50:28I would like a digital camera that worked like that.

0:50:30Do whatever you can to help me get a perfect exposure and focus.

0:50:35You know, set the focus distance, give me a recommended aperture, give me a recommended

0:50:39exposure time or let me set any of those variables manually if I choose to.

0:50:44And then when I hit click, it should just store the photo and then let me do everything

0:50:49else over a wireless connection to my iPhone.

0:50:53I would love that for a couple reasons.

0:50:55One, if you don't have an iPhone, you would just get whatever the QNX CarPlay system is,

0:50:59you know, whatever the standard software is on the phone.

0:51:02But if you do have it, you get a better experience and that becomes the same reason you want

0:51:05to get CarPlay.

0:51:06You know, this stuff all works better if you happen to have an iPhone.

0:51:09Yeah, boy, that would be great.

0:51:12But I do totally think that the WWDC 2014 heralded that sort of future.

0:51:19I think so too.

0:51:20And I think we also see, for example, continuity is going to work on the watch because there's

0:51:24going to be things on the watch.

0:51:25The watch to me is a total convenience play.

0:51:27It's for all those thousands of tiny interactions that you have with your phone every day that

0:51:32don't take a lot of time but are super important, yet you still have to go to your bag or go

0:51:35to your purse or go to your pocket.

0:51:38And I can sort of shift those to my watch.

0:51:40But if something ends up being more important than I thought it was, being able to just

0:51:43send that right back to my phone and continue it on my phone, Sync is great.

0:51:47But with Sync, I still have to unlock the phone, go find the app, go to the same place

0:51:51where I was, scroll through it, try to find it.

0:51:53But with continuity, I can be looking at something, press a button, and that exact same thing

0:51:57is just there waiting for me again.

0:51:59I think that's going to be much more interesting when the watch is in play.

0:52:02>> Yeah.

0:52:03And I think a lot of these things are sort of breaking -- it goes back to what I said

0:52:08earlier about Apple Pay where it's at a from a user's perspective it's outside

0:52:14the app centric world of using the phone itself it's it's much more about the

0:52:21real physical world where your phone is just within the Bluetooth and/or Wi-Fi

0:52:28you know wireless range of whatever terminal you're dealing with whether the

0:52:33terminal is your watch whether it's your dashboard in your car and you just tap

0:52:38on the watch and things get started you don't have to wake up your phone you

0:52:41don't and you definitely don't have to find any particular app like a Fuji app

0:52:47to get you know to get this to work you're just on your camera and hit a

0:52:51button on your camera and you know the phone interface just wakes up and starts

0:52:55you know can read those photos that are right on your phone now the phone

0:52:58becomes like the Star Destroyer and the watch becomes the shuttlecraft that

0:53:01moves you in between this big objects

0:53:04that's pretty good I like that what else from WWDC I guess Yosemite we could yeah

0:53:14you know and in the summer there wasn't really any news per se it was just you

0:53:19know betas of iOS and Yosemite not a bad way to just roll into if we're gonna

0:53:25talk 2014 in hindsight you I mean have to talk Yosemite yeah I mean Dave

0:53:30Wiska stood an article on macworld right before hand where you're sort of speculating of what Yosemite would end up looking like and I

0:53:36Think he was really really close. It's like Apple didn't just clone iOS 7 which was a long-running joke

0:53:41They they sort of took the cues from it the translucency and and the other effects and they made something that was very Mac

0:53:48And you know, they kept the shadows for example. Yeah our example when Dave and I were

0:53:52Noodling ideas for Vesper Mac before we saw Yosemite and we thought well

0:53:59what if they do totally just go all in iOS 7 look and feel and

0:54:03We the only thing we could come up with was the the iCloud web apps. Yeah, which are

0:54:08You know you use them with a mouse pointer, and you know I think typically I don't even think they run on an iPad

0:54:16So I mean you're using it on a Mac

0:54:18And they have some things like dialog boxes that you know you know it's like

0:54:23You know how would you do an iOS 7 dialog box with a mouse pointer?

0:54:28But overall, boy, we looked at that and we were like, "Boy, I hope that's not it."

0:54:34And it wasn't.

0:54:37It had to be enough because they did that back to the Mac event and they changed the names of the apps

0:54:41and they brought over the same look and feel and they really made an effort to get all the people who had iOS devices,

0:54:47not to make the Mac the same, but to make them comfortable, to make an easy sort of a halo effect transition.

0:54:52And when you look at Yosemite and you look at continuity, it's just about adding value.

0:54:56Again, if you have an iPhone or iPad,

0:54:58you'll have a much better experience with a Mac.

0:55:01- Yeah, absolutely.

0:55:02I do think too, and it shows,

0:55:04and part of it is our perspective

0:55:07where we get to go to these press events

0:55:09and talk to some of the people at Apple,

0:55:11like in the product marketing group.

0:55:13And there's a palpable sense.

0:55:16I mean, there's some things that they just never come up.

0:55:19I mean, nobody really spends a long time talking about the,

0:55:23we don't even call them that anymore,

0:55:24but like the iWorks apps, right?

0:55:26Like pages and numbers and keynote.

0:55:29They, you know, there hasn't been a lot of enthusiasm

0:55:32about those apps in recent years.

0:55:35I'm not saying there's none.

0:55:36I'm just saying that it's, you know,

0:55:39I think it shows in the real world

0:55:41and, you know, in this current state of those apps.

0:55:44And I think it shows in the enthusiasm

0:55:46when you talk to people at Apple privately.

0:55:48But whereas like the Mac overall and Yosemite overall,

0:55:51like there were people, there's people at Apple

0:55:52who just still love the Mac.

0:55:54Like as a whole, it is not like the, you know,

0:55:58forgotten first child, you know,

0:56:02brushed aside in favor of the beloved, you know, iOS,

0:56:07you know.

0:56:08- I wonder if that has anything to do with the Mac,

0:56:11like Yosemite being very firmly in Federighi's org,

0:56:13but things like iWork and iTunes all being projects

0:56:16that are run by, in Q's org, you know,

0:56:18almost like a totally secondary

0:56:19software development system.

0:56:21- I do wonder about that.

0:56:23And I don't know if it's because it's any way to

0:56:28to slag at EQ, but almost that he's got so much on his plate

0:56:32that how could it get any more of his attention,

0:56:35you know, with how much that he's got on his plate.

0:56:38- And you don't have the Federica,

0:56:40like the one guy who's in charge of software engineering

0:56:42isn't in charge of those bits of software engineering.

0:56:44- But as a whole, I, you know, this year,

0:56:47I think that the people I've spoken to at Apple

0:56:51were more excited about Yosemite and what's new on the Mac than iOS 8. And you

0:56:55know and a lot of it is hard to separate because so much of what's new about both

0:56:59iOS 8 and Yosemite is the continuity stuff which ties them together and there

0:57:03is no one without the other. That was one of the most impressive things to me

0:57:07because the famously iOS and OS X used to be run separately and there was a big

0:57:12rework but not only that it's it's it filtered down so instead of having

0:57:16someone in charge of Yosemite and someone in charge of iOS the person who

0:57:19was in charge of extensibility,

0:57:21or at least the engineering program manager

0:57:24was in charge of extensibility for iOS and OS X,

0:57:27was in charge of continuity for iOS and iOS X.

0:57:30And even when it would have been easier

0:57:31to do them separately or do them in different ways,

0:57:33they made sure that they were done in the same way,

0:57:35so developers had just one way

0:57:36to target them on both systems.

0:57:38And that might be a subtle change,

0:57:39but I think that's a really profound change

0:57:41based on how Apple used to be run.

0:57:43- Yeah, and it's a recurring theme

0:57:47since he left the company, but you know with forestall and again, I overall I'm a big fan of forestall and I think

0:57:54You know for Scott forestall is a huge reason that the iPhone was a hit product

0:58:01I was as good as it was I think he is a huge reason that the App Store

0:58:05Exists and that it's as popular as it is problems aside and we can get into that because there's been a lot of recent

0:58:12you know problems with the App Store, but on the whole, you know, it's

0:58:17you know a success and you know at a time when in

0:58:212007 when the first iPhone came out and there wasn't any

0:58:24Third-party software at all and there were questions about whether there ever would be and then even when it was announced

0:58:31Well house how strict are they gonna keep this?

0:58:33How much is it gonna be a handful of apps that Apple vets and how much is it gonna be?

0:58:38You know, are they gonna allow tens of thousands hundreds thousands of apps?

0:58:42I think all of that is thanks to forest all or at least by these partly thanks to forest all absolutely

0:58:48But on the other hand, I don't think continuity happens

0:58:51All in one fell swoop in 2014 if forest all is still running iOS as his own fiefdom because the way he ran it was

0:58:59secretly

0:59:02Even when it wasn't new, you know even you know, you know 20

0:59:062012 I guess when he

0:59:09Got pushed out. Mm-hmm

0:59:11You know.

0:59:12Yeah, I think he was a phenomenal partner for Steve Jobs.

0:59:15I mean you hear stories about when he was at Apple, he knew which of the three studded

0:59:21leather textures Steve would pick.

0:59:23And when he wasn't there, the designers just kept hearing no and no and no over and over

0:59:27again.

0:59:28And he was just so good at working with Steve Jobs.

0:59:30But then, you know, he faced an Apple without Steve Jobs.

0:59:32And it's possible that he was the best person in the world to birth the iPhone but not the

0:59:36best person to get it through the awkward teenage years.

0:59:39We'll see that with the watch now because Kevin Lynch runs watch software at Apple.

0:59:42It's not in Craig Federighi's org.

0:59:44But that's sort of what you have to do when you're creating something new.

0:59:46You have to give it that sort of independent space to come alive and then you integrate

0:59:50it back again over time.

0:59:51Right.

0:59:52But even with Lynch and that's a good open question as to in terms of what to look for

0:59:57in 2015.

0:59:59How good is their initial watch software going to be?

1:00:05it's fair or not, you know, how good the initial like when we get our first Apple watch 1.0

1:00:11in quote early 2015. We're gonna we're all going to form pretty firm opinions of Kevin

1:00:20Lynch as an Apple product manager, right off the bat. But Lynch was hired into an Apple

1:00:27where, you know, he could be told point blank and I'm sure was this is how we work now we

1:00:33collaborate you know and I think that's why you see you know that you know

1:00:36Schiller's already wearing an Apple watch, Eddy Q's wearing an Apple watch,

1:00:40Federighi is wearing an Apple watch, you know that they're not locked out of that

1:00:44in the way that I think a lot of people were with the iPhone before it came out.

1:00:49And the other thing that I mean I've heard really good things about Kevin

1:00:53Lynch's work at Apple like he sounds like he's doing a great job but also

1:00:56while the watch stuff is separate for example like I don't know this for a

1:01:01Fact but it sounds to me like messages is not being like if you're working on watch messages

1:01:05You're not allowed to talk to the guy working on iOS or Mac messages

1:01:08It sounds like that's not the case that the messages group, you know spans across from that which is what you want

1:01:12Because otherwise it's gonna create a broken experience

1:01:14Yeah, I do. I think that's absolutely the case where where he you know, it might be separate from

1:01:20Federighi's stuff but in a sense it's not because it's Federighi isn't trusted with it or he's not part of it

1:01:26But that he's already got enough on this plate and they need this is such a big undertaking that it needs

1:01:31Its own point person and team but they're not I think the difference is maybe maybe the word is fiefdom

1:01:37You know that iOS was run by Scott for stall as his own fiefdom within the company and that's not the case with the watch

1:01:44And I was talking to Brad Ellis about this last week

1:01:47But you look at the design cues of the watch and you start to imagine

1:01:50It's not just a copy of iOS 7 or a copy of Yosemite

1:01:53It is it is being given the room to be its own thing sort of establish its own identity as well

1:01:57Yeah, I almost get the sense that it if there's anything that holds up as an analogy

1:02:01It's almost like the watch OS is to iOS what iOS?

1:02:06Was to Mac OS yeah, you know that yes, we're not throwing everything out the kernel

1:02:13It might be the exact same kernel. There's there it might be a UI kit

1:02:17That's doing drawing it runs from port like the iPhone runs from port right

1:02:24but that it's it's just about based, you know using the technology that makes sense to reuse but but

1:02:31Stripping it down to a level that's appropriate for this new dramatically

1:02:37Lesser form factor. Yeah, but the strategic

1:02:40aspects of how the software runs

1:02:44Couldn't be more different from the original iPhone where the original iPhone

1:02:51only had this tangential relationship with your Mac, which was

1:02:55connect a 30 pin connector and a USB cord to the two and

1:03:00Hit them, you know sync and wait and

1:03:05Have you know, I still think it's almost seems prehistoric. I can't believe it's only seven years ago

1:03:11But that's the only way you've got calendar events on your phone or back to your Mac if you created the event on your phone

1:03:18It's the only way you could sync calendar events, the only way you could sync contacts.

1:03:24It's crazy that you only had to do all that tethered.

1:03:26But then once you untethered, your phone was a completely, iPhone was a completely independent

1:03:32device that had to do everything.

1:03:35Any kind of computation was done on the CPU on the phone.

1:03:38All of the drawing was done on the GPU on the phone.

1:03:41And the watch, at least for third party software, is largely just a projected screen where it's

1:03:47doing the least work possible. It's almost like the web app solution for the

1:03:53original iPhone where when you no longer connected to the internet nothing can

1:03:56update when you're not when your phone is no longer in vicinity nothing can

1:03:58update. Right yeah absolutely. Let's take a break and we'll come back and talk

1:04:05more Yosemite but I want to thank our second sponsor and it's another long

1:04:10friend of the show our good friends at lynda.com. L-Y-N-D-A dot com. lynda.com is

1:04:18an easy and affordable way to help you learn. Learn what? Well just about

1:04:25anything from programming to photography to design to audio editing even even

1:04:33stuff like negotiation skills they have classes on that. It's amazing the breadth

1:04:37of their library. You instantly stream thousands of courses created by experts

1:04:42on software, web development, graphic design, any of those things and watch

1:04:46them right on your computer. Fresh content, there's new courses added daily.

1:04:52They work directly with industry experts and software companies to provide timely

1:04:56training often the same day that new versions or releases of apps or products

1:05:00or services hit the market. So if you want to learn something new, new version

1:05:04of Lightroom comes out, guess what? You can learn everything that's new from

1:05:07from Linda.com right away.

1:05:10Easy to learn, high quality, easy to follow.

1:05:14Their video tutorials are produced at the highest quality.

1:05:18Courses are broken down into bite size pieces so you can learn at your own pace and learn

1:05:23from start to finish or just find a quick answer.

1:05:27They have beginning level stuff, mid level stuff and expert level courses.

1:05:32They have great, great tools including searchable transcripts.

1:05:37Super super important if you're looking back to find something that you knew you saw a

1:05:40couple weeks ago in a course and you can't find it and you know what it is, you want

1:05:44to search for it, well they've got it because all of their stuff has transcripts.

1:05:47You can make playlists and they even have stuff like certificates.

1:05:51So like when you finish a course you can publish in your LinkedIn profile a certificate of

1:05:56which lynda.com courses you've completed.

1:06:01have mobile apps so you can learn on the go with your iPhone, iPad, even Android. And

1:06:07if you get a premium account, you can download the courses to your mobile device like your

1:06:14iPad, your iPhone, and watch them offline. Premium plan members can also download project

1:06:21files and practice along with the instructor. So how do you get all this? Do you pay for

1:06:25by the video nope one low monthly price you pay 25 bucks per month and that

1:06:32gives you unlimited access to over 100,000 video tutorials the whole

1:06:37library you pay 25 bucks a month you get everything now you might be thinking

1:06:44well 25 bucks a month that's actually not cheap that's that's that's a lot of

1:06:48money here's how confident Linda comm is in their service they have a special

1:06:54deal just for listeners of the show. Go to Linda calm l y n da.com slash the talk show

1:07:02with the and for the next seven days, you can access everything for free no credit card

1:07:09upfront. Just go there linda.com slash the talk show they'll know you're coming from

1:07:14the show. And for seven days, you can watch everything they have unlimited. That's and

1:07:20see for yourself how good this stuff is and that's how confident they are that

1:07:24at the end of that period you're gonna jump at the chance to sign up for an

1:07:27account and stick with them really really good stuff I've I've used it for

1:07:32several things it's really really can't say good enough just how high quality

1:07:37Linda comms material is so my thanks to them and check them out at Linda comm

1:07:40slash the talk show do you still have any machines that are running Mavericks

1:07:47Renee I don't I waited a year to upgrade from

1:07:50Mountain Lion to Mavericks on my podcast machine and I think I lasted a month before putting a somebody on it. I

1:07:56Still have the the air that I used to record these shows

1:08:02Like I'm recording right now using my my old MacBook Air still runs the latest version of Mavericks and it's funny

1:08:10how

1:08:13It feels to me like it's years old. Yeah, like I can't I was just thinking before we started recording and thinking about the you know

1:08:19You're all I was like, I wonder how long I how long how how to date am I and then I realized I'm really only like

1:08:23Still only like two months how to date

1:08:26But it looks ancient to my eyes just the wallpaper when you see the Mavericks wallpaper. It feels like a bygone era

1:08:32Yeah, I think so. But it's there to me. It's the fonts, you know and the the heaviness of the buttons

1:08:40It's yeah, it's it's a much heavier more dour experience and that's probably why I upgraded

1:08:45I just I would look at it when I podcast and it would just look wrong to me

1:08:48And it was a visuals. I think more than anything else that encouraged me to upgrade. Yeah, I think I over the holiday break

1:08:54I'm gonna upgrade this machine to it. I can't think of a good reason to keep one around anymore either. There's nothing you know

1:09:01It's really just out of laziness and the fact that I don't use this machine for much anymore

1:09:06I just happens to be all set up with the you know

1:09:10Software I used to record the shows and so it's sort of like and if it ain't broke don't

1:09:14Fix it

1:09:16Situation but it just staring at it just looks ugly and I got the retina 5k iMac after the event

1:09:23I just couldn't on unsee it and you know that shipped with

1:09:26a ship with

1:09:29Yo, somebody yeah, and I was just all in yeah

1:09:33I've also grown to be completely I don't I wouldn't quite say in love, but I'm completely accustomed to the

1:09:41system version of Helvetica Noya as the system font

1:09:45It's it looks so good on a retina

1:09:49We were arguing the other day whether it you would prefer to have something like San Francisco or the mythical Apple songs

1:09:53If they ever shipped it, but they they did a really great job of putting Helvetica Noya on on the Mac

1:09:59Do you have any idea whether San Francisco is Apple sand? I've heard that it isn't

1:10:03I don't know if that's true or not because I haven't heard it from a lot of people but I heard an offhand comment that it

1:10:07Wasn't I wouldn't be surprised if it's not but I have no no idea

1:10:11Like the little birdies that told me about Apple Sands and the little birdies that told me about San Francisco

1:10:15Or they really tell me about it

1:10:18They didn't know about it in advance, but uh, but that told me that internally they were calling it din vetica

1:10:22But nobody's told me whether they're one in the same and I can't help but think that they're not the same

1:10:28I mean

1:10:29It's hard to interpret it because it's almost like reading smoke signals and it could just mean that this an optimized version

1:10:33version of Apple songs for the watch and that's why they're considered different

1:10:35but it struck me that they were different yeah the thing I've found

1:10:39playing with the San Francisco is that it really only looks good very very

1:10:43small yeah I mean and from my hands-on time you know months ago at the Apple

1:10:49watch event I thought it looked fantastic up close like just really

1:10:53really look good playing with it on my Mac now that we have the SDK it doesn't

1:10:59really look good to me at the sizes that I use fonts on the Mac.

1:11:03Yeah, it's not optimized.

1:11:04Right.

1:11:05And I tried the, I think I mentioned this a few shows ago, but I tried, there's like

1:11:09a GitHub thing with hacked versions of San Francisco that have metadata set that make

1:11:15it look like they tell the system it's the system font.

1:11:18And if you put them, and I don't recommend anybody try this because it's hacking with

1:11:23your system, you're on your own.

1:11:24But more or less what you do is you put these hacked versions, and also it's like a copyright

1:11:28violation and a direct violation of the terms of the SDK download that you're not allowed

1:11:35to diddle with the San Francisco font and you're expressly not allowed to use it for

1:11:38anything other than developing watch kit apps.

1:11:42But what you could do is go to find this project on GitHub, download these versions of the

1:11:47fonts, which are different from Apple's versions.

1:11:49There's some kind of metadata that's set that tells the system, "Hey, this is the system

1:11:52font."

1:11:53them in at slash library or yeah slash library fonts slash library slash fonts

1:12:02and you can't put them in your user font file not you you know users your name

1:12:09library fonts because the system won't look there for system fonts the system

1:12:14looks first in slash system library fonts and that's your Helvetica system

1:12:19font is still there you're not replacing it you're not deleting it you're not

1:12:22renaming it or not moving it. But then the system will look in slash library fonts and

1:12:27if it finds another system font there, it will use that one instead. So you just put

1:12:30these font files there, log out, log back in and Yosemite will draw as with the system

1:12:37font it will use San Francisco. So I tried it just to see what it was like and it just

1:12:45doesn't work. It's not that it doesn't work like it's broken and it's a technical failure.

1:12:52Aesthetically, it's just kind of not right

1:12:55Which is interesting because I didn't think I'd like Helvetica on the Mac as much as I did but then

1:12:59After the Apple TV update which came much after you know much after WBC and now I'm seeing Helvetica on my Apple TV

1:13:06That is much more every time I see it. I get a little reaction to it. Yeah

1:13:10And it feels it's somehow crazy to me how Apple has made it a font that is available to everyone anywhere

1:13:17Feel like they own it

1:13:20Yeah, and it just when they use it. It's it's such an established font

1:13:24It's such a classic and yet it feels so modern in the way that they're using it. Yeah

1:13:27But I don't think at San Francisco to me. It's it's completely designed

1:13:32I think for the watch and it's meant to be used at watch like sizes which are physically very very small

1:13:39Yeah, like the biggest you're ever gonna see text on your Apple watch is a pretty small size

1:13:43It's it's sort of in context

1:13:46I know you've spoken with us on previous shows with the vibrancy and you know some people turn it off

1:13:50But I've even gotten used to that

1:13:52I've gotten used to seeing areas of red or black or or things and it it just I

1:13:56Don't buy the argument that it brings a desktop through but it does sort of make the whole system seem more alive

1:14:02Yeah, but I was no doubt that like Syracuse has mentioned several times

1:14:06There's no doubt that that's gonna get toned down. Yeah next year and a year after you know that they start out with

1:14:11taking an idea to the

1:14:14Maximal level and then over the years dial it back to where it should be but there they you know

1:14:19Apple is it as a company tends to err on the side of taking an idea too far than taking not taking it far enough

1:14:26And it's also they're very for a giant company

1:14:29They've they have a lot of respect for the singular designer vision like the person who designed

1:14:33Somebody had a lot of ideas and those ideas not all of them made it through but a lot of them did in a lot

1:14:37Of companies it would have fallen to design by committee very quickly. Yeah

1:14:41So I think overall Yosemite has been a pretty pretty strong success

1:14:49Yeah, I agree completely and for all the bugs that iOS 8 had and you know hit so many people

1:14:55I think I think Yosemite has been pretty stable and and you know deserves applause right from the get-go for

1:15:02for being pretty

1:15:04Trouble-free if you were an early adopter

1:15:06They had a couple Wi-Fi patch and Wi-Fi and Bluetooth seemed to be something that just affects some percentage of people every time

1:15:12They had some security things even today. They patched it was yesterday. They're patching security now faster than they've ever done before

1:15:19Yeah, it's it's really a new age in at least a delivery of Mac software

1:15:23Yeah today as we record we're recording on December 23rd, and it might have rolled out

1:15:29I think I rolled out last night at least on us time

1:15:32But within the 24 hours that we're recording as we speak

1:15:35There was a bug fix that Apple rolled out that for the first time ever they pushed to

1:15:41At least me of 70, I don't know if Mavericks got the push

1:15:45But if you're running Yosemite, I got the notification like when I logged in this morning

1:15:50It just said a security update was applied. Yeah, and that's it. It's like, you know

1:15:55And I you know, it's a lot of pressure for them because if they ever pushed one of those that did break things

1:16:01it's there it's gonna be you know quite a scandal yeah I mean they're paying

1:16:08close attention to that stuff now but it's sort of we complained that they

1:16:10weren't being fast enough for security updates and a certain point they just

1:16:13you know pick up the pace yeah and I'd you know the the thanks for that the

1:16:18applause for that is never as loud as the criticism beforehand no no no it

1:16:24does seem like they're getting faster I can't help but think that with the

1:16:27Bluetooth and Wi-Fi that it must it must just be that the matrix of how many

1:16:34different Wi-Fi chipsets there are in all the supported Macs that run Yosemite

1:16:39multiplied by all the various chipsets in the Wi-Fi routers out in the real

1:16:45world is just it it's just a testing nightmare like you know you know it's

1:16:53almost we're almost lucky that it works at all because it just happens over

1:16:56and over and over again. I just run all Apple stuff and I've never had a Wi-Fi

1:17:00or Bluetooth problem but I imagine when you like you say if you have every

1:17:02single vendor in there and every single variant you're gonna you're gonna hit

1:17:05whatever bugs are in both those stacks fairly often. Yeah I have an Apple router

1:17:10downstairs I think it's the latest whatever extreme I don't know what they

1:17:14call it anymore but the one that's tall and have for years and I've never been

1:17:20hit with those problems either because I'm surely you know every single

1:17:23Standard Apple Wi-Fi chipset in a Mac does get tested against Apple's own routers

1:17:29Yeah, I think they're first in line, right

1:17:32And I think that max or I mean you see bugs with with iOS and Wi-Fi, too

1:17:39But I do think it seems to hit the Mac more and I can't help

1:17:41But think it's because the Mac hardware is not as unified as iOS hardware

1:17:45I think iPad air 2 is the first iPad where we didn't see a bunch of people complaining about Wi-Fi

1:17:49As soon as it launched

1:17:52Yeah, I get the feeling that like supporting Wi-Fi at the driver level is you know sort of like supporting

1:17:58I'm app when you're writing a mail client

1:18:00Which it meaning that every single I map server has like a different interpretation of the I map spec at some level. Yeah

1:18:08Like there's no way to just write a generic I map client every I map client that it gains any popularity because it hasn't you know

1:18:17It's actually useful

1:18:19Effectively as you know

1:18:21you know, I'm

1:18:22Server by server list of exceptions and and stuff like that which was the big complaint about mail and Mavericks especially with Gmail's

1:18:29Eccentric to use the polite word. I'm app implementation and now with Yosemite. You don't hear that very much anymore either

1:18:35No, you don't I think it's I think they've cleaned that up pretty well. Yeah

1:18:39Where are we at in a calendar year? I think we're heading towards the iPhone 6 and 6 plus event. Yeah

1:18:47Which was also the debut of the watch. Yeah

1:18:50Big and bigger and then small right and Apple pay

1:18:55Yeah, and in the demo area, I mean they had the iPhones laid out. They had the iPads

1:19:00They had the Apple watch laid out and then they had a whole area where you could go and see

1:19:04Apple pay both in the app and at a simulated

1:19:07checkout station

1:19:10Yeah, and I do think that's a good example of how

1:19:14How difficult this you know and broads broke strokes how difficult Apple and you know anybody else who's in the industry?

1:19:22But how it's not a month to month year to year game. It's a decade-long game because even with Apple pay

1:19:30You know it's intertwined with the iPhone 6 because it's the iPhone 6 and 6 plus

1:19:36They're the only phones that work with Apple pay at least at retail terminals

1:19:40and

1:19:43You know you had to have touch ID first so that was a year that goes back a year ago to the iPhone 5s

1:19:49You had to have it and it had to work really well, so that starts a year ago now this year

1:19:56you've got the two new phones that have NFC built in and

1:19:59The rollout in the retail stores of the terminals you know that accept it

1:20:08But you're still talking about a service that only works two months in for people who've bought a brand new

1:20:14Top of the line iPhone within the last two months right like the real the real Apple play is

1:20:20Two three years ago when 85% of active iPhone users are using something iPhone 6 or newer

1:20:27It's it shows the patience that Apple has for some things and it shows how for example

1:20:32NFC to a lot of their competitors was just a chipset like they would just throw it in there

1:20:36They didn't really care what you did with it.

1:20:37Different manufacturers would do different things.

1:20:40Where Apple, there's no such thing as a chip set.

1:20:41It's a feature set.

1:20:42And they experimented with NFC.

1:20:44There were prototypes with NFC for years

1:20:46and they just never shipped it

1:20:46'cause they didn't have a feature set that needed it.

1:20:48Not that it was a curiosity and might be a benefit,

1:20:51but actually needed it as a core technology in the phone.

1:20:54And when they did, they put NFC in and they shipped it.

1:20:56And it took until iPhone 6 for that to happen.

1:20:59But like you said, they had to have Passbook,

1:21:01they had to have Touch ID,

1:21:02they'd have all these things in place.

1:21:04And then when it made sense as a product, it gets shipped.

1:21:06- Yeah, I've heard about NFC for iPhone,

1:21:09I think as far back as 2009,

1:21:12which was the year that the 3GS came out.

1:21:15And that, I'm trying to think when that was

1:21:17that I heard that.

1:21:18I mean, it wouldn't have been right before,

1:21:21it would have been like seven or eight months before

1:21:24that it was a maybe for the next iPhone.

1:21:27And clearly, obviously it did not happen.

1:21:30And I think ultimately, why not?

1:21:33And then again, it was a recurring thing.

1:21:35Like 2009, maybe 2010, definitely maybe

1:21:38Apple is very, very interested in NFC.

1:21:40So that would have been the iPhone 4, wasn't there.

1:21:45And I think it was always,

1:21:46is that there was no story behind it, right?

1:21:49There's no, how is this actually gonna be useful

1:21:52to people in the real world?

1:21:55- Absolutely, I mean, they would prototype it.

1:21:57Apple prototypes almost anything

1:21:59that you can find a blog post about

1:22:00that makes even the slightest logical sense.

1:22:02Apple will have prototyped it.

1:22:04Like when they say Macs make no sense for multi-touch,

1:22:06it's not because they're just daydreaming

1:22:08or saying it for the sake of saying it.

1:22:09It's because they built it,

1:22:10they spent a lot of time trying it

1:22:12and they decided it wasn't an experience they wanna ship.

1:22:14And in one day, maybe it will be.

1:22:16And with NFC, it was in later stage prototypes

1:22:18for different phones and they're trying things

1:22:20and they're, like you said, no story, so it didn't ship.

1:22:22And then as soon as they had a really compelling story,

1:22:24which was Apple Pay, that's in every phone we have now.

1:22:27- Yeah, so tying it in, the iPhone 6 announcement

1:22:31with this week's news.

1:22:33There's another rumor that came out of Asia,

1:22:36some analyst that Apple is considering

1:22:39a new four-inch iPhone for next year.

1:22:44Do you see that?

1:22:46- Yep.

1:22:47- I think MacRumors had it.

1:22:47I think the name the guy came up with it was totally stupid.

1:22:51He called it the iPhone 6S Mini.

1:22:55- Yeah.

1:22:56They just call it the 6S minus.

1:22:58- I think the name would be,

1:22:59- Clearly it would be the iPhone 6C, right?

1:23:01- Yep.

1:23:02- I think it almost certainly would be the iPhone 6C

1:23:05and if not C, then Air maybe.

1:23:08- It's gotta be 6S minus 6S and 6S Plus.

1:23:12Use them, just ride that math analogy into the ground.

1:23:17- Minus.

1:23:18And they'd actually spell it out like M-I-N-U-S.

1:23:21- I think, again, I'm almost, you know,

1:23:23I can't say I'm positive,

1:23:24but I think it's very likely

1:23:25that Apple's prototyping four inch iPhones

1:23:26'cause they prototype tons of different sizes.

1:23:29What was interesting to me is I heard you say that

1:23:30on a previous show, it might've been two episodes ago

1:23:32or three episodes ago.

1:23:33And I was curious what Android people thought of that

1:23:36'cause their phones, I mean, their version of the HTC One Mini

1:23:39was I think five inches or something.

1:23:42And so I asked them, is there a demand

1:23:44for four-inch Android phones?

1:23:45I heard crickets.

1:23:46People said, "No, 4.7 is the smallest we'd ever want."

1:23:50And to me, that doesn't mean Apple should make one.

1:23:52That means there's probably a segment of the market

1:23:54is totally underserved by the volume vendors and that there is opportunity

1:23:58for people who are distinguished or have very specific tastes and would enjoy

1:24:02iOS at that size. Yeah, the thing that makes and this isn't based on this guy's

1:24:07reporting this is just my I close my eyes and think about the way Apple

1:24:10thinks and the way Apple has acted over the last seven years and I think it's

1:24:15probably true but I also think that calling it the 6c whether they call it

1:24:20that or not tells you exactly what it's going to be is I think it's going to be

1:24:23an A8, you know, this year's A8 and a camera like this year's camera, it's, you know, going

1:24:35to be effectively an iPhone 6 shrunk to 4 inches. Whereas the iPhone 6s and 6s plus,

1:24:42if they call them that, will get the A9 and they'll get a better camera and other, you

1:24:48whatever the 2015 technical improvements are.

1:24:52So that you'll be able to buy a four-inch iPhone next year, and you'll have Touch ID,

1:24:58and you'll have Apple Pay, and you'll have an A8, and you'll have a camera like the one

1:25:03we have today.

1:25:04But if you want the top of the line, if you want the newest, the latest, and greatest

1:25:07camera, if you want the latest and greatest system on a chip, you're still going to have

1:25:12to go 4.7 or 5.5.

1:25:16It makes a lot of sense for the same reasons, because the iPhone 5C was always called the

1:25:21cheap iPhone and Apple never makes cheap products, but they wanted to make a popular iPhone.

1:25:25They wanted something that would sit on the shelves, not like a blockbuster movie, but

1:25:28like a TV show that people could buy anytime.

1:25:31But it also let them shove that down to the bottom of the line much faster.

1:25:34They wouldn't have to leave an iPhone 5 there.

1:25:36And the same logic makes sense for an iPhone 6C to be able to move that down the product

1:25:41line faster and make Apple Pay more accessible to more people and to have it in more parts

1:25:45of their product line up.

1:25:46Yeah, and I think the other thing that they don't want is that third pricing tier that

1:25:52starts it.

1:25:53Because that's the other thing.

1:25:54If you do want a new four inch phone next year, if I'm right, then it's going to be

1:25:59the 2014 technical stuff, the A8 and the camera, etc.

1:26:03The upside will be that you'll save money because I think it'll start at $99 on a contract

1:26:08and if it's off contract, it'll be $100 less than the 6S.

1:26:12Success. Yeah, you have 4.7 at the 199 mark the 4-inch just based on human behavior has to be cheaper

1:26:20Yeah

1:26:20The thing that I think they wanted to get away from is having that $99 tier and I'm speaking in the subsidized terms

1:26:27But the $99 tier look virtually identical to the 199 tier. Yeah, right

1:26:35That's what the six or the five see did is they you know, it had exactly the same

1:26:41tech specs

1:26:43Almost to a T as the iPhone 5 but it looked different and some people, you know, obviously some people thought it looked better

1:26:50I know people who bought it because they wanted a colorful phone

1:26:53But it's still even if that's the case then you know good for you. You saved a hundred bucks

1:26:57but I don't think Apple liked it where up until the 5c was introduced the the

1:27:04$99 option looked I'd or nearly identical, you know

1:27:08There were obviously some certain tells that you could tell an iPhone 4 from 4s

1:27:13you know the antenna bands were it's certainly different at slightly different points and

1:27:17earlier that when they first started keeping the year old phone around the 3g and the 3gs you could tell them apart because the eye

1:27:25The word iPhone on the back was written. Yes shiny letters instead of flat letters

1:27:30Well people want to show they have the new one right as part of the esteem of having the new iPhone, right?

1:27:34No, I totally think so, you know, and it's an Apple wants to enable that so that's why I think that you know

1:27:41I don't know if I don't know if an iPhone

1:27:436 C would be plastic like the 5c like I wouldn't be surprised if it's metal or

1:27:51In rounded, you know with rounded corners like the 6s and 6 plus but just the size of it would tell you that it's you

1:27:58Know the lesser model. Yeah, it was funny with the iPhone 5 even though Apple rebuilt it from the Adams on up

1:28:04It was boring, but the minute they made it in gold, you know people first made fun of it

1:28:07And then everyone complained they couldn't get one

1:28:09Did you you know, yeah, it's still hard to get and

1:28:15iPhones yeah, like there's there's still I didn't know that until I was listening to ATP and heard

1:28:21Syracuse are talking about it

1:28:24It's that yeah supply still hasn't caught up with demand

1:28:27Milton has been trying to get them for weeks and I think he had to finally call in favors to try to get them shipped

1:28:33to them.

1:28:34That makes me laugh.

1:28:36Well, it's hilarious because people who leave Apple have no idea how to get a, like how

1:28:39normal people get their phones.

1:28:40Like they just, they've never had to deal with carriers or with retail stores or, and

1:28:44it sounds like some of them, you know, as much as I love them, they're just a little

1:28:46inadequate and equipped to deal with the horrors of retail shopping.

1:28:50Yeah, let me see here.

1:28:54If I get a 6 and I get it in space gray, I get it on Verizon.

1:29:01If I want, well it looks like I can get 128 gigs is available 3 to 5 business days.

1:29:13I think the 6 Plus is still harder than the 6.

1:29:16Yeah.

1:29:17But they're starting to fall into more balance.

1:29:18Which is crazy.

1:29:19I mean as much as people complain about the iPhone, you still can't get them.

1:29:23Get them that there's their come put their supply constraint for months after launch. Yeah

1:29:27Just crazy

1:29:30And I think that's you know, but I still think that's pretty interesting that they're at a point where they still don't catch up in

1:29:36Supply demand until after the holiday. Yeah and year after year - it's not a diminishing thing

1:29:43They're making more and more money off the iPhone. Yeah

1:29:46What's left? I guess we have the last event of the year, which would be the iPad air

1:29:52- yes and Yosemite L and the retina iMac. Yeah

1:29:56Retina iMac is only one it really sticks out to me. I still I love the iPad air - I still think I think it's an

1:30:02amazing device, but it's it's a refinement of the iPad air whereas the

1:30:07The retina 5k Mac is to me like a new a new era the two things that are similar to me about those devices

1:30:15Are that with the iPad air - Apple started making their own GPUs, you know, like an antech first thought it was a six core

1:30:22imagination chip and they later realized that it was an eight core one which was

1:30:27totally theoretical until Apple made it. It wasn't just a design they actually

1:30:31took the architecture and built their own custom GPU and they've been doing

1:30:34CPUs for a couple generations like they had Swift and they had Cyclone now they

1:30:37have Cyclone 2 but now they're doing the entire chip almost is in-house at Apple

1:30:43and then you look at the iMac and they made the timing controller for that

1:30:48They made 5k possible in that computer when Intel has not yet shipped

1:30:51Skylake or Thunderbolt 3 or anything so they are there again. They're making more and more of the internals of their machines

1:30:58Yeah, and that's interesting to me that they've done it for the iMac because they've they've they've had this economy of scale with iOS

1:31:06devices because even as they've expanded the lineups and they've gone out of two iPhone sizes and

1:31:12you know, there's two iPad sizes and

1:31:16There are cellular and non-cellular versions of the iPads, but for the most part it's still in terms of what's actually new this year

1:31:23It's a very limited number of SKUs

1:31:27Right and and they share a lot of stuff, you know that the iPhone 6 and 6 plus

1:31:32Are really very very there's a slight difference in the camera where the the 6 plus camera has optical image stabilization

1:31:40So that's a different part, but it's the same a8 CPU

1:31:44And it's you know, just the stuff that has to be different. It's different, you know different display

1:31:49Because it's a different size and it's different pixels

1:31:53But that they've you know

1:31:57They had this great economy of scale which lets them do these things like you're saying like build their own systems on a chip

1:32:02And not share it with the rest of the you know, have these things that aren't available to anybody else in the industry

1:32:07It's interesting to me that they've done it with the iMac too, which is clearly lower volume. I mean without question

1:32:14I mean, I think all IMAX together are just dropping the bucket volume wise compared to iPad or

1:32:20any iPhone or iPad model, but the retina one in particular existing only at the top of the

1:32:27Product what do you call it the product the pyramid? Yeah the pyramid, right?

1:32:34It's only the best option the good and better ones are still non retina because the retina display

1:32:41You know, it's it's this weird combination where it's you know in one sense

1:32:45It's remarkably inexpensive because famously like Dell has a 5k display didn't they come out with a 5k display

1:32:51They yeah, they came out with a month or so ago, but it requires two

1:32:54Displayport connections, but it costs as much it costs as much or more as the whole I'm yes, right

1:33:00So Dell came out with a 5k display

1:33:02We're just the display and forget about whether you need how you're gonna actually run it and that you need to display ports and all

1:33:07That how are you gonna get graphics cards? How are you gonna get how's everything gonna work?

1:33:10Just forget about it. Just the display itself costs as much as the whole iMac which includes a pretty killer computer. Yeah, and

1:33:18The crazy thing is Apple if you asked me for you know, ten years ago, you know, Apple's not a chip fab

1:33:24They're not an Intel. They're not a TMCH

1:33:25They're not any one of these companies and they got to 64-bit first and now they're they're making chips that are just

1:33:30Pushing the industry forward and they're not a peripheral maker

1:33:33But they're with the original IPS iMac and now with the 5k iMac they're making displays

1:33:38That's just pushing the industry forward and the the iPad air 2 is so overpowered that you could arguably say, you know guys relax

1:33:45Stop but instead of that apples just saying run get as far ahead as fast as you can and just keep going just push

1:33:51The state of this technology because it will filter down and we will figure out a way to make all this stuff super

1:33:55Super important and to do things that nobody else can do. Yeah, and that's it's turning the

1:34:02Industries model on its head where from the outset from the very beginning of personal computing

1:34:09Through recently the model was that it's you know this commodity market where you buy

1:34:16CPUs from Intel you buy graphics cards from Nvidia or you know whoever else

1:34:24Radion I guess it you know, but there'd be graphics companies. There'd be memory makers, you know, there'd be

1:34:32hard drive makers and you would just put all the you know if you wanted to make a computer you'd pick and choose you get the

1:34:38Salad bar, right? I guess yeah, it's totally like a salad bar

1:34:41But everybody else could get them too and you could make deals and depending on your volume

1:34:46I'm sure you know Dell and HP as higher volume vendors would have some sort of leverage in priority

1:34:52Versus you know a smaller

1:34:55by market share PC maker, you know, but

1:34:59It was that the what you were possible. What was possible to do though was

1:35:05limited by these

1:35:07Specialists, so if you wanted to drive a 5k display

1:35:11You were limited unless you could get somebody out

1:35:16You know that less the state-of-the-art in the graphics industry was a graphics card that could push that many

1:35:21pixels and a connector

1:35:24That could carry them

1:35:27Whereas Apple has started turning things like that on its head and it doesn't matter if the industry can't do it yet the state-of-the-art in

1:35:34the industry they just made their own and

1:35:36Made it work. Yeah, and it's not available to anybody else

1:35:40That's the in like you said like to do things that other people can't do

1:35:45What goes back to your only Apple piece from WVDC?

1:35:49Yeah, I think it's you know, probably the best piece I wrote this year

1:35:53I think it's the only one that or at least the one that has the most staying value

1:35:57Even lo these many months later. I think it's it's if anything I underplayed it

1:36:01Yeah, and I think it's true and I think when we like next year we already mentioned

1:36:04Maybe there's a bigger iPad but maybe there's software and services that go along with that and having two gigs and having

1:36:10An octa core GPU makes a lot more sense, you know next year than it makes this year

1:36:14But it allows people who buy the brand new iPad air this year to not feel left behind when the newer devices or newer software ships

1:36:21Mm-hmm. I and I still can't I keep thinking about 64-bit for mobile and you know

1:36:26Nobody else has it yet. I mean there's some chips that are possible of it out for Android

1:36:31But it certainly is far from mainstream

1:36:33Yeah

1:36:33the Nexus 9 I think ship with it just because they they decided they had to have they couldn't wait any longer to

1:36:38Get 64-bit out the door, but it's not in it's not arm. It's Intel right? It's the Nexus 9 I think is

1:36:44X 84 it's 86. I think no, I think it's Qualcomm, but I'd have to double-check. I don't know what either way though

1:36:52It certainly isn't like a mainstream thing

1:36:54But to me it's 64-bit came out and people complained. Oh, there's no four gigabytes of memory

1:36:58Apple's just wasting it but it turns out that the ARM v8

1:37:00Instruction set was so much better and the security that they could use enabled all the touch ID stuff

1:37:06There was just so many other things about building that chipset that 64-bit was almost a bonus for them the same way three cores on

1:37:12The iPhone 6 is almost a bonus and eight cores on the eye on the iPad air - they're doing it because they can there's no

1:37:17Reason not to so why shouldn't we do it?

1:37:20Right. It just goes hand in hand with the new instruction set which is really where the performance wins come from

1:37:25Not the mat not any sort of magical going from 32 to 64 on any hypothetical platform

1:37:31Magically makes things better. It wasn't like that. It was a very very practical, you know arm

1:37:37The new arm instruction set is way better. It gets rid of all sorts of legacy cruft

1:37:42You know that dates back to the early days of arm when it was powering things like the Newton

1:37:48and Palm pilots and stuff like that.

1:37:51- And way more registers, it's just so many benefits.

1:37:54- Right, and everything that the computer engineers

1:37:57have learned since then about how to make efficient

1:38:00instruction sets for computers

1:38:03and what is it that a modern compiler wants to see

1:38:08in an instruction set to generate efficient code?

1:38:11And it was rewritten from scratch with all this cruft gone

1:38:17and all sorts of new stuff to help modern compilers in there.

1:38:21And here we are over a year later,

1:38:23and Apple is still the only mainstream device that has it.

1:38:27And we have Swift and we have Metal.

1:38:29So when you put those technologies all together,

1:38:31eventually the performance is gonna be way beyond

1:38:33what just the hardware delivers.

1:38:35Yeah, and I think that those two things,

1:38:37Swift is obviously new for 2014, Metal is new for 2014.

1:38:44And I think they get to the heart of like,

1:38:49what is Apple going to be like as a big company

1:38:53with big weapons to swing around?

1:38:57And obviously, like I said,

1:39:00the watch that the Canary Nicole found I'm looking for

1:39:02is hubris, and obviously when a company gets bigger,

1:39:05it tries to do more on its own.

1:39:07I mean, Microsoft famously does everything on its own.

1:39:13They're the only company that use back to you know, just little details like that. They use backslashes instead of slashes between directory paths

1:39:20To you know having had their own

1:39:24You know developer toolchain and their own programming language, you know for you know, but they did more than that though

1:39:32I feel like when Microsoft was at its height, you know in the 90s, you know

1:39:37it was the fact that they expanded into things like

1:39:42ownership of slate.com the founding of msnbc you know that they wanted to own a cable news network

1:39:48right why would microsoft want to get involved in cable news you know but

1:39:53i feel like apple as they try to do more and more on their own it's only in the name of enabling

1:40:00features that would be better for the products they're already making right like for enterprise

1:40:05they didn't decide to create an enterprise company or buy an enterprise company they partnered with

1:40:08IBM to let them do what they did well.

1:40:10Right. Yeah, that's a great example of that they didn't create this new enterprise division

1:40:17within Apple, which is outside their expertise and risks losing their focus.

1:40:23If Tim Cook wants to make a big bet and do this, he doesn't have to spend anywhere near

1:40:29as much attention on it as he would in this world where they're willing to say, "You know what?

1:40:35We just want our devices to be used in the enterprise

1:40:38We'll let IBM handle how to make the sales and how to write these you know these apps that are meant for that market

1:40:44It's a perfect example

1:40:46Yeah, much better than buying SAP or something that the imaginary people always want Apple to buy right and Swift

1:40:52You know is an example where they're not they didn't create a new programming language to change computer science

1:40:58It's not you know if anything that the critiques from people who are like

1:41:03Programming language critics is that it's sort of a boring language. There's nothing outlandish about it. There's nothing novel about it

1:41:11It's just a nice simple language, you know in term not not that there aren't clever things under the hood and like the fact that

1:41:20You know

1:41:23Most of the language it's designed is is defined in the runtime not in the language itself

1:41:29The language itself is super super minimal

1:41:30There's something you know artistic about that, but effectively it's just what kind of programming language

1:41:36Would you write would you want to enable the sort of software that Apple wants to run?

1:41:42That's it. It's just a very very practical language

1:41:45You know and what would you get when you have a language that's

1:41:50Led by the compiler guy Chris Ladner or a company that lets the compiler guy leave the language, right?

1:41:57But it's sort of the opposite of the sort of hoity-toity

1:42:00academic languages that you know with the new programming languages that I remember when I was young and in college in the 90s where it

1:42:07Was all led it was you know that the the practical utility them was completely abstracted. It was all

1:42:14Philosophical in terms of what was driving the decisions behind them

1:42:19Yeah, it's a language designed to be used by Apple and and sooner rather than later

1:42:23Yes, very much so and very much designed, you know as

1:42:27Syracuse's pointed out on ATP

1:42:30It's we've already one thing we've got that is not going to budge is we've already got these frameworks the cocoa frameworks and

1:42:37In theory if they were going to start with all new frameworks, maybe they'd come up with a new language

1:42:41But it's we've got these frameworks that are you know have these you know that are already designed and already have these these

1:42:48You know design patterns what type of new language would we use that would best leverage them?

1:42:53And that's one of the things that I really like about the way that Apple is running now is there

1:42:57No, they don't have to restart everything again

1:42:59They can do something like add

1:43:01LLVM and add Swift and do these things that

1:43:04Take them further without having to destroy or stop or paid an artificial break between what they had before

1:43:09It's like they're swapping the parts behind the scenes and if you're not paying attention

1:43:12You might not even see it, but it gives them tremendous benefit over time. Yeah and metal likewise

1:43:18You know, it's it's it's the only it's the sort of thing you can only do when you have a big user base

1:43:25I mean Microsoft famously has done that with the DirectX, you know, we're Mike, you know

1:43:30And it's you know sustained to this day that their leadership in PC gaming, you know

1:43:35If that there's probably no area of computing where they're stronger than PC gaming

1:43:40And they're able to say here's you know, here's the graphics language

1:43:44you're going to use and that's it and they can do that because they've got the

1:43:48footprint

1:43:50Apple couldn't do metal, you know

1:43:53Ten years ago with the Mac

1:43:55I mean, it's still not on the Mac

1:43:56But they couldn't and I don't think they could have I don't think it would have really taken off in 2008 or 2009

1:44:01They really needed that massive hundreds of millions of users base and this you know

1:44:08This de facto

1:44:10Position is like the leading handheld gaming market and now it's not like they're forcing it down developers throats there

1:44:18You know, you don't have to use it

1:44:20It's not like they're they've said like oh next year if you don't use if your game isn't using Swift

1:44:25It won't be in the App Store

1:44:27it's something developers want to use though because

1:44:29It's it gives them better performance and lets them hit

1:44:35You know a huge number of their users and it was something that they could announce at

1:44:39WWDC while they were announcing that I forget the four or five biggest game engines in the world were all supporting it

1:44:44so for most developers they

1:44:46Quote-unquote get it for free because the engine that they're already using is just now getting the benefits of all of that, right?

1:44:50all right, and it's definitely a

1:44:53Yeah, I guess that it's in broad strokes

1:44:57it's the sort of thing Apple could only do now that they're big and

1:45:00the market leader and that wouldn't it just wasn't possible in the old days when they were

1:45:06The little guy on the sides when the adobe's and Microsoft's could say no, we're not going to support your

1:45:11Your rap city. Yeah, that's a you know, perfect example, right?

1:45:16Although the rhapsody thing was a little bit more it's funny because they were a little bit more

1:45:21Adamant back then where their initial proposal with adamant with rap city was you're going to rewrite your apps in cocoa

1:45:28Or else you have to run in this little little ghetto

1:45:34environment

1:45:35Whereas, you know even with Swift like I said, they're not saying you have to use Swift

1:45:39even though they could

1:45:42Really? I mean, I think they could get away with it. But you know, they're not because I feel like there's a

1:45:48Humility to them

1:45:51Yeah, I mean absolutely and you get people like, you know, Brent Simmons now

1:45:54We get to play around with it and blog about all their experiences with it and the benefits everybody

1:45:58It's almost like a built-in

1:45:59They don't do betas the way Google does but the way they're releasing it gives a lot of people a lot of time

1:46:03To weigh in beyond the five and then hundred people at Apple who knew about it

1:46:06let me take a break here and thank our third and final sponsor of

1:46:10The show and it's our good friends at hover

1:46:14HOV ER

1:46:17Hover is and I say this without any hesitation the world's best way to manage and buy domain names

1:46:26there are domain registrar and

1:46:29They're the best they really are they've been around for a long time. They've been around I think 15 years maybe even more

1:46:35They have tremendous customer service they have a no gimmick no upsell

1:46:43No, scammy buying process. They have great search for domain names

1:46:49They have great tools to help you if the one you're looking for your first guess is the domain name you want

1:46:54You type it in ends up. It's already taken ends up. None of the

1:46:58the top level domains where it's available or what you want.

1:47:01They have great tools to help you find one,

1:47:03a similar domain name that you do want.

1:47:07In less than five minutes with hover,

1:47:11you can find the domain name you want,

1:47:13get it up and running.

1:47:14All you have to do is search for

1:47:15keywords and they'll show you the best options.

1:47:18If you've ever registered a domain name anywhere else,

1:47:21and I'm guessing that the number of listeners of this show who

1:47:24own just one domain name is probably minimal.

1:47:27I mean, I think most of the people like me probably have a problem and have too many

1:47:31domain names, most of them unused.

1:47:33But if you've ever registered a domain name anywhere else, you know that most of the other

1:47:38registrars out there make it a really unpleasant experience.

1:47:43They make it complicated just to buy what you really need.

1:47:45They try to upsell you with stuff you don't need on your way to the shopping cart.

1:47:48You have to double check that they haven't already inserted something that you don't

1:47:52want in there.

1:47:53And they make you pay extra to upgrade for things that should be included like who is

1:47:57privacy.

1:47:58Like you don't have to pay extra to hover to get your who is record made private.

1:48:04It's just part of the service that they offer because who wouldn't want it made private.

1:48:10I remember years ago it used to be your who is registry had to have your home phone number

1:48:14in it or an active working phone number and then telemarketers could just go through who

1:48:20as records and get a you know a list of working phone numbers you don't want

1:48:24that you want privacy hover just gives it to you for free here's the most

1:48:29amazing thing though this I say this every time that they sponsor the show

1:48:32they have what they call part of their technical support is free valet

1:48:37transfer service so if you've already got domains at some other registrar if

1:48:42you're willing to give hover your login information to your to your registry

1:48:48account at the other registrar. They will just move your domains over from your old

1:48:53registrar to your new one at hover and take care of all the stuff that needs to be changed

1:48:59the DNS and all that stuff. This is all their their valet transfer people do their experts

1:49:05in moving domains. You like me probably are not an expert in moving domains. And when

1:49:10you do it, you make a mistake with DNS, you can ruin your day, you could knock your website

1:49:15offline for the day before when you fix it propagates to everywhere that got the bad

1:49:20stuff.

1:49:22Just amazing.

1:49:24No wait, no hold, no transfer technical support.

1:49:28You just call them up.

1:49:29You call them up on the phone and they answer the phone like a person answers the phone.

1:49:33Amazing.

1:49:34So where do you go to find out more?

1:49:37Go to hover.com and use this promo code.

1:49:40The promo code for my show this week is scotch, like the beverage, S-C-O-T-C-H.

1:49:46Use scotch as your promo code at Hover and you'll get 10% off your first purchase by

1:49:53going to hover.com and typing in that promo code.

1:49:57Can't recommend them highly enough.

1:49:58Great thing, you got time to burn over the holidays and you got your domains tied up

1:50:02at some shitty registry.

1:50:04Go to Hover, sign up, use that code scotch and move your domains over.

1:50:09save money and then you'll you'll email me and you'll say I can't believe I

1:50:12didn't move my stuff over to hover before so my thanks to hover drink any

1:50:16good scotch lately Renee only when I'm out with you and guy that's the time

1:50:21when I get the bourbon in the scotch I don't think I've had any scotch lately

1:50:25or if I do I don't remember so lack of Christmas Apple events yeah so that's it

1:50:32though I think that what else is up for 2014 and review I think there's sort of

1:50:36things that we could touch on just quickly one is the

1:50:38Tim Cook beyond just running at Apple, but the the moves he's made towards the inclusivity and towards equal opportunity. Oh

1:50:45liberties I

1:50:47Can't believe I didn't think of that. I think that's it's absolutely been a big year for that

1:50:51That his essay I think was just absolutely pitch-perfect

1:50:55Just his own version of you know thoughts on and but it was so much more personal

1:51:02Yeah, I think even if he hadn't written that and come out himself as gay this year

1:51:08I think it would still be worth talking about the like you said inclusivity and

1:51:12Etc that that he's led and that Apple is pushed this year

1:51:17It's terrific and it reminds me of the story that I heard

1:51:20You know what?

1:51:21Scott forest all whether he really wanted to make Apple a more inclusive company and he believed that you in order to hire more

1:51:28With more diversity you had to have more diversity in the hiring process. So when he would get they had terrific female engineer

1:51:34I mean Vicki Murley famously but terrific female engineers on the Safari team, for example

1:51:38And they would they would not only send them on the resumes

1:51:41but they would send them out to you know on the job hunt to the to the colleges because they knew that they would come

1:51:46back with a different perspective and

1:51:48We we haven't seen tremendous spread of that effect

1:51:51We haven't seen a huge swing in the amount of women or minorities and in jobs in Silicon Valley

1:51:56But we have seen improvements and I think with Apple's report as disappointing as the results might be to many people

1:52:01The exposure that it gets and the willingness for people to want to make it better. I think we're huge this year

1:52:06Yeah, and I think it's again another one of those things where I think you can really just take Tim Cook at his word

1:52:14Yeah, and it's no euphemism. It's not just you know, trying to say what people want to hear

1:52:20I think he means it where a he thinks it's just right

1:52:23it's just the right thing to do but be that that that fierce competitor in him you can tell when he says it that

1:52:29It's there's there's obviously so much untapped talent

1:52:33outside

1:52:36The white male engineer, you know, yeah whites and Asians, you know that everybody else women people of color

1:52:43men and women

1:52:46It's the talent is out there and Apple is starved for talent and they want it

1:52:52you know, so there's in addition to the the

1:52:55Justice angle, you know that it's the way it should be that that people don't feel welcome in the industry

1:53:02But it there's also just a purely

1:53:04competitive aspect to it

1:53:07It's it was that beautiful moment too with Tim Cook when they were at the shareholders meeting and the guy stood up and he said why

1:53:12Are you waste basically said why are you wasting my money on?

1:53:15Environmentalism and accessibility and Tim Cook said, you know that this stuff matters and if you don't think it matters

1:53:20Just get the hell out of the stock, right? It was the guy brought up ROI

1:53:23Yeah, an investment and you know and it was fascinating

1:53:27You know that that cook got as angry as he did and said everything we do isn't about the bloody our ROI

1:53:34Yeah, and it's funny that he said bloody because she says, you know clearly he's not British

1:53:38She's he's the cool one right like we'd expect that from Steve Jobs

1:53:41Steve Jobs was bombastic

1:53:42But Tim Cook always looked like he would just sit there with laser beams in his eyes and that for him is hugely emotional

1:53:48Right, it wouldn't be surprising if Tim Cook I mean if Steve Jobs had gotten angry at a Cheryl

1:53:54Yeah, whereas Tim Cook is the guy you'd think no matter what any crackpot shareholder would say

1:53:58He's not gonna get angry

1:53:59But he did that clearly angered him and again like when I think was the Financial Times that named him their

1:54:05CEO of the year there was somebody there was a couple yes so far

1:54:09But the one that I linked to I remember that they led their their here's why with that anecdote and I think in hindsight

1:54:16said it was the most telling anecdote of the year you know in terms of Tim Cook

1:54:21being unscripted yes you know I think in terms of what was scripted and what it

1:54:25was planned his you know his coming out essay in business week was probably it

1:54:30but that moment at the shareholders meeting I think was the most telling

1:54:34impromptu moment yeah and you know it really made me think it's strange to say

1:54:39but it made me think a lot more of Tim Cook because you know it is hard to tell

1:54:42he is so controlled in public and so on message and so on point and he's such

1:54:46He's so gifted as a thinker and someone who controls logistics and all these things to see his remotional response sort of added

1:54:53A whole new dimension to him as not just a CEO, but a person

1:54:56yeah, I think absolutely and

1:54:59You know, and I think that's it. It's also a to me a sign of the long-term thinking

1:55:06That the Apple, you know under jobs, you know constantly, you know consistently since since the in the post next

1:55:15Verification era, you know that they've been a long-term company that's looking at building a company that's going to be here for 50 or 100 years

1:55:22You know that's going to outlive everybody who's at the company today, you know

1:55:27And there's I really do think that that's what they're looking at that they're trying to build an institution that's going to still be here

1:55:33when Tim Cook and Phil Schiller and Angela aren'ts are all long retired and you know

1:55:40Frankly in the grave. Yeah, and how do you do that? Well, you don't do it by sweating the ROI on every single thing you do

1:55:47Yeah, and it's you know, the other thing too it that and I think it's probably what burned him up is

1:55:54It's not like Apple, you know has dipped into low profit margins and that they're still spending money

1:56:01I think it was in particular with the

1:56:03the the clean energy for the data centers and

1:56:08Spending money on thing, you know worrying about things like their environmental impact on global warming or climate change, whatever you want to call it

1:56:15Carbon footprint. Yeah, it definitely struck a chord with him. It was a good chord to been struck

1:56:21And you know the whole, you know social

1:56:25Equality angle is has clearly I don't think Steve Jobs was against it, but it's you know

1:56:34Apple is clearly as a company is clearly more outspoken about it now than they were under him

1:56:39Well jobs seem to believe that all that stuff was deeply personal charity charitable donations and support for causes was something that he believed that

1:56:45Apple paying that people could let people spend their own money on but it wasn't at a corporate level where Tim Cook

1:56:50You know, he took Apple on the gay pride parade. He's put Apple behind equal employment legislation

1:56:55He's really believed that the power and and wealth of Apple can be used for more than just generating more power and wealth. Yeah

1:57:03Yeah

1:57:04Absolutely. All right, and what was your second thing? My second thing was I was gonna talk about the App Store stuff

1:57:08But I feel like it's a bit of a downer at the end now

1:57:10Maybe we did him in the wrong order

1:57:12Well, we should still do it. Well, we'll let whiskers fix it. Okay

1:57:16Right with the

1:57:22Well the today view widgets right this that people you know

1:57:29in short it was like Apple introduced these today view widgets and

1:57:33At WWDC and then you know, I think they might have even literally said we can't wait to see what you guys do with them

1:57:39yeah, and

1:57:40Then they saw what people were doing with them and rejected a whole bunch of the most clever

1:57:46versions of them

1:57:48Who was it

1:57:51Was it I think it was James Thompson's p-calc. Yeah, that was simultaneously being promoted

1:57:58in the App Store with a banner for great new uses of TodayView widgets because he added

1:58:06a calculator.

1:58:07So without even opening the app right in TodayView, if you put the PCALC widget in, you could

1:58:11just do your calculation right there.

1:58:14It was being promoted as a great new widget at the same time that the review team had

1:58:19contacted him and said, "You know what?

1:58:21That's outside the bounds of what we intended to be enabled, so you're going to have to

1:58:24submit a new build that takes that out."

1:58:27On the outside it looks absolutely insane and I think it's worth explaining, not to

1:58:31excuse it, but sort of to explain it.

1:58:33So extensibility is this huge new feature and everyone is trying to ship iOS 8 and developers

1:58:38are trying to get their apps approved and app review is the worst time of the year to

1:58:41work in app review.

1:58:42And they bring in as many people as they can and they try to get as many apps as possible

1:58:46onto the store.

1:58:47And as soon as an app is approved, and this is all under Phil Schiller's org, that moves

1:58:51to Eddy Cue's org where they have app editorial and they need to program the entire app store

1:58:55or promotion for all that stuff,

1:58:57and all they see is approved.

1:58:58They have no idea what might be going on behind the scenes.

1:59:00It's flagged as approved, it's fine for editorial.

1:59:02And then when things sort of slow down again,

1:59:04people who are higher up in App Store review,

1:59:07who have a lot of ideas about what they believe,

1:59:09you know, and they sincerely believe

1:59:11certain things about experience,

1:59:12and whether a button will confuse an average user,

1:59:14or whether someone is spending time in Notification Center,

1:59:17and they're not supposed to,

1:59:18it's supposed to be a quick conduit.

1:59:20And they care a lot about these things,

1:59:21and they'll flag it, and then it'll get removed,

1:59:24and it won't make any sense,

1:59:25Developers will appeal and it'll go to a higher level and it might end up on the executive review committee's desk

1:59:30And they might say it's fine

1:59:31You know stop worrying about it

1:59:33And but it I think extensibility was so new that it created a disconnect between what was technically possible

1:59:38And what people who had been in app review, you know me at a slightly higher level for many years

1:59:43Thought should be the experience on the system

1:59:46Yeah, I think that's a very good way to put it and I think maybe the transmit

1:59:53It was transmitted right yeah, yeah that had the sharing to

1:59:58Storage services like box.net and Dropbox and I cloud drive

2:00:06You know that

2:00:09Completely within the the they didn't they didn't use any non-private or non-public

2:00:15Apis all public api's the sharing sheet itself the the what's it called move to?

2:00:22whatever you want to call it send to send to

2:00:24They don't have any control over it's part of that whole

2:00:29Inner application communication that that enables so many of these continuity features and sharing

2:00:37It's one sheet that can't line item veto certain services right because the system is drawing it which is

2:00:42Why Apple is opening up seemingly opening up and letting you do these things that you couldn't do before?

2:00:48and

2:00:50Then they were told you can't you can't do this for iCloud Drive. You can't send anything you you can't send anything

2:00:57That wasn't created in your your own app to iCloud Drive

2:01:00Which meant like you said because you don't have line item veto on the services that are listed

2:01:05That you had to take out the whole thing and now the app couldn't send to anybody

2:01:09Including Dropbox or box or anybody who Apple doesn't care about

2:01:14Whereas it almost seemed like it was exactly why they added the send to in the first place so that you could do things like that

2:01:21It's again when you look at it from certain perspective and I'm not supporting this perspective

2:01:25But I know it's almost thing like, you know

2:01:27I understand is that they didn't they don't want the line item veto because they think that there can be disputes within companies that would

2:01:32Cause one company to sort of remove a competitor or remove a service and that's not to the benefit of the user

2:01:37But the original model on Mac it's the same like there was Apple made a calculator widget for OS 10

2:01:43and they didn't make one for iOS for a variety of reasons,

2:01:45but they thought it wasn't the right experience.

2:01:47So they deliberately didn't make one.

2:01:49Then, you know, James Thompson,

2:01:50who's a phenomenal developer did make one.

2:01:52For iCloud drive on the Mac,

2:01:53you could put any arbitrary file there,

2:01:54but on iOS, it was sort of understood

2:01:56that you could only put files that you created or edited,

2:01:59because that meant the user knew that they were in your app

2:02:01and was working on them,

2:02:03and they would understand it was in that space.

2:02:05But then something like transit comes along,

2:02:06which is the, you know, quote unquote,

2:02:08Steve Jobs unforeseen thing.

2:02:09And it's taken to the level where they can say,

2:02:11This isn't what we intended for it to do,

2:02:14but it's not taken to the level of thinking,

2:02:15well, is it a good thing anyway?

2:02:17Like, should we let it in anyway?

2:02:19So it gets rejected, then it gets appealed,

2:02:21then it gets overturned,

2:02:22and it makes Apple look horrible in the press.

2:02:24It stresses out the developers,

2:02:25and it affects the features that customers believe

2:02:27that they've paid for, and don't have paid for,

2:02:30and it's just not a good outcome for anybody.

2:02:32- Yeah, but I do, yeah.

2:02:33And if you, like you said though,

2:02:34I think if you wanna try to understand why,

2:02:36it's that it's so new, and there's so many moving pieces.

2:02:40And the thing that made-- if you understood everything that

2:02:45was going on, the thing that made Transmits--

2:02:47and again, Transmit wasn't yanked from the App Store.

2:02:49They got a mostly friendly notification

2:02:53that they were told, you need to submit a new build that

2:02:56takes this out.

2:02:58And they couldn't wait forever.

2:03:00I'm sure that at some point, Apple would--

2:03:02It's like two weeks usually, I think.

2:03:03Yeah.

2:03:04And it's more or less, take out those lines of code

2:03:06that do this, test your new build, and submit it,

2:03:09and we'll do this.

2:03:10I don't think it's any surprise that it was the iOS version

2:03:15that caused the problem.

2:03:17Now, if you understood what was going on,

2:03:18it didn't make any sense though,

2:03:19because nothing you could do from the iOS version,

2:03:21no file that you could put, move from transmit

2:03:26to your iCloud drive.

2:03:28You couldn't do the exact same thing on Yosemite.

2:03:31You could do the exact same thing.

2:03:32So there was nothing that they were,

2:03:35whoever it was who thought they needed

2:03:38to not be able to do this from their iOS app,

2:03:41it was seemingly unaware that whatever it was

2:03:44that you would do, whether it was a porno file

2:03:46or a illegally downloaded movie or whatever it is

2:03:49that they were worried about, was it copyright, whatever.

2:03:52- Or just stealing files, you know, you load an app

2:03:54and it starts taking your files and putting it

2:03:55on someone's server somewhere.

2:03:56- Yes.

2:03:57It was all stuff that you could do right in a finder

2:04:02in Yosemite, you can put whatever file you want

2:04:03in your iCloud drive, you know, in the same way

2:04:06that the finder doesn't keep you from moving,

2:04:07You know a file from any folder anywhere to any other folder

2:04:11But I think it's understandable because that you know it the review teams and it correct me if you're wrong

2:04:17I think you might know more about their internal makeup, but the Iowa it's not like a review team

2:04:21There's iOS reviewers and Mac. Yes, and the iOS reviewers are coming from a years-long

2:04:28history of you know, what's restricted on iOS and

2:04:33moving files that weren't created in app whatever your app is to anywhere else has always been

2:04:40Forbidden and so it's you know, I could see how it even got high up

2:04:44Not to the highest levels but pretty high up and they thought no this has to be against the rules

2:04:49This isn't something that iOS does I wrote a piece about this and one of the things I just wanted to

2:04:53To help people understand is that when you say like Apple rejected it Apple has these same discussions

2:04:59Like if you listen to ATP or you listen to the talk show, that's the discussion that's happening inside Apple as well

2:05:03and there's people advocating very strongly that these things should be allowed, and there's

2:05:07people advocating saying, "This button here is going to confuse somebody.

2:05:10They'll press it.

2:05:11They'll suddenly be an app.

2:05:12They won't know where they are."

2:05:13And they're not modeling it for me or you or Marco or John or somebody.

2:05:16They're marketing it for our parents and our non-sophisticated tech-using relatives.

2:05:22There are some people who are deeply, deeply concerned that they have a very sensible,

2:05:26understandable experience.

2:05:28You could argue that widgets and extensibility in general is a pretty nerdy feature, and

2:05:32anyone using it probably knows what they're doing.

2:05:34And I think that's the argument that's winning out now.

2:05:37But it really is these sorts of discussions.

2:05:39And people want more rules sometimes on the App Store,

2:05:42but Apple believes that the more,

2:05:43my understanding is that Apple believes

2:05:45that the more rules will actually chill innovation.

2:05:47And they'd much rather see James Thompson,

2:05:49as annoying as it is, make a calculator widget,

2:05:51have it rejected, then have it approved,

2:05:53then have him to see a rule and just never make it

2:05:55or have to lobby for a change in the rule.

2:05:57That might take years.

2:05:58Because right now as ugly and as frustrating

2:06:00as a process was we have PCalc, we have Transmit,

2:06:03we have all these things now officially on the store

2:06:05and we have these things officially clarified.

2:06:06And it's only been like two months.

2:06:09- That's a good point.

2:06:10- Yeah, I would like to see,

2:06:11and I wrote a thing about this,

2:06:12but I think it would be great for everybody

2:06:14if there was a public facing vice president of App Store.

2:06:17There are really good directors of App Stores,

2:06:20there's really good people in both Schiller and Q's org,

2:06:24but they're split over all these different organizations

2:06:26and much like software development

2:06:28accelerated under Federighi and stores are accelerating under Angela Ahrens.

2:06:32I think if there was somebody whose only job it was to make a fantastic

2:06:36experience on the App Store, whether it's making review better, whether it's adding

2:06:40sloppy search finally to the App Store, but to someone who all he had to do is

2:06:45wake up every day and make developers and customers super happy, I think that

2:06:48would improve the situation for everybody. What's the word, there's a word

2:06:53like newspapers sometimes have them. Ombudsman's. Ombudsman. That's yeah I was

2:06:59thinking the New York Times doesn't call them an ombudsman they call the the

2:07:03public editor. Only and my understanding of why is that for decades they rejected

2:07:09having an ombudsman and then when they finally added an ombudsman they didn't

2:07:13want to say okay now we have an ombudsman they just call their ombudsman

2:07:16the public editor. But the idea of the ombudsman is that at a newspaper for

2:07:21example the ombudsman doesn't is independent and doesn't report to the

2:07:25you know editor-in-chief of the newspaper and so a reader who has a

2:07:29problem with let's say the and it's some sort of bias in the coverage of anything

2:07:33can go to the ombudsman and the ombudsman can conduct like an independent review I

2:07:38would love to see Apple have an App Store ombudsman yeah you know and and

2:07:46And I think the way to do it would be to write a blog.

2:07:52And have a blog--

2:07:53so it's not like anybody could create an ombudsman issue.

2:07:59The ombudsman would still get to choose what they wrote about,

2:08:02but that they could look at something like pCalc

2:08:05or Transmit.

2:08:06And not just like when I write about it, or you write about it,

2:08:12and kind of make a stink and hope somebody at Apple

2:08:15reads our sites and does something about it.

2:08:17But before going public with it,

2:08:19the ombudsman could go inside and go to somebody

2:08:22and do the research and maybe get it clarified

2:08:25without the stink.

2:08:27- Yeah, sort of deescalate it

2:08:28before it hits the media and the executives.

2:08:31- Yeah, but then the ombudsman, as somebody inside Apple,

2:08:36could then write a post

2:08:37that maybe explains what Apple is thinking.

2:08:40And again, without making new rules

2:08:42and creating an ever more complicated set of guidelines

2:08:46for the App Store, at least sort of explain

2:08:49in plain English, here's the sort of things

2:08:51that are okay in a today view widget

2:08:53and here's the sort of things that aren't.

2:08:56- And I think that's a really good idea

2:08:57because we're friends with a lot of people

2:09:00who make productivity and creativity apps

2:09:01and that's where this is a problem.

2:09:03The people making Clash of Clans and Candy Crush

2:09:05and all the people who are making the billions of dollars

2:09:07on the App Store, there's no uncertainty for them,

2:09:09there's no problem with app review for them.

2:09:11they're all fine.

2:09:12- Right, I'm sure it never occurred to the developer

2:09:15to make a version of Crossy Road

2:09:18that runs as a today to view widget.

2:09:20- Yeah, and I mean, those are the easy problems,

2:09:22it's the ones that are more shades of gray

2:09:25that have these problems.

2:09:27And the other argument that it's killing innovation,

2:09:29I mean, I've had Android devices for four or five years,

2:09:31they have a much easier review process than Apple does.

2:09:34And I've not seen the groundbreaking platform making

2:09:38sort of future apps arrive on Android any faster

2:09:41because of that than iOS.

2:09:43And it's easy to say maybe Android sucks,

2:09:44and that's why it doesn't happen.

2:09:45But it's also possible that Apple does add background tasks

2:09:48and they do add extensibility,

2:09:50and they do add the features that they need to add

2:09:53to give developers sort of the tools

2:09:54that they need to make these sorts of apps.

2:09:56And it's possible that things like Workflow and Uber

2:09:59get made regardless of what App Review does,

2:10:01because those things, as cool as they are,

2:10:04they don't come across anywhere near

2:10:06the lines that Apple draws.

2:10:09Well, on the other hand though, I do think, to take a devil's advocate position, we do

2:10:14have far more, a far richer variety of outside the bounds of the stock factory OS productivity

2:10:24software on Mac than we do iOS.

2:10:27The difference is that iOS is starting with this foundation of we, Apple, are promising

2:10:34you that nothing you install from the App Store is going to do something like run away

2:10:39in the background or be hard to uninstall if you don't like it.

2:10:47Whereas the risks you take on the Mac of allowing anything and everything that you can download

2:10:53outside the App Store is that you have utilities that can be hard to uninstall.

2:10:58I tried to uninstall BlackBerry Connect and it was a nightmare.

2:11:02You know, it's always I think it's less of a problem than it used to be

2:11:05But it's always been a problem and that you might add uncertainty and if you feel like, you know

2:11:10Like a non technical user like we know that if the fans running on your computer and you don't think it should be you can

2:11:15Go to activity monitor or up there to the battery menu and it'll tell you you know in recent versions

2:11:20Who's you know, which app is using excessive power?

2:11:22You know, but it's can be it can be confusing to a typical user

2:11:28They don't know to do those things and what if it's some app that they've never heard of because it's you know

2:11:33The helper app for another app. It's a faceless background app. That doesn't doesn't even show up in their doc

2:11:39Well, then what do they do? You know iOS has this promise of

2:11:43We're you're never gonna have to worry about those things and you know part of that promise it only happens if if

2:11:50Everything goes through an App Store review process

2:11:53Which is why to install the keyboard you got to download an app and even though that app does absolutely nothing

2:11:57once you've downloaded it and if you delete it,

2:12:00the keyboard goes away, it's still the same mechanism

2:12:02to deliver all the new features that they're adding.

2:12:05It's an interesting problem to solve.

2:12:06And I think, you know, I use PCALC, the widget all the time.

2:12:10I barely, sorry, James, I barely launch PCALC anymore

2:12:12'cause a widget is just enough almost all the time.

2:12:15And I use drafts and I use transmit

2:12:17and I love all these features

2:12:18and I'm happy that Apple reversed the stuff.

2:12:20I just think that it's worth breaking down the process

2:12:23that happens because the more you understand it.

2:12:25- Did drafts get everything back?

2:12:26- Yes.

2:12:27Well, I wasn't aware of that.

2:12:29I knew that they had had some, you know, the same type of issues.

2:12:32Yeah.

2:12:33Well, that's good to know.

2:12:34The only thing that was rejected outright was the app launcher, because Apple really

2:12:37doesn't believe that other things should launch apps.

2:12:39And the guy who tried...

2:12:40There was a rule that says you couldn't have keyboards in widgets.

2:12:42So the guy basically drew his own instead of invoking the built-in one, and that was

2:12:46still rejected.

2:12:47Yeah, I think it comes down to my...

2:12:48I forgot I was arguing earlier where you have to err on one side or the other.

2:12:52And that at least with iOS, Apple is going to continue to err on the side of being a

2:12:59little too strict.

2:13:02And you know, the side effect of that, like the benefit of that is that abusive software

2:13:11isn't going to, is less likely to slip through.

2:13:15The downside to it is, like you said, sometimes it's going to take some ugly airing of dirty

2:13:21laundry, public airing of dirty laundry, to get it sufficiently looked at by a high enough

2:13:27level person.

2:13:28And I think, I don't want to call it a problem, but I think the sign of the change is that

2:13:32Craig Federicchi, he skews more towards geeky than Scott Forrestal.

2:13:35I mean, it was hard to get airdrop on the iPhone, and now we have extensibility and

2:13:41continuity.

2:13:42And App Store review hasn't changed the way software development has changed.

2:13:46They're still very much the organization they were back in the Forrestal era, and there's

2:13:50is gonna be some tension until that's worked out.

2:13:52As we get geekier features, we're gonna,

2:13:55the iPhone was not made for geeks.

2:13:56It was made for mainstream people.

2:13:58It was a smartphone that everybody could use,

2:14:00but geeks loved it as well.

2:14:01And now it's becoming a phone that works great for geeks

2:14:04because of these features.

2:14:05And I think app review is gonna have to evolve

2:14:07the way software has.

2:14:09- Yeah, totally agree.

2:14:10All right, I think that catches up.

2:14:14I think that's our year in review.

2:14:16- Good year.

2:14:17- Yeah, it was.

2:14:18Excited about next year?

2:14:20I can't wait everything from the Apple watch to the theoretically larger iPad to the new features. We'll see with it and an iOS 9

2:14:27It's I think it's gonna be a great year. I guess I think one thing is for sure

2:14:32I think one thing when we if we look back a year from now in 2015

2:14:36I think the first half of 2015 is gonna be a lot more interesting than the first half of 2014

2:14:41Yeah, it's gonna be harken back. I think to the first year

2:14:43I wouldn't be surprised if the first year

2:14:45Sorry

2:14:45the first part of 2015 is very similar to the first part of 2010 and the iWatch is similar to the launch of the

2:14:50original iPad yeah I do I cuz I you know just off the top of my head I expect

2:14:55both a bigger iPad and the watch in the first half yeah maybe whether they come

2:14:59at the same event or not I don't know but you know I think they're both coming

2:15:03sort of before I just don't know if the Apple TV will come with them where if

2:15:07that's still in the garage you know honestly no idea wouldn't be surprised

2:15:11it would be huge if they did all three in the first half that'd be almost

2:15:15unprecedented and it just as a not to try to you know err on the side of

2:15:22getting too excited but it would kind of make sense in the context of Tim Cook's

2:15:26previous you know maybe over promising of what they were going to deliver in

2:15:322014 that some of these things you know maybe got bumped you know you know Apple

2:15:38Apple Pay and Apple Watch count as the plural new product categories, but it does seem like

2:15:49when he first started talking about that I expected a little bit more, like maybe one

2:15:53more thing for 2014.

2:15:54Yeah, well I think, I don't know if you heard the same thing I did, but the Apple TV sounded

2:15:57like last spring and then it sounded like this fall and then it sounds like next spring

2:16:00and it sounds like that's a bigger job than people thought it was originally going to

2:16:03be.

2:16:04Yeah, I definitely heard back in June in WWDC that it was

2:16:09Maybe originally thought that it would come out before the end of 2014, but even back at June it was no way

2:16:16Yeah, not even not even feasible for it to be a 2014 thing. I'm good

2:16:20I'm happy if they I mean I liked it when Apple had products spread across the year

2:16:23I find everything coming in fall just quite a lot to deal with

2:16:26Yeah, well and the other thing too that I think made it impossible and it's not even to get in any details of it

2:16:31But it's just the simple fact that if it doesn't ship by October it doesn't ship that yes that November and December don't count because they

2:16:38Can they're just it too late for the holiday season absolutely that if it can't be announced in October

2:16:43It doesn't get announced till 2015 and it doesn't get announced 2015

2:16:47It's probably like more like February than January yeah

2:16:51And we'd start to see signs already I mean if any of those products were like January February we'd start seeing things moving

2:16:55Yeah, like November December January not that Apple doesn't get work done

2:17:00But products don't get slated for release in those months

2:17:03All right, Renee more people can find out more see your great work at I'm more of course. I'm more calm

2:17:09What are your podcasts lists your podcast? I have debug with guy English

2:17:14We talked to developers about developing stuff and then I have vector with guy English Dave whiskus and Georgia Dow

2:17:19We talked about the intersection of technology and humanity and I do iterate with Mark Edwards and Seth Clifford, which is designer oriented stuff

2:17:25Who do you think is gonna record more podcast episodes in 2015?

2:17:30You or Jason snow. I it's it's neck and neck but I love that or maybe Mike Hurley

2:17:35I mean it's becoming it's becoming a bit of a joke

2:17:38They're all good shows you're prolific

2:17:43I like here's why I like having you on this show because I feel like on your regular shows you

2:17:48Defer to your guests and sometimes I forget that you're you're even there. I'm like word Renee go

2:17:54I'd like to hear Renee pipe in you are so deferential

2:17:57I like having you here and letting you go off because man you really know your shit. Thank you. I really appreciate that

2:18:02all right

2:18:04well, thanks to you and

2:18:06Go check out Renee's shows and go read I'm on you John. All right, I'm hitting stop