0:00:00Psst! Hey! This episode of the talk show is brought to you by Backblaze online backup.
0:00:08Unlimited, unthrottled, uncomplicated. Available anywhere.
0:00:13Go to backblaze.com/daringfireball to learn more.
0:00:18Oh man, so I took a vaca- you know, took most of August, or a bit of August, or I don't know, all of August off.
0:00:28and lots happened. It's kind of anti-traditional for August.
0:00:35So you've probably talked, I have to admit I'm a little bit behind on the ATP, so I mean
0:00:42you've probably talked about some of this stuff, but people like to hear about it over
0:00:46and over again. Steve Ballmer, out at Microsoft.
0:00:51That's true. Did you not talk about this in your last show?
0:00:55I believe no.
0:00:57No, because it didn't happen then?
0:00:58I guess not.
0:00:59Yeah, it didn't happen.
0:01:00Yeah, no, we did talk about it.
0:01:02That's how long ago it's been since I've recorded
0:01:04an episode of the talk show.
0:01:05Yeah, I hadn't realized there had been a gap.
0:01:07Maybe I'm caught up.
0:01:08Who was your last guest?
0:01:09It was MG Siegler.
0:01:10We talked about Amazon.
0:01:11No, I heard that one.
0:01:12Yeah, I heard that one.
0:01:12That was the last one, I guess.
0:01:13Wow, you did take a break.
0:01:14Yeah.
0:01:16And in fact, the Siegler one I recorded before I took off.
0:01:23And it was held, I think, a week.
0:01:25It's possible. It's possible. I actually...
0:01:28It's all a little blurry, but it's possible that
0:01:31Balmer announced his retirement before the episode came out, but I don't think so.
0:01:35I think the episode came out like on Wednesday and then Balmer's announcement was Friday.
0:01:41That was the week. But the episode was recorded like the Friday before.
0:01:46Yeah, so not surprising, right? I mean...
0:01:49No, I don't think so. I think it was a little overdue. I think some of the reaction to it has been
0:01:53a little surprising. I think some of the defense of Vollmer as CEO, it surprises me a little
0:01:59bit.
0:02:00Well, it's like backlash, backlash. So you get the story is he's out, and then it's like,
0:02:04"Well, good riddance, he needed to go." That's the main story. And then the backlash story
0:02:08is, "Oh, he wasn't as bad as you thought he was." And now we're going to do the backlash,
0:02:11backlash, which is, "No, really, he was pretty bad." And it just oscillates back and forth
0:02:14until it finally settles on the central thing. We'll get there eventually.
0:02:20that. Yeah, I mean, you were posting on your side that he was kicked out and that people
0:02:27freaked out about that because you're really just speculating, but I don't think it really
0:02:30matters at this point. It was clear what his job was when he took over for Bill Gates,
0:02:36and he hasn't pulled it off, and it's time for a change, right? And it seems like, again,
0:02:43reading the tea leaves, it doesn't seem like that he graciously stepped aside to allow
0:02:48someone else to have a crack at it. It's not his personality. That's not the type of guy
0:02:52he is. So what's the only way to get rid of him? The only way to get rid of him is to
0:02:57kick him out, right? He's not going to leave on his own. You're going to wait for him to
0:03:00die. He's going to live to be a thousand, powered by his anger or whatever. So yeah,
0:03:05you got to get rid of him.
0:03:06And I think, you know, there were a couple of people who wrote about it. I forget who
0:03:10had the good piece, like what it would look like when a board forces a CEO out. And some
0:03:16of the tells are that there's no named successor, you know, that if this was orderly, there'd
0:03:22be a named, you know, somebody ready to go, you know, that there's, you know, if this
0:03:26was part of a plan, well, there wouldn't be a, you know, we need 12 months to name somebody.
0:03:32And the interviews with them, like, you know, the things you're supposed to say when if
0:03:37you're stepping down, you say all and he wasn't saying those things, like, he couldn't even
0:03:41like they were asking questions like, what made you decide to leave that he's got to
0:03:44make some crap up, he's like, "I didn't decide to leave."
0:03:47It seems like it could have got much worse.
0:03:48It could be adversarial and they're all trash talking to each other.
0:03:51It wasn't.
0:03:52He eventually was convinced that he's a company man.
0:03:54He's not going to go out and burn bridges and say, "Microsoft is doomed there.
0:03:58Not going to have Steve Ballmer to kick around anymore."
0:04:01He went out as graciously as you can imagine, but again, I don't think he wanted to go.
0:04:07He thought he could still pull it off.
0:04:09I think the thing that was keeping him there for such a long time is that he was there
0:04:12from the beginning. And he was, I'm assuming, Bill Gates' friend. And all those things,
0:04:17all those intangibles kept him there for longer than he should have been.
0:04:22My one question that I have that I didn't really know the answer to when we were talking
0:04:26about ATP is the transformation into along functional lines and the sort of amplification
0:04:32of Microsoft, was that his idea? And then it was like his last gasp and then they kicked
0:04:40him out or was that sort of something that the board wanted to happen and he was allowed
0:04:44to make it seem like it was his idea on his way out?
0:04:47My guess is that it was the latter, that it was Balmer's thing, because I can't imagine
0:04:58that they would institute something. And it seems like a true – if it is as they've
0:05:05described it. It's a true company-wide reorganization along functional lines,
0:05:09which is not the way Microsoft has ever operated. I mean, and it's a true
0:05:13transformation of the company. I can't see why they would do they, the board,
0:05:17would do that if they knew they were gonna bring in somebody new and they
0:05:21didn't have someone specific in mind. But on the other hand, why would you let him,
0:05:26if you know you want to get rid of him, they must have known it before. It's not
0:05:29like this was the last straw. Like, that's another theory that like they're like,
0:05:31"Okay, well, let's see what he has," and then let him announce and put into motion this
0:05:37plan to totally transform his company and then kick him out?
0:05:40This plan was a surprise to the board, I would imagine, right?
0:05:43Why let some guy do something?
0:05:47That was one of the theories in ATP, is like, "Did he announce this?"
0:05:50Then the board was like, "Okay, that's it.
0:05:52This guy's nuts.
0:05:53He's going to destroy the company.
0:05:54He's got to go out."
0:05:55That seems unlikely to me because this type of transformation, you'd get him out before
0:05:58he implements the plan.
0:05:59We'd hear about, "Oh, he was going to transform the company, but he got kicked out."
0:06:03So it's kind of weird.
0:06:05My question is, is this transformation still going on right now?
0:06:08Are parts of the company reorganizing?
0:06:11Are they continuing a pace to implement this transformation plan despite the fact that
0:06:14it was the idea of the guy they're kicking out?
0:06:17Does the plan survive him because it wasn't just him?
0:06:20They really thought this was a good idea.
0:06:21They just didn't think he was the guy to lead it.
0:06:23It's a good question.
0:06:24I hadn't really thought about it, but it is interesting.
0:06:27it was along the lines of Ballmer goes to the board with his plan to do this
0:06:34and the board is like maybe unsettled about his future and they're like hmm
0:06:40you know and they know they know there's a bad smell about the place you know
0:06:44that that that they're they're big thing windows is in decline and it doesn't
0:06:49seem like their next big things like mobile are gaining any traction at all
0:06:54They know there's it's it's at the point now where even the Microsoft optimists have got to see that there's problems in the near future for the company
0:07:02But at he says alright, I'm gonna do this
0:07:05And they're like, okay, and then it's like in the weeks after that there, you know, you know what maybe you know
0:07:12We got to get we got to we got to push this guy out
0:07:14And that's not the way you want that to go though
0:07:16Like that's another another fumbled seems like by the board or like you'd want to go and like and well
0:07:22Well, I mean, this sounds like, "Oh, who really cares?
0:07:23Who really cares if he was kicked out or he left or whatever?"
0:07:26It's all you'll find out in the tell-all books 10 years from now or whatever.
0:07:29But it makes a difference for the future of the company because I guess we will find out
0:07:33when the new CEO comes in, if his first order of business is to undo that entire plan, we'll
0:07:38know that that plan was clearly, it was Balmer's thing and the new guy is reversing.
0:07:42He says, "No, this is actually how we want to do things."
0:07:45But if the new CEO comes in and just tweaks the plan and says, "Okay, now I'm going to
0:07:50But it's not really what we're going to do.
0:07:52It's how we're going to be organized.
0:07:54So it could be that the organization survives him, and it's just that the new CEO says,
0:07:57"Now we're going to make toasters or something."
0:07:59And that would still be a radical shift.
0:08:02Because the new guy could come in and just immediately undo this plan and say, "Yeah,
0:08:07we're not going to do that.
0:08:08We're going to do something different.
0:08:09In fact, we're going to reorganize in a hub and spoke pattern.
0:08:12I'm in the hub," or whatever.
0:08:13Who knows?
0:08:14Yeah, I don't know.
0:08:16There's a line here.
0:08:17is the the internal email that Balmer sent to the company on the day of his
0:08:22the announcement. Second and third sentences to me are the ones that are
0:08:29almost that this is as close as ever gonna tell to the fact that he was kind
0:08:33of pushed or actually pushed. He says there's never a perfect time for this
0:08:38type of transition but now is the right time. My original thoughts on timing
0:08:44would have had my retirement happened in the middle of our transformation to a
0:08:47a devices and services company focused on empowering customers and the activities they
0:08:52value most. That, my original thoughts, that to me is translate as I would have stayed,
0:08:59but blank.
0:09:01Yeah, he's choking it down. Like, I mean, that's the one break in that I read that thing.
0:09:06That's the one break from his, like, you know, corporate veneer of, like, he's not going
0:09:09to bad math now. He's not going to trash the company. He loves Microsoft, right? He wants
0:09:13see them succeed so he can't he's not going to go down in flames but he also can't help
0:09:18like that little bit leaks out and I bet he regrets that I bet see it's a my original
0:09:21thought because that totally makes it clear it's like oh all right and I'm in the interviewer
0:09:25like if you're interviewing you'd feel bad at that moment right yeah you know I do kind
0:09:30of you know I mean I there's a lot of I told you so in the fact that I've seen to me it's
0:09:35been very clear for years that the guys you know been making profound mistakes of judgment
0:09:42But I don't hold any personal animosity against him.
0:09:44And I think it is very clear.
0:09:46I don't see how anybody, whether you
0:09:49have been a fan of the guy of the company's products
0:09:52or whatever or not, the opposite,
0:09:55I don't see how anybody could deny that the guy has put
0:09:57his life into the company.
0:09:59I mean, he is truly the company's man company man
0:10:01for Microsoft.
0:10:03Yeah, I think I would have personal animosity towards him
0:10:05if I was a big Microsoft fan and enthusiast.
0:10:08Because I would feel like he was steering
0:10:11ship into the iceberg over the past decade and just not, you know, I would be screaming
0:10:16and yelling for, you know, it's like when you scream and yell at the manager to pull
0:10:22a picture, right, because you're a fan of the team, right? You have personal hatred
0:10:25towards that guy. I see I'm gonna put all the baseball analogies for you. You know,
0:10:29but if you don't care, you're like, "Yeah, I'm gonna..." You know, because he did do,
0:10:32like, the things he did was he sort of took the businesses that he knew how to be successful
0:10:39because they work the same as they used to work and continued to, you know, sort of build those
0:10:45and, you know, didn't fumble the ball on those. He just was unable to break into any new businesses
0:10:52with Microsoft in a successful fashion. I also think there's a profound irony in the fact that
0:11:00his dad was an executive in fat Ford in Detroit. And, you know, he grew up as a in a car company.
0:11:13And that, you know, apparently, you know, it's still to this day, you know, has driven nothing
0:11:17but cars from the Ford Motor Company. I think it was Ford. I don't think it was GM. I'm almost sure
0:11:22Balmer's dad was Ford. But regardless, his father's generation of Detroit car
0:11:30executives were the generation that that ran the Detroit companies into real
0:11:35problems when a disruptive new class of cars came about in the 70s. And that his
0:11:43read bombers reaction to the disruptive technologies of the last 1015 20 years
0:11:49cars is, you know, in broad strokes very similar to Detroit's where they kind of just stuck
0:11:54with their old, you know, in broad strokes. Again, broad strokes. Let's just make big
0:11:59gas guzzling cars and let's just laugh off the threat from smaller, cheaper Japanese
0:12:06imports.
0:12:07Now, the idea of him only driving Ford cars despite being like a multi-billionaire because
0:12:14his father was a Ford man.
0:12:18It clicked together in my mind with Melinda Gates forbidding--
0:12:22was it her forbidding her children to have iPods?
0:12:26That attitude, not that--
0:12:28I'm taking Bill Gates and Steve Ballmer,
0:12:30like the one, two at Microsoft.
0:12:31And you can't say this pervades the entire company.
0:12:33But that attitude of like--
0:12:35and it's kind of like being a company man.
0:12:38You're Bill Gates' children.
0:12:39You're not going to have iPods.
0:12:40And Steve Ballmer, his father is saying, you're my son.
0:12:43I don't know if his father is saying this,
0:12:44He's doing it out of loyalty to his followers, and I'm only going to buy Ford's, despite
0:12:47the fact that I can have any car in the world, right?
0:12:50Compare this to Steve Jobs coming to Apple and continuing to use a ThinkPad because he
0:12:55can run Next Step on it.
0:12:56He's not going to run their friggin' classic Mac OS with the platinum windows and all this
0:12:59crap because it's not good enough for him, right?
0:13:03That whole idea of towing the line, being a company man, like it's a loyalty type thing,
0:13:11versus ruthlessly using what you think is the best product no matter what and trying like sort of being aspirational like you would hope that Steve
0:13:18Ballmer will be driving, you know, a Ferrari or BMW or Mercedes or something to give him a taste for what amazing products can be like
0:13:27And to aspire to make not that he has to make all his products expensive a Ferrari
0:13:31But like that type of that attitude to me is alien that that I'm only gonna drive forwards because my father
0:13:36I mean maybe he's fine if you can only afford Fords and it's like, you know picking Ford Chevy or Honda
0:13:40whatever, fine, stick with Fords. But it's just so crazy to me, that type of attitude,
0:13:45you know, from the Gates children not having iPods and just Steve Ballmer only driving
0:13:49Fords. That highlights, I think, the difference between Apple and Microsoft.
0:13:53Yeah. And, you know, like a Lincoln is made by Ford and is a higher quality car than,
0:13:59you know, like a Ford Escort or something like that. But point taken, I totally agree.
0:14:06I don't think Ballmer would fit in a Ferrari, by the way.
0:14:09They are very accommodating if you have enough money.
0:14:12They'll move the seat back.
0:14:14I don't know.
0:14:15I've never tried to sit in one.
0:14:16I've heard that they're pretty difficult for even – I don't even know if you or I would
0:14:20fit very well in a Ferrari.
0:14:22Italians all fit in Ferraris.
0:14:23Yeah.
0:14:24Well, Italians are very – well, typically very short men.
0:14:27Oh, God.
0:14:29There goes the Italian audience.
0:14:36I haven't seen a lot of speculation yet on who Microsoft might replace Balmer with.
0:14:44And it seems, this seems like a fun game to play.
0:14:47Yeah, I've heard a lot, I mean there's a lot of fun suggestions that you know aren't realistic.
0:14:53The favorite one is that, I think Marco was the one I saw, I said this first, but many
0:14:56people have as well, like, "Scott Forestall's available here."
0:15:00Not that he would ever, seems like, want to run Microsoft, ever.
0:15:05But that's a fun one to think about.
0:15:07- Yeah, let's take it seriously.
0:15:08I've definitely seen that one on Twitter.
0:15:10I saw that from five minutes after,
0:15:14when I first saw the announcement that Ballmer was out.
0:15:16- Right.
0:15:17- I don't think, I mean, I certainly cannot claim,
0:15:22I've met Forstall once,
0:15:24but I did have a nice conversation with him.
0:15:27Or maybe, and I've said hi to him at events
0:15:29a few times after that.
0:15:31But can't claim that I know him.
0:15:34but what I know of him, I can't imagine that he would want the job.
0:15:37Yeah, well think about this. Who would want the job?
0:15:41It's a good question to ask when you throw anybody's name out.
0:15:45Because it's the type of position where
0:15:48at this point in Microsoft's history, almost anybody
0:15:52who would claim to want the job is probably not the right guy for the job.
0:15:55Because if you want the job, it's like you know you have a lot on your plate,
0:15:59right? And you know it's going to be super difficult to
0:16:02to turn this big ship around.
0:16:03But you also know that no matter how bad a job you do,
0:16:06you're gonna be filthy stinking rich
0:16:08and be extremely powerful for the time
0:16:10you're in the position.
0:16:11So there's a whole class of terrible,
0:16:13sort of aspiring C-level executives
0:16:16from Fortune 500 companies who would jump at the chance
0:16:18to further take Microsoft down the tubes
0:16:22because you would make a lot of money
0:16:24and you would be powerful and you would be in the press
0:16:25and you would be interviewed in all these magazines,
0:16:27you know what I mean?
0:16:28And so for all the wrong reasons,
0:16:30If you're motivated by all the wrong things, yeah, those people want the position.
0:16:34But that's not who Microsoft wants.
0:16:35Microsoft wants someone who loves the company, who believes they can do better, and who's
0:16:40going to do something amazing and radical.
0:16:43And that's tough to find that person, the person who's motivated by all the right things
0:16:47but is also capable of it.
0:16:49Right.
0:16:50I would say with Forstall, I would bet everything that we have not heard the last from Scott
0:16:55Forstall.
0:16:56is that the terms of his departure from Apple were that he got a boatload of
0:17:03money. I mean like maybe literally like an entire boatload of money. And the
0:17:10terms were now you go away and you remain completely quiet for 12 months or
0:17:1618 months or something you know somewhere around there. I think maybe it
0:17:18was 12 months. So whenever that when was that it was last November when it was
0:17:22announced. I wouldn't be surprised if you first see his name even just in an
0:17:26interview or something come December but I think it was a 12-month period where
0:17:30he is not allowed to say anything in public whatsoever he's not allowed to
0:17:34tweet he is not allowed to I mean even like tweet a picture of like flower
0:17:39can't do it complete radio silence for 12 months not allowed to work anywhere
0:17:43not allowed to do anything and then after that you know it's probably some
0:17:47kind of standard list of non competes for some period of time yeah that's how
0:17:52long he needs to start gathering his future employees and his new company
0:17:56anyway, right?
0:17:57But look what other similarly having been successful people
0:18:00who left Apple, even if they left on better terms than him
0:18:03have done.
0:18:03There's Tony Fidell, the guy who led the original iPod team,
0:18:07went on to make the Nest thermostat.
0:18:09And he didn't leave on that much better terms than Forrestal
0:18:11when you think about it.
0:18:13I think maybe it was a little better, but not much.
0:18:18I mean, certainly he wasn't-- well, both of them
0:18:20had been named by various random quote, unquote,
0:18:25analyst is like potentially future people who could run the company but I
0:18:28forced all I think people took more seriously as that as a possibility but
0:18:32both of them believe they were kind of could have been in that you know your
0:18:36career path and then both booted out yeah but yeah but that like forced all I
0:18:40think has is a me gonna aim higher than a nest level thing yeah but it the point
0:18:45though is that it's a new company founded by Fidel in you know it exactly
0:18:50as he wants it. Bertrand. Now, we don't know exactly what he's working on yet at that mystery
0:18:56startup, some kind of... They've got like a slogan or something, but it's a new company
0:19:04that he's working on down in San Jose somewhere secretly. Obviously, he could go almost anywhere
0:19:11he wanted to if... The guy has an unbelievable record, but made a new company.
0:19:17Well, yeah, so I think those are two very different things.
0:19:20Because think about this.
0:19:21Bertrand, I think, would have no problem if his company makes something amazing selling
0:19:26the company back to Apple.
0:19:28Right.
0:19:29That's very true.
0:19:30Whereas Forstall, at this point in his career, wants to be the Steve Jobs of whatever he
0:19:34does next.
0:19:35And Steve Jobs, you know, I mean, Steve Jobs did sell next back to Apple, but it was a
0:19:39long time coming, and that was not his first choice, right?
0:19:42Right.
0:19:43ever coming back to Apple is after some sort of decade-long disastrous drought?
0:19:49No, I mean, you know, I mean, is it possible? It certainly doesn't seem possible right now, but...
0:19:54Right, and after Tim Cook dies in a private jet accident or something.
0:19:57Well, you know, if we get to the year 2022 and Apple has had, you know, their stock's been flat
0:20:05ever since 2011 and they're losing money and the iPhone, you know, is no longer a viable platform,
0:20:13etc, etc, who knows? But I mean it would take, you know, like Apple back to where they were
0:20:18in 1997 sort of disaster for Forstall to come back. And like a complete execution of the
0:20:24entire current executive staff. So no, I don't think Scott Forstall has any interest in the
0:20:32Microsoft job.
0:20:33Yeah, I mean, I think he wants to do his own thing. I mean, at the very least, you have
0:20:36you'd have to give someone like him time to go off, try to do your own thing and decide
0:20:39if they didn't like it, or fail once or twice or something like that.
0:20:44If they're smart, they'll court him.
0:20:46Like if they're smart, they're going to at least make the call, make the offer, talk
0:20:49to him about it, find out what the deal is, but I think he will rebuff them.
0:20:53So that's why people don't take it seriously.
0:20:55It seems so unlikely because I've never even spoken to him, but from what I can tell him,
0:21:00he doesn't seem like the type of person who's just interested in being the CEO of something
0:21:04or just interested in being powerful.
0:21:06And he also seems like the kind of person who would turn up his nose at Microsoft for
0:21:09the same reason that all Apple snobs turn up their nose at Microsoft, right?
0:21:12Right.
0:21:13I don't think that their technology is appealing to him.
0:21:16You know, that the whole technology stack they have in place, I don't know that he'd
0:21:19be – he'd have any interest in.
0:21:21Yeah.
0:21:25But that is – it certainly is an interesting what if.
0:21:28But I don't think it's going to happen.
0:21:29I don't think it's feasible.
0:21:32So here's one.
0:21:33How about Jeff Bezos?
0:21:34Or Bezos.
0:21:35Bezos however you want to say it. What could they possibly say that would make him
0:21:38Interested. I mean he's already got a massive
0:21:42You know massive corporation that's entirely built in his own image
0:21:47Yeah, but the other thing about him is though he he strikes me as a person who is able to see
0:21:55how
0:21:58Seemingly unconnected things can be worked together worked together for mutual benefit
0:22:02Like he's the guy who took the company that was selling books on the internet
0:22:04and decided to build a storage service and like, you know, and EC2 for cloud
0:22:11computing and stuff.
0:22:11And yeah, some of that is because, well, okay, we need something like that for it
0:22:14to run our own servers, but, but reselling it and deciding to make tablet computers
0:22:18and like an E Ink reader, like, and, and, you know, it's not that farfetched, but.
0:22:22If you were the CEO of a company selling books on the internet, those are not your
0:22:26first, like it, the things Amazon has done seem like if you, if you were
0:22:31told me in like 1995 or whenever Amazon started, fast forward a couple of years and Amazon's
0:22:37going to have this and this and this. You're like, "What? Why would they have that? It
0:22:40doesn't even make sense. It doesn't even seem like it's in the same business." So what could
0:22:45he do owning both Amazon and Microsoft? How could those two things work together? And
0:22:51I can think of lots of ways those two things could work together to make Amazon and Microsoft
0:22:54better.
0:22:55Well, what do you say, though, that he'd be like where Jobs was the CEO of Pixar and Apple,
0:22:58he'd be the CEO of both Amazon and Microsoft?
0:23:00Oh, yeah. No, yes, that he would be the CEO of both. That they would not pull him away.
0:23:04Yes, exactly.
0:23:05I can see if Bezos said I'd be interested, I can certainly see why Microsoft would want
0:23:10to listen to him. I can't see why Bezos would want to do it. I can't see why he would even
0:23:15spend 30 seconds thinking about it.
0:23:17Yeah, because it has the smell factor of like, you know, Amazon is the – if not on the
0:23:24ascent, then it's a survivor and it's doing well and people like it and stuff. And Microsoft
0:23:29seen as being on the downslope, and I don't think he really feels the need. He wants to
0:23:33rescue Microsoft.
0:23:34Like, one thing he clearly has at Amazon, and you know, I've spoken and written a bit
0:23:39about Amazon in the last month or so, but I mean, and there's a lot of dispute from
0:23:43from more financial-minded people that I've got it all, you know, I've got Amazon all
0:23:48wrong. But one thing I don't think anybody could deny is that Bezos has effectively carte
0:23:54Blanche from his investors and Mike and and the board. He doesn't really have to
0:24:00answer to anybody and the board and Amazon investors are very happy with
0:24:04what he's doing. Whereas that big problem with Microsoft right now is that
0:24:08investors are very unhappy with them. There was a story just today that a what
0:24:12do you call it a activist investor group has successfully gotten a new member of
0:24:20of the board at Microsoft, which is, according to the Wall Street Journal, almost unprecedented
0:24:25for a company their size. You know, that investors are very unhappy. And that it's the investors
0:24:31being unhappy that seemingly has gotten the board agitated. And now, you know, it's the
0:24:35board that made the move to do this. You know, he's not--there's a lot of people to answer
0:24:40to there. I mean, I guess you could theoretically get a contract written that says, you know,
0:24:44you're going to have to, you know, get off my back and I don't have to run ideas by you.
0:24:49going to make me the CEO and I get to do whatever I want.
0:24:51But it doesn't really work like that.
0:24:54That's like the worst thing that could happen to a company like Microsoft in this situation
0:24:57is to have suddenly the board sort of get emergency powers or whatever.
0:25:04To have the future of the company be decided by a committee, even if that committee is
0:25:08only a handful of people, that is the worst possible thing.
0:25:11The reason it worked at Apple is because Jobs came in and the board, I don't know if he
0:25:18Shuffled through the border replacing people whatever but like it was a hundred percent backing of him
0:25:22They just rubber-stamped what he did like him and he talked to them and he got advice or whatever
0:25:26But it was not as if they were like, okay Steve
0:25:28But we're really watching you and maybe they were but like it was not
0:25:31You can't run the company by committee it you when you have a company situation Microsoft is in you need like strong
0:25:38Decisive leadership that also happens to be correct. Yeah jobs almost
0:25:42I mean I might be getting this slightly wrong and there might be
0:25:45Maybe one or two board members who he kept on, like maybe Bill Campbell was already on
0:25:49the board.
0:25:50But he, you know, but he's was friends, personal friends with Steve Jobs.
0:25:54So it's not surprising that he did.
0:25:55Or maybe, but I might be wrong, maybe even Bill Campbell was somebody who Jobs brought
0:25:59on after he came back in 97.
0:26:01But he effectively got most of the existing Apple board to commit seppuku, you know, even
0:26:08longtime members like what's his name Mark Mark Kula, the guy who is like the third or
0:26:14fourth founder of Apple, like the big investor. I mean, no surprise there since he was one
0:26:19of the guys who forced Jobs out in '86. But when the board got Jobs to come back, they
0:26:27more or less, part of the deal was, "And all of you have to sit step down. Or at least
0:26:32all of you have to submit a resignation, and I'll pick which ones of you stay."
0:26:35Yeah, I was saying on ATP that the advantage that Apple and Jobs had was that Apple was
0:26:39in way worse shape than Microsoft.
0:26:43It's so much easier to do the radical scary thing when it's your only choice.
0:26:47Like, "Look, we're going to go bankrupt otherwise."
0:26:49So then, how about the whole board steps down with a Steve Jobs takeover and he populates
0:26:53the board with his friends and does whatever the hell he wants.
0:26:55You're like, "Well, we're going to be out of business if we know to do something, and
0:26:58so that sounds good."
0:26:59And the board stepping aside, they probably thought they were leaving a sinking ship,
0:27:02the people who didn't have faith in Jobs or whatever.
0:27:06The fact that the board was populated with people who were just going to more or less
0:27:09give thumbs up to whatever Steve did, let him execute his plan over the years that he
0:27:13was with the company in his second reign.
0:27:19If Microsoft board suddenly like, "Oh, shareholders are pissed off and they're putting a guy on
0:27:22the board and the board is like, I don't know, but the board doesn't know what the hell to
0:27:25do."
0:27:26Those people have no idea of how to fix Microsoft.
0:27:27None of those people, if elevated to CEO, could fix the company.
0:27:31As far as we know, it seems very unlikely.
0:27:34They've been overseeing the Baltimore reign and just kind of going, "Mm-hmm," and hemming
0:27:37and hawing.
0:27:38Like, you do not want rule by committee.
0:27:42You want something exciting and radical.
0:27:44And you probably also need to be willing to take Microsoft down further to bring it up.
0:27:51So like, pick businesses that, you know, not that you have to go by the Steve Jobs playbook,
0:27:56but when he came in, he cleaned house in an already dying company, canceling projects
0:28:03left and right.
0:28:04You have to decide what do you want Microsoft to be, and everything that's not totally concentrating
0:28:07on achieving that gold, you ditch.
0:28:09You don't put it into maintenance mode.
0:28:11You don't say, well, they're going to get less updates
0:28:13or whatever.
0:28:13You just say, we've got to cut it off.
0:28:14And at this point in Microsoft's history,
0:28:16you can't do that because each one of those businesses,
0:28:19it's worth-- maybe not percentage-wise a lot,
0:28:21but in real money, it's worth a lot.
0:28:22And then the boards are going to be like, whoa, what are you
0:28:24doing?
0:28:24And our revenue is going to go down, and you can't do this,
0:28:26and I'm not going to give you-- Microsoft
0:28:28doesn't have a year or two years to reboot a bunch of things.
0:28:31And they're in a tough situation.
0:28:34And I feel like it would be better
0:28:36if their business was failing monetarily. Unfortunately, it's not.
0:28:39Right. To draw an analogy, clearly it's hard to get everyone to act on climate change based on
0:28:48evidence that we may be seeing trouble ahead. Whereas it would be a lot easier to get everybody
0:28:53on board if Manhattan were under 20 feet of water. Yep.
0:28:57Right? And you can say, "Well, then it's too late." But that's where Apple was in '97.
0:29:04Apple in 97 was you know Manhattan's got 20 feet of water
0:29:07Yeah entire ground floor of every building in Manhattan is underwater and well jobs thing Steve Jobs decision was Manhattan has lost screw Manhattan
0:29:15We start building a new city inland, right and you're not allowed to use gasoline anymore, right?
0:29:20Right, and you know and that's you know, nobody was gonna nobody would have gone for that, you know, three four years earlier
0:29:26When they should have maybe
0:29:31So I will and I'll just say one more thing before I take the first sponsor break
0:29:35There is one person who's currently on the Microsoft board who could conceivably take over as CEO. I
0:29:40Have no ideas on the Microsoft board so well Bill Gates. Oh no forget that. Yeah
0:29:47No, I've heard that one as well. But like he's someone who did leave
0:29:50On his own terms, right?
0:29:53Tote, you know he decided when he was gonna leave he decided who the successor was gonna be
0:29:56he took like a year to walk out the door and
0:29:59He is totally the wrong person. I think even if he wanted to do it because
0:30:03Well, I don't know maybe not totally the wrong person he he missed the internet thing
0:30:09But he did turn the company around in time to I mean time to crush Netscape using illegal tactics
0:30:16I mean like it like I don't know if that's who you want running the show
0:30:19But he is definitely of the old Microsoft mindset like I don't I don't know if that mindset that mindset served him
0:30:27well in the environment that he was in at that time.
0:30:30And I don't know if he has the--
0:30:32even if he wanted to, had the mindset and the skills
0:30:34to succeed in the current market.
0:30:36Because he oversaw a lot of the--
0:30:39wasn't he still the CEO when they were doing the--
0:30:42well, he's certainly for the pen computing, and the tablet,
0:30:44and the speech recognition.
0:30:45And I think for a little bit of the smartphone stuff
0:30:47that they were doing, he was there in all those fields,
0:30:50doing crappy things before everyone else
0:30:52was doing anything.
0:30:53Those were there for the taking, and he didn't take them,
0:30:56And he missed them.
0:30:57He miscalculated.
0:30:58He had to spend all his money on R&D and all these different research projects.
0:31:00And every year at CES, he would be up there telling you, in the future, we're going to
0:31:03be like blah, blah, blah, blah.
0:31:04And then he would never ship it.
0:31:05And then he walked out the door.
0:31:07So I don't think he is the guy you want anyway.
0:31:10And I don't think there's a chance in hell that he's coming back.
0:31:14I don't think so either.
0:31:15But it would be a credible choice in the eyes of at least a significant -- certainly, I think,
0:31:23the business world would be seen as a credible choice and would be seen as a credible choice
0:31:28in some portion of the tech world.
0:31:30Yeah, it would get a thumbs up from everybody.
0:31:32Well, not everybody.
0:31:33Like the stock market, well, most, I think the stock market would like it.
0:31:35I think the board would like it and they would say, "Oh, it would be just like Steve Jobs
0:31:38coming back to Apple.
0:31:39Here comes Bill Gates."
0:31:40It's the one with the best optics because anybody else you bring is either going to
0:31:46be an unknown and that's like bad, it makes people nervous.
0:31:49Or like best case, like so they get Scott Forstall or whatever, people are like nervous
0:31:52then, right?
0:31:53Right.
0:31:54And so Bill Gates is like, "It's a devil you know."
0:31:56And he's the one who made like, that is their best choice if you want the highest ratio
0:32:01of positive to negative stories and the best reaction of the stock price.
0:32:04But long term, I don't think it's their best bet.
0:32:07I don't think so either because the question you have to ask is, what would Bill Gates
0:32:12have done differently if he had stayed on as CEO for the past, what, 12 years instead
0:32:20of taking the chairmanship and having Balmer take over, what would he have done differently?
0:32:25And I don't know that the answer is much at all.
0:32:28He strikes me as being more ruthless and Machiavellian than Balmer in that he just wants to win the
0:32:35game, whether it's a board game or the game of companies, and he will do whatever it takes
0:32:40to win the game, which is sort of why he was able to crush Netscape and why he was willing
0:32:46to turn the whole company around with the internet tidal wave memo and all that other
0:32:50But I think it takes more than that, but that is at least showing a little bit more scrap
0:32:54and fight than Balmer has shown, where Balmer has kind of been tepidly trying to move in
0:32:58the right direction, but Gates would just be like up at night thinking about how can
0:33:02I outmaneuver these companies?
0:33:03Who are my competitors and how can I defeat them?
0:33:06And that fire, I don't know if that fire has gone in him now or if it's still there,
0:33:11but if he was in charge, I feel like Microsoft would have done more bold things than they
0:33:17did under Balmer.
0:33:18And it does seem true that he was more hands-on, maybe significantly more hands-on in product
0:33:25development than Balmer ever was.
0:33:28That major software products went before Bill Gates for review, and certainly without the
0:33:35level of taste, which we should get back to because I think it's a fundamental failing
0:33:40of Balmer and Microsoft's culture as a whole.
0:33:45But in terms of being strongly opinionated and by his word alone, you've got to go back
0:33:51to the drawing board. Bill Gates had that, and I don't know that Gates ever really involved
0:33:55himself at that level.
0:33:56A bomber, you mean?
0:33:57A bomber.
0:33:58Yeah, no, Gates was a nerd, and he was a programmer, and he wanted to hear stuff. And bomber was
0:34:03like NBA type, right? He can't tell you... I mean, there's that famous tale from Spolsky's
0:34:10things on his site about coming to them about some calendaring function in Excel and having
0:34:14Ballmer quizzed him on like leap year and leap second and crazy edge cases about dates
0:34:18and stuff that he brushed up on before he came to the meeting, and then having to have
0:34:22answers for him. And that's not happening with Ballmer. I mean, not that you're saying
0:34:24you don't have to be an engineer to be CEO. I mean, Tim Cook's not an engineer either.
0:34:27But that was Gates' type attitude. And because it was a tech company and because he was a
0:34:31tech nerd, he failed to do that. But even just the thing where Gates would go away for
0:34:35like a week or two every year to do like his thinking time with his books and everything,
0:34:39like that's when he came back with the internet title wave memo. Just like I've read about
0:34:42I've been reading about this internet, I've been keeping up with it, and I've decided
0:34:45it's a big deal now.
0:34:46He was always going away and coming back with ideas like that, and he was usually right
0:34:50about the areas they had to be in.
0:34:51It's just that then they executed poorly and made crappy products, and that gets back
0:34:56to the taste thing of like, he knew that they should be into tablet computing and pen computing
0:35:02and speech recognition and mobile.
0:35:05Just the products they created there were not good enough, didn't break far enough
0:35:09with the past, and he just couldn't get it done.
0:35:12One of my favorite Bill Gates stories is from Andy Hertzfeld's folklore website and what
0:35:19was the book version, Revolution in the Valley, where the first time, I think it was Andy's
0:35:25story, but the first time he showed Bill Gates a Macintosh, this was before it was released
0:35:32and Microsoft, they were trying to get Microsoft on board as an app developer. The thing that
0:35:39he caught onto was the mouse pointer animation, which was terrific and was the sort of thing
0:35:46like to get it to animate without like trails and lagginess. And Gates accused them of cheating,
0:35:56that it was somehow like a hardware cheat, that there was something that was in the hardware
0:36:01just to get the mouse pointer to animate as well as it did on 1980, you know, probably
0:36:07then 1983 hardware.
0:36:09And then he grilled Hertzfeld on how they were doing it.
0:36:13But he caught on to a little detail like that
0:36:16and knew that there must be some-- either they were cheating
0:36:19or it was genius, that it was working as well as it did.
0:36:23Yeah, I believe that scene was dramatized
0:36:27with varying degrees of accuracy in the Pirates of Silicon Valley
0:36:30terrible TV movie, ways back.
0:36:32But yeah, Andy's recollection of it
0:36:33is I would take that as more accurate than the thing
0:36:36Noah Wiley, but that's what you get when you show something to an engineer.
0:36:41And I think this is unfair to Bill Gates, but he's kind of the...
0:36:47What's that guy's name from Amadeus who wasn't Amadeus?
0:36:49Salieri?
0:36:50Was that his name?
0:36:51I forget.
0:36:52Well, anyway, have you seen the movie Amadeus?
0:36:54A long time ago.
0:36:55All right.
0:36:56So Amadeus is Mozart.
0:36:57He's amazingly talented.
0:36:58And there's his contemporary guy who is sort of Mozart's competitor, but is smart enough
0:37:05to realize that Mozart is a genius and is so pissed that he's never going to be that
0:37:10good.
0:37:11Right?
0:37:12And that Mozart gets...
0:37:13And so Bill Gates was smart enough to see the Mac and immediately notice that cursor
0:37:17and be technical enough to ask, you know, to grill them, "I got to find out how you
0:37:20did this."
0:37:21And it's like every time he would see Apple do something, he'd be like, "Look, you know,
0:37:25Microsoft is bigger than Apple.
0:37:26I'm better than Apple.
0:37:27I'm richer than all the people at Apple.
0:37:29I'm the richest man in the world.
0:37:30I have my software on every desktop.
0:37:32But damn those Apple people when they do this crap.
0:37:34He's got Apple envy.
0:37:35Bill Gates had Apple envy.
0:37:36He was smart enough to have Apple envy.
0:37:39And when he talks about Steve Jobs after his death and everything like that, I believe
0:37:42that the admiration he talks about with Steve Jobs is not BS sort of business people who
0:37:46got to say nice things about my contemporary competitors.
0:37:48I believe he really did admire and respect Steve Jobs and envied a lot of the products
0:37:54that Apple and Steve Jobs were able to make.
0:37:56And that's to Bill Gates' credit that he did that, and it just pissed him off.
0:38:01Why can't we make things that nice?
0:38:03Why aren't our things that nice?
0:38:04Like he could he had just enough taste to be able to know that the cursor movement on
0:38:09the Macintosh is way better than the cursor movement on that they've been able to do with
0:38:12their you know attempts to do similar types of thing and he could see it and he pissed
0:38:16them off and he had to know how it was done.
0:38:18Right.
0:38:19It was the same reason why so much of everything you drug on the original Mac was an outline
0:38:25just a little bit because it was hard to to make things animate like that and there was
0:38:29kind of trick that probably Hertzfeld didn't even come up with it was probably
0:38:34what's his name the quick-draw guy Bill Atkinson yeah Atkinson but it was some
0:38:41and had something to do with the fact that it was exactly 16 by 16 pixels and
0:38:45they couldn't do use the same trick to make say live animation of a whole
0:38:49window or even a whole icon but for a 16 by 16 square they could do it on then on
0:38:55that hardware. Yeah, I think it says everything about Gates that he like latched onto it immediately.
0:39:00Let me take a break and we'll get back to I think we should get back to the taste issue
0:39:07at Microsoft. I want to talk about our first sponsor, Backblaze. Backblaze is an unlimited,
0:39:16unthrottled, uncomplicated online backup software and it costs just five bucks a month. They
0:39:23up all the data on your computer, movies, music, presentations, photos, everything,
0:39:28including any hard drives you have connected, external hard drives. All your data is available
0:39:32over the web or on your phone or iPad, everything. Want to get one file back? You can get one
0:39:39file back. You need to get them all back? You can get them all back with a few clicks.
0:39:42It was founded by ex-Apple engineers. It runs native on your Mac. It's not some kind of
0:39:48janky thing that's weird on a Mac. It's made by ex-Apple engineers. It's the simplest
0:39:53backup software out there. You install it and they do the rest. Now this is a line they
0:40:00suggested I read, but I'm gonna read it. Don't let your data die in a fireball. Back it up
0:40:05now with back place. It's a great service. Five bucks a month. Everything is offline.
0:40:13If like disaster strikes, you can get them to FedEx you an external hard drive that restores
0:40:18all of your data. No add-ons, no gimmicks, they don't give you any kind of goo. You think,
0:40:23"Ah, they'd say it's five bucks a month but then they're gonna hit me with all these charges
0:40:27or add-ons and stuff like that." Nope, five bucks a month, unlimited backup. Here's what
0:40:33you do to find out more. Go to www.backblaze.com/daringfireball. I didn't think they did this before with the
0:40:44URL. Instead of using the talk show, they used Daring Fireball. But I don't care. Everybody
0:40:48knows. It's the same thing. Show should probably be called the Daring Fireball Show anyway.
0:40:55www.backblaze.com/daringfireball and then they'll know you came from the show. Can't
0:40:59recommend it enough.
0:41:00**Matt Stauffer** They probably like the fireball theme because
0:41:02do you remember the old Backblaze site had a little movie in the header that showed someone
0:41:09squirting lighter fluid on their laptop and lighting it on fire?
0:41:11**Justin Jackson** No, I don't. I don't remember that.
0:41:13**Matt Stauffer** That was one of the early versions of their
0:41:15website was like, "What, torch your computer? Don't worry, we got your data backed up."
0:41:19The other thing I liked about Backblaze is that I use it on the computer I'm sitting
0:41:22in front of now. So they mail you the hard drive thing, and I've been a Backblaze customer
0:41:26since back when they did the lighter fluid thing on their website. And they'll be like,
0:41:33"Okay, and we'll send you... You can get your data online, but we'll also send you a hard
0:41:38drive because it's way easier to get that amount of data." And they showed the hard
0:41:41drive size they will send you, and it's like if your stuff doesn't fit on one hard drive,
0:41:45we'll send you multiple hard drives. And I looked at the size of the hard drives, and
0:41:47like, "Ooh, my stuff's not going to fit there because I've got so much stuff. I don't have
0:41:50to get multiples if I've got a backup." But that was so long ago. They keep increasing
0:41:54the size of the hard drives they'll send you. So I'm still paying the same rate I was always
0:41:59paying, but now they'll send you a three terabyte hard drive or something. I forget how big
0:42:03it is, but it's way bigger than it was when I first signed up.
0:42:07You can imagine a company like, "Well, when you signed up, your $5 a month only got you
0:42:10a 320 gigabyte hard drive in the mail. So if you want the better version, you have to
0:42:14sign it. Nope, they just keep making the hard drive sizes bigger, which is great, but that's
0:42:17what you want. You want them to FedEx you like the biggest drive you can. At that point,
0:42:21you know, paying for them to FedEx you a big hard drive is like the least of your concerns
0:42:25of like your house burned down.
0:42:26What are the cardinal sins of backup are? Let me think here. Not backing up everything.
0:42:32Well, they back up everything, right? If you only back up X, Y, and Z, but you don't back
0:42:35up W, guess what? W is what you're going to need when trouble strikes. So if you don't
0:42:39don't back up everything Murphy's law says it's the thing you don't back up that you're
0:42:43going to regret. Well, they back up everything. Not backing up frequently enough. If you only
0:42:48run manual backups, it's the time when you don't run it for two weeks that that's when
0:42:53you're going to that's when disaster is going to strike Murphy's law guarantees it. Their
0:42:58software just you know, you do a big backup and then it just you know, updates incrementally
0:43:02without you doing anything. And then what's see off site? Well, they're off site by definition,
0:43:09It's an online backup service.
0:43:11I would add a fourth one, which is not testing restores.
0:43:14And you can test restores anytime you want.
0:43:16You can go to their website and pick files at random
0:43:19and get a zip file containing them
0:43:21and confirm that they are the--
0:43:23The files you need.
0:43:24Right.
0:43:24I've not done it just to test restores.
0:43:26I've done it to actually restore stuff.
0:43:28But since they have an iOS app now, I think, too, don't they?
0:43:31Yes.
0:43:32So testing restores is something I
0:43:35should be doing on a more regular basis just to check.
0:43:37But over the matter of course of just having the service,
0:43:40it's like, where the heck is that file?
0:43:41Sometimes it's easier to dig through it in your backups
0:43:43and get it back.
0:43:44Then I am, as a side effect, I'm also
0:43:47testing the restore process every time
0:43:49I pull a file from Backblaze Backup.
0:43:50All right, so you're at some meeting,
0:43:52all you brought with you is your iPhone.
0:43:54And all of a sudden in the meeting,
0:43:55you need some file from your computer.
0:43:56You could use Backblaze, the app, and you could get it.
0:43:59Anyway, great stuff, www.backblaze.com/daringfireball.
0:44:04My only problem with them is I have trouble
0:44:06pronouncing their name. I want to say black bays, which is probably a website you don't
0:44:13want to go to. That's true. I don't even know what that would mean. So I really think that
0:44:20part of you know, bombers come up and is that the man has no taste. And whatever lack of
0:44:27taste Bill Gates had, I think bomber is worse. And I keep pointing to I've pointed to it
0:44:34for years. I've pointed to it for years as proof that they should have fired him years
0:44:40ago. The infamous interview he gave when the iPhone was first announced when he laughed
0:44:44at it on camera and said, you know, a $600 phone with no keyboard? You've got to be kidding
0:44:51me and just laughed and laughed and laughed. I've pointed to that for years as proof that
0:44:58this guy, you know, was not asleep at the switch and was the wrong guy for the job.
0:45:02And the point that the people--every time I link to it, I get e-mail from people saying,
0:45:08"Well, what do you expect him to say? That's not proof of anything. He's the CEO of a rival
0:45:12company. He can't say good things about the iPhone." But that's the point. He didn't just
0:45:17not say good things about the iPhone. He laughed at it. There's a video you can look at now
0:45:22and it looks horrendous in hindsight.
0:45:25It's not just him pooh-poohing the iPhone
0:45:28or saying, you know, pointing out one bad thing about it,
0:45:33like the price.
0:45:34The original 2007 iPhone, which they
0:45:36tried to sell unsubsidized, was very expensive.
0:45:39$600 iPhone was not going to take over the market.
0:45:44So he could have just said, look, it's too expensive,
0:45:46and then talk up whatever the best Windows mobile phones were
0:45:49of the time.
0:45:50There is a way to play that on camera that stuck to a Windows mobile-centric line, but
0:46:00which didn't dismiss the iPhone or didn't mock the iPhone, I should say.
0:46:06Well, I don't think he really believed that.
0:46:08I do.
0:46:10I don't think he looked at the iPhone and thought, "Holy shit, we're fucked."
0:46:15Well, he wouldn't...
0:46:16I don't think he understood the depth of the problem, but it's kind of like a Cold War
0:46:20era mentality where as soon as the US does anything, the Soviet Union would be like,
0:46:25"Our fighter jets are ten times, our pilots are ten times better than theirs are, and
0:46:30we have more tanks and you will never..."
0:46:32It's propaganda.
0:46:33As soon as the iPhone comes out, again, he's a company man.
0:46:36He's going to say, "Windows Mobile," and he would pull out the stats about, "We sell this
0:46:41many phones and we've been doing this for this long, and look at this thing, and it's
0:46:43It's terrible in every possible way.
0:46:45It's propaganda against the enemy.
0:46:50And that is his first instinct.
0:46:51And the problem with having that be your first instinct as CEO, to have that reaction, I
0:46:55think it's disingenuous or whatever.
0:46:57But eventually you start to convince yourself.
0:46:58Because if you keep saying those things, I think eventually because he doesn't want to
0:47:02believe that this thing is better as everyone says it is, because that pisses him off, he
0:47:09saying these things and eventually starts to believe them more than he should.
0:47:14But I don't think, no matter how much he convinced himself, I don't think he ever really believed
0:47:18all the things he was saying about how terrible the iPhone is.
0:47:21I think he went back to the people on his team and said, "Why aren't iPhones like this?
0:47:24Why?"
0:47:25At the very least, just simply saying, "Why doesn't the press say the same things about
0:47:28the latest version of Windows Mobile that they're saying about this?"
0:47:30You know what I mean?
0:47:31Because he's going to go back and yell at his people and ask why that's the problem,
0:47:35even if he doesn't understand why.
0:47:37And the taste thing, like when we say they have bad taste, like what we kind of mean
0:47:40is they don't have the same taste as us or the same taste as Apple.
0:47:44Because he does have a form of taste, but his taste runs towards things that don't make
0:47:48for a successful consumer product, right?
0:47:50So it's not like he has no taste.
0:47:52He has a taste and a design aesthetic, you know, as embodied in, I don't know, what can
0:47:57you look at to figure it out?
0:47:58As embodied in the product, the way he managed Microsoft, as embodied in his wardrobe, his
0:48:03transportation choices. Like he has some taste, it's just different than the taste that we
0:48:08have. And at this point, you say, "Well, so what? Your taste is just different. Apple's
0:48:13taste is just different." But I think Apple at this point has vindicated in showing it.
0:48:17Or even just saying, there's a sameness to saying, "What was Sony's taste like when they
0:48:21were the king of the consumer electronics sale? What does Apple's taste like?" There
0:48:24is a through line between those companies, and it is not like the taste of Microsoft
0:48:29or Steve Ballmer. So it's the incorrect taste to have if you want to be in this type of business.
0:48:34[0:14]
0:48:35Glenn: Sony, when they were on top, had a very distinctive taste. I liked it. It was usually black,
0:48:42like black devices. And when they weren't, they would go in almost radical directions,
0:48:51like the waterproof Walkman that were bright yellow.
0:48:54Yeah.
0:48:55No, Sony's still like that.
0:48:58I continue to be amazed that Sony, they've fallen so low, right?
0:49:02But they still have some designers and they're doing interesting things.
0:49:06Look at the design of the PlayStation 2, for instance.
0:49:08It was very futuristic and impressive.
0:49:11And the PlayStation 3 did look like a George Foreman grill, but always everything you do
0:49:15is interesting in terms of design.
0:49:18Unfortunately, the rest of the things that the company does is not probably doing that
0:49:22And now they're like a movie studio and all sorts of other entanglements and messed up things
0:49:26but design wise there is there are some good designers still at Sony and
0:49:30They do make things that sort of capture the imagination more than like compare the original Xbox
0:49:36Which is also black plastic, right?
0:49:38I like it's like oh just like a ps2 but that like if you can't tell the difference between the original Xbox and the ps2
0:49:43In terms of design like there's your problem, right?
0:49:46If you can't detect that difference like well, they're both plastic
0:49:49They both have the black plastic, they have slats in them.
0:49:51Damn, they look about the same.
0:49:53One's obviously bigger than the other, but you know, ignoring the size difference, like
0:49:55there's a huge difference design-wise between those two things.
0:49:58Yeah, and I would say the controllers too.
0:50:00I mean, and I know that controllers are – it's almost like we're going to get into how
0:50:04clicky your keyboard should be, but – and I'm not a gamer, but I've just thought
0:50:08just at like a snap judgment level that PlayStation controllers have always looked very appealing
0:50:13to me, and Xbox ones, for example, not so much.
0:50:16Yeah, unfortunately when it comes to controllers or things you're going to hold in your hand,
0:50:20how it looks like, that's when Sony's failing there. And Apple's failing to many degrees.
0:50:25Think of the hockey puck mouse or even the current Magic Mouse, which I feel like is
0:50:27too low. If you have a visual design aesthetic and you want things to look just so, that
0:50:35is exactly the wrong instinct to indulge when you're making something that fits inside someone's
0:50:39hand.
0:50:40And that they're not supposed to look at while they're using.
0:50:41Right. I mean, Sony does make, they did make their controllers beautiful and symmetrical
0:50:45with conical sections for the little things that you hold, but that's not what shape people's
0:50:49hands are in.
0:50:50And so it looks like a nice piece of art, but it's not great to hold.
0:50:53Whereas Microsoft, in the other direction, said, "We're selling to 30-year-old guys.
0:50:58Make the controller bigger.
0:50:59Make it bubblous and strange."
0:51:01And yeah, it's an ugly thing, but I think the Xbox controller is actually a more successful
0:51:05controller than the PlayStation controller.
0:51:08But yeah, looking at the two of them, one of them looks like a hamburger, and the other
0:51:10one looks like a sleek, futuristic thing.
0:51:14Yeah, I totally agree with that.
0:51:18Here's another bit of taste.
0:51:21Remember the – this is back in September 2010 when Windows Phone 7 was released to
0:51:28manufacturing and they held a funeral parade on Microsoft's campus for the BlackBerry
0:51:36and iPhone.
0:51:37Yeah.
0:51:38Like, compare that to Apple, which had a funeral for its own operating system, Mac OS 9.
0:51:43That's very true.
0:51:44They had a coffin on stage, and it was for their own product that they were crossing.
0:51:47Not that Apple hasn't beyond propaganda.
0:51:49They do the start your photocopiers and trashing Windows or whatever.
0:51:54But that's, I mean, in all cases, that always seems kind of unseemly.
0:51:59If you're the underdog, sometimes you need that to motivate the troops.
0:52:04When Apple was the underdog, that's when it worked, and then they started to become the
0:52:07overdog.
0:52:08That's when it became a little bit distasteful.
0:52:09But at that point, Microsoft had this momentum of being the big dog, and it's kind of unseemly
0:52:16for them to be trashing the other competitors.
0:52:19But that just fits into the Cold War mentality and the propaganda.
0:52:22It's like, "Oh, everything we do is 100% better than them.
0:52:24Everything they do is terrible.
0:52:25We are the best.
0:52:26We're going to win."
0:52:27And that's not helpful.
0:52:30That type of propaganda doesn't motivate the troops, because they know it's not true
0:52:33just as much as you know or should know that it's not true.
0:52:37There's a measured rational response that will let the people in your company know that
0:52:42you understand what is better about those other products and you're still behind, you
0:52:46still believe your company can best them, but now you know what you have to do.
0:52:50And that is not communicated by just blind, rah-rah cheerleading for everything that your
0:52:56company does.
0:52:57Right.
0:52:58And I think it's kind of dispiriting if you're the troops, if you can't believe everything
0:53:04that your leader says, right?
0:53:05I mean, I think everybody at Microsoft knew that Windows Phone 7, no matter how well it
0:53:11did and no matter how good it was, and it was certainly a lot better than everything
0:53:16Microsoft had done in mobile before, but it wasn't going to kill the iPhone.
0:53:21I don't think there was anybody there who believed it, maybe except for Ballmer.
0:53:24They could have had that meeting if they had Windows Phone 7 series, Phone 7, you know,
0:53:29a year before the iPhone, right?
0:53:30Right.
0:53:31Because then it really would have been like, wow, where the hell did this come from?
0:53:34it was so much better than what they had before. They were justifiably proud of it, but again,
0:53:38they overshoot. And the thing about burying RIM, I think that was their one good call,
0:53:43because I think everyone at that point could – anyone with a brain could see that RIM
0:53:46was in serious trouble. So that was actually a good call on their part.
0:53:49I think everybody in the computer industry could see it, because I think what everybody
0:53:53could see – and that was the whole basis of the big "Why I thought RIM was screwed"
0:53:57thing in 2008 – was simply from the basis of, look, we call them smartphones, but they're
0:54:02not phones. They're little tiny personal computers that happen to have cell phone networking.
0:54:09And RIM has no experience making computers. They make little messaging devices. They're
0:54:15screwed because they can't make computers. And they eventually realized that when they
0:54:20bought, what do you call it, the QNX? Yeah, yeah, the QNX, which was, you know, got them
0:54:26in the game with a, you know, by all measures, you know, say what you want about the BlackBerry
0:54:31OS, but the QNX core underneath is super well regarded. It's the real deal. But it was way
0:54:41too little too late. And I think that's clear. Even Microsoft could see, hey, these things
0:54:46are all little computers now. RIM's out of the game.
0:54:49Yeah. Which one were they burying? They were at a half-uneral for RIM. Who else?
0:54:55It was BlackBerry and iPhone.
0:54:56Oh, and iPhone. No, they didn't even put...
0:54:58That's the two they lumped together.
0:55:00No.
0:55:01The reason they probably didn't mention Nokia is the same reason everyone thought Nokia
0:55:03was invincible because you look at the sales number and you're like, "Well, Nokia sells
0:55:06like a hodgillion phones every year."
0:55:08So we're not even going to talk about that because obviously nobody can touch Nokia and
0:55:11they'll be on top forever.
0:55:12That's the business sense of not realizing that what they're selling are feature phones,
0:55:18dumb phones.
0:55:19Well, and I wouldn't be surprised.
0:55:20I forget when Steven Elop took over as Nokia CEO, which is certainly when it became much
0:55:27more likely that they would license Windows as an operating system. But I wouldn't be
0:55:31surprised if they already had Nokia, you know, on the list of lined up, we'd like them to
0:55:36make Windows Phone seven, they, you know, the big thing, the big similarity between
0:55:41rim and Apple was that they were the two companies that built the whole kit, you know, the hardware
0:55:47and the OS, you know, the companies they couldn't afford to mock where anybody who was a potential
0:55:52OEM for Windows. Yeah, that's probably true. But yeah, but yeah, you're right. Like, if
0:55:57company should know that some other company having a huge head start on the software ecosystem
0:56:03is a big problem, it should have been Microsoft, because that was such a key factor in their
0:56:08success with the PC, getting the apps, getting all this.
0:56:11By that point, the App Star had moved along and had enough momentum that, you're right,
0:56:16nobody in Microsoft believed, even the people cheering the audience believed in their heart
0:56:20of hearts that Windows Phone 7 was going to sweep the iPhone off the table anytime soon.
0:56:27And best case, they're thinking, boy, three years from now, we may be tied with them in
0:56:32terms of developer support and number of apps.
0:56:34And that's best case scenario.
0:56:35Right.
0:56:36I think anybody at Microsoft, even at Ballmer, anybody who should have been the CEO of Microsoft,
0:56:42should have been able to realize immediately the day of the iPhone being unveiled on stage
0:56:48at Macworld in January 2007 that, wow, we've been caught flat-footed, and we need to start
0:56:54today.
0:56:55I mean, right now, immediate emergency meeting, we've got to we've got to think about how
0:57:01we're going to catch up to this, just by looking at what Apple showed on the first day with
0:57:08the iPhone. But even if you didn't have the taste to recognize that the moment where everybody
0:57:13at Microsoft should have had that, you know, this is an emergency meeting would have been
0:57:18a year later when the App Store was announced and response was so incredibly strong from
0:57:26such a diverse array of developers.
0:57:29Yeah, no, like, I can forgive them for not believing or not wanting to believe day of
0:57:34announcement and because it was so different. The iPhone was so different that there was
0:57:37a good chance like if you didn't if you didn't understand like what they were showing there,
0:57:41there's like, this seems kind of weird could go either way, right. And I would say like
0:57:46A year later, that's way too late.
0:57:47I would say the time when you should have that meeting if you didn't have it immediately,
0:57:52because I think it makes sense not to have it immediately.
0:57:54Wait and see.
0:57:55Let's see what's going to happen here.
0:57:56The time to have that meeting is once any of the C-level executives at Microsoft or
0:58:01anybody is able to go to the store, buy an iPhone, bring it home, and play with it, then
0:58:04you damn well better have that meeting because you're like, "Uh-oh.
0:58:07We've got a problem here," because you play with that phone and you realize, "I don't
0:58:10want to go back to my other phone."
0:58:12The iPhone was a compelling product once you had it in your hands, and that's when you
0:58:15need to have that meeting because the proof is in the
0:58:17product, right? $600 or no, if you play around with that thing,
0:58:22you know, on day one, the original iPhone and don't
0:58:24realize, Oh, damn, I cannot go back to my Windows mobile phone
0:58:27after this, we need to have a meeting. That's, that's the
0:58:29problem.
0:58:30That's a good point. And because it was it was it was a product
0:58:33that was as good as the demos claimed it was.
0:58:36And you can't be sure of that. Like they put up on screen like
0:58:38Yeah, like, oh, Microsoft does that. Right? You can't you can't
0:58:42tell until we didn't all know either. We seemed amazing. We
0:58:45trust we had faith in Apple, but until you get that thing in your hand, you're not sure,
0:58:48because it was so weird and different, and it's like, is that even going to work?
0:58:52But yeah, the proof is in the product.
0:58:55Microsoft had to know by the time they all had iPhones.
0:58:57Maybe the fact that Microsoft has a history of sort of sham demos, maybe that actually
0:59:03set them back six months, because they just, you know, much like RIM's famous response
0:59:09where they actually had a meeting the week after the iPhone came out and came away with
0:59:14the conclusion that Apple had faked the whole thing because it wasn't possible, you know,
0:59:19maybe Microsoft had a similar reaction.
0:59:21Yeah, but it's the type of, you know, Cold War analogy again. So they watch the demo,
0:59:26right? And they go down to their phone team and they say, "We just saw this iPhone demo.
0:59:31We're not sure if that's going to fly or if it's BS or we don't know, but, you know, what
0:59:36do you think of it, head of Windows Mobile?" And Windows Mobile says, "Our phones are strong.
0:59:40We don't have to worry. Strong Windows Mobile." You know, because that's what they have to
0:59:43As a company man down the chain of command, you never tell your superior,
0:59:47"We're screwed in the thing we've been working on for these past few years.
0:59:50This does not hold a candle to what they have and we need to regroup."
0:59:52Right?
0:59:53Your initial reaction is always, "Don't worry, everything's fine."
0:59:56Because that's how you got your job, that's how you keep your job.
1:00:00You always just say, "No, everything's great. We're great.
1:00:02Our phones are the best."
1:00:03Because that's the company line.
1:00:04And just if everyone keeps repeating that to themselves
1:00:06while having a sinking feeling in the pit of their stomach, that's bad.
1:00:10I completely agree. I think you had a good point too about the developer support. And
1:00:20one thing that I think should have been terrifying to Microsoft and that because like you said,
1:00:23if any company understands the value of having third party developers support for your platform,
1:00:32it's them. The scariest thing was that Apple almost literally
1:00:42didn't do any work to get that support. They actually worked
1:00:46against it. And we're telling developers at the beginning,
1:00:49we're not even going to let you write apps for this. And third
1:00:53party developers were like, please let us write apps. And
1:00:56they said, No, you can write little web apps. No. And then
1:00:59they were like, please let us write apps. And then like within
1:01:01And then a month of the thing coming out, Craig Hockenberry and Lucas Newman figured
1:01:08out how to write apps around Apple's back with no actual support, no SDK.
1:01:14Lucas Newman had the, what was it, the Lights Out game and--
1:01:18Yeah, that was like when the iPhone was announced.
1:01:21That was the-- and it's amazing to me that Apple, for all its foresight, doesn't see
1:01:25these things, or at least Steve Jobs did initially.
1:01:29I think it was Macworld, right, when it was announced?
1:01:31- Yeah, it was January Macworld.
1:01:33- So at Macworld, you and Cable Sasser did a podcast
1:01:37in the Macworld fishbowl or whatever you were,
1:01:40talking about, of course, talking about the iPhone.
1:01:42And I wasn't there, but I did a,
1:01:45the one video I've ever posted on our stack,
1:01:47I did a little video, and my video was not
1:01:49of how awesome the iPhone is or anything.
1:01:51My video was about the fact that every single person
1:01:55at Macworld, in our circle of people
1:01:57who are like Mac developers who saw that phone said
1:02:00the same thing that I quoted from Cable Sasser
1:02:02from your podcast and interview, which is like,
1:02:04can we write apps for this phone?
1:02:06Because that would be awesome.
1:02:07I'm paraphrasing, but I think I got it almost exactly.
1:02:09That was the story.
1:02:11Macworld was like, we see this phone, this phone is amazing.
1:02:13Everyone wants, like immediately,
1:02:15not like a month later, a year later, thinking about apps.
1:02:18Like as soon as all the tech nerds saw that phone,
1:02:21they're like, I want my apps to be on that phone.
1:02:24I want to write apps.
1:02:24That was the day of the announcement.
1:02:26He was saying that.
1:02:27And that, you know, and that's the video I have was like the song "Dance With Me" because
1:02:31everyone's just like, "Yes, you, me, phone, we together make beautiful apps, right?
1:02:35We don't even know how to make apps.
1:02:36We don't know anything about this thing.
1:02:38We don't know what makes a good iPhone app, but we know we want to be there and we want
1:02:40to write apps."
1:02:41There's a template to Apple's keynote presentations.
1:02:46And you can almost see, well, not like a literal keynote template, but there probably is for
1:02:50that too, but a form that they typically follow.
1:02:55one of them often is for a new thing, they'll say, "Here's ten things we want
1:03:01you to know about it," and I'll go through the ten. But you can also see then how
1:03:04that maybe they started with 40 things, and they say, "Here's the 40 things we
1:03:09might want to talk about. What are the ten that'll be the best to talk about in
1:03:12the thing?" And I'm sure that, you know, it's a weeks long, we could do these ten,
1:03:16you could do these, you could do this. They pick the ten, they rehearse the ten,
1:03:20they have them ready to go. And then there's often a slide where they'll show
1:03:24like the other 30 or 40 things. It's like one slide with all these different other features
1:03:30in various sizes of myriad. And they'll say look, and there's all this stuff too. And at the iPhone
1:03:38debut at Mac world, that slide had up in like the upper right corner, one of the words was cocoa.
1:03:45Like they never had Steve Jobs never said cocoa. It was just a word on a slide with like 30 other
1:03:52features of the iPhone but but here's what he did say though that's why I was
1:03:55flipping out he said it runs OS 10 OS 10 was that right that brief naming thing
1:04:01of fun right he said it runs OS 10 and up on that slide it said Coco and it
1:04:07like you said in our crowd everybody was already over the fact that it was so
1:04:11awesome looking but it was that they'd already start you know they realized
1:04:14that this thing you know if it was if that was true that you could build apps
1:04:19because that's how they made their apps you know that it was you know all these
1:04:24like Jurassic Park this is a unique system I know this I know Coco I can
1:04:28write an app for that phone right that that just by him saying it runs OS 10
1:04:33and that word Coco that everybody in our crowd had already figured out that iOS
1:04:37was what iOS is that it was the mythical stripped down version of OS 10 with the
1:04:44next step frameworks for application development and everyone wanted to write
1:04:48an app like we all saw the app and it's kind of like Apple falling ass backwards
1:04:52into success like the same thing with jobs you know refusing to make iTunes
1:04:56for Windows for so long it had to be argued down by the rest of the you know
1:05:01slightly less stubborn executive team at Apple like fine we'll make it for
1:05:06Windows and let these stupid iPod become a runaway success if that's what you
1:05:09want fine go ahead don't ask that was like more or less how it happened all
1:05:16All right, second sponsor break. I want to tell you about, this is another repeat sponsor.
1:05:21Just by coincidence, but I know that they have also sponsored the ATP. They know their
1:05:26audience. This is Transporter by our friends at Connected Data. Now you remember Transporter.
1:05:34Transporter is your own private distributed storage service. Again, this analogy comes
1:05:42from them. I'm not making it up. It's like your own private Dropbox. You buy a piece
1:05:47of hardware from them. You install the hardware right there in your home in your office wherever
1:05:52you want it. You can buy more than one of them. You can distribute them. You sign up
1:05:56for your transporter account and you get a little shared Dropbox style storage system.
1:06:06I don't know how you describe it. It just works. You install the software, you install
1:06:10the hardware and then all of a sudden whatever you put in your transporter is on all of your
1:06:15transporters. Why would you use this instead of Dropbox? It's because you control and own
1:06:19the hardware. This is not online storage. There are cloud storage. There is no mysterious
1:06:23transporter place where they have your data. Your data only exists on these hardware devices
1:06:29that you own, which is important for untold many reasons. Some people have to based on
1:06:35client regulations or other privacy recu--, you know, things, HIPAA things for people
1:06:41who work in medicine. I don't know if any of you have heard about this. There's an organization
1:06:46in the US called the NSA that is apparently listening to John and I record this show right
1:06:52now. All sorts of reasons why you might want to control privately your own data. Well,
1:06:58guess what? They've got version 2.0 software coming out of beta. It's--. They've got early
1:07:05access to it. Whole bunch of amazing new features. They have new videos that show you how to
1:07:12set up a transporter, how easy it is to use with your Mac, how easy it is to share files
1:07:16and folders with friends and colleagues. And you can watch those videos at www.filetransporter.com/howto.
1:07:26Now they spell how to H-O-W dash T-O. I'll bet if you just went to their homepage, you
1:07:33You could probably find those videos too. They have a special offer for listeners of
1:07:38the talk show. To celebrate the early access release of their 2.0 software, Connected Data
1:07:44is offering listeners of this show 50 bucks off their purchase of a transporter. This
1:07:51applies to all three configurations of their hardware. You can buy the zero terabyte model.
1:07:56That's for the nerds. That's if you want to install your own hard drive. Kind of a cool
1:08:00option. They also have models with one terabyte or two pair terabyte drives. No matter which
1:08:07one you choose, you could save 50 bucks. I mean, that's a serious discount. That is like,
1:08:11I mean, that's no joke. All you have to do to save that money is use this code, TALK8,
1:08:18T-A-L-K, and then the digit 8. You want to act now though, because that code doesn't last
1:08:25The discount is only available through midnight, September 15th.
1:08:31So don't wait till the 15th and try to guess which time zone midnight the expiration is in.
1:08:37Just go now. Check it out. If you like it, buy it. Use the code. You'll save 50 bucks.
1:08:42But do it before September 15th at filetransporterstore.com.
1:08:50Got a file transporter?
1:08:52I do, I just promoted it to my little network attached storage area I have in the basement.
1:08:57I bought a UPS, hooked the transporter up to it.
1:08:59That's what I like about network attached storage, is you can put it somewhere where
1:09:02it's like completely out of sight and it just seems like magic.
1:09:05Then like no matter where you are in the world, like you have access to the storage.
1:09:08And I know it's sitting in my basement, I know where it is, but it seems like magic.
1:09:14Really great guys, great company.
1:09:16What were we just talking about?
1:09:20What was the last thing?
1:09:21Microsoft, I don't know, we're probably done with Microsoft.
1:09:26Yeah.
1:09:27There's a little bit of dancing on their grave, I feel like.
1:09:29Yeah.
1:09:30But it's kind of a little bit unseemly to, you know, Microsoft.
1:09:33Any other names we want to toss out?
1:09:35What about Steven Sinofsky?
1:09:36What about bringing him back?
1:09:38I don't know if he knew, I don't know if he knows how to make Microsoft successful.
1:09:43I think he's a smart guy and I think he has some good ideas, but, I mean, he's not, it's not terrible.
1:09:49It's not terrible. I don't think if they brought him back. I wouldn't say that like
1:09:54It would require there to be like unbeknownst to us
1:09:58You know that before he was pushed out by Ballmer that you know the board said Tori
1:10:05Well or that you know whatever the disagreement was with Ballmer that the board agrees that
1:10:11Sinofsky's should have won that argument
1:10:13You know seems a little antisocial though like he seems like hard to get on with this in the same vein as forestall
1:10:19Yeah, but that might work better if he's the CEO.
1:10:22Yeah, it only works better if he has good ideas, though.
1:10:25Right.
1:10:26Well...
1:10:27I mean, he did, like...
1:10:29I don't know.
1:10:30I can't get a read on him.
1:10:31He certainly has a lot of the aspects that you want, and that he's got that quality of
1:10:35he's going to boldly do things.
1:10:38I just don't have quite enough faith that he is going to do the right things.
1:10:43And I also don't have quite enough faith to believe that he is going to bend in the way
1:10:48that you would want him to bend.
1:10:50Steve Jobs was pig-headed, stubborn, and obnoxious with the best of them.
1:10:54He defined that practically in the CEO space.
1:10:56And yet, he was able to be argued down into doing iTunes on Windows and being pissy about
1:11:02it and everything.
1:11:03But the fact that he was able to allow that to happen speaks volumes.
1:11:10If the stereotype of Steve Jobs was actually true, there's no way he would have let that
1:11:13happen and that would have been a terrible mistake.
1:11:15So I don't know if Sinofsky is the type of guy who is going to be bold and have great
1:11:19ideas and power through, but know when all the other smart people you surrounded yourself
1:11:24are arguing against you that sometimes you should give in.
1:11:26You know what I mean?
1:11:27And that, I think, is key.
1:11:28Yeah.
1:11:29I don't know him well enough.
1:11:31I don't know.
1:11:32I was just trying to pick somebody from within Microsoft, and even though Sinofsky is no
1:11:35longer within Microsoft, I think if they named him as CEO, it would be seen sort of as an
1:11:40internal.
1:11:41You know it would be a repudiate a big repudiation of balmer. Yeah, definitely
1:11:45What about the all the guys who got kicked out with the courier project didn't get kicked out?
1:11:51But like they can't courier and then that team sort of spread to the four winds who is there was Jay Allard
1:11:56Jay Jay just just the letter J. I went to school with him, so now I can't imagine somebody went to school with Ryan Microsoft
1:12:03So I'm cutting him off the list
1:12:05Robbie Bach
1:12:07Yeah, like that's what I was thinking of.
1:12:09So if the vision is Microsoft is going to be remade as a consumer electronic services
1:12:16company that makes devices and hardware and software, like that's the vision which Ballmer
1:12:20articulated, that the board agrees that Microsoft should go and just sort of be kind of like
1:12:24Apple in that way.
1:12:27Pulling somebody from the side of Microsoft that was always on the consumer electronics
1:12:31thing, like the Xbox guys, like Robbie Bach was involved with Xbox, I believe, in Courier
1:12:34and all that type of stuff.
1:12:37If this is what you want Microsoft to be in the future, those guys might be someplace
1:12:41to look because that was always their passion.
1:12:43It was always to pull Microsoft in that direction.
1:12:45I mean, Jay Lard and those guys brought the plan to Bill Gates and said, "Why doesn't
1:12:50Microsoft make a game console?"
1:12:51And we're able to make that happen within Microsoft, which shows that they have some
1:12:54ability to navigate the political dangers of the company and make things happen.
1:12:58And they were doing the courier thing and got candid.
1:13:00Who knows if courier was any good or not, but their instincts are in that direction.
1:13:04So if you want Microsoft to do that, maybe those guys.
1:13:07And pulled it off without having it called Windows Game Platform Certified 2000 and without
1:13:15a win.
1:13:16I mean, I guess Xbox has always, yeah, I'm almost certain it has always run with the
1:13:21Windows NT kernel and that programming games for the Xbox was always, part of the appeal
1:13:28was supposedly that it was a lot like writing Windows PC games.
1:13:33The DirectX box, DirectX was their 3D API.
1:13:35Right, but from a consumer standpoint, a branding standpoint, and a user interface standpoint,
1:13:42no legacy whatsoever.
1:13:45This is what a game platform should look like.
1:13:47People keep crapping on the Xbox, that product line in terms of, if you look over its entire
1:13:52life, I believe it has either been money neutral or losing money.
1:13:55They had huge write downs for their hardware problems with the red ring of death.
1:14:00the beginning the Xbox are really expensive to make or whatever but I
1:14:02always come back to it as that that should be held up as a Microsoft success
1:14:06financially maybe not but like they entered a very difficult market with you
1:14:11know fierce competitors an established market and were able to make a name for
1:14:15themselves that now they are always a serious contender to be number one in
1:14:19any console generation and the value of that may be diminishing but it shows
1:14:23that Microsoft like it's it's it's like Microsoft did something right they you
1:14:27you know, kind of, sort of with fumbles or whatever, but there are so many people who
1:14:31would never even think of entering that market. It's like a bunch of sharks in there, right?
1:14:35And Microsoft did it and succeeded, and I think it's to their credit.
1:14:39Yeah, and I think that, you know, it's like they could have, like one of the ways that
1:14:47come the day that the iPhone shipped in 2007 and they had the, what they should have had,
1:14:52the what the hell are we going to do moment, that that team could have proposed, you know,
1:14:57something called like the X pad and base it on the Xbox branding and say look why don't
1:15:02we make something you know a gaming type thing and we can also you know I don't know.
1:15:10They could have made a part like the portable gaming space has been a real thing for a long
1:15:13time Sony's got a portable system that you've all heard of the Game Boy right so the next
1:15:17logical step for Microsoft you know say we are now established player in the in the console
1:15:21space why don't we also make a handheld and that like is the limit of Microsoft's
1:15:26corporate tolerance for strategy tax type things.
1:15:29Like, whoa, whoa, whoa.
1:15:30If there's going to be anything portable in your hands that's
1:15:32going to play Xbox games, it's going
1:15:34to be name whatever the group is that's
1:15:36working on Microsoft's current tablet computing initiative.
1:15:39And that one gets killed by the strategy tax.
1:15:40Like, are we let you do this Xbox thing
1:15:42without having Windows logo pop up and stuff like that?
1:15:44But there's no way in hell you're
1:15:46making the Microsoft Game Boy, because the phone group
1:15:49doesn't like that.
1:15:50The tablet group doesn't like that.
1:15:51And then it's a whole strategy tax thing.
1:15:53And that's why the Xbox Moment was
1:15:56kind of amazing that they were able to get that product, but like, there was that was
1:16:00like their limit. Like, look, this Xbox thing is losing money, you are in no position to
1:16:03dictate that we should make a portable. Everyone knows Nintendo has that, you know, market
1:16:07sewn up anyway, so forget it. And so they never did make the Microsoft Game Boy. And
1:16:12yeah,
1:16:13And it's it speaks to the credibility of the Xbox, though. And like you said, like that
1:16:17it should be seen as a long term success that it would such a thing would have had instant
1:16:21credibility.
1:16:22Yeah, no, totally. Like at this point, like if the Xbox was spun off as a separate company,
1:16:27just completely cleanly separated, people would still say, "Come, you know, the next
1:16:32generation of game consoles in, you know, eight years or something, if there is a next
1:16:37generation of game consoles," they would be talking about them as like, you know, people
1:16:42to watch.
1:16:43Company worth listening to.
1:16:44Yeah.
1:16:45I'll go to the big announcement that they've scheduled for next year.
1:16:47Yes, no, totally. Like, because there are so few, I mean, it's like the personal computer
1:16:50operating system space. How many people, if you had a company now and said, "You know
1:16:54what? I'm going to get into personal computer operating systems." You're going to do what?
1:16:58That's crazy. It was like the same thing with the game console. "I'm going to make a game
1:17:01console." It's a platform. Who wants to make a platform? RIM, to its credit, made another
1:17:08platform, which was unheard of practically. They did it not in the PC space, but they
1:17:11said, "We're going to make a new platform." That is so unprecedented and so rare to happen
1:17:16it's so difficult to do. It was short lived platform. It's going down the tubes, but
1:17:20they did it. You know, you're talking about the bb 10.
1:17:23Yeah, no, like, they're, you know, they're messaging service. Like, they, it was a platform.
1:17:31And it's so hard to make those and to make them succeed.
1:17:34Even if even if only fleetingly. Yeah. Yeah.
1:17:43One last, well, any other names you want to toss out as a possible CEO?
1:17:46I don't know many executives.
1:17:51My gut feeling is it's going to be somebody and somebody I've never heard of.
1:17:55Someone from inside Microsoft, like, yeah, you just go down the corporate letter of Microsoft
1:18:01and pick for one of the 800 vice presidents and say, I mean, the thing is, there could be
1:18:04untapped talent inside Microsoft. I don't want to poo poo that either. Like, I don't know all those
1:18:08people. It might be the best case scenario for them too. It's like, you need the right guy.
1:18:12Like I you know, that's that's the key decision
1:18:14You don't we talked about the optics before of like oh
1:18:17How's this gonna look in the press and who is what does it happens gonna stock price whatever all that is gonna you just gonna
1:18:21Have to deal with whatever happens
1:18:23That you just got to find the right person at the right person is in Microsoft fine
1:18:27If they're outside Microsoft fine
1:18:29Whatever you got to do get the right person and don't worry about what's going to happen the day you announce it because that is
1:18:34Who cares?
1:18:35Yeah
1:18:36Somebody who you know and and Microsoft has to be Microsoft, you know
1:18:41They can't beat that. They're never gonna win if they try to be Apple or anybody else or Google I
1:18:45Would say this I would say in mobile I would say maybe and just that maybe the last point I want to make about
1:18:54bomber and Microsoft is
1:18:56That maybe the iPhone is almost not irrelevant
1:18:59But is not the thing people should look at as the main failing of Microsoft in mobile
1:19:05I would say the two companies that show what a failure Microsoft has been in mobile are rim
1:19:10and Android, which I sort of separate from Google.
1:19:15But that RIM's long-term success, I mean the whole bread and butter of
1:19:20RIM through their heyday was in the
1:19:23corporate market. I mean it was a long time before they even became a consumer
1:19:26brand.
1:19:27That, like RIM's days as a consumer success
1:19:31were pretty fleeting, but they spent, you know, a long time as a big success in IT.
1:19:36That market should have been Microsoft's.
1:19:40The fact that they let RIM become the de facto corporate mobile OS should have been seen
1:19:48as a failure very early.
1:19:50And I think that if they had somehow, if Windows Mobile, crummy as it was taste-wise, had been
1:19:57the success that RIM was all along, I think Microsoft would have had something to parlay
1:20:04off a lot sooner and they'd be in a much better position today even in the consumer market.
1:20:09That was classic low-end disruption because Microsoft had a smartphone platform, but Microsoft's
1:20:15like, "When we feel the smartphone platform, it's going to be Windows on a phone.
1:20:19It's going to be Windows CE, Windows Consumer Edition, the whole nine yards."
1:20:24Whereas BlackBerry, unconstrained by that kind of attitude of, "Well, it has to be full
1:20:29Windows," they gave you basically a pager that you could type on.
1:20:31Exactly.
1:20:32That was really good.
1:20:33And then they ramped up from, "A pager you can type on?
1:20:35Whatever.
1:20:36We're making Windows on a phone.
1:20:37Have you seen our thing?
1:20:38It's a friggin' smartphone.
1:20:39one megabyte of RAM and you can run these, you know, it's a stylus, right? And if we don't care
1:20:44about this pager with a keyboard and you know, it was low on disruption that pager with a keyboard
1:20:48grew smarter and bigger and better. And you know, servers were attached to it. And like,
1:20:52even when it was just a pager with the keyboard, the utility of being able to just, you know,
1:20:55tap out emails on your little pager with a keyboard thing was unbelievable. And it was
1:20:59easy to use. You know, you could, the function it was designed to use, you could use it for
1:21:03immediately. And that, that's what made Blackberry and Microsoft was too tied up and thinking we have
1:21:09have to ship you an entire PC in your hand, which they weren't ready to do yet, you know?
1:21:13Right. Yeah, because BBM is always sort of like a halfway between email and texting.
1:21:19And it was exactly, you know, it was the exact thing that the technology of the Times, it
1:21:25was like optimal for the technology of the Times.
1:21:28Targeted the people who needed to be able to basically send email from anywhere in the
1:21:31world.
1:21:32And had the money to pay for it.
1:21:33Yeah.
1:21:34know, paid paid relatively large monthly fees. And then I say
1:21:39Android, because clearly what and you know, it's it's Android,
1:21:43not the iPhone that is now where Microsoft thought it was going
1:21:47to be, you know, an OS that OEMs make device, you know, like what
1:21:51Windows was, I mean, and you know, a lot of people pointed
1:21:54this out that in broad terms, you know, maybe the percent, you
1:21:56know, certainly the percentages of market share are different.
1:21:58But in broad terms, it's almost uncanny how much Android is to
1:22:04mobile what Windows was to PCs and iOS and the iPhone are to mobile what the Mac and
1:22:11Mac OS were to PCs.
1:22:13How can you blame Microsoft for not doing what Android did though?
1:22:16Because Microsoft must have been looking at Android and saying, "They're doing exactly
1:22:20what we do except for the part where you collect the money."
1:22:22Exactly.
1:22:23Because they gave it away to everybody, right?
1:22:26And that works with Google's business because their business was get people on the internet,
1:22:29get them to do Google searches, collect their personal information, because they were an
1:22:32advertising company.
1:22:33But Microsoft didn't have that business model.
1:22:35And so it's like, how could you compete with Android?
1:22:38How could you out Android Android?
1:22:39You had to get there first, which Microsoft was.
1:22:41So they could have done that.
1:22:41But once Android is out the door,
1:22:43it's like, so do we subsidize this
1:22:46with our exchange licenses?
1:22:47Do we become an advertising company?
1:22:49Because it was so hard for them to go to the OEMs
1:22:52and say, you should make Windows phones.
1:22:54For a while, they could use their licensing terms
1:22:56for the Windows operating system for their PCs as leverage.
1:22:58But that starts to fade in power.
1:23:00And Google was a tough competitor,
1:23:02because they had the skills and they gave the thing away for free.
1:23:06And they subsidized it.
1:23:07I think maybe the only chance they had, and it is true, and it's part of what makes Google
1:23:14such a difficult competitor in any market it gets into because they give everything
1:23:20away and subsidize it through advertising, that they're very, very good at monetizing
1:23:27you know, in, you know, very small pennies, you know, pennies, pennies per view multiplied
1:23:34by a very large number ends up being, you know, billions of dollars. But I think Microsoft's
1:23:41opportunity was to have Windows Mobile be way better than what Android was sooner. Because
1:23:48the first few years of Android after it shipped, it was really bad. I mean, it got, it's gotten
1:23:54a lot better very quickly. But like, you know, 2009, 2010, Android was a really, really crummy
1:24:01system. And maybe there was an opportunity there where, look, you know, your competitors
1:24:07might be paying $0 to Google for Android, but you can pay us $10 for a license for Windows
1:24:14Mobile and your phone is going to look a hell of a lot better in the cell phone store.
1:24:19Yeah, and they did that for a while. They had a lot of people making Windows Mobile
1:24:22phones, and sometimes either also making Android phones
1:24:25or making Windows mobile phones instead of.
1:24:27And they'd go to the big name people, and they'd like, oh,
1:24:29you should make a Windows mobile phone,
1:24:30because you're a brand name.
1:24:32And they'll let those other random Asian manufacturers
1:24:34make Android phones.
1:24:35But it was like the product they were offering,
1:24:37it was maybe better, and it had a big Microsoft name
1:24:40and everything, but it was not better enough.
1:24:42Right, and I don't think it was.
1:24:44And for example, I mean, to me, this is the biggest tell,
1:24:46is that HTC is the perfect example.
1:24:49Because at one point HTC was by far the world's biggest Windows phone maker.
1:24:55I forget what percentage of Windows phones were HTC, but I think it was like a majority
1:24:59share.
1:25:00Like at least 50% of all Windows phones were HTC.
1:25:04Maybe a lot higher.
1:25:07And you know, clearly now it's a, I mean I don't think, I guess HTC maybe tried making
1:25:12one Windows 8 phone or something like that, but almost everything HTC sells is Android.
1:25:17The HTC is kind of like a cautionary tale, though.
1:25:19Like, this is what happens when you listen to the siren
1:25:21song of Microsoft and try to get on board with their Windows
1:25:24thing.
1:25:25It distracts you.
1:25:25And by the time-- like, now they're kind of recovering,
1:25:28and they have-- the HTC One is an amazing phone that
1:25:31people feel like should be doing better than it is.
1:25:33But it's like, well, you spent all that time off
1:25:35with Microsoft.
1:25:36And while you were doing that, Samsung came
1:25:39and became the name and face of good Android phones.
1:25:42And despite the fact that you now have a great phone
1:25:45the HTC one, you know, Samsung, people associate, you know, the name Galaxy tab, the whole product,
1:25:51you know, like, as like, Damn, if we didn't spend all that time making those windows phones,
1:25:56we would, you know, maybe we could be Samsung. Yeah, maybe. Alright, let me do the last sponsor
1:26:00break. And then we'll talk to you about about video games. Do you play any video games?
1:26:04I do. Alright, last sponsor. Great sponsor. Another repeat sponsor delighted to have him
1:26:10our friends at igloo igloo is an intranet
1:26:14that you'll actually like don't just take my word for it
1:26:18don't just take igloo's word for it there's a case study
1:26:22actual customer Children's Hospital Foundation
1:26:26in Washington DC now this is an outfit they were using
1:26:30shared drives USB drives walking around almost like the old sneaker net
1:26:35and email and a complicated SharePoint
1:26:39intranet to manage everything in their organization.
1:26:42Well, they set a goal.
1:26:43They wanted double their fundraising,
1:26:45and they needed a better way
1:26:46for the whole organization to collaborate.
1:26:48So they tried out a whole bunch of different software.
1:26:50They chose Igloo.
1:26:52And after they set it up, after their whole staff saw
1:26:55how easy it was using Igloo to collaborate,
1:26:59they actually clapped.
1:27:00They had like a company-wide meeting where they said,
1:27:02"Here's what we're gonna use.
1:27:03"Here's what it looks like.
1:27:04"Here's how it works."
1:27:05And the staff broke out in applause.
1:27:07Children's Hospital Foundation has been using igloo for a year now. Still love it still
1:27:14with it. And here's the thing, they have a new software update just came out the other
1:27:18day at the end of August. They call it scone. That's the name of the new update. Every igloo
1:27:23customer was instantly upgraded as soon as it came out because it's a web app. New stuff
1:27:27that they have they've a new HTML five document previews, video previews, improved analytics
1:27:34and a whole bunch more. When they come up with a software update, everybody's existing
1:27:38igloo internet already automatically gets upgraded. Great service. And this is the part
1:27:45that's amazing. It's free to use with up to 10 people. So if you're a small team, it's
1:27:51free for your team to use. If you're a big team, you can try it out, have a group of
1:27:55you, try it out with up to 10 of you just to see if you like it. And when your igloo
1:27:59grows when you need to add people, it's only $12 a person a month. Go to igloosoftware.com/thetalkshow
1:28:10to start building your igloo. igloosoftware.com/thetalkshow and start building your igloo. And don't forget,
1:28:18if you're new, go to their homepage and they have a whole bunch of sandwich videos made
1:28:22by the aforementioned Adam Lisagor. And they're hilarious. It's like a little sitcom that
1:28:29that he made for a glue. I should say they made I don't know sandwich videos getting
1:28:35big they got they got like a whole team.
1:28:36I did everything himself. Oh, he camera video right. He makes you think that I don't he
1:28:43might be semi retired at this point.
1:28:46It's a series of body doubles. Yeah.
1:28:50He's actually officiating the the the aforementioned. See, that's what I'm saying. How can you be
1:28:55doing all these things at once? He makes videos, he stars in the videos, he officiates weddings,
1:28:59You know?
1:29:00You're going to get into a taxi, go to the airport, he's your driver.
1:29:04He's the pilot on the airplane.
1:29:06He's quite talented.
1:29:09All right, video games.
1:29:11So I wrote a big piece today based on -- it was funny.
1:29:15I didn't plan on it.
1:29:17Somebody on Twitter said the reason that I stirred up so much shit by saying that Nintendo
1:29:20should make -- I wrote like a two-line link list entry that said they should just give
1:29:24in and make iOS games when they announced the new 2DS last week. And I got so -- I got
1:29:30great feedback from it. I don't mean it in terms of you dummies shouldn't send me feedback.
1:29:34It was great. I mean, I thought -- I couldn't believe how much interesting stuff came out
1:29:38of a two-sentence piece that I wrote. But I had a lot more to say, and I wrote it today.
1:29:43I won't repeat it here. I'll assume everybody who's listened has read it. But the gist of
1:29:48it is I stand by it. I think Nintendo is screwed at least in -- maybe especially in handhelds.
1:29:54and I think that I think they should seriously consider making iOS games even if that means
1:30:00that the company is going to shrink in uncomfortable ways.
1:30:05I think you probably get a lot of crap about it for the obvious reason is that like normally
1:30:11I mean you said yourself you're not a gamer and you do write about game technology occasionally
1:30:15but most of your beat is like you know personal computers, mobile phones, stuff like that
1:30:19So the people who are inside that circle are going to say, "This guy doesn't know the history,
1:30:25doesn't have the depth of background and personal experience to comment knowingly on this topic."
1:30:31So you get crap from those people, right?
1:30:33And the flip side of that, which I'm always cognizant of, is that when you're inside that
1:30:39circle, it's very easy to have preconceived notions about what Nintendo is and how they
1:30:45have to behave and sometimes it's the people who are outside that as assuming that you
1:30:49know that they're you know smart people they can give you a view on it that you're not
1:30:53willing to accept because it goes against you know central tenets of your belief system
1:30:58from being a gamer for the past 20 years or whatever so it's always important that when
1:31:01the outside guy says something crazy maybe he's wrong because he doesn't have the background
1:31:05to know about it but on the other hand maybe you can't conceive of that possibility because
1:31:11because it just it runs counter to everything you've felt about Nintendo for the past, you
1:31:15know, 30 years of your life or whatever.
1:31:18I agree with you there. And I, you know, and I'll just say this, I if I end up being proven
1:31:23wrong and have to eat my hat on this one, I'll be happy. Like, let's say 10 years from
1:31:28now, Nintendo still has never made a game for anything but their own systems. And they
1:31:32have a successful handheld platform and it's still a successful plug into your TV platform.
1:31:38news. I would be that would be delighted. And I'm sure that would be good news for the
1:31:42gaming industry. And for people who like to play games and for fans of longtime fans of
1:31:47Nintendo's franchises. Great. I'm I will be happy to be proven wrong. I just don't think
1:31:54so. And to me, you know, the comparison and it's uncomfortable, but I do think that they're
1:31:59in a similar situation to where rim was five, six years ago, in so far as that they're unable
1:32:07to compete as computer makers with iOS and, to a lesser degree, Android.
1:32:14I think that there's a kernel of something in there that you're on the right track about,
1:32:23but in that duality, and again, I'm being very cognizant to try to think outside the
1:32:28box and not accept the accepted narrative of the game industry because I consider myself
1:32:34someone who is deeply entrenched in that world.
1:32:36But I think you are missing a lot of things
1:32:40about Nintendo here,
1:32:40and that's why you're getting a lot of crap.
1:32:42Because you're like, you're off,
1:32:44you veered off in the wrong direction.
1:32:45And the kernel of truth that you have here
1:32:47is what you're getting at.
1:32:48That like, that you see competitors
1:32:52taking the attention and time and money
1:32:55that used to be Nintendo's,
1:32:58and you're thinking, Nintendo doesn't have what it takes
1:33:01to match up with those competitors, right?
1:33:05That you see how people are playing iOS games,
1:33:06people doing this.
1:33:07Can Nintendo compete with that on those terms?
1:33:15And it's like, well, no, they can't.
1:33:16Like you said with BlackBerry,
1:33:17could they make iPhone-caliber hardware and software?
1:33:19Because that's what it was gonna take
1:33:20to stay in the phone business.
1:33:21It's like, all right, here's the iPhone,
1:33:23what do you got, BlackBerry?
1:33:24And they just kept putting out these phones
1:33:26that were not iPhone-caliber,
1:33:28but either in the hardware or the software,
1:33:30Like it's sticking with the hardware keyboard and it's just like no BlackBerry. That's not the bar
1:33:34That's not the minimum entry price is like Windows Phone, right?
1:33:37Windows Phone 7 and 8 like that is a valid entry in the field Android is a valid entry in the field
1:33:43But you are putting out is not you are not competing on the end. It's like well, you know BlackBerry, you know rim BlackBerry is a company
1:33:49Couldn't do that
1:33:51They you know, they didn't they maybe they didn't have time. They didn't have people they were too late whatever
1:33:55They just just couldn't get it together and you know that and so that's what you're saying about about Nintendo
1:33:59But your suggested remedies are not good, I think,
1:34:02and not good at all.
1:34:04Because-- and the other thing you get right
1:34:07is that Nintendo has problems.
1:34:09Like, I think we all agree that Nintendo is in not
1:34:12a terrible spot, but they're not doing well.
1:34:14Like, they're not certainly coming down
1:34:16off the high of the Wii.
1:34:17They're not doing as well as they had to.
1:34:19So I think those are the two parts that, underneath it all,
1:34:22that you're kind of getting right,
1:34:23that you could recognize from seeing the technology.
1:34:25But the rest of the details, I think you're off of that.
1:34:28Well, and one thing I didn't even get into, and this is where I maybe it's even maybe I should
1:34:32have because I think maybe it's even harder problem is I think going forward to remain competitive
1:34:36both handheld and on console. I feel like the ever-growing complexity of the things that the
1:34:49competitors they're against are such that they need a better operating system and
1:34:56and like developer system.
1:35:00And that, you know, that they, you know, I think by all reports that they really have
1:35:04like a crummy one. Like they can't, they still don't think that they can do like
1:35:08patches to games once they've been released.
1:35:12So this is where you get into trouble. Alright, am I wrong? Downloadable content.
1:35:16So, here's what I think Nintendo's problems are. Because like I said, there is, there is a core
1:35:20issue here, right? And here's how I would define Nintendo's problems.
1:35:24the first question you have to ask about Nintendo's problems. Is there a future for game only
1:35:29or sort of game mostly hardware devices that something something that you buy that mostly
1:35:35plays games, maybe just streaming video or things or whatever? Is there a market for
1:35:39that? You know, currently or in the future? And so what's your answer to that question?
1:35:43My answer is yes, but it's shrinking so fast that it doesn't remain, that market doesn't
1:35:55remain big enough to sustain Nintendo.
1:35:57Yeah.
1:35:58So the, I think the question of this is like, I think it's still an open question and I
1:36:02think the upcoming TV console generation, the Xbox one and PlayStation four will give
1:36:08us a really important data point.
1:36:10If they sell in radically lower numbers than expected,
1:36:14like than the previous generation of consoles did,
1:36:17then we'll know that the market for game machines, things
1:36:21that pretty much mostly do games,
1:36:22despite the fact that both the Xbox One and PlayStation 4
1:36:25were also doing Netflix and all these other things,
1:36:27like all the stuff we expect them to do.
1:36:28If they don't sell in high numbers,
1:36:29then we'll know that what you just said
1:36:31is that now is that time, that it's shrinking,
1:36:34and that it's only a matter of time before it goes away.
1:36:36If, on the other hand, they sell in the expected numbers
1:36:40and they sell huge numbers on them, we'll say, All right, well,
1:36:42apparently there is still a market for game only devices. We
1:36:46don't know how long that market's gonna be around. But
1:36:47nobody knows around but like, it hasn't gone away.
1:36:49Let me let me revise and say, for ones that you plug into your
1:36:53TV, in your home entertainment system, non portable ones, non
1:36:58mobile ones. Let me say I don't know. And I'll let me plead
1:37:02ignorance and say that I'm so far out of it that I really
1:37:05don't know. But maybe because I can imagine that as you know, as
1:37:09computing power grows, you could do more and more amazing stuff. And that one that's primarily
1:37:14centered on games will remain unbeatable. And that people have historically, consumers
1:37:20have historically been willing to plug numerous things into their TV. There's a limit. And
1:37:25people get annoyed when you reach a certain limit. But people have, you know, for decades
1:37:30now have had like a cable box and a DVD player and a game machine, you know, and or, you
1:37:37some kind of a streaming box like an Apple TV or a rock you or something like that. So there's
1:37:41a history of that and TVs are made for it with multiple HDMI ports. And it's not that painful
1:37:47to have one more box plugged in. And so I'll say maybe if not probably plugged into the TV. But
1:37:52for mobile for handheld devices, I think the answer is no.
1:37:57Well, I think the question is, like, I don't think you can separate those two because you're saying
1:38:04there is a market attached to your TV and there isn't for handheld, if what you say
1:38:09about handheld is true, there's no reason that that same technology couldn't come and
1:38:14displace the television attached one. You know what I mean? Because we're already at
1:38:18the point where the high-end iPad has previous generation game console caliber power close
1:38:23to it anyway.
1:38:24Right, because the iPad, as small as it is physically, has more pixels than your TV.
1:38:28Oh, yeah, no, but even just the GPU itself, just like if you had it run 1080p, if what
1:38:33say is true and that the market for handheld gaming only hardware doesn't exist, then I
1:38:38think that the power we already have in our phones, like it's only, it's a short distance
1:38:42to say that why can't something similarly small and portable also be your television
1:38:47gaming device, or in addition be your television gaming device? Like, I don't know if you could
1:38:53separate them, because like, the only difference between handheld and attached to your TV is
1:38:57one of like time. It's like the technology that used to be required a big box attached
1:39:01television with the fan now can fit in your phone and that just that will just
1:39:05continue apace right that's why I think the key question is is there a market
1:39:09for any kind of game only a game mostly device and I think for now for this
1:39:14generation I predict that the Xbox one and ps4 will sell in reasonable numbers
1:39:19the time of the game only a game mostly device is not over and the reason I
1:39:23think this is an extremely relevant question for Nintendo is because I don't
1:39:27think Nintendo has what it takes to feel the device that is not a game only a
1:39:30game mostly device. They can't make a personal computing platform. They can't make an app
1:39:34platform. They're not going to compete with Android. They're not going to compete with
1:39:38iOS or even Windows Mobile. I don't think the company has it in them to sell a device
1:39:42that's a general purpose. Because again, like we said, who makes a software platform? How
1:39:47often does that even happen that you make a successful platform? That is not what Nintendo
1:39:51is designed to do. They can't compete in that market. If that's where the market is going,
1:39:55that is more or less the end of the line for Nintendo as we know it as a company, and they
1:39:59could go on and become just a software company, do all the things you talked about or whatever,
1:40:03but that is the line that I would draw. And I don't think that right now is that line.
1:40:07I don't think that you can say that, nope, that time is over. There's no more market
1:40:11for game only devices. Nintendo, your only choice is to become a different kind of company.
1:40:15And that's where I part ways with your suggested solution of them trying out an iOS game.
1:40:21I see it mostly, I don't see that. You might be right though about the fact that if anything
1:40:26is going to end the demand for console.
1:40:33Is console the right word for the ones you plug in?
1:40:35Yeah.
1:40:36All right.
1:40:36Right.
1:40:37But the distinction I'm drawing is game only hardware.
1:40:39You buy it to play games and stream video.
1:40:42You don't run apps.
1:40:45The problem I see for them is more specific.
1:40:49I see it more clearly.
1:40:50And it is in a lot of ways-- and it
1:40:52was hard for me to write the article
1:40:53because I didn't want to just say I have a gut feeling.
1:40:55and I tried to justify it as logically as I could,
1:40:58and I stand behind it.
1:40:59But to me, I see it, and I certainly
1:41:01feel it more viscerally with the handhelds,
1:41:06with the 3DS versus iPhones and Android phones.
1:41:12And number one, I don't think they could even
1:41:15make an iPod Touch caliber device.
1:41:18And if they did, I don't think that they could make it
1:41:21at a cheap enough price.
1:41:23And they're competing.
1:41:24And this is the part where they're almost screwed and it's not even fair, which is that
1:41:28they're competing against the iPhone and Galaxies and other high-end Android phones, which are
1:41:35subsidized in so many markets around the world. And, you know, complain all you want about
1:41:41how subsidized phones, you still end up paying as much or more over the long run. The fact
1:41:45is most people think a brand new iPhone 5 costs $199. And it, you know, it doesn't actually.
1:41:53But how can they compete with that when it's in fact a $700 gadget?
1:41:59I think you're off on this comparison as well because it gets back to the RIM thing where
1:42:04you were saying that RIM was sticking with the hardware keyboard and making the crap
1:42:09your hardware and they just couldn't compete, which was true in the smartphone space.
1:42:13But the key difference between what you're describing and what happened with RIM and
1:42:18is that right now, like you said,
1:42:20Nintendo can't make an iPhone-caliber piece of hardware.
1:42:25When RIM was circling the drain,
1:42:30the devices they were putting out gave inferior experiences.
1:42:34If you bought an iPhone and you bought whatever thing
1:42:36RIM was promoting as their top-of-the-line touch-type thing,
1:42:39the iPhone was better to use.
1:42:41It was nicer, you had access to better apps,
1:42:43they were more fun to use, it was easier,
1:42:45everything about it was better.
1:42:47If you give a kid an iPod Touch and a significantly cheaper
1:42:53Nintendo 2DS, the Nintendo 2DS delivers a far superior gaming
1:42:57experience than the iPod Touch.
1:43:01I kind of disagree with that.
1:43:02Totally superior gaming experience
1:43:04for all but the very, very most casual games-- Angry Birds,
1:43:09Cutthroat, stuff like that.
1:43:12The Nintendo handheld is more valuable.
1:43:15That's why the games can command a higher price,
1:43:17because they're more valuable.
1:43:18The people who really, really love games
1:43:21love the Nintendo handhelds.
1:43:23To the degree you like games,
1:43:24you would like the Nintendo handheld
1:43:26better than an iPod touch.
1:43:27And in the same way, the people who are gaga for smartphones
1:43:30and love smartphones love the iPhone.
1:43:32They did not, you know, the rim started to look ancient.
1:43:34And I think you're judging on the wrong criteria.
1:43:37Like, retina screens, it's meaningless
1:43:39on a Nintendo handheld.
1:43:41- I'm gonna disagree with you there.
1:43:44- Because they're not displaying text.
1:43:45It's not just playing apps, right?
1:43:50And it's not-- it's definitely not better at all things.
1:43:52And like I wrote, there's certainly
1:43:54some games where you want a D-pad and buttons.
1:43:56No doubt about it.
1:43:57And those are traditionally Nintendo's bread and butter
1:44:00games, because they've built the game specifically
1:44:02for the hardware.
1:44:04And again, I'm not advising that they just
1:44:06take the existing games and put a virtual D-pad on iOS
1:44:10and call it a day.
1:44:11I think if they're going to do it,
1:44:12They've got to make games that are meant to be run on iOS.
1:44:16But the same -- there was a few things, though, that BlackBerry was and maybe even today is
1:44:21still better at than iOS.
1:44:23There are very few, but it's specific to messaging, like going through email.
1:44:27And I remember one time years ago -- I don't know, it was probably back in 2008, and I
1:44:31think it was one of the reasons that it was sort of grist for my "Why RIM is screwed"
1:44:37post.
1:44:38I remember getting picked up at the airport in San Francisco with my friend Jason Hoffman,
1:44:46who I used to work at. He's still there, but at Joyent. And it was like by coincidence,
1:44:53like we were both—I think so. I might be misremembering the details. But I was in San
1:44:56Francisco probably for an Apple event, and he was arriving from somewhere, and a mutual
1:45:00friend picked us both up. And I was in a car with him. And he was one of those guys who
1:45:05at the time had a Blackberry and an iPhone. And I was a little surprised by that because
1:45:09I knew, you know, I used an iPhone for most things. And he used the Blackberry just for
1:45:13email. And I he gave me in the car like a big demo of who here's why I use and he was
1:45:18so efficient. It was so amazingly quick to go message to message to message and peck
1:45:23out a return that he could get through. And he had had like a long flight and it was in
1:45:28the air when it was a lot harder to maybe there weren't even a Wi Fi flights at the
1:45:32time but he did not want so we had like a whole days where the female and went
1:45:37through them boom boom boom boom boom in a way that it would be a lot slower on
1:45:41iOS and less efficient and I was a that is pretty interesting and then his
1:45:44complete he is his conclusion was yet and rem is totally screwed that you know
1:45:48that I bet they're out of business in two years that he used the thing and
1:45:52enjoyed it but completely recognized why they were totally screwed
1:45:56all the hardware software keyboard difference I think is another one
1:45:58another instructor one because I think they
1:46:00Although they seem similar, like, hey, Nintendo, yeah,
1:46:02I know you got hardware controls now,
1:46:04but that's the past come to touch games.
1:46:05But it's not.
1:46:07Well, the big thing with the comparison with BlackBerry,
1:46:09though, is that they had the hardware for going up and down
1:46:12in your messages, which is way better than any way
1:46:14to get from message to message in iOS still.
1:46:17Well, I was thinking more of the hardware keyboard,
1:46:19because that was the thing that people were like, oh, I can't
1:46:20type on that software keyboard.
1:46:22But it's so different than touch controls
1:46:25for gaming versus buttons and D-pads and analog sticks
1:46:28and stuff.
1:46:28Like with the hardware versus software keyboard,
1:46:30it was the same number of buttons,
1:46:33and there were advantages to the software keyboard
1:46:35that the hardware one couldn't match.
1:46:36Like you could reconfigure the software keyboard,
1:46:37you can do predictive hit areas,
1:46:39which you couldn't do with the hardware keyboard.
1:46:40The buttons couldn't get bigger because it knows
1:46:42that the next likely character's probably an R, right?
1:46:45The software keyboard had advantages,
1:46:47so it was like a superset.
1:46:48It was like, you can do everything
1:46:49the hardware keyboard can do.
1:46:50We got all the same buttons,
1:46:51and also we can do fancy things that you can't do,
1:46:53and it gets out of your way when you don't want it, right?
1:46:56touch versus hardware buttons on gaming devices,
1:46:59touch only has an advantage in a narrow band of games
1:47:02like Angry Birds or Cut the Rope
1:47:03or any kind of touch type games,
1:47:05but it has massive sort of exclusionary disadvantages
1:47:09in different kind of games.
1:47:10Like you can't make a whole class of very popular games
1:47:14that people like to play if your finger is on the screen.
1:47:17- True.
1:47:18- And so it's like, it's not like,
1:47:21oh, this is exactly the equivalent.
1:47:22You've got shoulder buttons, you've got face buttons,
1:47:24you've got a D-pad.
1:47:25just that now they're all software.
1:47:27Never mind that that would be terrible to use as well,
1:47:28'cause you know from trying to use D-pad type games.
1:47:32It's not a superset.
1:47:33It is really, really narrowly defining things,
1:47:35and it fences you into a certain area of gaming.
1:47:38The whole question is like,
1:47:39all right, maybe that is the old way.
1:47:40I'll know that's the old way when people stop wanting
1:47:43to play games that require those controls.
1:47:44So you're watching, you're watching.
1:47:46Who's gonna buy these things?
1:47:47Are they selling 3DSs?
1:47:48Are they gonna sell 2DSs?
1:47:51Are they selling game only hardware?
1:47:52Are people buying consoles?
1:47:53That's how you'll know when it's a problem.
1:47:56Well, that's why I think it's already a problem,
1:47:58that the numbers that Lucas Mathis cited in his response
1:48:01to me that, hey, the 3DS is selling OK,
1:48:04it was 130 months in, or weeks in, I guess weeks in,
1:48:10which is a decent measure, like 2 and 1/2 years,
1:48:13that the last generation DS was at 43 million,
1:48:17and the 3DS is only at 33 million.
1:48:19So it's 23% down generation to generation.
1:48:22And it just happens to coincide with the rise
1:48:26of modern smartphones.
1:48:28I think that's the cause.
1:48:30I don't think it's anything specific to the 3DS.
1:48:32I think it's the fact that it's in the era of the smartphone.
1:48:37Well, that gets back to the idea of game only hardware.
1:48:40Is that something that's still going to be?
1:48:42Do you still just want to buy something--
1:48:43And I also know.
1:48:44I know.
1:48:46And we've owned a bunch of-- I've
1:48:47owned Nintendo hardware, a lot of Nintendo hardware
1:48:49over the years.
1:48:51never been a serious game role of a man younger played a lot more but uh...
1:48:56you know and i know that nintendo has a cultural explicit cultural policy of of
1:49:01embracing
1:49:02older
1:49:04lesser
1:49:05cheaper technology
1:49:07you know and that the gameboy famously didn't have a color screen
1:49:11uh... until years after other competing ones did outsold them all
1:49:15and that you know the we famously was was
1:49:19Like I wrote today, it was standard def.
1:49:21I mean, for, you know, it's almost ridiculous
1:49:23that it wasn't high def.
1:49:24And, you know, outsold on a unit share basis
1:49:26PlayStation and Xbox.
1:49:28But I think the big difference
1:49:30that they're facing against smartphones,
1:49:33technically, is that with the smartphones,
1:49:35it's about the, you're asking me to carry a second device.
1:49:40That their policy of having lesser technology
1:49:43worked for them when it was,
1:49:45will you buy our thing that's cheaper and more fun,
1:49:48even though it's less technically advanced, or the other guy's thing, which is more technically
1:49:55advanced but not as fun.
1:49:57I think that's going to protect them in handheld though because handheld gaming, kids don't
1:50:03have smartphones. I guess at a certain age they do, maybe middle school or high school
1:50:07or whatever, but younger kids still play games. That's a market that may be protected from
1:50:13smartphone infiltration for a while anyway because people aren't going to give their
1:50:17kids smartphone but they will give them an intended 2ds for Christmas.
1:50:20Yeah, but I you know and and this is a lot of it is a very very small sample size on
1:50:24scientific polling based on the fact that I have a nine year old son but he has a sample
1:50:31size of one has both a 3ds and an iPhone and he does play the 3ds but he plays the iPhone
1:50:40more and if it's like hey we're going out to dinner you can take something he takes
1:50:45And this is not by me pushing him.
1:50:47I'm certainly no-- in fact, I almost
1:50:49wish he played the 3DS more.
1:50:51I almost feel like maybe we haven't gotten
1:50:53our money's worth out of it.
1:50:54I mean, he plays it.
1:50:55But it just seems to me like when push comes to shove,
1:50:58he'll take the iPhone.
1:51:00And it's hard.
1:51:03I try to ask him about it.
1:51:04And he's only nine, so it's hard for him
1:51:08to explain his choices.
1:51:09But definitely part of it is that when
1:51:12you take your iPhone with you, you take all your games with you. And maybe none of the
1:51:16games are as fun as the best game for the 3DS, but you've got them all. And you can
1:51:21never lose the cartridge. He's lost one 3DS cartridge, which I think is pretty good for
1:51:27a nine-year-old. But he's never lost an iOS game.
1:51:29So this is like --
1:51:30And if he wants to take all of his 3DS games with him, he's got to take a little, like,
1:51:34a briefcase.
1:51:35Yeah. So, like, Nintendo's problems, even if you assume that there is still a market
1:51:40game-only devices, even if you give that as a given, because I think that is like, that's
1:51:43like the red line in Nintendo's future, and probably the future of the Xbox and Playstation
1:51:48as well, is, you know, game-only hardware is still a viable business, and I think currently
1:51:52it still is, don't know about the future, right?
1:51:55Even if you allow for that, you have to say, "Okay, Nintendo has other problems, and a
1:52:01lot of those have to do with the things that iOS does better than Nintendo as a gaming
1:52:04platform."
1:52:05Ease of purchase and installation and the whole ownership experience, you just went
1:52:07through it.
1:52:08Cartridges?
1:52:09Digital downloads, yes.
1:52:11Nintendo's digital commerce stuff is way behind even like Steam on the PC, let alone the App
1:52:15Store.
1:52:16It's so much easier to deal with games in the App Store than really any of the platforms,
1:52:22Microsoft, Sony, or Nintendo.
1:52:23So Apple's way ahead there, and you're seeing that factor when making choices of what device
1:52:29you want to bring with you.
1:52:31Nintendo is super dumb in this area.
1:52:33They would tie their games to their hardware.
1:52:35So, "Oh, you can do a digital download, but those are tied to your particular Wii hardware."
1:52:38You get a Wii U, you got through this crazy transfer process that makes our DRM elves
1:52:42happy and could screw up and do all these terrible things, right?
1:52:46Sony has actually some interesting ideas about this for the PlayStation 4 where they say
1:52:50all the right things.
1:52:51They always say all the right things, right?
1:52:53But like, yeah, we're going to have downloadable games.
1:52:55They'll be downloaded day of.
1:52:56You don't have to buy discs you don't want.
1:52:57And they also have the interesting technology they've been touting like, say you're going
1:53:00to download this gigantic game for your PlayStation.
1:53:02You can start playing it even before the whole game is downloaded.
1:53:05We'll tailor them so we'll immediately start streaming you like the first level so you
1:53:08so you can start playing immediately.
1:53:09That's something that's ahead of Apple,
1:53:11if it turns out to work, right?
1:53:13Because Apple, if you want some multi-gigabyte game
1:53:15on your iOS device, you gotta wait for the whole game
1:53:16to download before you can play it.
1:53:18So Sony is at least saying the right things.
1:53:20Microsoft had some really interesting ideas
1:53:22about like lending games and resale.
1:53:24Like you could lend the game to any person
1:53:26in your family for free, like up to 10 people or whatever,
1:53:30without having them rebuy it, and it would transfer.
1:53:33People freaked out about that for DRM reasons,
1:53:35and they did some other stupid things as well,
1:53:36and they backed out a lot of decisions.
1:53:37What's the joke that it should be called the new platform, the Microsoft 180?
1:53:42Yeah, the Xbox 180.
1:53:44They had all these grand plans, and half of them were actually really awesome, and half
1:53:47of them were terrible, and they just said, "Oh, never mind, we're going to do what we
1:53:49did with the 360."
1:53:50Right?
1:53:51And you could just take your disks back and sell them at GameStop.
1:53:53Yeah, exactly.
1:53:54But Nintendo is way behind there, and that, I think, is a much more pressing problem than
1:53:58the things you've listed that they...
1:54:00Even if you say gaming things are going to be future, you've got to get your act together.
1:54:03It's got to be as easy to buy and deal with games as it is on the App Store, and it's
1:54:06And it's not, and that's really going to hurt them.
1:54:08And online gaming and collaboration, I don't know if Apple is ahead here, but Microsoft
1:54:13certainly is in the lead with Xbox Live where you get all your friends and you can go online
1:54:16and play with them.
1:54:17And Sony and Nintendo both have not been doing well.
1:54:19Nintendo's always been trying to be like family-friendly and stuff, but like limiting access to online
1:54:24so you don't have people like cursing at you in the chat and everything.
1:54:27But that's an area where they're all kind of like fumbling and are not quite up to the
1:54:31standards you'd want them to be.
1:54:33And the final thing is market access.
1:54:35Like, it's still easier to get a game in the App Store than it is to get a game on Nintendo,
1:54:40Sony, or Microsoft gaming platforms.
1:54:42Those are the biggest problems facing Nintendo right now, aside from the meta question of
1:54:46whether game-only products are valid.
1:54:50All that stuff that iOS does better and that makes it so that people say, "Me and my buddy
1:54:54are going to make an iOS game, and why aren't you making Nintendo games?"
1:54:57"Oh, because that's a pain in the butt.
1:54:58I don't even know how I would do that, and it's not easy to buy things there, and I could
1:55:02just tell people to go on their phones and download this app."
1:55:05Those are all the big problems that Nintendo has, but all the things that you listed about
1:55:11the hardware and everything I think are missing the forest for the trees because, like, I
1:55:14could, like, you listed resisted touch screens as a problem, like you said they're like a,
1:55:19I feel like a relic for a museum.
1:55:23Like, there are reasons for resisted touch screens.
1:55:26Not that they're never, they're gonna have them forever, but, I mean, the first reason
1:55:30is like precision, because fingers get in the way more than a stylus does, and Nintendo
1:55:37had specific games in mind that it wanted you to be able to use a stylus, but that you
1:55:40needed that kind of precision, like to draw the path for Link's Boomerang in one of the
1:55:42Zelda games or whatever.
1:55:44So you're going to have a stylus, and if you have a stylus, pressure sensitive was the
1:55:47only option they had at that time.
1:55:50And also, once you give someone a stylus, they're going to jab that thing to the screen
1:55:53like crazy, and you cannot have someone jabbing a pointy thing into a glass screen, because
1:55:57it will crack, or at the very least,
1:55:59if you make it thick enough, it'll skitter off
1:56:01and be unpleasant, and it won't be as nice.
1:56:03So you gotta have resistive touchscreen for that.
1:56:05And for the resolution, it's not a retina screen,
1:56:08but the specs of Nintendo's handhelds, anyway,
1:56:12are pretty easily explained by their focus
1:56:14is gaming-only machines, so you don't have to show text
1:56:17or beautiful things like retina graphics or whatever,
1:56:19and the price.
1:56:20'Cause super high-res has diminishing returns
1:56:22in terms of fun factor over a certain res.
1:56:24You do not need 300 dpi for your 3d graphics game. You won't even notice that it'll just be it's just a it's completely
1:56:30I'll sunk you know hardware cost that you're just paying to put all those pixels out
1:56:33And so Nintendo chose the balance
1:56:35They let to hit like a low price point and still make a profit on their things and and I was trying to look up
1:56:41Before the show like what the power specs are for like what is more powerful in terms of 3d processing power a 3ds or?
1:56:47You know an iPad 4 and all I could find were specs for like the you know
1:56:52the previous generation of iPad hardware and yeah, the iPad GPUs have way more fill rate because they're filling a retina screen and
1:56:58Nintendo ones don't have to have that kind of power but the 3d power on those things
1:57:02It's not I'm not gonna say it's impressive and I'm pretty sure they're using 64 nanometer chips in there
1:57:06Which is insane because Apple's like using 32 and soon to be 28 I think and you know state-of-the-art is like 22, right?
1:57:12So it is you're right. It is older technology, but that their focus is so much on like durability
1:57:18Price, you know accessibility to young people as a product for the handhelds very specifically
1:57:24That I can justify every one of their decisions that they made and I think like I predicted them on ATP that the 2ds is
1:57:31Not doomed in the market like it's not it's not crazy to think that when Pokemon xy come out that a bunch of parents are
1:57:38Gonna buy their kids this thing is it's the cheapest way to get this game
1:57:40And I remember you on the site also were I think it was you was poo-pooing it like oh, it's only $40 cheaper
1:57:46Yeah, like it doesn't seem like a lot well. What if I told you that you had to take you know the the iPhone
1:57:535 and shave $40 off the price
1:57:56But you can't change any of the specs has to have the same amount of RAM has to be just as fast
1:57:59I just need $40 off the price. Oh, you can't get rid of the camera. You can't get rid of anything
1:58:03You know shave $40 off the price
1:58:04It's not easy to bring $40 out of like it's not like this is like the Nintendo 2ds is like the iPhone 4s like the previous
1:58:10Generation you sell ever cheaper it runs all 3ds games granted not in 3d, but like it runs them
1:58:16It doesn't have any sort of disadvantages in terms of speed or anything
1:58:19Well, they had to head to pull 40 bucks out of this thing and $40
1:58:22And I'll grant you to that at $40 is a lot more when it's 25%
1:58:28As opposed to it probably might be easy to shave $40 off an iPhone 5
1:58:34Because it's already $700
1:58:37Not shaving another profit take it have the rest of good as opposed to shaving 25% off
1:58:42Yeah, like by putting it in percentage terms makes it more impressive than in dollar terms. Yeah
1:58:47But I know that's what they're doing with the 2ds like it's like they're they're aiming for price point
1:58:52and these are as I said an ATP the 2ds is not the move of a
1:58:56You know of like it's not a power move
1:58:59It's not someone at the top of their game saying we rule the handheld market and now we're making it's a it's a move
1:59:03You know, they want to sell more if they got to get the price lower
1:59:06how can we pull the cost out of it while still making a good gaming device like
1:59:11It's it's not desperation move, but it's also not a like supremely confident. We rule the market in fact
1:59:17We're gonna make even more money because the margins I don't have to be lower like they're gonna make less money on it
1:59:21They're gonna try to make it up in volume by lowering the price and selling more of them, and and maybe they will
1:59:26But you know I don't think it's a terrible product. I think there's a chance that it will sell pretty well
1:59:32if it doesn't
1:59:35It's probably not because the product itself is bad, but it's probably because of you know
1:59:39All the other things I listed of it that Nintendo doesn't do as well as as iOS does I mean if you want to look
1:59:45at a powerful handheld because there's the
1:59:47PlayStation Vita which is way more powerful than 3ds and has lots of interesting features and yet
1:59:51It's crushed by Nintendo in the market because you know Nintendo has more interesting things and better and more fun games, right?
1:59:57I think you know handheld dedicated gaming device versus handheld gaming dedicated gaming device
2:00:03Nintendo's in good shape and that their strategy continues to work and they don't need leading tech
2:00:08I think the problem is against smartphones, it's you're asking me to carry a second device.
2:00:14And it's the same thing that faces camera makers, right?
2:00:16And I, you know, I'm, I actually am pulling this out of my ass, but I can only assume
2:00:21that point and shoot camera sales are slowing in the face of people having smartphones that
2:00:26are good enough.
2:00:27Well, you're pulling it all back to is there a place for gaming only piece of hardware?
2:00:32Right.
2:00:33And you know, music players, obviously, iPod sales are way down, even including the iPod
2:00:37iPod touch in iPod sales, which really prompts those numbers up. And I really would if there's
2:00:42almost maybe if there's one thing I wish Apple would do differently in its financial reports,
2:00:47it would be to report the iPod touch separately from the other iPods. But those are way down
2:00:54every other second device is way down. I mean, and you know, fame, I think famously, I think
2:01:00it's almost been the biggest distraction in trying to talk about these things over the
2:01:04last seven years is that we call them smartphones when they're really not phones. They're little
2:01:10computers that can be phones. The traditional phone market is decimated profit wise, maybe
2:01:17not unit share wise, even though smartphones in a lot of ways aren't even great phones.
2:01:22I mean, the verge had a thing this week with a new dumb phone from Nokia that gets actually
2:01:29looks pretty cool as a dumb phone and it gets like a ridiculous it was like was it 138 hours
2:01:37of battery life I forget what it was ridiculous it was like a week of battery life or more
2:01:42I don't know I charge my phone once a week yeah it was just stupid which is and it's
2:01:49better to have a phone that you don't have to worry about charging every day is way better
2:01:53just in terms of like hey if somebody needs me I'm available and my phone's not dead great
2:01:58But it's that asking people to carry a second device, you know, what we call smartphones
2:02:04are hurting all of them.
2:02:06And the thing that really hurts something like the DS platform or whatever the next
2:02:11generation is going to be called, is that unlike, say, a camera maker like Nikon or
2:02:17Canon, which can still profitably make more continue making point dedicated point and
2:02:23shoot cameras, even if they're selling fewer of them in absolute terms, is that a software
2:02:28platform like a gaming device needs that network effect of having enough people out there to
2:02:33make it worthwhile to make the game.
2:02:35Well, that's why I think the DS is more viable.
2:02:39You should have been crapping on the Wii U more because the handheld space, Nintendo,
2:02:43I mean, it may still have problems, but it's not in current imminent danger of complete
2:02:48collapse whereas on the desktop side, Nintendo is in way worse shape because the Wii U is
2:02:53not doing anything that they want out there in the market and it's about to be run over
2:02:57I assume the PlayStation 4 and Xbox one, I think both gonna come out of the gate much stronger than the way you did
2:03:02Yeah, I don't know anything about the actual specs of the Wii U except that we own one and we we also have
2:03:08PlayStation 3 which I've I've got like I think I have two games for
2:03:14But it seems to me like it just
2:03:18Looking at them that the Wii U is finally like caught up to like the PlayStation 3. Yeah, that's pretty much where it's gone
2:03:25I mean, so that's it's a previous its previous generation Harvard, right? It looks roughly equivalent to me
2:03:30you know in terms of graphics as the PlayStation 3 because we what we've got is Jonas is into the the Batman Arkham games and
2:03:38which are like I think like totally inappropriate for a nine-year-old, but
2:03:42but we've got the one on
2:03:45PlayStation 3 and the other one on Wii U and to me graphically they look almost you know
2:03:51Distinctive which makes me think that the PlayStation 4 is going to come and just blow it out
2:03:55Yeah
2:03:55So the other reason that I think you're way off with it with the iOS
2:03:58suggesting to make games or iOS is because it doesn't like again assuming that you assume that
2:04:03They're assuming you assume that there's still place for game only hardware and then Nintendo is going to be in that you have to look
2:04:09at the way
2:04:11Nintendo has
2:04:12How they succeeded what what what defines Nintendo?
2:04:16and how are they able to be a successful company that get sells you things that you play games on and
2:04:20Possibly other things but not like a software platform and the way Nintendo has succeeded
2:04:25Over its entire history in the gaming world
2:04:28hinges on as I'm sure many of your people have emailed you about the
2:04:32Synergy of hardware and software a lot like Apple which is why people keep bringing that up, right? And I mean if
2:04:37You've had to pick three things out of the history you think like the NES like the original NES
2:04:42What was what was the hardware and software?
2:04:44Synergy there well like why did why couldn't they just make games well that was after the big you know game system crashed the Atari
2:04:50crash and everything and no one wanted to sell game consoles.
2:04:53They thought it was a sucker business.
2:04:54So they put that robot with it.
2:04:55Remember Rob?
2:04:56Oh, yeah.
2:04:57Rob the robot.
2:04:58Like that was like a decoy to, you know, to get the thing into the other thing on the
2:05:03store shelves and get people to buy it.
2:05:04Like, oh, this isn't like an Atari.
2:05:06That stupid thing that had those terrible games.
2:05:07It's just this is a robot within the robot.
2:05:10Like people threw that away.
2:05:11Who knows where the robots went?
2:05:12Like once you've got the thing and you played Super Mario Brothers, like screw that robot.
2:05:16Like it was a total decoy, but they could make the hardware.
2:05:19they could put that stupid robot in it,
2:05:22and the light gun to some degree or whatever,
2:05:23and get the things into people's homes,
2:05:25and then say, "Now we've got the thing in front of you,
2:05:26"we can help you."
2:05:27And they could, you know, make,
2:05:28and they could also make the hardware cheap,
2:05:29way cheaper than a PC of the day.
2:05:31Like, the game console model was, you know,
2:05:33defined by like Atari and all those people,
2:05:35but it was dead, like people said, "Don't do that again."
2:05:37So they had to control the hardware
2:05:39to get the thing into people's hands.
2:05:41And then the N64 was 3D, of course,
2:05:43and this is a very app-like example of them
2:05:45totally, you know, cannibalizing their own product.
2:05:47They were defined by little side scrolling things with Mario and jump over stuff, and
2:05:51they said, "Nope, no more of that.
2:05:52The next Mario game is not going to be two-dimensional.
2:05:55You're not going to run from left to right and jump and do a lot of stuff.
2:05:59It's going to be completely 3D.
2:06:00We're going whole hog 3D.
2:06:01This could have been the end of the company."
2:06:03But it wasn't.
2:06:05Other people got to do it before them.
2:06:07There was the Sega Saturn and the PlayStation all came out before Nintendo 64.
2:06:11All were capable of 3D.
2:06:12Why didn't they eat Nintendo's lunch?
2:06:13Well, because Nintendo designed the hardware
2:06:16and software together and was able to make them work
2:06:18in Synergy to put you an analog stick on the controller.
2:06:20They said, "We're going 3D, and we can't go 3D
2:06:22"with a D-pad, we have to have an analog stick."
2:06:24Other guys could have done it, they didn't,
2:06:25until after Nintendo did it.
2:06:28And that made, and it's such an amazing experience
2:06:30with Mario 64, and the analog stick,
2:06:33that was hardware and software synergy.
2:06:34They could not have put Mario 64 on the Sega Saturn.
2:06:37They couldn't have put it on the PlayStation, right?
2:06:39And the Wii was exactly the same thing.
2:06:41You know, they were down in the dumps.
2:06:42They had been in last place out of three competitors for the past two console generations, selling
2:06:46fewer and fewer with each successive product they put out.
2:06:49And so you're in last place, and the next generation you're also in last place, even
2:06:52more so.
2:06:53Right?
2:06:54And so they come out with the Wii that is the wussiest piece of hardware that's standard
2:06:57death.
2:06:58Wait, they were last place two in a row?
2:07:00I knew the GameCube.
2:07:01Yeah.
2:07:02What was the one before that?
2:07:03Nintendo 64.
2:07:04Oh, that was last place?
2:07:05Three times as many PlayStations sold as Nintendo 64s.
2:07:08Yeah.
2:07:09Huh.
2:07:10That's funny, because I had a Nintendo 64 and just...
2:07:11"Oh, you know what? I do remember from that. You know what I remember from that era?
2:07:14I had a Nintendo 64, and that was the era when Blockbuster rented games, and my then roommate at the time,
2:07:20yeah, I remember that now. In hindsight, we were so pissed because you'd go there and Blockbuster would have like
2:07:2540 awesome PlayStation games and
2:07:28like two Nintendo games."
2:07:31Yeah, I mean, like, and there were amazing things in that platform, some of the best games of its generation.
2:07:36"GoldenEye."
2:07:36They were losing. Yeah, exactly.
2:07:37It's great stuff, but not doing well. And so when the Wii came out, it's like,
2:07:41Like, this is terrible.
2:07:43Hardware specs about it were terrible, and it would look ridiculous, but we know what
2:07:49happened, right?
2:07:50It totally crushed all of its competitors with the worst hardware you could possibly
2:07:54ever imagine.
2:07:55It was basically just an overclocked GameCube, again, previous generation hardware.
2:08:01And they couldn't have done that if they didn't also make the hardware, because there's no
2:08:04way you can sell Wii Sports on any of the other platforms, right?
2:08:07Well, why can't they make iOS games while they continue to make their own hardware and
2:08:12just expand into it? Like I, you know, like my analogy, like where Disney went and made
2:08:16TV shows and kept making feature films. Why can't they treat this as a third opportunity
2:08:21where they went from console to console and handheld with the Game Boy and they've kept
2:08:26that going into the DSL and treat mobile phones as a third opportunity?
2:08:31Why would they take, like, they have something good, right?
2:08:35And they know they can't make something as good for someone else's platform.
2:08:39But it's good because they don't control.
2:08:40But I think it's because it's shrinking, and I think it's inevitably going to continue
2:08:45to shrink.
2:08:46I think if they've only sold 33 million of this one in 130 months, then the next generation
2:08:50one, no matter what it looks like, they're only going to sell 15 million of it.
2:08:54Well, if you take the past as an indicator of Nintendo's possible attitude, they went
2:08:58two entire console generations being in last place and doing worse and worse and didn't
2:09:03do, you know, execute the plan you're suggesting. Maybe this current drop with the Wii U is
2:09:08much worse than those previous ones were, so we'll see, but they make so much more money
2:09:13selling games on their own platforms than they will on someone else's platform. If you
2:09:16-- the cautionary tale is Sega that people keep bringing up. You know, once you're just
2:09:20a software maker, you live and die by the hits. You're like a movie studio, right? And
2:09:26Your hits are on platforms you don't control with promotion that you basically have to
2:09:29do yourself because you can't promote your own stuff inside.
2:09:32You don't control the platform like Apple does and can promote its own apps in the App Store.
2:09:36There's no ongoing platform royalties or hardware profits to sustain you while you're making
2:09:41these games.
2:09:42It's like a hit studio.
2:09:43It's like you've got to have your hit movie.
2:09:44You've got to have it.
2:09:45And if you don't have it, then you're screwed.
2:09:49You do not want to be in the business of publishing games.
2:09:52the game software business is terrible and cutthroat. And that's why there's so few people
2:09:56still in it. And there's so much consolidation because even if you have a hit game, half
2:10:00the times you have a hit game, and the studio closes anyway, or you get bought up by a competitor
2:10:04and get liquidated, it is not the business you want to be in much better to be in the
2:10:07business of selling a platform, making a little bit money on the hardware, and then making
2:10:11platform royalties for every game that's sold on your platform and being able to sell your
2:10:14own games on your platform for way more money than you can charge for the same games in
2:10:17the App Store.
2:10:18totally agree with all of that. I just don't think it's feasible going forward. I just
2:10:23don't think, especially on handhelds, I just don't think that it's feasible because you're
2:10:29asking people to carry a second device.
2:10:32You may be right about the handheld market because if it like, if I think about the reason
2:10:38I think less about the handheld market and more about the television market because is
2:10:41because like, I'm kind of amazed at the number of 3ds is that they continue to sell and it
2:10:46It makes me think that there's still a market for people who want to play deep games on
2:10:50a handheld.
2:10:51And the reason I think that market is protected is because no one, with the exception of Sony,
2:10:56seems to want it.
2:10:57Microsoft, as we mentioned earlier, there's no portable Xbox.
2:11:00They're not getting into that business for whatever reason, right?
2:11:03Sony has tried to compete with Nintendo in this area for so long and has very often had
2:11:08interesting devices and was not able to pull that off.
2:11:09Wasn't the first one the best-selling?
2:11:10I thought that there was an older PlayStation handheld that was the best-selling handheld
2:11:16of all time.
2:11:17The PSP?
2:11:18Yeah.
2:11:19No.
2:11:20It's not the best selling handheld of all time.
2:11:21What was the best seller of all time?
2:11:22I thought somebody had an article, one of these ones that said that DS was the second
2:11:27best of all time, but that the best of all time was the PSP.
2:11:30I'm wrong.
2:11:31That was probably some Game Boy that was the best of all time.
2:11:34It certainly wasn't the PSP.
2:11:36But Sony has tried to compete and has not quite done it, right?
2:11:40But Apple does not want that market, despite their, like, "Oh, you can now use a controller
2:11:46with your iOS devices."
2:11:48So far, Apple has not been interested in selling you a device that has buttons and shoulder
2:11:54buttons and triggers and stuff and lets you play traditional games like that.
2:11:57And so if that market goes away, then fine, then those guys go away.
2:12:00But if there continues to be a market for people who want to play games that can only
2:12:03be played with an analog stick and shoulder buttons and face buttons, and Apple doesn't
2:12:07want that market and Sony can't beat Nintendo in it and Nintendo keeps that market.
2:12:10Well that's why I think that they could do it and continue to make the devices and let
2:12:15the devices be for the more serious game players who want those extra hardware things and make
2:12:22different games that are specific for mobile and I think that Nintendo has a...
2:12:26But like they would make enough extra money on that. It would be demotivating people from
2:12:30buying things and your suggestion of Mario Kart, I don't want to play Mario Kart with
2:12:33touch controls. Nobody wants to do that. Like, I mean, maybe they'd sell a whole bunch of
2:12:36They'd sell tons of copies if they put Super Mario Brothers 2D side scroller with an onscreen
2:12:41D-pad.
2:12:42Sure, they'd sell a lot of copies, but it's not the experience that they want, and it
2:12:45demotivates people from buying the platforms that make Nintendo much more money.
2:12:50Sega went software only because it had to, because its hardware failed, and it didn't
2:12:54have the bank role and the history and the stability of Nintendo.
2:12:59So Dreamcast didn't make it in the market, and they had to exit the hardware business,
2:13:02and they only made software.
2:13:03I just don't want to see Nintendo wait until they have to and I think it'll be too late
2:13:07Well, they have a lot more they have a lot more time on their side now
2:13:10But the reason I'm worried so much about the television console space more than the portable one because like I said the portable one Apple
2:13:16Seems not to be not to want that they're not going to come and because that you know Apple or even Microsoft
2:13:21I think were the kind of people who come in there and knock Nintendo around Sony's been trying to knock them around hasn't succeeded Apple
2:13:26Could but I don't think they want it but in the television attached console space. I think they have a problem because
2:13:32It's much easier for Apple to almost accidentally
2:13:36Crush them in that market people say all that Apple's accidentally crushed them in the portable gaming market
2:13:41I'm not so sure about that because I don't think the 3ds would be a viable platform
2:13:45That was the case and it still is but if Apple produces a television attached device
2:13:50With the GPU power of the iPad 4 in it
2:13:52Which is not inconceivable that they could ship a little puck shaped thing like that and hooks it up to the App Store
2:13:57Right, you know, you're not going to be touching your TV screen anyway
2:14:00So there has to be some kind of input device and we don't know what the hell Apple is doing there
2:14:03but suddenly the idea of Apple or someone else like giving you a game controller for your
2:14:08Television connected Apple device with the GPU and cop that's comparable in power to what's in like, you know
2:14:14one of the higher-end iPads now that is a big problem for
2:14:17Nintendo or any other company with a television attached console because Apple's get makes really easy to buy games
2:14:23It really easy to manage games don't have to worry about all that and makes it really easy to develop games
2:14:28Anybody who wants to make a game can get it on their TV and you can play it and that is a realm where I think
2:14:33Apple maybe not would be enthusiastic about making a controller or whatever
2:14:36But suddenly a controller is a possibility because the control like
2:14:38If you try to sell like a third-party control like I'll buy my game from the App Store for your phone
2:14:43But you need this weird widget II thing
2:14:44I think that's a harder sell than buying a game for your TV
2:14:47And of course you need this weird widget II thing because how the hell is you're gonna play a game on TV
2:14:50You can't touch the screen. You're not gonna play with the remote, right?
2:14:53so and you know
2:14:55The new Apple TV has Bluetooth and there's the App Store now and you can play my game.
2:14:58I don't think that's Apple's plan or whatever, but that is a bigger danger, especially with
2:15:03the Wii U totally tanking.
2:15:05That kind of danger of a competitor that does all the things right that Nintendo does wrong,
2:15:09and also, by the way, has a reasonably viable gaming platform.
2:15:13At that point, if you take away all of Nintendo's television-attached console sales, all they've
2:15:19got left is the portables.
2:15:20I don't know if that's enough to subsidize the next, you know, Zelda or Mario 3D game.
2:15:25I don't know. We'll see. It's a good discussion. Before I let you go, I have a question for
2:15:32you. Serious question. Let's say that the Gruber household was thinking about maybe
2:15:40buying a PS4 or Xbox One. Which one looks like it's going to be better?
2:15:46PlayStation 4.
2:15:47Okay.
2:15:48No question.
2:15:49Alright. That way I don't have to do any research. This is like when Amy
2:15:52usually wants Marco to research something. Like whenever we want to buy
2:15:56something.
2:15:56I thought, "Why would I even look into this? I'll just get Siracusa on the show
2:16:00and I'll just ask him."
2:16:01Now I don't have to look into it. Yeah. I mean, it's the purest
2:16:06plain old attach to duty and play games with it. It's got everything going for it.
2:16:11It has none of the weird
2:16:12You don't even have to explain it. Don't even explain it. Alright. Good enough.
2:16:15For before we go because we've been on we've been recording for four hours now
2:16:18Have you seen this is the last thing it just came out like an hour or two ago venture beat has
2:16:25Purported pictures of the Samsung smartwatch that is going to be announced in three days
2:16:30Paste it into me. I have not seen it because I've been talking to you for two hours
2:16:35all right, you've got to see this before we sign off I
2:16:38I'm gonna go with that. They've been punked
2:16:44And I mean that I'm not even joking. I'm not even gonna link to it from daring fireball until somebody
2:16:50I'm not gonna link to it from daring fireball
2:16:52I'm not I'm not gonna do it because I don't want this is one of the things I live in fear of is that
2:16:58Somebody is gonna post perfect. Somebody else is gonna fall for a prank, but it's right in my wheelhouse and fits with my
2:17:06preconceived
2:17:09biases yeah, and I'm gonna go along for the ride to and make like some wisecrack about it and then it's gonna
2:17:17Turned out it was the whole thing was a punk and it's not it because this thing
2:17:21I don't think that's beyond Samsung to produce. I don't either so I'm tempted
2:17:28I think it could be real, but it's so bad
2:17:31That I um it's so bad that I'm not going to link to it until somebody can confirm
2:17:36Yeah, my guess would have been that this is a product that
2:17:39already exists and someone dug up.
2:17:41This doesn't sound like something
2:17:42that maybe came out two years ago.
2:17:44It probably already exists when they've taken shots.
2:17:46That I would see as plausible, because maybe no one knows
2:17:49about it.
2:17:49It didn't sell a lot, but someone dug up
2:17:51a picture from the catalog, and there it is.
2:17:53It looks like a Saturday Night Live skit.
2:17:55It's like an iPhone, like a three-inch iPhone strapped
2:17:58to somebody's wrist.
2:18:00There's nothing in the screenshots, right?
2:18:01Well, let's see.
2:18:02No, I don't think so.
2:18:03Well, there's something there.
2:18:04There's a logo, and there's a little--
2:18:06I can't help but think it's a pulse meter or something.
2:18:10You know, like some kind of health tracker. It looks like it's, you know, it's like a bar graph.
2:18:14I don't know. I like the little drawings showing like the pencil drawings of the side views.
2:18:18That seems more plausible to me. Like it's all curved and everything and that looks like it didn't come out two years ago.
2:18:24I, I, this is really bad.
2:18:26I think it's okay for you to wait on it.
2:18:28Yeah, I'm gonna wait. But boy, if this is it, it is exactly what I thought it was gonna be.
2:18:33Which is you cannot believe how bad Samsung is it designing something when they don't have I haven't even tried it yet
2:18:40Maybe it's an amazing transformative. I like how even on the drawings. It's so big that it's it's double the width of the wrist of the
2:18:47Yeah, that's why it looks like a Photoshop job. It looks like it's the strap is too big. It's like tilting
2:18:53It's like a little kid wearing his dad's watch. I
2:18:59I can't wait to see if this is real. I'm so worried that it's not though that I'm not going to link to it.
2:19:05Yeah, you don't like to like spy shots and rumors. You know, you haven't been linking to the 8,000
2:19:08pictures of the iPhone 5c or whatever. You wait till they announce something. You talk about what
2:19:12they announced. Exactly. I think the gold thing seems real. What do you think they're going to do
2:19:16with the gold iPhone? Do you think it's going to be the white iPhone now has gold metallic trim?
2:19:23Or is it a third option? That's what everyone keeps saying. I kind of agree with the people
2:19:27People think that black and gold might be good, but geez, I don't know.
2:19:31Like I don't think it's crazy for it to be champagne colored.
2:19:36Yeah, I don't think so either.
2:19:37I don't think it's crazy.
2:19:39It's not really my taste, but I've never bought the white one anyway.
2:19:41But I feel like if the only way to get a white one is with that, I feel like that's asking
2:19:46a lot for people who do like white.
2:19:48Like I don't think – Oh, no.
2:19:49I think they got to stick with the white.
2:19:50It's going to be white and black and then this thing.
2:19:52Hmm.
2:19:53But then what face does this thing have?
2:19:55White.
2:19:56So there'll be two white ones you think one with the plain silver trim and one gold
2:20:02Yeah, and I'm only saying that just because that's everything that I've heard
2:20:05I don't see I tend to think otherwise I tend see I tend to think it's more Apple like that if they're only gonna have
2:20:10Black and white faces that there's one black overall color scheme and one white overall color scheme and that is it would be champagne
2:20:18I just feel like that would be more appley even though personally I would find that disappointing
2:20:22It's very difficult to make judgments like this when all you see are are you know mock-ups and like
2:20:28Speculations because the exact color of gold dictates whether it looks awful with white or good with yeah and everything we've seen you know
2:20:35If yeah
2:20:35There's so much smoke with the gold trim that it I feel like there's enough smoke that I'm willing to say there's probably certainly a fire
2:20:42But it's all based on like weird component leaks and it's somebody with a cell phone taking a picture of a thing under fluorescent light
2:20:50And tons of mock-ups 8,000 mock-ups if this is what it could look like whatever look like this
2:20:54So it'll look like this. It would look good with white. It looked like this would look good with black
2:20:57I can't tell like, you know, it's speculating about colors. It's pretty dumb
2:21:01Anyway, like is that materials maybe I can get with you but colors like whatever they want
2:21:05It's fashion as long as it's not, you know Dalmatian or flower power. I'm fine
2:21:08I hadn't even thought about the fact that it could be the black one then I'd that would be a real dilemma for me personally
2:21:13Like yeah, you'd get the totally black one. Well, that's assuming there is a totally black
2:21:17Yeah, then you're right. You would have if my choice if my choice were between a white
2:21:21one with silver trim and a black faced one with gold trim. Geez, I don't know what I'd
2:21:27have to I'd have to look at him but I was seven makes the white one suddenly more attractive
2:21:32for the obsessive people who want things like matching like you know what the iOS seven
2:21:36looks like it was made for the white iPhone. I've you know, people have said that I don't
2:21:40see that I've been running seven betas ever since beta three on my black iPhone and I
2:21:46I don't see it as any less cohesive.
2:21:49Well, you're right in reality, but in the product shots,
2:21:52it looks like it matches up with the white.
2:21:53But in reality, I always remind people,
2:21:55this is why I never buy white iOS devices.
2:21:57All you're doing is highlighting how bad the white is
2:22:00on those screens, right?
2:22:02Because the white on those screens
2:22:03is never going to be as white as the real white thing.
2:22:05Especially in sunlight, it's just
2:22:06going to look worse and worse.
2:22:07All you're doing is making your screen look dingier and crappier
2:22:10by putting bright white next to it.
2:22:12You put black next to it, and suddenly the screen
2:22:14looks amazing.
2:22:15'Cause you're like, oh, everything else just fades away,
2:22:17and I will totally believe that that white on that screen
2:22:19is exactly what white should look like,
2:22:20'cause I don't have three millimeters from it,
2:22:22a piece of white plastic showing me,
2:22:23oh, that's what white would look like
2:22:25if I wasn't looking at, you know,
2:22:26little tiny glowing backlight.
2:22:28- Yeah.
2:22:29- I'm an anti-white iOS device.
2:22:31- Yeah, I do agree that it would look better
2:22:34in their product shots.
2:22:35In fact, already does in their iOS 7.
2:22:39- 'Cause everything in their product shots is pure white.
2:22:41It's magic, magic.
2:22:42- Yeah, perfect white.
2:22:44infinite you know it's like the same white that's in the background of their
2:22:47commercials so you know heavenly white
2:22:52I'm gonna call a show that was good yeah
2:22:55there is long ones may help me down
2:22:57[BLANK_AUDIO]