0:00:00So, lots of stuff going on this week. I guess the big one, you know, I think if we look
0:00:04back, if we did like a week by week highlight, you know, years from now, we'd look back
0:00:09and the big news this week is Satya Nadella is being named the CEO at Microsoft.
0:00:14Pete: Yup.
0:00:15Pete: Yup.
0:00:16Dave: And it's a little weird because it leaked a little bit early and I think in
0:00:22hindsight, it's sort of a, like my initial take is why did it take him so long to name
0:00:28the guy because it seemed pretty obvious.
0:00:30Right. I totally agree with that. You know, there have been...how many different front-runners
0:00:37have there been? At first it was Steven Elop, right?
0:00:40Right.
0:00:41Then it became the Ford CEO, Alan Mulally. Is that right?
0:00:47Mulally?
0:00:48Mulally? I'm not sure how to pronounce it.
0:00:49I think it's Mulally.
0:00:51And then, you know, there were some other names bandied about.
0:00:56The Skype guy, Tony Bates.
0:01:00But they were more, I guess they were more dark horses.
0:01:03But Satya Nadella is one that was always mentioned, certainly, because he is one of the senior
0:01:08executives there.
0:01:09But it is, you know, it seems like everyone is saying that this is the absolute right
0:01:14call, but why wasn't it the right call six months ago?
0:01:17Yeah, and the only one that I could see that maybe they wanted to really push on was Malali
0:01:26from Ford and he used to be at Boeing, which means he has Seattle area roots.
0:01:32And you know, and while I first I thought, well, Ford, that's not really a technical
0:01:38company, but you read up on Malali, he does have an engineering background.
0:01:42He's not like a business school mind.
0:01:46He's an engineering guy who worked up to become an executive.
0:01:49So it's not outlandish.
0:01:51And the story that was told on that was that, hey, and he's a little bit older.
0:01:56He's already had a successful career.
0:01:57He's very successful at Boeing, turned Ford around through a very difficult time for the
0:02:02car industry.
0:02:03He would just go to Microsoft for a couple of years and sort of take probably, and it
0:02:08was even rumored, Nadella under his wing and sort of teach him the ropes of being a CEO.
0:02:14Yeah, that sounds like a pretty good theory about that because that is the one main criticism,
0:02:20I guess, that people have of Nadal is that he's never been a CEO at all. And so taking
0:02:24over one of the largest companies in the world is certainly going to be a challenge and it
0:02:28probably would have been beneficial to have a "coach" to help him along that. But he is
0:02:35Bill Gates now to do that too.
0:02:38Right. But my thought on the timing is though, when Mullally backed out and just said, pretty
0:02:44much point blank. You know what? I'm staying at Ford. That's it. Then I don't understand
0:02:49why it took months after that for this to be named.
0:02:52Yeah, it seems like, who knows? I mean, reading into all the various stories that have come
0:02:57out in these past few months, it definitely does sound like there was quite a bit of tension
0:03:03on the board between, in particular, sort of between some of the candidates they were
0:03:08talking to and the power dynamics of would Gates remain chairman and would Ballmer remain
0:03:13on the board because that would be a very weird situation,
0:03:17I would imagine, for someone, an outsider especially,
0:03:20to come into that company with the two previous CEOs
0:03:24on their board of directors.
0:03:26Well, we didn't do it this way in the past type thing
0:03:31coming up again and again and again, you can imagine.
0:03:34It seems like there was definitely a board struggle
0:03:37a little bit and they finally have sorted that out,
0:03:39but I still don't know why that took six months.
0:03:41- Yeah, and I feel like there was a story in the journal
0:03:46a day or two after the announcement
0:03:48that was purported to be the,
0:03:49hey, here's what happened behind the scenes.
0:03:51And there was a little bit of color,
0:03:53but not really anything that explained why it took as long.
0:03:58And I get, like the real story behind it did not come out.
0:04:01- Yeah, yeah, I think I read that as well.
0:04:03And there's other sort of things
0:04:06that have yet to be seen on this.
0:04:07So the one guy from, you know, the activist shareholder
0:04:12is going to be taking a board seat soon,
0:04:14from value click, I think that's what it was.
0:04:17And so, you know, there was a lot of talk
0:04:20of when that was going to happen,
0:04:21like sort of Balmer had to concede
0:04:23that he was going to allow this activist shareholder
0:04:26to take the board seat.
0:04:27And what does that mean for the dynamics of the board
0:04:29now that Gates is no longer chairman?
0:04:32And I don't, like no one's really talking
0:04:35about that right now, but I don't know what that will mean.
0:04:37because you would assume that the activist shareholder
0:04:39wanted to take the board seat in order to shake things up.
0:04:42Things have already been shaken up now.
0:04:44So what is his role there?
0:04:48And why does his company still want that position?
0:04:52I would imagine it's to see how things go
0:04:54for the first few months,
0:04:55to see if Microsoft is actually willing now
0:04:58with new leadership to change direction in any way.
0:05:02And I don't know, what are your thoughts on that?
0:05:03Do you think that they actually will
0:05:06sort of changed from Balmer's last reorg stance?
0:05:11- I don't know and I think everybody,
0:05:15I don't think you have to be juiced into Microsoft
0:05:18or be a keen observer.
0:05:19Just common sense tells you that,
0:05:22I think it was Guy English who was on the show
0:05:24a couple months ago or weeks ago and we talked about,
0:05:26it's just weird that they did the reorg,
0:05:30then said Balmer's leaving.
0:05:32- Yeah. - You know,
0:05:33really seems like, hey, we want a new CEO and we want to reorg. It seems like the way
0:05:38you do that is you put the new CEO in and let the new CEO run and structure and improve
0:05:45of the reorg. And I guess naming an insider, a guy, you know, Nadella, who's been there,
0:05:52it adds a little bit of continuity and, you know, maybe that it makes a little bit more
0:05:57sense. But then that again raises to me the question of why they didn't just name him
0:06:00earlier.
0:06:01Yeah, I think that by sort of doing that reorg, that certainly seems to speak to the notion
0:06:10that perhaps Balmer wasn't at all ready to go, even though he sort of made it seem like
0:06:16it was his own call.
0:06:18And ultimately it may have been, but he was certainly at least pushed in that direction,
0:06:23I would imagine.
0:06:24Because it does seem insane that he would orchestrate this entire change of the company,
0:06:29Even if he thought someone, an insider, was going to take over underneath him.
0:06:33It's still like, you know, it's someone else sort of setting the table for your dinner.
0:06:41It's a weird thing.
0:06:42And then what about the element of, remember all this Steven Elop stuff that leaked?
0:06:48Yeah, yeah.
0:06:49Talking about how different, you know, he's gonna cut everything up into little pieces
0:06:54and sell off certain businesses.
0:06:57Do we think that was from him or from one of his rivals camps because it obviously it ultimately I don't know if it torpedoed his
0:07:03His candidacy, but it certainly ended up not helping it because he's not the CEO right now
0:07:08Yeah, that's a good question either either it must be one or the other it must either be that he thought it helped and that
0:07:15He must have also thought that he or knew you know like in private conversation that he had some support on the board
0:07:23And that leaking it
0:07:26would get
0:07:28outsiders, you know like investors, you know, I mean and yeah like the like the people were just talking right the value act people who would
0:07:35Definitely I think that that's their sort of stated goal who is sorted to get Microsoft to to cut itself up into little pieces
0:07:41to to sort of throw
0:07:43Pressure behind that and and make it you know
0:07:47Put every put pressure on the ones who were maybe pushing against elop to go his way
0:07:51Or you know and it is you know, and it's it sounds you know
0:07:55You start you say this and it sounds a little silly and you start thinking maybe you know, come on
0:07:59Everything's not like a movie but you know what they're in real life
0:08:02There are politics and people do play dirty tricks
0:08:04The other our idea would be that it was somebody else
0:08:07Who seeded it to make him look bad like he can't keep his mouth shut and that yeah
0:08:12It's a leak to the press sort of guy
0:08:14Yeah, that's sort of you know again, who knows what's actually going on?
0:08:18But that sounds fairly plausible because of the you saw what the reaction was to it when that happened
0:08:24It's like, oh my god, this is insane.
0:08:28Well, there were two camps, as there always are.
0:08:30The people who think that Microsoft should be split up
0:08:33are like, hell yeah, this is exactly what they need to do.
0:08:35And then there's the people who are just
0:08:37looking at the company overall and just having gone through
0:08:40sort of this reorg and saying, oh my god,
0:08:42this is going to throw things into further disarray.
0:08:45This is pretty much the end of Microsoft
0:08:47if they let this happen.
0:08:48If I had to guess, though, I think
0:08:50that it was Elop and his people who leaked it,
0:08:54because if it weren't, he could've,
0:08:58there are ways for him to, you know,
0:09:00if he somehow tried, got thrown under the bus
0:09:03by somebody else, there's ways that he could
0:09:05spin it the other way, you know,
0:09:07and if it wasn't his actual plan
0:09:09to split the company up like that,
0:09:11you know, he could've--
0:09:13- Yeah, come out and just said so.
0:09:14- Yeah, and said this, you know,
0:09:15that didn't come from me, that's not my plan.
0:09:17I don't-- - Yeah, what if it's,
0:09:20what if it was a situation where he sorta knew
0:09:22that he, at that point, somehow he knew
0:09:24that he wasn't the front runner,
0:09:25and he thought, let's just try something wild,
0:09:27and sort of a John McCain kidding Sarah Palin in the race.
0:09:31And it backfires like that.
0:09:33- What's the old saying, never attribute to malice
0:09:37what can be attributed to stupidity?
0:09:39And I always thought that that made a lot of sense,
0:09:44even with the whole thing where he was at Nokia,
0:09:51And when he first went there from Microsoft,
0:09:53and there were a lot of people who said,
0:09:54"Wait, they've hired a guy from Microsoft,
0:09:56"and then he comes in, and the first thing he says is,
0:09:58"we should ditch all of our existing plans
0:10:01"and go with Windows Phone."
0:10:03And a lot of people said, "Is this, you know,
0:10:04"is he like a double agent?
0:10:06"Is he, you know--"
0:10:07- The puppet government.
0:10:08- Right, I mean, what if he's come in here
0:10:10and purposefully trying to run the company into the ground
0:10:14so that Microsoft can buy them?
0:10:15And then he ran the company into the ground,
0:10:18lost a lot of shareholder value.
0:10:20and made tens of millions of dollars for himself when--
0:10:24- Right, right, with a crazy contract
0:10:26that was structured in a way that if the company
0:10:30lost a lot of value and was sold,
0:10:33or if the Mobile Handset Division was sold,
0:10:35that he would profit.
0:10:36- Right, it played out, you know,
0:10:40the conspiracy theorists would have a field day
0:10:42with that one, 'cause it played out perfectly
0:10:44along those lines.
0:10:45- Right, and so I don't know, I mean,
0:10:47it actually, it makes sense both ways,
0:10:49that he's actually not very good at his job, or he's devilishly good but devious.
0:10:58Both explanations make sense.
0:11:00I don't think either explanation makes him a good pick to be Microsoft's CEO, though.
0:11:05I agree.
0:11:07And there's another sort of interesting wrinkle to this one.
0:11:09I was sort of reading through all these stories that I realized, which is that now not being
0:11:14CEO, he is going to be when the deal, I think the deal is closing sometime this quarter
0:11:19with Nokia, he will be the one put in charge of the devices business basically.
0:11:27And that was with the previous re-org, if you remember there was this sort of big press
0:11:33cycle around Julie Larson Green, who was previously an executive but not one of the senior executives
0:11:41at the company, and she was being elevated to senior executive and put in charge of the
0:11:45devices thing right before they announced the Nokia deal.
0:11:49And I remember, I think there was, I don't remember who ran the profile, it may have
0:11:52been The Verge, it may have been someone else, but they had a big profile on her and how
0:11:57she's ascending to the top of the company and maybe she will one day be CEO.
0:12:02And now all of a sudden with the Nokia deal, ELOP is now her boss, so she got demoted essentially.
0:12:10And then thinking there was that, well, maybe it's only a temporary thing because maybe
0:12:15when ELOP is anointed CEO, she will get her job back.
0:12:20But it obviously didn't play out that way.
0:12:23Yeah.
0:12:24And is she still...
0:12:27She's not in charge of Windows, though?
0:12:29I would have to look what it is.
0:12:32I do know that she was...
0:12:34I know she was for a while.
0:12:35She worked with Sinofsky.
0:12:37Yeah, right.
0:12:39Yeah, right because she took over when when he was out and sort of took over that thing
0:12:44But yeah, I believe with the reorg. She was the one being put in charge of the division that
0:12:48ELOP is now and will be in charge of once once they acquire Nokia. All right, I
0:12:54Think one thing that springs to my mind and and it really shows I think I really do think
0:13:01that
0:13:04Just how how badly a job balmer did in certain ways and I do know I know that he you know under his
0:13:11Leadership the company's revenues and profits have gone up up up
0:13:15Yep, even over the last few years, and that's you know
0:13:18So he's by no measure a complete failure, and and I think you know for years
0:13:24It's not just after the fact, but all along
0:13:26He's publicly stated that that's how he measures the success of the company right?
0:13:32So in some measures, you know, Microsoft's board got exactly what they thought they were should have thought they were gonna get under balmer
0:13:39but the one of the ways that I think that he really left them in the lurch was was with
0:13:44How many other executives he effectively pushed out over the last five six years like synovsky like Ray Ozzie?
0:13:52Robbie boss, yeah the to the Xbox guy Jay Allard Jay allard, right who you know a lot of people sort of
0:14:01you know, even just a couple of years ago, I'm not even sure what he's up to anymore,
0:14:06but even just a couple years ago, a lot of people considered him sort of appear to like a Tony
0:14:12Fidele, like a rival, you know, like, right, you know, near the top, and then charge of consumer
0:14:18devices and a keen eye for, you know, leading that sort of team. And all those people were gone,
0:14:24and all those people and who know, you know, some of them, maybe they should have been gone. I don't
0:14:28I always thought Ray Ozzie, for example, to me was a little bit, was not a practical person.
0:14:34It always seemed to me when I listened to him talk that he, I was like, "What did he
0:14:39really say?"
0:14:40I don't know.
0:14:41It never really made a lot of sense to me.
0:14:43Well, and he, I mean, he had sort of the hardest role to step into, which was replacing the
0:14:47Gates role, right?
0:14:48Because he was supposed to be the chief software architect.
0:14:51So I'm not going to say that all of them should have stayed or that it was possible.
0:14:55But the fact is that none of them stayed.
0:14:57All of them are gone.
0:14:58And so in terms of continuity and picking somebody from the inside and having a smooth
0:15:05transition, which, you know, and let's just face it, in some aspects the public relations
0:15:10of a CEO transition are, the stakes are high but the optics are simple, right?
0:15:17What you really want is a nice smooth handoff with a handshake and a smile and it all happens
0:15:22in one announcement.
0:15:23Right?
0:15:24It's I'm stepping down and I'm happy to say the board has already approved that my protege
0:15:30insert name here is
0:15:33Replacing me the company's in great hands. We've worked together for the last so many years
0:15:38He or she has led this part of the company it's great success
0:15:43Couldn't be happier. It's a great day for the company
0:15:47There you go
0:15:47and that is which is exactly what Apple did under very different circumstances for the stepping down of the
0:15:53of the CEO, right?
0:15:56It was, but, you know,
0:15:59Apple was clearly set up where,
0:16:03in some alternate universe where, you know,
0:16:07Jobs stayed a step ahead of the cancer,
0:16:12but decided, you know,
0:16:15took a look at what happened with the cancer
0:16:19and took a look at what he'd done through, you know,
0:16:21the release of the iPad and said, you know what?
0:16:24I'm going to Hawaii.
0:16:25Right, I'm gonna become chairman of the board
0:16:28and I'm gonna come in for two or three weeks a year
0:16:30and I'm going to Hawaii for the other 50, 49 weeks a year.
0:16:34It would have been Tim Cook is, you know,
0:16:39he's been COO for all this time, he's done a great job.
0:16:43The company's in great hands, you know, Sayonara, right?
0:16:46It would have been exact same transition,
0:16:48just not without the tragedy.
0:16:52- Yes.
0:16:53- And Balmer really, and I can't help but feel
0:16:58that political intrigue-wise that he did that on purpose.
0:17:03That it was too, it's sort of a godfather,
0:17:06like a mafia movie type scenario,
0:17:08but with the set of Killing 'Em,
0:17:09it's just squeezing people out of the company.
0:17:11- Yeah, and there've long been those sort of rumors
0:17:14that that is what Balmer was like,
0:17:17not so even secretly doing, sort of just anyone who was rising to a level that seemed like
0:17:22it could challenge him within the company was somehow immediately, you know, exited.
0:17:29Right, 'cause so just take, for example, Sinofsky, who is a very smart guy, and when you read
0:17:33like, you know, he's blogging now and stuff, his stuff is, to me, very cogent and makes
0:17:37a lot of sense. You know, I think if he had still been at the company, clearly would have
0:17:43been a if not the leading candidate and he wasn't there anymore and at once he's
0:17:49not there anymore I feel like PR wise the board was kind of you know legally
0:17:56speaking of course they could hire anybody you know they could hire you
0:17:59know they could try to hire Tim Cook they could hire you know they could
0:18:03certainly bring Sanofsky back but bringing Sanofsky back would be like a
0:18:06slap in Balmer's face and it would make the company look bad yeah for sure like
0:18:10Like their hands were tied in terms of if any of those people who left the company,
0:18:15if the board actually thought these were good candidates to lead the company.
0:18:20So what do you think happens now with Nadella as CEO?
0:18:23Do you think that there will be more internal sort of shakeup and strife?
0:18:28Do you think people will leave because they were either passed over?
0:18:31Like we'll see what happens with Elop.
0:18:33I assume that he can't.
0:18:35He must have some sort of handcuffs that are a part of the Nokia deal where he has to come
0:18:40over and actually stay within the company for a while. But there's others. There's Tony
0:18:45Bates like we were talking about. There's several others who could have felt like they
0:18:50were slighted in some way and are they going to feel weird now being managed by or being
0:18:56overseen by what was their peer before?
0:18:58Right. I don't know. I don't know enough about the company to have a sense of that. My guess
0:19:04is no though it sounds to me and reading you know the blogs of people who are
0:19:10more juiced into Microsoft and and you know no people who work there it seems
0:19:16like he's a very pop seen as a popular choice from within the company yeah so
0:19:21if there are executives who might leave if ELOP might try to get out now or
0:19:26whatever I don't know but I think in terms of the rank and file though it's
0:19:29it's seen as a good move yeah and I think that's sort of been the consensus
0:19:33among everything you read, even sort of talking to Microsoft employees.
0:19:37Now they seem pretty excited about this.
0:19:39I do think though, I think there is still the lingering questions in the air as to once
0:19:45this honeymoon period is over, what they are actually going to do.
0:19:49Is it going to just be executing Balmer's strategy with Nadella, or are they going to
0:19:56actually try to make some different choices with some of the products that just aren't
0:20:01going anywhere?
0:20:02And well, and the other big question I have is,
0:20:06what is Bill Gates' actual role?
0:20:10- Yeah.
0:20:10- And it was, you know, it's, I forget how they phrase it,
0:20:14it was actually a very deft turn of phrase where he's,
0:20:17not that he stepped down as chairman,
0:20:20but he stepped up into a day-to-day role.
0:20:23It's actually, you know, we laugh,
0:20:25but it's actually a very good PR writer.
0:20:27- The way it is put it, yeah, totally, totally.
0:20:29Yep.
0:20:31- You know, so--
0:20:31He said he's going to be spending a third of his time on this, on Microsoft now, which
0:20:35is significant considering before, obviously he was chairman, but I think he was not involved
0:20:43in a very major way at all.
0:20:44It's all his philanthropy.
0:20:46So now he's willing to take on this more.
0:20:49But what does that mean?
0:20:51I don't know.
0:20:53I think the easiest thing in the world that I think he could do that would be beneficial
0:20:58to the company is just something as simple as being the yes/no man, the last word on
0:21:06what they actually decide to go after in terms of new projects or what they actually ship.
0:21:12It just seems like they are at this place now where they put everything out there.
0:21:18Windows 8 is a good example of that in my mind because all of us looking at it from
0:21:23the outside, not all of us, but a lot of us looking at it from the outside, I think saw
0:21:27where this was going. I remember I was talking to developers who were beta testing Windows
0:21:338 and trying to gauge their thoughts on it. And everyone was unanimous and saying, "This
0:21:40is going to be a total nightmare for the company." And somehow the company didn't see that. And
0:21:46they thought it'd be a great thing and they shipped it. I don't know if they just weren't
0:21:49talking to people on the outside or what, but there should have been someone within
0:21:53the company with the power to be able to say like look let's stop here I know it will look
0:21:58really bad if we delay a major operating system but you know it might be worse if we ship
0:22:04something that you know the community just totally rejects which is what happened.
0:22:09I you know my take on it as I wrote last week is that I think that Windows 8 was designed
0:22:15to fit a goal as opposed to being designed to be good in and of itself.
0:22:24By which I mean that to me, Balmer never shook the view that the way things ought to be in
0:22:32the world, the right way, the way the industry should be, should be that somewhere around
0:22:3695% of all computing devices should be running Windows.
0:22:41And that was no, you know, iOS and Android combined in two very different ways.
0:22:49But you know, hand in hand over the last six years changed that to the case where, you
0:22:56know, Horace Dejue is the one who graphed this.
0:22:59I think brilliantly that it's only like, if you count smartphones and tablets as computing
0:23:05devices, which I think is very, very fair.
0:23:07You're installing apps on them, you're browsing the web.
0:23:09Yeah, you're doing all the same thing windows in our computers
0:23:12There's more windows devices in use than ever before in the aggregate, but because there's so many other computing devices
0:23:19It's an explosion of new devices that only you know in
0:23:222007 90% of all computing devices were running windows 90 and in
0:23:272013 at the end of the year it was like 38% or 35%
0:23:32It's an enormous number, but now it's like the world is federated. It's you know there's yeah
0:23:39There's three or four mega platforms for computing devices and Windows is just one of them and it's not even
0:23:46A majority anymore and it never will be again
0:23:49But I don't think bomber ever came to grips with that and accepted it and I think Windows 8's goal was look people want touch
0:23:55screens will add a touchscreen thing to it and then everything in theory could be running Windows 8 and
0:24:01Yep, that'll be good. And and that's and that's so crazy when you think about that
0:24:06just when you're saying that right now,
0:24:08it's just like, Microsoft obviously looked at the world,
0:24:12they saw their dominant position,
0:24:14and you have to assume that they were looking around them
0:24:17seeing who could possibly compete with us,
0:24:21and sort of looking at the competition,
0:24:22it's like Apple is out there,
0:24:23and they have a very small percentage
0:24:25of market share with Macs.
0:24:27And instead what happened is they were just totally blindsided
0:24:31'cause they didn't realize that the competition
0:24:33wouldn't come in the form of an actual computer,
0:24:35It would come in the form of a phone, and then later a tablet, and now Balmer saw that
0:24:41six, seven years too late, and now is trying to squeeze windows, which doesn't even make
0:24:47sense of course.
0:24:49There are no more windows onto these devices in order to sort of unify and get the house
0:24:55back in order, but you just can't do that.
0:24:57Yeah, and I really don't think it matters that much.
0:25:02And I got a lot of pushback on that.
0:25:03Or I got mostly agreement, but I got some pushback
0:25:08on my piece last week from people who truly do believe
0:25:13that what they want is--
0:25:15and admitting that Windows 8, as it is,
0:25:18is not perfect and not good enough,
0:25:20but that the goal is tenable to have one operating system
0:25:24and have a device that is terrific for mouse
0:25:27and keyboard or trackpad and keyboard,
0:25:29or a mouse pointer on screen and pixel precise control
0:25:34and touch and that you could do it
0:25:36and then it would simplify things
0:25:37because you've got all that,
0:25:39you can have your cake and eat it too.
0:25:43And I'm not gonna say they're wrong,
0:25:45I can't prove that they're wrong.
0:25:46All I can say is that everything I've seen to date
0:25:50suggests that they're wrong.
0:25:52- And you're thinking about it, of course,
0:25:55like in a utopian world where everything is perfect,
0:25:59would you rather have one device that can do everything
0:26:02versus sort of two or three devices
0:26:04that you have to have with you at all times?
0:26:05Of course, I think everyone would want that.
0:26:08But it's not that simple.
0:26:09It's not that simple for both users,
0:26:10but it's also not that simple for developers.
0:26:12Could you imagine a developer trying to develop
0:26:14a Windows 8 application for both a phone and a computer
0:26:19that operates in the same way?
0:26:22I mean, they would, first of all,
0:26:23it can't operate in the same way.
0:26:25And so they would take so much more developments into it.
0:26:28And like, do you think a startup
0:26:30is going to be able to do that?
0:26:31You know, a company with like two people,
0:26:33they're going to have to do all this work
0:26:35to get something to work on this Windows unified platform.
0:26:38It's just not realistic to think about it,
0:26:41at least right now.
0:26:43So I don't know, you know, who in their right mind
0:26:45would actually argue that we can live
0:26:48in that world right now.
0:26:49It's just, we can't.
0:26:50- And you know, to me, I've always said, you know,
0:26:56question I've tried to you know my whole writing career is what is design what
0:27:01does it mean and it's it's hard it's hard to really nail it down but the best
0:27:05explanation I've ever come up with is design is making decisions to solve
0:27:10problems it's the decision-making and I'll go back to when they unveiled the
0:27:16surface strategy and they came out with two they have the surface that runs real
0:27:22Windows and can have you know traditional Windows apps and it runs on
0:27:26Intel chips the surface Pro it was right and then there's a surface RT which was
0:27:30the more iPad style one which ran on ARM and was thinner and lighter but only ran
0:27:37you know the metro apps right to me that's a failure of design it's both are
0:27:43reasonable strategies but you can't ship both right you you know there there was
0:27:50Just it's nowhere near as profound a difference. But I know for a fact that I'm sure you I think
0:27:57we even talked about this but late in the game for the original iPad and and the original one
0:28:04and for the first two years had an equal width bezel all the way around the screen. Easy to
0:28:09forget now with the air and the new mini and they had version with the home button where it is and
0:28:17And then they had another version where the home button was on the long side.
0:28:22In other words, that is the default orientation of an iPad, horizontal or vertical, landscape
0:28:28or portrait.
0:28:29And they had both versions until very late in the game and only made that decision at
0:28:36the end.
0:28:37And in fact, if I'm not mistaken, I'm sure if I am that I'll get an email about it, but
0:28:41But I'm pretty sure that the coordinate system of the iPad for developers, I don't even know
0:28:47if it still is the same, but the coordinate system was such that the zero zero point made
0:28:52it seem as though the home button should be on the long side, not the short side.
0:28:58They didn't ship both of those.
0:28:59Right?
0:29:00They didn't say, "Hey, if you want an iPad, figure out which way you want to hold it,
0:29:05and you know, most of the time, and buy the one with the home button as such."
0:29:10They shipped one.
0:29:11They had to decide.
0:29:13And I know that that happened to be a contentious decision within the company and it really
0:29:18was like a 51 to 49 type thing.
0:29:23And surely, because of when it came out, the deciding vote came down to Steve Jobs.
0:29:30But it was a lot of people on both sides of that.
0:29:33But I don't think anybody, even the people who wanted it on the other location, nobody
0:29:38would have endorsed the idea of shipping both.
0:29:41Right.
0:29:42You know, and I feel like that's what the Surface Pro versus Surface RT is, that there
0:29:45were people within the company who wanted it one way and people who wanted it the other,
0:29:49and so they said, "Okay, let's make everybody happy.
0:29:51We'll ship both."
0:29:52Yeah, and I wonder if sort of Balmer's thought on that was like, "Look, we're already behind
0:29:58in this space.
0:29:59Let's just get both out there and see which works, if any of them work, and maybe sort
0:30:05let the masses decide what they want since we really can't afford to make one bet here.
0:30:11But I can't imagine that is how that played out because of course they took a, what was it,
0:30:17a $900 million write down on the RT that was very detrimental to that one quarter where it basically
0:30:24sank and tanked their entire quarter. And that's not Ballmer's, as we just talked about, he's the
0:30:30business guy. He always delivered his numbers and that was the one quarter he did really awful on.
0:30:34A billion here and a billion there and you eventually do have a problem no matter how big you are.
0:30:39Yeah, right.
0:30:40Let me take a break here and thank our first sponsor. First sponsor is our good friends
0:30:45at Squarespace. Now you know Squarespace. Squarespace is constantly improving their platform
0:30:51with new features, new designs, and even better support. They have beautiful designs for you to
0:30:56start with and all the style options you need to create your own unique website for yourself
0:31:02or your business. Easy to use. Their support team is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
0:31:08If 100 employees on this customer care team alone based in New York, it's an amazing thing. The
0:31:15support alone is one of the most amazing things. Services plan start at just $8 a month and include
0:31:23a free domain name if you sign up for a year, eight bucks a month for a top notch platform for
0:31:29launching your website, you can start a trial with no credit card required. Free trial,
0:31:38right? And that's it. I just noticed that from another sponsor and another thing earlier
0:31:41and that that no credit card required is a big deal because everybody knows if you if
0:31:45the free trial requires a credit card, that means if you forget to cancel, you're going
0:31:49to start getting charged and then you got to deal with the hassle. No credit card required
0:31:53the free trial you don't start paying you don't give them your credit card until you
0:31:56want to pay and when that happens when you do want to pay here's what you do
0:32:00use the offer code bond bond and you'll get 10% off your purchase and they'll
0:32:09know you came from this show so my thanks to Squarespace go to
0:32:12squarespace.com and remember the offer code bond as in James Bond they pick
0:32:18they're doing like these cutesy codes where they pick things that are of
0:32:22interest to the hosts of the show. That's good, it's easy to remember. Yeah, so go there
0:32:28and my thanks to them. I think we're done with the Microsoft thing. Yeah, this, I
0:32:35mean this is gonna be a story for the next, God knows how many years. I do
0:32:38think, I guess the only other thing is the fact that that Nadella comes from
0:32:42the server side. Servers, yep. And my colleague at Qbranch, Brent Simmons, has
0:32:48written about it, that he's really happy about it because he's done a lot of
0:32:51coding on on Azure you know as a back end for an iOS developer and his point
0:32:58I thought was really really astute where the old Microsoft was always in their
0:33:03own universe technically and you know and it worked out for them but you know
0:33:07they wrote everything was theirs there was their own OS their own kernel you
0:33:12know they're the only ones in in the world who've you know the whole world's
0:33:17effectively gone Unix you know Mac OS X is Unix Linux is a clone of Unix
0:33:23Android runs on as a Linux kernel and at the kernel level you know every the
0:33:28whole world went Unix except you know even your TiVo runs a version of Linux
0:33:33except Windows Windows is like the this alternate universe it's this you know
0:33:38everything was their own their own programming languages their own API's
0:33:44everything at a technical their own networking their own mail server you
0:33:47know everybody else is using I map they have outlook you know it's all
0:33:51proprietary that was the Microsoft way and it you know a little bit of
0:33:56stubbornness strategically it was often about lock-in the Windows Server
0:34:01division that Nadella Rand is very different you know they support you know
0:34:06you can do things like you know really hip modern stuff like node JS I don't
0:34:12How do people say that do they say the dot no dot JS?
0:34:14either you know, yeah, it's
0:34:17Yeah, and I wonder
0:34:21So, you know you'd hope that that mentality sort of spreads to the other divisions now and they sort of Microsoft sort of opens up
0:34:28I think you know and if they are going to do that Nadella is obviously the right person to make that happen
0:34:33I think that he
0:34:34Recognizes and is realistic about the world that that we live in in the world Microsoft exists in now and it can't be the siloed
0:34:41behemoth anymore because that is the way forward of the company eventually finding hard times,
0:34:51very hard times potentially.
0:34:54We talked about the numbers are great now.
0:34:57The numbers can be deceiving a lot of times.
0:35:00The numbers were great for Nokia.
0:35:01The numbers were great for RIM leading up to when all of a sudden they're not great.
0:35:07You could argue that Microsoft certainly has a lot of the characteristics of those same
0:35:11companies even win post in great numbers because there's a few things that can happen that
0:35:17can make the this ship sort of start to sink really quickly and Nadella is given sort of
0:35:24all the stuff that you're talking about and his willingness to realize the world that
0:35:30we live in now.
0:35:31I think that he is probably the best candidate to sort of try to wake Microsoft up.
0:35:36Yeah, I think financial numbers are, and I don't think this is any kind of deep insight,
0:35:42I think this is common sense, but it seems like an awful lot of people can be fooled by it. They're
0:35:46a lagging indicator, not a leading indicator. So the iPhone didn't make a huge dent financially
0:35:55for Apple for a couple of years. It happened pretty quickly, but certainly 2007, it was not
0:36:03a significant financial thing. I mean the whole thing was they I think their goal for the first
0:36:07year was to sell them 1 million phones. Yep. And you know a lot of people thought that was
0:36:12a lot of people thought they weren't gonna do it or was it 10 million in the first year?
0:36:18Maybe it was 10 million for the year. Maybe it was for the year but yeah he did state the
0:36:22million thing he wanted to make sure to get that but then there was the the certain percentage
0:36:26that they were trying to hit. One percent of the phone market they wanted. Right that's right.
0:36:32it took a little bit.
0:36:33And if you just looked at how many phones they were selling
0:36:36when the first iPhone came out, it was not that huge.
0:36:40And conversely, RIM had a great year in 2007 and 2008.
0:36:47Nokia was still good.
0:36:48I was, in the research on an article I'm writing,
0:36:52maybe we'll talk about it later in the show,
0:36:53the same subject, but just about that same subject,
0:36:57leading numbers as a leading lagging indicator.
0:37:00In October of 2007, here is a headline in the New York Times.
0:37:05This is five or six months after the iPhone shipped.
0:37:09Nokia profit soars as market share nears 40%.
0:37:14(laughing)
0:37:16Right?
0:37:16You know, like numbers are not, I don't know.
0:37:21I think that that's,
0:37:22well it was you, right?
0:37:26Who, when the Microsoft CFO stepped down
0:37:29earlier this year, right?
0:37:31And what did you write about that?
0:37:32I thought that was, I just remember,
0:37:34that really stuck out in my mind.
0:37:36- I think I said, using the Game of Thrones analogy,
0:37:39like who is best poised to know when winter is coming?
0:37:44- Right. - The CFO.
0:37:46- Right. - Who's second best to know?
0:37:47The CEO.
0:37:48And so both of those guys are gone within Microsoft.
0:37:52- Right, that this, you know,
0:37:53if there's anybody at Microsoft who maybe had a,
0:37:56could smell something in the air that, you know,
0:37:59not this quarter, not next quarter, but...
0:38:02- Down the road.
0:38:03- Yeah, let's start looking at,
0:38:04talking about years rather than quarters,
0:38:07and maybe look one or two years ahead
0:38:10that trouble is brewing.
0:38:11It very likely would have been the CFO,
0:38:15and he got out of Dodge.
0:38:16- He did, and by the way,
0:38:19I think he said at the time,
0:38:21in Microsoft's statement at the time,
0:38:22was that he was taking some,
0:38:25He has been in the ranks for 30, 40 years or whatever it was.
0:38:30And he's finally ready to just take time
0:38:34and be with his family indefinitely.
0:38:36And I think four months later, he was in a new CFO job.
0:38:39(laughing)
0:38:41- Right, and that just gets back down
0:38:42to those very simple PR optics
0:38:47of executive shakeups at big companies.
0:38:50You always say that.
0:38:51You never wanna make it look like
0:38:54there's any kind, you know, no matter how ugly it is,
0:38:57you wanna downplay the ugliness.
0:38:59- Yep.
0:39:00- And it's true for all companies.
0:39:01We're not just laughing at Microsoft.
0:39:02I mean, it's the same way when
0:39:04Forstall got pushed out at Apple.
0:39:08- Yeah.
0:39:09- I mean, and they were a little bit,
0:39:10a little bit honest about it
0:39:12with the whole increased collaboration, you know,
0:39:15which is exactly what you hear.
0:39:17- They were indirectly honest.
0:39:19They didn't say that Forstall was the problem,
0:39:22but they indicated there was a problem
0:39:24with everyone sort of being on the same page.
0:39:27- Right.
0:39:28You could read between the lines and it came out
0:39:30that those of us who are left
0:39:33are gonna get along a lot better now.
0:39:35- Have you heard of anything about him recently, by the way?
0:39:39- No, I have not.
0:39:40Have you?
0:39:41- I haven't either, no.
0:39:42I would assume, the way that these deals
0:39:45usually are structured is that someone
0:39:48is being shown the door, but at the same time,
0:39:52they have so much proprietary information
0:39:54and knowledge about, especially with Apple,
0:39:56with top secret things sort of being worked on,
0:39:58that Apple certainly doesn't want
0:40:00them going to a competitor and really doesn't want them out
0:40:03on the marketplace at all.
0:40:05And so they usually give them some sort
0:40:08of exit package, which very well compensated for ensuring
0:40:12that they stay with the company for something like a year,
0:40:15sometimes more, sometimes less.
0:40:18I think Tony Fidell may have had the same type of thing.
0:40:20He's a special--
0:40:21Fidell's was not as contentious, though.
0:40:23No, definitely not. I think that that's 100% true. But he was, as Forstall I believe is
0:40:29now, a special advisor to the CEO or whatever.
0:40:31Yeah, I don't know if he still is or not though. They never named it what his period was. I
0:40:38have not heard what he's up to. I have heard from a pretty good little birdie that, yeah,
0:40:47exactly what you're saying. But that he was offered what, and I'll never forget the words,
0:40:52a truckload of money.
0:40:57And you drive off in this truck full of cash and for X – now, the one thing my birdie
0:41:03did not know is how long X is.
0:41:05His guess was a year, but maybe it's longer.
0:41:07And for the next –
0:41:08I would guess it's a year.
0:41:09For the next year, you do nothing.
0:41:11You cannot work for anybody and you cannot speak to anybody and you don't tweet, you
0:41:18don't have a Facebook.
0:41:19you know, anybody, reporters call you, you don't answer the phone.
0:41:24Not just talk about Apple, but anything, right?
0:41:27So –
0:41:28And I do think that that's what has happened, and the interesting thing now, of course,
0:41:31is that it has been a year.
0:41:33It's just over a year, right?
0:41:35Right.
0:41:36So it was last December.
0:41:37Yeah, it was like December.
0:41:38So it's, you know, I remember looking it up for the date, and I knew that it was after
0:41:43all of the product announcements, you know.
0:41:46Right.
0:41:47It was the slow period.
0:41:48Yeah, I forget if it was November or December, but it was somewhere around there and I've ever since then I've sort of like
0:41:55Just you know double-check to make sure that he hasn't started, you know, maybe showing up at
0:42:03Events and stuff like that, but so far I've heard nothing I heard from one reader who saw him somewhere
0:42:08It wasn't you know, it was just like a yet. Yeah, right citing it's like he's not you know housebound. He's not under house arrest
0:42:18But yeah, so I do think that we will see him surface at some point in the next few months
0:42:22I do wonder you know, he's a relatively young guy
0:42:25I think that he could definitely do a startup if he wanted to he would certainly have no problem getting any funding that he wanted
0:42:31Yeah, he's like 40 41 something. I mean, he's right around my age very very
0:42:35One of the weird what if one of the weird wildcards is to sort of tie this debate together
0:42:39What if Microsoft tries to hire him, you know a lot of people that's like
0:42:44Like a frequently asked question in my reader email is you know, well not now
0:42:48But during the whole run-up was would that be possible?
0:42:52I know I guess it's not impossible, but I always thought that it wasn't a good match for either company just because
0:42:58They're so different right and in pretty much every way
0:43:02Right, and I don't think that he would want to I would imagine that he would do something more a lot more like Tony
0:43:10Fidel. Go get some funding and start something new that would be obviously
0:43:16you know Nest became you know relatively big relatively quickly I mean it sold
0:43:21for over three billion dollars I mean which is you know you're talking
0:43:26billions not millions it's a pretty good deal but compared to Apple where Fidel
0:43:31was before very very small right but you can't start something that big right you
0:43:35can either start something new that's relatively small even if it has a lot of
0:43:39investment and very big goals or you can step into an existing giant and I just don't see
0:43:45Forstall stepping into an existing giant. I guess maybe the only one I could see and again I have
0:43:54no idea of what he'll do or any insight into any real knowledge of what's going on but I wouldn't
0:44:00be shocked if somehow Facebook convinced him to come there and to do some sort of skunkworks
0:44:06project that he would be best suited for.
0:44:10It's just like you feel,
0:44:11when I see Facebook do sort of these deals a lot
0:44:15where they hire sort of above what you think
0:44:17their weight should be, right?
0:44:18Where they convince these people to get in there
0:44:21and sort of work on these projects
0:44:23and just give them whatever resources they need.
0:44:26And so that wouldn't actually shock me,
0:44:28even though that would be sort of a shocking headline.
0:44:30I wouldn't be so surprised by that.
0:44:33- Yeah, I would see it more--
0:44:34- It's a really only one.
0:44:36- More as Facebook incubating an ambitious new division.
0:44:41Not that he would step in and run anything
0:44:45that Facebook already has.
0:44:48Yeah, I could see that though.
0:44:49I would see that as one existing company
0:44:51that I could see him going to.
0:44:52Couldn't see him going to Google.
0:44:54Couldn't, Microsoft, I just don't see it.
0:44:56I really don't.
0:44:57It just seems like it's intriguing to think about it,
0:45:00but I just don't see how it really matched,
0:45:01would have matched up for either of them.
0:45:04- Yeah, and I agree, I largely agree with that.
0:45:06I think the only reason I bring it up now
0:45:08is just because of the new leadership thing.
0:45:10Like maybe he's able to be convinced
0:45:13that things are really going to,
0:45:14they really wanna change things.
0:45:16And so this is how much we wanna change things.
0:45:19We're bringing in a guy synonymous with sort of Apple
0:45:22and one of Steve Jobs' lieutenant from the next days
0:45:25to really show you how different we're thinking.
0:45:29- Here's a question I've thought about.
0:45:31And to me, I don't really mean it as a joke.
0:45:35It actually makes me a little sad.
0:45:38Do you think Scott Forstall upgraded his phone to iOS 7?
0:45:41[LAUGHTER]
0:45:44That's a very good question.
0:45:45It is funny.
0:45:46He still wouldn't have to yet, right?
0:45:50You could still get away with running--
0:45:52what was the last version of 6?
0:45:54But he'd have to also be running an old iPhone 5.
0:45:58You can't use an iPhone 5S.
0:46:00And did he get a 5S?
0:46:02And did he have to like buy it online?
0:46:04- He seems like a green 5C guy, I don't know.
0:46:08- But I know it is funny, it's funny, but it's not,
0:46:14I've met Forrestal a few times, can't say I'm close to him,
0:46:17but I've met him, he was always very nice to me.
0:46:21And you know, I liked him, right?
0:46:26- I would--
0:46:27I would also say that clearly I'm a big fan of his work.
0:46:30And whether it was the right move or not to squeeze him out
0:46:34is almost beside the point.
0:46:36I just feel bad that it didn't work out.
0:46:38I do in a certain way.
0:46:39And I can imagine it was his life's work.
0:46:42I mean, the only thing he ever did was work at Next.
0:46:44He went right from college to Next and worked his way up.
0:46:48And it was a continuous thing for his entire adult life,
0:46:52working from Next to Apple and the Mac OS X transition
0:46:57to Mac OS X to the entire creation of iOS.
0:47:03And I think very clearly they took iOS
0:47:07in a different direction.
0:47:08- And so yeah, he'd be using it every day
0:47:11and staring at the cause of his sort of future.
0:47:14- What else is he going to do?
0:47:15He's not gonna switch to Android.
0:47:17Surely he still is using an iPhone.
0:47:19I think the only thing I can imagine.
0:47:22My only real, like I don't think I've ever interacted
0:47:25with Forsall, I don't think in all the time,
0:47:26like in all the different Apple events,
0:47:27I don't think I ever actually spoke with him,
0:47:29but I have seen him of course a number of times,
0:47:31and I actually saw him out and about once
0:47:33at a concert of all places.
0:47:34And I just remember my lasting sort of memory of that
0:47:39is him just like being very adamant
0:47:43about taking so many pictures using his iPhone.
0:47:46And so that leads me to believe that even if he hates
0:47:49He has to like the iPhone 5s just for the better camera
0:47:53Yeah
0:47:53And so he might be just using it solely for the camera and willing to forgo his sort of
0:47:59Hatred if he has hatred of iOS 7 right and surely up until when the iPhone 5s came out
0:48:06He'd never bought an iPhone in his life
0:48:08I mean he'd been using the new ones, you know, as soon as they were, you know prototypes were in from the factory
0:48:19You know and and presumably every single detail and pixel of the OS met with his approval or at least you know
0:48:25He'd gotten his input into
0:48:27and now you know
0:48:29You know to me. It's like it's like a weird. It's just to imagine the scenario
0:48:34What does he do go online and do it? I mean he's not a can't go to an Apple store
0:48:37Right
0:48:40So he's got to like I go online or maybe you know maybe as a an assistant or something
0:48:46you know, as an assistant, and go buy it for him.
0:48:49- This is like the end of Shawshanker's redemption,
0:48:51or whatever, like this is, but it's more like,
0:48:54what's the character, the old man who sort of
0:48:57gets reintroduced into the world after all the years
0:48:59in prison. - Right.
0:49:02Right, and it's like-- - He doesn't know
0:49:03how to do anything. - Right, and it's like,
0:49:05yeah, you haven't seen a supermarket with OCR scanners,
0:49:09right? (laughing)
0:49:10Wasn't that the thing with George Bush,
0:49:12the first George Bush president,
0:49:14'cause he'd been a vice president from like 1980
0:49:17and then he was the president.
0:49:19And then it came out when he was running
0:49:21against Clinton in '93.
0:49:22He'd never seen an OCR scanner in a supermarket.
0:49:25Why make fun of him for that?
0:49:27The guy hadn't done grocery shopping.
0:49:29What, do you think that the vice president
0:49:32does his own grocery shopping?
0:49:34No.
0:49:34So, but the last time he'd been in a supermarket
0:49:37was like 1979.
0:49:38I don't know, it just to me is something to imagine.
0:49:43I don't know. I'm betting he does. I'm betting he's...
0:49:46I would bet he does too. I think it would be hard. I think it also would be very hard
0:49:53for someone like him to use old technology when he's been so bleeding edge the entire
0:49:57time. It would be frustrating.
0:50:00But he's in a unique situation where the what-ifs will never stop in terms of what he's got
0:50:08his hand. But that's my guess. My guess is he has a 5s and runs iOS 7 and just seethes.
0:50:13He might even run iOS 7.1 because it finally doesn't crash every five seconds.
0:50:20Yeah, but that raises another question. Did he sign up for a developer account?
0:50:25A developer account, yeah.
0:50:26Because surely his old one doesn't work. He can't, you know, I'm pretty sure that,
0:50:31you know, that his cut off from the Apple VPN, he can't just do that.
0:50:37Yeah, do you think like he's been tinkering around with making some apps?
0:50:40I wonder I don't know. I mean Annette it's absolutely the case
0:50:44I don't think that he was spent his days as you know, a senior VP writing code
0:50:49But I mean he you know, that's he worked his way up from that right? Yeah, right. I remember there was a
0:50:55it was a
0:50:58WWDC session a couple years ago and it's sort of an obscure one and I forget who was leading it
0:51:04but I was sitting in the audience and it was
0:51:06But, you know, the guy on stage was an old next hand, but he's, you know, still just
0:51:12an engineer, like a senior engineer at Apple, and he's given a WWDC presentation.
0:51:16He was talking about something in iOS that was, or maybe it was Mac OS X, but either
0:51:20way, that had roots back to an old thing that he had done at Next in 1989.
0:51:27And he said, "Here, let me show you what I did.
0:51:29And, you know, here was the thing I wrote in 1989 while I was at Next.
0:51:33And, you know, you could see the roots are here to today."
0:51:35And he was like, "Here's the about box from the thing I wrote then."
0:51:39And the credits were him and Scott Forstall.
0:51:41And he was like, "I don't know what happened to the other guy."
0:51:45And this was when Forstall was still the senior VP.
0:51:46He wasn't making a joke at Forstall's expense last year, but it was a big belly laugh at
0:51:51the audience.
0:51:55He was listed second because he was an intern or something at the time.
0:51:59But he was writing code.
0:52:01I don't know.
0:52:02Could be.
0:52:03Yeah.
0:52:04Yeah.
0:52:05It would be interesting if he came out with something, if he came out, you know, de-cloaked
0:52:10with some kind of startup that was iOS related.
0:52:14Yeah, and so he's always been a software guy, so you'd assume he's not going to do sort
0:52:21of the Tony Fidell type, you know, startup, so he would do more of a software type startup,
0:52:26you would assume.
0:52:28Maybe he would pair up with someone who has sort of hardware experience.
0:52:32And certainly there are plenty of ex-Apple people now with the hardware experience that
0:52:36he would know.
0:52:37But if he were to do something by himself, it would presumably be something in software.
0:52:41Right.
0:52:42Yeah, I don't know.
0:52:44That's a good question.
0:52:48I'll take a break and thank my second sponsor.
0:52:54And it is our good friends at Backblaze.
0:53:00Blaze is unlimited, un-throttled backup for five dollars a month. They have an
0:53:06iOS app. This is for your Mac. You install Backblaze on your Mac. It's a
0:53:10little, it's just a simple little thing that goes in System Preferences, runs in
0:53:15the background, uploads everything on your Mac that you want. If you have
0:53:19something you don't want backed up, it's easy to make exclusion folders.
0:53:23Everything you want backed up though goes to their thing in the cloud. Five
0:53:27dollars a month as much space as you have in your Mac you could back it all
0:53:31up just takes longer for the first backup that's the only there is no
0:53:34catch they have an iOS app that you can use to access and share any of your
0:53:39files so when you're out and about you can fire it up the app on your iPhone
0:53:42get anything that's on your Mac because it's mirrored in the cloud there get a
0:53:46file look something up it's founded by ex Apple engineers I always emphasize
0:53:52this because it is written by people who you know know and get the Mac it doesn't
0:53:58feel like some kind of foreign thing that was ported to the Mac runs great on
0:54:03Mavericks it's up to date there's no add-ons no gimmicks no additional
0:54:07charges you just sign up you can start for free give it a try see that it works
0:54:12if I got two week trial period and then when you're ready to go when you see it
0:54:18works $5 a month per computer and that's it. It's the simplest online backup program to
0:54:24use. Just install it and it does the rest. And I always emphasize this, it's such peace
0:54:31of mind. I'm a happy Backblaze user and it's such a peace of mind to have a backup that's
0:54:37off site because you just never know. Fire, theft, like I said. I pointed out when Marco
0:54:45was on the show the other week, you know, the, you know, things you don't even think
0:54:48of like water damage, like a pipe on the ceiling above where your computer is. And then, and
0:54:53somebody, some reader wrote in and said that exact scenario happened to them where their
0:54:57upstairs neighbor left the their tub running and he came in and his MacBook was just completely
0:55:04drenched, you know, by like gallons of water, just completely fried everything on his desk
0:55:09is hard drive. So if you have like a time machine hard drive next to your thing, that's
0:55:14It's good, but it's not offsite.
0:55:16Backblaze gives you peace of mind.
0:55:19Really great service.
0:55:20Where do you go to find out more?
0:55:22Go to www.backblaze.com/daringfireball.
0:55:33They'll know you came from here.
0:55:34They'll know you came from the show and can't recommend them enough.
0:55:38Really, really good stuff.
0:55:39My thanks to Backblaze.
0:55:40How about Facebook paper?
0:55:49Yes.
0:55:52I have not…
0:55:53So you don't have Facebook.
0:55:54Yes.
0:55:55This is the dilemma.
0:55:56Let me explain.
0:55:57I've not written about this much on Daring Fireball.
0:55:59I have never signed up for Facebook.
0:56:02Still haven't.
0:56:04Have never been tempted to until now because I'm tempted to sign up for Facebook.
0:56:10just to use paper. And in fact, I've been thinking about this for longer than just
0:56:15the last week because I actually got a briefing from Facebook in New York a
0:56:22week or two before paper came out. Mike Mattis emailed me and
0:56:26said, "Hey, I've finally got something to show. You wouldn't
0:56:30want to come up and see I'm gonna be in New York." I was like, "Sure." And I was just
0:56:35blown away. Absolutely positive. I haven't written about it because I don't know
0:56:38how to contextualize it yet because I am so it why don't you just make it can
0:56:43you make like just a dummy account not friend anyone just I don't know you know
0:56:47and it's weird I guess that's what I should do I don't know I mean I've seen
0:56:50it I most of my experience with the app is with Mike's account I just used Mike's
0:56:54phone maybe he just has a beautiful family and that's why you like well you
0:56:59know that's the pushback against it the pushback against paper that I've seen is
0:57:04is that it's great if your friends are all
0:57:09UI design artists who take really great photos.
0:57:14And it isn't great if you're,
0:57:17you'd like most people on Facebook
0:57:19and your family takes really shitty photos
0:57:22and posts the cat gifs and stuff like that.
0:57:27- So, but your predicament raises an interesting question
0:57:32which is that I wonder if Facebook is able to,
0:57:37either for the first time,
0:57:38obviously you know that you're certainly an oddity
0:57:41in being in a developed country
0:57:44and not having Facebook at this point,
0:57:46but I wonder if they feel like it's also an opportunity
0:57:51to not only bring in new, but reengage people
0:57:54who are burnt out by Facebook,
0:57:56which is many, many people.
0:57:57Basically, you talk to anyone
0:58:00within your own personal circles,
0:58:03you'll have several people who say like,
0:58:05yeah, Facebook is so lame now,
0:58:07or Facebook is sort of, it's all just,
0:58:10it's all for my parents,
0:58:11or it's just sort of like old high school friends
0:58:16that I never talk to anymore using it,
0:58:17so it's really not that interesting to me anymore.
0:58:19But paper is a complete reimagining
0:58:22of what the experience should be like.
0:58:24And there are definitely things that I like
0:58:27and don't like about it.
0:58:28Certainly it's beautifully designed,
0:58:31and I think there's some great functionality in there.
0:58:33But I don't really, I don't know.
0:58:35I mean, we could dive into all the little things about it.
0:58:39I'm a little concerned that a lot of what,
0:58:42and you will know this better
0:58:43having talked to Mike Mattis about it directly,
0:58:45but I'm a little bit concerned
0:58:46that it's a little bit too worried
0:58:49about sort of addressing the Twitter question head on,
0:58:53which is no one is using Facebook really
0:58:56to talk about current events,
0:58:58or at least the right people aren't using Facebook
0:59:01that they want to get the word out there.
0:59:03Like during the Super Bowl, you know,
0:59:04like tweets are going crazy, everyone's talking about it.
0:59:07Is anyone using Facebook?
0:59:08Facebook tried to get people using it this year.
0:59:10They reached out to a bunch of celebrities.
0:59:12- Yeah, I saw that.
0:59:13- That document leaked, you know,
0:59:14talking about like what you should be using Facebook for
0:59:18during the Super Bowl.
0:59:20And so when I look at paper,
0:59:21when I look beyond the obvious beauty on the surface,
0:59:25I see sort of a desire to get back into sort of the real-time news conversation, which
0:59:32I don't know.
0:59:33I don't know if that's coming from the right place or not.
0:59:35Yeah.
0:59:36I think you're off on that and having talked to Mike about it.
0:59:40I don't think that's what their goal is.
0:59:42I think their goal is a little bit – it's almost obvious, which is that – and in fact,
0:59:51It's a direct answer to the thing I just said a minute ago,
0:59:53that the complaint is that people aren't cultivating
0:59:57what they post to Facebook to make it beautiful.
1:00:00And the paper's theory is, the paper team's theory is,
1:00:04nobody's going to do that until we give them a beautiful way,
1:00:08a beautiful interface to do it.
1:00:10That it's the, if we build it, they will come theory.
1:00:13That they have to build a beautiful interface to paper first
1:00:19that encourages a sort of more,
1:00:23I know that a lot of people are gonna laugh and say,
1:00:26"Come on, Facebook and artistic expression."
1:00:28It's not what it was for.
1:00:30But that's a little bit highfaluting,
1:00:34but it's more or less what they're thinking,
1:00:36that if we give them this beautiful, serene interface,
1:00:39that that's when people will start posting things
1:00:42that actually fit better in paper
1:00:44and are a little bit more,
1:00:47not cultivated, but curated, I don't know
1:00:49what you wanna say, but that people will generate content
1:00:53that fits in paper and feels right in paper
1:00:57only after paper is out and actually exists.
1:01:00It has to be built first.
1:01:01But I don't think it's about real-time stuff.
1:01:05- Okay, that's interesting.
1:01:07So I can understand how,
1:01:10I can definitely understand that line of thinking.
1:01:12I will say one other thing that I did here,
1:01:14So this was being talked about when paper was released.
1:01:19And I think a bunch of people tweeted about it.
1:01:21I did, and others.
1:01:22But I have since heard from a pretty good source on this
1:01:25that it's also not out of left field
1:01:29to think that this is how Facebook is experimenting
1:01:34with new UI to see what would work for the actual product
1:01:38itself.
1:01:40I asked about that.
1:01:43much of this response did you get that not a direct response and I you know so
1:01:47I don't want to put words in the mics mouth or anybody so I didn't get but you
1:01:52know I think reading between the line and I think just looking at the app it
1:01:56is clear you know and it's exactly like what you wrote on Paris lemon that
1:02:01there is no way that they could drop you know put out a facebook dot app version
1:02:08that was this and just right right out of that no way they've got too many
1:02:12users, right? And it's way too different. And it doesn't have the complete Facebook
1:02:17experience. It doesn't have everything.
1:02:19Yeah. Though it does have a lot. It has way more than I thought it would.
1:02:23It is a very largely a... You know what it's a lot like? It's a lot like mobile email clients
1:02:31where maybe your mobile email client doesn't do everything that you can do with email,
1:02:36but it does most of it, right? That you can do most of what you do in email with the mail
1:02:41client you're using on your phone, even if it doesn't do everything.
1:02:44And you might have to use something at your desk to, I don't know, create, I don't think,
1:02:49can you create new folders in mail or most mail apps on iPhone?
1:02:53Maybe not, but you can certainly read all of your mail and reply to it and do a lot
1:02:57of other stuff, flag them and stuff.
1:02:59That Facebook Paper is largely an alternative to Facebook.app for your phone.
1:03:04Oh, and I replaced Facebook.app with paper pretty much on day one because it is so much
1:03:12better.
1:03:13It's just a number of things are better about it.
1:03:15I find the performance actually better, which is sort of surprising given how visual it
1:03:19is.
1:03:20But performance is better.
1:03:22It obviously looks a lot better.
1:03:24And it does, like you're saying, it performs the basic, sort of the high level functions
1:03:28that you need.
1:03:29The one thing it's missing, the one complaint that people do bring up who use Facebook is
1:03:34that it's missing events. And the rumor, of course, is that Facebook is working on a separate
1:03:38events app.
1:03:39Yeah, that's what I think. Well, and I think it all, it fits, and I think, you know, I
1:03:46certainly don't know Zuck. I don't know his mind. But the evidence that I've seen with
1:03:52the acquisitions they've made, including Mattis's Push Pop Press a little over two years ago,
1:04:00he bought Sofa. And also knowing, and you know this is something I can't name names,
1:04:06but it's in the iOS and Mac developer community, they pretty much went to anybody who's done
1:04:14like Apple design award level work and you know made AquaHire offers. There's an awful
1:04:22lot of people who you think I wonder if they went to them, the answer is probably yes.
1:04:27Yeah, which makes sense for them, obviously.
1:04:31Right.
1:04:32Like, what's the best talent in the world to do what they want to do?
1:04:34It's right in front of them.
1:04:35Right.
1:04:36And I think the explanation is that for a while, Zuck had it in mind that Facebook was
1:04:41a website and that the mobile version should be a mobile version of that website.
1:04:48And the early versions of the Facebook app for iPhone were...
1:04:53Who was the developer?
1:04:54Was it Joe Hewitt?
1:04:55It was Joe Hewitt.
1:04:56Joe Hewitt and he did great work and he you know yeah he was you know do you do
1:05:01you remember the HTML 5 version you know before there were native apps that was
1:05:06like the first really impressive application that I saw again not a
1:05:10native application right in the web browser built for the iPhone well so one
1:05:14thing you can definitely say for Zuck and Facebook is as soon as the iPhone
1:05:17came out they instantly saw we need to be on that and they did it you know
1:05:21before there were even apps and then when there were apps but they their
1:05:25Their initial app was a lot more like not native, you know, using web things, you know,
1:05:31web views and stuff like that.
1:05:32And I feel like a lot of, you know, as an indication that he is a very good CEO, I think
1:05:42Zuck had a complete 180 and realized, you know what, native apps matter for mobile,
1:05:48for performance, for latency, for just the way, you know, it just isn't going to work
1:05:53be one level behind in abstraction with all the the little nagging things that
1:06:01that that entails and it was like so what do we do let's hire some great
1:06:05native app developers and designers and I think also part of that is that you on
1:06:15on the phone on mobile in general it makes more sense to have
1:06:20Not a ton of apps but more separate apps than one app that does everything
1:06:27Especially for something the size of Facebook because Facebook can do so many things, you know, you do events you do chat you do
1:06:34Status updates you do pictures like all these things. It's like it was getting it was getting almost ridiculous. That's like the side menu
1:06:42That's in the previous one where it's like there's so there's so many different things that you can drill down into it's almost like
1:06:48Ridiculous to try to hit some of them with a with a fingertip, right?
1:06:51And you know take a look at Apple with iTunes right out on the Mac and Windows and there's you know
1:06:56I think a large part of that is because they have to maintain parity on Mac and Windows
1:07:00But it's a monolithic app and you know, it's almost at this point. It's almost infamous for being
1:07:06Overloaded with responsibilities and
1:07:12And iOS debuted and has sort of stayed with everything broken apart into separate apps.
1:07:18There's a music player app and there's a store app for buying music and a podcast app for
1:07:27podcasts.
1:07:28And you can see, you know, like, you know, and a lot of people aren't happy with the
1:07:31podcast app.
1:07:32But just the fact that the way Apple sees it, it should be a separate app says a lot.
1:07:37You know, that that's the way to develop for mobile.
1:07:40and I think Facebook has that in mind too.
1:07:42- And so did you talk to Madison at all about the fact
1:07:46that it's obviously iPhone first and iPhone only right now
1:07:49and it's not iPad.
1:07:50- Right, and I think it's the obvious
1:07:55that it took them this long to build the iPhone version
1:07:59and it's ready to ship and so they shipped it
1:08:01and they had no comment on whether there's going
1:08:05to be an iPad version or there's going
1:08:07to be an Android version.
1:08:08And although I got the feeling,
1:08:11I can't quote me on it, and it's not a quote,
1:08:15but I did get the feeling though that his team,
1:08:17at least at the moment, is an iOS team,
1:08:20that they, you know, and it's relatively small.
1:08:23- Right.
1:08:24- You know, that if and when there is going to be
1:08:26an Android version of paper, that it's, you know,
1:08:28they'll need to expand to do it.
1:08:31- Well, and I wonder if it would even be that team, right?
1:08:35Like if Zuck really is sort of thinking about this
1:08:39in the new way that you're suggesting,
1:08:42sort of moving away from the Facebook is a website
1:08:45and now it's whatever it needs to be
1:08:48on whatever device you're using.
1:08:49And so you could certainly make the argument
1:08:52that maybe it should be different for Android
1:08:55entirely than it is even right now for paper with iOS.
1:08:59- I think that's-- - They have different
1:09:02screen sizes.
1:09:03And different metaphors and different capabilities.
1:09:07iOS is much more--
1:09:10everybody's always said this.
1:09:12Things animate smoother.
1:09:15It has these transitions, and it has--
1:09:19when you want to do GPU-intensive things,
1:09:22you have this tremendous advantage
1:09:24of only having to target two or three GPUs.
1:09:31I don't know what--
1:09:32I don't know how far back Facebook paper works.
1:09:34I don't know if they support like the 4S
1:09:36or what the limit is.
1:09:37But even so, there's only three,
1:09:39even if they go back all the way to the 4S,
1:09:42it's only three generations that they have to support.
1:09:44And it's a very, very graphically intensive app.
1:09:48- So I wonder if Facebook will be sort of
1:09:50the first major service to go like total,
1:09:55in a totally different direction
1:09:56with their application for Android.
1:09:58Just because like of what you're talking about
1:10:00where Madison's team is, I would assume, all iOS right now.
1:10:04And they would either have to hire and sort of train people
1:10:09in terms of what they built for iOS.
1:10:12Even though it wouldn't technically be a quote unquote port,
1:10:15it would still sort of be a port, right?
1:10:17It would be like--
1:10:18- Right, if they were gonna call it paper.
1:10:20- Yeah, so--
1:10:21- And use the same interface and style.
1:10:24I don't think that they're gonna do it.
1:10:25I really wouldn't be surprised if there's never,
1:10:28I don't know the answer, I really don't.
1:10:29I mean, but my guess is I wouldn't be surprised
1:10:32if there's never paper for Android.
1:10:34But like you just said, if there's something else,
1:10:37Facebook, something else for Android
1:10:40that has a different interface
1:10:42and then never exists for iOS.
1:10:44- Which, by the way, they've done.
1:10:46That's what Facebook Home was, right?
1:10:47- Right.
1:10:48- It was Android only.
1:10:49- Right. - Yeah.
1:10:51- Yeah, and you know what?
1:10:52So maybe that's actually a good way of thinking
1:10:54that they've already done that.
1:10:55They've already done a thing for Android
1:10:57that doesn't exist on iOS,
1:10:58it's sort of embracing rather than trying to do this seeing them as two
1:11:05versions of the same idea treat them as different two different things which i
1:11:09think is actually closer to the truth you know yeah and don't do the way don't
1:11:15see this the way that Windows and Mac OS 10 evolved where a company like Adobe
1:11:20more or less had the exact same interface for you know Photoshop and
1:11:25and InDesign and Illustrator on Windows and Mac,
1:11:29where the only differences were the iOS,
1:11:32the OS specific things like that menu bar is at the top
1:11:35on the Mac and the menu is in the window on Windows.
1:11:39But otherwise, they shipped at the same time,
1:11:42they had the same features,
1:11:44they were built from the same code base.
1:11:46I don't think that's the way to do iOS
1:11:48and Android development, I really don't.
1:11:50- Yeah, I agree.
1:11:51I think that too often we see these companies go into it,
1:11:55well, we built the iOS version, it's doing great,
1:11:58now let's make the Android version,
1:12:00it's gonna be the same Instagram, it's the exact same.
1:12:02- Right.
1:12:03- Well, maybe Instagram's an example
1:12:04where that makes sense, because it's--
1:12:06- It does, yeah.
1:12:07- It's so simple. - You can argue that.
1:12:09But, when you, you should go into the mentality
1:12:13with we wanna create the best application
1:12:15for this specific device,
1:12:16for these specific set of devices, this OS,
1:12:19rather than the other way around.
1:12:20- Yeah, and I, you know, Twitter maybe is an example
1:12:23doing that wrong, where they're sort of developing
1:12:26this single-minded, single Twitter interface
1:12:30that's everywhere?
1:12:32- Right.
1:12:32- You know, I don't--
1:12:33- Though, we'll see if that continues.
1:12:35That was definitely the marching order for a long time,
1:12:40and I think that a lot of that was driven by the need
1:12:43for simplicity, cross-platform simplicity,
1:12:46to get users to understand what they're doing.
1:12:49When they look at one thing, you know, it's like,
1:12:51oh, here's where the tweet button is.
1:12:53so I know what to do.
1:12:54But I wouldn't be surprised if that's changing too,
1:12:56that mentality.
1:12:57- So things with paper, the thing that fascinates me,
1:13:00and there's two sides to it.
1:13:02There's one, is it a good client for Facebook?
1:13:05And that I don't know how to judge
1:13:07because I'm not a Facebook user.
1:13:08So I honestly don't know how to judge it.
1:13:10But two, from a design perspective,
1:13:14it is fascinating.
1:13:17'Cause it is almost like a reimagination
1:13:21of what iOS should be.
1:13:24It doesn't feel foreign, it doesn't feel like alien,
1:13:29but it's definitely not standard.
1:13:32And it is of a piece with Mike Mattes' previous works
1:13:37and very specifically with the work they did
1:13:43at Push Pop Press.
1:13:45The only example of which we saw publicly
1:13:48was the Al Gore book.
1:13:50choice right which is worth but if you're an interface designer it's worth
1:13:55buying that not to read even if you have no interest in the book itself it's
1:13:59worth buying as an example of an alternative way to think about
1:14:04touchscreen design is it still it's still available I think so I hope so I
1:14:08don't know yeah I don't know but this you know and I I don't know how much you
1:14:17know I do you never know I mean there is a team and it's madis is not the only
1:14:19designer but I think the whole team is on board with the philosophy and the
1:14:25philosophy is I think one way to put it is that it that Apple wasn't bold enough
1:14:34with iOS right and you go back all the way to Steve Jobs's 2007 unveiling of
1:14:40the original iPhone and and he spoke a you know at the highest level when he
1:14:47was introducing it and sort of framing how we should think about this. That it was when
1:14:52he snuck in the dig about a stylus, you know, that look, in 1984 we made this thing called
1:14:58the Mac and you, you know, did all this stuff visually using a mouse to guide a pointer
1:15:04on screen. What are we going to do for a pointer here? He goes, "Well, a stylus." And everybody
1:15:10goes, "No, of course not. It's terrible." And everybody laughed. He goes, "A stylus
1:15:14us a piece of junk, you're going to lose it. And nobody wants that. No, we're all born
1:15:19with a pointer right here. And he stuck up his index finger, right. And that's the, you
1:15:23know, the high level, that's the breakthrough of iOS that you just use your finger, and
1:15:28you do things. So instead of having a scroll bar that you move to scroll the content, you
1:15:33just touch the content and move it, and you scroll up, and there's not you don't have
1:15:37a button, you know, like, and you think back, and we, you know, it's easy to sort of forget.
1:15:41you see this evolution over the years of Mac and Windows
1:15:44where we have either the wheel or the trackpad or something.
1:15:49But think back to the original Mac and the original Windows
1:15:54before there were even scroll wheels on mice.
1:15:56And to scroll the content, you had to put the cursor
1:15:59on the arrow in the scroll bar to click
1:16:02or put it on the, what's it called, the thumb,
1:16:04the elevator, whatever you wanna call it, and drag it.
1:16:08And it was a complete level of abstraction
1:16:11that you had to click the button, the arrow buttons,
1:16:13to scroll it or click the actual--
1:16:15click and drag the actual wheel to do it.
1:16:20And iOS completely eliminated the entire thing,
1:16:22where it's all just direct.
1:16:24But in other areas, it's a lot of the standard iOS navigation.
1:16:30Just think about two apps that I think are very, very--
1:16:36almost canonical if you want to study
1:16:39what it is to be an iOS app.
1:16:40Mail and the Settings app.
1:16:44Settings app is maybe the best example.
1:16:46Settings is just pure iOS.
1:16:49It's a lot of buttons.
1:16:51And even like you go into a level,
1:16:52and then how do you go back?
1:16:54You go to the top left, and there's a button.
1:16:56And then back button.
1:16:57And it's a back button.
1:16:58And you tap the back button as though you use your finger
1:17:01to tap the button in the same way
1:17:03that you'd use a mouse pointer to click a button.
1:17:08And the maddest philosophy, and paper really exemplifies this,
1:17:12is that you get rid of those buttons, too.
1:17:16And you just open and close things.
1:17:19You can tap on a thing to open it, and then to close it,
1:17:21you just squeeze it.
1:17:22And it gets smaller and goes back to the smaller state.
1:17:26And it's not just the obvious sort of-- or what's
1:17:30been around for a while, like pinch to zoom
1:17:32and sort of pinch to close.
1:17:33It is like as simple as sort of drag up and drag down.
1:17:37Yeah.
1:17:37Yeah.
1:17:38So you don't even have to use two fingers.
1:17:41That's my favorite thing about it,
1:17:43where I'm looking at it right now.
1:17:44And it's just like the sort of bar
1:17:47along the bottom with the content
1:17:49that you scroll through, it almost is--
1:17:51in a way, it's like in the shape of your thumb.
1:17:53It's like drawing your thumb towards it to place it on there.
1:17:58And then once you do that, you just sort of move up,
1:18:01and then you're right into it.
1:18:02And you can read it the entire way when it's going up, right?
1:18:05Because it's just scaling it right up.
1:18:07then to get it away you just push it back down. It's very well done.
1:18:10And it's very natural and it is really unlike the standard system in a profound way even though it's
1:18:19so simple and part of it there's a humility towards it where it's not a lot of like whiz-bang
1:18:26stuff that you could... I mean I know for example I know that Matus worked on when he was at Apple
1:18:32years ago worked on Time Machine and Time Machine's interface is look at look
1:18:37at this this is supposed to be like whoa right with the whole windows going into
1:18:433d and they're an outer space and it's like it is a very ostentatious design
1:18:49and it doesn't matter what you know aside whether you think it's a good
1:18:52design for for a backup system or not it's ostentatious right the paper thing
1:18:57is is very humble in my opinion because I think normal people they might think
1:19:01hey this is nice but they're not going to be like wow it it's right you know
1:19:07and I mean that as a very high compliment that it's it's not trying to
1:19:11show off it's all and I think there's tons I know for a fact that there's tons
1:19:16and tons of work to get these things because they're not built into the
1:19:20system you don't get them for free from Coco Touch this these you know opening
1:19:27and closing and smooth everything is super smooth it's all custom and it's
1:19:31all super smooth. And the big problem with any kind of high level, like how are you going
1:19:39to navigate this design, is that there's a very few number of gestures available and
1:19:45you have to allocate them. You have to decide, you have to be very careful about it. So just
1:19:50think back to the original Mac. And I think in hindsight, we can probably agree that a
1:19:55a mistake that they made was that single click in the finder selects an item and double click
1:20:06opens because double click is cognitively difficult for normal people.
1:20:14And it's led to, the best example is people whose parents double click on links in web
1:20:22browsers.
1:20:23Right?
1:20:24They somehow, they don't understand that some things you click on to open and some things
1:20:29you double click to open.
1:20:30And you kind of have to have a deeper understanding of how the computer is working as opposed
1:20:36to how the interface is working to know that difference.
1:20:39Which is why, you know, it makes way more sense the way that iOS and almost every modern
1:20:46system works where you tap to open and you do like a long tap to select or something
1:20:52else.
1:20:53tap-dope and so you do you have so few things to do and and you don't want to
1:21:01get into a thing where anything primary involves things like well you could put
1:21:07two fingers on screen and drag up and down well normal people are never gonna
1:21:10get that right pinching with two fingers they'll get because it's it is it feels
1:21:17is real. But things like the iOS four finger swipe to switch apps, that's a power user
1:21:24feature. That and it's absolutely fine that Apple made that. I think it's fine feature.
1:21:30I use it especially on the iPad. I don't think I have it turned on on the phone, but on the
1:21:33iPad I use it all the time. But I, you know, it's, I guarantee you 99.5% of all iPad users
1:21:41have no idea that it exists and if you told them it exists they would forget it
1:21:45by tomorrow so what Facebook had to solve with paper is what can you how
1:21:52much can you do with one finger just dragging you've got left right and
1:21:57you've got up down and that's it and so you go left right to navigate between
1:22:04items in the stream and up to open down to close and it's even it's a little bit
1:22:14more sort of interesting how they're doing it because there's also down like
1:22:20it seems like one of the issues that they're having which I understand is
1:22:24that people don't know at first how to create a post right because that's
1:22:28another swipe down from the top and there's no real indication that that's
1:22:31There is through in the walkthrough of course
1:22:33But there's no indication when you're just looking at it that that's what you would do right and that they're trying to like create a new
1:22:39Norm I guess for that yeah, and where it's instead of being the side sort of the hamburger bun to the side
1:22:45It's now swiping down to get to it
1:22:47Yeah
1:22:47And maybe that's a spot where it's not quite fair of me to say that it doesn't feel foreign because it is
1:22:54Because it's non-standard
1:22:58But I guess what I see is that I when I look at paper
1:23:02I see a way that the whole system could work that way right that in some alternate universe
1:23:08Mike Mattes is that still at Apple and is in charge of iOS or
1:23:13Is a lead developer and that iOS 7 works like this across the board and that there's you know, for example
1:23:20There's no status bar all the time in Facebook paper
1:23:27But it's there you just pull down at the top a little bit and then you can see it. Yep, and I
1:23:32Know for a fact there's an eye that is you know, it's a stupid little thing, but I know from talking to other
1:23:38Designers and people who think about things like this
1:23:41There's an awful lot of people who think that that's the way iOS should work that the status bar is
1:23:45Clutter and that you know, why not just give the whole screen and you know
1:23:49Show the status when you need it and how do you do it? Just pull it down
1:23:54Do you know what else I just realized like just playing around with it right now
1:23:57I think they're one of the first ones that I can remember actually doing this
1:24:02In a way, I think is correct
1:24:04Which is that?
1:24:05When you do so when you do you're on the main screen and you swipe down to get to sort of where you can post
1:24:10Where your profile is that that back, you know the back of the sort of cards metaphor. Yeah
1:24:15When that puts the main
1:24:18Sort of card at the bottom so you can still get back there by tapping on it and then it just pops back up
1:24:24right? So that's how you navigate back? Yes. But it is impossible to actually pull up the up menu
1:24:31from there. You know how in so many apps now with iOS 7 they have the pull up menu where you know
1:24:37where they have the flashlight and all those other things. Yeah. It is actually impossible to do that
1:24:42at least as far as I can see right now to pull up that menu which is great because so many of
1:24:47of these apps that are trying to be clever with sort of using
1:24:51new UI forget that there is already a system-wide UI
1:24:57to pull up that menu, right?
1:25:00And somehow, I assume you can do this in--
1:25:04you can make this a setting.
1:25:06Paper has figured out, like, if we put this card at the bottom
1:25:12and ask people to go back to it, a lot of times
1:25:14they're going to end up pulling up the Settings menu,
1:25:17and we don't want them to do that, so let's just disable that.
1:25:20And so there's no way to do that, which is great.
1:25:22Because I'm always afraid now whenever I'm touching something at the bottom of the screen
1:25:25that I'm going to pull up that menu.
1:25:27Yeah, I know exactly what you mean.
1:25:31I think, and it's tricky too when the keyboard is visible, and it feels, I could be wrong,
1:25:38it could just be that I've gotten better at it, but I'm running the iOS 7.1 betas on my
1:25:42phone.
1:25:43Yeah, me too.
1:25:45And it feels as though they've, in the last beta or two,
1:25:48they've gotten better at system-wide.
1:25:51When you want to bring up the, what's it called,
1:25:54the control center is the thing you're talking about.
1:25:57You swipe from the bottom.
1:25:59Previously, when the keyboard was up,
1:26:01every time I tried it, I'd get a space.
1:26:04It would just hit the key.
1:26:05And they've gotten something.
1:26:07They figured out some way of doing it now,
1:26:08wherein the keyboard's visible.
1:26:10You can bring that up.
1:26:11It's a tricky thing.
1:26:12And I agree that-- yeah, I know exactly what
1:26:13you're talking about in paper.
1:26:14You more or less push the whole regular interface down.
1:26:18Regular interface meaning you're browsing through
1:26:22the content in your feed.
1:26:23You push that down to get a sort of meta interface
1:26:30and it's like a transparent thing with your Facebook,
1:26:34not your profile. - It is search.
1:26:35It has your profile, it has create a post,
1:26:37it has edit sections and settings.
1:26:39- Right.
1:26:40So another thing that they did that I think,
1:26:43and it speaks to the thought that went into it.
1:26:45It's like the Einstein quote,
1:26:48everything should be as simple as possible,
1:26:50but not more so.
1:26:52And I've looked it up over the years
1:26:55and maybe there's a lot of,
1:26:56it could be one of those things
1:26:57where he didn't even say it,
1:26:58but that's the way I know the adage.
1:27:02What does it mean as simple as possible, but not more so?
1:27:07Well, it's a little cute,
1:27:09but it more or less means don't take an idea too far.
1:27:12And as an example, it's--
1:27:13OK, so they've gotten rid of a lot of buttons
1:27:16in the navigation.
1:27:17That you don't go back, you just push it down and it closes.
1:27:21But they don't have any kind of--
1:27:23we're not going to have any buttons at all.
1:27:25And we're going to figure out a way to do this with no buttons.
1:27:27Where it makes sense to just have a button,
1:27:29they have a button.
1:27:31Like when you write a post, you just start typing.
1:27:33And then there's a button that says post.
1:27:35And it's super obvious.
1:27:37There's no cutesy way of somehow posting
1:27:41without actually having a post button.
1:27:44Yeah, yeah, I think that that's right.
1:27:48They have the minimal amount of buttons
1:27:50you would need to do what you want to do.
1:27:53Yeah.
1:27:54They have a super cool thing when you go into the settings.
1:27:58And it uses-- once you're in the settings for Facebook Paper,
1:28:04it is a very standard iOS metaphor,
1:28:07where there's a list, and you tap an item,
1:28:09and it goes left to right and navigation stack
1:28:14goes the same way that you're familiar with.
1:28:16And I think it's exactly right.
1:28:19Instead of trying to get real clever
1:28:20and do something original there, they do it.
1:28:22But they do a really cool thing with the animation
1:28:25at the top of the screen,
1:28:27where there is actually a back button
1:28:29when you're in the settings.
1:28:31But if you swipe it, it's like the back button thing,
1:28:33unlike iOS 7 standard navigation,
1:28:36it doesn't just fade from one to another,
1:28:38it like shoots as though a rubber band pushed it.
1:28:41- Yeah.
1:28:42- Really, really, really.
1:28:44And honestly, it's better than the iOS.
1:28:47I wish that that was iOS 7 standard.
1:28:49- Yeah, and everything sort of cascades in.
1:28:51- Yeah.
1:28:52- As they're coming, yeah.
1:28:53- Yeah, exactly.
1:28:54It's like a cascade animation, like almost like a wave.
1:28:58I don't know how you would call it, but it's,
1:29:01(laughs)
1:29:02I'm making up a word here, but it's very physicky.
1:29:06- Physics-y, physical, physical.
1:29:08I guess it's just physical, but it's like physics.
1:29:11And again, that's a little thing,
1:29:16and that is not a standard animation from iOS.
1:29:20That is something that they worked on themselves.
1:29:23There's an awful lot of--
1:29:23- So did you get a sense from him?
1:29:26Did he talk at all?
1:29:27Are they going to open source any of this stuff
1:29:29for other sort of iOS developers to use, do you know?
1:29:33- I didn't ask, I don't know.
1:29:35I don't think so.
1:29:36That'd be great, but yeah.
1:29:38Yeah, I don't think so.
1:29:39Although they did, you know, they have the tool, the meta layer on top of Quartz compositor
1:29:44that they're using.
1:29:46Quartz Composer?
1:29:47That's right.
1:29:48Or origami?
1:29:49Is that what they're called?
1:29:50Yeah, origami.
1:29:51I forget if it's Quartz Compositor or Composer.
1:29:52Whichever one it is, I always guess wrong.
1:29:53So it's whatever.
1:29:54Composer.
1:29:55Quartz Composer.
1:29:56Yeah.
1:29:57I think the telling thing about that that's interesting as someone who works and tries
1:30:03to think about design and stuff is that... and Matus has been using Quartz Composer for a long
1:30:11time for his mock-ups and stuff. And I had spoken about this before, but like he showed me like with
1:30:17PushPop Press before it came out and he was showing me the development version of it where
1:30:24they had like in the beta versions or the in-house versions there was an extra layer of settings where
1:30:31there were sliders for all the variables in the physics engine. And so instead of like a programmer
1:30:44typing into Xcode that gravity for flinging down a picture to close it is at 0.78 and then you
1:30:55compile and build and install a beta on your phone and you play around with it and then Mike would
1:31:00say, "You know what? Try like 0.85 and then compile it and build it and give it to him."
1:31:06He had sliders for all of those things and he could sit there and drag these little sliders
1:31:12and adjust things and make pictures more or less really. And I got to play with it with
1:31:18those settings enabled, make things like photos feel heavier or lighter. And it was very,
1:31:24very, you know, it was very tactile where it really did feel like, "Whoa, that's heavier.
1:31:28whoa, that's lighter.
1:31:30And I think the idea is that you can't really design
1:31:35with this modern sense of a physics-driven interaction
1:31:40without actually having design tools
1:31:44that are not just animated,
1:31:46but that you can tweak all sorts of variables.
1:31:50And I think that's where they're going with origami,
1:31:52where you're not, you cannot,
1:31:53you can't create things like this in Photoshop
1:31:56and just have, here's the start frame, here's the end frame,
1:32:00and in between it animates.
1:32:04- Yeah, and it's 'cause you're forcing your brain
1:32:07to shift between two different processes, right?
1:32:12You're going from a very numbers-driven analytical process
1:32:17by typing in .87.
1:32:20It's like you're doing math versus designing.
1:32:24I think it's the equivalent of like in sculpture
1:32:26where you're working, you know,
1:32:28it's like having clay in your hands
1:32:30and being able to mold it with your hands
1:32:33as opposed to defining, you know,
1:32:35mathematically the shape of the sculpture.
1:32:37- Right.
1:32:38What do you think about the photo elements
1:32:42where you're tilting to, you know, sort of look at,
1:32:45the panoramic mode?
1:32:46- Yeah, they call it, I don't know if this is public or not.
1:32:49I know internally they call it Ken Turns,
1:32:52the Ken Turns effect.
1:32:54- That's good, that's funny.
1:32:55- I think it's brilliant.
1:32:57I think it is really, really,
1:32:59I think it works.
1:33:02It is so super effective, and I think, you know,
1:33:07it's like, I always say, like, you know,
1:33:09first is the original, the second is a rip-off,
1:33:13and the third, it's a standard.
1:33:15So somebody's gonna rip it off,
1:33:17and then everybody's gonna say,
1:33:18hey, they ripped off the Ken Turns effect
1:33:20from Facebook Paper, and then two or three other apps
1:33:23are gonna come out that use it,
1:33:24and it's everybody's, you know,
1:33:26well, we should always remember that they did it first,
1:33:28but it's, I think it's gonna become a standard.
1:33:31So the idea is, if you haven't,
1:33:32if you're out there, you're listening,
1:33:33and you haven't seen paper or used it,
1:33:35if you open a photo, they open it
1:33:38so that it always fills the screen.
1:33:41And so if it's like a, and it's even most noticeable
1:33:44if you think of a panoramic photo,
1:33:46like if you take a panoramic photo with your iPhone,
1:33:48where it's way wider than it is tall,
1:33:50well, it opens at full height on your phone,
1:33:52and then to see the rest of it,
1:33:54you just hold your phone in front of you
1:33:56and you can either twist it
1:33:58or you can actually rotate your body
1:34:02and the photo pans along as you move.
1:34:07I think it's brilliant.
1:34:09I think it works so well.
1:34:11- And it's just like it basically turns the phone screen
1:34:15is a window sort of into a picture,
1:34:18making it more like real life.
1:34:20- Yes, and it is, you know.
1:34:22So we sit at our desks and we have things like 27-inch iMacs or 21-inch iMacs or cinema
1:34:33displays or even on like a MacBook.
1:34:39We have retina displays on MacBook Pros now with incredible pixel counts and compared
1:34:43to a phone, a big screen.
1:34:46I think this Ken Turns thing for how do you view something that you really do want big
1:34:51like a photo, how do you view it on a little four inch screen? I think it's the best solution
1:34:57anybody's come up with. I think it's brilliant. They told me, "Here's one thing."
1:35:02So the name, they said that they started with the Ken Burns effect, where they would open
1:35:07the photo at that size.
1:35:08And then it just automatically moved?
1:35:10Yeah. And they said the problem was that they realized was a lot of times the most interesting
1:35:19part of the photo, maybe it was at the beginning, it's at the left edge, and then it already
1:35:23pans past.
1:35:24Right, and then you miss.
1:35:25You want to go back, and you have to wait for the animation, or you have to swipe it.
1:35:29That's interesting.
1:35:30Right.
1:35:31And then the main problem, so this is what this shows to me, which I think is pretty
1:35:35genius, which is that normally, so even right now, if you open up a panoramic picture, if
1:35:42you open it on your phone sort of in landscape mode or in horizontal mode, it will be so
1:35:49small and so you'll want to zoom in, right? But to see then the rest of the photo, you
1:35:53have to take your thumb and like sort of push. And so that's like putting your thumb in between
1:35:58what you're trying to look at, whereas this totally removes it because you never have
1:36:02to use your thumb.
1:36:03Well, exactly. So you're not covering the photo with your fat ugly thumb. And this gets
1:36:09back to what I said before, they've already assigned swiping left and right
1:36:13to going to the next thing. That's right, to navigation, and it does that.
1:36:17People, I'm assuming, right now are trying to do, you know, to get to the other part
1:36:21of the photo just because that has previously been the norm, and now
1:36:25they're just swiping to, you know, the next story and being like, "Oh, this is
1:36:28different. How do I get that?" To me, it's just a genius, and it's, you know, it's so easy to
1:36:35to overlook how much thought went into that, you know?
1:36:37And again, it would be the wrong solution,
1:36:41but it's, you know, the things that would be easier
1:36:43to think of, you know, and that a simple little mind
1:36:46like mine would think of would be, well,
1:36:47put two fingers on the screen and swipe left, right
1:36:50to pan the photo, and one finger is still just go next
1:36:54or forward, but people don't think like that.
1:36:56That two fingers on screen to go to do it is terrible.
1:36:59You know, this, you know, using,
1:37:02why don't we use the accelerometer and the gyroscope?
1:37:05It's a really great idea.
1:37:08I really can't.
1:37:09- And they have other little things
1:37:12like the autoplay of the videos.
1:37:14Normally people hate that,
1:37:15and I'm one of those people who hate that,
1:37:16but it's like when you are in sort of full mode,
1:37:21so it doesn't autoplay them when you're in
1:37:22sort of the browsing mode where you can,
1:37:25the stories are at the bottom of the screen
1:37:27and you're swiping through them,
1:37:28but once you bring it up to full screen,
1:37:30it does autoplay it,
1:37:31because it's like that's the content and you want to see it and you're just
1:37:34removing sort of a barrier to entry to see that. Yep, yeah exactly.
1:37:38Yeah. Really, really thoughtful stuff and you know I think you know rightly or
1:37:46wrongly a lot of the discussion has been more about it as hey is this an
1:37:50alternative way to look at Facebook but I think that you know interface wise it
1:37:53is fascinating it is you know you could teach a whole course of interface design
1:37:58and based on the novelties that they've come up with
1:38:01in the app.
1:38:02- So I guess the biggest complaint I would have
1:38:06as someone who does occasionally use Facebook,
1:38:09I mean I'm not, I certainly don't use it
1:38:10as much as much of the world does,
1:38:12but the difference between the regular sort of
1:38:17standard Facebook app and even the website and this
1:38:20is that for, it might not even be true,
1:38:23but there's something about it to me
1:38:24that makes it feel like there is much less content.
1:38:28and so it's much more shallow.
1:38:30And maybe that's on purpose,
1:38:31maybe it's sort of making Facebook less overwhelming
1:38:33because maybe it is too overwhelming now
1:38:35because everyone has sort of a thousand friends on it,
1:38:37even though you're probably not really friends
1:38:38with a thousand people.
1:38:39And so maybe they're doing some smart things
1:38:43and maybe I just haven't played around with it enough
1:38:44to know that they're serving up really what is the best
1:38:48of the content that I should see.
1:38:50But I do get the sense that there's just like
1:38:54much less content.
1:38:55And maybe it's because the cards are sort of at the bottom and they're sort of, you
1:38:59know, you can get basically two and a little bit more into one sort of screen.
1:39:04And so it takes quite a bit of swiping to get through to what you used to be able to
1:39:09get through in less sort of swiping up and down when you're swiping through something.
1:39:12Yeah, I don't think it's not a good interface.
1:39:15More or less it's probably not a good interface for going through a ton of stuff.
1:39:19Yeah.
1:39:20Right?
1:39:21Because you have to go left, right, and their minimum size is sort of a thumbnail.
1:39:25So you can't just scroll through a ton of stuff.
1:39:28It's not, I guess it's, you know, I don't know.
1:39:31I think that that's, I don't think it's ever going to replace the regular Facebook interface.
1:39:36I don't think it could, but I think it's an interesting alternative for some people and
1:39:40maybe so that some people, people who are turned off by the existing regular Facebook
1:39:47interface and what it promotes in terms of, you know, behavior and how many people you
1:39:54friend and etc. It's a way for more people to want to use Facebook. I think
1:40:01I'm probably gonna sign up but I don't think I really do and now it's almost
1:40:04like I just I don't want to it's like I don't I think it's stupid for me to just
1:40:08say I want to stick to this you know it I don't it's too arbitrary for me to say
1:40:14you know what I want I'm not gonna sign up for it just because I want to be able
1:40:16to always say I never signed up for Facebook right but I think my idea is
1:40:21is I'll sign up. I still don't want to use Facebook anywhere else. The only way I'll
1:40:26use Facebook is through paper. I've actually tried. You can't create an account using paper.
1:40:33So I would have to go to the website. But then after I do that, I'm never going to use
1:40:41anywhere else.
1:40:42And will you start offing in with Facebook then? Will you use that aspect of it too?
1:40:47I imagine that must be a pain for you with so many.
1:40:49Because I don't know that there's anything I've ever wanted to use that only offers a Facebook off there
1:40:54Yeah, I feel like that's less of an issue now like a year ago or two years ago. That was an issue
1:40:59There would be like I remember I was you know, sort of
1:41:01Looking at or sort of testing out many different apps that would have Facebook only and that was the number one complaint
1:41:08Of course, right? Yeah, you know I do at least email - that doesn't seem to be an issue anymore. We actually
1:41:13Did I mean it's it's not really it wasn't
1:41:19scientific, but for Vesper and for the eventual syncing thing that we're working on, we thought
1:41:25about should we have our own login system or should we use Twitter or should we use
1:41:29Facebook or should we do both? And there's, you know, a lot of, it solves a lot of problems
1:41:33to use an existing identity like that. But what we did is ask like real people, our wives
1:41:41and friends and people who aren't developers and very, very quickly got a lot of, you know,
1:41:48came very, very clear that normal people
1:41:50don't like using that.
1:41:52And it's because they don't trust that whatever app
1:41:55they're authoring in is gonna post to their board
1:41:58or to their Twitter.
1:42:00And they just don't like it.
1:42:01And they don't want Facebook or Twitter knowing
1:42:04what other apps they use.
1:42:05They just don't, you know, normal people,
1:42:08not like nerds, not privacy experts,
1:42:12just normal people have like a sense,
1:42:15just a common sense like aversion to letting these big companies know everything they do.
1:42:22Then they don't like it. They really don't. And that they also know intuitively that if
1:42:26your ID is just your email address that nobody knows, you know, that are...
1:42:32Right. The email provider doesn't care about that.
1:42:35Right. That they're not seeing...
1:42:37Or can't. I mean, they can't even really...
1:42:39Right. It's just a...
1:42:40There's no way that they could get access to that.
1:42:41that your email address isn't really a system,
1:42:43it's just a unique string,
1:42:45just by the way that domain names work,
1:42:48that there's one username at domain that can exist,
1:42:52and it's just a unique identifier, not a unique identity.
1:42:56And then it gets down to do it as an option,
1:43:03and then it's a design question of,
1:43:05well, how do you make people choose?
1:43:06But I don't know, and it seems to me the trend,
1:43:09And I've been looking at it, thinking about it for Vesper
1:43:12for a while, it seems to me like more services going forward
1:43:16are only offering things like Facebook and Twitter Auth
1:43:19as an option, not as your right way.
1:43:22- Well, and yeah, I guess the obvious upside is one button
1:43:28and you're done, right, rather than typing in an email.
1:43:31- Facebook is the first, or Facebook Paper is really
1:43:33the first time that I've needed a Facebook account
1:43:36to use a thing, and it's because it's actually,
1:43:38you know, very specific to paper.
1:43:40Let me do the third sponsor,
1:43:43and there's another angle to Facebook paper
1:43:45we can talk about, which is the sort of sections,
1:43:49the content sections.
1:43:50But our third sponsor is our good friends at Fracture.
1:43:56Fracture is the photo printing service.
1:44:00They print your photo directly onto a piece of glass.
1:44:04You have to see it to believe it,
1:44:07but it really is a very different visual effect
1:44:10than a piece of paper behind glass in a frame.
1:44:13It's a piece of glass with the paper printed on it.
1:44:15It's almost like if you're old enough to remember
1:44:17when people used to shoot slides.
1:44:19It's like having a piece of glass
1:44:21that's a slide of your photo.
1:44:23And there's a certain vibrancy to it,
1:44:26and it's also, it's a lot like with the iPhone and stuff
1:44:31where it's just closer to the surface of the glass,
1:44:33and it's just a great effect.
1:44:36They come in all sorts of sizes from very small to very big.
1:44:40They ship it in these ingenious containers where it's, if you want to hang it on a wall,
1:44:46you can hang it on a wall.
1:44:47If you want to put it on your desk, you can put it on your desk.
1:44:49It's like a frame and a desk stand all in one.
1:44:55Really you have to see it to believe it.
1:44:57It makes a great gift.
1:45:00My wife and I made a bunch of these for people for Christmas in the family.
1:45:06It's a huge hit.
1:45:07It also raises, as soon as people see it, they can see there's something different about
1:45:10it and they're like, "How did you do this?
1:45:12Where did you get this?"
1:45:14People love them.
1:45:16And I have a coupon code.
1:45:20You get 10% off any order.
1:45:23The coupon code is TheTalkShow.
1:45:26I love that because that's, to me, the ones who use, put the "the" in there, they're the
1:45:29ones who actually listen to the show.
1:45:32Where do you go to find out more?
1:45:34website is fractureme.com and I believe you can also just go to fracture.me. I'm going
1:45:41to type it in right now.
1:45:44Yep, you could go to fracture.me or fractureme.com. Learn more. They have a great video. You could
1:45:51just see it and it kind of shows off just how different it is. See the sizes and prices
1:45:59and get started and remember that code the talk show and you'll save 10% so go check them out
1:46:05it's a great service so here's the other thing with facebook paper it's us only
1:46:09not just iphone only it's us only and and the reason for that is because of the the content
1:46:14sections they have where it's not just your regular facebook feed they have sections for
1:46:20things like tech and sports and like world news I think. Yeah, planet, cities.
1:46:27And they're not scraping those. It's not just like they're scraping RSS feeds and
1:46:35showing whatever they want. They've got partnerships with content providers and
1:46:40I more or less I think that's why it's US only for now because it's like you
1:46:47You know, you go the—and I know a lot of people have compared Facebook paper to Flipboard,
1:46:52but I don't really think that they're that direct a competitor.
1:46:55I think it's because some of the animations are a little similar that people think that.
1:47:00Yeah, and, I mean, that's sort of what I was getting at the very beginning where it
1:47:04almost feels like this—this is the part to me that feels sort of like a response to
1:47:09Twitter.
1:47:10It's because Twitter is a place you go to get news right now, right?
1:47:12It's like where a lot of people actually find links for the first time, find links
1:47:16about news, breaking news happening. And Facebook now with this, with these sections are, as
1:47:22you said, sort of making partnerships with the actual news organizations to make this
1:47:26like an actual news reader.
1:47:28Well I didn't think about that as a response to Twitter, but maybe you're right though
1:47:32that it kind of is in terms of that you go to this app for news, but that you're not
1:47:36expecting it to come from your followers.
1:47:41Your friends.
1:47:42Right.
1:47:43Right.
1:47:44It's about this sort of professional editorial cultivation.
1:47:46cultivation. That's a good point because it's more along the lines of like Twitter if you only
1:47:51followed the actual news sources, right, rather than your friends. So you follow the account of
1:47:57New York Times and Washington Post and whoever else if you use Twitter that way, which some
1:48:02people do I think use or at least have power users of course have separate sort of Twitter
1:48:07screens set up with just sort of breaking news alerts on different items. Hmm, yeah. I don't know
1:48:15You know and I do I that's something where I just don't know whether because I'm not a Facebook user
1:48:20I don't know how much sense it makes to integrate these two things, you know
1:48:24It's like I can't I feel like I can't judge it. Yay or nay
1:48:28What do you think? Yeah, you say you're using it on your phone. Are you using the
1:48:33So no, I that's that's interesting. I am using it and I as I said I have I have replaced its
1:48:42I've replaced the Facebook app, the regular app, with paper.
1:48:46And it's great for all the reasons we just have talked about and elaborated upon.
1:48:51But I'm not really using the news sections.
1:48:54I don't know why.
1:48:56It does feel a little bit foreign to me because I am thinking about this as a Facebook replacement,
1:49:02even though I know that's not the only mentality you're supposed to be going into this thinking
1:49:07about and you are supposed to be focused on these different sections where you can read
1:49:11about news, but I don't know. I just don't use it that way, and I'm never compelled to
1:49:16sort of open up paper to be able to get to the latest Wall Street Journal story. And
1:49:23I don't know if that's because I'm a heavy Twitter user and I feel like I will have already
1:49:27seen it on Twitter. I guess maybe that's what it comes down to, the fact that I use Twitter
1:49:33must be 10 to 20x more times a day than I use Facebook. And so I'm already getting my
1:49:40news from Twitter. And so I'm just not in the right sort of mode to go into this paper
1:49:47app to sort of read about things right now. I don't know. And maybe I'm different. Maybe
1:49:52I'm one of 1.2 billion people who use Facebook.
1:49:55You know, it might be an interesting way to just wrap up the show. And as a sort of...
1:50:01I hadn't really thought about it before, but now you've got me thinking about Twitter versus
1:50:05Facebook overall. They're not the same thing, but they're clearly rivals. Facebook clearly
1:50:18has way more people.
1:50:19It's like 1.2 something billion to about 200 and some million.
1:50:25And somebody pointed out the other day, and I saw it on Twitter, that Facebook, last quarter,
1:50:32grew by a, even though they're bigger, grew by a faster percentage than Twitter.
1:50:37I saw that. I think that was Dustin Curtis who said that.
1:50:40Yeah.
1:50:41That's right.
1:50:42But you can't watch TV without seeing hashtags on the screen, right?
1:50:51Yes.
1:50:52And the hashtags are clearly, I mean, you can use them in Instagram, and people do,
1:50:59but clearly it's about tweets.
1:51:01Yes, and you know there is no Facebook equivalent to that that that on you know just watching any
1:51:07Stupid show or sports or the Super Bowl or anything?
1:51:12There's hashtags on screen commercials have hashtags right and it's all in Twitter and so
1:51:17Facebook has tried to do this you know they've they've in they've
1:51:21Integrated hashtags as a feature now. You know sort of copying the notion
1:51:25It still doesn't seem like it's taken off at all certainly not in the feeds of anyone that I'm friends with or that I follow
1:51:31on Facebook. And I think that's what we were talking about earlier where Facebook was talking
1:51:38to celebrities and influencers about using Facebook during the Super Bowl. And it's just,
1:51:43I don't know. To me, it seems very unnatural. I don't think it's going to be used that way.
1:51:47Facebook is what it is and Twitter is what it is. And it's especially hard to change something
1:51:53that 1.2 billion people are already using for a reason. And if that reason is not to talk about
1:51:58about the Super Bowl or at least not to sort of talk about
1:52:02in real time with the same sort of speed
1:52:07that people do on Twitter.
1:52:09I don't know, I'm not so sure that that's like a great idea
1:52:11for them to try to squeeze these things into this.
1:52:14And for me, what this boils down to is both
1:52:17of these companies are now public companies.
1:52:19Twitter, of course, just went public a few months ago.
1:52:24And so what this all boils down to,
1:52:27especially with regard to television,
1:52:28is trying to get advertisers on board
1:52:31and trying to monetize this.
1:52:32And so you can make the argument that while,
1:52:35I think, so Twitter had their first earnings
1:52:37and they beat the earnings estimates,
1:52:40but their user numbers were sort of
1:52:42the cause for concern there.
1:52:44But that sort of also points to the fact
1:52:46that I think Twitter actually has,
1:52:48and you can make a case, will be easier to monetize
1:52:51because it's sort of this zeitgeist
1:52:55that people use during all of these major events,
1:52:57like whether it's the Super Bowl,
1:52:59whether it's now the Olympics,
1:53:01and there's like a very direct sort of advertising
1:53:06nut to crack.
1:53:07I don't think that they have cracked it yet,
1:53:08but I think that there is a way to do that,
1:53:09much more so than with Facebook,
1:53:12even though Facebook has so many more users.
1:53:13- And I, it's just a strained, strained analogy,
1:53:17and it's not gonna hold a lot of water,
1:53:18but it's a little bit like iOS to Android,
1:53:21where Android has more people,
1:53:23but iOS is easier to monetize?
1:53:25You know, that it's, that, you know.
1:53:27- Yeah, that is, yeah, yep.
1:53:29I think that that works in some ways.
1:53:30- You know, and the other thing I see on TV,
1:53:32I see it on sports.
1:53:33Well, you know what, news too.
1:53:35I don't watch, I watch very little TV news,
1:53:37but I do watch sports.
1:53:39And they'll, you know, it's ubiquitous almost
1:53:43that, you know, the commentators,
1:53:45they'll put their Twitter names up, right?
1:53:48But I see it when I watch--
1:53:49- Especially sports.
1:53:50Sports is like the greatest example of that.
1:53:52It's all over.
1:53:53on SportsCenter. Every single person has their Twitter handle. There is no Facebook equivalent
1:53:57of that.
1:53:58Right. You know what? I was trying to think about how do I know this about TV news. I
1:54:04know how I know it. I know because I watch The Daily Show and The Daily Show shows me
1:54:07the clips I need to see of Fox and CNN and MSNBC. They do it too when they show you the
1:54:13clips of whatever they're making fun of on The Daily Show and on these news channels.
1:54:19Everybody gets introduced with their name and then underneath it, @ whatever their Twitter
1:54:24handle is.
1:54:28If I work at Twitter, if I'm Dick Costolo, I'm very happy about that.
1:54:33Oh, yeah.
1:54:34Of course.
1:54:35I mean, they are getting free advertising.
1:54:37But it's not just advertising though.
1:54:43It's like a way of entering the culture.
1:54:48culture mindshare.
1:54:49Right. It's culture mindshare. It's like being Coca-Cola. It's just huge. And that people
1:54:59know this. You go there and you go on TV and it'll say...
1:55:04And you see an @ sign and you know what that means.
1:55:07Right. You go on and it just says @ParisLemon under your name on TV and people know that
1:55:13if they want to see you on Twitter, they'll go to just search for that name on Twitter.
1:55:18It's really--
1:55:19- And that's interesting when you think about it
1:55:22compared to Facebook where Facebook,
1:55:24for a long time their strength
1:55:25was this real names component, right?
1:55:27Like everyone was going to be their actual selves
1:55:30on this service.
1:55:31The problem was like in the beginning,
1:55:34I don't know if you even notice not being a Facebook user,
1:55:37but they used to not even have like an actual slash username
1:55:41set up at all. - No, I did know that.
1:55:44- It was a string of numbers, like 16 numbers.
1:55:47- Right. - It was sort of crazy.
1:55:49Now they have, of course, vanity URLs,
1:55:51but it's still, that hasn't translated though.
1:55:55I actually have /ParisLemon on Facebook,
1:55:58and you can get to me that way,
1:55:59but what would I put on,
1:56:01what would someone put on television screen
1:56:03if you were doing that?
1:56:05Is it just slash?
1:56:06Could you do that?
1:56:07No one would know what that is, right?
1:56:08- It is kind of, for lack of a better word, gross to me.
1:56:16somebody who's been a longtime Mac user and always objected to file name
1:56:19extensions in general, not just three letter ones, but just the whole idea
1:56:22because like in like we had a more elegant system in the 80s and 90s on the
1:56:28Mac where you didn't need file extensions period. The name of the file
1:56:31was just a name with upper and lowercase letters and spaces you could just put a
1:56:35space in the name, you know like things in the real world and all the other
1:56:40computer systems you know Unix of course that you know you of course allowed
1:56:44spaces but you know it's the worst idea in the world because then you have to
1:56:48like backslash escape them you know at the command line right and to me the you
1:56:54know using a punctuation character like that and same thing with hashtags like
1:56:57to me hashtags are gross design wise but I do have to admit as they've gone on to
1:57:05become part of the culture there's no other way to do it like to me like tags
1:57:11you know like in tags and Vesper there's no advantage using hashtags in Vesper
1:57:17because it's not shared it's not public so tags and Vesper are just like old
1:57:21school Mac filings you just type whatever you want upper and lowercase
1:57:24with spaces and it's English and it looks nice and it's readable but I
1:57:28totally understand how on a social network that the hashtag thing is
1:57:32genius because you can put it on screen and people know what it means and
1:57:38there's no explanation and doesn't need a look it's just the the bang whatever
1:57:43and there it is right because you could argue that like in you know in our ever
1:57:49in increasing capabilities computationally like you should be able
1:57:54to say enter a status message and it sees say like Olympics and it should be
1:57:59able to know that the Olympics you're talking about is the same that you know
1:58:03a million other people are talking about and so there should you know sort of be
1:58:06way, at least theoretically, to sort of link those together. But how would you
1:58:10convey that on television? There would be no way, right? And you can, you know, and it
1:58:13shows up in all other places, you know, billboards and stuff like that, just
1:58:16hashtag whatever, or usernames, you know. It's really, you know, effectively
1:58:21it's been genius, you know. And it's funny too that neither of those things
1:58:26came from Twitter. Right, the users. And Chris Messina, you know, definitely, I
1:58:34I mean, we know that he more or less invented the hashtag not as a Twitter employee just as a Twitter user
1:58:40It's this like total company building
1:58:44Culture changing idea that he just like said hey, I think what if we just use hashtags
1:58:53Hashines and tag names after the hashtag to group tweets
1:58:59And the ad thing I think is a little bit murkier in terms of last time I saw anybody try to figure out who started
1:59:05Doing it but and and you know, there was some well and it has ties to email
1:59:10Yeah, and and flickr people were doing it on flickr where they were in a comment section, you know
1:59:15it was a it was a thing where if if there's like
1:59:1814 comments on a photo and you want to reply to the seventh commenter you type at their username
1:59:26and then space
1:59:28Meaning you were directing it at them.
1:59:30'Cause I remember when the,
1:59:32there was, when sort of the location services
1:59:34like Foursquare and Goa and stuff
1:59:35started gaining popularity, it was like,
1:59:38it's too bad that the at symbol has already been
1:59:42sort of taken by using it to direct a message at someone
1:59:45rather than it being an actual location.
1:59:47- Right.
1:59:48- Which would arguably make more sense.
1:59:49- Yeah, definitely.
1:59:50Well, and in the email sense, that's what it meant.
1:59:53It was, if you were John@daringfireball.com,
1:59:58It's me, you know, means I'm John is me at this server.
2:00:03You know, it kind of makes, in the Twitter sense,
2:00:08it doesn't, except when you think about the fact
2:00:11that the reply is supposed to be at them, right?
2:00:14There's like a, I guess semantically,
2:00:17the at is different than the username.
2:00:19The at is saying this is at this person.
2:00:22Gruber is really my Twitter handle,
2:00:25But it's just visually, it's just become, you know,
2:00:29at Gruber is now my Twitter handle.
2:00:33And it's a funny way to kind of take use of
2:00:35these characters that are on everybody's keyboard
2:00:39that were kind of underused.
2:00:42At was really, I mean, the only way I ever saw anything
2:00:45used, the at symbol in my entire life before email
2:00:49was like at a grocery store where they would say like,
2:00:52two at one dollar or something like that
2:00:55instead of a slash.
2:00:56- Just because it's shorter, yeah.
2:00:57- Right.
2:00:58It was almost like, why in the world do we have that one,
2:01:04especially on our keyboard?
2:01:05How in the world did that become a standard thing
2:01:07on everybody's keyboard?
2:01:08But then email made great use of it,
2:01:10and then in this username scenario, it's become great.
2:01:15And then number sign, I guess that everybody uses it
2:01:17for number one, number two.
2:01:18But it somehow works.
2:01:25and it's a thing. It looks geeky, but obviously if you just go and like surf hashtags on Twitter
2:01:30and Instagram, I mean millions of people use them, normal people. And so another one is
2:01:34like ampersand. Do people use, like does anyone use that often? Certainly in writing, but like
2:01:41do you ever see that being used, you know, like in sort of in emails that you send or receive?
2:01:46Are people still using it as a shorthand for, you know, for and?
2:01:52There's a very few.
2:01:54It's a pet peeve of mine.
2:01:56And so every once in a while, like for example, you know, I don't have any co-writers at Daring
2:02:02Fireball, but when a sponsored, my weekly sponsorships come in, every once in a while,
2:02:07whoever wrote the sponsored thing will use ampersands instead of ands, and I just change
2:02:11them to ands.
2:02:12it's it's so it's not it's not rare but it's uncommon it's a little unusual I
2:02:20don't know if it's that could be it that could be one that gets it gets taken
2:02:24yeah I think it's there I think it's totally ripe to be taken yeah yeah what's
2:02:30a percentage sign dollar sign now everybody knows what they mean and
2:02:33they're kind of right you know I guess the carrot the up sort of you know yeah
2:02:38the carrot is maybe the only other one that you could use but the tilde and the
2:02:42the back tick
2:02:44You know, which is probably like the least used key on anybody's keyboard, but they're too they're too small
2:02:50You can't they're not visually discernible like the other advantages of the at sign and the pound sign or hash
2:02:56Whatever you want to call that thing
2:02:58Is that they're so visually distinctive
2:03:01Yes, they stand out there the full height, you know, and they're very very visually
2:03:10distinctive ampersand has that going for it.
2:03:13- Karen, people of course have used,
2:03:17most notably I guess StockTwits is the one
2:03:19to use the money sign.
2:03:20- Oh, right.
2:03:21- To say that you're talking about a stock when you do it.
2:03:23And I think that works.
2:03:24That's pretty effective. - Yeah, that's actually,
2:03:25I forgot about that, but that does work, right?
2:03:27Because in the other, it doesn't collide
2:03:30with the other sense because--
2:03:32- There's no numbers, right? - Right, yeah.
2:03:34Like dollar sign followed by letters
2:03:36never had meaning before.
2:03:38- Yes.
2:03:39No, it actually is a good use.
2:03:41That's another one, that's a good counter example.
2:03:45I thought about the other day, actually,
2:03:46I was thinking about this with the hash symbol,
2:03:49whether if I were inventing Markdown today,
2:03:54whether I would still use that,
2:03:56it's a way to indicate headings.
2:03:59- Right, right. - And I don't think
2:04:01it collides because there's a space after it,
2:04:04and I don't think that, you know,
2:04:06I think I guess I would, 'cause I couldn't think
2:04:08of another character that I would use.
2:04:09But hashtags didn't even exist when I invented Markdown.
2:04:14And nobody's ever written to me to complain about that,
2:04:16so I'm guessing that it isn't a problem.
2:04:18- Why did you, how come, why not use something
2:04:23like the @ symbol for like a link or something like that?
2:04:27Why do it the way that it's done right now?
2:04:29- 'Cause I wanted it to be as visually
2:04:31non-distracting as possible.
2:04:35- Okay.
2:04:35So that's why it's like square brackets.
2:04:41Right.
2:04:41Sounds like a show.
2:04:49Yeah.
2:04:49All right.
2:04:51MG Siegeler, thank you very much for your time.
2:04:55Of course.
2:04:55And--
2:04:56As always.
2:04:57--people can catch you @ParisLemon.
2:05:01Hash-- no hashtags.
2:05:02Hashtags.
2:05:02I don't have my own hashtag.
2:05:04But you do have a username.
2:05:05and parislemon.com.
2:05:08- Yes.
2:05:10- All right, I'll talk to you soon.