Podcast Search

The Talk Show

97: ‘Copious Software Projects’ With Guy English

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Hey man, how's the game?

0:00:01- Well, you know, it's funny watching baseball

0:00:04when you don't really have a vested interest

0:00:06in any of the particular teams.

0:00:07And then I get like, I develop a little mini interest

0:00:10in one of the teams and, you know, it's like,

0:00:14I don't know, it's how it was,

0:00:15we were talking about it during the World Cup

0:00:16where like two teams who you don't really care about

0:00:19start playing, and then one of them will do something

0:00:21and it's like, that's my team.

0:00:23And then you're like invested for like,

0:00:25you're like a fan for an hour.

0:00:27Yeah, until the duration is over and then

0:00:32then this penalty kicks and you don't give a crap anymore.

0:00:35Now, I became a

0:00:37temporary fan of the Los Angeles Dodgers

0:00:41simply because their manager is Don Mattingly who was on the Yankees

0:00:45when I was growing up. He was my boyhood Yankee title.

0:00:48That is a very you thing to do.

0:00:50That is so arbitrary, it's crazy.

0:00:52He was my favorite Yankee growing up.

0:00:54He was awesome. I always loved him. Do you call the managers Yankees? Like, that's, if

0:00:59you're in the organization. Oh, he was. Okay. I'm sorry. Yeah, he played first base. He

0:01:03was an all star first baseman for the Yankees through the 80s. And then sort of a tragic

0:01:10career where he's, he's, without doubt, the greatest New York Yankee who never won a World

0:01:16Series, and not only never won a World Series, he never won a playoff series. He played right

0:01:22after the Reggie Jackson era Yankees had won some World Series and then he played right through the

0:01:2680s and the early 90s when the Yankees were actually pretty bad overall. He was like the

0:01:30star player on a pretty bad team. And then in his last season and he got cut short he had a

0:01:36relatively shorter career than most players. He had a bad back in 1995. From injury or just?

0:01:41Yeah well just wear and tear. Yeah who knows. He kind of had a funny batting stance where he

0:01:46squatted over maybe that contributed to it. But anyway he had a bad back so it was going to be

0:01:50his last year and the Yankees made the playoffs for the first time in a long time and they lost a

0:01:55Game five in a five-game series to the

0:01:58The Seattle Mariners John Molts his team. That's not a real team

0:02:03That's a Canadian team then he retired and then starting in 96 the Yankees won for the next five World Series

0:02:09So it's sort of things. Yeah. Yeah, so he's sort of a tragic figure in my mind

0:02:15And now he's managing the Dodgers and they yeah, but you know, he's still working in the field. That's

0:02:19Right. Not everybody gets to do that, right? Well, no, that's true. No. And they just,

0:02:25right before we started recording it, Los Angeles Dodgers were eliminated.

0:02:29I just, yeah, it's like the cherry on his shit sundae, basically.

0:02:35Yeah. And it was close. It was 3-2. Heartbreaker.

0:02:39So you know what? You're turning me around on baseball a little bit.

0:02:41Boy, the playoffs, playoff baseball is a different sport.

0:02:44Yeah, playoff anything is great, but yeah.

0:02:47Yeah, I could see how a lot of people someone who doesn't really get it would could get it same thing to me with with

0:02:52The soccer where I'm not gonna really watch regular season soccer, but I'm into the World Cup now. Yeah good

0:02:58Euro - it's probably gonna be exciting

0:03:01You know, you still you're as weird because you're gonna have to pick something at random, right?

0:03:05You're never gonna have a home team in the Euro, but right

0:03:09But know what? I mean your conversation with Ben last week was great. I loved it

0:03:15What I like about soccer is

0:03:17that and

0:03:19And it's kind of what you guys discussed. It's that eventually the scoreline doesn't matter. It's the stories that get told after the game

0:03:25And you cover that a lot with Derek Jeter, right where you could both recount

0:03:31crazy moves that he did and

0:03:34You know not once did you ever

0:03:38Really mentioned the scoreline, right?

0:03:41And if you look at that sort of spreadsheet like, you know, here's the game reduced to numbers. It just doesn't it doesn't show up

0:03:47It doesn't pop off the page. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Like I call it when I'm dismissive of a static color the baseball stat

0:03:53Right only because without context so much stuff is just completely pointless. Like there's really no reason to it and it I

0:04:00Was adverse to baseball for many years probably still am

0:04:04Because it seems to fetishize stats in a way because nothing else is going on

0:04:10sometimes. Yeah, it lends itself to it too. It's the pace of the game too and it's a game that

0:04:17lends itself to the keeping of innumerable statistics. And there's ways to show that

0:04:24all sorts of those statistics correlate, at least in some way, to winning and losing. And so you

0:04:30can, you know, it just lends itself to just elaborate, elaborate statistical analysis.

0:04:36I know and that turned me off though because when you start telling stories about Derek

0:04:41Jeter or whoever, I'm all into that. I love that kind of stuff. That's kind of why I like

0:04:47soccer. I don't want to say heroism, but it's the ups and downs of individual players and

0:04:56teams and that kind of thing that captures my attention.

0:05:00Yeah. Bottom line for me, and I know every week there's always somebody out there saying,

0:05:05I don't care about any sports at all, but the bottom line for me and it's the appeal and it's it fits right in with

0:05:10You know and like take a guy like Jason snow. Yeah, who's a big baseball fan. He likes football to us football. Yeah

0:05:15But you know obviously with all the incomparable stuff he does he consumes an enormous amount of

0:05:21fiction narrative fiction

0:05:25it to me a lot of sports fans or at least that like in my

0:05:29Friend Matt's parlance stats versus story guys the story guys like me

0:05:33we watch sports for the same reason we like to watch things like movies is there's drama,

0:05:39but it's the weird thing with sports with a movie. Ostensibly, there's always going to be drama,

0:05:44and there's always going to be a good ending and a good story. Sometimes a sports game is just

0:05:49boring because one team jumps out eight nothing and it stays eight nothing and it's kind of,

0:05:53well, that was kind of dull. So you can't fake it. And then all of a sudden, sometimes it's three

0:05:58to two in the ninth inning and the bases are loaded and nobody's out. And you've got a

0:06:03real story. And nobody, there's no one person like an author or a director who gets to decide

0:06:09how it turns out based on what they think. You know, and it's that difference. It's that

0:06:13realness. It's that sometimes it is, you know, it's going to end, you know, the good guys,

0:06:19you know, meaning the team I'm rooting for, the good guys are going to lose. They're not

0:06:24always going to win.

0:06:25You know, I'm like this Dodgers manager.

0:06:27Right.

0:06:28Like a good guy.

0:06:29Yeah.

0:06:30Great guy.

0:06:31Best nickname ever.

0:06:32His nickname, literally, I swear to God, his nickname is Donnie Baseball.

0:06:35Oh, God.

0:06:36Okay.

0:06:37This guy's aces.

0:06:38I like this guy.

0:06:39Right.

0:06:40How does he really...

0:06:41Donnie Baseball?

0:06:42How does he get it?

0:06:43Yeah.

0:06:44That's crazy.

0:06:45How did he get that nickname?

0:06:46Just because he's like the baseball player's baseball player.

0:06:48Really?

0:06:49He's that kind of...

0:06:50Okay.

0:06:51Did you ever see it?

0:06:52Yeah, I swear to God.

0:06:53I Twittered it the other day.

0:06:54who—there's a YouTube clip of it, like in a regular season game in 1985. There was

0:06:59a foul ball, a big high pop-up going over into the stands, and he ran over to see if

0:07:03he could catch it, and it went too far into the stands. He couldn't catch it. Meanwhile,

0:07:07there's a kid in the front row eating a box of popcorn, and the kid had turned around

0:07:11to look where the foul ball landed, and Mattingly just reaches over and takes a handful of popcorn

0:07:16out of the kid's box.

0:07:17I saw that, that is him.

0:07:18And then he just—the kid turns around and is like, "Whoa, Don Mattingly just stole

0:07:22my popcorn and then Mattingly just gives him like a little nod like thanks for popcorn kid

0:07:26that's and it goes back to first base to finish the game that's awesome

0:07:29right that's that's why he's donnie baseball uh yeah good because it like while playing at the

0:07:36highest level he's also thinking well i could go for some popcorn that's that's perfect see stories

0:07:41yeah right yeah that's see that's way better than what was batting average yeah who cares whatever

0:07:47It doesn't matter.

0:07:48Right.

0:07:49But he took the popcorn.

0:07:50Now that's--

0:07:50Right.

0:07:51That makes him cool to me.

0:07:53I don't care what he--

0:07:54He's on my fantasy team that--

0:07:56Exactly.

0:07:57He's immediately there.

0:07:58Yeah.

0:07:58Wow.

0:08:01You want to talk non-sports?

0:08:03If anybody's listening, stop, first of all.

0:08:06Second, I'm not a sports guy, but I do enjoy stories.

0:08:11Yeah, to me, that's just it, though.

0:08:13It's a way of hopefully manufacturing some actual drama that's going to be,

0:08:18it's going to come to a conclusion fair and square based on the athletic abilities of the people

0:08:25involved. Well, not even fair and square if you got a dirty ref, which is like soccer half the time.

0:08:31That's kind of part of the story. But even then it adds to the story.

0:08:36Yes, I totally agree. And the other thing too about that to me, it makes sports appealing is that

0:08:42It's the complaint that a lot of people have about sports is that well, it's pointless

0:08:46Well, that's sort of what makes it it makes it exciting because you can get all invested in it and the team you're rooting for

0:08:52and we're invested when lose and it's you know, it hurts and you're upset and you feel terrible for a day

0:08:59But ultimately it's okay because it was just it's nothing. Yeah, you've only invested what you've

0:09:05Emotionally put on the table right like right? This is something to change anybody's life, right?

0:09:11Whereas unless you actually bet heavy which don't don't do that. That's bad

0:09:15But whereas concentrating and obsessing over something that is even more dramatic

0:09:20But but where the stakes are real like, you know the situation in the Middle East

0:09:25Yes between Israel and Palestine or with this Isis outfit anything like that

0:09:31But there's all sorts of incredibly exciting drama involved

0:09:37Great stories to be told but the stakes are so real and it's it's real stuff

0:09:41You can't you can't take it lightly and can't you know went when there's a big turn of events

0:09:45You can't go. Well that was something but too bad II, you know, yeah, I know I totally agree. I think with sports

0:09:50Win or lose in a way you can always laugh at yourself, right?

0:09:55Like I can't believe I was so happy that this random team did this random thing or I can't believe that

0:10:01It was so bummed out they that they lost

0:10:04You know with real life stuff like like what you're talking about, right? You don't get the laughs because it's you know

0:10:10People's lives on the line. It's like a real thing

0:10:13Right, we can be happy that the Death Star got blown up because you know

0:10:17The six billion people on the planet Alderaan weren't real people. Yeah, there wasn't actually a real Holocaust that happened

0:10:25It was just something that was in a space movie

0:10:27Yeah, like if you actually think about how horrible that movie is that there's a lot of dead people in there

0:10:33It could be like the number one dead people movie, right?

0:10:37There might have been more people killed in that movie than in any other movie ever filmed

0:10:41I think that that's actually that's an interesting argument. I would almost certainly think that that it's okay

0:10:46It's got to be close right? I mean, right if you assume we didn't know learn much about Alderaan

0:10:51But let's assume it was roughly earth-like. Yeah, then five to six billion people on there

0:10:55Right plus all of the people dead on the death star which has been dead gone into you

0:11:01Yeah, plus the new mobile rebels killed, right?

0:11:05Mix to mix Darth Vader seemed like a like a teddy bear. Yeah, cuz he only killed one person

0:11:11Right bad. Yeah, he didn't have anything to do with firing that that's our that was all talking exactly. Yeah

0:11:17Want to talk what people want to hear about yeah

0:11:25You know what though? It's a good time before we get started on what people really want to hear about

0:11:28Let's knock out the first sponsor

0:11:31and let me tell everybody about our good friends

0:11:35returning as a sponsor of the show,

0:11:37our good friends at Harry's.

0:11:39Harry's makes high quality men's shaving stuff

0:11:44and makes it available at a terrific price.

0:11:48I've told you this before, but it's a great story.

0:11:53Harry's was started by a guy who went in,

0:11:55who was out of town traveling, went into a drugstore

0:11:57'cause he realized he didn't pack his shaving stuff.

0:12:00went in and all the shaving stuff in the drug store

0:12:03is all locked up behind a case.

0:12:05You have to get a clerk, you have to let him open it,

0:12:07and then you find out it's like 40 bucks

0:12:09for a pack of razor blades.

0:12:11So he thought, hey, there's gotta be a better way.

0:12:14This stuff, there's only like two or three big companies,

0:12:16Gillette and Schick and whoever else who control this stuff.

0:12:19These prices have gotta be artificially high.

0:12:21Ends up, they are.

0:12:23And-- - Who to against?

0:12:26So Harry's focus is just a pure old-fashioned disruption.

0:12:31You go, you sign up at Harry's, you get a kit,

0:12:35you get a reusable razor,

0:12:38and then you get a couple of blades to start with,

0:12:40and then going forward, you just get new blades sent to you.

0:12:44Really good price, half the price of the competitors,

0:12:47like Gillette.

0:12:48Marco did the research.

0:12:49I would just steal his research from an ATP

0:12:51where they sponsored, but Marco went to Amazon

0:12:55and priced a pack of Gillette Fusion blades.

0:12:59It was like 40 some bucks.

0:13:01That's Amazon.

0:13:02We know Amazon cuts the prices

0:13:04about as low as they're gonna go retail.

0:13:06Same equivalent pack of blades from Harry's was 20 bucks.

0:13:10Really, so when they say half the price,

0:13:12it's not like about half the price.

0:13:13Literally, half the price.

0:13:15Ship 'em right to you.

0:13:16Really, really cool product design.

0:13:18That just nice feel to the stuff.

0:13:22Really nice heft.

0:13:23really like I love the thing it's just feels like something's gonna last

0:13:27forever

0:13:27a nice branding everything's nice nice packaging

0:13:31everything opens up nice there's no blister packs or any crap like that it's

0:13:35just a nice little

0:13:35cardboard package open up just couldn't be better

0:13:39if you're using the other anything else you're probably paying too much

0:13:42and you're probably not getting as good as stuff and then the other thing I

0:13:45always love this too

0:13:47because it just shows how serious these guys are is that they're not just like

0:13:50white labeling

0:13:51some kind of razor blades they get from some generic contractor like they went to Germany

0:13:55and bought a razor blade factory and they make their own German engineered razor blades

0:14:02like they're not just buying you know Chinese razors and and putting Harry's name on it

0:14:07they making their own in Germany I love it super convenient just like anything else that

0:14:12once you get used to ordering it online instead of having to go to the store and buy it every

0:14:16couple weeks or months you just never go back really good stuff high quality great

0:14:21price. So here's what you do and you'll get five bucks off your first purchase

0:14:24if you do what I tell you to do which is go to harrys.com. H-A-R-R-Y-S dot com and

0:14:32use the promo code talk show just T-A-L-K-S-H-O-W and you'll save five bucks off

0:14:40your first purchase and their regular prices are already really low. So go do

0:14:44that my thanks to Harry's full disclosure Harry's also sponsors my show

0:14:51but you know what pretty awesome I'm really happy I have you in the past two

0:14:56days I got some samples of new shaving cream in an aftershave I didn't get

0:15:02anything they don't send me they don't like you know but they love me and I'm

0:15:06telling you it's it's I think whiskers takes all this I think whiskers probably

0:15:10He probably just swipes everything.

0:15:11No, you know, I heard that. I heard that they got a new cream. They have a lathering cream

0:15:17instead of like the first cream that they have, which is the one I use. It doesn't really work up

0:15:22a lather. It's just like... It's just a cream. It works great, but it doesn't like foam up.

0:15:26So the new one... And that some people just... Yeah, some people just like it to foam up.

0:15:30Yep. And now they have one of them. And today, just today, I haven't tried it yet,

0:15:32but the bottle looks awesome. I have like an aftershave sort of thing to try tomorrow.

0:15:39But it's great. I love it. And you know what? Besides the product, the packaging is incredible.

0:15:46Just the way the delivery, the design, everything about it is just amazing. I would buy it. I don't

0:15:54even care what's in the bottle. I feel bad. It's one of those things like Apple products where I

0:15:57feel bad throwing the box out. Yeah, I keep my boxes until I get made fun of to the point

0:16:02that it's like, no, I've really got to get rid of this thing. I still have my Mac Pro box. It's just

0:16:06sitting there. No good reason. Anyway, so I don't know. We're what, 20 minutes in?

0:16:13You want to get the show going? Yeah. Here's the big topic, I think, and I don't know where it'll

0:16:20lead us when we get into the details, but it's this idea that you and I have been involved in

0:16:27several of these threads this week on Twitter. A couple of other people have too. And I think

0:16:32It's not that I'm hunting for people who agree with me, but I just there doesn't really see I found it very curious

0:16:37that there was nobody arguing the other side which is more or less that a thesis that

0:16:42Well, the two ways to pose it at least this year with iOS 8 and Yosemite Apple bit off more than it could chew

0:16:50in terms of that how much it was going to do and ship and

0:16:54It's the quality control is suffering therefore that they they tried to do too much by September when they had to ship

0:17:02iOS 8 because the new iPhones needed iOS 8

0:17:05And that this annual schedule there not that the annual schedule is necessarily too

0:17:11too

0:17:13Short a period but that they're trying to do too much in those annual schedules

0:17:17And if they want to do that much between major releases

0:17:19It has to be more than a year and if they want it to be a year they have to do less at a time

0:17:23okay, so yeah, I've I

0:17:26Don't know I was asked about this and I kind of disagreed with you

0:17:31and

0:17:33Stated like that I actually do agree with you because I think we probably think this similarly on a lot of these subjects

0:17:40You can't keep making the giant leaps that each of these OSes take in this space of a year and

0:17:48The reason for that is that you don't have a year to do it. You've got maybe four to five

0:17:54Maybe six if you're lucky months

0:17:56Yeah, you and you made this point on

0:18:00It was a vector last week or debug it could I don't know

0:18:03Whichever whichever but yeah explain but explain I thought this is

0:18:08And I don't think that this I don't think people think this because people think like well

0:18:13It's been a year since Iowa 7 came out. So why couldn't they do this in a year?

0:18:17But explain right so that I mean the reason is and this is not just me. This is you know, I've talked to

0:18:21Project managers and people inside Apple. So I actually know that this is pretty much the fact

0:18:29Or the case I don't want to say fact because I can't prove it

0:18:31The first few months are spent

0:18:36Fixing the bugs that you did ship, right? That's the eight point zero one

0:18:41And right and even it just clearly a panic and we should get back to you

0:18:44But yeah, if you forget if you forget what it was like a year ago when I was seven for a ship

0:18:49Don't worry about it

0:18:49Just think about what what you must assume

0:18:51People at Apple who work on iOS are doing right now today is they've got to be working on iOS 8 bugs

0:18:56Have to be everybody knows it. Yeah. All right, so they're doing that now you should call that call that October November

0:19:02Maybe even December. Yeah, so the iOS

0:19:048.0.1 bug hit 40 to 50 thousand people out of

0:19:10What I understand to be like a 10 million

0:19:13install base

0:19:16Despite that being a low percentage that is a lot of people and it is it's bad mojo. It's it's bad news, right?

0:19:24So yeah, and it's it's enough like and you know, it's you know, I've clearly this small sample

0:19:28This is the definition of exactly but the day that that happened that the 8.01 day. I think it was a Wednesday

0:19:34whatever day that week it was midday and

0:19:37My pal Lee the the bartender, but oh man, I'm seeing London. Okay. Hey Lee

0:19:43he

0:19:45He was guest bartending at a Jose Garcia's restaurant here in Philadelphia

0:19:50for a happy hour and invited me and Amy to come and so

0:19:54Got got the kid taken care of it, you know five went out

0:19:59They had a couple cocktails with Lee at a new place and he he sat us next to a guy and a guy

0:20:04He sat us next to happened to be he was like are you John Gruber and I was and I don't get that much in

0:20:08Philadelphia and I was like, I am and he ends up he's a big fan

0:20:10He he's just an attorney it works in Philadelphia also a fan of hops in laundromat bricked his iPhone 6+ that day

0:20:19Because he like came out he had like he had like court in the morning had lunch came out of lunch saw that

0:20:258.01 was out hit update and

0:20:28by one o'clock his brand new iPhone 6 plus couldn't make phone calls, so

0:20:33You know, I thought that was really interesting. I was like wow, I just you know met somebody who got hit by the bug

0:20:39You know, so I was like seems to me like it's pretty prevalent

0:20:41Forty to fifty thousand people again could have been a lot worse if it was everybody, right?

0:20:45But I think the window is pretty small, right? It was right

0:20:48I don't know how many hours it was posted for well, but it was weird though because I

0:20:53it's one of those weird things about the way stuff propagates around the world with Apple and the

0:20:59CD ends that they use where they were still I was still getting hearing from people on Twitter saying it like 4 in the afternoon

0:21:04On Eastern Time that their iPhone was still offering it and they knew not to allow it

0:21:09But if they didn't, you know hadn't been following the tech news of the day

0:21:13They might have that it you know still hadn't been rescinded from at least their phones perspective

0:21:17Yeah, and you know you have a pretty broad audience, but that is a tiny slice of Apple consumers, right?

0:21:24So yeah, and I guess it kind of makes sense that that that would be the max

0:21:28You know that something like that would be the number because if it was a hundred percent of people then it would have been caught

0:21:33Yeah, it must whatever the circumstances were that made that that that that made this and I've still not seen anybody

0:21:40Apparently it's a Delta update like if you just it's the Delta download from a specific version to screws it up

0:21:46Apparently.

0:21:47Yeah, but it must have been something like that because if it had affected everybody,

0:21:52it never would have made it out of QA.

0:21:53No.

0:21:54If it only affected, I don't know, 5% for some reason, you know, if you have this, if

0:22:01you have that, if you have this, then it breaks your phone.

0:22:05Right.

0:22:06It just wasn't in their testing matrix, I guess.

0:22:09I think it was Business Insider that tried to name the – well, they did actually name

0:22:13the QA manager.

0:22:14No, it was Business Week.

0:22:15I'm sorry. It's funny that I go to business insider. But yeah, okay, so business week.

0:22:23Don't do that. That's horrible reporting. You're missing the story, and it's completely

0:22:27pointless.

0:22:28Yeah, that was a really… I thought that was so uncalled for.

0:22:31It's just dumb. It's like when Jesus Diaz called out the guy that lost his iPhone 4

0:22:37prototype.

0:22:38Right.

0:22:39And guess what? He says, "I'm going to call you out." Which is, again, a dick move.

0:22:44It was even worse. I would say it was even worse.

0:22:47Really?

0:22:48Well, maybe not.

0:22:49No, no.

0:22:50Yeah, maybe not.

0:22:51There was an entire piece based on who this guy was. There was no reason for that. This

0:22:52poor kid—I'm calling him a kid, but whatever. He was 20-some-odd.

0:22:58Made a genuinely honest mistake.

0:23:00It was an honest mistake. People screw up. There was no need to rake him up with coals

0:23:04and out him. At least focus on the phone that you got. You really don't need to do a piece

0:23:09about the guy that goofed and lost it.

0:23:14Yeah, I was gonna say that it was worse though, and I know worse is the wrong word

0:23:19But I would say and the reason I was gonna say that though is at least with the kid who lost the iPhone

0:23:23He really did lose the iPhone and what he was accused of having done is exactly what he did that he had

0:23:29As an engineer he had access to pre-release

0:23:33iPhone what was it the iPhone 4 to use in the wild for field testing and

0:23:38left it at a

0:23:41Bar restaurant well we don't know or it was lifted or it was lifted, but but you know but end of the day

0:23:47It was not with him when he left right right which is exactly what happened nobody's that's not in dispute

0:23:52Where is the first thing he did in the morning or is like calling and be like yeah?

0:23:57Yo, I lost my iPhone so right yeah, right he did the right thing you know

0:24:01But with the business week story naming the guy and as being responsible for this 801 update

0:24:06And then further saying that he was on the QA team that he was the leader of the QA team

0:24:11than Apple Maps. It's actually wrong though. Like, you know, I did the same thing as you.

0:24:18I asked around and it ends, you know, the guy is responsible for some level of QA at Apple,

0:24:23but nobody inside Apple that I talked to said that there's any sense that he like single-handedly

0:24:29pulled the trigger or deserves that anybody other than the entire company deserves team credit for

0:24:35the for the fiasco. If, you know, business week made it sound like one guy was like hitting a

0:24:40button and saying it's ready to go.

0:24:42It's uh, and his role, his role on maps was, had nothing to do with the maps data.

0:24:49It was the maps app, which nobody, which I know for users, they don't have, uh, it

0:24:55doesn't make a difference.

0:24:56They don't see a difference between the data and the app.

0:24:59Um, but anybody who's listening to this show knows, knows the difference.

0:25:03Do you know what anybody reporting on technology for business week

0:25:06should know the difference?

0:25:08Right.

0:25:09It's like being, you know, it's sort of like the difference between your email client and

0:25:17what's in your emails, you know? It's like it's not your email client's fault if the emails are

0:25:22full of junk. And the Maps app worked fine. It was just that it had bad data and, you know,

0:25:29empty data that it was missing a lot of data, which he had nothing to do with. That wasn't

0:25:33what he was QA. And yet there he is listed in Business Week as like, you know, and the

0:25:38insinuation it wasn't quite directed but the only insinuation you could draw from

0:25:42it is that was the worst thing though is that it was an insinuation and it wasn't

0:25:46like putting all the wood behind the arrow like at least that would be a

0:25:52thing this was just more like this was like backhanded gossipy stuff yeah and

0:25:57it's like the insinuation as Apple has and you know at least one inept bozo

0:26:02running you know doing a way who's who's still you know after he you know made a

0:26:07terrible mistake with the maps is still bricking new iPhones. Which is so far, it's just way off,

0:26:13basically. - Somebody buy that guy a beer, because he probably deserves it after this.

0:26:18- I'll tell you, I don't think I've ever told this story publicly. I don't think, but I will.

0:26:24The writer, at least one of the writers on that story, was Adam Satoriano. And

0:26:31Adam sorta Rios a Toriano a couple years ago wrote a piece for business week on me yours truly John Gruber

0:26:38Which I went along with

0:26:41Half-heartedly, I did talk to him. I got thirsty bear when I was in San Francisco

0:26:45That's your first mistake

0:26:48That was daytime and I met with a colleague of his here in Philly for follow-up questions

0:26:53And it was about what I do that the phenomenon of it was well

0:26:57It was posed to me initially as that they were going to write a piece about the independent Mac

0:27:01journalism web people like me and

0:27:05Arnold Kim who founded Mac rumors and maybe Jim Dalrymple and other people like that

0:27:10You know people who are covering Apple, but but as you know, either individuals like me or as new and you know

0:27:18publications like the loop and make rumors

0:27:22And it became very obvious to me as the

0:27:25Interviews progressed that it was not going to be that that it was more just about me

0:27:30Which I found uncomfortable and I encouraged them to not make it about me and make it about

0:27:35All of us together of which I'm just one example

0:27:38and

0:27:40So I kind of and as it as that became clear to me I participated less and less

0:27:45and you know, I don't think I wasn't rude and I didn't stop talking to them, but I

0:27:51I stopped participating and they asked me to pose for a photograph and I refused.

0:27:57That's awkward.

0:28:01Well, but I've seen the photographs that they had published of others and they made people look

0:28:07goofy like I told them this. So like, what's the guy's name? Gene Munster.

0:28:13Yeah.

0:28:13Who's famously the analyst.

0:28:15TV.

0:28:15Yeah.

0:28:17I'm pulling for Gene, man. Love that guy.

0:28:19So I haven't looked at this well, but see if you Google Gene Munster business. I think

0:28:26it was Business Week, but it might have been Bloomberg. But Bloomberg owns Business Week.

0:28:32Gene Munster says Apple is going to $1,000.

0:28:35That might be it.

0:28:36No, no. That's from 2012. I don't want to make too much fun of him because the stock

0:28:40splits since then. So it's just very not fair. It's at $700 now if you don't get

0:28:46the splits.

0:28:47But that's it. That's app, but that's it. Look at the picture of him

0:28:50Why would you do this to somebody?

0:28:52Right. It's a very to me. I think a very flattering photo

0:28:57I mean, I think he's goofy because of the TV stuff that he keeps bringing up, but this is that don't do that to him

0:29:03He's smarter than that. Yeah

0:29:05Clown yeah

0:29:09Yeah

0:29:10And and I've seen other publications do this and I can also I and so I wanted nothing to do with it

0:29:16And you don't get to approve it.

0:29:19It's not like if they shoot 20 photos of me, I get to then pick which one they can use.

0:29:23They're all theirs.

0:29:24>> Yeah.

0:29:24>> You agreed to let them do it.

0:29:25And I wanted nothing to do with that.

0:29:26Nor would I allow them to use any of the photos I have of me.

0:29:30So they -- I think if you look at the profile they had of me, if you Google it, they found like a,

0:29:35I don't know, a third-party photo, like a Creative Commons thing from Flickr or something.

0:29:40>> Yeah.

0:29:40But anyway, the main point though is that there were then – then towards the end,

0:29:49they came out and asked the question I knew that they were going to ask which is, "How

0:29:52much money do you make?"

0:29:54And I said to Adam Satoriano on the record, I said, "I don't know.

0:29:59I don't keep track."

0:30:00And he paused and he said, "Really?"

0:30:05And I said, "Really, I don't keep track."

0:30:08And I said, "Off the record?"

0:30:09He said what I said that what you do what I just told you is what you can quote me on

0:30:13You can quote the world in business week. I don't know. I don't keep track

0:30:16And other than that, I'm not gonna talk about it

0:30:20And he'd you know, he was like so I could run that I said sure

0:30:25I would love it if you ran that I still wish he had right but instead

0:30:27When the thing came out it said like Gruber wouldn't discuss it

0:30:31But somebody familiar with his finances who can't be with hell I swear to God

0:30:39because he doesn't have permission, pegged his income at, I don't know what it was, $400,000.

0:30:46Well, you have a big organization, so I mean, God knows who leaked that.

0:30:49Right. Well, here's the thing that made me so mad about that. I called Adam on it privately,

0:30:54I didn't, not publicly, because I didn't want to bring it up because…

0:30:56Until now.

0:30:57Well, I feel like on the talk show, maybe I can do it and it won't be in print. But I said,

0:31:02I know that it's bullshit. I know that it's bullshit, because there's literally only three

0:31:06people on the planet who have any familiarity with my finances at all

0:31:10that's me my wife and my accountant and I guess maybe if there's a fourth it

0:31:16would be somebody at the IRS who handles the tax return that my accountant

0:31:22submits but even then I doubt that there's anybody who remembers my name I

0:31:25presume that those things are completely automated robots forget it yeah it's

0:31:29just robots so there's literally only three people on the planet and I know

0:31:32know for a fact that he didn't speak to so so Amy didn't rat you out no and I

0:31:38don't pay phone on the corner and like privately like right so what I presume

0:31:44that it I don't think he made it up I presume that what he did is he found one

0:31:47person who sponsored my site and asked you know what did you pay for the

0:31:52sponsorship and multiplied it or something like that I don't know but

0:31:56there's no way that that would quality you present rates on your website right

0:32:00Right, but the description...

0:32:02But that's not what he said though.

0:32:04The description he used in print in Business Week is absolutely incompatible with any way that he could have come up with the number.

0:32:11Yeah.

0:32:12I thought that was so telling about...

0:32:14Well, you know what? It's like, "Hey kid, get me a coffee. Go to this website. Find me this number. Multiply it by 12."

0:32:20Right.

0:32:21It's just dumb. It's just... Anyway.

0:32:23Right. But I feel like it's dishonest. I feel like if that's what he did, then he should have said in print, you know,

0:32:28should have spelled that out just like you did in print and said as a ballpark estimate. There you go.

0:32:33Yeah.

0:32:34No, but what he said was that somebody familiar with my finances who didn't have,

0:32:38which it made me mad in two ways because the first way is that I know it's not true,

0:32:44but the second way is that insinuates that there's somebody who's close to me who betrayed me,

0:32:48which is even more angering.

0:32:51Yeah, that, yeah, I hadn't even thought of it like that. Yeah.

0:32:57That was like my secondary reaction. And in fact, that actually bothered me even more.

0:33:01That somebody that I would share my finances with somebody and that they would blab

0:33:06off the record to Adam Santoriano at Business Week, which didn't happen.

0:33:09Why would you? Right. Yeah.

0:33:11So, it always and I always file that in my head whenever I see. I've never,

0:33:16I've always been a little bit skeptical of any unnamed sources in anything I read online. But

0:33:21after that I'm even more so when I see information attributed to people familiar with the matter.

0:33:27Yeah, you have to. Right.

0:33:30I yeah, I agree with you. I've rejected that intellectually, but

0:33:35this is like a visceral rejection, you know, like just being your pal. I know that no, that's

0:33:43nobody would do that. I don't understand. Yeah, I am not a fan of Adam Zatorianos work.

0:33:51So we outed this guy at QA and I think that was a, that was a hack job and

0:33:55whatever.

0:33:57Pointless.

0:33:59We got way off track cause I was telling you why, uh, putting out an OS every year

0:34:05is kind of a pain in the ass.

0:34:06Right.

0:34:07At least three months after the OS comes out, you're fixing bugs.

0:34:10Minimum, you know, and you know, during that time, hopefully the management is,

0:34:15uh, trying to discern which are the major features that are going to be able to

0:34:20make it into the next release.

0:34:21And then you've got maybe between, if you're lucky, three to six months to implement them, if you're lucky.

0:34:32More or less squeezing it in for WWDC. I don't know what's the December/January timeline for it.

0:34:42Last year, 7.1 didn't come out until March.

0:34:46Yeah. But I figured just as a rough timeline that through December it was mostly heads down on fixing stuff and doing stuff for 7.1.

0:34:55January and February I'm sure a lot of resources started going towards iOS 8. But some was still finishing the final touches on 7.1.

0:35:04Yeah. But then roughly, you know, up until June you're trying to get the first working version of new stuff done for the next version of the OS.

0:35:13Right. I mean, yeah, so I'm hesitant to peg months to certain phases.

0:35:22Right.

0:35:23Because, you know, I think that's fluid, but, you know, the general process is that you'll get, if you're lucky, three to six months to actually implement stuff.

0:35:33implement stuff and the rest of the time, at the end, you will be fixing everything

0:35:39that you find after you have released it as a beta, which is what WWDC is, right?

0:35:45Right.

0:35:46And so that means that any one given release has really only had, if you're lucky, three

0:35:54to six months of actual development time in terms of implementing new features, which

0:36:00is…

0:36:01Yeah, like creating.

0:36:02Creating.

0:36:03creative phase of software development.

0:36:05That's the best way of putting it. Yes, I totally agree.

0:36:07And so having this yearly schedule

0:36:11becomes onerous if you keep trying to

0:36:15bite off giant portions

0:36:19of the pie. If you know what

0:36:23you want to build, and I believe that Apple probably has a road line that goes out

0:36:27a couple of versions at least, or at least they have aspirations,

0:36:31You're doing so only in chunks of three to six months of pure creative engineering.

0:36:40The rest of the time is dealing with the bugs you created in the previous version

0:36:45and the bugs that you're fixing in order to get the current version out the door.

0:36:49And I think ultimately what they want to get out the door may be running up against the limits of what they can achieve in that time frame.

0:37:04Yeah, I totally agree with that.

0:37:07And I think they've compounded the problem.

0:37:09I mean, this all sounds very negative, but I mean, they've got Mac OS X, they've got iOS, and now they've got the watch OS.

0:37:17All of them increasingly have to work together.

0:37:20That's...

0:37:23Stuff's going to take time. I think maybe...

0:37:26I think there will be difficulties down the road trying to iron all of this stuff out.

0:37:32There's a lot of... I don't know if bootstrapping is quite the right word,

0:37:36but it's almost like gear fitting,

0:37:39where, you know, with the way that these things are integrated with each other,

0:37:43which is great and which is the way to go

0:37:46and which is better than the way that everything

0:37:48used to be a lot more siloed from Apple.

0:37:51But the fact that it's all geared together

0:37:55creates these weird hiccups

0:37:57when one of the gears isn't ready yet, right?

0:37:59Like, I mean, just one example,

0:38:02but I think it's a major one,

0:38:03is the photo situation with iOS.

0:38:06- Right, totally.

0:38:07- Where are your photos and where are they,

0:38:10how many are backed up and the ones that are,

0:38:11you know, to the iCloud and the fact,

0:38:15I mean, they're not even trying it with the, even when Yosemite ships, the new Mac photo stuff, they've already said, they said back at WWDC that that wasn't coming till 2015.

0:38:25Yeah.

0:38:25You know, in terms of having the Mac be a full client towards this new iCloud centric look.

0:38:32Yeah.

0:38:32And I, I, I heard it suggested that they were doing it in Swift and they, it, it's not, it just takes that long to do that kind of app.

0:38:41Right.

0:38:43And that they know that because they do have some experience with,

0:38:47and it's always hard to estimate exactly, it's impossible to estimate exactly how long software is going to take to write.

0:38:53But they know how long it took to write iPhoto and they know how long it took to write Aputure.

0:38:57And they know how long a major update to Aputure took and how long a major update to iPhoto took.

0:39:01And they knew that what they were undertaking with this is, you know, in that scope.

0:39:05And they know that, you know, that's a nine, 10 months away thing.

0:39:08But it's such a big hole in the process.

0:39:13in the overall experience right now that nobody quite knows where their photos are and how

0:39:20to make sure that they're everywhere.

0:39:23Yeah, I think they're lucky that they're ahead. Not lucky, they worked hard. They're ahead.

0:39:30This kind of weird little, as you describe it, the cogs not maybe meeting up exactly

0:39:35and there's a little bit of grind. I think that's expected. And I don't think it's necessarily

0:39:42cause for alarm but I think institutionally they're gonna have to

0:39:47sort of adapt to this kind of interconnected stuff that they're

0:39:51committing to and again you mentioned this on your show last week and I think

0:39:57it's another point I took a note that it's worth pointing out and just saying

0:40:00it like hey look we're literally armchair quarterbacks here we're just

0:40:04two guys you know yeah I think I said that not a joke yeah we're just two guys

0:40:10You know observing from across the continent and inside Apple their leadership is running a hundred billion dollar a year

0:40:17Corporation. Yes, you know and we're not

0:40:21I'm not trying to tell them I know better. No, no, I'm just listen to me. Just keep doing good stuff

0:40:26Don't write like yeah

0:40:28but I'm just saying though as an observer if we want to just take a step back and look at the state that that

0:40:34The whole software ecosystem is across the Apple board right now. It's not good right now in September October

0:40:402014 rough spot. Yeah. Yeah and last year was very similar

0:40:45Yeah, I thought yeah, I mean last year last year I think a lot of us chalk chalked it up to well

0:40:53It was seven seventy to change it forced all being gone, right?

0:40:56So that's going to be boot the process and they didn't really have that much time

0:41:00Right that and that those of us who know how long stuff takes were still and still to this day

0:41:05I'm kind of in awe that they shipped iOS 7 as

0:41:08Even though as rough as it was in as short a time as they did. Yeah, no one should not have happened

0:41:13Right knowing that it really didn't start until after four stalls out stirred, you know late and late in the year

0:41:192012 well, I think some of the technical underpinnings did but certainly the redesign was new

0:41:26Yeah, and some of the noodlings of the design had started

0:41:29Yeah, but but as a look we're going to actually do this and we actually need to take this style of design and apply it

0:41:36To everything top to bottom

0:41:38didn't start until the forestall ouster and

0:41:42rejigging of the you know

0:41:45John putting Johnny I've in front of in charge of all design software and hardware a job in

0:41:50putting

0:41:52What's his name in charge of software engineering

0:41:57Mr. The hair. Yeah

0:42:00Craig Federighi. Yeah, Federighi in charge of you know, the engineering

0:42:05That's incredible timeframe

0:42:07And so we I think we we as like observers and critics of the company

0:42:12We're willing to grant a little bit more grace last year with Iowa seven bugginess until Iowa seven one

0:42:17Whereas this year it doesn't really seem it seems like an own goal like a for an unforced error. Yeah, they didn't necessarily

0:42:26Double right devil sports metaphor. Yeah, double sports matter. I'll go on for Sarah. I'll take our own goal

0:42:31Oh goal is a little war is too drastic

0:42:33It's yeah

0:42:34It's more like an unforced error that they didn't quite have to do as much of this as they needed to all at once

0:42:38They didn't have to do third-party keyboards

0:42:40right now

0:42:42Right. Well, didn't they I mean, I don't know I don't personally know

0:42:48I don't think so. I'm probably not gonna use a lot of those keyboards

0:42:51I just don't think they needed to do it yet, you know, I mean I think in hind, you know

0:42:55But again, but you know, wait, you know the press better than tonight you

0:42:59Do you think that would have been called out

0:43:02Iowa still does not support swipe which yeah, I think so. I do think I do think that there was you know,

0:43:10There's this weird. I mean the news cycle is always screwed up right like the bending phones

0:43:15Yeah, I do think that you know that I firmly believe I've said this for years and I think I think it you know

0:43:22People I say you can kind of tell like just shiller alone is not he's not just there to do ads

0:43:28You know that no, no, it's not like marketing. I think it's a bad rap and there might be some companies that do it this way

0:43:35But that you know, somebody creates the product does in certain type the company designs

0:43:41Whatever it is and engineers make it and it becomes real and then it's finished and then they hand it to marketing and they say now

0:43:46Sell it

0:43:47That's not how

0:43:49marketing works at Apple and it's not how it works at most companies.

0:43:51Marketing is just describing what the product is and marketing is part of the design process of making sure that it fills a need and that it's going to sell before it's made.

0:44:02You know, it's...

0:44:03Yeah, I mean, I was just talking to Neaton Conatra and Don Melton yesterday, I guess I'm going to name-jaw.

0:44:10And I mean, they were both, they're both been in meetings with Phil.

0:44:15Right.

0:44:16And no, it's very much part of the design process.

0:44:19Like this is not working the way I'd like it to work.

0:44:21Go make it work better.

0:44:24Like this is failing me in these kinds of ways.

0:44:26It's it's, it's part of the process.

0:44:28Like they're, they're built in from the beginning.

0:44:30And then at the end of the process, when it is time to come up with actual slogans

0:44:34and the billboards and here's the way we're going to present it on stage at the

0:44:39intro event, you're just, they're just describing what it actually is.

0:44:43Right.

0:44:44Yeah.

0:44:44And I think that's very, very true of almost all Apple products is that the marketing really is pretty apt. It's well, you know

0:44:52why I think because

0:44:53Marketing has been and marketing is a horrible word. I wish I wish there was a better word for it because it's it's been stained too

0:45:00Often yeah. Yeah. Well, yeah, it's not inherently

0:45:03Bad word and now but from like a geek culture. It's like

0:45:07It's like lie to people. No. No, it's not always that I

0:45:13Had the same conversation this week on Twitter with anil - and Gina tripani at think up

0:45:18They were the sponsors of daring fireball last week and that they're there think up thing

0:45:22They described as social network analytics and on Twitter or even in my write-up on during fireball

0:45:27I said look analytics is a sullied word. Yeah, don't think of it that way

0:45:30it's just useful information about you that you would want to know and it's not like for douchebags and

0:45:36Anil even said that it's like internally like then he knows they couldn't say it

0:45:41but that he thought of a slogan like it's social analytics,

0:45:44but we swear it's not douchey.

0:45:46Because it's, and again, there's nothing inherently wrong

0:45:49with the word analytics, technically, literally,

0:45:51by the definition, that is what ThinkUp does.

0:45:53- I agree.

0:45:54- And that is what, you know, marketing is, you know,

0:45:56it is what it says it is,

0:45:58but the word has just taken on a bad connotation

0:46:01over the years. - Oh, totally.

0:46:01Yeah, no, that's great advice.

0:46:04- Right. - A couple smart people too.

0:46:05Sorry. - And I totally understand

0:46:07that one of the marketing stamps for iOS 8 this year,

0:46:11Well, not just iOS 8 it goes hand in hand with the fact that the iPhones 6 or bigger is

0:46:16It's the shut up about Android year, right? Right like like like or

0:46:21maybe that's a bad way to put it, but it's the

0:46:24Here's the things that here here's the the reasonable reasons that somebody might choose Android over iPhone

0:46:33Here will will give you our answer on them, right? So you like bigger phones totally reasonable

0:46:40Okay, now we have bigger phones

0:46:42You like third-party keyboards? Okay. Now we have third-party keyboards you like sharing information directly between applications and you know

0:46:50Doing that, you know and it is it's all the big highlight

0:46:54Most of the big highlight features are these sort of things that Android had gotten to first

0:46:59Yeah, okay, even Windows Phone have

0:47:02You know taking a bite out of that stuff. Yeah. Yeah, I think Windows Phone with the sharing between applications was

0:47:10you know, yeah, I I know Android had some stuff first, but I thought the way that Windows did it was was more of a

0:47:16Oddly enough it was closer to Apple. Yeah, it was a lot more like yeah apples well services and Mac OS X. Yeah, you know

0:47:25It's just taken Apple

0:47:27You know all these literally decades to get back around to services from a you know

0:47:33Why so forced all stomped on the idea of services in iOS iOS. Oh, I didn't know that

0:47:39Yeah, you didn't know that because you haven't heard the show yet.

0:47:41Neaton was just talking about it yesterday.

0:47:44Ooh, ouch.

0:47:46Well, not ouch.

0:47:48It was because if every single app that exposed the service as OS X does,

0:47:53you just haven't looked at the completely unwieldy services menu.

0:47:57Oh, yeah. Well, that's a great point.

0:47:59Oh, I see. I see. Services as we knew them.

0:48:02Literally, because I mean,

0:48:04they have a pace board server in iOS.

0:48:06Like it, iOS works incredibly similarly to the way the Mac does.

0:48:12Yeah.

0:48:12Uh, if you know how to implement services, um, it's really pretty basic.

0:48:17It's like something goes on a pace board, not the, not the one that you copy and paste into, but a separate one.

0:48:22Another app can then is invoked and it pulls something off that pace board.

0:48:28It does something with it and it pastes it, copies it back up to the pace board.

0:48:33And then the app that you called it from just takes that from the

0:48:36baseboard and puts it in the app.

0:48:37It is, if you can do copy and paste, you can do services.

0:48:41Yeah.

0:48:42And it's just a very basic little specification of here's the data type.

0:48:45Here's the standard data types for services.

0:48:48And here are the ones I'm interested in.

0:48:50It's dead simple.

0:48:50Me as a service, I might only be interested in text.

0:48:54Yeah.

0:48:54So don't even bother with me if the selection is something else.

0:48:57It's dead simple.

0:48:58And the idea got, well, it, they didn't want to put it into iOS

0:49:02because the, the model, the interaction model would just eventually become

0:49:08cumbersome with so many applications.

0:49:09Well, and you can see it, you can see it on Mac OS X, if you have enough third

0:49:12party apps and stuff.

0:49:13Yeah, it's already seen it and nobody looks at that menu.

0:49:15I mean, you and I do, and maybe some portion of your listeners, but.

0:49:18It's a power user feature.

0:49:20It definitely is.

0:49:21And it's always been, and will always be, unless they totally

0:49:25revolutionize it, like, like with extensions.

0:49:27Yeah.

0:49:27I mean, so my app implements a couple of services.

0:49:30I imagine if you know, when you ship Vesper for the Mac, I imagine you'll have a service.

0:49:35Right.

0:49:36Uh, I think you'd be surprised at how few people use it, but it kind of needs to be there just cause.

0:49:44The people who do use it will definitely want to put it in their workplace.

0:49:47Yes.

0:49:47Cause we appreciate these kinds of people.

0:49:48And you can go into, and it's so weird.

0:49:52It's like, you'd never think to look there.

0:49:53You have to go to system preferences on the Mac system preferences, keyboards.

0:49:59shortcuts, services, and there you get a list of all of the services from all the apps you have installed, and then you can turn off the ones you don't use.

0:50:11And it's so, like, who would ever think that you would go there to manage the system services, to go keyboard shortcuts services? It's just such a weird hidden place.

0:50:21And it is a giant list, too. It's kind of crazy.

0:50:24Yeah, and it's also a mess too because the service can specify its own keyboard shortcut

0:50:28But there's nothing that stops two services conflicting. Yeah, people shortcuts and there's no good

0:50:34No good way to resolve that I don't even know what the rules are like one of them somehow wins

0:50:40I don't know if it's the first one to claim it or the last one to claim it

0:50:43But one of them wins but it's not not because you the user if you can't order the first or last one. So it's

0:50:50I would imagine it's the last one that the system notices and registers, but completely arbitrary. Anyway, so long story short,

0:50:57yeah, the idea of services got nixed in iOS and...

0:51:02I thought you meant when I when I when I tooth sucked before and said ouch,

0:51:07I thought you meant the idea of like extensions for iOS. No, no, no. You're saying certain literally services.

0:51:15Right. Yeah. Well, that makes sense and that's forced all at his best. I think so, too.

0:51:19And I imagine this part will make the show. We're gonna have to edit that because I think

0:51:26I think some stuff got said that probably shouldn't have got said or at least publicly.

0:51:32I think that that was forced all at his best because he's an old next guy and

0:51:39services were kind of a feather in the cap of the next system and for him to be like no screw this

0:51:46We really don't want to go down this rabbit hole

0:51:48Yeah, and I think he was I think he had his eyes open enough to see that it didn't play out well on Mac OS X

0:51:54and I think part of the reason it didn't play out as well on Mac OS X as next is

0:51:59That next never really had a lot of developers

0:52:02They had like some and some the ones that they had even the third-party ones were amazing, right?

0:52:08The Omni group is still around the Omni group started right, you know, they were the you know

0:52:12fantastic company

0:52:15But there weren't you know people with next computers were never complaining about how long their services menu was because all the apps were

0:52:21Providing all these services that didn't have that many apps. That is exactly what he said. He's like

0:52:26There's like five apps out there. Don't worry about it. It's not an issue

0:52:32Try it on an iPhone. It's like oh my god

0:52:35I'm gonna be scrolling for like three weeks trying to figure out like where the service is that they want

0:52:40Right like I when I upgraded to iOS 8

0:52:43I took the time and like deleted all the apps that I hadn't used and I

0:52:47Figured if I haven't used it in a more than a month just delete it

0:52:49And if I really ever want it back I can just go to the App Store and get it back

0:52:53I wish I had I've got some man and I still have so many apps

0:52:56I you know and there's some I haven't used it, but I still I like that game

0:53:00So maybe I'll keep it. But anyway, I still have so many apps

0:53:03I can't even imagine how long my services menu would be. Yeah. Well, I mean I imagine you just install apps to try them, right?

0:53:08Yeah, and I do the same thing like and it's a lot easier to just leave them around than it's exactly I just can't be bothered

0:53:14I literally have grind around my app and I'm a straight male. So I don't know

0:53:18It's like every now and then somebody notices. I'm like I just I I needed to see what the UI was

0:53:26Cuz people were talking about this app all the time

0:53:28Just just in case

0:53:31Curious, who knows maybe I'll get drunk. I don't know. Yeah

0:53:36I've got I've got tinder to which else whenever is

0:53:39It's just awkward. There's I've got period trackers to like there is absolutely phone that I cannot explain to anybody except that like

0:53:47Somebody told me it was a good app to just see this kind of particular interaction with something. Okay, I'll buy it and try it out

0:53:54Yeah, whiskers, and I do that a lot

0:53:56Just if one of us spots an app that has an interesting interaction. We'll buy the app just just just to see like a good

0:54:04Oh, you should see the way that you can reorder lists in this app. You don't have to hit edit first. You just do this

0:54:12We're down to think yeah, like what like a long press and that you reorder. Yeah

0:54:16Yeah, yeah, and then but like what the app actually does something that's yeah, who cares what it is, right?

0:54:20It's it's like yeah might be managing your you know, your glucose levels for diabetes. I don't have diabetes. Yeah

0:54:26Something like that. Anyway, let's take a break. I'll thank our second sponsor

0:54:33grinder

0:54:35No, no not grinder now grand is awesome, I mean, you know, yeah, but it's not our sponsor

0:54:41It is back place our good friends at back place

0:54:44I have a great story to tell this is amazing. This is

0:54:47We are recording on Tuesday, October 7th last night Monday, October 6th my main Mac

0:54:59Fan was on real loud at my desk. My wife was gonna record her podcast

0:55:03And you know what and I checked the uptime and it was like 14 days

0:55:07I was like, that's a long time to run at this thing

0:55:09I'll just restart so I restarted the Mac and to let it sit at that login screen and

0:55:14Just shut up and let the fan go off

0:55:17So when she record she records at my desk because that's where the microphone is

0:55:20And she recorded her podcast

0:55:23Just the tip with the pork facets good podcast

0:55:28PK I came back after watching the baseball game and I wanted to get my computer

0:55:33You know restart and get it Safari back on ended up wouldn't restart

0:55:36I thought oh and I look and I like hit the power button held the power button shut down and

0:55:42Held the power button again, and I heard a little something starting up and a light came on

0:55:46But it never even got to the startup time

0:55:48Which is a very bad sign if this do you know if you don't hear that bong when you start your math

0:55:54You don't get past the post. That's a

0:55:57Very you could you should bet money that you have a logic board problem

0:56:00and

0:56:03I thought

0:56:05And then I thought you know what I know I'm backed up I know I'm backed up so there's you know worst-case scenario

0:56:11All I've got to do is just wait and restore from backup. I haven't lost anything

0:56:15I'm backed up in a couple ways

0:56:18But one of the ways I'm backed up and I know I'm backed up is through back place which is online

0:56:23backup that runs in the background and it's actually the one that gives me the most peace

0:56:27of mind because it's the one that I don't have to do anything about and I literally this is what I

0:56:31did is I didn't try to resuscitate the Mac it was late at night and I thought I'll worry about this

0:56:34in the morning I just went to a different machine could have been my iPhone could have been another

0:56:39Mac doesn't matter you just log into backblaze I logged into my backblaze account and just looked

0:56:43and it said that I was backed up as of like 8 p.m last night and I was like oh I'm all set

0:56:49What is back plays back up it backs up everything on your Mac everything if you have external hard drives it backs those up to

0:56:57What's the limit on space? It's unlimited. You just pay five dollars a month and everything on your Mac gets backed up

0:57:04What's the catch there is no catch if there's if there's technically a catch it's that the five dollars a month

0:57:10Which is incredibly low is per Mac

0:57:13But that per Mac cost is everything on the Mac including the external drives

0:57:18I if I didn't have back plays I have no idea

0:57:21I either we've been up all night trying to restore or resuscitate the drive opening the case trying to take the SSD out and put

0:57:26it in a

0:57:28Another case and putting it in stayed up all night doing stuff like that

0:57:32All I did is just log in my back place account. I knew I was backed up

0:57:36Nothing to worry about

0:57:39Can't say enough

0:57:41What a great feeling that is

0:57:43You just here's what you do to sign up go to back blaze comm slash daring fireball back blaze bla

0:57:50Z.com slash daring fireball they know you come from the show that way

0:57:54You get a 14-day free trial no credit card up front. Just do that install their software on your Mac

0:58:02Set up an account use the 14 days. It might take a while for all of your stuff to get up upstream through the cloud

0:58:10Do that in the first 14 days see how it works

0:58:13See how it's just once you have it set up it just runs you don't do anything

0:58:17You don't have to remember once a day to hit the back place button and do an upload

0:58:20It just uploads as it sees that you need to incrementally

0:58:24Can't say enough. I mean here I am testimony to it

0:58:28Broken Mac nothing lost camp couldn't be easier. So my thanks to

0:58:34Back place go get them. Don't be a dummy who's not backed up

0:58:39That's great. I mean just honestly we had to deliver show because you're Microsoft bust up. Yeah

0:58:44I'm glad it worked out. Yeah, I

0:58:47The best thing about I'm telling the best thing about it. You don't have to remember anything to do it

0:58:51Yeah, I know. I don't trust myself either

0:58:53Which is a testament to backless, I don't really like it, you know, I'm never gonna

0:58:58If I intentionally have to think about backing up, but I'm gonna screw it up sometime. Yeah, it's not really backup

0:59:05I think somebody argued with me once and I agree with it that if if your backup system is something you have to invoke manually

0:59:11That's not a backup system. It's

0:59:13Smart, it's smart. You know, it's something you've got clones of your data

0:59:17It's worth doing I use super duper like that the third part, you know external drives, but it's

0:59:24It's not really backed up backed up is when something hits unexpectedly and then I go and check and I'm backed up from the last

0:59:31Moment, I remember sitting at my computer, right?

0:59:34Well, I think, you know, I think that's what Time Machine tries to address and I think

0:59:39that that's what Backblaze does in spades, right?

0:59:42Yeah.

0:59:43Yeah, Time Machine is a great solution too.

0:59:44I'd say do them all.

0:59:45Do, you know, there's no way you could be more backed up.

0:59:48Yeah.

0:59:49You could be too backed up.

0:59:50Well, you can be, but not in terms of your computer.

0:59:53Yeah.

0:59:54No, Time Machine is one of the best things that Apple did.

0:59:56I still think that they need to, I would love to see Apple do something, improve the means

1:00:02of using Time Machine from a MacBook.

1:00:05Like I know they've got the Time Machine base station, but I still feel like that could

1:00:11be a better experience.

1:00:12I mean, did you notice that they got rid of the... maybe I can talk about this.

1:00:17I'm gonna anyway.

1:00:19They got rid of the Star of Backfield background?

1:00:21Yeah, yeah.

1:00:23Yeah.

1:00:24Good call.

1:00:25Way better.

1:00:26Yeah.

1:00:27Yeah.

1:00:28My understanding is the starfield was literally a joke. It was like somebody…

1:00:34My understanding is that it was Mattis basically making a joke and they were like, "Yeah, run with

1:00:41that." Yeah, it was definitely Mattis. I've heard the stories. Yeah, I don't want to peg it to

1:00:45someone. But that's hilarious. It's like, "Here's the goofiest thing I can imagine. Yeah, let's make

1:00:51that a product." Right. It's like an interesting way of starting. Like, "Well, what's the most

1:00:57outlandish what like what's the most what's the most buttoned up way that we

1:01:01could do it well see time machine here's dr. who right well you could do like

1:01:06both extremes you could say what's this most straight laced conservative

1:01:09buttoned up way we could do it and say well it would look like the finder

1:01:12except just maybe it's just list view you know it just looked just like the

1:01:15finder but maybe yeah that's a different color okay all right what's the most

1:01:19outlandish way we can do it yeah you're like it's like the credit scene of dr.

1:01:25who like the opening right you're dr. who and we'll do it we'll do it in 3d

1:01:33and that's no they were like let's let's go ahead and do it we were talking about

1:01:39forestall before and somebody emailed me and again you can't you know it's small

1:01:43data samples because it's only been two major releases since forestall left but

1:01:48somebody emailed me I didn't recognize the name it's not it's not like somebody

1:01:54somebody who, you know, but it was clearly somebody who had some, you know, who used

1:01:57to work at Apple, you know, some engineer and just said, hey, you know, but doesn't

1:02:01work there anymore. And just more or less said, you know, this could be, you know, the

1:02:06downside of losing Scott Forstall because whatever you want to say about Scott Forstall,

1:02:11Scott Forstall knew how to manage large software projects.

1:02:16I don't know how much from the outside. Now, this is somebody who was on the inside who

1:02:19I said, you know, this is just seems a lot like like Scott was better at knowing that we should

1:02:25We should kill a couple of these features because we're not we're not gonna ship on time. Otherwise, I

1:02:32You know, I don't know that's I thought that was an interesting observation maybe that's not true

1:02:37Maybe there's you know people from Apple who are listening to the show right now shaking their heads thinking my god

1:02:42That Scott was the worst at that. I don't know. I'm just saying that's what one person wrote in

1:02:47But so far two for two major iOS releases post forestall and again just leaving aside the design

1:02:54Style of them which clearly was in opposition to his you know his direction

1:02:58But in terms of how good were they, you know when they shipped in September, they're not that not so good quality wise

1:03:05And I think in both cases it was because of I think it's too much to do in a year I

1:03:12Honestly think it's too much to do in a year

1:03:17To be honest, I've heard nothing bad about working under Scott for style

1:03:22You know beyond the regular Apple rigmarole right there, you know, it was demanding of course

1:03:33It's like yeah. Yeah you

1:03:36if you're reporting to Scott forced all your you know,

1:03:39You're up there and you did it's a high-pressure job for sure, right?

1:03:46But in general, it's unclear to me why the break with the company happened.

1:03:53Maybe it was just time to change management, change it up a little bit.

1:04:00It's unfortunate that since then we've had a couple of iOS releases that maybe seem a little bit undercooked.

1:04:13For lack of a better word.

1:04:16Yeah, and I…

1:04:19I know you attribute it to being locked to the hardware, but I more attribute it to being

1:04:26overzealous with adding features.

1:04:29Because I mean, there's two things, right?

1:04:30Like you can either hit the date or you can do less stuff.

1:04:34And I would err on this site, and certainly in this case, just do less stuff rather than…

1:04:41You can't change the hardware, really.

1:04:43- And I think you have to combine that with the new,

1:04:48and again, from a product marketing perspective,

1:04:50I totally understand it, but from this style of,

1:04:52we're gonna tell you all about it at WWTC in June.

1:04:56And I feel like they feel like they're painted in a corner

1:05:00that what they've promised in June

1:05:02has to ship in September, for the most part.

1:05:05- Yes, yeah, yeah.

1:05:06- And there's a couple of things that don't,

1:05:08but that will be coming in October

1:05:10because they need Yosemite for them.

1:05:12And it's the same, I've pointed this out before,

1:05:14it's like the iCloud Keychain was last year.

1:05:19iCloud Keychain was a WWDC unveiled feature.

1:05:22September, iOS 7 came out,

1:05:24and even though it was in the betas throughout the summer,

1:05:26it wasn't in the final version,

1:05:28and then it was there in October in a point release

1:05:32when Mac OS X Maverick shipped,

1:05:34because it somehow needed all of that.

1:05:36And again, it goes back to the gears needing all the,

1:05:39You need all the gears to be there for this thing to work.

1:05:42Right.

1:05:43And as I said at the top of the show, I think the interconnectedness is, and with the watch

1:05:48too, and you know, the imaginary Apple TV sometime next year.

1:05:55This is just, it's going to keep getting more complicated, right?

1:05:59Like the interoperability is going to end up being a difficult thing to address in a

1:06:07lockstep manner.

1:06:08you need a lock separately, well you don't need one, but ideally you would have a lock

1:06:13separately for all of these features.

1:06:17Maybe and this is me trying to play devil's advocate, maybe take a more optimistic view.

1:06:22Maybe though iOS 8 was sort of like iOS 7 where iOS 7 was this. We have to do all these

1:06:29visuals at once. We have to redo the visuals and all these animations and everything that

1:06:34you all the pixels that are thrown on screen across the system at once in nine months.

1:06:39And so of course it was going to be rocky. And maybe iOS 8 is the same way in terms of

1:06:44laying the foundation for all of this interapp communication.

1:06:49Yeah, the extensions and all that, right. Yeah.

1:06:51Well, and I'll go even further, interapp and interdevice communication.

1:06:57Good point. Yeah.

1:06:59And that maybe things can slow down in terms of how much happens year over year and that

1:07:05iOS 9 in September will by nature bite off less because it's going to be about making

1:07:12these things work better and more seamlessly rather than starting them from scratch.

1:07:17Yeah, I agree.

1:07:20And again, I don't want to pretend that iOS 8 or the extension or anything are bad,

1:07:27misconceived or poorly done, there's just more rough edges in the OS than you would

1:07:36expect.

1:07:37And I think that's because of the, you know, I think they tried to do a lot more in a lot

1:07:45less time than they could really achieve with certainty.

1:07:51Yeah, and I don't think it's in any way a

1:07:54Refuting the idea that Apple is internally more collaborative than before or

1:08:04That that they could solve this that they're still understaffed or something like that

1:08:08I think it's it's simply the nature of you know, it's it's the mythical man month. You can't exactly

1:08:16Yeah cannot you really?

1:08:18You can actually like almost prove it that you cannot ship software high quality software faster by throwing people at it

1:08:25You know and that I do think I think the nature of the features

1:08:28Themselves shows that they're the company is more collaborative

1:08:33But that doesn't mean that you can that it makes it possible to do this

1:08:36Like if they weren't if they were as siloed as they used to be there's these features wouldn't even exist

1:08:41So do you know who argues against this notion?

1:08:47Smart guy. His name is John Gruber from back in 2003.

1:08:53This is that...

1:08:56Yeah, this came up last night on Twitter. And you know what? This is a great article.

1:09:01I disagree with a lot of it, as I did at the time, because I don't think we...

1:09:05I don't even know if we knew each other, but, you know, I'd read you because you're smart

1:09:10and just disagree with a lot of your arguments. But this is literally called the good, the bad,

1:09:16on the Avi, which is a classic dick move.

1:09:21This was when Avi left, right?

1:09:24It was when Avi left, and like, yeah.

1:09:28Yeah. Sûlée was like the replacement for the software guy.

1:09:32But you have a couple of... This is when you actually bother to write

1:09:37like a million words. You haven't learned to edit yourself yet.

1:09:42But an essential aspect of Mac OS X's success is that it didn't merely ship, it shipped with discernible momentum.

1:09:49It got better both in terms of performance and usability steadily and on a regular schedule.

1:09:55First the public beta and then each release from 10 through 2.

1:10:00You go on to say, I feel like a jackass quoting you to yourself, but...

1:10:07That's all right.

1:10:07Yeah.

1:10:07It's my 11 year old self.

1:10:09So it's a different person.

1:10:11a whole different person. This one major update per year schedule is an essential aspect of

1:10:16Mac OS X's success. The general perception is Mac OS X isn't just good, but that it's

1:10:22good and getting better. That perception seems to be held not just by the Mac community,

1:10:27but the computer industry in general. I think that's an incredibly astute point. The rest

1:10:33of the article I can argue with you about a lot, but you specifically call out the yearly

1:10:40schedule.

1:10:41I'll say this. I don't think you're in disagreement with me though. I don't know and and that was it was

1:10:45the first few years of Mac OS X it was

1:10:48Definitely. I mean it was very annual. I mean the first release was six months the 10/1 came out. Yeah, they really needed it

1:10:55Yeah, and yeah talk to people who worked on it. They were like, yeah, we that had to have to also

1:10:59trivia first free OS X release

1:11:03Was it 10/1? 10/1 was free? 10/1 was free. They just gave it away if you went to like any appy dealer

1:11:10Yeah, it was an apology. They would burn you a DVD and just give it to you

1:11:13And that was when after that though they were still selling them for $129 each. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, that's right

1:11:19I think about how old I remember being shocked when they started dropping the price of the major OS releases

1:11:25Yeah, me too. 129 bucks compared to Windows seemed reasonable to me, right?

1:11:29But now it seems like oh my god, that would be awful. Yeah, no one would upgrade

1:11:38But I see the thing is though is that I feel like in those 10 1 10 2 10 3 10 4

1:11:44I forget when I slowed down and dropped off the annual cycle maybe around 10 5

1:11:50Yeah, but they were it was it wasn't two steps forward one step back

1:11:54It was just two steps forward year after year after year and there wasn't any kind of

1:12:00But I mean there might have been niggling details here and there if we went back and read Syracuse's

1:12:05you know, refresh our minds about what it was. But they were niggles. There wasn't like major

1:12:10fundamental things that were, here's a big new thing in 10.2. It didn't ship like totally not

1:12:16working. It shipped and it worked. And it was like, oh, this is bad. Yeah, more or less. I mean,

1:12:20you could complain about Spotlight or some weird little stuff around the edges, you know, but.

1:12:25Something that was broken in the, you know, the first, you know, the GM version and, you know,

1:12:30needed a bug fix. So, you know, there are always bugs.

1:12:33And, and Syracuse, yeah, the finder is garbage and fine.

1:12:37Nobody was arguing though that nobody was arguing in the 10.1 to 10.2 to 10.3 to

1:12:4410.4 era that Apple's trying to do too much year over year. Right.

1:12:48I think it was more like what I said in the article that, wow, this,

1:12:51they're really on fire and they're just improving the OS on a steady basis.

1:12:55Well, you did at the, at the start of the article,

1:12:58and I'm trying to find it now because I don't want to misquote you,

1:13:00But you said something about copious software projects.

1:13:03The announcement also indicates that the change was more than titular and that

1:13:10Cirle will be taking over responsibility for day-to-day management of the company's

1:13:14copious software projects, which at the time did not raise an eyebrow at all.

1:13:20Right.

1:13:21Yes, completely correct.

1:13:22Now that's kind of funny.

1:13:24Just thinking about how the scope and the scale has changed.

1:13:30This is great piece. Like I implore everybody to go read this piece.

1:13:33It was a different time for sure. I mean, and it was, that piece was also,

1:13:40I specifically remember when I wrote it,

1:13:41it was trying to catch up from the fact that daring

1:13:47fireball didn't start until 2002. And a lot of the,

1:13:51um, the next,

1:13:54the new guys from next versus old guys from the Mac side friction,

1:13:59was mostly played out around '99, 2000, 2001, before I had "Daring Fireball" to do it.

1:14:07So you dredged it up?

1:14:10A little, I think a little bit.

1:14:12I remember reading this piece and being like, "Really? Are we still doing this?"

1:14:17Right.

1:14:18But it's smart, and I don't disagree with... I understand a lot of the perspective now.

1:14:24I still like to and in hindsight, you know in hindsight, it's you know, it's it all worked out for the better

1:14:31You know, but I've said this before that I still like to think that

1:14:34the the Apple next

1:14:37Combination I know some people have called it a reverse takeover and it's more of a joke though. But yeah

1:14:43Yeah, but at an executive level it did happen

1:14:45Yeah, it's in terms of Steve and in the people he picked to directly report to him. It was mostly a reverse

1:14:52Well, whatever. It's a it's a marriage. It's a marriage and the next people ended up wearing their pants

1:14:57Shiller was already there. Right and Schiller stayed and is there to the state Johnny?

1:15:02I've was there and Steve, you know as said we kind of picked him out of the

1:15:05He went in he went in Steve went into the industrial design group having looked at Apple shipping products and

1:15:12Drawn an estimation of the quality of their industrial design

1:15:16He thought I'm gonna have to go in here and fire all of these people

1:15:18Walked in and met Johnny I've and saw the stuff that Johnny I've had wanted to ship and was like, holy shit

1:15:24There's a gold mine. These guys are geniuses. Yeah, you know, it was like, you know

1:15:28It was to be fair to computers at the time Apple was still shipping some beautiful stuff. Go look at a beige g3

1:15:35266

1:15:38Just before it had that little sidebar thing and and the way that the panel came off with like that that little

1:15:45It was like a green Bondi Blue almost kind of latch that you could just hit and the side panel would fall off so you could

1:15:52access the interior. Way better case design than anybody making PCs.

1:15:59I had a

1:16:01Power Mac 9600.

1:16:03God, I forget what the chip was in that.

1:16:07Like a

1:16:10604?

1:16:11That makes a power PC 604. Yeah, I think so. That makes sense. Yeah.

1:16:15I think it was before there were rumors of an upcoming

1:16:18620 that I don't think they ever shipped and they did went to the g3 instead

1:16:22I had a 604 but it was but it had that same thing though where you could access the case

1:16:27Internals without like tools and stuff like that. You could take it apart. Yeah, not needing a screwdriver. I

1:16:32Mean and everything was wrong at the time. Yeah, and everything was super neatly organized inside

1:16:39It was like going into a like a library and it's like here's where you'd put RAM in

1:16:43here's what you do. So if you wanted to add RAM or change the RAM, you know, take out your, you know, one gigabyte

1:16:48Your one megabyte Sims remember Sims and replace them with two gigabytes or whatever

1:16:57It was easy and that the clips were nice. It didn't feel like you were breaking the motherboard

1:17:02Everything was great. Especially I mean I'd come from history of building my own PC's which was awful

1:17:08well, I mean I enjoyed it at the time but

1:17:12you know needing a screwdriver to get into your case was kind of in the ass and this was the

1:17:17exact opposite of that experience I

1:17:20Remember I had friends in the dorm trexel who had a built a built from scratch PC and that they they ran it

1:17:28Literally where they ran it with the with the top open. They just left it unscrewed and they'd

1:17:36They had a positioned a box fan like an actual like the thing you'd put in your window

1:17:41They put a box fan next to it to keep you down. Yeah, that's awesome. I had

1:17:47Just one up here. I so I built a second PC so that I could play like network games on it

1:17:56and

1:17:57I didn't buy a case. I literally had a motherboard the mother the motherboard was sitting atop

1:18:04I swear to God I'm not making this up. It sounds like I'm just gonna make this up.

1:18:09It was sitting atop an old issue of Macworld magazine.

1:18:11Long, long way at rest.

1:18:14There was like a motherboard with like a VGA card,

1:18:17like literally like a VGA card, a networking card, and I think that was it.

1:18:22There was some RAM in there and it was just wired up to a monitor.

1:18:25And you know where it was? In my closet in my apartment.

1:18:29And my friends would go in there and like sit on a milk crate and

1:18:33We'd played Age of Empires one

1:18:35It was like the best 300 bucks had spent but it you know

1:18:42No, it was like C3PO before they put the don't even that didn't happen

1:18:47But anyway where I was going is that whatever the the the the hiccups were

1:18:56You know the friction the years of friction between two different cultures - I like to think of it in hindsight as a reunification

1:19:02that the the next side that jobs created clearly had Apple DNA I

1:19:08Couldn't agree just you know it but then they were separated by years like, you know again not to draw

1:19:15Too too dramatic an analogy but like East Germany and West Germany, but then when the wall came down

1:19:21Yeah, it was rough for a couple of years because it had been so different on the two sides, but they're still all Germans

1:19:27No, so I totally agree. So I came to this from

1:19:31The next point of view if not actually having been super invested in next and I would read you and

1:19:39Syracuse a and

1:19:42disagree on some of the technical issues, but

1:19:46You know over the long run. I think we share the same philosophy in a lot of ways

1:19:51And we're good

1:19:53philosophy is I think we're all pretty much of one minded by this point right like right yeah like an

1:19:58Insatiable desire for nice things. Yes, exactly. Right? Yeah, and what what you attribute to being a nice thing I

1:20:04Think has changed over the years. Yeah. Yeah, but

1:20:08Ultimately, it's the same

1:20:11Like you say like a DNA like that there's a commonality there, right, right and that you know

1:20:18Once the initial friction was off, but I you know there in those early years though

1:20:21I had very strong opinions on a lot of those issues and almost always erred on the side of the traditional Mac

1:20:28side of the argument. File name extensions versus type and creator codes, stuff like that.

1:20:35Yeah, you got it wrong so often back then.

1:20:38No, I was totally right. I was totally right. I maintain. I was totally right.

1:20:44The path, the stupid addressing files by path instead of file ID. It's ridiculous.

1:20:50I don't disagree, but you're... OK, this is like a 20 year old argument at this point. Forget it.

1:20:56Right, but you know.

1:20:58I mean ultimately if people had done what you wanted them to do, it would have been

1:21:02a non-starter.

1:21:03No, I don't think so.

1:21:05I think it would have, no, we would have gotten to where we are now anyway.

1:21:09It's just where, how, what was…

1:21:10You wanted to use New Kernel.

1:21:12No, well, I don't know.

1:21:14Did I say that?

1:21:15You literally said, I'm not, this is a quote, I'm looking at the website, and this is

1:21:20really unfair, okay?

1:21:22I don't have anything from this period that you can call me on for being stupid, and I'm sure it was stupid in a lot of ways.

1:21:27And I don't even think this is stupid, but you literally wrote, "I'm not claiming that New Kernel was perfect or superior to Mach in every way. I'm not in any position to make such judgments." That's great.

1:21:40But by all accounts, the idea of using New Kernel rather than Mach was never even considered by Tevinian, no matter what inventions it held.

1:21:49Which, yeah, because swapping out a kernel under an OS is a pain in the ass.

1:21:55New kernel, remember, was designed from the outset as a kernel to power future

1:22:01PowerPC based Mac operating systems.

1:22:04Mark wasn't.

1:22:06Wait, there's something about power management in here that I really want to find.

1:22:11We're going to have to get Dave to edit this.

1:22:13For one, superior power management, a continuing weak spot in Mac OS X.

1:22:18It was it was it was

1:22:20At the time you were completely correct now it runs on your phone

1:22:25It's very true. All right, they saw so again, they solved it in a different way

1:22:31It's and they you know, you could say that right, but I don't know that that it was I'm not saying you're wrong

1:22:35I'm just saying right, right, but it was true like flavor of the commentary was different right like right because there was a

1:22:43Cultural divide. All right

1:22:46Yeah, well, you know the kernel stuff is probably a thing over my head but

1:22:51No, I mean, I'm not

1:22:54Trying to be a jerk here. No, but another part too though is I'd I'd

1:22:58Wasn't I didn't know enough about how the next system worked and I was thinking about it more from like the open step perspective

1:23:06Which maybe that was mock too, but I thought that was a little bit more abstract where it ran on Solaris

1:23:11It was mock and I had a lot of weird stuff and yeah, it could well

1:23:15But that because like that open step ran on Solaris, I thought that that well Coco that the Coco

1:23:21Right. Yeah

1:23:24You know and I that's what I thought that more or less was I was thinking was that why couldn't they take Coco?

1:23:30And do on new kernel what they did to get it running on Solaris. Maybe that was a terrible idea

1:23:36Maybe that you know, that's you know, what? I don't know. I honestly don't know

1:23:40I think new kernel is probably kind of billiard

1:23:44Right because they even had they even had the cocoa layer running on Windows

1:23:47I mean that was they were actually and they actually thought maybe they'd still ship that at first they were going to ship the

1:23:53They're gonna call it yellow box from when yeah, they really could I mean

1:23:56yeah, the the open step lever the cocoa layer as we call it today can ship on a bunch of different OS's and

1:24:02To be honest probably will in the future

1:24:05Go eventually gonna swap out the underpinnings. I

1:24:11I shouldn't be passing judge again from a computer.

1:24:13So you literally say I'm not in any position to make judgments.

1:24:17And you said that back in 2003.

1:24:19So I'm really not trying to be a dick about this.

1:24:22I'm just, it's just, it's funny, right?

1:24:24Like it's, it's worth the discussion about it.

1:24:27Right.

1:24:27But there was, it was, I was expressing the frustrations from a lot of people I

1:24:30knew within Apple who were there, you know, from the Mac side who knew that,

1:24:35maybe that's just one example,

1:24:37but that there was a lot of Mac stuff that wasn't even considered, you know,

1:24:40just because it was a, you know, if it wasn't from the next side, it was crap inside of things.

1:24:46And the only stuff that did survive was stuff that Next didn't even have, you know, like QuickTime

1:24:50famously survived. And not because QuickTime had a great API, QuickTime had a horrible API. I mean,

1:24:55you talk to anybody who ever programmed QuickTime, they get the shakes and you bring it up. But it

1:25:01was the fact that Next didn't have anything. They didn't have a multimedia thing. They needed,

1:25:07you know, QuickTime gave them something they didn't even have before. You couldn't even play

1:25:10movies on next machines. They replaced quick draw with quartz. Yeah, well that was a big win because

1:25:16quick draw was so much better. They ditched the wrong thing. They ditched display postscript.

1:25:21Right, right. That was just, you know, that was one that I don't remember being contentious,

1:25:27though. There might have been some, no, it was one of the best moves that they did with with OS X,

1:25:31for sure. Right. And that, you know, the quick draw, having been designed to do

1:25:35technically amazing things on 1984, 1985 computers was not,

1:25:40did not make it relevant going into the future. Right. Yeah. Uh, so yeah,

1:25:44so quartz, the compositing windows server was way ahead of its time. Yeah.

1:25:49And at the time I was frustrated with Syracuse's reviews because

1:25:54he complained about resizing windows.

1:25:56Like why do they resize with live?

1:25:59Like rather than just the classic Mac OS outline thing.

1:26:04And I was like, because that's cool and it's awesome?

1:26:09But he's right.

1:26:10Like I've come to see the product point of view of it

1:26:13where, you know, resizing it five frames per second is not,

1:26:18that's not tenable, it's dumb.

1:26:20- I remember at the time, that was the years

1:26:25that I was working at bare bones software.

1:26:28And we'd get new developer betas of OS 10

1:26:32Install them on you know, really good hardware, you know, it wasn't like we were installing it on cheapy stuff. And I remember watching

1:26:38Jim Korea who's now at Omni group with just all the

1:26:44Fellas, but Jim would Jim would just open a window and first he would grab the corner and resize it really really fast and

1:26:52His eyes would start to roll

1:26:54Then he'd grab the window title bar and just shake it over the screen as fast as he could and you'd see all of this

1:27:01Shearing I mean it was just there's no way that it could keep up with you know

1:27:04Jim's hand just going side to side and they would just roll, you know, just sigh walk away. So it was so bad

1:27:11You know what? That's funny though. It's what I think is so interesting though. Is that in between?

1:27:142000 2001 Apple which went for looks beautiful even if it is painfully slow to

1:27:232006 Apple making the first version of iOS which looked beautiful

1:27:30but never got slow. So was that it was a subtle shift in priorities where I disagree with that characterization, but

1:27:38Sorry finish. Well, here's the example that the example is you load daring fireball and mobile Safari on the original iPhone running iOS

1:27:461.0 and you start to scroll. What do you see? You saw that checkerboard. Remember the checkerboard?

1:27:50Yes. Yeah, so the scrolling always kept up with your finger

1:27:55But they would just dump the content and show a checkerboard if they needed to

1:27:58So it always felt like it was perfectly responsive with your finger. So, you know

1:28:03it but it wasn't showing you the

1:28:06Content in high fidelity and in fact with the checkerboard it would just drop it completely

1:28:10Mm-hmm, and I thought you know

1:28:13I thought that was one of the most genius decisions in all of the original iOS 1.0. Was that checkerboard?

1:28:18Of course, you know clearly the ultimate answer was to just keep up with your finger with the actual content

1:28:26Which is what all iPhones do today?

1:28:28But in terms of what they should do then, the macOS 10 1.0 solution would have been for the iOS to do really jittery,

1:28:37sheery, you know, shearing scrolling, have scrolling get real slow as you scroll a big long web page.

1:28:44And what they came up with in 2007 was delightful.

1:28:48It actually, even though it was disappointing slightly at first that, oh, I can't keep the whole page there.

1:28:53But the fact that it no matter what you did what you saw those checkerboards moving up in the screen kept pace with your finger

1:28:59Was to me delightful. So I agree. I was initially going to disagree. But yeah, the the the checkup the

1:29:06instant

1:29:08interaction is always

1:29:10Better

1:29:13What I liked about Mac OS X at the time when it was released was that it was betting on the future

1:29:20like yeah hard like harder than it really should have because at the time when it shipped the product I

1:29:26Liked because I was more on the nerdy side of the scale like I could see what they were doing

1:29:33But it wasn't a great product

1:29:37Well, and it's harder to bet on the future when you're behind right, but they did they bet hard and you know

1:29:44Microsoft had to catch up years later with Vista which right comically late to the game at that point, right?

1:29:49Well and that and and at the same time that os 10 was shipping more or less

1:29:53Roughly 2000 2001. I mean 2001 was actually when XP shipped

1:29:58Yeah

1:29:59But Microsoft was shipping what would go on to be the single most popular version of Windows that ever shipped

1:30:04Right, and I think it's quite possible. Maybe it that ever will ship

1:30:09They might be in some if not a decline like they've hit a permanent plateau. Yeah, and they'll never be as popular

1:30:15No new version of Windows will ever be as popular as XP was

1:30:19Yeah, do you find that I find that a bit of a bummer? I don't know how you feel about that

1:30:24No, I think it's do I think it's a little depressing because I feel like it'd be better

1:30:28You know best thing there, you know

1:30:29It's clearly the one of the best things that's happened to the iOS is Android getting its design act together

1:30:34Right, you know, yeah whether you know, well, I mean that much of it of you know, the market

1:30:43is God kind of kind of person I just like to see everybody doing awesome stuff all of the time and

1:30:49It's not happening, right?

1:30:52Right, it would be better. It's just better in general if other people are doing awesome stuff and it's also

1:30:57Yeah, but you know and then from a more objective point of view it does keep everybody on their toes. Oh, yes. Yeah, you know

1:31:04You know just going back to the main thesis of this episode where we're talking about is Apple doing too much per year

1:31:13year. Maybe it's better if they do a little bit too much per year than do a little too

1:31:18little too per year, right? As a general rule of thumb, if they have to err on one side

1:31:23or the other and because humans are imperfect and because software planning is imperfect

1:31:28and software management is imperfect and software engineering is certainly imperfect, you're

1:31:34never going to get it exactly right. So if you have to take a guess whether you're going

1:31:38to go a little too fast or a little too slow, it might be better to go too fast.

1:31:41So, you know, yeah, well and so I agree with you

1:31:45But I'm gonna have to I'm gonna play devil's advocate for the sake of conversation

1:31:50Just before the show you sent me the link that yeah says that iOS 8

1:31:55Adoption has stagnated compared to iOS 7 adoption

1:32:00If that keeps happening

1:32:04That is that's a bad sign, right? I think this it's and I think it's a really bad sign

1:32:11So it's and these are Apple's own numbers, which is really interesting.

1:32:16I don't want to say damning, but kind of damning.

1:32:19Apple has a web page on there.

1:32:21It's the App Store support page for developers.

1:32:24And it tells you at like a once a week snapshot.

1:32:28I think it's once a week.

1:32:29I don't know.

1:32:30As we record today on October 7th, the data comes from October 5th, two days ago.

1:32:35And it just tells you of devices that have come to the App Store in the last,

1:32:40I don't know, is it a week or something like that? Here's what OS they were running.

1:32:43And as of, you know, 20 days after the release of iOS 8, it's about a 50/50 split. iOS 7 is at 47%,

1:32:52iOS 8 is at 47%, and earlier versions, the remaining 6%. The reason that's bad, that's really...

1:33:00I mean, to be fair, that's better than most other people in the industry.

1:33:04Yeah, but it's really a year ago, Iowa 7, 20 days after it came out was at 70%.

1:33:10Right.

1:33:11Which is not, it's not like that's well within, you know, outside like statistical variation.

1:33:18You know, that's a big difference. That's what is that 24%? And, you know, there might be,

1:33:26almost certainly it's multifaceted the reasons why, but I don't think it's outlandish at all.

1:33:31I think it's almost certain that part of it is that

1:33:35people out there feel like they've either had bad experiences in the past when they've okayed the

1:33:43Okay, a software update is available. Do you want to install it?

1:33:47And now they're more likely to hit cancel than they were otherwise

1:33:51Or it's just what they're hearing from people about iOS 8 then. Oh don't do it. You know wait

1:33:57I've

1:34:00As I said, I told Adrian not to update and she'd already heard it from people at work

1:34:07That's that's a bad sign like that

1:34:14You can't do that. Yeah, like eventually on last week's episode of this show with Ben Thompson

1:34:21I just said offhand I said, you know, that's the long term if they keep having OS releases like that

1:34:25it seems inevitable that it's gonna slow the pace

1:34:28of adoption, which is not in Apple's interest,

1:34:31and it's not in the interest of third-party developers.

1:34:33Like, it's been a very virtuous circle for Apple,

1:34:37because their newest features are in front of more people,

1:34:41and if it works well, it makes people feel like,

1:34:45"Hey, my year-old iPhone is even better

1:34:47"than it was a year ago,

1:34:48"because I've got these cool new features."

1:34:50And it's good for developers,

1:34:51because when new developer technologies come out,

1:34:56they can adopt them quicker than right away,

1:35:00like the new auto layout stuff

1:35:02and adaptive size stuff for new screens.

1:35:07You can do that even though it's iOS 8 only

1:35:09because Apple promises that a majority of customers

1:35:12are gonna be running iOS 8 very soon.

1:35:14- Well, I think like,

1:35:18It's almost absurd that you can, like a great lens to look at Apple is to look at the order of priorities, right?

1:35:30Which is at this point, pretty basic.

1:35:33It's Apple, their customers, and then third party developers.

1:35:36Right.

1:35:37I think that, you know, shipping buggy OS updates initially hurts their own customers.

1:35:46And that's probably what they care about the most.

1:35:48Right.

1:35:48Yep.

1:35:48Yeah.

1:35:49And then their customers won't update and that's going to trickle

1:35:52down into third party developers.

1:35:53Right.

1:35:54And then that's the, you know, given the cycle of life, like the feedback

1:35:57loop, uh, if third party developers can't count on customers, having the

1:36:02up the OS updated, they can't adopt the good, the good stuff that Apple

1:36:08has released and wants people to do.

1:36:11Uh, it's.

1:36:13It's a horrible cycle.

1:36:15So yeah, as a developer, that sucks that maybe I can't count on these new things, but I think

1:36:29Apple should probably serve their customers first.

1:36:33I understand the priority system.

1:36:36I think they've failed their own customers in a certain way, to some small degree.

1:36:41Yeah, it might be, you know, that you can't overestimate, underestimate, I don't know,

1:36:50whichever way works.

1:36:53How much damage you can do to the trust between the typical user, of which there are now hundreds

1:37:02of millions of them.

1:37:03Exactly.

1:37:04So they're not technical people at all, they're just people who want to have an iPhone that

1:37:07works or an iPad. And the trust that they have in Apple when that dialog box comes up and says,

1:37:13"A new version of iOS 8 is available for your device. Tap here to install."

1:37:18Because I think once you've said no once, why would you not say no again the second time?

1:37:25You have to... You've been trained that everything's great and then something bit you.

1:37:32Yeah, there's a little boy who cried wolf angle to it and it's slightly a bad metaphor because that the kid in that allegory is a liar

1:37:39And apple's not doing this on purpose. They're not lying. No, no

1:37:42Clearly everybody with an apple wishes that all these features worked

1:37:45Perfectly also, I hate that story because it's dumb to show up every time the kid kills wolf like just do it

1:37:51Like why just a point a new kid?

1:37:53Just get the kid off the hill

1:37:56There's better solutions to this problem. Yeah, you know what you're gonna work you're gonna work inside from now on

1:38:01Anyway, sorry to cut you off.

1:38:05But the townspeople's reaction, though, is human nature, where if you feel like you've

1:38:11been burned a couple times and you feel like, "Hey, my iPad got kind of slow when I installed

1:38:16iOS 7," it is going to make you less likely to do it.

1:38:20And I know that that whole aspect gets…

1:38:24The jackass way to overstate it is that whole thing that came up last year where that it

1:38:28was planned obsolescence.

1:38:30That infuriated me. Well, here's what and I think now we're seeing why it's so infuriating, right?

1:38:36So last year there were there was there were people like in the New York Times

1:38:39I forget who but a couple people chirping in that. Hey, I upgraded my old iPhone. It's a year older

1:38:44It's two years old and now it's slower

1:38:46Apple did that on purpose because they want me to buy a new iPhone and

1:38:49I thought that was so stupid because it's had so little respect for people like if Apple had done that on purpose

1:38:55Isn't it a natural response for somebody who says hey, I?

1:38:59Had I paid a lot of money for my iPhone. I did what Apple told me to do and it got slower

1:39:04Maybe I should try a Samsung phone or something

1:39:08I mean, that's a little bit of culture the market II kind of thing for me personally, but I see your point

1:39:13I do I understand where you can that's that's a perfectly rational reaction to it. Yeah, I you know

1:39:18That's what I think if it had been the case. Yes, but yeah

1:39:22Take the politics out of the fact that Android versus iOS is sort of a political thing where we've got we've got

1:39:28Tribes, you know that you and I are part of this, you know

1:39:32Mac indie Mac iOS. Yeah, I like to pretend that I'm not but right but fair enough

1:39:37Yeah, take it to something where there's there's less really, you know religious style fervor

1:39:42I know we try I do hope that I do too that I kind of try to stay above that and keep my mind open

1:39:47It's best I can but there's no doubt be honest it, you know

1:39:50And it's there and the people who listen to our show and stuff like that

1:39:53But just I'm just saying though that like if you buy that let's take two brands that are really close and intertwined in their histories

1:40:00And in their reputations Honda and Toyota right that they're both Japanese

1:40:04And they both have this reputation for quality and for durability that you know you can buy a Honda or Toyota

1:40:09And it's a very good likelihood. It's gonna last for over a hundred thousand miles

1:40:13And that's you know you bought Toyota's two two or three cars in a row

1:40:17And then you buy a Toyota and you get a bad one

1:40:20And it's you know has transmission problems two years in doesn't that make you more likely to think hey?

1:40:25Maybe I should try a Honda next time right it doesn't make you think I bet Toyota did this on purpose because they want me

1:40:31To buy another car right that's just it's counter to the brand and the Apple brand is

1:40:36We make good stuff, and it lasts at least in terms of technology world lasts long

1:40:41And anything that did anything that goes against that is off the brand and off the message and off the relationship

1:40:48that they want to have with their customers.

1:40:50So I really think that that whole idea that it's planned obsolescence,

1:40:56that new versions of iOS run poorly on, or even less than ideally, on older devices,

1:41:03it's not just wrong, because I know from the people I know at Apple,

1:41:06the people I know at Apple would quit if they were told,

1:41:08"Hey, make this run slow on an iPhone 4."

1:41:10- Yeah, there's no way that it isn't really. - But really what?

1:41:13- No. - I mean that sincerely.

1:41:14sincerely I had a conversation with a friend at WWDC who rolled his eyes about

1:41:18and said literally I would quit if my boss came into me and told me to do

1:41:22something like that I would just immediately I would just say okay and

1:41:24then I would just pack up my stuff because I could get a job somewhere else

1:41:27I'm not gonna you know why would I do something like that that's you know

1:41:30evil's the wrong way that's not what he said but I would have no respect for

1:41:33myself if I did that that's not how they do it.

1:41:36No, that's honestly Apple. If anything, Apple is facing a crisis of talent retention.

1:41:45Yeah. And that's the sort of thing that would make it worse.

1:41:47If you start being like, well, you know what, cripple a phone in a year.

1:41:50Right.

1:41:51It's like, fuck you. I'll go, do you have much money that can get elsewhere? Like, it's fine.

1:41:58Like, these people can get a job wherever they want.

1:42:01Right. Like, the people I know at Apple are the opposite, where they would take pride in the fact

1:42:05that you know I worked on you know I don't know I worked on you know this UI

1:42:10list view scrolling yeah and it's still buttery smooth on an iPhone 4s I totally

1:42:15agree with you right and that's like that's a feather in my cap that it's you

1:42:19know that one I wrote it 100% nobody is trying to make anything slow right and I

1:42:26think that this thing to go back to this you know that the upgrade pace is

1:42:29is apparently significantly off year over year is to me, like I said, a canary in a coal mine

1:42:37that those sort of, hey, if you keep doing this, it's going to affect it,

1:42:41that it's come to fruition that we've got a dead canary here.

1:42:45I feel like it's a sprinter that is hit a stride that's like a little bit off and it's almost

1:42:51stumbling at this point. Right. And instead of saying like, hey, this could happen, you know,

1:42:57it's actually happening and we're seeing, you know, here the last lap around the track was slower.

1:43:02Right. Exactly.

1:43:03It's not just you and I, the commentators in the booth, speculating that maybe he's slower,

1:43:08the runner is slower, that it's, hey, you know.

1:43:10You can clock it.

1:43:11Yeah, the pace is off. Very, very worrisome to me. I haven't linked it up on During Fire. I

1:43:16probably will before the show hits, but I think it's, and there's a couple, somebody else has

1:43:20data that backs it up to Mixpanel. I don't know who they are, but the stuff from Apple I trust.

1:43:26Yeah, I mean it's their own numbers, right? So kind of

1:43:29I'd imagine you can hold them to their own numbers that I don't know why you wouldn't

1:43:34Yeah want to um, I think I think that they'll they it's not like and I don't think it's too late

1:43:40I don't think they can not turn, you know, but I feel like

1:43:42No, I think though that they've got to shift priorities

1:43:46subtly

1:43:48in favor of

1:43:49Higher quality even at the expense of doing less in the same amount of time

1:43:54Mm-hmm. Well, I mean, is it too late for the next cycle? I don't know. Yeah, I don't know Mark Gurman

1:44:01reported that

1:44:039-5 Mac. Yeah

1:44:05That they've got eight point one eight point two and eight point three in testing which is different than all most previous years

1:44:12They've only done a point one. Mm-hmm

1:44:14And I you know, who knows if that's the case or not

1:44:18I'm it was unclear from his report how much of that was just coming from

1:44:21User agent strings that that they saw at nine to five Mac in Google Analytics, which are easily fake. Yeah, I'm hesitant to

1:44:28But he also suggested though that he'd spoken to people who backed that up eight point two. I believe he's great

1:44:36He's got good sourcing a lot of the time

1:44:38I'm hesitant to

1:44:42You know to ascribe anything to version numbers like

1:44:48You know, the 6+ is, I believe, iPhone 7, 2.

1:44:54Yeah, 6 is 7, 1.

1:44:56Yeah, it does not matter. Those things don't get assigned until way later in the process.

1:45:02No, and the code names were weird, too.

1:45:04The plus was N56.

1:45:07The 6 was N61. I hadn't heard those, but they're arbitrary. I think we've both been told that they're...

1:45:16Yeah, you don't make any sense. Yeah. Yeah, like for example, yeah, like for example

1:45:21The fact that the six is n61 and the plus is n56 doesn't mean that the six came after

1:45:29There's no right. It doesn't mean that there were four iterations between it

1:45:33There's no rhyme or reason to any of this stuff. It is apparently just a you know, there's an open slot at n56 here

1:45:40Take it you call it your device the n56, right?

1:45:44But people inside Apple get you really used to calling it by those divide those names like they yeah

1:45:49I mean why we knew that's it, right? Yeah

1:45:51But but there's there's no reason. Yeah, right

1:45:56Right and the easiest thing to fake or fudge or whatever in the world is the user agent string of a browser. I

1:46:03know Don has

1:46:06All right, let me take a third break here, but then we'll wrap up the show but I want to thank our

1:46:13our third and final sponsor of this episode.

1:46:18Right back week after week from last week,

1:46:22it's U-Bar.

1:46:24It's a Mac utility.

1:46:25It's a dock replacement for the Mac.

1:46:29And it can be configured in a bunch of ways.

1:46:32You can configure it as a replacement for the Mac OS dock,

1:46:35that sort of same style.

1:46:36Or if you're a Windows convert to the Mac,

1:46:40or just a Mac user who likes the Windows-style taskbar.

1:46:43Ubar has configuration options that you can set it up

1:46:48to be a lot more taskbar-like than doc-like.

1:46:51So if you prefer a doc, you can configure it that way.

1:46:54If it's a taskbar, you can do it that way.

1:46:57But no matter how you configure it, it looks great.

1:47:00It's pure OS X, it's just a Mac utility,

1:47:02it's all written really native.

1:47:04The developer, I mentioned this last week,

1:47:07but it's so fascinating to me,

1:47:08his hobby is one of his hobbies is mechanical watchmaking and it really

1:47:15shows like a really really nice handmade mechanical watches with you know just

1:47:19everything you'd think you know really fine attention to the typography on the

1:47:23dials and the shape and exact length of the hands and everything like that you

1:47:28bar looks like software from someone who makes precision watches really does to

1:47:34me. But it's got a bunch of added features, nerdy features, sort of stuff that if you

1:47:40listen to the talk show you might be interested in. So it sort of also adds the features of

1:47:45Activity Monitor right into your taskbar, your dock. So if you hold the control key

1:47:50on your keyboard while you scrub across apps in the dock, it replaces the CPU name or the

1:47:57app name with the CPU and RAM usage for each process running in your dock. You can spot

1:48:03Unresponsive apps immediately an app that's you know doing the spinning pizza of death

1:48:08Gets a flag right in the right in the dock right away

1:48:11tons of customers

1:48:14Customization light and dark themes just like in Yosemite

1:48:18You can add favorites for quick access or have it's just show the apps that are running

1:48:23And the developer he's right. He's working like mad. He's really just focused on this

1:48:27You bar 2.0 launched in July and there's already been 30 updates

1:48:33And they sponsored the show last episode and he emailed me and said the response from listeners has been phenomenal a

1:48:40Bunch of listener suggestions have already been implemented in you bar through updates just since last week

1:48:46and he's been blown away by how smart and enthusiastic and

1:48:50Allah's dad how good-looking the the audience that listens to this show is

1:48:57He's already had he had the Apple store business specialists emailed him because customers started asking about you bar after he was on the show

1:49:05That's great

1:49:06And it a Japanese user spent it sent him an email saying that a typhoon was on its way to Japan

1:49:11Which gave him free time because he didn't have to go to work. And so he sent over a full Japanese translation

1:49:16Of the user interface. So gee, I think the bar is now just since the last episode of the talk show

1:49:23It is now localized in Japanese due to a typhoon. So I hopefully everybody's okay from the typhoon

1:49:28Typhoon was good news really really really interesting software

1:49:33I had not heard of this utility before and it's really really interesting. I it's certainly not for everybody

1:49:38that's the whole point of things like dock replacements and and you know launch bar and

1:49:43Alfred and and apps like that

1:49:47That sort of thing is not for everybody right Alfred and launch bar are not supposed to replace spotlight for everybody spotlights the interface

1:49:55That's like that's for like

1:49:57hundreds of millions of people

1:49:58Things like you bar is you know for geeks who want to customize stuff really really interesting

1:50:03Normally, the app is 20 bucks, which is a steal for software like this

1:50:07But here's the password or the code coupon code Gruber Edition all one word. It's like the the watch Gruber

1:50:15edition

1:50:17and you get 50% off meaning it's just 10 bucks 50% off 10 bucks for an amazing

1:50:25app from a developer who's clearly very very responsive to requests so I wouldn't

1:50:31be surprised if you looked at it and thought well if it just did one more

1:50:33thing maybe I would send this suggestion in here's where you go to find out more

1:50:37Ubar, U-B-A-R, app.com. Ubar, app.com, and the coupon code, all one word, Gruber Edition.

1:50:47Nice. Like gold. Pure gold Gruber.

1:50:54It has been, it's been like eight days since the episode came out, but I thought,

1:50:57my God, that's a lot to happen in a week.

1:50:59Yeah, that seems awesome. That's great. And you know, it's not even like a Sherlock

1:51:07because he's you know like these kind of things I mean yeah it's reverse

1:51:11you're looking like this is this is destined and intended for aces like you

1:51:17if you are you a Mac ace go get this right yeah it's like you know BB edit is

1:51:24it was not Sherlock when they in text that is that in the system you know

1:51:28right it's like if you need it you do you know you need it whereas Apple is

1:51:32focusing on the you know all across the board like that's the way you survive

1:51:36when Apple has a built-in app that does the thing that you do yeah

1:51:39busy Cal busy Cal gets by by doing more and better than the built-in calendar

1:51:45app yeah yeah I mean you you ship a notes app right and you're moving to the

1:51:50Mac so you know all right you've got it you're trying to look at it and say we

1:51:56can do better right you have to look at it and say Apple is always going to do

1:51:59something that's sort of very very basic for the built-in thing yeah no I I

1:52:03totally agree where were we you tell me I don't know I think we were talking

1:52:13about we were wrapping up I think the discussion on on the annual cycle is

1:52:19that fair is that right yeah like where where do we think that they should go

1:52:26from here.

1:52:27And how about this…

1:52:28Do less.

1:52:29And you know what?

1:52:30Honestly, I think that at this point, I think one of the problems is they've committed

1:52:38themselves to doing a major revision every year.

1:52:42And that is… and as much as I love marketing at Apple, like done correctly, I don't think

1:52:55that you can commit yourself to doing as many new features per year as they have been committing

1:53:02themselves to do and integrating it across all of the product lines from the Mac to iOS

1:53:09to the watch and eventually to the Apple TV stuff. Maybe that's a minor point but it'll

1:53:18eventually be a thing. I don't know what to do. I mean, maybe just get away from numbers

1:53:27at that point, right? Like, does it need to be iOS 9 next year? Or can it just be like,

1:53:34here's our latest iOS?

1:53:36Yeah, I don't know though.

1:53:39I don't know either. I really don't know. But what's happening is untenable, I feel.

1:53:47I see the sense of that, of getting rid of version numbers, but on the other hand, I

1:53:51really don't know what version numbers mean to people. What does my dad think when his

1:53:56iPad says that iOS 8.0 is available? How much of that is gibberish and how much of it does

1:54:02he get the basic idea that it's a new number? I don't know.

1:54:10But I do want, so that's a, that's a great point, but I do wonder if that internally

1:54:15and because they're so involved in the industry and the, that particular way of

1:54:20looking at things, they see a new version number, meaning major new features.

1:54:27Maybe you don't need that, you know, like maybe.

1:54:31You know, and I know this is an off beaten path or what's the phrase, I don't know.

1:54:39Yeah.

1:54:39Whatever.

1:54:40Horse that's been beaten a lot. Somebody's been beaten beating it ever horse. Yeah

1:54:44But to compare the version to compare software version numbers to

1:54:51The automobile industry and nobody's confused when they say the new 2015 Honda Accord, right?

1:54:58but the 2016 Honda Accord may not be

1:55:02It's only every four three four five years that they actually do like wow. It's all together new. It's a new drivetrain

1:55:10It's a new you know a new body shape, you know and in between you know the years they're incremental, right?

1:55:17But they don't label them differently and they might advertise it more when there's a major new change

1:55:23right when they truly upgrade the body and it make it look a lot more modern and it's bigger and has a

1:55:29major new

1:55:30Technology in the engine they might spend more on the ad campaign that year than they did the year before

1:55:35When it was an incremental version of the one before but they still just give it a new year and they just say it's the 2016

1:55:42Honda Accord and

1:55:44You know and that seems to work pretty well for them

1:55:48I don't know and I always thought that that was sort of what Microsoft was going for when they went from Windows 3

1:55:54Oh to 3 1 to Windows 95 was right the some let's not bother people with

1:56:00And then you know Windows 98 and then they you know, I guess there was a Windows 2000

1:56:05But then they were ran in a different direction with XP because it was I think maybe because they were I think that was a good

1:56:11idea, but

1:56:13You know, they were to announce something and then ship a year later and I think that bit them and they got cold feet

1:56:18Yeah that they were having they were yeah and and it they weren't doing it annually

1:56:23And so you were still running office 98 in the year

1:56:262001 and it fried old whereas if it had just been a version number you might not think that whereas it really seemed like and

1:56:33I don't know. Maybe there was something even that made it worse about crossing the millennium and still running, you know

1:56:39Maybe but I mean I works 11. Yeah, that was kind of awful

1:56:44I think Apple kind of stepped in that exact same right so Apple had stepped in the same thing

1:56:49Yeah, I work 11 was was up to date up until

1:56:53And it's funny because some people still like it better. Yeah, so that's awkward

1:56:58They had a bit of a Microsoft moment in a microcosm right there, right?

1:57:03And it's just the case that you know, even the companies that are functioning

1:57:06Well, it's just so takes so long to ship big software projects, right?

1:57:12So, yeah, I don't know if getting rid of version numbers would be the problem

1:57:17I don't know if just doing less in each one and letting you know

1:57:19like as other a couple people have called it having a snow leopard moment and you know

1:57:25like Apple said with snow leopard which no new features right no what a great ballsy move did

1:57:34I can't think of any other company in the industry ever literally ever that is had a big event saying

1:57:44we have nothing new right we're just going to spill we've we're just gonna spend this next you

1:57:49know, a couple of months and, you know, we've spent the last few months and we're

1:57:54going to keep spending the next few months, you know, cleaning up the foundation.

1:57:57Which, if we're honest, was effectively a misdirection because they had GCD, they

1:58:03had a bunch of API changes under the hood.

1:58:06Yeah.

1:58:06They had done a lot of work.

1:58:08But it was stuff that was...

1:58:09The user features, right?

1:58:10Yeah.

1:58:10It was really hard to market, right?

1:58:12GCD.

1:58:12Yeah.

1:58:12GCD, that was when GCD...

1:58:14So GCD is a perfect example where it was...

1:58:16I think that's when they killed garbage collection too, in favor of AHRQ.

1:58:19Yeah, I think so. Yeah. And I think Syracuse have pointed out perfectly in his review that,

1:58:25you know, no new features does not mean he had nothing to write about. If anything,

1:58:30he had as much to write about as ever before, because he cares deeply about that sort of stuff.

1:58:36But from like, what do you tell normal people who are just coming in for a new MacBook? Well,

1:58:41what's new in Snow Leopard? It's well, we've cleaned it up under hood, and it runs more

1:58:45more efficiently. It's not the answer is it's better, right? Like better than that.

1:58:50Seeing it in conversation.

1:58:53But it's, you know,

1:58:53it was a fact that though that a lot of engineering resources had been committed

1:58:58to and devoted to things like GCD and arc and stuff like that,

1:59:02that wasn't user facing. And you know, again, it's, it's in a sense,

1:59:07sometimes or not even sometimes,

1:59:09almost always the best marketing is to be completely honest, you know,

1:59:13And even if it sounds like a funny thing for a tech company to say, no new features, I don't know, it went over well with everybody I know.

1:59:21And I think in hindsight it was a great release.

1:59:24I agree, but I do, you know, kind of everybody you know and everybody I know is that, you know, that's a bit of a small window, right?

1:59:33Yeah, but, you know, it is…

1:59:36Tech-wise, right?

1:59:37Right, but think about the people you know. You know, like, like with Adri, like with

1:59:43you recommending that she not update. Wouldn't you like to be able to tell her next year

1:59:47with iOS nine? Yeah, just go ahead and update. It's just gonna make your phone run faster.

1:59:51Like, really, if you really believe that that was the case, don't you think that would go

1:59:55over well with her? I mean, I

1:59:56Oh, yeah, yeah. Like, like, restoring a little bit of faith and stuff. I mean, I already

2:00:01told her like 802 whatever 8 yeah 802 do it go for it it's gonna be good I think

2:00:11there's still like a little bit of trepidation but yeah like next year I

2:00:14just want yeah I get crap from Amy I do like I think like a lot of people like

2:00:21she had iTunes match turned on and she updated she got a new phone and she

2:00:26updated or she had to update cuz she got a new phone and I said all of her music

2:00:30was there and then she went to the gym and there was like no music on her phone.

2:00:35And I was like, "Welcome to iTunes Match."

2:00:38And she blamed me because she just, you know, she knows that I don't work at Apple and I

2:00:42certainly, you know, I had nothing to do with iTunes Match.

2:00:45But she blames me that the cloud is just unreliable.

2:00:50And I said, "I'll tell you, I think that what I did is I turned off iTunes Match and I have

2:00:54all the music I want.

2:00:55It's on my computer and I just sync to iTunes the old-fashioned way."

2:00:58So I said, "Here, give me your phone."

2:00:59off iTunes match, plugged it into her Mac, and sync and said, put all of her music on

2:01:05it. And now all of our music is there. And she's never going to complain again. But I

2:01:08would love to have been able to say to her, yeah, just upgrade to iOS eight, and it fixes

2:01:12all the iTunes match issues.

2:01:14Yeah, that makes sense to me. I haven't actually ever used iTunes match. But there's a lot

2:01:21of little things with the cloud stuff that works like that. Well, that's, yeah, that's

2:01:25what I'm saying. Like, I used to really worry about backing up my iTunes library, because

2:01:29I bought that and if my hard drive died, I'd be

2:01:33screwed. Uh, that's mostly no longer the case,

2:01:38right? Like, man, I don't care anymore. I buy a

2:01:42new device and I've got all of it. It, at least

2:01:45it lists everything that I've ever bought and I

2:01:48can watch, you know, I can buy my new phone and I

2:01:51can watch a casino rail on it because I bought it

2:01:56years ago

2:01:59so i don't i don't really care about that kind of stuff that much anymore

2:02:04well i think music and not to go

2:02:06gone a total i tend to enter but i think music is very different from movies

2:02:09because with movies

2:02:11if you're real you know

2:02:14you don't missus there's no real good reason to have all of your movies with

2:02:18you all the time

2:02:19on a local device real desert the only time i worry about is that i'm going to

2:02:23go to flight

2:02:24Yeah, something. And even then you're probably only gonna load a handful of them and you can stand to just sit there and wait

2:02:31Whereas if you're you know want to listen to music for the next 90 minutes and you don't have any of it on your device

2:02:37Right, it's you know, it's a pain in the ass if you have to sit there and wait and wait and wait and wait

2:02:41and wait

2:02:43Yeah, it's a little different. Yeah

2:02:45And for the most part this stuff does still just work where you get a new device and sign it even if you don't restore

2:02:51from a backup and you just sign into your iCloud account and you say what was that book that I book I bought and I

2:02:56Wanted to look it back up there. It is and you hit the cloud button and just comes down

2:02:59But it doesn't always work. Sometimes it just you know, the download gets stuck

2:03:03so

2:03:07What's your take on this yearly update thing

2:03:10You know

2:03:14John Gruber in

2:03:162003 seem to think it was a great idea. I

2:03:20I think what like what would be your like how would you frame this discussion now? You know if you had to rewrite this piece?

2:03:25Well, not the whole piece. I wouldn't I think that they I think that they should go they there

2:03:31I think the annual pace is probably fine and actually probably helps keep them in check

2:03:37But I think that they should consider doing less per year and polishing more

2:03:42And if they can figure out a way to let some ideas

2:03:48operate, you know, well if you get it done then you're in but if you don't but then maybe not

2:03:55advertising them at W maybe promising less at WWDC and maybe slating some of those things for

2:04:02a 9.2 update in March of 2016. That does make it hard for developers and it makes it hard for

2:04:12customer well more importantly from Apple perspective customers right like you need to I

2:04:16I think the reason that they stick to hard version numbers is that that is the gate for functionality.

2:04:25Right. And it is. And so many other things are annual at Apple, the phones come out on an annual basis.

2:04:32And for competitive reasons, they really do need to, because their competitors come out with new Apple only come out with one set of new phones every year is slow compared to everybody else in the industry.

2:04:42Oh, yeah, it's and it was a glacial but it's

2:04:46It's deliberative delivered in an industry where there's not much deliberation where it's sort of

2:04:52Soon, you know if you can ship it, let's ship it and see if people will buy it

2:04:56But Apple is very deliberative and they have to be but then they run into things where if they're gonna sell a hundred million of

2:05:02The same thing a year they need to be able to have a hundred million of every single component

2:05:06You know, they need to have a hundred million a eight systems on a chip and a hundred million

2:05:12Of the new you know HD retina displays in two different sizes etc etc every single thing in the box

2:05:19But the hardware runs on doesn't run on a yearly cycle though

2:05:24That's the thing they come out with one every year

2:05:26But they're in the works for longer than a year a lot longer than a year

2:05:30Which is why it's taken them a little bit too longer than the market would dictate to come out with bigger phones

2:05:36Because it's you know if it takes two years to make a new iPhone

2:05:39They didn't get to commit to these phones until about two years ago

2:05:43Like the iPhone 7 or whatever you want to call it two years. Maybe a big window. Yeah, but it's more than a year

2:05:49Oh, yeah, it's so maybe it's not quite two years. Maybe it's been more like for something

2:05:54But but the team that's doing next year's iPhones is already, you know long, you know

2:06:00They've been at work for you know, six seven eight months. The specs are already out there. I don't know. I mean

2:06:04I'm sure you know, but just listen, it's out there

2:06:07It's kind of funny when you talk to people who work at Apple because they have no idea what happened in what release

2:06:12No, they literally did like oh was that in that one. I don't know

2:06:16Blur's together more for them. Yeah, it's like I was done with that six months a year before yeah

2:06:24I mean you ever saw it so right yeah

2:06:27Yeah, and that they don't they don't even know what it's gonna be called. They have no idea

2:06:32They honestly don't yeah

2:06:33No, and so that really is what confuses it for them historically is that while they were working on stuff

2:06:38They don't know what it was going to be called and so in hindsight when they look back like two three years

2:06:44They don't they just know it was a mystery. Can't remember what product something shipped in they have no idea

2:06:49You have to remind them and they're like, oh really that's interesting. Yeah

2:06:54So no, I don't think the annual schedule is off, but I think that they need to pace themselves better

2:07:00I don't know and but again like I said, maybe the optimistic take is that iOS 8 because it introduced all this

2:07:06You think this was an aggressive release followed?

2:07:10That preceded by another guess of really yeah, yeah

2:07:15Maybe that'd be great. Yeah, I

2:07:19Think it's it'll be interesting to see how Yosemite comes out. I I've been running the GM

2:07:25I

2:07:27I think it's pretty good, but I don't know.

2:07:29I like it. I have some weird aesthetic choices about it, but whatever.

2:07:34Yeah, but in terms of quality, I don't think it's going to be a problem like iOS 8. Famous last words.

2:07:39Yeah, exactly.

2:07:41Famous last words, I guess, but I don't think so. I think the changes are mostly skin deep.

2:07:47Yeah, and while I have some issues with it, I don't think you're going to be

2:07:53Viting at the most the last

2:07:56blur

2:07:58Pieces right? No, no, like it's it's weird, but I don't think you need to you know, take the knives out of that one

2:08:05No, and I think it also passes the every time I go back to Mavericks now, I think it looks really outdated

2:08:11Yeah, yeah, and the hilarious thing is that it brings me back to Windows Vista

2:08:17Which did the blur thing right years ago and whoever did that?

2:08:22that if you're listening and you find me, I will buy you lots of beers because…

2:08:29Who did the Vista one?

2:08:31Yeah, the Vista Blur.

2:08:33That sucks for that guy.

2:08:34We all laughed at him.

2:08:37And now iOS and macOS are just totally like, "Yeah, let's blur everything."

2:08:42All of the time.

2:08:43Everything is blurry.

2:08:45And that guy is just…

2:08:46If he's not at the bottom of a glass, he should be.

2:08:51There is.

2:08:52We've already been two hours. We should wrap it up and I want to wait till Yosemite actually ships before really getting yeah

2:08:57Yeah, but there is some weird stuff though where the way that Apple's doing it doesn't make any fucking sense

2:09:04Right, and I know you're gonna agree with me. The main thing is that what you have a translucent sidebar the whole sidebar is

2:09:10Translucent in whatever. Yeah, it reflects the color of your desktop

2:09:15Regardless of how many windows are in between the front window and the desktop it

2:09:20It's completely random. I don't know. I want to talk to you who did this

2:09:25So like let's just say you have an orange desktop

2:09:28I've got a machine here right now with with the the the carpet from the shiny

2:09:32But it only does it when the window is the frontmost window. Otherwise, it's completely opaque, right?

2:09:38Anyway, yeah, it is

2:09:43People I well people I'm good people are gonna hear my description and then they're gonna file it away

2:09:49And I think I can't quite be like that

2:09:51But then everybody's gonna upgrade to Yosemite in a couple of weeks a week or two and then they're gonna

2:09:55Oh my god Gruber was right, but it's like so if you just just imagine you have one window open

2:10:01That's it

2:10:01And that's how Apple all their screenshots show just one window at a time this translucent part shows the colors

2:10:07Blurred shows the colors of your underlying desktop picture through so if you have like an orange desktop pattern, it's orange blurry

2:10:16But then if you have windows in between the front window and the desktop and they're all white like let's just say they're all

2:10:23Text edit windows, but they're all stacked on top of each other. The sidebar is still orange

2:10:28It's somehow

2:10:30Right I

2:10:33Can imagine the discussion that led to this where I can imagine a discussion where the idea was started

2:10:39We'll make it you know

2:10:40We'll make it see-through will make it translucent and it was all based on just like one window on the desktop and then somebody

2:10:46was like, but what if you have windows in between in the background?

2:10:49I love that that's the objection.

2:10:50Right?

2:10:51But what if there was more than one window?

2:10:54Right.

2:10:55And instead of saying –

2:10:56That's pretty much where you should start, right?

2:10:57Right.

2:10:58They would just be like, well, then it would be – it'll just be gray.

2:11:01And then somebody was like, well, then that'll be dull.

2:11:04And it will lose that – what's that phrase they keep using?

2:11:06That it shows the character of your desktop, you know, in front of your window.

2:11:10And then somebody said, well, it'll still show your desktop colors right through.

2:11:15And then they that's what they made happen. I

2:11:19Don't understand there's no logic to it, right?

2:11:24Maybe and maybe that's a you know

2:11:27Maybe that knowing two people like you and I but right because I want to see I want it to work like

2:11:33Somehow like I need to understand it visually and spatially, right? Yeah, I want there to be rules

2:11:38I want it to be like a game but that there are rules and if this is see-through then it should show

2:11:45whatever is behind it. I totally agree with you. The rules are completely fucking arbitrary at this

2:11:50point. Like now I'm looking at the programming. Like, restrictions have been placed on this,

2:11:58that, you know, I can't wrap my head around. I can guess why the choices were made, but

2:12:09aesthetically I can't explain it. Yeah, I'm not sure. I also, I do feel too, I feel like I'll

2:12:15predict that the other backlash is going to be that Helvetica as a system font really is pretty

2:12:24choppy on non-retina displays. And it's, this is the, what you're seeing in Yosemite, I guess

2:12:32there's no name for it really. There's not like a name for the theme anymore. It's not like called

2:12:36anything but the Yosemite you know look and feel the chrome is it's forward

2:12:41thinking to when all Macs are gonna have retina quality displays which I think is

2:12:46reasonable I mean and I think you're trying to avoid like aqua no way or

2:12:50something right yeah it's a it's it's a different thing yeah I think it's the

2:12:55right time and it's again it just you know it's like you said with the whole

2:12:58compositing system in Mac OS 10 10.0 right I take your lumps right you gotta

2:13:03- Take your lumps. - Right, take your lumps,

2:13:05but then when the hardware catches up,

2:13:06we'll already be ready.

2:13:08And I feel like the whole Yosemite look and feel

2:13:12is so clearly optimized for retina

2:13:15and then made secondhand to look as good as possible

2:13:18on non-retina, as opposed to the other way around,

2:13:21where up until now, the Mac interface

2:13:23has been non-retina first,

2:13:25and then it just looks kind of weird on retina.

2:13:28Not that it looks low res,

2:13:29but that it just are odd decisions.

2:13:32isn't quite suitable, yeah. No, I totally agree. And this is, I am sitting in front

2:13:38of a Mac Pro, more or less the most expensive computer you could buy from Apple, and I don't

2:13:46have the written screen. And I'm kind of bummed out by the, you know, Yosemite look.

2:13:54One day, hopefully soon, I'll be able to upgrade. But no, I totally agree with you

2:13:59I think it's fine. I think every now and then there's going to be a jump and something is going to be degraded.

2:14:07And to bring it back to the Fireball piece that we talked about previously and Techno 2034,

2:14:16every now and then you take your lumps. You take a step back and it lets you sort of move into the future a little bit more.

2:14:28And I think Yosemite is one of those kind of releases.

2:14:30Yeah, I agree.

2:14:32Yeah, I'll have to link.

2:14:34I'll put it in the show notes.

2:14:35I'll link up that.

2:14:36You really should.

2:14:37You know what?

2:14:37It's a great article.

2:14:38And I disagree with like 90% of this.

2:14:41Well, because it's easy to say now.

2:14:46And I did it, I did at the time, but I can't prove it.

2:14:48But like a lot of this is like provably wrong, right?

2:14:52Or at least history didn't bear you out.

2:14:54But this is, I kept reading you.

2:14:57And this is one of the reasons why I'm like, this is, this is a very smart piece.

2:15:02Very well considered.

2:15:03I disagree with the conclusions.

2:15:04A lot of it though, is our stuff that could never really be settled.

2:15:08Yeah, I know.

2:15:09I grew up with that too.

2:15:10The file name extensions, file name extensions is perfect.

2:15:12And the, the file paths is another one.

2:15:15The file path thing was just stupid.

2:15:17I could, I could do another show about all of this.

2:15:20Yes.

2:15:21Yeah.

2:15:21I remember at some point, I mean, we had, we had software updaters in the

2:15:25nineties for the classic Mac OS.

2:15:27Mac OS that no matter where you put the application on your hard disk, if you ran

2:15:30the updater, it would find it because it would find the app by an identifier and

2:15:36then update the app to the latest version.

2:15:38So you didn't have to put it in a special folder.

2:15:39And then I remember, I forget which app it was, if it was iPhoto or one of the

2:15:44iTunes or iPhoto, but the next guys wrote an updater in like 2002 or 2003 or so.

2:15:51So do you know what?

2:15:53It's the very next article.

2:15:55It's the very next article on Daring Fireball called Finding Abby.

2:15:59You had your knives out for--

2:16:02Yeah, I did.

2:16:02--to opinion.

2:16:03I don't know why, but you did.

2:16:06Yeah, you'd run the iTunes updater, and it would nuke your whole hard drive.

2:16:13If you had renamed your hard disk.

2:16:16If you'd done anything clever at all, it would nuke your hard drive,

2:16:20which is awesome.

2:16:21Because it was making assumptions about the paths.

2:16:23Yeah.

2:16:24Oh, totally.

2:16:25It was awful.

2:16:25There were rough times.

2:16:26You know what though?

2:16:27I'm going to try to address this obliquely.

2:16:33A friend of ours who went on to manage iMessage, Game Center, and all of that kind

2:16:39of stuff.

2:16:40Do you know the guy I'm talking about?

2:16:42Yeah, I know exactly.

2:16:43Okay.

2:16:43So apparently, my belief is one of his first gigs was like, the can't the guy

2:16:51that wrote that installer and his thing was to fix it.

2:16:53It's great, right?

2:17:01I feel bad.

2:17:04I know.

2:17:05I feel bad.

2:17:06I don't want to be…

2:17:07I mean, mistakes happen.

2:17:08I really…

2:17:09I'm not laughing at the guy.

2:17:10I'm just laughing at the circumstance.

2:17:11Like, shit happens.

2:17:13You know what?

2:17:14I was…

2:17:15Like, the way that you say I really had it out for Avi Tavanian back then.

2:17:17I don't know why you did.

2:17:18I really don't.

2:17:19I didn't understand it.

2:17:20I don't know either.

2:17:21Yeah.

2:17:22It was immature even in my 30s. Yeah

2:17:26Well, it was pennies dude, he's done like a great stuff right? Yeah, and in hindsight, you know

2:17:35It was you know help turn Apple around, you know

2:17:37Yeah

2:17:37And and you know what and I even I even acknowledged in the article even acknowledged in the article that the classic Mac OS updates

2:17:44Yes

2:17:46next reunification him and they were outstanding like

2:17:51Eight to nine for whatever.

2:17:54- Yeah, but especially 8.0 and 8.1, I think--

2:17:58- 8.5 was, whoa, okay, maybe 8.1.

2:18:018.5 was big 'cause I think it put quick draw on PowerPC.

2:18:06- Yeah.

2:18:08- And I'm definitely iffy with my classic Mac OS history,

2:18:12but there was a lot of good work down there, like a lot.

2:18:17And it was all under him.

2:18:18- Yeah.

2:18:19- And then you just come out.

2:18:21But I acknowledge that though.

2:18:22But they, you know, they don't understand what the animosity was.

2:18:26Well, you know, file extensions.

2:18:30Was it like a, just a narrative device or, which is cool.

2:18:38I don't know.

2:18:39I was a little bit, and I was a little bit more, um, less hesitant to go a little

2:18:47over the top, you know, to, to fill the glass all the way up.

2:18:50Because I didn't have a big audience. It was a very small audience

2:18:55I didn't like I would never have expected that he'd he'd read what I wrote and maybe he did

2:19:00I don't know but I you know, whereas now today

2:19:02I know that if I wrote something like that that whoever it is with an apple would read it and not that I'm afraid

2:19:06To write anything critical of someone at Apple, but it would be more measured, right?

2:19:10Yeah, I want to have my ducks in a row and make sure that it is right. It is not over the top

2:19:15I want it to be at the exact right level of

2:19:19Yeah, these two posts to me are literally fireballs

2:19:23Yeah, which is not to say that you don't love them

2:19:26now and I don't mean to take that away from me, but this is just

2:19:31Yeah, it's like a bit more headstrong than I think you would be now

2:19:35I think you'd be more measured and it's like my answer, right?

2:19:39It's like my my use of the word jackass where I was. Yeah, I used to be freer with it

2:19:44Yeah, and I don't think I ever once used it. Maybe there's one time where I regretted it a little bit

2:19:49But I miss those jackass of the week was funny

2:19:51It was funny, but and it was usually people being jackasses

2:19:55But it got to the point where I realized though that a lot of people who I would call jackass of the week when you googled

2:20:00Them the first hit was me calling them a jackass. This is horrible. You don't mean that

2:20:05I don't but I did mean no

2:20:07But I always meant though that when I said someone was being a jackass that they were literally being a jackass

2:20:13They were being willfully ignorant or will deceitful is that it was particular choice is bad doesn't mean that they're

2:20:19You don't type that right, but I usually come up with like oh, they're a jackass like that

2:20:24I use it way less frequently now though because I know that I've you know

2:20:28Daring fireball is more widely read and more influential. Yeah, I know that was a conscious decision though, right? Right, right

2:20:34and it's the same way where if my criticism of like an Apple executive or something like that is

2:20:38Try I try to be more measured now

2:20:42But without being you know, I don't want to be dull and I don't hold back. No, no

2:20:48Best way I can put it is I don't want to go over the top. I want to get right to the top

2:20:52I want to make sure it's accurate

2:20:54Whereas in the early days I would felt free to go over the top because I didn't feel that there were any repercussions from it

2:20:59yeah, and I am I don't mean to be blog critic, but

2:21:03So the second piece about Ivy

2:21:06Immediately after the other one finding Ivy

2:21:10literally starts with a handful of readers emailed to complain about Monday's mixed review of

2:21:15Aubrey Tabinian's legacy at Apple's vice president of software engineering.

2:21:20And you addressed it head on, which is one of the reasons I'm like, man, I fucking totally disagree

2:21:29with this guy, but good work.

2:21:32You know?

2:21:33Boy, those articles are way down in the archives.

2:21:37Yeah.

2:21:38They're way back and it's totally unfair to hold them to you.

2:21:41I will link them up.

2:21:42All right, we should end the show, but I will put them in the show notes, or at least I'll

2:21:45put one in the show notes and then if anybody wants to read them, you can keep reading next

2:21:49previous article to read the time.

2:21:53What was the time?

2:21:542003?

2:21:55Yeah, it was like a long time ago.

2:21:58Well, I can just search for his name.

2:22:00Yeah.

2:22:01Audiosafie.

2:22:02Fine.

2:22:03Thank you.

2:22:04You're such a dick.

2:22:05It was awesome.

2:22:07So this is very oblique and probably pretty inside baseball.

2:22:12I loved that Ben flip-flopped his opinion on the watch introduction.

2:22:21I thought that was great. I really did. And it speaks, I mean,

2:22:26I'm only bringing it up because I've read these articles back in the day and I

2:22:31was like, I disagree with a lot of this.

2:22:33And I sometimes read Ben's pieces and I'm like, kind of disagree, but so well thought

2:22:41out.

2:22:42Like, good, you know, smart guy.

2:22:45Very, very smart guy.

2:22:46Yeah, no, it reminds me of the thing I just liked two weeks ago linked to a Jason Fried

2:22:51piece where he, you know, Bezos was addressing 30, well it's not Basecamp now, not 37signals,

2:22:59but came in and did like a Q&A.

2:23:01He's you know, I'm sure he's not the first person to say it

2:23:03But here's how you can be right most of the time be willing to change your mind. Yeah, I love that

2:23:07Yeah, you know because you'll be wrong and then you'll change your mind and then it kid

2:23:11It's just funny and Ben Ben did that with a watch where Ben, you know had a sort of almost scathing

2:23:17Initial take on it and then we could talk to himself into being one of the biggest proponents out there, right?

2:23:23And there was a similar thing with Steve Jobs and Tim Cook and

2:23:30You know came out after Steve died, but like Tim's first, you know, D whatever conference, you know

2:23:36He said he was he was the world's biggest flip-flop er and waffler in the world

2:23:40But that's what made him great was one day. He'd tell you this is a terrible idea

2:23:44It's awful and then he come in the next day and say I have a great idea and it was your idea. Yeah

2:23:48That you know that his refute, you know that he was open to anything, you know, we're never gonna make an iTunes for Windows

2:23:56Okay, we'll make iTunes for Windows and then you know, I you know iPod from Windows becomes, you know a huge hit

2:24:02Over and over and over again and then you know

2:24:06It just comes up with people who you know have quotes of Steve Jobs saying that you know

2:24:10Eight inch tablets are a terrible idea or you know big nobody's ever gonna buy a big phone

2:24:14But it's proof that Apple is doing things. They wouldn't have done under Steve Jobs. No, I mean it's you know

2:24:20The market changes, you know, no, I took it. Well, it's not even market. I mean

2:24:24Good lines change. Yeah, I exactly that's a good way of putting it. I think there is a huge I

2:24:32Think it is an error to canonize Steve Jobs

2:24:36brilliant guy I don't want to take them away from him, but

2:24:40You know his is not the word of God like it's not set in stone

2:24:46Well, it's that word the the word from the you know again not to get bringing too much actual religion into it

2:24:52but with the Catholic Church, infallibility.

2:24:55Right, exactly.

2:24:55Yeah, he's not the pope of the…

2:24:57Right, the pope is held as infallible.

2:25:00And, you know, it's a real problem, because, you know, human beings aren't actually infallible.

2:25:07But there's a tendency among many to view.

2:25:09And it's funny because it comes from both sides, though.

2:25:12It also comes from, like, even like the diehard Android types, who say, "I thought Steve Jobs was infallible."

2:25:20And he said nobody would buy a five inch phone.

2:25:22Nitpicking effectively, which is like...

2:25:24Right.

2:25:24Yeah.

2:25:25And, you know, and it's also combined with the fact that what's true in 2011 is not true in 2014.

2:25:30Right.

2:25:31So, I mean, I believe this is in your Twitter stream somewhere.

2:25:37Uh, you know, there was a guy telling Neaton Ginnatra that Apple doesn't behave in a certain way.

2:25:46And, you know, Neaton Van, the Iowa...

2:25:49He was the director of iOS apps.

2:25:52And I think that there's a projected view of the way that Apple does and does not

2:26:01operate and where it will innovate and where it will just, I don't mean just, but

2:26:12where it adopts the common implementation, for lack of a better word, the compatibility option.

2:26:23And I think with the file extensions and the credit codes and all of that, I think Apple did cave from something that might have been better,

2:26:35but they caved in order to achieve compatibility,

2:26:41and I noticed that you put that in quotes in one of your tweets,

2:26:45but a compatibility with a broader computing world.

2:26:49And they did so in order to achieve the ability to communicate with the outside world better.

2:26:57Which I think was a smart choice given the time, right?

2:27:01communicating was just about to become essential.

2:27:07I agree with that to some degree. I would at least say that there's a, it wasn't an

2:27:12unreasonable, the other side of the argument wasn't unreasonable.

2:27:15No I don't think so, which is why I read you in Syracuse and I was like.

2:27:19It was different sets of trade-offs and what do you value more and I just, you know, you

2:27:24know, and again you might be right though that in the long run it worked out better

2:27:27going with those decisions then. And you know, one of the reasons why is that ultimately we resulted

2:27:34with iOS where the actual file system is hidden. Right. Which I think Neaton is a big proponent of.

2:27:41Yeah. That's fine to me because then it doesn't matter if under the hood it's a case-sensitive

2:27:48file system with file extensions, which I think it still is. I know it was for a while.

2:27:52Yeah, it is. It is. Yeah, it's still case sensitive.

2:27:55Which is fine. I would argue against that vehemently if they ever did that with the Mac,

2:27:59where the file system matters. Well, that's because it's exposed to you.

2:28:03But right. And to usual users, right? Right. You know, I can conceive of a Mac 10 years from now,

2:28:09or maybe even less, maybe five years from now, where it's the file system is only for people

2:28:14who've installed Xcode. Right. So I have a difference between the presentation versus

2:28:20the representation, right? Where the presentation is what you see as a user, and the representation

2:28:25what is actually happening on disk.

2:28:28And I think file systems in a lot of ways

2:28:30have often favored exposing a representation

2:28:35of exactly what's happening,

2:28:38rather than projecting a view

2:28:43that is more useful to the user.

2:28:46- In my analogy on file system, on file name extensions,

2:28:50as a user exposed feature, it's always been that--

2:28:54They're bullshit. It's awful.

2:28:56It's two pieces of data in one field, separated by an arbor, just a piece of text, just a dot.

2:29:06Well, there's a turret sitting there between the two.

2:29:08Right. And so it's easily, you know, it is easily changed, you know, if you want to, but it, you know,

2:29:16I can't tell you how many times I've talked to people who thought that the way you convert a ping to a JPEG is to erase the PNG and type JPG.

2:29:24Do you know what? That should actually work.

2:29:26- It should in theory.

2:29:27That would be amazing if it worked.

2:29:28I could see, you know, again.

2:29:30- The Finder should do that.

2:29:31That should work.

2:29:32- It should say, "I noticed you did that.

2:29:35Would you like me to change this to a JPEG?"

2:29:36That would be amazing.

2:29:37But guess what?

2:29:39That doesn't actually happen, and it didn't happen there.

2:29:42But people, I can see why to a normal person,

2:29:44it should work.

2:29:45And to me, it's just like, well,

2:29:47why not put the creation and modification date in there too?

2:29:50And then you have to have a date and a name

2:29:52and a file extension all in one field.

2:29:54- Ah, you're just being a jackass.

2:29:56- No, it's the exact same.

2:29:58It's all-- - I understand, okay.

2:30:00I understand it's the same thing.

2:30:02- The file system has always had a field

2:30:04for the creation date and the modification date,

2:30:06and it's different from the name.

2:30:08And it never had a field for the type, and it should've.

2:30:12- I mean, do you wanna go over the history of this?

2:30:14- No, but I'm just saying that two pieces of data

2:30:17in the same field is a clued.

2:30:19And the Mac didn't suffer from that.

2:30:21The Mac had something that was more graceful.

2:30:23And it wasn't built for the future, and it wasn't built for compatibility with anybody

2:30:27else.

2:30:28But they should have only replaced it with something that was better, not with something

2:30:32that was more primitive.

2:30:34I think file name extensions were...

2:30:39You used to be able to name a file, and whatever type it was didn't matter.

2:30:44It was assumed that you'd be able to feed it into the correct app.

2:30:48This is before GUIs, you know, old school stuff, right?

2:30:52When it became apparent that we would have file formats that would work in not just one application,

2:31:02but in multiple applications, extensions were born, right?

2:31:08And the way that that got addressed was just being literally appended to the end of the file name.

2:31:14It's the most pragmatic workman-like thing you can do.

2:31:22It was so obvious and so basic that I think pretty much universally it was adopted.

2:31:29The Mac tried to throw it off, and I think ultimately it failed because it didn't command

2:31:37the market share that could really make it happen.

2:31:41You know what I mean?

2:31:42Well, no, but it wasn't really a problem for Mac users though.

2:31:45So when you download, in the old days, when you would download a GIF file,

2:31:50and on the server that it was coming from, it didn't have any type code

2:31:55because it wasn't a Mac server. It would just come down.

2:31:57Whatever software you downloaded with would look at the file extension

2:32:01and just put the right creator code on. Or not creator code, type code.

2:32:05Well, wait, it would look at the file extension or would it look at the MIME type given by the server?

2:32:10Yeah, probably the MIME type.

2:32:13And all the browsers did it, all the FTP clients did it.

2:32:17It wasn't as much of a problem as you would think it was.

2:32:21It was not an issue.

2:32:22No, no, no.

2:32:23I'm saying this is why the file name extension thing exists and why…

2:32:28I think you can explain it to anybody and anybody would get it.

2:32:32Yeah.

2:32:33But I just…

2:32:34In hindsight, to me, the big thing isn't which side was right.

2:32:37it's that everybody was wrong because giving users access to the file system

2:32:41was wrong in the first place.

2:32:43I agree with you 100%.

2:32:45Yeah.

2:32:46Right.

2:32:46And it was what level of technical ability are you expecting the people who do

2:32:50have access to the file system to have?

2:32:52Well, so wait, so wait, I agree with you, but I don't think it was wrong

2:32:58so much as a necessity at the time.

2:33:02I mean, the first Mac ships you've got what?

2:33:06What was it?

2:33:07640K?

2:33:08No, more than that.

2:33:10Our note was 128K.

2:33:12128K?

2:33:13Yeah?

2:33:14Okay.

2:33:15So whatever it was, you didn't have the resources in order to abstract a storage system away,

2:33:24right?

2:33:25And I'm sure that was not even on their minds.

2:33:28I can't believe this is what we're arguing about.

2:33:30I don't know if we're arguing.

2:33:31No, not really.

2:33:32But here's another factor, too.

2:33:33So the Technote 2034 said use file extensions.

2:33:38I think it said use it instead of type in crater code.

2:33:42I'm not sure.

2:33:43Yeah, it was.

2:33:44But the problem that it ran into is that it broke the way millions of actual Mac users

2:33:50were using their Macs.

2:33:51And Mac users did things.

2:33:53They did.

2:33:54No, it's adorable.

2:33:55Millions?

2:33:56That's how many sell in a quarter these days.

2:33:58Oh, I know.

2:33:59It's a very small number.

2:34:00I mean it was for a long, long time,

2:34:03the estimated user base of active Mac users hovered

2:34:07and that's dangerous when it hovers instead of grows

2:34:10at about 20 million.

2:34:11- Yeah, I'm gonna guess that you do that

2:34:14in a quarter or two these days.

2:34:16- Yeah, well, yeah, it's like four to five million a quarter

2:34:20I think they sell.

2:34:21- So okay, so maybe a year you'll, anyway.

2:34:24- Who knows how many are really customers though.

2:34:27But the idea, but--

2:34:28The hand wringing over that person.

2:34:30And whatever.

2:34:32I'll let you finish.

2:34:33People, as a graphic designer, as an artist, you assume that you could have files with the same extension that would open when you double click them would open in different apps.

2:34:42You know, that the ones you created in Photoshop would open in Photoshop and the ones you created in, I don't know, Debabilizer would open in Debabilizer.

2:34:50I think that's a great feature.

2:34:51I think it's a mis feature when you send that file over the network and somebody tries to click it and

2:34:57Right. I totally agree.

2:34:59You don't have that app. I'm like, I don't care. I want to open my app, right?

2:35:04Yeah, I totally agree with that. It did make some problems like that. But it was just, again, it's trade-offs.

2:35:11Is it better for me? Is it better for me to be able to have all my files open right in the app I made them with?

2:35:16Or is it better for you when I give them to you that they have the right code?

2:35:19Right. I feel like we could hit a middle, Grant, where it's like if you strip off the created code during transmit.

2:35:24panic plug transmission, like copying it to another computer, it would be fine.

2:35:31And you'd get a new one based on your preferences when it came out.

2:35:34Yeah, it would be the default. There would be no created code, whatever the default is.

2:35:37But the main point, to zoom back out, the main point though is that none of these people, none of the graphic design workflows

2:35:41should not have been built around direct access to the computer file system.

2:35:44There should have been something a little bit more abstracted.

2:35:47And the way iOS has gone is ideal, and it makes everybody happy.

2:35:51I think so. I agree. I mean, it's literally a fresh reboot, right? And, you know, there's been

2:35:58missteps. Yeah, but well, and it's taken a while to get there. Like, and that's, you know, the

2:36:02whole iOS document picking thing, which is what everybody brings up is up. Now we're back with

2:36:06a file system. It's not the file system. It's a file system. Like, what did you call it? Projection,

2:36:11projection. And I actually, I don't pat myself on the back that often. But I really think that

2:36:19the projection is the right way to think about this kind of stuff like that. iCloud Drive

2:36:24on Yosemite does it. I think that this is not, we are not looking at the file system.

2:36:31We are looking at a projection of data just as if you pulled up the photo picker. You

2:36:39don't think about the files, you think about the photos you've got. And I think that this

2:36:44is the better way forward.

2:36:46Right. And it's not confusing. It might be limiting. It still is limiting. And until the document picker, it was definitely limiting.

2:36:54Because to open the same image on iOS that was in your camera roll, to open it in Afterlight or VSCO cam, you would make a copy of it and import it into their thing.

2:37:05And then they would open it. And then if you wanted to save it back out, you'd have to save a new copy back to the photo roll.

2:37:10You've got three copies now, your original, the one in VSCO cam, and the one that was

2:37:15the filtered version saved back to your camera roll.

2:37:18Obviously inefficient, but it didn't, you know, it was inefficient, but it didn't, you

2:37:23know, at least protected people from blowing their photos apart.

2:37:28And the new way, you know, is better.

2:37:30It's way cooler that you can just open it right up in VSCO cam and it saves right back

2:37:34to the same camera roll.

2:37:36know it's great but it was it that's what that's the ultimate goal all along

2:37:45the whole you know idea that users are not going to have direct access to the

2:37:49file system because so many things could go bad and to me the most telltale sign

2:37:53that it was that the file name extensions were a bad idea in the Mac

2:37:56was that they immediately defaulted to hiding them yeah and that in 10.0 I mean

2:38:03And it came pretty quick, right?

2:38:04I think it was in 10.0 where the file name extensions were hidden.

2:38:08And it made people so confused because on the old Mac, in classic Mac OS, if you had

2:38:13a file named portrait.jpg, it didn't have to have the .jpg.

2:38:20So you could just have – you didn't need the file extension.

2:38:22It could be a JPEG, but it would just be named portrait.

2:38:25And if you had another file and you wanted to convert it to a different format like ping

2:38:29or something like that, you couldn't give it the same name.

2:38:32You couldn't have two files named portrait in the same folder because it's a file system

2:38:35that couldn't do it.

2:38:36Whereas all of a sudden in Mac OS X, you could have portrait.jpg and portrait.png in the

2:38:41same folder and they both said portrait and they both look like the same image.

2:38:45And because the file extension is hidden, you can't tell which is yes.

2:38:48Right.

2:38:49So, you know, you're just talking yourself in circles when you start saying that we can

2:38:53do it and then to avoid the confusion we'll hide it and hiding things is never the right

2:38:58idea.

2:38:59So I agree with you and I did at the time I just think it's a pragmatic solution, right?

2:39:05But you know the truth is I the reason I'll say that it was we're all we're but just wrong fighting over

2:39:11Which ways to be wrong because Mac users?

2:39:13Foot Mac users shot themselves in the foot with the file system - they just did it in different ways than

2:39:18Unix and Windows I I just I I

2:39:21Feel that there is as yet an unsolved problem here

2:39:27But I don't think exposing file systems is the way to go basically.

2:39:33Yeah.

2:39:34No. It's a developer. The file system is a developer level.

2:39:37Yeah.

2:39:37Anything else? We should wrap up.

2:39:40I'm kind of bored of you.

2:39:42Yeah, me too. Good thing we're running into each other in three days.

2:39:45I know. Yeah. It's gonna be a good weekend.

2:39:48Well, at least we got all the nerd talk out of the way.

2:39:52Yeah, exactly.

2:39:53Let me, let's give a big pitch to the podcast because you're doing amazing, amazing work

2:40:01that you've dropped a couple references to it, but you've got a series, and this is on

2:40:05debug.

2:40:06Debug, yeah.

2:40:08Where you've got Nitin-

2:40:09Nitin Ganatra.

2:40:11Nitin Ganatra.

2:40:14Don Melton.

2:40:15Don Melton.

2:40:16Now, Don Melton, you guys might know, he left Apple recently.

2:40:18was the head of the WebKit and Safari and adds a super colorful history in the industry

2:40:26and one of the best storytellers I've ever heard. And these are epic, epic podcasts that

2:40:33you guys have recorded with them. Part one was two hours and you just did a part two

2:40:37yesterday?

2:40:38Yeah, so I mean we sat down with Neaton in June and I was, as every podcast I'm like,

2:40:48"Man, am I going to get an hour out of this interview?" I don't know if you do, like,

2:40:53do you ever do a cold interview where you're like, "Hey, I hope I get an hour out of this."

2:40:57And then it's, forget it, it ran. And so we had like three episodes with Neaton totaling

2:41:04over six hours, which is horrible. And then we put Don Melton and Neaton together in Gannatra

2:41:12together and we had another two hour episode and we just recorded another two hours yesterday.

2:41:19Right. And Neaton's a guy who's, you know, again, you don't want to make assumptions

2:41:24about how things work inside Apple. But like you said, he was at one point he was the head

2:41:27of iOS apps, right? What the...

2:41:29He literally came up from working on all kinds of old school Apple stuff.

2:41:35Right.

2:41:36Through doing carbon.

2:41:37Through the carbon file manager.

2:41:39Like seriously low level carbon stuff.

2:41:41Like the carbon file manager.

2:41:43He's brilliant.

2:41:45We may cut this out of the show, but they've both been at the same top 100 meeting at Apple.

2:41:54Right.

2:41:55Right.

2:41:56you know if you want to hear some more people speak about Apple a little bit

2:42:01more freely than you're used to because they're not at Apple anymore they're not

2:42:04allowed out there and you know Renee and especially Renee but myself too we we

2:42:11afford them a place where they can just speak freely and we'll cut anything in

2:42:17retrospect they they made right now one have said so that's it the the debug

2:42:22So, Debug Podcast is www.

2:42:24Yeah, iMore.com/debug.

2:42:25Yeah, iMore.com/debug.

2:42:26And that's like the only project that I'm willing to really plug because it's got very

2:42:33little to do with me and has like the guests are amazing.

2:42:37Okay.

2:42:38I was going to give you Vector too, but if you just want to do it.

2:42:41Yeah, if you want to do Vector, okay.

2:42:43That's for you.

2:42:44I'll keep quiet with that.

2:42:46Whiskus is on that too.

2:42:47Oh, is he?

2:42:48What's the one that Whiskus is on?

2:42:50What's the one that Jesse Char was recently on?

2:42:53Vector.

2:42:54Oh.

2:42:55Did you like that one?

2:42:56I like that one.

2:42:57Yeah, but was Whiskus on that one?

2:42:59No, he stepped out and Jesse stepped in.

2:43:01We just did.

2:43:02Maybe that's why I like that one.

2:43:04Maybe that's why you like that one.

2:43:05Guess what?

2:43:06You're going to like the next one.

2:43:07Whiskus is also away.

2:43:09Hey, Dave, please edit this kindly.

2:43:12I know you're listening.

2:43:14Love you, buddy.

2:43:15The worst part is he cut in.

2:43:17He's got the final word.

2:43:18I know.

2:43:19just jump in here

2:43:22and that's also I'm more calm slash vector I mean this week is Christina

2:43:29Warren who guess what kind of smart yeah very smart at she's imaginable I believe

2:43:36right probably best known to readers from her bylines at mashable yeah yeah

2:43:42where I just saw her recently where did I see her the event I guess yeah that's

2:43:48are somewhere else but anyway yeah very very smart I believe you know sure yeah

2:43:54she'll be it she'll be here this weekend yeah there you go well two great

2:44:00podcasts that you host regularly and have both of them have been on fire

2:44:03recently so anybody looking for more podcasts of girl on these lines boy I

2:44:09can't recommend those enough and the debug ones are classic seriously I mean

2:44:13I think that I don't mean to butter your toast here guy but honestly I think

2:44:17I think that they're up there with some of the Andy Hertzfeld stuff in terms of, you

2:44:22know, get those transcribed because 15, 20 years from now that's good stuff that's largely

2:44:28been undocumented.

2:44:30We transcribed all of them and we may be putting a collection at some point.

2:44:36Right, because these stories are largely untold and some of them are told but only like privately,

2:44:43but you know.

2:44:44And again, it's not like they're burning bridges.

2:44:46They're not spilling state secrets.

2:44:48- No, often it's years old stuff,

2:44:50but there's so much context and so much,

2:44:53I think you start to understand the culture a lot more.

2:44:58- Yeah, no, you definitely do.

2:45:00And it's a great place to start.

2:45:02- Thanks.

2:45:03Again, that's not me.

2:45:06We really just set the stage

2:45:08and we have some great people tell some great stories.

2:45:11- Yeah.

2:45:13All right, Guy English, I will see you soon.

2:45:14- Yeah, yeah.

2:45:16this weekend.

2:45:17Bring your wife, I like her better.

2:45:18[