Podcast Search

The Talk Show

43: All The Leaks Are Wrong

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00last day of school oh big day talk about a big day that's it's like the greatest

0:00:06holiday in the world so you get a half day you know what they do and it's awful

0:00:11I think is is it's like a not a quite a half day it's like an early dismissal

0:00:16and then there's a sing a quote unquote thing where you the parents are invited

0:00:22to go to the gym the gymnasium great acoustics there and the kids sing like

0:00:28three songs and then they get to go home. I skipped. I'm missing it right now as we

0:00:35speak.

0:00:38Mike: Well, my kid's got another week. I don't know why. Your kid goes to like a...

0:00:45Dave: Private school.

0:00:49Mike; A fancy military academy.

0:00:52Academy yeah it's a military a lot of marching it's nice though because

0:00:59usually it's one of those things that last most years it coincides with WWDC

0:01:05so I don't get to be here for last day of school but this year it's it's a week

0:01:10early so so I think usually his schedule would be next week - it's I don't know

0:01:15why I don't know you know it's it seems like all sorts of early June stuff has

0:01:22been moved around this year?

0:01:24Tim Cynova Well, some of those private schools use older

0:01:28calendars.

0:01:29Dave Asprey Like ones like Gregorian calendars or something?

0:01:33Tim Cynova Yeah, something.

0:01:34Yeah, Julian.

0:01:35Is there a Julian calendar?

0:01:36Dave Asprey Just to maintain their tradition.

0:01:39Tim Cynova That's right because they've been using

0:01:41them for years.

0:01:42They don't want to switch.

0:01:43That's why it's a private school.

0:01:45They didn't want the government telling them which calendar to use.

0:01:48You know, I had a conversation with my son.

0:01:53He's really into the Harry Potter books now.

0:01:55Oh, good.

0:01:55And I couldn't be prouder, because I didn't read books of that length

0:02:01when I was in third grade.

0:02:02I never read for pleasure.

0:02:04I was-- I don't know.

0:02:05It's amazing I turned out to be a writer.

0:02:07So I'm super proud of him, and he's really into them.

0:02:11And at one point, he said something about, wouldn't it be great if this were real

0:02:14and I could go to Hogwarts?

0:02:16And I said, well, it sounds like fun.

0:02:17But think about it.

0:02:19You'd have to move away from me and your mom.

0:02:23You'd have to go there.

0:02:24And he just looked at me, and he was like, and your point is--

0:02:29and I was like, wow.

0:02:30That was most of the idea.

0:02:32Yeah.

0:02:32It's like he doesn't even care about the Defense

0:02:35Against the Dark Arts crap.

0:02:36He just wants to get out of the house already.

0:02:40I just want to live in a dorm somewhere.

0:02:41I really thought we could wait until he

0:02:43was a teenager for that.

0:02:46Yeah.

0:02:47I guess they really do that in Britain, or at least they used to, right?

0:02:53They used to have schools like that where they go away at like 11.

0:02:57Yeah, I think it was a-- they have a weird thing too where a public school in Britain

0:03:02is what we call a private school.

0:03:04And I don't know what they call it, what we call a public school.

0:03:08But like a public--

0:03:10A lorry.

0:03:11I believe they call it a lorry.

0:03:12Yeah.

0:03:12[LAUGHTER]

0:03:16So I made an app.

0:03:19So I heard.

0:03:20Yeah, I read about it.

0:03:21It was on the internet.

0:03:22I read about it on your site.

0:03:23It was a very nice thing.

0:03:24Oh, I also used it for two weeks before it came out.

0:03:26Yeah.

0:03:27It's nice.

0:03:28I like it.

0:03:29I use it every day.

0:03:30Do you really?

0:03:31Yeah, I do.

0:03:32I do too.

0:03:33I mean, that's how I knew that.

0:03:34That's how I felt like I told myself in the lead up to releasing.

0:03:38Every time I get real nervous, I'd be like, "You know what?

0:03:40I like it, so it's got to be something."

0:03:42Yeah.

0:03:43I mean, of course, I'm on your podcast, so I have to suck up to you.

0:03:46But I do like it.

0:03:47>> No, you don't really.

0:03:48I think it would be dynamite.

0:03:50It would be great if we had an argument over if you said, "You know what?

0:03:55This is a real turd."

0:03:57>> It's the worst app I've ever used.

0:04:03I use it to – I wrote on my website.

0:04:05I use it to track story ideas for the most part, just things that I want to write about

0:04:10and possibly stuff that I might want to pitch to Macworld or some other place.

0:04:13and I just keep track of it. I tag it by who I might want to pitch it to, and they got

0:04:19ten really shitty ideas in there right now.

0:04:23Dave So I built it. I don't know if everybody

0:04:26knows. Probably everybody knows by now, but I worked on it with Brent Simmons, legendary

0:04:31developer, and Dave Whiskus, a very, very good designer. But let's face it. Whiskus

0:04:37is no Simmons.

0:04:38Tim Who is, though.

0:04:40Dave No, not really.

0:04:41Tim That may be an unfair comparison.

0:04:43Yeah, you know Brent really is amazing

0:04:46I mean Dave is super talented and Dave's the one who I worked with the most like I had the most

0:04:51interaction like it is a funny thing with the three-man team, but

0:04:55Dave ended up being sort of the hub where

0:04:59Dave and I would go back and forth on design and I mean like literally I'll bet we have tens of thousands of instant messages

0:05:07since December when we started

0:05:10I mean, I should figure out a way to write a script to like go through the message logs

0:05:14and count them.

0:05:15But I mean, thousands of iMessages.

0:05:19And then we'd settle on something and Dave would be the one who would give it to Brent

0:05:24in a form that, "Here, this is what we want you to make.

0:05:28This is what it should look like."

0:05:29But, you know, I certainly had interactions with Brent.

0:05:34You know, we were using the glassboard internally.

0:05:37But he's amazing.

0:05:39He truly is.

0:05:40Like, working with Brent Simmons is exactly what you think it might be like.

0:05:45Like things he'll, you know, be like, "Look, we want you to change this to be like this."

0:05:50And he'd be like, "Whew.

0:05:51All right.

0:05:52It's going to take two days."

0:05:54And 30 minutes later, he's like, "Uh, I figure…"

0:05:56Yeah, it's literally.

0:05:57He'd be like, "You know what?

0:05:58I was stupid.

0:05:59We could use the blah, blah, blah.

0:06:01I never used it before.

0:06:02I never looked at it, but it was really easy to hook up and now it works."

0:06:06We'd be like, "Oh, okay."

0:06:08It must be nice to be able to do that.

0:06:13I made a number of false starts at trying to learn how to program just anything, really.

0:06:22I always hit a wall, but I always dreamed that it would be nice to be able to have that

0:06:26facility.

0:06:27Dave: Me too.

0:06:29I'll tell you what it's like with having Brent and Dave to combine, really, for me.

0:06:37I used to use, remember the real basic?

0:06:39- Yeah, yeah.

0:06:41- It's still around, but it's sort of shifted

0:06:43in terms of its focus.

0:06:44But back when it first came out and it was Mac only,

0:06:47it was really great for someone like me who can program,

0:06:53but is not really good at programming,

0:06:55and it sort of does all the scaffolding for you,

0:06:58and you can just sort of put a button in a thing

0:07:00and drag it around and make it look right,

0:07:02and then click on the button and say,

0:07:03here's the code that the button should run.

0:07:05It was a lot, or a hypercard for people who are older

0:07:07have longer memories. It's a lot like that. Yeah. And I've read so often on during fireball

0:07:12over the years, I've, you know, bemoaned the lack of, for lack of a better sake, a modern

0:07:17hypercard, right? Like, let's say something for iPhone or iPad, where you could, you know,

0:07:22drag stuff around and sort of wouldn't be a replacement for Xcode, it would be sort

0:07:26of a higher level Xcode for, you know, less, you know, talented people. I don't know how

0:07:34us to say it. I don't know. You know, I mean, well, but like the difference between iPhoto

0:07:40and Lightroom or Aputure, right? Like, you know, something that's not for pros. And if you are a

0:07:46pro, if you're taking professional caliber photography, you're not gonna use iPhoto to,

0:07:51to, you know, take out the red eye, you're going to use Photoshop and Lightroom, you know, the

0:07:56equivalent of that for programming. Working with Brent and Dave is like having that, except from

0:08:02like a hundred years in the future where you just talk to the thing and it's like

0:08:07it's like no I here's the idea I think that when you slide the hamburger button

0:08:14over to get to the sidebar there should be like this parallax effect on the

0:08:19sidebar as it drags out instead of just being there it would kind of and and ten

0:08:24minutes later it's like I just do a pull from the source you know the the

0:08:29the Mercurial source code thing and do a build and it's on my phone and it works. And it's

0:08:33like what? It is amazing. It really has been a tremendous amount of fun for me.

0:08:40So everyone should just have their own Brent Simmons.

0:08:43That's exactly my point. Everybody should go out and buy it. You should probably buy

0:08:47Vesper. Go to the Vesperapp.co website. Can you believe some son of a bitch has been sitting

0:08:53on Vesperapp.com? It's just like a placeholder. What the hell is that? It's just a thing.

0:08:58like somebody 10 years ago randomly bought that yeah so we had to settle for

0:09:04Vesper app didn't that co well that's not so bad but he didn't he didn't

0:09:08contact you and contacted yet and tried to sell it to you for five thousand ten

0:09:12thousand no not yet maybe he will I don't know seems like that that would be

0:09:18likely the next shoe to drop so my smart right I mean yeah I guess I don't know

0:09:25who knows I never tell you about the guy who has newspaper calm now go to

0:09:31newspaper calm is it alright yeah it is safe for work I guarantee you it is the

0:09:37in fact it is the safest for work website on the internet everybody out

0:09:43there listening to the show open or I'll open up your phone and go to newspaper

0:09:47Which is why it's taking so long.

0:09:53I see what you did there.

0:09:56Did it work?

0:10:01Newspapers dot com?

0:10:02I thought it was newspaper dot com.

0:10:06Just stuck.

0:10:10That could be.

0:10:13Well anyway it points to...

0:10:14We're not having good technology days.

0:10:17Yeah.

0:10:18Well, here's the spoiler.

0:10:19It points to DaringFireball.net.

0:10:20Oh, really?

0:10:22Yeah.

0:10:23And it's not mine.

0:10:27I don't own it.

0:10:28Oh, okay.

0:10:29No.

0:10:30Whoever owns it though knows that it's valuable.

0:10:33And I don't even know his name.

0:10:34I think he did email me.

0:10:36I might have his name.

0:10:38What happened is I started getting offers from people who wanted to buy it. And I was

0:10:48like, "Why are people doing this? Why am I getting offers for this domain that I don't

0:10:52have?" And then I went to it and I saw that it pointed to darinkfireball.net and I got

0:10:56very confused. And so somehow I got in touch with the guy. And long story short, he's had

0:11:01it for years. He knows it's valuable. He doesn't really want to sell it though and doesn't

0:11:04don't want to give it to jerks." And he said, "I just – but I really like your website,

0:11:09so I figured I'd just point it there for now. I have nothing better to put there."

0:11:12And I was like, "Okay. That's cool with me." And he was like, "If you don't want it, I'll

0:11:16take it away." And I was like, "No, I don't care."

0:11:18Tim Cynova That explains all your page views.

0:11:20Dave Asprey Yeah. Wouldn't that be funny if that actually

0:11:23is? Tim Cynova

0:11:24Oh, there it works. I did it. I tried it again. I just went – it came right out.

0:11:26Dave Asprey Yeah. It was like some kind of hiccup on the

0:11:28redirect. Tim Cynova

0:11:29The first – yeah. Dave Asprey

0:11:30Wouldn't that be hilarious if he sold it and something else went there and then all

0:11:33of a sudden my traffic just completely dried up. It ends up that my website is not that

0:11:38popular at all. That would be hilarious.

0:11:45Yeah, I'm sure that would be really funny for you. So, by the time this episode comes

0:12:00out…

0:12:01over the weekend. I want this episode.

0:12:02Oh, yeah. Okay. So, we can talk. We can talk WWDC.

0:12:06Yeah. WWDC is coming up. You know what's amazing about WWDC is – oh, you know what

0:12:12I should tell everybody? I want to tell everybody before we move on that – so, why do I have

0:12:18John Moltz on the show instead of Brent and Dave? I'll have Brent and Dave on the show

0:12:21eventually anyway. But they've got podcast too. Brent has the one he does with Michael

0:12:26Simmons, the identical cousins. Michael Simmons is a guy behind Fantastic Al and a bunch of

0:12:33other great, great apps. But Brent and him, who are not related, just because their last

0:12:39name is the same, they have to have a podcast together. And that's cool. And Dave, of course,

0:12:45right here on Mule Radio, has The Unprofessional with Lex Friedman, which is a pretty good

0:12:51podcast. I don't know. I've never listened to it.

0:12:53but they get some pretty good guests.

0:12:56- They do, they do, you've been on it, right?

0:12:58- Apart from me and your wife.

0:12:59- Well, they did, yeah, well, do they have other guests?

0:13:03No, they get amazing guests, that's actually their shtick.

0:13:05- They really get great guests.

0:13:06- They do.

0:13:07- I don't know how they do it, but they get great guests.

0:13:10- But we figured, hey, you know what would be fair,

0:13:17would be maybe we'll do the talk show eventually,

0:13:20but why don't we do somebody else's show?

0:13:22And so we did Renee Ritchie and Guy English's Debug Podcast.

0:13:27And they were beta testers too, so they knew about them.

0:13:30We recorded it a few days ago, and that's out.

0:13:34So you can just Google it.

0:13:36But anybody who likes the talk show,

0:13:37you're going to love this episode of Debug.

0:13:40It is two hours of us talking everything Vesper,

0:13:44and collaboration, and how do people--

0:13:46three guys who work in Seattle, Denver, and Philadelphia

0:13:52collaborate and make an app. I thought it really turned out great. So look for that.

0:13:56It's the Bug Pod Debug. It's over there at the iMore website, but it's really, really

0:14:02good. I think people here are going to like it.

0:14:04Tim Cynova You know that Rene Ritchie? He's a smart guy.

0:14:07Dave Asprey Oh, my God. He's just incredibly smart.

0:14:10Tim Cynova Yeah. And Guy English is good looking.

0:14:14Yeah, he is bastard

0:14:16WWDC

0:14:23So, you know, what's amazing? I think it's amazing. We're recording this on Friday. There is like nothing

0:14:28Like there's a little is there did I miss well? Well, there's the okay Mac Pro, right, right and

0:14:35MacBook Air right those two seem pretty sure

0:14:40For next week, right? Yeah

0:14:43And then everything else is kind of a...

0:14:50The Mac Pro. So what do you think is going on with that? I saw Marco had like a detailed

0:14:54thing. Some of these guys get real into it.

0:14:56Yeah, Marco is really into it.

0:14:58Right, because Marco gets... I guess that's because he really needs it. But Marco really

0:15:02gets into it with the Intel roadmap and knowing what Intel has and therefore what's possible.

0:15:11I don't know. Maybe I'm just losing it as I get older. I just can't do that level of

0:15:17research. I'm just going to wait for Apple to tell me what's in the damn thing.

0:15:22Yeah. Would you really buy one?

0:15:25I would consider it because I've still been putting this off for years and years of just

0:15:30breaking down and getting a new computer. My computer is ancient. I still call it a

0:15:36My display is ancient.

0:15:39It's only 20 inches.

0:15:41I think it's like eight, nine years old.

0:15:43I don't know.

0:15:45So I'm due for a nice big upgrade here on my desk.

0:15:48And I've just been waiting for the right one.

0:15:50And I just keep putting off buying an iMac

0:15:52because I just feel like it's--

0:15:54I don't know, I'm just resistant to tying my display

0:15:56to the computer.

0:15:58And I don't think the Mini--

0:15:59I don't want the Mini.

0:16:00I want something better.

0:16:01If it's going to be on my desktop,

0:16:02I want something that's going to be fast for years to come.

0:16:05Yeah.

0:16:06It does seem more though that it really is a pro, it's more of a pro machine than it

0:16:13used to be.

0:16:15Even much more than, what's it called now?

0:16:18The MacBook Pro.

0:16:22Because the laptop seems like more people get it than just really professionals.

0:16:26Whereas only professionals are really interested in the Mac Pro these days.

0:16:31It used to be that it was not an uncommon thing to get a machine that you wanted to

0:16:36use for gaming or whatever and you would upgrade it.

0:16:38So you wanted something that you could upgrade all the parts inside of.

0:16:42And now the prices have come down to the point where it's just like you just buy a new one

0:16:47every few years.

0:16:48You keep up that way.

0:16:50Because I always ran into this problem.

0:16:51I haven't had a pro since my last one was like a 1999 Sawtooth.

0:16:58And I used it for years and kept upgrading components on the inside.

0:17:02But then eventually you run into the problem where third-party peripheral makers won't

0:17:07support adding cards.

0:17:09They only want to…

0:17:12If you're not plugging the device into an Apple-supplied USB 3.0 card, they're not

0:17:20going to help you.

0:17:23So if you put a PCI, third-party PCI card that gives your older Mac USB 3, you're out

0:17:33of luck.

0:17:34So it doesn't seem like it's worth it anymore.

0:17:37No.

0:17:38And it sounds like from the rumors that what they're going to do, if they really do have

0:17:42Mac Pros to announce, is that they're going to change from internal, you know, it's still

0:17:47going to be the upgradable machine, but it's going to be all about the, what's it called,

0:17:51the Thunderbolt.

0:17:52Thunderbolt.

0:17:53and it's going to be so I think I can only assume if it's external rather than

0:18:00internal therefore the actual Mac Pro will therefore shrink in size

0:18:05tremendously yeah and then you'll just you know connect whatever external stuff

0:18:10you need through Thunderbolt yeah which is interesting it would be I mean is that

0:18:18I guess that's possible I guess I should have I guess Syracuse it would know he's

0:18:21He's probably rolling his eyes at our ignorance.

0:18:24He's probably having a stroke as he listens to this episode.

0:18:29Would it be possible to have an external video card?

0:18:31I guess so.

0:18:32I guess that's the whole point.

0:18:33Right?

0:18:34If you wanted to add an extra video card to add another Al Gore-style 30-inch display

0:18:38to your desk, you'd have some kind of external thing that you would connect.

0:18:43That seems crazy.

0:18:44Yeah.

0:18:45It's a whole new world.

0:18:49I think that's the gist of the expectations that Mac Pro hardware Macbook Airs

0:18:53Well, will they will they or not be retina? I don't know I guess that's the big question

0:18:59But most you know, I think most of the thing is gonna be about the software it's gonna be about Mac OS 10

0:19:0510.9 and iOS 7 right and nobody seems to know Jack about anything about it. Yeah

0:19:12Which is kind of exciting. So is it Monday? Yes, it's Monday morning, right?

0:19:18because the WWDC runs all week

0:19:22so that keynote is monday even though they usually prefer Tuesday

0:19:26announcements and stuff

0:19:28now i'm super excited i know absolutely almost absolutely nothing i don't think

0:19:33i've been this ignorant of what's coming

0:19:36software-wise

0:19:38for a keynote

0:19:40since the iphone one back in

0:19:42two thousand seven

0:19:44which is great i'm super excited about it

0:19:47unless they get up there and they don't have anything to announce.

0:19:51[laughter]

0:19:52Wouldn't that be great?

0:19:56The one thing I keep hearing over and over again from friends who would know is the one

0:20:02word I keep hearing is that some of the stuff they're going to show is "polarizing."

0:20:07Flat?

0:20:08No, polarizing.

0:20:10Polarizing?

0:20:11Yeah.

0:20:13I also heard from somebody that just, quote, "All the leaks are wrong," which is interesting.

0:20:21I have no idea what to make of it.

0:20:26One way that could be, wouldn't it be great if it was like the new look couldn't be more

0:20:33extravagantly skeuomorphic?

0:20:35It's like a liberal – like the entire OS looks like the Liberace house in that Candelabra

0:20:42It's all like gold and shiny.

0:20:47We got rid of all the felt and leather and replaced it with gold and platinum.

0:20:50It's skins.

0:20:51They have a whole bunch of skins.

0:20:54And then you do an in-app purchase to upgrade.

0:20:57To get more.

0:20:58Right.

0:20:59To get like a better, you know, like it comes with diamonds, but they're like low on, what

0:21:05are those things?

0:21:06Clarity and the color.

0:21:08Cut and clarity.

0:21:09Cut and clarity.

0:21:10You kind of do an in-app upgrade to get a better diamond better and bigger diamonds

0:21:13You remember all those remember those skins that they had and was it a West eight

0:21:19That ever actually come that ever did that did that ever actually come out? Oh my god John

0:21:27I can't believe you remember used to get kaleidoscope, right?

0:21:30There was that kaleidoscope for years right and then they did put they did put that in yeah

0:21:34But what happened is and then jobs took it back out when he got back before it actually shipped

0:21:40So they shipped OS 8 with the appearance manager. It was what it was called. It was the shift where it was called the appearance manager. Capital A, capital M.

0:21:54And that was a big pain in the ass for developers to support a lot of rewriting. Which was all about making it themable.

0:22:04And then Jobs got there and said, "These other themes all look like garbage.

0:22:07We're not shipping them.

0:22:08Take them out.

0:22:09You know, we're – the user doesn't design the system.

0:22:13We do.

0:22:14This is what it looks like."

0:22:15So they had – they shipped the OS with this appearance manager that supported multiple

0:22:18themes that never had more than one theme.

0:22:21And I guess the other ones leaked, you know, that – what was it?

0:22:24Gizmo?

0:22:25And Tecmo or something like that.

0:22:27Tecmo was like a dark black one, you know.

0:22:30It's like a kids' one.

0:22:31Was that Gizmo?

0:22:32I think that was Gizmo. Gizmo looked like Nickelodeon. It was asymmetrical and had little

0:22:38squiggly spiral straws and stuff like that. But they never shipped it. I don't remember

0:22:49if hackers, I think hackers, like enthusiasts, ended up backwards engineering the theme format

0:22:54and so you could, in a way that you could get kaleidoscope themes, you could get appearance

0:22:58manager themes but I don't think it ever overtook I think the people who are into

0:23:03that still stuck with kaleidoscope because it actually yeah yeah it was

0:23:06better right and more they had more themes right so what do you expect well

0:23:17other than this there's two hardware things that I mentioned I don't know

0:23:20either it would be nice to see something about the iPhone hardware wise but

0:23:28It doesn't seem like that's the… unless they come out… unless they're doing a

0:23:34launch of a cheaper phone.

0:23:35Yeah, I just don't see it.

0:23:39Yeah.

0:23:40No way.

0:23:41No.

0:23:42I mean, it would certainly be a big drop out of nowhere.

0:23:43I mean, would it be shocking?

0:23:45No.

0:23:46But it just seems like that sort of thing, if it were coming, would be braced for it.

0:23:53And I do think that the thing Tim Cook said at the-- was it D11?

0:23:59I think that was the only place he really spoke.

0:24:01But where he said, we've got great stuff in the line later in the year and next year.

0:24:05I think that means I know iOS devices till later in the year.

0:24:11Mac doesn't even count anymore, really.

0:24:14Well, it doesn't in terms of what drives the market at large.

0:24:19Like, you know, it doesn't matter.

0:24:21Like, let's just say Monday, come Monday, they announce a new Mac Pro.

0:24:24And it makes everybody happy.

0:24:27John Siracusa is happy.

0:24:29Marco is happy.

0:24:30You know, it's super powerful.

0:24:32It is super expandable.

0:24:34It is at a great price.

0:24:36And it looks cool.

0:24:38That does nothing to Apple's stock.

0:24:40And it does nothing.

0:24:41It shouldn't actually.

0:24:42That's this is one case.

0:24:43It's not a complaint because I think, you know, the most possible Mac Pros they would

0:24:46sell at the best price with great margins and it's an amazing product is almost negligible

0:24:52to their bottom line.

0:24:56That's why Tim Cook, I think, has to say that.

0:25:01They can't oversell the Mac Pro as being an important product.

0:25:06Yeah, there I mean it seems like the Mac line is

0:25:09Caught up with the the malaise that's affecting the PC industry as a whole. Yeah, I definitely think so

0:25:18Speaking of stock price though. Do you see this? I just saw this today on

0:25:23Strat tech Gary that's the the new website from Ben

0:25:27Ben Thompson

0:25:33Been reading that site. I have it's a good site. Yeah

0:25:35He's got a thing here.

0:25:39Samsung Electronics lost $12 billion in market value on smartphone worries.

0:25:44So it seems like they're copying everything from Apple.

0:25:47Tim Cynova Shamelessly.

0:25:49Dave Asprey Now they're even copying irrational investor

0:25:53panic that loses billions of dollars in market cap in a single day.

0:25:59Tim Cynova On slowing sales of flagship Galaxy S4 smartphone.

0:26:03phone. Right, which I don't know because I don't know. Again, and this is, you know,

0:26:09here's, here's, you know, here's me trying to be, or hopefully showing that I'm not,

0:26:14you know, blindly pro-apple. Like, this makes no sense to me. This, you know, Samsung is,

0:26:22everybody, for everything I saw is that the Galaxy S4 is selling exactly as they wanted

0:26:26the Galaxy S4 to sell. It seemed like it was selling fairly well, but at the same time,

0:26:31I think some of the analysts, all this stuff is about Wall Street expectations. What they

0:26:35had expected was something like 30 million a quarter, and it was only selling like 20

0:26:42million a quarter. They had to cut their expectations.

0:26:45Dave: Yeah, I guess. I don't know.

0:26:47Tim N

0:27:00It's a wildly competitive business and traditionally fortunes do change every few years.

0:27:06So I'm not saying that Samsung and Apple's positions are locked in and a sure thing going

0:27:12forward forever and ever.

0:27:13Of course not.

0:27:14But $12 billion in market cap in a day doesn't seem anywhere near rational.

0:27:21Seems like anybody investing in mobile technology, tablets and cell phones at all, pretty much

0:27:28treats it like being drunk at the blackjack table.

0:27:32"Ah, double down.

0:27:33I'm out.

0:27:34I'm out."

0:27:35I don't know where…

0:27:38I always think that they try to keep that money in the same sort of industry in general.

0:27:46So if you're not investing in Apple and Samsung, who the heck are you going to take

0:27:49your money out of?

0:27:50You should take your money out of those two.

0:27:52Where are you putting it?

0:27:56The other thing that Ben Thompson had talked about, I think maybe it was last week that

0:28:00I wanted to talk to you about, was Apple TV predictions because he has predicted an SDK

0:28:07for the Apple TV on Monday.

0:28:10We had talked about this.

0:28:11I feel like you and I talked about this a while ago.

0:28:15No one's been talking about that recently, but he brought that back up.

0:28:18That's a good topic.

0:28:20Let's get to it, but let's do the first sponsor break first and then we'll do that.

0:28:24And the first sponsor, this is great, I'm going to tell you about An Event Apart.

0:28:29It's the design conference for people who make websites.

0:28:32They have upcoming events.

0:28:34Now this is one of the things that's great about An Event Apart is they don't just do

0:28:38like one big show a year and then you got to go there and do it.

0:28:41They bring the show around the country.

0:28:43They've got upcoming events in San Diego, Boston, Washington, DC, Chicago, Austin, Texas,

0:28:50and San Francisco.

0:28:54by web visionaries Eric Meyer and Jeffrey Zeldman, friends of mine, both great guys,

0:29:00dedicated to the proposition that the creators of great web experiences deserve a great learning

0:29:06experience. And Event Apart brings together 12 leading minds in web design for two days

0:29:11of nonstop inspiration and enlightenment, plus an optional day-long workshop on multi-device

0:29:17web design, which is really, I mean, bottom line is, is that's where web design is today,

0:29:22How do you make stuff look great across three inch screens to 30 inch screens?

0:29:28If you care about code as well as content usability and design, Event Apart is the conference

0:29:32you've been waiting for.

0:29:35Go to aneventapart.com/talkshow.

0:29:42Aneventapart.com/talkshow to learn more.

0:29:46I've been to several Event Aparts.

0:29:50And they're one of the best run, smoothest conferences I've ever been at.

0:29:56I was actually at the very first one.

0:29:58The first one was actually in Philadelphia, I think back in, I want to say 2007, 2008-ish,

0:30:05something like that.

0:30:06It was right here in Philadelphia.

0:30:07And I was at one a couple of years ago in Chicago.

0:30:09It was fantastic.

0:30:12Amazing conference.

0:30:13Mike: Yeah.

0:30:14And they always have some of our pals speaking.

0:30:17Speaking. Oh, yeah, great speakers. Really really great. See Mike Monteiro's mug on their page

0:30:23Yeah, Mike's been there

0:30:25Jason Santa Maria is a longtime speaker there man. Does that guy know how to talk about typography and stuff like that?

0:30:32Great great stuff. So Apple TV next week boy, that would be a good surprise. That would be exciting. Yeah

0:30:39Here's why I think he's wrong though

0:30:44Unless I think and and guy English and I have talked this over, you know, you know, it's no deja vu

0:30:50But we've talked about on the show

0:30:52I think that he's right that there is an SDK coming for Apple TV and apps and that it'll be a third-party thing. I

0:31:00Don't think it's coming to the Apple TV that we have today. I think it requires

0:31:05Next generation hardware and the reason I think that is that I think it requires some sort of next generation

0:31:13remote. And the current one just doesn't have the support for that.

0:31:19No, you can't do anything with the current one.

0:31:21You could do—the only thing you could do—it's fine for play/pause and seek, up/down/left/right,

0:31:28play/pause, but it's not good for any—so it really wouldn't be good for apps that

0:31:33did anything more than just deliver video content, which alone is a big deal. I mean,

0:31:39let's face it, things are TV. But I think that thing needs games and stuff like that.

0:31:46And I think that needs a next generation remote. And I don't think that the remote can be,

0:31:51well, just use this app on your iPhone or iPod or iPad or something like that.

0:31:57**Matt Stauffer:** Why not?

0:31:58**Ezra Klein:** Because I think it's clumsy. I think it's

0:32:01weird to think that you've got to fish your iPhone out of your pocket just to do anything

0:32:05on the TV. I think you need a remote that sits there on your coffee table and it's ready

0:32:09to go. And it doesn't cost $600 or $700. I mean, I guess iPod Touch is 220 now that they

0:32:19have the new one. But you can't sell a $99 set-top box that requires a $220 remote. It

0:32:26just doesn't work. And I just don't think an app is the right thing. I don't think because

0:32:31apps. This is the other thing is I think that the, you know, iPhone is all about looking

0:32:38at the screen and touching things right TV is about looking not at your remote, it's

0:32:43about looking at the screen. Right, you need a remote that that you don't look at to use.

0:32:51And the iPhone is not it a piece of glass is, you know, it gives you no affordance for

0:32:55for knowing what you're doing.

0:32:58Gosh, it seems weird to think of Apple shipping

0:33:01a remote with physical keys for gaming.

0:33:07Yeah, this is where my imagination fails me.

0:33:10And maybe I'm wrong.

0:33:11Maybe I'm all wet, and it really is something about apps,

0:33:15an app that you control it with.

0:33:17Or maybe it's like a Kinect type thing,

0:33:19and you wave your hand and talk to it.

0:33:21I don't know.

0:33:21I lack the imagination to even think about what it is.

0:33:25but I just know that it just seems to me in my gut though,

0:33:28like I can't imagine what the new thing

0:33:31that I think they have to make to make this happen is,

0:33:34but I do know that the one I have downstairs isn't it.

0:33:38Right, you can't just have that little crummy remote.

0:33:41- Yeah, but really just the remote.

0:33:43It's not so much anything with the device.

0:33:46- Yeah, I don't think that in terms of,

0:33:48now that they've got 1080p output,

0:33:50they're set in terms of like hardware,

0:33:54and I don't think it needs to be all that computationally. Although maybe it needs better

0:33:58graphics for games. I don't think that they're obviously not going to, well not obviously,

0:34:03but I think we know Apple isn't going to get in a graphics horsepower race with Xbox and

0:34:09PlayStation and sell $300, $400 things that are at a loss. But more graphics power is

0:34:20always better. But I don't know how different it is than the Retina iPad. I think that these

0:34:29A6 or A7 or whatever the next one's going to be are already pretty graphically powerful.

0:34:37Tim Cynova So that's sort of the dark horse.

0:34:41Dave Asprey What do you think?

0:34:42Well, I don't see why they couldn't deliver a remote next week and the SDK.

0:34:53But I certainly haven't heard anything.

0:35:00He was the only one that I noticed talking about it, and I just jog my memory that that

0:35:04was something, seemed like something that was on our list of possibilities and then

0:35:07dropped off the radar. Because it didn't happen for a while.

0:35:13Yeah, and I guess the other thing that I, you know, maybe he's right is, is I guess

0:35:21the other thing I think in my head is it would be weird if they announced it and

0:35:25said, "Hey, we have this great new app store," and said, "You have to buy a new

0:35:28Apple TV and all of you guys who've already bought an Apple TV, you know,

0:35:32tough noogies." You know, like, that's a hard... Not that Apple never does that. Not

0:35:37Not that Apple never is afraid to give you tough noogies news,

0:35:42lovers of floppy drives.

0:35:43But it seems a little--

0:35:47I don't know.

0:35:48It seems like that's a tough thing to--

0:35:50Well, why couldn't they just sell the remote separately, too?

0:35:53Yeah, maybe.

0:35:53Does that-- I guess I can--

0:35:55It comes with a new one.

0:35:57Right.

0:35:58And maybe--

0:35:59And you probably-- I mean, if you're going to have--

0:36:01it's going to be like--

0:36:02Bluetooth is what it would be.

0:36:03that Bluetooth level four that's low power.

0:36:07- And if it's gonna be like the Wii or whatever,

0:36:09you're probably gonna want six of them.

0:36:11- Yeah, maybe, I don't know.

0:36:14Yeah, I didn't even think about that,

0:36:18that if it's like a combination remote game controller,

0:36:21you'd want multiple ones.

0:36:22- You guys have a, you have a Wii U.

0:36:26- Yes.

0:36:27- And that does have, that has a screen,

0:36:30but it actually has physical buttons.

0:36:32on the remote. Yes. It's a weird thing. Jonas really likes it. Just by coincidence, it really

0:36:44is funny. Our old Wii crapped out a couple of days before Christmas. We actually needed

0:36:54something. I guess I could have bought a new Wii. It does seem, though, like the Wii U

0:37:01it's just not getting a lot of games. And the controller is interesting, but it is weird.

0:37:05Yeah. The weirdest thing about it is that it currently only supports one. Like, you

0:37:12can use as many – for – to play multiplayer games, you just use the old Wii controllers.

0:37:17But the new – the new touch screen, the one that gets all the things, the system can

0:37:21only support one of those at a time. Huh. Because that's not what the – I'm pretty

0:37:28pretty sure that's not what the intro, you know, like the videos showed when the thing

0:37:32came out.

0:37:33I don't know. I don't think that they showed multiple. I don't know. But it does. It was

0:37:37a surprise to me. It's because it just seemed to me like, yeah, just seems no fair. You

0:37:44know, here, I play a two player game and I get this fancy new touchscreen thing here,

0:37:48you get a joystick. But I guess all the multiplayer games that we have so far when you do play

0:37:52multiplayer at both people have to use the the old school Wii remote. And it's just single

0:37:57player games where you get the touch screen one.

0:38:01You know, and there's some cool games that take advantage of it.

0:38:03He's got this Batman Arkham Asylum game, which is a questionable content level for a nine-year-old.

0:38:10I was going to say, they're the one that's rated for like 14 and up.

0:38:13Yeah.

0:38:14My wife heard him.

0:38:18But he's seen, you know, he's seen The Shining, so.

0:38:24But it does have some cool stuff where the gimmick is that the touch screen is...

0:38:34Batman has built a new thing on his suit where he's sort of got like an iPhone built into his wrist

0:38:39on his armor and I'm so old. He's got an iWatch? Yeah, sort of. Yeah, he's got like a... yeah,

0:38:46yeah, he's got like a big four-inch iWatch and the the remote is the iWatch.

0:38:52So like, you know, you so you know the game is first-person perspective.

0:38:58Right, and it's it seems like well done but it's I you know I'm not

0:39:05surprised that Nintendo's not doing too well. Yeah, I think you know I do think

0:39:11the potential there is for the sort of explosive vibrance in gaming that you see in the App Store

0:39:21from iPhone and iPad where two guys can just go and make games. And I know that there's things

0:39:28like that for PlayStation and there's a marketplace or something like that. But Apple does that better

0:39:34than anybody else. Like everybody will say, "Hey, PlayStation's had the, what do you call it,

0:39:39and Xbox has the 360 market or Xbox Live or whatever the hell it's called where you can

0:39:44download indie games. So like everything else, Apple won't be first, but they'll be.

0:39:50>> Yeah. On the Wii, they seem like they're older. I don't know what it's like on the

0:39:59Xbox, but it seems like they're older games on the Wii and usually not. The indie ones

0:40:04are not necessarily as good as the stuff that you get on the disk.

0:40:08Right. Whereas I foresee with Apple, it would be a type of thing where an indie game might

0:40:13turn out to be the hit game of the year. The biggest game. You're not in this little ghetto

0:40:19where EA and the big publishers like that are all the flagship titles and you're over

0:40:25here in the little market. I would foresee it like the app store where two guys can make

0:40:35Doodle jump and the thing is like the top grossing app and the whole thing for the year

0:40:39right

0:40:43on the world

0:40:45it seems like and that's you know that kind of

0:40:50almost a whole new platform is would be a great thing for Apple right now given the

0:40:56whining and complaining

0:40:58yeah it kind of would be I still think and I've said this before many times and our poor

0:41:03friend Gene Munster, who I really think is losing his mind. You see he tweeted at me

0:41:11when I…

0:41:12Yeah. Yeah. You told me that.

0:41:14Yeah. Good spirit. Good ticket and stride. Gene Munster, for those of you who don't

0:41:21know, is an Apple analyst. He's somewhere out of like Minneapolis or something like

0:41:25that, long-term follower of the company, oft-quoted. He's always available to media looking for

0:41:31a quote on Apple. And for the most part, I think he gets the company. He's not a jackass.

0:41:37He's a pretty astute analyst. But he's obsessed. I would say, I think for about five or six

0:41:46years with the idea of Apple selling a TV set. In his world, the Apple TV is an actual

0:41:54screen, the 50, 60-inch LCD or whatever it would be, screen. And he's been saying that

0:42:00it's coming in a year for about five years. Would you say that's right?

0:42:06I think that's about right. And as time goes on, and they might be working, but

0:42:10his obsession is just palpable, like where, you know, he'll chime in every

0:42:17time on a conference call, when it's time for Gene Munster, you know it's gonna be

0:42:22something about Apple TV. And he hears stuff, you know, that just isn't

0:42:28there. It's like when Tim Cook on the last one said, more or less, I mean this isn't

0:42:35a quote, but he said, "We've got some great products that we're working on for later

0:42:39this year and next year." Right? More or less is what he said. Gene Munster heard that

0:42:47as, "We're going to have an Apple TV later this year or next year." Right? I mean,

0:42:53like well maybe you know it could be but that's not what he said but I think I

0:43:01still think I think that Apple's TV strategy is what we see I think it's

0:43:06right in front of us it's a $99 box that you hook up to any TV that you want and

0:43:12you know and there's some iteration some iteration of that right but not not it

0:43:17yeah I don't it doesn't seem like there's value and in trying to get into

0:43:21making thousand dollar huge screens right or you know and I've said this

0:43:29before too maybe they would but only as like in addition to a box that you can

0:43:37put into anybody's TV right that they would still sell the $99 box and maybe

0:43:42they would also sell an Apple branded TV set that has it built in but so you can

0:43:47get on the platform and buy the apps and use your Apple TV with your existing TV set. And

0:43:52if you're in the market for a new TV set, you could just buy the Apple one and have

0:43:56one less box. But I don't think that they would go TV set only because it seems to me

0:44:01like they'd be purposefully taking only a very small part of the market, which is the

0:44:05people in the market for a new TV set.

0:44:08I mean, like look at the iPhone, right? The iPhone has been a tremendous hit. But people

0:44:15didn't buy them all at once. People bought them over time as they needed or wanted a new cell

0:44:22phone. It's a huge hit, but Apple doesn't make – I mean, idiots like us go get in line and buy

0:44:27stuff on day one, but that's not normal people. Normal people bought their iPhone when their old

0:44:32iPhone – when their old phone broke or they finally got fed up with it or just kind of got

0:44:36in the mood or especially when their contracts were up.

0:44:39Yeah, the contract. It's the contract.

0:44:42So I think the TV industry had a great decade because just about everybody I know has shifted

0:44:51from big old clunky glass CRTs to nice flat screen plasma or LCD or whatever, wide screen

0:45:02TVs. But everybody, I think normal people think, "Well, now I'm set. It's like the Fight

0:45:08club thing. I had a nice couch. I solved the couch problem. Now, I don't need to worry

0:45:13about a couch. Well, now, I feel like my TV set is set. I'm not in the market for a new

0:45:18TV set.

0:45:19Mike: Yeah. It's the same thing with cars. People also sometimes speculate that Apple

0:45:30release a car. You can't just get into that. You got to wait a long time in order to make

0:45:40any money out of either one of those businesses because people aren't just going to up and

0:45:44run out and buy another one.

0:45:45Dave Asprey But if they sold it as a $99 box that you attach

0:45:49to anybody's TV, all of a sudden, it's a new thing and you don't have to replace anything

0:45:54and you don't have to outlay a large amount of cash and boom, you're in.

0:45:58I've got a couple of other things I want to talk about.

0:46:04But let's do the second sponsor and then we'll do that and then we'll finish up.

0:46:09I want to talk about the eBook, Price Fixing.

0:46:12Man, I like that.

0:46:14Isn't it getting funny?

0:46:18I can't wait to talk about it.

0:46:21But our second sponsor, long-time friend of the show, our good friends at Squarespace.

0:46:27Space does it all. This is where you go if you need a website, you go to Squarespace,

0:46:33sign up and all of a sudden you have a website and it can do and be whatever you need. You

0:46:38need a portfolio site to show your art, you can make it a portfolio site. Do you need

0:46:43a blog? You can just turn it into a blog. They have that. You want to integrate it with

0:46:48your social media, you want to have your Twitter feed in there, you want to have your Instagram

0:46:52in there, you can just hook it up. You want to customize the templates, you can get in

0:46:58there at the code level. You don't want it, you don't know code, you don't know how to

0:47:01do CSS, you can change all sorts of stuff. You can customize, you can pick themes through

0:47:06a great interface, like a real interface that's meant for normal people to use and change

0:47:13all sorts of stuff and make a website that is all your own. It doesn't just look like

0:47:17a cookie cutter that everybody else has. You have your own website. Domain name registration,

0:47:22can handle it for you. Online commerce, they can handle it for you so you don't have to

0:47:27worry about all of that stuff. It's just a tremendous service. I keep hearing from readers

0:47:33who sign up and they're like, "You know, I hear you talking about Squarespace." I really

0:47:36do get email like this and you say it over and over again and I finally needed a website

0:47:40and I went and I just couldn't believe how easy it was. It's almost like a too good to

0:47:44be true type of thing when you go there. Check it out. What do you do to find out more? This

0:47:50This is easy. Just go to squarespace.com. Not a custom URL. Just go there. Just go to

0:47:54squarespace.com. But when you sign up, here's what you do. You use offer code, talk show

0:48:006. Talk show and then the Arabic numeral 6. And that will let you know you're coming from

0:48:09here. I thought that they incremented those with each sponsorship. It ends up I found

0:48:13out how those codes work. The 6 stands for June. It's the 6th month. So I'm not sure

0:48:20who's sponsoring shows later in a month but if there's another Squarespace

0:48:24sponsored later in a month it'll still be talk show six but if you're listening

0:48:27to this episode use that one and they'll know you came from this show if you need

0:48:31a website you're not if you don't check out Squarespace yeah the great thing

0:48:35about them is that you don't there's no you know you're probably visiting a

0:48:38whole bunch of great Squarespace sites and you don't even know it that is a

0:48:42great point that's a great point it's not like you sign up for Squarespace and

0:48:46now you've got a Squarespace site and there's yeah I was based off all over it

0:48:49It's not squarespace.com. There's no logo. There's nothing. It's your site. It's just

0:48:55it's easy to put together with their tools.

0:49:00Absolutely. E-book price fixing case. So that's gone to trial. It's kind of interesting. Now,

0:49:13I've had a busy week with Vesper,

0:49:15so I'm not as versed on this as I would be in a normal week,

0:49:20but I've been following,

0:49:21and Philip Elmer DeWitt has had some good coverage,

0:49:24as have some others.

0:49:26My perspective at the outset of this is that,

0:49:29and again, and critics of me

0:49:36who think I have a pro-Apple bias,

0:49:38maybe this is a case where they're right,

0:49:40because my thought going into this

0:49:42is that this seems like bullshit.

0:49:44Because, and you know, I'm not alone.

0:49:48Scott Turow, the president of the Authors Guild months ago

0:49:51had an op-ed in the New York Times

0:49:53in saying that the authors are on Apple's side of this,

0:49:56that they were opposed to Amazon,

0:49:58which had either a monopoly or a near monopoly on ebooks

0:50:03and were selling books at a loss.

0:50:07Like Scott Turow or anybody, big name novelist,

0:50:11comes out with a new novel.

0:50:12Publisher wants the ebook version at $15.

0:50:16So Amazon would buy it for $15 from them

0:50:19and sell it for $9.99.

0:50:22And now that's, you know, from a consumer point,

0:50:24now that's great.

0:50:24I can see and I know there's a lot of fans

0:50:26of Amazon for doing this,

0:50:27'cause consumers think that's great.

0:50:29I don't care if Amazon sells at a loss.

0:50:31I've saved five bucks on a book.

0:50:34That's great.

0:50:35Authors don't like it though,

0:50:37even though they get paid the wholesale price they wanted,

0:50:39because what they could see

0:50:40is that if Amazon solidified a long-term monopoly,

0:50:44then all of a sudden Amazon's going to say,

0:50:47okay, now your wholesale cost is $6

0:50:52because we're gonna keep selling them at 9.99

0:50:53and now we'd like to have a profit.

0:50:55And they'd have to acquiesce because there's a monopoly

0:50:58and there's no other way to do it.

0:51:00And so instead of $15 books, it would be $6 books.

0:51:03And consumers would be left out of it

0:51:05because they'd still be buying 9.99 books.

0:51:07all of a sudden the revenue generated by these books would be decimated.

0:51:11I'm not saying that's exactly what would happen, but that's the point of view of the authors

0:51:15and publishers of Amazon's selling at a loss thing.

0:51:22And this agency model is a way to make sure that publishers can't sell, resellers can't

0:51:29sell books at a loss.

0:51:31It's this app store model that's exactly like the app store where whatever the price is,

0:51:36the store gets 30%, and that's it.

0:51:43It's an interesting case because there are several ways to look at it.

0:51:47Because you could say, "Oh yeah, Apple's the bad guy because they're trying to drive

0:51:51the prices up."

0:51:53But at the same time, Amazon, so it's price fixing because Apple's trying to go in and

0:51:58get all these publishers to collude in fixing the prices of these books.

0:52:03At the same time, Amazon, because it's a monopoly, doesn't have to do collusion in

0:52:09order to have price fixing.

0:52:10It just fixes the price because it just does it itself.

0:52:15It's power as a basic – I mean, it's arguably – it's pretty close to a monopoly.

0:52:23There are other ways to get books.

0:52:25But –

0:52:26You know, and Apple – and it's not that Apple wanted to raise prices.

0:52:30It's that Apple wanted to let publishers set prices.

0:52:32So, like for example, with Vesper, we chose the price.

0:52:37We could have charged 99 cents.

0:52:39We could have charged – what was that I'm rich app?

0:52:44$999.99.

0:52:45I think that's the maximum.

0:52:46I forget how much that was.

0:52:48The maximum price in the app store.

0:52:51We picked the price and whatever price – it has to end at 99 cents.

0:52:56So any integer from 0 to 99 or 999 and then Apple takes 30 percent off every sale and

0:53:04that's it.

0:53:05We picked the price.

0:53:06Why shouldn't the people who make books have that same privilege or right to set the price

0:53:12of their book?

0:53:14It doesn't seem unreasonable to me.

0:53:16But here's another way of putting it.

0:53:22to me another way of putting it is that Apple's proposal to booksellers is why don't we sell

0:53:28ebooks like we sell apps. You set the price, we take 30% and handle the distribution in

0:53:36the DRM. And you know, so I don't see how that's anymore price fixing than it's price

0:53:42fixing with the app store.

0:53:45And yet all these publishers rolled over.

0:53:48Right. I don't think they wanted to fight.

0:53:52Yeah, yeah, yeah, and there's a lot there's lots of reasons why they might have done that but apparently they did

0:53:57Yeah, they just didn't want to deal with it

0:53:59And they're still they are still have what they wanted which is the agency model

0:54:03Right that they've sort of given in to the DOJ, but they still have the agency model, right? Isn't that how the Kindle thing works?

0:54:09Is an Amazon Amazon on the same page with that now, yes, yeah

0:54:19So then yesterday, this is the thing that to me is just amazing is

0:54:26There's two good stories well, the one is this is the first one is an Amazon executive took the stand and

0:54:38Wouldn't answer any questions. This is Russell

0:54:43Brandon Eddy, Amazon's vice president for Kindle content, was asked in court about a

0:54:48meeting he attended in Jeff Bezos' boathouse.

0:54:53And he said, "I'm not comfortable discussing the contents of that meeting."

0:54:56And he wouldn't even say whether Bezos was there.

0:55:03How weird is that?

0:55:04Yeah.

0:55:05What was that picture that you had retweeted?

0:55:12Was that a joke?

0:55:13Yeah, that was a joke. It was a retweet of...

0:55:17Okay, I didn't get it.

0:55:18Well, it was a scene from The Godfather.

0:55:20Okay.

0:55:22Somebody... The picture I retweeted was...

0:55:24I didn't place it.

0:55:25Here's a picture from the meeting at Bezos' house, and it was...

0:55:29It was the lake house in The Godfather II, where Michael decides to take care of...

0:55:36Take care of his brother, Fredo.

0:55:38right now.

0:55:41[laughs]

0:55:44So there's that, yeah, which is very strange.

0:55:48And well, anyway, it's very strange.

0:55:52And then today, there's another story about, this is on the verge, about Google's testimony.

0:56:01No, I didn't see that.

0:56:03I haven't seen it.

0:56:07They basically got the Google guy up on the stand and he initially said that publishers

0:56:20were telling him directly that Apple, told him directly that they were switching to the

0:56:27agency model because contracts they entered into with Apple required it.

0:56:32And then when they started cross-examining him, he said, "Well," basically said,

0:56:39"Who told you that?"

0:56:41He said, "I can't remember who told me that."

0:56:43And then he said, "Well, it might have been somebody on my team that they told."

0:56:47And he basically just admitted that he did not know of any instances of publishers telling

0:56:52anybody that.

0:56:53That's bizarre.

0:56:54He completely, completely collapsed.

0:57:02seems like a very strange why would you go in saying that if you weren't able to

0:57:08back it up that is very very strange so I asked about the guy the Amazon guy who

0:57:14wouldn't answer the questions I thought that was so bizarre and and in a way it

0:57:18was explained to me is well a it could have been sort of a taking the Fifth

0:57:22Amendment invoking the the the right not to incriminate yourself and which you

0:57:27shouldn't I I you know it's a amazing part of our Constitution and I fully

0:57:32support it. But, you know, when you invoke it, it does imply that, you know, that you're

0:57:39acknowledging a crime may have been committed, you know.

0:57:43[laughs]

0:57:44Like, and I really...

0:57:46Well, not necessarily.

0:57:48Right. But it's, you know, effectively he's a hostile witness. But I guess what the other

0:57:51thing that, you know, not being a lawyer, I didn't really think through, is that your

0:57:56obligation when you're on the stand and under oath in a court case, you are absolutely,

0:58:01law are, you know, with serious repercussions, you must tell the truth. But that doesn't

0:58:07mean you have to answer. So, I, see, I thought like yes/no questions you had to answer, but

0:58:13you don't. So they could say, "Was Jeff Bezos there?" And you can just say, "I'm not comfortable

0:58:17answering that. That's the truth. You're not lying." But they can't make you answer. And,

0:58:25you know, make of that what you will if you're on the jury or the judge. So, like, if, let's

0:58:30say Bezos was there. You can't say no, that's perjury. Now you've committed a felony. You

0:58:35can refuse to answer though, which is kind of just, I don't know. I would be so...

0:58:41>> They have to invoke some kind of law in order to compel you to answer the question.

0:58:48And in this instance, I don't think... They would have to... I guess they would have to

0:58:58evidence that a crime was being committed at the meeting.

0:59:01>> Right.

0:59:02>> Right?

0:59:03And then they will be able to say, well, if you're withholding evidence about what happened

0:59:07at this meeting, you're withholding evidence of a crime.

0:59:12And they have no evidence that a crime was committed at the meeting.

0:59:17Other than the murder of Fredo.

0:59:23We know there was a murder at the meeting, but other than that, we don't know what else

0:59:27It just really seems to me like a bad deal.

0:59:33And the other thing too is that it, you know, by all, everybody seems to suggest that this

0:59:37case was prompted by Amazon.

0:59:39That it was Amazon that got the DOJ, the Department of Justice to investigate this.

0:59:46But it seems as though Amazon did the exact same thing Apple did.

0:59:50They negotiated contracts with the publishers with the same terms.

0:59:57They're very strange to me. It really seems like a waste of time.

1:00:00I got to assume that Amazon spends a lot of money lobbying.

1:00:04I guess. It really just seems though...

1:00:07A lot more than Apple.

1:00:08Yeah. And that brings back that thing from a couple of weeks ago when Tim Cook was down

1:00:13there in front of the Senate testifying on taxes. And the guy at Politico had the thing

1:00:18that... Or I think it was Politico. I don't know where it was. Maybe it was the Washington

1:00:21Examiner or something. But more or less, the message really was nothing about Apple's taxes.

1:00:25It was really, "Hey, you guys should spend a lot more money on taxes."

1:00:27money on that. Otherwise, we're going to drag you down here again in a couple of months.

1:00:34It's a nice business you have here. I'd be ashamed of something you have to do with it.

1:00:43No, it's an ugly business. The last thing in the news, I think, I mean, again, I'm behind

1:00:49with the Vesper, but there's this whole, let's just call it what it is, a shitstorm about

1:00:55about the US government and national security agency and a couple of things actually. Two

1:01:04separate ones, at least two separate things but they're of the same piece. A couple of

1:01:10days ago, the Guardian got a tremendous scoop where they found a thing that shows that Verizon

1:01:18wireless in the US turns over to the NSA the phone records of everybody.

1:01:25They don't turn over the phone calls according to this.

1:01:28It's just the records and that the NSA, the darkest of the spook organizations in the

1:01:34US, the one that does all the electronic eavesdropping has phone records of everybody, every call

1:01:43you've made, every call everybody's made.

1:01:47you know, you're everybody. So just the, just the who called and who they called, right?

1:01:54Which is, you know, a huge, it's, you know, don't think, wow, who cares about that? That's huge.

1:02:00Incredible. I mean, you can draw all sorts of, oh, and location data, all the metadata associated

1:02:07with your cell phone account, which is a lot. And I would presume, I think it's, you know,

1:02:15I don't know that you could even find anybody to take this bet.

1:02:18I can only presume that it just so happens that it's the Verizon thing that leaked.

1:02:22It doesn't mean that only Verizon's doing it.

1:02:25If you think AT&T and Sprint and T-Mobile, et cetera, haven't too, you know, I've got

1:02:33a bridge to sell you.

1:02:35And I don't blame -- I can't believe these words are coming out of my mouth.

1:02:40I don't blame the carriers.

1:02:43I think this is like a godfather situation.

1:02:48I think the NSA came to them with an offer they could not refuse.

1:02:53You're going to give us everything and you're also not going to tell anybody that this is

1:02:59going on and you're going to like it.

1:03:03I think.

1:03:04I don't know that they had an option.

1:03:05I don't think this was like, "Hey, would you mind giving us all of your customers'

1:03:11data and Verizon was like, "Sure."

1:03:13Why not?

1:03:14Well, they say that this was done under the Protect America Act.

1:03:18Right.

1:03:19And that they're-

1:03:20So they probably walked in there waving the act and saying, "You have to give us this

1:03:25or we'll- "

1:03:26Right.

1:03:27And the act of the law, in addition to authorizing them to do it, also indemnifies the carriers.

1:03:36that there is no basis for anybody to sue Verizon for doing it, that the law says they

1:03:42are in the clear.

1:03:45And then the next piece is the Washington Post came out with this thing about this thing

1:03:50called PRISM, P-R-I-S-M, it's an acronym, that all sorts of companies like Google, Apple,

1:04:00Facebook, I don't know who else, you name them, but the big ones are...

1:04:05Microsoft, YouTube, Skype, AOL.

1:04:09Everybody but Twitter, the big ones.

1:04:11And Dropbox.

1:04:12They said Dropbox is coming, I guess.

1:04:15And they also said about Apple that Apple resisted and that whether it's a coincidence

1:04:19or not that they got on it shortly after Steve Jobs died.

1:04:24Oh yeah, you're right. You're right about Dropbox. Yeah, coming.

1:04:27You know, whether that's just a coincidence that Apple got on board after Steve Jobs died

1:04:33whether Jobs personally was resisting, we don't know.

1:04:38But it also is one of those things where it seems like

1:04:42part of the deal isn't just that they're giving the data,

1:04:45it's also that they are not allowed to talk about it.

1:04:47And a lot of companies today have issued statements,

1:04:52but there's a lot of, they're not blanket denials.

1:04:55They are, they're saying--

1:04:57- I was gonna say, this would be,

1:04:59this would be, it would have been a good week

1:05:00to buy stock in weasel words.

1:05:03Yes, there's a lot of statements that the NSA or that the US federal government does

1:05:09not have direct access to our servers.

1:05:15That the NSA doesn't have a box connected to Google data centers or Apple data centers

1:05:20or Facebook data centers.

1:05:23And somebody on Twitter, I think it was, I don't know, I saw some people talking about

1:05:27One very, very easy work around that does not contradict any of these denials from these

1:05:35companies would be, well, do they send a copy of the data to the NSA?

1:05:40Not that the NSA has a box that's connected, but do these companies have something in place

1:05:45where everything gets copied and then sent to the NSA?

1:05:49If that's what's going on, none of the denials would contradict it.

1:05:53And the other statement that came out was they said, I can't remember if it was the

1:05:57NSA or the administration said that they are not targeting US citizens.

1:06:06And my reading of that is, well, if we're collecting everything, we're not targeting

1:06:12US citizens.

1:06:13We're just getting it all.

1:06:19We go to Verizon and we ask them for all their records and they give us all their records.

1:06:23we have not targeted US citizens.

1:06:25And then later what we do is we go in and they target certain individuals who are of

1:06:30interest.

1:06:39And I didn't see Obama's press conference today, but I read some of the quotes from

1:06:44and it was really it was about everything that you would expect of

1:06:51somebody not really seemingly enough concerned about the but the problem here

1:07:01yeah I gotta say I'm pretty disappointed I think yeah yeah I am too Pauline here

1:07:08I am now I've got to agree this is so bad I'm in agreement with Mike Arrington

1:07:13My guarantee is I had a blog post today on this.

1:07:17I guess I'll put it in the show notes, but it's – here's what he says on the Washington

1:07:23Post story.

1:07:24Because what they had, what the Washington Post based this on was an NSA presentation,

1:07:29like a keynote deck or a – what's the one from Microsoft?

1:07:33PowerPoint deck.

1:07:34Probably PowerPoint.

1:07:35That leads to Washington.

1:07:36I'm sure it's PowerPoint.

1:07:40And it stated that the NSA is tapping direct quote.

1:07:43This is what the presentation said, "Tapping directly into the central servers of nine

1:07:47leading U.S. Internet companies to collect information on users."

1:07:50And as Arrington says on the story, one of these must be true.

1:07:55One, the NSA presentation is fake and the Washington Post got duped.

1:07:59Two, Microsoft, Yahoo, Google, Facebook, Apple, et cetera, are lying in terms of their denials.

1:08:08Or three, the presentation is real and the companies are carefully drafting responses

1:08:13so that they aren't technically lying. I believe the third option is the truth.

1:08:17Yes. It seems like that's got to be it.

1:08:18Look at this. We're stuck saying we agree with Mike Arrington. I think it shows…

1:08:23That's really the most hurtful part of this whole thing, isn't it?

1:08:25It really is. But it's…

1:08:27Even more so than the government having your Verizon records.

1:08:31Exactly. Here's the thing here I saw. I'm going to link up on the site, but this is

1:08:37the editorial board at the New York Times. Let me see the passage I wanted to...

1:08:49Here it is. "The administration has now lost all credibility on this issue. Mr.

1:08:54Obama is proving the truism that the executive branch will use any power it

1:08:59it is given and very likely abuse it. And I couldn't agree more. Yeah. The answer is,

1:09:09"Hey, terrorists, scary, scary, scary stuff going on out there. You should trust us. We've

1:09:13got it."

1:09:14Yeah.

1:09:15And, you know, I don't know. That doesn't fly with me.

1:09:18Me either.

1:09:19Very sad.

1:09:20I mean, the terrible thing is all of this stuff was approved by Congress.

1:09:24Right.

1:09:25So, it just doesn't seem like we'll ever get any rectification of this, because the

1:09:34people who would investigate it were the people who have approved it.

1:09:38And even though Republicans love to investigate and try and find fault with the administration,

1:09:45they probably won't.

1:09:46I just don't see them doing anything about this.

1:09:47I guess the best—

1:09:48Because they're knee-deep in it too.

1:09:50Right.

1:09:51would be for them to sort of have an about face on this and figure out a way to unite

1:10:01their dislike and their obstinance of anything Obama does and make this the central part

1:10:07of it because it would actually be good for the country.

1:10:10A perfect example of that is the quote unquote Obamacare, the healthcare legislation that

1:10:17Obama pushed through, which is actually based on proposals that used to come from Republicans.

1:10:24Like back in the 90s when Clinton was president and they tried to rejigger everything, their

1:10:30proposal was far more, well let's just say progressive, liberal, you know, more like

1:10:36what other people have around the world.

1:10:39And the Republican answer wasn't, you know, you can't just say, "Well, no."

1:10:42You know, you have to have a counter proposal.

1:10:44And their counterproposal, which was more based on working with the existing insurance

1:10:48companies and et cetera, was pretty much exactly what Obamacare is.

1:10:51And it's just that by the time Obama got to it, they were like, "Well, no.

1:10:55We don't want it."

1:10:56Well, they should do that with the -- see, now that -- here's a case where I could get

1:11:00behind it.

1:11:01They should get behind -- they should do that.

1:11:02Where, yeah, you were -- sure, you were on board with it a decade ago.

1:11:06Just find some technicality to say, "Well, but it's different just because," and fight

1:11:11bite this tooth and nail and get some of this stuff dismantled.

1:11:13Tim Cynova Or just say enough is enough.

1:11:16Dave Asprey Enough is enough, right.

1:11:18Tim Cynova Even if you said that the real danger has

1:11:22passed or something, we needed it then, but we don't need it anymore.

1:11:27Dave Asprey Right. And a big part of it to me is at least

1:11:29be transparent about what is going on. There was a great article. I wish I could. I've

1:11:36looked for it before, but there was an article I read a long time ago in Wired Magazine from

1:11:41somebody like a futurist type person who's specialized in thinking about privacy.

1:11:47And his stance, he's very, very pro-privacy, but his stance was like on a specific issue

1:11:53of security cameras.

1:11:57Let's say like the one that the government installs, like municipalities, like let's

1:12:01say the ones at stoplights.

1:12:04That if the government is going to have security cameras, then everybody should be able to

1:12:09access them. That if there's a camera at the intersection of Sixth and Spruce, anybody

1:12:15should be able to access it. And so if law enforcement wants to use it to see if a crime

1:12:20was committed there, they can use it and use it as evidence, but anybody can get it. If

1:12:25there's an archive of it, then it all has to be publicly available.

1:12:28Yeah.

1:12:29You know? And if you say, "Well, no, no, no. Everybody

1:12:31shouldn't have it." Well, then you shouldn't have a camera there. Right? And that, you

1:12:36know, and then it goes back to the idea that they're really, you know, we

1:12:39shouldn't be thinking of the government as a separate entity, that the government

1:12:42is us. It's, you know, it's our elected officials. And it makes it, it makes a

1:12:47tremendous amount of sense. You think, well, you know, that seems creepy if

1:12:51everybody could just look and see what's going on at, you know, this street

1:12:54intersection. Well, then don't put cameras there. But if a camera is there, everybody

1:12:57should have access to it. It's not exactly the same as... I'm not saying

1:13:01everybody should have access to everybody's phone records, but if you're...

1:13:05Everybody should have access to everybody else's Google Glass records.

1:13:08That's now that I can get behind.

1:13:10Oh my god.

1:13:14Because if there's nothing wrong with Google Glass then...

1:13:18Or if you know if there is something wrong don't don't put it on your face.

1:13:23I actually saw a surprising number of people on Twitter yesterday because Vesper 1.0 does not

1:13:34It does not sink to any service in the cloud.

1:13:38What you put in Vesper is on your phone.

1:13:40I saw a lot of people draw the connection between that and this Prism stuff and say,

1:13:44"You know what?

1:13:45I like that it doesn't sink," which is not why it doesn't sink.

1:13:49This is not a tinfoil hat thing.

1:13:54But you know what?

1:13:55It's funny because I was thinking about it.

1:13:56They kind of have a point.

1:13:57You can put that in the notes.

1:14:02Use that as an advertising point.

1:14:04It protects your data by…

1:14:05Yeah.

1:14:06Paints us in a corner about future sync options.

1:14:09I know.

1:14:11Because it's everybody, too.

1:14:15Yeah.

1:14:16You can't go right.

1:14:17You can't go iCloud.

1:14:18You can't go Azure.

1:14:20Nope.

1:14:21You can't go…

1:14:22Is Amazon listed?

1:14:23Dropbox.

1:14:24I can't believe that.

1:14:26I didn't see Amazon. It seems like everybody else is on the list. It seems like they would

1:14:38too.

1:14:39I didn't see it. I don't know. It's an interesting and depressing thing. I hope that this is

1:14:49not one of those things that blows over. I kind of hope that this is something that sticks

1:14:52because it's worrisome.

1:14:54Yeah.

1:14:55Again, I don't really blame the companies so much.

1:14:58I don't think that any of these companies, I don't think that Apple or Google or Microsoft

1:15:05just jumped on this and gleefully, I think that they were given offers they could not

1:15:10refuse.

1:15:12But we'll see.

1:15:13I think it would be good to see this stuff investigated and see.

1:15:16Mike: I suppose you could try and challenge the constitutionality of the law, but then

1:15:23you really set yourself up for trouble.

1:15:24Yeah. And the NSA is, you know, the more you read about it, it really is sort of a spooky

1:15:32organization where there's a lot less oversight over them than the FBI or the CIA. They operate,

1:15:40I'm not going to say autonomously, but more autonomously than any other similar organization

1:15:47in our government. They're right behind you right now.

1:15:50Oh, I'm sure they're listening to this. I mean, we know they're hooked into Skype.

1:15:53Yeah, right, right. They're at least collecting it.

1:15:58They may not actually listen to it, but they're collecting.

1:16:03Dave Asprey Right. Like the guys at the NSA, and they probably are. I mean,

1:16:06they're chock full of computer guys. I mean, I wouldn't be surprised if the majority of their

1:16:10employees are computer programmers. I mean, there's probably a lot of people at the NSA who listen to

1:16:15the show. They get to listen to it early. Hello.

1:16:19Hello NSA listeners of the talk show.

1:16:26They're all having a good laugh right now.

1:16:31They think—

1:16:32We hate you.

1:16:34We hate you.

1:16:36We're very angry at you right now.

1:16:38How spooked would you be if our Skype call dropped?

1:16:43Thank you.