0:00:00What a week.
0:00:01Yeah, it's been a really crazy one for a number of reasons.
0:00:06So, it's like just before we came on the air here, there's an announcement from the mailbox
0:00:11guys.
0:00:12So, this is like breaking news.
0:00:13I mean, I never know how to handle that on the show because it's a weekly show.
0:00:17But the mailbox guys are joining Dropbox.
0:00:20Yes.
0:00:21So, of course, I should mention I was an investor in mailbox.
0:00:27And I know you and I both tested it before it came out.
0:00:31And I know you and I had differing opinions on that.
0:00:35You wrote about some of yours a few weeks ago, I guess, talking about how it didn't
0:00:42really work into your workflow.
0:00:43Mainly, I think, you made a lot of good points, I think, but mainly because you don't use
0:00:48Gmail primarily.
0:00:49Right.
0:00:50Well, more or less.
0:00:51I used Gmail in a weird way, and it didn't fit with Mailbot.
0:00:54I think it was one of the neatest emails.
0:00:57My compliments were sincere.
0:00:58I think it's a great app.
0:01:00But it implies a certain way of doing email
0:01:03that didn't fit with the way I use all my other clients.
0:01:06- Yeah, I think that was a big part,
0:01:08and will remain a big part of mailbox,
0:01:10'cause of course they're not shutting it down.
0:01:11This is going to remain a product under the Dropbox brand.
0:01:15But a big part of it was kinda letting go
0:01:19of the way that you did previously do email,
0:01:21and I think that's why the people
0:01:23who had a hard time getting into it,
0:01:25I talked to a number of them, of course.
0:01:27And once some of those people were able to just totally
0:01:32let go of the previous ways that they were doing email
0:01:36and almost archive everything and then just wait
0:01:39for new stuff to come in and then keep archiving it
0:01:41or keep pushing it, then they sort of got into it.
0:01:44And I sort of, I got into it immediately
0:01:48because I had actually done that by myself
0:01:51before mailbox even existed.
0:01:52I just decided email was getting way out of control.
0:01:56I just had to archive everything,
0:01:58and then I was starting kind of fresh,
0:02:00and then I would, when mailbox didn't exist,
0:02:03I would almost, at the end of every week and on the weekend,
0:02:05go through all my email that came in
0:02:07and just go through it as quickly as possible,
0:02:10and then archive anything I didn't need
0:02:12and then respond to anything I needed to.
0:02:14This just allowed me to do it
0:02:15in a much more simple way on the iPhone itself.
0:02:18- No, I think it's a really interesting way
0:02:19to do email on a small screen device.
0:02:22And the other thing, though, one of the reasons
0:02:24I think it works so well,
0:02:26and what they're almost infamous for,
0:02:28is that to use the app, you've gotta sign up
0:02:31and you've gotta wait for your turn,
0:02:32and people crack a lot of jokes about how long
0:02:34it's taking for people to get let in.
0:02:37But it's not like just an arbitrary,
0:02:39we're trying to be exclusive to be cool,
0:02:42it's because there's a server-side component.
0:02:44And this is part of what makes it work so well,
0:02:47is you give your Gmail credentials to Mailbox
0:02:51and they check your mail from them.
0:02:54- Right.
0:02:55- And the app interfaces with them,
0:02:57and so it makes it way more efficient.
0:02:59- Yeah, and I think they really did nail that.
0:03:02They were really worried about rolling it out too quickly
0:03:06that this would crash and bring down the whole thing.
0:03:08So I think it really was out of necessity
0:03:10that they did the system that they made.
0:03:12And I think it's a pretty ingenious system.
0:03:14I know a lot of people were upset
0:03:15just because the wait has been so long.
0:03:18They still haven't let in everyone even now.
0:03:21But yeah, it was totally out of necessity.
0:03:22And they worked a lot on the back end of that system
0:03:24to make it all work as seamlessly as it does.
0:03:27And it really does.
0:03:28I mean, I now use it too on my iPad.
0:03:30I use it on both iPads, the big one and the mini,
0:03:32even though it's of course not tailored
0:03:34specifically for those.
0:03:35But it's great how it just is constantly in sync
0:03:38between all of them.
0:03:40And it's great that you can also use it with regular Gmail
0:03:43when you're on your desktop because they do a smart things
0:03:46with folders within Gmail.
0:03:48So they have Mailbox slash Later slash Weekend and all the different labeling systems.
0:03:55So it was a really smart way that they went about doing it.
0:03:58Obviously I was a huge fan of the product and I will remain a huge fan.
0:04:02I think that the Dropbox deal is very smart from Dropbox's perspective.
0:04:07You think about what Dropbox is, they're now moving more towards, it looks like, becoming
0:04:12sort of a cloud-based OS in their own right.
0:04:16Yeah, and the Dropbox, there's a couple of things I want to talk about. It's a totally
0:04:22funny coincidence that you're the guest on the show this week and that you're, you know
0:04:25the mailbox guys, you're an investor. Because this literally broke like an hour ago.
0:04:33But what, you know, clearly one of the things the Dropbox has got, I mean everybody knows
0:04:37this, they could obviously bring them expertise with scaling to large amounts of information,
0:04:43Large amounts of concurrency, huge number of users, and a terrific, almost maybe unparalleled
0:04:50reputation for reliability.
0:04:52Yeah.
0:04:53And so I think Dropbox, they have over 100 million users, something like that, God knows
0:04:57how many files they're actually working with.
0:05:00But I think the mailbox guys, I think they realized that they had a huge hit on their
0:05:05hands, but I think also they knew that in order for this to keep working as well as
0:05:11it has been working. They need to really get to scale pretty quickly as a number of other
0:05:17people I assume will be coming after them. Who knows what Google is doing itself with
0:05:22Gmail. This gets them right to where they need to be. In Dropbox now, all of a sudden,
0:05:30how do a lot of people still send attachments? It's over email. They have this perfect system
0:05:37to do that now.
0:05:38So, let me press you a little bit though as an investor.
0:05:41Isn't this a little early for somebody to sell?
0:05:45It is pretty quick.
0:05:46We've had this happen a number of times now.
0:05:49The last good example is Vine, the quick video sharing service that Twitter acquired actually
0:05:55before they launched.
0:06:00That's going to be a record that might be hard to play.
0:06:04The good news is that I think Crunchfund, the fund where I'm a general partner at,
0:06:11is doing a good job of picking some services that are pretty compelling and end up being
0:06:16good things.
0:06:18The downside is it is a little bit bittersweet to see these things just be taken under someone
0:06:24else's wing so quickly after they launched, or like Vine before they launched.
0:06:30Because you always want to see a startup try to do it by themselves, see what scale they
0:06:36can get to, see if they can become the next giant company on their own.
0:06:41And I think that's why every investor makes their initial investment to begin with.
0:06:47Of course, there are great outcomes, and that's the way that it works, but I think that you
0:06:52don't make an initial investment hoping that someone's going to sell the company within
0:06:55six months because you would be an awful overall investor if you did that.
0:07:00Well, and while you say it's bittersweet, there's a big difference between both of
0:07:04those acquisitions and a lot of the acquisitions that I've had my eye on in
0:07:09the last, I don't know, couple of years, which is it's not the they're both, you
0:07:15know, Vine was acquired and so they could launch Vine and do Vine and Vine is what
0:07:20Vine was meant to be and Mailbox, like we said, is continuing a Dropbox bought it
0:07:25so they can continue doing it. This isn't those one of those talent acquisitions
0:07:29where the bigger company takes the product in,
0:07:32but all they really wanted was the team,
0:07:35and the product immediately goes into shutdown mode.
0:07:38I mean, a perfect parallel, 'cause it's also,
0:07:42was a popular iOS Mac email client was Sparrow.
0:07:45- Of course, right, and right, that's sort of,
0:07:49I don't want to say that's sort of the nightmare scenario
0:07:51that you kind of dread, but I think that by all accounts,
0:07:55that's not been the greatest exit,
0:07:59And I don't know from an insider perspective
0:08:01if I'm not an investor in that or anything.
0:08:04I just think that that was a pure acqui-hire.
0:08:08The product is still working, but they said immediately
0:08:10right after that they were basically
0:08:12gonna stop developing for it,
0:08:13or that they were gonna open source some of it,
0:08:15I think they said.
0:08:16Yeah, but it's all just faded away.
0:08:18I mean, who talks about Sparrow anymore?
0:08:19Right, and so yes, you're right.
0:08:21That is like the worst case scenario
0:08:23where that happens quite often.
0:08:26And it's great that both Vine and now Mailbox
0:08:28going to live on.
0:08:31I think we're already seeing now in Vine's case,
0:08:33there were some numbers earlier this week,
0:08:35that they're getting to a scale that's really impressive pretty
0:08:39quickly.
0:08:39And that's something that Twitter enables.
0:08:41Who knows if they would have been
0:08:42able to do that on their own.
0:08:43You'd like to think that they could
0:08:45have done that on their own.
0:08:46But I think that there's no question that Twitter gets them
0:08:49to a place that they want to be faster than they could possibly
0:08:53do it if they remained independent.
0:08:57I would also—and again, I'm not trying to put you on the spot and have you reveal
0:09:02things that they're not ready to reveal.
0:09:04But in addition to scaling, Dropbox is doing really well financially.
0:09:07Might help the mailbox team expand a little bit so that they can get to—I mean, I think
0:09:14what's obviously would be coming next would be an iPad-native client and maybe even a
0:09:19Mac client.
0:09:20Sure.
0:09:21Yeah, I mean, I think that everyone has been clamoring for those since they started using
0:09:25the iPhone version itself.
0:09:27I know you said that if they had a Mac client, you might even, that would make it sort of
0:09:30interesting to you because then you could use it more seamlessly with your workflow.
0:09:34Right, because it seems that's the gist of my, not even a complaint, just observation
0:09:39with the workflow.
0:09:40Because I know a lot of people when they're on their Mac, when they do email, they're
0:09:43in a browser on gmail.com.
0:09:46And if that's how you do email, I think mailbox on your iPhone is, I'm not going to say a
0:09:52no-brainer, but it's really something you should look at.
0:09:55But I don't.
0:09:56I really don't like the Gmail interface.
0:09:59And so I use Gmail-backed email addresses,
0:10:02but primarily just as IMAP with really good spam filtering.
0:10:06Yeah, yeah, I got that.
0:10:08And I do use Gmail on the web, though.
0:10:12I actually only use it basically for search
0:10:15and to kind of look at things quickly as they're coming in throughout the day.
0:10:17When I respond to email before Mailbox,
0:10:20it used to be I would just use the iPad with the Logitech keyboard,
0:10:23because it's so much faster than trying to use the web-based Gmail.
0:10:27Yeah, so I don't know, you know, but if I could use mailbox everywhere, it would make a big difference.
0:10:34That's really the bottom of my complaint. But anyway, I'm excited about this. This does seem like, it seems like good news overall.
0:10:40Yeah, I think it's two great companies that will only help mailbox kind of get to the point where they need to be with all those different clients, like you said.
0:10:49you said.
0:10:50Right.
0:10:51And Dropbox seems, you know, I mean you never know, but Dropbox really does seem from the
0:10:54outside to almost like Twitter, they're determined to stay independent.
0:11:02Like you never say never, but it doesn't seem like Dropbox is interested in selling.
0:11:07Right.
0:11:08We had the, of course, there were the rumors or talk a long time ago about the meeting
0:11:12with Steve Jobs between them, you know, sort of trying to bully them into selling or whatnot.
0:11:18And yeah, I mean, they've raised a huge amount of money, and I think that they're
0:11:25making a huge amount of money.
0:11:26I don't know.
0:11:27I'm not privy to their actual finances.
0:11:29But yeah, I think that they'll be fine staying independent, and I think that that's their
0:11:34plan.
0:11:35So that's great.
0:11:36Mad Fientist Lots of other news this week.
0:11:39But we have a couple of sponsors this week, so let me do one right now.
0:11:43And let me tell you about Things and Things Cloud Sync.
0:11:47Everybody knows things. Things has been a popular Mac and iOS to-do system for a couple of years.
0:11:57But the big new thing that they've launched fairly recently is Things Cloud Sync.
0:12:01And it was in the works for a while, almost was notorious for, you know, "Hey, when are you guys going to get sync?"
0:12:07But it's out now, and it really does work great.
0:12:11And so if you use things on your Mac and on your iPhone,
0:12:15you log in with things Cloud Sync and it all just works.
0:12:20Now, part of the thing that makes it great that they develop their own system rather than waiting for,
0:12:24say, Apple, is all of the problems a lot of people are having with iCloud Sync and Core Data,
0:12:32you know, almost notorious we could almost do a whole show on that.
0:12:35They're not using that.
0:12:36And I think it shows because their sync works instantly.
0:12:40And they also have a really cool feature, and this would never happen through iCloud,
0:12:47but one of the things they have with Things Cloud is what they call local push.
0:12:52And when one device sends an update to the cloud, it also broadcasts an encrypted notification
0:12:57over the local network telling other clients that are logged in at the same time on the
0:13:02same account, like let's say on your home Wi-Fi network, that they should check for
0:13:07updates now.
0:13:08And so when you try this out, and I did it, it's almost bizarre.
0:13:12It's like you type something on your Mac and you have your iPhone open, and it's almost
0:13:17like you're typing on your iPhone from your Mac.
0:13:19Like you hit return and there it shows up.
0:13:22Really, really great.
0:13:25Other notable features they've got, they've got integration with Siri so you can speak
0:13:29your to-dos directly into things.
0:13:32They have a new daily review feature that streamlines your daily decision making, sort
0:13:36sort of take a look at your whole pile of to-dos, what am I going to do today?
0:13:41And they have a new custom designed scrolling date picker.
0:13:44It's really, really nice UI.
0:13:47I think they really have sort of built something better than the OS standard for picking dates
0:13:52to assign dates to your to-dos.
0:13:55So check out things too.
0:13:58Give it a spin, but you've really got to think about the Cloud Sync to understand just how
0:14:02great the system that they have right now is.
0:14:05Check them out at culturedcode.com, C-U-L-T-U-R-E-D-C-O-D-E dot com.
0:14:14And my thanks to them for sponsoring the show this week.
0:14:16It's interesting that Things was one of your sponsors.
0:14:21Going back to Mailbox for a second, their original product was Orchestra, which was
0:14:25also a to-do list.
0:14:27Yeah, it just never really…
0:14:30I think it was pretty interesting.
0:14:31were doing before Siri existed, they were doing some of the voice techniques to kind
0:14:36of, you know, just be able to hit a button and speak your to-do list. Yeah, just never
0:14:40really took off in the same way that some of those other to-do lists have.
0:14:44Yeah, I sort of feel like they… and the orchestra thing was sort of, "Hey, everybody's
0:14:50using their inbox as a to-do list. Is there a way that we can go with that?" And they
0:14:54tried something. And I remember looking at it and thinking, "Interesting," but didn't
0:14:59click. Right, but it's going to end up being, you know, it already is, one of those
0:15:05fascinating stories where what they were doing early on, while it didn't
0:15:09quite click, really did lead to the idea of what Mailbox was, because when you
0:15:13look at the Mailbox app, it basically is, I think that they realized the
0:15:18notion of your email inbox is a to-do list that someone else makes for you, so
0:15:23why don't we just kind of take that to the next, you know, logical step and make
0:15:27it an actual sort of to-do list, push stuff off to do later, to bring it back, that kind
0:15:31of stuff.
0:15:32Yeah.
0:15:33And it's an interesting way of not staying too attached to your first idea and letting
0:15:38it take you to a next new idea.
0:15:42Yep.
0:15:43Don't stay too attached.
0:15:45Yep.
0:15:47So, what else?
0:15:49What do you want to do next?
0:15:50How about the Schiller interviews?
0:15:51Sure.
0:15:52So, on the eve, I guess it was actually two days before, but it's so that the articles
0:15:59would hit the day before the Galaxy S4 launch. Phil Schiller did two interviews, one with
0:16:06the Wall Street Journal, one with Reuters.
0:16:09Are we sure there were only two also? Because I know both you and I didn't see that Reuters
0:16:12one to begin with, I think.
0:16:14No, neither. No, and I think it hit later, which is weird. Maybe it was conducted later,
0:16:20too.
0:16:20And why Reuters?
0:16:21When does Apple talk to Reuters?
0:16:22Like what's going on there?
0:16:24I don't know.
0:16:25It's all a little new.
0:16:29I don't know.
0:16:31Curious?
0:16:32Yeah.
0:16:33I don't think either really went well.
0:16:35Or at least it didn't play out, I think, the way that Apple wanted to.
0:16:39Although I do think, and I think you're a little bit more – this was a mistake than
0:16:45I am.
0:16:46Right.
0:16:47But I don't want to put words in your mouth.
0:16:48But I'll just say the headlines.
0:16:49headline in the Wall Street Journal was, "In rare move, Apple goes on the defensive against
0:16:55Samsung."
0:16:56Right. That's clearly not what Apple was going for by speaking. If anything, they would want
0:17:02the opposite, right? Apple goes on the offensive.
0:17:04Exactly. Well, and that's what Reuters headline was. Reuters headline is, "Apple's Shiller
0:17:10blasts Android, Samsung on Galaxy's Eve." So at least that's, I think, the headline
0:17:16that Apple was going for.
0:17:18Yeah. I assume with the Reuters thing, the only sense I can make of it is that they knew
0:17:26that this was going to be a huge press event. I think one of the first ones that Samsung
0:17:31has done in the United States for these types of things. And so with Reuters, they wanted
0:17:36to get the biggest, widest mainstream media reach as possible, and same with Wall Street
0:17:42Journal and also a little bit more from the business perspective, I imagine.
0:17:49But it's still, I don't know. I do think it was a mistake for them to do that just because,
0:17:55in hindsight, of course, the Wall Street Journal headline is bad for them. But I also just
0:17:59think, I don't know, I don't think that they needed to do it. What's the benefit of doing
0:18:03it versus not saying anything? What ended up happening is that Samsung sort of, I think,
0:18:12everyone would agree, shot themselves in the foot
0:18:14with that kind of weird presentation.
0:18:17So if Apple had said nothing,
0:18:18it would be the same outcome, I think.
0:18:21I just don't see what the major benefit was
0:18:24of Schiller trying to talk to these guys.
0:18:26- I called it an unforced error
0:18:28because Schiller had one technical error
0:18:31in his Reuters interview where he, based on rumors,
0:18:33said that the Galaxy was gonna launch
0:18:36with a year-old operating system,
0:18:37which I think meant Android 4.1,
0:18:41It's shipped in July.
0:18:43But it doesn't.
0:18:44It's actually on the latest,
0:18:45it's the first Android phone I can ever remember
0:18:47that's other than a Nexus that's shipped
0:18:50with the currently latest version of Android,
0:18:53which is 4.2, which is from November.
0:18:56- Yeah, I assume that everyone thought
0:18:58that wouldn't be possible given they have to redesign
0:19:02or whatever touchwiz their awful interface on top of it.
0:19:07- I don't think they call it that anymore.
0:19:08Or at least they didn't mention it.
0:19:09I watched the whole presentation,
0:19:11And I don't remember that the word TouchWiz even showed up.
0:19:13I think that they're just calling it Galaxy.
0:19:17- Well, that's smart.
0:19:18That's what they should do.
0:19:19If they want to break away, it seems like all indications are they are sort of creating
0:19:24their own brand around these Galaxy phones, not mentioning Android as little as possible.
0:19:30And TouchWiz was just an awful name.
0:19:33So it's good to do Galaxy, I think.
0:19:37But yeah, I'm kind of coming around to you.
0:19:39And I thought that was the only error that Schiller made,
0:19:41is Schiller said that, and now you can pick on something
0:19:44that he said and say, "Look, that's not even true."
0:19:46And it was risky, I think,
0:19:47'cause he obviously didn't know.
0:19:49I thought maybe he had some intel on it and knew
0:19:54and attributed it to rumors that,
0:19:56"Hey, it's gonna have a year-old operating system."
0:19:58But that the only way he would have said it publicly
0:20:00is if he somehow knew, like, a source at a carrier
0:20:03or something like that. - Right.
0:20:05But it ends up that's not even true.
0:20:07- But why do you think that he did it?
0:20:09Why do you think that he's going for,
0:20:12what's he going for by saying anything?
0:20:14It just doesn't seem like the Apple we all know.
0:20:18- Well, usually what they do is if they want
0:20:22to take a little air out of,
0:20:24and it's certainly not unique to Apple,
0:20:27but everybody kind of plays this game,
0:20:28that if one of your opponent's competitors, let's say,
0:20:32is on the cusp of a big announcement,
0:20:34do something right before it to take a little air out to distract a little bit from it.
0:20:40So Apple would usually do is, I can't off the top of my head and think of it, but announce
0:20:46some sort of minor update, you know, like 10.83, but something for the iPhone.
0:20:53I don't know, a minor update to something.
0:20:55Speed bumps to the MacBook Airs, I don't know.
0:20:58Have something to announce the day of or the day before just to take some of the top spots
0:21:04at Techmeme and the equivalent. But not say anything, just announce a product and let
0:21:10you think, "Well, maybe it's a coincidence, could be." And I don't know, maybe it's that
0:21:16they had nothing to release and still wanted to somehow insert themselves into the news
0:21:23this week?
0:21:24Yeah, that strikes me as the right thought, if there is anything, if there is any strategic
0:21:32thinking here, it probably is the fact that they do usually do some sort of incremental
0:21:37update stuff right before, and they may just not have anything because we're in this very
0:21:43extended weird lull of no real product updates because they did so many at the end of last
0:21:49year.
0:21:50And the other thing, and it's loose, I can't make a completely logical cohesive argument
0:21:57for it. But I think it's loosely related to the stuff that I've been writing about lately about
0:22:02just the plain bullshit that a lot of the business press has been writing. You know, like this,
0:22:09the Reuters interview in the second paragraph where I wrote a whole piece last night about
0:22:13this, this paragraph, which is the second paragraph in the story, which is pretty
0:22:19important. The marketing chief's rare attack on arrival on the eve of the Galaxy S4's global
0:22:25premiere in New York underscores the extent of the pressure piled upon a company that
0:22:29once stood the undisputed leader of the smart phone arena, comma, so far so good, right?
0:22:37There is more pressure on Apple because they're no longer undisputed. And then the rest of
0:22:42the clause, the rest of the sentences, "But ceded its crown to Samsung in 2012." And that's
0:22:47just, again, this is a news, this is what, you know, it boggles my mind because, I mean,
0:22:53Honestly, I could maybe just skip the whole article I wrote and just point out that Apple had 70% of the profit in the industry
0:22:59last year and Samsung, you know had
0:23:0132 of it, you know, so they're both doing really well
0:23:05It's an amazing statistic that two companies have
0:23:08The entirety of the profits of the industry and that all the other companies combined are losing money
0:23:14We make Samsung and Apple share out up to over a hundred. That's pretty amazing. I think that
0:23:19it's sort of
0:23:22- If I had to guess why these stories keep happening,
0:23:25I think you're exactly right,
0:23:27and I said this in a much more subtle way,
0:23:29I even tweeted about it a few months ago,
0:23:30where it's just that the tech press is more or less bored
0:23:33because they've written the same thing
0:23:34that Apple is winning Apple,
0:23:36like oh my god, how much money is Apple making,
0:23:38all that over and over again.
0:23:40And so the only reason,
0:23:41it's almost like blogging journalism 101,
0:23:44you build something up to knock it down later.
0:23:47And there's no way to really knock Apple down
0:23:49other than to say the market share thing, right?
0:23:52I mean, there's, and it's like,
0:23:54it is sort of a silly metric when you think about it
0:23:56as compared to the profit thing,
0:23:58because what matters at the end of the day
0:24:00in how healthy a company is, is not the market share,
0:24:03even though it seems like it should be correlated
0:24:05to the actual profit and to the revenue.
0:24:10It's actually not, and so it doesn't make a lot of sense.
0:24:13And so some of these guys may be thinking
0:24:16still along the lines of the Wintel days
0:24:19And so eventually Samsung with this huge market share
0:24:23will just turn a few screws
0:24:25and really kind of drive Apple into the ground
0:24:27and then the profit will just evaporate overnight
0:24:30because of that.
0:24:32And I think that's ridiculous.
0:24:34The only way you could argue that that wasn't ridiculous
0:24:38is if somehow the carrier subsidy model
0:24:41changes in the United States,
0:24:43or if worldwide that market becomes so much more important
0:24:48and if Apple doesn't do anything
0:24:49kind of come out to more strongly meet some of the Android competition in places like
0:24:55India and China. I think that that's the only way you could make the argument that the market
0:25:00share stuff does matter, but it doesn't seem like any of that stuff is changing.
0:25:04No, and one of the points I've made in the past is that you can cheat to gain market
0:25:09share. And maybe cheating isn't quite the right word, but what you can do is take unsustainable
0:25:17like charge for a thing below costs, you know, and eventually though you've got to
0:25:24figure out a way to make money on it, you know, famously like in the console
0:25:30business of video games, like everybody knew that like when the new Xbox 360
0:25:35came out, it, Microsoft was losing money on each unit sold, right, and it was a way
0:25:42of gaining market share. But there's really no way to cheat to gain profits. So somebody
0:25:50could sell phones at cost and gain market share, but they can't sell-- there's no way
0:25:55to cheat and gain profit share. Profit share is a more accurate measure, especially over
0:26:00a long period of time. So I just sent you a link. It's from Benedict Evans.
0:26:07Twitter DM is just so great. Let me just say how wonderfully fast it is.
0:26:12It's a chart from Benedict Evans, or a couple of charts, but it's the bottom one that to me
0:26:17is more interesting, where he compares unit sold, revenue, and operating profits of three entities,
0:26:26Apple, Samsung, and all others. And this is the global handset market share.
0:26:33And I'll put it in the show links, because I think that this chart says a lot.
0:26:37And what you see is, in terms of units, other has like 60%, right?
0:26:45Apple has only 10%, real small, and Samsung has, you know, somewhere around, I don't know,
0:26:5120 to 30%.
0:26:52Then in revenue, other only has about 30, and Samsung has about 30, and Apple has about
0:27:0040.
0:27:01close to a sort of three-way tie in revenue.
0:27:05But then you look at profits, and it's the complete inverse
0:27:08of the first one.
0:27:09It's really kind of symmetric, where other has almost nothing.
0:27:14Samsung has about 30, and Apple has like 70.
0:27:23And I feel like-- so one of the things there is I feel like lazy thinkers who
0:27:27really do think that market share equates to profit share and revenue share. They understand
0:27:33Samsung because Samsung is right around 30 each way. They sell about 30% of the phones,
0:27:39make about 30% of the revenue, and make about 30% of the profit in the industry. And that
0:27:43and everybody thinks, well, that's a normal business. And then there's Apple, who's all
0:27:48over the, you know, who it's the complete inverse, they only sell 10% of the phones,
0:27:53but they get about 30, 40% of the revenue,
0:27:55but they make 70% of the profit.
0:27:58And it just doesn't register in people's minds as possible.
0:28:02And so they think it's unsustainable and then, you know.
0:28:05- You know, the other side of this
0:28:07that people have been railing on for a few years now
0:28:09is that when someone else dominates the market share,
0:28:14and in this case now, Samsung and Android overall,
0:28:19that developers will just flock to them
0:28:21And that's not sustainable for Apple because people will just go for the huge quantity
0:28:28of numbers.
0:28:29Developers will go for where the market is.
0:28:32And the problem there, as you know as well as I do, is that while yes, there is some
0:28:37legitimacy to that argument you're already seeing, you see more developers go more quickly
0:28:42to Android, they're still doing primarily iOS first, mailbox being a great example of
0:28:47that, because if you do want to do something that's an actual business and you're making
0:28:51money off of it, whether, not necessarily a venture-backed
0:28:55business even, but if you're trying to do just a small shop
0:28:58and you're making your own apps that you intend to sell,
0:29:01it's still so much better to do that within the iOS ecosystem
0:29:05than it is within Android.
0:29:06And so that plays against the market share argument as well.
0:29:11Totally.
0:29:12And another, I feel like there's so many facets here,
0:29:16but it's not that hard to understand it.
0:29:18Another one is the idea if you value market share above all else, then you're assuming
0:29:24that one user is as good as another or almost, that they're roughly equivalent.
0:29:29And they're not. It's really, especially in the phone market, it really is not true. And that's
0:29:35why, and I again, I wrote this on a branch a while back, but people don't want to say it because by
0:29:43saying that somebody is a better customer than another, right? They feel like they're coming
0:29:47dangerously close to saying they're a better person than another and that's not what I mean at all like a
0:29:52person an individual who just goes into a
0:29:55Verizon store and says just I want a new I want a new phone and gets talked into an Android, you know a droid whatever
0:30:02And just uses it to make phone calls and answer texts which which by the way
0:30:08Let me interrupt you because this is exactly the story of my father when I went to go visit him over
0:30:14Thanksgiving holidays there in Florida, my parents.
0:30:17Right.
0:30:18He pulls out this phone, and I'm like, oh, you finally
0:30:21got a new phone.
0:30:22He had a flip phone or whatever for all these years.
0:30:24He has this Android phone.
0:30:25I forget what it was.
0:30:26I tweeted about it because it was the funniest thing.
0:30:28He just says, like, I hate this fucking piece of shit.
0:30:31Because he just says--
0:30:32all he's like, all I want to do is make a phone call on this.
0:30:35So they gave me this phone.
0:30:37I picked this phone because it was the free one that Verizon
0:30:39was pushing at me.
0:30:41And he happened to know, of course, because he follows me.
0:30:44I knew that an iPhone was on the verge of being launched,
0:30:47so he got it in September or something like that.
0:30:51So I knew a new iPhone, so I didn't wanna get that one,
0:30:53even though I probably happily would've gotten that.
0:30:55I know what a big fan you are of it.
0:30:57But this was just the free one,
0:30:58and so I said, "Yeah, sure, why not?"
0:30:59And so they give this to me, and he's like,
0:31:01"God, it's got all this crap on it.
0:31:02"I don't know, there's stuff that's preloaded.
0:31:04"All I wanna do is make a phone call,
0:31:05"and they make it so hard to do that."
0:31:07So my dad is the perfect example of that.
0:31:10- Absolutely, I mean, that's canonical.
0:31:12And now he's probably not using it to browse the web.
0:31:14No.
0:31:15Right.
0:31:15Which is hilarious.
0:31:16He's not installing apps on it.
0:31:19And so yes, it counts towards Android market share.
0:31:21But it also counts away from these bizarre, seemingly
0:31:25bizarre, statistics that show that iPhone users buy way more
0:31:30apps, download way more free apps, browse the web more.
0:31:35All of these usage statistics that
0:31:37show that iPhone users use their phones more than Android
0:31:40makes them, it's because they're better customers.
0:31:42They're people who knew what they wanted.
0:31:45And the people who knew what they wanted and made a choice
0:31:47are more likely to choose an iPhone.
0:31:49And they're better customers in so far as that
0:31:51they're more willing to spend money
0:31:52because they had to spend money.
0:31:54Or you can get a free iPhone now,
0:31:56but iPhone users disproportionately buy
0:32:00the highest end model.
0:32:01The best selling iPhone isn't the free one,
0:32:04it's the iPhone 5.
0:32:07And last year the best selling iPhone was the 4S.
0:32:09The top-selling one, which is more expensive, sells more units than the $99 one from a year
0:32:16ago and the free one from two years ago.
0:32:19And the $99 one sells more units than any other phone made by anyone else, right?
0:32:24It's the top two are always, it's the iPhone 5 and then the iPhone 4S, and then it's one
0:32:28that I think the Galaxy S3, I think, was the latest stats on what the top actual smartphones
0:32:34were.
0:32:35It may have been, I don't know, I don't want to say that.
0:32:38We should look it up.
0:32:39have been that the iPhone was the top three top selling ones?
0:32:42Maybe not, but it was close.
0:32:43Yeah, it was close.
0:32:44And I think that all three are in the top five, at least
0:32:46in the United States.
0:32:47Right.
0:32:47And again, worldwide, it only accounts to Apple's--
0:32:52all iPhones only account for 10% of all phones.
0:32:54That just shows, though, how long the tail is of how
0:32:59many phones are out there.
0:33:00Right.
0:33:01That there's so many gazillion phones on the market that
0:33:05have 0.002% of the market.
0:33:08And so Google only counts the ones
0:33:11that access the Google Play Store in their statistics
0:33:13where they break down the OS stuff.
0:33:15But I think those other guys count
0:33:17all different kinds of things, the people who do the surveys
0:33:19and stuff like that.
0:33:20And someone had the great way of putting it.
0:33:23I forget who this was, but basically it's
0:33:25almost like some of those Android phones
0:33:27out there are the equivalent of dark matter, where they're
0:33:30out there and you know they're out there.
0:33:32And there are small little signals
0:33:34that indicate-- you can almost infer that they're out there,
0:33:37But there's no real direct signals because the people aren't using them in a way that
0:33:40you can measure directly.
0:33:41Right.
0:33:42I totally agree.
0:33:43And I think a big example of that is a lot of the ones in China, which are – none of
0:33:49them – I don't think or very few of them are hooked up with the regular Google Play,
0:33:55Gmail, Google Maps set of apps that Google wants Android phones to be using.
0:34:01They're all set up with the Chinese equivalents, the Baidu and whatever map service they have
0:34:08over there.
0:34:09So how long do you think until Samsung moves away from that stack, the Google stack?
0:34:16We got the news yesterday.
0:34:18I think one of the now three Samsung CEOs gave an interview with someone saying that
0:34:25their first Tizen, is that how you pronounce it, Tizen phone is coming later this year,
0:34:29So that's their own operating system that they co-develop with Intel and some others.
0:34:34How long do you think Samsung remains loyal to Google's actual stack for Android?
0:34:41I think not much longer.
0:34:43Although, honestly, I know that they're talking about Tizen.
0:34:48And this, to me, is just going on a complete hunch.
0:34:51But whenever I hear about a new OS from a company that's never shipped a computer operating
0:34:56system before. I automatically assume it is never gonna hit the light of day because it's
0:35:02just so hard and there's so few companies who have ever successfully launched an operating
0:35:08system. I mean, right now there's only three I think that are in business. There's Apple,
0:35:14there's Microsoft and now Google. And to their credit, you know, Android was new and, you
0:35:20You know, they did something very, very difficult,
0:35:24but they pulled it off.
0:35:25- Right, and it took a while for them to do it, right?
0:35:30The initial versions of Android were pretty bad.
0:35:32- I presume, though, that Tizen is never really gonna hit.
0:35:35And even if they launch a phone with it,
0:35:37it's not gonna take off.
0:35:38I think what's more likely is that they pull an Amazon
0:35:42and fork Android.
0:35:44- I totally agree.
0:35:45- And the reason for that, and do their own store,
0:35:47with their own Samsung or, they'd probably call it the Galaxy store and, you know, have
0:35:53developers submit their Android apps through the Galaxy store, do their own books and music
0:36:01and stuff like that. But the reason I think that's more likely than Tizen taking off is
0:36:07that it would be, I think it would be so much easier to get developers on board because
0:36:11just like with Amazon, you don't have to recompile your app.
0:36:14Yep. I'm not saying there's no technical differences. And that is not a pain in the
0:36:19ass to be an Android developer and to have to deal with certain differences between developing
0:36:24for the Kindle Fire HD and the, you know, I don't know, the Nexus seven or something like that. And
0:36:31going through, there might be some I'm sure there's some technical differences. But for the most part,
0:36:35though, you write your app to one of the Android API, you say, we'll go to API level 15, you know,
0:36:42which equates to, I don't know, Jelly Bean or something like that.
0:36:45Right.
0:36:46And it should work on any of these Android platforms.
0:36:50But I think that's more likely than Tizen taking off.
0:36:54Because presumably with Tizen, they would either have to have an all new API
0:36:57and get developers to totally rewrite their apps, or do something like have an Android emulation layer,
0:37:04at which point you're already going to have a massive performance problem on mobile.
0:37:10and why not just stick with Android at that point?
0:37:14- Yeah, and I think you're exactly right there
0:37:16because I also think the only way that that works,
0:37:19that Tizen will work, would be if Samsung said,
0:37:22look, we're only doing Tizen, we're gonna cut off Android
0:37:25and we're gonna cut off Windows Mobile
0:37:28because then we go back to the market share thing
0:37:30where it's like the scale of Samsung
0:37:32would still make it interesting to some developers,
0:37:35but if they're going to keep doing Android
0:37:37and that's the majority of their scale,
0:37:39would any developer kind of waste their resources, their limited resources that they already
0:37:43have on Tizen?
0:37:44Right.
0:37:45So the problem with Tizen is twofold, actually.
0:37:47One is actually shipping it, getting it to the point where it's complete enough to say
0:37:52this is a reasonable, modern mobile OS with an API for developers and everything else
0:37:58you need.
0:37:59A, I doubt that they can even pull that off.
0:38:02I really do.
0:38:04But B, even if they do, how do you get developers to write for it?
0:38:08And there's the problem that BlackBerry faces right now,
0:38:11because the new BlackBerry 10 is real.
0:38:14They shipped a real modern operating system
0:38:18that if they had shipped this exact same thing
0:38:20four or five years ago, might have set the industry on fire.
0:38:23But nobody's writing apps for it.
0:38:25And so they're stuck with this stupid idea
0:38:27of running Android apps in emulation
0:38:29or something like that, which nobody wants to do.
0:38:31- And we see it with Windows Phone.
0:38:33I mean, Microsoft has been offering to pay everyone,
0:38:35every developer I talk to these days says,
0:38:37Yeah, Microsoft's been offering to pay 10 grand or whatever
0:38:40for us to do this app.
0:38:41And it's just not that interesting to them
0:38:42because there's a number of reasons.
0:38:44First of all, it's like, yeah, we could do it
0:38:46or we could have Microsoft do it,
0:38:48but then we still have to support that app going forward.
0:38:51And it's like, we just don't have the resources to do it.
0:38:53And the scale just isn't interesting enough.
0:38:55And so even with all of Microsoft's resources
0:38:57and their cash being offered to developers,
0:39:00people still aren't doing it.
0:39:01Right.
0:39:02And so imagine if, I don't know,
0:39:05you know, it's like, so the S4 launches last night, and whatever you want to say about
0:39:11it, it's at least, at the very least, it's a better version of the S3. And the S3 is
0:39:16a well-respected phone, and it runs all the Android apps, you know, and it's, because
0:39:20it's so popular, it's not going to be overlooked by most app developers. They're going to make
0:39:25sure that their app works on the S3. They're going to make sure it works on the S4.
0:39:29Yep
0:39:31So whatever the fragmentation problems are in Android buying a galaxy s4
0:39:35You're probably gonna see the least of the fragmentation problems as a user
0:39:40Yeah, now imagine six months from now. They launched the galaxy blah blah blah
0:39:45I don't know the galaxy Tizen the galaxy T. I don't know call it something like that and it runs Tizen
0:39:50I mean it runs no apps
0:39:52I mean, I don't get it right or they if they can maybe get a couple of developers on board
0:39:57I don't know, but I don't even see them doing that.
0:39:59I mean, one of the weird things to me about last night's,
0:40:02oh, let's just call it a shit show,
0:40:05was that they had no third-party developers,
0:40:08no mention of any third-party software whatsoever.
0:40:11- Yeah.
0:40:12So two other wildcards in there,
0:40:16'cause I do think you're right,
0:40:17that if they do something,
0:40:18and if they do something and they plan to be successful,
0:40:20it is forking Android,
0:40:22because the two wildcards now are
0:40:24now are what Google's doing with Motorola,
0:40:27so rumors of the X phone or whatever it is,
0:40:30and then what Amazon is doing in the phone space.
0:40:33So they already have, of course, the Kindle tablets,
0:40:34and those have been successful to some degree at least.
0:40:38And now what they're going to do with a phone,
0:40:40which again is just rumored, but it seems like
0:40:42that's pretty likely that they're going to do that.
0:40:43And so does Samsung sit back and wait
0:40:46for those two things to happen before they fork Android
0:40:49and do their own thing, or do they preempt them?
0:40:52That's kind of the big question in my mind.
0:40:55- Yeah, I don't know.
0:40:56I'm not quite sure what they're, it's hard to tell.
0:40:59- Because it's all about being, I mean,
0:41:02if Google really does make their own flagship phone
0:41:07that's beyond Nexus, you know,
0:41:09because it's a company that they actually own,
0:41:11a Motorola phone, and they just kind of put
0:41:15their marketing muscle, they start pushing it on Google.com
0:41:19and they start to have more strained relationships
0:41:22Samsung. Samsung does not want to be in that position, obviously. One of the most interesting
0:41:26charts that you put up in your last post last night and someone else tweeted about, and I saw
0:41:32this, the notion that Samsung is making more profit off of their smartphones than Google is
0:41:41making as an entire company, which is just fascinating because all of that profit you
0:41:45have to assume for Samsung is from Android. I mean, they're probably making a little bit off
0:41:49of some of the other things.
0:41:51Yeah, because of Samsung's business, or mobile business at least, of selling anything, you
0:41:57know, everything from cheap candy bar phones to truly high-end.
0:42:01I mean, some of the Galaxy S4 models have eight core processors.
0:42:05And that's another weird thing about the Galaxy S4.
0:42:07Just as an aside, there is no single Galaxy S4, at least in a way.
0:42:11And I know there's a couple of different iPhone SKUs around the world for like different antenna
0:42:15bands, but like the system on a chip is the same.
0:42:18You get the same performance.
0:42:20Whereas depending on what country you're in,
0:42:21you get a radically different system on a chip
0:42:24with the Galaxy phones.
0:42:25Like, and apparently the US isn't getting the eight core one
0:42:29that all the spec nerds are slavering over.
0:42:33They're getting the four core. - Oh, I didn't even realize
0:42:34that. - Yeah, the US is gonna,
0:42:36ah, who knows?
0:42:38I don't know.
0:42:39This makes no sense to me.
0:42:41I don't know.
0:42:42But anyway.
0:42:42- But you have to think about that
0:42:46from Google's perspective for a second.
0:42:48They, as a company, they're a public company,
0:42:52they need to keep growing the bottom line,
0:42:53just like Apple does, just like every public company does.
0:42:57They have a company out there that is showing them
0:43:00exactly how to do that, because they're making more money
0:43:03off of a product that Google created
0:43:05than Google is making as an entire company itself.
0:43:08So at some point, you have to think
0:43:10that it's their fiduciary duty to cut that off
0:43:13and start taking that profit
0:43:15and those revenues themselves, right?
0:43:17- Right, and it hasn't, seemingly hasn't worked out
0:43:20like the PC industry did,
0:43:23where Intel and HP,
0:43:28and back in the day, Compaq,
0:43:31the people who made the PC hardware that ran Windows
0:43:36made a lot of money.
0:43:37Intel particularly, but Dell and HP and Compaq
0:43:41all had really good years making a lot of money
0:43:43selling PCs, and Microsoft made more than any of them
0:43:47by providing the operating system and software.
0:43:50And Google obviously wasn't gonna make it the same way
0:43:53by selling the software.
0:43:56- Right.
0:43:57- But I think that they assumed that by giving away
0:44:01the software but having it with all these Google services
0:44:03that they would profit as handsomely through all the ads
0:44:07that they could show and the search results and et cetera.
0:44:11And it does seem like they're doing better.
0:44:14I don't know what the numbers are off the top of my head,
0:44:16but it does seem like they are monetizing increasingly
0:44:19better on mobile, as you might expect, certainly
0:44:21with the scale again, and just getting better ads
0:44:24and getting better about figuring out
0:44:26how to do this on mobile.
0:44:28But it's nowhere near the profit that Samsung
0:44:31is seeing by selling devices.
0:44:33No, definitely.
0:44:34It's not even close, I think.
0:44:37And it's a little hard with Samsung,
0:44:39because Samsung doesn't reveal
0:44:43their handset sales numbers at all,
0:44:45famously stopped a while back.
0:44:46So they don't say how many Galaxy phones have been sold.
0:44:49And so whenever you do see a comparison of,
0:44:52and I think it's an important thing
0:44:55that's always overlooked is,
0:44:57when you see a comparison between how many iPhone 5s
0:45:02were sold last quarter and how many Galaxy 4s were sold
0:45:08in the same quarter.
0:45:09The number for the iPhones comes from Apple
0:45:13in an SCC filing.
0:45:14That is like, they're legally mandated to tell the truth.
0:45:18Well, although I guess Apple, does Apple,
0:45:21I guess Apple doesn't break down by--
0:45:23- Yeah, they just say iPhones overall.
0:45:25- All right, iPhones overall.
0:45:26But at least there's a legal number.
0:45:28Whereas what Samsung does is nothing.
0:45:32It's all based on analyst conjecture.
0:45:34- Right.
0:45:35- And the analyst says it was this many.
0:45:37You can kind of back it out with Apple though
0:45:41by based on average, they do reveal
0:45:43the average selling price.
0:45:45And so you can kind of make a reasonable informed guess.
0:45:49Whereas the analyst numbers really seem like
0:45:51they're just pulled out of the air for Samsung.
0:45:54But what they do give is a number for their entire
0:45:57mobile and telecom division.
0:45:59Now they sell some other stuff from that division
0:46:02other than mobile phones, but I can't believe
0:46:05that it's that much to make that big of a dent.
0:46:08And that division made more profit last quarter
0:46:11than all of Google.
0:46:12- That is crazy and untenable, I think,
0:46:17for the Google-Samsung relationship.
0:46:19- So I wanna do, let me do another sponsor break,
0:46:23but let's parlay after the break,
0:46:25let's go and talk about what that means
0:46:27with the Andy Rubin news.
0:46:28Think about that.
0:46:29So a second sponsor that I wanna thank
0:46:31is I wanna thank Pixelmator,
0:46:34or as we call it here Pixelmator.
0:46:37And what they want me to tell you about is their new version,
0:46:40Pixelmator 2.2 Blueberry.
0:46:43It's not out yet, coming out at the end of March.
0:46:46I kind of can't believe they're calling it 2.2.
0:46:47This really seems like a 3.0.
0:46:50Because what they've done is they've added a ton of new vector shape
0:46:54features.
0:46:55And it's really sort of adding almost
0:46:58like a vector/illustrator type aspect to the app going way beyond just pixel image editing.
0:47:10Really great state of the art shape tools that let you create gorgeous compositions.
0:47:14You can use it for things like logos, posters, web layouts, easy to use drawing tools.
0:47:25is familiar with vector based drawing tools from other apps is going to find a
0:47:30lot of stuff in there that's exactly the same. All sorts of shapes, rectangles,
0:47:35ellipses, rounded rectangles, polygons, lines, all of these things are vector not
0:47:40pixel. You've got fill, stroke, shadow, modes, shape settings, you can assign
0:47:48shape styles, create a style for a shape, save it as a saved almost like a like a
0:47:53a style sheet, then create a new shape and then instantly apply the style that
0:47:57you painstakingly made for the first one.
0:48:01Smart shapes have easy to use controls that let you quickly adjust the
0:48:06shapes outline to get just the look that you're after. Custom shapes, I mean it's
0:48:12these things look like hand-drawn icons but they're vector so they scale. The
0:48:18The other thing they have is shape sharing.
0:48:21So when you create a new custom shape, you can export it, drag them out to the desktop,
0:48:26send it to your friend.
0:48:27Your friend drags it into their shapes palette and they've got the shape that you made over
0:48:32on your machine.
0:48:34It's a really great feature.
0:48:36I really, like I said, I cannot believe that they're calling it a 2.2 instead of a 3.0
0:48:40with all of this stuff.
0:48:42They've also added a whole bunch of other improvements.
0:48:44They've improved their type tool.
0:48:47improved their gradient presets, all sorts of performance upgrades. So go check it out
0:48:54at pixelmator.com. P-I-X-E-L-M-A-T-O-R dot com. And get Pixelmator.
0:49:08I'm a big fan of Pixelmator. Mator. Whatever you want to call it.
0:49:11Pixelmator. Don't let me throw you off. It's really Pixelmator.
0:49:13Yeah.
0:49:14It's now, it's, I mean, how can I not stick
0:49:17with the running gag?
0:49:18- Yeah. - It is, it's a phenomenal app.
0:49:20- Yep.
0:49:21So Andy Rubin.
0:49:24- Andy Rubin.
0:49:25So,
0:49:26is it a bombshell?
0:49:30I think it's a bombshell.
0:49:31- Yeah. - Although I'm not
0:49:32as juiced into Google as--
0:49:34- So my understanding is, and I've talked to a few people
0:49:38about this now, this was a complete surprise
0:49:42pretty much across the company.
0:49:44I think a few people probably knew about it in the days leading up to it, but certainly not the weeks.
0:49:49And just look at his schedule. He was scheduled to talk at the D11 conference and all these other places.
0:49:55Far in the future, obviously, on behalf of Android.
0:50:00Now he's no longer going to be speaking on behalf of Android because he's no longer doing that.
0:50:05I didn't know that. So is he taking off the D11 conference?
0:50:09I don't know. I actually don't know what's going on with that. I don't know if they would
0:50:12put, yeah, maybe they put in Sundar, the guy who took over for him.
0:50:16That would be interesting to see.
0:50:17Yeah. But yes, the understanding is that this was a huge shock within the company as well.
0:50:22I always thought that within Google, and it's curious that they had these two post-PC
0:50:30operating systems, Android and Chrome OS. And I always thought it was sort of,
0:50:37I think you're going to love this.
0:50:38You're going to love this.
0:50:39It's sort of like the scene in the Batman movie with the Joker where the Joker goes
0:50:45into the black guy's gang pretending to be dead, pops out of the bag, kills the leader,
0:50:51and there's two guys left.
0:50:53He snaps a Q stick in half and says, "We've got room for one more guy in our gang," and
0:50:59throws the pool sticks.
0:51:00Right?
0:51:01I've always thought that was Chrome versus Android, that they've got room for one post-PC
0:51:06operating system, you two guys fight it out. Right. And now, so you know, following that
0:51:14along, it looks like Chrome OS in some way won, at least their leader won, because now
0:51:21he's in charge of both. Right, and I guess the surprising thing to me is that it seems
0:51:25to me like Android is the one that's doing better, but maybe that's because I've been
0:51:29blinded by pure market share, right? Because there's a gazillion Android things out there,
0:51:34and nowhere near as many Chrome OS devices.
0:51:37Right.
0:51:37Yeah, I don't know.
0:51:38I think that-- I do--
0:51:40I mean, I think there's no question
0:51:42that Android is doing significantly better than Chrome
0:51:44OS.
0:51:45It is curious, though, as to why they would do that.
0:51:48Part of it is maybe the fact that Sundar Pichai, who's
0:51:55going to be the new head of both units,
0:51:58is very well regarded within Google.
0:52:00Everyone I've talked to loves him.
0:52:01I've met him a few times.
0:52:02He's a really nice guy, really level-headed.
0:52:05We got into it, I used to get into it with him
0:52:08over bundling Flash and Chrome,
0:52:11how they automatically, they make you download it
0:52:14and automatically enable it.
0:52:16He's just like, he would give his viewpoint,
0:52:20I'd give mine, we'd disagree,
0:52:21but he was very open-minded and very thoughtful
0:52:23about the way that he would think about all this stuff
0:52:25and the fact that he would come in
0:52:26to have these conversations,
0:52:28just with some random blogger at the time
0:52:31to kind of talk about some of these bigger ideas.
0:52:35So I think part of it is that he's very well regarded.
0:52:38And also remember, there were those stories,
0:52:40I guess it was last year,
0:52:41maybe even almost two years ago now,
0:52:43where he was sort of one of the guys
0:52:46who was being hotly recruited by almost every startup.
0:52:49I think the reports were that Twitter was trying
0:52:52to hire him and I think it was actually Mike Arrington
0:52:55who broke the news that in order to keep Sundar around,
0:52:59and they gave him something like 50, 75 million dollars
0:53:02worth of restricted stock or something like that.
0:53:07And so I think that he's clearly someone
0:53:11that Google really wanted to keep around
0:53:13and really wanted to make happy
0:53:14and again is really highly regarded.
0:53:16And while Chrome OS may not be setting the world on fire,
0:53:19Chrome certainly has.
0:53:21It's the largest browser in the world now
0:53:23which is pretty remarkable.
0:53:25And so why not just put a fresh set of eyes on it?
0:53:28That's kind of the only thing I can imagine is going on.
0:53:32I doubt that Andy Rubin was pushed out in a bad way.
0:53:40I mean, he is saying--
0:53:41Like in a forestall way.
0:53:42Yeah, because he is staying with the company.
0:53:44It's not announced what he's doing yet,
0:53:46but it seems like he's going to stay there.
0:53:49And there may have been some sort of,
0:53:54let's just get a fresh set of eyes on this thing.
0:53:56You've been doing it for a long time.
0:53:58I think either somebody's going to find out.
0:54:01Either it'll leak and we'll find out sooner or we'll have to wait and see what Andy Rubin
0:54:06does.
0:54:07Because on the one hand, yeah, it could be that he wasn't quite pushed and maybe he was
0:54:10bored and maybe he really does have a new idea for a new thing.
0:54:15He really wants to just start from scratch in the Google X incubator.
0:54:22So maybe he really – this is all – we're reading too much into it and Andy Rubin really
0:54:26he just said, "I'm kind of done with this.
0:54:28"This is feeling like a chore.
0:54:30"I wanna go do something new."
0:54:32- Right.
0:54:33- And Larry Page is like, "That's great, have at it."
0:54:36And Sundar, you take over, we totally trust you.
0:54:41On the other hand though, if he was kind of pushed,
0:54:45then maybe going to Google X is the Google equivalent
0:54:50of serving as an advisor to Tim Cook, right?
0:54:54- Right.
0:54:55Because I don't even know, like, Forstall technically might still be, I don't know
0:55:01how long that lasts.
0:55:02Like, I never quite noticed when, you know, that's what they did to Tony Fidell.
0:55:05Right.
0:55:06How long was he actually there?
0:55:07Yeah.
0:55:08Right.
0:55:09And they never really, it's like a gradient that just sort of feeds away.
0:55:12They don't put out a press release saying, "Tony Fidell has stopped being a special
0:55:15advisor to Steve Jobs now."
0:55:17Right.
0:55:18And then, you know, all of a sudden, two years later, Ness comes out and is like, "Oh, yeah,
0:55:22whatever happened to Tony Fidell?
0:55:23When did he stop being a special advisor?"
0:55:25So, like, I'm pretty sure, though, that Scott Forstall is still technically a full-time
0:55:30Apple employee who's a special advisor to Tim Cook, who, you know, never comes in and
0:55:35never advises Tim Cook.
0:55:37So maybe that's the equivalent.
0:55:39I don't know.
0:55:40We'll see.
0:55:41Because, like, what have—you know, let's see if Andy Rubin is still at Google a year
0:55:44from now.
0:55:45I really—I have no clue.
0:55:46My guess is that I think that he is going to do something else within Google, but that's
0:55:52just a pure guess.
0:55:53My other thought, which again is based on nothing,
0:55:56is that I could see that this played out in a way
0:56:00where Larry Page has taken over control of the company
0:56:04for however long it's been now.
0:56:06It's been two years, it's been a year and something.
0:56:10So his thing was all about kind of streamlining
0:56:13the processes, getting everyone on the same page,
0:56:16and cutting off some of the bureaucracy.
0:56:20And so a lot of indications about Andy Rubin
0:56:23were that while people who were under him
0:56:26loved working for him, and he was obviously a brilliant guy
0:56:30and did a great job with Android,
0:56:31he wasn't the easiest person to get along with,
0:56:33and there were a lot of politics involved
0:56:35within the Android system.
0:56:37Just look how long it took to get Chrome on Android.
0:56:39Why was there a different browser for all that time?
0:56:42- No, and that was, you probably even know this better,
0:56:46in fact, I know that you know it better than I do,
0:56:47but even I know that that was a political thing
0:56:50within the company.
0:56:51There was, and it was like possibly between Andy and Sundar.
0:56:56- Sundar, it could have been, I don't know.
0:56:57- But it was definitely that they had,
0:56:59the Chrome guys had a version of Chrome
0:57:02that ran on Android better than the Android
0:57:05just blandly named browser.
0:57:07- Right.
0:57:08- Way long before they put it into Android.
0:57:11Like, it really did seem a little--
0:57:14- And I think that Chrome Android team is still separate
0:57:19from the Android team itself,
0:57:22and that will obviously change under Sundar.
0:57:24But so anyway, I think that,
0:57:26I do think that I could see how that is,
0:57:30is the situation that went down.
0:57:32It was just, you know, everything's going great,
0:57:35but things are still a little bit too political.
0:57:37We really, we have this rocket ship,
0:57:39we don't wanna slow it down at all.
0:57:42You know, if you're open to it, you know, you can,
0:57:45we'd love to have you do something else within Google,
0:57:49and love to have you stick around,
0:57:50but maybe we can just really see where we can take this now
0:57:54with the foundation that you've built for it.
0:57:56And another part is, I pulled this up
0:57:58when you mentioned we were going to be talking
0:58:01about the Andy Rubin thing.
0:58:03So I would imagine that he's probably not been
0:58:08the best person to work with from a negotiating standpoint
0:58:12with the carriers, just look at the fact that,
0:58:14remember it was in May 2011 at I/O,
0:58:17and we're coming up on the next Google I/O now.
0:58:19It was made 2011, so two years ago,
0:58:22that Google announced their Android update initiative,
0:58:26where they were gonna have all of the Android partners
0:58:29were going to commit to getting the newest version
0:58:33of Android on the Android devices within 18 months.
0:58:36This was the promise, this was set on stage,
0:58:38Andy Rubin announced this, and it was a big deal.
0:58:41We haven't heard a word about it since.
0:58:43And no one's really called them out for it,
0:58:46which is sort of--
0:58:47in order to worry about it and clearly has not come true.
0:58:49And clearly has not come true, right.
0:58:51And so that's another part of it maybe
0:58:55that Google realizes that coming up,
0:58:58now that they have Motorola under their wing,
0:59:01if they're going to keep kind of operating
0:59:06within with these carriers and with worldwide carriers,
0:59:09they really need a force that's not so abrasive
0:59:13towards working with these guys.
0:59:16- That could be.
0:59:17And if this is all true, it is perhaps oddly parallel
0:59:22to the Forstall situation at Apple.
0:59:27Internal politics, a sort of hard to get a great leader
0:59:32and clearly successful over the last few years,
0:59:35but hard to get along with.
0:59:37- Yeah, and like just silos his team
0:59:42into a fiefdom of sorts.
0:59:44and replaced by somebody who is seemingly better
0:59:49to get along with.
0:59:50At least at Apple, Federighi is who I'm thinking
0:59:52he's replaced him on a technical side.
0:59:54Johnny Ive, I don't know, I've never heard anything
0:59:56about what it's like to get along with him.
0:59:58Although he doesn't really seem confrontational.
1:00:00- Right.
1:00:01- He clearly has very high standards,
1:00:02but I've never heard anybody call him an asshole.
1:00:07- Right.
1:00:08Yeah, what's weird about the Ive thing taking over
1:00:11is that he really doesn't like to be on stage, right?
1:00:14So he never does that.
1:00:15He does the video stuff, but he does not be on stage.
1:00:17And Forstalt was always on stage, though.
1:00:19It's interesting.
1:00:21But yeah, so going back to Reuben,
1:00:23again, that's all pure speculation.
1:00:25But I wouldn't be shocked if it was something
1:00:28along those lines.
1:00:29Because it's just like you think about what the--
1:00:32kind of logically what the most obvious answer is,
1:00:34something like that.
1:00:35There could have been some bombshell.
1:00:37Maybe something happened.
1:00:38Maybe some partner deal got badly screwed up
1:00:40that we'll hear about or something like that.
1:00:42Do you think the timing on that announcement
1:00:45is a little weird with regard to it coming
1:00:48on the eve of the Galaxy S4?
1:00:51- Yeah, it is. - Is that sort of,
1:00:52is that sort of the Google equivalent
1:00:54of the Phil Schiller interviews of,
1:00:55let's take some piss out of Samsung's thing?
1:00:58- Huh, that's interesting.
1:00:59I hadn't really thought about that.
1:01:01Yeah, the timing is strange,
1:01:05just because it seems like there's nothing,
1:01:08there's no other reason to announce it then
1:01:10and for that change to happen then, right?
1:01:12other than this is the only Android-related thing
1:01:15that's coming up, right?
1:01:17- Right.
1:01:18- It didn't work.
1:01:19- Well, and it's possible, yeah.
1:01:21You know, and it kind of got looped into,
1:01:24and we can come back to this later if we have a little time,
1:01:26but there were a whole bunch of Google,
1:01:27we're making some changes this week, announcements,
1:01:31you know, stuff with their calendar API,
1:01:33big one that everybody listening to the show
1:01:35probably wants to know about is that they've,
1:01:36they're shit canning Google Reader come July.
1:01:40But they mixed, the official Google blogs had this post
1:01:44with like, here's the eight changes we're making.
1:01:46And they just like threw some of these things in the middle.
1:01:48It's like, oh, we're changing our calendar API.
1:01:51Oh, and by the way, Andy Rubin is no longer leaving Android.
1:01:53- Right, that would have been a great
1:01:54bullet point number four or whatever.
1:01:56- Right, our search results are 2% faster.
1:01:59Oh, by the way, Google Reader is gonna be dead in July.
1:02:02But I can't help but think that, I don't know.
1:02:06And I do think it comes down to like that observation
1:02:09that Samsung's making more from Android.
1:02:14And there was the Wall Street Journal story
1:02:15that this is a major concern that maybe Samsung
1:02:18is usurping Android from Google.
1:02:21- Right.
1:02:22- That that might be a problem.
1:02:23That as popular as Android is,
1:02:27it may not be as it's evolving as aligned
1:02:30with Google's interests as Chrome and Chrome OS are.
1:02:34- Right.
1:02:36maybe Andrew Rubin is going to become the fourth CEO of Samsung.
1:02:45So what about the Galaxy S4 event? Did you watch it?
1:02:48No, I didn't watch it. I was following along with the tweet stream. I didn't watch the
1:02:53live stream of it, though. So I didn't actually get to experience firsthand what a fiasco
1:02:58was, but I read a lot of the coverage of it, and sort of talking about how it was sort
1:03:02of sexist in a way misogynist and not just yeah in a lot of ways but well the one thing good thing
1:03:10i can say about it is that it was an hour long yeah so short yeah it it's really bizarre i mean
1:03:20it i saw a couple people on twitter say the same thing that it's you know that it the the that
1:03:25bizarre Qualcomm CES keynote. Had a short life as the weirdest tech keynote.
1:03:36Did they have jugglers or something?
1:03:38I didn't see, what, CES or the Samsung one?
1:03:42The Samsung one.
1:03:43No, they didn't see jugglers. They might have. My eyes started getting blinky. But
1:03:47they had this. It was in Radio City Music Hall, and they had a big orchestra and a lot of
1:03:53Broadway-style theatrics.
1:03:57But then it opened with a lot of specs.
1:04:02It opened with the president of the company coming out--
1:04:05I forget his name-- but he came out and just sort of introduced
1:04:10all the features they were going to talk about, but said nothing about them.
1:04:13He just sort of read the H1 level outline of the new features
1:04:18they were going to introduce and said that--
1:04:21leading innovation and thank you very much and got off the stage.
1:04:24And you know, and I think, I don't know, I think he wanted to come out, but English is
1:04:29clearly a second language, so he wasn't going to be able to emcee the show.
1:04:34The emcee was some actor, I don't know what his name is, something Chase, but he is, you
1:04:38know, he's not famous, he's just like a stage actor.
1:04:41Okay.
1:04:42Fifteen minutes of specs, him, this actor talking to Samsung America's equivalent of
1:04:48Phil Schiller, I guess, VP of marketing.
1:04:51and talking about specs.
1:04:53And then, like that's about 15 minutes.
1:05:00So far, so good.
1:05:01Not really weird, it is sort of the opposite
1:05:03of the way Apple does shows,
1:05:04where Apple does shows and talks about features,
1:05:07and then at the end will tell you the specs
1:05:11that they want to reveal.
1:05:12Like the specs is sort of the one sheet
1:05:14that they give you at the end of the show.
1:05:16Like, you know, and here's the price,
1:05:17and here's the, you know,
1:05:19here's the carriers that we're gonna be on,
1:05:21here's the bands of you know such and such that we're going to support blah blah blah get off
1:05:25they did the specs first then 15 minutes in they just they said they're going to switch
1:05:30they're going to tell us about the phone with a series of skits and they and and it was just
1:05:39they kept getting weirder and weirder where the first one is is i think it was the first one but
1:05:45but it's like here's an elementary school in New York
1:05:48and they're having the school play
1:05:50and here's a girl and there's a little girl
1:05:53on stage dancing and her dad doesn't have a Galaxy S4
1:05:57so the pictures he's taking won't be 13 megabytes.
1:06:01And all of a sudden the girl breaks out of character
1:06:04and comes out and addresses the MC and says, "What?"
1:06:08And then she turns to her dad and berates him
1:06:11for not having a 13 megapixel S4
1:06:14and why is she practiced?
1:06:17And it's like--
1:06:18- Oh, God, that sounds awful.
1:06:20- Right, it's an awful child.
1:06:22What kind of a child would do this?
1:06:24It's an awful, awful bratty spoiled child,
1:06:29and the dad is apologizing,
1:06:31and he instantly apologizes to his daughter and says,
1:06:34"Don't worry, I'm gonna get an S4 tomorrow,
1:06:37"and our next show I'll have these great S4 pictures."
1:06:42- So it's like--
1:06:43I gotta watch this now.
1:06:44So is this like, is this a cultural thing?
1:06:46Is this something that's poorly translated
1:06:47from like South Korean into American culture?
1:06:50- Somebody Twittered me and said,
1:06:52and is somebody on Twitter who I think is Korean
1:06:56or South Korean and said that it clearly to him
1:06:59seems like it was written by South Koreans
1:07:02and just translated to English.
1:07:04Although I don't know, is that right?
1:07:05That in Korea, your father expects his 13 year old girl
1:07:09to berate him publicly?
1:07:10I don't know.
1:07:11(laughing)
1:07:13I don't know how long I'm going, but next was this boy, and it's the same boy who was
1:07:20in their little commercials, and he was tap dancing earlier in the show, or I guess he
1:07:25was tap dancing on the thing.
1:07:27The gimmick with his parents was that they're using this new picture-in-picture photo thing,
1:07:32which seems terrible to me.
1:07:34But the idea is that the major new feature – one of the major new features they're
1:07:37to advertise is that when you the dad are taking pictures instead of just your wife and kids in the
1:07:46picture you can get in the corner just like when you do a Skype chat or a video chat there's in the
1:07:52corner from the front facing camera your face shows up too. And you can take a picture that
1:07:58way so that you can be in the picture but if you really consider that being in the picture I mean
1:08:04I heard it was more along the lines of like, you're watching a sports moment and then you
1:08:09take a picture of your reaction shot along with whatever just happened.
1:08:11I guess that makes more sense than what they were showing.
1:08:14Yeah.
1:08:14There was the school, I forget, I really started getting just boggled my mind.
1:08:22A weird one was the act, then they said, "We've shown," they'd showed something else,
1:08:27and then the actor said, the guy who was the MC said, "All right, we've shown you
1:08:31what the Galaxy S4 means to normal people. And he says, "Let's see what it's like for someone who's
1:08:38really special, a New York City actor." And he took a role. But it's like, what kind of attitude is
1:08:45that? Like, you've just slagged your customers and said, "You know, moms and dads, you know,
1:08:50you guys are boring. Let's see how it affects me, an awesome actor." And we're supposed to all of a
1:08:56sudden the set is supposed to be his New York City apartment and out of the ground in the stage rises
1:09:04a red convertible sports car. But I swear to you it's on its side. It is sideways. And the actor,
1:09:14and everybody looked at it and he pointed to it and he goes, "Hey, hey, you know, parking's tight
1:09:19in New York City." And that was the only explanation for why the car was on its side.
1:09:23I can only assume that it was because whatever elevator they had on the stage wasn't wide enough for the car to come up
1:09:29Right way so rather than not have the car they had the car come up sideways
1:09:34Why did they just cut the car in half?
1:09:36And then he had like this incredibly ignorant conversation with his agent
1:09:44I have to watch this thing now the guy also honest to God
1:09:51This is like when he was like talking about like the family using the s4 to do something
1:09:55The MC would literally say let's go back to our fake family and see how they use
1:10:01The new video thing in the phone or whatever, but he'd just say let's go back to our fake family. I
1:10:07Almost wish I went to this now. I would have loved a live tweet during I
1:10:11Kind of do wish I was I literally was there
1:10:15I think it would have been something to see but then the one that really got me the one that like really made me almost
1:10:19break out just watching it at home into a flop sweat was this bridal party in
1:10:26Miami and the the skit was about five or six women who have been longtime friends
1:10:32one of them is getting married this weekend and they're having her bridal
1:10:35shower and and they're talking about all the things they love about the galaxy s4
1:10:43and the different cases that they have.
1:10:46And it was so sexist, it was ridiculous.
1:10:52And these women are interested in things like calories
1:10:56and losing weight and marrying doctors.
1:11:01Right, when they found out about the health features,
1:11:05these health tracking features in the phone,
1:11:06the one woman says, "My mother always wanted me
1:11:09"to marry a doctor.
1:11:10"Well, this is the next best thing."
1:11:12And then the actor breaks into an immediate disclaimer that they just cut to the actor
1:11:17who's the emcee and he goes, "The Galaxy S4 is no replacement for a medical doctor."
1:11:21I swear to you.
1:11:24And then they go back to them.
1:11:26And then there's one of the women, and I know that Molly Wood from CNET really just
1:11:30ripped it apart, and I linked to it today, and she just ripped this thing apart perfectly.
1:11:33But she described the one of these women as the comically drunk cougar.
1:11:42And there's literally no exaggeration.
1:11:45And it is not like, oh, she exaggerated
1:11:48for the point of criticizing.
1:11:49(laughing)
1:11:50It was a woman, older, I'd say in her mid-40s
1:11:54or something like that, with a drink in her hand
1:11:57and her Galaxy S4 in the other,
1:11:59and they were talking about this new feature
1:12:00they have, this no-touch tracking,
1:12:02where you can kind of just point your finger at the screen.
1:12:04Let's see how it works.
1:12:05I mean, we have no idea.
1:12:06But anyway, but they were talking about
1:12:07why you would wanna use it, and her reason was
1:12:09she didn't wanna put her drink down.
1:12:11(laughing)
1:12:13And then they used her for this eye tracking feature.
1:12:17Now this features is supposed to be that
1:12:19like when you're reading an article,
1:12:20if you look down, the screen is gonna start
1:12:23scrolling automatically.
1:12:25And if you're watching a movie or a video
1:12:27and you look away from the screen,
1:12:29it will pause instantly.
1:12:31And then when you look back, it will go.
1:12:33And I swear to you, I'm not making this up.
1:12:36He called her over, her character's name was Dee Dee.
1:12:38He goes, Dee Dee, come on over here.
1:12:40and she's still got a drink in her hand, so she's watching the movie.
1:12:45And a greenskeeper comes out, a young, looked latina.
1:12:51They said that these women were all in Miami.
1:12:53Young Latino stud comes out with a leaf blower, and that's what catches her eye and takes
1:13:01her away from the movie.
1:13:02She's watching this younger, very attractive man, and she's sort of stunned.
1:13:09then he the MC has to remind her that she has to look back at the screen to
1:13:13pretend that the video starts playing again and she says oh yeah and then she
1:13:17does it and then the guy takes his shirt off and she immediately looks over at
1:13:21him again like in awe oh my god well I mean you really have to see it to
1:13:28believe and I guess you know maybe the explanation I've heard is that that sort
1:13:32of thing is considered like that's what a typical TV show is like in South Korea
1:13:37But I don't know anything about that.
1:13:40So just compare and contrast that to, you know, like, I think we both really like the
1:13:47one unveiling that Apple did where it was of the iPad, and it's just Steve Jobs on stage
1:13:52with a chair.
1:13:53It's like, could it be any more different than what you're describing right there?
1:13:58Right.
1:13:59And they did introduce, the other thing is that they introduced a bunch of features.
1:14:03And I'm not going to judge them because I haven't used them.
1:14:07And they didn't even really show them.
1:14:08They just talked about them.
1:14:10So with this eye tracking feature, they didn't actually show it working.
1:14:16I doubt that the woman's phone really was even on.
1:14:18I think she was just pantomiming it.
1:14:20There was no video that you could see on a screen showing it in actual use or anything
1:14:25like that.
1:14:26You just had to pretend that these things were working.
1:14:28And they just had characters pointing fingers at it.
1:14:31But they gave each one of them like 30 seconds.
1:14:34They introduced like eight features
1:14:36and gave none of the features any breathing room
1:14:39to actually understand how it would actually work.
1:14:42- That sounds amazing.
1:14:45Talk about the finger tracking thing.
1:14:50Like you said a woman didn't want to put down her drink.
1:14:53Why is that a good feature for a phone?
1:14:55When will that be useful?
1:14:57- I don't know.
1:14:59It sounds to me terrible.
1:15:01Again, I'm not going to prejudge it and say that it is terrible,
1:15:04but it sounds terrible to me.
1:15:06I guess one of the explanations that it makes the phone easier
1:15:08to use with gloves, that you could point a gloved finger at it
1:15:13and scroll the screen.
1:15:14But even in the brief demo they showed that,
1:15:18it seemed to work about as well as you think it would.
1:15:21Like, it was nowhere near tracking the finger
1:15:23the way a finger on the actual glass tracks the scrolling.
1:15:29And so I love the dichotomy here of a lot of people
1:15:34in the media giving Apple a hard time
1:15:36because they haven't come out with new
1:15:37and innovative features.
1:15:39You know, what are deemed like giant tent pole features
1:15:42is the thing.
1:15:43And look at what the S4 has.
1:15:45It's finger tracking.
1:15:47Like what is that?
1:15:48Who spends time working on that?
1:15:51And why on earth does anyone think that that's going
1:15:53to be a really selling point of that device?
1:15:57Well, and the one that struck me was one of the examples they gave.
1:16:00I guess cold weather with gloves is one where you can't touch.
1:16:03And the one where the woman had a drink in her hand, why not just use your thumb on your
1:16:09other hand, except for the fact that because the phone is five inches big, it's not good
1:16:14for one-handed use, right?
1:16:15Like I mean, again, I'm biased.
1:16:17I really like the smaller size of the iPhone.
1:16:20I've tried five-inch phones.
1:16:21Really don't like them very much specifically because I do – I use my iPhone one-handed
1:16:25a lot.
1:16:26But that seemed like if you have a drink in one hand and still want to use your phone
1:16:30in the other, it seems like, you know, just use your thumb.
1:16:34I joked on Twitter that it's great if you're murdering someone and you have blood all over
1:16:38your hands and then you can just – and that – you can still use your phone afterwards.
1:16:42So that's good.
1:16:43And you don't have to clean it up afterwards.
1:16:49Let me do our last sponsor real quick and then we'll talk about Google Reader.
1:16:51Sure.
1:16:52And our last sponsor is Studio Neat.
1:16:54These are the guys behind the Glyph, a bunch of other great products.
1:16:58Well, their newest product is an iPhone app called Simple Bracket.
1:17:02I'll bet you've heard of this, MG.
1:17:04It's an iPhone app for filling in your March Madness NCAA college basketball brackets and
1:17:10competing with friends and family.
1:17:14Super easy to log in.
1:17:15How do you identify yourself to your friends and family?
1:17:17It's easy.
1:17:18You log in with your Twitter ID and it's built right into the iOS.
1:17:21You don't even have to enter your password.
1:17:23you just authorize it to use one of your Twitter accounts that you've already got set up in
1:17:26iOS. It has a beautiful UI. I mean, you know, everybody knows I'm a huge fan of Futura.
1:17:30These guys know how to use Futura. And I think they've done some really innovative thinking
1:17:37with the way that the actual brackets, anybody out there who knows what I'm talking about,
1:17:41filling in the NCAA brackets, knows what I'm talking about. There's like a standard look
1:17:45to them. Those of you out there who have no idea what an NCAA, what the NCAA tournament
1:17:49is this app is probably not going to be of interest to you.
1:17:52But if you know what the tournament is, you've got to check it out.
1:17:54And I think they've done something really clever with the way the bracket is laid out
1:17:58where the traditional layout would, you think, "Ah, I don't see how that would fit on an
1:18:02iPhone screen."
1:18:03Well, they thought the same thing and they've come out with a really neat layout.
1:18:06I think it works perfect for something as complicated as a 64-team elimination bracket.
1:18:13Really, really clever user interface and layout.
1:18:18They've got their own scoring system and it's – how do you judge who wins one of these
1:18:23bracket tournaments?
1:18:24Well, they went to a mathematician and got a new formula for computing the winner and
1:18:28it gives proper weight to upset picks based on the probability of outcome.
1:18:33So in other words, if you pick a bunch of upsets, you get more credit than someone who
1:18:38maybe had the same number of wins in the first round but their wins were all from favorites,
1:18:43which to me does seem fair.
1:18:46It's available now. Just go to the App Store, search for Simple Bracket. It's one
1:18:52buck, which is unbelievable to me because I think it's a great app and everybody
1:18:56who's going to use it, you know what you're going to do. You're going to bet
1:18:58in pools way more than a buck. Well, you can use this to manage your pool and, you
1:19:03know, gambling is not legal in your state. I did not tell you to do it. No, but you can use it. You can
1:19:09set up your own pools with your friends and invite people. It all gets managed
1:19:12through this app. If you're going to set up a pool and everybody in pool has an iPhone,
1:19:17I mean, I can't imagine a better way to do it. It's a lot of fun. You could even do it
1:19:21for fun without the gambling. Grab the app now, though, because the teams are going to
1:19:26be announced on Sunday and you're going to want to have it by then to start making your
1:19:31picks. So go to the app store, search for Simple Bracket if you have any interest in
1:19:35the NCAA tournament. And my thanks to Studio Neat.
1:19:38neat.
1:19:39You like the NCAA tournament?
1:19:42Yes, though. I know Michigan, where I went to school, they just lost today in the Big
1:19:47Ten tournament, so I'm not thrilled about that, but they'll still be a relatively
1:19:50high seed in the NCAA tournament, so I'm excited for it.
1:19:54You do the same thing I do. My favorite team—the school I went to, Drexel, they're seldom
1:19:59in the tournament, although when they are, it's very exciting. But my favorite big
1:20:02name team has always been North Carolina. And so I always, whenever I fill out my bracket,
1:20:07The first thing I do is just fill in North Carolina right through to the end.
1:20:10It doesn't matter whether they're having a good season or a bad season.
1:20:13I always fill them into the end, and I've never once not done it.
1:20:16And here's the reason why for me is because I'm less interested in winning the thing
1:20:21than I am in the agony I would cause myself if I didn't pick them and they actually
1:20:27won.
1:20:28I would think, "How can I doubt my own favorite team?"
1:20:30So I always just start by just filling them in right to the end.
1:20:33And then I go back and start filling in all the other ones.
1:20:36Yeah.
1:20:37Do you do the same thing with Michigan?
1:20:38Yeah.
1:20:39Unfortunately, Michigan has been awful for about a decade because they were on probation
1:20:42for the whole Chris Webber, Fab Five type stuff, including when I was at school.
1:20:48So they're finally good again.
1:20:49So I'm excited for the tournament this year now that they're good again.
1:20:52Now that they are in the tournament, they were there last year, but now that I can actually
1:20:55fill them in for the bracket.
1:20:56Yeah.
1:20:57You know, I never thought about it.
1:20:58I'm not trying to rub it in.
1:20:59But it just occurred to me that probably the biggest moment in Michigan basketball history
1:21:05It was against North Carolina.
1:21:06- Yeah, the false timeout.
1:21:09- Right.
1:21:09- Yeah, that was great.
1:21:11(laughing)
1:21:13Chris Weber has done a lot of good from Michigan.
1:21:16- You know what though?
1:21:17Even as a North Carolina fan,
1:21:20it was sort of an ignominious way to win.
1:21:22It was like you're waiting for this firecracker
1:21:25to go off of an exciting down
1:21:27to the last second basketball game,
1:21:30and the way that it finished was,
1:21:32oh, one of the guys on the other team
1:21:34poured water on the firecracker.
1:21:35- Right, right.
1:21:36- Right?
1:21:37- Yeah.
1:21:38- It's like, you win, 'cause that's not allowed.
1:21:39You're not allowed to put water on the firecracker.
1:21:41- Yeah, yeah.
1:21:44- What happened, for anybody who doesn't know,
1:21:46and again, I don't mean to rub salt in the wood,
1:21:48but it was a close game.
1:21:49I think North Carolina was up by one.
1:21:52Could be getting that wrong,
1:21:53but Michigan could've won, and they had the ball,
1:21:56but they had no timeouts left,
1:21:58and one of their star players,
1:21:59probably the star player, tried to call a timeout,
1:22:02And in basketball, if you don't have timeouts and try to call a timeout, it's a technical
1:22:06foul.
1:22:07The other team gets to shoot some free throws and they get the ball back and that sort of
1:22:11ended the game right there.
1:22:14That was the most anticlimactic ending possible ever.
1:22:18Alright, Google Reader.
1:22:21So I think you and I are going to maybe disagree on this.
1:22:24Well, I think that you will think that we will because I was being sort of funny on
1:22:28on Twitter yesterday about it, but I actually am fairly annoyed by this.
1:22:34Just because I see my traffic logs and stuff and I see where a lot of the people are reading
1:22:40from, it's a ton of people still reading from Google Reader.
1:22:44So I don't know where they...
1:22:46I mean, obviously, a lot of people now are saying that they're going to step up and fill
1:22:49the void, but it's still...
1:22:51It's an underlying layer that a lot of these other services were using.
1:22:55Yeah.
1:22:56what there's two there's two aspects to google reader there's the google reader
1:22:59the traditional google reader interface where you go to the web and you go to
1:23:02reader google.com or whatever the url was and and read google reader there and
1:23:07tons of people definitely do that because i see that from my referral logs
1:23:11of people coming from google reader urls all the time um i know what a lot of
1:23:16daring fireball readers do is and i think that they you know i don't know i
1:23:19don't know what it's going to mean for daring fireball because i think what
1:23:22happens is most of my stuff my link list stuff they read and they know how it
1:23:25how it works and they click the headline
1:23:27and I never see them.
1:23:28They just go to where I'm pointing, which is fine with me.
1:23:31It's your attention that I want more than,
1:23:33I don't want the page views 'cause I don't sell ads
1:23:35by page views.
1:23:36And I'm just glad to have you reading my feed
1:23:39and that's why I sell sponsorships that go into the feed.
1:23:42They pay for it, so it's great.
1:23:44But what a lot of people do is when I write a full article,
1:23:47like the one I wrote last night,
1:23:48then instead of reading it in Reader,
1:23:50then they come to my site because they wanna read it
1:23:52on Daring Fireball.
1:23:53And when I write a full article, I get almost always
1:23:57the number one referral is Google Reader.
1:24:00And if not, it's some Tico URL from Twitter.
1:24:03- Right.
1:24:04And yeah, those are going to go away.
1:24:08I mean, so I have not used,
1:24:11I used to be a Google Reader junkie.
1:24:13Like maybe, I think there was a service I used the most.
1:24:17I was like, I was so adamant about making sure
1:24:21that I read every single thing,
1:24:23whether, not necessarily reading, but at least seeing
1:24:25and skimming every single thing that was in there.
1:24:27I had like over 100 feeds that I was doing that for,
1:24:31and I was just very diligent about throughout a day.
1:24:34That was like my go-to thing, especially in my prime time
1:24:39of doing tech blogging.
1:24:40That's like how I would stay on top of every little thing.
1:24:43And now, my life is different now, of course,
1:24:46but it just seems like I never use Google Reader anymore.
1:24:51I would use occasionally Reader, the iOS app,
1:24:54which is on both iPhone and iPad and is great,
1:24:59but uses Google Reader as kind of the underlayer for it.
1:25:03- Right, that's the second use of Google Reader,
1:25:05is as an API and a syncing API for client apps.
1:25:10- Yep, right. - And that to me,
1:25:12and Brent Simmons pointed out yesterday,
1:25:14is at least in like referral logs is dark matter.
1:25:17- Right. - Because it doesn't show up.
1:25:19- Right. - Right?
1:25:20Don't underestimate how many people are using apps
1:25:24for feed reading, and a lot of those apps
1:25:26use Google Reader as their way of syncing.
1:25:28- And so people say, a few of these guys,
1:25:30so Dig has come out, Feedly, Flipboard,
1:25:34like a number of them have come out
1:25:35and said that they're going to recreate, right,
1:25:37Google Reader, but a few of them have said
1:25:39that they're gonna try and recreate the API as well.
1:25:41It's not clear to me how they're doing that.
1:25:44Are they just going to scrape the,
1:25:49kind of your, what is it, OPML?
1:25:50Isn't that what the--
1:25:52- I don't know, I don't know enough about
1:25:55how the Google Reader API worked.
1:25:56It must be more than just OPML though,
1:25:58because there has to be a way for clients to send like,
1:26:00hey, this one's been read.
1:26:02- Yeah, right, you're right.
1:26:03- And pull more, it's, but I've also heard though,
1:26:08you know, and Brent Simmons is actually,
1:26:11yeah, but not even heard, it's not even like a secret,
1:26:13but it's not a great API.
1:26:15Well, the reason everybody adopted it is that it worked.
1:26:18know, and it's a kind of a crummy API, but it worked. And it was never really published
1:26:22as an official API. The API use is all sort of, and it was never really official. Like,
1:26:28Google never really blocked it and never said, "Don't use it," but they never said, "Hey,
1:26:32here's an API you can use for syncing." People sort of backwards engineered it.
1:26:37And for example, some of the best documentation for it, Brent Simmons of NetNewswire fame,
1:26:43but he doesn't do NetNewswire anymore. That's at BlackPixel. But while he was doing NetNewswire,
1:26:48NewsWire. At NewsGator, he and the guy behind FeedDemon, I'm blanking on his name right
1:26:57now, but sorry about that. But the FeedDemon app, which is like NetNewsWire for Windows,
1:27:03he sort of backwards engineered a lot of their API and documented it for their own use at
1:27:10NewsGator for their apps. But Google never really published docs for it. So all these
1:27:15These people who say they're going to duplicate it are duplicating an API that was never really
1:27:19fully published.
1:27:20That's interesting. The response to it was amazing. Just looking at my Twitter feed,
1:27:31everyone was so pissed off. I do wonder. I got into it a little bit with someone yesterday,
1:27:38wondering if this is the first time under the Larry Page era that Google goes back on
1:27:43It almost seems like there's a chance they could do that right because the backlash has just been so great
1:27:49Like Google has to see this and look like maybe we did have something there. Maybe we just didn't put enough resources
1:27:54Maybe we made a mistake and like I don't think anyone would
1:27:57Think poorly on them if they said they came out and said exactly that like well Marco Arman made the argument that it would be
1:28:04The worst thing they could do that
1:28:05Maybe the best thing they could have done was just stick with it and improve it
1:28:08But now once they've announced that it's dead and all these other people start building
1:28:12Competitors and trying to break out of the ecosystem the worst thing they could do or I think he called it a dick move
1:28:16Would be to then say nope never mind
1:28:19We're gonna we're gonna keep it going and then have all that wasted effort in the mean time
1:28:23I guess unless they say reversely yeah, if they reverse course quickly enough though. I'm not quite sure that that applies
1:28:29Yeah, I thought his other point Marcus other point was better where it's sort of I think this was his point at least that
1:28:36Google Reader, while all these people are up in arms
1:28:40about it, and rightfully so in some ways,
1:28:42it's also, it really did sort of stifle innovation
1:28:45in the RSS space, because it just became
1:28:48such a dominant player, and sort of,
1:28:50that maybe not killed off some of the other guys,
1:28:52but they all had to either be compatible with it,
1:28:55and so it really didn't help that space at all,
1:29:00and so now maybe there will be innovation there again.
1:29:03- At a certain point, free and good enough,
1:29:06and with Google behind it,
1:29:09it's almost impossible to overcome.
1:29:13- Right.
1:29:14- I don't know if that's quite true,
1:29:15but in the case of the RSS market as it stood around 2005,
1:29:19it was impossible for anybody to really overcome it.
1:29:22And everybody who sort of survived,
1:29:25like apps like Reader and Net News Wire,
1:29:27survived by getting on board with it
1:29:31as their syncing engine.
1:29:32Right.
1:29:34How do you view, though, RSS overall?
1:29:36I mean, this is sort of the point where we may disagree.
1:29:39It's like, obviously, both of our readers
1:29:43are fairly still addicted to it and use it.
1:29:46And you and I both, in the past, if not now,
1:29:49were addicted to using it.
1:29:50But it's never really been a mainstream thing.
1:29:54I think everyone would agree on that.
1:29:57I think that you could make the argument that it's
1:29:58a mainstream thing in that people use things
1:30:01like Flipboard and stuff maybe,
1:30:02but they don't realize they're using RSS.
1:30:04But no one, like my parents, have no idea what RSS is.
1:30:07And now, Twitter and Facebook and the social services
1:30:12have sort of replaced the need for it,
1:30:14but to some extent, some of them still use it.
1:30:16Like, I don't know, how do you syndicate out
1:30:18the Daring Fireball Twitter account?
1:30:20Do you just sync from a RSS feed?
1:30:22Is that how you do it?
1:30:23- Yeah, I wrote a little thing
1:30:24that just reads my RSS feed and auto-tune.
1:30:26I know there's other services that do it,
1:30:28but I wanted to do it my own way
1:30:30so I could truncate.
1:30:31If I happened to write a title that plus the URL was greater
1:30:35than 140 characters, I wanted to truncate it.
1:30:38Got it.
1:30:38Yeah.
1:30:39So I did the same thing.
1:30:40And I just wanted control over it.
1:30:41I just wanted control over--
1:30:44Yeah.
1:30:45That makes sense.
1:30:46Yeah, and you know what?
1:30:46It's also the only way I could figure out
1:30:48to get my custom link shortener in the tweets.
1:30:50So the @daringfireball account is a little-- I don't know.
1:30:54It's only like 40 lines of Perl code.
1:30:56OK.
1:30:58- But so how do you view RSS now?
1:31:00Since it never has become a mainstream thing
1:31:02and it wasn't going to, right?
1:31:04- There's two, I think there's two ways to view it.
1:31:06One is as technical plumbing.
1:31:08And I don't think Google Reader's disappearance
1:31:11changes that at all.
1:31:12Google Reader disappears and people who, like you said,
1:31:16who read Flipboard, and Flipboard just keeps working
1:31:19as ever, it's not like websites are gonna pull their feeds.
1:31:22I'm not going to, just because Google Reader's down.
1:31:24Even if those tends to, I don't even know how many,
1:31:29I really don't know how many people,
1:31:31but lots and lots of during five hour readers
1:31:33read it through Google Reader.
1:31:34Even if those readers don't subscribe to the feed again
1:31:38in another app and they just go away,
1:31:40I'm still not taking my feed away, you know,
1:31:42'cause I know there's enough people who use it elsewhere
1:31:44and people who read it through Flipboard
1:31:45and stuff like that.
1:31:46I mean, it's still worth having a feed.
1:31:48So the way that RSS is just plumbing that other apps use
1:31:52and people don't even know they're reading RSS.
1:31:55Google Reader really I don't think has any relevance
1:31:57to that.
1:31:58I don't think it changes at all.
1:32:00I think where it does though, I think the other aspect
1:32:02of RSS is among the people who do know what RSS is,
1:32:07and it's clearly a minority of the overall public,
1:32:11but who they are are the news junkies.
1:32:13- Right.
1:32:14- And I think news junkies are, it's again,
1:32:19it's just sort of like with the phones,
1:32:21where every reader is not equivalent, right?
1:32:25It's not like, well, if only 3% of overall readers
1:32:29use RSS and know what RSS is, then it doesn't really matter
1:32:32if Google Reader goes away.
1:32:34But those 3% of readers are the best readers,
1:32:36because they're junkies, and they're going to come back
1:32:38multiple times a day.
1:32:39They're the ones who are likely to read every single thing I
1:32:42post.
1:32:44They're like the most avid readers of Daring Fireball.
1:32:47So I think that's incredibly valuable.
1:32:49Like, sometimes, you know, it's the same way that the Mac could be an important part of
1:32:57the computer industry with 4-5% market share.
1:33:00Right.
1:33:01And that's sort of why this confuses me about why Google did it.
1:33:03Because first of all, they're obviously, they haven't put resources into it in a long time.
1:33:07The entire team that built it is long gone.
1:33:09They probably had a few people, like literally a few people working on it, you know, in their
1:33:13spare time or whatever.
1:33:15But that's all they needed, right?
1:33:17Like, it didn't need anything.
1:33:18and they weren't going to build any new features for it.
1:33:20I have to wonder if they're doing it just as a signal to,
1:33:25we really are behind, again, Google+,
1:33:28and we want people to read the news that way,
1:33:30and we don't want it.
1:33:31But it almost seems like just shooting themselves
1:33:33in the foot with just pure bad PR for no real reason.
1:33:38Because again, not taking up a lot of resources or whatever.
1:33:41Yes, it's a great noble cause to say
1:33:43that you want to be focused and have fewer products.
1:33:46And I think that that has helped Google
1:33:48in a lot of regards, but this is something
1:33:50where it's such a passionate user base
1:33:53that it was gonna never be anything but a negative for them.
1:33:56It sort of reminds me of when Yahoo sunsetted Delicious,
1:33:59right, it was like they ended up having
1:34:02to spin it out and sell it.
1:34:03It's like, does Google do that?
1:34:05Do they sell it to someone else?
1:34:07- And I bet there's a lot of, I bet it's a lot of overlap
1:34:09between the people who are diehard Delicious users,
1:34:11I bet are largely overlap with people
1:34:13who are very avid Google Reader users.
1:34:15Yeah.
1:34:16And Google had to know that it's like the heavy Google Reader
1:34:20users are also a lot, probably every single tech blogger
1:34:24out there.
1:34:25And they knew they were just going
1:34:26to get pounded and pounded and pounded on these things.
1:34:30But they did it anyway.
1:34:31But I think you retweeted that one funny tweet where it's
1:34:34like, so Google wants to focus.
1:34:38Google Glass, good.
1:34:40Google Cars, good.
1:34:42Self-driving cars, magic glasses.
1:34:45The Brazilian social network.
1:34:49Those stay.
1:34:49Google Reader, done.
1:34:52Yeah, that's pretty funny.
1:34:54That would--
1:34:55Yeah, so I'm surprised that they did this, at least the way
1:35:01that they did it.
1:35:02And it's happening very soon, too.
1:35:04It's only a few months, which doesn't
1:35:06give those other teams that are working on things from scratch
1:35:08dig a lot of time to come up with something.
1:35:11Well, and sometimes, I do wonder what Google sees as valuable.
1:35:19Clearly what they can sell ads against is valuable to them.
1:35:22That's where their revenue and profits come from.
1:35:23Right.
1:35:23And that's an important point, because they
1:35:25tried to do that with FeedBurner,
1:35:27and then they had FeedSense, right?
1:35:29And that just never took off.
1:35:30Right.
1:35:32And FeedBurner is still around, but the fact
1:35:35that they're doing this to Google Reader would make--
1:35:39and I've never put a feed in FeedBurner.
1:35:41specifically because I never want to trust,
1:35:45even though they give you good analytics,
1:35:47I've always thought I'd rather control my feed
1:35:51than have the analytics.
1:35:54- So I am in FeedBurner, and I do wonder now,
1:35:57what does that mean?
1:35:59FeedBurner has been probably, in my mind,
1:36:01one of the most neglected Google products
1:36:04in the last at least five years, six years,
1:36:06whatever it's been, way more so than Google Reader.
1:36:09- They bought it and just stopped doing anything with it.
1:36:11Right, and you know, it's sort of humorous,
1:36:13that Dick Costolo was one of the founders of it,
1:36:16to the point of, humorous aside,
1:36:18he used to actually, I would have problems
1:36:20with my personal blog feed,
1:36:22I would email Google about it,
1:36:23and it would be Dick Costolo on the email,
1:36:26saying, "Hi, MG, let me look into that for you,"
1:36:29while he was, sort of funny how times change.
1:36:32But, so, yeah, they really didn't do anything with it,
1:36:35and if you ever wanna hear someone
1:36:38just complain nonstop about feed burn,
1:36:40just talked to Gabe Rivera of TechMeam, because he sees,
1:36:43it's not only that FeedBurner was neglected,
1:36:45it would like really mess up feeds in some way,
1:36:49to the point where like when he was trying to crawl them
1:36:51for TechMeam to get headlines on there,
1:36:53it'd be all kinds of problems,
1:36:54and he had to create his own system
1:36:55to like un-FeedBurner feeds.
1:36:58Yeah.
1:37:00- Yeah, and part of the,
1:37:01and I've heard that too about FeedBurner,
1:37:03that FeedBurner mangles feeds,
1:37:04and that's so, it's so almost ironic,
1:37:08because one of the best things about Google Reader
1:37:11is that Google Reader is famously good
1:37:14at understanding mangled feeds.
1:37:18That mismanaged feeds with misformed XML,
1:37:24Google Reader was famous for being able to-- I understand
1:37:28what you really wanted.
1:37:30Like in the way that web browsers have always
1:37:33dealt as gracefully as they can with mangled HTML.
1:37:39Part of the whole idea behind RSS--
1:37:43not RSS, XML as a whole at the beginning was--
1:37:47and I don't want to get into a big rant on web standards,
1:37:49but the XML guys were sort of idealists.
1:37:52And they looked at HTML and said,
1:37:54this is a nightmare the way that all the browsers have
1:37:57to support mangled, invalid HTML.
1:38:01let's make it a rule that XML parsers, if they encounter an XML error, have to break.
1:38:06And that's actually in the spec. And RSS is a form of XML. So if you have bad RSS, whatever the app that's reading it is supposed to throw up an error.
1:38:16And everybody who writes software was like, "That's like the worst user experience ever. I'm not going to do that. I'm going to do my best to read it."
1:38:25And I think overall RSS is a lot better formed and more valid than HTML, but it's, you know,
1:38:31it's just the nature of the world.
1:38:33People are going to write bad XML.
1:38:35And Google Reader did a great job of making sense of it.
1:38:39And that meant that like apps like Reader or Net News Wire that go through Google Reader
1:38:45for syncing could get the advantages of that sort of parsing smartness.
1:38:51So, I wonder now if, as a result of this, there's either going to be one of two things
1:38:59happen. Either people like you and I who get a significant number of readers coming in
1:39:04from Google Reader just lose those guys, like you said, and they don't come back. Or does
1:39:11it help a few of the new guys that can actually innovate on top of what a news reader should
1:39:18be sort of like reinvigorate the space? Do you think that that will happen or do you
1:39:21think it will be like, that's it, they'll now read through Twitter and so they'll
1:39:26read less?
1:39:28You never know. I think there's an opportunity, clearly there's an opportunity here for
1:39:31reinvigoration of the entire RSS market. And if you're really a news junkie, I mean,
1:39:37and I do, I really do worry about it like in terms of the overall traffic at Daring
1:39:41Fireball because anytime you have to make a choice, you can make a choice not to do
1:39:44Whereas like, so like a diehard daring fireball reader
1:39:47who's subscribed through Google Reader
1:39:49and reads everything I write,
1:39:50once Google Reader goes away,
1:39:52that reader has a choice of, you know,
1:39:55that, this, that, the other replacement for Google Reader,
1:39:58but another one of the choices they have
1:40:00is just not to subscribe
1:40:02and just think in the back of their mind,
1:40:03ah, I'll check daring fireball out on the web
1:40:05whenever I think of it.
1:40:06- Right, and you have to imagine
1:40:07that that's going to be at least some percentage
1:40:10are not going to be available.
1:40:10- It has to, it's gonna be more than zero, right?
1:40:12It's, you know, and who knows how big it is.
1:40:16So I mean, I'm not going to say I'm worried,
1:40:18but it's certainly something I'm concerned about.
1:40:20I mean, here's one of the other things, too,
1:40:22is I have no idea how many people read Daring
1:40:24Fireball through Google Reader.
1:40:25I posted a thing the other day where when they hit your feed,
1:40:28they put in the user agent string
1:40:31how many subscribers there are to your feed in Google Reader.
1:40:34And for Daring Fireball, it's 370-some thousand,
1:40:37plus a bunch of other hundred and some that are--
1:40:40that for some reason Google Reader sometimes puts your feed in under a different ID. But
1:40:46it's, you know, somewhere on the order of close to 400,000. But there's no way that
1:40:51there's actually 400,000 active readers because that counts everybody who's ever subscribed
1:40:56to my feed in Google Reader whether they're still using Google Reader or not. Right? When
1:41:01somebody who uses any feed reader, Google Reader, Net News, or anything, when they stop
1:41:06using it, when they just sort of fade away from using Google Reader and don't really
1:41:10check in anymore. Nobody goes in and unsubscribes from all their feeds first. They're still
1:41:16subscribed. So I have no idea. Is there 100,000 active readers of Daring Fireball's feed
1:41:21in Google Reader? Is it actually close to that 370,000 number? Is it really only 25,000?
1:41:27I have no idea.
1:41:28And so do you also think—someone put this forward, I think it was on Twitter yesterday—the
1:41:34The notion that because FeedSense,
1:41:37so the monetization of the feeds never really took off
1:41:40in the way that anyone was hoping,
1:41:42Google viewed this as like, it's almost like the antithesis
1:41:46of what they want to do because they want people
1:41:51to be on the web, they want people to be using Google,
1:41:53and they want people to be on websites
1:41:54where they're showing up Google Ads.
1:41:56And a lot of people, you know, like I would just view things
1:42:00through the feed reader if it had a full feed,
1:42:02and I would never hit those sites,
1:42:03I'm not going to go there to comment and do other things.
1:42:06And so there's an argument that could be made that I was, in a way, if you want to
1:42:12call it mooching or whatever, off of those sites that were making no advertising money
1:42:17off of me. And so since Google being the largest by far web advertiser, Google to some extent
1:42:23then was losing money as a result of that.
1:42:26I guess so. Maybe. I can't help but think that that must be part of the equation that
1:42:30they put, you know, to decide to stop this, that they couldn't, you know, they didn't
1:42:34think it was a way to make money. But the thing that surprises me is that they didn't
1:42:37see it as a way to collect interesting information about people.
1:42:41Like, here's what, you know, that maybe they can't put ads on it while you're reading
1:42:46in Google Reader, but they do know what you're reading in Google Reader. And that seems to
1:42:50me like it would inform the ads they can show you elsewhere when they can show you ads.
1:42:56So that's what surprises me, is it seems to me that knowing what a couple of million news
1:43:00junkies are reading seems like really interesting information from a Google perspective, like
1:43:06something that they could do something, that just seems like prime Google material.
1:43:10And I just always assume that's why they built it in the first place.
1:43:12And that reminds me of something which I hadn't thought about until right now, but someone
1:43:16had, oh, it was BuzzFeed.
1:43:19BuzzFeed about three months ago, because I linked to it, and so I just searched for it
1:43:23quickly.
1:43:24had the story that goes in depth about the night
1:43:28that Google shut off the social features
1:43:31within Google Reader and switched over
1:43:33to Google+ integration.
1:43:36And this was like a giant thing for a lot of these users.
1:43:38It was really like the first step when everyone knew like,
1:43:40oh God, the end is coming or whatever.
1:43:43But there's like, there's this whole thing
1:43:45called like Share Bros.
1:43:47I know that sounds ridiculous,
1:43:48but there's some kind of community called Share Bros
1:43:51within the Google Reader community that were just like,
1:43:53using Google Reader just to share with one another.
1:43:56And it really was like a very tight-knit community, I guess,
1:44:01of people around news.
1:44:03And Google could have had all of this interesting information
1:44:06around that kind of data.
1:44:08But instead, they tried to go for the Google+ integration,
1:44:12and it alienated all of those users.
1:44:14And then they either took off, or they were just pissed off.
1:44:19But that speaks to what you were getting at, where Google could
1:44:21have done a lot more interesting things.
1:44:23like they had a really great social network for news
1:44:27and they never really did anything with it.
1:44:30- Right, it just doesn't quite,
1:44:32I've always thought that Google had two types of things
1:44:35they're interested in.
1:44:36One, the things that they can actually sell ads against.
1:44:39And then two, the type of things where they can collect
1:44:42information about you if you're signed into Google
1:44:46that would be useful for selling ads against you
1:44:49of your interest later.
1:44:50like one level away from advertising.
1:44:53And so to me, Maps is like that.
1:44:55Like to me, I never see many ads on Maps, very few.
1:44:59Certainly, I've never seen enough ads in Google Maps
1:45:02that would ever justify the value I've gotten out of it.
1:45:06But presumably, when I'm signed into Google and use Maps,
1:45:09the location data that they've collected about me
1:45:12is useful to them.
1:45:14That it's more the aggregate location data of their users
1:45:19is what's valuable to Google Maps for them,
1:45:21not the ads they're actually selling through Google Maps.
1:45:23- Yeah.
1:45:25- And I always thought the same thing about Google Reader.
1:45:27- Yeah, so the only thing that sticks in my head then
1:45:30is just that they feel like, once again,
1:45:33they need to push Google+ to be that source
1:45:37of information, right?
1:45:38- Well, and that's, you know,
1:45:40I guess that's the other factor.
1:45:42And here's the other thing I thought Google Reader
1:45:43would be interesting for.
1:45:45Maybe it already is, maybe this is a source of information
1:45:47that's going away, but I always presume
1:45:49that Google Reader would be important
1:45:51for driving the algorithms behind Google News.
1:45:54- Right.
1:45:55- And what's a top story?
1:45:56What's going to get people interested?
1:45:59Like, boy, a lot of people are interested
1:46:01in this Galaxy S4 launch,
1:46:05'cause they're all reading these things about it,
1:46:06so let's promote that story on Google News
1:46:09to the mass market of people who just check out Google News.
1:46:12- Yeah, and there was a notion way back in the day,
1:46:16probably five years ago or something,
1:46:17that Google was going to create a quote, unquote dig killer
1:46:21by using the Google Reader information, right,
1:46:24to see what people were starring,
1:46:26because remember that was like a big part of it,
1:46:27you could star all the things.
1:46:29- Right, and people would subscribe to say,
1:46:31you know, Scoble's favorites.
1:46:33- Right, right, right, and so you could surface then
1:46:35the top news of the day via that,
1:46:37and they just never did it.
1:46:39- Right, it was like an easy way
1:46:40to create your own link blog,
1:46:42where you would go through Google Reader,
1:46:44and when you saw something interesting, you'd star it,
1:46:47and then anybody, if you're, I guess,
1:46:49I think you had control over whether that was public.
1:46:51- Yeah, you did.
1:46:52They even had designs for it, right, at one point.
1:46:54- Right, then you could, you know,
1:46:55your starred links through Google Reader
1:46:58was, you know, like a link blog.
1:47:00- Yep.
1:47:01- That's the thing, though, that you were saying
1:47:02about Google+, is I also, I do wonder whether this was like
1:47:05political spitefulness of that they've been trying
1:47:08to get people to use Google+ for a lot of the same things,
1:47:12discovery of interesting links and sharing links,
1:47:16and it just isn't taking off.
1:47:19Right, and somebody else made the point that
1:47:21if the reason, if their reason for killing Google Reader
1:47:26is it just isn't popular enough,
1:47:28then why is Google+ still around?
1:47:29Because clearly fewer people are using Google+
1:47:32than Google Reader.
1:47:33- And someone had the stats yesterday
1:47:35that they're still seeing way more inbound traffic
1:47:37from Google Reader than Google+.
1:47:39- Oh, everybody is, everybody is.
1:47:40And the only reason that when they quote Google+ numbers
1:47:43that they quote a huge number is they count Gmail users
1:47:45Google Plus. So everybody who uses Gmail, which is like 50 million people, counts as
1:47:50an active Google Plus user, but nobody's actually using Google Plus as Google--well, not nobody,
1:47:55but relatively few compared to Google Reader.
1:47:57I can't--
1:47:58Peter: Very few people outside of Google employees.
1:48:00Right?
1:48:01Justin: But Google Plus is like the baby. That's the prize, the favored child. That's the one
1:48:06Larry Page, you know, that's his baby as CEO. That's the one that--what's his name? The
1:48:13guy from Microsoft.
1:48:14Peter. Vic Gundotra.
1:48:15who's always a keynote guy at IO.
1:48:18- Vic Gundotra.
1:48:21- Yeah, Vic Gundotra.
1:48:22He's obviously very influential there,
1:48:26and Google+ is sort of his baby.
1:48:29And I kinda can't help but feel that they've,
1:48:33they poked some sticks, like come on,
1:48:35move to Google+, move to Google+,
1:48:37and none of the diehard Google reader users did,
1:48:41and now it's like, well, now you're gonna have to.
1:48:43(laughing)
1:48:43- Yeah, which is just--
1:48:44I haven't heard one single person say, "Ah, I can't believe they did this to Google Reader, but I guess I'll move to Google Plus."
1:48:50Yeah, if anything, the opposite will happen. They'll just be more spiteful of it and just not go over there.
1:48:55Right, because you can't even do—I mean, there's the sharing stuff you can do, but you can't subscribe to feeds.
1:49:01I mean, that's what most people want to do, is they want to—here's these things I'm interested in, and I want to see every single thing that they post.
1:49:07Right, and you can, I mean, you could do it in the same convoluted way that you do that
1:49:11for Twitter, which is that you would set up some kind of automated thing where you create
1:49:16a page for your site or whatever, and then you do an RSS to Google+ post.
1:49:21Right, it's sort of a boil the ocean plan, though, where everybody who is publishing
1:49:26RSS is going to publish a Google+ feed. I mean, I'm not going to do that.
1:49:32Yeah, right.
1:49:34I hope not. I hope I'm not going to do that.
1:49:38That's going to be your future, all Google+ all the time.
1:49:40Yeah, so I don't know. How do you see it playing out before we sign off? Do you think that
1:49:44this—again, it's not—there's zero chance that RSS's technical plumbing is going away.
1:49:51I think Renee Ritchie at iMore called it the—it's like the file system of news, right?
1:49:57And I think that's a great analogy insofar as it's like iOS users and post-PC, all
1:50:03All post-PC platforms sort of obfuscate the file system from the users.
1:50:07That doesn't mean the file system isn't there, though.
1:50:10It's just there and the code uses it.
1:50:11That's not going away.
1:50:12But is news reading for news junkies going away?
1:50:15So I guess the way I would answer that is I wonder what this means relative to the world
1:50:22just continuing to shift towards mobile computing, right?
1:50:25It's like the RSS readers and Google Reader in particular were great on the desktop.
1:50:32But on mobile, while Reader and there are some other good ones out there, it's not the
1:50:38same.
1:50:39And I don't feel like people use it in the exact same way, because you just can't.
1:50:44It's a small screen, you can't multitask really in the same way of doing as you can on a computer.
1:50:51And so I think that this is an opportunity for something new to come about, or for someone
1:50:58like Flipboard or Dig or someone else to take advantage and really innovate on top of what
1:51:03has come before it.
1:51:04But I do think it's going to have to be different from what it was.
1:51:07I don't think that we just get the straight up news reader as we had with Google Reader,
1:51:13because it just, you know, everyone's on their phone all the time and most of the links I
1:51:17click through are on Twitter and then I either save them to read later in Instapaper or whatever,
1:51:23but I'm just not using a feed reader anymore.
1:51:27I do on my desktop, but I don't on my phone because Twitter fills up the entirety of my
1:51:34– I'm on my phone and I'm bored or I'm waiting in a line or I have a couple of minutes
1:51:39to blow.
1:51:40What's new?
1:51:41I never get to the end of what's new in Twitter and then think, "Well, all right,
1:51:45maybe I'll switch to RSS and see what's new."
1:51:48I never get to it.
1:51:49That's exactly right.
1:51:50I'm the exact same way.
1:51:51And I assume you still click on links within Twitter and you read some of those stories
1:51:54as you're going.
1:51:55It's just a different way of, it's a different mentality because it's a different use case.
1:51:59So I do think that it's just going to be different going forward.
1:52:03But clearly, I'm sure there's a lot of people listening right now who do, who use
1:52:08Reader or NetNewswire or something on their phones and their iPads.
1:52:13Reader certainly is very popular on the phone.
1:52:19What are they going to use for syncing?
1:52:20I don't know.
1:52:21And I do, that's the one thing, that's the thing that Google Reader had that's essential
1:52:25to mobile is it really, nobody wants to use an RSS readers that don't sync.
1:52:33Right?
1:52:34Like it's the same way that nobody wants to use email that doesn't sync.
1:52:37Like if you read 10 emails on your phone, nobody wants to sit down at their desktop
1:52:42and mark those 10 messages read again.
1:52:45I mean it would drive you nuts.
1:52:47Same thing with RSS.
1:52:48You don't want to see all these articles you read on your phone.
1:52:50when you sit down, you've got to have sync.
1:52:52But everybody was using Google Reader for sync,
1:52:54so what's gonna happen?
1:52:56- Yeah, so one of these guys, I don't know,
1:52:58I don't know who will win.
1:52:59I would imagine that there won't be just one
1:53:02that becomes massive, 'cause I think they'll all
1:53:04go about it a different way, right?
1:53:06There'll be a visual one, there'll be a more
1:53:08streamlined, quick one, so yeah.
1:53:11I think it's a good opportunity for a lot of people,
1:53:13but it does, it's gonna hurt for a while
1:53:15until someone builds this again.
1:53:18- Yeah, and it also seems to me like,
1:53:19And at first thought, if anybody thinks,
1:53:21well, they're giving us till July,
1:53:23that's pretty generous.
1:53:25From an engineering standpoint,
1:53:26boy, from now to July is not a long time
1:53:28to build a reliable, scalable
1:53:30platform. - Right, right.
1:53:33It's gonna be tough.
1:53:35One last final point I wanted to make
1:53:39'cause you brought up, going back to Andy Rubin,
1:53:42so going back to our earlier thing.
1:53:43So you brought up Google I/O with Vic and Dojo
1:53:46talking about that.
1:53:46I wonder if maybe that has to do with the timing, right?
1:53:49Because they know that Google I/O is coming up.
1:53:52Android is going to be a huge part of it, maybe even half of
1:53:55it, say.
1:53:56And they need to nail that presentation, right?
1:54:00And they can't have Andy Rubin on his way out the door,
1:54:05having just stepped down two weeks earlier or whatever,
1:54:09up there on stage giving that presentation.
1:54:11They need cohesive leadership and everyone
1:54:14to be on the same page.
1:54:15So maybe that does have something to do with it.
1:54:17Yeah, but they could have done it today.
1:54:20That's true.
1:54:20And even if they didn't want to bury it on a Friday,
1:54:23then it could have done it Monday.
1:54:26That's true.
1:54:27I don't really get it.
1:54:28I just-- I don't know.
1:54:29Just verbalizing it made me think that it's not a-- it
1:54:31really is not a coincidence that they did it the day before,
1:54:35or the day of--
1:54:36I forget, but right before the S4 launch.
1:54:39Maybe that was either the ultimate middle finger
1:54:43or ultimate olive branch to Samsung.
1:54:45- Hard to say, it could be either way,
1:54:47but I don't think it was unrelated.
1:54:49- Yeah.
1:54:50- Very interesting.
1:54:52Well, MG Siegler, thanks for being here,
1:54:55ParisLemon.com, @ParisLemon on Twitter.
1:54:59- Yeah, thank you for having me again.
1:55:01- And my thanks to my sponsors,
1:55:02Studio Neat with Simple Bracket, the great iPhone app,
1:55:05Pixelmature, at Pixelmature.com,
1:55:07and Things, and Things Cloud Sync at culturedcode.com.
1:55:12[BLANK_AUDIO]