Podcast Search

The Talk Show

32: Denied Permission for an Emergency Landing at Clavius

Select a time to play from there. The line being spoken is highlighted as the audio plays.

0:00:00Well, as it happens, I'm on my way up to the moon.

0:00:03Are you by any chance going up to your base at Clavius?

0:00:06Yes, as a matter of fact I am.

0:00:09Is there any particular reason why you ask?

0:00:12Well, Dr. Floyd, I hope you don't think I'm too inquisitive,

0:00:16but perhaps you can clear up the mystery about what's been going on up there.

0:00:19I'm sorry, but I'm not sure I know what you mean.

0:00:23Well, it's just for the past two weeks there have been some extremely odd things happening at Clavius.

0:00:29Really?

0:00:30Yes, well, for one thing, whenever you phone the base, all you get is a recording which

0:00:34repeats that the phone lines are temporarily out of order.

0:00:37Well, I suppose they've been having a bit of trouble with some of the equipment.

0:00:41Yes, well, at first we thought that was the explanation, but it's been going on for the

0:00:45past ten days.

0:00:47You mean you haven't been able to get anyone at the base for ten days?

0:00:49That's right.

0:00:50I see.

0:00:51Another thing.

0:00:52Two days ago, one of our rocket buses was denied permission for an emergency landing

0:00:57at Clavius.

0:00:59How did they manage to do that without any communication?

0:01:01Well, Clavius' control came on the air just long enough to transmit their refusal.

0:01:06Well, that does sound very odd.

0:01:08Yes, I'm afraid there's going to be a bit of a row about it.

0:01:11Denying the men permission to land was a direct violation of the IAS convention.

0:01:16Yes.

0:01:17Well, I hope the crew got back safely.

0:01:19Fortunately they did.

0:01:20Well, I'm glad about that.

0:01:22Dr. Floyd, at the risk of pressing you on a point you seem reticent to discuss, may

0:01:27May I ask you a straightforward question?

0:01:29Certainly.

0:01:30Quite frankly, we have some very reliable intelligence reports that a quite serious

0:01:35epidemic has broken out at Clavius.

0:01:37Something apparently of an unknown origin.

0:01:41Is this in fact what has happened?

0:01:44I'm sorry, Dr. Smeislov, but I'm really not at liberty to discuss this.

0:01:49This epidemic could easily spread to our base, Dr. Floyd.

0:01:52We should be given all the facts.

0:01:54Dr. Smyslov, I'm not permitted to discuss this.

0:01:58So I'm here in Chicago,

0:02:02Kudol Partners World Headquarters,

0:02:04with my good friend Jim Kudol.

0:02:07Jim, welcome.

0:02:10Thank you.

0:02:10Last night we went to see a screening of 2001,

0:02:15a space odyssey at the...

0:02:17Music Box Theater.

0:02:18Music Box Theater, 70mm print.

0:02:23A couple years ago there was a new print of this movie that came out and we thought we

0:02:27were going to go see it and it was a different older sort of scratched up 70mm print.

0:02:33Yeah, we were going to go, we went to the Wexler Art Center at Ohio State University

0:02:38because we had heard that they had the new print and as soon as it was sold out, it was

0:02:43great to see it projected large, but as soon as it started rolling there's a ticking artifact

0:02:48on the left side channel of the audio in the first section of the film and as soon as we

0:02:53heard that ticking, we knew that we were watching that same old print. So if you

0:02:57go to see 2001 in a 70 millimeter print you'll know you've got the right print

0:03:02when the picture is absolutely gorgeous and there's no crazy audio thing on the

0:03:05left side. Right, and in addition to the fact that we didn't have any audio errors

0:03:09last night, it was a digital audio thing. It was not the analog audio on

0:03:16the side of the film. Optical, yeah. Well we were lucky enough to meet to chat

0:03:20with the projectionist last night during intermission. How's that? Intermission in a film. So cool.

0:03:25And he said that originally the 70 millimeter prints were released with an optical audio

0:03:31track that ran alongside the picture. And that after that, they used a strip of mag,

0:03:40like magnetic tape that ran along the picture. But that now all that's alongside the picture

0:03:46his time code and it slaves basically a CD player which has all the digital audio on it.

0:03:52But even though the audio was perfectly clear it is an old track and I believe that it's mono

0:04:01and we also noticed that there's very little bottom end. There's very little base in the track

0:04:07and I think that's probably true of most of the films of that era. We're sort of spoiled now by

0:04:13Transformers and everything else. These chest-thumping subwoofer

0:04:17theatre sound experience. Exactly, although it did sound great and it did sound great.

0:04:21It did sound great. Again, no bottom end, it was no heavy bass, but it

0:04:27would, in addition to a truly, truly magnificent picture quality, it sounded

0:04:31great. Yeah, yeah. It was, you know, my father took me to see 2001, I can't

0:04:38figure out exactly when it was, but it was soon after it came out. That would

0:04:42to put me about eight years old so I chose how old I am.

0:04:44But, and I remember being enthralled

0:04:47and confused by the film.

0:04:50But this was certainly the best representation

0:04:54of the film I've ever seen.

0:04:55And we were sitting right in the second row

0:04:57and that was the right place to be, I think.

0:05:00So it's a full house, Stanley can still sell them out.

0:05:02- Absolutely. - I think the film,

0:05:04the film has been part of a 70 millimeter festival

0:05:06that they're running and I think every seat

0:05:08for every show sold out right away.

0:05:10- Wow, that's pretty cool.

0:05:12- So,

0:05:16I think anybody who ever goes to see this movie,

0:05:20you come out of it and you do exactly what I always think

0:05:23I'm not gonna do, which is start talking about what it means.

0:05:26- Well, we were with my 12-year-old son yesterday,

0:05:28so we couldn't help you.

0:05:29His first question is, "What was that?"

0:05:32- I actually liked, I really thought that Spencer

0:05:36had a truly fabulous interpretation

0:05:39of the last shot of the movie, which is that it's Superman

0:05:43floating over the Earth.

0:05:44And I know he was kind of half joking,

0:05:46but I actually think that's, you know,

0:05:49that to me is the basic gist of the story as I see it,

0:05:52is that four million years ago, whoever this is

0:05:56behind the monoliths, used a monolith to turn

0:06:00our ape-like ancestors into men.

0:06:04How did we turn from apes to men?

0:06:06It was with their help and that monolith.

0:06:08And that now, four million years later,

0:06:11through the same people's help,

0:06:14Dave Bowman has become the first whatever's next after us.

0:06:18Like going from humans to whatever is greater than humans,

0:06:23Dave Bowman's the first one who's done it.

0:06:26- Yeah, and I don't think Spencer was the first one

0:06:28with that theory, but that's the best I can make of it.

0:06:31You know, the more I learn about the film

0:06:34and the more I see it, the less I care, sort of,

0:06:37about what the actual specific meaning of that last reel of the film is.

0:06:42You know, it's so interesting.

0:06:45All the details in the middle section and the Jupiter discovery section,

0:06:50all the details are like, everything takes forever,

0:06:52and you see every little bit of everything.

0:06:54And then we make these huge jumps.

0:06:59Obviously the most famous cut in cinema history between the bone and the spaceship

0:07:03and the spaceship is a jump and then, you know, we jump down that slit scan, acid-induced

0:07:09sort of color section. Well, and it really is, right, there's these two fantastic leaps

0:07:15in the movie. There's the one where you, the jump cut from four million years ago to

0:07:21forty years in the future. I mean, I still think of it as the future, because even though

0:07:25it's 11 years after, right?

0:07:28But, I guess 12 years now, it's 2013.

0:07:31But then that last reel is another jump like that.

0:07:36Where, I mean, who knows when or where you are.

0:07:38But the other thing that really struck me last night,

0:07:42I mean, again, this is super obvious,

0:07:44but up until that last reel, up until the slit scan,

0:07:49I think of it like, I always thought

0:07:51he was going through hyperspace or something.

0:07:53That's where he's going to wherever the people who made the monolith are.

0:07:57Right.

0:07:58But at that moment, the movie shifts from two hours or so of being extremely, almost

0:08:06pedantically scientific, like both from the caveman stuff through the space stuff, you

0:08:12know, this sort of almost extraordinary precision and an attempt to do everything as

0:08:20realistically as possible to a final reel, which every single second of it, who knows

0:08:29if any of it is even real.

0:08:33It's completely poetic.

0:08:35Is it in Bowman's head?

0:08:38Is it a wormhole through space?

0:08:44Spencer's other theory was when the very old man wakes up at the end, he said, "Well, it

0:08:48was all a dream, which is sort of a conventional Hollywood way to approach it.

0:08:52If you have a chance to see this print, and we understand that this will be the

0:08:56print that's circulating, so I would certainly encourage you

0:09:00if you have a chance to see it, to see it, a little

0:09:04bit about the technical thing of it. It's the first time I ever

0:09:08saw the film where things started to feel fake.

0:09:12And I don't mean that as an insult to the film, obviously it's

0:09:16special effects and it's from 1968. But the, you mentioned last night and I think

0:09:23the same thing, the 3D model stuff like of the Discovery still holds up really

0:09:27well. But some of the scenes are actually 2D photo realistic paintings or

0:09:37photographs that are moved across another 2D surface and the fidelity of

0:09:42of the picture last night, put the lie to that a little bit.

0:09:47- It looked flat.

0:09:48- Yeah, right, right.

0:09:50It didn't look bad, it just looked flat.

0:09:55It's sort of interesting to see it projected.

0:09:59It's such a different thing than to see even the DVD

0:10:01on your big screen, flat screen at home or whatever.

0:10:04- And some of this stuff, honestly, I don't think

0:10:07that it's just me being an enormous fan of the movie.

0:10:10Some of the special effects scenes still look as good

0:10:13as anything you're ever gonna see

0:10:16because it looks absolutely real.

0:10:18Like there's some shots where the camera

0:10:20is sort of stationary in space, outer space,

0:10:23and the discovery is passing over it.

0:10:26And it looks, I don't think it can ever be surpassed

0:10:30because it really looks like what it would look like

0:10:32if you put a 70 millimeter camera in outer space

0:10:35and built a real discovery and flew it over the camera.

0:10:38- Right, right, right.

0:10:39And every flyby of the camera of every spaceship since 1968

0:10:44owes its existence to that particular opening scene.

0:10:49- And a lot of the interiors--

0:10:51- Opening scene of the discovery of the Jupiter section.

0:10:55- The interiors really hold up just remarkably well.

0:10:59Just in terms of does that feel like this could be

0:11:02a real pod-based station in a starship.

0:11:06And it just feels absolutely real.

0:11:08And actually, the scientist's wardrobe is sort of right back in style right now.

0:11:12The cut of the suits and everything is very contemporary.

0:11:18I guess we've got to get on them to do Barry Lyndon next, right?

0:11:22Oh, that would be a great pick.

0:11:23Because that's another one where I would just love to see it on a big screen.

0:11:27Yeah, me too.

0:11:28Of all of the other films, I think that would be the one.

0:11:31Just talking about "Seen You Projected," that would be the next one I'd want to see

0:11:35projected, I think.

0:11:36I was at the Kubrick exhibit in Amsterdam, and that was sort of interesting.

0:11:41It's now in LA.

0:11:42I don't know how long it is.

0:11:43It's the same exhibit.

0:11:44It's the same exhibit.

0:11:45They had this big space at the new film museum right on the water there, a really great building.

0:11:51The space was divided up by the movie.

0:11:53So there was one section that was Dr. Strangelove, and there was another section that was 2001,

0:11:58and there was another section that was Paths of Glory.

0:12:01The really cool thing was they were showing a projection of long sequences from the film

0:12:08on large screens in each of the sections, but the sections of the exhibit were not separated

0:12:13from each other.

0:12:14So while you were watching Alex in Clockwork, you could hear Hal at the other side of the

0:12:21room and you could hear Merkin Muffley talking to the Russian premier from Strangelove.

0:12:28It was like your head, the net effect of it was maybe what it might have been to be like

0:12:34Kubrick, because you had all these ideas floating around in your head at one time.

0:12:37There's a great app for that exhibit, too.

0:12:40Have you seen that?

0:12:41Yeah, yeah.

0:12:42And it's got photos I've never seen anywhere before in that app.

0:12:45In fact, photos are in that app that aren't even in the exhibit.

0:12:47Interesting.

0:12:48Yeah, so anybody out there is vaguely interested in Kubrick, and if you're not, you've probably

0:12:52already stopped the podcast.

0:12:54But you've got to go to the app store.

0:12:56- Go to the app store and just search for Kubrick,

0:12:58and I think that's actually just the name of the app,

0:13:00it's just Kubrick, but yeah, it's like a great ebook,

0:13:04really, like a coffee table book type thing.

0:13:06- It's really cool.

0:13:08- There was another thing, just like a random thing

0:13:10that stuck out to me last night,

0:13:11I mentioned this to you last night after the film,

0:13:13but I'd never thought about it before,

0:13:15but it really stuck out to me,

0:13:17was in the caveman sequence, in the prehistoric sequence,

0:13:21there's a scene where a cheetah is up a bunnet,

0:13:26on like a little small cliff above the tribe

0:13:31and pounces and attacks one of the tribe's people.

0:13:36And I don't know how they shot that

0:13:37because I realized like it's,

0:13:39and it wasn't all diced up with cuts, it was like--

0:13:42- It was one cut, one shot I believe.

0:13:45- I think it cut when it jumped,

0:13:46it cut when the cheetah jumped

0:13:48and then the rest of it is just,

0:13:50it holds on a shot, like kind of a long shot

0:13:52of a guy, not really a guy, but one of these,

0:13:57what do you want to call them, cavemen,

0:14:01I call them cavemen, whatever.

0:14:02- Monkeys, whatever you call them.

0:14:03- Right, fighting a cheetah, and everybody knows

0:14:07that it was people in suits doing this.

0:14:10So they had a guy in a suit fighting an actual cheetah.

0:14:14- Against a front projection glass screen

0:14:17showing the Sahara Desert.

0:14:19I noticed that scene too, but not for that,

0:14:22It didn't occur to me, I guess I'm so immune to Hollywood special effects.

0:14:28One of the Oscar nominated films is a boy and a tiger in a boat for God's sake.

0:14:33Maybe it didn't occur to me that, God that cat's actually attacking that guy.

0:14:37The thing that occurred to me in that scene is that the color correction was off in that

0:14:41scene relative to the scenes before and after it.

0:14:44It made me think, I've seen this movie too many times, but it made me think I bet they

0:14:49only got that once.

0:14:51They only got the action they wanted once and maybe the lighting wasn't correct, but

0:14:55the fact was that they needed the action so they had to do what they could with the color

0:15:00correction to make it sort of fit with the scene that came before and after it.

0:15:04I agree with that.

0:15:05There is something off about the lighting.

0:15:07I love the scene where the leopard turns into the camera and the front projection light

0:15:12is reflected in his eyes.

0:15:14For me that's like a really awesome scene, which probably wouldn't happen in nature,

0:15:18but in a way.

0:15:20Let's talk about one other thing.

0:15:21It's a lot of scenes.

0:15:22It got a good big laugh in the movie.

0:15:23It always gets a big laugh when you see the movie.

0:15:25It's the zero gravity toilet instruction scene.

0:15:29- Right, on the Pan Am shuttle.

0:15:32- Yeah, to Clavius. - That Heywood Floyd is on.

0:15:34- Yeah, that he's going, to Clavius?

0:15:35- No, I think it's on his way to the space station.

0:15:37- It's on the way to the space station.

0:15:38And it's like paragraphs and paragraphs of text.

0:15:43And I believe it's all real text.

0:15:44It's not like Lorem Ipsum Dolar.

0:15:46And that comes up and Heywood Floyd's looking at it

0:15:49and he's like puzzled by it.

0:15:50And I sort of think that that scene is like maybe the only scene of the film that actually doesn't fit.

0:15:56That's actually there just as a gag.

0:15:58Because, as you said, he's been flying around the galaxy for a long time.

0:16:06He's been on these ships before.

0:16:07I find it hard to believe he hadn't had to go to the bathroom before.

0:16:10And secondly, if everyone who ever flew on these ships used the zero gravity toilet,

0:16:17would they have to have like all of these instructions?

0:16:20I mean it's clearly a joke for the contemporary audience watching the film.

0:16:26Right.

0:16:26Which there's really very little of that. The other thing is that the stewardesses,

0:16:30I think we can call them a stewardess because they're not really a flight attack.

0:16:33The stewardesses shoes which have some velcro on the bottom to keep her from,

0:16:38to allow her to walk in zero gravity, it said grip shoes on the side.

0:16:43Right.

0:16:43And for me that, and it looked cool, it was almost like an Adidas looking thing,

0:16:47But for me that was another thing like a thing for the audience because if everybody wore those shoes

0:16:52You wouldn't put grip to it doesn't say tennis shoes on the side of my shoes, you know

0:16:57It doesn't you know, like so it was sort of a way to give out some scientific information

0:17:03Yeah, it was almost as though they they did like

0:17:05It was almost the equivalent of putting a graphic on screen with an arrow

0:17:09You know like a pop-up graphic right that like labels it or explains it or like you do and you know

0:17:15Like some comic books will explain, you know, like like the old Dick Tracy comics, right?

0:17:20Would draw like a little arrow to his watch and say two-way wrist radio, right?

0:17:24It's almost proof of how smart we are about the future, right?

0:17:27You know and I do kind of miss Pan Am now now after seeing it again, you know

0:17:32Is there any more Pan Am airline? No, no, and they were gonna be the ones that made it to the future

0:17:36But they didn't I guess yeah, it's weird. We don't really do that. It was still good, right?

0:17:43- Right, Hilton's still there. - Hilton's still there.

0:17:44It was Ma Bell, AT&T, I guess.

0:17:47I don't know what it was exactly,

0:17:48but anyhow, interesting on that.

0:17:51Great time.

0:17:52- I do, and I, there's so many scenes that I love,

0:17:55but the scene in Hilton, to me, is one of my favorites.

0:17:59It's-- - The one we did.

0:18:00- Right. - Yeah, right.

0:18:01- The one we did a read-through here for the opening.

0:18:04And there's something about the way

0:18:07that the guy who plays Haywood Floyd,

0:18:09I don't know, I don't remember his name as an actor.

0:18:12as far as I know he's never been in anything

0:18:13I've seen since, but he's so deadpan

0:18:16in terms of, he obviously knows,

0:18:19but he's not underplaying it, he's not overplaying it,

0:18:22he's just stone-faced about it.

0:18:24And he's not tight-lipped about it.

0:18:28He seems like exactly the sort of guy

0:18:30who you'd want in the government to trust

0:18:33with the single greatest secret the government's ever had.

0:18:36He really does seem like the perfect guy.

0:18:38- Yeah, and then he does the presentation later

0:18:41where he doesn't really say anything to anyone.

0:18:43- Right.

0:18:44- He's like perfect government scientific bureaucrat.

0:18:47- Right.

0:18:48He's still really the only guy who knows

0:18:50what the hell's going on, even in the presentation, yeah.

0:18:53- Yeah, right.

0:18:54Yeah, he's just trying to keep them in line, so to speak.

0:18:58- Sort of like, it's almost like just a formality,

0:19:03like just good manners that I'm not gonna not address you,

0:19:07but I'm not going to tell you anything

0:19:09when I do address you.

0:19:10- Right, and you have to keep up the charade of the epidemic.

0:19:13- Right, but that's a beautiful Kubrickian thing too,

0:19:15is that he sets up the scene with Smyslov in the Hilton.

0:19:18And the end of that scene that we just kind of went through

0:19:23is where he accuses Floyd of hiding the fact

0:19:27that there's an epidemic on the clavian base.

0:19:29And then later he makes the presentation

0:19:32and he talks about what's going on in the base

0:19:34and at the end of the presentation he says,

0:19:35"And that's why it's so important

0:19:36that we keep up the appearance of an epidemic at the base.

0:19:40So at the moment when we first saw Floyd,

0:19:44we didn't know what he thought about this idea

0:19:47of an epidemic and later we find out what a cool cat he is

0:19:50because he's orchestrated this entire cover story.

0:19:53It's a good exposition by Kubrick

0:19:55because we know as little as the people in the scene know.

0:19:59We are like the Russians in the first scene

0:20:01and in the second scene of the presentation,

0:20:04we are like the ignorant other officials

0:20:06from the other area, so it's nice.

0:20:08It's like the film we learn as characters

0:20:13in the film learn, sort of.

0:20:15Like Heywood's got one over on us, too.

0:20:18- Right.

0:20:19And then there's the, you pointed it out,

0:20:22that on the next shuttle, the smaller one

0:20:24that goes from the space station to Clavius,

0:20:27where they're wearing actual astronaut suits.

0:20:30- When they're having sandwiches.

0:20:31- And they're eating sandwiches.

0:20:32And the one guy is like, great presentation.

0:20:34- Yeah, you really bucked up the truth.

0:20:36You didn't do anything.

0:20:37You did nothing of this sort.

0:20:39- Right, really.

0:20:40- I mean, unless there were some other speech he gave

0:20:42that we didn't see.

0:20:44- I don't, well, maybe, but I don't think so.

0:20:46I think it was in reference to that presentation,

0:20:48and I think he was just trying to be complimentary

0:20:50to clearly, you know--

0:20:51- Kissing up to him.

0:20:52- To the highest ranking guy

0:20:53that he's probably ever gonna encounter in his career.

0:20:56- But that guy knew what was going on at Clavius.

0:20:58- Right.

0:20:59- So he was one of the guys at the meeting, you know, so.

0:21:02I don't know, "Clevius," good place for a mystery.

0:21:05- So that, you know, and clearly,

0:21:07for people who aren't a fan of the movie, the--

0:21:09- Well, they certainly would have hit pause by now.

0:21:12- Right.

0:21:13- On this podcast.

0:21:14- Well, the complaint, and it has merit, really,

0:21:18is that the film is tedious.

0:21:20It's tedious deliberately, though, right?

0:21:23- It's glacial.

0:21:24- Right. - Yeah, yeah.

0:21:25- There's, yeah, there's extended sequences

0:21:28of people doing truly mundane things,

0:21:31And the point of it, it's almost like a deliberation

0:21:34on what the mundane aspects of the future are going to be.

0:21:39It's like almost like a painstakingly detailed,

0:21:44we've thought of every single thing

0:21:46and we're gonna show it to you.

0:21:47And the pacing of it, it does,

0:21:50it always puts me in a certain mindset

0:21:52where it does, it zones me out.

0:21:54- Yeah, and that, and Dave's, and Bob's breathing too,

0:21:59like the whole thing has sort of a zen sort of a quantity,

0:22:03quality to it. Like when he opens,

0:22:06when he's going to use the explosive bolts to get back into the discovery,

0:22:10when he opens that hand crank door,

0:22:13it takes forever. Like he just turns it and turns it and turns it and turns it.

0:22:19And we're waiting and we're waiting and we're waiting and the tension is

0:22:21building and building and building. I mean, it's just beautiful.

0:22:24And the whole film is, I mean,

0:22:25The whole middle section of that film is the most anti-science fiction, science fiction

0:22:30film ever made.

0:22:32In the time it took him to open that door, in most science fiction films, civilizations

0:22:37will have born, lived, and died in the same time it took Dave to open the door.

0:22:42New generations of weapons will be developed to counter the weapons that would have been

0:22:46shown 15 minutes ago.

0:22:49Exactly.

0:22:51It is a science fiction movie, but it's...

0:22:53Our idea of what a science fiction movie is now is a lot different than it was in 1968,

0:22:57too.

0:22:58I think there's...

0:22:59And most of them owe everything to it, I would say.

0:23:03One of the little oddities about it is that it's a G-rated movie, and surely the only

0:23:09G-rated movie Stanley Kubrick ever made.

0:23:13Which I think, A, is a little weird because it just seems to me like a murderous robot

0:23:22is maybe PG already.

0:23:25Four people get murdered, including Frank Poole, who I think kind of gets murdered in

0:23:32one of the most terrifying ways imaginable.

0:23:35It's maybe even worse than drowning, right?

0:23:38Just to be in a suit knowing that you've been cut.

0:23:41know he had a couple seconds there before he died where he knew well I'm

0:23:44gonna die right I'm gonna float away into truly oblivion yeah and of course

0:23:49the actual act takes place off-screen right which is so interesting since we

0:23:53they've spent their time to be spent his time showing us every little detail of

0:23:57every little thing except for the most crucial moment in that reel of the film

0:24:00that happens off-frame on a frame and the murder of the three crew members who

0:24:07who are hibernating is something too, yeah.

0:24:10If it was a murderous robot, it would have been PG-13,

0:24:15but it's a murderous mainframe.

0:24:17That's a little different.

0:24:18- Right, and I do think that that might be why

0:24:20that they didn't see it that way,

0:24:22because HAL's physical instantiation isn't a robot,

0:24:26isn't a humanoid type C-3PO thing.

0:24:29- Right. - It's really just

0:24:30a presence on the ship.

0:24:31He's a camera, you know, he's a series of red cameras

0:24:34and a voice, and that's it.

0:24:36Like if you want to think about it, it's almost like he's the ship.

0:24:40Right.

0:24:41Yeah, it's like when we think of being killed by machines, generally we imagine them marching

0:24:45at us with lasers, you know what I mean?

0:24:50Not turning off the power to our hibernation cocoons.

0:24:54And that whole sequence after Hal kills Frank Poole and his body is going out into oblivion.

0:25:04And what Dave Bowman does then is never explain.

0:25:09He doesn't say anything,

0:25:10'cause the only person he would talk to would be Hal.

0:25:13And he clearly knows, I guess, it seems realistic to me,

0:25:15it seems, you know, but it also seems like

0:25:18unlike most Hollywood movies where he never, you know,

0:25:22does like a shakes his fist at Hal and swears revenge

0:25:25and screams at him and says,

0:25:27"Well, I'm gonna go get his body or something like that.

0:25:30"I'm not gonna let him,

0:25:33I'm not gonna let him go like that.

0:25:35I mean, clearly he knew he was dead.

0:25:37I think the only reason he went to get him

0:25:39is out of respect for his friend and clearly,

0:25:41it wasn't like he thought

0:25:42he had any hope of saving his life.

0:25:44He just, he went out to retrieve his body

0:25:49and it's minutes long.

0:25:51I mean, I wonder how long that scene is.

0:25:54That's one of those things where I wouldn't be surprised

0:25:55if somebody told me it was actually 20 minutes long.

0:25:58I don't even know, it might be 20 minutes

0:26:00before he gets down the steps,

0:26:02gets into a... From the time he leaves until the time he blows through the

0:26:07explosive bolts to get back in that is a long and again glacial

0:26:12and quiet sort of a sequence. You know like even when he blows the bolts

0:26:17you don't even hear the explosion. It's sort of like the Ridley Scott line right?

0:26:20In space no one can hear you scream. Like there's no sound of the explosion.

0:26:24The only sound comes as as he closes the door and air starts to rush back into the

0:26:28airlock. Sort of interesting choice there. And that is one of the

0:26:32when I say it's like super scientific, one of the ways that the film is is when the camera is

0:26:37exterior in space, there is no sound. Spaceships don't make any whooshing sound. It's just pure

0:26:43silence. And the sound, some of the sounds in the movie, it was so loud in the theater.

0:26:47The silence really pops. The silence, it's like, you know, in great visual, in graphic design,

0:26:53where if you make truly great use of white space, it's striking. But then the only time he ever

0:27:00interrupts that would be to use the breathing of an astronaut and sort of it

0:27:05almost like audio audio wise puts you in a first-person perspective yes yes as the

0:27:11same way of a point-of-view camera that's exact I mean that's exactly it

0:27:14every time you're the breathing you are Dave like in a way you know what I mean

0:27:17you are booming so it almost makes my face feel hot like I can feel my own hot

0:27:23breath in a glass you know and closed helmet right

0:27:28- So did we waste enough time talking about 2001 yet?

0:27:32- Well, I could never waste enough time.

0:27:33- I know.

0:27:33- Here's my question for you is if Hal killed me

0:27:37and my body was floating out into the middle of nowhere

0:27:41between Jupiter and Mars, would you get in a pod

0:27:44and come out and rescue my body?

0:27:45- Yes, because I, at that moment,

0:27:48I did not know that Hal knew.

0:27:52Remember, Hal doesn't reveal that he had read his lips

0:27:55until after.

0:27:56So I, you get the feeling though

0:28:01that Bowman is suspicious beyond the fact

0:28:04of just, just from the look on his face.

0:28:07But yeah, of course I'd come and get you, Jon.

0:28:10- All right, good to know, Jim.

0:28:11- But then when I got back and I couldn't get in,

0:28:13I'd have to let you float away.

0:28:15- I think Bowman at that point is angry,

0:28:18'cause I think he knows it's Hal's fault,

0:28:20but that he's only unsure whether it's Hal is malfunctioning

0:28:26- Or malevolent. - Or malevolent.

0:28:28- Yeah, right, right. - Right.

0:28:29And so I think, though, and I think he's so

0:28:32in a state of shock, because, you know,

0:28:34I mean, obviously he was good, he was his friend,

0:28:36the only guy he's talked to in the last year or something.

0:28:38I don't know how long he'd been up there, but--

0:28:40- A long time. - It's an 18-month mission,

0:28:41and it seems like they're pretty far along in it.

0:28:43- Well, it's mostly almost there,

0:28:45because he sees the video transmission from Floyd

0:28:50when he's disconnecting Hal, and that means--

0:28:53- That's when he's up there. - And he says,

0:28:55"We're only going to give you this message now that you're in reach of Jupiter."

0:28:59- Jupiter, right.

0:29:00Yeah, so it must be like 18 months.

0:29:01So in like 18 months, he's the only guy he's known.

0:29:05He's in a state of shock.

0:29:06He forgets his helmet.

0:29:09But whether he completely forgot the helmet or just made the assumption that I don't really

0:29:13need it because I'm not going out of the pod, I'm just going to use the arms to get Frank

0:29:17and then Hal will let me back in here, just never even occurred to him that Hal wouldn't

0:29:22let him back in.

0:29:23- Yeah, that's the answer, I think.

0:29:25And then there's, you know, you go into that whole sequence of the slitscreen camera and

0:29:33everything that goes into there.

0:29:34Now there's two ways this movie can go, really.

0:29:37One way is if you stay on the same path, you wind up in the room with the white floors

0:29:42and Dave Bowman and the changing of time and the space baby.

0:29:47But if you make a little left-hand turn right there, you run right into Terrence Malick's

0:29:51Tree of Life.

0:29:52And then that movie takes over from there.

0:29:54So that's the primordial ooze from which interesting movies come or something.

0:30:02Although you can't make Tree of Life into a science fiction movie.

0:30:05That would be a hell of a double feature.

0:30:07Yeah, you better drink some coffee.

0:30:11That would be like six hours.

0:30:14I could stand it.

0:30:15I don't know if anybody else could.

0:30:16I don't think Spencer could.

0:30:17I don't think my son could.

0:30:19I don't know what kind of state of mind you'd be in by the end of that, too.

0:30:24All right, well, that was good.

0:30:25Let me do the first sponsor read.

0:30:27I want to thank Squarespace.

0:30:30Squarespace is back on board this week to sponsor the show.

0:30:34You guys know who Squarespace is.

0:30:35It's a beautiful, intuitive website platform that allows anyone to easily create professional

0:30:41webpages, blogs, online stores, galleries.

0:30:46It's all on a single platform.

0:30:48You log in and you get to choose which parts of those things you want for your site.

0:30:54You simply start with one of their designs.

0:30:56You can start with one of their designs.

0:30:58You add your own images and content, anything you want to sell.

0:31:02You connect your social accounts, your Twitter account, your Facebook account, that sort

0:31:05of thing.

0:31:06And you'll have a website that looks great on every device because one of the things

0:31:09Squarespace has in all of their templates is that responsive design where the same thing,

0:31:15The same URL is optimized for the iPad, it's optimized for your iPhone or your smartphone,

0:31:20and it looks great on a big desktop monitor.

0:31:24All Squarespace accounts come with their award-winning 24/7 technical support, their cloud hosting,

0:31:31they take care of all the hosting needs, they do domain name registration, they have real-time

0:31:35analytics, so you log in, you get to see who's coming to your site where live.

0:31:41And if you sign up for a year, they even give you a free domain name.

0:31:46The new thing they have, this is the new thing, is this integrated store.

0:31:51They call it Squarespace Commerce.

0:31:53And you can add a fully integrated store to your website and start accepting payments

0:31:57and like everything else in Squarespace, literally in just minutes.

0:32:01You can sell anything.

0:32:02You can add a store and you get to set up what type of objects you're selling.

0:32:08easy store management and great options for payment.

0:32:12I think that they – I think it's Stripe.

0:32:14Yeah, I think that's their primary.

0:32:15That's their primary.

0:32:16Yeah, and everybody knows Stripe is just – it's the best way to do online commerce.

0:32:20So I mean it really took something that's a huge pain in the ass.

0:32:24I mean and Jim and I both know that setting up an online store and have made it really,

0:32:29really easy.

0:32:30So check them out.

0:32:32The URL is squarespace.com/thetalkshow.

0:32:37dot com slash the talk show that way they'll know you're coming here from the show but

0:32:42check them out especially if you've got something you've been thinking about setting up an online

0:32:46store that's new so check out what they have to offer before you make a mistake and go

0:32:50with someone else. Yeah I mean just brand new I think it's brand new and it's a whole

0:32:54suite of e-commerce features that are loaded into your account so it looks cool I've been

0:33:00playing around with it a little bit so it looks cool. They're a sponsor on the deck

0:33:03They are. They're a long time sponsor of the deck. Like other smart companies. Very smart

0:33:10companies. Let's talk about the deck. So when, how long have we been doing this?

0:33:15The deck's been going since about 2007, 2008, was kind of in its infancy and then really

0:33:24started getting going in 2009. So it kind of, it ran as a small text ad service as a

0:33:32sort of a proof of concept and originally just ran on Kudol.com and then after that

0:33:36it got we sort of got serious about it so I think it was 2009 was when we we might have run a little

0:33:42at the end of 2008 but 2009 would have been the first year of the deck I guess and here we are in

0:33:4713 so are you sure you don't have the years wrong on that I thought it was sooner I mean or older

0:33:52I thought it was no I don't think it's much older than that we happen to be sitting in my office so

0:33:57so I can just look on my computer and see.

0:33:59- What I remember is that it first launched

0:34:01with you and 37signals and Zeldin.

0:34:05- That is correct.

0:34:06You are correct.

0:34:09- And you guys, the Jewelboxing, I think.

0:34:13- Yes, 2006 and 2007, 2008 and 2009.

0:34:18- That makes sense 'cause it really sort of coincides

0:34:20with when I took Darren Fireball full time.

0:34:22And prior to that--

0:34:24- Man, it's a long time ago now.

0:34:26- Feels like it.

0:34:27But prior to that, I'd been selling my own totally text ads.

0:34:31Same spot where the deck ads are on Daring Fireball.

0:34:34- Right, I remember that, yeah.

0:34:35- It was just text.

0:34:36And similar model where it was sort of like

0:34:38my RSS sponsorship still are,

0:34:39where it's one spot a week.

0:34:41One sponsor a week.

0:34:43And you were buying those spots occasionally

0:34:47for Jewel Boxing.

0:34:49- Right.

0:34:50- And I don't think Field Notes existed then.

0:34:51- No, it was just starting 2007.

0:34:53- I think it was Jewel Boxing.

0:34:55'cause back then people actually needed

0:34:56jewel boxes for discs.

0:34:58I mean, that's how old we are now.

0:34:59- Despite everything, some people still do.

0:35:03Business, jewel boxes still selling.

0:35:04Not very many compared to the old days.

0:35:06- And I was gonna go,

0:35:10when I wanted to take Daring Farboul full-time,

0:35:12I needed somebody else to sell the ads.

0:35:14I needed bigger and better ads.

0:35:16I needed some more money from it.

0:35:18And so I just emailed you to say,

0:35:19"Hey, thanks for all of the jewel boxing things

0:35:22"you've sponsored here,

0:35:23"but I'm going to start looking for something else for ads."

0:35:28And you were like, "Hold that thought, John.

0:35:30"Give me a week."

0:35:32And then the next week you were like,

0:35:34"All right, you want to be in the deck."

0:35:35- Right, well we had done,

0:35:37I was always convinced it would work,

0:35:39and I believe it was at South By in 2006

0:35:43where it was easy to talk Jason Fried into it

0:35:45because we shared an office.

0:35:47So I'm like, "Jason, I'm going to do this ad thing.

0:35:48"Come and do it with me."

0:35:49And then I talked Jeffrey Zeldman into it

0:35:53a list apart. And then it ran with us three as the only place where the ads appeared for

0:35:57a little bit, for a while. I believe you were next or maybe Andy. You were Andy. I don't

0:36:03know who was next.

0:36:04It was really close between me and Andy Baio's waxy.org.

0:36:07And then it started. Then it grew fairly quickly. Now it's growing slowly. But that's how we

0:36:12want it to be. At that point, it was relatively easy to... There were different concerns about

0:36:21getting new affiliates at that point.

0:36:23Now we're looking for exactly the right affiliate and one that the ads work well for the audience

0:36:28and that is designed properly, whatever.

0:36:30But back then, nobody was carrying ads.

0:36:34And when you put the ads on your site or Jason Kotke did or we did, there was some concern

0:36:42that our readers would see that as a betrayal, which seems kind of funny now, doesn't it?

0:36:47Like to be so worried about that.

0:36:49Yeah.

0:36:50And that is definitely true.

0:36:51were in those, you know, I've been doing Daring Fireball

0:36:54for 10 years, so we can talk about it

0:36:56as a little bit over 10 years now, but as a decade.

0:36:58And in that first half, the 2002, 2003, 2004 years,

0:37:03nobody had ads on their weblogs.

0:37:06Nobody had any kind of ads.

0:37:08And then Google had the AdSense thing,

0:37:13but that was still just text, and it was all pay-per-click.

0:37:16And that was, I mean, it really was controversial

0:37:19and people would just add like a single Google text thing.

0:37:22It was like a, I don't know, a complete aversion

0:37:24to advertising at all in this.

0:37:26- Yeah.

0:37:27We were more altruistic back in our young days, I guess.

0:37:30- But at the same time, there were,

0:37:33I've always been, other websites, the CNETs,

0:37:35the New York Times is the ones that were not personal

0:37:39but somehow, I don't know what you want to call them,

0:37:42institutionalized news sites had the worst ads.

0:37:47I mean, ads that are worse than the ones you even see today.

0:37:49I mean, I think like about 10, eight, nine years ago,

0:37:53advertising online was absolutely at like the bottom.

0:37:57- Right.

0:37:58- Punch the Monkey, you remember that?

0:38:00They would have these ads that--

0:38:02- There's plenty of bad shit out there now too though.

0:38:04- Yeah, maybe I just don't see it

0:38:05'cause I have flash turned off on my computer.

0:38:07I don't know, maybe I shouldn't say that.

0:38:09- Would you think, should I, I mean,

0:38:10the idea of the deck was, just to go over the basics

0:38:13if you know this, I'm sorry to repeat,

0:38:14but the idea of the deck was we thought

0:38:16there was probably a better way to do display advertising that would provide benefits for

0:38:22all three people in the advertising equation.

0:38:24By the three people in the equation, I mean the publisher, the advertiser, and the reader.

0:38:30If we felt like when we made the deck, if we could come up with a concept for delivering

0:38:34advertiser that would be beneficial to all three of those people, then it would work.

0:38:38Up until that point, it was for the advertiser, it was for the publisher, it was for the publisher,

0:38:45It was for the reader, whatever.

0:38:47Our concept was if we put together a confederation of like-minded sites that we displayed a single

0:38:57ad from an advertiser that was truly relevant to the readership that everybody could benefit.

0:39:05We've never said that if an ad is in the deck, we endorse its business, but it's sort of

0:39:10an implied endorsement since we turn down ads all the time.

0:39:14Since we're fairly low-fi and low-tech, and we're serving up, I mean the deck is not any

0:39:20whiz-bang programming thing, and we're serving up these ads, we have very low overhead on

0:39:25the network, and so we deliver a lot of impressions for a relatively good cost.

0:39:31So lots of people want to buy on the deck, but we don't want the ads from lots of people.

0:39:35We want ads from people who have products and services that appeal to our audience in

0:39:39a real way, not just in a sort of, you know.

0:39:43I'm unconvinced that an algorithm can ever really choose relevance for advertising to

0:39:50a marketplace.

0:39:51I mean, maybe someday I can.

0:39:52The other thing that's not really of direct concern to people who read sites that are

0:39:57on the deck, people who read Daring Fireball or who read Kaki, they don't need to understand

0:40:02this and it doesn't matter.

0:40:05But the fact is the deck has never paid by the page view ever.

0:40:08In fact, that was part of the concept of this.

0:40:12It's better for everybody if we do it this way, where advertisers just paid the deck

0:40:17a set fee and they run for the month.

0:40:23It's not that we don't give them traffic numbers and we tell them collectively we tend to do

0:40:29this many page views a month or whatever, but if we happen to do more, we do a little

0:40:33less in a month, it doesn't affect it.

0:40:38That's to me the biggest thing.

0:40:39To me, that's even bigger than the unobtrusiveness of the actual physical format of the ad on

0:40:43the page is that it takes away any sort of impetus to trump up your page views.

0:40:48There is no reason.

0:40:49And so you don't see, there's nobody I know of on the deck who takes long articles and

0:40:53breaks them into six pages, which is truly just, it's just a scam.

0:40:57I mean, and I don't even use that word lightly.

0:41:00It's a scam to get your page views up.

0:41:03And that works against nobody.

0:41:06So the pay-per-view model that most of the rest of online advertising uses is bad for

0:41:11everybody because it's bad for the advertiser because they're getting these numbers that

0:41:17don't correlate to people.

0:41:18They correlate to people clicking on web pages, right?

0:41:21So when you go through and the worst of it now, the way that that's sort of bottomed

0:41:25out are the slideshows, right?

0:41:28Here's 20 ways that Apple could screw up the iWatch.

0:41:34And then you've got to click 20 times and it counts as 20 pages.

0:41:37But that's no good for the advertiser.

0:41:39Right.

0:41:40Because each one of those advertisers, let's say there's four advertisers in the slide

0:41:43view, they're all being charged the full price of a page view when it goes without saying

0:41:48that if I'm clicking through to 20 pictures and not seeing 20 pictures on one page, what's

0:41:51a more valuable impression?

0:41:55If I'm involved in an article, I'm reading it at Fireball or I'm reading a post from

0:42:00from TNet, Swiss Miss, or a long thread on MetaFilter,

0:42:04I'm involved in the ad is there.

0:42:06If I have to click through and see four ads,

0:42:09sure, we'll get four more impressions,

0:42:11but are those four impressions equal

0:42:13to the single impression?

0:42:14No, of course not.

0:42:15- Right.

0:42:15It's even worse for the reader.

0:42:17I mean, nobody ever in the history of the world has said,

0:42:19"You know what I like to do is I like to click 20 times

0:42:21"to see all 20 ideas you have about the--"

0:42:24- All the Kate Upton pictures I can handle, right?

0:42:26Whatever it is, yeah.

0:42:28And it's no good for the sites themselves,

0:42:30because then they're busy themselves

0:42:32with trumped up SEO headlines.

0:42:36Who feels good about taking a nice long article

0:42:39that's really a good read and chopping it up into bits,

0:42:42where you know that each one of those times

0:42:44where you make asking the reader to click the thing,

0:42:46you know that half of them are gonna just drop out.

0:42:48- And some are gonna drop away, yeah.

0:42:49- Right, it's almost heartbreaking to know

0:42:51that if you've written something that really is good,

0:42:53like a real nice 2,000 word piece,

0:42:55It's almost heartbreaking to think that two thirds of the readers only go to the first

0:43:00seven hundred words because they just closed the window.

0:43:03So it doesn't work for anybody.

0:43:04And yet it's like entrenched.

0:43:06Right.

0:43:07And it's not just that.

0:43:08It's the idea of displaying five ads on a page and counting them all as an you don't

0:43:15count each of those as somehow for some reason you don't count each of those as a fifth of

0:43:19an impression.

0:43:20Right.

0:43:21You count them all as a full impression.

0:43:22So I don't know, maybe we're over-delivering, but the dirty little secret of the deck is

0:43:26for the right advertiser, it works very well.

0:43:28Most of our advertisers renew.

0:43:30Advertisers that have the service or a product that fits with the mindset of the affiliates

0:43:34that are in the deck do very well.

0:43:36So we don't have to change all the advertising on the web.

0:43:39We just have to keep going.

0:43:41The equivalent, and it's hard to equate the ads in any one medium to another.

0:43:46How is a TV commercial like a magazine ad?

0:43:50It's hard to draw the comparison.

0:43:52But to me, the way that there's five ads on a page at the Washington Post or something

0:43:58like that, and they sell them all as separate page views, to me it's like selling a full-page

0:44:01ad in the newspaper or magazine, but putting five ads on the page.

0:44:06Right.

0:44:07That's the point I was trying to make.

0:44:08That's a good way to put it.

0:44:09But you know what it is?

0:44:10I often think that buying a slot on the deck, which buys you one slot on the deck, buys

0:44:17you 3% of all the impressions across all the sites and services in the network for a calendar

0:44:25month and that works out to somewhere between 2 and 3 million impressions.

0:44:29But buying that, currently it does, but buying that is most akin to buying a full page in

0:44:35the New Yorker in a magazine.

0:44:36It's more like a magazine ad because you're buying a monthly thing.

0:44:41Your ad is by itself.

0:44:44It is adjacent to content but it is not adjacent to other ads.

0:44:48It's a very difficult thing to quantify the results that you get for it but if you

0:44:54buy the ad in the New Yorker and your sales go up, you probably renew the ad and you can

0:44:59track who saw it in the New Yorker.

0:45:00Well, it's the same thing with the deck.

0:45:02So I think the deck, if it's like anything in old media, it's more like a full page

0:45:08magazine ad in a magazine than it is like a TV commercial or like a traditional banner

0:45:13ad. I just wish the deck could just take over all the pages on the affiliates. The deck

0:45:19ad could get really big and blot out all the content. I think the readers and the advertisers

0:45:23would appreciate that.

0:45:24Yeah, or if you could use a little JavaScript to make the ad march over the page and you

0:45:29have to shoot it before it and it'll go back to the spot that it was in.

0:45:34And then it puts up a dialogue that says,

0:45:36do you really want to leave this ad?

0:45:38I love those.

0:45:39But it's like, yes, you're trying to leave this page.

0:45:40Now you don't know what to click

0:45:41'cause you feel like you're in the spammer's embrace already

0:45:44like, and so if you click, no, I don't want to leave,

0:45:46you're saying, yes, I appreciate your takeover ad.

0:45:49But if you say, I want to leave,

0:45:50you think maybe that they're smart enough

0:45:52to make that the default that sends you

0:45:54to the Florida property page or whatever,

0:45:56whoever the advertiser is or something more nefarious.

0:45:59- Have you noticed that Netflix still does pop under ads?

0:46:04I don't see them. I don't know why. Maybe it's because Safari's good at getting rid of them. I don't know.

0:46:08It's like a cat and mouse game, I think, between the browsers and the rotten thieves who are trying to circumvent the anti-popup thing.

0:46:16But every once in a while--and I still see them from Netflix. And every time I see one--

0:46:21I've been a happy Netflix customer for years, and I still am. But every time I see a pop-under from Netflix,

0:46:26it puts the idea in my head that maybe I should unsubscribe from Netflix just because they're using some of the money to do pop-under ads.

0:46:32which are the worst.

0:46:33- Right, so it's not working.

0:46:36The advertisers are not working.

0:46:37In fact, it's counterproductive on you.

0:46:39I don't know who's, I don't see them.

0:46:41I don't know, maybe I must have some settings

0:46:42set up or something.

0:46:43- I don't see many.

0:46:44I do have to admit that I use Safari.

0:46:46I have to admit they're pretty good at blocking.

0:46:49- Right, so if you are like Squarespace

0:46:52and you have a product or service that could benefit

0:46:55by being in front of millions of creative, intelligent,

0:46:59curious, and good looking people, you should go to the deck

0:47:02and give us a holler.

0:47:03Let me ask you about another subject.

0:47:05- All right.

0:47:05- Tell me about Webstock.

0:47:07You and I were both in New Zealand,

0:47:08so tell me about that.

0:47:09- We were there a week ago, as we're recording today,

0:47:12Friday, February 22nd, a week ago we were together,

0:47:15except instead of being in Chicago,

0:47:16we were in Wellington, New Zealand.

0:47:18- Just about this time you were doing your presentation.

0:47:21- I think that's probably about right.

0:47:22- A week ago.

0:47:23- Although--

0:47:24- Well, the time difference was--

0:47:25- Right, which is mind-blowing, right?

0:47:26And there's this whole thing where

0:47:28the international date line, you cross,

0:47:30So they're in tomorrow already.

0:47:33- Right.

0:47:34Well, it's not good.

0:47:35That's sort of like the end of 2001,

0:47:39the end of the day.

0:47:39You just can't really understand it.

0:47:40- You know what?

0:47:41I should have had though that our friend,

0:47:42our mutual great friend, Michael Lop,

0:47:44had a birthday and he...

0:47:47- He left California on the 9th on the airplane

0:47:51from San Francisco.

0:47:51I was on the plane with him.

0:47:52We arrived in Wellington, New Zealand on the 11th.

0:47:56Michael's birthday's the 10th,

0:47:57so he got gypped out of a birthday.

0:47:58- Right, he had no birthday.

0:47:59Or maybe it's a positive, because maybe it doesn't have to count.

0:48:01- Right, now maybe, yeah, does it legally count

0:48:04as being a year older than when you weren't around

0:48:06on your birthday?

0:48:07- I don't know.

0:48:08Talk about, it's a great conference.

0:48:10What did you think of it?

0:48:11- I really, I went back, I was there two years ago,

0:48:15and it was such a long flight, and as soon as I came back,

0:48:17I thought, well, that was great, but never again,

0:48:19because the flight was too long.

0:48:20And then I think it's like the way that, I don't know,

0:48:23they say with, you know, like childbearing,

0:48:25where it hurts, and then women say,

0:48:27well, never gonna do it again.

0:48:28But then you're engineered to forget how painful it was.

0:48:31It's like, the flight's not that bad.

0:48:34But I remember it was such a great conference two years ago,

0:48:37and so I jumped at the chance to go back.

0:48:39And I thought the same thing, that it was, man,

0:48:41I would have loved to have been here even if I wasn't speaking,

0:48:44just to see these talks.

0:48:45Yeah.

0:48:46It's the best conference I've ever-- I've even put on conferences,

0:48:49and I never did that good.

0:48:50I mean, it's the best conference I've ever been to.

0:48:52Maybe only rivaled by 2007, 2008, South By,

0:48:57before it turned into the monster that took over the world.

0:49:00The thing, it's a single track with a small exception.

0:49:04It's a single track concept.

0:49:05So there's about 850 people there,

0:49:07and everybody sees all the same talks.

0:49:08In the middle of the day, half the people who are more

0:49:11developers go one way, and half the people who are more

0:49:13designers go the other way.

0:49:14But by and large, it's a single track conference.

0:49:16And I have never been to a conference

0:49:19where more of the speakers sat and rooted

0:49:21for the other speakers.

0:49:22I mean, for me, that really said what

0:49:24interesting and well-programmed conference it was is that I wanted to

0:49:30see all the other speakers and not just because I knew some of them but but

0:49:33because and many of them I didn't know at all or only know now and that was

0:49:37sort of interesting and it's in a cool place Wellington's a cool place it's a

0:49:41very cool place and it's nice it is a really nice tree and I was every speaker

0:49:46from North America well or your yeah but I think we're all from the northern

0:49:52hemisphere. I don't think they had any, what do you call them, antipodes?

0:49:55Yeah, I don't know. It depends on where you count Craig Modis from being from.

0:50:00Yeah.

0:50:00If he's from San Francisco, he's one thing, but he's also from Tokyo.

0:50:04I don't know. Yeah. But it's really nice to go from mid-February northern hemisphere to

0:50:12mid-February southern hemisphere. I guess, what is that? That's the equivalent of August?

0:50:17Yeah. It's like summer, mid-summer.

0:50:18- Yeah, and it's not real hot.

0:50:22It was, I don't know, 70 every day.

0:50:25It was like 70 and sunny every day.

0:50:27- Which apparently is not the case in Wellington

0:50:29most of the time.

0:50:30It's very windy and it rains quite a bit,

0:50:32but we didn't see any of that.

0:50:33- Yeah, we had more rain too.

0:50:34- It could be that sort of thing where they tell everybody

0:50:35it's windy and rainy all the time to keep people away.

0:50:38Like they don't want to share their space

0:50:39with everybody else.

0:50:40It might be that.

0:50:41- I think the single-track nature of Webstock,

0:50:46I mean, and there's certainly other single-track conferences,

0:50:48But a lot of the other single-track conferences

0:50:50that I go to or have been to are significantly smaller.

0:50:54- Yeah.

0:50:55- The new one, Singleton, which has gone on two years

0:50:59in a row in October in Montreal is about 100,

0:51:02I think the two years have been 100 and 125 people or so.

0:51:06And C4 here in Chicago before that,

0:51:10it was like a 2006 to '10 thing.

0:51:11- Are those both nerdier?

0:51:13- Yeah, those are more specifically focused

0:51:17on Apple developers.

0:51:18Used to be Mac developers, but now clearly Mac and iOS,

0:51:22Coke developers, if you will.

0:51:23- I mean, there was some nerdiness of WebStack,

0:51:27but it was more of a general developer-designer,

0:51:31broadened your mind a little bit.

0:51:33Like, for example, Craig talked about what he called,

0:51:36what does he call the publishing, the subcompact publishing,

0:51:40talking about Marco a little bit, and the magazine,

0:51:42but also sort of general trends.

0:51:45It was more like that.

0:51:47It was more like big idea and then let's break it down

0:51:50as opposed to this is how you code a shopping cart

0:51:53and rails or whatever.

0:51:55- Right, and Craig, his Craig Mod's talk

0:51:58is probably a perfect example of that

0:51:59where I feel like they, I mean,

0:52:01the name of the conference, Webstock, implies its roots,

0:52:04which was people making websites.

0:52:06You know, back, I think this was the seventh year

0:52:07that they ran the conference, seventh grade.

0:52:09And I think originally it was more specific

0:52:12about designing and building websites

0:52:14and now they've gotten away from that.

0:52:16I mean, that's certainly part of it.

0:52:18But I think Craig's talk exemplified

0:52:19why they're getting away from that,

0:52:21because there's not that much of a difference.

0:52:22And if you're gonna do an online publication,

0:52:25you're gonna need web stuff and app stuff.

0:52:30- Right. - You know, I did a show

0:52:31of hands in my talk, 'cause I was curious,

0:52:32'cause I remember two years ago I did the same thing.

0:52:35You know, what are the people in the audience working on?

0:52:37And it was overwhelmingly websites, web stuff.

0:52:39And I asked this year how many people were working on apps.

0:52:42And I'd say easily over half the hands went up.

0:52:45And the most hands went up were the ones when you said how many are working on both.

0:52:48Right.

0:52:48You said you're working on websites and mobile apps and like the whole crowd.

0:52:53Yeah.

0:52:54Everything went up and that's, you know, I even put my hand up and I'm not working on any of that.

0:52:57I just got caught up in the emotion of the whole thing.

0:53:00And I think that, but I think that that, I think it speaks to the strength of the programming of the conference that Dave sort of adjusted instead of trying to replay what Webstock was in 2007.

0:53:12it's they've really sort of got their finger on the pulse of what are these people working on today.

0:53:17Or even if it's not what they're working on, it's what issues, what larger issues in design and

0:53:26development can we discuss that will benefit your work. And the other thing they do is they have the

0:53:32first two days of the conference are workshops. So you can go to a half-day workshop with Cragmod,

0:53:37for example, about subcompact publishing.

0:53:40And I think they actually, with their iPhones, published a book to Amazon

0:53:45in their half-day conference of photography.

0:53:47So, I mean, there was, I think the more practical sort of things like

0:53:52Karen McGrane's talks, and they wound up in the workshops where people could

0:53:57really get their hands on the stuff.

0:53:59And the more conceptual stuff wound up in the main presentations, I think.

0:54:05But I would encourage anybody who is interested in going to New Zealand to go to the next

0:54:12Web Stock.

0:54:13I hope they're all sold out.

0:54:16It's one of those things where I guess no matter how effusive our praise is of the conference,

0:54:22anybody who's listening from North America, even on the West Coast where you're already

0:54:26closer is still going to roll their eyes and think, "Well, I'm not going all the way to

0:54:30New Zealand for a conference."

0:54:32But if you've ever thought about going to New Zealand or maybe some kind of combined

0:54:36two-week trip where you'd go to Australia too or something like that, and you could

0:54:43work it out schedule-wise to do it with web stock in the middle, boy, that would be worth

0:54:47it.

0:54:48I mean, it really is the best.

0:54:49It's the best conference I know of that's going on right now.

0:54:51Yeah, yeah.

0:54:52And we'll see because it's in this beautiful hall.

0:54:55The main presentations are what's called the Wellington Town Hall, which was from 1906

0:54:58or something.

0:55:00And it's this big, beautiful old building.

0:55:02The Beatles played there, the Talking Heads played there, and all this other stuff happened

0:55:06there.

0:55:07It's quite an imposing stage for a speaker.

0:55:09But with the big earthquake in Christchurch a year ago, two years ago, they have made

0:55:18much stronger regulations about how buildings have to be supported.

0:55:22So the town hall is going to be closed for two years while they reinforce it.

0:55:26So I don't know what's going to happen with Webstock.

0:55:29For me, it's hard to imagine that happening without that beautiful building, but I suppose

0:55:32it could happen anywhere.

0:55:33I'll have to see what happens.

0:55:35My story on the earthquake was that it happened, and again, I certainly didn't suffer for it.

0:55:41You caused it.

0:55:42Right.

0:55:43But it happened two or three hours after our plane took off from Auckland, the 12-hour flight

0:55:49from Auckland to SFO.

0:55:51So we were in Auckland and there was no earthquake.

0:55:54we got on an airplane two or three hours later

0:55:55is when this truly horrifying earthquake,

0:55:58I mean, and again, I don't think it's hyperbole,

0:56:02devastated the city of Christchurch.

0:56:03And it was major, major world news.

0:56:07And so, like, mine and Amy's family saw this thing,

0:56:11major earthquake in New Zealand,

0:56:13and they didn't know what city,

0:56:14all they knew was we said we're going to New Zealand

0:56:16for a conference, and they, you know,

0:56:17blah, blah, blah, Wellington, Auckland, Christchurch.

0:56:19They didn't know.

0:56:20For all I knew, we were in Christchurch.

0:56:22And so they all tried calling us,

0:56:24and of course we couldn't get a call

0:56:25because we were only two or three,

0:56:27we had nine hours to go before we land in SFO.

0:56:30So when we landed in SFO, our phones,

0:56:32and we turned our phones on, it was like,

0:56:34voicemail, voicemail, voicemail, voicemail.

0:56:36Are you all right, are you all right, are you all right?

0:56:38And my first thought was, it's the way you always,

0:56:41when you get bad news and you just instantly blank

0:56:43and go into denial almost, and I was like,

0:56:46there was no earthquake in New Zealand.

0:56:48'Cause I was just there and there was no earthquake.

0:56:51It doesn't occur to you that something like that

0:56:52happen when you're flying over the Pacific.

0:56:54Right, especially when the other thing about that is remember when you fly from

0:56:58Auckland to San Francisco you pretty much arrive

0:57:01at the same time you left because of the international dateline so actually

0:57:04there's no time you know right if you leave there at three in the afternoon

0:57:07you get to San Francisco at about three in the afternoon it's almost like

0:57:10it's a free 24 hours. So of course it didn't happen.

0:57:14Yeah so if if if Lop's birthday had been a week later

0:57:17you would have had two birthdays, right?

0:57:20- You could have had two, oh yes,

0:57:23you could have had your birthday

0:57:24and then had your birthday again.

0:57:25- Right, except you would have spent

0:57:26the whole time on an airplane.

0:57:27- Yeah, which is not anybody's idea

0:57:29of a great birthday, I don't think.

0:57:30- All right, let me do the second sponsor.

0:57:31- Okay.

0:57:32- New sponsor, and this is really,

0:57:34I'd say this not because of the sponsor,

0:57:37but because I'm really impressed by what they've built.

0:57:39It's Everpix, E-V-E-R-P-I-X.

0:57:43Everpix is a smart photo platform

0:57:46that helps you make sense of your growing

0:57:47photo collection. They have no storage limit, so you have all your photos anywhere, everywhere,

0:57:54organized automatically in the cloud. Really, the bottom line, long story short, is that

0:57:59they're aiming to replace something like iPhoto or Lightroom as your canonical file store.

0:58:07Four photos. Four photos. And the problem that they're trying to solve is that they

0:58:13They think and I believe that the modern photographer is simply casual photographer is overwhelmed

0:58:21by the number of photos that they take.

0:58:23You take hundreds a month, thousands in a year and you end up, we've all had digital

0:58:28cameras now for probably like 10 years.

0:58:30We have libraries of 10 or more thousand files and nobody organizes them and let's not pretend

0:58:38that you're going to when you get back from your vacation and that you're going to take

0:58:40those 300 photos and put tags on all of them and name them all.

0:58:44So they have done all this algorithmically.

0:58:47It's really, really smart stuff from a really smart team.

0:58:50And they have a great iPhone app and iPad app for navigating these libraries.

0:58:55On the Mac, you can still use something like iPhoto or Lightroom to suck the photos off

0:59:01your card and to make color corrections and delete the ones that are no good and eyes

0:59:04are closed.

0:59:06But then instead of organizing them into albums or anything like that, just go through and

0:59:10iPhoto you tell Everpix's Mac client, it's sort of like Dropbox, it's just a simple little

0:59:17faceless thing that runs in the background, you get to pick which known file locations,

0:59:22whether you just pick a folder or you pick your iPhoto library, it uploads them to your

0:59:26account in the cloud. And everything else happens after that. The app is really, really

0:59:32impressive. By default, it just groups everything by date into events. It's really, really smart

0:59:37about detecting the interesting parts of a photo.

0:59:40So when it puts them together in a collage on screen

0:59:42for you to pick from and scroll through,

0:59:45it shows you just great little thumbnails

0:59:47and it's very fast, very beautiful.

0:59:51You can try it for free.

0:59:54The apps are all free, the software's free,

0:59:56and you can do a 30-day free trial

0:59:58just to see how it works.

1:00:00If you like it, you pay.

1:00:02I think it's $40 a month, or $40 a year, I'm sorry,

1:00:06or $5 a month, very reasonable, unlimited storage.

1:00:11And again, I was doubtful at the beginning.

1:00:16And I wasn't quite sure what it was.

1:00:17What it's not, it's not a replacement for Flickr,

1:00:19it's not Instagram, it's not photo sharing.

1:00:22It's your personal library, backed in the cloud,

1:00:25available on all of your devices all the time.

1:00:28I'm using it, I really couldn't be happier with it.

1:00:31I'm really impressed.

1:00:32I just, just before we recorded the show,

1:00:34I was showing Jim I was getting all maudlin and showing baby pictures of Jonas when he was a

1:00:39Year old the pictures. I haven't seen in forever and it was it was just great

1:00:44So ever picks what you want to do is go to ever picks dot-com

1:00:49Eevee er pix calm and check it out. My thanks to them for sponsoring the show. I will check it out, too

1:00:57Because I had said the other day that I hope that there's actually there is reincarnation

1:01:02Because then I will be able to organize my digital photos

1:01:04Because otherwise it's never gonna happen. Yeah, I think it's a great premise

1:01:09I really do the premise is you're never going to organize them just give them to us and we'll organize them for you

1:01:14Right, right that long story short. That's the gist of the app

1:01:16And it's it's I think that they've got it

1:01:19Do people even delete you still delete photos and say that's not a good like I think I know it's just there's so much

1:01:24It's like I do that when I shoot with my real camera

1:01:28I do because I shoot so many pictures.

1:01:30But I used to do like a two pass thing

1:01:33where the first pass is go through,

1:01:35like with Webstock, I took, I don't know,

1:01:36300 pictures down there.

1:01:38First pass is just go through

1:01:40and pick out anything that's just awful,

1:01:43you know, out of focus or the lights way off

1:01:46or somebody's eyes are closed.

1:01:48And then if there's one where I took like,

1:01:50let's say four pictures of the same thing,

1:01:52I'll quick make a snap decision

1:01:55which one's the good one and go on.

1:01:56- And delete the other three.

1:01:57And then the old way, then what I used to do years ago,

1:02:00and I still do every once in a while,

1:02:02but I have to admit I just never get around to it

1:02:04with most events, then I would go through

1:02:07and really start thinking about which ones are good

1:02:09and giving a four star ranking to this one

1:02:11and five star to this one and stuff like that.

1:02:14Giving them titles or putting names and stuff.

1:02:18- I mean, I don't do anything.

1:02:20I don't delete, I don't title, I don't organize.

1:02:23And it's not that I don't want to,

1:02:27it's just that I, it's just so much.

1:02:29- It just never seems like there's a right time.

1:02:31When you really want to take two hours and go through.

1:02:33And it's, you know, once you've fallen behind,

1:02:35now you've got, you know, a year worth of photos.

1:02:38- Well, CJ said, who we met, who I met,

1:02:40you've met before CJ at Webstock,

1:02:42said that an eight hour layover in Singapore

1:02:45is a good time to organize photos.

1:02:47(both laughing)

1:02:48So that seems like a long layover to me.

1:02:50- Yeah, hanging out with CJ at Webstock

1:02:53made me feel great about my New Zealand to Philadelphia

1:02:58by way of Auckland and LAX.

1:03:01I went through LAX, but there's no difference really

1:03:05than going through SFO.

1:03:06It made me feel a lot better

1:03:07'cause he was going home to Sweden

1:03:09and he was flying, instead of flying east,

1:03:12he was flying west.

1:03:12So it was like New Zealand to Australia to Singapore

1:03:16to God knows where, Timbuktu.

1:03:19Right, it was like one of the Indiana Jones trip, you know dot the picture of the little plane on the map on the sepia tone map

1:03:26So what would you go back to web stock I would I think I mean I would hope to be invited again

1:03:34But I but you know what I would like to do and we should get we should talk to Mike Monteiro

1:03:39Because he did it a little bit is I would like to go for longer

1:03:41go to web stock and then take a car around the South Island because everybody said that's like

1:03:46That's the place and that's where a lot of them there are some locations around Wellington from the the Lord of the Rings movie

1:03:54That's sort of like their cottage industry. Yeah

1:03:56Tourist pitch anyhow is is go there and see the Lord of the Rings

1:04:01Sites and stuff like that and the studio isn't right the studio is in Wellington. The was it weta. Yeah. Yeah, WTA right? Yeah

1:04:09I'll take a guess and I'll assume I'm wrong that it's weta. Yeah, but it is I really

1:04:16- Really?

1:04:17See now everybody will be surprised

1:04:18'cause whenever I have to guess at the pronunciation

1:04:20of something, I always guess.

1:04:22- I just what the cab driver said,

1:04:23so maybe he was wrong, so I don't know.

1:04:25- There's some locations on the North Island,

1:04:28which is the one with Auckland and Wellington,

1:04:31but the South Island is the one where it's apparently

1:04:33a little bit more--

1:04:34- A lot more scenic.

1:04:35There's a lot more.

1:04:36There's a lot less population,

1:04:37a lot more public ground is supposed to be.

1:04:39So I think that would be, you know,

1:04:42I think I would like to go to Webstock again.

1:04:45I would also like to see more of New Zealand.

1:04:48So maybe we can work those two things together

1:04:50at some point.

1:04:51What else?

1:04:57What talk did you think at Webstock

1:05:01was most gratifying or most illuminating?

1:05:07- That's a good question.

1:05:12There were a bunch that were really good.

1:05:14- I'm drawing a blank on his name.

1:05:15The guy who wrote the novel, Mr. Penumbra's--

1:05:17- Sloan, Robin Sloan. - Robin Sloan.

1:05:19- That was a great talk, yeah.

1:05:20- Gave a great talk on the way we,

1:05:25I don't wanna butcher it by summarizing it the wrong way,

1:05:29but part of it was about the way

1:05:31that we don't really understand any new medium

1:05:34until decades after it comes out.

1:05:36And one of the ways he proved that was

1:05:39by going back to the turn of the last century

1:05:42and how when movies first became a thing,

1:05:46people put like sarcastic quotes around the word movies.

1:05:49That it was, you know, movies with quotes around it.

1:05:53And that that lasted for decades,

1:05:55like even up through like the 20s,

1:05:57even until like the 1930s,

1:05:59when people in newspapers wrote about movies,

1:06:01they put the word in quotes,

1:06:03like it was sort of not a real thing

1:06:05or a valid art form.

1:06:06- Right, or passing fancy of some sort, right, right.

1:06:09- Right.

1:06:12His talk reminded me of one thing.

1:06:13I don't remember who said it, maybe,

1:06:15I don't know where the quote is,

1:06:16but when they first shown a movie for the first time,

1:06:21somewhere in India or somewhere,

1:06:24the audience didn't know whether they should look

1:06:27at the screen or the light moving through the air,

1:06:30like from the projection booth,

1:06:32like they didn't know what was the most interesting thing.

1:06:34I thought that's sort of funny.

1:06:35So which way do you turn your chair?

1:06:36- What was the best one for you?

1:06:40What was your favorite?

1:06:41I think that one was very entertaining.

1:06:45I sort of enjoyed Jason Kotke's talk about building Stellar,

1:06:49which I don't want to-- and I believe all the Web Stock

1:06:51videos go up online, right?

1:06:53So I'm not going to sort of spoil what it's about,

1:06:55but it was a surprising--

1:06:58it was a very typical talk about one guy building a web app that

1:07:02took an interesting and surprising turn.

1:07:06It was very human and emotional and also very informative.

1:07:09So I like that.

1:07:10And then I saw Kelly Anderson's talk about design

1:07:15in everyday life, which really was great.

1:07:19Some super interesting projects and a lot of really

1:07:22terrific work presented in a entertaining

1:07:25and intelligent way.

1:07:26If you get a chance to see her speak, I would do that.

1:07:29I think those two maybe were--

1:07:31- Unsurprisingly, I have the same taste as you.

1:07:34But yeah, Kottke's was great and very personal

1:07:39in a very Jason way.

1:07:41- Yes.

1:07:42Every one of the room was surprised at one point in it.

1:07:47Let's put it that way.

1:07:48- Right, and I know he doesn't speak a lot,

1:07:49so there's probably a lot of people out there listening

1:07:51who certainly know his sight, probably daily,

1:07:54but maybe don't know what he's like in person.

1:07:59But I think he is a lot like what you think he is

1:08:01from his sight.

1:08:02You know, it's not quiet, but he's--

1:08:05- Thoughtful and observant.

1:08:07- Right.

1:08:09Not a shouter.

1:08:09- Sneaky funny.

1:08:10- Right.

1:08:11- That doesn't mean he's not funny,

1:08:12it just means it's quiet funny, like smart funny.

1:08:16- His talk and the way he gave it was really him,

1:08:19I thought, in a way that I can't do.

1:08:22I don't know, there's like a stage John Gruber that's,

1:08:26I don't think it's, I'm disingenuous on stage,

1:08:29but I don't know, I know that I'm not as

1:08:32broadly personal as he was.

1:08:35And I really enjoyed that.

1:08:36And Kelly's, again, was great.

1:08:37Kelly's one of those ones, like you said,

1:08:39where I had never, I wasn't familiar with her work before.

1:08:42I'd never met her before and now would consider her a friend

1:08:46and blown away by the quality of her work.

1:08:49- And then Mike brought the house down.

1:08:52Mike Montero brought the house down.

1:08:53He was the last speech on the last day

1:08:55and he talked about designers' responsibility

1:08:58to their work and to what's right and to their craft.

1:09:03And it was, I don't know what you call that.

1:09:07It brought the house down.

1:09:10Everybody was, everybody was,

1:09:11and it was powerful and positive,

1:09:14and it was also a bit of a lecture,

1:09:17so, but you know, but good, in a good way.

1:09:19- And it was, boy, was that the right audience

1:09:22for that talk, right?

1:09:23I mean, like, in terms of actually him giving,

1:09:26you know, hey, if you're doing it this way,

1:09:27you're doing it wrong, and you should do it this way,

1:09:30and not just for yourself, but really, literally,

1:09:32he meant it for the world.

1:09:34And the people in the audience are the people who,

1:09:36You know and you know what a lot of speakers swear a lot right for effect

1:09:41But he's the man nobody swears like fun to like in a speech like that, which is a highly structured well-rehearsed, right?

1:09:49intellectually rigorous presentation

1:09:51He is his his his profanity is powerful. I will say in a good way. So

1:09:59Yeah, his use of profanity is about as eloquent

1:10:04Well, what is the title of his most famous speech online fuck you pay me fuck you pay me, right?

1:10:11So he's also good at making this time. This was called how designers destroyed the world, right? He's good with titles. He is good

1:10:17It was a good way to end web stock

1:10:21It's probably a good way to end the show. It probably is. Well, thanks for having me on

1:10:25Yeah, thanks. I'm listening first time caller as they say

1:10:30And if you have a chance to see the new 70 millimeter print of 2001, travel all the way

1:10:35from Philadelphia to Chicago if you have to, it's worth it.

1:10:37You know what this means, of course.

1:10:39You know that they're going to schedule a 70 millimeter, a screening of this print in

1:10:42Philly, probably while I'm flying home.

1:10:44Yeah, maybe.

1:10:45That's right.

1:10:46Right.

1:10:47Well, keep our eyes open for Barry Lyndon.

1:10:48We'll go back to Ohio State.

1:10:49We could tell the story about the countdown bar at some point, but we'll have to do that

1:10:52on a future episode.

1:10:53Yeah, we'll save that one.

1:10:54All right.

1:10:55Thanks, John.