Podcast Search

The Talk Show

59: A Dog Named Maverick

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00You had a rough week this week, huh?

0:00:02Well with the baseball. Yeah, you have the baseball and then you got owned by Kefauzis?

0:00:08It's just one indignity after another. That was stupid. I mean who cares? Who does something like that?

0:00:14Tiny tiny men. Exactly. I mean, I don't care. I'm not superstitious. Superstitions are for red.

0:00:21That just says everything you need to know about Red Sox fans.

0:00:23You know what I mean? Like there was a, you know, when they built the new Yankee Stadium a couple years ago

0:00:28there was some goofball guy in the construction crew who

0:00:31apparently

0:00:34Are supposedly purportedly reputedly?

0:00:37Put a Red Sox jersey into like a vat of concrete that they you know

0:00:43Poured a column or something like that and then they ended up like ripping it out or something

0:00:47I don't even know if it was there who does stuff like that

0:00:49Well, you know that they were cursed for what is it 86 years or whatever it was no they did weren't cursed they just stunk

0:00:57That's it. It was it's superstitious Red Sox fans who thought it was a curse whereas Yankee fans just said, you know, they stink

0:01:05Yeah

0:01:07Honda good team this year though good team my elderly relatives who are Yankees fan used to call the Yankees

0:01:15What the uncle bums always the bums those bums?

0:01:18Always wait, but they were Yankee fans. Yeah called the Yankees the bums, huh? I

0:01:24Thought that was I thought that was also what they used to call the the Brooklyn Dodgers

0:01:29Yeah, I think that's what every every person who grew up, you know in New York 50 70 years ago. They're all bums

0:01:36Big week for you last week. Yeah, do you got the review out, right? Yeah, that's why I'm doing all these podcasts

0:01:48Yeah, I'm in demand for a week and a half a year

0:01:51our little you know the media I

0:01:54Don't want to call it the in the ecosphere. What do you want to call it?

0:01:58But they you know the way that there's a bunch of cabal maybe well, but it's more than that though

0:02:03there's also people who aren't

0:02:05cabal implies that we're

0:02:07Implies that there's a plan and there's not yeah exactly

0:02:11It's just you know that there are now shows and there's more websites and stuff like that

0:02:16But a lot of people have shows and now you can we can we as you know

0:02:21indie nerd whatever we are is

0:02:23But when we have something big and new come out like a new app

0:02:26Like when I had Vesper come out last year or you when you you know, you've got the the big

0:02:32Really? It's we call them reviews, but they're almost like

0:02:35Short concise books if you think of them as short concise books, they don't seem so long

0:02:39But now we can do what like

0:02:43Actors do when a movie comes out is you go on a bunch of shows and you let people know

0:02:48Yeah, I'm hoping that like what I try to do is I don't have to do that

0:02:53So I don't have to go on all the shows that I don't want to go on

0:02:55I just go on the shows that I do want to go on and that narrows down

0:02:57Considerably like because I don't feel compelled to just you know

0:03:00Tons and tons of offers like you know, hey come on here coming in

0:03:03There's always you know offers here and there but as soon as this comes out

0:03:06everybody wants to PC on I have the luxury unlike the people who have to go and promote a movie to right to pick and

0:03:11Choose only right so but like so you're not gonna go on guy English's stupid show. No, I already blew him off

0:03:16No, I will go on his show. It's just like I couldn't I like literally couldn't fit in the schedule

0:03:20You know what time do I have for podcasting?

0:03:22I have like after the kids are in bed and even then usually only on weekdays and just you know

0:03:27When I'm booked up on booked up is only you know, five slots a week and doing five things a night

0:03:31Makes my wife angry. So yeah, I can believe that trying to try to keep that under control

0:03:36Yeah, I don't know. I don't know if my wife would be angry or she'd be happier

0:03:40So how would how's the reaction gone to the to the review? Yeah, it's good

0:03:46I guess

0:03:47Do you think people are starting to take him for granted?

0:03:49I mean like I think you know

0:03:51I think it's been tapering off the past few years in terms of just attention on the Mac at all

0:03:55And so the people who like it still really really like it like that's my that's my core audience of you know

0:04:01The people who do like what I do really really like it, but then for everyone else. It's like yeah, you know there's this thing

0:04:06It's alright

0:04:07I guess like if you look at the the histogram of you know because it's split up into like pages quote unquote pages

0:04:12but not really.

0:04:13If you look at the histogram of who visits the first page,

0:04:16second page, third page, or whatever,

0:04:18it looks like a big U shape.

0:04:19Because tons of people get the first page,

0:04:21and tons of people read the last page,

0:04:23and people who read the middle not so much.

0:04:25So it's always been like that, but now it just-- it does well.

0:04:31A lot of people read it.

0:04:34But I think just the interest in it in general

0:04:37is people aren't as excited.

0:04:38And it was the 10th one, 10th major release.

0:04:40It's like all right. I guess they're still doing that Mac thing. Let's learn about it a little bit, and that's that

0:04:45Do you ever think about doing them for iOS too? No no no I don't I don't I don't want to do them for iOS

0:04:53I don't feel like I mean you could say like oh well

0:04:55I do them for the Mac because I've got all this history you know being a Mac user since 1984 and everything well

0:05:00I've been an iOS user since pretty much day one too, but it just doesn't feel the same to me

0:05:04You know doesn't it's not that's not my thing some kid who was 12 years old in

0:05:102007 should be doing these iOS reviews you know what I mean like for whom

0:05:14iOS is that that seminal technology moment in their life and for me that was the Mac, but it's not

0:05:20iOS is not that for me a little if you you know if you look at my reviews

0:05:24iOS is just like this shadow that looms over the entire thing because it's hard to even talk about the Mac without

0:05:29You know

0:05:31Comparing comparing it to iOS and thinking about how it is a reaction to iOS or how iOS might be a reaction to what it's doing

0:05:39Like, it's impossible to do an OS X review

0:05:41without talking about iOS.

0:05:42So I do, but I wouldn't want to review the OS proper.

0:05:46Yeah, in other words, it's your obsession

0:05:50with Mac OS X that drives it.

0:05:52It's not just that you want to have

0:05:56a big, comprehensive review of something that Apple's done.

0:06:00This is the thing that you really-- your mind just

0:06:03naturally latches onto wanting to know all these details.

0:06:07And I like Macs better, and I like the things

0:06:09you can do with them.

0:06:10And a lot of the technology things I'm talking about,

0:06:12there are probably equivalents in iOS,

0:06:14or they may have started in iOS or whatever.

0:06:18Maybe it's just because I have more background.

0:06:20But it seems like a lot of these things,

0:06:22I can get more technical info about the details of OS X.

0:06:27Even just from Apple, just from going to the WLDC sessions,

0:06:29you're much more likely to see some in-depth end users,

0:06:33and even developers really, don't need

0:06:35to know this information.

0:06:36but they're gonna talk about it in a presentation

0:06:38than you would for iOS.

0:06:39And I guess the people who jailbreak iOS

0:06:41and are in there with debuggers and poking and prodding it

0:06:43could do a similar type of thing,

0:06:44but Apple is not offering up that information

0:06:47as readily as they have historically offered it up

0:06:50for the Mac.

0:06:50And then there's all the dev tools and stuff,

0:06:52which is common to all platforms,

0:06:53and that could be in an iOS review

0:06:55just as easily as an OS X review.

0:06:56But yeah, I like the weird things

0:07:00and nooks and crannies of OS X,

0:07:01and OS X has evolved more.

0:07:03Like it's older, and so if you look back,

0:07:06Even though iOS 7 is this big radical break, if you compare iOS 1 through 6 and then 7,

0:07:12that's just like the first quarter of OS X's history.

0:07:17The way it's changed and how just look and feel, interface, technology is underpinning

0:07:22everything, the time before iOS existed compared to the time after, OS X has been through a

0:07:27lot whereas iOS is still spring chicken.

0:07:30It's maybe not as interesting from a historical perspective quite yet.

0:07:36One thing that stuck out to me, and part of it

0:07:38is the fact that this is the 10th one,

0:07:40and that makes the math a lot easier,

0:07:44is you can divide and just sort of figure, well,

0:07:48over the lifetime of Mac OS--

0:07:51I still call it Mac OS X. I even write it sometimes.

0:07:54Yeah, I know.

0:07:55It's hard.

0:07:55I try to train myself out of it.

0:07:58It's like one of those ways around just curmudgeonly.

0:08:01Because to me, putting the Mac in Mac OS X,

0:08:04It just jumps out at you and there's no confusion.

0:08:07Whereas with iOS and OS 10, it's all about that OS.

0:08:13And to me, it's one of those, then I could get confused.

0:08:16And I might write the wrong one.

0:08:18Or if I'm reading somebody else's,

0:08:19I'll read it the wrong way if I'm reading too fast.

0:08:22Yeah, and everyone read so much into dropping of the Mac.

0:08:24And I still don't quite understand the thinking

0:08:27behind it, other than just the basic, well, it's

0:08:29one fewer word.

0:08:30It's simplification, right?

0:08:32But it's like, oh, they can drop the Mac,

0:08:33Because then you could have OS X on non Mac platforms and fast forward like four years and it's like no, not so much.

0:08:39Yeah, and I was one of those ones and God bless my readers, but it was like one of those ones where it was

0:08:46I mean like 30 or 40 emails over the next day or two from people who all

0:08:51Suggesting the same thing that it meant that that Apple was gonna license

0:08:55Yeah, the OS to you know, probably not everybody but maybe like just for example just Dell

0:09:02and let Dell make...

0:09:04Yeah, I mean like who knows, you know, who knows how these decisions come to pass, but you know,

0:09:08there was that brief moment where they were trying to say OS X was like the common platform

0:09:12beneath iOS and Mac OS X or iPhone OS and Mac OS X. It was like three days when that was the case and

0:09:17then they backpedaled and then later, you know, took off the Mac again. Like,

0:09:21you know, it could be

0:09:24preparing for possibly doing that or running in this OS and something that's not a Mac because it's like a

0:09:29TV thing or like who knows what you know, but they just

0:09:32It seems to have a mind of its own

0:09:35It's like well we're doing this name change and if if the name change was really going to be linked to hey

0:09:40We're licensing it you think it would be announced at the same time

0:09:42It's not like you you change the name first and then announce the licensing later

0:09:46So the name change like has a life of its own and it's one of those things where Apple

0:09:50Apple doesn't explain like remember when you're trying to ask Apple about like, you know

0:09:53What's the deal with like the new iPad when you know and they were just they you know, it was like talking to her

0:09:58I'm not gonna get political. Anyway, it was like talking points.

0:10:01Yeah.

0:10:01They all said the same thing. They're like, you know, we have a speech every time you ask it,

0:10:06we just like to call it the new iPad. Like they were reading from an index card.

0:10:08Right. But it's in a way that it's utterly a

0:10:11nonpartisan. It has nothing to do with left or right, liberal, conservative, Republican, Democrat.

0:10:17All of them are the same. Where when you get one of them in public, especially like on a

0:10:23campaign for an election, you just cannot knock them off the talking points.

0:10:28Even if you have a question that none of the talking points answer, they'll just pick one

0:10:33of them at random and it ends up like a non sequitur.

0:10:36Well, Apple is as disciplined or even more disciplined than political campaigns at the

0:10:42top of their game.

0:10:43Because some political campaigns, good reporters can trip them up or whatever, but the very

0:10:49best, most efficient political machines cannot be tripped up. And they speak with one voice,

0:10:53and they stick to their talking points, and they execute their strategy, and it's like

0:10:57talking to a brick wall. I mean, who cares? Like, the name of a product's not a big deal,

0:11:00but Apple employs that strategy to great effect. So if they don't want to explain why they

0:11:05change names, they're not going to. And in the grand scheme of things, it doesn't really

0:11:09matter, so we're just left to scratch our heads and go, oh, well, that's what it's called

0:11:13now.

0:11:14little background on that and it's not definitive and I can't you know it's

0:11:19it's off the record and again it's not definitive so I could be wrong but

0:11:23somebody was telling me that they had the name iPad air in mind all along or

0:11:32at least you know like this product was on the roadmap for a while and they knew

0:11:35they wanted to call it iPad air but that wanting to call this year's new full

0:11:42size iPad the air when they could make it this size and this weight was why they stopped

0:11:47putting the numbers after the iPad three and four because they felt like if they did two

0:11:54more iPads with numbers it would create it it would make the iPad air when it come out

0:12:00if it wasn't called the five make it seem like it I think they overthink stuff like

0:12:04this that it would you know that once you get to four it would have to be five to be

0:12:09better than the four, but they didn't want to call it that. They wanted to call it the

0:12:12air. So they just stopped, you know, they just had two models, but they didn't. But

0:12:16everybody, I just call them, everybody else, like we call them the iPad 3 and iPad 4.

0:12:20Yeah, and like that, that strategy, whether they thought it was a good idea or not, like

0:12:25all they did was trade a future scenario in which people expect a number that's one bigger

0:12:29than the previous number for a more present scenario. Because people had all this, all

0:12:33the same stuff happened when it was the new iPad. And so all that stuff that happened,

0:12:38what they were trying to avoid. All they did was shift it forward in time, which is fine,

0:12:41like whatever. You know, I think it's reasonable to take the numbers off the thing. But if

0:12:45it was their strategy to like, we don't want that burden on top of the Air. We want that

0:12:49burden now on top of the iPad 3. Well, you got what you wanted.

0:12:52Well, and the flip side of that too is it makes me think that they're going to stick

0:12:57with the numbers for the iPhone. If they thought about that and they didn't want to have these

0:13:02numbers and not, you know, eventually go away for the iPad, then why would they, why are

0:13:06they still, you know, numbering the iPhones. So…

0:13:08**Matt Stauffer** Well, you know, wait for them to drop the number on the iPhone and then, you know,

0:13:12two years later, the iPhone Air that's going to be a thickness of a credit card is going to come out.

0:13:15**Ezra Kleinman** Exactly. That's a good point. That might be.

0:13:18I also think in general that Apple, not that they're not good at naming things,

0:13:25but they're not good at explaining why they name things. I think even to themselves, that they just,

0:13:30you know, even without Steve Jobs there, even as it goes on, it's sort of, you know,

0:13:35They just pick names that feel right and whether there's any

0:13:38Sense to it or not

0:13:41They don't care or names that feel wrong like MacBook. Yeah, Marco's still hung up on that one

0:13:46No, I mean, it's us, you know, you get used to anything you get used to anything

0:13:49But like you just you have to judge a name like when you first see it and say is this name have any awkward?

0:13:55Aspect of it that's weird. And what am I trading that awkwardness for my train that awkwardness for better brand recognition for the word

0:14:01Mac, well, you just took it out of the OS name, so I'm not sure what the grand strategy is there.

0:14:05iPod and iPad relying on this different vowel sound and very similar looking letters to

0:14:12distinguish, it's not the greatest, but it worked out in the end. iPod Touch, people call it the

0:14:19iTouch, it's kind of a mess. In the end, the names don't matter that much, but certainly I would say

0:14:25Naming is not consistent vision of naming is not Apple strong suit, but you know, you have to pick a weakness

0:14:32It's fine where we are recording this on Halloween evening

0:14:35I was out trick-or-treating with the boy and his friends earlier this evening and one of the kids dad's

0:14:43Who knows what I do asked me he says he wants to get a new 13-inch

0:14:48Notebook or laptop or whatever and wanted to know which one you should get the air book or the MacBook Pro

0:14:55Pro. I don't think I've ever heard that one before.

0:14:58Yeah, I mean, if you're not in-- don't follow this stuff.

0:15:01The names all start to sound the same.

0:15:02They all got "I" in the front of them.

0:15:04There's some sort of-- "Air" is like in the mix.

0:15:06And sometimes there's Mac, and there's a pad and pods.

0:15:09And people don't know.

0:15:10People don't care.

0:15:12I think I had a good answer for him.

0:15:14I think that's become a very easy decision to make,

0:15:17just a little bit off the topic here.

0:15:20But to choose which MacBook to buy.

0:15:23I think here's how I think it is

0:15:25I think if you spend a lot of time running off the battery you should get the air and if you spend most of your

0:15:30Time with the AC cord plugged in and you should spend the extra couple hundred bucks and get the pro

0:15:36I think the screen is still a factor in my like it depends if you think people care

0:15:41But I think even regular people know what a bad viewing angle is like they don't they can't articulate it

0:15:46But like, you know, it's it's the case that a lot of people still can't tell you

0:15:51retina, non-retina, but everybody can tell the difference between IPS and TN panels.

0:15:58This screen doesn't quite look as good, because if you're at a slightly off angle, that's

0:16:02the one remaining weakness of the Air, even though I still recommend it.

0:16:05It was so much easier to recommend it when none of the machines were retina.

0:16:09Like there was that honeymoon period where, which laptop Mac should I get?

0:16:13The default answer was 13-inch Air.

0:16:16And then you could just waffle from there.

0:16:18it's like 13 inch air, but have you seen the screen on the 13 inch retina? Even before the revisions,

0:16:23you know, like that's those things look so nice. And if you're gonna be spending all day looking

0:16:27at the actual laptop screen, especially now the 13 inch, you know, non-air is getting so thin,

0:16:34it's it's a harder decision. Yeah, it's pretty comparable to like, I don't know, maybe I'm a

0:16:39little off, but I think it's getting pretty close to the weight of the original 13 inch

0:16:44It's not quite there, but like I said in an ATP couple of weeks ago, if you just imagine

0:16:49the original error, but it didn't taper.

0:16:51It's very similar.

0:16:54Just stuff with extra battery.

0:16:57Like a bazillion times faster and better battery life and everything else so much better about

0:17:02it.

0:17:03Let me take a time out to tell everybody about our first sponsor.

0:17:08I think this might be a record for the soonest I've had the forethought to do a sponsor break.

0:17:13So our good friends at Transporter, aka File Transporter, founded by a bunch of guys who

0:17:22used to work at Drobo.

0:17:23Now they're reunited.

0:17:25The Drobo people have acquired them.

0:17:29It's a Drobo product.

0:17:33What is File Transporter?

0:17:34It's like your own personal Dropbox.

0:17:38It's a piece of hardware.

0:17:39buy it and you plug it in to your home network or your office or you could buy

0:17:45two you could put one in your home one in your office sign them in with the

0:17:47same account and what does it do it works like Dropbox it just syncs the any

0:17:52files you put on it between each one if you have more than one and all the Macs

0:17:57you sign into on the same account what's the advantage of it well it's your

0:18:02device you control it you know where it is and there is no cloud component the

0:18:07The only part that's online that these guys do is the magic to sort of poke holes through

0:18:14your router, your home network, your office network.

0:18:18They don't do any storage though.

0:18:19All they do is connect sort of a peer-to-peer basis just to sort of get you through the

0:18:24– what do you call it?

0:18:28The firewall?

0:18:29Whatever you want to call it, the router.

0:18:31Am I saying this right, John?

0:18:33John: Firewall, you got it.

0:18:35They don't store your stuff on any kind of cloud-based system.

0:18:41And I can't imagine. I say this every time these guys come on as a sponsor.

0:18:44I really can't imagine the...

0:18:48I mean it's a terrible complicated and

0:18:51political situation with the US government and the NSA and the spying and

0:18:56stuff like that that's going on.

0:18:58With leaks coming every single week. I can't even imagine

0:19:02the forethought that went into them launching this product about a year ago

0:19:05and then to have this next year of news break out like this.

0:19:09In terms of trying to convince people why you might want to take

0:19:13control and ownership of your distributed

0:19:17ubiquitous everywhere you go file storage.

0:19:21They have an app for the iPhone so you can

0:19:24use that you can connect to your stuff from wherever you are even on your phone.

0:19:28It's a great product, really is. Works

0:19:32very simply, very quietly.

0:19:34It's just a completely unobtrusive piece of hardware.

0:19:37That is the one thing I always,

0:19:39when I first heard about it months ago,

0:19:41my first thought was, well, do I really want to hook up?

0:19:44I'm lazy, I really am.

0:19:46And the older I get, the lazier I get.

0:19:47Do I really wanna hook up some kind of complicated,

0:19:50you know, piece of storage hardware?

0:19:54This thing is adorably a little cute.

0:19:56I mean, it's, you know, fits in the palm of your hand.

0:19:59Very simple to set up.

0:20:01Quiet and all the good things you could say about it

0:20:04Where do you go to find out more easy you go

0:20:11File transporter comm slash talk ta lk nice short code that way

0:20:20They will know that you came from the show

0:20:23It's cheap

0:20:26You can do things. What's the starting cost for this thing John? You know, cuz you they sponsor your show - isn't like

0:20:32$2.99 I

0:20:35Think have the new one that doesn't have the hard drive into that

0:20:38I think is even cheaper

0:20:39But they do sell an empty one that you can supply your own hard drive for but yeah, it's something like that

0:20:43Here's one you could get one look at this your own unlimited private cloud. Here it is. It's brand new. It's a new device

0:20:49$99, that's the little puck shape one. That's the little puck shaped one. Yeah, I'm get started for $99

0:20:54I should also add, here's another thing, no fees.

0:20:57You don't pay fees, you don't pay any kind of monthly thing.

0:20:59You buy them, it's like Apple.

0:21:02It's like you give them money for hardware

0:21:04and then it just runs for free after that.

0:21:07No monthly fees, you just buy the thing.

0:21:09And really, it's great.

0:21:11If you're a nerd, you wanna buy the one

0:21:12that doesn't come with a hard drive,

0:21:13you put your own hard drive in it.

0:21:15Otherwise, you can get one from them

0:21:16that's all set up, ready to go right out of the box.

0:21:18So check 'em out, filetransporter.com/talk.

0:21:23Yeah, this new puck-shaped one looks adorable.

0:21:27Reminds me of the old Griffin thing.

0:21:29Remember that Griffin--

0:21:30It was a big knob that you turned or something?

0:21:32Yeah, it was this hardware thing.

0:21:36You'd plug it in USB.

0:21:38Or was it so old that it was ADB?

0:21:40I think it was USB.

0:21:43And it was just a dial.

0:21:45And there was software where you could

0:21:47make it control your volume.

0:21:50If you wanted instead, you could have it scroll whatever app

0:21:53you were in.

0:21:54It would be nice if you could play Kaboom with it.

0:21:58I'm sure you could.

0:21:59You must have been able to.

0:22:00It seems like it would be criminal not to let you play Kaboom.

0:22:04That was my favorite, one of my favorite games for 2600.

0:22:08It was a very good game.

0:22:10There was a whole, I don't even know what you want to call it.

0:22:13There was a genre of classic video games which was going side to side catching things.

0:22:19Yeah.

0:22:20Like this is it could be just be childhood, you know, Rosie rose colored childhood memory

0:22:25But I would love for someone to hook one of those things up to find like a TV with an RF

0:22:29Interface and everything when I hook it up with period correct hardware and see what is the latency between?

0:22:35when you turn that little analog knob and when you know the image moves on the screen because it just felt like

0:22:41You were directly connected wired up to that little stack of things trying to catch your stuff as they fall

0:22:47Maybe the lag was horrendous and I just don't remember because I was so young but

0:22:50In my memory, that was the most responsive "I move part of my body and an image moves

0:22:56on a screen" interface that I can remember.

0:22:59Atari called it the "paddle," right?

0:23:01That's what they called them, the "that controller."

0:23:06Maybe.

0:23:07That was the only device, well, maybe there's newer ones that come.

0:23:10But that was one of the weird things about Atari is it came with two sets of controllers.

0:23:13You had a set of joysticks and a set of paddles, because it was for two totally different games,

0:23:18types of games. My favorite of the genre was Circus Atari. Do you remember that one?

0:23:24**Matt Stauffer** It does not ring a bell.

0:23:26**Justin Jackson** Ooh, that was a really good one. It was the same type thing. It was you were a

0:23:30clown on a teeter totter and it just went side to side and then you had a partner who would jump on

0:23:37a trampoline to start and you had to catch him and you had to catch him on the upside of the

0:23:43teeter totter and then he would shoot you up in the air and then you'd be the, you know,

0:23:47You'd just go side to side and there were balloons to pop.

0:23:51It was Breakout, really.

0:23:54But instead of, you know, I don't know what the premise in Breakout was, you were clowns

0:23:58popping balloons.

0:23:59AG Yeah, my one friend with the 2600 must not have had that game because I never had

0:24:04one.

0:24:05DAVE It was good and it didn't look good.

0:24:06It sounded so stupid because it didn't have any spaceships, didn't have any guns.

0:24:10I mean, you were, you know, the box showed you that you were a clown.

0:24:15So it was one of those ones where we got it like when we got our family 2600 for Christmas,

0:24:19but my sister and I never played it.

0:24:21And then one day I was home sick, like I had the flu or something, missed school.

0:24:26And I was sick of all...

0:24:27I was sick, I was like ill, but I was also tired, bored of all the games I had.

0:24:34And then I realized there was this circus Atari game that I'd never really played.

0:24:37And I put it in and I had like seven continuous hours, just played it nonstop.

0:24:43it up. It's a good one. But it would be – it was absolutely dependent upon the paddle.

0:24:49It wouldn't make any sense with the joystick.

0:24:52Yeah.

0:24:53I think the latency was pretty good on those things. I seem to recall that you could get

0:24:58– it was really – you could get very precise. I don't think – because I don't think

0:25:01there was much – again, it could just be the haze of 20, 30 – I guess 30 years, jeez,

0:25:10memories. But it seems, you know, it was very simple, you know, there really wasn't much

0:25:16going on. There wasn't much processing going on. I mean, it was just electrical impulses

0:25:20from the paddle into the thing and then just shooting them up on the TV.

0:25:24AG: There's a great book on this that I have not read but I keep meaning to called "Racing

0:25:28the Beam."

0:25:29AG Yeah. I think I got a copy of that book, like a courtesy copy, as the writer of "Daring

0:25:36And it's like I never read it, but it's somewhere on my list of books

0:25:40I actually want to read. Yeah, and I think the title is a reference to the practice of trying to do computations

0:25:46You know the electron beam is scanning left to right left to right doing a rows at a time of the television in your CRT

0:25:52And it was you know there wasn't enough memory to do anything for an entire screen image

0:25:55So what you would do is do some calculations and the beam would start to draw them

0:25:58And then you would ditch what you did and start doing new

0:26:01Calculations before the beam got to the row that you were figuring out what it was going to look like right?

0:26:05I think that's what it's a reference to.

0:26:07Again, not having read the book, I'm surmising based on.

0:26:10But that's what makes me think it must have been pretty darn

0:26:13responsive, is that you just had so little to work with

0:26:15and so little to do that how could you take time

0:26:17to do anything?

0:26:18Because everything just had to respond immediately.

0:26:24There was no big, long, hard thinking

0:26:26about what you were going to do.

0:26:28You didn't have time.

0:26:28You just had to figure out what the dots were going to be

0:26:30and throw them up on the screen and react to input immediately.

0:26:34one of my friends from college... I don't think he listens... I don't know if he listens to this show, but if he's out there...

0:26:38hello Andrew Ross, a good friend from college, but I know he reads the site.

0:26:42And he

0:26:46corrected me a couple weeks ago. Somehow Pac-Man came up on Daring Fireball

0:26:51and I called the bad guys "ghosts."

0:26:54But they weren't ghosts, they were monsters. That was the...

0:26:58you know, what were the bad guys in Pac-Man according to the official game?

0:27:02They were

0:27:03monsters but Atari called them ghosts for the pac-man version or the Atari

0:27:08version of pac-man because they couldn't figure out a way to animate all for them

0:27:15at the same time and so they they would draw each of them only 1/4 at the time

0:27:20and so they looked flickery and transparent because they were only

0:27:23drawing one at a time of the four ghosts or the four monsters so they just they

0:27:28just instead of calling it a bug they just said rename them ghosts and called

0:27:32it a feature.

0:27:33Well, they do look kind of like ghosts.

0:27:35They do look kind of like something

0:27:36with a sheet over its head with two eye holes cut

0:27:39and a ragged bottom to the sheet.

0:27:42So it fit quite well.

0:27:43But the monstrous thing, it just sounds

0:27:45like a bad translation of whatever the word is

0:27:49in Japan for these things.

0:27:50And like, well, that roughly means monster, whatever.

0:27:52It's a video game.

0:27:53Who cares?

0:27:54It probably came out because of your-- what do you call it?

0:27:57Talk?

0:27:57Didn't you do that at Webstock?

0:27:59No, you know what?

0:28:00I think, well, maybe it was.

0:28:02Maybe it was.

0:28:03Maybe it was my web-- maybe that's what it was.

0:28:05Because I don't even think I linked to that talk

0:28:07down there on Fireball, though.

0:28:08But maybe he just saw it because somebody else--

0:28:10Yeah, I don't know how I saw it, but I came up on a Twitter feed

0:28:13or whatever.

0:28:13Maybe just the web stock account and someone retweeted it

0:28:15or whatever.

0:28:16Yeah.

0:28:16And I do think, though, that you're right, though,

0:28:18and the reason that I remember them as ghosts is because they

0:28:20do.

0:28:21They have that classic sheet over a head look.

0:28:26Like from a Charlie Brown special.

0:28:27Yeah.

0:28:29I didn't see any kids dressed like that today.

0:28:31You don't see that.

0:28:32Me neither.

0:28:33You see any good costumes on the kids?

0:28:36Eh, that's all right.

0:28:38I mean, we don't get a lot of kids here.

0:28:39We get like maybe three quarters of a bowl of candy's worth of kids.

0:28:44It's mostly like younger kids with parents.

0:28:47Some of them are cute, but nothing super impressive.

0:28:50Also this year, not a lot of the kids who are not really dressed up like the kids who

0:28:54are a little bit too old to be trick or treating and didn't even put in the effort to put on

0:28:57of thing, but just want free candy.

0:29:01When we do trick or treating, usually my wife goes out

0:29:03with the kids, and I am the person who mans the house,

0:29:06so we can hand out candy and be a good neighbor or whatever.

0:29:11And let me tell you, you can learn not everything

0:29:14you need to know, but you can learn a hell of a lot

0:29:16in about three seconds about every kid that

0:29:18comes to your door based on how they deal with the candy

0:29:21situation.

0:29:22Because some people, when you come to their door,

0:29:25they let you know immediately how it's going to be.

0:29:27I just simply extend the bowl and do not offer any advice about how many candies you should

0:29:33take or anything like that.

0:29:35Some kids ask, "How many can we take?"

0:29:37Some kids don't ask and just take one.

0:29:39Some kids don't ask and take two hands full.

0:29:43Some kids try to take one and say, "Thank you," but then rotate around their friend

0:29:46and come on the other side and take another one and say, "Thank you."

0:29:49And you could just like, "I should be taking these kids' names down."

0:29:52"Uh-huh.

0:29:53All right.

0:29:54I got your number.

0:29:55Yep.

0:29:56Okay.

0:29:57It is a 30-second personality test for young children, how they deal with that bowl of

0:30:03candy.

0:30:04John: Jonas would certainly be a take one.

0:30:08He's very…

0:30:09John: Without asking?

0:30:10Like, how many do we have?

0:30:12John; If you extended it, the bowl, then he would reach in and very selectively pick whatever,

0:30:19take a look and pick one thing that he thought looked best.

0:30:22John; The people asking, like…

0:30:24It's also about the way they ask.

0:30:25Some people are asking is they just want to make sure they're not doing anything bad,

0:30:29but they're also asking because they're hoping the answer is not one.

0:30:32And I give different answers to different kids, because I'm running an experiment here.

0:30:36Depending on how the kids look or whatever, sometimes they say one, sometimes they say

0:30:40two.

0:30:41Really, towards the end of the night, I want the bowl to be depleted so I don't have leftover

0:30:44candy, so I give higher numbers.

0:30:45But then occasionally, the kids will come and I'll see a couple of greedy people in

0:30:48there and one of their friends will ask and I'll say, "One, actually."

0:30:51You know, like not like, I'm just like, one,

0:30:54I'm trying not to interfere with the experiment,

0:30:55but fascinating, I should film it.

0:30:59- You should tell them, take what you feel you deserve.

0:31:01- No, that's let your conscience be your guide

0:31:03is what I almost say to these kids,

0:31:05but I feel like they'll, you know,

0:31:06I don't wanna be the weird house.

0:31:08- Take what you've earned.

0:31:12- Right.

0:31:13- What kind of candy do you give out?

0:31:15- My wife buys it, it's just, you know,

0:31:17little miniatures, you know, I responded to Marco

0:31:21and Tiff's tweet about their candy and which candy do you think would go first. And I read

0:31:26it late so I didn't get the answer, but I knew what the answer would be.

0:31:28I didn't see it. What were the options? I didn't see the tweet.

0:31:30It was like Whoppers, Dots, like little Jolly Rancher looking things, and Butterfingers,

0:31:39I think. And maybe they weren't Jolly Ranchers. They might have been gum. But the kids, I've

0:31:44learned this from doing Halloween, they love the crappiest candy, whatever it is, just like sugar,

0:31:50Just like nerds or you know like dots for the first one to go there just terrible

0:31:54You know completely sugar-candy my memory from childhood is that you always go for the chocolate first even when we were little so you

0:32:01crazy

0:32:01Snickers bar versus anything else like you're not gonna who wants a jolly ranch or who wants a piece of gum who wants nerds who?

0:32:07Wants dots everyone wanted chocolate but kids these days they want Sour Patch kids they want dots

0:32:13They want skittles like and we and what we get is you know Snickers bars Milky Way bars Three Musketeers

0:32:19Butter fingers and also, you know Skittles and some other type of candy and the terrible crap sugar candy always goes first

0:32:26And it boggles my mind. Yeah, I think I've told this story before I think back on the old show with

0:32:32Dan but the the gold standard

0:32:35For me and on my neighborhood growing up as a kid was always

0:32:40Full size pack of

0:32:43Reese's peanut butter cups. They hold two packs, right? You'd get two whole peanut butter cups or

0:32:50some other similar full-size milk chocolate covered candy bar. A full Snickers or a full

0:32:57Hershey bar. A lot of people are doing that. Like, it's a trend. I mean, and Andy Inako just posted

0:33:04that that's what he was doing. But like the full-size ones, that would start to get spendy

0:33:07with the amount of kids that we get. And honestly, but I don't think their parents would probably

0:33:12give us the stink eye of giving like this two-year-old kid a Snickers bar the size of his

0:33:16forearm. It's not, you know, I know what it's like to have kids. At least with the small ones, you can

0:33:21say, "Okay, you can have one candy," and they eat one and they're not wired all night. You eat one of

0:33:25those Snickers bars. That's too much. I remember there was this Dnavich family in my neighborhood

0:33:30growing up, and Mrs. Dnavich was always really into Halloween. She was just one of those moms who

0:33:35just loved it. They had a pretty cool house, and it had like a second floor porch. I don't know what

0:33:41what you call it, like a balcony/porch on the second floor.

0:33:44And they always, every year, they hung up like a witch.

0:33:47Like, she probably-- it was one of those tricks of perspective

0:33:51where I'm sure in real life she wasn't actually

0:33:54a five-foot tall mannequin.

0:33:57She's probably more like four feet tall or something.

0:33:59But from the street, it looked like a full-sized witch

0:34:01on a broom hanging up there and some kind of lighting

0:34:06to light her up and it looked great.

0:34:08She always gave out full-size candy bars.

0:34:10Because she knew me, because I was around the corner,

0:34:16she would let me take two.

0:34:17And CNN, I would be like, really?

0:34:19I would think, is this a trick?

0:34:21I'm going to get in trouble when I accept the second one, right?

0:34:25This can't be true.

0:34:26Second one's filled with razor blades, though.

0:34:28[LAUGHTER]

0:34:32Is that still a thing?

0:34:33Does that ever--

0:34:33I don't think kids know about that these days.

0:34:35These days, when the kids come, we

0:34:37have a separate bowl for peanut free.

0:34:38That's the level things are in our neighborhood.

0:34:42And the kids come and they ask for it.

0:34:43They say, do you have any peanut free?

0:34:45And I say, actually, I do.

0:34:46Here you go.

0:34:48Ready for it.

0:34:49Yeah, the razor blade thing.

0:34:51That's got to be one of those things that never actually

0:34:53happened.

0:34:54No, I don't think it ever did.

0:34:55But just the thought of it was just-- it was enough.

0:34:59You just turn it over in your mind as a little kid.

0:35:01It's like, I love candy.

0:35:02I love Halloween.

0:35:03But biting into a piece of candy and finding a straight razor

0:35:06cutting into the roof of my mouth would not be good.

0:35:09It didn't stop you.

0:35:10You'd still get the candy and you'd delete it.

0:35:11And I remember the other one too was--

0:35:15I don't know if it was because somebody figured it out

0:35:18that, hey, it doesn't even make that-- it would actually

0:35:19be kind of hard to put a razor blade in a candy bar

0:35:22and then seal it back up.

0:35:24The other one was that there were rumors that some people

0:35:27put straight pins in them.

0:35:29Yeah, it's easier to sneak in there.

0:35:32The thing was they'd give you an apple,

0:35:33and the apple would have the tiny, thin, straight razor in it.

0:35:36And that, you could sneak in there.

0:35:37And that's just like, you know how you bite into an apple.

0:35:39You don't want a razor blade being involved there.

0:35:41But yeah, that's all just things to scare kids as far as--

0:35:44I've never read an actual documented case of it

0:35:46really happening, which is pretty amazing considering

0:35:48how prevalent that myth was and how much copycat people do

0:35:52crazy things like that.

0:35:53Exactly.

0:35:54Nobody would ever think to do it until it

0:35:56became a prevalent meme.

0:35:59And then all sorts of weirdos would think, well,

0:36:01maybe I should do that.

0:36:02I guess maybe weirdos have trouble attracting children to their houses on Halloween.

0:36:06Because there really are things.

0:36:08I don't really think it was ever a thing where that was an actual problem, but I know that

0:36:12there were things where you can take your Halloween candy to the emergency room and

0:36:16get them X-rayed.

0:36:17I mean, that's like an actual thing in some places.

0:36:20And it's like, imagine if you actually suffered some kind of accident or injury on Halloween

0:36:26and you're waiting—you always wait too long in the emergency room.

0:36:30And then you gotta sit there and wait for kids to get their damn Snickers X-rayed?

0:36:34I got their candy irradiated.

0:36:36Right.

0:36:37Yeah, they do stuff like that that just makes parents feel better.

0:36:41Yeah.

0:36:42I guess they could offer that as a service at the airport, too.

0:36:44Like, take one of the TSA lines and let kids walk through with their candy and see if it

0:36:48sets it off.

0:36:49No, then you'll just see the candy, like, naked without the wrapper, but you won't actually

0:36:52see what's inside it.

0:36:56see all the gummy bears genitalia.

0:37:05Smooth as Ken doll.

0:37:07Mavericks.

0:37:08Have you gotten used to the name?

0:37:13Yeah, I'm fine with it.

0:37:15I mean, in the grand scheme of things, it's weird and awkward, but it's fine.

0:37:21It's not like MacBook.

0:37:22It's not like Wii.

0:37:23It's not embarrassing.

0:37:24It's just eccentric, which is fine.

0:37:27Right. And apparently it did start. I read that the story behind the name of the location was that,

0:37:34you know, at some point in the 60s, I guess it didn't even have a name until then when, you know,

0:37:38like surfing culture got to be big. And then a bunch of, you know, hippie surfers in the 60s

0:37:44found this great beach. And one of them had a dog named Maverick. And that somehow that's,

0:37:49and who knows if it's apocryphal or not, but that it came from that the beach was Maverick's,

0:37:54because that's where the dog Maverick hung out while his owner surfed.

0:37:58So you were joining a long, distinguished line of people who have been telling me the origin of the

0:38:04name by reciting to me or summarizing to me the very thing that I linked in the paragraph where

0:38:11I discussed the name. And I know everyone doesn't follow every link, but it's like,

0:38:14I linked that in the review. I read it on the iPad. There's too many links.

0:38:17Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I will stay to be here. But the point is, yeah, lots of people are like,

0:38:20you may not know this, but Mavericks is actually blah, blah, blah. So, you know, a lot of people

0:38:24were just simply reciting or copying and pasting the actual page I link, which is like the Wikipedia

0:38:29page about the thing. And the second strain of corrections to this is people saying,

0:38:33"It's not actually plural. You see, it's possessive because..." And again, this is mentioned in the

0:38:36Wikipedia. It's not, you know, it's possessive, blah, blah, blah. One person had the presence

0:38:40of mind to link to the other thing, which was my second go-to that I was going to link to this,

0:38:44but I didn't want to have too many links. See? I just linked to the Wikipedia page. Page explaining

0:38:49that when they do place names and they're possessive, they tend to drop the apostrophes.

0:38:52Like, that has historical precedent, you know, Saint Mary's or whatever. It's, you know,

0:38:56S-T period Mary's, but without the apostrophe S. So yeah, no, I totally understand where the name

0:39:02comes from. I understand what it is. But, you know, if you don't know the backstory and you see

0:39:07"Mavericks," it reads as plural. And most people don't know or care or understand the backstory,

0:39:12and that's why it's awkwardly plural. Is it really plural? Is it, you know, it's either awkwardly

0:39:15plural or awkwardly possessive, but you know, whatever you decide. But there's a certain

0:39:19awkwardness to it. But, you know, maverick is a word that people know and like, and it's

0:39:23distinctive, and hey, it's not a cat, right? So, you know, we're off in a new direction,

0:39:27and there are plenty of places in California to go to next.

0:39:30Does McDonald's still have the apostrophe? I'm looking it up.

0:39:34Friendly's dropped it. Remember that?

0:39:37Yeah.

0:39:37Or, for now, Friendly's dropped—it used to be just "friendly," like, singular.

0:39:40Yeah, or was that—did they switch to—

0:39:44They added the apostrophe S because everybody called it "Friendlies."

0:39:48And so it used to be singular, "Friendly."

0:39:50And for the longest time, we had one near where

0:39:53I grew up that had a sign, like a big fancy sign on a brick building that

0:39:56didn't have the apostrophe S on it.

0:39:58And I would tell people, you know the place is actually named Friendly, right?

0:40:01And they'd be like, no.

0:40:01I'm like, come look at the sign.

0:40:02And they would swear that sign says Friendly until you get up there

0:40:05and look at it, see?

0:40:05No apostrophe S. And then it's like, oh, it must have fallen off.

0:40:08Nope.

0:40:08Didn't fall off.

0:40:09But they gave in.

0:40:10We had two in my vague hometown area growing up.

0:40:15And one of them was a Friendly's and one was a Friendly.

0:40:18And I noticed stuff like that.

0:40:21And I always wondered-- and this is before you could look stuff up on the internet.

0:40:24I always wondered whether perhaps they were two rival brands.

0:40:28[LAUGHTER]

0:40:28Yeah, like McDowell's.

0:40:30Right.

0:40:30That some jerk started Friendly after Friendly's started because they didn't

0:40:38register the trademark on the non-possessive or something like that.

0:40:41You can get a sundae and a Yankees cup.

0:40:42Because all I could think was otherwise it doesn't make any sense. Why wouldn't you enforce

0:40:46consistency across all of your franchises?

0:40:48Well, they did slowly. Do you have one of those still or did you remember getting those? It was

0:40:52like the upside-down plastic baseball cap.

0:40:54Yeah.

0:40:55You can get a sundae in it. I still think I have a Yankees version of that somewhere.

0:40:58I don't know if I got one at Friendly or where I got that, but I do remember having a little,

0:41:04Yeah, like a little plastic batting helmet, roughly the size of a scoop of ice cream.

0:41:11It's a pretty good deal considering the crap that you get with like Happy Meals and stuff now.

0:41:15They just gave you that as the thing they served your ice cream in, and you take it home,

0:41:18and you got a nice little--

0:41:19Yeah, something you might actually want to keep.

0:41:21And I'm assuming it was licensed from Major League Baseball and was the real logo on it.

0:41:24Yeah, I'm sure. Had to be. McDonald's still has the apostrophe.

0:41:28Although I wonder, did you have like Phillies hats or something? I didn't really think about it,

0:41:33about doing we had Yankees things I don't know if I don't know how I got the

0:41:37one I had a Yankees one I don't know if there's back in the old days when the

0:41:40only one they just assumed the entire country recognized the Yankees supremacy

0:41:45and just about the whole country gets Yankees hats right I don't know if I

0:41:48don't know how that I don't know or I you know for all I know I don't remember

0:41:51getting it I just remember having and for all I know somebody some relative of

0:41:55mine got it somewhere else and you know let's get one of those for John keep it

0:41:59form. I don't know. But I remember having the little hat.

0:42:04I keep trailing off Mavericks and going off into baseball.

0:42:11Yeah. And friendlies.

0:42:12I really thought this would be the show where there wasn't any baseball. The episode where

0:42:15there's no baseball.

0:42:16Well, hey, how could it not be like this could have been preempted by game seven?

0:42:19Yeah, it could have been. I had a bad feeling about the Cardinals.

0:42:25And watch any of it. I'm not paying attention to it at all, but my Twitter feed is still

0:42:28So I feel like I'm like a contact contact high from baseball talk.

0:42:33I was talking to my dad.

0:42:36My dad's a big baseball fan, and we were talking the other day.

0:42:39And I guess he does not like-- I've said this on the show many times-- he does not like

0:42:42the American League.

0:42:43He doesn't like the designated hitter role.

0:42:45So he just, you know, he watches sports, and he likes baseball, but he doesn't watch a

0:42:49lot of-- it won't just-- like if it's two American League teams playing on TV on ESPN

0:42:53or something, he won't watch.

0:42:56So he was really kind of unaware of the whole beard situation

0:42:59with the Red Sox until--

0:43:00I mean, he'd heard about it.

0:43:02But then he was watching the World Series.

0:43:03And he was like--

0:43:04he said that the Red Sox looked like the type of guys.

0:43:08If you saw a couple of them in the bus station,

0:43:10you'd just walk the other way.

0:43:13Yeah, I knew about the beard thing, but only like,

0:43:15you know, academically, like I understood the concept.

0:43:18And then I'd caught a piece of a game.

0:43:19And I'm like, all right, this is out of control.

0:43:22Someone had a good tweet.

0:43:23I forget who it was.

0:43:24It might have actually been Dan Poger.

0:43:26No, maybe it was a comedian saying, after the series,

0:43:28the Red Sox are going to go back to their normal jobs

0:43:31of driving a carriage for the Amish.

0:43:35Like, they were just some serious beard,

0:43:37like Jebediah caliber beards poking out of these people

0:43:41here.

0:43:43They just look like the type of people who don't bathe.

0:43:47Yeah.

0:43:47They don't.

0:43:48It's not a good look on a lot of them.

0:43:50Being looking a little scruffy is good,

0:43:52But once it goes out into Amish/homeless person,

0:43:57that's just too much.

0:43:59It doesn't look classy.

0:44:02No, it does not.

0:44:03I don't know enough about baseball to know.

0:44:08I see you making the comments about the weird alternate

0:44:10uniforms and stuff like that.

0:44:12But all sports teams go through some awkward phase

0:44:15with their outfits.

0:44:16But if you had to pick a team that aesthetically

0:44:18is the apple of baseball, it would

0:44:19be the Yankees with the pinstripes.

0:44:21It's like it's just classy and simple and straightforward.

0:44:24And even their logo is--

0:44:26it's not like a weird teal-looking thing.

0:44:29Red Sox have a certain class to them.

0:44:31But when you have someone with a big giant beard

0:44:33and the bright saturated red, it starts

0:44:35to look a little bit Ronald McDonald.

0:44:38It did accentuate the un-Yankeyness of the Red Sox.

0:44:45Yankees, in fact, famously have always

0:44:48had a grooming code.

0:44:53In the '70s and maybe even early '80s,

0:44:56when men's fashion was such that the hairstyles were longer,

0:45:01the Yankees would occasionally get dinged by George Steinbrenner

0:45:03like, hey, you got to go get a haircut.

0:45:05So they have a Don Mattingly exception?

0:45:07Mattingly got in trouble for his hair at one point

0:45:11later in his career.

0:45:13And it just became a weird thing.

0:45:16It was just sort of like an 80s mullet type look.

0:45:18And it wasn't really long hair.

0:45:19But I don't know.

0:45:20It was like Steinbrenner got a bee in his bonnet over it.

0:45:25But Mattingly was already like the team captain

0:45:28and a perennial all-star.

0:45:29And I just remember as a kid thinking,

0:45:31boy, what a silly thing for the Yankees

0:45:34to be worried about because they stunk at the time.

0:45:37And also the facial hair.

0:45:39It's like working at Disney or something like that

0:45:42when you're on the Yankees.

0:45:43You can't have--

0:45:44I can't scare the kids.

0:45:45Matt only had the big handlebar, right?

0:45:47Right.

0:45:47You could have a mustache.

0:45:48Couldn't have a beard, though.

0:45:49I think the most you can get away with is--

0:45:53I know that there's some pitchers, a lot of pitchers,

0:45:56who don't like to shave before they pitch.

0:45:58So you can go like three or four days without shaving.

0:46:01You don't have to shave every day, but you can't grow a beard.

0:46:05I guess catchers can be Quasimodo.

0:46:07Doesn't matter what they look like.

0:46:08Yeah, nobody ever sees their face.

0:46:11Nobody ever sees their face.

0:46:12No one ever sees their face or their prehensile tails.

0:46:15Yeah.

0:46:17Are you sad to see the big cat names go?

0:46:20No, because I think they were out.

0:46:21Like, I would have liked to see a lynx in there somewhere.

0:46:23I think that's the only one that they left on the floor.

0:46:26Because I think that's kind of a cool name.

0:46:28It's got an X in it.

0:46:29It's interesting.

0:46:30But that would have to be kind of like a middle name.

0:46:31And once you go lion, where can you go?

0:46:33I mean, even mountain lion's a cop out.

0:46:34Like, yeah, I guess it's like lion, but different.

0:46:37But mountain lion is-- you know, mountain lion

0:46:39is nothing compared to lion.

0:46:40It's not lightning bug and lightning, but it's close.

0:46:42Yeah, and snow leopard was sort of it worked on two levels where it got them an extra year without coming up with a new cat

0:46:50And it really did fit that that release in terms of it famously being the look

0:46:56Quote-unquote no new features release and snow leopards look cool. Yeah, like I mean a lot of it, you know

0:47:02You get a pic cool links is probably don't look that cool, but the name is cool

0:47:06So that's probably the only one they do and it's kind of a shame

0:47:09They never got to like when they did cheetah and puma they were not into the putting the cat branding out in your face

0:47:14Yeah

0:47:15Like yeah

0:47:16There was just behind the scenes and then they burned those two names and like and cheetah is great as like the ultimate inside joke

0:47:21But the people who are putting out that oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. What are we gonna start with? Yeah, we're gonna call us when cheetah

0:47:25I know I even want yeah, I tend to think I don't even know if that's the origin if it was it wasn't like hey

0:47:32Let's give them big cat names. It was oh my god. This thing is so slow. Let's call it cheetah

0:47:38Internally and then somehow it's stuck

0:47:40Yeah

0:47:40And then as the wine names which at least they had the good sense the marketing department had the good sense not to try to

0:47:45Go with the wine names, which they continue to have

0:47:47Do that. I don't know about this. Yeah, they all the OS releases. I think all of them have have you know a

0:47:53Super secret code name, especially now that the when the code names became, you know

0:47:57It started with Jaguar where they started to become the marketing names as well

0:48:00They have wine names and I get I'm assuming it's Bertrand

0:48:03I mean, you know gonna go with that but like I even up to line

0:48:06I think lion was like Barolo or something. I don't drink wine, so I don't know a lot of wine name

0:48:10So what Pino was it was maybe?

0:48:1210 3 or something

0:48:15I don't remember the name some some Apple person could send you an email and tell you what all the wine names were and are

0:48:19But if you if you like

0:48:21Gripped through the various shell scripts and other readable things occasionally you can find a comment or a reference to a name of a wine

0:48:28And that's what they're talking about

0:48:30Do we I forget if I talked about this and if I did I would think it might have been when you were on the show

0:48:36Also could have been in person like at WWDC. I don't know but if I'm repeating myself forgive me

0:48:41I don't know. I forget what it's been on this show three months ago

0:48:44But the other names that were went unused

0:48:49But couldn't for obvious reasons. I was talking to somebody at Apple about him was you know

0:48:55How could they if they wanted to how could they have gotten another cat?

0:48:58Cougar

0:49:01Which they didn't want to use for the connotation and pop culture of you know, older women who chase young men

0:49:07But cougar is a pretty cool, you know until recently I think they could have used that I think that that usage of cougar is

0:49:16kind of a

0:49:18Modern thing and I think they could have gotten over that

0:49:21I don't I don't know that the that the snickering over calling a version cougar would have lasted any longer than the snickering over

0:49:29iPad yeah, you know it would have blown over and it was perfectly serviceable name right you know what uh what is it?

0:49:34It's you know what are they gonna call the big one the maxi pad?

0:49:37You know I think Cougars if you know I mean there was John Cougar Mellencamp, and it's pretty cool cat

0:49:43What was the other one I

0:49:48Can't remember there was one more that they could also ocelot

0:49:52ocelot is

0:49:55You know is one. I think I

0:49:58could swear I've had this conversation before I just can't remember if it was on the show or not Jonas used to play and

0:50:03When he was the seven and eight year old Little League teams

0:50:07In the league he played here in Philly all the teams had big cat names

0:50:13And I think that there were the ten or eleven teams in the league

0:50:17So it was a little bit more than you know, the maybe there are twelve teams

0:50:21So it was more than the OS releases and there there wasn't ocelots

0:50:26Which I think is probably the worst I mean

0:50:28It's you know most of the kids couldn't even spell that and the other cool cat that was one of his team names

0:50:34And they I know that Apple considered it. I think if they've gone one more. This is the one they would have used was

0:50:39Wildcats

0:50:42Yeah, I mean like a lot of these names as you know any biologist points out

0:50:46They're like different names for the same actual animal and then known by different names and wildcat

0:50:50I'm assuming is you know similar type of things what the hell's a wildcat right right?

0:50:54You know but like the wildcat is a one that definitely has you have to tie that to something

0:50:59There has to be something wild about it like it right. You know Mavericks is like a little bit maverick

0:51:04It's different or whatever, but not it's nothing like wildcat like wildcat could be like when you do

0:51:09You know iOS six to seven type transition. Well. It's wildcat. It's wild you know whatever

0:51:13But you can't just you can't just slap that on something like if they had called this one

0:51:17Wildcat all the reviews would be like this isn't very wild

0:51:21Even now like a lot of them were like it's even mine like it's not particularly maverick

0:51:26Like I made that point in the end of it. It's like, you know, kind of like cheetah was the slowest maverick is

0:51:30Not really, you know boldly asserting a you know new direction. It's kind of not maverick. I

0:51:37I'm gonna I don't want to spoil it. I'm gonna assume I think you know, hopefully I think that you know

0:51:43Anybody out there is listening

0:51:45If you've had plenty of time to read

0:51:48John's review so I mean I don't want to spoil it, but at the end you you said if it was if os10 were

0:51:54Anthropomorphized you you cast as as os 10 woody allen

0:51:59And you said ios would be the suave coolness of brad pitt this totally see brad pitt as ios

0:52:06Anthropomorphized I wouldn't say woody allen now well

0:52:11I say not not the os, but this particular release of the os because it's kind of like oh well

0:52:16"Well, you know, I don't know about this whole wood thing.

0:52:19We're gonna get the wood out there, but, you know, just I think everything is okay.

0:52:22If we'll leave at the Felton Game Center..."

0:52:24This is my Woody Allen impression.

0:52:25That's pretty good.

0:52:26I'm really enjoying that.

0:52:27But, like, yeah, it's like Woody Allen is kind of cool in some of his movies, you know?

0:52:32But he also can get easily flustered and seems uncertain, right?

0:52:36And so this thing is like it's kind of got a little bit of, you know, Woody Allen is

0:52:42smart and resourceful and introspective.

0:52:45that was the subhead of this thing of like time for introspection.

0:52:47It seems like OS X is like looking at stuff in the mirror and go,

0:52:50"What am I going to do with my life?"

0:52:51And it's wiped off a lot of the crap that was added to all those applications,

0:52:54making them look like books and look like the iOS apps.

0:52:57But that's all it's done to this point is wipe the stuff off.

0:52:59Like it just smear, smear, smear, leather gone from calendar.

0:53:02But it's not like, "Oh, let me just radically rethink all these applications."

0:53:06And some of them it didn't even get time to clean up.

0:53:08So it knows what it doesn't want to be,

0:53:11but doesn't even have the time to rewind it.

0:53:13And so that's why I'm looking for something that's like, you know, Woody Allen is—people

0:53:18have different impressions of Woody Allen, so that's difficult to say. Most people would not

0:53:22think of the Woody Allen—maybe if you're a neurotic New Yorker, you will look up to Woody Allen in

0:53:28some degree, but other people might look at Woody Allen as just entirely like the sort of nervous,

0:53:33sweating, fidgeting type of thing. But there are admirable things about Woody Allen, but he also

0:53:37has that angle of uncertainty and always questioning himself. Yeah. I guess there is this

0:53:42sort of introspection is a good way to put it, where that's really where most of the

0:53:49changes in Mavericks are. I mean, it's very obvious. You don't even have to read a 24,000

0:53:56word review to figure out that it doesn't really look different than before, other than,

0:54:01as you said, in the case of specific apps that have been de-s-... Let's use the S-word,

0:54:08skew skew amorphized is the f word before stalled before stalled right but

0:54:16what did they end up looking like they've really all those apps you know

0:54:19contacts and etc really just look like generic apps you know it it's just a

0:54:28very straightforward right out of app kit well and I'm not even that because

0:54:33if you had made them straight with app kit they would not be like they are what

0:54:36What they are is like underneath that--

0:54:39it's like makeup.

0:54:39If you wipe off all that makeup underneath there,

0:54:41it's like just the thing that was always under there.

0:54:43Because it's strangely structured,

0:54:45like contacts where they had the three panes out of the books

0:54:48or whatever.

0:54:48Yeah, you're right.

0:54:49Once you get rid of the book art,

0:54:51it's like, would I ever make this window

0:54:52if I didn't know that previously it had started

0:54:54as a book type thing?

0:54:55And they made the three panes more or less

0:54:57independently resizable so you can get it

0:54:58into arrangements that would never

0:55:00correspond to a book that always had

0:55:01to be split down the middle.

0:55:02But if you just started from scratch

0:55:04and said, make me a contacts window,

0:55:05you would never make a window like that.

0:55:06It only makes sense if you look at, oh, I see it used to be covered with a book, you

0:55:10know?

0:55:11Or the notes application, oh, I see this used to be yellow-lined paper, and then this was

0:55:16a sidebar.

0:55:17Now it's just kind of like this beige thing.

0:55:18You have to know where it came from for the current Windows to make sense.

0:55:21Otherwise, they look kind of small and squinty and strange and use weird fonts and don't

0:55:24look like Mac apps at all.

0:55:26They look like iOS apps that have been scoured down.

0:55:30That's more or less what they are.

0:55:31And again, I assume it's because they didn't have time to do anything else.

0:55:33They said well, we're sure as hell not not shipping that leather stuff anymore. That was the easiest one

0:55:38Okay, just replace it with a gray header and throw a little bit of you know

0:55:42Thin Helvetica in there for like the month name or whatever, but they're they're not entirely rethought. It's just like

0:55:47You know backpedaling

0:55:50Yeah notes in particular

0:55:52I think really kind of sticks out cuz like you can like double click a note to open it into its own window

0:55:56But it it doesn't have a standard

0:55:59window title bar at all, it's like a

0:56:02It used to be like a little yellow sticky note.

0:56:04And now that they're not that yellow anymore,

0:56:06now it's just like a weird window.

0:56:07It doesn't make it-- doesn't read that well.

0:56:10And like, reminders kept whatever

0:56:13that crazy black stuff is.

0:56:14It's like, well, they didn't have time to redo reminders.

0:56:16They didn't have time to get to redo Game Centers.

0:56:18There's too much graphics.

0:56:19And all those people are too busy working on iOS 7 now,

0:56:21and whatever.

0:56:24It's sort of like-- if you want to go

0:56:28with the anthropomorphized thing,

0:56:30It's sort of like somebody who's sobered up after a long bender.

0:56:39And Game Center is like the face tattoo?

0:56:42Yeah, sort of.

0:56:43Or maybe a face tattoo is a little tough, or a little out there.

0:56:49But yeah.

0:56:49I was going for the hangover, which I hadn't seen.

0:56:51But it's the lampshade on the head.

0:56:53And it's like, well, you woke up and you're just like, geez,

0:57:00I'm just going to I'm just going to put on a t-shirt

0:57:02Call it dressed

0:57:05And but it did the introspection though I did you know so yeah the look and feel is obviously it's really just

0:57:14Taking out those over-the-top

0:57:17skeuomorphic resources and that's really the extent of

0:57:20Significant changes to the way it looks I mean like you know they change the doc again, too

0:57:26I mean like they always screw with the doc

0:57:28The doc on the side looks different.

0:57:30Like, you know.

0:57:30There are so few user interface elements

0:57:33that are guaranteed to be visible in OS X.

0:57:35The doc is-- it's like the doc, the menu bar, and the window

0:57:38title bar.

0:57:39So like, that's the look of the OS.

0:57:40Because there's not that much other surface area.

0:57:42So any time they change the doc, it's like, well,

0:57:44that's the one thing that you know

0:57:45is going to be in people's faces.

0:57:47And you know.

0:57:49So most of the changes, you know,

0:57:51how do you write a 24,000 word review

0:57:53of an OS that didn't really change

0:57:55that much the way it looks?

0:57:57It's, you know, the stuff that's new is under the hood.

0:58:01And it's really sort of a deep--

0:58:03it is sort of introspective.

0:58:05It's like, why are we doing this?

0:58:07Why have we spent all this time over the decades letting

0:58:11background processes consume as much CPU time as they could?

0:58:15What is the purpose of the OS?

0:58:17What is the job of the OS?

0:58:18Job used to be like give every process all the resources it

0:58:22needs, manage access to the hardware,

0:58:23and coordinate them all, and have them just maximize it.

0:58:26And now it's like the parent that was too permissive.

0:58:30And it realizes, what is the purpose of being a parent?

0:58:32Is it just to give your kid everything that they want?

0:58:34Maybe not.

0:58:34Like iOS, again, if you can't talk about the Mac without talking about iOS,

0:58:38iOS showed-- because you had to, you had no choice.

0:58:41Like you're on a phone, you can't have all that crap in the background.

0:58:44And there's that story that I don't remember the source of this.

0:58:48Maybe you do, like Steve Jobs, seeing the iPad.

0:58:50I'm the source of the story.

0:58:52I wanted to tell you this.

0:58:53This is my story.

0:58:55Well, I wasn't there, but I spoke to someone who was there.

0:59:00It was after the original iPad was unveiled.

0:59:07So it's 2010, and it had been a secret project.

0:59:10Everybody was something, something.

0:59:11Apple's doing a tablet.

0:59:13But like any Apple project, only the people who worked on the iPad knew about the iPad

0:59:19before it came out.

0:59:20I mean, the iOS team knew more or less, but that was it.

0:59:23And then after it came out, then everybody at Apple knew what it was, and then he could

0:59:27do it.

0:59:28And there was a meeting with the hardware team for the MacBook hardware team.

0:59:31And it was, "What are we going to do for the next MacBook?"

0:59:33And Jobs had been on his first medical leave – well, not first, but the first toward

0:59:42the latter years of his life.

0:59:44In 2009, he'd been gone a lot of the time.

0:59:46And it was when he came back, it was that first – that one – it was the medical

0:59:51that started with the Kim canceling the Macworld keynote and this etc and was

0:59:56when he came back in the summer and it was like what is he gonna do with maybe

1:00:00less time that he can spend in and he spent the rest of that year doing the

1:00:04original iPad but it really devoted himself to it I mean he knew the iPad

1:00:08in and out and so his next meeting with the the MacBook people this must have

1:00:12been probably like March of 2010 it kid they came in her and they expect it was

1:00:19like budgeted it like three hours. It was like going to be a three hour meeting where

1:00:22Steve Jobs is going to lay out the line of what are we going to do with the MacBook.

1:00:25He came in carrying an iPad and there were all the existing MacBooks around the table.

1:00:32And he said, "Here, look at this. This is asleep." And then he touched the button on

1:00:36the iPad and it instantly turned on. He goes, "Now it's awake." And he goes, "I'm going

1:00:40to do it again." He turned it off. He says, "Now it's asleep. Touch the button. Now it's

1:00:44awake. He goes, Why can't I do that on this and pointed to a MacBook and then he just left the room.

1:00:50Yeah, and it's the same thing that we all felt like when we, you know, the iPhone to begin with

1:00:58is like, that's why it seems so magical. You use it and you're like, why is this thing that I know

1:01:03is like one, especially the original iPhone one 10,000th as powerful as the Mac? Why does it feel

1:01:09so? Why does it feel so fast? Why does it feel so responsive? Why does the magnet is kind of unfair

1:01:14to do that to the MacBook hardware team,

1:01:16if that's who he was talking to, because it's not just

1:01:19a hardware solution.

1:01:20And Mavericks is finally the software side of that coming.

1:01:25All these things that iOS does to be

1:01:30that responsive and such crappy hardware,

1:01:32finally getting the Mac to get some of that religion.

1:01:35Do less stuff.

1:01:35Only do what the user asks.

1:01:38Do what they ask immediately.

1:01:39Everything else gets screwed.

1:01:42And you can't do that entirely on the Mac,

1:01:44because the part of the Mac is useless,

1:01:45be able to run all this stuff in the background.

1:01:46But if you spend any time with the command line tools

1:01:49like fs_usage, or in the old days, sc_usage,

1:01:53and these other command line tools that show you

1:01:54what's going on in your system, fs_usage in particular,

1:01:56I'm always looking at it, because I'm always trying

1:01:58to figure out what the hell is grinding my disk to death.

1:02:00So much crap, just run this on your machine now.

1:02:03fs_usage, it should be in your path if you've got the,

1:02:06maybe it's part of the dev tools.

1:02:07Look at how many processes are just beating your disk

1:02:10to hell, and you're like, what are these things doing?

1:02:12Does something really need to be checking

1:02:13this preference file 30 times a second.

1:02:17Sometimes I've written bug reports for programs

1:02:19that say, your program is looking at this--

1:02:23is statting this file literally hundreds of times a second.

1:02:27That seems excessive.

1:02:28Don't do that.

1:02:29And Mavericks is, what is the role of the OS

1:02:32and the introspection angle?

1:02:33Maybe the role of the OS is to say,

1:02:35I don't care how fast you want to check that file.

1:02:37If you're not the process that the user is interacting with,

1:02:40but you're some faceless demon and something else is going on,

1:02:43and more important things are happening,

1:02:44you're gonna be throttled.

1:02:46I'm gonna give you less CPU time.

1:02:47And there's always been process priority

1:02:49and stuff like that,

1:02:51and Mac OS X has always prioritized

1:02:53the quote-unquote interactive tasks

1:02:54over the non-interactive ones,

1:02:55but Mavericks is really cranking it up,

1:02:58not just giving them less time,

1:02:59but also trying to have fewer of those things happening.

1:03:01And it's kind of weird.

1:03:02It's happening at the same time

1:03:04that iOS 7 is finally saying,

1:03:05"Okay, a couple of applications can run in the background,"

1:03:08kind of like you do on the Mac.

1:03:10iOS used to be just this totalitarian regime

1:03:12where nobody gets to run only one process at once.

1:03:15And now, with the A7 and stuff, they finally

1:03:17have enough CPU power to say, OK, we can open up

1:03:19the policy a little bit.

1:03:21Apps can run in the background, subject to some restrictions.

1:03:24And the Mac is coming from the other direction,

1:03:26trying to lock everything down.

1:03:27But it's one of those things where

1:03:29I feel like you had to go all the way to the iOS, the iPhone,

1:03:33and iPad to sort of open your eyes to these questions.

1:03:38The questions just didn't occur prior to that.

1:03:41Why would you let an application that the user can't even see,

1:03:48why are we letting it spend as much CPU time

1:03:50as it wants to update its UI?

1:03:53You know, it doesn't make any sense.

1:03:55Whereas iOS, that's like when you think,

1:03:57when you sit there and think, well, why does the iPad

1:04:01get such amazing battery life?

1:04:03And one of the things is, even now that it has multitasking

1:04:07and you can keep multiple apps in memory to some degree,

1:04:11And you get a real win out of that when you switch.

1:04:14If you're switching from mail to Safari

1:04:18to your Twitter client, and all three of them

1:04:20can stay in open in RAM,

1:04:22they may not be doing stuff in the background,

1:04:25but then when you switch to them,

1:04:26it's right there where you left off

1:04:28and there's no wait at all.

1:04:30But on the other hand, it's not doing anything

1:04:33in the background that you don't need to happen.

1:04:36And all of a sudden, I think that Apple is clearly asking,

1:04:39why can't the Mac be more like that?

1:04:40So here's the thing about that Steve Jobs story.

1:04:44At that time, and to this day, but at that time as well,

1:04:48Max had an amazing reputation for being

1:04:51the laptop that wakes from sleep really, really fast.

1:04:54Like they were the gold standard of the industry.

1:04:56And even among PC users, they'd see how fast-- this

1:04:59is before that meeting they had this reputation.

1:05:01And it's exactly-- it's totally Steve Jobs' move

1:05:04to come into the room.

1:05:05And the one thing he picks on is the one thing

1:05:06that MacBooks are universally recognized

1:05:09as being the best in the industry at.

1:05:10And that's a thing that he says is crap.

1:05:12And why is it crap?

1:05:13Because Apple itself had made a device that shows,

1:05:15don't be satisfied merely by being the laptop

1:05:18that wakes from sleep the fastest.

1:05:19There's a whole other realm of possibility

1:05:21over here on this little thing.

1:05:23- Right, don't just compare yourself to Windows PCs.

1:05:26- Right, and the thing about the iPad,

1:05:28I remember back in the day,

1:05:29and I even find myself slipping into this,

1:05:31I think I even did in the review,

1:05:32like the iPad was so amazing

1:05:33'cause it was like 10 hour battery life,

1:05:35and that's when laptops were getting

1:05:36like three and four hour battery lives.

1:05:38And you look at it and you're like,

1:05:39how the hell does this thing have a 10-hour battery life

1:05:43when the battery for a MacBook Pro or whatever

1:05:47weighs more than the entire iPad screen at all?

1:05:51We have this huge battery, and we get three hours.

1:05:53And they have a battery that's so skinny that we barely

1:05:55need to shove it in the back of this thing.

1:05:56And that continued to happen as the battery for the iPad

1:05:58got skinnier and skinnier.

1:06:00It was like the Mac laptops had bigger batteries.

1:06:03And now finally with Mavericks, even before that with Haswell,

1:06:07Like, finally, Mac laptops are getting the benefit

1:06:11of having just massively more battery than the iPad.

1:06:13Because the iPad now has this little tiny sliver.

1:06:15iPad Air has a battery.

1:06:16It's probably like a sheet of paper inside there.

1:06:19There's no room in there.

1:06:20The battery is so tiny compared to the battery

1:06:22in a 15-inch MacBook Pro, which is just seven big, chunky cells.

1:06:27They're still small.

1:06:29And a MacBook Air running Mavericks,

1:06:31we were getting like 14, 15 hours of battery life.

1:06:34So now suddenly, the world makes sense again.

1:06:37the thing with the bigger battery does get more battery life, whereas before it was like

1:06:39the thing with the bigger battery gets a third of the battery life of the iPad.

1:06:43Right. Why in the world does the Mac, even the 11-inch MacBook Air, which clearly has

1:06:49the smallest battery of any MacBook, because it's the smallest anything in a MacBook, but

1:06:55if it weighs two and a half times as much as an iPad, how could it not get better battery

1:07:01life? Or at least match it or something.

1:07:03But it was you know and I think it's only really with this year's models that it really jumped past it and like you said

1:07:08With Mavericks, it's clearly past it

1:07:11I mean, it's yeah as well as the big part of it in terms of like, you know the hardware

1:07:15That was the big win, you know getting the CPU putting more stuff on the chip, you know

1:07:19Like we're not it's not an a7 system on a chip yet

1:07:21But like we're there they're going towards each other and then the software side of it is the other half of that

1:07:26Okay, we have the CPU and chipset that's able to not use a lot of power and it's not doing anything now

1:07:31it's the OS's job to make sure we're not doing anything when we're not doing anything.

1:07:35Well, you ran your own tests for your review where you, you know, and it's, you know,

1:07:42like a real-world test. It's not some kind of abstract benchmark. It was loading web pages,

1:07:47waiting a couple seconds, you know, maybe to simulate actually, you know, looking at the

1:07:52web page and then closing it and loading more. Yeah, I got a newfound, not a newfound,

1:07:58I always had respect for an antagonist people with lots of benchmarks but doing benchmarks like this like synthetic ones are so much nicer because they're

1:08:04Repeatable but I'm doing a real benchmark using real websites, right?

1:08:08Right and real websites vary from day to day right or you know you and you installed the flash plug-in

1:08:14Yeah, I'm like a real-world usage. But then if if if your advertisements that are flash-based

1:08:20Consume CPU it matters which ads load

1:08:23yeah, and then it's like I would have to because I'm trying to I was trying to compare Mavericks to mountain lion and

1:08:28And I'd only had one machine to test on.

1:08:31So I'd run the Mavericks one.

1:08:33I'd reboot for the battery to recharge and run the next one.

1:08:36And I was getting such variability

1:08:38on the Mountain Lion ones.

1:08:39The Mavericks ones were pretty consistent,

1:08:41but the Mountain Lion ones just varied like crazy.

1:08:43And so the numbers in the review are direct numbers from runs.

1:08:49But we had many, many runs.

1:08:50And I was like, should I average them?

1:08:51Should I not?

1:08:52I just kind of took an actual run

1:08:54that was kind of in the middle.

1:08:55But they vary.

1:08:56It's like, what is the weather on the internet today

1:08:58in terms of flash ad crap?

1:09:00And if it's a bad flash ad weather day on the internet,

1:09:02the machine that willingly runs flash ads

1:09:05is going to get slaughtered.

1:09:06And Mavericks is like, I don't care what the flash ad weather

1:09:08is like.

1:09:09I'll load the flash thing, but I'm not

1:09:10going to let it auto play.

1:09:11Like, I intentionally pick pages that occasionally

1:09:14had auto playing ads, like YouTube and--

1:09:16I think The Verge has them occasionally as well.

1:09:18Like, I was trying to pick sites that tech nerds might go to.

1:09:22The test itself, I think it was gentle,

1:09:24like it was a light usage test, because it was like,

1:09:27go to web pages, change to a tab, go to a text edit document,

1:09:30add a line of text, let the autosave thing work,

1:09:32hide the window, show the window, bring this tab

1:09:34to the front, hide that tab.

1:09:36But it's really light usage, not doing anything strange

1:09:39at all.

1:09:39So in that respect, it's not representative of you

1:09:41actually using and hammering on your computer.

1:09:43But I just wanted to see what kind of percentage increase

1:09:46could we get.

1:09:46And I was trying to demo AppNap, making sure

1:09:49that AppNap was a factor.

1:09:51Like, I was stopping for like five seconds, at least,

1:09:53changing tabs to simulate reading something for five seconds, and that's enough time for

1:09:57AppNap to kick in.

1:09:58And Flash was there to demonstrate the amazing benefit you get by not auto-playing Flash

1:10:03ads, even though Flash was installed.

1:10:07If people read it, they should look at the mountain lion numbers, because if you're not

1:10:10currently getting 12 or 13 hours out of mountain lion, you're not going to get 15 hours out

1:10:15of Mavericks.

1:10:16It's like the percentage increase is probably representative, but the absolute value is

1:10:21It depends on the age of your battery and all that stuff.

1:10:23But it does seem true, though.

1:10:26I mean, it really just seems bottom line true.

1:10:28And it's one of those things that seems--

1:10:31it sounds too good to be true, and everybody naturally sort of just

1:10:34thinks, let's see.

1:10:36When Craig Federighi first ran through the features back at WWDC of Mavericks

1:10:45and said that we can get with these things that we're doing,

1:10:48AppNap and the coalesced network.

1:10:54Timers.

1:10:55Yeah, and I/O, if you can even just coalesce hitting

1:11:00the hard drive, it adds up, and you're

1:11:03going to get 20%, 30% more battery life.

1:11:08Just by upgrading to the new OS, that sounds too good to be

1:11:11true.

1:11:12And I asked Apple if they had any kind of number

1:11:14that they were going to throw out there

1:11:16as a marketing type thing.

1:11:18I really didn't expect anything, and to their credit,

1:11:19they didn't give one, because this is the thing

1:11:21about battery life.

1:11:22The whole game here is you're not,

1:11:25you can't get blood from a stone.

1:11:26The battery has the energy that it has.

1:11:27The CPU has the energy it has, and I was trying to emphasize

1:11:30that with the early on graph showing, pulled right from WWC.

1:11:33Look at this CPU.

1:11:34It uses nothing when you're not using it,

1:11:36but it uses 25 watts when you're hammering it,

1:11:39and it's a 54 watt hour battery.

1:11:41Do the math.

1:11:42How many hours do you get when you're using 25 watts

1:11:44and your battery's 54 watt?

1:11:45You don't get 12, that's for sure.

1:11:48That's the thing about battery usage, and that's why I talked about the application

1:11:51so much, is that you get this new OS, and you go out and you put it on your machine,

1:11:55and you're like, "Wow, now I'm going to get real battery life increase."

1:11:58There's nothing the OS can do if you're running a bunch of crap that is just, you know, hamming

1:12:02your CPU and your GPU constantly.

1:12:04Like, the OS can't stop that.

1:12:05If you have some third-party thing that's in your menu bar, drawing 60 frames a second

1:12:09constantly, that is going to suck your power like a vampire.

1:12:11Like, Mavericks' whole trick is it doesn't magically make more battery, it makes less

1:12:15stuff go on.

1:12:16But if you force stuff to go on, you're going to-- like,

1:12:18you could burn your--

1:12:19through your battery just as fast

1:12:21from average because you can't amount

1:12:22to money if you just have a bad application.

1:12:23Just one bad application.

1:12:24So there's the-- what do you call it?

1:12:26The wall of shame?

1:12:29In the--

1:12:30Energy shaming, yeah.

1:12:31It's a great idea.

1:12:32And I think it's one of my favorite parts of your review

1:12:35because I noticed the feature.

1:12:38And I thought, oh, that's interesting.

1:12:39And it shows-- and for anybody who doesn't know,

1:12:42it's like when you go to the battery meter in the menu bar.

1:12:45And do you even-- is that on desktops?

1:12:47How does that show up on desktops?

1:12:49Yeah, I went and looked for it recently.

1:12:51I'm like, I wish that showed up on desktops.

1:12:52Because even though I don't have battery power,

1:12:54I want to know what the hell is stealing my CPU cycle--

1:12:56Right.

1:12:56--and doing my disk and doing all this crap.

1:12:58Right.

1:12:58So it's in the battery meter.

1:13:00So I guess you don't see it on desktops.

1:13:02But you go up to the little battery thing in the menu bar,

1:13:04and you pull it down.

1:13:05And in addition to telling you the stuff it used to tell you,

1:13:08like whether you show the percentage or not,

1:13:11or just show the icon, it now has a list of apps

1:13:15using significant energy.

1:13:17And so it's all posited in the terms of energy.

1:13:21But like you said, it also means which apps

1:13:24are slowing my system down.

1:13:25If there's an app using 30% of your CPU,

1:13:28even if you're plugged into AC, if you're

1:13:30using a Mac Pro or an iMac or something,

1:13:33you'd still like to know about that app because if you

1:13:36can make it stop doing that, your machine will be faster.

1:13:38And it's brutal because, first of all, it shows the icon.

1:13:41So your face is out there.

1:13:45And the battery menu is like, people

1:13:46know about the battery menu.

1:13:48People just know about it.

1:13:50They like to have it in the menu bar.

1:13:52They don't just look a little icon.

1:13:53It is very likely to be found.

1:13:55Because you can get all the same information

1:13:56by just going to activity monitor,

1:13:57but nobody knows about activity monitor.

1:13:58Normally users don't hang out there.

1:14:00So if you look in the menu, it's putting

1:14:02in front of more or less regular users' faces, potentially

1:14:06your application icon.

1:14:08And like I said in the review, if I was a developer,

1:14:11I would be kind of annoyed by this,

1:14:12'cause you just know the support email you're gonna get.

1:14:14'Cause like, oh, your app is using significant,

1:14:16it's like, it's a game, you're playing the game.

1:14:18Of course it's gonna be using, like, what the hell?

1:14:20It's not magic, and your app is gonna show up,

1:14:22and you're just gonna have to field request after request

1:14:24about like, yes, I understand, people are gonna complain.

1:14:27But it's the only way to do it to get,

1:14:30to shame the people who really need to be shamed.

1:14:32Your stupid little dinky thing that I'm not even using

1:14:34is showing up on this menu, what the hell is the deal?

1:14:37And when you select it from the menu,

1:14:39it goes to activity monitor with the application highlighted,

1:14:42like as in kill me now.

1:14:44Like this is a quit button right up in the,

1:14:45like it's like volunteering to say,

1:14:48this here's the guilty application,

1:14:49you wanna kill it off?

1:14:50Just click this big red stop sign button in the toolbar

1:14:53and we'll kill it.

1:14:54- So the day that Mavericks came out,

1:14:57my friend James Duncan Davidson, the photographer,

1:15:02he just emailed me with a, oh boy,

1:15:06screenshot of his app shame list, which listed Photoshop.

1:15:14And he said, this is when no documents open.

1:15:17Yeah.

1:15:17And you know, and now there's the thing where it's like, if you really--

1:15:24if Photoshop is--

1:15:26who knows what the hell it's doing.

1:15:27But if it's doing something where it's using significant energy while you

1:15:31and don't even have a document open.

1:15:34But your professional work is such that you need Photoshop.

1:15:39Well, this is what you're getting at, though.

1:15:41You're not--

1:15:43Mavericks--

1:15:44Your computer is there to be used for something.

1:15:46Right, but Mavericks isn't going to magically make that less

1:15:50painful on your battery life.

1:15:52And the thing is, that's not instantaneous.

1:15:54It's not a snapshot of looking at activity monitor top.

1:15:57That energy stuff is averaged over a long period of time.

1:16:00So it's trying to say, in the past 10 minutes, 15 minutes,

1:16:03hour, whatever, even an activity monitor,

1:16:05the average energy impact, it's not like,

1:16:08right now I'm not doing anything in Photoshop.

1:16:09Why is it in the menu?

1:16:10It's in the menu because over the past little while,

1:16:13that's been the guy that's been using a lot of your energy,

1:16:15even if you're not doing it right now.

1:16:17So if he was just saying, I don't have any documents open

1:16:19now and it's still in the menu,

1:16:20yeah, it's gonna be in the menu.

1:16:21But if you haven't touched Photoshop in 10, 15, 20 minutes

1:16:24and it's still in the menu,

1:16:25then maybe something's going wrong.

1:16:26Obviously, it's there kind of quote, unquote, "unfairly."

1:16:30And I think the annoying users who

1:16:33are going to send an email to developers--

1:16:35maybe not Adobe, because they're not going to listen or whatever.

1:16:38But if you make some little application,

1:16:40and your users keep sending you email,

1:16:42maybe it'll make you look at the WWDC session

1:16:45about how can I make my application more

1:16:47energy efficient.

1:16:49There's so much low-hanging fruit

1:16:50that regular developers can do.

1:16:52And Apple trying to preach at them at WWDC,

1:16:54saying, oh, having session after session about here's

1:16:56you be energy efficient? They've been doing that for years, and developers are like, "Yeah,

1:16:59yeah, whatever." Now, if it's a support load and your customers realize that you're doing

1:17:03something silly, then maybe you're like, "Okay, fine. I'll go look at the sessions and I'll

1:17:07change my application."

1:17:08Yeah, and I don't know. It's just one of those cultural things where maybe it's like the

1:17:15way that certain values get hammered, just kind of become ingrained over time. I don't

1:17:25I just might be a bad analogy but like when when I grew up

1:17:27you know

1:17:28nobody had car seats and the kids just stood in the backseat and jumped up and down until you got to where you were going

1:17:33Now if you saw like a four-year-old kid standing in the backseat of a car, you'd be appalled you would call it called police

1:17:39I wouldn't I mean, you know

1:17:41Just want kids to die and right well

1:17:45I don't want him to die. I would just wish him good

1:17:48I was just send like a good thought his way and hope that I hope his parents aren't safe drivers

1:17:53I don't want to get involved.

1:17:55Is that terrible?

1:17:56Would you call the police?

1:17:57Dr. Justin Marchegiani Talk to Amy about it after the show.

1:18:00Dr. Justin Marchegiani Alright.

1:18:03But you know, it's collectively we've shared—we've raised the importance of safety in cars, you

1:18:11know, collectively, you know, where adults are expected to be wearing seatbelts.

1:18:15Seatbelts are expected to, you know, you know, we expect even more now.

1:18:19We have airbags and side impact airbags.

1:18:22We have all this stuff.

1:18:23You're expected to survive most car crashes.

1:18:27It's just become a priority.

1:18:29And I think that energy usage and doing--

1:18:32just every little step along the way, prioritizing these things

1:18:37has got to become a developer priority.

1:18:40Yeah, I don't remember what I actually said,

1:18:42but I was tempted to say that that little presence in the menu

1:18:45bar is the most important energy saving feature of the OS long term.

1:18:49because it's the part-- you can do all you want with the internals

1:18:52and all you want with developer evangelism, but it's so hard to--

1:18:56it's like eating your vegetables.

1:18:58It's so hard to get people to care about this.

1:19:00You need something.

1:19:01What's going to move the needle on this one aspect of this?

1:19:04Because that's the worst thing that could have happened to Apple.

1:19:06And that's one of the reasons that I ran my Mavericks energy

1:19:08test with only Apple-supplied applications plus Flash,

1:19:12is because if third-party developers don't get on board with this,

1:19:15there's nothing Mavericks can do to extend your battery life,

1:19:18because you're just going to keep running the same third party applications you have.

1:19:21They're going to need up all your battery.

1:19:22And maybe the OS trying to be quiet will help a little,

1:19:25but if the OS itself, if you aren't using Apple's bundled applications,

1:19:29you aren't getting the benefit of Apple's work that they did on that.

1:19:31And the OS is rarely doing anything anyway, so maybe you get a little benefit.

1:19:35But third party applications will just kill your battery life.

1:19:38And so how do you do that?

1:19:39We made this amazing OS that can be super energy efficient.

1:19:42We have all these new APIs that you can learn when you're not visible

1:19:45and learn when you don't have to draw stuff and set your priorities and throttle.

1:19:48if no one uses those APIs, you don't get the benefit of all this hard work. It's like,

1:19:52how the hell do we get people to use these APIs? You have to shame them. You have to put them up

1:19:56there and go, this guy right here, he sucks. You know, and you're going to unfairly shame

1:20:01applications that are not doing anything bad that merely are being used a lot.

1:20:05Because or because the whole point of them is to do something CPU. Yeah, like like a game like

1:20:10yes, a game is going to destroy your battery life. That's the whole point of the game is to use every

1:20:13single resource on the entire system to its maximum extent. If you're not using every execution unit

1:20:18In your and every core in your CPU and you know using all the bandwidth and all the processing power in your GPU

1:20:23You know

1:20:24That's not a good game design

1:20:25right if you shoot 300 photographs and a bunch of videos on vacation and come in and plug it in and take

1:20:31Start sucking those pictures off your SD card into iPhoto or Lightroom or aperture and you have it set to you know

1:20:37Like aperture a Lightroom. I don't know if I voted that but you can like and you know put like a

1:20:43default

1:20:45filter over every one of them. You're filtering 300 photos at once while reading from a slow

1:20:50SD card. It's going to be, you know, that's exactly what you're asking the app to do,

1:20:55though, is to do something that is, you know, IO and CPU intensive.

1:21:00And so it's going to get painted with the same brush. So it's not a perfect system,

1:21:04but it's the only tool they have at their disposal. They were desperate enough, it's

1:21:07like, "We've just got to shame them." You know, like, I guess it's kind of still hidden

1:21:12in a little bit, but it's prominent enough. Like, activity monitor is not sufficient.

1:21:16No one goes to activity monitor, but people click that battery menu, especially when they

1:21:19want to see the time remaining if they don't display it. They're like, "Oh, I see the battery.

1:21:25The little stuff inside the battery has moved a little bit, but I want to know how much

1:21:28time do I have left?" And a lot of people don't display that in the menu bar. I don't

1:21:31even know if you can anymore, because it takes up more room. So they click to see, and when

1:21:34they click to see it, there is the hall of shame right there.

1:21:37I love it. I do. I do. I just did not give... This is one of those things where I just didn't

1:21:42give it a lot of thought before reading your review. And then I really... Like you said,

1:21:45I really do think it might have the most lasting impact of all of these changes on battery

1:21:49life.

1:21:50All right. Let me do the second sponsor break. I'm going to talk about our good friends,

1:21:55long-time Mac developers, now great iOS developers too. Smile. And they have a great app I want

1:22:02I tell you about called PDF pen scan plus.

1:22:07PDF pen scan plus.

1:22:10It's a great app.

1:22:11One touch scanning directly from your iPhone or iPad camera.

1:22:17You can scan multiple pages into a single document.

1:22:21You can use OCR to convert scans into searchable PDFs.

1:22:26The OCR is performed by the app itself,

1:22:28not offloaded to a cloud service.

1:22:32So you can do OCR even if you aren't connected to the network,

1:22:36or if you have sensitive documents that you can't share,

1:22:40or maybe it's like a HIPAA type thing, you're not legally--

1:22:43you can't have this thing going off to a cloud service.

1:22:46Happens right there on your iPhone or iPad.

1:22:50You can export PDFs with the OCR text included.

1:22:55They support 16 languages for OCR.

1:22:58It's a perfect companion to Smiles' great app, PDF Pen,

1:23:04for iPad and iPhone, which is a great, great PDF.

1:23:07These guys have been doing great stuff with PDF for longer

1:23:11than I can remember.

1:23:13They have sharing options you can share by Dropbox,

1:23:17Evernote, other services.

1:23:18But just hooking up to Dropbox alone

1:23:20means that you can use your iPhone or iPad

1:23:22to scan documents, put them together, multiple pages, one

1:23:26document, share it by Dropbox, and there it is waiting for you when you get back to your

1:23:30Mac or wherever else you want it.

1:23:33PDF Scan Plus is available on the App Store at the intro price of just $4.99.

1:23:40Five bucks and it's like you've got what used to be a $100, $200 document scanner right

1:23:46there on your iPhone.

1:23:48I have a great video, a demo video by David Sparks, who's a great podcaster and blogger.

1:23:57He'll show you all the powerful features that are packed into this great tool.

1:24:01So where do you go to find out more?

1:24:02Go to Smilesoftware.com/talkshow.

1:24:11And it will take you right there to the page where you can learn all about it.

1:24:17Great app.

1:24:18Scanning is one of those things that I still like let out a sigh when I realize I have to use my scanner because I've

1:24:23Got my printer hooked up to my airport thing, but I can't do scanning through it

1:24:26So every time I got a scan I have to like plug the printer directly into the computer to use a stupid flatbed

1:24:31Scanner and lift the thing up and put it on so terrible

1:24:34I I should just get this app and just stop doing that because I don't care about you know

1:24:38Like I just want you know scanning documents for you know

1:24:41Archival purposes or whatever just take my phone or iPod and take a picture of the thing

1:24:46Yeah, it makes a ton of sense for me. I mean it's and I you know what am I doing?

1:24:50I mean how often do I need to scan something, but when I do it's such a pain

1:24:53Yeah, and the P it p didn't mention but like PDF pen there are other application for editing PDFs

1:24:57It always annoyed me dealing with PDFs like a preview would almost kind of it was so close to being what you wanted

1:25:03But you're like oh you can't really do that because it's a PDF and PDFs aren't editable to their read-only right having PDF pen

1:25:09Like the whole concept of it's a PDF, but you can finally screw with it

1:25:12It's like oh, thank God because it's nothing worse than just dealing with a PDF that you just want to change one little thing

1:25:16or modify in some simple way that you think

1:25:18should be possible and is not.

1:25:19- Right, and it's, you know, I forget when I first saw that,

1:25:24you know, like PDFs that you could have

1:25:26that were clearly scanned, but had been OCR'd

1:25:29so you can search--

1:25:30- Yeah, you'd swipe the text and you're like,

1:25:32how is it selecting this text?

1:25:33- Right, because this is clearly not a font,

1:25:35this is, you know, this looks like a fax.

1:25:37- It's like ink blots and everything

1:25:38and you're swiping over it.

1:25:40- Powerful stuff.

1:25:41OCR seems like one of those tasks,

1:25:44I guess never gonna be perfect, of course.

1:25:46I mean, you've talked about this on your show

1:25:48with Marco and Casey about, you know,

1:25:52I talked to Marco about it too,

1:25:55the episode a couple weeks back where Casey brought up

1:25:57the episode of the Shield show

1:26:01where they made a joke about Siri.

1:26:03And you pointed out, look, Siri could improve a lot

1:26:06and maybe it needs to improve a lot,

1:26:08but it's never going to not be make funable, right?

1:26:12We're never gonna get to a point where AI,

1:26:15at least in our lifetimes, where AI isn't going to be,

1:26:18have some kind of uncanny valley,

1:26:20where it's clearly not a person,

1:26:21and therefore we can make fun of it.

1:26:24OCR is sorta like that.

1:26:25- If you wanna get really depressed about that,

1:26:26think how often you see people make fun

1:26:28of their human coworkers or assistants.

1:26:33Even when you have an actual human,

1:26:35it's the subject of ridicule

1:26:36about how it doesn't understand what you want,

1:26:38because it's not inside your brain.

1:26:40It's an unsolvable problem.

1:26:44Unless we have direct telepathy or become a hive mind.

1:26:48And same thing with OCR. Human beings can't read stuff when it's

1:26:52sufficiently smudged and crappy. Just look at the stupid captchas that we all have to do on the web.

1:26:56Did you see the Paul

1:27:00forget his last name, the guy from Tapbots

1:27:04Tapbots Paul. See that's the thing, I don't know his last name.

1:27:08Paul Paul hadad he bought a surface Microsoft surface to try it out and

1:27:14Here's the capture. Yeah

1:27:17I'm like a login or something you you buy a new surface and you start setting it up in the first run experience

1:27:22like step four of the first run experience is to do a capture and it's like

1:27:28Just in case you're a robot right with with hot dog fingers using the surface, right?

1:27:33But why do they care if robots are buying surfaces? You're buying a surface.

1:27:38It's like maybe, you know, again, you know, with water filled or hot dog fingers, like there's a

1:27:43bunch of like machines somewhere where they have a bunch of surfaces lined up with these little

1:27:48things, you know, trying to scam captchas. I don't understand it either.

1:27:54There's another, a capture that I don't understand the scenario that they're defending against either

1:27:59is the, what's that, the GoGo wireless internet

1:28:04on the airplane.

1:28:07At least, that's the network we have on US Air,

1:28:12and I have an account, I fly enough where I have like,

1:28:16I just have like my account credentials saved.

1:28:18So when I'm on an airplane and there's WiFi,

1:28:21I type in my password, I say yes, use my saved credit card,

1:28:26and then I have to do a captcha.

1:28:28And it stinks if you're on the phone,

1:28:30because it's like you can't see the captcha

1:28:33and see the text field and the keyboard all at the same time.

1:28:38So you have to memorize the captcha and then type it in.

1:28:41And it's case sensitive.

1:28:43It's like, I don't understand what

1:28:45they're defending against.

1:28:46I just gave you my username and password.

1:28:48I just let you charge my credit card.

1:28:50Why am I doing a captcha?

1:28:52There is a BS business buzzword to explain

1:28:55every crazy thing like that.

1:28:56And I think in this case, the BS word is best practices,

1:29:00which is someone just decides it's best practice to have

1:29:01a caption on every login screen,

1:29:03and then they blanket apply that policy.

1:29:04Why? Best practices, best practices.

1:29:06This is definitely a Merlin topic.

1:29:08And so you end up with it in places where it makes no sense

1:29:11because if you didn't take it there, it's like,

1:29:12well, don't you understand?

1:29:13That's best practices.

1:29:14Everyone has captures now.

1:29:15It's corporate policy.

1:29:16- Way to the future.

1:29:17- Yep.

1:29:18(laughing)

1:29:20Have you even seen that movie?

1:29:22- The Aviator?

1:29:23- Yeah.

1:29:24- Oh yeah, I love it.

1:29:25I wonder, I mean, I've seen it as well, but I think the movie is more obscure than

1:29:32a lot of the other things they reference, even like the Big Lebowski, but now it has

1:29:36come to prominence due to their obsession with it.

1:29:39Yeah, I think that the Aviator, I saw it when, I didn't see it in theaters, it's

1:29:45the whole having kids thing where I don't see many movies at all in theaters anymore,

1:29:49but I did see it when it first, I love, big Scorsese fan, and so when it first came out

1:29:53on iTunes, I got it. And I remember being a little disappointed the first time I saw

1:29:57it. I don't know what I expected it to be. I guess I wanted it to be Goodfellas with

1:30:01a billionaire. And it wasn't. And I was a little disappointed. And then I watched it

1:30:07like a year or so ago and thought, "My God, what a remarkable movie." The second time

1:30:12I watched it a year or two later, two, three years later, I really thought, "This is just

1:30:17fantastic. Love that movie."

1:30:19It grows on you. You know, I don't think I'm obsessive compulsive. I don't have any kind

1:30:28of disorder like that, but it seems like such an otherworldly... If you don't suffer from it,

1:30:33I think it's hard to imagine it, and I feel like he really kind of... I don't know. By the second

1:30:39time I watched it, I came out of it thinking somehow, "There but for the grace of God go I."

1:30:42Maybe I am a little closer to that than than

1:30:45comfort

1:30:47Yeah

1:30:48You know I think everyone can identify with it a little bit all right

1:30:51Some some more than others. Let's say all right

1:30:54What a great guy that Howard Hughes was I

1:31:00I don't know if I've ever seen anything about him

1:31:05That wasn't like fictionalized like news reels or interviews or read anything about the actual person so all I have in my mind is the

1:31:11fictional Howard Hughes. Yeah, just building airplanes, building casinos, and

1:31:17dating famous actresses, making movies. There's a life. I mean, what more was there to do?

1:31:25Peeing into bottles, wearing tissue boxes on your feet. Yeah, that doesn't end well.

1:31:28This is really, really this is a cautionary tale about working from home.

1:31:34You should be, that's why you should be on the watch out for this.

1:31:37Exactly, that's that is sort of

1:31:40That is sort of I think what made it uncomfortable for me so I installed the

1:31:46David underscores underscore David Smith. How do we say his name?

1:31:51underscore David Smith, yes

1:31:53his

1:31:55Pedometer app for the iPhone the what's it called steps. I forget what?

1:32:00Pedometer plus plus plus plus I don't know what I don't know how it got two pluses but

1:32:06Pedometer plus plus great app. I think it's a free app and there's like you can do it like an in-app purchase to give them

1:32:12a couple bucks

1:32:13But it just ties into your the motion

1:32:16Processor and the iPhone 5s and gives you your steps

1:32:20I

1:32:22Take shockingly few steps on some days and this is this is still

1:32:28Before winter, you know, it's it's actually, you know, October in Philadelphia is actually beautiful. It's probably

1:32:35Probably my favorite month the climate wise in Philadelphia. It couldn't be more beautiful. We haven't had a lot of rain

1:32:41There's zero reason why I shouldn't be getting more steps than at any point in here

1:32:45And I've you know, I took here you go Wednesday. I took 13 steps

1:32:50Don't you have to get coffee in the morning?

1:32:52Don't you like the Starbucks down the street from every morning or something make it at home now Oh

1:32:56Amy's got the Fitbit and everything that you should buy you one and you could be like Fitbit buddies

1:33:02then maybe you'd be motivated, because now you just

1:33:04have like 13 steps.

1:33:06Did you walk really carefully from your bed to the office

1:33:09so those didn't count as steps, like you

1:33:10were shuffling your feet and your bunny slippers?

1:33:12No.

1:33:13So here's my actual score for Wednesday, October 30,

1:33:15was 3,466 steps.

1:33:18But you're supposed to-- and it gets colored red.

1:33:22So 10,000, everybody says, is what you want every day.

1:33:27I only got 3,466 on Wednesday.

1:33:31Yeah, those step draggers there, I feel like they should count things differently.

1:33:34Because I park in a parking garage, like I usually on the fifth floor by the time I get

1:33:37there, and I run up and down those steps to the fifth floor parking garage, and those

1:33:40should count for more steps than just walking up the steps.

1:33:43Yeah, that's because—

1:33:44You run up five flights of stairs, it's very different than walking up five flight

1:33:46stairs, and yet same number of steps.

1:33:48Yeah, yeah.

1:33:49Taking steps, going up as flight of steps is definitely more, and going down steps is

1:33:55less, I think.

1:33:56Yeah.

1:33:57Because you just, you know, going down steps is really just a controlled fall.

1:33:59And they're just trying to get you to move.

1:34:00I mean, it's motivating you to get outside more.

1:34:04You could get yourself a dog or something.

1:34:06Trick or treat.

1:34:07Trick or treat today, though.

1:34:08I got a good one.

1:34:09I got 15,000 steps.

1:34:11Yeah, well, there you go.

1:34:13Once your son gets tired of you, which will happen,

1:34:15then you get yourself a dog, and you'll have something

1:34:17to do in your old age.

1:34:19Go ahead.

1:34:19Take the dog out for a walk every day.

1:34:21It makes you get outside.

1:34:22You're not a smoker, so you don't have a reason

1:34:23to be outside in the winter, right?

1:34:25So you've got to get some reason to be out there.

1:34:27Do you track your steps?

1:34:30You don't track your steps.

1:34:31No, I don't use any.

1:34:32I think I might be interested in trying it.

1:34:35I like the concept of the gameplay type thing,

1:34:37but it's never come up.

1:34:39I sure as hell don't want to wear anything

1:34:41on my wrist, which is going to be a problem for the iWatch.

1:34:43But I don't want one of those Fitbit that's attached there.

1:34:45And the ones that clip onto your clothes,

1:34:47I know it's just like my laundry machines will eat it.

1:34:50I'm not responsible enough to have

1:34:52$100 little rubberized electronic turds

1:34:56clipped to my clothes, because I'll wash it in the first week,

1:34:58and then I'll have to buy another one.

1:34:59Eventually, it's like it's like a tax of like, you know average of $75 a month for the rest of my life to keep buying new

1:35:04Fitbits. Yeah, I'm exactly the same. I I bought one

1:35:07I bought the it was an Indiegogo project or it was a Kickstarter one of those things. It was called the misfit shine

1:35:13You know misfit is the company

1:35:16and it's like a you know a

1:35:19Fitbit and it was a little it's like a little quarter-sized disc and it had a couple of ways

1:35:25You could wear you could wear it on your wrist. I chose not to I

1:35:28Magnet thing I put it on my pants and I had it for six days before I lost it like on the seventh day

1:35:33I was like, where's that thing? And I'm no I felt in the toilet somewhere, you know, I do

1:35:37Yeah, and I didn't remember I couldn't remember the last time I checked it from the day before I remember

1:35:43I definitely had it the day before and at some point I didn't have it and then it's gone

1:35:47So the phone is the perfect thing then because the phone is like you're not gonna lose track of that because it cost so much

1:35:51Money and you're using it all the time and it's got the tracker in and it doesn't kill your battery

1:35:54so you're good to go.

1:35:55Like, I put that, I put underscore David Smith's Spinnaker plus list thing on my wife's iPhone.

1:36:00It doesn't work for her, unfortunately, because her phone is not allowed in all sorts of places

1:36:04in her work for security reasons.

1:36:07So it's like she doesn't get the benefit of the steps that are taking place when she doesn't

1:36:11have her phone with her, because a lot of times it has to be left elsewhere.

1:36:14So her numbers are low, but she has excuses.

1:36:17It's like a secure zone 12 stories up, and the only way to get there is on a flight of

1:36:23stairs.

1:36:24You can't bring it with you. You gotta stay in the purse in the office.

1:36:28So like the longest hallway in the whole facility. No credit.

1:36:31It's Maxwell Smart. You gotta throw all those doors.

1:36:33Right. What else in Mavericks? What's your favorite thing? What's your favorite thing

1:36:40that they did this year in Mavericks? I said this on ATP that we recorded earlier

1:36:45in the week and people are going to think I'm crazy or a total noob as the kids say.

1:36:50Like, you know the whole thing of back when Mac OS X was slow?

1:36:53After every release of OS X, people in the forums

1:36:56would install it.

1:36:57Oh, it's so much snappier.

1:36:59And it's because every time you install a new version of the OS

1:37:02like you've quit all your applications,

1:37:04everything's fresh, all the caches are rebuilt for you.

1:37:08Of course it feels faster.

1:37:09You just click System Preferences,

1:37:10and it was like one bounce.

1:37:11And it opened right up.

1:37:12Because nothing else was happening in your machine

1:37:13because you just rebooted it and you just reinstalled the OS.

1:37:16Of course it feels snappy.

1:37:18So that effect has always been there, right?

1:37:20But I really feel like having installed Mavericks

1:37:22on so many machines, that it actually does feel snappier,

1:37:27taking into account that yes, of course,

1:37:29it's gonna be a snapper and everything's quit.

1:37:30Like I've been using it for days and days and days,

1:37:32like the release version on my real machines,

1:37:34to do real work, in actual work, and it feels snappier.

1:37:39And it could all be in my head.

1:37:41I'm totally willing to believe that it's all in my head.

1:37:43But if it's not all in my head, what it's coming from is

1:37:46My computer is doing less useless crap.

1:37:48And that means it's more available to do the stuff

1:37:52that I want it to do.

1:37:53And so it could just be they shorten some animation somewhere.

1:37:56It could be anything.

1:37:57Even terminal, for instance.

1:38:00When I use terminal and type ls or something in a local directory

1:38:03or do something that spits out text, it seems like the text

1:38:05appears in the terminal window faster.

1:38:07And it's like, that can't be possible.

1:38:09It already appeared so lightning fast.

1:38:10It wasn't like I was waiting for little characters.

1:38:12It was already so fast.

1:38:13Why does it feel faster to me?

1:38:15So there's some either psychological,

1:38:19not really there, but I think it's there,

1:38:21or actual kind of like trickery, perceived trickery,

1:38:24or whatever, it just, you know,

1:38:26maybe it's just because I spent so freaking long

1:38:28writing that review, it just feels more efficient to me.

1:38:30It just does.

1:38:32- I think it's subtle, but I think it does feel

1:38:35a little snappier too, and I'm running it mostly

1:38:36on a very old PowerBook, a 2008 MacBook,

1:38:40when I say PowerBook, MacBook Pro.

1:38:43and the 2010 MacBook Air that I mentioned in my iPad review.

1:38:49Not new stuff.

1:38:51So there's definitely-- and I feel like on both machines,

1:38:53it feels a little snappier.

1:38:54And I think there's got to be room for that snappiness

1:38:58improvement because, specifically,

1:39:00just comparing the way Mac OS X feels to an iPad, even older

1:39:05iPads.

1:39:06And that's just the whole initial appeal of iOS is,

1:39:10my god this this feels so much more responsive to my input than my computer

1:39:17even though it's only you know a tenth or is 20th you know as powerful as a you

1:39:22know CPU eyes my actual favorite like real feature that is not all in my head

1:39:27is the new version of Safari because I use Safari as my main browser but I also

1:39:33run Chrome all day I always use two browsers and have certain things I do in

1:39:36and certain things I do in Safari,

1:39:37but Safari is my default.

1:39:40And one of the things I always liked about Safari

1:39:42is I felt like when I hit Command-N to make a new window,

1:39:45which I occasionally do because I don't always use tabs,

1:39:46so I feel like they get too crowded to make a new window,

1:39:49it just felt like it was fast.

1:39:50It was like a native UI.

1:39:52Everything about it was native.

1:39:53It was fast, right?

1:39:54And Chrome, what I liked about it was

1:39:56I felt like when Safari was starting to get hung up,

1:39:59especially Safari 6 and the WebKit 2 thing

1:40:01where I would get hung up and you get that dialog box

1:40:03and you have to reload all your windows, which pissed me off

1:40:05no end. When that happened, or when something was slower, when I just saw the progress bar

1:40:09in Safari just hanging there, I always knew I could switch to Chrome, make a new window,

1:40:15and because it was a separate process, no matter what the hell's going on in all my other Chrome

1:40:18tabs and all my other Chrome windows, no matter what the hell Safari is doing being hung,

1:40:22I can get a new Chrome window and it will load the damn thing that I want it to load,

1:40:25because it's independent. And so going to process per tab in Safari is like...

1:40:29Maybe this is just me. People write in and say, "I still get that dialog box that says

1:40:35things are not responding. It's just not all the tabs in Safari now, it's just a few of them.

1:40:38Which I suppose could happen, but I used to get that "pages are not responding,

1:40:42do you want to visit page or reload all the tabs" thing.

1:40:45Used to get it in the old version of Safari constantly.

1:40:48It was driving me nuts, it was driving me to the point where I was thinking of switching my default browser.

1:40:51And during the whole course of writing the review on a Mountain Lion system,

1:40:55I kept getting it again and again. It was taunting me, saying goodbye to me.

1:40:58And I never once, not once, still haven't, not once, gotten it on Mavericks or Safari 7.

1:41:03I don't you know it may happen

1:41:05You know and it may be when it happens it still happens in the effect is less

1:41:08But I just haven't seen it all and that that that is a big change in my daily life because if you use safari is

1:41:14Your default browser and you get that thing like more than you know once every couple of weeks

1:41:18It really changes when that just goes away, and you don't see that anymore

1:41:22Yeah, I you the story you just told is me exactly everything about it. I'd Safari is my default browser

1:41:29I

1:41:30I've run into that dialog box all the time

1:41:35over the time that Safari's used that

1:41:40two process architecture, where there was one

1:41:44to render the UI and one monolithic process

1:41:47to handle all of the rendering.

1:41:50That whole time, was it just one OS release

1:41:53or was it two OS releases?

1:41:54Was it just Mountain Lion?

1:41:56- I am so bad at remembering what you're saying, Matt.

1:41:59I think it might have been Lion and Mountain Lion, whatever

1:42:01WebKit2 came out of.

1:42:02Well, the whole time I ran into that so many times.

1:42:04And when it would get bad, that and that reason alone

1:42:08made me think that maybe I should switch

1:42:10to Chrome as my main browser.

1:42:13The only reason-- and there's not one other thing about Chrome

1:42:16that I prefer to Safari, except for the fact

1:42:18that Chrome for years has had a-- each tab gets

1:42:22its own rendering process.

1:42:24I do like other things about Chrome.

1:42:27When I use Google's applications,

1:42:28I use them in Chrome because I think

1:42:29it's a nice marriage between all their crazy stuff

1:42:31that they do to make things fast and everything.

1:42:33But it's just Chrome is-- and again,

1:42:35people have different experiences.

1:42:36People email me and say, you keep saying Chrome is solid,

1:42:39but it crashes for me all the time.

1:42:40Chrome is so solid for me.

1:42:42I'm on the beta channel for Chrome.

1:42:44I don't even do the regular releases.

1:42:45I'm on the beta.

1:42:46So every time a new beta comes out,

1:42:47I just get it automatically.

1:42:48And even that, I always know if I go to Chrome

1:42:52and make a new window or a new tab, I can load a page.

1:42:55It will never, no matter what's happening,

1:42:57their architecture is so good.

1:42:59And maybe Safari's not up to that level yet,

1:43:01but Chrome has always been just rock solid.

1:43:03And yeah, the UI looks weird,

1:43:04and I don't like how it's not native

1:43:06and all this other stuff,

1:43:06but there are things I do like about Chrome.

1:43:08- Yeah, I wouldn't say that there's nothing else

1:43:10I don't like about it,

1:43:11but there's nothing that tempted me to switch,

1:43:13because I'm not a big user of Google Apps.

1:43:15I don't like the stuff that I don't like.

1:43:17I don't like the non-standard UI.

1:43:19So I'm not saying that,

1:43:21I can see why other people use Chrome for other reasons,

1:43:24But for me, the main thing that was always drawing me

1:43:28was the processor architecture.

1:43:31- And more recently, work-related.

1:43:33I've found myself using the dev tools built into Chrome.

1:43:38I mean, you think, oh, they're both based on WebKit

1:43:40and they both use the WebKit debugger,

1:43:41but they've diverged significantly over the years

1:43:43in terms of what those things look like.

1:43:44And they're pretty much feature-comparable.

1:43:46It's not like the Safari Web Inspector lacks features.

1:43:50It's just the way things are arranged.

1:43:51I've just got, again, with Chrome being so reliable

1:43:54And when you're debugging a web app,

1:43:55you're doing all sorts of crazy crap and certain breakpoints

1:43:58and putting in bad JavaScript that you're trying to fix

1:44:00and all sorts of things that can very quickly get Safari

1:44:04confused and hosed.

1:44:05And when it's hosed, the whole app, back in the bad old days,

1:44:07was hosed.

1:44:09I run Chrome and never have to relaunch it.

1:44:11And so I work.

1:44:12When I'm doing work-related stuff and debugging

1:44:14JavaScript that I could-- webkit-related issues

1:44:16or just testing a web app that I'm writing in JavaScript,

1:44:19I do all my debugging in Chrome these days.

1:44:21Even though it's not as nice and pretty as the debugger

1:44:23and Safari and Safari debugger has gotten a lot better.

1:44:26I just find myself-- even now with Safari 7,

1:44:29I still use Chrome as my debugger.

1:44:32It used to be that I would use Firebug and Firefox back

1:44:34when nobody had good debugging, except for Firefox.

1:44:36So Google, a feature that most people don't care about.

1:44:39But if you're a web developer, I think

1:44:41Chrome's web development tools have really come a long way,

1:44:44and I lean on them every day.

1:44:47I think with Safari breaking a web kit

1:44:51into the separate process architecture--

1:44:53And it seems like there's a big political backstory to that.

1:44:56And you mentioned it, where Apple had invited Google

1:44:59to contribute theirs to the WebKit project,

1:45:03and Google declined.

1:45:05And I also seem to recall reading something

1:45:09about how that it wasn't that great anyway,

1:45:13that it was a lot of work,

1:45:15and what they've wound up with for WebKit 2 now

1:45:19with this processor architecture is a lot better

1:45:23then I don't know if it's better than Chrome,

1:45:26but better for WebKit as a project

1:45:28than Chrome's specific implementation would have been.

1:45:32- No, I mean, that's a little bit sour grapes.

1:45:34- I don't know.

1:45:35- 'Cause I think, you know, like, if you look at what Chrome,

1:45:36and proof is in the pudding, Chrome,

1:45:38if you look at the Chrome documents

1:45:39that I linked in the thing,

1:45:40Chrome has the flexibility to do, you know,

1:45:43the Chromium open source project that it's based on,

1:45:45has the flexibility to do all sorts of different arrangements

1:45:47in terms of processes and tabs and stuff like that.

1:45:50You know, so it's very flexible,

1:45:52And a lot of that stuff is implemented--

1:45:53it's implemented in the application layer

1:45:55versus being implemented in the engine layer.

1:45:57Whereas when they did it in WebKit,

1:45:59if Google had said, oh, sure, here you go.

1:46:03We'll rip this stuff out of our Chromium stuff,

1:46:05and we'll integrate it into WebKit,

1:46:06and then we'll refactor Chrome to no longer do

1:46:09this stuff at the application level,

1:46:10but to use the thing that we put into WebKit.

1:46:13I think Apple sure would have liked that, because they're

1:46:15like, hey, Google has already worked out this process stuff,

1:46:17and their stuff is really solid.

1:46:19But Google was like, no, I thought

1:46:21that's not the proper place for it.

1:46:22We like the layering area, we've picked it, whatever.

1:46:25And it just didn't work out,

1:46:26so the Apple had to do something,

1:46:27and what it did was it said,

1:46:28well, we'll put it in the engine.

1:46:30We'll make it an engine-level feature,

1:46:32'cause we think that's the right place for it or whatever.

1:46:34And I don't think there's anything,

1:46:35it's a difference in philosophy, a difference in design.

1:46:37There's nothing about Apple's approach

1:46:39that said it was necessarily going to be better or worse.

1:46:41It just, it had bugs.

1:46:42Like, it's not working right when things get wedged like that

1:46:45Why did it have bugs?

1:46:46Did it have bugs?

1:46:47Because it's more difficult to make 15 different processes,

1:46:50to make one process communicate with another

1:46:52than to have a one-to-one link.

1:46:54Having all your tabs communicating

1:46:55with your one web backend versus having process per tab

1:46:58where fine, if one tab goes off the rails,

1:47:00it doesn't affect anything else.

1:47:02I don't know, all I know is that the result was

1:47:05that Chrome was kicking Safari's butt in terms of stability

1:47:08and that something had to be done.

1:47:09- And just in terms of what is it like to use it,

1:47:13just put anything you can quantify aside,

1:47:17put the stopwatch down, just use it.

1:47:19it just felt responsive.

1:47:21And like you said, you can always hit Command-T or Command-N

1:47:24to get a new tab at any time.

1:47:25Whereas in Safari, sometimes you end up with the spinner.

1:47:28It's like everything classic Mac OS and Mac OS X

1:47:32with preemptive multitasking versus cooperative.

1:47:34Whereas in the old classic Mac days,

1:47:36you could anger an application to a degree

1:47:38that it would prevent you from doing something else.

1:47:40Where in OS X, no matter how screwed some application is,

1:47:43you can always click over to your Twitter client.

1:47:45I do this frequently when I beach ball an application.

1:47:48I just go over to another application.

1:47:49That other application's not beach balled.

1:47:50It's still pulling events off the queue.

1:47:53We take that for granted with the modern OS,

1:47:55that the processes are independent.

1:47:56That's the job of the OS, to keep them independent.

1:47:59Web browsers, even though it's one application,

1:48:02logically speaking, you think of it as like,

1:48:05well, that may be one application,

1:48:06but I have a bazillion tabs open.

1:48:09I want to see this tab.

1:48:10I don't care if that tab is hung

1:48:11with some stupid flash thing that's dying.

1:48:13And so that architecture, like the web browser,

1:48:16it's such an important application

1:48:17it becomes a microcosm of the OS itself. It's like another level of hierarchy. And within

1:48:22this application, those tabs better be independent of each other, just like processes are independent

1:48:27of each other in the OS, so you make the tabs a process. And it's natural and it makes sense.

1:48:31Like, the other approach could have worked. If it worked, fine, we wouldn't be having

1:48:34this conversation, but it didn't. So thumbs up on changing it.

1:48:37I've been under the impression, and I might be, again, I could be wrong on this, but I

1:48:41was under the impression that maybe, I can't remember if somebody told me this or not.

1:48:46My memory is really starting to-- I'm losing it, John.

1:48:49But I seem to recall some discussion with somebody.

1:48:52It seems like something maybe at WWDC.

1:48:54But the gist of it was that Apple's Safari team never

1:48:57really thought that that monolithic rendering

1:49:01process that handles all of your tabs was the right decision.

1:49:06It was what they-- it was just a matter of time,

1:49:09that they wanted to break rendering

1:49:10into a separate process for security reasons.

1:49:13Yeah, for security reasons, yeah.

1:49:14Only.

1:49:14And it was really about security and having all the plugins in a sandbox rendering process

1:49:22and that they could get that done in time for Lion and Mountain Lion, but that the work

1:49:28that we now see to get each tab in its own rendering process, it was going to take this

1:49:34long anyway.

1:49:36So was it better or worse in the interim to have it split into that monolithic one?

1:49:41I almost think it was worse,

1:49:42that they would have been better security,

1:49:44damn the security implications,

1:49:46it would have been better to stick with

1:49:47the old Safari architecture,

1:49:50where it wasn't a separate process.

1:49:52- Yeah, well, I mean, they took the lesson of Windows XP

1:49:55to heart and said, like, the web,

1:49:56it's so dangerous to have something,

1:49:58because it wasn't just, like, sandboxing plugins is one thing.

1:50:00The second thing was, like,

1:50:01sandboxing JavaScript execution,

1:50:03so that if someone found the exploit

1:50:05where they could put JavaScript code on a webpage

1:50:06that would cause a buffer overflow

1:50:09in your JavaScript engine

1:50:10cause arbitrary code execution, that now all of a sudden you had a webpage that could take

1:50:14out people's Macs or steal information from them and do stuff like that.

1:50:18And that's so incredible, especially in the days before the big push to send everybody

1:50:23updates constantly, updates being shoved in people's faces so you had a chance of upgrading

1:50:29everybody.

1:50:30It was still coming off of the days where, oh god, if suddenly there was an exploit out

1:50:35there that we didn't find out about until it started infecting people's computers and

1:50:39and it's in a web browser and everybody's using it

1:50:41and it's going all over the web, we're screwed.

1:50:43So I understand the priority of like,

1:50:45we gotta get JavaScript, any place,

1:50:47any executable code that you wrote from another page runs,

1:50:50it needs to be running someplace where it has no privileges.

1:50:51So put it in that separate process

1:50:53where it can't do anything.

1:50:54And yet it's same thing with plugins,

1:50:55get them in a sandbox because the down,

1:50:59I mean, I guess the calculus was,

1:51:01if we get, if something like that happens,

1:51:04Macs will get a reputation for being bad and unsafe

1:51:06and our browser is insecure and stuff like that.

1:51:08And just get it done.

1:51:11And I guess they were hoping it would work out,

1:51:14but stability-wise it didn't.

1:51:16But it's still probably better than the alternative.

1:51:19Because Safari being flaky and occasionally

1:51:21getting that dialogue once a week or so,

1:51:24if you're lucky or unlucky,

1:51:26does not make the evening news, so to speak.

1:51:29Metaphorically speaking,

1:51:30'cause no one watches the evening news anymore.

1:51:32- Right.

1:51:32- But if it's a security thing, it would.

1:51:33- A webpage that takes over your computer

1:51:36makes the news.

1:51:37Yeah, it's Windows XP all over again.

1:51:39It was a PR disaster for Microsoft.

1:51:40It was the worst thing that could happen to you.

1:51:42Once you get that reputation, it's hard to shake it.

1:51:44So they probably made the right call.

1:51:46But like so many things in people's lives,

1:51:51how would our lives have been better

1:51:53if mommy and daddy stayed together?

1:51:55How would our lives be different if Google and Apple had divided

1:52:00up the labors of inventing the future with Google doing

1:52:03the server side and Apple doing the client side

1:52:05and had not split up the way they did.

1:52:07And this is just another artifact of that divorce,

1:52:11that their interests were not aligned

1:52:13when it came to Google made Chrome,

1:52:15because it totally aligned with its interest,

1:52:17built on a WebKit which aligned with Apple's interest,

1:52:19but eventually their interest diverged enough

1:52:22that now they're doing Blink and Apple's left with WebKit

1:52:24and they couldn't agree on the process thing,

1:52:26and it's all fallout from that split.

1:52:29- In the mail today, I just got an advanced copy

1:52:32of Dogfight, which is Fred Vogelstein's new book.

1:52:37I think it comes out this week.

1:52:40He's the guy who wrote that story that was in the,

1:52:42or it was actually an excerpt from the book

1:52:44that was in the New York Times a few weeks ago

1:52:45where he talked to the engineer.

1:52:47He got like a former Apple engineer to go on the record

1:52:50and talk about the launch of the original iPhone.

1:52:52Remember that story?

1:52:53It was great.

1:52:54- It's in Instapaper.

1:52:55I haven't read it yet though.

1:52:56- So that was an excerpt from this book,

1:52:58and the gist of the book is just specifically

1:53:01how you know the Apple and Google's fight over you know iOS and Android and you know

1:53:09starting I think you know probably I don't know I haven't read the book yet but probably starting

1:53:14like 2005 2006 when they were still saw it as like you said splitting it up with Google doing the

1:53:19services and Apple doing the devices and how they got from there to here where they kind of hate

1:53:24each other so I'm looking forward to it I don't read a lot of books like that but this one I'm

1:53:29And especially based on the excerpt, which I thought was really dynamite.

1:53:32Yeah, but nerds like us are so desperate for any real firsthand accounts from inside and you know

1:53:36That's kind of like you just get it from like

1:53:39It seems like you're not gonna get it

1:53:40You're not gonna get the Phil Shilla tell all these not until he's like 85 or whatever

1:53:44But you'll get like some random dude who you'd never heard of but you're like so hungry for any scrap of information about like oh

1:53:49He was there and you know and yet and the worst thing about that is you never know like that guy could have an agenda

1:53:54And could giving you it could be giving you a skewed view of things

1:53:57but you'll never know because he's the only person talking at all. So that's what we got to go on and we just we just

1:54:00want to know. We want to know what happened. It's our version of like People magazine.

1:54:03Yeah, and it is there's sort of like a prisoner's dilemma aspect to it where it makes sense if everybody just keeps their mouth shut.

1:54:11But if one guy speaks up, he's gonna put the story out there in his best light and

1:54:17so it kind of makes sense for everybody to talk and that makes that's what makes it so surprising that Apple has maintained

1:54:24Not to secrecy while you're working on stuff. I mean that's not that hard

1:54:27But even the fact that you know, five six seven eight years later people don't talk about Apple stuff is kind of impressive

1:54:34Well, we get like the book that would appeal to to me and maybe to other Apple nerds like you and everything would be

1:54:40because we get this like

1:54:41Ambiently where people will come off of come out of Apple and many years will pass and they'll tell you like more or less benign

1:54:48stories about, you know, what was that guy who had like the writer's block website who

1:54:53was, you know, worked on iDVD back in the day, what's that guy's name?

1:54:57Oh, I forget, but I know him.

1:55:00But it's so far removed now, and he's just gonna tell some like, you know, it's not gossip,

1:55:05but reasonably pleasant stories about like what it was like trying to deal with the iDVD

1:55:09intro, and even like, you know, Don Melton telling stories about, you know, they're not

1:55:14the type of thing that makes for sensational excerpts from books, but the accumulation

1:55:18of all those stories that either people publish or you hear at WWDC, they're not sensational

1:55:23in themselves, but you start to form a picture from the fringes, from each little person's

1:55:28anecdotes, like this little story and that little story and that little story, and you

1:55:30start to get sort of, like we have this outsider perspective where we know nothing, and now

1:55:35the shape is dimly visible underneath the black cloth, just from the accumulation of

1:55:39these nice stories from friendly people at WWDC or P.O.

1:55:42Pulsing, and it's so many years removed.

1:55:44At this point, do people remember what iDVD was?

1:55:47like the slot-loading IMAX. No one cares about that. So they feel safe in talking about that.

1:55:52If we can't get the big names to ever talk, if someone just collected up all the little names

1:56:0020 years away, you could make a nice sort of anthology.

1:56:03Isn't the IDVD story another one of those 30-second meetings with Steve Jobs?

1:56:08Isn't this story where they had all these complex mock-ups of different ways to do the design,

1:56:15And they were gonna present these all these mock-ups to Steve Jobs and he came in and went to the whiteboard drew a rectangle

1:56:21Said here's our interface you drag video here, and then there's a button at the bottom

1:56:26It says rip and then he'd like walked it just left he goes that yeah

1:56:29Yeah

1:56:30There's something along those lines and the other part of the story was like what it was like

1:56:33To be behind the scenes and responsible for making one of Steve's like old-style Mac world demos

1:56:39You know like right?

1:56:40You know, pre-OS 10, pre-iPhone, pre-everything,

1:56:43to make one of those demos go off without a hitch

1:56:45and everything that goes on behind the scenes.

1:56:47There was a recent story about that

1:56:49from some piece of software.

1:56:50Was that on a podcast recently, maybe?

1:56:53I don't know.

1:56:53What was it?

1:56:54There was some piece of software,

1:56:55and they were paranoid that it wasn't going to work,

1:56:57and they were drinking.

1:56:58From your podcast, they were drinking in the audience?

1:57:00No.

1:57:01That's the Fred Vogelstein story from the engineer

1:57:04at the original iPhone demo.

1:57:06Yeah, you must have talked about it on the talk show.

1:57:08Yeah.

1:57:08that they had a flask of scots that they were passing.

1:57:11- Yeah, 'cause it was like the odds of it getting through

1:57:13that the demo perfectly.

1:57:14And that's who you're gonna hear from,

1:57:16the guy who's like, his name's not on the marquee.

1:57:19He's not on the PR BIOS page,

1:57:22but he's the poor guy who's in charge

1:57:24of the particular application that Steve is demoing

1:57:26and it damn well better work.

1:57:27- And each time one of the guys,

1:57:29like the second or third row Apple guys,

1:57:32the engineers who'd been invited,

1:57:33each time your thing, the thing you had worked on,

1:57:36Like if you worked on mail, and when he got through

1:57:41the iPhone mail demo and it didn't crash,

1:57:44then you would just quick take the flask

1:57:46and be like, thank God almighty, I made it past my part.

1:57:50Mine wasn't the thing that blew up on stage.

1:57:52- Yeah, what I would like to hear from,

1:57:54like you get down to the level of like the stage,

1:57:57I don't know what you call the people,

1:57:58remember when you used to have things raise out of the stage

1:58:00and you always had to come up with like an elevator

1:58:02and stuff, if those things ever got stuck,

1:58:04they would be held to pay.

1:58:04So, you know, some guys do practice and bringing that thing up and down 20 times, making sure

1:58:08the little cloth doesn't fall off when it goes up and down, all that stuff.

1:58:15I remember somebody told me once that, and I'm sure they still do it because why would

1:58:18they stop, but that after the final rehearsal, which I, and again, I don't know if this is

1:58:26true. This is one of those things where who knows, but I've always heard that they do

1:58:29one the morning of the events, that there's like a same, you know, they rehearse the day

1:58:33day before all day until late at night, and then the morning they do a rehearsal. I don't

1:58:37know if that's true or not, but after the last rehearsal, a white glove team comes out

1:58:43and wipes everything down. The desks that the Demo Max are on, the Demo Max, everything.

1:58:51Everything gets wiped down with white gloves to factory-fresh, perfect status. The reason

1:59:00Why? Just because.

1:59:03Even just hearing that story makes me nervous that the guys wiping stuff down are going

1:59:06to bump a cable loose and screw up. We did the run-through. Everything went perfectly.

1:59:10What the hell happened? Well, the cleaning crew, one guy pulled out one pin of the dock

1:59:14connector slightly, and now everything's all screwed up.

1:59:17Yeah. I imagine those guys are like CSI crime lab delicate. Yeah, they're going to get every

1:59:25fingerprint off the glass, but they are using the least minimum pressure necessary to do

1:59:29I gotta do a third sponsor and I have a few other questions for you. I want to tell you about Igloo, long time sponsors of the show. Great, great service.

1:59:41If you don't remember what they are, they give you an internet that you'll actually

1:59:47like.

1:59:48You can share content quickly with the built-in apps for the internet.

1:59:53They have blogs, calendars, file sharing, forums, Twitter-like micro-blogs, wikis.

2:00:01Just think about what it would be like to have your own little private Twitter for your

2:00:04internet, for your company, your team that you know is private because it's on your own

2:00:09internet.

2:00:10you know, do anything silly like actually use Twitter but make up fake names or, you know,

2:00:14try to have your own, even if it's not confidential, just to sort of communicate privately.

2:00:19You have your own little thing. Be perfect. The whole thing is social. You can comment on any

2:00:27type of content. You can @ mention your co-workers, just like on Twitter, all of it private to your own

2:00:33team. You can follow content so you can get updates. They have tags to group things around

2:00:42the way you work. So you can use the same tag on a blog entry as on an event on the

2:00:48calendar and you can group them together by that tag. It's easy. The whole thing is drag

2:00:54and drop to configure to style. They have responsive designs that look great on every

2:01:00device from your phone to a 27 inch display. They have fonts from Typekit. I mean that's

2:01:06probably one of the best type libraries there is in the world. Here's the thing that's amazing.

2:01:11It is free to use. Igloo is free for up to 10 people. And when your Igloo grows, it only

2:01:18costs $12 a person for each month. Go to igloosoftware.com/the-talk-show. igloosoftware.com/the-talk-show.

2:01:29and you can find out more. So they mentioned tags in the igloo thing. So tags are a new

2:01:38feature in Mavericks and I had no idea. This is something I just wasn't paying attention

2:01:45until I read your review that they really are sort of piggybacked on the old labels.

2:01:54The labels feature that goes all the way back to System 7.

2:01:56Yeah, there has been this feature where you could apply a color with an associated word

2:02:03to a file forever, for ages.

2:02:06It makes you feel old when you talk to someone who thinks, "I think I heard someone say on

2:02:10a podcast or read somewhere..."

2:02:12I think they added those in Jaguar.

2:02:13It's like, "Oh, man."

2:02:15Anyway, there already is a feature that does that.

2:02:18And so it is very on-apple-like, despite what people think about them breaking with the

2:02:23past and doing these clean breaks.

2:02:24in terms of software compatibility, if there's already a feature that does that, and they

2:02:27already carried it across OS boundaries, bringing it from classic into OS X, like they brought

2:02:31it forward, you're going to make a new feature that gives you a new way to apply multiple

2:02:35colors and words to files. Not making it backward compatible in some way would just be weird

2:02:41and just not... Some people won't use labels at all, fine, but other people use them, like

2:02:45they put everything like the red ones are the ones I've got to work on next week, and

2:02:48I know when I change it it'll be blue, like they use them as an alternate way instead

2:02:52of arranging things in folders.

2:02:54And if you made this new system that was completely independent of that, it would not go over

2:02:59well.

2:03:00It would be like, "Well, now what do I use?

2:03:01I use labels or use tags.

2:03:02Do I have to go back to all my files that are labeled and tag them with the same color

2:03:05as the labels?"

2:03:06So it just makes sense from a user-friendliness and from an Apple philosophy of backward compatibility,

2:03:11especially for a feature that's lasted this long, to say, "All right, we'll build on it.

2:03:14It will be a superset.

2:03:15We can't totally make it up, because you can only have one label, but whatever the most

2:03:20recent tag you put will be the label. And as I explained in the review, the implementation

2:03:26details that I go into explain why it works this way. Why are there only seven labels?

2:03:31Why are the names independent of the colors? Why could I get into these weird scenarios

2:03:37when I copy it from one disk to the other? What happens if I change the name of a label

2:03:40that a million files are labeled with?

2:03:42Why do you not get to pick your own colors? You get to pick any of these seven colors,

2:03:46but you can't make your own mauve.

2:03:48- Yeah, although they could do that.

2:03:50Like they used to be able to change the colors,

2:03:52but like it's just, you see what it is,

2:03:53it's a number, one through six.

2:03:55Zero means no label, one through six is, you know,

2:03:57here are things that you get to pick from.

2:03:59And once you understand the implementation,

2:04:02then you're like, oh, I see how the behavior

2:04:04falls out of the implementation.

2:04:06And why do they use that implementation?

2:04:08Well, because it allows it to be backward compatible

2:04:10with the existing labels.

2:04:11And why do the using labels use this crazy ass implementation?

2:04:14'Cause they're from like 1988, that's why.

2:04:16So it all connects back and it's all,

2:04:19it gives an explanation of the feature

2:04:21that it would be difficult to understand

2:04:24what the hell's going on

2:04:25without knowing these internal details.

2:04:26'Cause otherwise it might seem like

2:04:27either poorly implemented feature or nonsensical

2:04:30or why does it work this way or it seems silly,

2:04:32but there are reasons for it.

2:04:33- And I guess the other way that it looks,

2:04:36if you don't know the story behind it,

2:04:37what makes it seem weird are the default tags,

2:04:40which are color names, red, blue, yellow.

2:04:44It just seems like an odd batch of defaults.

2:04:47- Well, you remember what the old defaults were?

2:04:49- Hot, essential.

2:04:51- Yeah, yeah, right.

2:04:52Like I threw one of the, I see a couple of those in there.

2:04:53I think I threw an essential in there or whatever.

2:04:55Like they were so weird.

2:04:57Like I would love to be in the meeting,

2:04:58like we're gonna have default names for the labels

2:05:00and what should we call them?

2:05:01- I just remember hot and essential.

2:05:02- Yeah, no, exactly.

2:05:04What's the difference?

2:05:05We should go look that up right now.

2:05:07- You should, dude.

2:05:08I do forget that.

2:05:10I get any other thing too with this new implementation

2:05:14And tags to me are way more interesting.

2:05:16I haven't used labels in years.

2:05:19I anticipate using tags quite a bit.

2:05:22But I don't think, I think they've built this

2:05:24on top of labels.

2:05:25And if on the converse, you're the type of person

2:05:28who used labels and you wanna keep using labels

2:05:30and you don't really wanna use tags per se,

2:05:32you just wanna use the labels you always used,

2:05:35it doesn't really set you back any.

2:05:37I mean, I think a little bit in terms of,

2:05:39the only thing I could think of is if you really wanna

2:05:42just use it the way you always used it and you don't like the new the new way

2:05:46you have to unlabel before you relabel to get rid of you know yeah because

2:05:54otherwise you'll be adding yeah otherwise you're just adding so you have

2:05:57some water the old hit one extra click to take off the old label when you want

2:06:02to change it from hot to essential and the little words that little tool tip

2:06:06of everything's trying to tell you what's going on like add label this it

2:06:09make it clear that what you're going to do isn't what you thought. So here are the old

2:06:12labels. Essential, hot, in progress, cool, personal, project one, project two. What the

2:06:18hell is there in between hot and cool? Essential, hot and cool, like they could all mean the

2:06:22same thing. Essential was orange, hot was red, in progress, purple, cool is like an

2:06:26ice blue, personal was navy blue, project one green, and project two brown. This is

2:06:31all based on my Mac emulator.

2:06:33What did they even mean by hot? Hot like the boss wants this now. This is hot.

2:06:39hot issue, or is it hot like sexy? Oh, man, that's hot.

2:06:43Yeah, and the thing is, if you go to control panels labels, like I'm running system seven

2:06:47in the simulator to look this up, but you could change the names of them. And you could

2:06:50change the colors too. You click on the color, you can make them any color you want. And

2:06:53it's like, what the hell do they care? And you could drive yourself crazy, because if

2:06:56you decide to change label number one to be important, and you make it red, and you copy

2:07:02that file to your friend's Mac, this is back in the system seven days, and their label

2:07:06number one is purple and it's called trash, then suddenly your file comes over and it's

2:07:13like, "Oh, find the file with the red label, but it's not red on my machine." All these

2:07:17problems always existed in terms of who has the central index of what color and what label

2:07:21and what word and all this other stuff. All they have is three bits inside a field inside

2:07:26H of S plus and then a mapping of those, a local mapping of those two words. And now

2:07:31they kind of have the same thing, but they also have this binary property list XML thing

2:07:35that contains the list of labels, and what do they put in the list? A word and a number,

2:07:39separated by a new line for some crazy-ass reason.

2:07:41Yeah, I saw that, too. That was weird. That is really weird. I cannot—I sat there—and

2:07:47that was one of those things, because, you know, that's like the exact sort of, like,

2:07:53programming task that I can fully comprehend. I understand an XML file. I can—and you

2:07:59said, like, I can't think of a reason why they would do this. And I said, I thought,

2:08:02Well, there's a puzzle.

2:08:03Let's think about this.

2:08:04There's got to be a good reason.

2:08:06And I sat there for like 10 minutes,

2:08:07and I cannot think of why it's not a separate string

2:08:12and integer.

2:08:14It could be like cutting the ends off the roast,

2:08:16where it's just like it's something that-- or not even

2:08:19like that.

2:08:21When you're writing a project and like,

2:08:23oh, I've got to add this thing quickly,

2:08:24and I'll change it later, and you don't,

2:08:26and it just ends up shipping that way.

2:08:30Not that you're gonna wanna have new lines

2:08:32in your label name, but it's right there in front of you.

2:08:36You have a way to store the number and the name.

2:08:39It's sitting there, you're in a property list, right?

2:08:41And they go with the new line.

2:08:43- And it just sticks out when you're looking

2:08:47at an XML file and you're just used to everything

2:08:51being tagged and then all of a sudden

2:08:54you see something new line separated like it's a whole--

2:08:56- It looks all ugly in the dump.

2:08:57So here's a theory I can think of is that

2:08:59It might have to do with spotlight indexing.

2:09:02Maybe the text parser that parses out--

2:09:04because they want to spotlight index all these labels,

2:09:06but they don't want to have separate extended attributes.

2:09:08They want to have one extended attribute, I guess,

2:09:10that you can pull in because it's like underscore KMD

2:09:14label, the tag name.

2:09:15They have those K constants that apply in spotlight.

2:09:18You know what those mean when you do the advanced searches.

2:09:21Every one of those has a constant.

2:09:22It looks like a constant from the classic Mac days

2:09:24with a leading lowercase K. And if you

2:09:27were going to write a query, a spotlight query,

2:09:29You could say where essentially file name contains this and date modified is this.

2:09:34Each one of those things, file name, date modified, label, has a single symbolic name

2:09:38that corresponds to where the thing is.

2:09:40So all of the tags are in a single one of those.

2:09:42That's why they're all in one big property list instead of having separate extended attributes.

2:09:45So you can do where one of the labels is hot and one of the labels is like KMD label whatever

2:09:54thing.

2:09:55It will pull that whole property list out.

2:09:56Maybe it's pulling that property list out

2:09:58and parsing it as pulling out the text parts

2:10:02and parsing it as free text as if it was number,

2:10:05new line, name, new line.

2:10:07And they couldn't use spaces because then if the names

2:10:09probably could have spaces but they used new lines.

2:10:11Like I'm just making stuff up here.

2:10:12But there are semi-reasonable reasons

2:10:15why they wanted to leverage the existing architecture

2:10:17for simply indexing text content to files

2:10:20and it makes it easier if they have them this way.

2:10:21But it sure as hell looks weird.

2:10:23And it's one of those decisions that's like,

2:10:24Well, once you've done that, you are creating tons and tons of files with extended attributes

2:10:29filled with this exact property list, and so you're forever doomed to have to support

2:10:33that weird format and backward compatibility.

2:10:36My only thought was that it was just some lazy programmer who one day, like you said,

2:10:40maybe he thought he'd get back to it and fix it, but that it was just easier to just, he's

2:10:45got the two values, it was easier to just concatenate the two strings together and separate

2:10:50it with a new line because think in your head, will there ever be a new line in the actual

2:10:54name, no. It probably, I'm almost certain it guards against it, even if you paste it in text that had a new line as the tag name, it almost certainly, I'll bet, strips that. So you're never going to get an actual new line there so you can do it and it was easier, you know.

2:11:11Like it could have been the names weren't in there originally originally was just the numbers, right?

2:11:15And then they said oh we need to put the names there too because we're not gonna have you know

2:11:18The problem I just described where one person names at one thing. We're gonna put the names in there, too

2:11:21Alright, we'll just throw it in with a new line and the thing and I can parse that decision talk about things

2:11:27You're not gonna see a book written about it, you know, you're in that guy

2:11:30Here's the here's the thing you didn't mention that jumped out at me about tags right in the keynote at WWDC is

2:11:39why are they adding tags to files now? And to me, I think it's clearly driven by

2:11:48iCloud and the sandbox, because now, only now with tags, can you easily group

2:11:57related documents together, even if they're all from iCloud sandbox apps. So

2:12:06So you could take a text edit app or a file and--

2:12:11thinking of other sandbox apps-- preview

2:12:14and give them the same tag.

2:12:17And now in the Finder, they show up

2:12:19in the same tag sidebar location.

2:12:22Yeah, even if you go further in that,

2:12:24I would say the whole fact that you

2:12:26can have documents in the cloud, but you only

2:12:27get one level of folders.

2:12:29Now finally, you can have multiple levels of hierarchy.

2:12:31You don't get to call them folders.

2:12:33You get to call them labels.

2:12:34you can slice and dice things into better because if you are trying to keep all your

2:12:38documents like with the documents in the cloud and using applications that do that, just

2:12:41having one level of folders eventually starts to get crazy. So now tags give you one more

2:12:46organizational tool. And yes, of course, also across applications. But the thing about the

2:12:49cross application things is that the only tool that can cross cut that thing is the

2:12:55finder. Within the individual iOS or Mac sandbox iCloud documents and without applications,

2:13:01You can't ask them to show you anything.

2:13:02It's only the Finder and the Finder itself and an OpenSave dialog box that's not looking

2:13:09at iCloud documents but is looking at your disk.

2:13:11Those are the only things where you can say, "Show me all the things from the Jones project,"

2:13:15and it will find them across all the applications.

2:13:17And even on the Mac, I think it might try to hide them because they're in the iCloud

2:13:20container things.

2:13:21But if you're sufficiently resourceful, and maybe it exposes...

2:13:23Do you know if it exposes that?

2:13:24Like, you know where the documents really are in your Mac, where they're in the thing?

2:13:27Yeah.

2:13:28Because you go in a sidebar to the tags, and you click a tag that has some files to it.

2:13:35And then you can go, it'll show you those files, and then you can control click on it

2:13:39and say, "Show an enclosing folder."

2:13:42And it's the crazy iCloud document container somewhere under your library folder, right?

2:13:45Yeah, exactly.

2:13:46So for example, text edit documents are users group or library/mobile documents/com~apple~textedit/documents.

2:14:02I don't know why they use tildes instead of dots.

2:14:06That doesn't make any sense. But all the apps are like that in the library/mobile documents folder.

2:14:11That's where your iCloud sandboxes are.

2:14:14But you can get there very easily through the finder just by going to the tag

2:14:19Collection in the sidebar and then

2:14:23Control clicking and say show in enclosing

2:14:26Yeah

2:14:27Or you just show the like there's the thing lets you see the the bottom bar and a finder window that shows you the path

2:14:31With the little folders the arrows between them. Yeah. Yeah, does it show you that too? I don't know

2:14:37there's a way to get it to display show show the path view path or whatever, but

2:14:42Yeah, it's it's they haven't solved that problem of the siloed documents and tags tags give you one more tool

2:14:49But it makes it I think it makes it all the more apparent like you're in these little islands when you're in the application

2:14:53Only the finder could see them all and then there's no equivalent of the finder on iOS where you could see

2:14:57Yeah, all the various pieces across all that

2:14:59They still have to figure out what they're gonna do there

2:15:01But it tags is like it was sitting there like they spent so many years

2:15:04Building up to this and they implemented extended attributes and use them so extensively and all the other features

2:15:09And it's like once you've got extended attributes, like that's the first thing everybody else,

2:15:12all the third parties did with them.

2:15:13Remember all the tagging apps that are out there?

2:15:15I've had tons of them over the years.

2:15:16So they would be like, "We don't need to implement this.

2:15:18It's part of the OS.

2:15:19You can attach arbitrary data to any file.

2:15:22All we need is an application that can create the data and interpret it."

2:15:25So tons of finder-like organization applications would say, "Here you go.

2:15:29Use our application and you can apply tags to your files and organize your stuff according

2:15:33to them."

2:15:34And tags have advantages over folders because a file can only be in one folder according

2:15:37because there are rules the way we do things, but you can apply multiple tags.

2:15:40It's kind of the difference between Gmail and, you know, Apple Mail and why

2:15:44they don't get along in terms of, you know, tag, you know. So it was right there

2:15:48for them to do. It's kind of like tabs in the Finder. It's right there. Like tabs

2:15:51are on the browsers. Apple knows how to make tabs. Why are there no tabs in the

2:15:55Finder browser? Especially, you know, and again we could do a whole three-hour show

2:15:59just on the Finder, but especially with the the fact that the OS X Finder is

2:16:06is naturally a browser, not a, you know, it worked.

2:16:11That's just how it clearly is meant to work,

2:16:14not the old spatial thing.

2:16:17- It's kind of half-heartedly a browser,

2:16:18but it's like, yeah, if you're gonna do a browser,

2:16:20we know that tabs are useful in browsers,

2:16:22and it's like you didn't get around to it.

2:16:24So they got around to tabs, they got around to tags.

2:16:27- Tabs still aren't a standard cocoa thing, though, are they?

2:16:33Like, there's no way, like, even though it seems

2:16:35it's using the same tabs as Safari and Terminal. But actually, Terminal uses totally different

2:16:43tabs still, even on just the look and feel of the tabs.

2:16:48Well, yeah, they're never standardized. I mean, remember Toppy Tabs?

2:16:52Yeah, Toppy Tabs.

2:16:55Safari 4, briefly.

2:16:57Right.

2:16:57Like, you know, there's tabs across all applications. Apple has kind of decided

2:17:03decided that they're vaguely, they're not metallic, they used to be rush metal, but

2:17:07they're dark gray and they come down and they have little rounded corners and this little

2:17:11plus sign to make new ones. But it's probably not a standard control because...

2:17:17**Matt Stauffer** No, it's definitely not a standard control

2:17:18because...

2:17:19**Matt Stauffer** Well, I wonder if Apple shares the code, like

2:17:21between their three Apple...

2:17:22**Matt Stauffer** Well, here's one thing I noticed, is you pointed

2:17:24out that the new Safari in Mavericks has a feature that it seems to have learned from

2:17:33Chrome where as you're closing tabs, it won't change the width of the remaining tabs until

2:17:40you're done closing them, which enables you to sit there and just click, click, click without

2:17:45moving the mouse. But the Finder tabs don't do that. The Finder tabs act like it's like

2:17:50they copied the old implementation from Safari,

2:17:53where each time you close a tab, the remaining tabs

2:17:55resize to fit the width.

2:17:57So if they're sharing code, they shared the code

2:18:01from the old Safari, not the new one.

2:18:03And even in Safari, it only does that

2:18:05until all the tabs to your right are gone.

2:18:07And then it says, oh, it's safe for me to resize.

2:18:09Right, because you don't get the benefit of the click, click,

2:18:12click, click, click.

2:18:13Right.

2:18:13Whereas at Chrome, because partially due to the fact

2:18:17that Chrome's closed box is on the right edge of the tab,

2:18:20It will, even when you have no more tabs remaining

2:18:22on your right side, it will still not resize the tab.

2:18:25So you can click it again and close the tab

2:18:28that you were over to begin with.

2:18:29And then it will slide the other tabs

2:18:30that are now to your left, and it will put the closed box,

2:18:32like Chrome's implementation is still better.

2:18:34Like they had more time to work this out.

2:18:36So Apple copied it, and I can't think of a reason

2:18:39why they wouldn't have copied that thing,

2:18:40except for the fact that their closed boxes

2:18:42are on the wrong side, and it may be more awkward.

2:18:44Like Chrome will totally try to put a closed box

2:18:46under your cursor for as long as it possibly reasonably can.

2:18:48Whereas Safari, after you've closed all the tabs

2:18:51to your right, it gives up trying to put a closed box

2:18:53under your cursor, which is a minor thing

2:18:55in the grand scheme of things,

2:18:56because people use Command + W or whatever.

2:18:58But it's a neat feature of Chrome

2:19:00that they were wise to copy,

2:19:02even if they copied it kind of not in part.

2:19:05- Oh, I never noticed that before.

2:19:06I just played with it.

2:19:07So I see what you mean.

2:19:08There's two different resizings of the tabs in Chrome.

2:19:12There's one when you have finished closing

2:19:15all the rightmost tabs.

2:19:17Then an intermediate one where it'll resize the leftmost ones

2:19:22just to put the next one's close box under your mouse.

2:19:29And then when you're done completely

2:19:31and move the mouse away, it'll resize to fill the window.

2:19:35Yeah, and by the way, the same feature

2:19:36is in Safari 6.1 on Mountain Lion.

2:19:39Like, 6.1 is kind of like the Safari 7 for Mountain Lion

2:19:42users.

2:19:43Like, a lot of these things, even the power

2:19:44everything that doesn't run the flash stuff and the plugins and everything, came back,

2:19:50which is nice. They don't always do that. You don't always like, "Oh, well, you're running

2:19:54Mountain Lion. You're not going to get the cool new features." They basically gave everyone

2:19:56running Mountain Lion 75% of Safari 7, including these nice little UI things.

2:20:03I always complain. One of the things I complain about in Chrome is the fact that the closed

2:20:06boxes are on the right side of the tabs. I feel like because on the Mac, I know this

2:20:11is like a Windows Mac thing, but on the Mac,

2:20:13close has always been left.

2:20:16And to me, a tab is close enough to being

2:20:19like its own little docked window that it should--

2:20:23a tab should be like a window, and the close

2:20:24should be in the left.

2:20:25And I've had people argue with me

2:20:27that with the close on the left, then you

2:20:30couldn't get this tap, tap, tap to close tabs.

2:20:34But that doesn't--

2:20:35It's harder.

2:20:36Because you can see, watch when Chrome starts resizing the ones

2:20:38to your left.

2:20:39It's easier for it to put the next closed box

2:20:42under your thing.

2:20:42It doesn't have to slide everything way over.

2:20:44Like, it's a little bit easier for it to work out.

2:20:45Right.

2:20:46But that's not a good reason to put the close on it, right?

2:20:50I mean, I use Chrome so much, I don't mind it too much.

2:20:52The thing that bothers me about Chrome

2:20:54is the giant fav icons and the--

2:20:56Yeah.

2:20:57So I'm hoping-- I've been hoping for years it's

2:21:00one of my little, like, annual things

2:21:02that I hope to see at WWDC.

2:21:04But I keep waiting for AppKit to get standard-- it's just,

2:21:08you know, tabs.

2:21:09And I feel like the tabs that they should take are Safaris.

2:21:12I think Safaris are the best.

2:21:13They're better than the Finders,

2:21:15and they're way better than the ones in Terminal.

2:21:18Terminal ones are just a little weird.

2:21:22- Yeah, I mean, I just feel like the trend is away from tabs

2:21:24even though we're all can't live without them

2:21:27and they're adding them back to things on the Mac.

2:21:29Like, I mean, I don't know.

2:21:30I guess they added tabs to Safari and iOS.

2:21:33- Right. - You know,

2:21:34and they made the crazy new updated version of the tabs

2:21:36where the progress bar is a little blue line

2:21:37in the bottom of the tab, you know, in iOS 7.

2:21:39Like, they're still experimenting.

2:21:42It seems like they're still in the experimental phase

2:21:44with tabs because, yeah, I don't know.

2:21:47Like, they're a weird mix.

2:21:48So many features that we like to use

2:21:50are not used by regular people using their Macs,

2:21:53but tabs are pretty universal.

2:21:56Like, no matter how novice you are,

2:21:58once you see how tabs work, people,

2:22:00maybe it's because there's a relation to paper tabs

2:22:02that used to exist way back in the day.

2:22:03Like, they get it, they use them.

2:22:05And it's not like a power user feature.

2:22:08It's like super advanced.

2:22:09People use tabs.

2:22:11Everybody uses tabs.

2:22:12So even though they make things much more complicated,

2:22:15they make us lose track of where the hell things are,

2:22:16and in the worst case, they make us not

2:22:18know where the hell that sound is coming from,

2:22:20because it's coming from one of the freaking tabs

2:22:22that you can't find.

2:22:23They get used.

2:22:23Am I misremembering this from the last time

2:22:26I tinkered with it?

2:22:26But I think Chromebooks are just tabbed.

2:22:29I don't even think they have Windows.

2:22:31I think everything is-- I think it's the whole metaphor.

2:22:34Chromebook, the Chromebook OS, Chrome OS is tabs. But if not, if not, it's clearly

2:22:41how they intend people to use it. If you can have multiple windows, most of the

2:22:45time you're just opening tabs. Yeah, I've seen a Chromebook once in real life and

2:22:48I just realized I don't think I ever used the software. I think it just played

2:22:51with the hardware because it was a Chromebook pixel. I know it's the show's

2:22:55already been long and we could go forever on this, but quickly, what do you,

2:22:59what do you think, do you think that that the next version of Mac OS X is going

2:23:04to get a iOS 7, not that it would look like iOS 7, but iOS 7-esque or sized visual refresh.

2:23:15I think it's probably due for one, if not in this release, then the next one.

2:23:20What it needs more than a radical refresh of the look is they've got to finish the job

2:23:27that they started with, like, you know, D iOS 6-ing everything, right?

2:23:31Yeah.

2:23:32Because they just scrape stuff off of the application.

2:23:34need to go back to those applications. If you really care about these applications,

2:23:40give each of those built-in apps a thorough redesign. And as part of that process, maybe

2:23:45you come up with some new UI ideas for the whole OS. But a lot about OS X, again, it's

2:23:52an older OS and it's gone through more changes. We're out of the iOS 6 level awkward phase.

2:24:00We did that with brush metal and pinstripes and teal things and lozenges.

2:24:06We did that in the drawers and everything.

2:24:08And we came out the other side in Leopard with the unified single window appearance,

2:24:11which still doesn't look bad.

2:24:13It looks good and everything.

2:24:16We had that time where it was like, have an original idea and take that idea to its logical

2:24:23conclusion like they did with iOS 6 and say, "Okay, now it's time for a new idea."

2:24:27And that reset was around 10.5.

2:24:28So I don't know if we're due for, "Oh, you've got to change how the menu bar works.

2:24:32You've got to change how all those standard window tile bars look, because the old one

2:24:35doesn't look good anymore."

2:24:37It's fine, right?

2:24:39It could be tweaked in a subtle way, but what they do need to do is rethink all the applications

2:24:43that have been through this terrible trauma of being made to look exactly like their iOS

2:24:476 counterparts and have not fully recovered for them, and finish the job of address game

2:24:51center and all the other things that still look like they used to before, and make those

2:24:55applications better.

2:24:58They give so much attention to Safari,

2:24:59'cause I pointed out in the review,

2:25:00it's such an important application,

2:25:01like the web browser, right?

2:25:03But they continue to ship mail and reminders and notes,

2:25:07and those applications are not best of breed, right?

2:25:10They don't show Apple in a great light,

2:25:11and especially even with the whole thing with mail

2:25:13not working well with Gmail

2:25:15because of the various changes there.

2:25:17They're trying to make it better, but they screwed it up.

2:25:20I don't know anyone who's ever used mail.

2:25:22I would never use mail with Gmail.

2:25:24I have no experience in any past versions.

2:25:26Current, past, future, it's just a bad idea,

2:25:27because they don't get along.

2:25:29- Yeah, I do, and it's only,

2:25:32I think it's almost because I'm nerdy enough,

2:25:36and email nerdy enough, that I understand the way

2:25:42that they don't match up metaphorically.

2:25:46And so, because I understand it,

2:25:47I purposefully work around it.

2:25:50So I don't, I know, and I think this is one of the things

2:25:53that people are running into with the Mavericks mail,

2:25:57where it's like if you've turned off the all mail folder

2:26:02to the IMAP interface in Gmail, as everybody who I know

2:26:06who uses Gmail through IMAP has done,

2:26:08so you don't get two of every email when you search for them,

2:26:13then when you hit the Archive button,

2:26:14things just disappear and reappear in your inbox and stuff.

2:26:17So I just never hit Mails Archive.

2:26:19I don't archive in mail.

2:26:20I have--

2:26:21But there's new bugs in Mavericks

2:26:23where even if you follow the best practices,

2:26:25either follow Google's guidelines of the old ones or Apple's with the new ones, you'll

2:26:28get into a situation where you'll receive new mail and it will not appear even in your

2:26:32inbox on the Mac, but it will appear in the web UI, regardless of whether you have all

2:26:36mail off like the old way or all mail on like the new way.

2:26:39Like it's just full of bugs and stuff.

2:26:41That stuff reflects badly on Apple and makes the Mac look bad, and so it needs to be addressed.

2:26:45And in the process of addressing those, you can have some new ideas about UI and you can

2:26:49kind of use it.

2:26:50Remember iTunes used to be like a leading indicator where they might possibly be thinking

2:26:53about going in terms of UI.

2:26:55And it never really was.

2:26:56We never got the iTunes 7 scroll bars.

2:26:58The scroll bars we got in, what was it, Lion or whatever,

2:27:00they turned into the little thin graphite sort of lozenges.

2:27:04Those didn't look like the iTunes one,

2:27:05but iTunes was like, let's think about some things

2:27:07that we can do there, right?

2:27:09So I think the applications are a place

2:27:11to experiment with like that.

2:27:12And the OS is due for, I mean, you know,

2:27:1510.5 was the big, you know, we ran up to 10.5

2:27:17and did a reset, and now we're gonna run up to 10.10

2:27:20and do a reset.

2:27:21It's kind of about that time,

2:27:23And it could totally use with one,

2:27:24but I think it's more important.

2:27:25I would be perfectly fine if they just really gave

2:27:28the application some attention,

2:27:29and then just put a nice subtle revision of all the UI

2:27:33of just looking a little bit different,

2:27:34'cause that's enough.

2:27:35Like there's nothing, there's no equivalent

2:27:37in the current version of OS X that is equivalent

2:27:41to all of the skeuomorphic stuff that was in iOS 6.

2:27:43It's not gaudy and embarrassing, you know what I mean?

2:27:45Just look at a title bar of a standard Mac window.

2:27:48- Right.

2:27:48- You know, maybe the little lozenges

2:27:50look a little bit dated, but we're not looking at,

2:27:51you know, wood and felt and linen here.

2:27:54- I've been wondering if,

2:27:56if Lucida Grand, Grandi,

2:28:01I don't even know how you pronounce it.

2:28:02Lucida Grand is--

2:28:03- Grande, like when you order from Starbucks?

2:28:05- Yeah, Grande,

2:28:05is gonna go, was gonna be, you know, shown the door once,

2:28:12you know, the Mac is a mostly retina platform,

2:28:16which I still don't think,

2:28:17I think it's gonna be a while before it's,

2:28:18Mac is mostly retina devices.

2:28:21because I just don't think it looks that good as a real font.

2:28:25I think it was a nice choice as a screen font

2:28:28and it went rendered well on non-retina screens

2:28:30better than most fonts do.

2:28:32But there's a reason, like I've said before on the show,

2:28:35there's a reason why you don't see people using Lucida Grande

2:28:39in real documents in print design and stuff,

2:28:42because it's not a great font, it isn't.

2:28:45- Well, there's something to be said for using a font

2:28:47that people wouldn't use in content

2:28:50to distinguish the UI from the content.

2:28:52Right, that is true.

2:28:53And I've talked about this with a lot of people,

2:28:56that there is something to me that's a little--

2:29:00as a longtime Mac user, I've always seen the system font

2:29:03that way, going all the way back to the Chicago,

2:29:06and then what was the next one?

2:29:09Charcoal.

2:29:10What did you do?

2:29:11Did you use charcoal, or did you revert to Chicago?

2:29:14Remember, you used to have that option.

2:29:15There was like, SP Sands in there, wasn't there?

2:29:18Yeah.

2:29:19Talk about things Apple would never do anymore.

2:29:21You used to get a choice for your system font.

2:29:23- Oh yeah, you could use BrushScript.

2:29:25Remember that?

2:29:26It's like, yeah, the theming days.

2:29:28You know, I always went with,

2:29:29when they changed the default from Chicago,

2:29:31I said, "I'm just gonna go with it.

2:29:32"I'm gonna go with what they picked."

2:29:33- Even though I didn't like the lowercase R.

2:29:36But I did that.

2:29:39I went with it.

2:29:39But it was always a font.

2:29:40Chicago and Charcoal were always these sort of,

2:29:43almost like a semi-bold font.

2:29:46It was not bold enough to be bold,

2:29:48but bolder than a regular font, but it made, you know,

2:29:52it took up two pixels in a lot of places where instead of one, and it looked good on

2:29:56those low-res screens. But there was always a very, very

2:30:00visceral, to me, difference between the UI font

2:30:04and the content fonts. Yeah, although it was made weird

2:30:08by the fact that, like, so the reason Chicago looked the way it did is because

2:30:12they had to gray out menu items in the original Mac, and you can't gray things out when you have a

2:30:16black and white screen.

2:30:17So they had to make every single letter big enough

2:30:19so you could knock out every other pixel

2:30:21in a checkerboard pattern and you could still read the words.

2:30:23- Right. - Right?

2:30:24And so that's fine.

2:30:25And that also meant that they had to use Chicago

2:30:28as like, for like long freeform text

2:30:30where they wouldn't use Lucida Grande right now,

2:30:33like a dialogue that explains stuff,

2:30:35they would use that system font as well.

2:30:37And you just did not want to read a paragraph of Chicago.

2:30:40It's like it was never something that you would want to do.

2:30:42It just looked awkward, but they had to do it

2:30:43because what if you had to gray out that text or something?

2:30:45You know, it just uses a system font.

2:30:47And when they went with the new fonts like charcoal and stuff, they didn't need to do

2:30:50that pixel thing anymore.

2:30:51Like, they had grayscale, but they somehow felt like, well, a system font is something

2:30:56that looks big and chunky.

2:30:57And so those fonts were also big and chunky, and like Lucida is like moving—it's not

2:31:02as thin as Helvetica, but you know, it's finally shedding that kind of "I've got big fat forearms"

2:31:07kind of look of the fonts, right?

2:31:09It doesn't look like that.

2:31:10It looks like I'm kind of svelte and thin, but I'm also kind of like bold and I look

2:31:14like a label.

2:31:15labeling something. I'm not a headline, I'm not body text, I'm a UI font. So I don't mind

2:31:21it that much, and I don't know what they would replace it with. I fear a new replacement.

2:31:27That seems too wimpy for me for a Mac. It seems right for a handheld, especially with

2:31:31iOS 7, it totally fits there with that aesthetic, but I feel like the Mac should be beefier.

2:31:36I'm glad that it's still there. I'm glad that it still has a system font. I thought it was

2:31:42interesting you pointed out in your review that they actually are new. This is what I

2:31:46was getting at is that they actually have like new Lucida Grande font files in Mavericks

2:31:52that are retina optimized. And I think that some of the features in there, there's like

2:31:57kerning pairs and stuff like that which they actually Lucida Grande never had before.

2:32:06It was...

2:32:07Yeah. Well, the whole texture system got a revision to much better handle like ligatures

2:32:11and all the other stuff, you know, in regular text stuff.

2:32:13And, but, but above and beyond that, which I would have liked to put a section in

2:32:16the review about that, but I didn't know enough about the details about how they

2:32:19changed the tech system and it's like, you know, I don't know how much people

2:32:22would care, but changing the system font, like above and beyond the changes of

2:32:25Texas, they made a special new variant of the font.

2:32:29Like if you pick Lucida Grande in the, as we pronounce this font name, seven

2:32:33different ways in the same podcast.

2:32:34If you pick that font and text edit and type with it, you are not typing with

2:32:37the same one they use to draw the menus.

2:32:39Because at least as of WWDC, and I think this is still the case,

2:32:43they have a specially tweaked version for when

2:32:45Apple uses it in the UI.

2:32:47In fact, I think it used to actually show up

2:32:49in the font picker with some weird name.

2:32:51So it's like two different things.

2:32:53And I think that's appropriate, because the application

2:32:56of a font as your UI thing, even if you found exactly the font

2:32:59you wanted, you always want to just do,

2:33:01well, I'm going to tweak it in ways that only makes sense when

2:33:04it's like a menu bar and a menu item.

2:33:05But you would not want to write it

2:33:07if you're using a page layout program

2:33:09in this particular font.

2:33:11- Right.

2:33:12Yeah, like you said, they're labels, you know?

2:33:14And a label font is different than a reading font.

2:33:17- Did you follow that link?

2:33:18Like one guy, after I posted my review,

2:33:19one guy actually figured out what the differences were

2:33:22and posted this big long blog post.

2:33:23Go find that part of my review and click on like the,

2:33:26whatever that means, text.

2:33:28Because I didn't know, like, you know,

2:33:29and I asked Apple, I didn't know what it meant

2:33:31and I asked Apple, like, I know you changed the font

2:33:33and you said it's optimized for rendering display.

2:33:35Like what does that mean?

2:33:35And it's like, well, it means they didn't give me any specific deal.

2:33:40So here's this guy who said, OK, I'm going to pull up the fonts in my editor.

2:33:43And he shows exactly how they changed the letter forms for this thing

2:33:46versus the old one.

2:33:48All right, I'm going to link it up.

2:33:50Oh, whatever that means.

2:33:51There we go.

2:33:52I mean, look at that.

2:33:53Some of the changes-- like the guy said, some of the changes

2:33:55make sense and see why they do it.

2:33:56Other changes, it's like, was that a mistake?

2:33:58Or did they just forget to change it?

2:33:59It's weird.

2:34:00I saw the Stephen Cole's post on the typographic guy, but I did not see this.

2:34:08Yeah, here we go.

2:34:09Great.

2:34:10I love this guy.

2:34:12All right.

2:34:14Let's call it a show.

2:34:15Let's get to bed.

2:34:16JAYLEE MUSIAL Yeah, Jeez.

2:34:17I don't have the last time even.

2:34:18DAVE SMITH John Siracusa, thank you so much.

2:34:21People can go.

2:34:22They can read your review.

2:34:23I mean, I can't believe if you haven't, shame on you if you haven't already read it, but

2:34:26it's at Ars Technica.

2:34:29Just type in Ars Technica Mavericks review in your local Google.

2:34:33Anyway, you'll get to it.

2:34:34I always like to be able to type my last name in Mavericks.

2:34:38Type Syracuse in Mavericks.

2:34:39I want my result to be the top one.

2:34:41Sometimes it isn't, but yeah.

2:34:42Oh, yeah.

2:34:43How could that not be the top result?

2:34:44Yeah.

2:34:45I'll eat my hat off that side.

2:34:46I see SEO, man.

2:34:47SEO.

2:34:48Syracuse in Maverick.

2:34:49Mavericks.

2:34:50That's what I've always called you in my mind.

2:34:53Maverick.

2:34:54Yeah, it's the first hit.

2:34:55All right.

2:34:56But anyway, you can find it.

2:34:57It's off the front page of ours by this point.

2:34:59That's how old it is.

2:35:00- Yeah, but it's on the first page of our hearts.