Podcast Search

The Talk Show

63: Would You Pay A Quarter For That?

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00So Glenn Fleishman welcome to the talk show. Thanks for having me on. All right, so let's just

0:00:04run down the balls you've got in the air. So you're I think and I think this is new since

0:00:10the last time you were on this show is that I think that you're now the owner publisher editor

0:00:18or not editor. I'm not sure about that of the magazine. I'm everything. I'm the bottle washer.

0:00:24Yeah, I think I was on just before Mark when I did the deal or a few months before it was

0:00:29So, living longer than that.

0:00:31Oh, no, it was actually, I think after I came on as editor,

0:00:34yeah, when Marco sold everything, except his dog

0:00:38and children and child in May and June,

0:00:42it was a very funny time.

0:00:43But yeah, it was a logical thing.

0:00:45I mean, I love doing this and Marco's a programmer

0:00:50and the cycle is really different

0:00:51between being a programmer and a publisher.

0:00:53And I think the timing was great

0:00:54when he was ready to move on with his new endeavors,

0:00:57do not no longer secret podcast thing.

0:00:59All right. But anyway, you're running an entire magazine, a weekly magazine,

0:01:03no biweekly.

0:01:04That's correct. Fortnightly every two weeks.

0:01:07Isn't, isn't biweekly one of those words that can mean two different things?

0:01:13Yeah. It's like, can you quick annual perennial,

0:01:16which means every year and which means, uh, they only once.

0:01:20No, they both mean every year.

0:01:22No. And annual plant. Oh, I think it's the plant annual, uh, in plants,

0:01:27I guess is the thing is it only comes out once and a perennial will bloom again every

0:01:30year.

0:01:31I don't get it.

0:01:32It's language. Language is a problem. Yeah, biweekly used to be, not sometimes people

0:01:36say semi-weekly.

0:01:37No, bi-monthly. Isn't bi-monthly? Bi-monthly can mean twice a month or every two months.

0:01:42The language has evolved to where most people will say semi-monthly or twice a month and

0:01:46then bi-monthly means every other month. But it's, yeah, it's becoming, in periodicals

0:01:51it's becoming more common because publications are reducing their frequency. New York Magazine

0:01:56is going to every other week now, for instance, after many, many years of being weekly.

0:02:01Right. I saw that.

0:02:03It's interesting.

0:02:05Just read it off topic. I have a whole bunch of on topic stuff for this show. But there

0:02:13was a, they have a great article. I don't think I've, yeah, I have not yet linked it

0:02:17from Daring Fireball, but by the time the show comes out, I will have a cover story

0:02:22on the new issue of New York Magazine about Alex Rodriguez, the New York Yankees embattled

0:02:27superstar. And it's one of the finest pieces of journalism that I've read in a long time

0:02:34because there's this whole thing where he's been accused of using performance-enhancing

0:02:38drugs and he was issued a 211-game suspension. And he's fought it and nobody really knows

0:02:45what the hell is going on. And this article, and I follow it as a Yankees fan, I've been

0:02:49following the saga, you know, pretty avidly, I guess I would say, you know, all year long.

0:03:00And still had no idea. Like, to me, it still has never been clear just what evidence they

0:03:04had against him. They must have had something, blah, blah, blah. This article makes the whole

0:03:09thing clear, and you really—it's really journalism at its finest.

0:03:13mhmm. Yeah, it's a funny thing. Journalism is a problem because the best kind of journalism

0:03:18that we think we like the most, that we, like, sticks with us and you may go back and read

0:03:24or it turns into a book or it changes the law or whatever. That stuff is so ridiculously

0:03:30unprofitable, it costs so much money to do that entire news organizations are devoted

0:03:36to making enough money to afford to be able to do that sort of journalism.

0:03:39Pete: Yeah.

0:03:40Pete; Because it just, I mean, the Seattle Times, I always cite them because they're

0:03:43a family-run paper and the family is really weird and they've made some really terrible

0:03:47business decisions, but it's still 51% owned by the family that bought it in the 1800s.

0:03:51And they will do things like spend $2 million for a two-year investigation into the Washington

0:03:56State Court's ceiling documents inappropriately and cause massive positive political social

0:04:02change.

0:04:03They did not make $2 million off that, right?

0:04:05I mean, everything else they did subsidized that $2 million so that could happen, and

0:04:10they have to actually believe in their mission enough and believe that it gives them an aura

0:04:13that keeps subscribers or brings subscribers in

0:04:15that it was worth it.

0:04:17And that's a hard sell.

0:04:19- Yeah, and just, you know, this article I'm talking about,

0:04:23just titled "Chasing A-Rod,"

0:04:25and it is written by, hold on,

0:04:29I've gotta go back to page one, goddamn pagination,

0:04:33which I wanna get into, Steve Fishman,

0:04:36who wrote this cover story.

0:04:37- Related to me, of course, no, no, sorry.

0:04:39- And it was a monumental effort.

0:04:42effort. It really is, you know, and the best of feature-length magazine writing is much

0:04:49closer to, in scope, to book writing than to, you know, article writing. It's closer

0:04:57to a miniature book than it is to what, you know, to me an article is somewhere around

0:05:03a thousand words.

0:05:04Mm-hmm.

0:05:05And once you get past that, you know, you're somehow, you're taking on something that needs

0:05:10a lot more nurturing work. But this is a guy who traveled to Miami. That's where Alex Rodriguez

0:05:16lives and a big part of the reason this article is so interesting is that he's the first journalist

0:05:22who Alex Rodriguez had opened up to. And so he traveled to Miami and hung out with him

0:05:32and was there. He spent time in New York in the, not a trial, but an arbitration hearing

0:05:39with Major League Baseball.

0:05:42You know, that's putting your ass in the seat in a room where there, you know, those things,

0:05:47anybody who's ever been in a courtroom, you've ever done, you know, jury duty or even just

0:05:51gotten out of jury duty, you know that all those things, they go slowly.

0:05:54It's days, you know, of just waiting for what, you know, a couple of paragraphs.

0:06:01And in the meantime, you know, the guy's a writer, bills have to be paid, you know, so

0:06:05it takes money to gather, just to gather the reporting,

0:06:09let alone the time it takes to write the actual article.

0:06:13- Yeah, I remember reading,

0:06:14Neal Stephenson wrote a piece for Wired years ago

0:06:16where he traced fiber optic cable around the world.

0:06:19And I read it and I thought, A, this is,

0:06:22I mean, he's still, you know, top of his career,

0:06:24but this is when he was really on the peak.

0:06:25So he's getting massive amounts of advances

0:06:27and selling millions of books.

0:06:28And I thought, A, how much money

0:06:30do they have to pay him for a fee?

0:06:31But B, reading all the places he went,

0:06:34I'm thinking he had like a $75,000 expense budget,

0:06:39traveling coach, staying in two star hotels

0:06:42because of the 50 places he went

0:06:44and just the sheer amount of time.

0:06:46It's astonishing the amount.

0:06:48Yeah, I mean, that's the thing.

0:06:49He's a thousand words.

0:06:50You could talk to someone on the phone

0:06:51and write a thousand words in a 20 minute conversation,

0:06:5410 minute conversation and write about one thing.

0:06:56But when you get beyond that,

0:06:57you have to start to shape a narrative

0:06:59and you have to start doing research.

0:07:00You have to have things that go beyond

0:07:03the obvious or a few quotations because otherwise, like, what are you writing about for that

0:07:07long? There's not enough to say. I mean, people write philosophical essays that are

0:07:10longer, but if you're writing about news and real things, then, you know.

0:07:14Ben de la Torre Yeah, and so that's—I still feel—and

0:07:18I feel like it's a good topic to talk to you about is, where does the money for this

0:07:24type of work continue to come from as we move forward into a BuzzFeed-driven world?

0:07:29That's what I'm asking. Where does it come from?

0:07:32Um, you know, and I don't even know where to start, but with, uh, just stuff in the

0:07:40last week, you know, where over Thanksgiving, did you follow, you had to follow this, this

0:07:47Elan/Gail saga?

0:07:48Oh yeah, that was, yeah, and I felt very bad for my sped about myself. At first I thought

0:07:54it was hilarious, and I thought, "Oh no, wait, the guy's a dick," and then I thought,

0:07:57no, this can't even be true, went through regret.

0:08:02- For anybody who missed it, Elon Gale,

0:08:04who I never heard of before,

0:08:04but he's apparently the producer, executive producer

0:08:07of a bunch of really shitty reality shows

0:08:09like The Bachelor and The Bachelorette and something else.

0:08:13And over Thanksgiving, I guess on the day,

0:08:16he tweeted a series of tweets ostensibly live

0:08:19from a wifi equipped plane about a terrible woman

0:08:23a few rows ahead of him who was,

0:08:26know, berating the crew because their flight was delayed.

0:08:33And this woman, you know, and it ends up, and then he sent her notes and drinks and

0:08:40got really rude with her.

0:08:41And that was the part, there's two weird parts to it.

0:08:43Like the weirdest part is that it ends up the whole thing was fake.

0:08:46He made the whole thing up.

0:08:47But a lot of, you know, but it was all presented as being true.

0:08:50And even on Twitter when people said, "Hey, is this fake?" and he denied it.

0:08:58But the other thing too was that even if it was true, yeah, like you said, at first...and

0:09:06it was like a slow boiling frog where his behavior to the woman at first, if it were

0:09:10true, was kind of funny.

0:09:11But then when he started sending notes to her that said, "Eat my dick," that's over

0:09:18the line.

0:09:19actually a really creepy thing to do, even if it were true.

0:09:23I mean, that's sort of--

0:09:26- Yeah, I mean, that kind of thing could get you arrested.

0:09:27Everyone in the situation could get arrested,

0:09:29and then she allegedly, he said she slapped him

0:09:32and nothing happened, the police weren't called,

0:09:35and it was a weird story.

0:09:38Well, it started out, I mean, this is that,

0:09:41he was channeling that rage we all have now

0:09:44because the airlines pack us in,

0:09:46and the flying experience is horrible,

0:09:48and all the planes are full and everything is bad about flying.

0:09:52And he did a great job tapping into that feeling where we see,

0:09:56like, we feel like we are surrounded by horrible people.

0:10:00Even if they're perfectly nice in other circumstances,

0:10:02everyone is pushed to the limit.

0:10:03And he's like, all right, you know, so I'm taking action.

0:10:05It's like, all right, that's great.

0:10:06Then it's like, oh, but you're a dick.

0:10:08That you're being a dick.

0:10:09It's like, ugh.

0:10:10- The thing is, is it turned into a sensation.

0:10:12I mean, then, you know, a multi-million page view sensation

0:10:17on sites like Buzzfeed and I don't know if the Huffington Post picked it up, but I know

0:10:20Buzzfeed did and probably did as much as anybody to drive it as a, I hate to say this, viral

0:10:28meme, I don't know, or story. But here's the thing, even if it were true, it is kind of

0:10:35bullshit to be the biggest story of the day and it ends up the whole thing was a hoax

0:10:40and was rather easily verified as a hoax or at least nobody did any work to actually see

0:10:46if it were true. And yet that, everything has continued to devolve. Even though everybody

0:10:53knows that page views are so problematic as a measure of advertising in so many ways,

0:11:01the publishing world has continued to, even knowing how poisonous this whole model is,

0:11:07has continued to devolve in that direction. And I can't think of, it's as good an example

0:11:12as anything.

0:11:13Pete: Yeah, I mean, look, here's the example of where we're at, is that Business Insider

0:11:18running, you know, they've got all kinds of opinions about them, of course, and how they

0:11:22fight, they follow page views.

0:11:26The bit that one of their editors wrote about his rebooked trip to China where it was paid

0:11:30for by the Chinese airline, that whole crazy story, they got like 1.5 million page views

0:11:36or something, a story about how he was traveling in the lap of luxury and he took a bunch of

0:11:41of pictures and Henry Blodgett's awful thing

0:11:44about being cramped and I don't know,

0:11:45American Airlines flight last year or whenever that was,

0:11:47that got hundreds of thousands of views.

0:11:49So they figured out how to tap people's sort of

0:11:53prurient or I don't know what it is like,

0:11:56it's lolcat interest and turn it into massive traffic

0:12:00and then they sell that massive traffic

0:12:01at an incredibly, incredibly low rate.

0:12:04So they have to have billions of views

0:12:06to make any kind of real money in any case.

0:12:08But they're finding people who will come and read the stuff.

0:12:11So there is an audience for it.

0:12:12- And there's no chance that that sort of crap

0:12:17is going to go away.

0:12:19And I'm not even saying it should.

0:12:21I mean, and then, you know, and in some sense, you know,

0:12:23like this Elon Gale guy, his professional career

0:12:26is an example of that, you know, where--

0:12:28- Yes, we have to remember how classy he is

0:12:30in his day job too.

0:12:31- Right, but it really does show you.

0:12:33I mean, and if you watch, or even just tune in, you know,

0:12:38halfway through any random episode

0:12:40of one of these reality shows, with a critical eye,

0:12:44you can really see just how the whole thing,

0:12:47it really, the word reality needs dick quotes around it,

0:12:51because it's, how could it be?

0:12:54You know, like where these regular characters enter a room,

0:12:58and somebody who they're ostensibly meeting

0:13:01documentary style, you know, for real,

0:13:04is already wearing a lav mic?

0:13:07You know, it's like, it's almost like how can you possibly believe that this is real

0:13:12if the people they're meeting, you know, in a restaurant or something have already

0:13:15been mic'd?

0:13:16Oh, I saw that the other day. Someone was mentioning that, like, if you see, if a random

0:13:20person that someone meets in a reality show is already mic'd for sound, it's not a

0:13:24random person. Like, oh, well, yes, but you don't--

0:13:27Yeah, I think you must have seen the same tweet, right?

0:13:29You don't think that's how-- it's a good tell. That was the same thing with the Elon

0:13:31situation. As someone pointed out a couple days afterwards, said the picture where he

0:13:35posted the note with the glass of wine, he couldn't have taken that because that would

0:13:39have meant that he had gotten up and was standing next to her taking the photo before she, whatever,

0:13:44there's no way that would have worked. Like, he, it doesn't make any sense. It's like,

0:13:48"Oh, you're right." It was internally inconsistent. Nick Bilton at the New York

0:13:52Times was actually looking at flight schedules and so forth and correlating them with tweets

0:13:56and decided it was nonsense just based on that. It cracked me up.

0:14:00That's funny.

0:14:01I thought it was my first, I don't know,

0:14:03something set me off on it right away,

0:14:05and my first thing was that, and maybe it's my ears,

0:14:08I don't know, like I've said this before in the show,

0:14:10I worry a little bit, and it runs in my family,

0:14:12that hearing loss in the men, in the Gruber family,

0:14:15is sort of a problem.

0:14:17So maybe it's just me, but I have trouble,

0:14:22like when we sit, like if my family travels,

0:14:25and Amy and I both take aisle seats,

0:14:29and maybe Jonas sits in the middle next to Amy,

0:14:32I have trouble hearing Amy across the aisle.

0:14:34Like if, you know, like if I'm 7C and she's 7D,

0:14:39I have trouble hearing her on this ship because,

0:14:43you know, or on the plane,

0:14:44because she doesn't wanna talk real loud, you know.

0:14:47And he said she was, I don't know, five rows ahead of her,

0:14:50three or four rows ahead of her?

0:14:52- Oh yeah, yeah.

0:14:53- It's really hard to overhear somebody,

0:14:55Even if somebody was really, you know, sort of being abusive toward the flight crew, if

0:15:02she's sitting five rows ahead of you, it's really pretty hard.

0:15:04Plus, the whole thing, like, it was repeated endlessly over and over and over again that

0:15:09she was Diane in 7A.

0:15:11Well, 7A is a window seat.

0:15:13So all this note passing nonsense, it's a little bit more possible if it's like a 747

0:15:20a 242, you know, with two aisles, because then, you know, I guess he could only have to reach over

0:15:28one person, 7B. But most planes on domestic flights are not 747s. They're, you know, they're,

0:15:38forget the numbers.

0:15:41Pete: They're not narrow-bodied, what they call them, they're mainline, but yeah, they're 727-900.

0:15:46I just wrote Alaska has an upgraded Boeing that I really liked, I wrote the other day. It actually

0:15:50has room, I could cross my legs.

0:15:52But if it's a three seats aisle, three seats setup, then, you know, it's really, it would

0:16:00be almost impossible to pass a note to somebody in 7A.

0:16:03Right, but people were repeating this credibly, like, it got turned into news, it got cycled

0:16:08into news incredibly fast without any actual documentary evidence except his tweets and

0:16:13people's suppositions, even though if you'd stopped as Nick Bilton did or as you're thinking

0:16:17about it or other people did looking at the photos, like, anyone with any journalist should

0:16:22have used their powers of observation and pointed out that this was very clearly fake.

0:16:28And he was probably, I'm actually curious if the guy himself was astonished that people

0:16:32took it as real because he had, there were so many tells.

0:16:36Ted: Yeah, I think he, I think, no, I don't think he was astonished. I think he tried

0:16:39to fake it and he's, I forget, somebody else pointed out that he has a history of this

0:16:43sort of thing.

0:16:44Yeah, but it really shows you what he thinks of as reality. It's you know, it's you know

0:16:50I guess it's what makes him good at his job, but it makes me think that you know, like I'm The Bachelor. There's probably

0:16:55You know the like the the what's the idea with The Bachelor and The Bachelorette

0:17:01There's like a hero character on The Bachelor who's a guy and on The Bachelorette who's a woman and then they present them

0:17:07I don't know a dozen

0:17:08people of the opposite gender to pick from

0:17:11And each week they kick one out.

0:17:14That the person probably doesn't even kick them out.

0:17:17The show probably tells them who to pick based on who's the most popular.

0:17:23That it's probably all as contrived as the whole thing would be if it were run on the

0:17:26up and up.

0:17:27It's probably not even run on the up and up.

0:17:29So, it's true.

0:17:30And films and TV do that.

0:17:33I think they have to, or they think they have to.

0:17:37that came out several years ago,

0:17:40The King of Kong, Fistful of Quarters, about,

0:17:42yeah, which a great movie.

0:17:44- The Donkey Kong. - Really interesting.

0:17:45- The competition to score the perfect Donkey Kong game.

0:17:49- Yeah, and there was a villain,

0:17:51there's this guy Billy who ran a restaurant

0:17:53and had maybe faked some high scores,

0:17:56but probably gotten him and he was on the cover

0:17:58of Newsweek or something in the 80s,

0:18:01and this up and coming laid off school teacher

0:18:03who is playing in his garage

0:18:07and tops of the high score, so he's the hero,

0:18:10you've got the villain.

0:18:11Well, there was a piece, and I think it was Atlantic,

0:18:13after the movie came out by a guy

0:18:14who had been involved in the shooting a bit,

0:18:16who said, "Well, Billy really isn't the way he was depicted."

0:18:19They kind of emphasized things,

0:18:20but they didn't make stuff up,

0:18:22but they made him into a villain

0:18:24because they wanted a goat in the film

0:18:26for people to root against,

0:18:27and actually he's much more nuanced,

0:18:28as everyone is in life.

0:18:29But it's hard to, I think film and TV

0:18:32often remove the nuance,

0:18:33because you can't tell a story as well in those mediums

0:18:35without having, I don't know, unless it's a really good filmmaker, without having identifiable

0:18:43people to root for and against. I mean, it's part of human nature, but it's also how a

0:18:46lot of films are made.

0:18:48Ben de Mello - Perfectly agree. But I think that stuff is not going to go away. I think

0:18:56everybody, if you watch it, I think you should watch it with a giant grain of salt. And I

0:19:02think that's to me is the interesting takeaway from this Elon Gale tweet hoax

0:19:06thing is not just that his tweet thing was a hoax but what does it tell you

0:19:10about you know these reality shows that dominate TV you know major network TV

0:19:19today I saw another tweet a couple days ago from somebody I don't remember who

0:19:23who just posited that if you showed today's reality shows to someone from

0:19:3220 years ago, 25 years ago. They would think it was stuff from a dystopian science fiction future.

0:19:40Pete: Oh yeah, or they might also, they might actually also see it for the false front it

0:19:48presents. There's a bit in, it was The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat, the Oliver Sacks book,

0:19:53I think it's in that book, where he talks about being in a ward where there are people who had

0:19:57at aphasia and other people, one group of people could not understand the meanings of

0:20:03words, but they could hear words literally only. The other could not understand what

0:20:07words meant, but they could hear the emotion behind it, it was two different neurological

0:20:10conditions, and he watched them watching Ronald Reagan deliver speeches and they were all

0:20:15laughing.

0:20:16Pete: Huh.

0:20:17Pete; Because Reagan was a perfect melody, in his description at least, of being able

0:20:19to lie effectively in some combination, but if you could cut out either the meaning or

0:20:27the emotional part, it was transparent.

0:20:29And I have that feeling sometimes,

0:20:30if you took somebody who hadn't watched TV,

0:20:33you know, a bit out of culture,

0:20:34they were often in some remote place,

0:20:36they come back 25 years later and they watch reality TV

0:20:38and say, "Why does everyone watch these fake things?

0:20:40"These are made for TV movies, right?"

0:20:42You're like, "No, no, this is supposed to be real."

0:20:43And they'd say, "But it's so fake!"

0:20:45You know, and we've become conditioned

0:20:47to what we believe reality is supposed to be

0:20:49as portrayed in those,

0:20:50and we accept it more fully as reality.

0:20:53Everything is worldwide wrestling foundation,

0:20:56whatever it's called. It's all wrestling.

0:20:59- Horrible people.

0:21:00(laughing)

0:21:02Acting horribly.

0:21:03Right, I always think back, and the first thought I had

0:21:06when I saw that tweet, and if you're,

0:21:08I don't know who it was, but if, you know,

0:21:10I apologize for not remembering.

0:21:12That first thing I thought of was that show

0:21:18that was on all the TVs in RoboCop,

0:21:22where it was like that creepy, older, nebbishy guy

0:21:27who was always surrounded by like really skanky models.

0:21:33And no matter what happened, he had that catchphrase,

0:21:36I'd buy that for a dollar.

0:21:38- It's the best thing.

0:21:40And you know, that dates back to the Corn Bluth story,

0:21:44The Marching Morons.

0:21:45Great science fiction story you can find online

0:21:47from the 1950s.

0:21:48The phrase there was, would you pay a quarter for that?

0:21:51It was an homage to that.

0:21:53In that story, an ad guy convinces

0:21:56the supposedly stupidest people in society

0:21:59to board rocket ships that land on the sun.

0:22:02(laughs)

0:22:03That go straight to the sun.

0:22:04To get rid of all the excess population of idiots.

0:22:06That's kind of a 1950s idea.

0:22:08It's a fascinating story.

0:22:09- I also thought of the old Stephen King,

0:22:13I think it was a novella.

0:22:14I think it was one of the ones he wrote under a pseudonym.

0:22:17Richard Bachman. - Richard Bachman, yeah.

0:22:19- The Running Man.

0:22:20Which they turned into a Schwarzenegger movie, but sort of--

0:22:23- Crazy film.

0:22:24- The novella was a lot less Schwarzenegger-y

0:22:27in a little bit, but it was really kind of spot on

0:22:30about where TV's going, you know,

0:22:32that it is sort of feeding.

0:22:35Now, you know, obviously the king twist

0:22:38was that they were actually trying to kill the protagonists,

0:22:41and that is not going to happen.

0:22:43But it does--

0:22:47- I watched the season of Survivor

0:22:48which they put people with no clean water supply and brain eating parasites on the island.

0:22:52So you know, nobody died, but—

0:22:54Pete: Close, right?

0:22:55Alan: Yeah, I mean, that was a scenario.

0:22:56People were doing—

0:22:57Pete; Right, right.

0:22:58They did have a medical crew nearby for anybody who came down with dysentery.

0:23:00Alan; Well, it's true, but brain eating parasites, I mean, that's, you know, you're

0:23:02pushing the limit there a little.

0:23:04Pete; But it does sort of feed into, you know, the sort of dark side of our psyche that led

0:23:13to, you know, the Roman Colosseum, right?

0:23:16Where you know—

0:23:17You know as long as you can brand the people as some sort of other

0:23:21You know watching them destroy their lives you can take solace, you know, you take pleasure in it, right? Well, they're just

0:23:29You know trashy housewives from Beverly Hills. So, you know watching, you know, one of them, you know

0:23:37Drink herself into rehab on TV in front of the whole nation

0:23:44somehow you take pleasure in it,

0:23:46or at least you're supposed to.

0:23:48- Sick fascination gets ratings and it gets page views.

0:23:52And we are denying something about ourselves

0:23:55as a society or humanity if we don't accept that.

0:23:59But pandering to it,

0:24:01we don't have to agree to pander to it.

0:24:02And I think that's been that divide in culture

0:24:04between highbrow and lowbrow,

0:24:05is highbrow is we're not gonna pander.

0:24:07You all, lowbrow people,

0:24:08should lift yourself up to our level

0:24:11so that you can appreciate this fine culture

0:24:13that's actually what you should be watching.

0:24:14And lowbrow is, look, we're just enjoying this stuff.

0:24:18It's not serious, get off your high horse.

0:24:21But the gap seems to get bigger and bigger for people

0:24:23and people who feel like there's a cultural loss.

0:24:26I mean, people are saying, you know,

0:24:27that you can look at people writing in the 17th century

0:24:30about terrible popular music and entertainment

0:24:32and only the good stuff you could find in the salons

0:24:34and those idiots in the streets are morons.

0:24:37And I'm sure you can find it in Roman times and before,

0:24:40like whenever there was culture, there was a divide.

0:24:42but it somehow seems more obvious to us now

0:24:44because it's so exposed.

0:24:45We can all see and find the worst stuff

0:24:48and see exactly how many people are obsessed by

0:24:52and reading the worst stuff,

0:24:53which we used to not be able to,

0:24:54we didn't have to know that as much.

0:24:56I mean, 'cause there were tabloids,

0:24:57people read, you know,

0:24:58the New York Daily News still exists

0:24:59and all those are out there.

0:25:01And that used to be the battle

0:25:01between the New York Times and the tabloid papers.

0:25:04So it's just more obvious and more people we know

0:25:09that we wouldn't think would spread it

0:25:10are passing on this stuff too, so it gets in our face.

0:25:13- Well, compared to something like Buzzfeed,

0:25:15even though Buzzfeed occasionally has really good features,

0:25:18they had a really good feature I read about

0:25:20a young man from Utah who disappeared in China

0:25:28at the end of his mission and his family

0:25:30has spent the last few years trying to figure out

0:25:31what happened to him and their best guess,

0:25:33and they really have some pretty, nothing confirming it,

0:25:37but some pretty good circumstantial evidence

0:25:39he might have been kidnapped by North Korean secret agents and taken to North Korea.

0:25:43Pete: Oh my god. Unplausible, sadly, yeah.

0:25:45Ted, in a way. At BuzzFeed, you know, which, you know, it's not their bread and butter,

0:25:50you know, but they're, they are paying for some feature writing.

0:25:53Pete Yeah, everybody is –

0:25:55Ted But compared to, compared to most of what

0:25:57BuzzFeed publishes though, something like the New York Post and the New York Daily News is

0:26:01relatively highbrow today.

0:26:03Pete Yeah, the, it, right, and the, well,

0:26:05the, this is, here's the interesting trend, the long form journalism trend is that

0:26:08A lot of sites that do, they make it up in volume.

0:26:12So Buzzfeed, it's the same thing with Huffington Post to some extent, or political, I don't

0:26:18want to argue political is different, but you need a business insider probably in this

0:26:22camp too, is they need billions of very, very, very low paying page views to have enough

0:26:28money to then afford to do stuff that will get higher ad rates because it's higher quality,

0:26:34but requires more of an investment.

0:26:35And BuzzFeed certainly, they've got this huge war chest of private investment and they

0:26:40certainly have been perfecting the bulk model and they've been hiring more and more serious

0:26:46journalists at the sort of top end of news reporting and long form end and are doing

0:26:51good work there.

0:26:53Much as I hate to say it, they're doing good work there.

0:26:55And I think, you know, Digg actually is producing features now.

0:26:59That's new.

0:27:00Like, all the sites out there that produce any kind of volume are also now trying to

0:27:05do long-form work? Well, let's get back to that. I'm going to take a break right now

0:27:11though and talk about our first sponsor. It's our good friends at MailRoute. MailRoute,

0:27:19in short, is an easy to implement, fully customizable front-end for your domain's email. It works

0:27:29simply, it's easy, reliable, it's easy, reliable, it's easy, and reliable. That's

0:27:35the talking points they want me to hit. Easy, reliable. But it really is. It's the

0:27:41best solution an IT person can pick for spam and virus filtering. They filter

0:27:45spam and viruses out of your email and deliver clean mail to your mailbox. More

0:27:50than 90% of all email traffic today is spam and viruses. Mail route keeps that

0:27:56garbage off your service, off your servers and out of your mailboxes.

0:28:00So your mail servers don't even have to deal with it.

0:28:03You just take the 10% of the email that's actually the real stuff.

0:28:08Has a very low, very low false positive rate and reliable uptime.

0:28:13And it's a hosted service in the cloud.

0:28:15It's not hardware that you have to install.

0:28:17It's not software that you have to install and worry if it's compatible with your existing

0:28:25email server.

0:28:28It's just a service that you point your MX records to and then the mail gets forwarded

0:28:32on to your existing server.

0:28:34So you don't have to change anything on your mail servers end.

0:28:37You just point your MX records at mail route.

0:28:39They do all the filtering.

0:28:41Then the clean mail comes to you.

0:28:44Very very elegant and graceful solution for a third party filtering service.

0:28:48Because it could work with any, it could work for anybody.

0:28:51It's written and created by email nerds and their target is the ITPro crowd, right?

0:28:57They have an API so you can write your own scripts, customize it to your heart's content.

0:29:03They know that ITPros want to have it just the way they want it so you can manage it

0:29:08with all the stuff you want.

0:29:09You can manage your users through LDAP, Active Directory or with MailRoute's own custom API.

0:29:17It's the only email service that they're aware of that has an API like that.

0:29:22So you can reduce your hardware costs.

0:29:25You can probably cut a lot of their examples if you go to their website and check them

0:29:29out.

0:29:30A lot of their customers have been able to greatly reduce the number of email servers

0:29:35they have because the bulk of what they had multiple servers for was just dealing with

0:29:41the vast amount of email that's garbage, just spam and viruses and stuff.

0:29:46They love admins and they also love little guys, even if you're a small organization.

0:29:50They have no minimum number of users and no maximum number either.

0:29:56Go to mailroute.net/thetalkshow to find out more.

0:30:01So anyway, I started the show talking about the balls you have up in here.

0:30:05We only got to the magazine.

0:30:06You're also still writing for speaking a magazine to the economist and talk about doing it the

0:30:13right way and shooting for top-tier journalism and analysis. You've got your podcast, The

0:30:24New Disruptors. Is that weekly? You do that every week?

0:30:27Every week. I tape ahead, so it's slightly non-perishable, so I sometimes do batches

0:30:34at a time, but just celebrated a year. This is a year of episodes. I skipped one episode,

0:30:39I've done 50, episode 52 is this week on the anniversary.

0:30:43All right, when we're recording this, I should say.

0:30:45- Congratulations.

0:30:46- Mr. Reza, thank you.

0:30:47It's so much fun.

0:30:48It's just, I love dealing with creative people.

0:30:50Like I have this background in art, work in journalism.

0:30:54I love collaborating.

0:30:55I mean, my favorite thing is finding people

0:30:57I like to work with and figuring out something

0:30:59to do with them.

0:31:00And so the podcast, like every week I get to talk to new

0:31:02and interesting people who are just,

0:31:05I keep trying to find, you know, I'm not a Pollyanna,

0:31:06but I like people who are excited and happy

0:31:08about what they do.

0:31:09And that's kind of my Twitter problem too,

0:31:11is people who are sad sacks, I tend to unfollow.

0:31:13Like even if they're people I otherwise like,

0:31:15like I don't want relentless negativity.

0:31:16I don't need relentless positivity either.

0:31:19But so the podcast, I find people who have just,

0:31:23are just full of this incredible creativity

0:31:26and enthusiasm and just engaged with life.

0:31:29And then sometimes it's, you know,

0:31:31really off-base stuff.

0:31:32And sometimes it's like, you know,

0:31:33these people are making a book or they have a business,

0:31:36they do whatever, but it's just, it's so much fun.

0:31:38- All right, I'm on your Twitter page, Glenn F with two N's.

0:31:43- That's me.

0:31:46- It says right now, just on your profile page,

0:31:51180,091 tweets.

0:31:56- Yeah, it's a little crazy, isn't it?

0:31:57I've been on for, you know,

0:31:58that's only 40,000 tweets a year or something.

0:32:01I talk to people though,

0:32:04Twitter is not optimized for @mentions,

0:32:06So I will get blocked on Twitter during active things going on, and 95% of what I'm tweeting

0:32:12is not, you know, quote unquote public.

0:32:14It starts with an @ sign, so only people following me and the other person see it.

0:32:18So I think of it as having a conversation, and Twitter counts that against you.

0:32:22So I'll be going back and forth with someone, you know, quasi-publicly, but nobody on my,

0:32:28none of my followers see it unless they happen to intersect with that other person.

0:32:31So for some people, I'm being very talky.

0:32:34You know, if you and I have a similar graph, then I'm very talky if we're going back

0:32:37and forth, but to everybody else, they don't see it at all unless they've got, you know,

0:32:40configured whatever.

0:32:42So it's weird.

0:32:43So in some ways, I'm really prolific.

0:32:44Other ways, it's like, well, this is my chat tool.

0:32:46This is my public chat thing.

0:32:49So, let me ask you this.

0:32:53With the magazine, the magazine is still completely funded by subscriptions.

0:32:58Is that correct?

0:32:59Yeah.

0:33:00- I think, well, let's see, I have to put a proviso in

0:33:03because we've started doing some work with Medium,

0:33:06Medium.com, because they are doing their own experiments

0:33:10with what people are gonna pay for for content

0:33:12or look at for content.

0:33:14So they're paying some publishers, including me,

0:33:16to develop some new content that appears

0:33:19exclusively there first.

0:33:20So it's not this wonderful giant pot of money

0:33:24they're throwing at me, but so some money for the magazine

0:33:27could ostensibly be said to be coming from the net

0:33:29after I pay writers for that,

0:33:32but it's a pretty tiny amount

0:33:34relative to the subscription revenue.

0:33:35There's no advertising in Medium,

0:33:37which is why it makes it a reasonable place to work with,

0:33:41where I don't have to change the model of what I'm doing

0:33:43or worry about people being irritated

0:33:45by having ads in one place or another.

0:33:47Sort of another publishing platform I'm trying out

0:33:49and they're subsidizing that, which is kinda cool.

0:33:53- Well, but if they don't have ads

0:33:54and they don't charge for access,

0:33:56then where are they ever gonna get money?

0:33:58How is it not just burning up a pile of venture capital?

0:34:02- Volume, of course.

0:34:04No, that's the change bank.

0:34:05Well, from what I can tell, it's funny,

0:34:08they don't play it too close to the vest.

0:34:09And I think Ava's talked about it in public a bit too,

0:34:13is they're experimenting now.

0:34:15I mean, this is kind of the Twitter model,

0:34:17is Twitter, what was it, five years

0:34:19before they ever started doing advertising

0:34:21or doing anything to do with money.

0:34:23And these are the same folks behind that, essentially.

0:34:28It's some of the same folks and they're funding it,

0:34:31I think, as a, hey, we don't know what's gonna happen next.

0:34:33Nobody does.

0:34:34This is the time to noodle

0:34:35and we're gonna blow some money on noodling,

0:34:37but they're trying to noodle

0:34:38on the high end of the spectrum,

0:34:41which is, you know, it's another one

0:34:41of those great for readers things,

0:34:43how it works out for publications and investors,

0:34:46you know, to be determined,

0:34:47but they're paying for content internally.

0:34:50I mean, they made a blogging platform.

0:34:51So this is the thing that's confusing right now

0:34:53is Medium used to be one thing when it launched.

0:34:55It was like a place where people who were invited

0:34:57could use a new, essentially blogging platform

0:35:00that has a really great editor, editing interface,

0:35:04to post essays and stuff, right?

0:35:06That was what it launched as.

0:35:07And you had to be invited, and it was a little rudimentary,

0:35:09but it was a very attractive way to write and read.

0:35:12Then it became, well, more people are being invited.

0:35:14Then it became anyone now can go sign up with Twitter,

0:35:17or via Twitter account, authenticate themselves,

0:35:20and post whatever they want in Medium.

0:35:22And so it's a blogging platform, right?

0:35:23And you can export all your stuff

0:35:25in a format you can bring somewhere else,

0:35:26but you know, you own your words,

0:35:28they have a non-exclusive license, no ads.

0:35:31But now it's expanded, as several months ago

0:35:33they started hiring editors and they have,

0:35:36they assign out articles.

0:35:38They hired my friend Matt Bors, editorial cartoonist,

0:35:41is their kind of on-staff guy,

0:35:44and he runs all his stuff first there,

0:35:45he's doing original work for them,

0:35:46and he's contracting people like Rich Stevens

0:35:49and Tom Tomorrow and so forth to do original

0:35:52and reprint work on the site.

0:35:54So now they're an editorial operation

0:35:55that's doing cartoons and long form journalism

0:35:58and other stuff and with editors.

0:35:59And then the third thing is what they're doing with me

0:36:02and a few other publications,

0:36:04where they're subsidizing content in the interest of us

0:36:07creating new high quality stuff that meets, you know,

0:36:10good stringent editorial requirements,

0:36:12but they don't have to pay for our editorial operations.

0:36:15They don't have to build them themselves.

0:36:16They're just paying us a fee and we're posting stuff

0:36:19and we're seeing what happens.

0:36:22So I think it's a great multi-tier experiment

0:36:24and they keep improving the editing experience.

0:36:27You, like I, have worked with a lot of

0:36:29content management systems or CMSs over the year,

0:36:32and they're all awful,

0:36:33and Medium is the best CMS I've ever worked with.

0:36:36It's not very flexible in that you're sort of like Apple.

0:36:39Like, Medium and Apple have a lot in common.

0:36:42You don't have a lot of choices,

0:36:43but the choices are generally good.

0:36:45If you don't like 'em, you're stuck,

0:36:47but you generally like 'em.

0:36:49So like, remember how Keynote, when it launched,

0:36:51there were very few things you could do in Keynote,

0:36:53But it was hard to make a bad presentation in Keynote,

0:36:55like a truly ugly PowerPoint presentation.

0:36:58The default setting in PowerPoint is ugly and bad.

0:37:00The default setting in Keynote is attractive and reasonable.

0:37:04It's still hard to communicate.

0:37:05You have to work in Keynote to communicate

0:37:07like you do anywhere.

0:37:08So Medium's default is very nicely presented,

0:37:11very straightforward, minimal formatting,

0:37:13and it's a delightful,

0:37:15distraction-free place to write as well.

0:37:17So as a writer, I don't like writing in crazy environments.

0:37:20I write in BB Edit, mostly.

0:37:22And Medium is the closest thing to writing

0:37:24and kind of a stripped down editor as you can get,

0:37:26but you can throw images in, you can do limited formatting.

0:37:28So that's kind of the thing is they've built

0:37:30a really great CMS in which the backend writing

0:37:34and administration is very, very, very close

0:37:37to what the front end is.

0:37:38Like when you switch from editing to publishing,

0:37:40the difference is really tiny and that's kind of awesome.

0:37:43It's very WYSIWYG and it's very direct

0:37:46and that is huge in its own self.

0:37:48And then they're trying all these models

0:37:49to see what gets people to read.

0:37:52And then I assume at some point, you know,

0:37:53they will figure out what it is.

0:37:55Do they put ads on like the decks

0:37:57that are really unobtrusive but effective,

0:37:59but don't feel like crazy banner advertising?

0:38:02Or do they go to a subscription model or do they,

0:38:04I don't know what they do, but I'm glad

0:38:06that they're pouring some real money in

0:38:08'cause newspapers aren't.

0:38:09None of the conventional journalism sources

0:38:12are really experimenting in this radical way

0:38:15with what the future of a reading experience is.

0:38:17I mean, this is almost a natural outgrowth

0:38:19of what Marco's ideas have been with Instapaper

0:38:21and with other Read It Later services about,

0:38:24you know, what do people wanna read online?

0:38:26They don't want cruft, they don't want nonsense,

0:38:27and Medium is that.

0:38:28It's no cruft, no ads, and very, very straightforward

0:38:31reading in every platform.

0:38:33- Right, and you're gonna lose, everybody's gonna lose

0:38:36if your idea is what does everybody wanna read online?

0:38:39What can we make that everybody is gonna wanna read?

0:38:42'Cause no, you're not gonna do it.

0:38:43And if you want to say, well, what is,

0:38:47Most, what are most people gonna wanna read?

0:38:49Well, then you're gonna end up

0:38:50with some crap like Buzzfeed, right?

0:38:52But what are, what is an untapped or under,

0:38:56underserved market for what some people want to read online?

0:39:03Right, and that's, you know, how about, you know, good stuff?

0:39:07- It's like, what would a New Yorker be like

0:39:09if the New Yorker didn't have its legacy

0:39:11but had the same quality of writing?

0:39:13I mean, I don't wanna promote Medium as being the New Yorker

0:39:16but they're more on that end of things,

0:39:19and people will pay, The New Yorker has not really ever

0:39:21been a very profitable publication.

0:39:23- Yeah, I've heard that.

0:39:24- Yeah, on its own it wasn't,

0:39:25and then Condé Nast has subsidized

0:39:27in different ways for years.

0:39:28I think it actually has made money for a while,

0:39:31partly because probably reducing expenses

0:39:33like everybody else, but The New Yorker is not

0:39:37like this great engine.

0:39:39Newspapers used to make 25 to 35% profit,

0:39:41we talked about it the last time I was on.

0:39:42I mean, these huge profit margins,

0:39:44The New Yorker has probably made 1% profit

0:39:46over its 100 or 90 years in existence.

0:39:50So that hearkens back to what I was saying in the beginning

0:39:52that like you don't do really great,

0:39:55most of the time really great journalism,

0:39:58really interesting stuff that you read

0:40:00is not massively profitable,

0:40:01but it should pay everyone involved.

0:40:03So the New Yorker may not return money to investors,

0:40:06but everyone involved in it gets that reporters

0:40:08get paid well, the staff, the editors.

0:40:11- What did you say?

0:40:11It's like the heritage of the New Yorker.

0:40:13what did you just say?

0:40:14The, the, the, the, something about like the, the, I forget how you said it, but it was

0:40:20perfect. It was the way that the New Yorker has such a great legacy. I don't know. What

0:40:24did you say?

0:40:25I don't even know. That's like, we need to go to the top.

0:40:28Something about how they build on that and that it exists, you know, and that they're,

0:40:31you know, the New Yorker still looks like the New Yorker.

0:40:34Oh yeah, yeah. And I mean, that's the thing is they are doing what they call digital replica

0:40:37publishing. And this, you know, this gets us into a different issue is what I know I'll

0:40:42back to the, you know, is the magazine, you know, so about 97 or 98% of the funding is,

0:40:48or of our, you know, net revenue is coming from subscriptions or it comes from some subscriptions.

0:40:53And there's, we're in a very interesting position. I bring up the New Yorker because,

0:40:59and this gets us into the whole newsstand, Apple newsstand thing, is that the New Yorker and a lot

0:41:07of other publications because of how newspaper and magazine auditing is done for circulation,

0:41:14they do a digital replica, which is the kind of Adobe or other bloated interface, right?

0:41:20And that's, again, that's what brought Marco into making the magazine.

0:41:22The first place was 780 megabyte downloads of The New Yorker for an issue on the iPad.

0:41:27And you're like, what?

0:41:28God's name needs 800 megabytes.

0:41:30But they have to produce something that's very similar in form to the print issue to

0:41:34get auditing, get the advertising.

0:41:35that's their model, even though they're selling subscriptions digital only.

0:41:38So, uh, in GigaOM a couple months ago,

0:41:41they put this report in which they showed some of the numbers from the audited

0:41:45circulation, the digital replica and print circulation of various publications,

0:41:50including, you know, the top ones, New Yorker and so forth.

0:41:53And it turns out they don't have very many subscriptions. I mean,

0:41:56the New Yorker,

0:41:56I think has a million print subscriptions and a hundred thousand digital only,

0:42:00you know, replica subscriptions. And that's not a lot. And you know,

0:42:04most of those probably don't come from the newsstand. They come from the New Yorkers

0:42:07website or they could come from another app.

0:42:09So...

0:42:10Yeah, mine do, yeah. Because I was already a print subscriber.

0:42:12Yeah, and you get a free, right, if you're a print subscriber, a lot of publications,

0:42:16you're not going to the newsstand to subscribe. So, Apple had started the newsstand conceivably

0:42:20as a way to take some of the really huge amounts of money spent on periodicals, bring it in

0:42:25house there, take their 30% cut, and save the periodical industry because they were

0:42:31are going to make it easy for people to subscribe,

0:42:34lost subscribers would come back,

0:42:36marketing would be cheaper and it would be worth 30%

0:42:38because Apple was handling all of this

0:42:41and it was a much stickier experience and blah, blah, blah.

0:42:43And that's obviously turned out not to be true.

0:42:45I think it's clear that Apple is not the savior

0:42:47of the book industry or the periodical industry

0:42:50and it's led to sort of where they are today with Newsstand.

0:42:55The magazine is actually one of the more popular

0:42:58publications and we shouldn't be on Newsstand.

0:43:00And we show up in the top grossing list,

0:43:03sometimes very close to the top.

0:43:04And we should not, if the other publications were doing

0:43:07as well as they should in selling on Newsstand

0:43:10as their primary place for their digital subscriptions

0:43:13to be purchased.

0:43:14- I still think, and I think this is one of those like,

0:43:18sort of, it's meta analysis,

0:43:21but I think it's sort of underrepresented,

0:43:24is on the day the original iPad was introduced

0:43:28at that event.

0:43:29And it kind of garnered a, at least in some quarters,

0:43:35especially in the more mainstream.

0:43:37I think that, you know, I certainly got it.

0:43:39I really was impressed by the original iPad.

0:43:43And I think a lot of other tech sort of public,

0:43:48or at least like the people who get what Apple does

0:43:51were very impressed right off the bat.

0:43:52But the collective response in the mainstream media

0:43:56was a sort of meh.

0:43:58It's just a big eye for you.

0:44:00But a big part of that was definitely

0:44:04because leading up to the announcement,

0:44:08when everybody knew it was gonna be a tablet, right?

0:44:10There was, you know, for months in advance,

0:44:12there was Apple's working on a tablet.

0:44:13They're working on a tablet.

0:44:14And then the day, you know, before the event,

0:44:16everybody knew or thought they knew.

0:44:19Everybody was pretty darn sure

0:44:20that what this event was for was for this tablet.

0:44:24They were gonna introduce a tablet.

0:44:27But part of that was that it was also widely predicted that the tablet was going to save

0:44:35the publishing industry, save the newspaper and magazine issue.

0:44:39It was going to do for newspapers and magazines what the iPod did for music.

0:44:45And I know that in hindsight, lots and lots of music executives still say they still think

0:44:49that they would have been better off without it because the revenues are still lower than

0:44:54they were at the peak of the CD era.

0:44:57But that, you know, I think rational analysis will tell you that the CD era was an anomaly

0:45:03because they, you know, right up until Napster, they were charging people 17, $18 for a hit

0:45:10CD and people were buying them just to get like the two songs that they wanted on it.

0:45:14Oh, well, there's also CDs were repurchasing.

0:45:17Oh, yes, yes, yes, yes.

0:45:18So you had that bubble when people, all the scratchy LPs were thrown out and they're like,

0:45:22I'm getting this.

0:45:23You know for me, you know, like I'm young enough there where my original music collection was cassette tapes

0:45:28And I bought rebought a lot of stuff on CD. Yes

0:45:30You know, I remember you know for me and this is totally true I remember thinking this you know when I was in college a

0:45:40significant

0:45:42Part of my net worth was my CDs and I didn't have a huge CD collection. I had I don't know maybe I

0:45:49I don't know, 100 to 200.

0:45:51I would just estimate I had somewhere between 100 and 200 compact discs.

0:45:55But you could resell them, right?

0:45:57You could – there were – there was a huge thing in the '90s where you go to a used

0:46:01CD shop.

0:46:02Yeah.

0:46:03And you could resell – you could sell them for roughly 10 bucks, give or take, depending

0:46:09on what it was, 5 to 10 bucks if it was in good shape.

0:46:12So if I had 100 CDs, I could, if I needed the money, I could go and sell them and walk

0:46:20out of the store with like $1,000, $1,500, right?

0:46:23And that was actually a huge amount of my net worth.

0:46:25I had a checking account that my parents occasionally put some money into.

0:46:32I had a MAC LC that by the time I was in my third or fourth year of college, had greatly

0:46:42appreciated and valued. And I had my CDs, you know? And I had a stereo system to play

0:46:48them on. That's really all I had that if I really needed money, that's all I had to sell.

0:46:54But the thing that was probably worth the most by the time I graduated were the CDs,

0:46:59which is crazy if you think about it. There's no rational world. In a rational world, a

0:47:0322-year-old who likes to listen to music shouldn't have to have $2,000, $3,000 tied up in their

0:47:08music collection. It's ridiculous. But that's what they wanted to go back to. Anyway, music

0:47:13executives today will argue, some will argue that Apple, that if it hadn't been for those

0:47:18jerks at Apple, they'd have somehow come up with something that would have kept the golden

0:47:21era going. But I think rational people would agree Apple did save them from a world where

0:47:26everything had gone free.

0:47:28And this is what we're seeing with cable TV too, is like the cable industry, the thing

0:47:32that freaks them out the most is unbundling because nobody wants all those channels. Nobody

0:47:35wants to pay $80 for 500 channels, they want to pay $20, $30 for like seven channels they

0:47:41watch all the time.

0:47:42Right. But anyway, there was this undercurrent. And I mean, it was literally, there were people

0:47:45talking about it before they let us into the event. I was there, the other press people

0:47:50then that was a widely talked about this. What are they going to do? I wonder if our

0:47:55people who worked for newspapers and stuff were wondering, is my paper going to get involved

0:48:00with this, whatever. And when the event came and finished without any kind of announcement

0:48:05of anything like it. No mention of newspaper. I guess they had the New York Times app was

0:48:11demoed at the event.

0:48:12Darrell Bock But they were like, "Wait, it's an app, though.

0:48:15It's not a thing."

0:48:16Like, it's not a –

0:48:17Ben Stuart And I think that fueled the mad response to

0:48:20the iPad, because these, you know, from people who work at these publications who were hoping

0:48:24that Apple – they kind of went into it with this perspective of, "How's Apple going

0:48:28to save my publication? I'm worried about my job." And the event came and went with

0:48:33no word about it.

0:48:37I think it fueled that initial poor response to the iPad because they were so…and it's

0:48:43only natural if you're worried about the future of your own job and your own industry.

0:48:51It still is the case today if you're somebody who's…especially if you're a little bit

0:48:55older and already established and you thought even just a few years ago that you had a career

0:49:03for the rest of your working years,

0:49:04it's not just that you're worried

0:49:07that your publication's gonna go under

0:49:09and you'll have to go to some other publication.

0:49:11The worry is that if the industry shrivels,

0:49:14there won't be anybody else to go to.

0:49:16- Yeah, it's not irrational because there's,

0:49:19I mean, this is the problem, the disruption problem

0:49:21is when you have these huge changes in the economy.

0:49:24In the past, I would say pre-digital,

0:49:27there was still the issue of moving atoms around.

0:49:29So even if you figured out a new way

0:49:31make an atomic thing better.

0:49:33Like this process shaves 80% of the cost off.

0:49:36People were still used to paying the same.

0:49:38Like you didn't suck all of the money out of the system.

0:49:41What usually you did is you sucked some of the money

0:49:44into a new segment of industry or new companies.

0:49:46The old ones might collapse and you'd have bankruptcies

0:49:49and stuff like that, but all the money didn't go away.

0:49:52The publishing industry disruption is that

0:49:55because I think bad decisions and bad ways of thinking

0:49:59the 1990s that everything should be, this is that misreading of Stewart Brand, I hear it all the

0:50:04time, is Stewart Brand said, "Information wants to be free." He was not, this is that Libris versus

0:50:09Libra, or Gratis or Libra versus Freedom of Thought, right? He meant--

0:50:14Pete L

0:50:14He's meant-

0:50:15- Frias and beer versus frias and freedom.

0:50:18- Yeah, and so his statement,

0:50:19if you read it more carefully in context,

0:50:22was that you should be able to have accessed information,

0:50:25not that you shouldn't pay for it.

0:50:27I mean, of course he was advocating more availability

0:50:30of information at no cost,

0:50:33but also the availability of information in general.

0:50:36And he was a publisher, he sold information.

0:50:38He wasn't giving it away.

0:50:39So I don't know why this infected things,

0:50:43And I don't think it was people buying into it.

0:50:44I think the publishing industry simply did not understand

0:50:47the internet and thought it was a fad

0:50:48because they'd gone through video text and whatever,

0:50:51you know, executives going through generation.

0:50:53Yeah, like all these things are like,

0:50:55ah, the internet is a lot more people,

0:50:57but it's ultimately, there's no money there.

0:50:58No one's gonna care and it's gonna come and go.

0:51:00So we'll put some time money into it.

0:51:02There were people with a lot of forethought,

0:51:03like Ken Doctor, who was at, I think he was at Night Ritter.

0:51:05He wrote this book called "Newsonomics" a few years ago.

0:51:08He was one of the voices in the wilderness,

0:51:10did some smart things, but I think,

0:51:12I didn't want to say he was advocating paywalls in the 1990s.

0:51:14You know, it was, and it's not that we should all be paying

0:51:17for all the journalism out there.

0:51:19As a publisher who has a publication where I want you to pay,

0:51:21I understand there are different philosophies

0:51:23and ads can support some of it.

0:51:25But like 95% of the money from advertising

0:51:28locked up in these quasi-local monopoly publishing,

0:51:31and you know, in some national publishing markets

0:51:33where the only venue where advertisers could reach people

0:51:37in print were through these very specific ways

0:51:39that had extremely high inflated high profit methods.

0:51:43That got sucked totally out

0:51:45and it wasn't replaced with much, right?

0:51:47Online advertising is a huge industry,

0:51:49but it's so dispersed, it's so spread so thin

0:51:52that even though it's many,

0:51:54like tens of billions of dollars a year now,

0:51:56it didn't go back to the previous high market gatekeepers,

0:52:00but advertisers have found much more efficiency, right?

0:52:02So the efficiency and the disbursement,

0:52:05the distribution of people's attention

0:52:08at the same time, just sucked so much money out.

0:52:11There's no clear path for how to fund

0:52:15what was funded for, you know, 100 plus years.

0:52:17Like that journalism can't exist in the same form

0:52:19because the advertising money just simply

0:52:22isn't coming back at that intensity per reader.

0:52:27And the subscription model is still developing

0:52:30whether people are willing to pay enough.

0:52:31And I'm an, the magazine is an ongoing experiment.

0:52:34I don't think of it as a successful business.

0:52:36I'll be honest, it is a very interesting thing for me to do as an entrepreneur, but I think

0:52:40of it as an ongoing experiment in how people read and what they're willing to pay for,

0:52:45and I feel like I'm on the front lines of the cutting edge of understanding that, because

0:52:50we're trying to do something very independent that's new, that's very much of the internet

0:52:56born digital, and yet we're looking to this old model of pay us something so you can read

0:53:00it.

0:53:01Well, and this ties, this relates right back to what we were talking about earlier in the

0:53:07show where, you know, let's call it clickbait, right?

0:53:10It's just empty garbage that has no lasting value but generates lots of traffic.

0:53:20You know, effectively, you know, newspapers and magazines aren't, you know, even historically,

0:53:29they're not innocent of that.

0:53:30always some fluff right there's you know I like comics I love I used to love the

0:53:35comics I used when I was a daily newspaper reader love the comics page

0:53:38but let's face it it's not serious it's not what when people talk about

0:53:42newspapers as serious institutions you know the comics page is not it you know

0:53:48the New York Times famously you know does not have a comics page you know

0:53:54there's the society pages you know a lot of newspapers have gossip columns stuff

0:53:59like that. The thing is, because it was all bundled and you had to buy either

0:54:06you were a subscriber who got the whole thing every day or you bought a single

0:54:10copy every day, you bought the whole thing. And so the fact that expensive

0:54:15investigative journalism, something where you put a team of two reporters to

0:54:20investigate whether the mayor's office has been taking illegal contributions

0:54:25from, you know, a construction company. You know, the sort of thing that local newspapers are really

0:54:31the only institution that can uncover that sort of thing. The sports scores for the high schools. I

0:54:36mean, that was a huge reason that people read newspapers at one point. Right. Right. And so,

0:54:42you know, there might be a lot more people who check the scores on the sports page than who read

0:54:49the, you know, the City Hall reporters daily filings but, you know, it was, you

0:54:58know, it was all of a bundle and it wasn't, it didn't matter if that City

0:55:02Hall reporting cost more than, you know, paying an intern to type the high

0:55:09school basketball scores as they came in. You know, it was just considered part of

0:55:13the institution whereas now with this page view model where you can see what's

0:55:17making the money, it just, it corrupts the whole thing and steers the institution in the direction

0:55:24of where the page views are coming from.

0:55:27Right, and everything becomes vertical in this market, right? Is that you have the incredibly

0:55:31crass page view acquiring like lowest common denominator, puree and stuff, is all one vertical.

0:55:36It's all business insider for business news, it's all Huffington Post for sort of political gossip,

0:55:42it's all buzzfeed for just nonsense, right? Or you know, or even the I Can Ask Hamburger,

0:55:47or I Can Ask Hamburger, which has never, was never intended to pretend to be news or anything like

0:55:52that. There are all these verticals for that kind of low common denominator that used to help

0:55:58justify or buoy up the profits. And then there's a vertical for comics, right? There are different

0:56:06comic sites, you have all these web comics artists, many of them making part or even a

0:56:11very good living. It's a huge range of people there who they would previously have to be

0:56:15in a paper and syndicated and most of the money would go to the newspaper and the syndicate.

0:56:19They make it directly, right? So you have them too. Then you have this investigative

0:56:24part, like the features part, the investigative part, the sports part, all verticals. The

0:56:28trouble is the long form and investigative part doesn't really pay. Like, you can't…

0:56:34So Paul Carr just sold or sort of quasi-acquired moved NSFW Corp, his publication, into Pando

0:56:44Daily.

0:56:45And like, you know, we all have, you and I, and we all have different feelings about Pando

0:56:47Daily and it's kind of in bed with its investors in terms of like writing about companies that

0:56:52funded it and whatever.

0:56:53So there's, that's a whole thing.

0:56:55But NSFW Corp, I subscribe to, is a very interesting and good publication and it was essentially

0:57:00the investigative arm of a newspaper or magazine.

0:57:04they ran these really long super in-depth features

0:57:07and they paid people fairly well for it, they had a staff.

0:57:10They ran through a million dollars and they could not,

0:57:12I think they had several thousand subscribers by the end,

0:57:16which is nothing in terms of being able

0:57:17to produce the revenue you need

0:57:19for the investors investing in it.

0:57:21So it doesn't say that you can't,

0:57:23and you know what I'm doing,

0:57:23I still have a modest number of subscribers,

0:57:25what I'm doing is sustainable and I'm trying to branch out

0:57:28into different publishing methods

0:57:29as I feel like the newsstand is not being as viable

0:57:32it was, trying to do books and other things, but it's that in the past each part would subsidize

0:57:39the other. And maybe you would do this incredible investigative piece and, you know, like Newsweek,

0:57:44or no, Time, didn't Time have the cover story by Stephen Brill about medical bills?

0:57:48Pete: Yes.

0:57:48Pete; Yeah. So, Time could have sold, I don't know if this is true or not, but Time could

0:57:52actually have sold a million copies on the newsstand more because this was a big, you know,

0:57:56this is, that kind of thing that gets that much buzz actually used to drive newsstand sales.

0:58:02They go back to the presses, they would print more copies.

0:58:05So you could come out with a great newspaper story or a great magazine story and actually recoup some of the expense sometimes by selling more copies.

0:58:13And there's just none of that now.

0:58:15A million, 10 million extra page views might be tens of thousands of dollars.

0:58:20It's not hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars.

0:58:22So there's a mismatch now between what used to all be grouped as like one publication

0:58:28and all these different verticals, each of which may not be sustainable separately, and

0:58:33maybe they have to get squeezed back together.

0:58:35And that's why I say like BuzzFeed has the high end, the features and stuff they're

0:58:39doing, and the lowbrow, which is the, you know, the billion page view things.

0:58:43They seem to be trying to tie those back together, to glue them together, to make both ends work.

0:58:48Let's come back to that. I wanted to ask you a few questions about the new standard magazine.

0:58:55Speaking of which, I'm going to take a break here and do an ad read, but I also absolutely, I must do an F.U.

0:59:02I must do a follow-up from last week's show with Moltz where I was talking about Apple's bunny suit ad,

0:59:10the one where they torched the Intel guy in a bunny suit, and I said it was for the G5.

0:59:16It's not. John Siracusa very politely corrected me. It was that was from the G3 PowerMax.

0:59:26The which were so far so old I'll put that I put a link to the ad in the show notes but it was

0:59:32actually when Apple was still building beige boxes. It was from 1998. So I guess the candy

0:59:40colored IMAX route but the equivalent industrial design PowerMax weren't yet.

0:59:48It's a really old ad.

0:59:51Had what's his name, Dreyfus was the narrator.

0:59:57Let me take a break and tell you about another great return sponsor to the show, our friends

1:00:04at Igloo.

1:00:06igloo you'll remember this they give you an internet that you'll actually like

1:00:12you can share content quickly with built-in apps they've got blogs

1:00:16calendars file sharing forums Twitter like micro blogs wikis right so if

1:00:23you've ever thought wouldn't it be great if we had like our group our team our

1:00:26company if we had our own little private Twitter something where we could just

1:00:30post things like links and little short things but keep it private it's just for

1:00:34us. Igloo can give you that. Everything is social. You can

1:00:39comment on any type of any type of comment in that thing,

1:00:43comment on calendar items, comment on files that are

1:00:45uploaded. You can add mention each other, you know, your

1:00:50co workers and colleagues. And you can follow content for

1:00:54updates and use tags to group things the way you work. So you

1:00:59You can tag an event and a file and have them grouped together by that tag even though they're

1:01:07different discrete items.

1:01:11You can add rooms like little mini igloos.

1:01:14So if you're in a bigger organization, you can have a primary igloo for the whole organization

1:01:21or company and mini igloos for each of the teams that they can work in.

1:01:25It's very easy.

1:01:26thing is drag and drop and it features responsive design so everything looks great on the phone,

1:01:33on tablets, on 30-inch cinema displays.

1:01:38It looks good too.

1:01:39They've got beautiful fonts from Typekit.

1:01:41You've got the Adobe Type Library right at your fingerprints for customizing and designing.

1:01:46They have enterprise-grade security.

1:01:47You can start using it right away.

1:01:49This is the best thing.

1:01:50I love this.

1:01:51This is such a great...

1:01:52This is the thing about Igloo that I think is fueling their success, is their pricing

1:01:57model.

1:01:58It's free for use with up to 10 people.

1:02:01When your Igloo grows, then you pay $12 a person each month.

1:02:04For big companies, they charge money per person.

1:02:08Even if you're a huge organization, you can try it for free.

1:02:12Just install it, try it.

1:02:14Use it with up to 10 people to see if it's going to suit your needs, if it's as good

1:02:18as I'm telling you that it really is, for free.

1:02:22You don't need to get permission.

1:02:23There's nothing, no kind of credit card you have to put on file to get started.

1:02:27Just sign up, use it for free, and when you see how good it is, then you can start paying.

1:02:32Where do you go to find out more?

1:02:33Easy.

1:02:34Go to igloosoftware.com/thetalkshow, and that'll let you know you came from this show.

1:02:42Igloosoftware.com/thetalkshow.

1:02:44So, let's try to figure out what the hell is going on with Newsstand.

1:02:51I have some ideas.

1:02:55So, I guess effectively Newsstand is what a lot of people, in terms of a goal, it's

1:03:02what I think everybody was hoping for the first day the iPad was announced, which is

1:03:09here's our, meaning Apple's, solution to how publishers can take advantage of

1:03:18this platform iOS and the iTunes store where people are spending money. Right? I

1:03:27mean that's the goal. It's Apple's solution to publishers who want to make money

1:03:31from iOS users. Yeah and they special cased it. I mean that's kind of the

1:03:38programmer's explanation, right?

1:03:39Is they said, okay, you know, you still have to make an app.

1:03:42We're not making a delivery format for you.

1:03:44We're not like a Kindle where you make a Moby file.

1:03:47- Or we're not like iBooks where you make,

1:03:50you know, an EPUB file, right?

1:03:52- Yeah, we're more sophisticated.

1:03:54Like we want you to take advantage of this platform.

1:03:56And that was, you know, I think publishers were like,

1:03:58okay, you know, you're giving us a showcase

1:04:00and we have to invest in this anyway.

1:04:02We don't want to just publish EPUBs.

1:04:04It doesn't give us control.

1:04:05We want to do new things.

1:04:06So it seemed like a reasonable deal.

1:04:07And they were like, okay, I mean,

1:04:09I think the initial deal was, and you know,

1:04:11you linked to Marco Karpinen's essay a few months ago,

1:04:15middle of October in iOS 7, the final straw for newsstand.

1:04:18And he runs it down.

1:04:19So I won't repeat everything 'cause you should read,

1:04:21that's a great article everyone should read.

1:04:23I took it to heart.

1:04:24But there were like seven, he lists this off,

1:04:26let's do seven unique behaviors that publishers were given

1:04:30in the newsstand initially.

1:04:31And one of them was you could change the cover of every issue.

1:04:34You know, you can update your screen captures on iTunes

1:04:36every issue, not just with new dot releases of an app.

1:04:39You had a special place, you know,

1:04:40you could download the background.

1:04:42There were all these things that you could do

1:04:45that were publication-oriented and like,

1:04:47so that people using an iPad or iPhone

1:04:50would look at the newsstand.

1:04:52The newsstand was always front and center, right?

1:04:54You could move the fake folder somewhere,

1:04:56but you couldn't hide it inside another folder.

1:04:58And it showed little tiny, tiny, tiny icons,

1:05:00which in retina are not too bad, of the publication.

1:05:03And the covers would change,

1:05:04so you'd know if it had an issue.

1:05:05had background downloads.

1:05:07- Yeah, all this stuff.

1:05:08- So that you could, you know,

1:05:09if your publication was relatively big,

1:05:11I mean, 'cause nothing's worse.

1:05:13Like, let's say, you know, whatever the reason,

1:05:15let's not say whether it's a good idea or bad,

1:05:16but if each issue is 100 megabytes,

1:05:19which is not that uncommon for some publications,

1:05:22and if it's really truly photographic heavy,

1:05:26maybe it has to be, but either way,

1:05:28nothing is worse than saying,

1:05:29"Hey, I wanna read the new copy of National Geographic,"

1:05:32and you tap the thing and it says, "Wait for download."

1:05:35And if you're out and about out of the house, not on WiFi,

1:05:39you know, you may not even be able to get it.

1:05:41Or if you do, you might risk going over, you know,

1:05:44your data limit.

1:05:45- So yeah, I think my suspicion is--

1:05:47- So they had this thing,

1:05:48so if you could download in the background,

1:05:50that was a huge win.

1:05:52And the only way you could do it

1:05:53was to be in Newsstand for a while, or till Iowa 7.

1:05:56- That's right.

1:05:57So I mean, I, you know, based on the way

1:05:58that Apple was talking to book publishers ahead of time,

1:06:00it's clear they talked to tons of periodical publishers,

1:06:02got them started, made sure that people,

1:06:04their magazines were on board,

1:06:06and they told them the 30% cut thing, I'm sure,

1:06:08but there were plenty of stuff available for the iPad

1:06:11pretty quickly from major magazines and newspapers.

1:06:15And I'm sure they listened, Apple does listen.

1:06:18Some people think Apple does not listen

1:06:21to its customers or partners, and it listens.

1:06:23It's just sort of like, you pray to God,

1:06:25he doesn't always say yes, right?

1:06:26He's always listening, that's the theory.

1:06:28So you pray to Apple and Apple doesn't always say yes,

1:06:30But the newsstand looked to me like it was a bunch of things

1:06:34where they had actually listened, consulted,

1:06:36and come up with something

1:06:38that was intended to benefit both sides.

1:06:41And my take is that it clearly has not worked out for Apple

1:06:45and publishers have clearly not walked away from it,

1:06:49but walked back from it in a way

1:06:51that Apple is not getting the kind of return

1:06:54it wants from it because Apple has not,

1:06:56I would say, improved the newsstand.

1:06:58It's made its utility as a specific destination worse

1:07:02in Iowa 7, it's particularly bad, it's sort of ignored.

1:07:05It's kind of like, let's just forget about it.

1:07:07- And it's widely complained about.

1:07:09I see it on Twitter, I see it in my email

1:07:11from Daring Fireball readers,

1:07:12widely complained about that, you know,

1:07:15is something that you can't hide, you know,

1:07:17that there's an awful lot of people

1:07:19who don't have anything in their newsstand.

1:07:23and just, and, you know, I don't wanna say

1:07:28obsessive compulsive, but just, you know, fussy enough.

1:07:31You know, there's nothing wrong with that,

1:07:33being fussy and wanting to have

1:07:34your home screens arranged just so, right?

1:07:37That's sort of the mindset that attracts people to iOS

1:07:40in the first place, that you care about details.

1:07:43So yeah, I've got at the end, you know,

1:07:45my first two home screens are organized

1:07:47just the way I want them, and then pretty much screens

1:07:49two through whatever, or three through for whatever,

1:07:52are just a junk drawer of apps that I search for

1:07:55if I need them.

1:07:56But I can totally understand the mindset

1:07:58of someone who just wants one or two screens

1:08:01of just the things they use

1:08:02and wants them organized just so.

1:08:04And it just bothers these people

1:08:06that you can't get rid of that newsstand icon, right?

1:08:09I see more people talking about,

1:08:11"I wish I could get rid of newsstand completely

1:08:13"than talking about anything that's actually in newsstand,"

1:08:16which is a problem, right?

1:08:17- And that's the change.

1:08:18I mean, iOS 7, so part of it is

1:08:20you can hide the newsstand icon now.

1:08:21You can't throw it away, you can't delete it

1:08:23like a lot of the ups.

1:08:24But iOS 7 is, the new stand was de-emphasized in importance.

1:08:28You can put it inside another folder,

1:08:30you no longer see the tiny, tiny icons,

1:08:32which have more of a cue for people than I realize,

1:08:34based on what I hear from readers,

1:08:36they forget because they don't see the tiny icon changes.

1:08:39The brain is an amazing thing.

1:08:41If you subscribe to publications and in iOS 6,

1:08:45every time you fire it up, it's on your home screen

1:08:47or maybe your second screen, but you look and you go,

1:08:49oh, that's different, your brain knows.

1:08:51and even though you can't even make out the detail

1:08:53at 100 pixels tall, you know it's different

1:08:57and you tap it or there's a blue dot or whatever.

1:08:59I mean, there's some indication.

1:09:00Iowa 7, that's gone.

1:09:02So people interested are telling me

1:09:04they don't even notice the issue's changed.

1:09:05I mean, I send out Iowa 7 notifications

1:09:07as do other publications, but I'm only every other week.

1:09:10People lose sight of it.

1:09:12And then you can hide it entirely, which is everyone's,

1:09:14which is fine.

1:09:15Some people wanna do that.

1:09:16Apple wanted them to do that.

1:09:17But it also is that thing of like

1:09:20de-emphasizing its importance to Apple,

1:09:22the fact that you can hide it is a user request

1:09:24and it's great they're doing it

1:09:25because people who don't wanna use it can hide it now,

1:09:27but it also shows that it's not important enough to Apple

1:09:29to irritate people by making it stay on a home screen.

1:09:32- Right, so it's sort of like the converse,

1:09:34like it's a problematic design on both ends

1:09:37because if you don't use it,

1:09:39you know, you have to do something to get rid of it

1:09:41and now they've added a feature where you can't.

1:09:43But then if you do, like if say the magazine

1:09:46is one of your favorite apps

1:09:48or if you read the New York Times app,

1:09:51which is a newsstand app, every day,

1:09:52if that's how you start your day every day

1:09:54is reading the New York Times app,

1:09:55you can't put that app icon on your home screen

1:10:00or in your dock.

1:10:02It has to be.

1:10:03It's permanently, it's enforced that it's one level deep.

1:10:08And it's even worse, in my opinion, on iOS,

1:10:11because it's such a flat, conceptually,

1:10:16the design is so flat.

1:10:18Like it's really and it's one of the strengths. I think it's one of the reasons iOS has proven to be so popular

1:10:23with the general public is

1:10:25That there is no hierarchy by default

1:10:29Right, or I guess there is I guess they do actually put a folder in there's like you I think they changed at some point

1:10:35When now there is at least one folder like in a brand new factory fresh

1:10:39iOS install but it's certainly de-emphasized and and you know

1:10:44I think that's a strength of iOS because I think hierarchy is a huge problem.

1:10:49Even one level of hierarchy is a huge problem for most people, because if they don't see it, it's not there.

1:10:54Yeah, it's right. Out of sight, out of mind is true, and people's attention is very scarce.

1:10:59They have a lot of things they can do, and once you start routinely forgetting about something

1:11:03and not being reminded about it, then it's an issue. Now, you know, I understand, so I should

1:11:08point out, like this, I don't want to sound like I'm bitching and moaning about like, "Oh, people

1:11:11aren't subscribing to my publication, cry for me. It's more like I know we're doing good work. I

1:11:16know I write for The Economist, I write for other publications, the people contributing are doing

1:11:20good, or you know, write for other publications that people think of as having a high degree of

1:11:25quality. I know what we're doing is good work and it's always frustrating when you're doing good

1:11:29work and you feel like you can't get an audience. That is a marketing issue that is separate and

1:11:33that's my own problem, right? But when I feel like the people who, so there's a difference

1:11:39who I can't find and don't care about the magazine or unsubscribe because they've lost interest in the content.

1:11:44That is one category, right? The category that I'm having a problem with is the people who actually like the magazine, tell me they like it, and they're emailing me to say, "You know, I'm unsubscribing because I forget it exists because in Iowa 7."

1:11:57Isn't that a frustrating problem? So, bottom line, let's just spell it out. Bottom line, if you could flip a switch and turn the magazine from a newsstand app to a non-newsstand app, you would flip that switch.

1:12:08Totally totally and that's the thing and I don't think a lot of people know this

1:12:12You can't and I'll make that's not to say you forever and ever you won't be able to but as it stands today

1:12:17You can't there is no thing you can go to in iTunes connect and say take that

1:12:23You know my app the magazine which is now a new stand app and make it a regular app even though

1:12:29All the things that you get from new stand you could do

1:12:34You know like background downloads and stuff like yeah

1:12:37There's there's a little bit of recoding us sorry because there's a couple things that are used in the newsstand as I recollect that you have

1:12:42To you and clean the background download. There's a different method which I think I can use now to Marco

1:12:47I was just blogging about this. I mean Marco said the same thing

1:12:49He wrote a blog post at Marco org and said if I was doing it today

1:12:52I wouldn't put it in the newsstand and he's and he's right

1:12:55I don't fault him for it because it made perfect sense at the time of course and it got a lot of attention

1:13:00being in the newsstand, but Marco Karpinen,

1:13:03he wrote in his entry too, he's like,

1:13:05"They are a platform," his firm,

1:13:07"and they are not recommending using the newsstand."

1:13:09And I believe that I could actually reformulate the app,

1:13:13resubmit it, but I would lose 100% of the subscribers.

1:13:17Apple does not let you transfer the subscribers.

1:13:20So, I mean, the ideal case for me is that

1:13:22they would let users choose, not enforce this on users,

1:13:26They would let users choose to break open the newsstand

1:13:31and say either don't use the newsstand,

1:13:35put all the apps on my home screens

1:13:37or let me drag stuff out of the newsstand

1:13:39but still give me the ability to change covers.

1:13:41That's the ideal thing is give me the,

1:13:44I mean, Apple wanted to give publishers and users

1:13:47that sense of timeliness, that this is something new,

1:13:50the cover changes, that was part of the design

1:13:53and it's part of the one that I think

1:13:54a really appealing part of the design,

1:13:56even though, outside of me and The Loop

1:13:58and a few other people, a lot of publishers

1:14:00just take their newsstand subscription,

1:14:01again because of this digital replica issue,

1:14:04and they slap it on there with type

1:14:06that's in negative one point size.

1:14:07So that's a very appealing thing,

1:14:10being able to show a new color.

1:14:12- But think about this.

1:14:13I think even the name newsstand itself

1:14:17shows that the metaphor's a bit broken, right?

1:14:19So newsstand is where you go to--

1:14:21- It's skeuomorphic.

1:14:22- Right, but no, but think about it.

1:14:23what is the newsstand?

1:14:24The newsstand is where you go and choose

1:14:27from a whole bunch of things.

1:14:29And most of the stuff on the newsstand

1:14:30is stuff that you've never read.

1:14:33When you go to a real life newsstand,

1:14:34how many of the magazines are ones

1:14:36that you've never even looked at a copy of?

1:14:39Most of them, right?

1:14:40And there's everything from celebrity gossip,

1:14:43to sports, to world affairs.

1:14:46A newsstand is something like the store, right?

1:14:52The newsstand metaphor should be something in iTunes, where you go to pick a magazine

1:15:00to read, not a place where your magazines, the ones that you've chosen to subscribe

1:15:06to show up.

1:15:08In the real world, when you subscribe to two magazines and a daily newspaper, you don't

1:15:13go to the newsstand to get them.

1:15:15They come to your house.

1:15:17They're right there.

1:15:19The magazine is stuffed right through the mail slot in your door.

1:15:21It should be called "The Latest" or "News" or "My Subscriptions" or something like that.

1:15:27You're right, the terminology is exactly that.

1:15:29Right.

1:15:29I will say the most fascinating thing about the newsstand when you go to the iTunes to see what they're listing there is apparently there's a lot of market for scantily clad tattooed women in tattoo magazines.

1:15:41I had no idea.

1:15:42The number, the sheer quantity of different titles in that market that show up among the top grossing newsstand titles is fascinating.

1:15:50I guess it's like buying romance novels. Like, guys wanna buy tattoo mags because now they're

1:15:55hidden away. The other advantage though is they don't show up on your screen. So if you're trying

1:15:58to buy magazines you're embarrassed about now, they show up in the newsstand and the cover is

1:16:02hidden. So that's the little brown cover for the newsstand.

1:16:05AC/BS But I just think that in some ways the metaphor, you really just think about it. When

1:16:11you subscribe to a magazine, a real paper magazine, they do the most convenient thing that they can

1:16:18possibly think to do, which is we will just mail it to you.

1:16:23We'll just put it in the mail, and it will show up,

1:16:25a US postal carrier will literally put it through a slot

1:16:30in the door of your house, and it'll just be there for you.

1:16:33And newspapers do something just ever so slightly

1:16:36less convenient, but you tell a newspaper,

1:16:38here, take my money and give me a copy

1:16:41of your paper newspaper every day.

1:16:43They say, okay, we'll take it from here,

1:16:45and every day, right outside your front door

1:16:48in the morning, there will be, there it'll be.

1:16:50Just walk right out your front door

1:16:52and there's your newspaper.

1:16:53- It's on your front porch, which is your home screen,

1:16:56right, is that your metaphor?

1:16:57- Right, well they're just making it

1:16:58the most convenient thing possible.

1:17:00And it's, they're not bothering you.

1:17:03These are people, you know, this is what you've asked for.

1:17:05This is only after you've given them money

1:17:07and said, do this, drop this off every day.

1:17:09Obviously, if you didn't want the newspaper

1:17:11and if you, you know, like I live in an urban area

1:17:14and there's local newspapers that, you know,

1:17:16that'll stuff your front door with newspapers you didn't ask for. But that's a different

1:17:22case. I'm saying with these subscriptions through the iTunes store, they should make

1:17:25it as convenient as possible, which to me is exactly what you said. Let it – you can

1:17:30put it right on your home screen or even on your dock, the icons that you see no matter

1:17:35which home screen you're on.

1:17:36And I really think that that just wasn't thought through and that the name itself,

1:17:41really shows just how poorly thought through the metaphor is.

1:17:46- It's, yeah, I mean, it made sense at the time though.

1:17:50It's like every time Apple, 'cause it was a browsing thing.

1:17:52When it started, it wasn't,

1:17:54it wasn't here's the stuff you wanna read.

1:17:56It was like, here's your portal

1:17:58to the App Store listing of publications,

1:18:01and then stuff will show up here.

1:18:03And now it's, you know, now it's something else.

1:18:06This ties back to my contention based on the looking

1:18:10looking at where I know where I am,

1:18:11'cause I know my numbers

1:18:12and I can look at the top grossing lists in iTunes

1:18:16for the iPhone and iPad and I can see where I sit

1:18:18and I can look at those numbers

1:18:20from the audited digital replica versions

1:18:23that people are only subscribing to the digital version.

1:18:25And I can say, as we were talking about earlier,

1:18:27that people are subscribing through a website

1:18:29or the print subscribers can get web stuff for free,

1:18:32typically, and that's not counted

1:18:34in the digital only subscriptions and the audited returns.

1:18:37But I can see people are probably

1:18:38subscribing through the website.

1:18:39The Economist is probably not selling

1:18:41most of its subscriptions through Newsstand.

1:18:43They're selling them mostly through economist.com

1:18:45and people have multimodal access and Android and whatever.

1:18:48So I guess what that says to me is that

1:18:51Apple didn't provide maybe a compelling enough front end

1:18:55and as they've lost interest in it,

1:18:56they've backed off more and more because Apple,

1:18:59I always say this, you know, Apple eats its babies

1:19:01and you may find that abhorrent

1:19:03or you may find it wonderful.

1:19:04It works out really well

1:19:05if it's something you don't care about

1:19:06and they focus their attention more on stuff that works.

1:19:09it can be irritating if it's something that you like

1:19:12and you're like, oh, why haven't you made iPhoto

1:19:15actually good after this many years?

1:19:17Like why have you lost interest in that Apple

1:19:20and they don't make money off it

1:19:21or it's not important to their core direction anymore.

1:19:23Newsstand, in Iowa 7 showed to me that it's,

1:19:27for the moment, they're pushing it off to the side,

1:19:30they're not getting rid of it because what most publishers

1:19:31are doing is they're making free apps

1:19:33and the money for that app is coming

1:19:35from outside Apple's system.

1:19:36So Apple gets no benefit except in the desirability

1:19:40of their platform for people downloading

1:19:43and using the New York Times or New Yorker

1:19:46or People or whatever app there is.

1:19:48Those apps do not generate any return.

1:19:51I mean, this one's a no return,

1:19:52but those do not generate a substantial return for Apple,

1:19:55probably in the way they conceived of it.

1:19:57- Not enough to garner their attention.

1:19:59- Yeah, it's an adjunct.

1:20:00The apps are an adjunct to the entire magazine presence

1:20:03for a magazine as opposed to the newsstand

1:20:06the central point through which people then maybe go out and read on the web too, but

1:20:10they come in through that way. And you know, that's life. So I'm not, you know, I hate to sound like

1:20:15I'm bitching about like, like I'm not whining that Apple's lost focus on this. I'm more like, well,

1:20:19damn, this, I thought it kind of worked okay. And it's not. So I mean, this is part of why I'm going

1:20:25into all these different directions too. I've got a lot of different things going on.

1:20:27Because—

1:20:27But it's also true too that you're not asking a lot of Apple, right? Now, so that, that vague

1:20:33idea that I talked about back in 2010 when a lot of people in newspapers and magazines

1:20:40kind of had this vague notion that Apple is going to unveil some sort of boil the ocean

1:20:44save the publishing industry thing was sort of thinking you know Apple is going to do

1:20:49a lot of work and come up with something you know ingenious that's going to you know pump

1:20:54infusal you know re-infuse money into this industry. That's hoping that Apple does a

1:20:59lot. What we're talking about here is just a relatively minor

1:21:05amount of attention to what's going on in newsstand. Whether it would be putting

1:21:10the work in to allow a newsstand app to go non newsstand and keep it

1:21:16subscribers or something like a setting in iOS that would allow a user to say

1:21:24you know, use Newsstand for Newsstand apps. And then you talk, you know, on/off. And if you turn

1:21:31it off, then it would say, you know, a little explanatory text, "Newsstand apps will appear

1:21:36at the root level of your home screen." Pete: Exactly. And this is, you know,

1:21:39I hear from readers, and again, I don't mean to sound, this is like, I'm not extolling what I do.

1:21:45And you know, it's funny because I always feel like the magazine is something I inherited,

1:21:48like Marco was my rich old uncle, and you know, I mean, this is a cash deal, right? We know this

1:21:52is a buyout and so forth, but I didn't make the app and I love the app. And so when I

1:21:56talked about it with great affection, I'm talking about Marco's work and I sort of forget

1:22:00I own it sometimes. I don't think of myself as an app developer. But I do hear from, I

1:22:05hear from readers regularly who say, you know, I don't really buy into the newsstand. The

1:22:08only periodical app that I have that I really use is the magazine. I don't want the newsstand

1:22:12icon. Can I just drag it out? And I'm like, well, if you crack it, you can. So it's, and

1:22:17I hear, but I also hear that I'll see people talking on Twitter about, God damn it, I only

1:22:21use the New York Times, I only use whatever. Why can't I just have that? And so the option

1:22:26is now either hide your entire newsstand folder in a subfolder, which then you have to nest

1:22:32into to bring up or double tap to double press to find it if you used it recently. Or, you

1:22:38know, I figured out this workaround, this stupid workaround, I have a redirect. So you

1:22:42can go to a web page at my site, I put it in the FAQ even, you bookmark the web page,

1:22:46It's got an icon that you can make as a web app

1:22:49on your home screen.

1:22:51So you mark it as a bookmark on your home screen,

1:22:53and then when you tap it, it loads the webpage,

1:22:55does the redirect to the app, and it launches the app.

1:22:57It's stupid, but it works.

1:22:58It gives you an icon on your screen

1:23:00that when you tap it, it launches the app.

1:23:02And a number of people are like, oh, thanks for doing that.

1:23:03But you know, it's like 75 people did that or something,

1:23:06but I wanted to let people do it.

1:23:08But it's that, at some level, it's that easy.

1:23:10I realize in Apple's infrastructure,

1:23:12allowing us to, as a new stand apps to come out

1:23:17and like be a regular app.

1:23:19And even if they disabled the cover change feature,

1:23:21maybe that's not an option.

1:23:22Like I'm sure there's some ugly plumbing there.

1:23:24- They would definitely make the apps, if they did that,

1:23:29whether you'd get to change it every issue or not,

1:23:31I don't know, but you'd have to conform to that shape,

1:23:33that round square shape.

1:23:35- Yeah, something would be, yeah, exactly.

1:23:37Something would be different 'cause they wouldn't,

1:23:38Johnny Ives is not gonna allow that on the screen,

1:23:41like a bunch of different shapes.

1:23:42not after all the changes they made.

1:23:44So I completely appreciate and understand that.

1:23:48And it's not like Apple's trying to do anything to anybody,

1:23:52me or the New York Times.

1:23:54It's more like they didn't crack this nut.

1:23:57And they're so good at cracking a lot of nuts.

1:23:58And this one, they didn't crack.

1:24:00And so they've kind of put it aside

1:24:02and maybe they'll come back to it later

1:24:04in the seventh cycle.

1:24:05- Another thing that's occurred to me in this, again,

1:24:07is not asking a lot of Apple would be,

1:24:09perhaps the best idea would be just abandon the newsstand.

1:24:12Just do an iOS 7.2, or I don't know,

1:24:17we're already in,

1:24:20- Yeah, it could be works.

1:24:22- We're already in December, so maybe it's an iOS 8 thing.

1:24:24But just get rid of it, and that's an Apple-like thing to do

1:24:27don't even announce it, when they get rid of things,

1:24:30they don't talk about it because it's sort of tacitly

1:24:32acknowledging a mistake, just get rid of it,

1:24:35and when you upgrade to iOS 7.2 or to iOS 8,

1:24:39your newsstand apps are just on your home screen.

1:24:41- Yeah, well, I'll tell you the other thing

1:24:42that's interesting, of course--

1:24:43- Or if you're an existing user,

1:24:44or if you're an existing user,

1:24:46newsstand just becomes a normal folder.

1:24:49If you've got an existing installation

1:24:51and then you can open it up and drag them out

1:24:53and drag them back in.

1:24:54So that it's still organized the way it was

1:24:56before you upgraded, so there's no disorientation

1:24:58of where is what happened to my icon.

1:25:01But just turn it, just turn newsstand into a normal folder.

1:25:04- Yeah, I mean, newsstand is the other thing

1:25:05which drives people nuts, which is you can't tap on it

1:25:08to get it to zoom out like you can with any folder.

1:25:11So you, when you're in Newsstand,

1:25:14even if you get there by a circuitous route,

1:25:17like you exit, you know, you tap while you're in

1:25:19a Newsstand app, you can't tap on the background

1:25:22and exit the folder and go back up a level,

1:25:23which I've seen so many people tweet about how,

1:25:26it breaks the metaphor.

1:25:28But okay, so here's the thing that Newsstand

1:25:30has taught me though, or I should say

1:25:31running a subscription publication has taught me

1:25:33that's separate from Newsstand, but sort of tied in is,

1:25:37It's very interesting after having spent

1:25:40like the last 10 years on sort of writing with blogs

1:25:44or daily sites or sites that update all the time,

1:25:48having a cycle like this and dealing with subscribers

1:25:52who get fatigued.

1:25:54Like I know people get tired of reading a given site,

1:25:56but it's fascinating to get email from

1:25:58and talk to people who say they kind of ran out of steam.

1:26:00And even when they say, I really like what you're publishing

1:26:04I just don't have the time to keep up with it.

1:26:05I'm like, we're doing five articles that are 1500

1:26:09or 2500 words every two weeks.

1:26:11And I'm like, really?

1:26:12Like, and I'm a bad example

1:26:13because I have very little time to read

1:26:15now that I'm an editor.

1:26:16I'm spending all my time editing, working with writers.

1:26:18But there's definitely reader fatigue you get.

1:26:21And that's kind of where the one-two punch is that

1:26:25Apple sort of de-emphasizing Newsstand

1:26:27makes it a little bit harder to keep existing subscribers,

1:26:31makes it a little bit harder to get new ones

1:26:34to deal with the churn.

1:26:35'cause there's always gonna be churn.

1:26:36And so it makes the equation a little bit more difficult

1:26:39for me, especially as an independent publisher,

1:26:41because I don't have a website

1:26:43that people are used to going to,

1:26:44even though you can go to the-magazine.org

1:26:47and you can get a subscription there,

1:26:48you can read all the articles there.

1:26:49It's a full website, has been for nine months

1:26:53and people mostly don't realize that,

1:26:54which is fascinating to me.

1:26:55But we don't have like a website

1:26:57that people are used to going to

1:26:58and this is the iOS adjunct or alternative,

1:27:02where for every other publication just about,

1:27:04They have a website which is where the traffic's at

1:27:07and this is an upgrade from the mobile version

1:27:09of their site.

1:27:10The app is a better thing to read in.

1:27:11So that's been an interesting thing to wrestle with too.

1:27:14And I mean that's why I launched the Kickstarter

1:27:15is we're doing a book because I need a different modality.

1:27:19I can't have everything be resting on subscriptions

1:27:21because subscriptions, especially 95% of it

1:27:24being an Apple site, I have probably 5% of subscribers

1:27:27coming from the web.

1:27:29So I need to rejigger things so that all the revenue

1:27:32and in one pot to make the engine go.

1:27:35- I was working towards the Kickstarter.

1:27:37I wasn't gonna let it slip.

1:27:38- Oh, I know, no, but it's funny.

1:27:39- You've always, you've wanted a Kickstarter.

1:27:42You had a, what was your Kickstarter before?

1:27:44You had a Kickstarter that didn't get off the ground.

1:27:47- I had an ontological Kickstarter.

1:27:49It was a Kickstarter campaign to write a book

1:27:53about how to run a Kickstarter campaign.

1:27:55- Right.

1:27:57- And the special irony is it didn't fund.

1:27:58But what happened is I kinda did everything wrong.

1:28:01I thought I'd studied Kickstarter enough. I'd been writing about it for a couple years.

1:28:04It's a good thing then, because then your book would have been wrong.

1:28:08Oh, that's right. Yeah, if I'd funded it, I don't know what I would have said in the book. But

1:28:13everything good that I'm doing in my life came out of its failure, which is, you know, that's my

1:28:16lemonade stand, is like lemons of a veil thing. It's like 10 days into the Kickstarter, I'm like,

1:28:21"Oh, I did this all wrong. People gave me advice. I should have asked more ahead of time." It had

1:28:25funded about 10%, and I'm like, "It's not gonna fund." So, I just canceled it instead of having

1:28:29the ignominy of hitting the end and not reaching the goal and launched the new Disruptors and went

1:28:34to the XOXO Festival in September 2012, launched the podcast in December of last year, joined Marco

1:28:41at the magazine in October of last year and feel like I now, I haven't learned all the secrets,

1:28:48but now I really have a better sense of what makes sense to crowdfund, I think. And I think this will

1:28:55be successful. Like we're almost halfway there. - Here's the deal. It's called The

1:28:59The magazine, the book, which of course is the obvious title.

1:29:03- How did that? - How did it not be?

1:29:04So, and in parentheses, year one.

1:29:06So it's the, pretty much it's the best

1:29:08of the first year of the magazine.

1:29:10And you want to do it both as a print and ebook collection.

1:29:15- Yeah, that was the thing is I thought it didn't,

1:29:17you know, it could do an ebook very easily, right?

1:29:19That doesn't take a lot of time and effort.

1:29:21And it wouldn't actually, it could be well-designed,

1:29:24but you wouldn't get the full benefit

1:29:25because I'd be thinking mostly about people

1:29:28reading an EPUB, say, or Moby on a Kindle.

1:29:30So it'd be relatively simplified.

1:29:32So I thought, you know, we should put a stick in the sand.

1:29:34Like we're electronic periodical.

1:29:37Why don't we do a hardcover book

1:29:38that's designed like a magazine?

1:29:40So we have the magazine style of design

1:29:44that we don't even do in the app

1:29:45because the app is meant for simple reading.

1:29:47We're gonna take advantage of the print medium

1:29:49and then we'll produce a PDF, an EPUB,

1:29:50and a Moby version of it as well, all without DRM.

1:29:54None of that goddamn DRM.

1:29:55You can read it wherever you want to.

1:29:58Put it on every device you own, every computer.

1:30:01But yeah, I want to do a hardcover book

1:30:03so that it'd be something special.

1:30:04And there'd be a reason people would be motivated

1:30:07to be part of the Kickstarter,

1:30:08'cause there was a reason for it.

1:30:09It wasn't like, hey, I can't afford to make an ebook.

1:30:12It's like printing costs a lot of money.

1:30:13So I need to pull together people to make it happen.

1:30:17- When did you announce this?

1:30:18It was recent?

1:30:21- Yeah, it was just before Thanksgiving.

1:30:22The timing's a little off.

1:30:23- I was hoping to do it early to be done before Thanksgiving

1:30:26and then everything always takes longer.

1:30:27- Oh, I know that.

1:30:28- You know this feeling.

1:30:29So I went again this year.

1:30:30So it launched on, I don't remember the exact date,

1:30:34I don't know what date it was.

1:30:35It was two, it was a couple weeks ago.

1:30:37It was on November 21st, I think.

1:30:41The same day that I put out issue number 30 of the magazine.

1:30:44So we're past a year in the magazine.

1:30:46- We got a $48,000 goal.

1:30:48- Yeah.

1:30:49- Right now, as we record, it is at 22,555.

1:30:53just a hair under 50%. But it was a big push at first, and I thought, just watching it,

1:30:59like the first 24 hours, I thought it was going gangbusters. I still think you're gonna make it.

1:31:03I think I am. The odds are good. The thing that's interesting, and so some Kickstarters,

1:31:07there's like three typical Kickstarter profiles, like graphs. One is the, "Oh my god," and it goes

1:31:13like, like a straight line up until the end. And that's like--

1:31:16- Somebody asked for $100,000 to make a,

1:31:20like the watch to turn your iPod,

1:31:24your little square nano into a watch

1:31:25and they ask for 100 grand and within three days,

1:31:28they have 2 million.

1:31:29- Yeah, and those build on themselves

1:31:31because there's something appealing,

1:31:32it's usually consumer products,

1:31:34something super appealing about it,

1:31:35or it's like a Veronica Mars where there's an enormous,

1:31:38they have an audience of tens of millions of people

1:31:40and a tiny fraction of that audience

1:31:42is constantly discovering it and spreading it and coming on.

1:31:45So you have this kind of straight line up,

1:31:47or maybe it curves up and then tapers off

1:31:49to like a straight line up.

1:31:50So that's one kind.

1:31:51One is this, one is like the,

1:31:54does kind of badly, badly, badly,

1:31:55and then suddenly they pull it off

1:31:57and it goes boom to the top near the end.

1:31:58They get a whole bunch of people.

1:31:59Mine is the, apparently,

1:32:01and I've heard this now since it launched,

1:32:03I've seen it before, is actually much more typical,

1:32:05is really huge first day or two,

1:32:07then you have a nice gentle climb as you go along,

1:32:10you cross 50% and then a nice huge spike at the end

1:32:14the last couple days. And that's what, and so the statistics—

1:32:18Jared: That third one is that this is why daddy drinks curve.

1:32:21[Laughter]

1:32:21Pete: Exactly. I know, that's, and you're like, so in my case, 48 grand, we raised $16,000 in 24

1:32:27hours. Boom! And at 24 hours, it immediately tapered off because people saw like, oh, it's

1:32:32gonna happen. We hit 33%, they're fine. I mean, literally, at that moment, 24 hours, it went to

1:32:37that slower taper. And then so, in, you know, in the first day, it was 16 grand, the next 10 days,

1:32:42or next 14 days, I'm sorry, has been,

1:32:45or 13 days has been about six or $7,000,

1:32:48which is much slower.

1:32:50I have so many people are like,

1:32:51"Oh, I'm gonna come in, just remind me before it's over."

1:32:53I'm like, "All right, all right."

1:32:54- You had a stat, you tweeted the other day

1:32:56that was something like, it was like the percentage,

1:32:59once you hit 50%, your odds are pretty good.

1:33:02It was like 90% or something?

1:33:03- Yeah, people have done this great crunching

1:33:05and there's these charts you can look at

1:33:06like for different projects of different values.

1:33:09So for zero to $50,000 is one range

1:33:12or whatever.

1:33:13So you can look at this thing and you can say,

1:33:14"Okay, where am I at?"

1:33:16And once you hit, the sweet spot is,

1:33:20once you've got half of your goal,

1:33:22so for me that's $24,000 to $48,000,

1:33:25and you're a $50,000 less project,

1:33:27statistically once you reach half the goal,

1:33:30you are 97% likely, or 97% of projects

1:33:33that reach half the goal go on to at least fund 100%,

1:33:37if not more.

1:33:38So that's a great stat.

1:33:40The thing about Kickstarter that's fascinating

1:33:41is it's a 56% failure.

1:33:4656% of projects do not fund.

1:33:49But of those 56%, about a third get no pledges at all.

1:33:54Somebody posts it and they do not tell anyone about it,

1:33:57no one even does it.

1:33:58Another third of the failed ones

1:34:00get like less than 20% of the funding.

1:34:02So there's this very narrow band

1:34:03where people get between 20 to 50% of the funding

1:34:06and they can't get all the way there.

1:34:08But once you hit that sort of magic middle point,

1:34:10it shows enough momentum that it's just a question

1:34:14of time and that curve.

1:34:15Most Kickstarter projects, the average project

1:34:17when you take out the outliers like Pebble or Glyph

1:34:20or the ones that super fund, Elevation Doc,

1:34:23most fund at about 105% to 110% of the goal

1:34:28because people come and they meet it

1:34:29and they meet it at the end.

1:34:30They're like, "Oh, they need, I'll raise my pledge

1:34:32$10 to make it happen," or whatever.

1:34:35So it's a, I don't wanna say it's a finely tuned art,

1:34:37but I'm feeling happy about it.

1:34:39you know, so I should come back. The reason I did it though is like, I like the stories we tell,

1:34:43right? This is the whole thing. Like it's, this isn't a money-making endeavor in the sense that-

1:34:46I was about to say, cause you kind of, I was going to come back to that. You kind of hinted at that

1:34:50a few minutes ago where you somehow, you know, were bringing it up as a money-making event.

1:34:54I was going to, I was going to tell you, you know, that's not that it's a bad idea to do this.

1:34:58I think it's a great idea. I think looking at it as a money-making idea is not a good idea.

1:35:03Oh yeah. No, I mean the diversification of the magazine from being only a subscription-based

1:35:07periodical to being something that produces content in lots of different ways. That's

1:35:12the money making idea. That's the I need revenue. I want newsstand now is 95, 92% of the revenue

1:35:18that comes in is directly from Apple with their 30% cut. And I'd like that to be 25

1:35:23to 30% in a year.

1:35:24All right. Can I just put on my consulting ad here?

1:35:27Yeah, absolutely.

1:35:28For free. I'm not going to charge you any more.

1:35:30Oh, good. Excellent. Excellent.

1:35:31All right. But I am going to tell you how to make more money from the magazine.

1:35:34Oh, good. Excellent. I want to hear this.

1:35:36What you do is you sell one sponsorship slot per issue.

1:35:41And there's a nice one full page ad

1:35:45from that issue's sponsor.

1:35:48Boom, there you go.

1:35:49That would have cost like $50,000 in consulting fees

1:35:54if you had to come on my show.

1:35:56- I appreciate that.

1:35:57- Have you, I mean, surely you've thought

1:35:59about putting advertising in the magazine.

1:36:02- Yeah, I don't have an objection.

1:36:04- So I guess I have a structural objection

1:36:06as opposed to say an ethical one.

1:36:08So there's a mission thing,

1:36:09which is that it's been sold as something that has no ads.

1:36:11And so if it changes-

1:36:13- Has it though?

1:36:14Is that really true?

1:36:15- It has, oh yeah, from day one,

1:36:16Marcos pushed that out, I pushed that out as the idea

1:36:18is there's no cruft and there's no ads.

1:36:21- Well, I don't know.

1:36:22I think you could renege on that.

1:36:24- Well, no, I absolutely could,

1:36:25but it takes, there's a threshold to overcome

1:36:27to say like, okay, we said that

1:36:29and now we're doing this other thing, all you subscribers.

1:36:31So I'm not conscientiously opposed to advertising if it works, and especially that kind of model.

1:36:37The sponsorship model, like this is why I like the podcasting model, is that yes, you

1:36:42have ads on a podcast, but it's much more in the mode of this cooperative thing.

1:36:47It doesn't feel like advertising the same way that horrible flashy banner ads feel like.

1:36:50Right?

1:36:51And I really think that the listening experience bears that out, where when you listen to terrestrial

1:36:57radio, even on FM, it does seem to me like there's too many ad breaks.

1:37:03And when you listen to AM radio, if you ever listen to like, just, you know, like just

1:37:06for shits and giggles, like listen to the Rush Limbaugh show, there are so many ad breaks,

1:37:11it is ridiculous.

1:37:13The only show that I know of that doesn't have that problem is the Howard Stern show,

1:37:17which does far fewer breaks, but does really long breaks, like where they put all the ads

1:37:22into one stretch in the hour.

1:37:26and people listen to podcast ads

1:37:28because they don't feel like ads.

1:37:30And so I could see doing, I love how that works

1:37:33and people respond to it.

1:37:35So having a sponsor for the magazine

1:37:37where it's like one quality thing,

1:37:39it's like this is a roadblock

1:37:40and so-and-so is sponsoring this issue.

1:37:42Here's an advertisement and we're gonna send you one email

1:37:45or God knows what we're gonna do.

1:37:46That doesn't seem antithetical.

1:37:48The problem I have structurally though

1:37:49is that subscribers are worth a ton of money

1:37:52as a subscriber in advertising,

1:37:54typically to reach the audience of the scale that I have,

1:37:58there's not enough money in the ad side

1:38:00to make that worthwhile.

1:38:01- See, I think the problem is convincing advertisers

1:38:05that it's not like buying an ad in another magazine.

1:38:09- Well, that's exactly it.

1:38:10Well, I did the math.

1:38:11If you go to, I put this up at my website,

1:38:14it's glog.glennf.com.

1:38:16I did the math a few weeks ago

1:38:18'cause people kept asking me about why I don't have ads

1:38:21in the magazine.

1:38:22I said, if it was the conventional model,

1:38:24I would probably need as many as 20 million page views

1:38:26a month to equal--

1:38:28- No, I'm not saying your math is wrong.

1:38:29I'm saying, nope, that's not--

1:38:31- But I mean, that's right.

1:38:32Oh yeah, exactly.

1:38:33I've got like, we've done a lot of articles.

1:38:35We have 150 articles.

1:38:36I'm not gonna get, there's no universe

1:38:37in which I can do that, right, to get 20 million.

1:38:40So right, so with the current rates that are paid,

1:38:43with the yield, with selling inventory,

1:38:45and that doesn't even include,

1:38:46you know, includes commissions to ad people,

1:38:48but that doesn't include me having an ad staff.

1:38:49I have to outsource it.

1:38:51So I need 20 million page reviews, let's say roughly,

1:38:53to reach what I'm getting from subscribers paying.

1:38:56That's really hard, but one sponsor who is a supplement

1:39:00to who makes the thing possible,

1:39:02that's the extra revenue necessary to make the thing grow

1:39:04or whatever, that's a different equation.

1:39:06Someone might be willing to pay a sizable amount of money

1:39:09to be exclusive and to reach them people in a tasteful way.

1:39:12And that's again, the podcast model,

1:39:14that's why it's valuable here

1:39:15and it could be valuable there.

1:39:16- But let me do my third sponsor.

1:39:19And it's again, an old friend of the show,

1:39:23long time sponsor and event apart. An event apart is an intensely educational two day

1:39:30learning session, a great conference for people who make websites. And instead of being like

1:39:38a once a year thing where you have to put on your schedule, book travel and stuff like

1:39:42that, they effectively come to you. They've got events next year in 2014 around North

1:39:49America there in San Francisco that's this month Atlanta Seattle Boston San

1:39:56Diego Washington DC and I think that's just like the first half of the year you

1:40:05know almost a monthly event go to their website find an event near you and you

1:40:11will not be disappointed now an event apart was founded by Eric Meyer who I

1:40:17I think easily you could say knows more about CSS than anybody walking the face of the earth.

1:40:22And Jeffrey Zeldman, longtime friend of the show and one of the great proponents

1:40:29of web standards and the whole thing is dedicated to the proposition that the creators

1:40:34of great web experiences deserve a great learning experience.

1:40:38These guys have one of the best speaker lineups of any conference I've ever seen.

1:40:42If you build websites and you've not been to an event apart, you're really missing out.

1:40:48If you have been to an event apart, you don't even have to listen to me because you know

1:40:51how good it was and I'm sure you want to go back.

1:40:53I've said it before too, they even have great swag, even just the stuff they give you, the

1:40:58bad name badges.

1:41:01Last time I was at one, they got a custom version of Field Notes, just a great conference.

1:41:07Where do you go to find out more?

1:41:09Go to aneventapart.com/talkshow.

1:41:15Know the, just /talkshow.

1:41:17They'll know you came from the show.

1:41:20I cannot recommend this conference highly enough.

1:41:22Go there, check the schedule, find one coming near you and you will not be disappointed.

1:41:31This has been an obsession of mine.

1:41:34It's not like a side obsession.

1:41:35I mean, it really is.

1:41:36I'm I run a business or two businesses if you count the show is a separate thing where it's you know

1:41:42It's part of that. I mean I make my income I support my family on advertising, right?

1:41:47But I've been obsessed with it all the way from before what I was doing was successful

1:41:52you know before I knew whether it could work, but you know, I

1:41:56I'm obsessed with it and I think it's so interesting

1:41:59There's that I don't know

1:42:00I mean who knows if Einstein even came up with it but that that quote that the definition of insanity is doing the same thing

1:42:05over and over again and expecting a different result. And that's the thing that drives me

1:42:09nuts about the print as print publications move to the web and lose money is they still

1:42:16keep trying to sell ads in a way that they've shown over and over and over again don't support

1:42:24the publication. And why keep doing that? And it just seems and maybe I'm underestimating

1:42:33how long it takes for a new medium to settle into our society, you know, and that to me

1:42:38the web is this old thing and it's established and it's, you know, clearly here to stay.

1:42:44Whereas, you know, what is it really? How old is it really? What, like 17 years old,

1:42:5018 years old? And not in terms of when the first website wound up, but when like Netscape

1:42:54appeared, you know, 1995, 96. Maybe, you know, TV 16, 17 years after the first TV sets were

1:43:01sold still didn't know how to do advertising the right way. I don't know. But it's just

1:43:06as frustrating to me because it's just crazy that they just keep doing it the same way.

1:43:11And it's eventually you figure out what it is you have to sell. And what did print publications

1:43:16have to sell? They could sell space on paper, including an entire page at a time.

1:43:21Daishi They were monopoly. They were the only efficient

1:43:23way to reach the audience in a locality or national level and advertisers knew that.

1:43:28But what was the actual format? What they had to sell was space on printed pages, right? And it's

1:43:34still what they have. What does TV have to sell? They have time, right? They can sell the whole

1:43:39screen at a time, 30 seconds, you know, the fact that it, you know, we ended up with these 30

1:43:45second spots instead of, you know, 60 second spots or whatever, it doesn't really matter.

1:43:50But what they're selling is time, that's the same thing radio had.

1:43:57And what do they have in the web? And the web, I think, has spent its entire time trying

1:44:03to replicate the print idea that you're selling space on a page. And it's a disaster, right?

1:44:16And it's just never made sense to me. Because what can you do in a magazine? I've said this

1:44:20before. I know I've said this on the show before. But every magazine I read, what's

1:44:26What's on the front?

1:44:27A cover.

1:44:28And what's on the cover is something that's obviously supposed to capture your interest

1:44:30or intrigue you in some way.

1:44:31And what's on the back?

1:44:32What's on the back is a full-page ad.

1:44:35Right?

1:44:36Right.

1:44:37And the better the magazine, the better the ad usually.

1:44:39Yeah.

1:44:40Right?

1:44:41It's usually something from, you know, here's the new issue of The New Yorker just showed

1:44:44up at my house today.

1:44:45It's an ad for Breguet.

1:44:46Breguet?

1:44:47I don't know how to pronounce it.

1:44:48It's a watch company?

1:44:49Yeah.

1:44:50Exactly.

1:44:51Swiss watches or Apple or a Ryan fashion thing?

1:44:53Right.

1:44:54on the back of the New Yorker I would I I would guess that this is probably like a 10 or

1:44:59$15,000 watch right?

1:45:02Yeah, or Cadillac or BMW or something like that?

1:45:05And what do you get in the first few pages of the magazine you get full page ads two page spreads these valuable things

1:45:11Is it a is it inconvenient to you as the magazine reader?

1:45:15No, because you know and a lot of the magazines there are things that I like

1:45:19I don't I'm not gonna buy that $15,000 rich watch, but I like looking at it

1:45:22I like to see that no, I like to look at the ad and see what the hell does it

1:45:26$15,000 wish ones look like

1:45:28And if I don't if I'm not interested at all in the ad it's a second to flip past it to the next page

1:45:35The web it just doesn't work like that and all they do

1:45:38Traditionally is sell these little two inch by three inch or long things and they just booger up

1:45:44The web page like the back of the magazine right like the last few pages where they'll yeah

1:45:49"Yeah, we'll take your 50 bucks and put a little ad alongside the article."

1:45:55There is no thing that's the equivalent of a full-page ad on the web.

1:45:59So just get over it.

1:46:00What do you really have?

1:46:01What are we down to?

1:46:02The thing that the web and the internet in general has to sell is attention.

1:46:08And the only way to sort of make that attention, to sell it in a premium way, is to sell less

1:46:14of it.

1:46:15- Yes, but it means that you have to be producing something

1:46:18of such high quality that people have to discriminate.

1:46:20I mean, it's a socioeconomic thing in part,

1:46:23is that the New Yorker can sell its ads for a lot of money

1:46:26because its demographics are so good,

1:46:28and the advertisers have seen that that watch ad in the back

1:46:32sells millions of dollars of watches or whatever,

1:46:34it's selling hundreds of thousands of dollars of watches,

1:46:36or it's part of an overall high-end branding campaign

1:46:39that lets the watch be sold for $15,000

1:46:42because it appears on the back of the New Yorker.

1:46:45They get the cache of that too.

1:46:47But it's, I think sites reveal way too much

1:46:51about themselves.

1:46:52Like you go to sites, I don't even wanna pinpoint it,

1:46:55but like sites you would formally think of

1:46:57as in the real world, they were terrific publications

1:47:00with integrity and they're running remainder ads

1:47:02that I know are bringing them in 50 cents or less

1:47:05per thousand views.

1:47:06They're running these things at the bottom

1:47:08that show these terrible, read these other articles

1:47:10that are spam or they're selling, you know,

1:47:13some kind of Juju Berry thing or whatever.

1:47:15And I'm like, where does that get you

1:47:18that you made that extra, you know,

1:47:2010th of a cent on that page?

1:47:21It doesn't get you anywhere.

1:47:22- I don't know. - That's what it comes to.

1:47:24- But, so there's one point that I wanna make though,

1:47:26which is that the Kickstarter,

1:47:28so I'm actually using the Kickstarter

1:47:30in what I think is the right way

1:47:32for someone like me to use a Kickstarter,

1:47:34which is probably most Kickstarters,

1:47:35which is the $48,000, it's funny,

1:47:38I mean, you know, I don't wanna,

1:47:40I'm not trying to reveal my own salary,

1:47:41But like the magazine is, it does well and I pay the writers well, but it's not how I make my living.

1:47:45It's part of it. You know, it's still kind of a startup. It's an experiment and I love it.

1:47:50But I make my living from a variety of things and I put most of my time in the magazine, but it's not where, you know, where I'm making my living from entirely.

1:47:56So it's not like this isn't a disclaimer about like pledge 48 grand and I get 40,000 of it.

1:48:02but I'm really using the Kickstarter the way

1:48:05that is very useful when you really just need some capital

1:48:08and you wanna give people a incentive to do it

1:48:12because they like what you're doing,

1:48:13but also you're giving them,

1:48:15the reward is actually the thing you're making

1:48:17as a result of raising the money.

1:48:18So the book, you buy a book in the Kickstarter,

1:48:21you get a book, that's great.

1:48:22But I had a threshold to hit.

1:48:24So 48 grand, that was in all my budgeting,

1:48:26that gets me more copies to print, of course,

1:48:29than I'm gonna fulfill.

1:48:30I don't wind up with really any money at the end.

1:48:32there's a little bit of margin of error.

1:48:33- You end up with a garage full of books.

1:48:35- Yeah, exactly.

1:48:36Well, I've got a printer, so it's great.

1:48:37So the goal is really, I wanna sell about 1500 books,

1:48:40roughly, reaches the goal.

1:48:42And 1500 hardcover books.

1:48:44And it could be some mix, you know,

1:48:45a lot of people could buy ebooks

1:48:46or buy some of the higher level rewards, that's fine.

1:48:48But roughly 1500 books,

1:48:49I'm gonna print about 2000 books.

1:48:51So I don't make really any money.

1:48:53All the writers get paid again,

1:48:54they get reprint fees, the designer, the printer,

1:48:56everybody gets paid.

1:48:57And I wind up with books, that's the outcome.

1:48:59And then I have to sell,

1:49:00I can sell any number of ebooks after it's done

1:49:02and 100% of the cost has been paid for.

1:49:04And I can sell, say 500 print books

1:49:07or even do another run if those sell over the next year.

1:49:09And that's where it actually benefits the bottom line

1:49:12is the Kickstarter helps me come up with a capital

1:49:15that's very high to do this right

1:49:17and to do something that I think is worth

1:49:19people's time and attention.

1:49:20And then my reward for myself personally

1:49:22is I have more stuff I can sell that's been paid for

1:49:25in the process of producing this thing for them

1:49:28as the result.

1:49:29- That sounds good. - That's my math at least.

1:49:30- All right, I can't let this close though

1:49:33without talking about these,

1:49:35to me, very creepy high-end pledge levels.

1:49:40Now there's two things here.

1:49:41You got four of these.

1:49:42You've got a $5,000 pledge level.

1:49:44You get a Lex Friedman visit and he comes

1:49:46and gives you a shave and I don't know,

1:49:51speaks in front of a group or something.

1:49:53- He gets into a snuggie with you

1:49:54and shows you Sutra positions from his book.

1:49:56- Chris Higgins, same deal, five grand.

1:49:59He'll visit you anywhere in continental US and again with the continental US

1:50:02What you know if I if somebody lived in Hawaii, I know that it's a you know more of a flight

1:50:08But hey Hawaii is beautiful. It's true. I can see I can negotiate I can see an escape, you know clause for Alaska

1:50:15We can negotiate we can negotiate people want to if you want to send to Hawaii. They should talk to me

1:50:20So Chris Higgins, this is a frequent contributor to the magazine just like Lex Hill Hill come

1:50:25and

1:50:27And then there's a Jason Snell visit, but the Jason Snell visit is 5001.

1:50:34This is a grudge visit.

1:50:36This is a grudge visit.

1:50:37So I launched the Kickstarter and Lex and Chris were up there and Jason's like, "Why am I not there?"

1:50:42I'm like, "Well, you know, it's sort of fun."

1:50:44And, you know, I thought it'd be people react very strongly to Lex and Chris's pieces and they've done a ton.

1:50:51They're the two biggest contributors, of course, to the history of the magazine.

1:50:53So I thought it'd be fun.

1:50:54And I asked them and they were game to do it.

1:50:56If somebody wants them to come, it's fun. They'll come and give a talk.

1:50:58They'll buy the people dinner.

1:51:00Yeah, but what's with the 5,001?

1:51:02So Jason's like, I'll do it. I'm like, Oh, that's great. You know,

1:51:05what are you doing? He's like, I'll come, we'll tape it.

1:51:06He said, I'll come and we'll buy people dinner and I'll tape it and comparable

1:51:10with them. Like that's great. And he said,

1:51:11but I have to be a dollar more than Lex and I said, done.

1:51:14All right. And then here's the other thing. Then you are, you can,

1:51:18people could buy a visit from you and yours is $8,000.

1:51:23Now, how can you charge more than these guys

1:51:26who you've doing this nice thing for you?

1:51:29- I have this dear friend, a dear friend

1:51:31who's given me great advice about the structural things

1:51:36to do with promoting stuff.

1:51:37And she said, "You can't, you're the editor.

1:51:41You cannot list yourself as $5,000.

1:51:44These guys are writers and they're perfectly wonderful,

1:51:46but you really, you're the editor of the thing.

1:51:47You should put yourself in more."

1:51:48I'm like, "No."

1:51:49And she's like, "Make yourself $10,000."

1:51:51And I said, "No, that's ridiculous."

1:51:52I said, I can do 8,000.

1:51:54But I thought, I will take her advice because,

1:51:56and you know, what's serious at some level is,

1:52:00if you've ever priced out getting people

1:52:02for speakers bureaus,

1:52:03it is crazy the amount of money people charge.

1:52:05And what I'm hoping is, I mean, to be actually serious,

1:52:08the only reason I listed these,

1:52:09I actually, they're quasi serious.

1:52:10They come with books, you know,

1:52:11and you send them people books

1:52:12and it'll cover all the costs of someone coming.

1:52:15But it's the idea of like, if you like the idea of this

1:52:18and you want someone,

1:52:19you wanna both support the publication

1:52:21and help the thing happen, which I've got some great patrons.

1:52:24- Or if you've already got like an event scheduled.

1:52:26- Exactly, this is a booking fee.

1:52:27And so if you have a group that wants to raise some money,

1:52:30I actually took this partly from Amanda Palmer

1:52:32because I know it's sort of funny,

1:52:33but it's true is she does house concerts.

1:52:35And I thought of this as like,

1:52:36this is the house concert equivalent

1:52:38of being a writer or speaker or whatever.

1:52:40And she sold, I can't remember how many

1:52:42in her million dollar plus campaign

1:52:45and it's still fulfilling them like two years in

1:52:47and the pictures are crazy.

1:52:48It's like, you can have a rock star come to your house

1:52:50snuggle with you as part of the her deal more or less.

1:52:52Can I tell you, I've met Amanda.

1:52:55Yeah, yeah.

1:52:56And she's a great artist and her success is completely justified. No surprise. Again,

1:53:03I would pay $5,000 not to have a house concert.

1:53:08I know that. Someone come to your house. Which her deal was...

1:53:11Right. Not because of her music. I would not like, I wouldn't want Bob Dylan to perform in my house.

1:53:17I should point out these visits in my campaign. They will not stay with you there. It covers

1:53:21hotel for them to stay. So they don't know what to say. Now, you know that story. I forget. It's

1:53:25actually based on a true story. Uh, PT Anderson made it into a film punch drunk love, uh,

1:53:30a really great movie, but it was about a guy in the movies played by Adam Sandler, but he's not,

1:53:34it's absolutely not an Adam Sandler movie. I recommend this movie totally. But the idea was

1:53:39that, uh, there were these, uh, 89 cent cans of like dinty Moore soup that you bought them. And

1:53:46and on the back of the can of soup

1:53:47was like a thousand miles on American Airlines.

1:53:52- Oh.

1:53:53- And he figured out that, you know,

1:53:56that the miles, if you just compute

1:53:58what's the miles roughly worth,

1:54:00were worth way more than 89 cents.

1:54:04So he just bought literally thousands of dollars,

1:54:07thousands and thousands of dollars,

1:54:08and thousands and thousands of cans of soup,

1:54:10and cut all these coupons out and ended up with, you know.

1:54:14Like a million miles?

1:54:16Right, like he's like, he's, you know, he became like the most, you know, mild customer on American Airlines.

1:54:22Uh, my mind works the same way where I often try to see the loopholes.

1:54:28And I got to tell you, I know for a fact, because part of this is you get taken out to dinner.

1:54:34I could rack up more than $5000 on a dinner.

1:54:37It is true.

1:54:39It is true.

1:54:40I am.

1:54:40I'm slightly concerned that someone will push the aisle.

1:54:43We did not set a limit.

1:54:44However, we hope that the people who would pay $5,000

1:54:47would do it.

1:54:48But oh, but the Amanda Palmer thing--

1:54:49- I could easily, I could easily rack up

1:54:51more than $5,000 on a dinner.

1:54:53- Because she was doing house concerts,

1:54:54she said a lot of her things were like 50 people

1:54:56got together and put $100 into the kitty

1:54:58and they got Amanda Palmer to come and swim with them

1:55:01and snuggle in the closet and perform and whatever.

1:55:04And I mean, that's, you know, hey, that's worth 100 bucks.

1:55:06- All right.

1:55:07- I don't know if I will snuggle for $8,000.

1:55:10It might cost more, but I'm not Amanda Palmer either,

1:55:12so I may not be in that camp.

1:55:13- Oh, we should wrap up.

1:55:18We've been on for a while, but it's been a great show.

1:55:20We know I was gonna talk to you about Bitcoin,

1:55:22but God Almighty, I have to have you back for another show

1:55:24because we've expended the whole thing

1:55:26on ads and publications.

1:55:27- I will come back and blow you, I think I understand.

1:55:31- You had a great piece, I'm gonna link to it.

1:55:33I will link it up.

1:55:34It's in the queue for "Daring Fireball,"

1:55:35so it'll be through there.

1:55:36But you have a great piece in "The Economist."

1:55:39- This is a, yeah, this is a--

1:55:40- I don't wanna get, we're not gonna talk about it

1:55:42'cause we run out of time.

1:55:43- I think I actually understand how it works technically.

1:55:47I still don't get the currency side.

1:55:48Well, we'll talk about it.

1:55:49I'll talk about it.

1:55:50- Yeah, it's fascinating though, right?

1:55:51Even if you're-- - It's beautiful.

1:55:52It's ridiculously elegant and clever at every level

1:55:55and every level is insane at the same time.

1:55:58- Right.

1:55:59I wanted to mention this.

1:56:00This is sort of off topic.

1:56:01I don't work in it naturally, but I can't.

1:56:03But when you were talking about

1:56:06the history of "The New Yorker," right?

1:56:08And I guess I'll tie it in as a wrap up of the show

1:56:11of why it's worth having a publication

1:56:14that can stand the test of time and build its own legacy.

1:56:17So the new issue, the December 9th issue

1:56:21of The New Yorker came to my house today.

1:56:24And on the cover, it's a lovely cover

1:56:26by his name is Istvan Banyai.

1:56:31- Oh, I love his work.

1:56:32- And it is a picture of McSorley's Old Ale House,

1:56:37established 1859 and it's mostly monochrome but there's a little Christmas to it and including

1:56:45a Merry Christmas in the window and a present on the ground a snow-filled street and I think

1:56:50lower Manhattan and there's a guy out front playing a trumpet and a cute waitress inside.

1:57:00Now the thing that caught my eye about this and I you know most of I've subscribed this

1:57:05The New Yorker comes every week and I've got like a big stack. I mean literally, you know, like knee-deep in my office of unread issues

1:57:11I can't keep up with it

1:57:12I love so I love the New Yorker can't keep up with it every week

1:57:15But I happen to know this because my friend Scott Simpson recommended this book to me a while ago

1:57:20It's a book called up in the old hotel by James Joseph Mitchell. You ever heard of Joseph Mitchell?

1:57:25Yes, Joseph Mitchell

1:57:28Was a staff writer at the New Yorker. I think maybe when it was founded if not, he was one of the early hires

1:57:33He started in 1939 and was for a few decades was one of the top contributors

1:57:38And this is a collection of his work in the New Yorker. It is a wonderful book and what the kind of stories

1:57:45He used to write were just like, you know

1:57:47Just man on the street stories about the regular citizens of New York and he was one

1:57:53I mean, it's it's one of the best books I've ever read and it was really great recommendation

1:57:57I can't recommend it highly enough up in the old hotel

1:58:00and the first story in the

1:58:04In this book by Joseph Mitchell is

1:58:09the old house at home and it's a profile of

1:58:14McSorley's old ale house. Oh my gosh. Now this was written. Let me see. I have the book in front of me here

1:58:20When was that written? I

1:58:22Don't know if they give you the year. Maybe it's at the end. Hold on

1:58:25It's a 21

1:58:26And this is also about long form stuff.

1:58:28And it's just a story about the saloon and who owns it and what it's like inside.

1:58:33I think it was written in like 1939 or something.

1:58:35No, I just found 1943.

1:58:371943.

1:58:38Yeah.

1:58:391940.

1:58:40No, 1940.

1:58:41Oh.

1:58:42It says in the book at least.

1:58:43So here's a story about this old ale house that was established in 1859, the oldest pub

1:58:48in New York City.

1:58:52Continuously open I believe since 1859.

1:58:54Oh, how?

1:58:55And it was one of the most famous, you know, a great historically notable profile that

1:59:02the New Yorker ran.

1:59:03But I ran it 73 years ago.

1:59:09And now here's the cover story and it's, you know, a picture of it.

1:59:12And I think that's so great.

1:59:13And I don't know how many readers of the New Yorker are going to know that.

1:59:18But like as soon as I saw it, it was like, to me, it was like boom.

1:59:22Like that's awesome.

1:59:24a great follow-up too, which I just found the blog post at the newyorker.com about it,

1:59:28and it's funded some additional cartoons for the site, and it's a slideshow showing Winnie

1:59:34the Pooh wandering in.

1:59:35Oh, yeah?

1:59:36I don't know, have you ever seen Winnie the Pooh smoking a cigarette? Well, now you can.

1:59:41The other thing that's interesting about Joseph Mitchell is—now, this is the foreword to

1:59:48the book and it's written by David Remnick the current editor of the New

1:59:52Yorker Joe Gould secret is is this I'm quoting from his David Remnick's

1:59:58introduction Joe Gould secret is Mitchell's masterpiece that's the last

2:00:03piece in the book it is also of course his last piece he never published again

2:00:09for the next 31 years and six months Mitchell came to work almost every day

2:00:14day and submitted not even a story for the talk of the town. No one was more esteemed

2:00:20by the staff than this courtly soft-spoken genius, and no one but a fool would ask about

2:00:25his silence. There were theories about what might have hindered him. Some great personal

2:00:31sadness, the weight of reputation, the radical changes in New York. He admitted when he was

2:00:38in his 80s, "I can't seem to get anything finished anymore. The hideous state the world

2:00:43is in just defeats the kind of writing I used to do.

2:00:46Pete: Oh my gosh.

2:00:47Chris: So he, but that's the sort of, but he remained a staff writer, full-time employed

2:00:51and came to work five days a week for 31 years and six months and never wrote another piece.

2:00:57Pete; That is, there's something, wow, that's almost, it's an incredible self-abnegation

2:01:04about that. You know, that was Tom Lehrer's comment about why after being one of the most

2:01:09successful political humorists in America for years and years that he gave it up. I

2:01:15mean he was a math professor, that was his full-time job, right? But he gave it up as,

2:01:18he said after Henry Kissinger won the Nobel, or was nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize,

2:01:23political satire became obsolete. Something of that nature. And it's like, yeah, that's

2:01:27kind of it.

2:01:28Craig T.

2:01:28Interesting. I just thought that was so fascinating.

2:01:30Oh, it's amazing.

2:01:30I think it's so great that they would call back to that. Anyway, I wish that--

2:01:34Is that your plan for Daring Fireball? It's just going to be a blank page for the next 31 years.

2:01:38Every day, people will get up and look at the page, and there'll be nothing there.

2:01:42That's probably how it'll end.

2:01:46Not with a whimper, but with a hashbang.

2:01:48Right.

2:01:49Sorry.

2:01:49Probably is how it'll end. People will just keep coming back hoping for something new.

2:01:55Alright Glenn, thanks a lot. Everybody check out the Kickstarter for the magazine, the book.

2:02:00And then check the show notes and read Glenn's piece on Bitcoin and Glenn's various bylines and 37 different weekly publications.

2:02:11I try. Thank you John.

2:02:12Alright. Thank you Glenn.

2:02:14Thanks.