0:00:00So did you get your WWDC ticket?
0:00:02Uh, you know me.
0:00:05I don't need a ticket.
0:00:09No, you don't need a ticket.
0:00:10I'm not going for the event.
0:00:13That was pretty amazing.
0:00:15I was meant to go back to see what the jokey predictions were from last year to see if they were actually beaten.
0:00:25Right, because everybody was sort of looking at this exponential growth.
0:00:29When it sold out, yeah, right, when it sold out.
0:00:31You know, where it went from never having sold out to selling out in, I don't know.
0:00:36I actually have this written down.
0:00:38Hold on.
0:00:39I can look it up and then we'll sound smart.
0:00:42It was up through 2008, never sold out.
0:00:46Then 2008 was the first sell out and it was announced March 13th, sold out two months
0:00:52later, the 14th of May.
0:00:542009 was the 26th of March they announced it and it sold out one month the 28th of April. So when two months one month
0:01:02The next year was about a week 28th of April to the 6th of May. That's
0:01:082010 it sold out then then 2011 is when it started getting nuts
0:01:12Announced in the morning on 28th of March and sold out 12 hours later and then last year
0:01:22What was it two hours? Yeah, two hours two hours yesterday. It's sold out in a half a second. I
0:01:28Was predicting a total with utter shit show
0:01:36I've thought that they'd flip a switch at 1 p.m
0:01:39Pacific and say we're starting to take tickets and then I thought everything would just the entire internet would collapse upon itself. Nothing would happen
0:01:46And it wasn't quite like that. I
0:01:50I didn't know. I did secure a ticket. And I wasn't –
0:01:55You did.
0:01:56I had no secret system. I just –
0:01:58Really?
0:01:59What was it? 1 p.m. my time. I reloaded the page. It still said, "Not yet," or whatever
0:02:07the thing said. And I hit reload again and it was a little button showed up that said,
0:02:14in and I hit sign in and it auto filled my ADC credentials and I hit continue and then
0:02:22there was something else and it said continue and then it said now it's time to pay and
0:02:26it auto filled my Safari auto filled my I have different it's a different we call those
0:02:34things the Apple ID that has my payment information and it pre filled in my credit card all I
0:02:40had to do is type the secret four digit code. I hit continue and then it said, "Thank you.
0:02:49You've purchased a WWDC ticket." And I was like, "Wow! That was really easy." And then
0:02:54in the meantime, over in my IM window, I think it was a couple of friends were open and Paul
0:02:59Kefasas was like, "Sold out." And I just thought he was joking. And then something
0:03:04that it was sold out and I you know I just presumed that because it was like
0:03:09four clicks and I credit card confirmation number for me that it was
0:03:13like the same way for everybody but apparently not I where do they go from
0:03:19here I don't know I really don't I think it's you know I don't know what
0:03:24you know I guess this is better I think this is better than then last year you
0:03:30know where if they start selling at the moment they announce it somebody
0:03:34somewhere around the world it's the middle of the night and they're asleep
0:03:37and it's you know it's too late so people keep asking for a lottery system
0:03:43people keep asking what for a lottery system yeah I feel kind of feel like
0:03:48what they did yesterday was a de facto lottery well that's what I was one that's
0:03:52what I was thinking too you know I don't know how else I don't know how else they
0:03:56They could make it more luck-based.
0:03:58I don't know.
0:03:59I don't know.
0:04:00I don't know.
0:04:01I don't know.
0:04:02I don't know.
0:04:03I don't know.
0:04:04I don't know.
0:04:05I don't know.
0:04:06I don't know.
0:04:07I don't know.
0:04:08I don't know.
0:04:09I don't know.
0:04:10I don't know.
0:04:11I don't know.
0:04:12I don't know.
0:04:13I don't know.
0:04:14I don't know.
0:04:15I don't know.
0:04:16I don't know.
0:04:17I don't know.
0:04:18I don't know.
0:04:19I don't know.
0:04:20I don't know.
0:04:21I don't know.
0:04:22I don't know.
0:04:23I don't know.
0:04:24I don't know.
0:04:25I don't know.
0:04:26of Moscone, the north or south or something like that and have more room.
0:04:31But that doesn't get them that much further, I don't think.
0:04:34And they can't really, like one thing lots and lots of people suggest is why don't they
0:04:38split off Mac and iOS.
0:04:42I think two problems with that is, the biggest problem is they can't do two, well they could
0:04:47do two weeks, they could do whatever they want.
0:04:49But every week of WWDC is a week where Apple's engineering effectively shuts down.
0:04:53Like this is actual, the actual people making Apple products,
0:04:57or at least the software, are there at WWDC
0:05:00doing these presentations and stuff.
0:05:02And to do it for two weeks would be, you know,
0:05:07an additional drain on Apple actually working
0:05:11on their products and stuff like that.
0:05:12I think the other problem with that is that iOS
0:05:15so dwarfs Mac OS X, even though Mac OS X
0:05:18has never been as popular as it is,
0:05:19as you know, developer platform,
0:05:22I just don't think it makes a big difference.
0:05:25I think that if--
0:05:26- Some of the resources are the same, right?
0:05:27- I think the other, the way they could split it
0:05:29that might make it a little bit more double capacity
0:05:33would be if they split off games as a separate conference.
0:05:38- Ah, yeah.
0:05:40- Like, I think if there's one group that could,
0:05:44I don't know if it would be half,
0:05:45but one group that would split off the most people
0:05:48who are interested in something else specific
0:05:50that could sort of be its own conference would be like iOS gaming.
0:05:53Right.
0:05:56I mean it seems like some people are trying to
0:06:01fill the gap that Apple can't fill by creating side conferences and even
0:06:06trying to run them during the same week which I think is kind of
0:06:09clever. Yeah it is kind of interesting because one thing too about WWDC
0:06:14I mean even though it sells out instantly and it's as big as Apple can make it in
0:06:17Moscone West
0:06:18it's not that big of a conference by Moscone standards, you know, compared to...
0:06:24because, you know, I don't even know if Apple's made this official, but
0:06:28everybody just passes the number around that it's capped at about 5,000 people.
0:06:33And I know that that's about right. It's somewhere around four or five thousand
0:06:37attendees at WWDC. But like, I know that the Java 1 conference that Sun used to
0:06:43run, and I guess Oracle runs now, I think it's over 20,000 attendees, you know, it's
0:06:47almost more like a convention, you know, like a trade show type thing too. And
0:06:52there's a couple of other trade shows and I know that that there's a GDC
0:06:55conference, the Game Developer Conference, that's huge because it used to be, I
0:07:00think it's in March or something like that or February, and the last couple of
0:07:04years it coincided with when Apple was into having introduction events for new
0:07:11iPads. And so I was out in San Francisco for the event and like it was like hard
0:07:17to get a hotel room and I'm like totally unfamiliar with that you know usually
0:07:20like for like Mac world and for WWDC it's not that hard to get a hotel room
0:07:26there's tons of hotels around Lascone but like GDC is so big that it actually
0:07:30like fills up the hotels you can't even get a room so WWDC is not like that at
0:07:35all so there is room for you know little alternative things yeah and it seems
0:07:42part of the the great thing about WWDC is getting personal contact with the
0:07:47Apple developers right absolutely it's getting it I mean the sessions are part
0:07:51of the point but also part of the point is being able to go up to the guy or
0:07:54woman after the session and say I've got this particular problem and you know I
0:08:00don't know how to solve it and they give you a clue as to maybe what the problem
0:08:03is right and they they will sometimes I mean you know you can't count on it but
0:08:08sometimes you can get them to say something to you that they would not put
0:08:12writing in an email. Right. Right. You know, some, you know what I mean? And you might be able,
0:08:18you know, they're not going to say, but there are, there is a, you know, you forward on the
0:08:22Mac could get them in trouble. But there is also a host of good Apple developers who are not,
0:08:31who do not work at Apple. And it seems like a lot of people could benefit from
0:08:38going to something else that might be less expensive and you can actually get a ticket to.
0:08:42Yeah, and the only thing I wonder is I wonder if these alternative things,
0:08:46I know there's a CocoConf that I think they're trying to get up, a CocoConf alt or something
0:08:52like that and uh yeah I forget what and then there's one called alt what's the other one
0:08:56alt wwdc yeah which I guess they get away with by the fact that they're not charging anything
0:09:04Yeah, I don't know about that. That's, I don't know. It seems a little kind of concerning.
0:09:10They just, some jackbooted Apple thugs come into the middle and shut the whole thing down.
0:09:19Frog march everybody out.
0:09:23So the other big thing this week, and it does seem now like it's, I mean, you call it two
0:09:31times in a row I call it a pattern. It's two times in a row they've announced WWDC the
0:09:36day after Apple's second quarter earnings come out. And I think, I don't know that it's
0:09:42quite the plan like they knew all along. I think that it's that they don't announce WWDC
0:09:47because they're not 100% sure they're going to be ready and they want to wait till they're
0:09:52100% sure that they, you know, they're going to have, you know, new versions of iOS ready
0:09:56to show for developers and stuff. And then by the time they're ready, if it's close enough
0:10:00to the earnings date then they're in that quiet period and I feel like you know they
0:10:05just figure we might as well wait till it's over. That whole quiet period thing though
0:10:09I don't understand. It seems like it's like it's sort of muscally defined. Do you understand
0:10:14that?
0:10:15Yeah I well I mean I understand the principle but I don't understand I don't know if there
0:10:19is anything that's set in stone as to how far in advance they can't talk.
0:10:26And those earnings. My God what a shit show.
0:10:30This is one of those things, and this is one of the reasons I wanted to have you on the
0:10:33show this week, because I feel like it's become the second thing, that people, there's like
0:10:37a contingent of people, and I realize, I truly believe them, that they're annoyed and that
0:10:42they're sick of it or whatever, but the one thing that often comes up is there's a contingent
0:10:47of people who don't like it when people like us link to stupid articles and point out specifically
0:10:55how stupid they are because we're quote-unquote feeding the trolls and we're giving them exactly
0:11:00what they want, which is page views, and we're making Rob Enderle filthy, stinking rich.
0:11:10And I kind of understand the principle there, but I'd, you know, and I try not to link to
0:11:16stupid people who are in obscurity. But like when somebody writes something really stupid
0:11:21at like, let's say, Forbes or something like that, like, I feel like if you can point out
0:11:26how stupid it is there's a there's a point to it right because I mean I know
0:11:30Forbes has always been sort of the nutty of the serious financial publications
0:11:35but it still it's it's relatively well respected in some regards right and you
0:11:42think that they would know better right and the other thing that people are
0:11:46starting to complain about is why does everybody write about Apple's finances
0:11:50who cares about the finances and the stock price blah blah blah just you know
0:11:54we want to read about the products and what they're doing and stuff like that and I understand that too, but
0:11:59I kind of feel like it's such an absurd story
0:12:03that it
0:12:06It demands attention
0:12:09Yeah, it's just it's a bizarre story. Like if their stock price were what I think is even vaguely
0:12:15aligned with
0:12:18How well they're doing well then I wouldn't be writing about it
0:12:22right? And there was a time when I think it was for years where it was at least loosely sane,
0:12:27and I didn't write about it. I feel like what makes it interesting is how insane it's gotten.
0:12:31Yeah. It's people have become detached from reality.
0:12:38And in some- Oh, absolutely. And some of it seems to be- it's so hard to figure for- for me anyway
0:12:47to figure out the workings of Wall Street, but there's so much 12-dimensional chess
0:12:52going on that – but some of it seems like it's deliberate.
0:12:55Right.
0:12:56You know, there's a deliberate campaign and what – you know, I'm not tinfoil-hatted
0:13:03enough to think that it's an organized campaign, but there are very good reasons for – you
0:13:10know, financial reasons for some of these people to try and drive the stock down.
0:13:14Right.
0:13:15And so they do just that.
0:13:16It's not just like speculators or people shorting the stock or stuff like that
0:13:20somebody any reader sent me a quote today from a guy at
0:13:24At one of the European carriers, I don't know Sweden or something like that
0:13:31He was speaking at a conference and the guy was like the CEO of one of the major carriers there and he just flat-out set
0:13:37On stage it would be great for us. I really hope Apple falls on its face and collapses in the phone market
0:13:45You know and I think the thinking there is that Apple is in such a strong position that of course the carriers have this contentious
0:13:51relationship with them because they want to dominate the relationship with the customers and Apple has sort of usurped that where
0:13:57With the iPhone Apple controls it right and you know famously just stuff like the fact that Apple controls the software updates
0:14:04I mean no other phone still has that every other phone around the world you still get your software updates through the carrier
0:14:10Yeah, and so that's you know if what if not for Apple Apple's like the Scooby-doo gang
0:14:13You know who you know if not for the kids. I would have gotten away with my plot
0:14:17But then you see then like this guy at least had the balls to be honest and say it
0:14:23You know just come out and say it on stage, but you know that a lot of those guys are the unnamed sources
0:14:29You know that these business record
0:14:31reporters
0:14:33quote you know when they say source is close to the familiar with the blah blah blah say you know
0:14:38Component orders are down for Apple or whatever. It's people who have
0:14:43you know, a stake in the game. Right. And now that this, I mean this was actually even before
0:14:50they announced their quarterly results, but there was a Forbes piece from Sky about how, you know,
0:14:57Tim Cook's days were numbered. That's one of the ones I was thinking about, right. And it was widely
0:15:04cited. And then the thing that happens, and it's so dastardly, is like this, it's the old game of
0:15:10telephone where it's like after this guy does and he's not even like a columnist
0:15:14at Forbes he's like a contributor which is like what Forbes means by that is
0:15:19shit that anybody can throw up against the wall and see what sticks and they
0:15:24get rewarded for writing the stuff that gets a lot of page views you know and
0:15:30then that guy Doug Cass who he just tweets and apparently he just
0:15:36purposefully and apparently completely legally just tweets things that aren't true and then
0:15:42bets the way that that is going to go and famously it was wasn't the day of their quarterly
0:15:50results oh it was right before their stock stockholders meeting right before apples annual
0:15:55stockholder meeting a couple months ago a couple weeks ago like the day before Doug
0:16:00Doug Cass says, "My gnomes up in the mountains say Apple's about to announce a stock split."
0:16:07And I don't know if that was good news or bad news in investor speak, but whichever
0:16:11way it was, he bet the other way.
0:16:13He like – because he knew it wasn't true.
0:16:15And then like two hours later, he's like, "Well, what does my guy know?
0:16:18I don't know."
0:16:19And then the next day, he comes and goes and there's no stock split and nobody cares.
0:16:23And then now, two months later, two days or one day right before Apple releases its financial
0:16:30results he tweets my gnome says Tim Cook's Tim Cook is cooked right and then
0:16:37all of a sudden with this guy who made up a thing about a stock split two
0:16:40months ago and we know we made it up or if he didn't make it up whoever told him
0:16:47made it up you know same guy who made that up two months ago says that Tim
0:16:51Cook is cooked and one guy in Forbes says that executives at the company say
0:16:56The board is looking for a replacement to Tim Cook
0:16:59The thing that happens in is now you can find like 20 30 40 things around the web of people saying
0:17:05People are saying right and cook is in trouble
0:17:07Word is Tim Cook is in trouble
0:17:11and
0:17:13It is
0:17:14Couldn't looking at looking at his complete nonsense his wording
0:17:18So some Wall Street sources close to some Apple executives
0:17:23Say such a move is afoot
0:17:26So this guy on Wall Street says he knows somewhat at Apple who says that it's
0:17:36happening. And it just beggars belief like who in the world seriously who in
0:17:43the world there's what is there seven billion people on the planet that we up
0:17:46to seven billion out of all seven billion people who are walking the face
0:17:50of the earth who could replace who could Apple's board sanely replace Tim Cook
0:17:55with right now. Right. Now, in all honesty, anybody in the world? I mean, now you I could
0:18:02come up with maybe two or three answers. I would say Johnny Ive, maybe Phil Schiller.
0:18:10I think if they announced that they said we fired Tim Cook and replace him with Phil Schiller,
0:18:14I think everybody would think, well, that's, that's, what's the point of that? Right? Johnny
0:18:17Ive might be the one who's some people would say, well, that's good. Here's why, though,
0:18:22nonsense though what does anybody actually think that Johnny I've has less
0:18:27control right now today then he would if his title were changed to CEO he has
0:18:34exactly the right amount of control for the things that he's an expert in right
0:18:38and I don't even know what his title is but he's effectively he's like chief
0:18:42designer chief product designer chief design officer yeah I think it's I think
0:18:45it's now chief design officer to to describe it but especially given what
0:18:50happened with Scott Forstall last year where Johnny Ive was put in charge of
0:18:54software design - he's effectively in charge of all product design hardware
0:18:59and software right which is exactly like what Steve Jobs was really in charge of
0:19:06you know the ultimate arbiter of taste in product design for the company like
0:19:11so it wouldn't it wouldn't make any change right does anybody actually think
0:19:15that like Johnny Ive has this like game-changing world shaking it's it's
0:19:22like the next thing that's as amazing as the first iPhone and Tim Cook is like no
0:19:26I don't think so Johnny I think we better just keep selling that we have
0:19:30keep that one in labs we don't need anything like that and and the other
0:19:35thing is that we put I've in charge of stuff that he's not competent to be in
0:19:40charge of. Right, he would need Tim Cook. Right, right. He'd need a great operations person. Spend his entire day, come in in the morning and
0:19:49leave at night doing nothing but look and work and refine and iterate product design.
0:19:54Yeah, yeah. Exactly. So like there would be a credibility of saying Johnny Ive is
0:19:58the CEO of Apple where, you know, the people who are at Apple's clearly respect
0:20:02him and if not, you know, love him and he's there, he knows and understands
0:20:09Apple but exactly it would just be burdening him with responsibilities that
0:20:12would distract him from what he does best and he doesn't seem like the kind
0:20:15of guy who really wants that spotlight anyway no he hates that he never gets up
0:20:19on stage he needs to do that stuff right so I know and people often you know
0:20:23write to me and say do you think Johnny I will do the keynote at WWDC and stuff
0:20:27like that and if he could in theory I mean he'd certainly have the
0:20:29credibility but my understanding and it certainly seems to be from years and
0:20:33years of watching is that he just doesn't enjoy the you know he doesn't
0:20:37public speaking. He likes, you know, and he certainly acquits himself very, very well in
0:20:42those design videos they always show. But I don't think, you know, he likes being in front of a
0:20:47crowd. Right. You know who I'd like to see though? Who? Big Bob Mansfield. Oh, man. Big Bob Mansfield
0:20:53would kill it on stage. Can you imagine? I mean, I was thinking of it. I was thinking of CEO.
0:21:00Stage time at that event. That's right. Yeah, yeah. But I was thinking of CEO.
0:21:05Oh, CEO. Yeah, yeah, I could see big Bob Mansfield as CEO.
0:21:10Talk about gravitas.
0:21:11Right. He really looks like...
0:21:13He's just...
0:21:13And he's like the type of guy too where... Because some of it is like negotiations,
0:21:20where you're negotiating with record labels or movie companies or something like that, or
0:21:25parts suppliers. Wouldn't you like to see... I'd like to see Bob Mansfield
0:21:30in the negotiating room. And he probably actually is there, actually, if you think about what he
0:21:35does. He probably is there. The ones with Samsung, where they're negotiating over the
0:21:40CPUs and the stuff that Samsung makes for them. I think those have got to be the best
0:21:46meetings that Apple has.
0:21:47I think he walks in...
0:21:48The ones where they're dealing with Samsung over the components they order with them.
0:21:51He walks in and he has a bowling ball in his hand and he just crushes it.
0:21:58Like he probably weighs... And he's not a corpulent man. He's just a large man.
0:22:02No, he's just sturdy.
0:22:03Sturdy, you know, but he's he's he's a very imposing
0:22:06Yeah, and I you know, yeah just figured that these guys from Korea are not physically imposing
0:22:11I got he probably weighs as much as three of them
0:22:13The other person I what about forest all I
0:22:19Think I think that would play very poorly
0:22:23I think it would play poorly too, but I would imagine that that's somebody that people think of
0:22:28All right
0:22:30I think if he hadn't been ousted if that hadn't happened
0:22:34you know it
0:22:37He in theory could have been CEO
0:22:40It seems like you get a lot of it be the next one or something like that
0:22:43And I probably you know, I don't know that much about like intrigue at that level
0:22:47But I wouldn't be surprised if that's what forestall thought in the back of his mind
0:22:50Not that he was going to boot Tim Cook out
0:22:53But that if if and when cook stepped aside say 10 years from now or 15 years from now that he might be next in
0:22:59line. But the main point though is that there is nobody outside Apple who would have any
0:23:05credibility whatsoever as CEO of Apple. Nobody, not one person in the world could possibly
0:23:11come in at this point and be CEO of Apple. Nobody and nobody within the company would
0:23:17have any faith in that move. That would be like if you think that there's any kind of
0:23:22brain drain now of engineers leaving. I mean they would all, I mean it would just be like
0:23:27a "rats leaving the sinking ship" type thing if the board went nuts, fired Tim Cook, and
0:23:32hired anybody outside the company.
0:23:35But it just doesn't even seem like this question in reality is being broached whatsoever.
0:23:41Right.
0:23:42That this whole thing is just complete and utter fabrication.
0:23:47Right.
0:23:48It makes no sense.
0:23:49Either maliciously…
0:23:50It really doesn't.
0:23:51It is like the logical equivalent of somebody saying that we can solve climate change by
0:23:57just everybody just turn your vacuum on and just vacuum up the CO2 in the atmosphere and
0:24:03then keep it, you know, make sure the bag is sealed tight.
0:24:07Problem solved.
0:24:08Like it makes that much sense.
0:24:11There's no logic to it whatsoever.
0:24:13Because I guess what they're saying, I guess if you want to pretend and just play along
0:24:17with them that the board is actually thinking about kicking, giving the boot to Tim Cook
0:24:21and hiring somebody outside the company to take over, is that the board of Apple is not
0:24:27just going to fire Tim Cook, but that they are going to completely change what Apple
0:24:32does and the way Apple does things and do things completely differently and I guess
0:24:39more like what other companies do. You know, why can't Apple be more like a regular normal
0:24:44computer company
0:24:46Which makes no sense when you look at the actual numbers they reported which is like insane amounts of revenue and profit
0:24:54Like why in the world would you want to change that it makes no sense whatsoever. Yeah
0:25:01and the
0:25:04degree to which
0:25:06The overblown analysis is going there. So let me give you another quote. This is
0:25:11somebody writing for Yahoo Finance
0:25:14Regardless of what Apple stock does in the near term, yesterday's performance left little doubt that Cook is not only a pale imitation of Steve Jobs
0:25:21but a low-rent version of John Sculley.
0:25:25Doesn't make any sense. It doesn't make any sense. It sounds bad. If it were true, if it were true, that would be devastating.
0:25:36It's just a, it's just a cheap shot. Right. That has no basis in fact. I mean,
0:25:42School Apple was losing money when Scully was was in charge
0:25:46No, they were I looked at them profit
0:25:50I looked at I they had they had one they had at least one story was that he really left them in bad shape for
0:25:56the future yes, because
0:25:58Under Scully they did ship the Newton and the Newton, you know was a real thing
0:26:03And very well regarded and you know
0:26:06It's we could do a whole show about how much how far ahead of its time
0:26:09it was in in terms of post PC computing and stuff like that a great great thing loved my Newton in a lot of ways but
0:26:16was not a financial hit so it didn't help Apple financially and
0:26:20They wasted all this time on the Mac on these things the pink intelligent and all these things that never amounted to anything
0:26:28But I do think that he left them profitable. They did they had it they had a whole under
0:26:33What's the guy not Gil? Who's the guy spinner German guy who used to hide under his desk and cry?
0:26:39Michael Spindler.
0:26:40Michael Spindler.
0:26:41Michael Spindler.
0:26:42Yeah.
0:26:43Where the hell is he?
0:26:44He's the one Apple CEO who is still alive, but nobody ever trots him out.
0:26:50You know, like Scully gets trotted out every couple of months and gives his two cents on
0:26:55what Apple's up to.
0:26:58Nobody ever talks to Michael Spindler.
0:26:59I think he's a venture capitalist now.
0:27:02I should get Spindler.
0:27:03Wouldn't that be a great get from the talk show?
0:27:06Okay.
0:27:07I looked this up previously and
0:27:10the so
0:27:12Scully got ousted in October of 93 and
0:27:17In the second calendar quarter Apple reported its worst quarterly loss ever
0:27:24188 million
0:27:26Which now so you know 180 million? They were losing money regularly, right?
0:27:31right
0:27:34Here's a here's an article. I found this is the same thing. This is now. This is in the Harvard Business Review now
0:27:39I believe the Harvard is still a respected
0:27:42College and University
0:27:46There's still a they're still in the Ivy League right yes, all right Harvard Business Review, and it's by Vijay
0:27:52I'm gonna do a very poor job on their their their names Vijay
0:27:56Govinda Jharan and
0:27:59Sree Sree Kanth
0:28:03Srinivas leave there might both be of Indian descent but my apologies to them
0:28:08you're the worst person in the world to be trying to pronounce their names it's
0:28:11an article called finding your place in the competitive jungle and they're
0:28:17saying that there's there's four types of innovators you can and it goes by
0:28:22whether your size is high or low and your speed is low or high and so if
0:28:27If you're a low size, small size, low speed, you're a tortoise.
0:28:34If you're small and high speed, you're a rabbit.
0:28:40If you're large and slow, you're an elephant.
0:28:45If you're large and fast, you're a jaguar.
0:28:49The iPhone was a jaguar.
0:28:53I mean, Jesus.
0:28:59Apple's iPhone was a jaguar, big and years ahead of the competition.
0:29:02It got there through a series of breakthrough innovations, the touch screen and integrated
0:29:06smartphone pricing where the end consumer pays 199.
0:29:12So the iPhone invented that?
0:29:14The iPhone invented getting an expensive phone for 199?
0:29:16I was not aware of that.
0:29:18And the App Store.
0:29:19Now, the App Store, they did enter.
0:29:21That actually is true.
0:29:22fast but the competition was moving faster it slipped from Jaguar to
0:29:26elephant rather swiftly and Samsung took over that spot with its galaxy right
0:29:32here's the thing we know this we know this is a fact though right that the
0:29:36Apple the iPhone still gets 70% of the profit in the total handset industry
0:29:40right right but that's it's in second place to Samsung yeah but Samsung
0:29:45overall the iPhone still outsells the galaxy right that's the other thing even
0:29:51Even if you want to just talk market share.
0:29:52It's like somehow because Samsung has more total market share because they sell an awful
0:29:57lot of low end phones, everybody just counts them all as galaxies.
0:30:04And now people seem to count them all as galaxy notes because everybody seems to think, "Oh,
0:30:10customers want larger screens."
0:30:11Well, actually customers buy more iPhones than they buy Samsung's large screen phones.
0:30:17Some of that will change because, you know, I mean, Samsung will probably sell more because
0:30:21now the Galaxy S series is huge too.
0:30:26But previously, it was just the Galaxy Note and a couple other ones that – and they
0:30:30did not come close to adding up to what the iPhone sells.
0:30:37But yet, it gets reported over and over again as if fablets are beating the pants off the
0:30:44iPhone.
0:30:45Here's their conclusion over how here's their explanation for how the galaxy became the jaguar and the iPhone and elephant
0:30:51Even though that you know the funny thing is that the galaxy doesn't doesn't Samsung have a Samsung Galaxy elephant. That's like seven inches I
0:30:59Don't know
0:31:02Over a four year period the galaxy caught up with all that Apple had to offer and added several
0:31:07Innovations the key ones being a bigger screen there you go better GPS functionality now that is that true
0:31:14I don't even know what that would be. I've never range of phones to cover all segments from low end to high end
0:31:19better rendering of websites with flash players
0:31:23And better working relationships with partners operating system partners like Google and Android
0:31:30carriers like Verizon and retailers like Best Buy
0:31:34It didn't help that in addition to complacence Apple was also arrogant and failed to listen to customer needs
0:31:43Wall Street recognized this shift early and has published punished Apple stock in spite of great quarterly financial performance
0:31:50So what was the in the conference call and I know it's the iPad not the iPhone
0:31:55But I think Tim Cook cited that with the iPad and you know for talking iOS versus Android not just phones or whatever
0:32:01That 96% of people who buy an iPhone are satisfied with their purchase
0:32:05Yeah, but they're not listening to customer customer. Yeah, and
0:32:10And I think you linked to that thing today about customer satisfaction.
0:32:14Yeah, a 16,000 person survey conducted by Carl Howe, who's actually a pretty good analyst
0:32:20at the Yankee Group. Right. And the numbers aren't bad for Android. It was something like
0:32:2874% of current Android users plan to buy another Android phone with their next phone. But 91%
0:32:34of iPhone users plan to buy another iPhone with their next phone. But Apple's the one
0:32:40who's not listening to its customers.
0:32:42I think, you know what,
0:32:47and one of the things that drives me nuts
0:32:49is about this whole stock price thing,
0:32:51is that there really does seem to be
0:32:54a significant contingent of people
0:32:58who really do think that whatever Wall Street does
0:33:02with the stock is right and sane,
0:33:04and therefore, any explanation you can come up
0:33:07to justify that is reasonable.
0:33:09So that's what these guys at the Harvard Business Group do.
0:33:12It's proof positive that Apple's not listening to customers,
0:33:16not because of sales numbers, not because of surveys
0:33:20that show customer satisfaction, but because the stock went
0:33:22down.
0:33:23That's the proof.
0:33:24Let me do the first sponsor.
0:33:30And then we'll come back to it.
0:33:33And my first sponsor, I want to thank,
0:33:36Windows Azure Mobile Services.
0:33:39That's right, Microsoft.
0:33:40And they've got-- everybody-- and I
0:33:45know they sponsored Daring Fireball the other week,
0:33:47and everybody was a little surprised.
0:33:48It actually shouldn't be surprising
0:33:50that they're sponsoring this, because they
0:33:52know that a lot of developers listen to my show,
0:33:54read the website.
0:33:56And Windows Azure Mobile Services
0:33:58is truly a great, great platform for iOS developers
0:34:02who want to provide cloud services for their apps.
0:34:06Their mobile services, they take care of the glue code
0:34:08necessary for storing data in the cloud.
0:34:11And this is huge.
0:34:13This is absolutely huge.
0:34:14They take care of authenticating users.
0:34:16And they do it either by Facebook or Twitter
0:34:20and sending push notifications.
0:34:23So in other words, what you can do
0:34:25is you sign up with Azure services.
0:34:26And instead of setting up your own user system, which
0:34:30is a huge pain in the ass, let's face it.
0:34:34Usernames, passwords, sending out email,
0:34:36people lose their passwords, stuff like that.
0:34:37Forget it all.
0:34:38let people sign in using either twitter or face book and microsoft there
0:34:43the mobile services takes care of it all and you've got them that's it they've
0:34:47already got an account and who doesn't have either a face book or twitter
0:34:50account nobody everybody has that
0:34:53it's all set then you've got a user system in place push notifications you
0:34:57don't have to set up your own server for push notifications microsoft already has
0:35:00it for you
0:35:01it's easy
0:35:03for anybody who's tried sending push notifications before you know
0:35:06that configuring that can get really complex fairly quickly.
0:35:09With mobile services, adding push to your iOS app
0:35:13is as simple as typing push.apns.send.
0:35:17That's source code.
0:35:18You just read-- there it is.
0:35:19It's-- what is that?
0:35:2018 characters.
0:35:20Push.apns.send and specify the device token
0:35:26for where the push notification is going, the payload.
0:35:29In other words, what's the message?
0:35:30What are you sending to them?
0:35:31And that's it.
0:35:32Boom, it goes off.
0:35:33And then your user's phone pings,
0:35:34there's the push notification if you're looking to build an iOS app or connect
0:35:39an app that you already have to the cloud take a look at their stuff you can
0:35:43get started today for free absolutely free here's where you go www.windows
0:35:50azure.com / iOS and you need the www do the www don't skip it www.windowsazure.com/ios
0:35:59azure.com/ios. It's, I'd really check it out. I mean you know, and the videos they
0:36:08have that show you how to use this stuff, it's all done by Brent Simmons. If Brent
0:36:12Simmons is using this stuff, you know it's good. I mean I can't think of a
0:36:15higher compliment to pay. And they're good videos too. Really, really good stuff.
0:36:20So check it out if you're an iOS developer. That was the first, that was
0:36:23the first time I saw it because he linked to those videos and I thought, "Oh, well,
0:36:27take a look I was surprised too until I heard it you know and then I saw it and
0:36:31it was like you know what they're really they're killing it they really are yeah
0:36:35it's a smart move on their part what it is it's the same reason that developers
0:36:40love cocoa and the reason they love writing iOS apps is that so much of the
0:36:45the busy work of getting a new app off the ground the scaffolding the framework
0:36:50let's just say framework is there and that you can just if you want to make an
0:36:55app that well I don't know what the hell it is but you know you don't have to
0:37:00worry about all this stuff of getting an app that draws and does a list and has
0:37:04smooth scrolling cocoa gives you all that well windows is or is like that but
0:37:08for the cloud services where you don't have to be a you don't have to set up
0:37:11your own server and do all this programming it's all there they already
0:37:13have a push notification thing really good check it out so app back to apples
0:37:21financial results. So the thing that they're getting dinged on is that the
0:37:28that's the standout numbers is that earnings were down profit was down year
0:37:33over year and that's the first time since I think 2003 that earnings dropped
0:37:38in any quarter compared to the same quarter a year ago. So that I mean that's
0:37:42obviously that's worth noting that's there's no burying the fact that that's
0:37:46you know it's not a good thing but revenue was up and I think you know I I
0:37:53know Horace did you of course has a much smarter and deeper analysis about this
0:37:57but I think long story short the story is simply that in the year ago quarter
0:38:04they had 47 percent profit margins and now this quarter at 37 percent profit
0:38:09margins which is a huge drop but it's not that they dropped and now they have
0:38:13bad profit margins they still have profit margins that are the envy of the
0:38:16entire industry. They're almost as high as Microsoft's, and Microsoft is a software
0:38:22company, not a hardware company. The hardware companies aren't supposed to have profit
0:38:25margins that high. It's really that last year, a year ago, it was just like a fluke,
0:38:33crazy high profit margin.
0:38:35Tim Cynova Yeah. They had an amazing quarter a year ago.
0:38:40I was looking at some of the …
0:38:41some of the yeah it's sort of like a basketball player who like has a game
0:38:49you know it's like like Michael Jordan has a game where he makes 27 out of 28
0:38:55shots makes every free throw and a bunch of three pointers and scores 64 points
0:39:00and then the next game you know scores 32 points and then you know it's a huge
0:39:05drop but scoring 32 points is still you know it's great you just you can't have
0:39:09have that perfect quarter every time.
0:39:12They also introduced more lower margin products.
0:39:17Right.
0:39:17And they expressly admitted that the iPad mini
0:39:21is a low margin product by Apple's standards for profit margins.
0:39:26I mean, they're still selling.
0:39:28And I'm checking the numbers here, but I'm pretty sure that everything
0:39:31other than Macs went up.
0:39:35Right.
0:39:36more iPads, more iPhones.
0:39:39Macs were basically flat, down just a tiny bit.
0:39:43And--
0:39:44iPods are down.
0:39:45But that business is kind of going away.
0:39:46Well, so iPods are kind of disappearing.
0:39:48Sure.
0:39:50But I think it's because--
0:39:52you know what I also think is really--
0:39:54I think a big part of that is because of iPhone.
0:39:57For years now, the decline in iPods
0:39:59has been because people are buying iPhones,
0:40:01and they're just using their iPhone everywhere
0:40:03they would use an iPod.
0:40:05And I think the other nail in the coffin for the iPod line
0:40:08is the iPad mini, right?
0:40:10'Cause I think that the thing you buy
0:40:12for playing games and stuff like that,
0:40:14I think there's an awful lot of people
0:40:15who maybe were buying iPod touches for that
0:40:18and now they're just buying a mini instead.
0:40:20- Right.
0:40:21- So I don't really think the iPod,
0:40:25anybody's really worried, you know, I don't know.
0:40:28I'm not gonna say it's irrelevant,
0:40:29but it's just, it's almost irrelevant.
0:40:31- It's no longer, I mean,
0:40:33It's not a very big slice of their revenue anyway anymore.
0:40:36The iPad numbers were huge.
0:40:38It went from like 11 point something million a quarter ago to 19.5 million, almost 20 million,
0:40:45which is huge growth.
0:40:47And I know, yes, that a big part of that is a lower margin profit or lower profit margin
0:40:52iPad mini.
0:40:54But I still think that what Apple-- and they don't reveal.
0:40:58They don't say what the profit margins are on any individual product.
0:41:01they did was acknowledge that it's lower than their usual standards. I'll bet it's still
0:41:05better than almost anybody else in the industry gets for their tablets.
0:41:08Tim Cynova Oh, yeah. It's gotta be. I mean, most of
0:41:11those guys aren't even making anything off their tablets, right? The seven-inch ones
0:41:16are basically being sold almost at cost for, in the hopes that people will buy movies and
0:41:22stuff.
0:41:23Dave Asprey So one thing that to me is interesting about
0:41:26that is if the iPad mini is low margin, and they said it is, and it still costs more than
0:41:32what a lot of us were kind of expecting it to cost. I mean, so it's $329 is the starting
0:41:37price. And I know a lot of us, before it came out, were kind of thinking they would hit
0:41:41maybe like $249 or something like that. So, A, how unrealistic were our predictions that
0:41:49it would only be $249 or even $199, right? People were thinking, "Well, hell, if Amazon
0:41:54has 199 tablet then Apple will have 199 tablet but if it's already low margin at
0:42:00329 that was clearly we were vastly underestimating how much these things
0:42:04cost mm-hmm and then be how how crappy are the tablets that other people make
0:42:10that do cost 199 because you said I didn't know this that you you bought a
0:42:19Did you buy a Kindle Fire or a Nexus 7?
0:42:22No, it's a Nexus 7.
0:42:23I bought a Nexus 7.
0:42:24I actually bought it for my wife because she wanted something.
0:42:28She thought the iPad was too… the 10-inch iPad was too large for her to read in bed.
0:42:33And she wanted something with a backlit screen to read in bed.
0:42:36And I wanted to try it.
0:42:39So I bought her the Nexus 7.
0:42:41And it was fine for her.
0:42:44She basically used it for a few months for a reading device and playing basic games.
0:42:53It worked fine.
0:42:54Then the iPad Mini came out and we were like, "Okay, well enough of that.
0:43:00Let's get an iPad Mini."
0:43:03I got her an iPad Mini and then I took the Nexus 7 and I was going to use it on my desk
0:43:08as just a thing to play music and maybe watch Netflix on or something.
0:43:14I went to start it up and it was completely dead and I tried to recharge it.
0:43:21I had to plug it in and it took more than 24 hours of charging for the thing to come
0:43:27back to the point where it would do anything.
0:43:32Now I've reconditioned it a little bit and so the battery is better now than it was,
0:43:37but it still doesn't hold the charge that my iPad holds.
0:43:41And it's only what like like oh yes, not even it's not even an aerial. Yeah, it's ten months old
0:43:46And then I found when I did put it on my desk
0:43:50The sound that was coming through when I put headphones on
0:43:54Was just it was scratchy because of interference from either my iPhone or we have a we got a micro cell
0:44:01Because we're still on AT&T. Yeah, it's that what is it that weird like yeah. Yeah, yeah, it's like that
0:44:07Yeah, so it basically
0:44:10Failed I mean it didn't it couldn't do what I wanted it to do
0:44:13It's a ten I wonder how hard that stuff is like like that
0:44:17I never think about that
0:44:18But it used to be more of a problem with my consumer electronics though that weird those interference sounds and I yeah
0:44:23You pointing that out made me realize that I can't remember the last time I've had that problem
0:44:27I I can't either I seem to remember getting that a lot particularly doing stuff like this
0:44:31Like if I had my iPhone on the on the desk
0:44:34It would it would interfere with
0:44:37Yeah, recording. I'll bet that's another one of those things that Apple spends a lot of time in those those weird anabolic chambers
0:44:44Yeah, in addition to testings like cell phone and Wi-Fi its antenna strength. They must go in there and and work on
0:44:51Cutting down on that sort of interference. Yeah, but I don't have it anymore. I mean, I've got my iPhone on the
0:44:57Table, I don't have it. So it's on and I don't watch a lot of stuff here at the desk with yeah
0:45:02Mini as a TV. Yeah, I watch baseball games. Let's admit it. Yeah
0:45:06So anyway, yeah. In my experience, anecdotally, there's a difference between a $200 device
0:45:20and a $330 device.
0:45:22Right. And you can say what you want about Apple's margins. I know our good friend,
0:45:31Paul Thoreau or Throt, whatever his name is, often makes the case that Apple's margins
0:45:38are immoral, that it's somehow immoral to charge what people are willing to pay.
0:45:43You know, I've seen other people too that you should charge like a good honest 10% profit
0:45:48margin and I don't know.
0:45:53I'm not quite sure where the moral logic there goes.
0:45:57But if they admit that it's a low margin product, selling at $329 and let's, you know, I think
0:46:05the average price of an iPad mini is probably more like $400 because people get the cellular
0:46:09version or the 32 gigabyte version or something like that.
0:46:16How it just goes to, and you know that Apple is very efficient and they're making these
0:46:22things in great quantity, right?
0:46:24Apple has the best deals on flash memory, the best deals on screen components because
0:46:28they make the most, you know, they sell the most of them. So yeah, there must be a huge
0:46:33drop off in quality to sell something for $199 even if you're like Amazon and willing
0:46:38to do it at no profit. Because if the iPad mini actually cost $199 to make, then they
0:46:46wouldn't, it would, it wouldn't, they wouldn't be saying it as lower margins than Apple averages.
0:46:52That would be like right in line. That would be like 33, 35 percent.
0:46:56So, it must cost more than $199 to make a mini.
0:47:02Well, you'd think.
0:47:04Right. But then those guys at – what's that company called? They told me that the
0:47:10iPad mini only costs like $17 to make. What are those guys called?
0:47:15That's like every time you hear like, "The human body is only made up of 90 percent water."
0:47:20Right.
0:47:21Well, let's get some water and make it human.
0:47:24Look at all those guys. I can't remember them. They always do that, and they always get headlines.
0:47:27Every time, like two days after an iPhone hits stores, they take it apart, and they say, "The components cost $6."
0:47:33The base metals in this iPod are practically free.
0:47:39And that's another one of those things where nobody ever takes apart anybody else's device and does that.
0:47:44Nobody ever says that these guys--maybe they do it, but nobody ever makes an article out of it.
0:47:48Nobody ever makes a big deal about it, right?
0:47:50ever writes an article that says the Samsung Galaxy S6 costs $7 in components.
0:47:58So what here's my other thought I took away when I was listening to the call
0:48:04this is another one of the notes I made when I was listening to the conference
0:48:07call this week with the Tim Cook and his pals is that if it's a low-margin thing
0:48:13and they're still talking about it being a low-margin thing I am NOT holding out
0:48:17hope for a retina iPad mini this year.
0:48:21That makes me think it's a next year type thing.
0:48:23Oh, man.
0:48:25Especially-- two points to make on that.
0:48:27One is if it's already a low margin product,
0:48:32it's-- I can actually think of three arguments.
0:48:34I keep thinking of arguments.
0:48:35So first is the margins.
0:48:36If it's already low margin, putting
0:48:38a really expensive retina display in there
0:48:40is just going to make it worse.
0:48:41And I don't think they're going to do it.
0:48:43Number two, it's clearly having--
0:48:45it's clearly super popular.
0:48:47They said it was popular.
0:48:48They couldn't keep it in stock the last quarter.
0:48:50And it's affected-- it's clear that it's
0:48:52affected their average selling price on iPads,
0:48:54because nothing else-- there is no other iPad that could
0:48:57be pulling the price down.
0:49:00So it's popular as is.
0:49:03And then three, when they added the retina display
0:49:06to the regular iPad, they made it thicker and heavier.
0:49:10And I think they really regretted that.
0:49:11And I don't think they would do that with the Mini.
0:49:14Yeah.
0:49:15I think the minis even just the name sort of makes that impossible
0:49:19and they kind you know they had to do that to put a bigger battery in there to
0:49:22power the all the extra graphic power to do four times the pixels
0:49:28also they don't sell they don't sell the we know they do so the iPad 2 still
0:49:33yeah they do I want to know more it'll be interesting the next time they do a
0:49:37product refresh what happens to that if they can't that slot there
0:49:41because I think the whole reason they kept it around was
0:49:44that they weren't sure why the old iPad was selling.
0:49:49Was it that people wanted a cheaper iPad
0:49:52and didn't, a cheaper iPad but wanted the tenant size
0:50:00or was it that they just wanted a cheaper iPad
0:50:03and now they're buying a mini instead?
0:50:05Like I think they kept it around
0:50:07'cause they just didn't know.
0:50:09I think it'll be a tell if they do the same thing,
0:50:13like introduce a new generation of iPad and then keep the current generation, you know,
0:50:19one 16 gigabyte model around at a low price point for people who do want the big size
0:50:24but are willing to buy last year's tech to save $100.
0:50:27>> Got it. It's the year before.
0:50:29>> Yeah, I guess so.
0:50:31>> It's two years old now.
0:50:32>> Well, I'm assuming that if they did that, they would--that if they did it again this
0:50:38year, they would take that one out and put the iPad 4 or whatever we call the current
0:50:43ones in.
0:50:44But maybe I'm wrong.
0:50:45Yeah, I don't know.
0:50:47The theory that I've heard, and I don't remember where I've heard this, is that it's the business
0:50:53iPad, that a lot of companies buy it because it's cheaper, but they want a larger screen,
0:51:01but they don't care if it's a retina display.
0:51:03Like the fleet ones, right?
0:51:05they're setting up a thing in a warehouse where the guy walking around
0:51:08the house is carrying an iPad instead of a clipboard now you know and it might
0:51:14get banged up and stuff like that who do you know and they don't care it's not
0:51:16like a personal device that you get from the company to like use as your device
0:51:21it's like a part of the work environment you're saying something like that yeah
0:51:24yeah I mean or just yeah everywhere I point point of sale terminals right yeah
0:51:30oh that's true yeah I didn't even think about that actually I mean most of my my
0:51:34vision of this is colored by what my experience was where we were working, where we kept talking
0:51:39about rolling these out to deliver reporting because for years we were still putting everything
0:51:47in PDFs and then a lot of the, you know, we're delivering reports to executives and they
0:51:52would end up printing them.
0:51:53It's just like, no, no, we're giving them to you electronically.
0:51:58You can either have this PDF, we'll deliver into your inbox or it's on this website
0:52:03you could go to too. No, they would get the PDF and then they'd print them out. They're
0:52:08like, "Okay, well, that's a waste. Why don't we give them iPads because you could get it
0:52:13for them?" That pays for itself as opposed to the printing.
0:52:17I guess so, but I do – the one that they're giving out though, it's not – or they're
0:52:21not giving out, but the low cost, full-size iPad is not retina, right? It's an iPad
0:52:262, right?
0:52:27It's not. Yes, it's an iPad 2.
0:52:29I can't wait.
0:52:30I just feel like they've – and again, it's going to be a while because I do think – I
0:52:36expect – I would love, love, love to be wrong.
0:52:38This is one of those things where if I'm wrong, I will actually be delighted and I'll
0:52:43be in line to buy one if they come out with a retina iPad Mini this year.
0:52:46That would be great.
0:52:48But I don't expect it.
0:52:50But that means that developers are going to be supporting non-retina iPads for a while
0:52:56because I think they're going to be selling non-retina iPads at least until 2014.
0:53:02But I would love to see them get rid of all the last non-retina full-size iPad.
0:53:07Yeah. It just irks you.
0:53:13It doesn't irk me, but I just can't wait to get to the world where everything's retina.
0:53:20Yeah.
0:53:20I want retina, iMacs, all the laptops, all the MacBooks to be retina, all the iPads,
0:53:26all the iPhones. So the iPhone's the first one to go all retina. Now it's the first one
0:53:31where you can't buy one that's not retina. I just think that it's going to be a total
0:53:35win for everybody when everything's retina. And then you don't have to worry about when
0:53:40you're making a website or making an app. You don't have to worry about doing two sets
0:53:44of graphics. And we've picked this great custom web font and we don't have to pick from Verdana
0:53:50and George anymore and it looks beautiful and it's great. And oh, let's go see what
0:53:55it looks like on a 3G. Oh my God. You can't read it. It's terrible. It's a huge pain in
0:54:03the ass, I think. Especially the retina, the non-retina big iPad, because it's only like
0:54:10133 pixels per inch. It really kind of stands out when you see one.
0:54:16So what were the other numbers from the quarter? So the Mac one, I think, is interesting, because
0:54:22Mac sales were a little bit down, slightly down, quarter over quarter.
0:54:26Oh, this is a good one too, the Verge.
0:54:29This is one of my favorite little – just my little Apple fairness radar.
0:54:34So when the Verge reported Apple's results, now the iPhone sales went from 35 million
0:54:43to 37 million year over year.
0:54:47They called that flat.
0:54:49iPhone sales were flat.
0:54:51And Mac sales went from 4 million to 3.95 million.
0:54:56And they called those down.
0:54:58I love that.
0:55:05That's great.
0:55:06Tumbling, tumbling, tumbling Mac sales.
0:55:08And I think Tim Cook really emphasized this.
0:55:11It's in the face of the whole PC industry declining 14% year
0:55:17over year.
0:55:17Which is like kind of terrifying if you're, I don't know, in the PC industry.
0:55:26So it's in one of those weird ways where it's like, in a way, it's kind of up.
0:55:31Like if the whole industry was down 14% and you were only down like 1.2%
0:55:39we're in a face of an industry that was down 14%.
0:55:44So that's kind of a win in a way-ish.
0:55:47Well, I guess it increases their share, right?
0:55:49Right.
0:55:49And it continues that streak where
0:55:51they outgrew the industry.
0:55:53I guess it's weird you can't really call it outgrowing,
0:55:55but they outpaced the industry for something
0:55:58like every single quarter for eight consecutive years.
0:56:01They're still outpacing the PC industry.
0:56:06Right.
0:56:08They're doing better than everybody else.
0:56:10Yeah.
0:56:12And what was last--
0:56:13I was going to look and see what last year's Mac results were,
0:56:16if they were inordinately high. I don't imagine. No, they weren't. They had one or two quarters
0:56:23where they actually got to five million. Yeah, yeah. It was sort of an average quarter. It's
0:56:31just that's the way this is going. People are buying fewer PCs. Right. And you know,
0:56:36and you know, you call it cannibalization if you want, but I think it's more of this
0:56:41transition from PCs to post PCs. But I just really think that a lot of this, you know,
0:56:45the high-water mark of five million max and a quarter everybody knows I mean
0:56:52they've been saying Apple has been saying this for years I mean I think
0:56:54even since before even the iPhone came out that look the this industry is
0:56:59shifting towards laptops laptops are you know that the the main max now are the
0:57:06Mac books you know and the iMac and the Mac Pro and the Mac mini and stuff are
0:57:10sort of the the the niche max because every you know that's just the numbers
0:57:15the numbers don't lie. And I think that's why the iPad is more easily
0:57:21cannibalizing PC sales now than it would have ten years ago because it's
0:57:26replacing laptops. Whereas if you really thought you needed an iMac, the iPad
0:57:32isn't even really something you're gonna think about. You know, if you really are
0:57:35thinking, "Hey, I want this giant 27-inch display and I really want a lot of RAM
0:57:40and I'm gonna be doing these demanding things that I need, you know, a super pro
0:57:44computer for, you know, the iPad isn't that. But if you're thinking, "Hey, I was
0:57:49gonna get an 11-inch MacBook Air. Why don't I just buy an iPad instead?"
0:57:53I think there's an awful lot of people who are doing that. I mean, I think that's
0:57:55how you go from 11 million to 20 million iPads in a quarter.
0:57:59Yeah. Do you think you spend—well, we're probably bad examples to ask this, but I
0:58:05was kind of wondering if people are spending more now than they used to—I
0:58:09guess people in general are probably spending more now than they used to on
0:58:12computer devices more money or more time yeah more money I don't know they used
0:58:21to be more expensive my max very quick very often I've never really I've always
0:58:27liked to use my Mac until they feel way too slow and then I get a new one and
0:58:32it's like wow they've really improved this year over year I mean like my
0:58:35desktop Mac is still a 2008 hi you know the time best best MacBook Pro you
0:58:42you could buy, but by today's standards, I think it's ancient.
0:58:47Yeah. Yeah. But we buy more devices.
0:58:50I do. I buy so many iPads, I have to give them away.
0:58:57Right. And phones and smartphones. But we used to spend all—I mean, the computers
0:59:03used to be much more expensive. Right. That's the other thing, too, is Macs
0:59:08used to be— We routinely spend—
0:59:10couldn't even buy one for $2,000. They were like $3,000, $4,000.
0:59:13Right. You'd buy a Mac or a MacBook. It'd be like $2,500 to get in the door, almost.
0:59:21You get a good one. $1024 by $768.
0:59:24We chewed that up pretty quick.
0:59:28All right. Let me thank the second sponsor before we run out of gas. Our second sponsor is great,
0:59:34very excited their first-time sponsor for the show and it's igloo IGL oo just
0:59:40like the Eskimos igloo is an intranet you will actually like and I know you
0:59:49say intranet and I I hear 1997 and that's exactly what they've set out to
0:59:55like rethink and replace is the the whole idea of a private sharing website
1:00:03for your company, your team, your team within the company, whatever you want to do.
1:00:08But something private, right? And igloo is just great. You can upload and share documents, but you can also create content
1:00:15with their apps that are built into the system. They've got apps for blogging, shared calendars, forums.
1:00:21They have their own little Twitter-like microblog, corporate wikis. Now think about that. Like if you had a team or a company,
1:00:28company, how great would it be to have your own little private Twitter where
1:00:32everybody can post little Twitter like status messages but you're not, you know,
1:00:36do you know that it's private because it's completely within your own company
1:00:40and it's your own little thing you're not risking sharing details or secrets
1:00:45with the outside world. That would be fantastic. Well that's what Igloo
1:00:49gives you. It's easy to work with your team because they have collaboration
1:00:53tools, built-in commenting, they have version control, you can @ mention your co-workers,
1:01:01again just like your own little private version of Twitter. And it's secure. They are totally
1:01:07into the whole enterprise security thing and they've got clients, big, big clients, RSA,
1:01:12Kimberly-Clark, Kimberly-Clark, they're the tissue people, right? They make Kleenex, IDC.
1:01:18And the main reason you're going to love the platform, if you're the sort of person who
1:01:22works you know you're the decision maker you're the nerd at the company who's in
1:01:25charge of something like this right you're gonna love it because you can
1:01:28configure the whole thing with drag-and-drop widgets anybody could do
1:01:32it right you just set this thing up and you just drag the things you want to use
1:01:36up take the things you don't want to use down hook it all up it's great and if
1:01:41you're even more technical it's great for you too everything is a hundred
1:01:45percent customizable the whole igloo website when you go to check it out is
1:01:48built using their platform, right? It's the whole eating your own dog food thing.
1:01:53So when you check out the software, realize that they're using igloo to
1:01:58build the talk, the public website that you're seeing. You have full control over
1:02:04the CSS, you can inject global or per page JavaScript in there, anything you
1:02:09can do as a nerd you could, you'd want to do you can do. And they even have an
1:02:14open API so you can bring content into or out of igloo from other sources like
1:02:19you could bring in the actual Twitter from the public Twitter you can get a
1:02:2530-day free trial you go to igloo software comm slash the talk show igloo
1:02:32software comm slash the talk show and as a side note this is great I've already
1:02:38seen them I've cheated they've already shown them to me but they've got a bunch
1:02:41videos, sandwich videos. And they're coming out soon. I think they might actually be there
1:02:49by the time this episode airs, at least the first one. And it's really, really funny.
1:02:55It is—I'm not going to spoil it. I'm not going to say a damn thing about it. But
1:03:00I laughed and I thought, "My God, it made me want to create my own software company
1:03:05so that I could have a sandwich video. But anybody who hires a sandwich video, you know
1:03:11that it's a good product. So at least go check them out to see the sandwich video. And the
1:03:16sandwich video, I think it's probably going to have you signing up. You get a 30-day free
1:03:21trial so why not sign up? Check them out.
1:03:23Tim Cynova - These guys have also sponsored my site in the past and every time they do,
1:03:28I always think, God, I wish I had had this
1:03:31when I was working at corporate IT
1:03:34because we had all these problems.
1:03:36- Yeah, it's absolutely, you know,
1:03:40and I checked it out, it's really, really good stuff.
1:03:43I really, they've clearly thought this thing through.
1:03:46It's not bullshit enterprise software.
1:03:50It's like, hey, let's like make something that people like,
1:03:53that is like a real usable product for people.
1:03:56Yeah. My kid still loves the check mark sandwich ad. Do you remember that one?
1:04:02Which one was that?
1:04:03That's the one with the guy, the sort of announcer guy that follows him around with the funny
1:04:08accent.
1:04:09Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. That was good. I like the one they did for Karateka, the Karateka
1:04:16Reel.
1:04:17Oh, yeah. Yeah. Very good.
1:04:21Jonas really hung on to that one too. Then he kept asking me, "Well, why do you always
1:04:25punch the eagle. And I was like, "Just do it." He got hung up on that part of it.
1:04:35The other thing that Tim Cook talked about was new products.
1:04:39Yes.
1:04:41Not until fall, but he said, "Not until fall, but in the fall and then throughout
1:04:472014."
1:04:49And I saw, it's like, I don't know, it was unusual to say that. They usually don't
1:04:57say a damn thing about when you should expect anything new. And I think that it's gotten
1:05:01to the point with the stock price being depressed that they want to set accurate and reasonable
1:05:06expectations. I think that's also why they've switched to, instead of severely low balling
1:05:13their forecasts being pretty accurate for about a year now. I feel like they
1:05:19feel like by being accurate and a little bit forthright about what to expect it
1:05:23it will hopefully inject some sanity into the stock market thing right so
1:05:28don't expect a new iPhone in June at WWDC and they sort of did that last year
1:05:36too when they announced WWDC last year,
1:05:41Apple PR put it out there.
1:05:44I mean, it wasn't even--
1:05:46it wasn't like a whisper campaign,
1:05:48but they pretty much put out there
1:05:51that this year's WWDC is going to be about software.
1:05:55And read between the lines on that,
1:05:57it means therefore there is not going to be new hardware.
1:06:00So last year, they didn't quite come out
1:06:02and say there's no new hardware, but they said WWDC
1:06:05is going to be all about software. Right. It was because it was the year before that they didn't say
1:06:11anything, right? And then the iPhone 4S didn't come out until October and everybody was pulling
1:06:16their hair out. Right. Everybody, like, there were people, like when the keynote was over
1:06:20and, like, everybody's filing out of the keynote room, there were people screaming and pulling hair
1:06:25out of their heads screaming, "Where's the new iPhone?" And people were panicking as though the
1:06:30the building were on fire because there was no there was no iPhone one of my
1:06:37other favorite things of the last week or two of insane Apple coverage was the
1:06:41I think it was the Wall Street Journal but one of them it was either Wall Street
1:06:46Journal or Reuters or one of them quoted an analyst from from Samsung was it
1:06:54Samsung finance Samsung I forget the name of it but it's it's a wholly owned
1:06:59subsidiary of Samsung it's like a financial company they quoted an analyst
1:07:04from Samsung who said that the iPhone was scheduled for June or July and is
1:07:11now going to be late it's like well of course if a guy from Samsung says that
1:07:17it must be true what kind of know what kind of bias is you know certainly
1:07:24nothing wrong with that. Here's my thing. It's the third paragraph from
1:07:32Jung Ali's report for Bloomberg. I'm sorry to the Wall Street Journal and
1:07:35Reuters. It was Bloomberg, but I knew it was one of those guys. It was LG display
1:07:40profit misses estimates on stalling Apple sales. Apple is losing dominance.
1:07:46This is the quote. "Apple is losing dominance and will likely delay launching
1:07:50successor to the iPhone until at least September. Harrison Cho, an analyst for
1:07:55soul-based Samsung Securities Company, said before the earnings release.
1:08:02That guy's bonus this year is gonna be huge. Somebody on Twitter posted to me
1:08:12Coca-Cola tastes like dog urine, says Pepsi in securities animals.
1:08:19Coke's docked down.
1:08:23Right.
1:08:26Last week, you and Mike Lop—
1:08:31Michael Lop.
1:08:32Michael Lop were talking about the rumors of what we might expect.
1:08:38Yeah.
1:08:40I'm actually working on something for Macworld, so I'm teasing something that'll come out
1:08:44next week.
1:08:49Just that you guys – and I see everybody seems to have the same kind of feeling, just
1:08:54that no one's that excited about what they've heard about.
1:08:59Because the rumors are cheaper iPhone, television, and a watch.
1:09:10And my point is kind of that to a certain degree, well, first of all, the rumored devices
1:09:20that we had previously, the tablet, the phone, and the set-top box were like the big three
1:09:28rumored devices of the previous decade.
1:09:31But we had those for a decade.
1:09:34stuff that stuff got started some of that stuff got started in the late 90s
1:09:40and we had a long time to think about that stuff before it came out are you
1:09:46saying that other companies had like cell phones since the 90s or you're
1:09:50saying that no I'm saying the rumors state rumors that Apple was going to
1:09:53make one dated yeah the tap that at least what your point yeah the tap right
1:09:56the rumors about Apple date back that far right the tablet and at least the
1:10:01tablet and the set-top box date back that far. The phone got started a little bit later.
1:10:08And then the other thing I was thinking is that even then, a lot of people didn't necessarily
1:10:16think that they would be that great. That Apple would have that much to... I mean, I
1:10:22know people who really like Apple who didn't think that Apple really was going to bring
1:10:27that much to a phone.
1:10:28Right.
1:10:29But on the other hand, the other difference I see too though is that there were a lot
1:10:35of people who said, "I don't see what Apple's going to bring to a phone."
1:10:37But there was also the large consensus that all phones sucked.
1:10:41Right?
1:10:42That, "My God, these phones are terrible."
1:10:46Especially phones that tried to do anything more than just be phones.
1:10:51Anything more than telephone calls.
1:10:53Anything more than that.
1:10:54They were just abysmal.
1:10:55So there was this consensus that, my God, this is horrible,
1:10:58and Apple come rescue us.
1:11:00Whereas that's why I think there's so little excitement
1:11:03about watches, for example.
1:11:05Nobody is saying, my God, I can't find a good watch.
1:11:09I can't find a watch that I like.
1:11:12Yeah, but as you've noted, it may not be a watch at all.
1:11:16Right.
1:11:17It could be something--
1:11:18I think that's the best way to think of it,
1:11:19if there's any truth to it, is that something
1:11:22that you might wear, you might even wear it on your wrist.
1:11:25But I don't think thinking of it as a watch is the right way to go.
1:11:28And it's probably true in hindsight that you shouldn't think of the iPhone as a phone.
1:11:32Right.
1:11:33Right?
1:11:34It's really, you know, it goes back to that Clayton Christensen thing where he, you know,
1:11:39admits that it was like this huge error he made when the iPhone was introduced that that's
1:11:44the innovator's dilemma guy where he didn't think it was going to change the industry
1:11:48because the disruption always comes from the low end and the iPhone was this super high-end
1:11:53phone.
1:11:54the mistake was it wasn't really a high-end phone. It was a super low-end portable computer.
1:11:58It was this way too small, way too crappy portable computer. But because it was so crazy
1:12:03small and you'd have it everywhere, it completely disrupted the computer industry by way of the
1:12:09phone industry. I think it's that sort of thing. It might tell you time, but it's not really a watch.
1:12:15Yeah, I hardly ever talk on my iPhone.
1:12:18Really, I seriously--
1:12:19And the other thing too, and that's the other thing too with the--
1:12:22Oh, my god, I told you before, I can't even hear people on my phone.
1:12:26It's like cell networks.
1:12:27Even when you upgrade to-- I upgraded from AT&T to Verizon when the iPhone 5 came out,
1:12:32and my phone calls all sounded better.
1:12:34I was like, "Yes, I now have better sounding phone calls consistently."
1:12:37And then I realized that they still sound terrible.
1:12:41Like, a perfect connection on a cell phone call.
1:12:45It still is like really crap audio.
1:12:48But in researching this piece that I was writing, I found some great claim chowder for you.
1:12:54Ooh.
1:12:55Ooh, well, let's hear it.
1:12:56So this is back in 2002.
1:12:57That was not me.
1:12:58Because that was like the—you jumped to the punchline.
1:13:03Oh, it's me.
1:13:04You wrote the punchline.
1:13:07But John Markoff wrote this piece, and I think this was like the first mention of an iPhone,
1:13:13and he wrote a piece in the New York Times about it and was talking about how, you know,
1:13:17we'd have apps for, you know, email and Sherlock and things like that.
1:13:22And you wrote, "These are applications, not technologies.
1:13:26The article seems to insinuate that Apple could make Sherlock run on a cell phone.
1:13:30That's impossible unless the cell phone were actually running Mac OS X, which is definitely
1:13:35impossible.
1:13:36You know, a lot of people trot that's actually the one I was worried you were going to bring
1:13:40up.
1:13:41A lot of people trot that out.
1:13:42And I don't want to seem defensive, but I meant it was an article that claimed that
1:13:46that device was like in the labs and like ready to come out in 2003.
1:13:51And that's where you're right.
1:13:52Right.
1:13:53I wasn't saying that it was always going to be impossible.
1:13:54In 2002, it was not.
1:13:55That it would never be possible.
1:13:57I was saying it was impossible in 2003 to make a phone that ran a cut down version of
1:14:02Mac OS X.
1:14:03I still stand by that, that I was right.
1:14:05And it certainly didn't come out.
1:14:08The difference between 2002 and 2007
1:14:11was huge in terms of what was possible.
1:14:14So I don't think that counts.
1:14:15I think that counts as a median right.
1:14:16But people love to trot that one out and act
1:14:18as though I'm the big dumb dumb.
1:14:20I just wanted to bring that up to get you back
1:14:23for your Ichiro crack.
1:14:24Planning that for like two or three weeks, whatever it was.
1:14:33That's impossible. Remember Sherlock?
1:14:35Yeah. Yeah.
1:14:37Was Sherlock kind of a
1:14:41predecessor to Siri?
1:14:43Kind of. Yeah. Yeah, definitely.
1:14:45Right? Like, asking for sports scores and weather and stuff like that.
1:14:49Like, sort of componentized data.
1:14:53Yeah, they could have used that name.
1:14:55Yeah.
1:14:57It would have to have, like, a British accent, though.
1:14:59accent though but that was an idea that they kind of well at least the people
1:15:03said that they cop from somebody else right right Watson Watson right right
1:15:11yeah so do you want to talk about insta paper I guess so I I don't know what to
1:15:20say about it really I mean so then I think Marco announced yesterday that he
1:15:25has sold Instapaper to, or quote-unquote "controlling interest" in Instapaper, I
1:15:30don't even know what that means, to Betaworks, the guys who bought Dig.
1:15:34Apparently they're doing good stuff there. I don't know. Some people said, I haven't really
1:15:39paid attention. I haven't paid attention to it either, but that's what I keep
1:15:41hearing, and it seems like they want to step in to fill the gap that
1:15:45Google made by killing Reeder. Right, and I do, if that's true, and that they're
1:15:52going to make something that people would consider a replacement for Google
1:15:56Reader, in other words reading people's feeds in the aggregate, you know, RSS
1:16:01feeds. It certainly makes a lot of sense. It really, I hate to use the word, I think
1:16:07for the second time this week, but it does seem like there's an awful lot of
1:16:10synergy there with something like Instapaper. Like a read loader service that nicely formats articles in a consistent way and stuff
1:16:19because it seems like you could cut down on the whole jumping through hoops to
1:16:26actually get the thing into your Instapaper. Yeah. So, I mean, I always get
1:16:33nervous when these things happen, but because you never know how it's
1:16:37gonna end up. Right, and you know, I mean, I think Marco in his
1:16:41typical style, you know, was very honest about it. I thought, you know, his
1:16:45explanation was, look, this--
1:16:48and I forgot.
1:16:49It's one of those things where four or five years goes by
1:16:52and you forget just how different things were.
1:16:55I've totally forgot that Instapaper started as a website.
1:17:00Oh, I didn't even--
1:17:01Because I never used it.
1:17:03I don't think I ever used it as a website.
1:17:05To me, it's always been about reading on the iPhone
1:17:10and eventually the iPad.
1:17:13Totally forgot.
1:17:14To me, the app was Instapaper.
1:17:16I really forgot that he started as a website first and then did the app.
1:17:23But he said in the years since, it's gotten so competitive.
1:17:27And he's up against these VC-funded dipshits who are giving everything away for free and
1:17:38have like $45 million in VC money to fund it all.
1:17:43So there's definitely a-- it's a tough competitive angle,
1:17:46right?
1:17:47I mean, this is great.
1:17:48This is so great.
1:17:48You're going to love this if you haven't noticed.
1:17:50Somebody pointed out yesterday in the aftermath
1:17:52of Marco's announcement about this, a Hacker News thread.
1:17:55And you know it's going to be good on Hacker News.
1:17:59Where somebody on Hacker News was comparing Instapaper,
1:18:03which I think is like $3.99, to one of the other competitors
1:18:08that is-- they're giving the whole thing away for free.
1:18:11I don't know if it was Pocket or Readability or one of them.
1:18:14But they were like, "So Pocket is free and Instapaper is $4.
1:18:20Is it really – if it costs four times as much, is it really four times better?"
1:18:30Because if it's not, I don't see how that's justified, which is really good because you
1:18:38None of those guys on Hacker News think they're good at math.
1:18:42And even-- it's funny because it would be a little--
1:18:45it would be like a slight chuckle for me,
1:18:47even if it was a $1 to $4 comparison.
1:18:50And the guy tried to make an argument that it would have to be four times
1:18:54better apt to justify being $4 versus $1, which is not the way decisions are
1:19:01made.
1:19:02But the four times zero thing was pretty good, I thought.
1:19:08Yeah, four times as much right? I
1:19:10Do get nervous though, I mean because it's you know, I'm Marco
1:19:15I was so Marco said a that you know to compete he need he would seriously compete against these guys
1:19:20He'd kind of need to hire a team
1:19:22And expand because one person can't really keep up with
1:19:27These other competitors that have teams of people working on it and that's not what he wants to do. He does not want to
1:19:33Become a manager and hire a team and have employees and stuff like that
1:19:37I mean, I certainly appreciate firsthand the advantages of being a one-person operation
1:19:46and not having any employees and stuff like that.
1:19:49And number two, that he just wanted to move on and do something new, that he wants to
1:19:53do something new.
1:19:54So hopefully, he did pick a good home for the app.
1:19:59I certainly use it enough where I'm going to be somewhat upset if it somehow falls into
1:20:05disarray.
1:20:06Yeah.
1:20:07There's a difference.
1:20:08For better or worse, there's a different mentality
1:20:10between being able to create an app like that
1:20:13and then wanting to maintain it forever.
1:20:18And it seems like a lot of these-- I don't have an ounce
1:20:25of the kind of ability that Marco's got.
1:20:29But that's what happens when these guys-- it's a lot of fun
1:20:32to make something, and then it's a lot less fun to just sit
1:20:34there and--
1:20:37I realize how much affection I have for Instapaper.
1:20:40If I ever get on an airplane, like a Wi-Fi-less airplane,
1:20:44and then realize as I take my devices out
1:20:46that I hadn't turned any of them on before getting on the plane,
1:20:50and that my Instapaper is not up to date.
1:20:52Because that's-- I'll just sit there with my--
1:20:56no connection, just sit there and hit the reload button
1:20:59in Instapaper and be like, give me those articles I queued up
1:21:02to read on this flight.
1:21:03Yeah, I don't know what else to say about it. I mean, you know, congratulations. I hope
1:21:10it works out.
1:21:12Yeah, no, and yeah. It's certainly good for Marco.
1:21:16Yeah, and I do think, you know, and I suspect that it was, I don't know, and I trust Marco
1:21:23and I trust his judgment. You know, I think he, you know, it wasn't like he was forced
1:21:28to do this. So I feel like it was measured and deliberate. So I think it will probably
1:21:38work out pretty well.
1:21:39Tim Cynova Yeah. You don't want it to end up like George
1:21:42Lucas.
1:21:43Dave Asprey I don't know about that. What do you think?
1:21:47How do you mean by that?
1:21:49Tim Cynova Just hanging on to something for too long
1:21:50and ruining it.
1:21:51Dave Asprey Oh, right, right, right. The Jar Jar Binks
1:21:54version of Instapaper.
1:21:55Tim Cynova Yeah. You have Fire Up Instapaper and there's
1:21:58a little cartoon idiot I don't even know what that would be what would what would
1:22:06be charge our version of insta papers be the Phantom Menace person of insta paper
1:22:11no I don't even want to think about it yeah I don't know too horrible to behold
1:22:16insta paper on your watch you can see that trying to think is there anything
1:22:24new anything else I guess the other thing would be want to go back to the
1:22:29call is that Tim Cook did tease a quote unquote or do you say categories plural
1:22:35new proud product categories yeah which I don't think got as much attention as
1:22:42it deserved like I kind of feel like people glossed over that like he that
1:22:45does not mean a new iPhone or a new iPad that means you know a new brand new
1:22:50revision of the whole a new thing like the iPad well I think it's because
1:22:55everybody knows it's not true because innovation is dead at Apple yeah so
1:22:59that's why nobody that's why nobody paid attention did you listen to the call
1:23:03yeah I work from home now yeah it's what's his name the team nothing else
1:23:11Jean Munster yeah that was a funny like he came it's like he came in late cuz he
1:23:20asked his question. These guys get like one question a quarter and basically,
1:23:26Munster wastes it asking what he said earlier. Tim, did you say earlier there would be new products?
1:23:34Tim Cynova New product categories.
1:23:36Tim Cynova Like he caught on that it was a new product category.
1:23:39Tim Cynova And Tim leans at, "Yes, that's what I said."
1:23:43Tim Cynova Yeah. It reminds me of Sticker Guy from the
1:23:49thing years ago, I forget what event that was. It was some event at Apple's Town Hall
1:23:54for like IMAX or something and the guy who asked the question about why they don't
1:23:57put Intel inside stickers all over their computers. Yeah, Gene Munster. Did you see my tweet?
1:24:06Probably, which one? After the conference call I tweeted like a what was his name
1:24:19Howard Hughes type scenario. Oh yeah. Gee Monster in 2037. All alone in a dark room
1:24:26thin gray long gray beard surrounded by bottles of his own urine
1:24:32and muttering, "Apple TV, way of the future."
1:24:37He answered me on Twitter.
1:24:38He is a good sport.
1:24:39He was like, he gave me an @ reply and was like, "You'll see."
1:24:43The thing is, if you don't know, is that Gene Munster, I forget who he works for, but he's
1:24:49an Apple analyst.
1:24:50He's been an Apple analyst for a long time.
1:24:53He's been saying that Apple is going to come out with their own TV sets, not Apple TV,
1:24:58Apple branded TV sets for six, seven years. And he's never quite said, "Hey, it's coming
1:25:06next month." But he's more or less been saying that next year is the year that Apple's going
1:25:10to do a TV set for about six or seven years and has never, ever lost the fervor for it.
1:25:18Right. Which I guess you have to admire his consistency.
1:25:24Yeah, well and it's another one of those things sort of like the the claim chatter you pulled on me where I
1:25:30you know
1:25:33If they did come out with an apple-branded television set next year and everyone see see Gene Munster was right
1:25:39Well, it he wasn't right in
1:25:412007 when he said that they're coming out with an Apple TV next year, right like everybody sort of condenses history, but no
1:25:48That's my I said in 2007 that you're coming out with a TV next year and then it comes out in 2014
1:25:53That's not right.
1:25:54That's my theory of the infallibility of Apple rumors is that as long as Apple comes
1:26:01out with something remotely like what you said it would come out with next year, even
1:26:06if it's 40 years later, then you can claim that you're right.
1:26:12You know what?
1:26:13The same thing to some degree possibly applies with Google Glass too.
1:26:20I have to write about it on Daring Fireball because I keep making a shit out of Google
1:26:23Glass.
1:26:24And I don't mean to say that I don't think heads-up displays are ever going to be a thing
1:26:29and that they're not cool technology and that I'm never going to buy one or whatever.
1:26:34It sounds, obviously, clearly, there's a lot of, everybody who's seen Minority Report,
1:26:38there's a lot of potential there.
1:26:40I'm saying these Google Glasses, the ones that they've got right now that they're selling
1:26:45is fifteen hundred dollar developer units and and that stupid thing that it
1:26:49puts up in the corner of your eye and the way they look
1:26:52i'm saying these google glasses the ones right now
1:26:55ones that they're gonna you know the first batch are coming out are stupid
1:26:58and no one's gonna buy them
1:27:00and that they're creepy
1:27:02well they're too expensive, well at least if the price stays what it is it's too
1:27:05expensive that to really... right but then you know really catch them now
1:27:09when like the oculus rift thing comes out and you can play xbox games on it
1:27:14really cool heads-up display and have this incredibly
1:27:16immersive experience, people are going to say,
1:27:19see, you're wrong about heads-up displays or whatever.
1:27:22And I'm not saying there's never going to be a use or a purpose
1:27:25or there's not going to be a call.
1:27:27I'm saying these Google, this specific product
1:27:30that they've shown us.
1:27:31And this is the difference-- we think
1:27:33we've talked about this before-- but this
1:27:34is the difference between Apple and Google,
1:27:36is that Google does a lot of its product development
1:27:38out in the open.
1:27:40kind of drags us all through the mess of getting it to the point where it's a cool product
1:27:47before an Apple does all this behind the scenes and only ships it when it's finished and polished.
1:27:53Right. So, you know, and then, you know, all credit to them if you want to show it, you
1:27:57know, you get credit for showing it.
1:27:58Yeah, I mean, and I don't think that's bad necessarily. You know, it's just the way they
1:28:02do it.
1:28:03Right. It's like the people, there's still people who hang on to the idea that Bill Gates
1:28:06was right about tablets.
1:28:10I mean, nobody was saying he was wrong that in theory, a tablet
1:28:13computer would be cool, or the way of the future,
1:28:17to quote Howard Hughes.
1:28:19But you don't really get credit for the Windows tablets
1:28:23that came out in 2002, because they were horrible.
1:28:27I mean, there's some sort of credit
1:28:29for at least being on the record and trying early,
1:28:32but you don't get credit for the iPad,
1:28:35because you ship the whatever the thing was called in 2003.
1:28:39Yeah.
1:28:40What was the other one today Google Glass related?
1:28:44It was Eric Schmidt at some conference and he called, he admitted that Google Glass was
1:28:50weird and inappropriate.
1:28:52You do have to give the guy credit.
1:28:55He is, in some ways, he's actually amazingly honest.
1:28:59You do get a lot of honest because the most honest thing he's ever said and it's, you
1:29:03know it is it gets exactly to what I don't like about Google it was that the
1:29:07the thing he said a year or two ago about that Google's Google's purpose is
1:29:11to get right up against the creepy line yeah right I mean at least he admitted
1:29:17it I mean they do know so credit to him you know who to Google for towing the
1:29:22creepy line but at least he does admit it do you remember this I got a good one
1:29:28Yeah. Yeah, I definitely remember that. And didn't he – I thought I saw this someplace.
1:29:36The other –
1:29:37Eric Schmidt, the CEO of Google, has described his company's policy. "Google policy is
1:29:42to get right up to the creepy line and not cross it." That's a quote. Like, I do
1:29:50feel like there's this big divide. And there's a lot of people who really do like Google
1:29:55and you know and I'm glad they read my site and stuff it I feel like they read it though just to get angry
1:30:00But you know if you don't if you don't see how that's a weird thing for the
1:30:07CEO and or former CEO and and and chairman of the board of a company to say then I mean we're
1:30:13We're never really gonna agree on much
1:30:16Didn't you say something about how
1:30:21Also, it's like if you think that it's creepy too bad because it's coming anyway
1:30:25About teenagers changing their names remember that one. Oh, yeah. Could you look it up? Look at him? You gotta read it
1:30:35My keyboards too loud
1:30:39Every young person one day he was talking about this that our job is to get right up
1:30:48To the creepy line and not cross it
1:30:50It was talking about the possibility of chip implants that you would put under your skin that Google would provide you in the future
1:30:56With your permission you give us more information about you about your friends and we can improve the quality of our searches
1:31:03We don't need you to type at all. We know where you are. We know where you've been
1:31:07We can more or less know what you're thinking about
1:31:10That's over the creepy line
1:31:16No, that's right up against that's the best part is he thinks that's not yeah. Yeah be like
1:31:22He predicts apparently seriously that every young person one day will be entitled
1:31:28Automatically to change his or her name on reaching adulthood in order to disown youthful hijinks stored on their friends social media sites. I
1:31:36Do think I mean I do think that I am glad that I grew up before
1:31:45So this technology was available
1:31:47Yeah, because I would have been reckless I would have been bad
1:31:53Yeah, I would have been pretty right and now I've let me you know
1:31:55I got it, you know
1:31:56I got in right at the right time where all this stuff became available when I was already told I
1:32:02Know I you know, I think though that's so ubiquitous though
1:32:08I don't feel though that like the future politicians of America need you know
1:32:12the 15 year old today who's going to be running for the Senate in California
1:32:1935 years from now I don't think he has to worry about his tweets because who
1:32:23you know who the hell is yeah who is not going to everybody's gonna have
1:32:28something tweets for whenever 15 you know Google ball that's what I would
1:32:35like to know though if he thinks knowing where we've been where we are and more
1:32:40us knowing what we're thinking about is up to but not over the creepy line. I would love to know
1:32:45like what's the discussions that they've had where they're like well that's over the creepy line. I
1:32:49would love to see that they have the whiteboard with the well that's over the creepy line we
1:32:54can't do that. I would love to know. I think that would be so great. I wonder if they have
1:32:58a specification for that. Right. We have a guess we have a pretty good guess what you look like naked.
1:33:08Looks a little bit like this.
1:33:10[laughs]
1:33:15All right, I say we call it a show.
1:33:16Anything else? Nothing else to cover.
1:33:18No. John Molt's very nice website. Dot net.
1:33:22Thank you.
1:33:23Thanks for having me.
1:33:24That's where everybody can get their fill of molts.
1:33:28[laughs]
1:33:29All five of you.