0:00:00So, anyway, have you ever noticed—Ben Thompson joining me this week on the talk show—do
0:00:05you ever notice there's some websites where the username and password don't get autofilled?
0:00:11Ben: Yeah, I think usually it's the website's fault. Like, mislabel the field or something.
0:00:15Pete: Yeah, and it's not like the thing where certain financial sites have an opt-out
0:00:21thing. It's like a site where there's nothing really super confidential about it. It should
0:00:26work, it just doesn't.
0:00:27Yeah. Well, I'm still scarred from the whole like, they've had auto complete for just like addresses, like when you're buying something. And I swear those never worked for like the first three years. And maybe they work today, but I will never know because I refuse to use them.
0:00:42Well, you don't use the auto
0:00:44I still tabbing through every field, which then brings me to the even worse annoyance when they have the fields in the wrong order in your tab selling lands you on the bottom of the page.
0:00:53The credit card thing works perfectly for me. I can't remember the last time that the credit
0:00:58card autofill didn't work. But the password thing drives me nuts. And sometimes I think it's because
0:01:05it's like I've already saved a password for www.example.com. But right now, I'm on store.example.com.
0:01:16And so it doesn't see it as the same website and doesn't fill it in. I don't even know. And then
0:01:22other times I think it's like you said like they don't have the password field
0:01:25correctly labeled as a password field like yeah I don't know I I've used I
0:01:30mean I've used one password for a long time but the funny thing is funny thing
0:01:34is I actually rarely use it because I have this you know this super convoluted
0:01:39system for for passwords that you know involves like a a seed a random string
0:01:46shifting your your fingers like two things over on the keyboard explain it
0:01:51Explain it in detail for us.
0:01:52Well, no, it was basically it's it I actually don't mind. I feel
0:01:57pretty I mean, I should never say that some of the actually
0:02:00I'm not gonna say anything as for those that listen to ATP and
0:02:03Casey's showbot know that challenging, challenging tech
0:02:08listeners to do anything is not a good idea. But it's quite
0:02:13convoluted. It takes it would take me like 10 minutes to
0:02:15explain it, which is hopefully a sign that it's it's robust. But
0:02:20But it's good though, actually I switched to this when the iPhone first came out and
0:02:26you couldn't use like one password or anything like that.
0:02:29I wanted to have complex passwords and different passwords on every site, but still be able
0:02:34to somehow memorize them all.
0:02:37And so it's been pretty good.
0:02:39Most of the only thing is when a site has a breakdown or passwords get stolen, they
0:02:45have to reset it and then you have to have a backup system for sites that have been compromised
0:02:49once and it gets messy pretty quickly.
0:02:50Well, the thing that gets me is that I'm more annoyed now when I run into a site where the
0:02:57password autofill doesn't work than I was back in the days when no passwords got autofilled.
0:03:02Yeah, because it's like it wasn't an annoyance before.
0:03:05Right. I think it's probably like when they invented modern plumbing and people who grew
0:03:11up always having to go to an outhouse every time they wanted to go. And then all of a
0:03:15of a sudden most places had indoor plumbing but then every once in a while you get to
0:03:19a place where you'd have to go out in the outhouse. It was worse. I'm sure that that
0:03:22was worse than when they were children and had to go in the outhouse every single time.
0:03:27Kevin: Yup, everything is relative.
0:03:28Davey, Right. It's like once the bar is raised, you can never go back.
0:03:33Kevin Yup. I think there's probably, I was going to make some sort of, there's a funny
0:03:40tweet on Twitter that day about someone's going to make a podcast cut up of everyone
0:03:44saying can I swear and there's some shitty joke to be made there except that
0:03:49I remember the last time I was on the show that was the time you I think you
0:03:52actually did get busted for swearing on your podcast oh you think it was your
0:03:55it was it your episode I think so I think it was because you I think you
0:03:58pretty cool days later because we had talked about on the podcast like yeah so
0:04:01I actually I met the guy from Apple on podcast he asked me to tone it down yeah
0:04:06and that was the one where the shit hit the fan maybe I don't remember but
0:04:09that's funny because you don't seem you seem like one of my least profane I know
0:04:13I think I had one word the whole thing.
0:04:16But maybe it's the exact same thing you just talked about.
0:04:18When there's one password that doesn't work, it stands out more.
0:04:21Whereas if there's just a whole string of expletives, they kind of just run into each
0:04:25other at some point.
0:04:28But there's just one, one finally placed one, it really jumps out.
0:04:31I'd like to be known for that.
0:04:33The well-placed expletive.
0:04:35[laughter]
0:04:36The well-placed expletive, that's a good site.
0:04:43So I guess there's not much going on except that it seems like everybody has collectively
0:04:49sort of finished digesting WWDC and Google I/O.
0:04:57Yeah, no, I agree.
0:05:01And a couple of good pieces this week.
0:05:04You had a good piece on, let me try this, Stratechary.
0:05:07Stratechary?
0:05:09Second one's the term.
0:05:10Stratechary, because it's tech.
0:05:12But I did switch it up, so it's my fault that now no one knows how to say it.
0:05:16But you did have a good piece on Samsung, because that's a little tidbit.
0:05:22And who knows?
0:05:23One quarter is a data point, not necessarily a trend.
0:05:29But Samsung had a pretty bad quarter.
0:05:32Their last one wasn't hot either.
0:05:35It was soft, I think is the word that they use.
0:05:39So this is not by any means out of the blue.
0:05:44Right.
0:05:45Well, let's talk about them first.
0:05:47I think in broad strokes, what it seems like we're seeing is that Samsung had for a while
0:05:55occupied a certain middle ground, making some money on a lot of high quantity of lower end
0:06:05smartphones and a decent size chunk of higher-end smartphones, but that they're—we're seeing
0:06:14signs that they're getting pinched on both sides, that Apple still—it dominates the
0:06:18high-end and as, you know, has throughout the whole era of smartphones in terms of profit
0:06:25and revenue.
0:06:27And on the low end, they're running into various competitors, right?
0:06:33in China in particular with, how do you say it?
0:06:37- Xiaomi.
0:06:38- Xiaomi, now how do you spell that?
0:06:40- X-I-A-O-M-I, which is the,
0:06:45it's actually, it's originally a Chinese character
0:06:48and that's how you use what's called pinyin
0:06:50to write it in English, so.
0:06:52But it actually, it works well.
0:06:54Any name with an X in it looks good.
0:06:56- And it's a company that's very interesting to me
0:07:00and you know far more about them than I do.
0:07:03It's actually one of the main reasons I thought to invite you on the show this week.
0:07:07If I don't know a lot about them, I can't help but think that there's an awful lot of
0:07:11listeners of the show who don't and maybe even haven't heard of them before.
0:07:14But I think they should be on everybody's radar, especially when it comes to Samsung.
0:07:23Even though I think for the last year or so, there's been a lot of stuff in the press and
0:07:27in the investor world that sort of has them as somebody who Apple should be looking out for.
0:07:35But I think it's actually, I think you've made this point pretty well that it's Samsung.
0:07:38Well, I think the number one thing about Xiaomi in particular is you have to really,
0:07:46there's this really breathless feature in Bloomberg and they had Xiaomi Week, talking
0:07:53about Xiaomi, this big thing. You have to clearly delineate between China and the rest of the world.
0:08:00And in China, Xiaomi deserves all the hype. They're killing it.
0:08:07They are a Chinese company. They are a Chinese company and just in general, and this goes for a lot of the Chinese companies in general, like China really is its own completely separate world where very little applies to what happens the rest of the world, particularly in the West and vice versa.
0:08:27versa and a lot of that's because of the great firewall. Part of it is because of
0:08:31you know just cultural differences and part of it is because it's such a huge
0:08:36market. It's like I mean US companies get criticized for being you know
0:08:41too US focused but why wouldn't they be? It's you know it's 300 million of the
0:08:45richest consumers in the world like it makes sense to start out there. Same
0:08:49thing if you're a Chinese company like you're sitting you have a billion
0:08:52customers, an absolute number of which are very rich and a good number of which are getting
0:09:02richer, so why not focus there?
0:09:08Anytime you talk about Xiaomi or anything about China, it's really important to draw
0:09:12the two.
0:09:13I think Xiaomi is not much of a threat outside China, but in China they're a big deal.
0:09:18In China, they're a threat to Apple as well, but that's why you have to make the distinction.
0:09:23Right, and China is big enough that even if they're a Chinese-only company, it's big
0:09:30enough to matter.
0:09:31Oh, it's big enough to matter.
0:09:32I mean, China's going to be Apple's biggest market in like five years or something.
0:09:37So it matters, just to give you an idea of what a massive market it is.
0:09:43And so it does matter, even if Xiaomi only threatened Samsung in China or only threatened
0:09:50Apple in China, because China is such a significant market for both companies, that means the
0:09:56companies as a whole are threatened.
0:10:01And part of it too is this is where being based on Android can work in their favor is
0:10:10If they were running their own proprietary platform, it might be a problem that they
0:10:15were strong only in China.
0:10:18Maybe sort of like what Blackberry was like back when Blackberry had a huge market share
0:10:24in the US and was sort of nonexistent elsewhere.
0:10:28This is going back pre-iPhone.
0:10:30This is like early 2000s when Blackberry was this abnormality.
0:10:35It worked for them because they didn't need software.
0:10:38It wasn't really about apps yet.
0:10:39it was just about communicating. And the people in the US who had Blackberries were for the
0:10:43most part communicating with other people at Blackberries, so it was okay. Whereas now,
0:10:48where you need an app ecosystem, you know, Xiaomi can capitalize on that, even if they're
0:10:57only really strong in China because Android is Android.
0:11:00Well, I mean, it's actually funny because that's the other part where China is just
0:11:05a different world, right? As a rule, I think we talked about this last time, is you have
0:11:12to be one of the two. Sorry, I lost my train of thought. You have to be one of the two,
0:11:21but in China, that's the big exception, right? Because most of phones in China are on AOSP,
0:11:28the open source Android, and there's a whole plethora of services that fill in there. Like,
0:11:33UCWeb, which is the biggest browser, which was just bought by Alibaba, there's a whole
0:11:38bunch of app stores, a few of which, like, there's been some competitions, some of which
0:11:42are kind of emerging as the key ones, and so there's almost like, there is a whole separate
0:11:48ecosystem of services that most of the phones there use, and it actually, so in China, Chinese
0:11:54developers are used to this, right?
0:11:55There's actually services that help you get your app on all the different stores, you
0:12:00be everywhere. And it's funny, if that sort of whole ecosystem were in the West, it would
0:12:08actually totally transform the market here because it would really weaken the importance
0:12:16that the Play Store does have in giving Google full control of that, if that makes sense.
0:12:24Everything there is really so different, and there's lots of things that are interesting
0:12:28for Western companies, it means Google's really not important at all there. They're
0:12:34not important because they're blocked as far as search, but they're also not important
0:12:37because they don't really control Android there. And the only Western company actually
0:12:41that really matters is Apple, and that's because they sell hardware.
0:12:45So do you think that's already having an effect on Samsung's numbers?
0:12:50Oh, yeah.
0:12:51Or do you think it's more, it's already partly China, but is it only China? Is it
0:12:57worldwide?
0:12:58I think for sure, so you alluded to it before, I think Samsung has a problem on both ends.
0:13:07On the high end, they got a lot of high end customers, I think, for two specific reasons.
0:13:17Again, this was more conjecture previously, but now that it's actually happening, I think
0:13:21we can say a little more certainty.
0:13:24One was the iPhone has always been relatively limited when it comes to carrier distribution.
0:13:30They were stuck at 220 for two or three years, and even before then it was even lower.
0:13:38That left a good 500 carriers around the world where there was no iPhone, and presuming you
0:13:44were loyal to your carrier, and in richer countries people tend to be more loyal to
0:13:48with their carriers, and you wanted a high-end phone,
0:13:52well, there was no iPhone choice.
0:13:54It was Samsung or HTC or whatever those.
0:13:57And Samsung has always been a very good competitor.
0:14:02Whatever you think about their design decisions,
0:14:05they're a very well-run company,
0:14:06they're a very good competitor, they have great marketing,
0:14:08they pull all the levers.
0:14:10And if there were no iPhone, they would continue,
0:14:15I think, to do very well at the high end.
0:14:17and HTC would probably be doing much better as well.
0:14:21But now the iPhone has really started to again expand its carriers.
0:14:27And part of that is the big ones, which is NTD, Docomo in Japan, and China Mobile in
0:14:31China, but also lots of little ones.
0:14:33Like I'm here in, I'm back in the States now, I'm in Madison just for the summer, and a
0:14:37big carrier here is US Cellular, right?
0:14:39It's the fifth largest in the US, but still a lot smaller than the other ones.
0:14:42They've never had the iPhone, now they do.
0:14:44And there's lots of these little ones that any one of them by themselves doesn't mean
0:14:48much, but when you're adding like 50 of them, like Apple has, that just increases Samsung's
0:14:55competition where Pusi didn't have any competition there.
0:14:58Yeah, it's filling out the long tail of carriers.
0:15:01Right, exactly, exactly.
0:15:02And Samsung has owned that long tail.
0:15:05Samsung's big advantage still remains their relationship with carriers and how they own
0:15:13that whole connection, they deliver exactly what the carriers want, what they need. And
0:15:17really, they've kind of stepped into the Nokia role, which that used to be Nokia. Nokia had
0:15:21all the except for except for the US, Nokia had relationships with every carrier, they
0:15:27delivered everything that the carriers wanted, they needed. And that gave them a that's really
0:15:31important in the mobile business. And Samsung has kind of inherited that and they still have
0:15:35that advantage. You know, what made the iPhone so unique when it came to carriers and that sort
0:15:40thing was it was the first phone that people where people valued the phone more than they
0:15:44valued their relationship with their carrier and that really upset the whole apple cart
0:15:50and it is less in samsung's advantage in the carriers where they're competing directly
0:15:56with with the iphone yeah i think like go back you know pre smartphone you know and
0:16:01you'd go in and you know the big ones i remember at least here in the states were always nokia
0:16:06and Ericsson and eventually Sony Ericsson. But they were seemed to me like somebody who
0:16:14never was really into cell phones before that. I mean I'd have one just for the sake of making
0:16:18calls and truly rudimentary texting. But it just seemed to me that those were the two
0:16:25brands and you'd go in. But it never really seemed to matter too much. You know it was
0:16:30far, far more about choosing between, you know, Verizon and Singular or whoever, you
0:16:36know, whatever the names of the various carriers were in the States then. It was really mostly
0:16:39about which carrier store you're going to go into.
0:16:41Yep. And even now, I mean, what made the iPhone so unique is, you know, it was the first phone
0:16:50that people were really willing to switch carriers for, and that gave Apple all the
0:16:56negotiating leverage with carriers from that point on.
0:17:00But even then, there was still a limit to the number of people who would do that.
0:17:07There were still people who were going to stay with Verizon no matter what.
0:17:12And so it's been that dynamic has helped Samsung and continues to help them.
0:17:20But as Apple expands, that kind of, again, picks off just a lot of the long tail, exactly
0:17:26as you said.
0:17:27Yeah.
0:17:28And you made the point that one of the things to understand the dynamics of this is that
0:17:33for practical purposes, no, it's not really 100 percent, of course.
0:17:36Nothing ever is.
0:17:37But practically speaking, it's best to think of it as this.
0:17:41Everybody is going to own a smartphone.
0:17:43Right.
0:17:44Which is, there's very few things in the world that are like that.
0:17:50Especially in tech.
0:17:51A lot of the things that are like that are things like, I don't know, like...
0:17:55JE: Wash machines or...
0:17:57DAVE PORTNOY Yeah, or having a toilet in your house.
0:17:59Yeah, or TV, a TV is a good example.
0:18:01JE Sure.
0:18:02But that's the thing though, TVs even will ultimately have less penetration than a smartphone,
0:18:07which is pretty amazing.
0:18:08DAVE PORTNOY Right, because a lot of, it's going to end
0:18:10I think maybe a little bit more towards one TV per household and
0:18:14one cell phone per person
0:18:17Right. Yeah, exactly. Yep. And even if you go to multiple TVs per household
0:18:21it still is probably going to trend not towards one per person but
0:18:25But less than one per person maybe you'll have one in the master bedroom and one in the living room
0:18:31But tablets are clearly eating into that, you know where a lot of you know personal consumption of video
0:18:39is clearly going towards tablets and smartphones, you know, like like if
0:18:43You know the average number of TVs in a house
0:18:46I'm sure has
0:18:47if anything it might be going down because if you were going to have one like for your teenager and let your teenager have a
0:18:52TV in their room
0:18:54That might be a PC and a tablet now, right, you know PC for the games and and a tablet for watching video and TV
0:19:02Well, just to just kind of rathole a little bit more
0:19:06One thing that's actually really interesting about these Samsung results, we'll get back
0:19:10to the high and low and stuff, but is they talked about the fact that they felt their
0:19:15tablet sales had been hurt by their big phones, their phablets.
0:19:21Which building on this point, I think there's a lot of conjecture, and I think rightly so,
0:19:25that a lot of tablets are used primarily for TV viewing basically.
0:19:29Especially worldwide. Not the US market where the iPad has disproportionate share, but if you look worldwide at tablets, and so many people had so many observations from CES this year, that there were a lot of the no-name brand Android tablets that are clearly designed knowing that they're just going to be used for consuming video.
0:19:51yep and the other thing about video is like video in Asia is a lot different than here in that
0:20:00basically everything is available very easily like I mean it's yes there's things like Hulu and
0:20:08Netflix here but there's always kind of a bit of a challenge of seeing like whatever's up next
0:20:13like whatever hot show is going on and right now they're mostly Korean shows like these soap operas
0:20:20or like, once it's aired, it is available for streaming within like an hour, if not faster.
0:20:28And it's interesting because I don't think it's actually, it's not really frowned upon. I don't
0:20:35think anyone really sees it as an issue. Is it legal? You're saying it's not legal, but the
0:20:41IP infrastructure there is such that nobody really... I'm not sure, to be honest. I mean,
0:20:48I mean, it may be one of those things where it's nominally legal, but no one actually
0:20:54cares.
0:20:55It is true that in many countries the IP infrastructure is not there.
0:21:00But also--
0:21:01Or maybe even the IP culture, frankly.
0:21:03Yeah, that's a big part of it as well.
0:21:06The other thing is, just in general, there's a different-- I mean, because it's very open,
0:21:12right?
0:21:13in some of the more, you know, I don't know, advances in the word, but countries that have
0:21:20had a longer history of IP enforcement like Japan or Taiwan a little bit more so. Although
0:21:27it's not, you can still find counterfeit bags and stuff, but they're more like in the alleys,
0:21:34right? It's not like on the street corner like in some parts of Asia. So it's a little
0:21:38stronger. But they're very publicly available and to watch TV like that is very common.
0:21:50And I don't know all the countries in Asia, obviously, but in my experience, TV is just
0:21:57as much a thing there as it is here, if not more so. And so, yeah, that whole idea of
0:22:04being used primarily for that use rings very, very true to me.
0:22:08Well, all right, and then you were saying that Samsung explicitly said with regard to
0:22:14their poor results or disappointing results.
0:22:16Yeah, and they had a whole--
0:22:17And it's not just that they're down. They were down, it was somewhere around 16% less
0:22:22profit than was expected.
0:22:25Right, I mean, that's the weird thing about reporting results, right? It's all about expectations.
0:22:28And they were under their expectations, they were under analyst expectations, and by a
0:22:33significant amount. So we can even even if we go with the hey come on analysts just make this stuff
0:22:39up at least Samsung's own guidance is a you know should be a fair measure that most companies you
0:22:46know usually put out guidance that they expect to at least be able to meet like it's a genuine
0:22:50it's one if it's just you know an apple has run into this many times over the years where where
0:22:56apple will will post results that are pretty close to their guidance maybe a little up maybe a little
0:23:01down but generally pretty close but if they're way less than what analysts had
0:23:06had projected it's uh... headlined as a big mess yet what's weird because the
0:23:11like the worst of the worst thing you can do is miss your own guidance right
0:23:15you're gonna get hammered for that uh... the second worst thing you can do
0:23:20it was that that that is missing analyst guidance but then there's also if your
0:23:24guidance is lower than what analysts expect your head and to be like in so
0:23:28So that's when Apple takes hits after earnings.
0:23:31It's usually because their guidance for the following quarter is lower than what analysts
0:23:36anticipated it would be.
0:23:39Whereas everything that happened in the previous quarter, that's almost always baked in.
0:23:42And Apple's never missed meaningfully, at least in recent history, their recent results.
0:23:49So, yeah, it's all an expectations game.
0:23:53I know people get frustrated with Wall Street, but it's a lot more, it's not as ridiculous
0:24:00as people think. I think the main thing with Wall Street is Wall Street is a stock inherently
0:24:06is all about the future. So whatever you've done in the past, it's only useful in so much
0:24:12as it's an indicator of what will happen going forward, right? It's not a reward system.
0:24:16bringing Apple into it is sort of an aside but I think it's interesting
0:24:20because there has been I mean this is not this is something that they actually
0:24:23came out and said is that we're going to try to be a little bit more accurate
0:24:27with our does Apple that that you know a couple of maybe it was a year or so ago
0:24:32maybe a little bit more yeah I think about a couple years but yeah and that
0:24:34they said look we're good we used to you know give you a lower end of our
0:24:38guidance yeah which is translated means we really low balled the numbers and
0:24:43to always put out a number that we knew that we could beat.
0:24:46And therefore, anybody who is trying to accurately gauge what to expect from Apple had to pick
0:24:53a number that was higher than that.
0:24:55And so you had to, analysts had to pick a number that was different from Apple's, always
0:25:02higher because Apple low balled it, significantly low balled them.
0:25:09I think that the change, and this is one of those, it's something that started in the
0:25:15post-Steve Jobs era.
0:25:17I think it's probably had the intended effect in that it seems as though Apple's guidance
0:25:23and Wall Street guidance have become much more largely aligned.
0:25:28Whether it's a little bit up or a little bit worse, it seems like the stock has become
0:25:34a little bit less volatile just when results are issued.
0:25:39No, that's a really good point. I think you're probably exactly right that this
0:25:43is probably a cook thing. Jobs probably enjoyed beating expectations by a lot, but the reality
0:25:50is that actually introduced more uncertainty. Yeah, I think Jobs' perspective was probably
0:25:55along the lines of, "Screw those guys. Screw them."
0:25:57Well, Jobs liked the surprise, right? He liked to pop out and say, "Wow, lookit, we just
0:26:02murder results right i mean it was another chance
0:26:05um you know he loved the reveal um where but i think it was bad for apple
0:26:10you're exactly right because analysts had to make
0:26:13had to pick something up and what i just said about
0:26:16about the current results no longer being interesting
0:26:19is because of this change it's because they they are almost exactly right every
0:26:23time and so now everyone's focused on their
0:26:25they're going forward estimates yeah yeah i think that i think under jobs
0:26:30with the low ball numbers, it was like, screw 'em,
0:26:32let them figure it out.
0:26:34Whereas the cook idea is, let's help these guys out
0:26:38because they're wrong, they're always wrong.
0:26:40- And it hurts Apple.
0:26:41- Because we keep so much close to our vest, so let's, yeah.
0:26:45And them being wrong hurts us.
0:26:47So it's in our interest to help these guys
0:26:50and give them guidance that actually is truly guidance.
0:26:54- Yeah, I mean, this is another thing
0:26:57that just really attests to Cook's, how impressive Cook's
0:27:02operation is, is the way that Apple is so exact on their
0:27:08numbers every single time.
0:27:09And that goes back to the operations side of it.
0:27:12Operations is not just the actual making, it's the
0:27:15predicting, it's the modeling, knowing what we're going to
0:27:19sell of what.
0:27:20And Apple, ever since they did this change--
0:27:25And I think Horace DeGio has a chart that shows how much off they've been.
0:27:30Like has been in almost exactly.
0:27:32And I think a lot of the optimism for Apple
0:27:34actually is because last quarter they actually did beat themselves, right?
0:27:38In a way that they hadn't previously.
0:27:40And so that showed that even Apple was surprised.
0:27:43But I mean, it's kind of uncanny how perfectly almost it
0:27:48feels like they can predict the future.
0:27:50Yeah.
0:27:50And sometimes I feel like it's because of changes
0:27:52that they couldn't foresee, like not necessarily demand,
0:27:55but pricing of components or something like that, like something maybe dropped in price
0:28:01and helped margins and they just couldn't foresee that.
0:28:06Jeff: Right. Well, I think, right. If that's what happens, it's usually what it is. But
0:28:10I do think it was last quarter, like they genuinely beat their numbers and they're like,
0:28:15"Yeah, we had a really good quarter." And I think that's why like right now, there is
0:28:21so much positive sentiment around Apple, I think is they've kind of, you know, the
0:28:26challenge with, you know, I think Apple's actually mostly gotten past the kind of big
0:28:31number, it's not really a big number problem, but like the problem where because they're
0:28:36such a big company now, like any percentage increase is going to be small because the
0:28:40denominator is so huge.
0:28:42Right, and conversely, any small percentage difference is actually going to be a large
0:28:48number of dollars. So Apple could miss by half a billion dollars and it's like, "Holy
0:28:53shit, they missed by half a billion dollars," and it's a couple of percent.
0:28:58Right. Exactly. But I think 2012, I think late 2012, was like their growth rate peaked.
0:29:07Ever since then, their growth has slowed considerably. And I think that really, I think justifiably,
0:29:14depressed the stock for a few years now. But I feel like that's been worked through the
0:29:19system. And this is the-- with any company that's changing up, that's just shifting in
0:29:25a different phase, there is this part where-- and a lot of stock is an expectation sort
0:29:31of thing, like people understanding and grappling with your business. As your business changes,
0:29:35there's going to be upheaval. And I think-- and so you talk about a company like Intel
0:29:39or like Microsoft that has to make big changes.
0:29:45Once you get through those changes
0:29:47and you've kind of shifted expectations
0:29:49and people are now used to something else,
0:29:51then you actually do get more breathing room.
0:29:53And I actually feel like Apple has kind of crossed
0:29:55that cast in a lot of ways.
0:29:57People are cool with 6% growth, 10% growth,
0:30:02whereas before they were punished because they were no longer
0:30:05growing 20%, 30%.
0:30:08And I think that's just going back to like there's the famous saying like in the,
0:30:12what is it in the, something about the stock market,
0:30:15the short term is a something machine and long term it's a weighing machine.
0:30:18The idea is like over time, over a few years,
0:30:22like the stock market actually is very,
0:30:25very rational and it does exactly what you'd expect it to.
0:30:27And there's no point in getting caught up on kind of what happens day to day or
0:30:32quarter to quarter because it usually does work itself out in a way that makes
0:30:35sense.
0:30:36All right, I'm going to take a break in just a moment.
0:30:38But I come back to that because I think it plays into the next point I want to talk to
0:30:42you about, which is software as differentiation, which I think, and the reason I think it's
0:30:47a good parlay is I think it helps explain Samsung's problem, which is something you
0:30:52wrote about this week.
0:30:53And I also think it's something that might finally be sinking in in Wall Street's consensus
0:31:00estimate of Apple is that tablets aren't just tablets, you know, that the iPad and iPhone
0:31:07have a sustainable position because of the differentiation but hold that thought. Think
0:31:12about it while I thank our first sponsor, our good friends at Squarespace. Now you guys
0:31:19know Squarespace. I talk about them all the time because they're longtime supporters of
0:31:23this podcast and many others. You can get a free trial, 10% off if you visit squarespace.com
0:31:31and enter offer code JG, just JG, my initials at checkout. What do they do? They let you,
0:31:37you sign up for Squarespace and they help you build a website. And it's so easy, simple,
0:31:43easy, beautiful design, a whole bunch of beautiful templates to choose from, drag and drop content.
0:31:50Just, you don't have to code it up. You look at it and you add the features you want, position
0:31:54them on the page where you want by drag and drop. If you want to get into the nitty gritty,
0:31:59you want to edit CSS, you want to inject JavaScript and stuff like that, you can do that too if
0:32:04you want to, if you know how to. But if you don't, you can build a complete website by
0:32:09drag and drop. The other thing Squarespace has that is, again, I'll use the word differentiation,
0:32:15is award winning 24/7 support. They do it through live chat and email and it's located.
0:32:23They have support centers in New York City, Dublin, and Portland.
0:32:29Portland is new, I think.
0:32:30And I think the logic behind that is that's what helps them have 24/7 is between Dublin
0:32:36and New York City and Portland, Oregon, it's covered all across time zones.
0:32:45They've got plans that start at 8 bucks a month, 8 bucks, and include a free domain
0:32:49name if you sign up for a year.
0:32:52design everything looks great from phones and tablets to 30 inch displays and online
0:33:00stores every site comes with an online store so go there go to squarespace.com/groober
0:33:09you can go that way you can use that URL don't know you came from the show and when you sign
0:33:13up use that code JG and you get 10% off your first purchase and I'll know that you're a
0:33:18listener of the talk show so my thanks to Squarespace. All right, so tell me about the
0:33:24tell me you tell me about software differentiation as an advantage and the lack thereof as a
0:33:31disadvantage in mobile.
0:33:33I think the easiest thing is look at computers. I mean like I have if you have a MacBook it
0:33:41runs OS 10 if you have any other computer it runs it runs Windows and even if you had
0:33:46the exact same hardware, if you have a preference for OS X, you're going to buy the one that
0:33:54has OS X.
0:33:56And even if, virtually identical hardware, if the OS X machine costs $1,000 and the Windows
0:34:03machine costs $800, well it turns out there are a lot of people that will pay the extra
0:34:08$200 for that machine and that $200 is pure profit, right?
0:34:12Even if they don't perceive a difference in the hardware.
0:34:16- Exactly.
0:34:17- Even if you're there and if side by side
0:34:19with the screens off, you don't see an advantage
0:34:24to the MacBook Air versus the HP, you know,
0:34:30HP Air, whatever they call their, you know.
0:34:32- Well, even if Apple licensed out their hardware, right?
0:34:37And it was like literally every single component
0:34:41on this computer is identical.
0:34:42It has the same track pad, it has the same keyboard.
0:34:45- But it doesn't run OS X.
0:34:46but it doesn't run OS X.
0:34:47People will pay a premium for that.
0:34:50I'm sure I'm speaking to the choir here
0:34:53with you and your audience.
0:34:55And by definition, that premium is profit.
0:35:00Because Samsung's a big guy, all these guys are big guys,
0:35:05HP's a big guy, they are all going to get the economies
0:35:08of scale that Apple is getting.
0:35:10So if the parts for this machine cost $750, let's say,
0:35:15And the guy who has Windows charges $800, well he has $50 of profit, that's not very great.
0:35:23Meanwhile Apple's charging $1,000, that's $250 of profit, that's 33%, that's very good.
0:35:31And that difference is solely because it runs OS X.
0:35:38And it turns out that Apple is the only company that sells OS X,
0:35:43you can't buy OS X separately and put it on your own computer. You have to buy the hardware
0:35:47to get the software. And that makes the hardware valuable. And I think it's valuable in a way
0:35:59that generates profit. It's all upside. Because software is free. It's not free to make, but
0:36:06to make one additional copy of software is free. If I already have OS X, to make another
0:36:10OS X is literally just clicking a button.
0:36:14And it's the exact same thing with phones.
0:36:17If you prefer iOS or the iOS ecosystem, guess what?
0:36:21There's only one way to get iOS and that's to buy hardware from Apple.
0:36:25And so even if HTC or Samsung made an iPhone where every single component was the same,
0:36:33look and feel was the same, and the camera was the same, and the button was the same,
0:36:39Apple could still charge a premium because people will pay for iOS.
0:36:43Yet, iOS doesn't cost Apple anything.
0:36:47So that's why Apple dominates profits and that's why, I think to your point, why Apple
0:36:54is safe in a lot of ways.
0:36:56Like...
0:36:57It leads to less fluctuation year over year and less pressure to come out with.
0:37:04And this is something Apple has gotten dinged in the press year after year after year with
0:37:08new iPhones. Well, geez, this is almost just like last year's iPhone, but it's a little
0:37:12smarter and a little faster and the camera's better. And I think you see that with Samsung
0:37:18flailing around with a lot of gimmickry in their new phones. Like a year and a half ago
0:37:24when they came out with the ones that tried to read your eyes for, "Hey, look up. We'll
0:37:29pause the video for you or we'll scroll the webpage while you're moving your eyes," which
0:37:34And by all the reviews I've seen, it wasn't really a good feature, but they needed some
0:37:38way to do that, to stay above the fray of all the other Android phones that were similar
0:37:46to the previous Samsung phone.
0:37:49Whereas Apple doesn't really need to worry about gimmicks like that, because people who
0:37:56want to buy an iPhone are going to buy the new iPhone no matter what.
0:37:59Right, and so the problem is, this is actually why in the long run you end up not having
0:38:05hardware comparable to Apple. Why doesn't someone, you hear this a lot, like why aren't
0:38:10there any laptops as good as Macbooks? I mean there are some.
0:38:14Lenovo I would always hold up as the one who's closest and I would also
0:38:20I would take a ThinkPad, if they had better screens, I would take a ThinkPad over a Macbook.
0:38:25Those machines are amazing.
0:38:28Well, I've always said that if I couldn't, like as a what-if scenario, you know, it's
0:38:33not going to happen. But if you had to choose between a, let's say, a ThinkPad running OS
0:38:3810 or a MacBook Pro running Windows, which would you prefer? And I wouldn't even hesitate.
0:38:44I'd rather have a ThinkPad running OS 10. I don't think I would prefer a ThinkPad running
0:38:49OS 10 versus a MacBook running OS 10, but I would at least try it.
0:38:53The nub isn't acquired taste. I get that.
0:38:57the software that's more important. Right, no exactly. What happens though is, so let's
0:39:02say you start out at point zero, right? And the Apple, you have two, you have Samsung
0:39:08and Apple, say, and they make identical phones. And one runs Android, the other runs OS X,
0:39:15or sorry, iOS. Yeah, right, like hypothetically speaking, let's take Samsung's copying to
0:39:22the logical extreme. And legalities aside, let's say that they made a genuine complete
0:39:27clone of the iPhone. Right. So it's perfect. It's exactly the same. The problem is, and
0:39:32so the problem is, is because Android's open and there's lots of hardware manufacturers
0:39:37out there, someone's going to come along and make another Android phone and maybe they
0:39:43copy it too and they make it the exact same way. But what are they going to do? Samsung,
0:39:48so Apple's priced it at $600, Samsung's priced it at $600, well the other guy's going to
0:39:52is going to price it at $575. And then everyone's going to go buy the other one. And then Sam,
0:39:59and so what happens, Sam's going to respond by lowering the price. But the problem is
0:40:02as you lower the price, now your margins getting compressed. And so you start cutting corners.
0:40:07So suddenly the display is not quite as good. Or the button quality is a little lower. Or,
0:40:13you know, and so what happens is because you're forced to compete on price, the quality actually
0:40:21ends up going down along the way because it's like, you know, it's death by a thousand cuts.
0:40:27And that's why, and you saw this in PCs, this is why laptops have always been, Windows laptops
0:40:33have mostly always been inferior from a quality perspective. It's not, it's not, it has nothing
0:40:39to do with the software per se, it's because they're stuck in this game where they have
0:40:43to find margins somewhere.
0:40:44Right, and, but then they screw up the software because to try to squeeze little bits of margin
0:40:50is why they do things like pre-install the Norton bug you until you try to sign up for
0:40:59Norton experience, right? You go in and buy a brand new laptop and you open it up and
0:41:04if it's running Windows and it's from most OEMs, you're going to have stuff that's not
0:41:09from Microsoft, not officially part of Windows and it's all annoying and it's there to try
0:41:15to – a lot of it is there to try to increase the margins because Norton gives them two
0:41:20or three bucks for everybody who has it pre-installed.
0:41:22So that's actually where most OEMs make all their margin. Like actually most computers
0:41:29are made at cost and then any profit margin they make is from the crapware. And that's
0:41:33why to get a crapware free machine you have to pay more. And the thing is, in Windows,
0:41:42I obviously worked for Microsoft and worked for Windows and they would bitch and moan
0:41:45about how terrible the hardware was, but this is all Microsoft's fault, right?
0:41:50It's one of those things where it was always to their benefit, right?
0:41:55The whole thing where you want to commoditize your compliments.
0:41:58Like the things that are important for your product, but that you don't sell,
0:42:02you want them to be as cheap and as low cost as possible.
0:42:06And so it was in Microsoft's great benefit that computers decreased in cost so rapidly,
0:42:12and there was all this competition and driving down prices,
0:42:15But the problem is, as with anything, you take it too far and then oops, you're stuck with these terrible machines with creaky hinges and crapware all over them.
0:42:25And then that rolls back and now it's being ascribed to Microsoft and they're like, "Well, Microsoft always is on crappy machines and whatever."
0:42:33And it's the same thing with Google, except Google is even more ruthless, right?
0:42:38right? They don't... they want everything to be free. They want everything to not cost anything.
0:42:43They want people to be online as much as possible, as easily as possible,
0:42:46and they are more than happy to watch Samsung and HTC and everyone kind of kill themselves here.
0:42:53And again, Google is quite smart about this, because to our earlier point,
0:42:57because smartphones are going to be everywhere, everyone's going to have one.
0:43:01Like there really is no floor to like how cheap or crappy a phone can be because someone
0:43:09is going to buy it.
0:43:10Right.
0:43:11There's a tweet from earlier today.
0:43:14I think it was earlier.
0:43:15Yeah.
0:43:16Earlier today from our mutual friend Benedict Evans.
0:43:20And I think it's very, very well summarizes the situation in the long term.
0:43:25Here's his whole tweet.
0:43:27OEMs will be able to differentiate on this common platform has been a false
0:43:33promise for 30 years right that's because they're kicking it old-school
0:43:39here but I mean this was something like when Apple was in trouble in the 90s
0:43:42that was over and over and over again people would say well what Apple should
0:43:45do is start making Windows machines too and differentiate on on design right so
0:43:53Apple but you know Apple's strength isn't Mac OS are getting killed because
0:43:56because the Mac is so much smaller than Windows
0:43:58and everybody's on Windows.
0:43:59What Apple's good at is design.
0:44:01So Apple should make Windows machines
0:44:02and differentiate on design.
0:44:05And that's, it's, actually that's exactly,
0:44:08I would say that's exactly the Sony PC business, right?
0:44:13That was the art, you know, the whole idea of Sony's PC.
0:44:16Right, and how'd that work out?
0:44:18- They, Vio is now its own company.
0:44:20(laughing)
0:44:21And they're money losing one at that.
0:44:23would say Sony gave that as good a run as anybody. Yeah, and they were very nice computers. Right.
0:44:30And, and, you know, innovative in certain ways to like VAOs got small, like usable small laptops,
0:44:40you know, way before everyone else, right before everyone else with, you know, with with minimal
0:44:45compromises. And it just, it's not sustainable on a common platform. Yeah, no, it's like, I think,
0:44:52like the analogy is almost like air travel and this is I'm not sure this is gonna work
0:44:56because it literally just occurred to me um but like everyone like bitches about like oh we want
0:45:01good service on airplanes and like we want more seats more more seating area and stuff like that
0:45:06the problem is every single time an airline tries that like continental did a thing where we're
0:45:11gonna have better service American Airlines did a thing where we're gonna have you know more more
0:45:15room in our aisles and we're gonna advertise based on that and we're gonna be able to to charge a you
0:45:19you know, a slightly higher price. Well, guess what, everyone kept going to Expedia
0:45:23or Kayak or whatever and picking the lowest, the lowest number.
0:45:26This is very painful to me because two or three years ago,
0:45:31Virgin America came to Philadelphia and,
0:45:34and it was the most welcome breath of fresh air in the history of PHL
0:45:39International Airport.
0:45:41And they are leaving Philadelphia International Airport in two months because
0:45:48No one wants to pay.
0:45:50Well, it's not-- and they're not going away,
0:45:52but clearly it wasn't a big success for them.
0:45:54And they were always more expensive.
0:45:56US Air is the carrier that dominates PHL.
0:45:58And it's one of their hubs.
0:46:00And they've got this merger with American.
0:46:04And part of the concessions for this merger
0:46:08is they had to give up gates at Washington--
0:46:12National, yeah.
0:46:13And one of the New York ones.
0:46:15I'm guessing it's probably JFK because JFK is bigger.
0:46:21That combined, US Air and American have to give up some number of their gates at those
0:46:27and Virgin decided to take, I think, I don't know if they took them at Washington too,
0:46:31but I know that they took some of their JFK ones and they literally don't have enough
0:46:35airplanes.
0:46:36So they have to take the airplanes that have been flying the Philly routes and they're
0:46:39going to be flying JFK routes.
0:46:41they're like, it's like a waiting list.
0:46:44It's like trying to get Washington Redskins season tickets
0:46:47or something that's like,
0:46:48there's like a five-year waiting list
0:46:51to get new airplanes from Boeing or something like that.
0:46:54They can't just order them.
0:46:55And I don't think that they were,
0:46:57I'm pretty sure Virgin America
0:46:58has never turned a profit anyway on a quarter.
0:47:00- No, well, yeah, I was gonna mention that.
0:47:03It just doesn't work because it's one of those things,
0:47:06like air travel is a commodity.
0:47:11I don't know. I think the analogy sort of holds up. It is a commodity and there's an economy of scale.
0:47:16That's the thing. That's the magic. You've got to get off the ground somehow and get this mass
0:47:26of users to sustain it if you're going to be different. They just don't have it.
0:47:33Virgin America just didn't have it, at least out of Philly.
0:47:37yep do any I think you there's the whole business thing right because they're the
0:47:41ones that are price
0:47:42insensitive arm and yeah I don't know what
0:47:45we're not an airlines it is for you though they think there's actually a ton
0:47:48of people that I know
0:47:49I myself am kinda narrow arrow airlines geek there's some people I follow on
0:47:52Twitter
0:47:53and it's funny there's actually it's like there's quite a few people
0:47:57in in in tech or whatever that
0:48:00as a side thing like love to follow like the airline industry arm
0:48:04It's so much better than others. I mean I and I'm what I actually have gold status on US air because I that's all I ever
0:48:10Fly I mean every flight I take whether it's a vacation or whether it's work to go to the West Coast. It's always
0:48:15US air and because so many of my flights are entirely across the country. I've somehow gotten the gold status
0:48:22Which is good customer service wise like I can book tickets now that that are like
0:48:28refundable. I can change my tickets and not pay a fee, like
0:48:32literally not even pay like a nominal fee. It's kind of
0:48:34awesome. And if I could book a flight on Virgin America, and it
0:48:39costs more, I would do it in a heartbeat because it's such a
0:48:42nicer experience.
0:48:42Unfortunately, you know, you have a, you know, well, a
0:48:46reputation for valuing quality in the products you buy that is
0:48:51that is not broadly shared.
0:48:53I've been on I've been on flights. I can't remember the
0:48:56last time I flew in you know for the most part it was all SFO to Philly
0:49:01although sometimes depending on the hour I would I would even take this is what I
0:49:05would do too is I would fly Philly to LAX LAX to SFO on virgin rather than a
0:49:12non-stop which I have numerous numerous choices between SFO and Philly on US air
0:49:16right rather have the layover in LAX oh yeah well and once you're flying far
0:49:20enough it makes enough of a difference. Especially with Wi-Fi.
0:49:26It's everything. It's just so much more comfortable. The plane doesn't have the funky smell. But
0:49:33anyway, there's not enough people like me to get it off the ground.
0:49:37It's funny because we should probably stop rattling on airlines. I'm based in Asia where
0:49:43flying economy class on an Asian airline is like flying above first class on a typical
0:49:47US Airline. US Airline has Stockholm Syndrome. They're like Business Insider, right? They
0:49:56always do the "Oh, I flew on this airline," and everyone clicks on it 5 million times.
0:50:01But I think Steve Kovacs did one. He's like Singapore Air. He's marveling at every seat
0:50:06had its own television. It's like, "Oh, first class." I forgot how bad. No, in economy.
0:50:12First class on US Air is literally just a bigger seat. They do give you a meal. They
0:50:16They do give you a meal that you don't get back there, but it's so bad.
0:50:20Honestly, you're a fool if you eat it, I think.
0:50:24You're just asking to be made sick.
0:50:27You get drinks.
0:50:29It's a bigger seat and you get alcoholic drinks.
0:50:33That's it.
0:50:34Which one should not frown upon too much.
0:50:36No, but it's so much different than international airlines.
0:50:43We are massively...
0:50:44So it's funny, so we are way off, right?
0:50:45So that Samsung--
0:50:47- Well, I don't know that we're way off though.
0:50:48I do think it kind of explained the race to the bottom
0:50:52on a commodity platform like Windows,
0:50:57and I think that's where Android is heading.
0:50:59- Well, the weird thing with,
0:51:00what makes it different though,
0:51:02and the weird, well, maybe it's the same,
0:51:04because the thing with an airline
0:51:06is because it is super heavily regulated, right?
0:51:08There's a certain floor of service.
0:51:11Even if you fly Frontier or Spirit or whatever,
0:51:13the cheap ones are, you can feel reasonably confident that they're going to get you there
0:51:19in one piece. Because they all have to pass the same FAA regulations, they all have to
0:51:24have the same maintenance regimes. And so because of that, it's not like you're flying
0:51:31and like, "Wow, this guy is $300 cheaper, but they have a plane crash every other week."
0:51:39everyone's at a certain level.
0:51:41And what's happening with smartphones is you're getting actually a similar idea.
0:51:45Like a few years ago, even a couple years ago, the difference between a $200 smartphone and a $400 smartphone was huge.
0:51:54Now, there really isn't that much of a difference at all.
0:51:57And by the way, that $200 smartphone is now a $100 smartphone or a $150 smartphone.
0:52:02phone. And so like the the the the difference between the high
0:52:08and low end is shrinking. And what's funny is everyone uses
0:52:11this to say why Apple's doomed, but they're only doomed if you
0:52:15ignore the software, right? All those critics actually, I think
0:52:18the first time you've linked to me I'd have been this article,
0:52:19like I said, well over a year ago that Samsung was in trouble.
0:52:22Because unlike Apple, there is nothing to make a Samsung phone
0:52:28different from a no-name phone.
0:52:32And especially in China, where in China, there's--
0:52:37well, first off, there's a few more things that are different
0:52:40in China.
0:52:40One, there's just way more--
0:52:42because that's where all the manufacturing happens,
0:52:45there's just way more phones there.
0:52:47There's way more companies making phones,
0:52:49the vast majority of which don't export at all.
0:52:51So there's tons and tons and tons of, quote, unquote,
0:52:54"brands" in China, most of whom I've never heard of,
0:52:57much less anyone else.
0:52:58So one, there's just way more competition.
0:53:01And then two, in China, for the most,
0:53:05it's much more so the phone is separate from the plan.
0:53:10So you usually, not always,
0:53:13I mean, and actually the iPhone has pushed
0:53:15more of a subsidization into the system,
0:53:18but especially traditionally,
0:53:19it's always been very separate,
0:53:20where you buy your service from the carrier
0:53:24and you buy your device from a device seller.
0:53:27Like they're different transactions.
0:53:29And so that neuters Samsung's carrier advantage.
0:53:32It doesn't really exist as much there.
0:53:35And then you add on top of that,
0:53:38Samsung did have more of a prestigious brand in China.
0:53:41Like if you're gonna buy,
0:53:42it'd be better to buy a $200 Samsung phone
0:53:44than a $200 Chinese phone
0:53:46because Samsung was a meaningful brand.
0:53:49- And that's where you get into that massive spend
0:53:51that Samsung still has on marketing.
0:53:54- Totally, totally.
0:53:56But Xiaomi's just destroyed that.
0:53:57Like that's, like Xiaomi is,
0:54:00Xiaomi, what Xiaomi really does have a lot in common
0:54:02with Apple is like Xiaomi's founders are like rock stars.
0:54:06Right?
0:54:07They are the Steve Jobs and, you know,
0:54:09and the Craig Federighis of China.
0:54:13- And their phones actually do,
0:54:14I've never held one in my hand,
0:54:15so I can't speak to build quality,
0:54:17but you take a look at them and they do,
0:54:18to my eyes, instantly look better designed
0:54:22than Samsung and most other brands.
0:54:25- Yeah, and the quality is decent.
0:54:28I've held both the high end and the low end.
0:54:31The low end wasn't the most previous one.
0:54:34It was a little, like, I thought it was a little flimsier,
0:54:37but it wasn't, it was a fully functional,
0:54:42like, there's no problem in using this day to day.
0:54:44You can tell it's a couple hundred bucks cheaper
0:54:46than its sibling.
0:54:47But again, that's improving as well.
0:54:51like those are way better than what was available at the price point previously
0:54:55and so for Xiaomi, and then Xiaomi has like
0:54:58you know, so they have these rock stars and there's the whole Chinese like social network
0:55:02you know, which we talked about last time, the WeChat and all these sort of things
0:55:06where they actually sell, they sell completely online
0:55:09so they don't have to pay any overhead to carriers, they pay nothing for marketing
0:55:12they just basically sell everything through their brand and through their website
0:55:16and so they can keep their costs super low and then their whole business model
0:55:20is to basically sell at cost, right?
0:55:22They say they're gonna make it up by selling services,
0:55:25by selling app store and all that sort of stuff.
0:55:28And Samsung is just getting walloped.
0:55:31Like Samsung can't compete with that.
0:55:34And that's why Apple is more threatened in China
0:55:36by Xiaomi as well, because Xiaomi isn't just cheap.
0:55:39They're cheap and they're a brand.
0:55:42And they're like, they're a statement.
0:55:44Like you're saying something by carrying a Xiaomi phone.
0:55:48And that has been Apple's selling point in China
0:55:50Yes, the software is important, but it's actually, I think it's less of a differentiator in China,
0:55:59especially because there's lots of crazy stuff you can do with Android, right?
0:56:03That Chinese value.
0:56:06Whereas Apple, the lockdown actually works against them a lot of ways.
0:56:10This is actually an area where the keyboards are going to help.
0:56:13There's lots of alternate Chinese keyboards that I know people that's been a holdup for not wanting to go with iOS
0:56:23But even beyond that there's tons of stuff like the whole idea of skinning stuff and having all these cutesy things
0:56:28and all this stuff on our phone that we in the West feels very weird
0:56:33It's just different there
0:56:35You go to Yahoo China or Alibaba or Baidu
0:56:39The pages are all busy and there's links everywhere and they're just like, they hurt your eyes.
0:56:44It's just a very different aesthetic.
0:56:46And so, Xiaomi delivers all that and they let you customize, let you do all this stuff, yet they're also cool.
0:56:54But all those advantages only exist in China.
0:56:59And so that's why Xiaomi is a big deal in China, but I'm way more skeptical about them outside of China.
0:57:06Because it just doesn't translate as much.
0:57:09Alright, let's hold this thought because I'll pick it right back up.
0:57:12I know where I want to go.
0:57:13But I want to thank our second sponsor, another long time supporter of the show, our good
0:57:18friends at Backblaze.
0:57:21Backblaze is online backup for your Mac, unthrottle and unlimited.
0:57:29You download Backblaze, you get a free trial, risk free, no credit card required.
0:57:34Just sign up.
0:57:35Just go to backblaze.com/daringfireball.
0:57:38Download it.
0:57:39days, see how it works completely and after that, only after that do they ask you for
0:57:45a credit card and I guarantee you you're probably going to sign up because it's great. They
0:57:49have over 100 petabytes of data backed up among all their users. Now last week I said
0:57:56I don't even know how much that is. Our good friends at Backblaze, they got in touch. So
0:58:00one petabyte is a thousand terabytes. They have a hundred petabytes of data backed up.
0:58:08how much they have stored. They've just crossed the 6 billion file mark for how many files have
0:58:15been restored by users. In other words, users of Backblaze have restored 6 billion files that have
0:58:22been backed up by Backblaze. Lots of users, great track record, great software, an iPad, an iPhone
0:58:29app, I mean, to access and share any of your files from anywhere. You can restore one file at a time,
0:58:37if it's just like, oh my god, I just need that one thing,
0:58:39I don't know where it is, it's not on my machine anymore,
0:58:41but I bet Backblaze has it backed up.
0:58:43Or all of your files, easily with the web restore.
0:58:4725% of all restores though are just one file.
0:58:50It's not just for computer disasters,
0:58:52although it's great peace of mind and a great service
0:58:55if you do run into a disaster.
0:58:57Founded by ex-Apple engineers,
0:59:00it runs natively on your Mac and on Mavericks.
0:59:03There's no add-ons, no gimmicks, no additional charges,
0:59:06It's just five bucks a month per computer
0:59:11for unlimited un-throttle backup.
0:59:13Go to backblaze.com/daringfireball
0:59:17and just download it if you haven't already.
0:59:19So my thanks to them.
0:59:20So I think the irony,
0:59:21the irony of the whole Samsung-Apple thing
0:59:23is that the consensus refrain against Apple,
0:59:28I would say while like the stock was depressed
0:59:32after Tim Cook first took over,
0:59:34that it's unsustainable for the minority market share OS. They can't sustain it against Android.
0:59:43It's inevitable that it's going to be all commoditized and the whole thing's going to
0:59:47collapse. And Samsung is going to beat them. Samsung is more innovative than Apple. They
0:59:53can't beat Samsung. I think the irony is that it's really all those arguments really do
0:59:59apply, but they don't apply to Apple, they apply to Samsung.
1:00:02You know, the knock against Apple for most of 2011, 2012, maybe even into 2013,
1:00:09really was the case against Samsung. That the differentiation that they had for a while was
1:00:16not sustainable. No, that's exactly it. I mean, I think, like I said, I think this is when we
1:00:21first connected was, you know, I wrote a piece called Two Bears, like, that basically it's this
1:00:29point, it's like, for some reason, and it's funny, like, I wrote another piece, Two Bears Revisited,
1:00:36where I drudged up like some old like PC reviews of like Mac books, right? And in every single one
1:00:42of them, they don't talk about the operating system, they talk about like, what ports it has,
1:00:46the screen quality, the keyboard quality, and it's like, and analysts do the same thing, and it's
1:00:51so weird, right? It's like, how can you, like, I think the vast majority of the Apple is doomed
1:01:00narrative comes from people that fundamentally don't grok the software differentiation angle,
1:01:07right? And if you don't understand that, then yes, Apple is doomed. They're selling very expensive
1:01:13of gadgets when you can get a perfectly good gadget for a quarter of the price.
1:01:17Right. And it's almost impossible to overstate just how high the table stakes are to get
1:01:30into that. So clearly the biggest thing that's happened in tech, I mean we spent most of
1:01:40last seven years talking about one thing which is the revolution that iOS sparked. It's not
1:01:45all about iOS because Android followed, but it's changed the world. But it wasn't just
1:01:50that Apple in 2005 through 2007 was able to create iOS. That iOS entirely is based on
1:01:59work that started in 1988 with Next and that in some sense it was a continuous effort.
1:02:07Not that in 1988 or 1989 that Next had in mind something like the iPhone, but there's
1:02:14so much that is shared and that is built on, you know, and why, you know, for example,
1:02:20just the simple aspect of, you know, it's something that came up once again just every
1:02:24single year, just like it being the year of Linux.
1:02:26This is the year where Android gets 60 frames per second animation.
1:02:30Why does the iPhone have better, less stuttery scrolling and animation than Android?
1:02:37not because of work that Apple did not only because of work that Apple had did in 2006
1:02:42through the present it's because of work that Apple has done since 1988.
1:02:46What about the next?
1:02:47Well, and why it's on the same point. Windows Phone came out after Android yet Windows Phone
1:02:52has always had better animation.
1:02:54Why?
1:02:55Exactly.
1:02:56Because Microsoft's been writing device drivers since the 80s, right?
1:03:00And has always to their credit for all the knocks you can give against Windows up until
1:03:06Vista had a tremendous reputation for at least the interface in Windows was snappy and responsive.
1:03:15Right.
1:03:16Especially like XP versus the early versions of Mac OS X. Apple's interface felt slower because
1:03:25they were doing so much more graphically. It was like a long play that got them to where they could
1:03:31do these things like the stuff.
1:03:34But anyway, following different paths
1:03:36and with different priorities, Microsoft and Apple both
1:03:39have decades of work that's resulted
1:03:44in the snappiness of the interfaces you see today.
1:03:47And so it's just so hard to overstate
1:03:50how hard it would be for somebody like Tizen
1:03:53or like Samsung to get Tizen established
1:03:56as a true peer to those platforms.
1:04:01Well, I mean, I think yeah, because I mean, it's easy to look at the, the App Store. And that's certainly a big part of it. But like, I mean, if you think about that, that's another part of the table stakes at this point, though, because it wasn't in 2007 or 2008. Right now it is what
1:04:16No, that's my point, right? Because everyone, you can stop there and say that's reason enough that no one else is going to break in.
1:04:23But if you look at iOS, to me there's like three, I mean everything's Unix, right? But there's three kind of seminal, proprietary things that happened that made iOS.
1:04:32iOS. One is next, back in the 80s. So that's where it started. Two was the iTunes store.
1:04:42And then three was the App Store, which I guess is part of that. But what makes iOS what it is,
1:04:51has been a decade-long process. And that's the thing, right? It's not just that Apple's
1:04:59differentiated, it's almost a little too simple to say Apple products are differentiated by software,
1:05:05because it really is differentiated by the entire ecosystem, by everything that sits on top of it.
1:05:11So now, and we saw this with Palm in a lot of ways, even if you came out with an operating system
1:05:16that was as elegant and as easy to use, now that is no longer enough. And there is nothing like,
1:05:26There are very few things in business broadly, I think, that are more challenging than building an ecosystem.
1:05:34Because there's so many players involved. There's so much out of your control.
1:05:38When I was at Windows, I was working on the Windows 8 App Store and managed a few categories in the App Store and trying to get people on board.
1:05:46And you need the users in place. You need the developers in place. You need the right capabilities in the system.
1:05:53Like there's, it's this, it's like, speaking of watches, like this inter,
1:05:57interlocking watch, right?
1:05:58But it's not like where you can put one piece in and add the next piece.
1:06:02And then they all work together.
1:06:03You have to not just put all the pieces in, but they have to all fit in at the same
1:06:07time immediately, right?
1:06:08Like they have to just magically come together and then work.
1:06:11And without that, um, it's you, you're forced to like go to shortcuts where it's
1:06:17paying developers, whether it's, um, you know, trying to come up with something
1:06:22that's so unique that people will look over the holes, which you know, Amazon's trying
1:06:28to do. But it's fiendishly hard. And this is, if Apple is discounted on Wall Street,
1:06:38and I think this is going away to your point, but it's on this, is that people don't, like,
1:06:45someone at Microsoft told me that, you know, what Wall Street values is knowing that you
1:06:51can totally fuck it up and you'll still be in business, right?
1:06:54And so Microsoft can release Vista and they're still going to make tons of money.
1:06:59You know, they can release Windows 8, they're still going to be making tons of money.
1:07:02Their stock is higher now than it's been in years.
1:07:05That's an interesting point.
1:07:07And this is one of the reasons why Amazon has always had such a strong stock is like
1:07:11people view them as being untouchable, right?
1:07:15Like their core business, no one's going to threaten it.
1:07:20And Apple has always been viewed as, well, one bad break and they're in trouble.
1:07:25And that's why the Intendigate was a big deal to a lot of people, because there's this perception,
1:07:31"Well, is this it?
1:07:32Did they finally mess up?"
1:07:34And what I think they've missed and what most analysts miss is actually Apple could release
1:07:39a dud and they would be okay because their ecosystem advantage is so significant and
1:07:46it's so hard to, to catch up with that. Yeah, I totally
1:07:51agree. That's a good point. And I do think that there is like,
1:07:56as you know, circling back a couple of minutes, you know,
1:08:00segments ago, that I do think that it's finally starting to
1:08:05dawn on the, you know, investor world, you know, that Apple is
1:08:10not on the precipice, you know, yeah, I, you know, I still think
1:08:15you're going to see a lot of jackassery related to Apple.
1:08:19I still think that you're going to see, let's just say,
1:08:23they ship something that you wear on your wrist
1:08:26and it costs $300 and they sell 5 million of them,
1:08:31which I think is pretty reasonable for a new thing.
1:08:34Let's just say, I don't know, who knows what the device does?
1:08:36It's a dingus that you wear on your wrist
1:08:39and it sells for $300 and they sell 5 million of them.
1:08:42And there's going to be people who say,
1:08:44Multiply five million by three hundred dollars and say well that's nothing that that that averages out to zero for Apple
1:08:51Therefore Apple is doomed because they needed to sell 50 million of them which doesn't happen with new products. Mm-hmm, right
1:08:57You're still gonna see that to some degree, but I think that
1:09:01Most there's there's that it's gonna be the fringe that that holds on to that rather than the the conventional wisdom. Yep
1:09:12No, that's part of the what we talked about like there's kind of like this
1:09:15Apple had to go through the valley a little bit as far as like
1:09:19Perception goes and and this is something where I mean, I know I talked to I talked to some people who you know
1:09:25been long close watch of Apple and we're very nervous about
1:09:29Cook meeting with like Carl Carl icon and stuff like that and and really holding that up as a counter to what you know
1:09:36What jobs would have done?
1:09:37- Right, which is tell Carl I kinda go fuck himself.
1:09:40- Right, exactly.
1:09:41And, but I think this was,
1:09:44and I was sympathetic to the degree,
1:09:46I've always been very sympathetic to Cook's position
1:09:49that the stock price matters a lot for employee retention.
1:09:53It's kind of been my position,
1:09:56but I think what you're seeing now
1:09:58is that kind of effort paying off, right?
1:10:01Like Apple, I feel like Apple
1:10:04has gotten a lot more breathing room,
1:10:07exactly what you just said.
1:10:08And that actually is to, I think,
1:10:11Cook's credit quite a bit as well.
1:10:13- Yeah, I think it may be, you know,
1:10:15I don't wanna psychoanalyze him because, you know,
1:10:18I'm not a psychoanalyst and I'm too distant,
1:10:20but that there's something, you know, to be said
1:10:22that among the ways that Cook is a great CEO
1:10:25for Apple right now and ways that he is better
1:10:28than Steve Jobs is ego, right?
1:10:31That obviously, I mean, famously,
1:10:33I don't think it takes, you don't have to be a psychologist to say that Steve Jobs had
1:10:37a very large ego.
1:10:41I think while Apple was an upstart, it helped.
1:10:44It helped to have a rock star at the helm of the company.
1:10:49But doing something like going to dinner with Carl Icahn, that shows that not that Tim Cook
1:10:54doesn't have a large ego, but that he's willing to sublimate it.
1:10:58He's willing to say, "Look, I really doubt.
1:11:02I'll bet, I really doubt that he felt like going to dinner with Carl Icahn.
1:11:05But he did it because it was good for the company.
1:11:07I think there's a certain extraordinary diligence to the way Cook is doing that.
1:11:14A humility, maybe.
1:11:16Maybe that's a better word.
1:11:18That there's a humility to Tim Cook.
1:11:22Whether that's innate, whether that's partly his southern upbringing, I don't know.
1:11:26But one thing nobody would say about Steve Jobs is that he was humble.
1:11:29Well, and I think, you know, it's one of those things where it's super easy to look back on someone, right?
1:11:35And you only see the positive sides. But if Steve Jobs acted like Steve Jobs does, well, Apple is the most valuable company in the world.
1:11:43Like, you would like to think that everything is logical and like, no one, like, it's just a lot easier to see them getting themselves in trouble.
1:11:53whether it be with the government, whether it be with like, with other people, like, um,
1:11:58you know, the, whether it be the app store sort of stuff. I mean,
1:12:02I don't know what it would be, but that kind of imperiousness, um,
1:12:06where's much better to your point when you're,
1:12:09when you're the underdog as opposed to when you're the 800 pound gorilla. And,
1:12:13um, you know, when I was, when I w this was something that was talked about a lot,
1:12:17you know, I was there at, you know, the university was like,
1:12:19Like, we have to change, like, by virtue of being huge, we have changed.
1:12:28And we can either accept that and then try to figure out how to preserve what makes Apple
1:12:33Apple, or we can continue as we are, but that's actually a worse place to be, because we're
1:12:39kind of being blind about the reality, which is the fact that we're this massive company
1:12:43now.
1:12:44We can't, it can never be the way it was,
1:12:47just because things have changed, the world has changed.
1:12:51- Yeah, and I think the flip side of that exact same
1:12:55thinking is what I wrote about last month
1:12:57with the only Apple piece that I killed myself knocking out,
1:13:02and about the way that, you know,
1:13:05that I, it seems very clear to me that Tim Cook
1:13:08has brought about in the same way that the operations
1:13:12manufacturing has always been very very
1:13:15a well-oiled
1:13:17you know i use that a multi-part watch all works together that he's bringing
1:13:21that sort of efficiency to apples internals in cooper tino
1:13:25with divisions working together across you know that that
1:13:28things like just a perfect example the way that this extensions system is
1:13:32coming to you know seventy and i was a at the same time
1:13:36because they're working together i've i'd w_w_t_c_ i spoke to some of the
1:13:39engineers
1:13:41You know, and that Apple just was not set up that way.
1:13:43Those were silos previously.
1:13:45And it would have been, you know, they even called it the one time back to the Mac.
1:13:50It's like, okay, here's a bunch of stuff where iOS got ahead of the Mac.
1:13:54It's already shipped.
1:13:55It shipped last year, you know, in last year's version of iOS.
1:13:57Now we're bringing it to the Mac.
1:14:00Apple isn't working like that now.
1:14:02They're developing these things together, you know, and some of them are things that
1:14:05have to be done together like I keep forgetting the name of the
1:14:11feature but you know, hey, there's a web page in front of
1:14:13me and Safari on my Mac and I want to fling it over to my
1:14:16phone continuity continuity. Well, the continuity is the the
1:14:19the parent name for all of these features, but there's a specific
1:14:23name for handoff. Right? Yep. handoff is that is continuity is
1:14:27like the umbrella name for all of the features that are like
1:14:30this. Like answering a phone call on your Mac is part of
1:14:33continuity too. But they're all you know that it's you know and to me it's a
1:14:40realization that it's not just about Tim Cook having a different personality than
1:14:45Steve Jobs. I think it's about Apple being big enough that they can do things
1:14:51like this. Like it's not that let's say Apple circa 2003 or 2004 could have been
1:14:57operating like that or should have been operating like that under Steve Jobs and
1:15:01that Steve Jobs' mercurial nature kept them from doing it. They weren't big enough
1:15:05to do it yet, and they needed to be more focused. I think it was the right strategy. But they've
1:15:13crossed a certain chasm in terms of size where if they didn't embrace a more collaborative
1:15:20culture, they were missing an enormous opportunity, that they were leaving an enormous amount
1:15:27of wasted potential on the floor because they could be doing so much more in the same amount
1:15:33of time with a more collaborative culture than they would otherwise.
1:15:37So, here's the question though. I agree with you. I wrote a similar thing, but something
1:15:43that after your piece on my podcast exponent with James Allworth, we talked about this,
1:15:52Like, yeah, it's what's so fascinating, and you talked about Apple growing up, and I talked about them, you know, kind of forgetting like the 1997 mindset, you know, that was kind of holding them, holding them back.
1:16:06them back. And what's so striking about this is the language that we are using, and I literally
1:16:15went back and looked up articles and profiles, was the exact same language that was used for
1:16:19a company like Microsoft in the early 2000s. Like, "Oh, they've grown up. They're going to
1:16:24stop being bullies, and they're going to be more collaborative." And yes, again, I'm not saying
1:16:30Apple's Microsoft at all. There's lots of important differences. But it is worth thinking
1:16:38of. I'm just curious what you think, right? Steve Jobs said, "Stay hungry, stay foolish."
1:16:43But we're talking about them growing up and being a little less foolish. Do you worry
1:16:48at all that maybe there might be something that gets lost in this?
1:16:53Oh, definitely. I mean, worry is the wrong word, but I definitely file it under things
1:16:59to keep an eye on. Because I think it's uncharted territory. I don't think that they're following
1:17:06Microsoft's footsteps. And some people have… if there was any criticism of my only Apple
1:17:13piece, it was along the lines of how is this different from what Steve Ballmer taking over
1:17:20from Bill Gates, you know, and they, you know, first couple of, well, actually, the whole time,
1:17:26he did lead Microsoft to significantly higher revenue and profits on a consistent basis,
1:17:30while driving the, you know, a ship that with the product categories that were heading over a cliff,
1:17:37strategically, by being a little bit more conservative and, you know,
1:17:42focusing on what we already have, rather than new stuff.
1:17:44Well, I think that's not true, though, because Microsoft did know that mobile was next. And so,
1:17:50Yeah, but they didn't want to disrupt themselves and they didn't want to do mobile in a way
1:17:53that might decrease sales of Windows PCs.
1:17:57I think that's the fundamental difference.
1:17:58And that's, to me, is the thing that I don't worry about.
1:18:02If somebody came to Tim Cook with an idea that—I don't know what it would be, but
1:18:07clearly the sacred cow at Apple financially is the iPhone.
1:18:12I think it's over half of profits and half of revenue, even though the iPad is still
1:18:17growing and is huge and the Mac is doing very well. The iPhone is the thing. If they came
1:18:22up with something that would make people less likely to buy iPhones, I don't know what it
1:18:26would be. But if this is say a watch that is so it doesn't it's not a something that
1:18:31you Bluetooth tethered to your phone. It's just a watch and it would make people not
1:18:36buy iPhones. And it only costs $300 but it's so awesome that do it would genuinely drive
1:18:42a rational person to think I don't even need an iPhone anymore. I don't think Tim Cook
1:18:45would hesitate to do that, to go ahead with it. Because if somebody could do it, it might
1:18:50as, you know, that logic of being able to, you know, rather disrupting yourself than
1:18:55having somebody else disrupt you, it holds true. I think he has the common sense to think,
1:19:01well, you know, that's where it's going. You know, I don't think he would hesitate
1:19:04to chase that and pursue that.
1:19:06Yeah, I mean I think the best thing in support of that is probably the iPad, which is cheaper
1:19:16than a Mac and does cannibalize the Mac. I do think that...
1:19:20And I don't think they care, right? And it sells for a significantly lower average selling
1:19:25price than even the cheapest MacBook Air, let alone the average selling price of a regular
1:19:30MacBook.
1:19:31Right.
1:19:32probably half the price at least of average selling price. And I don't think Apple regrets
1:19:37it at one bit.
1:19:38Yeah, well they've increased volume, right?
1:19:41Right.
1:19:42I think the only hesitation I have is people always point to like, "Oh, the iPhone replaced
1:19:49the iPod." Well, the problem is they're making more money on iPhones than they were on one
1:19:53iPhone than they do on one iPod. So it's not a great example. That's why I like the iPad
1:19:57But it's interesting.
1:20:01The other reason I think that Apple is not Microsoft is Microsoft's strengths and advantages
1:20:09were not in the product.
1:20:14Microsoft has always been a marketing company.
1:20:16Where by marketing I mean not advertising, but they've always done a very good job of
1:20:21understanding their customers' needs and then building exactly what they want.
1:20:26And that's why they have all the backwards compatibility stuff and all the like multiple,
1:20:31all the driver issues and stuff.
1:20:32All that is because everything they do has been, they really have gone all bent over
1:20:39backwards to meet people's needs, right?
1:20:43But that doesn't work so well when it comes to consumer products where you can't ask every
1:20:49consumer what they want.
1:20:50You have to build like the right product and make them want it.
1:20:55I've always said that one of the things I think is underestimated is the importance
1:21:01of the exact order of your priorities. Even if you only care as an institution or even
1:21:07a person about three things, it really makes a difference which one's number one and which
1:21:12one's number two.
1:21:13Because there always come a decision where you have to choose.
1:21:15Right. Like all I really care about in life is, you know, or I don't know how to say it
1:21:21but let's say Apple. I still think that their number one priority is creating great products
1:21:27and great experiences for the users. And maybe number two is doing it at a profit because
1:21:34the profits sustain everything. But it makes a huge difference that one is in front of
1:21:40two and that all sorts of things fall out from that, especially in the long run.
1:21:45It's going to be interesting to see the...
1:21:48Because it's not that Microsoft doesn't care about experience.
1:21:51I just don't think that they place it quite as high in the priority list institutionally as Apple.
1:21:55And then there's, in the long run, there's been profound differences because of that.
1:22:00Well, and there's different kinds of experiences, right?
1:22:03To satisfy a business's needs, you often prioritize things other than like the end user experience of actually using the product, right?
1:22:14using the product, right?
1:22:15It's because the buyer is different than the user.
1:22:19And so you prioritize what the buyer values.
1:22:22And yeah, and I think that's the real kind of big difference
1:22:27between the consumer market and the business market
1:22:30is the end user is the buyer.
1:22:35And that, yeah, that makes Apple's strategy
1:22:38much more, much better, Apple's priorities,
1:22:42a much better match for the consumer market.
1:22:45- Here's another example.
1:22:46I'll give you an example that I think is very clear
1:22:48and that this month's Android Wear watches show.
1:22:53Google and OEMs like LG and Samsung plays a much higher,
1:23:02well, maybe not much, it's just a different order,
1:23:05but they place a higher priority on being first to market
1:23:09than Apple does.
1:23:11No doubt in my mind, and it's watches to me are proof of it, that they're clearly
1:23:17rushed.
1:23:18They're clunky.
1:23:19There's a lot of – you read the reviews, there's a lot of things that just are half-baked.
1:23:22You know, Joanna Stern had my favorite review of them in the Wall Street Journal.
1:23:29I guess it was last week, but great review.
1:23:32But right now, notifications are all or nothing.
1:23:35You either say all of your notifications from your phone go to your watch or none of them
1:23:40at least on an app-by-app basis. So it's like you either have if you want a
1:23:43notifications for incoming email on your phone then every time you get an email
1:23:46your wrist is gonna buzz which is maddening at least for some people like
1:23:50Joanna and it is for me because I've tried it with the pebble but you might
1:23:55want something like look just these two people my wife and my boss you know when
1:24:01they email me I want or like in Apple terms the VIP list right if my it just
1:24:06if there's nothing like that and of course it's going to come eventually but
1:24:09But that just seems like a, "Why would you buy that?"
1:24:12And then an even better example, the Moto 360, which is, to me, it's the most controversial
1:24:18product I can remember in years.
1:24:22Because so many people on the Android site are saying, "Now, here's a beautiful thing."
1:24:27And it's like, "No, it's not.
1:24:29It is not a beautiful thing."
1:24:31It is better looking than the other two clunkers so far from LG and Samsung, that's for sure.
1:24:38But it is not a beautiful thing.
1:24:40And that stupid bar at the bottom of the screen.
1:24:44Oh, it's awful.
1:24:45It's awful.
1:24:46Apple wouldn't ship that in a million years.
1:24:48And the only reason Motorola is shipping it is because it's rushed to market.
1:24:51Everything's relative, right?
1:24:52Right.
1:24:53Yeah, it looks great compared to the LG, but compared to my watch, it's...
1:24:57Right.
1:24:58And clearly, Motorola and the designers and the team that built that Moto 360 place a
1:25:01a higher priority on design than the idiots at LG and Samsung who made their watches.
1:25:09And even if they value design as much as Apple, they also have this higher priority of wanting
1:25:14to ship it as soon as possible. Clearly, I guess, in anticipation of Apple coming out
1:25:19with something, shipping it before Apple does. And so they were willing to compromise and
1:25:23ship this thing with a black bar at the bottom of the circle, which is ridiculous.
1:25:26So here's what's interesting is, you know, because the counter would be, "Oh, that's okay, we're going to iterate, we want to learn from the market."
1:25:32But in the meantime, they're charging people $225 for these things.
1:25:36Well, it's not just that, though, because think about it. If you actually realize that you only want notifications for one to two people, do you then need a screen?
1:25:51Well, that's a good question. Let's come back to that
1:25:53Let me thank our third sponsor and then we'll do one more segment on the show and we'll start with with that with the watches
1:25:58I want to thank another
1:26:00Long time friend of the show our good friends at igloo the intranet you'll actually like
1:26:07I was listening to
1:26:09ATP podcast
1:26:11this week and
1:26:13I'm just gonna steal the line from Marco which is that it's always a good if there's ever anything in your life
1:26:18that's annoying. It's a great idea for new products in general. If you can find something
1:26:21where all of your options are annoying and you can think of a way to build a version
1:26:25that's not annoying and doesn't suck, that's generally a good idea. Well, that's what Igloo
1:26:30has done with intranets. Intranets suck. Igloo has attacked the problem and built an intranet
1:26:37product that doesn't suck. They have a new update that's coming soon. We've talked about
1:26:44it on the show before. It's called Unicorn and it has a ton of new features. But the
1:26:48best part of it is integrated task management that will change the way you stay on track
1:26:53with work. Igloo tasks can be assigned in different ways depending on the work you're
1:26:57doing. One of the coolest ways to use tasks is creating them directly on your content.
1:27:03Why do you need this? Well, you're requesting updates on a graphic or a text correction
1:27:08on a Word document. You can create these tasks right on your content so your team can stay
1:27:12up to date with what has to be done next to update the graphic or edit the text.
1:27:18When you're viewing content, even if it's a blog entry, an event, a form topic inside
1:27:22your igloo, these tasks are all right there, informing everyone of all the tasks that have
1:27:28been completed and what needs additional work.
1:27:31You can assign tasks to yourself, to teammates.
1:27:34You can comment on the tasks and you can keep all the changes in one place.
1:27:38feature. I think this is, it's obviously turned Igloo into more than just an internet. It's
1:27:43more of a project management platform for your small teams. Really great stuff. It's
1:27:48a free update for all Igloo customers. It's coming this summer. You can learn more about
1:27:54it. Here's where you go. Igloosoftware.com/talkshow. They've got all sorts of great stuff too.
1:28:02I always throw this out there. It's free for up to 10 people, not free for like a month,
1:28:07free period for up to 10 people. No obligation. So if you have a team of people working together,
1:28:15go check them out igloosoftware.com/thetalkshow. That's a great point. I think bottom line
1:28:24is I think you were saying about do you need if you only want notification for one or two
1:28:28people do you need a screen on your wrist? To me the answer is no. I don't think so.
1:28:34Just before we actually get into that, and I'd actually love your take, as we've established back and forth, your product sense is much better than mine.
1:28:42But what's interesting though about these guys rushing to market is they can say that, "Oh, we're just iterating."
1:28:50But now they're locked into this paradigm, right?
1:28:52If it turns out that the best sort of secondary device needs only to be screenless, for example,
1:29:02Like, now they're like, now they're kind of like, it's like they've sailed up a dead end.
1:29:06Now it's not just that they need to iterate, they actually need to backtrack and like re,
1:29:11you know, they've actually put themselves more behind than they might have been otherwise.
1:29:15So that's what would make something like that particularly interesting if they actually were
1:29:20pursuing the wrong paradigm to start out with. I'm not saying they are, it's just—
1:29:24Pete: I don't know, but I can't help but think that they are. And, you know,
1:29:27Joanna Stern's review just went, just explicitly called it, you know, what I think it looks like is they've taken modern smartphones and shrunk them to two inches and put them on a wristband and now they go on your wrist.
1:29:39And we saw that worked with mobile, right? That's what Microsoft did. Taking it, taking this conversation full circle. They tried, they literally had a start button.
1:29:47That's true. In the lower left, lower left.
1:29:50Right.
1:29:51And I think they might have had it on the upper left just to switch it up a little bit.
1:29:56- Oh, maybe they did, yeah.
1:29:57But it was the same thing though.
1:29:59Tap the start button and get a start menu and go from there.
1:30:02- Right, and so I really do think
1:30:04their mobile shortcomings were first and foremost
1:30:08because they just made a bad product.
1:30:10And they made a bad product
1:30:11because they couldn't break out of desktop thinking.
1:30:15And to me, this is by far the biggest criticism
1:30:18of Android Wear.
1:30:19I have a few criticisms, but the biggest one is
1:30:21it's Windows Mobile 2.0.
1:30:24It's taking a smartphone and cramming it onto your wrist.
1:30:28And I, anytime you're shifting a paradigm
1:30:32or shifting a device, like I think we,
1:30:36tech history isn't that old,
1:30:38but I think we can say pretty confidently
1:30:40that you have to change everything.
1:30:42And they haven't done that.
1:30:44And yeah, I'm, for that reason alone,
1:30:47plus some other reasons, I'm very skeptical.
1:30:50- You know, and I've gotten some emails,
1:30:52and I love them, I do.
1:30:54And I know that my audience, that there's a,
1:30:57just human nature is such that,
1:30:58and modern media is such that whether it's,
1:31:01you know, like national politics or whether it's tech,
1:31:04that people tend to, they enjoy reading the things
1:31:08that come from the people who already think
1:31:09the way they think.
1:31:11But I do, I love the people who are like big Android fans
1:31:13who read "Daring Fireball."
1:31:15'Cause their feedback to me, they seldom change my mind,
1:31:20but I always consider it, and it's, you know,
1:31:22To me, it's a great perspective.
1:31:24And I've already gotten some emails from people
1:31:26who were at IO and have one of these Wear watches already
1:31:31and they say that they like it.
1:31:32I've probably gotten more such emails
1:31:36than I've ever gotten from people
1:31:37who tell me that glass is actually for good.
1:31:40(laughing)
1:31:41- Well, you're talking about relativity
1:31:44and setting little bars.
1:31:45- Basically, saying, you know what, I think it's great.
1:31:49I love having my notifications on my wrist.
1:31:51People love Windows Mobile.
1:31:52- Right, yeah.
1:31:53I just don't think it's,
1:31:54I don't dispute that there are some number of people
1:31:57who do like getting their notifications on their wrist
1:32:00and just looking at it.
1:32:01And my big thing with the Pebble
1:32:03that I just thought was the deal breaker was that,
1:32:07okay, I tried boring the Pebble and God bless them,
1:32:10I love their gumption.
1:32:13But you get a notification
1:32:15and if it was something you had to act on,
1:32:18you had to take your phone out, right?
1:32:21So it's, you know, the one time I was wearing a pebble,
1:32:24the one time I wore it for a couple of weeks,
1:32:27that it was actually useful as I was driving my car
1:32:30and I was going to pick up my son at school
1:32:33and I got a text from my wife,
1:32:34and I forget what it was said,
1:32:36but it was something, it was actually useful
1:32:38for me to get the text, but I needed to text her back.
1:32:41So I had to, and I do this, I'm literally,
1:32:44I'm like a fanatic about it.
1:32:45I will not use my phone while I'm driving a car.
1:32:47I had to pull over and park the car for a second
1:32:51and then text her.
1:32:53It wasn't that much better than just feeling
1:32:55the phone vibrate and waiting until I got to the school
1:32:59and take the phone out and see the text.
1:33:02It wasn't an emergency, it was not an emergency thing,
1:33:04it was just, but I had to write her back.
1:33:06The thing that the wear has is they have the talk,
1:33:09so that if you do get a text and your hands are free,
1:33:11you can speak your reply to the thing.
1:33:15So there is that and that's a huge step over Pebble.
1:33:18But to me, it is not an inconvenience to me.
1:33:22It's never felt like a burden to me to take my phone out when I feel a buzz.
1:33:26Well, I mean, I think they've solved a problem that I don't think many people have.
1:33:31And I can't tell you how many people have told me over the years, all this time that
1:33:34watches have been rumored as the next area of innovation in text, I can't even count
1:33:39the number of emails and tweets I've gotten from people who say, "I used to wear a watch.
1:33:44were a watch when I was in college, whatever.
1:33:47Haven't won a watch since I started carrying a cell phone.
1:33:49I wanna know the time, I just take my phone out.
1:33:51- So what's interesting is I do think
1:33:53where it makes a big difference actually is for women,
1:33:56especially if they carry their phone in their bags.
1:33:59I mean--
1:34:01- That's a very good point, right?
1:34:03That it's harder to find a phone in a bag
1:34:07than it is to find a phone in your front pocket.
1:34:08- Yep, and actually in Asia, most men carry bags as well.
1:34:12Like that's actually another reason why the bigger phones
1:34:14are a thing.
1:34:16- And so they've made these watches
1:34:18that are so appealing to women.
1:34:20- No, but that's the point.
1:34:22So actually, probably the best market is women
1:34:25and these are, yeah.
1:34:26The video, the listeners have to watch
1:34:30the Joanna Stern video.
1:34:31- Right, I'll put it in the show notes.
1:34:33- We won't give it away, it's really great.
1:34:38Which addresses that point specifically.
1:34:41But anyway, the one thing that watches have been best at, ever since they were invented,
1:34:45is telling time. That's the one thing everybody, I think, would agree is the one thing that,
1:34:49you know, it's the definition of a watch. Everything else, every other complication
1:34:53on a watch is like a secondary feature. Primary purpose is to find out what time it is. And
1:34:59I think for most people, the phone has proven to be a good enough solution. And that, you
1:35:08you know i can't tell you how many people told me that that the one thing
1:35:10watches specialize in
1:35:12people like i always have myself on my pocket i don't wear a watch anymore
1:35:15let alone
1:35:17let alone everything else like people who might be texting you pictures and
1:35:21longer texts and
1:35:23you know uh...
1:35:25even on screenshots you know that i don't know there's just so many so many
1:35:28bizarre compromises in the design of this where and the pebbles the same way
1:35:32where it shows so few characters because
1:35:35you know it's a tiny little you know
1:35:38one point six inch display
1:35:40and you can't just can't show even like a text message is hard to fit on
1:35:43and once yeah
1:35:44uh... the other thing that is
1:35:46like there's one thing watches are better at and even then people are
1:35:49going to wear them
1:35:50right why would they were them for something that
1:35:52it's worse that
1:35:53and it's you know and and again repeating myself everybody's made this
1:35:57point but it's also very decidedly
1:36:00uh... a generational thing
1:36:02where the younger you are, the less like you are
1:36:07to have ever worn a watch,
1:36:09and therefore why would I do that?
1:36:10Why would I buy a thing that just tells me the time?
1:36:12I always know the time I've got my phone with me.
1:36:14- So I increasingly feel, again,
1:36:18I don't have a great product sense,
1:36:19but just kind of thinking through this stuff through,
1:36:22is one, I think there's gonna be a range.
1:36:27I don't think there is AI watch or animal watch.
1:36:30There's gonna be a whole bunch of devices there might be rings there might be watches there might be clips there might be
1:36:35like you literally might be like ten different things actually um and
1:36:39Two I think most of them won't have screens. Maybe there will be one or two that do but um I
1:36:45Don't know that that's kind of thing. Yeah
1:36:48I don't know I especially screens as we know them which are enormous energy hogs and which is the reason why your
1:36:54Gear watch has to or Android wear watch has to be charged daily
1:36:59And I know, I think I said this last week when Whiskas was on the show, but I just think
1:37:04people are, I think so many tech people are vastly, vastly overestimating what an enormous
1:37:11burden is to carry even a single device that needs charging daily. And we've all made this
1:37:17decision. We all have decided that having these modern cell phones is important enough
1:37:23to do it. But it's an enormous burden. And every time you go to the airport and you see
1:37:27people sitting, grown men in suits sitting on the floor so they can be near an electrical
1:37:32socket. That's for one device, right? Asking people to have a second device that you need
1:37:38to charge on a daily basis and one which requires a proprietary weirdo charger thing that you
1:37:45have to somehow carry around with you is, again, I'm not saying it's impossible, you
1:37:52know, clearly the cell phone river. If it's possible to get
1:37:56everybody to carry one device that needs charging daily. It's
1:37:59possible to make them have to, but don't underestimate just how
1:38:03crazy it is that we've convinced everybody to carry even one
1:38:06device that needs charging. Yeah,
1:38:07I don't think so. I mean, because you just said you just
1:38:09said it exactly right. If that one device can do what that
1:38:12other device. Yeah,
1:38:12exactly. It was show notifications like you reply to
1:38:16them. But
1:38:16like we were convincing me even more like I really don't think
1:38:20there's gonna be a screen because like,
1:38:22you know, there's a, you think about it a few ways.
1:38:25Like, well, one, just imagine the showmanship, right?
1:38:27It's gonna be like the whole like,
1:38:28the iPhone has no buttons,
1:38:30while the iWatch has no screen.
1:38:32But I think you have to think about it.
1:38:34Like, you think back to the iPod.
1:38:36Like, what made the iPod so transformative?
1:38:40It was that it removed features from music players, right?
1:38:44There were music players on the market,
1:38:46but they had all these fiddly things to change controls.
1:38:49I mean, yes, part of it was the thousand songs in the pocket
1:38:51and the design, but a big part of it was iTunes.
1:38:55It was that all this complex management stuff
1:38:59was removed from the device
1:39:01and put on a much more suitable device.
1:39:03- Yeah, using it felt like going downhill, not uphill.
1:39:07- Right, exactly.
1:39:08Like, all it did was like what only it could do,
1:39:11which was play music on the go.
1:39:13And actually managing playlists
1:39:14and all that sort of stuff you did on your computer.
1:39:17And over time that changed.
1:39:20Like now my phone has never been connected
1:39:23to my computer, right?
1:39:24But that took like over a decade, right?
1:39:27I think watches or these wearables
1:39:31are gonna start the same way.
1:39:32Like their function will be something
1:39:34that only they can do, that a watch cannot do.
1:39:37It's probably, some of it's gonna be the sensor stuff,
1:39:39some of it's gonna be, I think that,
1:39:40I do think there'll be a notification thing,
1:39:42but it will be the like only your favorites.
1:39:45Like you can do favorites on your phone,
1:39:46those will be the only ones. And people will bitch and moan about how limited it is. But,
1:39:51and then all the other stuff will be on the phone. There won't be, I don't think there will be,
1:39:56there will be minimal, if any, duplication between what one does and what the other does.
1:40:01And on the flip side, I think Apple is going to try to make these not tech devices that look good,
1:40:08but fashion accessories that happen to have electronic functions.
1:40:13them. Right. You've got to work backwards. And it's a, you know, I'll paraphrase it,
1:40:16but it's a Steve Jobs quote that you've got to work backwards from the experience,
1:40:23what it is you want to do to the technology and not the other way around. And to me, these
1:40:27Android Wear devices are exactly the opposite. It's starting with, and Google even said this
1:40:33explicitly on stage at I/O, it's now possible to build a smartphone-like device that fits
1:40:39on your wrist. And it's true that that wasn't possible before. That it's, it's, you know,
1:40:45great increases in miniaturization, great increases in, you know, it, you know, just the ability to
1:40:52power the power of this little tiny screens, even for a day does require new technology.
1:40:58And Bluetooth LTE is new technology so that you can actually maintain a tethered connection.
1:41:03Even if you know, one day's battery life is crappy, I think for a watch, but it says something
1:41:08that you can keep a Bluetooth and all the reviews indicate that you do get a full day
1:41:13out of the thing. That's new technology. But it's all working backwards from we can do
1:41:17this so let's do it and here it is instead of starting with what would actually be a
1:41:22good experience for a thing you wear on your wrist and what would look good.
1:41:25Dave Asprey No, exactly. I do, I have one more question
1:41:29for you. That I'm actually curious your take on. So that's my, we just nailed my big criticism
1:41:35and Android Wear and Wear I don't think, like I think it's a misstep. I think it's Windows
1:41:41Mobile. My other question is what you think about Google now.
1:41:48I, you know, I think it's, I wrote just a little thing about it when I linked to Joanna
1:41:56Stern's review today. But I do think that's where there's the
1:42:00most potential in Android or Google based wearables is that
1:42:09Google to me, I think has best of breed speech understanding
1:42:15speaking.
1:42:15Oh, yeah, it's amazing. It works every single time.
1:42:18Yeah. And I think Siri has gotten better. I really do. I
1:42:21use it all the time walking, walking around the city while
1:42:24while texting, I'll do use the speech and I serious the umbrella term, not Siri, the
1:42:28intelligent agent, but Siri, the hit the microphone next to the spacebar to dictate a text. It's
1:42:35gotten better, it's gotten more accurate, and it has gotten the latencies improved,
1:42:39and it works better over cellular, but it still is not as good as Google's. And that's
1:42:42because I think Google's is isn't standing still on that either. Right? Best of breed,
1:42:46Google's best best of breed for speaking to a device and understanding it quickly. And
1:42:52I think there's a lot of potential there for wearables.
1:42:55But my problem is I don't buy into the,
1:42:57let Google know everything about me.
1:42:59I don't use Google Calendar.
1:43:00I don't want Google knowing my location.
1:43:04I'm genuinely creeped out by all of that.
1:43:06- Well, what if you weren't creeped out though?
1:43:08Like, do you think that's something
1:43:09that you would find useful?
1:43:11I mean, the reason I ask is to me,
1:43:15I feel this is a,
1:43:17there's a really interesting interview
1:43:20with Vinod Khosla of Khosla Ventures and Larry Page and Sergey Brin earlier this week.
1:43:28And they talk about this a bit.
1:43:30And I feel there's just a fundamentally different view of computing between Google and Apple.
1:43:37And it really is personified right now more than anything by Siri versus Google Now.
1:43:41Yeah, I think that's a good point.
1:43:43I think I know where you're going with that.
1:43:44And part of it is I've been reading these reviews of the Wear devices.
1:43:48And a lot of what you see on them isn't what you've asked for.
1:43:51It's what Google thinks you want to see.
1:43:53Right.
1:43:54And like Google…
1:43:55You don't say, "Show me my flight."
1:43:57It…
1:43:58You've put your flight in your calendar and at a certain point Google says, "Hey,
1:44:02you've got a 1 p.m. flight and it's 1030 in the morning and it's going to take you
1:44:07at least 45 minutes to get there."
1:44:10And it comes up…
1:44:11You didn't ask for it, does it?
1:44:12And I've seen a couple of reviews mention weather is like that.
1:44:15Like, you'll get like a weather thing and once you dismiss it, you can't make it come
1:44:19back.
1:44:20There's no way to say, "Show me that weather card I just dismissed."
1:44:22They show you the weather when they think you'd want to know about the weather.
1:44:26And I think I would find that maddening.
1:44:28Well, yeah, one thing that was interesting that…
1:44:31No, exactly.
1:44:32It's they… their view is anticipating your needs and like taking care of them for
1:44:39you.
1:44:40it really is a um...
1:44:42uh... you know, Larry Page said like that's why the "I'm feeling lucky" button was there
1:44:46because "I'm feeling lucky" is what Google...
1:44:48that's Google's ideal vision of Google search
1:44:51is that actually everyone always can hit "I feel lucky" because it will always serve
1:44:55exactly the right result
1:44:57and
1:44:58but their vision now is even past that it's like you don't even have to type
1:45:01something in the box like they will know what you want and give it to you
1:45:04and it's like
1:45:05it really is uh...
1:45:07uh...
1:45:08Benedict Evans, we mentioned earlier, posted a tweet during Google I/O of saying,
1:45:14he posted a picture of the scene from Wall-E, where everyone's fat and sitting in chairs,
1:45:20and all their needs are being addressed. He's like, "Oh, Google and Apple are racing here."
1:45:24And I wrote in a piece, I'm like, "Actually, I think Google is going there,
1:45:29but I think Apple is very explicitly not going there."
1:45:33And it goes back to Steve Jobs saying the computer is a bicycle, right?
1:45:38A bicycle is still subject to a human's direction and a human's propulsion.
1:45:44It just enhances that.
1:45:47It's not a self-driving car taking you where you want to go.
1:45:52And you see that with Siri.
1:45:54Siri doesn't anticipate your needs.
1:45:56It only responds to questions.
1:45:58And I don't think that's a technical limitation.
1:46:01I think it's a philosophical one.
1:46:03And to me, I think that's something that is really
1:46:08a question of who's going to own the future.
1:46:10Because if Google's right, they will own the future,
1:46:13because they're so far ahead of everyone.
1:46:17But if computers stay a tool, then Apple and their user
1:46:25experience and all that sort of stuff
1:46:27will continue to differentiate them.
1:46:29Yeah, maybe it's not either or either. Maybe it's a bifurcation and one group of, depending
1:46:39on your personality, is drawn to one side and one's drawn to another. And it comes back
1:46:43to, I think, what Benedict Evans had written this week about that ever since 2007, iOS
1:46:52and Android have been converging and that they've been picking up the same feed. Google
1:46:57picked up Drag From The Top for notifications first and then Apple picked it up and Android
1:47:03picked up a whole bunch of features from that iOS. It was way ahead of them as the years
1:47:07went on. But then eventually they picked up all—both of them got all the low hanging
1:47:10fruit and with this year's iOS 8 and Android L announcements, now you're seeing them
1:47:15go in different directions. I think you're talking about the same sort of thing, I think.
1:47:22Maybe they're both sustainable. Maybe it's not, but that they appeal to very different
1:47:26people. I don't know. I think one of the most telling things I've read about Android Wear,
1:47:30I haven't written about it yet, but it was Ron Amadeo's review in Ars Technica of Android Wear,
1:47:39just the software, which when I first started reading it, I thought I expected to roll my
1:47:45eyes because I thought it was a weird idea to review the software in the abstract as opposed
1:47:53to the actual experience of the watches it on the actual devices but you know to
1:48:00their credit ours did have reviews of the watches but and Ron's review of just
1:48:05Android where was interesting because it just sort of focused on the philosophy
1:48:08of it and yet you know it emphasized these things that a lot of what you see
1:48:12on it is what Google thinks you want to see and that you know and he mentioned
1:48:17specifically with the weather that it was frustrating that you couldn't just
1:48:20bring it back up. And that to me would be maddening, but I think it's also very telling
1:48:25about the philosophy behind it. And I think you're exactly right, that it is, philosophical
1:48:35differences is that exactly. And I saw the interview, I didn't read the whole thing,
1:48:40but I saw the interview with, where was that? I should probably link that up too, the interview
1:48:44with Sergey. I think the gist of it was that he was saying that eventually the algorithms
1:48:49are going to be smarter than us.
1:48:51Right.
1:48:51I mean, it really-- it's interesting, too.
1:48:53And I think this is part of the thing why Google tends
1:48:59to have such a hold on geeks in general,
1:49:02is it's always been a very geeky domain.
1:49:07Geeks aren't afraid of AI.
1:49:09They're not afraid of robots.
1:49:11They're intrigued by them.
1:49:12They're drawn to them like moths to a flame.
1:49:15And Google has always been very much in that sort of vibe.
1:49:20But what's really interesting and is going to be--
1:49:23you see it starting to play out now, it's going to play out even more--
1:49:25is as tech has kind of spent the last 30 years eating itself, right?
1:49:30We disrupt each other and all that sort of stuff.
1:49:33But now as it's touching every part of society,
1:49:36you're getting people who don't think about this, who really
1:49:39do see computers as tools, right?
1:49:42They help them get stuff done.
1:49:45now they're encountering this, they're encountering stuff like Facebook and the testing and all that, which to most geeks it's A/B testing, but to someone else it's like, what the hell is going on here, right?
1:49:55And I think it's going to be really interesting to see as this kind of collision happens with society as a whole and they start waking up to this kind of like, what is almost we're used to,
1:50:08I suspect that actually that I obviously think it's going to play out more in the computers as tools and it's on most people view them and want them to operate.
1:50:19But maybe Google's right and people do want, you know, personal assistance.
1:50:25All right, and that algorithms can deliver a satisfying...
1:50:30Superior.
1:50:31Yeah, or superior, right.
1:50:33I mean, that's the whole...
1:50:34I mean, it's not even new.
1:50:35It's not...
1:50:36It's certainly not a new direction for Google.
1:50:37It's new terrain in the same direction.
1:50:42You know, like Google News, that's the whole point between Google News is that you could...
1:50:46Which, you know, I don't think it's a major product for them anymore, but the basic idea
1:50:50behind it that Google could algorithmically predict the most important news and the news,
1:50:56I guess, personalized that would be most appealing to you as opposed to the editors of the New
1:51:01York Times or the Verge for technology or whatever.
1:51:08What's so interesting though is Google's big product still is today is search. And search
1:51:14is actually much more, if we're going to call this divide like an Apple-Google divide, it's
1:51:18much more on the Apple side of things. It's directed. You go there and you put in a word
1:51:24and you click the button or you press enter.
1:51:26Right. It's the one Google product that Steve Jobs has adamantly said is a great product.
1:51:30Exactly. It's funny because what Google is pushing for is actually different than what
1:51:38their big successful product is.
1:51:40Yeah. Yeah. That's a great point. I agree with that. Briefly, because I don't want to
1:51:45go past the two hour mark.
1:51:46But one last thing I wanted to speak to you about while I had
1:51:49you, and I'd loathe it if I didn't,
1:51:51is that just yesterday it broke that Apple has hired--
1:52:01Yeah, Tag Heuer, the sales director.
1:52:03Yeah, sales director, sales executive
1:52:05from Tag Heuer, a high end luxury watch brand,
1:52:09which is part of-- it's not like an independent brand.
1:52:11It's part of--
1:52:12LVMH.
1:52:13LVMH, which is Louis Vuitton.
1:52:15What's the MH stand for?
1:52:16- I always get the M wrong, 'cause H is Hennessy.
1:52:18It's a Mo, I think it's like the champagne brand
1:52:22or something, isn't it?
1:52:23- Well, it's a--
1:52:24- I get this wrong every single time.
1:52:25- Oh, I know the, all right.
1:52:26So, but anyway, French conglomerate
1:52:28that owns Louis Vuitton, Hennessy, you know,
1:52:32true conglomerate, 'cause it's part of their stuff is--
1:52:34- Moet, M-O-E-T with the little, with omelet on it.
1:52:37- Right, so, you know, I think it's fair to say
1:52:40that any company that owns both Louis Vuitton
1:52:42and the champagne and cognac brand is a conglomerate.
1:52:47But obviously there's a certain, you know, it's luxury.
1:52:52It's quality, it's branding.
1:52:56They've hired a sales executive from Tag Heuer.
1:53:00And that joins Paul Deneve who came from Yves Saint Lawrence
1:53:04and most famously Angela Arenz.
1:53:06- Burberry. - Burberry.
1:53:11And I wrote about this and said that I would include Jimmy,
1:53:15Yovine, and Dr. Dre in that group.
1:53:17And that's all I said last night.
1:53:19And I got a lot of stuff like,
1:53:20ah, Beats isn't a luxury brand.
1:53:23And I realized luxury is the wrong word.
1:53:24And this is the clarifying thing I added today,
1:53:28is that I include Yovine and Dr. Dre
1:53:30because I don't think Beats is a luxury brand,
1:53:32but I don't think luxury is the right word
1:53:34to explain these hires.
1:53:35It's about some kind of like circling around taste,
1:53:39style, branding.
1:53:41Yes, see, Beats is a luxury brand, though.
1:53:43It's a luxury brand the same way Apple is a luxury brand.
1:53:45Right, well, and then I even said,
1:53:48here's where I think when people say I'm worried about this,
1:53:50I'm worried about the direction Apple's going,
1:53:51is think about this.
1:53:52The iPhone is nothing like Virtu,
1:53:55where you buy like a $6,000 Symbian phone,
1:53:58and it's got leather and jewels on it.
1:54:02And Beats isn't like Virtu either, right?
1:54:03Because I never see people walking down
1:54:05the street with Virtu phones.
1:54:07But every single day in Philadelphia,
1:54:08I see people wearing-- especially,
1:54:10it's certainly come to my attention since Apple bought them. I see them every day. I
1:54:14see people wearing Beats every single day in Philadelphia. And Virtu's not like that.
1:54:19Beats is like an Apple luxury brand where it's accessible luxury.
1:54:23Right. And depending on your taste in music, it's as good of-- people are going to crucify
1:54:29me for this. It's as good of a performance you can get, right? People like that sound.
1:54:34I know it's not technically accurate.
1:54:36Right. It's, you know, it's, you know--
1:54:39The point is most people don't feel like they're sacrificing.
1:54:42To use a virtue, you're sacrificing.
1:54:45You're not using an iPhone.
1:54:46Right, exactly.
1:54:47Or they make androids and all that.
1:54:50And don't you think there's some quality in a certain sense?
1:54:55Somebody told me, for example, and this is the sort of thing, I don't know a lot about
1:54:58headphones.
1:54:59I really didn't know a lot about Beats before Apple bought them.
1:55:00But one guy wrote me and said, "You know why I buy Beats headphones?
1:55:03They have an amazing return policy and they take care of you."
1:55:07He said, "I bought a pair of Beats, cost me 300 bucks, and like nine months later they
1:55:10broke and I took them back and they just took them and gave me a new pair.
1:55:13No questions asked."
1:55:14And he goes, "That's, it can't be Beat and you don't get that sort of thing from other
1:55:18companies."
1:55:19Yeah.
1:55:20Making people happy and building a relationship.
1:55:23I don't know a ton about Beats specifically, but what strikes me about these…
1:55:29Yeah, I'm more interested not in your take on Beats, but just on the hiring of, you know,
1:55:35or two could be an outlier but it seems to be a trend.
1:55:37Yeah, I mean to me that suggests one that the wearable thing is multiple things. Two,
1:55:44that they're focused on fashion first.
1:55:48Yeah, you know I missed that word. Fashion is an important word, I think.
1:55:52But three, I thought it was most interesting that this guy was the sales director.
1:55:56Yep, I thought so too.
1:55:57Because that's a completely different kettle of fish than retail which they already do
1:56:03or the CEO, which you could certainly see him tie more into the product side of things.
1:56:08But this guy is not doing product.
1:56:10He's not actually making the things.
1:56:11He's selling things.
1:56:12He presumably has connections with these Asian department stores that sell LVMH products
1:56:20or with the duty-free shops over here that-- I'm not over here anymore-- but that sell--
1:56:29that sell champagne, that sell all the perfumes.
1:56:34I think Christian Dior is part of them
1:56:36and all that sort of stuff.
1:56:38That's super interesting because it's not just
1:56:41that Apple's doing a new product,
1:56:42but they're talking about a new channel,
1:56:43a new distribution strategy.
1:56:45And I would suspect that errands would have a lot to say
1:56:49about that as well.
1:56:50Because the traditional Burberry outlet,
1:56:54yes, they are in the same place as Apple stores.
1:56:56Apple stores have been in malls and stuff like that.
1:56:59Like, there's not a Burberry in your typical suburban mall.
1:57:04There is a Burberry in like the, you know,
1:57:08the Hong Kong airport or like the Taipei 101 building,
1:57:11which is like these super high-end shopping destinations.
1:57:15- Right, or like the shops at Caesars
1:57:18right in the middle of the most,
1:57:20the best intersection of the strip in Vegas.
1:57:22- Right, and Apple does do that internationally
1:57:25with their stores.
1:57:27So this is something that's really interesting too,
1:57:28that's really interesting about analyzing Apple.
1:57:31And I wanted to get this, it's like,
1:57:34it differs by region, right?
1:57:36The way Apple presents itself in the US
1:57:40is different than they're presented in,
1:57:42like China, for example,
1:57:43where it's much more of a luxury good
1:57:45and their stores are next to,
1:57:47it's next to the Louis Vuitton store,
1:57:49whereas in the US it's famously,
1:57:51they're always next to Victoria's Secrets.
1:57:54It's just a different, it's a different presentation and--
1:57:58But yet they also have, for example, a true flagship destination store on Fifth Avenue
1:58:05in New York.
1:58:06Oh, for sure. Yeah, they do both in the US.
1:58:08They do both, right. They're right there on Fifth Avenue with the true flagship, you
1:58:13know, almost sickening when you see how many people take pictures in front of it with all
1:58:19the other landmarks in New York. But yet, at the same time, they're at the Burlington
1:58:24Mall in New Hampshire.
1:58:26And the other thing is this is why Apple will never release a low-end iPhone, right?
1:58:32Because that would hurt their brand in other parts of the world.
1:58:40And so it's super interesting, hiring the sales guy, because that also makes me think
1:58:47that you're not going to get into these stores selling a smartwatch that looks good.
1:58:53You're gonna get in these stores by selling a desirable object that also has this functionality.
1:59:02And that's, again, I don't see there being a bulky screen on it.
1:59:06I don't see there being a charger with it.
1:59:07I think I see it being something that's very, a range of things.
1:59:12I don't know.
1:59:13It's super interesting.
1:59:14Yeah.
1:59:15Let me correct myself.
1:59:16Rockingham Mall, Rockingham Park.
1:59:18That's where I used to go to the Apple Store when I lived up in Massachusetts.
1:59:21It's great that we know more about suburban malls than we do the names of luxury goods
1:59:24companies.
1:59:25In beautiful Salem, New Hampshire.
1:59:28Yeah, I totally agree.
1:59:30And like I said, I stand by this.
1:59:32I really do.
1:59:33In the weeks since I wrote it, I really do think that it has to start with a design that
1:59:41before you even see what it does, when you hold it up, that you say, "Ooh, I might
1:59:44buy that and wear it."
1:59:45Yep.
1:59:46It has to.
1:59:47that sounds, there's a certain logical minded engineering mindset out there.
1:59:55And I think sort of people who might be drawn more towards the Google side of things than
2:00:00the Apple side of things who thinks that's crazy.
2:00:03Why in the world would you, why would that matter?
2:00:06It's function first, right?
2:00:08And I'm telling you that for me, and I think for the mass market, you've got to start with
2:00:12something where you just hold it up and before you turn it on, people say, "Oh, I want that."
2:00:16I hate to say it, I think the iPhone was like that.
2:00:20And I think the most amazing thing about the iPhone was what the software did and how the
2:00:24screen worked.
2:00:25But I think it could have just held that up and not even turned the screen on and said,
2:00:29"Here's the iPhone."
2:00:30And people would have been like, "Oh, where do I get in line?"
2:00:32So what's interesting is this takes it full circle, right?
2:00:34Because we just talked about the beginning where the hardware actually wasn't Apple's
2:00:38most important thing, it was the software.
2:00:40But in a lot of ways, for a new category, it's the hardware that gets you in the door.
2:00:45And then you hook people and now they're stuck on the software and they're not going anywhere.
2:00:51Right.
2:00:52Yeah.
2:00:53It's never, never…
2:00:54There are certain areas where the software is more important and certain areas where
2:00:57the hardware is more important, but it never, never…
2:00:59You're always in trouble if you start saying that Apple is either a hardware company that
2:01:04does software well or a software company that does hardware well.
2:01:09You got to see it as a virtuous cycle.
2:01:12Neither is more important than the other.
2:01:13just there's certain aspects of the product cycle where one is more important than the
2:01:18other. All right, let's call that a show. Ben Thompson. Thank you. Where can people
2:01:23find more people who want more Ben Thompson can go to let's say there's Stratechery.
2:01:27Ben Thompson 0:
2:01:27Stratechery. S T R A T E C H E R Y.com.
2:01:31Trenton Larkin Yeah, just Google Ben Thompson blog.
2:01:33Ben Thompson 0.0 0.0
2:01:34Ben Thompson I show up. I show up at first people always give me a hard time because
2:01:38my website's like official name is Stratechery by Ben Thompson. But with a name like Ben
2:01:43Thompson you have to like yeah, I don't want to make sure you I
2:01:46don't blame you one bit. There's the exponent podcast. Yeah, I've
2:01:50been listening to very good. That's an exponent dot FM. I
2:01:54correct them. Yep. I just did that by memory. Yeah, no, I
2:01:57like I think. I don't know if Marco started it. That's where
2:02:00I was where I got it from was the whole FM for podcasts. Oh, I
2:02:03think it's great. Yeah. Yeah. It gets totally memorable. And it's
2:02:07easy to get names too. Because it costs like 80 bucks a year.
2:02:09Right? Which is high enough that people aren't gonna squat on it.
2:02:12Right, but not like crazy. So yeah, it's funny
2:02:15You get to be an adult and you have 80 bucks a year and it's actually a good thing
2:02:20Whereas I remember I started registering domain names and it was like, what do you mean you want $15 a year?
2:02:25I just registered one for $8 a year
2:02:27It was funny those I I have my domains registered at a company called Gandhi
2:02:32Yeah, and and they tell you like how much you've spent on domains. Oh, that's terrible. Why would you do that?
2:02:39- I know, it's pretty, 'cause now it's been years, right?
2:02:43I've been carrying domains for like 10, 15 years
2:02:46at this point, it adds up.
2:02:48- Oh my God, yeah, it's like when Mike Montero
2:02:50was on this show, it's like you never tell an addict
2:02:52how much they've spent.
2:02:53- I know, it's so true, yup.
2:02:55- Like you get a bar tab, but they don't put like a thing
2:02:58at the bottom of your bar tab that tells you like,
2:02:59here's what you've spent year to date.
2:03:01(laughing)
2:03:02Right, nobody would do that.
2:03:04Like your beer distributor does not give you a year to date
2:03:09tab
2:03:10the crazy
2:03:11well anyway last but not least on twitter excellent twitter account you
2:03:15are uh...
2:03:18monk m_o_n_k_
2:03:20bent b_e_n_t_ as in ben thompson that's me
2:03:24uh... so thank you very much great show this is absolutely great i think it was
2:03:27uh... worth it just for thinking of android where as as windows mobile two
2:03:31point oh
2:03:33alone 'cause to me that's it
2:03:35just put that
2:03:36finger right on the middle of the button of what I see as being the problem with it. Anyway,
2:03:40thank you, Ben.
2:03:41Ben: Good to be here.
2:03:42I'm hitting stop.
2:03:43[End of Audio]
2:03:43[BLANK_AUDIO]