0:00:00Peter Kafka, it's good to have you on my show.
0:00:03I did your show, God, that was years ago now
0:00:05at this point, isn't it?
0:00:06- It was years ago and then we had a crossover
0:00:09and so I think this is our third podcast conversation.
0:00:12Thanks for having me, Jon.
0:00:13- It's a pleasure.
0:00:14Before we get in to all of the streaming,
0:00:20Michigan-ness, we can just recap yesterday.
0:00:24We're recording on Wednesday.
0:00:26Yesterday Apple had their remote virtual,
0:00:29however you want to describe it, Time Flies event.
0:00:32I have presumed that you watched.
0:00:35- I have watched because I'm not in the business
0:00:40of paying a lot of attention to their watches and iPads,
0:00:43but when it came time to talk about content bundles,
0:00:46I perked up a little bit.
0:00:47- The funny part about that is it's an hour event,
0:00:51nice and tight.
0:00:52They only announced really three things,
0:00:55new watches, new iPads, and a streaming bundle.
0:00:59The streaming bundle, I actually double checked.
0:01:02My notes were under two minutes
0:01:04and then I watched the video again.
0:01:06It was literally under two minutes.
0:01:08- Yeah, it's not, I mean, it's Apple
0:01:12and dutifully people come out saying
0:01:15this is a game changer, et cetera,
0:01:17'cause you have to, I think still reflexively
0:01:19when Apple has an event, you have to justify
0:01:21the time spent paying attention to it.
0:01:23And it's much less now, right?
0:01:25You don't have to fly anywhere.
0:01:26It's just an hour long webinar, so it's easier to go,
0:01:28yeah, they got some new stuff.
0:01:31But yeah, I thought Apple was not overselling
0:01:33the importance of this bundle.
0:01:35- No, but well, we'll get into it then.
0:01:38But what do you, are you an Apple Watch wearer?
0:01:42- I am, but I am not, I'm kind of reluctant about it.
0:01:48I was just taking it off my wrist to tell you
0:01:50what model it was, 'cause I pay that little attention.
0:01:52It's a Series 3.
0:01:54And I won't say I was shocked when they came out
0:01:56with a new line, including like the lower end one
0:01:58that started at what, was it 300 bucks?
0:02:00- 279, but it's like-- - What was the S?
0:02:02The S, for the SE?
0:02:03That's the cheap model?
0:02:05- Well, it's the cheap new model, right?
0:02:09It's brand new product, and it's sort of best thought of
0:02:12as last year's Series 5, but without like the ECG.
0:02:17I always wanna say EKG, but ECG sensor.
0:02:21- It's bananas, it's to me.
0:02:25I mean, I know they sell well.
0:02:26And people will ask me about my watch periodically.
0:02:28I say, hey, Apple Watch, how do you like it?
0:02:30And should I get the wireless version?
0:02:31And I'll say, it's an odometer, and I wear it.
0:02:35And when I don't wear it, I feel bad that I didn't wear it,
0:02:38but that's the entire utility.
0:02:40So the idea of like selling a super premium version of it
0:02:43is bananas to me, but I'm sure Apple knows.
0:02:46Well, no, I don't know that Apple knows what they're doing,
0:02:48but presumably there is a market for that.
0:02:50- I think that people, I think your take is very typical,
0:02:53and you're obviously juiced in more to this
0:02:55than the average person out there.
0:02:58For most people, getting a $300 digital watch
0:03:03is a pretty expensive digital watch.
0:03:05And that is what it is, right?
0:03:07It is, I mean, we can get into nerd out,
0:03:11and you're running apps, and you're doing all this stuff,
0:03:13but it's a digital watch.
0:03:16And 300 bucks is more than most people spend on a watch.
0:03:18And if they do get one, they're gonna wear it forever,
0:03:22by some definition of forever,
0:03:24which is less than a watch, a super watch,
0:03:29mechanical watch nerd's definition of forever,
0:03:31which is like decades,
0:03:33but way, way more than like a tech person would think,
0:03:36hey, that's not the latest version.
0:03:39- Yeah, the last time I spent a lot of time thinking about
0:03:43is when they introduced wireless,
0:03:45because I thought that was pretty interesting,
0:03:47and we finally got the sort of Dick Tracy land,
0:03:49and what if this thing would allow me
0:03:51to not take my phone with me on verit, too,
0:03:55when I went out, and I borrowed a watch from Apple
0:03:58using that premise, and Apple, to their credit,
0:04:01pretty much said, the thing you wanna do is not gonna work.
0:04:04You cannot use this as a phone substitute.
0:04:09And they're right, but when you tell people that,
0:04:12they get ash in the face.
0:04:14They're like, well, what's the point of that?
0:04:16I'm like, I don't know.
0:04:17- Yeah, I wonder, too.
0:04:19And I do have it, I have the,
0:04:22I bought a new one for myself last year,
0:04:24'cause I hadn't had one in a couple years,
0:04:25and I did get the cellular option,
0:04:28and I just justify it all as, well,
0:04:31I write Daring Fireball, I should have the cellular thing.
0:04:33- Yeah, exactly. - And I can,
0:04:36I pass off my whole, not singular, Verizon bill,
0:04:40as a tax, it's a business expense
0:04:42that I charge $10 a month to put my watch on.
0:04:46I almost never, ever use the cellular thing on my phone,
0:04:50or on my watch.
0:04:51But I will say this, and I'm not saying it's worth it,
0:04:55'cause I think Verizon charges me 10 bucks a month for it.
0:04:58It's at least-- - That sounds right, yeah.
0:05:00- I will say this, there was one time,
0:05:03and I don't remember, I'm not trying to obfuscate
0:05:06a personal detail, I forget what it was,
0:05:08but at some point, a couple months ago,
0:05:11but I know it was during the quarantine,
0:05:14'cause I've sort of got quarantine time locked in my head,
0:05:17there was a minor iOS update, just 13.1 points, whatever,
0:05:22and I'm like, okay, I'll update my phone.
0:05:26And it was like noon, and I got,
0:05:30while my phone was updating, I got a call
0:05:32I had been waiting for, I forget what it was,
0:05:34but it was a fairly important call
0:05:36from somebody who I was waiting to call me,
0:05:38and so I was really, and my, it went off on my wrist,
0:05:43and I was like, whoa, what's going on?
0:05:44And I look, and my phone has got that Apple logo
0:05:47that it takes five, you don't even know
0:05:49how long it's gonna take till your phone's updated.
0:05:51I'm like, oh, I can answer on my wrist,
0:05:53and I took the entire important phone call on my watch
0:05:57while my phone was incapacitated,
0:06:02and I was like, I don't know if this is worth $120 a year,
0:06:05but almost.
0:06:06- It works remarkably well as a speakerphone,
0:06:09I will say that, it's way better
0:06:11than you would expect that to work.
0:06:12What I wanted was something that allowed me
0:06:14to go to my kid's soccer game,
0:06:16and if I needed to see an email or see a text
0:06:19or reply to one, that I could do that
0:06:20and not bring my phone, and then thus,
0:06:22I wouldn't be looking at my phone,
0:06:24or I'd be more in tune to my kids,
0:06:26and even as you say this out loud,
0:06:27you're saying, wait, you're gonna spend several hundred
0:06:29dollars plus $10 a month so you could
0:06:34not look at your phone, why don't you just not look
0:06:36at your phone, and of course, if you're listening
0:06:38to this podcast, you know that's very hard,
0:06:39and it sounds pathetic to say that,
0:06:41but it doesn't allow you to do that.
0:06:43Mail won't work, text will kind of work
0:06:45if it's iMessage, but not, you know,
0:06:47it doesn't, like the Apple people said,
0:06:49it doesn't do what you want it to do in that case.
0:06:52- No, it definitely does not.
0:06:53The other thing is, and this is the interesting thing
0:07:00that they announced yesterday, was this sort of
0:07:03cellular watches for your young children
0:07:08and for your elderly, confused parents.
0:07:12And I don't know, it's like I've got one kid
0:07:18and now he's in 11th grade, so I'm out of that,
0:07:23and you know, he's got a phone.
0:07:26If you don't wanna buy a phone for your kid,
0:07:31which I get, and I totally, you know,
0:07:33I'm not telling anybody how to parent their kids
0:07:34and what age should a kid get their own cell phone
0:07:37is a huge question, it's like the parental question,
0:07:40one of the big parental questions of our generation.
0:07:43But if you're on the fence about it,
0:07:47whether it's expense-wise or whatever else,
0:07:50are you gonna buy your kid a $350 or $400 watch?
0:07:53- Yeah, that baffled me as well.
0:07:56I thought the exact same thing,
0:07:57which is, my kids have a tracking device,
0:07:59it's the phone I bought for them.
0:08:01Or the phone, and buying that phone's a big deal,
0:08:05and I bought a used phone from Amazon, Amazon renewed,
0:08:08now I got battery problems and all that.
0:08:09But yeah, it's the tracking device is the phone.
0:08:13We don't need a second tracking device.
0:08:14- And it's like if you're the kid who's like 11 or 12,
0:08:18and your parents are willing to get you a $400 thing
0:08:22to add to the family's cell phone plan,
0:08:25don't you want the iPhone SE?
0:08:27Like, I want the phone, I want the thing I can play with
0:08:30and take pictures with.
0:08:31- I kind of assume that everyone in that market
0:08:33has the phone too.
0:08:35That's what I imagine in Apple.
0:08:37- Yeah, but they really sold that feature as like your kid.
0:08:41They didn't, and it's weird, 'cause it's like Apple can't
0:08:44say if you don't wanna get your kid a phone,
0:08:46because they're Apple, they want everybody to have a phone.
0:08:50So you had to, it was a weird sort of, not doublespeak,
0:08:55what's the opposite of doublespeak,
0:08:56where you don't mention something?
0:08:58Like a conspicuous--
0:08:59- You walk all the way up to it.
0:09:02- The version of that that I really noticed was the
0:09:05blood oxygen reader, which I never would have thought
0:09:09prior to March of this year, but when you talk about
0:09:12blood oxygen levels, and I'm like, oh, that's a COVID
0:09:15detector, but of course they can't say that,
0:09:18'cause it's not.
0:09:19- Yeah, and--
0:09:19- And you have all kinds of liability problems,
0:09:21but I thought, I mean, I don't think there's anyone
0:09:23who saw that presentation and wasn't thinking about,
0:09:26will this tell me if I'm getting, if I'm sick
0:09:28or getting sick?
0:09:29And they conspicuously did not say that out loud.
0:09:32- Yeah, and it's, the other factor is that it's partially
0:09:35coincidental, because clearly these sort of sensors
0:09:38are years in the making, both in terms of just that
0:09:42the components technically take years, and then with these
0:09:45watch things, they take even longer, I think,
0:09:48than most of Apple's technology, 'cause they have to get
0:09:50FDA approval, and then the FDA equivalents around the world,
0:09:54you know, it's a regulatory nightmare.
0:09:57- Right, it's not like one of these drop shipping people
0:10:00who came out with masks, you know, in the middle of March,
0:10:03and said, this will help you, this will protect you.
0:10:07They weren't, it wasn't that, but it was still very clear
0:10:09that this was an application that you could use it for,
0:10:12but they weren't gonna suggest that out loud.
0:10:13- Right, and it, there's just, but let's,
0:10:18exactly what you said, nobody's listening to this
0:10:20and not thinking that, because other than medical
0:10:24professionals, I don't know of anybody who hasn't heard
0:10:27blood oxygen as a term and thought about it
0:10:32more than in the last six months.
0:10:35I mean, I don't, I mean, I guess I've heard of it
0:10:37beforehand, but I mean, 99% of the times it's ever come up
0:10:40in my awareness is COVID.
0:10:43- Yep, yep.
0:10:45- So it was in, you know, they have these off the record
0:10:49briefings for the media after events, and they're,
0:10:53you know, they're getting better at 'em, it was, you know,
0:10:55and it's off the record, so I can't really spill
0:10:57the details of it, but people did ask, you know,
0:11:01and it's like they can't say it, it's, you know,
0:11:03it's more than the typical Apple not wanting to say,
0:11:06get knocked off message, they just legally can't talk
0:11:10about it in that context.
0:11:11- Yes, that's right, yeah.
0:11:13As by the way, they should, they should be very reticent
0:11:18to make medical claims, which is, I mean, again,
0:11:22and I don't follow the watch stuff carefully,
0:11:23but I do know as a watch user that, you know,
0:11:26when I'm sitting on the subway and I'm traveling
0:11:29under the East River and all of a sudden the watch tells me
0:11:31that I passed my movement goal for the day,
0:11:34or my standing goal for the day, I get a chuckle,
0:11:37and I go, ah, you know, it's harmless,
0:11:38it doesn't really matter to me one way or the other,
0:11:40but I do think about sort of people who are relying
0:11:44on these devices for actual medical information,
0:11:46and because, you know, Apple half-positions this now
0:11:49as a, they no longer say it's, you know, for work, right,
0:11:51it's for health and fitness, and the fitness part
0:11:55I sort of get, and there's people who really,
0:11:57it really does matter to them how many miles they clock
0:12:00and how many minutes, but for most people, I think,
0:12:02are probably more in my group, right, it's casual,
0:12:05but the medical stuff really unnerved,
0:12:07would unnerve me if I was Apple and had people relying
0:12:11on me for medical information.
0:12:13Yeah, I wouldn't, and I'll defer to actual experts on that,
0:12:18but I do think about that a lot, 'cause it's clearly
0:12:20a device that has a limit on its accuracy,
0:12:23which is fine in most cases.
0:12:24- And I kind of feel like, you know, he's such a
0:12:28bizarro second version of Tim Cook,
0:12:32but that Jeff Williams being in charge of the watch
0:12:35is sort of unsurprising, like he's clearly a bit
0:12:39of a cipher personality-wise, but he definitely seems
0:12:44like the, you know, the old carpenter saying,
0:12:49measure twice, cut once, Tim Cook and Jeff Williams
0:12:52seem like measure 100 times, cut once type of people.
0:12:56- Yeah, they're not freelancing a lot at these things.
0:12:59- Right, and so on the one hand, they definitely
0:13:00are clearly incentivized to sell a lot of watches,
0:13:04but neither of them really feel like, well,
0:13:06let's cut some corners and make some bold claims
0:13:09on the medical efficacy of these sensors, you know,
0:13:12they seem to be doing a pretty good job on that stuff.
0:13:16- Yeah, yeah, yeah, no, they're not telling you
0:13:17what's gonna, they're not misleading you.
0:13:20But on the other hand, they are saying these things
0:13:22have benefits and these can help you track your health,
0:13:24and I think there's a, for me, there's an uncomfortable
0:13:27middle ground there.
0:13:28- The bigger one to me, and they spent less time on it,
0:13:31like they showed kids, but the bigger one to me
0:13:34is the question of getting it for your, quote, older parents.
0:13:39That seems to me the, and I forget if it was a year ago
0:13:44or two years ago when they added fall detection,
0:13:47and they keep showing people on mountain bikes
0:13:50and making jokes about a guy yesterday getting chased
0:13:53off a cliff by a bear, and that's real.
0:13:55And I know in California, the mountain biking thing is real
0:13:58and the mountains are, you know, real mountains,
0:14:01not our East Coast mountains.
0:14:03But they--
0:14:06- They also have bears.
0:14:06- Yeah. (laughs)
0:14:09But they also danced around that when they introduced it too
0:14:12where they did show like a grandmother type in a kitchen
0:14:17on a stool, and then there was a little, you know,
0:14:19she was like watching her grandkid who was running in,
0:14:22and then they definitely cut away,
0:14:24and then all of the actual simulations of an adult
0:14:28falling in the home weren't photographed,
0:14:31they were pictograms, you know, like the Olympic style
0:14:35stick figures of somebody.
0:14:37And I remember talking to people at Apple about it,
0:14:40like that was pretty, and they were like, yeah,
0:14:42we were, you know, we really had to be careful
0:14:44'cause we wanted people to know that it is good for this,
0:14:46and we actually designed it with like older people in mind
0:14:50so that when they, you know, that their type of falls
0:14:53are going to be less violent,
0:14:56and we really wanna be in tune to it,
0:14:58but we can't show it, you know, it's, you know,
0:15:01it's grotesque, you can't just show an old person
0:15:04falling off a stool in an Apple event, it's, it--
0:15:07- Well, you're not in an Apple event,
0:15:09but it has been done before, but here's my question,
0:15:12I think we're roughly the same age,
0:15:13is the clapper and iPhone and I can't get up,
0:15:16is that the same thing?
0:15:18Okay, yeah, that's what I thought.
0:15:20- No, I think I've fallen and I can't get up
0:15:23was the medic alert.
0:15:24Remember that?
0:15:26It was a-- - Okay, okay, yes.
0:15:28You're right, but that did show the older people
0:15:31on the ground yelling for help,
0:15:33and it's, I would say it's burned indelibly in our minds,
0:15:36but of course I just, I'm confused about which brand it was,
0:15:39but yeah, if you were a certain age
0:15:40and you watched a certain kind of TV,
0:15:41you saw a lot of us at.
0:15:42- Right, and as media junkies, you and I saw all of them.
0:15:45Right, 'cause what was the other one?
0:15:47There was another one where the old lady,
0:15:48there was a burglar outside her window.
0:15:50Do you remember?
0:15:53- No, I don't remember that.
0:15:54I remember the rascal that would take you up the stairs
0:15:57and then the clapper, and they all seemed to be sort of
0:16:00aimed at the exact same target market.
0:16:02- I think it might have been the same product
0:16:04as the I've fallen and I can't get up, the medic alert,
0:16:06but it was, in addition to falling,
0:16:09there was a burglar outside an old lady's window
0:16:13conveniently on the ground floor,
0:16:15and he was making faces at her through the window
0:16:19to show that he was about to come in and, you know, burglars.
0:16:23- You know, the most alarming passage in time
0:16:25is when you go from laughing at those ads
0:16:27that are aimed at old people to gradually getting closer
0:16:30and closer to the target market.
0:16:31It's definitely happened to me with pharma stuff.
0:16:33- Yeah, totally.
0:16:34- Those pharma ads that run during football or 60 minutes
0:16:37I never paid any attention to,
0:16:38and I'm still not really the market for it yet,
0:16:41but I'm definitely getting closer.
0:16:42And I keep thinking, all right, you know, one day
0:16:44I'm gonna pay a lot of attention to that small type.
0:16:47- Yeah, I think what happens with that, with the sports,
0:16:50is you run out of, I'm 47, so I've run out of athletes
0:16:55who are my age, you know, it was, as a Yankees fan,
0:17:00one of the nice things about being a Yankees fan of my age
0:17:05is that Derek Jeter and Mariano Rivera had,
0:17:08in addition to extremely successful careers,
0:17:11played until they were like 41, 42 years old,
0:17:15and they were roughly my age, and so I still had guys,
0:17:18my guys, my age, you know, playing professional sports.
0:17:22Now I'm 47, nobody's left, you know, Tom Brady is,
0:17:25I don't know, a remarkable 43
0:17:26and still playing an NFL quarterback, but--
0:17:29- And perhaps washed up, yeah.
0:17:31Yeah, kickers, I think, is our last chance
0:17:34to find someone, Morton Anderson or someone like,
0:17:36oh my God, we're so old.
0:17:38- And every once in a while there'd be a baseball pitcher
0:17:41who could pitch until his 40s
0:17:42'cause he was a knuckleball thrower or something like that.
0:17:45- Phil Nicro, I remember being very old, yeah, yeah.
0:17:48But yeah, this has been Old Timey Radio
0:17:50brought to you by Jimmy Jeter.
0:17:51- Well, but what happens is you go from having the last gasp
0:17:56of athletes your age to suddenly watching the commercials
0:18:01between there, and it's clearly a product
0:18:03for an older gentleman, and you're like, wait a minute,
0:18:06that actor looks younger than me.
0:18:10Whatever the medical problem that's ailing him
0:18:14that you tend to think of as being a generation older
0:18:17than you, all of a sudden I'm looking at the casting
0:18:19and I'm like, well, he's a professional actor,
0:18:22but damn, he looks--
0:18:24- A handsome fellow, yes.
0:18:26Yeah, I got an Instagram ad inviting me
0:18:28to join a COVID vaccine test, I think it was Pfizer,
0:18:32and it's clearly one of those things where they are A/B
0:18:35testing different images and targeting different people,
0:18:37and the gentleman in my Instagram ad was,
0:18:41I'm guessing at least 10 years older than me,
0:18:43but it was gnarly to realize that they had pegged me
0:18:46as someone in that general bracket who might be interested
0:18:50in getting COVID testing through an Instagram ad,
0:18:52which is a whole other story.
0:18:54- Instagram, people ask me, I keep saying this,
0:18:56people ask me like, hey, you're a Facebook critic,
0:18:58why do you still have Instagram?
0:19:00And it's like, partially because I've got friends
0:19:04on Instagram and I'm hooked, I get it,
0:19:07that I do like all the other craziness,
0:19:10but professionally, I'm obsessed
0:19:13with the accuracy of their ads.
0:19:15It is--
0:19:17- Yeah, no, I just went through this with someone who said,
0:19:19I'm quitting Facebook because of this latest outrage,
0:19:22and I'm going, meet me over on Instagram,
0:19:25and I gently pointed out, and she knew,
0:19:27she knew that they were owned by the same thing.
0:19:29She said, I know, I just can't tolerate Facebook,
0:19:32and this is the compromise I'm making in my head,
0:19:34but I can't give up Instagram.
0:19:36- The bizarre accuracy of their ads
0:19:38is like passing a street performer
0:19:41who's good at sleight of hand magic,
0:19:43and it's like, sometimes you see the same trick,
0:19:47it's like, okay, you got me, I like old watches,
0:19:50so yeah, yeah, here's another vintage,
0:19:52either vintage-style watch or something, you know, all right.
0:19:56But then they'll show me an ad for something else,
0:19:58and I'm like, wait, how did you know?
0:20:00- The savviest people I know, people who are in tech,
0:20:05people who write about tech will continue to tell me
0:20:07that Instagram or Facebook must be listening to them,
0:20:10and that's how they do the ad targeting,
0:20:11and then you explain it, that can't be possible,
0:20:14and they refuse to believe you 'cause it's too eerie.
0:20:18And the sad reality, right, is a lot of,
0:20:20we're much less interesting than we think we are,
0:20:23and there's much bigger pools of people who look like
0:20:25and act like us than we realize or want to observe.
0:20:27- Yeah, I'm not a hobbyist sleight of hand magician,
0:20:32but I am a big devotee of just observing it,
0:20:37and that's exactly how sleight of hand magic works
0:20:40at a very macro level.
0:20:42Everybody's guess, well, they must be blank,
0:20:44and that's never it, right,
0:20:46that's never the explanation for the trick.
0:20:48But if you ever do get the explanation for a trick,
0:20:51it is always so mundane.
0:20:53It is like, what, really?
0:20:54- Yeah. - That's how you do that?
0:20:55- Yeah. - The--
0:20:57- Yeah, that's it. - Yeah, you just scoop
0:20:58the coin into your lap, that's it, you know.
0:21:00(laughing)
0:21:02And the, oh no, they must be blank is like the equivalent
0:21:06of they must be listening to us,
0:21:08and it's like, nope, that's not it.
0:21:11- Are you a Ricky J fan? - Oh, the biggest.
0:21:13- Okay, I figured, I figured, I love it too.
0:21:17Great, and a great New Yorker profile of him
0:21:19from years ago, if you don't know that.
0:21:20- Oh, I have, I've read all of it.
0:21:22When he died, I went back and watched all of it,
0:21:27and there's like YouTubes that are like,
0:21:29I don't even know what's under 480p,
0:21:32but some of his old VHS stuff is really, really low res,
0:21:37and even there, it's like amazing.
0:21:40I love Ricky J.
0:21:42Also, what a great character. - Put him in, put him in.
0:21:44So great, so he'll go in your show notes.
0:21:46- Yeah. - And I feel like
0:21:47I've contributed, good. - Yeah.
0:21:49Here, let me take a break and thank our first sponsor
0:21:53of the show, our, my good friends at Linode, L-I-N-O-D-E.
0:21:56I used to pronounce them Li-node,
0:21:58but it's Linode like Linux 'cause it's Linux hosting.
0:22:01That's where I host during Fireball.
0:22:03Could not be happier with them.
0:22:04They are a phenomenal, phenomenal hosting service
0:22:08with great customer support and amazing prices,
0:22:12quite frankly.
0:22:13They have a code, talk show 20,
0:22:17and when you create a new Linode account,
0:22:19you get $20 credit towards your next project,
0:22:21which can go a lot further than you think.
0:22:23They have 11 data centers worldwide,
0:22:26which matters for a lot of uses.
0:22:27If you need a data center close to you
0:22:29or perhaps for legal compliance reasons in your country,
0:22:33starting this year, they have a new object storage
0:22:37bucket system that is S3 compatible.
0:22:40Basically, if you have something that uses Amazon S3,
0:22:44you can just plug and play connect your code
0:22:46to use this instead.
0:22:48It is fantastic.
0:22:49They also have one-click installs of all the popular stuff
0:22:53you might wanna host yourself, WordPress,
0:22:55game servers for Minecraft, big, big, big.
0:22:57Every time I mention that when I do these reads for Linode,
0:23:00people write and say, yeah, they got one for their kid,
0:23:03and it has made them like the most popular parent
0:23:05in the grade.
0:23:07Great, great use of this.
0:23:08Native SSD storage.
0:23:10They have a 40 gigabyte network
0:23:11at every one of their data centers.
0:23:14Just great stuff.
0:23:15They're also hiring, linode.com/careers to find out more.
0:23:19If you are even vaguely thinking that you should work
0:23:22for a professional web hosting service,
0:23:24you know the type of jobs they have.
0:23:25Go check it out.
0:23:26It's a great company.
0:23:27And that $20 credit, they have nanoed plans
0:23:32that are just five bucks a month,
0:23:34so you can get a great plan, super useful.
0:23:37With the $20 credit, you get four months free.
0:23:39Unbelievable deal.
0:23:40Still going on.
0:23:41TalkShow 20 is the code, and go to linode,
0:23:45L-I-N-O-D-E.com/the-talkshow.
0:23:50Linode.com/the-talkshow to get started
0:23:53and find out more.
0:23:54My thanks to them, not just for sponsoring the show,
0:23:57but for keeping my website up.
0:23:58So I've got the new watch that came this morning,
0:24:03which was kind of an unbelievable story.
0:24:06So I don't know, you didn't follow real closely.
0:24:09You know, they've got these new,
0:24:11they call them solo loop bands.
0:24:14So they're--
0:24:15- Yeah, it looked like the loop
0:24:17that I have on my Series 3.
0:24:19There's the bass one. - At a glance,
0:24:20it looks exactly like the Apple Watch straps
0:24:23that most people have, the rubber ones.
0:24:24But there's no, there is no clasp.
0:24:27They just stretch. - Right.
0:24:29- And they are very--
0:24:30- And is it one size fits all,
0:24:32and then you sort of stretch into it?
0:24:33- Nope, it is, this is the part
0:24:35that I cannot stop thinking about,
0:24:37and I don't know what to do.
0:24:38'Cause again, it seems like I'm the victim
0:24:42of a sleight of hand magic trick.
0:24:44They have 12 sizes.
0:24:45Nine, so there's nine each.
0:24:48You know how there's like the larger watch
0:24:50and the smaller watch.
0:24:51Roughly men's, women's, but I know a lot of men
0:24:54who have the 40 millimeter one.
0:24:56For each one, there's nine.
0:24:58So like sizes one through nine
0:25:00are for the 40 millimeter smaller watches,
0:25:02and sizes four through 12 are for the 44 millimeter watches.
0:25:07And again, my take on this is that it's like buying shoes.
0:25:13It is meant for an in-person retail experience.
0:25:16Go into the store, they have a whole bunch.
0:25:18You find the one you like, fit this is great,
0:25:21and then you walk out.
0:25:22You can't do that in the COVID era.
0:25:24So they have this thing you print out, a PDF.
0:25:26You print it out, cut it out like you're in kindergarten.
0:25:28- You wrap it around your wrist?
0:25:30- Yeah, and it, but, and so I do this last night,
0:25:34and I didn't publish my post
0:25:35until after midnight on the East Coast.
0:25:37And I know that's not where they got it,
0:25:40because the package arrived at my house this morning
0:25:43at 8 a.m.
0:25:46I took mine out, and mine is a size seven,
0:25:50according to their scale, one to 12,
0:25:53and closer to an eight than to a six,
0:25:57but definitely in the seven,
0:25:58and they're only about a centimeter difference,
0:26:01maybe even less than a centimeter.
0:26:02They're pretty fine-grained.
0:26:04They sent me two straps, a seven and an eight.
0:26:07How did they do this?
0:26:11Actually, they sent me four.
0:26:13They sent me the rubber one and the braided yarn one,
0:26:15but each of those they sent in the size seven and eight.
0:26:18And I wrote to Apple PR.
0:26:21I was like, I'm blown away by this.
0:26:23How did you know?
0:26:24And they were like, that's the magic
0:26:26of the Apple Watch team.
0:26:28And I'm like, that's not an answer.
0:26:30Like, they've got, I think it's like a carnival,
0:26:33you know, like guess your weight or guess your age.
0:26:36They have somebody.
0:26:37- How much variance can there be in wrist size?
0:26:40You can be very skinny or very heavy, I guess,
0:26:43and then everyone else is kinda in the middle, right?
0:26:45- Well, it's, but think about like the regular strap
0:26:49with the one you have with the pins, right?
0:26:52It's effectively like guessing exactly
0:26:54which pin size you take, you know,
0:26:57which hole your pin goes through.
0:26:59And so they sent me two, you know,
0:27:00but it's out of all those holes in your straps,
0:27:04they got me the exact right size.
0:27:07It's unbelievable.
0:27:08- Yeah, I bet you most people have the same hole
0:27:11on their strap too.
0:27:13- Maybe, I mean--
0:27:14- Is my guess.
0:27:15- You have to--
0:27:15- Is in keeping with the carnival trick.
0:27:17Like there's actually much less variance than you think.
0:27:19- Yeah, so what I need to do after we record
0:27:21is I gotta ping a couple of my friends in the racket,
0:27:24you know, like I'll ping like Joanna, Stern,
0:27:27and maybe Nely, who obviously have very different wrists
0:27:31and see if they got this, but they must, you know,
0:27:34they, I'm sure they didn't send the same size to everybody,
0:27:37but you know, did they guess that Nely needed a thicker one?
0:27:40I don't know, but whoever's doing the carnival wrist size
0:27:43guessing for the Apple Watch team nailed me spot on.
0:27:47I love this strap.
0:27:48It is very, very nice and comfortable.
0:27:50- Can I ask you something about that?
0:27:53Because like I said, I do wear the watch,
0:27:55and I have the, at one point I went out
0:27:57and got the fancier straps and would take the,
0:27:59put 'em on and off if I was exercising,
0:28:01and then I realized I'm just gonna keep the one on.
0:28:03And that one, I don't wanna gross anybody out,
0:28:06but it gets a little gamey over time,
0:28:08and I have to sort of wash it down,
0:28:10and if I'm exercising with it, and I,
0:28:12periodically I'm like, oh yeah,
0:28:13that thing needs a little wipe.
0:28:15How does that factor into a thing that you,
0:28:20I guess it's the same thing, right?
0:28:22It's a strap is a strap, and whether it's got a pin
0:28:25or a stretchy thing, it shouldn't matter.
0:28:27I was thinking about that as they talked about the one band,
0:28:30it's harder to move.
0:28:31- Yeah, well, it still slides in and out just as easily.
0:28:34You know, it's like you don't really disconnect it,
0:28:36but you know, I think anything rubbery like that,
0:28:39you're gonna wanna wash with soap and water once in a while.
0:28:42And that's sort of, as a, again,
0:28:44not to get into a watch nerd discussion,
0:28:46but it is sort of the problem with leather watch straps
0:28:49of all kinds, is they don't last, if you wear one,
0:28:53if you get like a watch with a leather strap,
0:28:55it's not gonna last for years.
0:28:57It just falls apart.
0:28:59- Yeah, but you want it to sort of have that weathered look.
0:29:01- Yeah, but eventually it's sort of,
0:29:03it goes from looking like cool and weathered
0:29:06to looking like disgusting or maybe having a bit of a smell.
0:29:11And leather doesn't take to a soap and water
0:29:14as well as other materials.
0:29:16- I'm grossed out, it's my wrist I'm talking about.
0:29:20- But anyway, it is a very nice strap.
0:29:21I feel it'll be very popular.
0:29:23And I will say their cutout system nailed my size perfectly.
0:29:27The seven is, the one that I thought from the paper cutout
0:29:30is exactly the most comfortable.
0:29:32The eight that Apple sent me as like a second best guess
0:29:36fits, but is a little loose for my taste.
0:29:40Like, and it feels like maybe somebody
0:29:42who likes a looser watch would prefer it,
0:29:46but it's really nice.
0:29:49And it's definitely lighter.
0:29:50I use my kitchen scale.
0:29:52The regular rubber straps, the sport bands, they call them,
0:29:56are about 25 grams.
0:29:57This one's only 13 grams, so it's about half the weight.
0:30:01Feels like nothing on your wrist.
0:30:02- Can I ask a meta question here for you?
0:30:04- Of course.
0:30:05- They had one hour, two, 2.5 announcements to make.
0:30:10Do you prefer, and they no longer, right,
0:30:14they can have their announcements
0:30:15at whatever schedule they want,
0:30:16and they don't need to bring press out there.
0:30:19Do you prefer sort of these discrete chunks of announcements
0:30:22versus sort of one mega announcement,
0:30:23and here's six different things,
0:30:25and we're doing it all in one day?
0:30:26Does it matter to you as a professional Apple observer?
0:30:30- I prefer the smaller ones, personally.
0:30:32I would, and over the years, I struggle.
0:30:37And part of it is my personal nature.
0:30:43Part of it is what I talked to you about on your show
0:30:46is the weird sort of semi-unique nature
0:30:50of my media empire, which is me,
0:30:54and it makes it harder for me,
0:30:56but I'm also, personality-wise,
0:30:58just not as good at covering a shotgun approach.
0:31:02Here's 12 things, here's my thoughts.
0:31:04I do much better with one thing to concentrate on,
0:31:07even if it's not something that's my favorite thing.
0:31:10- Yeah, that's what I figured,
0:31:12and again, since there's no travel,
0:31:13it's not like you have to complain
0:31:14about getting on a plane in September and October.
0:31:18- Yeah, and the other problem, too,
0:31:20and I find dealing with Apple professionally in the media is,
0:31:26I feel like, in some ways, they're not that atypical,
0:31:31but they're always very Apple-y,
0:31:33and the one thing I always say to people,
0:31:35in all these years that I've been doing this,
0:31:36I have never once, in my opinion, been lied to by Apple.
0:31:40They've never said anything that I've thought was a lie,
0:31:43and I've never really felt like they screwed me
0:31:46on their response to something.
0:31:48If they don't wanna answer a question,
0:31:49they just don't answer it,
0:31:51or more typically, they give you
0:31:53a very Apple-y non-answer,
0:31:56that they acknowledge is a non-answer.
0:31:58And I miss, one of the things I miss about being in person
0:32:02is they'll give you a look that says,
0:32:04"I know it's a non-answer,"
0:32:05but in the words coming out of their mouth are a non-answer,
0:32:08but there's sort of a nod of the head that's like,
0:32:12that's the best I'm gonna give you.
0:32:14- Yeah, I think that is more common than not.
0:32:18The people who are actually gonna lie to you, to your face,
0:32:22if they're professionals,
0:32:23they don't tend to last that long in the industry,
0:32:26and if it's a company, same problem.
0:32:28You can get away with it once or twice,
0:32:31but generally, it's not a good way.
0:32:35And everyone sort of accepts that a non-answer
0:32:37is a non-answer, and they understand why you're doing it.
0:32:39- Well, there was a good story, I'm sure you saw it.
0:32:41There was a good story about a month ago,
0:32:43I think it was the Columbia Journalism Review
0:32:45who had a story about dealing with Facebook,
0:32:47and that Facebook is sort of the exception to the rule
0:32:50where a lot of people in the media
0:32:52feel burned by Facebook PR.
0:32:54- Yeah, there was, you know,
0:32:59Casey Newton has an anecdote about being deceived
0:33:02about the plane, and to me,
0:33:03that seems like more of an outlier.
0:33:05I pretty much group Facebook in that same group
0:33:08of they might waste your time
0:33:11and not tell you things they wanna tell you,
0:33:12and hold press events, and which is very little to say,
0:33:15but I think they are less often,
0:33:18they're less likely to lie to you,
0:33:19and I think that story has a lot more to do
0:33:21with sort of the change in the way people perceive Facebook
0:33:25and the kinds of questions they ask Facebook now,
0:33:29as opposed to four or six years ago,
0:33:32and I think that's the difference,
0:33:34is you're asking much more serious questions
0:33:36about Facebook that are much more important
0:33:38than whether a plane is actually in the air,
0:33:40or this widget does that.
0:33:42It has more consequence, and I think,
0:33:46when I read that story,
0:33:47that I don't think this is terribly dissimilar
0:33:49from a lot of other companies,
0:33:50but I think it was also shaded a bit.
0:33:52- Well, the other factor is that Facebook PR,
0:33:57for all of Facebook's properties,
0:33:59it's just not the worst place to work,
0:34:04but the busiest, because they have the most PR issues
0:34:07to put out that aren't of their own doing, right?
0:34:10You can't go through a week without at least two stories
0:34:15about Facebook popping up that they kind of have to address
0:34:19in some way as a professional PR team
0:34:22that aren't based on their announcements.
0:34:25They're about these constant fires that keep popping up.
0:34:28- Right, that's what I'm getting at, right?
0:34:30It's one thing if you're Apple,
0:34:31and you're generally just getting asked
0:34:33about the new whatever, right?
0:34:35And when is it coming out, and what are the stats?
0:34:37And occasionally, there's something unpleasant
0:34:39you have to discuss involving China or something,
0:34:42but usually it's not, right?
0:34:43And Facebook, now they're asking you about
0:34:45sort of the existence and essence of Facebook,
0:34:49and are they responsible for this atrocity?
0:34:51It's a very different set of questions.
0:34:53- And I will say this.
0:34:56The one exception to the Apple PR doesn't say things
0:34:59that aren't true would be going back to
0:35:02when Steve Jobs' health was in decline,
0:35:04and there were some definite issues there
0:35:07where what they said in hindsight clearly wasn't true.
0:35:12And again, it's such a unique situation,
0:35:15and I was nowhere near in the position I am now
0:35:20when that happened, around 2009, 2010.
0:35:24But there was an issue.
0:35:28- I remember a lot of that.
0:35:30I remember Henry Blodgett saying,
0:35:31"Steve Jobs looks very sick on stage.
0:35:34"What's going on?"
0:35:35And they were indignant about it,
0:35:36and there were all kinds of variants of that.
0:35:38And I was gonna say the other exception to that
0:35:39is just Jobs in general, right?
0:35:42He was famous for saying,
0:35:42"We're not gonna do the following and then do that."
0:35:45And that's--
0:35:47- It was less Apple than Steve Jobs personally,
0:35:50deciding, "I'm not going to be forthcoming
0:35:52"about what's going on."
0:35:53And it was like right before he took
0:35:55his first medical leave, and it was like,
0:35:58I don't know, it seems, or second medical leave,
0:36:00and it was like everybody knew he had had cancer before,
0:36:02and it's like, "Is it back?"
0:36:03And it was like, "No, yeah, I have a dietary issue,"
0:36:06or something, I forget what it was, but it was like--
0:36:08- Yep, yep, yep.
0:36:09He had a cold, it was gaunt, and yeah, yeah.
0:36:12So I will just say that was a notable exception,
0:36:15but it was more like the exception that proved the rule
0:36:18than indicative of dealing with Apple
0:36:21and anything related to their products.
0:36:23It was all very, very personal,
0:36:25and I feel like there was,
0:36:26who at Apple was gonna stand up and say,
0:36:28"You can't do this," you know?
0:36:31- Yeah, I mean, since we're having the meta conversation,
0:36:33I mean, again, this probably seems obvious,
0:36:35but it has taken me quite a while to figure it out,
0:36:37is that everyone in the company
0:36:39takes the cue from their leader,
0:36:40and if you're upset about Facebook's PR or Apple's PR,
0:36:44whoever it is, that is,
0:36:46they're doing what they think their boss wants them to do,
0:36:50and their boss usually does want them to do it,
0:36:52and if there's a disconnect,
0:36:53that usually gets solved one way or another,
0:36:55and so if you're upset with a certain way
0:36:57a company's treating you, it's as a press person,
0:37:00that's what their CEO wants.
0:37:02- Yeah, yeah.
0:37:02That's all I'll say now for the,
0:37:06getting back to the watch.
0:37:07(laughing)
0:37:10I love it.
0:37:11I do like the strap, I think it's nice,
0:37:13I think people are gonna wanna try 'em on.
0:37:15I do think the paper thing is an accurate gauge,
0:37:17but that's really all I have to say for now.
0:37:19It's not a super exciting product, so I don't feel,
0:37:22to me, I'm most interested in those two minutes of the,
0:37:27this is why I wanted to talk to you this week,
0:37:29is to me, it's the bundle and the streaming,
0:37:32and where this stuff is going.
0:37:35So what are your thoughts on the Apple One bundle
0:37:37that they announced?
0:37:40- Uh, I am, I think it is,
0:37:44my mentions were flooded with people disagreeing with me,
0:37:47and that's their right,
0:37:48but I think it is an unimpressive bundle.
0:37:50I don't think it's meaningful for consumers or for Apple.
0:37:55My thought on bundles in general is they work
0:37:58when they are anchored by something that you really want.
0:38:01So if it's cable TV, you're paying for a bunch of channels
0:38:04because you want sports or live news or whatever it is,
0:38:07and Amazon Prime gives you a bunch of stuff,
0:38:09but you're not subscribing to Amazon Prime
0:38:11because you want Prime Video,
0:38:13you're subscribing because you want the free shipping.
0:38:16And I don't see the live sports
0:38:20or free shipping part of the Apple bundles.
0:38:24And so we can start there, but that to me is,
0:38:27it's not a meaningful thing until they connect it
0:38:30to the must-have Apple product, which is the device.
0:38:33And we can talk about why that maybe
0:38:36isn't the case right now.
0:38:38- I guess my,
0:38:41I don't completely disagree,
0:38:44but I think I feel more like Apple Music
0:38:47is that linchpin service.
0:38:49And that is how, that's what I did to guess
0:38:53what their pricing would be, which was pretty accurate,
0:38:55as I thought, well, why don't you take
0:38:57the Apple Music pricing and add $5, and there's your bundle.
0:39:01And that's pretty much exactly the pricing
0:39:03for individual and family.
0:39:05Take the 10 and $15 that Apple Music costs
0:39:08as individual or a family, and add $5 a month
0:39:13and include not everything else,
0:39:16but the arcade and the TV Plus,
0:39:21and some iCloud storage, which I still really feel
0:39:25like they're nickel and diming people on.
0:39:27Like, for the individual thing,
0:39:30it's like to upgrade the people to the 50 gigabytes
0:39:33when they're selling these phones
0:39:35that have 512 gigabytes of storage
0:39:38and shoot 4K video that easily fills up 50 gigabytes
0:39:43if you're shooting it a lot.
0:39:45It's like, wow, I can't believe that.
0:39:48If these people are gonna give you $20 or $15 a month,
0:39:50why not just give them more of that storage
0:39:53for their backups?
0:39:54But anyway.
0:39:55- I used to feel the same way about storage in general
0:39:59on the device, right?
0:40:01The markup for whatever the base level iPhone,
0:40:03which early on became an unusable amount of storage, right?
0:40:07You had to get a higher level.
0:40:09It was an enormous markup to go to the next level.
0:40:12Especially when it's almost irresponsible
0:40:13to sell the phone at sort of the base level,
0:40:15whatever that used to be.
0:40:16I remember having a tell-- - It was 16.
0:40:17- I remember having a tell relative,
0:40:19it was like, you don't buy that.
0:40:20Like, you think you're saving money,
0:40:21but you don't want to have a functioning job.
0:40:23- Yeah, it was 16 gigabytes that they stuck with
0:40:25as the base for way too long, because at 16 gigabytes,
0:40:29it was like half of it was taken up by the operating system.
0:40:32You know, like once they burst past 16,
0:40:36even the 32, it's like you mostly get 32.
0:40:40But with 16, you didn't even get close to 16
0:40:43of usable storage, because the OS and everything else
0:40:46had to be in there.
0:40:46And they had to reserve enough space
0:40:49so that you could do software updates, you know?
0:40:52And even if they only reserve like two gigabytes
0:40:54so that when a software update comes,
0:40:55there's space to write the update before doing the update,
0:40:58it's like if you're only giving people 16,
0:41:01you're taking away one eighth of their storage.
0:41:04- Yep, and I think you're right.
0:41:05I think, I mean, music is by far,
0:41:07music and the data are by far the most widely used
0:41:10of those offerings, and I think there are probably
0:41:13tens of millions of people who are using both music
0:41:15and data, and so right there, you're getting pretty close.
0:41:18- But the big difference between those two, though,
0:41:21is music is fun.
0:41:22People want to listen to music, and people,
0:41:25why do people listen to music?
0:41:27Because music makes them happy, right?
0:41:30It's very, you know, it's the one form of our media
0:41:34that is just the closest, it's just purely emotional, right?
0:41:39It makes you happy.
0:41:40That's why you pay for streaming music.
0:41:43Why do you pay for iCloud storage?
0:41:45It is the most cerebral aspect of this offering.
0:41:48It is medicine, to be honest.
0:41:50It is, you're signing up to take some vitamins,
0:41:53and you should be taking them,
0:41:55and you should have enough storage in your iCloud plan
0:41:58so that you can back up your devices,
0:42:00because having those backups in iCloud is really fantastic
0:42:04and a great way to make sure you don't lose your photos
0:42:06and stuff like that, but it's medicine, right?
0:42:09It's no fun at all.
0:42:11Upgrading from the base storage to more storage,
0:42:16you don't see anything, you don't get to watch
0:42:18a funny episode of Ted Lasso, you don't get to listen.
0:42:21- You don't get to brag to someone
0:42:23about how big your storage is?
0:42:24- No, you get, it's medicine.
0:42:27It's good, but that's why I feel like
0:42:30they should just offer everybody who gets into
0:42:32this Apple One bundle the two gigabytes, honestly,
0:42:35that, or terabytes, so that, and it's like,
0:42:38well, that's more than anybody needs.
0:42:40Well, then fine, then they don't have to worry about it,
0:42:42but isn't that a great, anyway,
0:42:44that's my argument on that.
0:42:46- Well, yeah, and frankly, I think that should be
0:42:48factored into your $1,000 phone.
0:42:50- Right, right.
0:42:51- You're paying this much, or you're paying this much
0:42:53for Apple Care, the storage should come with that.
0:42:55Like, it should just be a thing you don't have to decide
0:42:58you need to buy when the thing you wanted to access
0:43:01is no longer available and you thought it was, right?
0:43:04That's, it's not just medicine, right, or exercise,
0:43:08it's finding out you needed, you should have had the storage
0:43:11but didn't, and now you have a,
0:43:13there's something bad has happened.
0:43:15- Yeah, so I--
0:43:17- Oh, you wish, oh, I would have just gone ahead
0:43:18and bought it in advance.
0:43:20- So anyway, I think music might be that linchpin.
0:43:24It, you know, if you like listening to music,
0:43:27you need at least one streaming music plan in today's world.
0:43:32And, you know, if it's gonna be Apple Music,
0:43:34then why not spend $5 more a month and get the Apple One
0:43:37and then you get the TV shows and whatever else,
0:43:40the arcade games?
0:43:41- Yeah, I just, I, to me, if they said, yeah,
0:43:47Apple Music now comes with these following three services,
0:43:50that makes, that's the Amazon model, right?
0:43:52Here's the thing you're already buying,
0:43:54now we're throwing more stuff in.
0:43:56And maybe gradually over time, we up the price
0:43:59and you're not complaining 'cause we've,
0:44:01we're making it harder, we're making it stickier, right?
0:44:04- Right.
0:44:05- Less churn by adding more stuff, but trying to say,
0:44:08look, you're already paying for this thing,
0:44:09why don't you pay a little more and get more stuff?
0:44:12If it's not stuff you want,
0:44:14that's where it falls flat for me.
0:44:17- Yeah, so, and I guess that is sort of, you know,
0:44:22how important is this?
0:44:25You know, why even bother with Apple Music?
0:44:28Why let, you know, why it's,
0:44:31why not walk away from the music business?
0:44:35I mean, I guess I think I see why, you know,
0:44:38Apple cares about it, but what the iTunes
0:44:41buy a song for 99 cents revolution meant to the company
0:44:4520 years ago, it really helped rejuvenate the company,
0:44:50you know, and it's what drove the iPod sales.
0:44:54And I remember when Apple retail stores
0:44:56first started opening in malls,
0:44:58if you perked your ears open, you'd hear kids saying,
0:45:01hey, let's go to the iPod store, right?
0:45:05It was really what made the company relevant.
0:45:08Does Apple need to be in the music business today?
0:45:12I mean, it's too late, they're obviously
0:45:14not gonna get out of it, but it's not essential
0:45:17to what they do or, you know,
0:45:20all that meaningful to them financially.
0:45:23- No, it's, I mean, it's in the billions of dollars now,
0:45:27right, so it starts to become meaningful
0:45:31and they couldn't take it away without having a problem.
0:45:34And I think we're sort of explaining
0:45:36why they need to be in the music business.
0:45:38If you wanna create a bundle of services,
0:45:39you need to have something that people want
0:45:41and that's the thing, it's not games,
0:45:44it's not Apple news, and it's not Apple TV+ for the moment.
0:45:47So here's the one thing that tens of millions of people
0:45:50are willingly paying for.
0:45:51- And, you know, and I think that's what they were thinking,
0:45:55you know, that this is something
0:45:56we don't wanna walk away from, and there's their linchpin.
0:45:59But then, now this gets into the competitive aspects.
0:46:03You had a comment yesterday,
0:46:05right after the event from Spotify.
0:46:07Here, here's their statement that you tweeted.
0:46:10Once again, Apple is using its dominant position
0:46:12and unfair practices to disadvantage competitors
0:46:14and deprive consumers by favoring its own services.
0:46:17We call on competition authorities to act urgently
0:46:20to restrict Apple's anti-competitive behavior,
0:46:23which if left unchecked will cause irreparable harm
0:46:26to the developer community
0:46:27and threaten our collective freedoms
0:46:29to listen, learn, create, and connect.
0:46:31It's a little purple.
0:46:34- A little.
0:46:35(laughing)
0:46:38I take solace in a little bit like that being purple.
0:46:42Like, in normal times, I'd hurt my eyes,
0:46:48rolling my eyes at that.
0:46:50In our times, I'm like, oh no, this is fun.
0:46:54It's fun to get all indignant about something
0:46:57as trivial as streaming music,
0:47:01when it's possible that come November,
0:47:04we're gonna have armed riots in the streets,
0:47:06and a president who lost an election
0:47:09and refuses to acknowledge it,
0:47:10and nobody knows what to do, right?
0:47:13It's sort of like, yeah, let's argue
0:47:15about anti-competitive aspects
0:47:17of whether it's fair or unfair for Apple
0:47:19to include music in a streaming
0:47:21when it's the platform provider of the operating system.
0:47:25- Yeah, I mean, the whole idea that this stuff
0:47:28is gonna get eventually kicked up to,
0:47:31some government agency or group of politicians
0:47:34will rule on this, is impossible to imagine
0:47:37in the United States.
0:47:38And by the way, it's not a coincidence
0:47:42that the Spotify/Apple fight is happening in the EU.
0:47:46It's not happening in the US.
0:47:48But yeah, it's impossible to imagine.
0:47:50I do, I'm not surprised that Spotify said
0:47:54we're indignant about this.
0:47:56I think they have, and I'm not an antitrust expert,
0:47:59nor do I play one on TV,
0:48:01but I do think they have much less of a ground
0:48:03to stand on here than the base argument they have,
0:48:07which is that Apple music tied to the device
0:48:10is anti-competitive.
0:48:11If you're just gonna say, all right,
0:48:12a bunch of stuff tied to other Apple services
0:48:15is anti-competitive, it's a harder argument to make.
0:48:17- And I do wonder, I wonder how much it's even worth arguing
0:48:20about how many people are like,
0:48:22well, this is my first iPhone,
0:48:24and I've taken it out of, I've unwrapped the box,
0:48:26and I'm turning it on, and I'm going through this,
0:48:29and I have no backup to restore, I'm new to this.
0:48:32Oh, and there right in my dock is a music app,
0:48:35and I tap the music app,
0:48:37and I'm prompted to sign up for Apple Music.
0:48:41That's basically the gist
0:48:43of what Spotify's complaining about, right?
0:48:45And it is.
0:48:48- It's that plus pricing.
0:48:49- Right, because they don't have to pay the 30%.
0:48:51Apple doesn't have to pay itself 30%
0:48:54for an in-app purchase to sign up.
0:48:57And I do feel that there's arguments to be made there.
0:49:00Again, I'm not a legal expert,
0:49:03but just common sense tells you,
0:49:04well, that is something to argue about, right?
0:49:07I mean, common sense says whether that should be allowed
0:49:11or not, it's at least in this sphere of a debatable,
0:49:15this is something that's logical to debate.
0:49:20I think that what Spotify's arguing here with the bundle
0:49:23to me is sort of getting into the tiny violin,
0:49:28playing the world's saddest song,
0:49:30because Apple could do so much more here, really.
0:49:34The bundle that would really be both lowercase a,
0:49:39now I'm not saying legally anti-competitive, I don't know,
0:49:42but certainly lowercase a, anti-competitive
0:49:46in the common sense term would be if they said,
0:49:48pay us X dollars a month,
0:49:51and we'll give you a new iPhone every two years too, right?
0:49:55So this is the most interesting thing,
0:49:58and it's a thing that didn't happen, right?
0:50:01But why did that not happen?
0:50:03People like you and I have been speculating
0:50:04about an Apple bundle that would,
0:50:06basically you'd an all-in Apple subscription service
0:50:09where you're paying for your phone and AppleCare
0:50:11and a bunch of other stuff, and it's one monthly fee,
0:50:14and a lot of people say, give me that, I want that.
0:50:17And so why didn't they do it?
0:50:18And a really obvious guess, a semi-informed guess on my part
0:50:24is maybe they do wanna do it,
0:50:26but they certainly can't do it in today's political climate
0:50:29when they're fighting antitrust rights.
0:50:31And then the question is, okay,
0:50:34is this something they think they can get to
0:50:36X number of years down the road?
0:50:38Is this something they've held off on doing
0:50:40because they were hoping to be able to do it,
0:50:41and they've concluded, look,
0:50:43we just can't do that anytime soon,
0:50:46so this is what we got.
0:50:47But to me, it's the obvious thing,
0:50:50that's to answer, to respond to the thing I was positing
0:50:54earlier, that's the thing, their version of sports, TV,
0:50:58and free shipping is the phone,
0:51:00and so you should bundle it with the phone,
0:51:02and why aren't they doing that?
0:51:04And they're certainly not gonna come out and say,
0:51:05we'd love to do it, but we'll get killed
0:51:07by the antitrust guys.
0:51:08And for all I know, they're gonna announce it next fall,
0:51:12next with the iPhone.
0:51:14They'll say, ah, now here's the super-duper bundle,
0:51:16but I don't, I think they would wait, right?
0:51:18You wouldn't announce the bundle until,
0:51:20if you were gonna do a super bundle, you'd do it all.
0:51:22- Yeah, I think so too,
0:51:23especially since they've already called
0:51:25the one-tier Premier, and not that they couldn't add
0:51:27a Super Premier that includes a new iPhone.
0:51:30- Super Premier Max.
0:51:31- But that is the, and it is the thing
0:51:37that I still think has at least,
0:51:40I don't wanna project more than 10 years in the future,
0:51:42but I think for the next 10 years,
0:51:45the idea that people will still want a new phone
0:51:48every two or three years is pretty, pretty solid bet,
0:51:53just in terms of camera improvements and stuff, right?
0:51:58If only camera improvements.
0:52:00I really think that five years from now,
0:52:04we'll look back at what our cameras do now on these phones
0:52:07and be like, oh my god, can you believe that piece of junk?
0:52:09Whereas now, we're amazed by it.
0:52:10So I think there's legs on that,
0:52:13that it would be a huge appeal if they said,
0:52:15okay, here, just pay us,
0:52:16I don't know what it would be a month,
0:52:18and every two years, you get a new iPhone,
0:52:20and you get all these services.
0:52:23It's just one, one bet.
0:52:24- Yeah, and whether you care about any spec at all,
0:52:27you just say, look, I just don't care.
0:52:28I know that whatever phone I have is the best phone.
0:52:30I don't need to worry about it.
0:52:32I can afford not to worry about it.
0:52:34This would obviously be towards a wealthier tier
0:52:36of Apple customers who are wealthy to begin with,
0:52:39generally speaking.
0:52:40That's a gross generalization,
0:52:43but compared to an Android consumer,
0:52:47that seems like the no-brainer,
0:52:49and so its absence is super interesting to me.
0:52:52- And it just happens to be,
0:52:54in the wake of Microsoft announcing
0:52:57the same sort of kind of idea
0:53:00with the new Xbox console hardwares,
0:53:02the Series S and the Series X,
0:53:06which I really, it's almost like a speech therapy exercise
0:53:11to make sure that audibly I say S and X differently,
0:53:16but with their game streaming service,
0:53:18and it's, Ben Thompson and I have talked about this
0:53:21on Dithering, it's really a very appealing deal
0:53:24because it's not like a credit card thing
0:53:27where you're paying interest
0:53:30and you wind up paying more over two years
0:53:32than you would have if you just bought it outright.
0:53:35As long as you're interested in the monthly game service,
0:53:40you do this for two years for a monthly fee,
0:53:43and including the game service,
0:53:45you wind up owning an Xbox console at the end
0:53:48for a very appealing monthly rate,
0:53:50and you don't really pay a penalty for it
0:53:52in terms of interest or whatever,
0:53:55and all of a sudden, this multi-hundred dollar console
0:53:59and a library of lots of games has this very appealing,
0:54:03oh, it's 25 bucks a month, that's it.
0:54:05- Yeah, it's super compelling,
0:54:07and we're a household where we're considering
0:54:09making our first sort of big console purchase
0:54:11in a long time, and we're thinking through this right now,
0:54:14and they've had that for a while now,
0:54:16but they're certainly pushing more and more
0:54:18towards gaming as a service,
0:54:21where the device is secondary,
0:54:24and Apple is definitely not in that mode, right?
0:54:27Apple is still, the device is primary.
0:54:28- And so we have to go meta for a moment here
0:54:31and just acknowledge, and you and I, again,
0:54:34we're of a certain age, where can you imagine
0:54:36going back 25 years, 20 years, and telling our former selves
0:54:41that in the year 2020, we're gonna be talking
0:54:44about Microsoft and Apple and one company
0:54:49feeling free and liberated antitrust-wise
0:54:54to offer these content bundles,
0:54:55and the other one sitting on its hands
0:54:59missing an obvious opportunity,
0:55:01and it's Apple that's sort of staring down the barrel
0:55:05of anti-competition regulators,
0:55:08and Microsoft that is like,
0:55:10here, here's this super compelling deal.
0:55:12- Yeah, and also Microsoft being the company
0:55:16that could conceivably have spent 20 or $30 billion
0:55:19to buy the hottest new social media/video service,
0:55:23and all the rest of its competitors couldn't
0:55:25because they were too powerful.
0:55:26- Right, that does sort of go unsaid
0:55:30in the whole TikTok fiasco, was that Microsoft was...
0:55:35- There was no other consumer tech company
0:55:40that could have plausibly tried to get that deal through.
0:55:43- Right. (laughs)
0:55:45I know somebody, there was a report somebody had earlier
0:55:47that Apple at least took a meeting or something,
0:55:50and it's like, I couldn't imagine that,
0:55:51because I guess...
0:55:54- Apple, Apple, Apple, Apple was excited to bat that down.
0:55:58- It doesn't make any sense.
0:55:59- That's one of those, like, yeah,
0:56:01someone called someone from Apple or a banker
0:56:03said they talked to Apple once or something like that.
0:56:05Apple, they went from, we don't comment
0:56:07on rumor and speculation, to hell no.
0:56:10There's no way we're doing this.
0:56:11- It was just sort of the old salesman trick of,
0:56:15hey, you know that rich guy?
0:56:16He's interested. (laughs)
0:56:18- Yeah, I got a lot of people coming down
0:56:20to look at this car, so I can't promise it's here tomorrow.
0:56:24- Very, very true.
0:56:25I wanna keep going on streaming,
0:56:26but I have one more sponsor I wanna thank on this episode,
0:56:28and it's, oh, man, do I love this company, Mack Weldon.
0:56:32Mack Weldon believes in smart design, premium fabrics,
0:56:35and simple shopping.
0:56:36They sell all sorts of stuff.
0:56:39They got started selling underwear, socks,
0:56:42all the sort of dependables that you need in your lower,
0:56:45I keep 'em in my lower drawers, you know,
0:56:46undershirts and underwear and socks and stuff like that.
0:56:49But they've got all sorts of stuff now, hoodies and polos.
0:56:53I had a polo on yesterday from Mack Weldon, love it.
0:56:57One of my all-time favorites.
0:56:59They have a new line of silver underwear and shirts
0:57:01that are naturally antimicrobial,
0:57:04which means they eliminate odor.
0:57:05It's a very friendly way of saying they don't get stinky.
0:57:10But they're super comfortable, very stylish.
0:57:12I love all the color options.
0:57:14They have great, even just great packaging.
0:57:17I'm a nerd for stuff like that,
0:57:19but I like it when I open a new thing
0:57:21and like the packaging is nice and it smells good
0:57:23just coming out of the packaging.
0:57:25Mack Weldon stuff is like that.
0:57:27They have even created their own new, totally free,
0:57:32loyalty program that they call Weldon Blue.
0:57:35Now, you just buy more stuff.
0:57:37All you have to do is buy the stuff you're already buying
0:57:39from Mack Weldon and they just escalate you
0:57:42through the thing.
0:57:43Once you get to level one, you get free shipping for life.
0:57:46So you sort of get that, hey,
0:57:48if you just need some underwear, you just buy it
0:57:50and you know you're getting free shipping.
0:57:52And then once you reach level two,
0:57:54you only have to spend 200 bucks to get there.
0:57:57You start getting 20% off every order for the next year.
0:58:03So you spend 200 bucks, not that much.
0:58:05You've already got level one, which is free shipping,
0:58:08and now you save 20% on every order for the next year
0:58:11as long as you stay at level two.
0:58:12It's a great deal.
0:58:13And there's no fee or anything like that.
0:58:16You just buy good stuff.
0:58:17I wear their stuff all the time.
0:58:19Really do like it.
0:58:21Here's the deal.
0:58:22Go to Mack Weldon, M-A-C-K-W-E-L-D-O-N.com/talkshow.
0:58:27Mack Weldon.com/talkshow.
0:58:32Enter the promo code, talk show, same code,
0:58:35and that'll get you 20% off your first order.
0:58:38It's like you're already at level two.
0:58:40There you go.
0:58:41Mack Weldon, go and buy nice clothing.
0:58:44- Dude, I thought I'd do good Mack Weldon ads,
0:58:47but that was great.
0:58:48- You know what?
0:58:49I love it when it's a, and it just sounds corny
0:58:52and it's like, you know, but I just love it
0:58:54when it's a sponsor whose stuff I really love.
0:58:56And it's like--
0:58:57- My line is I spend my own money on their product,
0:59:00which is true.
0:59:01- Oh, I should mention too, a year ago,
0:59:04Merlin Mann was on the show and I was telling him
0:59:06about the Mack Weldon slippers and then they sold out
0:59:11and they were not a sponsor.
0:59:12We were just talking about them.
0:59:14But I love their slippers 'cause they have a little back
0:59:17so that they stay on.
0:59:17I don't like a backless slipper.
0:59:19And lo and behold, a pandemic hits.
0:59:23I didn't put real shoes on.
0:59:24I wore out a pair of the slippers.
0:59:27But they were the, I've probably spent like 10 years
0:59:31worth of time in slippers in the last six months
0:59:33with the Mack Weldon slippers.
0:59:34They're fantastic.
0:59:35They're the best slippers I've ever owned.
0:59:38- Cosine.
0:59:39- So let's talk streaming in the big world, right?
0:59:45Where Apple is.
0:59:47I kind of feel like, here's an interesting thought I had
0:59:51as I was going off to sleep last night
0:59:53after absorbing all of this.
0:59:56So Apple comes out with this new Fitness Plus thing,
0:59:59which is not for me.
1:00:00- Oh my God, that Twitter fight.
1:00:03- Oh, what's this?
1:00:04- I don't know, it was a Twitter fight.
1:00:04No, no, you were involved in it.
1:00:05- Oh, yeah, yeah.
1:00:06- Watching you and Horace and Ben.
1:00:07- Oh, and the Peloton, yeah, yeah.
1:00:09- Oh my God, yeah.
1:00:10- People that, you know what, Peloton is, I've said this,
1:00:15I've been staying with Ben.
1:00:16So we have a Peloton.
1:00:18I don't use it, my wife does.
1:00:20She won't even let me use it.
1:00:21She's very serious about it.
1:00:23I guess she would let me use it if I asked to.
1:00:26But we are a Peloton family.
1:00:28Ben has one too.
1:00:30It is exactly like arguing with people
1:00:34about Macintosh computers 20, 25 years ago,
1:00:36where people who've never used one, never seen a Macintosh,
1:00:40will just tell you blindly that they're overpriced garbage
1:00:44and you're buying hype and you could buy this other thing
1:00:46for less and it's better.
1:00:48And people saying that you should just buy a regular bicycle
1:00:51and put it on a treadmill or something
1:00:53and then you get the same thing.
1:00:54And it's like, you don't get it.
1:00:56This is like one of the nicest pieces of kit
1:00:59I've ever seen in my life.
1:01:01My wife--
1:01:02- They're very good.
1:01:03And I was a reluctant buyer
1:01:06'cause I didn't wanna own one of them.
1:01:07There was a pandemic.
1:01:08I'm like, all right, 'cause I'm not going to the gym.
1:01:09But, and it's very good and all of that.
1:01:11And yes, there's definitely a cult around it.
1:01:14I'm not in the cult.
1:01:15It's a fine product.
1:01:16I'm happy to buy it,
1:01:17but I'm not gonna go sing its praises.
1:01:19The thing that I find confusing from people
1:01:21who should know better is saying
1:01:22that the Apple exercise thing is competitive with Peloton,
1:01:26but that makes no sense.
1:01:27- It makes no sense at all.
1:01:28- It's competitive with a million other free
1:01:31and paid workout apps and videos, not with a device.
1:01:36- Right, and the device is, it's the starting point.
1:01:40It's not like you sign up for Peloton classes
1:01:42and then, oh, maybe you get the bike.
1:01:44It's like you decide to get the bike
1:01:46and then you sign up for the classes.
1:01:47It's a great product.
1:01:48- Right, you could technically,
1:01:50I mean, and Peloton has sold some people,
1:01:52it's subscription service who don't use the bike,
1:01:55but that's a very small group of people.
1:01:56It doesn't make any sense.
1:01:57- Yeah, and it's not central to their success.
1:02:00That's not their company's story
1:02:02and it's not why people who are bullish on them are bullish.
1:02:06Anyway, I think that the fitness thing
1:02:09is orthogonal to Peloton.
1:02:11I don't wanna get sidetracked on that,
1:02:12but the one thought I had going to sleep last night is,
1:02:14okay, what is the fitness plus thing?
1:02:18In a sense, if you, they talked about it all
1:02:21in the context of actual fitness
1:02:24and you wear your watch and you measure all this stuff,
1:02:27fitness, fitness, fitness, that's what you sign,
1:02:29it's certainly why you would sign up for it,
1:02:30but really all it is is a streaming video platform, right?
1:02:35It looks like they've signed up about 30 trainers.
1:02:41I didn't do a headcount in the class photo,
1:02:46but they have, looks like somewhere around 30 or 40 trainers.
1:02:51To do these, and some of them have specialties.
1:02:54Some of these might be in bicycling or somebody,
1:02:56strength training is obviously very different
1:02:58than cardio training.
1:03:00And it seems like, and they talked about,
1:03:04the diversity's obvious just when you look at it,
1:03:07but apparently personality-wise and background-wise,
1:03:10it's very diverse, but it's sorta like a reality show
1:03:12where there's like, they've got a cast of trainers
1:03:16and you can get to know them and they have personalities.
1:03:20It's 10 bucks a month,
1:03:21and Apple TV+ is five bucks a month.
1:03:26Which one costs more to produce?
1:03:28It's clearly TV+, right?
1:03:33TV+ is, they're spending billions of dollars a year
1:03:36on original content. - That's right.
1:03:38- And it costs five dollars.
1:03:40The scope, I'm not saying that me and you, Peter,
1:03:44can go out and hire 30 trainers,
1:03:46but I feel like I could understand the scope
1:03:50of setting up a direct competitor to Fitness+, right?
1:03:53Get 30, 35 trainers of a diverse background
1:03:57and various skills and studio space and a couple of cameras,
1:04:01and every week we'll have a bunch of these classes.
1:04:03I understand the scope of that.
1:04:05I don't understand the scope of making one top-tier TV+
1:04:10original content series, let alone all of them
1:04:13and the movies that they're--
1:04:14- Jennifer Aniston and Reese Witherspoon
1:04:17got what, two million bucks a piece per episode?
1:04:20I may have inflated a 2X, but that's a lot, yeah.
1:04:23The cost, yeah, and now you'd have to bring in someone
1:04:27who's an actual fitness expert here.
1:04:28I mean, again, during the pandemic,
1:04:30our first thought was, oh, we gotta exercise,
1:04:32let's see what we can get for free on YouTube.
1:04:34And we didn't try very hard,
1:04:35but obviously there's a ton of that free stuff,
1:04:37and there are subscription services,
1:04:38those that have existed for a long time.
1:04:41I can see Apple saying, all right, yeah,
1:04:42people are paying five bucks a month for online yoga,
1:04:45we can charge a premium for that, fine.
1:04:47Or by the way, the Peloton standalone service
1:04:50is however many dollars a month,
1:04:51we can charge less than that, fine.
1:04:53- Right, right, yeah, it's like 30 bucks.
1:04:56- I mean, I don't know.
1:04:58I don't wanna argue about fitness trends.
1:05:01It is hard to imagine a lot of people sticking with that
1:05:05for the same reason that everyone's joke
1:05:07about the Peloton, right, is that it's gonna collect,
1:05:09it's gonna be a good towel rack in a year,
1:05:12because that is the traditional trajectory
1:05:14for any home exercise machine.
1:05:16You can get the Nordic Track or whatever it is,
1:05:18and then it goes unused,
1:05:19and I would imagine fitness will have the same life cycle.
1:05:24But I mean, as we were just talking about, right,
1:05:27there is a bundle of stuff, you can throw that in there.
1:05:29Is it in the bundle, did I miss that?
1:05:31- No, it is if you get the Premier level,
1:05:34which is above family, and it's,
1:05:37so Premier gets you, the editions are News Plus
1:05:41and Fitness Plus, and I asked Apple why,
1:05:46I get why News Plus is in a different tier,
1:05:48because there's, Apple doesn't own the content.
1:05:51There's marginal cost to each subscriber
1:05:53'cause they're paying the participating publications,
1:05:56and I get why News Plus is, for lack of a better term,
1:05:59region locked, because the publications
1:06:02are largely US-centric, and the other countries
1:06:05where it's available, it's a country-by-country rollout,
1:06:09and if you live in a Spanish-speaking country,
1:06:13it doesn't do you any good to sign up
1:06:15for a News Plus subscription
1:06:16for a bunch of English-language publications.
1:06:19Why is Fitness Plus in there?
1:06:22'Cause Apple owns all the IP, and the answer is,
1:06:27it's not really, it's not, they were like,
1:06:29don't read too much about the similarities to News,
1:06:32but at a basic level right now,
1:06:35their initial cast of trainers, they all speak English,
1:06:40and so the countries where Fitness Plus is available
1:06:42are places where English is the primary language,
1:06:45and typical Apple, they have nothing to announce
1:06:48about further plans for other languages.
1:06:50- But that's a very easy solve.
1:06:51You can find Spanish-speaking trainers.
1:06:54- Right, but why, think about it.
1:06:57When you buy hardware devices from Apple,
1:07:00or most companies, just about any company,
1:07:03if one of them is half the price of another,
1:07:06even a casual observer can figure out why.
1:07:10Why is the iPhone SE half the price of the iPhone 11 Pro?
1:07:15Well, it's smaller, and it's older,
1:07:18and it doesn't have Face ID, and it has the old design,
1:07:20and the camera's not as fancy, and there you go.
1:07:24It's not as good a device.
1:07:26But TV Plus is way more stuff
1:07:30that is way, way, way more expensive to produce,
1:07:34and it's only $5 a month,
1:07:35and Fitness Plus is way easier to produce,
1:07:39way more limited, and it's $10 a month.
1:07:41It's like an inverse correlation to spending
1:07:45for how much it costs Apple to produce the Surface.
1:07:48- I don't know, maybe you can do the math
1:07:51where you figure out dollar spent per time used,
1:07:54but I mean, look, why is music $10 a month,
1:07:57but Netflix is $13 a month?
1:08:00There isn't necessarily a math you could do in your head,
1:08:04or the New York Times $15 a month, but the prices are,
1:08:07I mean, I can tell you why Apple TV Plus is $5 a month,
1:08:10or really free, right?
1:08:12It's 'cause no one would pay for it right now.
1:08:15And Apple will concede that.
1:08:18They're like, "We're not, you give us a year minimum
1:08:21"before we can sort of have a fully competitive product,"
1:08:23is what they have told me in the past.
1:08:25And that's fair, right?
1:08:26You just can't, and presumably, Apple's saying,
1:08:28"Yeah, this fitness thing, we're gonna come out
1:08:30"out of the gates, and it'll be competitive
1:08:32"with any other subscription training service."
1:08:36- Right, so yeah, your take more or less matches mine,
1:08:40which is that Fitness Plus is a real product where,
1:08:44what I mean by that is they're saying $10 a month,
1:08:48we can turn a profit, it's a profitable business
1:08:51for us to sign up X million people to pay $10 a month,
1:08:54or to get it in their upgraded Apple One bundle,
1:08:58and the cost it costs us to do this.
1:09:01Whereas TV Plus isn't intended at all
1:09:05as we plan to make a profit selling this for $5 a month
1:09:10and giving it away to as many people
1:09:12as we possibly can excuse ourselves to give it away
1:09:15for year-long extensions at a time.
1:09:18It's the strategy reasons behind them getting
1:09:21into their own original content with TV Plus
1:09:26have nothing to do with making money selling it
1:09:28for $5 a month, and I think that's more clear now
1:09:32and the Fitness Plus thing clarifies that
1:09:34than it was even when they announced it.
1:09:37- Yeah, and I guess I just would hammer on the idea
1:09:38that presumably they're saying,
1:09:40"This is a finished product, this thing is competitive.
1:09:44"If you were using a different subscription service,
1:09:46"you can compare this to that,
1:09:47"or if you were taking classes at your local gym,
1:09:50"which you can no longer go to,
1:09:51"you can compare this to that."
1:09:53Whereas you cannot compare, or you shouldn't
1:09:55if you're Apple, you don't want to compare TV Plus
1:09:58to HBO or HBO Max or Netflix or Disney Plus, right?
1:10:01There's just way more stuff on those other services.
1:10:04- Yeah, but also each of those companies
1:10:07has sort of very different levels of investment in it, right?
1:10:12Like Netflix, what is Netflix?
1:10:15It's nothing but the streaming service, right?
1:10:17- Right, those are different questions
1:10:20than those from the consumer though, right?
1:10:22Like you're gonna spend $10 or $5 or no dollars,
1:10:26and so you don't care why Netflix is priced one way
1:10:29and Disney is priced another,
1:10:31you just know what you're getting for your money.
1:10:32- Right, right.
1:10:35I can't think of another competitive landscape
1:10:39that is so disparate though like that, right?
1:10:42It's like just to pick three, right?
1:10:46So Netflix, everything, the entire company,
1:10:48and they have a massive valuation,
1:10:51and I think rightly so.
1:10:52They're just a huge cultural touchstone worldwide
1:10:56and incredible sell-through
1:11:01in terms of how many people have a Netflix subscription,
1:11:04but there is nothing else to the company
1:11:06than the monthly streaming subscription.
1:11:09Disney sort of in the middle, right?
1:11:11Disney does lots of things and makes money lots of ways
1:11:14with theme parks and cruise lines,
1:11:16and God bless 'em for trying to fill cruise ships
1:11:20going forward, but motion pictures--
1:11:25- Right, they are trying to create their own Netflix
1:11:30in a significant way, and the other would-be competitors
1:11:34are still trying to, they're not trying to do that yet.
1:11:37They may say they are, but they're hedging their bets,
1:11:39and they're not making that same kind of commitment.
1:11:41- Right, and Disney also is a longtime Disney nerd,
1:11:46and I always feel, I feel like the long-term trajectory
1:11:50for Apple in some ways, Disney has always been
1:11:53an interesting pattern to follow, right?
1:11:56There's the charismatic founder who died too young,
1:12:01you know, and what does the company do
1:12:04after Steve Jobs is gone, after Walt Disney is gone?
1:12:07But one of the things that,
1:12:10there's so many similarities between them,
1:12:12but one of the things was that Disney
1:12:16embraced TV at a time when movie studios were anti-TV, right?
1:12:21They were like, the movie studios, you know,
1:12:24movies were movies, and TV was this garbage
1:12:27black and white thing that was staticky,
1:12:29and Walt Disney was like, no, we can be in their homes.
1:12:33Hell yeah, we're gonna have Mickey Mouse on every day,
1:12:36right after school, you know, what time does school end?
1:12:38Three o'clock, 3.30 every day, Mickey Mouse Club.
1:12:42We'll have kids running home to catch the show every day,
1:12:46unlike every other movie studio, and you know,
1:12:49culturally, Disney has always sort of had that idea
1:12:52of they need to stay relevant
1:12:54and not just keep doing what they did,
1:12:56and the way to be relevant in today's world
1:12:58is to have a streaming service, right?
1:13:01TV channels aren't it for kids anymore, right?
1:13:04It's as great as it was.
1:13:06- Yes, yes, and it's also the model
1:13:08the consumer wants, right?
1:13:10- Right.
1:13:11- Broadly, right, I want on demand,
1:13:13and there are still a lot of people,
1:13:15there's 80-some million people
1:13:17who are getting linear cable TV,
1:13:18but that is going to continue to shrink,
1:13:20and they're saying, yeah, we're gonna try to transition
1:13:23out of our existing business while keeping it going
1:13:27and move into streaming.
1:13:29Yeah, it's working.
1:13:31I mean, it's working so far.
1:13:32- I'm, you know, and I remember being a kid,
1:13:35and I don't know how I did it,
1:13:36'cause it's one of those things that seems like,
1:13:40my parents are, you know, just put it
1:13:44as belovedly as I can, a bit tight with the money,
1:13:47and so I kind of can't believe that we got cable TV
1:13:52as early as we did, and I can't believe we got HBO.
1:13:55We had HBO like in the early '80s,
1:13:58and we eventually got rid of it,
1:14:00and I was very upset about it,
1:14:02because it was like, they were like,
1:14:03nobody watches it except you, and I'm like.
1:14:05- Yeah, you were watching Porky's,
1:14:08and there was a Ninja movie, I think, with the big,
1:14:11the big draws.
1:14:13- Nobody watches it but you, John,
1:14:14was not a great way of selling the,
1:14:17we're downgrading from HBO.
1:14:19But I just remember the same thing,
1:14:22where it was like, well, you know,
1:14:24a majority of households don't have cable TV.
1:14:26They still get their TV over the air,
1:14:28and it's like, yeah, that's, you know,
1:14:30that was, you know, it's hard to believe,
1:14:32but yeah, that's how the '80s went,
1:14:33where there were still lots of people who didn't have cable
1:14:36and had, you know, rabbit ears, you know,
1:14:38getting their TV reception.
1:14:40- Yeah, and that turned out to be a giant expansion
1:14:42of the media business, and in the same way,
1:14:45like the CDs were a giant expansion of the music business.
1:14:49What you are seeing now
1:14:50with all these big streaming companies is,
1:14:53they are inevitably going to have smaller profit margins
1:14:57because they do have to throw so much more into programming
1:15:00because it is so much more competitive,
1:15:02because they're not gonna have that really,
1:15:04really fat bundle that they can sort of
1:15:06force people to take.
1:15:07And so you are gonna see a lot of sort of the fun of,
1:15:11and fun and compensation taken out of working
1:15:15in the media business, which again,
1:15:16doesn't matter if you're the consumer,
1:15:18and for the consumer, it's great right now.
1:15:19You have more choice than ever.
1:15:21- What do you think of where Time Warner is,
1:15:26and HBO in particular?
1:15:29- I find HBO, I have it, you know, and we're in HBO.
1:15:32We've always been an HBO family,
1:15:34and I have some shows I like there,
1:15:35but I think HBO Max is a mess, brand-wise.
1:15:40- It is a mess, brand-wise, the actual sort of UI,
1:15:46and I'm not someone who spends a lot of time
1:15:47thinking about UI, except that I've been watching
1:15:50a lot of video in the last six months,
1:15:52or however long the pandemic's gone on for,
1:15:54and I'm a fan of Netflix, the product,
1:15:58but I didn't realize how much better they were
1:16:01at sort of getting you the thing you want
1:16:03than everybody else.
1:16:04I've been trying to watch a bunch of Amazon Prime recently.
1:16:06It's terrible at saying, "This is the show you were watching.
1:16:10"Would you like to continue watching it?"
1:16:12All of that stuff, they're terrible at.
1:16:14I mean, you know, HBO Max, AT&T just brought on Jason Kyler,
1:16:19who ran Hulu in its glory days.
1:16:21He's a product guy.
1:16:22That product will look better eventually.
1:16:25It will no longer, when you're trying to watch a download
1:16:30of Perry Mason in your mother-in-law's Philadelphia house,
1:16:35to name an example that I can think of recently,
1:16:37and you have downloaded it, it won't require six extra steps
1:16:41for you to find that thing on your phone.
1:16:43It will get better.
1:16:44And similarly, it's a grab bag of stuff, right?
1:16:48Friends and the Criterion Collection.
1:16:51I think they'll sort that out over time.
1:16:53And the bigger question is, does AT&T,
1:16:55which is still a phone company
1:16:58and has an enormous amount of debt
1:16:59that it has to service and has to pay out dividends,
1:17:02it has all these financial obligations,
1:17:04do they want to spend competitively
1:17:06to keep up with Netflix and Disney?
1:17:09Right.
1:17:10And we don't know the answer to that yet.
1:17:11And even Apple, who I think, you know,
1:17:14I mean, just like the way that Apple scooped up the,
1:17:16I forget the name of it already,
1:17:17the Tom Cruise, or not Tom Cruise, Tom Hanks,
1:17:20World War II. Greyhound, yeah.
1:17:22Yeah, Greyhound, which was totally a COVID opportunity.
1:17:26It was supposed to be a big theatrical movie,
1:17:27but it couldn't.
1:17:28And it's just one of those things where,
1:17:32well, why did Apple win the bidding?
1:17:34One of the reasons is that it's a pittance for Apple, right?
1:17:38You know, oh, $100 million, whatever, you know.
1:17:44Sounds good.
1:17:44Apple is, the most recently described to me is,
1:17:48this is pre-COVID, but the new dumb money in Hollywood.
1:17:52That Eddy Cue is the most important guy,
1:17:54but he's the person you bring your project to first
1:17:57because he may pay the most,
1:17:59which isn't really a ringing endorsement.
1:18:01And again, they'll probably sort that over time.
1:18:04I mean, Amazon has also done money.
1:18:06They're burning money on this Lord of the Rings prequel,
1:18:10which doesn't exist yet.
1:18:12And it's sort of astonishing that they've been at video
1:18:14for so long and really have not made a ton of progress.
1:18:18But again, Amazon can afford to screw around
1:18:21and not get it right for a long time.
1:18:23So can Apple.
1:18:25Netflix is getting it right.
1:18:27They're still spending $3 billion a year more
1:18:30than they're bringing in to finance all this stuff.
1:18:33But Wall Street's okay with it.
1:18:35And then, but for these other companies
1:18:37that are in the middle, where it is their core business,
1:18:41but it's unclear how much they're gonna be able
1:18:43to throw at that, that's the real question mark.
1:18:45And it's weird to talk about the company
1:18:47that used to be called Time Warner being sort of
1:18:50in the middle of the tier of giant media companies,
1:18:55but that's kind of where they are right now.
1:18:57- That's a good way to wrap up.
1:18:58Thank you, Peter Kafka.
1:19:00Anything else you wanted to talk about?
1:19:04- I'm delighted to be on the internet with you, John.
1:19:06Thank you for having me.
1:19:07- Let me thank our sponsors, Mack Weldon and Linode.
1:19:10And everybody can catch Peter's own podcast, Recode Media,
1:19:14just on your favorite podcast player.
1:19:16- Oh, I'll plug something I already did.
1:19:19We did, my colleague and I, Ronnie Mola,
1:19:20did a seven-part series on Netflix called Land of the Giants,
1:19:23which you can also get where you hear your favorite podcast.
1:19:26So if you like hearing about Netflix and streaming,
1:19:28we've got seven episodes of that for you.
1:19:30- Excellent.
1:19:31Thank you, Peter.